id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07520v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07520v2
|
PromptSync: Bridging Domain Gaps in Vision-Language Models through Class-Aware Prototype Alignment and Discrimination
| 2024-04-11T07:26:00 | 2024-04-12T17:01:04 |
Anant Khandelwal
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The potential for zero-shot generalization in vision-language (V-L) models
such as CLIP has spurred their widespread adoption in addressing numerous
downstream tasks. Previous methods have employed test-time prompt tuning to
adapt the model to unseen domains, but they overlooked the issue of imbalanced
class distributions. In this study, we explicitly address this problem by
employing class-aware prototype alignment weighted by mean class probabilities
obtained for the test sample and filtered augmented views. Additionally, we
ensure that the class probabilities are as accurate as possible by performing
prototype discrimination using contrastive learning. The combination of
alignment and discriminative loss serves as a geometric regularizer, preventing
the prompt representation from collapsing onto a single class and effectively
bridging the distribution gap between the source and test domains. Our method,
named PromptSync, synchronizes the prompts for each test sample on both the
text and vision branches of the V-L model. In empirical evaluations on the
domain generalization benchmark, our method outperforms previous best methods
by 2.33% in overall performance, by 1% in base-to-novel generalization, and by
2.84% in cross-dataset transfer tasks.
|
[
-0.2977772355079651,
-0.4138905704021454,
0.47103452682495117,
0.07627996057271957,
-0.2213941514492035,
0.31166496872901917,
-0.17319265007972717,
-0.25391632318496704,
0.07570300996303558,
-0.0032601880375295877,
-0.7318633198738098,
-0.4691679775714874,
-0.27283984422683716,
-0.0014526317827403545,
-0.24818791449069977,
0.6300738453865051,
-0.08670514822006226,
0.11377265304327011,
-0.3215945065021515,
-0.20485566556453705,
-0.7375546097755432,
-0.3866848945617676,
-0.11282554268836975,
0.05014808103442192,
0.19822409749031067,
0.4050627052783966,
0.5894302129745483,
0.8174164891242981,
0.2697764039039612,
0.20383204519748688,
-0.005654493812471628,
0.01613842137157917,
-0.10153611749410629,
0.20291893184185028,
-0.28971052169799805,
-0.48742905259132385,
-0.3708297908306122,
-0.0695510134100914,
0.6950241327285767,
0.9178727269172668,
-0.033410124480724335,
0.17150890827178955,
0.3833804130554199,
0.255501389503479,
-1.0901192426681519,
-0.13329429924488068,
-0.5984429717063904,
0.07799337804317474,
-0.3604115843772888,
-0.017094289883971214,
-0.583203911781311,
-0.16010650992393494,
0.1954306811094284,
-0.8405617475509644,
0.8579310178756714,
0.21672864258289337,
0.9355707764625549,
0.06171988695859909,
0.13562829792499542,
0.309965044260025,
-0.37405866384506226,
0.8902796506881714,
-0.2506563663482666,
0.4665939509868622,
0.002352253533899784,
0.5489866137504578,
0.21937528252601624,
-0.5133933424949646,
-0.795671820640564,
0.11913514882326126,
0.17915435135364532,
0.22715291380882263,
-0.16457141935825348,
0.21042990684509277,
0.26629841327667236,
0.36959734559059143,
-0.8237302303314209,
0.2875067889690399,
-0.19532181322574615,
-0.3831903636455536,
0.22661547362804413,
0.275508314371109,
0.33725646138191223,
-0.04623818024992943,
-0.4592050015926361,
-0.38755902647972107,
-0.4329017698764801,
0.1920490264892578,
0.2961370646953583,
0.5561017990112305,
-0.1934671252965927,
0.5759360194206238,
-0.25543513894081116,
1.059787392616272,
0.32195889949798584,
0.06221173331141472,
0.3528316915035248,
-0.5924375057220459,
-0.2906376123428345,
0.04705878719687462,
0.5258042812347412,
0.7743394374847412,
0.22273162007331848,
0.06071196869015694,
-0.04692573845386505,
0.5837823152542114,
0.1021500676870346,
-0.6537770628929138,
-0.3292391300201416,
0.015149036422371864,
-0.3210534453392029,
-0.1592317372560501,
-0.1478889435529709,
-0.9638240337371826,
-0.3209143877029419,
-0.35410404205322266,
0.4361194670200348,
-0.21752840280532837,
0.05185835063457489,
0.2667904794216156,
-0.31133097410202026,
0.3948574364185333,
0.6447040438652039,
-1.1575173139572144,
0.23256109654903412,
0.3854851722717285,
1.0529217720031738,
-0.5140674710273743,
-0.3034709095954895,
-0.7618071436882019,
-0.005468772258609533,
-0.14791367948055267,
0.6924930214881897,
-0.4545195996761322,
-0.24792994558811188,
0.23756439983844757,
0.12614868581295013,
-0.37669697403907776,
-0.46139615774154663,
0.3185986876487732,
-0.1832471489906311,
0.4079921841621399,
-0.13734577596187592,
-0.6401824355125427,
0.33455878496170044,
0.2069978415966034,
-0.23324556648731232,
0.726606547832489,
0.11870932579040527,
-0.7111179232597351,
0.5053296089172363,
-0.0005548596382141113,
-0.08461464196443558,
0.41219058632850647,
-0.29636141657829285,
-0.5658804178237915,
-0.017868956550955772,
0.5547258853912354,
0.2676691710948944,
0.013923470862209797,
0.017306271940469742,
-0.48617565631866455,
-0.5411967635154724,
-0.10151460766792297,
-0.22381538152694702,
0.6175028681755066,
-0.03416505455970764,
-0.33464497327804565,
0.25975167751312256,
-0.6903615593910217,
-0.04631740227341652,
0.02387266419827938,
0.2480544149875641,
-0.5947201251983643,
-0.219130277633667,
0.10796475410461426,
0.03814386576414108,
0.1076253280043602,
-0.7408427596092224,
0.4094938337802887,
-0.30252403020858765,
0.026420198380947113,
0.8296980261802673,
-0.14363403618335724,
0.6661964654922485,
-0.2816319465637207,
0.6822959780693054,
0.10880088061094284,
0.4869035482406616,
-0.6371814608573914,
-0.5146908164024353,
-0.8915783166885376,
-0.2490357905626297,
0.2031446248292923,
0.754225492477417,
-0.8175252079963684,
0.25596222281455994,
-0.05867518484592438,
-0.1850842833518982,
-0.7049121260643005,
-0.10893619060516357,
0.5066155195236206,
0.8678907752037048,
0.45393961668014526,
-0.3914509117603302,
-0.35313573479652405,
-0.7344052791595459,
-0.13928529620170593,
-0.12728573381900787,
-0.1863485723733902,
0.19519078731536865,
0.12283793091773987,
0.086819589138031,
1.021196961402893,
-0.720858633518219,
-0.2451317459344864,
-0.26585260033607483,
-0.22244901955127716,
0.17738531529903412,
0.7055128812789917,
0.781992495059967,
-0.5635572075843811,
-0.4540598690509796,
-0.18520408868789673,
-0.5125346779823303,
-0.3709733784198761,
-0.07352948188781738,
-0.28276753425598145,
0.09679107367992401,
0.37769097089767456,
-0.39860087633132935,
0.5560299158096313,
0.37200140953063965,
-0.5979017615318298,
0.6447247862815857,
0.06606096774339676,
0.07285557687282562,
-1.0621007680892944,
0.03307121619582176,
0.16244083642959595,
-0.2975347638130188,
-0.5734938979148865,
-0.24336504936218262,
0.3214532136917114,
-0.2525171637535095,
-0.5019288063049316,
0.6486193537712097,
-0.3588126599788666,
-0.0500093474984169,
-0.15298958122730255,
0.46101799607276917,
0.28399163484573364,
0.348203182220459,
0.026969600468873978,
1.116246223449707,
0.7504479289054871,
-0.6379930973052979,
0.08130539208650589,
0.6112143993377686,
-0.2494748830795288,
0.9444119334220886,
-0.7105753421783447,
-0.31217023730278015,
-0.2198358178138733,
-0.17982693016529083,
-0.9765962362289429,
-0.1306292712688446,
0.3410300016403198,
-0.47732236981391907,
0.19174723327159882,
-0.20001152157783508,
-0.006118019577115774,
-0.2247941642999649,
-0.36617520451545715,
0.4555661380290985,
0.7122160792350769,
-0.7812050580978394,
0.2642243504524231,
0.059275709092617035,
-0.17126481235027313,
-0.8563373684883118,
-0.36192476749420166,
-0.17668412625789642,
0.002747938269749284,
-0.4924243688583374,
0.5237356424331665,
-0.19649472832679749,
-0.13631939888000488,
-0.20820680260658264,
-0.2656610310077667,
0.1591285914182663,
0.05998477339744568,
0.23410414159297943,
0.753437876701355,
-0.1838638037443161,
0.01581987552344799,
0.049222104251384735,
0.052739836275577545,
-0.22906552255153656,
-0.45909300446510315,
0.5211055278778076,
0.21626971662044525,
-0.4465559422969818,
-0.5287550687789917,
0.016667192801833153,
0.35118475556373596,
-0.1830672323703766,
0.4959295988082886,
0.2429162859916687,
-0.16043224930763245,
-0.6035336852073669,
-0.3225442171096802,
-0.16081516444683075,
-0.4911617040634155,
0.20428504049777985,
-0.3039391040802002,
-0.8888642191886902,
0.4919493496417999,
0.028455330058932304,
-0.005797774996608496,
0.22905755043029785,
0.3022441565990448,
-0.017587387934327126,
0.9236429929733276,
1.0286173820495605,
0.006949894595891237,
0.9666368961334229,
-0.11175477504730225,
-0.020695514976978302,
-0.932062029838562,
-0.24754419922828674,
-0.41127967834472656,
-0.13412253558635712,
-0.10737999528646469,
-0.4211961328983307,
0.21554452180862427,
0.1537572741508484,
-0.07864127308130264,
0.42376935482025146,
-0.5393368005752563,
0.5575000643730164,
0.7297758460044861,
-0.010077557526528835,
0.19105151295661926,
0.1286601722240448,
-0.37874412536621094,
-0.4460126757621765,
-0.465686172246933,
-0.1795184314250946,
0.9206505417823792,
0.03553728759288788,
0.6600964069366455,
-0.017159301787614822,
0.38828280568122864,
0.393481969833374,
-0.035875819623470306,
-0.7774098515510559,
0.5459967851638794,
-0.23873154819011688,
0.07994186878204346,
-0.006771632470190525,
-0.10853099077939987,
-0.6605768799781799,
0.445108562707901,
-0.18386368453502655,
-0.6897196769714355,
0.5663988590240479,
0.4228532016277313,
-0.36940842866897583,
0.24770396947860718,
-0.562104344367981,
1.1140519380569458,
0.2006479799747467,
-0.5505995154380798,
0.1979476660490036,
-0.661867618560791,
0.4624989628791809,
0.08142497390508652,
-0.25431180000305176,
-0.16608315706253052,
0.10471225529909134,
0.4367578625679016,
-0.6368838548660278,
0.8939356803894043,
-0.3182331919670105,
0.1228143498301506,
-0.00508100213482976,
0.01893370971083641,
0.2615163028240204,
-0.13481943309307098,
0.24544760584831238,
-0.08224021643400192,
-0.2665526568889618,
-0.47749757766723633,
-0.6498947143554688,
0.3504502475261688,
-0.5919620394706726,
-0.5537988543510437,
-0.45385849475860596,
-0.3256855010986328,
-0.29753559827804565,
0.16986463963985443,
0.537634551525116,
0.5915430188179016,
-0.13950636982917786,
-0.3084906041622162,
0.8144603967666626,
-0.19813096523284912,
0.5910943746566772,
0.6590825319290161,
-0.3080917000770569,
-0.4616662561893463,
0.883513867855072,
-0.3301169276237488,
0.6135023236274719,
0.37806588411331177,
-0.16484463214874268,
-0.3398382365703583,
-0.552977442741394,
-0.8014668822288513,
0.09308362752199173,
-0.7135048508644104,
-0.3036366105079651,
-0.558648407459259,
-0.039230652153491974,
-0.5084756016731262,
-0.6079537868499756,
-0.15171478688716888,
-0.49862396717071533,
-0.45233380794525146,
0.05868756026029587,
0.12885363399982452,
0.08516713976860046,
0.1816723346710205,
0.618423342704773,
-0.46789973974227905,
0.11120568215847015,
0.3427932560443878,
0.23550871014595032,
-0.2418719232082367,
-0.7467369437217712,
0.0662500411272049,
-0.323956161737442,
-0.3313993513584137,
-0.5811828970909119,
0.3237399458885193,
0.39555099606513977,
0.43245261907577515,
0.33146557211875916,
0.23422768712043762,
0.7779791951179504,
-0.6578792929649353,
1.0802937746047974,
0.5372048616409302,
-1.1583679914474487,
0.8025084733963013,
-0.2033175677061081,
0.41119280457496643,
0.5365779399871826,
-0.03440796583890915,
-0.6477858424186707,
-0.5506338477134705,
-0.26481518149375916,
-0.7859559655189514,
0.6667430996894836,
0.0031683819834142923,
0.020353885367512703,
0.0017232440877705812,
0.22617694735527039,
0.15698213875293732,
0.21747690439224243,
-0.3152424395084381,
-0.3306800425052643,
-0.4599657952785492,
-0.46126803755760193,
-0.05784570425748825,
-0.0022517219185829163,
0.20305027067661285,
-0.14726369082927704,
0.405961811542511,
-0.41231265664100647,
0.02478652633726597,
0.4083505868911743,
-0.24981683492660522,
-0.034243930131196976,
0.2556423544883728,
0.7625396847724915,
0.5464358925819397,
-0.10618116706609726,
0.17649464309215546,
-0.13679134845733643,
-0.8976912498474121,
0.36464831233024597,
0.2284758985042572,
-0.6103167533874512,
0.38187506794929504,
0.21557912230491638,
0.9884982109069824,
0.12347690016031265,
-0.7335577607154846,
1.0446606874465942,
-0.11086979508399963,
-0.08372495323419571,
0.014484571292996407,
0.16163715720176697,
-0.6713575124740601,
0.238798588514328,
0.306669682264328,
0.3989015519618988,
0.15563294291496277,
-0.1179281696677208,
0.48748308420181274,
0.3907143771648407,
-0.3873503506183624,
-0.5475055575370789,
1.1252533197402954,
0.22819888591766357,
0.05734362453222275,
0.6032457947731018,
-0.1567840278148651,
-0.5403335094451904,
0.5165807008743286,
0.6533286571502686,
0.999060332775116,
-0.27712878584861755,
0.5019832849502563,
0.44617658853530884,
0.03611202910542488,
-0.19289308786392212,
0.3431086242198944,
-0.2568873167037964,
-0.7635026574134827,
-0.4379027187824249,
-0.5992258191108704,
-0.7683850526809692,
-0.27786266803741455,
-0.7917323112487793,
0.4287876486778259,
-0.48384904861450195,
-0.227921724319458,
-0.076846644282341,
-0.3396591246128082,
-0.5310888886451721,
-0.04337555915117264,
0.17562153935432434,
1.0076916217803955,
-1.037371039390564,
0.6848490834236145,
0.5487578511238098,
-0.323356032371521,
-0.3931753635406494,
0.12963706254959106,
0.021135982125997543,
-0.9319911003112793,
0.6331155896186829,
0.31241077184677124,
0.04473428800702095,
-0.06991560012102127,
-0.5029300451278687,
-0.6730411648750305,
0.9650236368179321,
0.4033697545528412,
-0.9716619253158569,
0.1272030621767044,
-0.1555282473564148,
0.21541854739189148,
-0.29320111870765686,
-0.051634859293699265,
0.31357234716415405,
-0.09248262643814087,
0.28322526812553406,
-1.0492000579833984,
-0.055636901408433914,
-0.2875754237174988,
0.24162644147872925,
0.2667180001735687,
-0.5275367498397827,
1.0018421411514282,
-0.410254567861557,
-0.5170196294784546,
0.22749236226081848,
0.6478722095489502,
0.41753309965133667,
0.49678340554237366,
0.308810293674469,
0.485483855009079,
0.7838311195373535,
-0.1466309279203415,
0.7144320607185364,
-0.3580280840396881,
0.2617930769920349,
1.1716605424880981,
-0.5482599139213562,
0.6586287021636963,
0.45200857520103455,
-0.12923844158649445,
0.3560657501220703,
0.4167400598526001,
-0.2639605700969696,
0.7202913165092468,
0.1656496822834015,
-0.49770599603652954,
-0.3425799310207367,
-0.5061129331588745,
-0.27919793128967285,
-0.026422278955578804,
0.11359662562608719,
-0.2420445829629898,
-0.18094395101070404,
0.3006517291069031,
-0.19956840574741364,
0.15639550983905792,
-0.5602098107337952,
0.4810149371623993,
-0.16336213052272797,
-0.5904702544212341,
0.4992287755012512,
-0.35964909195899963,
0.764794647693634,
-0.4996657073497772,
0.005840103141963482,
-0.353887677192688,
0.4853312075138092,
0.03847474977374077,
-0.8005744218826294,
-0.07368195056915283,
-0.09335824847221375,
-0.3693162500858307,
-0.11636774986982346,
0.5428277254104614,
-0.5775662064552307,
-0.21428506076335907,
-0.0050412798300385475,
0.4370999038219452,
-0.18961168825626373,
0.12058326601982117,
-0.32768362760543823,
0.2907627820968628,
0.0016441449988633394,
0.2894383668899536,
0.27595415711402893,
0.08396212756633759,
-0.1979440301656723,
0.4914737343788147,
0.31354376673698425,
0.1717192530632019,
0.24795149266719818,
0.3300669491291046,
0.8223999738693237,
-0.5497922301292419,
-0.6120149493217468,
-0.8621324300765991,
0.534403383731842,
-0.2948213517665863,
-0.5866677761077881,
0.9409558773040771,
0.5895500779151917,
1.0362211465835571,
-0.2843519449234009,
0.7512682676315308,
0.23194022476673126,
0.4854007065296173,
-0.5466666221618652,
0.23385711014270782,
-0.31977778673171997,
0.11362043023109436,
-0.37497735023498535,
-1.014691710472107,
-0.5249791145324707,
0.3318132162094116,
0.032164670526981354,
-0.40415140986442566,
0.5414584875106812,
0.581343948841095,
-0.15722018480300903,
-0.1850757747888565,
0.34102991223335266,
-0.29192793369293213,
0.24163301289081573,
0.5574547052383423,
0.7633497714996338,
-0.5115535259246826,
0.24082225561141968,
-0.1947825402021408,
-0.33486151695251465,
-0.2470504194498062,
-0.6605545282363892,
-1.0077794790267944,
-0.4938870966434479,
-0.6149014830589294,
-0.2928094267845154,
0.20859311521053314,
0.7305372953414917,
0.6554375886917114,
-0.8355713486671448,
-0.06899772584438324,
-0.05958864465355873,
-0.0185194481164217,
-0.2798219323158264,
-0.2555701434612274,
0.4646179974079132,
-0.6551088690757751,
-0.8445791006088257,
0.29852765798568726,
0.43276941776275635,
0.6561021208763123,
-0.11759898066520691,
0.08558187633752823,
0.4338526427745819,
-0.19165292382240295,
0.4705221951007843,
0.4290594160556793,
-0.6246734261512756,
-0.28210484981536865,
0.4361950159072876,
0.018119707703590393,
0.04771257936954498,
0.8293169140815735,
-1.051671028137207,
0.7280717492103577,
0.4234033226966858,
0.6314899325370789,
0.04868915304541588,
0.3021993339061737,
0.6898336410522461,
-1.0130549669265747,
0.4512454569339752,
0.06038844585418701,
0.502069354057312,
0.41350650787353516,
-0.21955478191375732,
0.288950651884079,
0.7238222360610962,
-0.3691965639591217,
-0.9903393387794495,
0.3588891923427582,
-1.1950037479400635,
-0.05765192583203316,
0.6892237663269043,
-0.04967018961906433,
-0.31054961681365967,
-0.15061256289482117,
-0.2053668200969696,
0.03930538147687912,
-0.4203738272190094,
0.5027285814285278,
0.37941956520080566,
0.050071585923433304,
-0.40300774574279785,
-0.2811846137046814,
0.6723247766494751,
0.42353230714797974,
-0.5548243522644043,
0.20600463449954987,
0.659294843673706,
0.2302873283624649,
0.1016504094004631,
0.5482180118560791,
0.14224711060523987,
0.4407912492752075,
-0.05692986771464348,
0.30297571420669556,
0.12001701444387436,
-0.3282583951950073,
-0.6609237790107727,
0.09111849963665009,
-0.18958809971809387,
-0.7670626044273376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08704v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08704v1
|
MM-PhyQA: Multimodal Physics Question-Answering With Multi-Image CoT Prompting
| 2024-04-11T07:11:47 | 2024-04-11T07:11:47 |
Avinash Anand, Janak Kapuriya, Apoorv Singh, Jay Saraf, Naman Lal, Astha Verma, Rushali Gupta, Rajiv Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) can achieve human-level performance in
various tasks, they continue to face challenges when it comes to effectively
tackling multi-step physics reasoning tasks. To identify the shortcomings of
existing models and facilitate further research in this area, we curated a
novel dataset, MM-PhyQA, which comprises well-constructed, high schoollevel
multimodal physics problems. By evaluating the performance of contemporary LLMs
that are publicly available, both with and without the incorporation of
multimodal elements in these problems, we aim to shed light on their
capabilities. For generating answers for questions consisting of multimodal
input (in this case, images and text) we employed Zero-shot prediction using
GPT-4 and utilized LLaVA (LLaVA and LLaVA-1.5), the latter of which were
fine-tuned on our dataset. For evaluating the performance of LLMs consisting
solely of textual input, we tested the performance of the base and fine-tuned
versions of the Mistral-7B and LLaMA2-7b models. We also showcased the
performance of the novel Multi-Image Chain-of-Thought (MI-CoT) Prompting
technique, which when used to train LLaVA-1.5 13b yielded the best results when
tested on our dataset, with superior scores in most metrics and the highest
accuracy of 71.65% on the test set.
|
[
-0.39511048793792725,
-1.0358798503875732,
0.924382209777832,
0.09693842381238937,
-0.2437303066253662,
0.3317124843597412,
0.11261998862028122,
-0.2582832872867584,
-0.11518204212188721,
0.08354805409908295,
-0.8736085295677185,
-0.15181584656238556,
-0.5294919013977051,
0.3837372064590454,
-0.22165049612522125,
0.5181005597114563,
-0.3060576617717743,
0.28993168473243713,
-0.3134748935699463,
0.14901821315288544,
-0.44448935985565186,
-0.22143901884555817,
-0.16672293841838837,
-0.2980649769306183,
0.6490207314491272,
0.4130192697048187,
0.6010638475418091,
0.19348658621311188,
0.637096107006073,
0.310771644115448,
-0.004531663376837969,
0.43925729393959045,
-0.2050609290599823,
0.010146880522370338,
-0.09654425829648972,
-0.2098112851381302,
-0.32025399804115295,
-0.16163432598114014,
0.7604434490203857,
0.48552751541137695,
0.0035759578458964825,
0.27143946290016174,
-0.1819014698266983,
0.39220359921455383,
-0.747085690498352,
-0.02103443630039692,
-0.5029765367507935,
0.06351038068532944,
0.1376659870147705,
-0.4271273910999298,
-0.40275922417640686,
0.11638131737709045,
-0.13581953942775726,
-0.8414905071258545,
0.11105231940746307,
0.1620427817106247,
0.787714958190918,
0.09894949197769165,
-0.7519132494926453,
-0.16751927137374878,
-0.48879972100257874,
0.8283862471580505,
-0.3173771798610687,
0.649079442024231,
0.24009937047958374,
0.16797542572021484,
-0.2917459011077881,
-0.4481704831123352,
-0.6646053791046143,
-0.2612439692020416,
0.37324994802474976,
0.4889332354068756,
0.10797472298145294,
0.13123293220996857,
0.23292987048625946,
0.18372191488742828,
-0.8420384526252747,
-0.14405971765518188,
-0.6707010269165039,
-0.38531598448753357,
0.2861641049385071,
0.275936484336853,
0.15061460435390472,
-0.46218186616897583,
-0.43867257237434387,
-0.25101813673973083,
-0.5123373866081238,
0.23891136050224304,
0.352969229221344,
0.04040854424238205,
-0.09345170855522156,
1.1339441537857056,
-0.4674125611782074,
0.5564895272254944,
0.035533607006073,
-0.5641981959342957,
0.2529832422733307,
-0.49217864871025085,
0.004666193854063749,
-0.23289363086223602,
0.9063021540641785,
0.5253157615661621,
0.2267734855413437,
0.2005327343940735,
0.020791536197066307,
0.05810350179672241,
-0.19594740867614746,
-0.7451865077018738,
-0.14215438067913055,
0.4120560586452484,
-0.27578747272491455,
-0.04509642347693443,
-0.2578306496143341,
-0.8735421895980835,
-0.5088403224945068,
-0.3097427785396576,
0.7631123661994934,
-0.5101890563964844,
-0.3570854067802429,
0.36851462721824646,
-0.22784610092639923,
0.1144656389951706,
0.5468157529830933,
-0.7330834865570068,
-0.07365961372852325,
0.32834258675575256,
0.8075188398361206,
0.24991649389266968,
-0.6224665641784668,
-0.27700895071029663,
0.2669113278388977,
-0.31295913457870483,
0.937100350856781,
-0.5771216750144958,
-0.4762488603591919,
-0.38799455761909485,
-0.04000736027956009,
-0.09896133095026016,
-0.15488116443157196,
0.35810843110084534,
-0.33886468410491943,
0.4214525520801544,
-0.31811434030532837,
-0.32721421122550964,
0.042447302490472794,
0.46439528465270996,
-0.46018075942993164,
0.8987011313438416,
-0.05714854225516319,
-0.5741801857948303,
0.21745657920837402,
-0.5376736521720886,
-0.001486029359512031,
-0.17940753698349,
-0.31883504986763,
-0.06278888136148453,
0.07578621804714203,
0.6421612501144409,
0.3860907554626465,
-0.4548470377922058,
0.27576813101768494,
-0.2767429053783417,
-0.23804622888565063,
0.5263247489929199,
-0.6610767841339111,
0.4136309027671814,
0.2505594789981842,
0.03972939774394035,
-0.07585889846086502,
-0.83394855260849,
0.03209085762500763,
0.1571897566318512,
-0.28168630599975586,
0.07754655182361603,
-0.23817265033721924,
-0.2557828426361084,
0.5987803339958191,
0.3003172278404236,
-0.8462275862693787,
0.11973890662193298,
-0.11560787260532379,
0.27135705947875977,
0.8032258749008179,
0.04400407522916794,
0.24075733125209808,
-0.48310109972953796,
0.7439078092575073,
0.23363110423088074,
0.19265632331371307,
-0.5650273561477661,
-0.88137286901474,
-0.2976365089416504,
-0.3506934344768524,
-0.1539473980665207,
0.4572031497955322,
-1.1255403757095337,
-0.2990935444831848,
-0.10387908667325974,
-0.5814786553382874,
-0.5170590877532959,
0.30888453125953674,
0.47072145342826843,
0.7901579737663269,
0.43645721673965454,
-0.035773809999227524,
-0.28095191717147827,
-0.8006162047386169,
-0.04753178730607033,
-0.2976432740688324,
-0.07116514444351196,
0.35500243306159973,
0.582048773765564,
0.13517151772975922,
0.5035486221313477,
-0.5075550675392151,
0.2626209855079651,
0.027827678248286247,
0.24741683900356293,
0.037063319236040115,
0.29737409949302673,
0.11307390034198761,
-0.8045153021812439,
-0.002774807158857584,
-0.16836653649806976,
-0.9219474792480469,
0.03450421616435051,
-0.07891731709241867,
-0.09651096910238266,
-0.12780174612998962,
0.3103669583797455,
-0.9712154865264893,
0.1733165830373764,
0.6489265561103821,
-0.4636414349079132,
0.9620038270950317,
-0.13002139329910278,
0.7015480399131775,
-1.181707501411438,
-0.11769592761993408,
0.20006072521209717,
0.0437287800014019,
-0.38083258271217346,
0.12567290663719177,
0.32799652218818665,
-0.41857537627220154,
-0.964100182056427,
0.6046749949455261,
-0.3896239101886749,
-0.10940750688314438,
-0.15866871178150177,
0.18703091144561768,
0.3738299310207367,
0.46321195363998413,
0.056112367659807205,
0.7980179190635681,
0.7720680832862854,
-0.634880542755127,
0.5648301839828491,
0.10237640142440796,
-0.3590407073497772,
0.5215612053871155,
-0.7120065689086914,
0.09237278252840042,
-0.41141921281814575,
0.34554657340049744,
-1.1920064687728882,
-0.5178374648094177,
0.12972228229045868,
-0.5094479322433472,
0.015796108171343803,
-0.07009391486644745,
-0.7197994589805603,
-0.4588227868080139,
-0.31355801224708557,
0.8124129772186279,
0.25676780939102173,
-0.3441203236579895,
0.5630624294281006,
-0.05843757465481758,
-0.05224522575736046,
-0.8580389618873596,
-0.5193842649459839,
0.012863796204328537,
-0.04217309132218361,
-0.6531859040260315,
-0.06204267218708992,
-0.3927275240421295,
-0.0437878854572773,
-0.17414425313472748,
-0.027668403461575508,
-0.07936916500329971,
-0.08117897063493729,
0.2675619423389435,
0.5685824751853943,
-0.2191145420074463,
0.19277091324329376,
0.07091905176639557,
-0.01989327371120453,
0.11300386488437653,
-0.025579439476132393,
0.6055157780647278,
-0.2970176041126251,
-0.6153031587600708,
-0.6373719573020935,
0.17905481159687042,
0.7204524278640747,
-0.116939015686512,
0.5193995237350464,
0.6138002872467041,
-0.3219519555568695,
0.3757795989513397,
-0.45287054777145386,
-0.1500193476676941,
-0.5589585900306702,
0.407119482755661,
-0.6864139437675476,
-0.8174083232879639,
0.3842206597328186,
-0.01720995269715786,
-0.042403444647789,
0.17761991918087006,
0.9367656111717224,
-0.28384819626808167,
1.3818734884262085,
0.21856720745563507,
0.3927761912345886,
0.23064236342906952,
-0.20062009990215302,
0.060910262167453766,
-0.7902966141700745,
-0.5786983370780945,
-0.27045688033103943,
-0.11545077711343765,
-0.46715834736824036,
-0.5566484332084656,
0.6262321472167969,
-0.07848366349935532,
-0.280611515045166,
0.10566369444131851,
-0.34747645258903503,
0.6682090759277344,
0.2609553337097168,
0.26953378319740295,
0.47372543811798096,
0.05874038487672806,
-0.42587339878082275,
0.11118726432323456,
-0.5449146628379822,
-0.28137704730033875,
1.1114213466644287,
0.2759338915348053,
1.0843645334243774,
0.175185889005661,
0.35713568329811096,
-0.3339499831199646,
-0.09800679981708527,
-0.7411218285560608,
0.6466777920722961,
0.24473397433757782,
-0.9193687438964844,
-0.17454668879508972,
-0.6041362285614014,
-0.959038257598877,
0.5237255096435547,
-0.3681281507015228,
-0.7321473956108093,
-0.054415512830019,
0.06930367648601532,
-0.362949401140213,
0.3441958725452423,
-0.8800122141838074,
0.5345418453216553,
-0.2675660252571106,
-0.5612817406654358,
-0.21498043835163116,
-0.4415901005268097,
0.7702668309211731,
-0.06770059466362,
0.5037573575973511,
-0.4293178617954254,
-0.20278078317642212,
0.4880218505859375,
0.02322792448103428,
0.4443523585796356,
-0.12345463037490845,
-0.15858209133148193,
0.42602965235710144,
0.1852540820837021,
-0.11502117663621902,
0.20869587361812592,
0.026558738201856613,
-0.16292618215084076,
0.5121097564697266,
-0.6165459156036377,
-0.6929311752319336,
0.7111796736717224,
-0.839141845703125,
-0.47741013765335083,
-0.33505553007125854,
-1.0127065181732178,
-0.480968177318573,
0.17870257794857025,
0.3144506812095642,
0.8307245969772339,
0.3364138901233673,
0.17328166961669922,
0.5888156294822693,
-0.3600988984107971,
0.37067273259162903,
0.36157962679862976,
-0.4622000753879547,
-0.4601020812988281,
0.8157567977905273,
-0.05387851968407631,
0.3400111198425293,
0.45782068371772766,
0.4367635250091553,
-0.6499398350715637,
-0.2989998757839203,
-0.6456438899040222,
0.3530175983905792,
-0.884238600730896,
-0.31894269585609436,
-0.5099102854728699,
-0.08899318426847458,
-0.37488237023353577,
-0.05273287743330002,
-0.27537474036216736,
-0.6084321141242981,
-0.10087570548057556,
-0.0045404816046357155,
0.1124071478843689,
0.6489608883857727,
0.09334175288677216,
0.09333734959363937,
-0.947778582572937,
0.7570156455039978,
0.349597305059433,
0.31469622254371643,
-0.08239766955375671,
-0.523765504360199,
-0.10972078144550323,
0.1685589849948883,
-0.6504866480827332,
-0.7822656631469727,
0.11000579595565796,
0.08797090500593185,
0.3741508424282074,
-0.0009445196483284235,
-0.14467711746692657,
0.9370561242103577,
-0.43478745222091675,
1.0400820970535278,
0.6473915576934814,
-0.6838462948799133,
0.6609281301498413,
-0.4789700508117676,
0.6339505314826965,
0.28782325983047485,
0.6020208597183228,
-0.10246425122022629,
-0.44044187664985657,
-0.4613862633705139,
-0.519257664680481,
0.35316842794418335,
0.19766122102737427,
0.0810389369726181,
0.08904300630092621,
0.4143272936344147,
0.03946548327803612,
0.28042513132095337,
-0.6942618489265442,
0.05860450863838196,
-0.3507888913154602,
-0.3110361695289612,
-0.02104160189628601,
-0.0018069331999868155,
0.016799446195364,
-0.231271892786026,
0.42402198910713196,
-0.3291269838809967,
0.23358002305030823,
0.41960740089416504,
-0.2067839354276657,
-0.38147810101509094,
0.3178890347480774,
0.6124369502067566,
0.9170977473258972,
-0.22226588428020477,
0.1964217722415924,
0.08570683002471924,
-0.6223925948143005,
0.4444505274295807,
-0.22965046763420105,
0.06740239262580872,
-0.2425224632024765,
0.19330660998821259,
0.421124130487442,
0.14297179877758026,
-1.04651939868927,
0.37677034735679626,
-0.22427277266979218,
-0.5490246415138245,
0.022943979129195213,
-0.08023597300052643,
0.040082331746816635,
0.2698967456817627,
0.5176945924758911,
-0.06552425026893616,
0.15420687198638916,
-0.5738909840583801,
0.030019160360097885,
0.3467091917991638,
0.020720919594168663,
-0.39688608050346375,
0.6000682711601257,
-0.22346657514572144,
0.07115022093057632,
0.34146469831466675,
0.027775205671787262,
-0.17086383700370789,
0.6171339750289917,
0.44393470883369446,
0.29457327723503113,
-0.0612550750374794,
0.40723398327827454,
0.5889153480529785,
0.3323952257633209,
-0.03650042042136192,
0.657880425453186,
0.0958278551697731,
-0.7512147426605225,
-0.7772414088249207,
-0.4274978041648865,
-0.7049371600151062,
0.1664717197418213,
-0.5598134398460388,
0.37515538930892944,
-0.6123892664909363,
-0.19861547648906708,
0.05018142610788345,
0.08129479736089706,
-0.6034159064292908,
0.28916388750076294,
0.4172343611717224,
0.7920957207679749,
-0.6867898106575012,
0.6757038831710815,
0.8006464838981628,
-0.43094033002853394,
-0.7522738575935364,
-0.29762208461761475,
0.2050648331642151,
-0.8240922093391418,
0.530714750289917,
0.11100776493549347,
-0.38394880294799805,
0.005489702336490154,
-0.6962842345237732,
-0.9281500577926636,
1.257224678993225,
0.534408688545227,
-0.26677656173706055,
-0.11254171282052994,
0.16780444979667664,
0.3129326403141022,
0.015809746459126472,
0.5878625512123108,
0.1855446994304657,
0.30654749274253845,
0.39862966537475586,
-1.099360704421997,
-0.22320376336574554,
-0.33692246675491333,
-0.3364082872867584,
0.09755343943834305,
-0.8650827407836914,
0.9934686422348022,
-0.3293220102787018,
0.09116771072149277,
0.264817476272583,
0.5102730989456177,
0.9896473288536072,
0.5970917344093323,
0.4144198000431061,
0.4224245548248291,
0.7173951268196106,
0.05792719125747681,
1.1159268617630005,
-0.2057255655527115,
0.33601394295692444,
0.7746806144714355,
-0.27770793437957764,
0.7921029329299927,
0.6879585981369019,
-0.11032422631978989,
0.37914201617240906,
0.5987020134925842,
0.19794170558452606,
0.45492592453956604,
-0.1060897633433342,
-0.19097264111042023,
-0.35621052980422974,
-0.2302316576242447,
-0.3441961109638214,
0.5419964790344238,
0.34683647751808167,
0.22769050300121307,
-0.35177889466285706,
0.2659541666507721,
-0.32282519340515137,
-0.047207124531269073,
-0.4363243877887726,
0.36173319816589355,
0.0698162093758583,
-0.4537525177001953,
0.5400814414024353,
-0.10986039787530899,
0.6636930704116821,
-0.6495717167854309,
0.0635819211602211,
-0.022827109321951866,
-0.14681842923164368,
-0.1409875452518463,
-1.1009485721588135,
-0.1675477772951126,
0.045791491866111755,
-0.026989251375198364,
-0.1152191162109375,
0.6611285209655762,
-0.338448166847229,
-0.7352805733680725,
-0.08481276035308838,
0.8954354524612427,
0.15090066194534302,
0.1890879124403,
-0.840001106262207,
-0.05010058358311653,
-0.41505423188209534,
-0.2451391965150833,
0.5435460209846497,
0.5760730504989624,
0.07900971919298172,
1.1090764999389648,
0.6892820596694946,
-0.10407117754220963,
0.3652912676334381,
-0.02609703131020069,
0.8279712200164795,
-0.636220395565033,
-0.30913248658180237,
-0.6574214696884155,
0.5343793034553528,
0.2551349699497223,
-0.5280727744102478,
0.7529972195625305,
0.49778005480766296,
0.623205304145813,
-0.06279962509870529,
0.5177933573722839,
0.21081723272800446,
0.3179864287376404,
-0.9611161351203918,
0.20418818295001984,
-0.7399041056632996,
-0.007390719838440418,
-0.4574553668498993,
-0.7349623441696167,
-0.15912093222141266,
0.40445059537887573,
-0.20017096400260925,
0.1142994835972786,
0.9037710428237915,
1.032510757446289,
-0.09879039973020554,
0.07114150375127792,
0.5885956883430481,
-0.0954657793045044,
0.4043131172657013,
0.7886292934417725,
1.4906429052352905,
-0.600373387336731,
0.7223756313323975,
-0.5102152228355408,
0.00014363802620209754,
0.03200826421380043,
-0.8657045364379883,
-0.8098998665809631,
-0.7186232209205627,
-0.28005197644233704,
-0.36130911111831665,
-0.17035193741321564,
0.9619659781455994,
0.6078633069992065,
-0.5540187954902649,
-0.10118989646434784,
0.19760484993457794,
-0.06335516273975372,
0.13961686193943024,
-0.17377477884292603,
0.22943159937858582,
-0.10396827757358551,
-0.6280018091201782,
0.5602449774742126,
0.10587278008460999,
0.18928366899490356,
-0.272758424282074,
-0.13737522065639496,
-0.4028328061103821,
0.0314459390938282,
0.7543315887451172,
0.0321793295443058,
-0.7899045944213867,
-0.22620455920696259,
0.40395501255989075,
0.008749528788030148,
0.012190353125333786,
0.8244242668151855,
-0.7458516955375671,
0.533648669719696,
0.46568563580513,
0.5120790004730225,
0.4606493413448334,
0.05829380825161934,
0.3050755262374878,
-0.6785353422164917,
0.3915017247200012,
0.1760372370481491,
0.5643664002418518,
0.32563516497612,
-0.26815980672836304,
0.13805854320526123,
0.30435726046562195,
-0.556424617767334,
-0.751700758934021,
0.20682887732982635,
-1.100928544998169,
-0.48776695132255554,
1.2398033142089844,
0.1456073820590973,
-0.40854018926620483,
-0.12147651612758636,
-0.4130319356918335,
0.11946723610162735,
-0.3605012595653534,
0.6092897057533264,
0.9592214822769165,
-0.27174246311187744,
-0.7921334505081177,
-0.7053137421607971,
-0.05374792963266373,
0.4919516146183014,
-0.6100412011146545,
-0.31972116231918335,
0.7180647253990173,
0.19999906420707703,
0.24175873398780823,
0.6403021216392517,
-0.29413244128227234,
0.6661520004272461,
0.07369972765445709,
-0.22005848586559296,
-0.2962613105773926,
-0.5539282560348511,
-0.28540176153182983,
0.3313068449497223,
0.11452974379062653,
-0.072772316634655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07503v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07503v1
|
Best Practices and Lessons Learned on Synthetic Data for Language Models
| 2024-04-11T06:34:17 | 2024-04-11T06:34:17 |
Ruibo Liu, Jerry Wei, Fangyu Liu, Chenglei Si, Yanzhe Zhang, Jinmeng Rao, Steven Zheng, Daiyi Peng, Diyi Yang, Denny Zhou, Andrew M. Dai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The success of AI models relies on the availability of large, diverse, and
high-quality datasets, which can be challenging to obtain due to data scarcity,
privacy concerns, and high costs. Synthetic data has emerged as a promising
solution by generating artificial data that mimics real-world patterns. This
paper provides an overview of synthetic data research, discussing its
applications, challenges, and future directions. We present empirical evidence
from prior art to demonstrate its effectiveness and highlight the importance of
ensuring its factuality, fidelity, and unbiasedness. We emphasize the need for
responsible use of synthetic data to build more powerful, inclusive, and
trustworthy language models.
|
[
-0.09137552976608276,
-0.9482678174972534,
0.7218700647354126,
0.00989267136901617,
0.075154609978199,
0.3496735692024231,
-0.13218028843402863,
-0.6195035576820374,
-0.17840458452701569,
0.7041234970092773,
-0.19408947229385376,
-0.5252634286880493,
-0.27741554379463196,
0.10751775652170181,
-0.7843436598777771,
0.6735901236534119,
0.050967346876859665,
0.17925506830215454,
-0.16649815440177917,
-0.04589252173900604,
-0.3328823745250702,
-0.9540460109710693,
-0.5758904218673706,
-0.24023108184337616,
0.1209738627076149,
0.31975775957107544,
0.9769582748413086,
0.9628710150718689,
0.25225624442100525,
0.3402673900127411,
0.13966336846351624,
0.3536856472492218,
-0.4092283844947815,
0.21617145836353302,
-0.12716543674468994,
-0.4281129240989685,
-0.3032373785972595,
0.5000048279762268,
0.7411208152770996,
0.848329484462738,
-0.3820244371891022,
-0.06711198389530182,
-0.17256295680999756,
0.5934486389160156,
-0.13135315477848053,
0.49770286679267883,
-0.6995375752449036,
0.025090724229812622,
-0.38321012258529663,
0.15967091917991638,
-0.3087991774082184,
-0.6813468337059021,
0.2134239822626114,
-0.7051871418952942,
0.34035131335258484,
0.31057965755462646,
0.6253272294998169,
-0.015503993257880211,
-0.43404924869537354,
-0.3648119568824768,
-1.2309489250183105,
0.8161895871162415,
-0.8473206162452698,
0.5775901079177856,
0.49570387601852417,
0.5737863779067993,
-0.49074846506118774,
-0.8594886660575867,
-0.8521116375923157,
-0.3348473608493805,
-0.05571603402495384,
-0.06657283753156662,
0.04508097097277641,
-0.23997832834720612,
0.09567859023809433,
0.40875715017318726,
-0.688924252986908,
-0.019961679354310036,
-0.5039982199668884,
-0.19857120513916016,
0.9574826955795288,
0.1586335301399231,
0.5404773354530334,
0.25958606600761414,
0.036754727363586426,
-0.2800642251968384,
-0.9037100672721863,
-0.10105340927839279,
0.6985242962837219,
0.44007137417793274,
-0.0790194571018219,
0.5206848382949829,
-0.32630228996276855,
0.5355380177497864,
-0.41981491446495056,
0.10024003684520721,
0.3103176951408386,
-0.6317188739776611,
0.05940208211541176,
-0.12689965963363647,
0.6721693277359009,
0.08408663421869278,
0.6593036651611328,
-0.27680423855781555,
-0.13287922739982605,
0.16488945484161377,
0.2939651310443878,
-0.382843941450119,
-0.2737220227718353,
0.22832748293876648,
-0.37606412172317505,
-0.2562800943851471,
0.09513471275568008,
-0.8933645486831665,
-0.21893927454948425,
-0.8317225575447083,
-0.030924508348107338,
-0.388071745634079,
-0.5020464062690735,
0.05751081556081772,
-0.1561541110277176,
0.10883849114179611,
0.012051597237586975,
-0.9291964173316956,
0.5818974375724792,
0.6934472918510437,
0.6787015795707703,
-0.36209702491760254,
-0.11041373759508133,
-0.027639979496598244,
-0.007444288581609726,
-0.7406532764434814,
0.6818509101867676,
-0.5468442440032959,
-0.5136824250221252,
0.0536687858402729,
-0.13166649639606476,
0.03757821023464203,
-0.7809110879898071,
0.4313099682331085,
-0.14752954244613647,
0.12735851109027863,
0.03589704632759094,
-0.5282697677612305,
0.03796876221895218,
0.06252451986074448,
-0.8037106990814209,
0.8516791462898254,
0.21142692863941193,
-0.24344775080680847,
0.12834298610687256,
-0.4727865755558014,
-0.5683313012123108,
-0.17038655281066895,
-0.3265988230705261,
-0.42519691586494446,
0.3965856730937958,
0.04553353786468506,
0.11852537840604782,
-0.28152036666870117,
0.4077022969722748,
-0.26831886172294617,
-0.09697788953781128,
0.5639868378639221,
-0.5319532155990601,
0.7062133550643921,
0.402049720287323,
0.03401372581720352,
-0.14700691401958466,
-1.0274415016174316,
0.05583381652832031,
0.37045401334762573,
0.05927281826734543,
-0.41039809584617615,
0.148818239569664,
0.3226805329322815,
0.09139857441186905,
-0.11010660231113434,
-0.6669377684593201,
0.16540682315826416,
-0.46737441420555115,
0.41205427050590515,
0.7082476615905762,
-0.12133543938398361,
0.3435981273651123,
-0.5067397356033325,
0.5215979814529419,
-0.13722123205661774,
0.11271432787179947,
0.0424947626888752,
-0.5923112630844116,
-0.3516072928905487,
-0.007552738767117262,
0.4910271465778351,
0.4274055063724518,
-0.523215115070343,
0.24943745136260986,
-0.057791683822870255,
-0.6807491183280945,
-0.6360805034637451,
0.16419373452663422,
0.1576729714870453,
0.3435693383216858,
0.15409724414348602,
-0.3168333172798157,
-0.8245154619216919,
-0.988151490688324,
-0.2860683798789978,
-0.1428067684173584,
0.3044244647026062,
0.23661066591739655,
0.3460168242454529,
-0.3735942542552948,
1.1656768321990967,
-0.377882182598114,
0.04207243397831917,
-0.4232510030269623,
0.22409208118915558,
0.10783975571393967,
0.7928026914596558,
0.5924769043922424,
-0.923609733581543,
-0.3328110873699188,
0.008856826461851597,
-0.7361063957214355,
0.1059127151966095,
-0.20888814330101013,
-0.2656673491001129,
0.29529812932014465,
0.30157867074012756,
-0.8520800471305847,
0.2579980492591858,
0.7845870852470398,
-0.10698321461677551,
0.5340051054954529,
-0.12832856178283691,
0.1027977243065834,
-1.2208086252212524,
0.161934494972229,
-0.04427341744303703,
-0.28534793853759766,
-0.998343825340271,
-0.09715880453586578,
-0.28537264466285706,
-0.21016421914100647,
-0.3287358582019806,
0.7138159871101379,
-0.09646707773208618,
-0.028769763186573982,
-0.10001461207866669,
-0.3331725001335144,
-0.1713913530111313,
0.043725933879613876,
0.280691534280777,
0.9292407631874084,
0.30275583267211914,
-0.41397741436958313,
0.429432213306427,
0.3012242615222931,
-0.5340140461921692,
0.01618165895342827,
-0.7399446368217468,
0.3414316773414612,
-0.11916972696781158,
0.15736255049705505,
-0.6689123511314392,
-0.3396655023097992,
0.08537013828754425,
-0.4597255289554596,
0.3456084728240967,
0.0503787100315094,
-0.5986628532409668,
-0.05654190480709076,
0.018653877079486847,
0.41566920280456543,
0.7721977233886719,
-0.3548040986061096,
0.4759874939918518,
0.9149503111839294,
-0.2745297849178314,
-0.3399529457092285,
-0.5399975180625916,
0.0923066958785057,
-0.1431998759508133,
-0.23774439096450806,
0.36300668120384216,
-0.12217351794242859,
-0.4973599314689636,
-0.01476178877055645,
0.09198983758687973,
-0.27405938506126404,
0.09162355959415436,
0.15719042718410492,
0.049631498754024506,
-0.05687775835394859,
-0.10020323097705841,
-0.12676823139190674,
-0.28478822112083435,
0.1559019684791565,
-0.19068323075771332,
0.582032322883606,
0.13414780795574188,
-0.23708480596542358,
-0.4467621445655823,
0.5035015940666199,
0.6493073105812073,
-0.09429844468832016,
0.6304658651351929,
0.25436416268348694,
-0.6881757974624634,
-0.47393232583999634,
-0.3261672258377075,
-0.2242193967103958,
-0.45950430631637573,
0.28116318583488464,
-0.08115614950656891,
-0.4368186891078949,
0.3547545075416565,
-0.08707895874977112,
0.039773017168045044,
0.1442319005727768,
0.4748043119907379,
-0.27163344621658325,
1.2705374956130981,
0.6680448055267334,
-0.1388801485300064,
0.40513864159584045,
-0.26259103417396545,
0.4672415554523468,
-0.27712148427963257,
-0.22201523184776306,
-0.7443704009056091,
0.25169602036476135,
-0.8898645639419556,
-0.15621814131736755,
0.18579760193824768,
-0.2300497591495514,
0.03028162755072117,
0.20254874229431152,
-0.18486148118972778,
0.4344576895236969,
0.8002390265464783,
-0.19170904159545898,
0.40844637155532837,
0.14026999473571777,
0.13962578773498535,
-0.07018127292394638,
-0.4892536699771881,
-0.7923975586891174,
1.1566771268844604,
0.2560414969921112,
0.7314265370368958,
-0.1102042943239212,
0.4435007572174072,
0.35277631878852844,
0.1114787682890892,
-0.3166198432445526,
0.3815405070781708,
-0.1137952208518982,
-0.8213796019554138,
-0.3760830760002136,
-0.4147418737411499,
-1.0031245946884155,
-0.014482651837170124,
-0.30285635590553284,
-0.3912127614021301,
0.043132759630680084,
0.4496559500694275,
0.04145968332886696,
-0.08239966630935669,
-0.7369859218597412,
0.8000032305717468,
-0.28426817059516907,
-0.1078128069639206,
-0.19805753231048584,
-0.44161251187324524,
0.3569583594799042,
-0.32885727286338806,
0.5365874171257019,
-0.04453354701399803,
0.4503748416900635,
0.5567057728767395,
-0.28884515166282654,
0.7958624362945557,
0.06565254926681519,
0.013308356516063213,
0.5578694343566895,
0.028092948719859123,
0.5920635461807251,
0.07222682982683182,
-0.09797769784927368,
0.3458002209663391,
0.16118912398815155,
-0.3300224840641022,
-0.8025783896446228,
0.5306259989738464,
-0.7240840792655945,
-0.45693767070770264,
-0.5064327120780945,
-0.6906635761260986,
-0.5728842616081238,
-0.0070698196068406105,
-0.10591037571430206,
0.34710031747817993,
-0.3333393335342407,
0.3222050964832306,
0.3142339289188385,
-0.2821555733680725,
0.2379286140203476,
0.2758020758628845,
-0.08142716437578201,
-0.33202406764030457,
1.2435178756713867,
0.33447691798210144,
0.29436442255973816,
-0.12657280266284943,
0.18708300590515137,
-0.37279295921325684,
-0.8773317933082581,
-0.39235004782676697,
0.1658010631799698,
-0.2778152525424957,
0.06232266128063202,
-0.3748724162578583,
-0.3399498462677002,
-0.6584303379058838,
0.20922145247459412,
-0.6647960543632507,
-0.6940650939941406,
0.05575687438249588,
-0.3454238772392273,
0.1721726655960083,
0.8214331865310669,
-0.09393175691366196,
-0.008656313642859459,
-0.7847998738288879,
0.3178422451019287,
0.06163037195801735,
0.2868492901325226,
-0.2259562462568283,
0.14830926060676575,
-0.24610635638237,
0.4500575661659241,
-0.08154720813035965,
-0.534399151802063,
0.7614638805389404,
0.21798866987228394,
0.9649825096130371,
-0.10172165185213089,
0.0773407593369484,
0.4515421390533447,
-0.5266203284263611,
0.7900781035423279,
-0.38258954882621765,
-0.7346357107162476,
0.5548216700553894,
-0.404011070728302,
-0.15143385529518127,
0.41433802247047424,
0.518449068069458,
-0.5185325741767883,
-0.44820383191108704,
-0.6666864156723022,
-0.7234162092208862,
0.5019914507865906,
0.6116527915000916,
0.4516805410385132,
0.16855427622795105,
0.43825700879096985,
0.5052161812782288,
0.39559662342071533,
-0.5066088438034058,
-0.16351322829723358,
-0.2594871520996094,
-0.7479435801506042,
-0.1719127744436264,
0.14226949214935303,
0.20685389637947083,
-0.3130631744861603,
0.6769663095474243,
-0.03995838388800621,
0.17237567901611328,
-0.16359663009643555,
0.014745167456567287,
0.12494921684265137,
0.17152820527553558,
0.6312102675437927,
0.7778605818748474,
-0.008550173602998257,
-0.02639766037464142,
0.031105373054742813,
-0.5368616580963135,
0.11631383001804352,
-0.045406632125377655,
-0.373349130153656,
-0.04731554538011551,
0.365660160779953,
0.36336004734039307,
-0.371801495552063,
-1.0132732391357422,
0.13349375128746033,
-0.11268702894449234,
0.07216033339500427,
-0.5146213173866272,
0.21190378069877625,
-0.09919171780347824,
0.026671646162867546,
0.24511021375656128,
-0.04437883943319321,
0.1597532331943512,
-1.0402147769927979,
0.33741822838783264,
0.386120468378067,
-0.05430476740002632,
-0.5088319182395935,
0.24529126286506653,
0.029867107048630714,
-0.28930869698524475,
0.8665318489074707,
0.2699688971042633,
-0.3211047947406769,
0.7017342448234558,
0.8277479410171509,
0.3927540183067322,
-0.41483765840530396,
0.31546568870544434,
0.14370258152484894,
0.07570668309926987,
-0.24409781396389008,
0.43575048446655273,
0.2014932632446289,
-0.8950703144073486,
-0.19235676527023315,
-0.5163468718528748,
-0.6046512126922607,
0.26833051443099976,
-0.36908265948295593,
0.009916012175381184,
-0.6009755730628967,
-0.021336354315280914,
-0.10864686965942383,
-0.13121658563613892,
-0.5054323077201843,
0.3337784707546234,
0.00015730081941001117,
0.5912354588508606,
-0.8798038363456726,
0.9598541259765625,
0.2832895517349243,
-0.44943705201148987,
-0.6125068068504333,
-0.2720790207386017,
0.19450508058071136,
-0.727672815322876,
0.4485320448875427,
-0.1067652702331543,
0.08809120953083038,
0.003632570616900921,
-0.7314451336860657,
-1.0356086492538452,
0.7055802345275879,
0.4876974821090698,
-0.3886721432209015,
-0.0435069277882576,
0.6110172271728516,
0.8072405457496643,
-0.6145431399345398,
-0.08405990898609161,
0.7989497184753418,
0.3572886884212494,
0.019525952637195587,
-0.5786033272743225,
-0.11503560841083527,
-0.3672971725463867,
0.00138364196754992,
-0.10983003675937653,
-0.34315574169158936,
0.7698734998703003,
-0.008315428160130978,
-0.4488080143928528,
0.1709151715040207,
0.5553006529808044,
0.28793805837631226,
0.2898005545139313,
0.1661088615655899,
0.23151075839996338,
0.6567757725715637,
-0.1543339341878891,
1.1474515199661255,
-0.35845884680747986,
0.14183510839939117,
1.0348460674285889,
-0.3865620493888855,
0.764457106590271,
0.2642502784729004,
-0.16575908660888672,
0.38531845808029175,
0.5566331744194031,
0.031502559781074524,
0.4923534691333771,
0.21731004118919373,
0.1553530991077423,
-0.08857598900794983,
-0.43407323956489563,
-0.312826931476593,
0.6253808736801147,
0.5173275470733643,
-0.32826948165893555,
0.057908471673727036,
-0.0473410040140152,
-0.1797855645418167,
0.32212546467781067,
0.24818283319473267,
0.8058066964149475,
0.10224533081054688,
-0.5084467530250549,
0.2138868272304535,
-0.21053585410118103,
0.12606772780418396,
-0.397225558757782,
-0.5664080381393433,
-0.28379321098327637,
0.21288970112800598,
0.051545992493629456,
-0.6446009874343872,
0.6198439002037048,
-0.08443255722522736,
0.01448117010295391,
-0.41767895221710205,
0.381319522857666,
-0.5254623889923096,
-0.6062523722648621,
-0.12687988579273224,
0.590912401676178,
0.042294107377529144,
0.1405867338180542,
-0.4301692247390747,
0.13067330420017242,
-0.27997297048568726,
-0.13634636998176575,
0.20040327310562134,
0.20236091315746307,
-0.20309534668922424,
0.7128130793571472,
1.063043236732483,
0.5143207311630249,
0.10813628137111664,
0.036405377089977264,
0.6073338985443115,
-0.7717580795288086,
-0.28439292311668396,
-0.699620246887207,
0.48907470703125,
-0.3433850407600403,
-0.327619343996048,
0.6803467869758606,
0.6086279153823853,
1.1349846124649048,
-0.05101728066802025,
1.0354188680648804,
0.21116773784160614,
0.7477314472198486,
-0.7378206849098206,
0.8382840156555176,
-0.1452406495809555,
0.011042393743991852,
-0.03254108130931854,
-0.9193069338798523,
-0.4659903943538666,
0.7259407639503479,
0.060581136494874954,
0.10336057096719742,
0.4851698577404022,
0.8540568351745605,
-0.03054030053317547,
0.21392981708049774,
0.1722276210784912,
0.13998140394687653,
0.6988965272903442,
0.10578157752752304,
0.9178799986839294,
-0.4485265016555786,
0.19358216226100922,
-0.3598182201385498,
0.05008488520979881,
0.10896259546279907,
-0.6100983619689941,
-0.7070029377937317,
-0.9543322920799255,
-0.27663567662239075,
-0.13196615874767303,
0.1766943782567978,
1.2395074367523193,
1.0004632472991943,
-1.2309677600860596,
-0.26810720562934875,
-0.4798295497894287,
0.12633228302001953,
-0.16026271879673004,
-0.17206346988677979,
0.18080337345600128,
-0.2319803237915039,
-1.0193148851394653,
0.5668397545814514,
-0.10465212911367416,
0.6593224406242371,
-0.19334647059440613,
-0.14777711033821106,
-0.05826479196548462,
0.39176619052886963,
0.4994615316390991,
0.469887912273407,
-0.5815869569778442,
-0.35828298330307007,
-0.12657135725021362,
-0.13088743388652802,
-0.14204904437065125,
1.0209161043167114,
-0.8060070276260376,
0.4151815176010132,
0.5023219585418701,
0.7753419280052185,
0.2119835764169693,
0.13598822057247162,
1.357024908065796,
-0.5662518739700317,
0.14209726452827454,
0.3938443064689636,
0.3805605173110962,
0.4619414806365967,
-0.2486449033021927,
0.6176165342330933,
0.18880504369735718,
-0.3417285084724426,
-1.0527443885803223,
0.1984165906906128,
-0.5974994897842407,
-0.26671043038368225,
1.0014160871505737,
-0.02685253880918026,
-0.20751221477985382,
-0.43740761280059814,
-0.3148879110813141,
0.27603283524513245,
-0.3142682909965515,
1.065360188484192,
0.7147498726844788,
-0.17087408900260925,
-0.24656562507152557,
-0.6452536582946777,
0.8633286356925964,
0.051020074635744095,
-1.1485575437545776,
0.2604181170463562,
0.545462429523468,
0.040636345744132996,
0.008991432376205921,
0.18376486003398895,
-0.2419663518667221,
-0.07528045773506165,
0.04758382961153984,
-0.3726769685745239,
-0.14582818746566772,
-0.6227597594261169,
-0.1823861300945282,
0.005368832964450121,
-0.0021629163529723883,
0.061966292560100555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07501v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07501v1
|
Leveraging Data Augmentation for Process Information Extraction
| 2024-04-11T06:32:03 | 2024-04-11T06:32:03 |
Julian Neuberger, Leonie Doll, Benedict Engelmann, Lars Ackermann, Stefan Jablonski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Business Process Modeling projects often require formal process models as a
central component. High costs associated with the creation of such formal
process models motivated many different fields of research aimed at automated
generation of process models from readily available data. These include process
mining on event logs, and generating business process models from natural
language texts. Research in the latter field is regularly faced with the
problem of limited data availability, hindering both evaluation and development
of new techniques, especially learning-based ones.
To overcome this data scarcity issue, in this paper we investigate the
application of data augmentation for natural language text data. Data
augmentation methods are well established in machine learning for creating new,
synthetic data without human assistance. We find that many of these methods are
applicable to the task of business process information extraction, improving
the accuracy of extraction. Our study shows, that data augmentation is an
important component in enabling machine learning methods for the task of
business process model generation from natural language text, where currently
mostly rule-based systems are still state of the art. Simple data augmentation
techniques improved the $F_1$ score of mention extraction by 2.9 percentage
points, and the $F_1$ of relation extraction by $4.5$. To better understand how
data augmentation alters human annotated texts, we analyze the resulting text,
visualizing and discussing the properties of augmented textual data.
We make all code and experiments results publicly available.
|
[
-0.33056724071502686,
-1.0570292472839355,
0.3821982443332672,
-0.07036711275577545,
-0.35616612434387207,
-0.04585015028715134,
-0.24348998069763184,
-0.9855930209159851,
0.006959385238587856,
0.9423907995223999,
-0.6674671769142151,
-0.3703693151473999,
-0.4362170696258545,
0.3140609860420227,
-0.17471858859062195,
1.1284451484680176,
-0.022189833223819733,
-0.20157186686992645,
-0.16752353310585022,
0.17332495748996735,
-0.4760003089904785,
-0.6188348531723022,
-0.45061787962913513,
-0.3813568651676178,
-0.11052253842353821,
0.5097377300262451,
0.5978167057037354,
0.6621037125587463,
0.5588356852531433,
0.2965620160102844,
0.10404601693153381,
0.4330228865146637,
-0.06962306797504425,
0.3547157347202301,
-0.08579406887292862,
-0.35230305790901184,
-0.39607033133506775,
0.12049056589603424,
0.5699387192726135,
0.8349285125732422,
0.10139200091362,
0.20538559556007385,
0.05515633523464203,
0.7892447113990784,
-0.4101831912994385,
0.4980531632900238,
-0.7057453989982605,
0.04942088574171066,
-0.21099738776683807,
-0.3479563295841217,
-0.16935107111930847,
-0.404705286026001,
0.5004134774208069,
-0.5679119229316711,
0.5288034081459045,
0.0037642219103872776,
0.9334549307823181,
-0.04275887459516525,
-0.050529658794403076,
-0.4902506172657013,
-0.9776938557624817,
0.6054717898368835,
-0.6980147957801819,
0.12721861898899078,
0.40930646657943726,
0.24151043593883514,
-0.20323418080806732,
-0.8326910734176636,
-0.5338964462280273,
-0.20089885592460632,
-0.18578112125396729,
-0.04898642376065254,
-0.19927509129047394,
0.03833133727312088,
0.6326582431793213,
0.5622709393501282,
-0.27893248200416565,
-0.11861670017242432,
-0.5003554821014404,
-0.04103817790746689,
0.6810075640678406,
0.09350112080574036,
0.15966281294822693,
-0.1849849373102188,
-0.23258690536022186,
0.07953287661075592,
-0.15731319785118103,
-0.09259190410375595,
0.43949785828590393,
0.5096440315246582,
0.339529424905777,
0.7160203456878662,
-0.4807959198951721,
0.685492992401123,
-0.07918153703212738,
0.15793445706367493,
0.38985833525657654,
-0.5113410949707031,
-0.5224621295928955,
0.11273795366287231,
0.5714876055717468,
0.05833686143159866,
0.1293754279613495,
-0.28626683354377747,
-0.15505822002887726,
-0.018448129296302795,
0.3487889766693115,
-0.8949555158615112,
-0.278251588344574,
0.1449488401412964,
-0.40832972526550293,
-0.2800796627998352,
0.4171077311038971,
-0.7415934801101685,
-0.4637044370174408,
-0.6728538274765015,
0.24419954419136047,
-0.5502011179924011,
-0.15331965684890747,
-0.27343204617500305,
-0.5440654158592224,
-0.0058813998475670815,
0.3222918212413788,
-0.7878279089927673,
0.3465641438961029,
0.7723402380943298,
0.7273464798927307,
-0.2706671953201294,
0.12278947979211807,
-0.645134449005127,
0.17782267928123474,
-0.3547239899635315,
0.5944197177886963,
-0.8704814314842224,
-0.24245256185531616,
-0.20897571742534637,
0.10556704550981522,
0.19983907043933868,
-0.874327540397644,
0.9613887667655945,
-0.3628346920013428,
0.29907625913619995,
0.07164034247398376,
-0.9324949383735657,
-0.2447739839553833,
0.06368374824523926,
-0.8912645578384399,
1.1665658950805664,
-0.03966008126735687,
-0.5947862863540649,
0.5981045961380005,
-0.8653176426887512,
-0.49583569169044495,
0.2620301842689514,
-0.1423347145318985,
-0.6433711647987366,
0.2596488296985626,
0.430135577917099,
0.5566083192825317,
-0.2820321023464203,
0.09320005774497986,
-0.2376064956188202,
0.017223913222551346,
0.4296781122684479,
-0.5117049813270569,
0.5993772745132446,
0.26625388860702515,
-0.22200635075569153,
-0.2018621414899826,
-1.006395936012268,
-0.17099149525165558,
-0.0992380827665329,
-0.31469735503196716,
-0.4410117268562317,
-0.08978765457868576,
0.05140510946512222,
0.13289615511894226,
0.2399962991476059,
-0.5417649149894714,
0.13023754954338074,
-0.7360633611679077,
-0.08737975358963013,
0.5002729892730713,
0.5791568160057068,
0.5057334303855896,
-0.21527987718582153,
0.4228423833847046,
-0.004071271512657404,
-0.08795832842588425,
-0.5739027857780457,
-0.5776438117027283,
-0.5946944952011108,
-0.4966149926185608,
0.2154259830713272,
0.4151255190372467,
-0.5988326072692871,
0.6134633421897888,
-0.19271643459796906,
-0.5524527430534363,
-0.6921558380126953,
0.30930855870246887,
-0.1595482975244522,
0.8226591348648071,
0.3050003945827484,
-0.24023263156414032,
-0.9806696176528931,
-0.8562878370285034,
-0.43247702717781067,
0.052721671760082245,
-0.2553388476371765,
0.051843054592609406,
0.23309096693992615,
-0.29747623205184937,
1.2979930639266968,
-0.6272950172424316,
-0.22193960845470428,
-0.27948737144470215,
0.5924856662750244,
0.37242835760116577,
0.469756543636322,
0.08726223558187485,
-0.8526756167411804,
-0.19828566908836365,
0.322314590215683,
-0.6122975945472717,
-0.21527881920337677,
-0.32405373454093933,
-0.14404375851154327,
0.5662112832069397,
-0.07840925455093384,
-0.43577390909194946,
0.7491621971130371,
0.11681173741817474,
-0.002652302384376526,
0.5484355688095093,
-0.3494639992713928,
0.17646892368793488,
-0.9806157350540161,
0.35625696182250977,
0.33089375495910645,
-0.3489949107170105,
-0.9879006743431091,
-0.21745344996452332,
0.04958612099289894,
-0.3450506925582886,
0.13785792887210846,
0.25747406482696533,
-0.4897095859050751,
-0.039094675332307816,
-0.6788076758384705,
-0.11807340383529663,
0.29520660638809204,
0.35771259665489197,
0.40606290102005005,
0.40654492378234863,
0.3498556315898895,
-0.708736777305603,
0.3961910307407379,
0.16637462377548218,
-0.341994971036911,
0.31163662672042847,
-0.21824967861175537,
0.11317671090364456,
-0.21725159883499146,
-0.05385582894086838,
-0.8305131793022156,
-0.17452076077461243,
0.37917569279670715,
-0.47312837839126587,
0.255446195602417,
-0.2047460675239563,
-0.5254802703857422,
-0.07802896946668625,
-0.13453470170497894,
-0.49961045384407043,
0.47888892889022827,
-0.5140682458877563,
0.5643119812011719,
0.6395702958106995,
-0.3923887014389038,
-0.11355596780776978,
-0.7344745397567749,
0.15123362839221954,
-0.14796675741672516,
-0.5323116779327393,
0.26368072628974915,
0.1069093719124794,
-0.08202430605888367,
0.018011463806033134,
-0.3861728608608246,
-0.5251771807670593,
0.11111941188573837,
0.2640729546546936,
0.677946925163269,
0.17882750928401947,
0.3090273141860962,
-0.04727042093873024,
-0.23099322617053986,
0.22088885307312012,
-0.2334223985671997,
0.09255838394165039,
0.27540701627731323,
-0.11929576843976974,
-0.7518206834793091,
0.3244969844818115,
0.23252035677433014,
-0.13086439669132233,
0.6979860067367554,
0.6541531682014465,
-0.8444332480430603,
0.04688518866896629,
-0.6217861771583557,
-0.32873356342315674,
-0.4465169608592987,
0.2129717320203781,
-0.07380802929401398,
-0.36835238337516785,
0.30146607756614685,
-0.34868738055229187,
0.22136692702770233,
0.43793997168540955,
0.31722161173820496,
-0.030319292098283768,
0.8927326202392578,
0.6278494596481323,
-0.09890012443065643,
0.5653733611106873,
-0.19146083295345306,
0.3364828824996948,
-0.4725899398326874,
-0.32806816697120667,
-0.6867920160293579,
-0.06101708114147186,
-0.5100482702255249,
-0.3463705778121948,
0.13134492933750153,
0.0011143733281642199,
0.5739962458610535,
0.3031430244445801,
-0.3830750286579132,
0.16888561844825745,
0.42759639024734497,
0.04315447434782982,
0.6319544911384583,
0.3478286564350128,
0.24538488686084747,
-0.3860641419887543,
-0.4578910768032074,
-0.7937358021736145,
1.0132062435150146,
0.3560473918914795,
0.42570605874061584,
-0.28114157915115356,
0.5906623005867004,
0.42037394642829895,
0.3190895915031433,
-0.5256664752960205,
0.34376659989356995,
0.11024860292673111,
-0.7308722734451294,
-0.3226517140865326,
-0.5778947472572327,
-0.8551415205001831,
-0.0409502275288105,
-0.5671407580375671,
-0.6025120615959167,
0.17872542142868042,
0.09947934001684189,
-0.034172430634498596,
0.04949341341853142,
-0.8715785145759583,
0.5562750101089478,
0.004226404242217541,
-0.5054522752761841,
-0.06186207756400108,
-0.4320138692855835,
0.15609204769134521,
-0.265144020318985,
0.3372654616832733,
0.056216951459646225,
-0.026837117969989777,
0.7712369561195374,
-0.720970094203949,
0.6544675827026367,
-0.18947406113147736,
-0.08392570912837982,
0.3164758086204529,
-0.36584097146987915,
0.9857854843139648,
0.018134236335754395,
-0.45577335357666016,
0.04424882307648659,
-0.2863411605358124,
-0.1904110610485077,
-0.8961867690086365,
0.344370573759079,
-0.05261371284723282,
-0.21153292059898376,
-0.35212886333465576,
-0.36859503388404846,
-0.13795503973960876,
0.001980516593903303,
-0.042564935982227325,
0.3084251582622528,
-0.11495140194892883,
0.07721135765314102,
0.48247453570365906,
-0.021671323105692863,
0.5629026293754578,
0.37071046233177185,
0.04888511449098587,
-0.42588353157043457,
0.9001805782318115,
0.16536298394203186,
-0.00626236479729414,
0.3436383306980133,
0.07952858507633209,
-0.34573474526405334,
-0.4715922176837921,
-0.3073011338710785,
-0.16949836909770966,
-0.4069546163082123,
-0.17209826409816742,
-0.6782978177070618,
-0.16671383380889893,
-0.5221192240715027,
0.1631988286972046,
-0.08442651480436325,
-0.7108331918716431,
-0.5342718362808228,
-0.24003060162067413,
0.46846044063568115,
0.37848812341690063,
0.03673733025789261,
0.1288641095161438,
-1.095065712928772,
0.44233494997024536,
0.11430338770151138,
0.21453556418418884,
-0.15144619345664978,
-0.17682552337646484,
-0.5341638922691345,
0.20787902176380157,
-0.34724655747413635,
-1.0644911527633667,
0.6235530376434326,
0.27757516503334045,
0.5583043098449707,
0.4359632134437561,
0.04340376332402229,
0.8870898485183716,
-0.19720785319805145,
0.5573652386665344,
-0.11807288229465485,
-0.8588899374008179,
0.7581170797348022,
-0.027071235701441765,
0.06062563881278038,
0.5089800357818604,
0.4345310628414154,
-0.3542470335960388,
-0.37883588671684265,
-0.9170984029769897,
-0.93264240026474,
0.9358747601509094,
0.5771628618240356,
0.0491175502538681,
0.15796245634555817,
0.5238306522369385,
0.6024163365364075,
0.3924570381641388,
-0.4295884668827057,
-0.22204001247882843,
0.295430988073349,
-0.28228235244750977,
0.18031874299049377,
0.04801051318645477,
0.31131747364997864,
-0.24557332694530487,
1.0177956819534302,
0.11483966559171677,
-0.006267883814871311,
0.3064587712287903,
-0.20185810327529907,
-0.0033542721066623926,
0.20564883947372437,
0.05435730516910553,
0.5546280741691589,
-0.1450006514787674,
-0.11590283364057541,
0.2407902181148529,
-0.5643131732940674,
-0.3040858209133148,
0.5600175857543945,
-0.12237704545259476,
0.38175666332244873,
0.27897727489471436,
0.907982349395752,
-0.21490882337093353,
-0.7707019448280334,
0.07591478526592255,
0.15091457962989807,
-0.1369897723197937,
-0.2164466679096222,
0.18807697296142578,
-0.3247556686401367,
0.3188106417655945,
0.7062893509864807,
0.16877543926239014,
0.6048161387443542,
-0.6272484660148621,
0.4222504794597626,
0.3823685348033905,
-0.3124985098838806,
-0.13384287059307098,
0.24067336320877075,
0.11121494323015213,
-0.292205274105072,
0.40542563796043396,
-0.18837490677833557,
-0.09734217822551727,
0.24438098073005676,
0.46532905101776123,
0.7546154260635376,
-0.09081774950027466,
0.13057827949523926,
0.34010300040245056,
0.30994075536727905,
0.058768242597579956,
0.15668487548828125,
-0.2765178680419922,
-0.2678512930870056,
-0.584526777267456,
-0.48426055908203125,
-0.5389822125434875,
0.29984626173973083,
-0.43841803073883057,
0.42962712049484253,
-0.26769372820854187,
-0.24034003913402557,
0.16053524613380432,
0.40470123291015625,
-0.5806090235710144,
0.21395036578178406,
0.17112506926059723,
0.5708839297294617,
-0.8918192982673645,
0.5866358876228333,
0.6257678270339966,
-0.4414707124233246,
-0.3327696919441223,
-0.054930754005908966,
-0.4479774534702301,
-0.19086861610412598,
0.4315357208251953,
0.34043729305267334,
0.2746390998363495,
-0.13040117919445038,
-0.3403761684894562,
-0.44335657358169556,
0.7469975352287292,
0.3435908257961273,
-0.3664698004722595,
0.11269614100456238,
0.3359096348285675,
0.6440666913986206,
-0.4164102077484131,
0.16542965173721313,
0.7516030669212341,
0.5211629271507263,
0.208759605884552,
-0.3445582985877991,
0.18658484518527985,
-0.36192232370376587,
-0.03406088054180145,
0.2907302975654602,
0.2829084098339081,
0.3423749506473541,
0.09903546422719955,
-0.39628586173057556,
-0.2264263927936554,
0.7898042798042297,
0.20640425384044647,
0.4920334219932556,
0.28485772013664246,
0.4091002643108368,
1.101503610610962,
0.08558106422424316,
0.7255889773368835,
0.1337272971868515,
0.05132198706269264,
1.1969143152236938,
-0.3248752951622009,
0.6253719925880432,
0.44141581654548645,
0.01774492673575878,
0.5033318400382996,
0.37429845333099365,
-0.11395502090454102,
0.14725016057491302,
-0.011384926736354828,
-0.3926889896392822,
0.10512466728687286,
-0.0063521065749228,
-0.040419355034828186,
0.17141175270080566,
0.4957408905029297,
-0.6164649128913879,
-0.0512072816491127,
-0.017713638022542,
-0.10105203837156296,
-0.009128682315349579,
-0.07252679765224457,
1.1441676616668701,
-0.28249362111091614,
-0.6220367550849915,
0.1749863475561142,
-0.010387146845459938,
0.3044784665107727,
-0.5215562582015991,
-0.4170045554637909,
0.11811010539531708,
0.006734554190188646,
-0.34052062034606934,
-0.5891982913017273,
0.591602623462677,
0.4467680752277374,
-0.2901279330253601,
-0.27241843938827515,
1.058323860168457,
-0.44897928833961487,
-0.7439621090888977,
-0.18363560736179352,
0.19876620173454285,
0.2754901647567749,
-0.3081323206424713,
-0.45452645421028137,
-0.13221584260463715,
0.01646847277879715,
-0.16229607164859772,
0.007424124050885439,
0.6498886346817017,
0.058148857206106186,
0.34961599111557007,
0.9809262156486511,
0.32907000184059143,
0.10633585602045059,
-0.11416257172822952,
0.7456669807434082,
-0.6045957803726196,
-0.5136206746101379,
-0.989597499370575,
0.6998534798622131,
-0.7878572940826416,
0.11939089000225067,
0.7052494883537292,
0.90372633934021,
0.4249520003795624,
0.014460943639278412,
1.2176165580749512,
0.09885493665933609,
0.6555363535881042,
-0.5761696100234985,
0.33988356590270996,
-0.1063607931137085,
0.42896974086761475,
-0.5375356078147888,
-0.8888641595840454,
-0.23553195595741272,
0.37489020824432373,
-0.3425053060054779,
-0.17452701926231384,
0.5278542637825012,
0.6901167631149292,
0.005502378102391958,
0.5521699786186218,
-0.10584468394517899,
-0.13178716599941254,
0.2600307762622833,
0.028277184814214706,
0.3818424642086029,
-0.5295881628990173,
0.5284081101417542,
-0.4097287058830261,
-0.4396718740463257,
-0.2820173501968384,
-0.9975874423980713,
-0.689817488193512,
-0.6801802515983582,
-0.5611457824707031,
-0.03174767643213272,
-0.09319507330656052,
0.9473773241043091,
0.5637031197547913,
-0.6484238505363464,
-0.13742001354694366,
-0.4581974148750305,
0.021355096250772476,
-0.22602976858615875,
-0.29581066966056824,
0.1312006264925003,
-0.6860705614089966,
-0.7861014604568481,
0.3565404415130615,
0.27251359820365906,
0.3231252431869507,
0.06835958361625671,
0.17016422748565674,
-0.3312729001045227,
-0.05020713433623314,
0.3836217224597931,
0.1826263666152954,
-0.11533233523368835,
0.06918305903673172,
-0.1692640483379364,
0.28611165285110474,
0.20929107069969177,
0.7297865152359009,
-0.8909815549850464,
0.6516615748405457,
0.7308946847915649,
0.9133109450340271,
0.8363981246948242,
0.26174572110176086,
0.801567792892456,
-1.0806810855865479,
0.06658802181482315,
0.03856594115495682,
0.031174378469586372,
0.5088893175125122,
-0.524296760559082,
0.5643740296363831,
0.3113025724887848,
-0.3401707708835602,
-0.6180575489997864,
0.07211188971996307,
-0.7207849025726318,
-0.13675794005393982,
0.7848861813545227,
0.12720654904842377,
-0.3423115313053131,
-0.314141184091568,
-0.5653602480888367,
0.6658610701560974,
-0.5695474147796631,
0.755482017993927,
0.6989494562149048,
-0.4179036319255829,
0.13779614865779877,
-0.6149228811264038,
0.5959637761116028,
0.018792735412716866,
-1.239579200744629,
0.367287814617157,
0.6232994198799133,
-0.04938371852040291,
0.1321505457162857,
0.3894040584564209,
-0.04912656173110008,
0.050556790083646774,
-0.35380417108535767,
0.22285613417625427,
-0.10014211386442184,
0.05250760167837143,
-0.5042665004730225,
0.28379955887794495,
-0.12928658723831177,
-0.27741554379463196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07498v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07498v1
|
Interactive Prompt Debugging with Sequence Salience
| 2024-04-11T06:22:56 | 2024-04-11T06:22:56 |
Ian Tenney, Ryan Mullins, Bin Du, Shree Pandya, Minsuk Kahng, Lucas Dixon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
We present Sequence Salience, a visual tool for interactive prompt debugging
with input salience methods. Sequence Salience builds on widely used salience
methods for text classification and single-token prediction, and extends this
to a system tailored for debugging complex LLM prompts. Our system is
well-suited for long texts, and expands on previous work by 1) providing
controllable aggregation of token-level salience to the word, sentence, or
paragraph level, making salience over long inputs tractable; and 2) supporting
rapid iteration where practitioners can act on salience results, refine
prompts, and run salience on the new output. We include case studies showing
how Sequence Salience can help practitioners work with several complex
prompting strategies, including few-shot, chain-of-thought, and constitutional
principles. Sequence Salience is built on the Learning Interpretability Tool,
an open-source platform for ML model visualizations, and code, notebooks, and
tutorials are available at http://goo.gle/sequence-salience.
|
[
-0.07045461237430573,
-0.9695737361907959,
0.7130547165870667,
0.5906840562820435,
-0.3619600534439087,
0.1513475626707077,
0.03586648032069206,
-0.3935853838920593,
0.3594060242176056,
0.32925885915756226,
-0.6977154612541199,
-0.5844457149505615,
-0.49981144070625305,
0.32029375433921814,
-0.42458516359329224,
0.7992525100708008,
0.19200512766838074,
-0.004539717920124531,
-0.423706591129303,
0.14472690224647522,
-0.7058855891227722,
-0.37262552976608276,
-0.7664961218833923,
0.07977846264839172,
0.98138427734375,
0.741875410079956,
0.3755742907524109,
0.4270210862159729,
0.5987273454666138,
0.212337926030159,
-0.3398061692714691,
-0.06648850440979004,
-0.4117061495780945,
0.7116038203239441,
-0.056839946657419205,
-0.41167715191841125,
-0.37489989399909973,
-0.33856022357940674,
0.4236298203468323,
0.6380318999290466,
0.32452890276908875,
0.3986820876598358,
0.0993504747748375,
0.5955091714859009,
-0.40671032667160034,
0.21752120554447174,
-0.1547800600528717,
0.2514907121658325,
-0.2865794897079468,
-0.39827871322631836,
-0.3198891282081604,
-0.39483416080474854,
0.10570170730352402,
-0.5538537502288818,
-0.026340030133724213,
0.181275874376297,
0.3662494421005249,
0.7799478769302368,
-0.3375656306743622,
-0.3254588842391968,
-0.30758848786354065,
0.44936269521713257,
-0.5366138815879822,
0.10372162610292435,
0.16478995978832245,
0.4977361559867859,
-0.11361999809741974,
-0.9336502552032471,
-0.5113481879234314,
-0.4323107898235321,
-0.15453101694583893,
0.16534407436847687,
-0.0830710232257843,
0.10390400886535645,
0.5827426910400391,
0.3574110269546509,
-0.5498115420341492,
0.3040626347064972,
-0.15990252792835236,
0.035202499479055405,
0.39726394414901733,
0.3941050171852112,
0.3889552056789398,
-0.3531501591205597,
-0.3721518814563751,
0.21333971619606018,
-0.6418837904930115,
0.3973105549812317,
0.28580135107040405,
0.16126099228858948,
-0.2237519770860672,
0.5599393844604492,
-0.06620540469884872,
0.8421732187271118,
-0.17621348798274994,
0.2492828071117401,
-0.14122888445854187,
-0.23641085624694824,
-0.017477501183748245,
0.3097691237926483,
0.6574840545654297,
0.3021355867385864,
0.006710153538733721,
-0.01172547321766615,
0.025365442037582397,
-0.3459821343421936,
0.05425380542874336,
-0.7275885939598083,
-0.48395025730133057,
0.5640964508056641,
-0.5071720480918884,
-0.36756354570388794,
0.1516333818435669,
-1.1813079118728638,
-0.980495274066925,
-0.40181732177734375,
0.17210730910301208,
-0.335934579372406,
0.16387301683425903,
0.07881134003400803,
-0.5419384837150574,
0.07952722907066345,
0.6042845845222473,
-0.8327975869178772,
-0.06274400651454926,
0.6290021538734436,
0.9552592039108276,
-0.4526759386062622,
-0.06693235039710999,
-1.0644935369491577,
-0.12819184362888336,
0.27307093143463135,
0.8236163854598999,
-0.7127243876457214,
-0.7237350344657898,
-0.15768848359584808,
-0.05493726581335068,
0.29752299189567566,
-0.49515315890312195,
0.48252445459365845,
-0.15615172684192657,
0.22617843747138977,
-0.3346169590950012,
-0.5034029483795166,
-0.031928423792123795,
0.41933178901672363,
-0.84332674741745,
0.983519434928894,
0.060827042907476425,
-0.8123035430908203,
0.18671797215938568,
-1.195483922958374,
-0.13344089686870575,
0.23272983729839325,
-0.10231725871562958,
-0.09850558638572693,
-0.05056685954332352,
0.0092209717258811,
0.3333578109741211,
-0.041694026440382004,
-0.03200308233499527,
-0.33293667435646057,
-0.7434515357017517,
0.2267768234014511,
-0.28637853264808655,
0.8005313873291016,
-0.027918074280023575,
-0.4332883656024933,
0.5689693689346313,
-1.0875310897827148,
-0.22373056411743164,
0.04961945489048958,
-0.2043685019016266,
-0.27806806564331055,
-0.15082673728466034,
-0.04675934836268425,
-0.14927297830581665,
0.394308477640152,
-0.31701502203941345,
0.7199957966804504,
-0.0939796045422554,
0.19931767880916595,
0.8613055944442749,
0.25152823328971863,
0.10396965593099594,
0.2876482605934143,
1.007786512374878,
0.18638484179973602,
0.06264696270227432,
-0.7455808520317078,
-0.55596524477005,
-0.6790827512741089,
-0.5575451850891113,
0.20201575756072998,
0.724746584892273,
-0.6659207940101624,
0.3653620183467865,
0.028766989707946777,
-0.08018594235181808,
-0.43219810724258423,
-0.17912952601909637,
0.15015684068202972,
0.7353933453559875,
0.4381019175052643,
0.04812365025281906,
-0.5108873844146729,
-0.6908714771270752,
-0.4655052423477173,
-0.18195515871047974,
-0.09987609833478928,
0.06261318176984787,
0.3901267349720001,
-0.21005141735076904,
1.0123469829559326,
-0.744678795337677,
0.31718987226486206,
-0.058213137090206146,
0.527280867099762,
0.37225353717803955,
0.38365939259529114,
0.5510069131851196,
-0.6130581498146057,
-0.19346871972084045,
-0.3317834138870239,
-0.5912013053894043,
-0.5195895433425903,
-0.22793681919574738,
-0.09787046164274216,
-0.08925892412662506,
0.37115079164505005,
-0.4809912145137787,
0.4975380599498749,
0.18691802024841309,
-1.0497395992279053,
0.8089994192123413,
0.171530082821846,
0.3060479760169983,
-0.9529805183410645,
0.30533117055892944,
-0.16938480734825134,
-0.18908751010894775,
-0.37311533093452454,
-0.028725307434797287,
-0.023883936926722527,
-0.10523448139429092,
-0.4635303020477295,
0.8441736698150635,
-0.2803746163845062,
-0.13747566938400269,
-0.1361227184534073,
-0.1782694011926651,
0.13325689733028412,
0.1826762855052948,
-0.3425922989845276,
0.680270254611969,
0.5686601400375366,
-0.5871027112007141,
0.884067177772522,
0.29224660992622375,
-0.11655226349830627,
0.5147597789764404,
-0.8206978440284729,
0.1598769724369049,
-0.21710287034511566,
0.004418619908392429,
-1.2076137065887451,
-0.3990791440010071,
0.5799219012260437,
-0.3304602801799774,
0.19902057945728302,
-0.13414309918880463,
-0.49544575810432434,
-0.43951648473739624,
-0.548732578754425,
0.3638775050640106,
0.40018853545188904,
-0.8384405970573425,
0.2087959200143814,
-0.45035669207572937,
-0.5435528755187988,
-0.7432352304458618,
-0.6225817799568176,
0.15345332026481628,
-0.3645240068435669,
-0.40785691142082214,
0.09266293048858643,
-0.39523354172706604,
-0.43424534797668457,
-0.1714026778936386,
-0.05730833113193512,
0.03328863903880119,
0.46185529232025146,
0.615606963634491,
0.4146413803100586,
-0.0313054583966732,
0.19974900782108307,
0.39420387148857117,
-0.22949601709842682,
0.2520407736301422,
-0.11938197910785675,
0.3575817942619324,
-0.2165367752313614,
-0.6835125088691711,
-0.36073267459869385,
0.45269498229026794,
0.5874221920967102,
-0.07086703926324844,
0.22515355050563812,
0.6478666067123413,
-0.10878275334835052,
0.0589132159948349,
-0.09045296907424927,
-0.24200019240379333,
-0.45647016167640686,
0.10769354552030563,
-0.18193355202674866,
-1.0769304037094116,
0.6268839836120605,
-0.1723320037126541,
0.06802478432655334,
0.2623389661312103,
0.3265722692012787,
-0.14135389029979706,
0.8269228935241699,
0.7381094694137573,
0.31012076139450073,
0.5684278607368469,
-0.09761322289705276,
-0.0016304197488352656,
-0.38105231523513794,
-0.39278796315193176,
-0.4533675014972687,
-0.5690329670906067,
0.06325122714042664,
-0.25628089904785156,
0.38798871636390686,
0.5239197015762329,
-0.15827994048595428,
-0.21573497354984283,
-0.657646894454956,
0.7288221716880798,
0.594549298286438,
-0.04961840808391571,
0.39629819989204407,
-0.29039305448532104,
-0.04388285055756569,
-0.2295210063457489,
-0.43440496921539307,
-0.5437968969345093,
0.3791012465953827,
0.34477221965789795,
0.8072922825813293,
0.24991834163665771,
0.9807175397872925,
0.5826244354248047,
0.09821391105651855,
-1.2806727886199951,
0.6479044556617737,
0.1799713522195816,
0.05327960476279259,
-0.3814837634563446,
-0.32328757643699646,
-1.0393576622009277,
-0.1592843234539032,
-0.08174975216388702,
-0.8711845874786377,
0.17823733389377594,
0.6195645928382874,
-0.8600666522979736,
0.0951237827539444,
-0.580173671245575,
1.1776752471923828,
-0.24316461384296417,
-0.37418898940086365,
0.04104837030172348,
-0.8633771538734436,
0.4740707576274872,
0.24364031851291656,
-0.09296467900276184,
0.024153023958206177,
-0.1693682223558426,
0.48586660623550415,
-0.27198725938796997,
1.144119143486023,
-0.21339434385299683,
-0.3195096254348755,
0.14287500083446503,
0.18907517194747925,
0.25597500801086426,
0.2841194272041321,
-0.1466614156961441,
-0.056862082332372665,
-0.03248891979455948,
-0.4307316839694977,
-0.7392387986183167,
0.6273516416549683,
-0.15973453223705292,
-0.6390334963798523,
-0.3145327568054199,
-0.40273797512054443,
0.2024674266576767,
0.17359785735607147,
0.20146943628787994,
0.5001333951950073,
-0.24590428173542023,
-0.1310998797416687,
0.7141644954681396,
-0.3790295720100403,
0.8743047118186951,
0.29565322399139404,
-0.447150319814682,
-0.18525804579257965,
0.71151202917099,
-0.17654268443584442,
-0.05982791632413864,
0.34018951654434204,
0.16040177643299103,
-0.3489656150341034,
-0.32207387685775757,
-0.6766310930252075,
-0.3461873531341553,
-0.739220917224884,
-0.23944897949695587,
-0.5411431193351746,
0.14669547975063324,
-0.24578507244586945,
-0.16580061614513397,
0.21459737420082092,
-0.93172687292099,
-0.6210721135139465,
-0.23740671575069427,
0.8330723643302917,
0.8994114398956299,
0.0012647256953641772,
0.28186503052711487,
-1.1567306518554688,
0.39493000507354736,
0.48979493975639343,
0.36520013213157654,
-0.08084824681282043,
-0.38312041759490967,
-0.1108831986784935,
-0.3667469024658203,
-0.39220166206359863,
-1.1845223903656006,
0.22434739768505096,
-0.05442802235484123,
0.24612873792648315,
0.5157493948936462,
0.12895247340202332,
0.6077933311462402,
-0.4841127395629883,
1.4062620401382446,
0.3551766276359558,
-1.1212923526763916,
0.8525795936584473,
-0.2999905049800873,
0.5738564729690552,
0.3803207576274872,
0.34330669045448303,
-0.5863234996795654,
-0.44478145241737366,
-0.4494324326515198,
-1.1671030521392822,
0.2444075047969818,
-0.1933024376630783,
-0.0036076302640140057,
-0.3910108804702759,
0.37862628698349,
0.6065279841423035,
0.192501038312912,
-0.3919416069984436,
-0.3109232485294342,
-0.27135342359542847,
-0.32906970381736755,
0.3165687918663025,
-0.46803751587867737,
-0.21025414764881134,
-0.30330902338027954,
0.1247539296746254,
-0.19961783289909363,
0.2176400125026703,
0.32818102836608887,
-0.2575727105140686,
0.05858676880598068,
0.48252952098846436,
0.8788793683052063,
0.8296812772750854,
-0.23298810422420502,
0.3749566972255707,
0.04675733670592308,
-0.24568453431129456,
0.018025286495685577,
0.2698492407798767,
0.07802969962358475,
0.2732638418674469,
0.3719871938228607,
0.8699894547462463,
0.4161062240600586,
-0.9508883953094482,
0.4910717010498047,
-0.008548746816813946,
0.18816262483596802,
-0.24348275363445282,
0.10828416794538498,
-0.049522534012794495,
0.43003055453300476,
0.5795716047286987,
-0.2780725955963135,
0.5574742555618286,
-0.41029125452041626,
0.06636018306016922,
0.17620761692523956,
-0.25438937544822693,
-0.24326980113983154,
0.8719061017036438,
0.4323195815086365,
-0.3646896779537201,
0.4654625356197357,
-0.20903059840202332,
-0.49105769395828247,
0.7725039720535278,
0.3889351189136505,
0.8283708095550537,
-0.008943557739257812,
0.1453048288822174,
0.260025292634964,
-0.223427414894104,
0.16097363829612732,
0.5744062662124634,
-0.19438640773296356,
0.05569719523191452,
-0.4894908666610718,
-0.35377755761146545,
-0.7615591883659363,
-0.10896473377943039,
-0.8388214111328125,
0.3105335533618927,
-0.4500693380832672,
-0.12711483240127563,
-0.025257769972085953,
-0.48473769426345825,
-0.2828744053840637,
-0.1733035296201706,
0.18859949707984924,
1.1114165782928467,
-0.5298680663108826,
0.26812177896499634,
0.8405553698539734,
-0.4366455078125,
-0.2072887271642685,
0.07664192467927933,
0.21400980651378632,
-0.5899009108543396,
1.0671093463897705,
0.5411027669906616,
-0.03715309128165245,
0.17158028483390808,
-1.0465537309646606,
-0.4421078562736511,
1.1910605430603027,
0.26488471031188965,
-0.5932637453079224,
0.046291232109069824,
-0.2544727921485901,
0.3538733124732971,
-0.07587039470672607,
0.2730899751186371,
0.5614957809448242,
0.6835514307022095,
0.06470555812120438,
-0.6770623922348022,
0.27249813079833984,
-0.36012721061706543,
-0.28653785586357117,
0.20819881558418274,
-0.44698137044906616,
0.43187013268470764,
-0.5485772490501404,
-0.03931368514895439,
0.2283010333776474,
0.8620176911354065,
0.47382673621177673,
0.690314769744873,
0.5233054757118225,
0.47665509581565857,
1.077496886253357,
-0.3151280879974365,
0.9460610747337341,
-0.21953986585140228,
0.042939119040966034,
1.2313790321350098,
-0.033285509794950485,
0.5385746359825134,
0.758888304233551,
0.08460968732833862,
0.7153414487838745,
0.7658752202987671,
-0.15507210791110992,
0.28112366795539856,
0.5663136839866638,
-0.4862554967403412,
-0.020267587155103683,
-0.17987267673015594,
-0.4285123646259308,
0.09351453185081482,
0.29326918721199036,
-0.2599483132362366,
-0.06926071643829346,
0.14843639731407166,
-0.04317285865545273,
-0.17467492818832397,
-0.5388909578323364,
0.5835058093070984,
0.2361050248146057,
-0.4147246181964874,
0.4772906005382538,
-0.36202505230903625,
0.7137612700462341,
-0.34377825260162354,
-0.4857131838798523,
-0.22486303746700287,
-0.2916773855686188,
-0.30984243750572205,
-1.0502253770828247,
0.21488158404827118,
0.2807106077671051,
-0.3754924535751343,
-0.2880551815032959,
0.7224740386009216,
-0.4531117379665375,
-0.11606483906507492,
0.015640316531062126,
0.5360313057899475,
0.40726110339164734,
-0.051168303936719894,
-0.565397322177887,
-0.03693775832653046,
-0.048969678580760956,
-0.5072340965270996,
0.010573891922831535,
0.6190617084503174,
0.08552537113428116,
0.6271835565567017,
0.5220716595649719,
-0.3573729991912842,
0.1544102132320404,
0.3470066487789154,
0.9188952445983887,
-1.173445463180542,
-0.35674232244491577,
-1.1059694290161133,
1.2311646938323975,
-0.4061180353164673,
-0.40081316232681274,
0.6658061146736145,
0.37927550077438354,
0.05843866616487503,
-0.4414390027523041,
0.7545420527458191,
-0.011171060614287853,
0.31665605306625366,
-0.6122215390205383,
0.3816681206226349,
-0.3625344932079315,
0.41850900650024414,
-0.05934157595038414,
-0.6413228511810303,
-0.5141484141349792,
0.2372218370437622,
-0.009380726143717766,
-0.4100227653980255,
0.5794267654418945,
0.43828725814819336,
0.06857961416244507,
-0.038255687803030014,
0.11293977499008179,
0.10503270477056503,
0.1408548206090927,
0.2688644826412201,
1.2215042114257812,
0.2797294855117798,
0.3189883530139923,
0.02121054381132126,
-0.37169310450553894,
-0.4383629858493805,
-1.1924763917922974,
-0.918156623840332,
-0.06841272860765457,
-0.4861060380935669,
-0.38917455077171326,
0.0031808223575353622,
1.144901990890503,
0.14687331020832062,
-0.7218244671821594,
0.22590042650699615,
-0.022733569145202637,
0.408152312040329,
-0.06124407425522804,
-0.36526715755462646,
0.14467386901378632,
-0.5135571956634521,
-0.7106983065605164,
0.4969296157360077,
0.48868420720100403,
0.44825220108032227,
-0.19606640934944153,
0.14806269109249115,
0.23687149584293365,
-0.20187696814537048,
0.8617097735404968,
0.6177716851234436,
-0.7073472142219543,
-0.2307942509651184,
0.13265812397003174,
-0.006470607127994299,
-0.15815167129039764,
0.993799090385437,
-0.7138321995735168,
0.39212745428085327,
0.6997348070144653,
0.6572052836418152,
0.09428413957357407,
0.1619243174791336,
0.6094081997871399,
-0.9969180822372437,
0.20529092848300934,
0.38722914457321167,
0.436847060918808,
0.1217137798666954,
-0.8223104476928711,
0.5872118473052979,
0.14801828563213348,
-0.4665123522281647,
-0.9716642498970032,
0.35284164547920227,
-1.3426976203918457,
-0.3128521740436554,
0.9572844505310059,
-0.29006239771842957,
-0.02957005985081196,
0.016317926347255707,
-0.7735453248023987,
0.21752366423606873,
-0.49603965878486633,
0.7490602135658264,
0.6961387395858765,
-0.5468846559524536,
-0.3262642025947571,
-0.14535361528396606,
0.5201817750930786,
0.44161534309387207,
-1.1395847797393799,
0.10079964995384216,
0.778944194316864,
-0.11172469705343246,
0.13632850348949432,
0.3344346880912781,
0.17677757143974304,
0.3188512325286865,
-0.17924493551254272,
0.1596163511276245,
-0.37009915709495544,
-0.3755810856819153,
-0.847200334072113,
-0.039780694991350174,
0.018120499327778816,
-0.19816522300243378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08020v1
|
Augmenting Knowledge Graph Hierarchies Using Neural Transformers
| 2024-04-11T05:53:38 | 2024-04-11T05:53:38 |
Sanat Sharma, Mayank Poddar, Jayant Kumar, Kosta Blank, Tracy King
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Knowledge graphs are useful tools to organize, recommend and sort data.
Hierarchies in knowledge graphs provide significant benefit in improving
understanding and compartmentalization of the data within a knowledge graph.
This work leverages large language models to generate and augment hierarchies
in an existing knowledge graph. For small (<100,000 node) domain-specific KGs,
we find that a combination of few-shot prompting with one-shot generation works
well, while larger KG may require cyclical generation. We present techniques
for augmenting hierarchies, which led to coverage increase by 98% for intents
and 99% for colors in our knowledge graph.
|
[
-0.5624205470085144,
-0.4772816598415375,
0.4309006631374359,
-0.12513217329978943,
-0.0035575826186686754,
0.0378149151802063,
-0.08068415522575378,
-0.5471110939979553,
0.2635584771633148,
0.43633967638015747,
-0.5394914150238037,
-0.5154434442520142,
-0.46779942512512207,
-0.12260813266038895,
-0.2331455945968628,
0.9408051371574402,
0.2688106894493103,
-0.24352768063545227,
-0.26165902614593506,
-0.19867080450057983,
-0.6587150692939758,
-0.27970728278160095,
-0.571999192237854,
-0.8181374073028564,
1.027051329612732,
0.6817989945411682,
1.1417856216430664,
0.5113143920898438,
0.37223777174949646,
0.40106719732284546,
-0.22537676990032196,
0.364845871925354,
-0.624850869178772,
0.4541011154651642,
-0.009589596651494503,
-0.5188499689102173,
-0.5018739104270935,
-0.2160809338092804,
0.5305805802345276,
1.122791051864624,
0.19765159487724304,
0.04354415833950043,
0.06748955696821213,
0.742778480052948,
-0.5425196886062622,
0.5462063550949097,
-0.454633891582489,
0.21443986892700195,
-0.14858075976371765,
-0.27798548340797424,
-0.3188314437866211,
-0.3977741301059723,
0.4290003478527069,
-0.8628518581390381,
-0.03779223561286926,
0.20564870536327362,
0.38557761907577515,
0.03976939991116524,
-0.30641111731529236,
-0.039398182183504105,
-0.8801865577697754,
0.4965305030345917,
-0.3731459975242615,
0.40901800990104675,
0.3503555953502655,
0.7711382508277893,
-0.022182172164320946,
-1.169289231300354,
-0.5257856249809265,
-0.016791369765996933,
-0.5801544189453125,
0.01033856999129057,
-0.41473719477653503,
0.06004553660750389,
0.46721547842025757,
0.23680898547172546,
-0.3445896804332733,
0.1182011067867279,
-0.4054561257362366,
-0.25089558959007263,
0.42075851559638977,
0.4069138467311859,
0.5729480981826782,
-0.36360490322113037,
-0.15718260407447815,
-0.36489102244377136,
-0.8100322484970093,
-0.1263245940208435,
0.6138308644294739,
0.29155051708221436,
0.3639822006225586,
0.7578373551368713,
-0.5928674936294556,
1.064212679862976,
-0.06927275657653809,
-0.14801408350467682,
0.29007649421691895,
-0.5653374195098877,
-0.12370117008686066,
0.06320865452289581,
0.42938095331192017,
0.3852253556251526,
0.3477408289909363,
-0.46856576204299927,
-0.14107906818389893,
-0.27196717262268066,
0.44060754776000977,
-0.8637418746948242,
-0.27694833278656006,
-0.04979453235864639,
-0.3905659317970276,
-0.4529685378074646,
-0.11555617302656174,
-0.6680113077163696,
-0.6240043640136719,
-0.2648232877254486,
0.5512659549713135,
-0.6340392827987671,
-0.2262432873249054,
0.038613151758909225,
-0.6417956352233887,
-0.07356581836938858,
0.39328134059906006,
-0.9633464813232422,
0.07982129603624344,
0.4415301978588104,
0.5616366267204285,
0.09730854630470276,
-0.45807501673698425,
-0.017271962016820908,
0.24487297236919403,
-0.30937570333480835,
0.7960096597671509,
-0.46754512190818787,
-0.1567605584859848,
0.11261682957410812,
-0.14608925580978394,
-0.04057348519563675,
-0.5361854434013367,
0.10336055606603622,
-0.9454924464225769,
0.18130899965763092,
-0.3390011191368103,
-0.4233475923538208,
-0.37819531559944153,
0.5663366913795471,
-0.7139989733695984,
1.0092756748199463,
0.6390297412872314,
-0.8724938035011292,
0.48985838890075684,
-0.7806640267372131,
-0.6716518998146057,
0.39108383655548096,
0.05704089626669884,
-0.2171209156513214,
-0.33144518733024597,
0.3339734971523285,
0.3162227272987366,
-0.0342959389090538,
-0.09059492498636246,
0.024796675890684128,
-0.2448030412197113,
0.06890478730201721,
-0.17335927486419678,
0.6467631459236145,
0.2078453004360199,
-0.10337694734334946,
0.20976796746253967,
-0.4577954113483429,
0.08131840080022812,
0.09338207542896271,
-0.08259361982345581,
-0.39786025881767273,
-0.04547681659460068,
-0.34604522585868835,
0.0933479443192482,
0.15124930441379547,
-0.2556200325489044,
0.5234941840171814,
-0.7620996832847595,
0.33765870332717896,
0.4271484911441803,
0.3348847031593323,
0.929369330406189,
-0.3405205309391022,
0.6771854162216187,
0.2316274791955948,
0.2878649830818176,
-0.4243178069591522,
-0.7895553708076477,
-0.6896492838859558,
0.12325756251811981,
0.2369489222764969,
0.13800084590911865,
-1.2799385786056519,
0.34820231795310974,
-0.48225584626197815,
-0.5304563641548157,
-0.3152192234992981,
0.11103572696447372,
0.047782789915800095,
0.774040937423706,
0.417378306388855,
-0.20636676251888275,
-0.43243998289108276,
-0.816494882106781,
0.14240403473377228,
-0.31306397914886475,
-0.06694405525922775,
0.356661856174469,
0.1702960580587387,
-0.2379826307296753,
1.1350822448730469,
-0.7384690642356873,
-0.20437876880168915,
-0.4655686318874359,
0.21959467232227325,
0.25660958886146545,
0.1849391609430313,
0.6835566163063049,
-0.600897490978241,
-0.43443191051483154,
0.23191948235034943,
-0.6886220574378967,
0.14711308479309082,
0.058028995990753174,
-0.37780728936195374,
-0.24930594861507416,
0.4302597939968109,
-0.5838302969932556,
0.4588813781738281,
0.08288794010877609,
-0.289963036775589,
0.3026021718978882,
0.09636066854000092,
0.09313026070594788,
-1.1064397096633911,
-0.15553772449493408,
-0.36584433913230896,
-0.2847810983657837,
-0.8853901028633118,
0.04893046244978905,
-0.07451740652322769,
-0.10938559472560883,
-0.4959584176540375,
0.4681645333766937,
-0.2174226939678192,
-0.11421387642621994,
-0.25791439414024353,
0.24038638174533844,
0.0366598516702652,
0.45594197511672974,
-0.24884799122810364,
0.6798502206802368,
0.6541311144828796,
-0.6108853220939636,
0.49940693378448486,
0.6122806072235107,
-0.5165140628814697,
0.29110080003738403,
-0.43173712491989136,
-0.0042815012857317924,
-0.3166700005531311,
0.08853064477443695,
-0.9471641182899475,
-0.40678462386131287,
0.25294187664985657,
-0.41317448019981384,
0.28326475620269775,
-0.48625051975250244,
-0.7594367861747742,
-0.666748583316803,
-0.15449170768260956,
0.3717697262763977,
0.6811632513999939,
-0.8757761716842651,
0.449334979057312,
0.294890820980072,
-0.06870802491903305,
-0.5705826282501221,
-0.6277453899383545,
0.05291103199124336,
-0.014832952991127968,
-0.9685243964195251,
0.43756428360939026,
0.08761338144540787,
-0.020112888887524605,
0.15613120794296265,
0.05253306031227112,
0.16731882095336914,
-0.0888487696647644,
0.20298995077610016,
0.14195723831653595,
-0.29658374190330505,
0.5312383770942688,
0.012083646841347218,
-0.10643763095140457,
-0.09001725167036057,
-0.9024263620376587,
0.8768653273582458,
0.11175625026226044,
-0.4340164065361023,
-0.2731626033782959,
-0.01864488236606121,
0.6464550495147705,
-0.191986545920372,
0.8970549702644348,
0.5349594354629517,
-0.3852926194667816,
-0.2421112358570099,
-0.2910047471523285,
-0.485787570476532,
-0.5780835747718811,
0.2593173384666443,
-0.24466590583324432,
-0.8942135572433472,
0.5023872256278992,
-0.01408215332776308,
-0.15776348114013672,
0.46675190329551697,
0.5664958953857422,
-0.008555987849831581,
1.2865145206451416,
0.4834670126438141,
-0.2932960093021393,
0.7213020324707031,
-0.4899580776691437,
0.409175843000412,
-0.6275140643119812,
-0.3280680477619171,
-0.4170914590358734,
-0.6006331443786621,
-0.636992871761322,
-0.21529072523117065,
0.7136488556861877,
0.21972577273845673,
-0.09006888419389725,
0.5695288181304932,
-0.6449207663536072,
0.698428213596344,
0.5783349871635437,
0.42572394013404846,
0.3053967356681824,
0.27937138080596924,
-0.11263623833656311,
0.18468406796455383,
-1.1965138912200928,
-0.15895389020442963,
0.9387416839599609,
0.33413371443748474,
0.9091132879257202,
-0.06637299805879593,
0.6405132412910461,
0.01808241754770279,
0.4333900511264801,
-1.1667943000793457,
0.4125705063343048,
0.06446241587400436,
-0.38647955656051636,
-0.6360880732536316,
-0.3357638120651245,
-1.24658203125,
-0.03839762508869171,
-0.27311697602272034,
-0.6710774898529053,
0.2583237290382385,
0.22199270129203796,
-0.46859660744667053,
0.27394530177116394,
-0.7492841482162476,
0.7915197014808655,
0.10849403589963913,
-0.011125147342681885,
-0.08500460535287857,
-0.4745842516422272,
0.26668834686279297,
0.15227685868740082,
-0.36496809124946594,
0.2599748969078064,
0.42840906977653503,
0.7196959257125854,
-0.6336747407913208,
0.8366860747337341,
-0.17457546293735504,
0.13664968311786652,
0.5178447961807251,
0.05494001880288124,
0.5858337879180908,
-0.2066534459590912,
-0.2855806350708008,
-0.20016154646873474,
-0.3863455355167389,
-0.22544102370738983,
-1.053044080734253,
0.513634204864502,
-0.6215522885322571,
-0.6473773717880249,
0.146312415599823,
-1.0836037397384644,
-0.3727802038192749,
0.4693058133125305,
0.1516076922416687,
0.49353504180908203,
0.2613998353481293,
0.39548569917678833,
0.41697046160697937,
-0.11493058502674103,
0.2813909351825714,
0.13993914425373077,
-0.15266171097755432,
-0.19094102084636688,
0.8470326066017151,
0.3394721746444702,
0.3320028781890869,
0.14808331429958344,
0.4088195860385895,
-0.3981700539588928,
-0.5732396245002747,
-0.36929556727409363,
-0.17507602274417877,
-1.0217386484146118,
-0.5716188549995422,
-0.8765840530395508,
-0.38808485865592957,
-0.6954447031021118,
-0.0962635800242424,
0.23639987409114838,
-0.8838739991188049,
-0.028539855033159256,
-0.35578152537345886,
0.7021658420562744,
1.0361506938934326,
0.17993323504924774,
0.6859310865402222,
-0.7616521120071411,
0.2528347671031952,
0.7512503266334534,
0.2242213636636734,
0.29312559962272644,
-0.30250298976898193,
-0.3880574703216553,
-0.21497316658496857,
-0.35472768545150757,
-1.0285593271255493,
0.33835914731025696,
-0.1388714462518692,
0.6257256865501404,
0.47798609733581543,
-0.07709931582212448,
0.8725820183753967,
-0.5512570142745972,
0.6676967144012451,
0.3363058865070343,
-0.41001084446907043,
0.5852426886558533,
-0.4441438913345337,
0.4428700804710388,
0.4909021556377411,
0.4330548644065857,
-0.5808279514312744,
-0.4412577450275421,
-0.728719174861908,
-0.8192480206489563,
0.8761628270149231,
0.31883570551872253,
0.3486098051071167,
-0.015168406069278717,
0.3318697512149811,
-0.19219161570072174,
0.18704892694950104,
-0.333082377910614,
-0.35928434133529663,
-0.35163500905036926,
-0.2948007583618164,
0.2662595510482788,
0.052720945328474045,
-0.3293587863445282,
-0.4696232080459595,
0.47067758440971375,
-0.40560057759284973,
0.25758668780326843,
-0.013265597634017467,
-0.04278690367937088,
-0.35139164328575134,
0.22751612961292267,
0.023644886910915375,
0.7391530275344849,
0.04747582599520683,
0.3135172724723816,
0.25040557980537415,
-0.27394968271255493,
-0.18342620134353638,
0.17545895278453827,
-0.4471592605113983,
-0.21086905896663666,
0.35214653611183167,
0.866745114326477,
0.13078194856643677,
-0.11437635123729706,
0.3341646194458008,
0.23190663754940033,
0.01795353926718235,
0.19054171442985535,
0.39617452025413513,
0.2176666259765625,
0.3672747015953064,
0.2696070671081543,
0.18914060294628143,
0.12258894741535187,
-0.7392892837524414,
0.3383454978466034,
0.41735008358955383,
-0.34068459272384644,
-0.11381784826517105,
0.2538003921508789,
0.08274947106838226,
-0.3594608008861542,
0.9645846486091614,
-0.2782239019870758,
-0.8099308013916016,
0.7354931235313416,
0.6890117526054382,
0.5225733518600464,
0.05009886249899864,
0.4588698446750641,
0.5502951145172119,
0.4438323974609375,
0.033878814429044724,
0.08378017693758011,
-0.1419740468263626,
-1.0652974843978882,
-0.440475195646286,
-0.5988097786903381,
-0.42610490322113037,
-0.06631528586149216,
-0.3551676571369171,
0.25018227100372314,
-0.10506482422351837,
-0.17910701036453247,
0.32065215706825256,
-0.19764471054077148,
-0.8168651461601257,
0.037774618715047836,
-0.11651622503995895,
1.0867887735366821,
-0.6066548824310303,
0.9465429782867432,
0.6259397268295288,
-0.6650426983833313,
-0.9593411087989807,
-0.06651107221841812,
-0.345054030418396,
-0.905417263507843,
0.8270106315612793,
0.022436585277318954,
0.03990432992577553,
0.26324403285980225,
-0.5320016145706177,
-0.6208536028862,
1.385286808013916,
0.11762987822294235,
-0.32729873061180115,
-0.18794837594032288,
0.5694677829742432,
0.758985161781311,
-0.40499889850616455,
0.1748073846101761,
0.5562701225280762,
0.8053510785102844,
0.3761841356754303,
-0.41238316893577576,
-0.03629462420940399,
-0.04784616455435753,
-0.20806169509887695,
0.32083016633987427,
-0.07346631586551666,
0.5572915077209473,
-0.14468605816364288,
-0.12817534804344177,
-0.1222735345363617,
0.5129527449607849,
0.09335113316774368,
0.24541226029396057,
0.8291412591934204,
0.5770514607429504,
0.7128047943115234,
-0.24572627246379852,
1.319523572921753,
-0.4784151315689087,
0.1116202175617218,
0.8743290305137634,
-0.010246695019304752,
0.3066073954105377,
0.2977806627750397,
-0.010146350599825382,
0.5774859189987183,
0.4151812195777893,
0.01701434515416622,
0.31061771512031555,
-0.017040854319930077,
-0.25640779733657837,
-0.2883323132991791,
-0.4077407121658325,
-0.2390836626291275,
0.14801588654518127,
0.32846200466156006,
-0.23683379590511322,
-0.3175979554653168,
0.04627048224210739,
-0.057085178792476654,
-0.31958988308906555,
-0.2860468626022339,
0.8975509405136108,
-0.20456872880458832,
-0.9173857569694519,
0.35570815205574036,
-0.2965356111526489,
0.23881228268146515,
-0.6544228196144104,
-0.20291629433631897,
-0.2110346406698227,
-0.18458567559719086,
-0.4433412253856659,
-1.1849433183670044,
0.258022278547287,
-0.24234206974506378,
-0.18445977568626404,
-0.47779327630996704,
1.3460785150527954,
-0.4800444543361664,
-0.29748857021331787,
0.2828068733215332,
0.720766544342041,
-0.2578303813934326,
-0.060471005737781525,
-0.332856148481369,
-0.5285732746124268,
-0.24114631116390228,
-0.31512415409088135,
0.2366536259651184,
0.3504878282546997,
-0.07803042232990265,
0.5152178406715393,
0.6772952675819397,
-0.0815548226237297,
0.19768840074539185,
0.5937861800193787,
1.3206769227981567,
-0.38476091623306274,
-0.3420315384864807,
-0.48474496603012085,
0.5394929051399231,
-0.20788754522800446,
0.008027623407542706,
0.7995870113372803,
0.40930497646331787,
0.8321940302848816,
-0.07617083191871643,
0.5808736681938171,
-0.2667573392391205,
-0.001088127144612372,
-0.371315598487854,
0.8618332147598267,
-0.5062132477760315,
0.10451366007328033,
0.02039356529712677,
-0.861489474773407,
-0.3937382698059082,
0.3365032374858856,
-0.3910336196422577,
0.0033166625071316957,
0.6303698420524597,
1.0602010488510132,
-0.17195779085159302,
0.08642106503248215,
0.5126760601997375,
0.2450592815876007,
0.04290977492928505,
0.1425236165523529,
1.0890272855758667,
-0.27213022112846375,
0.7583595514297485,
-0.48999303579330444,
-0.0599001944065094,
0.06331276893615723,
-0.5500012040138245,
-0.944290280342102,
-0.3406066298484802,
-0.1030605286359787,
-0.5212841033935547,
-0.005885681137442589,
0.545976996421814,
1.018054723739624,
-0.7041574120521545,
0.1399652659893036,
-0.10128746926784515,
0.6267529726028442,
-0.23457376658916473,
-0.3006325662136078,
0.23345062136650085,
-0.7635582089424133,
-0.7348709106445312,
0.6654495596885681,
0.3259359300136566,
0.10337311774492264,
-0.42219382524490356,
-0.06287959963083267,
0.04043606296181679,
-0.22952605783939362,
0.8653257489204407,
0.11083658784627914,
-0.12338627129793167,
-0.4798445999622345,
0.3085865378379822,
0.008248956874012947,
0.22859646379947662,
1.1386306285858154,
-1.0743438005447388,
0.6001859307289124,
1.1435670852661133,
0.5822296142578125,
0.6216228008270264,
-0.09202168881893158,
0.4516494870185852,
-1.2086740732192993,
0.09548258036375046,
0.21004368364810944,
0.4276784360408783,
0.1054014042019844,
-0.4268277883529663,
0.6439275145530701,
0.09431791305541992,
-0.36793890595436096,
-0.4649672508239746,
0.3874577581882477,
-0.8704869747161865,
-0.1690288931131363,
0.9532820582389832,
0.16692835092544556,
-0.22199176251888275,
-0.24900083243846893,
-0.20494438707828522,
0.45803314447402954,
-0.1669078916311264,
0.6028707027435303,
0.5378155708312988,
-0.3293303847312927,
0.03354015201330185,
-0.35113590955734253,
0.4867924451828003,
0.3351501226425171,
-1.1590101718902588,
-0.2774971127510071,
0.32708925008773804,
0.1169172003865242,
0.606317400932312,
0.5370641350746155,
-0.26043134927749634,
0.1640775352716446,
-0.20650626718997955,
-0.09857995808124542,
-0.09238404780626297,
-0.6134098172187805,
-0.02481761947274208,
0.36208462715148926,
-0.0037293576169759035,
0.08017205446958542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07475v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07475v2
|
Laissez-Faire Harms: Algorithmic Biases in Generative Language Models
| 2024-04-11T05:09:03 | 2024-04-16T04:07:42 |
Evan Shieh, Faye-Marie Vassel, Cassidy Sugimoto, Thema Monroe-White
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
The rapid deployment of generative language models (LMs) has raised concerns
about social biases affecting the well-being of diverse consumers. The extant
literature on generative LMs has primarily examined bias via explicit identity
prompting. However, prior research on bias in earlier language-based technology
platforms, including search engines, has shown that discrimination can occur
even when identity terms are not specified explicitly. Studies of bias in LM
responses to open-ended prompts (where identity classifications are left
unspecified) are lacking and have not yet been grounded in end-consumer harms.
Here, we advance studies of generative LM bias by considering a broader set of
natural use cases via open-ended prompting. In this "laissez-faire" setting, we
find that synthetically generated texts from five of the most pervasive LMs
(ChatGPT3.5, ChatGPT4, Claude2.0, Llama2, and PaLM2) perpetuate harms of
omission, subordination, and stereotyping for minoritized individuals with
intersectional race, gender, and/or sexual orientation identities (AI/AN,
Asian, Black, Latine, MENA, NH/PI, Female, Non-binary, Queer). We find
widespread evidence of bias to an extent that such individuals are hundreds to
thousands of times more likely to encounter LM-generated outputs that portray
their identities in a subordinated manner compared to representative or
empowering portrayals. We also document a prevalence of stereotypes (e.g.
perpetual foreigner) in LM-generated outputs that are known to trigger
psychological harms that disproportionately affect minoritized individuals.
These include stereotype threat, which leads to impaired cognitive performance
and increased negative self-perception. Our findings highlight the urgent need
to protect consumers from discriminatory harms caused by language models and
invest in critical AI education programs tailored towards empowering diverse
consumers.
|
[
-0.2721785008907318,
-0.8028075695037842,
0.36437156796455383,
0.31613779067993164,
0.13605189323425293,
-0.09074468165636063,
-0.15219560265541077,
-0.5571761131286621,
0.0861445739865303,
0.4193236827850342,
-0.6025806665420532,
-0.3572494685649872,
-0.48732033371925354,
0.00532620120793581,
-0.44755983352661133,
1.1099191904067993,
0.14941412210464478,
0.12803052365779877,
-0.08510777354240417,
-0.22258391976356506,
-0.5983088612556458,
-0.4954600930213928,
-0.40974605083465576,
-0.03579572215676308,
0.656304121017456,
0.29482147097587585,
0.9740158319473267,
0.25170332193374634,
0.051555242389440536,
0.2416699379682541,
-0.10739859193563461,
-0.14265182614326477,
-0.47632312774658203,
0.30420398712158203,
-0.22283935546875,
-0.5856296420097351,
-0.1690319925546646,
0.2853612005710602,
0.26328498125076294,
0.7339273691177368,
-0.05759410932660103,
0.4995516240596771,
0.3265264928340912,
0.824737012386322,
-0.9131298065185547,
-0.30675947666168213,
-0.5310131311416626,
0.23327717185020447,
-0.3711528778076172,
0.012736299075186253,
-0.6047489047050476,
-0.5625648498535156,
-0.09428083151578903,
-0.48807793855667114,
0.4036085903644562,
0.04700285568833351,
0.6992797255516052,
0.36691904067993164,
-0.4014648497104645,
-0.6209524273872375,
-0.9291853904724121,
0.8136836886405945,
-0.5201548337936401,
0.4522477686405182,
0.3133651614189148,
0.19345402717590332,
-0.10617716610431671,
-0.42486074566841125,
-0.7506865859031677,
-0.19881947338581085,
-0.038095589727163315,
0.17281241714954376,
-0.3378327488899231,
0.14571499824523926,
0.586516797542572,
0.2516911029815674,
-0.47148793935775757,
0.36341190338134766,
-0.5675243139266968,
-0.032299887388944626,
0.6519098877906799,
0.15046191215515137,
0.6711475253105164,
-0.1510641723871231,
-0.24280957877635956,
-0.02167734131217003,
-0.8852236270904541,
0.2367836833000183,
0.8079062104225159,
0.29333555698394775,
-0.1535061150789261,
0.73287433385849,
0.14590750634670258,
0.5100679993629456,
0.06084410101175308,
0.03802861273288727,
0.41699108481407166,
0.04203116148710251,
-0.3068416118621826,
0.16803258657455444,
1.015748381614685,
0.6586242318153381,
0.5675124526023865,
0.04300856217741966,
-0.07218671590089798,
0.33484017848968506,
0.16361373662948608,
-0.5919167995452881,
0.346619188785553,
0.20555518567562103,
-0.752299427986145,
-0.28237566351890564,
0.10877609252929688,
-0.9206857681274414,
-0.64069002866745,
-0.10276307910680771,
0.19417069852352142,
0.028519028797745705,
-0.009240416809916496,
0.059914663434028625,
-0.14564819633960724,
0.07794070243835449,
0.02233649045228958,
-0.836212694644928,
0.18369241058826447,
0.38538962602615356,
0.7146298289299011,
-0.11968379467725754,
0.046843621879816055,
-0.4027613699436188,
0.02398335188627243,
-0.43003469705581665,
0.5012655258178711,
-0.4750395715236664,
-0.5721172094345093,
0.16407078504562378,
-0.17348282039165497,
0.10036984086036682,
-0.8582313656806946,
0.9467710256576538,
-0.46466806530952454,
0.415067583322525,
-0.5520322918891907,
-0.05864604935050011,
0.049180109053850174,
-0.21955174207687378,
-0.6783684492111206,
0.7810523509979248,
-0.07017628848552704,
-0.8390073180198669,
0.40005210041999817,
-0.6246758103370667,
-0.4764920473098755,
0.11878347396850586,
-0.5585225820541382,
-0.28810808062553406,
0.15653353929519653,
0.15944740176200867,
0.27184659242630005,
-0.41451236605644226,
0.3389998972415924,
-0.2675671875476837,
-0.2893780767917633,
0.394180566072464,
-0.7205643057823181,
1.0233913660049438,
0.36970558762550354,
-0.6683135032653809,
0.17273518443107605,
-0.3253560960292816,
-0.29071345925331116,
0.2596822679042816,
-0.04642578586935997,
-0.42175549268722534,
0.0392964631319046,
0.14349782466888428,
0.34709033370018005,
-0.026576044037938118,
-0.5144322514533997,
-0.3079312741756439,
-0.36218830943107605,
0.22659073770046234,
1.1746512651443481,
-0.217372864484787,
0.46937790513038635,
-0.5097415447235107,
0.7442272305488586,
0.00030117330607026815,
0.48574405908584595,
-0.20071262121200562,
-0.5857595205307007,
-0.6594035625457764,
-0.1677813082933426,
0.06357893347740173,
0.5556915402412415,
-0.560409665107727,
0.1585036814212799,
-0.07087387889623642,
-0.1805732250213623,
-0.5998040437698364,
-0.08058220148086548,
0.2934551239013672,
0.4523295760154724,
0.07044633477926254,
-0.10030972212553024,
-0.30140194296836853,
-1.296167254447937,
-0.6471056342124939,
-0.20203156769275665,
-0.285501092672348,
0.6530562043190002,
0.06527400761842728,
-0.3848245441913605,
0.9977428913116455,
-0.418228417634964,
-0.4434543251991272,
0.126942440867424,
-0.009761222638189793,
0.18786513805389404,
0.1086147129535675,
0.6402073502540588,
-0.6588471531867981,
-0.6620247960090637,
-0.2690379023551941,
-0.7870615720748901,
-0.6277563571929932,
-0.207858607172966,
0.00449571805074811,
0.2156827449798584,
0.28086891770362854,
-0.5916079878807068,
0.472906231880188,
0.5159002542495728,
-0.41398903727531433,
0.5300408601760864,
0.1441550999879837,
-0.018759869039058685,
-0.8034480810165405,
-0.05678335204720497,
0.2166694849729538,
0.07669514417648315,
-0.595565915107727,
-0.0005983407027088106,
-0.17423377931118011,
0.03171810880303383,
-0.44586458802223206,
0.612712025642395,
-0.4233700633049011,
-0.0018561688484624028,
-0.20828506350517273,
-0.040858954191207886,
-0.06910031288862228,
-0.12434454262256622,
-0.1461150199174881,
1.014929175376892,
0.29449278116226196,
-0.5700766444206238,
-0.07600422948598862,
0.03777719661593437,
-0.32241472601890564,
0.40505871176719666,
-0.7676290273666382,
0.12254644185304642,
-0.5585775971412659,
0.14988155663013458,
-0.5553802251815796,
-0.0015812659403309226,
0.655689537525177,
-0.36834388971328735,
-0.13540992140769958,
0.18601861596107483,
-0.3988521099090576,
-0.2828429639339447,
-0.26615944504737854,
0.7751652002334595,
0.772230327129364,
-0.7452231049537659,
0.4703497290611267,
0.47244733572006226,
-0.22662368416786194,
-0.6719048619270325,
-0.5546306371688843,
0.17018912732601166,
-0.4472237229347229,
-0.6710096597671509,
0.32744503021240234,
-0.225815549492836,
-0.5901779532432556,
-0.21840423345565796,
0.045247942209243774,
0.37126868963241577,
0.03293222561478615,
0.4019445478916168,
0.07059982419013977,
0.11408749222755432,
0.14682713150978088,
0.19056305289268494,
-0.0042493646033108234,
0.28790485858917236,
-0.035770054906606674,
0.6036949157714844,
0.05004941672086716,
-0.36103692650794983,
-0.22232991456985474,
0.6499138474464417,
0.34889400005340576,
-0.12376226484775543,
0.6918414831161499,
0.36216259002685547,
-0.40774106979370117,
-0.3138575851917267,
-0.5210821628570557,
-0.1590316891670227,
-0.5416099429130554,
0.1221100464463234,
-0.04770205542445183,
-1.0459983348846436,
0.5723547339439392,
0.24826839566230774,
-0.014658885076642036,
0.3698222041130066,
0.7409633994102478,
-0.05256316065788269,
1.1687960624694824,
0.539775013923645,
-0.1352488100528717,
0.5530999302864075,
0.14227597415447235,
0.5142411589622498,
-0.5484076142311096,
-0.3363509178161621,
-0.7471569776535034,
-0.18473578989505768,
-0.9396792054176331,
-0.4972258508205414,
0.3851175010204315,
-0.010550815612077713,
-0.3636859059333801,
-0.37967348098754883,
-0.5466561913490295,
0.5428364872932434,
0.6343353390693665,
0.028947193175554276,
0.19178055226802826,
0.16341593861579895,
-0.15197157859802246,
-0.23685474693775177,
-0.6164467930793762,
-0.8424786329269409,
1.1324130296707153,
0.6199928522109985,
0.9447191953659058,
0.16155920922756195,
0.5000020861625671,
0.7396848201751709,
0.5940499305725098,
-0.5885330438613892,
0.3368494510650635,
-0.045943450182676315,
-0.8135917782783508,
-0.01284448616206646,
-0.37868112325668335,
-0.9367663264274597,
-0.010080465115606785,
0.024059735238552094,
-0.9385004639625549,
0.5063449144363403,
0.2850607931613922,
-0.264869749546051,
0.020165828987956047,
-0.575814425945282,
0.7479029297828674,
-0.48059913516044617,
-0.5136035084724426,
-0.01781376637518406,
-0.46866682171821594,
0.5027741193771362,
-0.11712969839572906,
0.7343617677688599,
-0.3467332124710083,
0.08171728253364563,
0.7807994484901428,
-0.2870735824108124,
0.9752020835876465,
-0.27748531103134155,
-0.352936714887619,
0.2998282015323639,
0.1363605111837387,
0.2904491126537323,
0.08100444823503494,
-0.03540077805519104,
0.3568806052207947,
-0.33645692467689514,
-0.3410102427005768,
-0.3773697316646576,
0.6286090612411499,
-0.7830731868743896,
-0.6532713770866394,
-0.5566093325614929,
-0.3274073302745819,
0.008585099130868912,
0.14115816354751587,
0.5753987431526184,
-0.008441065438091755,
-0.3680962920188904,
-0.3007163107395172,
0.6559786796569824,
-0.7008847594261169,
0.2595325708389282,
0.24046844244003296,
-0.2950332760810852,
-0.17933259904384613,
0.9006115794181824,
-0.02508528158068657,
0.30471163988113403,
-0.20308661460876465,
0.23739223182201385,
-0.11042918264865875,
-0.2676866948604584,
-0.35858073830604553,
0.036588482558727264,
-0.7249216437339783,
-0.0949043408036232,
-0.5777390599250793,
-0.1160019040107727,
-0.30383190512657166,
-0.15036891400814056,
-0.255279541015625,
-0.03405570983886719,
-0.3009346127510071,
-0.14560452103614807,
-0.08206050097942352,
0.7395521998405457,
-0.09553585946559906,
0.4379434883594513,
-0.5533260107040405,
0.49288231134414673,
0.28731009364128113,
0.36102381348609924,
0.037442855536937714,
-0.2026013731956482,
0.019205821678042412,
0.3226059079170227,
-0.3150887191295624,
-1.077000379562378,
0.059172727167606354,
0.06736766546964645,
0.6606184840202332,
0.6713762283325195,
0.27399638295173645,
0.15354162454605103,
-0.5083575248718262,
0.9113759398460388,
0.3530671000480652,
-0.8305617570877075,
0.3585304915904999,
-0.4567301869392395,
0.08902636915445328,
0.3394921123981476,
0.46886634826660156,
-1.044793963432312,
-0.32406970858573914,
-0.32672178745269775,
-0.9188770055770874,
0.7689854502677917,
0.2577071785926819,
0.6244115233421326,
-0.5357202291488647,
0.20467063784599304,
0.4468337297439575,
0.29049602150917053,
-1.1417031288146973,
-0.6184229254722595,
-0.21538709104061127,
-0.25504863262176514,
0.09668193012475967,
-0.5436391830444336,
-0.048580192029476166,
0.05421096459031105,
0.6664969325065613,
-0.16527648270130157,
0.30171290040016174,
0.0831780955195427,
-0.0802847295999527,
-0.3616082966327667,
0.3730733096599579,
0.44292840361595154,
0.24425919353961945,
0.07016953825950623,
-0.02132793329656124,
-0.2769003212451935,
-0.27531710267066956,
0.22656244039535522,
0.12342388927936554,
-0.888218104839325,
-0.13030506670475006,
0.09421822428703308,
0.8496429324150085,
-0.4291468858718872,
-0.9336594343185425,
0.5158831477165222,
-0.1742181032896042,
0.16210126876831055,
-0.3697730600833893,
-0.09600900858640671,
-0.26881685853004456,
0.10622145980596542,
0.36589357256889343,
0.018258821219205856,
0.48089948296546936,
-0.6798900961875916,
-0.2408948838710785,
0.7622042894363403,
-0.42682406306266785,
-0.1864565759897232,
0.7827356457710266,
0.23659640550613403,
-0.5052744150161743,
0.46711158752441406,
-0.12409678846597672,
-0.48379889130592346,
0.38631483912467957,
0.4328206777572632,
1.0937579870224,
-0.4755989611148834,
0.47611257433891296,
0.24410313367843628,
0.5423200726509094,
0.11219756305217743,
0.18893897533416748,
0.09320449084043503,
-1.0238018035888672,
-0.025677505880594254,
-0.642368495464325,
0.03847088664770126,
0.14226818084716797,
-0.531652569770813,
0.0812019556760788,
-0.4600639343261719,
-0.4964786171913147,
-0.08318047225475311,
-0.7115159034729004,
-0.6831201910972595,
0.07030218094587326,
0.4326988458633423,
0.5984852313995361,
-1.0883591175079346,
0.05789480730891228,
0.5250298976898193,
-0.45390585064888,
-0.3220880627632141,
0.42430949211120605,
0.13460887968540192,
-0.5406588912010193,
0.6075352430343628,
0.40575581789016724,
-0.054177649319171906,
-0.30575042963027954,
-0.35403260588645935,
-0.6676616668701172,
0.5457848310470581,
0.5104853510856628,
-0.5942977666854858,
-0.12350612878799438,
0.7818565368652344,
0.4684409499168396,
-0.2748763859272003,
0.43006229400634766,
0.5405530333518982,
0.2595754861831665,
-0.2479425072669983,
-1.0120646953582764,
0.1631525605916977,
-0.262714684009552,
0.20174825191497803,
0.14108838140964508,
-0.6455756425857544,
0.8596236109733582,
-0.22118574380874634,
-0.5515337586402893,
-0.18338321149349213,
0.34119024872779846,
0.17091938853263855,
0.4754717946052551,
0.4807473421096802,
0.3687463104724884,
0.6560168862342834,
0.09155568480491638,
0.95296710729599,
-0.008265283890068531,
0.10589445382356644,
1.01055908203125,
-0.3307063579559326,
0.3288743197917938,
0.48371151089668274,
-0.2654138505458832,
0.5585629940032959,
0.644027829170227,
0.3025771379470825,
0.40949106216430664,
0.35123875737190247,
-0.5066326856613159,
0.069739930331707,
-0.6463351249694824,
-0.3149208426475525,
0.22569456696510315,
0.46627506613731384,
-0.7890241742134094,
-0.07551787048578262,
0.18971554934978485,
0.0480886809527874,
0.33793678879737854,
-0.18713517487049103,
0.6801232695579529,
0.3807145655155182,
-0.5553349852561951,
0.3370380699634552,
0.29855841398239136,
0.8389601111412048,
-0.28101539611816406,
0.2693028151988983,
-0.2828546464443207,
0.03630547225475311,
-0.3084915578365326,
-0.522539496421814,
0.1328303962945938,
0.11787966638803482,
-0.43582314252853394,
-0.2723854184150696,
0.7320398092269897,
-0.12370826303958893,
-0.5612638592720032,
0.5177793502807617,
0.6968138813972473,
-0.16121523082256317,
-0.0769965723156929,
-0.7372095584869385,
0.24099200963974,
0.07444389909505844,
-0.15620942413806915,
0.218939408659935,
-0.06430668383836746,
-0.4431920647621155,
0.5666679739952087,
0.6178566813468933,
-0.048196323215961456,
0.38726842403411865,
0.4336901605129242,
0.6895742416381836,
-0.47183671593666077,
-0.5632166862487793,
-0.8934326171875,
0.5436036586761475,
-0.03224264085292816,
-0.04099436104297638,
0.669141948223114,
0.5328925848007202,
1.0001026391983032,
0.07333266735076904,
1.152237057685852,
0.02346031926572323,
0.22541826963424683,
-0.4282276928424835,
0.6410733461380005,
-0.37145403027534485,
0.43249693512916565,
-0.3769325613975525,
-1.1125121116638184,
0.018291974440217018,
0.49315932393074036,
-0.40991052985191345,
0.5398132801055908,
0.27553027868270874,
0.6453297138214111,
0.128448948264122,
0.09902290999889374,
0.031617023050785065,
0.2817603051662445,
0.376242995262146,
0.27913525700569153,
1.0882476568222046,
-0.1914471685886383,
0.025936363264918327,
-0.2374141365289688,
-0.3837752342224121,
-0.07008341699838638,
-0.7137041091918945,
-0.8818949460983276,
-0.3986212909221649,
-0.26295673847198486,
-0.46028512716293335,
0.17774100601673126,
1.0844566822052002,
0.31431862711906433,
-0.6973391771316528,
-0.33401721715927124,
0.013812312856316566,
0.1656525880098343,
0.19076959788799286,
-0.31529006361961365,
0.26796552538871765,
-0.17663168907165527,
-0.738852322101593,
-0.02742352895438671,
0.12860286235809326,
0.10354289412498474,
-0.364723801612854,
-0.2240234911441803,
0.3481888771057129,
0.17463544011116028,
0.6565768718719482,
0.1426159143447876,
-0.8575904369354248,
-0.11869803071022034,
-0.019890619441866875,
-0.026344014331698418,
-0.07799526304006577,
0.7746881246566772,
-0.8294055461883545,
0.41155222058296204,
0.2855289578437805,
0.2914913296699524,
-0.04115036875009537,
-0.03205639123916626,
0.7594456076622009,
-0.6596631407737732,
0.11670847237110138,
0.44906237721443176,
0.2712966799736023,
0.2897481322288513,
-0.6033128499984741,
0.08558531105518341,
0.2072201520204544,
-0.31748995184898376,
-0.9673575758934021,
0.4809410870075226,
-0.46586522459983826,
-0.2904154360294342,
1.262768268585205,
0.308454304933548,
-0.005431229714304209,
0.11735469847917557,
-0.3532174825668335,
0.1770557463169098,
-0.4400998651981354,
0.9551582336425781,
0.44210994243621826,
0.05739632621407509,
-0.12819425761699677,
-0.7510647177696228,
0.69460129737854,
0.46458882093429565,
-0.7942360639572144,
0.1571032553911209,
0.7791175842285156,
0.22396785020828247,
0.015609660185873508,
0.7754142880439758,
-0.1508956253528595,
0.3375341594219208,
-0.3397417962551117,
0.20937886834144592,
0.19172227382659912,
-0.2856864333152771,
-0.3668104410171509,
0.01902925595641136,
0.30855870246887207,
0.12793974578380585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07471v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07471v1
|
Structure-aware Fine-tuning for Code Pre-trained Models
| 2024-04-11T04:24:48 | 2024-04-11T04:24:48 |
Jiayi Wu, Renyu Zhu, Nuo Chen, Qiushi Sun, Xiang Li, Ming Gao
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Over the past few years, we have witnessed remarkable advancements in Code
Pre-trained Models (CodePTMs). These models achieved excellent representation
capabilities by designing structure-based pre-training tasks for code. However,
how to enhance the absorption of structural knowledge when fine-tuning CodePTMs
still remains a significant challenge. To fill this gap, in this paper, we
present Structure-aware Fine-tuning (SAT), a novel structure-enhanced and
plug-and-play fine-tuning method for CodePTMs. We first propose a structure
loss to quantify the difference between the information learned by CodePTMs and
the knowledge extracted from code structure. Specifically, we use the attention
scores extracted from Transformer layer as the learned structural information,
and the shortest path length between leaves in abstract syntax trees as the
structural knowledge. Subsequently, multi-task learning is introduced to
improve the performance of fine-tuning. Experiments conducted on four
pre-trained models and two generation tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of
our proposed method as a plug-and-play solution. Furthermore, we observed that
SAT can benefit CodePTMs more with limited training data.
|
[
-0.4270431101322174,
-0.6289840340614319,
0.40749162435531616,
0.12465764582157135,
-0.30361807346343994,
0.30197086930274963,
-0.3860919773578644,
-0.37708359956741333,
-0.048410814255476,
0.342839777469635,
-0.37411439418792725,
-0.5186469554901123,
-0.39432263374328613,
-0.13291892409324646,
0.020470526069402695,
0.7983357906341553,
-0.005583393387496471,
0.05388987436890602,
-0.20724664628505707,
0.029320156201720238,
-0.6648486852645874,
-0.25811102986335754,
-0.2370336949825287,
-0.12306917458772659,
0.294117271900177,
0.46894946694374084,
0.44360625743865967,
0.8098260760307312,
0.5354672074317932,
0.25838300585746765,
-0.2605213224887848,
0.5241950750350952,
-0.4475555121898651,
-0.30173757672309875,
-0.18069320917129517,
-0.8532164096832275,
-0.6298088431358337,
-0.21110548079013824,
0.4423665702342987,
0.6455894708633423,
0.15569628775119781,
0.41384363174438477,
0.3394198715686798,
0.7923856973648071,
-0.7451643347740173,
0.4865514934062958,
-0.7860141396522522,
0.12353816628456116,
-0.0481419563293457,
-0.5993636250495911,
-0.443758487701416,
-0.27509620785713196,
-0.2545504570007324,
-0.6520076394081116,
0.3673219084739685,
-0.10794270783662796,
0.772937536239624,
0.6965600252151489,
-0.30908334255218506,
0.12963317334651947,
-0.4685671925544739,
0.4091157019138336,
-0.503479540348053,
0.3289134204387665,
0.3546043634414673,
0.10060131549835205,
-0.15178106725215912,
-0.41113847494125366,
-0.023767223581671715,
-0.19143730401992798,
-0.21436350047588348,
-0.046607855707407,
0.1811581552028656,
0.3826836943626404,
0.2853776812553406,
0.6580157279968262,
-0.5859277248382568,
-0.08252526819705963,
-0.21079012751579285,
-0.19910264015197754,
0.20050384104251862,
-0.04116662219166756,
0.07373354583978653,
-0.13049384951591492,
-0.11043655127286911,
0.20100700855255127,
-0.8415499925613403,
0.1354474276304245,
0.12185452878475189,
0.6320562958717346,
-0.16279369592666626,
0.3385876417160034,
-0.24662935733795166,
0.726170003414154,
0.2695545554161072,
0.17424286901950836,
0.3409903049468994,
-0.34209251403808594,
-0.41659608483314514,
-0.030980337411165237,
0.127339705824852,
-0.11181272566318512,
0.36890798807144165,
-0.03475985303521156,
-0.011778293177485466,
0.4221400022506714,
0.4492834806442261,
-0.8925194144248962,
-0.5987732410430908,
0.05856766179203987,
-0.5839830636978149,
-0.1860368251800537,
-0.04869000241160393,
-0.05201499164104462,
-0.2875872254371643,
-0.6361615061759949,
0.5212820768356323,
-0.4240076243877411,
-0.3046417534351349,
0.3657721281051636,
-0.03931313008069992,
0.3157312870025635,
0.34497159719467163,
-0.5681414008140564,
0.04801798239350319,
0.6382362246513367,
0.7072227001190186,
0.019154973328113556,
-0.13322284817695618,
-0.8174980878829956,
0.1332511454820633,
-0.43336397409439087,
0.8626716136932373,
-0.4609970450401306,
-0.07845374941825867,
-0.1755203902721405,
-0.06157520413398743,
-0.13753250241279602,
-0.6906208395957947,
0.2148188352584839,
-0.5198013186454773,
-0.355075478553772,
0.05087040737271309,
-0.5630670785903931,
-0.07018109411001205,
0.3208082914352417,
-0.40462639927864075,
0.8671339750289917,
0.26604127883911133,
-0.6039892435073853,
0.3255082070827484,
-0.582065999507904,
-0.8682869672775269,
0.10310527682304382,
-0.31270653009414673,
-0.6404005289077759,
0.6039169430732727,
0.3192351162433624,
0.5854287147521973,
0.2350061535835266,
0.22765645384788513,
-0.39646831154823303,
-0.5985403656959534,
-0.3097037672996521,
0.07131214439868927,
0.3947475254535675,
0.38241076469421387,
-0.37801408767700195,
0.4763867259025574,
-0.9462074041366577,
0.4274132549762726,
-0.11313869059085846,
-0.49688246846199036,
-0.19627489149570465,
0.003460280131548643,
0.02048313617706299,
0.053429778665304184,
0.17672273516654968,
-0.2884845435619354,
0.3735588788986206,
-0.7144571542739868,
0.5121603012084961,
0.5772682428359985,
-0.08851929008960724,
0.532964825630188,
-0.29248374700546265,
0.48744213581085205,
0.09051202237606049,
0.12465440481901169,
-0.48795178532600403,
0.035480353981256485,
-0.5657493472099304,
-0.3592834174633026,
0.28319624066352844,
0.2783348858356476,
-0.4111923575401306,
0.5028571486473083,
0.06399538367986679,
-0.46467119455337524,
-0.2970573604106903,
0.07023004442453384,
0.539798378944397,
0.20407573878765106,
0.5690089464187622,
-0.30919957160949707,
-0.6736444234848022,
-0.6030409932136536,
-0.6074733138084412,
0.2467055469751358,
0.019116727635264397,
0.5806140303611755,
0.30946147441864014,
-0.19830907881259918,
0.6613325476646423,
-0.9591701626777649,
-0.5960607528686523,
-0.23472021520137787,
0.02953391522169113,
0.018383385613560677,
0.8673161268234253,
0.3484306037425995,
-0.7097903490066528,
-0.40753433108329773,
-0.014732243493199348,
-0.0925038754940033,
0.2306661158800125,
-0.2236461490392685,
-0.04084516316652298,
-0.12494882941246033,
0.6408789157867432,
-0.4276513457298279,
0.30777376890182495,
0.2711639404296875,
-0.29078754782676697,
0.6532692909240723,
-0.47434693574905396,
0.12305691838264465,
-1.0902072191238403,
0.10440291464328766,
-0.14866112172603607,
-0.32395219802856445,
-0.20822574198246002,
0.32046112418174744,
0.5521997213363647,
-0.17163921892642975,
-0.35263553261756897,
0.1018526703119278,
-0.798027753829956,
-0.2269367128610611,
-0.24146227538585663,
-0.36095044016838074,
0.21145468950271606,
0.832880437374115,
-0.12407153099775314,
0.7998994588851929,
0.7165066003799438,
-0.8468461632728577,
-0.378731906414032,
0.21657833456993103,
-0.6026385426521301,
0.33647146821022034,
-0.5949648022651672,
0.13306845724582672,
-0.08542263507843018,
-0.014207734726369381,
-0.9573464393615723,
-0.1843656599521637,
-0.105286605656147,
-0.2762516438961029,
0.4996664822101593,
-0.47990232706069946,
-0.5001057982444763,
-0.18058724701404572,
-0.09943083673715591,
0.5626358985900879,
0.08199219405651093,
-0.4972115159034729,
0.6587743163108826,
0.2847217619419098,
0.1647651344537735,
-0.1427648365497589,
-0.3811553120613098,
-0.3172217905521393,
0.01885196566581726,
-0.31947600841522217,
0.7465335726737976,
-0.29820775985717773,
0.43182680010795593,
-0.13570331037044525,
-0.6749265789985657,
-0.355872243642807,
0.36875659227371216,
0.4120338261127472,
-0.0296043511480093,
-0.2870889902114868,
0.3058483600616455,
0.30797699093818665,
-0.09367192536592484,
-0.12394791841506958,
-0.394868940114975,
0.5005088448524475,
-0.4455716013908386,
-0.29438385367393494,
-0.29518571496009827,
-0.05231751874089241,
0.48091578483581543,
-1.129323959350586,
0.3175335228443146,
0.5344953536987305,
-0.34641972184181213,
-0.5318168997764587,
-0.4468739628791809,
-0.1233033537864685,
-0.5246325731277466,
0.6157516837120056,
-0.684929609298706,
-1.1479867696762085,
0.4783094525337219,
-0.7616084814071655,
-0.09352840483188629,
0.19686028361320496,
0.2595042884349823,
-0.13349448144435883,
1.1170796155929565,
1.1288907527923584,
0.02409888431429863,
0.8298503160476685,
-0.525653064250946,
0.01635035313665867,
-0.6176642775535583,
-0.22834350168704987,
-0.8291776776313782,
-0.32293766736984253,
-0.3027222454547882,
-0.6225335001945496,
0.22543273866176605,
0.3801816999912262,
-0.38853466510772705,
0.6881401538848877,
-0.7569520473480225,
0.7763866782188416,
0.3286149799823761,
0.46274903416633606,
0.3458268344402313,
-0.11027593165636063,
-0.007666885852813721,
0.32028645277023315,
-0.721823513507843,
-0.0010826061479747295,
0.7539523839950562,
0.1960999220609665,
0.801081120967865,
-0.3735816180706024,
0.517375111579895,
0.05586869642138481,
-0.17675861716270447,
-0.7311918139457703,
0.28323647379875183,
-0.16130706667900085,
-0.41143614053726196,
-0.014387944713234901,
-0.6657286286354065,
-0.5484616160392761,
-0.12235365808010101,
0.01991880126297474,
-0.27993977069854736,
0.4559541940689087,
0.5784164667129517,
-0.7133257389068604,
0.004171895328909159,
-0.8317574262619019,
1.2269359827041626,
-0.2318391650915146,
-0.19146986305713654,
-0.6462503671646118,
-0.663985013961792,
0.07280184328556061,
0.12268847972154617,
0.1506645828485489,
-0.027222497388720512,
0.19624623656272888,
0.2819401025772095,
-0.1527559906244278,
0.7537031173706055,
-0.2740955054759979,
-0.09016765654087067,
0.11487152427434921,
0.18136878311634064,
0.5466797351837158,
0.24571192264556885,
0.18268714845180511,
-0.04202219843864441,
0.062092460691928864,
-0.3356466591358185,
-0.4563716948032379,
0.6025140285491943,
-0.6695128679275513,
-0.3356854319572449,
0.03809467703104019,
-0.736993670463562,
-0.38469815254211426,
0.4409305453300476,
0.1547170728445053,
0.6440631747245789,
-0.0810224860906601,
0.4389605224132538,
0.8928545117378235,
-0.17276673018932343,
0.22304825484752655,
0.5435665249824524,
0.09881053864955902,
-0.24331825971603394,
0.8288789391517639,
-0.05060487613081932,
0.06995449960231781,
0.747903048992157,
0.08109758049249649,
-0.07160135358572006,
-0.621980607509613,
-0.15855620801448822,
-0.058914944529533386,
-0.22555023431777954,
-0.6397284865379333,
-0.449120432138443,
-0.169441357254982,
-0.16454365849494934,
-0.29467257857322693,
-0.582630455493927,
-0.13291028141975403,
-0.34360137581825256,
-0.08515848964452744,
0.1471617966890335,
0.46906808018684387,
0.22839093208312988,
0.4870617389678955,
-0.7306078672409058,
0.5944401621818542,
-0.002748440019786358,
1.1577357053756714,
-0.17342275381088257,
-0.3783581852912903,
-0.7605746984481812,
-0.05339287221431732,
-0.1762872338294983,
-0.5219900012016296,
-0.09084291011095047,
0.4908427298069,
0.45132389664649963,
0.29385247826576233,
0.06575291603803635,
0.9707067012786865,
-0.520849883556366,
0.19912713766098022,
-0.12663312256336212,
-1.1039156913757324,
0.9420050978660583,
-0.278725802898407,
0.7085915803909302,
0.7406796216964722,
0.06331540644168854,
0.13123275339603424,
-0.34535834193229675,
-0.336714506149292,
-0.46265897154808044,
0.7637715339660645,
-0.015931475907564163,
0.036656878888607025,
0.23675501346588135,
0.504771888256073,
-0.07485416531562805,
0.3910437524318695,
-0.6259276866912842,
-0.058911848813295364,
-0.2919628918170929,
-0.12218573689460754,
-0.1102265864610672,
-0.0366075225174427,
0.1612406224012375,
-0.636714518070221,
0.33300602436065674,
-0.515719473361969,
0.09830772876739502,
0.16411954164505005,
-0.6146222949028015,
-0.25479647517204285,
0.3287261724472046,
0.5683319568634033,
0.6748738288879395,
-0.2647619843482971,
0.2812342345714569,
-0.0681363046169281,
-0.324861615896225,
0.027224553748965263,
0.12524721026420593,
0.04767239838838577,
-0.31697404384613037,
0.08435528725385666,
0.828875720500946,
0.590641975402832,
-0.4960535764694214,
0.36614853143692017,
0.03801223263144493,
-0.1601419597864151,
0.17342257499694824,
0.4241847097873688,
0.049487482756376266,
0.3796769976615906,
0.1543280929327011,
0.7411490678787231,
0.08911500871181488,
-0.48920559883117676,
0.46714919805526733,
0.5601519346237183,
-0.39195516705513,
-0.27331915497779846,
0.6998070478439331,
0.08843764662742615,
-0.19128818809986115,
0.023899605497717857,
-0.07047992199659348,
-0.5055162310600281,
0.869265079498291,
0.4972423315048218,
0.7237813472747803,
-0.18011213839054108,
0.12170441448688507,
0.39010992646217346,
0.2997693419456482,
0.11420778185129166,
0.5642021298408508,
-0.4988933503627777,
-0.4067302942276001,
-0.7254639863967896,
-0.7566991448402405,
0.08103032410144806,
0.09848964959383011,
-0.5110051035881042,
0.3046289384365082,
-0.5387631058692932,
0.07511455565690994,
-0.21725381910800934,
0.26853761076927185,
-0.7397672533988953,
0.22678478062152863,
-0.12473475188016891,
1.155327320098877,
-0.5421515107154846,
0.9571841359138489,
0.790057361125946,
-0.25062426924705505,
-1.1816202402114868,
0.0420798622071743,
-0.48493000864982605,
-0.37690094113349915,
0.31392472982406616,
0.47178030014038086,
-0.09279610216617584,
0.5135086178779602,
-0.32128867506980896,
-0.8171099424362183,
0.7506570219993591,
0.6973169445991516,
-0.6623715162277222,
-0.09450947493314743,
-0.010786127299070358,
0.4721856713294983,
-0.2962894141674042,
0.08286534994840622,
0.34975001215934753,
0.2734672725200653,
-0.2905232906341553,
-0.7486900091171265,
-0.10321198403835297,
-0.28344786167144775,
0.11638136208057404,
0.38337942957878113,
-0.5067150592803955,
0.6144236922264099,
-0.4337872862815857,
-0.24159730970859528,
-0.166896253824234,
0.628488302230835,
0.0007561888778582215,
0.03032512404024601,
0.607644259929657,
0.38354745507240295,
0.5291072726249695,
0.028363613411784172,
0.6242784857749939,
-0.7650802731513977,
0.349420428276062,
1.3534702062606812,
0.13952641189098358,
0.7076988220214844,
0.14556501805782318,
-0.038511279970407486,
0.26263538002967834,
0.6167682409286499,
-0.0885746031999588,
0.6789820194244385,
0.3132827579975128,
0.3633916676044464,
-0.6244031190872192,
0.01751193031668663,
-0.6954938769340515,
0.5483814477920532,
0.1507214605808258,
-0.16919463872909546,
-0.19903914630413055,
0.06512083858251572,
-0.43292906880378723,
0.18997956812381744,
-0.6516885757446289,
0.7914228439331055,
0.09204309433698654,
-0.523352861404419,
0.6718742251396179,
0.012481201440095901,
0.5287270545959473,
-0.6957820653915405,
-0.08463478088378906,
-0.22398041188716888,
0.5016120672225952,
-0.4936983585357666,
-0.2982896566390991,
0.4621903598308563,
-0.21522916853427887,
-0.45670056343078613,
-0.2254747897386551,
0.8115906119346619,
-0.6137226819992065,
-0.26228877902030945,
0.19030199944972992,
0.33007895946502686,
-0.37123557925224304,
-0.7313817739486694,
-0.40931573510169983,
0.07863565534353256,
-0.06696974486112595,
0.019867070019245148,
0.47875699400901794,
0.20259913802146912,
0.21769092977046967,
0.3919045627117157,
0.48039761185646057,
0.016410628333687782,
-0.015705661848187447,
0.10598480701446533,
1.1323813199996948,
-0.4509715735912323,
-0.8410468697547913,
-0.5522308945655823,
0.5104421973228455,
0.19628119468688965,
-0.25339916348457336,
0.6446285843849182,
0.9230027198791504,
1.0490772724151611,
-0.43178924918174744,
0.2897443473339081,
0.23173747956752777,
0.38764891028404236,
-0.3669794499874115,
0.8499293923377991,
-0.640595555305481,
0.2717805802822113,
-0.5827191472053528,
-1.0016335248947144,
-0.3570425808429718,
0.513984739780426,
-0.06978541612625122,
-0.09733724594116211,
0.5320896506309509,
1.0277652740478516,
-0.3460434675216675,
-0.05280876159667969,
0.21652306616306305,
0.23734596371650696,
0.1976620852947235,
0.6671063303947449,
0.4666936695575714,
-0.4469061493873596,
0.6463479995727539,
-0.22565177083015442,
-0.26335853338241577,
-0.2720701992511749,
-0.7018768787384033,
-0.8985438346862793,
-0.41481322050094604,
-0.42481669783592224,
0.10574674606323242,
0.039135370403528214,
0.7412530183792114,
0.9803401231765747,
-0.8283170461654663,
-0.0523124523460865,
-0.6440681219100952,
0.19991976022720337,
-0.6560549139976501,
-0.16471758484840393,
0.5272967219352722,
-0.6871684193611145,
-0.25015801191329956,
0.6474996209144592,
0.40240147709846497,
-0.19789452850818634,
0.17053599655628204,
-0.020587369799613953,
0.04282710328698158,
-0.10519911348819733,
0.7041298747062683,
0.09143466502428055,
-0.332236647605896,
-0.25569093227386475,
0.1074020117521286,
-0.08460288494825363,
0.2959919571876526,
1.089551568031311,
-1.0248626470565796,
0.31490540504455566,
0.5150827169418335,
0.8269750475883484,
0.4140179753303528,
0.016129393130540848,
0.5135570764541626,
-1.1168575286865234,
0.025966886430978775,
0.14491944015026093,
0.3004246950149536,
-0.06343311071395874,
-0.585588812828064,
0.27786993980407715,
0.08210895210504532,
-0.4150736927986145,
-0.7980725169181824,
0.40464019775390625,
-0.9858192801475525,
-0.4422062337398529,
0.5145136117935181,
-0.07835201919078827,
0.05526795610785484,
-0.12314847856760025,
-0.3445228338241577,
0.4481484889984131,
-0.05116523429751396,
0.7452102899551392,
-0.0019193945918232203,
0.09212759137153625,
-0.12794829905033112,
-0.06638883054256439,
0.8752215504646301,
0.566368043422699,
-1.0377907752990723,
0.3243005573749542,
0.5168842673301697,
0.11475187540054321,
0.02592121995985508,
0.4206770658493042,
0.04666798561811447,
0.4457370638847351,
-0.34359440207481384,
0.04467690736055374,
-0.6115784049034119,
-0.9638538956642151,
-0.3206307590007782,
0.48645544052124023,
0.14053229987621307,
-0.24243128299713135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07470v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07470v1
|
Scalable Language Model with Generalized Continual Learning
| 2024-04-11T04:22:15 | 2024-04-11T04:22:15 |
Bohao Peng, Zhuotao Tian, Shu Liu, Mingchang Yang, Jiaya Jia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Continual learning has gained increasing importance as it facilitates the
acquisition and refinement of scalable knowledge and skills in language models.
However, existing methods typically encounter strict limitations and challenges
in real-world scenarios, such as reliance on experience replay, optimization
constraints, and inference task-ID. In this study, we introduce the Scalable
Language Model (SLM) to overcome these limitations within a more challenging
and generalized setting, representing a significant advancement toward
practical applications for continual learning. Specifically, we propose the
Joint Adaptive Re-Parameterization (JARe), integrated with Dynamic Task-related
Knowledge Retrieval (DTKR), to enable adaptive adjustment of language models
based on specific downstream tasks. This approach leverages the task
distribution within the vector space, aiming to achieve a smooth and effortless
continual learning process. Our method demonstrates state-of-the-art
performance on diverse backbones and benchmarks, achieving effective continual
learning in both full-set and few-shot scenarios with minimal forgetting.
Moreover, while prior research primarily focused on a single task type such as
classification, our study goes beyond, with the large language model, i.e.,
LLaMA-2, to explore the effects across diverse domains and task types, such
that a single language model can be decently scaled to broader applications.
|
[
0.022933639585971832,
-1.1691540479660034,
0.5121280550956726,
0.21649013459682465,
-0.35195040702819824,
0.35425877571105957,
-0.36389902234077454,
-0.29736876487731934,
0.03665223717689514,
0.60329270362854,
-0.46511733531951904,
-0.38626784086227417,
-0.7497594356536865,
-0.1299288421869278,
-0.1760360449552536,
0.8594674468040466,
-0.23736441135406494,
-0.17535504698753357,
-0.32760196924209595,
-0.5347936153411865,
-0.9469852447509766,
-0.41318345069885254,
-1.0253430604934692,
-0.35593992471694946,
0.5435545444488525,
0.5214512348175049,
0.35509663820266724,
0.5274267196655273,
0.20272162556648254,
0.241094708442688,
-0.047512706369161606,
0.04689023643732071,
-0.6392300724983215,
0.6520802974700928,
-0.24649368226528168,
-0.40449604392051697,
-0.32039669156074524,
-0.22670719027519226,
1.2534620761871338,
1.0378559827804565,
-0.29038384556770325,
0.21578344702720642,
0.23822148144245148,
0.5833998918533325,
-0.5503506660461426,
0.2901093065738678,
-0.798449695110321,
-0.16795167326927185,
0.05104522779583931,
0.11282998323440552,
-0.31592822074890137,
-0.21601374447345734,
0.13654109835624695,
-0.6766751408576965,
-0.1590012162923813,
-0.013655416667461395,
0.8251870274543762,
0.5324024558067322,
-0.30623331665992737,
-0.30779170989990234,
-0.9378189444541931,
1.1755868196487427,
-0.5117453336715698,
0.6698116064071655,
0.25944244861602783,
0.4388652741909027,
-0.13242627680301666,
-0.8585785627365112,
-0.251604825258255,
-0.6916890740394592,
0.27987566590309143,
-0.08132975548505783,
-0.028412990272045135,
-0.20809593796730042,
-0.002576112514361739,
0.12302106618881226,
-0.5274149179458618,
0.15976004302501678,
0.044521164149045944,
0.0496777705848217,
0.21050310134887695,
0.3445691168308258,
0.37365859746932983,
0.496669203042984,
-0.19253937900066376,
0.16700132191181183,
-0.629652202129364,
-0.009366079233586788,
-0.05579670891165733,
0.3043653964996338,
-0.11843129992485046,
0.2298411726951599,
-0.124083012342453,
0.7657904624938965,
0.04528065025806427,
-0.45159149169921875,
0.15251080691814423,
-0.18581418693065643,
-0.12382564693689346,
-0.5199216604232788,
0.3560878336429596,
-0.19331178069114685,
0.05675520747900009,
-0.6423472166061401,
-0.20834578573703766,
-0.17871637642383575,
0.5907091498374939,
-0.4189738631248474,
0.08124127238988876,
0.04695490002632141,
-0.05257575586438179,
-0.14682842791080475,
-0.444569855928421,
-0.6601662635803223,
0.034068457782268524,
-0.5021472573280334,
0.5109444856643677,
-0.3874528706073761,
-0.4859215319156647,
0.009834425523877144,
0.19910508394241333,
0.0518118180334568,
0.2912285327911377,
-0.8908578157424927,
0.4363864064216614,
0.5600249767303467,
1.0048741102218628,
-0.4899202883243561,
-0.3402417004108429,
-0.6496674418449402,
0.47673702239990234,
-0.4386327862739563,
0.5653070211410522,
-0.8666864633560181,
-0.411928653717041,
-0.037305399775505066,
-0.04040444269776344,
-0.2053007334470749,
-0.61723393201828,
0.17764155566692352,
-0.7425938844680786,
0.05618513748049736,
-0.17142711579799652,
-0.5455753207206726,
-0.2571994960308075,
0.5607863664627075,
-0.41150957345962524,
1.0915169715881348,
0.32243070006370544,
-0.36899954080581665,
0.5854171514511108,
-0.3557251989841461,
-0.1716887503862381,
0.4439167380332947,
-0.17165285348892212,
-0.6190107464790344,
0.07869299501180649,
-0.17781950533390045,
0.3385690152645111,
-0.2425096482038498,
0.6389073133468628,
-0.38073498010635376,
-0.3351783752441406,
-0.2585316002368927,
-0.20159199833869934,
0.24763984978199005,
0.022182894870638847,
-0.25027996301651,
0.12991707026958466,
-0.8323617577552795,
-0.06805126368999481,
0.30036166310310364,
-0.6729563474655151,
-0.46650946140289307,
0.16166120767593384,
-0.1501779854297638,
0.12100701034069061,
0.4121401607990265,
-0.3215647339820862,
0.43965935707092285,
-0.2920151352882385,
0.09741149097681046,
0.5056744813919067,
0.2752052843570709,
0.6182934641838074,
-0.20487356185913086,
0.6786628365516663,
-0.052707843482494354,
0.018382208421826363,
0.09540455043315887,
-0.19954609870910645,
-0.8633028268814087,
-0.3007962107658386,
0.07930988073348999,
0.5864697694778442,
-0.8709187507629395,
0.11708617955446243,
-0.5019009113311768,
-0.5300796627998352,
-0.023469289764761925,
0.3718903362751007,
0.4136311709880829,
0.6141019463539124,
0.3669326603412628,
-0.22159335017204285,
-0.4481717646121979,
-0.523593544960022,
-0.26911866664886475,
-0.1880171149969101,
-0.16641540825366974,
0.424832820892334,
0.3923090398311615,
-0.5930468440055847,
0.910622239112854,
-0.2808750867843628,
-0.1392369568347931,
-0.6356480717658997,
0.18059387803077698,
0.0597887821495533,
0.488088995218277,
0.42718377709388733,
-0.600701093673706,
-0.5627104640007019,
0.06460648775100708,
-0.8334842920303345,
-0.16367806494235992,
-0.37013009190559387,
0.012486813589930534,
0.23169122636318207,
0.43453747034072876,
-0.19630253314971924,
-0.10284096747636795,
0.4767433702945709,
-0.2291739583015442,
0.6430349946022034,
-0.38196489214897156,
-0.12255720794200897,
-1.0017485618591309,
0.15996980667114258,
-0.029230592772364616,
-0.4065277576446533,
-0.8600919246673584,
0.3771876394748688,
0.12487498670816422,
0.03607843071222305,
-0.20047883689403534,
0.857437252998352,
-0.21410098671913147,
0.08180338144302368,
-0.48854440450668335,
-0.03049740381538868,
-0.3014869689941406,
0.5976724624633789,
0.1178625226020813,
0.7461151480674744,
0.8400598764419556,
-0.9467995762825012,
0.2108478993177414,
-0.17615589499473572,
-0.12907560169696808,
0.31268244981765747,
-0.7230526208877563,
0.1122734323143959,
-0.18422171473503113,
0.26600125432014465,
-0.7595141530036926,
-0.13638785481452942,
0.3368300795555115,
-0.10712408274412155,
0.6453726887702942,
-0.1729375123977661,
-0.386424720287323,
-0.11786606907844543,
0.1251668632030487,
0.41490912437438965,
0.5777525901794434,
-0.39240431785583496,
0.9142591953277588,
0.4509466886520386,
-0.4533163011074066,
-0.6118122935295105,
-0.2607039213180542,
0.1785629540681839,
-0.3583066165447235,
-0.23975315690040588,
0.1683005392551422,
-0.05633421614766121,
-0.17300164699554443,
-0.1818111538887024,
-0.3609258830547333,
-0.25181782245635986,
0.18622936308383942,
0.28499531745910645,
0.26652780175209045,
-0.11403176933526993,
0.4002864360809326,
0.15664394199848175,
-0.15162472426891327,
-0.10643864423036575,
-0.4876035749912262,
0.5486705303192139,
-0.17185628414154053,
-0.06164480745792389,
-0.07306904345750809,
0.22343364357948303,
0.5149698257446289,
0.05186610296368599,
1.011033296585083,
0.5982841849327087,
-0.27259573340415955,
-0.29955077171325684,
-0.800940215587616,
0.07863476127386093,
-0.4601518213748932,
0.6272507309913635,
-0.5636215806007385,
-1.4802675247192383,
0.5476400256156921,
-0.4382495880126953,
0.29624390602111816,
0.3443678915500641,
0.6606242656707764,
-0.05340402573347092,
0.5787429213523865,
1.0344760417938232,
-0.2541179358959198,
0.41619324684143066,
-0.08671338856220245,
-0.0004041939973831177,
-0.7147420644760132,
-0.3477097153663635,
-0.3153704106807709,
0.004303766414523125,
-0.245979905128479,
-0.4328189492225647,
0.3339061439037323,
0.39200520515441895,
-0.47776705026626587,
0.26862940192222595,
-0.1557788997888565,
0.37459179759025574,
0.17059504985809326,
-0.005872881039977074,
0.16036321222782135,
0.05176690220832825,
-0.2786400318145752,
0.11325329542160034,
-0.6919498443603516,
-0.4614415764808655,
0.9627419710159302,
0.46134865283966064,
0.5174403190612793,
0.17104503512382507,
0.5923758149147034,
0.24268688261508942,
0.3490162491798401,
-0.552055835723877,
0.6229293942451477,
-0.055183958262205124,
-0.21448205411434174,
-0.5287761688232422,
-0.6679934859275818,
-0.9589402675628662,
0.24180291593074799,
0.0869995728135109,
-0.8293192982673645,
-0.1528809815645218,
0.2531157433986664,
-0.030304957181215286,
0.34703540802001953,
-0.35703596472740173,
0.6300477385520935,
-0.08914926648139954,
-0.46928152441978455,
-0.45769643783569336,
-0.46686461567878723,
0.34391120076179504,
-0.5736101269721985,
0.2239234447479248,
-0.15682663023471832,
-0.5370972752571106,
0.663443386554718,
-0.07146299630403519,
0.8735295534133911,
-0.27084586024284363,
-0.04678007960319519,
0.25603362917900085,
0.14441239833831787,
0.633436918258667,
0.18972189724445343,
0.10254961252212524,
0.20558121800422668,
-0.08680638670921326,
-0.5543112754821777,
-0.6115018725395203,
0.8183995485305786,
-0.7220344543457031,
-0.7326472997665405,
-0.2572838068008423,
-0.8538012504577637,
-0.600540041923523,
0.12945929169654846,
-0.17705337703227997,
0.2874543368816376,
-0.17510321736335754,
0.04959472268819809,
0.7680939435958862,
-0.36442920565605164,
0.33595937490463257,
0.7741125822067261,
-0.19272807240486145,
-0.1743224561214447,
1.128645658493042,
0.08669815957546234,
0.5109541416168213,
0.4330294132232666,
0.18870113790035248,
-0.33177340030670166,
-0.6508824825286865,
-0.298458069562912,
0.3912383019924164,
-0.7337946891784668,
0.1392597109079361,
-0.8343744874000549,
-0.024536218494176865,
-0.24747629463672638,
-0.3124511241912842,
-0.419677197933197,
-0.24006427824497223,
-0.2563207149505615,
0.18236349523067474,
0.154927060008049,
0.7683602571487427,
0.06399788707494736,
0.08536332845687866,
-0.7379361987113953,
0.3946989178657532,
0.5462496876716614,
0.6120350956916809,
0.19980007410049438,
-1.0273261070251465,
-0.37517493963241577,
-0.15078799426555634,
-0.15630125999450684,
-0.41450685262680054,
0.3710971474647522,
0.49756550788879395,
0.8206222653388977,
-0.009123243391513824,
-0.272258460521698,
0.6540096402168274,
-0.6748419404029846,
0.8902885317802429,
0.1578814536333084,
-0.7007765769958496,
0.454670786857605,
-0.31067749857902527,
0.7029938697814941,
0.49993157386779785,
0.6056302189826965,
-0.6478115320205688,
-0.6620314717292786,
-0.27110856771469116,
-0.9692124724388123,
0.30428650975227356,
-0.04032434523105621,
0.30979636311531067,
0.015867849811911583,
0.7549125552177429,
0.26365071535110474,
-0.032959047704935074,
-0.7742142081260681,
-0.13756954669952393,
-0.08233198523521423,
-0.05703718215227127,
-0.04587993398308754,
-0.5861724615097046,
0.2415655106306076,
-0.19355106353759766,
0.8490939140319824,
-0.0678059533238411,
0.10159841924905777,
-0.482597291469574,
-0.3741559386253357,
-0.08948896825313568,
0.3557814061641693,
0.6099762916564941,
0.9044606685638428,
-0.11133372783660889,
-0.16866743564605713,
0.6385555267333984,
-0.7591290473937988,
0.35211002826690674,
-0.1975366175174713,
-0.14733189344406128,
-0.04197430610656738,
0.3567965030670166,
0.7278647422790527,
0.5591375231742859,
-0.8224781155586243,
-0.015078328549861908,
-0.026699788868427277,
-0.1824457198381424,
-0.42837977409362793,
0.28347715735435486,
0.10949838906526566,
0.2917308211326599,
0.4601345360279083,
-0.19616271555423737,
-0.2618744373321533,
-0.29418209195137024,
0.38519689440727234,
0.3571544289588928,
-0.3126412332057953,
-0.19884249567985535,
0.7136131525039673,
0.011295940726995468,
-0.04938855394721031,
0.5316712260246277,
-0.31081122159957886,
-0.1967732161283493,
0.3967941999435425,
0.6609599590301514,
0.7868151664733887,
-0.36618590354919434,
0.1160195991396904,
0.6779464483261108,
0.11465424299240112,
-0.3140082061290741,
0.09119619429111481,
-0.19860497117042542,
-0.5952885746955872,
-0.6616692543029785,
-0.983981728553772,
-0.49612534046173096,
0.18694154918193817,
-0.6114280819892883,
-0.0812799334526062,
-0.5026613473892212,
0.052001629024744034,
-0.4314722716808319,
0.10664893686771393,
-0.481803834438324,
0.24520155787467957,
0.0085593918338418,
0.6531509757041931,
-0.7744986414909363,
1.3676819801330566,
0.6657787561416626,
-0.42961442470550537,
-0.7055371999740601,
-0.040393125265836716,
-0.06777864694595337,
-0.7393155694007874,
0.8023104071617126,
-0.12654447555541992,
-0.14822444319725037,
0.12860138714313507,
-0.2985791265964508,
-1.2052710056304932,
1.2341225147247314,
0.27297133207321167,
-0.7406871318817139,
-0.12549453973770142,
0.3165765702724457,
0.4682837724685669,
-0.3530251979827881,
-0.11734069883823395,
0.5889987945556641,
0.18262703716754913,
0.39494070410728455,
-0.7842763066291809,
-0.07505445927381516,
-0.00263440259732306,
0.4314224421977997,
0.22419731318950653,
-0.4494221806526184,
0.5148864984512329,
0.045040830969810486,
-0.13241830468177795,
-0.009104283526539803,
0.7896555066108704,
0.5520187616348267,
0.09653205424547195,
0.6004565954208374,
0.6654037833213806,
0.6716923713684082,
0.10050398856401443,
0.8957651853561401,
-0.24603064358234406,
0.40869832038879395,
1.2541906833648682,
-0.270243376493454,
0.8316092491149902,
0.3819733262062073,
-0.18464776873588562,
0.5569844245910645,
0.42679378390312195,
0.12765973806381226,
0.5475466251373291,
0.07386942207813263,
-0.5911813378334045,
-0.35313576459884644,
-0.05804372578859329,
-0.13671304285526276,
0.26395201683044434,
0.626253068447113,
0.012227433733642101,
-0.3124300241470337,
0.36072349548339844,
-0.050057679414749146,
0.025567904114723206,
-0.5966939330101013,
0.7912549376487732,
0.07857375591993332,
-0.49206429719924927,
0.7134923338890076,
-0.02904980257153511,
0.7529034614562988,
-0.8768323063850403,
0.05943121761083603,
-0.29096367955207825,
0.026652811095118523,
0.27585792541503906,
-0.3847883641719818,
0.6065009236335754,
0.1312650740146637,
-0.2562968134880066,
-0.24707572162151337,
0.7773760557174683,
-0.5855188965797424,
-0.650979220867157,
0.2405824363231659,
0.37875857949256897,
0.044925007969141006,
0.11057252436876297,
-0.7483653426170349,
0.31861984729766846,
-0.19618690013885498,
-0.32188791036605835,
0.6780869960784912,
0.14729362726211548,
-0.03802481293678284,
1.2917956113815308,
0.3055684268474579,
0.0608823299407959,
0.18264928460121155,
0.20485541224479675,
0.7836416959762573,
-0.4492213726043701,
-0.41187721490859985,
-0.6270967721939087,
0.4202587306499481,
0.23666886985301971,
-0.07829544693231583,
0.6752781271934509,
0.26419785618782043,
0.742203950881958,
-0.09713151305913925,
0.679288387298584,
0.08134492486715317,
0.6138726472854614,
-0.40925833582878113,
0.5960686802864075,
-0.7200703024864197,
0.3693212866783142,
-0.09474962949752808,
-0.8798518180847168,
-0.4597475528717041,
0.3114030659198761,
-0.30354371666908264,
0.17750677466392517,
0.575684666633606,
0.48501142859458923,
-0.012652658857405186,
-0.5014832019805908,
0.5932113528251648,
0.16750307381153107,
0.366936594247818,
0.6610079407691956,
0.38203001022338867,
-0.054413050413131714,
0.5345051884651184,
-0.06338614970445633,
-0.10755784064531326,
-0.0255317073315382,
-0.6953507661819458,
-0.7632666230201721,
-0.8062454462051392,
-0.5871723890304565,
-0.028793787583708763,
0.28772175312042236,
0.6578006744384766,
0.4554062485694885,
-0.7157037258148193,
-0.2433941811323166,
-0.36600053310394287,
-0.03872717171907425,
-0.32980605959892273,
-0.17249628901481628,
0.2062198668718338,
-0.9944324493408203,
-0.6757007241249084,
0.4203484058380127,
0.5812113881111145,
-0.16608551144599915,
-0.17061612010002136,
-0.323808878660202,
-0.2360720932483673,
0.020141763612627983,
0.6919355988502502,
0.6096940040588379,
-0.8869172930717468,
-0.49943122267723083,
-0.2539428174495697,
-0.08915049582719803,
-0.16783417761325836,
0.5103812217712402,
-1.001389980316162,
0.5158053040504456,
-0.04809264466166496,
1.076587200164795,
0.49649709463119507,
-0.2752438187599182,
0.5187905430793762,
-0.967748761177063,
0.23573146760463715,
0.3124050199985504,
0.19163070619106293,
0.09093094617128372,
-0.27941519021987915,
0.4219857156276703,
0.300370454788208,
-0.7067161202430725,
-0.6850963234901428,
0.3017851412296295,
-0.9773916602134705,
-0.39963799715042114,
1.2203037738800049,
-0.3514136075973511,
0.12187368422746658,
-0.45291557908058167,
0.1849384903907776,
0.37676724791526794,
-0.04610465094447136,
0.8030095100402832,
0.6377921104431152,
0.15835095942020416,
-0.5568416118621826,
-0.6740517616271973,
0.19078150391578674,
0.41455116868019104,
-0.6629338264465332,
-0.0498659685254097,
0.3617953658103943,
0.6477248072624207,
-0.21589328348636627,
0.5397710204124451,
0.20705947279930115,
0.17348790168762207,
0.014626347459852695,
-0.1325373649597168,
-0.11982337385416031,
-0.4171963334083557,
-0.3942893445491791,
0.291547030210495,
0.3466639220714569,
-0.054020002484321594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07461v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07461v1
|
"Confidently Nonsensical?'': A Critical Survey on the Perspectives and Challenges of 'Hallucinations' in NLP
| 2024-04-11T03:51:29 | 2024-04-11T03:51:29 |
Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Tatiana Chakravorti, Vipul Gupta, Heidi Biggs, Mukund Srinath, Koustava Goswami, Sarah Rajtmajer, Shomir Wilson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We investigate how hallucination in large language models (LLM) is
characterized in peer-reviewed literature using a critical examination of 103
publications across NLP research. Through a comprehensive review of
sociological and technological literature, we identify a lack of agreement with
the term `hallucination.' Additionally, we conduct a survey with 171
practitioners from the field of NLP and AI to capture varying perspectives on
hallucination. Our analysis underscores the necessity for explicit definitions
and frameworks outlining hallucination within NLP, highlighting potential
challenges, and our survey inputs provide a thematic understanding of the
influence and ramifications of hallucination in society.
|
[
-0.2915090024471283,
-0.922454833984375,
0.6304337978363037,
0.44024908542633057,
-0.06565813720226288,
0.10061874240636826,
-0.3253200948238373,
-0.7186560034751892,
0.6030409336090088,
0.5186935663223267,
-0.4842170476913452,
-0.4416954219341278,
-0.7908940315246582,
0.5903624892234802,
-0.7257174253463745,
0.7333617210388184,
0.1366528570652008,
0.029984550550580025,
-0.2889150083065033,
-0.1045718863606453,
-0.4881793260574341,
-0.643598198890686,
-0.29271939396858215,
-0.23513992130756378,
0.23260976374149323,
0.12433600425720215,
0.6894194483757019,
-0.10643506795167923,
0.5559154152870178,
0.2813897728919983,
-0.23630554974079132,
0.0734546110033989,
-0.5785407423973083,
0.4342241585254669,
-0.014177246019244194,
-0.40210700035095215,
-0.18292011320590973,
-0.07632411271333694,
0.5553166270256042,
1.2614390850067139,
-0.18275047838687897,
0.11804439127445221,
0.30190369486808777,
0.9294235110282898,
-0.4951631426811218,
-0.040488265454769135,
-0.8755597472190857,
0.42634695768356323,
-0.027365166693925858,
-0.09517736732959747,
-0.6113823652267456,
-0.3767378032207489,
0.13767266273498535,
-0.11240801215171814,
0.4152255654335022,
-0.02506987191736698,
0.5343362092971802,
0.47257542610168457,
-0.27200421690940857,
-0.5090699195861816,
-1.0587193965911865,
0.6736798882484436,
-0.5533134341239929,
0.5380163788795471,
0.45761919021606445,
0.039671890437603,
-0.08428139984607697,
-0.6851249933242798,
-0.5936736464500427,
-0.4750487208366394,
0.03410366550087929,
-0.21919380128383636,
0.21036992967128754,
-0.21112006902694702,
0.3568100333213806,
0.24450838565826416,
-0.6127598285675049,
-0.029639067128300667,
-0.4595874845981598,
-0.033346064388751984,
0.7718731760978699,
0.10910725593566895,
0.10290168225765228,
-0.29697442054748535,
-0.026963604614138603,
0.4221477210521698,
-0.41859957575798035,
-0.47959715127944946,
0.25376784801483154,
0.2426030933856964,
0.20509789884090424,
0.9059295654296875,
-0.09095887094736099,
0.3904625475406647,
-0.17596353590488434,
0.08015626668930054,
0.2983948886394501,
-0.0930718183517456,
-0.12567272782325745,
0.16388098895549774,
0.8919036984443665,
0.42345136404037476,
0.11694066226482391,
-0.5840958952903748,
-0.21216091513633728,
-0.03997372090816498,
0.5999274253845215,
-0.36832523345947266,
-0.10318311303853989,
0.7688844203948975,
-0.640368640422821,
-0.27974921464920044,
-0.01884830743074417,
-0.8223883509635925,
-0.7801729440689087,
-0.1565876454114914,
0.13155673444271088,
-0.11246472597122192,
-0.500338613986969,
0.1860722005367279,
-0.12360783666372299,
0.25210991501808167,
0.2327832579612732,
-0.8426868915557861,
0.29638397693634033,
0.7493938207626343,
0.9851147532463074,
-0.33594968914985657,
-0.24823115766048431,
0.25484737753868103,
-0.21213571727275848,
-0.5647131204605103,
0.906353235244751,
-0.3967894911766052,
-0.74387526512146,
0.18427202105522156,
0.2120327204465866,
-0.04051333665847778,
-0.7159281969070435,
0.46026748418807983,
-0.012447654269635677,
0.04431870952248573,
-0.37981969118118286,
-0.36159786581993103,
-0.3561435639858246,
0.24475069344043732,
-0.6282362341880798,
0.9347454905509949,
-0.136923685669899,
-0.5573605298995972,
0.21312259137630463,
-0.22817733883857727,
-0.23947784304618835,
0.2650729715824127,
-0.39944037795066833,
-0.13664543628692627,
0.5321303606033325,
-0.306749165058136,
0.46053168177604675,
-0.13324204087257385,
0.7624715566635132,
-0.32917195558547974,
-0.3874668776988983,
0.6334782242774963,
-0.39392921328544617,
0.7864253520965576,
-0.04083675518631935,
-0.6741325259208679,
0.07782937586307526,
-0.8147416114807129,
-0.06156834959983826,
0.049477726221084595,
0.21248063445091248,
-0.07481938600540161,
0.30830496549606323,
0.2079484909772873,
0.18955355882644653,
0.3211217522621155,
-0.2571484446525574,
0.18387505412101746,
-0.4758621156215668,
0.3162314295768738,
0.6022347211837769,
-0.028948986902832985,
0.2928553819656372,
-0.41264718770980835,
0.3518611490726471,
-0.45800909399986267,
0.17530043423175812,
0.42845991253852844,
-0.7785349488258362,
-0.7582945227622986,
0.39951810240745544,
0.014488492161035538,
0.3520510494709015,
-0.5807037353515625,
0.6410114765167236,
0.03732449933886528,
-0.7165624499320984,
-0.2168118804693222,
-0.0035709883086383343,
0.19573748111724854,
0.5772716403007507,
0.2754296064376831,
-0.07962463796138763,
-0.6482254266738892,
-0.8214548230171204,
-0.06504014879465103,
-0.46467939019203186,
0.09018787741661072,
0.294402152299881,
0.8353271484375,
-0.39141181111335754,
0.561004102230072,
-0.3150689899921417,
-0.565910816192627,
-0.42608851194381714,
0.38318026065826416,
-0.05198577046394348,
0.22294974327087402,
0.06934365630149841,
-0.527226984500885,
-0.3283572793006897,
-0.28349241614341736,
-1.0604523420333862,
0.0030753917526453733,
-0.3234841525554657,
0.23951582610607147,
0.44086432456970215,
0.6864660382270813,
-0.655419647693634,
0.23332291841506958,
0.4197283089160919,
-0.26695552468299866,
0.8420254588127136,
-0.05281047523021698,
-0.07827875018119812,
-0.70484858751297,
0.10187927633523941,
-0.21405434608459473,
0.2803153395652771,
-0.624902069568634,
0.1662502884864807,
-0.38578858971595764,
0.10248014330863953,
-0.3032619059085846,
0.23053985834121704,
-0.3541624844074249,
0.1339941918849945,
-0.20824967324733734,
0.3976590633392334,
-0.2748430371284485,
0.10677506029605865,
0.44563210010528564,
0.42484769225120544,
0.45777615904808044,
-0.6206522583961487,
0.2523569166660309,
0.3518732190132141,
-0.31130096316337585,
0.2287844717502594,
-0.6649616360664368,
0.2193584442138672,
-0.2139597088098526,
0.1278187483549118,
-1.0496340990066528,
-0.3672325015068054,
0.260306179523468,
-0.47511589527130127,
-0.02324630506336689,
0.3011828362941742,
-0.33990931510925293,
-0.11483001708984375,
-0.31484556198120117,
0.3793683350086212,
0.259988933801651,
-0.0027630736585706472,
0.3752513527870178,
0.5853673219680786,
-0.03844078630208969,
-0.652006983757019,
-0.8862985968589783,
0.4822196066379547,
-0.10174980014562607,
-0.3698303699493408,
-0.03220898658037186,
-0.029425788670778275,
-0.7554692625999451,
-0.3472924530506134,
-0.00021429985645227134,
-0.08178199082612991,
0.15311743319034576,
0.4041394889354706,
0.13705119490623474,
-0.05400031805038452,
0.10976416617631912,
-0.3382827043533325,
0.07473352551460266,
0.48911839723587036,
0.07445375621318817,
0.7100774049758911,
-0.08035700768232346,
-0.42937299609184265,
-0.41259682178497314,
0.4890083074569702,
0.3045213520526886,
0.4220832884311676,
0.681666374206543,
0.2697625160217285,
-0.5731998682022095,
-0.3475644290447235,
-0.5856064558029175,
-0.34216368198394775,
-0.39338159561157227,
0.42245134711265564,
-0.17236566543579102,
-0.7662848830223083,
0.5520678162574768,
0.07698755711317062,
-0.11344300955533981,
0.5059798359870911,
0.5092423558235168,
-0.01018213015049696,
0.9014683365821838,
0.5823609828948975,
0.26603466272354126,
-0.23037755489349365,
-0.21564073860645294,
0.5141151547431946,
-0.5567893981933594,
-0.7299874424934387,
-0.8528760075569153,
-0.4187951385974884,
-0.8403177261352539,
-0.3602023124694824,
0.020850298926234245,
-0.19640593230724335,
0.2206379622220993,
0.002078733639791608,
-0.9176803231239319,
0.11442940682172775,
0.08782733976840973,
-0.12946626543998718,
0.29370248317718506,
-0.22944900393486023,
0.24547652900218964,
-0.4510694444179535,
-0.2675606906414032,
-0.7851601839065552,
1.1386812925338745,
0.3699893057346344,
0.6494877934455872,
0.24752600491046906,
0.8441925048828125,
0.1293165534734726,
-0.09717430919408798,
-1.1657480001449585,
0.8224897980690002,
0.2769489288330078,
-0.8299562335014343,
-0.5960445404052734,
-0.2236061990261078,
-0.9789057374000549,
0.11021362990140915,
-0.4174472689628601,
-1.1413711309432983,
0.3845359981060028,
-0.32254767417907715,
-0.3299528658390045,
0.2733067274093628,
-0.32680824398994446,
0.4838223457336426,
-0.20795805752277374,
-0.20147627592086792,
0.06457837671041489,
-0.7141956090927124,
0.692241370677948,
-0.13557030260562897,
0.3237121105194092,
-0.15440243482589722,
-0.07894418388605118,
0.8521958589553833,
-0.2290656715631485,
0.8473809361457825,
-0.10464370250701904,
-0.39157769083976746,
0.29489973187446594,
0.377339243888855,
0.32629281282424927,
0.14837825298309326,
0.03392353653907776,
0.397316038608551,
0.19804008305072784,
-0.005986200179904699,
-0.4842366874217987,
0.5147952437400818,
-0.5283215641975403,
-0.6335829496383667,
-0.7653519511222839,
-0.43093574047088623,
-0.436080664396286,
0.156551793217659,
0.23096899688243866,
0.09362663328647614,
-0.3874850869178772,
0.37081319093704224,
0.8813322186470032,
-0.19086307287216187,
0.4533000588417053,
0.12855103611946106,
-0.6735076308250427,
-0.04859551414847374,
0.9695121049880981,
0.43148675560951233,
0.09137814491987228,
0.17286142706871033,
-0.1050909087061882,
-0.5193402767181396,
-0.8829568028450012,
0.0016978313215076923,
0.366474449634552,
-0.7218620181083679,
0.44840627908706665,
-1.0046682357788086,
-0.5128148198127747,
-0.7307432889938354,
-0.23317092657089233,
-0.4465852975845337,
-0.5330394506454468,
-0.4299510419368744,
-0.01683497056365013,
-0.0809817984700203,
1.2500396966934204,
0.03374384716153145,
-0.0860808864235878,
-0.5321633219718933,
0.49537360668182373,
0.09447992593050003,
0.18327127397060394,
0.1203528642654419,
-0.3969931900501251,
0.0069826641120016575,
-0.3576433062553406,
-0.13638298213481903,
-0.9549771547317505,
0.4049845039844513,
-0.2424376904964447,
0.4029426574707031,
0.5934097170829773,
0.3486500084400177,
0.5821613073348999,
-0.36000022292137146,
1.3415346145629883,
0.16143691539764404,
-0.756052553653717,
0.2439795881509781,
-0.040369290858507156,
0.015348155982792377,
0.7996962666511536,
0.6009986996650696,
-0.6231801509857178,
-0.7611349821090698,
-0.7398673892021179,
-1.0860471725463867,
0.17506660521030426,
0.1292785108089447,
0.24751952290534973,
-0.26375094056129456,
0.22034640610218048,
0.29721343517303467,
0.3602536618709564,
-0.989046573638916,
-0.23249362409114838,
-0.022816646844148636,
0.15907859802246094,
-0.18924511969089508,
-0.6476602554321289,
-0.2163127213716507,
-0.23770250380039215,
0.44501155614852905,
0.016140572726726532,
0.4119980037212372,
0.25867897272109985,
-0.1492648422718048,
0.021359186619520187,
0.08191194385290146,
0.7496968507766724,
1.1068081855773926,
-0.41452962160110474,
0.2916831970214844,
0.07217849045991898,
-0.7412083745002747,
0.18032045662403107,
-0.27575036883354187,
-0.3618185818195343,
0.4335538148880005,
0.42760467529296875,
0.31096309423446655,
0.0570109561085701,
-0.6304470896720886,
0.41094231605529785,
-0.143278107047081,
-0.5970366597175598,
-0.7866994142532349,
-0.11866531521081924,
-0.005769094452261925,
0.08066721260547638,
0.5127846002578735,
0.0389772467315197,
0.35409459471702576,
-0.6231924295425415,
0.1990283876657486,
0.686276912689209,
-0.5521107316017151,
-0.24244530498981476,
0.682587742805481,
-0.1029180958867073,
-0.3868178725242615,
0.6029115915298462,
-0.2799804210662842,
-0.18891756236553192,
0.4768017530441284,
0.461683988571167,
1.2613211870193481,
0.12365882843732834,
0.545030951499939,
0.30724194645881653,
0.6921984553337097,
-0.3802995979785919,
0.5880773663520813,
0.021345557644963264,
-0.6823129653930664,
-0.2849758267402649,
-0.7148324251174927,
-0.46571195125579834,
0.42532646656036377,
-0.5220115780830383,
0.24300089478492737,
-0.6383896470069885,
-0.2926759421825409,
-0.15986496210098267,
-0.14246146380901337,
-0.15214523673057556,
0.11508813500404358,
0.03399522230029106,
0.7950215339660645,
-0.7847657799720764,
0.39970502257347107,
0.3448360562324524,
-0.42269378900527954,
-0.4122123122215271,
0.43384310603141785,
0.15024666488170624,
-0.48115289211273193,
0.4611227214336395,
0.17802618443965912,
-0.1855604499578476,
-0.21027138829231262,
-0.7122243046760559,
-0.6225420832633972,
0.6365078091621399,
-0.03149843215942383,
-0.43680906295776367,
-0.3717869520187378,
0.4060998558998108,
0.5602429509162903,
-0.10423988848924637,
0.19497784972190857,
0.4669756591320038,
0.6143568158149719,
0.17138442397117615,
-0.7170436978340149,
0.1922370344400406,
-0.0543661043047905,
0.021514330059289932,
-0.1911655217409134,
-0.6798685193061829,
0.5634335875511169,
-0.0944410040974617,
-0.19339041411876678,
0.1969623565673828,
0.6552362442016602,
0.14947786927223206,
0.42707425355911255,
0.19096235930919647,
0.34742310643196106,
0.7873235940933228,
-0.08887147158384323,
0.7047044634819031,
-0.19163770973682404,
0.1557691991329193,
1.0503236055374146,
-0.35566166043281555,
0.7967082858085632,
0.7150269746780396,
-0.20573627948760986,
0.18731926381587982,
0.6577897071838379,
0.036948636174201965,
0.22817642986774445,
0.2936080992221832,
-0.24580736458301544,
-0.1361645758152008,
-0.3207906186580658,
-0.498977392911911,
0.5903647541999817,
0.44666606187820435,
-0.25736263394355774,
0.008904829621315002,
-0.15510053932666779,
-0.2555750608444214,
0.1753673106431961,
-0.13291431963443756,
0.8815253973007202,
0.3201476037502289,
-0.6480506658554077,
0.6652195453643799,
-0.14680808782577515,
0.5170090794563293,
-0.36855944991111755,
-0.0620662085711956,
-0.04767317324876785,
-0.3053014874458313,
-0.5608904361724854,
-0.6331983804702759,
0.8244113922119141,
-0.15240634977817535,
-0.051446590572595596,
-0.2757571041584015,
0.5991588830947876,
-0.00994613952934742,
-0.4932723939418793,
0.2652689814567566,
0.7773838639259338,
0.7856745719909668,
-0.10468687862157822,
-0.4877096116542816,
0.32236194610595703,
-0.008201571181416512,
-0.07501239329576492,
0.19359613955020905,
0.6131707429885864,
0.11853286623954773,
0.553347647190094,
0.3201165795326233,
0.28689101338386536,
0.05790656805038452,
0.15634755790233612,
0.4452735483646393,
-0.9397796988487244,
0.020490257069468498,
-0.8527953624725342,
0.5489203929901123,
0.03870769590139389,
-0.5899212956428528,
0.7988099455833435,
0.4787232279777527,
0.8065823316574097,
-0.1024945005774498,
0.8309244513511658,
-0.20031613111495972,
0.4361216127872467,
-0.4461209774017334,
0.9506052136421204,
-0.572180449962616,
0.26724281907081604,
-0.38727253675460815,
-1.1075012683868408,
-0.559964656829834,
0.839596688747406,
-0.18817691504955292,
0.06014136224985123,
1.0268852710723877,
0.7148051261901855,
0.4251907765865326,
0.2542722225189209,
0.5154090523719788,
0.5149331092834473,
-0.16215790808200836,
0.17615872621536255,
1.023630142211914,
-0.10575766861438751,
0.18540023267269135,
-0.28608572483062744,
0.05501604080200195,
-0.2901795506477356,
-0.7372260689735413,
-0.9036000370979309,
-0.9409390687942505,
-0.43469667434692383,
-0.6548272967338562,
-0.3454279601573944,
0.8233532309532166,
0.13413721323013306,
-0.8523299694061279,
-0.4689590632915497,
-0.14228923618793488,
0.4078132212162018,
-0.06171611323952675,
-0.2840927839279175,
0.09456752240657806,
-0.5710369348526001,
-0.7020938992500305,
0.17625930905342102,
0.2567491829395294,
0.0794856920838356,
-0.8386633396148682,
0.09873861819505692,
-0.17944249510765076,
0.11514154821634293,
0.6224336624145508,
0.17676842212677002,
-0.8301422595977783,
-0.20250025391578674,
0.23654186725616455,
-0.034596338868141174,
-0.03637750819325447,
0.6303932070732117,
-0.453575074672699,
0.40236300230026245,
0.45367705821990967,
0.4415450990200043,
0.030623527243733406,
-0.39791280031204224,
0.27145400643348694,
-0.38229134678840637,
0.16485504806041718,
0.5502685904502869,
0.18019472062587738,
0.27405497431755066,
-0.4584074020385742,
0.474078893661499,
0.5289146304130554,
-0.5855947136878967,
-1.3217569589614868,
0.2237866073846817,
-0.9439372420310974,
-0.46021124720573425,
1.2066980600357056,
0.37358567118644714,
-0.2643129229545593,
-0.594491720199585,
-0.06698061525821686,
-0.007328461855649948,
-0.09853809326887131,
1.4219120740890503,
1.1483995914459229,
-0.239313542842865,
-0.10497047007083893,
-0.8219434022903442,
0.8342167139053345,
0.2632717192173004,
-0.5089156031608582,
0.07288266718387604,
0.5265225768089294,
-0.30569297075271606,
0.5835123062133789,
0.7260937690734863,
-0.1882493942975998,
-0.1605445146560669,
0.19387662410736084,
0.04413728788495064,
0.4079797565937042,
-0.45733392238616943,
-0.38198813796043396,
0.5323538780212402,
0.4122978150844574,
0.4203890562057495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07448v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07448v2
|
Transferable and Principled Efficiency for Open-Vocabulary Segmentation
| 2024-04-11T03:08:53 | 2024-06-04T03:15:51 |
Jingxuan Xu, Wuyang Chen, Yao Zhao, Yunchao Wei
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, eess.IV
|
Recent success of pre-trained foundation vision-language models makes
Open-Vocabulary Segmentation (OVS) possible. Despite the promising performance,
this approach introduces heavy computational overheads for two challenges: 1)
large model sizes of the backbone; 2) expensive costs during the fine-tuning.
These challenges hinder this OVS strategy from being widely applicable and
affordable in real-world scenarios. Although traditional methods such as model
compression and efficient fine-tuning can address these challenges, they often
rely on heuristics. This means that their solutions cannot be easily
transferred and necessitate re-training on different models, which comes at a
cost. In the context of efficient OVS, we target achieving performance that is
comparable to or even better than prior OVS works based on large
vision-language foundation models, by utilizing smaller models that incur lower
training costs. The core strategy is to make our efficiency principled and thus
seamlessly transferable from one OVS framework to others without further
customization. Comprehensive experiments on diverse OVS benchmarks demonstrate
our superior trade-off between segmentation accuracy and computation costs over
previous works. Our code is available on https://github.com/Xujxyang/OpenTrans
|
[
-0.3416505455970764,
-0.2810232937335968,
0.11291229724884033,
-0.011369903571903706,
-0.42482590675354004,
-0.12946264445781708,
-0.4090638756752014,
-0.5932904481887817,
-0.024366706609725952,
0.5704666376113892,
-0.2632722854614258,
-0.35007530450820923,
-0.309282124042511,
-0.2542908191680908,
-0.3238960802555084,
0.3031919598579407,
-0.08885906636714935,
0.011775673367083073,
-0.03141028434038162,
-0.4737573266029358,
0.10271114110946655,
-0.15783600509166718,
-0.6747654676437378,
0.1705530285835266,
0.35820698738098145,
0.5100375413894653,
0.493320107460022,
1.0643123388290405,
0.8266000151634216,
0.19249235093593597,
-0.21628737449645996,
0.3355470299720764,
-0.6229760050773621,
-0.1582978367805481,
-0.40876471996307373,
-0.2863590121269226,
-0.14772483706474304,
-0.2153945118188858,
0.7775598764419556,
0.9286279678344727,
-0.31491243839263916,
0.07906600832939148,
0.07443714886903763,
0.763638436794281,
-1.1889089345932007,
0.04380619898438454,
-0.7147318720817566,
0.06742633879184723,
-0.33048108220100403,
0.03394804894924164,
-0.2965444326400757,
-0.2978183627128601,
0.46249979734420776,
-0.8566287755966187,
0.06852792203426361,
-0.07138338685035706,
1.235215425491333,
0.34633520245552063,
0.2516724467277527,
0.023408621549606323,
-0.542229413986206,
0.6526169776916504,
-0.12641765177249908,
0.5766013264656067,
0.10857217758893967,
0.5157908201217651,
0.20119377970695496,
-1.0499894618988037,
-0.23229846358299255,
-0.151483952999115,
0.28719791769981384,
-0.13042683899402618,
-0.3956700265407562,
-0.06402447819709778,
0.04414965957403183,
0.4751632511615753,
-0.25722116231918335,
0.34334003925323486,
-0.6505383849143982,
-0.13944055140018463,
0.19909794628620148,
0.03604425862431526,
0.006809596437960863,
0.23752988874912262,
-0.4461778700351715,
-0.35652515292167664,
-0.6108066439628601,
0.24728764593601227,
0.24583694338798523,
0.5353720784187317,
0.10015376657247543,
0.6027361750602722,
-0.4162943661212921,
0.9626312851905823,
-0.2527373135089874,
-0.2498394399881363,
0.27959752082824707,
-0.5332903861999512,
-0.26210469007492065,
-0.03512655571103096,
0.5025929808616638,
0.3152625262737274,
0.5814201235771179,
-0.2818145453929901,
-0.11313419789075851,
0.09266665577888489,
0.3703412711620331,
-0.9124495983123779,
-0.33217597007751465,
-0.16884908080101013,
-0.4974571466445923,
-0.2507387101650238,
0.15771004557609558,
-0.6809659004211426,
-0.1497945338487625,
-0.12342225760221481,
0.46272778511047363,
-0.5548198223114014,
-0.08712714910507202,
0.6109801530838013,
-0.19947449862957,
0.23244468867778778,
0.569661021232605,
-0.7251867651939392,
0.379167377948761,
0.6584497690200806,
1.2290418148040771,
-0.251546710729599,
0.031681470572948456,
-0.8185391426086426,
-0.04292967915534973,
-0.4600539803504944,
0.5727747678756714,
-0.3658759891986847,
-0.3190784752368927,
-0.16554157435894012,
-0.2559671998023987,
-0.24167484045028687,
-0.5168072581291199,
0.3464241325855255,
-0.3934122920036316,
-0.1622461974620819,
-0.12082024663686752,
-0.1615169495344162,
0.05719350650906563,
0.28262418508529663,
-0.6034648418426514,
0.7816357016563416,
0.32422247529029846,
-0.5543845295906067,
0.33725136518478394,
-0.8209242224693298,
-0.4566851556301117,
0.021968336775898933,
0.039274465292692184,
-0.217612624168396,
0.22913822531700134,
0.17561163008213043,
0.38908809423446655,
-0.4999505281448364,
-0.41114962100982666,
-0.23826904594898224,
-0.0241293553262949,
-0.20333051681518555,
-0.0447450615465641,
0.7199839353561401,
0.509009063243866,
-0.07318545132875443,
0.3415306508541107,
-0.8999244570732117,
0.01449620258063078,
0.252814382314682,
-0.23038610816001892,
-0.7906026840209961,
-0.07425317168235779,
-0.09557365626096725,
-0.257131963968277,
0.1835566610097885,
-0.7442178130149841,
0.3059391379356384,
-0.7989656925201416,
0.3358749449253082,
0.5489537715911865,
-0.4185689687728882,
0.8778541684150696,
0.026360828429460526,
0.3032681941986084,
-0.08804015815258026,
0.3828054368495941,
-0.1483689248561859,
-0.29595500230789185,
-0.8674494624137878,
-0.6651906967163086,
0.5172753930091858,
0.3007830083370209,
-0.8936328887939453,
0.2083349972963333,
-0.410076379776001,
-0.6380516886711121,
-0.38606682419776917,
-0.19581934809684753,
0.392069548368454,
0.7832719087600708,
0.3791384696960449,
-0.8326475620269775,
-0.3496250510215759,
-0.824863851070404,
-0.08486058562994003,
0.021519163623452187,
0.22458483278751373,
0.3055381178855896,
0.511271595954895,
0.304882287979126,
1.1643706560134888,
-0.9690142869949341,
-0.5356183648109436,
-0.15883903205394745,
-0.18631760776042938,
-0.15311090648174286,
0.5517773628234863,
0.7613125443458557,
-0.8049243092536926,
-0.5131694078445435,
0.3170754909515381,
-0.4305754601955414,
-0.02269727922976017,
0.27319616079330444,
-0.17626166343688965,
0.2610177993774414,
0.6688500046730042,
-0.3186917304992676,
0.690004289150238,
0.392095685005188,
-0.27321621775627136,
0.3108130097389221,
-0.3100280463695526,
-0.11292973905801773,
-0.9068102240562439,
0.18242232501506805,
-0.09033148735761642,
-0.12636423110961914,
-0.3780389726161957,
0.340383917093277,
-0.01355646550655365,
0.0534004308283329,
-0.8040030598640442,
0.5981055498123169,
-0.4731235206127167,
-0.3011581003665924,
0.0714632198214531,
-0.01010675635188818,
-0.0289734099060297,
0.30716171860694885,
0.07686517387628555,
0.8417209982872009,
0.7254707217216492,
-0.6849988102912903,
0.06209145486354828,
0.18262191116809845,
-0.8417558670043945,
0.49940699338912964,
-0.6415484547615051,
-0.283719539642334,
-0.06511729955673218,
-0.049652181565761566,
-0.6320786476135254,
-0.1470094621181488,
0.54998379945755,
-0.03676430881023407,
0.199519544839859,
-0.287339985370636,
-0.26974284648895264,
-0.06790328025817871,
-0.32045140862464905,
0.31733807921409607,
0.7163564562797546,
-0.8899667263031006,
0.6637608408927917,
0.3972669541835785,
0.2893325686454773,
-0.7181785106658936,
-0.6653657555580139,
-0.2690361440181732,
-0.013828645460307598,
-0.8236619830131531,
0.532309889793396,
0.29574713110923767,
-0.2040313482284546,
0.3744780123233795,
-0.32322582602500916,
-0.16537104547023773,
0.2452012300491333,
-0.046038348227739334,
-0.01355931255966425,
-0.5480848550796509,
0.11096291989088058,
-0.2830791175365448,
-0.08061403781175613,
-0.3603735566139221,
-0.834389865398407,
0.5382490158081055,
-0.2487591952085495,
-0.36125946044921875,
-0.06274597346782684,
0.006360326427966356,
0.5307570695877075,
-0.9158363342285156,
0.9817222952842712,
0.5462102293968201,
-0.40992870926856995,
-0.3707682490348816,
-0.29169324040412903,
0.12573932111263275,
-0.4043538570404053,
0.49939414858818054,
-0.5270493030548096,
-0.9314634203910828,
0.2686363458633423,
-0.09663783758878708,
0.2612020671367645,
0.29984042048454285,
0.2423429936170578,
0.26349228620529175,
0.6102076172828674,
0.5961366891860962,
0.3450659215450287,
0.7448193430900574,
-0.37796443700790405,
-0.06396261602640152,
-0.6782459020614624,
-0.21416401863098145,
-0.8356919884681702,
-0.11072005331516266,
-0.17108310759067535,
-0.7857513427734375,
0.39957544207572937,
0.30286577343940735,
0.07253499329090118,
0.41931113600730896,
-0.5277515053749084,
0.6915513277053833,
0.5635999441146851,
-0.002350080758333206,
0.21530388295650482,
0.3900276720523834,
-0.20911037921905518,
0.35853126645088196,
-0.98780757188797,
-0.25807619094848633,
1.0232267379760742,
0.4339776337146759,
0.8387333750724792,
0.2280064970254898,
0.5650331377983093,
-0.12829037010669708,
0.12560009956359863,
-1.020264983177185,
0.5778437852859497,
-0.5960670709609985,
-0.31334710121154785,
-0.5474164485931396,
-0.6021761894226074,
-1.2058945894241333,
0.5710304975509644,
-0.15866923332214355,
-1.002929925918579,
0.3950788676738739,
0.3442671000957489,
-0.5386388301849365,
0.6077243685722351,
-0.5530014038085938,
1.1093436479568481,
0.011568854562938213,
-0.4846705496311188,
-0.2371852546930313,
-0.6827783584594727,
0.21358144283294678,
-0.01657371036708355,
-0.08647319674491882,
-0.15869395434856415,
-0.2865211069583893,
0.77504563331604,
-0.8007864952087402,
0.5580634474754333,
-0.18272437155246735,
0.005354552064090967,
0.2986195981502533,
-0.20244082808494568,
0.13588041067123413,
-0.44688880443573,
0.2374674677848816,
0.29533860087394714,
-0.05235740542411804,
-0.2811749577522278,
-0.4511651396751404,
0.5528964996337891,
-0.5331218242645264,
-0.1061321496963501,
-0.3755498230457306,
-0.2726682126522064,
-0.11430305987596512,
0.31345584988594055,
0.3035614490509033,
0.5390712022781372,
-0.37277543544769287,
0.5362761616706848,
0.9409240484237671,
-0.01927894912660122,
0.39125344157218933,
0.3824138045310974,
-0.25830644369125366,
-0.2936641275882721,
0.9878291487693787,
0.25669991970062256,
0.475455641746521,
0.5735738277435303,
0.5147375464439392,
-0.22455407679080963,
-0.8702675104141235,
-0.5623729825019836,
0.011947829276323318,
-0.7375283241271973,
-0.14968198537826538,
-0.46917837858200073,
0.07427084445953369,
-0.38647735118865967,
-0.2474069595336914,
-0.8591244220733643,
-0.5119447708129883,
-0.41961437463760376,
0.27723437547683716,
0.2604038119316101,
0.24669422209262848,
-0.2540038228034973,
0.4751843512058258,
-0.7179754376411438,
0.43267950415611267,
0.22851620614528656,
0.5879413485527039,
0.023859236389398575,
-0.47846168279647827,
-0.3899132013320923,
-0.2147466540336609,
0.04823887720704079,
-0.466321736574173,
0.20285940170288086,
0.35834717750549316,
0.45909997820854187,
0.44858795404434204,
0.19107788801193237,
0.7361740469932556,
-0.34993207454681396,
0.5053077936172485,
0.4262375831604004,
-0.831037700176239,
0.14266091585159302,
0.02892109379172325,
0.26566198468208313,
0.789803147315979,
0.30001920461654663,
-0.07640642672777176,
0.35495442152023315,
-0.2730650007724762,
-0.9975210428237915,
1.0326006412506104,
0.18469367921352386,
-0.4424719512462616,
0.1839868724346161,
0.2932828366756439,
-0.02623680792748928,
0.01455041766166687,
-0.11145661771297455,
-0.04935014247894287,
-0.2239387184381485,
-0.27971139550209045,
-0.11596432328224182,
0.10687997937202454,
-0.08566775172948837,
-0.13040708005428314,
0.6026769876480103,
-0.39499446749687195,
-0.2414417415857315,
0.3035893440246582,
-0.21775761246681213,
0.03135044500231743,
0.026106124743819237,
0.665582537651062,
0.4823340177536011,
-0.14557845890522003,
0.02948150224983692,
0.05459292605519295,
-0.6180095672607422,
-0.058095045387744904,
0.017506003379821777,
-0.24287515878677368,
-0.24719466269016266,
0.10754429548978806,
1.0638606548309326,
0.19994142651557922,
-0.8086227178573608,
0.6726813912391663,
-0.05911368504166603,
-0.3981519937515259,
-0.060228295624256134,
0.18038639426231384,
0.034722112119197845,
0.21594612300395966,
-0.017146190628409386,
0.6054013967514038,
0.0815424695611,
-0.381550669670105,
-0.03432096913456917,
0.45840373635292053,
-0.4377538859844208,
0.06670843064785004,
0.384471595287323,
0.3322131335735321,
-0.1880604475736618,
0.45274868607521057,
-0.04204715043306351,
-0.3925633430480957,
0.5177342891693115,
-0.0010709663620218635,
0.8961231112480164,
-0.07415599375963211,
-0.0043833814561367035,
0.20477549731731415,
0.34785565733909607,
-0.5056652426719666,
0.26216834783554077,
-0.08881627023220062,
-0.8900789022445679,
-0.43417537212371826,
-0.8685063719749451,
-0.29302918910980225,
-0.2770914137363434,
-0.8418259024620056,
0.33709245920181274,
-0.5695422887802124,
0.06840382516384125,
0.07160881161689758,
-0.677582323551178,
-0.615767240524292,
0.2437482476234436,
0.11546877771615982,
1.5222352743148804,
-0.2368977665901184,
0.7277173399925232,
0.7340782880783081,
-0.28587377071380615,
-0.6198388934135437,
-0.20492444932460785,
-0.3263290226459503,
-0.9090068936347961,
0.6081421375274658,
0.226027712225914,
-0.5480679869651794,
-0.01540602557361126,
-0.2753918468952179,
-0.8596131801605225,
0.8312171697616577,
0.3536272943019867,
-0.6712892651557922,
-0.2731873393058777,
-0.12963254749774933,
0.3483293652534485,
-0.46261370182037354,
-0.19598937034606934,
0.44376295804977417,
0.3227766752243042,
0.4122384190559387,
-1.0976661443710327,
-0.23222953081130981,
0.18596668541431427,
0.0523223951458931,
0.5712039470672607,
-0.5227797031402588,
0.927821934223175,
-0.3768230080604553,
-0.38692158460617065,
0.34817078709602356,
0.7154725790023804,
-0.3575648069381714,
0.12498956173658371,
0.8467577695846558,
0.7897775173187256,
0.5304394364356995,
-0.17819175124168396,
0.9021021723747253,
-0.277662068605423,
0.16793519258499146,
0.9295880794525146,
-0.30950841307640076,
1.0334076881408691,
0.5159829258918762,
0.03968482464551926,
0.20448771119117737,
0.320814847946167,
0.15520654618740082,
0.8461613655090332,
0.3973861336708069,
0.018382366746664047,
-0.43687692284584045,
-0.31458115577697754,
-0.3148306906223297,
0.8345272541046143,
0.23309630155563354,
-0.3085629343986511,
-0.30126675963401794,
0.10815183818340302,
-0.24857327342033386,
0.020175518468022346,
-0.6310009360313416,
0.5783582925796509,
-0.11170487850904465,
-0.6471114158630371,
0.553111732006073,
0.14349575340747833,
0.6068938374519348,
-1.0659483671188354,
0.14442656934261322,
0.3098505139350891,
0.49497610330581665,
-0.09488987922668457,
-0.5741691589355469,
0.4173908829689026,
-0.16450437903404236,
0.1214999109506607,
-0.30847200751304626,
0.7308632731437683,
-0.2743641436100006,
-0.06240210682153702,
0.14153333008289337,
0.5164910554885864,
0.11698868125677109,
-0.25446373224258423,
-0.2913651168346405,
0.1904870718717575,
0.12695327401161194,
-0.08749315142631531,
0.4116877615451813,
0.13366642594337463,
-0.15688209235668182,
0.5410374999046326,
0.6984835267066956,
0.18198467791080475,
-0.03495882824063301,
-0.06135793775320053,
0.9659456014633179,
-0.3515796959400177,
-0.7040299773216248,
-0.7097527980804443,
0.41651803255081177,
-0.20746628940105438,
-0.6461074948310852,
0.4457132816314697,
0.6159719228744507,
1.0790165662765503,
-0.1351097673177719,
0.5042888522148132,
0.035017482936382294,
0.4176223576068878,
-0.788055419921875,
0.5943994522094727,
-0.8546294569969177,
0.055856652557849884,
-0.15724124014377594,
-0.7205937504768372,
-0.35552263259887695,
0.9266691207885742,
-0.19110257923603058,
-0.3894467353820801,
0.5656599998474121,
0.6485391855239868,
-0.3181513845920563,
0.05413694679737091,
0.3211122751235962,
-0.20242348313331604,
0.0841643363237381,
0.42918094992637634,
0.6777512431144714,
-0.06601712852716446,
0.7080156207084656,
-0.44014599919319153,
-0.4388946294784546,
-0.32182297110557556,
-0.930943489074707,
-0.7216415405273438,
-0.387738972902298,
-0.5606900453567505,
-0.261206716299057,
0.23152977228164673,
0.9160343408584595,
1.0370240211486816,
-0.4292299747467041,
-0.1806269735097885,
-0.14538796246051788,
-0.12523683905601501,
-0.2831515967845917,
-0.15167151391506195,
0.3357899487018585,
-0.10316145420074463,
-0.5733121037483215,
0.5183698534965515,
0.4883233904838562,
0.01724417880177498,
-0.38545718789100647,
-0.09959030151367188,
0.03117026947438717,
0.11181200295686722,
0.6349191069602966,
0.5888291001319885,
-0.6831944584846497,
-0.3364224433898926,
0.1104460060596466,
-0.0632898285984993,
0.1284363865852356,
0.7770976424217224,
-0.8023293614387512,
0.5338788032531738,
0.5295075178146362,
0.9661086797714233,
0.5033348798751831,
-0.06885520368814468,
0.3184439539909363,
-0.6548827886581421,
0.11438766121864319,
0.20332342386245728,
0.4265006482601166,
0.32855263352394104,
0.20760932564735413,
0.8748558163642883,
0.3960700035095215,
0.05295534431934357,
-0.9503983855247498,
0.41470736265182495,
-1.1755733489990234,
-0.48180529475212097,
0.9973531365394592,
-0.45091351866722107,
-0.5826238989830017,
0.032536618411540985,
-0.2480776458978653,
0.003000089433044195,
-0.3079439699649811,
0.12168633937835693,
0.323689728975296,
0.039415013045072556,
0.010051608085632324,
0.09373234957456589,
0.343120813369751,
0.3215429484844208,
-0.7285129427909851,
-0.0633745789527893,
0.3887910544872284,
0.18969771265983582,
0.4789833426475525,
0.3690301775932312,
-0.030180348083376884,
0.3300815224647522,
0.3302912712097168,
0.12515923380851746,
-0.49532073736190796,
-0.6536827683448792,
-0.3181706964969635,
0.7560103535652161,
0.03700144588947296,
-0.701143205165863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07439v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07439v1
|
Behavior Trees Enable Structured Programming of Language Model Agents
| 2024-04-11T02:44:13 | 2024-04-11T02:44:13 |
Richard Kelley
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Language models trained on internet-scale data sets have shown an impressive
ability to solve problems in Natural Language Processing and Computer Vision.
However, experience is showing that these models are frequently brittle in
unexpected ways, and require significant scaffolding to ensure that they
operate correctly in the larger systems that comprise "language-model agents."
In this paper, we argue that behavior trees provide a unifying framework for
combining language models with classical AI and traditional programming. We
introduce Dendron, a Python library for programming language model agents using
behavior trees. We demonstrate the approach embodied by Dendron in three case
studies: building a chat agent, a camera-based infrastructure inspection agent
for use on a mobile robot or vehicle, and an agent that has been built to
satisfy safety constraints that it did not receive through instruction tuning
or RLHF.
|
[
0.0993027314543724,
-0.7648404836654663,
0.3263395428657532,
0.22804895043373108,
0.06770756840705872,
0.4933592677116394,
0.25147610902786255,
-0.4278765618801117,
-0.12641742825508118,
0.424503356218338,
-0.48626863956451416,
-0.6072207093238831,
-0.23610790073871613,
-0.08401988446712494,
-0.5417875647544861,
0.9340780973434448,
0.23049874603748322,
-0.5705985426902771,
-0.0349711999297142,
-0.06689905375242233,
-0.24493059515953064,
-0.4021639823913574,
-0.7244139909744263,
-0.4330778121948242,
0.07946691662073135,
-0.06719937175512314,
1.1063281297683716,
0.6501319408416748,
0.388438880443573,
0.4441816210746765,
-0.03916990011930466,
0.14012956619262695,
-0.20062334835529327,
0.26769644021987915,
0.08955452591180801,
-0.3625358045101166,
-0.618846595287323,
-0.04414639621973038,
0.5856328010559082,
0.7022263407707214,
-0.5564917922019958,
-0.2675284743309021,
-0.1289369761943817,
0.6009441614151001,
-0.19183321297168732,
0.5697482824325562,
-0.5431721806526184,
0.13141709566116333,
0.29366764426231384,
-0.32813677191734314,
-0.29284754395484924,
-0.24666261672973633,
-0.07164334505796432,
-0.589568555355072,
-0.1572672426700592,
-0.239876389503479,
0.8640667200088501,
0.3912909924983978,
-0.6349884271621704,
-0.12481226772069931,
-0.8864814043045044,
0.7445685863494873,
-0.6885512471199036,
0.25523099303245544,
0.3866795599460602,
0.357834130525589,
-0.48931339383125305,
-0.5816335678100586,
-0.330112487077713,
-0.49726584553718567,
-0.2433798909187317,
-0.29428890347480774,
-0.3191259503364563,
0.4976286292076111,
0.15434466302394867,
0.09624209254980087,
-0.5886319875717163,
0.07213567197322845,
-0.21470868587493896,
0.028248634189367294,
0.6801090240478516,
0.5794280767440796,
0.5484510064125061,
-0.040482088923454285,
0.37459972500801086,
-0.17964379489421844,
-0.6259956359863281,
0.3043439984321594,
0.29775670170783997,
0.5931588411331177,
-0.1576540619134903,
0.3624885082244873,
-0.1716269552707672,
1.0873280763626099,
-0.34072145819664,
-0.34068697690963745,
-0.05918183550238609,
-0.06315222382545471,
-0.5227811932563782,
-0.1487182080745697,
0.5676665306091309,
0.19196094572544098,
0.5839617252349854,
-0.22209207713603973,
-0.3084409832954407,
0.29986363649368286,
0.2546503245830536,
-0.7374320030212402,
-0.6176839470863342,
0.4653432071208954,
-0.5785982012748718,
-0.9869183301925659,
-0.05320293828845024,
-0.518348753452301,
-0.3322358727455139,
-0.29286548495292664,
-0.04759564995765686,
-0.4369301199913025,
-0.6637631058692932,
0.012875420041382313,
-0.13891896605491638,
0.25183025002479553,
0.31190526485443115,
-1.0670944452285767,
0.43562525510787964,
0.9601583480834961,
1.0488184690475464,
0.30893003940582275,
-0.3987211585044861,
-0.7142162322998047,
0.2713589072227478,
-0.7964284420013428,
0.5684979557991028,
-1.0584018230438232,
-0.4309259355068207,
0.046867724508047104,
0.01672503724694252,
-0.12526056170463562,
-0.3056868016719818,
-0.15466424822807312,
-0.3994235396385193,
-0.22421245276927948,
0.49872615933418274,
-0.02677706442773342,
-0.26118800044059753,
0.5351316332817078,
-0.39599210023880005,
1.0674068927764893,
0.3162018060684204,
-0.4868163764476776,
0.25029876828193665,
-0.8178630471229553,
-0.744690477848053,
0.1256411075592041,
-0.4140290319919586,
-0.28408604860305786,
-0.10429475456476212,
-0.11394388973712921,
0.35705244541168213,
0.24378594756126404,
0.36772021651268005,
-0.17855745553970337,
-0.33785581588745117,
0.01804608851671219,
-0.23186907172203064,
1.07784903049469,
0.18608181178569794,
-0.12601318955421448,
0.25917553901672363,
-0.7176116704940796,
0.0306217260658741,
0.0808710977435112,
-0.8184446096420288,
-0.34589946269989014,
0.4485497772693634,
-0.14657269418239594,
-0.08134929835796356,
0.059151697903871536,
-0.3558696210384369,
0.5016255378723145,
-0.5479332208633423,
0.9119626879692078,
0.7257788181304932,
-0.24447695910930634,
0.25920799374580383,
-0.32918575406074524,
0.7862297892570496,
-0.03915254771709442,
-0.005936215631663799,
-0.15179572999477386,
-0.482845276594162,
-0.2573322653770447,
-0.062096912413835526,
-0.08922179043292999,
0.4535556435585022,
-0.4529247581958771,
0.17603044211864471,
-0.17150461673736572,
-0.4339703321456909,
-0.1923573762178421,
-0.07530593127012253,
0.1332690715789795,
0.2871866822242737,
-0.2016068398952484,
-0.34308502078056335,
-0.5086228251457214,
-0.37900876998901367,
0.06456408649682999,
-0.7304427623748779,
0.2336554080247879,
0.3076450824737549,
0.5633898377418518,
-0.3869986832141876,
1.1110972166061401,
-0.38931509852409363,
-0.05579129233956337,
-0.35119014978408813,
0.22849851846694946,
0.24029996991157532,
0.5199137330055237,
0.5597035884857178,
-0.8120572566986084,
-0.36811596155166626,
0.46397310495376587,
-0.7527943253517151,
0.22984348237514496,
-0.1368316113948822,
0.19678376615047455,
0.5928041338920593,
0.41973286867141724,
-0.8000881671905518,
0.4219810962677002,
0.8845828771591187,
-0.280285120010376,
0.7332580089569092,
-0.4708687365055084,
0.07641787827014923,
-0.7801485657691956,
0.17558497190475464,
-0.14604401588439941,
-0.41964811086654663,
-0.7307941317558289,
0.12263991683721542,
-0.5585349202156067,
-0.40567752718925476,
-0.14002162218093872,
0.26944583654403687,
-0.26301127672195435,
-0.5564973950386047,
-0.1000283733010292,
-0.14965318143367767,
-0.012466944754123688,
0.54510098695755,
0.32350826263427734,
0.5523732304573059,
1.0199835300445557,
-0.7945544719696045,
0.5941190123558044,
0.3546428680419922,
-0.22323964536190033,
0.5848002433776855,
-0.7622978091239929,
0.14513452351093292,
-0.2440366894006729,
-0.020779022946953773,
-0.6177118420600891,
-0.15014460682868958,
0.18608011305332184,
-0.4677501618862152,
0.0873790830373764,
-0.763288676738739,
-0.2420101761817932,
-0.051169030368328094,
-0.4107822775840759,
-0.028514450415968895,
0.5551801323890686,
-0.441501259803772,
0.5160704851150513,
0.44535350799560547,
0.23994623124599457,
-0.480004221200943,
-0.6809850931167603,
0.2704261243343353,
-0.28488877415657043,
-0.563423216342926,
0.020851243287324905,
-0.01707003079354763,
-0.5979920029640198,
0.27076399326324463,
-0.06455250084400177,
-0.5003902316093445,
0.48548001050949097,
0.6011688113212585,
0.022119082510471344,
-0.2726878821849823,
0.1782233715057373,
-0.2497292459011078,
0.009557130746543407,
0.003866342594847083,
-0.17773714661598206,
0.3813473582267761,
-0.46503397822380066,
-0.3549860715866089,
-0.4168581962585449,
0.15099023282527924,
0.7540093064308167,
-0.43563786149024963,
0.5442220568656921,
-0.034937337040901184,
-0.27547863125801086,
-0.2905578315258026,
0.2903658151626587,
-0.14279454946517944,
-0.5973179340362549,
0.37189680337905884,
-0.5458783507347107,
-0.8390868306159973,
-0.061872053891420364,
-0.2261115312576294,
0.4583956301212311,
-0.31812188029289246,
0.29004067182540894,
-0.2256508469581604,
1.455915927886963,
0.8510640263557434,
-0.053941357880830765,
0.8443769216537476,
-0.33014073967933655,
0.3979915678501129,
-0.4248349070549011,
-0.29940712451934814,
-0.6251468658447266,
-0.14107158780097961,
-0.6954268217086792,
-0.060201890766620636,
0.10943642258644104,
-0.11662333458662033,
-0.49291300773620605,
0.6177552342414856,
-0.8643054962158203,
0.37280675768852234,
0.6003535985946655,
-0.2685927748680115,
0.6091622710227966,
0.24120786786079407,
0.1113462895154953,
0.24818380177021027,
-0.788394033908844,
-0.8882401585578918,
0.912206768989563,
0.3050365149974823,
0.8997086882591248,
0.07500093430280685,
0.6386975646018982,
0.5194031000137329,
0.057042136788368225,
-0.8658269047737122,
0.7695234417915344,
-0.03422614187002182,
-0.5283348560333252,
-0.5771356821060181,
-0.41823989152908325,
-1.5163675546646118,
0.37459465861320496,
0.053278520703315735,
-0.9625658988952637,
0.17965765297412872,
0.2733052372932434,
-0.42026087641716003,
0.2116280496120453,
-0.46038782596588135,
1.1621628999710083,
-0.3115644156932831,
0.028204280883073807,
-0.5789511799812317,
-0.37259361147880554,
0.3935348093509674,
0.4822615683078766,
0.1967017501592636,
-0.1882861703634262,
0.28537148237228394,
0.5768492817878723,
-0.77588951587677,
1.0563249588012695,
-0.0005858719814568758,
-0.03120824508368969,
0.5756049156188965,
0.9184564352035522,
0.5514554381370544,
-0.08220687508583069,
0.10542330890893936,
-0.11605385690927505,
0.8468965888023376,
-0.13397692143917084,
-0.5415990352630615,
0.4691867530345917,
-0.8714538812637329,
-0.4484286308288574,
-0.6719513535499573,
-0.6177390217781067,
-0.04830344393849373,
-0.027297968044877052,
-0.7809817790985107,
0.8337726593017578,
-0.3915542960166931,
0.1334122270345688,
0.16075851023197174,
-0.07953711599111557,
0.7329238057136536,
0.7445356249809265,
-0.3632200062274933,
0.22587603330612183,
0.9426425695419312,
-0.08012570440769196,
0.0435718297958374,
0.33306053280830383,
-0.015177255496382713,
0.15533506870269775,
-0.6309769153594971,
-0.14342521131038666,
-0.1097932904958725,
-0.5513368844985962,
-0.00516164256259799,
-0.5637969374656677,
-0.29648295044898987,
-0.4366939067840576,
-0.1003226563334465,
-0.11422568559646606,
-0.4058009684085846,
0.02780238352715969,
-0.18217337131500244,
0.6795781254768372,
1.1527955532073975,
-0.26692304015159607,
0.536737322807312,
-0.6623638272285461,
0.23085452616214752,
0.7256898283958435,
0.3820485770702362,
-0.004092340357601643,
-0.024083882570266724,
-0.00851130485534668,
0.11652731895446777,
-0.2982105016708374,
-0.8348961472511292,
0.5480997562408447,
0.38105982542037964,
0.47249552607536316,
0.4240233898162842,
-0.06951684504747391,
0.4901820421218872,
-0.14238126575946808,
0.46860623359680176,
-0.19162105023860931,
-0.5992658138275146,
0.807137131690979,
-0.434623122215271,
-0.15907186269760132,
0.24547885358333588,
-0.04089584946632385,
-0.8681159615516663,
-0.38363921642303467,
-0.47770386934280396,
-0.15452302992343903,
1.0458366870880127,
0.19379448890686035,
0.14764872193336487,
-0.014498520642518997,
0.008719664067029953,
-0.3893555998802185,
0.5221946239471436,
-0.7549933791160583,
0.3953729569911957,
-0.34052008390426636,
-0.20544877648353577,
0.06218405067920685,
0.07880694419145584,
-0.3878728747367859,
-0.27575427293777466,
0.4109756052494049,
-0.40925440192222595,
-0.13331134617328644,
0.012127172201871872,
-0.26098817586898804,
-0.2874281704425812,
0.19561341404914856,
0.2098577469587326,
0.5275433659553528,
-0.37368685007095337,
0.4058404862880707,
-0.439792662858963,
-0.3832119405269623,
0.22816155850887299,
-0.3035534620285034,
-0.41882967948913574,
-0.31630322337150574,
0.4778773784637451,
0.5915497541427612,
-0.037601254880428314,
-1.0571587085723877,
0.2026970237493515,
0.15310190618038177,
0.14083589613437653,
-0.03942150995135307,
0.274485319852829,
0.09877534210681915,
0.27521687746047974,
-0.20718535780906677,
-0.017547180876135826,
0.014383543282747269,
-1.1833313703536987,
0.17260980606079102,
0.8762966394424438,
-0.4231741428375244,
-0.6121160387992859,
0.4096832275390625,
0.38227590918540955,
-0.7050462961196899,
1.0358830690383911,
-0.285163015127182,
-0.44559118151664734,
1.1483300924301147,
0.4272017180919647,
0.7741837501525879,
-0.09120333939790726,
0.8768091201782227,
0.12478546798229218,
0.7628759145736694,
-0.041165150701999664,
0.36950984597206116,
-0.1828160285949707,
-0.8418988585472107,
-0.342482328414917,
-0.6996765732765198,
-0.446029394865036,
-0.11899671703577042,
0.09278751909732819,
0.06703902035951614,
-0.836536169052124,
0.0677945464849472,
-0.48444056510925293,
0.07996257394552231,
-0.2262803465127945,
0.06631996482610703,
-0.010022698901593685,
0.699562132358551,
-0.9625037312507629,
1.0607001781463623,
1.0905121564865112,
-0.5726228952407837,
-0.8941581845283508,
-0.2292724996805191,
-0.07306350022554398,
-0.7926569581031799,
0.686830997467041,
0.17479564249515533,
-0.26082760095596313,
0.2852078676223755,
-0.6285943984985352,
-0.5216138958930969,
1.0282139778137207,
0.4378640353679657,
-0.32066839933395386,
0.0368976853787899,
0.14333990216255188,
0.7465112209320068,
-0.4348910450935364,
0.262276828289032,
0.9414248466491699,
0.535104513168335,
0.18510492146015167,
-0.7311329245567322,
0.03145262971520424,
-0.22455942630767822,
-0.1298910677433014,
0.11065157502889633,
-0.37812915444374084,
0.9234843850135803,
-0.4076507091522217,
-0.4117297828197479,
0.016653066501021385,
0.20060916244983673,
0.46135494112968445,
0.22910034656524658,
0.5643154382705688,
0.4681020677089691,
0.6656800508499146,
0.13213708996772766,
0.9620879292488098,
-0.4916057288646698,
0.12090284377336502,
0.8934164047241211,
-0.2722070515155792,
0.6313588619232178,
0.2900063991546631,
-0.5024747252464294,
1.01911199092865,
0.8179835677146912,
0.058939505368471146,
0.5002356767654419,
-0.0069907959550619125,
-0.0908120796084404,
-0.5106359124183655,
-0.2820202112197876,
-0.04126414656639099,
0.33272483944892883,
0.29795071482658386,
0.24228616058826447,
-0.39792633056640625,
-0.43132275342941284,
-0.04548097401857376,
0.13476957380771637,
-0.15449652075767517,
0.5859395861625671,
0.11309914290904999,
-0.6176364421844482,
0.34710565209388733,
0.08160222321748734,
0.27383700013160706,
-0.6483750343322754,
-0.4348003566265106,
-0.40875810384750366,
0.07665061950683594,
-0.5140243172645569,
-0.8965792059898376,
0.6595069169998169,
-0.1747923493385315,
0.49358025193214417,
-0.34331801533699036,
0.6298953294754028,
-0.22423724830150604,
-0.24340872466564178,
0.16220760345458984,
0.2798673212528229,
0.4551650583744049,
-0.13810397684574127,
-0.7327311038970947,
0.028178881853818893,
-0.4305567741394043,
-0.241906076669693,
0.22717870771884918,
0.33277207612991333,
-0.3299410939216614,
1.121192216873169,
0.530269205570221,
0.06181495636701584,
-0.10355071723461151,
-0.1553971767425537,
0.7853731513023376,
-0.5626499056816101,
-0.6116847395896912,
-0.9500687718391418,
0.4815913438796997,
0.08121928572654724,
0.057132307440042496,
0.4425090551376343,
0.3726213574409485,
0.2995588183403015,
0.21056383848190308,
0.7543372511863708,
-0.48051097989082336,
-0.14230363070964813,
-0.20717620849609375,
0.5015547871589661,
-0.4679177403450012,
0.21583357453346252,
-0.014879406429827213,
-0.7940748333930969,
-0.2371489554643631,
0.873767614364624,
-0.040272828191518784,
-0.015475637279450893,
0.5273265242576599,
1.1745911836624146,
-0.07931587845087051,
-0.3975677490234375,
0.47827646136283875,
0.2844111919403076,
0.541110634803772,
0.625150203704834,
0.9253461956977844,
0.06519767642021179,
0.8204610347747803,
-0.036227669566869736,
-0.16199631989002228,
-0.21905215084552765,
-0.838983416557312,
-1.2790155410766602,
-0.48615655303001404,
-0.6022095084190369,
-0.2588558793067932,
0.1825823038816452,
0.8037250638008118,
1.015474557876587,
-0.6985832452774048,
-0.5889312028884888,
-0.6193141341209412,
0.584191083908081,
-0.5925105214118958,
-0.21270576119422913,
0.07936008274555206,
-0.23967710137367249,
-0.5604467988014221,
0.7891733646392822,
0.595089852809906,
0.265287309885025,
-0.544041633605957,
-0.5324629545211792,
-0.08017149567604065,
0.23594316840171814,
0.5042579174041748,
0.7214995622634888,
-0.4447459578514099,
-0.35433849692344666,
-0.337030291557312,
-0.1728731244802475,
0.1262727677822113,
0.8878930807113647,
-1.0633538961410522,
0.28424274921417236,
0.659766435623169,
0.18996605277061462,
0.27527061104774475,
0.06281696259975433,
0.77588951587677,
-0.7198674082756042,
0.4621186852455139,
0.2665809094905853,
0.27547144889831543,
0.32342052459716797,
-0.020998355001211166,
0.6827051639556885,
0.32139813899993896,
-0.350711464881897,
-1.1748710870742798,
0.6293563842773438,
-0.7748956680297852,
-0.45897048711776733,
0.8621484041213989,
-0.10061699151992798,
-0.3041016757488251,
-0.37462949752807617,
-0.3467928171157837,
-0.029870418831706047,
-0.32454341650009155,
0.9037625789642334,
0.4287201464176178,
-0.19482485949993134,
-0.4518719017505646,
-0.482310950756073,
0.6620709896087646,
0.05309966951608658,
-0.9358313679695129,
0.20500309765338898,
0.46713724732398987,
0.1576421707868576,
-0.056326571851968765,
0.9892320036888123,
0.07226263731718063,
0.13903596997261047,
0.2865909934043884,
0.13250461220741272,
-0.3563564717769623,
-0.5915014147758484,
-0.5862540602684021,
0.06396706402301788,
0.5685742497444153,
-0.16365113854408264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07413v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07413v1
|
JetMoE: Reaching Llama2 Performance with 0.1M Dollars
| 2024-04-11T00:52:39 | 2024-04-11T00:52:39 |
Yikang Shen, Zhen Guo, Tianle Cai, Zengyi Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable results, but their
increasing resource demand has become a major obstacle to the development of
powerful and accessible super-human intelligence. This report introduces
JetMoE-8B, a new LLM trained with less than $0.1 million, using 1.25T tokens
from carefully mixed open-source corpora and 30,000 H100 GPU hours. Despite its
low cost, the JetMoE-8B demonstrates impressive performance, with JetMoE-8B
outperforming the Llama2-7B model and JetMoE-8B-Chat surpassing the
Llama2-13B-Chat model. These results suggest that LLM training can be much more
cost-effective than generally thought. JetMoE-8B is based on an efficient
Sparsely-gated Mixture-of-Experts (SMoE) architecture, composed of attention
and feedforward experts. Both layers are sparsely activated, allowing JetMoE-8B
to have 8B parameters while only activating 2B for each input token, reducing
inference computation by about 70% compared to Llama2-7B. Moreover, JetMoE-8B
is highly open and academia-friendly, using only public datasets and training
code. All training parameters and data mixtures have been detailed in this
report to facilitate future efforts in the development of open foundation
models. This transparency aims to encourage collaboration and further
advancements in the field of accessible and efficient LLMs. The model weights
are publicly available at https://github.com/myshell-ai/JetMoE.
|
[
-0.4024841785430908,
-0.4750101566314697,
0.27579429745674133,
0.3006291091442108,
-0.2604549825191498,
0.24321316182613373,
-0.20719213783740997,
-0.744019091129303,
0.03014027513563633,
0.7428328394889832,
-0.44293585419654846,
-0.21976788341999054,
-0.9757538437843323,
-0.13697367906570435,
-0.18188372254371643,
0.7464849352836609,
0.1658838391304016,
0.04295141249895096,
-0.06736454367637634,
-0.1711384505033493,
-0.23576043546199799,
-0.3716910183429718,
-0.7238208651542664,
-0.3086521625518799,
0.7590703964233398,
0.5134376287460327,
0.424172967672348,
0.8508723378181458,
0.5876710414886475,
0.25515803694725037,
-0.23836565017700195,
0.3554721474647522,
-0.8962222337722778,
-0.13665728271007538,
0.07319888472557068,
-0.5213223695755005,
-0.6569920182228088,
0.13097453117370605,
0.4187653064727783,
0.5445266366004944,
-0.21271802484989166,
0.22273162007331848,
-0.2399819791316986,
0.6152201294898987,
-0.6250156164169312,
0.2953476309776306,
-0.7128451466560364,
-0.2876654267311096,
-0.27789390087127686,
0.2212177813053131,
-0.5355612635612488,
0.1358548104763031,
-0.16834817826747894,
-0.5069488286972046,
-0.27382317185401917,
0.20699885487556458,
0.7812747359275818,
0.2730412483215332,
-0.41590824723243713,
-0.16686972975730896,
-0.518202006816864,
0.769504725933075,
-0.9442285895347595,
0.6504971981048584,
0.09798158705234528,
0.43730679154396057,
-0.38023194670677185,
-0.6974565982818604,
-0.35022228956222534,
-0.4342426061630249,
0.40672436356544495,
-0.034583527594804764,
-0.12164565920829773,
0.15687771141529083,
0.15424835681915283,
0.3429180681705475,
-0.4932214617729187,
0.48298215866088867,
-0.452065110206604,
0.1411060392856598,
0.6442568302154541,
0.041901346296072006,
0.05617707595229149,
0.1492283046245575,
-0.3500273823738098,
0.009177753701806068,
-0.8909409642219543,
-0.17116786539554596,
0.4051925539970398,
0.07706232368946075,
-0.15887275338172913,
0.5695061087608337,
-0.31279510259628296,
0.39718419313430786,
-0.1451384276151657,
-0.5750945210456848,
-0.012349528260529041,
-0.013492057099938393,
-0.3114808201789856,
-0.08193284273147583,
0.5884066820144653,
0.16971835494041443,
0.21637307107448578,
-0.4553251266479492,
-0.2944393455982208,
-0.18015141785144806,
-0.009305819869041443,
-1.1884849071502686,
-0.052294667810201645,
0.019146094098687172,
-0.40751171112060547,
-0.26578015089035034,
-0.1115022525191307,
-0.374616801738739,
-0.5532513856887817,
-0.12387838959693909,
0.36036217212677,
-0.20038267970085144,
-0.4072769284248352,
0.23829568922519684,
0.03198133409023285,
0.09889580309391022,
0.43407541513442993,
-0.9711628556251526,
0.441843181848526,
0.6700336337089539,
0.864666223526001,
-0.1524883508682251,
-0.21349363029003143,
-0.3367023766040802,
0.1869819313287735,
-0.335904598236084,
0.9263240098953247,
-0.4238854944705963,
-0.5391613245010376,
-0.42013153433799744,
-0.38448336720466614,
0.07473252713680267,
-0.8431643843650818,
0.3722124397754669,
-0.543274462223053,
0.13071076571941376,
-0.006606556009501219,
-0.7296165227890015,
-0.33865076303482056,
-0.027852395549416542,
-0.6916172504425049,
1.1229327917099,
0.25639957189559937,
-0.4933808743953705,
0.19551241397857666,
-0.8152176141738892,
-0.11957374960184097,
0.2278730273246765,
-0.2024325430393219,
-0.24029383063316345,
0.12215004116296768,
0.09556012600660324,
0.4533775746822357,
-0.6900336742401123,
0.2916801869869232,
-0.40443944931030273,
-0.6516331434249878,
0.07205061614513397,
-0.4194655418395996,
0.9596563577651978,
0.24704895913600922,
-0.4323987662792206,
-0.12437430024147034,
-0.7146776914596558,
-0.1835336834192276,
0.24812255799770355,
-0.6212659478187561,
0.2288413792848587,
-0.11362802982330322,
-0.09137409925460815,
0.04184553399682045,
0.4121374785900116,
-0.38632482290267944,
0.2401358187198639,
-0.5582353472709656,
0.3111973702907562,
0.7762406468391418,
-0.25989875197410583,
0.3620350956916809,
-0.15957903861999512,
0.4456404149532318,
0.02456957846879959,
0.17815259099006653,
-0.2202252894639969,
-0.6202777028083801,
-0.8585611581802368,
-0.7672172784805298,
0.301098108291626,
0.4501970410346985,
-0.2398921698331833,
0.27778851985931396,
-0.17120197415351868,
-0.5138252377510071,
-0.7791494727134705,
0.5643904209136963,
0.3233626186847687,
0.24476264417171478,
0.1802414357662201,
-0.09722498059272766,
-0.68113774061203,
-1.0405657291412354,
-0.09801934659481049,
-0.33077502250671387,
-0.02370545081794262,
0.5129714608192444,
0.4809079170227051,
-0.2857998311519623,
0.5649582743644714,
-0.26392602920532227,
0.11135910451412201,
-0.3920595049858093,
-0.008535867556929588,
0.05159309506416321,
0.3216189742088318,
0.5622429847717285,
-0.40724632143974304,
-0.2992684245109558,
0.27395811676979065,
-0.6931600570678711,
-0.15233248472213745,
0.3897857666015625,
-0.17304997146129608,
0.33791762590408325,
0.3847479820251465,
-0.7919131517410278,
-0.0004219022812321782,
0.738101601600647,
-0.04951663315296173,
0.1801127940416336,
0.13496243953704834,
-0.054377973079681396,
-1.1459040641784668,
0.1280994415283203,
-0.18151907622814178,
-0.13337665796279907,
-0.32787805795669556,
0.20184221863746643,
-0.0920245498418808,
-0.1041489914059639,
-0.6243028044700623,
0.8215408325195312,
-0.5872594118118286,
-0.06775089353322983,
-0.4595355987548828,
0.1693004071712494,
-0.16353149712085724,
0.5701690912246704,
-0.38456064462661743,
0.9296940565109253,
0.2867852747440338,
-0.20503799617290497,
0.3854754865169525,
-0.21178297698497772,
-0.5126800537109375,
0.006888776086270809,
-0.5146381855010986,
0.43271154165267944,
-0.0037482669577002525,
0.22941459715366364,
-0.7559285163879395,
-0.31675654649734497,
0.2397528737783432,
-0.36357396841049194,
0.2408771961927414,
-0.03632952272891998,
-0.32849305868148804,
-0.21202072501182556,
-0.21473529934883118,
0.27623891830444336,
0.6350352764129639,
-0.5120186805725098,
0.6342001557350159,
0.63029944896698,
-0.1394474357366562,
-0.6775573492050171,
-0.6487998366355896,
0.39302995800971985,
0.06246841326355934,
-0.6072502732276917,
0.036098722368478775,
-0.13377688825130463,
-0.231044739484787,
0.04871952906250954,
-0.15681329369544983,
-0.16497160494327545,
0.42194321751594543,
0.36481231451034546,
0.2961834669113159,
-0.4471645653247833,
-0.334216445684433,
-0.0316576324403286,
-0.15025441348552704,
0.096250019967556,
-0.40453821420669556,
0.40157392621040344,
-0.1068154126405716,
-0.23390774428844452,
-0.1923794001340866,
0.1465580016374588,
0.49165841937065125,
-0.18592077493667603,
0.8534379005432129,
0.5952693223953247,
-0.5307223796844482,
-0.20818409323692322,
-0.8327949643135071,
0.03225364536046982,
-0.49477824568748474,
0.676098108291626,
-0.29035934805870056,
-1.2231409549713135,
0.2365555763244629,
-0.15491990745067596,
0.25108057260513306,
0.3105776309967041,
0.8226875066757202,
0.06668666750192642,
1.0856053829193115,
0.603857696056366,
-0.2924085259437561,
0.44219088554382324,
-0.36486271023750305,
0.3053032159805298,
-0.5949265956878662,
-0.6434890627861023,
-0.43792062997817993,
-0.27353373169898987,
-0.4607866108417511,
-0.7179650068283081,
0.21341349184513092,
0.2337346225976944,
-0.31356146931648254,
0.12358242273330688,
-0.07750547677278519,
0.762360155582428,
0.5081243515014648,
-0.014913572929799557,
0.3558780550956726,
-0.04511675983667374,
0.206379234790802,
0.2717958688735962,
-0.7899415493011475,
-0.7386524677276611,
1.2170588970184326,
0.4769953191280365,
0.6629828214645386,
0.19431228935718536,
0.5593695044517517,
0.21657073497772217,
0.5581479668617249,
-0.730446457862854,
0.8017472624778748,
-0.05196499079465866,
-0.8152533173561096,
-0.06446611136198044,
-0.46867847442626953,
-0.6035309433937073,
0.24063807725906372,
-0.2054395228624344,
-0.6335731744766235,
-0.14230722188949585,
0.05784904584288597,
0.10083799809217453,
0.4325883686542511,
-0.8032764196395874,
0.76435786485672,
-0.31545811891555786,
-0.24364662170410156,
-0.49499598145484924,
-0.5266063809394836,
0.6412627696990967,
-0.005923845339566469,
-0.08565647900104523,
-0.6893612146377563,
-0.3786082863807678,
0.8713876605033875,
-0.135956808924675,
0.642068088054657,
-0.19768787920475006,
0.07362548261880875,
0.20672141015529633,
-0.02232419326901436,
0.5094342827796936,
-0.027757784351706505,
-0.1354837864637375,
0.427933007478714,
-0.5886159539222717,
-0.6970559358596802,
-0.6525390148162842,
0.8850076794624329,
-1.0579781532287598,
-0.7895288467407227,
-0.16456685960292816,
-0.7159783244132996,
-0.25419652462005615,
0.34378984570503235,
-0.018252497538924217,
0.25520622730255127,
-0.09232329577207565,
0.46426475048065186,
0.8197216987609863,
0.056243475526571274,
0.21530799567699432,
0.6861518621444702,
-0.2832932472229004,
-0.6339923143386841,
0.918006420135498,
0.2137301117181778,
0.20205463469028473,
0.550006091594696,
0.04549122601747513,
-0.24915184080600739,
-0.7608954906463623,
-0.6459157466888428,
0.40696436166763306,
-0.551966667175293,
-0.2670661509037018,
-0.6353949308395386,
-0.37593334913253784,
-0.38537994027137756,
-0.11278606206178665,
-0.5972256064414978,
-0.5596131682395935,
-0.29194948077201843,
-0.26319608092308044,
0.22752788662910461,
0.9473500847816467,
0.16504047811031342,
0.5231022238731384,
-0.3382349908351898,
-0.041242435574531555,
0.25501230359077454,
0.24856802821159363,
0.038736484944820404,
-0.6724132299423218,
-0.7182474732398987,
0.03025798872113228,
-0.3570064604282379,
-0.46222442388534546,
0.08819480985403061,
-0.04603619873523712,
0.6802550554275513,
0.6672977805137634,
-0.40337443351745605,
0.6290842294692993,
-0.3138408362865448,
0.6107595562934875,
0.13743288815021515,
-0.7827808260917664,
0.14321480691432953,
-0.39495858550071716,
-0.015301655977964401,
0.3626161217689514,
0.3438081741333008,
-0.22692300379276276,
-0.5321841239929199,
-0.5993441343307495,
-0.584930956363678,
0.7591862082481384,
-0.012757874093949795,
0.038673579692840576,
0.10859224945306778,
0.4792645573616028,
0.19766820967197418,
0.336581826210022,
-0.6598408818244934,
-0.2551771402359009,
-0.08119142055511475,
-0.30215317010879517,
-0.02750985696911812,
-0.4752623438835144,
-0.006683338899165392,
-0.08256073296070099,
0.8305188417434692,
-0.05862300843000412,
0.33002209663391113,
-0.3297407925128937,
-0.0614384189248085,
-0.05166437849402428,
-0.009328523650765419,
0.7033002972602844,
0.5614299178123474,
-0.407951682806015,
0.09655988961458206,
0.3898727297782898,
-0.41174885630607605,
0.27916598320007324,
0.10481264442205429,
0.03510579839348793,
-0.2921160161495209,
0.4901163578033447,
1.0791306495666504,
0.3772920072078705,
-1.0634214878082275,
0.5494709610939026,
0.243061363697052,
-0.3734189569950104,
0.12611646950244904,
0.4598963260650635,
0.5043596625328064,
0.4195960462093353,
0.11355960369110107,
-0.04315964877605438,
0.1836409568786621,
-0.26428675651550293,
-0.1311779022216797,
0.38194552063941956,
-0.0004113929462619126,
-0.17797477543354034,
0.9393092393875122,
0.45298901200294495,
-0.21543745696544647,
0.4509645998477936,
-0.11423226445913315,
-0.2370944321155548,
0.5677556991577148,
0.6495169401168823,
0.8262112736701965,
-0.17049849033355713,
-0.07242047041654587,
-0.034758057445287704,
0.4624481201171875,
-0.17245425283908844,
0.0858626589179039,
0.20464636385440826,
-0.5622784495353699,
-0.5706210732460022,
-0.42213332653045654,
-0.8609901666641235,
0.1527508795261383,
-0.32772335410118103,
0.34479770064353943,
-0.7696280479431152,
0.06881169229745865,
-0.25212353467941284,
0.45221370458602905,
-0.46303170919418335,
0.2233513742685318,
0.33915773034095764,
1.2544113397598267,
-0.5702615976333618,
0.9521430730819702,
0.7746642827987671,
-0.36267581582069397,
-0.8048940300941467,
-0.49540942907333374,
-0.12691667675971985,
-1.2075068950653076,
0.5531625151634216,
0.30817967653274536,
-0.31498855352401733,
0.17572002112865448,
-0.402574360370636,
-0.7763521671295166,
1.266579508781433,
0.9910594820976257,
-0.7150555849075317,
-0.21818052232265472,
0.012669581919908524,
0.14589901268482208,
-0.3897252082824707,
0.626478910446167,
0.4748973846435547,
0.3715912699699402,
-0.024956192821264267,
-0.7244261503219604,
-0.2033618986606598,
-0.2797989547252655,
0.12413547933101654,
0.2197955995798111,
-1.1993542909622192,
0.7930728197097778,
-0.2519145905971527,
0.029717721045017242,
-0.027183732017874718,
0.8675312399864197,
0.2843020260334015,
0.2095656394958496,
0.3822942078113556,
0.6735879182815552,
0.8718564510345459,
0.15809784829616547,
0.8564337491989136,
-0.47727400064468384,
0.18934893608093262,
0.7018661499023438,
-0.41900622844696045,
0.9655447006225586,
0.24088574945926666,
-0.15422983467578888,
0.5767046213150024,
0.5521876811981201,
0.16204993426799774,
0.3662625849246979,
-0.04597204178571701,
-0.595973014831543,
-0.3099846839904785,
-0.3321528434753418,
-0.18187215924263,
0.30985718965530396,
0.05971131473779678,
-0.15000556409358978,
0.041373979300260544,
-0.18748411536216736,
0.2767244577407837,
-0.27608436346054077,
-0.22530052065849304,
0.7949581146240234,
0.32426121830940247,
-0.32572126388549805,
0.5669838190078735,
0.2128075808286667,
0.4676724672317505,
-0.7060064673423767,
0.13430500030517578,
-0.5116140842437744,
0.19982431828975677,
-0.06920115649700165,
-0.31468498706817627,
-0.07647310942411423,
0.150035098195076,
-0.14946675300598145,
0.046910833567380905,
0.6506069302558899,
-0.2884014844894409,
-0.6000098586082458,
0.4503609538078308,
0.48894253373146057,
0.23663507401943207,
0.06890629231929779,
-0.5062332153320312,
0.357927143573761,
-0.029859164729714394,
-0.5506604909896851,
0.5290583372116089,
0.35794371366500854,
0.10549602657556534,
0.954048216342926,
0.5455154180526733,
0.17600440979003906,
0.18886087834835052,
-0.1274815797805786,
1.0194844007492065,
-0.6239393353462219,
-0.2674928903579712,
-0.7224923968315125,
0.33767130970954895,
0.02908707782626152,
-0.36261168122291565,
0.6078370809555054,
0.7991741895675659,
0.954120397567749,
0.16696585714817047,
0.7971086502075195,
0.25171974301338196,
0.39143046736717224,
-0.5810012817382812,
0.43207812309265137,
-0.6270164847373962,
0.2963273823261261,
0.3163631856441498,
-0.8315504193305969,
-0.11596355587244034,
0.48219728469848633,
-0.11356747150421143,
0.1577364057302475,
0.4927879571914673,
1.0819584131240845,
-0.02861161343753338,
0.050697240978479385,
0.42959585785865784,
0.30379748344421387,
0.4012306034564972,
0.7128140330314636,
0.7532239556312561,
-0.35372936725616455,
0.7314982414245605,
-0.1957455426454544,
-0.18250101804733276,
-0.6096108555793762,
-0.7431450486183167,
-1.0171128511428833,
-0.010999277234077454,
-0.09152389317750931,
-0.16489753127098083,
0.39436569809913635,
1.278612494468689,
0.9506108164787292,
-0.7047695517539978,
-0.6123284101486206,
0.11123724281787872,
0.13004517555236816,
-0.06896433234214783,
-0.14375457167625427,
-0.06629956513643265,
-0.09902949631214142,
-0.8984566926956177,
0.7990505695343018,
0.5829029679298401,
0.04178057983517647,
-0.5507314801216125,
-0.40892353653907776,
-0.030390840023756027,
0.36817991733551025,
0.5802696347236633,
0.13095098733901978,
-0.8137538433074951,
0.093141108751297,
0.024013860151171684,
-0.3140295445919037,
0.18477672338485718,
0.7062045335769653,
-0.5360244512557983,
0.08899630606174469,
0.2749289870262146,
1.064379334449768,
0.6756557822227478,
-0.17008432745933533,
0.33055582642555237,
-0.33146145939826965,
0.4502865970134735,
0.12166249752044678,
0.29051539301872253,
0.22617460787296295,
-0.2366609275341034,
0.511268138885498,
0.4638192355632782,
-0.7223271131515503,
-1.0261691808700562,
-0.07938701659440994,
-0.9799305200576782,
-0.22549986839294434,
0.9796660542488098,
-0.06270522624254227,
-0.2765163481235504,
0.2531253397464752,
-0.3822034001350403,
0.1269272267818451,
-0.5817402601242065,
0.6264898180961609,
0.6446097493171692,
-0.13258470594882965,
-0.2886127531528473,
-0.7537409663200378,
-0.02591896243393421,
0.3291226029396057,
-0.8832148313522339,
-0.17001307010650635,
0.4468504786491394,
0.27436092495918274,
-0.4363568425178528,
0.743762195110321,
0.1580430120229721,
0.24264253675937653,
0.3663618862628937,
0.3155222535133362,
-0.6630662679672241,
-0.5592679381370544,
0.013852208852767944,
0.16451933979988098,
0.5762646794319153,
-0.05260460078716278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08018v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08018v1
|
Analyzing the Performance of Large Language Models on Code Summarization
| 2024-04-10T22:42:18 | 2024-04-10T22:42:18 |
Rajarshi Haldar, Julia Hockenmaier
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) such as Llama 2 perform very well on tasks that
involve both natural language and source code, particularly code summarization
and code generation. We show that for the task of code summarization, the
performance of these models on individual examples often depends on the amount
of (subword) token overlap between the code and the corresponding reference
natural language descriptions in the dataset. This token overlap arises because
the reference descriptions in standard datasets (corresponding to docstrings in
large code bases) are often highly similar to the names of the functions they
describe. We also show that this token overlap occurs largely in the function
names of the code and compare the relative performance of these models after
removing function names versus removing code structure. We also show that using
multiple evaluation metrics like BLEU and BERTScore gives us very little
additional insight since these metrics are highly correlated with each other.
|
[
-0.2863200604915619,
-0.5187835693359375,
0.3184260129928589,
0.4317286014556885,
-0.4846729636192322,
0.40716469287872314,
-0.2781570851802826,
-0.8537755012512207,
0.11553826928138733,
0.3627490699291229,
-0.07676044851541519,
-0.39851194620132446,
-0.6982026696205139,
0.15880103409290314,
-0.6282175779342651,
0.9665318131446838,
-0.1033240556716919,
-0.01755080185830593,
-0.46898072957992554,
-0.12778960168361664,
-0.26079803705215454,
-0.7949507832527161,
-0.15206310153007507,
-0.39334458112716675,
0.39306867122650146,
0.12149962037801743,
0.6582468152046204,
0.7685188055038452,
0.9929021000862122,
0.3178587555885315,
-0.4297987222671509,
0.17651261389255524,
-0.6620264053344727,
0.005608958657830954,
0.038260821253061295,
-0.6020593047142029,
-0.624079167842865,
-0.4131236672401428,
0.7519465684890747,
0.6604521870613098,
0.1475220024585724,
0.4336819648742676,
0.04914475604891777,
0.565367579460144,
-0.46067437529563904,
0.23585839569568634,
-0.5332834124565125,
-0.1268043965101242,
-0.1824478805065155,
-0.18167166411876678,
-0.05625146999955177,
-0.48062700033187866,
-0.002066780813038349,
-0.2068031281232834,
0.03886657580733299,
-0.11094324290752411,
0.7243101000785828,
0.37518197298049927,
-0.23989084362983704,
-0.39440563321113586,
-0.6804143190383911,
0.8370686173439026,
-1.0729013681411743,
-0.035986095666885376,
0.12900099158287048,
-0.0008423883118666708,
-0.13761262595653534,
-0.6214063763618469,
-0.5479846000671387,
-0.31866350769996643,
-0.29899242520332336,
-0.10242448002099991,
-0.5593782663345337,
0.11467154324054718,
0.4611743092536926,
0.6037098169326782,
-0.5273826718330383,
0.4850543141365051,
-0.6818190217018127,
-0.1854507327079773,
0.6853883862495422,
0.4184677302837372,
0.22592546045780182,
-0.1218959391117096,
-0.21322563290596008,
0.36569175124168396,
-0.7989084124565125,
0.014955149032175541,
0.4919729232788086,
0.06559697538614273,
-0.35705462098121643,
0.8694297075271606,
-0.07337860018014908,
0.7714614868164062,
-0.5528993606567383,
-0.3866674602031708,
0.3327714204788208,
-0.6356474161148071,
-0.3642789125442505,
-0.043776072561740875,
0.565402626991272,
0.46207961440086365,
0.5621471405029297,
-0.3302038311958313,
-0.2984490692615509,
0.14849551022052765,
0.12921278178691864,
-0.9379692673683167,
-0.11024437099695206,
0.3556792438030243,
-0.6740439534187317,
-0.2398555427789688,
0.047308266162872314,
-0.4517775774002075,
-0.3281514346599579,
-0.515804648399353,
-0.03268151357769966,
-0.027104342356324196,
-0.25688591599464417,
-0.0071958573535084724,
-0.2224327176809311,
0.25895094871520996,
-0.012320347130298615,
-0.6721844673156738,
0.45247477293014526,
1.0923444032669067,
1.0150718688964844,
-0.3967353403568268,
-0.38741374015808105,
-0.5568345189094543,
-0.002866277936846018,
-0.3755296766757965,
0.6999839544296265,
-0.6511402130126953,
-0.6560351848602295,
-0.15666413307189941,
-0.17944644391536713,
0.052237510681152344,
-0.8208615779876709,
0.0800614133477211,
-0.5246331095695496,
-0.34682944416999817,
-0.2540493905544281,
-0.7426083087921143,
-0.15031300485134125,
-0.10288884490728378,
-0.7814956307411194,
1.0553181171417236,
0.1480770707130432,
-0.7835177183151245,
0.2242318093776703,
-0.5689499974250793,
-0.7464324831962585,
-0.08805307745933533,
-0.19987516105175018,
-0.3018634021282196,
0.5510004758834839,
0.02609127201139927,
0.5569181442260742,
-0.466716468334198,
0.22122785449028015,
0.027438517659902573,
-0.8480376601219177,
0.39806437492370605,
-0.08474449813365936,
0.3382895588874817,
0.26416370272636414,
-0.29634761810302734,
0.21775388717651367,
-0.9002998471260071,
-0.07077156007289886,
0.013120083138346672,
-0.5480202436447144,
-0.459622859954834,
0.02530788630247116,
0.06812436878681183,
-0.046563770622015,
0.37264689803123474,
-0.07459983229637146,
0.35384440422058105,
-0.2799037992954254,
0.48041221499443054,
0.5755293965339661,
-0.09591972827911377,
0.1735018938779831,
-0.35942187905311584,
0.7897420525550842,
0.02007094770669937,
-0.10269753634929657,
-0.5166094303131104,
-0.456405371427536,
-0.7385089993476868,
-0.4725365936756134,
0.38088157773017883,
0.43140289187431335,
-0.40609100461006165,
0.18848742544651031,
-0.5289745926856995,
-0.5371420979499817,
-0.3675052523612976,
0.4064774811267853,
0.7596294283866882,
0.19989170134067535,
0.16554686427116394,
-0.3997255563735962,
-0.7979589700698853,
-1.1305712461471558,
-0.2547362446784973,
-0.24604621529579163,
-0.044857416301965714,
0.17593124508857727,
0.675588071346283,
-0.1694621443748474,
0.968793511390686,
-0.41921380162239075,
0.2671235203742981,
-0.375305712223053,
0.06519138067960739,
0.48705577850341797,
0.2242116630077362,
0.5961176753044128,
-0.4940056800842285,
-0.24939733743667603,
0.04741578921675682,
-0.7302061319351196,
-0.4755590856075287,
-0.04984043911099434,
0.1958945393562317,
0.2893747389316559,
0.5813455581665039,
-0.32396841049194336,
0.25635412335395813,
0.732235312461853,
-0.15786096453666687,
0.7724400162696838,
-0.2433285415172577,
-0.024907967075705528,
-0.8327475786209106,
0.372976690530777,
-0.21180927753448486,
0.007970995269715786,
-0.6650857925415039,
0.2724530100822449,
0.09374367445707321,
0.22366423904895782,
-0.3995656967163086,
0.33663472533226013,
-0.682971179485321,
-0.719893753528595,
-0.31278568506240845,
0.17891769111156464,
-0.11468435078859329,
0.3232235908508301,
-0.23675581812858582,
1.268152117729187,
0.48240169882774353,
-0.6968820691108704,
0.22796863317489624,
-0.05043938755989075,
-0.8504548668861389,
0.12288083881139755,
-1.0497698783874512,
0.15090680122375488,
0.13074615597724915,
0.13205094635486603,
-1.1376323699951172,
-0.057144489139318466,
-0.3007577061653137,
-0.2860831022262573,
0.1424981653690338,
-0.19188986718654633,
-0.7501632571220398,
-0.2860032916069031,
-0.31629934906959534,
0.5945459604263306,
0.47585156559944153,
-0.4782359004020691,
0.28948265314102173,
0.3975394666194916,
-0.24560579657554626,
-0.7246941924095154,
-1.0126121044158936,
0.2800770401954651,
-0.32235953211784363,
-0.4798165261745453,
0.23849183320999146,
0.18936194479465485,
-0.5995508432388306,
0.016978634521365166,
-0.10693499445915222,
0.1063031554222107,
0.32838723063468933,
0.3542666733264923,
0.37732452154159546,
-0.3617623448371887,
0.3389277458190918,
-0.04649268835783005,
-0.015254665166139603,
-0.047836340963840485,
0.022490521892905235,
0.6917154788970947,
-0.13234882056713104,
-0.293742835521698,
-0.11287476122379303,
0.16706527769565582,
0.6889719367027283,
-0.470988929271698,
0.7299480438232422,
0.2359829843044281,
-0.0483635812997818,
0.05198916420340538,
-0.5441436171531677,
0.40514880418777466,
-0.4089542031288147,
0.6965660452842712,
-0.42529061436653137,
-0.9398159980773926,
0.9896653890609741,
0.22594602406024933,
0.22631120681762695,
0.3783248960971832,
0.759088397026062,
0.24056871235370636,
0.6883023977279663,
0.5529587864875793,
-0.41855692863464355,
0.43635401129722595,
-0.362628698348999,
0.22744953632354736,
-0.8612925410270691,
-0.13818293809890747,
-0.5548607707023621,
-0.33765849471092224,
-0.45231884717941284,
-0.792432427406311,
-0.004454528912901878,
0.33170652389526367,
0.0708140954375267,
0.5363267660140991,
-0.3352962136268616,
0.6969903707504272,
0.31662794947624207,
-0.5946680307388306,
0.6667848825454712,
0.16858841478824615,
-0.03127822279930115,
0.20625989139080048,
-0.6026003956794739,
-0.6084004640579224,
1.2252594232559204,
0.431477814912796,
0.8048580884933472,
0.29313942790031433,
0.6332104206085205,
0.21170516312122345,
0.29892033338546753,
-0.6504492163658142,
0.45475539565086365,
-0.21163631975650787,
-0.2774142622947693,
0.004716656170785427,
-0.5535424947738647,
-0.8468721508979797,
0.4480895698070526,
0.11976974457502365,
-0.641505241394043,
-0.1258968561887741,
-0.06891520321369171,
-0.21490123867988586,
0.32629987597465515,
-0.7831963300704956,
0.33767077326774597,
-0.22566336393356323,
-0.10542558133602142,
-0.4558749198913574,
-0.37943166494369507,
0.544533908367157,
-0.1620797961950302,
0.3345901668071747,
-0.0429607518017292,
-0.3382185697555542,
0.805976390838623,
-0.3191013038158417,
0.6636114716529846,
0.1542222797870636,
-0.3479892909526825,
0.26587823033332825,
0.06457769125699997,
0.3651059567928314,
-0.1337367594242096,
-0.09976007789373398,
0.5780956745147705,
-0.0018333916086703539,
-0.3230130076408386,
-0.3930607736110687,
0.7600173354148865,
-0.5212215185165405,
-0.34715938568115234,
-0.07371405512094498,
-0.5699484944343567,
0.025017911568284035,
-0.05860835686326027,
0.14720866084098816,
0.658010721206665,
-0.04833880439400673,
0.06734368205070496,
0.30455416440963745,
-0.5001915693283081,
0.6503739953041077,
0.467372864484787,
-0.3966897130012512,
-0.22027967870235443,
0.7441189289093018,
0.18606334924697876,
0.37450310587882996,
0.3348005712032318,
-0.14331290125846863,
-0.06346399337053299,
-0.7572153806686401,
-0.3818301558494568,
0.4207841157913208,
-0.6637434959411621,
-0.22298529744148254,
-0.5730833411216736,
-0.10563245415687561,
-0.18481899797916412,
-0.06563791632652283,
-0.06822451204061508,
-0.7566075325012207,
-0.05648341029882431,
-0.1870047152042389,
0.30238309502601624,
1.0893292427062988,
0.2696726322174072,
0.5204657912254333,
-0.9917768836021423,
0.21599853038787842,
-0.06074737384915352,
0.5882174372673035,
0.4306769371032715,
-0.46762025356292725,
-0.6107422709465027,
-0.3461490273475647,
-0.05561574548482895,
-0.5529109835624695,
0.10198267549276352,
-0.002673858543857932,
0.7264471054077148,
0.3730171024799347,
-0.3538617789745331,
0.8272437453269958,
-0.3351101577281952,
0.9535152912139893,
0.1964869201183319,
-1.1022558212280273,
0.07635405659675598,
-0.1329023689031601,
0.6161437630653381,
0.26109156012535095,
-0.03070652298629284,
-0.5441702008247375,
-0.599513828754425,
-0.22501033544540405,
-0.9895616173744202,
0.6145288348197937,
0.42416322231292725,
0.2385404109954834,
-0.029836192727088928,
0.25772494077682495,
0.03971686214208603,
0.3519991636276245,
-0.5362957119941711,
-0.34881719946861267,
0.34579068422317505,
-0.02765262871980667,
-0.11896897107362747,
-0.5999647378921509,
-0.2146301120519638,
-0.12572355568408966,
0.21808652579784393,
-0.0046440414153039455,
0.3707691729068756,
-0.057018015533685684,
-0.30055299401283264,
-0.04313137009739876,
0.14477384090423584,
0.9518851637840271,
1.1238348484039307,
0.1077122837305069,
0.06471526622772217,
0.2707779109477997,
-0.3715430200099945,
-0.25936999917030334,
-0.08294766396284103,
0.380301833152771,
0.08137685805559158,
1.2003344297409058,
0.6083240509033203,
0.3847074508666992,
-1.0227653980255127,
0.34569165110588074,
-0.05861663818359375,
0.03563114255666733,
-0.03484993800520897,
0.13937774300575256,
0.22859624028205872,
0.2735869884490967,
0.43319785594940186,
-0.21453824639320374,
0.17600780725479126,
-0.5833841562271118,
0.09360868483781815,
0.3550976812839508,
0.09907738864421844,
-0.2138098180294037,
0.3831731081008911,
0.2415061593055725,
-0.2615041732788086,
0.51063472032547,
0.11220862716436386,
-0.7506335973739624,
1.2336537837982178,
0.4101647436618805,
0.7456300854682922,
0.13247907161712646,
-0.26942914724349976,
0.2343599796295166,
0.35441750288009644,
0.10333393514156342,
0.15687295794487,
-0.23300233483314514,
-0.2548856735229492,
-0.8706744909286499,
-0.6542447805404663,
-0.25912314653396606,
-0.09772410243749619,
-0.5613964796066284,
0.0917285904288292,
-0.2848131060600281,
-0.04362177103757858,
-0.03186192736029625,
-0.08651762455701828,
-0.5400103330612183,
-0.15734945237636566,
0.19610477983951569,
1.0220471620559692,
-0.6059070229530334,
0.7603231072425842,
0.538066029548645,
-0.29078295826911926,
-0.744868278503418,
-0.034838274121284485,
-0.15882913768291473,
-0.7554789781570435,
0.7759783864021301,
0.24266771972179413,
-0.22462518513202667,
-0.43468406796455383,
-0.1933618038892746,
-0.9925544857978821,
1.0582754611968994,
0.23800845444202423,
-0.7713190317153931,
-0.1512233167886734,
0.11056823283433914,
0.8585358262062073,
-0.39358991384506226,
0.36926281452178955,
0.8403664827346802,
0.33760711550712585,
-0.11035618931055069,
-1.3249151706695557,
-0.06677276641130447,
-0.3481638729572296,
0.26720568537712097,
0.33969756960868835,
-0.7766081690788269,
0.7423665523529053,
-0.44754651188850403,
-0.2411508709192276,
0.2860763967037201,
0.45018813014030457,
0.19284947216510773,
0.2705570161342621,
0.2889978885650635,
0.33005326986312866,
0.6957385540008545,
-0.04141313582658768,
1.3587201833724976,
-0.49803441762924194,
0.4443804919719696,
1.1027218103408813,
-0.16287019848823547,
0.7560892105102539,
0.45163694024086,
-0.5843032002449036,
0.3739852011203766,
0.4116191565990448,
-0.2874854505062103,
0.20021642744541168,
0.4990302622318268,
0.07661300152540207,
0.058178070932626724,
0.1850261688232422,
-0.5355628132820129,
0.5378113985061646,
0.21847808361053467,
-0.5714272260665894,
-0.15264438092708588,
-0.44378164410591125,
-0.008943980559706688,
-0.0024660977069288492,
-0.23032130300998688,
0.7148482799530029,
0.13733233511447906,
-0.7375558614730835,
0.6672722697257996,
0.16461734473705292,
0.7003546953201294,
-0.5309506058692932,
-0.010034486651420593,
-0.47756317257881165,
0.08350786566734314,
-0.4285429120063782,
-0.637166440486908,
0.5444838404655457,
0.30644986033439636,
-0.1639011800289154,
0.20398767292499542,
0.2722621262073517,
-0.1061324030160904,
-0.4433453679084778,
0.5766378045082092,
0.30005791783332825,
0.35639137029647827,
0.3233473002910614,
-0.32868054509162903,
0.356069952249527,
-0.08821908384561539,
-0.20296551287174225,
0.30422142148017883,
0.11053024977445602,
-0.11901258677244186,
0.7573593258857727,
0.6513840556144714,
0.247909814119339,
0.23098820447921753,
0.3405352234840393,
0.9620635509490967,
-0.552498459815979,
-0.4975026249885559,
-1.1183339357376099,
0.30581408739089966,
-0.09285620599985123,
-0.3195285201072693,
0.8078317046165466,
1.011997103691101,
0.6920037865638733,
-0.09428588300943375,
0.6632835268974304,
-0.0004165857098996639,
0.32580849528312683,
-0.7436239123344421,
0.533075213432312,
-0.5206215977668762,
0.8364670276641846,
-0.4593007266521454,
-1.3331340551376343,
-0.26098930835723877,
0.29550471901893616,
-0.201743945479393,
0.045259300619363785,
0.5707533359527588,
0.9161979556083679,
0.013506893068552017,
-0.20583300292491913,
0.35858482122421265,
0.3387852907180786,
0.38979384303092957,
0.5802645683288574,
0.9224684834480286,
-0.16974100470542908,
0.587628185749054,
0.04375236853957176,
-0.07462332397699356,
-0.4386143386363983,
-0.9337537884712219,
-0.8972553014755249,
-0.3179965913295746,
-0.06450359523296356,
-0.052228886634111404,
-0.10891154408454895,
0.7424496412277222,
0.5832458138465881,
-0.8451595306396484,
-0.47217243909835815,
0.11912956833839417,
0.29785144329071045,
-0.16471363604068756,
-0.19370409846305847,
0.3940522074699402,
-0.20863044261932373,
-0.8543245792388916,
0.1952243596315384,
0.3996569514274597,
-0.12419559806585312,
-0.36216792464256287,
-0.13391152024269104,
0.12477852404117584,
0.2044360637664795,
0.598122239112854,
0.04357023537158966,
-0.9115846753120422,
0.10604682564735413,
-0.04266161844134331,
-0.15973159670829773,
-0.06272344291210175,
1.2673486471176147,
-0.7350252270698547,
0.30159977078437805,
0.5686527490615845,
0.6734805107116699,
0.32323309779167175,
0.2637638747692108,
0.5344966650009155,
-0.7086913585662842,
0.13785095512866974,
-0.25605466961860657,
0.3997138440608978,
0.29108038544654846,
-0.3087439239025116,
0.733420193195343,
-0.10072041302919388,
-0.5159980058670044,
-1.0520466566085815,
0.13431735336780548,
-0.9753881692886353,
-0.4025515913963318,
1.367844820022583,
-0.2078617811203003,
0.07548797130584717,
-0.06366781890392303,
-0.1008378267288208,
0.07343676686286926,
-0.1788547784090042,
0.6880083680152893,
0.8380932211875916,
-0.2280317097902298,
0.14454178512096405,
-0.5901857614517212,
0.1525231897830963,
0.38163214921951294,
-0.5944123864173889,
0.23300299048423767,
0.5056098699569702,
0.3099631369113922,
0.15959703922271729,
0.4781074821949005,
-0.2935880124568939,
0.3235514163970947,
-0.04545704647898674,
-0.03441721200942993,
-0.4666433334350586,
-0.1296657770872116,
-0.7125980854034424,
-0.00041960948146879673,
0.3039194345474243,
0.08088815957307816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07377v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07377v1
|
Deep Generative Sampling in the Dual Divergence Space: A Data-efficient & Interpretative Approach for Generative AI
| 2024-04-10T22:35:06 | 2024-04-10T22:35:06 |
Sahil Garg, Anderson Schneider, Anant Raj, Kashif Rasul, Yuriy Nevmyvaka, Sneihil Gopal, Amit Dhurandhar, Guillermo Cecchi, Irina Rish
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.IT, math.IT
|
Building on the remarkable achievements in generative sampling of natural
images, we propose an innovative challenge, potentially overly ambitious, which
involves generating samples of entire multivariate time series that resemble
images. However, the statistical challenge lies in the small sample size,
sometimes consisting of a few hundred subjects. This issue is especially
problematic for deep generative models that follow the conventional approach of
generating samples from a canonical distribution and then decoding or denoising
them to match the true data distribution. In contrast, our method is grounded
in information theory and aims to implicitly characterize the distribution of
images, particularly the (global and local) dependency structure between
pixels. We achieve this by empirically estimating its KL-divergence in the dual
form with respect to the respective marginal distribution. This enables us to
perform generative sampling directly in the optimized 1-D dual divergence
space. Specifically, in the dual space, training samples representing the data
distribution are embedded in the form of various clusters between two end
points. In theory, any sample embedded between those two end points is
in-distribution w.r.t. the data distribution. Our key idea for generating novel
samples of images is to interpolate between the clusters via a walk as per
gradients of the dual function w.r.t. the data dimensions. In addition to the
data efficiency gained from direct sampling, we propose an algorithm that
offers a significant reduction in sample complexity for estimating the
divergence of the data distribution with respect to the marginal distribution.
We provide strong theoretical guarantees along with an extensive empirical
evaluation using many real-world datasets from diverse domains, establishing
the superiority of our approach w.r.t. state-of-the-art deep learning methods.
|
[
-0.44768285751342773,
-0.5474722385406494,
0.38768282532691956,
0.07824506610631943,
-0.33486947417259216,
0.30361196398735046,
-0.13212907314300537,
-0.3843192160129547,
0.15426549315452576,
0.10515737533569336,
-0.7425506711006165,
-0.5288131237030029,
-0.3336685299873352,
-0.30269309878349304,
-0.28197160363197327,
0.5184490084648132,
0.10376033186912537,
0.19885993003845215,
-0.3351200222969055,
-0.25625231862068176,
-0.2197641283273697,
-0.20392008125782013,
-0.619799792766571,
-0.0454234816133976,
0.42752575874328613,
0.187980517745018,
0.563285231590271,
0.2555506229400635,
0.7157771587371826,
0.15892304480075836,
-0.009976287372410297,
0.15120534598827362,
-0.5044294595718384,
0.10201139748096466,
0.15814335644245148,
-0.5272853970527649,
0.0957377627491951,
-0.07136207818984985,
0.8198469281196594,
1.0272176265716553,
-0.05568154528737068,
0.08585624396800995,
0.0224651750177145,
1.0548590421676636,
-0.6474951505661011,
0.09302110970020294,
-0.17468439042568207,
0.5992575287818909,
-0.4139750599861145,
-0.16999459266662598,
-0.09266052395105362,
-0.35737138986587524,
0.0161502156406641,
-0.5941756367683411,
0.8895316123962402,
-0.4333965480327606,
0.38020059466362,
0.5604697465896606,
-0.542822003364563,
-0.14647559821605682,
-1.2602258920669556,
0.6695658564567566,
-0.2832847833633423,
0.06913328915834427,
0.16697461903095245,
0.7339836955070496,
0.15649519860744476,
-0.6232708096504211,
-0.6025533080101013,
-0.3902845084667206,
0.22884680330753326,
0.2842246890068054,
0.011883700266480446,
-0.15195491909980774,
0.21450471878051758,
0.8834289908409119,
-0.39068710803985596,
0.21835452318191528,
-0.39662858843803406,
0.11472879350185394,
0.781620979309082,
0.32136183977127075,
0.23739205300807953,
0.23634064197540283,
-0.453125,
-0.5430864095687866,
-0.7840840220451355,
0.06395481526851654,
0.7872475385665894,
0.15243516862392426,
-0.38516154885292053,
0.4746176600456238,
-0.0726146325469017,
0.26140740513801575,
-0.12111861258745193,
0.2217666506767273,
0.3179837167263031,
-0.48559021949768066,
-0.17409299314022064,
-0.3814300000667572,
0.7113111019134521,
0.17550159990787506,
0.006180695258080959,
0.039713259786367416,
-0.02295531891286373,
0.13477163016796112,
0.1428581029176712,
-0.8404908180236816,
-0.5336516499519348,
0.16568171977996826,
-0.5757017731666565,
-0.37884005904197693,
0.22391045093536377,
-1.228477120399475,
-0.6339705586433411,
-0.3602391481399536,
0.08726334571838379,
-0.23983557522296906,
-0.534759521484375,
0.0134409349411726,
-0.26710185408592224,
0.15665382146835327,
0.3377213180065155,
-0.6946514844894409,
0.2407602220773697,
0.18913830816745758,
0.8224769830703735,
-0.11494152992963791,
-0.030210789293050766,
-0.07012726366519928,
-0.004905125126242638,
-0.575029194355011,
0.794920802116394,
-0.4145382344722748,
-0.4919320046901703,
0.02011352777481079,
-0.40961140394210815,
0.19762663543224335,
-0.629023551940918,
0.4287843406200409,
-0.5484564304351807,
-0.16751788556575775,
-0.17574593424797058,
-0.5033440589904785,
-0.04800697788596153,
0.07544185221195221,
-0.9253519177436829,
0.7375428676605225,
0.15887103974819183,
-0.6534966826438904,
0.7124478220939636,
-0.8237070441246033,
-0.31643128395080566,
0.2133479118347168,
-0.4838187098503113,
-0.45970794558525085,
0.1714298129081726,
0.4120463728904724,
0.3822573125362396,
-0.33456164598464966,
-0.058005087077617645,
-0.6972566843032837,
-0.11958353221416473,
0.07278526574373245,
-0.7590818405151367,
0.8302424550056458,
0.3677809536457062,
-0.15818719565868378,
-0.12957987189292908,
-0.6317862272262573,
-0.052366241812705994,
0.33986061811447144,
-0.18684124946594238,
-0.30206847190856934,
-0.02740105800330639,
0.15868079662322998,
-0.17148441076278687,
-0.1798897683620453,
-0.4328772723674774,
0.5229927897453308,
-0.005399623885750771,
0.2390461564064026,
0.7924933433532715,
0.25641709566116333,
0.6500545740127563,
-0.09456530958414078,
0.6907950639724731,
0.23533852398395538,
0.19509665668010712,
-0.160087451338768,
-0.3280673623085022,
-0.2629808485507965,
-0.6850096583366394,
0.5295050144195557,
0.31896549463272095,
-0.6892035603523254,
0.5111845135688782,
-0.4260762929916382,
-0.5232877135276794,
-0.4806780517101288,
-0.010291827842593193,
0.0434904471039772,
0.1818474680185318,
0.2716839015483856,
-0.38803330063819885,
-0.2789831757545471,
-0.8099278807640076,
0.2533736824989319,
0.1996879279613495,
-0.056543149054050446,
0.2691640257835388,
0.5276161432266235,
-0.36365458369255066,
0.7880611419677734,
-0.7258347272872925,
-0.2138969749212265,
0.030792679637670517,
0.21934786438941956,
0.15059074759483337,
0.546839714050293,
0.7443757653236389,
-1.1750675439834595,
-0.646903932094574,
-0.2563078999519348,
-0.9486170411109924,
0.3577137589454651,
-0.22036360204219818,
-0.2454649657011032,
-0.03599078208208084,
0.4205058217048645,
-0.7134877443313599,
0.6964030861854553,
0.24122630059719086,
-0.13925062119960785,
0.41348737478256226,
-0.36754339933395386,
-0.004356660880148411,
-0.9251179099082947,
0.1609068363904953,
0.1443488448858261,
0.14705157279968262,
-0.48092421889305115,
0.20668546855449677,
-0.15164294838905334,
-0.04783997684717178,
-0.014778169803321362,
0.37186893820762634,
-0.5663641095161438,
-0.14268121123313904,
-0.06135869026184082,
-0.5057511925697327,
-0.11487138271331787,
0.3697351813316345,
0.06717105954885483,
0.5066742300987244,
0.727279007434845,
-0.5963484048843384,
0.43072739243507385,
0.2496528923511505,
-0.5922495722770691,
0.6464585065841675,
-0.5387859344482422,
0.15329225361347198,
-0.5804106593132019,
0.5498669147491455,
-1.2076873779296875,
-0.17562872171401978,
0.2935659885406494,
-0.271904319524765,
0.48769158124923706,
-0.2368905395269394,
-0.522428572177887,
-0.3427940905094147,
-0.369209885597229,
0.8768863081932068,
0.7492141127586365,
-0.7595652937889099,
0.19948334991931915,
0.4290504455566406,
0.04847582057118416,
-0.6268594264984131,
-0.7716942429542542,
-0.058356378227472305,
-0.29087120294570923,
-0.44964611530303955,
0.2845553159713745,
-0.2567461431026459,
-0.25737959146499634,
0.28679272532463074,
0.03950335457921028,
0.04754745215177536,
-0.16247373819351196,
0.19183482229709625,
0.04509683698415756,
-0.20207129418849945,
0.2846994996070862,
0.12078473716974258,
-0.07013171166181564,
-0.09857631474733353,
-0.4588008522987366,
0.5796347856521606,
0.26956048607826233,
-0.724673330783844,
-0.4637574851512909,
0.6769146919250488,
0.4362954795360565,
0.12337139248847961,
0.37280964851379395,
0.7991422414779663,
-0.34647560119628906,
-0.35262182354927063,
-0.09785779565572739,
-0.08023843169212341,
-0.3599364757537842,
0.11660817265510559,
-0.4522557854652405,
-0.266937792301178,
0.3810954689979553,
0.05992862209677696,
-0.022928304970264435,
0.5031158328056335,
0.5509241223335266,
-0.3586784899234772,
0.9032821655273438,
0.5485213398933411,
-0.204727903008461,
0.49673205614089966,
-0.94143146276474,
0.14441163837909698,
-0.6669908165931702,
-0.2711591124534607,
-0.16670750081539154,
-0.7133651971817017,
-0.4764140248298645,
-0.6673084497451782,
0.5848327279090881,
0.03540724143385887,
-0.14251777529716492,
-0.3799726665019989,
-0.45498746633529663,
0.3303162753582001,
1.0326098203659058,
0.18119925260543823,
0.0671825036406517,
0.48918309807777405,
0.03890048712491989,
-0.028327856212854385,
-0.47472402453422546,
-0.12915177643299103,
1.2343227863311768,
0.19384001195430756,
0.9689938426017761,
-0.0073940204456448555,
0.6836188435554504,
0.7280985116958618,
0.09596054255962372,
-0.6495258212089539,
0.2296467125415802,
-0.19256344437599182,
-0.3414798080921173,
-0.14897200465202332,
-0.5819023251533508,
-1.1241403818130493,
0.15256258845329285,
-0.01684478484094143,
-0.2316533923149109,
0.6030312776565552,
0.4331260323524475,
-0.2918623387813568,
0.6132344603538513,
-0.7098628878593445,
0.6509947180747986,
-0.11579587310552597,
-0.12028876692056656,
-0.2683916687965393,
-0.7389439344406128,
0.45668095350265503,
0.15127189457416534,
-0.11469516158103943,
-0.043413352221250534,
0.10001995414495468,
0.3966011703014374,
-0.2877853214740753,
1.0745818614959717,
-0.7258431315422058,
0.014725940302014351,
0.6130545139312744,
-0.10566166043281555,
0.3513855040073395,
0.19982022047042847,
0.19921331107616425,
0.2522597908973694,
-0.03739370405673981,
-0.744884729385376,
-0.563124418258667,
0.29680192470550537,
-0.8316539525985718,
-0.14829114079475403,
-0.3194177746772766,
-0.49589893221855164,
-0.08754879236221313,
-0.11713604629039764,
0.6373811364173889,
0.48094552755355835,
-0.33963096141815186,
0.15756890177726746,
0.34890931844711304,
-0.2553116977214813,
0.24654017388820648,
-0.17122089862823486,
0.16309906542301178,
-0.362641841173172,
0.8345000147819519,
-0.0261627696454525,
0.20017512142658234,
0.5776064991950989,
0.09902400523424149,
-0.6787919998168945,
-0.5786804556846619,
-0.5449634790420532,
0.09352122992277145,
-0.6073148846626282,
-0.1626073122024536,
-0.25178346037864685,
-0.1541861742734909,
-0.2904737591743469,
-0.04007432237267494,
-0.24957850575447083,
-0.3400738537311554,
-0.2538841962814331,
-0.03642314299941063,
0.11223714053630829,
0.726413369178772,
-0.35926324129104614,
0.09032303094863892,
-0.5467605590820312,
0.4388333559036255,
0.3126007616519928,
0.07829800248146057,
0.07380601018667221,
-0.21480202674865723,
-0.011349545791745186,
0.3531496524810791,
-0.17788466811180115,
-0.5414829850196838,
0.35651782155036926,
0.20065191388130188,
0.5845634937286377,
0.6166733503341675,
-0.004690195433795452,
0.6321559548377991,
-0.30701082944869995,
0.8674498200416565,
0.2858804166316986,
-0.35804975032806396,
0.4279652237892151,
-0.21080230176448822,
0.15650303661823273,
0.47733446955680847,
0.3359660804271698,
-0.36564013361930847,
-0.05197738856077194,
-0.7644588351249695,
-0.8588687777519226,
0.3616614043712616,
0.19905170798301697,
0.2935017943382263,
0.3082343339920044,
0.3296504318714142,
0.2718951404094696,
0.3393478989601135,
-0.43212956190109253,
-0.3149876594543457,
-0.1721220761537552,
-0.40717118978500366,
-0.35231369733810425,
-0.16611738502979279,
-0.3673129379749298,
-0.279122918844223,
0.2814500033855438,
-0.2755812108516693,
0.7112453579902649,
0.17683060467243195,
0.050129663199186325,
-0.08976022899150848,
-0.15331542491912842,
0.35402992367744446,
0.1998598575592041,
-0.05326574668288231,
0.3498303294181824,
-0.2768692374229431,
-0.611689031124115,
0.25485023856163025,
0.27611759305000305,
-0.37746134400367737,
-0.12359289824962616,
0.35216620564460754,
0.6985093355178833,
-0.5112855434417725,
-0.48935467004776,
0.4534909725189209,
-0.1125197634100914,
-0.1909763514995575,
-0.6743485331535339,
-0.07395335286855698,
-0.12572020292282104,
0.44561243057250977,
0.4497756361961365,
0.47303518652915955,
0.3990030884742737,
-0.4087474048137665,
0.07545751333236694,
0.7004344463348389,
-0.255088210105896,
-0.5419495701789856,
0.5130250453948975,
0.017841359600424767,
-0.05087360367178917,
0.9216127395629883,
-0.5167715549468994,
0.007962431758642197,
1.0799739360809326,
0.18130452930927277,
0.9909418225288391,
0.10616208612918854,
0.39678752422332764,
0.483492374420166,
0.04836824908852577,
0.02609679102897644,
0.20106427371501923,
-0.49759379029273987,
-0.8957105875015259,
-0.2069006860256195,
-0.4811578392982483,
-0.2008795440196991,
0.24462202191352844,
-0.7654386758804321,
-0.18756379187107086,
-0.37528544664382935,
0.012758098542690277,
-0.030499281361699104,
-0.12495338171720505,
-0.849744975566864,
-0.013232464902102947,
0.4310339689254761,
0.8815272450447083,
-0.8895694613456726,
0.6131473183631897,
0.5410383939743042,
-0.42383408546447754,
-0.2895728349685669,
0.26013433933258057,
-0.07779931277036667,
-0.8340798616409302,
0.5285826325416565,
0.19083386659622192,
-0.03620986267924309,
-0.03253842517733574,
-0.7058864235877991,
-0.61037677526474,
1.1089777946472168,
0.29398614168167114,
-0.4394759237766266,
0.156752809882164,
0.07694793492555618,
0.5965625047683716,
-0.16647441685199738,
-0.06869428604841232,
0.42625343799591064,
0.2520515024662018,
0.2844820022583008,
-0.03960346058011055,
-0.16306430101394653,
-0.5516375303268433,
0.314230352640152,
0.4234555661678314,
-0.5264849066734314,
0.6681835651397705,
-0.487293004989624,
-0.4860285520553589,
0.30229809880256653,
0.5630573630332947,
0.1591145247220993,
0.3600088655948639,
0.8460810780525208,
0.7722968459129333,
0.8261159658432007,
0.10028744488954544,
1.1852519512176514,
-0.08262941241264343,
0.5615782737731934,
0.7701571583747864,
-0.11993522197008133,
0.4362383782863617,
0.5428824424743652,
-0.5766605734825134,
0.39059963822364807,
0.6802113056182861,
-0.3807080090045929,
0.8622481822967529,
0.19279013574123383,
-0.7544952034950256,
0.04113217443227768,
0.09314066171646118,
-0.42046234011650085,
0.10952495038509369,
0.517945408821106,
-0.21334637701511383,
-0.34086185693740845,
0.06805679202079773,
-0.651445746421814,
-0.050752587616443634,
-0.19244541227817535,
0.413673460483551,
0.03041129745543003,
-0.4419931173324585,
0.2110740691423416,
-0.30355799198150635,
0.5798077583312988,
-0.4270845651626587,
-0.3430851697921753,
-0.37658002972602844,
0.29086145758628845,
-0.00216966075822711,
-0.8184181451797485,
0.30781278014183044,
-0.26111674308776855,
-0.1618034839630127,
-0.257158488035202,
0.5101988911628723,
-0.3084593117237091,
-0.6174803376197815,
0.03716963157057762,
0.42023706436157227,
0.26205456256866455,
-0.18945159018039703,
-0.5378378033638,
-0.27332234382629395,
-0.12087686359882355,
-0.20149622857570648,
0.06411930173635483,
0.23262177407741547,
0.18564607203006744,
0.2901226878166199,
0.7540495991706848,
0.1122804582118988,
0.21531125903129578,
0.24254640936851501,
0.5348979830741882,
-0.5215411186218262,
-0.5656352043151855,
-0.7458001971244812,
0.6635904908180237,
-0.24559882283210754,
-0.30439186096191406,
0.3220614194869995,
0.510097861289978,
0.7746264934539795,
-0.4069426953792572,
1.09110426902771,
-0.3774352967739105,
0.2524098753929138,
-0.622191309928894,
0.22015798091888428,
-0.596508264541626,
-0.010240605100989342,
0.16041849553585052,
-0.6681390404701233,
-0.3349744975566864,
0.5046131014823914,
-0.24862895905971527,
0.19470667839050293,
0.3883779048919678,
0.7388998866081238,
-0.38398972153663635,
-0.10242494195699692,
0.1830485761165619,
-0.09017597138881683,
0.3626856207847595,
0.5675751566886902,
1.2254102230072021,
-0.20026180148124695,
0.3575346767902374,
-0.5520454049110413,
-0.23119544982910156,
-0.1663314700126648,
-0.5334465503692627,
-0.505939245223999,
-0.7389073967933655,
-0.30846893787384033,
-0.09567892551422119,
-0.39097437262535095,
0.6171668171882629,
0.9772641658782959,
-0.7136203050613403,
0.039681244641542435,
-0.6410437822341919,
-0.17605437338352203,
-0.5086989402770996,
-0.2751901149749756,
0.6212471723556519,
-0.29946190118789673,
-1.131316065788269,
0.3486110270023346,
0.2044324427843094,
0.4013623595237732,
-0.6283255219459534,
0.004595195408910513,
0.21817970275878906,
-0.4005064070224762,
0.46751177310943604,
0.4001651704311371,
-0.3525814712047577,
-0.07668156176805496,
-0.22687754034996033,
-0.06357570737600327,
0.2628561556339264,
1.0507454872131348,
-0.6070864796638489,
0.572515606880188,
0.5265849828720093,
0.7442799210548401,
0.8733882308006287,
-0.00266329781152308,
0.31218230724334717,
-0.9784142374992371,
0.3868229389190674,
0.4314221441745758,
0.21458800137043,
0.40121766924858093,
-0.49702176451683044,
0.7362241744995117,
0.5443181991577148,
-0.3112086057662964,
-0.8636779189109802,
0.5528795719146729,
-1.101518154144287,
-0.2755529284477234,
1.0245230197906494,
-0.02790110930800438,
0.04487745836377144,
0.14319826662540436,
-0.09791206568479538,
0.17013348639011383,
-0.1533244550228119,
0.758765459060669,
0.29790642857551575,
-0.24702006578445435,
-0.004009447526186705,
-0.49236005544662476,
0.4632892310619354,
0.2201523333787918,
-0.7807598114013672,
-0.17464609444141388,
0.5112589597702026,
0.2761957049369812,
0.2811754047870636,
0.9103080034255981,
0.01778360828757286,
0.11980977654457092,
0.4268398582935333,
0.16766749322414398,
0.23149149119853973,
-0.37823793292045593,
-0.6462122797966003,
0.3427090346813202,
-0.12131744623184204,
-0.665047287940979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07376v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07376v1
|
LLMs in Biomedicine: A study on clinical Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-04-10T22:26:26 | 2024-04-10T22:26:26 |
Masoud Monajatipoor, Jiaxin Yang, Joel Stremmel, Melika Emami, Fazlolah Mohaghegh, Mozhdeh Rouhsedaghat, Kai-Wei Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable versatility in various
NLP tasks but encounter distinct challenges in biomedicine due to medical
language complexities and data scarcity. This paper investigates the
application of LLMs in the medical domain by exploring strategies to enhance
their performance for the Named-Entity Recognition (NER) task. Specifically,
our study reveals the importance of meticulously designed prompts in
biomedicine. Strategic selection of in-context examples yields a notable
improvement, showcasing ~15-20\% increase in F1 score across all benchmark
datasets for few-shot clinical NER. Additionally, our findings suggest that
integrating external resources through prompting strategies can bridge the gap
between general-purpose LLM proficiency and the specialized demands of medical
NER. Leveraging a medical knowledge base, our proposed method inspired by
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) can boost the F1 score of LLMs for
zero-shot clinical NER. We will release the code upon publication.
|
[
-0.13613347709178925,
-0.5795778632164001,
1.0529087781906128,
-0.003764092456549406,
-0.33173537254333496,
0.24163824319839478,
-0.14395369589328766,
-0.6152355670928955,
0.4854503870010376,
0.4162255823612213,
-0.38916710019111633,
-0.561580240726471,
-0.5107558965682983,
0.632927656173706,
-0.10587701946496964,
0.8997694253921509,
0.014569832943379879,
0.5804902911186218,
-0.3817441761493683,
-0.23488934338092804,
-0.48947593569755554,
-0.37919342517852783,
-0.9426713585853577,
-0.4116674065589905,
0.9146097898483276,
0.3134130835533142,
0.10015087574720383,
0.6651893258094788,
0.8180983066558838,
0.2088029384613037,
-0.2743878960609436,
0.38565370440483093,
-0.20968139171600342,
0.4978947341442108,
-0.17839649319648743,
-0.4861658215522766,
-0.3415849208831787,
-0.20249797403812408,
0.6142421364784241,
0.7408196926116943,
0.03574641793966293,
-0.03851045295596123,
-0.0529152974486351,
0.6132615804672241,
-0.31700268387794495,
-0.13278988003730774,
-0.4271669387817383,
0.11055700480937958,
-0.28581666946411133,
-0.5971242785453796,
-0.39696651697158813,
-0.18205833435058594,
0.08828192204236984,
-0.5199856758117676,
0.14989444613456726,
0.049837373197078705,
0.7140293121337891,
0.24767367541790009,
-0.24631215631961823,
-0.2798199951648712,
-0.5408974289894104,
0.5815979242324829,
-0.46196842193603516,
0.375535786151886,
0.002329169772565365,
0.2813233435153961,
-0.487320214509964,
-0.7713805437088013,
-0.2583391070365906,
-0.4188743829727173,
0.03979998454451561,
0.009770913980901241,
-0.1499694287776947,
0.23914538323879242,
0.5416171550750732,
0.20821668207645416,
-0.3233683407306671,
0.3574129641056061,
-0.3418758511543274,
-0.056767579168081284,
0.48424026370048523,
0.46680504083633423,
0.35369884967803955,
-0.15559811890125275,
-0.3553164303302765,
0.3153252601623535,
-1.0317519903182983,
0.028214162215590477,
-0.28031882643699646,
0.3677358329296112,
0.17973387241363525,
0.5751756429672241,
-0.261366069316864,
0.6687410473823547,
0.18396589159965515,
-0.4112504720687866,
0.3584752678871155,
-0.1716286689043045,
-0.17680518329143524,
0.10341653972864151,
0.5649182200431824,
0.17485971748828888,
0.07829955965280533,
-0.22444036602973938,
-0.12413980066776276,
-0.19716595113277435,
0.36572402715682983,
-0.8396831750869751,
-0.032429926097393036,
0.45185840129852295,
-0.37281084060668945,
-0.3917943835258484,
-0.41171202063560486,
-0.7383200526237488,
-0.764331579208374,
-0.2982136905193329,
0.2630024254322052,
-0.5909036993980408,
0.30491000413894653,
-0.0379604808986187,
-0.21981282532215118,
0.2939580976963043,
0.6732776761054993,
-0.5257254242897034,
0.12046372890472412,
0.5439274907112122,
0.7617220282554626,
-0.26749876141548157,
0.14645929634571075,
-0.5884969830513,
0.2043956220149994,
-0.28486526012420654,
0.9537774920463562,
-0.5055004954338074,
-0.5927826166152954,
-0.19263528287410736,
-0.05144868791103363,
-0.020690036937594414,
-0.7556010484695435,
0.3882253170013428,
-0.4676413834095001,
-0.13749612867832184,
-0.35865318775177,
-0.7066319584846497,
-0.033486366271972656,
0.24079114198684692,
-0.47302210330963135,
0.5570233464241028,
-0.08852192759513855,
-0.5086883306503296,
0.4885365962982178,
-0.6807770133018494,
-0.49468711018562317,
0.6564030647277832,
-0.5334230661392212,
-0.27349475026130676,
0.2653537094593048,
0.2975771725177765,
0.5429000854492188,
-0.43595412373542786,
0.2961373031139374,
-0.029911644756793976,
-0.22768935561180115,
0.46964505314826965,
-0.2434045523405075,
0.4403652846813202,
0.08460339158773422,
-0.10847685486078262,
0.05121568962931633,
-0.7564359307289124,
0.10492562502622604,
0.09437442570924759,
-0.46659934520721436,
-0.3020722568035126,
-0.20158874988555908,
-0.2201768010854721,
-0.047871723771095276,
0.006281867157667875,
-0.5403817296028137,
0.2712897062301636,
-0.7011266350746155,
0.2154635787010193,
0.3701373040676117,
0.41230911016464233,
0.39686378836631775,
-0.5465096235275269,
0.6707150936126709,
-0.08194395154714584,
-0.18104077875614166,
-0.10006875544786453,
-0.5481004118919373,
-0.5537405610084534,
-0.6425237655639648,
0.5196594595909119,
0.7596728801727295,
-0.7909632921218872,
0.01673724688589573,
-0.02033180743455887,
-0.4450571537017822,
-0.6246448755264282,
-0.00865183211863041,
0.26483121514320374,
0.9531137347221375,
0.5280530452728271,
-0.0028892613481730223,
-0.6221212148666382,
-0.7846287488937378,
-0.3144064247608185,
0.03471238166093826,
-0.23765616118907928,
0.7074798941612244,
0.4494558274745941,
-0.45810022950172424,
0.7688513994216919,
-0.428392231464386,
-0.28784337639808655,
-0.431147962808609,
-0.16911639273166656,
0.5382258296012878,
0.2660415470600128,
0.3012470304965973,
-0.5671837329864502,
-0.2642468512058258,
-0.15403033792972565,
-0.8101481199264526,
-0.42393815517425537,
-0.08489681035280228,
0.07860426604747772,
-0.015274733304977417,
0.5884757041931152,
-0.658370316028595,
0.2581729292869568,
0.032771699130535126,
-0.06258424371480942,
0.45063698291778564,
-0.2012094408273697,
0.2896769046783447,
-1.0751405954360962,
0.22505053877830505,
-0.06550424546003342,
-0.3528520464897156,
-0.794334888458252,
0.14903461933135986,
0.05460966005921364,
-0.07046989351511002,
-0.7246038317680359,
1.0044946670532227,
-0.6608986258506775,
0.3237718641757965,
-0.2301824390888214,
-0.07093992829322815,
-0.0020312967244535685,
-0.015221122652292252,
0.051095232367515564,
0.6359370350837708,
0.5974167585372925,
-0.8508597016334534,
0.36884352564811707,
0.34688642621040344,
-0.15698683261871338,
0.7075595259666443,
-0.7202407121658325,
-0.03576396033167839,
-0.3139496147632599,
0.12082695215940475,
-0.598238468170166,
-0.4997658431529999,
0.2354721575975418,
-0.33319440484046936,
0.8011382818222046,
0.05816727504134178,
-0.3854562044143677,
-0.39120548963546753,
-0.10855844616889954,
0.3224175274372101,
0.5274361371994019,
-0.4998784065246582,
0.34661638736724854,
0.3967978060245514,
-0.23521582782268524,
-0.38819873332977295,
-0.6018843054771423,
0.26053154468536377,
-0.28405070304870605,
-0.20067580044269562,
0.6161004304885864,
0.011121749877929688,
-0.1876043826341629,
-0.27245476841926575,
-0.11139336973428726,
0.147162526845932,
0.045713406056165695,
0.377434104681015,
0.3779155910015106,
-0.24082936346530914,
0.5215463638305664,
0.03840919956564903,
-0.20561467111110687,
-0.021997375413775444,
0.04604075476527214,
0.26171573996543884,
0.24317152798175812,
-0.2631145119667053,
-0.34848904609680176,
0.3135795295238495,
0.2869189977645874,
-0.04760982468724251,
0.5848889350891113,
0.2726404070854187,
-0.6169800162315369,
-0.11741823703050613,
-0.6594493985176086,
-0.39344969391822815,
-0.416515976190567,
0.23220622539520264,
-0.19995665550231934,
-0.9772179126739502,
0.3967684805393219,
-0.4796961545944214,
-0.3471101224422455,
0.3251354992389679,
0.6145550012588501,
-0.3529774248600006,
0.7161412239074707,
0.2258307784795761,
0.13099616765975952,
0.21630480885505676,
0.004232042469084263,
0.07846831530332565,
-1.0780305862426758,
-0.30835235118865967,
-0.33748242259025574,
-0.31717878580093384,
-0.49627169966697693,
-0.6769128441810608,
0.84424889087677,
0.05623935908079147,
0.08925662189722061,
0.11217368394136429,
-0.689293622970581,
0.43810346722602844,
0.3071085810661316,
0.36800625920295715,
0.1521514356136322,
-0.013137929141521454,
-0.4969725012779236,
-0.08492125570774078,
-0.7325876951217651,
-0.5011951327323914,
1.0339257717132568,
0.42346352338790894,
0.6152070164680481,
-0.02573835477232933,
1.1118125915527344,
0.056572478264570236,
0.40716907382011414,
-0.9590561389923096,
0.7163616418838501,
-0.0452902652323246,
-0.41867512464523315,
-0.10563301295042038,
-0.4227985143661499,
-1.1777561902999878,
-0.22416365146636963,
-0.4688258767127991,
-0.666439950466156,
0.12849801778793335,
0.018306169658899307,
-0.8072943687438965,
0.01151744183152914,
-0.09478910267353058,
0.4704747200012207,
-0.23878300189971924,
-0.2141774743795395,
0.11973229050636292,
-0.48240041732788086,
0.03488306701183319,
-0.08310389518737793,
0.02299981191754341,
-0.04617926478385925,
-0.3414902687072754,
0.4736311733722687,
-0.3336857855319977,
0.7049549221992493,
-0.07136406004428864,
0.15487618744373322,
0.16633683443069458,
-0.12502864003181458,
0.39559903740882874,
0.3938036859035492,
-0.01456268597394228,
0.20761306583881378,
-0.19084641337394714,
-0.05199960246682167,
-0.4289720952510834,
0.7024262547492981,
-0.19517305493354797,
-0.7919108271598816,
-0.47219008207321167,
-0.4762127995491028,
-0.4027196764945984,
0.3190719187259674,
0.5055208206176758,
0.4884045720100403,
-0.28072434663772583,
0.058675751090049744,
0.9131296277046204,
-0.5576576590538025,
0.14600636065006256,
0.7367199659347534,
0.03735555708408356,
-0.49759942293167114,
0.6448971629142761,
0.12682098150253296,
-0.031311340630054474,
0.6171598434448242,
-0.0014036467764526606,
-0.16816562414169312,
-0.7787318229675293,
-0.578040361404419,
0.4487559497356415,
-0.5321823358535767,
-0.6511482000350952,
-0.821931004524231,
-0.36914029717445374,
-0.39666855335235596,
-0.2840554416179657,
0.11446988582611084,
-0.21128304302692413,
-0.6849843859672546,
-0.07575324922800064,
0.7136965990066528,
0.5892201066017151,
0.04123634472489357,
0.0697406530380249,
-1.0518462657928467,
0.4668545126914978,
-0.0016793669201433659,
0.3855891525745392,
-0.29686692357063293,
-0.4344466030597687,
0.04495939984917641,
-0.3746950924396515,
-0.04279658943414688,
-1.235062599182129,
0.4693846106529236,
0.13959646224975586,
0.8232012391090393,
0.34552469849586487,
-0.242558553814888,
0.6428824663162231,
-0.9933101534843445,
0.4693436324596405,
0.05072783678770065,
-0.4775960445404053,
0.7958102226257324,
-0.2551419734954834,
0.34726694226264954,
0.7196393013000488,
0.5961468815803528,
-0.4606182873249054,
-0.31411078572273254,
-0.5034717917442322,
-0.820765495300293,
0.2756274342536926,
-0.22394253313541412,
0.06253337115049362,
-0.41926971077919006,
0.6641925573348999,
-0.05136920511722565,
0.25431519746780396,
-0.2890898287296295,
-0.2771119177341461,
0.7402634024620056,
-0.3214528560638428,
0.14617891609668732,
-0.35434767603874207,
-0.2165127694606781,
-0.17169037461280823,
0.5121636390686035,
-0.21720707416534424,
0.4300957918167114,
0.6806354522705078,
-0.05106864124536514,
-0.04688560962677002,
0.41991057991981506,
0.5649207830429077,
0.23824116587638855,
0.08767101913690567,
-0.23114542663097382,
0.4059268832206726,
-0.3994552195072174,
0.22448642551898956,
0.18435268104076385,
-0.19982077181339264,
0.1961791217327118,
0.40406957268714905,
0.513551652431488,
0.3677942454814911,
-0.8088914155960083,
0.2850586473941803,
0.1853315830230713,
-0.057157281786203384,
-0.2620021402835846,
0.2477731555700302,
0.023116115480661392,
0.47774410247802734,
0.2534888982772827,
-0.04648985713720322,
0.4512099027633667,
-0.215549498796463,
0.3598710596561432,
0.6670042872428894,
-0.3677341639995575,
0.0761275663971901,
0.6754485368728638,
0.06500054895877838,
-0.2956780195236206,
0.3998366594314575,
-0.1919766068458557,
-0.18390917778015137,
0.590391218662262,
0.6213642358779907,
0.5442229509353638,
-0.25363102555274963,
0.13271775841712952,
0.39857301115989685,
-0.12148474901914597,
-0.15007352828979492,
0.4920996427536011,
0.09387312829494476,
-0.5713094472885132,
-0.35248565673828125,
-0.7258466482162476,
-0.5012330412864685,
0.10029483586549759,
-0.2967727780342102,
0.6576211452484131,
-0.6060166954994202,
-0.4340797960758209,
0.4017932713031769,
-0.08488308638334274,
-0.6181426644325256,
0.2498413473367691,
0.2503361403942108,
1.0082528591156006,
-0.29630622267723083,
0.5762453675270081,
0.8450248837471008,
-0.3976532220840454,
-0.6894621253013611,
-0.307699978351593,
0.1893802136182785,
-0.8184230923652649,
0.7930912375450134,
0.22138136625289917,
0.33102959394454956,
-0.017048224806785583,
-0.3742620348930359,
-0.8053029775619507,
1.1160227060317993,
0.11984921991825104,
-0.6074547171592712,
-0.2929239273071289,
0.024134133011102676,
0.758233368396759,
-0.5103302001953125,
0.23388268053531647,
0.2874828577041626,
0.34055906534194946,
0.15061324834823608,
-0.8215698599815369,
0.20803691446781158,
-0.18479721248149872,
-0.14137329161167145,
0.32687216997146606,
-0.15768137574195862,
0.5695639848709106,
-0.7126469016075134,
-0.25673583149909973,
0.32165291905403137,
0.3035980761051178,
0.7041394710540771,
0.7022452354431152,
0.09285812079906464,
0.45503997802734375,
0.8534331917762756,
-0.05655527487397194,
1.1015589237213135,
-0.19104745984077454,
-0.1832646131515503,
0.7572066783905029,
-0.42918410897254944,
0.6960166692733765,
0.6134983897209167,
-0.17879794538021088,
0.4361792802810669,
0.41800329089164734,
-0.2139502316713333,
0.33020535111427307,
0.40985143184661865,
-0.532896101474762,
-0.11310576647520065,
-0.47273126244544983,
-0.355194091796875,
0.31515491008758545,
0.7014226913452148,
-0.7560128569602966,
-0.022036798298358917,
0.3173004388809204,
-0.020459802821278572,
-0.08804305642843246,
-0.49015942215919495,
1.07693350315094,
0.5064643621444702,
-0.39276427030563354,
0.4118939936161041,
-0.1942971795797348,
0.4694225490093231,
-0.4519600570201874,
-0.24898971617221832,
0.01308787427842617,
-0.03542235866189003,
-0.24656885862350464,
-0.5895372033119202,
0.11344148218631744,
0.02571430616080761,
-0.3392166793346405,
-0.07455600798130035,
1.002312183380127,
-0.37967562675476074,
-0.5377508997917175,
0.2619439363479614,
0.6279436349868774,
0.24881692230701447,
0.15146833658218384,
-0.5607258081436157,
-0.17691393196582794,
-0.1981128603219986,
-0.018632788211107254,
0.3530128300189972,
0.4504441022872925,
-0.021503327414393425,
0.6203300356864929,
0.6553223133087158,
0.6043716073036194,
-0.42602261900901794,
0.22326959669589996,
0.7772144079208374,
-0.8418310284614563,
-0.1270020455121994,
-0.8737562894821167,
0.27937841415405273,
-0.10265194624662399,
-0.09561768174171448,
0.4833582043647766,
0.34778833389282227,
0.3591274917125702,
-0.22028562426567078,
0.4536668658256531,
0.32509076595306396,
0.9356250166893005,
-0.5629733800888062,
0.732503354549408,
-0.5934374928474426,
0.35454052686691284,
-0.23546399176120758,
-0.5043809413909912,
-0.690459668636322,
0.3094274401664734,
-0.2409716248512268,
0.10280489921569824,
0.5378100275993347,
0.7630816102027893,
0.34336331486701965,
-0.21273131668567657,
0.44350674748420715,
0.1616872251033783,
0.0207479540258646,
0.7007468938827515,
0.6496516466140747,
-0.2101755291223526,
-0.008037449792027473,
-0.06456666439771652,
-0.1842075139284134,
-0.41904380917549133,
-0.9008001089096069,
-0.8807480931282043,
-0.12627680599689484,
-0.39049968123435974,
-0.3198647201061249,
0.25539031624794006,
1.225142478942871,
0.4070146083831787,
-0.8144782781600952,
0.34033867716789246,
-0.00875395629554987,
0.06347224116325378,
-0.057124193757772446,
-0.21528980135917664,
0.13418139517307281,
-0.525314211845398,
-0.45798853039741516,
0.8576812148094177,
0.5609042644500732,
0.18991050124168396,
0.06714538484811783,
0.12721426784992218,
-0.09638812392950058,
0.16232608258724213,
0.4877142906188965,
0.37500515580177307,
-0.6561321020126343,
0.09134546667337418,
0.42333200573921204,
-0.4108388125896454,
0.09245805442333221,
0.9173579812049866,
-1.194043517112732,
0.2742805480957031,
0.5083984732627869,
0.923465371131897,
-0.08595506101846695,
-0.14112484455108643,
0.5297016501426697,
-0.636583685874939,
-0.2804242670536041,
0.5120678544044495,
0.5058041214942932,
0.4607081413269043,
-0.7418767213821411,
0.5497483611106873,
0.28211745619773865,
-0.6167113184928894,
-0.801377534866333,
0.11169207096099854,
-0.8150643706321716,
-0.13825106620788574,
1.2163026332855225,
0.09778114408254623,
-0.18219046294689178,
-0.18769285082817078,
-0.22859393060207367,
0.18514102697372437,
-0.37528327107429504,
0.5130890607833862,
0.34754419326782227,
-0.5267845392227173,
-0.16938291490077972,
-0.7851473093032837,
0.7848087549209595,
0.40742337703704834,
-0.803443431854248,
-0.5396677851676941,
0.3952988386154175,
0.35534754395484924,
0.1371501386165619,
0.8819180130958557,
-0.2913168668746948,
0.41647836565971375,
-0.4295331835746765,
-0.06754060089588165,
-0.08569671958684921,
-0.403997540473938,
-0.662086009979248,
0.03134077042341232,
0.1021939367055893,
0.10331208258867264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07341v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07341v2
|
Conformer-1: Robust ASR via Large-Scale Semisupervised Bootstrapping
| 2024-04-10T20:40:24 | 2024-04-12T18:23:35 |
Kevin Zhang, Luka Chkhetiani, Francis McCann Ramirez, Yash Khare, Andrea Vanzo, Michael Liang, Sergio Ramirez Martin, Gabriel Oexle, Ruben Bousbib, Taufiquzzaman Peyash, Michael Nguyen, Dillon Pulliam, Domenic Donato
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
This paper presents Conformer-1, an end-to-end Automatic Speech Recognition
(ASR) model trained on an extensive dataset of 570k hours of speech audio data,
91% of which was acquired from publicly available sources. To achieve this, we
perform Noisy Student Training after generating pseudo-labels for the unlabeled
public data using a strong Conformer RNN-T baseline model. The addition of
these pseudo-labeled data results in remarkable improvements in relative Word
Error Rate (WER) by 11.5% and 24.3% for our asynchronous and realtime models,
respectively. Additionally, the model is more robust to background noise owing
to the addition of these data. The results obtained in this study demonstrate
that the incorporation of pseudo-labeled publicly available data is a highly
effective strategy for improving ASR accuracy and noise robustness.
|
[
-0.13980111479759216,
-0.2986587882041931,
0.12403683364391327,
-0.0060350364074110985,
-0.18682080507278442,
-0.0685250461101532,
-0.3317493200302124,
-0.5864644646644592,
-0.14557358622550964,
0.05773834139108658,
-0.1566482037305832,
-0.25579193234443665,
-0.7699335217475891,
0.14190346002578735,
-0.8347652554512024,
0.646537184715271,
0.3386852741241455,
0.3398299813270569,
0.0011852238094434142,
-0.1950024664402008,
0.1604796200990677,
-0.6768160462379456,
-0.5784214735031128,
-0.10623669624328613,
0.11672833561897278,
0.31529656052589417,
0.4192698001861572,
0.6229059100151062,
0.1949843466281891,
0.3579135835170746,
-0.26679983735084534,
-0.5148925185203552,
-0.40768006443977356,
-0.06288304179906845,
-0.03746166080236435,
-0.25260502099990845,
-0.40081459283828735,
-0.05222567543387413,
1.0487128496170044,
0.40561023354530334,
-0.4740884006023407,
0.6228811144828796,
-0.005650215316563845,
0.5592426061630249,
-0.5438660383224487,
0.2832697033882141,
-0.6587755084037781,
-0.36640217900276184,
-0.4294583201408386,
0.4780207574367523,
-0.23713527619838715,
-0.3296767771244049,
0.4123244881629944,
-0.6267262697219849,
0.3012321889400482,
-0.2681017816066742,
0.9092212915420532,
0.6049662232398987,
0.05047158896923065,
-0.3222210705280304,
-0.917614221572876,
0.7123868465423584,
-0.816107988357544,
0.9403608441352844,
0.5209723114967346,
0.621726393699646,
0.2716467082500458,
-1.0521892309188843,
-0.5916744470596313,
-0.10600104182958603,
0.124602772295475,
0.009275905787944794,
-0.39593082666397095,
-0.14478211104869843,
0.18163247406482697,
0.37424999475479126,
-0.3431236147880554,
0.17472784221172333,
-0.7927899360656738,
-0.5441235899925232,
0.43229472637176514,
-0.42537400126457214,
-0.051501836627721786,
0.41471219062805176,
-0.18282821774482727,
-0.12388774007558823,
-0.3258533775806427,
0.24482984840869904,
0.18561458587646484,
0.4536982774734497,
-0.23546352982521057,
0.42308348417282104,
-0.1121758371591568,
0.9446893930435181,
0.2993472218513489,
-0.3594942092895508,
0.3244873285293579,
-0.26895245909690857,
-0.11265385895967484,
0.5026161670684814,
0.9287147521972656,
0.07689233869314194,
0.3608124256134033,
-0.15400154888629913,
-0.41514357924461365,
0.3484667241573334,
0.09943251311779022,
-0.7924158573150635,
-0.5318861603736877,
0.15075092017650604,
-0.26248642802238464,
-0.2583144009113312,
0.19278085231781006,
-0.5174033641815186,
-0.10836485773324966,
-0.640349268913269,
0.6075268387794495,
-0.25864264369010925,
-0.15372349321842194,
0.007708202116191387,
0.07453365623950958,
0.2907602787017822,
0.3620070219039917,
-0.5276758074760437,
0.6043968796730042,
0.21170049905776978,
1.0561721324920654,
-0.11668790876865387,
0.11172390729188919,
-0.7142845392227173,
0.2881532311439514,
-0.1823756992816925,
0.8852760195732117,
-0.45302653312683105,
-0.23080717027187347,
-0.3218693435192108,
0.12669575214385986,
0.09006991982460022,
-0.7042747735977173,
0.3668312132358551,
-0.370792031288147,
0.06682498008012772,
-0.028630485758185387,
-0.5736203193664551,
0.07904499769210815,
0.11415407806634903,
-0.6922463178634644,
0.7935279011726379,
0.06545950472354889,
-0.64154052734375,
0.4086845815181732,
-0.560401439666748,
-0.4276217222213745,
-0.05311964824795723,
-0.14966249465942383,
-0.8804539442062378,
-0.22622175514698029,
0.1620817631483078,
0.3126606345176697,
-0.2917162775993347,
0.19273117184638977,
0.09060337394475937,
-0.2828715443611145,
0.2728677988052368,
-0.2734657824039459,
0.6933760643005371,
0.21765533089637756,
-0.30096063017845154,
0.11982979625463486,
-1.3096976280212402,
-0.04872693493962288,
-0.008148317225277424,
-0.5803666114807129,
-0.1351878046989441,
-0.11668706685304642,
0.4159667491912842,
0.18453580141067505,
0.09143276512622833,
-0.9365078210830688,
-0.32328683137893677,
-0.2730969488620758,
0.5104122757911682,
0.6466888189315796,
-0.06885359436273575,
0.3572379946708679,
-0.40320396423339844,
0.31913965940475464,
0.006643692031502724,
-0.10424328595399857,
-0.11601536720991135,
-0.27259311079978943,
-0.4715644121170044,
-0.7242709994316101,
0.6353685855865479,
0.4118351340293884,
-0.11690057069063187,
0.5392702221870422,
-0.29004180431365967,
-0.64484703540802,
-0.6713058352470398,
0.03954402357339859,
0.4612828493118286,
0.7932177186012268,
0.5483810305595398,
-0.017815109342336655,
-0.6524114012718201,
-0.7050004005432129,
-0.05840101093053818,
-0.26565513014793396,
-0.5536491870880127,
-0.13593222200870514,
0.07938450574874878,
-0.19098389148712158,
0.9784778356552124,
-0.28702229261398315,
-0.5105921626091003,
-0.06833136081695557,
0.11803490668535233,
-0.01262736041098833,
0.5777794718742371,
0.16337436437606812,
-0.754722535610199,
-0.6331764459609985,
-0.3535449504852295,
-0.29902684688568115,
-0.08507799357175827,
-0.05359504744410515,
0.364131897687912,
0.11908862739801407,
0.5628098845481873,
0.08348414301872253,
0.4381447732448578,
0.45734015107154846,
-0.0071955895982682705,
0.35130229592323303,
-0.06190883740782738,
-0.21834224462509155,
-1.070436716079712,
0.208643838763237,
0.4142397940158844,
-0.4999300241470337,
-0.8401339650154114,
-0.6034112572669983,
0.0585947260260582,
-0.10057667642831802,
-0.35696277022361755,
0.04953204095363617,
-0.6588698625564575,
0.034185465425252914,
-0.14240685105323792,
-0.09432486444711685,
-0.4071250557899475,
0.035756561905145645,
0.2991548478603363,
1.1031756401062012,
0.9518939852714539,
-0.7018219232559204,
0.18241791427135468,
0.5415275692939758,
-0.40648722648620605,
0.2053859531879425,
-1.1261461973190308,
0.2706269323825836,
-0.24129872024059296,
0.3294091522693634,
-1.167799472808838,
-0.3542378544807434,
-0.11703549325466156,
-0.4831122159957886,
0.6952626705169678,
-0.2667798101902008,
-0.47677165269851685,
-0.18052518367767334,
-0.09588613361120224,
0.3320196568965912,
0.7403466105461121,
-0.556779682636261,
0.1814909428358078,
0.8706679344177246,
-0.1643541008234024,
0.04882138594985008,
-0.6719757318496704,
-0.1779036968946457,
-0.0017083704005926847,
-0.27129077911376953,
-0.047333698719739914,
0.057771533727645874,
-0.0943918451666832,
-0.6121385097503662,
-0.4936330020427704,
-0.2030157446861267,
-0.4208741784095764,
0.24255330860614777,
0.2544417381286621,
-0.20706716179847717,
-0.19886177778244019,
-0.31994569301605225,
-0.3282918632030487,
0.09593109786510468,
-0.3443484902381897,
0.14088517427444458,
-0.2207283079624176,
-0.31063833832740784,
-0.9602380394935608,
-0.153945654630661,
0.7739484310150146,
-0.1269761472940445,
0.6153897643089294,
0.3876844048500061,
-0.6293656826019287,
0.08832138776779175,
-0.5859301090240479,
-0.13357986509799957,
-0.46107035875320435,
0.24284614622592926,
-0.10573805123567581,
-0.571458101272583,
0.3534778654575348,
-0.2329547107219696,
0.02000238373875618,
0.06669487059116364,
0.4012177586555481,
0.0284713264554739,
0.4831831455230713,
0.6052260994911194,
-0.24188587069511414,
0.43225210905075073,
-0.17366163432598114,
0.045764002948999405,
-0.6939609050750732,
-0.4100816249847412,
-0.6783278584480286,
-0.1899353265762329,
-0.43786242604255676,
-0.4553073048591614,
0.48568427562713623,
-0.23972837626934052,
-0.2579338848590851,
0.5253167152404785,
-0.8213858604431152,
0.3545208275318146,
0.5202745199203491,
0.20331743359565735,
0.29708778858184814,
-0.08026216179132462,
0.2660156190395355,
-0.1509428322315216,
-0.526482105255127,
-0.5516027808189392,
1.222870111465454,
0.6149805188179016,
1.0362850427627563,
0.07288618385791779,
0.2962043285369873,
0.18851713836193085,
0.16025984287261963,
-0.8054828643798828,
0.29899317026138306,
-0.05697784572839737,
-0.6918591260910034,
-0.6746268272399902,
-0.18936285376548767,
-0.5205570459365845,
-0.0884208232164383,
-0.18936118483543396,
-1.0049556493759155,
0.37868526577949524,
0.42985615134239197,
-0.2551684081554413,
0.2005617469549179,
-0.5660358667373657,
0.4283754229545593,
0.22226931154727936,
-0.2295835167169571,
0.42775532603263855,
-1.1431788206100464,
0.043578993529081345,
-0.6221511363983154,
0.24384662508964539,
0.23371721804141998,
0.048198506236076355,
1.2725205421447754,
-0.5195833444595337,
0.7718821167945862,
-0.349518358707428,
-0.10686581581830978,
0.3593769967556,
-0.36198604106903076,
0.8067187666893005,
-0.21027565002441406,
-0.20800180733203888,
0.4144150912761688,
0.24442940950393677,
-0.297163188457489,
-0.2407434582710266,
0.2527298629283905,
-0.9117854237556458,
-0.048679281026124954,
-0.5071504712104797,
-0.4522421360015869,
-0.4334162175655365,
0.08174937218427658,
0.6868929266929626,
0.7194526791572571,
-0.08939849585294724,
0.40642261505126953,
0.8647439479827881,
0.16604755818843842,
0.2563534677028656,
0.7633469104766846,
0.23596829175949097,
-0.5230413675308228,
0.9025838375091553,
0.5563142895698547,
0.42034226655960083,
0.19579266011714935,
0.29082047939300537,
-0.6419247388839722,
-0.5677424669265747,
-0.2507615387439728,
0.17323780059814453,
-0.41841593384742737,
-0.1900930255651474,
-0.7260938286781311,
-0.4809534549713135,
-0.5431074500083923,
-0.22327975928783417,
-0.9106462597846985,
-0.6089212894439697,
-0.11816178262233734,
-0.12655365467071533,
0.26558995246887207,
0.7206176519393921,
-0.19655323028564453,
0.5926496386528015,
-0.5815701484680176,
0.5626487135887146,
0.16499942541122437,
0.33181753754615784,
-0.19377319514751434,
-1.0253652334213257,
-0.17604225873947144,
0.054224587976932526,
-0.0190590713173151,
-0.7886966466903687,
0.0887693390250206,
0.4936133325099945,
0.4811153709888458,
0.6595048308372498,
0.39904454350471497,
0.7246400713920593,
-0.544352650642395,
0.5872931480407715,
0.35760849714279175,
-0.9263719916343689,
0.6548800468444824,
-0.2749987840652466,
0.5887806415557861,
0.6864100694656372,
0.3210074305534363,
0.02481420524418354,
-0.652223527431488,
-0.5243232250213623,
-0.8885109424591064,
0.8859449028968811,
0.3735213875770569,
-0.2908293902873993,
0.3859994411468506,
0.1044318675994873,
0.0844375416636467,
0.023801419883966446,
-0.7108525037765503,
-0.5196602940559387,
-0.5973834991455078,
-0.20640681684017181,
-0.12514150142669678,
-0.12173265218734741,
-0.05150340870022774,
-0.6744101047515869,
0.8383392095565796,
0.07417217642068863,
0.10019499808549881,
0.32150736451148987,
-0.15020497143268585,
-0.31224822998046875,
0.45486339926719666,
0.5173249840736389,
0.7107532620429993,
-0.3127152919769287,
0.15924376249313354,
0.24359191954135895,
-0.8614559173583984,
0.40181225538253784,
0.45864564180374146,
-0.2813049554824829,
0.23096700012683868,
0.14315974712371826,
0.3695979416370392,
0.16682685911655426,
-0.5088567137718201,
0.5777012705802917,
-0.01892850548028946,
-0.2234840840101242,
-0.5262181758880615,
-0.22140483558177948,
-0.044377394020557404,
0.062160979956388474,
0.5120774507522583,
0.16049730777740479,
0.2879694402217865,
-0.3157833218574524,
0.6588358879089355,
0.26141300797462463,
-0.6307111382484436,
-0.6231541633605957,
1.0678693056106567,
-0.10472505539655685,
-0.25263822078704834,
0.4476392865180969,
0.09591224789619446,
-0.3834003806114197,
0.2862222194671631,
1.0018576383590698,
0.5582654476165771,
-0.6864604353904724,
-0.017822621390223503,
0.7224586009979248,
0.3080999255180359,
-0.41528576612472534,
-0.009972551837563515,
-0.25091710686683655,
-0.3695560693740845,
-0.0653526708483696,
-0.6556044220924377,
-0.44024884700775146,
0.436847448348999,
-1.168391227722168,
0.34435611963272095,
-0.5266374349594116,
-0.13040053844451904,
0.22944575548171997,
-0.43056267499923706,
-0.14641889929771423,
0.4441308081150055,
0.24724066257476807,
0.9865313172340393,
-0.9387163519859314,
0.8518996238708496,
1.0264338254928589,
-0.10792671144008636,
-0.8194541335105896,
0.34335336089134216,
0.3149348199367523,
-0.4594295024871826,
0.162641704082489,
0.22909311950206757,
-0.30266034603118896,
0.2875550389289856,
-0.7831712961196899,
-0.9830899238586426,
1.123052716255188,
0.41711485385894775,
-1.0846534967422485,
0.10747425258159637,
0.08201836794614792,
0.4662436544895172,
0.03480382636189461,
-0.19990989565849304,
0.5101715326309204,
0.35330477356910706,
0.6960026025772095,
-1.1441516876220703,
0.0888751819729805,
-0.13428336381912231,
-0.08770804107189178,
0.2196323275566101,
-0.6388046145439148,
0.304412841796875,
-0.21453280746936798,
-0.30444857478141785,
-0.19389861822128296,
0.9618644714355469,
0.4180440604686737,
0.5157151222229004,
0.6771864891052246,
0.2754313349723816,
0.9373950362205505,
0.1066717654466629,
0.4680229127407074,
-0.282440721988678,
0.15429800748825073,
1.2851438522338867,
-0.10721373558044434,
0.8436672687530518,
0.4693600833415985,
-0.40703436732292175,
0.07272298634052277,
0.3071114420890808,
-0.17596986889839172,
0.7494044303894043,
0.17032507061958313,
-0.3302244246006012,
-0.21936927735805511,
0.15986761450767517,
-0.34731853008270264,
0.401586651802063,
0.12557052075862885,
-0.05441258102655411,
-0.297545462846756,
0.07367409020662308,
-0.0730101689696312,
0.1236225813627243,
-0.2657385468482971,
1.0017647743225098,
-0.005759312305599451,
-0.07590848207473755,
0.6942634582519531,
-0.3335992097854614,
0.729773998260498,
-0.7628437876701355,
0.13560491800308228,
0.3568578362464905,
0.2761734127998352,
-0.3090013563632965,
-0.3562942445278168,
0.44922804832458496,
0.3397347629070282,
-0.24381980299949646,
-0.16970893740653992,
0.6952269673347473,
-0.4580310881137848,
-0.8377915024757385,
-0.07359262555837631,
0.17516879737377167,
0.3717518746852875,
-0.014111604541540146,
-0.34203600883483887,
0.1475551575422287,
-0.17617908120155334,
-0.14873553812503815,
0.3126503527164459,
0.21512067317962646,
0.10314050316810608,
0.7015138268470764,
0.6810961961746216,
0.13558059930801392,
0.26787951588630676,
-0.05993758141994476,
1.2054673433303833,
-0.24595235288143158,
-0.6563472747802734,
-0.4694770872592926,
0.7262309193611145,
0.05811651796102524,
-0.07169663161039352,
0.6024784445762634,
0.9201385974884033,
0.7295829653739929,
0.0576598085463047,
0.8282565474510193,
-0.045687075704336166,
0.9789261817932129,
-0.22359491884708405,
0.9458814859390259,
-0.24582427740097046,
0.39453232288360596,
-0.32585448026657104,
-0.6160894632339478,
-0.2817274034023285,
0.92246413230896,
-0.12780894339084625,
-0.05772810056805611,
0.18528024852275848,
0.8517425060272217,
-0.4263950288295746,
-0.005797749385237694,
0.4827592968940735,
0.40253788232803345,
0.19791078567504883,
-0.03900284692645073,
0.5470045208930969,
-0.7330528497695923,
0.5680853128433228,
-0.22200411558151245,
-0.5991944670677185,
0.26742658019065857,
-0.4053703248500824,
-0.831794798374176,
-0.9219494462013245,
-0.7178182005882263,
-0.4952560067176819,
0.04669341444969177,
0.9754891991615295,
0.9234798550605774,
-1.2959089279174805,
-0.18556150794029236,
-0.11196932196617126,
-0.5540624260902405,
-0.0475882813334465,
-0.16681955754756927,
0.29652267694473267,
-0.12855620682239532,
-0.5951752662658691,
0.5232963562011719,
-0.08280730247497559,
0.4020620286464691,
0.11791611462831497,
-0.16084441542625427,
-0.23234790563583374,
0.16564200818538666,
0.1650543063879013,
0.5545759797096252,
-0.4213114082813263,
-0.02386035956442356,
-0.15713484585285187,
0.10591747611761093,
0.2100895494222641,
0.4853559136390686,
-0.854814887046814,
0.6381756067276001,
0.06218956038355827,
0.32365912199020386,
0.6708889603614807,
0.4754215180873871,
0.597093939781189,
-0.7209107279777527,
0.16460971534252167,
0.13248935341835022,
0.1347278654575348,
0.4684253931045532,
-0.31478866934776306,
0.32936447858810425,
0.04819314181804657,
-0.6993253827095032,
-1.0222071409225464,
-0.009702164679765701,
-1.053283452987671,
0.14635194838047028,
1.2325953245162964,
-0.1995081752538681,
-0.09169156849384308,
-0.4196292757987976,
0.050471216440200806,
0.5835074782371521,
-0.5480397939682007,
0.8079804182052612,
0.428878515958786,
-0.06880384683609009,
-0.1666126698255539,
-0.31107503175735474,
0.5406962633132935,
-0.2788585424423218,
-0.5755251049995422,
0.05249139666557312,
0.5796489119529724,
0.7954545021057129,
0.3029918372631073,
0.7563604712486267,
-0.34847354888916016,
0.1499190479516983,
0.1343165785074234,
-0.14818228781223297,
-0.28627243638038635,
-0.344845175743103,
-0.6465303897857666,
0.07881064713001251,
0.06898535043001175,
-0.6590805053710938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07304v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07304v2
|
We're Calling an Intervention: Exploring the Fundamental Hurdles in Adapting Language Models to Nonstandard Text
| 2024-04-10T18:56:53 | 2024-06-16T02:09:44 |
Aarohi Srivastava, David Chiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present a suite of experiments that allow us to understand the underlying
challenges of language model adaptation to nonstandard text. We do so by
designing interventions that approximate several types of linguistic variation
and their interactions with existing biases of language models. Applying our
interventions during language model adaptation with varying size and nature of
training data, we gain important insights into when knowledge transfer can be
successful, as well as the aspects of linguistic variation that are
particularly difficult for language models to deal with. For instance, on text
with character-level variation, performance improves with even a few training
examples but approaches a plateau, suggesting that more data is not the
solution. In contrast, on text with variation involving new words or meanings,
far more data is needed, but it leads to a massive breakthrough in performance.
Our findings reveal that existing models lack the necessary infrastructure to
handle diverse forms of nonstandard text and linguistic variation, guiding the
development of more resilient language modeling techniques for the future. We
make the code for our interventions, which can be applied to any English text
data, publicly available.
|
[
-0.10829763859510422,
-0.7293980717658997,
0.4359804689884186,
0.2351459413766861,
0.08536901324987411,
0.058575961738824844,
-0.15499189496040344,
-0.33550751209259033,
-0.043741777539253235,
0.4548255503177643,
-0.46228182315826416,
-0.2648845613002777,
-0.8782153129577637,
0.36222460865974426,
-0.26437854766845703,
0.9801398515701294,
-0.3106156885623932,
0.07222117483615875,
-0.1540399193763733,
-0.32178157567977905,
-0.9346930384635925,
-0.4179542064666748,
-0.4374469220638275,
-0.15323954820632935,
0.37686455249786377,
0.622003972530365,
0.4023832380771637,
0.2991204857826233,
0.670086145401001,
0.24058344960212708,
-0.18199577927589417,
0.04643996059894562,
-0.6844314336776733,
-0.12868009507656097,
-0.43388187885284424,
-0.7416393160820007,
-0.12178200483322144,
0.08987534046173096,
0.870290994644165,
0.9715433120727539,
0.042376358062028885,
-0.23692195117473602,
0.10060329735279083,
0.7813521027565002,
-0.6620814204216003,
-0.06960071623325348,
-0.47383978962898254,
-0.10448645800352097,
-0.10749887675046921,
-0.010584378615021706,
-0.36743399500846863,
-0.4046216607093811,
0.17567424476146698,
-0.6019602417945862,
0.23038218915462494,
0.10197961330413818,
0.6088990569114685,
0.15246348083019257,
-0.5109128355979919,
-0.5011613368988037,
-0.7966742515563965,
0.8218746781349182,
-0.8132724165916443,
0.2798674404621124,
0.44478651881217957,
0.02083510346710682,
-0.35619258880615234,
-0.4591650664806366,
-0.47373440861701965,
-0.4349316358566284,
0.09504597634077072,
-0.025535820052027702,
-0.22632180154323578,
0.02800584025681019,
0.2240350842475891,
0.18545030057430267,
-0.27976956963539124,
0.2010030597448349,
-0.38584578037261963,
-0.020913140848279,
0.5948173999786377,
0.2943376898765564,
0.587057888507843,
-0.1445101946592331,
0.015549775213003159,
-0.07417351752519608,
-0.449063777923584,
0.28540515899658203,
0.3692081868648529,
0.49596089124679565,
-0.5419999361038208,
0.5006412863731384,
-0.050562966614961624,
0.4747271239757538,
-0.11226227134466171,
0.04528249800205231,
0.1157873198390007,
-0.30511602759361267,
-0.10833561420440674,
-0.19504016637802124,
0.5649442672729492,
0.24020491540431976,
0.11605055630207062,
-0.20084552466869354,
-0.26503074169158936,
-0.22740253806114197,
0.2987108528614044,
-0.6740138530731201,
-0.39523380994796753,
0.05278540030121803,
-0.2880095839500427,
-0.2926720380783081,
-0.37393516302108765,
-0.95020592212677,
-0.5862776637077332,
-0.02926437184214592,
0.6644654870033264,
-0.5991829037666321,
-0.41453930735588074,
0.18603040277957916,
-0.4025813043117523,
0.1336212456226349,
0.339645653963089,
-1.0281902551651,
0.15145091712474823,
0.4608863890171051,
0.9735720157623291,
-0.0772385448217392,
-0.4195793867111206,
-0.15855175256729126,
-0.06351333856582642,
-0.6412811279296875,
0.8421489000320435,
-0.9473336338996887,
-0.7136898636817932,
0.1535765677690506,
0.2186974734067917,
-0.5403854250907898,
-0.31362539529800415,
0.5926908850669861,
-0.14222678542137146,
0.3057175576686859,
-0.5035085082054138,
-0.6818045377731323,
-0.011446119286119938,
0.11575538665056229,
-0.7666588425636292,
0.7928224205970764,
0.2097843438386917,
-1.0258489847183228,
0.13982358574867249,
-1.1447253227233887,
-0.4358174800872803,
-0.1801375448703766,
0.13783489167690277,
-0.3050939440727234,
0.7342742085456848,
0.08725897967815399,
-0.09070193022489548,
-0.3442364037036896,
-0.03528155758976936,
-0.33446773886680603,
-0.26763442158699036,
0.6455426216125488,
-0.49026280641555786,
0.3751719295978546,
-0.2363962084054947,
-0.18857671320438385,
-0.03605825826525688,
-0.7513017058372498,
-0.27236342430114746,
0.12361528724431992,
-0.2137020230293274,
-0.634244441986084,
0.09721078723669052,
0.3745594620704651,
-0.02451329305768013,
0.2328573763370514,
-0.37488874793052673,
0.27040717005729675,
-0.4809669256210327,
0.36598145961761475,
0.847845733165741,
0.108126699924469,
0.6962742209434509,
-0.4168228805065155,
0.8255042433738708,
-0.15324091911315918,
0.04769928753376007,
-0.14166389405727386,
-0.50338214635849,
-0.7486429214477539,
-0.13374453783035278,
0.5213313102722168,
0.3886851668357849,
-0.9124029278755188,
-0.11046341806650162,
-0.23932668566703796,
-0.26744744181632996,
-0.5907447934150696,
-0.009786094538867474,
0.4908972680568695,
0.6080389022827148,
0.2222011238336563,
-0.3560592234134674,
-0.4046456217765808,
-0.9162847995758057,
-0.5176961421966553,
-0.2781067490577698,
-0.04654388874769211,
0.2470412254333496,
0.6380525231361389,
-0.0827864557504654,
0.8983655571937561,
-0.24448728561401367,
-0.14749065041542053,
-0.3111734688282013,
0.6147541403770447,
0.03307360038161278,
0.52840256690979,
0.460647314786911,
-0.6697640419006348,
-0.5871989130973816,
0.05916159227490425,
-0.5889803171157837,
-0.3851368725299835,
-0.33155834674835205,
0.06214269623160362,
0.17485174536705017,
0.4187086522579193,
0.03169543668627739,
0.2578597068786621,
0.8053573966026306,
-0.19601699709892273,
0.505126416683197,
-0.26187294721603394,
0.25308412313461304,
-1.0144768953323364,
0.09530371427536011,
-0.192572221159935,
0.02948303334414959,
-1.2808566093444824,
-0.10449131578207016,
0.15345624089241028,
-0.017437173053622246,
-0.3287407457828522,
0.4319499433040619,
-0.32340875267982483,
0.39705154299736023,
-0.5199874043464661,
0.05162438005208969,
-0.02091108448803425,
0.21763427555561066,
0.19829854369163513,
1.0730676651000977,
0.5078637003898621,
-0.48645293712615967,
-0.38225650787353516,
0.3109666407108307,
-0.18650954961776733,
0.7453239560127258,
-0.4363628029823303,
0.3451366722583771,
-0.35800039768218994,
-0.14773687720298767,
-0.962437629699707,
-0.4010730981826782,
0.15916068851947784,
-0.3320746421813965,
0.44186902046203613,
-0.1599150151014328,
-0.002524607814848423,
-0.05616270750761032,
-0.37905967235565186,
0.3490711748600006,
0.3417254090309143,
-0.24234986305236816,
0.5740041732788086,
0.3984743356704712,
-0.27477961778640747,
-0.2810177206993103,
-0.7001767158508301,
0.42597439885139465,
-0.28526318073272705,
-0.3806264102458954,
0.04494502395391464,
-0.1879323273897171,
-0.07514549791812897,
0.09694769233465195,
-0.0701240599155426,
-0.34046486020088196,
0.42815616726875305,
-0.03002985753118992,
0.01802152208983898,
-0.2646957039833069,
0.19828683137893677,
0.3137124180793762,
-0.01780523546040058,
0.021861154586076736,
-0.11229101568460464,
-0.00528992572799325,
0.18029245734214783,
-0.37243708968162537,
-0.544701099395752,
0.5850574970245361,
0.5097070336341858,
0.06151731684803963,
0.9569231867790222,
0.27959755063056946,
-0.41297802329063416,
-0.1495790332555771,
-0.2726892828941345,
-0.06504291296005249,
-0.4854530394077301,
0.7155609726905823,
-0.37491166591644287,
-0.9645281434059143,
0.08145953714847565,
-0.16922527551651,
0.16634611785411835,
0.10917909443378448,
0.4443950057029724,
-0.1330185979604721,
0.7983569502830505,
1.1035603284835815,
-0.02809121459722519,
0.6220753192901611,
0.2669790983200073,
0.4456302523612976,
-0.872253954410553,
-0.14362776279449463,
-0.6206251382827759,
-0.2533615231513977,
-0.6067810654640198,
-0.6856784224510193,
0.11720330268144608,
0.3251591622829437,
0.1648971438407898,
0.37652626633644104,
-0.25139516592025757,
0.2556125819683075,
0.08666574209928513,
-0.07161147892475128,
0.19627219438552856,
-0.17692930996418,
0.2793998420238495,
-0.5283622145652771,
-0.8288779854774475,
-0.46889761090278625,
1.2191197872161865,
0.40591269731521606,
0.7088162899017334,
0.21597743034362793,
0.36227357387542725,
0.2983913719654083,
0.8263668417930603,
-0.5905398726463318,
0.10285020619630814,
-0.1505221575498581,
-0.5836189389228821,
-0.320972740650177,
-0.575355052947998,
-0.9438197612762451,
0.07444924116134644,
-0.2806060016155243,
-0.659970223903656,
0.5188372731208801,
0.15036949515342712,
0.11658506840467453,
0.1632654070854187,
-0.8924509882926941,
0.6336859464645386,
-0.06524387747049332,
-0.07617665827274323,
0.05442626029253006,
-0.2425399273633957,
0.3011678457260132,
-0.5248833894729614,
0.758009135723114,
-0.07764337956905365,
-0.12749208509922028,
0.7734631896018982,
-0.13118590414524078,
0.9604904651641846,
-0.18672874569892883,
-0.17302384972572327,
0.05170835554599762,
0.09419550746679306,
0.6022999286651611,
-0.08651106059551239,
-0.02464536763727665,
0.1284158080816269,
-0.052529774606227875,
-0.7391535043716431,
-0.5619858503341675,
0.28527358174324036,
-0.798421323299408,
-0.5906850099563599,
-0.24276389181613922,
-0.9581374526023865,
-0.5506374835968018,
-0.14795099198818207,
0.10359923541545868,
0.13520179688930511,
-0.5897443294525146,
0.2072092443704605,
0.6757247447967529,
-0.4398972690105438,
0.4666222631931305,
0.8227996230125427,
0.03108946420252323,
-0.416885644197464,
0.9645563960075378,
0.042457595467567444,
0.5528287291526794,
0.5233907103538513,
0.2555178999900818,
-0.18704891204833984,
-0.9668248891830444,
-0.09507270157337189,
0.1319970041513443,
-0.5274031162261963,
0.19510391354560852,
-0.6363860368728638,
-0.057646870613098145,
-0.5880044102668762,
-0.1609756052494049,
-0.42742690443992615,
-0.3306107223033905,
-0.32831430435180664,
0.004862204659730196,
0.5563759803771973,
0.9796355366706848,
-0.32648640871047974,
0.42531514167785645,
-0.8362468481063843,
0.08512910455465317,
0.18122431635856628,
0.24550580978393555,
-0.1009536013007164,
-1.0539376735687256,
-0.619773805141449,
0.008601108565926552,
-0.16364283859729767,
-1.101741909980774,
0.3172203600406647,
0.33882248401641846,
0.3023034930229187,
0.10169664770364761,
0.0368247888982296,
0.6129858493804932,
-0.6913679242134094,
0.7368080019950867,
0.22261980175971985,
-1.0600594282150269,
0.3161123991012573,
-0.3096299469470978,
0.17331118881702423,
0.6093779802322388,
0.4165176451206207,
-0.7975254654884338,
-0.40102794766426086,
-0.3016316592693329,
-0.8057043552398682,
0.7870316505432129,
0.48225268721580505,
0.41130125522613525,
0.19143760204315186,
0.5225703716278076,
-0.014566383324563503,
0.262572318315506,
-0.6053075194358826,
0.05670134723186493,
-0.31119316816329956,
-0.24087116122245789,
-0.1447017937898636,
-0.29555103182792664,
-0.2212284654378891,
0.15523560345172882,
0.5041202306747437,
-0.26697948575019836,
0.12198688089847565,
0.25380241870880127,
-0.2925226390361786,
-0.05411669984459877,
0.30448204278945923,
0.683454692363739,
0.40179136395454407,
0.09472619742155075,
-0.14202120900154114,
0.45022374391555786,
-0.5451682209968567,
0.023087667301297188,
-0.0397789403796196,
-0.037160709500312805,
-0.051009755581617355,
0.7859495878219604,
1.065855860710144,
0.4763987958431244,
-0.6510018706321716,
0.3604077100753784,
-0.16716426610946655,
-0.41330686211586,
0.12411972135305405,
0.019682154059410095,
0.11567788571119308,
0.13965150713920593,
0.06675640493631363,
-0.2056306153535843,
-0.06329818069934845,
-0.424416184425354,
0.12366309762001038,
0.25798332691192627,
-0.6558302044868469,
-0.5630013346672058,
0.6024929881095886,
0.16281914710998535,
-0.7613217234611511,
0.2749319076538086,
0.03375425189733505,
-0.3154415190219879,
0.6455162167549133,
0.7165848016738892,
0.7634429335594177,
-0.41317877173423767,
0.4460468590259552,
0.022341333329677582,
0.6923900246620178,
-0.09220223128795624,
0.26423951983451843,
0.3578667640686035,
-0.6187695860862732,
-0.4828837513923645,
-0.5023432374000549,
-0.603981077671051,
0.18923774361610413,
-0.6493305563926697,
0.15795481204986572,
-0.5898743271827698,
0.15732601284980774,
-0.20931600034236908,
-0.3390541970729828,
-0.35176214575767517,
-0.03254608064889908,
-0.042716462165117264,
1.2287547588348389,
-1.4282034635543823,
0.7881903052330017,
0.6740812063217163,
-0.38451525568962097,
-0.610233724117279,
0.30907803773880005,
-0.11539046466350555,
-0.558564305305481,
0.17956671118736267,
-0.025067128241062164,
0.2700634002685547,
-0.05202600732445717,
-0.4257422685623169,
-0.7844680547714233,
0.5549187660217285,
0.4464688301086426,
-0.5733471512794495,
-0.04489554837346077,
0.47982147336006165,
0.6971483826637268,
-0.3586753010749817,
0.17311811447143555,
0.7746334671974182,
0.6854206323623657,
-0.17860956490039825,
-0.7959540486335754,
0.020013421773910522,
-0.2364179641008377,
0.32534417510032654,
0.16395531594753265,
-0.5161981582641602,
0.7210503220558167,
0.13946181535720825,
-0.0012260889634490013,
0.30686861276626587,
0.563444972038269,
-0.1180005893111229,
0.2582661509513855,
0.33705130219459534,
0.25337597727775574,
0.7837027907371521,
0.01999030075967312,
1.0800296068191528,
-0.22667790949344635,
0.42448773980140686,
0.9803881049156189,
-0.25818368792533875,
0.6586743593215942,
0.5832059979438782,
-0.21750788390636444,
0.390347957611084,
0.47571173310279846,
0.24431921541690826,
0.6248984932899475,
0.04243003576993942,
-0.34683355689048767,
-0.09928235411643982,
-0.28088855743408203,
-0.354868620634079,
0.038809582591056824,
0.49870920181274414,
-0.0699467808008194,
-0.24215295910835266,
0.360821932554245,
-0.04209872707724571,
0.3280404806137085,
-0.01318639051169157,
0.5877322554588318,
0.06322421878576279,
-0.32152172923088074,
0.6050765514373779,
0.23617315292358398,
0.49375593662261963,
-0.5219906568527222,
-0.06371550261974335,
-0.3406547009944916,
-0.11476514488458633,
0.010880919173359871,
-0.37966811656951904,
0.44635120034217834,
-0.012740940786898136,
-0.24135960638523102,
-0.14200438559055328,
0.41267046332359314,
-0.3620058000087738,
-0.568098247051239,
0.27252742648124695,
0.31892409920692444,
0.14235103130340576,
0.10617252439260483,
-0.7000443339347839,
0.06963616609573364,
0.1090177372097969,
-0.08950041234493256,
0.5357821583747864,
0.8157737255096436,
-0.16966690123081207,
0.3573642373085022,
0.7235612273216248,
0.06339716166257858,
0.16564786434173584,
0.09601902216672897,
0.8233439326286316,
-0.701362133026123,
-0.28351977467536926,
-0.5742670297622681,
0.5748642086982727,
0.022242341190576553,
-0.4006917476654053,
0.6182325482368469,
0.20647533237934113,
0.40037471055984497,
-0.025175796821713448,
0.9001719355583191,
-0.013764197006821632,
0.30245447158813477,
-0.532383918762207,
0.6381422877311707,
-0.716611385345459,
0.22717908024787903,
-0.26804840564727783,
-0.34756866097450256,
-0.24888163805007935,
0.3243192434310913,
-0.34213200211524963,
-0.22661373019218445,
0.9573461413383484,
0.79425448179245,
0.11427826434373856,
0.13429881632328033,
0.4520895481109619,
0.6018754839897156,
0.5017400979995728,
0.651966392993927,
0.7617911100387573,
-0.23519007861614227,
0.4155031442642212,
0.0636710450053215,
-0.6767013669013977,
-0.10089193284511566,
-0.878637969493866,
-1.069738507270813,
-0.5152351260185242,
-0.18010129034519196,
-0.3171900808811188,
0.48981380462646484,
0.6291303634643555,
0.2871754467487335,
-0.8843880891799927,
-0.21482537686824799,
-0.5672031044960022,
0.3202610909938812,
0.011437663808465004,
-0.18839465081691742,
0.2644032835960388,
-0.6320199370384216,
-1.0575615167617798,
0.5757301449775696,
0.2812374234199524,
0.039324499666690826,
-0.1005922257900238,
0.14510056376457214,
-0.11594638973474503,
0.5586698651313782,
0.26376423239707947,
0.49374598264694214,
-0.1821388304233551,
-0.5021302103996277,
0.03173845261335373,
0.1494912952184677,
0.14081217348575592,
1.061367154121399,
-0.32918140292167664,
0.4056006968021393,
0.3852376937866211,
0.9931696653366089,
0.09059324860572815,
-0.3863484859466553,
0.7651973962783813,
-0.6112950444221497,
0.2941361367702484,
0.10886485129594803,
0.0959627702832222,
0.433933287858963,
-0.26567038893699646,
0.15161235630512238,
0.3971311151981354,
-0.312621533870697,
-1.1409283876419067,
0.417942076921463,
-0.2871473729610443,
-0.3329203128814697,
1.0353130102157593,
-0.23072881996631622,
-0.23601454496383667,
-0.4188193082809448,
-0.07470647990703583,
0.10918257385492325,
-0.20943385362625122,
1.1338891983032227,
0.978080153465271,
0.01902669109404087,
-0.1731402575969696,
-0.7547187209129333,
0.5282975435256958,
0.6882221698760986,
-0.8030775189399719,
0.21767878532409668,
0.1398298293352127,
0.5524117350578308,
0.038115356117486954,
0.7168083190917969,
-0.11845693737268448,
0.16240818798542023,
0.05035474896430969,
0.01648523472249508,
0.287958025932312,
-0.32781946659088135,
-0.8406379222869873,
0.0484967939555645,
0.3066602647304535,
0.0014032345497980714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08700v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08700v2
|
DyKnow:Dynamically Verifying Time-Sensitive Factual Knowledge in LLMs
| 2024-04-10T18:08:59 | 2024-06-12T13:44:10 |
Seyed Mahed Mousavi, Simone Alghisi, Giuseppe Riccardi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
LLMs acquire knowledge from massive data snapshots collected at different
timestamps. Their knowledge is then commonly evaluated using static benchmarks.
However, factual knowledge is generally subject to time-sensitive changes, and
static benchmarks cannot address those cases. We present an approach to
dynamically evaluate the knowledge in LLMs and their time-sensitiveness against
Wikidata, a publicly available up-to-date knowledge graph. We evaluate the
time-sensitive knowledge in twenty-four private and open-source LLMs, as well
as the effectiveness of four editing methods in updating the outdated facts.
Our results show that 1) outdatedness is a critical problem across
state-of-the-art LLMs; 2) LLMs output inconsistent answers when prompted with
slight variations of the question prompt; and 3) the performance of the
state-of-the-art knowledge editing algorithms is very limited, as they can not
reduce the cases of outdatedness and output inconsistency.
|
[
0.013475769199430943,
-1.0055042505264282,
0.9138228297233582,
0.09148601442575455,
-0.19900920987129211,
0.6713919043540955,
-0.1775539666414261,
-0.7273779511451721,
-0.1058526411652565,
0.0404980331659317,
-0.6950961351394653,
-0.6913318634033203,
-0.47347190976142883,
0.29178500175476074,
-0.35244908928871155,
0.8252686262130737,
-0.588611364364624,
-0.26161259412765503,
-0.5413835644721985,
-0.4047941267490387,
-0.21727354824543,
-0.25143685936927795,
0.01816285401582718,
-0.31884169578552246,
0.6766586899757385,
0.3398825526237488,
0.6156443357467651,
0.663438618183136,
0.4576962888240814,
0.3597821593284607,
-0.4243357181549072,
0.5780127048492432,
-0.5851176977157593,
0.5055860280990601,
-0.4094313979148865,
-0.5014835596084595,
-0.5846627950668335,
-0.05626475438475609,
0.5738471150398254,
0.48312076926231384,
0.01920218952000141,
0.6874539256095886,
-0.10963180661201477,
0.6547511219978333,
-0.884956419467926,
0.2564362585544586,
-0.9543880224227905,
0.24348056316375732,
-0.3164730370044708,
-0.36552754044532776,
-0.11140958219766617,
-0.6615405082702637,
0.11071967333555222,
-0.8477435111999512,
0.03352080285549164,
-0.18226833641529083,
0.7326595783233643,
0.5482786297798157,
-0.6488622426986694,
-0.3928098678588867,
-0.9405577778816223,
0.41471579670906067,
-0.5536347031593323,
0.24119417369365692,
0.14739243686199188,
0.5681713223457336,
-0.2286553978919983,
-1.0831257104873657,
-0.7301864624023438,
-0.21889124810695648,
0.15330979228019714,
0.031161973252892494,
-0.046779561787843704,
-0.24985893070697784,
0.5848158001899719,
0.4884603023529053,
-0.11519969999790192,
0.17808601260185242,
-0.2249853014945984,
-0.22482147812843323,
0.562664806842804,
0.48092368245124817,
0.13998697698116302,
-0.30206725001335144,
-0.44457361102104187,
0.2595774531364441,
-0.6410256624221802,
-0.08484794944524765,
0.4658086895942688,
-0.19220595061779022,
0.035091910511255264,
0.9077630043029785,
-0.5484128594398499,
0.6782585382461548,
0.3883618414402008,
-0.4530937373638153,
0.04441070184111595,
-0.24637553095817566,
-0.06412190943956375,
0.0487864725291729,
0.31017300486564636,
0.6001361012458801,
-0.07762989401817322,
-0.41836145520210266,
-0.03850529342889786,
-0.0009291626047343016,
0.0880274698138237,
-0.3663668930530548,
-0.027309251949191093,
0.57599937915802,
-0.1804080754518509,
-0.6283335089683533,
-0.3002403676509857,
-0.8153746724128723,
-0.7092238664627075,
-0.21230146288871765,
0.411037802696228,
-0.08461260050535202,
-0.12574662268161774,
-0.18623287975788116,
-0.13718654215335846,
-0.2277025580406189,
0.6005892753601074,
-0.3718660771846771,
-0.05828413739800453,
0.6406624913215637,
0.7370172142982483,
-0.2764204144477844,
-0.27779242396354675,
-0.1757054179906845,
0.4125388562679291,
-0.2894929051399231,
0.6141283512115479,
-0.1734694242477417,
-0.09345711767673492,
-0.09059885144233704,
-0.05900956690311432,
0.1726880520582199,
-0.434693306684494,
0.22779352962970734,
-1.1614935398101807,
0.17238037288188934,
-0.6678080558776855,
-0.9061452746391296,
0.15389299392700195,
0.6391870975494385,
-0.6588467359542847,
1.0365804433822632,
0.31880125403404236,
-1.1595489978790283,
0.7331235408782959,
-0.39994168281555176,
-0.1387624591588974,
0.13692060112953186,
-0.07027646899223328,
-0.24068190157413483,
-0.1659127175807953,
0.09046635776758194,
0.2812923789024353,
0.14510048925876617,
0.3596411943435669,
-0.5308231115341187,
-0.2836257517337799,
0.7257348895072937,
-0.5940966606140137,
0.7068079710006714,
0.3569256365299225,
-0.579450249671936,
-0.15053921937942505,
-1.1618558168411255,
0.020190933719277382,
0.11863604933023453,
-0.8021587133407593,
-0.251569539308548,
0.1390802562236786,
-0.6582331657409668,
0.17196030914783478,
0.6454127430915833,
-0.7311762571334839,
0.40880730748176575,
0.0009436399559490383,
0.2436210811138153,
1.1103368997573853,
0.3159637153148651,
0.01968008279800415,
-0.47906672954559326,
0.29854878783226013,
-0.05547568202018738,
0.40422654151916504,
0.3348041772842407,
-0.19210687279701233,
-0.6874481439590454,
-0.00666704960167408,
0.30702027678489685,
0.678067684173584,
-0.9971737861633301,
0.2121722251176834,
-0.5456027388572693,
-0.6806074976921082,
-0.17017795145511627,
0.3192574977874756,
0.022145820781588554,
0.8373441696166992,
0.3076741695404053,
0.10399588942527771,
-0.4395960867404938,
-0.5051676630973816,
-0.47292274236679077,
-0.4312494397163391,
0.06893972307443619,
0.40634140372276306,
0.4521416127681732,
-0.16556134819984436,
0.9076671600341797,
-0.5489510893821716,
0.24933992326259613,
0.4367023706436157,
-0.0489010289311409,
0.1635187864303589,
-0.11968272179365158,
0.27847179770469666,
-0.45053932070732117,
-0.35209769010543823,
-0.08130419999361038,
-1.1181973218917847,
-0.19228658080101013,
0.1420612782239914,
0.1373649686574936,
0.3548400104045868,
0.4714655876159668,
-0.8126407861709595,
0.31019750237464905,
0.5025691390037537,
-0.5363627672195435,
0.6939584612846375,
-0.24682533740997314,
0.4340176284313202,
-0.7358865141868591,
0.17426130175590515,
-0.5612109899520874,
-0.37196582555770874,
-0.2741736173629761,
-0.026887496933341026,
0.07810772210359573,
0.007676011882722378,
-0.5492022633552551,
0.6158867478370667,
-0.4098360240459442,
-0.07093092799186707,
0.024553077295422554,
0.414278507232666,
-0.07315423339605331,
0.21333687007427216,
-0.5739756226539612,
0.5891212224960327,
0.03332123905420303,
-0.7965273857116699,
1.0243014097213745,
0.037304122000932693,
-0.9294257760047913,
0.5857229828834534,
-0.44433045387268066,
0.32975253462791443,
0.02799316681921482,
0.16016729176044464,
-0.8106898069381714,
-0.27652600407600403,
0.396729439496994,
-0.15367043018341064,
0.2914535403251648,
-0.2039976865053177,
-0.5868673920631409,
-0.39906322956085205,
-0.28634411096572876,
0.2199133038520813,
0.13026198744773865,
-0.6984313130378723,
0.5320188403129578,
0.20054949820041656,
-0.08907057344913483,
-0.9591418504714966,
-0.39221540093421936,
-0.024437392130494118,
-0.038075853139162064,
-0.7821571230888367,
0.2302219271659851,
-0.06208372488617897,
-0.7352097630500793,
0.5206722021102905,
-0.5303977131843567,
0.053847793489694595,
0.33185163140296936,
0.06008093059062958,
0.126993790268898,
0.07860308140516281,
0.13678081333637238,
-0.01855333521962166,
0.04328268766403198,
0.11863870918750763,
-0.3189157545566559,
0.08998323231935501,
0.22475461661815643,
-0.6979582905769348,
-0.22734498977661133,
-0.3026029169559479,
0.9700687527656555,
0.2281375527381897,
0.5373205542564392,
0.4975356459617615,
-0.4407776892185211,
-0.16049617528915405,
-0.8060418367385864,
0.15288305282592773,
-0.5021758675575256,
0.2807994484901428,
-0.10380219668149948,
-0.7377486824989319,
0.5986380577087402,
-0.2236795723438263,
0.3448086977005005,
0.5757650136947632,
0.7860782742500305,
-0.3286130130290985,
0.5362046957015991,
0.12328679114580154,
0.16955989599227905,
0.20276638865470886,
-0.03692921623587608,
-0.17209693789482117,
-0.4865726828575134,
-0.6611536741256714,
-0.2732994258403778,
-0.4678868055343628,
-0.6893072128295898,
-0.45241132378578186,
0.4502515196800232,
-0.22254420816898346,
-0.12916205823421478,
-0.24160000681877136,
-0.12217963486909866,
0.3913072645664215,
0.18392297625541687,
0.3711853325366974,
0.7237955927848816,
-0.05291816592216492,
-0.2511630058288574,
0.022405745461583138,
-0.5967912673950195,
-0.5726382732391357,
1.121303677558899,
0.3261323869228363,
0.8785820603370667,
0.23519940674304962,
0.16820333898067474,
0.7564740777015686,
0.21105346083641052,
-0.3668443560600281,
0.5109103322029114,
-0.01355633046478033,
-0.960055947303772,
-0.5258540511131287,
-0.6999148726463318,
-0.6246655583381653,
-0.1825580596923828,
-0.34213951230049133,
-0.45630934834480286,
0.16935990750789642,
0.32899296283721924,
-0.18720553815364838,
0.8008612990379333,
-0.4575861990451813,
0.3863469362258911,
-0.38111141324043274,
-0.6268001794815063,
-0.28925657272338867,
-0.49018633365631104,
0.34446069598197937,
-0.18105749785900116,
0.18257871270179749,
-0.602268397808075,
-0.24944768846035004,
0.6339576840400696,
-0.5793156623840332,
0.9532166719436646,
-0.4947407841682434,
-0.23146842420101166,
0.21452154219150543,
0.337821900844574,
0.703964352607727,
0.32900482416152954,
0.027731139212846756,
0.09566085785627365,
0.24909669160842896,
-0.4144473671913147,
-0.8432254791259766,
0.6868366599082947,
-0.9582402110099792,
-0.651181161403656,
-0.49323180317878723,
-0.6138925552368164,
-0.5076047778129578,
0.17869338393211365,
0.2809702157974243,
0.3166268765926361,
-0.22003215551376343,
-0.07443197071552277,
0.771615207195282,
-0.2547493278980255,
0.16845841705799103,
0.8202934861183167,
-0.13168446719646454,
-0.3502163887023926,
0.5529731512069702,
0.6174689531326294,
0.23569899797439575,
0.42581599950790405,
0.2334606796503067,
-0.28298935294151306,
-0.5969963669776917,
-0.35392051935195923,
0.15186898410320282,
-1.0889525413513184,
-0.22320540249347687,
-0.6480865478515625,
-0.051996491849422455,
-0.14196696877479553,
0.08432286232709885,
-0.33201491832733154,
-0.9246715307235718,
-0.1272004097700119,
-0.25641492009162903,
0.6824091076850891,
1.004414439201355,
-0.11620751768350601,
-0.39728641510009766,
-0.6711962223052979,
0.32876551151275635,
0.7880429029464722,
0.5629596710205078,
-0.0831737145781517,
-0.3323110044002533,
-0.09775669127702713,
-0.068863146007061,
-0.14163219928741455,
-0.8175355195999146,
-0.5232512354850769,
-0.11119583249092102,
0.7982905507087708,
0.2561827003955841,
0.4096005856990814,
0.442604124546051,
-0.29970046877861023,
0.8100740909576416,
-0.21794743835926056,
-0.8514487743377686,
0.5219724178314209,
-0.28968846797943115,
0.3753092288970947,
0.6164127588272095,
0.42744019627571106,
-0.6085715889930725,
-0.4730030298233032,
-0.6019625663757324,
-0.6984144449234009,
0.31290072202682495,
0.03880704566836357,
-0.03413790464401245,
0.25950688123703003,
0.7040679454803467,
0.19028142094612122,
0.2755796015262604,
-0.3651346266269684,
-0.43661263585090637,
-0.22926698625087738,
-0.18466386198997498,
0.27637726068496704,
-0.6917515993118286,
-0.4412632882595062,
-0.2048351764678955,
0.5924694538116455,
0.15969957411289215,
-0.004580439999699593,
0.33076050877571106,
-0.32315924763679504,
-0.26715683937072754,
0.394657164812088,
0.6038309335708618,
1.3978220224380493,
-0.44703713059425354,
0.2523176670074463,
0.7844395041465759,
-0.6481648683547974,
0.48328495025634766,
-0.04222320765256882,
-0.45974424481391907,
0.1515360176563263,
0.6267663836479187,
0.632954478263855,
0.3284662961959839,
-0.28533822298049927,
0.3969385623931885,
-0.1841217577457428,
-0.05837215483188629,
-0.23955121636390686,
0.023544838652014732,
-0.006096906494349241,
0.40090441703796387,
0.30458343029022217,
-0.06536702811717987,
-0.2909126579761505,
-0.3558046221733093,
0.05470261350274086,
-0.10970824211835861,
-0.026463942602276802,
-0.3640543818473816,
0.5364106297492981,
0.28319987654685974,
0.02277841791510582,
0.5346524119377136,
0.03682679310441017,
-0.4047376215457916,
0.26963773369789124,
0.061134133487939835,
0.48476189374923706,
-0.16242368519306183,
0.01670694723725319,
0.1581135392189026,
0.2638961970806122,
0.34701356291770935,
0.3955458402633667,
-0.16585075855255127,
-0.673536479473114,
-0.4451002776622772,
-0.2769089341163635,
-0.8171222805976868,
0.12478044629096985,
-0.5857372879981995,
0.272150456905365,
-0.6887205839157104,
-0.5502932667732239,
-0.22442403435707092,
0.460888534784317,
-0.7899500131607056,
0.08157802373170853,
-0.2455066293478012,
1.278627634048462,
-0.4772453308105469,
0.399907648563385,
0.6505623459815979,
0.112667016685009,
-0.47528180480003357,
0.009572405368089676,
0.2572832703590393,
-0.8242239952087402,
0.5618157982826233,
-0.4841345250606537,
0.009178469888865948,
-0.2847425043582916,
-0.4911995232105255,
-0.8260827660560608,
1.5899715423583984,
0.591613233089447,
-0.6807977557182312,
-0.10134365409612656,
0.04068318381905556,
0.436749130487442,
0.3514207601547241,
-0.20153428614139557,
0.38174968957901,
0.6362809538841248,
0.006828973535448313,
-0.7308171391487122,
0.12187289446592331,
-0.07383430004119873,
-0.4390527606010437,
-0.0818621814250946,
-0.6935819387435913,
0.5950070023536682,
-0.22863708436489105,
-0.4491698443889618,
-0.3086492419242859,
0.6957888603210449,
0.35991424322128296,
0.5189332962036133,
0.6648860573768616,
0.4686936140060425,
1.3775852918624878,
-0.08592671155929565,
0.8234503269195557,
-0.539260983467102,
0.24422162771224976,
1.0713874101638794,
-0.4143730401992798,
0.48567667603492737,
0.45060956478118896,
-0.38197988271713257,
0.5872532725334167,
0.6219950914382935,
-0.09429600834846497,
0.47684383392333984,
0.11139930784702301,
-0.6031379103660583,
-0.032002177089452744,
0.06214859336614609,
-0.564601480960846,
0.3370088040828705,
0.10614348948001862,
-0.04224016144871712,
-0.20622678101062775,
-0.34185394644737244,
0.38098031282424927,
-0.06505535542964935,
-0.19087162613868713,
0.8015896081924438,
-0.1529998481273651,
-0.47371411323547363,
0.321959525346756,
-0.024317864328622818,
0.39165592193603516,
-0.6372288465499878,
0.23563945293426514,
-0.19398967921733856,
0.268552303314209,
-0.4014676511287689,
-0.9864902496337891,
0.242539182305336,
0.3571010231971741,
-0.2419600933790207,
0.06246470659971237,
1.0785144567489624,
-0.06340312212705612,
-0.32548967003822327,
0.22978119552135468,
0.6229667067527771,
-0.2347223311662674,
0.3075031042098999,
-0.39972400665283203,
0.2096686065196991,
-0.2048281878232956,
-0.28641360998153687,
0.045408476144075394,
0.7923226356506348,
0.08255597949028015,
0.8363586068153381,
0.5720011591911316,
0.4020299017429352,
0.22660143673419952,
-0.13987550139427185,
0.9659744501113892,
-0.3415098190307617,
-0.29433855414390564,
-0.8970770835876465,
0.3855839967727661,
-0.3251647651195526,
-0.22054094076156616,
0.9790806174278259,
0.21369725465774536,
0.85240638256073,
0.15458598732948303,
0.7965080142021179,
-0.07869528234004974,
0.622373640537262,
-0.8125560879707336,
0.8733608722686768,
-0.3249596655368805,
0.5127535462379456,
-0.13639666140079498,
-0.7950900197029114,
0.07031198590993881,
-0.04136933013796806,
-0.30530470609664917,
-0.18492931127548218,
0.5693200826644897,
0.4922694265842438,
0.1563802808523178,
-0.018129955977201462,
0.1594759225845337,
0.49781763553619385,
0.3086184859275818,
0.2809793949127197,
1.3135986328125,
-0.0568704791367054,
0.6787635684013367,
-0.6224561929702759,
-0.18626253306865692,
-0.07631069421768188,
-1.285870909690857,
-0.6902164816856384,
-0.5069015026092529,
-0.5090177655220032,
-0.6068650484085083,
0.3787096440792084,
0.7612237334251404,
0.4036502242088318,
-0.5106521844863892,
0.23874081671237946,
0.5169640183448792,
0.5869230031967163,
-0.10175198316574097,
-0.16946503520011902,
0.4267885386943817,
-0.07103592157363892,
-0.16495782136917114,
0.439349889755249,
0.12145247310400009,
0.17813920974731445,
-0.4210103452205658,
0.09416721016168594,
-0.029666095972061157,
-0.04388939216732979,
0.4971684515476227,
0.17702320218086243,
-0.4247629642486572,
-0.5631123781204224,
0.05083393305540085,
-0.15942691266536713,
-0.1980622261762619,
0.8801723718643188,
-0.5670307278633118,
0.5600017309188843,
0.6132029294967651,
0.44600602984428406,
0.5437669157981873,
-0.07076330482959747,
0.29863500595092773,
-0.7939363718032837,
-0.14659938216209412,
0.0731191486120224,
0.21049097180366516,
0.47013869881629944,
-0.6368240714073181,
0.36915323138237,
0.6564804911613464,
-0.7252050042152405,
-0.8659605383872986,
0.06453800201416016,
-0.6766968965530396,
-0.2818543612957001,
1.050799012184143,
-0.4280712902545929,
-0.2765103876590729,
-0.5080711841583252,
0.27665963768959045,
0.5043966174125671,
0.08636066317558289,
1.2248352766036987,
0.9690556526184082,
0.1142759919166565,
0.4271049201488495,
-0.40011128783226013,
0.5182477831840515,
-0.23443953692913055,
-0.7702071070671082,
0.17674139142036438,
0.4118744730949402,
0.8822174668312073,
0.11053616553544998,
0.6571030020713806,
-0.3322531282901764,
0.3587273061275482,
0.07602096349000931,
-0.3329043388366699,
-0.5237696766853333,
-0.1345587968826294,
-0.1101674884557724,
0.11784329265356064,
0.39213666319847107,
-0.011569957248866558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07202v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07202v1
|
UMBRAE: Unified Multimodal Decoding of Brain Signals
| 2024-04-10T17:59:20 | 2024-04-10T17:59:20 |
Weihao Xia, Raoul de Charette, Cengiz Öztireli, Jing-Hao Xue
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We address prevailing challenges of the brain-powered research, departing
from the observation that the literature hardly recover accurate spatial
information and require subject-specific models. To address these challenges,
we propose UMBRAE, a unified multimodal decoding of brain signals. First, to
extract instance-level conceptual and spatial details from neural signals, we
introduce an efficient universal brain encoder for multimodal-brain alignment
and recover object descriptions at multiple levels of granularity from
subsequent multimodal large language model (MLLM). Second, we introduce a
cross-subject training strategy mapping subject-specific features to a common
feature space. This allows a model to be trained on multiple subjects without
extra resources, even yielding superior results compared to subject-specific
models. Further, we demonstrate this supports weakly-supervised adaptation to
new subjects, with only a fraction of the total training data. Experiments
demonstrate that UMBRAE not only achieves superior results in the newly
introduced tasks but also outperforms methods in well established tasks. To
assess our method, we construct and share with the community a comprehensive
brain understanding benchmark BrainHub. Our code and benchmark are available at
https://weihaox.github.io/UMBRAE.
|
[
-0.2710922062397003,
-0.729098916053772,
0.3411460220813751,
0.5639735460281372,
-0.3015632629394531,
-0.3382572531700134,
-0.3505794405937195,
-0.2268601953983307,
0.030661972239613533,
0.3450038731098175,
-0.49110928177833557,
-0.7727771997451782,
-0.4766767919063568,
-0.30104681849479675,
-0.35876718163490295,
0.7963854670524597,
0.21416550874710083,
0.30095094442367554,
-0.14982041716575623,
-0.41106030344963074,
-0.8867325782775879,
-0.6200025081634521,
-0.41524040699005127,
-0.33826228976249695,
0.7734086513519287,
0.05261069908738136,
0.2401333451271057,
0.430302232503891,
0.2709176540374756,
0.2692919969558716,
-0.09989877045154572,
0.20000939071178436,
-0.04179483279585838,
-0.10965797305107117,
-0.23959755897521973,
-0.24959658086299896,
-0.5934977531433105,
-0.4809729754924774,
0.3096669912338257,
1.3425939083099365,
-0.3615410625934601,
0.2612946033477783,
0.3703819215297699,
0.474139541387558,
-0.9836980700492859,
0.3372574746608734,
-0.27691277861595154,
0.09839431941509247,
-0.0007690317579545081,
-0.18806999921798706,
-0.7140017747879028,
-0.02124927006661892,
-0.10728819668292999,
-0.36038389801979065,
-0.0061806319281458855,
-0.06448821723461151,
0.5676194429397583,
0.16388987004756927,
-0.738108217716217,
0.2964295446872711,
-0.4839140474796295,
0.5620779991149902,
-0.30306193232536316,
0.6564642190933228,
0.0002164768084185198,
0.22865435481071472,
-0.12318816035985947,
-0.6910638213157654,
-0.3050278127193451,
0.16187864542007446,
-0.04320511966943741,
0.07198841869831085,
-0.48081523180007935,
-0.0241505429148674,
0.04865477979183197,
-0.19856515526771545,
-0.5165929198265076,
-0.0158731359988451,
-0.24076689779758453,
-0.3390718698501587,
0.34923791885375977,
0.19747097790241241,
0.3068263530731201,
-0.3712798058986664,
-0.33240658044815063,
-0.3537555932998657,
-0.4456292390823364,
0.11863277852535248,
-0.06011173874139786,
0.02811652235686779,
-0.07800761610269547,
0.4221464693546295,
-0.004543201066553593,
0.5997695922851562,
-0.08502761274576187,
0.18409302830696106,
0.21430793404579163,
-0.2959100902080536,
-0.1759035289287567,
-0.057682350277900696,
0.6454504132270813,
0.3379969000816345,
0.006780983414500952,
-0.6640498638153076,
0.23393364250659943,
0.22230130434036255,
0.29193803668022156,
-0.47923964262008667,
-0.5515527725219727,
0.14436517655849457,
-0.5960789918899536,
0.2779333293437958,
-0.033571064472198486,
-0.9027768969535828,
-0.4595798850059509,
-0.6150248646736145,
0.38054358959198,
-0.688999593257904,
-0.35968682169914246,
0.33174803853034973,
-0.2726607918739319,
0.15518513321876526,
0.30788031220436096,
-1.0678050518035889,
0.04829525947570801,
0.3720770478248596,
0.3808656930923462,
-0.14316146075725555,
-0.5950274467468262,
-0.248586967587471,
0.3049173355102539,
0.018537264317274094,
1.0225290060043335,
-0.1908416897058487,
-0.14644058048725128,
-0.22088226675987244,
0.17398469150066376,
-0.04826883599162102,
-0.06594318896532059,
0.4894157350063324,
-0.4538262188434601,
-0.0546194426715374,
-0.3833409547805786,
0.033839479088783264,
-0.39031195640563965,
-0.1286185383796692,
-0.3911420404911041,
0.3729049265384674,
-0.05779450386762619,
-0.55367112159729,
0.42360642552375793,
-1.0626935958862305,
-0.5385997295379639,
-0.3060740530490875,
-0.18305887281894684,
-0.06115511432290077,
0.40107759833335876,
0.5772007703781128,
0.49727827310562134,
-0.0737951323390007,
0.19950062036514282,
-0.7316322922706604,
-0.2447393834590912,
0.39111751317977905,
-0.684165894985199,
1.2266829013824463,
0.18573857843875885,
-0.07915711402893066,
0.08441433310508728,
-0.7762022018432617,
0.27666595578193665,
0.06645078212022781,
-0.3805179297924042,
-0.32376861572265625,
-0.040815141052007675,
0.6176425218582153,
0.04090965539216995,
0.10139497369527817,
-0.6540268063545227,
0.14051780104637146,
-0.023142121732234955,
0.5375394225120544,
0.6297408938407898,
-0.26543328166007996,
0.5960748195648193,
0.25294727087020874,
0.09554959833621979,
0.21568700671195984,
0.08002603054046631,
-0.3627566397190094,
-0.2936878204345703,
-0.47828009724617004,
-0.46622470021247864,
0.6086803674697876,
0.4469345211982727,
-0.33628255128860474,
0.7253096103668213,
-0.5499069690704346,
-0.07601716369390488,
-0.7853860855102539,
-0.04507327824831009,
0.2530505061149597,
0.24624291062355042,
0.516804039478302,
-0.5051767230033875,
-0.8316211104393005,
-0.818471372127533,
-0.15901444852352142,
0.2631576955318451,
-0.3286401033401489,
0.10064347833395004,
0.41054123640060425,
-0.44982990622520447,
0.9855542778968811,
-0.4622504413127899,
-0.38500237464904785,
0.2672821879386902,
0.49946147203445435,
-0.029987307265400887,
0.5792216658592224,
0.2990661561489105,
-0.6935403943061829,
0.1153339371085167,
0.19200094044208527,
-1.310544490814209,
-0.048977967351675034,
0.12840354442596436,
-0.2627723515033722,
0.07008127868175507,
0.3216082751750946,
-0.5082967877388,
0.4138045608997345,
0.5972975492477417,
-0.42404693365097046,
-0.15609972178936005,
-0.4900381565093994,
0.3750559389591217,
-0.9631125330924988,
0.30942052602767944,
-0.288987934589386,
0.18424497544765472,
-0.3223918080329895,
-0.025825589895248413,
0.30383142828941345,
-0.12589912116527557,
-0.23529237508773804,
0.14615468680858612,
-0.8969794511795044,
-0.23208904266357422,
-0.4609191417694092,
0.13811923563480377,
0.17292916774749756,
0.8872957825660706,
0.07165417075157166,
0.14524972438812256,
0.6986508965492249,
-0.4482516944408417,
0.20234562456607819,
0.4411936402320862,
0.013036658987402916,
0.8911517858505249,
-0.44557100534439087,
0.515644371509552,
-0.42218512296676636,
0.17625024914741516,
-1.0012105703353882,
-0.3373582661151886,
-0.18749766051769257,
-0.44813430309295654,
0.31934332847595215,
-0.13382592797279358,
-0.49587202072143555,
-0.4758029580116272,
0.03426764905452728,
0.5233831405639648,
0.5651740431785583,
-0.7269634008407593,
1.0981526374816895,
0.7053662538528442,
0.15550385415554047,
-0.6874280571937561,
-1.0240622758865356,
0.1986841857433319,
-0.06166323274374008,
-0.7271231412887573,
0.09737187623977661,
-0.062116943299770355,
0.2556643486022949,
0.14479216933250427,
-0.1343042254447937,
-0.3049047589302063,
0.07758195698261261,
0.6273685693740845,
0.0032960702665150166,
-0.0846797451376915,
-0.1292850226163864,
0.22990478575229645,
-0.24836719036102295,
0.36224108934402466,
-0.48079660534858704,
0.46433305740356445,
-0.10916433483362198,
-0.6557910442352295,
-0.16822747886180878,
0.450308620929718,
0.4760679304599762,
-0.3336324989795685,
0.31819435954093933,
1.058995246887207,
-0.5230436325073242,
0.000364808744052425,
-0.15059493482112885,
-0.2882494330406189,
-0.4748864769935608,
0.455110102891922,
-0.47765791416168213,
-0.6208673715591431,
0.3132403492927551,
-0.23550915718078613,
0.005283257458359003,
-0.03705111891031265,
0.4938810467720032,
-0.35843393206596375,
1.409677267074585,
0.9160633087158203,
-0.018985135480761528,
0.16036613285541534,
-0.060662295669317245,
0.10601598769426346,
-1.014485478401184,
-0.6508442163467407,
-0.2650672495365143,
-0.5391242504119873,
0.10036034882068634,
-0.16297027468681335,
0.43614524602890015,
0.06134769320487976,
0.018527889624238014,
0.44644126296043396,
-0.7944419980049133,
0.4739827811717987,
0.5555844306945801,
0.41804763674736023,
0.28952914476394653,
0.3863861560821533,
-0.13326269388198853,
-0.1682877391576767,
-0.7667007446289062,
-0.31185677647590637,
1.3034998178482056,
-0.006074226461350918,
0.8598889708518982,
-0.031321290880441666,
0.15652818977832794,
0.26792481541633606,
0.33627164363861084,
-0.3321971297264099,
0.5652848482131958,
0.006474831607192755,
-0.7668517231941223,
-0.006392843089997768,
-0.20987120270729065,
-1.394964575767517,
0.7134411334991455,
-0.32637378573417664,
-1.0557302236557007,
0.39142221212387085,
0.04067742079496384,
-0.518815815448761,
0.27160966396331787,
-0.774294912815094,
1.0084240436553955,
-0.24263276159763336,
-0.35164371132850647,
-0.31850430369377136,
-0.8004193902015686,
0.3618762195110321,
-0.01017696876078844,
0.12104831635951996,
-0.05869415029883385,
0.10794392228126526,
0.6588222980499268,
0.35316359996795654,
0.9097561836242676,
-0.23381955921649933,
-0.10166392475366592,
0.03255187347531319,
-0.1258150041103363,
-0.2799651026725769,
0.25529593229293823,
0.299152135848999,
0.6263455748558044,
0.11097592860460281,
-0.7537746429443359,
-0.5234654545783997,
0.7032949328422546,
-0.8082959055900574,
0.006550599820911884,
-0.18775519728660583,
-0.9929890036582947,
-0.22007527947425842,
0.16490387916564941,
0.30157941579818726,
0.5441398620605469,
-0.4196403920650482,
0.37038034200668335,
0.6196224689483643,
0.13183487951755524,
0.6577814221382141,
0.6085503697395325,
-0.18695111572742462,
-0.6745360493659973,
0.633823037147522,
-0.19796514511108398,
-0.5479069948196411,
0.5666290521621704,
-0.4716152548789978,
-0.3061712980270386,
-0.4160573482513428,
-0.3960648477077484,
0.023153170943260193,
-0.8253113627433777,
-0.061361681669950485,
-0.8282005786895752,
0.33670952916145325,
-0.21734917163848877,
-0.08697282522916794,
-0.3006593585014343,
-0.0062055266462266445,
-0.0934792011976242,
0.17292477190494537,
0.03202463313937187,
0.5351821184158325,
-0.43004441261291504,
0.45054322481155396,
-0.8249837756156921,
0.5185494422912598,
0.3927726149559021,
-0.039948638528585434,
-0.1568676084280014,
-0.4032589793205261,
-0.3620137870311737,
0.33688482642173767,
-0.43264421820640564,
-1.038760781288147,
0.2809797525405884,
-0.2513902485370636,
0.48250338435173035,
0.4552750289440155,
-0.23997338116168976,
0.7735321521759033,
-0.4923507571220398,
0.38277190923690796,
0.47709083557128906,
-1.0118640661239624,
0.4538979232311249,
-0.20053814351558685,
0.4679870903491974,
0.4244016110897064,
0.16436129808425903,
-0.3547406792640686,
0.08813755214214325,
-0.5020005702972412,
-0.7876207828521729,
0.623143196105957,
0.003669261932373047,
0.13499513268470764,
0.19355252385139465,
0.10873773694038391,
0.09909152239561081,
0.28591102361679077,
-0.7514612078666687,
-0.3268148899078369,
-0.1162554919719696,
-0.29633378982543945,
0.08171024918556213,
0.04705774411559105,
-0.4456481337547302,
-0.5937194228172302,
-0.1470390409231186,
-0.361850380897522,
0.9261897802352905,
-0.0714024007320404,
-0.46448421478271484,
0.04037313908338547,
0.40762045979499817,
0.16453224420547485,
0.506706714630127,
-0.21337401866912842,
0.2986629605293274,
0.5225973725318909,
-0.34155091643333435,
0.2246149331331253,
0.27662035822868347,
0.2531454265117645,
0.0166697446256876,
0.26010334491729736,
0.7313235998153687,
0.5850042104721069,
-0.5102319121360779,
0.5752580761909485,
-0.11927241086959839,
-0.01863439567387104,
-0.23717635869979858,
-0.07851596176624298,
0.18541565537452698,
0.3918120563030243,
0.3309987783432007,
0.6149057745933533,
0.2830592393875122,
-0.3604716658592224,
0.26740762591362,
0.407096266746521,
-0.23737980425357819,
-0.8090882301330566,
0.968559205532074,
0.16697782278060913,
0.045504603534936905,
0.6951958537101746,
0.06705506145954132,
0.20235097408294678,
0.5205184817314148,
0.5709812641143799,
0.7950605154037476,
0.1485447883605957,
-0.08748640865087509,
0.04945389926433563,
0.2498716115951538,
0.1615815907716751,
0.5907948017120361,
-0.19605238735675812,
-0.7288329601287842,
-0.6624710559844971,
-0.40309450030326843,
-0.21919040381908417,
0.008246082812547684,
-0.9669021368026733,
0.01158546470105648,
-0.2990753948688507,
-0.38431471586227417,
0.15581217408180237,
-0.6091710329055786,
-0.7743675112724304,
0.06563349068164825,
0.5935755968093872,
0.6080660223960876,
-0.7338796257972717,
0.9825682044029236,
1.100770354270935,
-0.47210270166397095,
-0.4622027575969696,
-0.4758605360984802,
-0.02570178732275963,
-0.6724847555160522,
0.5711536407470703,
0.29242101311683655,
-0.1253700852394104,
0.2380049228668213,
-0.6358472108840942,
-0.6811767220497131,
1.1969598531723022,
0.7759206891059875,
-0.2017020583152771,
-0.18425345420837402,
-0.10620622336864471,
0.3452264964580536,
-0.3366377651691437,
0.5035663843154907,
0.5644890666007996,
0.6278989911079407,
-0.6306928992271423,
-0.6110386252403259,
-0.042980924248695374,
-0.2818222939968109,
0.11083130538463593,
0.23568065464496613,
-0.4025018513202667,
0.6756942868232727,
-0.363581120967865,
-0.25170713663101196,
0.028735948726534843,
0.993051290512085,
0.004347920883446932,
0.40229180455207825,
0.2755921185016632,
0.6331570148468018,
0.6992162466049194,
-0.30611297488212585,
0.8146883249282837,
-0.23572631180286407,
0.36131712794303894,
0.762009859085083,
-0.09532193839550018,
0.7783229351043701,
0.555230438709259,
-0.04821162298321724,
0.6191259622573853,
0.18956103920936584,
0.0017152494983747602,
0.5858098268508911,
-0.20705395936965942,
-0.032192621380090714,
-0.3880866467952728,
0.08538325875997543,
-0.2641441226005554,
0.6927041411399841,
0.2580018639564514,
-0.10020245611667633,
-0.5781555771827698,
0.6920116543769836,
-0.22633612155914307,
0.11244974285364151,
-0.26537656784057617,
0.5402959585189819,
0.2523668706417084,
-0.5253168940544128,
0.6912505030632019,
-0.10258238762617111,
0.7126765847206116,
-0.5834717750549316,
0.06431303918361664,
-0.20832036435604095,
0.6218937039375305,
-0.09479407966136932,
-0.64872807264328,
0.1181509867310524,
-0.3281381130218506,
-0.2924095392227173,
-0.2096841037273407,
0.55577152967453,
-0.4335126280784607,
0.057845670729875565,
0.6677385568618774,
0.6205929517745972,
0.18033038079738617,
-0.3642478883266449,
-0.7093996405601501,
0.13720658421516418,
0.017595764249563217,
-0.07030675560235977,
0.49623623490333557,
0.6467718482017517,
0.09287430346012115,
0.5606558918952942,
0.7453767657279968,
-0.3980085253715515,
0.15486305952072144,
0.04306244105100632,
0.6789488196372986,
-0.9769376516342163,
-0.22657592594623566,
-0.7781990170478821,
0.7298122048377991,
-0.06435815244913101,
-0.4889388978481293,
0.885844349861145,
0.19426751136779785,
0.6745383739471436,
-0.36339810490608215,
0.4742843806743622,
-0.1705966740846634,
-0.14543546736240387,
-0.394493043422699,
0.6150985956192017,
-0.5295642614364624,
-0.12198390811681747,
-0.03217104449868202,
-0.763122022151947,
-0.36537250876426697,
0.4194726347923279,
0.019187534227967262,
0.04411393776535988,
1.0108575820922852,
0.6591148972511292,
-0.380643367767334,
0.29149129986763,
0.38568639755249023,
0.02929075062274933,
-0.23278675973415375,
0.9428247213363647,
0.8860201835632324,
-0.5397384166717529,
0.8389111161231995,
-0.1568545401096344,
-0.16154968738555908,
-0.1475439816713333,
-0.6463546752929688,
-0.9415882229804993,
-0.44514498114585876,
-0.3234247863292694,
-0.216568723320961,
0.025304825976490974,
0.6462584733963013,
1.1601711511611938,
-0.8576207160949707,
-0.2883141040802002,
-0.025453438982367516,
-0.2020300328731537,
-0.5959560871124268,
-0.10418632626533508,
0.3843710720539093,
-0.3183921277523041,
-0.7500911355018616,
0.5212860703468323,
0.4103407561779022,
-0.25296539068222046,
-0.19759196043014526,
0.04929272457957268,
-0.06988596171140671,
-0.13595257699489594,
0.8955574035644531,
0.3875763714313507,
-0.5831724405288696,
-0.02424691617488861,
0.040807440876960754,
-0.30661740899086,
0.04578447341918945,
0.8457956910133362,
-0.6849637627601624,
0.19249986112117767,
0.3273337483406067,
0.8021116852760315,
0.47104912996292114,
-0.1837109923362732,
0.33529338240623474,
-0.6979756355285645,
0.35437890887260437,
-0.09102946519851685,
0.8077965378761292,
0.3709774315357208,
-0.12662120163440704,
0.4538271129131317,
0.12535706162452698,
-0.5249293446540833,
-0.603273868560791,
0.056191880255937576,
-1.4534971714019775,
-0.6383681297302246,
0.9540997743606567,
-0.10805781930685043,
-0.8058104515075684,
-0.34242650866508484,
-0.43644699454307556,
0.23062996566295624,
-0.2892932593822479,
0.6757982969284058,
0.45264557003974915,
-0.19691132009029388,
-0.13768376410007477,
-0.2001529335975647,
-0.20689700543880463,
0.7602598667144775,
-0.8206700682640076,
0.05135960504412651,
0.8124978542327881,
0.26344895362854004,
0.4969535768032074,
0.43077370524406433,
-0.17052944004535675,
0.5857481360435486,
0.17747734487056732,
0.7687931656837463,
-0.10720048099756241,
-0.5202086567878723,
-0.6040103435516357,
0.8291853666305542,
-0.21359939873218536,
-0.5334994196891785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08699v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08699v2
|
Analyzing the Impact of Data Selection and Fine-Tuning on Economic and Political Biases in LLMs
| 2024-04-10T16:30:09 | 2024-04-21T23:51:29 |
Ahmed Agiza, Mohamed Mostagir, Sherief Reda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In an era where language models are increasingly integrated into
decision-making and communication, understanding the biases within Large
Language Models (LLMs) becomes imperative, especially when these models are
applied in the economic and political domains. This work investigates the
impact of fine-tuning and data selection on economic and political biases in
LLM. We explore the methodological aspects of biasing LLMs towards specific
ideologies, mindful of the biases that arise from their extensive training on
diverse datasets. Our approach, distinct from earlier efforts that either focus
on smaller models or entail resource-intensive pre-training, employs
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) techniques. These techniques allow for
the alignment of LLMs with targeted ideologies by modifying a small subset of
parameters. We introduce a systematic method for dataset selection, annotation,
and instruction tuning, and we assess its effectiveness through both
quantitative and qualitative evaluations. Our work analyzes the potential of
embedding specific biases into LLMs and contributes to the dialogue on the
ethical application of AI, highlighting the importance of deploying AI in a
manner that aligns with societal values.
|
[
-0.6840806007385254,
-0.8906209468841553,
0.5598557591438293,
-0.19853954017162323,
-0.25591057538986206,
0.2611897587776184,
-0.5657123923301697,
-0.25384968519210815,
-0.16217689216136932,
0.8025566339492798,
-0.5138787627220154,
-0.4243202209472656,
-0.6080619692802429,
-0.09802281111478806,
0.06490086764097214,
1.2900733947753906,
0.2576042115688324,
0.36748504638671875,
-0.015403545461595058,
-0.06580822169780731,
-0.17600056529045105,
-0.44691815972328186,
-0.685063362121582,
-0.6330625414848328,
0.28780150413513184,
0.4125666618347168,
1.0299822092056274,
1.027090311050415,
0.5583101511001587,
0.1533166766166687,
-0.11226876080036163,
0.17842987179756165,
-0.7671880125999451,
-0.18819035589694977,
-0.5215022563934326,
-0.5941705107688904,
-0.19692423939704895,
0.5270906686782837,
0.5961397290229797,
0.6298639178276062,
0.104326032102108,
0.5815392136573792,
0.23452292382717133,
0.7224540710449219,
-0.712855339050293,
0.242624893784523,
-1.1042122840881348,
-0.10045481473207474,
-0.24962176382541656,
-0.2737654149532318,
-0.29355019330978394,
-0.4036649465560913,
0.18467533588409424,
-0.38994258642196655,
-0.08644768595695496,
0.3853115439414978,
0.785760760307312,
0.606343150138855,
-0.39928993582725525,
-0.27930787205696106,
-0.6157593727111816,
1.1774373054504395,
-0.6023447513580322,
0.3435564637184143,
0.4430830180644989,
-0.024827629327774048,
-0.16075865924358368,
-0.22292141616344452,
-0.3455210328102112,
0.13478325307369232,
0.04365481808781624,
-0.11363224685192108,
0.1305353194475174,
0.3582288920879364,
0.26359522342681885,
0.362936407327652,
0.14810852706432343,
0.47887110710144043,
-0.30486786365509033,
-0.028066452592611313,
0.6611785888671875,
0.20112822949886322,
-0.03763773292303085,
-0.13642053306102753,
-0.0740659087896347,
-0.06954075396060944,
-0.9186599254608154,
-0.14922180771827698,
1.0042357444763184,
0.6681258082389832,
-0.07554055005311966,
0.5213485360145569,
-0.22019816935062408,
0.8031635880470276,
0.26223495602607727,
-0.015176395885646343,
0.018205197528004646,
-0.3583901822566986,
-0.40993618965148926,
-0.08960691839456558,
0.5952320694923401,
0.5858554244041443,
0.7046874761581421,
0.24219505488872528,
-0.18571282923221588,
0.06902739405632019,
0.17389702796936035,
-0.5315097570419312,
0.024794816970825195,
0.09775934368371964,
-0.6319827437400818,
-0.5580374002456665,
-0.14314903318881989,
-1.042981505393982,
-0.5752381682395935,
-0.915177583694458,
0.10576561093330383,
-0.009170174598693848,
0.09812850505113602,
0.0898141860961914,
0.07342038303613663,
0.32977983355522156,
0.21845966577529907,
-1.0208837985992432,
0.18410034477710724,
0.8681232333183289,
0.44363531470298767,
0.06963525712490082,
-0.07056979835033417,
-0.5345345735549927,
0.15245723724365234,
-0.3657834231853485,
0.6824953556060791,
-1.0494049787521362,
-0.18991631269454956,
0.0824025496840477,
-0.20747631788253784,
0.020546140149235725,
-0.7863187789916992,
0.4817405939102173,
-0.42797452211380005,
0.07289886474609375,
-0.49467962980270386,
-0.6834482550621033,
-0.021097058430314064,
0.18532763421535492,
-0.695370078086853,
0.8501594662666321,
-0.04636494070291519,
-0.7726266384124756,
0.9076199531555176,
-0.7207326292991638,
-0.2931332290172577,
-0.35210466384887695,
-0.5532866716384888,
-0.3649524748325348,
0.12993797659873962,
0.2507523000240326,
0.5491206645965576,
-0.5775298476219177,
0.4680061638355255,
-0.3781873285770416,
-0.38503462076187134,
0.0992622971534729,
-0.5055547952651978,
0.7752837538719177,
0.14409959316253662,
-0.6117098331451416,
0.08008046448230743,
-0.7793847918510437,
-0.10628697276115417,
-0.10880278795957565,
-0.3744302988052368,
-0.4242062270641327,
0.3793782591819763,
0.03343610838055611,
0.12196231633424759,
0.20633980631828308,
-0.19449485838413239,
0.25407153367996216,
-0.48074042797088623,
0.5875025987625122,
1.235482931137085,
-0.1793917566537857,
0.7076172828674316,
-0.3812864422798157,
0.35617876052856445,
-0.3213689923286438,
0.4004228115081787,
0.2646610140800476,
-0.18861857056617737,
-0.6294170618057251,
-0.1474749594926834,
0.4288690984249115,
0.5859662294387817,
-0.3333536386489868,
0.25801631808280945,
0.17958544194698334,
-0.2930557429790497,
-0.8505741953849792,
0.20021429657936096,
0.036003902554512024,
0.17775405943393707,
0.05618186295032501,
0.09957503527402878,
-0.41893652081489563,
-1.316961407661438,
-0.6887692213058472,
-0.17756809294223785,
0.01301567256450653,
0.5804955959320068,
0.6210449934005737,
-0.03582754731178284,
0.8366823196411133,
-0.15780673921108246,
-0.24645961821079254,
-0.004444907419383526,
-0.13382188975811005,
0.26242101192474365,
0.4400815963745117,
0.4750097990036011,
-0.5933172106742859,
-0.3145078718662262,
0.13514839112758636,
-0.12599442899227142,
-0.264396071434021,
-0.36517333984375,
-0.23557251691818237,
0.11189795285463333,
0.1881427764892578,
-0.26699453592300415,
0.372627854347229,
0.39297258853912354,
-0.40492480993270874,
0.25574368238449097,
-0.012246659956872463,
0.2572798430919647,
-0.8227006196975708,
-0.1648278832435608,
0.1626710295677185,
-0.19377392530441284,
-0.23250442743301392,
-0.18197283148765564,
-0.12138541042804718,
0.45674124360084534,
-0.37737515568733215,
0.4053962230682373,
-0.32336950302124023,
-0.05465157330036163,
-0.18514548242092133,
-0.04627101123332977,
-0.02194087579846382,
0.07926394045352936,
-0.1126004159450531,
0.9086348414421082,
0.4162716567516327,
-0.35983502864837646,
0.03607211261987686,
0.12680445611476898,
-0.5919052362442017,
0.6788994073867798,
-0.36509397625923157,
0.3124966621398926,
-0.17881862819194794,
-0.12175870686769485,
-0.3768933117389679,
-0.06332753598690033,
0.2605035603046417,
0.14384396374225616,
0.23901581764221191,
-0.34364211559295654,
-0.6443564295768738,
0.2856212556362152,
-0.3749139904975891,
0.21454912424087524,
0.4288799464702606,
-0.39480894804000854,
0.3032752573490143,
0.771869957447052,
-0.06384655088186264,
-0.5590407848358154,
-0.45625829696655273,
-0.07581987231969833,
-0.7190983891487122,
-0.2434319257736206,
0.24841420352458954,
0.12517149746418,
-0.8969051837921143,
-0.16360166668891907,
0.08323416858911514,
0.32244905829429626,
0.14661246538162231,
-0.08405207097530365,
0.19149763882160187,
-0.04962810128927231,
0.023711035028100014,
0.35102400183677673,
-0.010473988018929958,
0.07399512827396393,
-0.29209691286087036,
0.4987245202064514,
-0.1595654934644699,
-0.25190025568008423,
-0.36322277784347534,
0.2417108714580536,
0.6277810335159302,
-0.29406657814979553,
0.8438776135444641,
0.17949679493904114,
-0.25204384326934814,
-0.3320043087005615,
-0.8060312867164612,
-0.23415665328502655,
-0.4938954710960388,
0.3317207992076874,
0.16501040756702423,
-0.8512616157531738,
0.38187935948371887,
-0.40021035075187683,
0.14802829921245575,
0.34552380442619324,
0.9036736488342285,
0.020268406718969345,
1.0292807817459106,
0.7464730143547058,
-0.3515888452529907,
0.6156314015388489,
-0.24614442884922028,
0.26946744322776794,
-0.7637083530426025,
-0.19263482093811035,
-0.5848737359046936,
-0.407327264547348,
-0.8067845106124878,
-0.35430893301963806,
0.14052365720272064,
-0.16900837421417236,
-0.7021052837371826,
-0.4206353425979614,
-0.5241049528121948,
0.8785768747329712,
0.5556395649909973,
0.021677203476428986,
0.142792209982872,
0.1277070790529251,
0.2487688660621643,
-0.2032356858253479,
-0.4809599220752716,
-1.084916353225708,
1.295227289199829,
0.3953566551208496,
0.987638533115387,
-0.43733739852905273,
0.39024198055267334,
0.3863876163959503,
0.1400793343782425,
-0.6849908828735352,
0.2897419035434723,
-0.3102611005306244,
-0.5499274134635925,
-0.2856070101261139,
-0.2658003866672516,
-0.684227705001831,
0.09328073263168335,
-0.38698697090148926,
-0.7157807350158691,
0.34477484226226807,
0.01929333806037903,
-0.5101054310798645,
0.48104095458984375,
-0.47225886583328247,
0.7745104432106018,
-0.4724609851837158,
-0.4771062731742859,
-0.46371224522590637,
-0.616689145565033,
-0.12543600797653198,
-0.09667888283729553,
0.4482424259185791,
-0.5119576454162598,
-0.13974665105342865,
0.706513524055481,
0.11759883910417557,
1.0848511457443237,
-0.08495235443115234,
-0.12445510178804398,
-0.1506304144859314,
-0.3321513533592224,
0.48090076446533203,
0.2225382924079895,
-0.47584474086761475,
0.32398611307144165,
0.0906129702925682,
-0.3409740924835205,
-0.1389426589012146,
0.669119119644165,
-0.9507825970649719,
-0.7854886054992676,
-0.23452402651309967,
-0.7579666972160339,
-0.3775041103363037,
0.09995748102664948,
0.14403268694877625,
-0.10741342604160309,
-0.2687848210334778,
0.15164421498775482,
0.8901504278182983,
-0.3527508080005646,
-0.024277692660689354,
0.2954338490962982,
-0.05047072842717171,
-0.24504639208316803,
0.6255874633789062,
0.4614924490451813,
0.40958836674690247,
0.03769123926758766,
0.2776392996311188,
-0.012802045792341232,
-0.6202936172485352,
-0.3988017439842224,
0.24083735048770905,
-0.5814390778541565,
-0.20892879366874695,
-0.1995292603969574,
0.1120452731847763,
-0.07364743947982788,
-0.3073887825012207,
-0.498711496591568,
-0.15543268620967865,
-0.622961163520813,
-0.11943462491035461,
0.4359505772590637,
0.8519797325134277,
0.07193924486637115,
0.31442031264305115,
-0.1343892216682434,
0.0768863633275032,
-0.0323009192943573,
0.6489292979240417,
-0.3479475677013397,
-0.35143139958381653,
-0.30781951546669006,
0.3472297787666321,
-0.12226533889770508,
-0.7592875361442566,
0.03317663446068764,
0.27826422452926636,
0.5784559845924377,
0.36641356348991394,
0.09914416074752808,
0.6225680708885193,
-0.6113320589065552,
0.5940936207771301,
-0.4206906855106354,
-0.9474788308143616,
0.7836040258407593,
-0.40198513865470886,
-0.035408180207014084,
0.8358278274536133,
0.23495429754257202,
-0.14552490413188934,
-0.5870434641838074,
-0.47616297006607056,
-0.8970451354980469,
0.8996163606643677,
0.017794184386730194,
0.355491042137146,
0.04524685814976692,
0.6797197461128235,
0.34168753027915955,
0.3922935426235199,
-0.28803977370262146,
-0.42176350951194763,
0.1513487845659256,
-0.19910858571529388,
0.09610427170991898,
-0.17107993364334106,
-0.3249660134315491,
-0.36922961473464966,
0.7877046465873718,
-0.239251047372818,
-0.30767422914505005,
-0.08034321665763855,
0.16230283677577972,
-0.2341488003730774,
0.35072705149650574,
0.1824522465467453,
0.8381445407867432,
-0.025896623730659485,
-0.12532728910446167,
0.11656346172094345,
-0.16267885267734528,
-0.06704702973365784,
0.14671896398067474,
-0.3845638632774353,
-0.1839914470911026,
-0.16747766733169556,
0.8420048356056213,
-0.08399558067321777,
-0.6914716362953186,
0.047885261476039886,
0.15514807403087616,
0.10775209218263626,
-0.18311497569084167,
0.03622264415025711,
-0.04417187348008156,
0.6024224758148193,
0.20547686517238617,
-0.026808375492691994,
0.18617434799671173,
-0.7596626281738281,
-0.06960561871528625,
0.8570561408996582,
-0.08746827393770218,
-0.0705590695142746,
0.6714814901351929,
0.1621716320514679,
-0.2571774125099182,
0.537150502204895,
0.11784464120864868,
-0.4372636377811432,
0.7501225471496582,
0.26948484778404236,
0.5844863653182983,
-0.10690116137266159,
0.11680096387863159,
-0.0502692386507988,
0.7494790554046631,
-0.017537256702780724,
0.35581305623054504,
0.24959319829940796,
-0.8287659287452698,
-0.549608051776886,
-0.6620505452156067,
-0.5279478430747986,
0.35091787576675415,
-0.7734513878822327,
0.3965047299861908,
-0.6368235945701599,
-0.37084248661994934,
0.02480996772646904,
0.36523857712745667,
-0.8165557980537415,
0.15380032360553741,
0.281760036945343,
0.6673540472984314,
-0.9854188561439514,
0.7082295417785645,
0.7118067741394043,
-0.01837301440536976,
-0.50310879945755,
0.10459685325622559,
0.13308008015155792,
-1.015262484550476,
0.5216201543807983,
-0.15557515621185303,
0.05885697156190872,
-0.12020676583051682,
-0.671756386756897,
-0.7662543058395386,
0.7226824164390564,
0.8935157060623169,
-0.6761246919631958,
0.15512989461421967,
0.45679736137390137,
0.2854459285736084,
-0.5804807543754578,
0.0756792351603508,
1.247151494026184,
0.6591135859489441,
-0.5907089114189148,
-1.0878345966339111,
-0.1605873852968216,
0.11469168215990067,
-0.03517567366361618,
0.44188034534454346,
-0.9313681125640869,
0.7043983340263367,
0.07368990033864975,
0.1289854198694229,
-0.396645724773407,
0.2361956536769867,
0.06834124773740768,
0.3187152147293091,
0.41197896003723145,
0.2648674547672272,
0.958796501159668,
-0.1586933434009552,
0.8103734850883484,
-0.6452353000640869,
0.4707318842411041,
0.9071869254112244,
-0.39352259039878845,
0.4620611369609833,
0.772686779499054,
-0.32276469469070435,
0.09064354002475739,
0.9845727682113647,
-0.21947354078292847,
0.488815575838089,
0.3938651978969574,
-0.03547123074531555,
-0.22367455065250397,
-0.5115433931350708,
-0.16121210157871246,
0.5286802053451538,
0.7478291392326355,
-0.5635867714881897,
-0.07106912136077881,
-0.1043587177991867,
0.19164195656776428,
0.186948761343956,
-0.5304183959960938,
0.7813066244125366,
-0.0603502131998539,
-0.3343633711338043,
0.10826290398836136,
-0.1554180383682251,
0.7816193699836731,
-0.2972958981990814,
-0.07420790940523148,
-0.1049284040927887,
0.013041939586400986,
-0.30767107009887695,
-0.8556380867958069,
0.4546716809272766,
0.19438336789608002,
-0.3123703896999359,
-0.43091291189193726,
0.4973906874656677,
-0.4218718707561493,
-0.5009294748306274,
0.16025356948375702,
0.5350490212440491,
-0.04847239702939987,
-0.04764604568481445,
-0.846399188041687,
0.5099781155586243,
0.21690502762794495,
-0.4550679922103882,
0.44108977913856506,
0.42028525471687317,
-0.0345890112221241,
0.33909153938293457,
0.4942927956581116,
0.30251237750053406,
-0.35503625869750977,
0.17807067930698395,
0.7530702352523804,
-0.46525320410728455,
-0.2518342435359955,
-1.204085111618042,
0.182878315448761,
-0.10131187736988068,
-0.25160738825798035,
0.5682504177093506,
0.6949540376663208,
1.1701699495315552,
0.2755485773086548,
1.112925410270691,
0.14773693680763245,
0.284519225358963,
-0.6397585272789001,
0.9189516305923462,
-0.4028504192829132,
0.5914238691329956,
-0.12779901921749115,
-0.7928393483161926,
-0.14207544922828674,
0.8247228860855103,
-0.78411865234375,
0.09197088330984116,
0.09138945490121841,
0.6266477704048157,
0.08628349006175995,
0.015766769647598267,
0.12920749187469482,
0.1305101066827774,
0.038348715752363205,
0.15913912653923035,
0.8178136348724365,
0.12139502912759781,
0.1694198101758957,
-0.4775969982147217,
-0.2373887598514557,
0.011380182579159737,
-1.0440518856048584,
-0.9656616449356079,
-0.30377089977264404,
-0.3882398307323456,
-0.11935222148895264,
0.26481375098228455,
1.343095064163208,
0.5516824126243591,
-0.7212475538253784,
-0.42897430062294006,
0.3236791491508484,
0.32368984818458557,
0.11988738924264908,
-0.22387224435806274,
0.4057314395904541,
-0.30587834119796753,
-1.109015703201294,
-0.07531031966209412,
0.4545843005180359,
-0.20579415559768677,
-0.35135000944137573,
0.23387238383293152,
-0.1749531328678131,
0.43239670991897583,
0.44196024537086487,
-0.15369170904159546,
-0.8372132182121277,
-0.46784648299217224,
-0.2031642347574234,
0.232476606965065,
0.2052512913942337,
0.8563207983970642,
-0.8471078276634216,
0.3174726963043213,
0.123687744140625,
0.6743152141571045,
-0.07879684865474701,
-0.16520708799362183,
0.738872230052948,
-0.25857463479042053,
0.14236074686050415,
0.4010103642940521,
0.31090086698532104,
0.33545005321502686,
-0.5392288565635681,
0.4500834047794342,
-0.162917360663414,
-0.8523502945899963,
-1.0226845741271973,
0.2591140568256378,
-0.48135051131248474,
-0.34660664200782776,
1.2467631101608276,
0.3601019084453583,
-0.05839873477816582,
-0.24168497323989868,
-0.44328680634498596,
0.21253469586372375,
-0.4714755117893219,
0.9091269373893738,
0.7641866207122803,
-0.16126862168312073,
-0.04069865867495537,
-0.7436715364456177,
0.6453413367271423,
0.406688392162323,
-0.6886346340179443,
0.30715566873550415,
0.49939265847206116,
0.27522987127304077,
-0.3369406759738922,
0.3253779709339142,
0.02512224204838276,
-0.044244252145290375,
-0.3988599181175232,
-0.19119569659233093,
0.2976273000240326,
0.09336027503013611,
-0.41466084122657776,
-0.082033671438694,
0.2202322781085968,
0.09152737259864807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07143v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07143v1
|
Leave No Context Behind: Efficient Infinite Context Transformers with Infini-attention
| 2024-04-10T16:18:42 | 2024-04-10T16:18:42 |
Tsendsuren Munkhdalai, Manaal Faruqui, Siddharth Gopal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE
|
This work introduces an efficient method to scale Transformer-based Large
Language Models (LLMs) to infinitely long inputs with bounded memory and
computation. A key component in our proposed approach is a new attention
technique dubbed Infini-attention. The Infini-attention incorporates a
compressive memory into the vanilla attention mechanism and builds in both
masked local attention and long-term linear attention mechanisms in a single
Transformer block. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach on
long-context language modeling benchmarks, 1M sequence length passkey context
block retrieval and 500K length book summarization tasks with 1B and 8B LLMs.
Our approach introduces minimal bounded memory parameters and enables fast
streaming inference for LLMs.
|
[
-0.5240113139152527,
-0.6546789407730103,
0.7713800668716431,
0.3524681627750397,
-0.22109106183052063,
-0.13404665887355804,
-0.4281122088432312,
-0.21999892592430115,
0.13032269477844238,
0.7815775275230408,
-0.5208981037139893,
-0.07578737288713455,
-0.3899458646774292,
-0.08573202788829803,
-0.6345775723457336,
0.6997225880622864,
-0.07379899173974991,
-0.3866593837738037,
-0.2567984461784363,
-0.16040395200252533,
-0.35148054361343384,
-0.33790478110313416,
-0.6950021982192993,
-0.291859894990921,
0.41826871037483215,
0.7044576406478882,
0.5515541434288025,
0.5642865896224976,
0.30791693925857544,
0.23211944103240967,
-0.1835428774356842,
-0.1385127156972885,
-1.0181804895401,
0.08397551625967026,
-0.18831239640712738,
0.019677115604281425,
-0.41420072317123413,
-0.2767356336116791,
1.0798183679580688,
0.6977757811546326,
0.11061305552721024,
0.4360218346118927,
0.11046850681304932,
0.5123245120048523,
-0.7538043856620789,
0.05450930446386337,
-0.5381988883018494,
-0.037007465958595276,
-0.07898423820734024,
-0.21197935938835144,
-0.8087491989135742,
-0.11109550297260284,
0.051506415009498596,
-0.3263034522533417,
0.17150136828422546,
0.015018217265605927,
0.26065948605537415,
0.5181690454483032,
-0.47367414832115173,
-0.03445544093847275,
-0.7425339221954346,
1.0543020963668823,
-0.6709781885147095,
0.5274030566215515,
0.1802443414926529,
0.32190752029418945,
-0.13788758218288422,
-0.710397481918335,
-0.6882669925689697,
-0.005254076793789864,
-0.15849024057388306,
0.22795602679252625,
-0.25013917684555054,
0.1850082278251648,
0.31166785955429077,
0.4742506444454193,
-0.21910329163074493,
-0.09399425238370895,
-0.1301015019416809,
0.29828983545303345,
0.4019250273704529,
0.05212392285466194,
0.12268783152103424,
0.1829347014427185,
-0.43966230750083923,
0.15091769397258759,
-0.8053505420684814,
-0.059699006378650665,
-0.2085523158311844,
-0.04494231939315796,
-0.060740869492292404,
0.49774861335754395,
-0.1018885001540184,
0.8863497972488403,
0.29847201704978943,
-0.24537301063537598,
-0.2041430026292801,
-0.12349429726600647,
-0.5081825256347656,
0.08527836203575134,
0.5141986608505249,
0.27823659777641296,
0.04462478309869766,
-0.7174099087715149,
-0.16151998937129974,
-0.2760196030139923,
0.35233667492866516,
-0.7908294200897217,
0.40052932500839233,
0.4050946831703186,
-0.379784494638443,
0.09270013123750687,
-0.38319113850593567,
-0.9074315428733826,
-0.04648441821336746,
-0.16681864857673645,
0.4139065146446228,
-0.3699890375137329,
-0.003135295119136572,
-0.03908482939004898,
0.1049666777253151,
0.5102257132530212,
0.08687903732061386,
-1.1239068508148193,
0.7244752645492554,
0.6567360162734985,
0.9234810471534729,
-0.3300807476043701,
0.07813476771116257,
-0.7866898775100708,
0.43768376111984253,
-0.10265655815601349,
0.6028827428817749,
-0.5987598299980164,
-0.24110208451747894,
-0.022220246493816376,
-0.03125312924385071,
-0.22996686398983002,
-0.36013659834861755,
0.5902201533317566,
-0.7396574020385742,
0.03644685447216034,
0.2623682916164398,
-0.8447270393371582,
-0.3745688199996948,
0.06892967969179153,
-0.6653861403465271,
0.9753748774528503,
0.41224178671836853,
-0.4606446325778961,
-0.19514495134353638,
-0.8936918377876282,
-0.5158974528312683,
0.22217510640621185,
0.20972631871700287,
-0.1258847564458847,
0.27090954780578613,
0.10768858343362808,
0.658515453338623,
-0.3956682085990906,
0.43847742676734924,
-0.2731758952140808,
-0.700854480266571,
0.1353832185268402,
-0.6057104468345642,
0.5224513411521912,
0.10659850388765335,
-0.5223410129547119,
0.12871234118938446,
-0.8108974695205688,
0.0021058584097772837,
0.03601916506886482,
-0.15382300317287445,
-0.08559071272611618,
-0.004394713789224625,
0.44177159667015076,
0.19744300842285156,
0.23262211680412292,
-0.8111093640327454,
0.009467090480029583,
-0.6660871505737305,
0.7248267531394958,
0.4660585820674896,
-0.2000662088394165,
0.8125407695770264,
-0.054359789937734604,
0.6677979230880737,
-0.3430573046207428,
0.19815126061439514,
-0.5517046451568604,
0.030425457283854485,
-1.012627363204956,
-0.48484835028648376,
0.12436718493700027,
0.31971481442451477,
-0.3735118806362152,
0.5164073705673218,
-0.6676422953605652,
-0.2370758056640625,
-0.3086378872394562,
-0.027740851044654846,
0.304192453622818,
0.539901614189148,
0.2622124254703522,
0.023924043402075768,
-0.387026309967041,
-0.8560137152671814,
-0.031183073297142982,
0.4296083152294159,
-0.3876507878303528,
0.2453833818435669,
0.3507169485092163,
-0.2422531545162201,
1.188155174255371,
-0.2693346440792084,
-0.25973522663116455,
-0.4136578142642975,
-0.6163581013679504,
0.38608911633491516,
0.2748739719390869,
0.3674422800540924,
-0.6324024796485901,
-0.651177704334259,
-0.006801029201596975,
-0.4892026484012604,
0.07355309277772903,
-0.23217758536338806,
-0.09557101875543594,
0.23916640877723694,
0.8714317083358765,
-0.721502423286438,
0.34202662110328674,
0.5784962177276611,
-0.2329334169626236,
-0.2328035533428192,
0.10234376788139343,
-0.3130398988723755,
-0.9754772186279297,
0.3453562557697296,
-0.04471864923834801,
-0.6812712550163269,
-0.9249942302703857,
0.2477283775806427,
0.5052846074104309,
-0.24480478465557098,
-0.6607144474983215,
1.1452856063842773,
-0.4895046055316925,
0.09676758944988251,
-0.1798849254846573,
0.3563661575317383,
-0.13722272217273712,
0.8791776895523071,
-0.04197336733341217,
0.5572221279144287,
0.4446745812892914,
-0.40234366059303284,
0.2332192361354828,
0.14870958030223846,
-0.09297171980142593,
0.3665392994880676,
-0.5699082612991333,
0.21879203617572784,
-0.24062563478946686,
0.5024239420890808,
-1.4715685844421387,
-0.1341477632522583,
0.32588040828704834,
-0.09994900971651077,
0.6464594602584839,
-0.0448036827147007,
-0.4808013141155243,
-0.4470524191856384,
-0.3857923448085785,
0.5992798805236816,
0.4474843144416809,
-0.8322114944458008,
0.9348926544189453,
0.21336111426353455,
-0.1782068908214569,
-0.3483734130859375,
-0.6208011507987976,
0.21851173043251038,
-0.5638447403907776,
-0.4692022204399109,
0.4194217026233673,
-0.3144281804561615,
-0.20243977010250092,
-0.23051726818084717,
-0.2365046888589859,
-0.15983030200004578,
-0.13274052739143372,
0.2997299134731293,
0.08181892335414886,
-0.22387723624706268,
0.05737916752696037,
0.0559605173766613,
-0.14172908663749695,
-0.038773611187934875,
-0.36903443932533264,
0.4762860834598541,
0.0038833781145513058,
0.0029023424722254276,
-0.3509327471256256,
0.7708947062492371,
1.0405890941619873,
-0.04553833231329918,
0.5792684555053711,
0.2051524966955185,
-0.22894948720932007,
-0.1355619728565216,
-0.9790170788764954,
-0.051419761031866074,
-0.48937660455703735,
0.3199194669723511,
-0.2614756226539612,
-1.1996715068817139,
0.5671899318695068,
0.0025666269939392805,
0.07462140917778015,
0.1911741942167282,
0.44438284635543823,
0.07386185228824615,
0.8355613350868225,
0.8867296576499939,
-0.44201087951660156,
0.5323647260665894,
-0.172030970454216,
0.4745747447013855,
-1.1844849586486816,
0.12117443978786469,
-0.09642062336206436,
-0.28042006492614746,
-0.11284561455249786,
-0.3336349129676819,
0.3197462260723114,
-0.055678244680166245,
-0.36662596464157104,
0.29618003964424133,
-0.5090405941009521,
0.8853567242622375,
0.2367228865623474,
0.057906072586774826,
0.12635748088359833,
-0.13630497455596924,
0.34784725308418274,
0.12729208171367645,
-0.9511433243751526,
-0.29161229729652405,
1.1041818857192993,
0.569783091545105,
0.530201256275177,
0.10400466620922089,
0.3864749073982239,
-0.004722041077911854,
0.720971941947937,
-0.9661288857460022,
0.5342036485671997,
0.048268359154462814,
-0.3736589550971985,
-0.6749456524848938,
-0.1621689647436142,
-0.6579919457435608,
0.4127693474292755,
0.43026334047317505,
-0.9232518672943115,
-0.05638818070292473,
-0.045137543231248856,
-0.7965860962867737,
0.386898398399353,
-0.6606478691101074,
0.7427988648414612,
0.07775626331567764,
-0.42085370421409607,
-0.26544827222824097,
-0.9063730239868164,
0.46738964319229126,
-0.335618793964386,
0.20414283871650696,
0.17230536043643951,
-0.2207331508398056,
0.388596773147583,
-0.3064071834087372,
0.9548768401145935,
0.18247023224830627,
-0.2854118347167969,
0.163264662027359,
0.06273604929447174,
0.5920941233634949,
0.17424660921096802,
0.12142442911863327,
0.04826769605278969,
-0.3477972447872162,
-0.4858316481113434,
-0.5923775434494019,
0.8880949020385742,
-0.3287929892539978,
-0.5783876180648804,
-0.13496077060699463,
-0.7883061766624451,
-0.19359402358531952,
0.3873843848705292,
0.2721173167228699,
0.556273341178894,
-0.24689677357673645,
0.3456280529499054,
1.153478980064392,
0.055954910814762115,
1.1345092058181763,
0.5681710839271545,
0.053105756640434265,
-0.39803674817085266,
0.4765092432498932,
0.10260355472564697,
0.38557592034339905,
0.69077068567276,
-0.1261766403913498,
-0.40112820267677307,
-0.15370218455791473,
-0.5163483619689941,
0.44890764355659485,
-0.6898585557937622,
-0.2663303017616272,
-0.8488507270812988,
-0.27535280585289,
-0.24045458436012268,
-0.36180824041366577,
-0.4192560911178589,
-0.2098594754934311,
-0.24183069169521332,
0.19245705008506775,
0.2335832267999649,
0.4963831901550293,
0.3702053427696228,
0.519912838935852,
-0.5731505751609802,
0.30877572298049927,
0.2517857253551483,
0.6044742465019226,
0.409242182970047,
-0.8617631196975708,
-0.3861285150051117,
-0.3385365903377533,
-0.2381962537765503,
-0.527961015701294,
0.3859085142612457,
0.20667801797389984,
0.40188753604888916,
0.6134023070335388,
-0.02034056931734085,
0.671198308467865,
-0.7345723509788513,
0.5394418239593506,
0.1920316517353058,
-1.1410362720489502,
0.16549080610275269,
-0.42917153239250183,
0.8504934310913086,
0.31176674365997314,
0.24940064549446106,
-0.625299870967865,
-0.5609802007675171,
-0.5834103226661682,
-0.9904584288597107,
0.6971741914749146,
0.16120240092277527,
0.339645117521286,
-0.17302851378917694,
0.5175940990447998,
-0.06909925490617752,
-0.014395661652088165,
-0.7473769783973694,
-0.3013748526573181,
0.06087461858987808,
-0.15379539132118225,
-0.3183709681034088,
-0.7597419023513794,
-0.03620893135666847,
-0.3143038749694824,
0.5018864274024963,
-0.2598645091056824,
0.3127586841583252,
0.2416713833808899,
-0.22017592191696167,
-0.20087909698486328,
0.30050572752952576,
0.838627815246582,
0.6384009718894958,
-0.23758259415626526,
0.15107637643814087,
0.5495076775550842,
-0.2699539363384247,
0.15009945631027222,
-0.08485302329063416,
-0.06406909972429276,
-0.029230136424303055,
0.20720452070236206,
0.5996826887130737,
0.7587242722511292,
-0.7782018780708313,
0.45163917541503906,
-0.14629341661930084,
0.11327141523361206,
-0.7118814587593079,
-0.261376291513443,
0.31386739015579224,
0.17844247817993164,
0.3469906747341156,
-0.04934108257293701,
0.0900888741016388,
-0.2758783996105194,
0.2878919541835785,
0.3891877830028534,
-0.5556415319442749,
-0.08869392424821854,
0.8514239192008972,
0.09679223597049713,
-0.1171339675784111,
0.6154714226722717,
0.21221041679382324,
-0.11548618972301483,
0.413827121257782,
0.9010540246963501,
0.8938524723052979,
-0.3002425730228424,
-0.1805177479982376,
0.21466605365276337,
0.020886676385998726,
-0.11381928622722626,
-0.2726370096206665,
-0.46355414390563965,
-0.4415590763092041,
-0.7548071146011353,
-0.43573954701423645,
-0.2834014296531677,
0.41340556740760803,
-0.5162392854690552,
0.11061014235019684,
-0.49514254927635193,
0.12546491622924805,
-0.15883852541446686,
-0.3534334897994995,
-0.47170305252075195,
0.21141141653060913,
0.34891828894615173,
0.8751162886619568,
-0.5332992672920227,
1.0633636713027954,
0.1650051325559616,
-0.032850559800863266,
-0.3645790219306946,
-0.017705075442790985,
-0.3452050983905792,
-0.3611423075199127,
0.44773438572883606,
0.4451192617416382,
-0.3816728889942169,
0.35090363025665283,
-0.6539959907531738,
-1.387718677520752,
0.8882654905319214,
0.42272859811782837,
-0.8062689900398254,
0.08299519121646881,
-0.054964788258075714,
0.3830185532569885,
-0.3711065649986267,
0.4520196318626404,
0.8012449145317078,
0.39962834119796753,
0.20934584736824036,
-0.6207699179649353,
0.04616715386509895,
-0.13133618235588074,
0.12968644499778748,
0.2818863093852997,
-1.085375189781189,
0.5746185779571533,
0.1381731629371643,
-0.4175460934638977,
0.10821816325187683,
0.8206325769424438,
-0.0713275596499443,
-0.02820410579442978,
0.41288459300994873,
0.5712425708770752,
0.2736077904701233,
0.21477994322776794,
1.1723294258117676,
-0.30522415041923523,
0.35097020864486694,
1.1774461269378662,
-0.340709388256073,
0.7880731821060181,
0.7654010653495789,
0.17990177869796753,
0.10924475640058517,
0.3894181549549103,
0.22965309023857117,
0.6044849157333374,
0.2565937042236328,
-0.48823124170303345,
-0.07725013047456741,
-0.09127591550350189,
-0.07808167487382889,
0.08977603167295456,
0.26870885491371155,
-0.1916055679321289,
-0.21930338442325592,
0.2456723302602768,
0.33913692831993103,
-0.019781867042183876,
-0.34689053893089294,
0.5879627466201782,
0.1259552389383316,
-0.7898831367492676,
0.926134467124939,
-0.056017082184553146,
0.7623546123504639,
-0.5397827625274658,
0.06536814570426941,
-0.5310701727867126,
0.34245723485946655,
0.06057598441839218,
-0.4010316729545593,
0.4004392921924591,
-0.10403362661600113,
-0.5150334239006042,
-0.47324806451797485,
0.460079163312912,
-0.5729129314422607,
-0.4953254163265228,
0.404288113117218,
-0.13461773097515106,
0.019666196778416634,
-0.3237820565700531,
-0.04961732029914856,
0.04040183871984482,
-0.010269531980156898,
-0.5667569637298584,
0.38499364256858826,
0.3335346579551697,
-0.1425163298845291,
0.8893023133277893,
0.3342774510383606,
-0.4077613651752472,
0.00031675584614276886,
-0.14521178603172302,
0.8960907459259033,
-0.7898293137550354,
-0.4616222381591797,
-1.0666344165802002,
0.3526419699192047,
0.07888703048229218,
-0.06213384121656418,
0.8770511150360107,
0.6540560722351074,
0.6732978224754333,
-0.24352043867111206,
0.6666368842124939,
0.13179317116737366,
0.4449287950992584,
-0.2629185616970062,
0.6268966197967529,
-0.46731245517730713,
-0.022333292290568352,
-0.1674426943063736,
-1.1535485982894897,
-0.6304548978805542,
0.2333885282278061,
-0.1813974678516388,
-0.1869775801897049,
0.8082503080368042,
0.5676994919776917,
-0.3205549716949463,
-0.22417959570884705,
0.612973690032959,
0.1880735605955124,
0.13286355137825012,
0.9077750444412231,
0.6192147135734558,
-0.4669572710990906,
0.41354110836982727,
0.03229467198252678,
-0.3417714238166809,
-0.25586313009262085,
-0.7675140500068665,
-0.9936608076095581,
-0.3143324553966522,
-0.06088951230049133,
-0.046462301164865494,
-0.2901175916194916,
0.6064013838768005,
0.7756543159484863,
-0.8114801049232483,
-0.39809826016426086,
-0.03206413984298706,
-0.00707173440605402,
-0.18526649475097656,
-0.25116297602653503,
0.5228596925735474,
-0.42885828018188477,
-0.8895938396453857,
0.7296169996261597,
0.6361551880836487,
-0.06668777018785477,
-0.4199520945549011,
0.1300298571586609,
-0.0652923583984375,
0.31190037727355957,
1.0102277994155884,
0.28745198249816895,
-0.8147163391113281,
-0.2479136884212494,
0.00045258659520186484,
-0.03095611371099949,
0.17280161380767822,
0.7768789529800415,
-0.7734026908874512,
0.4309012293815613,
0.2223391979932785,
0.5178685784339905,
0.7245216369628906,
-0.06269145011901855,
0.6323118209838867,
-0.7081645727157593,
0.5475506782531738,
0.24736937880516052,
0.23499751091003418,
0.17945316433906555,
-0.5274998545646667,
0.5777585506439209,
-0.2644898593425751,
-0.6453740000724792,
-0.6785575747489929,
0.05476125329732895,
-1.0595290660858154,
-0.25050485134124756,
1.1093980073928833,
0.0025356742553412914,
-0.5420382022857666,
-0.07154738903045654,
-0.1259223371744156,
0.05859002470970154,
-0.42957112193107605,
0.5467173457145691,
0.5182254314422607,
0.03539925068616867,
-0.36731424927711487,
-0.720755934715271,
0.41260409355163574,
0.5658612847328186,
-0.3336251676082611,
0.31115496158599854,
0.30607080459594727,
0.14828521013259888,
0.11493218690156937,
0.6038129329681396,
-0.09468074887990952,
0.019957073032855988,
-0.29106470942497253,
0.17750875651836395,
0.20731481909751892,
-0.3051867187023163,
-0.6562871336936951,
0.4366225600242615,
-0.44923844933509827,
-0.05803791061043739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07135v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07135v2
|
Towards Robustness of Text-to-Visualization Translation against Lexical and Phrasal Variability
| 2024-04-10T16:12:50 | 2024-04-11T05:56:39 |
Jinwei Lu, Yuanfeng Song, Haodi Zhang, Chen Zhang, Raymond Chi-Wing Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text-to-Vis is an emerging task in the natural language processing (NLP) area
that aims to automatically generate data visualizations from natural language
questions (NLQs). Despite their progress, existing text-to-vis models often
heavily rely on lexical matching between words in the questions and tokens in
data schemas. This overreliance on lexical matching may lead to a diminished
level of model robustness against input variations. In this study, we
thoroughly examine the robustness of current text-to-vis models, an area that
has not previously been explored. In particular, we construct the first
robustness dataset nvBench-Rob, which contains diverse lexical and phrasal
variations based on the original text-to-vis benchmark nvBench. Then, we found
that the performance of existing text-to-vis models on this new dataset
dramatically drops, implying that these methods exhibit inadequate robustness
overall. Finally, we propose a novel framework based on Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) technique, named GRED, specifically designed to address input
perturbations in these two variants. The framework consists of three parts:
NLQ-Retrieval Generator, Visualization Query-Retrieval Retuner and
Annotation-based Debugger, which are used to tackle the challenges posed by
natural language variants, programming style differences and data schema
variants, respectively. Extensive experimental evaluations show that, compared
to the state-of-the-art model RGVisNet in the Text-to-Vis field, GRED performs
better in terms of model robustness, with a 32% increase in accuracy on the
proposed nvBench-Rob dataset.
|
[
-0.2551043629646301,
-0.8944659233093262,
0.4199959337711334,
-0.06487234681844711,
-0.4964812695980072,
-0.008042602799832821,
-0.2021300047636032,
-0.4456619620323181,
0.05333453044295311,
0.4451218545436859,
-0.3164355158805847,
-0.6917591691017151,
-0.7574489116668701,
0.2294013500213623,
-0.6159082055091858,
1.1828997135162354,
-0.06857325881719589,
-0.14336661994457245,
-0.43978196382522583,
-0.36342355608940125,
-0.6412469744682312,
-0.25519639253616333,
-0.16731038689613342,
0.0102009829133749,
0.4391080141067505,
0.22182297706604004,
0.848117470741272,
0.7192955017089844,
0.858663022518158,
0.15664364397525787,
-0.12897969782352448,
0.4066503047943115,
-0.6704810857772827,
0.5475876927375793,
-0.4225691556930542,
-0.3652612566947937,
-0.3108237683773041,
-0.4127599000930786,
0.6570166349411011,
0.548133909702301,
-0.09321200102567673,
0.15506692230701447,
0.36026427149772644,
0.6770782470703125,
-0.5709063410758972,
0.14751984179019928,
-0.8734500408172607,
-0.2374582588672638,
-0.33677154779434204,
-0.32722410559654236,
-0.48734867572784424,
-0.14660541713237762,
0.36777451634407043,
-0.7662969827651978,
0.15122151374816895,
0.13372476398944855,
1.1830919981002808,
0.5822070837020874,
-0.3576223850250244,
-0.19601716101169586,
-0.5853241682052612,
0.7447666525840759,
-0.7745772004127502,
0.5185531377792358,
0.26410436630249023,
0.44959354400634766,
-0.19992469251155853,
-0.8934145569801331,
-0.36530113220214844,
-0.13312873244285583,
0.04937879741191864,
0.19088327884674072,
-0.24584290385246277,
-0.11892244219779968,
0.01885155774652958,
0.43380433320999146,
-0.6706179976463318,
-0.08224573731422424,
0.06767071038484573,
-0.12293168902397156,
0.33860787749290466,
0.1977996826171875,
0.46278223395347595,
-0.4175533056259155,
-0.6455660462379456,
-0.5045902132987976,
-0.35789668560028076,
-0.07105400413274765,
0.10993735492229462,
0.6381773948669434,
-0.21763552725315094,
0.7257608771324158,
-0.02351708523929119,
0.9816443920135498,
-0.10172684490680695,
-0.27895230054855347,
0.24875615537166595,
-0.544272780418396,
-0.3227187395095825,
-0.4410496950149536,
0.7580867409706116,
0.7002931237220764,
0.33361104130744934,
-0.3563646078109741,
-0.2757703363895416,
-0.0109349200502038,
0.3929429054260254,
-0.758533775806427,
-0.2871289551258087,
0.0715218037366867,
-0.33791711926460266,
-0.5396227240562439,
0.09708691388368607,
-1.0693763494491577,
-0.5743861198425293,
-0.049469880759716034,
0.5417327284812927,
-0.540733277797699,
-0.09275420010089874,
0.14967378973960876,
-0.15326575934886932,
0.1913837343454361,
0.3889297544956207,
-0.8536490201950073,
0.15685243904590607,
0.5457431077957153,
0.9359431266784668,
-0.8074368834495544,
-0.1815129518508911,
-0.46341782808303833,
0.11896958202123642,
-0.5037274956703186,
0.7429379224777222,
-0.3429749310016632,
-0.47200241684913635,
-0.041483074426651,
-0.1780347228050232,
-0.18658313155174255,
-0.46444422006607056,
0.4124187231063843,
-0.4376268684864044,
0.21295537054538727,
-0.353193998336792,
-0.4995277225971222,
-0.14323420822620392,
0.6246960163116455,
-0.5882867574691772,
1.0545486211776733,
0.10588181763887405,
-1.379500150680542,
0.5847993493080139,
-0.27690425515174866,
-0.2785363793373108,
-0.053873881697654724,
-0.4940166473388672,
-0.6267586350440979,
0.06406684964895248,
0.4186376631259918,
0.2964700758457184,
-0.5891830325126648,
0.4136875569820404,
-0.15070763230323792,
-0.24148550629615784,
0.044823046773672104,
-0.6194287538528442,
0.4933924078941345,
0.09443686157464981,
-0.16963866353034973,
0.18119575083255768,
-0.9283014535903931,
0.011831018142402172,
0.31052544713020325,
-0.4172033667564392,
-0.40779992938041687,
0.22080644965171814,
0.22188349068164825,
-0.01802176609635353,
0.1588762402534485,
-0.26217320561408997,
0.16052569448947906,
-0.6807134747505188,
0.1291593760251999,
0.5899978876113892,
0.15490064024925232,
0.5383033752441406,
-0.27495846152305603,
0.7008295655250549,
-0.06813444942235947,
-0.058850862085819244,
-0.2911064624786377,
-0.6301520466804504,
-0.46480366587638855,
-0.3605867922306061,
0.30226969718933105,
0.8846784234046936,
-1.2230008840560913,
0.05415189638733864,
-0.582513153553009,
-0.5466848015785217,
-0.01672496274113655,
-0.13966207206249237,
0.19322845339775085,
0.9854595065116882,
0.3926260471343994,
-0.25055187940597534,
-0.29240426421165466,
-0.7598320841789246,
-0.38998496532440186,
-0.42190101742744446,
-0.19388890266418457,
0.27453142404556274,
0.40016764402389526,
-0.42401304841041565,
1.0359779596328735,
-0.2866840660572052,
-0.17650288343429565,
-0.16570618748664856,
0.1987171471118927,
0.05784666910767555,
0.36029303073883057,
0.8236915469169617,
-0.8134757280349731,
-0.39021754264831543,
0.3166877031326294,
-0.6304011940956116,
-0.34085994958877563,
-0.0876844972372055,
-0.16229377686977386,
0.21481013298034668,
0.4976121187210083,
-0.10652466118335724,
0.8626543879508972,
0.6161813139915466,
-0.3841812014579773,
0.4622567594051361,
-0.26498904824256897,
0.018505269661545753,
-1.4404009580612183,
0.28999432921409607,
-0.005237656179815531,
-0.33339449763298035,
-0.6086699366569519,
0.19766634702682495,
0.1048092320561409,
-0.13099943101406097,
-0.2923988997936249,
0.41475170850753784,
-0.22798995673656464,
-0.0022897745948284864,
-0.2958810031414032,
0.20837333798408508,
0.27827897667884827,
0.26000070571899414,
-0.29504960775375366,
0.8541401028633118,
0.7505382895469666,
-0.6262217164039612,
0.28172674775123596,
0.4061224162578583,
-0.23351094126701355,
0.6517232656478882,
-0.8718481063842773,
-0.06921395659446716,
-0.3455278277397156,
-0.0066957478411495686,
-1.0566990375518799,
-0.22035188972949982,
0.3748966157436371,
-0.5993384122848511,
0.4066627323627472,
-0.07365033030509949,
-0.5114022493362427,
0.16433674097061157,
-0.3649900257587433,
0.48598557710647583,
0.17578844726085663,
-0.549875020980835,
0.8489419221878052,
0.18214280903339386,
-0.11991207301616669,
-0.6198440194129944,
-0.8855708837509155,
0.31461837887763977,
-0.2451368123292923,
-0.8721667528152466,
0.34963560104370117,
0.08596103638410568,
-0.18012002110481262,
-0.15516798198223114,
-0.20660318434238434,
0.025060953572392464,
0.059967041015625,
0.1932707279920578,
0.5946590304374695,
-0.11520522832870483,
0.01700134016573429,
-0.15658038854599,
-0.05871661752462387,
-0.1171613559126854,
-0.21983084082603455,
0.3286593556404114,
-0.06304318457841873,
-0.4483698606491089,
-0.104859858751297,
0.3043026030063629,
0.5016372799873352,
-0.37861862778663635,
0.6219092607498169,
0.6261078119277954,
-0.3618326485157013,
-0.1462542712688446,
-0.2180165946483612,
0.055327292531728745,
-0.441873162984848,
0.5880946516990662,
-0.1719914674758911,
-0.6702993512153625,
0.6931257843971252,
0.07123173773288727,
0.2288103699684143,
0.4348047971725464,
0.5767237544059753,
0.04632867872714996,
0.8864913582801819,
0.9168730974197388,
0.08949435502290726,
0.5602977871894836,
0.016933254897594452,
0.16609083116054535,
-0.5608677268028259,
-0.19800728559494019,
-0.431903213262558,
-0.10112310945987701,
-0.9038490056991577,
-0.5359633564949036,
0.3925899565219879,
-0.2502908408641815,
0.07774028927087784,
0.19154159724712372,
-0.6328589916229248,
0.05451161041855812,
0.30495935678482056,
-0.2891421616077423,
0.16009561717510223,
0.2606126666069031,
-0.3356405794620514,
-0.39484256505966187,
-0.7861074209213257,
-0.444597989320755,
0.9580117464065552,
0.295316606760025,
1.0081937313079834,
0.13171063363552094,
0.395212322473526,
0.10966512560844421,
-0.20057018101215363,
-0.6140140295028687,
0.4974529445171356,
-0.2207619994878769,
-0.3256213366985321,
-0.27276909351348877,
-0.5164655447006226,
-1.0587486028671265,
0.39513441920280457,
-0.5774482488632202,
-0.927818238735199,
0.564417839050293,
0.18015240132808685,
-0.0030900368001312017,
0.4388638734817505,
-0.6860532760620117,
0.8535792231559753,
-0.11314012855291367,
-0.5721015930175781,
0.39599674940109253,
-0.8491399884223938,
-0.048205938190221786,
-0.06354731321334839,
0.16864517331123352,
0.10864542424678802,
-0.09476000815629959,
0.43095341324806213,
-0.2912282645702362,
0.5720524787902832,
0.12824714183807373,
-0.4849484860897064,
0.08841775357723236,
0.35018327832221985,
0.5947492122650146,
0.287565141916275,
0.08497966825962067,
-0.00036651379195973277,
0.07810162752866745,
-0.32537713646888733,
-0.5808482766151428,
0.5247306227684021,
-0.3401072025299072,
-0.32067278027534485,
-0.4940322935581207,
-0.827736496925354,
-0.2516316771507263,
0.2888243496417999,
0.6524357795715332,
0.6132742166519165,
-0.11977949738502502,
0.19439354538917542,
0.7239504456520081,
-0.5352801084518433,
0.22824284434318542,
0.0673259049654007,
-0.7276121377944946,
-0.38344302773475647,
1.1234346628189087,
0.056423161178827286,
0.49487197399139404,
0.4609740376472473,
0.1521175056695938,
-0.12806656956672668,
-0.6105767488479614,
-0.6092492341995239,
-0.09853610396385193,
-0.8039862513542175,
-0.19884146749973297,
-0.29540911316871643,
0.010236331261694431,
-0.31411078572273254,
-0.04792726784944534,
-0.42312324047088623,
-0.14245791733264923,
-0.3769482672214508,
0.09451517462730408,
0.38094478845596313,
0.6230325102806091,
0.11313685774803162,
-0.05391768366098404,
-0.4351733326911926,
0.5668277740478516,
0.23642313480377197,
0.46946972608566284,
-0.2822735607624054,
-0.639548659324646,
-0.07332157343626022,
-0.060982607305049896,
0.0027216633316129446,
-1.0272090435028076,
0.3450412452220917,
0.19579088687896729,
0.25451651215553284,
0.23286519944667816,
0.013018721714615822,
0.45406374335289,
-0.4327390491962433,
0.814826250076294,
0.010221507400274277,
-0.5707916021347046,
0.6406113505363464,
-0.5889967679977417,
0.365943044424057,
0.5967069268226624,
-0.2483816146850586,
-0.41533973813056946,
-0.4841059148311615,
-0.2535094618797302,
-1.2973883152008057,
0.2669816315174103,
0.3245275020599365,
0.012573922984302044,
0.05560857430100441,
0.30707743763923645,
0.20004472136497498,
0.16181865334510803,
-0.5932976603507996,
-0.33448755741119385,
-0.4548749029636383,
-0.19474157691001892,
0.08814974874258041,
-0.16632632911205292,
0.15907706320285797,
-0.12674564123153687,
0.4725397825241089,
-0.23535391688346863,
0.0667528510093689,
0.2679726779460907,
-0.011199074797332287,
0.21307554841041565,
0.08470840007066727,
0.4591981768608093,
0.7146468758583069,
-0.2362753003835678,
0.19100061058998108,
0.15485306084156036,
-0.6880339980125427,
-0.2743307054042816,
0.1585315614938736,
-0.49146583676338196,
0.23624178767204285,
0.2373468279838562,
0.9681273698806763,
0.0012889810604974627,
-0.7317292094230652,
0.6514838933944702,
-0.2481534332036972,
-0.15467719733715057,
0.16289393603801727,
-0.19715505838394165,
-0.23429006338119507,
0.056814372539520264,
0.26995211839675903,
0.30454832315444946,
0.17415592074394226,
-0.18999171257019043,
0.1278167963027954,
0.5151110291481018,
-0.3036169409751892,
-0.06764999777078629,
1.0980234146118164,
-0.15152670443058014,
-0.11123603582382202,
0.1752958744764328,
-0.07301642745733261,
-0.25862476229667664,
0.28662413358688354,
0.5232388973236084,
0.6111440062522888,
0.20500677824020386,
0.19631339609622955,
0.14984051883220673,
0.40113765001296997,
-0.0718473270535469,
0.22910350561141968,
0.13227152824401855,
-0.3923065960407257,
-0.49103087186813354,
-0.1941261887550354,
-0.41677042841911316,
-0.16052497923374176,
-0.9581384658813477,
0.39629343152046204,
-0.1843908727169037,
-0.3558642864227295,
-0.30860331654548645,
-0.44482046365737915,
-0.49093136191368103,
0.32514044642448425,
0.10107160359621048,
0.7259675860404968,
-0.6897563338279724,
0.6291894316673279,
0.8687353134155273,
-0.26220110058784485,
-0.6052645444869995,
0.32405903935432434,
-0.3012101948261261,
-0.5723733305931091,
0.09308173507452011,
-0.10103437304496765,
-0.24893498420715332,
-0.19525893032550812,
-0.6332539916038513,
-0.9673378467559814,
1.0721899271011353,
0.6687840819358826,
-0.27366355061531067,
-0.07547633349895477,
0.2828422784805298,
0.5559954643249512,
0.10614405572414398,
-0.25185856223106384,
0.40051454305648804,
0.37472015619277954,
0.05338573083281517,
-0.897952675819397,
-0.1005631610751152,
-0.42389336228370667,
0.341650128364563,
0.21543678641319275,
-0.2003142237663269,
0.8631046414375305,
-0.11104882508516312,
-0.44478705525398254,
0.023778779432177544,
0.7084851264953613,
0.2014627754688263,
0.2505480647087097,
0.3577598035335541,
0.44830989837646484,
0.7743310928344727,
-0.17861956357955933,
1.2857446670532227,
-0.2523373067378998,
0.3713023364543915,
1.0947901010513306,
-0.05971290543675423,
0.6855644583702087,
0.8072137236595154,
0.1702488213777542,
0.23209500312805176,
0.17822158336639404,
-0.19144536554813385,
0.6880905628204346,
0.16839700937271118,
0.25306737422943115,
-0.0420050248503685,
-0.047599658370018005,
-0.45773839950561523,
0.3338581323623657,
0.1918513923883438,
-0.23236185312271118,
-0.39266419410705566,
0.005513916723430157,
-0.21819575130939484,
0.5178622603416443,
-0.009922964498400688,
0.575468897819519,
-0.1309530884027481,
-0.3700536787509918,
0.7060781717300415,
0.05926434323191643,
0.9461489319801331,
-0.5570482015609741,
0.08637052029371262,
-0.016874581575393677,
-0.05510422959923744,
-0.11661926656961441,
-0.6601523160934448,
0.2989155650138855,
0.09685344994068146,
-0.1668047308921814,
-0.016581661999225616,
1.066693663597107,
-0.2657383680343628,
-0.6354967951774597,
0.1753518432378769,
0.7410392165184021,
-0.1004902571439743,
0.13964851200580597,
-0.4000016152858734,
0.1868986338376999,
0.08263471722602844,
-0.22120724618434906,
0.30523526668548584,
0.5930819511413574,
-0.10061950981616974,
0.8502936959266663,
0.2914344370365143,
0.061642348766326904,
0.2960321009159088,
0.10371071845293045,
0.7328284382820129,
-0.3311563730239868,
-0.4636375308036804,
-0.9264799952507019,
0.498892217874527,
0.03929031640291214,
-0.40080583095550537,
0.9152216911315918,
0.45544981956481934,
0.6875408887863159,
0.0888657420873642,
0.7417611479759216,
-0.00901112426072359,
0.5628376007080078,
-0.3586357831954956,
0.7190753221511841,
-0.7633748650550842,
0.3339124023914337,
-0.6480388045310974,
-0.7460687756538391,
-0.5394079089164734,
0.644703209400177,
0.05385274812579155,
-0.05737040936946869,
0.4527866542339325,
0.5925738215446472,
0.008384431712329388,
-0.19216474890708923,
0.2731935679912567,
-0.07752059400081635,
0.47582393884658813,
0.2672296166419983,
0.43714088201522827,
-0.4808686077594757,
0.7148536443710327,
-0.03686174750328064,
0.0385759100317955,
-0.18308842182159424,
-1.147693395614624,
-0.8201990723609924,
-0.7468208074569702,
-0.3000399172306061,
-0.4569045305252075,
0.05781244859099388,
0.5386077761650085,
0.27201929688453674,
-0.5950355529785156,
0.059012047946453094,
-0.25249984860420227,
-0.026816336438059807,
-0.1150631457567215,
-0.19556336104869843,
0.42889082431793213,
-0.23986536264419556,
-0.5862677097320557,
0.356829971075058,
0.3197568356990814,
0.3652782142162323,
-0.17333149909973145,
0.1849697381258011,
0.018146483227610588,
0.2022165060043335,
0.4415352940559387,
0.14803802967071533,
-0.5082200169563293,
-0.41418886184692383,
0.26930949091911316,
-0.19690605998039246,
0.28565993905067444,
0.32397887110710144,
-0.751882791519165,
0.7227603197097778,
0.7266538739204407,
1.0079264640808105,
0.2704298496246338,
0.12819436192512512,
0.6791278719902039,
-0.9600552916526794,
0.1653064787387848,
0.18016700446605682,
0.26540642976760864,
0.5774187445640564,
-0.07155222445726395,
0.4745618999004364,
0.010032432153820992,
-0.5616562962532043,
-1.0650737285614014,
0.2921920120716095,
-1.1150861978530884,
-0.06620275229215622,
1.3008499145507812,
0.11647188663482666,
-0.24642342329025269,
0.0019394075497984886,
-0.4700284004211426,
0.3769042193889618,
-0.12940055131912231,
0.7105188369750977,
0.7259776592254639,
0.24419695138931274,
0.17707911133766174,
-0.7786031365394592,
0.3075478672981262,
0.5711082220077515,
-0.6516666412353516,
0.06557286530733109,
0.32566672563552856,
0.19099725782871246,
0.15701085329055786,
0.16952933371067047,
-0.13519228994846344,
0.16650637984275818,
-0.10844700038433075,
-0.10205279290676117,
-0.00048578623682260513,
-0.17810681462287903,
-0.1945841759443283,
0.09948419779539108,
0.18590056896209717,
-0.3872012197971344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08698v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08698v1
|
Lossless Acceleration of Large Language Model via Adaptive N-gram Parallel Decoding
| 2024-04-10T16:11:09 | 2024-04-10T16:11:09 |
Jie Ou, Yueming Chen, Wenhong Tian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable abilities, they are
hindered by significant resource consumption and considerable latency due to
autoregressive processing. In this study, we introduce Adaptive N-gram Parallel
Decoding (ANPD), an innovative and lossless approach that accelerates inference
by allowing the simultaneous generation of multiple tokens. ANPD incorporates a
two-stage approach: it begins with a rapid drafting phase that employs an
N-gram module, which adapts based on the current interactive context, followed
by a verification phase, during which the original LLM assesses and confirms
the proposed tokens. Consequently, ANPD preserves the integrity of the LLM's
original output while enhancing processing speed. We further leverage a
multi-level architecture for the N-gram module to enhance the precision of the
initial draft, consequently reducing inference latency. ANPD eliminates the
need for retraining or extra GPU memory, making it an efficient and
plug-and-play enhancement. In our experiments, models such as LLaMA and its
fine-tuned variants have shown speed improvements up to 3.67x, validating the
effectiveness of our proposed ANPD.
|
[
-0.15351594984531403,
-0.7488744258880615,
0.38330039381980896,
0.624879002571106,
-0.3846818208694458,
0.38441359996795654,
-0.2508573532104492,
-0.3633743226528168,
0.09474921971559525,
0.3330781161785126,
-0.26275867223739624,
-0.38510841131210327,
-0.9265384078025818,
0.211748868227005,
-0.36317721009254456,
0.38270851969718933,
-0.08839953690767288,
0.11450011283159256,
0.03414274379611015,
-0.32763320207595825,
-0.3664763569831848,
-0.25927653908729553,
-1.0960160493850708,
-0.1651204377412796,
0.1923760622739792,
0.543110191822052,
0.5843623280525208,
1.1367735862731934,
0.24925343692302704,
0.2956332564353943,
-0.2858330011367798,
0.3001090884208679,
-0.3346991539001465,
0.05971476808190346,
0.13142740726470947,
-0.4633430242538452,
-0.8613843321800232,
-0.5355623364448547,
0.9780067205429077,
0.5448791980743408,
-0.33590060472488403,
0.10043076425790787,
0.04312995448708534,
0.7924842834472656,
-0.7919279932975769,
0.29328495264053345,
-0.7109838724136353,
-0.1429980993270874,
-0.14522869884967804,
-0.31319916248321533,
-0.5014734268188477,
-0.2461279183626175,
-0.18223832547664642,
-0.6948453783988953,
0.18344052135944366,
0.13987381756305695,
0.35447508096694946,
0.20368905365467072,
-0.16923405230045319,
-0.2852626442909241,
-0.5591049790382385,
0.5721035003662109,
-1.0263442993164062,
0.40578797459602356,
0.10939814150333405,
0.2727881371974945,
-0.4116443693637848,
-0.6314460635185242,
-0.7064979076385498,
-0.17300495505332947,
0.2876955568790436,
-0.1777733713388443,
-0.30275028944015503,
0.1183968260884285,
0.3187828063964844,
0.28688111901283264,
-0.5478184819221497,
0.5473219752311707,
0.01443979050964117,
-0.14390593767166138,
0.43984508514404297,
0.3527148962020874,
0.287649542093277,
0.07704000920057297,
-0.20392833650112152,
-0.029865961521863937,
-0.56671541929245,
-0.22755174338817596,
0.4048421084880829,
0.2686641216278076,
-0.42391571402549744,
0.3097659945487976,
-0.4548088610172272,
0.6890615224838257,
0.04370226338505745,
-0.1191045343875885,
0.4084472358226776,
-0.3344918489456177,
-0.1331307291984558,
0.1818424016237259,
0.6999247074127197,
0.2874526381492615,
0.29932186007499695,
-0.12493611127138138,
-0.11961916834115982,
0.14147982001304626,
0.07279744744300842,
-1.06571626663208,
-0.09439259022474289,
0.25026610493659973,
-0.5466639399528503,
-0.10498695820569992,
-0.464967280626297,
-1.100719928741455,
-0.49562665820121765,
-0.04696819186210632,
0.2628959119319916,
-0.2527530789375305,
-0.3842359185218811,
0.6567383408546448,
-0.014406442642211914,
0.08510156720876694,
0.5124161839485168,
-1.1380677223205566,
0.5080134868621826,
0.5511341691017151,
1.1261134147644043,
-0.24655121564865112,
-0.4797903895378113,
-0.7999081611633301,
0.26694735884666443,
-0.3976326286792755,
0.907435953617096,
-0.7257050275802612,
-0.32228419184684753,
-0.08000224083662033,
-0.14465849101543427,
-0.012510739266872406,
-0.4758715033531189,
0.6390012502670288,
-0.5207475423812866,
-0.14841443300247192,
-0.15987235307693481,
-0.4627746641635895,
-0.2265707403421402,
0.18662047386169434,
-0.4831269383430481,
0.9002513885498047,
-0.33192309737205505,
-0.949932873249054,
0.2691146433353424,
-0.7277862429618835,
-0.5145038366317749,
-0.06466581672430038,
0.06996475160121918,
-0.260348379611969,
0.51478111743927,
0.7081281542778015,
0.29946351051330566,
-0.49209097027778625,
0.06055322289466858,
-0.48535147309303284,
-0.5447201132774353,
-0.3027753531932831,
-0.6210057735443115,
0.6488633751869202,
-0.07920128107070923,
-0.2110769897699356,
0.286381334066391,
-1.2580602169036865,
-0.22693583369255066,
0.20143817365169525,
-0.5811991691589355,
-0.036293819546699524,
0.23585562407970428,
-0.13725203275680542,
-0.021356267854571342,
0.19869962334632874,
-0.8345829844474792,
0.4042883813381195,
-0.3041480481624603,
0.45540860295295715,
0.8653669357299805,
-0.14648087322711945,
0.5287098288536072,
-0.17291933298110962,
0.49321720004081726,
-0.09129556268453598,
0.04155204817652702,
-0.24052409827709198,
-0.46110624074935913,
-0.8289171457290649,
-0.3180537223815918,
0.36695396900177,
0.41120919585227966,
-0.8017733097076416,
0.1343686431646347,
-0.480485737323761,
-0.3832370936870575,
-0.5200110077857971,
0.12529201805591583,
0.13706906139850616,
0.5375382900238037,
0.40583476424217224,
-0.6224222779273987,
-0.4883577227592468,
-0.5432724952697754,
-0.28138643503189087,
-0.3548777997493744,
-0.12952056527137756,
0.1254412978887558,
0.056278567761182785,
-0.029638746753335,
0.44487422704696655,
-0.43448886275291443,
-0.1501753032207489,
-0.3298582434654236,
0.3983078896999359,
0.19838404655456543,
0.4520874619483948,
0.47700828313827515,
-0.32675230503082275,
-0.5246051549911499,
0.08030620217323303,
-0.59694504737854,
-0.4565247595310211,
-0.10062076151371002,
-0.1279163360595703,
0.21553866565227509,
0.6059829592704773,
-0.5000395774841309,
0.24340295791625977,
0.8164510726928711,
-0.30796921253204346,
0.5966513752937317,
-0.7032240033149719,
-0.07513689994812012,
-0.8048620223999023,
-0.031413353979587555,
-0.3794921934604645,
-0.19945083558559418,
-0.7701958417892456,
0.0010486538521945477,
0.4297963082790375,
0.07475943118333817,
-0.1532127559185028,
0.6838482618331909,
-0.615198016166687,
-0.319612592458725,
-0.9692086577415466,
-0.05494507774710655,
0.11564461141824722,
0.36522531509399414,
-0.01925237663090229,
0.9352064728736877,
1.009431004524231,
-0.7020254731178284,
0.13223862648010254,
0.14145632088184357,
-0.2636539340019226,
0.16869592666625977,
-0.43896692991256714,
0.158641517162323,
-0.47223740816116333,
0.42111048102378845,
-0.9165128469467163,
-0.08299394696950912,
0.13098889589309692,
-0.4366822838783264,
0.29134654998779297,
-0.11291602998971939,
-0.7399831414222717,
-0.13535337150096893,
-0.16231206059455872,
0.5604267120361328,
0.39863258600234985,
-0.7474367618560791,
0.9173393845558167,
0.2065839022397995,
-0.3253399431705475,
-0.5089305639266968,
-0.6891039609909058,
0.44749775528907776,
-0.03752010315656662,
-0.43715307116508484,
0.3020007312297821,
-0.03182150796055794,
0.22147201001644135,
0.05604238063097,
-0.14268147945404053,
-0.051150862127542496,
0.1617995649576187,
-0.02321215718984604,
0.016300471499562263,
-0.33607161045074463,
0.12818452715873718,
0.077772356569767,
-0.2373223453760147,
-0.021520668640732765,
-0.39081916213035583,
0.7925679683685303,
0.24490800499916077,
-0.1340363472700119,
-0.7143701314926147,
0.39495113492012024,
0.8059268593788147,
-0.4416925311088562,
0.796380877494812,
0.678333580493927,
-0.3465481102466583,
-0.2973144054412842,
-0.6225672960281372,
0.27394434809684753,
-0.4815017580986023,
0.40473806858062744,
-0.22551649808883667,
-0.8301542401313782,
0.7115731835365295,
-0.08338543027639389,
0.053815506398677826,
0.2147553414106369,
0.7824962735176086,
0.580636203289032,
1.0428465604782104,
0.738222599029541,
-0.30887457728385925,
0.6461613774299622,
0.17330418527126312,
0.11932528018951416,
-0.9005235433578491,
-0.14183001220226288,
-0.5753599405288696,
-0.1399955451488495,
-0.40158653259277344,
-0.7272393107414246,
0.11018966883420944,
0.24075500667095184,
-0.13177677989006042,
0.174209326505661,
-0.05790958181023598,
0.340461403131485,
0.3709268867969513,
-0.08195579051971436,
0.5834789276123047,
0.06333903968334198,
-0.10135868936777115,
0.4241868555545807,
-0.798991322517395,
-0.31855249404907227,
1.2253127098083496,
0.45765310525894165,
0.8555709719657898,
0.19785001873970032,
0.3994709849357605,
0.1784103512763977,
0.22659507393836975,
-0.6746642589569092,
0.6250606179237366,
-0.3599875569343567,
-0.1489814966917038,
-0.10443092882633209,
-0.6087662577629089,
-0.5508674383163452,
0.46083661913871765,
-0.2608848810195923,
-0.7303447127342224,
0.30144059658050537,
0.34691593050956726,
-0.2391577512025833,
0.45770055055618286,
-0.7559643387794495,
0.6027427911758423,
-0.07493532449007034,
-0.407645046710968,
-0.49579286575317383,
-0.05590684711933136,
0.37124890089035034,
-0.2570449411869049,
0.1609640121459961,
-0.41940411925315857,
-0.2834756374359131,
0.5328068733215332,
-0.1675547957420349,
0.5664830207824707,
-0.4476546049118042,
-0.15640076994895935,
0.0578889362514019,
0.05012446641921997,
0.7201399207115173,
0.11080268025398254,
-0.5367569327354431,
0.1983785480260849,
-0.46903881430625916,
-0.6617879271507263,
-0.6205818057060242,
0.6484968066215515,
-0.3644806444644928,
-0.6515001058578491,
-0.11041995882987976,
-0.8948251605033875,
-0.2772211730480194,
0.3626203238964081,
-0.22457487881183624,
0.5118411183357239,
0.19635282456874847,
-0.03738359734416008,
0.2097851186990738,
-0.5270261168479919,
0.7832058668136597,
0.6425396800041199,
-0.06828878819942474,
-0.44948238134384155,
0.6955528259277344,
-0.0394883006811142,
0.5346598625183105,
0.38569381833076477,
0.3256088197231293,
-0.47037506103515625,
-1.2865915298461914,
-0.7876620888710022,
0.1674795150756836,
-0.5664004683494568,
-0.1985144317150116,
-0.8560498952865601,
0.21171313524246216,
-0.5337724685668945,
0.18447355926036835,
-0.47808846831321716,
-0.40114814043045044,
-0.15088044106960297,
0.04315076768398285,
0.28896594047546387,
0.5969462990760803,
-0.15038242936134338,
0.45423388481140137,
-0.8213019371032715,
0.5635057091712952,
0.08201172202825546,
0.5653040409088135,
0.44324102997779846,
-0.7178501486778259,
-0.13811354339122772,
-0.31448957324028015,
-0.0987565740942955,
-0.5712239146232605,
0.3799721598625183,
0.41824448108673096,
0.3873053193092346,
0.3944569230079651,
0.04284631088376045,
1.0079305171966553,
-0.8376121520996094,
0.3997557461261749,
0.03707486763596535,
-1.0728998184204102,
-0.00950143113732338,
-0.13482263684272766,
0.6015037298202515,
0.27608922123908997,
0.04902796074748039,
-0.3896406292915344,
-0.3278261721134186,
-0.05304411053657532,
-0.7424106597900391,
0.7430490851402283,
-0.003929470665752888,
0.30663934350013733,
0.007202059030532837,
0.36860421299934387,
0.051423121243715286,
0.05321458354592323,
-0.4850563406944275,
-0.02030842937529087,
-0.05772089958190918,
-0.133992537856102,
-0.12764815986156464,
-0.6217676997184753,
0.2792171239852905,
-0.004397126846015453,
0.5378299951553345,
-0.32447993755340576,
0.2513616681098938,
0.11856728047132492,
-0.045011937618255615,
-0.18372012674808502,
0.24823231995105743,
0.5729905366897583,
0.6868542432785034,
-0.1886564940214157,
0.15029242634773254,
0.3159146010875702,
-0.5157128572463989,
0.25287121534347534,
0.22784414887428284,
0.0012584950309246778,
-0.10234776884317398,
0.5318217873573303,
1.1634140014648438,
0.04887723550200462,
-0.6928265690803528,
0.46682751178741455,
-0.48220351338386536,
-0.17378120124340057,
0.24740999937057495,
-0.1421184092760086,
0.1310405284166336,
0.32186099886894226,
0.37237662076950073,
-0.03414011001586914,
0.06664971262216568,
-0.27238979935646057,
0.1304464340209961,
0.24968449771404266,
0.20970574021339417,
-0.296923965215683,
0.8410245776176453,
0.05852961912751198,
-0.20933225750923157,
0.4855749011039734,
-0.3742665946483612,
-0.3289373517036438,
0.39736053347587585,
0.84125155210495,
0.9439371824264526,
-0.27196672558784485,
0.07685848325490952,
0.4410001337528229,
0.27745309472084045,
-0.3289323151111603,
0.3267097771167755,
0.006954267155379057,
-0.8032915592193604,
-0.811183750629425,
-1.116217017173767,
-0.34418123960494995,
-0.012549852952361107,
-0.6105825901031494,
0.03626783564686775,
-0.7628346681594849,
0.26124709844589233,
-0.13520918786525726,
-0.22107486426830292,
-0.31057798862457275,
-0.025906812399625778,
0.18911589682102203,
1.4071292877197266,
-0.8599978089332581,
1.1239433288574219,
0.30295220017433167,
0.27415457367897034,
-0.6030992269515991,
0.45696306228637695,
-0.20755714178085327,
-0.974711537361145,
0.389486163854599,
0.3120570480823517,
-0.07466797530651093,
0.21106351912021637,
0.17992912232875824,
-1.0123305320739746,
0.8391751646995544,
0.7904182076454163,
-0.6285921335220337,
-0.13072702288627625,
0.013884354382753372,
0.5283964276313782,
-0.3832988739013672,
0.17376042902469635,
0.5779677629470825,
0.24723148345947266,
0.15093369781970978,
-0.8905302882194519,
0.23558390140533447,
-0.12282615900039673,
0.20304787158966064,
0.18451601266860962,
-0.48841235041618347,
0.9281907081604004,
-0.21401850879192352,
-0.3963950276374817,
0.30112722516059875,
0.7539888620376587,
0.19529619812965393,
-0.03992404788732529,
0.5723171830177307,
0.7278879284858704,
0.6665650606155396,
0.2695140540599823,
1.1251533031463623,
-0.5085164904594421,
0.12145604193210602,
1.1219600439071655,
-0.2423429787158966,
1.0697941780090332,
0.33327430486679077,
0.05379355326294899,
0.46443721652030945,
0.33556461334228516,
0.22346536815166473,
0.41600900888442993,
0.2912241220474243,
-0.520944356918335,
-0.2813815772533417,
-0.1840979903936386,
-0.3511638641357422,
0.7458112835884094,
0.315073698759079,
-0.108201764523983,
-0.5274263024330139,
-0.010302589274942875,
-0.21157950162887573,
0.049885351210832596,
-0.6192470192909241,
0.5690589547157288,
-0.18250423669815063,
-0.42388567328453064,
0.7096192240715027,
0.40894559025764465,
0.6362945437431335,
-0.4638798236846924,
-0.03590799495577812,
-0.2945879399776459,
0.21130290627479553,
-0.050329238176345825,
-0.3331472873687744,
0.245883509516716,
0.2099113017320633,
-0.025418896228075027,
-0.21223415434360504,
0.6078693270683289,
-0.32506296038627625,
-0.7084642052650452,
0.6311705112457275,
0.22519248723983765,
-0.08738436549901962,
-0.042397789657115936,
-0.5579748153686523,
0.4778805077075958,
-0.2670586407184601,
-0.10757646709680557,
0.3240460157394409,
0.48903778195381165,
0.013832759112119675,
0.7317418456077576,
0.6910315155982971,
0.40697023272514343,
0.5447920560836792,
0.1984652429819107,
0.9734784364700317,
-0.45863428711891174,
-0.6090902090072632,
-0.9357135891914368,
0.17928732931613922,
0.10847202688455582,
-0.05912614241242409,
0.7971102595329285,
0.46223530173301697,
0.8408305048942566,
0.048456884920597076,
0.5947780609130859,
0.15049304068088531,
0.27802377939224243,
-0.7894589304924011,
0.4283359944820404,
-0.5500270128250122,
0.34653887152671814,
-0.15934821963310242,
-0.8520499467849731,
-0.6079434156417847,
0.2639129161834717,
-0.11535321921110153,
-0.22454984486103058,
0.4715445041656494,
0.9181273579597473,
-0.11985006183385849,
-0.056091465055942535,
0.22139713168144226,
0.4522456228733063,
0.41953927278518677,
0.6310840249061584,
0.4240598678588867,
-0.35027801990509033,
0.5543117523193359,
-0.030417127534747124,
-0.3566402196884155,
0.07162007689476013,
-1.1891587972640991,
-0.7534716129302979,
0.13338986039161682,
-0.10005135089159012,
-0.13589443266391754,
0.17998726665973663,
0.6504806876182556,
0.4694713056087494,
-0.7237293124198914,
-0.4441114068031311,
-0.5760641694068909,
-0.024027014151215553,
-0.06323960423469543,
-0.09600190818309784,
0.5009428262710571,
-0.5189900398254395,
-1.035180926322937,
0.7267088294029236,
0.6472764015197754,
-0.09153489023447037,
-0.09069973230361938,
-0.20316152274608612,
-0.20193079113960266,
0.005896999966353178,
0.4925362467765808,
0.2893557548522949,
-0.5861005187034607,
-0.38194674253463745,
-0.40785709023475647,
0.30533507466316223,
0.23678608238697052,
0.7421984672546387,
-0.6331883072853088,
0.7182306051254272,
0.6930235028266907,
1.1252402067184448,
0.4655247926712036,
0.039487097412347794,
0.7316634654998779,
-0.48118552565574646,
0.3829784095287323,
-0.08603186160326004,
0.3324536681175232,
0.37943029403686523,
-0.2000223994255066,
-0.022668717429041862,
0.24659812450408936,
-0.323476105928421,
-1.001538872718811,
0.2293986976146698,
-0.7923864722251892,
-0.1634509414434433,
0.9470590949058533,
-0.2970615029335022,
-0.24958500266075134,
0.08087389171123505,
-0.07692081481218338,
0.26608285307884216,
-0.3797042667865753,
0.7148513793945312,
0.544005811214447,
-0.07817727327346802,
-0.3639342486858368,
-0.5239768028259277,
0.24403727054595947,
0.6033401489257812,
-0.8030629754066467,
0.5398261547088623,
0.23229621350765228,
0.26254841685295105,
-0.1968585103750229,
0.8569739460945129,
-0.1266157329082489,
0.20234689116477966,
0.29256993532180786,
0.00021015257516410202,
-0.27721288800239563,
-0.5214667916297913,
-0.7827833294868469,
0.35049086809158325,
0.33866792917251587,
-0.4632745385169983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07117v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07117v1
|
Continuous Language Model Interpolation for Dynamic and Controllable Text Generation
| 2024-04-10T15:55:07 | 2024-04-10T15:55:07 |
Sara Kangaslahti, David Alvarez-Melis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
As large language models (LLMs) have gained popularity for a variety of use
cases, making them adaptable and controllable has become increasingly
important, especially for user-facing applications. While the existing
literature on LLM adaptation primarily focuses on finding a model (or models)
that optimizes a single predefined objective, here we focus on the challenging
case where the model must dynamically adapt to diverse -- and often changing --
user preferences. For this, we leverage adaptation methods based on linear
weight interpolation, casting them as continuous multi-domain interpolators
that produce models with specific prescribed generation characteristics
on-the-fly. Specifically, we use low-rank updates to fine-tune a base model to
various different domains, yielding a set of anchor models with distinct
generation profiles. Then, we use the weight updates of these anchor models to
parametrize the entire (infinite) class of models contained within their convex
hull. We empirically show that varying the interpolation weights yields
predictable and consistent change in the model outputs with respect to all of
the controlled attributes. We find that there is little entanglement between
most attributes and identify and discuss the pairs of attributes for which this
is not the case. Our results suggest that linearly interpolating between the
weights of fine-tuned models facilitates predictable, fine-grained control of
model outputs with respect to multiple stylistic characteristics
simultaneously.
|
[
-0.19154396653175354,
-0.8123306632041931,
0.6285873055458069,
0.5723366141319275,
-0.12739600241184235,
0.42051708698272705,
-0.5484941601753235,
-0.37736546993255615,
-0.1229967325925827,
0.5361772179603577,
-0.5907569527626038,
-0.45607733726501465,
-0.5891591906547546,
0.04637531191110611,
-0.35732942819595337,
0.9736795425415039,
-0.17571642994880676,
-0.1471269279718399,
-0.2896324098110199,
-0.1309189647436142,
-0.30211684107780457,
-0.5372777581214905,
-0.6178726553916931,
-0.3928646743297577,
0.657593309879303,
0.43391886353492737,
0.7883391380310059,
0.5016292929649353,
0.2741343677043915,
0.1730932593345642,
-0.08107207715511322,
0.3330489993095398,
-0.6279541850090027,
0.27460137009620667,
-0.28311046957969666,
-0.3274524509906769,
-0.323921799659729,
-0.017016008496284485,
0.8081990480422974,
0.48524561524391174,
-0.02613365650177002,
0.15247409045696259,
0.5391619801521301,
0.5880647897720337,
-0.32346677780151367,
-0.028303224593400955,
-1.1349339485168457,
-0.2287939041852951,
-0.14923390746116638,
-0.6142483353614807,
-0.6520135998725891,
-0.4231194257736206,
-0.023220641538500786,
-0.5605120658874512,
-0.008081626147031784,
0.016719257459044456,
0.9446710348129272,
0.2360977828502655,
-0.4351177215576172,
-0.6235748529434204,
-1.0418486595153809,
0.9400586485862732,
-0.9315640926361084,
0.22868067026138306,
0.09353581815958023,
0.09729119390249252,
-0.3679659962654114,
-0.6611795425415039,
-0.39189413189888,
-0.6130819916725159,
0.20175707340240479,
0.11147947609424591,
-0.03517554700374603,
0.08562665432691574,
0.08361666649580002,
-0.012786728329956532,
-0.12448087334632874,
0.4257493317127228,
-0.05938602238893509,
0.21405145525932312,
0.6607180237770081,
0.12688440084457397,
0.35825997591018677,
0.1513068675994873,
-0.34046196937561035,
-0.007154365535825491,
-0.7765838503837585,
0.16978389024734497,
0.7231317162513733,
0.48156875371932983,
-0.3153100609779358,
0.5047750473022461,
-0.12553438544273376,
0.6649774312973022,
0.35080787539482117,
-0.31810733675956726,
-0.16230662167072296,
-0.24309605360031128,
0.21826766431331635,
-0.05754450708627701,
0.562960147857666,
0.27340421080589294,
0.6150938868522644,
0.05752146244049072,
-0.25284144282341003,
-0.2641693353652954,
0.3633624315261841,
-0.7410727739334106,
-0.2178107053041458,
0.1330965906381607,
-0.36973336338996887,
-0.39080139994621277,
-0.08613134175539017,
-0.6779751777648926,
-0.3587009906768799,
-0.48645633459091187,
0.40224921703338623,
-0.18872611224651337,
0.055790018290281296,
0.16581963002681732,
0.2654241919517517,
0.0509350448846817,
0.4723895490169525,
-1.1623766422271729,
0.40716809034347534,
0.3186756372451782,
0.8527826070785522,
-0.5385749936103821,
-0.10607758909463882,
-0.5850415229797363,
0.2186882048845291,
-0.3563228249549866,
0.4721050560474396,
-0.6508275866508484,
-0.06393488496541977,
0.14753511548042297,
-0.17305351793766022,
0.015346689149737358,
-0.42825931310653687,
0.1331394761800766,
-0.5678678154945374,
0.006550540216267109,
0.07309778034687042,
-0.36289164423942566,
0.1988482028245926,
0.13399189710617065,
-0.4902915954589844,
0.9484000205993652,
0.14692559838294983,
-0.57471764087677,
0.3303244709968567,
-0.27014049887657166,
-0.23820926249027252,
-0.01157232467085123,
-0.14172151684761047,
-0.7029474377632141,
0.3483019769191742,
-0.017071697860956192,
0.5454323291778564,
-0.3508376181125641,
0.25400441884994507,
-0.4820135533809662,
-0.06622817367315292,
0.5264057517051697,
-0.40739360451698303,
0.15141795575618744,
0.11102265864610672,
-0.14529570937156677,
0.31180036067962646,
-0.9942693710327148,
0.10296953469514847,
0.04781376197934151,
-0.8371660113334656,
-0.26825982332229614,
0.5441688299179077,
0.2816837430000305,
0.16620545089244843,
0.32449913024902344,
-0.278107613325119,
0.34206369519233704,
0.019325120374560356,
0.4073483943939209,
0.8251174092292786,
0.15415853261947632,
0.42714163661003113,
-0.48328351974487305,
0.5817381739616394,
-0.04536475986242294,
-0.02363794855773449,
-0.07274852693080902,
-0.3207971453666687,
-0.8945729732513428,
-0.255658894777298,
0.3548654615879059,
0.3411104679107666,
-0.7369321584701538,
0.2263765186071396,
-0.24147789180278778,
-0.5031229853630066,
-0.26453980803489685,
0.1797269880771637,
0.286029577255249,
0.24437522888183594,
0.2841428220272064,
-0.13972525298595428,
-0.14085619151592255,
-0.648777961730957,
-0.592654287815094,
0.054401397705078125,
-0.08697634935379028,
0.27137893438339233,
0.24238480627536774,
0.09835181385278702,
0.8624743223190308,
-0.4881342053413391,
-0.09652583301067352,
-0.35528191924095154,
0.2715429365634918,
0.2643137574195862,
0.6094787120819092,
0.7496374845504761,
-0.8176971077919006,
-0.8909134268760681,
0.08955812454223633,
-0.41471919417381287,
-0.40891262888908386,
-0.733364999294281,
-0.024966584518551826,
0.020458009093999863,
0.74139404296875,
-0.1405913531780243,
0.16791808605194092,
0.9709792137145996,
-0.13094967603683472,
0.6045160293579102,
-0.47395119071006775,
-0.19030559062957764,
-1.0590511560440063,
-0.153547465801239,
0.1103862076997757,
-0.43378496170043945,
-0.6830308437347412,
0.08810357004404068,
0.04801030829548836,
0.07910726964473724,
-0.26981407403945923,
0.6085608601570129,
-0.4989154636859894,
-0.018605129793286324,
-0.3447173237800598,
0.013381454162299633,
0.04934746026992798,
0.5368826389312744,
-0.06608957052230835,
0.7605885863304138,
0.31324437260627747,
-0.7148212194442749,
0.11785529553890228,
0.0007968885474838316,
-0.4580425024032593,
0.32998567819595337,
-0.568621039390564,
0.1409091204404831,
-0.21277152001857758,
0.06751490384340286,
-0.9493834972381592,
-0.30804362893104553,
-0.04227933660149574,
-0.15932409465312958,
0.18500632047653198,
-0.14858417212963104,
-0.4696134626865387,
0.04778396338224411,
-0.12213332206010818,
0.19303792715072632,
0.36529600620269775,
-0.42128896713256836,
0.6575325727462769,
0.15776605904102325,
-0.5367420315742493,
-0.050220564007759094,
-0.4832126200199127,
-0.0034269767347723246,
-0.2711259126663208,
-0.2422368824481964,
0.6952285766601562,
-0.6018216013908386,
-0.2960350215435028,
-0.14963924884796143,
0.06144699826836586,
0.01378739345818758,
0.23500002920627594,
0.12617497146129608,
0.1075863316655159,
-0.14119791984558105,
0.09712321311235428,
0.5107458233833313,
0.06473661214113235,
-0.332327663898468,
-0.40115365386009216,
0.6842166781425476,
0.16038274765014648,
-0.3234461545944214,
-0.16089507937431335,
0.26153993606567383,
0.6371795535087585,
-0.16855093836784363,
0.7184833884239197,
0.24263118207454681,
-0.3109075725078583,
-0.6722095608711243,
-0.3368690311908722,
0.05822450667619705,
-0.5285776257514954,
0.5024200081825256,
-0.6407010555267334,
-0.8873801827430725,
0.44677719473838806,
-0.22397178411483765,
0.2565361261367798,
0.14215001463890076,
0.8791174292564392,
-0.1503112018108368,
1.0870270729064941,
1.067294716835022,
0.34007635712623596,
0.729483962059021,
0.2553516924381256,
0.027347570285201073,
-0.6868568062782288,
0.020537955686450005,
-0.4109249413013458,
-0.45480403304100037,
-0.8600091338157654,
-0.16009224951267242,
0.5470170378684998,
0.36855992674827576,
-0.07241281121969223,
0.2245457023382187,
-0.36262446641921997,
0.31045329570770264,
0.4983189105987549,
0.20323483645915985,
0.3515302836894989,
0.1476738452911377,
-0.13576723635196686,
-0.2187950164079666,
-0.5492092967033386,
-0.5545055270195007,
0.8397982120513916,
0.3668985962867737,
1.1452594995498657,
0.1685812920331955,
0.42116081714630127,
0.5349867939949036,
0.36173784732818604,
-0.6329882740974426,
0.34756916761398315,
-0.5142826437950134,
-0.18975941836833954,
-0.1984473317861557,
-0.3526214361190796,
-0.7129673957824707,
0.05689411982893944,
-0.5319320559501648,
-0.8024317622184753,
0.1939707100391388,
0.4079526960849762,
-0.32021111249923706,
0.1944374293088913,
-0.33581891655921936,
0.38344696164131165,
-0.30480635166168213,
-0.42524653673171997,
-0.15844225883483887,
-0.22922568023204803,
0.1796727478504181,
-0.6880598664283752,
0.17369399964809418,
-0.43272751569747925,
-0.0528627410531044,
0.28681880235671997,
-0.16706489026546478,
0.8159375786781311,
0.13581103086471558,
-0.15381106734275818,
0.15035408735275269,
0.2686648368835449,
0.6872159838676453,
0.022994238883256912,
-0.31894025206565857,
-0.06482642889022827,
-0.08135653287172318,
-0.26981693506240845,
-0.4116764962673187,
0.6711121797561646,
-0.8021660447120667,
-0.5135530829429626,
-0.09842666983604431,
-0.8787135481834412,
-0.34994587302207947,
0.23142366111278534,
0.2500022351741791,
0.5202420353889465,
-0.07186049968004227,
0.30300500988960266,
0.513563334941864,
-0.5520365238189697,
0.4255313575267792,
0.2831273078918457,
-0.38888776302337646,
-0.2246105819940567,
0.8539975881576538,
0.19837883114814758,
0.8165388703346252,
0.5491724014282227,
0.20996853709220886,
-0.034249767661094666,
-0.7248789668083191,
-0.4418712556362152,
0.22949853539466858,
-0.6922377943992615,
-0.04471420496702194,
-0.48329585790634155,
-0.42879265546798706,
-0.10910191386938095,
-0.5561612248420715,
-0.28958526253700256,
-0.3526468873023987,
-0.643754780292511,
0.15298539400100708,
0.40626174211502075,
0.8302285075187683,
0.24362945556640625,
0.7694007754325867,
-0.5795005559921265,
0.43609124422073364,
0.29211753606796265,
0.22229620814323425,
-0.21521306037902832,
-0.7214728593826294,
-0.28143301606178284,
-0.08291437476873398,
-0.31319954991340637,
-0.7073719501495361,
0.5401387810707092,
0.583464503288269,
0.29751089215278625,
0.13755308091640472,
0.04345066100358963,
0.45683807134628296,
-0.6635671257972717,
0.6129067540168762,
0.20363843441009521,
-0.9619308114051819,
0.20442864298820496,
-0.5380289554595947,
0.4495757818222046,
0.30608701705932617,
0.2999626100063324,
-0.48540830612182617,
-0.5695523023605347,
-0.12577085196971893,
-0.842810869216919,
0.5637273192405701,
-0.027560420334339142,
0.5504488945007324,
0.3796783983707428,
0.6463915705680847,
0.1800210028886795,
0.3114543557167053,
-1.0075291395187378,
0.14388270676136017,
-0.014956222847104073,
-0.5733550190925598,
0.10248281061649323,
-0.38364744186401367,
-0.004182456526905298,
0.05496697872877121,
0.6636020541191101,
-0.5831637382507324,
-0.07885261625051498,
-0.20733843743801117,
-0.12390512973070145,
-0.20125068724155426,
0.21304094791412354,
0.7524958848953247,
0.8936010003089905,
-0.1714611053466797,
0.16197438538074493,
0.0033187614753842354,
-0.4111688733100891,
0.24717244505882263,
0.0002566210168879479,
-0.49422478675842285,
-0.07665358483791351,
0.24470852315425873,
0.9437000751495361,
0.3204450309276581,
-0.5899890661239624,
0.31044572591781616,
0.06375129520893097,
-0.10811340808868408,
-0.24498899281024933,
0.16815508902072906,
0.09596675634384155,
0.3112558424472809,
0.35330280661582947,
-0.012848662212491035,
-0.48532629013061523,
-0.39496809244155884,
0.1697368323802948,
0.3710329532623291,
-0.4390801191329956,
-0.3979494273662567,
1.1258307695388794,
0.06637772172689438,
-0.282874196767807,
0.23003080487251282,
0.17932172119617462,
-0.185402512550354,
0.4412018060684204,
0.7628792524337769,
0.8791175484657288,
-0.1513931304216385,
0.10937423259019852,
0.21617065370082855,
0.27734315395355225,
0.08351686596870422,
0.23102083802223206,
0.20166702568531036,
-1.0314658880233765,
-0.31354838609695435,
-0.9608963131904602,
-0.5090513825416565,
0.132109135389328,
-0.5217729806900024,
0.4761390686035156,
-0.873891294002533,
-0.27038687467575073,
-0.017372217029333115,
-0.3128712475299835,
-0.3797123432159424,
0.2083357274532318,
0.267669677734375,
0.9207620620727539,
-0.6901164650917053,
1.09101140499115,
0.3857232332229614,
-0.2654557526111603,
-0.4950159788131714,
0.34597936272621155,
-0.07146268337965012,
-0.6273901462554932,
0.4963766038417816,
-0.08240746706724167,
-0.19527950882911682,
0.43324434757232666,
-0.7053662538528442,
-1.0763323307037354,
0.9338390231132507,
0.4094786047935486,
-0.7292096018791199,
-0.3389763832092285,
0.3811565935611725,
0.3641069233417511,
-0.6279801726341248,
-0.15098482370376587,
0.34278714656829834,
0.36417028307914734,
-0.09383522719144821,
-0.7582258582115173,
-0.08244650065898895,
0.05207900330424309,
0.33782723546028137,
-0.020218996331095695,
-0.7246471643447876,
1.0262444019317627,
-0.030489187687635422,
-0.12570004165172577,
0.3117200434207916,
0.8485238552093506,
0.5341458916664124,
-0.1537669599056244,
0.6348745226860046,
0.03441814333200455,
0.5243489146232605,
-0.015191937796771526,
0.8358097672462463,
-0.5585266947746277,
0.2080019861459732,
1.286659598350525,
-0.3765978515148163,
0.740014910697937,
0.5247873663902283,
0.023687750101089478,
0.5876210331916809,
0.46526771783828735,
-0.01753988303244114,
0.5484026670455933,
0.31601524353027344,
-0.3590737283229828,
-0.1997627168893814,
-0.15934887528419495,
0.12004131823778152,
0.30048009753227234,
0.47774654626846313,
-0.376936674118042,
-0.01446453295648098,
0.11312823742628098,
0.22183524072170258,
0.4337432086467743,
-0.2853814661502838,
0.5339061617851257,
0.13342654705047607,
-0.7464900016784668,
0.5622501373291016,
0.316718727350235,
0.6482194662094116,
-0.9563541412353516,
0.02520749717950821,
-0.018468892201781273,
0.31944623589515686,
-0.021465059369802475,
-0.6034346222877502,
-0.018186477944254875,
0.08582031726837158,
-0.31272244453430176,
-0.6154158711433411,
0.7849039435386658,
-0.7581402659416199,
-0.4843420684337616,
0.36004453897476196,
0.17843839526176453,
-0.27108803391456604,
0.05569475516676903,
-0.6592960953712463,
0.36681652069091797,
0.18435896933078766,
-0.5039368271827698,
0.42998215556144714,
0.15001149475574493,
-0.27862226963043213,
0.6816744804382324,
0.8557743430137634,
0.44111689925193787,
0.48843640089035034,
-0.052286870777606964,
0.8660271167755127,
-0.3430790305137634,
-0.34842321276664734,
-0.6404281854629517,
0.692399799823761,
0.1354435682296753,
-0.36111003160476685,
0.5051398277282715,
0.1773848831653595,
0.7705872058868408,
-0.16782927513122559,
0.9089360237121582,
0.11590200662612915,
0.40484559535980225,
-0.9156892895698547,
0.8017956018447876,
-0.7793636918067932,
0.12345264106988907,
-0.2567233145236969,
-1.2413239479064941,
-0.3243314027786255,
0.22336071729660034,
-0.02546112984418869,
-0.11238479614257812,
0.3708758056163788,
0.6283361315727234,
-0.17535583674907684,
-0.5859230160713196,
0.428613543510437,
0.4364623427391052,
0.5941618084907532,
0.2393028885126114,
0.721234917640686,
-0.10500507801771164,
0.28858137130737305,
-0.07558147609233856,
-0.34615954756736755,
-0.2284783124923706,
-1.2137532234191895,
-0.6443480253219604,
-0.6498650908470154,
-0.33424368500709534,
-0.41197460889816284,
0.035150282084941864,
0.9330289363861084,
0.7884106636047363,
-0.817914605140686,
-0.44670259952545166,
-0.02382076345384121,
-0.05504602566361427,
-0.15706005692481995,
-0.22807790338993073,
0.1593363881111145,
-0.46554866433143616,
-1.033170461654663,
0.46127569675445557,
0.45387378334999084,
0.14918242394924164,
-0.38625508546829224,
-0.11688248813152313,
-0.23212696611881256,
0.722862720489502,
0.6389188170433044,
0.28488582372665405,
-0.5956465005874634,
-0.4002033770084381,
-0.21656884253025055,
-0.3383801281452179,
0.04786587879061699,
0.7840571999549866,
-0.48082050681114197,
0.4967758059501648,
0.4152686595916748,
0.622404158115387,
0.6113325953483582,
0.10979382693767548,
0.7075538635253906,
-1.0703015327453613,
0.2611095607280731,
0.013636915944516659,
0.2101246565580368,
0.2678370475769043,
-0.3054843842983246,
0.18673647940158844,
0.06168312579393387,
-0.5905792713165283,
-0.7838858962059021,
0.5689005851745605,
-1.001499891281128,
-0.298730731010437,
1.1746350526809692,
-0.15631242096424103,
0.01990986429154873,
0.11615070700645447,
-0.16095539927482605,
0.1634863018989563,
-0.05101146176457405,
0.6756640672683716,
0.6337783336639404,
-0.07566221803426743,
-0.2767452001571655,
-0.6330150961875916,
0.5780640244483948,
0.24050049483776093,
-0.9749687314033508,
0.13363239169120789,
0.32517534494400024,
0.2919537425041199,
-0.08111734688282013,
0.5612116456031799,
0.028887713328003883,
-0.2396431565284729,
-0.38966047763824463,
0.2232825607061386,
0.2814362943172455,
-0.5806964039802551,
-0.2054591029882431,
0.09084003418684006,
0.47649067640304565,
0.2080279290676117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07108v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07108v2
|
From Model-centered to Human-Centered: Revision Distance as a Metric for Text Evaluation in LLMs-based Applications
| 2024-04-10T15:46:08 | 2024-04-11T02:36:27 |
Yongqiang Ma, Lizhi Qing, Jiawei Liu, Yangyang Kang, Yue Zhang, Wei Lu, Xiaozhong Liu, Qikai Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Evaluating large language models (LLMs) is fundamental, particularly in the
context of practical applications. Conventional evaluation methods, typically
designed primarily for LLM development, yield numerical scores that ignore the
user experience. Therefore, our study shifts the focus from model-centered to
human-centered evaluation in the context of AI-powered writing assistance
applications. Our proposed metric, termed ``Revision Distance,'' utilizes LLMs
to suggest revision edits that mimic the human writing process. It is
determined by counting the revision edits generated by LLMs. Benefiting from
the generated revision edit details, our metric can provide a self-explained
text evaluation result in a human-understandable manner beyond the
context-independent score. Our results show that for the easy-writing task,
``Revision Distance'' is consistent with established metrics (ROUGE,
Bert-score, and GPT-score), but offers more insightful, detailed feedback and
better distinguishes between texts. Moreover, in the context of challenging
academic writing tasks, our metric still delivers reliable evaluations where
other metrics tend to struggle. Furthermore, our metric also holds significant
potential for scenarios lacking reference texts.
|
[
-0.06458442658185959,
-0.6082334518432617,
0.9664227366447449,
0.18422441184520721,
-0.11190993338823318,
0.024871477857232094,
-0.47110044956207275,
-0.6352739334106445,
0.06066852807998657,
0.289705753326416,
-0.5860478281974792,
-0.5288515686988831,
-0.37489941716194153,
0.4809004068374634,
-0.2374068945646286,
0.863469123840332,
-0.19353027641773224,
0.21815605461597443,
-0.7692676186561584,
-0.049402106553316116,
-0.24895262718200684,
-0.4976736009120941,
-0.31263917684555054,
-0.48929399251937866,
0.7898207306861877,
0.2107643336057663,
0.2748490571975708,
0.9692681431770325,
0.94032222032547,
0.3313490152359009,
-0.04725509509444237,
0.06998994946479797,
-0.05064356327056885,
0.18922995030879974,
-0.25038406252861023,
-0.5956801176071167,
-0.7538709044456482,
-0.02071501314640045,
0.7617685198783875,
0.7884048223495483,
0.11968469619750977,
0.1787489503622055,
0.12625713646411896,
1.2763996124267578,
-0.459258109331131,
-0.1618904173374176,
-0.3217024505138397,
0.0374474823474884,
-0.34094297885894775,
0.020639950409531593,
-0.37605029344558716,
-0.5008732676506042,
0.21363569796085358,
-0.6938085556030273,
0.4375438094139099,
-0.022742198780179024,
0.6622031927108765,
0.2080915868282318,
-0.18832166492938995,
-0.36286818981170654,
-0.891597330570221,
0.7349318265914917,
-0.6665640473365784,
0.412282258272171,
0.04032593220472336,
0.31986281275749207,
-0.21184301376342773,
-0.6042494773864746,
-0.5823615193367004,
-0.3269835412502289,
0.04499395191669464,
0.04559490829706192,
-0.060253869742155075,
0.2484944462776184,
0.22746308147907257,
0.3817831575870514,
-0.32280924916267395,
0.12650899589061737,
-0.4660820960998535,
-0.2222532033920288,
0.8250464200973511,
0.38559797406196594,
-0.0017137384274974465,
-0.33327844738960266,
-0.20648141205310822,
0.05546199530363083,
-0.6712692975997925,
-0.1168275773525238,
0.4500521719455719,
0.2608623504638672,
0.0874876081943512,
0.297580361366272,
-0.26148664951324463,
0.6909918189048767,
-0.10187374800443649,
-0.10139501839876175,
0.14068558812141418,
-0.32331010699272156,
-0.23828674852848053,
-0.2973414659500122,
0.8395673036575317,
0.6759719848632812,
0.16534064710140228,
-0.36830130219459534,
-0.38603904843330383,
-0.1733318716287613,
0.45658010244369507,
-0.634027361869812,
-0.09668770432472229,
-0.22386778891086578,
-0.6254556775093079,
-0.13554345071315765,
0.1364627331495285,
-0.6578176021575928,
-0.7554066777229309,
-0.6970241069793701,
0.3317781388759613,
-0.2979063391685486,
0.08185193687677383,
-0.23906318843364716,
0.02768681012094021,
-0.12716840207576752,
0.7800323963165283,
-0.6591528654098511,
0.427396297454834,
0.7836667895317078,
1.0010968446731567,
-0.4620685875415802,
-0.5099795460700989,
-0.08685381710529327,
-0.018160337582230568,
-0.16346818208694458,
1.000796914100647,
-0.3503422737121582,
-0.6419978141784668,
-0.32822224497795105,
-0.23600991070270538,
0.12187296152114868,
-0.6022025346755981,
0.5544915199279785,
-0.2654336392879486,
0.19944220781326294,
-0.2383752018213272,
-0.7785031199455261,
-0.24435098469257355,
0.3741273283958435,
-0.5940505862236023,
1.0958442687988281,
0.1591566801071167,
-0.5155026316642761,
0.2565653920173645,
-0.6209014058113098,
-0.42979392409324646,
-0.0985594168305397,
0.19884781539440155,
-0.36740124225616455,
0.18922489881515503,
0.02047581784427166,
0.2856694757938385,
-0.5595883131027222,
-0.057696543633937836,
-0.24797455966472626,
-0.546066164970398,
0.11378231644630432,
-0.6374117136001587,
0.11609043926000595,
-0.056152116507291794,
-0.17397361993789673,
0.44641101360321045,
-0.8052733540534973,
-0.03390687704086304,
-0.2760145366191864,
-0.5195069313049316,
-0.5427493453025818,
0.005614411551505327,
-0.03432335704565048,
0.013530544005334377,
0.3058810532093048,
-0.6199518442153931,
0.40746426582336426,
-0.3153274953365326,
0.2599405348300934,
0.9716651439666748,
-0.059205733239650726,
0.6079157590866089,
-0.5452212691307068,
0.6689457893371582,
-0.4652320444583893,
0.17910873889923096,
-0.1802959442138672,
-0.17606383562088013,
-0.6446691751480103,
-0.3303188681602478,
0.43962743878364563,
0.41186392307281494,
-0.29508960247039795,
0.49896830320358276,
-0.4788441061973572,
-0.7327179908752441,
-0.7306907176971436,
0.26145994663238525,
0.4436962902545929,
0.692007303237915,
0.2794427275657654,
-0.33308133482933044,
-0.42873814702033997,
-0.7290947437286377,
-0.7280526757240295,
-0.41481342911720276,
-0.24402658641338348,
0.23248247802257538,
0.39874139428138733,
-0.23839206993579865,
0.9940364360809326,
-0.501605212688446,
-0.47941556572914124,
-0.24135510623455048,
-0.05391690880060196,
-0.012127247639000416,
0.20626212656497955,
0.18842372298240662,
-0.43702423572540283,
-0.5227558612823486,
-0.24074842035770416,
-0.5150562524795532,
-0.5256367921829224,
-0.2355879843235016,
-0.08509790897369385,
0.3272321820259094,
0.6079056859016418,
-0.3775031268596649,
0.47046950459480286,
0.29177984595298767,
-0.3371247947216034,
0.8775601387023926,
-0.4677249491214752,
0.25041428208351135,
-0.9779011011123657,
0.22828726470470428,
0.16154982149600983,
-0.3257608711719513,
-0.32023176550865173,
-0.20200127363204956,
0.027912253513932228,
0.34193965792655945,
-0.07650911062955856,
0.7570943236351013,
-0.52817302942276,
-0.2179512232542038,
-0.0388951376080513,
0.5936620235443115,
0.2561494708061218,
0.1535276621580124,
-0.21409763395786285,
0.5833223462104797,
-0.1570746749639511,
-0.23396821320056915,
0.3333742320537567,
-0.1564519852399826,
-0.3493465185165405,
0.8561382293701172,
-0.4100036323070526,
0.5609563589096069,
0.10936997085809708,
0.32284367084503174,
-0.8291359543800354,
-0.038318827748298645,
-0.06561776250600815,
-0.3629557192325592,
0.04528430476784706,
0.28834256529808044,
-0.4608853757381439,
-0.2430957853794098,
-0.5225383639335632,
0.22853709757328033,
0.2994271516799927,
-0.2985609471797943,
0.44275936484336853,
-0.01972145400941372,
-0.19377551972866058,
-0.30401062965393066,
-0.5120642781257629,
0.15699222683906555,
-0.10933144390583038,
-0.601729154586792,
0.43629884719848633,
-0.21794356405735016,
-0.5813502669334412,
-0.06116929277777672,
-0.02633155696094036,
0.03752670809626579,
0.11989408731460571,
0.5877528190612793,
0.39254698157310486,
-0.04312024638056755,
0.3150769770145416,
0.08428645133972168,
0.006857538595795631,
0.17794154584407806,
0.02315385639667511,
0.0018768776208162308,
-0.04506446421146393,
-0.4938545227050781,
-0.5262860059738159,
0.06217446178197861,
0.6687815189361572,
-0.0076717715710401535,
0.4120791554450989,
0.1489073634147644,
-0.3501299321651459,
-0.09585700184106827,
-0.6118798851966858,
-0.22626133263111115,
-0.39871126413345337,
0.4019244909286499,
-0.22909098863601685,
-0.7322990298271179,
0.34447917342185974,
-0.08302568644285202,
0.11243537813425064,
0.5225817561149597,
0.446100115776062,
-0.130501851439476,
0.4866204261779785,
0.6657022833824158,
-0.23798376321792603,
0.511955201625824,
0.09281913191080093,
0.06579355150461197,
-1.1496738195419312,
-0.3497677147388458,
-0.5959298014640808,
-0.47912290692329407,
-0.14209377765655518,
-0.32302531599998474,
0.33118903636932373,
0.29848283529281616,
-0.07353083044290543,
0.005941282492130995,
-0.5009019374847412,
0.5269522070884705,
0.40275028347969055,
0.031718891113996506,
0.6254359483718872,
-0.07900605350732803,
-0.14422032237052917,
-0.485540509223938,
-0.36567696928977966,
-0.764518678188324,
1.1008214950561523,
0.40102487802505493,
0.46281835436820984,
-0.00883183442056179,
0.7549277544021606,
0.5796645283699036,
0.9864407181739807,
-0.8586924076080322,
0.6014344096183777,
-0.08903595060110092,
-0.37915998697280884,
-0.5140654444694519,
-0.3951178789138794,
-0.6484395861625671,
0.2279915064573288,
-0.07934916764497757,
-0.6105505228042603,
-0.43813976645469666,
-0.013954846188426018,
-0.30867379903793335,
0.3005218803882599,
-0.6329594850540161,
0.72813880443573,
-0.07905317097902298,
-0.4210165739059448,
-0.2757260799407959,
-0.5537562966346741,
-0.07169203460216522,
-0.14182230830192566,
0.30914387106895447,
-0.10823603719472885,
-0.12030600756406784,
0.8435994982719421,
-0.6383169293403625,
0.5062040090560913,
-0.026855193078517914,
-0.04676876217126846,
0.20597754418849945,
0.326141893863678,
0.15726704895496368,
-0.19369423389434814,
-0.6317618489265442,
0.2046137899160385,
-0.15101642906665802,
0.013089127838611603,
-0.7385724186897278,
0.7744702100753784,
-0.5653197765350342,
-0.5578091144561768,
-0.4234214723110199,
-0.7841452956199646,
-0.10890455543994904,
0.4004700779914856,
0.11177153140306473,
0.2603068947792053,
-0.3325754702091217,
0.0018278240459039807,
0.0028865623753517866,
-0.03260951116681099,
0.6172810196876526,
0.6895919442176819,
-0.2636124789714813,
-0.4564160704612732,
0.49779924750328064,
0.007234896998852491,
0.2506335973739624,
0.439510315656662,
0.2612574100494385,
-0.5362643599510193,
-0.5425647497177124,
-0.7412371039390564,
0.3222639858722687,
-0.6838229894638062,
-0.10448084771633148,
-0.13974133133888245,
0.15503565967082977,
-0.3023887872695923,
-0.4299842119216919,
-0.31744059920310974,
-0.4034043550491333,
-0.415780246257782,
-0.07027105242013931,
0.2764664888381958,
1.2538485527038574,
-0.08220117539167404,
0.09629924595355988,
-0.9194033741950989,
-0.03767656534910202,
-0.10098229348659515,
0.4536772072315216,
0.1809774935245514,
-0.6472002863883972,
-0.26887351274490356,
-0.11285409331321716,
-0.57258540391922,
-0.7659596800804138,
0.24548350274562836,
0.13981670141220093,
0.025901976972818375,
0.04780272766947746,
-0.0535857118666172,
0.7139897346496582,
-0.5329076647758484,
0.9158486127853394,
0.1173090934753418,
-1.056215524673462,
0.26990291476249695,
-0.28444960713386536,
0.4252186715602875,
0.765188992023468,
-0.08082524687051773,
-0.8278400301933289,
-0.28506186604499817,
-0.2593347728252411,
-0.6441887617111206,
0.5712049007415771,
0.07437589019536972,
-0.04530363902449608,
0.2847597599029541,
0.9673714637756348,
0.07804735004901886,
0.10283014923334122,
-0.6372735500335693,
-0.10825147479772568,
0.34510233998298645,
-0.3410135805606842,
-0.04501378536224365,
0.021711649373173714,
0.25298717617988586,
-0.4000001549720764,
0.5350723266601562,
-0.025979826226830482,
0.13973210752010345,
0.5267319679260254,
-0.14861565828323364,
-0.2864927351474762,
0.27903035283088684,
0.6880051493644714,
0.8701257109642029,
-0.08528533577919006,
-0.028949903324246407,
0.2939867079257965,
-0.7317180037498474,
0.18281668424606323,
0.10774543136358261,
-0.1597171574831009,
0.06385725736618042,
0.8436998724937439,
0.40105608105659485,
-0.20131734013557434,
-0.5345687866210938,
0.4816918671131134,
-0.0875888392329216,
0.07496994733810425,
-0.2465956062078476,
-0.05467821657657623,
0.031031819060444832,
0.17403516173362732,
0.3394019603729248,
0.18680024147033691,
0.10090998560190201,
-0.13998012244701385,
0.030703846365213394,
0.15262220799922943,
-0.7438722848892212,
-0.47493603825569153,
0.40952208638191223,
0.47235172986984253,
-0.8290000557899475,
0.6977996826171875,
-0.025437822565436363,
-0.5074085593223572,
0.6856576204299927,
0.2629742920398712,
1.131775975227356,
-0.3013157844543457,
-0.07513439655303955,
0.2297615110874176,
0.2495766431093216,
-0.12361806631088257,
-0.021135304123163223,
-0.0483991876244545,
-0.2349199503660202,
-0.1720592975616455,
-0.7905490398406982,
-0.43077412247657776,
-0.08385971188545227,
-0.6042966246604919,
0.4029276967048645,
-0.6575882434844971,
-0.11342402547597885,
-0.10466141253709793,
0.07060728222131729,
-0.23960940539836884,
0.28078141808509827,
-0.13280661404132843,
0.8782718181610107,
-0.41958361864089966,
0.6966864466667175,
0.8611665964126587,
-0.07539859414100647,
-0.678789496421814,
0.2746777832508087,
0.15325652062892914,
-0.08443303406238556,
0.4799079895019531,
0.4051980674266815,
-0.38177722692489624,
-0.3168991208076477,
-0.09818622469902039,
-0.3313089609146118,
1.3286176919937134,
0.315618097782135,
-0.9338799118995667,
-0.17765003442764282,
0.239179328083992,
1.0679551362991333,
-0.27586522698402405,
0.4416595995426178,
0.6111490726470947,
0.3337310552597046,
-0.42625898122787476,
-0.995021641254425,
0.031376272439956665,
-0.19604633748531342,
0.13732174038887024,
0.3640538454055786,
-0.7582191228866577,
0.5790919065475464,
-0.29432445764541626,
0.17799769341945648,
0.3881523311138153,
0.5705647468566895,
0.04967805743217468,
0.5204711556434631,
0.40635544061660767,
0.4491157531738281,
0.7046884298324585,
-0.04472679644823074,
1.1742498874664307,
-0.24851509928703308,
0.3361668884754181,
1.143553614616394,
-0.2358650416135788,
0.8637582659721375,
0.5607240200042725,
-0.362548291683197,
0.7492573857307434,
0.5141707062721252,
0.16646787524223328,
0.1646447777748108,
0.5231924057006836,
-0.35485339164733887,
0.05443459749221802,
-0.06984710693359375,
0.005728323012590408,
0.017401892691850662,
0.006106119137257338,
-0.5800235271453857,
-0.02001296356320381,
-0.2568342387676239,
0.2422443926334381,
0.6201293468475342,
-0.22577886283397675,
0.7524896264076233,
0.3760571777820587,
-0.7642417550086975,
0.12743866443634033,
0.39467909932136536,
0.4858298599720001,
-0.46036866307258606,
-0.025416171178221703,
-0.3548222780227661,
0.5460718870162964,
-0.23380669951438904,
-0.8122394680976868,
0.4603169858455658,
0.2525821328163147,
-0.5850124955177307,
-0.20091968774795532,
0.4787684679031372,
-0.21599391102790833,
-0.43550458550453186,
0.2971875071525574,
0.2272629737854004,
0.032568518072366714,
-0.19478493928909302,
-0.6513668894767761,
0.13141880929470062,
-0.07032071799039841,
-0.3895856440067291,
0.2385832965373993,
0.448469877243042,
-0.13744765520095825,
0.6361480355262756,
0.46968281269073486,
0.21695952117443085,
-0.18679790198802948,
0.21270406246185303,
0.5077911615371704,
-0.6198458671569824,
-0.36614760756492615,
-1.2360877990722656,
0.2646028697490692,
-0.01966203562915325,
-0.4759477972984314,
0.9120398759841919,
0.622801661491394,
0.5364012718200684,
0.09948346018791199,
0.9305761456489563,
0.15084868669509888,
0.7702188491821289,
-0.3139822781085968,
0.7968040704727173,
-0.698152482509613,
0.584952712059021,
-0.6945509314537048,
-1.2319904565811157,
-0.4824748933315277,
0.42051416635513306,
-0.639861524105072,
-0.0019031732808798552,
0.7672812938690186,
0.7651469111442566,
0.29524925351142883,
-0.1876392811536789,
0.08887986093759537,
-0.0347302183508873,
0.4005855619907379,
0.6057528853416443,
0.7489094734191895,
-0.30845674872398376,
0.3904632329940796,
-0.24844487011432648,
-0.2062303125858307,
-0.017107397317886353,
-1.000420093536377,
-0.8798508048057556,
-0.5506061911582947,
-0.1313658207654953,
-0.4213535189628601,
0.09552902728319168,
0.9577167630195618,
0.3859718143939972,
-0.32370078563690186,
-0.40399274230003357,
-0.129079207777977,
0.20807647705078125,
-0.014553438872098923,
-0.19105741381645203,
0.46618542075157166,
0.026840612292289734,
-0.7586789131164551,
0.09550096094608307,
0.4042600393295288,
-0.09925355017185211,
-0.5813724994659424,
-0.278957724571228,
0.09829076379537582,
0.14624309539794922,
0.41516202688217163,
-0.05728769302368164,
-0.740229606628418,
-0.3482576012611389,
0.0954071655869484,
-0.36733120679855347,
0.12013296037912369,
0.7699806690216064,
-0.6674693822860718,
0.7916486263275146,
0.5880406498908997,
0.4944814443588257,
0.11104392260313034,
0.3273455798625946,
0.7135645151138306,
-0.5776262283325195,
-0.02790534868836403,
0.24370332062244415,
0.016729386523365974,
0.7733259797096252,
-0.41517889499664307,
0.5384535193443298,
0.5151351094245911,
-0.652614951133728,
-0.7882493734359741,
-0.003200845792889595,
-0.5949263572692871,
-0.08273924142122269,
1.2719008922576904,
-0.4559376537799835,
-0.23731429874897003,
0.1516849398612976,
-0.46799227595329285,
0.1822204440832138,
-0.32110705971717834,
1.050523042678833,
0.8699715733528137,
-0.31324830651283264,
0.09115531295537949,
-0.25174883008003235,
0.6177926659584045,
0.526752769947052,
-1.0921598672866821,
0.13888141512870789,
0.688322126865387,
0.382699579000473,
0.20430921018123627,
0.589819610118866,
-0.1471569687128067,
0.23704904317855835,
-0.29959848523139954,
0.3304060995578766,
-0.028446344658732414,
-0.3002832531929016,
-0.5925461649894714,
-0.14326445758342743,
0.3478994071483612,
0.32890501618385315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07103v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07103v1
|
Graph Chain-of-Thought: Augmenting Large Language Models by Reasoning on Graphs
| 2024-04-10T15:41:53 | 2024-04-10T15:41:53 |
Bowen Jin, Chulin Xie, Jiawei Zhang, Kashob Kumar Roy, Yu Zhang, Suhang Wang, Yu Meng, Jiawei Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs), while exhibiting exceptional performance,
suffer from hallucinations, especially on knowledge-intensive tasks. Existing
works propose to augment LLMs with individual text units retrieved from
external knowledge corpora to alleviate the issue. However, in many domains,
texts are interconnected (e.g., academic papers in a bibliographic graph are
linked by citations and co-authorships) which form a (text-attributed) graph.
The knowledge in such graphs is encoded not only in single texts/nodes but also
in their associated connections. To facilitate the research of augmenting LLMs
with graphs, we manually construct a Graph Reasoning Benchmark dataset called
GRBench, containing 1,740 questions that can be answered with the knowledge
from 10 domain graphs. Then, we propose a simple and effective framework called
Graph Chain-of-thought (Graph-CoT) to augment LLMs with graphs by encouraging
LLMs to reason on the graph iteratively. Each Graph-CoT iteration consists of
three sub-steps: LLM reasoning, LLM-graph interaction, and graph execution. We
conduct systematic experiments with three LLM backbones on GRBench, where
Graph-CoT outperforms the baselines consistently. The code is available at
https://github.com/PeterGriffinJin/Graph-CoT.
|
[
-0.6838122010231018,
-1.0382355451583862,
0.9999361038208008,
-0.09160246700048447,
-0.3093585968017578,
0.5629132390022278,
-0.3064694106578827,
-0.5219125747680664,
0.2288062572479248,
0.7458593845367432,
-0.4448227286338806,
-0.6651177406311035,
-0.491839200258255,
-0.03598295524716377,
-0.5530982613563538,
0.8745344877243042,
-0.28223204612731934,
-0.1871410608291626,
-0.23042526841163635,
-0.0707913413643837,
-0.22720561921596527,
-0.6787751913070679,
-0.5358357429504395,
-0.6146695017814636,
0.7319921851158142,
0.12175668776035309,
0.6423999071121216,
0.4805961847305298,
0.39049220085144043,
0.2093326449394226,
-0.0576719269156456,
0.7468725442886353,
-0.8123894333839417,
0.022176669910550117,
-0.513219952583313,
-0.1270936131477356,
-0.6196237802505493,
-0.21390797197818756,
0.5470566153526306,
0.9798862338066101,
0.14288201928138733,
-0.05915967747569084,
0.016055509448051453,
0.7411999106407166,
-0.498613178730011,
0.17697586119174957,
-0.8161771893501282,
-0.28191113471984863,
-0.038370851427316666,
-0.257564902305603,
-0.6250194311141968,
-0.31141334772109985,
-0.12780465185642242,
-0.4576995372772217,
-0.13990971446037292,
0.489348441362381,
0.6687902808189392,
0.003799982601776719,
-0.3729342222213745,
-0.30598852038383484,
-0.6189486980438232,
0.2223198413848877,
-0.4733017683029175,
0.4405958354473114,
0.3183770775794983,
0.1107638031244278,
-0.5368760824203491,
-0.91086345911026,
-0.6055279970169067,
-0.034733161330223083,
-0.144487664103508,
-0.08481340110301971,
-0.18960373103618622,
0.2611420154571533,
0.4524538218975067,
0.42822664976119995,
-0.4860922396183014,
-0.012777474708855152,
-0.1573977768421173,
-0.011434553191065788,
0.4783814549446106,
0.14486698806285858,
0.3078024983406067,
0.09956233203411102,
-0.21459096670150757,
-0.08183325082063675,
-0.7598282694816589,
-0.3274901211261749,
0.4984995424747467,
0.34006479382514954,
0.22480304539203644,
0.6592888236045837,
-0.22022701799869537,
0.9566011428833008,
-0.07720118761062622,
0.12702789902687073,
0.27298638224601746,
-0.16515320539474487,
-0.13665220141410828,
0.14282894134521484,
0.7296298742294312,
0.21804894506931305,
0.5234724283218384,
-0.4935415983200073,
-0.22802916169166565,
0.3395569324493408,
0.24851854145526886,
-0.6796968579292297,
-0.3927006125450134,
0.17544090747833252,
0.021851778030395508,
-0.20496292412281036,
-0.07302182912826538,
-0.5169097781181335,
-0.4185177981853485,
-0.3619215190410614,
0.3120422065258026,
-0.5502832531929016,
-0.25945088267326355,
0.26711589097976685,
-0.1705189049243927,
-0.30269116163253784,
0.2786868214607239,
-0.5912619233131409,
0.6546135544776917,
0.7087447643280029,
0.7280046939849854,
-0.20650535821914673,
-0.4438116252422333,
-0.4078430235385895,
0.3882920742034912,
-0.5407926440238953,
0.8462528586387634,
-0.7590797543525696,
-0.22506114840507507,
-0.23193058371543884,
0.09119893610477448,
-0.2024061530828476,
-0.3609939217567444,
0.24494139850139618,
-0.6287670135498047,
-0.08700145781040192,
-0.3871336579322815,
-0.8613072037696838,
-0.18278223276138306,
0.42762571573257446,
-0.6878826022148132,
1.1263909339904785,
0.24055209755897522,
-0.8982303142547607,
-0.05245395377278328,
-0.3747064471244812,
-0.5698866248130798,
0.04333868995308876,
-0.4030308127403259,
0.082159124314785,
-0.04633230343461037,
0.36632055044174194,
0.26372912526130676,
-0.5114232301712036,
0.30769452452659607,
-0.5403890609741211,
-0.4975651204586029,
0.21243315935134888,
-0.029134029522538185,
0.6528075337409973,
0.059713128954172134,
-0.2936898469924927,
0.10588802397251129,
-0.6738542318344116,
0.2798950672149658,
0.038278769701719284,
-0.03928498923778534,
-0.2810036838054657,
-0.16137458384037018,
-0.46037113666534424,
0.15076138079166412,
-0.06139723211526871,
-0.13198401033878326,
0.308206170797348,
-0.3626750409603119,
0.4783759117126465,
0.8865954279899597,
0.12569455802440643,
0.204128235578537,
-0.2107749879360199,
0.39146730303764343,
-0.20927956700325012,
-0.15077154338359833,
0.01794552616775036,
-0.3114161789417267,
-0.767498791217804,
-0.1848674714565277,
0.21424396336078644,
0.2254583239555359,
-0.9589974284172058,
0.40059158205986023,
-0.32304537296295166,
-0.5024117231369019,
-0.1665315181016922,
0.17242802679538727,
0.26424267888069153,
0.5937379598617554,
0.37554991245269775,
-0.2979090213775635,
-0.5502634048461914,
-0.4913214147090912,
-0.2129976898431778,
-0.3361419141292572,
0.2900163531303406,
0.35622790455818176,
0.5848175883293152,
-0.35668128728866577,
0.7291721105575562,
-0.7947365045547485,
-0.00005733608122682199,
-0.2797410786151886,
-0.010835974477231503,
0.2463342696428299,
0.1901494860649109,
0.24473245441913605,
-0.30700838565826416,
-0.2547079622745514,
0.2423117607831955,
-0.8820939660072327,
-0.0770573541522026,
0.15015195310115814,
-0.39153197407722473,
0.03491181135177612,
0.6644797325134277,
-0.5995664000511169,
0.30400198698043823,
0.5694175362586975,
-0.16418306529521942,
0.7212718725204468,
-0.2134040743112564,
0.04306161031126976,
-0.8027220368385315,
0.05136959254741669,
-0.2229699045419693,
-0.3595297932624817,
-0.43924960494041443,
0.1796514093875885,
-0.2760133445262909,
-0.07254038006067276,
0.08093226701021194,
0.563316822052002,
-0.49703121185302734,
-0.3015801012516022,
-0.42456522583961487,
0.7519513964653015,
0.21152947843074799,
0.5949674844741821,
-0.19336262345314026,
0.6945241093635559,
0.6052159070968628,
-0.5491278171539307,
0.42733463644981384,
0.09055174142122269,
-0.6134257316589355,
0.2281230241060257,
-0.4519215524196625,
0.569948136806488,
-0.04701532423496246,
0.47744807600975037,
-0.9420760273933411,
-0.1853119283914566,
0.15506625175476074,
-0.12528690695762634,
0.014035374857485294,
-0.02535315975546837,
-0.847367525100708,
-0.6951854825019836,
0.06679891794919968,
0.35948988795280457,
0.299251526594162,
-0.820098876953125,
0.6689434051513672,
0.5315083861351013,
0.045136794447898865,
-0.45987990498542786,
-0.4929770827293396,
0.22621645033359528,
0.06592527776956558,
-0.596765398979187,
0.393253356218338,
-0.010560214519500732,
-0.3617233335971832,
0.29224544763565063,
-0.1652158796787262,
0.16460572183132172,
-0.05492468923330307,
0.0902678444981575,
0.2769060432910919,
0.0947122648358345,
0.4997100234031677,
0.0531897209584713,
-0.06885577738285065,
0.06146978959441185,
-0.7326289415359497,
0.9281282424926758,
-0.4979972243309021,
-0.5528442859649658,
0.0791211649775505,
0.046493589878082275,
0.49369460344314575,
-0.07332947105169296,
0.5304056406021118,
0.25653836131095886,
-0.3647901117801666,
-0.44765764474868774,
-0.4897508919239044,
-0.16022391617298126,
-0.43349340558052063,
0.19135090708732605,
-0.6069929599761963,
-1.032921314239502,
0.6076796650886536,
-0.6168966889381409,
-0.35100582242012024,
0.22856108844280243,
0.5371153354644775,
-0.07602084428071976,
1.0644476413726807,
0.2954026460647583,
-0.09705255180597305,
0.1709405928850174,
-0.4453718066215515,
0.5652320981025696,
-0.936951220035553,
-0.060835495591163635,
-0.20129375159740448,
-0.1017870157957077,
-0.4874266982078552,
-0.6792722344398499,
0.2647395730018616,
0.3593890368938446,
-0.438614159822464,
0.4410698413848877,
-0.5245034098625183,
0.5939236283302307,
0.13457374274730682,
0.34442999958992004,
0.4967483580112457,
0.10557159036397934,
-0.6267871856689453,
0.5276824831962585,
-0.8496922254562378,
-0.5495747327804565,
0.8348805904388428,
0.02655050717294216,
0.9882920980453491,
-0.227482870221138,
0.5159100890159607,
0.19297246634960175,
0.22012066841125488,
-0.6293160319328308,
0.8241795301437378,
-0.061196859925985336,
-0.4523969292640686,
-0.19144253432750702,
-0.47461697459220886,
-0.7270563244819641,
0.3512657880783081,
-0.047969721257686615,
-1.1489828824996948,
-0.05010329186916351,
0.18355858325958252,
0.10626820474863052,
0.6469415426254272,
-0.33564749360084534,
0.6091337203979492,
-0.3176456093788147,
-0.4857911467552185,
-0.4608832001686096,
-0.39582645893096924,
0.38676851987838745,
-0.07385613024234772,
0.3619835078716278,
0.005678113084286451,
0.37766340374946594,
0.520325243473053,
-0.6917760372161865,
0.736100971698761,
0.1703704297542572,
-0.2750461995601654,
0.6823275089263916,
0.1067163273692131,
1.0822209119796753,
-0.19692197442054749,
-0.11852093786001205,
0.05382693558931351,
-0.3290608823299408,
-0.1799413412809372,
-0.7579394578933716,
0.912996232509613,
-0.5929194092750549,
-0.7900180220603943,
-0.12077906727790833,
-0.795842170715332,
-0.5110697150230408,
0.2963354289531708,
-0.07927148789167404,
0.5777336359024048,
0.013742415234446526,
-0.04373501241207123,
0.42612719535827637,
0.037168100476264954,
0.02605527825653553,
-0.10902628302574158,
-0.8900960683822632,
-0.6490288376808167,
0.8815049529075623,
0.16593925654888153,
0.5670726895332336,
0.0901942029595375,
0.11066363006830215,
-0.2549501359462738,
-0.41042035818099976,
-0.3745812773704529,
0.31299707293510437,
-1.1713230609893799,
0.06347371637821198,
-0.9106078147888184,
-0.3083265423774719,
-0.2355884611606598,
-0.12173730880022049,
-0.16438058018684387,
-0.44927483797073364,
0.07438625395298004,
-0.4694102108478546,
0.6372405886650085,
0.606924831867218,
0.12176680564880371,
0.2097882181406021,
-0.37405088543891907,
0.2875082492828369,
0.22748017311096191,
0.4769493341445923,
0.33355289697647095,
-0.15472747385501862,
-0.29357609152793884,
0.03340721130371094,
-0.13102398812770844,
-0.5820477604866028,
0.07215379178524017,
-0.33332332968711853,
0.5006473660469055,
0.31059983372688293,
0.053990162909030914,
1.0531973838806152,
-0.4358234703540802,
0.39842256903648376,
0.3647749125957489,
-1.0964089632034302,
0.36558037996292114,
-0.33126822113990784,
0.014685270376503468,
0.4966225028038025,
0.29419180750846863,
-0.3385359048843384,
-0.7126277685165405,
-0.6304935812950134,
-0.8179569840431213,
0.38098233938217163,
0.2994561791419983,
-0.19530372321605682,
-0.18866421282291412,
0.3363268971443176,
0.039241377264261246,
0.2770760655403137,
-0.5936369895935059,
-0.05696152523159981,
-0.10239463299512863,
-0.10202202945947647,
-0.002171191154047847,
0.1030208170413971,
-0.3207959830760956,
-0.5097400546073914,
0.7184751629829407,
-0.5137682557106018,
0.0816422551870346,
0.09884396195411682,
-0.19306716322898865,
-0.12666137516498566,
0.05836230516433716,
0.19453690946102142,
1.0691261291503906,
-0.11366048455238342,
0.7246037721633911,
0.37401282787323,
-0.07855450361967087,
0.04376163333654404,
-0.1357545703649521,
0.0877671167254448,
-0.16781707108020782,
0.46806013584136963,
1.133155107498169,
0.024906177073717117,
-0.7161523103713989,
0.10109442472457886,
0.2028394192457199,
-0.19595147669315338,
-0.047799527645111084,
0.14434069395065308,
0.42882239818573,
0.34139421582221985,
0.14909479022026062,
-0.102034792304039,
-0.14227494597434998,
-0.8041571378707886,
0.142312690615654,
0.3263775110244751,
-0.47319725155830383,
-0.13936568796634674,
0.4478195309638977,
-0.03180409595370293,
-0.19635120034217834,
0.6637029051780701,
-0.30170875787734985,
-0.7615358829498291,
0.45216089487075806,
0.8075628280639648,
0.6158541440963745,
0.36574551463127136,
0.06028052419424057,
0.29890361428260803,
0.3442005217075348,
-0.15408548712730408,
0.3167104423046112,
0.13565824925899506,
-0.9096254110336304,
-0.553463339805603,
-0.2863248288631439,
-0.48359552025794983,
-0.0004912347649224102,
-0.2828556299209595,
0.325761079788208,
-0.5438619256019592,
-0.3411218822002411,
-0.11179187148809433,
-0.018426457419991493,
-0.48168909549713135,
0.16828855872154236,
0.04846306890249252,
0.7982408404350281,
-0.6178023219108582,
0.9731816649436951,
0.4307299852371216,
-0.35810211300849915,
-0.8022339344024658,
-0.03585035353899002,
-0.30515360832214355,
-0.9013988375663757,
0.5796365737915039,
0.17498473823070526,
-0.6054805517196655,
0.3027006983757019,
-0.565097987651825,
-0.7632856369018555,
1.0021804571151733,
0.49781671166419983,
-0.8310726284980774,
-0.020526694133877754,
0.09793300926685333,
0.5913329124450684,
-0.678852379322052,
0.11143562197685242,
0.5804511308670044,
0.5021818280220032,
0.241437628865242,
-0.5574682950973511,
0.39180392026901245,
-0.14844076335430145,
-0.1297454535961151,
0.29690414667129517,
-0.63518226146698,
0.8116679191589355,
-0.40849363803863525,
-0.2629443109035492,
-0.26976633071899414,
0.3680964410305023,
0.5368226170539856,
0.17909766733646393,
0.6666368246078491,
0.7695372700691223,
1.3478623628616333,
-0.009586070664227009,
1.1980081796646118,
-0.6138994693756104,
0.3741457164287567,
1.4249975681304932,
-0.6486549973487854,
0.4891035258769989,
0.512667715549469,
-0.17543068528175354,
0.9821847677230835,
0.5936028361320496,
0.05145886912941933,
0.3587360382080078,
0.4908432066440582,
-0.10255629569292068,
-0.513454794883728,
-0.2606287896633148,
-0.35639774799346924,
0.03869881108403206,
0.3878045678138733,
-0.34011998772621155,
-0.04777268320322037,
-0.14595161378383636,
0.07416823506355286,
0.09681344777345657,
-0.14660081267356873,
0.6385393142700195,
0.26306062936782837,
-0.6973137259483337,
0.6776397824287415,
-0.3484114706516266,
-0.07332311570644379,
-0.44828373193740845,
-0.00041768024675548077,
0.11203653365373611,
0.22831685841083527,
-0.18355269730091095,
-0.9152308702468872,
-0.012677475810050964,
0.00042991017107851803,
-0.11760661005973816,
-0.00503294263035059,
0.9786421656608582,
-0.2755255401134491,
-0.6132714748382568,
0.862132728099823,
0.6340064406394958,
0.19605551660060883,
-0.03024730645120144,
-0.41961660981178284,
0.29944631457328796,
-0.22546100616455078,
-0.11838343739509583,
0.20308832824230194,
0.6099681258201599,
-0.267636239528656,
0.8311421871185303,
0.7114182114601135,
0.10545793920755386,
-0.25064709782600403,
0.5724070072174072,
1.5231503248214722,
-0.6450204253196716,
-0.3581816852092743,
-1.0362658500671387,
0.0884069874882698,
-0.4168280065059662,
0.03255050629377365,
0.6159562468528748,
0.6531878113746643,
0.843278706073761,
0.2179701179265976,
0.9304415583610535,
0.008957811631262302,
0.03353911638259888,
-0.5703203678131104,
0.5016208291053772,
-0.3586592674255371,
0.27104490995407104,
-0.5707793235778809,
-0.8763346076011658,
-0.10101725161075592,
0.5305576324462891,
-0.5134547352790833,
-0.05010215565562248,
1.2004823684692383,
0.8043833374977112,
0.18900494277477264,
0.2751334011554718,
0.15029820799827576,
0.27892133593559265,
0.3372553884983063,
0.5210198163986206,
0.959341824054718,
-0.27336573600769043,
0.48468732833862305,
-0.04355964437127113,
-0.06748438626527786,
0.037170037627220154,
-0.899417519569397,
-1.1897032260894775,
-0.3941018283367157,
-0.2610377073287964,
-0.630277693271637,
0.18071484565734863,
0.9195602536201477,
0.47604477405548096,
-0.5567309260368347,
-0.3603551685810089,
-0.6017670631408691,
0.5272690653800964,
-0.4134129583835602,
-0.19767335057258606,
0.4783605933189392,
-0.42912745475769043,
-0.45183128118515015,
0.4014401137828827,
0.44854113459587097,
-0.12334538996219635,
-0.2765776216983795,
-0.19000014662742615,
-0.36794736981391907,
0.151828333735466,
0.7672976851463318,
-0.26004257798194885,
-0.6621531248092651,
-0.4880934953689575,
-0.13275927305221558,
-0.00021860870765522122,
0.10598710924386978,
0.9793718457221985,
-0.8385748863220215,
0.5658038258552551,
0.5019334554672241,
0.5660086274147034,
0.9525318741798401,
0.11213180422782898,
0.5505795478820801,
-0.44440600275993347,
-0.01886785589158535,
0.029716290533542633,
0.5933092832565308,
0.2584899663925171,
-0.2520282566547394,
0.9414622783660889,
0.4042646586894989,
-0.3553231656551361,
-1.0110576152801514,
0.3057321012020111,
-0.9035188555717468,
-0.5455766916275024,
1.064960241317749,
-0.1344134360551834,
-0.32138362526893616,
-0.07777846604585648,
-0.17282681167125702,
0.3375397324562073,
-0.06752056628465652,
0.7323651313781738,
0.9127280712127686,
-0.32242777943611145,
-0.13406316936016083,
-0.14263783395290375,
0.21500447392463684,
-0.06674899905920029,
-1.0816278457641602,
0.43399518728256226,
0.40370842814445496,
0.021500132977962494,
0.12857183814048767,
0.8113380670547485,
-0.061721328645944595,
-0.20216313004493713,
0.21131372451782227,
-0.01432645320892334,
-0.11533934623003006,
-0.4992528259754181,
0.3490757644176483,
0.28182223439216614,
0.05357576906681061,
0.39056092500686646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07084v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07084v1
|
Dynamic Generation of Personalities with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-10T15:17:17 | 2024-04-10T15:17:17 |
Jianzhi Liu, Hexiang Gu, Tianyu Zheng, Liuyu Xiang, Huijia Wu, Jie Fu, Zhaofeng He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the realm of mimicking human deliberation, large language models (LLMs)
show promising performance, thereby amplifying the importance of this research
area. Deliberation is influenced by both logic and personality. However,
previous studies predominantly focused on the logic of LLMs, neglecting the
exploration of personality aspects. In this work, we introduce Dynamic
Personality Generation (DPG), a dynamic personality generation method based on
Hypernetworks. Initially, we embed the Big Five personality theory into GPT-4
to form a personality assessment machine, enabling it to evaluate characters'
personality traits from dialogues automatically. We propose a new metric to
assess personality generation capability based on this evaluation method. Then,
we use this personality assessment machine to evaluate dialogues in script
data, resulting in a personality-dialogue dataset. Finally, we fine-tune DPG on
the personality-dialogue dataset. Experiments prove that DPG's personality
generation capability is stronger after fine-tuning on this dataset than
traditional fine-tuning methods, surpassing prompt-based GPT-4.
|
[
-0.60588139295578,
-0.7481162548065186,
0.8037499785423279,
0.21774320304393768,
-0.08406331390142441,
0.49860066175460815,
-0.3627387285232544,
-0.2627318203449249,
0.08154347538948059,
0.5556275248527527,
-0.9935402274131775,
-0.39709898829460144,
-0.3416006863117218,
0.3548596203327179,
0.006745252292603254,
0.9537743926048279,
0.31622135639190674,
-0.19980840384960175,
0.09750399738550186,
0.14688527584075928,
-0.618972897529602,
-0.41315069794654846,
-0.5991932153701782,
-0.41398677229881287,
0.925494372844696,
0.21083295345306396,
0.7404804229736328,
0.5573245286941528,
0.21646924316883087,
0.4862864017486572,
0.00942898914217949,
0.3485441207885742,
-0.6456400156021118,
0.45550358295440674,
-0.3041945695877075,
-0.3606911301612854,
-0.5602672696113586,
0.2139768898487091,
0.8032234907150269,
0.3732977509498596,
-0.04191029071807861,
0.15327534079551697,
-0.16825221478939056,
0.6731417775154114,
-0.2771773934364319,
0.40013808012008667,
-1.03231680393219,
0.2591251730918884,
-0.29226353764533997,
-0.24556201696395874,
-0.24996918439865112,
-0.5918548703193665,
0.2603433430194855,
-0.0662439838051796,
-0.01702267676591873,
0.014099282212555408,
0.4632420837879181,
0.29217326641082764,
-0.5543266534805298,
-0.08593975007534027,
-1.0021412372589111,
0.9621176719665527,
-0.7071719169616699,
-0.11890636384487152,
0.10758145153522491,
0.47452864050865173,
-0.4087808132171631,
-0.6088436245918274,
-1.0155539512634277,
-0.3085937798023224,
0.09913118183612823,
-0.02063555084168911,
0.041850097477436066,
0.03149585798382759,
0.5534022450447083,
0.36890971660614014,
-0.32116931676864624,
0.1648291051387787,
0.02840142697095871,
0.18491241335868835,
0.8334479928016663,
0.5418022871017456,
0.03773248940706253,
-0.1815095841884613,
0.13403970003128052,
-0.09705237299203873,
-0.5570945143699646,
-0.5704046487808228,
0.8654312491416931,
0.1663323938846588,
0.24576929211616516,
0.11570087820291519,
-0.23578037321567535,
0.5904977917671204,
0.7428643703460693,
-0.31057220697402954,
0.4571894705295563,
-0.17268379032611847,
-0.1371583342552185,
-0.07711820304393768,
0.8169365525245667,
0.21272563934326172,
0.5559982061386108,
0.16360776126384735,
-0.004188449587672949,
-0.18057945370674133,
0.48575955629348755,
-1.0523433685302734,
-0.313981831073761,
0.544291615486145,
-0.3331912159919739,
-0.8448188304901123,
-0.015489348210394382,
-0.8537482023239136,
-0.7039410471916199,
-0.33288583159446716,
-0.15678486227989197,
-0.3396066725254059,
-0.40756508708000183,
-0.12355926632881165,
0.06016452983021736,
0.22931315004825592,
0.41436704993247986,
-1.1075944900512695,
-0.07480167597532272,
0.5835071802139282,
0.4198908805847168,
-0.3813990354537964,
-0.3524024188518524,
-0.48468858003616333,
0.09217264503240585,
-0.23443353176116943,
0.47772347927093506,
-0.5170952677726746,
-0.24442608654499054,
0.09300429373979568,
-0.22811122238636017,
0.12369874864816666,
-0.6795000433921814,
0.23399662971496582,
-0.3152894675731659,
0.21422207355499268,
-0.3973368704319,
-0.3451445698738098,
-0.031312230974435806,
0.514618456363678,
-0.4816669225692749,
0.6616460084915161,
0.30871376395225525,
-0.6433841586112976,
0.5595861673355103,
-0.5844599604606628,
-0.2307492196559906,
0.49827462434768677,
-0.5449913740158081,
-0.4715227782726288,
0.02685151807963848,
-0.12004413455724716,
0.6981387138366699,
-0.25830522179603577,
0.5882230997085571,
-0.5266916155815125,
-0.09092734009027481,
0.7502104043960571,
-0.45812082290649414,
0.3000483512878418,
0.09686208516359329,
-0.6081739068031311,
0.10010061413049698,
-0.9269790053367615,
0.35197627544403076,
0.10079289972782135,
-0.4800262451171875,
0.2600797712802887,
0.4149107336997986,
-0.20593440532684326,
0.4396323263645172,
0.3112580478191376,
-0.746883749961853,
0.3608803153038025,
-0.3692382276058197,
0.4746202230453491,
0.7177439332008362,
0.17237770557403564,
-0.05953317508101463,
-0.3734292984008789,
0.32197868824005127,
0.1325104534626007,
-0.013120490126311779,
-0.04808935150504112,
-0.23514993488788605,
-0.5590013265609741,
-0.3342364430427551,
-0.03346319496631622,
0.39546504616737366,
-0.5900028347969055,
0.938640832901001,
-0.15869610011577606,
-0.6835439801216125,
-0.07494917511940002,
0.11972405761480331,
0.2685224115848541,
0.25066694617271423,
0.03778048977255821,
-0.16616250574588776,
-0.47801584005355835,
-0.6627194285392761,
-0.09341008216142654,
-0.3575149178504944,
0.08828748762607574,
0.5192450881004333,
0.2745085656642914,
-0.4347136616706848,
0.7607704997062683,
-0.6151614189147949,
0.30742090940475464,
-0.5796460509300232,
0.21059100329875946,
0.25424349308013916,
0.34874629974365234,
0.6642804741859436,
-0.6538941264152527,
-0.6206398606300354,
-0.17307205498218536,
-0.6502679586410522,
-0.1561005860567093,
-0.01660643145442009,
-0.20414108037948608,
0.021327350288629532,
0.28035107254981995,
-0.5524027943611145,
0.15774498879909515,
0.44564539194107056,
-0.19859559834003448,
0.9020757675170898,
-0.08959616720676422,
-0.040371134877204895,
-1.0001345872879028,
0.11160381883382797,
-0.19075985252857208,
-0.18711932003498077,
-0.5215763449668884,
-0.07165873795747757,
-0.420314222574234,
-0.299160361289978,
-0.29075726866722107,
0.5248032212257385,
-0.312489777803421,
0.0696546882390976,
-0.3523007333278656,
0.16917282342910767,
-0.29826846718788147,
0.5442860722541809,
-0.12010961771011353,
0.2955559492111206,
0.3792271912097931,
-0.3558872938156128,
0.8523935079574585,
0.3758523166179657,
-0.5617855787277222,
0.6537598371505737,
-0.5453372001647949,
0.46046045422554016,
-0.07606346905231476,
0.49624407291412354,
-0.8679389357566833,
-0.5036051273345947,
-0.15900996327400208,
0.014020564965903759,
0.31201621890068054,
-0.03134503588080406,
-0.5448986291885376,
-0.5517063736915588,
-0.32025986909866333,
-0.22865596413612366,
0.5068660378456116,
-0.4087335467338562,
0.3931736648082733,
0.25299811363220215,
-0.530156672000885,
-0.20563966035842896,
-0.37955141067504883,
0.21081584692001343,
-0.3676178455352783,
-0.6908985376358032,
0.3976196050643921,
-0.320596843957901,
-0.24022094905376434,
-0.5274796485900879,
0.2716476619243622,
0.314222514629364,
-0.041163019835948944,
0.08284951746463776,
0.09180643409490585,
-0.010509813204407692,
-0.05640213564038277,
0.09668181091547012,
0.03578723222017288,
0.04993530735373497,
-0.18920166790485382,
0.7712128162384033,
-0.21291743218898773,
-0.1583559215068817,
-0.4000396728515625,
0.3055003583431244,
0.8864609599113464,
-0.43311238288879395,
0.5324029922485352,
0.7793257832527161,
0.10044008493423462,
-0.4525337517261505,
-0.4993914067745209,
-0.1683993637561798,
-0.5719576478004456,
0.585163950920105,
-0.35414668917655945,
-0.8820175528526306,
0.5049886107444763,
-0.32903918623924255,
0.34985870122909546,
0.07869014889001846,
1.1972160339355469,
0.038895975798368454,
1.2946813106536865,
0.3156123161315918,
0.32366546988487244,
0.7550637125968933,
0.08920058608055115,
0.2589205205440521,
-0.6992251873016357,
-0.08948346227407455,
-0.1828743815422058,
-0.8443160653114319,
-1.007759690284729,
-0.00595697108656168,
0.3627341091632843,
-0.5143304467201233,
-0.5854474902153015,
-0.008449774235486984,
-0.479670912027359,
0.28898656368255615,
0.339238703250885,
-0.040378935635089874,
0.07277844846248627,
-0.11474048346281052,
-0.230060875415802,
-0.11689382046461105,
-0.25717025995254517,
-0.6320432424545288,
0.9743266105651855,
0.33461830019950867,
0.6736899018287659,
0.4090164005756378,
0.6723431348800659,
0.16461603343486786,
0.20644137263298035,
-0.7645167708396912,
0.8560476303100586,
-0.1911429464817047,
-0.49207422137260437,
-0.4280422329902649,
-0.644433319568634,
-0.8453139662742615,
0.04004237800836563,
-0.44339418411254883,
-0.9637761116027832,
0.05816119909286499,
0.2697308361530304,
-0.626448392868042,
0.10669739544391632,
-0.42963191866874695,
0.5538216829299927,
-0.2511996924877167,
-0.4645945429801941,
-0.27913275361061096,
-0.5989928841590881,
0.3991471230983734,
-0.37469738721847534,
-0.5934973359107971,
-0.2978639304637909,
0.5188159942626953,
0.4380910396575928,
-0.45097532868385315,
0.7644623517990112,
-0.42863893508911133,
-0.22874034941196442,
0.18556012213230133,
0.4029203951358795,
0.5517190098762512,
0.12770035862922668,
-0.3237004280090332,
-0.10030175000429153,
0.013229048810899258,
0.10724249482154846,
-0.9577512145042419,
1.0073131322860718,
-0.9323169589042664,
-0.7392789721488953,
-0.2001284807920456,
-0.5805326104164124,
-0.715932309627533,
0.1047186329960823,
-0.14491353929042816,
0.2966710329055786,
-0.3444077968597412,
0.2863188683986664,
0.6348127722740173,
-0.5238593220710754,
0.2867339253425598,
0.5071706771850586,
-0.3963730037212372,
-0.22089295089244843,
0.8624816536903381,
0.15552788972854614,
0.25183403491973877,
0.051762934774160385,
0.5106166005134583,
-0.146824911236763,
-0.32835498452186584,
-0.5190590023994446,
0.3309589624404907,
-0.2253931760787964,
0.1400856077671051,
-0.6179577708244324,
-0.196936696767807,
-0.2980504333972931,
0.09940050542354584,
-0.3494357466697693,
-0.07609174400568008,
0.09011879563331604,
-0.020915919914841652,
0.15256403386592865,
0.7787907719612122,
0.37672072649002075,
0.3446944057941437,
-0.6673743724822998,
-0.023999998345971107,
0.6123572587966919,
0.23029054701328278,
0.06114034727215767,
-0.17676888406276703,
-0.08125002682209015,
-0.15255847573280334,
-0.8765921592712402,
-0.8664745092391968,
0.4232950806617737,
0.10190995037555695,
0.4292077124118805,
0.601945161819458,
-0.2640931308269501,
0.2636513411998749,
-0.5029196739196777,
0.7859861850738525,
-0.09701425582170486,
-0.6680871248245239,
0.41553157567977905,
-0.8449298143386841,
0.4356801509857178,
0.5961712598800659,
0.1888154000043869,
-0.5746759176254272,
-0.2456265538930893,
-0.6778489947319031,
-0.44532015919685364,
0.5672679543495178,
0.1402207463979721,
0.26099175214767456,
-0.09410186856985092,
0.5083835124969482,
-0.023991497233510017,
0.6477976441383362,
-0.31481343507766724,
0.13356217741966248,
-0.1399937868118286,
-0.36477887630462646,
0.030805988237261772,
-0.05184706300497055,
-0.06828135997056961,
-0.32564330101013184,
0.3723357915878296,
-0.4692842662334442,
0.4704548716545105,
-0.1759539544582367,
0.6024038791656494,
-0.09603251516819,
0.15503087639808655,
0.4143798053264618,
0.6345201134681702,
-0.18202665448188782,
-0.02771836891770363,
-0.025796957314014435,
-0.4809824824333191,
0.12577663362026215,
-0.15998102724552155,
-0.06455683708190918,
-0.2309211939573288,
0.05224258452653885,
1.0346959829330444,
-0.1999247819185257,
-0.5114694833755493,
0.4320000112056732,
-0.07799724489450455,
-0.2636774480342865,
-0.5128456354141235,
0.6081271171569824,
0.07394463568925858,
0.2347654551267624,
0.0949387475848198,
-0.23316523432731628,
-0.3256799578666687,
-0.8929632902145386,
0.07790296524763107,
0.2691320478916168,
-0.28219467401504517,
-0.41430944204330444,
0.3833772540092468,
0.5901274085044861,
-0.35216522216796875,
0.9236370921134949,
-0.37785807251930237,
-0.4672393798828125,
0.41928160190582275,
0.4807862639427185,
1.1088457107543945,
-0.20731575787067413,
0.2938742935657501,
0.23861615359783173,
-0.1875961422920227,
0.14063987135887146,
0.4740639626979828,
-0.0057767173275351524,
-0.963083803653717,
-0.5865243673324585,
-0.8179751038551331,
-0.52299565076828,
0.5908501744270325,
-0.17077988386154175,
0.39270642399787903,
-0.7784472107887268,
-0.4005902111530304,
0.13866788148880005,
0.4054965674877167,
-0.643837034702301,
0.2128141075372696,
0.3417813181877136,
0.41878196597099304,
-0.4539732336997986,
0.7806148529052734,
0.5518589019775391,
0.020269308239221573,
-0.7342490553855896,
0.4164018929004669,
0.1855761557817459,
-0.485029399394989,
0.8456566333770752,
0.060871779918670654,
-0.09035377949476242,
0.21574844419956207,
-0.6445959210395813,
-0.6494812965393066,
0.9840051531791687,
0.3863641023635864,
-0.6382144093513489,
-0.11708316206932068,
0.03383835777640343,
0.6914966702461243,
-0.5388776659965515,
0.2662038207054138,
0.563278317451477,
0.747443675994873,
0.1577872931957245,
-0.7746989130973816,
0.06781310588121414,
-0.2695675194263458,
0.042459532618522644,
0.12442165613174438,
-1.0296533107757568,
0.8206313848495483,
-0.15251880884170532,
0.030176179483532906,
0.08420690149068832,
0.6828286647796631,
0.3975004553794861,
-0.35003364086151123,
0.6398056745529175,
0.1079460009932518,
0.8802609443664551,
-0.07481604069471359,
0.7922094464302063,
-0.524476945400238,
0.04306530952453613,
1.1342687606811523,
-0.8154560923576355,
0.5046488642692566,
0.20124831795692444,
-0.022593297064304352,
0.9581260085105896,
0.3146023154258728,
-0.24032346904277802,
0.19232337176799774,
0.7325588464736938,
-0.41613471508026123,
-0.3685622215270996,
0.18951654434204102,
0.14372728765010834,
0.9246931672096252,
0.24934116005897522,
-0.41336315870285034,
0.14972460269927979,
-0.13806037604808807,
0.23593007028102875,
-0.06288125365972519,
0.0774732232093811,
0.766559898853302,
-0.18703028559684753,
-1.0068135261535645,
0.38633573055267334,
0.23034048080444336,
0.4706844687461853,
-0.7147658467292786,
-0.06755663454532623,
-0.18549656867980957,
0.389192670583725,
-0.09856651723384857,
-0.9174564480781555,
0.22558090090751648,
0.1458394080400467,
-0.12139177322387695,
-0.32838720083236694,
0.6583781838417053,
-0.3628080189228058,
-0.22183427214622498,
-0.08307050913572311,
0.6788158416748047,
0.20692391693592072,
-0.03809936344623566,
-0.621362030506134,
0.028118018060922623,
0.1340211182832718,
-0.5577023029327393,
0.5045787692070007,
0.5935010313987732,
-0.04400823265314102,
0.6242163777351379,
0.6164140105247498,
0.175668403506279,
-0.2301529496908188,
0.20004571974277496,
0.7075632214546204,
-0.6627540588378906,
-0.4580833315849304,
-0.9403159618377686,
0.2687065303325653,
-0.29557088017463684,
-0.518695056438446,
0.6381305456161499,
0.23445020616054535,
0.506780743598938,
-0.057575881481170654,
1.0723334550857544,
-0.27887409925460815,
0.6029548048973083,
-0.1822064220905304,
0.7913188934326172,
-0.11799698323011398,
-0.1527806967496872,
-0.6006221771240234,
-1.035546898841858,
0.10323352366685867,
0.530312716960907,
-0.38883185386657715,
0.4992429316043854,
0.5283116698265076,
0.8037309050559998,
0.10455262660980225,
0.029672741889953613,
0.500361442565918,
0.5972269773483276,
0.6622722744941711,
0.3942128121852875,
0.9435324668884277,
0.18999822437763214,
0.1076996922492981,
0.23462721705436707,
-0.4527137577533722,
-0.1155373603105545,
-1.0144010782241821,
-1.0508983135223389,
-0.44722795486450195,
-0.3440861105918884,
-0.2836906909942627,
-0.26720085740089417,
0.9051953554153442,
0.6394335627555847,
-0.2299441397190094,
-0.11132484674453735,
-0.005251743830740452,
-0.2601940333843231,
-0.10606491565704346,
-0.25173747539520264,
-0.1228519156575203,
-0.14557598531246185,
-1.063416838645935,
0.4809424877166748,
0.3180277943611145,
-0.22893734276294708,
-1.1568818092346191,
0.046089768409729004,
0.07558149844408035,
0.4730013608932495,
0.7396041750907898,
0.09516869485378265,
-0.32330194115638733,
-0.5118164420127869,
-0.10884495824575424,
-0.022761011496186256,
-0.11525770276784897,
0.912013828754425,
-0.6368607878684998,
0.31236058473587036,
0.5666391849517822,
0.33643639087677,
0.4829254150390625,
0.059574615210294724,
0.801300585269928,
-0.7515074610710144,
-0.16918735206127167,
0.17487090826034546,
0.14057832956314087,
0.3401646018028259,
-0.46424639225006104,
0.031049305573105812,
0.36488521099090576,
-0.8796151876449585,
-0.5171098709106445,
0.7346318960189819,
-0.8932186961174011,
0.09553000330924988,
1.268371820449829,
-0.09443098306655884,
-0.06920798122882843,
-0.04047689214348793,
-0.44853830337524414,
0.12675431370735168,
-0.3753395676612854,
0.8830661773681641,
0.6948817372322083,
-0.455250084400177,
0.09238923341035843,
-0.3723633885383606,
0.5664590001106262,
0.30081939697265625,
-0.8628848791122437,
0.40107646584510803,
0.5884713530540466,
0.21362905204296112,
0.2138231247663498,
0.49785327911376953,
-0.18867936730384827,
-0.21238134801387787,
-0.14611245691776276,
0.052220240235328674,
-0.10899844765663147,
-0.34016966819763184,
0.1357952505350113,
0.23180924355983734,
0.028035666793584824,
0.3681255877017975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07066v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07066v2
|
Exploring Concept Depth: How Large Language Models Acquire Knowledge at Different Layers?
| 2024-04-10T14:56:40 | 2024-04-30T18:53:56 |
Mingyu Jin, Qinkai Yu, Jingyuan Huang, Qingcheng Zeng, Zhenting Wang, Wenyue Hua, Haiyan Zhao, Kai Mei, Yanda Meng, Kaize Ding, Fan Yang, Mengnan Du, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performances across a wide
range of tasks. However, the mechanisms by which these models encode tasks of
varying complexities remain poorly understood. In this paper, we explore the
hypothesis that LLMs process concepts of varying complexities in different
layers, introducing the idea of "Concept Depth" to suggest that more complex
concepts are typically acquired in deeper layers. Specifically, we categorize
concepts based on their level of abstraction, defining them in the order of
increasing complexity within factual, emotional, and inferential tasks. We
conduct extensive probing experiments using layer-wise representations across
various LLM families (Gemma, LLaMA, QWen) on various datasets spanning the
three domains of tasks. Our findings reveal that models could efficiently
conduct probing for simpler tasks in shallow layers, and more complex tasks
typically necessitate deeper layers for accurate understanding. Additionally,
we examine how external factors, such as adding noise to the input and
quantizing the model weights, might affect layer-wise representations. Our
findings suggest that these factors can impede the development of a conceptual
understanding of LLMs until deeper layers are explored. We hope that our
proposed concept and experimental insights will enhance the understanding of
the mechanisms underlying LLMs. Our codes are available at
https://github.com/Luckfort/CD.
|
[
-0.4217066168785095,
-0.8721945881843567,
0.9066829681396484,
0.01590445078909397,
-0.1413128525018692,
0.4847036302089691,
-0.17103274166584015,
-0.7135838866233826,
-0.08577858656644821,
0.4219357967376709,
-0.38764485716819763,
-0.4604467451572418,
-0.8730723857879639,
-0.13408437371253967,
-0.40638551115989685,
0.5785824656486511,
-0.07075594365596771,
-0.049955181777477264,
-0.4674907624721527,
0.1765453815460205,
-0.16884271800518036,
-0.5246424078941345,
-0.6056031584739685,
-0.7984985709190369,
0.6425914168357849,
0.6192215085029602,
0.5455330610275269,
0.4454439580440521,
0.6374390125274658,
0.2661220133304596,
-0.3696548044681549,
0.3161938190460205,
-0.49722549319267273,
0.1706138253211975,
-0.07215624302625656,
-0.755070686340332,
-0.3298044502735138,
-0.005956634879112244,
0.6005316972732544,
1.077795147895813,
0.012260853312909603,
0.11511793732643127,
-0.010246507823467255,
0.6322032809257507,
-0.5962996482849121,
0.1401013731956482,
-0.4470009505748749,
0.09846723824739456,
-0.08774103224277496,
-0.1450490653514862,
-0.16976088285446167,
0.23679734766483307,
0.5326995253562927,
-0.2994477152824402,
0.2329915165901184,
-0.02909325808286667,
0.7302618622779846,
0.011219584383070469,
-0.5445113182067871,
-0.4113530218601227,
-0.8846932649612427,
0.6076542139053345,
-0.5729930996894836,
0.3574163317680359,
0.3686685562133789,
0.021632036194205284,
0.13795027136802673,
-0.5363683700561523,
-0.6137674450874329,
-0.3445391356945038,
-0.08375658839941025,
-0.03625405952334404,
-0.05073121190071106,
0.01968350075185299,
0.40391555428504944,
0.5272853374481201,
-0.2111004739999771,
0.2969650626182556,
-0.33148282766342163,
0.044306136667728424,
0.6060411930084229,
0.18252341449260712,
0.30075129866600037,
-0.24135904014110565,
-0.3006262481212616,
0.029152892529964447,
-0.769748866558075,
0.3585208058357239,
0.2511497735977173,
0.19266138970851898,
-0.4500914514064789,
0.6918109655380249,
-0.2565334141254425,
0.3691534399986267,
-0.029227685183286667,
-0.2459476888179779,
0.26735758781433105,
-0.1984701007604599,
-0.37324681878089905,
0.12093643844127655,
0.4847998321056366,
-0.11306244134902954,
0.17118540406227112,
-0.23813194036483765,
-0.35274967551231384,
-0.09355512261390686,
0.23798879981040955,
-0.7079271674156189,
-0.08965200185775757,
0.4599956274032593,
-0.1876295953989029,
-0.3542800545692444,
0.09846611320972443,
-0.06121496111154556,
-0.5581641793251038,
-0.4100564122200012,
0.4743152856826782,
-0.4486861824989319,
-0.5562481880187988,
0.578850269317627,
-0.10937543958425522,
0.33320602774620056,
0.3380856513977051,
-0.6031326055526733,
0.509925901889801,
0.9655292630195618,
0.7727092504501343,
-0.2871277630329132,
-0.25599199533462524,
-0.17640191316604614,
0.20140640437602997,
-0.5353232026100159,
0.737562358379364,
-0.8300642967224121,
-0.24478891491889954,
-0.134885773062706,
-0.10219442844390869,
-0.04852205142378807,
-0.6264333724975586,
0.412322998046875,
-0.7621644735336304,
0.13395483791828156,
-0.482002854347229,
-0.6887796521186829,
-0.3461718261241913,
0.3247765898704529,
-0.6285906434059143,
0.8952091932296753,
-0.05186391621828079,
-0.7448768615722656,
0.28319182991981506,
-0.6064127683639526,
-0.5176097750663757,
0.026522943750023842,
-0.2268555611371994,
-0.13199825584888458,
0.5753602981567383,
0.12986882030963898,
0.9109471440315247,
-0.6322207450866699,
0.053170304745435715,
-0.23733937740325928,
-0.35055866837501526,
0.45602431893348694,
0.008048530668020248,
0.6243633031845093,
0.09785403311252594,
-0.2531304657459259,
0.06882381439208984,
-0.6829631328582764,
-0.3169085383415222,
0.3388519585132599,
-0.276388943195343,
-0.5494685769081116,
0.02677335776388645,
-0.4681684672832489,
0.2019694298505783,
0.18333378434181213,
-0.5716629028320312,
0.07419703900814056,
-0.42909693717956543,
0.655839204788208,
0.38158535957336426,
0.10809867829084396,
0.7153818607330322,
-0.12731371819972992,
0.5036815404891968,
0.6477406620979309,
-0.2692456543445587,
-0.06826020777225494,
-0.3011026680469513,
-0.8351701498031616,
-0.04439039155840874,
0.15767697989940643,
0.3190527856349945,
-0.5087888836860657,
0.04585126042366028,
-0.37546828389167786,
-0.46220898628234863,
-0.5065893530845642,
0.23827475309371948,
0.42421332001686096,
0.25253474712371826,
0.1840670257806778,
-0.4972718060016632,
-0.029576018452644348,
-0.9610748887062073,
0.10773731023073196,
-0.17405878007411957,
-0.03342105820775032,
0.3256906569004059,
0.63950115442276,
-0.2231530249118805,
0.5971251726150513,
-0.5690577626228333,
-0.11200043559074402,
-0.4124949872493744,
0.21506112813949585,
0.0044619617983698845,
0.40205588936805725,
0.19141815602779388,
-0.7475454211235046,
0.06319759786128998,
0.24713531136512756,
-0.6040253639221191,
0.10674754530191422,
-0.06102346256375313,
-0.08386333286762238,
-0.1697734296321869,
0.6206295490264893,
-0.9734005928039551,
-0.09705488383769989,
0.5865721106529236,
0.004760576877743006,
0.3638406991958618,
-0.08955216407775879,
-0.2766476571559906,
-0.932289183139801,
-0.22027181088924408,
0.06668668985366821,
-0.018472231924533844,
-0.8304779529571533,
0.4456624388694763,
0.18382437527179718,
0.2863014340400696,
-0.34382668137550354,
0.29778027534484863,
-0.7284403443336487,
-0.41777971386909485,
-0.09745074808597565,
0.35556042194366455,
0.4140431582927704,
0.4408082365989685,
0.14514166116714478,
0.4830245077610016,
0.7731730341911316,
-0.7585818767547607,
0.3907078504562378,
-0.2372950315475464,
-0.7446580529212952,
0.3107118308544159,
-0.7286852598190308,
0.3604995608329773,
-0.21615424752235413,
0.048182450234889984,
-1.036704659461975,
-0.2634866237640381,
0.036265548318624496,
-0.3273448944091797,
0.42156124114990234,
-0.03291557729244232,
-0.6932631731033325,
-0.12136180698871613,
-0.09226571023464203,
0.44455474615097046,
0.26447594165802,
-0.1270662099123001,
0.5919741988182068,
0.5373799800872803,
-0.055795107036828995,
-0.47802871465682983,
-0.8524051308631897,
0.13269950449466705,
-0.45293375849723816,
-0.6714662909507751,
0.5134109854698181,
0.11953027546405792,
-0.6757391095161438,
-0.1281326711177826,
-0.27473241090774536,
-0.08509381115436554,
0.24300538003444672,
0.2685692608356476,
-0.10697487741708755,
-0.5017098188400269,
0.30625951290130615,
0.13614816963672638,
0.38851839303970337,
0.5681486129760742,
-0.3547361195087433,
0.6215758919715881,
-0.05968722328543663,
-0.47822651267051697,
-0.18247416615486145,
0.13782276213169098,
0.5618557333946228,
-0.4300813376903534,
0.6955780982971191,
0.5096168518066406,
-0.4645002484321594,
-0.533940315246582,
-0.6797372102737427,
-0.10869132727384567,
-0.46642976999282837,
0.48778894543647766,
-0.8064935207366943,
-1.0375730991363525,
0.8304178714752197,
-0.07600772380828857,
-0.1749279499053955,
0.26276764273643494,
0.5081584453582764,
-0.34505417943000793,
0.8431005477905273,
0.7311903238296509,
0.02551329880952835,
0.12827058136463165,
-0.6429451704025269,
0.08460074663162231,
-1.0243666172027588,
-0.4434073269367218,
-0.3815871477127075,
-0.331027090549469,
-0.3676261901855469,
-0.8041529059410095,
0.082709401845932,
0.2949412167072296,
-0.17055922746658325,
-0.09988412261009216,
0.03842424601316452,
0.6049404740333557,
0.28915348649024963,
0.23095467686653137,
0.4867272675037384,
0.1230177953839302,
-0.15039114654064178,
0.32042112946510315,
-0.6269391775131226,
-0.38309940695762634,
0.6782747507095337,
0.7658044695854187,
0.7469739317893982,
0.15843285620212555,
0.7345386743545532,
-0.02487342618405819,
-0.03993907570838928,
-1.0594303607940674,
0.4107094407081604,
-0.0913316011428833,
-0.4386632740497589,
-0.38585904240608215,
-0.29648885130882263,
-0.7880887389183044,
0.2540344297885895,
0.1136908084154129,
-0.4289380609989166,
0.4203616976737976,
-0.23813998699188232,
-0.38438838720321655,
0.2661055028438568,
-0.6819767355918884,
0.5408152937889099,
-0.1498587429523468,
-0.2877011299133301,
-0.3688207268714905,
-0.6311359405517578,
0.5587581396102905,
-0.17368297278881073,
0.21800176799297333,
-0.13876627385616302,
-0.1549653708934784,
0.5135344862937927,
0.07509306073188782,
0.9638203978538513,
-0.005259880796074867,
-0.9685001373291016,
0.37637677788734436,
0.513724148273468,
0.2749529182910919,
0.12873490154743195,
-0.020102418959140778,
0.11127937585115433,
-0.2525554299354553,
-0.4041427969932556,
-0.5499039888381958,
0.6313582062721252,
-0.9525285959243774,
-0.7611286640167236,
0.004472270607948303,
-0.753830075263977,
-0.41343188285827637,
-0.018335219472646713,
0.04894737899303436,
0.45990845561027527,
0.11256090551614761,
0.302163302898407,
0.995521068572998,
-0.24008780717849731,
0.0592765212059021,
0.369737446308136,
-0.07669561356306076,
0.47739139199256897,
0.8170298933982849,
0.1440892219543457,
0.6285294890403748,
0.8309968113899231,
0.15853138267993927,
-0.15239813923835754,
-0.9348256587982178,
-0.07549849897623062,
0.2103399634361267,
-0.8196360468864441,
-0.07399879395961761,
-0.6702494621276855,
-0.3783454895019531,
-0.2656250596046448,
0.18008209764957428,
-0.23156321048736572,
-0.43577277660369873,
-0.32380712032318115,
-0.5483755469322205,
0.1988089233636856,
0.9859154224395752,
0.19266074895858765,
0.29816147685050964,
-0.5622298121452332,
0.36512771248817444,
0.470490038394928,
0.2831229269504547,
0.245700404047966,
-0.6810657978057861,
-0.3157661259174347,
0.11564427614212036,
-0.028560558333992958,
-0.548349916934967,
0.13262155652046204,
0.17622706294059753,
0.4217836260795593,
0.38962888717651367,
-0.18537846207618713,
0.7741003632545471,
-0.3028336763381958,
0.7178715467453003,
-0.18017011880874634,
-0.9979338645935059,
0.2886570394039154,
-0.2775750756263733,
0.4805886447429657,
0.12098748236894608,
0.42379289865493774,
-0.413330614566803,
-0.5591911673545837,
-0.5088419914245605,
-0.7913323044776917,
0.7241109609603882,
0.018711483106017113,
0.5270853042602539,
0.23728047311306,
0.5272828936576843,
0.12938793003559113,
0.24506613612174988,
-0.5909987092018127,
-0.10866384208202362,
0.09562660753726959,
0.23415125906467438,
-0.2292977273464203,
-0.4940928816795349,
-0.15533357858657837,
-0.07104622572660446,
0.07136877626180649,
0.01797623187303543,
0.23761628568172455,
0.3097742795944214,
-0.38981571793556213,
-0.1585092842578888,
0.21959440410137177,
0.5690847039222717,
0.6338028311729431,
-0.12865974009037018,
0.6387486457824707,
0.1687958985567093,
-0.3826296925544739,
-0.13072876632213593,
-0.23116850852966309,
0.21149349212646484,
-0.3468618392944336,
0.8817092776298523,
0.9976494908332825,
0.3056218922138214,
-0.5140820145606995,
0.2525155246257782,
0.07683227956295013,
-0.40697720646858215,
-0.10313348472118378,
0.29519543051719666,
0.6102855801582336,
0.5024890899658203,
0.2996843457221985,
-0.2394372820854187,
0.1518932580947876,
-0.7596478462219238,
-0.0538405179977417,
0.43990179896354675,
-0.21368011832237244,
-0.4702500104904175,
0.14103981852531433,
0.050732798874378204,
-0.009866763837635517,
0.39720985293388367,
-0.2346847951412201,
-0.4153876006603241,
0.8017359375953674,
0.3733636438846588,
0.7263161540031433,
0.012447034940123558,
0.3120734989643097,
-0.024339202791452408,
0.33688920736312866,
-0.11223898082971573,
0.29137295484542847,
-0.04490634426474571,
-1.2601816654205322,
-0.6949397921562195,
-0.6646534204483032,
-0.3583235740661621,
0.35611724853515625,
-0.5335803627967834,
-0.11941742151975632,
-0.5053312182426453,
0.06293592602014542,
0.0020245532505214214,
0.10503817349672318,
-0.8437187075614929,
0.32453837990760803,
0.55958092212677,
0.8551788330078125,
-0.6046168804168701,
0.8745054006576538,
0.7238401770591736,
-0.21149207651615143,
-0.8517070412635803,
0.14655953645706177,
-0.13377396762371063,
-1.0215803384780884,
0.976654589176178,
0.054892756044864655,
-0.49646613001823425,
0.048180002719163895,
-0.6099585890769958,
-1.0397799015045166,
0.9563687443733215,
0.23981434106826782,
-0.5074812173843384,
-0.27219903469085693,
0.4570077955722809,
0.7217262387275696,
-0.7652676105499268,
-0.015948664397001266,
0.7291728854179382,
0.27099505066871643,
0.09640908986330032,
-0.6803349256515503,
0.0997597947716713,
-0.21502184867858887,
0.06264877319335938,
-0.19513891637325287,
-0.48600852489471436,
0.9766180515289307,
-0.5563657283782959,
-0.4058587849140167,
-0.245651513338089,
0.5727828741073608,
0.08952925354242325,
0.17824630439281464,
0.5080323815345764,
0.47263771295547485,
0.6811999678611755,
0.017887713387608528,
1.149013638496399,
-0.21499060094356537,
0.07856424152851105,
0.9637662172317505,
-0.36346715688705444,
0.7870296239852905,
0.3254379332065582,
-0.06130996719002724,
0.630363941192627,
0.659922182559967,
0.24753248691558838,
0.3023856282234192,
0.4829632639884949,
0.003692240919917822,
-0.25997889041900635,
-0.3142258822917938,
-0.1869218647480011,
0.5552200675010681,
0.7558426856994629,
-0.20060423016548157,
0.16781216859817505,
-0.08620453625917435,
-0.1964942365884781,
-0.20048008859157562,
-0.36742112040519714,
0.907997727394104,
0.4084616005420685,
-0.4293699562549591,
0.63698410987854,
0.10357538610696793,
0.5724077224731445,
-0.4250710904598236,
0.24216949939727783,
-0.2984411120414734,
-0.15311267971992493,
-0.2826993763446808,
-1.0908303260803223,
-0.1179625540971756,
-0.19925281405448914,
-0.10127563029527664,
-0.2075280398130417,
0.8108609318733215,
-0.43866533041000366,
-0.4617234468460083,
0.5776189565658569,
1.0678696632385254,
0.0009485908085480332,
-0.19508197903633118,
-0.5211052894592285,
0.2583896219730377,
-0.3311416804790497,
-0.4948854446411133,
0.2124721109867096,
1.0569418668746948,
0.07894880324602127,
0.6699507236480713,
0.42684492468833923,
0.22963722050189972,
0.1468316614627838,
0.47316259145736694,
0.8193148970603943,
-0.5869074463844299,
-0.13862188160419464,
-0.8366310000419617,
0.44037267565727234,
0.09990791231393814,
-0.14875438809394836,
0.6204648017883301,
0.286936491727829,
1.1662677526474,
0.09184806048870087,
0.532217800617218,
0.23739467561244965,
0.2295774519443512,
-0.6842214465141296,
0.36385712027549744,
-0.7474088668823242,
0.5831503868103027,
-0.4003470242023468,
-0.9109724164009094,
-0.19443081319332123,
0.482116162776947,
-0.40403610467910767,
-0.08883696049451828,
0.7732656002044678,
0.6185163259506226,
-0.25971493124961853,
0.0678362175822258,
0.22105492651462555,
0.5055931806564331,
0.3287678062915802,
0.5320655703544617,
1.1926240921020508,
0.0013215665239840746,
0.1233164370059967,
-0.6231589317321777,
0.13873720169067383,
0.018451811745762825,
-0.6280456185340881,
-0.9319515228271484,
-0.6099051237106323,
-0.29547908902168274,
0.034870535135269165,
-0.1939115971326828,
0.7115374803543091,
0.6951073408126831,
-0.565434992313385,
-0.5239051580429077,
-0.03928327187895775,
0.22343821823596954,
-0.053514137864112854,
-0.21785588562488556,
0.3000751733779907,
-0.35606491565704346,
-0.7419938445091248,
0.32367655634880066,
0.21418316662311554,
0.04733128473162651,
-0.49138301610946655,
0.08719448745250702,
-0.03127185255289078,
0.039098698645830154,
0.9380151033401489,
-0.27880293130874634,
-0.8193226456642151,
-0.23052038252353668,
0.03841753676533699,
-0.23973077535629272,
0.027856457978487015,
1.0201865434646606,
-0.5817713141441345,
0.02984953112900257,
0.5684694647789001,
0.7637028098106384,
0.39045003056526184,
-0.23915345966815948,
0.45526760816574097,
-0.927912712097168,
-0.044218096882104874,
0.1278144270181656,
0.3250947892665863,
0.4248450994491577,
-0.42623797059059143,
0.31535714864730835,
-0.012024777010083199,
-0.07880286127328873,
-1.0188595056533813,
0.4342617988586426,
-0.9418233633041382,
-0.6060218811035156,
1.213497281074524,
0.0530349463224411,
-0.047071054577827454,
0.09013162553310394,
-0.07512076199054718,
0.10933241993188858,
-0.23278483748435974,
0.8501558303833008,
0.9915035367012024,
-0.17016656696796417,
-0.3811134696006775,
-0.6783619523048401,
0.3932079076766968,
0.35580572485923767,
-0.7241175174713135,
0.16870766878128052,
0.163875550031662,
0.24947713315486908,
0.36998939514160156,
0.36449676752090454,
-0.08153991401195526,
-0.1638927459716797,
-0.315165638923645,
-0.3371286392211914,
0.0409625805914402,
-0.4724085330963135,
-0.33208760619163513,
0.40502965450286865,
0.21245673298835754,
0.26073339581489563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07060v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07060v1
|
Groundedness in Retrieval-augmented Long-form Generation: An Empirical Study
| 2024-04-10T14:50:10 | 2024-04-10T14:50:10 |
Alessandro Stolfo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present an empirical study of groundedness in long-form question answering
(LFQA) by retrieval-augmented large language models (LLMs). In particular, we
evaluate whether every generated sentence is grounded in the retrieved
documents or the model's pre-training data. Across 3 datasets and 4 model
families, our findings reveal that a significant fraction of generated
sentences are consistently ungrounded, even when those sentences contain
correct ground-truth answers. Additionally, we examine the impacts of factors
such as model size, decoding strategy, and instruction tuning on groundedness.
Our results show that while larger models tend to ground their outputs more
effectively, a significant portion of correct answers remains compromised by
hallucinations. This study provides novel insights into the groundedness
challenges in LFQA and underscores the necessity for more robust mechanisms in
LLMs to mitigate the generation of ungrounded content.
|
[
-0.28864991664886475,
-1.0854308605194092,
1.0980569124221802,
0.09839504957199097,
-0.29443034529685974,
0.041775040328502655,
-0.29626932740211487,
-0.29235658049583435,
0.2374216914176941,
0.7323468923568726,
-0.456452339887619,
-0.4754983186721802,
-0.3581010401248932,
0.12386152893304825,
-0.6859486103057861,
0.75464928150177,
0.10627377778291702,
-0.11615421622991562,
-0.6477189064025879,
-0.14435698091983795,
-0.5899287462234497,
-0.9408786296844482,
-0.08328928798437119,
-0.3912019729614258,
0.2744929790496826,
0.35463106632232666,
0.5640712976455688,
0.3238787055015564,
0.2714950144290924,
0.13368169963359833,
-0.332235187292099,
-0.05285940319299698,
-0.6799160838127136,
0.35948216915130615,
-0.0673464983701706,
-0.41691577434539795,
-0.20975342392921448,
-0.16847680509090424,
0.8443674445152283,
1.0635724067687988,
-0.1913275122642517,
0.08667796850204468,
0.01143668219447136,
0.8238805532455444,
-0.6696043610572815,
-0.4312843978404999,
-0.6758224964141846,
0.08851087838411331,
0.1400943249464035,
-0.2976936995983124,
-0.5770548582077026,
-0.31022873520851135,
-0.09412363171577454,
-0.30097857117652893,
0.4493404030799866,
0.10982947051525116,
0.8621858358383179,
0.3408883810043335,
-0.6942724585533142,
-0.2858204245567322,
-0.5387696623802185,
0.6853299140930176,
-0.6862490177154541,
0.5224484801292419,
0.5047260522842407,
0.09657560288906097,
-0.39321067929267883,
-0.7122953534126282,
-0.44602498412132263,
-0.5532963275909424,
-0.03530532866716385,
0.1950211077928543,
0.18816499412059784,
0.25253304839134216,
0.522653341293335,
0.5610201358795166,
-0.2947830855846405,
0.09912732243537903,
-0.2586043179035187,
-0.0026040002703666687,
0.5342037081718445,
-0.10520894080400467,
0.23247280716896057,
-0.4132159352302551,
-0.13063569366931915,
0.19194108247756958,
-0.9760234355926514,
0.3035365343093872,
0.3526853919029236,
0.187194362282753,
0.24496528506278992,
1.0673850774765015,
-0.46362245082855225,
0.5534239411354065,
0.42490050196647644,
-0.06021811440587044,
0.050055816769599915,
-0.08794145286083221,
-0.36679378151893616,
0.3160964846611023,
0.3093454837799072,
0.34261012077331543,
0.1365705132484436,
-0.4613671600818634,
-0.41298678517341614,
-0.3166489601135254,
0.4350437521934509,
-0.7906973958015442,
0.2446313500404358,
0.49615681171417236,
-0.4923410415649414,
-0.4390806555747986,
0.1574058085680008,
-0.42240893840789795,
-0.46856173872947693,
-0.38041794300079346,
0.28403574228286743,
-0.18879276514053345,
-0.2816306948661804,
0.10749370604753494,
0.013766694813966751,
0.4535185992717743,
0.24233298003673553,
-0.6426755785942078,
0.4615659713745117,
0.7550723552703857,
0.5091453790664673,
-0.24743136763572693,
-0.2195988893508911,
-0.821500301361084,
-0.1257341504096985,
-0.5473961234092712,
0.5233213901519775,
-0.2063334584236145,
-0.35703280568122864,
0.23688191175460815,
0.2624843716621399,
0.023646993562579155,
-0.662645161151886,
0.7059206366539001,
-0.8082951903343201,
0.3278777599334717,
-0.6627233624458313,
-0.5678666234016418,
-0.13569574058055878,
0.4633869230747223,
-0.4435792565345764,
1.2463982105255127,
0.06080019101500511,
-0.7438552975654602,
0.390019953250885,
-0.13634347915649414,
-0.3782835304737091,
-0.1921517550945282,
-0.35099515318870544,
-0.26134854555130005,
0.5891051292419434,
0.1623384654521942,
0.6200247406959534,
-0.29191675782203674,
0.8339850902557373,
-0.1969207376241684,
-0.6167404651641846,
0.360454261302948,
-0.5041157603263855,
0.5553250312805176,
0.007378211710602045,
-0.7226037383079529,
0.01438712328672409,
-1.0921815633773804,
0.2290586531162262,
0.2541032135486603,
-0.35503605008125305,
-0.18325744569301605,
0.23693478107452393,
-0.041375063359737396,
0.24008096754550934,
-0.06857187300920486,
-0.5064388513565063,
-0.04093794897198677,
-0.4265679121017456,
0.30429038405418396,
0.5865805745124817,
0.3231264054775238,
0.2752567529678345,
-0.20642510056495667,
0.3676359951496124,
0.03313712403178215,
-0.4230336844921112,
-0.2526603043079376,
-0.2010319083929062,
-0.8845630884170532,
-0.06493116170167923,
0.06976350396871567,
0.36426302790641785,
-0.43445006012916565,
0.5954619646072388,
-0.3871322274208069,
-0.20466777682304382,
-0.19714051485061646,
0.004963996354490519,
0.3292403519153595,
0.7740699648857117,
0.34306374192237854,
0.17681780457496643,
-0.3152009844779968,
-0.9571028351783752,
-0.10114523023366928,
0.026832889765501022,
-0.0023019229993224144,
0.3606940507888794,
0.6207014918327332,
-0.25661030411720276,
1.078046441078186,
-0.4002831280231476,
0.2525328993797302,
-0.03354142606258392,
-0.005971586797386408,
0.29858240485191345,
0.39410385489463806,
0.5351381897926331,
-0.8139256834983826,
-0.017069945111870766,
-0.27776604890823364,
-1.0678341388702393,
-0.09822480380535126,
-0.14609859883785248,
-0.026477938517928123,
0.14094355702400208,
0.688170313835144,
-1.0688666105270386,
0.5020425915718079,
0.21041272580623627,
-0.329414963722229,
0.5189011096954346,
-0.09155987948179245,
0.33572664856910706,
-1.0567982196807861,
0.17500180006027222,
-0.5331385135650635,
-0.2864213287830353,
-0.4655994772911072,
0.3482517898082733,
0.05674779787659645,
-0.3159639835357666,
-0.3380146920681,
0.25592362880706787,
-0.645719587802887,
-0.27994289994239807,
-0.3570621609687805,
0.1631976068019867,
0.2775775194168091,
0.22987249493598938,
0.12042843550443649,
1.1111711263656616,
0.3395332396030426,
-0.6233686208724976,
0.21738392114639282,
0.08433189243078232,
-0.19359725713729858,
0.27530428767204285,
-0.9258303642272949,
0.4316205084323883,
-0.6183776259422302,
0.26481661200523376,
-0.9872820973396301,
-0.5636211633682251,
-0.17437294125556946,
-0.35338184237480164,
0.24367079138755798,
-0.016366129741072655,
-0.5255424380302429,
-0.18417280912399292,
-0.2618822455406189,
0.3913176357746124,
0.6315900683403015,
-0.6739275455474854,
0.6355792284011841,
-0.066109798848629,
0.07166244834661484,
-0.5920493006706238,
-0.4657226800918579,
0.09894844889640808,
-0.37335091829299927,
-0.6457422375679016,
0.2512587606906891,
-0.09534785151481628,
-0.5807201862335205,
-0.17842137813568115,
-0.1732238233089447,
0.10742302238941193,
0.43530556559562683,
0.5105475187301636,
-0.2842812240123749,
-0.5162662863731384,
0.22383899986743927,
0.24159446358680725,
0.3402971029281616,
0.6152987480163574,
0.0027204109355807304,
0.6083242893218994,
-0.048041049391031265,
-0.5934999585151672,
-0.04364948719739914,
0.5367680191993713,
0.7077212333679199,
-0.1350264698266983,
0.994233250617981,
0.06224600225687027,
-0.6224822998046875,
-0.01516752876341343,
-0.7528301477432251,
-0.17643803358078003,
-0.43291613459587097,
0.1545022428035736,
-0.4412357211112976,
-0.9389898180961609,
0.6920258402824402,
0.1371171921491623,
-0.08836838603019714,
0.615976870059967,
0.4623492360115051,
-0.12200749665498734,
0.9571396708488464,
0.43281883001327515,
0.1829565465450287,
-0.07621369510889053,
0.07769229263067245,
0.06110018864274025,
-0.6366286873817444,
-0.3823074400424957,
-0.47427818179130554,
0.13541512191295624,
-0.43109017610549927,
-0.11626796424388885,
0.058658551424741745,
0.5152599811553955,
-0.37809640169143677,
-0.3785194754600525,
-0.37832680344581604,
0.4944246709346771,
0.5034644603729248,
0.21499155461788177,
0.11474279314279556,
0.06327138096094131,
-0.11917789280414581,
-0.10593195259571075,
-0.2769106924533844,
-0.6071518659591675,
1.0459237098693848,
0.4626436233520508,
0.40052518248558044,
0.18303237855434418,
0.7821150422096252,
0.27724483609199524,
0.025546126067638397,
-0.6633071303367615,
0.49281764030456543,
0.39617636799812317,
-0.6641302704811096,
-0.16948775947093964,
-0.23512865602970123,
-0.6517667174339294,
0.18995821475982666,
-0.35783058404922485,
-0.4469291567802429,
0.008337834849953651,
-0.1665102243423462,
-0.3484581410884857,
-0.015228098258376122,
-0.3964218199253082,
0.48602530360221863,
-0.5231378674507141,
-0.6251843571662903,
0.1494867205619812,
-0.7686532735824585,
0.527472198009491,
-0.24112258851528168,
-0.01949336566030979,
0.09726233780384064,
0.33301231265068054,
0.7960143089294434,
-0.32235482335090637,
0.6083689332008362,
-0.24650539457798004,
-0.43314430117607117,
0.3718148469924927,
-0.044499803334474564,
0.4918053150177002,
0.4035205543041229,
-0.04359404742717743,
-0.13710716366767883,
-0.08501985669136047,
-0.5340182185173035,
-0.7541921138763428,
0.7176111340522766,
-0.8371927738189697,
-1.041224479675293,
-0.5604807138442993,
-0.2178724706172943,
-0.4170927405357361,
0.5037833452224731,
0.44603556394577026,
0.3017578423023224,
-0.34670865535736084,
0.7188445329666138,
1.1269012689590454,
-0.3226099908351898,
0.12402769923210144,
0.27774181962013245,
-0.5707668662071228,
-0.524905264377594,
0.3298231065273285,
0.19211407005786896,
0.27809324860572815,
0.21765205264091492,
-0.06939837336540222,
-0.189264178276062,
-0.7048863768577576,
-0.3524187207221985,
0.2526862919330597,
-1.0298689603805542,
0.02126333862543106,
-0.8101658821105957,
-0.48734188079833984,
-0.471143901348114,
-0.2265702784061432,
-0.24744907021522522,
-0.3184927701950073,
-0.5518506169319153,
-0.5552011728286743,
0.26334160566329956,
0.652417004108429,
0.34537652134895325,
0.20936939120292664,
-0.6859841346740723,
0.6505252122879028,
0.3377877473831177,
0.15311725437641144,
-0.14216315746307373,
-0.7152937054634094,
0.05408566817641258,
0.3830431401729584,
-0.054578498005867004,
-0.8994358777999878,
-0.01387722510844469,
-0.03766721859574318,
0.5071249604225159,
0.356116384267807,
0.17049278318881989,
0.73626708984375,
-0.6994944214820862,
1.1313433647155762,
-0.04222050681710243,
-0.828318178653717,
0.5731616020202637,
-0.580807626247406,
0.08773644268512726,
0.7321339249610901,
0.1537998914718628,
-0.13674522936344147,
-0.1829918622970581,
-0.592247724533081,
-0.940336287021637,
0.3014332950115204,
0.3496379852294922,
0.5301324725151062,
-0.26063141226768494,
0.8426881432533264,
0.001972888596355915,
0.4639878571033478,
-0.738349437713623,
-0.1332903355360031,
-0.432407021522522,
0.03731568157672882,
-0.27334094047546387,
-0.7953963279724121,
-0.24451760947704315,
-0.26494932174682617,
0.41693341732025146,
-0.07456116378307343,
0.27198532223701477,
0.3062798082828522,
-0.3443068563938141,
-0.21673168241977692,
0.33490926027297974,
0.9163727760314941,
0.8206619024276733,
-0.6325979232788086,
0.27332520484924316,
0.19146284461021423,
-0.38051125407218933,
0.3012022078037262,
-0.09629181772470474,
-0.37217962741851807,
0.009953552857041359,
0.48576870560646057,
0.7609133720397949,
0.1194760724902153,
-0.7932456135749817,
0.47933879494667053,
0.03769553080201149,
-0.4396192133426666,
-0.8288185596466064,
-0.0259353369474411,
-0.07348090410232544,
0.035921741276979446,
0.7731515765190125,
-0.34920528531074524,
0.06486350297927856,
-0.6070888638496399,
0.15216900408267975,
0.4949760138988495,
-0.21409669518470764,
-0.181443989276886,
0.7786202430725098,
-0.044218335300683975,
-0.13332317769527435,
0.9186964631080627,
0.2583582401275635,
-0.5813261270523071,
0.6578434109687805,
0.7338864803314209,
0.9098119139671326,
0.2803644835948944,
0.02840198017656803,
0.19456849992275238,
0.42041003704071045,
-0.2849998474121094,
0.22375836968421936,
-0.06754610687494278,
-0.5589056611061096,
-0.26453179121017456,
-0.580624520778656,
-0.34782639145851135,
0.46946579217910767,
-1.057359218597412,
0.119825080037117,
-0.45177367329597473,
-0.06729645282030106,
-0.4723449945449829,
0.004497276619076729,
-0.3368651866912842,
0.5849131941795349,
0.1415284126996994,
0.7456334829330444,
-0.8673858046531677,
0.37800881266593933,
0.65728360414505,
-0.5270981192588806,
-0.8138430118560791,
0.33000701665878296,
-0.46188628673553467,
-0.3984268307685852,
0.816470205783844,
0.48480507731437683,
-0.3331383466720581,
0.144884392619133,
-0.7965413928031921,
-1.042202115058899,
1.1683164834976196,
0.3169618546962738,
-0.12854626774787903,
-0.18975625932216644,
0.27548402547836304,
0.6023499965667725,
-0.2924349009990692,
0.05208425968885422,
0.28654974699020386,
0.151369109749794,
-0.007277432829141617,
-0.5186315774917603,
0.1649351269006729,
-0.24090217053890228,
-0.18854732811450958,
-0.07354193925857544,
-0.5112206339836121,
0.7708854675292969,
0.00643236143514514,
-0.2230728268623352,
0.07170788943767548,
0.9338088035583496,
0.7252404689788818,
0.4486848711967468,
0.24782921373844147,
0.6164180636405945,
0.806652307510376,
0.047647472470998764,
0.8982046246528625,
-0.2510833442211151,
0.20725597441196442,
0.9297577738761902,
-0.6778992414474487,
0.8300697207450867,
0.7333325743675232,
0.22750887274742126,
0.32904213666915894,
0.6220681071281433,
0.29056012630462646,
0.4881910979747772,
0.2636166512966156,
-0.004724032711237669,
-0.4389496147632599,
-0.09974746406078339,
-0.6892896890640259,
0.39357033371925354,
0.02174055576324463,
-0.4965350031852722,
-0.13072681427001953,
0.1857258379459381,
0.05188412219285965,
0.43120208382606506,
-0.3030676543712616,
0.598243236541748,
0.06739559769630432,
-0.9645846486091614,
1.1033490896224976,
0.11047389358282089,
0.2930608093738556,
-0.21817083656787872,
-0.10439315438270569,
-0.5598530173301697,
-0.06127782166004181,
-0.31737154722213745,
-0.6736310720443726,
0.04142270237207413,
0.16029813885688782,
-0.5241055488586426,
-0.26103660464286804,
0.8133747577667236,
-0.11978265643119812,
-0.3926234543323517,
0.1716357171535492,
0.6918299794197083,
0.10693288594484329,
-0.2946566641330719,
-0.15581004321575165,
-0.06312120705842972,
-0.17671692371368408,
-0.5954505801200867,
0.42180636525154114,
0.6209714412689209,
-0.1731613129377365,
0.5407224893569946,
0.784224271774292,
-0.18181687593460083,
0.3601920008659363,
-0.009268645197153091,
1.0391570329666138,
-0.9184330701828003,
-0.29558703303337097,
-0.6948278546333313,
0.5918869972229004,
-0.09719233214855194,
-0.13768170773983002,
0.974805474281311,
0.6548768877983093,
0.4251534640789032,
-0.061609797179698944,
0.5689850449562073,
0.13489589095115662,
0.6311657428741455,
-1.0834603309631348,
0.7782458662986755,
-0.6198158264160156,
0.28938359022140503,
-0.1753838211297989,
-1.236430287361145,
-0.12656143307685852,
0.395300030708313,
-0.20424461364746094,
0.16175666451454163,
0.7448874115943909,
0.49969810247421265,
-0.12957541644573212,
-0.2955072224140167,
0.40088772773742676,
0.05851069837808609,
0.20986726880073547,
0.16713900864124298,
1.1875965595245361,
-0.5051558017730713,
-0.16804403066635132,
-0.28857409954071045,
0.18632663786411285,
-0.1876470446586609,
-0.9097535014152527,
-1.220726728439331,
-0.3967030346393585,
-0.08648708462715149,
-0.7113359570503235,
0.13565415143966675,
0.980316162109375,
0.16770488023757935,
-0.7053358554840088,
-0.00024267792468890548,
-0.33697691559791565,
-0.07877383381128311,
0.23252658545970917,
-0.2185564488172531,
0.5505461096763611,
-0.19646520912647247,
-0.15078887343406677,
0.5901005864143372,
-0.08155012875795364,
0.07841162383556366,
-0.060165196657180786,
-0.00786123238503933,
-0.20309391617774963,
0.21640479564666748,
0.7320932149887085,
0.18737086653709412,
-0.8364379405975342,
-0.595292866230011,
0.5978750586509705,
-0.12299326062202454,
0.07229586690664291,
0.6894651651382446,
-0.9271285533905029,
0.11352970451116562,
0.24521152675151825,
0.858639657497406,
0.20334213972091675,
0.5651254653930664,
0.3450562655925751,
-0.8622179627418518,
0.32968124747276306,
0.2639317214488983,
0.33581000566482544,
0.3349718153476715,
-0.6421567797660828,
0.3568183481693268,
0.16768962144851685,
-0.6385397911071777,
-1.4035084247589111,
0.04161248728632927,
-0.8738276958465576,
-0.08302327990531921,
1.6329618692398071,
0.09051992744207382,
-0.12582477927207947,
0.08373089879751205,
-0.23460513353347778,
0.12862031161785126,
0.12271066009998322,
0.6477212309837341,
1.0117605924606323,
0.2522895932197571,
-0.4559341371059418,
-0.6924876570701599,
0.3200492858886719,
0.6374219655990601,
-0.6649928092956543,
0.1616080105304718,
0.9555369019508362,
0.3310062885284424,
0.167485311627388,
0.6477327942848206,
0.25203394889831543,
0.32086217403411865,
-0.23991462588310242,
0.014993701130151749,
-0.09823765605688095,
-0.37095537781715393,
-0.5479335188865662,
0.4102057218551636,
0.462520956993103,
0.1823578029870987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07053v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07053v1
|
Meta4XNLI: A Crosslingual Parallel Corpus for Metaphor Detection and Interpretation
| 2024-04-10T14:44:48 | 2024-04-10T14:44:48 |
Elisa Sanchez-Bayona, Rodrigo Agerri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Metaphors, although occasionally unperceived, are ubiquitous in our everyday
language. Thus, it is crucial for Language Models to be able to grasp the
underlying meaning of this kind of figurative language. In this work, we
present Meta4XNLI, a novel parallel dataset for the tasks of metaphor detection
and interpretation that contains metaphor annotations in both Spanish and
English. We investigate language models' metaphor identification and
understanding abilities through a series of monolingual and cross-lingual
experiments by leveraging our proposed corpus. In order to comprehend how these
non-literal expressions affect models' performance, we look over the results
and perform an error analysis. Additionally, parallel data offers many
potential opportunities to investigate metaphor transferability between these
languages and the impact of translation on the development of multilingual
annotated resources.
|
[
-0.36406564712524414,
-0.2727694511413574,
0.5543491244316101,
0.5554515719413757,
-0.3787737786769867,
-0.002908878494054079,
0.012152419425547123,
-0.8236764669418335,
0.39873483777046204,
0.33472010493278503,
-0.5617843866348267,
-0.3846034109592438,
-0.5738263130187988,
0.4932771921157837,
-0.4619658887386322,
0.9415802955627441,
-0.08460437506437302,
0.10294438153505325,
-0.30055686831474304,
-0.5851349234580994,
-0.6042104363441467,
-0.43247705698013306,
-0.5190544724464417,
-0.03741680830717087,
0.9734373688697815,
0.1093166396021843,
1.0825213193893433,
0.7672995328903198,
0.2741907835006714,
0.29934296011924744,
0.545113205909729,
-0.2645902633666992,
-0.2564629018306732,
-0.274965763092041,
-0.5006325244903564,
-0.8492913246154785,
-0.14393693208694458,
0.13841645419597626,
1.0554918050765991,
0.8174221515655518,
0.09419931471347809,
0.25472381711006165,
-0.05789557844400406,
0.16846776008605957,
-0.6304386854171753,
0.5244849920272827,
-0.6730467677116394,
0.23677487671375275,
-0.5493143796920776,
-0.12438420951366425,
-0.10673187673091888,
-0.10128076374530792,
0.010511691682040691,
-0.6707881689071655,
0.0757572278380394,
0.4384253919124603,
0.6802869439125061,
0.18053247034549713,
-0.18884924054145813,
-0.17523902654647827,
-0.2679661810398102,
1.0744619369506836,
-0.5143947005271912,
0.5397823452949524,
-0.07095102220773697,
0.6181060671806335,
0.2553803026676178,
-0.9221574068069458,
-0.8020918965339661,
0.15606848895549774,
-0.43084073066711426,
0.12708662450313568,
-0.2910160720348358,
-0.38977307081222534,
0.26243501901626587,
0.07349928468465805,
-0.6344150900840759,
0.07887318730354309,
-0.4212576746940613,
-0.29989463090896606,
0.21120502054691315,
0.38085177540779114,
0.7012515068054199,
-0.17262639105319977,
-0.45187830924987793,
-0.16290061175823212,
-0.5924920439720154,
-0.18723075091838837,
0.5992790460586548,
0.44257208704948425,
-0.32192954421043396,
0.13925209641456604,
0.3376149535179138,
0.7355417013168335,
-0.9069086313247681,
-0.14953382313251495,
0.6515842080116272,
-0.44361332058906555,
-0.16182412207126617,
0.20183034241199493,
0.8512476086616516,
0.3411913216114044,
0.43494758009910583,
-0.23161928355693817,
-0.1645353138446808,
0.3014192283153534,
0.13275694847106934,
-0.47185176610946655,
0.03401476889848709,
-0.03729894757270813,
-0.4744490087032318,
-0.43761464953422546,
0.10029764473438263,
-0.8584018349647522,
-0.14674244821071625,
-0.33401528000831604,
0.3362644612789154,
-0.26629114151000977,
-0.3063402473926544,
0.2338758260011673,
-0.4741905629634857,
-0.002750080544501543,
0.02343318611383438,
-0.6712293028831482,
0.323466956615448,
0.6827415227890015,
0.7202351093292236,
-0.15967606008052826,
-0.9113805294036865,
-0.41246217489242554,
0.36193540692329407,
-0.2161930948495865,
0.5148134827613831,
-0.7364449501037598,
-0.023329535499215126,
-0.10837876051664352,
0.27123430371284485,
-0.42676302790641785,
-0.41875842213630676,
0.7524228096008301,
-0.2486172467470169,
0.11309490352869034,
-0.34857505559921265,
-0.11896989494562149,
-0.3609603941440582,
0.3395857512950897,
-1.2323346138000488,
0.6067332625389099,
-0.1369376927614212,
-1.2142376899719238,
-0.09725304692983627,
-0.6474271416664124,
-0.12193986028432846,
-0.10137342661619186,
-0.5299775004386902,
-0.05468478798866272,
0.1804623156785965,
0.2158297598361969,
0.23810067772865295,
-0.7487728595733643,
0.28943687677383423,
-0.35042282938957214,
-0.300597608089447,
0.4267865717411041,
-0.40432360768318176,
0.7181118130683899,
0.18698716163635254,
-0.25353673100471497,
-0.0050697834230959415,
-0.6143797636032104,
-0.03516416251659393,
0.3239765465259552,
0.3254947364330292,
-0.6641533970832825,
-0.29974400997161865,
0.5740523934364319,
0.45128312706947327,
0.1954013556241989,
-0.7311937212944031,
-0.4328885078430176,
-0.142069011926651,
0.2909261882305145,
0.3600820004940033,
-0.5859982967376709,
0.03088182583451271,
-0.36215919256210327,
0.6656992435455322,
0.19661816954612732,
-0.012460729107260704,
-0.4121510684490204,
-0.5576521754264832,
-0.47186580300331116,
-0.26575660705566406,
0.6841148734092712,
0.6505101323127747,
-0.9516393542289734,
-0.1769634634256363,
-0.5794733762741089,
-0.10142956674098969,
-0.7080235481262207,
-0.03551831841468811,
0.4993544816970825,
0.5752405524253845,
0.426679402589798,
0.07765582203865051,
-0.7243654131889343,
-1.3495457172393799,
-0.570621907711029,
0.0932953804731369,
-0.0438358373939991,
0.3260631859302521,
0.5899661183357239,
-0.27518653869628906,
0.8939275741577148,
-0.06823805719614029,
-0.13285945355892181,
-0.37609782814979553,
0.5342994332313538,
0.22747626900672913,
0.38043010234832764,
1.1592901945114136,
-0.8986024856567383,
-0.34741851687431335,
0.023938890546560287,
-1.167940378189087,
-0.3299153447151184,
-0.17921939492225647,
-0.20640704035758972,
-0.24911755323410034,
0.4613647758960724,
-0.35416004061698914,
0.2931865453720093,
0.7750995755195618,
-0.1901886910200119,
0.4130456745624542,
-0.0037349998019635677,
-0.02955358661711216,
-1.0272395610809326,
0.2410610467195511,
-0.21979373693466187,
-0.3850330710411072,
-0.5326513648033142,
0.2126755565404892,
0.16966696083545685,
0.0026763027999550104,
-0.6722407341003418,
0.8619672060012817,
-0.32724514603614807,
-0.289434552192688,
-0.27501532435417175,
0.05740940198302269,
-0.04445718973875046,
0.07420746237039566,
0.43991008400917053,
0.7753496766090393,
0.6731209754943848,
0.00460081547498703,
0.26733312010765076,
-0.028585372492671013,
-0.24182958900928497,
0.4086272716522217,
-0.6400476694107056,
-0.17114663124084473,
-0.30488839745521545,
0.25560441613197327,
-0.6134437322616577,
-0.0695086419582367,
0.3167685270309448,
-0.004183400422334671,
-0.16798807680606842,
0.30852606892585754,
-0.7547293901443481,
-0.21198102831840515,
-0.23483557999134064,
1.002590298652649,
0.11673890799283981,
-0.774761438369751,
0.7368175387382507,
0.28538328409194946,
0.049869149923324585,
-0.8321782350540161,
-0.901771068572998,
0.2712271809577942,
-0.33544233441352844,
-0.5189929604530334,
0.37469449639320374,
0.17163510620594025,
-0.214650958776474,
0.1410890519618988,
0.13595271110534668,
-0.14286962151527405,
-0.23904584348201752,
0.14016583561897278,
0.16011947393417358,
-0.19462202489376068,
-0.10808809846639633,
0.12350743263959885,
-0.2657616436481476,
0.4014296233654022,
-0.27303946018218994,
0.37217825651168823,
-0.25058045983314514,
-0.22938619554042816,
-0.5323115587234497,
0.5551749467849731,
0.9382454752922058,
-0.2049691528081894,
0.752326250076294,
0.7760068774223328,
-0.493897020816803,
0.04965195804834366,
-0.48621103167533875,
0.09403019398450851,
-0.3591412305831909,
-0.0264067854732275,
-0.8210870027542114,
-0.5508498549461365,
0.6431823968887329,
0.12685829401016235,
-0.0912943035364151,
0.27552759647369385,
0.3453664183616638,
0.11759404838085175,
0.6424590349197388,
0.44752371311187744,
-0.22094567120075226,
-0.0028162735980004072,
-0.02625788189470768,
0.07930686324834824,
-0.5165817141532898,
-0.020691998302936554,
-0.43624040484428406,
-0.5408698916435242,
-0.47131428122520447,
-0.7491008043289185,
0.24168018996715546,
-0.33707374334335327,
0.16286735236644745,
0.43324172496795654,
0.10337453335523605,
0.5274885296821594,
0.5087747573852539,
-0.1989332139492035,
0.4403074085712433,
-0.07666973024606705,
-0.4322291612625122,
-0.2998352646827698,
-0.630213737487793,
-0.38358020782470703,
0.9074155688285828,
0.5152878165245056,
0.32174912095069885,
0.09125930815935135,
0.5084404349327087,
-0.11768291145563126,
0.3562150299549103,
-0.24422869086265564,
0.38071009516716003,
-0.011644208803772926,
-0.6153864860534668,
-0.0009036746341735125,
-0.35415321588516235,
-0.9656770825386047,
0.6402884721755981,
-0.10513678938150406,
-0.5662502646446228,
0.19861820340156555,
-0.06920667737722397,
-0.14220952987670898,
0.36467164754867554,
-0.4273751676082611,
1.319451928138733,
-0.3558482527732849,
-0.1638788878917694,
-0.3052091598510742,
-0.7920717597007751,
0.6071221828460693,
-0.4565466046333313,
0.6457955241203308,
-0.18444758653640747,
-0.3321363031864166,
0.56524658203125,
-0.14699339866638184,
0.7370554804801941,
0.09682509303092957,
0.139855295419693,
0.15663787722587585,
0.018132418394088745,
0.2968079447746277,
0.23914188146591187,
-0.1365048587322235,
0.7473390102386475,
0.4082674980163574,
-0.5218889117240906,
-0.8597708344459534,
0.6507568359375,
-0.5427708029747009,
-0.3390151560306549,
-0.5698714256286621,
-1.1414778232574463,
-0.07206705957651138,
0.13505755364894867,
0.06056739017367363,
0.05282880365848541,
-0.18519476056098938,
-0.04078061506152153,
0.047292560338974,
-0.4078717529773712,
0.5205504298210144,
0.4027392864227295,
-0.46584463119506836,
-0.17750948667526245,
0.9629534482955933,
-0.004701693542301655,
-0.0805458351969719,
0.29720231890678406,
0.230509951710701,
-0.4397527575492859,
-0.17331384122371674,
-0.4087628424167633,
0.6713279485702515,
-0.6228467226028442,
0.10408885031938553,
-0.8173121213912964,
-0.02945743128657341,
-0.07339353114366531,
0.22515369951725006,
-0.3008836805820465,
-0.34164702892303467,
-0.04116594046354294,
-0.21424977481365204,
0.07421029359102249,
0.3760833442211151,
-0.07336563616991043,
0.05980685353279114,
-0.836699366569519,
0.24994835257530212,
0.1217486634850502,
0.001211326103657484,
-0.21743592619895935,
-0.06102670729160309,
-0.03827934339642525,
-0.045506298542022705,
0.3134860396385193,
-0.9508973956108093,
0.5389913320541382,
0.025613509118556976,
0.4937826693058014,
0.34661591053009033,
-0.1046828031539917,
0.6128447651863098,
-0.7445241212844849,
0.2950473427772522,
0.35682713985443115,
-1.0358269214630127,
0.2108527570962906,
-0.49401766061782837,
0.18128079175949097,
0.33625343441963196,
0.6251093149185181,
-0.5448105931282043,
-0.3276863694190979,
-0.4812822937965393,
-0.3344494700431824,
0.6766840815544128,
0.533338725566864,
0.2030961513519287,
-0.0414828322827816,
0.19533075392246246,
0.2429785430431366,
0.4461342990398407,
-0.9956532120704651,
-0.08363436907529831,
-0.2163558155298233,
-0.3268861472606659,
-0.16979847848415375,
-0.07009154558181763,
-0.2559049427509308,
-0.40016859769821167,
0.0777282789349556,
-0.25361162424087524,
0.20595930516719818,
-0.23829862475395203,
-0.11614762991666794,
0.17154905200004578,
-0.07588914781808853,
0.3309812843799591,
0.6870599985122681,
0.01684744656085968,
0.40016672015190125,
0.212493896484375,
-0.24679939448833466,
-0.22964659333229065,
0.12397244572639465,
0.12130201607942581,
0.4408355951309204,
0.4580104947090149,
0.9834237098693848,
0.5096299052238464,
-0.9880416989326477,
0.5422667860984802,
-0.20047859847545624,
0.03873289003968239,
-0.4125395715236664,
-0.44615450501441956,
0.2227293848991394,
0.22575347125530243,
-0.06295838207006454,
-0.09903417527675629,
0.4149806797504425,
-0.6908962726593018,
0.1655009537935257,
0.32671159505844116,
-0.05628611892461777,
-0.6257584095001221,
0.8220452070236206,
0.0032603363506495953,
0.14193566143512726,
0.5015906095504761,
-0.07025624811649323,
-0.4274774193763733,
0.5426430702209473,
0.8046567440032959,
0.6763666272163391,
-0.2793619930744171,
0.20478376746177673,
0.2591831386089325,
0.4010125696659088,
-0.0535321868956089,
0.32731643319129944,
0.17343521118164062,
-1.0217207670211792,
-0.10951103270053864,
-0.7832049131393433,
-0.17669594287872314,
0.09763303399085999,
-0.6685357689857483,
0.42824918031692505,
-0.10671675950288773,
0.17641201615333557,
0.27095696330070496,
-0.8477258682250977,
-0.9012762904167175,
0.19932794570922852,
0.3731095492839813,
0.8765262961387634,
-1.4157209396362305,
1.2630937099456787,
0.6902604699134827,
-0.4047660231590271,
-0.6429799795150757,
-0.07401721179485321,
-0.0188400000333786,
-0.6955221891403198,
0.96501624584198,
0.4978492558002472,
-0.13015195727348328,
0.027814850211143494,
0.042278140783309937,
-0.9848531484603882,
0.9993861317634583,
0.8387354612350464,
-0.4261735677719116,
-0.22137363255023956,
0.7351808547973633,
0.6525177955627441,
-0.7103813886642456,
0.5902625322341919,
0.860205888748169,
0.7722163796424866,
-0.06747794896364212,
-1.139976143836975,
0.1647476702928543,
-0.2682839334011078,
0.24496807157993317,
-0.02755645290017128,
-0.38975057005882263,
1.2658381462097168,
0.2139810025691986,
-0.23751859366893768,
0.005203737877309322,
0.5601388216018677,
0.21384409070014954,
0.5105785131454468,
0.712749719619751,
0.7993570566177368,
0.48070892691612244,
-0.05359894409775734,
1.1821776628494263,
-0.41806814074516296,
0.11889763921499252,
1.1440349817276,
-0.31527334451675415,
0.7252367734909058,
0.6109253168106079,
0.11915568262338638,
0.6204347610473633,
0.4560326039791107,
0.11290933936834335,
0.2962230443954468,
0.06450431793928146,
-0.32504361867904663,
-0.19248805940151215,
-0.3008645176887512,
-0.277011901140213,
0.41321516036987305,
0.4833486080169678,
-0.6251444816589355,
-0.6640362739562988,
0.5052763223648071,
-0.009849456138908863,
0.1484641134738922,
0.0530545637011528,
0.04372024163603783,
0.07738731801509857,
-0.5535679459571838,
0.5051354765892029,
0.0556994266808033,
0.38437631726264954,
-0.2404196411371231,
-0.1575222611427307,
0.10030544549226761,
0.10607568174600601,
-0.1290823221206665,
-0.5955069065093994,
0.8012199997901917,
-0.2141466587781906,
-0.022178664803504944,
-0.10101970285177231,
0.20607586205005646,
-0.46181410551071167,
-0.6840388774871826,
0.7848092317581177,
0.7782412171363831,
0.5160484313964844,
-0.1445298194885254,
-1.0438928604125977,
0.4810628592967987,
-0.2377946674823761,
0.26381900906562805,
0.26315465569496155,
0.47167304158210754,
-0.5408099889755249,
0.436191201210022,
0.5038179755210876,
-0.18504370748996735,
0.1960451453924179,
0.17265911400318146,
0.7422387599945068,
-0.6921492218971252,
-0.6081861853599548,
-0.8149824738502502,
0.289711594581604,
-0.11370956897735596,
-0.029149357229471207,
0.8121729493141174,
0.6766453981399536,
0.8960522413253784,
-0.37450772523880005,
0.8672815561294556,
0.046008843928575516,
0.6330206990242004,
-0.35354238748550415,
0.545953094959259,
-0.6400229930877686,
0.13282854855060577,
-0.3693707585334778,
-1.018517255783081,
-0.5800799131393433,
0.4341210722923279,
-0.2448856085538864,
-0.2083754539489746,
1.1034119129180908,
0.6966359615325928,
-0.4647117555141449,
0.23961447179317474,
0.5069907903671265,
0.06298980116844177,
0.019327916204929352,
0.516955554485321,
0.8592268824577332,
-0.5444064736366272,
0.43029218912124634,
-0.24014468491077423,
-0.048123281449079514,
0.27041739225387573,
-1.0252726078033447,
-1.116842269897461,
-0.4120495915412903,
-0.1579451709985733,
0.023471899330615997,
0.10415387153625488,
0.6380871534347534,
0.41228893399238586,
-0.7758172154426575,
-0.530444860458374,
-0.3321455419063568,
0.08802346885204315,
-0.2350228726863861,
-0.17026744782924652,
0.1806584596633911,
-0.5749486088752747,
-1.3132224082946777,
0.45548027753829956,
0.2372422218322754,
-0.1727782040834427,
-0.2806911766529083,
0.14320243895053864,
-0.20429787039756775,
0.19174990057945251,
0.336534708738327,
0.28461015224456787,
-1.0001779794692993,
-0.20355501770973206,
-0.2422102838754654,
0.06454404443502426,
-0.06675950437784195,
0.9524905681610107,
-0.9496492743492126,
0.573054313659668,
0.4556007981300354,
0.7334772348403931,
0.3349333703517914,
-0.1756380796432495,
0.7484754323959351,
-0.676410436630249,
0.7392185926437378,
-0.032708995044231415,
0.6174272298812866,
0.2017601877450943,
-0.11868397146463394,
0.635841429233551,
0.6519456505775452,
0.1129162609577179,
-0.9770903587341309,
0.1709771305322647,
-0.7167974710464478,
-0.3921455442905426,
0.8385469913482666,
-0.3599487543106079,
-0.3957580029964447,
-0.061617661267519,
-0.03810650482773781,
0.008657124824821949,
0.11895064264535904,
0.44577091932296753,
0.5929840207099915,
0.05337187647819519,
-0.41563525795936584,
-0.9494907855987549,
0.2825409471988678,
0.5582708716392517,
-0.6867356896400452,
-0.22392737865447998,
0.20680995285511017,
0.3614712357521057,
0.4469563364982605,
0.21284745633602142,
-0.3119703531265259,
0.26963892579078674,
-0.04698887839913368,
0.11645013839006424,
0.058432210236787796,
-0.5383021235466003,
-0.2826753854751587,
0.2767530083656311,
-0.4482235312461853,
-0.45295992493629456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07036v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07036v1
|
A Computational Analysis of the Dehumanisation of Migrants from Syria and Ukraine in Slovene News Media
| 2024-04-10T14:28:09 | 2024-04-10T14:28:09 |
Jaya Caporusso, Damar Hoogland, Mojca Brglez, Boshko Koloski, Matthew Purver, Senja Pollak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dehumanisation involves the perception and or treatment of a social group's
members as less than human. This phenomenon is rarely addressed with
computational linguistic techniques. We adapt a recently proposed approach for
English, making it easier to transfer to other languages and to evaluate,
introducing a new sentiment resource, the use of zero-shot cross-lingual
valence and arousal detection, and a new method for statistical significance
testing. We then apply it to study attitudes to migration expressed in Slovene
newspapers, to examine changes in the Slovene discourse on migration between
the 2015-16 migration crisis following the war in Syria and the 2022-23 period
following the war in Ukraine. We find that while this discourse became more
negative and more intense over time, it is less dehumanising when specifically
addressing Ukrainian migrants compared to others.
|
[
-0.6003087759017944,
-0.6377490758895874,
0.45565107464790344,
0.16244661808013916,
-0.2941133975982666,
0.13880126178264618,
0.05904480814933777,
-0.360147088766098,
0.44360727071762085,
0.28188031911849976,
-0.500830888748169,
-0.6810466647148132,
-0.7341873049736023,
0.19415131211280823,
-0.2516496777534485,
0.8700341582298279,
-0.02979288622736931,
0.04308398440480232,
0.027993129566311836,
-0.3714257776737213,
0.1489366590976715,
-0.5631998181343079,
-0.15791282057762146,
0.08925735950469971,
0.5853836536407471,
0.303123414516449,
0.7247307300567627,
0.25146400928497314,
0.5173370242118835,
0.2970883846282959,
-0.174761101603508,
-0.5833690166473389,
-0.5338164567947388,
0.05861341580748558,
-0.5388749241828918,
-0.4917013645172119,
-0.01600850746035576,
0.22519010305404663,
0.39149796962738037,
0.6672446727752686,
0.2043031007051468,
0.6128202080726624,
-0.07057732343673706,
0.9664286971092224,
-0.5512390732765198,
-0.1920901983976364,
-0.5444596409797668,
0.311932772397995,
0.04636584222316742,
-0.03251277655363083,
-0.08271806687116623,
-0.36760687828063965,
-0.3170260488986969,
-0.13788340985774994,
0.4228644371032715,
-0.30508601665496826,
0.613610029220581,
0.29364949464797974,
-0.6287218928337097,
0.029095295816659927,
-0.8595291376113892,
0.9066478610038757,
-0.37622568011283875,
0.39169448614120483,
0.16730396449565887,
0.08354683965444565,
-0.07388394325971603,
-0.20579254627227783,
-0.4468122720718384,
-0.2813226580619812,
0.053706299513578415,
0.2571428120136261,
-0.37214943766593933,
-0.19244426488876343,
0.20591945946216583,
0.06288211047649384,
-0.8197008371353149,
-0.15992659330368042,
-1.0346479415893555,
-0.1616164892911911,
0.5828900337219238,
0.11978980153799057,
0.48563554883003235,
-0.3971776068210602,
-0.333710640668869,
0.4963921308517456,
-0.5168002843856812,
-0.009380460716784,
0.7444149255752563,
0.2545842230319977,
-0.15271510183811188,
0.7078404426574707,
-0.21386151015758514,
0.48202547430992126,
-0.03894992545247078,
-0.12266532331705093,
0.40286436676979065,
-0.01789078861474991,
0.11865126341581345,
0.2613098621368408,
0.3354968726634979,
0.9135571718215942,
-0.012658041901886463,
-0.10251034051179886,
0.20577563345432281,
0.7384085059165955,
0.5290654897689819,
-0.8638543486595154,
-0.0005213003023527563,
0.056647758930921555,
-0.4312901198863983,
-0.5266408324241638,
-0.2769790589809418,
-1.1149336099624634,
-0.46303805708885193,
-0.18916690349578857,
-0.08782260119915009,
-0.04392366483807564,
-0.21070709824562073,
0.22770331799983978,
-0.04403569921851158,
0.3165062665939331,
0.5449219942092896,
-0.4017332196235657,
0.29279592633247375,
0.5708540081977844,
0.7591993808746338,
-0.2957315742969513,
0.18463213741779327,
-0.4419798254966736,
-0.3126312792301178,
-0.3612789213657379,
0.7150930762290955,
-0.6056069731712341,
-0.5226905345916748,
-0.1841231733560562,
0.24501436948776245,
0.05603311210870743,
-0.2787530720233917,
0.8141023516654968,
-0.3672042787075043,
0.32409512996673584,
-0.26000919938087463,
-0.013291727751493454,
-0.4493977427482605,
0.6314293742179871,
-0.4857829809188843,
0.878576934337616,
0.6948837041854858,
-0.989156186580658,
0.20503024756908417,
-0.3569492697715759,
-0.18182151019573212,
-0.24195900559425354,
0.18198326230049133,
-0.11305759847164154,
0.2980417311191559,
-0.09836506098508835,
0.12486333400011063,
-0.2655608654022217,
0.051838379353284836,
-0.6264850497245789,
-0.3813551664352417,
0.25313669443130493,
0.13512510061264038,
0.7690395712852478,
0.41385895013809204,
-0.4275963306427002,
-0.23348698019981384,
-0.6779431700706482,
-0.4592699706554413,
-0.2243048995733261,
-0.2510703504085541,
-0.44106537103652954,
0.07161064445972443,
-0.17465603351593018,
0.7055410146713257,
-0.21700350940227509,
-1.0529998540878296,
0.3710380494594574,
-0.8657454252243042,
0.21417321264743805,
0.12753163278102875,
0.21390512585639954,
0.7051355242729187,
-0.22466573119163513,
0.8659124374389648,
0.4872031509876251,
0.15285895764827728,
0.4199470579624176,
-0.39372944831848145,
-0.7733354568481445,
0.07526849955320358,
-0.09149924665689468,
0.853252112865448,
-0.6143167614936829,
0.05797279626131058,
-0.12276839464902878,
-0.5457997918128967,
-0.5474903583526611,
-0.13994544744491577,
0.07661560922861099,
0.821344792842865,
0.24330101907253265,
-0.18605002760887146,
-0.8631948828697205,
-0.9452471733093262,
-0.3233238160610199,
-0.6377654075622559,
0.34951263666152954,
0.09898935258388519,
0.487225741147995,
-0.6009176969528198,
0.6679613590240479,
-0.33461764454841614,
0.0082970280200243,
-0.006178249605000019,
0.22006675601005554,
0.0066069345921278,
0.4751144051551819,
0.7453182935714722,
-0.934495747089386,
-0.3543986976146698,
0.03503720089793205,
-0.41972145438194275,
-0.1767662912607193,
0.03092951886355877,
-0.21244452893733978,
0.5155780911445618,
0.34911850094795227,
-0.7270246148109436,
0.6367462277412415,
0.3330974280834198,
-0.37646397948265076,
0.40863555669784546,
0.38888686895370483,
0.6161733865737915,
-1.0376148223876953,
0.07713411748409271,
0.23475202918052673,
-0.0277435090392828,
-0.6730844974517822,
-0.20500418543815613,
-0.49313709139823914,
-0.3688613772392273,
-1.0850725173950195,
0.6246383786201477,
-0.3239530920982361,
-0.0876171812415123,
0.18418273329734802,
0.398301362991333,
0.04548434168100357,
0.014899292960762978,
-0.22281189262866974,
0.3872200548648834,
0.6147029399871826,
-0.1569298356771469,
0.562186062335968,
0.18332071602344513,
-0.2960962951183319,
0.5792364478111267,
-0.04530813544988632,
0.05955411493778229,
-0.9132982492446899,
0.09654612839221954,
-1.3157265186309814,
-0.05346624180674553,
0.7542181015014648,
-0.5585041642189026,
-0.31129568815231323,
-0.4619370400905609,
-0.031478773802518845,
-0.5209258794784546,
-0.5478281378746033,
0.5490325689315796,
0.5785059928894043,
0.25598612427711487,
0.44304603338241577,
0.54752516746521,
-0.4573827385902405,
-0.31908127665519714,
-0.8578881621360779,
0.4181017577648163,
-0.8986820578575134,
-0.550015926361084,
0.04723416268825531,
0.12490082532167435,
-0.8953008651733398,
0.2269820123910904,
0.19815824925899506,
-0.27943164110183716,
0.2605800926685333,
0.29931584000587463,
0.2661621868610382,
-0.1980946958065033,
0.1353277713060379,
0.1856003999710083,
-0.1027812510728836,
0.21282070875167847,
-0.15274809300899506,
0.21494029462337494,
0.06901392340660095,
-0.22901001572608948,
-0.26383575797080994,
0.5781485438346863,
0.8653213977813721,
-0.12028051167726517,
0.8129594326019287,
0.7987097501754761,
-0.08319257944822311,
0.1533431112766266,
-0.5161352753639221,
0.069642074406147,
-0.2926761507987976,
0.28139495849609375,
-0.10330372303724289,
-0.8599788546562195,
0.8258698582649231,
-0.19381944835186005,
-0.34919923543930054,
0.7251775860786438,
0.7270841002464294,
0.07672717422246933,
0.9971863031387329,
0.49104762077331543,
-0.3027854263782501,
0.041938889771699905,
-0.016861537471413612,
0.12514548003673553,
-0.6066532135009766,
-0.45143258571624756,
-0.8167471289634705,
-0.762833297252655,
-0.7818541526794434,
-0.3892597556114197,
0.3057122230529785,
-0.149044468998909,
-0.11401434987783432,
0.060350172221660614,
-0.5638828873634338,
0.32083839178085327,
-0.06630770862102509,
-0.16777721047401428,
0.20550820231437683,
0.07207394391298294,
0.1565777063369751,
-0.29711997509002686,
-0.3050079047679901,
-0.6193116307258606,
0.3246701657772064,
0.13312698900699615,
0.9708065390586853,
0.19760964810848236,
0.6713599562644958,
0.5551807880401611,
0.7293263077735901,
-0.8467949032783508,
0.6073623895645142,
0.1649208515882492,
-0.6832296252250671,
-0.12949781119823456,
-0.38526490330696106,
-1.0336120128631592,
0.2905054986476898,
-0.18658435344696045,
-1.1937353610992432,
0.6620543003082275,
-0.20166440308094025,
-0.35150250792503357,
0.3445332646369934,
-0.27115046977996826,
0.5263419151306152,
0.10092967003583908,
-0.3044532537460327,
-0.302482008934021,
-0.7615156173706055,
0.5199596285820007,
-0.1120561733841896,
0.5548107624053955,
-0.5225487947463989,
-0.2965431809425354,
0.47827982902526855,
-0.12433129549026489,
0.8148384690284729,
-0.392258882522583,
-0.16679918766021729,
0.4021005928516388,
0.3555660843849182,
0.00846252404153347,
-0.1944451481103897,
-0.5854225158691406,
0.0381961353123188,
0.2683199644088745,
-0.48557987809181213,
-0.558324933052063,
0.785045862197876,
-0.8952860832214355,
-0.5440343618392944,
-0.2143443375825882,
-0.3882856070995331,
-0.030885573476552963,
-0.2552783787250519,
0.24792183935642242,
0.0392320416867733,
-0.5193703174591064,
0.01573067158460617,
0.06600318849086761,
-0.30416929721832275,
0.17408135533332825,
0.38229435682296753,
-0.5888411998748779,
-0.4074004292488098,
0.6634696125984192,
0.5014453530311584,
-0.09626636654138565,
-0.05213819071650505,
0.07630112767219543,
-0.2228274643421173,
-0.17954915761947632,
-0.7830298542976379,
0.23069226741790771,
-0.527217447757721,
0.04763849452137947,
-0.5938817262649536,
0.19351260364055634,
-0.4773441255092621,
-0.3308294713497162,
-0.2132449597120285,
-0.5468322038650513,
-0.4449552893638611,
0.005203279200941324,
0.023649992421269417,
0.49727416038513184,
-0.04957304894924164,
0.1444096565246582,
-0.9245165586471558,
0.3225685656070709,
-0.061236876994371414,
-0.01581464894115925,
-0.5308910608291626,
-0.8038990497589111,
-0.3272959589958191,
0.124565988779068,
-0.3005049526691437,
-1.4983218908309937,
0.6366495490074158,
-0.0881100445985794,
0.24420307576656342,
0.24098065495491028,
0.4804867208003998,
0.4732016921043396,
-0.23110802471637726,
0.9577463269233704,
-0.1099986732006073,
-0.6839383244514465,
0.5140213370323181,
-0.5358479619026184,
0.019858092069625854,
0.7613514065742493,
0.8282080292701721,
-0.6076388359069824,
-0.38954561948776245,
-0.6954033970832825,
-0.7117801308631897,
0.5850841403007507,
-0.0644516870379448,
0.49528664350509644,
-0.17063561081886292,
0.5067903399467468,
0.012830166146159172,
0.2668147683143616,
-0.5058487057685852,
-0.04110966622829437,
0.04582813382148743,
0.006679603364318609,
-0.1766255795955658,
-0.39610257744789124,
-0.06416323035955429,
-0.7740908861160278,
0.4891425371170044,
0.13413859903812408,
0.08892715722322464,
0.3640579581260681,
-0.24314150214195251,
-0.39170145988464355,
0.3509431481361389,
0.5208980441093445,
0.6418418884277344,
0.06274111568927765,
0.5170360803604126,
0.33659687638282776,
-0.18082697689533234,
0.7791954874992371,
-0.0475468747317791,
-0.2097761631011963,
0.3945552408695221,
-0.056427594274282455,
0.6718634963035583,
0.08093752712011337,
-0.42373141646385193,
0.6878678798675537,
0.1620291769504547,
-0.5501619577407837,
-0.24753957986831665,
-0.0808241218328476,
-0.006603786256164312,
0.47886884212493896,
0.1302562952041626,
0.06727477163076401,
0.5289122462272644,
-0.868830680847168,
0.03767542541027069,
0.3532825708389282,
-0.6529530882835388,
-0.8212524652481079,
0.2758511006832123,
0.3489939570426941,
-0.4528173804283142,
0.23454493284225464,
-0.3645016551017761,
-0.7685022354125977,
0.34926238656044006,
0.4454933702945709,
0.8069599866867065,
-0.4833698868751526,
0.7434937357902527,
0.3847576379776001,
0.3754781484603882,
0.10787402838468552,
0.39221063256263733,
-0.06976322829723358,
-0.6634867191314697,
-0.5438472032546997,
-0.6866458058357239,
-0.17962217330932617,
-0.1202554777264595,
-0.910488486289978,
0.25986284017562866,
-0.06507596373558044,
-0.43740853667259216,
-0.21235448122024536,
0.014993082731962204,
-0.385139137506485,
0.215998575091362,
0.5583956837654114,
0.6911303997039795,
-1.2920957803726196,
0.3253032863140106,
0.9969675540924072,
-0.04358869045972824,
-0.1961819976568222,
0.01726105622947216,
0.42827755212783813,
-0.1756020039319992,
0.8755618333816528,
0.27048829197883606,
-0.3139893114566803,
0.1334354281425476,
-0.41711995005607605,
-0.6373711824417114,
0.19686803221702576,
0.8174375891685486,
-0.11990810185670853,
0.004988430067896843,
0.42133644223213196,
0.6847781538963318,
-0.15237845480442047,
-0.1241929829120636,
0.7410508990287781,
0.6217151284217834,
-0.03392167389392853,
-0.5563706159591675,
-0.16613736748695374,
-0.45951756834983826,
-0.1942535787820816,
0.34374523162841797,
-0.6366152167320251,
0.7967807054519653,
0.06533219665288925,
-0.5134199857711792,
-0.2675453722476959,
0.16082923114299774,
-0.5188278555870056,
0.33270272612571716,
0.49597597122192383,
0.4664049446582794,
0.47182658314704895,
-0.0011466993018984795,
0.7976523637771606,
-0.35351240634918213,
0.4034172594547272,
0.5430464744567871,
-0.2740980088710785,
0.3659851551055908,
0.4504062831401825,
-0.2790268361568451,
0.786504864692688,
0.4056699872016907,
0.22949814796447754,
0.34672752022743225,
0.5585373640060425,
-0.645972728729248,
-0.04802709072828293,
-0.35531356930732727,
-0.0957341343164444,
0.7836653590202332,
0.16869260370731354,
-0.3916879892349243,
-0.8525171875953674,
0.5173063278198242,
0.07449295371770859,
0.05472389608621597,
-0.4998137056827545,
0.8779135942459106,
0.013011716306209564,
-0.43993476033210754,
0.604350209236145,
0.11921930313110352,
0.2007436603307724,
0.1709810048341751,
0.11692387610673904,
-0.24373739957809448,
-0.11511460691690445,
-0.2703802287578583,
-0.6505580544471741,
1.0301364660263062,
0.12379412353038788,
-0.21998825669288635,
-0.11813755333423615,
1.0558152198791504,
-0.4387904703617096,
-0.8289234638214111,
0.34633901715278625,
1.0378986597061157,
0.7344813346862793,
-0.2120460569858551,
-0.7601498365402222,
0.2978784441947937,
0.14300689101219177,
-0.4857105016708374,
0.40105515718460083,
0.6747239232063293,
-0.1622416079044342,
0.42376142740249634,
0.34481045603752136,
0.4316316843032837,
-0.022027822211384773,
-0.12478575855493546,
1.1196250915527344,
-0.7182129621505737,
-0.35429808497428894,
-1.3596525192260742,
0.6037041544914246,
0.08903669565916061,
-0.1295836716890335,
0.7193997502326965,
0.5941017270088196,
0.3673255443572998,
0.009679427370429039,
0.5726758241653442,
0.018832899630069733,
0.7342937588691711,
-0.033743493258953094,
0.7213072776794434,
-0.5164594650268555,
-0.2709316313266754,
-0.6599176526069641,
-0.9419478178024292,
-0.4617719054222107,
0.6447107195854187,
-0.6634010076522827,
-0.40945756435394287,
0.19418209791183472,
1.1005547046661377,
0.07440480589866638,
-0.335805207490921,
0.4399101436138153,
0.12815415859222412,
-0.20429101586341858,
0.20563040673732758,
1.1763238906860352,
0.05118725821375847,
0.2554541230201721,
-0.2145870178937912,
0.008732510730624199,
-0.23472411930561066,
-0.7605133056640625,
-0.611214816570282,
-0.6211602091789246,
-0.34981754422187805,
-0.44116857647895813,
0.07208835333585739,
0.7016292810440063,
0.4502675533294678,
-0.38918885588645935,
0.1425974816083908,
0.2823841869831085,
0.12998545169830322,
0.47965627908706665,
-0.23018865287303925,
-0.008128355257213116,
-0.20640528202056885,
-0.6588161587715149,
-0.03400386869907379,
0.39696305990219116,
0.12969563901424408,
-0.714130699634552,
0.22917157411575317,
0.04808879643678665,
0.2999207079410553,
0.7453060746192932,
0.1431194245815277,
-0.5025957822799683,
-0.2811189293861389,
-0.2657248079776764,
-0.16536657512187958,
0.1665315181016922,
0.5597459077835083,
-1.054429531097412,
0.2470998466014862,
0.5168468356132507,
0.4786960184574127,
0.4793989956378937,
0.6596917510032654,
-0.0278317891061306,
-0.44248026609420776,
0.7487485408782959,
0.4761849343776703,
0.06972469389438629,
0.5187526941299438,
-0.45918703079223633,
0.3734714388847351,
0.5293411016464233,
-0.342236191034317,
-1.0158724784851074,
0.06118441000580788,
-0.6825496554374695,
-0.10620731860399246,
1.1879957914352417,
0.007554840296506882,
-0.48223599791526794,
-0.42828992009162903,
-0.49944227933883667,
0.26073819398880005,
-0.20635388791561127,
1.130987286567688,
0.5799860954284668,
0.02059478498995304,
-0.16079486906528473,
-0.5549620985984802,
0.257600873708725,
0.24539512395858765,
-0.8162701725959778,
-0.10027756541967392,
0.792730987071991,
0.06589760631322861,
0.31460362672805786,
0.6749977469444275,
-0.1465393751859665,
-0.03296559676527977,
-0.04256162792444229,
0.08974665403366089,
0.23854880034923553,
-0.35822319984436035,
-0.26078104972839355,
0.29911431670188904,
-0.2547655999660492,
-0.020218346267938614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07017v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07017v3
|
Improving Language Model Reasoning with Self-motivated Learning
| 2024-04-10T14:05:44 | 2024-04-30T14:38:59 |
Yunlong Feng, Yang Xu, Libo Qin, Yasheng Wang, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large-scale high-quality training data is important for improving the
performance of models. After trained with data that has rationales (reasoning
steps), models gain reasoning capability. However, the dataset with
high-quality rationales is relatively scarce due to the high annotation cost.
To address this issue, we propose \textit{Self-motivated Learning} framework.
The framework motivates the model itself to automatically generate rationales
on existing datasets. Based on the inherent rank from correctness across
multiple rationales, the model learns to generate better rationales, leading to
higher reasoning capability. Specifically, we train a reward model with the
rank to evaluate the quality of rationales, and improve the performance of
reasoning through reinforcement learning. Experiment results of Llama2 7B on
multiple reasoning datasets show that our method significantly improves the
reasoning ability of models, even outperforming text-davinci-002 in some
datasets.
|
[
-0.12983210384845734,
-0.3319512903690338,
0.841701865196228,
0.1987859308719635,
-0.010881522670388222,
-0.08526149392127991,
-0.2649182379245758,
-0.1139383390545845,
-0.04997844249010086,
0.6250826716423035,
-0.3710111975669861,
-0.3236422836780548,
-0.5690694451332092,
0.173239603638649,
-0.06536871939897537,
0.6818117499351501,
-0.0608011856675148,
0.16826628148555756,
-0.23105038702487946,
-0.16722561419010162,
-0.4904886484146118,
-0.8212113976478577,
-0.7231108546257019,
-0.3785085678100586,
0.8022506237030029,
0.42834311723709106,
0.321743905544281,
0.9390553832054138,
0.24503639340400696,
0.32391178607940674,
0.12647521495819092,
0.2896900773048401,
-0.5503111481666565,
0.5282277464866638,
-0.3527536392211914,
-0.5196354389190674,
-0.10464739054441452,
0.2844253182411194,
0.4026297926902771,
0.3412868082523346,
-0.2240905463695526,
-0.038347117602825165,
-0.16905058920383453,
0.6854767203330994,
-0.4027136266231537,
0.32748138904571533,
-0.5513037443161011,
-0.24285711348056793,
-0.0734015703201294,
-0.43161091208457947,
-0.6467489004135132,
-0.25070640444755554,
-0.24602645635604858,
-0.6699591279029846,
-0.17844589054584503,
0.12159456312656403,
0.6039889454841614,
0.5135695934295654,
-0.4954011142253876,
-0.2608688473701477,
-0.500164270401001,
0.9236885905265808,
-0.6942763924598694,
0.372019499540329,
0.5178027749061584,
0.4189457297325134,
-0.17915621399879456,
-0.4213098883628845,
-0.3974178731441498,
-0.4069842994213104,
-0.0008001327514648438,
-0.05889414995908737,
0.31677234172821045,
-0.14320014417171478,
0.6459092497825623,
0.21389339864253998,
-0.4710131287574768,
0.0754685252904892,
-0.09771554917097092,
-0.12967191636562347,
0.9081582427024841,
0.02970227785408497,
0.13338841497898102,
-0.26449137926101685,
-0.1490064263343811,
-0.39694470167160034,
-0.7644320130348206,
0.2873622179031372,
0.41010215878486633,
0.23445028066635132,
0.4589187800884247,
0.5245588421821594,
-0.6334277391433716,
0.681818962097168,
-0.0388566330075264,
-0.40033867955207825,
0.18152689933776855,
-0.06675052642822266,
-0.041868314146995544,
0.06810017675161362,
0.45943769812583923,
0.0625440701842308,
0.293395459651947,
-0.06903119385242462,
-0.4679861068725586,
0.17331703007221222,
0.12009736895561218,
-0.8724403381347656,
-0.38371843099594116,
0.334654301404953,
-0.432413786649704,
-0.30034229159355164,
-0.21654115617275238,
-0.26378944516181946,
-0.3236508369445801,
-0.7253166437149048,
0.4368343651294708,
-0.4624392092227936,
-0.48298022150993347,
0.29558178782463074,
-0.08595667779445648,
0.0057485951110720634,
0.7120364904403687,
-1.2876474857330322,
-0.13466158509254456,
0.5895899534225464,
0.441834032535553,
-0.16218170523643494,
-0.28208234906196594,
-0.6817813515663147,
0.19032691419124603,
-0.5983604192733765,
1.020922064781189,
-0.5961453914642334,
-0.007670062594115734,
-0.2594183087348938,
-0.21463674306869507,
-0.17264509201049805,
-0.6198883056640625,
0.512955904006958,
-0.3947674036026001,
0.27899521589279175,
-0.5775417685508728,
-0.794285774230957,
-0.2871960401535034,
0.34211069345474243,
-0.5917211174964905,
1.11619234085083,
0.20763526856899261,
-0.2853936553001404,
0.4468172490596771,
-0.6873855590820312,
-0.2701037526130676,
0.10071504861116409,
-0.26627594232559204,
-0.0151707474142313,
0.0733933374285698,
0.43921294808387756,
0.39898669719696045,
-0.34424546360969543,
0.653233528137207,
-0.3824869990348816,
-0.001586240017786622,
0.19272801280021667,
-0.2971844971179962,
0.6400448679924011,
0.2841643691062927,
-0.33163660764694214,
0.321492463350296,
-0.6861973404884338,
0.14055107533931732,
0.2637895345687866,
-0.3856201171875,
-0.38441282510757446,
0.06939434260129929,
-0.4756985306739807,
0.6141097545623779,
0.028796391561627388,
-0.30936938524246216,
0.4849114716053009,
-0.41249164938926697,
0.26837947964668274,
0.8238146901130676,
0.03611668199300766,
0.45900198817253113,
-0.2929040491580963,
0.4655503034591675,
0.06430290639400482,
0.02158946730196476,
-0.2638418972492218,
-0.34508270025253296,
-0.9667752385139465,
-0.2637244760990143,
0.40592554211616516,
0.4388963282108307,
-0.6647131443023682,
0.3809530436992645,
0.04582061991095543,
-0.4309993088245392,
-0.5462915301322937,
0.35764822363853455,
0.16974376142024994,
0.5303806066513062,
0.5180355906486511,
0.13665053248405457,
-0.34080860018730164,
-0.6612856984138489,
-0.22929440438747406,
-0.22838649153709412,
0.17678202688694,
0.2282497137784958,
0.4932468831539154,
-0.06749258935451508,
0.849156379699707,
-0.25766393542289734,
-0.1276412010192871,
-0.2893293499946594,
0.33241650462150574,
0.14829805493354797,
0.7815014719963074,
0.4580923616886139,
-0.6561343669891357,
-0.24622249603271484,
-0.16584065556526184,
-0.9047298431396484,
-0.17334827780723572,
-0.27738669514656067,
-0.44387534260749817,
0.3072981834411621,
0.5040947794914246,
-0.47459471225738525,
0.16503922641277313,
0.26722943782806396,
-0.34758123755455017,
0.48055362701416016,
-0.15048794448375702,
0.3500118553638458,
-0.7959517240524292,
-0.12574011087417603,
-0.008267535828053951,
-0.2144549936056137,
-0.3476622700691223,
-0.15681712329387665,
-0.059300754219293594,
-0.03405298292636871,
-0.17014336585998535,
0.6229496002197266,
-0.18800440430641174,
0.046503279358148575,
-0.3308907151222229,
-0.07282780855894089,
0.06166087090969086,
0.6311764121055603,
0.40219196677207947,
0.7862306833267212,
0.5892845392227173,
-0.6099545955657959,
0.4665817618370056,
0.1501646637916565,
-0.3566746413707733,
0.30577898025512695,
-0.5912314057350159,
-0.06821317970752716,
-0.1018647626042366,
0.09635579586029053,
-0.9068491458892822,
-0.4857468008995056,
0.1154961958527565,
-0.33981114625930786,
0.09096873551607132,
-0.07957221567630768,
-0.6461576223373413,
-0.11064597219228745,
0.13864180445671082,
0.2789004147052765,
0.33214452862739563,
-1.0622889995574951,
0.5220762491226196,
0.228130042552948,
-0.1771247535943985,
-0.474357545375824,
-0.33362334966659546,
-0.09867899119853973,
-0.22977915406227112,
-0.5166863203048706,
0.062241531908512115,
-0.23085379600524902,
-0.17134247720241547,
-0.13620588183403015,
-0.14665137231349945,
0.20762857794761658,
0.2878427505493164,
-0.022678690031170845,
0.08100152015686035,
-0.11967656016349792,
0.6055018901824951,
0.22191430628299713,
-0.39880436658859253,
0.30061259865760803,
-0.36702635884284973,
0.42335397005081177,
-0.18183957040309906,
-0.42550891637802124,
-0.43503448367118835,
0.2889377772808075,
0.3844190239906311,
-0.3799247145652771,
0.659500777721405,
0.2021888643503189,
-0.2773520350456238,
-0.30101916193962097,
-0.6750122904777527,
-0.3445931673049927,
-0.46038585901260376,
0.08548780530691147,
-0.5899576544761658,
-1.0795916318893433,
0.24254271388053894,
-0.2935071587562561,
-0.04962432011961937,
0.5828742384910583,
0.6958038806915283,
-0.0840148851275444,
1.6221654415130615,
0.260980486869812,
0.12258122861385345,
0.34190833568573,
-0.10118715465068817,
0.25624319911003113,
-0.4458859860897064,
-0.456266850233078,
-0.41500914096832275,
0.09703588485717773,
-0.4117184281349182,
-0.3739115297794342,
-0.01614704355597496,
0.38440051674842834,
-0.4364822804927826,
0.14674782752990723,
-0.658019483089447,
0.5243896842002869,
0.6240227222442627,
-0.07412447780370712,
0.2559535503387451,
0.01574801281094551,
-0.23843485116958618,
0.02964981272816658,
-0.7200813293457031,
-0.6947011351585388,
1.0143319368362427,
0.3269801437854767,
0.6947874426841736,
0.24249795079231262,
0.9043539762496948,
0.26594287157058716,
0.4700618088245392,
-0.6301783323287964,
0.4474738836288452,
0.2992190718650818,
-0.5619718432426453,
-0.4465586841106415,
-0.7599440217018127,
-0.6946679353713989,
0.35725000500679016,
-0.19373853504657745,
-0.5814138650894165,
0.2059537023305893,
0.39516332745552063,
-0.2076696753501892,
-0.10140213370323181,
-0.7007887363433838,
1.2118053436279297,
-0.7083369493484497,
-0.3617129623889923,
-0.42854708433151245,
-0.2536594569683075,
0.4039929509162903,
0.1318238377571106,
0.0016324932221323252,
-0.46735450625419617,
0.31230872869491577,
0.6940385103225708,
-0.4291638135910034,
0.46127668023109436,
-0.2736324667930603,
-0.1750640869140625,
0.1773284375667572,
0.25253522396087646,
0.3303907811641693,
0.2655816376209259,
-0.3334760069847107,
-0.06251657754182816,
-0.1272050142288208,
-0.5932775735855103,
-1.0023633241653442,
0.708344042301178,
-0.6699841022491455,
-0.9832200407981873,
-0.5497205257415771,
-0.616898775100708,
-0.2637424170970917,
0.07950334995985031,
-0.05438012629747391,
0.4219413995742798,
0.2230185717344284,
0.1758066713809967,
0.7600916624069214,
0.027266662567853928,
0.2516811192035675,
0.28155410289764404,
-0.3699701428413391,
-0.46954649686813354,
0.9306554794311523,
0.056155696511268616,
0.3564084768295288,
0.24557362496852875,
0.2767859101295471,
-0.6941291093826294,
-0.3026500940322876,
-0.6748453974723816,
0.16953237354755402,
-0.9615948796272278,
-0.19596122205257416,
-0.5794026255607605,
-0.1107596904039383,
-0.6021566987037659,
-0.005692196544259787,
-0.3495914340019226,
-0.7004984617233276,
-0.2415619045495987,
-0.13377273082733154,
0.39617446064949036,
0.6798551082611084,
-0.15711380541324615,
0.12007003277540207,
-0.4105437994003296,
0.17295488715171814,
0.6182653903961182,
0.2172461301088333,
0.09010352194309235,
-0.6680651307106018,
-0.1920115053653717,
-0.0956864058971405,
-0.13860011100769043,
-0.697999894618988,
0.5181767344474792,
-0.17719435691833496,
0.8926621675491333,
0.3221546411514282,
0.027627995237708092,
0.46517065167427063,
-0.16389168798923492,
0.4707256555557251,
0.17082609236240387,
-1.0022969245910645,
0.885736882686615,
-0.3537800908088684,
0.2281985580921173,
0.48945948481559753,
0.42609164118766785,
-0.2210363745689392,
-0.2519010901451111,
-0.7596986293792725,
-0.5474372506141663,
0.721242368221283,
0.14445056021213531,
-0.12407826632261276,
-0.02761809155344963,
0.5704169869422913,
-0.007826642133295536,
0.1298804134130478,
-1.1022660732269287,
-0.02125926874577999,
-0.6193394064903259,
-0.3092907667160034,
-0.030600611120462418,
-0.3459869623184204,
-0.1077488586306572,
-0.5218851566314697,
1.150978922843933,
-0.5248906016349792,
0.051681485027074814,
0.1313169151544571,
-0.15392325818538666,
-0.007256493903696537,
0.2036050707101822,
0.4598753750324249,
0.588959276676178,
-0.0229925736784935,
0.09610355645418167,
-0.06990159302949905,
0.35704004764556885,
0.43560224771499634,
0.11498018354177475,
0.0650411993265152,
-0.2982379198074341,
0.13282376527786255,
0.9662767052650452,
-0.08328858762979507,
-0.7423120141029358,
0.4255385100841522,
-0.07211162149906158,
-0.08866313099861145,
-0.23387296497821808,
0.5231349468231201,
0.22761136293411255,
0.3252696990966797,
0.3165508508682251,
0.030253197997808456,
0.08424709737300873,
-0.3154051899909973,
0.11552073061466217,
0.16617394983768463,
-0.05649262294173241,
0.135992169380188,
0.5605098605155945,
0.2112155556678772,
-0.20132094621658325,
0.6708579659461975,
-0.36706045269966125,
-0.6083902716636658,
0.46399959921836853,
0.7461410164833069,
0.3589603304862976,
-0.3315582275390625,
0.35133349895477295,
0.8356926441192627,
0.1957397609949112,
-0.7049096822738647,
0.1250811070203781,
-0.30747807025909424,
-0.7777099013328552,
-0.817365288734436,
-0.5375859141349792,
-0.5084996223449707,
0.05801556259393692,
-0.4235990345478058,
0.2120416909456253,
-0.35749319195747375,
0.022844018414616585,
-0.13743318617343903,
-0.07558130472898483,
-0.2365078181028366,
0.4014592170715332,
0.20340050756931305,
0.8513340353965759,
-0.7958444356918335,
1.0217734575271606,
0.4200116693973541,
-0.781517744064331,
-1.0690698623657227,
-0.21241140365600586,
-0.30304601788520813,
-0.5097607374191284,
1.0455138683319092,
0.551437497138977,
-0.11943530291318893,
0.24481739103794098,
-0.708255410194397,
-1.2439842224121094,
0.8342294692993164,
0.5803402662277222,
-0.4369421601295471,
0.233250230550766,
-0.06720753014087677,
0.49729883670806885,
-0.7394734621047974,
0.3028171956539154,
0.5113251209259033,
0.4716559052467346,
0.1492311656475067,
-0.40749090909957886,
-0.06950947642326355,
-0.32082599401474,
-0.06081879138946533,
0.0016743058804422617,
-0.3375193774700165,
0.7190695405006409,
-0.22443076968193054,
-0.05251461640000343,
0.009757830761373043,
0.8883396983146667,
0.6988617181777954,
0.12414713948965073,
0.5886154174804688,
0.712160050868988,
1.0066651105880737,
-0.2400006204843521,
1.1202181577682495,
-0.19923679530620575,
0.4329202473163605,
0.9601698517799377,
-0.42942729592323303,
0.8303388357162476,
0.28055816888809204,
0.26804810762405396,
0.9555816650390625,
0.8421987295150757,
-0.06650581955909729,
0.47248145937919617,
0.1070513054728508,
-0.1702367514371872,
-1.151145100593567,
-0.08682716637849808,
-0.23244479298591614,
0.4309726357460022,
0.3813939094543457,
-0.2676551342010498,
-0.1361701786518097,
0.09411592781543732,
-0.1837625503540039,
0.4049479365348816,
-0.15189270675182343,
0.6093645691871643,
-0.0897795632481575,
-1.1020417213439941,
0.6956675052642822,
-0.04870198294520378,
0.1772095113992691,
-0.4767494797706604,
-0.2242880016565323,
-0.1378331035375595,
0.0622461773455143,
-0.07387164235115051,
-0.45883414149284363,
0.09314198791980743,
-0.09819912165403366,
-0.2920584976673126,
-0.6233103275299072,
0.6362224221229553,
-0.5667263269424438,
-0.4183783531188965,
0.31498897075653076,
0.5755876302719116,
0.15938331186771393,
-0.10639046132564545,
-0.8675104379653931,
0.0013761892914772034,
-0.007807659450918436,
-0.49064895510673523,
0.38762810826301575,
0.5335749983787537,
-0.055590443313121796,
0.8762874603271484,
1.0110749006271362,
-0.0995861366391182,
-0.2679671347141266,
0.2894913852214813,
0.8474531769752502,
-0.7851181030273438,
-0.615002453327179,
-0.7431811094284058,
0.34452831745147705,
-0.3772338628768921,
-0.30903565883636475,
0.6274874806404114,
0.5993481874465942,
0.8791576623916626,
0.011434023268520832,
0.6955872178077698,
0.09376125782728195,
0.6691569685935974,
-0.6815525889396667,
0.32599255442619324,
-0.675055742263794,
0.35589784383773804,
0.25779372453689575,
-0.6954772472381592,
-0.3552606999874115,
1.1348382234573364,
-0.5874991416931152,
0.07104809582233429,
0.6704269051551819,
0.8289046883583069,
0.2148568481206894,
0.0684698075056076,
0.39461567997932434,
0.021387381479144096,
0.34314271807670593,
0.43474775552749634,
1.154140830039978,
-0.13250456750392914,
0.2767443358898163,
-0.36287376284599304,
-0.22542349994182587,
-0.1488235592842102,
-0.9355279207229614,
-1.003385305404663,
-0.5539141893386841,
-0.3756219148635864,
-0.4426339864730835,
0.0007848389795981348,
1.3099370002746582,
0.9074052572250366,
-0.8937555551528931,
-0.23569916188716888,
-0.27953457832336426,
0.3110213875770569,
-0.31914642453193665,
-0.23470234870910645,
0.18209242820739746,
-0.948007345199585,
-0.6224562525749207,
0.6017276644706726,
0.40439972281455994,
-0.06471100449562073,
-0.35651490092277527,
-0.3540596663951874,
-0.35159730911254883,
0.11769959330558777,
0.6147115230560303,
0.2866671681404114,
-0.8429292440414429,
-0.34083640575408936,
-0.05086531490087509,
-0.2561085522174835,
0.18346120417118073,
0.8702410459518433,
-0.9018058776855469,
0.2897934317588806,
0.45959794521331787,
0.7418745756149292,
0.43791908025741577,
0.13658608496189117,
0.5380178689956665,
-0.27109482884407043,
-0.05486931651830673,
0.3121209740638733,
0.5277209281921387,
0.4938547909259796,
-0.4725227952003479,
0.6606935262680054,
0.32414230704307556,
-0.8010013103485107,
-0.7609317302703857,
0.31349194049835205,
-0.8785420060157776,
-0.38988012075424194,
1.2668473720550537,
-0.22144053876399994,
-0.1447322517633438,
-0.042972631752491,
-0.26359739899635315,
0.16332204639911652,
-0.4659701883792877,
0.9591546654701233,
0.6889906525611877,
-0.4594455063343048,
-0.32333314418792725,
-0.33219555020332336,
0.671083390712738,
0.8588721752166748,
-1.1654306650161743,
0.24562637507915497,
0.6622493267059326,
0.276764839887619,
0.08434806764125824,
0.5691257119178772,
0.006489775609225035,
0.3708076477050781,
-0.150253564119339,
0.10440608859062195,
-0.10091403126716614,
-0.6113104224205017,
-0.2569074332714081,
0.2152194082736969,
0.3712676167488098,
0.24610882997512817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07009v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07009v3
|
A Mathematical Theory for Learning Semantic Languages by Abstract Learners
| 2024-04-10T13:50:46 | 2024-05-15T18:05:54 |
Kuo-Yu Liao, Cheng-Shang Chang, Y. -W. Peter Hong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT
|
Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated the
emergence of capabilities (learned skills) when the number of system parameters
and the size of training data surpass certain thresholds. The exact mechanisms
behind such phenomena are not fully understood and remain a topic of active
research. Inspired by the skill-text bipartite graph model proposed by Arora
and Goyal for modeling semantic languages, we develop a mathematical theory to
explain the emergence of learned skills, taking the learning (or training)
process into account. Our approach models the learning process for skills in
the skill-text bipartite graph as an iterative decoding process in Low-Density
Parity Check (LDPC) codes and Irregular Repetition Slotted ALOHA (IRSA). Using
density evolution analysis, we demonstrate the emergence of learned skills when
the ratio of the number of training texts to the number of skills exceeds a
certain threshold. Our analysis also yields a scaling law for testing errors
relative to this ratio. Upon completion of the training, the association of
learned skills can also be acquired to form a skill association graph. We use
site percolation analysis to derive the conditions for the existence of a giant
component in the skill association graph. Our analysis can also be extended to
the setting with a hierarchy of skills, where a fine-tuned model is built upon
a foundation model. It is also applicable to the setting with multiple classes
of skills and texts. As an important application, we propose a method for
semantic compression and discuss its connections to semantic communication.
|
[
-0.2710118889808655,
-1.0868723392486572,
0.47074824571609497,
0.15512509644031525,
-0.15279285609722137,
-0.08793040364980698,
-0.15559282898902893,
-0.38392314314842224,
0.1634325236082077,
0.5036700963973999,
-0.4813078045845032,
-0.346003919839859,
-0.7860845923423767,
0.20106768608093262,
-0.41561707854270935,
0.8018678426742554,
0.14319340884685516,
0.028697360306978226,
-0.09979473799467087,
-0.09478529542684555,
-0.46313804388046265,
-0.3355271816253662,
-0.7114983201026917,
-0.3156506419181824,
0.3916577994823456,
0.496722549200058,
0.5399810671806335,
0.7444162368774414,
0.22488704323768616,
0.297407865524292,
-0.17948904633522034,
-0.07281210273504257,
-0.6534813642501831,
-0.10164698213338852,
-0.10049693286418915,
-0.554803729057312,
-0.27011141180992126,
-0.09099384397268295,
0.9323620796203613,
1.3312970399856567,
-0.2006864845752716,
-0.17327101528644562,
0.1469593346118927,
0.5534151196479797,
-0.2076612412929535,
0.4942644238471985,
-0.9018148183822632,
0.026035893708467484,
-0.002297335769981146,
-0.40304145216941833,
-0.4211490750312805,
-0.04905136674642563,
0.24790041148662567,
-0.6401253938674927,
0.3284764587879181,
-0.22881433367729187,
0.6554916501045227,
0.012228315696120262,
-0.34309670329093933,
-0.5500801205635071,
-0.5517178773880005,
0.7907808423042297,
-0.257902055978775,
0.27879422903060913,
0.588828444480896,
0.13158763945102692,
-0.36576586961746216,
-0.4330843389034271,
-0.7963641285896301,
-0.038184866309165955,
0.15497222542762756,
-0.12430951744318008,
0.2297714650630951,
-0.11574999988079071,
0.260293185710907,
0.2901563346385956,
-0.3801606595516205,
0.25117725133895874,
-0.48258790373802185,
0.08108527213335037,
0.4802688956260681,
0.15229766070842743,
0.6853299140930176,
-0.059901099652051926,
-0.33174532651901245,
-0.25771385431289673,
-0.8643161654472351,
0.0984855443239212,
0.4381040036678314,
0.5428299903869629,
-0.3715131878852844,
0.6493638157844543,
-0.14757046103477478,
0.749232292175293,
-0.46705490350723267,
-0.618132472038269,
0.19494539499282837,
-0.2681596279144287,
0.05305809900164604,
0.15765832364559174,
0.6052842140197754,
-0.2974563539028168,
0.5906305909156799,
-0.1920774281024933,
0.008818766102194786,
0.30975204706192017,
0.12938515841960907,
-0.6114333868026733,
-0.35696300864219666,
-0.17310960590839386,
-0.3697747588157654,
-0.46339768171310425,
-0.11113647371530533,
-0.4985720217227936,
-0.17763963341712952,
-0.3205287754535675,
0.4745646119117737,
-0.7392895817756653,
-0.4564662575721741,
0.4002838730812073,
-0.02415565587580204,
0.27124741673469543,
0.12840335071086884,
-1.1558265686035156,
0.545552134513855,
0.6583037972450256,
0.6138060688972473,
0.11128222942352295,
-0.6477928757667542,
-0.4188077449798584,
0.010968458838760853,
-0.2594289183616638,
0.6579378247261047,
-0.6489266157150269,
-0.30742010474205017,
0.11957993358373642,
-0.16906993091106415,
-0.10990351438522339,
-0.32442790269851685,
0.2812880575656891,
-0.7917899489402771,
-0.1862069070339203,
-0.054021287709474564,
-0.7215322852134705,
-0.23906615376472473,
-0.11894484609365463,
-0.6935094594955444,
0.7333221435546875,
0.33814430236816406,
-0.6751133799552917,
0.5120776295661926,
-0.4235188066959381,
-0.42819705605506897,
0.4215911030769348,
-0.3075701594352722,
-0.3657091557979584,
0.09569226950407028,
-0.2927309274673462,
0.5026434659957886,
-0.21818003058433533,
-0.11169125139713287,
-0.43166986107826233,
-0.05297836661338806,
0.3043661415576935,
-0.2252846211194992,
1.127256155014038,
-0.07616747915744781,
-0.05089564248919487,
-0.2832658290863037,
-0.9712091684341431,
0.24850597977638245,
0.284579336643219,
-0.5639123916625977,
-0.31737756729125977,
0.1825268715620041,
-0.46361446380615234,
0.2992132902145386,
0.054377418011426926,
-0.3962361812591553,
0.015876173973083496,
-0.5771083831787109,
0.5634905099868774,
0.5965946912765503,
0.171512633562088,
0.45700615644454956,
0.019155781716108322,
0.10807369649410248,
0.05825807899236679,
-0.1621088981628418,
-0.09574424475431442,
-0.5616263151168823,
-0.686351478099823,
-0.2522544264793396,
0.2754608690738678,
0.5139667391777039,
-0.7321090698242188,
0.7324604988098145,
-0.45537400245666504,
-0.2262565642595291,
-0.18115763366222382,
0.6325377821922302,
0.38215431571006775,
0.31008180975914,
0.2530427873134613,
-0.5105685591697693,
-0.2031581848859787,
-0.5628935694694519,
0.35038647055625916,
-0.24463967978954315,
0.10120930522680283,
0.18788035213947296,
0.522952675819397,
-0.1262631118297577,
0.9136581420898438,
-0.38398227095603943,
-0.12117674201726913,
-0.24168598651885986,
0.0945994034409523,
0.06293047964572906,
0.493397057056427,
0.38520628213882446,
-0.7113655209541321,
-0.33644524216651917,
0.06816032528877258,
-0.7981263399124146,
-0.09322254359722137,
0.21252977848052979,
-0.1088753193616867,
0.181607186794281,
0.3656699061393738,
-0.41165685653686523,
0.23827867209911346,
0.5232030749320984,
-0.4974595904350281,
0.4102422297000885,
-0.43168267607688904,
-0.41543442010879517,
-0.9638919830322266,
-0.17100836336612701,
-0.1735474169254303,
0.029260316863656044,
-0.6839953660964966,
0.18541912734508514,
-0.14013807475566864,
-0.2159014195203781,
-0.21284346282482147,
0.4786245822906494,
-0.34856662154197693,
-0.4090278744697571,
-0.3782281279563904,
0.3358006477355957,
-0.3275560736656189,
0.5731623768806458,
0.1530519425868988,
0.45688343048095703,
0.7191979289054871,
-0.8410992622375488,
0.20040373504161835,
0.25926563143730164,
-0.5375987887382507,
0.4281408190727234,
-0.6053718328475952,
-0.053885914385318756,
-0.19024944305419922,
-0.3047155737876892,
-0.9948371648788452,
-0.08679201453924179,
-0.07571247965097427,
-0.4760400652885437,
0.21487167477607727,
-0.2585681080818176,
-0.6719520688056946,
-0.08344633877277374,
0.17236274480819702,
0.41730064153671265,
0.5602701306343079,
-0.4762257933616638,
0.5087276697158813,
0.48869428038597107,
-0.24163565039634705,
-0.42615437507629395,
-0.21800486743450165,
-0.2219959795475006,
-0.11982220411300659,
-0.9155887365341187,
0.06944625079631805,
-0.006584346294403076,
-0.18910890817642212,
0.12982968986034393,
0.1904342621564865,
-0.29184478521347046,
0.463186651468277,
0.051453106105327606,
0.19547605514526367,
-0.14178527891635895,
0.36093562841415405,
0.11885616928339005,
-0.3642813563346863,
0.1294352263212204,
-0.46320295333862305,
0.7924624681472778,
-0.13224974274635315,
-0.06576751172542572,
-0.13007541000843048,
0.08300144970417023,
0.40764227509498596,
-0.18019862473011017,
1.111522912979126,
0.19179010391235352,
-0.1809387058019638,
-0.5457359552383423,
-0.20101916790008545,
-0.29696542024612427,
-0.441231906414032,
0.4985021650791168,
-0.6487016677856445,
-0.8166214823722839,
0.673188328742981,
0.013606664724647999,
-0.18632492423057556,
0.499376118183136,
0.551730215549469,
0.23006311058998108,
0.7439297437667847,
1.0311830043792725,
0.29983025789260864,
0.4370602071285248,
-0.5575851202011108,
0.10941962152719498,
-0.6434550285339355,
-0.2836940288543701,
-0.5148996710777283,
0.07434049993753433,
-0.4739152491092682,
-0.38723546266555786,
0.4082983434200287,
0.5751145482063293,
-0.3022480607032776,
0.23543715476989746,
-0.006618094630539417,
0.5041621327400208,
0.36203113198280334,
0.19884046912193298,
0.36344900727272034,
0.4442436099052429,
-0.31762710213661194,
0.160828098654747,
-0.7962695956230164,
-0.25737446546554565,
1.0448970794677734,
0.37162357568740845,
0.516790509223938,
0.2669086456298828,
0.6615594029426575,
0.06946484744548798,
-0.03238605707883835,
-0.8903799057006836,
0.6004714965820312,
-0.1834551990032196,
-0.1897588074207306,
-0.7258284687995911,
-0.6704162955284119,
-1.1494439840316772,
0.1340721696615219,
-0.5094342827796936,
-0.5005172491073608,
0.11749017238616943,
-0.12324444204568863,
0.13362526893615723,
0.16769443452358246,
-0.6975594758987427,
0.7026249170303345,
-0.047186292707920074,
-0.30010905861854553,
-0.4508931636810303,
-0.5470558404922485,
0.054900504648685455,
-0.2822754383087158,
0.1857781708240509,
-0.1601411998271942,
-0.10338737070560455,
0.6950146555900574,
-0.48346009850502014,
1.1482813358306885,
-0.07402850687503815,
-0.2605594992637634,
0.47069889307022095,
0.321183443069458,
0.5202422142028809,
-0.033358730375766754,
0.05019030719995499,
0.0420624203979969,
-0.11623650789260864,
-0.811303973197937,
-0.636527419090271,
0.44838351011276245,
-1.1227877140045166,
-0.15187868475914001,
0.008204150013625622,
-0.4589267373085022,
-0.17899756133556366,
0.390184223651886,
0.15277275443077087,
0.597165048122406,
0.07829420268535614,
0.034559376537799835,
1.0304991006851196,
-0.01105820294469595,
0.2816004753112793,
0.5389063954353333,
0.02821122668683529,
-0.24007554352283478,
1.1532843112945557,
0.28145602345466614,
0.5195686221122742,
0.2943008542060852,
0.31799933314323425,
0.0703117698431015,
-0.7506133913993835,
-0.05519837141036987,
0.5384082198143005,
-0.9238985180854797,
-0.0053605795837938786,
-0.5739752054214478,
-0.3287595808506012,
-0.29678088426589966,
-0.234323188662529,
-0.032961901277303696,
-0.4042587876319885,
-0.2031669169664383,
-0.05720632150769234,
0.35617804527282715,
0.7040064930915833,
0.03865974396467209,
0.4421633183956146,
-0.6080112457275391,
-0.023117950186133385,
0.4816909432411194,
0.3925868570804596,
0.34478649497032166,
-0.5486985445022583,
-0.3984605073928833,
-0.06199847534298897,
-0.1276496797800064,
-0.6207402944564819,
0.3978819251060486,
0.30058008432388306,
0.6990276575088501,
0.46099454164505005,
-0.3011607229709625,
0.29376333951950073,
-0.5993138551712036,
0.43814629316329956,
0.19805899262428284,
-0.8464305996894836,
0.24861645698547363,
-0.35328057408332825,
-0.1475941240787506,
0.30029210448265076,
0.5478634238243103,
-0.36995893716812134,
-0.1952064335346222,
-0.8678310513496399,
-0.6802419424057007,
0.5007285475730896,
0.07554848492145538,
0.3928876221179962,
-0.2768914997577667,
0.6443055868148804,
0.22548536956310272,
0.04342655465006828,
-0.7911463379859924,
0.010547946207225323,
-0.21865610778331757,
-0.2642403244972229,
-0.07385434210300446,
-0.5594493746757507,
-0.026124170050024986,
-0.05483902618288994,
0.4463231563568115,
-0.39103907346725464,
0.2314237654209137,
-0.10201873630285263,
-0.2196638137102127,
-0.02502785250544548,
0.17188765108585358,
0.45663437247276306,
0.8417814373970032,
0.12905313074588776,
0.21770119667053223,
0.09440361708402634,
-0.52872234582901,
0.08635853976011276,
-0.17378117144107819,
0.11543214321136475,
-0.5435996651649475,
0.7035681009292603,
0.8485022783279419,
0.395854651927948,
-0.7196940779685974,
0.42954856157302856,
0.29325294494628906,
-0.2726982533931732,
-0.3731222450733185,
0.2001674622297287,
-0.03387513756752014,
0.05485178157687187,
0.20798631012439728,
-0.40836507081985474,
-0.03384879231452942,
-0.7320486903190613,
0.21652090549468994,
0.39080438017845154,
-0.32012662291526794,
-0.3715440630912781,
0.09455026686191559,
0.13125312328338623,
-0.2569099962711334,
0.8726638555526733,
-0.30965545773506165,
-0.43300294876098633,
0.6073294878005981,
0.8075975179672241,
0.4863211512565613,
-0.1009785383939743,
0.25372543931007385,
0.2280208170413971,
0.1992698609828949,
-0.10716202110052109,
0.12384684383869171,
-0.18566961586475372,
-1.1562906503677368,
-0.6435878276824951,
-0.921807587146759,
-0.05071825534105301,
-0.10074867308139801,
-0.29039227962493896,
0.3073299527168274,
-0.4775151312351227,
0.18917405605316162,
0.2590394616127014,
0.16890263557434082,
-0.4645112454891205,
0.11159191280603409,
-0.005825611297041178,
0.7849137187004089,
-1.0846824645996094,
0.8684762716293335,
0.4297894537448883,
-0.4835100769996643,
-0.8934749364852905,
-0.3331204950809479,
-0.2533421516418457,
-1.2171733379364014,
1.1649338006973267,
-0.15514126420021057,
-0.018608516082167625,
0.3105849325656891,
-0.41908711194992065,
-0.8760147094726562,
0.807046115398407,
0.1378019154071808,
0.01082949060946703,
-0.15393061935901642,
0.22144465148448944,
0.5815414190292358,
-0.5766057372093201,
-0.11914775520563126,
0.38595330715179443,
-0.10463937371969223,
0.34695643186569214,
-0.5828601121902466,
-0.11887623369693756,
-0.1450096070766449,
0.21219401061534882,
0.413774311542511,
-0.3395316004753113,
0.971278965473175,
-0.1295626014471054,
-0.22227931022644043,
0.066090889275074,
0.5282652974128723,
0.058933280408382416,
-0.17602545022964478,
0.3466530740261078,
0.7410589456558228,
0.6833464503288269,
0.1393214911222458,
1.0389199256896973,
-0.3699905574321747,
0.4378802180290222,
0.6796988248825073,
-0.1766851842403412,
0.8708056211471558,
0.15245388448238373,
-0.2417871505022049,
0.874736487865448,
0.17609241604804993,
0.22719363868236542,
0.47207728028297424,
0.43848830461502075,
-0.3469499945640564,
-0.21730594336986542,
0.12362408638000488,
-0.04504845663905144,
0.29263073205947876,
0.6920919418334961,
-0.3570876717567444,
-0.33727967739105225,
0.17077943682670593,
-0.04865526407957077,
0.1179325133562088,
-0.42242711782455444,
0.9689992666244507,
0.0885927751660347,
-0.2598734498023987,
0.6009427309036255,
-0.06175268441438675,
0.23037299513816833,
-0.7421718835830688,
-0.19926095008850098,
0.16381999850273132,
0.01950610615313053,
-0.07402762025594711,
-0.8922740817070007,
0.1629444658756256,
-0.40422648191452026,
-0.3454616665840149,
0.06066002696752548,
0.6188035011291504,
-0.4131598472595215,
-0.4384675920009613,
0.3947966992855072,
0.424589067697525,
0.3327752947807312,
0.5159797072410583,
-0.4312271475791931,
0.045484282076358795,
-0.2997729778289795,
0.16597309708595276,
0.4209126830101013,
0.7669422030448914,
-0.0487312376499176,
0.5733150243759155,
0.6447692513465881,
0.34988027811050415,
0.3385935425758362,
-0.1252862513065338,
0.7289248704910278,
-0.38694095611572266,
-0.5910800695419312,
-0.7099255919456482,
0.23703674972057343,
-0.00696602463722229,
-0.19629839062690735,
0.49864253401756287,
0.24055548012256622,
0.9582215547561646,
0.10275514423847198,
0.5857234597206116,
-0.09396268427371979,
0.3240949213504791,
-0.8452763557434082,
0.5016631484031677,
-0.17290416359901428,
0.3121902346611023,
-0.18977107107639313,
-0.963167667388916,
-0.1783311814069748,
0.7900489568710327,
-0.43764281272888184,
0.08142648637294769,
0.7994731068611145,
0.6047419309616089,
0.042345546185970306,
0.03363540768623352,
0.44384366273880005,
0.2595427930355072,
0.21405215561389923,
0.6397534012794495,
0.45087605714797974,
-0.1531277447938919,
0.4216284155845642,
-0.3645116984844208,
-0.5435823798179626,
-0.09818653762340546,
-0.6429450511932373,
-1.0210778713226318,
-0.7962458729743958,
-0.161372572183609,
-0.6491568684577942,
-0.17346465587615967,
0.6427085995674133,
0.42224711179733276,
-0.35394230484962463,
-0.4614216387271881,
-0.45965322852134705,
0.31652846932411194,
-0.2932862341403961,
-0.22894041240215302,
0.4967508316040039,
-0.7777517437934875,
-0.4301701486110687,
0.07044482231140137,
0.23350977897644043,
0.21491487324237823,
-0.27174052596092224,
-0.200587660074234,
-0.038124553859233856,
0.05903593450784683,
0.7874696850776672,
0.5963413119316101,
-0.26412883400917053,
-0.17122069001197815,
-0.310810387134552,
-0.01029142178595066,
-0.14655523002147675,
0.8885048031806946,
-0.8436363339424133,
0.41719871759414673,
0.45727720856666565,
0.7017024755477905,
0.2512339651584625,
-0.4852854311466217,
0.23113635182380676,
-0.6007469296455383,
0.37331801652908325,
-0.15449675917625427,
0.298565536737442,
0.12667027115821838,
-0.1382916420698166,
0.4602046012878418,
0.6158323287963867,
-0.2647845149040222,
-0.8514439463615417,
0.4954318106174469,
-0.8118005990982056,
-0.32266664505004883,
1.0084117650985718,
-0.002350996946915984,
-0.42432326078414917,
-0.275468647480011,
0.1819872111082077,
0.1433144062757492,
0.026391124352812767,
0.9171192049980164,
0.6635350584983826,
-0.09094726294279099,
-0.03432413935661316,
-0.42818745970726013,
0.5179194211959839,
0.19067174196243286,
-0.6480123996734619,
0.0762411430478096,
0.24656429886817932,
0.41925033926963806,
0.42111736536026,
0.5481189489364624,
-0.26296764612197876,
0.42311057448387146,
0.3048080801963806,
-0.1141870990395546,
0.022476086392998695,
-0.5072919130325317,
-0.34074339270591736,
0.3178845942020416,
0.34750884771347046,
0.34919077157974243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07005v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07005v1
|
WordDecipher: Enhancing Digital Workspace Communication with Explainable AI for Non-native English Speakers
| 2024-04-10T13:40:29 | 2024-04-10T13:40:29 |
Yuexi Chen, Zhicheng Liu
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Non-native English speakers (NNES) face challenges in digital workspace
communication (e.g., emails, Slack messages), often inadvertently translating
expressions from their native languages, which can lead to awkward or incorrect
usage. Current AI-assisted writing tools are equipped with fluency enhancement
and rewriting suggestions; however, NNES may struggle to grasp the subtleties
among various expressions, making it challenging to choose the one that
accurately reflects their intent. Such challenges are exacerbated in high-stake
text-based communications, where the absence of non-verbal cues heightens the
risk of misinterpretation. By leveraging the latest advancements in large
language models (LLM) and word embeddings, we propose WordDecipher, an
explainable AI-assisted writing tool to enhance digital workspace communication
for NNES. WordDecipher not only identifies the perceived social intentions
detected in users' writing, but also generates rewriting suggestions aligned
with users' intended messages, either numerically or by inferring from users'
writing in their native language. Then, WordDecipher provides an overview of
nuances to help NNES make selections. Through a usage scenario, we demonstrate
how WordDecipher can significantly enhance an NNES's ability to communicate her
request, showcasing its potential to transform workspace communication for
NNES.
|
[
-0.38649341464042664,
-0.8235878348350525,
0.8270225524902344,
0.23678021132946014,
-0.42711547017097473,
0.3679756224155426,
-0.1778438240289688,
-0.5359290838241577,
0.5940648317337036,
0.28586241602897644,
-0.9146994948387146,
-0.7214032411575317,
-0.7677890658378601,
0.5877814888954163,
-0.6910361647605896,
0.9133279323577881,
-0.34701356291770935,
-0.45683562755584717,
-0.7784796953201294,
-0.0800873339176178,
-0.5645071268081665,
-0.14222921431064606,
-0.6424236297607422,
-0.23094797134399414,
0.20348180830478668,
0.7438755631446838,
0.8580454587936401,
0.2916502356529236,
0.37415269017219543,
0.28515130281448364,
-0.012010143138468266,
0.4713478088378906,
-0.4253827631473541,
-0.07759276032447815,
-0.05739791691303253,
-0.4460574984550476,
-0.42419296503067017,
-0.32427892088890076,
0.17743678390979767,
0.5726765394210815,
-0.16409027576446533,
-0.06692646443843842,
0.01628740318119526,
0.4098324179649353,
-0.41030406951904297,
0.2924124002456665,
-0.6082322001457214,
-0.006585267372429371,
0.07075846195220947,
0.015051702037453651,
-0.22890709340572357,
-0.2382112443447113,
-0.1758316606283188,
-1.1650227308273315,
0.09344515204429626,
-0.028225142508745193,
0.460836797952652,
0.43112075328826904,
-0.20749378204345703,
-0.35046398639678955,
-0.719435453414917,
0.35063639283180237,
-0.6282456517219543,
0.40840211510658264,
0.40900516510009766,
0.2932547628879547,
-0.10444072633981705,
-0.860856831073761,
-1.067482590675354,
0.05757211148738861,
0.175876647233963,
0.26051101088523865,
-0.320534884929657,
0.10588835179805756,
0.1355682611465454,
0.3862875998020172,
-0.36179104447364807,
0.15018443763256073,
-0.13069427013397217,
-0.2010728269815445,
0.5111019611358643,
0.3167375922203064,
0.45859476923942566,
0.1632748544216156,
-0.056663982570171356,
0.13223062455654144,
-0.297176718711853,
-0.2529720366001129,
0.13890758156776428,
0.16264189779758453,
-0.30291932821273804,
0.6238295435905457,
-0.05498264357447624,
0.4957728981971741,
0.003952293656766415,
0.24916714429855347,
0.06024886295199394,
-0.3083758056163788,
-0.08192674070596695,
0.08216466754674911,
0.5287152528762817,
0.5511788725852966,
0.22270019352436066,
-0.5568759441375732,
-0.10828012973070145,
0.5095056891441345,
0.30185648798942566,
-0.7842848300933838,
0.0006913248798809946,
0.3595306873321533,
-0.258067786693573,
-0.4708666503429413,
0.08439798653125763,
-0.532977283000946,
-0.7753508687019348,
-0.3501676321029663,
0.37541672587394714,
-0.30336394906044006,
-0.38258832693099976,
0.0845382884144783,
-0.5916516184806824,
-0.15211090445518494,
0.6708799600601196,
-0.6999860405921936,
0.5622261762619019,
0.7157904505729675,
1.047108769416809,
-0.1639532744884491,
-0.26299452781677246,
-0.3172377049922943,
0.08032937347888947,
-0.4135831296443939,
0.5914040803909302,
-0.7741417288780212,
-0.5785101056098938,
-0.04187185317277908,
0.03692430630326271,
0.060138583183288574,
-0.32273316383361816,
0.42768537998199463,
-0.20477381348609924,
0.26153838634490967,
-0.04276101291179657,
-0.49245065450668335,
-0.054797522723674774,
0.3376446068286896,
-0.5986281037330627,
0.7051827311515808,
0.14932669699192047,
-0.9804268479347229,
0.21705472469329834,
-0.9950447678565979,
-0.3643742799758911,
0.4788414537906647,
-0.21114803850650787,
-0.2522399425506592,
0.45705607533454895,
0.38413000106811523,
0.2725123167037964,
-0.05668144300580025,
0.05755520984530449,
-0.12121477723121643,
-0.5343176126480103,
0.16664136946201324,
-0.3420082628726959,
0.49155282974243164,
-0.03915271908044815,
-0.5403136014938354,
0.08454453945159912,
-0.4379992187023163,
-0.11842867732048035,
0.2799638509750366,
-0.012978619895875454,
-0.3585955798625946,
-0.011081110686063766,
0.05479932203888893,
0.17884649336338043,
0.5186281204223633,
-0.7367004156112671,
0.09834898263216019,
-0.5881588459014893,
0.7097203731536865,
0.5506489276885986,
-0.09310915321111679,
0.46796855330467224,
-0.40900933742523193,
0.7632601857185364,
-0.10238794982433319,
0.18656986951828003,
0.00905226357281208,
-0.5353278517723083,
-0.27603355050086975,
-0.2712390422821045,
-0.12771070003509521,
0.5792180299758911,
-1.2519804239273071,
-0.0790538415312767,
-0.5432928204536438,
-0.516213059425354,
-0.8153477311134338,
0.40958064794540405,
0.2661627233028412,
0.5066126585006714,
0.2677517831325531,
-0.041774578392505646,
-0.39593687653541565,
-0.9030430912971497,
-0.2512032091617584,
-0.19467753171920776,
0.03515148535370827,
0.5537688732147217,
0.39933404326438904,
-0.7750648260116577,
0.9100488424301147,
-0.4703216552734375,
-0.2557811439037323,
-0.7227938771247864,
0.3533484637737274,
0.09396868199110031,
-0.24338732659816742,
0.07477088272571564,
-0.824171781539917,
-0.5670233368873596,
-0.17832882702350616,
-0.5078282952308655,
-0.36626771092414856,
-0.5311886668205261,
-0.01582195982336998,
0.4094364643096924,
0.7376420497894287,
-0.6202194094657898,
0.6661982536315918,
0.646564781665802,
-0.3581694960594177,
0.4226514399051666,
-0.5516072511672974,
-0.15611504018306732,
-1.4052424430847168,
-0.1338345855474472,
-0.19219745695590973,
-0.20445409417152405,
-0.45197632908821106,
-0.07414819300174713,
0.12399639189243317,
-0.32897207140922546,
-0.39430245757102966,
0.6507204174995422,
-0.5141764283180237,
-0.02100946195423603,
-0.5606979727745056,
0.7447311282157898,
0.4062965512275696,
0.1373041719198227,
0.1853533238172531,
0.8878394365310669,
0.3728398084640503,
-0.36218973994255066,
0.22211194038391113,
0.9056157469749451,
-0.1335839331150055,
0.7165361642837524,
-0.7840073108673096,
0.34428200125694275,
-0.3490896224975586,
0.4248063266277313,
-1.0209448337554932,
0.17363029718399048,
-0.018478622660040855,
-0.6020596027374268,
-0.1502452790737152,
0.23195688426494598,
-0.627697229385376,
-0.40136954188346863,
-0.33868053555488586,
0.2477990984916687,
-0.013674263842403889,
-0.7063531279563904,
0.4512527585029602,
0.30496108531951904,
-0.17060038447380066,
-0.08559354394674301,
-0.931466281414032,
0.9008957743644714,
-0.20262083411216736,
-0.8218309879302979,
0.8503005504608154,
-0.17416828870773315,
-0.46650630235671997,
-0.0949348658323288,
0.14206171035766602,
-0.13645726442337036,
0.5135618448257446,
0.6403182148933411,
0.30074599385261536,
0.19418330490589142,
0.20216399431228638,
-0.09326767921447754,
-0.12867985665798187,
0.2544812560081482,
-0.3129008114337921,
0.32342544198036194,
-0.04600267484784126,
-0.15691371262073517,
-0.5615760684013367,
0.6094688177108765,
0.8579376339912415,
-0.3005448281764984,
0.932924211025238,
0.7229994535446167,
-0.5019869208335876,
-0.40740227699279785,
-0.04463403671979904,
-0.4474756419658661,
-0.49277904629707336,
0.29038354754447937,
-0.07313297688961029,
-0.6468420624732971,
0.3752731382846832,
-0.2111341655254364,
0.3056032955646515,
0.27370887994766235,
0.2806377708911896,
-0.0025240695104002953,
0.9669159054756165,
0.8149890303611755,
-0.015539954416453838,
0.4669032692909241,
-0.20505891740322113,
0.5797317624092102,
-0.8332329392433167,
-0.10619309544563293,
-0.23987193405628204,
-0.42500069737434387,
-0.3440556526184082,
-0.4450433850288391,
0.11004318296909332,
-0.4270245432853699,
0.32449495792388916,
0.5896486639976501,
-0.5754718780517578,
0.2952900826931,
0.4499027132987976,
-0.026979973539710045,
0.08223474770784378,
-0.11771981418132782,
-0.24649673700332642,
-0.2817213833332062,
-0.4636049270629883,
-0.5601585507392883,
0.6778758764266968,
0.1406698226928711,
0.6658949851989746,
0.21020598709583282,
0.9405694603919983,
0.5551077723503113,
0.101719431579113,
-0.7833334803581238,
0.5040884613990784,
-0.11616132408380508,
-0.32190439105033875,
-0.2769215404987335,
-0.2917063534259796,
-0.7864118814468384,
-0.05480367690324783,
-0.542244553565979,
-0.7573849558830261,
-0.14476069808006287,
0.02567794732749462,
-0.11982977390289307,
0.15903480350971222,
-0.5971052050590515,
0.9238465428352356,
-0.42573121190071106,
-0.3993973433971405,
-0.25400060415267944,
-0.22562843561172485,
-0.1577032059431076,
-0.03932434692978859,
0.5941027998924255,
0.03325076028704643,
-0.14701341092586517,
0.5877371430397034,
-0.5151697397232056,
0.9777443408966064,
-0.23057197034358978,
-0.10660134255886078,
0.18445764482021332,
0.3331209421157837,
0.7189250588417053,
0.12161506712436676,
-0.1802726835012436,
0.2633090317249298,
0.003969000186771154,
0.2423056811094284,
-0.6198838949203491,
0.704846978187561,
-0.6202797889709473,
-0.5135960578918457,
0.023228976875543594,
-0.6051331758499146,
-0.2030661702156067,
0.2887360155582428,
0.23311592638492584,
0.5557971000671387,
-0.44205915927886963,
0.053865108639001846,
0.17185239493846893,
-0.39752987027168274,
0.3937768042087555,
0.3474949896335602,
-0.04996908828616142,
-0.2588399648666382,
0.9743197560310364,
-0.0663510113954544,
0.09165017306804657,
0.38111549615859985,
0.24528521299362183,
-0.5672838687896729,
-0.35869261622428894,
-0.38296377658843994,
0.14343157410621643,
-0.7032749652862549,
0.013310502283275127,
-0.810554563999176,
0.02443831041455269,
-0.4647536277770996,
-0.6639924645423889,
-0.07489517331123352,
-0.7915441989898682,
-0.522458016872406,
-0.3389982581138611,
0.4120367765426636,
0.6853002905845642,
0.11109507083892822,
0.3939000070095062,
-0.5417548418045044,
0.487379252910614,
-0.00492599792778492,
0.22525930404663086,
-0.23407457768917084,
-0.48023152351379395,
-0.20616167783737183,
0.2464362531900406,
-0.243937686085701,
-0.9434146881103516,
0.5744925141334534,
0.5652000308036804,
0.5720760822296143,
0.34662407636642456,
0.24326901137828827,
0.5696978569030762,
-0.38664862513542175,
0.684524655342102,
-0.0039049903862178326,
-1.112665057182312,
0.6861509084701538,
-0.08174227178096771,
0.39235204458236694,
0.7526068091392517,
0.1364021748304367,
-1.073188304901123,
-0.585989773273468,
-0.8232768774032593,
-1.1741505861282349,
0.47772476077079773,
0.3332284390926361,
0.3611900210380554,
-0.25381773710250854,
0.38003435730934143,
0.13972245156764984,
0.26884815096855164,
-0.5574325323104858,
-0.012878084555268288,
-0.4254879951477051,
-0.5532287359237671,
-0.19518090784549713,
-0.06763839721679688,
-0.05365109071135521,
-0.03922584652900696,
0.3774298429489136,
-0.2931627929210663,
0.6659556031227112,
0.14342918992042542,
-0.3622340261936188,
0.25179991126060486,
0.12601293623447418,
0.6541748046875,
0.67780601978302,
0.07483040541410446,
0.20836570858955383,
0.30752766132354736,
-0.4688013792037964,
-0.3429485261440277,
0.05147523432970047,
0.08476243168115616,
0.24535581469535828,
0.36071544885635376,
0.6405515670776367,
0.16068194806575775,
-0.5562109351158142,
0.7418856024742126,
-0.5614179372787476,
-0.6752490997314453,
-0.5139931440353394,
0.055719539523124695,
0.5170807838439941,
-0.03204105421900749,
-0.014916989021003246,
-0.4069559872150421,
0.021513046696782112,
-0.33658912777900696,
-0.011647573672235012,
0.6019765138626099,
-0.4652355909347534,
-0.2690117359161377,
0.8609665036201477,
0.4421198070049286,
-0.7576924562454224,
0.8004299998283386,
-0.14280331134796143,
-0.5891007781028748,
0.7830483913421631,
0.9136461615562439,
0.9928862452507019,
0.30803003907203674,
0.7146816849708557,
0.026780223473906517,
0.4307630956172943,
0.23149144649505615,
0.5373838543891907,
-0.37064993381500244,
-0.5626431703567505,
0.052029915153980255,
-0.20560629665851593,
-0.7210524678230286,
-0.39262959361076355,
-0.23589642345905304,
0.2113029807806015,
-0.6771238446235657,
-0.0486421212553978,
0.1303454339504242,
-0.11064772307872772,
-0.670123279094696,
-0.05933151766657829,
0.3434346914291382,
1.1274861097335815,
-1.0051175355911255,
0.3958887755870819,
0.8840458393096924,
-0.01925136148929596,
-0.5206276178359985,
0.06377949565649033,
0.15428544580936432,
-0.8277066946029663,
0.376826673746109,
0.4014832079410553,
-0.28486448526382446,
0.18071907758712769,
-0.3589268922805786,
-0.43186238408088684,
1.3063210248947144,
0.2584489583969116,
-0.3700399398803711,
0.27234533429145813,
0.5849056839942932,
0.6308666467666626,
-0.3385591506958008,
0.49862009286880493,
-0.11237524449825287,
0.6095592379570007,
0.047564875334501266,
-0.6459565162658691,
0.14885282516479492,
-0.36220839619636536,
-0.036551572382450104,
0.227768674492836,
-0.2585374712944031,
0.5934556722640991,
-0.378734290599823,
-0.3904552757740021,
-0.3615465462207794,
0.3742709457874298,
-0.27100804448127747,
0.5368280410766602,
0.518300473690033,
0.48340708017349243,
0.9926551580429077,
0.03872065246105194,
0.9000041484832764,
-0.5572786331176758,
-0.36584004759788513,
0.9922736883163452,
-0.1543341428041458,
0.7574708461761475,
0.6017476916313171,
0.2697933316230774,
0.7838574051856995,
0.2619216740131378,
0.18519210815429688,
0.2924897372722626,
0.19475263357162476,
-0.4691886901855469,
-0.09069637209177017,
-0.40654346346855164,
0.022306816652417183,
0.4572843909263611,
0.6077669262886047,
-0.2184295356273651,
-0.23761112987995148,
0.026569465175271034,
0.056571342051029205,
0.4155401289463043,
-0.07966889441013336,
1.0853168964385986,
0.1825934648513794,
-0.5196825265884399,
0.416580468416214,
0.33169299364089966,
0.604378879070282,
-0.29277607798576355,
-0.04623851552605629,
-0.2586180567741394,
0.3428306579589844,
-0.5046243667602539,
-0.8043526411056519,
0.6969987750053406,
-0.01339142955839634,
0.016692420467734337,
-0.5043980479240417,
0.5519749522209167,
-0.29961249232292175,
-0.5920103192329407,
0.2647572457790375,
0.15403813123703003,
0.03551807627081871,
-0.4443660080432892,
-0.7181708216667175,
-0.03820253536105156,
-0.1585608422756195,
0.5018899440765381,
-0.21681760251522064,
0.5593950748443604,
-0.31641483306884766,
0.725216805934906,
0.5860074758529663,
0.054953332990407944,
-0.3433729410171509,
0.14276613295078278,
0.6316573023796082,
-0.25991448760032654,
-0.6908702850341797,
-0.8341015577316284,
0.31425294280052185,
-0.24559330940246582,
-0.3306327164173126,
0.8088256120681763,
0.35143595933914185,
0.402374804019928,
0.20309065282344818,
0.9021557569503784,
0.030222302302718163,
0.18407300114631653,
0.012194358743727207,
0.6819448471069336,
-0.713545024394989,
0.016569629311561584,
-0.5575427412986755,
-0.8935253024101257,
-0.15894204378128052,
0.6321857571601868,
-0.4219137132167816,
-0.2987123429775238,
0.5940097570419312,
0.6948590278625488,
-0.02844751439988613,
0.2546793222427368,
0.20808018743991852,
0.022792866453528404,
0.5163748264312744,
0.6085452437400818,
0.5477810502052307,
-0.0538732074201107,
0.6860787868499756,
-0.22344940900802612,
-0.3514086902141571,
-0.3008442521095276,
-1.1790486574172974,
-0.919218122959137,
-0.6195444464683533,
-0.567268967628479,
-0.2015846222639084,
-0.04844371974468231,
0.8792492747306824,
0.36560794711112976,
-0.3226716220378876,
0.25963929295539856,
-0.437567800283432,
0.2089918702840805,
-0.13722622394561768,
-0.1715579479932785,
-0.03725656867027283,
0.10970273613929749,
-0.5095571875572205,
0.41283634305000305,
0.3149241507053375,
0.15883834660053253,
-0.16599009931087494,
-0.20730681717395782,
0.15445254743099213,
0.38857075572013855,
0.35730698704719543,
0.22537261247634888,
-0.29828253388404846,
-0.04926981031894684,
0.1207452043890953,
-0.11269396543502808,
-0.2458764910697937,
0.3739083707332611,
-0.5441552400588989,
0.464586079120636,
0.4305683970451355,
0.9471899271011353,
0.3139491379261017,
0.07008574903011322,
0.6948754191398621,
-0.63932865858078,
0.08687129616737366,
0.18240389227867126,
0.2103969007730484,
0.6893694400787354,
-0.6538808941841125,
0.12609827518463135,
0.0738435760140419,
-0.3067184388637543,
-0.4446144104003906,
0.1028304323554039,
-0.47232502698898315,
-0.42438140511512756,
1.0247572660446167,
0.12075228244066238,
-0.260481059551239,
-0.25966283679008484,
-0.45032358169555664,
0.03754561394453049,
-0.1346837431192398,
1.2535070180892944,
0.6513466238975525,
0.16577036678791046,
-0.24011112749576569,
-0.449288547039032,
0.4221399426460266,
0.3276314437389374,
-0.9759784936904907,
0.31424254179000854,
0.45879486203193665,
0.04646218195557594,
0.1361009031534195,
0.7432025671005249,
0.0169680155813694,
0.32810914516448975,
-0.030432535335421562,
0.03628220036625862,
-0.6256489753723145,
-0.31344905495643616,
-0.08088286966085434,
-0.35240837931632996,
0.258928120136261,
-0.3588305711746216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07004v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07004v1
|
LM Transparency Tool: Interactive Tool for Analyzing Transformer Language Models
| 2024-04-10T13:39:11 | 2024-04-10T13:39:11 |
Igor Tufanov, Karen Hambardzumyan, Javier Ferrando, Elena Voita
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present the LM Transparency Tool (LM-TT), an open-source interactive
toolkit for analyzing the internal workings of Transformer-based language
models. Differently from previously existing tools that focus on isolated parts
of the decision-making process, our framework is designed to make the entire
prediction process transparent, and allows tracing back model behavior from the
top-layer representation to very fine-grained parts of the model. Specifically,
it (1) shows the important part of the whole input-to-output information flow,
(2) allows attributing any changes done by a model block to individual
attention heads and feed-forward neurons, (3) allows interpreting the functions
of those heads or neurons. A crucial part of this pipeline is showing the
importance of specific model components at each step. As a result, we are able
to look at the roles of model components only in cases where they are important
for a prediction. Since knowing which components should be inspected is key for
analyzing large models where the number of these components is extremely high,
we believe our tool will greatly support the interpretability community both in
research settings and in practical applications.
|
[
-0.4272162616252899,
-0.8407437205314636,
0.6780927777290344,
0.358722984790802,
0.030049612745642662,
0.01997254602611065,
-0.30807456374168396,
-0.48911193013191223,
0.0020250265952199697,
0.7579582929611206,
-0.6972018480300903,
-0.5099785923957825,
-0.5180073380470276,
-0.31197652220726013,
-0.5983266234397888,
0.9641347527503967,
-0.06120668724179268,
-0.14417017996311188,
-0.0783856064081192,
0.2748447358608246,
-0.4732462763786316,
-0.14185045659542084,
-0.7540797591209412,
-0.7351300120353699,
0.6161514520645142,
0.2508714199066162,
0.8979029655456543,
0.6105491518974304,
0.42815107107162476,
0.34959328174591064,
-0.18532328307628632,
-0.39018282294273376,
-0.5281190276145935,
0.35467466711997986,
-0.48359912633895874,
-0.6922611594200134,
-0.7557296752929688,
-0.014338793233036995,
0.6467085480690002,
0.7621079683303833,
-0.09775692969560623,
0.4239810109138489,
0.44780832529067993,
0.4960215985774994,
-0.6568596959114075,
0.5207423567771912,
-0.5413495302200317,
0.23156902194023132,
-0.1173771321773529,
-0.12941168248653412,
-0.7031033635139465,
-0.23245574533939362,
0.1104525774717331,
-0.4025767743587494,
0.11585529893636703,
0.006835407577455044,
0.634602427482605,
0.40289047360420227,
-0.29309529066085815,
0.10336557775735855,
-1.0435501337051392,
0.7499861717224121,
-0.4478800892829895,
0.6498779058456421,
0.4085031747817993,
0.580193817615509,
0.04040152207016945,
-1.0108351707458496,
-0.48078760504722595,
-0.25137266516685486,
-0.4259234666824341,
0.3683815598487854,
-0.45741164684295654,
0.39961954951286316,
0.11675357818603516,
0.383327454328537,
-0.2505781054496765,
0.0658949539065361,
-0.382188618183136,
-0.49328693747520447,
0.298848032951355,
0.21101337671279907,
0.09767499566078186,
0.11059879511594772,
-0.13360735774040222,
-0.011900067329406738,
-0.4305921792984009,
-0.11353778094053268,
0.27664095163345337,
0.2751164138317108,
-0.2291485071182251,
0.6327635645866394,
-0.0628376230597496,
0.4568139910697937,
-0.10201253741979599,
0.11939210444688797,
0.1021546721458435,
-0.28881460428237915,
-0.46945419907569885,
0.09910184890031815,
0.8066375851631165,
0.2367425411939621,
0.07410062849521637,
-0.13668079674243927,
-0.3786398768424988,
-0.21282051503658295,
0.2682914137840271,
-0.7445433139801025,
-0.21784716844558716,
0.4613872468471527,
-0.480503648519516,
-0.37715619802474976,
0.19237516820430756,
-0.8781713843345642,
-0.5184465646743774,
-0.27134421467781067,
0.4906289577484131,
-0.17420203983783722,
-0.5285831689834595,
0.15913966298103333,
0.03799455240368843,
0.1826048046350479,
0.40423864126205444,
-0.6893598437309265,
0.46931493282318115,
0.8068496584892273,
0.9008395671844482,
-0.3254754841327667,
-0.20404958724975586,
-0.6032968759536743,
0.11810889095067978,
-0.13671743869781494,
0.554641842842102,
-0.5589590668678284,
-0.5065118074417114,
-0.1841239482164383,
0.22511200606822968,
0.018667694181203842,
-0.4263290762901306,
0.6262508034706116,
-0.3893328607082367,
0.22328369319438934,
0.0961073487997055,
-0.3704890012741089,
-0.32381778955459595,
0.11656168848276138,
-1.0582820177078247,
1.1272598505020142,
0.3469204306602478,
-0.8255290985107422,
0.09090690314769745,
-1.0010439157485962,
0.13501331210136414,
-0.0389578714966774,
-0.1353112906217575,
-0.5205017328262329,
0.10982376337051392,
0.1126425564289093,
0.48223090171813965,
-0.263906866312027,
0.32813760638237,
-0.2009698748588562,
-0.26978376507759094,
0.31191956996917725,
-0.6120762825012207,
0.6932224631309509,
0.06254337728023529,
-0.4326302707195282,
0.8108402490615845,
-0.5684985518455505,
-0.04113691672682762,
0.07649818807840347,
-0.09334073960781097,
0.013403740711510181,
-0.2514008581638336,
0.19580745697021484,
0.07126355916261673,
0.1756528913974762,
-0.47728997468948364,
0.05606669560074806,
-0.34442126750946045,
0.34406524896621704,
1.0262051820755005,
-0.1086781844496727,
0.5766636729240417,
0.16454055905342102,
0.9388868808746338,
0.18425264954566956,
0.49211379885673523,
-0.6514283418655396,
-0.7451672554016113,
-0.9248253107070923,
-0.06723684072494507,
0.6021628379821777,
0.27551180124282837,
-0.4540620744228363,
0.4699020981788635,
-0.08512809872627258,
-0.5424838662147522,
-0.8954901695251465,
-0.4399300515651703,
0.267619252204895,
0.5418795347213745,
0.11935140192508698,
-0.22502438724040985,
-0.43255355954170227,
-1.1613438129425049,
-0.22455193102359772,
-0.04597736895084381,
-0.15722472965717316,
0.007895855233073235,
0.6083783507347107,
-0.16682888567447662,
1.10030996799469,
-0.6318619847297668,
-0.24594952166080475,
-0.4394747316837311,
0.061100102961063385,
0.36336150765419006,
0.3766734302043915,
0.4234298765659332,
-0.6543872356414795,
-0.4803657531738281,
0.38134095072746277,
-0.44672009348869324,
-0.19250783324241638,
0.055477119982242584,
-0.32228323817253113,
-0.028701672330498695,
0.5954124927520752,
-0.5117543339729309,
0.6007962822914124,
0.7570673823356628,
-0.6079423427581787,
0.41176965832710266,
-0.06519243866205215,
-0.16184256970882416,
-0.7719154953956604,
0.31204473972320557,
-0.12454266846179962,
-0.4363318681716919,
-0.7129647135734558,
0.1574549376964569,
0.23745666444301605,
-0.07598467171192169,
-0.5186274647712708,
0.6428644061088562,
-0.3002172112464905,
-0.3156430125236511,
-0.11745020002126694,
-0.10172387957572937,
0.1268940567970276,
0.5065874457359314,
-0.13509498536586761,
0.8223167061805725,
0.6621572971343994,
-0.3238905072212219,
0.10185831785202026,
-0.06333373486995697,
-0.33772799372673035,
0.18361063301563263,
-0.7389935851097107,
0.3418659269809723,
-0.19422581791877747,
-0.0518818199634552,
-0.6640305519104004,
-0.17632049322128296,
0.6129922270774841,
-0.3286680579185486,
0.373762845993042,
-0.08641308546066284,
-0.41163066029548645,
-0.027903180569410324,
-0.34761106967926025,
0.21736463904380798,
0.37493640184402466,
-0.34195223450660706,
1.0748244524002075,
0.4708699584007263,
-0.12389755994081497,
-0.5444543957710266,
-0.6877046823501587,
-0.25264546275138855,
-0.06717903912067413,
-0.4993724822998047,
0.40544840693473816,
-0.15668675303459167,
-0.28903546929359436,
0.1680150032043457,
-0.2059149295091629,
-0.19758620858192444,
0.1596374213695526,
0.5071013569831848,
0.19936352968215942,
-0.38095951080322266,
-0.20360365509986877,
0.012001385912299156,
-0.400028258562088,
0.26504579186439514,
-0.15142501890659332,
0.704162061214447,
-0.416441410779953,
-0.4773431718349457,
-0.5136839747428894,
0.17317821085453033,
0.595897376537323,
-0.370378315448761,
0.8413488864898682,
0.6368155479431152,
-0.41077741980552673,
-0.29336443543434143,
-0.2284029722213745,
-0.3080286383628845,
-0.524032711982727,
0.4738977551460266,
-0.2671487629413605,
-0.740848958492279,
0.6703276634216309,
0.09038813412189484,
0.027201317250728607,
0.5713778734207153,
0.6258038282394409,
0.23623064160346985,
1.088313102722168,
1.1787691116333008,
-0.0019157109782099724,
0.5441863536834717,
-0.2413494735956192,
0.09727217257022858,
-0.7026030421257019,
-0.5064460635185242,
-0.4466192126274109,
-0.2696494162082672,
-0.45793333649635315,
-0.3968745768070221,
0.43069496750831604,
0.05218827351927757,
-0.10279969871044159,
0.10000745952129364,
-0.6284342408180237,
0.6739299297332764,
0.5322238206863403,
-0.02947063185274601,
0.5590586066246033,
-0.2829528748989105,
-0.062392573803663254,
-0.1323385238647461,
-0.48604816198349,
-0.422203928232193,
0.9067083597183228,
0.9966893792152405,
0.7931333184242249,
-0.20994706451892853,
0.4179958403110504,
0.17139409482479095,
0.5587222576141357,
-1.1869837045669556,
0.5887593030929565,
0.3710540235042572,
-0.48408129811286926,
-0.2965148687362671,
-0.2053842842578888,
-0.858919084072113,
0.421597421169281,
-0.03593120351433754,
-0.8022701740264893,
0.02095337025821209,
0.3173910081386566,
-0.22924314439296722,
0.4539516866207123,
-0.8102894425392151,
1.0431972742080688,
0.01777411624789238,
-0.24392850697040558,
-0.09527231007814407,
-0.5047268867492676,
0.4391005337238312,
-0.19976907968521118,
0.1311134248971939,
0.00993166770786047,
-0.06456409394741058,
0.6268538236618042,
-0.08383306115865707,
1.0426647663116455,
-0.1408812701702118,
-0.3929372727870941,
0.12947966158390045,
0.3681972622871399,
0.4487122893333435,
-0.15785692632198334,
-0.2291838675737381,
0.47601285576820374,
-0.0827035903930664,
0.1002109944820404,
-0.6434465050697327,
0.3128238916397095,
-0.5143306255340576,
-0.5717336535453796,
-0.42535242438316345,
-0.5723305344581604,
0.02674550563097,
0.5045928359031677,
0.1132698580622673,
0.06293648481369019,
-0.12002088129520416,
0.2893869876861572,
0.4837855100631714,
-0.1282789260149002,
0.3731566369533539,
0.4012984335422516,
-0.918269693851471,
-0.10866928845643997,
0.6531553864479065,
-0.083841472864151,
0.2478770613670349,
0.3817577660083771,
0.4277649521827698,
-0.17964620888233185,
-0.6616235375404358,
-0.040018387138843536,
0.20193177461624146,
-0.8517860770225525,
-0.06095164269208908,
-0.4753580093383789,
-0.4388483464717865,
0.14258703589439392,
0.24074891209602356,
-0.6025415062904358,
-0.5233708024024963,
-0.051945798099040985,
-0.2363976240158081,
0.13864992558956146,
1.0571070909500122,
0.19891729950904846,
0.5654311180114746,
-0.7462870478630066,
0.3069649636745453,
0.07185468077659607,
0.8418903946876526,
-0.09955529868602753,
-0.28061443567276,
-0.4389179050922394,
-0.11194473505020142,
-0.5965372920036316,
-0.8505761623382568,
0.21788407862186432,
0.03176891431212425,
0.6314758062362671,
0.34915897250175476,
-0.08473857492208481,
0.3764783442020416,
-0.5094724893569946,
0.78778475522995,
0.1225636824965477,
-1.1686497926712036,
0.652116060256958,
-0.1780114322900772,
0.32485032081604004,
0.20120005309581757,
0.14109115302562714,
-0.49291902780532837,
-0.7874436378479004,
-0.46245139837265015,
-0.8563826680183411,
1.023674726486206,
0.5460392236709595,
-0.22806482017040253,
0.4095746576786041,
0.08499450236558914,
0.4820527732372284,
0.2911287248134613,
-0.8628728985786438,
-0.3315679430961609,
-0.23103882372379303,
-0.2596416473388672,
0.11640231311321259,
-0.17452917993068695,
-0.1364395022392273,
-0.14440424740314484,
0.4823704957962036,
-0.26868879795074463,
0.3916819095611572,
-0.015147741883993149,
-0.06138915196061134,
-0.32653307914733887,
0.31728288531303406,
0.41216301918029785,
0.81220543384552,
-0.5007778406143188,
0.1800653338432312,
-0.004604923073202372,
-0.7522114515304565,
-0.4127333462238312,
-0.1512172818183899,
-0.3208431303501129,
0.16201314330101013,
0.37626001238822937,
0.9058815240859985,
0.1749776154756546,
-0.455384224653244,
0.37550538778305054,
-0.12022198736667633,
0.05058420076966286,
-0.36450135707855225,
0.06919243186712265,
0.09551013261079788,
0.5418800711631775,
0.054444678127765656,
0.15033265948295593,
0.22225148975849152,
-0.5685177445411682,
0.0750480443239212,
0.2726103365421295,
-0.7526997923851013,
-0.6370165348052979,
0.8431439399719238,
0.15100599825382233,
-0.31226420402526855,
0.42913082242012024,
0.15733602643013,
-0.4467751979827881,
0.527619481086731,
0.31143784523010254,
1.2985721826553345,
-0.3392210900783539,
0.15092222392559052,
0.09015432745218277,
0.5895736217498779,
-0.022201236337423325,
0.19913743436336517,
0.06895668804645538,
-0.62849360704422,
-0.5816801190376282,
-0.6100517511367798,
-0.657394289970398,
0.43855005502700806,
-0.8408932089805603,
0.37932056188583374,
-0.23223620653152466,
-0.284516841173172,
0.1493636965751648,
-0.6344882249832153,
-0.6008965373039246,
0.06627253443002701,
0.15847128629684448,
1.0632944107055664,
-0.5864797830581665,
0.9596893191337585,
0.3005144000053406,
-0.36290213465690613,
-0.49707263708114624,
0.28415608406066895,
-0.05450687184929848,
-0.7997798323631287,
0.5915365815162659,
0.2539147138595581,
-0.45888447761535645,
-0.05344172567129135,
-0.5605224370956421,
-0.6765719652175903,
1.1225494146347046,
0.8619309067726135,
-0.524060070514679,
-0.19541345536708832,
0.2786160111427307,
0.37339887022972107,
-0.3206228017807007,
0.5641250014305115,
0.6794071793556213,
0.7660442590713501,
-0.27030879259109497,
-1.2185686826705933,
0.21672262251377106,
-0.01289209071546793,
-0.08139670640230179,
0.42781051993370056,
-0.35672232508659363,
0.7851772904396057,
0.01669885218143463,
-0.37057361006736755,
-0.24600888788700104,
0.6561433672904968,
-0.06407582014799118,
0.3138209581375122,
0.6559207439422607,
0.06847579032182693,
0.5189461708068848,
-0.2858552932739258,
0.9895376563072205,
-0.3746575117111206,
0.6070939898490906,
1.0919147729873657,
0.023331541568040848,
0.7635053396224976,
0.6201164722442627,
-0.17210246622562408,
0.2534259259700775,
0.29828718304634094,
0.011310989037156105,
0.5125473141670227,
-0.026191776618361473,
0.06767748296260834,
-0.053215108811855316,
-0.28433459997177124,
-0.1921091377735138,
0.3114994168281555,
0.4218082129955292,
-0.44344818592071533,
-0.21146288514137268,
-0.17436577379703522,
-0.026529621332883835,
-0.16905291378498077,
-0.5116011500358582,
0.49826934933662415,
0.2116076797246933,
-0.4887188673019409,
0.1693374663591385,
-0.01590201072394848,
0.5080363750457764,
-0.7241266965866089,
-0.14756368100643158,
0.01857040449976921,
0.17432932555675507,
-0.3912816643714905,
-1.4394315481185913,
0.7217840552330017,
-0.16146670281887054,
-0.13509348034858704,
-0.4832004904747009,
0.8437024354934692,
-0.4288286566734314,
-0.31787699460983276,
0.6255095601081848,
0.5667783617973328,
0.09880226105451584,
-0.38137394189834595,
-0.7360551357269287,
0.3503997027873993,
-0.0021538378205150366,
-0.664810836315155,
0.03162593021988869,
0.3279106616973877,
-0.03366108983755112,
0.8338273167610168,
0.4166066646575928,
0.045295726507902145,
-0.08534988760948181,
0.3496204912662506,
0.8420730233192444,
-0.8884720802307129,
-0.4680386781692505,
-0.8783152103424072,
1.1054027080535889,
-0.0860903412103653,
0.042842570692300797,
0.5182625651359558,
0.5477508306503296,
0.8128413558006287,
-0.10071274638175964,
0.8089406490325928,
0.28183290362358093,
0.3707641363143921,
-0.6364520788192749,
0.9737427234649658,
-0.2979468107223511,
0.3369891047477722,
-0.06764145940542221,
-1.1739784479141235,
-0.23040179908275604,
0.29843175411224365,
0.045902956277132034,
-0.03432127833366394,
0.8177399635314941,
0.7193657755851746,
-0.4015082120895386,
0.09799373894929886,
0.443196564912796,
0.6009815335273743,
0.21256960928440094,
0.11431695520877838,
1.055976152420044,
-0.22391939163208008,
0.668880820274353,
-0.4973844885826111,
-0.14142462611198425,
-0.047889694571495056,
-1.039733648300171,
-0.8810263872146606,
-0.5795120596885681,
-0.4038972854614258,
-0.31086093187332153,
-0.3264547884464264,
0.6642304062843323,
0.5360119342803955,
-0.9159711599349976,
-0.3213036060333252,
-0.16199800372123718,
0.25971242785453796,
-0.19416965544223785,
-0.27823594212532043,
0.32061779499053955,
0.10314640402793884,
-0.8404218554496765,
0.3582024872303009,
0.47205889225006104,
-0.07358616590499878,
-0.5942617654800415,
0.11224375665187836,
0.5158957242965698,
-0.027551019564270973,
0.6664851903915405,
-0.039681002497673035,
-0.8269473910331726,
-0.32810989022254944,
0.10479137301445007,
0.2007044106721878,
0.16639874875545502,
0.8751396536827087,
-0.5968963503837585,
0.6079039573669434,
0.4557655453681946,
0.3999241590499878,
0.7458332777023315,
-0.479954332113266,
0.8722912073135376,
-0.7959409952163696,
0.18100176751613617,
0.25795844197273254,
0.4999190866947174,
0.20181062817573547,
-0.3508460819721222,
0.6090442538261414,
-0.2539464235305786,
-0.4415506422519684,
-1.0796165466308594,
0.45648428797721863,
-1.1091598272323608,
-0.07027269899845123,
0.9477164149284363,
-0.04563402384519577,
-0.38876184821128845,
-0.21163888275623322,
-0.4655730128288269,
0.3502371311187744,
-0.539213240146637,
0.39105892181396484,
0.5450421571731567,
-0.10351788252592087,
-0.4139286279678345,
-0.9522742033004761,
0.3341183364391327,
0.0940549224615097,
-0.8127266764640808,
0.170258566737175,
0.007972919382154942,
0.18586856126785278,
0.29010671377182007,
0.4669608175754547,
-0.22947922348976135,
-0.04435235634446144,
-0.1928745061159134,
0.2466643899679184,
-0.1960984766483307,
-0.3784189820289612,
-0.6181098818778992,
0.2295217663049698,
0.0664805993437767,
-0.21204136312007904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07001v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07001v3
|
Event Grounded Criminal Court View Generation with Cooperative (Large) Language Models
| 2024-04-10T13:31:07 | 2024-04-16T06:34:31 |
Linan Yue, Qi Liu, Lili Zhao, Li Wang, Weibo Gao, Yanqing An
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the development of legal intelligence, Criminal Court View Generation
has attracted much attention as a crucial task of legal intelligence, which
aims to generate concise and coherent texts that summarize case facts and
provide explanations for verdicts. Existing researches explore the key
information in case facts to yield the court views. Most of them employ a
coarse-grained approach that partitions the facts into broad segments (e.g.,
verdict-related sentences) to make predictions. However, this approach fails to
capture the complex details present in the case facts, such as various criminal
elements and legal events. To this end, in this paper, we propose an Event
Grounded Generation (EGG) method for criminal court view generation with
cooperative (Large) Language Models, which introduces the fine-grained event
information into the generation. Specifically, we first design a LLMs-based
extraction method that can extract events in case facts without massive
annotated events. Then, we incorporate the extracted events into court view
generation by merging case facts and events. Besides, considering the
computational burden posed by the use of LLMs in the extraction phase of EGG,
we propose a LLMs-free EGG method that can eliminate the requirement for event
extraction using LLMs in the inference phase. Extensive experimental results on
a real-world dataset clearly validate the effectiveness of our proposed method.
|
[
-0.260743111371994,
-0.7889404296875,
1.010960340499878,
-0.22349239885807037,
-0.6867392063140869,
-0.13121813535690308,
-0.20225973427295685,
-0.2736397385597229,
0.375766783952713,
0.6360461115837097,
-0.6211338639259338,
-0.6460352540016174,
-0.2909133732318878,
-0.17254117131233215,
-0.35793018341064453,
0.8304517865180969,
0.2754392623901367,
0.11036063730716705,
-0.2080373466014862,
0.06152026727795601,
-0.19676858186721802,
-0.7004020810127258,
-0.4194965958595276,
-0.24211503565311432,
0.16233523190021515,
0.6428632736206055,
0.16900067031383514,
0.7479047179222107,
0.33310285210609436,
0.3008001744747162,
0.11139359325170517,
0.3476778566837311,
-0.5132803320884705,
0.08086307346820831,
-0.1483851820230484,
-0.5897706151008606,
-0.5120437145233154,
0.23313266038894653,
0.09004480391740799,
0.6329012513160706,
-0.1636686772108078,
-0.06884036958217621,
-0.3317880630493164,
0.635333776473999,
-0.8583924174308777,
0.15220792591571808,
-0.8302578926086426,
0.521530032157898,
-0.2947710454463959,
-0.41355565190315247,
-0.5230626463890076,
-0.38108018040657043,
-0.24558956921100616,
-0.6251513361930847,
0.4612290561199188,
0.11830444633960724,
0.5721927881240845,
-0.12322511523962021,
-0.4937162399291992,
-0.03517625480890274,
-0.6328968405723572,
0.7540580034255981,
-0.8179672956466675,
0.16122110188007355,
0.28720569610595703,
0.3110373914241791,
-0.5319696068763733,
-0.5651372671127319,
-0.679451048374176,
-0.20673848688602448,
0.045887306332588196,
0.46468180418014526,
0.09040281176567078,
0.1550290882587433,
0.23522566258907318,
0.12538540363311768,
-0.19257941842079163,
-0.1219700500369072,
-0.04022585228085518,
0.04505559429526329,
0.9514939785003662,
0.2669590413570404,
0.029646480455994606,
-0.3268428444862366,
-0.21159540116786957,
-0.010906192474067211,
-0.9133790731430054,
0.3257928192615509,
0.42158299684524536,
0.32595595717430115,
-0.2279299646615982,
0.752430260181427,
-0.45912015438079834,
0.21742360293865204,
0.5486862659454346,
-0.4285988211631775,
0.11726149171590805,
-0.20550106465816498,
-0.40743353962898254,
0.42195504903793335,
0.8760961890220642,
0.8819902539253235,
0.28975775837898254,
-0.2701241374015808,
0.021712159737944603,
0.1455925703048706,
0.1652652621269226,
-0.8813245892524719,
-0.014936055056750774,
0.548713207244873,
-0.5749425888061523,
-0.6346694827079773,
0.13789300620555878,
-1.2347960472106934,
-0.5832042098045349,
-0.20042291283607483,
-0.2648138999938965,
-0.33327990770339966,
-0.22646012902259827,
-0.08933363854885101,
-0.17682254314422607,
0.4183422327041626,
0.511682391166687,
-0.5508652329444885,
0.2415788769721985,
0.825565755367279,
0.2975386679172516,
-0.17136302590370178,
0.30630457401275635,
-1.3190335035324097,
0.4555729329586029,
-0.1486210823059082,
0.6716069579124451,
-0.6176267266273499,
-0.21345366537570953,
0.44989028573036194,
-0.03877371549606323,
0.3707922697067261,
-0.36114951968193054,
0.6275919079780579,
-0.6571570038795471,
-0.23849035799503326,
-0.19666688144207,
-0.6777045130729675,
-0.13430117070674896,
0.2966627776622772,
-0.17658033967018127,
0.4097115993499756,
-0.5373517870903015,
-0.6676921844482422,
0.8439253568649292,
-0.151959627866745,
-0.8689466118812561,
0.3970482051372528,
-0.9303523898124695,
-0.6903088688850403,
0.2702939808368683,
0.3996718227863312,
0.8112848401069641,
0.11636430770158768,
0.7210090160369873,
-0.48065489530563354,
0.08173801004886627,
0.06629566848278046,
-0.03474881500005722,
0.3559044897556305,
0.23840534687042236,
-0.6021240949630737,
-0.0541415698826313,
-1.231335163116455,
-0.215828537940979,
0.4220336973667145,
-0.33494874835014343,
-0.3059123456478119,
0.8101500272750854,
-0.2882636487483978,
0.0838492289185524,
-0.010796104557812214,
-0.8785848617553711,
0.09757261723279953,
-0.3859579861164093,
0.18516968190670013,
0.5490209460258484,
0.44994446635246277,
0.42231371998786926,
-0.09935068339109421,
0.2669379413127899,
0.471191942691803,
0.06086798012256622,
-0.22373613715171814,
-0.5259544253349304,
-0.7055914402008057,
-0.09700211882591248,
-0.2576252520084381,
0.4978051781654358,
-0.7456571459770203,
0.46319666504859924,
-0.09172724932432175,
-0.0053157564252614975,
0.06678756326436996,
-0.10275702178478241,
0.37208619713783264,
0.434255450963974,
0.08871793001890182,
0.10576456785202026,
-0.955352246761322,
-0.8484561443328857,
-0.38530823588371277,
-0.1704004853963852,
0.18038569390773773,
0.4254138767719269,
0.16278883814811707,
0.17403897643089294,
1.0039973258972168,
-0.3464287519454956,
-0.09647450596094131,
-0.394705593585968,
0.19643022119998932,
0.4163428544998169,
0.4282234013080597,
0.5485743284225464,
-0.8562054634094238,
-0.052458833903074265,
0.11363159120082855,
-0.8671953678131104,
-0.033216528594493866,
-0.1314951628446579,
-0.10139260441064835,
-0.04425220191478729,
0.6050441265106201,
-0.22683218121528625,
0.8791634440422058,
-0.02774367853999138,
-0.5704626441001892,
0.5044875741004944,
0.29017961025238037,
0.4400874674320221,
-0.9290438890457153,
-0.5991129279136658,
0.004382827784866095,
-0.7618558406829834,
-0.7426393628120422,
0.24796855449676514,
0.020572561770677567,
0.06343722343444824,
-0.6964836120605469,
0.023705435916781425,
-0.446032851934433,
-0.1881747841835022,
-0.22617357969284058,
0.36813464760780334,
-0.06141043081879616,
0.6026073098182678,
0.19401398301124573,
0.358425110578537,
0.30157357454299927,
-0.5812907218933105,
0.38536325097084045,
0.13043861091136932,
-0.14717914164066315,
0.48344096541404724,
-0.05806460231542587,
0.004915931262075901,
-0.006878702901303768,
-0.20799964666366577,
-0.7307881712913513,
-0.3814711272716522,
0.12130125612020493,
-0.018038572743535042,
0.3670507073402405,
-0.6366931200027466,
-0.3962378203868866,
-0.06161331385374069,
-0.3627452552318573,
0.41285476088523865,
0.5826693773269653,
-0.5805672407150269,
0.7978418469429016,
0.49799853563308716,
-0.0845138356089592,
-0.1633796989917755,
-0.6609081029891968,
0.22087326645851135,
-0.1957579255104065,
-0.6685361266136169,
0.24813039600849152,
0.20829534530639648,
-0.6952444911003113,
0.0059662978164851665,
0.0955936387181282,
0.2988375723361969,
-0.12795065343379974,
0.5404899716377258,
0.19096317887306213,
-0.5135394334793091,
-0.2514519691467285,
0.13569873571395874,
0.2816377878189087,
0.2885572016239166,
0.07703767716884613,
0.5428926944732666,
0.04644579440355301,
-0.6513018608093262,
-0.5646576285362244,
0.7919473052024841,
0.4209156930446625,
-0.10207973420619965,
0.38127222657203674,
-0.23634500801563263,
-0.3536655008792877,
-0.16425971686840057,
-0.8665915131568909,
0.08223981410264969,
-0.44205787777900696,
0.23329989612102509,
-0.3459482491016388,
-0.7516235113143921,
0.6547579169273376,
-0.33272117376327515,
0.22503088414669037,
0.36060187220573425,
0.615876317024231,
0.09542118012905121,
1.0289030075073242,
0.3690459728240967,
0.03078334406018257,
0.5490474700927734,
0.10256998240947723,
0.1995895653963089,
-0.6966990232467651,
-0.36855581402778625,
-0.34881994128227234,
-0.03329949453473091,
0.012447064742445946,
-0.04260246083140373,
0.20757870376110077,
0.2470712959766388,
-0.12017028778791428,
-0.18147766590118408,
-0.07565202564001083,
0.44402050971984863,
0.5372684597969055,
0.19849196076393127,
0.46855300664901733,
0.06408186256885529,
-0.5088889002799988,
0.02867962419986725,
-0.497309148311615,
-0.448198527097702,
1.024151086807251,
-0.1135084331035614,
0.4267279803752899,
0.09695801138877869,
0.9183386564254761,
0.21794217824935913,
-0.04520825669169426,
-0.6914434432983398,
0.7492437362670898,
-0.20512755215168,
-0.06812866032123566,
0.04438765347003937,
-0.2931625247001648,
-0.47653740644454956,
0.25432559847831726,
-0.4547022879123688,
-0.8576234579086304,
0.5065847039222717,
-0.3924252688884735,
-0.5999042987823486,
0.27465832233428955,
-0.5545826554298401,
0.25536462664604187,
-0.09110350906848907,
-0.7141779065132141,
-0.12239200621843338,
-0.21535108983516693,
0.8096056580543518,
-0.03205030411481857,
0.5559605956077576,
-0.12638279795646667,
0.33321675658226013,
0.7351533770561218,
-0.9107508659362793,
0.9590394496917725,
-0.23416121304035187,
0.16756080090999603,
0.4392319619655609,
0.36551398038864136,
1.0090298652648926,
0.5116686224937439,
-0.044136904180049896,
-0.24636366963386536,
-0.2983107566833496,
-0.004651248455047607,
-0.36846545338630676,
0.5492882132530212,
-0.5244429707527161,
-0.8405644297599792,
-0.2596081495285034,
-0.582928478717804,
-0.1978834569454193,
0.005872686393558979,
0.29239505529403687,
0.5716034770011902,
-0.17602111399173737,
0.08268845826387405,
0.525233805179596,
-0.033117685467004776,
0.7084028720855713,
0.6837682127952576,
-0.2769474983215332,
-0.42393046617507935,
0.40313440561294556,
-0.16494375467300415,
-0.12700189650058746,
0.07426810264587402,
0.07858069986104965,
0.10338909178972244,
-0.9384206533432007,
-0.5041350722312927,
0.012690616771578789,
-0.6280890107154846,
-0.33272096514701843,
-0.8155531883239746,
-0.1870201826095581,
-0.6099274158477783,
-0.6060291528701782,
-0.46636122465133667,
-0.41459301114082336,
-0.18138431012630463,
-0.25525468587875366,
0.5244009494781494,
0.43728405237197876,
0.0970621407032013,
0.33587846159935,
-0.6696454882621765,
0.689221978187561,
0.19895271956920624,
0.12309671938419342,
-0.1673547923564911,
-0.24609415233135223,
0.010158276185393333,
-0.10671290010213852,
-0.23273241519927979,
-0.8136717677116394,
0.4404534101486206,
0.1543761044740677,
0.6048275828361511,
0.9717341065406799,
0.36115866899490356,
0.865863561630249,
-0.9170966148376465,
0.9200146794319153,
0.30833128094673157,
-0.6457180976867676,
1.0842152833938599,
-0.33378422260284424,
-0.34427711367607117,
0.5159173607826233,
-0.2509773075580597,
-0.018040096387267113,
-0.7487099766731262,
-0.8590642213821411,
-0.8322662711143494,
0.9505527019500732,
0.43194085359573364,
-0.19890226423740387,
-0.21581080555915833,
0.730337917804718,
0.12492543458938599,
0.19375476241111755,
-0.6732491850852966,
-0.19298791885375977,
-0.07891520857810974,
-0.17077113687992096,
0.1580970287322998,
-0.32320693135261536,
-0.4364929497241974,
-0.25212907791137695,
0.7215132117271423,
0.03636493906378746,
0.11841991543769836,
0.24849551916122437,
0.019888995215296745,
-0.3008595108985901,
0.1869015097618103,
0.5037827491760254,
0.27790525555610657,
-0.4023681879043579,
0.2982611060142517,
-0.09770458191633224,
-0.5254913568496704,
0.1468816101551056,
-0.18773110210895538,
-0.28674620389938354,
-0.2164766788482666,
0.46105191111564636,
0.5988792181015015,
-0.03343148157000542,
-0.695156455039978,
0.9415310621261597,
-0.37144801020622253,
-0.44732964038848877,
-0.6590383648872375,
0.2912338674068451,
-0.24012865126132965,
0.8950774669647217,
0.4412965476512909,
-0.07888244837522507,
0.17259784042835236,
-0.766739547252655,
0.4824771285057068,
0.396782249212265,
-0.1502229869365692,
-0.13133014738559723,
0.8453160524368286,
0.23261356353759766,
-0.1439165323972702,
0.347651869058609,
-0.45954814553260803,
-0.5419882535934448,
0.6911139488220215,
0.6638255715370178,
0.9387189149856567,
0.3082142770290375,
-0.09479738771915436,
0.051440540701150894,
0.15917538106441498,
-0.11447656899690628,
0.3508099615573883,
0.0798928365111351,
-0.7360384464263916,
-0.4805557429790497,
-0.7567214965820312,
-0.16974137723445892,
0.34881719946861267,
-0.6734815239906311,
0.29449591040611267,
-0.6572129130363464,
0.12816640734672546,
-0.1585340052843094,
0.0944552943110466,
-0.5015641450881958,
0.15085601806640625,
0.4029194116592407,
0.7449126243591309,
-0.9277700185775757,
0.7246189713478088,
0.5979358553886414,
-0.3044204115867615,
-0.7764273881912231,
-0.17577527463436127,
0.23307302594184875,
-0.6563472151756287,
0.5645061135292053,
0.03984983637928963,
-0.04432855173945427,
-0.25038474798202515,
-0.741696834564209,
-0.4694071412086487,
0.9774304032325745,
0.12860779464244843,
-0.9004311561584473,
0.1683833748102188,
0.29338160157203674,
0.23766210675239563,
-1.0201454162597656,
-0.26117581129074097,
0.5449563264846802,
0.22334900498390198,
0.6449081897735596,
0.06601137667894363,
0.3081549108028412,
-0.4277949929237366,
-0.209258571267128,
0.07790334522724152,
-0.4663412272930145,
0.7879785895347595,
-0.0960981696844101,
-0.2502180337905884,
-0.1401243954896927,
0.9537940621376038,
0.5103528499603271,
0.6662171483039856,
0.37701353430747986,
0.5780316591262817,
0.6776586771011353,
-0.13323956727981567,
1.1234792470932007,
-0.14203502237796783,
0.15233869850635529,
1.116721510887146,
-0.6842864751815796,
0.6504666209220886,
0.6570042967796326,
0.07405736297369003,
0.3034965693950653,
0.33741265535354614,
-0.10925189405679703,
0.8357359170913696,
-0.06014828011393547,
-0.19292284548282623,
-0.8092855215072632,
0.17225894331932068,
-0.047445498406887054,
0.3339163362979889,
0.28660765290260315,
-0.21138855814933777,
-0.3164263963699341,
0.11022846400737762,
-0.027982093393802643,
0.16371741890907288,
-0.6883001327514648,
0.9080620408058167,
0.0021406824234873056,
-0.47513481974601746,
0.01159318070858717,
0.14967598021030426,
0.38230276107788086,
-0.11922203749418259,
-0.2442197948694229,
-0.38782814145088196,
0.18814754486083984,
-0.32337790727615356,
-0.5810461640357971,
0.05689648911356926,
0.3116956055164337,
-0.25446823239326477,
0.13010351359844208,
0.7525960803031921,
-0.11855839937925339,
-0.6858817338943481,
0.2153857797384262,
0.35954469442367554,
0.2748650312423706,
-0.09832976758480072,
-0.10687360912561417,
-0.13202303647994995,
-0.0392073392868042,
-0.3715932071208954,
0.3600723445415497,
0.8043813705444336,
-0.18439272046089172,
0.22434814274311066,
0.7633202075958252,
0.25429829955101013,
0.47996214032173157,
0.19724209606647491,
1.090588927268982,
-0.7720038294792175,
-0.6046324372291565,
-1.0102932453155518,
0.580973744392395,
-0.4300585389137268,
0.07968579977750778,
0.38663744926452637,
0.7185996174812317,
0.4926906228065491,
0.1626807153224945,
0.8858124613761902,
0.04441244155168533,
0.44663378596305847,
-0.9653662443161011,
0.44422122836112976,
-0.37834393978118896,
0.2617981433868408,
-0.2851770520210266,
-0.6051093935966492,
-0.22251658141613007,
0.3326837718486786,
-0.2684166729450226,
-0.28208109736442566,
0.4969344139099121,
0.4209292232990265,
-0.30661740899086,
0.23907043039798737,
0.5916871428489685,
0.24256391823291779,
0.4440370202064514,
0.6660420298576355,
0.9734129309654236,
-0.36393725872039795,
0.2838243246078491,
-0.12173868715763092,
-0.39626553654670715,
-0.7297261357307434,
-1.1974586248397827,
-1.1875064373016357,
-0.04578927904367447,
-0.406252920627594,
-0.11951670050621033,
0.08605806529521942,
0.8045564293861389,
0.6656951308250427,
-1.0071206092834473,
0.01885814219713211,
-0.33637896180152893,
-0.2718009948730469,
0.08751152455806732,
-0.20455597341060638,
0.35772061347961426,
-0.417459100484848,
-0.496163547039032,
0.676345944404602,
0.29611366987228394,
-0.20404109358787537,
0.38205429911613464,
0.16143079102039337,
-0.41693440079689026,
0.24202677607536316,
0.63566654920578,
-0.009907837957143784,
-0.63917475938797,
-0.6390016078948975,
-0.5567663311958313,
0.03691831976175308,
0.31468966603279114,
0.7983755469322205,
-0.843969464302063,
0.07954967767000198,
0.16843116283416748,
0.5576193928718567,
0.7311930656433105,
0.061263199895620346,
0.7321076393127441,
-0.9259693622589111,
0.5933082103729248,
0.051778580993413925,
0.9297759532928467,
-0.19977279007434845,
-0.8625680804252625,
0.3507654666900635,
0.4476429522037506,
-0.3513369858264923,
-0.6129640340805054,
0.46801650524139404,
-1.2626057863235474,
-0.19946499168872833,
1.1383177042007446,
-0.15090666711330414,
-0.5682178139686584,
-0.18831098079681396,
0.08022114634513855,
0.4507503807544708,
-0.583013117313385,
0.5908058881759644,
0.5155150294303894,
-0.30034005641937256,
-0.19731231033802032,
-0.548237144947052,
0.39528509974479675,
-0.011462676338851452,
-0.7520354986190796,
0.14538636803627014,
0.7389792799949646,
0.14178188145160675,
0.22677235305309296,
0.34211620688438416,
-0.3028441369533539,
0.16569846868515015,
-0.035077910870313644,
0.32025861740112305,
-0.39122939109802246,
-0.20395708084106445,
-0.11918428540229797,
0.6044320464134216,
-0.5625948309898376,
-0.08352187275886536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06996v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06996v1
|
XNLIeu: a dataset for cross-lingual NLI in Basque
| 2024-04-10T13:19:56 | 2024-04-10T13:19:56 |
Maite Heredia, Julen Etxaniz, Muitze Zulaika, Xabier Saralegi, Jeremy Barnes, Aitor Soroa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
XNLI is a popular Natural Language Inference (NLI) benchmark widely used to
evaluate cross-lingual Natural Language Understanding (NLU) capabilities across
languages. In this paper, we expand XNLI to include Basque, a low-resource
language that can greatly benefit from transfer-learning approaches. The new
dataset, dubbed XNLIeu, has been developed by first machine-translating the
English XNLI corpus into Basque, followed by a manual post-edition step. We
have conducted a series of experiments using mono- and multilingual LLMs to
assess a) the effect of professional post-edition on the MT system; b) the best
cross-lingual strategy for NLI in Basque; and c) whether the choice of the best
cross-lingual strategy is influenced by the fact that the dataset is built by
translation. The results show that post-edition is necessary and that the
translate-train cross-lingual strategy obtains better results overall, although
the gain is lower when tested in a dataset that has been built natively from
scratch. Our code and datasets are publicly available under open licenses.
|
[
-0.35206764936447144,
-0.16337727010250092,
0.16459597647190094,
0.466852605342865,
0.020484868437051773,
0.0177585668861866,
-0.4436255097389221,
-0.7134838104248047,
0.4765300154685974,
0.5646544694900513,
-0.5627167820930481,
-0.5174562335014343,
-0.546130895614624,
0.20478379726409912,
-0.3845691680908203,
0.8673076033592224,
0.011467712000012398,
0.18346531689167023,
0.2821301221847534,
-0.34602680802345276,
-0.23268353939056396,
-0.48081478476524353,
-1.0511900186538696,
-0.4601445198059082,
0.8437049984931946,
0.14619140326976776,
0.6677831411361694,
0.4776378273963928,
-0.13554060459136963,
0.26107215881347656,
0.12100032716989517,
0.07815426588058472,
-0.7355397939682007,
-0.461819052696228,
-0.32309427857398987,
-1.0484107732772827,
-0.31221744418144226,
-0.13443295657634735,
0.8641453981399536,
0.8012064695358276,
0.2436806559562683,
0.1526445746421814,
0.0385776050388813,
0.6430318355560303,
-0.5687629580497742,
-0.03828824684023857,
-0.44560760259628296,
0.3317371606826782,
-0.27405306696891785,
-0.27177923917770386,
-0.43592607975006104,
-0.2960417568683624,
0.21391865611076355,
-0.7601168751716614,
-0.04704317823052406,
0.08157768100500107,
0.6731292009353638,
0.2453051656484604,
-0.4701944589614868,
-0.12971602380275726,
-0.3647474944591522,
1.1524800062179565,
-0.5026146769523621,
0.7682668566703796,
0.11951526999473572,
0.25720345973968506,
-0.16652554273605347,
-0.6539734601974487,
-0.28414401412010193,
-0.036749549210071564,
-0.24811863899230957,
0.1815749555826187,
-0.18950441479682922,
-0.37234270572662354,
-0.054205626249313354,
0.31788697838783264,
-0.7924737334251404,
0.448635995388031,
-0.34628424048423767,
0.20528340339660645,
0.7671369314193726,
-0.08152821660041809,
0.3367767632007599,
-0.33658018708229065,
-0.44385817646980286,
-0.2872851490974426,
-0.8109076619148254,
0.040661610662937164,
0.4806413948535919,
0.39580243825912476,
-0.292387992143631,
0.20912732183933258,
-0.061599090695381165,
0.5320028066635132,
-0.39818087220191956,
0.17181625962257385,
0.643471360206604,
-0.5961039066314697,
-0.27198514342308044,
0.29963183403015137,
0.8464593887329102,
0.4345611035823822,
0.40483614802360535,
-0.6386376023292542,
-0.06648017466068268,
-0.06263561546802521,
0.016393354162573814,
-0.21980006992816925,
-0.15486162900924683,
0.22481326758861542,
-0.2598738670349121,
-0.4147862195968628,
-0.14113087952136993,
-0.7061479091644287,
-0.09294606000185013,
-0.3653692901134491,
0.2351362556219101,
-0.23858121037483215,
-0.31997159123420715,
0.35858190059661865,
-0.15843988955020905,
0.37572354078292847,
0.25176340341567993,
-0.6130418181419373,
0.45186731219291687,
0.6256064176559448,
0.6808547377586365,
-0.5420110821723938,
-0.5300498604774475,
-0.7993046045303345,
-0.061936136335134506,
-0.47950318455696106,
0.49570032954216003,
-0.08240325003862381,
-0.4493497908115387,
-0.045101866126060486,
0.33610889315605164,
-0.3032080829143524,
-0.4767666757106781,
0.9262480139732361,
-0.4383220672607422,
0.4349431097507477,
-0.30684250593185425,
-0.39463433623313904,
-0.1856004297733307,
0.18141962587833405,
-1.0273237228393555,
1.4258054494857788,
0.20203320682048798,
-0.700404703617096,
0.4736010730266571,
-0.5597665905952454,
-0.20502807199954987,
-0.1612424999475479,
-0.24570880830287933,
0.07134587317705154,
0.160287544131279,
0.031705692410469055,
0.1637350469827652,
-0.4252837896347046,
0.2544330656528473,
0.005891813430935144,
-0.17241959273815155,
0.28987231850624084,
-0.49667251110076904,
1.1599631309509277,
-0.16245412826538086,
-0.4856446087360382,
-0.07533903419971466,
-0.9735391736030579,
0.3511061668395996,
-0.09390567243099213,
-0.3210551142692566,
-0.5953800082206726,
-0.1601722091436386,
0.4232913553714752,
0.36331745982170105,
0.001984897768124938,
-0.8162983655929565,
-0.13344715535640717,
-0.5640076398849487,
0.02926744893193245,
0.5387394428253174,
-0.3787740170955658,
0.6180037260055542,
-0.398835688829422,
0.4383963346481323,
-0.48442134261131287,
0.09563946723937988,
0.3577800393104553,
-0.4994150400161743,
-0.5825685262680054,
-0.13145115971565247,
0.7793399691581726,
0.9769676327705383,
-1.0577601194381714,
0.3025999367237091,
-0.5846050381660461,
-0.24914392828941345,
-0.6097537279129028,
0.3369482755661011,
0.5429592132568359,
0.2152906060218811,
0.34429243206977844,
0.020099837332963943,
-0.6552615165710449,
-0.7930827736854553,
-0.10515747219324112,
0.019903533160686493,
-0.14244486391544342,
0.24629902839660645,
0.37965869903564453,
-0.23073133826255798,
0.6289736032485962,
-0.10052667558193207,
-0.1706683188676834,
-0.6243354082107544,
0.2021057903766632,
0.4320875406265259,
0.34504207968711853,
1.031096339225769,
-0.7041336894035339,
-0.5936219692230225,
0.49404388666152954,
-0.9220335483551025,
-0.40973421931266785,
-0.22511614859104156,
-0.610027015209198,
0.2153230607509613,
0.22505854070186615,
-0.23143234848976135,
0.3370393216609955,
0.9741870760917664,
-0.2836642861366272,
0.41142386198043823,
-0.12428558617830276,
0.16253997385501862,
-0.9163165092468262,
0.06635069102048874,
0.17349384725093842,
-0.49663203954696655,
-0.7591373324394226,
0.06035972759127617,
-0.167608842253685,
0.14949041604995728,
-0.7419207692146301,
1.085174322128296,
-0.2897942364215851,
-0.06080799177289009,
-0.06741510331630707,
0.40449273586273193,
0.14086012542247772,
0.48705726861953735,
0.49409937858581543,
0.7150449752807617,
0.45726338028907776,
-0.34121173620224,
0.037080056965351105,
0.19209147989749908,
-0.4735698103904724,
0.3805428743362427,
-0.7217008471488953,
-0.3079968988895416,
-0.08501902967691422,
-0.012630656361579895,
-0.6353150606155396,
0.19599148631095886,
0.3630680441856384,
-0.1895841360092163,
0.16100740432739258,
-0.07298176735639572,
-0.3136892020702362,
0.10380566865205765,
-0.4127841889858246,
0.37904664874076843,
0.2622700035572052,
-0.8698116540908813,
0.5319440960884094,
0.21778586506843567,
-0.010680211707949638,
-0.8191140294075012,
-1.0423840284347534,
0.3188457489013672,
-0.18872703611850739,
-0.5296101570129395,
0.4841036796569824,
0.018443409353494644,
-0.3140924274921417,
0.1406567245721817,
0.07627327740192413,
-0.19255366921424866,
-0.12971492111682892,
-0.1658228635787964,
0.1075785756111145,
-0.35360535979270935,
-0.1548885852098465,
0.04383496940135956,
-0.3110162615776062,
0.16754944622516632,
-0.42624011635780334,
0.21462921798229218,
0.1985814869403839,
-0.07823622226715088,
-0.21607878804206848,
0.48649102449417114,
0.3277980089187622,
-0.08471554517745972,
0.5327181816101074,
0.6310884356498718,
-0.10682003200054169,
-0.6346768736839294,
-0.2951771318912506,
0.1469360589981079,
-0.42187294363975525,
0.23124247789382935,
-0.5812296271324158,
-0.4933179020881653,
0.3031674325466156,
-0.020316921174526215,
0.24717916548252106,
-0.015503901988267899,
0.3413236737251282,
0.055856749415397644,
0.38070711493492126,
0.6218491792678833,
-0.33431553840637207,
0.3286453187465668,
-0.6770347356796265,
0.027072031050920486,
-0.6801196336746216,
0.11189386248588562,
-0.44188886880874634,
-0.5082096457481384,
-0.7052747011184692,
-0.6336812973022461,
0.08234237879514694,
-0.10051439702510834,
0.37253567576408386,
0.521476686000824,
0.00850449874997139,
0.4467347264289856,
0.6412692666053772,
0.2756345868110657,
0.5023642182350159,
0.07399740815162659,
0.03807121887803078,
-0.19180569052696228,
-1.097305417060852,
-0.3906729221343994,
1.1702224016189575,
0.16931453347206116,
0.5205747485160828,
0.326801598072052,
0.7745288014411926,
0.3179119825363159,
0.29739972949028015,
-0.6056159138679504,
0.35917627811431885,
-0.5553061366081238,
-0.42098933458328247,
-0.41998961567878723,
-0.626481831073761,
-1.1531627178192139,
0.47082892060279846,
-0.3126504123210907,
-0.6975799798965454,
0.5946673154830933,
-0.15561488270759583,
-0.12778547406196594,
0.49524152278900146,
-0.6343339681625366,
1.0617666244506836,
-0.6242104172706604,
-0.6536560654640198,
-0.11400027573108673,
-0.4942516088485718,
0.3529128134250641,
-0.3622620105743408,
0.23770932853221893,
-0.04668695479631424,
-0.1971980631351471,
0.6427589058876038,
-0.2240341156721115,
0.9345427751541138,
-0.09987770766019821,
-0.40341123938560486,
0.03031964600086212,
-0.20075704157352448,
0.21581700444221497,
0.2819552421569824,
-0.6529431343078613,
0.424810528755188,
0.1931062638759613,
-0.613889753818512,
-0.8631215691566467,
0.7151543498039246,
-0.81989586353302,
-0.22099871933460236,
-0.19799114763736725,
-0.45804810523986816,
0.02589326910674572,
0.06491241604089737,
0.412733256816864,
0.5691248178482056,
-0.5639756917953491,
-0.084339939057827,
0.7684586644172668,
-0.3500431776046753,
0.30638402700424194,
0.4626076817512512,
-0.46001386642456055,
-0.3053756654262543,
0.9920604825019836,
0.29640960693359375,
0.19715330004692078,
0.6217141151428223,
0.1662263721227646,
-0.4950161874294281,
-0.3914041221141815,
-0.8331305980682373,
0.3815160095691681,
-0.6648598909378052,
0.2401418685913086,
-0.3725961446762085,
0.0018678606720641255,
0.03261799365282059,
-0.11989500373601913,
-0.37490084767341614,
-0.5847395062446594,
0.028808824717998505,
-0.025444304570555687,
0.21599531173706055,
0.449135959148407,
-0.12556813657283783,
0.20832917094230652,
-0.7261992692947388,
0.3370887339115143,
-0.096201092004776,
0.17337840795516968,
-0.24892273545265198,
-0.3675686717033386,
-0.29226720333099365,
-0.0682305172085762,
0.5036400556564331,
-0.6742165684700012,
0.30136460065841675,
0.3701813519001007,
0.7622292041778564,
-0.02066675014793873,
0.26627317070961,
0.32918331027030945,
-0.47682422399520874,
0.33999374508857727,
0.1490517407655716,
-0.745808482170105,
0.15416373312473297,
-0.07092473655939102,
0.23525406420230865,
0.7629196643829346,
0.729051411151886,
-0.5941376090049744,
-0.21562764048576355,
-0.3343135416507721,
-0.6468374729156494,
0.4523355960845947,
0.17846187949180603,
0.009466046467423439,
-0.014446995221078396,
0.45720529556274414,
0.346309632062912,
0.013491890393197536,
-0.933172881603241,
-0.30609747767448425,
0.20146073400974274,
-0.1288284957408905,
-0.25823190808296204,
0.1400696039199829,
-0.014914378523826599,
-0.21475321054458618,
0.8271970748901367,
-0.20939266681671143,
-0.05650138854980469,
0.26024433970451355,
-0.3741369843482971,
0.1893554925918579,
0.23631466925144196,
0.12732328474521637,
0.6222910284996033,
-0.04242007061839104,
-0.14482876658439636,
0.4753952622413635,
-0.11395914852619171,
0.317006915807724,
-0.074129119515419,
-0.1887286901473999,
0.3814539611339569,
0.5313892960548401,
0.9545424580574036,
0.5271784663200378,
-0.7723484635353088,
0.48174604773521423,
-0.2782266438007355,
-0.3635053336620331,
-0.3451896905899048,
0.009804259054362774,
-0.22415083646774292,
0.22766657173633575,
0.0940483883023262,
-0.06859332323074341,
0.12280247360467911,
-0.43101581931114197,
0.34960082173347473,
0.09175840765237808,
-0.25238698720932007,
-0.511628270149231,
0.477857381105423,
0.18664613366127014,
-0.06826528161764145,
0.2489136904478073,
-0.3341958820819855,
-0.3064676821231842,
0.27378594875335693,
0.2504652142524719,
0.6352847814559937,
-0.11843997240066528,
0.3539588153362274,
0.340799480676651,
0.4844675362110138,
0.014398565515875816,
0.640445351600647,
-0.08985655009746552,
-0.811558723449707,
-1.0125967264175415,
-0.3729366958141327,
-0.33932602405548096,
-0.017641406506299973,
-0.7137059569358826,
0.44706302881240845,
-0.12223164737224579,
-0.11813856661319733,
-0.2069900929927826,
0.0017330256523564458,
-0.6990698575973511,
0.24391642212867737,
0.121502585709095,
1.3321694135665894,
-1.2196604013442993,
1.178723692893982,
0.5536147356033325,
0.027829542756080627,
-0.3110986351966858,
-0.2691495418548584,
-0.10226120054721832,
-0.6363282799720764,
0.8524344563484192,
-0.14694318175315857,
-0.34850043058395386,
-0.10504443943500519,
0.24056319892406464,
-0.841505229473114,
0.6544577479362488,
0.46323952078819275,
-0.5320376753807068,
-0.056904200464487076,
0.4747970402240753,
0.5373859405517578,
-0.17444348335266113,
0.21558165550231934,
0.8132511377334595,
0.5519641041755676,
-0.36882510781288147,
-0.875407874584198,
-0.12930621206760406,
-0.5226866602897644,
-0.12940259277820587,
0.2859622538089752,
-0.4173021912574768,
0.6017469763755798,
0.16950394213199615,
-0.20775580406188965,
0.190228670835495,
0.6149370074272156,
-0.10828543454408646,
0.2175380438566208,
0.5932424664497375,
0.783554196357727,
0.8259395956993103,
-0.0843002125620842,
1.2086535692214966,
-0.431423157453537,
-0.08977492153644562,
1.391669511795044,
-0.3242245018482208,
0.9891798496246338,
0.5640530586242676,
0.039354126900434494,
0.5621622204780579,
0.3850303888320923,
0.18944133818149567,
0.42510986328125,
0.30806970596313477,
-0.36664721369743347,
0.10762183368206024,
-0.2205369770526886,
-0.24378913640975952,
0.3834432065486908,
0.29409030079841614,
-0.23118282854557037,
-0.2896379828453064,
0.2743226885795593,
0.044578056782484055,
0.11601793020963669,
-0.0639740526676178,
0.5555793642997742,
-0.009945983998477459,
-0.3820815980434418,
0.9286707639694214,
-0.16314944624900818,
0.6905661225318909,
-0.6141465306282043,
0.14706996083259583,
-0.28058555722236633,
0.08751516789197922,
-0.45771265029907227,
-0.8331745266914368,
0.5171630382537842,
-0.02545367367565632,
-0.2040056586265564,
-0.13902592658996582,
0.24554061889648438,
-0.5524256825447083,
-0.691413402557373,
1.0348149538040161,
0.882593035697937,
0.2739119827747345,
0.3054236173629761,
-0.7689602375030518,
0.2033763974905014,
0.08758033812046051,
-0.12670068442821503,
0.32552674412727356,
0.7107991576194763,
-0.3491578996181488,
0.5069097876548767,
0.3690282702445984,
0.3979104161262512,
0.42607152462005615,
0.4126238524913788,
0.6937839984893799,
-0.3283163905143738,
-0.35516777634620667,
-0.4703485071659088,
0.5268826484680176,
-0.24811722338199615,
-0.4380672872066498,
0.8069859743118286,
0.6602194905281067,
1.071765422821045,
0.020037226378917694,
1.0196043252944946,
0.10783228278160095,
0.3483946919441223,
-0.6811003684997559,
0.2627561092376709,
-0.7252845168113708,
0.16382575035095215,
-0.13889315724372864,
-0.807008683681488,
-0.5192478895187378,
0.44342222809791565,
-0.4554143249988556,
-0.36733877658843994,
0.7090947031974792,
0.9696540236473083,
-0.31167376041412354,
-0.025871213525533676,
0.48780208826065063,
-0.14345264434814453,
-0.10707920789718628,
0.685044527053833,
0.6962596774101257,
-0.8183004856109619,
0.5292520523071289,
-0.4277636706829071,
-0.5019044280052185,
0.3633303642272949,
-0.9358355402946472,
-1.0296292304992676,
-0.13735339045524597,
-0.3951282799243927,
-0.0839555412530899,
0.32670968770980835,
0.9118865728378296,
0.7377357482910156,
-0.8171721696853638,
-0.7946657538414001,
0.016055725514888763,
0.1346367746591568,
-0.31801775097846985,
-0.17191852629184723,
0.31847602128982544,
-0.4138205051422119,
-1.02519953250885,
0.8357609510421753,
0.0483686625957489,
-0.36526572704315186,
-0.3229524791240692,
-0.267626017332077,
-0.3342255651950836,
-0.12258922308683395,
0.658928394317627,
0.41564199328422546,
-0.43641042709350586,
0.009154452942311764,
0.1747584342956543,
0.09804008901119232,
0.39266857504844666,
0.729820728302002,
-0.7365983724594116,
0.22301994264125824,
0.6247860193252563,
1.0478342771530151,
0.5780225396156311,
-0.42193785309791565,
0.9370012283325195,
-0.9003732204437256,
0.3585050106048584,
-0.3061355650424957,
0.5068290829658508,
0.19337503612041473,
-0.29170265793800354,
0.8831254839897156,
0.028917865827679634,
-0.18307316303253174,
-0.5817022323608398,
0.05368828400969505,
-0.6161219477653503,
-0.30681198835372925,
0.749082624912262,
-0.20735172927379608,
-0.6044501066207886,
-0.3587696850299835,
-0.18053166568279266,
-0.01239869836717844,
-0.09354592114686966,
0.396275132894516,
0.274029940366745,
-0.020095452666282654,
-0.3214168846607208,
-0.982712984085083,
0.36645469069480896,
0.5585395097732544,
-0.8414359092712402,
-0.03314345329999924,
-0.019760804250836372,
0.08959516882896423,
0.24318815767765045,
0.5462281703948975,
-0.08656569570302963,
0.3301367461681366,
-0.12159465998411179,
0.1203508973121643,
0.4631555676460266,
-0.3344916105270386,
-0.33642467856407166,
-0.010312606580555439,
-0.042156580835580826,
-0.10591014474630356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06970v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06970v1
|
Hybrid Multi-stage Decoding for Few-shot NER with Entity-aware Contrastive Learning
| 2024-04-10T12:31:09 | 2024-04-10T12:31:09 |
Peipei Liu, Gaosheng Wang, Ying Tong, Jian Liang, Zhenquan Ding, Hongsong Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Few-shot named entity recognition can identify new types of named entities
based on a few labeled examples. Previous methods employing token-level or
span-level metric learning suffer from the computational burden and a large
number of negative sample spans. In this paper, we propose the Hybrid
Multi-stage Decoding for Few-shot NER with Entity-aware Contrastive Learning
(MsFNER), which splits the general NER into two stages: entity-span detection
and entity classification. There are 3 processes for introducing MsFNER:
training, finetuning, and inference. In the training process, we train and get
the best entity-span detection model and the entity classification model
separately on the source domain using meta-learning, where we create a
contrastive learning module to enhance entity representations for entity
classification. During finetuning, we finetune the both models on the support
dataset of target domain. In the inference process, for the unlabeled data, we
first detect the entity-spans, then the entity-spans are jointly determined by
the entity classification model and the KNN. We conduct experiments on the open
FewNERD dataset and the results demonstrate the advance of MsFNER.
|
[
-0.6063981652259827,
-0.5299919247627258,
0.10652864724397659,
-0.03980490192770958,
-0.34007787704467773,
0.10877177864313126,
0.0820324718952179,
-0.6306058168411255,
0.23171573877334595,
0.35640281438827515,
-0.5804287791252136,
-0.463366836309433,
-0.5257240533828735,
0.4452023506164551,
-0.16808271408081055,
1.291621208190918,
0.015431034378707409,
0.41971468925476074,
0.24409528076648712,
-0.057672105729579926,
0.0258109662681818,
-0.23889946937561035,
-0.9498293399810791,
-0.4727270305156708,
0.3962384760379791,
0.6475855708122253,
-0.0528440847992897,
0.2656763792037964,
0.42128652334213257,
0.2746560573577881,
-0.12254936993122101,
0.2643745243549347,
-0.5388340950012207,
-0.20548422634601593,
-0.051630400121212006,
-0.4168051481246948,
-0.15794695913791656,
-0.4379454553127289,
0.7034509778022766,
0.40535542368888855,
-0.03278084099292755,
0.011394054628908634,
0.24266430735588074,
0.3109910488128662,
-0.9350571632385254,
0.03859323635697365,
-0.6289372444152832,
0.09961777925491333,
-0.22934703528881073,
-0.1374853104352951,
-0.5492960810661316,
0.11871694028377533,
-0.06365332007408142,
-0.764187753200531,
0.5785020589828491,
0.10175512731075287,
0.9632741808891296,
0.0787501260638237,
-0.6098006963729858,
0.021129721775650978,
-0.8128694295883179,
0.7536420226097107,
-0.5261018872261047,
0.38709503412246704,
0.2554910480976105,
0.4188842177391052,
-0.07942324876785278,
-0.5361157059669495,
-0.9044871926307678,
0.1944669783115387,
-0.3241111636161804,
0.21446895599365234,
-0.19298109412193298,
0.23515743017196655,
0.011063837446272373,
0.4132309854030609,
-0.5403619408607483,
0.27242517471313477,
-0.34567558765411377,
-0.3629463016986847,
0.13701298832893372,
0.3474521040916443,
0.007390584331005812,
-0.6500188112258911,
-0.5685344338417053,
-0.0511755645275116,
-0.3478493094444275,
-0.29124316573143005,
0.18486981093883514,
0.5410082340240479,
-0.23846131563186646,
0.4443119764328003,
-0.2989860475063324,
0.3910745084285736,
0.44882825016975403,
-0.41687485575675964,
0.38036778569221497,
-0.5007264614105225,
-0.3320302367210388,
0.08275706321001053,
0.7226356267929077,
0.1442476511001587,
-0.060485415160655975,
0.00086360948625952,
-0.33258727192878723,
0.2343742996454239,
-0.16815447807312012,
-0.9549577236175537,
-0.2576441466808319,
-0.032879043370485306,
-0.5526524782180786,
-0.0650414228439331,
-0.15596966445446014,
-1.0129621028900146,
-0.39613091945648193,
-0.03689981624484062,
0.5757554769515991,
-0.7181389927864075,
-0.40112006664276123,
-0.05403544753789902,
-0.11593760550022125,
0.3532247841358185,
0.14492546021938324,
-0.7266328930854797,
0.7277390360832214,
0.54982990026474,
0.775866687297821,
-0.08199658244848251,
-0.3522144556045532,
-0.7945280075073242,
0.1307349056005478,
-0.07977700978517532,
0.9150513410568237,
-0.4468313753604889,
-0.16653908789157867,
-0.2471732795238495,
-0.17128290235996246,
-0.3014356195926666,
-0.4504133462905884,
0.45378851890563965,
-0.7700298428535461,
0.10824020206928253,
0.1408541053533554,
-0.6421659588813782,
-0.1326666921377182,
0.4169635474681854,
-0.7937842011451721,
0.8689195513725281,
-0.07395851612091064,
-1.2092822790145874,
0.6590927243232727,
-0.5674891471862793,
-0.5092760324478149,
0.06527048349380493,
-0.2976868450641632,
-0.531309187412262,
0.05058266222476959,
0.3354843854904175,
0.5148377418518066,
0.06541527062654495,
-0.13790765404701233,
-0.1094134971499443,
-0.3000573217868805,
-0.11164071410894394,
-0.28148943185806274,
0.3327876329421997,
0.01803586445748806,
-0.333219438791275,
-0.14720256626605988,
-1.2812062501907349,
-0.236960306763649,
0.16447347402572632,
-0.4697440564632416,
-0.37128952145576477,
-0.2957693636417389,
0.3888123631477356,
0.4435250163078308,
-0.3675875961780548,
-0.6302176713943481,
-0.2041710764169693,
-0.42499542236328125,
0.11055915802717209,
0.47715380787849426,
0.46346592903137207,
0.8475762605667114,
-0.0018724377732723951,
0.4990592300891876,
0.536715567111969,
-0.3549903333187103,
-0.3492874503135681,
-0.07388066500425339,
-1.0295822620391846,
-0.4573146104812622,
0.4546370506286621,
0.6115762591362,
-1.2256927490234375,
0.24753828346729279,
-0.15531304478645325,
-0.026552585884928703,
-0.6258928179740906,
0.04721268266439438,
0.5571984648704529,
0.9193388819694519,
0.846241295337677,
0.043433498591184616,
-0.7282123565673828,
-0.9492530822753906,
-0.0206376314163208,
0.214755117893219,
0.09849385172128677,
0.3597080409526825,
1.0159704685211182,
-0.11570577323436737,
0.4659072458744049,
-0.3961701989173889,
-0.6896721720695496,
-0.5207430720329285,
0.39729371666908264,
0.1305299997329712,
0.5726984143257141,
0.05851907283067703,
-0.727327823638916,
-0.46383076906204224,
-0.024071775376796722,
-0.4646003544330597,
0.47046855092048645,
-0.2271701842546463,
-0.2207169234752655,
0.011015770025551319,
0.3979300260543823,
-0.30264467000961304,
0.0688820481300354,
0.3550710678100586,
0.03251196816563606,
0.2914673388004303,
0.010532276704907417,
0.15224505960941315,
-1.3460361957550049,
-0.06330984085798264,
0.3414631485939026,
-0.3303191363811493,
-0.724971354007721,
-0.03428106755018234,
0.027375154197216034,
-0.0021494412794709206,
-0.45895346999168396,
0.37256479263305664,
-0.6626118421554565,
-0.17737874388694763,
-0.40759071707725525,
0.07139880210161209,
0.04786447063088417,
0.3466379642486572,
0.33341488242149353,
0.4670616686344147,
0.5817221999168396,
-0.7507635951042175,
-0.26744768023490906,
0.2705146372318268,
-0.22654502093791962,
0.9390291571617126,
-0.33027395606040955,
0.21931302547454834,
-0.36668670177459717,
0.6563785672187805,
-0.6677750945091248,
-0.3313484489917755,
0.34465599060058594,
-0.22163672745227814,
0.5754052400588989,
-0.5689884424209595,
-0.5368695855140686,
-0.27055099606513977,
-0.01051472406834364,
0.3319917321205139,
0.04710309952497482,
-0.5599204897880554,
0.8731633424758911,
0.06113574281334877,
0.19915179908275604,
-0.6937904953956604,
-1.094761610031128,
-0.1437995284795761,
-0.1345640867948532,
-0.4708206057548523,
0.6150733828544617,
0.20315566658973694,
0.32217228412628174,
0.26358944177627563,
-0.41651421785354614,
-0.30301791429519653,
-0.39261895418167114,
0.15541371703147888,
0.2679649591445923,
-0.6518715620040894,
-0.08472747355699539,
0.15557079017162323,
-0.7165518403053284,
-0.4845104217529297,
-0.36936110258102417,
0.41939249634742737,
-0.06540203839540482,
-0.11846878379583359,
-0.5239914655685425,
0.40282317996025085,
-0.022276034578680992,
-0.3565106987953186,
0.9459958672523499,
0.9743528366088867,
-0.8095675110816956,
-0.30198872089385986,
-0.4033161401748657,
-0.34273824095726013,
-0.3971671462059021,
0.15010465681552887,
-0.7732222676277161,
-1.0031310319900513,
0.38583001494407654,
-0.2056911289691925,
-0.31246882677078247,
0.6841400861740112,
0.22186951339244843,
-0.10132627189159393,
0.7604547142982483,
0.782394528388977,
-0.024678189307451248,
0.37749436497688293,
-0.6788042187690735,
-0.007298896089196205,
-0.867863655090332,
-0.44705653190612793,
-0.42581596970558167,
-0.5052674412727356,
-0.5531921982765198,
-0.2033127397298813,
0.4275422990322113,
0.3430483043193817,
-0.16061106324195862,
0.31590932607650757,
-0.1698494255542755,
0.9560362100601196,
0.37117356061935425,
0.4444520175457001,
0.47515934705734253,
0.02745831198990345,
-0.3475579619407654,
-0.16247807443141937,
-0.5943038463592529,
-0.08913654834032059,
0.6780949831008911,
0.11344118416309357,
0.7404085993766785,
-0.08040028810501099,
1.3871220350265503,
-0.08683153241872787,
-0.057889893651008606,
-0.8471145629882812,
0.29410451650619507,
-0.2395603209733963,
-0.7594231367111206,
-0.09976359456777573,
-0.5160265564918518,
-0.6533308029174805,
0.5220741033554077,
-0.6046183109283447,
-0.6617420315742493,
0.45838990807533264,
0.27427247166633606,
-0.5499706864356995,
0.3356967568397522,
-0.6186032891273499,
0.8411001563072205,
0.05349567532539368,
-0.20348115265369415,
-0.2766205072402954,
-0.948718249797821,
0.6404410004615784,
0.1601535826921463,
0.03317798674106598,
0.22309942543506622,
-0.08666883409023285,
0.734129786491394,
-0.15644122660160065,
0.7838890552520752,
-0.2635103762149811,
0.4527004361152649,
0.11591633409261703,
0.1654587835073471,
0.6477663516998291,
0.04791776463389397,
-0.02557978220283985,
-0.2691029906272888,
-0.20057697594165802,
-0.469891756772995,
-0.29966431856155396,
0.6546525359153748,
-0.5114312767982483,
0.07415910810232162,
-0.5077968239784241,
0.013787922449409962,
-0.21637310087680817,
0.45979997515678406,
0.6294170022010803,
0.2494756132364273,
-0.2774519622325897,
0.034011997282505035,
0.7422221899032593,
0.12635518610477448,
0.4819749593734741,
0.4575081169605255,
0.12896762788295746,
-0.6198757290840149,
0.9221243262290955,
-0.24198965728282928,
0.1210549846291542,
0.772743284702301,
-0.13072523474693298,
-0.06400036066770554,
-0.7137385606765747,
-0.4802039861679077,
0.37597164511680603,
-0.8526318669319153,
-0.50321364402771,
-0.8657976388931274,
-0.1551293432712555,
0.025062596425414085,
-0.11481236666440964,
-0.43150627613067627,
0.04841644689440727,
-0.5576958656311035,
-0.2514415681362152,
0.10432843118906021,
0.5195230841636658,
-0.21996505558490753,
0.5191304087638855,
-0.8579174876213074,
0.8243945837020874,
0.00045308851986192167,
0.12553603947162628,
0.015523319132626057,
-0.42690494656562805,
-0.21936732530593872,
-0.30905741453170776,
0.15230214595794678,
-0.9438186883926392,
0.09862740337848663,
0.47902825474739075,
0.44083213806152344,
0.6673759818077087,
-0.01032085157930851,
0.7911812663078308,
-0.6265291571617126,
0.4057541489601135,
0.5076590776443481,
-0.9127660393714905,
0.5319638848304749,
0.07924037426710129,
0.17672738432884216,
0.924144446849823,
0.6435703039169312,
-0.3946952521800995,
0.11470938473939896,
-0.4667661190032959,
-0.6708634495735168,
1.1223050355911255,
0.05733445659279823,
0.13358886539936066,
-0.03622214123606682,
0.010344652459025383,
0.3164333701133728,
-0.15671880543231964,
-0.8547767400741577,
-0.44251465797424316,
-0.20832806825637817,
-0.03456587344408035,
0.033356454223394394,
-0.03663117066025734,
0.003094207961112261,
-0.03804025799036026,
0.5529878735542297,
-0.27793923020362854,
0.2513015866279602,
-0.00809655524790287,
-0.6136080622673035,
-0.09121811389923096,
0.6269174218177795,
0.40173324942588806,
0.11579938232898712,
-0.05383167415857315,
0.43124425411224365,
0.5261493921279907,
-0.15841573476791382,
0.22983072698116302,
0.42523297667503357,
-0.05893990769982338,
0.014833520166575909,
0.37516549229621887,
0.9403348565101624,
0.6683703064918518,
-0.020888857543468475,
0.5862971544265747,
0.18733611702919006,
-0.12888911366462708,
0.08617183566093445,
-0.05374537780880928,
0.05155705288052559,
0.5364274382591248,
0.3782189190387726,
0.3050878942012787,
0.5006158947944641,
-0.1684563159942627,
0.38862186670303345,
0.05151303857564926,
-0.14218325912952423,
-0.3031255304813385,
0.45515939593315125,
0.19906719028949738,
0.24310724437236786,
0.6094275712966919,
-0.6839249730110168,
-0.5395784974098206,
0.41827890276908875,
0.9464175701141357,
0.7562798261642456,
-0.07168878614902496,
0.423745334148407,
0.6485654711723328,
0.14155061542987823,
0.012892872095108032,
0.24393408000469208,
-0.08459477871656418,
-0.9645491242408752,
-0.4196680784225464,
-0.6905357241630554,
-0.1340903639793396,
0.3929218649864197,
-0.6885305643081665,
0.3477093577384949,
-0.5332121253013611,
0.03712913393974304,
0.4107635021209717,
-0.085844486951828,
-0.9107373356819153,
0.29066652059555054,
0.33949464559555054,
0.783785879611969,
-0.8545942306518555,
0.5487474799156189,
0.4674628973007202,
-0.7696428298950195,
-0.5793314576148987,
0.12555544078350067,
0.44730129837989807,
-0.578757107257843,
0.7284995913505554,
0.29762840270996094,
-0.3929307758808136,
0.25260332226753235,
-0.23629121482372284,
-0.5651469826698303,
1.1076157093048096,
0.095766581594944,
-0.615260660648346,
-0.2878103256225586,
-0.34424179792404175,
0.35963553190231323,
-0.5277195572853088,
0.2784869372844696,
0.5220247507095337,
0.2875414192676544,
0.2982131540775299,
-0.5693651437759399,
-0.05331044644117355,
-0.09844904392957687,
0.009679448790848255,
0.46391674876213074,
-0.3333660662174225,
0.7146885991096497,
-0.39535391330718994,
-0.48657190799713135,
-0.07147222757339478,
0.7955935001373291,
0.17119964957237244,
0.547832727432251,
0.5450355410575867,
0.6131402850151062,
0.6173080801963806,
0.1137705147266388,
0.8818687200546265,
0.05634170398116112,
0.3962329924106598,
1.3227089643478394,
-0.09737125039100647,
1.125884771347046,
0.26197221875190735,
-0.13424310088157654,
0.6452860236167908,
0.6347577571868896,
-0.19088852405548096,
0.7938608527183533,
0.013899539597332478,
-0.4679531157016754,
-0.30215132236480713,
-0.040499601513147354,
-0.2892550528049469,
0.44925040006637573,
0.43720167875289917,
-0.37271660566329956,
-0.5907249450683594,
0.37966492772102356,
0.06814920902252197,
-0.302420973777771,
-0.41536420583724976,
0.9635538458824158,
0.14049150049686432,
-0.03627324476838112,
0.36448046565055847,
0.2805483043193817,
1.0687472820281982,
-0.4727499186992645,
-0.07530467212200165,
-0.19573836028575897,
0.26387882232666016,
-0.6022219061851501,
-0.4586847126483917,
0.006788032129406929,
0.12006185203790665,
-0.30367881059646606,
0.2672748565673828,
1.0506033897399902,
-0.48857396841049194,
-0.3368099331855774,
0.4231342375278473,
0.602428674697876,
0.06877745687961578,
-0.018682178109884262,
-0.6972033977508545,
-0.4181058406829834,
-0.37704142928123474,
-0.015846379101276398,
0.3092813789844513,
0.3130367696285248,
0.2407252937555313,
0.2884376347064972,
0.5180301070213318,
-0.16218167543411255,
0.2896869480609894,
0.3224954903125763,
0.8824215531349182,
-0.659803569316864,
-0.6928126811981201,
-0.6508844494819641,
0.6533312201499939,
-0.00028379878494888544,
-0.2144874483346939,
0.31707707047462463,
0.6462284326553345,
1.0527704954147339,
-0.09796570986509323,
0.4934327006340027,
0.014765710569918156,
0.3890223801136017,
-0.7554031014442444,
0.3868982493877411,
-0.4169709384441376,
-0.12077218294143677,
-0.3523048460483551,
-0.8874646425247192,
-0.4277561902999878,
0.4465769827365875,
-0.043625883758068085,
0.220122292637825,
0.8557772040367126,
0.8120620250701904,
-0.5938140749931335,
-0.09326866269111633,
0.2780221402645111,
-0.06832265853881836,
-0.15887631475925446,
0.6567450761795044,
0.7775232195854187,
-0.5453293323516846,
0.8887671828269958,
-0.5167976021766663,
-0.0670519694685936,
-0.40570107102394104,
-0.6584434509277344,
-0.80476313829422,
-0.33237481117248535,
-0.38484060764312744,
-0.3317897915840149,
-0.09581075608730316,
0.8802607655525208,
0.8916799426078796,
-1.0955709218978882,
0.3030393421649933,
-0.24913573265075684,
0.04775777459144592,
-0.11028692126274109,
-0.2874374985694885,
0.18768024444580078,
-0.2441914826631546,
-0.772803783416748,
0.5940485596656799,
0.265203595161438,
0.17305797338485718,
0.055657487362623215,
-0.2433422952890396,
-0.46126508712768555,
-0.31949537992477417,
0.49689191579818726,
0.362867534160614,
-0.5792222619056702,
0.019419819116592407,
-0.00166028062812984,
-0.24597199261188507,
0.2420070916414261,
0.9944067001342773,
-0.6231076121330261,
0.3476104736328125,
0.5256086587905884,
0.911788284778595,
1.131248116493225,
-0.22408084571361542,
-0.07174231112003326,
-1.0468761920928955,
-0.06099759787321091,
0.21678945422172546,
0.4424189627170563,
0.4098615050315857,
-0.2910584807395935,
0.24660778045654297,
0.25417834520339966,
-0.09331884235143661,
-0.45395660400390625,
0.20316001772880554,
-0.8322115540504456,
-0.028661679476499557,
0.8972448706626892,
-0.03238874301314354,
0.1582717001438141,
0.02269222028553486,
0.04947344958782196,
0.38352563977241516,
-0.5545274019241333,
0.06150700896978378,
0.5107520818710327,
-0.5234048962593079,
-0.6379945874214172,
-0.21137665212154388,
0.3569713532924652,
0.09315694868564606,
-0.8788650631904602,
-0.6407338380813599,
0.6714828610420227,
0.4640081822872162,
0.24747128784656525,
0.6932849884033203,
0.041979361325502396,
0.25294458866119385,
0.5478233695030212,
-0.12638840079307556,
-0.011221032589673996,
-0.657105028629303,
-0.7469856142997742,
0.20545418560504913,
-0.2559187710285187,
-0.5941200852394104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06964v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06964v1
|
Charles Translator: A Machine Translation System between Ukrainian and Czech
| 2024-04-10T12:22:32 | 2024-04-10T12:22:32 |
Martin Popel, Lucie Poláková, Michal Novák, Jindřich Helcl, Jindřich Libovický, Pavel Straňák, Tomáš Krabač, Jaroslava Hlaváčová, Mariia Anisimova, Tereza Chlaňová
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present Charles Translator, a machine translation system between Ukrainian
and Czech, developed as part of a society-wide effort to mitigate the impact of
the Russian-Ukrainian war on individuals and society. The system was developed
in the spring of 2022 with the help of many language data providers in order to
quickly meet the demand for such a service, which was not available at the time
in the required quality. The translator was later implemented as an online web
interface and as an Android app with speech input, both featuring
Cyrillic-Latin script transliteration. The system translates directly, compared
to other available systems that use English as a pivot, and thus take advantage
of the typological similarity of the two languages. It uses the block
back-translation method, which allows for efficient use of monolingual training
data. The paper describes the development process, including data collection
and implementation, evaluation, mentions several use cases, and outlines
possibilities for the further development of the system for educational
purposes.
|
[
-0.11791839450597763,
-0.3290952444076538,
0.5723040699958801,
0.500754177570343,
-0.6083272695541382,
0.5320771336555481,
-0.16453713178634644,
-0.6491893529891968,
0.352538526058197,
0.49389952421188354,
-0.38105258345603943,
-0.5519221425056458,
-0.3825218975543976,
0.27684295177459717,
-0.6889214515686035,
0.6774643659591675,
-0.10387768596410751,
0.8254120349884033,
0.20988215506076813,
0.04114067927002907,
-0.521355152130127,
-0.611952006816864,
-0.49278348684310913,
-0.26259520649909973,
0.2133665382862091,
0.5306712985038757,
0.5704397559165955,
0.5232403874397278,
0.667631983757019,
0.38416334986686707,
0.15107117593288422,
-0.3272664546966553,
-0.4399721324443817,
0.3203277885913849,
-0.3358688950538635,
-0.4127560257911682,
-0.2425435334444046,
-0.5019456744194031,
0.7329651117324829,
0.6086496114730835,
0.0902940183877945,
0.16569776833057404,
0.20107297599315643,
0.862254798412323,
-0.23055675625801086,
-0.044327106326818466,
-0.37958431243896484,
-0.04281924292445183,
-0.07042402029037476,
-0.37722301483154297,
-0.47771599888801575,
-0.9479065537452698,
-0.08245965093374252,
-0.5438523888587952,
-0.19509314000606537,
0.09680105000734329,
0.48804301023483276,
-0.11740844696760178,
-0.6044524312019348,
-0.532691478729248,
-0.8808813095092773,
0.9659422636032104,
-0.16295671463012695,
0.43185266852378845,
0.46780338883399963,
0.6474860310554504,
-0.206488236784935,
-0.41304653882980347,
-0.18190547823905945,
0.08435776084661484,
-0.07706980407238007,
0.22646915912628174,
-0.2440284937620163,
-0.1769273728132248,
-0.4973588287830353,
0.09325379878282547,
-0.6997593641281128,
-0.3752528429031372,
-0.861063539981842,
-0.402479887008667,
0.5325214266777039,
0.5592465996742249,
0.31563064455986023,
-0.03847864642739296,
-0.1831779181957245,
0.1258043795824051,
-0.534588634967804,
0.14097166061401367,
0.44809582829475403,
0.590559184551239,
-0.22489774227142334,
0.8285142779350281,
-0.31307244300842285,
0.6258093118667603,
0.1379472315311432,
0.02814376913011074,
0.011084137484431267,
-0.8476800918579102,
-0.1777539849281311,
0.4573984146118164,
0.5924345850944519,
0.5204870700836182,
0.0022300193086266518,
-0.2178756147623062,
0.044041525572538376,
0.03846036642789841,
0.21536540985107422,
-0.9383826851844788,
0.03092900663614273,
0.02482249028980732,
-0.53268963098526,
-0.4657794237136841,
-0.08906827867031097,
-0.8359585404396057,
-0.21738603711128235,
-0.21814391016960144,
0.12717987596988678,
-0.3398253917694092,
0.07085960358381271,
0.1906377077102661,
0.028948673978447914,
0.12446010112762451,
0.4761945605278015,
-0.8326115012168884,
0.4967222511768341,
0.3364977240562439,
0.8586573600769043,
-0.1241597831249237,
-0.00850699096918106,
-0.671758234500885,
-0.184707373380661,
-0.6577293276786804,
0.7328783869743347,
-0.5977244973182678,
-0.5646990537643433,
0.08916214853525162,
0.40289777517318726,
0.3817799389362335,
-0.5770226716995239,
0.42066875100135803,
-0.5095897316932678,
0.17895916104316711,
0.048941001296043396,
-0.223646879196167,
-0.050368115305900574,
0.0036058342084288597,
-0.3806845545768738,
0.8343365788459778,
0.3239710032939911,
-0.5715480446815491,
0.2310861200094223,
-0.19768649339675903,
-0.48624882102012634,
0.3994583189487457,
-0.11914996057748795,
-0.13738349080085754,
-0.10437503457069397,
-0.3668619990348816,
0.2666241526603699,
-0.5775613188743591,
0.015886571258306503,
-0.18702805042266846,
-0.5573737621307373,
0.16156472265720367,
0.2909013330936432,
1.1853103637695312,
0.2798524498939514,
-0.16376444697380066,
0.15176019072532654,
-0.607615053653717,
0.3152158856391907,
-0.08540196716785431,
-1.070238471031189,
-0.46796175837516785,
0.12268819659948349,
0.5213192105293274,
0.31216326355934143,
0.42203059792518616,
-0.5901318788528442,
0.4172855615615845,
-0.4066500961780548,
0.5176448225975037,
0.2745239734649658,
-0.28648728132247925,
0.6599240303039551,
-0.03514396399259567,
0.9375929236412048,
-0.248989075422287,
0.17004753649234772,
-0.14058855175971985,
-0.47867798805236816,
-0.3630804717540741,
-0.24862080812454224,
0.36963027715682983,
0.9763977527618408,
-0.5834556818008423,
0.6513440608978271,
-0.004086463246494532,
-0.5657166242599487,
-0.8297522664070129,
0.06126299872994423,
0.2898821234703064,
0.146347314119339,
0.5205720067024231,
-0.3675350248813629,
-0.7254568338394165,
-0.9894707798957825,
0.040221285074949265,
-0.2806662917137146,
-0.022305088117718697,
-0.04799455404281616,
0.1866064965724945,
-0.049259405583143234,
0.6265566349029541,
0.07080703973770142,
0.02936648018658161,
-0.35259997844696045,
-0.033748190850019455,
-0.1551506370306015,
0.6661058068275452,
0.38593101501464844,
-0.5725822448730469,
-0.9872450828552246,
0.650600254535675,
-0.5785638093948364,
-0.15438517928123474,
-0.17172189056873322,
-0.36554476618766785,
0.35205042362213135,
0.37517648935317993,
-0.15056703984737396,
0.6482458710670471,
0.948809027671814,
-0.538670003414154,
0.8598003387451172,
-0.004425568971782923,
0.6657627820968628,
-1.634581208229065,
0.2192499190568924,
-0.6482903957366943,
-0.5393193364143372,
-0.49191972613334656,
0.011488733813166618,
0.1510191559791565,
-0.37665095925331116,
-0.540337860584259,
0.2969822883605957,
-0.33202317357063293,
-0.24356894195079803,
-0.4030515253543854,
0.36842408776283264,
-0.14686302840709686,
-0.13441240787506104,
0.07851655781269073,
0.7011988759040833,
0.5407413244247437,
-0.4020489454269409,
0.9185053110122681,
0.2766736149787903,
-0.33860307931900024,
0.9453434944152832,
-0.31096434593200684,
0.01190069131553173,
0.587609589099884,
0.01938300020992756,
-0.6256954073905945,
0.15890894830226898,
0.7557508945465088,
-0.8617698550224304,
-0.12502732872962952,
-0.20147088170051575,
-0.22712861001491547,
-0.25505784153938293,
-0.2567281424999237,
0.32589346170425415,
0.34722939133644104,
-0.23921050131320953,
0.45831942558288574,
0.15071815252304077,
-0.42800068855285645,
-0.596077024936676,
-0.9185222387313843,
0.4507615566253662,
-0.15998485684394836,
-0.6146907806396484,
0.03556584194302559,
-0.525475025177002,
-0.22246533632278442,
0.21067774295806885,
-0.023505136370658875,
-0.7932741641998291,
-0.16748541593551636,
-0.017595749348402023,
0.41129928827285767,
-0.2655279040336609,
0.1664612889289856,
0.3423891067504883,
-0.1037592664361,
-0.021110067144036293,
-0.42344942688941956,
0.49426594376564026,
-0.004458094015717506,
0.012206727638840675,
-0.8416957855224609,
0.8101925253868103,
0.6816765666007996,
0.03716466948390007,
0.6758043169975281,
-0.00362428929656744,
-0.3103628158569336,
0.12642927467823029,
-0.16757747530937195,
-0.22510145604610443,
-0.4749937355518341,
0.4019292891025543,
-0.35143476724624634,
-0.6241880059242249,
0.5066096186637878,
-0.3584192395210266,
-0.2485697716474533,
-0.043888479471206665,
0.6541014909744263,
-0.05898198485374451,
0.8583033680915833,
0.886364758014679,
0.057275284081697464,
0.36286404728889465,
0.2680213749408722,
0.29031839966773987,
-0.5230292677879333,
-0.47234800457954407,
-1.0231077671051025,
-0.13012361526489258,
-0.5058814287185669,
-0.17069029808044434,
-0.10610228031873703,
0.5910855531692505,
0.13252434134483337,
0.944023609161377,
-0.8163724541664124,
0.052887823432683945,
0.42783743143081665,
-0.19732411205768585,
0.5729178190231323,
-0.04395230486989021,
-0.19374538958072662,
-0.49349209666252136,
-0.3255365788936615,
-0.81841641664505,
0.9455839991569519,
-0.24817334115505219,
0.8370952606201172,
0.05685839429497719,
0.6817229986190796,
0.22201086580753326,
-0.1318921148777008,
-0.965013861656189,
0.6564618945121765,
0.038950223475694656,
-0.8949570655822754,
-0.3608427047729492,
-0.37839269638061523,
-1.260973334312439,
0.03183619678020477,
-0.47802701592445374,
-0.5823084712028503,
0.3456667363643646,
0.3349628448486328,
0.08555109798908234,
-0.11422526091337204,
-0.7763837575912476,
1.0588799715042114,
-0.332852303981781,
-0.43577104806900024,
-0.8079186677932739,
-0.5867910981178284,
0.12285005301237106,
-0.4343164563179016,
0.22048445045948029,
0.27655088901519775,
0.00577276898548007,
0.3053246736526489,
-0.2233126312494278,
0.3851897120475769,
0.3272568881511688,
0.34830644726753235,
0.09212134778499603,
0.44924843311309814,
0.13007141649723053,
-0.04301020875573158,
-0.05224163457751274,
-0.12802959978580475,
0.4503234326839447,
-0.6430556774139404,
-0.40636271238327026,
0.486523300409317,
-0.5812867879867554,
-0.1071862131357193,
-0.5542011857032776,
-0.2673858106136322,
0.414853572845459,
0.5052820444107056,
0.0867171436548233,
0.16653971374034882,
-0.6219466328620911,
0.36610278487205505,
0.10258403420448303,
-0.4130777418613434,
0.11514782160520554,
0.9490538239479065,
-0.7047037482261658,
-0.39329442381858826,
0.9285036325454712,
0.033140458166599274,
0.4000900089740753,
0.4901083707809448,
0.1191253736615181,
0.22872693836688995,
-0.4986879527568817,
-0.8386610746383667,
0.08819922804832458,
-0.6635802984237671,
-0.14461378753185272,
-0.14329497516155243,
-0.06242531165480614,
-0.34237393736839294,
-0.6433790922164917,
-0.49236735701560974,
-0.5082269310951233,
-0.039885394275188446,
0.23599855601787567,
0.03304492309689522,
1.1379632949829102,
-0.0032035645563155413,
0.2501077950000763,
-0.6434387564659119,
-0.10033641010522842,
0.2432585507631302,
0.021207144483923912,
-0.5104473233222961,
-0.35866937041282654,
-0.9700518250465393,
-0.24867768585681915,
-0.575520932674408,
-1.2868809700012207,
0.33664029836654663,
-0.3882415294647217,
0.14187446236610413,
0.028214959427714348,
0.058692190796136856,
0.39297330379486084,
-0.4636666476726532,
0.5878976583480835,
0.39391273260116577,
-1.1420735120773315,
0.44638603925704956,
-0.14270314574241638,
0.44075247645378113,
0.4231969118118286,
0.3282504677772522,
-0.9339464902877808,
-0.6345811486244202,
0.07353945076465607,
-0.7328658103942871,
0.9971063733100891,
0.15856897830963135,
-0.01981864683330059,
0.3883400857448578,
0.10243575274944305,
0.1179760992527008,
0.2690855860710144,
-0.6517051458358765,
-0.05674101784825325,
-0.41786935925483704,
-0.21845459938049316,
0.2425566017627716,
0.20766280591487885,
0.17376071214675903,
-0.4517610967159271,
0.8646281957626343,
0.1986674666404724,
0.17248207330703735,
0.0829276293516159,
-0.14680849015712738,
-0.3136523365974426,
0.7066574692726135,
0.6659606695175171,
0.6133506894111633,
0.01688552461564541,
-0.09569502621889114,
0.05116087198257446,
-0.779746949672699,
0.22569197416305542,
0.053029999136924744,
-0.31768396496772766,
0.020328020676970482,
0.012356169521808624,
0.2803741991519928,
0.22041915357112885,
-0.7999138832092285,
0.3179098963737488,
-0.1626279354095459,
-0.2971596419811249,
-0.3642962574958801,
-0.4336622953414917,
0.5927990078926086,
0.49265679717063904,
0.42790085077285767,
0.057072658091783524,
0.2916487753391266,
-0.6313208937644958,
0.1182747632265091,
0.32859253883361816,
-0.5298648476600647,
-0.5563608407974243,
0.26718154549598694,
0.5585423707962036,
-0.9007293581962585,
0.25047194957733154,
-0.304853618144989,
-0.6042888164520264,
0.40511977672576904,
0.6855048537254333,
0.7859245538711548,
-0.810417652130127,
0.418417364358902,
0.58012855052948,
0.7028687596321106,
0.1245485469698906,
0.3637334406375885,
0.020562533289194107,
-0.23196683824062347,
-0.3228726089000702,
-0.3856266140937805,
-0.395260751247406,
0.051363755017519,
-0.8490117788314819,
0.7365126609802246,
-0.16132092475891113,
-0.21289929747581482,
-0.1767125278711319,
-0.07017716020345688,
-0.4685412347316742,
-0.15950298309326172,
-0.2105536013841629,
0.7119124531745911,
-0.6804311275482178,
1.2430312633514404,
0.8074564337730408,
-0.2551429867744446,
-0.33961421251296997,
-0.3180275857448578,
-0.13940562307834625,
-0.5428209900856018,
0.963786780834198,
-0.24608950316905975,
-0.7289057970046997,
0.09475716203451157,
-0.16709406673908234,
-0.6202315092086792,
0.7655913233757019,
0.7212440967559814,
-0.8539694547653198,
0.11174881458282471,
0.1411837488412857,
0.508809506893158,
-0.4985261559486389,
-0.0035413336008787155,
0.4479852616786957,
0.6379947066307068,
-0.49086707830429077,
-1.1813747882843018,
-0.012441730126738548,
-0.15338222682476044,
-0.29883435368537903,
0.2632417678833008,
-0.3031267821788788,
0.36427944898605347,
0.2237669974565506,
-0.5296891927719116,
0.47797393798828125,
0.07284144312143326,
-0.3041297197341919,
0.3247789144515991,
0.006452546920627356,
-0.04611809924244881,
0.30585265159606934,
0.06643237173557281,
0.4552868902683258,
-0.5619810223579407,
0.22491975128650665,
0.9624722599983215,
-0.08654811978340149,
0.8489834666252136,
0.668400764465332,
-0.29519176483154297,
0.41102248430252075,
0.6767588257789612,
0.18992379307746887,
0.5808196067810059,
0.42466339468955994,
-0.5529951453208923,
-0.22367733716964722,
-0.11373955011367798,
-0.35377708077430725,
0.17758683860301971,
0.21552053093910217,
-0.5110676288604736,
-0.2476799041032791,
0.11456791311502457,
-0.06866858899593353,
0.6756032705307007,
-0.04892070218920708,
0.6121386289596558,
-0.10790468752384186,
-0.30507713556289673,
0.5639047026634216,
0.18975214660167694,
0.4090142548084259,
-0.7827800512313843,
-0.04024067521095276,
-0.03608430549502373,
0.038460541516542435,
-0.14774870872497559,
-0.46376004815101624,
0.5677486062049866,
0.13568724691867828,
-0.27436113357543945,
-0.16850504279136658,
0.24782639741897583,
-0.7338876724243164,
-0.6571620106697083,
0.9756178259849548,
0.4058442711830139,
0.7314777970314026,
0.2586306035518646,
-0.8703274726867676,
0.5363882780075073,
0.01163415051996708,
-0.1779569536447525,
0.2532566785812378,
0.2905021905899048,
-0.06664996594190598,
0.44914335012435913,
0.21857672929763794,
0.46611008048057556,
0.33892807364463806,
-0.4865458607673645,
0.7596985697746277,
-0.7021486759185791,
-0.3842855989933014,
-0.587196946144104,
0.35648995637893677,
0.1481451392173767,
-0.2467554211616516,
0.6813431978225708,
1.1113996505737305,
0.7564738988876343,
-0.031776562333106995,
1.1775761842727661,
-0.17221930623054504,
0.5724978446960449,
-0.17596545815467834,
0.7151510715484619,
-0.558023989200592,
-0.18224561214447021,
0.025110678747296333,
-1.1348021030426025,
-0.1595996767282486,
0.6771663427352905,
-0.037939075380563736,
-0.31025832891464233,
1.3924853801727295,
0.713402271270752,
0.22507530450820923,
-0.13676822185516357,
0.5485043525695801,
0.012311884202063084,
-0.031204305589199066,
0.5392133593559265,
0.5258557796478271,
-0.4492681324481964,
1.247916579246521,
-0.13729992508888245,
-0.2598384916782379,
-0.4539198577404022,
-0.5472773909568787,
-0.8487851619720459,
-0.8367648124694824,
0.07010511308908463,
-0.493063747882843,
0.5506839752197266,
0.9871680736541748,
0.7891169786453247,
-0.9241347312927246,
-0.6954392194747925,
0.06307728588581085,
-0.02373400703072548,
-0.2842279374599457,
-0.14644759893417358,
0.06580810248851776,
-0.0390031561255455,
-0.9976585507392883,
0.6497385501861572,
0.32820722460746765,
0.11276619136333466,
-0.4604029953479767,
-0.4133390486240387,
-0.09600356966257095,
0.10650981217622757,
0.5597279667854309,
0.3541170358657837,
-0.6695880889892578,
-0.17668363451957703,
0.24941658973693848,
-0.45478442311286926,
0.17363908886909485,
1.0268803834915161,
-0.5604832768440247,
1.0022797584533691,
0.5356224179267883,
0.8257701992988586,
0.4594811797142029,
-0.153375044465065,
0.7289016246795654,
-0.003227039473131299,
0.15262742340564728,
0.28836703300476074,
-0.09720040112733841,
0.5865886211395264,
-0.40313446521759033,
0.18211081624031067,
0.3441223204135895,
-0.7651766538619995,
-0.7811954617500305,
0.2660300135612488,
-0.9099331498146057,
-0.25287020206451416,
0.4960974454879761,
-0.05577291175723076,
0.044015176594257355,
-0.8063385486602783,
-0.5683498382568359,
0.4451107680797577,
-0.7801625728607178,
0.902365505695343,
1.2743674516677856,
0.13233156502246857,
0.23887920379638672,
-0.8297196626663208,
0.23251934349536896,
0.29278936982154846,
-0.8138211369514465,
0.11802814900875092,
0.3446938991546631,
0.19551168382167816,
0.23436203598976135,
0.8086338639259338,
-0.15213140845298767,
0.5550019145011902,
-0.06885518878698349,
0.8119972348213196,
0.42627397179603577,
-0.2547414004802704,
-0.5397501587867737,
-0.24927325546741486,
0.0435788668692112,
-0.21691541373729706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06954v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06954v1
|
Accelerating Inference in Large Language Models with a Unified Layer Skipping Strategy
| 2024-04-10T12:12:07 | 2024-04-10T12:12:07 |
Yijin Liu, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, dynamic computation methods have shown notable acceleration for
Large Language Models (LLMs) by skipping several layers of computations through
elaborate heuristics or additional predictors. However, in the decoding process
of existing approaches, different samples are assigned different computational
budgets, which cannot guarantee a stable and precise acceleration effect.
Furthermore, existing approaches generally skip multiple contiguous layers at
the bottom or top of the layers, leading to a drastic change in the model's
layer-wise representations, and thus a consequent performance degeneration.
Therefore, we propose a Unified Layer Skipping strategy, which selects the
number of layers to skip computation based solely on the target speedup ratio,
and then skips the corresponding number of intermediate layer computations in a
balanced manner. Since the Unified Layer Skipping strategy is independent of
input samples, it naturally supports popular acceleration techniques such as
batch decoding and KV caching, thus demonstrating more practicality for
real-world applications. Experimental results on two common tasks, i.e.,
machine translation and text summarization, indicate that given a target
speedup ratio, the Unified Layer Skipping strategy significantly enhances both
the inference performance and the actual model throughput over existing dynamic
approaches.
|
[
-0.3839123845100403,
-0.8894166350364685,
0.6753972172737122,
0.7344239354133606,
-0.3371523916721344,
0.3754308223724365,
-0.2636299133300781,
-0.40671852231025696,
0.015133978798985481,
0.5032745003700256,
-0.35803768038749695,
-0.1822635382413864,
-0.5706146955490112,
-0.16701021790504456,
-0.46827828884124756,
0.5097277760505676,
0.06698562204837799,
0.02803710661828518,
-0.3546104431152344,
0.17528097331523895,
-0.46447300910949707,
-0.26971757411956787,
-0.8555418252944946,
-0.6801756620407104,
0.5131361484527588,
0.556483268737793,
0.6652036905288696,
1.0425493717193604,
0.21869944036006927,
0.3226921558380127,
-0.3460982143878937,
0.18962104618549347,
-0.18262746930122375,
0.31907084584236145,
0.08817094564437866,
-0.09735944122076035,
-0.6070429086685181,
-0.42491424083709717,
0.9505006670951843,
1.0097558498382568,
-0.11452830582857132,
0.040133874863386154,
0.13237205147743225,
0.8459344506263733,
-0.8200679421424866,
-0.08012683689594269,
-0.43959537148475647,
0.011050088331103325,
-0.15283744037151337,
-0.2512408494949341,
-0.45464614033699036,
0.11576128751039505,
0.06209531053900719,
-0.4388643503189087,
-0.0013854880817234516,
-0.3895156681537628,
0.17998318374156952,
0.13296496868133545,
-0.32637184858322144,
0.15818092226982117,
-0.9871857762336731,
0.8026520609855652,
-0.8020669221878052,
0.3326146900653839,
0.15101180970668793,
0.044613588601350784,
-0.14867372810840607,
-0.7554767727851868,
-0.35133934020996094,
-0.1377425640821457,
0.1812930405139923,
0.08519035577774048,
-0.13036960363388062,
0.18578468263149261,
0.29819339513778687,
0.09291796386241913,
-0.392214834690094,
0.5208448767662048,
-0.20383107662200928,
-0.18937693536281586,
0.5238667726516724,
0.052423954010009766,
0.38986530900001526,
0.14108628034591675,
-0.372140496969223,
-0.15129706263542175,
-0.7290499806404114,
0.14718560874462128,
0.2675502896308899,
0.28929948806762695,
0.0008630299125798047,
0.2954082489013672,
-0.4232969284057617,
0.6085628867149353,
-0.10498177260160446,
0.03322464972734451,
0.21630875766277313,
-0.20229965448379517,
-0.37907618284225464,
0.3418310284614563,
0.6457269191741943,
0.10850352048873901,
0.3490390181541443,
-0.3962302505970001,
-0.09813226014375687,
0.08522221446037292,
-0.03559326007962227,
-0.9934694766998291,
-0.15385983884334564,
0.47342348098754883,
-0.11700093001127243,
-0.17262370884418488,
-0.2906728684902191,
-0.8643705248832703,
-0.19214363396167755,
-0.14559347927570343,
0.19784678518772125,
-0.3344388008117676,
-0.26496240496635437,
0.2960018813610077,
-0.072389155626297,
0.0011762073263525963,
0.38801702857017517,
-0.7800301909446716,
0.5824396014213562,
0.5422420501708984,
0.762566089630127,
-0.14294247329235077,
-0.5952659845352173,
-1.0257508754730225,
0.319072961807251,
-0.4081362187862396,
0.7208473682403564,
-0.7868937253952026,
-0.3960026502609253,
-0.22026214003562927,
-0.21698983013629913,
-0.07651838660240173,
-0.30407530069351196,
0.8368607759475708,
-0.5901881456375122,
0.007417154964059591,
-0.25490474700927734,
-0.5174155235290527,
-0.21103401482105255,
-0.19044914841651917,
-0.7713930606842041,
1.1381373405456543,
-0.36444416642189026,
-0.5888177156448364,
0.08898544311523438,
-0.6207764744758606,
-0.8334537148475647,
-0.07450389117002487,
0.11093278229236603,
-0.3059743046760559,
0.45245957374572754,
0.705904483795166,
0.5820789337158203,
-0.4475170373916626,
0.3723178803920746,
-0.217891663312912,
-0.6841022372245789,
-0.10248604416847229,
-0.598476231098175,
0.7217100262641907,
0.1572393774986267,
-0.452314168214798,
-0.023825110867619514,
-0.9378633499145508,
0.07286874204874039,
0.18797485530376434,
-0.6515108346939087,
-0.5237274169921875,
0.3804381191730499,
-0.20382528007030487,
0.25705277919769287,
0.05476248264312744,
-0.4410596787929535,
0.20823723077774048,
-0.12528164684772491,
0.2249397337436676,
0.8282843828201294,
-0.052751872688531876,
0.575531542301178,
0.05382384732365608,
0.5369597673416138,
0.19347940385341644,
-0.30252623558044434,
-0.507744550704956,
-0.3205803632736206,
-0.885197103023529,
-0.35311761498451233,
0.4165398180484772,
0.6602202653884888,
-0.6473544239997864,
0.30708047747612,
-0.39708366990089417,
-0.15897992253303528,
-0.5711455941200256,
0.21884113550186157,
0.610675036907196,
0.5831406712532043,
0.5512566566467285,
-0.2370547354221344,
-0.4601365923881531,
-0.6491623520851135,
-0.5667693614959717,
-0.036866478621959686,
-0.20361140370368958,
-0.12896151840686798,
0.187986820936203,
0.04242436960339546,
0.47799208760261536,
-0.2599543333053589,
0.188881516456604,
-0.5422245860099792,
0.34766095876693726,
0.07531222701072693,
0.6405555009841919,
0.2656327188014984,
-0.6627415418624878,
-0.2695552706718445,
0.021109875291585922,
-0.6192241907119751,
-0.27959930896759033,
-0.2558109760284424,
-0.09257413446903229,
0.11936268210411072,
0.6238452792167664,
-0.5130007863044739,
0.14514514803886414,
0.5553033351898193,
-0.08586365729570389,
0.37905359268188477,
-0.3402153551578522,
0.13728030025959015,
-0.7756034731864929,
-0.08900459110736847,
0.03307424113154411,
-0.20998921990394592,
-0.9369944930076599,
0.2209485024213791,
0.22143666446208954,
0.2667441964149475,
-0.3052864074707031,
0.6480462551116943,
-0.7464112043380737,
-0.17496037483215332,
-0.260836660861969,
0.07384790480136871,
0.24589364230632782,
0.44692856073379517,
0.011971657164394855,
0.7215698957443237,
0.7801569104194641,
-0.8958833813667297,
0.07273399084806442,
-0.3740232586860657,
-0.3086087703704834,
0.13821017742156982,
-0.744744062423706,
0.3230869770050049,
-0.1770736277103424,
0.3204182982444763,
-0.9883460402488708,
-0.11941896378993988,
-0.20190861821174622,
-0.2437998205423355,
0.31141194701194763,
-0.15570057928562164,
-0.5833107829093933,
-0.5763487219810486,
-0.3124501407146454,
0.4836403727531433,
0.5854963064193726,
-0.6362968683242798,
0.7739638090133667,
0.20511341094970703,
-0.11360643059015274,
-0.8634579181671143,
-1.0528440475463867,
0.17318286001682281,
-0.22740614414215088,
-0.6242828965187073,
0.3922120928764343,
-0.2219669669866562,
-0.12845204770565033,
-0.19444186985492706,
-0.22892960906028748,
-0.0660712718963623,
0.34783077239990234,
-0.09810901433229446,
0.04675339534878731,
-0.272676020860672,
-0.1302100419998169,
0.342670738697052,
0.020649194717407227,
0.05768756940960884,
-0.5711871981620789,
0.8030133843421936,
0.10418320447206497,
-0.34500157833099365,
-0.47279855608940125,
0.1556755155324936,
0.5543911457061768,
-0.2023857682943344,
0.5977867245674133,
0.6416619420051575,
-0.24951109290122986,
-0.30899322032928467,
-0.5974586606025696,
0.11901019513607025,
-0.49199378490448,
0.40648937225341797,
-0.4555417597293854,
-0.7342212200164795,
0.7642264366149902,
-0.20993515849113464,
0.1528528332710266,
0.3565877377986908,
0.5146451592445374,
0.06374853849411011,
1.166501760482788,
0.3403029441833496,
-0.326231986284256,
0.4290458559989929,
-0.10183843225240707,
-0.06447640061378479,
-0.8367414474487305,
0.02529405988752842,
-0.697333812713623,
-0.390766441822052,
-0.3865545690059662,
-0.6110062599182129,
0.11070335656404495,
0.44476330280303955,
-0.14926496148109436,
0.051120247691869736,
-0.17278078198432922,
0.841911256313324,
0.43713587522506714,
-0.0344424694776535,
0.6870328783988953,
0.4501653015613556,
-0.5061436295509338,
0.22799593210220337,
-0.6666372418403625,
-0.013540778309106827,
0.8488339185714722,
0.34796974062919617,
0.6982539892196655,
-0.0047162435948848724,
0.4700358211994171,
0.41046375036239624,
-0.03595000132918358,
-0.4382675588130951,
0.8334506750106812,
-0.31822484731674194,
-0.33236831426620483,
-0.3288874328136444,
-0.8013569712638855,
-0.6973732113838196,
0.6545278429985046,
0.20146511495113373,
-0.8403482437133789,
0.19874709844589233,
0.2981606721878052,
-0.15110687911510468,
0.5668944120407104,
-0.6111332178115845,
0.5941578149795532,
-0.13294090330600739,
-0.5354989171028137,
-0.2785893678665161,
-0.6132681369781494,
0.4340662658214569,
-0.08547703176736832,
0.21302227675914764,
-0.04237661510705948,
-0.07410143315792084,
0.5605761408805847,
-0.0908229872584343,
0.6546499133110046,
-0.37034139037132263,
-0.1093280091881752,
0.26328223943710327,
0.22512705624103546,
0.6812225580215454,
-0.22378355264663696,
-0.258789598941803,
0.125333771109581,
-0.48441171646118164,
-0.7043061852455139,
-0.5509458184242249,
0.7585261464118958,
-0.47224172949790955,
-0.48976007103919983,
-0.08376693725585938,
-0.7822567820549011,
-0.3148442804813385,
0.3987215757369995,
-0.02111796662211418,
0.5429818034172058,
-0.2215091735124588,
0.08626487851142883,
0.5596243739128113,
-0.2139289528131485,
0.7991719841957092,
0.5245322585105896,
-0.1536700278520584,
-0.16469602286815643,
0.7953163981437683,
0.05194929242134094,
0.6110334396362305,
0.5688539147377014,
0.3379792869091034,
-0.32226884365081787,
-0.8973912596702576,
-0.7217366099357605,
-0.0777759999036789,
-0.5556049346923828,
0.13130247592926025,
-0.9478210806846619,
-0.1516084372997284,
-0.49143776297569275,
-0.11221950501203537,
-0.4420716166496277,
-0.5583978891372681,
-0.051146239042282104,
-0.047587260603904724,
0.03627016767859459,
0.32881519198417664,
0.004927459172904491,
0.47184041142463684,
-0.8423115015029907,
0.384757936000824,
0.15238863229751587,
0.3445032238960266,
0.4311765134334564,
-0.6592475175857544,
-0.24505752325057983,
-0.09496931731700897,
-0.15857665240764618,
-0.3377080261707306,
0.33232545852661133,
0.10964515060186386,
0.5937946438789368,
0.4539394974708557,
-0.09052971750497818,
1.0907970666885376,
-0.5124337673187256,
0.41366130113601685,
0.07885721325874329,
-0.9692782759666443,
0.17087964713573456,
-0.4813036322593689,
0.69500732421875,
0.46151530742645264,
0.26071619987487793,
-0.45953330397605896,
-0.40451323986053467,
-0.43675586581230164,
-0.9865027666091919,
0.599783182144165,
0.1062396764755249,
0.19281719624996185,
0.185382679104805,
0.19043609499931335,
-0.2526630759239197,
0.11785967648029327,
-0.5519344806671143,
-0.12626881897449493,
0.3672909736633301,
0.15804822742938995,
-0.006185321137309074,
-0.16456174850463867,
0.3015490770339966,
-0.3454183340072632,
0.6237881183624268,
-0.11820091307163239,
0.12344546616077423,
0.11263394355773926,
-0.3061370253562927,
-0.3398566246032715,
0.3625391721725464,
0.40436500310897827,
0.7265527844429016,
-0.40133804082870483,
0.2052966058254242,
0.10034311562776566,
-0.5430956482887268,
0.07263176143169403,
0.23971985280513763,
-0.3703739047050476,
-0.14209938049316406,
0.44313615560531616,
0.9115507006645203,
0.3484509587287903,
-0.6510392427444458,
0.013779721222817898,
0.01581081934273243,
-0.11696755141019821,
0.06778492033481598,
0.14227861166000366,
0.3675919771194458,
0.2385825663805008,
0.5530944466590881,
0.07032151520252228,
0.1006067544221878,
-0.4266361892223358,
0.17223216593265533,
0.3578881323337555,
-0.12693798542022705,
-0.23325428366661072,
0.6430554986000061,
0.05510425940155983,
-0.10579881817102432,
0.5203914642333984,
-0.014187411405146122,
-0.3195344805717468,
0.7925736308097839,
0.6408898234367371,
0.9797996878623962,
-0.4628017246723175,
0.14549893140792847,
0.1407349407672882,
0.3911914825439453,
-0.5904736518859863,
0.08082112669944763,
-0.15376779437065125,
-0.7501254081726074,
-0.941582977771759,
-0.7583498358726501,
-0.32663387060165405,
0.18586747348308563,
-0.6165956258773804,
0.02953370288014412,
-0.39387038350105286,
0.40036681294441223,
0.09515585005283356,
0.029704097658395767,
-0.5257469415664673,
0.2008010596036911,
0.2737444341182709,
1.0389174222946167,
-0.7354123592376709,
1.1196385622024536,
0.5106185674667358,
-0.12833161652088165,
-0.5215849876403809,
0.20530225336551666,
-0.014575019478797913,
-0.6898479461669922,
0.3575042486190796,
0.10366912931203842,
-0.3740474283695221,
0.08741672337055206,
-0.3103218674659729,
-0.8073986768722534,
0.9730691313743591,
0.34469977021217346,
-0.5787470936775208,
-0.25798118114471436,
0.022534286603331566,
0.45550215244293213,
-0.5558326840400696,
0.1952163279056549,
0.7783637642860413,
0.4894767105579376,
0.32145142555236816,
-0.5094217658042908,
0.11291392147541046,
-0.06998101621866226,
0.1592109352350235,
0.18982166051864624,
-0.41485825181007385,
0.9849727749824524,
-0.2497866451740265,
-0.2048921138048172,
0.2243742197751999,
0.7370499968528748,
0.2524229884147644,
0.28230729699134827,
0.6816756725311279,
0.5873594880104065,
0.5735458731651306,
0.17725050449371338,
1.2812926769256592,
-0.18963946402072906,
0.07435063272714615,
1.1455154418945312,
-0.32847678661346436,
0.7565680146217346,
0.29309576749801636,
-0.0868835598230362,
0.38383209705352783,
0.3915732502937317,
0.21460770070552826,
0.26675042510032654,
0.07230943441390991,
-0.2747217118740082,
-0.3772721290588379,
-0.004349368624389172,
-0.06702779978513718,
0.4879859387874603,
0.29687801003456116,
-0.3314855396747589,
-0.35865870118141174,
-0.2666977643966675,
0.32251662015914917,
0.0015783958369866014,
-0.4951733946800232,
0.48875075578689575,
-0.17572693526744843,
-0.7908121347427368,
0.7027066946029663,
0.14568421244621277,
0.5497528314590454,
-0.6702927947044373,
-0.019999448210000992,
-0.4463745057582855,
0.1917639672756195,
0.06154334917664528,
-0.6202839612960815,
-0.12381330877542496,
-0.011686190962791443,
-0.1308489441871643,
-0.32168465852737427,
0.7840703129768372,
-0.4289284348487854,
-0.771844744682312,
0.7236108779907227,
0.6619076728820801,
0.11741655319929123,
-0.11256100982427597,
-0.598745584487915,
0.20434096455574036,
-0.015171132050454617,
-0.676200270652771,
0.57891845703125,
0.5152560472488403,
-0.24459409713745117,
0.57014000415802,
0.9486783742904663,
0.26697733998298645,
0.04575050249695778,
0.4031151831150055,
1.0637277364730835,
-0.7232369780540466,
-0.5277090668678284,
-1.1392017602920532,
0.6583597660064697,
-0.10882162302732468,
0.0964464545249939,
0.6106384992599487,
0.3889451324939728,
0.7389888763427734,
0.28540754318237305,
0.6633411049842834,
0.23541653156280518,
0.3590800166130066,
-0.7633188962936401,
0.39106011390686035,
-0.6942898631095886,
0.6325488686561584,
-0.5819475054740906,
-1.1232752799987793,
-0.3677158057689667,
0.22425302863121033,
0.010708222165703773,
0.17051802575588226,
0.48486098647117615,
0.473173588514328,
-0.34194478392601013,
-0.026857439428567886,
0.34305623173713684,
0.5608758330345154,
0.40607210993766785,
0.45360425114631653,
0.5076065063476562,
-0.12027761340141296,
0.3711918294429779,
-0.3252713978290558,
-0.21985238790512085,
0.009365537203848362,
-1.1841015815734863,
-0.8326435685157776,
-0.0428975410759449,
-0.03243677690625191,
-0.3000269830226898,
0.13708022236824036,
0.6807563900947571,
0.6170837879180908,
-0.6103073954582214,
-0.42037075757980347,
-0.28634878993034363,
0.17302080988883972,
-0.4511900246143341,
-0.19430284202098846,
0.29224148392677307,
-0.2691498100757599,
-0.8814976215362549,
0.7550727725028992,
0.4542393982410431,
-0.2533748745918274,
-0.38773390650749207,
0.09842217713594437,
-0.38346657156944275,
0.27695432305336,
0.6338667273521423,
0.5324863791465759,
-0.5958346724510193,
0.09927443414926529,
-0.108346126973629,
0.13479001820087433,
0.08524219691753387,
1.0452829599380493,
-0.9477330446243286,
0.30629488825798035,
0.6912059783935547,
1.0718692541122437,
0.7155570983886719,
0.11950396001338959,
0.6036415696144104,
-0.8286876678466797,
0.4270530939102173,
0.04536556452512741,
0.33372241258621216,
0.30931928753852844,
-0.2631584703922272,
0.3520210385322571,
0.18590861558914185,
-0.4489525556564331,
-0.9168042540550232,
0.12541449069976807,
-0.8999608159065247,
-0.49296534061431885,
0.9614701867103577,
-0.12606054544448853,
-0.32171598076820374,
0.015458932146430016,
0.29386574029922485,
0.09559675306081772,
-0.6182422637939453,
0.5656241774559021,
0.5484049320220947,
-0.16267448663711548,
-0.29755574464797974,
-0.811478853225708,
0.10213817656040192,
0.6729618310928345,
-0.7935532927513123,
0.4106767773628235,
0.5395407676696777,
0.1397874802350998,
0.11895649880170822,
0.8469074368476868,
0.004191886633634567,
0.15310759842395782,
-0.013389523141086102,
-0.02907511033117771,
-0.21751165390014648,
-0.7770605087280273,
-0.48195451498031616,
0.17440666258335114,
-0.20301683247089386,
0.06782511621713638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06948v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06948v2
|
MetaCheckGPT -- A Multi-task Hallucination Detector Using LLM Uncertainty and Meta-models
| 2024-04-10T11:56:01 | 2024-04-11T15:39:44 |
Rahul Mehta, Andrew Hoblitzell, Jack O'Keefe, Hyeju Jang, Vasudeva Varma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T07, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Hallucinations in large language models (LLMs) have recently become a
significant problem. A recent effort in this direction is a shared task at
Semeval 2024 Task 6, SHROOM, a Shared-task on Hallucinations and Related
Observable Overgeneration Mistakes. This paper describes our winning solution
ranked 1st and 2nd in the 2 sub-tasks of model agnostic and model aware tracks
respectively. We propose a meta-regressor framework of LLMs for model
evaluation and integration that achieves the highest scores on the leaderboard.
We also experiment with various transformer-based models and black box methods
like ChatGPT, Vectara, and others. In addition, we perform an error analysis
comparing GPT4 against our best model which shows the limitations of the
former.
|
[
-0.4298796057701111,
-0.6905093789100647,
0.9642123579978943,
0.14119839668273926,
-0.24610300362110138,
-0.17225709557533264,
-0.03242478892207146,
-0.3864601254463196,
0.3028573989868164,
0.5183290243148804,
-0.6384574174880981,
-0.48610585927963257,
-0.9871389269828796,
0.13498365879058838,
-0.5010586977005005,
0.6508651375770569,
-0.23433174192905426,
0.052622146904468536,
-0.013670752756297588,
0.11076080799102783,
-0.682371973991394,
-0.7379805445671082,
-0.220555379986763,
-0.47957777976989746,
0.28209277987480164,
0.05050944164395332,
0.5939195156097412,
0.14833271503448486,
0.5833930969238281,
0.24688652157783508,
0.2275329977273941,
0.2482367604970932,
-0.3046264350414276,
0.15734970569610596,
-0.20239463448524475,
-0.08527354151010513,
-0.5895174145698547,
-0.11908803880214691,
-0.03332306444644928,
0.2593287527561188,
-0.48726990818977356,
0.03379419445991516,
0.1498953104019165,
0.05624539777636528,
-0.5560067892074585,
0.4337235391139984,
-0.6336336135864258,
0.19449570775032043,
0.018377190455794334,
-0.2546673119068146,
-0.45967942476272583,
-0.1795235127210617,
-0.0918707326054573,
-0.17318327724933624,
0.31746962666511536,
-0.1590059995651245,
0.5565475225448608,
0.7723034620285034,
-0.3586331307888031,
-0.39842385053634644,
-0.7399550080299377,
0.6517027616500854,
-0.5678859949111938,
0.5891320705413818,
0.3359832167625427,
0.5180129408836365,
-0.0601089671254158,
-0.7761939764022827,
-0.41090232133865356,
-0.030591579154133797,
-0.07785648852586746,
0.11827096343040466,
-0.15021191537380219,
0.03890638053417206,
0.10412878543138504,
0.3139035701751709,
-0.5891830921173096,
-0.13503514230251312,
-0.3706210255622864,
-0.5202980637550354,
0.28937122225761414,
0.2536129951477051,
0.1383686065673828,
-0.24497905373573303,
-0.12381194531917572,
0.15127183496952057,
-0.2291037142276764,
-0.5546091198921204,
0.012279404327273369,
0.128516286611557,
0.39458510279655457,
0.5217509865760803,
-0.05480669066309929,
0.4581931233406067,
0.011629396118223667,
0.10251614451408386,
0.3273618221282959,
-0.20863960683345795,
-0.2477390617132187,
0.04581280052661896,
0.7296083569526672,
0.15564623475074768,
0.03158101066946983,
-0.2697199881076813,
-0.3956170976161957,
0.41542884707450867,
0.3540516197681427,
-0.7082099318504333,
-0.44899579882621765,
0.2540976107120514,
-0.36124181747436523,
-0.36218538880348206,
-0.0827513113617897,
-0.9179515242576599,
-0.5936982035636902,
-0.25291767716407776,
1.0688444375991821,
-0.31925979256629944,
-0.3160206079483032,
0.4845365583896637,
0.1729927659034729,
0.35058820247650146,
0.3077697455883026,
-0.8239083886146545,
0.2636243402957916,
0.7181264758110046,
0.911708414554596,
-0.3389156758785248,
-0.45597124099731445,
-0.49748602509498596,
-0.00529736652970314,
-0.14019370079040527,
0.7838271260261536,
-0.4888370633125305,
-0.358423113822937,
-0.14223189651966095,
0.21586988866329193,
-0.2586422562599182,
-0.48944851756095886,
0.9024572968482971,
-0.15937212109565735,
0.3768375813961029,
-0.41702497005462646,
-0.4693277180194855,
-0.3854547441005707,
0.2030320018529892,
-0.6185833215713501,
0.9158639311790466,
0.13177171349525452,
-0.6385947465896606,
0.34667763113975525,
-0.5681989789009094,
-0.13319392502307892,
0.30861368775367737,
-0.3649360239505768,
-0.43261194229125977,
0.21449358761310577,
0.270504891872406,
0.5553146004676819,
0.009048882871866226,
0.7121837735176086,
-0.20801736414432526,
-0.8221415877342224,
0.014099281281232834,
-0.4850503206253052,
0.49187904596328735,
-0.06646053493022919,
-0.8071653246879578,
0.30983811616897583,
-0.5683051347732544,
-0.07741501927375793,
0.018357377499341965,
-0.14990954101085663,
0.03985441103577614,
0.01424462255090475,
-0.03312123194336891,
0.30804556608200073,
0.1050393134355545,
-0.21940331161022186,
0.1103985458612442,
0.2927725911140442,
0.6364355683326721,
0.7400686144828796,
0.07287535816431046,
-0.13222599029541016,
-0.20568640530109406,
0.46938639879226685,
-0.14868073165416718,
0.30575281381607056,
-0.05266966298222542,
-0.4957224726676941,
-0.8301413655281067,
-0.3218097686767578,
0.07404947280883789,
0.6490178108215332,
-0.40991348028182983,
0.6601128578186035,
-0.06263504177331924,
-0.44387727975845337,
-0.5422694087028503,
-0.1743524670600891,
-0.019890397787094116,
0.08700977265834808,
0.6144621968269348,
-0.08561540395021439,
-0.5279377698898315,
-0.8719877004623413,
-0.12824788689613342,
0.25304752588272095,
-0.040994346141815186,
0.21677926182746887,
0.8353291153907776,
-1.0503218173980713,
0.3210607171058655,
-0.5509299635887146,
-0.5382708311080933,
0.039005961269140244,
0.4324670732021332,
0.2722099721431732,
0.32430726289749146,
0.2431277483701706,
-0.4902820885181427,
-0.2807392477989197,
-0.1424913853406906,
-0.9291152358055115,
-0.28338441252708435,
0.1526929885149002,
0.09811031818389893,
0.2737205922603607,
0.6236280202865601,
-0.7426277995109558,
0.3710809648036957,
0.7610906958580017,
-0.243724524974823,
0.5922491550445557,
-0.07214497774839401,
0.42349329590797424,
-0.8775875568389893,
-0.11563058942556381,
-0.4302660822868347,
-0.33698153495788574,
-0.7063483595848083,
0.09926352649927139,
0.0220320001244545,
-0.08903228491544724,
-0.13556642830371857,
0.08555515110492706,
-0.345698744058609,
-0.13984479010105133,
-0.39453476667404175,
0.027499860152602196,
-0.31417638063430786,
0.5938701033592224,
0.269259512424469,
0.5368236899375916,
0.6211795210838318,
-0.29310739040374756,
0.3592325448989868,
-0.03704201430082321,
-0.2679750621318817,
0.26509425044059753,
-0.671015202999115,
0.4816538989543915,
0.07788603752851486,
0.10335154086351395,
-1.0193434953689575,
-0.4283577799797058,
0.4358462989330292,
-0.2686576843261719,
0.13768763840198517,
0.2897038757801056,
-0.5501609444618225,
-0.4038516581058502,
-0.17781750857830048,
0.2864525318145752,
0.38457444310188293,
-0.5824313759803772,
0.800148606300354,
0.1930568516254425,
0.22222456336021423,
-0.5083158612251282,
-0.65213543176651,
0.09597861766815186,
-0.23183076083660126,
-0.5693173408508301,
0.3166979253292084,
0.013529079966247082,
-0.04936296492815018,
0.033863238990306854,
-0.4192827045917511,
-0.027745889499783516,
-0.077791728079319,
0.3391655385494232,
0.0859280377626419,
-0.08320096135139465,
-0.03450853377580643,
-0.2094927877187729,
-0.3190489411354065,
0.2063879519701004,
-0.18751133978366852,
0.8118385672569275,
-0.38321563601493835,
-0.7963586449623108,
-0.16956727206707,
0.15031465888023376,
0.7204351425170898,
0.05097261816263199,
0.5845240354537964,
0.8591144680976868,
-0.7161586284637451,
-0.17500390112400055,
-0.7996711730957031,
-0.3975180387496948,
-0.43380340933799744,
0.3854255974292755,
-0.4867837727069855,
-1.0069482326507568,
0.7162888646125793,
0.0859960988163948,
-0.19476692378520966,
0.4181278645992279,
0.6427634954452515,
0.270874559879303,
1.1227611303329468,
0.4408092200756073,
0.1622573286294937,
-0.029275229200720787,
-0.04868018254637718,
0.5412807464599609,
-0.6317409873008728,
-0.26717349886894226,
-0.2841782867908478,
-0.11566673219203949,
-0.49020057916641235,
-0.7569393515586853,
0.3871438801288605,
-0.17745454609394073,
-0.0736985132098198,
0.4114614427089691,
-0.8158156275749207,
0.3720870614051819,
0.4138926565647125,
0.24266809225082397,
0.47331589460372925,
-0.34513136744499207,
0.08544041961431503,
-0.26581132411956787,
-0.371670126914978,
-0.48371651768684387,
0.8717328310012817,
0.34669360518455505,
0.8706331253051758,
-0.028863957151770592,
0.9484360218048096,
0.24272744357585907,
0.13476023077964783,
-0.742756724357605,
0.5068285465240479,
0.009683677926659584,
-0.7155216932296753,
-0.5186209082603455,
-0.1947532594203949,
-0.34220990538597107,
0.6951654553413391,
0.05070912092924118,
-0.8248354196548462,
0.3030092716217041,
-0.16559655964374542,
-0.29473575949668884,
0.18571409583091736,
-0.3895508050918579,
0.878998875617981,
-0.06184603273868561,
-0.15852531790733337,
-0.10965994745492935,
-0.3539281487464905,
0.8516080975532532,
-0.5313448309898376,
0.18506379425525665,
0.028616050258278847,
0.2525547444820404,
0.5433027744293213,
-0.15318965911865234,
0.810459554195404,
-0.1443108171224594,
-0.1369086056947708,
0.2217051088809967,
0.28904294967651367,
0.6894347071647644,
-0.1351681798696518,
0.15378284454345703,
0.2860617935657501,
0.02873031422495842,
0.00564857991412282,
-0.5213795304298401,
0.5686304569244385,
-0.515500009059906,
-0.7254216074943542,
-0.6867408156394958,
-0.4085465371608734,
-0.0599471852183342,
0.19942350685596466,
0.6463452577590942,
0.1206916943192482,
-0.06669288128614426,
0.2567523717880249,
0.79268878698349,
-0.2742043137550354,
0.19255521893501282,
0.25563713908195496,
-0.46650972962379456,
-0.3713858723640442,
0.699242353439331,
0.14780691266059875,
0.10155943781137466,
0.08580347150564194,
0.15216399729251862,
-0.11481829732656479,
-0.4435879588127136,
0.02908407337963581,
0.22777849435806274,
-0.970600426197052,
-0.11220082640647888,
-1.0273538827896118,
-0.6155644655227661,
-0.49202781915664673,
-0.08390004187822342,
-0.3023300766944885,
-0.02627444453537464,
-0.09063056111335754,
-0.33409997820854187,
-0.17853949964046478,
0.6739161610603333,
-0.24721060693264008,
0.30711477994918823,
-0.6062496304512024,
0.3717561364173889,
0.6562536358833313,
0.21983321011066437,
-0.19739791750907898,
-0.5425287485122681,
0.013375869020819664,
-0.256875604391098,
-0.35299909114837646,
-1.0728250741958618,
0.37490418553352356,
-0.21298247575759888,
0.8369723558425903,
0.3496021032333374,
-0.17012059688568115,
0.7047107219696045,
-0.42594394087791443,
0.7041059732437134,
-0.04875791817903519,
-1.359545350074768,
0.42002153396606445,
-0.2101600468158722,
0.11022184044122696,
0.5152097940444946,
0.27109581232070923,
-0.6398816704750061,
-0.5610620379447937,
-0.515773355960846,
-0.481116384267807,
0.4928722083568573,
0.18149419128894806,
-0.05178326368331909,
0.19693690538406372,
0.24418596923351288,
0.2564460039138794,
0.22539864480495453,
-1.2575969696044922,
0.1323954313993454,
-0.3225702941417694,
0.009145197458565235,
0.004218584857881069,
-0.47113293409347534,
-0.04413770139217377,
-0.21375028789043427,
0.6684178113937378,
-0.061786048114299774,
0.3740686774253845,
0.19337420165538788,
-0.2729680836200714,
-0.21589037775993347,
0.2089715301990509,
0.8018691539764404,
0.6812043786048889,
-0.4881740212440491,
0.45251551270484924,
0.4439716041088104,
-0.5045572519302368,
0.07169303297996521,
-0.03137638792395592,
0.04203221574425697,
0.25621774792671204,
0.7073479294776917,
0.8047060966491699,
0.330080509185791,
-0.2962324321269989,
0.5899636745452881,
-0.08538980036973953,
-0.4944992959499359,
-0.27086424827575684,
0.016315704211592674,
0.08974948525428772,
0.5215746164321899,
0.3085594177246094,
0.05874080955982208,
0.515411376953125,
-0.5017513632774353,
0.6407739520072937,
0.41025498509407043,
-0.6025601029396057,
-0.38735783100128174,
0.772483229637146,
-0.08293823152780533,
-0.32115715742111206,
0.337013840675354,
-0.3842354714870453,
-1.1230336427688599,
0.3516503572463989,
0.4899946451187134,
1.1228138208389282,
-0.7447634935379028,
0.16397270560264587,
0.35284122824668884,
0.6547155380249023,
-0.48819923400878906,
0.4172064960002899,
0.08070923388004303,
-0.6878119707107544,
-0.47341302037239075,
-0.49107998609542847,
-0.31118112802505493,
0.442226767539978,
-0.5121378302574158,
0.710945725440979,
0.08871734887361526,
-0.1633671224117279,
-0.2491636425256729,
-0.25245586037635803,
-0.46169131994247437,
-0.171021968126297,
0.10797444730997086,
0.4665844738483429,
-1.1061625480651855,
0.7560106515884399,
0.16396763920783997,
-0.03329360857605934,
-0.5422829389572144,
0.1477874219417572,
0.04951396957039833,
-0.7873212099075317,
0.5075842142105103,
0.4275885224342346,
-0.23841223120689392,
-0.1118425503373146,
-0.3113642632961273,
-0.7327423095703125,
1.2292531728744507,
0.16966530680656433,
-0.755179226398468,
-0.21250297129154205,
-0.0712558701634407,
0.5091850161552429,
-0.2264237254858017,
0.0770794227719307,
0.7254927754402161,
0.6847273707389832,
0.3020680546760559,
-0.8908431529998779,
0.15845917165279388,
0.27238771319389343,
-0.46120160818099976,
0.34901413321495056,
-0.4429645538330078,
0.9412965178489685,
-0.15918418765068054,
-0.3006904721260071,
-0.2801589071750641,
0.3911384344100952,
0.486296147108078,
0.34189462661743164,
0.5824764370918274,
0.6102763414382935,
0.7785855531692505,
-0.14587636291980743,
0.5321856737136841,
-0.26461803913116455,
0.6712262034416199,
1.3068426847457886,
-0.3640970289707184,
0.5089439749717712,
0.41549772024154663,
-0.04812841862440109,
0.17778457701206207,
0.6724004149436951,
-0.33297696709632874,
0.7839128971099854,
0.3226519227027893,
-0.07486450672149658,
-0.5077003836631775,
0.2460593581199646,
-0.5835171341896057,
0.3774200975894928,
0.3419906198978424,
-0.32577547430992126,
-0.17967331409454346,
0.1464441418647766,
-0.15681102871894836,
-0.38080930709838867,
0.14068670570850372,
0.4944661855697632,
0.274315744638443,
-0.6128387451171875,
0.25308242440223694,
-0.1889883577823639,
0.7458017468452454,
-0.20222923159599304,
-0.13575059175491333,
-0.20119264721870422,
0.28034335374832153,
-0.23432573676109314,
-0.48997825384140015,
0.5260409116744995,
-0.2788071930408478,
0.20754411816596985,
-0.028644753620028496,
0.892794668674469,
-0.5094376802444458,
-0.5571369528770447,
0.7077573537826538,
0.5496883392333984,
0.2755220830440521,
-0.42724868655204773,
-0.4131341874599457,
0.3886696696281433,
0.021824073046445847,
-0.17487430572509766,
-0.12679162621498108,
0.6696518659591675,
0.029266342520713806,
0.5073580145835876,
0.15261738002300262,
-0.09217046201229095,
0.15752749145030975,
0.2369646579027176,
0.48589012026786804,
-0.6819879412651062,
-0.1962345540523529,
-1.1331511735916138,
0.23578038811683655,
0.16464006900787354,
-0.00008902460831450298,
0.6885216236114502,
0.46191439032554626,
0.45641496777534485,
-0.10299990326166153,
0.6359323859214783,
0.10107287764549255,
0.3410402238368988,
-0.3621350824832916,
0.5074806809425354,
-0.43403851985931396,
0.24934402108192444,
-0.46855419874191284,
-1.3360649347305298,
-0.2763337194919586,
0.8031403422355652,
-0.14761008322238922,
0.02319861203432083,
1.039263129234314,
0.8225736618041992,
-0.20279987156391144,
0.1564609408378601,
0.6006079316139221,
0.11940835416316986,
0.4546511769294739,
0.8602084517478943,
1.0576999187469482,
-0.6013254523277283,
0.49336332082748413,
-0.24424630403518677,
-0.2833535373210907,
-0.33032864332199097,
-0.8900570869445801,
-0.9689367413520813,
-0.9179013967514038,
-0.3742923438549042,
-0.26139143109321594,
-0.10953254252672195,
0.5931053161621094,
0.6716578006744385,
-0.9347960352897644,
-0.034349825233221054,
-0.07516157627105713,
0.013756713829934597,
-0.261016309261322,
-0.2600294351577759,
0.37269899249076843,
-0.19827818870544434,
-0.6281269192695618,
0.1961575299501419,
0.34552881121635437,
0.06340844929218292,
-0.524568498134613,
-0.07428079098463058,
0.08680254220962524,
0.16390223801136017,
0.5695337057113647,
-0.5326339602470398,
-0.9313415288925171,
-0.6585239768028259,
0.1760881543159485,
-0.194305881857872,
-0.1177595853805542,
0.785895586013794,
-0.35681474208831787,
0.19370754063129425,
0.5924423933029175,
0.4240562319755554,
0.7978530526161194,
-0.14365649223327637,
0.3803602457046509,
-0.17417187988758087,
-0.22827136516571045,
0.25291839241981506,
0.54545658826828,
0.10923998057842255,
-0.6495184898376465,
0.9895645380020142,
0.31426501274108887,
-0.9726001620292664,
-1.1374174356460571,
0.02255488932132721,
-0.8094421625137329,
-0.47042715549468994,
0.9493650197982788,
0.2457783818244934,
0.053010109812021255,
-0.0291840098798275,
-0.07674490660429001,
0.19111745059490204,
-0.07231427729129791,
1.1828268766403198,
1.3265122175216675,
-0.29290178418159485,
-0.37674668431282043,
-0.9184308052062988,
0.5540772080421448,
0.17466618120670319,
-0.8470380306243896,
0.08651120960712433,
0.49312320351600647,
0.14594823122024536,
0.5493701100349426,
0.7002729177474976,
-0.17918957769870758,
0.15119825303554535,
0.055417973548173904,
0.2788861393928528,
-0.02575463429093361,
-0.6078868508338928,
-0.5972442626953125,
0.08140634000301361,
-0.2284729927778244,
-0.24815815687179565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06921v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06921v1
|
GoEX: Perspectives and Designs Towards a Runtime for Autonomous LLM Applications
| 2024-04-10T11:17:33 | 2024-04-10T11:17:33 |
Shishir G. Patil, Tianjun Zhang, Vivian Fang, Noppapon C., Roy Huang, Aaron Hao, Martin Casado, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Raluca Ada Popa, Ion Stoica
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are evolving beyond their classical role of
providing information within dialogue systems to actively engaging with tools
and performing actions on real-world applications and services. Today, humans
verify the correctness and appropriateness of the LLM-generated outputs (e.g.,
code, functions, or actions) before putting them into real-world execution.
This poses significant challenges as code comprehension is well known to be
notoriously difficult. In this paper, we study how humans can efficiently
collaborate with, delegate to, and supervise autonomous LLMs in the future. We
argue that in many cases, "post-facto validation" - verifying the correctness
of a proposed action after seeing the output - is much easier than the
aforementioned "pre-facto validation" setting. The core concept behind enabling
a post-facto validation system is the integration of an intuitive undo feature,
and establishing a damage confinement for the LLM-generated actions as
effective strategies to mitigate the associated risks. Using this, a human can
now either revert the effect of an LLM-generated output or be confident that
the potential risk is bounded. We believe this is critical to unlock the
potential for LLM agents to interact with applications and services with
limited (post-facto) human involvement. We describe the design and
implementation of our open-source runtime for executing LLM actions, Gorilla
Execution Engine (GoEX), and present open research questions towards realizing
the goal of LLMs and applications interacting with each other with minimal
human supervision. We release GoEX at https://github.com/ShishirPatil/gorilla/.
|
[
-0.2023228406906128,
-0.5362215042114258,
0.7897526025772095,
0.17029431462287903,
0.0791604146361351,
0.17264026403427124,
-0.15870745480060577,
-0.6846866011619568,
0.004435787908732891,
0.6959946155548096,
-0.5971104502677917,
-0.38985636830329895,
-0.2983616292476654,
-0.18320320546627045,
-0.35946953296661377,
0.8244795203208923,
-0.4421516954898834,
-0.38415613770484924,
-0.4004240334033966,
-0.2356410026550293,
-0.02665487490594387,
-0.6281502842903137,
-0.5559271574020386,
-0.33298882842063904,
0.3232266306877136,
0.19146345555782318,
0.9758375883102417,
0.6952052712440491,
0.5037741661071777,
0.3340519666671753,
-0.08804704993963242,
0.2120160162448883,
-0.3683663308620453,
-0.08924712985754013,
-0.2837577760219574,
-0.3925299048423767,
-0.763139009475708,
0.13154077529907227,
0.29280009865760803,
0.7130841612815857,
-0.31591954827308655,
0.06309480220079422,
0.1696496456861496,
0.49574679136276245,
-0.664506733417511,
-0.025241266936063766,
-0.2227432131767273,
0.09243927150964737,
0.028623471036553383,
0.05319547280669212,
-0.2480558604001999,
-0.4369606375694275,
-0.08222921937704086,
-0.6131272912025452,
-0.19733943045139313,
0.1274181455373764,
0.6961352825164795,
0.4960539638996124,
-0.19480110704898834,
-0.21505969762802124,
-0.9171538949012756,
0.8006497621536255,
-0.7411854267120361,
0.27145326137542725,
0.17033478617668152,
0.3032767176628113,
-0.510854184627533,
-0.9029258489608765,
-0.6203380823135376,
-0.28772345185279846,
-0.07137090712785721,
0.20488429069519043,
-0.05346761643886566,
0.1758829802274704,
0.29820430278778076,
0.7429656386375427,
-0.6017876863479614,
0.1808464378118515,
-0.13243745267391205,
-0.18772131204605103,
0.5684815049171448,
0.2622382342815399,
0.3947232663631439,
0.3822728097438812,
-0.42768216133117676,
0.13918519020080566,
-1.072453498840332,
0.27667781710624695,
0.5118095874786377,
-0.12412666529417038,
-0.15600478649139404,
0.46584784984588623,
-0.18188193440437317,
0.5562005043029785,
-0.3226112425327301,
0.3490030765533447,
-0.04465577378869057,
-0.39550474286079407,
-0.37678706645965576,
-0.40132465958595276,
0.8616960048675537,
0.13149067759513855,
0.2014501988887787,
-0.2272007018327713,
-0.4488820433616638,
0.0490884967148304,
0.6472442746162415,
-0.41827628016471863,
-0.1405184119939804,
0.40308934450149536,
-0.43693816661834717,
-0.3294360339641571,
0.05257139727473259,
-0.5371145606040955,
-0.40846920013427734,
-0.5942612290382385,
0.5667182207107544,
-0.25805988907814026,
-0.2770553529262543,
0.13380341231822968,
0.22326113283634186,
0.28452080488204956,
0.4452293813228607,
-0.60068279504776,
0.6584412455558777,
0.7760730385780334,
0.6310606598854065,
-0.25133293867111206,
-0.44589653611183167,
-0.8080294728279114,
0.35642558336257935,
-0.6439939737319946,
0.42590659856796265,
-0.39755186438560486,
-0.37227073311805725,
-0.16036270558834076,
-0.15304924547672272,
0.15524853765964508,
-0.5879494547843933,
0.3563571572303772,
-0.5598641037940979,
0.05937102064490318,
0.1259632557630539,
-0.390950471162796,
-0.27827560901641846,
0.23879474401474,
-0.5228114128112793,
0.8181412816047668,
0.08416914939880371,
-0.5526568293571472,
0.11985878646373749,
-0.9791817665100098,
-0.4286244511604309,
0.09144166857004166,
-0.3284189701080322,
-0.21690399944782257,
0.26811131834983826,
0.10522949695587158,
0.25047361850738525,
-0.15686209499835968,
0.190743088722229,
-0.24458655714988708,
-0.48542729020118713,
0.05557217076420784,
-0.23082083463668823,
0.6747525930404663,
0.05923161283135414,
-0.5779628157615662,
0.6018669605255127,
-0.7747049927711487,
0.25708410143852234,
-0.011442283168435097,
-0.24619798362255096,
-0.1492929607629776,
0.40016940236091614,
-0.3692396581172943,
0.20812809467315674,
0.28065454959869385,
-0.4448661804199219,
0.11493966728448868,
-0.27548545598983765,
0.3884322941303253,
0.8583703637123108,
-0.24608439207077026,
0.5284770727157593,
-0.30535903573036194,
0.6806185245513916,
-0.0955231562256813,
0.6087028980255127,
-0.32174161076545715,
-0.22536557912826538,
-0.6675211191177368,
-0.23291492462158203,
0.007683297619223595,
0.7233249545097351,
-0.7621580362319946,
0.4905095100402832,
-0.08139099180698395,
-0.6067197322845459,
-0.19992117583751678,
0.44747820496559143,
0.38744333386421204,
0.3514229655265808,
0.2574142515659332,
-0.20490247011184692,
-0.4998939335346222,
-0.9355618953704834,
-0.1378459483385086,
-0.5294621586799622,
-0.2195594757795334,
0.5079374313354492,
0.3728271722793579,
-0.5685749053955078,
1.2064213752746582,
-0.4183702766895294,
-0.07686009258031845,
-0.2834213376045227,
0.004370444919914007,
0.3610707223415375,
0.4479595720767975,
0.23305927217006683,
-0.5734305381774902,
-0.12466346472501755,
0.25197410583496094,
-0.9904597997665405,
-0.30783069133758545,
0.08055150508880615,
-0.21458041667938232,
0.32027244567871094,
0.6887369155883789,
-0.4043598473072052,
0.6242312788963318,
0.7564733028411865,
0.010442880913615227,
0.825390636920929,
-0.44338998198509216,
0.0226144902408123,
-0.5589977502822876,
0.26052048802375793,
-0.4842391610145569,
-0.44931432604789734,
-0.45233556628227234,
0.1546376347541809,
0.03644178807735443,
-0.2911974787712097,
-0.5991976857185364,
0.5665902495384216,
-0.393997460603714,
-0.15392445027828217,
-0.34999382495880127,
-0.04216524958610535,
-0.021068425849080086,
0.40861523151397705,
0.3655773997306824,
0.9869204759597778,
0.705661416053772,
-1.0358251333236694,
0.4146435260772705,
-0.10351485013961792,
-0.40146493911743164,
0.5150015950202942,
-0.9180470705032349,
0.38419225811958313,
0.21687598526477814,
0.16851100325584412,
-0.7507415413856506,
-0.27499040961265564,
0.13229286670684814,
-0.13952673971652985,
-0.09612477570772171,
0.08948353677988052,
-0.595663845539093,
-0.38800039887428284,
-0.26765957474708557,
0.1497124880552292,
0.4414786398410797,
-0.6846562027931213,
0.8143752217292786,
0.42087894678115845,
-0.2214604616165161,
-0.5163458585739136,
-0.6279750466346741,
0.3782796263694763,
-0.15437941253185272,
-0.748481273651123,
0.18504557013511658,
-0.14565417170524597,
-0.5489730834960938,
-0.13901716470718384,
-0.0995459258556366,
-0.05228176340460777,
0.25321465730667114,
0.4953725337982178,
0.249841570854187,
-0.005068395286798477,
-0.15925966203212738,
0.043514400720596313,
-0.3245556950569153,
-0.017797861248254776,
-0.3146120309829712,
0.22418422996997833,
-0.18585100769996643,
-0.5013846755027771,
-0.2498980015516281,
0.4965917766094208,
0.5780584216117859,
-0.25019553303718567,
0.4358130991458893,
0.1328747421503067,
-0.2833169400691986,
-0.32164493203163147,
-0.38492193818092346,
-0.022047588601708412,
-0.5618489384651184,
0.03073173202574253,
-0.17078690230846405,
-0.9731168150901794,
0.6535553336143494,
-0.09994111210107803,
0.4295565187931061,
-0.0654653012752533,
0.5824244618415833,
-0.04858357086777687,
0.7519817352294922,
0.8726063370704651,
0.059152618050575256,
0.2494715005159378,
0.07522864639759064,
0.20890237390995026,
-0.794704258441925,
-0.025287937372922897,
-0.23361836373806,
-0.26863721013069153,
-0.05929847061634064,
-0.47127029299736023,
0.34424635767936707,
0.014061477035284042,
-0.236007422208786,
0.52602219581604,
-0.29665714502334595,
0.473964661359787,
0.6220816373825073,
-0.20007643103599548,
0.20322518050670624,
-0.4692347049713135,
-0.15410292148590088,
0.1795099973678589,
-0.45325350761413574,
-0.9751555323600769,
0.7297555208206177,
0.45267122983932495,
1.1589487791061401,
0.3032793700695038,
0.750366747379303,
0.21524366736412048,
0.4152878522872925,
-0.4909095764160156,
0.8604347109794617,
0.2352355718612671,
-0.5687355399131775,
-0.22551077604293823,
-0.35560116171836853,
-0.8284144997596741,
-0.02851514331996441,
0.46767881512641907,
-0.8012515306472778,
-0.08624476194381714,
0.31349286437034607,
-0.5249608159065247,
0.3187556564807892,
-0.7626453638076782,
0.8146040439605713,
-0.473064124584198,
-0.5969294905662537,
-0.08063898235559464,
-0.7248201370239258,
0.44735491275787354,
-0.08356941491365433,
0.35594698786735535,
0.26236090064048767,
-0.3625982403755188,
0.5815578103065491,
-0.6150545477867126,
0.9104575514793396,
-0.1548493653535843,
-0.6694154739379883,
0.5514482855796814,
0.3245885968208313,
0.7035295963287354,
-0.006762837991118431,
0.0772516056895256,
0.19761031866073608,
-0.16788119077682495,
-0.015569298528134823,
-0.505066990852356,
0.6318557858467102,
-0.5477072596549988,
-0.6138876080513,
-0.2535812556743622,
-0.3265337347984314,
-0.20508253574371338,
0.16691333055496216,
-0.012181796133518219,
0.13098450005054474,
-0.29379963874816895,
0.0063743507489562035,
0.6410030126571655,
-0.4235982894897461,
0.7254173755645752,
0.6491193771362305,
-0.7772057056427002,
-0.35796353220939636,
0.8518652319908142,
0.03236416354775429,
0.3281518220901489,
0.1545511931180954,
0.009574412368237972,
-0.16841164231300354,
-0.6114639043807983,
-0.3925764560699463,
0.017440784722566605,
-0.4315040409564972,
0.10525288432836533,
-0.5859623551368713,
-0.11965244263410568,
-0.2883416414260864,
-0.2426195591688156,
-0.5168903470039368,
-0.14294883608818054,
-0.33240270614624023,
-0.030325718224048615,
-0.033693838864564896,
0.8774651885032654,
-0.2847287058830261,
0.334624707698822,
-0.929908812046051,
0.2392628788948059,
0.3744540512561798,
0.6517543196678162,
-0.23691366612911224,
-0.2778717875480652,
-0.2788628041744232,
-0.20174656808376312,
-0.40571752190589905,
-0.41048118472099304,
0.11791544407606125,
0.012071367353200912,
0.7408791184425354,
0.4744396507740021,
0.06299210339784622,
0.4590509235858917,
-0.6754623651504517,
0.9937506914138794,
-0.1253826767206192,
-1.15788996219635,
0.628149151802063,
-0.278611958026886,
-0.026459768414497375,
0.4260249435901642,
0.23253917694091797,
-0.5700618028640747,
-0.4957650601863861,
-0.6202917695045471,
-0.7874179482460022,
0.7325513958930969,
0.3235930800437927,
0.08511613309383392,
0.09883382171392441,
0.17491169273853302,
0.23133349418640137,
0.21659879386425018,
-0.5890467762947083,
0.05951765552163124,
-0.011805071495473385,
0.12613725662231445,
-0.09551620483398438,
-0.22613154351711273,
-0.13809236884117126,
0.2928072214126587,
0.5906670689582825,
-0.16719436645507812,
0.19359304010868073,
0.15213799476623535,
-0.14445854723453522,
0.017613951116800308,
0.18493007123470306,
0.6855759024620056,
0.6999192237854004,
-0.01425714697688818,
0.276364266872406,
-0.03827108070254326,
-0.2655744254589081,
0.3147358298301697,
-0.1944892257452011,
-0.013799631968140602,
-0.29435938596725464,
0.4555152952671051,
0.5562444925308228,
0.05137701332569122,
-0.9042618274688721,
0.44043317437171936,
-0.14289812743663788,
-0.19153441488742828,
-0.38383749127388,
0.4257594645023346,
0.001399425556883216,
0.20589129626750946,
0.19523437321186066,
-0.08971615135669708,
0.025720439851284027,
-0.4582044184207916,
0.31004780530929565,
0.2890245020389557,
-0.39601731300354004,
-0.4994923174381256,
0.7706928253173828,
0.3393530249595642,
-0.45329293608665466,
0.31341031193733215,
-0.19400088489055634,
-0.38009878993034363,
0.5548518300056458,
0.22302207350730896,
0.8915143013000488,
-0.27999961376190186,
-0.06117979809641838,
-0.10730262100696564,
0.4683154225349426,
-0.047852203249931335,
0.4009179174900055,
-0.16183434426784515,
-0.4984745681285858,
-0.7910016179084778,
-0.464677095413208,
-0.9595685005187988,
0.25503411889076233,
-0.31836214661598206,
0.31027427315711975,
-0.6611886620521545,
0.10281447321176529,
-0.5141165852546692,
-0.3629806339740753,
-0.13860656321048737,
0.19836674630641937,
0.2428920865058899,
1.0667527914047241,
-0.44659623503685,
0.5005213022232056,
0.9013316631317139,
-0.04513735696673393,
-0.678611159324646,
0.041555266827344894,
0.14371679723262787,
-0.4362126588821411,
0.6259452700614929,
0.2616595923900604,
-0.33608126640319824,
-0.1106412410736084,
-0.7060524225234985,
-0.6833204627037048,
0.7690114974975586,
0.39185312390327454,
-0.521368682384491,
0.13793519139289856,
0.02146919257938862,
0.520931601524353,
-0.09492947161197662,
0.19692352414131165,
0.318263441324234,
0.4784736633300781,
0.040783438831567764,
-0.9547430276870728,
-0.13890080153942108,
-0.17802919447422028,
-0.18414612114429474,
0.10268738865852356,
-0.5410474538803101,
0.7269191145896912,
-0.21429990231990814,
-0.2016030102968216,
0.06425116956233978,
0.8271473050117493,
0.16251477599143982,
0.30429959297180176,
0.47331932187080383,
0.5307787656784058,
0.6812620162963867,
0.060317572206258774,
1.3518677949905396,
-0.19971199333667755,
0.04126359522342682,
1.214637279510498,
-0.8079881072044373,
0.5774838924407959,
0.39919352531433105,
-0.4983711540699005,
0.4690956473350525,
0.4705163836479187,
0.5590218305587769,
0.17289526760578156,
0.3361596465110779,
-0.4932539463043213,
-0.1919494867324829,
0.16886432468891144,
-0.007004948332905769,
0.38470274209976196,
0.19111798703670502,
-0.11671635508537292,
-0.32970330119132996,
-0.049467943608760834,
0.04215368255972862,
0.061647165566682816,
-0.3318251371383667,
0.8977531790733337,
0.044093046337366104,
-0.8278493881225586,
0.23363760113716125,
-0.1697814017534256,
0.5496135354042053,
-0.6963092684745789,
0.038426026701927185,
-0.23696807026863098,
0.44719216227531433,
-0.21922902762889862,
-0.902262806892395,
0.8279673457145691,
0.0640876367688179,
-0.01731237955391407,
-0.2831667959690094,
0.5925657749176025,
-0.05746261402964592,
-0.009319297038018703,
0.4338974356651306,
0.4429567754268646,
0.253211110830307,
-0.17760567367076874,
-0.42232227325439453,
0.25328442454338074,
-0.1444043070077896,
-0.4820793569087982,
0.2782042324542999,
0.4306254982948303,
-0.17429333925247192,
0.8833088874816895,
0.6988534331321716,
0.09741833060979843,
0.055347103625535965,
-0.17892441153526306,
0.8873757123947144,
-0.5777429938316345,
-0.5311420559883118,
-0.9663606286048889,
0.45451289415359497,
-0.01203902903944254,
0.11079388111829758,
0.5858964920043945,
0.578157365322113,
0.6029947996139526,
0.005132438614964485,
0.943393886089325,
-0.16967198252677917,
0.5505098700523376,
-0.49054598808288574,
0.7568913698196411,
-0.4357110559940338,
0.19074255228042603,
-0.2001168131828308,
-0.8190109729766846,
-0.4200119376182556,
0.5106347799301147,
-0.2504395842552185,
0.02576550655066967,
0.5391423106193542,
0.8572173714637756,
-0.06523584574460983,
-0.04209594428539276,
0.4037988781929016,
-0.036473289132118225,
0.849746823310852,
0.6882675886154175,
1.0891112089157104,
0.004790604114532471,
0.61586594581604,
-0.041281118988990784,
-0.5680916905403137,
0.024474747478961945,
-1.3236470222473145,
-0.7147755026817322,
-0.14868728816509247,
-0.40801718831062317,
-0.23002147674560547,
-0.12427139282226562,
0.7279459834098816,
0.6049969792366028,
-0.5823806524276733,
-0.34173062443733215,
-0.3944873511791229,
0.16636358201503754,
-0.41545265913009644,
-0.14233346283435822,
0.11568804830312729,
-0.45469823479652405,
-0.754803478717804,
0.5922732949256897,
0.765879213809967,
0.030746132135391235,
-0.35304975509643555,
-0.3391380310058594,
0.08053341507911682,
0.2317706048488617,
0.5162928700447083,
0.5339003801345825,
-0.437105268239975,
-0.3183407783508301,
-0.06680768728256226,
-0.20405030250549316,
-0.09416760504245758,
0.9552758932113647,
-0.9327282309532166,
0.1564708948135376,
0.32222071290016174,
0.8532021641731262,
-0.0998062863945961,
-0.04309697076678276,
0.817130982875824,
-0.650358259677887,
-0.11764781177043915,
0.19030673801898956,
0.2827986478805542,
0.15593205392360687,
-0.23955315351486206,
0.7735157608985901,
0.15199467539787292,
-0.7548520565032959,
-0.8576382994651794,
0.3911808729171753,
-0.7805158495903015,
0.057321738451719284,
1.0472254753112793,
-0.5658922791481018,
-0.3522210717201233,
-0.23671726882457733,
-0.40691763162612915,
-0.036332033574581146,
0.0013454732252284884,
0.5675421953201294,
0.7226500511169434,
-0.20239083468914032,
-0.2874745726585388,
-0.4258415102958679,
0.3760586678981781,
0.3002852201461792,
-1.1131609678268433,
0.579780101776123,
0.44374263286590576,
0.03136707469820976,
0.23367242515087128,
0.6160873770713806,
-0.33766213059425354,
0.30063024163246155,
-0.27663516998291016,
0.35012444853782654,
-0.45168405771255493,
-0.3271625339984894,
-0.3091132342815399,
0.008555419743061066,
-0.1200418770313263,
-0.19917109608650208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06911v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06911v1
|
GraSAME: Injecting Token-Level Structural Information to Pretrained Language Models via Graph-guided Self-Attention Mechanism
| 2024-04-10T11:03:57 | 2024-04-10T11:03:57 |
Shuzhou Yuan, Michael Färber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) benefit from external knowledge stored in
graph structures for various downstream tasks. However, bridging the modality
gap between graph structures and text remains a significant challenge.
Traditional methods like linearizing graphs for PLMs lose vital graph
connectivity, whereas Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) require cumbersome processes
for integration into PLMs. In this work, we propose a novel graph-guided
self-attention mechanism, GraSAME. GraSAME seamlessly incorporates token-level
structural information into PLMs without necessitating additional alignment or
concatenation efforts. As an end-to-end, lightweight multimodal module, GraSAME
follows a multi-task learning strategy and effectively bridges the gap between
graph and textual modalities, facilitating dynamic interactions between GNNs
and PLMs. Our experiments on the graph-to-text generation task demonstrate that
GraSAME outperforms baseline models and achieves results comparable to
state-of-the-art (SOTA) models on WebNLG datasets. Furthermore, compared to
SOTA models, GraSAME eliminates the need for extra pre-training tasks to adjust
graph inputs and reduces the number of trainable parameters by over 100
million.
|
[
-0.1705542802810669,
-0.8184167742729187,
0.3860369324684143,
0.1950223743915558,
-0.45822957158088684,
-0.05154849961400032,
-0.03019615262746811,
-0.2102251946926117,
0.3246699273586273,
0.3990052044391632,
-0.6255533695220947,
-0.6895509362220764,
-0.6618767380714417,
-0.1521201878786087,
-0.2514204680919647,
1.1612820625305176,
0.09170426428318024,
-0.059272401034832,
-0.39202365279197693,
0.0574834980070591,
-0.3098277449607849,
-0.4674605429172516,
-0.5193332433700562,
-0.18582689762115479,
0.7572565078735352,
-0.05504545569419861,
0.5907543897628784,
0.6430477499961853,
0.1514238864183426,
0.3160156309604645,
0.026394635438919067,
0.2259814292192459,
-0.545397937297821,
-0.15010038018226624,
-0.09758058190345764,
-0.4210384488105774,
-0.4445105791091919,
0.15487122535705566,
0.8093076348304749,
0.7596631646156311,
0.2352110594511032,
0.2711133062839508,
0.4131048023700714,
0.5832828283309937,
-0.5240675806999207,
0.47924619913101196,
-0.5695223808288574,
0.0057296440936625,
-0.5056632161140442,
-0.2235994189977646,
-0.47082751989364624,
-0.1620045006275177,
0.05792191997170448,
-0.6391361355781555,
0.20016102492809296,
-0.11356914788484573,
0.9314510226249695,
0.3979441821575165,
-0.5311452746391296,
-0.2582848072052002,
-0.00027692277217283845,
0.4089413285255432,
-0.593836784362793,
0.31292012333869934,
0.3698231875896454,
0.1511523276567459,
-0.4957449436187744,
-0.9673483371734619,
-0.23208793997764587,
-0.33604851365089417,
-0.4499456584453583,
0.14678217470645905,
0.17252914607524872,
0.35064464807510376,
-0.17836715281009674,
0.2687855362892151,
-0.6779034733772278,
-0.198811873793602,
-0.004573136102408171,
-0.3241615295410156,
-0.0737871378660202,
-0.22724904119968414,
0.40096569061279297,
-0.3721272647380829,
-0.46308207511901855,
0.17907501757144928,
-0.5828282237052917,
-0.1772451549768448,
0.59641033411026,
0.5958662629127502,
0.01824135147035122,
0.31794318556785583,
0.015003793872892857,
0.8775826692581177,
0.22032222151756287,
-0.03421609103679657,
0.3806169927120209,
-0.5026888847351074,
-0.2388884723186493,
-0.06665317714214325,
0.9394724369049072,
-0.06971793621778488,
0.050566669553518295,
-0.4248255491256714,
-0.06738513708114624,
0.14192843437194824,
0.23529382050037384,
-0.8633317351341248,
-0.18044857680797577,
-0.017929259687662125,
-0.4204055070877075,
-0.22633960843086243,
-0.16039586067199707,
-0.6201210618019104,
-0.056430134922266006,
-0.06380295753479004,
0.6144898533821106,
-0.2807082235813141,
0.0064401510171592236,
0.2307101935148239,
0.020593365654349327,
-0.38174036145210266,
0.16063416004180908,
-0.8915701508522034,
0.2667805254459381,
0.3911260664463043,
1.0899165868759155,
0.013389458879828453,
-0.46061065793037415,
-1.0093261003494263,
0.5332680940628052,
-0.04036307707428932,
0.8019922375679016,
-0.6225964426994324,
-0.2255493849515915,
-0.1325458437204361,
0.21805709600448608,
-0.5047253370285034,
-0.07849444448947906,
0.15590447187423706,
-0.3810521364212036,
0.507043719291687,
0.053658030927181244,
-0.5077479481697083,
-0.21157942712306976,
0.21510444581508636,
-0.5175629258155823,
1.0894627571105957,
0.19496887922286987,
-0.8387812972068787,
0.18157771229743958,
-0.7778696417808533,
-0.6794894933700562,
0.3351803719997406,
-0.4106736183166504,
-0.4172767102718353,
-0.011902767233550549,
0.34263476729393005,
0.5636383295059204,
-0.18764394521713257,
0.28559648990631104,
-0.254816472530365,
-0.1252666562795639,
-0.31818121671676636,
-0.15942218899726868,
0.3806383013725281,
0.061104804277420044,
-0.3015335202217102,
0.48229527473449707,
-0.6633983850479126,
0.03362489119172096,
0.1806461066007614,
-0.4827251732349396,
-0.3365114629268646,
-0.31854063272476196,
-0.16949264705181122,
0.33694180846214294,
0.5030366778373718,
-0.4482930898666382,
0.19692325592041016,
-0.49889618158340454,
0.6023430824279785,
0.699682891368866,
-0.18329539895057678,
0.5524149537086487,
-0.05843209847807884,
0.6158394813537598,
-0.2651459574699402,
0.05546271428465843,
-0.5716883540153503,
-0.28148993849754333,
-0.5463203191757202,
-0.4411941468715668,
0.4025173783302307,
0.1122872531414032,
-0.6594173312187195,
0.3027653396129608,
-0.11497237533330917,
-0.47014009952545166,
-0.4057174026966095,
0.1980518102645874,
0.580514132976532,
0.7011803984642029,
0.3229481875896454,
-0.36693012714385986,
-0.183679461479187,
-0.5593281388282776,
-0.31065139174461365,
-0.11979509145021439,
0.18920521438121796,
0.6153537034988403,
0.3049832880496979,
-0.36234551668167114,
0.8239145278930664,
-0.4200228154659271,
-0.7116557955741882,
-0.28310126066207886,
0.41754281520843506,
0.07251859456300735,
0.4667912721633911,
0.7827231884002686,
-0.4014410674571991,
-0.4693690836429596,
0.08268201351165771,
-0.5386641025543213,
-0.33866533637046814,
-0.1633126586675644,
-0.21564361453056335,
-0.02819077856838703,
0.5802183747291565,
-0.6542673110961914,
0.25482267141342163,
0.684535562992096,
-0.3368282914161682,
0.44549426436424255,
-0.19510874152183533,
-0.014261916279792786,
-1.2075282335281372,
0.2542658746242523,
-0.13251346349716187,
-0.5034335255622864,
-0.6205086708068848,
0.04580334946513176,
0.13644419610500336,
-0.28765708208084106,
-0.456133633852005,
0.8343846201896667,
-0.7662635445594788,
-0.3115379810333252,
-0.3183775246143341,
0.31123510003089905,
0.2253708392381668,
0.8541858792304993,
-0.3410026431083679,
0.9053440690040588,
0.6697834134101868,
-0.6969410181045532,
0.14798015356063843,
0.3114079535007477,
-0.27403274178504944,
0.12827889621257782,
-0.6731804013252258,
0.3354485034942627,
-0.3833003342151642,
0.34044334292411804,
-1.3409210443496704,
-0.22348079085350037,
0.3965415954589844,
-0.574167013168335,
0.38447636365890503,
-0.5523373484611511,
-0.4422820806503296,
-0.21387068927288055,
-0.15634232759475708,
0.5406143069267273,
-0.06122570112347603,
-0.5706673264503479,
0.9953101873397827,
0.44231241941452026,
-0.4814241826534271,
-0.5232048630714417,
-0.5616636276245117,
0.24201852083206177,
-0.003129027783870697,
-0.6358909010887146,
0.2921082079410553,
0.0657588467001915,
0.5838494300842285,
0.046228766441345215,
-0.022280998528003693,
0.09613947570323944,
0.20759150385856628,
0.09713451564311981,
0.01509307511150837,
0.025091521441936493,
0.5672101974487305,
0.15106555819511414,
-0.35360777378082275,
-0.09191256761550903,
-0.7627894282341003,
0.9978482127189636,
-0.13969555497169495,
-0.39894798398017883,
-0.5077094435691833,
0.19424773752689362,
0.5408360958099365,
-0.647750198841095,
0.5624189972877502,
0.6494123339653015,
-0.11204825341701508,
0.039193809032440186,
-0.2520287036895752,
-0.19818896055221558,
-0.5079211592674255,
0.6606584191322327,
-0.424399733543396,
-1.0412627458572388,
0.46510329842567444,
-0.40258127450942993,
-0.18266542255878448,
0.23600000143051147,
0.4134680926799774,
0.06521516293287277,
1.0222820043563843,
0.46220219135284424,
-0.13902504742145538,
0.8359569907188416,
-0.17651697993278503,
0.020740032196044922,
-0.6897361278533936,
-0.19995583593845367,
-0.5356661081314087,
-0.37165287137031555,
-0.08779894560575485,
-0.4281385540962219,
0.1788516640663147,
0.12888213992118835,
-0.008663240820169449,
0.29637932777404785,
-0.44638267159461975,
0.40544942021369934,
0.45519039034843445,
0.002524455077946186,
-0.011194701306521893,
-0.002431424567475915,
-0.4804994761943817,
0.1957246959209442,
-0.859481930732727,
-0.41271108388900757,
0.9257000684738159,
0.2809515595436096,
1.0226953029632568,
-0.13205283880233765,
0.6987296938896179,
0.12881141901016235,
0.2688520848751068,
-0.6150053143501282,
0.6934202909469604,
-0.24402055144309998,
-0.29682767391204834,
-0.4499920904636383,
-0.5548126697540283,
-0.9879304766654968,
0.3087143003940582,
0.18690039217472076,
-0.6406681537628174,
-0.07162056118249893,
0.32893434166908264,
-0.2057238668203354,
-0.011936606839299202,
-0.7985825538635254,
1.2833306789398193,
-0.32922208309173584,
-0.29722297191619873,
-0.0697266235947609,
-0.7503478527069092,
-0.045692071318626404,
0.03240464627742767,
0.2400692254304886,
-0.08444436639547348,
0.007850093767046928,
0.657957136631012,
-0.4877561926841736,
1.1755801439285278,
-0.34392258524894714,
-0.2500748932361603,
0.3423737585544586,
-0.041489552706480026,
0.9188379049301147,
0.0347977951169014,
0.3016670048236847,
0.06803102791309357,
-0.44322842359542847,
-0.5310537815093994,
-0.5597610473632812,
0.6727937459945679,
-0.7090354561805725,
-0.7070788145065308,
-0.1521865278482437,
-0.7524028420448303,
-0.22325122356414795,
0.5002332329750061,
0.1582721769809723,
0.7313902378082275,
0.05030224844813347,
0.1326434463262558,
0.33572736382484436,
0.09157822281122208,
0.451033353805542,
0.2675376832485199,
-0.3522884249687195,
-0.583253800868988,
0.9786187410354614,
0.10445386171340942,
0.45032820105552673,
0.3216868042945862,
0.20749078691005707,
-0.4997193515300751,
-0.5026839971542358,
-0.569614589214325,
0.36201000213623047,
-0.6385334134101868,
-0.04283476248383522,
-1.0274945497512817,
0.028750065714120865,
-0.5840551257133484,
0.012975777499377728,
-0.3061090111732483,
-0.3363310396671295,
-0.4062816798686981,
-0.12256678938865662,
0.10501253604888916,
0.5052104592323303,
0.17101164162158966,
0.7184318900108337,
-0.9073078632354736,
0.2517246603965759,
0.5672557353973389,
0.2842201292514801,
0.05855032429099083,
-0.5002031922340393,
-0.48280856013298035,
-0.011179587803781033,
-0.09251478314399719,
-0.7664415240287781,
0.25697264075279236,
0.42245298624038696,
0.6460357904434204,
0.42885154485702515,
-0.34767886996269226,
0.8573030233383179,
-0.566926896572113,
0.5008934140205383,
0.31435877084732056,
-0.9918815493583679,
0.6163235902786255,
-0.5818847417831421,
0.5188909769058228,
0.47451701760292053,
0.22105324268341064,
-0.46723473072052,
-0.5239159464836121,
-0.2522175908088684,
-0.6874869465827942,
0.667076826095581,
0.14324386417865753,
0.21335071325302124,
-0.33104056119918823,
0.46689337491989136,
0.17429432272911072,
0.4896340072154999,
-0.9399220943450928,
0.036405257880687714,
-0.5377086400985718,
-0.38411593437194824,
-0.030912699177861214,
-0.0428692102432251,
-0.04208604618906975,
0.11276416480541229,
0.5514794588088989,
-0.714120626449585,
0.08764217793941498,
0.03690260276198387,
-0.41535866260528564,
0.06576954573392868,
0.0550159215927124,
0.574915885925293,
0.3873007595539093,
0.11618640273809433,
0.3385012447834015,
-0.1273629516363144,
-0.468305379152298,
0.16024775803089142,
0.265844464302063,
-0.13193361461162567,
0.01688099466264248,
0.2424113154411316,
0.9967733025550842,
0.3080843389034271,
-0.3210039436817169,
0.6131300926208496,
-0.0958767682313919,
-0.06753922998905182,
0.3835339844226837,
-0.047337550669908524,
0.20128977298736572,
0.032346371561288834,
0.33358365297317505,
-0.07132232934236526,
-0.09495033323764801,
-0.5041729211807251,
0.2525486648082733,
0.5478472113609314,
-0.5364134311676025,
-0.504708468914032,
0.8925394415855408,
0.4683729410171509,
-0.14607679843902588,
-0.015869390219449997,
-0.1387072056531906,
-0.4417864978313446,
0.49849969148635864,
0.7567718029022217,
0.8055416941642761,
-0.3908228874206543,
0.5443151593208313,
0.11726630479097366,
0.23060931265354156,
0.15966755151748657,
0.21444621682167053,
-0.11231228709220886,
-0.4806131422519684,
-0.645622730255127,
-0.5733036398887634,
0.15628865361213684,
0.15684902667999268,
-0.24577423930168152,
0.02155127003788948,
-0.45154330134391785,
-0.3244268298149109,
-0.2507818639278412,
-0.2255609929561615,
-0.3301159143447876,
0.2812661826610565,
-0.1719634234905243,
0.49134886264801025,
-0.816717267036438,
0.7355098724365234,
0.8340985774993896,
-0.46853265166282654,
-0.4793040156364441,
-0.03452901169657707,
-0.29645463824272156,
-0.8404453992843628,
0.6255743503570557,
0.606230616569519,
-0.3616940975189209,
0.507411539554596,
-0.3956449329853058,
-1.0774744749069214,
0.862777829170227,
0.7519657611846924,
-0.32269132137298584,
-0.2595316469669342,
0.15982948243618011,
0.27074286341667175,
-0.49305859208106995,
0.15091772377490997,
-0.0045475587248802185,
0.415991872549057,
0.12515889108181,
-0.6060270071029663,
0.004261771682649851,
-0.26822465658187866,
-0.06942266970872879,
0.4766845107078552,
-0.9638175964355469,
0.9324371218681335,
-0.06845459342002869,
-0.6233376860618591,
-0.10427995026111603,
0.784605085849762,
-0.05152597278356552,
-0.161345437169075,
0.6572598814964294,
0.7199825644493103,
0.8787591457366943,
0.1488892287015915,
0.9252496361732483,
-0.5690734386444092,
0.22001783549785614,
1.343873143196106,
-0.2160824090242386,
0.09688425809144974,
0.39214667677879333,
0.16862033307552338,
0.4616308808326721,
0.6149803996086121,
0.29517650604248047,
0.7979385256767273,
0.05081183835864067,
-0.10386262834072113,
-0.43752214312553406,
-0.4401850998401642,
-0.44510704278945923,
0.2603820264339447,
0.1227974221110344,
-0.19755183160305023,
-0.5141264200210571,
0.12792302668094635,
0.08718322217464447,
0.0035640469286590815,
-0.3222801685333252,
0.7221282720565796,
-0.08410974591970444,
-0.4363950788974762,
0.4434843957424164,
-0.22350162267684937,
0.3247735798358917,
-0.9726554155349731,
0.13667337596416473,
-0.1653563678264618,
0.008726277388632298,
-0.09827857464551926,
-0.2579169273376465,
-0.010067395865917206,
-0.30482208728790283,
-0.08759371936321259,
-0.1404552459716797,
0.8655449748039246,
-0.6865173578262329,
-0.28350645303726196,
0.45152539014816284,
0.4493448734283447,
-0.01273511815816164,
-0.22455696761608124,
-0.49474865198135376,
-0.195839062333107,
-0.14390471577644348,
-0.3215886056423187,
0.581699788570404,
0.6315580010414124,
0.09732671827077866,
0.8755084872245789,
0.7296929955482483,
-0.14117057621479034,
0.21081660687923431,
0.4459097981452942,
1.16495943069458,
-0.43474507331848145,
-0.988645613193512,
-0.7502948045730591,
0.33041274547576904,
0.04181750491261482,
-0.3752967119216919,
0.8182557225227356,
0.5144947171211243,
0.5993751883506775,
-0.07908247411251068,
0.7792770266532898,
0.3501017391681671,
0.1630828082561493,
-0.6315123438835144,
0.7503440976142883,
-0.5717138648033142,
-0.25584959983825684,
-0.35763484239578247,
-0.7458407878875732,
-0.2422887533903122,
0.4889482259750366,
-0.1836761087179184,
0.15530282258987427,
0.7696529030799866,
0.7475787997245789,
0.11083687841892242,
-0.2659074366092682,
0.25208479166030884,
0.2491285800933838,
0.4193147122859955,
0.4867081940174103,
0.6282951235771179,
-0.26556992530822754,
0.7721560597419739,
0.4357294738292694,
-0.2959296405315399,
-0.2011919915676117,
-0.8596647381782532,
-1.2624176740646362,
-0.36561840772628784,
-0.177619069814682,
0.057512734085321426,
0.0779573917388916,
0.5985783338546753,
0.7436909675598145,
-0.45661646127700806,
0.012616656720638275,
-0.3993775248527527,
-0.031205572187900543,
-0.0724116787314415,
-0.15617597103118896,
0.5009366273880005,
-0.918303906917572,
-0.6973981261253357,
0.6260213255882263,
0.6639695167541504,
0.37266817688941956,
-0.2567690312862396,
-0.0698811411857605,
-0.4538615643978119,
0.06262347102165222,
0.421215683221817,
0.035523541271686554,
-0.524993896484375,
-0.3957219421863556,
-0.15400703251361847,
-0.28928014636039734,
0.09389649331569672,
0.7066938281059265,
-0.9134727716445923,
0.41879111528396606,
0.5489481091499329,
0.9519249796867371,
0.5410358905792236,
0.08887258917093277,
0.5455470085144043,
-1.0609936714172363,
0.40006211400032043,
-0.04003307595849037,
0.5267537832260132,
0.14730504155158997,
-0.46134981513023376,
0.43957212567329407,
0.30942025780677795,
-0.4221262037754059,
-0.5937360525131226,
0.39136359095573425,
-0.606566846370697,
-0.27866604924201965,
0.8944197297096252,
-0.35770609974861145,
-0.49156540632247925,
-0.11998022347688675,
-0.4289839565753937,
0.3064790368080139,
-0.3017583191394806,
0.7714892029762268,
0.6272563934326172,
0.30116844177246094,
-0.0714833065867424,
-0.08687137812376022,
0.4174991548061371,
0.5044543147087097,
-0.9910735487937927,
0.19169829785823822,
0.4194301664829254,
-0.07878526300191879,
0.21953999996185303,
0.7525640726089478,
-0.023928727954626083,
0.22820869088172913,
-0.21806858479976654,
0.19679377973079681,
-0.5034238696098328,
-0.6777171492576599,
-0.03625762090086937,
0.4520649313926697,
-0.33611854910850525,
-0.3983370065689087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06910v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06910v1
|
Superposition Prompting: Improving and Accelerating Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-04-10T11:03:17 | 2024-04-10T11:03:17 |
Thomas Merth, Qichen Fu, Mohammad Rastegari, Mahyar Najibi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Despite the successes of large language models (LLMs), they exhibit
significant drawbacks, particularly when processing long contexts. Their
inference cost scales quadratically with respect to sequence length, making it
expensive for deployment in some real-world text processing applications, such
as retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). Additionally, LLMs also exhibit the
"distraction phenomenon," where irrelevant context in the prompt degrades
output quality. To address these drawbacks, we propose a novel RAG prompting
methodology, superposition prompting, which can be directly applied to
pre-trained transformer-based LLMs without the need for fine-tuning. At a high
level, superposition prompting allows the LLM to process input documents in
parallel prompt paths, discarding paths once they are deemed irrelevant. We
demonstrate the capability of our method to simultaneously enhance time
efficiency across a variety of question-answering benchmarks using multiple
pre-trained LLMs. Furthermore, our technique significantly improves accuracy
when the retrieved context is large relative the context the model was trained
on. For example, our approach facilitates an 93x reduction in compute time
while improving accuracy by 43\% on the NaturalQuestions-Open dataset with the
MPT-7B instruction-tuned model over naive RAG.
|
[
-0.40962523221969604,
-0.7506300210952759,
0.7049388289451599,
0.3365401029586792,
-0.27968630194664,
0.000551315548364073,
-0.0788600966334343,
-0.3141855001449585,
0.21833078563213348,
0.3698473870754242,
-0.7250178456306458,
0.09716545790433884,
-0.4685814678668976,
0.31664782762527466,
-0.33542051911354065,
0.7559016346931458,
0.04818013682961464,
0.09696091711521149,
-0.5856955051422119,
0.143882617354393,
-0.6517020463943481,
-0.20524758100509644,
-0.6025941967964172,
-0.2983938157558441,
0.5699000954627991,
0.41012704372406006,
0.39527982473373413,
0.5200475454330444,
0.08399317413568497,
0.29589715600013733,
-0.3487394452095032,
0.5166175365447998,
-0.39321908354759216,
0.48466163873672485,
-0.3788968622684479,
-0.5950555205345154,
0.019552357494831085,
-0.09905026853084564,
0.6799601316452026,
0.3106861114501953,
-0.06343145668506622,
0.22767682373523712,
0.14433667063713074,
0.6663900017738342,
-0.6959109902381897,
-0.07948511093854904,
-0.5778981447219849,
-0.14506982266902924,
-0.019424231722950935,
-0.6256296038627625,
-0.5690797567367554,
-0.3827386796474457,
0.24244223535060883,
-0.6417668461799622,
0.5056912302970886,
0.019864993169903755,
0.7685906291007996,
0.5055709481239319,
-0.0555887408554554,
-0.21728454530239105,
-0.6796214580535889,
0.7588219046592712,
-0.33852967619895935,
0.46898218989372253,
0.26570945978164673,
0.2305692732334137,
-0.2755860388278961,
-0.6223797798156738,
-0.8572114706039429,
-0.22668109834194183,
-0.17643310129642487,
0.2727373540401459,
0.11202972382307053,
-0.20137262344360352,
0.6188346147537231,
0.18273289501667023,
-0.3012407124042511,
-0.11084412038326263,
-0.16132694482803345,
-0.06901977956295013,
0.20448510348796844,
0.1731901615858078,
0.06177271902561188,
-0.36383485794067383,
-0.2119416892528534,
-0.190207839012146,
-0.7994851469993591,
-0.14300937950611115,
0.1276492327451706,
0.2409202754497528,
0.29951849579811096,
0.24507872760295868,
-0.041424885392189026,
0.7892807722091675,
0.32027217745780945,
0.009068120270967484,
0.16714026033878326,
-0.4457883834838867,
-0.05692131817340851,
-0.08741211891174316,
0.2996440529823303,
0.3123548626899719,
-0.04751789569854736,
-0.02945716120302677,
-0.0566151961684227,
0.06493648886680603,
0.17218925058841705,
-0.7818506956100464,
0.23607200384140015,
0.21211259067058563,
0.004512065090239048,
0.03699440509080887,
-0.1673881560564041,
-0.6916784644126892,
-0.5583305358886719,
-0.5770339965820312,
0.5341511368751526,
-0.4155443012714386,
0.1913183033466339,
0.007521285675466061,
-0.19104009866714478,
0.23053710162639618,
0.3375045955181122,
-0.8360707759857178,
-0.14068466424942017,
0.5417373180389404,
0.6074237823486328,
-0.0008427146240137517,
-0.3186953365802765,
-0.8637263178825378,
0.19271400570869446,
-0.27394744753837585,
1.0111004114151,
-0.6998327374458313,
-0.6365389823913574,
-0.2848135828971863,
-0.04640611633658409,
-0.055355846881866455,
-0.7330400347709656,
0.6255918145179749,
-0.6859416365623474,
0.5115285515785217,
-0.4284372329711914,
-0.5608169436454773,
0.08006317168474197,
0.23221158981323242,
-0.5158125162124634,
1.4252080917358398,
0.19487376511096954,
-0.6113901734352112,
0.30221542716026306,
-0.4277281165122986,
-0.541469931602478,
0.1559981405735016,
-0.25870487093925476,
-0.20451320707798004,
0.03012836165726185,
0.73321133852005,
0.43682363629341125,
-0.5435394048690796,
0.42110806703567505,
0.4783118963241577,
-0.5657557249069214,
0.02537411078810692,
-0.44583073258399963,
0.6421400308609009,
-0.001360387192107737,
-0.4275238513946533,
0.11833345144987106,
-0.7328077554702759,
-0.12460839748382568,
0.051457881927490234,
-0.5166305303573608,
-0.3070935904979706,
-0.1396111249923706,
-0.3048270642757416,
0.1481974720954895,
0.2785879075527191,
-0.49593305587768555,
0.2911793887615204,
-0.5457062125205994,
0.10417108982801437,
0.8664196133613586,
0.14290045201778412,
0.41304001212120056,
-0.4849773347377777,
0.7365683913230896,
-0.08393177390098572,
0.11550388485193253,
-0.5513913035392761,
-0.21665816009044647,
-0.7610726952552795,
-0.08981072902679443,
0.3722818195819855,
0.7025153636932373,
-1.2585099935531616,
0.33656591176986694,
-0.2764398455619812,
-0.31069135665893555,
-0.5126115083694458,
0.007745149079710245,
0.569250226020813,
0.9176225662231445,
0.652899444103241,
0.17796532809734344,
-0.6892699003219604,
-0.48197147250175476,
-0.3188381493091583,
0.2156926542520523,
-0.17988184094429016,
0.5657587647438049,
0.0564580075442791,
-0.11236988753080368,
0.9079466462135315,
-0.44064950942993164,
-0.009276566095650196,
-0.3388843834400177,
0.2280782163143158,
0.365645170211792,
0.38010281324386597,
0.17898288369178772,
-0.952557384967804,
-0.6852601766586304,
-0.4733799695968628,
-0.31726977229118347,
-0.5359000563621521,
-0.3255164921283722,
-0.22258146107196808,
0.3349711298942566,
0.869674801826477,
-0.7261918187141418,
0.21124818921089172,
0.345563143491745,
-0.07117356359958649,
1.0219268798828125,
-0.3644782304763794,
0.1760232150554657,
-1.07722806930542,
-0.030420145019888878,
-0.2531599998474121,
0.12585265934467316,
-0.597806990146637,
0.06428159773349762,
0.24761177599430084,
0.12840232253074646,
-0.6308748722076416,
0.6324010491371155,
-0.5523521304130554,
0.11543363332748413,
-0.24217922985553741,
0.09538735449314117,
0.2344113141298294,
0.15823540091514587,
-0.14770974218845367,
1.3540606498718262,
0.4538705050945282,
-0.8877915740013123,
-0.04441418498754501,
0.2949816882610321,
-0.2795237898826599,
0.549680233001709,
-0.6196040511131287,
0.26019296050071716,
-0.4586952328681946,
0.5702664256095886,
-0.8627434968948364,
-0.17164525389671326,
0.07575080543756485,
-0.24774745106697083,
0.3650374412536621,
0.09713003784418106,
-0.5268617868423462,
-0.33575260639190674,
-0.3243735730648041,
0.3461087644100189,
0.43061694502830505,
-0.7829809784889221,
0.8016409277915955,
-0.04196660593152046,
-0.11195015162229538,
-0.7177329063415527,
-0.47025543451309204,
-0.013090538792312145,
-0.04285219684243202,
-0.4147660434246063,
0.6822148561477661,
-0.10958724468946457,
0.32503819465637207,
-0.3160906732082367,
-0.2768476903438568,
0.5160727500915527,
-0.1400650590658188,
0.02671981416642666,
0.43991249799728394,
-0.00587816396728158,
0.19618482887744904,
0.1262892782688141,
-0.30360159277915955,
-0.13547751307487488,
-0.3424816131591797,
0.6130329370498657,
0.35713550448417664,
-0.131291925907135,
-0.3650197386741638,
0.2825372815132141,
0.3702438175678253,
-0.3020723760128021,
0.6914119720458984,
0.33539748191833496,
-0.10718780010938644,
-0.26250725984573364,
-0.725102961063385,
-0.30116215348243713,
-0.5594435334205627,
-0.07987446337938309,
-0.26659780740737915,
-1.1055028438568115,
0.2834121286869049,
-0.12833605706691742,
0.06333377212285995,
0.03090064227581024,
0.32971513271331787,
0.13230390846729279,
1.0942829847335815,
0.22275951504707336,
0.13634775578975677,
0.815022885799408,
-0.21253588795661926,
0.1859726756811142,
-1.030154824256897,
-0.1015084832906723,
-0.5442862510681152,
-0.18924643099308014,
-0.3841702342033386,
-0.8062832355499268,
0.48884743452072144,
0.08517422527074814,
-0.06687038391828537,
0.2476450502872467,
-0.573803722858429,
0.9225636124610901,
0.7895423769950867,
0.2062033712863922,
0.12943632900714874,
-0.04168735817074776,
-0.3679310083389282,
-0.07828562706708908,
-0.8878874778747559,
-0.3239201009273529,
0.889744222164154,
-0.26507142186164856,
0.48825153708457947,
-0.04316197708249092,
0.8532938361167908,
-0.09377267211675644,
0.3415818512439728,
-0.5715500712394714,
0.8356818556785583,
-0.24094749987125397,
-0.5244483351707458,
-0.4035526216030121,
-0.5107105374336243,
-1.122545838356018,
0.1576576828956604,
-0.3448563516139984,
-0.7563621997833252,
0.08293341845273972,
0.3417697548866272,
-0.7739424705505371,
-0.14297407865524292,
-0.7804328203201294,
0.39452946186065674,
0.06526895612478256,
-0.648375391960144,
-0.04259829968214035,
-0.6076607704162598,
0.12571674585342407,
0.05042622238397598,
0.0149673568084836,
0.10799325257539749,
0.03968137502670288,
0.5106908679008484,
-0.23898929357528687,
0.4881557822227478,
-0.2677985429763794,
-0.0110933231189847,
0.2841077744960785,
0.20753248035907745,
0.9188550114631653,
-0.20998792350292206,
-0.08723792433738708,
-0.44362354278564453,
-0.29786887764930725,
-0.23927578330039978,
-0.9485114216804504,
0.5909150838851929,
-0.2768213748931885,
-1.0347459316253662,
-0.03438548743724823,
-0.8044533133506775,
-0.5324789881706238,
0.1892656832933426,
0.4133360981941223,
0.577422559261322,
0.25397077202796936,
0.1558683067560196,
0.878625214099884,
-0.5291271209716797,
0.35829073190689087,
0.5283381342887878,
-0.1802642047405243,
-0.2401883900165558,
1.032178282737732,
0.3353269398212433,
0.277097225189209,
0.5343259572982788,
0.5087456107139587,
-0.7338142991065979,
-0.31856071949005127,
-0.5075240731239319,
0.28193631768226624,
-0.5410680770874023,
-0.2056095451116562,
-0.7646181583404541,
-0.058185841888189316,
-0.5590583682060242,
-0.19483260810375214,
-0.021694809198379517,
-0.3990985155105591,
-0.2873271703720093,
-0.1338496208190918,
0.24655655026435852,
0.4647742211818695,
0.08686572313308716,
0.496107280254364,
-1.0588700771331787,
0.4813176095485687,
0.5236921906471252,
0.16561894118785858,
0.20798064768314362,
-0.6194760203361511,
-0.13593195378780365,
-0.298860102891922,
-0.3179824650287628,
-0.6457018852233887,
0.14980874955654144,
0.0726873129606247,
0.6457929015159607,
0.05263718590140343,
0.01110200397670269,
0.8254778385162354,
-0.7346099615097046,
0.8747745752334595,
-0.07716820389032364,
-1.00093412399292,
0.6043729186058044,
-0.3078254163265228,
0.6552264094352722,
0.5284702777862549,
0.4501645565032959,
-0.3398381173610687,
-0.4625834822654724,
-0.7049742341041565,
-0.9930150508880615,
0.7854669690132141,
0.02750658057630062,
0.17998196184635162,
-0.19975358247756958,
0.31781673431396484,
-0.031075477600097656,
-0.05637029930949211,
-0.21695943176746368,
-0.24619926512241364,
0.13566575944423676,
-0.03820240497589111,
-0.17939846217632294,
-0.48859724402427673,
0.05007254332304001,
-0.33827194571495056,
0.8040603995323181,
-0.060203734785318375,
0.17695516347885132,
0.4888670742511749,
-0.19460691511631012,
0.06343792378902435,
0.3702434301376343,
0.7463919520378113,
0.7411812543869019,
0.10917147994041443,
0.26473963260650635,
0.4349368214607239,
-0.3649657070636749,
0.44286754727363586,
0.16964785754680634,
-0.40435561537742615,
0.038845695555210114,
0.04432523250579834,
0.46428239345550537,
0.24252834916114807,
-0.5106721520423889,
0.20724482834339142,
-0.037215426564216614,
-0.051572490483522415,
0.33446699380874634,
0.277166485786438,
0.29757818579673767,
0.35450801253318787,
0.5396994352340698,
-0.1978493630886078,
0.08977844566106796,
-0.04512086883187294,
0.2714945673942566,
0.13278891146183014,
-0.07261519879102707,
0.16758069396018982,
0.7001789808273315,
0.13852089643478394,
-0.49173641204833984,
0.30380016565322876,
-0.22212526202201843,
-0.6280640363693237,
0.523476779460907,
0.7296832203865051,
0.6332184076309204,
-0.45622360706329346,
0.2120860368013382,
0.40146946907043457,
0.11630505323410034,
-0.4429500997066498,
0.4268229007720947,
-0.2836947441101074,
-0.7141390442848206,
-0.8717362284660339,
-0.6194725036621094,
-0.4547383785247803,
0.11429192125797272,
-0.5082048177719116,
0.15596336126327515,
-0.4327445328235626,
-0.07077976316213608,
0.013883068226277828,
-0.2181389480829239,
-0.40162894129753113,
0.13180169463157654,
-0.015606984496116638,
1.1210988759994507,
-0.5405638217926025,
0.511285126209259,
0.5615910887718201,
-0.12205434590578079,
-1.050616979598999,
0.271731436252594,
-0.3093838691711426,
-0.4976309835910797,
0.5170621871948242,
0.4667830467224121,
-0.4088878631591797,
0.39116552472114563,
-0.6087930798530579,
-0.7051616311073303,
0.9295064806938171,
0.5089350342750549,
-0.5453588366508484,
0.16568776965141296,
-0.024357730522751808,
0.5481396317481995,
-0.059064313769340515,
0.307449609041214,
0.7933781147003174,
0.4653838276863098,
0.2278740406036377,
-0.585117518901825,
0.3669244647026062,
-0.07514775544404984,
0.22072747349739075,
0.28513985872268677,
-0.5780435800552368,
0.7021706700325012,
-0.11715225875377655,
-0.4560610055923462,
-0.0441802479326725,
0.5944498181343079,
0.775303304195404,
0.1345769762992859,
0.6238968968391418,
0.41839537024497986,
0.7869794964790344,
0.12642545998096466,
0.9713389277458191,
-0.37267836928367615,
-0.014362695626914501,
1.314451813697815,
-0.29336345195770264,
0.6251082420349121,
0.7056761980056763,
-0.17888395488262177,
0.5877142548561096,
0.2752947509288788,
0.39686357975006104,
0.2613412141799927,
0.10880976915359497,
-0.4816284477710724,
-0.2720341384410858,
-0.3456037938594818,
-0.45585310459136963,
0.044364187866449356,
0.4517604112625122,
-0.2545281648635864,
-0.315866082906723,
-0.000807848060503602,
-0.1340303122997284,
0.07917236536741257,
-0.18314087390899658,
0.5014730095863342,
-0.06522103399038315,
-1.2109427452087402,
0.7210493683815002,
-0.32664862275123596,
0.6724715232849121,
-0.5194156169891357,
-0.1677018702030182,
-0.4254129230976105,
-0.04856302961707115,
-0.0852367952466011,
-0.6091375350952148,
0.20500712096691132,
-0.018990639597177505,
-0.3875979483127594,
-0.6088533997535706,
0.6871913075447083,
-0.2834089398384094,
-0.3319944143295288,
0.15596282482147217,
0.5295670032501221,
0.06623438745737076,
-0.08727741241455078,
-0.6288052797317505,
-0.19880080223083496,
-0.08225184679031372,
-0.37734895944595337,
0.17303980886936188,
0.46776002645492554,
-0.14416220784187317,
0.5140675902366638,
0.9951930642127991,
-0.1073659136891365,
0.010913847014307976,
0.41517022252082825,
0.9544495940208435,
-0.6829457879066467,
-0.7143880724906921,
-0.8517559170722961,
0.43810221552848816,
0.00627906434237957,
-0.10787000507116318,
0.8495180010795593,
0.4056870639324188,
0.721589982509613,
0.002745077246800065,
0.6004031896591187,
-0.026124699041247368,
0.86142498254776,
-0.6461517214775085,
0.2945561707019806,
-0.4681166112422943,
0.5197518467903137,
-0.21837882697582245,
-0.9273859858512878,
-0.3686813712120056,
0.3695589601993561,
-0.5169801712036133,
-0.17207129299640656,
0.5961990356445312,
1.3339349031448364,
0.1058635413646698,
0.08441898971796036,
0.2150373011827469,
0.06015504524111748,
0.204322949051857,
0.35773247480392456,
1.2149567604064941,
-0.20408415794372559,
0.622870147228241,
-0.003559874137863517,
-0.29758068919181824,
-0.21514204144477844,
-0.9526988863945007,
-0.6833910346031189,
-0.2781899869441986,
0.07530029118061066,
-0.42073723673820496,
0.048162635415792465,
0.8615999817848206,
0.49412333965301514,
-0.7092195749282837,
0.06595694273710251,
-0.38262811303138733,
0.26433292031288147,
-0.1861467808485031,
-0.2969622015953064,
0.24832847714424133,
-0.48770320415496826,
-0.7019672989845276,
0.6682792901992798,
0.1840895414352417,
0.2483261674642563,
-0.21652129292488098,
0.10261710733175278,
-0.5034365653991699,
0.27001363039016724,
0.6119726896286011,
0.15471205115318298,
-0.40575936436653137,
-0.3057030737400055,
0.28845977783203125,
-0.030911333858966827,
0.10334350168704987,
0.880771279335022,
-0.9909678101539612,
0.4572862684726715,
0.829501748085022,
0.8679074645042419,
0.47180354595184326,
0.3191554546356201,
0.5515857338905334,
-0.9840990900993347,
0.0890621691942215,
0.13361015915870667,
0.017453916370868683,
0.33414825797080994,
-0.6178158521652222,
0.35646557807922363,
0.2506219744682312,
-0.6300434470176697,
-0.738663911819458,
0.23325663805007935,
-0.37933623790740967,
-0.35661011934280396,
1.0683926343917847,
0.008402042090892792,
-0.3679341971874237,
-0.18101084232330322,
-0.6090343594551086,
0.2951028048992157,
-0.30502235889434814,
0.8237066268920898,
0.6156045794487,
-0.4232408106327057,
-0.06952126324176788,
-0.38436567783355713,
0.44729769229888916,
1.0208081007003784,
-0.5974854230880737,
0.1526847630739212,
0.4308678209781647,
-0.135308638215065,
0.36753717064857483,
0.6508464813232422,
0.14862161874771118,
0.4360988736152649,
-0.013308179564774036,
-0.19857314229011536,
-0.12536275386810303,
-0.5990931391716003,
-0.41402217745780945,
0.020316889509558678,
-0.38152578473091125,
-0.0050231413915753365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08695v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08695v2
|
Enhancing Question Answering for Enterprise Knowledge Bases using Large Language Models
| 2024-04-10T10:38:17 | 2024-04-20T05:29:29 |
Feihu Jiang, Chuan Qin, Kaichun Yao, Chuyu Fang, Fuzhen Zhuang, Hengshu Zhu, Hui Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Efficient knowledge management plays a pivotal role in augmenting both the
operational efficiency and the innovative capacity of businesses and
organizations. By indexing knowledge through vectorization, a variety of
knowledge retrieval methods have emerged, significantly enhancing the efficacy
of knowledge management systems. Recently, the rapid advancements in generative
natural language processing technologies paved the way for generating precise
and coherent answers after retrieving relevant documents tailored to user
queries. However, for enterprise knowledge bases, assembling extensive training
data from scratch for knowledge retrieval and generation is a formidable
challenge due to the privacy and security policies of private data, frequently
entailing substantial costs. To address the challenge above, in this paper, we
propose EKRG, a novel Retrieval-Generation framework based on large language
models (LLMs), expertly designed to enable question-answering for Enterprise
Knowledge bases with limited annotation costs. Specifically, for the retrieval
process, we first introduce an instruction-tuning method using an LLM to
generate sufficient document-question pairs for training a knowledge retriever.
This method, through carefully designed instructions, efficiently generates
diverse questions for enterprise knowledge bases, encompassing both
fact-oriented and solution-oriented knowledge. Additionally, we develop a
relevance-aware teacher-student learning strategy to further enhance the
efficiency of the training process. For the generation process, we propose a
novel chain of thought (CoT) based fine-tuning method to empower the LLM-based
generator to adeptly respond to user questions using retrieved documents.
Finally, extensive experiments on real-world datasets have demonstrated the
effectiveness of our proposed framework.
|
[
-0.6592457294464111,
-1.0318808555603027,
0.7476017475128174,
-0.37682297825813293,
-0.17589327692985535,
0.06742708384990692,
-0.24108539521694183,
-0.4518834054470062,
0.061297766864299774,
0.7895953059196472,
-0.4086676836013794,
-0.5935400128364563,
-0.16110149025917053,
0.10914713144302368,
-0.33178097009658813,
0.7290723919868469,
0.18399593234062195,
-0.12457060813903809,
-0.3837851285934448,
-0.3063984811306,
-0.3210286498069763,
-0.6377385854721069,
-0.49543488025665283,
-0.11202671378850937,
0.3561166226863861,
0.7507778406143188,
0.3151262104511261,
0.5994057655334473,
0.482057124376297,
0.27556243538856506,
-0.19300419092178345,
0.3642556667327881,
-0.3541428744792938,
0.5260518193244934,
-0.3055526316165924,
-0.5699816346168518,
-0.34235572814941406,
-0.6882902383804321,
0.638085663318634,
0.5538842678070068,
-0.4331979751586914,
0.4398045241832733,
-0.07936755567789078,
0.7755520939826965,
-0.4996030926704407,
0.08111942559480667,
-1.054213285446167,
-0.2973463833332062,
-0.010567122139036655,
-0.29480117559432983,
-0.40598204731941223,
-0.37530019879341125,
0.08276480436325073,
-0.4558345675468445,
0.28914737701416016,
0.5021569728851318,
0.7575058341026306,
-0.02915545180439949,
-0.252364844083786,
-0.25128012895584106,
-0.6495054960250854,
0.6359885334968567,
-0.6638249158859253,
0.4947267770767212,
0.22605884075164795,
0.36754482984542847,
-0.05392010509967804,
-0.7582957148551941,
-0.7000572681427002,
0.0867767184972763,
0.020425062626600266,
-0.1840910017490387,
-0.09597793966531754,
0.11204734444618225,
0.41756001114845276,
0.2231215089559555,
-0.616784393787384,
-0.034249596297740936,
-0.44451767206192017,
0.14148899912834167,
0.4776894152164459,
0.3673590123653412,
0.027910666540265083,
-0.19368976354599,
-0.17422419786453247,
-0.15812933444976807,
-0.6651626825332642,
-0.11184235662221909,
0.3959035277366638,
0.23882946372032166,
0.5819368362426758,
0.7172427177429199,
-0.5249333381652832,
0.759688138961792,
0.12925805151462555,
0.15629085898399353,
0.031162776052951813,
0.08759059756994247,
-0.3425990641117096,
0.07191339135169983,
0.29545509815216064,
0.3151250183582306,
-0.03908189758658409,
-0.4558332562446594,
-0.11717186123132706,
-0.2473537027835846,
0.45308446884155273,
-0.8833920359611511,
-0.12942831218242645,
0.35329669713974,
-0.21588341891765594,
-0.29926955699920654,
-0.027788477018475533,
-0.99217689037323,
-0.4457506537437439,
-0.23130793869495392,
0.545172393321991,
-0.47248393297195435,
-0.1580173671245575,
0.019900266081094742,
-0.04231462627649307,
0.671484112739563,
0.24771331250667572,
-0.7624960541725159,
0.17257961630821228,
0.7041009068489075,
0.2711167335510254,
0.15495923161506653,
0.07681851834058762,
-0.47428303956985474,
0.48316115140914917,
-0.28898388147354126,
0.6464533805847168,
-0.5176578164100647,
-0.2539415657520294,
-0.056662097573280334,
-0.10453839600086212,
0.09829820692539215,
-0.7819257974624634,
0.40414753556251526,
-1.109787940979004,
0.0873401015996933,
-0.5108472108840942,
-0.8261195421218872,
-0.284431517124176,
0.5716320872306824,
-0.4497213363647461,
1.0321223735809326,
-0.07907048612833023,
-0.6827815175056458,
0.2806173861026764,
-0.35517728328704834,
-0.2315591424703598,
0.45336219668388367,
-0.22573845088481903,
-0.47343993186950684,
-0.0731130838394165,
0.26023584604263306,
0.6046603918075562,
-0.46882760524749756,
0.15584704279899597,
-0.223735049366951,
0.10801299661397934,
-0.024784710258245468,
0.10128732770681381,
0.33860498666763306,
0.2626979947090149,
-0.309981107711792,
-0.33097442984580994,
-0.7900117635726929,
0.5870311260223389,
0.1107071191072464,
-0.44435691833496094,
-0.502359926700592,
0.028089700266718864,
-0.39657461643218994,
-0.014426845125854015,
0.3444843292236328,
-0.5075098276138306,
-0.01418126281350851,
-0.3275577425956726,
-0.022209005430340767,
0.6429006457328796,
0.5082113742828369,
0.4102649688720703,
-0.23928065598011017,
0.5828589797019958,
-0.04363686218857765,
-0.13858765363693237,
-0.19331060349941254,
-0.24806612730026245,
-0.8360310792922974,
0.08233299851417542,
0.08299212902784348,
0.4322989583015442,
-0.7439727783203125,
0.4663819968700409,
-0.36052241921424866,
-0.473699688911438,
-0.4717232584953308,
0.36597615480422974,
0.24081023037433624,
0.85261470079422,
0.46547630429267883,
-0.08182071894407272,
-0.5834255218505859,
-0.9553121328353882,
-0.28249412775039673,
-0.13530869781970978,
-0.05531924217939377,
0.7183066010475159,
0.33339112997055054,
0.10553235560655594,
0.9335222840309143,
-0.6952956914901733,
-0.12007108330726624,
-0.544618546962738,
0.12300651520490646,
0.10378292948007584,
0.1370144635438919,
0.2051907181739807,
-0.9017835855484009,
-0.5661027431488037,
0.23148910701274872,
-0.6094560623168945,
0.009854692034423351,
0.21958640217781067,
-0.43596360087394714,
0.3355158269405365,
0.48238328099250793,
-0.6064962148666382,
0.011322061531245708,
0.009918618015944958,
-0.12231758236885071,
0.4870964586734772,
-0.1696227341890335,
0.17000943422317505,
-1.1673206090927124,
0.44110238552093506,
-0.3476032018661499,
-0.32931655645370483,
-0.5756500959396362,
0.333912193775177,
0.20287936925888062,
-0.2974684536457062,
-0.27583611011505127,
0.45220425724983215,
-0.5326829552650452,
0.04513809457421303,
-0.013920529745519161,
0.3555375039577484,
0.20137231051921844,
0.5173616409301758,
0.019356373697519302,
0.6067975163459778,
0.31809014081954956,
-0.806590735912323,
0.4148029088973999,
0.6749894618988037,
-0.48622003197669983,
0.782148540019989,
-0.5539860725402832,
0.326740562915802,
-0.5124978423118591,
-0.07286155968904495,
-0.4843619763851166,
-0.27069154381752014,
-0.23611770570278168,
-0.3190973699092865,
0.4145453870296478,
-0.26776742935180664,
-0.49939969182014465,
-0.424537718296051,
-0.07737108319997787,
-0.16551080346107483,
0.6547862887382507,
-0.5351582169532776,
0.8011747002601624,
0.38437148928642273,
-0.4430566132068634,
-0.5343095660209656,
-0.448552668094635,
-0.011575860902667046,
-0.36414116621017456,
-0.8327430486679077,
0.016366509720683098,
0.10933464765548706,
-0.2626512944698334,
0.17003697156906128,
-0.4612719714641571,
-0.11520959436893463,
0.04814000800251961,
-0.35984930396080017,
0.30495887994766235,
-0.3060871958732605,
0.25721442699432373,
0.10422194004058838,
0.33315059542655945,
0.16772323846817017,
-0.43194547295570374,
0.4264073073863983,
-0.023173941299319267,
-0.3177165985107422,
0.33374014496803284,
0.46057531237602234,
0.3708976209163666,
-0.6336658596992493,
1.1394141912460327,
0.4810347855091095,
-0.36014941334724426,
-0.5688471794128418,
-0.9656867980957031,
-0.3146294355392456,
-0.49668559432029724,
0.7064021229743958,
-0.21431119740009308,
-0.9140117764472961,
0.4576479196548462,
-0.18299388885498047,
0.15102066099643707,
0.14927376806735992,
0.6151976585388184,
-0.17744995653629303,
0.9112964272499084,
0.6461725831031799,
-0.017668848857283592,
0.3271261751651764,
-0.37955242395401,
0.4766641855239868,
-0.9086683988571167,
-0.4053282141685486,
-0.6986258625984192,
-0.1575891226530075,
-0.2647768557071686,
-0.2863820791244507,
0.678934633731842,
0.2681037187576294,
-0.2819194197654724,
0.14833322167396545,
-0.32189857959747314,
0.6210229396820068,
0.46457138657569885,
0.2588118612766266,
0.2586430013179779,
0.03270220011472702,
-0.15103945136070251,
0.26796668767929077,
-0.8424928188323975,
-0.5897863507270813,
1.1655681133270264,
0.0828031525015831,
0.785531222820282,
0.2040550708770752,
0.7878157496452332,
0.02953098714351654,
0.04845235496759415,
-0.3535127639770508,
0.7290719747543335,
0.027907388284802437,
-0.8270946145057678,
-0.5310098528862,
-0.6651264429092407,
-0.7588308453559875,
0.27287283539772034,
-0.195145383477211,
-0.9363725781440735,
0.14011816680431366,
0.3389964699745178,
-0.35145074129104614,
0.5399454832077026,
-0.7425916194915771,
0.8334412574768066,
-0.29054388403892517,
-0.5173527002334595,
-0.20666645467281342,
-0.7089398503303528,
0.2458055019378662,
-0.10740827023983002,
-0.02942264825105667,
0.10327518731355667,
0.19784215092658997,
0.6822022795677185,
-0.33071959018707275,
0.3103303611278534,
-0.4217222332954407,
0.11774978041648865,
0.5272663831710815,
0.12417405843734741,
0.8598605394363403,
-0.05187475308775902,
-0.23469406366348267,
-0.3512912094593048,
-0.09307117760181427,
-0.22086097300052643,
-0.6713467836380005,
0.5656064748764038,
-0.3445224463939667,
-0.8055488467216492,
0.08537934720516205,
-0.43251365423202515,
-0.640546977519989,
0.33777764439582825,
-0.005476897116750479,
0.411965936422348,
-0.1538258194923401,
0.701789379119873,
1.2705854177474976,
-0.4761046767234802,
0.03178594633936882,
0.6870419383049011,
-0.04589788243174553,
-0.23398229479789734,
0.7829636335372925,
0.014436387456953526,
0.35643407702445984,
0.6026143431663513,
-0.09665115922689438,
-0.5685582160949707,
-0.2854122817516327,
-0.34093183279037476,
0.15045642852783203,
-0.753563404083252,
-0.5610598921775818,
-0.9164023995399475,
-0.10362860560417175,
-0.4287167489528656,
-0.01888630911707878,
0.00015227308904286474,
-0.45701488852500916,
-0.10168323665857315,
-0.3417736291885376,
0.5107735991477966,
0.35466790199279785,
0.35033297538757324,
-0.034647248685359955,
-0.9018208384513855,
0.31994619965553284,
0.4987107217311859,
0.44180330634117126,
0.3130990266799927,
-0.3442826271057129,
-0.5495536923408508,
-0.025523029267787933,
-0.5281381011009216,
-0.849197268486023,
0.3217986226081848,
0.2362542450428009,
0.6283324360847473,
-0.016358917579054832,
0.28367727994918823,
0.534623384475708,
-0.5593209862709045,
0.47145876288414,
-0.2777944505214691,
-0.5134069919586182,
0.4660802185535431,
-0.3774449825286865,
-0.07076968252658844,
0.6682536602020264,
0.3620195984840393,
-0.4738261103630066,
-0.42435720562934875,
-0.6468588709831238,
-1.4415602684020996,
0.8019059896469116,
-0.08964438736438751,
0.07109741121530533,
0.05677146837115288,
0.4368104636669159,
-0.04382675886154175,
0.5345098376274109,
-0.28830987215042114,
-0.4022592306137085,
0.21554900705814362,
-0.3776090145111084,
0.18011142313480377,
-0.24307268857955933,
-0.0026819955091923475,
-0.049183189868927,
1.056689739227295,
0.00169836834538728,
0.2479339838027954,
0.14475248754024506,
-0.2970459461212158,
-0.3092462420463562,
0.6836155652999878,
-0.04996216297149658,
0.6699349284172058,
-0.18471290171146393,
-0.08675248175859451,
0.4668044447898865,
-0.2532316744327545,
-0.022255508229136467,
0.2128334939479828,
-0.3169749677181244,
-0.06807196140289307,
-0.3291211724281311,
0.7209551334381104,
-0.16336511075496674,
-0.7337630987167358,
0.2771884500980377,
0.15357282757759094,
-0.14535416662693024,
-0.34004509449005127,
0.26337072253227234,
0.29908764362335205,
0.447777658700943,
0.5985532999038696,
-0.5037635564804077,
0.09483928978443146,
-0.23428966104984283,
0.16375325620174408,
0.5622054934501648,
0.20182174444198608,
0.15630827844142914,
0.754668116569519,
0.11424651741981506,
-0.18375952541828156,
0.6822502613067627,
-0.05233188346028328,
-0.642381489276886,
0.540740430355072,
0.3490793704986572,
0.711978018283844,
-0.1473967283964157,
0.06319702416658401,
0.26723045110702515,
0.2787221074104309,
0.04106198251247406,
0.5469197034835815,
-0.26685798168182373,
-0.5863000750541687,
-0.2513979971408844,
-0.8758169412612915,
-0.6375095844268799,
0.32955875992774963,
-0.804771363735199,
0.3312341868877411,
-0.16967365145683289,
0.05958442762494087,
-0.24489177763462067,
0.1053166314959526,
-0.8145649433135986,
0.19424580037593842,
-0.023466186597943306,
1.0988576412200928,
-0.4654170572757721,
0.570408284664154,
0.8483175039291382,
-0.2995096743106842,
-1.0716755390167236,
-0.2532159388065338,
-0.6173256635665894,
-0.4531610906124115,
0.37006163597106934,
-0.13660238683223724,
0.2337193489074707,
0.3686087131500244,
-0.3742321729660034,
-0.6909587383270264,
1.2965842485427856,
0.2577285170555115,
-0.6387421488761902,
-0.1923007369041443,
0.3263968825340271,
0.5840792059898376,
0.01609937660396099,
-0.10390596091747284,
0.5369942784309387,
0.43976491689682007,
-0.029169384390115738,
-0.3744405508041382,
-0.08731036633253098,
-0.10440637916326523,
-0.06591524183750153,
0.5478508472442627,
-0.5298214554786682,
0.38965100049972534,
-0.10809794813394547,
0.02943800948560238,
0.036297719925642014,
0.6216169595718384,
0.3339763879776001,
0.1732979714870453,
0.236726775765419,
0.7298501133918762,
0.8334259390830994,
0.12258655577898026,
0.8741642236709595,
-0.5649917721748352,
0.29535427689552307,
1.0595614910125732,
-0.3647647500038147,
0.8230294585227966,
0.47587859630584717,
0.04698240011930466,
0.3953191936016083,
0.1435442417860031,
-0.04153558239340782,
0.44328367710113525,
0.022799288854002953,
-0.41436100006103516,
-0.3255598247051239,
0.17549969255924225,
-0.23796489834785461,
0.09906288981437683,
0.3082341253757477,
-0.4671248495578766,
-0.21175341308116913,
-0.16449639201164246,
-0.12168224155902863,
0.018294045701622963,
-0.4615333378314972,
1.001355528831482,
0.11165854334831238,
-0.5542477965354919,
0.30539795756340027,
0.18746709823608398,
0.18691280484199524,
-0.7516772747039795,
0.022482415661215782,
-0.190949946641922,
0.1496286243200302,
-0.08429655432701111,
-0.6406977772712708,
0.14523138105869293,
0.2929251790046692,
-0.13007405400276184,
-0.22739002108573914,
0.7983342409133911,
-0.6623291969299316,
-0.31715893745422363,
-0.080005943775177,
0.6704443693161011,
-0.07491997629404068,
-0.03130090609192848,
-0.3435688614845276,
-0.402433842420578,
-0.15839864313602448,
-0.5383977890014648,
0.24168765544891357,
0.7236060500144958,
0.004181567579507828,
0.7635752558708191,
0.36799558997154236,
0.16402897238731384,
0.32764819264411926,
-0.19292153418064117,
0.8486417531967163,
-0.32955291867256165,
-0.6042288541793823,
-0.5109761953353882,
0.4807453155517578,
-0.1167193204164505,
0.17596395313739777,
0.724470317363739,
0.7117014527320862,
0.7893763780593872,
-0.0007027180399745703,
0.8467782735824585,
-0.3648739755153656,
0.8736246824264526,
-0.3744748830795288,
0.7433015704154968,
-0.4979136884212494,
0.368855744600296,
-0.2837296426296234,
-0.9822317957878113,
0.05330841988325119,
0.3648131191730499,
-0.435865193605423,
0.16330817341804504,
0.49042657017707825,
0.9333516955375671,
-0.03601430729031563,
-0.0578145794570446,
0.37539392709732056,
0.42092224955558777,
0.2232910394668579,
0.2111935168504715,
0.5180355906486511,
-0.14944328367710114,
0.850389838218689,
-0.3175133764743805,
0.17402689158916473,
-0.13853701949119568,
-0.6611921787261963,
-0.6582463383674622,
-0.4803277254104614,
0.010722296312451363,
-0.284053772687912,
0.2882031798362732,
0.9157227873802185,
0.36530932784080505,
-0.7237259149551392,
0.046476054936647415,
-0.08438651263713837,
-0.05855156481266022,
0.2192068099975586,
-0.2766670882701874,
0.4303187429904938,
-0.4694705307483673,
-0.3660077452659607,
0.08433333039283752,
0.026080625131726265,
-0.25172507762908936,
-0.09022090584039688,
0.09831379354000092,
-0.059492077678442,
0.046488646417856216,
0.4126339852809906,
0.26930418610572815,
-0.1689901351928711,
-0.2915116846561432,
0.36663705110549927,
0.08842848241329193,
-0.08584941923618317,
0.5857397317886353,
-0.6961702108383179,
0.29009807109832764,
0.4368826150894165,
1.1451468467712402,
0.680490255355835,
0.3017260730266571,
0.4321703314781189,
-0.999417781829834,
-0.33121630549430847,
0.49662524461746216,
0.29640379548072815,
0.384074866771698,
-0.5965582728385925,
0.20681604743003845,
-0.1311035454273224,
-0.718804657459259,
-0.8568020462989807,
0.19062641263008118,
-0.5890040397644043,
-0.03251774609088898,
1.071094274520874,
-0.0017486197175458074,
-0.3518669307231903,
-0.15619026124477386,
-0.1695808321237564,
0.136429563164711,
-0.33781394362449646,
0.9387227892875671,
0.5477160811424255,
-0.08810240030288696,
-0.11848855018615723,
-0.5195102095603943,
0.29120346903800964,
0.3914538621902466,
-0.8898217678070068,
0.2865855395793915,
0.625080943107605,
0.406053751707077,
-0.19544164836406708,
0.3982301950454712,
-0.14082074165344238,
0.26941004395484924,
-0.31538698077201843,
0.25093790888786316,
-0.1892649084329605,
-0.3053745925426483,
-0.10105571895837784,
0.25364813208580017,
0.33854052424430847,
-0.03781576827168465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06854v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06854v1
|
Control-DAG: Constrained Decoding for Non-Autoregressive Directed Acyclic T5 using Weighted Finite State Automata
| 2024-04-10T09:28:14 | 2024-04-10T09:28:14 |
Jinghong Chen, Weizhe Lin, Jingbiao Mei, Bill Byrne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2
|
The Directed Acyclic Transformer is a fast non-autoregressive (NAR) model
that performs well in Neural Machine Translation. Two issues prevent its
application to general Natural Language Generation (NLG) tasks: frequent
Out-Of-Vocabulary (OOV) errors and the inability to faithfully generate entity
names. We introduce Control-DAG, a constrained decoding algorithm for our
Directed Acyclic T5 (DA-T5) model which offers lexical, vocabulary and length
control. We show that Control-DAG significantly enhances DA-T5 on the Schema
Guided Dialogue and the DART datasets, establishing strong NAR results for
Task-Oriented Dialogue and Data-to-Text NLG.
|
[
-0.19634078443050385,
-0.7591796517372131,
0.19368045032024384,
0.13764727115631104,
-0.20245593786239624,
0.22693394124507904,
-0.09326397627592087,
-0.21125362813472748,
-0.0010590825695544481,
0.5087365508079529,
-0.7989959716796875,
-0.6412492990493774,
-0.812781810760498,
0.5496485233306885,
-0.7359040379524231,
0.8513696193695068,
-0.22662635147571564,
-0.1792062520980835,
0.20627255737781525,
0.10160679370164871,
-0.5339480638504028,
-0.20457950234413147,
-0.6188418865203857,
-0.426363080739975,
0.17557604610919952,
0.2887578010559082,
0.801703929901123,
1.0400317907333374,
0.5499045252799988,
0.23230589926242828,
0.1595221906900406,
0.2795248031616211,
-0.24399340152740479,
0.25971367955207825,
-0.18650463223457336,
-0.4699365794658661,
-0.5653666853904724,
-0.21033529937267303,
0.5322198867797852,
0.5549915432929993,
-0.5432270169258118,
-0.0065416148863732815,
-0.28413379192352295,
0.4925944209098816,
-0.6274981498718262,
0.3880675733089447,
-0.5749450922012329,
-0.034061819314956665,
0.12877771258354187,
-0.04120616987347603,
-0.5308913588523865,
-0.3387526273727417,
0.0976381003856659,
-0.7264785170555115,
0.2803744971752167,
0.2290557622909546,
0.8118929862976074,
1.0801008939743042,
-0.6626021862030029,
-0.6811394691467285,
-0.8656404614448547,
0.8492339849472046,
-0.6557243466377258,
0.39805930852890015,
0.21439631283283234,
0.09099631011486053,
-0.44286105036735535,
-0.7583579421043396,
-0.7704033851623535,
-0.19742119312286377,
-0.1661241203546524,
0.11555980890989304,
-0.5166037678718567,
0.6610460877418518,
0.23584672808647156,
0.3913518190383911,
-0.4987528324127197,
-0.057338912039995193,
-0.0886634811758995,
-0.12709364295005798,
0.7234033346176147,
0.42122402787208557,
0.2916291654109955,
-0.2899841368198395,
-0.4141775071620941,
-0.227810800075531,
-0.49872738122940063,
-0.2800622582435608,
0.26596009731292725,
-0.0039956518448889256,
-0.009144177660346031,
0.550218403339386,
-0.16101503372192383,
1.0202383995056152,
0.737668514251709,
-0.23964792490005493,
-0.1332305371761322,
-0.33227357268333435,
-0.2750796973705292,
0.16195125877857208,
0.8753286600112915,
0.42266911268234253,
0.13585351407527924,
-0.34159088134765625,
-0.27721163630485535,
0.4253961443901062,
0.3882046937942505,
-0.48198458552360535,
-0.4015427529811859,
0.08945338428020477,
-0.3272516131401062,
-0.1463555544614792,
-0.15133991837501526,
-0.45741575956344604,
0.02257000282406807,
-0.2059912532567978,
0.2720264494419098,
-0.2644488513469696,
-0.12690335512161255,
0.20707395672798157,
-0.06950157880783081,
0.30292677879333496,
0.1256764531135559,
-0.9790833592414856,
0.706743597984314,
0.027734030038118362,
0.6243203282356262,
-0.6151755452156067,
0.07759764045476913,
-0.44837552309036255,
0.2891293168067932,
-0.49561044573783875,
0.25790899991989136,
-0.3772863745689392,
-0.4871160686016083,
-0.22668245434761047,
-0.11531305313110352,
-0.3331695795059204,
-0.33478105068206787,
0.449866384267807,
-0.5799001455307007,
0.27910736203193665,
0.07915540039539337,
-0.4522205889225006,
-0.33871784806251526,
0.009102428331971169,
-0.6788168549537659,
0.7752789258956909,
0.16422078013420105,
-0.639217734336853,
0.3897998332977295,
-0.7549598813056946,
-0.674761176109314,
-0.004515624605119228,
-0.06959517300128937,
-0.2712918221950531,
0.1180441677570343,
0.3020467162132263,
0.19696515798568726,
-0.3325194716453552,
0.5940994620323181,
0.12301862984895706,
-0.09738945960998535,
-0.055285245180130005,
-0.3774266541004181,
0.5499109625816345,
0.4007313847541809,
-0.5125716924667358,
0.1857534646987915,
-0.8878224492073059,
-0.03213800862431526,
-0.013331158086657524,
-0.26203835010528564,
-0.13283492624759674,
0.1366824209690094,
-0.0847410261631012,
0.3440530598163605,
0.2221091091632843,
-0.5601559281349182,
0.5961253643035889,
-0.4703717827796936,
0.630088210105896,
0.29918161034584045,
0.18797513842582703,
0.6709631085395813,
-0.19427025318145752,
0.7512161135673523,
0.08109866082668304,
-0.07817230373620987,
0.04706988483667374,
-0.14804330468177795,
-1.028358817100525,
0.004443865269422531,
0.2782523036003113,
0.732333242893219,
-1.4013855457305908,
0.5838888883590698,
-0.20177021622657776,
-0.1833658665418625,
-0.6169438362121582,
-0.15092317759990692,
0.3381606936454773,
0.5008601546287537,
0.6057096719741821,
-0.24621209502220154,
-0.4156595766544342,
-0.8549095392227173,
0.0643959492444992,
-0.005865400191396475,
-0.08824475109577179,
0.22342383861541748,
0.3171999752521515,
-0.028834490105509758,
0.7812832593917847,
-0.40655186772346497,
-0.43150636553764343,
-0.32440680265426636,
0.31357911229133606,
0.12482017278671265,
0.4793705642223358,
0.13895878195762634,
-0.5393796563148499,
-0.44014471769332886,
-0.33709970116615295,
-0.4491826891899109,
-0.39943090081214905,
-0.2562987208366394,
0.2051808089017868,
0.5605525374412537,
0.4515789747238159,
-0.8566663861274719,
0.6046692728996277,
0.7052294611930847,
-0.43368977308273315,
0.05503102019429207,
-0.42714840173721313,
0.015737034380435944,
-0.981724202632904,
0.1756112426519394,
-0.2409859299659729,
-0.29401546716690063,
-0.6277418732643127,
-0.164638951420784,
0.10421614348888397,
0.12090262025594711,
-0.11230985075235367,
0.32962852716445923,
-0.5640897154808044,
0.24821700155735016,
-0.5351576209068298,
-0.0282006673514843,
-0.1618938148021698,
0.5660346746444702,
0.2932192087173462,
0.677157461643219,
0.4976058304309845,
-0.9755353331565857,
0.41483941674232483,
0.59129798412323,
0.03425351902842522,
0.4211805462837219,
-0.7263034582138062,
0.17890982329845428,
-0.089732825756073,
0.438135027885437,
-0.6678877472877502,
-0.1252223253250122,
0.32825976610183716,
-0.4150986075401306,
0.34311699867248535,
0.13911102712154388,
-0.5364119410514832,
-0.3630281984806061,
0.3992096483707428,
0.4403258264064789,
0.5616891980171204,
-0.4866043031215668,
0.6367139220237732,
0.1314554363489151,
0.19531622529029846,
-0.6204723715782166,
-0.7274408936500549,
0.2063942551612854,
-0.23057518899440765,
-0.18311092257499695,
0.6505497097969055,
-0.10888070613145828,
-0.20122499763965607,
0.013972085900604725,
-0.10968304425477982,
0.027979491278529167,
-0.008649630472064018,
0.22877539694309235,
0.002814108971506357,
0.2474687546491623,
0.10286708176136017,
0.24100245535373688,
-0.14805202186107635,
0.17514415085315704,
-0.5099436044692993,
0.573863685131073,
0.10798729211091995,
-0.08403339236974716,
-0.5289168953895569,
0.331714928150177,
0.5226160883903503,
-0.3121781051158905,
0.38435229659080505,
0.3206106126308441,
-0.12338896095752716,
-0.5961605310440063,
-0.22100044786930084,
-0.22585827112197876,
-0.4921596050262451,
0.03837425634264946,
-0.31363269686698914,
-0.7789474129676819,
0.40439799427986145,
0.14669615030288696,
-0.02593274787068367,
0.5640420317649841,
0.5562531352043152,
0.2879147529602051,
1.1336369514465332,
0.6799408793449402,
-0.09153681248426437,
0.29341015219688416,
-0.23439143598079681,
0.2565688192844391,
-0.2976127564907074,
-0.17767730355262756,
-0.21477746963500977,
-0.48446783423423767,
-0.8604965806007385,
-0.12139765173196793,
0.3970452547073364,
-0.09179546684026718,
-0.05723930522799492,
0.5265679359436035,
-0.7571506500244141,
0.11509223282337189,
0.4701351821422577,
-0.0962226465344429,
0.4675765633583069,
-0.40077948570251465,
-0.22265343368053436,
0.1053335964679718,
-1.028808832168579,
-0.12279081344604492,
0.969968855381012,
0.1952957659959793,
1.0600320100784302,
0.009856168180704117,
0.6958817839622498,
0.31909483671188354,
-0.11066816002130508,
-0.9914283156394958,
0.37380778789520264,
-0.1875297874212265,
-0.5698216557502747,
-0.13918441534042358,
-0.4494711756706238,
-0.9964196681976318,
-0.1890430897474289,
-0.050689298659563065,
-0.45670458674430847,
0.29651543498039246,
0.2873985171318054,
-0.3353423774242401,
0.22175702452659607,
-0.44795647263526917,
0.43641605973243713,
-0.050141267478466034,
-0.09041539579629898,
-0.10617037117481232,
-0.7152924537658691,
0.23609559237957,
0.2616298794746399,
-0.09000389277935028,
0.17969051003456116,
-0.2309507429599762,
0.4226374924182892,
-0.36153507232666016,
0.6668421030044556,
-0.3426792025566101,
-0.1911182999610901,
0.5210751891136169,
0.35592377185821533,
0.5612376928329468,
-0.14610865712165833,
0.2548559308052063,
0.017424326390028,
0.039584461599588394,
-0.24023857712745667,
-0.5995472073554993,
0.6264516115188599,
-0.5414707064628601,
-0.688880443572998,
-0.4980796277523041,
-0.9644462466239929,
-0.09206094592809677,
0.249883234500885,
0.45893594622612,
0.1703394204378128,
-0.020634032785892487,
0.12377142161130905,
0.7840731143951416,
-0.027244342491030693,
0.868813693523407,
0.43782415986061096,
0.08139704912900925,
-0.4589800238609314,
0.5583884716033936,
0.07057850062847137,
0.4790142774581909,
0.46001219749450684,
-0.15504536032676697,
-0.45250052213668823,
-0.7136338353157043,
-0.5053740739822388,
0.05479329451918602,
-0.4248853623867035,
-0.44350191950798035,
-0.5193051695823669,
-0.19113634526729584,
-0.3833024501800537,
0.07925071567296982,
-0.2516018748283386,
-0.5905293226242065,
-0.4313221871852875,
-0.056177519261837006,
0.30218207836151123,
1.152252197265625,
-0.05267397314310074,
0.5145837664604187,
-0.5484713315963745,
0.44099488854408264,
-0.006272910628467798,
0.3711957633495331,
-0.287073016166687,
-0.3569357395172119,
-0.07067254930734634,
-0.16689547896385193,
-0.29900023341178894,
-0.9728687405586243,
0.7251244187355042,
0.3525398075580597,
0.32237517833709717,
0.2763337194919586,
0.3707520067691803,
0.36543065309524536,
-0.5633339881896973,
0.6467054486274719,
0.10882502794265747,
-1.1382445096969604,
0.33456000685691833,
-0.5572211742401123,
0.7798680663108826,
0.20138543844223022,
0.25619906187057495,
-0.4209115505218506,
-0.5152807831764221,
-0.7420985102653503,
-0.7320699095726013,
0.6015772819519043,
0.22955454885959625,
-0.1026083454489708,
-0.36631783843040466,
0.5508895516395569,
-0.0204804465174675,
0.37004515528678894,
-0.6929848790168762,
-0.2748385965824127,
-0.5505945086479187,
-0.39244046807289124,
0.015163358300924301,
0.03186803311109543,
-0.054823704063892365,
0.12139653414487839,
0.5197780728340149,
-0.3201756477355957,
0.2994493544101715,
0.6417362093925476,
-0.1279185265302658,
-0.28235530853271484,
0.3488105237483978,
0.5212661623954773,
0.19551964104175568,
0.005723351147025824,
0.05410762503743172,
0.21231763064861298,
-0.4490392208099365,
0.3039136528968811,
0.12645086646080017,
-0.3827325701713562,
-0.054912421852350235,
0.21586619317531586,
0.8404501080513,
-0.21352310478687286,
-0.35371461510658264,
0.2822163701057434,
-0.11952683329582214,
-0.5651758313179016,
-0.25950801372528076,
0.31224119663238525,
-0.3748011887073517,
0.03125069662928581,
0.5099032521247864,
-0.12478654086589813,
0.26539403200149536,
0.0561487153172493,
0.2103043496608734,
0.36581459641456604,
-0.32057881355285645,
-0.18514935672283173,
1.0024298429489136,
0.06816908717155457,
-0.1075279712677002,
0.5922352075576782,
-0.2788026034832001,
-0.2546236515045166,
0.49811533093452454,
0.7015562653541565,
0.8737453818321228,
-0.35060012340545654,
-0.02574988268315792,
0.47657519578933716,
0.390059232711792,
-0.07141780108213425,
0.41652339696884155,
-0.23523780703544617,
-0.6488391757011414,
-0.6725698709487915,
-0.5889267325401306,
-0.269281268119812,
0.02063029445707798,
-0.7947655320167542,
-0.009869938716292381,
-0.6173849701881409,
-0.32293668389320374,
-0.4170440137386322,
-0.018157226964831352,
-0.49927741289138794,
0.5015321373939514,
-0.06896919012069702,
0.840516984462738,
-0.4999624788761139,
1.1266707181930542,
0.32815054059028625,
-0.14693348109722137,
-0.9417001605033875,
-0.05546535179018974,
-0.2114318311214447,
-0.42662015557289124,
0.7823175191879272,
-0.26543131470680237,
-0.4129469394683838,
0.474791556596756,
-0.6306735277175903,
-1.1285074949264526,
1.3632398843765259,
0.11534274369478226,
-0.5396194458007812,
-0.576373815536499,
0.16078491508960724,
0.6283522844314575,
-0.33510878682136536,
-0.1380745768547058,
0.807258129119873,
0.5392467379570007,
0.3158186078071594,
-1.2945120334625244,
0.10646187514066696,
-0.086198590695858,
0.0537366159260273,
0.5521942973136902,
-0.630547046661377,
0.6654360890388489,
-0.11750335991382599,
-0.43379583954811096,
0.10037387907505035,
0.7179739475250244,
-0.1887005716562271,
-0.040847986936569214,
0.41796207427978516,
0.7417977452278137,
0.44863128662109375,
-0.3201502859592438,
1.0230114459991455,
-0.6188963055610657,
0.22770977020263672,
0.8952817320823669,
-0.05803521350026131,
0.45058757066726685,
0.5933421850204468,
0.22247670590877533,
0.534634530544281,
0.3597586154937744,
-0.12177110463380814,
0.6982943415641785,
0.2980298697948456,
-0.2706908881664276,
-0.06900654733181,
-0.2475966215133667,
0.08283302187919617,
0.7766552567481995,
0.6586197018623352,
-0.4711592197418213,
-0.24318356812000275,
-0.0030863776337355375,
-0.0033439521212130785,
0.2366856038570404,
-0.4217611253261566,
0.9833261370658875,
0.0784291997551918,
-0.9110132455825806,
1.0646318197250366,
0.20724201202392578,
0.6324045062065125,
-0.529236376285553,
-0.09784656763076782,
-0.06419272720813751,
0.2395085245370865,
-0.2239232212305069,
-0.24286401271820068,
0.6080659031867981,
-0.17019103467464447,
-0.01056663691997528,
-0.5502897500991821,
0.7183865904808044,
-0.7625308036804199,
-0.057583004236221313,
0.2952078878879547,
0.38734307885169983,
-0.3243553936481476,
0.29985007643699646,
-0.46398085355758667,
-0.24017778038978577,
-0.03711215779185295,
-0.17196689546108246,
-0.16606687009334564,
0.1900298297405243,
-0.11557035893201828,
0.8501836657524109,
0.24644148349761963,
0.03769252449274063,
0.2720170319080353,
-0.4103563129901886,
0.709807276725769,
-0.7255764603614807,
-0.4469783306121826,
-0.5833181142807007,
0.1928679496049881,
0.44917169213294983,
-0.10212218016386032,
0.6909164190292358,
0.11420732736587524,
0.7183849215507507,
-0.06990960240364075,
0.9071060419082642,
-0.40668919682502747,
0.37256965041160583,
-0.7200432419776917,
0.7524698376655579,
-0.2761111259460449,
-0.18804500997066498,
0.12931129336357117,
-0.6592517495155334,
-0.44176408648490906,
0.4419926404953003,
-0.3968042731285095,
-0.1272345781326294,
0.817609429359436,
0.5659267902374268,
0.17096589505672455,
-0.2796310782432556,
0.38986966013908386,
0.19472642242908478,
0.33185267448425293,
0.9628567695617676,
0.41760092973709106,
-0.3885155916213989,
0.6386345028877258,
-0.09958118200302124,
-0.048355765640735626,
0.2107473909854889,
-0.8792792558670044,
-1.0859848260879517,
-0.6030742526054382,
-0.23514579236507416,
-0.4138752520084381,
0.04564071074128151,
0.918953537940979,
0.5516873598098755,
-0.8965427279472351,
-0.38516753911972046,
-0.7523755431175232,
-0.0346159003674984,
-0.07748293876647949,
-0.20807243883609772,
0.23425114154815674,
-0.4173985421657562,
-0.9674850702285767,
0.6238886117935181,
0.09811686724424362,
0.23861292004585266,
-0.3976396918296814,
-0.14575958251953125,
-0.2938998341560364,
0.2278255820274353,
0.1936223953962326,
0.1818094402551651,
-0.7650860548019409,
-0.14853356778621674,
0.20858266949653625,
-0.12604700028896332,
0.08553051948547363,
0.8639137148857117,
-0.6985084414482117,
0.5339796543121338,
0.33565205335617065,
0.5457103252410889,
0.5010358691215515,
0.12995611131191254,
1.0046712160110474,
-0.6456630825996399,
0.07709075510501862,
0.37535518407821655,
0.02189403586089611,
0.252007395029068,
-0.36018967628479004,
0.1558205485343933,
0.09311959892511368,
-0.6473381519317627,
-0.15732215344905853,
0.5763671398162842,
-0.8238745927810669,
-0.11091481149196625,
1.0992014408111572,
-0.03515902906656265,
-0.2982470393180847,
-0.107247494161129,
-0.08554577827453613,
0.6185958385467529,
-0.5754987597465515,
0.7770190834999084,
0.764091968536377,
-0.3651452362537384,
-0.45213356614112854,
-0.24931399524211884,
1.0422593355178833,
0.3478344678878784,
-0.7403903603553772,
-0.07082485407590866,
0.7805579900741577,
0.11246293783187866,
0.12109692394733429,
0.2906491756439209,
-0.04905444756150246,
0.22485119104385376,
-0.07779533416032791,
0.2702551782131195,
-0.21561230719089508,
-0.5201905965805054,
-0.6856365203857422,
0.21233788132667542,
0.0965617299079895,
-0.2613082826137543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06838v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06838v1
|
Simpler becomes Harder: Do LLMs Exhibit a Coherent Behavior on Simplified Corpora?
| 2024-04-10T09:02:33 | 2024-04-10T09:02:33 |
Miriam Anschütz, Edoardo Mosca, Georg Groh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text simplification seeks to improve readability while retaining the original
content and meaning. Our study investigates whether pre-trained classifiers
also maintain such coherence by comparing their predictions on both original
and simplified inputs. We conduct experiments using 11 pre-trained models,
including BERT and OpenAI's GPT 3.5, across six datasets spanning three
languages. Additionally, we conduct a detailed analysis of the correlation
between prediction change rates and simplification types/strengths. Our
findings reveal alarming inconsistencies across all languages and models. If
not promptly addressed, simplified inputs can be easily exploited to craft
zero-iteration model-agnostic adversarial attacks with success rates of up to
50%
|
[
-0.16244995594024658,
-0.8076216578483582,
0.7280274033546448,
-0.009494743309915066,
-0.41919824481010437,
-0.052178580313920975,
-0.35427963733673096,
-0.5447490215301514,
-0.06276323646306992,
0.05541808903217316,
-0.7276994585990906,
-0.3223586082458496,
-0.8150616884231567,
0.3026198148727417,
-0.5584221482276917,
1.1487958431243896,
-0.23324021697044373,
0.25103381276130676,
-0.09570205211639404,
0.1514882594347,
-0.06602983921766281,
-0.6463102102279663,
-0.5979171991348267,
-0.48910000920295715,
0.7130757570266724,
0.21415002644062042,
1.1111071109771729,
0.6414152383804321,
0.7311258912086487,
0.3309239447116852,
-0.2567800283432007,
-0.11579445749521255,
-0.5441579818725586,
0.17807677388191223,
0.20496605336666107,
-0.8180495500564575,
-0.3282466530799866,
0.005005875136703253,
0.3655402362346649,
0.9674782156944275,
-0.03321231156587601,
-0.14793601632118225,
0.30580493807792664,
0.560326874256134,
-0.5879040956497192,
0.10251953452825546,
-0.7717028856277466,
-0.010503613390028477,
-0.029370034113526344,
-0.13995470106601715,
-0.4134999215602875,
-0.28973472118377686,
0.12538784742355347,
-0.8293417692184448,
0.4363759160041809,
-0.18530872464179993,
0.9924755692481995,
0.4631434977054596,
-0.24063317477703094,
-0.6909492015838623,
-0.6657838821411133,
0.8118396997451782,
-0.3909136652946472,
0.3267066180706024,
0.05430852994322777,
0.11439491808414459,
-0.24014347791671753,
-0.8225716352462769,
-0.43113958835601807,
-0.31295740604400635,
-0.22521081566810608,
0.24653182923793793,
-0.40646281838417053,
0.2675645053386688,
0.3470739424228668,
0.31013765931129456,
-0.4746972918510437,
0.035169921815395355,
-0.555400550365448,
-0.13003665208816528,
0.5341580510139465,
-0.14463120698928833,
0.42712387442588806,
0.06428349018096924,
-0.46357262134552,
-0.15809178352355957,
-0.801193118095398,
0.11634965240955353,
0.47155314683914185,
0.20986482501029968,
-0.1339958757162094,
0.5629611015319824,
-0.1497628539800644,
0.3552539348602295,
0.17605911195278168,
-0.3387536108493805,
0.03980754688382149,
-0.42791521549224854,
-0.5604621171951294,
0.133018359541893,
0.7925183176994324,
-0.13492651283740997,
0.34873607754707336,
-0.26876020431518555,
-0.22801311314105988,
0.3312462568283081,
0.2804662883281708,
-0.6910844445228577,
-0.4615461826324463,
0.13017897307872772,
-0.2168467938899994,
-0.43860453367233276,
0.10132186114788055,
-0.07119645923376083,
-0.20796190202236176,
-0.4967201054096222,
0.48439449071884155,
-0.5658559799194336,
0.24118764698505402,
0.33525556325912476,
-0.10115975886583328,
0.23391938209533691,
0.9272129535675049,
-0.7142220735549927,
0.2817452847957611,
0.9269866943359375,
0.6102333664894104,
-0.33811837434768677,
-0.35423052310943604,
-0.2272202968597412,
0.07028944790363312,
-0.4632859230041504,
0.5863209962844849,
-0.2598910629749298,
-0.32909855246543884,
-0.21904540061950684,
-0.34869861602783203,
-0.08203282207250595,
-0.531056821346283,
0.7038393020629883,
-0.5233418345451355,
0.22765038907527924,
-0.16532646119594574,
-0.5560925006866455,
-0.04010384902358055,
0.3270912766456604,
-0.6921355128288269,
0.6452885866165161,
-0.3873915672302246,
-0.9362043738365173,
0.5974608063697815,
-0.2299967259168625,
-0.5148468613624573,
-0.17896588146686554,
-0.23945815861225128,
-0.6190180778503418,
0.334792822599411,
0.06653665006160736,
0.3278627395629883,
0.02243599109351635,
0.34065207839012146,
-0.5070836544036865,
-0.6848027110099792,
0.19427122175693512,
-0.871627688407898,
0.7133722305297852,
0.3744783103466034,
-0.27185651659965515,
0.07518608123064041,
-0.6374176740646362,
-0.03697866201400757,
-0.0067224809899926186,
-0.5036475658416748,
-0.17358358204364777,
-0.028332455083727837,
-0.3735819458961487,
0.06450241059064865,
0.44880765676498413,
-0.3989333510398865,
0.39787980914115906,
-0.18074531853199005,
0.08735568076372147,
0.6880679130554199,
-0.3300061523914337,
0.4922236502170563,
-0.31588536500930786,
0.41811835765838623,
0.08973477780818939,
0.22256483137607574,
-0.21852189302444458,
-0.3407551944255829,
-1.0083669424057007,
-0.5684348344802856,
0.39176908135414124,
0.6340230107307434,
-0.6209942102432251,
0.0987701416015625,
-0.47954773902893066,
-0.4025513231754303,
-0.4838184714317322,
0.4104025661945343,
0.2887185513973236,
0.1341807097196579,
0.40220096707344055,
0.006096202414482832,
-0.5986920595169067,
-0.7795277833938599,
-0.5142300128936768,
-0.3314375877380371,
-0.33160722255706787,
-0.20162184536457062,
0.34894663095474243,
-0.35267600417137146,
0.5667944550514221,
-0.41631266474723816,
0.15064553916454315,
-0.3545970320701599,
0.3509765863418579,
0.13224443793296814,
0.29281410574913025,
0.20057813823223114,
-0.8068970441818237,
-0.40737593173980713,
-0.26467350125312805,
-1.0055837631225586,
-0.0475778728723526,
-0.16394473612308502,
0.1616629660129547,
0.09010230004787445,
0.8763051629066467,
-0.5091305375099182,
0.5475701689720154,
0.514065682888031,
0.0781867727637291,
0.2819608449935913,
-0.2732485830783844,
0.0054974849335849285,
-0.7797533869743347,
-0.3499332666397095,
-0.29158058762550354,
-0.24678181111812592,
-0.9155986309051514,
-0.018211983144283295,
0.10838201642036438,
-0.03357852250337601,
-0.5619041919708252,
0.1397554725408554,
-0.44497165083885193,
0.07430946081876755,
-0.14119569957256317,
-0.08089303970336914,
-0.02117743156850338,
0.36827757954597473,
-0.029529402032494545,
0.8380953073501587,
0.4391501247882843,
-0.7150086164474487,
-0.12157183140516281,
-0.2043221890926361,
-0.3100316822528839,
0.22622452676296234,
-0.9426103830337524,
0.00039151092641986907,
-0.2636837065219879,
0.16023622453212738,
-1.022520661354065,
-0.36557430028915405,
0.06662849336862564,
-0.36980316042900085,
0.43934714794158936,
0.06847403198480606,
-0.5337254405021667,
0.012955250218510628,
-0.5173864364624023,
0.25505203008651733,
0.5123568177223206,
-0.5609506368637085,
0.5856102705001831,
-0.2883514165878296,
-0.2351008653640747,
-0.6149668097496033,
-0.9574631452560425,
-0.15528921782970428,
0.043739818036556244,
-0.6690724492073059,
0.1907784640789032,
-0.41061675548553467,
-0.41612234711647034,
-0.25891560316085815,
-0.21436123549938202,
-0.18649379909038544,
0.6315386295318604,
0.3263987600803375,
0.34053725004196167,
-0.10887092351913452,
-0.01992044225335121,
-0.019437966868281364,
0.26254701614379883,
-0.06342783570289612,
0.10072457045316696,
0.5119091272354126,
-0.27406957745552063,
-0.6648973822593689,
-0.5885204076766968,
0.10527492314577103,
0.3596062660217285,
0.3889034688472748,
0.5324996113777161,
0.3559247851371765,
0.014767446555197239,
0.034173861145973206,
-0.2307668775320053,
-0.01785384677350521,
-0.5378738045692444,
0.21482746303081512,
-0.6672908663749695,
-0.9247287511825562,
0.3879934251308441,
-0.055802565068006516,
-0.04002268239855766,
0.5046865940093994,
0.3155951201915741,
-0.5031625032424927,
0.9336270689964294,
0.6158336997032166,
0.2072017788887024,
0.5030422210693359,
-0.054820649325847626,
0.14591914415359497,
-0.27462971210479736,
-0.17136019468307495,
-0.271593302488327,
-0.07314378768205643,
-0.9003358483314514,
-0.20413729548454285,
0.18250718712806702,
0.6205059885978699,
-0.11181231588125229,
0.17434242367744446,
-0.14209908246994019,
0.4730287790298462,
0.40680137276649475,
0.14921917021274567,
0.34192153811454773,
0.1385313868522644,
0.012595913372933865,
0.04780929163098335,
-0.6454097628593445,
-0.5330533385276794,
1.1750539541244507,
0.3992402255535126,
1.0872715711593628,
0.31071901321411133,
1.2094613313674927,
0.15870791673660278,
0.6387377977371216,
-0.8917372226715088,
0.4791225790977478,
-0.33529701828956604,
-0.2850914001464844,
-0.18776410818099976,
-0.4470452666282654,
-1.1165815591812134,
0.31563594937324524,
-0.20972993969917297,
-0.08127311617136002,
0.11788461357355118,
0.19959436357021332,
-0.17541201412677765,
0.2771804630756378,
-0.7591468691825867,
0.5126326680183411,
-0.2700330317020416,
-0.14277689158916473,
0.1697419434785843,
-0.4415992200374603,
0.5204412937164307,
-0.27995502948760986,
0.2638527452945709,
0.08927754312753677,
-0.10627193003892899,
0.32617729902267456,
-0.5869114398956299,
0.8320260643959045,
0.23517011106014252,
-0.16867537796497345,
0.1283956617116928,
0.08454212546348572,
0.4303554892539978,
-0.1284385472536087,
0.01967558078467846,
0.31134849786758423,
-0.31576552987098694,
-0.5500012040138245,
-0.6173836588859558,
0.37541404366493225,
-1.0689176321029663,
-0.8901199698448181,
-0.43400731682777405,
-0.35916832089424133,
0.1308417171239853,
0.2295413613319397,
0.5237364172935486,
0.11211881041526794,
-0.4545556902885437,
0.2656216025352478,
0.8496665954589844,
0.14769665896892548,
0.4504527449607849,
0.3077855110168457,
-0.009294729679822922,
-0.45964929461479187,
0.49769777059555054,
0.2262883335351944,
0.6369748115539551,
0.2888144850730896,
0.0363491028547287,
-0.006262298207730055,
-0.6098244190216064,
-0.26379233598709106,
0.019806118682026863,
-0.8258695602416992,
-0.08815980702638626,
-0.5362566113471985,
-0.11047311127185822,
-0.5460190176963806,
-0.3949262201786041,
-0.03897015005350113,
-0.5287071466445923,
-0.3405035138130188,
-0.07666634023189545,
-0.12062501907348633,
1.0940426588058472,
0.024933772161602974,
0.5735909342765808,
-0.3550427258014679,
0.4087761342525482,
0.6201056838035583,
0.04611966013908386,
-0.45335155725479126,
-0.564874529838562,
0.13427872955799103,
0.10700443387031555,
-0.2658658027648926,
-0.7708248496055603,
0.2143825888633728,
0.3344642221927643,
0.44877299666404724,
0.3315717577934265,
-0.17918166518211365,
0.6545515060424805,
-0.47571679949760437,
0.6766692399978638,
0.36694836616516113,
-1.0318278074264526,
0.40330225229263306,
-0.2165922373533249,
0.4878316819667816,
0.7524541020393372,
0.47681617736816406,
-0.1361149698495865,
-0.3424687385559082,
-0.7279617190361023,
-0.5474644899368286,
0.6085811853408813,
0.3096533417701721,
0.00351412664167583,
0.18066266179084778,
0.34620264172554016,
0.16715097427368164,
0.39510244131088257,
-0.9139704704284668,
-0.49277064204216003,
-0.2543964982032776,
-0.4119834899902344,
-0.18720363080501556,
-0.4840400516986847,
-0.037126943469047546,
-0.07026553899049759,
0.3872791826725006,
0.10710195451974869,
0.07073377072811127,
0.19297705590724945,
-0.32882896065711975,
0.20810362696647644,
0.6089789867401123,
0.8090999126434326,
0.3783576786518097,
-0.13419482111930847,
0.3565812408924103,
0.4150967597961426,
-0.624012291431427,
0.3269076943397522,
0.04039283096790314,
-0.6096843481063843,
0.24631495773792267,
0.6719866394996643,
0.9132030010223389,
0.24503153562545776,
-0.30513450503349304,
0.7170642018318176,
-0.34808534383773804,
-0.48678338527679443,
-0.4453139305114746,
0.21691466867923737,
-0.10145514458417892,
-0.1264718472957611,
0.2595188319683075,
0.5306882858276367,
0.18661968410015106,
-0.8701526522636414,
0.15753184258937836,
0.24424344301223755,
-0.3859160244464874,
-0.34016916155815125,
0.4535942077636719,
-0.1262068748474121,
-0.03446291759610176,
0.2969318628311157,
-0.20935074985027313,
-0.6664330363273621,
0.4657285213470459,
0.2780546247959137,
0.9201351404190063,
-0.20946791768074036,
-0.05083779618144035,
-0.048329416662454605,
0.6095446944236755,
-0.4123705327510834,
0.2757050395011902,
-0.2104823887348175,
-0.6299605965614319,
-0.29079172015190125,
-0.5552354454994202,
-0.6511037945747375,
0.09491761028766632,
-0.6298383474349976,
0.5817714333534241,
-0.6684626936912537,
-0.009187046438455582,
0.0634576827287674,
-0.06062324345111847,
-0.8662919998168945,
0.4574345350265503,
0.4153136610984802,
0.7883145213127136,
-0.8405457735061646,
0.9387422800064087,
0.6174145936965942,
-0.3743259608745575,
-0.8831012845039368,
0.30019038915634155,
-0.03788559138774872,
-0.5866737365722656,
1.0248703956604004,
0.3165571093559265,
-0.3968101143836975,
-0.5110562443733215,
-0.8387728333473206,
-0.9621779918670654,
1.0529345273971558,
0.704967200756073,
-0.486503541469574,
0.0017009115545079112,
0.3647482693195343,
0.7379034757614136,
-0.2507409453392029,
0.2987655997276306,
0.33035531640052795,
0.3945212960243225,
0.15266484022140503,
-0.862381637096405,
-0.23200784623622894,
-0.15051092207431793,
-0.19399993121623993,
-0.03935392200946808,
-0.4405933916568756,
1.387834072113037,
-0.25159952044487,
-0.5847073793411255,
-0.1304279863834381,
0.922414243221283,
0.16901661455631256,
0.47233977913856506,
0.481654554605484,
0.6120570302009583,
1.0032891035079956,
-0.31662997603416443,
1.1940046548843384,
-0.2035270780324936,
0.13931643962860107,
1.2891987562179565,
-0.1528598666191101,
0.9559938311576843,
0.3469044268131256,
-0.1680506318807602,
0.7386316061019897,
0.5564053058624268,
0.08107077330350876,
0.5231258869171143,
0.2530231475830078,
-0.2946859896183014,
-0.2955601215362549,
0.17156246304512024,
-0.22003422677516937,
0.3371650278568268,
0.18133562803268433,
-0.1947541981935501,
-0.05706927925348282,
-0.12632626295089722,
0.44292664527893066,
0.040932875126600266,
-0.5032762885093689,
0.9281176924705505,
0.09608889371156693,
-0.713373601436615,
0.7145029902458191,
-0.11652982234954834,
1.150417447090149,
-0.7141465544700623,
0.2960493862628937,
-0.1748279184103012,
0.21504253149032593,
-0.2794536054134369,
-0.5877949595451355,
0.10949640721082687,
-0.08975916355848312,
-0.2769146263599396,
-0.2604043185710907,
0.7835232615470886,
-0.574101448059082,
-0.4901787042617798,
0.3364628255367279,
0.3256916105747223,
0.1915103793144226,
0.04618850722908974,
-0.6951837539672852,
0.273591011762619,
0.16162067651748657,
-0.11305815726518631,
0.18977460265159607,
0.44216668605804443,
0.04381590336561203,
0.7407401204109192,
0.6495648622512817,
0.09182906895875931,
0.360628604888916,
-0.006784942001104355,
0.8757776618003845,
-0.43184709548950195,
-0.16242511570453644,
-0.9877825379371643,
0.1294437050819397,
-0.1142551377415657,
-0.07246197015047073,
0.7828322649002075,
0.5727366209030151,
1.1204800605773926,
-0.14035660028457642,
1.002549409866333,
0.39444079995155334,
0.28958991169929504,
-0.5473186373710632,
0.45155808329582214,
-0.5801882147789001,
0.45145466923713684,
-0.06350685656070709,
-0.5787798762321472,
-0.3324850797653198,
0.2756982445716858,
-0.43270841240882874,
0.06619422882795334,
0.6826038956642151,
0.4835978150367737,
-0.13493703305721283,
-0.10289329290390015,
0.5131624937057495,
0.1957276463508606,
0.2308500111103058,
0.2252221703529358,
0.7771991491317749,
-0.5991112589836121,
0.7737057209014893,
-0.26505523920059204,
0.1371428668498993,
-0.24633407592773438,
-0.690156102180481,
-0.9703776836395264,
0.03470178321003914,
-0.37162894010543823,
-0.21701402962207794,
0.2557905614376068,
0.667312741279602,
0.3210315704345703,
-0.9178675413131714,
-0.0586332231760025,
-0.29060256481170654,
0.018762240186333656,
0.121429443359375,
-0.11932727694511414,
0.26224350929260254,
-0.7235936522483826,
-0.6322115659713745,
0.412437379360199,
0.10839860141277313,
0.51564621925354,
-0.14839069545269012,
-0.02020113170146942,
0.16811925172805786,
0.4706183671951294,
0.44660478830337524,
0.03253096342086792,
-0.795242428779602,
-0.1318308264017105,
0.10639501363039017,
-0.6037402153015137,
0.1186298057436943,
0.6865779161453247,
-0.5207709074020386,
0.3965977430343628,
0.6264752745628357,
0.3794310688972473,
0.3067193031311035,
0.10827043652534485,
0.5441288948059082,
-0.7013558745384216,
0.19072997570037842,
-0.18596643209457397,
0.5222724676132202,
0.42615434527397156,
-0.2924691438674927,
0.42730796337127686,
0.12593038380146027,
-0.30247971415519714,
-0.718746542930603,
0.41045045852661133,
-0.9240883588790894,
-0.45059528946876526,
0.9749505519866943,
-0.45417505502700806,
-0.419436514377594,
-0.08417738229036331,
-0.05074268579483032,
0.2859640121459961,
-0.24501539766788483,
0.5466986894607544,
0.6396150588989258,
-0.09884172677993774,
0.09134450554847717,
-0.31735414266586304,
0.9139153361320496,
0.657380223274231,
-0.737277090549469,
-0.2264489233493805,
0.27000880241394043,
0.3934669494628906,
0.330508291721344,
0.41913944482803345,
0.1029731035232544,
0.2652307152748108,
0.01665143296122551,
0.0806218683719635,
0.1050456240773201,
-0.3386911451816559,
-0.7321175336837769,
0.3637174069881439,
0.1644180864095688,
0.1496061235666275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06833v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06833v1
|
Does Mapo Tofu Contain Coffee? Probing LLMs for Food-related Cultural Knowledge
| 2024-04-10T08:49:27 | 2024-04-10T08:49:27 |
Li Zhou, Taelin Karidi, Nicolas Garneau, Yong Cao, Wanlong Liu, Wenyu Chen, Daniel Hershcovich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent studies have highlighted the presence of cultural biases in Large
Language Models (LLMs), yet often lack a robust methodology to dissect these
phenomena comprehensively. Our work aims to bridge this gap by delving into the
Food domain, a universally relevant yet culturally diverse aspect of human
life. We introduce FmLAMA, a multilingual dataset centered on food-related
cultural facts and variations in food practices. We analyze LLMs across various
architectures and configurations, evaluating their performance in both
monolingual and multilingual settings. By leveraging templates in six different
languages, we investigate how LLMs interact with language-specific and cultural
knowledge. Our findings reveal that (1) LLMs demonstrate a pronounced bias
towards food knowledge prevalent in the United States; (2) Incorporating
relevant cultural context significantly improves LLMs' ability to access
cultural knowledge; (3) The efficacy of LLMs in capturing cultural nuances is
highly dependent on the interplay between the probing language, the specific
model architecture, and the cultural context in question. This research
underscores the complexity of integrating cultural understanding into LLMs and
emphasizes the importance of culturally diverse datasets to mitigate biases and
enhance model performance across different cultural domains.
|
[
-0.27472448348999023,
-0.7466296553611755,
0.5466679334640503,
0.14543983340263367,
-0.07441876083612442,
0.06066815182566643,
-0.3154584467411041,
-0.6626609563827515,
0.236029252409935,
0.5047719478607178,
-0.5844114422798157,
-0.629941999912262,
-0.8563302755355835,
0.2959139347076416,
-0.17187412083148956,
0.8034460544586182,
-0.16853347420692444,
0.41051822900772095,
-0.420206218957901,
-0.4575461149215698,
-0.28093597292900085,
-0.4968722462654114,
-0.38396450877189636,
-0.789587140083313,
0.74277263879776,
0.4873603284358978,
0.6794643998146057,
0.5271748900413513,
0.3984072208404541,
0.17133229970932007,
-0.07297758758068085,
0.4052356779575348,
-0.6434459686279297,
-0.019073085859417915,
-0.2581256031990051,
-0.9572181105613708,
-0.03828861936926842,
-0.020092487335205078,
0.1955820918083191,
0.9647473096847534,
0.08935944736003876,
0.6261422038078308,
-0.219880610704422,
0.6295661926269531,
-0.43245038390159607,
0.4678528606891632,
-0.5814882516860962,
0.22628584504127502,
-0.2640000879764557,
-0.17416056990623474,
-0.4059421420097351,
-0.3518902659416199,
0.0452711395919323,
-0.6859619617462158,
-0.2393474578857422,
0.07252778112888336,
0.8168280124664307,
0.3798181712627411,
-1.096318006515503,
-0.4279218018054962,
-0.837108314037323,
0.7357723712921143,
-0.45120811462402344,
0.40192854404449463,
0.6189351081848145,
0.27941903471946716,
-0.3876039683818817,
-0.4478706121444702,
-0.4792904257774353,
0.181981161236763,
-0.23122939467430115,
-0.011067025363445282,
0.093608558177948,
-0.47284388542175293,
0.18262335658073425,
0.3237254023551941,
-0.43757134675979614,
0.051577478647232056,
-0.18124569952487946,
0.10929302871227264,
0.4967859983444214,
0.22605590522289276,
0.570736289024353,
-0.15352492034435272,
-0.5631649494171143,
-0.08490610867738724,
-0.8890546560287476,
0.4214169979095459,
0.1308881938457489,
0.14433275163173676,
-0.14202073216438293,
0.48840558528900146,
-0.10479802638292313,
0.6122393608093262,
-0.5874030590057373,
-0.5073418021202087,
0.049964144825935364,
-0.1491428017616272,
-0.0493091344833374,
-0.09993963688611984,
0.657353937625885,
0.6489245891571045,
0.49238842725753784,
-0.16688373684883118,
-0.06999842077493668,
0.016851553693413734,
-0.10346989333629608,
-0.6543282866477966,
-0.013247796334326267,
0.2149462252855301,
-0.34409597516059875,
-0.015795135870575905,
0.10355882346630096,
-0.6263582110404968,
-0.4497668445110321,
-0.17085383832454681,
-0.07561591267585754,
-0.14003106951713562,
-0.4476901888847351,
0.08642894774675369,
-0.397914320230484,
0.5574908256530762,
-0.004325339570641518,
-0.9334479570388794,
0.1608632504940033,
0.7838073372840881,
0.6180104613304138,
-0.17569591104984283,
-0.32191798090934753,
0.0595427080988884,
0.4599572718143463,
-0.5535197854042053,
0.8866536021232605,
-0.8029978275299072,
-0.33997857570648193,
0.11813411861658096,
0.09121641516685486,
-0.10355246812105179,
-0.7759568095207214,
0.5188137292861938,
-0.6121034026145935,
0.04634612053632736,
-0.9785252809524536,
-0.3634859025478363,
-0.7577603459358215,
0.4121464490890503,
-0.5808137059211731,
0.893746018409729,
0.17187726497650146,
-0.4914730489253998,
0.605376124382019,
-0.5902838110923767,
-0.8281844854354858,
-0.13656176626682281,
-0.5713568925857544,
0.026066135615110397,
0.07817728817462921,
0.304461270570755,
0.36946022510528564,
-0.6960328221321106,
0.4089865982532501,
-0.4531763195991516,
-0.42759793996810913,
0.6321298480033875,
-0.3927149176597595,
0.6955309510231018,
0.5174489617347717,
0.021060103550553322,
0.10208151489496231,
-0.6202067732810974,
-0.34989336133003235,
0.6064292788505554,
-0.37518244981765747,
-0.5417325496673584,
0.12259218841791153,
0.042063549160957336,
0.08516149967908859,
-0.0050966935232281685,
-0.1939382702112198,
0.1605989784002304,
-0.03429579734802246,
0.656255841255188,
0.5508024096488953,
-0.29341286420822144,
0.3511686325073242,
-0.5672640800476074,
0.44931817054748535,
0.3018631637096405,
0.11509320884943008,
-0.46402284502983093,
-0.6312289834022522,
-0.7147219181060791,
-0.0728420838713646,
0.05432262644171715,
0.47041842341423035,
-0.6982116103172302,
0.02136988937854767,
-0.30495521426200867,
-0.30795425176620483,
-0.45494744181632996,
0.13374195992946625,
-0.1321515589952469,
0.69660884141922,
-0.04706452414393425,
-0.1672893911600113,
-0.2809811532497406,
-0.9095014929771423,
-0.14696641266345978,
0.18311147391796112,
-0.20997072756290436,
0.2688952088356018,
0.31403911113739014,
-0.12699837982654572,
0.7260783910751343,
-0.782155454158783,
-0.45066899061203003,
-0.21132928133010864,
-0.16915196180343628,
0.41156044602394104,
0.1669408529996872,
0.9728817939758301,
-0.6326349973678589,
-0.33180320262908936,
0.23738078773021698,
-1.1769767999649048,
0.21586954593658447,
0.24233968555927277,
-0.23601487278938293,
-0.13527430593967438,
0.14334383606910706,
-0.3904232382774353,
0.20207220315933228,
0.7227485179901123,
-0.4842730760574341,
0.04133379086852074,
0.17640751600265503,
0.3018845319747925,
-1.3124340772628784,
-0.0937088131904602,
-0.19683127105236053,
0.06920851767063141,
-0.6082591414451599,
0.08441183716058731,
0.09150321036577225,
-0.24047443270683289,
-0.43392089009284973,
0.871143102645874,
-0.45244836807250977,
-0.198068767786026,
-0.35913872718811035,
-0.16798731684684753,
0.30076363682746887,
0.5356425046920776,
0.24144195020198822,
0.8731861710548401,
0.46498697996139526,
-0.5522226095199585,
0.008761623874306679,
0.10301137715578079,
-0.6668374538421631,
0.605812132358551,
-0.20720615983009338,
0.07464616745710373,
-0.18292754888534546,
0.42543408274650574,
-1.1165143251419067,
-0.17533531785011292,
0.409475177526474,
-0.11728276312351227,
0.08305967599153519,
-0.13533003628253937,
-0.7310832738876343,
-0.18413430452346802,
0.045953087508678436,
0.6470495462417603,
0.1665654331445694,
-0.5965054631233215,
0.8179948925971985,
0.7166528701782227,
0.16152063012123108,
-0.41672390699386597,
-0.8856266736984253,
0.008956942707300186,
-0.45709842443466187,
-0.9851390719413757,
-0.2292121946811676,
-0.06846127659082413,
-0.38744765520095825,
-0.4959385395050049,
-0.2791001498699188,
-0.12456471472978592,
0.35066062211990356,
0.22357381880283356,
0.005693279672414064,
-0.5176876187324524,
0.11280226707458496,
-0.1652624011039734,
0.2798183560371399,
0.37596002221107483,
-0.3152608573436737,
0.6453714966773987,
-0.10743922740221024,
-0.058744076639413834,
-0.2275354564189911,
0.4700685739517212,
0.7523495554924011,
-0.2093237340450287,
0.5906790494918823,
0.8407146334648132,
-0.43232759833335876,
-0.05391090735793114,
-0.3604785203933716,
-0.35326993465423584,
-0.44976747035980225,
-0.005893458146601915,
-0.7234867215156555,
-0.5770935416221619,
0.9713420867919922,
-0.19340282678604126,
-0.007859763689339161,
0.1732645481824875,
0.3094598948955536,
-0.3392828106880188,
0.22627240419387817,
0.4426216185092926,
-0.1682797372341156,
0.3054395318031311,
-0.3424842655658722,
0.06419923901557922,
-0.7289266586303711,
-0.5202565789222717,
-0.5701585412025452,
-0.5767863392829895,
-0.4818527102470398,
-0.8693642020225525,
0.3013897240161896,
-0.5322213172912598,
0.01263044960796833,
-0.2371492236852646,
0.1535506248474121,
0.7468637228012085,
0.19339287281036377,
0.13377736508846283,
0.6308704614639282,
0.0870925784111023,
-0.21677172183990479,
0.02037174627184868,
-0.9485263824462891,
-0.4893175959587097,
1.0940861701965332,
0.4477913975715637,
0.9707563519477844,
0.1782245635986328,
0.21396850049495697,
0.08872562646865845,
0.5798264741897583,
-0.8737717270851135,
0.23875245451927185,
-0.326911598443985,
-0.6733815670013428,
-0.02894669957458973,
-0.3745678663253784,
-0.8465428352355957,
0.45635509490966797,
0.1273261457681656,
-0.4503209590911865,
0.009062100201845169,
-0.21205252408981323,
-0.02540486305952072,
0.34055060148239136,
-0.9101982116699219,
0.6709092259407043,
-0.5794384479522705,
-0.28478050231933594,
0.30346623063087463,
-0.37573036551475525,
0.4533495604991913,
0.16058987379074097,
0.6838703155517578,
-0.6015439033508301,
-0.06756817549467087,
0.7931734919548035,
0.10131634771823883,
0.910469651222229,
0.30911463499069214,
-0.6714662909507751,
-0.002419719472527504,
0.2970653772354126,
0.27103936672210693,
0.3182604908943176,
-0.2643490433692932,
0.7476791739463806,
-0.14185383915901184,
-0.579991340637207,
-0.6936285495758057,
0.835778534412384,
-0.7309694886207581,
-0.7440117001533508,
-0.42789188027381897,
-0.946159839630127,
-0.4841344356536865,
0.21828322112560272,
-0.02556465193629265,
-0.14808769524097443,
-0.11370111256837845,
0.08536992222070694,
0.6317938566207886,
0.07371493428945541,
0.20179066061973572,
0.6663438081741333,
-0.4825325310230255,
-0.08510775864124298,
0.6622344255447388,
0.13042223453521729,
0.0018250029534101486,
0.6021956205368042,
0.3859695494174957,
-0.19061052799224854,
-0.183854877948761,
-0.397148072719574,
0.3134181797504425,
-0.9531044363975525,
-0.08974196016788483,
-0.516837477684021,
-0.01034373790025711,
-0.25158414244651794,
-0.19679388403892517,
-0.36928996443748474,
-0.22169624269008636,
-0.3971661627292633,
-0.4298339784145355,
0.3118111491203308,
0.6448315978050232,
0.3610617518424988,
0.09378732740879059,
-0.5056871771812439,
0.20818188786506653,
-0.01372174546122551,
0.29920101165771484,
0.12626688182353973,
-0.37069573998451233,
-0.05722464248538017,
0.10349161922931671,
-0.09849260002374649,
-0.8744503259658813,
0.14202776551246643,
0.1452670842409134,
0.4572204649448395,
0.8726302981376648,
-0.038350727409124374,
0.6578022241592407,
-0.24091386795043945,
0.7822534441947937,
0.08352463692426682,
-0.5038170218467712,
0.4434354305267334,
-0.35370081663131714,
0.7027089595794678,
0.33316197991371155,
0.8724000453948975,
-0.7518001794815063,
-0.5384521484375,
0.010085240937769413,
-0.7460381388664246,
0.5102843642234802,
-0.1989724487066269,
0.4180409014225006,
-0.16978146135807037,
0.00009583385690348223,
0.5140453577041626,
0.21510201692581177,
-0.8107368350028992,
-0.34192097187042236,
-0.14772608876228333,
0.06639749556779861,
-0.004687512293457985,
-0.20012176036834717,
-0.7781532406806946,
-0.2359231412410736,
0.3148387670516968,
-0.18818101286888123,
-0.12367556244134903,
-0.06111065670847893,
-0.01361539214849472,
-0.290579617023468,
0.14448603987693787,
0.6981906890869141,
1.0268388986587524,
-0.16207444667816162,
0.23788094520568848,
0.19973568618297577,
-0.2779066264629364,
0.07811986654996872,
-0.4094361662864685,
-0.42517614364624023,
-0.13603119552135468,
0.2863749861717224,
0.673270046710968,
0.33078765869140625,
-0.648265540599823,
-0.05907665193080902,
-0.3908812701702118,
0.005756183993071318,
-0.28166258335113525,
0.07067795097827911,
0.43524810671806335,
0.20040808618068695,
0.4123266041278839,
-0.24688459932804108,
-0.024597596377134323,
-0.8826158046722412,
0.10409942269325256,
0.285518616437912,
-0.1403111219406128,
-0.26666855812072754,
0.4528411328792572,
0.4380950927734375,
0.012317130342125893,
0.7928226590156555,
0.3306428790092468,
-0.19890673458576202,
0.6223229765892029,
0.6989090442657471,
0.3820168375968933,
-0.17127637565135956,
0.2420656532049179,
0.18333721160888672,
0.4044864773750305,
0.3810204565525055,
0.4427952766418457,
-0.056346211582422256,
-0.9910746812820435,
0.09161868691444397,
-0.6930630207061768,
-0.15704913437366486,
0.2735944092273712,
-0.4618609547615051,
0.06583677977323532,
-0.4553576111793518,
-0.26530295610427856,
-0.09977293759584427,
-0.21739508211612701,
-0.9223323464393616,
0.13042600452899933,
0.20809818804264069,
0.9024922251701355,
-0.9842281937599182,
0.8735459446907043,
0.7412214279174805,
-0.36410143971443176,
-0.6223095059394836,
0.27248504757881165,
0.12260349094867706,
-1.0266239643096924,
0.6566249132156372,
0.1234782338142395,
-0.09271295368671417,
-0.45703810453414917,
-0.12718439102172852,
-0.9719688892364502,
1.168563723564148,
0.5440776944160461,
-0.10459818691015244,
0.07410352677106857,
0.5680825114250183,
0.494315505027771,
-0.6176044344902039,
0.30650368332862854,
0.5336700081825256,
0.740421712398529,
0.3178379237651825,
-0.4900108873844147,
0.08781207352876663,
0.09262286126613617,
0.012258892878890038,
-0.10042596608400345,
-1.2087371349334717,
0.5018903017044067,
-0.3853566348552704,
-0.30636653304100037,
-0.35481512546539307,
0.9367856383323669,
0.02042482979595661,
0.6282588839530945,
0.19197224080562592,
0.350816011428833,
0.8731163740158081,
-0.3775387108325958,
1.046288251876831,
-0.2850519120693207,
0.05632632598280907,
1.1695493459701538,
-0.598328173160553,
0.6575548648834229,
0.8568599820137024,
-0.18833275139331818,
0.24775469303131104,
1.1594774723052979,
-0.034643836319446564,
0.3765783905982971,
0.37686505913734436,
0.01133196521550417,
-0.0022542565129697323,
-0.6867906451225281,
-0.4839858114719391,
0.9294738173484802,
0.42491614818573,
-0.5215449333190918,
-0.3623355031013489,
-0.040224019438028336,
0.4720795154571533,
0.10895337164402008,
0.04577772319316864,
0.7375593781471252,
0.3404419720172882,
-0.7357081770896912,
0.6065161228179932,
-0.09890124946832657,
0.387633353471756,
-0.8389469385147095,
0.06487353146076202,
-0.7919707298278809,
-0.25169065594673157,
-0.19603361189365387,
-0.7288879156112671,
0.3246651589870453,
-0.3104263246059418,
-0.392922043800354,
-0.18821266293525696,
0.31936195492744446,
-0.5173582434654236,
-0.5471586585044861,
0.6398419737815857,
0.5019939541816711,
-0.051927827298641205,
0.14479777216911316,
-0.309515118598938,
0.4126681089401245,
-0.024156298488378525,
0.04201260209083557,
0.457562655210495,
0.4459713399410248,
0.11681021749973297,
0.7391688823699951,
0.6743208765983582,
-0.07271423935890198,
0.03149402141571045,
0.0947825163602829,
0.6619864702224731,
-0.5211575627326965,
-0.3403773307800293,
-0.6315219402313232,
0.15945173799991608,
0.31119978427886963,
-0.2483144998550415,
0.6233710050582886,
0.5093815922737122,
1.3411606550216675,
-0.42783409357070923,
0.5961819291114807,
0.26696279644966125,
-0.19113896787166595,
-0.8284028768539429,
0.9344669580459595,
-0.8488551378250122,
0.34618961811065674,
0.31566280126571655,
-0.7025781273841858,
0.07374175637960434,
0.40545180439949036,
-0.383582204580307,
-0.0819968730211258,
0.8822954893112183,
0.6397662162780762,
-0.15293076634407043,
0.27281486988067627,
0.6123347282409668,
0.19410881400108337,
0.3593303859233856,
0.5433729290962219,
0.8864046931266785,
-0.4054960310459137,
0.3272932767868042,
-0.18463034927845,
-0.15546588599681854,
0.034452106803655624,
-0.6922394633293152,
-0.7531195282936096,
-0.6492903828620911,
-0.10665849596261978,
0.13650985062122345,
-0.036474596709012985,
0.7797916531562805,
0.8448114991188049,
-0.6705834865570068,
-0.8708414435386658,
0.8916330933570862,
0.58530193567276,
-0.3993709087371826,
-0.2438763827085495,
0.05073067918419838,
-0.31341353058815,
-0.8541328310966492,
0.6649830937385559,
0.27149319648742676,
-0.21274012327194214,
-0.13281330466270447,
0.09450642019510269,
-0.47154244780540466,
0.3319181501865387,
0.905215322971344,
0.10015822947025299,
-0.7420873641967773,
-0.023680005222558975,
0.016818756237626076,
0.02355562336742878,
0.2932305932044983,
1.0486873388290405,
-0.12006043642759323,
0.4631350636482239,
0.3042560815811157,
0.7118078470230103,
0.19190733134746552,
-0.3515094518661499,
0.7737039923667908,
-0.7696803212165833,
0.35769596695899963,
-0.0460917167365551,
0.5083236694335938,
0.36946165561676025,
-0.4838140606880188,
0.6277576684951782,
0.2629270851612091,
-0.2620488405227661,
-0.4117095172405243,
0.3650810122489929,
-0.9311717748641968,
-0.35006722807884216,
1.42841374874115,
-0.2650064527988434,
-0.6012675762176514,
0.14210829138755798,
0.15184693038463593,
0.18354572355747223,
-0.3579953908920288,
1.1894346475601196,
1.0746082067489624,
0.05407106503844261,
0.050334636121988297,
-0.5953260064125061,
0.43672627210617065,
0.24357128143310547,
-0.9741400480270386,
-0.08784572780132294,
0.3190332353115082,
0.8282264471054077,
0.17952965199947357,
0.5139402151107788,
-0.0918886810541153,
0.14243733882904053,
-0.3754728436470032,
-0.3099907338619232,
-0.06738875061273575,
-0.4290867745876312,
0.0968499407172203,
0.3262008726596832,
0.07898541539907455,
-0.16016459465026855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06812v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06812v1
|
Emotion-cause pair extraction method based on multi-granularity information and multi-module interaction
| 2024-04-10T08:00:26 | 2024-04-10T08:00:26 |
Mingrui Fu, Weijiang Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The purpose of emotion-cause pair extraction is to extract the pair of
emotion clauses and cause clauses. On the one hand, the existing methods do not
take fully into account the relationship between the emotion extraction of two
auxiliary tasks. On the other hand, the existing two-stage model has the
problem of error propagation. In addition, existing models do not adequately
address the emotion and cause-induced locational imbalance of samples. To solve
these problems, an end-to-end multitasking model (MM-ECPE) based on shared
interaction between GRU, knowledge graph and transformer modules is proposed.
Furthermore, based on MM-ECPE, in order to use the encoder layer to better
solve the problem of imbalanced distribution of clause distances between
clauses and emotion clauses, we propose a novel encoding based on BERT,
sentiment lexicon, and position-aware interaction module layer of emotion motif
pair retrieval model (MM-ECPE(BERT)). The model first fully models the
interaction between different tasks through the multi-level sharing module, and
mines the shared information between emotion-cause pair extraction and the
emotion extraction and cause extraction. Second, to solve the imbalanced
distribution of emotion clauses and cause clauses problem, suitable labels are
screened out according to the knowledge graph path length and task-specific
features are constructed so that the model can focus on extracting pairs with
corresponding emotion-cause relationships. Experimental results on the ECPE
benchmark dataset show that the proposed model achieves good performance,
especially on position-imbalanced samples.
|
[
-0.6432904601097107,
-0.991191029548645,
0.38061007857322693,
0.1435566395521164,
-0.29417911171913147,
-0.28979071974754333,
-0.05544596165418625,
-0.6643553376197815,
0.5463680028915405,
0.15696312487125397,
-0.8044349551200867,
-0.19837620854377747,
-0.6786654591560364,
-0.09861034154891968,
-0.2189144492149353,
0.9672610759735107,
0.07541663199663162,
-0.06175213307142258,
-0.24103190004825592,
-0.17124046385288239,
-0.18193167448043823,
-0.7753219604492188,
-0.43124353885650635,
-0.2504085600376129,
0.5149649381637573,
0.41834330558776855,
0.12602125108242035,
-0.12849202752113342,
0.39305591583251953,
0.2798725366592407,
0.025144392624497414,
0.35724136233329773,
-0.23675349354743958,
-0.007896524854004383,
0.20351968705654144,
-0.24266557395458221,
-0.7781270742416382,
-0.1008920669555664,
0.17587366700172424,
0.026456153020262718,
-0.33349403738975525,
0.06428473442792892,
0.07950016856193542,
0.6646807193756104,
-0.5943446159362793,
0.22047822177410126,
-0.5533003211021423,
0.07531046867370605,
-0.16460613906383514,
-0.43598973751068115,
-0.30556708574295044,
0.06957429647445679,
-0.014677115716040134,
-0.3054058849811554,
0.0937817320227623,
0.08065395057201385,
0.8845113515853882,
-0.010831563733518124,
-0.6432100534439087,
-0.3051111102104187,
-0.2100643366575241,
0.7319931983947754,
-0.835024893283844,
0.026430554687976837,
0.17468266189098358,
-0.17606958746910095,
-0.024729281663894653,
-0.006280924659222364,
-0.7069903016090393,
0.15588952600955963,
-0.31820228695869446,
0.39212942123413086,
-0.1292840987443924,
0.07566361129283905,
0.09982419013977051,
0.188449889421463,
-0.36373746395111084,
-0.1550402045249939,
-0.2590501010417938,
-0.07327818125486374,
0.5937503576278687,
0.08272849023342133,
0.6855888962745667,
-0.7327449321746826,
-0.4576955735683441,
0.07347568869590759,
-0.43933653831481934,
0.23290951550006866,
0.5062752366065979,
0.07572788745164871,
-0.3139970004558563,
0.5342941284179688,
-0.07380516082048416,
0.4553641080856323,
0.053824856877326965,
0.04745568707585335,
0.5823675990104675,
-0.18455226719379425,
-0.23015931248664856,
-0.06635899841785431,
0.815248966217041,
0.48474809527397156,
0.006840217858552933,
-0.14286299049854279,
-0.14601466059684753,
0.06315738707780838,
0.26637956500053406,
-0.577879786491394,
0.0973220020532608,
0.6684115529060364,
-0.6084281206130981,
-0.3262683153152466,
-0.014304090291261673,
-1.268133282661438,
-0.1051398292183876,
-0.42116034030914307,
0.6061803698539734,
-0.694811999797821,
-0.6901112198829651,
0.03681644797325134,
-0.2525692582130432,
0.2882964015007019,
0.0019066687673330307,
-0.9537754058837891,
0.3000505864620209,
0.6898230314254761,
0.7813462615013123,
-0.1616252362728119,
-0.19306600093841553,
-0.40987294912338257,
0.15416575968265533,
0.36108875274658203,
0.7068257927894592,
-0.5078476071357727,
-0.05515570566058159,
0.050387728959321976,
0.2362995147705078,
-0.3257778286933899,
-0.28340429067611694,
0.7152509093284607,
-0.22955749928951263,
0.36700254678726196,
-0.31115537881851196,
-0.5363398194313049,
-0.25056830048561096,
0.40567436814308167,
-0.6752550005912781,
1.1443123817443848,
0.015228664502501488,
-0.9360641241073608,
0.03738746419548988,
-0.9506464600563049,
-0.38355597853660583,
-0.15026380121707916,
-0.05007605254650116,
-0.44459909200668335,
0.2554492652416229,
0.3542020916938782,
0.7535215020179749,
-0.22776807844638824,
0.29064467549324036,
-0.2909155488014221,
-0.05392828956246376,
0.06427692621946335,
-0.062496308237314224,
0.6419367790222168,
-0.05860017240047455,
-0.2594916522502899,
0.1098925769329071,
-0.6405014991760254,
-0.088777095079422,
0.1927129626274109,
-0.3146568238735199,
-0.5658326745033264,
0.1523190438747406,
0.024261094629764557,
0.8314433693885803,
0.370344340801239,
-0.8347973823547363,
-0.08199021965265274,
-0.16173657774925232,
0.305073618888855,
0.8155473470687866,
0.1376550793647766,
0.28657007217407227,
-0.15546420216560364,
0.47568219900131226,
0.44528090953826904,
0.24073076248168945,
-0.18146809935569763,
-0.47297531366348267,
-0.5830742120742798,
-0.20729175209999084,
-0.15306316316127777,
0.5724177360534668,
-0.46565911173820496,
0.6030474305152893,
0.08490733057260513,
-0.2866939604282379,
-0.7145934700965881,
-0.127129465341568,
0.6125935912132263,
0.5448936820030212,
0.4206356406211853,
-0.09267723560333252,
-0.47535696625709534,
-0.7748051881790161,
0.025681504979729652,
0.2662819027900696,
0.1343832165002823,
0.6896805167198181,
0.3808968961238861,
0.04816092550754547,
0.6171027421951294,
-0.5066892504692078,
-0.1156252846121788,
-0.3120841085910797,
0.4206622540950775,
0.17226165533065796,
0.45847684144973755,
0.7247385382652283,
-0.7179270386695862,
-0.2854536473751068,
-0.016889121383428574,
-0.762406051158905,
-0.2698494493961334,
0.13453251123428345,
-0.5521730184555054,
0.39588090777397156,
0.1388302892446518,
-0.6432406306266785,
0.11472181230783463,
0.8060659766197205,
-0.5059244632720947,
0.7122097611427307,
-0.2216125875711441,
0.4421045184135437,
-1.233908772468567,
0.036571212112903595,
0.31962403655052185,
0.1323523074388504,
-0.547990620136261,
-0.052430856972932816,
0.25210750102996826,
-0.07320623844861984,
-0.3876382112503052,
0.15269307792186737,
-0.38887131214141846,
-0.014664470218122005,
-0.038613926619291306,
0.2146705836057663,
0.20732024312019348,
0.8940848708152771,
-0.20352564752101898,
0.10509984195232391,
0.5100578665733337,
-0.3346244990825653,
0.435945063829422,
0.15939609706401825,
0.01973857916891575,
0.9431315064430237,
-0.3652057647705078,
0.1861976683139801,
-0.3035240173339844,
-0.16519920527935028,
-0.9343716502189636,
-0.09692663699388504,
0.18254774808883667,
-0.4006917178630829,
0.33214136958122253,
-0.1781059354543686,
-0.4389412999153137,
-0.27563565969467163,
-0.2711307406425476,
0.21837015450000763,
0.48028260469436646,
-0.5127372145652771,
0.8642347455024719,
0.37814080715179443,
-0.366781085729599,
-0.5866686701774597,
-0.4435793459415436,
-0.17273733019828796,
-0.6108068823814392,
-0.8219591975212097,
0.4980126917362213,
-0.04497959464788437,
0.05242433026432991,
0.025595424696803093,
-0.09955289959907532,
-0.2001422941684723,
-0.20177115499973297,
0.16573914885520935,
0.23441842198371887,
0.0942935198545456,
0.35100284218788147,
0.11328116059303284,
-0.10145986825227737,
0.3115426301956177,
0.2901807129383087,
0.7342517971992493,
0.0158246960490942,
-0.22993198037147522,
-0.18468408286571503,
0.91395103931427,
0.6440862417221069,
-0.48902416229248047,
0.7695464491844177,
0.9321526288986206,
-0.3878602981567383,
-0.11864988505840302,
-0.6032412648200989,
-0.26383936405181885,
-0.425557404756546,
0.5514675974845886,
-0.3083287477493286,
-0.4914904832839966,
0.6111277937889099,
-0.2936033606529236,
-0.22155067324638367,
0.24426305294036865,
0.4114185571670532,
-0.291092187166214,
0.9800235033035278,
0.6083395481109619,
-0.3929089605808258,
0.7291794419288635,
-0.12048258632421494,
0.21481409668922424,
-1.0992339849472046,
-0.49796009063720703,
-0.32093775272369385,
-0.4590785503387451,
-0.01343663688749075,
-0.09978295862674713,
0.5782213807106018,
0.01159482728689909,
-0.06762547045946121,
0.06869694590568542,
-0.4393328130245209,
0.048113271594047546,
0.6766735315322876,
0.562981367111206,
-0.14290952682495117,
0.12717528641223907,
-0.24976319074630737,
-0.09165501594543457,
-0.3537157475948334,
-0.030582748353481293,
0.7677153944969177,
-0.031610071659088135,
0.3599664270877838,
0.24526436626911163,
0.760470449924469,
0.2633637487888336,
-0.3194778263568878,
-0.602636456489563,
0.4335295855998993,
-0.19168493151664734,
-0.4901740550994873,
-0.23356711864471436,
-0.2532065510749817,
-0.7593567371368408,
0.31192144751548767,
-0.33619001507759094,
-1.186200737953186,
0.07184316962957382,
0.04889201745390892,
-0.01419185008853674,
0.27749595046043396,
-0.9120455980300903,
1.0320765972137451,
-0.2791458070278168,
-0.2549506723880768,
-0.43348056077957153,
-0.8153093457221985,
0.4310927987098694,
-0.005958791822195053,
0.3534773886203766,
-0.18218013644218445,
0.5134709477424622,
0.7386724352836609,
-0.4725768268108368,
0.7725537419319153,
-0.5067945122718811,
-0.06658941507339478,
0.2739355266094208,
-0.025958193466067314,
0.7415199279785156,
-0.3133907914161682,
-0.3149884343147278,
0.16443373262882233,
-0.16952632367610931,
-0.299608439207077,
-0.6546560525894165,
0.5156573057174683,
-0.6734192371368408,
-0.32066190242767334,
0.17557726800441742,
-0.5965673327445984,
0.011529973708093166,
-0.0878181904554367,
0.17878815531730652,
0.5372422933578491,
0.14962778985500336,
-0.003036169335246086,
0.34251368045806885,
-0.33863359689712524,
0.8744882941246033,
0.48015296459198,
0.25272199511528015,
-0.4010588824748993,
0.8860887289047241,
-0.08135116100311279,
0.313070684671402,
0.394006609916687,
0.2712152898311615,
0.0019626221619546413,
0.16975685954093933,
-0.21272534132003784,
0.08790601789951324,
-0.4127359688282013,
-0.16946406662464142,
-0.8264413475990295,
-0.023351015523076057,
-0.18082083761692047,
-0.08405869454145432,
-0.28578197956085205,
-0.12384434789419174,
0.04874393716454506,
-0.04644425958395004,
0.48817285895347595,
0.21224121749401093,
-0.12072642892599106,
0.24861851334571838,
-0.9189646244049072,
0.5127964019775391,
0.13578839600086212,
0.0952836200594902,
0.11441325396299362,
-0.10655800998210907,
-0.293028324842453,
-0.23210379481315613,
-0.43677428364753723,
-1.241480827331543,
0.7753951549530029,
0.07476546615362167,
0.5452432036399841,
0.4135209321975708,
0.0745130106806755,
0.7536956071853638,
-0.23073618113994598,
0.6358011960983276,
0.39571988582611084,
-1.2214478254318237,
0.6308244466781616,
-0.27075108885765076,
-0.17674803733825684,
-0.16096365451812744,
0.15430408716201782,
-0.6875970959663391,
-0.24186104536056519,
-0.727999210357666,
-1.1271450519561768,
1.0473278760910034,
0.22917930781841278,
-0.11241525411605835,
-0.0748085081577301,
0.2661501467227936,
0.09623982012271881,
0.10871873795986176,
-0.9108452200889587,
-0.290120005607605,
-0.07161850482225418,
-0.4578133821487427,
0.28043296933174133,
-0.5166323781013489,
-0.02965633012354374,
-0.05396227911114693,
0.6113051176071167,
-0.057194702327251434,
0.7798036336898804,
0.2905232608318329,
-0.10156797617673874,
-0.38418298959732056,
0.47539836168289185,
0.21171684563159943,
-0.036803826689720154,
-0.3928045928478241,
0.08074408024549484,
0.16097423434257507,
-0.010191897861659527,
0.0069424305111169815,
0.09085804969072342,
0.20357418060302734,
-0.06708645075559616,
0.21145208179950714,
0.597202718257904,
0.13001732528209686,
-0.4582383632659912,
0.8620463013648987,
0.30517858266830444,
0.06724309176206589,
-0.1810075044631958,
-0.09287160634994507,
0.3732254207134247,
0.44120603799819946,
0.16406367719173431,
0.03825781121850014,
0.3240269124507904,
-0.44791799783706665,
0.27303197979927063,
0.5694295167922974,
-0.2720530927181244,
-0.526226282119751,
0.3103308081626892,
0.2630135715007782,
-0.15497107803821564,
0.48914507031440735,
-0.4152531921863556,
-0.5768990516662598,
1.0529239177703857,
0.6836689710617065,
0.6972405314445496,
-0.4499680697917938,
0.21106034517288208,
0.3924387991428375,
0.14979828894138336,
0.22229549288749695,
0.8720743656158447,
-0.08758483082056046,
-0.933593213558197,
-0.4284859001636505,
-0.354905366897583,
-0.22560015320777893,
0.058881379663944244,
-0.9360532760620117,
0.37607142329216003,
0.2105829268693924,
0.04069817066192627,
-0.2947782874107361,
-0.12235748767852783,
-0.6236010193824768,
0.21723030507564545,
0.3184981942176819,
0.2781849801540375,
-1.1098675727844238,
0.8178675770759583,
0.7526903748512268,
-0.4123286008834839,
-0.7557361721992493,
-0.20273776352405548,
0.1506289392709732,
-0.8042721152305603,
0.48457038402557373,
0.36355531215667725,
0.16439701616764069,
-0.2574068605899811,
-0.3699060082435608,
-0.665267288684845,
1.1485522985458374,
0.17198117077350616,
-0.6492651104927063,
0.05696806684136391,
-0.16242928802967072,
0.30434200167655945,
-0.4667453467845917,
0.3315792381763458,
0.268989235162735,
0.31036823987960815,
-0.08452799916267395,
-0.659757137298584,
0.2921026349067688,
-0.5897024869918823,
-0.6001033782958984,
0.5382177829742432,
-0.7948899865150452,
1.0146477222442627,
-0.046767428517341614,
0.15926508605480194,
-0.4894450008869171,
0.013348367065191269,
0.4036884307861328,
0.3676307499408722,
0.5948220491409302,
0.6038889288902283,
0.6913208365440369,
0.020177684724330902,
0.8268240690231323,
-0.5955383777618408,
0.5448022484779358,
0.9382047057151794,
-0.2382841259241104,
0.7910742163658142,
0.5554821491241455,
-0.11516740918159485,
0.5764449238777161,
0.4245736002922058,
0.08784482628107071,
0.5912650227546692,
-0.1431904286146164,
-0.37060609459877014,
-0.17276455461978912,
0.02905789390206337,
-0.22495613992214203,
0.3422210216522217,
0.5587784647941589,
-0.5265519618988037,
-0.07847890257835388,
-0.10887579619884491,
0.2018231600522995,
-0.6300980448722839,
-0.2403501570224762,
0.7133436799049377,
-0.034225091338157654,
-0.480949729681015,
0.02060011588037014,
-0.08721637725830078,
0.9038459658622742,
-0.4998949468135834,
0.03867131844162941,
-0.17031697928905487,
-0.10237115621566772,
-0.42487677931785583,
-0.4067882299423218,
0.2406320720911026,
-0.07592878490686417,
-0.27979835867881775,
0.1321064680814743,
0.835812509059906,
-0.6320508122444153,
-0.42759454250335693,
0.7451104521751404,
0.7191707491874695,
0.17146652936935425,
-0.2717365622520447,
-0.6461693644523621,
-0.2562822997570038,
-0.07483170181512833,
-0.5365362167358398,
0.35403236746788025,
0.8690254092216492,
0.22600716352462769,
0.20963527262210846,
0.5315747857093811,
0.11166796088218689,
0.11028403788805008,
0.3454027473926544,
0.7677710056304932,
-0.9501736760139465,
-0.4730111360549927,
-1.067686915397644,
0.9107981324195862,
-0.28559428453445435,
-0.16167794167995453,
0.16489571332931519,
0.1466759741306305,
0.16132846474647522,
-0.14444102346897125,
0.810336709022522,
-0.46640199422836304,
0.19378963112831116,
-0.506567656993866,
0.366117388010025,
-0.7593757510185242,
-0.07210288196802139,
-0.7702407836914062,
-0.7553179860115051,
0.0029780794866383076,
0.265367716550827,
0.036161817610263824,
-0.024967782199382782,
0.8725573420524597,
0.7262363433837891,
-0.113160140812397,
0.02135826088488102,
0.36424070596694946,
0.23772495985031128,
0.3027908504009247,
1.007286548614502,
0.5035345554351807,
-0.37275955080986023,
0.41667529940605164,
-0.3141193091869354,
-0.37931448221206665,
-0.25045451521873474,
-0.9503050446510315,
-0.6355154514312744,
-0.5835925936698914,
-0.4026469886302948,
-0.17707431316375732,
-0.07841028273105621,
0.8680217862129211,
0.7078632116317749,
-0.5679811835289001,
0.15086521208286285,
-0.12290002405643463,
-0.06434288620948792,
-0.39824986457824707,
-0.3257244825363159,
0.5230556130409241,
-0.479793518781662,
-0.6757065057754517,
0.08520087599754333,
0.3533097505569458,
-0.11720210313796997,
0.07315226644277573,
-0.057192929089069366,
-0.25858014822006226,
0.09212112426757812,
0.7251710891723633,
-0.1142740249633789,
-0.6814066767692566,
-0.4399644136428833,
-0.22903642058372498,
0.1406993269920349,
0.30858108401298523,
0.6709916591644287,
-0.30971193313598633,
0.39542922377586365,
0.4419654905796051,
0.211629256606102,
0.37279295921325684,
0.04398973658680916,
0.5607674717903137,
-1.16079580783844,
0.11065388470888138,
-0.3833206593990326,
1.0007976293563843,
0.15351201593875885,
-0.7217546105384827,
0.4411194920539856,
0.2581745386123657,
-0.6514492630958557,
-0.3016335368156433,
0.21982796490192413,
-1.3172857761383057,
-0.12231839448213577,
1.1892913579940796,
-0.4521901309490204,
-0.16690103709697723,
0.11798673123121262,
-0.4232330918312073,
0.5944710969924927,
-0.6062532663345337,
1.1349210739135742,
0.87708979845047,
-0.5542909502983093,
-0.27151697874069214,
-0.3511427938938141,
-0.004420642741024494,
0.633948028087616,
-1.0088964700698853,
-0.07121490687131882,
0.37080827355384827,
0.08652088046073914,
0.08124323934316635,
0.40104594826698303,
-0.21889996528625488,
-0.09601739048957825,
-0.007484386675059795,
0.8083794713020325,
-0.003016944508999586,
-0.08281770348548889,
-0.24704210460186005,
0.4215477406978607,
-0.531984806060791,
-0.36193475127220154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06809v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06809v2
|
Not All Contexts Are Equal: Teaching LLMs Credibility-aware Generation
| 2024-04-10T07:56:26 | 2024-05-09T02:45:33 |
Ruotong Pan, Boxi Cao, Hongyu Lin, Xianpei Han, Jia Zheng, Sirui Wang, Xunliang Cai, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid development of large language models has led to the widespread
adoption of Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), which integrates external
knowledge to alleviate knowledge bottlenecks and mitigate hallucinations.
However, the existing RAG paradigm inevitably suffers from the impact of flawed
information introduced during the retrieval phrase, thereby diminishing the
reliability and correctness of the generated outcomes. In this paper, we
propose Credibility-aware Generation (CAG), a universally applicable framework
designed to mitigate the impact of flawed information in RAG. At its core, CAG
aims to equip models with the ability to discern and process information based
on its credibility. To this end, we propose an innovative data transformation
framework that generates data based on credibility, thereby effectively
endowing models with the capability of CAG. Furthermore, to accurately evaluate
the models' capabilities of CAG, we construct a comprehensive benchmark
covering three critical real-world scenarios. Experimental results demonstrate
that our model can effectively understand and utilize credibility for
generation, significantly outperform other models with retrieval augmentation,
and exhibit resilience against the disruption caused by noisy documents,
thereby maintaining robust performance. Moreover, our model supports customized
credibility, offering a wide range of potential applications.
|
[
-0.026840094476938248,
-0.8260074257850647,
0.5584996938705444,
0.07561284303665161,
-0.14500662684440613,
0.11046150326728821,
-0.011067445389926434,
-0.5077880024909973,
-0.17610254883766174,
0.5683955550193787,
-0.29082489013671875,
-0.37314847111701965,
-0.6277055144309998,
-0.1398053616285324,
-0.805875837802887,
0.9103258848190308,
0.3318400979042053,
0.10168823599815369,
-0.2697290778160095,
0.14003169536590576,
-0.5079294443130493,
-0.4520258903503418,
-0.6404328942298889,
-0.49537041783332825,
0.11481782793998718,
0.31875523924827576,
0.9425983428955078,
0.9136403799057007,
0.273141086101532,
0.15704789757728577,
0.09553582221269608,
0.5971434712409973,
-0.8140134215354919,
0.26747313141822815,
-0.604196310043335,
-0.5983084440231323,
-0.5410858392715454,
0.05228376016020775,
0.6100087761878967,
0.4356098175048828,
-0.3804382383823395,
0.3239540457725525,
0.28398165106773376,
0.37815287709236145,
-0.5911304354667664,
-0.05552258342504501,
-1.299301028251648,
-0.21273422241210938,
-0.20706382393836975,
-0.4454561769962311,
-0.7332516312599182,
-0.4937826991081238,
-0.1494467556476593,
-0.6636233329772949,
0.6453418135643005,
0.14075735211372375,
1.0162218809127808,
0.3494306802749634,
-0.4529372453689575,
-0.36979198455810547,
-0.7114731073379517,
0.6268653869628906,
-0.6300985217094421,
0.4324319660663605,
0.15863974392414093,
0.4696679711341858,
-0.4991355538368225,
-1.0130518674850464,
-0.6204070448875427,
0.11932601034641266,
0.17988650500774384,
0.3379112184047699,
0.1809288114309311,
-0.14713281393051147,
0.1388145089149475,
0.5085663795471191,
-0.2640383541584015,
0.03195280581712723,
0.03205932676792145,
-0.3286374509334564,
0.3995235860347748,
-0.056653253734111786,
-0.045835647732019424,
-0.1349058896303177,
-0.7408905625343323,
-0.1577802300453186,
-0.9830109477043152,
-0.25142189860343933,
0.3730677366256714,
0.5060828328132629,
0.26270627975463867,
0.259488970041275,
-0.015874264761805534,
0.5856537222862244,
0.26172780990600586,
-0.6024560928344727,
-0.10880734026432037,
-0.14510028064250946,
-0.272591769695282,
0.1995784342288971,
0.27623704075813293,
0.2334195077419281,
-0.12060054391622543,
-0.1266472041606903,
-0.2615988850593567,
0.29202204942703247,
0.39916694164276123,
-0.7641242742538452,
0.1357347071170807,
-0.07029586285352707,
-0.2573511004447937,
-0.6761684417724609,
0.10985971987247467,
-0.8245033621788025,
-0.7046381831169128,
-0.2407854199409485,
0.6017365455627441,
-0.25156742334365845,
-0.19816213846206665,
0.20285733044147491,
0.14344415068626404,
0.17980234324932098,
0.2811179459095001,
-0.4777725040912628,
0.04028698429465294,
0.7434408068656921,
0.4689770042896271,
-0.09438269585371017,
0.14028161764144897,
-0.7383126616477966,
0.5473976135253906,
-0.35517650842666626,
0.7487753033638,
-0.2804427444934845,
-0.5680736899375916,
0.1790151447057724,
-0.14216823875904083,
0.2210465520620346,
-0.4862302243709564,
1.0897929668426514,
-0.5671101212501526,
0.14862635731697083,
-0.3144671320915222,
-0.7053940892219543,
-0.03797509893774986,
0.5091433525085449,
-0.4773975908756256,
1.0464752912521362,
0.030239295214414597,
-0.7451226115226746,
0.5450332760810852,
0.04020482674241066,
-0.20772069692611694,
0.03749735280871391,
-0.28223538398742676,
-0.6080448031425476,
0.12684309482574463,
0.17763465642929077,
0.4172293543815613,
-0.46252694725990295,
0.8531659245491028,
-0.07391093671321869,
-0.15462689101696014,
0.16943074762821198,
-0.7830169200897217,
0.3267734944820404,
0.24282808601856232,
-0.3157901465892792,
-0.27493107318878174,
-0.9620562791824341,
0.15254390239715576,
0.06596449762582779,
-0.6474104523658752,
-0.15858282148838043,
-0.05759920924901962,
-0.10023777186870575,
0.09263279289007187,
0.35100045800209045,
-0.3366374671459198,
0.09725461155176163,
-0.3519822955131531,
-0.19780534505844116,
0.8680492639541626,
0.2069534957408905,
0.3617641031742096,
-0.7040072083473206,
0.37635132670402527,
0.11429644376039505,
0.08939623832702637,
-0.26321426033973694,
-0.321581095457077,
-0.8699640035629272,
-0.12673914432525635,
0.3060438632965088,
0.409583181142807,
-0.9957062602043152,
0.18037700653076172,
-0.5900086164474487,
-0.5272290706634521,
-0.4746767580509186,
0.24491357803344727,
0.41711682081222534,
1.16660737991333,
0.3910207450389862,
-0.16267718374729156,
-0.5134255290031433,
-0.8492435216903687,
-0.7061658501625061,
-0.3343258500099182,
0.13539111614227295,
0.26158127188682556,
-0.00417661527171731,
-0.35222291946411133,
0.9628626704216003,
-0.165176123380661,
-0.15082170069217682,
-0.11446075886487961,
0.14531394839286804,
0.09223116934299469,
0.42927542328834534,
0.22749899327754974,
-1.0458271503448486,
-0.22945725917816162,
-0.19836179912090302,
-0.800041675567627,
-0.3174481689929962,
-0.5195910334587097,
-0.20884005725383759,
0.05536013841629028,
0.2152911275625229,
-0.21710167825222015,
0.4321986734867096,
0.5936927199363708,
-0.2779994606971741,
0.5859673023223877,
-0.1581593155860901,
0.27436718344688416,
-1.2603236436843872,
-0.12271204590797424,
-0.1364516168832779,
-0.4212915599346161,
-0.6146045923233032,
0.0888749286532402,
0.16976577043533325,
-0.03603950887918472,
-0.3267453908920288,
0.7196624279022217,
-0.35155755281448364,
-0.10224240273237228,
-0.4054650366306305,
0.3257291913032532,
0.27406346797943115,
-0.16592095792293549,
-0.12346679717302322,
0.6223744750022888,
0.4654606878757477,
-0.8720389008522034,
-0.1455306112766266,
0.23064883053302765,
-0.25964462757110596,
0.8225902318954468,
-0.11678530275821686,
-0.025785060599446297,
-0.05055391788482666,
0.23003926873207092,
-0.49710237979888916,
-0.36983203887939453,
-0.03664505481719971,
-0.6212598085403442,
0.6339952349662781,
-0.1956520527601242,
-0.7784837484359741,
-0.055728133767843246,
0.2038743793964386,
0.17629700899124146,
0.6361976861953735,
-1.2414774894714355,
0.6412916779518127,
0.19815702736377716,
0.20544841885566711,
-0.8957164287567139,
-0.6721857786178589,
0.2632036507129669,
-0.2986621856689453,
-0.745175302028656,
0.4338207244873047,
-0.0806007832288742,
-0.293636292219162,
-0.2571702003479004,
-0.38455185294151306,
0.05237887427210808,
0.06942589581012726,
0.2177632451057434,
0.17094047367572784,
0.0852154940366745,
0.38977912068367004,
0.05446801707148552,
-0.1333022117614746,
-0.08224603533744812,
-0.3269202411174774,
0.1680973619222641,
0.06146874278783798,
-0.4989289939403534,
0.08079968392848969,
-0.05566980689764023,
0.24453124403953552,
-0.11021392047405243,
0.735660970211029,
0.703823447227478,
-0.45720595121383667,
-0.6743547320365906,
-0.9428229331970215,
-0.2603454291820526,
-0.5323234796524048,
0.051660116761922836,
-0.1815308779478073,
-0.7134385108947754,
0.3378845453262329,
-0.6784499287605286,
0.23103748261928558,
0.17405222356319427,
0.43199622631073,
0.27348431944847107,
0.8123742341995239,
0.6784200668334961,
0.24575704336166382,
0.12309475243091583,
0.09571406990289688,
0.2640238404273987,
-0.5680720210075378,
-0.2045711725950241,
-0.37015068531036377,
0.17953161895275116,
-0.34388625621795654,
-0.6401480436325073,
0.31281578540802,
0.5181402564048767,
0.04309410974383354,
0.05243482440710068,
-0.6098872423171997,
0.2047968953847885,
0.21229013800621033,
0.10119780153036118,
0.6736651062965393,
0.11439010500907898,
-0.05528128147125244,
-0.19105002284049988,
-0.8644517064094543,
-0.8869473934173584,
1.2096205949783325,
0.3143972158432007,
0.7803168296813965,
0.08352614939212799,
0.7300810813903809,
0.44503673911094666,
0.7608274221420288,
-0.5113292932510376,
0.6636113524436951,
0.17198649048805237,
-0.8300933837890625,
0.21218079328536987,
-0.5613268613815308,
-0.8600324392318726,
0.22393687069416046,
-0.463468074798584,
-0.34217390418052673,
0.22524312138557434,
0.24448034167289734,
0.07009302824735641,
0.5388023853302002,
-0.3634217083454132,
0.1277223378419876,
-0.24066010117530823,
-0.726558268070221,
-0.17057129740715027,
-0.2031155675649643,
0.7340148091316223,
-0.42838484048843384,
0.6063840985298157,
0.007873190566897392,
0.009055218659341335,
0.37303951382637024,
-0.2928682267665863,
0.6053149700164795,
-0.21693763136863708,
-0.2821769416332245,
0.6609002351760864,
0.42303934693336487,
0.768781304359436,
0.17569494247436523,
-0.39610251784324646,
0.026647310703992844,
-0.4715007543563843,
-0.1270681619644165,
-0.5582625269889832,
0.8369343280792236,
-0.2307186722755432,
-0.8624699711799622,
-0.23432451486587524,
-0.6344864964485168,
-0.4160715937614441,
0.18374483287334442,
0.2141055315732956,
0.31532761454582214,
-0.3520640730857849,
0.09944969415664673,
0.9554623961448669,
-0.18456782400608063,
0.07956589013338089,
0.6733932495117188,
-0.28797420859336853,
-0.33025825023651123,
0.9701440334320068,
0.1821754425764084,
0.4065241515636444,
0.04948640614748001,
0.19806960225105286,
-0.34319743514060974,
-0.45078718662261963,
-0.2691604197025299,
0.17134882509708405,
-0.95828777551651,
-0.4640766382217407,
-0.4142135679721832,
-0.18763650953769684,
-0.5483551025390625,
-0.29684484004974365,
-0.3466901183128357,
-0.4028158485889435,
-0.2921176552772522,
-0.24271583557128906,
0.004179520066827536,
0.4236309230327606,
-0.29173874855041504,
0.30661505460739136,
-0.6482556462287903,
0.3360232710838318,
0.3520207107067108,
0.26951149106025696,
-0.1985633373260498,
-0.7599177956581116,
-0.2803228795528412,
0.03595346957445145,
-0.592242956161499,
-0.7935820817947388,
0.4507409334182739,
0.28811177611351013,
0.779817521572113,
0.4931063652038574,
0.09039125591516495,
0.6266648769378662,
-0.3405599296092987,
0.7648063898086548,
-0.008024071343243122,
-0.867206871509552,
0.5829905271530151,
-0.5770158171653748,
-0.14682132005691528,
0.37501204013824463,
0.07599164545536041,
-0.15358881652355194,
-0.4826452136039734,
-1.0850896835327148,
-0.7894960045814514,
0.14110933244228363,
0.16586317121982574,
-0.04231666773557663,
-0.2898734211921692,
0.7341564297676086,
0.32173094153404236,
0.20639847218990326,
-0.7707895040512085,
-0.1857464611530304,
-0.31357112526893616,
-0.1791687309741974,
0.1153498962521553,
-0.26685452461242676,
-0.1178220584988594,
0.29567062854766846,
1.0935208797454834,
-0.33522093296051025,
-0.06160656362771988,
0.3789605498313904,
-0.0873313695192337,
-0.05637723580002785,
0.46703314781188965,
0.24057146906852722,
0.6567862629890442,
0.10754252970218658,
0.16376742720603943,
0.12168484181165695,
-0.30618008971214294,
0.21487300097942352,
-0.057760924100875854,
-0.4769026041030884,
0.09302845597267151,
0.11876334249973297,
0.07310404628515244,
0.278948575258255,
-0.5152183771133423,
0.37775719165802,
0.064429372549057,
-0.03940386325120926,
-0.28633207082748413,
0.3564557433128357,
0.0383521169424057,
0.19017505645751953,
0.6114743947982788,
0.05319342389702797,
0.09836041927337646,
-0.34563499689102173,
0.47413480281829834,
0.43422427773475647,
-0.11566916108131409,
-0.007876735180616379,
0.9567915797233582,
0.08133681863546371,
-0.1308102309703827,
0.12570379674434662,
-0.14904966950416565,
-0.3242359161376953,
0.3757792115211487,
0.8579990863800049,
0.6163694858551025,
-0.3885018229484558,
0.17296183109283447,
0.6896733641624451,
0.2637304365634918,
-0.6786961555480957,
0.028808889910578728,
0.013936378993093967,
-0.9556533694267273,
-0.11750958114862442,
-0.8301836252212524,
-0.3575557768344879,
0.10094442218542099,
-0.7505051493644714,
0.2745608389377594,
-0.554686427116394,
-0.4882151484489441,
-0.5498420596122742,
-0.18886730074882507,
-0.5898700952529907,
0.6057183742523193,
0.13233667612075806,
0.8478072285652161,
-0.6185796856880188,
0.7338790893554688,
0.30685171484947205,
-0.12040847539901733,
-0.7088894248008728,
0.0005800802609883249,
0.16990679502487183,
-0.8025326132774353,
0.47108590602874756,
0.09579065442085266,
-0.27216285467147827,
0.13322852551937103,
-0.8721293807029724,
-0.7425197958946228,
1.4083768129348755,
0.5117107629776001,
-0.3716813325881958,
0.15760065615177155,
0.2061447948217392,
0.42375701665878296,
-0.557067334651947,
-0.22141601145267487,
0.39163368940353394,
0.46430182456970215,
0.20035526156425476,
-0.6547443866729736,
0.10346957296133041,
0.1123882383108139,
0.034557126462459564,
-0.20479309558868408,
-0.6851257085800171,
0.6517814993858337,
-0.07823456823825836,
-0.6615637540817261,
0.16688069701194763,
0.7720544338226318,
0.6624245643615723,
0.4130115509033203,
0.3812951445579529,
0.7508970499038696,
1.0968904495239258,
-0.22362501919269562,
0.982001543045044,
-0.2715975344181061,
0.15213128924369812,
1.4538099765777588,
-0.041007254272699356,
0.6197561025619507,
0.2357868105173111,
0.3636015057563782,
0.5502811670303345,
0.2691834568977356,
0.01829349622130394,
0.1822299361228943,
0.0871637836098671,
-0.43429192900657654,
-0.5625418424606323,
-0.40538662672042847,
-0.4005435109138489,
0.3698127567768097,
0.5664541721343994,
-0.725307047367096,
-0.35435980558395386,
-0.19044923782348633,
0.17306391894817352,
0.6668552160263062,
-0.4542314112186432,
0.4431523084640503,
0.07611814886331558,
-0.5883640646934509,
0.4764634966850281,
0.04359249770641327,
0.6011500358581543,
-0.5269272923469543,
-0.14817501604557037,
-0.08667513728141785,
0.32554617524147034,
-0.35153084993362427,
-0.5887337923049927,
0.13221946358680725,
-0.0280710831284523,
-0.24668526649475098,
-0.4110866189002991,
1.1878474950790405,
-0.5111702680587769,
-0.4395420253276825,
0.16517679393291473,
0.6002132892608643,
0.05549201741814613,
0.19031569361686707,
-0.5899149775505066,
0.08428089320659637,
0.07265365868806839,
-0.18865220248699188,
0.39311957359313965,
0.5963047742843628,
0.0871918722987175,
0.9447891116142273,
0.8398070931434631,
0.22491709887981415,
0.07484669983386993,
0.06439342349767685,
0.6299293041229248,
-0.2906878888607025,
-0.4086570143699646,
-0.4501678943634033,
0.6770787835121155,
-0.2407563030719757,
0.1875111609697342,
1.12455153465271,
0.6077349781990051,
0.7162655591964722,
0.2218918651342392,
0.8618302345275879,
0.28351473808288574,
0.7851753830909729,
-0.3791256546974182,
0.8734905123710632,
-0.37479978799819946,
0.6235421895980835,
-0.21494634449481964,
-1.030853271484375,
-0.1490657776594162,
0.29299256205558777,
-0.041869644075632095,
0.04192317649722099,
0.24642299115657806,
0.9893980622291565,
0.07092501223087311,
-0.09593214094638824,
0.6388790607452393,
0.333476185798645,
0.7150932550430298,
0.17502383887767792,
0.5427361726760864,
-0.7743672728538513,
0.6071237325668335,
0.1841706931591034,
-0.23779931664466858,
0.1036471500992775,
-1.0805078744888306,
-0.639005184173584,
-0.42443251609802246,
-0.2975175082683563,
-0.6824526190757751,
0.0818677693605423,
0.31232815980911255,
0.5886611342430115,
-0.22161537408828735,
0.22001589834690094,
-0.21063421666622162,
0.12763437628746033,
0.09464366734027863,
-0.29167062044143677,
0.17073886096477509,
-0.40952423214912415,
-0.47697943449020386,
0.6996389031410217,
0.06834282726049423,
0.25395408272743225,
-0.3924618661403656,
-0.07567021995782852,
0.11176947504281998,
0.5487135052680969,
0.29355064034461975,
0.30838513374328613,
-0.5789905190467834,
-0.4343976080417633,
-0.305746465921402,
-0.14021769165992737,
-0.043833017349243164,
0.6891260743141174,
-1.1263208389282227,
0.7356762290000916,
0.09985679388046265,
0.8809991478919983,
0.3138367831707001,
0.48937803506851196,
0.49213528633117676,
-0.8961673974990845,
-0.047132015228271484,
0.07760690152645111,
0.21690978109836578,
0.7750598788261414,
-0.7099778056144714,
0.6080964207649231,
0.3276016414165497,
-0.7604267001152039,
-1.0107673406600952,
0.3893704116344452,
-0.6886399388313293,
-0.06081788241863251,
1.2848455905914307,
-0.11803621053695679,
-0.01702173613011837,
-0.13477809727191925,
0.07414628565311432,
0.38996458053588867,
-0.13366715610027313,
1.1402777433395386,
0.5348527431488037,
0.18817603588104248,
0.07817740738391876,
-0.40262311697006226,
0.5448565483093262,
0.31336623430252075,
-0.8476199507713318,
0.09597242623567581,
0.5445631146430969,
0.2623213529586792,
0.2570585012435913,
0.39107033610343933,
-0.4359941780567169,
0.09836122393608093,
0.20751304924488068,
0.10784228146076202,
-0.1358688324689865,
-0.3091513216495514,
-0.1237117126584053,
0.3200613558292389,
0.06952220946550369,
0.43253740668296814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06762v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06762v1
|
Personality-aware Student Simulation for Conversational Intelligent Tutoring Systems
| 2024-04-10T06:03:13 | 2024-04-10T06:03:13 |
Zhengyuan Liu, Stella Xin Yin, Geyu Lin, Nancy F. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Intelligent Tutoring Systems (ITSs) can provide personalized and self-paced
learning experience. The emergence of large language models (LLMs) further
enables better human-machine interaction, and facilitates the development of
conversational ITSs in various disciplines such as math and language learning.
In dialogic teaching, recognizing and adapting to individual characteristics
can significantly enhance student engagement and learning efficiency. However,
characterizing and simulating student's persona remain challenging in training
and evaluating conversational ITSs. In this work, we propose a framework to
construct profiles of different student groups by refining and integrating both
cognitive and noncognitive aspects, and leverage LLMs for personality-aware
student simulation in a language learning scenario. We further enhance the
framework with multi-aspect validation, and conduct extensive analysis from
both teacher and student perspectives. Our experimental results show that
state-of-the-art LLMs can produce diverse student responses according to the
given language ability and personality traits, and trigger teacher's adaptive
scaffolding strategies.
|
[
-0.5221100449562073,
-0.8860989212989807,
0.507466733455658,
0.5724642872810364,
0.1405756026506424,
0.4082273244857788,
-0.40833836793899536,
-0.04243508353829384,
0.20555910468101501,
0.4671207070350647,
-0.5406754016876221,
-0.267171174287796,
-0.04894892871379852,
0.011666988953948021,
-0.3315596580505371,
1.050294280052185,
0.23474371433258057,
0.5464929342269897,
-0.6703489422798157,
-0.12295956909656525,
-0.5847469568252563,
-0.8811255097389221,
-0.7866271138191223,
-0.4801720082759857,
0.2543797791004181,
0.6206536293029785,
0.13990998268127441,
0.29218000173568726,
0.0149418069049716,
0.3690081238746643,
0.21963046491146088,
-0.30351367592811584,
0.03300653025507927,
0.31211045384407043,
-0.5094404220581055,
-0.38576504588127136,
-0.3999280333518982,
-0.15873941779136658,
0.9329091310501099,
0.8449503779411316,
-0.22379472851753235,
0.02278083749115467,
0.21537470817565918,
0.44965916872024536,
-0.15222986042499542,
0.2679327428340912,
-0.44789305329322815,
0.04792759194970131,
-0.03495580330491066,
0.1314719319343567,
-0.4659847915172577,
-0.30307283997535706,
0.4984646439552307,
-0.2956404387950897,
0.19801384210586548,
0.004642677493393421,
0.10832616686820984,
-0.032954491674900055,
-0.4366895258426666,
-0.16461864113807678,
-0.8383879065513611,
0.8101933002471924,
-0.5478498339653015,
0.291037917137146,
0.10263770073652267,
0.6961378455162048,
-0.09834634512662888,
-0.11629321426153183,
-0.6189656257629395,
-0.20845988392829895,
0.07538525015115738,
0.34492382407188416,
0.32353219389915466,
0.06459508836269379,
0.14625881612300873,
0.2505562901496887,
-0.3978084623813629,
0.4173339903354645,
-0.23688654601573944,
-0.11785772442817688,
0.5717453956604004,
0.4062373638153076,
0.015585287474095821,
-0.28083980083465576,
-0.3168150782585144,
-0.2114405333995819,
-0.33811914920806885,
0.3222504258155823,
0.7434714436531067,
0.43624404072761536,
-0.2764264643192291,
0.42057764530181885,
-0.21947616338729858,
0.3052775263786316,
0.11534345895051956,
-0.5474449396133423,
0.059903573244810104,
-0.05187463015317917,
0.035478170961141586,
0.05503816530108452,
0.6451836228370667,
0.16301821172237396,
0.5957820415496826,
-0.009081183932721615,
0.14175449311733246,
0.017685607075691223,
0.2191094309091568,
-0.9921166300773621,
-0.31990382075309753,
0.5395392179489136,
-0.07881136983633041,
-0.19452957808971405,
-0.32108455896377563,
-0.9749109148979187,
-0.39498576521873474,
-0.4588974714279175,
0.16721835732460022,
-0.8614184260368347,
-0.36980289220809937,
0.03567212447524071,
0.27898767590522766,
0.17404738068580627,
0.5782882571220398,
-0.7836127281188965,
0.3256431519985199,
0.3101794123649597,
0.37086212635040283,
-0.3353964388370514,
-0.471482515335083,
-0.19528250396251678,
0.17804305255413055,
0.13579463958740234,
0.771260678768158,
-0.7389718294143677,
-0.6579189896583557,
-0.03135579451918602,
-0.2719079852104187,
-0.3002391457557678,
-0.39654025435447693,
-0.027843914926052094,
-0.14685873687267303,
0.447043240070343,
-0.2475062608718872,
-0.7920324206352234,
-0.25789645314216614,
0.37116938829421997,
-0.1959908902645111,
0.8877081871032715,
0.409201055765152,
-0.4013673961162567,
-0.1893037110567093,
-0.6912506222724915,
-0.36890631914138794,
0.18787699937820435,
-0.4065254330635071,
-0.43180325627326965,
-0.03489794209599495,
-0.04142775014042854,
0.7071774005889893,
-0.008518987335264683,
0.5578068494796753,
-0.23240689933300018,
-0.13413502275943756,
0.6376762390136719,
-0.1362740844488144,
0.4735674560070038,
-0.12746763229370117,
-0.11781828850507736,
0.4047577679157257,
-0.7118161916732788,
0.19889363646507263,
0.08168351650238037,
-0.24557359516620636,
-0.03466319665312767,
-0.058571651577949524,
0.14060157537460327,
0.16646979749202728,
0.16061347723007202,
-0.4745241701602936,
0.3577295243740082,
-0.10966596007347107,
0.39503344893455505,
0.8952728509902954,
0.07245637476444244,
0.4159204363822937,
-0.37643250823020935,
0.5561837553977966,
0.31204038858413696,
-0.06709390133619308,
-0.5204743146896362,
-0.2787621021270752,
-0.8656931519508362,
-0.5797101259231567,
0.16795840859413147,
0.6984642744064331,
-0.7841988205909729,
0.4172699451446533,
-0.1319262534379959,
-0.4845402240753174,
-0.1542324274778366,
0.15371881425380707,
0.40814438462257385,
0.47604236006736755,
0.1753571629524231,
-0.3876661956310272,
-0.4539070725440979,
-0.8289191722869873,
-0.20378153026103973,
-0.3987118899822235,
-0.08858384937047958,
0.5789059400558472,
0.5279661417007446,
-0.050449058413505554,
1.088945746421814,
-0.18301190435886383,
-0.36784952878952026,
-0.5740771889686584,
-0.23462095856666565,
-0.24681831896305084,
0.7258493304252625,
0.8049667477607727,
-0.3379162549972534,
-0.6987536549568176,
-0.3101060688495636,
-0.6039089560508728,
0.01755419559776783,
-0.40903282165527344,
0.03540891781449318,
0.08679628372192383,
0.2532108426094055,
-0.1887119859457016,
0.3097432851791382,
0.2563849091529846,
-0.2125684767961502,
0.876292884349823,
-0.24954137206077576,
-0.03546923026442528,
-1.075958251953125,
-0.15393231809139252,
0.24837617576122284,
-0.19969148933887482,
-0.5919405221939087,
-0.07752706110477448,
0.0019684466533362865,
-0.14232145249843597,
-0.30175408720970154,
0.8116229772567749,
-0.08281122893095016,
-0.2552938163280487,
-0.19704577326774597,
0.26391837000846863,
-0.02139301225543022,
0.8670476675033569,
0.11371934413909912,
0.9897834062576294,
0.7920532822608948,
-0.4882366955280304,
0.1818179339170456,
0.22274842858314514,
-0.3728625774383545,
1.3275177478790283,
-0.6208316683769226,
0.09566021710634232,
-0.13632816076278687,
0.41386640071868896,
-0.7296528220176697,
-0.2664810121059418,
-0.07550109177827835,
-0.05086684226989746,
-0.011245692148804665,
0.08105171471834183,
-0.5472226142883301,
-0.1106448546051979,
-0.1900748759508133,
0.308851957321167,
0.2725376784801483,
-0.4527758061885834,
1.1966263055801392,
0.02378029376268387,
-0.3988235890865326,
0.04749111831188202,
-0.10501472651958466,
0.009247533977031708,
-0.34664130210876465,
-0.40234896540641785,
0.3826444447040558,
-0.5466400384902954,
-0.3252262473106384,
-0.43591681122779846,
0.19094353914260864,
0.006912323646247387,
0.30342715978622437,
0.27281907200813293,
0.26841971278190613,
0.04281207174062729,
0.08741920441389084,
0.13769210875034332,
0.0514354333281517,
0.07593395560979843,
-0.1059170812368393,
0.7406325340270996,
-0.4267803132534027,
-0.5671390295028687,
-0.5942273736000061,
0.5325682759284973,
0.6019896268844604,
-0.31448256969451904,
0.6868783235549927,
0.450630784034729,
-0.14234216511249542,
-0.21277371048927307,
-0.640651285648346,
-0.5411790609359741,
-0.5059880018234253,
0.6434186697006226,
-0.4381251633167267,
-0.940926194190979,
0.9345630407333374,
-0.12077683210372925,
0.12545597553253174,
-0.284583181142807,
0.5600754022598267,
-0.17854347825050354,
1.0558722019195557,
0.6431424021720886,
0.03205361217260361,
0.7582291960716248,
-0.03874306380748749,
0.3617142140865326,
-1.0810632705688477,
-0.5999811291694641,
-0.4389723241329193,
-0.07506506145000458,
-0.24681630730628967,
-0.2968881130218506,
0.2785017788410187,
-0.029693974182009697,
-0.42791661620140076,
0.10501018166542053,
-0.17167823016643524,
0.4104860723018646,
0.46981027722358704,
0.08128240704536438,
0.06232457607984543,
-0.01932353712618351,
-0.3171636164188385,
-0.2936679720878601,
-0.16912655532360077,
-0.6343681812286377,
1.0159918069839478,
0.27534475922584534,
0.4550984799861908,
0.2824634611606598,
0.34493130445480347,
-0.07805158942937851,
0.5472474694252014,
-0.8263692855834961,
0.8930477499961853,
0.00034494561259634793,
-0.6072412133216858,
-0.09486810863018036,
-0.30970874428749084,
-0.43277105689048767,
0.2509199380874634,
-0.24196381866931915,
-1.1718274354934692,
-0.3326050639152527,
0.03016206994652748,
-0.32553669810295105,
0.2109992504119873,
-0.7082118391990662,
0.5686530470848083,
-0.3676266372203827,
-0.32587024569511414,
-0.17077159881591797,
-0.4098771810531616,
0.07832739502191544,
-0.2265988141298294,
0.04976290836930275,
-0.09782852977514267,
0.3614045977592468,
0.6231900453567505,
-0.1516055166721344,
1.0654845237731934,
-0.18789298832416534,
0.015568161383271217,
0.2805836796760559,
0.3432829976081848,
0.12462567538022995,
0.25534477829933167,
-0.296723335981369,
-0.036993563175201416,
0.2045769840478897,
-0.523545503616333,
-0.835850179195404,
0.648533821105957,
-0.8583828806877136,
-0.9531885385513306,
-0.2624334394931793,
-0.7666603326797485,
-0.6117720007896423,
-0.02137313038110733,
-0.34191611409187317,
0.17765678465366364,
-0.3136795163154602,
0.08301039040088654,
0.7278252840042114,
-0.18242710828781128,
0.41714081168174744,
0.8498579263687134,
-0.6435962319374084,
-0.14640730619430542,
1.0912607908248901,
0.05574227124452591,
0.3261811137199402,
-0.20958606898784637,
0.31351837515830994,
-0.16823071241378784,
-0.4947185218334198,
-0.527218759059906,
0.26106444001197815,
-0.7303025126457214,
0.20429196953773499,
-0.7326674461364746,
-0.302867591381073,
-0.44743382930755615,
-0.2658681571483612,
-0.3433859348297119,
-0.18838323652744293,
-0.2419750839471817,
-0.019541410729289055,
0.26635363698005676,
0.5244324803352356,
0.4746050536632538,
0.9188863039016724,
-0.327884316444397,
-0.3217458128929138,
0.5300152897834778,
0.2979350984096527,
0.14568859338760376,
-0.4667517840862274,
-0.0002171700616599992,
-0.07916201651096344,
-0.5029903650283813,
-0.603766143321991,
0.2668764591217041,
0.35781168937683105,
0.7319296002388,
0.6994377970695496,
-0.1507749706506729,
0.4655103385448456,
-0.47466421127319336,
0.7948405146598816,
0.06753446161746979,
-0.9886224865913391,
0.5408328771591187,
-0.3090898096561432,
0.1563454121351242,
0.5057074427604675,
0.030536077916622162,
-0.5428255796432495,
-0.3981001377105713,
-0.5498000383377075,
-0.4874851107597351,
0.49217358231544495,
-0.01357207726687193,
0.4209122061729431,
0.21629759669303894,
0.6359586119651794,
0.2518671452999115,
0.335958331823349,
-0.6463399529457092,
-0.3173624873161316,
-0.4553644359111786,
-0.6950803995132446,
0.1054190993309021,
0.061033137142658234,
0.0069810193963348866,
-0.2830672860145569,
0.6522798538208008,
-0.6423535943031311,
0.11512238532304764,
-0.19872966408729553,
0.16179880499839783,
0.3853674530982971,
0.275293231010437,
0.41808992624282837,
0.38225388526916504,
-0.05847454071044922,
-0.12188531458377838,
0.22768931090831757,
-0.41795745491981506,
0.033369552344083786,
-0.20362457633018494,
0.1394004374742508,
-0.3685959279537201,
0.058539729565382004,
0.6828828454017639,
0.42734405398368835,
-0.8698378801345825,
0.5432571768760681,
-0.35128849744796753,
-0.027432942762970924,
-0.616378664970398,
0.5254833102226257,
0.12001964449882507,
0.5019770264625549,
0.33234089612960815,
0.029084498062729836,
-0.19758592545986176,
-0.4992648661136627,
-0.08006341755390167,
0.5473629832267761,
-0.2712962329387665,
-0.6463569402694702,
0.24290266633033752,
0.23319318890571594,
-0.6210963726043701,
0.39985305070877075,
-0.043852753937244415,
-0.6804854869842529,
0.7114007472991943,
0.7533043622970581,
0.6315256953239441,
-0.5729567408561707,
0.35204556584358215,
0.20929542183876038,
-0.1749676764011383,
0.19080814719200134,
0.2473260760307312,
-0.17576199769973755,
-0.7816939353942871,
-0.07666274905204773,
-0.4764770567417145,
-0.9241043925285339,
0.01119597814977169,
-0.6802961826324463,
0.21867622435092926,
-0.8818686604499817,
0.061937298625707626,
0.012079330161213875,
-0.004094349220395088,
-0.735255241394043,
0.19393569231033325,
-0.05793039873242378,
0.6361563205718994,
-0.7506793737411499,
0.9951037168502808,
1.073446273803711,
0.0029634167440235615,
-0.6892654299736023,
-0.07266531884670258,
-0.06517069786787033,
-0.679614245891571,
0.5899306535720825,
0.27889391779899597,
0.12389033287763596,
0.1426447480916977,
-0.32406607270240784,
-0.6133002638816833,
1.0565178394317627,
0.41289663314819336,
-0.21186263859272003,
-0.08438816666603088,
0.31628653407096863,
0.5389217138290405,
-0.793698787689209,
0.5266937613487244,
0.2407982498407364,
0.06252247840166092,
0.337197482585907,
-0.6969520449638367,
-0.30739831924438477,
-0.0019933907315135,
0.2534045875072479,
-0.48508694767951965,
-0.9307875633239746,
0.9073283076286316,
-0.12196970731019974,
-0.01247922983020544,
0.1932353675365448,
0.7968720197677612,
0.5174906849861145,
0.1366836428642273,
0.6140052080154419,
0.2396257370710373,
0.8019870519638062,
-0.049280960112810135,
0.6234440207481384,
-0.5840997099876404,
0.11456931382417679,
1.1082241535186768,
-0.6244583129882812,
0.6370738744735718,
0.5717949867248535,
-0.2357751429080963,
0.8631499409675598,
0.49926838278770447,
0.11182332783937454,
0.1747862845659256,
0.2748739421367645,
-0.4567507207393646,
-0.5011700987815857,
-0.19132466614246368,
-0.04962702840566635,
0.6801589131355286,
0.512431800365448,
-0.047466304153203964,
-0.055260468274354935,
0.5067442655563354,
0.13478916883468628,
0.27523472905158997,
-0.18088974058628082,
0.6157314777374268,
-0.13984784483909607,
-0.6780242919921875,
-0.142219677567482,
0.09349960088729858,
0.6750161051750183,
-0.5619115233421326,
0.23577781021595,
-0.22806303203105927,
0.24873022735118866,
-0.02212895266711712,
-0.6996994018554688,
-0.09946244955062866,
-0.06423494964838028,
-0.1597113460302353,
-0.29993948340415955,
0.34690773487091064,
-0.47257333993911743,
-0.507546067237854,
0.0792044922709465,
0.6289430856704712,
0.1530744433403015,
0.08484238386154175,
-0.6068671345710754,
-0.16721273958683014,
0.00008594014070695266,
-0.2541862428188324,
0.700333833694458,
0.27888965606689453,
-0.27963337302207947,
1.02657151222229,
0.5506991744041443,
-0.24446721374988556,
-0.2303066998720169,
0.29557088017463684,
0.7985694408416748,
-0.4731777310371399,
-0.6841599345207214,
-0.6074850559234619,
0.49874788522720337,
-0.07481637597084045,
-0.3323644697666168,
0.9736644625663757,
0.3867914378643036,
0.7931877970695496,
0.0049192337319254875,
0.7673020958900452,
0.27581098675727844,
0.4324793815612793,
-0.269815057516098,
0.4207903742790222,
-0.07641749829053879,
0.4846235513687134,
-0.3842911422252655,
-0.8450712561607361,
0.08929688483476639,
0.8885483741760254,
-0.3032718002796173,
0.45346808433532715,
0.5322508215904236,
0.4789189100265503,
0.17994272708892822,
0.5670976042747498,
0.28036409616470337,
-0.022683927789330482,
0.6801309585571289,
0.3985235095024109,
0.6815605759620667,
0.025007352232933044,
0.056379709392786026,
-0.49567103385925293,
-0.32742348313331604,
-0.25977733731269836,
-0.8100684881210327,
-1.483291506767273,
-0.6297298073768616,
-0.5769374966621399,
-0.2397356927394867,
-0.27051347494125366,
0.976318359375,
0.6618958711624146,
-0.7684101462364197,
-0.3202429711818695,
0.10208053886890411,
0.058335546404123306,
0.006005267612636089,
-0.29873430728912354,
0.09254970401525497,
-0.18301264941692352,
-0.9321091175079346,
0.19529452919960022,
0.2221231758594513,
0.5049878358840942,
-1.001986026763916,
0.09141280502080917,
0.1886054426431656,
0.33402660489082336,
0.5506472587585449,
0.09995392709970474,
-0.6006854176521301,
-0.6201590299606323,
0.2499772161245346,
-0.131468266248703,
0.04941534996032715,
0.810163676738739,
-1.0344938039779663,
0.2600027620792389,
-0.205078586935997,
0.6079902052879333,
0.2920394837856293,
-0.1303786337375641,
0.2531352937221527,
-0.9442888498306274,
0.18527095019817352,
0.2016833871603012,
0.34313687682151794,
0.5412524342536926,
-0.4551777243614197,
0.057767704129219055,
0.196186825633049,
-0.4530356228351593,
-0.816754162311554,
0.30563777685165405,
-0.9715376496315002,
-0.1461540013551712,
0.8862470984458923,
-0.49135488271713257,
-0.07687349617481232,
-0.18196003139019012,
-0.32283371686935425,
-0.0895068496465683,
-0.4307079315185547,
0.9223688840866089,
0.7628982663154602,
-0.47640255093574524,
-0.14664959907531738,
-0.46635347604751587,
0.046943262219429016,
0.6861581802368164,
-1.0394788980484009,
-0.059049900621175766,
0.2509748041629791,
0.5800787210464478,
0.2522035837173462,
0.46674033999443054,
0.12096992135047913,
-0.1392107456922531,
-0.4289955794811249,
0.15044796466827393,
-0.06556908786296844,
-0.43253666162490845,
-0.09140235930681229,
0.10468632727861404,
-0.12100479751825333,
0.22021149098873138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06760v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06760v1
|
DiffusionDialog: A Diffusion Model for Diverse Dialog Generation with Latent Space
| 2024-04-10T05:56:46 | 2024-04-10T05:56:46 |
Jianxiang Xiang, Zhenhua Liu, Haodong Liu, Yin Bai, Jia Cheng, Wenliang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In real-life conversations, the content is diverse, and there exists the
one-to-many problem that requires diverse generation. Previous studies
attempted to introduce discrete or Gaussian-based continuous latent variables
to address the one-to-many problem, but the diversity is limited. Recently,
diffusion models have made breakthroughs in computer vision, and some attempts
have been made in natural language processing. In this paper, we propose
DiffusionDialog, a novel approach to enhance the diversity of dialogue
generation with the help of diffusion model. In our approach, we introduce
continuous latent variables into the diffusion model. The problem of using
latent variables in the dialog task is how to build both an effective prior of
the latent space and an inferring process to obtain the proper latent given the
context. By combining the encoder and latent-based diffusion model, we encode
the response's latent representation in a continuous space as the prior,
instead of fixed Gaussian distribution or simply discrete ones. We then infer
the latent by denoising step by step with the diffusion model. The experimental
results show that our model greatly enhances the diversity of dialog responses
while maintaining coherence. Furthermore, in further analysis, we find that our
diffusion model achieves high inference efficiency, which is the main challenge
of applying diffusion models in natural language processing.
|
[
-0.3914038836956024,
-1.3304884433746338,
0.6131144762039185,
0.13273605704307556,
-0.34959787130355835,
0.19972580671310425,
0.06821608543395996,
-0.07424504309892654,
0.11300407350063324,
0.4551534652709961,
-0.6817644834518433,
-0.46137678623199463,
-0.572064995765686,
-0.12514597177505493,
-0.10221298038959503,
1.0390427112579346,
0.3507365584373474,
0.14369156956672668,
-0.23142461478710175,
-0.08211291581392288,
-0.5986071825027466,
-0.20404674112796783,
-0.6634405255317688,
-0.1913944035768509,
0.18571071326732635,
-0.09306959807872772,
0.7212026715278625,
-0.11454866826534271,
0.09454233944416046,
0.30062586069107056,
-0.41304394602775574,
0.19053272902965546,
-0.578970730304718,
0.3437502086162567,
0.11015699803829193,
-0.41293713450431824,
-0.3849940896034241,
-0.06457981467247009,
0.7895079255104065,
0.9918013215065002,
-0.3250616490840912,
-0.28760001063346863,
-0.011649910360574722,
0.18744689226150513,
-0.3241061866283417,
-0.2991671860218048,
-0.41444456577301025,
0.3117579221725464,
0.07916871458292007,
-0.08005807548761368,
-0.11928567290306091,
-0.5294199585914612,
0.564669668674469,
-0.543683648109436,
0.28278541564941406,
-0.14217615127563477,
0.3520853519439697,
0.12782840430736542,
-0.587966799736023,
-0.4206373691558838,
-1.036738634109497,
0.790332019329071,
-0.8767380714416504,
0.19101722538471222,
0.1437690258026123,
0.2934863567352295,
-0.22418330609798431,
-0.4303722679615021,
-0.7268988490104675,
-0.028849249705672264,
0.2318394035100937,
0.40015649795532227,
-0.21532513201236725,
-0.10572747141122818,
-0.09667661786079407,
0.4603870213031769,
-0.5590296983718872,
-0.26914212107658386,
-0.2924635410308838,
-0.15877903997898102,
0.1180110052227974,
0.28689873218536377,
0.32845407724380493,
0.06765090674161911,
-0.1450957953929901,
0.3828061521053314,
-0.26104435324668884,
-0.14078496396541595,
0.5409365892410278,
0.18346618115901947,
-0.2576839327812195,
0.06137709319591522,
-0.1480022370815277,
0.8266264796257019,
0.20799867808818817,
-0.2796536982059479,
0.0831850916147232,
-0.5425836443901062,
-0.08662809431552887,
-0.28884726762771606,
0.5110329985618591,
0.32418936491012573,
-0.18299445509910583,
-0.12074808776378632,
0.1348264366388321,
-0.1542329341173172,
0.11037664115428925,
-0.9270997047424316,
-0.053469136357307434,
0.07174964994192123,
-0.5971200466156006,
-0.34115445613861084,
-0.3030130863189697,
-1.1222540140151978,
-0.2227117419242859,
0.019992578774690628,
0.05488251894712448,
-0.13472381234169006,
-0.49460384249687195,
-0.035390704870224,
-0.19602884352207184,
-0.207651749253273,
1.0140429735183716,
-0.6811542510986328,
0.5566944479942322,
0.3047676086425781,
0.9960961937904358,
-0.21724852919578552,
0.4165705144405365,
-0.5351879000663757,
0.03463338688015938,
-0.017430191859602928,
0.7657964825630188,
-1.078094720840454,
-0.7793081998825073,
-0.0644959881901741,
-0.3904104232788086,
0.02498823218047619,
-0.6459762454032898,
0.007928533479571342,
-0.4719197154045105,
0.8764317631721497,
0.23993419110774994,
-0.7522107362747192,
-0.306961327791214,
0.2434219866991043,
-0.5413906574249268,
0.6585231423377991,
0.27249962091445923,
-0.6238001585006714,
0.2236265242099762,
-0.8681268095970154,
-0.07329680025577545,
0.3861256241798401,
-0.3084075152873993,
-0.32600000500679016,
0.00017713069973979145,
0.07777100056409836,
0.16273215413093567,
-0.2829451262950897,
0.4591861963272095,
-0.3580944836139679,
0.11048011481761932,
0.31388428807258606,
-0.8030655384063721,
0.6982313394546509,
0.2759023904800415,
0.008973930962383747,
-0.06234768405556679,
-0.5073843598365784,
-0.32480186223983765,
-0.17554733157157898,
-0.30490657687187195,
-0.28593799471855164,
-0.08501225709915161,
-0.08460870385169983,
0.1373937427997589,
0.08059275150299072,
-0.5989676713943481,
0.20390859246253967,
-0.4731655418872833,
0.31584349274635315,
0.5038482546806335,
0.580952525138855,
0.9506927728652954,
-0.22152864933013916,
0.6794402599334717,
0.41790345311164856,
0.028782246634364128,
-0.1924796849489212,
-1.0627211332321167,
-0.433902382850647,
-0.34330302476882935,
0.18079185485839844,
0.6387597322463989,
-0.44104069471359253,
0.4809008240699768,
0.02352067083120346,
-0.18208496272563934,
-0.248311385512352,
0.25725260376930237,
-0.08344997465610504,
0.5322831273078918,
-0.039646681398153305,
-0.5115253925323486,
-0.22472187876701355,
-0.5476388931274414,
0.3186224400997162,
-0.12756586074829102,
0.012662571854889393,
0.696094274520874,
0.27325329184532166,
-0.5816897749900818,
1.3791965246200562,
-0.7155441045761108,
0.016267506405711174,
-0.334347665309906,
0.42709654569625854,
0.0828639566898346,
0.6057276725769043,
0.5558753609657288,
-0.8633685111999512,
-0.4853878319263458,
-0.2246299684047699,
-0.5433383584022522,
-0.14293284714221954,
-0.30295196175575256,
-0.36876872181892395,
-0.2158689647912979,
0.27808770537376404,
-0.41857409477233887,
0.5188243389129639,
0.7548233866691589,
-0.42966678738594055,
0.2227921038866043,
-0.09140363335609436,
0.06812331825494766,
-1.2251654863357544,
-0.26305851340293884,
-0.004485580138862133,
-0.4581381678581238,
-0.8566465973854065,
-0.33049556612968445,
-0.6065952181816101,
-0.3784337043762207,
-0.32181650400161743,
0.7831887602806091,
-0.1541462391614914,
0.40611398220062256,
-0.20623575150966644,
0.13655197620391846,
-0.024576246738433838,
0.5741861462593079,
0.07084083557128906,
0.6845992803573608,
0.5019795298576355,
-0.6764368414878845,
0.09718930721282959,
0.4222782254219055,
-0.15770231187343597,
0.6750805377960205,
-0.42735931277275085,
0.12178625911474228,
-0.4405038058757782,
0.6756309270858765,
-1.329771876335144,
0.060227807611227036,
0.47346991300582886,
-0.21088770031929016,
-0.00038272063829936087,
-0.26766321063041687,
-0.24469256401062012,
0.0333232507109642,
-0.0133652463555336,
0.6671329736709595,
0.608586847782135,
-0.30685538053512573,
0.795936107635498,
0.28293415904045105,
-0.651440441608429,
0.015913531184196472,
-0.2941434681415558,
-0.06620075553655624,
-0.3121304214000702,
-0.9043624997138977,
0.28241002559661865,
-0.6068935394287109,
-0.2563740313053131,
-0.06776722520589828,
-0.10100468248128891,
-0.5892190337181091,
0.008097763173282146,
0.2748594284057617,
0.24823732674121857,
-0.148529052734375,
0.16276083886623383,
0.2149336040019989,
0.08269055932760239,
-0.3082426190376282,
-0.3618564009666443,
0.5601733326911926,
0.2073439210653305,
-0.24196533858776093,
-0.38172048330307007,
0.7693044543266296,
0.3739713132381439,
0.14401432871818542,
0.6541589498519897,
0.5738062262535095,
-0.19186300039291382,
-0.23646995425224304,
-0.4702467918395996,
-0.1880125105381012,
-0.47941166162490845,
0.17916788160800934,
-0.051991820335388184,
-1.3151682615280151,
0.5721794366836548,
-0.5972774028778076,
0.18407195806503296,
0.024973344057798386,
0.708362877368927,
-0.20298366248607635,
0.8753483891487122,
0.5693652629852295,
0.2582981586456299,
0.9031163454055786,
-0.1692989021539688,
0.40870755910873413,
-0.7819767594337463,
-0.006489449180662632,
-0.25125443935394287,
0.029884275048971176,
-0.23433563113212585,
-1.0348280668258667,
0.3620489537715912,
0.14672589302062988,
0.2363622486591339,
-0.2822781205177307,
-0.327213317155838,
0.1723577231168747,
0.2945247292518616,
0.18111269176006317,
0.40961411595344543,
0.18467915058135986,
-0.2625463306903839,
-0.2921473979949951,
-0.5907317399978638,
-0.680910587310791,
0.8027499318122864,
0.4137992262840271,
0.8498573303222656,
0.36396071314811707,
0.821352481842041,
0.5305860638618469,
0.1858750432729721,
-0.46975162625312805,
0.47676727175712585,
-0.10616136342287064,
-0.5477994084358215,
-0.32986319065093994,
-0.5882018804550171,
-1.0629216432571411,
0.5433515906333923,
-0.20456354320049286,
-0.9209740161895752,
0.12003889679908752,
0.06197537109255791,
-0.5865253806114197,
0.06888226419687271,
-0.5679864287376404,
0.6647616028785706,
0.1482958197593689,
-0.2917804718017578,
-0.422272652387619,
-0.28800690174102783,
0.29335102438926697,
-0.03963879123330116,
0.2924865186214447,
-0.1714434027671814,
0.22695648670196533,
0.6920398473739624,
-0.5634799003601074,
1.1989567279815674,
-0.3656395971775055,
-0.16633133590221405,
0.6720858216285706,
0.08648747950792313,
0.3590758144855499,
0.5664001107215881,
0.20439448952674866,
-0.013552063144743443,
-0.2992681860923767,
-0.30261585116386414,
-0.7647226452827454,
0.3477727174758911,
-0.6317116022109985,
-0.5987750291824341,
-0.034302107989788055,
-0.4828982949256897,
-0.1452902853488922,
0.01979786902666092,
0.16405031085014343,
0.5893594026565552,
-0.6929672956466675,
0.07939551770687103,
0.8059028387069702,
-0.3494636118412018,
0.37690120935440063,
0.45416906476020813,
-0.14832842350006104,
-0.3032001852989197,
0.7001970410346985,
-0.07481001317501068,
0.5256174802780151,
0.2703651785850525,
0.3162531852722168,
-0.07337001711130142,
-0.47695326805114746,
-0.2610473930835724,
0.0889485776424408,
-0.6445673108100891,
0.0953933447599411,
-1.1713098287582397,
-0.13669797778129578,
-0.38890066742897034,
-0.30843669176101685,
-0.1565389782190323,
-0.526814877986908,
-0.6178743243217468,
0.29808226227760315,
0.15821179747581482,
0.7184033989906311,
0.18885661661624908,
0.7076169848442078,
-0.8344395756721497,
0.5263822078704834,
0.8531742691993713,
0.21931388974189758,
0.08030328154563904,
-0.5715309977531433,
0.0354374535381794,
0.17777103185653687,
-0.4606107473373413,
-0.8044223785400391,
0.5555610060691833,
0.2235514521598816,
0.8062110543251038,
0.4008547067642212,
-0.30226024985313416,
0.6573415398597717,
-0.5892276763916016,
1.057906150817871,
0.46323999762535095,
-0.7527945041656494,
0.5789486765861511,
-0.3693064749240875,
0.579006552696228,
0.3492049276828766,
-0.04088112711906433,
-0.634428083896637,
-0.883665144443512,
-0.7355421781539917,
-0.714743435382843,
0.2997547686100006,
0.4916073977947235,
0.3475547134876251,
-0.0467754565179348,
0.009612279012799263,
0.5589653849601746,
0.2535954415798187,
-0.5164052248001099,
0.013890511356294155,
-0.26824796199798584,
-0.22311528027057648,
0.3413422703742981,
-0.20403772592544556,
-0.21380068361759186,
-0.026015106588602066,
0.27226248383522034,
-0.03959812968969345,
0.5331537127494812,
0.11382802575826645,
-0.2593652307987213,
-0.0053497180342674255,
0.4820433557033539,
0.6589573621749878,
0.21492476761341095,
-0.25256770849227905,
-0.15813514590263367,
0.15746760368347168,
-0.4943144619464874,
0.04007469862699509,
-0.21644091606140137,
-0.30473092198371887,
0.3424517810344696,
0.06851010769605637,
0.9165278077125549,
0.09767326712608337,
-0.37375113368034363,
0.4449610412120819,
-0.4211939871311188,
-0.1239708736538887,
-0.1657894104719162,
0.23088277876377106,
0.19766588509082794,
0.3422267735004425,
0.3617938756942749,
0.44597533345222473,
0.4381956458091736,
-0.4536556899547577,
0.08341801911592484,
0.4905240833759308,
-0.13985925912857056,
-0.35560333728790283,
0.5527425408363342,
0.7552962899208069,
-0.5250512361526489,
0.4543222188949585,
-0.3679679036140442,
-0.4165427088737488,
0.5529319047927856,
0.48808273673057556,
1.0094572305679321,
-0.032653409987688065,
0.5684274435043335,
0.35397645831108093,
-0.1812727153301239,
-0.014131814241409302,
0.06753039360046387,
-0.5378152132034302,
-0.9720301032066345,
-0.16018186509609222,
-0.6531471014022827,
-0.6540265083312988,
-0.003205952700227499,
-0.2051241099834442,
-0.42638739943504333,
-0.6241519451141357,
-0.4686923325061798,
0.006162055768072605,
-0.2067476361989975,
-0.7152635455131531,
0.06950628757476807,
0.28840741515159607,
0.46326130628585815,
-0.8297239542007446,
0.5620059967041016,
0.3353654444217682,
-0.21193630993366241,
-0.17244316637516022,
0.3187468647956848,
0.055010370910167694,
-0.31407293677330017,
0.7110322117805481,
-0.03831902891397476,
-0.09361421316862106,
-0.2334781140089035,
-0.6218463778495789,
-0.821320652961731,
0.7799282670021057,
0.008616035804152489,
-0.5465970039367676,
0.0550154484808445,
-0.07675468921661377,
0.5177348256111145,
-0.9297090768814087,
0.23924463987350464,
0.16962559521198273,
0.264823317527771,
0.4270552694797516,
-0.6552501320838928,
-0.1138981282711029,
-0.3095269501209259,
0.3330438435077667,
-0.12471477687358856,
-0.5325880646705627,
0.8393942713737488,
0.030792057514190674,
-0.3612958788871765,
0.14846684038639069,
0.5960124731063843,
0.2859047055244446,
0.15569479763507843,
0.7324668169021606,
0.21143509447574615,
0.8746691942214966,
0.11219469457864761,
0.6433141827583313,
0.012039738707244396,
0.20986509323120117,
1.1397382020950317,
-0.3412044942378998,
0.42497503757476807,
0.3405101001262665,
-0.1057262048125267,
0.8801489472389221,
0.24748492240905762,
0.04762141406536102,
0.6633477807044983,
0.02959255874156952,
-0.8181292414665222,
-0.2143351286649704,
-0.02084832265973091,
-0.09681232273578644,
0.12515515089035034,
0.6358842849731445,
-0.11339157074689865,
-0.4963572323322296,
0.2059783637523651,
-0.1295316517353058,
-0.025977404788136482,
0.1985618621110916,
0.9464990496635437,
-0.20104260742664337,
-0.5908780694007874,
0.16435137391090393,
-0.23096394538879395,
1.0132066011428833,
-0.5146778225898743,
-0.38621172308921814,
-0.35882169008255005,
-0.2569196820259094,
-0.10092698782682419,
-0.5059040188789368,
0.1367243379354477,
-0.06440766900777817,
-0.2631816565990448,
-0.37363460659980774,
0.5655192136764526,
-0.7498987317085266,
-0.48411062359809875,
0.037555694580078125,
0.5635942220687866,
0.21603389084339142,
0.2652769684791565,
-0.5865098237991333,
-0.1397511512041092,
0.15712103247642517,
-0.07192584872245789,
0.18295438587665558,
0.5620115399360657,
-0.10095422714948654,
0.4955233633518219,
0.5970705151557922,
0.046280864626169205,
0.345468133687973,
0.42624107003211975,
0.7724257707595825,
-0.5218547582626343,
-0.9126204252243042,
-0.45832905173301697,
0.7046251893043518,
-0.3174532651901245,
-0.3140321373939514,
0.36108875274658203,
0.3046104311943054,
0.23971468210220337,
0.012729153968393803,
1.0236929655075073,
0.10535655915737152,
0.558034360408783,
-0.2300494909286499,
0.35931888222694397,
-0.29200389981269836,
0.3010166883468628,
-0.2639498710632324,
-0.8803251385688782,
-0.06429067254066467,
0.9620096683502197,
-0.1782134771347046,
0.2528873682022095,
0.5033576488494873,
0.831754744052887,
-0.08119550347328186,
0.15193216502666473,
0.4713175594806671,
0.09561974555253983,
0.6248763799667358,
0.4109247326850891,
0.9109739065170288,
-0.17831824719905853,
0.4962518811225891,
0.2239261418581009,
-0.4685092270374298,
-0.24487589299678802,
-0.5132064819335938,
-1.0021039247512817,
-0.3466081917285919,
-0.5786879658699036,
-0.13525287806987762,
-0.10426042973995209,
0.6288984417915344,
0.8877996802330017,
-0.6128305196762085,
-0.1284104734659195,
-0.4069119989871979,
0.13120588660240173,
0.14951743185520172,
-0.2863403558731079,
-0.4099068343639374,
-0.3451407551765442,
-0.9202947020530701,
0.2644461691379547,
0.642124354839325,
0.42679911851882935,
-0.4673113524913788,
-0.08769284933805466,
-0.31315815448760986,
0.3637458384037018,
0.5608058571815491,
0.00729587534442544,
-0.6858298778533936,
-0.09426439553499222,
-0.26329299807548523,
-0.10947245359420776,
0.1640760451555252,
0.7737210988998413,
-0.8006048798561096,
0.7247153520584106,
0.5174153447151184,
0.40078964829444885,
0.7610273361206055,
-0.0095484284684062,
0.8983086943626404,
-0.8598355054855347,
0.524284303188324,
0.3829108774662018,
0.10163920372724533,
0.33429357409477234,
-0.4965212941169739,
0.3437710106372833,
0.4195175766944885,
-0.4014351963996887,
-0.47289979457855225,
0.5370904207229614,
-1.0198274850845337,
-0.46789664030075073,
0.9928784966468811,
-0.10107085108757019,
0.01076237391680479,
-0.48162180185317993,
-0.5337037444114685,
0.18779172003269196,
-0.9230340719223022,
0.6006456017494202,
0.7151889204978943,
-0.08108477294445038,
-0.2591002285480499,
-0.4550732374191284,
0.27375540137290955,
0.4754072427749634,
-0.8858488202095032,
-0.1299276202917099,
0.7711874842643738,
0.41576361656188965,
0.30005550384521484,
1.0630266666412354,
0.04918137937784195,
0.2542679011821747,
0.31779956817626953,
-0.48014649748802185,
0.5678373575210571,
-0.010869458317756653,
-0.2992272973060608,
0.3391689956188202,
-0.2277984619140625,
-0.03328769654035568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06757v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06757v1
|
Language Generation in the Limit
| 2024-04-10T05:53:25 | 2024-04-10T05:53:25 |
Jon Kleinberg, Sendhil Mullainathan
|
cs.DS
|
cs.DS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Although current large language models are complex, the most basic
specifications of the underlying language generation problem itself are simple
to state: given a finite set of training samples from an unknown language,
produce valid new strings from the language that don't already appear in the
training data. Here we ask what we can conclude about language generation using
only this specification, without further assumptions. In particular, suppose
that an adversary enumerates the strings of an unknown target language L that
is known only to come from one of a possibly infinite list of candidates. A
computational agent is trying to learn to generate from this language; we say
that the agent generates from L in the limit if after some finite point in the
enumeration of L, the agent is able to produce new elements that come
exclusively from L and that have not yet been presented by the adversary. Our
main result is that there is an agent that is able to generate in the limit for
every countable list of candidate languages. This contrasts dramatically with
negative results due to Gold and Angluin in a well-studied model of language
learning where the goal is to identify an unknown language from samples; the
difference between these results suggests that identifying a language is a
fundamentally different problem than generating from it.
|
[
-0.5763128399848938,
-0.709258496761322,
0.6145016551017761,
-0.08615658432245255,
0.1132701188325882,
0.25792673230171204,
-0.40613237023353577,
-0.8196382522583008,
-0.03514333814382553,
0.7017824053764343,
-0.45585012435913086,
0.06619247049093246,
-0.47144612669944763,
0.329730361700058,
-0.7559002041816711,
1.2626293897628784,
0.008015266619622707,
-0.36914193630218506,
-0.127964586019516,
0.0453152060508728,
-0.36028409004211426,
-0.3474119007587433,
-0.6620445251464844,
-0.2970150113105774,
0.28715068101882935,
0.5415336489677429,
0.5046418905258179,
0.730732798576355,
0.19150197505950928,
0.4061327278614044,
0.10589074343442917,
-0.021670306101441383,
-0.7089061141014099,
0.47227635979652405,
-0.0430748276412487,
-0.41701874136924744,
0.1299648880958557,
0.12315689027309418,
0.8335475325584412,
0.7045794725418091,
0.31298670172691345,
0.093730628490448,
-0.10532627254724503,
0.4901268482208252,
-0.4800913333892822,
-0.18471230566501617,
-1.152359962463379,
-0.039626289159059525,
-0.4077925682067871,
-0.22773417830467224,
-0.546812117099762,
-0.21579837799072266,
0.0869419053196907,
-0.40715479850769043,
0.6085935831069946,
-0.13493773341178894,
0.9142030477523804,
-0.1746203452348709,
-0.27059581875801086,
-0.6980629563331604,
-1.1023004055023193,
0.7515932321548462,
-0.5441145300865173,
0.09329336881637573,
0.2745417654514313,
0.4368550777435303,
-0.19135348498821259,
-0.49662116169929504,
-0.6674854755401611,
-0.6200755834579468,
0.40059617161750793,
-0.21423788368701935,
-0.2473873645067215,
-0.15884225070476532,
0.7043156027793884,
0.4935078024864197,
-0.5570166110992432,
-0.004804063588380814,
-0.7523279190063477,
-0.07807081937789917,
0.8943370580673218,
0.013075239025056362,
0.45885366201400757,
0.10435333102941513,
-0.18636813759803772,
-0.17931720614433289,
-0.8393361568450928,
-0.15288802981376648,
0.5914627909660339,
0.5628029108047485,
0.12127766758203506,
0.7095642685890198,
-0.036735352128744125,
0.6049280762672424,
0.09279510378837585,
0.039883069694042206,
-0.07365782558917999,
-0.06980276107788086,
-0.02209087461233139,
0.08472239971160889,
0.6367241740226746,
-0.07091512531042099,
0.45443296432495117,
-0.27267199754714966,
-0.3659951388835907,
0.09570932388305664,
0.18975956737995148,
-0.7025171518325806,
0.1575651317834854,
0.09828941524028778,
0.1371978223323822,
-0.34257054328918457,
0.3152241110801697,
-0.478520005941391,
-0.23339173197746277,
0.13520121574401855,
0.16737234592437744,
-0.3811293840408325,
-0.30843135714530945,
-0.24418266117572784,
-0.2997458279132843,
0.2772049903869629,
-0.1799429953098297,
-0.8324254751205444,
0.38455334305763245,
0.5362820029258728,
0.34673643112182617,
-0.027893265709280968,
-0.6070570349693298,
-0.6087983846664429,
-0.0064626699313521385,
-0.6871023178100586,
0.5650145411491394,
-0.6337119936943054,
-0.2441210150718689,
0.2185111790895462,
-0.03511078655719757,
0.030831480398774147,
-0.7144755721092224,
0.017078908160328865,
-0.6072837710380554,
-0.11111471056938171,
-0.3246995508670807,
-0.6789892911911011,
-0.04289745166897774,
-0.1503506302833557,
-0.7250778079032898,
0.717162549495697,
0.35487958788871765,
-0.3460928201675415,
0.6588761806488037,
-0.3378656804561615,
-0.5509998202323914,
0.5450407266616821,
-0.38509026169776917,
-0.3236280083656311,
0.38405999541282654,
-0.6572508811950684,
0.016391821205615997,
-0.5877574682235718,
0.31825292110443115,
-0.197435200214386,
-0.17492014169692993,
0.6941869258880615,
-0.3872360587120056,
0.5671182870864868,
0.5543928742408752,
-0.4972401261329651,
-0.09823724627494812,
-0.705096423625946,
0.05081348121166229,
0.38692593574523926,
-0.769611656665802,
0.04727517440915108,
0.0214698426425457,
-0.15818127989768982,
0.16715697944164276,
0.22554466128349304,
-0.9786947965621948,
0.07753705978393555,
-0.5963323712348938,
0.2868102788925171,
0.6586745977401733,
0.07709380984306335,
0.3914374113082886,
-0.42786329984664917,
0.7919569611549377,
-0.2907005250453949,
-0.30707135796546936,
-0.1893710047006607,
-0.45446181297302246,
-0.8653900623321533,
0.2806207537651062,
0.3992846608161926,
0.34739330410957336,
-0.5738827586174011,
0.33433210849761963,
0.06425366550683975,
-0.33055827021598816,
-0.2588227093219757,
0.2396569848060608,
0.4697498679161072,
-0.08809976279735565,
-0.21367569267749786,
-0.18129339814186096,
-0.7799227237701416,
-0.8106876611709595,
-0.38426655530929565,
-0.15585172176361084,
0.007984118536114693,
0.3954816162586212,
0.4299706518650055,
0.06770683079957962,
0.8750814199447632,
-0.3566322326660156,
0.28684213757514954,
-0.7010723352432251,
0.04601450636982918,
0.12669406831264496,
0.6737447381019592,
0.4917762279510498,
-0.5801818370819092,
-0.9264297485351562,
0.34616023302078247,
-0.6714918613433838,
-0.09841263294219971,
-0.28048187494277954,
-0.014608439058065414,
0.3635813593864441,
0.596626341342926,
-0.5570595860481262,
0.32741108536720276,
0.3729555308818817,
-0.1103454977273941,
0.27178311347961426,
-0.2598271369934082,
-0.2872021198272705,
-0.9851158857345581,
0.16866278648376465,
-0.16094724833965302,
-0.07778133451938629,
-1.0647103786468506,
0.1935238540172577,
-0.28271448612213135,
-0.6566085815429688,
-0.3785639703273773,
0.4955351948738098,
-0.38046830892562866,
-0.06051943078637123,
-0.6011465787887573,
0.09446938335895538,
-0.17782245576381683,
0.3468417823314667,
-0.17379580438137054,
0.3827497959136963,
0.7511345148086548,
-0.7372463345527649,
0.1706300973892212,
-0.17919445037841797,
-0.30228590965270996,
-0.047323256731033325,
-0.45328521728515625,
0.15027771890163422,
-0.21702831983566284,
0.0128241665661335,
-0.8071874976158142,
-0.4495158791542053,
0.11962496489286423,
-0.47922995686531067,
0.3639439344406128,
0.001413542777299881,
-0.26485487818717957,
-0.4651251435279846,
0.13206589221954346,
0.6248852014541626,
0.6837480068206787,
-0.2131616771221161,
0.17710191011428833,
0.31607475876808167,
0.05130981653928757,
-0.5111865997314453,
-0.5250775218009949,
-0.03463398665189743,
-0.12163364142179489,
-0.39170360565185547,
0.06507769227027893,
-0.353424072265625,
-0.5275108218193054,
-0.08923708647489548,
0.1507473886013031,
-0.018814705312252045,
0.22704654932022095,
0.2154150754213333,
-0.08898476511240005,
-0.21467699110507965,
0.25926488637924194,
0.011240045540034771,
-0.04922523349523544,
0.10823003202676773,
-0.35761559009552,
0.6542572975158691,
-0.09916563332080841,
-0.39543259143829346,
0.3004501461982727,
0.8592158555984497,
0.54946368932724,
-0.4004226326942444,
0.5109131336212158,
0.24935229122638702,
-0.37015366554260254,
-0.5122769474983215,
-0.37249988317489624,
0.011316775344312191,
-0.5260917544364929,
0.46653425693511963,
-0.626484215259552,
-0.7120853662490845,
0.4782203733921051,
0.2597509026527405,
0.23131489753723145,
0.8598745465278625,
0.4523378014564514,
0.4007437527179718,
1.1057628393173218,
0.8192757964134216,
0.18373443186283112,
0.3488071858882904,
-0.18673187494277954,
0.14173690974712372,
-0.33107972145080566,
0.030551351606845856,
-0.6205480098724365,
0.0006827698089182377,
-1.013260006904602,
-0.10969867557287216,
0.15087060630321503,
0.20815017819404602,
-0.32807308435440063,
0.5002338886260986,
-0.39910390973091125,
0.8939306139945984,
0.7549120783805847,
-0.1991848200559616,
-0.062201861292123795,
0.12316835671663284,
-0.018951617181301117,
0.2929198443889618,
-0.7416888475418091,
-0.3732995092868805,
1.1813238859176636,
0.16040422022342682,
0.3360235393047333,
0.16280223429203033,
0.9694572687149048,
0.1383690983057022,
0.3097783029079437,
-0.585494339466095,
0.6851323246955872,
-0.15518005192279816,
-0.962522566318512,
-0.4491460919380188,
-0.531846821308136,
-1.3024921417236328,
-0.09407840669155121,
-0.2498234361410141,
-0.6445005536079407,
0.1108265221118927,
-0.13548320531845093,
-0.12665174901485443,
0.33579543232917786,
-0.25771304965019226,
0.684766411781311,
-0.3509414494037628,
-0.23195861279964447,
-0.05954977869987488,
-0.3827120065689087,
0.4476976692676544,
-0.4691113233566284,
-0.05143425613641739,
-0.11457520723342896,
0.28878775238990784,
0.7642594575881958,
-0.5093017816543579,
0.6458905935287476,
-0.10487084090709686,
-0.29364922642707825,
0.9355363845825195,
0.2480504959821701,
0.5667567253112793,
-0.3133082687854767,
0.01390080340206623,
-0.4136529564857483,
-0.41524481773376465,
-0.4705923795700073,
-0.16509586572647095,
0.5340394973754883,
-0.672735333442688,
-0.7325079441070557,
-0.2664925456047058,
-0.6920310854911804,
0.12584885954856873,
0.4881840944290161,
0.8102056384086609,
0.3460032343864441,
-0.3087364435195923,
0.06916023790836334,
0.4844433665275574,
-0.6609576344490051,
0.4737577736377716,
0.6599406599998474,
-0.2989756464958191,
-0.05770609527826309,
1.538966417312622,
0.32476672530174255,
0.49998363852500916,
0.2587393522262573,
0.2487025111913681,
0.003919902257621288,
-0.527195155620575,
-0.44731879234313965,
0.4200701117515564,
-0.7306284308433533,
0.1855240911245346,
-0.265627384185791,
-0.5906981825828552,
-0.2576204836368561,
-0.11326391249895096,
-0.22371605038642883,
-0.15019896626472473,
-0.09265214204788208,
-0.05987007915973663,
0.05847089737653732,
1.1988980770111084,
-0.22755716741085052,
0.11545389145612717,
-0.6795541644096375,
-0.06534475088119507,
0.6224911212921143,
0.12153084576129913,
0.08286755532026291,
-0.5093008279800415,
-0.5795413255691528,
0.07901691645383835,
-0.44849663972854614,
-0.9301986694335938,
0.27984610199928284,
0.3609669804573059,
0.5778802037239075,
0.5247847437858582,
0.09162402153015137,
0.33033841848373413,
-0.6132987141609192,
0.6443996429443359,
0.10040606558322906,
-0.953460156917572,
0.39387044310569763,
-0.466977596282959,
0.37757036089897156,
0.4263441562652588,
0.4112183749675751,
-0.4786964952945709,
-1.086592197418213,
-1.1717737913131714,
-0.7361937761306763,
0.5842196345329285,
0.24510127305984497,
0.3891725242137909,
-0.35620221495628357,
0.3406212329864502,
0.3209681212902069,
0.2690013647079468,
-0.885074257850647,
-0.09520941972732544,
0.004988098982721567,
0.15952661633491516,
-0.21516360342502594,
-0.18888723850250244,
-0.011938815005123615,
0.189096137881279,
0.4280116856098175,
-0.01715274713933468,
0.2946747839450836,
-0.20230334997177124,
-0.07946553826332092,
-0.8176466226577759,
0.37954941391944885,
0.7786251306533813,
0.8769857287406921,
0.06477563828229904,
0.17365100979804993,
0.043179526925086975,
-0.07930967211723328,
0.18188460171222687,
-0.13353979587554932,
-0.3388519585132599,
0.009705201722681522,
0.4698880910873413,
0.973146915435791,
-0.38802239298820496,
-1.1514849662780762,
0.39103367924690247,
0.2446843981742859,
-0.4789527952671051,
-0.5474724769592285,
0.34749969840049744,
-0.1834060102701187,
0.267659068107605,
0.5362539887428284,
0.10228841006755829,
-0.07001422345638275,
-0.7659788131713867,
0.5030450224876404,
0.5902552008628845,
-0.17974665760993958,
-0.3719027042388916,
0.7128707766532898,
0.01480579562485218,
-0.6410962343215942,
0.7353737950325012,
-0.4719763696193695,
-0.40245598554611206,
0.8664214015007019,
0.9432461857795715,
0.9621671438217163,
-0.1582765132188797,
0.37173664569854736,
0.5446521639823914,
0.3523698151111603,
0.17410221695899963,
0.2889596223831177,
-0.16049720346927643,
-0.8400156497955322,
-0.38129478693008423,
-0.6188066601753235,
-0.19953951239585876,
0.4675823152065277,
-0.546217679977417,
-0.2721201777458191,
-0.4265255630016327,
-0.13203251361846924,
0.1016123965382576,
-0.16616304218769073,
-0.3677654266357422,
0.14354188740253448,
0.3731652498245239,
0.4923039674758911,
-1.0307697057724,
0.583040714263916,
0.2791333794593811,
-0.5222264528274536,
-0.7336199879646301,
0.03883986920118332,
-0.43453723192214966,
-0.710021436214447,
0.6738946437835693,
0.23582769930362701,
0.18395745754241943,
-0.2043333798646927,
-0.6992177367210388,
-0.874614417552948,
0.5688124895095825,
0.5675786137580872,
-0.4438287019729614,
0.10984465479850769,
0.5293055176734924,
0.6462464928627014,
-0.4156317114830017,
-0.26763075590133667,
0.41969600319862366,
0.3492821455001831,
0.15524333715438843,
-0.5514127612113953,
0.22526630759239197,
-0.5157331228256226,
-0.1266489326953888,
0.533735454082489,
-0.39832890033721924,
1.322328805923462,
-0.18925651907920837,
-0.6341291666030884,
0.3757174015045166,
0.46004295349121094,
0.23997144401073456,
0.007776842452585697,
0.48498645424842834,
0.274903267621994,
0.639409601688385,
0.14093856513500214,
1.1451457738876343,
-0.408383309841156,
0.08242608606815338,
0.8408142924308777,
-0.23622877895832062,
0.5838732719421387,
0.11267728358507156,
-0.12375231087207794,
0.27173474431037903,
0.5636151432991028,
-0.16889148950576782,
-0.01676631160080433,
0.6233171820640564,
-0.4227187931537628,
-0.3301791846752167,
-0.2407144457101822,
-0.4675077795982361,
0.4647122919559479,
0.1756249964237213,
-0.5988420248031616,
-0.32520774006843567,
0.042153529822826385,
-0.020897895097732544,
0.005743151996284723,
-0.07497432827949524,
0.8033337593078613,
0.022751059383153915,
-1.071221947669983,
1.0556691884994507,
0.013387415558099747,
-0.0000372864305973053,
-0.5621200799942017,
-0.01640934683382511,
-0.08891692012548447,
0.06895818561315536,
0.007696794345974922,
-0.4965817630290985,
0.07128553092479706,
0.20864027738571167,
-0.3071867823600769,
-0.052625373005867004,
0.6400352716445923,
-0.729886531829834,
-0.5396429300308228,
-0.025645701214671135,
0.47614437341690063,
0.5992128849029541,
0.12100721895694733,
-0.34875407814979553,
-0.09231963753700256,
0.21794050931930542,
-0.05509409308433533,
0.5907630920410156,
0.560610830783844,
0.012883909977972507,
0.46668514609336853,
0.4911454916000366,
0.34584492444992065,
0.24766284227371216,
-0.09304392337799072,
0.6331271529197693,
-0.43324267864227295,
-0.3411984443664551,
-0.7180472612380981,
0.2558848261833191,
0.0844472199678421,
-0.4434371590614319,
0.774920642375946,
0.38895183801651,
0.971785306930542,
-0.2625463902950287,
1.1924304962158203,
-0.35152536630630493,
0.34680214524269104,
-0.1871488094329834,
0.3252317011356354,
-0.5484119653701782,
0.2438134402036667,
-0.2863316535949707,
-0.999082088470459,
0.08971396088600159,
0.27979427576065063,
-0.0874648466706276,
0.13099026679992676,
0.7095043659210205,
0.6744472980499268,
0.37436968088150024,
-0.2054828703403473,
0.4100850820541382,
0.17344936728477478,
0.24853456020355225,
0.7553176879882812,
1.0284466743469238,
-0.24637754261493683,
0.7211388945579529,
-0.02993742749094963,
-0.10776229202747345,
0.1255209892988205,
-0.3462587594985962,
-0.6762686371803284,
-0.7204117774963379,
0.08388277888298035,
-0.41761407256126404,
-0.2665485143661499,
0.6243772506713867,
0.2445279061794281,
-0.7629985213279724,
-0.8458675742149353,
-0.6750261783599854,
-0.001310175284743309,
-0.24032722413539886,
-0.20030611753463745,
-0.029118621721863747,
-0.3868371248245239,
-0.8320619463920593,
0.578925371170044,
-0.04896176978945732,
0.2903551459312439,
-0.412911593914032,
-0.30787143111228943,
-0.018451720476150513,
0.39417701959609985,
0.37392669916152954,
0.9310466051101685,
-0.45851823687553406,
-0.2703019976615906,
-0.18059656023979187,
0.003296523354947567,
-0.043014317750930786,
0.9888548254966736,
-0.4801620543003082,
0.49747538566589355,
0.545219361782074,
0.6133208274841309,
0.573376476764679,
-0.29740291833877563,
0.9367993474006653,
-0.8066641688346863,
-0.030609827488660812,
0.1962580680847168,
0.03609701246023178,
-0.028654616326093674,
-0.20768816769123077,
0.17109274864196777,
0.1254328191280365,
-0.459301620721817,
-1.0229920148849487,
0.9641094207763672,
-0.5390059351921082,
-0.515752375125885,
1.0900466442108154,
-0.012417789548635483,
-0.145122691988945,
-0.11707410216331482,
0.053756605833768845,
0.426173597574234,
-0.2796104848384857,
0.5214695930480957,
0.43419212102890015,
-0.07809767872095108,
0.2719316780567169,
-0.4836276173591614,
0.6148937940597534,
0.29802206158638,
-0.5186343193054199,
0.12492599338293076,
0.2981763780117035,
0.12334660440683365,
0.5029032826423645,
0.6831409931182861,
0.14016734063625336,
0.3729890286922455,
0.4064088761806488,
-0.142389178276062,
0.22223210334777832,
-0.5771363973617554,
-0.04990140721201897,
0.4308047890663147,
0.5089280605316162,
-0.005044471472501755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06742v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06742v1
|
Transferable and Efficient Non-Factual Content Detection via Probe Training with Offline Consistency Checking
| 2024-04-10T05:00:35 | 2024-04-10T05:00:35 |
Xiaokang Zhang, Zijun Yao, Jing Zhang, Kaifeng Yun, Jifan Yu, Juanzi Li, Jie Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Detecting non-factual content is a longstanding goal to increase the
trustworthiness of large language models (LLMs) generations. Current factuality
probes, trained using humanannotated labels, exhibit limited transferability to
out-of-distribution content, while online selfconsistency checking imposes
extensive computation burden due to the necessity of generating multiple
outputs. This paper proposes PINOSE, which trains a probing model on offline
self-consistency checking results, thereby circumventing the need for
human-annotated data and achieving transferability across diverse data
distributions. As the consistency check process is offline, PINOSE reduces the
computational burden of generating multiple responses by online consistency
verification. Additionally, it examines various aspects of internal states
prior to response decoding, contributing to more effective detection of factual
inaccuracies. Experiment results on both factuality detection and question
answering benchmarks show that PINOSE achieves surpassing results than existing
factuality detection methods. Our code and datasets are publicly available on
this anonymized repository.
|
[
-0.2956959009170532,
-0.5663960576057434,
0.5382620096206665,
0.09133702516555786,
-0.04815877974033356,
0.08761326223611832,
-0.22848175466060638,
-0.4520113170146942,
0.309407114982605,
0.5275884866714478,
-0.47113344073295593,
-0.49459022283554077,
-0.4801825284957886,
0.21866898238658905,
-0.6185035109519958,
1.0664921998977661,
-0.17262804508209229,
-0.29187148809432983,
-0.46012166142463684,
-0.2656836211681366,
-0.2205583155155182,
-0.38430941104888916,
-0.21810568869113922,
-0.08310182392597198,
-0.012488513253629208,
0.6545721292495728,
0.10418765246868134,
0.7537022233009338,
0.4770140051841736,
0.2756465673446655,
0.23785340785980225,
0.49322375655174255,
-0.8546454906463623,
0.1724574714899063,
-0.6294633150100708,
-0.6212859153747559,
-0.2803117036819458,
0.1086953654885292,
0.5587700605392456,
0.28115832805633545,
-0.06036560237407684,
0.5035816431045532,
-0.15406034886837006,
0.372016042470932,
-0.7279149293899536,
0.21039290726184845,
-0.8155595064163208,
-0.30088093876838684,
-0.05795322731137276,
-0.2300928384065628,
-0.6313109993934631,
-0.8549368381500244,
-0.04041901230812073,
-0.5687788724899292,
0.6504716277122498,
0.3588455319404602,
1.0205961465835571,
0.2020408809185028,
-0.49503976106643677,
-0.601009726524353,
-0.6709669232368469,
0.5212332010269165,
-0.6732931733131409,
0.45960021018981934,
0.7354439496994019,
0.2469821274280548,
-0.130840003490448,
-0.7234353423118591,
-0.905439555644989,
-0.25933152437210083,
-0.15228445827960968,
0.08204802125692368,
0.0962601825594902,
-0.09798648208379745,
0.1584813892841339,
0.4241996705532074,
-0.4684537351131439,
-0.09655493497848511,
-0.22411951422691345,
-0.35949450731277466,
0.3935399651527405,
-0.1082242876291275,
0.2177930325269699,
-0.33052384853363037,
-0.5828414559364319,
-0.2647712826728821,
-0.654801607131958,
0.2632578909397125,
0.29798242449760437,
0.18984133005142212,
-0.15019004046916962,
0.4581489861011505,
-0.2761547863483429,
0.24093998968601227,
0.4851546883583069,
-0.3572164475917816,
0.009056196548044682,
-0.5955528020858765,
0.10574763268232346,
0.396541953086853,
0.5989668369293213,
0.2665984630584717,
-0.0819210410118103,
-0.2571025788784027,
-0.12812469899654388,
0.24876980483531952,
0.15038825571537018,
-0.7575989961624146,
-0.5971761345863342,
0.29351016879081726,
-0.15639564394950867,
-0.23894008994102478,
0.18301455676555634,
-0.8655006289482117,
-0.5177333950996399,
-0.037271663546562195,
0.40729621052742004,
-0.41086915135383606,
-0.15476201474666595,
0.16792313754558563,
0.15029753744602203,
0.03667900338768959,
0.3712216019630432,
-0.8508692979812622,
0.259789377450943,
0.7154673933982849,
0.868841290473938,
-0.09973225742578506,
-0.301194965839386,
-0.8153400421142578,
0.295585960149765,
-0.5333483219146729,
1.1080524921417236,
-0.10935023427009583,
0.040609244257211685,
-0.0508912056684494,
0.36770349740982056,
-0.09693917632102966,
-0.38206416368484497,
0.7335655093193054,
-0.375499427318573,
0.05650755390524864,
-0.7845802903175354,
-0.9704712629318237,
-0.35520002245903015,
0.6962249875068665,
-0.5549436807632446,
1.2363260984420776,
-0.030387217178940773,
-0.983291506767273,
0.357346773147583,
-0.48178425431251526,
-0.3662741780281067,
-0.04863729700446129,
-0.09612540900707245,
-0.4892173111438751,
-0.11883444339036942,
0.17127549648284912,
0.3687385022640228,
-0.20986364781856537,
0.477931946516037,
-0.5814203023910522,
-0.5679186582565308,
0.11924393475055695,
-0.007786961272358894,
0.6046860814094543,
-0.23475532233715057,
-0.8175206184387207,
-0.029526768252253532,
-0.6572766304016113,
-0.16636468470096588,
0.16459830105304718,
-0.19554708898067474,
-0.18572041392326355,
0.11063488572835922,
-0.43810200691223145,
0.0723203495144844,
0.15589605271816254,
-1.1303362846374512,
0.24184784293174744,
-0.1174553856253624,
0.21495623886585236,
0.6164580583572388,
0.021572457626461983,
0.3458411693572998,
-0.5962212681770325,
0.080329529941082,
-0.049337781965732574,
0.2005561888217926,
-0.24733608961105347,
-0.450783371925354,
-1.0459496974945068,
-0.6585143804550171,
0.2403934895992279,
0.7587425708770752,
-0.7368878722190857,
0.3888542354106903,
-0.3759249448776245,
-0.49672648310661316,
-0.6790711879730225,
0.1852990686893463,
0.2686397135257721,
1.1330620050430298,
0.37892013788223267,
0.08170412480831146,
-0.5123858451843262,
-0.6289538741111755,
0.04447340592741966,
-0.5744965076446533,
0.21421527862548828,
0.2493290901184082,
0.7374342083930969,
-0.11156264692544937,
1.137895107269287,
-0.4328121542930603,
-0.39289382100105286,
0.022033654153347015,
0.5836271643638611,
0.07404990494251251,
0.2732981741428375,
0.49841028451919556,
-0.5321404337882996,
-0.5353912711143494,
-0.15229767560958862,
-0.9319387078285217,
-0.26038607954978943,
-0.33443254232406616,
-0.0016963816015049815,
0.2526015043258667,
0.4079800546169281,
-0.4053134024143219,
0.43451204895973206,
0.7350960373878479,
-0.17200787365436554,
0.6155716180801392,
-0.42390844225883484,
0.5986026525497437,
-0.8574731945991516,
0.19477291405200958,
-0.2974637448787689,
-0.6722673773765564,
-0.465260773897171,
-0.010209501720964909,
0.508998692035675,
0.16440412402153015,
-0.4252091646194458,
0.4248661398887634,
-0.5584210157394409,
-0.051788266748189926,
-0.37635862827301025,
0.31593775749206543,
0.30733636021614075,
0.30995216965675354,
0.005577939562499523,
0.8501992225646973,
0.4801950454711914,
-0.46838098764419556,
0.5280295610427856,
0.5839982032775879,
-0.1670699119567871,
0.784589409828186,
-0.41625112295150757,
0.5002548098564148,
-0.11066778749227524,
0.46427860856056213,
-1.2590590715408325,
-0.08804392069578171,
0.38540953397750854,
-0.5927392840385437,
0.1682281196117401,
-0.7074000239372253,
-0.6645034551620483,
-0.016613846644759178,
-0.6516247987747192,
0.23081110417842865,
0.3659995496273041,
-0.9589061737060547,
0.35682442784309387,
0.08790682256221771,
0.04125538840889931,
-0.350594162940979,
-0.5587354898452759,
0.025317076593637466,
-0.0675520971417427,
-0.7094953656196594,
-0.008761896751821041,
-0.11389470845460892,
-0.021963147446513176,
0.01174770388752222,
0.01801113411784172,
-0.3496024012565613,
-0.09255138784646988,
0.2028864026069641,
0.4325295388698578,
-0.3641152083873749,
0.22396375238895416,
0.06860634684562683,
0.23708155751228333,
0.1369861215353012,
-0.42891043424606323,
0.16912169754505157,
-0.2689511775970459,
-0.5414140820503235,
-0.6095658540725708,
0.2067158818244934,
0.47654908895492554,
-0.2272191047668457,
0.9094474911689758,
0.4688822329044342,
-0.4049730598926544,
-0.32131168246269226,
-0.8269044756889343,
-0.4724694490432739,
-0.5169395804405212,
-0.09039833396673203,
-0.16457577049732208,
-0.8604477643966675,
0.60613614320755,
-0.14323367178440094,
-0.12462713569402695,
0.14775392413139343,
0.27659860253334045,
-0.31637611985206604,
0.5136672854423523,
0.523147463798523,
0.08459514379501343,
-0.043245431035757065,
0.0710744559764862,
0.2827197313308716,
-0.5396732091903687,
-0.30564984679222107,
-0.4736224114894867,
0.03613065183162689,
-0.5770309567451477,
-0.5188896656036377,
0.13730251789093018,
0.021677521988749504,
0.1639765501022339,
0.40601420402526855,
-0.2290334403514862,
0.37334001064300537,
0.25085675716400146,
0.21503683924674988,
0.5354886651039124,
-0.283585786819458,
0.03787875920534134,
-0.1865839809179306,
-0.46413904428482056,
-0.4157474637031555,
1.0923736095428467,
0.2998487651348114,
0.79010009765625,
0.13586172461509705,
0.47638046741485596,
0.6093977689743042,
0.4271579086780548,
-0.6799273490905762,
0.4018341600894928,
0.025347299873828888,
-0.8963948488235474,
-0.19334152340888977,
-0.6420748233795166,
-0.5150790810585022,
-0.14687860012054443,
-0.43671518564224243,
-0.6494636535644531,
0.38915595412254333,
0.4618799686431885,
-0.028588049113750458,
0.854085385799408,
-0.6088739633560181,
0.3363150358200073,
-0.2926844656467438,
-0.551373302936554,
0.18961076438426971,
-0.5677268505096436,
0.574338436126709,
-0.36718660593032837,
0.15334205329418182,
-0.19667105376720428,
0.27848342061042786,
0.5123270750045776,
-0.07728341221809387,
0.8641390204429626,
-0.11703414469957352,
-0.1159888356924057,
0.3298626244068146,
0.5513567924499512,
0.8948080539703369,
0.2703278958797455,
0.12287816405296326,
0.25852668285369873,
0.17495831847190857,
-0.43661296367645264,
-0.6124809384346008,
0.5892172455787659,
-0.3828734755516052,
-0.36151957511901855,
-0.6263881325721741,
-0.4741463363170624,
-0.2724633514881134,
0.3229883909225464,
0.38270455598831177,
0.32532602548599243,
0.07000182569026947,
0.1372014433145523,
1.2073187828063965,
-0.01390339620411396,
0.21984779834747314,
0.7904707193374634,
-0.07248646765947342,
-0.08713435381650925,
0.8934676647186279,
-0.12434464693069458,
0.11979414522647858,
0.38817477226257324,
0.3326488435268402,
-0.8300135135650635,
-0.48538485169410706,
-0.5948589444160461,
0.5278310179710388,
-0.8052999377250671,
-0.24580179154872894,
-0.7067791223526001,
0.01458926685154438,
-0.7376812100410461,
-0.12855854630470276,
-0.8449469804763794,
-0.18475092947483063,
-0.1680488884449005,
-0.027581235393881798,
0.45497235655784607,
0.8933793902397156,
-0.3565700054168701,
0.1506192982196808,
-0.7866345047950745,
0.49012404680252075,
0.2902262806892395,
0.3240502178668976,
-0.4282103180885315,
-0.884290874004364,
0.012684674002230167,
0.1272193342447281,
0.09451419115066528,
-0.9941380023956299,
-0.03303581103682518,
0.3886289894580841,
0.41224297881126404,
0.5897402167320251,
0.662132740020752,
0.3275935649871826,
-0.23457267880439758,
0.28962165117263794,
-0.09340938925743103,
-1.1589000225067139,
0.4371013045310974,
-0.38695549964904785,
-0.32546162605285645,
0.9371238946914673,
0.6647499799728394,
-0.3979184925556183,
-0.07320994883775711,
-0.19280456006526947,
-0.39530259370803833,
0.5887472629547119,
0.16258323192596436,
-0.24404923617839813,
0.07172756642103195,
0.4850078821182251,
0.32206639647483826,
0.1461959034204483,
-0.4684581160545349,
-0.00416033947840333,
-0.4251996874809265,
-0.0046282000839710236,
0.18573056161403656,
-0.18228940665721893,
-0.29516685009002686,
-0.06236928328871727,
0.6361424922943115,
-0.3770666718482971,
0.3061036467552185,
0.4832998514175415,
-0.4144541025161743,
0.13879181444644928,
0.09891059994697571,
0.5086355805397034,
0.6522984504699707,
-0.6609353423118591,
0.4226040244102478,
0.24554584920406342,
-0.5581767559051514,
0.49786919355392456,
-0.11710122227668762,
-0.1755967140197754,
-0.03136148303747177,
0.29116761684417725,
0.4587761163711548,
0.09239096194505692,
-0.5338219404220581,
0.8617542386054993,
-0.3162234425544739,
-0.2625766396522522,
-0.14814482629299164,
-0.20830141007900238,
-0.05809139087796211,
0.11815978586673737,
0.012150680646300316,
-0.24078814685344696,
0.21698695421218872,
-0.6171033382415771,
0.5472965836524963,
-0.04841932654380798,
-0.33004093170166016,
-0.5106639266014099,
0.5509269833564758,
0.10851537436246872,
0.13274088501930237,
0.8692741990089417,
-0.6730414628982544,
-0.7857800722122192,
0.32510286569595337,
0.6947064995765686,
0.43042758107185364,
-0.22753380239009857,
0.5385185480117798,
0.2970852553844452,
0.5865858197212219,
-0.3317387104034424,
0.33026251196861267,
-0.07071049511432648,
-0.7526808977127075,
-0.32409846782684326,
-0.25472399592399597,
-0.7560222744941711,
-0.005876278970390558,
-0.7936249375343323,
0.22051924467086792,
-0.6421517133712769,
0.03592829778790474,
-0.48496052622795105,
-0.1647907793521881,
-0.19850178062915802,
0.4078432619571686,
0.09951537102460861,
0.7941537499427795,
-1.0585243701934814,
0.863014817237854,
0.6497213244438171,
-0.11615032702684402,
-0.5907010436058044,
0.18190978467464447,
0.03600526973605156,
-0.7040991187095642,
0.3997189402580261,
0.14273318648338318,
-0.5019094944000244,
-0.132181778550148,
-0.5776040554046631,
-0.7850337624549866,
0.9457346796989441,
0.7446615695953369,
-0.35464611649513245,
0.19470766186714172,
0.2358582317829132,
0.2841290533542633,
0.12188053876161575,
0.3834386467933655,
0.41945144534111023,
0.3950830101966858,
0.23302730917930603,
-0.6745419502258301,
0.40428364276885986,
-0.0010878684697672725,
-0.6665234565734863,
0.13035398721694946,
-0.6460923552513123,
0.9009093642234802,
-0.035548046231269836,
-0.31913378834724426,
-0.13452987372875214,
0.6570812463760376,
0.3924371600151062,
0.35469797253608704,
0.5427396297454834,
0.502834141254425,
1.1534430980682373,
-0.08812753111124039,
0.7601765394210815,
-0.3898549973964691,
0.8176481127738953,
1.3070403337478638,
-0.5965781807899475,
0.8376456499099731,
0.1839538961648941,
0.16716839373111725,
0.5351793169975281,
0.5773333311080933,
-0.17514589428901672,
0.3794194459915161,
0.038504865020513535,
-0.2621941864490509,
-0.3138647973537445,
-0.3206939101219177,
-0.34551525115966797,
0.6318793296813965,
0.10908564180135727,
0.21177057921886444,
-0.295047402381897,
-0.2641943097114563,
0.32797664403915405,
0.14440901577472687,
0.06602878123521805,
0.36647507548332214,
-0.3048102855682373,
-0.5682226419448853,
0.6478550434112549,
-0.1166948601603508,
0.6294045448303223,
-0.6711517572402954,
-0.13193213939666748,
-0.5939445495605469,
0.28102681040763855,
-0.260593980550766,
-0.6968027949333191,
0.2594943940639496,
0.03891059383749962,
-0.12739655375480652,
-0.11145426332950592,
0.9004940390586853,
-0.2648497223854065,
-0.28545844554901123,
0.520875871181488,
0.31954818964004517,
0.20627674460411072,
-0.25541338324546814,
-0.36322060227394104,
-0.12783266603946686,
-0.13878610730171204,
0.1359945684671402,
0.09821274876594543,
0.4335409104824066,
-0.12210965156555176,
0.6875334978103638,
0.7993263602256775,
0.1551615446805954,
0.3543834984302521,
-0.43271952867507935,
0.7802289724349976,
-0.3418520987033844,
-0.752223551273346,
-0.443558931350708,
0.10641834884881973,
-0.08547122776508331,
-0.21328701078891754,
1.0118364095687866,
0.6064295172691345,
0.826933741569519,
0.18799762427806854,
0.7104061245918274,
0.0009962418116629124,
0.6886318922042847,
-0.47443687915802,
0.9622538089752197,
-0.36203232407569885,
-0.04012267664074898,
-0.03439674526453018,
-0.6277664303779602,
0.11514130979776382,
0.39561283588409424,
-0.11879190802574158,
-0.2831496000289917,
0.9653152823448181,
0.7846601605415344,
-0.4738137722015381,
0.2433290034532547,
0.3051550090312958,
0.2868216931819916,
0.3681849241256714,
0.33649584650993347,
0.8546765446662903,
-0.32606208324432373,
0.4997918903827667,
-0.4296537935733795,
-0.42957642674446106,
-0.1898326873779297,
-1.1738642454147339,
-1.2371200323104858,
-0.3835531771183014,
-0.2781415283679962,
-0.3876315951347351,
0.06766831874847412,
0.6537216305732727,
1.0138001441955566,
-1.1200648546218872,
-0.21295101940631866,
0.15478238463401794,
-0.19126668572425842,
0.24893254041671753,
-0.1705929934978485,
0.47849997878074646,
-0.09400900453329086,
-0.30632057785987854,
0.5911011099815369,
0.3089395761489868,
0.01968231052160263,
-0.20311637222766876,
0.20952771604061127,
-0.5758338570594788,
0.3295726180076599,
0.19497503340244293,
0.5224125385284424,
-0.22616702318191528,
-0.4281715452671051,
0.25012487173080444,
0.007828286848962307,
0.38325631618499756,
0.8161745667457581,
-0.44942837953567505,
0.7060091495513916,
0.7317512631416321,
1.0245587825775146,
0.707780122756958,
0.29760047793388367,
0.09452825039625168,
-0.7226065397262573,
0.023948632180690765,
0.05037952959537506,
0.21161513030529022,
0.6472607254981995,
-0.7670645117759705,
0.15199051797389984,
0.6140132546424866,
-0.5613025426864624,
-0.789584755897522,
0.1094931960105896,
-0.85625159740448,
-0.04505079612135887,
0.8927273750305176,
-0.8085871338844299,
-0.3614293038845062,
-0.3770659565925598,
0.16606786847114563,
0.43274176120758057,
-0.2880127429962158,
1.0686923265457153,
0.5566872358322144,
-0.28853678703308105,
-0.03573349490761757,
-0.5450683832168579,
0.31953251361846924,
0.4855482876300812,
-1.290313959121704,
-0.12237506359815598,
0.14451110363006592,
0.6247410774230957,
0.040289975702762604,
0.45172297954559326,
0.16698025166988373,
0.10672979801893234,
0.021747803315520287,
0.12251394242048264,
-0.12131498754024506,
-0.5591474771499634,
-0.05100459232926369,
0.005920210387557745,
-0.2953655421733856,
-0.503206193447113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06723v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06723v1
|
Global Contrastive Training for Multimodal Electronic Health Records with Language Supervision
| 2024-04-10T04:19:59 | 2024-04-10T04:19:59 |
Yingbo Ma, Suraj Kolla, Zhenhong Hu, Dhruv Kaliraman, Victoria Nolan, Ziyuan Guan, Yuanfang Ren, Brooke Armfield, Tezcan Ozrazgat-Baslanti, Jeremy A. Balch, Tyler J. Loftus, Parisa Rashidi, Azra Bihorac, Benjamin Shickel
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Modern electronic health records (EHRs) hold immense promise in tracking
personalized patient health trajectories through sequential deep learning,
owing to their extensive breadth, scale, and temporal granularity. Nonetheless,
how to effectively leverage multiple modalities from EHRs poses significant
challenges, given its complex characteristics such as high dimensionality,
multimodality, sparsity, varied recording frequencies, and temporal
irregularities. To this end, this paper introduces a novel multimodal
contrastive learning framework, specifically focusing on medical time series
and clinical notes. To tackle the challenge of sparsity and irregular time
intervals in medical time series, the framework integrates temporal
cross-attention transformers with a dynamic embedding and tokenization scheme
for learning multimodal feature representations. To harness the interconnected
relationships between medical time series and clinical notes, the framework
equips a global contrastive loss, aligning a patient's multimodal feature
representations with the corresponding discharge summaries. Since discharge
summaries uniquely pertain to individual patients and represent a holistic view
of the patient's hospital stay, machine learning models are led to learn
discriminative multimodal features via global contrasting. Extensive
experiments with a real-world EHR dataset demonstrated that our framework
outperformed state-of-the-art approaches on the exemplar task of predicting the
occurrence of nine postoperative complications for more than 120,000 major
inpatient surgeries using multimodal data from UF health system split among
three hospitals (UF Health Gainesville, UF Health Jacksonville, and UF Health
Jacksonville-North).
|
[
-0.09805407375097275,
-0.5725774168968201,
0.6234774589538574,
0.09672653675079346,
-0.44675055146217346,
0.13975830376148224,
0.15337194502353668,
-0.5418303608894348,
0.4639100432395935,
0.3574272394180298,
-0.6668341755867004,
-0.6014288067817688,
-0.5551367998123169,
-0.08969592303037643,
-0.01889188028872013,
1.4737828969955444,
-0.20033906400203705,
0.26080653071403503,
-0.10426868498325348,
-0.5464361906051636,
-0.11809885501861572,
-0.6800083518028259,
-0.3324212431907654,
-0.3448898196220398,
0.7117395997047424,
0.06621599942445755,
0.49849966168403625,
0.550515353679657,
0.7276883125305176,
0.3204973638057709,
0.26976242661476135,
0.3425445854663849,
0.02888280525803566,
0.166669100522995,
0.11351639777421951,
-0.1808953434228897,
-0.31897836923599243,
-0.5346947312355042,
0.4101221561431885,
0.4611015319824219,
-0.2937045693397522,
-0.015006264671683311,
-0.10077317804098129,
0.44569969177246094,
-0.3165286183357239,
0.32254546880722046,
-0.25024500489234924,
0.5024024248123169,
-0.1149030551314354,
-0.6125181317329407,
-0.1896561235189438,
-0.11113195866346359,
0.2947653830051422,
-0.6404578685760498,
0.47155508399009705,
-0.10805625468492508,
0.854255199432373,
0.3108189105987549,
-0.8515443205833435,
-0.20292149484157562,
-0.5877120494842529,
0.74613356590271,
-0.23532220721244812,
0.42110365629196167,
0.08699941635131836,
0.6242989897727966,
0.37272074818611145,
-0.8051591515541077,
-0.21913863718509674,
-0.10595232993364334,
-0.27588021755218506,
0.42041414976119995,
0.21723218262195587,
0.2263152152299881,
0.032844237983226776,
0.5127047300338745,
-0.5848069787025452,
-0.030003255233168602,
-0.08098281919956207,
-0.09902048110961914,
0.2537747919559479,
0.5046988129615784,
0.19447112083435059,
-0.0693693533539772,
-0.692399799823761,
-0.15249815583229065,
-0.24881407618522644,
-0.11867885291576385,
-0.17371419072151184,
0.04511890560388565,
-0.7840169668197632,
0.056190721690654755,
0.018220704048871994,
0.16601109504699707,
0.010625595226883888,
-0.5248746871948242,
0.8359103798866272,
-0.41738396883010864,
-0.19624951481819153,
0.043025411665439606,
0.5730524659156799,
0.4890134632587433,
-0.3003889322280884,
-0.029205655679106712,
-0.13788920640945435,
0.26830992102622986,
0.1911810040473938,
-0.71285480260849,
-0.38773950934410095,
0.2895616590976715,
-0.6622551679611206,
-0.11049675196409225,
0.06664802134037018,
-0.9200353026390076,
-0.625360369682312,
-0.5120857357978821,
0.12649008631706238,
-0.39628180861473083,
-0.05173331871628761,
0.03324738144874573,
0.1567849963903427,
-0.3211633265018463,
0.4703448712825775,
-0.8119627237319946,
0.31436267495155334,
0.2360730916261673,
0.9028332829475403,
0.007555051706731319,
-0.046222299337387085,
-0.771859347820282,
0.3092207610607147,
0.08576716482639313,
0.5613309741020203,
-0.43060529232025146,
-0.33559954166412354,
0.17048974335193634,
0.18739768862724304,
-0.1295015662908554,
-0.5000578165054321,
0.2426822930574417,
-0.18465998768806458,
0.20491519570350647,
0.2893352210521698,
-0.17018374800682068,
-0.13237500190734863,
0.4313852787017822,
-0.85661381483078,
0.4824429154396057,
0.16229547560214996,
-0.8364576101303101,
0.45972129702568054,
-0.4305800199508667,
-0.5698423981666565,
-0.2033688724040985,
-0.48840007185935974,
-1.1468408107757568,
-0.1075729951262474,
0.5083367824554443,
0.7234104871749878,
-0.07570826262235641,
0.4917711913585663,
-0.251987487077713,
-0.10278034955263138,
0.1682872474193573,
-0.3739762306213379,
0.4007071256637573,
0.174735426902771,
-0.16525980830192566,
0.36349496245384216,
-1.0362845659255981,
-0.2949216961860657,
0.03749692812561989,
-0.4800328016281128,
-0.23460078239440918,
-0.12391015887260437,
0.6017663478851318,
0.49874570965766907,
-0.26322346925735474,
-0.4506852626800537,
-0.05386841669678688,
-0.14463958144187927,
0.27825307846069336,
0.43809032440185547,
0.4123034179210663,
0.0083139194175601,
-0.7133265733718872,
0.49990347027778625,
0.6282017827033997,
0.28884246945381165,
-0.7007545232772827,
-0.16266478598117828,
-0.4860551357269287,
-0.5106748938560486,
-0.08439930528402328,
0.6222474575042725,
-0.6425754427909851,
0.21145963668823242,
-0.39036205410957336,
-0.2329777479171753,
-0.5349999070167542,
0.07403987646102905,
0.7572581171989441,
0.6994799375534058,
0.6774690747261047,
-0.3158685564994812,
-0.5442913174629211,
-0.7967443466186523,
0.08240092545747757,
0.09048989415168762,
-0.1245831623673439,
0.551009476184845,
0.39268431067466736,
-0.6403553485870361,
0.15563707053661346,
-0.30351191759109497,
-0.8595777750015259,
-0.052245356142520905,
0.3537006676197052,
0.15599796175956726,
0.5801893472671509,
0.3001818060874939,
-0.9770897030830383,
-0.415574312210083,
0.3524695932865143,
-0.7510591149330139,
0.15850922465324402,
-0.6340218782424927,
0.3103426396846771,
0.13749749958515167,
0.6136663556098938,
-0.24659763276576996,
0.09009498357772827,
0.5719035267829895,
-0.22960343956947327,
-0.014117390848696232,
-0.5225054621696472,
0.3163800537586212,
-1.3389180898666382,
0.18844257295131683,
0.35490620136260986,
-0.19924293458461761,
-0.41137397289276123,
-0.33063676953315735,
0.24829672276973724,
-0.07577621936798096,
-0.27105405926704407,
0.5581387877464294,
-0.484019011259079,
0.2810399532318115,
0.44405490159988403,
-0.05048348382115364,
0.21160733699798584,
0.4918122887611389,
0.012345983646810055,
0.07972767949104309,
0.16485115885734558,
-0.3934957981109619,
0.3050721287727356,
0.26714053750038147,
-0.32191184163093567,
0.8416182398796082,
-0.3071528971195221,
-0.21725137531757355,
-0.320704847574234,
0.33656400442123413,
-0.8045400977134705,
-0.4232797622680664,
0.06820974498987198,
-0.28242143988609314,
0.7532773613929749,
-0.12560437619686127,
-0.21168851852416992,
-0.07445409893989563,
-0.32986733317375183,
0.3484567701816559,
0.17771470546722412,
-0.43079596757888794,
0.7758186459541321,
0.3854779005050659,
-0.3700329661369324,
-0.7057249546051025,
-0.9198216795921326,
-0.16931483149528503,
-0.20999027788639069,
-0.30178701877593994,
0.6988829970359802,
0.036022644490003586,
-0.25596627593040466,
0.0646858736872673,
-0.10774558037519455,
-0.12798205018043518,
-0.007035403046756983,
0.4332124590873718,
0.39409390091896057,
-0.12722378969192505,
0.46929189562797546,
0.11905379593372345,
-0.20393656194210052,
-0.08317576348781586,
0.06374366581439972,
0.25630494952201843,
0.06285134702920914,
-0.7343510389328003,
-0.6218316555023193,
0.566475510597229,
0.5940057635307312,
-0.18271256983280182,
0.3578493297100067,
0.7925941348075867,
-0.41381388902664185,
0.11437807977199554,
-0.7943704724311829,
-0.11935567110776901,
-0.35011109709739685,
0.7826012372970581,
-0.1082051545381546,
-0.807894229888916,
0.6979390382766724,
0.05124703794717789,
0.07059015333652496,
0.26341915130615234,
0.44817864894866943,
-0.13223709166049957,
0.9953299164772034,
0.47019460797309875,
-0.10968335717916489,
0.5813523530960083,
-0.17020270228385925,
-0.16586634516716003,
-0.7066290974617004,
-0.7876120805740356,
-0.2549293041229248,
-0.216457337141037,
-0.7776539921760559,
-0.34575003385543823,
0.6332895755767822,
-0.3313613831996918,
-0.27601784467697144,
-0.4796125888824463,
-0.2716929614543915,
0.1918911188840866,
0.11944673210382462,
0.6359017491340637,
0.22491636872291565,
0.12824563682079315,
-0.3782021105289459,
-0.23071779310703278,
-0.31171804666519165,
-0.03853346034884453,
0.8983107209205627,
0.2662043869495392,
0.8762579560279846,
0.0282012727111578,
0.6831217408180237,
0.4146122634410858,
0.2964136600494385,
-0.4163041114807129,
-0.03272836282849312,
-0.3433266282081604,
-0.20895928144454956,
0.10060777515172958,
-0.3680882453918457,
-0.8649886846542358,
0.3005619943141937,
-0.388363242149353,
-0.27303510904312134,
0.05944390222430229,
0.5573310256004333,
-0.46214988827705383,
0.382440984249115,
-0.63212651014328,
0.9417756199836731,
-0.4125429093837738,
-0.5050880312919617,
-0.24766597151756287,
-1.171011209487915,
0.06888564676046371,
0.13388022780418396,
0.3630881905555725,
0.10748545825481415,
-0.30358055233955383,
0.21766680479049683,
-0.10641048103570938,
1.0443065166473389,
-0.12539002299308777,
0.2288317084312439,
-0.23431266844272614,
-0.04498307779431343,
0.17828214168548584,
0.2989901006221771,
0.41457661986351013,
0.14800018072128296,
-0.13010933995246887,
-0.2952811121940613,
-0.31572747230529785,
0.7496013641357422,
-0.6572027802467346,
-0.12251607328653336,
-0.5493002533912659,
-0.5051180124282837,
-0.32230144739151,
0.05879317596554756,
0.011463094502687454,
0.9428269267082214,
-0.328742116689682,
0.19160905480384827,
0.712740421295166,
-0.3661930561065674,
0.4366694688796997,
0.40343907475471497,
0.05761386454105377,
-0.8671067953109741,
0.8418947458267212,
-0.009678332135081291,
-0.05225749313831329,
1.0190504789352417,
0.16633881628513336,
-0.3612871766090393,
-0.3893234431743622,
-0.5328885912895203,
0.30298855900764465,
-0.8714916110038757,
-0.12863317131996155,
-0.8607229590415955,
-0.05943719297647476,
-0.17864854633808136,
-0.32612064480781555,
0.1640380322933197,
-0.03667226806282997,
-0.3711867332458496,
-0.07809579372406006,
0.09866702556610107,
0.536577582359314,
0.21009944379329681,
0.09033499658107758,
-1.1315386295318604,
0.39138251543045044,
0.18049077689647675,
0.39484214782714844,
-0.20007839798927307,
-0.34310978651046753,
-0.37986916303634644,
-0.6022884845733643,
-0.48016977310180664,
-0.5507861971855164,
0.5112545490264893,
0.4450071156024933,
0.6896551251411438,
0.747109055519104,
-0.19479206204414368,
0.6677767634391785,
-0.618943452835083,
0.5559800863265991,
0.6454506516456604,
-0.6046490669250488,
0.5024439692497253,
-0.341644823551178,
0.37318918108940125,
0.3990630805492401,
0.556336522102356,
-0.7544647455215454,
-0.10457143187522888,
-0.614136815071106,
-0.9395877718925476,
0.4642348885536194,
-0.4838073253631592,
-0.02372831292450428,
-0.11509004980325699,
0.005671681370586157,
0.306907057762146,
0.3141041100025177,
-0.7236162424087524,
-0.2794205844402313,
-0.3449515998363495,
-0.656743049621582,
-0.346225380897522,
-0.24418841302394867,
-0.16754800081253052,
0.2359904646873474,
0.3429846167564392,
-0.3194236755371094,
0.1515946090221405,
0.3278150260448456,
-0.19727860391139984,
-0.015661513432860374,
0.5943412780761719,
0.7430391311645508,
0.4664192199707031,
-0.18981067836284637,
0.309677392244339,
-0.014974982477724552,
-0.4298083484172821,
0.0348501093685627,
0.4913260042667389,
0.19913744926452637,
0.17720378935337067,
0.4821516275405884,
0.8404831290245056,
0.4446733295917511,
-0.5447874665260315,
0.4956108033657074,
0.1136702299118042,
-0.004779329057782888,
-0.4219362139701843,
-0.35600465536117554,
-0.031131930649280548,
0.28202614188194275,
0.0794929713010788,
0.2046605795621872,
0.2949162721633911,
-0.3134113848209381,
0.37047475576400757,
0.1462102234363556,
-0.6869558691978455,
-0.3403950035572052,
0.7400608658790588,
0.3200953006744385,
0.11597985029220581,
0.31347447633743286,
0.32433465123176575,
-0.18795835971832275,
0.5648159980773926,
0.4303339719772339,
0.6819645762443542,
-0.6536215543746948,
0.03556130453944206,
0.2864817976951599,
0.04650193452835083,
0.11351839452981949,
0.4066464602947235,
-0.08215554803609848,
-0.18170864880084991,
-0.28497928380966187,
-0.17289641499519348,
-0.44884562492370605,
0.28051459789276123,
-0.7537744045257568,
0.2394382655620575,
-0.5622283220291138,
-0.25239282846450806,
-0.024782473221421242,
-0.25772061944007874,
-0.5720506310462952,
0.40640780329704285,
0.28133243322372437,
0.24994049966335297,
-0.919409990310669,
0.5975115895271301,
0.8568099737167358,
-0.6218194365501404,
-0.239210307598114,
0.06604105234146118,
0.47630831599235535,
-0.5344629883766174,
0.6518178582191467,
0.4856421649456024,
-0.01881512999534607,
-0.5158874988555908,
0.3308338522911072,
-0.3387233316898346,
0.9653483033180237,
0.2518067955970764,
-0.721152663230896,
-0.15269185602664948,
0.00711348420009017,
0.593260645866394,
-0.3037188947200775,
0.22324779629707336,
0.06619258970022202,
-0.10331772267818451,
-0.17229989171028137,
-0.7996858358383179,
-0.04018750414252281,
-0.5306011438369751,
-0.05709575489163399,
0.4403228461742401,
-0.7577611804008484,
0.8209256529808044,
-0.4541153013706207,
-0.043300870805978775,
-0.28333228826522827,
0.3363419771194458,
0.08467330783605576,
0.535731315612793,
0.27511945366859436,
0.6389292478561401,
0.6556456089019775,
-0.14753137528896332,
1.1601334810256958,
-0.2689751982688904,
0.1304144710302353,
1.1802208423614502,
-0.2929154634475708,
0.4846225380897522,
0.5824140310287476,
-0.017329946160316467,
0.8175094127655029,
0.4671923816204071,
-0.1311320960521698,
0.660556972026825,
0.11125405877828598,
-0.582631528377533,
-0.23947855830192566,
-0.14794829487800598,
-0.42409709095954895,
-0.0062014078721404076,
0.6232448220252991,
-0.6774716377258301,
-0.1690785139799118,
0.3459768295288086,
-0.010088029317557812,
0.09492158144712448,
-0.29846319556236267,
0.9264416098594666,
0.1637655347585678,
-0.4097113311290741,
0.18289296329021454,
-0.3351224958896637,
0.6153099536895752,
-0.8291225433349609,
-0.5120362639427185,
-0.25289449095726013,
0.6933649778366089,
-0.3225195109844208,
-0.3548229932785034,
0.13121460378170013,
-0.3839524984359741,
-0.384433776140213,
-0.2145063579082489,
0.21460185945034027,
-0.5075250267982483,
-0.31633469462394714,
0.43226027488708496,
0.22088594734668732,
-0.23763097822666168,
0.42197516560554504,
-0.7674573659896851,
-0.03841215372085571,
-0.20376965403556824,
-0.10679367184638977,
0.5209903717041016,
0.5956535339355469,
-0.06878452748060226,
0.7398310303688049,
0.2292896956205368,
0.1916806697845459,
-0.2543051540851593,
0.4270099401473999,
0.7465618252754211,
-0.4794783592224121,
-0.962814211845398,
-0.8027040362358093,
0.7278481721878052,
-0.06037110462784767,
-0.3937857151031494,
0.33808672428131104,
0.5533638596534729,
0.9569242000579834,
-0.14180758595466614,
0.7888162732124329,
0.3191385865211487,
0.8611483573913574,
-0.7812567353248596,
0.45445680618286133,
-0.7266903519630432,
0.22201897203922272,
-0.14954620599746704,
-0.17775535583496094,
-0.705134928226471,
0.4226994216442108,
0.0656118392944336,
0.11261098831892014,
0.8691149950027466,
0.433910071849823,
-0.2322831004858017,
-0.4045385718345642,
0.3569132089614868,
-0.04009775444865227,
0.3279751241207123,
0.694378137588501,
0.4540759325027466,
-0.22822383046150208,
0.7436173558235168,
-0.43525931239128113,
-0.05818507820367813,
-0.46072807908058167,
-0.7519454956054688,
-0.9374829530715942,
-0.5067787766456604,
-0.5585941672325134,
-0.3163030445575714,
0.17002901434898376,
1.2173410654067993,
0.7153803110122681,
-1.0957273244857788,
0.10209494829177856,
0.33926814794540405,
-0.3004903197288513,
-0.22702209651470184,
-0.14666339755058289,
0.7075071334838867,
-0.2629031538963318,
-0.48845043778419495,
0.07059045135974884,
0.4273376762866974,
0.257841020822525,
-0.043078795075416565,
0.040522705763578415,
-0.013361076824367046,
-0.6570727229118347,
0.4296868145465851,
0.12435559928417206,
-0.8074215054512024,
-0.044004589319229126,
-0.029786191880702972,
-0.39871180057525635,
0.46326780319213867,
1.1134040355682373,
-0.606107771396637,
0.8000009059906006,
0.21578100323677063,
0.7644509077072144,
0.47644418478012085,
-0.07201530784368515,
0.019804449751973152,
-0.9334861040115356,
0.20804746448993683,
0.42632925510406494,
0.7334532737731934,
0.5163106322288513,
-0.45329567790031433,
0.2783501446247101,
0.36268889904022217,
-0.46591806411743164,
-0.4590827524662018,
0.059041883796453476,
-0.9749965667724609,
-0.08838452398777008,
0.6874191761016846,
-0.3986358940601349,
0.20525796711444855,
-0.5539276003837585,
-0.17795045673847198,
0.3599332869052887,
-0.5020627975463867,
0.9438959360122681,
0.15193189680576324,
-0.4010050296783447,
-0.39868155121803284,
-0.5682915449142456,
0.4062124788761139,
0.27118194103240967,
-0.9510542750358582,
-0.16690319776535034,
0.7922689318656921,
0.2615312337875366,
0.3772829473018646,
0.612309455871582,
-0.4903568923473358,
0.3943939208984375,
-0.022911114618182182,
0.20481956005096436,
-0.24352765083312988,
-0.4002624452114105,
-0.7059659361839294,
0.28442704677581787,
-0.31416383385658264,
-0.2464567869901657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06714v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06714v3
|
Llama-VITS: Enhancing TTS Synthesis with Semantic Awareness
| 2024-04-10T03:46:03 | 2024-04-18T03:54:38 |
Xincan Feng, Akifumi Yoshimoto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recent advancements in Natural Language Processing (NLP) have seen
Large-scale Language Models (LLMs) excel at producing high-quality text for
various purposes. Notably, in Text-To-Speech (TTS) systems, the integration of
BERT for semantic token generation has underscored the importance of semantic
content in producing coherent speech outputs. Despite this, the specific
utility of LLMs in enhancing TTS synthesis remains considerably limited. This
research introduces an innovative approach, Llama-VITS, which enhances TTS
synthesis by enriching the semantic content of text using LLM. Llama-VITS
integrates semantic embeddings from Llama2 with the VITS model, a leading
end-to-end TTS framework. By leveraging Llama2 for the primary speech synthesis
process, our experiments demonstrate that Llama-VITS matches the naturalness of
the original VITS (ORI-VITS) and those incorporate BERT (BERT-VITS), on the
LJSpeech dataset, a substantial collection of neutral, clear speech. Moreover,
our method significantly enhances emotive expressiveness on the EmoV_DB_bea_sem
dataset, a curated selection of emotionally consistent speech from the EmoV_DB
dataset, highlighting its potential to generate emotive speech.
|
[
-0.11650090664625168,
-0.7724478840827942,
0.5569201111793518,
0.3931964635848999,
-0.5418314337730408,
0.25518977642059326,
-0.28723639249801636,
-0.5810160040855408,
0.7283936738967896,
0.3711606562137604,
-0.4068087935447693,
-0.8109199404716492,
-0.5292422771453857,
0.21715548634529114,
-0.7234535217285156,
0.9802548885345459,
0.068637415766716,
-0.17125950753688812,
0.030749138444662094,
0.18147315084934235,
-0.39657723903656006,
-0.319560170173645,
-0.3570913076400757,
-0.1359233260154724,
0.5224019885063171,
0.31720787286758423,
0.4465576708316803,
0.6778320670127869,
0.18942880630493164,
0.21302390098571777,
-0.26075875759124756,
0.28235891461372375,
-0.5738240480422974,
0.7297714948654175,
-0.004530446603894234,
-0.37494173645973206,
-0.5747655034065247,
-0.40372398495674133,
0.6453139185905457,
0.26171958446502686,
-0.01213056966662407,
0.1665468066930771,
0.10807040333747864,
0.43893328309059143,
-0.5938394069671631,
0.0990535318851471,
-1.1201239824295044,
0.18480542302131653,
-0.18753646314144135,
-0.19300901889801025,
-0.3100174069404602,
-0.28471535444259644,
0.4422844350337982,
-0.6882685422897339,
-0.22713160514831543,
-0.2487049102783203,
0.548073410987854,
0.6211423277854919,
-0.3898409605026245,
-0.09060748666524887,
-0.6388407349586487,
0.6659395694732666,
-0.661928653717041,
0.5181290507316589,
0.08114704489707947,
0.10162721574306488,
-0.2474939525127411,
-0.845725953578949,
-0.6214873790740967,
-0.18719278275966644,
0.3494623899459839,
0.3993232846260071,
-0.3663147985935211,
0.061416175216436386,
-0.08922630548477173,
0.13135674595832825,
-0.24912577867507935,
0.16958102583885193,
-0.11671444773674011,
-0.3336232900619507,
0.44171348214149475,
0.16394591331481934,
0.0685998722910881,
-0.27979305386543274,
-0.661783754825592,
0.01929698884487152,
-0.8059704303741455,
-0.14682723581790924,
0.15198934078216553,
0.33746829628944397,
0.002385936677455902,
0.9908112287521362,
-0.3117329478263855,
0.5296233296394348,
-0.25959810614585876,
-0.3175950050354004,
0.2614191770553589,
-0.27839362621307373,
-0.3545231819152832,
0.21163201332092285,
0.5161890387535095,
0.4987603425979614,
0.25968295335769653,
-0.1762125939130783,
-0.22170180082321167,
0.41023126244544983,
0.11637315154075623,
-0.677753210067749,
0.18993380665779114,
0.1484190821647644,
-0.020355893298983574,
-0.48135513067245483,
-0.29616302251815796,
-0.5254406332969666,
-0.34720736742019653,
-0.5393369197845459,
0.4678419530391693,
-0.3583093285560608,
-0.31387123465538025,
0.095396026968956,
-0.21386708319187164,
0.40133389830589294,
0.5399731993675232,
-0.7804519534111023,
0.2483425885438919,
0.710426926612854,
0.6067137718200684,
-0.12732477486133575,
-0.07297448068857193,
-0.5144903659820557,
0.6715365648269653,
-0.480699747800827,
0.7940245270729065,
-0.47690942883491516,
-0.3915780782699585,
-0.0648222267627716,
-0.5201547741889954,
0.3737359642982483,
-0.28693050146102905,
0.46521738171577454,
-0.24373047053813934,
-0.20943166315555573,
-0.28969040513038635,
-0.48068660497665405,
-0.013077646493911743,
0.2400379180908203,
-0.15293830633163452,
1.2609864473342896,
-0.13015058636665344,
-0.49408113956451416,
0.32483723759651184,
-0.4943564832210541,
-0.5020318627357483,
-0.156777486205101,
-0.20459863543510437,
-0.16564379632472992,
0.31099626421928406,
0.28847751021385193,
0.4567909836769104,
-0.35101279616355896,
0.28346487879753113,
-0.08712605386972427,
-0.11129331588745117,
0.47596442699432373,
-0.4756002426147461,
0.24544808268547058,
0.16623464226722717,
-0.20341351628303528,
0.17141714692115784,
-0.6336622834205627,
0.04862576350569725,
0.16892077028751373,
-0.3202936351299286,
-0.2501469850540161,
0.018639422953128815,
0.08618425577878952,
0.02974878065288067,
0.4582308232784271,
-0.5928759574890137,
-0.1507045179605484,
-0.6610586047172546,
0.5223510265350342,
0.9053246974945068,
-0.07040421664714813,
0.23030760884284973,
-0.19521692395210266,
0.20949707925319672,
-0.17795434594154358,
0.11311107128858566,
-0.09543343633413315,
-0.8441455364227295,
-1.000644326210022,
-0.4034014642238617,
0.051627084612846375,
0.6487500667572021,
-0.5032535195350647,
0.5585171580314636,
-0.5106684565544128,
-0.5583020448684692,
-0.6421421766281128,
0.1254454404115677,
0.2470933049917221,
0.6233161687850952,
0.32890185713768005,
-0.3916122615337372,
-0.8337514996528625,
-0.871358335018158,
-0.3081953823566437,
-0.5021524429321289,
-0.20226210355758667,
0.12108016014099121,
0.20323453843593597,
-0.3008940815925598,
1.1999255418777466,
-0.35722801089286804,
-0.4512092173099518,
-0.07914326339960098,
-0.29767051339149475,
-0.1115020215511322,
0.3119010031223297,
0.21056607365608215,
-0.5560726523399353,
-0.29267269372940063,
0.018733389675617218,
-0.5387559533119202,
-0.2960698902606964,
0.1513548642396927,
-0.2493566870689392,
0.10712297260761261,
0.45137283205986023,
-0.530346155166626,
0.5654408931732178,
0.35710567235946655,
-0.18967795372009277,
0.15662962198257446,
0.07784424722194672,
-0.11333385854959488,
-1.1446175575256348,
-0.11047407984733582,
-0.3036169409751892,
-0.33002954721450806,
-0.6722590923309326,
-0.37521636486053467,
-0.419292688369751,
-0.023929579183459282,
-0.5662509799003601,
0.39893069863319397,
-0.062123313546180725,
-0.4722632169723511,
-0.05169687047600746,
0.5673296451568604,
0.16919440031051636,
0.36966031789779663,
0.06135094165802002,
0.7058734893798828,
0.4553133249282837,
-0.4047606289386749,
0.39952564239501953,
0.5308761596679688,
-0.12325814366340637,
0.44692671298980713,
-0.7962478995323181,
0.15649273991584778,
0.043610937893390656,
0.26698267459869385,
-1.0675616264343262,
-0.37451186776161194,
0.26006177067756653,
-0.5890194773674011,
0.08161238580942154,
0.008253766223788261,
-0.5716559290885925,
0.10784804821014404,
-0.4480656385421753,
0.17376108467578888,
0.6669647693634033,
-0.5254611372947693,
0.8368046283721924,
0.7321615219116211,
-0.5188170671463013,
-0.38186559081077576,
-1.10299813747406,
0.5418478846549988,
-0.20329147577285767,
-0.6708683371543884,
0.4974382221698761,
0.14354464411735535,
-0.192450612783432,
-0.05980956554412842,
-0.053282786160707474,
0.18347769975662231,
0.08709369599819183,
0.17389264702796936,
0.11655938625335693,
-0.2012758105993271,
0.3668867349624634,
0.46638381481170654,
-0.23946703970432281,
0.0012809319887310266,
-0.3604103624820709,
0.312802255153656,
-0.3203267753124237,
-0.4196305572986603,
-0.6125684976577759,
0.35167524218559265,
0.5577983260154724,
-0.2264987826347351,
0.29128217697143555,
0.6034619808197021,
-0.3393995761871338,
-0.1751321405172348,
-0.677788496017456,
-0.20425313711166382,
-0.408511757850647,
0.4176288843154907,
-0.2518494427204132,
-1.1457130908966064,
0.3484284579753876,
-0.11579099297523499,
0.06978663802146912,
0.3657829463481903,
0.7698308825492859,
-0.05145428329706192,
0.9174551367759705,
0.3878194987773895,
0.06156076490879059,
0.734714686870575,
0.06066344678401947,
0.02569260634481907,
-0.976848304271698,
-0.305091917514801,
-0.34132176637649536,
-0.15718410909175873,
-0.7202281355857849,
-0.5620302557945251,
0.620520830154419,
-0.3820606768131256,
-0.2566159963607788,
0.12116599082946777,
-0.5793545842170715,
0.2810542583465576,
0.45869868993759155,
0.18779140710830688,
0.42640092968940735,
0.4580921530723572,
0.01249868143349886,
-0.13581016659736633,
-0.579087495803833,
-0.742451012134552,
1.1413613557815552,
0.426577627658844,
0.6687988638877869,
0.3486822843551636,
0.8097518086433411,
0.12954697012901306,
0.24579688906669617,
-0.8376998901367188,
0.6788316965103149,
-0.216336190700531,
-0.18189063668251038,
-0.27249884605407715,
-0.12464830279350281,
-0.7695487141609192,
0.19274280965328217,
-0.3974308967590332,
-0.8425868153572083,
-0.054062601178884506,
0.1263621598482132,
-0.145815908908844,
0.08965620398521423,
-0.7586842179298401,
0.3241838216781616,
0.037546586245298386,
-0.4009956121444702,
-0.3595457077026367,
-0.7933038473129272,
0.19420404732227325,
0.06399598717689514,
-0.03151462972164154,
-0.37167057394981384,
-0.4781387150287628,
0.737418532371521,
-0.22994327545166016,
1.2011315822601318,
0.19140438735485077,
-0.4349037706851959,
0.48275455832481384,
0.11058851331472397,
0.5112242102622986,
0.2791654169559479,
-0.08629468083381653,
0.17830659449100494,
-0.41941162943840027,
-0.034216564148664474,
-0.3872873783111572,
0.72287917137146,
-0.6052548885345459,
-0.8161869645118713,
-0.0627678632736206,
-0.5130754709243774,
-0.30405473709106445,
0.06315881758928299,
-0.07372160255908966,
0.3431727886199951,
-0.30572509765625,
0.06722643971443176,
0.6304776668548584,
-0.11104349046945572,
-0.011885836720466614,
0.24100974202156067,
-0.39736834168434143,
-0.6724125742912292,
0.8401463031768799,
-0.05425078794360161,
0.42585524916648865,
0.5151827335357666,
0.24209411442279816,
-0.3444143235683441,
-0.4192894697189331,
-0.4150506556034088,
0.14165422320365906,
-0.8819044232368469,
-0.4309326112270355,
-0.6545894145965576,
-0.1704436093568802,
-0.47715938091278076,
-0.18482932448387146,
-0.5069398880004883,
-0.8110213279724121,
-0.482610821723938,
-0.3040209710597992,
0.9061524868011475,
0.8906991481781006,
-0.24773436784744263,
0.17660784721374512,
-0.6730384230613708,
0.45503997802734375,
0.5366787910461426,
0.20120778679847717,
-0.1388639509677887,
-0.5196887254714966,
0.016736630350351334,
0.11268378794193268,
-0.21922160685062408,
-0.8676623702049255,
0.367750346660614,
0.23984453082084656,
0.31308797001838684,
0.12098371982574463,
-0.07841238379478455,
0.5817307233810425,
-0.41174808144569397,
0.9189210534095764,
0.20775341987609863,
-1.418304204940796,
0.8976303935050964,
-0.3864384889602661,
-0.02475186251103878,
0.20837698876857758,
-0.39531534910202026,
-0.47694069147109985,
-0.9348849058151245,
-0.4261627793312073,
-1.119340419769287,
0.3011641204357147,
0.6201701760292053,
0.20345573127269745,
-0.17038792371749878,
0.159071683883667,
0.05834968760609627,
0.17023542523384094,
-0.5243333578109741,
0.018563680350780487,
-0.3589121401309967,
-0.5259237885475159,
0.17184069752693176,
-0.36383873224258423,
-0.2097649872303009,
0.004065564833581448,
0.7149552702903748,
-0.10225646942853928,
0.4434836506843567,
0.48904576897621155,
-0.03977643698453903,
0.0945965051651001,
0.3429497480392456,
0.5883761644363403,
0.0662866085767746,
-0.07775834202766418,
0.273441880941391,
0.5022845268249512,
-0.4132336676120758,
0.06360789388418198,
-0.1467447727918625,
-0.19397002458572388,
0.04088824242353439,
0.3023413419723511,
0.8961849212646484,
0.15182942152023315,
-0.6624001860618591,
0.41504114866256714,
-0.019742552191019058,
0.19669651985168457,
-0.34871527552604675,
0.11875019967556,
0.22479248046875,
0.3930360674858093,
0.1810896098613739,
0.05632146820425987,
0.10738658905029297,
-0.14895810186862946,
-0.025731444358825684,
0.3729654550552368,
-0.3022458553314209,
-0.3575412333011627,
0.64796382188797,
0.43961459398269653,
-0.15544672310352325,
0.28807735443115234,
0.2971307039260864,
-0.49016979336738586,
0.45249468088150024,
0.5873891115188599,
1.128608226776123,
-0.2710956931114197,
-0.07721284031867981,
-0.0016198980156332254,
0.40518268942832947,
0.15693074464797974,
0.4490410089492798,
-0.2744174599647522,
-0.6771564483642578,
-0.5147866606712341,
-0.6005578637123108,
-0.5266093015670776,
-0.4200126826763153,
-0.504340410232544,
0.3834623098373413,
-0.3837471008300781,
-0.35809326171875,
-0.2663707733154297,
-0.4540100693702698,
-0.5654014945030212,
0.22769978642463684,
0.31794941425323486,
0.7158816456794739,
-0.7615067958831787,
0.736563503742218,
0.44203248620033264,
-0.18217240273952484,
-0.7041451334953308,
0.014792299829423428,
-0.11215194314718246,
-0.9138166904449463,
0.6878461837768555,
0.12405487895011902,
-0.5713823437690735,
0.33093124628067017,
-0.35708487033843994,
-0.9061754941940308,
1.2092957496643066,
0.6517906785011292,
-0.3556472361087799,
0.24257448315620422,
0.4227598309516907,
0.6494913101196289,
-0.5237962007522583,
-0.12160452455282211,
0.5174503326416016,
0.45497259497642517,
0.12791411578655243,
-0.890761137008667,
0.09015683084726334,
-0.04851669445633888,
0.36075103282928467,
-0.05616569519042969,
-0.3914836049079895,
0.4258587062358856,
-0.38020163774490356,
-0.25872698426246643,
0.21126535534858704,
0.9610339403152466,
0.36409664154052734,
0.0938861072063446,
0.5001180768013,
0.5548674464225769,
0.7202337384223938,
-0.01704137772321701,
0.8359214067459106,
-0.036557700484991074,
-0.04702821001410484,
0.8124379515647888,
-0.4485131502151489,
1.0845575332641602,
0.8776535391807556,
-0.08238032460212708,
0.3857557475566864,
0.3348483145236969,
0.39413177967071533,
0.564648449420929,
0.2591864764690399,
-0.5633692145347595,
-0.30193835496902466,
-0.6016013026237488,
-0.472552627325058,
0.6472625732421875,
0.7021512389183044,
-0.23867157101631165,
-0.061115562915802,
-0.08076617866754532,
-0.06986270844936371,
0.024517778307199478,
-0.059591736644506454,
1.0637590885162354,
0.1581563651561737,
-0.29797428846359253,
0.4547211825847626,
-0.18027323484420776,
0.5367858409881592,
-0.6587427854537964,
-0.08248087763786316,
0.025370793417096138,
-0.08815651386976242,
-0.10014307498931885,
-0.9307605028152466,
0.36525076627731323,
0.3364570438861847,
-0.012624942697584629,
-0.2511948347091675,
0.886365532875061,
-0.5109937191009521,
-0.3495701551437378,
0.40500369668006897,
0.4872378706932068,
0.07039406895637512,
0.2290440946817398,
-0.2734498679637909,
0.4302513301372528,
0.05843961238861084,
-0.3520703911781311,
0.11415719985961914,
0.6664912104606628,
0.09280029684305191,
0.5922436118125916,
0.8814160823822021,
0.10136177390813828,
-0.06820274144411087,
0.19893795251846313,
1.0790855884552002,
-0.48973697423934937,
-0.506401777267456,
-0.8324429392814636,
0.590585470199585,
0.10691680759191513,
-0.3479001820087433,
0.5214524269104004,
0.30030325055122375,
0.5917235612869263,
0.03561928868293762,
0.935917854309082,
0.1306343376636505,
0.44228729605674744,
-0.7951831817626953,
0.47156423330307007,
-0.447942852973938,
0.3879924714565277,
-0.5081980228424072,
-0.7728375792503357,
-0.4422607421875,
0.7207167744636536,
-0.03335762023925781,
-0.27522075176239014,
0.22875894606113434,
0.9032305479049683,
0.36908939480781555,
0.140139639377594,
0.4426347315311432,
0.46104082465171814,
0.4989815354347229,
0.5235047340393066,
1.1184399127960205,
-0.387212872505188,
0.5581089854240417,
-0.014730487018823624,
-0.22966061532497406,
-0.1211303174495697,
-1.1708136796951294,
-0.6068317294120789,
-0.4995754063129425,
-0.2026112973690033,
-0.19164498150348663,
0.11072932183742523,
1.0410977602005005,
0.30002379417419434,
-0.4753943085670471,
-0.1525312215089798,
-0.1611972600221634,
0.22665002942085266,
0.14711391925811768,
-0.1365594118833542,
0.27900007367134094,
-0.2887747883796692,
-0.6283628940582275,
0.6397465467453003,
0.6139827370643616,
0.4092426598072052,
-0.09980975091457367,
0.01009693555533886,
0.12963318824768066,
0.26373371481895447,
0.8582427501678467,
-0.159593403339386,
-1.036171317100525,
-0.4469505846500397,
0.08236277103424072,
-0.049756381660699844,
-0.0005364707903936505,
0.46663394570350647,
-1.0561835765838623,
0.37605035305023193,
0.45648670196533203,
0.6984156370162964,
0.46779680252075195,
-0.3702187240123749,
0.6078304052352905,
-0.8439684510231018,
0.26171261072158813,
0.29196229577064514,
0.3332446813583374,
0.5927117466926575,
-0.2341894805431366,
0.49969831109046936,
0.10781148076057434,
-0.2609531581401825,
-0.8547376990318298,
0.44984516501426697,
-1.2464812994003296,
0.12311126291751862,
1.3674609661102295,
0.12686479091644287,
-0.22148677706718445,
-0.0037873636465519667,
-0.390912801027298,
0.570419192314148,
-0.6546667814254761,
0.6408963203430176,
0.30809080600738525,
0.03468210995197296,
0.3952341675758362,
-0.29986703395843506,
0.29804208874702454,
0.6251431703567505,
-0.8901134133338928,
0.2597142457962036,
0.4084996283054352,
0.12127615511417389,
0.0728178545832634,
0.4580914080142975,
-0.1433032602071762,
0.1678907424211502,
0.004948053043335676,
0.0961230993270874,
0.003988016862422228,
-0.23030966520309448,
-0.014613298699259758,
-0.14779594540596008,
0.04574461281299591,
-0.05094527825713158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06711v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06711v1
|
MathVC: An LLM-Simulated Multi-Character Virtual Classroom for Mathematics Education
| 2024-04-10T03:35:51 | 2024-04-10T03:35:51 |
Murong Yue, Wijdane Mifdal, Yixuan Zhang, Jennifer Suh, Ziyu Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Mathematical modeling (MM) is considered a fundamental skill for students in
STEM disciplines. Practicing the MM skill is often the most effective when
students can engage in group discussion and collaborative problem-solving.
However, due to unevenly distributed teachers and educational resources needed
to monitor such group activities, students do not always receive equal
opportunities for this practice. Excitingly, large language models (LLMs) have
recently demonstrated strong capability in both modeling mathematical problems
and simulating characters with different traits and properties. Drawing
inspiration from the advancement of LLMs, in this work, we present MATHVC, the
very first LLM-powered virtual classroom containing multiple LLM-simulated
student characters, with whom a human student can practice their MM skill. To
encourage each LLM character's behaviors to be aligned with their specified
math-relevant properties (termed "characteristics alignment") and the overall
conversational procedure to be close to an authentic student MM discussion
(termed "conversational procedural alignment"), we proposed three innovations:
integrating MM domain knowledge into the simulation, defining a symbolic schema
as the ground for character simulation, and designing a meta planner at the
platform level to drive the conversational procedure. Through experiments and
ablation studies, we confirmed the effectiveness of our simulation approach and
showed the promise for MATHVC to benefit real-life students in the future.
|
[
-0.40745458006858826,
-0.9708704948425293,
0.39296942949295044,
0.24087274074554443,
-0.2130519598722458,
0.5408158302307129,
-0.06941275298595428,
0.0561860129237175,
0.3780381381511688,
0.4317542612552643,
-0.817972719669342,
-0.5333457589149475,
-0.146180659532547,
0.000052428826165851206,
-0.22116471827030182,
0.669875979423523,
0.09005516767501831,
0.6233914494514465,
-0.6417277455329895,
0.05288464576005936,
-0.6580659747123718,
-0.9782335162162781,
-0.24334855377674103,
-0.2749302387237549,
0.4508230984210968,
0.3034871816635132,
0.684699535369873,
0.5922560095787048,
0.6673282980918884,
0.34992945194244385,
0.2758748531341553,
0.30001118779182434,
-0.4647204577922821,
-0.04486963897943497,
0.0953516960144043,
-0.6211621165275574,
-0.7218430042266846,
-0.04138610139489174,
0.7479446530342102,
0.7563675045967102,
-0.517047643661499,
-0.15260863304138184,
-0.0764031857252121,
0.410647451877594,
-0.005219233687967062,
0.2907889783382416,
-0.44101181626319885,
0.02204267308115959,
-0.07982990145683289,
0.03297580033540726,
-0.31817537546157837,
-0.4114196002483368,
0.02302294597029686,
-0.8509508967399597,
0.016238296404480934,
-0.18102197349071503,
0.4590541422367096,
0.2009333223104477,
-0.3186880946159363,
-0.2747530937194824,
-0.6279107332229614,
0.997570812702179,
-0.33440902829170227,
0.3700444996356964,
0.04477180168032646,
0.6582797169685364,
0.07068652659654617,
-0.3534559905529022,
-0.6007201671600342,
-0.011312758550047874,
0.38159334659576416,
0.12116867303848267,
0.044651322066783905,
0.07298658788204193,
0.40261539816856384,
0.004169057123363018,
-0.38116055727005005,
0.04173193499445915,
-0.5608419179916382,
-0.2718028128147125,
0.4052276015281677,
0.5877497792243958,
0.34489426016807556,
0.04639165475964546,
-0.14019709825515747,
-0.1408773511648178,
-0.675862729549408,
0.03813488036394119,
0.44654229283332825,
0.43811559677124023,
-0.16296137869358063,
0.9750092029571533,
0.357616662979126,
0.5278337597846985,
-0.46006104350090027,
-0.41345328092575073,
-0.01760771870613098,
-0.4004003405570984,
-0.12244418263435364,
0.16819916665554047,
0.42813849449157715,
0.13476277887821198,
0.6079069972038269,
0.2889820635318756,
0.38199952244758606,
0.6326748132705688,
0.337643027305603,
-0.9022444486618042,
-0.1631261110305786,
-0.24286186695098877,
-0.20432649552822113,
-0.48970067501068115,
0.0032339643221348524,
-0.7836665511131287,
-0.3034195601940155,
-0.7795432209968567,
0.2387843132019043,
-0.4469645321369171,
-0.3615029752254486,
0.11814787238836288,
0.3086433410644531,
0.2814781069755554,
0.6286014914512634,
-0.9330605864524841,
0.5897353291511536,
0.9772067666053772,
0.6831182837486267,
-0.24812889099121094,
-0.20916864275932312,
-0.3910491466522217,
-0.18764038383960724,
-0.23364882171154022,
0.34071940183639526,
-0.8552539348602295,
-0.7275992035865784,
0.06268395483493805,
-0.40952107310295105,
0.24083273112773895,
-0.2483237087726593,
0.4428260028362274,
-0.21889512240886688,
0.20192588865756989,
-0.2790282964706421,
-0.48230868577957153,
0.186859130859375,
0.2691658139228821,
-0.45109522342681885,
0.4273899793624878,
0.15408377349376678,
-0.4188789129257202,
0.021364865824580193,
-0.4805610477924347,
0.004468579776585102,
0.23803508281707764,
-0.6277960538864136,
-0.4565443992614746,
0.08577774465084076,
0.07845943421125412,
0.1454182267189026,
-0.1813536137342453,
0.24722816050052643,
-0.21477600932121277,
-0.4887377917766571,
0.602390706539154,
-0.6055756211280823,
0.6728318929672241,
0.029252883046865463,
0.25762221217155457,
0.022016113623976707,
-0.6118292212486267,
0.1221359446644783,
0.10821991413831711,
0.038091473281383514,
-0.3209898769855499,
-0.11906657367944717,
-0.24622561037540436,
0.30995529890060425,
0.08524627983570099,
-0.4902960956096649,
0.722295343875885,
-0.41539666056632996,
0.20578143000602722,
0.7111920714378357,
-0.284505695104599,
0.4067632555961609,
-0.5918623208999634,
0.9613087177276611,
-0.20177949965000153,
0.015701312571763992,
-0.556540846824646,
-0.704348623752594,
-0.6719600558280945,
-0.42096173763275146,
0.30448344349861145,
0.5437467098236084,
-0.8282797336578369,
-0.010116057470440865,
-0.31292566657066345,
-0.4853353500366211,
-0.6075245141983032,
0.040689364075660706,
0.5875564813613892,
0.3230127692222595,
0.12134970724582672,
-0.12691031396389008,
-0.554523229598999,
-0.5006462335586548,
-0.1367865353822708,
-0.19104818999767303,
-0.13090300559997559,
0.5198174118995667,
0.22985230386257172,
-0.14903606474399567,
1.043957233428955,
-0.5612059831619263,
-0.4588586390018463,
-0.2558245062828064,
-0.07532380521297455,
0.16677208244800568,
0.25257524847984314,
0.5192590355873108,
-0.49482598900794983,
-0.5207748413085938,
-0.14368383586406708,
-0.7865542769432068,
-0.30649086833000183,
-0.028645113110542297,
-0.368496835231781,
0.062453001737594604,
0.3269912600517273,
-0.3253672122955322,
0.3917967975139618,
0.6035374999046326,
-0.15625806152820587,
0.7850618362426758,
-0.21098381280899048,
0.07860216498374939,
-1.0782383680343628,
-0.35891470313072205,
-0.11646314710378647,
-0.0720520168542862,
-0.5275871753692627,
-0.03944544494152069,
0.01986030861735344,
-0.6246301531791687,
-0.510827362537384,
0.5178753733634949,
-0.18084843456745148,
-0.05490885302424431,
-0.10776953399181366,
0.18419663608074188,
-0.0741473063826561,
0.5472729802131653,
0.032678358256816864,
0.968060314655304,
0.48330092430114746,
-0.5147544741630554,
0.49292242527008057,
0.2436872273683548,
-0.2208617776632309,
0.905189037322998,
-0.6417215466499329,
-0.010538328438997269,
-0.05093976855278015,
-0.03581901639699936,
-0.7304796576499939,
-0.08226599544286728,
-0.07962244749069214,
-0.5226910710334778,
0.04331159591674805,
-0.1387108713388443,
-0.3786315321922302,
-0.339079886674881,
-0.010330015793442726,
0.6280072331428528,
0.594777524471283,
-0.26478949189186096,
0.8995331525802612,
0.4777257442474365,
-0.21952757239341736,
-0.3844466507434845,
-0.5391381978988647,
-0.10695961117744446,
-0.20461827516555786,
-0.8233152627944946,
0.17061646282672882,
-0.4352041184902191,
-0.42560508847236633,
-0.20477841794490814,
0.18593673408031464,
-0.10079971700906754,
-0.003682417329400778,
0.307073175907135,
0.7079508304595947,
-0.2075926959514618,
0.24539583921432495,
0.10629023611545563,
-0.26868870854377747,
0.11948170512914658,
-0.12301462888717651,
0.7159080505371094,
-0.27456751465797424,
-0.8364614844322205,
-0.45180827379226685,
0.26789599657058716,
0.7779759764671326,
-0.21501757204532623,
0.569691002368927,
0.0025573757011443377,
-0.4983943700790405,
-0.024967016652226448,
-0.5034489631652832,
-0.10630097985267639,
-0.4775243401527405,
0.3687276840209961,
-0.45000332593917847,
-0.9222270846366882,
0.40839144587516785,
-0.20911775529384613,
0.37305334210395813,
-0.07653304934501648,
0.5507436990737915,
-0.016151554882526398,
1.1037713289260864,
0.7060291767120361,
0.26286131143569946,
0.4854338765144348,
-0.15237677097320557,
0.22967159748077393,
-0.7154608964920044,
-0.4472416043281555,
-0.4379061758518219,
-0.10816244781017303,
-0.29431524872779846,
-0.9084307551383972,
0.5036401748657227,
-0.08343018591403961,
-0.12505683302879333,
0.30695411562919617,
-0.2905450463294983,
0.5922170877456665,
0.1565362811088562,
-0.023831643164157867,
0.3469407558441162,
0.3336591422557831,
-0.6127155423164368,
-0.9216936826705933,
-0.30374911427497864,
-0.5022491812705994,
1.0134973526000977,
0.28675922751426697,
0.9377768635749817,
0.27343878149986267,
0.5771358609199524,
-0.021046997979283333,
0.3870752155780792,
-0.9137670993804932,
0.710486650466919,
-0.10487300902605057,
-0.3104056715965271,
-0.3246742784976959,
-0.6621059775352478,
-0.6178677082061768,
0.4830476939678192,
-0.30021581053733826,
-0.3414517939090729,
-0.3257448077201843,
0.08359088003635406,
-0.1615535467863083,
0.24015682935714722,
-0.5319536924362183,
0.6667956113815308,
-0.42275315523147583,
-0.4539497196674347,
-0.33279669284820557,
-0.2009705901145935,
0.5954450368881226,
-0.2733457684516907,
0.5435437560081482,
0.016896020621061325,
0.1337612122297287,
0.12510891258716583,
-0.6188251972198486,
0.7616789937019348,
0.14472714066505432,
-0.09797240793704987,
0.4550420343875885,
0.5571216940879822,
0.16072732210159302,
-0.009733066894114017,
-0.12677675485610962,
0.17223739624023438,
-0.24264980852603912,
-0.10852838307619095,
-0.7784050703048706,
0.7810696363449097,
-0.9974743723869324,
-0.5793597102165222,
-0.4184509813785553,
-0.4467337429523468,
-0.053532905876636505,
0.009787642396986485,
-0.3569120466709137,
0.4923475980758667,
-0.4611071050167084,
0.27927154302597046,
0.7818728089332581,
-0.18189212679862976,
0.23825113475322723,
0.48955294489860535,
-0.7800623774528503,
-0.6475939750671387,
1.275915503501892,
0.1924894154071808,
0.4074043929576874,
0.3843133747577667,
0.40638604760169983,
-0.16300109028816223,
0.2663826048374176,
-0.30912286043167114,
0.4795567989349365,
-0.4748210906982422,
-0.031585436314344406,
-0.8003211617469788,
-0.5705907344818115,
-0.3025064468383789,
-0.5329611897468567,
-0.4371894299983978,
-0.5059628486633301,
-0.5414823293685913,
0.023430481553077698,
-0.010000353679060936,
0.44990527629852295,
0.20470650494098663,
0.4994666874408722,
-0.5873811841011047,
0.20143073797225952,
0.7962663173675537,
0.19187729060649872,
-0.24626143276691437,
-0.43487808108329773,
0.11833906173706055,
0.29556918144226074,
-0.6405673623085022,
-0.48379430174827576,
0.6781598329544067,
0.1224527359008789,
0.48822230100631714,
0.49977344274520874,
-0.34830254316329956,
0.8367036581039429,
-0.6959547996520996,
0.7067809700965881,
0.6115433573722839,
-1.0855668783187866,
0.35171201825141907,
-0.2577429711818695,
0.17137326300144196,
0.14459601044654846,
0.1238861232995987,
-0.6957048177719116,
-0.03719364479184151,
-0.4968528747558594,
-0.17756453156471252,
0.4707712233066559,
0.3827379643917084,
0.37538546323776245,
0.19143758714199066,
0.229034423828125,
0.14638106524944305,
0.5981468558311462,
-0.565078854560852,
-0.2538084089756012,
-0.3740631639957428,
-0.2908126413822174,
0.1938593089580536,
-0.20880913734436035,
-0.046240340918302536,
-0.2866953909397125,
0.3057973086833954,
-0.21280252933502197,
0.21092987060546875,
-0.27766579389572144,
0.14516828954219818,
-0.17035441100597382,
0.0643654391169548,
0.9176445603370667,
0.8568954467773438,
0.2804233133792877,
-0.0067895385436713696,
0.2506050765514374,
-0.6948259472846985,
0.15522240102291107,
-0.25003474950790405,
0.17921079695224762,
-0.019728776067495346,
0.13951337337493896,
0.4728207588195801,
0.441055029630661,
-0.7321656942367554,
0.6322645545005798,
-0.43368974328041077,
-0.4270891845226288,
-0.4288225769996643,
0.25871944427490234,
0.0904199406504631,
0.06929444521665573,
0.1176036074757576,
-0.22685547173023224,
-0.28847455978393555,
-0.51961749792099,
0.2411590963602066,
0.5687070488929749,
-0.32062846422195435,
-0.17607063055038452,
0.6394437551498413,
0.4208482503890991,
-0.8775328993797302,
0.7472286224365234,
0.033093906939029694,
-0.5981522798538208,
0.8093841671943665,
0.6863829493522644,
0.46783265471458435,
-0.36002984642982483,
0.29730501770973206,
0.3368135392665863,
0.2314683049917221,
0.10247448831796646,
0.343536376953125,
0.11908231675624847,
-0.5141977071762085,
-0.40649622678756714,
-0.5935363173484802,
-0.810212254524231,
-0.4467616677284241,
-0.2547280192375183,
0.8758057951927185,
-0.5278748273849487,
-0.02989218756556511,
-0.28384435176849365,
0.26064422726631165,
-0.5591936707496643,
-0.34956222772598267,
0.1953883171081543,
0.6897792220115662,
-0.7060268521308899,
0.8783419132232666,
0.3876574635505676,
-0.11573512107133865,
-0.7068167924880981,
-0.5719497799873352,
0.24427568912506104,
-1.04660964012146,
0.5769150853157043,
0.15152719616889954,
-0.01341320015490055,
0.10127335041761398,
-0.6375641226768494,
-0.6829444766044617,
1.1339802742004395,
0.43125656247138977,
-0.8733025789260864,
-0.22060860693454742,
0.4895733594894409,
0.5886565446853638,
-0.6367279887199402,
0.34374091029167175,
-0.035085901618003845,
-0.0030809349846094847,
0.6612712740898132,
-0.8072782754898071,
-0.5062277913093567,
-0.13155163824558258,
0.08093607425689697,
0.19347688555717468,
-0.6862086057662964,
0.9542016386985779,
-0.39376193284988403,
-0.003920774441212416,
0.17097115516662598,
0.8433939814567566,
0.8352991938591003,
0.2144172191619873,
0.2360142022371292,
0.5043367147445679,
0.8567113280296326,
-0.2494630515575409,
0.6865143775939941,
-0.2779548466205597,
0.1796770840883255,
0.8304619789123535,
-0.4043341875076294,
0.3626609742641449,
0.3275614082813263,
-0.14150603115558624,
0.568145215511322,
0.04388802498579025,
-0.05838366225361824,
0.2883448600769043,
0.7797223925590515,
-0.35836464166641235,
-0.5421059131622314,
-0.2928345501422882,
-0.5110260248184204,
0.3215715289115906,
0.6999346613883972,
0.03986647352576256,
-0.07681070268154144,
0.09304238855838776,
-0.07905013859272003,
0.3678206503391266,
-0.41575372219085693,
0.4577610194683075,
0.24324727058410645,
-0.36361929774284363,
-0.07980848103761673,
-0.03199874982237816,
0.44730907678604126,
-0.8582922220230103,
-0.5242405533790588,
0.004570640157908201,
0.06538528203964233,
0.07470525056123734,
-0.6164361238479614,
0.06095347926020622,
0.05085618048906326,
0.019596872851252556,
-0.4112303853034973,
0.37230443954467773,
-0.6400879621505737,
-0.9551772475242615,
-0.1768675297498703,
0.36859238147735596,
0.2802729308605194,
0.21102087199687958,
-0.46021267771720886,
0.349409282207489,
-0.28991836309432983,
0.49029311537742615,
0.43758851289749146,
0.8005970120429993,
-0.23961777985095978,
0.7736458778381348,
0.940507709980011,
-0.009916640818119049,
0.16316093504428864,
0.3111964464187622,
0.9947922229766846,
-0.45141926407814026,
-0.5025284886360168,
-0.8259645104408264,
0.6288684606552124,
0.04812100902199745,
-0.27013832330703735,
0.6269800066947937,
0.5391431450843811,
0.5805124044418335,
0.10155817121267319,
0.5154684782028198,
0.5613419413566589,
0.2901791036128998,
-0.3620341122150421,
0.45286762714385986,
-0.3151206970214844,
0.3151976764202118,
-0.5749408602714539,
-1.0327787399291992,
-0.2729583978652954,
0.8926554322242737,
0.20012228190898895,
0.12124644219875336,
0.6438919305801392,
0.4015766978263855,
0.03009939007461071,
0.08940719813108444,
0.8209678530693054,
-0.15016038715839386,
0.7911085486412048,
0.5702281594276428,
0.8608306646347046,
-0.2247672826051712,
0.6888546347618103,
-0.18993744254112244,
-0.33676213026046753,
-0.1853625774383545,
-0.8221765160560608,
-1.3169101476669312,
-0.24868574738502502,
-0.3108161985874176,
-0.2974766790866852,
-0.28344041109085083,
1.0329946279525757,
0.5082911849021912,
-0.27037543058395386,
-0.4814876317977905,
-0.22194306552410126,
0.3446391224861145,
0.013846246525645256,
-0.20021548867225647,
-0.12957032024860382,
0.06573513895273209,
-0.7407865524291992,
0.13372431695461273,
0.24952362477779388,
0.28855758905410767,
-0.7293885946273804,
-0.1046585738658905,
0.24222004413604736,
0.22836899757385254,
0.4694688022136688,
0.1249106377363205,
-0.6356276273727417,
0.10435737669467926,
0.5205950140953064,
-0.502691388130188,
-0.052233029156923294,
1.1259338855743408,
-0.7827978730201721,
0.746258020401001,
0.178707554936409,
0.7369805574417114,
0.1747950166463852,
0.17509321868419647,
0.517808735370636,
-0.5170884728431702,
0.008184891194105148,
0.2928188145160675,
0.2535306513309479,
0.05947265774011612,
-0.24753506481647491,
0.2595781981945038,
0.4229024350643158,
-0.5679324269294739,
-0.8057785034179688,
0.21485047042369843,
-0.9735495448112488,
0.11094176024198532,
0.8691966533660889,
0.002207267563790083,
-0.18737439811229706,
0.18335914611816406,
-0.5914580225944519,
0.14992012083530426,
-0.3007911145687103,
0.7257463932037354,
1.026380181312561,
0.019736725836992264,
-0.2360755354166031,
-0.5101925730705261,
-0.0006988854147493839,
0.18848231434822083,
-0.8550973534584045,
0.01239709835499525,
0.44462788105010986,
-0.076078861951828,
0.178341805934906,
0.4583592414855957,
-0.324606716632843,
0.16022029519081116,
-0.1576470583677292,
0.11266957223415375,
-0.3392968773841858,
-0.6457021832466125,
-0.31882721185684204,
0.06942693144083023,
-0.2938923239707947,
0.07864696532487869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08692v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08692v1
|
Apollonion: Profile-centric Dialog Agent
| 2024-04-10T03:32:41 | 2024-04-10T03:32:41 |
Shangyu Chen, Zibo Zhao, Yuanyuan Zhao, Xiang Li
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) has innovated the development
of dialog agents. Specially, a well-trained LLM, as a central process unit, is
capable of providing fluent and reasonable response for user's request.
Besides, auxiliary tools such as external knowledge retrieval, personalized
character for vivid response, short/long-term memory for ultra long context
management are developed, completing the usage experience for LLM-based dialog
agents. However, the above-mentioned techniques does not solve the issue of
\textbf{personalization from user perspective}: agents response in a same
fashion to different users, without consideration of their features, such as
habits, interests and past experience. In another words, current implementation
of dialog agents fail in ``knowing the user''. The capacity of well-description
and representation of user is under development. In this work, we proposed a
framework for dialog agent to incorporate user profiling (initialization,
update): user's query and response is analyzed and organized into a structural
user profile, which is latter served to provide personal and more precise
response. Besides, we proposed a series of evaluation protocols for
personalization: to what extend the response is personal to the different
users.
The framework is named as \method{}, inspired by inscription of ``Know
Yourself'' in the temple of Apollo (also known as \method{}) in Ancient Greek.
Few works have been conducted on incorporating personalization into LLM,
\method{} is a pioneer work on guiding LLM's response to meet individuation via
the application of dialog agents, with a set of evaluation methods for
measurement in personalization.
|
[
-0.511505663394928,
-0.8691710829734802,
0.5450435876846313,
0.16526563465595245,
-0.09301037341356277,
0.25708508491516113,
-0.12402880191802979,
-0.4726129174232483,
0.5203415155410767,
0.6956387162208557,
-0.5381552577018738,
-0.6363590955734253,
-0.045082006603479385,
0.15404535830020905,
-0.07549316436052322,
0.7447158098220825,
0.30359405279159546,
0.13513901829719543,
-0.0385623462498188,
-0.14191602170467377,
-0.6218497157096863,
-0.48270314931869507,
-0.9748483300209045,
-0.3354843258857727,
0.5079447627067566,
0.327675998210907,
0.310865581035614,
0.5680796504020691,
0.12598079442977905,
0.4732789397239685,
-0.3251315653324127,
0.11702156811952591,
-0.5225485563278198,
0.4368208944797516,
-0.24724870920181274,
-0.4804075360298157,
-0.5430179834365845,
0.18661342561244965,
0.5006277561187744,
0.5533487796783447,
-0.0340285561978817,
0.007034079171717167,
0.15896956622600555,
0.3958119750022888,
-0.38685598969459534,
0.1622554212808609,
-0.2946617007255554,
0.1953052282333374,
-0.11818980425596237,
-0.6148382425308228,
-0.09241194278001785,
-0.2197714000940323,
0.3818438649177551,
-0.717517614364624,
0.08514062315225601,
0.2301965355873108,
0.12920472025871277,
-0.04841342568397522,
-0.4372399151325226,
-0.6344340443611145,
-0.9069882035255432,
0.5759478211402893,
-0.7103185057640076,
0.08423513919115067,
0.1863609105348587,
0.603659987449646,
-0.026050586253404617,
-0.5215479731559753,
-0.5009452700614929,
-0.6043709516525269,
-0.003173625562340021,
0.2477719485759735,
0.4174202084541321,
0.19286681711673737,
-0.03595752269029617,
0.5003398656845093,
-0.18153280019760132,
0.18529364466667175,
-0.43694213032722473,
-0.5161658525466919,
0.32984527945518494,
0.623809814453125,
-0.07086923718452454,
-0.2231939285993576,
-0.5634171366691589,
0.04428057745099068,
-0.4652399718761444,
0.19838373363018036,
0.45935142040252686,
0.20877335965633392,
-0.09255731105804443,
0.5330140590667725,
-0.6922067999839783,
0.47109365463256836,
0.36570367217063904,
-0.5067079663276672,
0.20631608366966248,
-0.30432212352752686,
-0.16250765323638916,
0.105861134827137,
0.6976068019866943,
0.3229425847530365,
0.12920817732810974,
-0.3206614553928375,
-0.09816256910562515,
-0.3851436972618103,
0.20334608852863312,
-0.8023808598518372,
0.5217896103858948,
0.23531478643417358,
-0.3860340118408203,
-0.5247870087623596,
-0.020042087882757187,
-0.6424155235290527,
-0.6534373164176941,
-0.24029918015003204,
0.13491977751255035,
-0.4138842225074768,
0.08833770453929901,
-0.11655621230602264,
0.37649065256118774,
0.0952892005443573,
0.5463682413101196,
-0.6745883226394653,
0.2938810884952545,
0.6570922136306763,
0.7332872748374939,
-0.18931244313716888,
-0.19163618981838226,
-0.4053782522678375,
0.05192416533827782,
-0.10922535508871078,
0.579213559627533,
-0.6135915517807007,
-0.5778211355209351,
0.3518754243850708,
-0.07700680941343307,
0.18504880368709564,
-0.6950063705444336,
0.2394568920135498,
-0.7988664507865906,
0.4617856442928314,
-0.2535861134529114,
-0.596837043762207,
-0.2674022316932678,
0.5074639320373535,
-0.15458562970161438,
0.7352827191352844,
0.227050319314003,
-0.5153470039367676,
0.18145115673542023,
-0.7250393629074097,
-0.16422078013420105,
0.5679376125335693,
-0.18623097240924835,
0.10094589740037918,
0.12222538143396378,
-0.1650516241788864,
0.5489754676818848,
-0.3923244774341583,
0.09308139979839325,
-0.2975671589374542,
-0.4698980450630188,
0.49043625593185425,
0.02994653955101967,
0.6185364723205566,
0.4501716196537018,
-0.17758740484714508,
0.22533825039863586,
-0.7417259812355042,
0.0602288618683815,
-0.14151324331760406,
-0.6338919401168823,
-0.2916327714920044,
-0.2698781192302704,
0.1042601689696312,
0.16151000559329987,
0.6766010522842407,
-0.6026321649551392,
0.17459599673748016,
-0.5973567366600037,
0.3419076204299927,
0.9467042088508606,
-0.15502499043941498,
0.49175068736076355,
-0.1784462034702301,
0.7629461288452148,
-0.0457075759768486,
0.08150529116392136,
-0.3801014721393585,
-0.14816106855869293,
-0.5725513100624084,
-0.12928472459316254,
-0.12939871847629547,
0.7059433460235596,
-0.4494098722934723,
0.6334750652313232,
0.06852658092975616,
-0.38590192794799805,
-0.17965641617774963,
0.44632476568222046,
0.6921858191490173,
0.8672556281089783,
-0.10477522015571594,
-0.6548528671264648,
-0.4404459595680237,
-1.0690537691116333,
-0.1308635026216507,
-0.4195188283920288,
0.023672128096222878,
0.7073326706886292,
0.21119049191474915,
-0.3858494758605957,
0.9538643956184387,
-0.44965222477912903,
-0.5221475958824158,
-0.4643486738204956,
-0.1578819751739502,
0.15338753163814545,
0.11531199514865875,
0.4392573833465576,
-0.5844292044639587,
-0.5629863142967224,
0.14500226080417633,
-0.883601725101471,
-0.3014093041419983,
0.07256455719470978,
-0.03207254037261009,
-0.0969572365283966,
0.3857811689376831,
-0.5652987957000732,
0.2072257101535797,
0.2984539270401001,
-0.3812423646450043,
0.711794376373291,
-0.08865755051374435,
0.15174530446529388,
-1.5443674325942993,
0.10200254619121552,
0.09320313483476639,
-0.592082142829895,
-0.685400664806366,
0.008178732357919216,
-0.3749544024467468,
-0.11673931777477264,
-0.503002405166626,
1.1077780723571777,
-0.10639296472072601,
-0.025653813034296036,
-0.6555770039558411,
0.28188785910606384,
-0.2654860317707062,
0.6400371789932251,
-0.2625495195388794,
1.0011440515518188,
0.5555262565612793,
-0.6635913848876953,
0.6509526371955872,
0.4145941734313965,
0.0188848078250885,
1.138109564781189,
-0.62811678647995,
0.4104727506637573,
-0.12482189387083054,
0.17708702385425568,
-0.8256532549858093,
-0.24731911718845367,
0.7196595072746277,
-0.30684158205986023,
0.034784894436597824,
0.06786516308784485,
-0.4315487742424011,
-0.13141490519046783,
-0.5448563098907471,
0.14177116751670837,
0.2812713086605072,
-0.3394688069820404,
0.8234301805496216,
0.14923258125782013,
-0.12089335173368454,
-0.4043097496032715,
-0.023104481399059296,
0.06488249450922012,
-0.7880077958106995,
-0.6797234416007996,
0.25567296147346497,
-0.49924832582473755,
-0.2771177589893341,
-0.3407149314880371,
-0.10261718183755875,
0.11428871005773544,
0.0520392507314682,
0.2621990740299225,
0.11668835580348969,
-0.17215415835380554,
0.08471012860536575,
-0.34229880571365356,
-0.2241908758878708,
-0.05994139611721039,
-0.20466342568397522,
0.7584508061408997,
-0.28290727734565735,
0.04264180362224579,
-1.046856164932251,
0.253643661737442,
0.5565453171730042,
0.10856261849403381,
0.7984235286712646,
0.5256038308143616,
0.00648439209908247,
0.1542477160692215,
-0.8877614140510559,
-0.32495036721229553,
-0.5515297651290894,
0.4323592782020569,
-0.439559668302536,
-1.2306389808654785,
0.8847622275352478,
-0.32038700580596924,
-0.10979720205068588,
0.03189116343855858,
0.7839990258216858,
-0.2805919349193573,
0.8279003500938416,
0.760894238948822,
-0.2947608232498169,
0.6856535077095032,
-0.0025052970740944147,
-0.02634122036397457,
-1.3677592277526855,
-0.31600502133369446,
-0.3304370939731598,
-0.19552192091941833,
-0.519026517868042,
0.09905311465263367,
0.3955405354499817,
0.016486769542098045,
-0.23186172544956207,
0.1754235327243805,
-0.24827559292316437,
-0.009548184461891651,
0.5047860741615295,
-0.03735702484846115,
0.37064290046691895,
0.02514941245317459,
-0.11205094307661057,
0.10279707610607147,
-0.06613638252019882,
-0.786686897277832,
1.020917296409607,
0.286986768245697,
0.9224688410758972,
-0.014376931823790073,
0.6777430176734924,
0.49676650762557983,
0.29258766770362854,
-0.7930512428283691,
0.6810951232910156,
0.40073394775390625,
-0.7925349473953247,
-0.41757041215896606,
-0.48244884610176086,
-0.8379392623901367,
0.326175332069397,
0.1176750585436821,
-1.406065821647644,
-0.0768115296959877,
0.4295364320278168,
-0.4532938599586487,
-0.23084746301174164,
-0.6265724897384644,
0.5152079463005066,
-0.1861397624015808,
-0.445414662361145,
-0.10407615453004837,
-0.5297467708587646,
0.16804836690425873,
-0.06410427391529083,
-0.09258795529603958,
-0.10144214332103729,
0.02568335458636284,
0.7946192622184753,
-0.5701767206192017,
1.032131314277649,
-0.24780884385108948,
0.05164981260895729,
0.293523371219635,
0.11832615733146667,
0.4874700903892517,
0.6077336072921753,
0.044439513236284256,
-0.48126381635665894,
-0.034955982118844986,
-0.1842339187860489,
-0.6222121119499207,
0.8132623434066772,
-0.6705079078674316,
-1.02266526222229,
-0.17939668893814087,
-0.38623395562171936,
-0.3595319390296936,
0.2809297442436218,
0.20607304573059082,
0.29274898767471313,
-0.4813252389431,
0.0354202501475811,
0.56350177526474,
-0.1906569004058838,
0.09496267139911652,
0.7609686255455017,
-0.361417680978775,
-0.5056901574134827,
0.4555022418498993,
-0.24485725164413452,
-0.030384816229343414,
0.18720325827598572,
0.27043813467025757,
-0.21218298375606537,
-0.4537854790687561,
-0.16727790236473083,
0.4757932424545288,
-0.5550966262817383,
-0.12381646037101746,
-0.3535573184490204,
-0.14077624678611755,
-0.2625795900821686,
-0.10210518538951874,
-0.41741421818733215,
-0.051439352333545685,
-0.25034013390541077,
0.03673631697893143,
0.1797904074192047,
0.5593739151954651,
0.3918909728527069,
0.9012116193771362,
-0.29724621772766113,
0.10522789508104324,
0.3972899913787842,
0.21016192436218262,
-0.053344037383794785,
-0.4130387306213379,
-0.36460080742836,
-0.13527849316596985,
-0.6037691831588745,
-0.8249331712722778,
0.24133490025997162,
0.07809451222419739,
0.5096086859703064,
0.8660595417022705,
-0.36250656843185425,
0.3776189982891083,
-0.18348973989486694,
0.40326225757598877,
0.070433609187603,
-0.6509968042373657,
0.4560539126396179,
-0.2584691047668457,
0.28670111298561096,
0.69667649269104,
-0.025866996496915817,
-0.9518263339996338,
-0.3140261471271515,
-0.19698524475097656,
-0.6194464564323425,
0.8153082132339478,
0.25744038820266724,
0.6196572780609131,
0.27228447794914246,
0.9366965293884277,
0.18934504687786102,
0.5086343288421631,
-0.42967095971107483,
-0.41230475902557373,
-0.02832529880106449,
-0.04284612461924553,
-0.2099117934703827,
-0.3154284656047821,
-0.19228708744049072,
0.07816257327795029,
0.55890291929245,
-0.3756735026836395,
0.306772917509079,
0.31833434104919434,
-0.012306059710681438,
0.1333761364221573,
0.334248811006546,
0.4887915849685669,
0.858227550983429,
-0.37317538261413574,
-0.1719207465648651,
0.08067753165960312,
-0.47823527455329895,
0.10782618820667267,
0.12758685648441315,
-0.25776955485343933,
-0.5476455688476562,
0.30260413885116577,
0.5571746230125427,
-0.04779261350631714,
-0.6420908570289612,
0.2555237114429474,
-0.17324642837047577,
0.22933095693588257,
-0.8962169885635376,
0.28454649448394775,
0.16142813861370087,
0.5110010504722595,
0.4693097472190857,
-0.19557610154151917,
0.4269212484359741,
-0.7517679929733276,
-0.3017566204071045,
0.5685070753097534,
-0.685083270072937,
-0.7017824053764343,
0.6996871829032898,
0.33993858098983765,
-0.6106303930282593,
0.4354604482650757,
-0.1440647393465042,
-0.45687517523765564,
0.4077921509742737,
0.4041939079761505,
0.7896799445152283,
-0.45498326420783997,
0.28907766938209534,
0.057936616241931915,
-0.2639699876308441,
0.3558414876461029,
0.1664859503507614,
-0.2084689438343048,
-0.837731659412384,
0.027134153991937637,
-0.5966380834579468,
-0.11568666994571686,
0.33743414282798767,
-0.28434863686561584,
0.026444345712661743,
-0.7506388425827026,
-0.40423423051834106,
-0.06797771155834198,
0.26765695214271545,
-0.9171881079673767,
0.12894634902477264,
-0.029955508187413216,
0.8577563166618347,
-0.3957216441631317,
0.553763747215271,
0.9647622108459473,
-0.2024863362312317,
-0.5090230107307434,
-0.10150433331727982,
0.32203736901283264,
-0.7237723469734192,
0.7306793928146362,
0.29908257722854614,
-0.30664727091789246,
-0.15053628385066986,
-0.4048810601234436,
-0.5152841806411743,
1.3045247793197632,
0.22556699812412262,
-0.4140898883342743,
-0.044565580785274506,
0.13368740677833557,
0.7919889092445374,
-0.9944420456886292,
0.22830210626125336,
0.4193536937236786,
0.284572571516037,
0.2799931466579437,
-0.8340725302696228,
0.10135924071073532,
-0.2556309700012207,
0.36116617918014526,
-0.3440016508102417,
-0.9690935015678406,
0.45241865515708923,
0.15096165239810944,
0.06548846513032913,
0.5248298645019531,
0.7022682428359985,
0.3035951256752014,
0.5327677130699158,
0.44326260685920715,
0.33333587646484375,
0.524235188961029,
0.2531321346759796,
1.060638427734375,
-0.33816400170326233,
0.3585377633571625,
0.8720384240150452,
-0.4014735817909241,
0.155446395277977,
0.5112535357475281,
0.08738868683576584,
0.1900254637002945,
0.5664225220680237,
0.23312243819236755,
0.5211067795753479,
0.11384321004152298,
-0.44204503297805786,
-0.0580274723470211,
-0.2923712730407715,
-0.17065659165382385,
0.6108635663986206,
0.18518203496932983,
-0.5258016586303711,
0.1266174167394638,
0.11230271309614182,
0.26700878143310547,
0.032049063593149185,
-0.14294566214084625,
0.8172636032104492,
0.036763884127140045,
-0.5351206660270691,
0.252795934677124,
0.2576860785484314,
0.7003902196884155,
-0.5869502425193787,
0.22585684061050415,
-0.5035629868507385,
0.12197092920541763,
-0.008903270587325096,
-0.3793986439704895,
-0.20559094846248627,
-0.33409103751182556,
0.10956026613712311,
0.0467076413333416,
0.60820072889328,
0.07073065638542175,
-0.2499988079071045,
0.35261091589927673,
0.7303414940834045,
0.14335061609745026,
0.02326059900224209,
-0.5534238219261169,
-0.1420116275548935,
-0.05591801553964615,
-0.6071608662605286,
0.2140350341796875,
0.1372227817773819,
-0.13048014044761658,
0.8862462639808655,
0.34877175092697144,
0.09128023684024811,
-0.07715513557195663,
0.03187035024166107,
0.9872545599937439,
-0.654279887676239,
-0.48174920678138733,
-0.6358811259269714,
0.28050321340560913,
-0.21958622336387634,
-0.643946647644043,
0.6787207126617432,
0.6935675144195557,
0.6335943937301636,
-0.08917459100484848,
0.6830695867538452,
-0.0925830528140068,
0.5302445888519287,
-0.44584357738494873,
0.3371886909008026,
-0.42733103036880493,
0.52632737159729,
-0.19469718635082245,
-1.366990089416504,
0.10827988386154175,
0.47956016659736633,
-0.25286200642585754,
0.5993880033493042,
0.4490281343460083,
0.8483530879020691,
-0.04619205370545387,
-0.2858211398124695,
0.45386937260627747,
0.36563730239868164,
0.43518686294555664,
0.21491330862045288,
0.944855272769928,
0.07233569025993347,
0.31157582998275757,
-0.1986214965581894,
-0.4020116925239563,
-0.6345438361167908,
-0.17829981446266174,
-1.2342028617858887,
-0.7671833634376526,
-0.07977717369794846,
-0.1611231118440628,
0.2271205484867096,
0.8182589411735535,
0.950846254825592,
-0.4984801411628723,
-0.4105803668498993,
0.18714213371276855,
-0.17444314062595367,
0.06650630384683609,
-0.27823129296302795,
0.20484648644924164,
-0.26886287331581116,
-0.7862411737442017,
0.36124831438064575,
0.40475165843963623,
-0.01657986454665661,
-0.8258174657821655,
-0.4374910891056061,
0.43294471502304077,
0.14313149452209473,
0.46647384762763977,
0.4420076608657837,
-0.8360291123390198,
-0.34185394644737244,
0.029584094882011414,
-0.09163744002580643,
0.32424914836883545,
0.9068049192428589,
-0.8913389444351196,
0.6250681281089783,
0.21416206657886505,
0.2606150209903717,
0.5588555335998535,
0.21277649700641632,
0.47801631689071655,
-0.5085520148277283,
0.22489167749881744,
0.16579432785511017,
0.2707606852054596,
0.3668261766433716,
-0.8873567581176758,
0.25911954045295715,
0.036349307745695114,
-0.4673748016357422,
-0.24401630461215973,
0.5120907425880432,
-1.1934767961502075,
0.08091499656438828,
0.8095071315765381,
-0.1925274282693863,
-0.13787280023097992,
-0.08742594718933105,
-0.6305572390556335,
0.020824339240789413,
-0.8369535803794861,
1.2142924070358276,
0.7048829197883606,
-0.47075361013412476,
-0.060084957629442215,
-0.6061035990715027,
0.32202741503715515,
0.2179385870695114,
-0.8589678406715393,
-0.2967325747013092,
0.3405662178993225,
0.5470101237297058,
0.5083898901939392,
0.8711176514625549,
-0.05785910412669182,
0.0768333300948143,
-0.6080874800682068,
-0.179915189743042,
-0.23197785019874573,
-0.17216311395168304,
-0.030376937240362167,
0.2999017536640167,
0.37429770827293396,
0.05795647203922272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06709v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06709v1
|
CQIL: Inference Latency Optimization with Concurrent Computation of Quasi-Independent Layers
| 2024-04-10T03:30:01 | 2024-04-10T03:30:01 |
Longwei Zou, Qingyang Wang, Han Zhao, Jiangang Kong, Yi Yang, Yangdong Deng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The fast-growing large scale language models are delivering unprecedented
performance on almost all natural language processing tasks. However, the
effectiveness of large language models are reliant on an exponentially
increasing number of parameters. The overwhelming computation complexity incurs
a high inference latency that negatively affects user experience. Existing
methods to improve inference efficiency, such as tensor parallelism and
quantization, target to reduce per-layer computing latency, yet overlook the
cumulative latency due to the number of layers. Recent works on reducing the
cumulative latency through layer removing, however, lead to significant
performance drop. Motivated by the similarity of inputs among adjacent layers,
we propose to identify quasi-independent layers, which can be concurrently
computed to significantly decrease inference latency. We also introduce a
bypassing technique to mitigate the effect of information loss. Empirical
experiments of the proposed approach on the LLaMA models confirm that
Concurrent Computation of Quasi-Independent Layers (CQIL) can reduce latency by
up to 48.3% on the LLaMA-33B model, while maintaining a close level of
performance.
|
[
-0.31119632720947266,
-1.0872564315795898,
0.645410418510437,
0.353001207113266,
-0.0719996839761734,
0.3303748071193695,
0.16108042001724243,
-0.8302111625671387,
-0.0281883105635643,
0.34876808524131775,
-0.5280292630195618,
-0.06267528235912323,
-0.19103504717350006,
-0.39591580629348755,
-0.4042913317680359,
0.5154281854629517,
0.12419094890356064,
0.052991364151239395,
-0.3301306962966919,
0.19628912210464478,
0.0986638218164444,
-0.47895658016204834,
-1.043140172958374,
-0.22185593843460083,
0.5326876044273376,
0.32084792852401733,
0.8221404552459717,
0.6012822389602661,
0.29861944913864136,
0.2576008141040802,
-0.16415658593177795,
0.15165352821350098,
-0.5430676341056824,
-0.09095451980829239,
0.04012424126267433,
-0.5212385654449463,
-0.1916721612215042,
-0.35061120986938477,
1.1816481351852417,
0.8286026120185852,
-0.07656049728393555,
0.060847263783216476,
0.18792179226875305,
0.5770975351333618,
-1.0622223615646362,
-0.051019635051488876,
-0.3749655485153198,
0.27094075083732605,
-0.33241117000579834,
0.12804658710956573,
-0.3388252854347229,
-0.2601766884326935,
0.16649910807609558,
-0.5919675827026367,
0.21063971519470215,
0.3413979709148407,
0.7055582404136658,
0.44146060943603516,
-0.07096220552921295,
0.18934346735477448,
-0.7967684268951416,
1.0116562843322754,
-0.8658875823020935,
0.537021815776825,
0.3209734559059143,
-0.07326057553291321,
-0.20145051181316376,
-0.9324094653129578,
-0.6848810315132141,
-0.420692503452301,
-0.053388021886348724,
0.14947344362735748,
-0.16649441421031952,
0.3282269239425659,
0.14111702144145966,
0.2571549117565155,
-0.4959316849708557,
0.2609175145626068,
0.006567799020558596,
-0.36756613850593567,
0.5090405344963074,
0.21754522621631622,
0.218445286154747,
0.06791336834430695,
-0.3741414546966553,
0.06874915957450867,
-0.6424543857574463,
0.34513214230537415,
0.3007993996143341,
-0.12417950481176376,
-0.016535013914108276,
0.31026503443717957,
-0.4895428419113159,
0.4924428164958954,
-0.03128810599446297,
-0.20614564418792725,
0.0039034192450344563,
-0.34334319829940796,
-0.23896212875843048,
-0.04230014607310295,
0.8513521552085876,
-0.15654295682907104,
-0.12264273315668106,
-0.4435681700706482,
-0.14154545962810516,
0.055382441729307175,
-0.0253794863820076,
-0.7985880970954895,
-0.30984219908714294,
0.6577306985855103,
-0.49760702252388,
-0.060211971402168274,
-0.10796582698822021,
-0.47540268301963806,
-0.03276088833808899,
-0.0869775265455246,
0.34839755296707153,
-0.30165302753448486,
-0.17959091067314148,
-0.059155602008104324,
0.19339486956596375,
0.0008855771156959236,
0.13489139080047607,
-0.49572908878326416,
0.616873562335968,
0.5797989964485168,
0.7650124430656433,
-0.0703563466668129,
-0.3206131160259247,
-0.9664756655693054,
0.3709327280521393,
-0.34537866711616516,
0.7072587013244629,
-0.5351406335830688,
-0.19390003383159637,
-0.36685705184936523,
-0.27634453773498535,
-0.1867111325263977,
-0.42284640669822693,
0.7222380638122559,
-0.7435731291770935,
-0.0197588000446558,
-0.09408356994390488,
-0.6631976962089539,
-0.00861530564725399,
-0.1094534769654274,
-0.7937926054000854,
1.0606733560562134,
-0.08457645028829575,
-0.9890720248222351,
-0.08320467919111252,
-0.4421590566635132,
-0.3606451153755188,
0.09462419152259827,
0.06664206087589264,
-0.6733843088150024,
0.20128536224365234,
0.32111331820487976,
0.26173534989356995,
-0.7650992274284363,
0.30192360281944275,
-0.5298454165458679,
-0.70180743932724,
0.030408523976802826,
-0.21770069003105164,
0.9111720323562622,
0.527325451374054,
-0.3624403774738312,
-0.06937534362077713,
-0.7136510014533997,
0.35531899333000183,
-0.09370394051074982,
-0.18597854673862457,
-0.3947930335998535,
0.38983261585235596,
-0.003197266021743417,
0.1564895063638687,
0.20115768909454346,
-0.5084936022758484,
-0.1638520359992981,
-0.3662952184677124,
0.26532265543937683,
0.5999433398246765,
0.11542244255542755,
0.3621433973312378,
-0.3796688914299011,
0.5005163550376892,
0.29863250255584717,
0.40802255272865295,
0.35924580693244934,
-0.18540796637535095,
-0.9266965985298157,
-0.5372269153594971,
0.42233288288116455,
0.6444569230079651,
-1.1718398332595825,
0.08119603246450424,
0.13456834852695465,
-0.5910559296607971,
-0.7020676732063293,
0.15907548367977142,
0.8743398189544678,
0.5911097526550293,
0.3221100866794586,
-0.40743109583854675,
-0.4910750389099121,
-0.980584442615509,
-0.4063626825809479,
-0.3833242952823639,
-0.08058728277683258,
0.08873890340328217,
-0.10408168286085129,
0.15456874668598175,
0.7643502950668335,
-0.231620654463768,
0.16482366621494293,
0.0929948017001152,
-0.028506726026535034,
0.10864678025245667,
0.7323775887489319,
0.3034979999065399,
-0.7498043775558472,
-0.27959755063056946,
-0.1884506344795227,
-0.7796675562858582,
-0.3909052312374115,
-0.264426052570343,
-0.31370657682418823,
0.030506448820233345,
0.6719441413879395,
-0.49481338262557983,
0.3266091048717499,
0.671761155128479,
0.0022744620218873024,
0.6481726169586182,
-0.01862918585538864,
0.006974225863814354,
-0.46813488006591797,
-0.0782858282327652,
0.03436722233891487,
-0.1394556164741516,
-0.7380533814430237,
0.33480340242385864,
0.10994087904691696,
0.3312614858150482,
-0.6031584143638611,
0.6052252650260925,
-0.6934009790420532,
0.0421636663377285,
0.14691488444805145,
-0.05103190243244171,
0.16501392424106598,
0.5840855240821838,
0.06618983298540115,
0.9027741551399231,
0.6098827123641968,
-0.7002852559089661,
-0.149784654378891,
-0.1273130178451538,
-0.3713867664337158,
0.28189265727996826,
-0.7102987170219421,
0.23512209951877594,
0.02632547914981842,
0.29257169365882874,
-0.7610574960708618,
0.12826618552207947,
0.3578089475631714,
-0.022930217906832695,
-0.037195850163698196,
0.018306616693735123,
-0.6390262842178345,
-0.28053686022758484,
-0.2497435361146927,
0.8373159170150757,
0.2961472272872925,
-0.5240173935890198,
0.5598774552345276,
0.3756914734840393,
0.0541759692132473,
-0.6367611289024353,
-0.8847384452819824,
0.02173616737127304,
-0.07198021560907364,
-0.6908303499221802,
0.6796666383743286,
-0.2590956687927246,
-0.3555201292037964,
0.185745507478714,
0.13038769364356995,
-0.16108094155788422,
0.2871814966201782,
0.0023187287151813507,
0.11186660826206207,
-0.35431206226348877,
0.141431987285614,
0.3143088221549988,
0.12272385507822037,
0.10010778903961182,
-0.7307866811752319,
0.46396464109420776,
-0.11066829413175583,
-0.47026464343070984,
-0.8358777165412903,
0.6169854402542114,
0.07977212965488434,
-0.2896079421043396,
1.0940179824829102,
0.6658298373222351,
-0.33328089118003845,
-0.24201518297195435,
-0.8044268488883972,
0.09572087228298187,
-0.4344088137149811,
0.3111724555492401,
-0.685765266418457,
-0.9920989871025085,
0.5833849310874939,
0.15204878151416779,
-0.27226993441581726,
0.4201304614543915,
0.5047307014465332,
-0.09289027005434036,
0.877467930316925,
0.3614034950733185,
-0.23640280961990356,
0.6847254633903503,
-0.13482579588890076,
0.3337291479110718,
-0.74190354347229,
-0.14156602323055267,
-0.5259964466094971,
0.021410616114735603,
-0.7386135458946228,
-0.40470483899116516,
0.431059867143631,
0.4311455190181732,
-0.29863405227661133,
-0.09170400351285934,
-0.1492863893508911,
0.5530946850776672,
0.7442782521247864,
0.4448752701282501,
0.389363557100296,
-0.051342178136110306,
-0.40924423933029175,
0.33700376749038696,
-1.0005559921264648,
-0.1514306366443634,
0.6137515902519226,
0.22712868452072144,
0.6170642971992493,
0.23703745007514954,
0.7236118316650391,
0.3378532826900482,
-0.07365907728672028,
-0.34693557024002075,
0.5458362698554993,
-0.22412054240703583,
-0.20105595886707306,
-0.17718461155891418,
-0.8201022744178772,
-0.5534778237342834,
0.2635272145271301,
-0.25543180108070374,
-1.006137728691101,
0.18405568599700928,
0.26413074135780334,
-0.381289541721344,
0.4744759202003479,
-1.0219248533248901,
0.47795188426971436,
0.06806837022304535,
-1.167173981666565,
-0.21879912912845612,
-0.7723222970962524,
0.5870075225830078,
-0.047574564814567566,
0.12679843604564667,
0.12197063118219376,
-0.036917634308338165,
0.5235402584075928,
-0.7083722352981567,
0.7052793502807617,
-0.25397375226020813,
0.09613998234272003,
0.6083909869194031,
0.039194148033857346,
0.6370561718940735,
0.16237351298332214,
-0.35657790303230286,
0.2829231917858124,
0.1755777895450592,
-0.8149403929710388,
-0.35993385314941406,
0.6577494144439697,
-0.8059340715408325,
-0.5612593293190002,
-0.05943676456809044,
-0.6673246622085571,
-0.3866264820098877,
0.029176993295550346,
0.08316123485565186,
0.34064415097236633,
-0.13855011761188507,
-0.19877472519874573,
0.3996987044811249,
-0.15121428668498993,
0.7214305400848389,
0.09836039692163467,
0.0512072928249836,
-0.18830262124538422,
0.8391830325126648,
0.05053149163722992,
0.41991835832595825,
0.5264148116111755,
0.19796136021614075,
-0.27925577759742737,
-0.7800325155258179,
-0.19911517202854156,
0.299232542514801,
-0.358782023191452,
-0.003530174260959029,
-0.8475781083106995,
-0.595384955406189,
-0.2640710175037384,
0.15214745700359344,
-0.2879936993122101,
-0.6016368865966797,
-0.47546473145484924,
0.45182564854621887,
-0.1463547945022583,
0.28223106265068054,
-0.020596934482455254,
0.6413930058479309,
-0.8403538465499878,
0.4318774342536926,
0.17034770548343658,
0.3631224036216736,
0.525725245475769,
-0.24479956924915314,
-0.37984001636505127,
-0.03683751821517944,
-0.08995949476957321,
-0.3843303918838501,
0.20192298293113708,
0.3520798087120056,
0.7005056142807007,
0.35577303171157837,
0.208998441696167,
0.8633654117584229,
-0.19409413635730743,
0.715721070766449,
0.20300841331481934,
-1.322338342666626,
0.010428187437355518,
-0.08831433951854706,
0.45611661672592163,
0.2581571638584137,
0.1897382289171219,
-0.30101773142814636,
-0.7033097743988037,
-0.7400377988815308,
-0.7440111041069031,
0.44852322340011597,
0.4284251928329468,
-0.29777178168296814,
-0.017196068540215492,
0.26429498195648193,
-0.2446689009666443,
-0.04189436882734299,
-0.4571770429611206,
0.003218037076294422,
0.20506855845451355,
0.028319235891103745,
0.2775212228298187,
-0.4749576449394226,
0.21239911019802094,
-0.22547326982021332,
0.6722878217697144,
-0.11931289732456207,
0.14359761774539948,
0.41164007782936096,
-0.1833864003419876,
-0.0010042290668934584,
0.11930572986602783,
0.3637467324733734,
0.5892874002456665,
-0.08245981484651566,
0.22719520330429077,
0.14752954244613647,
-0.41916200518608093,
-0.04339306429028511,
0.16678005456924438,
-0.18883192539215088,
-0.2921363115310669,
0.4286353290081024,
0.584442675113678,
-0.09409519284963608,
-0.5380047559738159,
0.1807427853345871,
-0.16034919023513794,
-0.0012412131763994694,
-0.26143765449523926,
0.2488308846950531,
0.2342665195465088,
0.6324840188026428,
0.4237101078033447,
0.08245439827442169,
0.4007169306278229,
-0.2176397442817688,
0.1684914529323578,
0.42119359970092773,
-0.12486886233091354,
-0.06452158093452454,
0.8358213901519775,
-0.05991922318935394,
-0.20936055481433868,
0.5611404776573181,
-0.18311944603919983,
-0.38668036460876465,
0.753908634185791,
0.4971340596675873,
0.7531481981277466,
-0.32203027606010437,
0.10793758928775787,
0.29007595777511597,
0.1681133508682251,
-0.20303598046302795,
0.1604427993297577,
-0.14301495254039764,
-0.7247202396392822,
-0.7036129236221313,
-0.6180238127708435,
-0.5712607502937317,
-0.21186281740665436,
-0.5364251136779785,
-0.02630373276770115,
-0.6257591843605042,
-0.01521114632487297,
-0.12806452810764313,
0.2437073290348053,
-0.6720305681228638,
0.40649038553237915,
0.05043093487620354,
0.667108952999115,
-0.6296376585960388,
1.1114064455032349,
0.13078592717647552,
-0.20160254836082458,
-0.8739879131317139,
0.1300380378961563,
-0.030884593725204468,
-0.6577482223510742,
0.4227369725704193,
-0.16234320402145386,
-0.6345647573471069,
0.12561839818954468,
-0.6220077872276306,
-0.6425684094429016,
0.8077703714370728,
0.5373404622077942,
-0.7856636047363281,
-0.08720245212316513,
0.19201648235321045,
0.5524988770484924,
-0.29562389850616455,
0.6225507259368896,
0.6624672412872314,
0.22067582607269287,
0.05683870241045952,
-0.8045768737792969,
0.10732167214155197,
-0.2797117233276367,
0.34394630789756775,
0.08736361563205719,
-0.9998934864997864,
1.0973371267318726,
-0.21847482025623322,
-0.26846665143966675,
0.304761677980423,
0.8976004719734192,
0.4935576319694519,
0.41568008065223694,
0.7473270893096924,
0.4610951542854309,
0.8811274170875549,
0.22573985159397125,
1.0682543516159058,
-0.257636159658432,
0.3091988265514374,
1.105870008468628,
-0.07458735257387161,
0.8793936967849731,
0.8301194310188293,
-0.2852954566478729,
0.4623388946056366,
0.7014901638031006,
0.34419721364974976,
0.4489424526691437,
0.3548203706741333,
-0.608184814453125,
-0.2921600341796875,
-0.47256356477737427,
-0.1590166836977005,
0.43063443899154663,
0.21527692675590515,
-0.2585573196411133,
0.17142219841480255,
-0.40743592381477356,
0.11706399917602539,
-0.11734885722398758,
-0.20589065551757812,
0.5479713082313538,
0.10152193158864975,
-0.6632872819900513,
0.7200295329093933,
-0.06482407450675964,
0.4103618264198303,
-0.42405936121940613,
-0.07676354795694351,
-0.4485985338687897,
0.08386746793985367,
-0.21793599426746368,
-0.25003868341445923,
0.14810872077941895,
-0.2267460972070694,
-0.19954031705856323,
0.06393961608409882,
0.5455891489982605,
-0.388427197933197,
-0.6831001043319702,
0.5011317729949951,
0.7118635177612305,
0.032333847135305405,
-0.08979889005422592,
-0.6287580132484436,
0.1422247737646103,
-0.11821732670068741,
-0.3327191472053528,
0.22365371882915497,
0.36904776096343994,
-0.35013526678085327,
0.715194821357727,
0.8176206946372986,
0.2620982229709625,
0.18850302696228027,
0.23373599350452423,
1.1149179935455322,
-0.5092052817344666,
-0.6830130219459534,
-0.6923885345458984,
0.3511433005332947,
-0.09376686066389084,
-0.027517465874552727,
0.2797681987285614,
0.488989919424057,
0.8938729763031006,
0.13443462550640106,
0.5841630101203918,
0.008437085896730423,
0.38776490092277527,
-1.088017225265503,
0.735922634601593,
-0.7530892491340637,
0.7024852633476257,
-0.4626493752002716,
-1.0176531076431274,
-0.3729115426540375,
0.2159441113471985,
-0.1665681153535843,
0.09968876838684082,
0.9724248647689819,
0.9959539771080017,
-0.11855648458003998,
0.18699461221694946,
0.4084167182445526,
0.36088472604751587,
0.3322919011116028,
0.9199101328849792,
0.8684320449829102,
-0.5174514055252075,
0.4050682485103607,
-0.633468508720398,
-0.17168594896793365,
0.14547742903232574,
-1.0646541118621826,
-0.5905633568763733,
-0.4330671429634094,
-0.29606375098228455,
-0.18945343792438507,
0.34995147585868835,
0.5414450764656067,
0.8116430044174194,
-0.8439728021621704,
-0.34680742025375366,
-0.13952527940273285,
0.13645999133586884,
-0.41357091069221497,
-0.24431368708610535,
0.5542483925819397,
-0.2748023271560669,
-0.6681159734725952,
0.2801397144794464,
0.09120821207761765,
-0.3547045886516571,
-0.24280773103237152,
0.04993096739053726,
-0.49072161316871643,
0.051314521580934525,
0.41546669602394104,
0.398723840713501,
-0.881630003452301,
-0.4490264356136322,
-0.19549618661403656,
-0.16145288944244385,
-0.01147294882684946,
0.7017188668251038,
-0.9269348382949829,
0.3129355013370514,
0.4112309515476227,
0.8978473544120789,
0.8335761427879333,
0.032955724745988846,
0.37633705139160156,
-0.6240925788879395,
0.5153666734695435,
0.23061473667621613,
0.1928754448890686,
0.18506886065006256,
-0.5424638986587524,
0.3982597589492798,
0.19764314591884613,
-0.5402606129646301,
-0.5656707882881165,
-0.014971306547522545,
-1.0286636352539062,
-0.25168555974960327,
0.7536734938621521,
-0.28538355231285095,
-0.5172426104545593,
-0.16075138747692108,
0.11636850982904434,
0.333497554063797,
-0.3025003969669342,
0.7381207942962646,
0.5284992456436157,
-0.35851094126701355,
-0.7733004093170166,
-0.4551600217819214,
0.27324941754341125,
0.9846041798591614,
-0.9512935876846313,
-0.34069544076919556,
0.39100760221481323,
-0.06958077847957611,
-0.2307964563369751,
0.7277178168296814,
0.11902400106191635,
0.17350251972675323,
0.21493105590343475,
0.03382522612810135,
0.13835564255714417,
-0.2557913362979889,
0.043416593223810196,
0.3502175807952881,
0.16795556247234344,
-0.20867370069026947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06690v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06690v2
|
CoVoMix: Advancing Zero-Shot Speech Generation for Human-like Multi-talker Conversations
| 2024-04-10T02:32:58 | 2024-05-29T07:30:20 |
Leying Zhang, Yao Qian, Long Zhou, Shujie Liu, Dongmei Wang, Xiaofei Wang, Midia Yousefi, Yanmin Qian, Jinyu Li, Lei He, Sheng Zhao, Michael Zeng
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Recent advancements in zero-shot text-to-speech (TTS) modeling have led to
significant strides in generating high-fidelity and diverse speech. However,
dialogue generation, along with achieving human-like naturalness in speech,
continues to be a challenge. In this paper, we introduce CoVoMix:
Conversational Voice Mixture Generation, a novel model for zero-shot,
human-like, multi-speaker, multi-round dialogue speech generation. CoVoMix
first converts dialogue text into multiple streams of discrete tokens, with
each token stream representing semantic information for individual talkers.
These token streams are then fed into a flow-matching based acoustic model to
generate mixed mel-spectrograms. Finally, the speech waveforms are produced
using a HiFi-GAN model. Furthermore, we devise a comprehensive set of metrics
for measuring the effectiveness of dialogue modeling and generation. Our
experimental results show that CoVoMix can generate dialogues that are not only
human-like in their naturalness and coherence but also involve multiple talkers
engaging in multiple rounds of conversation. This is exemplified by instances
generated in a single channel where one speaker's utterance is seamlessly mixed
with another's interjections or laughter, indicating the latter's role as an
attentive listener. Audio samples are available at https://aka.ms/covomix.
|
[
-0.7324382662773132,
-0.8351620435714722,
0.19410158693790436,
0.09970247745513916,
-0.3133367598056793,
0.5100977420806885,
0.058991216123104095,
-0.3466345965862274,
0.29834461212158203,
0.506013810634613,
-0.7773714661598206,
-0.5360414385795593,
-0.081446073949337,
0.07019489258527756,
-0.4628519117832184,
0.8425987958908081,
0.7078982591629028,
0.11992906033992767,
-0.22345376014709473,
-0.09287649393081665,
-0.5827120542526245,
-0.5637538433074951,
-0.5999652743339539,
-0.4548848271369934,
0.5484282970428467,
0.494564950466156,
0.5656753778457642,
0.12359226495027542,
-0.21821433305740356,
0.17497679591178894,
0.1755744367837906,
0.15766873955726624,
-0.4767307937145233,
0.4809742867946625,
0.37116503715515137,
-0.3005228042602539,
-0.4683508276939392,
0.003973805345594883,
0.35619065165519714,
0.6435661315917969,
-0.54847651720047,
-0.12256146222352982,
-0.004103800281882286,
-0.03590330109000206,
-0.5128848552703857,
-0.2152952253818512,
-0.8121416568756104,
0.13455450534820557,
-0.012247362174093723,
-0.35898011922836304,
-0.24287083745002747,
-0.15768107771873474,
0.1582334190607071,
-0.5157524347305298,
0.5945382714271545,
0.05225377157330513,
0.5184109807014465,
0.14468495547771454,
-0.16788160800933838,
-0.19526724517345428,
-0.8456903100013733,
0.7936538457870483,
-0.82129967212677,
0.23120567202568054,
-0.10517421364784241,
0.5462205410003662,
-0.35662147402763367,
-0.344268798828125,
-0.8236309289932251,
-0.19660989940166473,
0.4182119369506836,
0.40453779697418213,
-0.19939258694648743,
0.08381958305835724,
-0.11136291921138763,
0.21480870246887207,
-0.5411423444747925,
-0.1033170223236084,
-0.05056608468294144,
-0.10227108001708984,
0.6338542103767395,
0.3229685127735138,
0.42784973978996277,
-0.19977155327796936,
-0.26277482509613037,
-0.12979842722415924,
-0.47525152564048767,
0.08386040478944778,
0.5067616105079651,
0.48639312386512756,
-0.3843879699707031,
0.514772891998291,
-0.25947895646095276,
0.8733826875686646,
0.12802405655384064,
-0.3401021957397461,
0.016054924577474594,
-0.49925878643989563,
-0.21388691663742065,
0.3266637623310089,
1.0527633428573608,
0.2274281531572342,
-0.09931601583957672,
-0.20431895554065704,
0.1662972867488861,
0.008868447504937649,
0.2936256229877472,
-0.971642792224884,
-0.16088007390499115,
0.37098246812820435,
0.017353957518935204,
-0.5042078495025635,
-0.021298255771398544,
-0.8231772780418396,
-0.2551741600036621,
-0.2505316734313965,
0.18090488016605377,
-0.36776912212371826,
-0.3397814929485321,
0.050465669482946396,
-0.38453325629234314,
0.1834806352853775,
0.27499210834503174,
-0.7579213380813599,
0.4320697486400604,
0.5842866897583008,
0.7349722981452942,
-0.1492013782262802,
-0.06832780689001083,
-1.0200207233428955,
0.1548258513212204,
-0.3955041468143463,
0.5972929000854492,
-0.6045047640800476,
-0.6557319760322571,
-0.23076938092708588,
-0.7121514678001404,
0.08914665877819061,
-0.7191593647003174,
0.28948429226875305,
0.10402633994817734,
0.3385378420352936,
0.15990214049816132,
-0.29238182306289673,
0.09821817278862,
0.28843438625335693,
-0.23121660947799683,
0.7994222640991211,
0.16943621635437012,
-0.38037773966789246,
0.30627235770225525,
-0.6861733198165894,
-0.3012791872024536,
0.3902643918991089,
-0.5167375206947327,
-0.6105055212974548,
0.10532403737306595,
-0.06940654665231705,
0.3657764792442322,
-0.47754502296447754,
0.62795090675354,
-0.47322723269462585,
-0.17657116055488586,
0.4283842444419861,
-0.6260958909988403,
0.5141986012458801,
0.3691657483577728,
-0.34383460879325867,
-0.007006562780588865,
-1.0008715391159058,
-0.031897567212581635,
0.06637759506702423,
0.02924242801964283,
-0.07649259269237518,
0.07819537073373795,
-0.10685230791568756,
0.40194717049598694,
-0.3918057084083557,
-0.8980449438095093,
-0.3589077889919281,
-0.43394240736961365,
0.5221561789512634,
0.03778926655650139,
0.31373244524002075,
0.4367615282535553,
-0.5807134509086609,
0.6277108788490295,
0.31709131598472595,
0.026674192398786545,
-0.6434535980224609,
-0.8358350396156311,
-0.8593019247055054,
-0.5161615014076233,
-0.11463320255279541,
0.5188657641410828,
-0.7677661776542664,
0.529000997543335,
-0.11438345909118652,
-0.6249061822891235,
-0.6047780513763428,
-0.23621554672718048,
0.2508556842803955,
0.6574504971504211,
0.25858020782470703,
-0.5096440315246582,
-0.4016488194465637,
-0.6123014092445374,
0.016000671312212944,
-0.13338728249073029,
-0.14576877653598785,
0.5935909152030945,
0.09488371014595032,
-0.08613470941781998,
1.3296170234680176,
-0.33741679787635803,
0.2645750939846039,
-0.2701241075992584,
0.653907299041748,
-0.22013385593891144,
0.2646533250808716,
0.4971288740634918,
-0.48459917306900024,
-0.494500070810318,
-0.1407625377178192,
-0.39775875210762024,
-0.2032831609249115,
-0.2123349905014038,
-0.18384967744350433,
-0.01947387121617794,
0.16720248758792877,
-0.2761376202106476,
0.2900528907775879,
0.69605952501297,
-0.03655343875288963,
0.5332303047180176,
-0.1579127162694931,
0.1332886964082718,
-1.5003468990325928,
-0.10733811557292938,
0.0044869245029985905,
-0.4747863709926605,
-1.0347884893417358,
-0.26541706919670105,
-0.7160795331001282,
-0.825947642326355,
-0.6938851475715637,
0.35379430651664734,
-0.3088376224040985,
-0.05868176743388176,
-0.24791750311851501,
0.13723205029964447,
0.2655515968799591,
0.5922881364822388,
-0.03451681509613991,
0.8988897800445557,
0.5553922653198242,
-0.5394002795219421,
0.6202902793884277,
0.3222089409828186,
-0.1799781322479248,
0.8566609025001526,
-0.6315923929214478,
0.5804532766342163,
0.0923684611916542,
0.3879892826080322,
-0.9636815786361694,
-0.21897202730178833,
0.21193479001522064,
-0.6634498238563538,
-0.08251643925905228,
0.0759710967540741,
-0.14005988836288452,
-0.16803908348083496,
-0.2055424004793167,
0.21921579539775848,
0.3506649136543274,
-0.387136846780777,
0.4607793390750885,
0.4689177870750427,
-0.6849453449249268,
-0.0013233551289886236,
-0.47562626004219055,
0.6090041399002075,
-0.06948763132095337,
-0.9776138067245483,
0.2291509509086609,
-0.3291241228580475,
-0.14154893159866333,
-0.42208510637283325,
0.27655231952667236,
-0.17676839232444763,
-0.07480335980653763,
0.28805872797966003,
0.24598810076713562,
-0.07568816095590591,
-0.2167157083749771,
0.17883910238742828,
0.14435963332653046,
-0.2202131599187851,
-0.09674374759197235,
0.8675405979156494,
0.19619575142860413,
-0.3874298334121704,
-0.46155545115470886,
1.035149097442627,
0.5492861270904541,
-0.19414867460727692,
0.3981315791606903,
0.7333180904388428,
-0.04510049149394035,
-0.02136753499507904,
-0.4449726343154907,
-0.23454251885414124,
-0.3706399202346802,
0.18913474678993225,
-0.4878741204738617,
-1.0497316122055054,
0.40805140137672424,
0.16656377911567688,
-0.12339287996292114,
0.1019953116774559,
0.7289091944694519,
-0.07225345075130463,
1.2356170415878296,
0.2859828472137451,
0.2642592191696167,
0.5052065849304199,
-0.0034558423794806004,
0.34368306398391724,
-0.563768208026886,
-0.30015575885772705,
-0.5789782404899597,
-0.0026977970264852047,
-0.5667228698730469,
-0.5931991934776306,
0.48968037962913513,
-0.37712159752845764,
-0.051777709275484085,
0.1548515409231186,
-0.29880446195602417,
0.10332857072353363,
0.8244799971580505,
-0.061354029923677444,
0.24399718642234802,
0.19273418188095093,
-0.1764591783285141,
0.038743410259485245,
-0.9083858132362366,
-0.24404962360858917,
0.6225521564483643,
0.0855073630809784,
0.5920606255531311,
-0.048191241919994354,
0.9557507038116455,
0.0933181494474411,
-0.059023417532444,
-0.6858357787132263,
0.530431866645813,
-0.12154164910316467,
-0.6536270976066589,
-0.26974397897720337,
-0.5270518660545349,
-0.8831074237823486,
0.1642255038022995,
-0.5918774008750916,
-0.5525981187820435,
0.2638314664363861,
0.05908454582095146,
-0.8377271294593811,
-0.005770757794380188,
-0.7438202500343323,
0.6225379705429077,
-0.00530516030266881,
-0.33300426602363586,
-0.12403583526611328,
-0.7485439777374268,
0.36946427822113037,
-0.056835297495126724,
0.04470203444361687,
-0.2603207528591156,
0.4224652647972107,
0.27585190534591675,
-0.4323611557483673,
0.7848345041275024,
-0.22061499953269958,
-0.069951131939888,
0.7163894772529602,
0.03982294350862503,
0.24060854315757751,
0.1407567858695984,
0.2052590698003769,
0.3609664738178253,
-0.06948711723089218,
-0.3782210946083069,
-0.41651445627212524,
0.3807949721813202,
-0.7904167771339417,
-0.39449453353881836,
-0.18403494358062744,
-0.6008837819099426,
-0.3210449814796448,
-0.08051144331693649,
0.37588804960250854,
0.7501813173294067,
-0.697835385799408,
0.2855556905269623,
0.33497315645217896,
-0.519065260887146,
0.3791041672229767,
0.45531824231147766,
-0.15896840393543243,
-0.6511702537536621,
1.2481563091278076,
-0.14345361292362213,
0.6025161743164062,
0.23078620433807373,
0.21391788125038147,
-0.0992550328373909,
-0.22390136122703552,
-0.5614684224128723,
0.01708669401705265,
0.13789379596710205,
-0.020494410768151283,
-0.7478007078170776,
-0.30411386489868164,
-0.5156654119491577,
-0.04973016306757927,
-0.45792141556739807,
-0.23637482523918152,
-0.4091300964355469,
0.31348007917404175,
-0.21491223573684692,
0.5146453380584717,
0.024398116394877434,
0.5318793654441833,
-0.992550253868103,
0.6792311072349548,
0.8651201725006104,
0.04507710784673691,
-0.31640318036079407,
-0.24867305159568787,
-0.17532142996788025,
0.5330270528793335,
-0.5308318734169006,
-0.8368009328842163,
0.8592332601547241,
0.3822983205318451,
0.34640058875083923,
0.14117451012134552,
-0.08342225849628448,
0.6696856617927551,
-0.5165688395500183,
1.0242698192596436,
0.9044801592826843,
-0.8639408349990845,
0.5221867561340332,
-0.594291090965271,
0.46240687370300293,
0.2988300919532776,
-0.39835262298583984,
-0.9108391404151917,
-0.7927651405334473,
-0.6135138869285583,
-0.6066938042640686,
0.7057428359985352,
0.5167451500892639,
0.23432330787181854,
-0.04719242826104164,
0.0031040250323712826,
0.38658881187438965,
0.3217606246471405,
-0.2037687748670578,
-0.1190333291888237,
-0.5598159432411194,
-0.24165202677249908,
-0.27236977219581604,
-0.11614065617322922,
-0.44912436604499817,
-0.18880850076675415,
0.45773187279701233,
-0.27226921916007996,
0.4933614432811737,
0.10768552124500275,
0.2003534734249115,
-0.30271288752555847,
0.7276235818862915,
0.9898359775543213,
0.1615549623966217,
-0.34025973081588745,
0.12444151192903519,
-0.14354145526885986,
-0.3383968770503998,
0.28026148676872253,
0.18129689991474152,
-0.09871724247932434,
0.2889661192893982,
-0.22319848835468292,
1.1566166877746582,
0.05164375901222229,
-0.5400486588478088,
0.4422411620616913,
-0.4301539659500122,
-0.4076283574104309,
-0.2184605598449707,
0.41019806265830994,
0.019186995923519135,
0.14687210321426392,
0.3337406814098358,
0.38220006227493286,
0.3244996666908264,
-0.6436115503311157,
0.20891642570495605,
0.45602700114250183,
-0.39275267720222473,
-0.35737428069114685,
0.7279419898986816,
0.7898423671722412,
-0.7074228525161743,
0.29174038767814636,
-0.3922981917858124,
-0.13448236882686615,
0.3024115264415741,
0.5652278661727905,
1.3100637197494507,
-0.21842506527900696,
0.49715307354927063,
0.19350609183311462,
-0.19733119010925293,
0.3513263165950775,
0.08816318213939667,
-0.35818207263946533,
-0.7810828685760498,
-0.38664716482162476,
-0.5822789072990417,
-0.911742091178894,
0.012785670347511768,
-0.505315899848938,
0.18244662880897522,
-0.013555102981626987,
-0.2614309787750244,
0.1545398235321045,
-0.17872869968414307,
-0.2863456606864929,
0.29228898882865906,
0.6963649392127991,
0.32141709327697754,
-0.777348518371582,
0.7930781245231628,
0.17674775421619415,
-0.141078919172287,
-0.7084025740623474,
-0.031882960349321365,
-0.1148228719830513,
-0.6011930108070374,
-0.011575720272958279,
0.15519236028194427,
-0.465737909078598,
0.1119069755077362,
-0.6596673727035522,
-0.24501241743564606,
1.135181188583374,
0.6411297917366028,
-0.828117311000824,
-0.03715375065803528,
0.6237602829933167,
0.4079161286354065,
-0.6562573313713074,
0.18904943764209747,
0.4943637549877167,
0.002037490950897336,
0.838512122631073,
-0.8267790079116821,
-0.5274462103843689,
-0.277468740940094,
0.14119844138622284,
-0.025789739564061165,
-0.6074233651161194,
0.7741178274154663,
-0.06223928928375244,
-0.09567686170339584,
0.09560780227184296,
0.4447503983974457,
0.5656009912490845,
0.5866812467575073,
0.61415696144104,
0.5864912271499634,
0.5829988718032837,
-0.1372411549091339,
0.8976213932037354,
-0.3531922399997711,
-0.08430059999227524,
1.375781536102295,
-0.4011417627334595,
0.6224572062492371,
0.22079631686210632,
0.007263966370373964,
0.386995404958725,
0.31640923023223877,
0.27389898896217346,
0.35538187623023987,
0.08090238273143768,
-0.8283340334892273,
-0.45184436440467834,
-0.38357627391815186,
-0.27109673619270325,
0.8128674626350403,
0.07555367052555084,
0.04404376819729805,
-0.11147835105657578,
0.10045196115970612,
-0.10937339812517166,
-0.09249237924814224,
0.07007412612438202,
1.0209157466888428,
0.08395624160766602,
-0.8719101548194885,
0.450054407119751,
-0.1624819040298462,
0.7127392292022705,
-0.34372764825820923,
-0.19873233139514923,
-0.16058211028575897,
-0.1733587086200714,
0.05572986975312233,
-0.5089742541313171,
0.2652551531791687,
0.17953400313854218,
-0.053056500852108,
-0.08240930736064911,
0.6849436163902283,
-0.9603561758995056,
-0.32476451992988586,
0.11184065788984299,
0.6980851292610168,
0.10439387708902359,
-0.20650839805603027,
-0.6262326240539551,
-0.09398889541625977,
-0.031064512208104134,
0.26463258266448975,
0.14512746036052704,
0.25362467765808105,
0.3179030418395996,
0.40083789825439453,
0.7440974712371826,
0.10905817151069641,
0.47610631585121155,
0.6854507327079773,
0.5524535775184631,
-0.5117143988609314,
-0.5860652327537537,
-0.637571394443512,
0.6363056898117065,
-0.19680219888687134,
-0.13935041427612305,
0.4379355013370514,
0.7435005307197571,
0.27914705872535706,
0.11162988096475601,
1.0531924962997437,
0.20215004682540894,
0.6123600602149963,
0.027280617505311966,
0.6628410816192627,
-0.40051352977752686,
-0.3560788333415985,
-0.2194184511899948,
-0.802233874797821,
-0.14344522356987,
0.26034417748451233,
0.18489980697631836,
-0.012170035392045975,
0.1215854361653328,
0.9439782500267029,
0.1447361260652542,
0.19717523455619812,
0.9198094606399536,
-0.0010683792643249035,
0.657760500907898,
0.38115862011909485,
1.0190140008926392,
-0.19455000758171082,
0.726559042930603,
-0.1255543828010559,
-0.029575325548648834,
-0.34695950150489807,
-0.5826421976089478,
-0.7449495792388916,
-0.3915290832519531,
-0.31492599844932556,
-0.1183275580406189,
-0.025338033214211464,
0.9182218313217163,
0.9611968398094177,
-0.6401775479316711,
-0.5116080045700073,
-0.42531299591064453,
-0.2618212401866913,
0.10449777543544769,
-0.21437329053878784,
-0.7112234830856323,
-0.3384893536567688,
-1.1091974973678589,
0.6579220294952393,
0.8730583786964417,
0.23624087870121002,
-0.49129146337509155,
-0.3449440896511078,
-0.1266334056854248,
0.6031385660171509,
0.5925965905189514,
0.21458646655082703,
-0.4993872046470642,
-0.11207375675439835,
0.1250636875629425,
-0.2001926749944687,
0.40743309259414673,
0.7476389408111572,
-0.6518322229385376,
1.0362155437469482,
0.38345107436180115,
0.1717064082622528,
0.7193717360496521,
-0.03950517252087593,
0.9519929885864258,
-1.1207160949707031,
0.26884302496910095,
0.3708976209163666,
0.038598671555519104,
0.5269979238510132,
0.0843430906534195,
-0.05242374911904335,
0.4406266510486603,
-0.43205609917640686,
-0.6957768201828003,
0.4238192141056061,
-1.352001667022705,
0.15467026829719543,
0.9588843584060669,
0.08879521489143372,
-0.12145837396383286,
-0.3560095727443695,
-0.4774731993675232,
0.6851713061332703,
-0.7425541877746582,
0.5648931860923767,
0.4712800681591034,
-0.26347705721855164,
-0.37061649560928345,
-0.3049595057964325,
0.19406163692474365,
0.30869072675704956,
-0.8766684532165527,
-0.3138938546180725,
0.5498422384262085,
0.1598280519247055,
0.28081315755844116,
0.6935054063796997,
0.135393887758255,
0.18570047616958618,
0.32866746187210083,
0.3470333516597748,
0.007284006103873253,
-0.1811574101448059,
-0.14650224149227142,
0.2818220257759094,
-0.16111543774604797,
-0.36608296632766724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06680v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06680v1
|
Onco-Retriever: Generative Classifier for Retrieval of EHR Records in Oncology
| 2024-04-10T02:02:34 | 2024-04-10T02:02:34 |
Shashi Kant Gupta, Aditya Basu, Bradley Taylor, Anai Kothari, Hrituraj Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieving information from EHR systems is essential for answering specific
questions about patient journeys and improving the delivery of clinical care.
Despite this fact, most EHR systems still rely on keyword-based searches. With
the advent of generative large language models (LLMs), retrieving information
can lead to better search and summarization capabilities. Such retrievers can
also feed Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) pipelines to answer any query.
However, the task of retrieving information from EHR real-world clinical data
contained within EHR systems in order to solve several downstream use cases is
challenging due to the difficulty in creating query-document support pairs. We
provide a blueprint for creating such datasets in an affordable manner using
large language models. Our method results in a retriever that is 30-50 F-1
points better than propriety counterparts such as Ada and Mistral for oncology
data elements. We further compare our model, called Onco-Retriever, against
fine-tuned PubMedBERT model as well. We conduct an extensive manual evaluation
on real-world EHR data along with latency analysis of the different models and
provide a path forward for healthcare organizations to build domain-specific
retrievers.
|
[
0.20818917453289032,
-0.5594745874404907,
0.8350462317466736,
-0.37365737557411194,
-0.09726673364639282,
0.0992182120680809,
0.2047690898180008,
-0.23003718256950378,
0.14129100739955902,
0.9482272863388062,
-0.15324576199054718,
-0.6107549071311951,
-0.5895631313323975,
-0.05427020415663719,
-0.2555937170982361,
0.9767953157424927,
0.22428789734840393,
0.08993187546730042,
-0.2024669349193573,
-0.024290384724736214,
-0.029658475890755653,
-0.5709200501441956,
-0.7801960706710815,
-0.40172603726387024,
0.9169498682022095,
0.4065985679626465,
0.3874553442001343,
0.7459892630577087,
0.768923819065094,
0.2007463127374649,
-0.24170799553394318,
0.0878773182630539,
-0.5839419960975647,
0.5705209374427795,
0.13967570662498474,
-0.6792636513710022,
-0.5957249999046326,
-0.6996316313743591,
0.3221277594566345,
0.43832191824913025,
-0.7451013326644897,
-0.1814388781785965,
-0.18855799734592438,
0.6518399715423584,
-0.8469616174697876,
0.039089128375053406,
-0.7146867513656616,
0.38756898045539856,
-0.3985097110271454,
-0.3908518850803375,
-0.43555396795272827,
-0.585120677947998,
0.16623811423778534,
-0.7192455530166626,
0.5499764680862427,
0.23098716139793396,
0.8424667119979858,
-0.01881634071469307,
-0.45938342809677124,
-0.5311402082443237,
-0.6375849843025208,
0.5876083970069885,
-0.4734891355037689,
0.6778214573860168,
0.5969886183738708,
0.5884963274002075,
0.10227017849683762,
-1.1750998497009277,
-0.12662014365196228,
-0.03660391643643379,
-0.055589232593774796,
0.36491087079048157,
-0.19653859734535217,
0.32306623458862305,
0.17208783328533173,
0.6699804663658142,
-0.5090292692184448,
-0.061815038323402405,
-0.29640698432922363,
-0.13832470774650574,
0.5012158751487732,
0.5334954261779785,
0.1642591655254364,
-0.1972675621509552,
-0.02981719560921192,
0.08209241926670074,
-1.0264452695846558,
-0.4182240664958954,
-0.177186518907547,
0.33487942814826965,
0.2086007446050644,
0.7009397149085999,
-0.3277713358402252,
0.6749243140220642,
0.18504422903060913,
-0.006433690432459116,
0.1286119818687439,
-0.40729275345802307,
-0.1243470311164856,
0.3792530596256256,
0.600450873374939,
-0.046686768531799316,
-0.4113980829715729,
-0.468226820230484,
-0.15845061838626862,
-0.26048779487609863,
0.5288425087928772,
-0.8656139373779297,
-0.2996383011341095,
0.367338627576828,
-0.6455650329589844,
-0.28449884057044983,
0.07490628212690353,
-0.9344950914382935,
-0.4151291251182556,
0.1338450014591217,
0.1799307018518448,
-0.30730146169662476,
0.2685822546482086,
0.18565168976783752,
-0.07159780710935593,
0.16958922147750854,
0.21242132782936096,
-0.657028079032898,
0.23501476645469666,
0.6361404657363892,
0.8663021326065063,
0.05764799937605858,
0.2861054241657257,
-1.0768518447875977,
0.3065338730812073,
-0.04200437664985657,
0.8109759092330933,
-0.6028621792793274,
-0.7077207565307617,
0.2812659740447998,
0.22431708872318268,
0.0013889293186366558,
-0.747454822063446,
0.7887377142906189,
-0.7864809632301331,
0.3292548954486847,
-0.4403294622898102,
-0.8352641463279724,
0.28228750824928284,
0.3397696912288666,
-0.8300395011901855,
0.5871009826660156,
0.0759187862277031,
-0.8870201706886292,
0.2572369873523712,
-0.5130817890167236,
-0.08119343221187592,
0.5986075401306152,
-0.35935235023498535,
-0.7441608905792236,
0.061522167176008224,
-0.049713607877492905,
0.34574127197265625,
-0.6517583727836609,
0.019991489127278328,
-0.04227834567427635,
-0.13734932243824005,
-0.0022815773263573647,
0.15153396129608154,
0.614875316619873,
0.6227902173995972,
0.1792520135641098,
-0.22023552656173706,
-0.7319554090499878,
0.10024057328701019,
0.2779523730278015,
-0.8231183290481567,
-0.5542165637016296,
0.26209402084350586,
0.04495792090892792,
0.06773212552070618,
0.00700781773775816,
-0.8941175937652588,
-0.005981086753308773,
-0.4601827561855316,
0.11161302030086517,
-0.018703514710068703,
0.21738438308238983,
0.03290948271751404,
-0.6111631989479065,
0.6315943002700806,
-0.1542198359966278,
-0.005625559948384762,
-0.3603462278842926,
-0.36064663529396057,
-0.5047491192817688,
-0.335845410823822,
0.3996155261993408,
0.47593897581100464,
-0.7818426489830017,
0.35791128873825073,
-0.33463960886001587,
-0.5732777714729309,
-0.7199573516845703,
-0.14178325235843658,
0.7468945384025574,
0.5979682803153992,
0.32992470264434814,
-0.3752725124359131,
-0.45984750986099243,
-0.46450406312942505,
0.012945366092026234,
0.12728166580200195,
-0.49493205547332764,
0.6068680882453918,
-0.006367087829858065,
-0.23215948045253754,
0.7065814137458801,
-0.8668943047523499,
-0.5632930994033813,
-0.3119828701019287,
-0.05376405641436577,
0.05520041659474373,
-0.03252699226140976,
-0.06572584807872772,
-0.8982569575309753,
-0.30061522126197815,
0.5080095529556274,
-0.9177974462509155,
-0.13684546947479248,
0.4450676739215851,
0.027003837749361992,
-0.16449329257011414,
0.4673459231853485,
-0.3273019790649414,
0.2952689230442047,
0.23679937422275543,
-0.2933177351951599,
0.09866398572921753,
-0.48441752791404724,
0.27191126346588135,
-0.9973933100700378,
0.5029717683792114,
-0.09323173761367798,
-0.17798908054828644,
-0.6840331554412842,
0.19590145349502563,
-0.038672495633363724,
-0.100960373878479,
-0.48767930269241333,
0.40954115986824036,
-0.5470994114875793,
-0.10075148940086365,
-0.05427628010511398,
-0.0488731823861599,
0.3111179769039154,
-0.07304319739341736,
0.13657087087631226,
0.3705809712409973,
0.19372926652431488,
-0.5693899989128113,
0.4974403381347656,
0.6015800833702087,
-0.420300155878067,
0.5566394925117493,
-0.7805112600326538,
0.27095985412597656,
-0.30322572588920593,
0.1376664936542511,
-0.5938172340393066,
-0.32603782415390015,
0.09050697088241577,
-0.13705593347549438,
0.29808759689331055,
-0.5144584774971008,
-0.38868004083633423,
-0.20648355782032013,
0.09430474042892456,
0.28300631046295166,
0.38346853852272034,
-0.370070219039917,
0.6738237738609314,
0.6385321021080017,
-0.4730489253997803,
-0.32411491870880127,
-0.6444941163063049,
-0.22326107323169708,
-0.10652324557304382,
-0.2353202849626541,
0.659653902053833,
0.29276981949806213,
-0.12922532856464386,
0.0771259218454361,
0.2625274062156677,
-0.1586570143699646,
-0.19036158919334412,
0.1985476016998291,
0.20529262721538544,
-0.1915884017944336,
0.3764955997467041,
0.0487213209271431,
0.014636513777077198,
0.00475357985123992,
-0.05364158749580383,
0.4335983991622925,
0.25359970331192017,
-0.6452505588531494,
0.02917536161839962,
0.4949991703033447,
0.3801019489765167,
-0.2706413269042969,
0.672137439250946,
-0.013789406977593899,
-0.511821448802948,
0.2556203603744507,
-0.5706863403320312,
-0.23015524446964264,
-0.38260436058044434,
0.37094447016716003,
-0.36832544207572937,
-0.862138569355011,
0.5529970526695251,
-0.09291594475507736,
0.020016435533761978,
0.3702189326286316,
0.6257427334785461,
0.09840720891952515,
1.0285673141479492,
0.3257454037666321,
0.22089146077632904,
0.2630148231983185,
-0.25617966055870056,
0.04726148396730423,
-0.9632830619812012,
-0.7723193764686584,
-0.7720919251441956,
0.25500813126564026,
-0.5790237784385681,
-0.28044572472572327,
0.561642050743103,
-0.1632162630558014,
-0.1928252875804901,
0.07037430256605148,
-0.5568733215332031,
0.21782347559928894,
0.02939540147781372,
0.3269527852535248,
0.6423240900039673,
0.26050907373428345,
-0.38048475980758667,
-0.11227653175592422,
-0.9139254093170166,
-0.3246624767780304,
1.2185392379760742,
0.26235663890838623,
0.9145636558532715,
0.32808148860931396,
0.5661492943763733,
0.2538636326789856,
0.2834247350692749,
-0.8090318441390991,
0.11364322900772095,
-0.5841948986053467,
-0.5772876739501953,
-0.04980187863111496,
-0.5272268056869507,
-1.5044081211090088,
0.21538573503494263,
-0.2923140525817871,
-0.5502393841743469,
0.31335094571113586,
0.17821112275123596,
-0.49305203557014465,
0.2160201519727707,
-0.012341916561126709,
0.8170004487037659,
-0.2278176248073578,
-0.28725454211235046,
0.13704007863998413,
-0.7058101296424866,
0.012537729926407337,
-0.08284270763397217,
0.12110832333564758,
0.1952264904975891,
-0.04773811623454094,
0.32734227180480957,
-0.6209325194358826,
0.35861578583717346,
-0.04413941502571106,
-0.05693857744336128,
0.25398775935173035,
0.05509740486741066,
0.5914090871810913,
-0.33196359872817993,
-0.33335158228874207,
-0.0642174705862999,
0.11754972487688065,
-0.21906793117523193,
-0.3699701726436615,
0.673831582069397,
-0.4182164669036865,
-0.22951529920101166,
-0.3250945508480072,
-0.04324720427393913,
-0.1006772592663765,
0.05789560824632645,
0.7856727838516235,
0.6553766131401062,
-0.3884502649307251,
0.36693066358566284,
0.9123793840408325,
-0.22643350064754486,
-0.1789466142654419,
0.6297128200531006,
-0.4389301538467407,
-0.24184824526309967,
0.9264623522758484,
0.19698235392570496,
0.2701111435890198,
0.7698194980621338,
0.12738248705863953,
-0.42597177624702454,
-0.435370534658432,
-0.34991133213043213,
0.1342148780822754,
-0.5551674962043762,
-0.2904938757419586,
-0.9885947108268738,
-0.47119006514549255,
-0.10396876931190491,
-0.06565207988023758,
-0.26504358649253845,
-0.1369752436876297,
-0.4217633903026581,
0.003907305188477039,
0.3668566644191742,
0.511359691619873,
0.4325271546840668,
0.34825947880744934,
-1.184609293937683,
0.03151557967066765,
0.2972273826599121,
0.23365874588489532,
-0.05256829038262367,
-0.6890192627906799,
-0.3157898187637329,
-0.18154609203338623,
-0.5921006202697754,
-0.8613806366920471,
0.6874002814292908,
0.31657055020332336,
0.5899330973625183,
0.46767252683639526,
0.049880124628543854,
0.13296253979206085,
-0.5017176866531372,
0.4500829577445984,
0.06541898846626282,
-0.3404896855354309,
0.8605807423591614,
-0.40317225456237793,
0.10934193432331085,
0.38748306035995483,
0.6022334098815918,
-0.6043121814727783,
-0.12623901665210724,
-0.6895365715026855,
-0.9813960790634155,
0.600372850894928,
0.043474823236465454,
-0.3184117078781128,
-0.22211503982543945,
0.6061164736747742,
-0.040894217789173126,
0.19999615848064423,
-0.0655483528971672,
-0.20312969386577606,
-0.005453774239867926,
-0.35612139105796814,
0.0478997565805912,
-0.35892006754875183,
-0.30336225032806396,
0.2612961232662201,
0.46215102076530457,
-0.09737135469913483,
0.46731501817703247,
0.3919057846069336,
0.05386129394173622,
-0.21703636646270752,
0.501038670539856,
-0.08640027791261673,
0.3502058982849121,
-0.37969571352005005,
-0.044882599264383316,
0.10920117050409317,
-0.5465497970581055,
0.05002039298415184,
0.27651819586753845,
-0.18680819869041443,
0.058749254792928696,
0.09340571612119675,
0.7876666784286499,
0.14100870490074158,
-0.8435797691345215,
0.4836166501045227,
-0.17643292248249054,
0.0014163111336529255,
-0.19605053961277008,
0.020237620919942856,
-0.061509910970926285,
-0.020781898871064186,
0.4044642150402069,
-0.5387408137321472,
0.7081880569458008,
-0.5094141960144043,
0.3654576539993286,
0.4113209843635559,
-0.7354862093925476,
-0.10232829302549362,
0.8240757584571838,
0.11101650446653366,
-0.30857664346694946,
0.7477327585220337,
0.0700295940041542,
-0.19379094243049622,
0.6561028361320496,
0.7246593832969666,
0.627597451210022,
-0.342608243227005,
0.09190715849399567,
0.3062856197357178,
-0.3856087028980255,
-0.3013472259044647,
0.43329766392707825,
0.19402934610843658,
-0.6499363780021667,
-0.23634478449821472,
-0.5846526622772217,
-0.6080522537231445,
-0.0770672932267189,
-0.9582610130310059,
0.14477083086967468,
-0.32880306243896484,
-0.32230740785598755,
0.10354296863079071,
-0.11914914101362228,
-0.5597602725028992,
0.2611912488937378,
-0.05398227646946907,
0.5691521763801575,
-0.44147124886512756,
0.8204132318496704,
0.7238213419914246,
-0.361579567193985,
-0.6481099128723145,
-0.12157060205936432,
0.1630050539970398,
-0.5126953721046448,
0.672020435333252,
-0.1932707279920578,
0.08620790392160416,
0.20082761347293854,
-0.03897261992096901,
-0.6570907831192017,
1.320894479751587,
0.15043707191944122,
-0.9508865475654602,
-0.16293738782405853,
-0.16376779973506927,
0.7466742992401123,
-0.49848341941833496,
0.4263632297515869,
0.36884763836860657,
0.07438565790653229,
0.4486713111400604,
-0.723093569278717,
0.09792686998844147,
-0.037385717034339905,
0.12048053741455078,
0.3880060315132141,
-0.5750752091407776,
0.761686384677887,
-0.192897230386734,
-0.3036419451236725,
0.17165908217430115,
0.12284569442272186,
0.5042136907577515,
0.7383427023887634,
0.09086569398641586,
0.7610516548156738,
0.7315319180488586,
-0.2319851666688919,
1.5811246633529663,
-0.055155836045742035,
0.537544846534729,
0.813016414642334,
-0.48073145747184753,
0.8898158073425293,
0.18606790900230408,
-0.3574570417404175,
0.4426756501197815,
0.2256174385547638,
0.1368998885154724,
0.7960841059684753,
0.2129833996295929,
-0.5575767755508423,
-0.19343650341033936,
-0.46714404225349426,
-0.44358617067337036,
0.18945170938968658,
0.6295152902603149,
-0.6132113337516785,
0.02873104438185692,
-0.05219196528196335,
0.018695412203669548,
-0.049049653112888336,
-0.3328866958618164,
1.0956647396087646,
0.12824395298957825,
-0.5821385383605957,
0.22506123781204224,
0.009903034195303917,
0.3739165961742401,
-0.567277193069458,
0.004198921378701925,
-0.35737937688827515,
0.3440200686454773,
-0.30266496539115906,
-0.5522972345352173,
0.45372724533081055,
0.056240685284137726,
-0.13859343528747559,
0.32914265990257263,
0.8384810090065002,
-0.4835321307182312,
-0.4465125799179077,
0.4340236783027649,
0.5866669416427612,
0.3124566972255707,
0.054746419191360474,
-0.5797078609466553,
0.16581010818481445,
-0.12631994485855103,
-0.03089143894612789,
0.44791892170906067,
0.3695911765098572,
0.12406332045793533,
0.7083929181098938,
0.446265310049057,
0.439689576625824,
-0.08485440909862518,
0.13581210374832153,
0.8302014470100403,
-0.6763735413551331,
-0.17557528614997864,
-0.374375581741333,
0.30753302574157715,
0.07023946195840836,
-0.13282565772533417,
0.2592625617980957,
0.8127630352973938,
0.5451616644859314,
0.01345076598227024,
0.8403925895690918,
-0.17696954309940338,
0.990387499332428,
-0.7146897315979004,
0.8430495262145996,
-0.7764031887054443,
0.44244006276130676,
0.12598773837089539,
-0.6178426742553711,
-0.4312097132205963,
0.5412594676017761,
-0.18743962049484253,
-0.07903164625167847,
0.47824645042419434,
0.836646556854248,
-0.07386434823274612,
-0.18179649114608765,
0.502621054649353,
0.25905582308769226,
0.30991610884666443,
0.5262656211853027,
0.5998150110244751,
-0.6549233198165894,
0.5052756667137146,
0.12517684698104858,
-0.007330055348575115,
-0.5780885219573975,
-0.5670503377914429,
-0.2659730315208435,
-0.35290443897247314,
-0.4013808071613312,
-0.5269390344619751,
0.5549845695495605,
0.8413922786712646,
0.6223611831665039,
-0.9024905562400818,
0.010744760744273663,
-0.1457158625125885,
-0.04485315456986427,
0.09634719789028168,
-0.174790620803833,
0.2671803832054138,
-0.1950957328081131,
-0.4665672183036804,
0.3257647454738617,
0.22903352975845337,
-0.16997624933719635,
0.067286916077137,
-0.30887851119041443,
-0.20334254205226898,
-0.12012697756290436,
0.5150773525238037,
0.6921314597129822,
-0.6353298425674438,
-0.006784237455576658,
0.14637768268585205,
-0.40281301736831665,
0.2840341031551361,
0.9172787070274353,
-0.7572206258773804,
0.7266379594802856,
0.5148168206214905,
0.7273038029670715,
0.8007205128669739,
0.1413688361644745,
0.3165017068386078,
-0.5078085660934448,
-0.41582778096199036,
0.41177889704704285,
0.3258735239505768,
0.3997425436973572,
-0.590878427028656,
0.40769392251968384,
0.09036467969417572,
-0.89051753282547,
-0.5621080994606018,
0.05793127417564392,
-0.778945803642273,
-0.01944940909743309,
1.0244909524917603,
-0.39019548892974854,
0.07837861776351929,
-0.5732137560844421,
-0.19792483747005463,
0.2952144145965576,
-0.3936923146247864,
0.7929699420928955,
0.16805489361286163,
-0.20732218027114868,
-0.35826173424720764,
-0.3825628161430359,
0.364096999168396,
0.15755482017993927,
-1.086988925933838,
-0.08536428958177567,
0.5991178154945374,
0.3751094937324524,
0.08537929505109787,
0.9284297823905945,
-0.5700310468673706,
0.1843768209218979,
-0.10862002521753311,
0.2476765364408493,
0.20226208865642548,
-0.16990680992603302,
-0.47515740990638733,
0.3957540988922119,
0.15232768654823303,
-0.14210696518421173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08008v1
|
Sample-Efficient Human Evaluation of Large Language Models via Maximum Discrepancy Competition
| 2024-04-10T01:26:24 | 2024-04-10T01:26:24 |
Kehua Feng, Keyan Ding, Kede Ma, Zhihua Wang, Qiang Zhang, Huajun Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
The past years have witnessed a proliferation of large language models
(LLMs). Yet, automated and unbiased evaluation of LLMs is challenging due to
the inaccuracy of standard metrics in reflecting human preferences and the
inefficiency in sampling informative and diverse test examples. While human
evaluation remains the gold standard, it is expensive and time-consuming,
especially when dealing with a large number of testing samples. To address this
problem, we propose a sample-efficient human evaluation method based on MAximum
Discrepancy (MAD) competition. MAD automatically selects a small set of
informative and diverse instructions, each adapted to two LLMs, whose responses
are subject to three-alternative forced choice by human subjects. The pairwise
comparison results are then aggregated into a global ranking using the Elo
rating system. We select eight representative LLMs and compare them in terms of
four skills: knowledge understanding, mathematical reasoning, writing, and
coding. Experimental results show that the proposed method achieves a reliable
and sensible ranking of LLMs' capabilities, identifies their relative strengths
and weaknesses, and offers valuable insights for further LLM advancement.
|
[
-0.3398229479789734,
-0.5266032814979553,
0.47295108437538147,
0.5038583874702454,
0.05582629516720772,
0.4243375062942505,
-0.38196226954460144,
-0.5120686888694763,
-0.23569780588150024,
0.422493577003479,
-0.3592792749404907,
-0.6773294806480408,
-0.5546916723251343,
0.4891389012336731,
-0.3169553875923157,
0.7017823457717896,
0.051054101437330246,
-0.06461529433727264,
-0.2756994962692261,
-0.10333535075187683,
-0.4713785648345947,
-0.4600570797920227,
-0.4942990839481354,
-0.4189732074737549,
0.2876199185848236,
0.5524595379829407,
0.5225491523742676,
0.49457427859306335,
0.4650070369243622,
0.37152740359306335,
-0.12559686601161957,
0.6168130040168762,
-0.47620007395744324,
-0.03555431589484215,
-0.20701125264167786,
-0.4502158463001251,
-0.3770945966243744,
0.10759307444095612,
0.365364670753479,
0.6729241609573364,
-0.2946590781211853,
0.2714511752128601,
-0.009522831998765469,
0.7491389513015747,
-0.5956981182098389,
0.262548565864563,
-0.8071231842041016,
-0.04890557751059532,
-0.15603965520858765,
-0.18816059827804565,
-0.49466967582702637,
-0.5501837134361267,
0.0952460989356041,
-0.4615699052810669,
0.3955650329589844,
0.1373850256204605,
0.7434191107749939,
0.1313546746969223,
-0.18995729088783264,
-0.13684311509132385,
-0.6338481307029724,
0.8695687055587769,
-0.562128484249115,
0.30633506178855896,
0.3865812420845032,
0.4594375491142273,
-0.2874055802822113,
-0.03171435743570328,
-0.622442901134491,
-0.6399804949760437,
0.32358506321907043,
0.10131941735744476,
-0.423552006483078,
0.042097315192222595,
0.07502386718988419,
0.1761876791715622,
-0.6696087718009949,
0.429124653339386,
-0.05995810776948929,
-0.13951173424720764,
1.0217077732086182,
0.20726415514945984,
0.31754401326179504,
0.043224044144153595,
-0.058427926152944565,
-0.4495755732059479,
-0.42315423488616943,
-0.30094456672668457,
0.7102497816085815,
0.23591706156730652,
0.13046899437904358,
0.6863863468170166,
-0.36693456768989563,
0.7928593158721924,
0.14443358778953552,
-0.27306634187698364,
0.5395604372024536,
-0.052803777158260345,
-0.08429882675409317,
-0.3124144971370697,
0.8580548763275146,
0.5123735070228577,
0.36391767859458923,
-0.2722174823284149,
-0.5469568371772766,
0.12392156571149826,
0.0327800028026104,
-0.41237935423851013,
-0.1503499150276184,
0.08120140433311462,
-0.1032310277223587,
-0.14354349672794342,
0.01825677417218685,
-1.0092326402664185,
-0.6815633177757263,
-0.0999889001250267,
0.3519600033760071,
-0.13685964047908783,
-0.18623128533363342,
0.41217681765556335,
-0.11427439749240875,
-0.17713208496570587,
0.3901921510696411,
-0.6239191293716431,
0.3971248269081116,
0.5182479023933411,
0.8007512092590332,
-0.4278261065483093,
-0.5269439220428467,
-0.4069482386112213,
-0.207342267036438,
-0.3471944034099579,
1.002461314201355,
-0.5545650720596313,
-0.46352943778038025,
-0.1465766727924347,
-0.4635695219039917,
-0.028820673003792763,
-1.1407313346862793,
0.6440098881721497,
-0.5570592284202576,
-0.05422696843743324,
-0.16744157671928406,
-0.47548288106918335,
-0.10262710601091385,
0.17477543652057648,
-0.9287208318710327,
1.0315340757369995,
0.3160308301448822,
-0.7862545251846313,
0.29801008105278015,
-0.6511572003364563,
-0.28488612174987793,
0.012308252044022083,
-0.04655997082591057,
-0.30857887864112854,
0.01222876738756895,
0.3464013934135437,
0.5409024357795715,
-0.48272988200187683,
0.19455882906913757,
-0.3424709141254425,
-0.4576602876186371,
0.3820374011993408,
-0.5134190320968628,
0.5641263127326965,
0.1870516836643219,
-0.3149662911891937,
-0.030706189572811127,
-0.8429977297782898,
-0.08742313832044601,
0.3132096827030182,
-0.613828182220459,
-0.3400055766105652,
-0.06039377301931381,
-0.1637841761112213,
0.32351452112197876,
0.17022518813610077,
-0.42298319935798645,
0.1612931340932846,
-0.4609525203704834,
0.10909758508205414,
0.9590182304382324,
-0.16004756093025208,
0.20718978345394135,
-0.46827495098114014,
0.6458418369293213,
-0.06237618625164032,
0.060630589723587036,
0.4232950508594513,
-0.31525787711143494,
-0.8351553082466125,
-0.39177587628364563,
0.35354748368263245,
0.7172197699546814,
-0.540833055973053,
0.9041748046875,
-0.3198387026786804,
-0.5280800461769104,
-0.7918446660041809,
0.4584676921367645,
0.4015580713748932,
0.08686401695013046,
0.1291700005531311,
-0.2670919597148895,
-0.6541406512260437,
-0.9978867173194885,
-0.3859567642211914,
-0.31363460421562195,
-0.054705359041690826,
0.256481409072876,
0.5171062350273132,
-0.13800771534442902,
0.7512920498847961,
-0.5513375401496887,
-0.20961754024028778,
-0.5462956428527832,
0.057302478700876236,
0.20293647050857544,
-0.0785481333732605,
0.12694117426872253,
-0.4464165270328522,
-0.3213280737400055,
0.13406254351139069,
-0.21475769579410553,
-0.6583705544471741,
-0.14461199939250946,
-0.3102664053440094,
0.2708333134651184,
0.1111660972237587,
-0.5559946298599243,
0.07666028290987015,
0.580540120601654,
-0.21505747735500336,
0.8880950808525085,
-0.3472713530063629,
0.16040955483913422,
-0.5352709889411926,
0.26056429743766785,
0.2715710699558258,
-0.2464800328016281,
-0.3155803084373474,
-0.0038487734273076057,
0.013888650573790073,
0.3401602506637573,
-0.13753961026668549,
0.8176938891410828,
-0.402656227350235,
-0.09931540489196777,
-0.22438068687915802,
0.5314198732376099,
-0.12219423800706863,
0.49930328130722046,
-0.26091665029525757,
0.7908824682235718,
0.16580311954021454,
-0.6063582897186279,
0.44048163294792175,
0.0625724047422409,
-0.6644330024719238,
0.3913567066192627,
-0.5230387449264526,
0.3957865536212921,
-0.0888650193810463,
0.28384336829185486,
-0.9570425152778625,
-0.1224658414721489,
-0.23065583407878876,
-0.3852451741695404,
0.015626821666955948,
0.2499445229768753,
-0.8899122476577759,
-0.5699517130851746,
-0.23929695785045624,
0.016324779018759727,
0.39081010222435,
-0.4767148494720459,
0.2525186836719513,
0.7154183387756348,
-0.19647450745105743,
-0.6951833963394165,
-0.345892071723938,
-0.025109652429819107,
-0.18091806769371033,
-0.42472735047340393,
0.07263749092817307,
-0.23666241765022278,
-0.4144103229045868,
-0.4066472351551056,
-0.2662905752658844,
-0.031398508697748184,
0.0963875874876976,
-0.08935526013374329,
0.33029377460479736,
0.30077987909317017,
-0.02789924480021,
-0.1121474876999855,
0.0323602631688118,
-0.13003963232040405,
-0.09252691268920898,
0.6624400615692139,
-0.18350523710250854,
-0.48450836539268494,
-0.3254213333129883,
0.25265079736709595,
0.6267103552818298,
-0.24139077961444855,
0.2929343581199646,
0.12968266010284424,
-0.13949373364448547,
-0.5469736456871033,
-0.8846986889839172,
0.2633208632469177,
-0.43773147463798523,
0.8646948337554932,
-0.2379016876220703,
-0.7124028205871582,
0.37885698676109314,
0.007649617735296488,
0.3382122814655304,
0.3287225067615509,
0.7599475979804993,
0.30715692043304443,
1.4559082984924316,
0.3248300552368164,
-0.3320830464363098,
0.27963194251060486,
-0.11011774837970734,
0.01768575981259346,
-0.514502763748169,
-0.2861921787261963,
-0.7314655780792236,
-0.26529067754745483,
-0.22710837423801422,
-0.4989420175552368,
0.3317846953868866,
-0.06905999779701233,
-0.36921459436416626,
0.11399835348129272,
-0.40754300355911255,
0.8141153454780579,
0.5022677183151245,
0.19704338908195496,
0.5890671014785767,
-0.03832540288567543,
-0.3918498754501343,
0.08161971718072891,
-0.5990455746650696,
-0.5439334511756897,
1.1333693265914917,
0.21958255767822266,
0.7491939067840576,
0.21793995797634125,
0.48169997334480286,
0.4616450369358063,
0.3609544634819031,
-0.6977848410606384,
0.7420564889907837,
-0.3284233808517456,
-0.4460894763469696,
-0.21645419299602509,
-0.6283986568450928,
-0.9026462435722351,
0.4905884861946106,
-0.19179464876651764,
-0.67798912525177,
-0.16962192952632904,
0.11227811872959137,
-0.4025600850582123,
0.3472508192062378,
-0.8006976246833801,
0.4935300946235657,
-0.22857798635959625,
0.04557005688548088,
-0.13347333669662476,
-0.3889484703540802,
0.475877583026886,
-0.2842422127723694,
0.32731157541275024,
-0.2580757439136505,
0.024555256590247154,
0.8044770956039429,
-0.12485431879758835,
0.6795451045036316,
-0.07058551907539368,
-0.10051202028989792,
0.001308864215388894,
0.27070102095603943,
0.4465564787387848,
-0.2388535439968109,
-0.2674492299556732,
-0.010786079801619053,
-0.23903052508831024,
-0.26706385612487793,
-0.7125645875930786,
0.5560088157653809,
-0.9856413006782532,
-0.6792853474617004,
-0.34685400128364563,
-0.6583238840103149,
-0.5583462119102478,
0.02265920862555504,
0.06696859747171402,
-0.08466163277626038,
-0.24645623564720154,
-0.20897983014583588,
0.5854364037513733,
-0.3732181489467621,
0.12430848926305771,
0.6248798966407776,
-0.24753215909004211,
-0.3538834750652313,
0.8542687892913818,
-0.12417183816432953,
0.32851317524909973,
0.4504906237125397,
0.45740944147109985,
-0.4927501678466797,
-0.5192045569419861,
-0.3866904675960541,
0.4288167953491211,
-0.6353199481964111,
-0.18607382476329803,
-0.7093468904495239,
0.09250647574663162,
-0.16196294128894806,
0.05224404111504555,
-0.39941009879112244,
-0.09504808485507965,
0.0038249145727604628,
-0.03308924660086632,
0.03499317914247513,
0.6174861192703247,
-0.04144907742738724,
0.08486618101596832,
-0.676727294921875,
0.20648746192455292,
0.40425124764442444,
0.23390138149261475,
0.25468724966049194,
-0.6619011163711548,
-0.20880340039730072,
-0.10809477418661118,
-0.554736852645874,
-0.8078117966651917,
0.4696243107318878,
0.13046105206012726,
0.8571418523788452,
0.3931179940700531,
0.030200695618987083,
0.8711790442466736,
-0.48512977361679077,
0.46112412214279175,
0.1945229172706604,
-1.0216549634933472,
0.2928469479084015,
0.0018572495318949223,
0.2480526715517044,
0.7085577845573425,
0.1291711926460266,
-0.614108681678772,
-0.6199074983596802,
-0.47977784276008606,
-0.8143918514251709,
0.6057047247886658,
0.09213615208864212,
-0.011865674518048763,
-0.06261958181858063,
0.066721610724926,
0.27508655190467834,
0.10033413022756577,
-0.48489391803741455,
-0.13289125263690948,
0.43260931968688965,
-0.2840544283390045,
-0.038587335497140884,
0.10260564088821411,
-0.2239709347486496,
-0.24493862688541412,
0.6494547724723816,
-0.0231978427618742,
0.25432220101356506,
0.04710010811686516,
-0.2341422736644745,
-0.05264217033982277,
0.3915310800075531,
0.400531142950058,
0.7964431047439575,
-0.07570807635784149,
0.16565363109111786,
0.3983066976070404,
-0.5476681590080261,
0.32016950845718384,
0.13737288117408752,
0.03513333946466446,
0.0896754190325737,
0.2619747817516327,
0.659981906414032,
0.11751886457204819,
-1.2618134021759033,
0.6394082307815552,
-0.046561263501644135,
-0.18314705789089203,
-0.05147232115268707,
0.20811204612255096,
-0.06286950409412384,
0.31016695499420166,
0.39054593443870544,
0.044221363961696625,
0.15857769548892975,
-0.3131425976753235,
0.07571244984865189,
0.358341246843338,
0.11556081473827362,
-0.20953954756259918,
0.39737096428871155,
0.21057650446891785,
-0.3396100103855133,
0.43041694164276123,
-0.352306604385376,
-0.47283217310905457,
0.5615845322608948,
0.5833185315132141,
0.7311986088752747,
-0.4536936581134796,
0.29625383019447327,
0.19900858402252197,
0.2592270076274872,
-0.5860090851783752,
0.2854820191860199,
0.3133368194103241,
-0.7645205855369568,
-0.4955233633518219,
-0.5284019708633423,
-0.5268197655677795,
0.3476986289024353,
-0.39914533495903015,
0.31690138578414917,
-0.33262398838996887,
-0.14046700298786163,
-0.08256726711988449,
0.2769957482814789,
-0.8518347144126892,
0.10214362293481827,
0.17773039638996124,
1.0198270082473755,
-0.781328022480011,
0.5392943620681763,
0.7036049365997314,
0.00040399018325842917,
-0.6640456914901733,
-0.04694771766662598,
0.01990838162600994,
-0.7523888349533081,
0.6643179059028625,
0.1481100618839264,
-0.31723010540008545,
-0.18308836221694946,
-0.4429740309715271,
-0.6242873668670654,
0.8207026720046997,
0.6992833614349365,
-0.7961305379867554,
-0.1510368287563324,
-0.11588368564844131,
0.5017278790473938,
-0.2558582127094269,
0.5547624826431274,
0.9224960207939148,
0.36985233426094055,
0.03887633606791496,
-1.0411518812179565,
-0.1515270471572876,
-0.3425538241863251,
0.11043676733970642,
0.07446520775556564,
-0.6001236438751221,
0.5217047333717346,
-0.3636404573917389,
-0.3403415381908417,
-0.0017554317601025105,
0.5746752619743347,
0.8297579884529114,
0.11602102220058441,
0.9408265948295593,
0.417571097612381,
1.143479347229004,
0.1662135273218155,
0.908059298992157,
-0.16311679780483246,
0.47619494795799255,
1.0428130626678467,
-0.5436618328094482,
0.9037734270095825,
0.15066251158714294,
-0.6289821863174438,
0.20885947346687317,
0.5762184262275696,
0.018948407843708992,
0.4041397273540497,
0.7412156462669373,
-0.3540252447128296,
-0.47380614280700684,
0.2223111093044281,
-0.0058520822785794735,
0.6403840184211731,
0.0914640724658966,
-0.039216022938489914,
-0.32958146929740906,
-0.2990485429763794,
0.15045993030071259,
0.1196511760354042,
-0.10300988703966141,
0.4517972469329834,
-0.07211882621049881,
-0.7082523703575134,
0.6553784608840942,
0.22178183495998383,
0.878390908241272,
-0.607343852519989,
-0.04989967867732048,
-0.31695035099983215,
0.10873092710971832,
-0.0968734622001648,
-0.7124196290969849,
-0.08552740514278412,
0.4665437638759613,
0.009447136893868446,
0.22438497841358185,
0.34046217799186707,
-0.346090167760849,
-0.515180766582489,
0.30310526490211487,
0.5558980703353882,
0.2671201527118683,
-0.13438937067985535,
-0.727891206741333,
-0.022461164742708206,
-0.05137237533926964,
-0.21264488995075226,
0.22880811989307404,
0.3070901930332184,
-0.13003894686698914,
0.9486485719680786,
0.637685239315033,
0.4578791856765747,
-0.11915236711502075,
0.3682917058467865,
0.6636022329330444,
-0.5815742611885071,
-0.5311895608901978,
-1.0025444030761719,
0.1742478758096695,
-0.2705264687538147,
-0.4827207028865814,
0.6827647089958191,
0.6223040819168091,
0.9766280651092529,
0.08949978649616241,
1.1031044721603394,
0.29074254631996155,
0.6246193051338196,
-0.336161345243454,
0.5997855067253113,
-0.49179765582084656,
0.4837905764579773,
-0.5411908626556396,
-0.8598344326019287,
-0.4599211513996124,
0.6451981067657471,
-0.2803037464618683,
0.1408797651529312,
0.5663332343101501,
0.8654413819313049,
0.09664604067802429,
-0.1328023225069046,
0.5087209343910217,
0.19609759747982025,
0.28638756275177,
0.9027592539787292,
0.849759578704834,
0.11237900704145432,
0.5760053396224976,
-0.023753752931952477,
-0.5502521991729736,
-0.3597847819328308,
-0.7352962493896484,
-0.8884649872779846,
-0.4104904234409332,
-0.20345546305179596,
-0.3547062277793884,
0.001498002209700644,
1.3524190187454224,
0.6225241422653198,
-0.6261367797851562,
-0.5333783626556396,
0.23750756680965424,
0.21437005698680878,
-0.4285946786403656,
-0.18536688387393951,
0.39903363585472107,
-0.029335100203752518,
-1.049529790878296,
0.327114462852478,
0.15458457171916962,
-0.20592178404331207,
-0.44770392775535583,
-0.08426349610090256,
-0.04000924900174141,
0.19685901701450348,
0.6133594512939453,
0.09685757756233215,
-0.6766158938407898,
-0.1586204320192337,
0.10593494027853012,
-0.1596890091896057,
0.06268495321273804,
0.6741405129432678,
-0.547594428062439,
0.5027698874473572,
0.46441876888275146,
0.7628600597381592,
0.0017002292443066835,
0.02986184135079384,
0.4809270203113556,
-0.593508243560791,
-0.2263655811548233,
0.2492198646068573,
0.20822599530220032,
0.4194357693195343,
-0.27883878350257874,
0.3163793385028839,
0.1728171706199646,
-0.702233612537384,
-0.8244774341583252,
0.1169162169098854,
-0.9867594838142395,
-0.25342679023742676,
1.4894641637802124,
-0.14168240129947662,
-0.06943075358867645,
-0.2804110646247864,
-0.3437274098396301,
0.25099897384643555,
-0.6204400658607483,
1.1989299058914185,
0.826594889163971,
-0.23619505763053894,
0.11448239535093307,
-0.8260953426361084,
0.0924307331442833,
0.24458876252174377,
-0.9497325420379639,
0.26882269978523254,
0.4574562609195709,
0.3650675415992737,
-0.06743671745061874,
0.5750976204872131,
-0.16916193068027496,
0.16840875148773193,
-0.22760820388793945,
0.31668609380722046,
-0.048447053879499435,
-0.19471774995326996,
-0.38893765211105347,
0.005627440754324198,
0.26505884528160095,
-0.12838797271251678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06670v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06670v1
|
What's Mine becomes Yours: Defining, Annotating and Detecting Context-Dependent Paraphrases in News Interview Dialogs
| 2024-04-10T01:14:12 | 2024-04-10T01:14:12 |
Anna Wegmann, Tijs van den Broek, Dong Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Best practices for high conflict conversations like counseling or customer
support almost always include recommendations to paraphrase the previous
speaker. Although paraphrase classification has received widespread attention
in NLP, paraphrases are usually considered independent from context, and common
models and datasets are not applicable to dialog settings. In this work, we
investigate paraphrases in dialog (e.g., Speaker 1: "That book is mine."
becomes Speaker 2: "That book is yours."). We provide an operationalization of
context-dependent paraphrases, and develop a training for crowd-workers to
classify paraphrases in dialog. We introduce a dataset with utterance pairs
from NPR and CNN news interviews annotated for context-dependent paraphrases.
To enable analyses on label variation, the dataset contains 5,581 annotations
on 600 utterance pairs. We present promising results with in-context learning
and with token classification models for automatic paraphrase detection in
dialog.
|
[
-0.36408182978630066,
-0.7495810985565186,
0.5876941680908203,
0.23369474709033966,
-0.19783982634544373,
-0.21689386665821075,
0.013305350206792355,
-0.16401714086532593,
0.1571282297372818,
0.9574252367019653,
-0.45535510778427124,
-0.2028367817401886,
-0.47441232204437256,
0.46572157740592957,
-0.379896342754364,
1.4563053846359253,
0.22828646004199982,
-0.049185238778591156,
-0.5808588266372681,
-0.4054214656352997,
-0.5831948518753052,
-0.6483014225959778,
-0.19404524564743042,
0.011984938755631447,
0.4341539740562439,
0.4596847593784332,
0.7691306471824646,
0.7440673112869263,
0.2612304985523224,
0.4417533278465271,
-0.4455883502960205,
-0.0705067366361618,
-0.24778160452842712,
0.5318845510482788,
-0.33785396814346313,
-0.284044474363327,
0.3917653262615204,
0.2804512679576874,
0.5399073958396912,
0.488477498292923,
-0.27943024039268494,
0.27222609519958496,
0.13829022645950317,
0.24366062879562378,
-0.48220568895339966,
0.4156087636947632,
-1.0645527839660645,
-0.003854980692267418,
-0.015275994315743446,
-0.4875010848045349,
-0.3125802278518677,
-0.39404380321502686,
0.3879156708717346,
-0.25458335876464844,
0.16970041394233704,
0.02190074324607849,
0.6415218710899353,
-0.06524509191513062,
-0.7360202074050903,
-0.5443890690803528,
-0.3097076416015625,
0.6772804856300354,
-0.637506365776062,
0.13281837105751038,
0.4431176483631134,
0.3699260354042053,
-0.09852296859025955,
-1.028812289237976,
-0.5673556327819824,
-0.05982518941164017,
-0.21420176327228546,
-0.0024973901454359293,
-0.07956875115633011,
-0.05071591958403587,
0.21704261004924774,
0.2047995775938034,
-0.233326718211174,
-0.6224834322929382,
-0.6031526923179626,
-0.16485197842121124,
0.18818087875843048,
0.1462581306695938,
0.2824680805206299,
-0.647519052028656,
-0.32268697023391724,
0.28228873014450073,
-0.33170896768569946,
-0.23548950254917145,
0.1706608235836029,
0.17800112068653107,
0.3597342073917389,
0.35093486309051514,
-0.4735284149646759,
0.716349184513092,
0.07960958778858185,
-0.3887880742549896,
0.31318068504333496,
-0.3049984872341156,
-0.17344799637794495,
0.18421310186386108,
0.5452571511268616,
0.5372046232223511,
0.23671765625476837,
-0.18096983432769775,
0.3679773807525635,
-0.5723070502281189,
0.20617780089378357,
-0.34875646233558655,
-0.06466146558523178,
-0.2123604714870453,
-0.40466493368148804,
-0.5266097784042358,
-0.36597126722335815,
-0.6048367619514465,
-0.5816196799278259,
-0.5999588966369629,
0.3282451927661896,
-0.21259279549121857,
-0.01825111359357834,
-0.09335002303123474,
-0.45643866062164307,
0.2222026139497757,
0.33795347809791565,
-0.6712697148323059,
0.13984329998493195,
0.9642921686172485,
0.9164040088653564,
0.12485066801309586,
-0.6186999678611755,
-0.6817252039909363,
0.18646420538425446,
-0.31591489911079407,
0.7224706411361694,
-0.7739395499229431,
-0.43236929178237915,
0.23201872408390045,
0.2732591927051544,
-0.2665335536003113,
-0.7186397910118103,
0.7691325545310974,
-0.37027058005332947,
0.653719425201416,
-0.5549208521842957,
-0.5303021669387817,
-0.25416749715805054,
0.3644453287124634,
-0.20490959286689758,
0.6578773260116577,
0.10995230823755264,
-1.010916829109192,
0.06636229902505875,
-0.13440613448619843,
-0.5291506052017212,
0.12279082834720612,
-0.29851746559143066,
-0.11241791397333145,
0.24368710815906525,
-0.025967493653297424,
0.43929049372673035,
-0.3492485582828522,
0.43747562170028687,
-0.4238255023956299,
-0.07610147446393967,
0.30955514311790466,
-0.21929587423801422,
0.534289538860321,
0.22519837319850922,
-0.05526037886738777,
-0.36127227544784546,
-0.5717576146125793,
0.016453318297863007,
-0.09058545529842377,
-0.3863259553909302,
-0.3335789144039154,
-0.015407277271151543,
0.020444022491574287,
0.4570210576057434,
0.2010413110256195,
-0.5590415000915527,
-0.03737887367606163,
-0.1346302479505539,
0.54072105884552,
0.715556263923645,
0.8291547894477844,
0.3674505054950714,
-0.5202604532241821,
0.16298164427280426,
-0.035153523087501526,
-0.025001391768455505,
-0.2031768262386322,
-0.6746237874031067,
-0.17491711676120758,
0.3340628445148468,
0.032961469143629074,
0.4860686957836151,
-0.6721146702766418,
0.5933865904808044,
-0.17700962722301483,
-0.18756960332393646,
-0.20367136597633362,
0.37976187467575073,
0.3358064889907837,
0.9678391814231873,
0.3475586473941803,
0.010811704210937023,
-0.5279967188835144,
-1.0202652215957642,
-0.5646955370903015,
-0.41309618949890137,
0.09194790571928024,
0.2914523482322693,
0.2793941795825958,
-0.22967560589313507,
1.0088964700698853,
-0.41630491614341736,
-0.33278632164001465,
-0.5175442099571228,
0.20003549754619598,
-0.11823637038469315,
0.5806511640548706,
0.3733753561973572,
-1.0558559894561768,
-0.4107593894004822,
-0.0905650183558464,
-0.9523820281028748,
-0.2533433437347412,
-0.42290380597114563,
-0.3868284523487091,
-0.4892483353614807,
0.8423937559127808,
-0.5255013108253479,
0.13205373287200928,
0.533919095993042,
-0.41444286704063416,
0.45971933007240295,
0.01893794909119606,
0.2926574945449829,
-1.4030842781066895,
-0.34792590141296387,
-0.13609154522418976,
-0.2209347039461136,
-0.3720870614051819,
-0.204814150929451,
-0.29545605182647705,
-0.22199945151805878,
-0.3768993616104126,
0.28200700879096985,
-0.1427091509103775,
-0.09831098467111588,
-0.4494476616382599,
0.1822335124015808,
0.09257086366415024,
0.5867660045623779,
0.13225840032100677,
0.6094900965690613,
0.39434003829956055,
-0.5228716135025024,
0.1849183887243271,
0.9276169538497925,
-0.4912995398044586,
0.834520161151886,
-0.34445881843566895,
0.05347343161702156,
-0.350864976644516,
0.47784075140953064,
-0.7844470739364624,
-0.3922530710697174,
0.28440406918525696,
-0.2679693400859833,
-0.0774073600769043,
-0.4416273236274719,
-0.4496559500694275,
0.03750726580619812,
-0.13160380721092224,
-0.05518397316336632,
0.37859103083610535,
-0.8476763963699341,
0.4773261547088623,
0.3589928448200226,
-0.5737006068229675,
-0.3640936017036438,
-0.5865738391876221,
0.46533647179603577,
-0.22279611229896545,
-0.3615422248840332,
0.07900163531303406,
-0.3159063160419464,
-0.1999247670173645,
-0.19433709979057312,
-0.1935368776321411,
-0.609809398651123,
-0.09405187517404556,
0.4305274486541748,
-0.49974146485328674,
-0.08686166256666183,
0.2505281865596771,
0.33588552474975586,
0.032934799790382385,
0.014616325497627258,
0.13691943883895874,
0.34640470147132874,
-0.25216367840766907,
0.06502574682235718,
-0.5035741329193115,
0.5262691378593445,
0.7582592368125916,
-0.11958003789186478,
0.6540228128433228,
0.49377715587615967,
-0.11255459487438202,
0.21324749290943146,
-0.8014319539070129,
-0.17063048481941223,
-0.5363332629203796,
0.48749756813049316,
-0.5333428382873535,
-0.4695282280445099,
0.20222482085227966,
-0.21461781859397888,
0.18269234895706177,
0.1859949827194214,
0.4421839416027069,
-0.1905529946088791,
0.9747560024261475,
0.2890167534351349,
-0.15953056514263153,
0.7218840718269348,
0.027086589485406876,
-0.15153737366199493,
-0.7563440203666687,
-0.11339684575796127,
-0.17219781875610352,
-0.24350859224796295,
-0.38092944025993347,
-0.4044336974620819,
0.2524644732475281,
-0.00988694280385971,
0.10550736635923386,
0.48548436164855957,
-0.12352138757705688,
0.6845703125,
0.8013238906860352,
0.12678629159927368,
0.4119710624217987,
-0.18540294468402863,
0.4999409019947052,
-0.3165387809276581,
-0.4707247018814087,
-0.6283664107322693,
0.7034778594970703,
0.1872309148311615,
0.3325459063053131,
0.06788104772567749,
0.929936945438385,
0.6005710363388062,
0.10063695907592773,
-0.2724686563014984,
0.6473764777183533,
0.22821971774101257,
-0.6506617665290833,
-0.03287622705101967,
-0.44025662541389465,
-0.8326622247695923,
0.4456414580345154,
-0.013355027884244919,
-0.7866621613502502,
0.05566520616412163,
-0.06512320041656494,
0.07239207625389099,
0.1947997361421585,
-0.7315184473991394,
0.9957132935523987,
0.12409447878599167,
0.08936470746994019,
0.01942094974219799,
-0.7130598425865173,
0.2855561375617981,
-0.11821495741605759,
0.01299126073718071,
-0.36942464113235474,
0.16537992656230927,
1.0413708686828613,
-0.3881719410419464,
0.7503216862678528,
-0.06485259532928467,
0.2985781729221344,
0.7457801103591919,
0.18990345299243927,
0.41263383626937866,
0.3168770372867584,
-0.22737741470336914,
-0.22875913977622986,
0.33930641412734985,
-0.44408056139945984,
-0.4806136190891266,
0.870858907699585,
-0.4656192660331726,
-0.7291950583457947,
-0.22992002964019775,
-0.4027833640575409,
-0.42317646741867065,
-0.11343783885240555,
0.5612831711769104,
0.4048365354537964,
-0.03384394571185112,
0.7066158652305603,
0.2814073860645294,
0.08162794262170792,
0.3537037968635559,
0.20875057578086853,
0.2838543653488159,
-0.3513513207435608,
0.9949862957000732,
0.10630069673061371,
0.21507497131824493,
0.19197799265384674,
0.5142390727996826,
-0.03890961781144142,
-0.34973710775375366,
-0.27145832777023315,
0.25554198026657104,
-1.1448663473129272,
-0.27282193303108215,
-1.0200762748718262,
-0.08389782160520554,
-0.49487781524658203,
-0.33071187138557434,
0.056160032749176025,
-0.17757321894168854,
-0.2149733603000641,
-0.3670142590999603,
0.39860132336616516,
0.6141940355300903,
0.040821559727191925,
0.6981560587882996,
-0.7935823202133179,
0.0038938676007092,
0.7012333869934082,
-0.31202495098114014,
-0.3964814841747284,
-0.8445004224777222,
-0.11814753711223602,
-0.0526227243244648,
-0.5721092820167542,
-1.0772181749343872,
0.5345758199691772,
0.5052618384361267,
0.431135356426239,
0.4180890917778015,
0.20173680782318115,
0.44216108322143555,
-0.5073555111885071,
0.742057204246521,
-0.02368427999317646,
-0.9990112781524658,
0.4134889841079712,
-0.5641679763793945,
0.10478660464286804,
1.0093278884887695,
0.28923481702804565,
-0.8638654947280884,
-0.7954728603363037,
-1.0485401153564453,
-0.5654945969581604,
0.4786512553691864,
0.3522779941558838,
0.5295889973640442,
-0.32685768604278564,
0.20513232052326202,
0.19520285725593567,
0.6348903179168701,
-1.0823811292648315,
-0.20379211008548737,
0.15422125160694122,
-0.3089412748813629,
-0.1152084693312645,
-0.39854612946510315,
-0.21832583844661713,
-0.08661498129367828,
0.28600969910621643,
-0.09860679507255554,
0.24540932476520538,
0.04362131655216217,
-0.23391352593898773,
0.2726653218269348,
0.07772664725780487,
0.2826371490955353,
0.3955889642238617,
-0.17211507260799408,
0.2390446960926056,
0.4963776171207428,
-0.0671844482421875,
-0.04460730031132698,
-0.2726130485534668,
0.019565271213650703,
0.6126700639724731,
0.3891032040119171,
0.585399329662323,
0.4898085296154022,
-0.7577836513519287,
0.8848450779914856,
0.12573595345020294,
-0.25824522972106934,
-0.19178341329097748,
-0.09724759310483932,
-0.08393529057502747,
0.4780503809452057,
0.11363895982503891,
0.026403551921248436,
0.5944932699203491,
-0.6619764566421509,
0.562371015548706,
-0.0047309608198702335,
-0.31431904435157776,
-0.26172110438346863,
0.42432838678359985,
0.2602103650569916,
-0.27574482560157776,
0.3619579076766968,
-0.2665681838989258,
-0.5199056267738342,
0.39530378580093384,
0.5150688290596008,
0.9766245484352112,
-0.039842389523983,
0.5023447871208191,
0.14343862235546112,
-0.02860514633357525,
-0.21819399297237396,
-0.04656509682536125,
-0.4656086564064026,
-0.42604246735572815,
0.1431540548801422,
-0.3367511034011841,
-0.6059762835502625,
0.1390514224767685,
-0.6470023393630981,
0.18347184360027313,
-0.654218316078186,
-0.003329130355268717,
0.048361267894506454,
-0.5355634689331055,
-0.439791738986969,
0.3949316740036011,
0.08603200316429138,
0.4260213077068329,
-0.9772993922233582,
0.5563008189201355,
0.22785323858261108,
-0.3304024040699005,
-0.13231469690799713,
0.42542535066604614,
0.04173651710152626,
-0.8440226912498474,
0.7140414118766785,
0.17584455013275146,
0.42787203192710876,
-0.059491947293281555,
-0.5074729323387146,
-0.9037185311317444,
0.7701245546340942,
0.12409743666648865,
-0.10820623487234116,
-0.10049869120121002,
-0.08595743030309677,
0.43131938576698303,
-0.43841415643692017,
0.14519067108631134,
0.4564855396747589,
0.1835481971502304,
0.0575142465531826,
-0.753105103969574,
-0.21140727400779724,
0.028347423300147057,
-0.07589299231767654,
0.03972107172012329,
-0.58937668800354,
0.8223913311958313,
0.20957747101783752,
0.11812484264373779,
0.2646862864494324,
0.6327894330024719,
-0.2694838047027588,
0.49681758880615234,
0.5548847913742065,
0.06268603354692459,
0.4502398371696472,
0.09513610601425171,
0.7252663969993591,
-0.36971503496170044,
0.2260078638792038,
1.4898818731307983,
-0.09405941516160965,
0.9840424656867981,
0.45921510457992554,
0.14071621000766754,
0.5846623182296753,
0.5283151268959045,
0.11110492050647736,
0.5471134185791016,
0.0314006432890892,
-0.44894206523895264,
-0.13941381871700287,
-0.24822227656841278,
-0.4658330976963043,
0.4666300117969513,
0.2440127432346344,
-0.7928812503814697,
-0.5190138220787048,
0.40850400924682617,
0.05745728313922882,
0.17445792257785797,
0.027331743389368057,
1.2116819620132446,
-0.06261762231588364,
-0.6332808136940002,
0.4346950948238373,
-0.0013736165128648281,
0.31716737151145935,
-0.4855714738368988,
0.18643364310264587,
-0.18350505828857422,
-0.11217077076435089,
-0.1422683447599411,
-0.5534597039222717,
0.3133106827735901,
-0.24483932554721832,
-0.12436532974243164,
-0.3858357071876526,
0.29841262102127075,
-0.6420305967330933,
-0.41968220472335815,
0.019686687737703323,
0.5560694932937622,
0.28871557116508484,
-0.3722604811191559,
-0.7910274863243103,
-0.1776239424943924,
0.3411615490913391,
-0.37319740653038025,
0.4208613336086273,
0.5390048027038574,
0.2140190303325653,
0.5573457479476929,
0.3719753324985504,
-0.2175186425447464,
0.3167366683483124,
-0.2560991942882538,
0.618974506855011,
-0.810373067855835,
-0.612433671951294,
-0.659260094165802,
0.034303538501262665,
-0.4324356019496918,
-0.7362226843833923,
0.8450742363929749,
0.5881909132003784,
0.43530383706092834,
-0.4039308428764343,
1.0822486877441406,
-0.034758757799863815,
0.784334123134613,
-0.29224255681037903,
0.191503643989563,
-0.35182666778564453,
0.003148878924548626,
-0.5242406725883484,
-0.8002671599388123,
0.3026614189147949,
0.5581218004226685,
-0.5148599147796631,
-0.23590359091758728,
0.49903473258018494,
0.699625551700592,
0.08246298879384995,
0.3029746413230896,
0.49368172883987427,
-0.09038445353507996,
0.2638278305530548,
0.29395392537117004,
1.0457615852355957,
-0.4617038667201996,
0.9717139005661011,
-0.3885914981365204,
0.07182890176773071,
-0.4386783838272095,
-0.6955577731132507,
-0.7967526316642761,
-0.9019684195518494,
-0.8729075789451599,
-0.5941583514213562,
0.012820431031286716,
0.8811858296394348,
0.5104644298553467,
-0.48194420337677,
-0.1819138526916504,
-0.3388890027999878,
0.43178197741508484,
-0.029211554676294327,
-0.258331835269928,
-0.1729373037815094,
-0.8375062346458435,
-0.8675007820129395,
0.4421273469924927,
0.1648026704788208,
0.24946388602256775,
0.4169371426105499,
0.10200091451406479,
-0.3521564304828644,
0.20619915425777435,
0.3778642416000366,
0.5646952390670776,
-0.5933170914649963,
-0.26750051975250244,
-0.46990224719047546,
-0.13056455552577972,
0.12493516504764557,
0.9238041639328003,
-0.3470337688922882,
0.5773049592971802,
0.5166456699371338,
0.7731010317802429,
0.21285445988178253,
0.4136597514152527,
0.7469044327735901,
-1.0092198848724365,
0.3260039985179901,
0.26126718521118164,
0.39527204632759094,
0.24537432193756104,
-0.1595660150051117,
0.36089271306991577,
0.5026645660400391,
-0.6670214533805847,
-0.9679137468338013,
0.20618240535259247,
-0.8423193097114563,
-0.4023396074771881,
1.4466556310653687,
-0.19853538274765015,
-0.1575809270143509,
-0.2583445608615875,
-0.7172726392745972,
-0.09468095749616623,
-0.4538167417049408,
0.6486964821815491,
0.5501534938812256,
0.10956966131925583,
0.18456341326236725,
-0.5711313486099243,
0.731713056564331,
0.4860735833644867,
-0.6487059593200684,
0.28198495507240295,
0.2824576795101166,
0.20994916558265686,
0.25055867433547974,
0.2844870388507843,
0.30907735228538513,
0.22917000949382782,
0.08399645984172821,
-0.3107549846172333,
0.21088404953479767,
-0.01509615033864975,
-0.15505453944206238,
0.2817327678203583,
0.02461381070315838,
-0.6236462593078613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06666v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06666v1
|
SafeGen: Mitigating Unsafe Content Generation in Text-to-Image Models
| 2024-04-10T00:26:08 | 2024-04-10T00:26:08 |
Xinfeng Li, Yuchen Yang, Jiangyi Deng, Chen Yan, Yanjiao Chen, Xiaoyu Ji, Wenyuan Xu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Text-to-image (T2I) models, such as Stable Diffusion, have exhibited
remarkable performance in generating high-quality images from text descriptions
in recent years. However, text-to-image models may be tricked into generating
not-safe-for-work (NSFW) content, particularly in sexual scenarios. Existing
countermeasures mostly focus on filtering inappropriate inputs and outputs, or
suppressing improper text embeddings, which can block explicit NSFW-related
content (e.g., naked or sexy) but may still be vulnerable to adversarial
prompts inputs that appear innocent but are ill-intended. In this paper, we
present SafeGen, a framework to mitigate unsafe content generation by
text-to-image models in a text-agnostic manner. The key idea is to eliminate
unsafe visual representations from the model regardless of the text input. In
this way, the text-to-image model is resistant to adversarial prompts since
unsafe visual representations are obstructed from within. Extensive experiments
conducted on four datasets demonstrate SafeGen's effectiveness in mitigating
unsafe content generation while preserving the high-fidelity of benign images.
SafeGen outperforms eight state-of-the-art baseline methods and achieves 99.1%
sexual content removal performance. Furthermore, our constructed benchmark of
adversarial prompts provides a basis for future development and evaluation of
anti-NSFW-generation methods.
|
[
-0.2048352211713791,
-0.9366083741188049,
0.3366048336029053,
0.09033019095659256,
-0.6399976015090942,
-0.17354781925678253,
0.03001030720770359,
-0.412479043006897,
-0.5631393790245056,
0.5497391819953918,
-0.42404705286026,
-0.7581364512443542,
-0.8086709976196289,
0.08552079647779465,
-0.6340969800949097,
0.7926307320594788,
0.047013044357299805,
-0.25240445137023926,
-0.5805442333221436,
0.05925169587135315,
-0.45740053057670593,
0.11182337254285812,
-0.8829668164253235,
-0.09254451841115952,
0.27646175026893616,
0.23616980016231537,
0.9528132677078247,
1.0111428499221802,
0.43373903632164,
0.23653241991996765,
0.16805998980998993,
0.18061913549900055,
-0.973970890045166,
0.6404677629470825,
-0.311484158039093,
-0.2769166827201843,
-0.19208668172359467,
0.031007589772343636,
0.4455552101135254,
0.09325607120990753,
0.14867575466632843,
-0.25413402915000916,
0.125473752617836,
0.5797594785690308,
-0.8088282346725464,
-0.21901746094226837,
-0.5714832544326782,
0.22398947179317474,
-0.24310487508773804,
-0.43883755803108215,
-0.8979908227920532,
-0.3636971116065979,
-0.1985679268836975,
-0.5582665801048279,
0.3163137435913086,
-0.020610857754945755,
0.7752968072891235,
0.40693745017051697,
-0.5951449275016785,
-0.10343258082866669,
-0.6822448372840881,
0.6845929622650146,
-0.3214004337787628,
0.3469879925251007,
0.5587461590766907,
-0.015910089015960693,
-0.5191048383712769,
-0.5675340294837952,
-0.141304150223732,
0.06168050318956375,
-0.03896410018205643,
0.06656141579151154,
-0.6371053457260132,
0.009635590948164463,
0.07367334514856339,
-0.21905498206615448,
-0.7200806140899658,
0.07831696420907974,
-0.23930427432060242,
-0.16766929626464844,
0.7571233510971069,
-0.08936148881912231,
0.879061222076416,
-0.178916335105896,
-0.7132498621940613,
-0.2564660906791687,
-1.102219581604004,
-0.16768434643745422,
0.36819031834602356,
-0.10596192628145218,
-0.0824519544839859,
0.5177052021026611,
0.18522371351718903,
0.230978325009346,
0.042538996785879135,
-0.10640425235033035,
-0.03370681777596474,
-0.13289718329906464,
-0.09092902392148972,
0.05835554003715515,
1.0785982608795166,
0.7921903729438782,
0.30590131878852844,
-0.43151283264160156,
-0.18509340286254883,
0.36058393120765686,
0.3987938463687897,
-1.2630140781402588,
-0.34314364194869995,
0.16883963346481323,
-0.6379836201667786,
-1.1287001371383667,
-0.20050311088562012,
-1.0857938528060913,
-0.6568766236305237,
0.42465248703956604,
0.5012979507446289,
-0.5735839605331421,
-0.27242693305015564,
-0.20980097353458405,
-0.443673700094223,
-0.09440896660089493,
0.08642221242189407,
-0.5427453517913818,
0.06391923874616623,
0.3265049457550049,
0.5740637183189392,
-0.2014259248971939,
0.13497135043144226,
-0.6929520964622498,
0.4328831136226654,
-0.6442338228225708,
0.5970917344093323,
-0.32527658343315125,
-0.8726457953453064,
0.21889400482177734,
0.06097361072897911,
0.17124028503894806,
-0.19286485016345978,
0.5550075769424438,
-0.6049821972846985,
0.14397676289081573,
-0.03676619753241539,
-0.4015272557735443,
-0.074528768658638,
0.1609363853931427,
-0.6915099620819092,
0.6789662837982178,
-0.3895624577999115,
-0.9681979417800903,
0.3165445327758789,
-0.47418445348739624,
-0.6407058238983154,
-0.12616200745105743,
-0.33447280526161194,
-0.5665183067321777,
-0.045325420796871185,
0.1539796143770218,
0.33842647075653076,
-0.10266511142253876,
0.35035228729248047,
-0.4502367377281189,
-0.34403061866760254,
0.30540987849235535,
-0.7814775705337524,
0.4881027340888977,
0.3264467418193817,
-0.501531720161438,
0.3298386037349701,
-0.5588496327400208,
-0.04635588079690933,
0.6508176922798157,
0.1933429092168808,
-0.7760332822799683,
0.22432057559490204,
0.12329227477312088,
0.24290238320827484,
-0.07841045409440994,
-0.623877763748169,
-0.324435830116272,
-0.25528088212013245,
0.2018640637397766,
0.876028299331665,
0.08638227730989456,
0.5785290598869324,
-0.281085729598999,
0.2871108055114746,
0.04196177050471306,
0.22090288996696472,
-0.24673180282115936,
-0.6616185903549194,
-0.3258878290653229,
-0.18015383183956146,
0.04370112344622612,
0.6963120698928833,
-1.3195830583572388,
0.007279064506292343,
-0.122478187084198,
-0.4586966931819916,
0.08114248514175415,
0.1344904750585556,
0.8224943280220032,
0.6356289982795715,
0.2697102427482605,
-0.18392738699913025,
-0.09399837255477905,
-0.9867775440216064,
-0.2831309735774994,
-0.07473506778478622,
-0.25906312465667725,
0.03579219803214073,
0.2648240327835083,
-0.12451688200235367,
0.6233600974082947,
-0.37117648124694824,
-0.06455865502357483,
0.08168000727891922,
0.4636901021003723,
-0.5395559668540955,
0.8571796417236328,
0.99256432056427,
-1.102579116821289,
-0.08489864319562912,
-0.5510368347167969,
-0.8217321634292603,
0.017288723960518837,
-0.08045712113380432,
-0.5472726821899414,
0.23584164679050446,
0.5371996164321899,
-0.5100861191749573,
0.810808002948761,
0.45152994990348816,
-0.6351179480552673,
0.07812761515378952,
-0.43540674448013306,
0.2682233154773712,
-1.182845115661621,
0.2233765870332718,
0.32185670733451843,
-0.47085708379745483,
-0.8356966972351074,
0.3023725152015686,
0.24520033597946167,
-0.2949812412261963,
-0.6974594593048096,
0.5731415152549744,
-0.21196293830871582,
0.29651135206222534,
-0.292700856924057,
0.0395534448325634,
0.03741728141903877,
0.19247248768806458,
0.09366853535175323,
0.8993074297904968,
0.5365028381347656,
-0.5415751934051514,
-0.14466600120067596,
0.5794240832328796,
0.04140079766511917,
0.39738115668296814,
-0.7020177841186523,
0.28776973485946655,
-0.39678969979286194,
0.18339714407920837,
-0.9257395267486572,
-0.43622907996177673,
0.5993770360946655,
-0.5554011464118958,
0.5111185908317566,
-0.22363582253456116,
-0.5794163346290588,
-0.008105681277811527,
-0.5752193927764893,
0.4896763265132904,
0.8180071115493774,
-0.621907651424408,
0.2863766849040985,
0.1862604320049286,
-0.24170595407485962,
-0.5659527778625488,
-0.83598792552948,
0.2787235677242279,
-0.018932588398456573,
-0.9078807830810547,
0.5355615019798279,
0.05155567452311516,
-0.06440923362970352,
0.26508596539497375,
0.032464101910591125,
-0.32307538390159607,
0.2531464993953705,
0.37523970007896423,
0.6215977668762207,
0.32956311106681824,
0.01591794192790985,
0.4989127814769745,
-0.2584104537963867,
0.2893680930137634,
-0.002318696118891239,
0.23791475594043732,
0.16861307621002197,
-0.3049978017807007,
-0.1936044842004776,
0.7606802582740784,
0.47179558873176575,
-0.4110322594642639,
0.7146406769752502,
0.8933122754096985,
-0.7287792563438416,
-0.3509117662906647,
0.056295666843652725,
-0.13773322105407715,
-0.5369471311569214,
0.2664913535118103,
0.12621787190437317,
-0.6716521978378296,
0.15689216554164886,
0.029883364215493202,
0.3307627737522125,
0.4548979699611664,
0.19007225334644318,
-0.09504013508558273,
1.3758518695831299,
0.4364180564880371,
0.5517331957817078,
0.2813225984573364,
-0.061056144535541534,
0.15848985314369202,
-0.18861491978168488,
-0.3122592270374298,
-0.43925741314888,
-0.2014264613389969,
-0.7055945992469788,
-0.48912176489830017,
0.3440293073654175,
-0.18953348696231842,
-0.1802666038274765,
0.12943023443222046,
-0.4401243329048157,
0.44687145948410034,
0.5009868741035461,
0.5486202239990234,
0.05500074476003647,
-0.033760905265808105,
-0.18707403540611267,
-0.03828161954879761,
-0.6686052680015564,
-0.5401949286460876,
0.8817515969276428,
0.31333407759666443,
1.0537549257278442,
0.3121689558029175,
0.5886245369911194,
0.48974135518074036,
0.3476299047470093,
-0.2678713798522949,
0.7718780040740967,
-0.8098810911178589,
-0.8052487373352051,
0.04019532352685928,
-0.46322163939476013,
-0.5514014363288879,
-0.027089711278676987,
-0.6624506711959839,
-0.5914398431777954,
0.2535342276096344,
0.25744691491127014,
-0.18564553558826447,
0.725168764591217,
-0.4835050702095032,
0.6322975158691406,
-0.19400762021541595,
-1.0238755941390991,
-0.11935067921876907,
-0.7429552674293518,
0.5436062812805176,
-0.10258962213993073,
0.2530985474586487,
-0.073725126683712,
-0.18497060239315033,
0.5927640795707703,
0.015648046508431435,
0.8584890365600586,
-0.2082541137933731,
-0.09753650426864624,
0.10850585252046585,
0.47934335470199585,
0.573890745639801,
0.17331811785697937,
0.08947159349918365,
0.12538722157478333,
-0.20346078276634216,
-0.2865722179412842,
-0.04500764235854149,
0.7757897973060608,
-0.4857257306575775,
-0.4363016188144684,
-0.2779083847999573,
-0.5979474186897278,
-0.1335766315460205,
0.5071413516998291,
0.8759050369262695,
0.6448365449905396,
-0.32768714427948,
0.4143165349960327,
1.1923032999038696,
-0.7924507260322571,
0.5326951146125793,
-0.1582893282175064,
-0.22127380967140198,
-0.6006991267204285,
0.9318318963050842,
-0.42496299743652344,
0.4027530252933502,
0.11254934966564178,
0.07007233798503876,
-0.6321922540664673,
-0.6173741817474365,
-0.8339622020721436,
-0.16064943373203278,
-0.827989935874939,
-0.39704522490501404,
-0.6635628342628479,
-0.181818887591362,
-0.3736495077610016,
-0.4275640547275543,
-0.31382662057876587,
-0.22501277923583984,
-0.6423658132553101,
-0.01745835319161415,
0.31600505113601685,
0.3850199282169342,
-0.0845794528722763,
-0.13293717801570892,
-1.1867244243621826,
0.6261253356933594,
0.23833554983139038,
0.5834347605705261,
-0.2684694826602936,
0.0420914888381958,
0.3283654749393463,
0.04282332956790924,
-0.26052147150039673,
-0.842562198638916,
0.4732586443424225,
0.2559056580066681,
0.3703239858150482,
0.6172858476638794,
0.6981943845748901,
0.2231154888868332,
-0.5092779397964478,
0.8026072978973389,
0.4690290689468384,
-0.7263587117195129,
0.6740131974220276,
-0.7431946396827698,
0.03763752058148384,
0.5236959457397461,
0.21109461784362793,
-0.1774064302444458,
-0.6490108370780945,
-0.4617220461368561,
-0.8200604915618896,
0.27752164006233215,
0.7037986516952515,
0.22621266543865204,
-0.09221263974905014,
0.30167993903160095,
0.20469725131988525,
0.2080509066581726,
-0.4515458643436432,
-0.09110774844884872,
-0.3809945285320282,
-0.3593538701534271,
0.17078131437301636,
-0.4269721806049347,
-0.4323931038379669,
0.46388548612594604,
0.5780584812164307,
0.06344228237867355,
0.45090043544769287,
0.1972087323665619,
-0.0706619918346405,
-0.506565272808075,
0.3777725100517273,
0.5124616026878357,
0.08559717237949371,
-0.25673139095306396,
0.2168969362974167,
-0.3876613974571228,
-0.5042345523834229,
0.3341284692287445,
0.26435989141464233,
-0.6264890432357788,
0.05240056663751602,
0.129456028342247,
0.6864293217658997,
0.02325572818517685,
-0.4829665422439575,
0.7007410526275635,
-0.4378495216369629,
-0.5300013422966003,
0.07725556194782257,
0.42652225494384766,
-0.23086045682430267,
-0.19788259267807007,
0.19976595044136047,
0.7219396829605103,
0.18794415891170502,
-0.23926584422588348,
0.574029266834259,
0.25076642632484436,
-0.6384824514389038,
-0.0542915016412735,
1.2746005058288574,
0.5329380631446838,
0.02581864409148693,
0.48721200227737427,
-0.12048213928937912,
-0.3032320737838745,
0.8123981952667236,
0.7546988725662231,
1.0811264514923096,
-0.2582606077194214,
0.3213672637939453,
0.3094869554042816,
0.47857850790023804,
-0.09176377207040787,
0.4179058074951172,
0.4840454161167145,
-0.5469977855682373,
0.03511486202478409,
-0.08786370605230331,
-0.15317049622535706,
0.014595355838537216,
-0.5643592476844788,
0.2565452754497528,
-0.5770942568778992,
-0.2147354930639267,
-0.16785196959972382,
-0.6900185346603394,
-0.4134855568408966,
0.4987739324569702,
0.33722031116485596,
0.9478577971458435,
-0.9311636090278625,
0.6689794063568115,
0.5365757346153259,
-0.08669047802686691,
-0.4418145418167114,
0.12836763262748718,
0.41186273097991943,
-0.35017091035842896,
0.03192678466439247,
0.395101934671402,
-0.1315450668334961,
-0.11169026046991348,
-0.6313623189926147,
-0.4391845464706421,
0.9682461023330688,
0.40376394987106323,
-0.2726250886917114,
-0.06044209003448486,
0.15015065670013428,
0.14052698016166687,
-0.15835797786712646,
-0.29819756746292114,
-0.027614815160632133,
0.360018253326416,
0.29980212450027466,
-0.023609759286046028,
0.590377151966095,
-0.7618194818496704,
0.2675677537918091,
0.26095864176750183,
-0.268666535615921,
0.53373122215271,
-0.24584831297397614,
-0.50434410572052,
0.4210250973701477,
0.3864973485469818,
0.3774101436138153,
0.6330962777137756,
0.8133074641227722,
0.31198564171791077,
0.3845502734184265,
-0.40503981709480286,
0.9290985465049744,
-0.1762237846851349,
0.0010475292801856995,
0.8624672293663025,
-0.10040008276700974,
0.5837627649307251,
0.3592371642589569,
0.5606685280799866,
0.058374084532260895,
0.6266130208969116,
-0.19220158457756042,
0.8915228843688965,
-0.04557659476995468,
-0.33065086603164673,
-0.4893123507499695,
-0.35596388578414917,
-0.5380569100379944,
0.34858059883117676,
0.3048768937587738,
-0.6457602977752686,
-0.38980481028556824,
0.281080961227417,
0.17108125984668732,
0.20575642585754395,
-0.1113152951002121,
0.6085301041603088,
-0.00956321507692337,
-0.4453500211238861,
0.24327777326107025,
0.11517655849456787,
0.6897488236427307,
-0.4095507264137268,
-0.11617375910282135,
-0.04801750183105469,
0.0721769630908966,
-0.13212984800338745,
-0.9045832753181458,
0.38583335280418396,
0.4714291989803314,
0.026396941393613815,
-0.5005409121513367,
1.6006791591644287,
-0.5218652486801147,
-0.38138067722320557,
0.14345625042915344,
0.12897056341171265,
-0.24189919233322144,
0.3547683656215668,
-0.4547235667705536,
-0.13941624760627747,
-0.004143989644944668,
-0.08155429363250732,
0.26044026017189026,
0.19598883390426636,
-0.07624571770429611,
0.5206297636032104,
0.7967863082885742,
-0.3812566101551056,
-0.2137126624584198,
-0.12157999724149704,
0.8398840427398682,
-0.3442491888999939,
-0.6871190071105957,
-0.6464436054229736,
0.6320558190345764,
-0.09566634148359299,
-0.020493049174547195,
0.3866017758846283,
0.2839970290660858,
0.43274617195129395,
-0.1455954611301422,
0.879004180431366,
-0.1403106451034546,
-0.07729791849851608,
-0.47219863533973694,
1.5139446258544922,
-0.7396683096885681,
-0.043831612914800644,
-0.5501202940940857,
-0.4501779079437256,
-0.532645583152771,
0.17797644436359406,
0.024079332128167152,
-0.2658233940601349,
0.3251686990261078,
0.7676129937171936,
-0.03333313390612602,
0.37202325463294983,
0.3538106679916382,
-0.07222017645835876,
0.6289187669754028,
0.3992224335670471,
0.9207822680473328,
-0.4967649579048157,
0.847737193107605,
-0.4565733075141907,
-0.24764469265937805,
-0.0017313749995082617,
-1.3727353811264038,
-0.8931206464767456,
-0.25089964270591736,
-0.34009477496147156,
-0.5648589134216309,
0.28491637110710144,
0.5829212069511414,
0.5648292303085327,
-0.4211072325706482,
0.41911807656288147,
-0.27637001872062683,
-0.11837862432003021,
0.04764934629201889,
-0.05935250595211983,
0.25660139322280884,
0.09681739658117294,
-0.47431206703186035,
0.3140081465244293,
0.14112329483032227,
0.5320609211921692,
-0.10645630955696106,
0.036989763379096985,
0.08953135460615158,
0.3345588743686676,
0.35935673117637634,
0.047264229506254196,
-0.23185867071151733,
-0.39489006996154785,
0.2723047435283661,
-0.31322258710861206,
-0.11864274740219116,
0.24021296203136444,
-0.3780550956726074,
0.493455171585083,
0.5805661082267761,
0.5694177150726318,
0.022413775324821472,
-0.07211288064718246,
0.8297420740127563,
-0.9162377715110779,
0.3845835030078888,
0.06833132356405258,
0.21027863025665283,
0.43907737731933594,
-0.7773842215538025,
0.44508811831474304,
0.24515466392040253,
-0.2524785101413727,
-0.6529499292373657,
0.2179524153470993,
-0.7568200826644897,
-0.45031970739364624,
1.1552374362945557,
-0.30064696073532104,
-0.44762852787971497,
0.1676785796880722,
-0.06120401993393898,
0.5302901864051819,
-0.4312000274658203,
0.7586729526519775,
0.2827904522418976,
0.3698710501194,
-0.22297173738479614,
-0.3763958513736725,
0.5913119316101074,
0.25222375988960266,
-0.9027860760688782,
-0.03562980145215988,
0.6304712891578674,
0.32684624195098877,
-0.023994561284780502,
0.30015257000923157,
-0.4651450514793396,
0.6293491125106812,
0.036246538162231445,
-0.18401484191417694,
-0.294432133436203,
-0.4995051920413971,
0.023833496496081352,
0.3057256042957306,
-0.36351901292800903,
-0.5738817453384399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06664v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06664v1
|
CulturalTeaming: AI-Assisted Interactive Red-Teaming for Challenging LLMs' (Lack of) Multicultural Knowledge
| 2024-04-10T00:25:09 | 2024-04-10T00:25:09 |
Yu Ying Chiu, Liwei Jiang, Maria Antoniak, Chan Young Park, Shuyue Stella Li, Mehar Bhatia, Sahithya Ravi, Yulia Tsvetkov, Vered Shwartz, Yejin Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Frontier large language models (LLMs) are developed by researchers and
practitioners with skewed cultural backgrounds and on datasets with skewed
sources. However, LLMs' (lack of) multicultural knowledge cannot be effectively
assessed with current methods for developing benchmarks. Existing multicultural
evaluations primarily rely on expensive and restricted human annotations or
potentially outdated internet resources. Thus, they struggle to capture the
intricacy, dynamics, and diversity of cultural norms. LLM-generated benchmarks
are promising, yet risk propagating the same biases they are meant to measure.
To synergize the creativity and expert cultural knowledge of human annotators
and the scalability and standardizability of LLM-based automation, we introduce
CulturalTeaming, an interactive red-teaming system that leverages human-AI
collaboration to build truly challenging evaluation dataset for assessing the
multicultural knowledge of LLMs, while improving annotators' capabilities and
experiences. Our study reveals that CulturalTeaming's various modes of AI
assistance support annotators in creating cultural questions, that modern LLMs
fail at, in a gamified manner. Importantly, the increased level of AI
assistance (e.g., LLM-generated revision hints) empowers users to create more
difficult questions with enhanced perceived creativity of themselves, shedding
light on the promises of involving heavier AI assistance in modern evaluation
dataset creation procedures. Through a series of 1-hour workshop sessions, we
gather CULTURALBENCH-V0.1, a compact yet high-quality evaluation dataset with
users' red-teaming attempts, that different families of modern LLMs perform
with accuracy ranging from 37.7% to 72.2%, revealing a notable gap in LLMs'
multicultural proficiency.
|
[
-0.6178303956985474,
-0.45535728335380554,
0.09624247252941132,
0.6274564862251282,
0.11112694442272186,
0.696746289730072,
-0.5878661870956421,
-0.5964176058769226,
0.337921142578125,
0.14602023363113403,
-0.8322742581367493,
-0.5734459161758423,
-0.5025182366371155,
0.30802518129348755,
0.10565006732940674,
0.8286126255989075,
-0.2660384774208069,
0.0904529020190239,
-0.3885160982608795,
-0.5318353176116943,
-0.6123452186584473,
-0.22141551971435547,
-0.40907883644104004,
-0.5475271940231323,
0.09431375563144684,
0.7164407968521118,
0.6492103338241577,
0.5398610830307007,
0.6502485275268555,
0.3476804196834564,
-0.1606018990278244,
0.4494922161102295,
-0.5363250374794006,
0.2078796923160553,
-0.020396791398525238,
-0.844066858291626,
-0.35584741830825806,
0.37198564410209656,
0.13873976469039917,
0.6500117778778076,
0.11370661854743958,
0.5726478099822998,
-0.20733097195625305,
0.6611352562904358,
-0.5066068172454834,
0.231839120388031,
-0.6687840223312378,
0.4320964813232422,
-0.16649700701236725,
-0.14726001024246216,
-0.015549605712294579,
-0.3508232831954956,
-0.004045049659907818,
-0.5569113492965698,
-0.028230424970388412,
0.0937512069940567,
0.3986459970474243,
0.7008188962936401,
-0.37684646248817444,
-0.2368641048669815,
-0.8407539129257202,
0.8186898827552795,
-0.26749902963638306,
0.03103775531053543,
0.5776269435882568,
0.551811158657074,
-0.16531307995319366,
-0.33975091576576233,
-0.6283944845199585,
-0.24431948363780975,
0.206331267952919,
0.2832137942314148,
-0.18177518248558044,
-0.2444671094417572,
0.21529363095760345,
0.3336487114429474,
-0.3966861665248871,
0.3457399010658264,
-0.4365256726741791,
-0.24574199318885803,
0.9616050720214844,
0.4768792688846588,
0.5383049249649048,
0.09266804158687592,
-0.4533800482749939,
-0.12332931160926819,
-0.4757782220840454,
-0.012775462120771408,
0.10697845369577408,
0.05553269386291504,
-0.3450259864330292,
0.42627832293510437,
-0.4641135632991791,
0.25573107600212097,
-0.05990214645862579,
-0.1841983050107956,
0.38826531171798706,
-0.36987265944480896,
0.07214849442243576,
-0.2916364371776581,
0.7717596888542175,
0.7588173151016235,
0.5222660899162292,
-0.19958612322807312,
-0.06161273270845413,
0.09718326479196548,
-0.007853957824409008,
-0.2653200328350067,
-0.1555185765028,
0.3871205151081085,
-0.20144648849964142,
-0.02176283858716488,
-0.0007071170257404447,
-0.6124307513237,
-0.5957159996032715,
-0.44198256731033325,
0.2173762023448944,
-0.37703603506088257,
-0.13542799651622772,
-0.3406056761741638,
-0.3974780738353729,
0.10268513113260269,
0.43271246552467346,
-0.7364532351493835,
0.006407084874808788,
0.520807147026062,
0.6764515042304993,
-0.42281919717788696,
-0.5263315439224243,
-0.2724389135837555,
0.11372163891792297,
-0.1548934131860733,
0.5236114263534546,
-0.4276236593723297,
-0.33432304859161377,
-0.07052653282880783,
-0.3116983473300934,
0.395730584859848,
-0.9097640514373779,
0.24459075927734375,
-0.41222724318504333,
0.10508265346288681,
-0.32437369227409363,
-0.272115021944046,
-0.09168487042188644,
0.5748468637466431,
-0.5745775699615479,
0.8733266592025757,
0.09033405035734177,
-0.30753669142723083,
0.73260897397995,
-0.8107942342758179,
-0.31599169969558716,
0.6791393160820007,
-0.3675861358642578,
-0.0513480007648468,
-0.19732047617435455,
0.43470659852027893,
0.19306471943855286,
-0.3645624816417694,
0.002829033648595214,
-0.3338494896888733,
-0.5728952288627625,
0.014825144782662392,
-0.0503334142267704,
1.0418481826782227,
0.3109942078590393,
-0.5572554469108582,
0.2866358458995819,
-0.5068903565406799,
-0.07789595425128937,
0.18027520179748535,
-0.46215900778770447,
-0.0007525114342570305,
-0.4096049666404724,
0.004719559568911791,
0.19379287958145142,
0.23760822415351868,
-0.34142524003982544,
0.12697315216064453,
0.023756349459290504,
0.1951361894607544,
0.7618997693061829,
-0.390158087015152,
0.5575662851333618,
-0.6971731185913086,
0.9853428602218628,
-0.20013687014579773,
-0.01842852309346199,
0.012565689161419868,
-0.4683859050273895,
-0.7193600535392761,
-0.4463433027267456,
0.1275496482849121,
0.8161045908927917,
-0.9735952615737915,
0.4725601375102997,
-0.28793618083000183,
-0.9170316457748413,
-0.7984523177146912,
0.5336474776268005,
-0.05658696964383125,
0.21234211325645447,
0.2626767158508301,
-0.376417875289917,
-0.6097109913825989,
-0.7643482089042664,
-0.2502857744693756,
-0.24404267966747284,
-0.23289497196674347,
0.2888527810573578,
0.454393595457077,
-0.39052507281303406,
1.0516859292984009,
-0.011656451970338821,
-0.7656233906745911,
-0.48927003145217896,
0.4853798449039459,
0.023787064477801323,
0.3637198805809021,
0.3257729113101959,
-0.5659400820732117,
-0.6509126424789429,
-0.04913730546832085,
-0.8621779680252075,
-0.3247164189815521,
-0.09603412449359894,
0.10215122997760773,
0.42268162965774536,
0.3255305588245392,
-0.24611595273017883,
0.20192992687225342,
0.5814955234527588,
-0.09771830588579178,
0.4959702491760254,
-0.0035137380473315716,
0.2882615327835083,
-0.6820446252822876,
-0.07379606366157532,
0.03371777758002281,
0.05787336453795433,
-0.4250834286212921,
0.17252393066883087,
-0.11169105023145676,
0.025903526693582535,
-0.43756183981895447,
0.7426702976226807,
-0.49623554944992065,
0.14846111834049225,
-0.17341351509094238,
0.2468155026435852,
-0.47256460785865784,
0.4295613467693329,
0.056237999349832535,
0.7647081017494202,
0.17493589222431183,
-0.054028309881687164,
0.5963578820228577,
0.29922935366630554,
-0.36590978503227234,
0.6144388914108276,
-0.13900385797023773,
0.1542915403842926,
-0.08732622861862183,
0.4024416208267212,
-0.7353889346122742,
-0.21457204222679138,
0.1533617079257965,
-0.27552807331085205,
-0.17031492292881012,
-0.12047913670539856,
-0.6787661910057068,
-0.4291127026081085,
-0.4067978858947754,
0.513516902923584,
0.6321971416473389,
-0.5345006585121155,
0.5770865082740784,
0.5676195025444031,
-0.432653546333313,
-0.47265392541885376,
-0.8150519132614136,
0.38054901361465454,
-0.5227276086807251,
-0.9521667957305908,
0.2400367259979248,
-0.045363180339336395,
-0.5868595242500305,
-0.26350682973861694,
0.11862862855195999,
0.05222482234239578,
0.4127710461616516,
0.20577937364578247,
0.1531374305486679,
0.03657164424657822,
0.10435040295124054,
-0.25748181343078613,
-0.0637868344783783,
0.16998203098773956,
0.17080453038215637,
0.5239026546478271,
-0.3544202446937561,
-0.46902844309806824,
-0.3380921185016632,
0.25919461250305176,
0.5793117880821228,
-0.4331114888191223,
0.49244603514671326,
0.9575923681259155,
-0.2269701063632965,
-0.36501315236091614,
-0.7510582804679871,
-0.14121809601783752,
-0.43561363220214844,
0.30050259828567505,
0.01165715605020523,
-1.0645816326141357,
0.7677034139633179,
-0.1585019826889038,
0.09897524863481522,
0.1836593747138977,
0.8796407580375671,
-0.26066309213638306,
0.590940535068512,
0.6308473348617554,
-0.1256081461906433,
0.3294861912727356,
-0.11175621300935745,
-0.14179857075214386,
-0.41954025626182556,
-0.3691464960575104,
-0.10722717642784119,
-0.9711818099021912,
-0.6910379528999329,
-0.5124781727790833,
0.7441491484642029,
-0.30417099595069885,
-0.22641395032405853,
-0.11757327616214752,
-0.32817578315734863,
0.7974635362625122,
0.9309588670730591,
-0.004799955058842897,
0.3359673023223877,
0.0036653373390436172,
0.00635907519608736,
-0.19113166630268097,
-0.7074581980705261,
-0.4006805717945099,
1.0454132556915283,
0.369722843170166,
0.6258366703987122,
0.20707982778549194,
0.8165535926818848,
0.3869023323059082,
0.728609561920166,
-0.6517887711524963,
0.5618142485618591,
0.1104024350643158,
-0.5887594819068909,
-0.35702142119407654,
-0.44856637716293335,
-0.5027675628662109,
0.06341694295406342,
-0.5352564454078674,
-0.7380962371826172,
-0.21382515132427216,
0.09517350047826767,
-0.31951072812080383,
0.24623361229896545,
-0.6914402842521667,
0.6520167589187622,
-0.32966870069503784,
-0.3830127716064453,
-0.012254039756953716,
-0.7298071384429932,
0.44423672556877136,
-0.17696957290172577,
0.25977426767349243,
-0.2689092457294464,
0.08765646815299988,
0.7232421040534973,
-0.15138466656208038,
0.9086707234382629,
-0.07355983555316925,
0.10819514095783234,
0.1871463656425476,
0.49160292744636536,
0.19687820971012115,
-0.09360676258802414,
-0.18812713027000427,
0.31414955854415894,
-0.18706749379634857,
-0.3359370529651642,
-0.4006568193435669,
0.40566956996917725,
-0.7545302510261536,
-0.8896081447601318,
-0.2156786024570465,
-1.134904146194458,
-0.45619338750839233,
-0.1099831610918045,
-0.07518885284662247,
-0.375497430562973,
0.06091863662004471,
0.11915180087089539,
-0.007450197357684374,
-0.16993948817253113,
0.3596911132335663,
0.3441341519355774,
0.08042042702436447,
-0.3947639763355255,
0.8989946246147156,
0.06029350310564041,
0.050826188176870346,
-0.0707072913646698,
-0.0002595810510683805,
-0.06754444539546967,
-0.42314907908439636,
-0.42389142513275146,
0.20405538380146027,
-0.7184657454490662,
-0.0972587987780571,
-0.2893962264060974,
0.12097752839326859,
-0.10769283026456833,
-0.28833210468292236,
0.007508773356676102,
-0.42215144634246826,
0.01651380956172943,
-0.08518823981285095,
0.30607175827026367,
0.5954053997993469,
-0.3808923363685608,
0.1386430710554123,
-0.7487220764160156,
-0.11776599287986755,
0.1494513750076294,
0.20666256546974182,
0.023881712928414345,
-0.24269980192184448,
-0.2310255914926529,
0.0037080904003232718,
-0.39797621965408325,
-0.6662554740905762,
0.2911810278892517,
-0.17291279137134552,
0.47479015588760376,
0.087947778403759,
0.09474968165159225,
0.6775668263435364,
-0.17756834626197815,
0.8640084266662598,
-0.06641434133052826,
-0.752959668636322,
0.3797966539859772,
-0.2749551236629486,
0.47789010405540466,
0.7646484375,
0.5842909216880798,
-0.5359069108963013,
-0.7557141184806824,
-0.29536569118499756,
-0.8577147722244263,
0.7789108753204346,
0.11010534316301346,
-0.011900191195309162,
-0.030621284618973732,
-0.10504081845283508,
0.03716212511062622,
0.08929359167814255,
-0.6654489040374756,
-0.2521740198135376,
0.09709646552801132,
-0.25685030221939087,
-0.04540026932954788,
0.07495018094778061,
-0.5568807125091553,
-0.2555447518825531,
0.41354864835739136,
-0.2226291298866272,
-0.12505486607551575,
0.0314955972135067,
-0.24070164561271667,
-0.29424434900283813,
0.1592017412185669,
0.5322521328926086,
0.6718177795410156,
-0.20033732056617737,
-0.05733349174261093,
0.7182776927947998,
-0.08224005252122879,
0.24006013572216034,
0.12165914475917816,
0.10129287838935852,
-0.41180452704429626,
0.6516750454902649,
0.33320051431655884,
-0.4963158369064331,
-1.0166420936584473,
0.24387499690055847,
-0.12058594822883606,
-0.16661128401756287,
-0.4633679687976837,
0.14667610824108124,
0.15975750982761383,
0.4281407296657562,
0.5433717966079712,
-0.07896370440721512,
-0.2897404730319977,
-0.6514474153518677,
0.13854065537452698,
0.6589270234107971,
-0.3994739055633545,
-0.00786581076681614,
0.6412543654441833,
0.5306004881858826,
-0.5362148880958557,
0.8049567341804504,
-0.2039758414030075,
-0.6762592792510986,
0.7522204518318176,
0.1697847843170166,
0.6695522665977478,
-0.03745154291391373,
0.21200402081012726,
0.011367478407919407,
0.4725910723209381,
0.362851619720459,
0.235189750790596,
-0.19539542496204376,
-0.7669267654418945,
-0.35827773809432983,
-0.3923697769641876,
-0.6981078386306763,
-0.13317714631557465,
-0.42787250876426697,
0.25086459517478943,
-0.46601030230522156,
-0.11886117607355118,
-0.36233481764793396,
0.12037527561187744,
-0.8349577188491821,
0.11750791221857071,
0.3187161684036255,
1.0621720552444458,
-0.9815104007720947,
0.2607107162475586,
0.9519279599189758,
-0.40238073468208313,
-0.5615206956863403,
0.08471987396478653,
0.5043114423751831,
-0.8652294874191284,
0.9558623433113098,
0.07700954377651215,
0.20726841688156128,
-0.34668439626693726,
-0.25865310430526733,
-0.48669496178627014,
1.3511102199554443,
0.3000590205192566,
-0.20056356489658356,
0.1676606833934784,
0.5389332175254822,
0.778379499912262,
-0.45737308263778687,
0.5478397607803345,
0.6346680521965027,
0.5915963649749756,
0.10315222293138504,
-1.1916131973266602,
0.07350797951221466,
-0.23943564295768738,
-0.3860485553741455,
-0.1803542673587799,
-0.8728916645050049,
0.5186854600906372,
-0.3856881558895111,
-0.10408972948789597,
-0.06928868591785431,
0.6206759810447693,
0.46955859661102295,
0.3593347370624542,
0.6759310364723206,
0.4663863778114319,
0.823449969291687,
-0.2786521017551422,
0.8224223852157593,
-0.34622570872306824,
0.01732657663524151,
0.9408091306686401,
-0.40173402428627014,
0.5866369009017944,
0.543848991394043,
-0.14165984094142914,
0.19824238121509552,
0.4960085451602936,
-0.2777606248855591,
-0.08066287636756897,
0.4403837025165558,
-0.29316842555999756,
-0.40546953678131104,
-0.3550114631652832,
-0.12885825335979462,
0.7251892685890198,
0.11285021156072617,
-0.03246542438864708,
-0.21200305223464966,
-0.2585305869579315,
-0.041109051555395126,
0.2538735270500183,
-0.031436022371053696,
0.7438117265701294,
-0.06573476642370224,
-0.7660240530967712,
0.5365858674049377,
-0.09598426520824432,
0.9019705653190613,
-0.4660443067550659,
0.045258332043886185,
-0.5850334763526917,
-0.1456255167722702,
-0.2642994523048401,
-0.9220584034919739,
0.2811272144317627,
-0.020009618252515793,
-0.008451328612864017,
-0.18439733982086182,
0.22972330451011658,
-0.5520041584968567,
-0.36641931533813477,
0.30730873346328735,
0.8567140698432922,
-0.013651050627231598,
0.24622109532356262,
-0.4884008765220642,
0.30777251720428467,
0.13073977828025818,
0.1450347751379013,
0.23291371762752533,
0.29585567116737366,
-0.32462435960769653,
1.0452334880828857,
0.5028197765350342,
0.2558661103248596,
-0.26408886909484863,
-0.07203587144613266,
0.5357362627983093,
-0.5940287113189697,
-0.3339042067527771,
-0.8382181525230408,
0.47119539976119995,
-0.01256914995610714,
-0.26144638657569885,
0.568730890750885,
0.150953009724617,
1.0758403539657593,
-0.07897467911243439,
0.7693297863006592,
0.011188172735273838,
0.1912255436182022,
-0.1559857726097107,
1.0159554481506348,
-0.795022189617157,
0.2796211540699005,
-0.16299164295196533,
-0.792354166507721,
-0.5053514242172241,
0.15962402522563934,
-0.3548860251903534,
0.11197324842214584,
0.22150473296642303,
0.7575762867927551,
0.1246572732925415,
0.19697031378746033,
0.14180144667625427,
0.09023461490869522,
0.5240088105201721,
0.5284507870674133,
1.0896868705749512,
0.21217340230941772,
0.6003080606460571,
-0.46193650364875793,
-0.5544237494468689,
-0.030429745092988014,
-0.8167496919631958,
-0.968754231929779,
-0.5592114925384521,
-0.25098639726638794,
0.08145817369222641,
-0.08728261291980743,
1.4658973217010498,
0.5477241277694702,
-0.5213479399681091,
-0.6010317802429199,
0.5303999185562134,
0.18670286238193512,
-0.0900547057390213,
-0.23990638554096222,
0.04237743839621544,
-0.2558773458003998,
-0.9595247507095337,
0.3452063798904419,
0.17560678720474243,
0.08053500950336456,
-0.373997300863266,
-0.00926809199154377,
0.06007402390241623,
-0.2485591173171997,
0.46583420038223267,
0.23974311351776123,
-0.7378742694854736,
-0.146116703748703,
-0.2598593235015869,
0.2092837393283844,
-0.04636885225772858,
0.35970595479011536,
-0.7217967510223389,
0.3670084774494171,
0.3982641100883484,
0.963466465473175,
0.11302125453948975,
0.11995967477560043,
0.7428128123283386,
-0.6986915469169617,
0.11491253972053528,
0.42996087670326233,
0.2896474003791809,
0.4087657034397125,
-0.06951599568128586,
0.6811478734016418,
0.22435079514980316,
-0.499519944190979,
-0.7500115633010864,
0.067911297082901,
-0.7875558137893677,
0.08228601515293121,
1.0315935611724854,
-0.047629792243242264,
-0.08714670687913895,
0.03349538892507553,
-0.1529901921749115,
-0.02660357393324375,
-0.24056197702884674,
1.1342331171035767,
0.7913848161697388,
-0.22649434208869934,
0.038721006363630295,
-0.18023470044136047,
0.3807055950164795,
0.8038545846939087,
-0.7455540895462036,
-0.08493353426456451,
0.38132840394973755,
0.23777630925178528,
0.4346010684967041,
0.440126895904541,
0.16793318092823029,
0.5231050252914429,
-0.3398149907588959,
0.3098333775997162,
-0.3404247760772705,
-0.18486176431179047,
-0.2575959861278534,
0.2704963982105255,
0.11684371531009674,
0.20174890756607056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06659v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06659v1
|
Leveraging Interesting Facts to Enhance User Engagement with Conversational Interfaces
| 2024-04-09T23:51:29 | 2024-04-09T23:51:29 |
Nikhita Vedula, Giuseppe Castellucci, Eugene Agichtein, Oleg Rokhlenko, Shervin Malmasi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Conversational Task Assistants (CTAs) guide users in performing a multitude
of activities, such as making recipes. However, ensuring that interactions
remain engaging, interesting, and enjoyable for CTA users is not trivial,
especially for time-consuming or challenging tasks. Grounded in psychological
theories of human interest, we propose to engage users with contextual and
interesting statements or facts during interactions with a multi-modal CTA, to
reduce fatigue and task abandonment before a task is complete. To
operationalize this idea, we train a high-performing classifier (82% F1-score)
to automatically identify relevant and interesting facts for users. We use it
to create an annotated dataset of task-specific interesting facts for the
domain of cooking. Finally, we design and validate a dialogue policy to
incorporate the identified relevant and interesting facts into a conversation,
to improve user engagement and task completion. Live testing on a leading
multi-modal voice assistant shows that 66% of the presented facts were received
positively, leading to a 40% gain in the user satisfaction rating, and a 37%
increase in conversation length. These findings emphasize that strategically
incorporating interesting facts into the CTA experience can promote real-world
user participation for guided task interactions.
|
[
-0.41391822695732117,
-0.9634818434715271,
0.9638670086860657,
0.13077455759048462,
-0.32704535126686096,
-0.0661047026515007,
-0.16150566935539246,
-0.4120009243488312,
0.2657987177371979,
0.2932506203651428,
-0.3815513849258423,
-0.32740315794944763,
-0.40029793977737427,
-0.45617127418518066,
-0.18299295008182526,
0.7405419945716858,
0.4159877896308899,
-0.04672003909945488,
-0.4759308993816376,
-0.15588779747486115,
-0.9496089816093445,
-0.6878249049186707,
-0.5792050957679749,
-0.07527118176221848,
0.7688827514648438,
0.6289249062538147,
0.8941723704338074,
0.41686928272247314,
0.1023484617471695,
0.33042386174201965,
-0.1861104518175125,
0.7362640500068665,
-0.44961032271385193,
0.5516369342803955,
0.08837362378835678,
-0.5845192670822144,
0.07122859358787537,
0.045136239379644394,
-0.09344014525413513,
0.6611404418945312,
-0.10050876438617706,
-0.20914959907531738,
0.15302148461341858,
0.44903072714805603,
-0.35558468103408813,
0.6939722299575806,
-0.15180695056915283,
-0.07519664615392685,
-0.27808108925819397,
-0.6700839996337891,
-0.3627132475376129,
-0.5120373368263245,
0.3871459364891052,
-0.8192548751831055,
-0.04175140708684921,
-0.022339744493365288,
0.621208667755127,
0.31988468766212463,
-0.8210415840148926,
-0.4925752878189087,
-0.7383146286010742,
0.661090612411499,
-0.48114657402038574,
0.4564850926399231,
0.2774510085582733,
0.1502397656440735,
-0.22006317973136902,
-0.2778996229171753,
-0.8803662061691284,
-0.3668944537639618,
-0.2396460920572281,
-0.012056976556777954,
-0.18912430107593536,
-0.053598642349243164,
0.4309065341949463,
-0.01769517920911312,
-0.16681945323944092,
-0.24197684228420258,
-0.06885900348424911,
0.010991351678967476,
0.37904858589172363,
0.3123410940170288,
0.598257303237915,
-0.02258560247719288,
-0.3035241663455963,
-0.1146608218550682,
-0.44949352741241455,
0.6728343963623047,
0.24020792543888092,
0.11348903924226761,
-0.26171737909317017,
0.6964333057403564,
-0.30817773938179016,
0.7294090986251831,
0.23031091690063477,
-0.16405172646045685,
0.5696430206298828,
-0.6114670634269714,
-0.04218202084302902,
-0.051835816353559494,
0.4930824935436249,
0.6059414744377136,
0.055063873529434204,
-0.38567599654197693,
0.3279311954975128,
-0.12252745032310486,
0.35138240456581116,
-0.7207311391830444,
-0.19506226480007172,
0.17670254409313202,
-0.2943498194217682,
-0.17754971981048584,
0.20360687375068665,
-0.5973981022834778,
-0.37625372409820557,
-0.5657947063446045,
0.34128662943840027,
-0.3657943606376648,
-0.09793797135353088,
-0.20228317379951477,
-0.4323183596134186,
-0.09472330659627914,
0.7693914771080017,
-0.7885701656341553,
-0.07373041659593582,
0.5245901346206665,
0.726887047290802,
-0.10205041617155075,
-0.014506950974464417,
-0.644551157951355,
0.24126170575618744,
-0.22523872554302216,
0.7787803411483765,
-0.8658521771430969,
-0.4612521827220917,
0.03899290785193443,
0.18898150324821472,
-0.3223796486854553,
-0.2575896084308624,
0.6567823886871338,
-0.5571020841598511,
0.4538952112197876,
-0.7805667519569397,
-0.16860315203666687,
-0.3837750554084778,
0.37197190523147583,
-0.5691245794296265,
0.9634318947792053,
-0.1524856984615326,
-0.4301207959651947,
0.5819166302680969,
-1.190194010734558,
-0.7229900360107422,
-0.11617321521043777,
-0.1882791370153427,
-0.03162031248211861,
0.10398838669061661,
0.13264866173267365,
0.5809381008148193,
-0.26013633608818054,
0.3402799367904663,
-0.05302031710743904,
-0.1515750288963318,
0.7625252604484558,
-0.4906822144985199,
0.32661670446395874,
0.5874527096748352,
-0.3832095265388489,
0.3234456479549408,
-0.22496020793914795,
-0.13226504623889923,
-0.30228191614151,
-0.5023987293243408,
-0.4319548010826111,
0.16742189228534698,
-0.001209825393743813,
0.28951311111450195,
0.07337117940187454,
-0.7848578691482544,
0.09283069521188736,
-0.10729135572910309,
0.13869476318359375,
0.42551949620246887,
0.19910088181495667,
0.15520478785037994,
-0.6249871850013733,
0.3887331187725067,
0.32791250944137573,
0.10674037784337997,
-0.4638291001319885,
-0.8716306686401367,
-0.7108197808265686,
-0.26468363404273987,
0.05019216984510422,
0.4467841684818268,
-0.9004611372947693,
0.26045936346054077,
-0.09258921444416046,
-0.6618233323097229,
-0.14857323467731476,
0.21330200135707855,
0.1884830892086029,
0.6994867324829102,
0.11314203590154648,
-0.269473671913147,
-0.20067620277404785,
-0.574989378452301,
-0.36430418491363525,
0.13012973964214325,
-0.1732664853334427,
0.6454252600669861,
-0.16499772667884827,
-0.015703042969107628,
0.9801242351531982,
-0.5814751386642456,
-0.18383586406707764,
-0.23493385314941406,
0.6644759774208069,
0.089403435587883,
0.5038433074951172,
0.6750439405441284,
-1.1361184120178223,
-0.6051397919654846,
0.2725272476673126,
-0.85685795545578,
0.0527971088886261,
-0.3551144301891327,
0.04804026708006859,
-0.0214207973331213,
0.21240179240703583,
-0.7555029988288879,
0.4933353364467621,
0.07073617726564407,
-0.40890246629714966,
-0.08822503685951233,
-0.0012415647506713867,
0.9408828020095825,
-0.9161502718925476,
-0.007315303664654493,
0.12663348019123077,
-0.1740150898694992,
-0.9064200520515442,
-0.4938218593597412,
-0.36496996879577637,
-0.335929811000824,
-0.6685057282447815,
0.47926071286201477,
-0.3711492717266083,
0.43008533120155334,
-0.3458380401134491,
-0.06894928216934204,
-0.14970727264881134,
0.7419026494026184,
0.1997438371181488,
1.0662250518798828,
0.31473827362060547,
-0.5010367631912231,
-0.052426476031541824,
0.40175846219062805,
-0.3817170560359955,
0.3849819600582123,
-0.4104247987270355,
0.0901680514216423,
0.04579831287264824,
0.02890302613377571,
-1.3045159578323364,
-0.2881234288215637,
0.04828624799847603,
-0.1796192079782486,
-0.2171073704957962,
0.03155917301774025,
-0.40324756503105164,
0.15749572217464447,
-0.3434261977672577,
0.3026924133300781,
0.3673318326473236,
-0.542316734790802,
0.9613204002380371,
0.8604862689971924,
-0.33888787031173706,
-0.3016534745693207,
-0.42917555570602417,
0.2632509171962738,
-0.33316561579704285,
-0.5662728548049927,
0.16101841628551483,
-0.36724796891212463,
-0.13022060692310333,
-0.22116528451442719,
-0.09527606517076492,
-0.185259148478508,
0.1532958745956421,
0.6857191324234009,
0.004373655188828707,
0.06068146973848343,
0.1072978675365448,
-0.08595293015241623,
0.03712538629770279,
0.059629905968904495,
0.28801485896110535,
0.4139575660228729,
-0.044412821531295776,
-0.25777745246887207,
-1.0282628536224365,
0.5213947296142578,
0.7639815807342529,
0.08893445879220963,
0.43927261233329773,
0.8428460955619812,
-0.11287757009267807,
0.5431830883026123,
-0.960240364074707,
-0.3738871216773987,
-0.4406334459781647,
-0.009759698063135147,
-0.4348051846027374,
-0.8420713543891907,
0.46644341945648193,
-0.2373126745223999,
0.30442801117897034,
0.053300000727176666,
0.5215404629707336,
-0.3873339295387268,
1.2643256187438965,
0.4965808093547821,
0.4761572480201721,
0.925423800945282,
0.20848962664604187,
0.4035235345363617,
-0.5660218596458435,
-0.6657017469406128,
-0.49519962072372437,
-0.2874666154384613,
-0.33274611830711365,
-0.5909209251403809,
0.6871718764305115,
-0.3470883369445801,
0.3086951673030853,
0.1971057802438736,
-0.19118225574493408,
0.25919219851493835,
0.8557569980621338,
0.36072099208831787,
0.1614844799041748,
-0.23735311627388,
0.2422640025615692,
-0.04700674116611481,
-0.6219002604484558,
-0.43577635288238525,
0.8135132789611816,
0.15669189393520355,
0.9012885093688965,
0.37634119391441345,
0.41469278931617737,
0.8248084783554077,
0.05624004080891609,
-0.8432126641273499,
0.4612903296947479,
0.16885946691036224,
-0.30269891023635864,
-0.3980008065700531,
-0.3164863586425781,
-0.8836084008216858,
-0.07457195967435837,
-0.21748416125774384,
-0.7678709030151367,
0.4087429940700531,
0.5093488097190857,
-0.409460186958313,
-0.07747028768062592,
-1.2610912322998047,
0.9704510569572449,
-0.4874628484249115,
-0.5515920519828796,
-0.388739675283432,
-0.5103515386581421,
0.20779511332511902,
0.29523882269859314,
0.11767905950546265,
-0.06386644393205643,
0.24804136157035828,
0.8168978095054626,
-0.33350569009780884,
1.1094869375228882,
-0.34991851449012756,
0.015328793786466122,
0.37422052025794983,
0.09825371950864792,
0.4899798631668091,
0.14011149108409882,
-0.04851090908050537,
-0.04373245686292648,
0.040216658264398575,
-0.2880001962184906,
-0.912521243095398,
0.8812130093574524,
-0.46501991152763367,
-0.9831447601318359,
-0.5077482461929321,
-0.9318013191223145,
-0.4711505174636841,
-0.014341941103339195,
-0.40091437101364136,
0.4442331790924072,
-0.1313720941543579,
0.5613411664962769,
0.8367340564727783,
0.33075767755508423,
0.41114696860313416,
0.3327578902244568,
0.5615625977516174,
0.054554086178541183,
0.942976176738739,
-0.02357548661530018,
0.1654791682958603,
0.5905331969261169,
0.32454580068588257,
-0.3443867266178131,
-0.28053727746009827,
-0.46452441811561584,
-0.30423107743263245,
-0.6129545569419861,
-0.05303037539124489,
-1.145699381828308,
0.26331543922424316,
-0.17312192916870117,
-0.2059166431427002,
-0.031066397204995155,
-0.690934956073761,
-0.5567951202392578,
-0.03151280805468559,
0.3175840973854065,
0.5965464115142822,
0.14342465996742249,
0.43105006217956543,
-0.7290859222412109,
0.25414448976516724,
0.6533628702163696,
-0.30910107493400574,
0.08856378495693207,
-0.17032134532928467,
-0.26649224758148193,
0.12886352837085724,
-0.5248850584030151,
-0.8649766445159912,
0.17001217603683472,
0.11632967740297318,
0.8738329410552979,
0.5728421807289124,
0.011610116809606552,
0.5696879625320435,
-0.010135750286281109,
0.9728580713272095,
0.45340675115585327,
-0.8586564064025879,
0.5049462914466858,
-0.2099761962890625,
0.4013579487800598,
0.5343412160873413,
0.4735962152481079,
-0.5254838466644287,
-0.21396085619926453,
-0.21092234551906586,
-0.6473318934440613,
0.8229641914367676,
0.01182683277875185,
0.4498802125453949,
-0.09535299241542816,
-0.16631299257278442,
0.40682002902030945,
0.5157337188720703,
-0.559956431388855,
-0.21708250045776367,
-0.5858374238014221,
-0.2678958475589752,
0.29958677291870117,
-0.34951457381248474,
-0.4420941472053528,
-0.03917745500802994,
0.5504039525985718,
-0.4333115220069885,
0.2696200907230377,
-0.14736545085906982,
0.03628204017877579,
0.11491239815950394,
0.5525460839271545,
0.9119617342948914,
0.8671292662620544,
-0.30596786737442017,
0.3301789462566376,
0.13946600258350372,
-0.32201698422431946,
0.00546601228415966,
0.14687837660312653,
0.14762847125530243,
-0.1864354908466339,
-0.14178913831710815,
0.6518216729164124,
0.4843212366104126,
-0.7926054000854492,
0.5430819988250732,
-0.500728964805603,
0.28196007013320923,
0.07193747907876968,
0.48993176221847534,
0.19129864871501923,
0.19042186439037323,
0.45477697253227234,
0.34011900424957275,
0.40666618943214417,
-1.0454038381576538,
0.13900204002857208,
0.48719683289527893,
-0.44127875566482544,
-0.3724386990070343,
0.5148073434829712,
0.9418089389801025,
-0.2643830478191376,
0.09725090861320496,
-0.1178591325879097,
-0.5036768317222595,
0.3351379632949829,
0.2557049095630646,
0.6025693416595459,
-0.04911969602108002,
0.29136231541633606,
0.006347041577100754,
-0.04484083503484726,
0.3133276402950287,
0.4755723178386688,
-0.697160005569458,
-0.3412160575389862,
-0.15168260037899017,
-0.09142713248729706,
-0.5061381459236145,
-0.07485747337341309,
-0.42498087882995605,
0.2503073811531067,
-0.016838030889630318,
-0.3005514442920685,
0.2747892737388611,
-0.14203402400016785,
-0.9689828753471375,
0.1937098205089569,
-0.10526158660650253,
0.49422284960746765,
-0.8216482996940613,
0.6513704657554626,
0.5240825414657593,
-0.4193394184112549,
-0.4954533576965332,
0.1101793497800827,
0.19362570345401764,
-0.677760660648346,
0.8223314881324768,
0.1380484253168106,
-0.2561885118484497,
-0.5085678696632385,
-0.16731639206409454,
-0.6046040058135986,
0.9304648637771606,
0.38961261510849,
-0.3694702088832855,
-0.061323389410972595,
0.09903912991285324,
0.35004162788391113,
-0.4858752489089966,
0.6078905463218689,
0.18359853327274323,
0.7289957404136658,
0.24831590056419373,
-0.7535396218299866,
0.24254752695560455,
-0.46862906217575073,
-0.3778075873851776,
0.022688835859298706,
-0.6187782287597656,
0.43021050095558167,
-0.3339368999004364,
-0.2804654836654663,
-0.042291026562452316,
0.7413632869720459,
-0.032705750316381454,
0.8923458456993103,
1.0353811979293823,
0.15098226070404053,
0.5735989212989807,
-0.281856894493103,
0.7004393935203552,
-0.2394014596939087,
-0.1614760458469391,
0.9678733348846436,
-0.2872314453125,
0.41385990381240845,
0.705617368221283,
0.3908582627773285,
0.48217278718948364,
0.5263885855674744,
0.28625524044036865,
0.5690137147903442,
-0.41554778814315796,
-0.37427815794944763,
-0.5833799839019775,
-0.7105166912078857,
-0.3353513181209564,
0.5707994103431702,
0.4595146179199219,
-0.22600248456001282,
-0.1201058179140091,
0.3767772912979126,
0.34195607900619507,
0.17943044006824493,
0.39737555384635925,
0.9073647856712341,
-0.30314385890960693,
-1.0619361400604248,
0.2092110812664032,
-0.5087988972663879,
0.45251286029815674,
-0.660611629486084,
-0.5922965407371521,
0.09123080223798752,
-0.367767333984375,
-0.19973208010196686,
-0.9204868078231812,
0.02281711809337139,
-0.06519043445587158,
-0.4381975531578064,
-0.2983488440513611,
0.29644888639450073,
-0.5006583333015442,
-0.009689943864941597,
-0.22975675761699677,
0.5454336404800415,
0.1441822052001953,
-0.016671014949679375,
-0.4113004803657532,
0.3324585556983948,
0.12272574752569199,
-0.1587889939546585,
0.21762213110923767,
0.31296178698539734,
-0.021893560886383057,
0.5925752520561218,
0.9614349007606506,
-0.5077779293060303,
-0.1974823772907257,
-0.058741919696331024,
1.0765268802642822,
-0.6062963604927063,
-0.7867212295532227,
-0.34526386857032776,
0.6238119006156921,
-0.3063915967941284,
-0.44361719489097595,
0.8097931146621704,
0.6021739840507507,
0.46403518319129944,
-0.22420765459537506,
0.7611410021781921,
-0.3769376575946808,
0.28957825899124146,
-0.624973714351654,
0.43303894996643066,
-0.5198513865470886,
0.4297689199447632,
-0.011458288878202438,
-0.49109959602355957,
0.1885719746351242,
0.16506606340408325,
-0.2348283976316452,
0.0929952934384346,
0.6027835011482239,
0.6793408989906311,
-0.34187957644462585,
0.38196122646331787,
0.4913793206214905,
-0.08698520809412003,
0.7893936634063721,
0.35101959109306335,
0.9268398880958557,
0.08502084016799927,
0.46189436316490173,
-0.5228155255317688,
-0.4948631227016449,
-0.4417700171470642,
-0.9119922518730164,
-1.1007648706436157,
-0.8474493026733398,
-0.34419623017311096,
0.10715297609567642,
0.2641898989677429,
1.0058526992797852,
1.2088744640350342,
-0.6429789662361145,
-0.2017439305782318,
0.332284152507782,
0.12063625454902649,
-0.5292451977729797,
-0.3291560113430023,
0.33308857679367065,
-0.5015172958374023,
-0.911316454410553,
0.7945602536201477,
0.2534167170524597,
-0.13418006896972656,
0.15714435279369354,
0.15584971010684967,
-0.5162860155105591,
0.2534158527851105,
0.750663697719574,
0.4185016453266144,
-0.6871190071105957,
-0.6128539443016052,
-0.017736950889229774,
0.10476801544427872,
-0.017357351258397102,
1.0957705974578857,
-0.8455084562301636,
0.8369607925415039,
0.5724489688873291,
0.823846697807312,
0.48810285329818726,
0.361225426197052,
0.5893247723579407,
-0.5737127661705017,
-0.005940103903412819,
0.11315033584833145,
0.19141581654548645,
0.28939932584762573,
-0.8855324983596802,
0.3707837760448456,
0.12774206697940826,
-0.5173712968826294,
-0.8332145810127258,
-0.0024251716677099466,
-1.7283521890640259,
-0.016344700008630753,
0.751349687576294,
-0.28680914640426636,
-0.2193092256784439,
-0.4456764757633209,
-0.5779663324356079,
0.15593142807483673,
-0.9312538504600525,
1.1437989473342896,
0.469074547290802,
-0.7850044369697571,
0.0533171072602272,
-0.46521154046058655,
0.7151086330413818,
0.6871373057365417,
-1.337010145187378,
0.1314694583415985,
0.4670727849006653,
0.10425764322280884,
0.5961199402809143,
0.39500048756599426,
0.3183792531490326,
0.7846708297729492,
-0.39495787024497986,
-0.26632145047187805,
-0.569844663143158,
-0.4788549840450287,
0.49137622117996216,
0.44101661443710327,
-0.01782349683344364,
-0.5281387567520142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06654v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06654v2
|
RULER: What's the Real Context Size of Your Long-Context Language Models?
| 2024-04-09T23:41:27 | 2024-04-11T23:53:59 |
Cheng-Ping Hsieh, Simeng Sun, Samuel Kriman, Shantanu Acharya, Dima Rekesh, Fei Jia, Yang Zhang, Boris Ginsburg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The needle-in-a-haystack (NIAH) test, which examines the ability to retrieve
a piece of information (the "needle") from long distractor texts (the
"haystack"), has been widely adopted to evaluate long-context language models
(LMs). However, this simple retrieval-based test is indicative of only a
superficial form of long-context understanding. To provide a more comprehensive
evaluation of long-context LMs, we create a new synthetic benchmark RULER with
flexible configurations for customized sequence length and task complexity.
RULER expands upon the vanilla NIAH test to encompass variations with diverse
types and quantities of needles. Moreover, RULER introduces new task categories
multi-hop tracing and aggregation to test behaviors beyond searching from
context. We evaluate ten long-context LMs with 13 representative tasks in
RULER. Despite achieving nearly perfect accuracy in the vanilla NIAH test, all
models exhibit large performance drops as the context length increases. While
these models all claim context sizes of 32K tokens or greater, only four models
(GPT-4, Command-R, Yi-34B, and Mixtral) can maintain satisfactory performance
at the length of 32K. Our analysis of Yi-34B, which supports context length of
200K, reveals large room for improvement as we increase input length and task
complexity. We open source RULER to spur comprehensive evaluation of
long-context LMs.
|
[
-0.6314405798912048,
-0.9356525540351868,
0.6813541650772095,
0.03816080838441849,
-0.3492457866668701,
-0.290963351726532,
-0.3893343508243561,
-0.9113655090332031,
0.36648914217948914,
0.48089250922203064,
-0.43970024585723877,
-0.09050069749355316,
-0.5087060332298279,
0.10013096034526825,
-0.6062187552452087,
0.9658485651016235,
-0.14461064338684082,
-0.20650500059127808,
-0.16467180848121643,
-0.3150918185710907,
-0.6920844912528992,
-0.44651541113853455,
-0.2816363573074341,
-0.016789056360721588,
0.7515562772750854,
0.7347784638404846,
0.6921419501304626,
0.9184277057647705,
0.6137502193450928,
0.21717755496501923,
-0.18895837664604187,
0.12248546630144119,
-0.2913098633289337,
-0.03613899648189545,
-0.09004062414169312,
0.07616841793060303,
-0.7192310690879822,
0.1324894279241562,
0.7713949680328369,
0.5951838493347168,
0.037039175629615784,
0.6004840135574341,
-0.020773975178599358,
0.7184215188026428,
-0.8904265761375427,
-0.03947299346327782,
-0.2580101788043976,
-0.23058490455150604,
-0.3688989579677582,
0.10745985805988312,
-0.38871532678604126,
-0.11823475360870361,
0.4960261583328247,
-0.35828733444213867,
-0.20273496210575104,
0.042710479348897934,
0.8858011364936829,
0.1658618003129959,
-0.9176574945449829,
-0.29643335938453674,
-0.7479940056800842,
1.0027450323104858,
-0.6831680536270142,
0.5136390924453735,
0.5075116753578186,
0.7557793259620667,
0.07246820628643036,
-0.8858970403671265,
-0.4679747223854065,
-0.5922499299049377,
-0.13723956048488617,
-0.09991196542978287,
0.10740112513303757,
-0.15458944439888,
0.29521888494491577,
0.340813547372818,
-0.31378623843193054,
0.29966703057289124,
-0.32303521037101746,
0.09894193708896637,
0.44532260298728943,
0.3607524037361145,
0.11936760693788528,
-0.20765061676502228,
-0.3592139482498169,
-0.029153557494282722,
-0.6879444718360901,
0.142912819981575,
-0.008887546136975288,
0.20548303425312042,
-0.13623853027820587,
0.35423743724823,
-0.10111289471387863,
1.0918341875076294,
0.057859376072883606,
-0.34882959723472595,
-0.1546301394701004,
-0.5035014748573303,
-0.23506011068820953,
-0.14073795080184937,
0.6187525391578674,
0.4562826156616211,
0.04798100143671036,
-0.13296350836753845,
-0.2656126320362091,
-0.3235381543636322,
0.39171040058135986,
-1.2196002006530762,
0.029471471905708313,
0.1678958535194397,
-0.34174248576164246,
0.1295103281736374,
0.10366293787956238,
-0.5940403938293457,
-0.28135284781455994,
-0.25439247488975525,
0.5343960523605347,
-0.5568246841430664,
-0.2556118667125702,
0.15983764827251434,
-0.12566164135932922,
0.3916514813899994,
0.20588192343711853,
-0.9185404181480408,
0.4531470537185669,
1.0022740364074707,
0.9449571371078491,
-0.36537081003189087,
-0.4163283109664917,
-0.6658098697662354,
-0.18156564235687256,
-0.6221171617507935,
0.4004606008529663,
-0.2681194245815277,
-0.3073423206806183,
-0.19900007545948029,
-0.12608198821544647,
-0.1461493968963623,
-0.6703789830207825,
0.5845996141433716,
-0.24921271204948425,
0.35866987705230713,
-0.4552721679210663,
-0.7194070816040039,
-0.21397064626216888,
0.3087095022201538,
-0.8097520470619202,
1.0302996635437012,
0.2767817974090576,
-0.6795997619628906,
0.6620903015136719,
-0.848827064037323,
-0.23353992402553558,
0.09673893451690674,
-0.19657975435256958,
-0.3687147796154022,
0.027026617899537086,
-0.036402635276317596,
0.5548440217971802,
-0.5022042989730835,
0.32811668515205383,
-0.23962804675102234,
-0.9424454569816589,
0.3259403705596924,
-0.1134101152420044,
0.44178518652915955,
-0.012538257986307144,
-0.43654686212539673,
0.47837793827056885,
-0.6786122918128967,
0.18617166578769684,
-0.020679311826825142,
-0.19145692884922028,
-0.375210165977478,
0.19828355312347412,
0.17686453461647034,
0.0773622915148735,
0.370239794254303,
-0.6325479745864868,
-0.0013216877123340964,
-0.07430748641490936,
0.39472463726997375,
0.6481478214263916,
-0.18348069489002228,
0.24788323044776917,
-0.5482239723205566,
0.2617306709289551,
-0.33239537477493286,
0.21795140206813812,
0.15433700382709503,
-0.22594712674617767,
-0.8659191727638245,
-0.5826944708824158,
0.2812437415122986,
0.29129448533058167,
-0.15923051536083221,
0.7822407484054565,
-0.4856596291065216,
-0.8913226127624512,
-0.10792818665504456,
-0.3243921995162964,
0.36576637625694275,
0.507536768913269,
0.3788120150566101,
-0.5010667443275452,
-0.4460752010345459,
-1.147786021232605,
-0.46594029664993286,
-0.056208159774541855,
-0.23173092305660248,
0.3214930295944214,
0.7878076434135437,
-0.3631134033203125,
1.1187704801559448,
-0.3532412350177765,
-0.13030874729156494,
-0.23270443081855774,
-0.24199709296226501,
0.38655969500541687,
0.21496503055095673,
0.7942465543746948,
-0.5845245718955994,
-0.5472909212112427,
0.05910811945796013,
-0.20832911133766174,
0.05881323665380478,
0.056835733354091644,
-0.015305137261748314,
0.08354029059410095,
0.2580825984477997,
-0.27526384592056274,
0.3923235833644867,
0.5907261371612549,
-0.7799773812294006,
1.2995638847351074,
-0.08698637038469315,
-0.01119423657655716,
-0.8645232319831848,
0.3700668513774872,
-0.06853917986154556,
-0.3060738742351532,
-0.5447512865066528,
0.35030657052993774,
0.747058629989624,
0.3911972939968109,
-0.3614722490310669,
0.8547293543815613,
-0.3364024758338928,
-0.19989927113056183,
-0.1518619954586029,
0.10965465009212494,
-0.09886099398136139,
0.344563752412796,
-0.1415097564458847,
1.0906895399093628,
0.22482185065746307,
-0.8838072419166565,
0.08450637757778168,
-0.05945296213030815,
-0.8201649785041809,
0.7560679316520691,
-0.43152809143066406,
0.10628975182771683,
0.1940792053937912,
0.12238183617591858,
-0.5044353604316711,
-0.2991988956928253,
-0.3429028391838074,
-0.24094900488853455,
0.033435773104429245,
-0.0037258113734424114,
-0.4731503427028656,
-0.24938198924064636,
-0.4600512981414795,
0.1872750073671341,
0.5727457404136658,
-0.7306258082389832,
0.27097776532173157,
0.21916250884532928,
0.27326643466949463,
-0.6181213855743408,
-0.2556234896183014,
0.1274266242980957,
-0.6613174080848694,
-0.5024684071540833,
0.3263334631919861,
-0.3621256351470947,
-0.3850085437297821,
-0.3463578224182129,
-0.46593746542930603,
-0.30242809653282166,
0.48341354727745056,
0.10618196427822113,
0.06689721345901489,
-0.29531049728393555,
0.18275949358940125,
-0.41012847423553467,
0.08169512450695038,
0.26003092527389526,
-0.05811746418476105,
0.5515201091766357,
-0.40034937858581543,
-0.1727944016456604,
-0.41377073526382446,
0.1743009388446808,
0.7007434964179993,
-0.2517041862010956,
0.729037880897522,
0.5138871669769287,
-0.24368484318256378,
-0.008740881457924843,
-0.3900783658027649,
-0.16801375150680542,
-0.49929580092430115,
0.6656587719917297,
-0.5235975980758667,
-0.9364146590232849,
0.5274010300636292,
0.17984376847743988,
0.3766442537307739,
0.5123723149299622,
0.3275836706161499,
0.2021264284849167,
0.9313182234764099,
0.7094982266426086,
-0.1577967405319214,
0.5981656908988953,
-0.15997067093849182,
0.12868744134902954,
-1.0394269227981567,
-0.02442689798772335,
-0.5315386056900024,
-0.36895081400871277,
-0.4608669579029083,
-0.28988558053970337,
0.4931395947933197,
0.22166194021701813,
-0.669070839881897,
0.446624755859375,
-0.31121984124183655,
0.5650739669799805,
0.4635958969593048,
-0.2185891568660736,
0.14338108897209167,
-0.4657368063926697,
-0.08272199332714081,
-0.17472143471240997,
-0.2744452655315399,
-0.6690042018890381,
0.8665059804916382,
0.37258633971214294,
0.3698405921459198,
0.4387311339378357,
0.5069112181663513,
-0.028992997482419014,
0.3010830581188202,
-1.2290735244750977,
0.6643744111061096,
-0.14361673593521118,
-0.5685731768608093,
-0.40814292430877686,
-0.3288211226463318,
-0.8872235417366028,
0.2833065688610077,
0.1207144558429718,
-0.9316781759262085,
-0.29120635986328125,
0.014376786537468433,
-0.2734614908695221,
0.48018863797187805,
-0.5407617092132568,
1.0865675210952759,
-0.2952635586261749,
-0.2780992388725281,
0.007212601602077484,
-0.37627434730529785,
0.3206957280635834,
-0.22168207168579102,
0.02407512068748474,
-0.31845831871032715,
-0.27939271926879883,
0.9545214772224426,
-0.5931585431098938,
0.4842393696308136,
0.02084360085427761,
-0.1557038128376007,
0.11490526795387268,
0.36721178889274597,
0.4145069420337677,
-0.011134762316942215,
-0.10579458624124527,
-0.13116154074668884,
0.41146472096443176,
-0.4011839032173157,
-0.475254625082016,
0.6573089957237244,
-0.603732705116272,
-0.482288658618927,
-0.35211411118507385,
-0.22495214641094208,
-0.21039026975631714,
0.32824477553367615,
0.17742906510829926,
0.5467716455459595,
-0.5003633499145508,
0.5500255823135376,
0.26506996154785156,
0.08263193070888519,
0.33941975235939026,
0.4803274869918823,
-0.37969985604286194,
-0.025236105546355247,
0.5311955809593201,
0.15726953744888306,
0.3547343909740448,
0.29297149181365967,
0.565132737159729,
-0.2954404652118683,
-0.47640901803970337,
-0.8136520385742188,
0.007185606751590967,
-0.3883667290210724,
-0.03797982260584831,
-0.2795296311378479,
-0.11228589713573456,
-0.1083926185965538,
-0.11251598596572876,
-0.4943365454673767,
-0.3049580752849579,
-0.08653485774993896,
-0.018652405589818954,
0.4656625986099243,
0.9774124026298523,
0.1865677684545517,
0.45244500041007996,
-0.6376459002494812,
0.05177487060427666,
0.29982614517211914,
0.6252123117446899,
0.14876724779605865,
-0.6701000928878784,
-0.49879300594329834,
-0.08030343055725098,
-0.10355741530656815,
-0.8671139478683472,
0.29102423787117004,
0.1268833428621292,
0.11733434349298477,
0.5321067571640015,
-0.08477387577295303,
0.9641258120536804,
-0.6107936501502991,
1.0009493827819824,
0.07220132648944855,
-1.0021485090255737,
-0.16807852685451508,
-0.36993736028671265,
0.47288990020751953,
0.32219576835632324,
0.13533207774162292,
-1.1484750509262085,
-0.12349914759397507,
-0.29368236660957336,
-0.8145101070404053,
0.4820803701877594,
-0.007046819198876619,
-0.09615955501794815,
-0.12340525537729263,
0.39319196343421936,
0.35886749625205994,
-0.18351688981056213,
-0.4796828329563141,
-0.1222216933965683,
0.05355112999677658,
-0.0020817872136831284,
-0.2808433175086975,
-0.393903523683548,
0.031176172196865082,
-0.3012329041957855,
0.3460525870323181,
-0.16315555572509766,
0.045157499611377716,
0.10926289856433868,
-0.09381794184446335,
0.0494171604514122,
0.47944000363349915,
0.4951322078704834,
1.1346931457519531,
-0.5296658277511597,
0.1304270327091217,
0.3726881146430969,
-0.614895224571228,
-0.13388195633888245,
-0.19929534196853638,
-0.06970728933811188,
-0.13863234221935272,
0.46587085723876953,
0.7698264122009277,
0.17467281222343445,
-0.8110834956169128,
0.4484262764453888,
-0.15031495690345764,
-0.10859665274620056,
-0.7358896136283875,
0.07374929636716843,
0.2747875452041626,
-0.1412019431591034,
0.3174310326576233,
-0.56031334400177,
0.2243148535490036,
-0.553654670715332,
0.2916887402534485,
0.47298383712768555,
-0.5928651690483093,
-0.22659644484519958,
0.35585567355155945,
0.00633999751880765,
-0.39235103130340576,
0.5348146557807922,
-0.1533290296792984,
-0.34965747594833374,
0.9194362759590149,
0.5104078650474548,
0.6050848364830017,
0.06825170665979385,
-0.005418841261416674,
0.5603551864624023,
0.1353272646665573,
-0.16120438277721405,
0.2059512585401535,
-0.06841002404689789,
-0.22883100807666779,
-0.5923442840576172,
-0.4873776435852051,
-0.581917941570282,
0.4458586275577545,
-0.8974897861480713,
0.20462174713611603,
-0.5084109902381897,
-0.21781578660011292,
0.014546627178788185,
0.5239103436470032,
-0.5890328288078308,
0.159231498837471,
-0.39955949783325195,
1.1454399824142456,
-0.19713939726352692,
0.8483831882476807,
0.44500845670700073,
0.11706122756004333,
-0.8040055632591248,
0.02390405163168907,
0.01791977509856224,
-0.4164203107357025,
0.30504533648490906,
0.7748796343803406,
-0.1673852652311325,
-0.4031544625759125,
-0.4187473952770233,
-0.9987565279006958,
1.1220616102218628,
-0.01720554195344448,
-0.5902103781700134,
0.09804307669401169,
-0.07547065615653992,
0.5530778169631958,
-0.15646320581436157,
0.4529963731765747,
0.8474559187889099,
0.48936620354652405,
-0.29480841755867004,
-1.5463886260986328,
-0.0042200833559036255,
0.015037250705063343,
-0.28840377926826477,
0.803168773651123,
-0.6418798565864563,
1.1707801818847656,
-0.09276802837848663,
-0.28036147356033325,
0.7021424770355225,
0.4209439754486084,
0.20094487071037292,
0.09518805146217346,
0.6342396140098572,
0.29595428705215454,
0.6303830146789551,
0.06326489895582199,
1.0025027990341187,
-0.11883864551782608,
0.215428426861763,
1.3589054346084595,
-0.37321236729621887,
1.1198656558990479,
0.47949084639549255,
0.07429180294275284,
0.8730911016464233,
0.662453293800354,
0.32269561290740967,
0.06103918328881264,
0.43737801909446716,
-0.05446852743625641,
-0.13588397204875946,
0.02311735413968563,
-0.3023127615451813,
0.5714579224586487,
0.3186262249946594,
-0.029223889112472534,
-0.05191069468855858,
-0.40685760974884033,
0.2742061913013458,
0.22961696982383728,
-0.18368418514728546,
0.549596905708313,
0.01348645519465208,
-0.7739278078079224,
0.7397390604019165,
0.3583475947380066,
0.8655087351799011,
-0.8076484799385071,
0.19705255329608917,
-0.251400887966156,
0.30472856760025024,
0.20103082060813904,
-0.6865038275718689,
0.17543959617614746,
0.06307171285152435,
0.13491535186767578,
-0.030504636466503143,
0.40485483407974243,
-0.1175047904253006,
-0.06251257658004761,
0.4049782156944275,
0.5749551653862,
0.25358229875564575,
-0.24686041474342346,
-0.326202392578125,
-0.3027794063091278,
-0.31771883368492126,
-0.2522610127925873,
0.47667086124420166,
0.19940237700939178,
-0.47818589210510254,
0.6520288586616516,
0.4156170189380646,
-0.04120100289583206,
-0.08803737163543701,
-0.2317558079957962,
0.46204379200935364,
-1.1661874055862427,
-0.5949177145957947,
-0.9736443161964417,
0.12143349647521973,
-0.3057578206062317,
-0.5655561089515686,
0.8980762362480164,
0.7533056735992432,
0.8744176626205444,
-0.10244401544332504,
0.24426507949829102,
-0.21203888952732086,
0.8058318495750427,
-0.26379886269569397,
0.8207169771194458,
-0.8161482810974121,
-0.22236368060112,
-0.04997417330741882,
-0.7644469141960144,
-0.020481372252106667,
0.4914875328540802,
-0.22317132353782654,
-0.03293105959892273,
0.7620174884796143,
0.35145533084869385,
-0.2492586374282837,
-0.19948402047157288,
0.34895485639572144,
0.02242039144039154,
0.4261009395122528,
0.8219934701919556,
0.9112465381622314,
-0.17709048092365265,
0.28695181012153625,
-0.3132150173187256,
-0.1392364650964737,
-0.47185826301574707,
-0.9006194472312927,
-0.9651579856872559,
-0.689098060131073,
0.1166696697473526,
-0.10836436599493027,
-0.1674981713294983,
0.8169069290161133,
0.9207331538200378,
-0.41244202852249146,
-0.7276700735092163,
0.3872694969177246,
-0.07086049020290375,
-0.5184161067008972,
-0.21599708497524261,
0.5851678252220154,
0.08481885492801666,
-0.6183096170425415,
0.46223384141921997,
0.10776979476213455,
0.0367005318403244,
-0.34355300664901733,
-0.26985231041908264,
0.03910081833600998,
0.03539716452360153,
0.6273121237754822,
0.24799205362796783,
-0.7243677973747253,
-0.7781007885932922,
0.22681304812431335,
-0.19735360145568848,
0.05983717367053032,
0.6835238933563232,
-0.7348310947418213,
0.3106694221496582,
0.48695990443229675,
0.24467389285564423,
0.38746416568756104,
-0.22489304840564728,
0.33835798501968384,
-0.6554199457168579,
0.16683617234230042,
0.29633665084838867,
0.37126126885414124,
0.12403926998376846,
-0.00633277976885438,
0.5475621223449707,
-0.3557460606098175,
-0.6374973058700562,
-0.9209799766540527,
0.5399381518363953,
-0.8802881836891174,
-0.4402305781841278,
0.9959481358528137,
0.09298815578222275,
-0.35094377398490906,
0.0662616714835167,
-0.25545796751976013,
0.05495314300060272,
-0.11936115473508835,
0.8013378977775574,
0.7227826118469238,
0.0015294823097065091,
0.17252369225025177,
-0.7672562599182129,
0.7112751603126526,
0.6525658965110779,
-0.7117224335670471,
0.23519179224967957,
0.5279900431632996,
0.5239360928535461,
0.23077397048473358,
0.6101802587509155,
-0.01969435252249241,
0.4070059359073639,
-0.34995490312576294,
-0.14662884175777435,
0.00544377788901329,
-0.3827119767665863,
-0.12306710332632065,
-0.20283257961273193,
0.3598046600818634,
-0.15616916120052338
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08690v1
|
Towards Building a Robust Toxicity Predictor
| 2024-04-09T22:56:05 | 2024-04-09T22:56:05 |
Dmitriy Bespalov, Sourav Bhabesh, Yi Xiang, Liutong Zhou, Yanjun Qi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Recent NLP literature pays little attention to the robustness of toxicity
language predictors, while these systems are most likely to be used in
adversarial contexts. This paper presents a novel adversarial attack,
\texttt{ToxicTrap}, introducing small word-level perturbations to fool SOTA
text classifiers to predict toxic text samples as benign. ToxicTrap exploits
greedy based search strategies to enable fast and effective generation of toxic
adversarial examples. Two novel goal function designs allow ToxicTrap to
identify weaknesses in both multiclass and multilabel toxic language detectors.
Our empirical results show that SOTA toxicity text classifiers are indeed
vulnerable to the proposed attacks, attaining over 98\% attack success rates in
multilabel cases. We also show how a vanilla adversarial training and its
improved version can help increase robustness of a toxicity detector even
against unseen attacks.
|
[
-0.08791209757328033,
-0.6467933058738708,
0.4318767786026001,
-0.06363718211650848,
0.061965666711330414,
-0.12355886399745941,
0.12665584683418274,
-0.2581293284893036,
-0.015307873487472534,
0.4977215826511383,
-0.44922950863838196,
-0.4559761583805084,
-0.9016261100769043,
-0.0758136585354805,
-0.18619637191295624,
1.453302264213562,
0.6828510761260986,
-0.005352261941879988,
0.3077562749385834,
-0.3784836232662201,
-0.2952360212802887,
-0.6934031844139099,
-1.0848175287246704,
-0.02260393649339676,
1.0694570541381836,
0.12902501225471497,
1.1440601348876953,
0.3006502091884613,
0.2306627780199051,
0.3102182447910309,
-0.2397962361574173,
-0.23384937644004822,
-0.5431897044181824,
0.3622179329395294,
-0.12379369139671326,
-0.642423152923584,
-0.291047066450119,
-0.2557682991027832,
0.076331228017807,
-0.0750335231423378,
-0.08145737648010254,
-0.17578154802322388,
0.044026829302310944,
0.43677574396133423,
-0.9367501139640808,
0.031830284744501114,
-1.1149388551712036,
0.1229136660695076,
-0.5403324961662292,
-0.2089785635471344,
-0.8439576625823975,
-0.10571357607841492,
-0.017794331535696983,
-0.32603901624679565,
-0.32332608103752136,
-0.31327274441719055,
0.8172057271003723,
0.5513492226600647,
-0.4958672821521759,
-0.5103527903556824,
-0.37012073397636414,
0.8437424898147583,
-0.6568382978439331,
-0.050934869796037674,
0.14406350255012512,
0.45803630352020264,
-0.42632684111595154,
-0.7848535776138306,
-0.2395883947610855,
-0.2930026054382324,
-0.07387521862983704,
0.1301349699497223,
-0.3209766149520874,
-0.03872043266892433,
0.048602569848299026,
-0.039513684809207916,
-0.5953009724617004,
0.04870694875717163,
0.034872107207775116,
-0.35996386408805847,
0.4349401295185089,
0.20387500524520874,
0.6611760854721069,
-0.1418902575969696,
-0.7152060270309448,
-0.11622104793787003,
-0.6594426035881042,
-0.2821129858493805,
0.44842228293418884,
0.5442482829093933,
0.30351704359054565,
0.22815348207950592,
0.34122782945632935,
0.581032931804657,
-0.37958863377571106,
0.17821452021598816,
-0.12920793890953064,
-0.12676994502544403,
-0.00010228584869764745,
0.04166574776172638,
1.2481250762939453,
0.09698698669672012,
0.09699343144893646,
-0.08066225051879883,
-0.11478288471698761,
0.40138307213783264,
0.583475649356842,
-0.8809168934822083,
-0.5935544371604919,
0.20835250616073608,
-0.07090195268392563,
-1.0729535818099976,
-0.4259277880191803,
-1.1011794805526733,
-0.7610148191452026,
0.8284068703651428,
0.6576577425003052,
-0.49125683307647705,
0.09345180541276932,
0.1327429860830307,
-0.11113078892230988,
-0.32575318217277527,
-0.1535610556602478,
-0.7733995318412781,
0.12415333092212677,
0.28784048557281494,
0.6801762580871582,
0.06737049669027328,
-0.2771945297718048,
-0.9851862788200378,
0.1130942776799202,
-0.049871306866407394,
0.8705866932868958,
-0.5223338007926941,
-0.2218462973833084,
0.022663865238428116,
-0.35407721996307373,
0.20652012526988983,
-0.3179205060005188,
0.9393981695175171,
-0.8347658514976501,
0.23928435146808624,
-0.20303218066692352,
0.06359615921974182,
-0.19914132356643677,
0.39676788449287415,
-0.7699377536773682,
0.7018215656280518,
0.1682126373052597,
-1.3771023750305176,
0.3545808494091034,
-0.6058951020240784,
-0.4875272810459137,
-0.0391281396150589,
0.3056650757789612,
-0.8731692433357239,
-0.26030322909355164,
-0.02447948046028614,
0.373905211687088,
0.18113647401332855,
0.05109865218400955,
-0.7313045263290405,
-0.2429323047399521,
0.3646683990955353,
-0.5181328058242798,
1.1949222087860107,
0.4432970881462097,
-0.3945232629776001,
0.39042025804519653,
-0.6877959966659546,
0.031256094574928284,
0.30567988753318787,
-0.4954880475997925,
-0.7395350337028503,
0.20452173054218292,
0.2616615891456604,
0.41663119196891785,
-0.025386428460478783,
-0.38873323798179626,
-0.1682700663805008,
-0.6015310883522034,
0.46530118584632874,
0.9170509576797485,
-0.09058188647031784,
0.21041028201580048,
-0.24336650967597961,
0.5475863218307495,
-0.2957369387149811,
0.29246243834495544,
0.13502414524555206,
-0.41543030738830566,
-0.37110641598701477,
-0.05423750355839729,
0.31911665201187134,
0.43080586194992065,
-1.057636022567749,
0.24383020401000977,
-0.020751671865582466,
-0.7943612933158875,
0.020974403247237206,
-0.14026077091693878,
0.6768569350242615,
0.3185521960258484,
0.4707958400249481,
-0.02066614478826523,
-0.39471474289894104,
-0.41553235054016113,
-0.7026436924934387,
-0.32301560044288635,
-0.1840083748102188,
0.20835237205028534,
0.2756687104701996,
-0.5132681131362915,
0.33472952246665955,
-0.7742174863815308,
-0.5511437654495239,
-0.1911737322807312,
-0.1448184698820114,
-0.07790050655603409,
0.14312253892421722,
0.9511736035346985,
-0.7394866347312927,
-0.789229691028595,
-0.17488934099674225,
-0.45292308926582336,
-0.08398781716823578,
0.006384841166436672,
-0.16067837178707123,
-0.047567255795001984,
0.48620232939720154,
-0.23138770461082458,
0.008437586948275566,
0.6516647934913635,
-0.5242863297462463,
0.39777660369873047,
0.014413843862712383,
-0.3447428345680237,
-0.8572998642921448,
-0.001371630933135748,
-0.033585891127586365,
-0.1580720692873001,
-0.966728925704956,
0.5259228348731995,
-0.053830306977033615,
-0.0438554622232914,
-0.9271987676620483,
0.41590872406959534,
0.0934683084487915,
0.5188069939613342,
-0.11397191882133484,
-0.05891459435224533,
-0.13636727631092072,
0.31962087750434875,
-0.21939891576766968,
0.5397956371307373,
0.5224748849868774,
-0.6450662612915039,
0.07226180285215378,
0.30074310302734375,
0.33533743023872375,
0.4600820243358612,
-0.5353633165359497,
0.054913390427827835,
0.012000400573015213,
0.3446594178676605,
-0.7819368839263916,
-0.01382231991738081,
0.27268439531326294,
-0.518856942653656,
0.5639750361442566,
-0.14385196566581726,
-0.435435026884079,
-0.1950187087059021,
-0.5916875600814819,
0.2148924022912979,
0.08287611603736877,
-0.5128372311592102,
0.6149742603302002,
0.5746691226959229,
-0.10927337408065796,
-0.8238793015480042,
-0.8438920378684998,
0.27524977922439575,
-0.6464162468910217,
-0.4583580493927002,
0.04396859556436539,
-0.2161022126674652,
0.08765363693237305,
-0.22569045424461365,
-0.061698831617832184,
-0.1423039585351944,
0.5447621941566467,
0.01777191087603569,
0.10492680966854095,
-0.04509502276778221,
-0.07120555639266968,
-0.23824752867221832,
-0.3673371970653534,
0.4989256262779236,
-0.11284971982240677,
0.5892295241355896,
-0.24538277089595795,
0.10999339073896408,
0.007785248104482889,
0.13433873653411865,
0.7475836277008057,
-0.03470117971301079,
0.7775948643684387,
0.6258543729782104,
-0.2765944302082062,
-0.39740392565727234,
0.0261074285954237,
-0.13097114861011505,
-0.5563480257987976,
0.7300853729248047,
-0.20539407432079315,
-0.4055609703063965,
0.37048593163490295,
0.20713722705841064,
-0.15137870609760284,
0.5922650694847107,
0.5046068429946899,
0.2789635956287384,
1.347118854522705,
0.39471277594566345,
-0.23321759700775146,
0.3913905620574951,
-0.1846892386674881,
0.014933579601347446,
-0.4785127341747284,
-0.21831682324409485,
-0.6279211044311523,
-0.20306545495986938,
-0.724565863609314,
-0.028963666409254074,
0.4863833785057068,
-0.4058135151863098,
-0.6095358729362488,
0.5457862615585327,
-0.6145678162574768,
0.4587608575820923,
0.5174295902252197,
0.24896159768104553,
0.06587577611207962,
-0.20139670372009277,
-0.07897288352251053,
-0.26763036847114563,
-0.9191726446151733,
-0.4500220715999603,
1.260031819343567,
0.5348048806190491,
0.7432639598846436,
0.30392593145370483,
0.6181979775428772,
0.058817364275455475,
0.741373598575592,
-0.7436602711677551,
0.4785009026527405,
-0.7312206625938416,
-0.940100908279419,
-0.16027940809726715,
-0.36770716309547424,
-0.7635195851325989,
0.20504818856716156,
-0.3171226978302002,
-0.5385714769363403,
-0.16042108833789825,
0.10748285800218582,
-0.4698326587677002,
0.5063137412071228,
-0.7639448642730713,
1.0424082279205322,
-0.3028366267681122,
-0.4103984236717224,
0.2500864863395691,
-0.8126062750816345,
0.5018352270126343,
-0.2566860020160675,
0.3121928572654724,
0.29446959495544434,
0.033718325197696686,
0.4230523109436035,
-0.3336520195007324,
0.809348464012146,
-0.22321787476539612,
-0.1580681949853897,
0.13888460397720337,
0.48250433802604675,
0.4785415232181549,
0.12609195709228516,
-0.2556878626346588,
0.04598230868577957,
0.007619898766279221,
-0.5127781629562378,
-0.31607455015182495,
0.7120994925498962,
-0.3730568587779999,
-0.3311793804168701,
-0.8260015845298767,
-0.3768772482872009,
-0.3308979868888855,
0.5197938084602356,
0.5822526216506958,
0.07563384622335434,
-0.17951656877994537,
0.00731540285050869,
0.6734135746955872,
-0.6154594421386719,
0.23805947601795197,
0.37877729535102844,
0.17006155848503113,
-0.3289596140384674,
1.2386553287506104,
-0.22535619139671326,
0.577997624874115,
0.44585293531417847,
0.7247272729873657,
-0.4052838385105133,
-0.5033290386199951,
-0.3710448443889618,
-0.23516462743282318,
-0.6740212440490723,
-0.6527002453804016,
-0.7758136987686157,
-0.3516901135444641,
-0.08032320439815521,
-0.0800023302435875,
-0.46340715885162354,
0.073676198720932,
-0.3244984745979309,
0.011419190093874931,
0.13736556470394135,
0.7866892218589783,
0.048637937754392624,
0.3056797683238983,
-0.7736740708351135,
0.135676771402359,
0.5192334055900574,
0.20339378714561462,
-0.0794132798910141,
-0.22222089767456055,
0.10673833638429642,
0.15234880149364471,
-0.7126350402832031,
-1.1632970571517944,
0.6625359654426575,
0.2711491584777832,
0.299418568611145,
0.6149142384529114,
0.5428552031517029,
0.12367844581604004,
-0.44394925236701965,
0.6102978587150574,
0.1903034895658493,
-0.7417939901351929,
0.7291894555091858,
-0.5683723092079163,
0.05279182642698288,
0.6091909408569336,
0.507034182548523,
-0.22571326792240143,
-0.9796556234359741,
-0.8014386296272278,
-0.784319281578064,
0.650294303894043,
0.30271559953689575,
0.22848953306674957,
-0.07016028463840485,
0.031940676271915436,
0.08368618041276932,
-0.10879595577716827,
-1.1450862884521484,
-0.5900005102157593,
-0.3864891529083252,
-0.21992817521095276,
-0.1437782496213913,
-0.5273867249488831,
-0.17398563027381897,
0.337141215801239,
0.6618746519088745,
-0.08137694001197815,
-0.12394127249717712,
-0.16611726582050323,
0.16240878403186798,
0.13589264452457428,
0.46827495098114014,
0.3803263008594513,
-0.28817617893218994,
-0.2486555278301239,
0.5924180150032043,
0.3074169158935547,
-0.6280747056007385,
0.17391622066497803,
0.0845944806933403,
-0.44150614738464355,
-0.2276277244091034,
0.2603519856929779,
0.3011726140975952,
0.1794852614402771,
-0.6593672633171082,
0.714634895324707,
-0.309749960899353,
0.02528318576514721,
-0.022520925849676132,
0.13603997230529785,
-0.02171139046549797,
0.028650106862187386,
-0.07554597407579422,
0.5961487889289856,
0.5462265610694885,
-0.6356697082519531,
0.47839346528053284,
0.7137786746025085,
-0.9357566833496094,
-0.3659067749977112,
1.1295498609542847,
0.0366896390914917,
-0.01938978210091591,
-0.11163202673196793,
-0.34904754161834717,
-1.14557945728302,
0.4061497151851654,
0.6336899399757385,
0.6830571293830872,
-0.5014297366142273,
0.38834965229034424,
0.1909974366426468,
0.31726935505867004,
0.12628646194934845,
0.2106311172246933,
0.38880258798599243,
-0.5848727226257324,
-0.012010459788143635,
-0.5874350666999817,
-0.11437410861253738,
0.37918102741241455,
-0.3535444736480713,
0.3520057201385498,
-0.6212095022201538,
-0.1819973886013031,
0.13890936970710754,
-0.04319990426301956,
-0.04865648224949837,
0.39499738812446594,
-0.05459386482834816,
0.5220866799354553,
-0.999438464641571,
0.5347625017166138,
0.7263584136962891,
-0.37420326471328735,
-0.6355823278427124,
0.23267926275730133,
0.23178382217884064,
-0.6541916728019714,
0.6043897867202759,
0.08638403564691544,
-0.14276769757270813,
-0.2850087583065033,
-0.28959232568740845,
-0.5517616271972656,
0.44201532006263733,
0.44684022665023804,
0.022679023444652557,
-0.09330153465270996,
-0.1490926593542099,
0.7990129590034485,
0.25015491247177124,
0.26354289054870605,
0.3952801525592804,
0.4343050718307495,
0.11625151336193085,
-0.2885367274284363,
0.46287575364112854,
-0.26843899488449097,
-0.10258021950721741,
0.2667301297187805,
-0.7176392674446106,
0.7930182814598083,
-0.27687498927116394,
-0.4338645339012146,
0.013973407447338104,
0.3838184177875519,
0.02537626400589943,
0.4657624363899231,
0.6032998561859131,
0.5329852104187012,
0.2699414789676666,
0.017181722447276115,
1.0930769443511963,
-0.00010582025424810126,
0.22692063450813293,
1.0859708786010742,
0.08988980203866959,
0.8645564317703247,
0.23778416216373444,
-0.12565450370311737,
0.47619178891181946,
0.3796217739582062,
-0.030800629407167435,
0.8374893069267273,
0.49623432755470276,
-0.2975154221057892,
-0.05144328251481056,
-0.10470043122768402,
-0.31168678402900696,
0.44368505477905273,
0.4681842029094696,
-0.09989310801029205,
-0.2931685745716095,
-0.001372099737636745,
0.4222654700279236,
0.3782438635826111,
-0.07313418388366699,
0.6052630543708801,
-0.054748859256505966,
-0.38082295656204224,
0.661717414855957,
-0.1255699098110199,
1.0636485815048218,
-0.6225926876068115,
0.29351258277893066,
0.13260972499847412,
0.5786450505256653,
-0.31822896003723145,
-0.6940686106681824,
0.6324639916419983,
-0.2787300646305084,
0.39195841550827026,
-0.019924229010939598,
0.9317541122436523,
-0.1843045949935913,
-0.20860734581947327,
0.5733104348182678,
-0.12350917607545853,
-0.2718220353126526,
-0.3738107681274414,
-0.693517804145813,
-0.13249452412128448,
0.03871802240610123,
-0.199443981051445,
0.5779421925544739,
0.5556508302688599,
0.22098304331302643,
0.9413747191429138,
0.5567734837532043,
0.3600675165653229,
-0.005465241614729166,
-0.1679804027080536,
1.0191348791122437,
-0.3220524489879608,
-0.4635138511657715,
-0.8839884400367737,
0.3963046371936798,
0.1391942948102951,
-0.208436980843544,
0.7254771590232849,
0.3405154049396515,
0.6929288506507874,
-0.017468230798840523,
0.6342117190361023,
0.058896586298942566,
0.3279968798160553,
-0.38157206773757935,
1.2882832288742065,
-0.6885953545570374,
0.5024735331535339,
-0.5220690369606018,
-0.4857800304889679,
-0.7245675921440125,
0.46994131803512573,
0.012440033257007599,
0.0780036449432373,
0.8605524897575378,
0.6986674666404724,
0.21006843447685242,
-0.15898355841636658,
0.22755400836467743,
0.5606978535652161,
0.6798645853996277,
0.8807070255279541,
0.8044276833534241,
-0.7232415080070496,
1.1562883853912354,
-0.32885855436325073,
-0.31003642082214355,
-0.1357954889535904,
-0.9281985759735107,
-1.0973926782608032,
-0.3512738049030304,
-0.1522524654865265,
-0.9109389781951904,
0.14485374093055725,
0.06064829230308533,
0.42393046617507935,
-0.9684766530990601,
0.3564763367176056,
-0.25115934014320374,
0.18017546832561493,
0.016675962135195732,
-0.3030719459056854,
0.25477334856987,
-0.3370237350463867,
-0.628557562828064,
0.23973076045513153,
0.20575159788131714,
-0.052933353930711746,
-0.3429951071739197,
-0.0100913280621171,
-0.11931613832712173,
0.040161292999982834,
0.5515100955963135,
0.2815558612346649,
-0.42515504360198975,
-0.39988309144973755,
-0.12585847079753876,
-0.4289330542087555,
-0.3196735978126526,
0.41326791048049927,
-0.48047173023223877,
0.43399447202682495,
0.3507208526134491,
0.5552858114242554,
0.1267704963684082,
-0.3593204617500305,
0.43870797753334045,
-0.7450896501541138,
0.05700446292757988,
0.7543399333953857,
0.11089950799942017,
0.14247570931911469,
-0.7027481198310852,
0.4029712677001953,
-0.057347167283296585,
-0.43548354506492615,
-0.9497050642967224,
0.4630535840988159,
-0.859569787979126,
-0.5457802414894104,
1.2714264392852783,
-0.22108232975006104,
-0.24581927061080933,
-0.2227220982313156,
-0.31434646248817444,
0.017124826088547707,
-0.4259207248687744,
1.0283547639846802,
0.3148775100708008,
0.31855615973472595,
0.4774516224861145,
-0.5286642909049988,
0.7598509788513184,
0.37529876828193665,
-0.754920244216919,
0.04262341186404228,
0.18080107867717743,
0.375501424074173,
0.48069435358047485,
0.5071427822113037,
-0.2688220143318176,
0.18885235488414764,
0.30866581201553345,
-0.43884941935539246,
0.0658666342496872,
-0.32308751344680786,
0.006964000873267651,
0.41071486473083496,
0.11457668244838715,
-0.14334456622600555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06644v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06644v1
|
Khayyam Challenge (PersianMMLU): Is Your LLM Truly Wise to The Persian Language?
| 2024-04-09T22:38:13 | 2024-04-09T22:38:13 |
Omid Ghahroodi, Marzia Nouri, Mohammad Vali Sanian, Alireza Sahebi, Doratossadat Dastgheib, Ehsaneddin Asgari, Mahdieh Soleymani Baghshah, Mohammad Hossein Rohban
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Evaluating Large Language Models (LLMs) is challenging due to their
generative nature, necessitating precise evaluation methodologies.
Additionally, non-English LLM evaluation lags behind English, resulting in the
absence or weakness of LLMs for many languages. In response to this necessity,
we introduce Khayyam Challenge (also known as PersianMMLU), a meticulously
curated collection comprising 20,192 four-choice questions sourced from 38
diverse tasks extracted from Persian examinations, spanning a wide spectrum of
subjects, complexities, and ages. The primary objective of the Khayyam
Challenge is to facilitate the rigorous evaluation of LLMs that support the
Persian language. Distinctive features of the Khayyam Challenge are (i) its
comprehensive coverage of various topics, including literary comprehension,
mathematics, sciences, logic, intelligence testing, etc., aimed at assessing
different facets of LLMs such as language comprehension, reasoning, and
information retrieval across various educational stages, from lower primary
school to upper secondary school (ii) its inclusion of rich metadata such as
human response rates, difficulty levels, and descriptive answers (iii) its
utilization of new data to avoid data contamination issues prevalent in
existing frameworks (iv) its use of original, non-translated data tailored for
Persian speakers, ensuring the framework is free from translation challenges
and errors while encompassing cultural nuances (v) its inherent scalability for
future data updates and evaluations without requiring special human effort.
Previous works lacked an evaluation framework that combined all of these
features into a single comprehensive benchmark. Furthermore, we evaluate a wide
range of existing LLMs that support the Persian language, with statistical
analyses and interpretations of their outputs.
|
[
-0.07341953366994858,
-0.5581802725791931,
0.633150041103363,
0.34988102316856384,
-0.35725104808807373,
0.5434455275535583,
-0.5546194314956665,
-0.3578334450721741,
0.014589701779186726,
0.21138978004455566,
-0.5971015095710754,
-0.3665318787097931,
-0.42841771245002747,
0.28335049748420715,
-0.24631723761558533,
0.7254138588905334,
-0.22261419892311096,
0.042743388563394547,
-0.22478874027729034,
-0.23377452790737152,
-0.5530360341072083,
-0.47470253705978394,
-0.5464236736297607,
-0.4027577340602875,
0.538775622844696,
0.8210267424583435,
0.6906223893165588,
0.5080989003181458,
0.5540739893913269,
0.26363056898117065,
-0.15970776975154877,
0.1843474805355072,
-0.415501207113266,
0.23155884444713593,
-0.3514556586742401,
-0.42017680406570435,
-0.12407244741916656,
0.024016430601477623,
0.8488517999649048,
0.8309285640716553,
-0.37931832671165466,
0.5804175734519958,
0.0928267166018486,
1.0769574642181396,
-0.6216821074485779,
-0.05168851092457771,
-0.44247469305992126,
0.13593271374702454,
-0.7259402275085449,
-0.03740239888429642,
-0.14532549679279327,
-0.624963641166687,
-0.1506742238998413,
-0.3171110153198242,
-0.35293009877204895,
0.08450714498758316,
0.5544689297676086,
0.06829558312892914,
-0.6921337246894836,
-0.3489304184913635,
-0.7796498537063599,
0.8724200129508972,
-0.25508835911750793,
0.45135241746902466,
0.23678171634674072,
0.7203996777534485,
-0.24015997350215912,
-0.2899087369441986,
-0.5707155466079712,
-0.6540905833244324,
0.2921852767467499,
0.27278581261634827,
-0.2728860080242157,
-0.3394109010696411,
0.09825274348258972,
0.7660203576087952,
-0.8631142973899841,
0.15699021518230438,
-0.5917588472366333,
-0.1801477074623108,
0.7391852140426636,
0.5235483050346375,
0.3164624273777008,
-0.3514159619808197,
-0.15349863469600677,
-0.24416255950927734,
-0.6392341256141663,
0.20268088579177856,
0.6397454738616943,
0.044681135565042496,
-0.021152382716536522,
0.6247017979621887,
-0.4343104362487793,
0.3820684850215912,
0.08737100660800934,
-0.4871251583099365,
0.16253423690795898,
-0.3082394301891327,
0.02728368528187275,
0.28966599702835083,
0.7231161594390869,
0.06591641157865524,
0.17674638330936432,
0.01609519124031067,
0.06352365761995316,
0.09564133733510971,
-0.15254729986190796,
-0.6594532132148743,
-0.18360552191734314,
0.4118446707725525,
-0.3409190773963928,
-0.2834741771221161,
-0.2525404691696167,
-0.4783586263656616,
-0.49039316177368164,
-0.17909546196460724,
0.045455411076545715,
-0.6268177628517151,
-0.38873091340065,
0.19550721347332,
0.16184218227863312,
0.5150963664054871,
0.4763137996196747,
-0.8460109233856201,
0.338852196931839,
0.7366604208946228,
0.68956458568573,
-0.37834295630455017,
-0.2073824554681778,
-0.34068936109542847,
-0.03700675442814827,
-0.5487682819366455,
0.8192395567893982,
-0.6959231495857239,
-0.4861435890197754,
-0.37222668528556824,
-0.056537874042987823,
-0.1583312749862671,
-0.6707437038421631,
0.9329954981803894,
-0.3235383927822113,
0.026830555871129036,
-0.1479944884777069,
-0.6021571159362793,
-0.1823287159204483,
0.33588844537734985,
-0.6322420239448547,
1.1877490282058716,
0.2557271420955658,
-0.5192157626152039,
-0.1962161511182785,
0.06486298888921738,
-0.2788461446762085,
0.42776450514793396,
-0.28919684886932373,
-0.2467091977596283,
0.3216703534126282,
0.07037188857793808,
0.24184317886829376,
-0.6256136894226074,
0.5098051428794861,
-0.2157481163740158,
-0.3854042887687683,
0.3755045235157013,
-0.35527992248535156,
0.8651944398880005,
0.32662075757980347,
-0.2802315056324005,
0.13485294580459595,
-0.8851364254951477,
0.3872479200363159,
0.3671364486217499,
-0.5152438879013062,
-0.2722363770008087,
-0.1045154258608818,
-0.048719484359025955,
0.2258293181657791,
0.34420379996299744,
-0.6166419386863708,
-0.09041787683963776,
-0.37898245453834534,
0.17250792682170868,
0.89533931016922,
-0.09623583406209946,
0.11309236288070679,
-0.5231121778488159,
0.994213879108429,
-0.11880303919315338,
0.13699010014533997,
0.012875092215836048,
-0.2799011170864105,
-0.6369507312774658,
-0.07805594056844711,
0.2608084976673126,
0.7387509942054749,
-0.5706973075866699,
0.08185101300477982,
-0.27215659618377686,
-1.1760034561157227,
-0.582792341709137,
0.3826289176940918,
0.41423675417900085,
0.2582818567752838,
0.03461400046944618,
-0.21137550473213196,
-0.3944372832775116,
-1.081681251525879,
-0.341427743434906,
-0.2207265943288803,
0.3326914608478546,
0.4643723964691162,
0.44692692160606384,
0.1661434918642044,
0.2886463403701782,
-0.13444475829601288,
-0.1667075753211975,
-0.46771708130836487,
-0.384909063577652,
0.423595666885376,
0.45690497756004333,
0.056026630103588104,
-0.534720778465271,
-0.688901960849762,
0.3722939193248749,
-0.5719212293624878,
-0.1868487000465393,
0.18201559782028198,
-0.1701391041278839,
0.3256021738052368,
0.6261374950408936,
-0.4731341302394867,
0.11434368789196014,
0.630838930606842,
-0.050462886691093445,
1.1099656820297241,
-0.04054673761129379,
0.14759139716625214,
-0.8937748670578003,
0.23828545212745667,
-0.20001424849033356,
-0.021638795733451843,
-0.39046362042427063,
0.4447636902332306,
0.4105386435985565,
-0.1242922693490982,
-0.4485015571117401,
0.48234349489212036,
-0.296730101108551,
0.24584642052650452,
-0.10356839001178741,
0.33154794573783875,
-0.2984734773635864,
0.46558403968811035,
-0.20405389368534088,
0.551190972328186,
0.291128009557724,
-0.44201821088790894,
0.8261615633964539,
-0.12044477462768555,
-0.7653555274009705,
0.8879817724227905,
-0.7064462900161743,
0.1310630440711975,
-0.1586538851261139,
0.15381138026714325,
-0.8514899015426636,
-0.13106223940849304,
0.39568543434143066,
-0.4561243951320648,
0.09114686399698257,
0.2942715585231781,
-0.6341218948364258,
-0.38332363963127136,
-0.4543428122997284,
0.5830392837524414,
0.6132844090461731,
-0.41833487153053284,
0.33545851707458496,
0.15874335169792175,
-0.1356230229139328,
-0.43725407123565674,
-0.27521875500679016,
0.1225351095199585,
-0.5169711709022522,
-0.3480708599090576,
0.1739673614501953,
-0.2946570813655853,
-0.4040091633796692,
0.01412896253168583,
-0.4115545451641083,
0.12112822383642197,
0.365339070558548,
0.1397676169872284,
0.13740256428718567,
-0.2998679280281067,
0.09770708531141281,
-0.0011345649836584926,
-0.09154228866100311,
0.20817434787750244,
-0.28030896186828613,
0.42936256527900696,
-0.16373804211616516,
-0.5939247608184814,
-0.3638366162776947,
0.24496574699878693,
0.3114815354347229,
-0.3764244318008423,
0.2284832000732422,
0.6868683695793152,
-0.3044166564941406,
-0.18852880597114563,
-0.49518418312072754,
0.24083644151687622,
-0.47445598244667053,
0.5715587735176086,
-0.5474055409431458,
-1.1528120040893555,
0.22526344656944275,
-0.12513437867164612,
-0.12598097324371338,
0.37674880027770996,
0.8171133399009705,
0.03764311224222183,
0.9833757281303406,
0.5737636685371399,
-0.3880435526371002,
-0.08906807750463486,
0.375103622674942,
0.27115917205810547,
-0.7485605478286743,
-0.4261336326599121,
-0.750387966632843,
-0.23017336428165436,
-0.6937114000320435,
-0.48722198605537415,
0.4155982732772827,
0.2623656094074249,
-0.06838995963335037,
0.08324268460273743,
-0.14440308511257172,
0.584173321723938,
0.3892121911048889,
0.05306989327073097,
0.5673472881317139,
0.07836809754371643,
-0.2509482204914093,
-0.22410425543785095,
-0.6672949194908142,
-0.5365204215049744,
1.1756842136383057,
0.1960129737854004,
0.7515908479690552,
0.713743269443512,
0.6342185139656067,
0.16814936697483063,
0.09151797741651535,
-0.9343072175979614,
0.7185010313987732,
0.16709502041339874,
-0.502589225769043,
-0.08765977621078491,
-0.5015671849250793,
-1.0346238613128662,
0.3630397319793701,
0.1564440131187439,
-0.8102023601531982,
-0.21654678881168365,
-0.17523418366909027,
-0.36359792947769165,
0.08553709834814072,
-0.17006899416446686,
0.6699719429016113,
-0.3312269151210785,
-0.42104771733283997,
-0.5661892890930176,
-0.38481611013412476,
0.8333529233932495,
-0.28944605588912964,
0.24708132445812225,
-0.46570974588394165,
-0.11703496426343918,
0.7020251154899597,
-0.44427579641342163,
0.3771909773349762,
0.36852771043777466,
-0.2706104516983032,
0.35236647725105286,
0.3100709617137909,
-0.015507856383919716,
0.1945168375968933,
-0.043207522481679916,
-0.335954487323761,
0.2505631446838379,
-0.6753899455070496,
-0.6331071257591248,
0.7994793057441711,
-0.6823713183403015,
-0.9308708906173706,
-0.9071899056434631,
-0.6081740260124207,
-0.3629594147205353,
0.10935009270906448,
-0.34030553698539734,
0.3814529776573181,
-0.3185899257659912,
0.0667368620634079,
0.6343408226966858,
-0.4725671112537384,
0.1531791090965271,
0.6254684925079346,
-0.5158021450042725,
-0.3330792188644409,
1.3011970520019531,
-0.04291756451129913,
0.3091365694999695,
0.1846999228000641,
0.47039923071861267,
-0.2758442163467407,
-0.5135411620140076,
-0.7841803431510925,
0.3717699944972992,
-0.777636706829071,
-0.004617207683622837,
-0.3269643187522888,
-0.2634556293487549,
-0.18540601432323456,
0.27053970098495483,
-0.17268814146518707,
-0.5361438393592834,
0.05202121660113335,
0.14857232570648193,
0.2770135700702667,
0.8146857619285583,
-0.15920698642730713,
-0.20398180186748505,
-0.8382662534713745,
0.07434695959091187,
0.3101353943347931,
0.174958735704422,
0.34248673915863037,
-0.6458718776702881,
-0.3280469477176666,
-0.22607891261577606,
-0.5044176578521729,
-0.849285900592804,
0.0856589823961258,
0.27955368161201477,
0.5415595769882202,
0.14579704403877258,
-0.052468281239271164,
0.7521955370903015,
-0.5818307399749756,
0.676823616027832,
-0.0893089696764946,
-0.9158012270927429,
0.6138063073158264,
-0.2481280118227005,
0.5843454003334045,
0.5825154781341553,
0.7588907480239868,
-0.8104774951934814,
-0.41751161217689514,
-0.4705474376678467,
-0.6544733643531799,
0.5170724391937256,
0.17736825346946716,
0.06922216713428497,
0.06841836869716644,
0.41567733883857727,
-0.06900802254676819,
0.1669776439666748,
-0.5175657272338867,
-0.29495465755462646,
0.29699838161468506,
-0.20532749593257904,
-0.09328624606132507,
-0.32852429151535034,
0.3171981871128082,
-0.4220212996006012,
0.708164393901825,
0.08104662597179413,
-0.36897316575050354,
0.1660935878753662,
-0.3728064000606537,
-0.179555743932724,
0.4357084333896637,
0.6327208876609802,
0.661614179611206,
-0.17684975266456604,
0.03901965543627739,
0.30937832593917847,
-0.7130830883979797,
0.3435203433036804,
0.0498456135392189,
0.04564909636974335,
-0.01065929513424635,
0.30531594157218933,
0.36680182814598083,
0.1894310861825943,
-1.2444024085998535,
0.18631166219711304,
-0.10699283331632614,
-0.14676672220230103,
-0.4947664141654968,
0.09286042302846909,
0.1909775584936142,
0.3181054890155792,
0.4075734317302704,
-0.4136987030506134,
0.08939076960086823,
-0.608343780040741,
-0.1490052342414856,
0.2435997724533081,
-0.295348197221756,
-0.21372756361961365,
0.41344547271728516,
-0.1991197168827057,
-0.012470830231904984,
0.45760709047317505,
-0.5188794732093811,
-0.7907589077949524,
0.6767140626907349,
0.48129382729530334,
0.5524892210960388,
-0.6326158046722412,
0.26672425866127014,
0.6217936277389526,
0.534428060054779,
0.04902086779475212,
0.5774780511856079,
-0.20088645815849304,
-0.4320122301578522,
-0.3933015465736389,
-0.8146486282348633,
-0.7085825204849243,
0.2895670533180237,
-0.602308452129364,
0.21848121285438538,
-0.6272355914115906,
0.21577543020248413,
-0.1732204705476761,
0.4940688908100128,
-0.33419832587242126,
-0.010942908935248852,
0.2982238829135895,
0.9944077134132385,
-0.4460286498069763,
0.8924051523208618,
0.7899552583694458,
-0.12989042699337006,
-0.9974050521850586,
-0.30837082862854004,
0.14320647716522217,
-0.7850744128227234,
0.7054013013839722,
0.07403041422367096,
-0.13901686668395996,
-0.04926731064915657,
-0.1651616245508194,
-0.9875017404556274,
0.8537487387657166,
0.28109413385391235,
-0.5716056823730469,
0.34379905462265015,
0.3796539008617401,
0.3935941159725189,
-0.009913111105561256,
0.12273776531219482,
0.910055935382843,
0.5410679578781128,
-0.03398627042770386,
-1.0709736347198486,
0.1721286177635193,
-0.5589749813079834,
0.04804631322622299,
0.2159431278705597,
-0.7630997896194458,
0.8345183730125427,
-0.19133897125720978,
-0.3798418939113617,
0.5975953936576843,
0.7880304455757141,
0.6926990151405334,
0.12354627996683121,
0.3051120340824127,
0.648466169834137,
0.8093858361244202,
0.07360835373401642,
1.000889778137207,
-0.29787567257881165,
0.13485269248485565,
1.010363221168518,
-0.45278042554855347,
0.818686306476593,
0.39992278814315796,
-0.44493651390075684,
0.41119077801704407,
0.7427966594696045,
0.05425373092293739,
0.16604860126972198,
0.8417395949363708,
-0.38395872712135315,
-0.26297464966773987,
-0.4668671786785126,
-0.5044187307357788,
0.6432375907897949,
0.3214355409145355,
0.27444157004356384,
-0.43705886602401733,
-0.15346480906009674,
0.2743910551071167,
0.4691467583179474,
-0.5271908044815063,
0.31709590554237366,
0.26684266328811646,
-0.7244112491607666,
0.7687940001487732,
0.4317910969257355,
0.4275856018066406,
-0.5305130481719971,
0.1440058797597885,
-0.4826309382915497,
0.2017972320318222,
-0.23330727219581604,
-0.5970141887664795,
0.30774760246276855,
0.073749840259552,
0.1555228978395462,
0.09947032481431961,
0.7338091731071472,
-0.5592080354690552,
-0.8379419445991516,
-0.06458988785743713,
0.8478335738182068,
0.32719412446022034,
-0.045736853033304214,
-0.6115677356719971,
0.3892827332019806,
-0.04882218688726425,
-0.07169356197118759,
0.4032086133956909,
0.4648488461971283,
-0.43540018796920776,
0.7000129818916321,
0.61114102602005,
0.0994357019662857,
-0.10159969329833984,
-0.05146617442369461,
0.6629424691200256,
-0.7867627143859863,
-0.36230209469795227,
-0.9971714019775391,
0.004900132771581411,
0.09562202543020248,
-0.34710416197776794,
1.2520928382873535,
0.6479246616363525,
0.887142539024353,
0.20431378483772278,
0.7209579944610596,
0.13053831458091736,
0.4969826340675354,
-0.42334216833114624,
0.6152332425117493,
-0.6851616501808167,
0.04857436940073967,
-0.3457167148590088,
-0.7866730093955994,
-0.03721403330564499,
0.4966382086277008,
-0.22785018384456635,
0.022677233442664146,
0.9612457156181335,
0.5085519552230835,
0.13614003360271454,
0.2876178026199341,
0.20131418108940125,
0.06318461894989014,
0.03171800449490547,
1.2943466901779175,
1.3932057619094849,
-0.36733752489089966,
0.6255744695663452,
-0.5695219039916992,
-0.21068447828292847,
-0.00389323802664876,
-0.8492719531059265,
-0.9558656215667725,
-0.5209652185440063,
-0.3942349851131439,
-0.41773390769958496,
0.019400278106331825,
0.993523895740509,
0.10732016712427139,
-0.7812085151672363,
-0.7999384999275208,
0.3283939063549042,
0.32844921946525574,
-0.26063767075538635,
-0.15647482872009277,
0.48189541697502136,
-0.13947805762290955,
-0.6931084394454956,
0.488727867603302,
0.2971397638320923,
-0.19376292824745178,
-0.41958481073379517,
-0.008036576211452484,
-0.08771027624607086,
-0.061658620834350586,
0.657084584236145,
0.274795264005661,
-0.5980100631713867,
-0.07613132894039154,
0.08155583590269089,
-0.27612560987472534,
-0.20846359431743622,
0.6086599826812744,
-0.7780957221984863,
0.10727585107088089,
0.26500263810157776,
0.8973096013069153,
0.18852871656417847,
-0.39853182435035706,
0.30236494541168213,
-0.22620682418346405,
0.12016228586435318,
0.2218671292066574,
0.17127759754657745,
0.351864218711853,
-0.15701457858085632,
0.4831397533416748,
0.22190453112125397,
-0.2781165838241577,
-0.9892525672912598,
0.32011130452156067,
-0.8436769843101501,
-0.16006143391132355,
0.8707566857337952,
0.04412068426609039,
-0.5280565619468689,
-0.07922539860010147,
-0.21244506537914276,
-0.12860731780529022,
-0.1349131315946579,
0.7039192318916321,
0.9152207970619202,
0.044882968068122864,
-0.29556673765182495,
-0.8774284720420837,
0.4013494551181793,
0.9263485074043274,
-0.6168204545974731,
-0.22799070179462433,
0.387847900390625,
0.2021477371454239,
-0.12236588448286057,
0.6373057961463928,
-0.29842817783355713,
0.6577057838439941,
-0.45768705010414124,
-0.23266859352588654,
-0.007786307018250227,
-0.20382609963417053,
-0.6870856285095215,
0.08703804761171341,
0.3840041160583496,
0.2520396411418915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06621v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06621v1
|
What is Your Favorite Gender, MLM? Gender Bias Evaluation in Multilingual Masked Language Models
| 2024-04-09T21:12:08 | 2024-04-09T21:12:08 |
Jeongrok Yu, Seong Ug Kim, Jacob Choi, Jinho D. Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Bias is a disproportionate prejudice in favor of one side against another.
Due to the success of transformer-based Masked Language Models (MLMs) and their
impact on many NLP tasks, a systematic evaluation of bias in these models is
needed more than ever. While many studies have evaluated gender bias in English
MLMs, only a few works have been conducted for the task in other languages.
This paper proposes a multilingual approach to estimate gender bias in MLMs
from 5 languages: Chinese, English, German, Portuguese, and Spanish. Unlike
previous work, our approach does not depend on parallel corpora coupled with
English to detect gender bias in other languages using multilingual lexicons.
Moreover, a novel model-based method is presented to generate sentence pairs
for a more robust analysis of gender bias, compared to the traditional
lexicon-based method. For each language, both the lexicon-based and model-based
methods are applied to create two datasets respectively, which are used to
evaluate gender bias in an MLM specifically trained for that language using one
existing and 3 new scoring metrics. Our results show that the previous approach
is data-sensitive and not stable as it does not remove contextual dependencies
irrelevant to gender. In fact, the results often flip when different scoring
metrics are used on the same dataset, suggesting that gender bias should be
studied on a large dataset using multiple evaluation metrics for best practice.
|
[
-0.39428675174713135,
-0.5441344380378723,
0.08601820468902588,
0.686622679233551,
0.22444641590118408,
-0.0020325768273323774,
-0.14841963350772858,
-0.3267464339733124,
0.03409089893102646,
0.41145631670951843,
-0.7788340449333191,
-0.5423744916915894,
-0.5410230159759521,
0.27637216448783875,
-0.2313191145658493,
1.0254850387573242,
0.14790040254592896,
1.0711761713027954,
-0.32908639311790466,
-0.2767845690250397,
-0.8215599656105042,
-0.7287611365318298,
-0.2654457986354828,
-0.4840501546859741,
0.32014814019203186,
0.1074901670217514,
0.494083046913147,
0.27132806181907654,
0.3560284674167633,
0.26272061467170715,
-0.16812336444854736,
0.3019006550312042,
-0.3766944110393524,
0.027035348117351532,
-0.08367137610912323,
-0.5322619080543518,
-0.3820800483226776,
0.2690639793872833,
0.38495612144470215,
0.8317946791648865,
-0.025180758908391,
0.5559754371643066,
0.15931980311870575,
0.9191060662269592,
-0.7938891649246216,
0.21388740837574005,
-0.5884476900100708,
0.4826934039592743,
-0.06253527849912643,
-0.002249178010970354,
-0.3428962826728821,
-0.3324446678161621,
0.19625186920166016,
-0.09297235310077667,
0.4575202465057373,
0.1698284149169922,
0.47316616773605347,
-0.16517066955566406,
-0.6382561326026917,
-0.2791091501712799,
-0.770672082901001,
1.0216548442840576,
-0.3861968219280243,
0.6336292028427124,
0.4096118211746216,
0.46155908703804016,
0.20094028115272522,
-0.04893488436937332,
-0.2596740424633026,
-0.2635842263698578,
-0.14691661298274994,
-0.01639471761882305,
-0.1175624430179596,
-0.45971766114234924,
0.11205950379371643,
0.1670207530260086,
-0.4830698072910309,
0.017200490459799767,
-0.04020129144191742,
-0.0662844106554985,
0.631610095500946,
-0.09084933251142502,
0.4117390513420105,
-0.005842580925673246,
-0.38318923115730286,
0.13989907503128052,
-0.6646413207054138,
-0.14951728284358978,
1.042425513267517,
0.4562923014163971,
0.012904321774840355,
0.460473895072937,
0.10429345071315765,
0.44852811098098755,
0.07813304662704468,
-0.13006877899169922,
0.41026195883750916,
-0.2728017568588257,
-0.06126198545098305,
0.08506505191326141,
0.8050524592399597,
0.6174207925796509,
0.45472514629364014,
-0.22718504071235657,
-0.05498424172401428,
0.03669767826795578,
0.04675756022334099,
-0.4909982681274414,
0.13261829316616058,
0.06853954493999481,
-0.7438327670097351,
-0.26757341623306274,
0.0667748972773552,
-0.7736139297485352,
-0.5670729875564575,
0.034164950251579285,
-0.046982645988464355,
0.11748708784580231,
-0.37650078535079956,
-0.05014410614967346,
-0.3040635585784912,
0.05905764177441597,
-0.002055808436125517,
-1.1391141414642334,
0.11564717441797256,
0.6314228773117065,
0.5632097721099854,
-0.30663150548934937,
-0.39890751242637634,
-0.280987948179245,
-0.0932314470410347,
-0.5130169987678528,
0.44595110416412354,
-0.5189118981361389,
-0.2144848108291626,
0.11583489924669266,
0.1301911473274231,
-0.16429618000984192,
-0.6611487865447998,
0.39000260829925537,
-0.13273051381111145,
0.722327470779419,
-0.43903034925460815,
-0.30064475536346436,
-0.07630918174982071,
0.2823060154914856,
-0.7475399971008301,
1.0052074193954468,
-0.2527371644973755,
-0.954736590385437,
0.7783207297325134,
-0.6289236545562744,
-0.2236529141664505,
-0.28207120299339294,
-0.332255095243454,
-0.456208199262619,
-0.29885807633399963,
0.45735642313957214,
0.349113404750824,
-0.23776710033416748,
0.5841790437698364,
-0.39668551087379456,
-0.145409494638443,
0.4108610451221466,
-0.6115833520889282,
0.9223600029945374,
-0.03337888792157173,
-0.4302048683166504,
0.20294536650180817,
-0.5254878401756287,
-0.37533000111579895,
0.07812661677598953,
-0.037800583988428116,
-0.3592240512371063,
0.015300852246582508,
0.09407764673233032,
0.450825035572052,
0.2032189518213272,
-0.5360100865364075,
-0.2256506234407425,
-0.3186069130897522,
0.09693001955747604,
0.7937320470809937,
-0.43295028805732727,
0.7565842866897583,
-0.2779569923877716,
0.4792201817035675,
0.03763600438833237,
0.21622994542121887,
-0.04912630841135979,
-0.6375077962875366,
-0.7269450426101685,
-0.07554323971271515,
0.3513757586479187,
0.6333826184272766,
-0.6519092321395874,
0.1730063110589981,
0.05656525492668152,
-0.27982887625694275,
-0.6041635870933533,
0.3209083378314972,
0.5136933326721191,
0.22917607426643372,
0.11619383096694946,
-0.12961864471435547,
-0.5648776292800903,
-1.328271508216858,
-0.6306212544441223,
-0.07334418594837189,
-0.14382603764533997,
0.3406364321708679,
0.6328451037406921,
-0.09886188805103302,
0.7750142812728882,
-0.35558879375457764,
-0.5090521574020386,
-0.42629265785217285,
-0.10905329138040543,
0.22007767856121063,
0.5296618938446045,
0.8152377605438232,
-0.7141911387443542,
-0.44957002997398376,
-0.05476520210504532,
-0.744677722454071,
-0.10752758383750916,
0.14037732779979706,
-0.4245079457759857,
0.18309977650642395,
0.10112906247377396,
-0.33953166007995605,
0.06289833784103394,
0.7323166728019714,
-0.4434746205806732,
0.5712083578109741,
0.11539941281080246,
0.0984329953789711,
-0.7693939805030823,
-0.048680081963539124,
0.3536631166934967,
-0.37134936451911926,
-0.645463228225708,
0.10117153078317642,
0.06394701451063156,
0.25651776790618896,
-0.6503233313560486,
0.7011358141899109,
-0.6188837885856628,
-0.0763351246714592,
-0.17323340475559235,
-0.24746350944042206,
-0.054654475301504135,
0.3987782597541809,
0.1932782530784607,
0.46008455753326416,
0.35807475447654724,
-0.41470423340797424,
0.2157379686832428,
0.29381680488586426,
-0.18210452795028687,
0.5931236743927002,
-0.2859433591365814,
0.3459773659706116,
-0.4526083171367645,
0.1925966739654541,
-0.8080573081970215,
0.3418653607368469,
0.41783493757247925,
-0.5088711977005005,
0.321203351020813,
-0.1931949257850647,
-0.1340630054473877,
-0.3033561706542969,
-0.5055267810821533,
0.13070280849933624,
0.07436409592628479,
-0.5810237526893616,
0.41736263036727905,
0.5689272880554199,
0.14911212027072906,
-1.1206893920898438,
-0.9498913884162903,
-0.0029339371249079704,
-0.31351977586746216,
-0.5076102614402771,
-0.04952002316713333,
-0.12217240035533905,
-0.34564927220344543,
-0.4113457500934601,
-0.1311861127614975,
-0.14410671591758728,
-0.003265462117269635,
0.2323591560125351,
0.38106149435043335,
-0.0556645430624485,
-0.15943749248981476,
-0.009555422700941563,
-0.11221889406442642,
0.07700096815824509,
-0.1712893843650818,
0.6033297181129456,
-0.1635865569114685,
-0.30990999937057495,
-0.006069713272154331,
0.6541001796722412,
0.32995325326919556,
0.054117072373628616,
0.8431928157806396,
0.9664897918701172,
-0.48756158351898193,
-0.3237075209617615,
-0.6713703274726868,
-0.3268817067146301,
-0.40031278133392334,
0.5041015148162842,
-0.31749024987220764,
-0.8444617986679077,
0.41770362854003906,
0.40656596422195435,
0.30136623978614807,
0.34330427646636963,
0.8484739065170288,
-0.012879632413387299,
1.35979163646698,
0.8523353338241577,
-0.3654862344264984,
0.2094770222902298,
-0.004061359912157059,
0.16138090193271637,
-0.4595834016799927,
-0.2693135142326355,
-0.6471421122550964,
-0.34651386737823486,
-0.870510458946228,
-0.38279029726982117,
0.14593052864074707,
-0.21609936654567719,
-0.2580961287021637,
0.0871376246213913,
-0.2640570402145386,
0.3437844514846802,
0.6830131411552429,
-0.01940256915986538,
0.26960107684135437,
0.0542631670832634,
-0.19578900933265686,
-0.42155659198760986,
-0.8228069543838501,
-0.7420092225074768,
1.1374895572662354,
0.638304591178894,
0.31683582067489624,
0.22528615593910217,
0.21429041028022766,
0.4388299584388733,
0.40801137685775757,
-0.4506233334541321,
0.2856159806251526,
-0.4300062954425812,
-1.0837033987045288,
-0.1635446399450302,
-0.5343286395072937,
-0.811713457107544,
0.6262661814689636,
-0.3006930649280548,
-0.6433355212211609,
0.051473114639520645,
-0.05186581239104271,
0.1259315460920334,
0.32835566997528076,
-0.6266991496086121,
0.9131084680557251,
-0.21799272298812866,
-0.44217145442962646,
0.36328354477882385,
-0.5010893940925598,
0.7512766718864441,
0.056683629751205444,
0.4679360091686249,
-0.38914796710014343,
0.08633332699537277,
0.798936665058136,
-0.16835333406925201,
0.7777556777000427,
-0.11686970293521881,
-0.29654446244239807,
-0.31362268328666687,
0.027583740651607513,
0.1190691888332367,
0.04101274535059929,
-0.18877139687538147,
0.7380213141441345,
-0.14133954048156738,
-0.3875848650932312,
-0.42547252774238586,
0.6029966473579407,
-0.6561337113380432,
-0.38061726093292236,
-0.5563300848007202,
-0.5361335873603821,
-0.34193846583366394,
0.14406879246234894,
0.07177139073610306,
-0.09539221227169037,
-0.45847180485725403,
-0.09843786805868149,
0.30014708638191223,
-0.5616207718849182,
0.45483648777008057,
0.6697884202003479,
-0.47626063227653503,
-0.06844070553779602,
0.764182448387146,
-0.007851450704038143,
0.1525450199842453,
0.46537676453590393,
0.3165585398674011,
-0.37066569924354553,
-0.03517013043165207,
-0.8577197790145874,
0.016869697719812393,
-0.6117063164710999,
0.14367413520812988,
-0.8381967544555664,
-0.08731765300035477,
-0.43985772132873535,
0.17958635091781616,
-0.5006863474845886,
-0.2280047982931137,
0.16093161702156067,
-0.14544713497161865,
-0.17319227755069733,
0.5127437114715576,
0.25575247406959534,
0.08434268832206726,
-0.527930498123169,
0.5065835118293762,
0.25862711668014526,
0.12675350904464722,
-0.04940324276685715,
-0.17928333580493927,
-0.04479118436574936,
0.12775282561779022,
-0.26485490798950195,
-1.049445629119873,
0.6661183834075928,
0.09108541905879974,
0.6932411193847656,
0.3889565169811249,
-0.36394551396369934,
0.22082485258579254,
-0.5878431797027588,
0.8771969079971313,
0.3219960033893585,
-0.8971779346466064,
0.34146517515182495,
-0.22225870192050934,
0.14928989112377167,
0.3242787718772888,
0.5604649186134338,
-0.6901448369026184,
-0.47967514395713806,
-0.2897394895553589,
-0.7340364456176758,
0.6880737543106079,
0.45533108711242676,
0.41393545269966125,
-0.02740308828651905,
-0.04915573075413704,
0.500458836555481,
0.8120594024658203,
-1.1411935091018677,
-1.0887165069580078,
0.10513512045145035,
0.013095265254378319,
-0.03437573090195656,
-0.34111082553863525,
-0.019262274727225304,
-0.1352331042289734,
0.7589594721794128,
-0.21229347586631775,
0.41835927963256836,
-0.13903585076332092,
-0.34625044465065,
-0.06526394188404083,
0.31291669607162476,
0.47162336111068726,
0.7242999076843262,
-0.298697292804718,
0.07392774522304535,
0.4678812623023987,
-0.6113789677619934,
0.20595358312129974,
-0.15645989775657654,
-0.6163370609283447,
0.4801395833492279,
0.28894561529159546,
0.8130762577056885,
-0.22394460439682007,
-0.41250813007354736,
0.6233420968055725,
-0.3252507746219635,
-0.0600459985435009,
-0.18543431162834167,
-0.3549630045890808,
0.07964218407869339,
0.2102370411157608,
0.4891436994075775,
0.09501618891954422,
0.30071577429771423,
-0.500455915927887,
0.04366819187998772,
0.6009997129440308,
-0.7801815867424011,
0.052280012518167496,
0.7274694442749023,
0.23361457884311676,
-0.07122795283794403,
0.12179248780012131,
-0.2702125906944275,
-0.6684200167655945,
0.7583187818527222,
0.5223012566566467,
1.1319336891174316,
-0.49733206629753113,
0.435194194316864,
0.3828481137752533,
0.7511880993843079,
-0.08331280946731567,
0.21425938606262207,
0.3170715570449829,
-1.1248703002929688,
-0.2583467364311218,
-0.5640366077423096,
-0.17400193214416504,
0.018067678436636925,
-0.46546077728271484,
0.5259440541267395,
-0.1864757239818573,
-0.19305120408535004,
0.01463093888014555,
-0.22142666578292847,
-0.7732442021369934,
0.022536473348736763,
0.5226227641105652,
0.42219677567481995,
-1.0705089569091797,
0.4475449025630951,
0.6355074644088745,
-0.000496519438456744,
-0.25743210315704346,
-0.2824304699897766,
0.3458525240421295,
-0.8982877135276794,
0.6745741367340088,
0.44358816742897034,
-0.015216520056128502,
-0.5927191376686096,
-0.0253681018948555,
-0.49159714579582214,
0.681064248085022,
0.5907561779022217,
-0.6814754605293274,
0.09759549051523209,
0.5993216037750244,
0.28808215260505676,
-0.6550085544586182,
0.9029256105422974,
0.6617693305015564,
0.4680340886116028,
-0.5321526527404785,
-1.053673267364502,
-0.1680038720369339,
-0.307738333940506,
0.1496138572692871,
-0.10377670079469681,
-0.5384697914123535,
0.8052928447723389,
0.07719893753528595,
0.13382470607757568,
-0.32765549421310425,
0.5015819072723389,
0.38226065039634705,
0.5730078220367432,
0.6776692271232605,
0.04172026365995407,
0.7581195831298828,
-0.13138823211193085,
0.8273234963417053,
-0.29830655455589294,
0.37777790427207947,
1.1889010667800903,
-0.3693968951702118,
0.3441145420074463,
0.39014992117881775,
-0.31547489762306213,
0.34675174951553345,
0.5113357901573181,
-0.08567891269922256,
0.033722445368766785,
0.37813353538513184,
-0.019089361652731895,
-0.006468561477959156,
-0.3378731906414032,
-0.4016231298446655,
0.570309579372406,
-0.14506536722183228,
-0.7181516885757446,
-0.04684493690729141,
0.1837584227323532,
0.38275521993637085,
0.15234489738941193,
-0.17075006663799286,
0.4608900845050812,
0.16899298131465912,
-0.37664783000946045,
0.19122569262981415,
0.4328337013721466,
1.097644329071045,
-0.6522619128227234,
0.04063154384493828,
-0.31049469113349915,
0.0030361786484718323,
-0.36562567949295044,
-0.2973330616950989,
0.12590515613555908,
0.24220602214336395,
-0.4687868654727936,
-0.37816619873046875,
0.6788824200630188,
-0.8372756838798523,
-1.0002696514129639,
0.43920692801475525,
0.8998399376869202,
0.033648841083049774,
-0.23424093425273895,
-0.9811097383499146,
-0.1770954430103302,
0.11702878028154373,
-0.13822272419929504,
0.45553433895111084,
-0.03202205151319504,
-0.2361144721508026,
0.7937762141227722,
0.6986823678016663,
0.08589436858892441,
0.25149014592170715,
0.6482423543930054,
0.1986282467842102,
-0.5424620509147644,
-0.5725820064544678,
-1.1826491355895996,
0.17858527600765228,
-0.05402521789073944,
-0.3319685757160187,
1.3150609731674194,
0.6987677812576294,
0.7763051390647888,
-0.2014951854944229,
0.8426464796066284,
0.4173326790332794,
0.4644163250923157,
-0.3286491632461548,
0.9922203421592712,
-0.3271643817424774,
0.3503166437149048,
-0.7556408643722534,
-1.2942389249801636,
-0.2745055556297302,
0.5436241030693054,
-0.22903485596179962,
0.38763540983200073,
0.5641078948974609,
0.7436012029647827,
0.09077996015548706,
0.19250690937042236,
0.37140846252441406,
-0.020150788128376007,
0.11566272377967834,
0.3491328954696655,
1.0121850967407227,
-0.5330909490585327,
0.1796790361404419,
-0.47034546732902527,
-0.16709619760513306,
0.03001878224313259,
-1.0401657819747925,
-1.0181760787963867,
-0.32785728573799133,
-0.5561060905456543,
-0.34454020857810974,
0.05675823241472244,
0.9870359897613525,
0.8476460576057434,
-0.8064947724342346,
-0.6033334136009216,
0.3316704034805298,
0.5986694693565369,
-0.41975852847099304,
-0.237999826669693,
0.1221841499209404,
-0.18126186728477478,
-1.1883870363235474,
0.16790173947811127,
0.06206248700618744,
-0.3155231773853302,
-0.662635862827301,
-0.021966775879263878,
-0.30959928035736084,
-0.24753424525260925,
0.6452090740203857,
-0.3905524015426636,
-0.5279170870780945,
0.07050221413373947,
0.1806829273700714,
-0.0343659408390522,
-0.12816494703292847,
0.8683264255523682,
-0.23622232675552368,
0.5784104466438293,
0.42792677879333496,
0.24378828704357147,
0.3831699788570404,
-0.3061144948005676,
0.945343017578125,
-0.7560490965843201,
0.20110422372817993,
0.1800452023744583,
0.43008342385292053,
0.5700237154960632,
-0.36341801285743713,
0.3706235885620117,
0.25537508726119995,
-0.1440143883228302,
-0.8230510354042053,
0.026406249031424522,
-0.4979657828807831,
-0.458377480506897,
1.4403990507125854,
0.06721063703298569,
-0.10553548485040665,
-0.22344915568828583,
-0.30525311827659607,
0.08735818415880203,
-0.27704280614852905,
0.5433904528617859,
0.8334226608276367,
0.2604345381259918,
0.0016231678891927004,
-0.9813095927238464,
0.3797212541103363,
0.5606746077537537,
-0.27262043952941895,
-0.26932451128959656,
0.21652516722679138,
0.3567805290222168,
-0.0055046710185706615,
0.35595008730888367,
-0.06515440344810486,
0.10300230979919434,
-0.19760701060295105,
0.3665994703769684,
0.10833743959665298,
-0.33065253496170044,
-0.41892170906066895,
0.20324841141700745,
-0.2928527593612671,
-0.33388975262641907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06619v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06619v1
|
FairPair: A Robust Evaluation of Biases in Language Models through Paired Perturbations
| 2024-04-09T21:09:22 | 2024-04-09T21:09:22 |
Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Raaz Dwivedi, Timo Schick
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
The accurate evaluation of differential treatment in language models to
specific groups is critical to ensuring a positive and safe user experience. An
ideal evaluation should have the properties of being robust, extendable to new
groups or attributes, and being able to capture biases that appear in typical
usage (rather than just extreme, rare cases). Relatedly, bias evaluation should
surface not only egregious biases but also ones that are subtle and
commonplace, such as a likelihood for talking about appearances with regard to
women. We present FairPair, an evaluation framework for assessing differential
treatment that occurs during ordinary usage. FairPair operates through
counterfactual pairs, but crucially, the paired continuations are grounded in
the same demographic group, which ensures equivalent comparison. Additionally,
unlike prior work, our method factors in the inherent variability that comes
from the generation process itself by measuring the sampling variability. We
present an evaluation of several commonly used generative models and a
qualitative analysis that indicates a preference for discussing family and
hobbies with regard to women.
|
[
-0.1265493929386139,
-0.7552779912948608,
0.23191674053668976,
0.5723435878753662,
0.05447050556540489,
0.04091671481728554,
-0.10922207683324814,
-0.08666296303272247,
-0.09258502721786499,
0.3327648639678955,
-0.5357294678688049,
-0.28898778557777405,
-0.7280340790748596,
-0.16029638051986694,
-0.5302008986473083,
0.9556622505187988,
-0.01480269804596901,
0.5030557513237,
-0.21250711381435394,
-0.4559698700904846,
-0.6893478035926819,
-0.45789390802383423,
-0.4378567337989807,
-0.5855167508125305,
0.1959206461906433,
0.08874709159135818,
0.8661642670631409,
0.2333659827709198,
0.3481401801109314,
0.30351266264915466,
-0.1360398828983307,
-0.2895829379558563,
-0.7305505871772766,
0.4300200939178467,
-0.20210008323192596,
-0.3793720304965973,
-0.3946486711502075,
0.3542388081550598,
0.38300055265426636,
1.2292011976242065,
-0.3476979732513428,
0.2813548445701599,
0.16325612366199493,
0.7365914583206177,
-0.8799200654029846,
-0.2734605073928833,
-0.3807281255722046,
0.27262523770332336,
-0.36797839403152466,
-0.1141367182135582,
-0.1567784547805786,
-0.561810314655304,
0.15880805253982544,
-0.3590371906757355,
0.4243484139442444,
-0.13654261827468872,
0.6794816255569458,
0.2475508600473404,
-0.3790050148963928,
-0.10503557324409485,
-0.7431918382644653,
0.9667371511459351,
-0.4826798141002655,
0.4695918560028076,
0.3536589741706848,
0.4988363981246948,
-0.4558827877044678,
-0.6508501172065735,
-0.6434754133224487,
-0.3745693862438202,
-0.1276342272758484,
-0.02514808252453804,
-0.5551566481590271,
-0.059798650443553925,
0.3924354910850525,
0.6218823194503784,
-0.48640304803848267,
-0.09485618025064468,
0.11380664259195328,
-0.24135874211788177,
0.45434150099754333,
0.3739118278026581,
0.5848251581192017,
-0.005049127619713545,
-0.21607165038585663,
0.0451354905962944,
-0.5656166076660156,
0.2754947543144226,
1.033827304840088,
0.13108159601688385,
-0.42874565720558167,
0.5949450731277466,
-0.47410497069358826,
0.7811146378517151,
0.39029940962791443,
-0.006425761617720127,
0.29491958022117615,
-0.295617014169693,
-0.14144422113895416,
-0.48143064975738525,
0.6844305992126465,
0.4396146535873413,
0.20105326175689697,
-0.31058937311172485,
-0.40268877148628235,
0.3909503221511841,
-0.011178255081176758,
-0.7087799310684204,
-0.12167184054851532,
-0.02252822369337082,
-0.7634775042533875,
-0.5052297711372375,
-0.029400037601590157,
-1.079789638519287,
-0.5506280660629272,
-0.18235722184181213,
0.33175331354141235,
0.14232085645198822,
-0.36227330565452576,
0.19236904382705688,
-0.3768363296985626,
0.15501311421394348,
0.21655529737472534,
-0.943301260471344,
0.7437137365341187,
0.5328453779220581,
0.4605506360530853,
-0.029908735305070877,
-0.12396086007356644,
-0.9595493078231812,
-0.1863780915737152,
0.01876583881676197,
0.7833982110023499,
-0.8846634030342102,
-0.6087481379508972,
-0.001194013631902635,
-0.16603738069534302,
0.10569813847541809,
-0.38348188996315,
0.662858247756958,
-0.3083955645561218,
0.5048139691352844,
-0.5044803023338318,
-0.2731337249279022,
0.12395253777503967,
0.11964018642902374,
-0.8018612861633301,
0.6445630788803101,
0.4294265806674957,
-1.2676048278808594,
0.611486554145813,
-0.6633427143096924,
-0.45573192834854126,
-0.03483634814620018,
-0.4858379662036896,
-0.2647404074668884,
0.16555196046829224,
0.15398457646369934,
0.11290266364812851,
-0.3819008469581604,
0.44385817646980286,
-0.4468441903591156,
-0.35616716742515564,
0.3291388750076294,
-0.6572247743606567,
1.0577261447906494,
0.19035455584526062,
-0.4715915620326996,
0.29145053029060364,
-0.5999343395233154,
-0.4090995490550995,
0.19657643139362335,
-0.12791909277439117,
-0.5994720458984375,
0.011480513960123062,
0.3845435380935669,
0.07060620188713074,
0.05913844704627991,
-0.48414409160614014,
0.011324170045554638,
-0.3308136463165283,
0.16148975491523743,
0.784959077835083,
-0.12628257274627686,
0.5089272260665894,
-0.5278989672660828,
0.783359706401825,
-0.22979192435741425,
0.31117555499076843,
0.23758487403392792,
-0.40184053778648376,
-0.6367632746696472,
-0.27443668246269226,
0.529970645904541,
0.3149147629737854,
-0.44771671295166016,
0.24989290535449982,
-0.12037385255098343,
-0.18559858202934265,
-0.4442421495914459,
0.16513606905937195,
0.6384651064872742,
0.5537833571434021,
0.01213926263153553,
-0.7075929045677185,
-0.5350280404090881,
-0.9366081357002258,
-0.6022235155105591,
0.03844510018825531,
0.013215893879532814,
0.3006129860877991,
0.21292316913604736,
-0.1703593134880066,
0.9450636506080627,
-0.2673279047012329,
-0.061127614229917526,
-0.3867535889148712,
0.4323155879974365,
-0.032988838851451874,
0.4539172649383545,
0.7085512280464172,
-1.0021641254425049,
-0.43940767645835876,
-0.48550158739089966,
-0.4779854118824005,
-0.44701141119003296,
0.09547014534473419,
-0.37133124470710754,
0.18101710081100464,
0.09453722834587097,
-0.17673224210739136,
0.5428892374038696,
0.7701214551925659,
-0.8151726126670837,
0.3904533386230469,
0.02409234270453453,
0.3347291946411133,
-0.6558355093002319,
0.35980039834976196,
-0.0324789322912693,
-0.42749902606010437,
-0.5385813117027283,
-0.03000803291797638,
-0.44365185499191284,
0.36733001470565796,
-0.32007208466529846,
0.837256133556366,
-0.20685502886772156,
0.03896990045905113,
-0.2117546945810318,
-0.09518654644489288,
0.08142244070768356,
-0.07298718392848969,
-0.13112729787826538,
0.6157320737838745,
0.4206189215183258,
-0.19714096188545227,
0.17973509430885315,
0.23042786121368408,
-0.11350259184837341,
0.6003069877624512,
-0.5617029666900635,
0.43151310086250305,
-0.19447392225265503,
0.2519649267196655,
-0.8654615879058838,
-0.3017389178276062,
0.30799248814582825,
-0.5250629186630249,
0.22495368123054504,
-0.13986016809940338,
-0.33836057782173157,
-0.06664776057004929,
-0.470447301864624,
0.58453768491745,
0.5057238936424255,
-0.5200342535972595,
0.5797492861747742,
0.7266110181808472,
-0.06685777008533478,
-0.9417484998703003,
-0.5069367289543152,
-0.11997080594301224,
-0.4064446687698364,
-0.6598522067070007,
0.15204618871212006,
-0.14910858869552612,
-0.7731388807296753,
-0.012780580669641495,
-0.17704929411411285,
-0.062380172312259674,
0.2429388463497162,
0.40296727418899536,
0.14002148807048798,
0.1903543770313263,
-0.16805101931095123,
0.24050995707511902,
-0.07950756698846817,
-0.19220708310604095,
0.2180653214454651,
0.9128104448318481,
-0.16247841715812683,
-0.100685253739357,
-0.20347003638744354,
0.6249236464500427,
0.18448016047477722,
-0.20457684993743896,
0.5498164892196655,
0.633607029914856,
-0.4720580577850342,
-0.0314936600625515,
-0.8911442756652832,
-0.09081803262233734,
-0.4289184510707855,
0.15283185243606567,
-0.5976532697677612,
-0.9423051476478577,
0.8225275874137878,
0.2627068758010864,
-0.3115319311618805,
0.4013146460056305,
0.6983380317687988,
0.0800984650850296,
1.1966102123260498,
1.098601222038269,
-0.07713083922863007,
0.3601458966732025,
0.1466410756111145,
0.006857533007860184,
-0.4719568192958832,
-0.09795919805765152,
-0.745400607585907,
-0.17699569463729858,
-0.821061909198761,
-0.07802676409482956,
-0.09780809283256531,
0.1561024785041809,
-0.28901422023773193,
-0.16848336160182953,
-0.23883160948753357,
0.3700407147407532,
0.43869689106941223,
-0.05928487330675125,
0.37426069378852844,
-0.10815393179655075,
-0.11581835895776749,
-0.23334155976772308,
-0.46352896094322205,
-0.9005248546600342,
1.18046236038208,
0.29433608055114746,
0.8530462384223938,
0.22370992600917816,
0.6458178758621216,
0.5311786532402039,
0.6220399737358093,
-0.5419993996620178,
0.2846057713031769,
-0.6077377200126648,
-0.6435754895210266,
-0.023763315752148628,
-0.5851502418518066,
-1.0485565662384033,
-0.0004935172037221491,
-0.17372961342334747,
-0.8849332928657532,
0.39396950602531433,
0.2654859721660614,
-0.4057753086090088,
0.02666385844349861,
-0.48745250701904297,
0.9444190859794617,
-0.06570533663034439,
-0.5297260880470276,
-0.236579030752182,
-0.7483192682266235,
0.5713544487953186,
0.10420740395784378,
0.09267662465572357,
-0.21588076651096344,
0.22846883535385132,
0.8392156958580017,
-0.18903730809688568,
0.6685560345649719,
-0.34925466775894165,
0.284519761800766,
0.03493925556540489,
0.37645554542541504,
-0.0776819959282875,
-0.013905427418649197,
-0.12975656986236572,
0.30448949337005615,
0.04948385804891586,
-0.3758697807788849,
-0.5588595271110535,
0.8472069501876831,
-0.7433003783226013,
-0.6301897168159485,
-0.49133092164993286,
-0.6039422154426575,
-0.23479193449020386,
0.14981390535831451,
0.13317491114139557,
0.3268715739250183,
-0.6072726845741272,
-0.06502770632505417,
0.3208697736263275,
-0.4556039571762085,
0.2011905312538147,
0.39296430349349976,
-0.3464999794960022,
-0.2078392654657364,
0.3103940486907959,
-0.11592131108045578,
0.20860253274440765,
0.2318163812160492,
0.5135435461997986,
-0.34468454122543335,
-0.15572600066661835,
-0.1754552721977234,
0.014926465228199959,
-0.6756170988082886,
-0.005502876825630665,
-0.6007311344146729,
0.1797063648700714,
-0.449841171503067,
0.06492644548416138,
-0.3274066746234894,
-0.6493372321128845,
0.21785441040992737,
0.06181060150265694,
-0.004645536653697491,
0.61062091588974,
-0.22412189841270447,
0.2185095250606537,
-0.41273173689842224,
0.4957006275653839,
0.47792884707450867,
0.4006941020488739,
-0.1755051165819168,
-0.3675942122936249,
0.4610890746116638,
-0.116634801030159,
-0.3641628623008728,
-0.944675087928772,
0.3821825385093689,
-0.13007892668247223,
0.8712753653526306,
0.22984348237514496,
0.1762246936559677,
0.4410858750343323,
-0.36055633425712585,
0.6925418376922607,
0.3248690962791443,
-1.3153084516525269,
0.5287535190582275,
-0.4008297324180603,
-0.12682107090950012,
0.7239318490028381,
0.12126678228378296,
-0.5129270553588867,
-0.20566435158252716,
-0.6543838977813721,
-0.680900514125824,
0.5645366311073303,
0.3392559289932251,
0.33436328172683716,
0.17600534856319427,
0.2834104895591736,
0.5605697631835938,
0.4554120898246765,
-0.9814438223838806,
-0.30949634313583374,
-0.3268180191516876,
-0.24771346151828766,
0.18428008258342743,
-0.3078421950340271,
-0.4644939601421356,
-0.04263337701559067,
0.20385590195655823,
0.14168576896190643,
0.178286612033844,
0.02098485268652439,
-0.11583742499351501,
-0.36564865708351135,
0.5177066922187805,
0.4473552703857422,
0.7250310182571411,
-0.3699103593826294,
0.1577669233083725,
-0.1406685709953308,
-0.48253190517425537,
0.11069640517234802,
0.37748458981513977,
-0.2660267949104309,
0.008202522061765194,
0.07791824638843536,
0.6560548543930054,
-0.3486519455909729,
-0.6246074438095093,
0.9557989239692688,
-0.4295607805252075,
0.16210158169269562,
-0.058318886905908585,
0.025368932634592056,
-0.280070960521698,
0.27073195576667786,
0.06755810230970383,
0.2819446325302124,
0.6443483233451843,
-0.6384329795837402,
0.05388271063566208,
0.4894642233848572,
-0.544005811214447,
-0.3467773497104645,
0.6424268484115601,
0.32983389496803284,
-0.3444829285144806,
0.40228402614593506,
-0.3738800287246704,
-0.5402992367744446,
0.39531174302101135,
0.3279432952404022,
1.0562894344329834,
-0.39593788981437683,
0.10517837852239609,
0.06324868649244308,
0.1935582309961319,
-0.011652330867946148,
0.4046398401260376,
-0.04429677501320839,
-0.8572996258735657,
-0.19136446714401245,
-0.832945704460144,
-0.2587943971157074,
0.20613889396190643,
-0.7505189180374146,
0.36117440462112427,
-0.18950112164020538,
-0.3296339213848114,
-0.1342315375804901,
-0.1623375117778778,
-0.9487636089324951,
0.101813904941082,
-0.021468278020620346,
0.6586483716964722,
-1.1630816459655762,
0.6770827174186707,
0.7133309841156006,
-0.7059371471405029,
-0.657296359539032,
0.3528689444065094,
0.012877908535301685,
-0.43608787655830383,
0.7851523756980896,
0.11708246916532516,
-0.375784307718277,
-0.5059299468994141,
-0.4621405005455017,
-0.34709233045578003,
0.6312282681465149,
0.7289702296257019,
-0.5395697355270386,
0.1579178124666214,
0.132341668009758,
0.560092568397522,
-0.25379684567451477,
0.3960985243320465,
0.7795979976654053,
0.42899414896965027,
-0.11873427778482437,
-1.2466877698898315,
0.16815203428268433,
-0.35193511843681335,
0.2045162469148636,
-0.10286134481430054,
-0.6289939284324646,
0.8364787697792053,
-0.014152944087982178,
-0.09079635888338089,
0.2696341276168823,
0.37754204869270325,
0.4722159206867218,
0.38799431920051575,
0.8324885368347168,
0.35133084654808044,
0.5679234862327576,
-0.1846657246351242,
1.1565407514572144,
0.04151184484362602,
0.328717440366745,
1.0931209325790405,
-0.37756213545799255,
0.586855947971344,
0.776496171951294,
-0.27876272797584534,
0.22167254984378815,
0.3254687488079071,
0.24480730295181274,
0.6549178957939148,
0.4447108507156372,
-0.2993553876876831,
-0.19908015429973602,
-0.27124637365341187,
-0.3478489816188812,
0.6188949346542358,
0.12286773324012756,
-0.19549381732940674,
-0.11867839843034744,
-0.025116082280874252,
0.14422403275966644,
0.5645624399185181,
-0.018912309780716896,
0.43224412202835083,
0.08074038475751877,
-0.5949466824531555,
0.013654449954628944,
0.22884778678417206,
0.8005642890930176,
-0.4022119641304016,
-0.2355903685092926,
-0.49412548542022705,
0.1894204318523407,
-0.26505711674690247,
-0.4676315188407898,
0.30358484387397766,
0.23956134915351868,
-0.3403779864311218,
-0.08044257014989853,
0.8721851706504822,
-0.19969874620437622,
-0.4639120399951935,
0.5075027942657471,
0.5372073650360107,
-0.11963988840579987,
0.2979436218738556,
-0.6204017996788025,
0.1590745747089386,
0.05206237733364105,
-0.24266035854816437,
0.26695120334625244,
0.061699286103248596,
-0.15606184303760529,
0.5090714693069458,
0.3598693013191223,
0.16134485602378845,
0.19870498776435852,
0.7912755012512207,
0.7728629112243652,
-0.3292040228843689,
-0.40698006749153137,
-0.6896010041236877,
0.774071991443634,
-0.07123611122369766,
-0.3388683795928955,
0.7065431475639343,
0.34923237562179565,
0.716222882270813,
0.095213882625103,
0.8314909338951111,
-0.0968775525689125,
0.6238270998001099,
-0.3863110840320587,
0.8851166367530823,
-0.43819865584373474,
0.4031388461589813,
-0.5634214282035828,
-0.9717634916305542,
-0.5453830361366272,
0.9328608512878418,
-0.5923374891281128,
0.4111442565917969,
0.3665711581707001,
0.6366439461708069,
-0.2370121330022812,
0.06909666955471039,
0.26949748396873474,
0.09408044070005417,
0.35519105195999146,
0.2254459708929062,
1.203040599822998,
-0.3175477683544159,
0.1756802797317505,
-0.26214835047721863,
-0.6289607286453247,
0.06318029016256332,
-0.975124180316925,
-0.8214596509933472,
-0.28970691561698914,
-0.32715943455696106,
-0.464133620262146,
0.4508940577507019,
0.9951515793800354,
0.5786592960357666,
-0.765738844871521,
-0.4167247414588928,
-0.16557711362838745,
-0.006387548521161079,
0.03062167949974537,
-0.23919746279716492,
0.20066633820533752,
-0.2676582932472229,
-0.9313153028488159,
0.1571415513753891,
0.021832570433616638,
-0.19433064758777618,
-0.5037888288497925,
-0.1832231879234314,
0.11774587631225586,
0.05948987975716591,
0.15431685745716095,
0.013530882075428963,
-0.6597798466682434,
-0.18341164290905,
-0.2430342137813568,
-0.07140002399682999,
-0.0517636202275753,
0.8560938239097595,
-0.7586728930473328,
0.6498197317123413,
0.5802046060562134,
0.33201301097869873,
0.360066682100296,
-0.0354333333671093,
0.8758425116539001,
-0.6105209589004517,
0.4986802339553833,
0.4213140308856964,
0.4952295124530792,
0.5895782113075256,
-0.19866594672203064,
0.3288383483886719,
0.17709608376026154,
-0.38987472653388977,
-1.0695198774337769,
0.3312597870826721,
-0.9539782404899597,
-0.06323599070310593,
1.099175214767456,
-0.20971554517745972,
0.25512364506721497,
-0.2095365971326828,
-0.13566632568836212,
0.36998459696769714,
-0.4800642132759094,
0.8492951989173889,
0.6816141605377197,
-0.23140521347522736,
0.07854409515857697,
-0.46099376678466797,
0.41886740922927856,
0.6171389222145081,
-0.43036720156669617,
-0.12446146458387375,
0.4559468924999237,
0.5364557504653931,
-0.08099789917469025,
0.7418100833892822,
-0.3710399866104126,
0.20988087356090546,
0.09738478809595108,
0.041888993233442307,
0.3048078715801239,
-0.056252967566251755,
-0.6508838534355164,
0.18898092210292816,
0.2523992359638214,
-0.0842374712228775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06579v1
|
Less is More for Improving Automatic Evaluation of Factual Consistency
| 2024-04-09T19:02:12 | 2024-04-09T19:02:12 |
Tong Wang, Ninad Kulkarni, Yanjun Qi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Assessing the factual consistency of automatically generated texts in
relation to source context is crucial for developing reliable natural language
generation applications. Recent literature proposes AlignScore which uses a
unified alignment model to evaluate factual consistency and substantially
outperforms previous methods across many benchmark tasks. In this paper, we
take a closer look of datasets used in AlignScore and uncover an unexpected
finding: utilizing a smaller number of data points can actually improve
performance. We process the original AlignScore training dataset to remove
noise, augment with robustness-enhanced samples, and utilize a subset
comprising 10\% of the data to train an improved factual consistency evaluation
model, we call LIM-RA (Less Is More for Robust AlignScore). LIM-RA demonstrates
superior performance, consistently outperforming AlignScore and other strong
baselines like ChatGPT across four benchmarks (two utilizing traditional
natural language generation datasets and two focused on large language model
outputs). Our experiments show that LIM-RA achieves the highest score on 24 of
the 33 test datasets, while staying competitive on the rest, establishing the
new state-of-the-art benchmarks.
|
[
-0.31368693709373474,
-0.2736130654811859,
0.453095406293869,
-0.16940729320049286,
-0.03601613640785217,
0.008403926156461239,
-0.4958035349845886,
-0.6294599175453186,
-0.30937060713768005,
0.15460099279880524,
-0.5687478184700012,
-0.38098570704460144,
-0.6092182397842407,
0.2593349516391754,
-0.2809620797634125,
0.9128305315971375,
-0.07649204879999161,
0.05085575580596924,
-0.4225245714187622,
-0.7156679630279541,
-0.8400325775146484,
0.18875670433044434,
-0.2727026045322418,
-0.5061451196670532,
0.1545047014951706,
0.5227724313735962,
0.9821444153785706,
0.7855433821678162,
0.8352783918380737,
0.23561061918735504,
0.19744619727134705,
0.32783418893814087,
-0.658900797367096,
-0.002812360879033804,
0.11481916904449463,
-0.20744143426418304,
-0.08963558077812195,
0.17505617439746857,
0.6033769845962524,
0.5206156373023987,
-0.18261435627937317,
0.4410719871520996,
0.033820874989032745,
0.8692879676818848,
-0.9522815346717834,
0.10798337310552597,
-0.6156070828437805,
-0.1206473857164383,
-0.010648861527442932,
0.21516969799995422,
-0.5868536233901978,
-0.7630442976951599,
0.01457712147384882,
-0.8847216963768005,
0.09968822449445724,
0.2588469386100769,
1.243178367614746,
0.5579356551170349,
-0.31512197852134705,
-0.1643623411655426,
-0.7043159008026123,
0.8647802472114563,
-0.8279601335525513,
0.6403222680091858,
0.10067632794380188,
0.5113663673400879,
0.10004645586013794,
-0.5209664106369019,
-0.7338671088218689,
-0.2729312777519226,
-0.1940196007490158,
0.13135632872581482,
-0.2592812478542328,
-0.2815893590450287,
0.5504691004753113,
0.23327670991420746,
-0.5802757740020752,
0.010082597844302654,
-0.21486376225948334,
-0.29230114817619324,
0.7393978238105774,
0.16533158719539642,
0.10576742887496948,
-0.27128803730010986,
-0.34979018568992615,
-0.4743460416793823,
-0.6391900777816772,
0.13900259137153625,
0.09819994866847992,
0.33042609691619873,
-0.1989489495754242,
0.8038016557693481,
-0.34243372082710266,
0.6870273351669312,
0.23503819108009338,
-0.4821639955043793,
0.2429371178150177,
-0.571454644203186,
-0.29094064235687256,
0.18224254250526428,
0.6954836249351501,
0.4565454125404358,
0.20723070204257965,
0.18864072859287262,
-0.036675650626420975,
0.35558152198791504,
0.17014190554618835,
-0.7856842279434204,
-0.31418266892433167,
-0.14610323309898376,
-0.2515930235385895,
-0.01764514110982418,
0.28166747093200684,
-0.4190450608730316,
-0.4431452453136444,
-0.73520427942276,
0.328715443611145,
-0.8290491104125977,
0.2917444705963135,
0.1074252799153328,
-0.09781301021575928,
0.5127483010292053,
0.45780497789382935,
-0.5380696654319763,
0.35830938816070557,
0.9590907096862793,
0.7688464522361755,
-0.20404231548309326,
-0.022529752925038338,
-0.6321682929992676,
-0.18207906186580658,
-0.5080748796463013,
0.888306736946106,
-0.6810652613639832,
0.06512990593910217,
-0.28792282938957214,
-0.3378540575504303,
-0.09515558928251266,
-0.6948328018188477,
0.8934952020645142,
-0.41130751371383667,
0.29588568210601807,
-0.6739328503608704,
-0.6255344152450562,
0.018509751185774803,
0.11597128212451935,
-0.8604896068572998,
1.3788714408874512,
0.08387736976146698,
-0.7233299016952515,
1.1686862707138062,
-0.35965144634246826,
-0.42050349712371826,
-0.09337785094976425,
-0.28288307785987854,
-0.7742401361465454,
0.09283347427845001,
0.2336665689945221,
-0.11929880827665329,
-0.572364091873169,
0.3732072114944458,
-0.20939823985099792,
-0.4972877502441406,
0.12819598615169525,
-0.5021101832389832,
0.6624589562416077,
0.3652203381061554,
-0.39908862113952637,
-0.36685556173324585,
-0.9971953630447388,
0.1993715912103653,
-0.12718768417835236,
-0.41927215456962585,
-0.42370811104774475,
-0.29884248971939087,
-0.20520199835300446,
0.0265023335814476,
0.11593487113714218,
-0.8219163417816162,
-0.11987745761871338,
-0.2739526927471161,
-0.27908259630203247,
0.2835107445716858,
-0.15712617337703705,
0.6383888721466064,
-0.7554395198822021,
0.17904223501682281,
-0.20759843289852142,
-0.09341873228549957,
-0.020053444430232048,
-0.5158292055130005,
-0.7894459366798401,
-0.5023364424705505,
0.5456463694572449,
0.35014399886131287,
-0.217010036110878,
0.6046741604804993,
-0.6548437476158142,
-0.5017964839935303,
-0.9339998364448547,
0.47873324155807495,
0.49014830589294434,
0.8424622416496277,
0.2941587269306183,
-0.3741162419319153,
-0.910320520401001,
-0.7470433115959167,
-0.5663622617721558,
-0.12088844925165176,
0.08203054219484329,
-0.07417816668748856,
0.46851903200149536,
-0.26315611600875854,
1.464285969734192,
-0.4189663827419281,
-0.2654269337654114,
-0.20383349061012268,
0.393835186958313,
0.1004311814904213,
0.5021965503692627,
0.25277215242385864,
-0.5773669481277466,
-0.9998734593391418,
0.0161674115806818,
-0.625304639339447,
-0.03663645312190056,
-0.1744784712791443,
-0.013903060927987099,
0.2525167465209961,
0.15481561422348022,
-0.6498929262161255,
0.2728007137775421,
0.37456214427948,
0.1026969701051712,
0.363595575094223,
-0.06183680146932602,
0.2337494045495987,
-0.6250449419021606,
0.2907748222351074,
0.01876715011894703,
-0.3898219168186188,
-0.24016185104846954,
-0.15499231219291687,
0.2604931890964508,
-0.06480364501476288,
-0.0711473822593689,
0.36446499824523926,
-0.5914676189422607,
-0.1521003395318985,
-0.07916606217622757,
0.43984872102737427,
0.381530225276947,
0.017484430223703384,
-0.21824337542057037,
0.9107593894004822,
0.2527894377708435,
-0.34817206859588623,
0.2533969283103943,
0.578522801399231,
-0.7504467964172363,
0.7547343373298645,
-0.3875071108341217,
0.009400196373462677,
-0.2618672251701355,
0.31027957797050476,
-1.1311659812927246,
-0.5134865045547485,
-0.23892520368099213,
-0.35752514004707336,
0.3450291156768799,
0.08304601907730103,
-0.3951725959777832,
-0.23592813313007355,
-0.5507537722587585,
0.15878815948963165,
0.8467515110969543,
-0.6935441493988037,
0.20931367576122284,
0.23030200600624084,
0.052735403180122375,
-0.7467861771583557,
-0.7677732110023499,
-0.1561008244752884,
-0.15169845521450043,
-0.8568589091300964,
0.037354424595832825,
0.04563114792108536,
-0.5831409692764282,
-0.0008735866285860538,
-0.38648495078086853,
-0.09278466552495956,
0.02720986120402813,
-0.037137068808078766,
0.17001399397850037,
-0.6384843587875366,
0.24570754170417786,
0.01025050412863493,
-0.14391332864761353,
-0.26529228687286377,
0.10882183164358139,
0.13209176063537598,
-0.16900019347667694,
-0.4755123257637024,
-0.7624853253364563,
-0.0894557312130928,
0.27753493189811707,
-0.018789276480674744,
0.8394307494163513,
0.4813254177570343,
-0.18348944187164307,
0.051390454173088074,
-0.6205919981002808,
-0.16263003647327423,
-0.4372166693210602,
-0.05667489022016525,
-0.08283256739377975,
-0.506130576133728,
0.203912615776062,
-0.12009800970554352,
0.2594545781612396,
0.590954601764679,
0.08361799269914627,
-0.043070562183856964,
1.030053973197937,
0.6280245184898376,
0.0055333757773041725,
0.17092375457286835,
0.08565173298120499,
0.3136787414550781,
-0.6630415916442871,
-0.185237854719162,
-0.4957452416419983,
-0.12496946007013321,
-0.5967926383018494,
-0.43466973304748535,
0.16580155491828918,
-0.05836628004908562,
-0.18782737851142883,
0.6145219802856445,
-0.35263803601264954,
0.609167218208313,
0.25440341234207153,
-0.2180308848619461,
0.6960510015487671,
-0.05821315199136734,
-0.19557498395442963,
-0.47963476181030273,
-0.7904369235038757,
-0.703915536403656,
1.0496948957443237,
0.12735070288181305,
0.8614210486412048,
0.17465172708034515,
0.5259241461753845,
0.2638961672782898,
0.6688631772994995,
-0.5989407896995544,
0.18778176605701447,
-0.18585336208343506,
-0.6379110813140869,
-0.3051730990409851,
-0.4849306344985962,
-0.7229682803153992,
0.02395230531692505,
-0.5227488279342651,
-0.3216104209423065,
0.1543308049440384,
0.23632198572158813,
-0.5581954121589661,
-0.08722256124019623,
-0.9076786041259766,
0.6604544520378113,
-0.08719665557146072,
-0.4803237020969391,
0.17540445923805237,
-0.662339448928833,
0.6402428150177002,
-0.26497992873191833,
0.19189439713954926,
-0.20850564539432526,
0.22960643470287323,
0.5109062790870667,
-0.539422869682312,
0.46332189440727234,
0.01576622761785984,
-0.18727192282676697,
0.46645471453666687,
-0.14415770769119263,
0.6911607980728149,
0.18957668542861938,
-0.41497528553009033,
-0.21406686305999756,
-0.2250671535730362,
-0.25588342547416687,
-0.5539754033088684,
0.7188106775283813,
-0.6268435716629028,
-0.255527138710022,
-0.36031168699264526,
-0.48136216402053833,
-0.2721959948539734,
0.09403868764638901,
0.46954578161239624,
0.45032647252082825,
-0.40366366505622864,
0.39938050508499146,
0.7283247709274292,
-0.05337408557534218,
0.07003097981214523,
0.4973698556423187,
0.2594597339630127,
-0.24014811217784882,
0.7689561247825623,
0.05488717928528786,
0.2394953817129135,
0.5189210176467896,
0.18476292490959167,
-0.5373389720916748,
-0.06089693680405617,
-0.2964993417263031,
0.19483347237110138,
-0.6711916327476501,
-0.5444650650024414,
-0.5034729242324829,
-0.06868905574083328,
-0.763451099395752,
-0.07628539204597473,
-0.7033751010894775,
-0.4738660454750061,
0.21039944887161255,
-0.11389029026031494,
0.3230034410953522,
0.6403449177742004,
-0.27612417936325073,
0.5184110403060913,
-0.5910720825195312,
0.3896309435367584,
0.3170625567436218,
0.34773728251457214,
-0.27773648500442505,
-0.6278493404388428,
-0.19121035933494568,
0.11509191244840622,
-0.24684655666351318,
-0.48108720779418945,
0.1744460016489029,
0.4711686968803406,
0.32680371403694153,
0.3636503219604492,
0.33376485109329224,
0.9105196595191956,
-0.5073448419570923,
0.40745794773101807,
0.2836851179599762,
-0.908344566822052,
0.1480913758277893,
-0.046114061027765274,
0.4837498366832733,
1.2294493913650513,
0.08874203264713287,
-0.28273001313209534,
-0.3532639443874359,
-0.680701494216919,
-0.6148253679275513,
0.6425974369049072,
0.474587619304657,
-0.14638961851596832,
0.2818239629268646,
0.11876372247934341,
0.5023882389068604,
0.1943960338830948,
-0.6677111983299255,
-0.32502326369285583,
-0.022654743865132332,
-0.6798635125160217,
0.023983394727110863,
-0.0682096928358078,
-0.18725475668907166,
-0.18154199421405792,
0.6536093950271606,
-0.10814394056797028,
0.05869798734784126,
0.15121357142925262,
-0.4101533591747284,
-0.20016416907310486,
0.4448317587375641,
0.6003053784370422,
0.6037896275520325,
-0.2780289053916931,
0.1012672409415245,
0.4392825961112976,
-0.4078785479068756,
0.10945624113082886,
0.19109833240509033,
-0.3312312662601471,
0.26028600335121155,
0.3873472511768341,
0.8033666014671326,
0.28087490797042847,
-0.7670655250549316,
0.6230769157409668,
-0.17321641743183136,
0.03176996856927872,
-0.3721521198749542,
0.25703439116477966,
-0.19981929659843445,
-0.031330905854701996,
0.27481454610824585,
0.4141923487186432,
0.1103769987821579,
-0.3803139925003052,
0.597661554813385,
0.40198755264282227,
-0.5302180647850037,
-0.14772407710552216,
0.5421390533447266,
0.030667848885059357,
0.10531055927276611,
0.3860071003437042,
-0.20332011580467224,
-0.14776228368282318,
0.47236770391464233,
0.373573899269104,
0.36892372369766235,
0.10312651097774506,
0.3653060495853424,
0.6732271909713745,
0.4834127426147461,
-0.3788354992866516,
-0.02978733740746975,
-0.14676247537136078,
-0.6147263646125793,
-0.6165185570716858,
-0.45611491799354553,
-0.4654404819011688,
0.07343321293592453,
-0.6894257068634033,
0.5806694626808167,
-0.38208773732185364,
-0.2071857899427414,
-0.12077502906322479,
0.2719308137893677,
-0.6038690209388733,
0.5162809491157532,
0.05081520974636078,
0.8379408717155457,
-0.9987742304801941,
0.5136788487434387,
0.595129132270813,
-0.1569414734840393,
-1.0232346057891846,
0.05542688071727753,
0.2158389836549759,
-0.6874092221260071,
0.4787583351135254,
0.37355348467826843,
-0.14258524775505066,
-0.3613177239894867,
-0.65580815076828,
-1.137648344039917,
1.1344012022018433,
0.6791077852249146,
-0.631665825843811,
0.3531419634819031,
0.17024968564510345,
0.6580603122711182,
-0.43191996216773987,
0.20091646909713745,
0.8891489505767822,
0.6965696215629578,
0.11320740729570389,
-0.7193414568901062,
0.18952679634094238,
-0.029303230345249176,
-0.2739305794239044,
0.1578313708305359,
-0.6614696383476257,
0.5599790215492249,
-0.3560568690299988,
-0.6176646947860718,
0.2931225895881653,
0.7465437054634094,
0.517979085445404,
0.5212353467941284,
0.30672281980514526,
0.7218404412269592,
1.1826201677322388,
-0.16187109053134918,
1.1157972812652588,
-0.10389804095029831,
0.45588141679763794,
1.4700028896331787,
-0.7888872623443604,
0.6489062905311584,
0.2544061243534088,
0.120880126953125,
0.6119105219841003,
0.18548625707626343,
-0.22531984746456146,
0.4058223366737366,
-0.2075430005788803,
-0.021643752232193947,
-0.21037015318870544,
-0.138403058052063,
-0.2716374695301056,
0.4809166193008423,
-0.26811477541923523,
0.054045118391513824,
-0.4220857620239258,
-0.17212051153182983,
0.24615904688835144,
0.6383522748947144,
0.19468069076538086,
0.7692322731018066,
-0.14231985807418823,
-0.8052968382835388,
0.6434062719345093,
-0.07967328280210495,
0.46287810802459717,
-0.4606149196624756,
0.021492594853043556,
-0.20337846875190735,
0.23542135953903198,
-0.23760436475276947,
-0.45731258392333984,
0.2425028681755066,
0.3641975224018097,
-0.041144393384456635,
-0.07697734981775284,
0.7019707560539246,
-0.22157610952854156,
-0.416509747505188,
0.044160302728414536,
0.21447937190532684,
-0.23224519193172455,
0.3807435631752014,
-0.48527777194976807,
0.06530095636844635,
-0.050309404730796814,
0.13048315048217773,
0.10797089338302612,
0.5701711177825928,
0.09133307635784149,
0.531512975692749,
0.6076371669769287,
-0.09725003689527512,
0.18430739641189575,
-0.03433549031615257,
0.6318258047103882,
-0.5195264220237732,
-0.12263195216655731,
-0.5503905415534973,
0.5836285948753357,
-0.48795390129089355,
-0.5537962913513184,
0.9815400838851929,
0.9458491802215576,
0.7743979096412659,
0.20166350901126862,
0.8592445850372314,
-0.2515331208705902,
0.8072189092636108,
-0.5455505847930908,
0.5059911608695984,
-0.37810033559799194,
0.399046927690506,
-0.2898004949092865,
-0.9551119804382324,
-0.23781247437000275,
0.6210489869117737,
-0.2903080880641937,
-0.002577517880126834,
0.8102105259895325,
0.5760300159454346,
-0.23737777769565582,
0.03399726748466492,
0.36322319507598877,
0.19049660861492157,
0.131749227643013,
0.16653002798557281,
0.7669462561607361,
-0.8360705375671387,
0.5366435647010803,
-0.3283742666244507,
-0.02282380685210228,
-0.12099169939756393,
-0.8994899392127991,
-0.5424314737319946,
-0.1805357187986374,
-0.4039757549762726,
-0.21178409457206726,
-0.022933989763259888,
0.8766158819198608,
0.5518078804016113,
-0.9697089195251465,
-0.044780053198337555,
-0.246149480342865,
0.06791839748620987,
-0.1408562809228897,
-0.2421180158853531,
0.04660705849528313,
-0.5145969986915588,
-0.5943953990936279,
0.3937409222126007,
0.10819843411445618,
-0.1474670022726059,
0.2872644066810608,
-0.23703578114509583,
-0.1685236692428589,
0.24312232434749603,
0.26372361183166504,
0.38864076137542725,
-0.19194436073303223,
-0.4762497544288635,
0.13959579169750214,
-0.5018125772476196,
0.4625319838523865,
0.702229917049408,
-0.8049556612968445,
0.3844594657421112,
0.5098335146903992,
0.7645577192306519,
0.4126679599285126,
0.5732760429382324,
0.6900783181190491,
-0.793567419052124,
0.09423620998859406,
0.08192366361618042,
0.23122026026248932,
0.7831319570541382,
-0.2752363383769989,
0.5161972641944885,
0.027422169223427773,
-0.3227754533290863,
-0.8076394200325012,
0.19690532982349396,
-0.9746260046958923,
0.15018795430660248,
1.0682684183120728,
-0.026585185900330544,
-0.19264720380306244,
-0.16850869357585907,
-0.09620703756809235,
0.3302883803844452,
-0.6501896381378174,
0.7279788255691528,
0.4385744035243988,
-0.15701229870319366,
0.1753397285938263,
-0.3710278272628784,
0.757392942905426,
0.7452784776687622,
-0.7164474725723267,
0.1520758718252182,
0.6462432146072388,
0.31672608852386475,
0.3223726451396942,
0.37843164801597595,
-0.14820244908332825,
0.3337271809577942,
-0.0035422369837760925,
-0.2904949486255646,
0.36005157232284546,
-0.22486262023448944,
-0.31503331661224365,
-0.07593614608049393,
0.17174804210662842,
0.2612243592739105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07242v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07242v1
|
Sandwich attack: Multi-language Mixture Adaptive Attack on LLMs
| 2024-04-09T18:29:42 | 2024-04-09T18:29:42 |
Bibek Upadhayay, Vahid Behzadan
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly being developed and applied,
but their widespread use faces challenges. These include aligning LLMs'
responses with human values to prevent harmful outputs, which is addressed
through safety training methods. Even so, bad actors and malicious users have
succeeded in attempts to manipulate the LLMs to generate misaligned responses
for harmful questions such as methods to create a bomb in school labs, recipes
for harmful drugs, and ways to evade privacy rights. Another challenge is the
multilingual capabilities of LLMs, which enable the model to understand and
respond in multiple languages. Consequently, attackers exploit the unbalanced
pre-training datasets of LLMs in different languages and the comparatively
lower model performance in low-resource languages than high-resource ones. As a
result, attackers use a low-resource languages to intentionally manipulate the
model to create harmful responses. Many of the similar attack vectors have been
patched by model providers, making the LLMs more robust against language-based
manipulation. In this paper, we introduce a new black-box attack vector called
the \emph{Sandwich attack}: a multi-language mixture attack, which manipulates
state-of-the-art LLMs into generating harmful and misaligned responses. Our
experiments with five different models, namely Google's Bard, Gemini Pro,
LLaMA-2-70-B-Chat, GPT-3.5-Turbo, GPT-4, and Claude-3-OPUS, show that this
attack vector can be used by adversaries to generate harmful responses and
elicit misaligned responses from these models. By detailing both the mechanism
and impact of the Sandwich attack, this paper aims to guide future research and
development towards more secure and resilient LLMs, ensuring they serve the
public good while minimizing potential for misuse.
|
[
-0.3511176109313965,
-1.2355653047561646,
0.3020307421684265,
0.12776702642440796,
-0.08874747902154922,
0.5034384727478027,
-0.02487080544233322,
-0.6048601269721985,
0.28426462411880493,
0.7581393122673035,
-0.40011289715766907,
-0.07512322813272476,
-0.8205628395080566,
-0.021315980702638626,
-0.5183886885643005,
0.8176096677780151,
0.24837052822113037,
0.1813441812992096,
-0.059927284717559814,
0.0028173746541142464,
-0.4401521682739258,
-0.8140862584114075,
-0.6078498959541321,
-0.14126074314117432,
0.5775372385978699,
0.12638092041015625,
0.5801043510437012,
0.15571247041225433,
0.5292861461639404,
0.3921158015727997,
0.0936327576637268,
-0.15663117170333862,
-0.6735912561416626,
0.1904909759759903,
-0.23199380934238434,
-0.4756148159503937,
-0.5051712989807129,
-0.12471745908260345,
0.4666265547275543,
0.5180779695510864,
-0.13432087004184723,
-0.051818832755088806,
0.00010405959619674832,
0.4566779136657715,
-0.807395339012146,
-0.3687967360019684,
-0.9969909191131592,
-0.18871305882930756,
-0.5095088481903076,
0.17395728826522827,
-0.4169362187385559,
-0.0047715045511722565,
-0.21853980422019958,
-0.31524038314819336,
-0.09293007850646973,
0.1346859335899353,
0.4797604978084564,
0.1460064947605133,
-0.39663878083229065,
-0.293906033039093,
-0.546443521976471,
0.8612903356552124,
-0.7586473822593689,
0.1497730016708374,
0.0711502805352211,
0.4328729510307312,
-0.7040123343467712,
-0.35380321741104126,
-0.6811752319335938,
0.006730298046022654,
0.07836788892745972,
0.23088590800762177,
-0.36004602909088135,
-0.13881486654281616,
-0.01382390595972538,
0.20324832201004028,
-0.4791548550128937,
0.49909526109695435,
-0.40013280510902405,
-0.16359363496303558,
0.716376543045044,
0.21869590878486633,
0.4954812526702881,
-0.19790934026241302,
-0.8394358158111572,
-0.16200608015060425,
-0.660647988319397,
0.12501607835292816,
0.4454173147678375,
0.21064895391464233,
-0.440881609916687,
0.6058433055877686,
0.1944424957036972,
0.9395942687988281,
0.07360740005970001,
-0.39256078004837036,
-0.04484626278281212,
-0.06746111810207367,
-0.26394131779670715,
0.2222737818956375,
0.8783398270606995,
0.37318331003189087,
0.12080121785402298,
0.016719141975045204,
-0.2379215955734253,
0.26235121488571167,
0.43003425002098083,
-0.41226768493652344,
0.0099143385887146,
0.3587999939918518,
-0.14114294946193695,
-0.46577194333076477,
-0.023688163608312607,
-1.0064369440078735,
-0.5744827389717102,
0.4223843514919281,
0.237912118434906,
-0.4230709969997406,
-0.20784910023212433,
0.4588613510131836,
-0.17254376411437988,
0.3244050443172455,
0.14605361223220825,
-0.7192301154136658,
0.45296332240104675,
0.7499826550483704,
0.540179431438446,
-0.2948945164680481,
-0.2527182698249817,
-0.3520498275756836,
0.6772028803825378,
-0.0665682703256607,
0.9361637234687805,
-0.7680333256721497,
-0.6852617859840393,
-0.1509997546672821,
-0.1008923277258873,
-0.22246088087558746,
-0.4451541006565094,
0.3841664791107178,
-0.5629908442497253,
0.4394772946834564,
-0.09363115578889847,
-0.4235135316848755,
-0.2647213637828827,
0.5813392400741577,
-0.6468138694763184,
0.6838637590408325,
-0.06375228613615036,
-0.9032695293426514,
-0.3274238705635071,
-0.5817167162895203,
-0.492542564868927,
-0.10644081979990005,
-0.09757766127586365,
-0.2531468868255615,
0.18639814853668213,
0.2795664072036743,
0.5025643706321716,
-0.4914175868034363,
-0.1532338559627533,
-0.6232196092605591,
-0.13445863127708435,
0.7686553597450256,
-0.281218945980072,
0.7866047620773315,
0.21453304588794708,
0.09194143116474152,
0.054663676768541336,
-0.829730749130249,
-0.20174792408943176,
0.5490729212760925,
-0.346493124961853,
-0.5581371784210205,
0.16987189650535583,
-0.14766138792037964,
0.2428802102804184,
0.3769699037075043,
-0.5903395414352417,
-0.10071458667516708,
-0.5279272198677063,
0.3787284791469574,
1.0349478721618652,
0.24933834373950958,
0.21154342591762543,
-0.5478596091270447,
0.6816365718841553,
-0.01786511018872261,
0.28727731108665466,
-0.11842041462659836,
-0.4124893546104431,
-0.3458358645439148,
-0.3870472013950348,
0.1690039485692978,
0.8647331595420837,
-0.7402350902557373,
0.117882139980793,
0.04605865478515625,
-0.6090789437294006,
-0.6331124901771545,
0.14759816229343414,
0.41690200567245483,
0.4876571297645569,
0.20963552594184875,
-0.4964286684989929,
-0.37030908465385437,
-0.9190534353256226,
-0.4290305972099304,
-0.13896392285823822,
0.06916123628616333,
0.07812909781932831,
0.27553313970565796,
-0.3889751732349396,
0.497243732213974,
-0.5561167001724243,
0.10141666978597641,
-0.2336217314004898,
-0.16266755759716034,
-0.029960479587316513,
0.47013208270072937,
0.7711010575294495,
-0.7195528149604797,
-0.4529741406440735,
-0.12274006009101868,
-0.5616222023963928,
-0.17143921554088593,
-0.10229932516813278,
-0.11407950520515442,
-0.10587899386882782,
0.35203996300697327,
-0.32843485474586487,
-0.28491541743278503,
0.7487292289733887,
-0.07507111877202988,
0.5892876982688904,
0.26660194993019104,
0.005125836469233036,
-1.2978932857513428,
-0.2310628443956375,
-0.028889209032058716,
-0.11714541167020798,
-0.8108512163162231,
0.31740498542785645,
0.10077838599681854,
-0.1372624933719635,
-0.8169212341308594,
0.5254871845245361,
-0.24287284910678864,
0.04492279142141342,
-0.38919585943222046,
0.03639526665210724,
0.03236266225576401,
0.24597974121570587,
-0.43171530961990356,
0.5869253873825073,
0.6292687654495239,
-0.4652838706970215,
0.6222885251045227,
-0.06308230757713318,
-0.17891724407672882,
0.884507417678833,
-0.6046439409255981,
0.25862109661102295,
-0.12731388211250305,
0.22789470851421356,
-0.9533358812332153,
-0.2923292815685272,
0.5486477017402649,
-0.38911938667297363,
0.47167709469795227,
0.08698900043964386,
-0.3110892176628113,
-0.29301154613494873,
-0.6398236751556396,
0.33953770995140076,
0.24598625302314758,
-0.3756175637245178,
0.7285495400428772,
0.7182198762893677,
-0.2103213369846344,
-0.8394052982330322,
-0.7682678699493408,
0.16366612911224365,
-0.4044974744319916,
-0.8341800570487976,
0.18884114921092987,
-0.36931881308555603,
-0.43805965781211853,
-0.1638908088207245,
-0.12304812669754028,
0.0003738893719855696,
0.5657748579978943,
0.06567741185426712,
0.2226163148880005,
0.04635176807641983,
-0.40262916684150696,
-0.12903530895709991,
-0.04622757062315941,
0.34614691138267517,
-0.05317738652229309,
0.6751090884208679,
0.20198075473308563,
-0.6088340878486633,
-0.000866453570779413,
0.5910066962242126,
0.6183054447174072,
-0.23303304612636566,
0.6459420919418335,
0.5692208409309387,
-0.2573133111000061,
-0.027698926627635956,
-0.6466315388679504,
-0.113515704870224,
-0.5557643175125122,
0.5137266516685486,
-0.3382610082626343,
-0.9938197731971741,
0.5930925607681274,
-0.06482473760843277,
0.061229534447193146,
0.28382304310798645,
0.6814136505126953,
-0.16984659433364868,
0.8013519644737244,
0.3973504900932312,
-0.31260591745376587,
0.4455629289150238,
0.3298250436782837,
0.14189359545707703,
-0.8991721272468567,
-0.4017832577228546,
-0.4909628629684448,
-0.3662279546260834,
-0.5316769480705261,
-0.36919090151786804,
0.45049500465393066,
-0.22926434874534607,
-0.14551982283592224,
0.08529285341501236,
-0.16775977611541748,
0.5372966527938843,
0.31915727257728577,
-0.07190192490816116,
-0.00958662573248148,
-0.013540910556912422,
-0.18177244067192078,
0.12131556123495102,
-0.6233935952186584,
-0.2760770320892334,
1.0796372890472412,
0.38429659605026245,
1.2897011041641235,
0.390206515789032,
0.6070061326026917,
0.2910781502723694,
-0.040462758392095566,
-0.41124022006988525,
0.6197565197944641,
-0.12913258373737335,
-0.6085200309753418,
0.20433765649795532,
-0.3635767698287964,
-0.9620490074157715,
0.45845314860343933,
-0.4247746765613556,
-0.6536476016044617,
0.026849189773201942,
-0.03879880532622337,
-0.3279808759689331,
0.46827274560928345,
-0.9470187425613403,
0.5920325517654419,
-0.8589242696762085,
-0.2728255093097687,
-0.08899493515491486,
-0.6527872681617737,
0.6547679901123047,
-0.5246598720550537,
0.5799002051353455,
-0.15115463733673096,
-0.11978249251842499,
0.5568749904632568,
0.13743893802165985,
1.2625023126602173,
0.09098436683416367,
-0.30388975143432617,
-0.1713627725839615,
0.31659841537475586,
0.6038753390312195,
-0.01458998117595911,
0.1484784483909607,
0.22438378632068634,
-0.24882397055625916,
-0.7831740975379944,
-0.5110630393028259,
0.818789541721344,
-0.759118378162384,
-0.9991291761398315,
-0.5542625188827515,
-0.487880140542984,
-0.2263796031475067,
0.08284108340740204,
0.0426565445959568,
-0.07852502167224884,
-0.3148123323917389,
-0.15301890671253204,
0.7627689242362976,
-0.5236832499504089,
0.42475172877311707,
0.8928126692771912,
-0.08357603847980499,
-0.4721156358718872,
0.9151926636695862,
-0.1954398900270462,
0.6812453866004944,
0.49028173089027405,
0.058172859251499176,
0.06443522125482559,
-0.6506967544555664,
-0.26930809020996094,
0.0693851187825203,
-0.4156460762023926,
-0.3101862668991089,
-0.6131125688552856,
-0.1323050558567047,
-0.5370465517044067,
-0.2681342661380768,
-0.30758795142173767,
-0.376045823097229,
0.04315821826457977,
0.016693973913788795,
0.05034691467881203,
0.6746052503585815,
0.08679788559675217,
0.5882274508476257,
-0.7747706770896912,
0.35100027918815613,
0.4698810577392578,
0.1285879760980606,
-0.1489906758069992,
-0.23407863080501556,
-0.21434442698955536,
-0.0366959311068058,
-0.4282092750072479,
-1.3436517715454102,
0.16531091928482056,
-0.12533454596996307,
0.7218660712242126,
0.39762693643569946,
-0.08443847298622131,
0.3481557071208954,
-0.4102226495742798,
0.886440098285675,
0.37124696373939514,
-0.7088327407836914,
0.3411499261856079,
-0.27625030279159546,
0.266196608543396,
0.12545990943908691,
0.2763104736804962,
-0.6334227919578552,
-0.591637372970581,
-0.6119457483291626,
-0.8331241011619568,
0.5792959332466125,
-0.12821155786514282,
0.22389134764671326,
-0.03783469274640083,
0.1053253784775734,
0.09395816177129745,
0.3125334084033966,
-0.9868015050888062,
-0.3585159182548523,
-0.20706616342067719,
-0.10217483341693878,
0.11780188977718353,
-0.5474900007247925,
-0.3572026491165161,
0.17108401656150818,
0.7667189836502075,
0.23060835897922516,
0.12559442222118378,
-0.38189995288848877,
-0.1451071947813034,
-0.14206305146217346,
0.5766698122024536,
0.6235014796257019,
0.1770939975976944,
-0.12315429747104645,
0.3047664165496826,
0.2558259069919586,
-0.45621606707572937,
0.26883819699287415,
0.10203022509813309,
-0.12453965842723846,
-0.6019898653030396,
0.3577902913093567,
0.538604736328125,
0.530956506729126,
-0.8626111149787903,
0.3558211028575897,
-0.2186686247587204,
0.14332473278045654,
-0.18072573840618134,
0.33487334847450256,
0.09554855525493622,
0.25798359513282776,
0.19449827075004578,
0.13920573890209198,
-0.15610456466674805,
-0.4693784713745117,
-0.0559583343565464,
0.8147774934768677,
-0.11525169014930725,
-0.2984614372253418,
0.44554564356803894,
0.19939269125461578,
-0.1595461666584015,
0.033125780522823334,
0.03096023015677929,
-0.6462486982345581,
0.34311434626579285,
1.028948426246643,
0.6144350171089172,
-0.7318326830863953,
-0.004723397083580494,
-0.1217726320028305,
0.7618537545204163,
0.14433278143405914,
0.17799502611160278,
0.48420247435569763,
-1.0075321197509766,
-0.2687380611896515,
-0.5279363989830017,
-0.40849828720092773,
0.4058261811733246,
-0.4715704917907715,
-0.044573135673999786,
-0.732566237449646,
0.0027436302043497562,
-0.028062330558896065,
-0.25013941526412964,
-0.25338101387023926,
-0.031227411702275276,
0.38995036482810974,
0.632805347442627,
-0.9265453815460205,
0.6477898955345154,
0.9176279306411743,
-0.1144622266292572,
-0.1654103696346283,
-0.17645743489265442,
0.34669676423072815,
-0.9424513578414917,
-0.018814576789736748,
-0.25302451848983765,
-0.057863060384988785,
-0.4057989716529846,
-0.5232749581336975,
-0.9755933880805969,
0.648215115070343,
0.6483446359634399,
-0.5637009143829346,
0.2710835933685303,
0.3852071464061737,
0.11380834877490997,
-0.3599369525909424,
-0.1306576430797577,
0.5890894532203674,
0.5731348395347595,
-0.1817203313112259,
-0.5833103060722351,
0.11706363409757614,
-0.2597503662109375,
-0.09111429005861282,
0.23293930292129517,
-0.8335458040237427,
1.1417557001113892,
0.1464419662952423,
-0.1405368596315384,
-0.3929087221622467,
0.4549824893474579,
0.3163350522518158,
0.09849771112203598,
0.40185514092445374,
0.7351130843162537,
0.7648943662643433,
0.11019627004861832,
1.2756637334823608,
-0.1723450869321823,
-0.15276964008808136,
1.1678922176361084,
-0.4983022212982178,
0.8279590010643005,
0.5391910076141357,
-0.03762763366103172,
0.38481947779655457,
0.541991114616394,
-0.11848678439855576,
0.5623457431793213,
0.2062324583530426,
-0.3310021758079529,
-0.0726901963353157,
0.1968623697757721,
-0.4013168513774872,
0.5226454138755798,
0.6205404996871948,
-0.08541765809059143,
-0.273859441280365,
0.23105596005916595,
0.21909810602664948,
0.2928956151008606,
-0.26659947633743286,
0.8297997713088989,
0.13435176014900208,
-0.1809970736503601,
0.5077807307243347,
0.5487051010131836,
0.8401870727539062,
-0.8641911149024963,
0.42796289920806885,
0.06830901652574539,
0.03318321332335472,
-0.08142201602458954,
-0.46260640025138855,
0.03574230521917343,
0.06836666911840439,
-0.21816569566726685,
0.22994951903820038,
0.9094240069389343,
-0.31072455644607544,
-0.6799062490463257,
0.5200754404067993,
0.6835293173789978,
-0.25277066230773926,
0.088417649269104,
-1.1280407905578613,
0.40549027919769287,
0.08440417051315308,
-0.0800575315952301,
0.7390854358673096,
0.12590143084526062,
0.013220303691923618,
0.6672723293304443,
0.690701425075531,
0.2659783959388733,
0.3942631781101227,
-0.15214930474758148,
0.9075331687927246,
-0.6490034461021423,
-0.5529648661613464,
-1.0508915185928345,
0.21024230122566223,
-0.17235396802425385,
0.22108718752861023,
0.9523820877075195,
0.45621731877326965,
1.1792117357254028,
-0.00693316338583827,
1.0438337326049805,
0.04333760216832161,
0.4483099579811096,
-0.648834228515625,
0.546919584274292,
-0.3498486578464508,
0.6228156089782715,
-0.3400720953941345,
-0.7359310984611511,
-0.19295597076416016,
0.25928622484207153,
-0.32132717967033386,
-0.06942491233348846,
0.6103553771972656,
0.8602598309516907,
-0.21030929684638977,
-0.045353662222623825,
0.15349332988262177,
0.49840983748435974,
0.5345916152000427,
0.7536386251449585,
0.9594957232475281,
-0.17319972813129425,
0.28687748312950134,
-0.18712946772575378,
-0.2053840309381485,
-0.17748937010765076,
-0.7957961559295654,
-1.0060399770736694,
-0.26640695333480835,
-0.12844553589820862,
-0.25264444947242737,
0.18323782086372375,
0.8457047939300537,
0.41273385286331177,
-0.8408940434455872,
-0.4930654764175415,
0.6740018129348755,
0.312898725271225,
-0.16589508950710297,
-0.16538721323013306,
0.06018446013331413,
-0.2522524297237396,
-0.541905403137207,
0.7828561067581177,
0.30303141474723816,
0.32165610790252686,
-0.37573760747909546,
0.016120553016662598,
-0.4119987487792969,
0.43765789270401,
0.46951478719711304,
0.3250902593135834,
-0.6087257266044617,
-0.16466477513313293,
-0.36651527881622314,
-0.09914526343345642,
-0.025152990594506264,
0.7414875626564026,
-0.45484256744384766,
0.4780353903770447,
0.11739785969257355,
0.9304660558700562,
0.13511529564857483,
-0.09121778607368469,
0.6332664489746094,
-1.0051430463790894,
0.3765370845794678,
0.15318098664283752,
0.4697432219982147,
0.5877216458320618,
-0.4446142017841339,
0.11172453314065933,
0.2010776698589325,
-0.1429850459098816,
-0.9029771685600281,
0.4819585084915161,
-1.0280407667160034,
-0.7653836011886597,
1.0250813961029053,
0.06800892949104309,
-0.7164862155914307,
-0.13331763446331024,
-0.12768863141536713,
-0.11372711509466171,
-0.4346449077129364,
1.0298845767974854,
0.6369315385818481,
0.13498134911060333,
0.12672491371631622,
-0.555061936378479,
0.2536095380783081,
0.371088445186615,
-0.8049812316894531,
-0.11028668284416199,
0.46792590618133545,
0.39047783613204956,
0.12595146894454956,
0.38390839099884033,
-0.28237196803092957,
0.13246239721775055,
-0.28256991505622864,
-0.09223000705242157,
-0.10576353967189789,
-0.04190656915307045,
-0.3610432744026184,
0.5651869773864746,
-0.04875293746590614,
-0.20530061423778534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06512v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06512v1
|
InternLM-XComposer2-4KHD: A Pioneering Large Vision-Language Model Handling Resolutions from 336 Pixels to 4K HD
| 2024-04-09T17:59:32 | 2024-04-09T17:59:32 |
Xiaoyi Dong, Pan Zhang, Yuhang Zang, Yuhang Cao, Bin Wang, Linke Ouyang, Songyang Zhang, Haodong Duan, Wenwei Zhang, Yining Li, Hang Yan, Yang Gao, Zhe Chen, Xinyue Zhang, Wei Li, Jingwen Li, Wenhai Wang, Kai Chen, Conghui He, Xingcheng Zhang, Jifeng Dai, Yu Qiao, Dahua Lin, Jiaqi Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The Large Vision-Language Model (LVLM) field has seen significant
advancements, yet its progression has been hindered by challenges in
comprehending fine-grained visual content due to limited resolution. Recent
efforts have aimed to enhance the high-resolution understanding capabilities of
LVLMs, yet they remain capped at approximately 1500 x 1500 pixels and
constrained to a relatively narrow resolution range. This paper represents
InternLM-XComposer2-4KHD, a groundbreaking exploration into elevating LVLM
resolution capabilities up to 4K HD (3840 x 1600) and beyond. Concurrently,
considering the ultra-high resolution may not be necessary in all scenarios, it
supports a wide range of diverse resolutions from 336 pixels to 4K standard,
significantly broadening its scope of applicability. Specifically, this
research advances the patch division paradigm by introducing a novel extension:
dynamic resolution with automatic patch configuration. It maintains the
training image aspect ratios while automatically varying patch counts and
configuring layouts based on a pre-trained Vision Transformer (ViT) (336 x
336), leading to dynamic training resolution from 336 pixels to 4K standard.
Our research demonstrates that scaling training resolution up to 4K HD leads to
consistent performance enhancements without hitting the ceiling of potential
improvements. InternLM-XComposer2-4KHD shows superb capability that matches or
even surpasses GPT-4V and Gemini Pro in 10 of the 16 benchmarks. The
InternLM-XComposer2-4KHD model series with 7B parameters are publicly available
at https://github.com/InternLM/InternLM-XComposer.
|
[
-0.6968600153923035,
-0.2800047695636749,
0.14891010522842407,
0.05528442561626434,
-0.40238866209983826,
0.4148785471916199,
0.015443725511431694,
-0.8223462700843811,
-0.07557940483093262,
0.41869327425956726,
-0.3575529456138611,
-0.05410655587911606,
-0.41504955291748047,
-0.10288634896278381,
-0.3082260191440582,
0.5761745572090149,
-0.22171957790851593,
-0.11908573657274246,
-0.169917032122612,
-0.3532533347606659,
-0.5686949491500854,
-0.5906105041503906,
-0.477262407541275,
-0.04031683877110481,
0.5827013850212097,
0.5013667941093445,
0.5036237239837646,
1.062746286392212,
0.9766355156898499,
0.4271508455276489,
-0.026560422033071518,
0.22640857100486755,
-0.4236605763435364,
-0.04183703288435936,
0.20036837458610535,
-0.4105031192302704,
-0.706455647945404,
-0.0649498701095581,
1.0213236808776855,
0.14070776104927063,
-0.15672366321086884,
0.08075638115406036,
0.07674551755189896,
0.9770970344543457,
-0.3743106722831726,
0.10462532192468643,
-0.6529416441917419,
0.05301881954073906,
-0.24775491654872894,
0.05329526588320732,
-0.08592340350151062,
0.07442884147167206,
-0.015619966201484203,
-0.6529893279075623,
0.38321924209594727,
0.174127995967865,
0.9896632432937622,
0.4080031216144562,
-0.42540833353996277,
0.15603283047676086,
-0.6376627683639526,
0.5603151321411133,
-0.3215050995349884,
0.6464299559593201,
0.027423052117228508,
0.8689829111099243,
0.2622354030609131,
-1.0841991901397705,
-0.39078792929649353,
-0.07773149758577347,
0.11583063006401062,
0.050812236964702606,
-0.20562411844730377,
0.17005407810211182,
0.44490453600883484,
0.7054253816604614,
-0.5258782505989075,
0.22375193238258362,
-0.5111097097396851,
-0.17767071723937988,
0.45412829518318176,
0.38534924387931824,
-0.14156699180603027,
0.05684481933712959,
-0.4643028676509857,
-0.012672052718698978,
-0.7089939713478088,
0.2180004119873047,
0.06950362026691437,
-0.27208593487739563,
-0.14688415825366974,
0.24677595496177673,
-0.1605125218629837,
0.8558545708656311,
0.07250261306762695,
0.08734701573848724,
0.2864328622817993,
-0.4244493544101715,
-0.18542197346687317,
-0.32786014676094055,
0.22698329389095306,
0.4713200330734253,
-0.2718683183193207,
0.2634226381778717,
-0.30653631687164307,
0.23812995851039886,
0.5205800533294678,
-0.7514379024505615,
-0.2614501118659973,
0.016699299216270447,
-0.5213754773139954,
-0.2488899528980255,
-0.3600146174430847,
-0.9518519043922424,
-0.3443945348262787,
-0.625879168510437,
0.371035635471344,
-0.22869646549224854,
-0.2913762927055359,
-0.09656640887260437,
0.12531518936157227,
0.19020791351795197,
0.4556170105934143,
-0.7175275683403015,
0.11578458547592163,
0.4690142273902893,
0.7325289845466614,
-0.3523293137550354,
-0.07114078849554062,
-0.34989380836486816,
-0.06265690177679062,
-0.49075451493263245,
0.5210827589035034,
-0.2288592904806137,
-0.180000901222229,
0.1828954815864563,
-0.1549183428287506,
0.558792233467102,
-0.700305163860321,
0.4583113193511963,
-0.7163020968437195,
-0.32218480110168457,
-0.13772153854370117,
-0.1801169365644455,
-0.08418485522270203,
0.7273946404457092,
-0.615800142288208,
0.9803279638290405,
0.4890144467353821,
-0.4906476140022278,
0.2575848400592804,
-0.48855331540107727,
0.20278441905975342,
0.5301241278648376,
-0.25709542632102966,
-0.5987619757652283,
0.12250691652297974,
-0.17438159883022308,
-0.004048557486385107,
-0.2580329477787018,
-0.10151179134845734,
0.05815049633383751,
-0.08801533281803131,
0.2626373767852783,
-0.6254810690879822,
0.05382515490055084,
0.0692247748374939,
-0.15375006198883057,
0.3365575075149536,
-0.9589133858680725,
0.011494194157421589,
0.0031820612493902445,
-0.4861660897731781,
-0.0894058346748352,
-0.1856212317943573,
-0.1352023482322693,
0.6357337236404419,
0.5369488000869751,
-0.8768815994262695,
0.11578361690044403,
-0.2952635884284973,
0.48022374510765076,
0.8576819896697998,
-0.529649019241333,
0.3285701870918274,
-0.18950602412223816,
0.4967159032821655,
-0.16059021651744843,
0.5975537300109863,
-0.5386710166931152,
-0.22570332884788513,
-1.0840065479278564,
-0.5949192047119141,
0.020837046205997467,
0.14023412764072418,
-0.7860441207885742,
0.08465199917554855,
-0.37813785672187805,
-0.5729474425315857,
-0.32685017585754395,
0.08713584393262863,
0.24634602665901184,
0.3875826299190521,
0.4651821255683899,
-0.18613968789577484,
-0.809678316116333,
-0.9571036100387573,
0.12836964428424835,
-0.005027831997722387,
0.12616696953773499,
0.38494786620140076,
0.2647117078304291,
-0.16528713703155518,
0.9666202664375305,
-0.5327615737915039,
-0.6846863031387329,
-0.3071289360523224,
-0.25098511576652527,
0.29576432704925537,
0.4214165508747101,
0.4800279140472412,
-0.9519559144973755,
-0.784744381904602,
0.26259514689445496,
-0.35056236386299133,
0.17981727421283722,
0.13724558055400848,
-0.10666840523481369,
0.42813777923583984,
0.48694393038749695,
-0.40466248989105225,
0.4881802499294281,
1.0360344648361206,
-0.3880060613155365,
0.8218329548835754,
-0.6923779249191284,
-0.08558160066604614,
-0.7483640909194946,
-0.14724841713905334,
-0.000044349671952659264,
-0.6734021902084351,
-0.7188494205474854,
0.19678306579589844,
0.4633861184120178,
0.11212094873189926,
-0.31191474199295044,
0.22350037097930908,
-0.39452555775642395,
-0.036933284252882004,
-0.4943635165691376,
-0.34916260838508606,
-0.0644422248005867,
0.34716999530792236,
0.1633792519569397,
0.5618558526039124,
0.2889666259288788,
-0.18176591396331787,
0.8008818626403809,
0.2941499352455139,
-0.5648005604743958,
0.5570992231369019,
-0.5592560172080994,
-0.11313634365797043,
0.13924546539783478,
0.4766085147857666,
-0.8159981966018677,
-0.22217148542404175,
-0.012035205028951168,
-0.2474343478679657,
0.4695884585380554,
0.006628687493503094,
-0.3652936518192291,
-0.7763177156448364,
-0.4450293481349945,
0.76743084192276,
0.8794443607330322,
-0.6810765862464905,
0.5293080806732178,
0.3330325186252594,
-0.0808844268321991,
-0.2899382412433624,
-0.576696515083313,
0.2620728015899658,
-0.1366216093301773,
-0.4898582696914673,
0.563703715801239,
-0.11539176106452942,
-0.048247095197439194,
-0.21182098984718323,
-0.006411580368876457,
0.14610442519187927,
-0.5774972438812256,
0.3519202768802643,
0.7204471230506897,
-0.22662073373794556,
-0.09742843359708786,
-0.346446692943573,
-0.3340286910533905,
0.034238748252391815,
-0.0587955005466938,
0.56093430519104,
-0.19969651103019714,
-0.2652362883090973,
-0.2227582335472107,
0.2813588082790375,
0.806530773639679,
-0.5213800668716431,
0.3684045076370239,
0.4135236442089081,
-0.12624628841876984,
0.07785209268331528,
-0.7037333846092224,
-0.09621603041887283,
-0.5636574625968933,
0.7511349320411682,
-0.4205033779144287,
-0.9035655856132507,
0.2698031961917877,
-0.15429775416851044,
0.26214417815208435,
0.1481379270553589,
0.6258715987205505,
-0.3241364657878876,
1.0074433088302612,
0.6813475489616394,
0.46062275767326355,
0.618139386177063,
-0.4979090988636017,
0.2823883891105652,
-1.28923761844635,
-0.44198694825172424,
-0.15239229798316956,
-0.6664653420448303,
-0.4363771080970764,
-0.9472454190254211,
0.5014610886573792,
-0.3797380030155182,
-0.46814778447151184,
-0.03160664439201355,
-0.5683967471122742,
0.40189436078071594,
0.5712518692016602,
0.007606671657413244,
0.1986256092786789,
0.06954941153526306,
0.08434849232435226,
-0.32640689611434937,
-0.6561090350151062,
-0.10589167475700378,
0.714781641960144,
0.6763103604316711,
0.5025621652603149,
0.0821964368224144,
0.06235464662313461,
0.3217451274394989,
0.11466270685195923,
-0.6307669281959534,
0.545468807220459,
-0.3343120813369751,
-0.5938405990600586,
-0.12324991822242737,
-0.062120966613292694,
-0.7080053687095642,
0.4410891532897949,
-0.0721099004149437,
-0.42871150374412537,
0.4125938415527344,
0.6765737533569336,
-0.22957868874073029,
0.565833330154419,
-0.19346338510513306,
0.6548578143119812,
-0.24504557251930237,
-0.5367316007614136,
-0.34855595231056213,
-0.8445751667022705,
0.3696715235710144,
-0.40508967638015747,
0.1606907993555069,
-0.21483361721038818,
-0.2515300512313843,
0.5346165299415588,
-0.5237907767295837,
0.7124415636062622,
-0.04589533060789108,
-0.15685079991817474,
0.03649082034826279,
-0.13752052187919617,
0.6973184943199158,
-0.05647137388586998,
0.04649394750595093,
0.28571468591690063,
-0.03549284115433693,
-0.33701473474502563,
-0.4811690151691437,
0.9015418291091919,
-1.058108925819397,
-0.48956042528152466,
-0.5239588022232056,
-0.9522969722747803,
-0.11641588062047958,
-0.0005516141536645591,
0.24589888751506805,
0.6669294238090515,
0.04352424293756485,
0.4747765362262726,
0.40246233344078064,
-0.1209079697728157,
0.47137314081192017,
0.5747783780097961,
-0.36478710174560547,
-0.4423600137233734,
1.1347955465316772,
0.3259296417236328,
0.5448580980300903,
0.19422578811645508,
-0.008295190520584583,
-0.4289809465408325,
-0.6425013542175293,
-0.4481450319290161,
0.09496069699525833,
-0.6835249662399292,
-0.5748072266578674,
-0.3235168755054474,
-0.47630512714385986,
0.02972983755171299,
-0.2468695491552353,
-0.783354640007019,
-0.16740909218788147,
-0.16607414186000824,
0.11618109047412872,
0.18525366485118866,
0.6011327505111694,
-0.2932937443256378,
0.30856722593307495,
-0.6949347853660583,
0.40185433626174927,
0.29233723878860474,
0.4759364426136017,
-0.15355192124843597,
-0.8226909041404724,
-0.48073405027389526,
-0.0589958056807518,
-0.3705589473247528,
-0.3063659965991974,
0.564050555229187,
-0.03626970201730728,
0.29208171367645264,
0.35580793023109436,
0.11549099534749985,
0.6184179782867432,
-0.7156471610069275,
0.8423109650611877,
0.530547022819519,
-0.5558773279190063,
0.21704626083374023,
-0.23439578711986542,
0.3985840976238251,
0.21764791011810303,
-0.05423467606306076,
-0.4862186014652252,
-0.07927320152521133,
-0.4763841927051544,
-0.8876532316207886,
0.6709988713264465,
0.24854111671447754,
0.2808503210544586,
0.40783992409706116,
0.46661266684532166,
0.1733332872390747,
-0.14314579963684082,
-0.3627403974533081,
-0.16061851382255554,
-0.5717115998268127,
-0.08466005325317383,
-0.16687676310539246,
-0.6234229207038879,
0.014628397300839424,
-0.6306116580963135,
0.5582897067070007,
-0.04853876307606697,
0.3485187292098999,
0.03043362870812416,
0.03510576859116554,
0.000930832524318248,
-0.1776939332485199,
0.5688866972923279,
0.6981016397476196,
-0.06974069029092789,
0.2389456033706665,
0.1549101024866104,
-0.704500675201416,
0.4330328106880188,
0.04623771086335182,
0.18264782428741455,
-0.16183733940124512,
0.3078199326992035,
1.046966791152954,
-0.18028561770915985,
-0.6096893548965454,
0.4537394642829895,
-0.03580967336893082,
-0.4029868543148041,
-0.383795827627182,
-0.01879665069282055,
-0.20177410542964935,
0.3438434302806854,
0.32433226704597473,
0.37361544370651245,
-0.19281049072742462,
-0.11839361488819122,
0.17958936095237732,
0.2801643908023834,
-0.5175151228904724,
-0.5150748491287231,
0.5017542243003845,
0.52308189868927,
-0.25561314821243286,
0.9385139346122742,
0.08905789256095886,
-0.6268437504768372,
0.6936725974082947,
0.6772031188011169,
0.235092893242836,
-0.47999101877212524,
0.12397489696741104,
0.4926815629005432,
0.21943429112434387,
0.18912005424499512,
0.21673673391342163,
-0.08131907880306244,
-0.864370584487915,
-0.5037127733230591,
-0.6723121404647827,
-0.3041093349456787,
0.22342130541801453,
-0.6475679278373718,
0.4541751444339752,
-0.1902092844247818,
0.06380122154951096,
-0.20052964985370636,
-0.0018237406620755792,
-0.5413625836372375,
0.19303515553474426,
0.19563806056976318,
1.2018359899520874,
-0.3148343563079834,
1.2779358625411987,
0.5650396347045898,
-0.01450339239090681,
-0.6789216995239258,
-0.2709989547729492,
0.041610099375247955,
-0.834351658821106,
0.7577523589134216,
0.3215101361274719,
0.2688921391963959,
0.41548505425453186,
-0.0958908274769783,
-0.7275029420852661,
1.1691035032272339,
0.12420327961444855,
-1.0848503112792969,
-0.011911335401237011,
0.5284921526908875,
0.37472355365753174,
-0.231811985373497,
-0.1309085190296173,
0.7881816625595093,
0.437079519033432,
0.37158992886543274,
-0.6765942573547363,
-0.1605221927165985,
-0.25257253646850586,
0.21537093818187714,
0.37291601300239563,
-0.7211306095123291,
0.7719394564628601,
-0.25540873408317566,
0.4299572706222534,
0.4657798111438751,
0.6695638298988342,
0.20883093774318695,
-0.14445549249649048,
0.6582943797111511,
0.5207235217094421,
0.27774152159690857,
-0.22217018902301788,
1.0648845434188843,
-0.18434220552444458,
0.24739553034305573,
0.8258839249610901,
-0.1644202619791031,
0.860850989818573,
0.6663964986801147,
-0.18775466084480286,
0.35199183225631714,
0.6300026774406433,
-0.17197032272815704,
0.612218976020813,
0.2478296160697937,
-0.6430457234382629,
-0.17113730311393738,
-0.08206111937761307,
-0.39174342155456543,
0.41616541147232056,
0.5562925338745117,
-0.28404974937438965,
-0.0069108582101762295,
0.5968549847602844,
-0.617722749710083,
-0.17532779276371002,
-0.524888813495636,
0.5871617197990417,
-0.1564868539571762,
-0.610579788684845,
0.5327228903770447,
-0.18243156373500824,
0.6389954686164856,
-0.6947597861289978,
-0.21022383868694305,
-0.2956003248691559,
0.7579919695854187,
-0.059662774205207825,
-0.9731211066246033,
0.46299418807029724,
-0.06782390177249908,
-0.26746296882629395,
-0.16079947352409363,
0.6428101658821106,
-0.2610378563404083,
-0.45747193694114685,
0.10177846252918243,
-0.03116285242140293,
-0.16254785656929016,
-0.29385194182395935,
-0.45487844944000244,
0.5600733160972595,
0.050266847014427185,
-0.09126489609479904,
0.48906993865966797,
0.2773679792881012,
-0.08474212884902954,
0.44715505838394165,
0.6136299967765808,
0.24343609809875488,
0.40248289704322815,
-0.35681676864624023,
1.1869431734085083,
-0.47022175788879395,
-0.49814021587371826,
-0.6189756393432617,
0.5636945962905884,
-0.21881254017353058,
-0.1393583118915558,
0.5051316618919373,
0.697412371635437,
0.5613601207733154,
-0.025956889614462852,
0.6974604725837708,
0.003520665457472205,
0.3779981732368469,
-0.11443645507097244,
0.33554232120513916,
-0.781369149684906,
0.06670371443033218,
0.22948093712329865,
-0.7899325489997864,
-0.5816017985343933,
0.4653491973876953,
-0.06221076473593712,
-0.2204728126525879,
0.46118244528770447,
0.7069876194000244,
-0.06563014537096024,
-0.3758081793785095,
0.7663769721984863,
0.429650217294693,
0.7803932428359985,
0.34460118412971497,
1.0084096193313599,
-0.1971416473388672,
0.8613352179527283,
-0.2414737492799759,
-0.5233137011528015,
-0.512094259262085,
-0.5393776297569275,
-0.5312514901161194,
-0.625975489616394,
-0.27766531705856323,
-0.2226996123790741,
-0.051828186959028244,
0.6618391275405884,
0.896401047706604,
-0.30368757247924805,
0.013852614909410477,
-0.259440541267395,
-0.39982616901397705,
-0.18850618600845337,
-0.08993919938802719,
0.4192062318325043,
-0.24024979770183563,
-0.7160243988037109,
0.05722317844629288,
0.5422719120979309,
0.07740523666143417,
-0.6448086500167847,
-0.579407811164856,
0.1518404185771942,
0.024858012795448303,
0.8602287769317627,
0.3986546993255615,
-0.976124107837677,
-0.21559667587280273,
-0.09564080089330673,
-0.09078380465507507,
0.4797123074531555,
0.690750002861023,
-1.0206997394561768,
0.703853189945221,
0.5735068917274475,
0.4016123116016388,
0.6064403653144836,
-0.16597017645835876,
0.5177624821662903,
-0.6947136521339417,
0.23762232065200806,
0.09255702793598175,
0.24501633644104004,
0.26445528864860535,
-0.16998028755187988,
0.435883104801178,
0.019755154848098755,
-0.7276980876922607,
-0.7553824782371521,
0.20310021936893463,
-1.145094394683838,
-0.11049248278141022,
0.9883152842521667,
-0.2254924774169922,
0.05667685344815254,
-0.09968157857656479,
-0.8690302968025208,
0.14545662701129913,
-0.06255805492401123,
0.6778184175491333,
0.3384673297405243,
-0.21747195720672607,
-0.624349057674408,
-0.7833002805709839,
0.4544612169265747,
0.06621196120977402,
-0.750466525554657,
0.02235499396920204,
0.19457237422466278,
0.01746053621172905,
0.216227188706398,
0.37555599212646484,
-0.26698559522628784,
0.5127434730529785,
0.04211718589067459,
0.17492415010929108,
-0.2715359032154083,
-0.18427813053131104,
-0.23203538358211517,
0.14704671502113342,
0.13774608075618744,
-0.5982990860939026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06508v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06508v2
|
On the Effect of (Near) Duplicate Subwords in Language Modelling
| 2024-04-09T17:57:29 | 2024-05-02T23:29:56 |
Anton Schäfer, Thomas Hofmann, Imanol Schlag, Tiago Pimentel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
Tokenisation is a core part of language models (LMs). It involves splitting a
character sequence into subwords which are assigned arbitrary indices before
being served to the LM. While typically lossless, however, this process may
lead to less sample efficient LM training: as it removes character-level
information, it could make it harder for LMs to generalise across similar
subwords, such as now and Now. We refer to such subwords as near duplicates. In
this paper, we study the impact of near duplicate subwords on LM training
efficiency. First, we design an experiment that gives us an upper bound to how
much we should expect a model to improve if we could perfectly generalise
across near duplicates. We do this by duplicating each subword in our LM's
vocabulary, creating perfectly equivalent classes of subwords. Experimentally,
we find that LMs need roughly 17% more data when trained in a fully duplicated
setting. Second, we investigate the impact of naturally occurring near
duplicates on LMs. Here, we see that merging them considerably hurts LM
performance. Therefore, although subword duplication negatively impacts LM
training efficiency, naturally occurring near duplicates may not be as similar
as anticipated, limiting the potential for performance improvements.
|
[
-0.2841460704803467,
-0.5989855527877808,
0.05615291744470596,
-0.17767305672168732,
-0.4698362350463867,
0.2064540684223175,
0.02551436237990856,
-0.7653288245201111,
0.218931645154953,
0.43683335185050964,
-0.2137063443660736,
-0.24959084391593933,
-0.429981529712677,
0.23259851336479187,
-0.5180193185806274,
0.8087112903594971,
0.06694008409976959,
0.33150604367256165,
-0.2953049838542938,
-0.3810677230358124,
-0.6554585099220276,
-1.2898752689361572,
-0.6342461109161377,
-0.3412012457847595,
0.6175462007522583,
0.10056670755147934,
0.6320470571517944,
0.4342672824859619,
0.413412481546402,
0.3133351504802704,
-0.4416500926017761,
-0.03427561745047569,
-0.6864956021308899,
-0.2391778528690338,
-0.2757715880870819,
-0.8910879492759705,
-0.39905858039855957,
0.09480908513069153,
0.9049351811408997,
1.070517897605896,
0.18200452625751495,
-0.11604412645101547,
-0.0037243159022182226,
0.7406507730484009,
-0.5487169623374939,
-0.08450436592102051,
-0.6467544436454773,
0.2605823874473572,
-0.4649965465068817,
-0.039906974881887436,
-0.10333188623189926,
-0.22948411107063293,
-0.0036951943766325712,
-0.3605586588382721,
0.37734511494636536,
0.10889428853988647,
0.6593618392944336,
-0.08105040341615677,
-0.014179302379488945,
-0.17461466789245605,
-0.40527117252349854,
0.929559051990509,
-0.8917341828346252,
0.4094763696193695,
0.16097891330718994,
-0.0563482791185379,
-0.18202263116836548,
-0.7436937689781189,
-0.8590717315673828,
-0.23539458215236664,
-0.4466612637042999,
-0.2189403474330902,
-0.26902759075164795,
0.24492362141609192,
0.44041702151298523,
0.7075574398040771,
-0.3141823709011078,
0.4207324981689453,
-0.5545282959938049,
-0.2016284167766571,
0.2859063446521759,
0.4464225769042969,
0.4517737627029419,
-0.28866246342658997,
-0.12853366136550903,
0.21102678775787354,
-0.7792807221412659,
0.06963607668876648,
0.5414712429046631,
0.6186025142669678,
0.0402599573135376,
0.6085041165351868,
-0.007320096716284752,
0.7319028973579407,
0.07103791832923889,
-0.13622824847698212,
0.6308315992355347,
-1.0054951906204224,
-0.11948324739933014,
-0.14767667651176453,
0.365975558757782,
0.09204830229282379,
0.40703171491622925,
-0.2651084065437317,
-0.28037041425704956,
0.009762764908373356,
0.1647549569606781,
-0.614204466342926,
-0.08376141637563705,
0.10977920889854431,
-0.5179848670959473,
-0.3629533052444458,
0.11471445113420486,
-0.2427707463502884,
-0.12699954211711884,
-0.37355560064315796,
0.3426699936389923,
-0.35281696915626526,
-0.19256296753883362,
0.19212858378887177,
-0.31867843866348267,
0.06223233789205551,
-0.16877639293670654,
-0.5982040166854858,
0.17044603824615479,
0.7972467541694641,
0.9140598773956299,
-0.17836084961891174,
-0.6684867739677429,
-0.5765736699104309,
-0.15313445031642914,
-0.3023470342159271,
0.5082192420959473,
-0.5498815178871155,
-0.6558207273483276,
-0.11547377705574036,
0.036328114569187164,
-0.12880121171474457,
-0.9515860080718994,
0.2621789574623108,
-0.5198858380317688,
0.5645813345909119,
-0.4805997908115387,
-0.7886435985565186,
-0.017321240156888962,
-0.09070441126823425,
-0.8330250382423401,
0.9387577176094055,
0.11870479583740234,
-1.0133339166641235,
0.6576927304267883,
-0.6572402715682983,
-0.6665318608283997,
0.17935344576835632,
0.04946887493133545,
-0.2451147586107254,
0.4347116947174072,
-0.056279271841049194,
0.24483054876327515,
0.04339888319373131,
-0.04576437547802925,
-0.2566314935684204,
-0.5350520014762878,
0.15406525135040283,
-0.26468610763549805,
0.3025191128253937,
-0.05640989542007446,
-0.23667632043361664,
-0.12097328901290894,
-0.3807135224342346,
-0.03842046856880188,
-0.07780304551124573,
-0.2781551480293274,
-0.723216712474823,
-0.3174082636833191,
-0.05620649829506874,
0.3609789311885834,
0.31329259276390076,
-0.6685503125190735,
0.24777133762836456,
-0.560866117477417,
0.27353575825691223,
0.6023306250572205,
0.0222187377512455,
0.5928028225898743,
-0.6418377161026001,
0.6819985508918762,
0.4025188088417053,
0.24845613539218903,
-0.08369050920009613,
-0.3506559431552887,
-0.6716115474700928,
-0.35031479597091675,
0.683236300945282,
0.3312310576438904,
-0.7226929664611816,
0.22493256628513336,
-0.32665443420410156,
-0.3492860794067383,
-0.5145848989486694,
0.28163471817970276,
0.7288662195205688,
0.18260601162910461,
0.14139798283576965,
-0.6431999802589417,
-0.7804089188575745,
-1.0574126243591309,
-0.7177781462669373,
0.04920662194490433,
0.4437946677207947,
0.0743667334318161,
0.576696515083313,
-0.20188112556934357,
1.2645869255065918,
-0.10583677142858505,
-0.5027122497558594,
-0.5484116077423096,
0.19067680835723877,
0.13820907473564148,
0.4987759292125702,
0.720140814781189,
-0.9514613151550293,
-0.39770129323005676,
-0.18787029385566711,
-0.5045560598373413,
-0.3172167241573334,
-0.06278717517852783,
0.11025557667016983,
0.5155221819877625,
0.6231452822685242,
-0.7092484831809998,
0.5556732416152954,
0.4775014817714691,
0.2653411626815796,
0.3350938558578491,
-0.189589262008667,
-0.22676487267017365,
-1.1769229173660278,
0.17268677055835724,
-0.38829293847084045,
-0.12977632880210876,
-0.7363221645355225,
0.11239982396364212,
-0.17067939043045044,
0.139340341091156,
-0.8762192726135254,
0.805655837059021,
-0.6067456603050232,
-0.30202195048332214,
-0.4257509112358093,
0.07307693362236023,
-0.14713332056999207,
0.3232686519622803,
-0.06462306529283524,
0.8654547333717346,
0.2964352071285248,
-0.5010116696357727,
0.15745332837104797,
-0.2525986433029175,
-0.5315983295440674,
0.242676243185997,
-0.5498989820480347,
0.22146131098270416,
-0.2764398455619812,
0.33442044258117676,
-0.604256272315979,
0.07696159929037094,
-0.11312230676412582,
-0.296807199716568,
0.3517487645149231,
-0.09469229727983475,
-0.7590166330337524,
-0.3723548352718353,
-0.21653401851654053,
0.7847447991371155,
0.4881792962551117,
-0.6560781598091125,
0.5570446848869324,
0.3976263105869293,
0.06499762088060379,
-0.6980820894241333,
-0.9037072062492371,
-0.02577587403357029,
-0.29543250799179077,
-0.414214164018631,
0.25642603635787964,
0.0846942812204361,
-0.30984658002853394,
0.1922782063484192,
-0.012114070355892181,
0.4304729104042053,
0.0594417080283165,
0.36046767234802246,
-0.12776008248329163,
0.009528540074825287,
0.22187231481075287,
-0.2997090816497803,
-0.06911268085241318,
-0.2686126232147217,
-0.6108312010765076,
0.8571414947509766,
-0.08043564110994339,
-0.3867534399032593,
-0.6593348979949951,
0.4813332259654999,
0.567009687423706,
-0.12761546671390533,
1.1176130771636963,
0.2273453325033188,
-0.46904900670051575,
-0.15334762632846832,
-0.5262863039970398,
0.13533373177051544,
-0.4802994728088379,
0.7245988249778748,
-0.6075370907783508,
-0.7856747508049011,
0.602267861366272,
0.22230428457260132,
0.1795985847711563,
0.4056548476219177,
0.4311341941356659,
-0.10969679057598114,
0.8538230061531067,
0.6905288696289062,
-0.4222727119922638,
0.8588773012161255,
-0.3789415955543518,
0.36210376024246216,
-0.6081495881080627,
-0.40296152234077454,
-0.3054525852203369,
-0.43799149990081787,
-0.3024238646030426,
-0.7565471529960632,
-0.053911883383989334,
0.38508307933807373,
0.3157804012298584,
0.31227436661720276,
0.027982112020254135,
0.7232822179794312,
0.5364710688591003,
-0.31383323669433594,
0.33213987946510315,
0.098444864153862,
-0.3807377815246582,
-0.15628203749656677,
-1.0272424221038818,
-0.3737901449203491,
0.8436676263809204,
0.15190252661705017,
0.6276649236679077,
0.10160750895738602,
0.749443769454956,
0.5389713048934937,
0.4144259989261627,
-0.6462958455085754,
0.5836755633354187,
-0.47183966636657715,
-0.5917714834213257,
-0.07923178374767303,
-0.6848971247673035,
-1.0370687246322632,
0.2426108419895172,
0.005827265325933695,
-0.2570568323135376,
-0.049846094101667404,
0.2673232853412628,
-0.21064400672912598,
0.7082210183143616,
-0.6911807656288147,
0.6386772394180298,
-0.31794726848602295,
-0.04220838472247124,
-0.2811985909938812,
-0.3648645281791687,
0.20624922215938568,
-0.5960562229156494,
0.38661521673202515,
0.2730017602443695,
-0.02830120548605919,
0.7732062339782715,
-0.7713527679443359,
0.9763720035552979,
-0.1151169165968895,
-0.0036460983101278543,
0.12357773631811142,
-0.1808892786502838,
0.4816557466983795,
-0.547062337398529,
0.10633894056081772,
0.36327844858169556,
0.05548559129238129,
-0.7738812565803528,
-0.5037422180175781,
0.7681401371955872,
-0.5897122025489807,
-0.48331642150878906,
-0.45143112540245056,
-0.4796312153339386,
-0.08810710161924362,
0.2338857203722,
0.5391167998313904,
0.5822579860687256,
-0.16989925503730774,
-0.09066805243492126,
0.1868007481098175,
-0.27161046862602234,
0.3744922876358032,
0.46805399656295776,
-0.4844531714916229,
-0.2775546610355377,
0.9058801531791687,
0.42952170968055725,
0.6996394991874695,
0.47694194316864014,
0.06250423938035965,
-0.43291088938713074,
-0.6058136820793152,
0.05780792236328125,
0.4036814272403717,
-0.7012493014335632,
0.12615856528282166,
-0.6665462255477905,
-0.10279534012079239,
-0.45578017830848694,
0.0051421173848211765,
-0.2921401560306549,
-0.5579193830490112,
-0.32554662227630615,
-0.16992665827274323,
0.09455837309360504,
0.8524676561355591,
-0.29881012439727783,
0.2708494961261749,
-0.9007077813148499,
0.06167414039373398,
0.2707492411136627,
0.29120033979415894,
0.17368464171886444,
-0.7225156426429749,
-0.5016016364097595,
0.1037272959947586,
0.28377583622932434,
-0.3473629653453827,
0.2858820855617523,
0.08455204218626022,
0.7079514861106873,
0.1867619901895523,
-0.22460365295410156,
0.9716456532478333,
-0.4099287688732147,
1.0295727252960205,
0.2416219264268875,
-0.9650518894195557,
-0.006849216762930155,
0.027249276638031006,
0.5311476588249207,
0.6130768656730652,
0.2771909832954407,
-0.7400090098381042,
-0.44169941544532776,
-0.7955482006072998,
-0.7334697246551514,
0.7004770040512085,
0.21447668969631195,
0.4332457184791565,
-0.07181542366743088,
0.42417195439338684,
0.2871735692024231,
0.18052938580513,
-0.5779399871826172,
-0.2973534166812897,
0.12940776348114014,
0.1971154659986496,
-0.3513250946998596,
-0.3176805377006531,
0.2998761534690857,
-0.23803848028182983,
0.7217277884483337,
0.34537050127983093,
-0.09812776744365692,
-0.2843124568462372,
-0.3292773365974426,
0.0017751803388819098,
0.13066250085830688,
0.5831446051597595,
0.40824511647224426,
-0.0045258766040205956,
-0.005394457373768091,
0.45298948884010315,
-0.3834248483181,
-0.2589946389198303,
-0.2749021351337433,
0.017467768862843513,
0.41088080406188965,
0.717097282409668,
0.7699349522590637,
0.13308115303516388,
-0.6640903949737549,
0.4997099041938782,
0.00458909897133708,
0.034189190715551376,
-0.42372560501098633,
-0.01813432201743126,
0.025752846151590347,
0.014852527529001236,
0.2901191711425781,
0.15682825446128845,
-0.33254504203796387,
-0.9549407362937927,
0.3427372872829437,
0.4744223654270172,
-0.0749894455075264,
-0.3870702087879181,
0.2798859179019928,
0.14481568336486816,
-0.618541419506073,
0.5986404418945312,
-0.13004645705223083,
-0.9685523509979248,
0.5245253443717957,
0.31262335181236267,
0.6473801732063293,
0.06679975986480713,
-0.32359540462493896,
0.1376425176858902,
0.29154837131500244,
-0.11741886287927628,
0.34596025943756104,
0.05884910747408867,
-0.6189709305763245,
-0.28937557339668274,
-0.6347339749336243,
-0.23296689987182617,
0.3631012439727783,
-0.5623547434806824,
0.1916753053665161,
-0.3414946496486664,
-0.42511293292045593,
-0.10605348646640778,
-0.03545869514346123,
-0.5646570920944214,
0.1953539252281189,
0.28365570306777954,
0.8518971800804138,
-0.8029698133468628,
0.8798352479934692,
0.7264727354049683,
-0.4778944253921509,
-0.7943922877311707,
0.05392061173915863,
-0.2943284809589386,
-0.6700265407562256,
0.8075486421585083,
0.27528509497642517,
-0.0629696398973465,
-0.2719622552394867,
-0.2274659425020218,
-0.8422265648841858,
0.7093375325202942,
0.14458464086055756,
-0.6435820460319519,
-0.3593319058418274,
0.6983562111854553,
0.9555438160896301,
-0.3258058428764343,
0.028197525069117546,
0.5614112019538879,
0.09091423451900482,
-0.01599576696753502,
-1.2500406503677368,
-0.2714729905128479,
-0.41072505712509155,
0.20463816821575165,
0.6449381709098816,
-0.6097624897956848,
1.1417503356933594,
-0.22653688490390778,
-0.41881150007247925,
0.5258839726448059,
0.48520928621292114,
0.03806125372648239,
0.07066550105810165,
0.6320688724517822,
0.7144611477851868,
0.6703039407730103,
0.19088579714298248,
1.296606421470642,
-0.2775740921497345,
0.37577366828918457,
1.243558645248413,
-0.1322881281375885,
0.6927170753479004,
0.5899965167045593,
-0.06221841648221016,
0.3238532245159149,
0.4122236669063568,
0.2657307982444763,
0.5057809352874756,
0.6090882420539856,
-0.1123342514038086,
-0.15553922951221466,
-0.22273977100849152,
-0.6730750203132629,
0.36131805181503296,
0.05051885545253754,
-0.6047511696815491,
-0.08097709715366364,
0.2855510115623474,
-0.06883614510297775,
-0.09931528568267822,
-0.36378395557403564,
0.5132903456687927,
0.21004246175289154,
-0.4706859886646271,
0.5195330381393433,
0.12556467950344086,
0.8497174382209778,
-0.508790910243988,
0.17723536491394043,
-0.7645959854125977,
0.29403066635131836,
-0.27816125750541687,
-0.4785216748714447,
0.3406970202922821,
0.028719665482640266,
-0.24106061458587646,
-0.20942941308021545,
0.40960484743118286,
-0.4324297606945038,
-0.4437040388584137,
0.37966659665107727,
0.4268571138381958,
0.4245539903640747,
0.09804968535900116,
-0.5963609218597412,
-0.07609228044748306,
-0.017177708446979523,
0.03522452339529991,
0.4871853291988373,
0.3315557539463043,
-0.17943620681762695,
0.5380576848983765,
0.8683614730834961,
0.3537919223308563,
0.4242366850376129,
0.22268816828727722,
0.7708801031112671,
-0.8154170513153076,
-0.568315863609314,
-0.7507046461105347,
0.1699901521205902,
-0.07075821608304977,
-0.3579213321208954,
0.8024086356163025,
0.8670023679733276,
1.2050046920776367,
0.08188250660896301,
0.7833110690116882,
0.18476919829845428,
0.7306259870529175,
-0.5593514442443848,
0.500819981098175,
-0.8838250041007996,
0.5755398869514465,
-0.29949209094047546,
-0.8780230283737183,
-0.13392376899719238,
0.10859615355730057,
-0.429934561252594,
0.23682904243469238,
0.7035285830497742,
0.8009044528007507,
-0.09646062552928925,
0.1289251297712326,
0.540673017501831,
0.3167165517807007,
0.018780697137117386,
0.43560487031936646,
1.1085331439971924,
-0.22502540051937103,
0.2702747583389282,
-0.38226640224456787,
0.2570286691188812,
-0.004150948021560907,
-0.580930233001709,
-1.2272669076919556,
-0.5299611687660217,
-0.10756951570510864,
-0.23913255333900452,
-0.008321131579577923,
0.8042640686035156,
0.4201469421386719,
-0.7306510210037231,
-0.019517431035637856,
-0.13044992089271545,
-0.10010945051908493,
0.12864677608013153,
-0.21920567750930786,
0.2891816794872284,
-0.2164781391620636,
-0.8580451011657715,
0.0945570170879364,
0.1283128410577774,
0.20492000877857208,
-0.2526051998138428,
0.03021387942135334,
-0.1835946887731552,
0.1152491346001625,
0.5668918490409851,
0.325583279132843,
-0.6912081241607666,
-0.18324412405490875,
-0.17489852011203766,
-0.2638900876045227,
-0.026706501841545105,
1.0709481239318848,
-1.0526916980743408,
0.3102561831474304,
0.5846412181854248,
0.4490908086299896,
0.29576238989830017,
0.12337948381900787,
0.5693352222442627,
-0.7846465110778809,
0.3476993441581726,
0.2815963327884674,
0.38020727038383484,
0.4227980077266693,
-0.151203915476799,
0.32590243220329285,
0.7089604139328003,
-0.004921655170619488,
-1.0872247219085693,
0.24269671738147736,
-0.5196704864501953,
-0.4298134446144104,
1.2467329502105713,
-0.08873945474624634,
0.07938741147518158,
-0.3054136335849762,
-0.06852942705154419,
0.16642121970653534,
-0.07645685225725174,
0.4320787191390991,
0.7060630321502686,
-0.012364998459815979,
0.17324168980121613,
-0.046225227415561676,
0.5037542581558228,
1.0387698411941528,
-0.5075461864471436,
-0.02204972878098488,
0.2977246046066284,
0.5344244241714478,
0.11980753391981125,
0.508094310760498,
-0.16318921744823456,
0.06956714391708374,
-0.101203054189682,
-0.0069549609906971455,
-0.22217705845832825,
-0.1087188646197319,
-0.6209732294082642,
0.22321467101573944,
-0.07254646718502045,
-0.19213055074214935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06503v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06503v1
|
Comparing Two Model Designs for Clinical Note Generation; Is an LLM a Useful Evaluator of Consistency?
| 2024-04-09T17:54:10 | 2024-04-09T17:54:10 |
Nathan Brake, Thomas Schaaf
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Following an interaction with a patient, physicians are responsible for the
submission of clinical documentation, often organized as a SOAP note. A
clinical note is not simply a summary of the conversation but requires the use
of appropriate medical terminology. The relevant information can then be
extracted and organized according to the structure of the SOAP note. In this
paper we analyze two different approaches to generate the different sections of
a SOAP note based on the audio recording of the conversation, and specifically
examine them in terms of note consistency. The first approach generates the
sections independently, while the second method generates them all together. In
this work we make use of PEGASUS-X Transformer models and observe that both
methods lead to similar ROUGE values (less than 1% difference) and have no
difference in terms of the Factuality metric. We perform a human evaluation to
measure aspects of consistency and demonstrate that LLMs like Llama2 can be
used to perform the same tasks with roughly the same agreement as the human
annotators. Between the Llama2 analysis and the human reviewers we observe a
Cohen Kappa inter-rater reliability of 0.79, 1.00, and 0.32 for consistency of
age, gender, and body part injury, respectively. With this we demonstrate the
usefulness of leveraging an LLM to measure quality indicators that can be
identified by humans but are not currently captured by automatic metrics. This
allows scaling evaluation to larger data sets, and we find that clinical note
consistency improves by generating each new section conditioned on the output
of all previously generated sections.
|
[
0.017580905929207802,
-0.511883556842804,
0.7837181687355042,
0.2926118075847626,
-0.3284716308116913,
-0.10693102329969406,
-0.0038342762272804976,
-0.5556944012641907,
0.4100429117679596,
0.509505569934845,
-0.2743450403213501,
-0.6304187178611755,
-0.6282304525375366,
0.16336530447006226,
-0.5114039182662964,
1.3093276023864746,
-0.1871623992919922,
0.36372634768486023,
-0.12324216961860657,
-0.2513226866722107,
-0.39613375067710876,
-0.2642122507095337,
-0.8877974152565002,
-0.44572725892066956,
0.5174654126167297,
-0.013247099705040455,
0.6489734649658203,
0.9369718432426453,
0.8503190875053406,
0.29446378350257874,
-0.21647804975509644,
0.38000884652137756,
-0.18121807277202606,
0.17481832206249237,
0.1021944209933281,
-0.43212804198265076,
-1.0238637924194336,
0.10786454379558563,
0.45172467827796936,
0.6078712940216064,
-0.28098583221435547,
0.29004353284835815,
0.0750114917755127,
0.35588887333869934,
-0.3751247227191925,
0.06084927171468735,
-0.2831948399543762,
0.08727739751338959,
-0.15898005664348602,
-0.22395600378513336,
-0.32183581590652466,
-0.5249457359313965,
0.03545646369457245,
-0.5590370893478394,
0.4965381324291229,
-0.11592832952737808,
0.8229958415031433,
0.14456520974636078,
-0.5151328444480896,
-0.602595329284668,
-0.8176968097686768,
0.43209290504455566,
-0.9798663258552551,
0.407173216342926,
0.3811647593975067,
0.33026859164237976,
-0.0956980362534523,
-0.9299806356430054,
-0.42396852374076843,
-0.7796302437782288,
-0.2721407413482666,
0.3072970509529114,
0.07296059280633926,
0.09540124237537384,
0.20358848571777344,
0.3931553065776825,
-0.18117788434028625,
0.26690778136253357,
-0.244648277759552,
-0.4322405457496643,
0.9118684530258179,
0.5573318600654602,
0.2963217794895172,
-0.1591545194387436,
-0.5382230281829834,
-0.08407609909772873,
-0.8384936451911926,
0.2300250232219696,
0.11172769218683243,
0.2527208626270294,
-0.12327520549297333,
0.5674445033073425,
0.15043318271636963,
0.2462807148694992,
0.19909685850143433,
-1.0394164323806763,
0.10553112626075745,
-0.44504252076148987,
-0.08786826580762863,
0.2478839010000229,
0.8456759452819824,
0.7195079922676086,
-0.0709315836429596,
-0.14289763569831848,
-0.4045274257659912,
0.044251699000597,
0.5560688376426697,
-0.6433569192886353,
-0.1672695279121399,
0.29103660583496094,
-0.8053780794143677,
-0.39506301283836365,
0.19396468997001648,
-0.3126315474510193,
-0.5755044221878052,
-0.4721842408180237,
0.18433496356010437,
-0.22191642224788666,
-0.13071613013744354,
-0.06639787554740906,
-0.021711956709623337,
-0.08429824560880661,
0.5976160764694214,
-0.9168402552604675,
0.7366567254066467,
0.8055233359336853,
0.6901177763938904,
-0.21684452891349792,
-0.10155563056468964,
-0.5196853280067444,
0.21256187558174133,
-0.5623735785484314,
0.6703548431396484,
0.0740726962685585,
-0.6640071272850037,
-0.09532751888036728,
0.010802395641803741,
0.10505769401788712,
-0.7657867074012756,
0.9279364347457886,
-0.06377848237752914,
-0.027011685073375702,
-0.29965531826019287,
-0.8277096152305603,
0.1756599247455597,
0.0941077247262001,
-0.6634935736656189,
0.9052572846412659,
0.33797377347946167,
-0.6090944409370422,
0.7534052729606628,
-0.3604486584663391,
-0.3697013556957245,
-0.17125184834003448,
-0.3534298241138458,
-0.955592691898346,
0.23364783823490143,
-0.12132708728313446,
0.21120093762874603,
-0.3355341851711273,
0.4492577612400055,
-0.20604188740253448,
-0.580158531665802,
0.658214807510376,
-0.5128373503684998,
0.500948965549469,
-0.0488177053630352,
-0.38557198643684387,
-0.12351945042610168,
-0.894324779510498,
-0.04584701731801033,
0.02620699815452099,
-0.7160148024559021,
0.04249531403183937,
-0.047324225306510925,
0.20835848152637482,
0.1357182413339615,
0.02725900709629059,
-0.785043478012085,
0.09818187355995178,
-0.042832691222429276,
0.3546518087387085,
0.5479614734649658,
0.31650295853614807,
0.0003998423053417355,
-0.8394876718521118,
0.3544110655784607,
0.15820544958114624,
0.2616608142852783,
-0.3333297371864319,
-0.41884851455688477,
-0.9312624931335449,
-0.4260837137699127,
0.281223863363266,
0.24092240631580353,
0.07199780642986298,
0.2785474956035614,
-0.17658817768096924,
-0.6661733984947205,
-0.6761347055435181,
0.19159455597400665,
0.7449415922164917,
0.7955055832862854,
0.4116738438606262,
-0.42794886231422424,
-0.6140589714050293,
-0.8695107698440552,
-0.12382064014673233,
-0.5114043951034546,
-0.19450971484184265,
0.39147406816482544,
0.1571173369884491,
-0.18846778571605682,
0.8225369453430176,
-0.14420747756958008,
-0.24903245270252228,
-0.28396353125572205,
0.016735272482037544,
0.11904730647802353,
0.44673579931259155,
0.41473668813705444,
-0.3944980800151825,
-0.3612912893295288,
-0.09426061809062958,
-0.8136036992073059,
-0.30647343397140503,
-0.2784106731414795,
0.05271981656551361,
0.3440380096435547,
0.29395705461502075,
-0.7492201328277588,
0.7049330472946167,
0.11506479233503342,
-0.06847473233938217,
0.6287879347801208,
-0.49301886558532715,
0.3563011586666107,
-0.8553459644317627,
0.06416095793247223,
0.0778413787484169,
-0.26736515760421753,
-0.8963854908943176,
-0.39309927821159363,
0.20730437338352203,
0.3017108738422394,
-0.37613099813461304,
0.5626288056373596,
-0.23607736825942993,
0.05306817218661308,
-0.34342747926712036,
0.23471693694591522,
0.16572466492652893,
0.1536746621131897,
-0.04151665046811104,
0.502190351486206,
-0.09242341667413712,
-0.49293702840805054,
0.057254206389188766,
0.33012694120407104,
-0.12360242009162903,
0.5758039355278015,
-0.9691035151481628,
0.4154583215713501,
0.0856628566980362,
0.31910714507102966,
-1.2156141996383667,
-0.005292088259011507,
0.12394235283136368,
-0.37705114483833313,
0.4155549108982086,
0.033780716359615326,
-0.31835129857063293,
-0.30015435814857483,
-0.3245925009250641,
0.026485327631235123,
0.6535059809684753,
-0.22404955327510834,
0.2943962812423706,
0.184896320104599,
-0.08628447353839874,
-0.370343416929245,
-0.6962167024612427,
0.03157452866435051,
-0.36056050658226013,
-0.6310732960700989,
0.3379904627799988,
0.06359532475471497,
-0.5818806886672974,
-0.28847166895866394,
-0.5632824897766113,
0.08166451752185822,
0.10582027584314346,
0.5658136606216431,
0.6287506222724915,
-0.48820528388023376,
-0.04609379172325134,
0.15408341586589813,
-0.3367486894130707,
0.19407831132411957,
0.11166545003652573,
0.1831377148628235,
0.1904773712158203,
-0.6935522556304932,
-1.0880823135375977,
0.1797456443309784,
0.544640302658081,
0.23739506304264069,
0.40383726358413696,
0.38496559858322144,
-0.21707305312156677,
0.11207372695207596,
-0.872406542301178,
-0.28744685649871826,
-0.39657074213027954,
0.042392510920763016,
-0.23964548110961914,
-0.5786450505256653,
0.607484757900238,
0.008957651443779469,
0.3363950252532959,
0.38641032576560974,
0.6729215383529663,
-0.5269389152526855,
0.9611886143684387,
0.5369061827659607,
0.04451264813542366,
-0.12877079844474792,
0.012622893787920475,
0.25797051191329956,
-0.9603010416030884,
-0.3000030815601349,
-0.4435429275035858,
-0.1079268828034401,
-0.5485098361968994,
-0.09569540619850159,
0.5700746178627014,
0.15653502941131592,
-0.34370678663253784,
0.21868197619915009,
-0.2691502869129181,
0.06694744527339935,
0.3841499388217926,
0.41672515869140625,
0.5368671417236328,
-0.18209947645664215,
-0.054995328187942505,
-0.12796753644943237,
-0.40533190965652466,
-1.1463855504989624,
1.3309370279312134,
0.580687403678894,
0.5979725122451782,
0.0941716656088829,
0.8925703763961792,
0.5282267332077026,
0.8359460234642029,
-0.5361340045928955,
0.4684661626815796,
-0.14083604514598846,
-0.28990378975868225,
-0.2237647920846939,
-0.1431092619895935,
-0.8807165026664734,
0.20500217378139496,
-0.2388956993818283,
-0.664112389087677,
-0.1735491305589676,
0.3447335958480835,
-0.41751164197921753,
0.0880071371793747,
-0.26600202918052673,
0.5336170196533203,
-0.24452467262744904,
-0.2600758373737335,
0.14963747560977936,
-0.6906773447990417,
0.3899769186973572,
-0.2434609830379486,
0.0744800716638565,
-0.1360202133655548,
-0.15435253083705902,
0.648568332195282,
-0.8253172039985657,
0.8756800293922424,
-0.04074155539274216,
-0.3669622838497162,
0.3750992715358734,
0.1650146096944809,
0.3505890667438507,
0.3098457157611847,
0.04733578488230705,
0.072564996778965,
-0.01517074927687645,
-0.12300381809473038,
-0.8104719519615173,
0.17375512421131134,
-0.7816345691680908,
-0.874377429485321,
-0.022301143035292625,
-0.5035254955291748,
0.004810350481420755,
-0.009170282632112503,
0.21204274892807007,
0.7390607595443726,
-0.2929978370666504,
-0.1996564120054245,
0.36502957344055176,
0.04401632770895958,
0.300550252199173,
0.7235653400421143,
-0.03235626220703125,
-0.5520046353340149,
0.5420413613319397,
-0.07105313986539841,
0.3819959759712219,
0.24817746877670288,
0.20832626521587372,
-0.3118603825569153,
-0.6143842339515686,
-0.4968513250350952,
0.5514532923698425,
-0.650698184967041,
-0.07184890657663345,
-0.4571826457977295,
-0.29426509141921997,
-0.3132600486278534,
-0.14921249449253082,
-0.30245116353034973,
-0.5464823246002197,
0.07941771298646927,
-0.17711009085178375,
0.07356049865484238,
0.7523332238197327,
0.04626228287816048,
0.17419400811195374,
-0.8772122263908386,
0.15889374911785126,
-0.02304968796670437,
-0.08454533666372299,
-0.02330387383699417,
-0.5356298685073853,
-0.19560202956199646,
0.05459944158792496,
-0.48638391494750977,
-0.7478928565979004,
0.05537848174571991,
-0.13929644227027893,
0.6078718900680542,
0.7363535165786743,
-0.2310122549533844,
0.5816794037818909,
-0.5177701711654663,
0.7617555856704712,
0.37245774269104004,
-0.9254670739173889,
0.584695041179657,
-0.30650779604911804,
-0.18841271102428436,
0.5732595324516296,
0.1352701187133789,
-0.5793591141700745,
-0.7253443598747253,
-0.8290550708770752,
-0.45159539580345154,
0.40094301104545593,
0.27344202995300293,
-0.10810542106628418,
-0.0743914544582367,
0.6126388311386108,
0.2665936052799225,
0.14201730489730835,
-0.3797338902950287,
-0.33127713203430176,
-0.07401308417320251,
-0.2059929221868515,
-0.041867855936288834,
-0.4570767879486084,
-0.5534070730209351,
0.0846295952796936,
0.28293487429618835,
0.08414257317781448,
-0.014044552110135555,
0.40791916847229004,
0.09062236547470093,
-0.009429700672626495,
0.10438431054353714,
0.9115661382675171,
0.80234295129776,
-0.22275641560554504,
0.24989204108715057,
0.1558193564414978,
-0.8457556366920471,
0.5931376814842224,
-0.25760284066200256,
-0.34450167417526245,
0.29787036776542664,
0.8217092156410217,
0.7569133043289185,
0.1947704404592514,
-0.685824453830719,
0.6353973746299744,
-0.06056119129061699,
-0.20693449676036835,
-0.37695467472076416,
0.21506251394748688,
0.19941118359565735,
0.21193115413188934,
-0.13965323567390442,
-0.04603191465139389,
0.11898471415042877,
-0.42823344469070435,
0.28262630105018616,
0.10640028119087219,
-0.42345893383026123,
-0.28636422753334045,
0.9263547658920288,
0.01935947872698307,
-0.568394660949707,
0.8492671847343445,
0.07415669411420822,
-0.054662059992551804,
0.8645216226577759,
0.737653911113739,
0.7627054452896118,
-0.2515840232372284,
0.21142840385437012,
0.2011881172657013,
0.22870907187461853,
-0.09512767195701599,
0.12208101898431778,
-0.1239522248506546,
-0.6335204839706421,
-0.21520784497261047,
-0.39508724212646484,
-0.6625701785087585,
-0.021838506683707237,
-0.9327744841575623,
0.3656826317310333,
-0.4721691608428955,
-0.5396803021430969,
0.16883067786693573,
-0.013216153718531132,
-0.32504042983055115,
0.3242407739162445,
0.08237183094024658,
0.9099946618080139,
-0.8494934439659119,
0.6782952547073364,
0.614065408706665,
-0.5669894814491272,
-1.0602434873580933,
-0.10558749735355377,
0.3909611403942108,
-0.7287197113037109,
0.6300851106643677,
0.012896323576569557,
-0.017341528087854385,
-0.7624397873878479,
0.09883458912372589,
-0.7221349477767944,
1.5225896835327148,
0.25385114550590515,
-0.5259914398193359,
0.1883314698934555,
0.5539115071296692,
0.8826457858085632,
-0.41669321060180664,
0.5756716728210449,
0.7624437212944031,
0.36959943175315857,
-0.014045040123164654,
-1.2184207439422607,
0.26480820775032043,
-0.21284553408622742,
0.07937315851449966,
0.12532596290111542,
-0.7134279608726501,
0.7929322719573975,
-0.49010857939720154,
-0.10257221013307571,
0.41995325684547424,
0.45291951298713684,
0.902492105960846,
0.7602292895317078,
0.41269972920417786,
0.41765138506889343,
1.0041136741638184,
0.022123578935861588,
1.0831199884414673,
-0.33295926451683044,
0.2872088551521301,
1.158481478691101,
-0.5219959616661072,
0.5510224103927612,
0.2757212817668915,
-0.36032748222351074,
0.45369863510131836,
0.469880610704422,
-0.0819089412689209,
0.17936919629573822,
0.2726169526576996,
-0.2541038990020752,
0.08326549082994461,
-0.049390196800231934,
-0.14781874418258667,
0.4326002597808838,
0.02908381260931492,
-0.7648947834968567,
-0.05201349034905434,
-0.33461013436317444,
0.6118512153625488,
-0.03502072021365166,
-0.13168488442897797,
0.8932218551635742,
0.27548304200172424,
-0.641430675983429,
0.671958327293396,
-0.024671852588653564,
0.046371906995773315,
-0.5178148150444031,
-0.018970506265759468,
-0.6215369701385498,
0.23866568505764008,
-0.3597094416618347,
-0.46828213334083557,
0.2267647683620453,
0.04137217625975609,
-0.2661292552947998,
-0.11744683235883713,
0.6157116889953613,
-0.3597494959831238,
-0.4652479290962219,
-0.11346070468425751,
0.4918384253978729,
0.3854241967201233,
0.5397431254386902,
-0.3785260319709778,
0.17125481367111206,
-0.15037132799625397,
-0.2475777417421341,
0.29884886741638184,
0.2565842270851135,
-0.1720985472202301,
0.68288654088974,
0.40516287088394165,
0.2776942551136017,
-0.04872700572013855,
0.5244619250297546,
0.6097854971885681,
-0.4838860332965851,
-0.19329559803009033,
-0.8977447748184204,
0.5573424100875854,
-0.1821064054965973,
-0.572036862373352,
0.8954127430915833,
0.7244119048118591,
0.32285481691360474,
0.11526045948266983,
0.7123993635177612,
0.38581591844558716,
0.5825099945068359,
-0.6794010996818542,
0.6164842247962952,
-0.3127051293849945,
0.3832045793533325,
-0.31208857893943787,
-0.9051705002784729,
-0.13814541697502136,
0.306307852268219,
0.18699988722801208,
0.013106176629662514,
0.8281590938568115,
0.7445014119148254,
-0.04374028369784355,
0.3293275833129883,
-0.00770029379054904,
0.060822341591119766,
0.524551272392273,
0.44355231523513794,
0.7975664138793945,
-0.41177496314048767,
0.1786840707063675,
-0.31182703375816345,
-0.23517730832099915,
0.08976832777261734,
-0.5988796949386597,
-0.7742252349853516,
-0.2783929407596588,
-0.45368900895118713,
-0.6538129448890686,
-0.032283663749694824,
0.8149353265762329,
0.6185324192047119,
-0.6313427090644836,
-0.37635254859924316,
0.09985894709825516,
-0.31156012415885925,
-0.4495869278907776,
-0.08087144047021866,
0.7043905854225159,
-0.3200685977935791,
-0.6108239889144897,
0.24516098201274872,
0.47803640365600586,
0.17074604332447052,
-0.2870270609855652,
-0.07667164504528046,
0.5634831786155701,
0.09901103377342224,
0.33728575706481934,
-0.009651098400354385,
-0.962576687335968,
-0.30414867401123047,
-0.05676538497209549,
-0.3791027367115021,
0.3296237289905548,
1.087900161743164,
-0.4495684504508972,
0.1826794594526291,
0.1554783582687378,
0.4632207453250885,
0.6015779376029968,
0.1499299705028534,
0.37762340903282166,
-0.1948106586933136,
-0.18528053164482117,
0.10699869692325592,
0.5731390714645386,
0.3076230585575104,
-0.3635956048965454,
0.6553531885147095,
0.10247451066970825,
-0.6686033010482788,
-0.8036355376243591,
-0.09851235896348953,
-1.151002049446106,
0.2381332367658615,
1.0118610858917236,
-0.4275580644607544,
-0.03981563448905945,
-0.14336691796779633,
-0.3755190372467041,
0.2355089783668518,
-0.2070506066083908,
1.0212748050689697,
0.36038878560066223,
-0.6319348216056824,
0.0618487149477005,
-0.5635364055633545,
0.5201392769813538,
0.22548900544643402,
-0.699166476726532,
-0.20324237644672394,
0.23343214392662048,
0.6018009185791016,
0.3324895203113556,
1.07243812084198,
-0.293283611536026,
0.42496734857559204,
0.11950971186161041,
-0.12534911930561066,
-0.0682583749294281,
-0.06890718638896942,
-0.10026904195547104,
0.10670346766710281,
-0.0411677286028862,
-0.04275115579366684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06488v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06488v1
|
Pitfalls of Conversational LLMs on News Debiasing
| 2024-04-09T17:42:59 | 2024-04-09T17:42:59 |
Ipek Baris Schlicht, Defne Altiok, Maryanne Taouk, Lucie Flek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper addresses debiasing in news editing and evaluates the
effectiveness of conversational Large Language Models in this task. We designed
an evaluation checklist tailored to news editors' perspectives, obtained
generated texts from three popular conversational models using a subset of a
publicly available dataset in media bias, and evaluated the texts according to
the designed checklist. Furthermore, we examined the models as evaluator for
checking the quality of debiased model outputs. Our findings indicate that none
of the LLMs are perfect in debiasing. Notably, some models, including ChatGPT,
introduced unnecessary changes that may impact the author's style and create
misinformation. Lastly, we show that the models do not perform as proficiently
as domain experts in evaluating the quality of debiased outputs.
|
[
-0.17567138373851776,
-0.8959649801254272,
0.8194870352745056,
0.15013347566127777,
-0.39872151613235474,
0.15176521241664886,
-0.2180929332971573,
-0.25346487760543823,
0.034369971603155136,
0.566502571105957,
-0.4438078999519348,
-0.7085637450218201,
-0.8504831790924072,
0.059388305991888046,
-0.6309216022491455,
1.0351260900497437,
0.08124065399169922,
0.20065711438655853,
-0.26242122054100037,
0.023348230868577957,
-0.5151404142379761,
-0.6081693768501282,
-0.5499693751335144,
-0.21661831438541412,
0.011732480488717556,
0.36426326632499695,
1.1936862468719482,
0.06920803338289261,
0.5835000872612,
0.20520685613155365,
-0.579425573348999,
0.11902359127998352,
-0.8245730996131897,
-0.008985074236989021,
-0.10438471287488937,
-0.40864479541778564,
-0.43412667512893677,
0.4231280982494354,
0.34100615978240967,
0.6538657546043396,
-0.10037731379270554,
0.061732467263936996,
0.1654791533946991,
0.6890401244163513,
-0.33023205399513245,
-0.11629641056060791,
-0.913576066493988,
0.14757755398750305,
0.3189103901386261,
-0.031107904389500618,
-0.42638590931892395,
-0.7022682428359985,
0.2212693840265274,
-0.13925112783908844,
-0.06691308319568634,
-0.14224250614643097,
0.882422685623169,
0.3213624358177185,
-0.5810346007347107,
-0.6095802783966064,
-0.8143243789672852,
0.8196249604225159,
-1.1290068626403809,
0.5019916892051697,
0.5233945846557617,
0.1270102858543396,
-0.1256360411643982,
-0.12258216738700867,
-0.5613129734992981,
-0.4707529842853546,
0.16317406296730042,
0.25983619689941406,
-0.5600137114524841,
0.198409304022789,
0.23743389546871185,
0.33852386474609375,
-0.3561195731163025,
0.30790311098098755,
-0.3913678228855133,
0.3357362151145935,
0.6573231220245361,
0.05656583234667778,
0.0051202489994466305,
-0.5432090759277344,
-0.3156477212905884,
0.4330252707004547,
-0.6642331480979919,
-0.2267036885023117,
0.8810420632362366,
-0.015883276239037514,
-0.23264871537685394,
0.7798690795898438,
-0.22622941434383392,
0.7726433277130127,
0.03623087704181671,
-0.44046881794929504,
0.05356106907129288,
-0.1231314167380333,
-0.3854905962944031,
-0.08612717688083649,
0.5876235365867615,
1.2155219316482544,
0.3659534454345703,
-0.08393297344446182,
-0.15493904054164886,
0.1570984423160553,
0.3453955054283142,
-0.5689953565597534,
-0.15530218183994293,
0.3546629250049591,
-0.5102362036705017,
-0.9131473302841187,
-0.1906866580247879,
-0.7970204949378967,
-0.7240199446678162,
-0.3053975999355316,
0.1457223743200302,
-0.043943118304014206,
0.16158293187618256,
0.30641329288482666,
-0.15906287729740143,
-0.26306745409965515,
0.5123906135559082,
-0.5048739910125732,
-0.0405886135995388,
0.4367620646953583,
0.6371884942054749,
-0.2787252366542816,
0.14010678231716156,
-0.2069399356842041,
-0.1436745524406433,
-0.4766467809677124,
0.6794957518577576,
-0.6542048454284668,
-0.7075605988502502,
0.12917189300060272,
-0.4075513780117035,
0.05352376773953438,
-0.5879107117652893,
0.8653536438941956,
-0.5284340381622314,
0.2906738817691803,
-0.205458402633667,
-0.4028700590133667,
-0.20264385640621185,
0.5053949356079102,
-0.4373857378959656,
0.5864770412445068,
0.08686775714159012,
-0.7726597189903259,
0.20535525679588318,
-0.2803986370563507,
-0.2697488069534302,
-0.5899854302406311,
-0.042058881372213364,
-0.2540269196033478,
0.033772971481084824,
0.37745344638824463,
0.3470327854156494,
-0.13416308164596558,
0.6068074107170105,
-0.4222634434700012,
-0.1948636919260025,
0.7120147943496704,
-0.6911892294883728,
0.6251256465911865,
0.39506685733795166,
-0.12810228765010834,
-0.14578518271446228,
-0.7634734511375427,
-0.25018179416656494,
-0.2261076122522354,
-0.6539602875709534,
-0.3299245834350586,
0.21476083993911743,
-0.10106085985898972,
0.18562932312488556,
-0.17760390043258667,
-0.40214526653289795,
0.13846875727176666,
-0.3108578026294708,
0.48840370774269104,
0.7128927707672119,
0.3929249048233032,
0.18532349169254303,
-0.5542411804199219,
0.4933987557888031,
0.20575055480003357,
0.10071226954460144,
0.012060203589498997,
-0.2771001160144806,
-1.0160499811172485,
0.11937396973371506,
0.35506460070610046,
0.5657177567481995,
-0.7306535243988037,
0.44554761052131653,
0.006793184671550989,
-0.7525447607040405,
-0.375313937664032,
0.29292723536491394,
0.35860973596572876,
0.34071776270866394,
-0.06634233146905899,
-0.1855810582637787,
-0.5338596701622009,
-0.9858840703964233,
-0.6102229952812195,
-0.01087148580700159,
0.25894787907600403,
0.1335485577583313,
0.32471761107444763,
-0.4526941478252411,
0.9148868322372437,
-0.4012662172317505,
0.024387581273913383,
-0.20791076123714447,
0.13932819664478302,
0.27102765440940857,
0.3133428394794464,
0.5275764465332031,
-0.5937879681587219,
-0.018323760479688644,
-0.31669312715530396,
-0.5915554165840149,
-0.38626357913017273,
-0.3156982958316803,
0.005252261180430651,
0.37457725405693054,
0.16765908896923065,
-0.8045099377632141,
0.6259615421295166,
0.7966611981391907,
-0.16268569231033325,
0.6632437109947205,
0.20851926505565643,
0.40767422318458557,
-0.9735220074653625,
-0.25549057126045227,
0.2927458584308624,
-0.3738373816013336,
-0.5314534306526184,
-0.2280949205160141,
-0.4389627277851105,
-0.27036455273628235,
-0.4833335876464844,
0.347900927066803,
-0.38590115308761597,
-0.07793863862752914,
-0.27861830592155457,
0.711942195892334,
0.29126089811325073,
0.18007367849349976,
-0.05331345647573471,
0.3116223216056824,
0.2544737160205841,
-0.6610299348831177,
0.44116079807281494,
0.4858579933643341,
-0.8141297698020935,
0.4838637411594391,
-0.5242897272109985,
0.14961965382099152,
-0.2930290699005127,
0.1528933346271515,
-1.0456562042236328,
-0.10771128535270691,
0.17339536547660828,
-0.3777468800544739,
-0.01255860086530447,
-0.24205036461353302,
-0.3201391100883484,
-0.4354405105113983,
-0.4776606261730194,
-0.08136335015296936,
0.4816564619541168,
-0.2965327501296997,
-0.11839787662029266,
0.5679911971092224,
-0.266882061958313,
-0.49198073148727417,
-1.0872563123703003,
0.3041408956050873,
-0.17856688797473907,
-0.45654335618019104,
0.05240511894226074,
-0.2158709019422531,
-0.7994208931922913,
-0.005770085845142603,
-0.24680303037166595,
-0.07789009064435959,
0.1124792993068695,
0.15314289927482605,
0.2914329767227173,
-0.040018532425165176,
0.09033806622028351,
-0.03581057861447334,
0.18124884366989136,
0.024127067998051643,
0.5029363036155701,
0.34665754437446594,
0.10598388314247131,
-0.6768627762794495,
-0.4945005476474762,
0.03860987722873688,
0.6254390478134155,
-0.00224970537237823,
0.313205361366272,
0.038361258804798126,
-0.23558884859085083,
0.044936131685972214,
-1.029617190361023,
-0.11068277806043625,
-0.32721397280693054,
0.5482980608940125,
0.12797288596630096,
-0.8126075863838196,
0.39605969190597534,
0.28072577714920044,
0.06587722897529602,
0.24491728842258453,
0.6408403515815735,
0.09869474917650223,
0.9958910346031189,
0.27695944905281067,
-0.1706729382276535,
0.3438790440559387,
-0.08753790706396103,
0.5002850890159607,
-0.5361678600311279,
0.10117633640766144,
-0.5899721384048462,
-0.3175329864025116,
-0.4714091122150421,
-0.3028779923915863,
0.30877476930618286,
0.10634654015302658,
-0.058316778391599655,
-0.08131013065576553,
-0.32681941986083984,
0.5340688228607178,
0.4894144833087921,
0.01745506003499031,
0.7037122845649719,
0.03131885454058647,
0.40056082606315613,
-0.09125349670648575,
-0.6924571394920349,
-0.9319858551025391,
0.8262290358543396,
0.6657328605651855,
1.426222324371338,
0.08636710792779922,
0.5122085809707642,
0.49341878294944763,
0.14885026216506958,
-0.8982965350151062,
0.4332332909107208,
-0.04419886693358421,
-0.525323748588562,
-0.11810982972383499,
-0.27995431423187256,
-0.47432586550712585,
0.32629692554473877,
-0.29773712158203125,
-0.8612762689590454,
0.413689523935318,
-0.03387567028403282,
-0.45830413699150085,
0.36754998564720154,
-0.6491027474403381,
0.6887656450271606,
-0.22255264222621918,
-0.06451182067394257,
-0.2640928626060486,
-0.19733081758022308,
0.7785127758979797,
-0.06791464984416962,
0.492274671792984,
-0.27550145983695984,
0.13766677677631378,
0.7796941995620728,
0.06020788848400116,
1.1203652620315552,
0.003581423545256257,
-0.15159153938293457,
0.5489481687545776,
0.3319665491580963,
0.41081762313842773,
0.20369605720043182,
-0.30647099018096924,
0.24129103124141693,
-0.008905983529984951,
0.009052184410393238,
-0.30970457196235657,
0.6635017991065979,
-0.8850303292274475,
-1.004145860671997,
-0.3551871180534363,
-0.4575915038585663,
-0.40868517756462097,
-0.10982353985309601,
0.05278348922729492,
0.4767583906650543,
-0.4680190086364746,
0.2672573924064636,
0.16645346581935883,
-0.314678817987442,
0.30371081829071045,
0.5449755191802979,
-0.3658958375453949,
-0.40617406368255615,
0.3440559208393097,
0.2090703397989273,
0.35498347878456116,
0.036723848432302475,
0.08462212234735489,
-0.013144698925316334,
-0.7311640381813049,
-0.48576733469963074,
-0.12483847886323929,
-0.8698517084121704,
-0.2964453399181366,
-0.6438683867454529,
-0.3266989290714264,
-0.4031440019607544,
-0.12389269471168518,
-0.271327942609787,
-0.5316892862319946,
-0.444313645362854,
-0.2846611738204956,
0.03897625580430031,
1.004309892654419,
0.2153606414794922,
0.5924584865570068,
-0.9404357671737671,
0.2793678641319275,
0.17582820355892181,
0.1222599670290947,
-0.24201184511184692,
-0.6267156004905701,
-0.17191603779792786,
0.3706834018230438,
-0.8349155187606812,
-1.2899150848388672,
0.5035325884819031,
-0.388331800699234,
0.6281135082244873,
0.3957955241203308,
0.21106013655662537,
0.4441879093647003,
-0.18201953172683716,
1.145340085029602,
0.08202847838401794,
-0.9147003293037415,
0.5264866352081299,
-0.5049737095832825,
0.11281656473875046,
0.5057355165481567,
0.41327163577079773,
-0.6005054116249084,
-0.8822710514068604,
-0.6528995037078857,
-0.4588433504104614,
0.5215767025947571,
0.11108462512493134,
0.4895651638507843,
-0.4048607051372528,
0.05403157323598862,
0.277424156665802,
0.6708056330680847,
-0.9509889483451843,
-0.0772879496216774,
-0.09143057465553284,
0.15923921763896942,
0.06631788611412048,
-1.0647549629211426,
-0.23200251162052155,
-0.10418243706226349,
1.0681606531143188,
0.12575751543045044,
-0.016458693891763687,
0.33908799290657043,
-0.2533116042613983,
-0.23414716124534607,
0.5789290070533752,
0.770503580570221,
1.0513685941696167,
-0.27466118335723877,
0.10149082541465759,
0.1366998553276062,
-0.113715760409832,
-0.04089224711060524,
-0.005319654475897551,
-0.3263130187988281,
0.39975690841674805,
0.16360606253147125,
0.9583643078804016,
0.4890376925468445,
-0.5409567952156067,
0.6458278894424438,
0.13462382555007935,
-0.27443262934684753,
-0.22477088868618011,
-0.09910974651575089,
0.22162769734859467,
0.41818666458129883,
0.07723546773195267,
0.25250616669654846,
0.16486774384975433,
-0.5629668831825256,
-0.10018443316221237,
0.6698718667030334,
-0.3743257522583008,
-0.11434707045555115,
0.6379623413085938,
0.4625351130962372,
-0.15401265025138855,
0.4069279432296753,
-0.060453929007053375,
-0.5437653660774231,
0.4481387138366699,
0.44082212448120117,
0.838106095790863,
-0.08758086711168289,
0.28623178601264954,
0.1411011815071106,
0.5427805185317993,
-0.03730613738298416,
-0.017589308321475983,
0.323544442653656,
-0.9629210829734802,
-0.3001430630683899,
-0.5826486945152283,
-0.7548475861549377,
0.5250824689865112,
-0.2449655532836914,
0.5460569262504578,
-0.2552920877933502,
-0.3700360357761383,
0.030084799975156784,
-0.14022435247898102,
-0.541034460067749,
0.22289620339870453,
0.18209119141101837,
0.8841426968574524,
-0.6862965226173401,
0.49358341097831726,
0.4662403166294098,
-0.3338095545768738,
-0.30759403109550476,
0.18359626829624176,
0.22625026106834412,
-0.8064619302749634,
0.46391141414642334,
-0.023010963574051857,
0.27479106187820435,
-0.28233450651168823,
-0.3577364981174469,
-0.6938006281852722,
0.6889231204986572,
0.6313916444778442,
-0.8362779021263123,
-0.09393247961997986,
0.19278749823570251,
0.2462175339460373,
-0.3059785068035126,
0.4297792315483093,
0.5106516480445862,
0.6233330368995667,
-0.03205877169966698,
-1.0370569229125977,
-0.2740054726600647,
0.07719063013792038,
-0.05897483974695206,
-0.3894332945346832,
-0.7396061420440674,
0.8569260239601135,
-0.24644418060779572,
-0.0710502341389656,
-0.04808616265654564,
0.12218590080738068,
-0.14725498855113983,
0.25058412551879883,
0.48316332697868347,
0.6800060868263245,
0.6008288860321045,
0.11262846738100052,
1.1217598915100098,
-0.24710559844970703,
0.45646268129348755,
1.1055694818496704,
-0.2927951216697693,
0.5513047575950623,
0.29984694719314575,
-0.23819607496261597,
0.23382455110549927,
0.5787807106971741,
-0.09176978468894958,
0.3713876008987427,
0.18584446609020233,
-0.2268754094839096,
-0.09906827658414841,
-0.03933459892868996,
-0.29131704568862915,
0.62029629945755,
0.05224394425749779,
-0.6057116985321045,
-0.5942825675010681,
0.13777142763137817,
0.45204421877861023,
0.1871640682220459,
-0.26151949167251587,
0.6923738121986389,
0.20304721593856812,
-0.6244025826454163,
0.5641389489173889,
0.2461928278207779,
0.6824758648872375,
-0.12348155677318573,
0.12069566547870636,
-0.2519983649253845,
-0.07597097754478455,
-0.38081759214401245,
-0.88104248046875,
0.5266121625900269,
0.22931014001369476,
-0.24035020172595978,
-0.06522229313850403,
0.9739007353782654,
-0.4716849625110626,
-0.51643306016922,
-0.09415007382631302,
0.9483551383018494,
0.2941031754016876,
-0.24978743493556976,
-0.5934014320373535,
0.4357789158821106,
0.35578474402427673,
-0.8225623965263367,
0.05564771965146065,
0.024314533919095993,
0.07616272568702698,
0.5487825870513916,
0.5696181654930115,
-0.00796484388411045,
-0.3138750493526459,
0.23978208005428314,
0.8967569470405579,
-0.7751309871673584,
-0.26407143473625183,
-1.2238913774490356,
0.33167919516563416,
-0.055285703390836716,
-0.26884639263153076,
0.8018104434013367,
0.6470503807067871,
0.6689134240150452,
-0.2791149318218231,
0.9520145058631897,
0.22323361039161682,
0.6547257304191589,
-0.721615731716156,
0.8299076557159424,
-0.07724439352750778,
0.4361056387424469,
-0.3098084628582001,
-0.9724146127700806,
-0.21802759170532227,
0.49468928575515747,
-0.7941147089004517,
0.14872479438781738,
0.617842435836792,
0.9364399313926697,
0.08095192909240723,
0.2815941870212555,
0.7641900777816772,
0.585039496421814,
0.23498548567295074,
0.3084932565689087,
1.215886116027832,
-0.14514663815498352,
0.4087305963039398,
-0.40660303831100464,
-0.030215876176953316,
-0.29732006788253784,
-1.1628676652908325,
-1.2495766878128052,
-0.322886198759079,
-0.3549130856990814,
-0.3825834393501282,
0.35118961334228516,
0.8417606353759766,
0.5543574690818787,
-0.3939332962036133,
0.014085179194808006,
0.22194892168045044,
0.5810539722442627,
0.3915281295776367,
-0.3045490086078644,
0.05358339846134186,
-0.35006198287010193,
-0.9544180035591125,
0.2598629593849182,
-0.07839613407850266,
0.04536745324730873,
-0.27092158794403076,
0.24570423364639282,
0.04888283833861351,
0.23887795209884644,
0.6532110571861267,
-0.34569641947746277,
-0.7620712518692017,
-0.5917285680770874,
-0.5073344707489014,
-0.1721198409795761,
0.0774560272693634,
0.42689844965934753,
-0.7413756847381592,
0.24304184317588806,
0.20153570175170898,
0.537746012210846,
0.24750067293643951,
0.2061169296503067,
0.3460000157356262,
-0.5215275287628174,
0.1471792310476303,
0.23039212822914124,
0.32480284571647644,
0.6444181799888611,
-0.438846617937088,
0.49779966473579407,
0.24222508072853088,
-0.6978952884674072,
-0.9766468405723572,
0.18327860534191132,
-1.1671931743621826,
-0.11569961905479431,
1.5703158378601074,
0.11065332591533661,
-0.13192838430404663,
0.0998530387878418,
-0.6251471638679504,
0.001584819401614368,
-0.33516329526901245,
0.9079950451850891,
1.1022735834121704,
0.03954675793647766,
0.021416865289211273,
-1.1177479028701782,
0.3884235620498657,
0.11450707912445068,
-0.6993823647499084,
0.21854747831821442,
0.7933988571166992,
0.28355053067207336,
-0.08764196932315826,
0.636322557926178,
-0.1184319257736206,
0.16750051081180573,
-0.08494741469621658,
0.057863809168338776,
-0.10552974045276642,
0.15944771468639374,
-0.27877676486968994,
-0.18401962518692017,
0.49526146054267883,
-0.04897693544626236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06480v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06480v2
|
Ada-LEval: Evaluating long-context LLMs with length-adaptable benchmarks
| 2024-04-09T17:30:48 | 2024-04-10T07:40:56 |
Chonghua Wang, Haodong Duan, Songyang Zhang, Dahua Lin, Kai Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, the large language model (LLM) community has shown increasing
interest in enhancing LLMs' capability to handle extremely long documents. As
various long-text techniques and model architectures emerge, the precise and
detailed evaluation of models' long-text capabilities has become increasingly
important. Existing long-text evaluation benchmarks, such as L-Eval and
LongBench, construct long-text test sets based on open-source datasets,
focusing mainly on QA and summarization tasks. These datasets include test
samples of varying lengths (from 2k to 32k+) entangled together, making it
challenging to assess model capabilities across different length ranges.
Moreover, they do not cover the ultralong settings (100k+ tokens) that the
latest LLMs claim to achieve. In this paper, we introduce Ada-LEval, a
length-adaptable benchmark for evaluating the long-context understanding of
LLMs. Ada-LEval includes two challenging subsets, TSort and BestAnswer, which
enable a more reliable evaluation of LLMs' long context capabilities. These
benchmarks support intricate manipulation of the length of test cases, and can
easily produce text samples up to 128k tokens. We evaluate 4 state-of-the-art
closed-source API models and 6 open-source models with Ada-LEval. The
evaluation results demonstrate the limitations of current LLMs, especially in
ultra-long-context settings. Our code is available at
https://github.com/open-compass/Ada-LEval.
|
[
-0.25443100929260254,
-0.7397662997245789,
0.7517989277839661,
0.41066157817840576,
-0.31651028990745544,
-0.025493880733847618,
-0.5003287196159363,
-0.6521427035331726,
-0.15449443459510803,
0.15218327939510345,
-0.1939922720193863,
-0.531967043876648,
-0.30487266182899475,
0.34671035408973694,
-0.5823194980621338,
1.0636286735534668,
-0.5135425925254822,
-0.13010743260383606,
-0.4702985882759094,
-0.5260498523712158,
-0.36602696776390076,
-0.3649592697620392,
-0.416493684053421,
0.06944264471530914,
0.29060131311416626,
0.14447101950645447,
0.4424137473106384,
0.5120739340782166,
0.4278871417045593,
0.2001095563173294,
-0.4603446125984192,
0.10763367265462875,
-0.5099455714225769,
0.2693845331668854,
-0.02452193945646286,
-0.39055830240249634,
-0.7456908226013184,
-0.17269006371498108,
1.1220570802688599,
0.5751470327377319,
-0.16553367674350739,
0.5206087231636047,
0.11395374685525894,
0.8703637719154358,
-0.4915434420108795,
0.025550514459609985,
-0.53509521484375,
-0.12553374469280243,
-0.19110529124736786,
0.10887648910284042,
-0.17541737854480743,
-0.28060442209243774,
0.1340363621711731,
-0.5281381607055664,
-0.1613573431968689,
0.21994471549987793,
0.5697298049926758,
0.1618526577949524,
-0.5078908801078796,
-0.32046785950660706,
-0.5317325592041016,
0.872223436832428,
-0.8750112056732178,
0.5155201554298401,
0.3045641779899597,
0.4613928496837616,
-0.1807100921869278,
-0.6788235902786255,
-0.3943163752555847,
-0.35091233253479004,
0.24299024045467377,
-0.09907848387956619,
-0.14095531404018402,
-0.006426655687391758,
0.35784977674484253,
0.5599321126937866,
-0.626365065574646,
0.3922984004020691,
-0.386541485786438,
0.028512345626950264,
0.46607694029808044,
0.2671998143196106,
0.14527377486228943,
-0.04398677125573158,
-0.4409711956977844,
0.22530683875083923,
-0.8927384614944458,
0.08901926875114441,
0.2693469226360321,
0.0963049978017807,
-0.2583576440811157,
0.6819623112678528,
-0.2583206295967102,
0.7481145858764648,
-0.2223566621541977,
0.07371950149536133,
0.2933008670806885,
-0.3184277415275574,
-0.31773391366004944,
-0.09587529301643372,
0.6241725087165833,
0.307418555021286,
0.14499077200889587,
-0.20283836126327515,
-0.5558304190635681,
-0.27108055353164673,
-0.10395970195531845,
-1.1215795278549194,
0.3059486746788025,
0.4344029724597931,
-0.5401813983917236,
-0.09170449525117874,
-0.4039541482925415,
-0.9302499294281006,
-0.4941904544830322,
-0.15770132839679718,
0.42847809195518494,
-0.30765464901924133,
-0.09356673806905746,
0.08880757540464401,
0.13205644488334656,
0.3197301924228668,
0.14375770092010498,
-0.6618332862854004,
0.5262144804000854,
0.8819294571876526,
1.152376651763916,
-0.46422290802001953,
-0.43279409408569336,
-0.8314047455787659,
-0.0758008062839508,
-0.4192065894603729,
0.6627365350723267,
-0.49545854330062866,
-0.4200904369354248,
-0.02892712503671646,
-0.08895716816186905,
0.02066972479224205,
-0.4401392340660095,
0.6367051005363464,
-0.6705617308616638,
0.10492060333490372,
-0.07823852449655533,
-0.8907071948051453,
0.059287846088409424,
0.349653035402298,
-0.6739274263381958,
1.013448715209961,
0.20414192974567413,
-0.530061662197113,
0.12451620399951935,
-0.8477451205253601,
-0.5055525898933411,
-0.08315970748662949,
-0.09471285343170166,
-0.4791163206100464,
0.25123873353004456,
0.24830618500709534,
0.15866491198539734,
-0.6229486465454102,
0.09740740060806274,
-0.33553069829940796,
-0.49988970160484314,
0.325732558965683,
-0.6816493272781372,
0.5697965025901794,
0.11424592137336731,
-0.2255682498216629,
0.4028424322605133,
-1.0793012380599976,
-0.035127706825733185,
-0.009613486006855965,
-0.5253558158874512,
-0.33442792296409607,
0.016111785545945168,
0.11864341050386429,
-0.12083524465560913,
0.5052348971366882,
-0.5731600522994995,
-0.12785238027572632,
-0.46450138092041016,
0.5265545845031738,
1.028194785118103,
-0.25137120485305786,
0.3781188428401947,
-0.3112964630126953,
0.612859845161438,
-0.3506672978401184,
0.07806334644556046,
-0.2186235785484314,
-0.17532186210155487,
-0.5199781060218811,
-0.3974021375179291,
0.5536271333694458,
0.22094953060150146,
-0.3393663167953491,
0.41599297523498535,
-0.5359084010124207,
-0.3612760305404663,
-0.3832448124885559,
0.2014051377773285,
0.4037090837955475,
0.4164944887161255,
0.3552815914154053,
-0.29393190145492554,
-0.29596853256225586,
-0.697097897529602,
-0.27877697348594666,
-0.11946112662553787,
-0.20244477689266205,
0.33281761407852173,
0.6253594160079956,
-0.12923818826675415,
0.8631888628005981,
-0.33787551522254944,
-0.08326027542352676,
-0.04789606109261513,
0.0037205079570412636,
0.3188401758670807,
0.23598529398441315,
0.4553249478340149,
-0.5030273795127869,
-0.4498426616191864,
-0.10032498836517334,
-0.5424132347106934,
-0.10273916274309158,
0.048834290355443954,
0.15299057960510254,
0.3388768136501312,
0.5522406101226807,
-0.6633099913597107,
0.4215563237667084,
0.7374966144561768,
-0.4880214333534241,
0.8697802424430847,
-0.31922999024391174,
-0.020748868584632874,
-1.1420671939849854,
0.180928036570549,
-0.12326034903526306,
-0.44449126720428467,
-0.398560106754303,
0.26099443435668945,
0.3852042555809021,
-0.07325588166713715,
-0.26829269528388977,
0.8267781138420105,
-0.5533144474029541,
-0.5122175216674805,
-0.3607092797756195,
0.1880609691143036,
-0.02056901529431343,
0.33188819885253906,
-0.20143021643161774,
1.068355679512024,
0.599112868309021,
-0.5721078515052795,
0.4583933353424072,
0.24930469691753387,
-0.7939073443412781,
0.7257947325706482,
-0.9122694134712219,
0.1984180212020874,
0.07454545795917511,
0.3359636068344116,
-0.7849730253219604,
-0.01666862703859806,
-0.20999343693256378,
-0.15657009184360504,
0.1716146171092987,
-0.19652970135211945,
-0.6230387687683105,
-0.16591206192970276,
-0.49402734637260437,
0.8849373459815979,
0.512291431427002,
-0.7582215070724487,
0.5835875272750854,
0.1966453492641449,
-0.25364208221435547,
-0.6241431832313538,
-0.5381952524185181,
0.35442811250686646,
-0.38659676909446716,
-0.4048702120780945,
0.3539917767047882,
-0.4732322096824646,
-0.2546548843383789,
-0.11124929785728455,
-0.39288967847824097,
0.06455106288194656,
0.04367108643054962,
0.25243133306503296,
0.15299539268016815,
-0.3812050223350525,
0.3358118534088135,
-0.08929131180047989,
0.07363900542259216,
0.05550215020775795,
-0.011885351501405239,
0.4857938289642334,
-0.6745915412902832,
-0.5326510071754456,
-0.10162611305713654,
0.14431333541870117,
0.820012629032135,
-0.45719972252845764,
0.6069193482398987,
0.2704998254776001,
-0.41206493973731995,
-0.3981664180755615,
-0.5030504465103149,
0.2455286979675293,
-0.45401808619499207,
0.6792013049125671,
-0.4764367938041687,
-0.8746548891067505,
0.6451168060302734,
-0.09006864577531815,
0.27356234192848206,
0.23738881945610046,
0.45660534501075745,
0.1898622363805771,
0.7025811672210693,
0.5127387046813965,
-0.3158800005912781,
0.31742823123931885,
0.048122838139534,
-0.07584065943956375,
-1.200253963470459,
0.10554911941289902,
-0.32462576031684875,
-0.18891440331935883,
-0.32214751839637756,
-0.4461880028247833,
0.4112688899040222,
-0.030425969511270523,
-0.31287479400634766,
0.19428634643554688,
0.0022150040604174137,
0.528073251247406,
0.19244424998760223,
-0.05481540411710739,
0.40347275137901306,
-0.2661997675895691,
-0.0732584148645401,
0.3489142656326294,
-0.18981622159481049,
-0.45317044854164124,
1.4709231853485107,
0.6912946701049805,
0.7492242455482483,
0.2863674759864807,
0.429800420999527,
0.24639663100242615,
0.21732595562934875,
-0.9427663683891296,
0.7286550998687744,
0.06950953602790833,
-0.4231158494949341,
-0.5629671216011047,
-0.4884538948535919,
-0.9807513356208801,
0.0636163055896759,
0.12305127084255219,
-0.5547341108322144,
0.09074517339468002,
-0.3091159462928772,
-0.33658698201179504,
0.4261150062084198,
-0.37523147463798523,
0.7424090504646301,
-0.4328102469444275,
-0.2669341266155243,
-0.251776784658432,
-0.37919119000434875,
0.14098118245601654,
-0.364818274974823,
0.2292298674583435,
-0.3719578981399536,
-0.4119660258293152,
0.80189049243927,
-0.3814670443534851,
0.5006769299507141,
0.10554786026477814,
-0.42967933416366577,
0.07919368892908096,
0.1141657680273056,
0.5063801407814026,
0.13187961280345917,
-0.26407143473625183,
0.14475548267364502,
0.1147591769695282,
-0.3367408215999603,
-0.4132254719734192,
0.8625081777572632,
-0.5551660060882568,
-0.4340764582157135,
-0.37367889285087585,
-0.8040482401847839,
-0.5152261853218079,
0.3329460322856903,
-0.1697283238172531,
0.6833664774894714,
-0.5086390972137451,
0.27098846435546875,
0.5590707063674927,
-0.2718746066093445,
0.6326773762702942,
0.6712548136711121,
-0.5244043469429016,
-0.3284541070461273,
0.6631350517272949,
-0.1740536093711853,
0.3236114978790283,
0.15137618780136108,
0.11393505334854126,
-0.46739205718040466,
-0.895828127861023,
-0.5513242483139038,
0.04137604683637619,
-0.8390130400657654,
-0.19898924231529236,
-0.10873991250991821,
-0.2259230613708496,
-0.060520075261592865,
0.1784130036830902,
-0.4029322862625122,
-0.41229113936424255,
-0.28934359550476074,
-0.09878479689359665,
0.42770862579345703,
0.6860011219978333,
0.04407023638486862,
-0.11172103881835938,
-0.6920608282089233,
0.5247666239738464,
0.427776575088501,
0.8778244853019714,
0.08860409259796143,
-0.7572037577629089,
-0.23099611699581146,
-0.13505549728870392,
0.02351553924381733,
-0.7220644354820251,
0.0013729333877563477,
0.3017690181732178,
0.3583908677101135,
0.1760423481464386,
0.019445596262812614,
0.639352023601532,
-0.7232946753501892,
0.6252223253250122,
0.05910835415124893,
-0.9105923175811768,
0.25228095054626465,
-0.30353254079818726,
0.32096239924430847,
0.6278208494186401,
0.07719504088163376,
-0.5116442441940308,
-0.1029672846198082,
-0.0658806785941124,
-0.8400514721870422,
0.3688296675682068,
0.2804194390773773,
0.13481907546520233,
0.06338979303836823,
0.4053049087524414,
0.14256218075752258,
0.024817682802677155,
-0.7453649044036865,
-0.056716188788414,
0.156307652592659,
-0.3627066910266876,
-0.05038018524646759,
-0.4091876447200775,
-0.2430185228586197,
-0.07846204936504364,
0.49993157386779785,
-0.13253140449523926,
-0.06523796170949936,
0.12259253114461899,
-0.3982304632663727,
-0.09414289146661758,
0.644812822341919,
0.5325298309326172,
1.2742164134979248,
-0.43387699127197266,
0.02671349234879017,
0.5164093375205994,
-0.28105875849723816,
0.032141100615262985,
0.5390247106552124,
0.03681035339832306,
-0.14218494296073914,
0.23450222611427307,
0.7262130379676819,
0.16362841427326202,
-1.095709204673767,
0.6559011936187744,
-0.2657996714115143,
-0.03379565849900246,
-0.340262770652771,
-0.27100542187690735,
0.1961788386106491,
0.3431110084056854,
0.3757086992263794,
-0.1846759170293808,
0.02219892106950283,
-0.4967532753944397,
0.07411022484302521,
0.45595335960388184,
-0.3977091312408447,
-0.29792749881744385,
0.6144955158233643,
0.18243131041526794,
-0.2815638780593872,
0.4111061692237854,
-0.09183090180158615,
-0.24660494923591614,
0.6389893293380737,
0.6161388158798218,
0.8651665449142456,
-0.060986071825027466,
-0.12493912130594254,
0.1757487803697586,
0.13420532643795013,
-0.19339808821678162,
0.12720973789691925,
-0.1588105857372284,
-0.27723294496536255,
-0.4791657328605652,
-0.8547565937042236,
-0.3744869530200958,
0.3157353699207306,
-0.6372025609016418,
0.24478358030319214,
-0.3326764404773712,
0.016726398840546608,
-0.27106863260269165,
-0.08344815671443939,
-0.5158583521842957,
-0.10011955350637436,
0.06591875106096268,
1.1955387592315674,
-0.47222796082496643,
0.5998748540878296,
0.540134847164154,
-0.04261992499232292,
-0.24728086590766907,
0.17494899034500122,
-0.21749939024448395,
-0.922700047492981,
0.35623183846473694,
0.37427589297294617,
-0.08253303915262222,
-0.14197297394275665,
-0.30194929242134094,
-0.7547257542610168,
1.270695447921753,
0.16327784955501556,
-0.8416831493377686,
-0.13590474426746368,
0.21091701090335846,
0.694717288017273,
-0.17453086376190186,
0.19332478940486908,
0.6036274433135986,
0.2530458867549896,
-0.24968861043453217,
-1.283316969871521,
0.28585293889045715,
-0.1477285474538803,
0.0649426057934761,
0.13781525194644928,
-0.7024902701377869,
0.684421956539154,
-0.19718322157859802,
-0.2129945456981659,
0.6238751411437988,
0.8506063222885132,
0.49754899740219116,
0.312966525554657,
0.6306772828102112,
0.7042030096054077,
0.7455931901931763,
0.33951807022094727,
0.9248597025871277,
-0.44218960404396057,
0.3681020140647888,
1.21690833568573,
-0.3608200252056122,
1.195261001586914,
0.3358869254589081,
-0.3619050085544586,
0.504203200340271,
0.5369665622711182,
0.009670421481132507,
0.2980736792087555,
0.5421292185783386,
-0.3913830816745758,
0.06087614968419075,
0.1316957175731659,
-0.458341121673584,
0.19896769523620605,
0.3158804476261139,
-0.1399671584367752,
-0.3260950446128845,
-0.09159873425960541,
-0.13643096387386322,
0.1257007122039795,
-0.4499157965183258,
0.5605452656745911,
0.3595450818538666,
-0.5494418144226074,
0.631852924823761,
0.14573265612125397,
0.720818042755127,
-0.477899432182312,
0.16545982658863068,
-0.26076099276542664,
0.10094542801380157,
0.03630451485514641,
-0.8515704274177551,
-0.04953144118189812,
0.3056944012641907,
0.1271357238292694,
0.08395668864250183,
0.5848789811134338,
-0.26678454875946045,
-0.4836157262325287,
0.24213454127311707,
0.4493107497692108,
0.1010190099477768,
-0.054340243339538574,
-0.6104188561439514,
0.01609901338815689,
-0.40204745531082153,
-0.4803018867969513,
0.45345592498779297,
0.3116746246814728,
0.02511574886739254,
0.7182384729385376,
0.478159099817276,
0.3296475410461426,
-0.0790192186832428,
0.10263650864362717,
0.7640643119812012,
-0.662703275680542,
-0.39759373664855957,
-0.9737130403518677,
0.1637355387210846,
0.005370041821151972,
-0.34909361600875854,
0.6343769431114197,
0.8821386098861694,
0.456533282995224,
0.2343500852584839,
0.6772681474685669,
0.10431662201881409,
0.5242867469787598,
-0.5908352136611938,
0.6791335940361023,
-0.7197926044464111,
0.5114665031433105,
0.015406969003379345,
-1.052917242050171,
-0.054054226726293564,
0.09066750109195709,
-0.30075907707214355,
0.10653498023748398,
0.6864011287689209,
0.5912347435951233,
-0.20984353125095367,
-0.09647533297538757,
0.1416711062192917,
0.3392331004142761,
0.4168919324874878,
0.7724682688713074,
0.9487165808677673,
-0.29510068893432617,
0.834484338760376,
0.16315674781799316,
-0.29950785636901855,
-0.1164795383810997,
-1.0922738313674927,
-1.1563103199005127,
-0.5429597496986389,
-0.028880298137664795,
-0.2983930706977844,
0.16741535067558289,
0.7642263770103455,
0.436447411775589,
-0.7027571797370911,
-0.3068157434463501,
-0.1429063230752945,
0.17870520055294037,
-0.05579867586493492,
-0.183977410197258,
0.739319920539856,
-0.37794217467308044,
-0.7024028301239014,
0.652331531047821,
0.32957226037979126,
0.13250499963760376,
-0.2303963452577591,
-0.19228039681911469,
0.21198907494544983,
0.14123547077178955,
0.6146730780601501,
0.4620177745819092,
-0.5413788557052612,
-0.27049490809440613,
-0.08699343353509903,
0.014609524980187416,
0.15360309183597565,
0.47922593355178833,
-0.5819834470748901,
0.5102242231369019,
0.40303927659988403,
0.8108105659484863,
0.4569997489452362,
-0.030430423095822334,
0.6737707853317261,
-0.685886025428772,
-0.12749198079109192,
0.2216089814901352,
0.5648049116134644,
0.23659057915210724,
-0.001571853063069284,
0.5367594957351685,
-0.18163610994815826,
-0.7744729518890381,
-1.2326041460037231,
0.13861234486103058,
-0.9340118169784546,
-0.42727339267730713,
1.4485841989517212,
-0.2133939117193222,
-0.2378581315279007,
0.050796352326869965,
0.019749663770198822,
0.10614534467458725,
-0.15094900131225586,
0.8350515961647034,
0.7012107968330383,
0.12697556614875793,
0.02869449183344841,
-0.6835989356040955,
0.4771387577056885,
0.5032551884651184,
-0.9723514318466187,
0.34895753860473633,
0.4869493246078491,
0.5489099621772766,
-0.08577941358089447,
0.6142645478248596,
-0.27105551958084106,
0.39664530754089355,
-0.287128210067749,
-0.15217286348342896,
-0.25480321049690247,
-0.18343795835971832,
-0.5737481117248535,
-0.03453299403190613,
0.3508324921131134,
-0.08967709541320801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06479v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06479v3
|
Text-Based Reasoning About Vector Graphics
| 2024-04-09T17:30:18 | 2024-05-24T19:40:26 |
Zhenhailong Wang, Joy Hsu, Xingyao Wang, Kuan-Hao Huang, Manling Li, Jiajun Wu, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
While large multimodal models excel in broad vision-language benchmarks, they
often struggle with tasks requiring precise perception of low-level visual
details, such as comparing line lengths or solving simple mazes. In particular,
this failure mode persists in question-answering tasks about vector graphics --
images composed purely of 2D objects and shapes. To address this challenge, we
propose the Visually Descriptive Language Model (VDLM), which performs
text-based reasoning about vector graphics. VDLM leverages Scalable Vector
Graphics (SVG) for a more precise visual description and first uses an
off-the-shelf raster-to-SVG algorithm for encoding. Since existing language
models cannot understand raw SVGs in a zero-shot setting, VDLM then bridges SVG
with pretrained language models through a newly introduced intermediate
symbolic representation, Primal Visual Description (PVD), comprising primitive
attributes (e.g., shape, position, measurement) with their corresponding
predicted values. PVD is task-agnostic and represents visual primitives that
are universal across all vector graphics. It can be learned with procedurally
generated (SVG, PVD) pairs and also enables the direct use of LLMs for
generalization to complex reasoning tasks. By casting an image to a text-based
representation, we can leverage the power of language models to learn alignment
from SVG to visual primitives and generalize to unseen question-answering
tasks. Empirical results show that VDLM achieves stronger zero-shot performance
compared to state-of-the-art LMMs, such as GPT-4V, in various low-level
multimodal perception and reasoning tasks on vector graphics. We additionally
present extensive analyses on VDLM's performance, demonstrating that our
framework offers better interpretability due to its disentangled perception and
reasoning processes. Project page: https://mikewangwzhl.github.io/VDLM/
|
[
-0.2827162742614746,
-0.975786030292511,
0.8500872254371643,
0.09421046078205109,
-0.42112892866134644,
-0.0534500814974308,
-0.1128457561135292,
-0.4992201328277588,
-0.22621266543865204,
0.5916650891304016,
-0.5779256224632263,
-0.8103664517402649,
-0.4319900572299957,
0.103111132979393,
-0.3550470173358917,
0.7811470031738281,
-0.23120234906673431,
0.08258341252803802,
-0.6653039455413818,
-0.15976224839687347,
-0.4253438711166382,
-0.5292196273803711,
-0.38388389348983765,
-0.24028128385543823,
0.5830599665641785,
0.10688892006874084,
0.6091123819351196,
0.9434487819671631,
0.6282301545143127,
0.3200548589229584,
-0.006811484694480896,
0.20930266380310059,
-0.43125298619270325,
0.08667111396789551,
-0.2692059874534607,
-0.6617607474327087,
-0.22687079012393951,
-0.22146326303482056,
0.35050907731056213,
0.40173250436782837,
0.13204623758792877,
-0.03314516693353653,
-0.1914561688899994,
0.5537478923797607,
-0.5346667170524597,
0.41426053643226624,
-0.4775387644767761,
0.1655575931072235,
0.14655068516731262,
-0.26892054080963135,
-0.4874251186847687,
-0.11545876413583755,
0.4039156436920166,
-0.7012690305709839,
0.25238242745399475,
0.014021297916769981,
0.9962958097457886,
0.5266348719596863,
-0.44021838903427124,
-0.14969755709171295,
-0.946082353591919,
0.9784998297691345,
-0.47182929515838623,
0.31912603974342346,
0.24851872026920319,
0.42305541038513184,
0.07396859675645828,
-0.7893252968788147,
-0.8166735172271729,
-0.10121767222881317,
-0.03917388245463371,
0.22958099842071533,
-0.11210785061120987,
0.2175363451242447,
0.4321334660053253,
0.30535584688186646,
-0.6668592691421509,
0.010905331000685692,
-0.35750409960746765,
-0.11070414632558823,
0.3315983712673187,
0.22870604693889618,
0.48590603470802307,
-0.4529673457145691,
-0.8486883044242859,
-0.05056330934166908,
-0.5553856492042542,
0.09941648691892624,
-0.06092926859855652,
-0.02484293095767498,
-0.10048900544643402,
0.8700739741325378,
0.035376016050577164,
0.9497905373573303,
-0.25838702917099,
-0.09421197324991226,
0.02135251834988594,
-0.4179130792617798,
-0.33373233675956726,
-0.34501415491104126,
0.6570345163345337,
0.7749255299568176,
0.36621004343032837,
0.03690015524625778,
-0.2576727569103241,
0.3823348581790924,
0.27390122413635254,
-0.7349532842636108,
-0.21956345438957214,
0.20226681232452393,
-0.5863591432571411,
-0.2975560426712036,
-0.2561449706554413,
-0.6366668939590454,
-0.36872413754463196,
-0.5321370363235474,
0.5877899527549744,
-0.6855133175849915,
-0.1905258595943451,
0.32362478971481323,
-0.3569820523262024,
0.46467888355255127,
0.7469581365585327,
-0.8052927851676941,
0.10306840389966965,
0.5308992266654968,
0.7788965106010437,
-0.24368387460708618,
-0.14371035993099213,
-0.39269548654556274,
0.2511400878429413,
-0.2623631954193115,
0.9853971004486084,
-0.5009761452674866,
-0.24984580278396606,
-0.11942199617624283,
-0.06088552996516228,
0.08735590428113937,
-0.3634253740310669,
0.4485797882080078,
-0.2731423079967499,
0.265412300825119,
-0.38413968682289124,
-0.4635131359100342,
-0.4409124553203583,
0.5038227438926697,
-0.568743109703064,
0.986772894859314,
-0.032776083797216415,
-0.8483843207359314,
0.4341394007205963,
-0.2529386878013611,
-0.10681207478046417,
0.3310728967189789,
-0.6612949967384338,
-0.27376750111579895,
0.031183207407593727,
0.27717143297195435,
0.5519953370094299,
-0.277853399515152,
-0.0897117480635643,
-0.24495194852352142,
-0.36843550205230713,
0.106960229575634,
-0.4423712491989136,
0.377219021320343,
0.11814553290605545,
-0.340041846036911,
0.329247385263443,
-0.7820454835891724,
0.20484451949596405,
0.27255722880363464,
-0.2376663088798523,
-0.44158390164375305,
0.304452121257782,
0.021193645894527435,
0.251407653093338,
0.37280452251434326,
-0.4092058837413788,
0.21741072833538055,
-0.30116069316864014,
0.37798556685447693,
0.7454143166542053,
-0.3394958972930908,
0.43172338604927063,
-0.17914512753486633,
0.5200381875038147,
0.0370514877140522,
0.07746647298336029,
-0.5324870347976685,
-0.5556730031967163,
-0.8117578625679016,
-0.472007691860199,
-0.08630487322807312,
0.7608739733695984,
-1.5307090282440186,
-0.13388259708881378,
-0.15003907680511475,
-0.2795998752117157,
-0.20832239091396332,
-0.032862357795238495,
0.5369917750358582,
0.6528024673461914,
0.47589850425720215,
-0.05222015455365181,
-0.390674889087677,
-0.8716608881950378,
0.13477733731269836,
-0.4592060148715973,
-0.05847373977303505,
0.3851293623447418,
0.4741317629814148,
-0.28493884205818176,
0.82230144739151,
-0.6005743145942688,
-0.20908793807029724,
-0.40811023116111755,
0.2734206020832062,
-0.08063550293445587,
0.0869583860039711,
0.7404541373252869,
-0.8779090642929077,
-0.3012206256389618,
0.04582884535193443,
-0.959121823310852,
0.0041229440830647945,
-0.12574011087417603,
-0.05279633030295372,
0.24192571640014648,
0.4549064338207245,
-0.6811162233352661,
0.6247344613075256,
0.3891957998275757,
-0.4444652497768402,
0.6737327575683594,
-0.5187976956367493,
0.06137559562921524,
-0.8373395800590515,
-0.23347176611423492,
0.39322319626808167,
-0.3227863013744354,
-0.5250027179718018,
-0.023907313123345375,
-0.021292902529239655,
0.005157665349543095,
-0.46479853987693787,
0.5585010647773743,
-0.40730077028274536,
-0.1532203108072281,
-0.40437230467796326,
0.04598115757107735,
0.07638485729694366,
0.661623477935791,
0.4122254252433777,
0.6666271090507507,
0.8470808267593384,
-0.5544438362121582,
0.6079689264297485,
0.10756738483905792,
-0.2598387598991394,
0.8927215337753296,
-0.8193271160125732,
-0.12605427205562592,
-0.6141672134399414,
-0.016774069517850876,
-1.3206056356430054,
0.009972170926630497,
0.18618254363536835,
-0.41013774275779724,
0.09193723648786545,
-0.09302207082509995,
-0.4039800465106964,
-0.4119594395160675,
-0.18133097887039185,
0.3879302740097046,
0.554226815700531,
-0.598304033279419,
0.819844663143158,
0.06997358053922653,
0.0032679690048098564,
-0.6980206370353699,
-0.6054523587226868,
0.0192237701267004,
-0.006523762829601765,
-0.6734263300895691,
0.11521686613559723,
-0.032937802374362946,
-0.2939442992210388,
0.172496035695076,
-0.06612531840801239,
-0.17592684924602509,
-0.16775934398174286,
0.25680777430534363,
0.6217272281646729,
-0.3248533010482788,
0.3862593472003937,
-0.21784649789333344,
-0.1383206993341446,
0.008875628001987934,
-0.23480716347694397,
0.3385002315044403,
-0.32049068808555603,
-0.4533006548881531,
-0.23113510012626648,
0.30510351061820984,
0.6473011374473572,
-0.283174067735672,
0.5468363165855408,
0.6542006134986877,
-0.3107832670211792,
-0.4519766867160797,
-0.17977192997932434,
0.003754937555640936,
-0.42485108971595764,
0.4429740905761719,
-0.4364668130874634,
-0.8001335859298706,
0.24537280201911926,
-0.14443737268447876,
0.056285373866558075,
0.5046482682228088,
0.6168403029441833,
-0.4038306176662445,
1.2877206802368164,
0.804442286491394,
0.5111724734306335,
0.33771976828575134,
-0.2980448603630066,
-0.04547123238444328,
-0.4370948374271393,
-0.4650796949863434,
-0.2513982057571411,
-0.1647396832704544,
-0.35726118087768555,
-0.8974688649177551,
0.17364341020584106,
0.15607565641403198,
0.0462980680167675,
0.16900448501110077,
-0.7536587715148926,
0.49152112007141113,
0.41285231709480286,
-0.028352970257401466,
0.26336103677749634,
0.044636212289333344,
-0.342820405960083,
-0.2650301158428192,
-0.5576634407043457,
-0.8139382004737854,
0.8939155340194702,
0.3110169768333435,
1.0439943075180054,
-0.05640052631497383,
0.27426275610923767,
0.13523493707180023,
0.1245451495051384,
-0.9100828170776367,
0.7762797474861145,
-0.2785135507583618,
-0.2647106647491455,
-0.2857341170310974,
-0.40167075395584106,
-0.6658158898353577,
0.4635210335254669,
-0.47082415223121643,
-0.6583743095397949,
-0.08522891998291016,
0.21159102022647858,
-0.06273296475410461,
0.42163410782814026,
-0.7933610677719116,
0.908703625202179,
-0.4889363646507263,
-0.27409493923187256,
-0.09642887115478516,
-0.4734923839569092,
0.41580983996391296,
0.284311443567276,
0.09667523205280304,
-0.14327412843704224,
-0.09910193830728531,
0.3315819501876831,
-0.5074939131736755,
0.8181840181350708,
-0.033012211322784424,
-0.2334357500076294,
0.23521359264850616,
-0.05320192128419876,
0.319647878408432,
-0.16508103907108307,
0.3053036630153656,
0.13539396226406097,
0.24342086911201477,
-0.3386497497558594,
-0.8585901856422424,
0.6174943447113037,
-0.7654593586921692,
-0.5499387383460999,
-0.45617586374282837,
-0.5163442492485046,
0.0599190928041935,
0.13022592663764954,
0.2530618906021118,
0.5784936547279358,
-0.12714888155460358,
0.10766825079917908,
0.9768052697181702,
-0.523143470287323,
0.23690082132816315,
0.22932124137878418,
-0.6502416729927063,
-0.17175720632076263,
1.0226960182189941,
-0.03144459053874016,
0.37666139006614685,
0.5828081369400024,
0.03192166984081268,
-0.5411937832832336,
-0.5373368859291077,
-0.6714949607849121,
0.1748703420162201,
-0.9900020360946655,
0.07125336676836014,
-0.7440129518508911,
-0.2787674069404602,
0.12717419862747192,
-0.10916635394096375,
-0.14225241541862488,
-0.41791480779647827,
-0.36202800273895264,
-0.12981629371643066,
0.4668945372104645,
0.7867525815963745,
0.15495671331882477,
0.006388158071786165,
-0.3682064712047577,
0.9125953912734985,
0.5700480937957764,
0.3882845938205719,
-0.14147508144378662,
-0.2406465709209442,
0.11152548342943192,
0.045572612434625626,
-0.18276385962963104,
-0.6852544546127319,
0.18420033156871796,
-0.05317097157239914,
0.5565893054008484,
0.33806484937667847,
-0.1555657833814621,
0.5811779499053955,
-0.7358555197715759,
0.7563108205795288,
0.5241918563842773,
-0.7432722449302673,
0.4853782653808594,
-0.2783326208591461,
0.33222857117652893,
-0.0811232328414917,
0.29342058300971985,
-0.47827401757240295,
-0.3960169851779938,
-0.17574985325336456,
-0.6581814289093018,
0.47777122259140015,
0.2665075957775116,
0.09723830968141556,
-0.09604877978563309,
0.3330935835838318,
-0.009700537659227848,
-0.004786768928170204,
-0.7410286068916321,
-0.39736801385879517,
-0.5695582628250122,
-0.3564678728580475,
-0.0675930604338646,
-0.41584694385528564,
-0.0004411209956742823,
-0.40868207812309265,
0.21014061570167542,
-0.27580970525741577,
0.4048725962638855,
0.2631309926509857,
-0.05501185357570648,
0.1227523609995842,
0.19636587798595428,
0.8213391304016113,
0.7175045013427734,
-0.04155139997601509,
0.573402464389801,
0.015478021465241909,
-0.31687870621681213,
0.21578477323055267,
-0.055375199764966965,
-0.18172025680541992,
0.25381192564964294,
0.39118635654449463,
0.9487929940223694,
-0.051554225385189056,
-0.954206109046936,
0.6868504285812378,
-0.3796563148498535,
-0.3909711539745331,
-0.16697287559509277,
0.028244562447071075,
0.1887189894914627,
0.2725183069705963,
0.35455337166786194,
0.06190743297338486,
-0.06399210542440414,
-0.39767321944236755,
0.165666401386261,
0.48253461718559265,
-0.6105062961578369,
-0.2661433517932892,
0.9659684300422668,
0.04842495173215866,
-0.15647241473197937,
0.34711596369743347,
0.001367466989904642,
-0.32929256558418274,
0.8130490183830261,
0.3968019485473633,
0.588299572467804,
0.11802596598863602,
0.5683061480522156,
0.29721391201019287,
0.36307492852211,
-0.08826518058776855,
0.715019166469574,
0.0362795852124691,
-0.6861361861228943,
-0.7275153398513794,
-0.49779772758483887,
-0.38690876960754395,
0.005002468358725309,
-0.3277563750743866,
0.2870495617389679,
-0.6506608128547668,
-0.1680518388748169,
0.16821657121181488,
-0.5626798868179321,
-0.5768023133277893,
0.3870745897293091,
0.3678737282752991,
0.6417595744132996,
-0.5816053748130798,
0.5375280976295471,
0.7750689387321472,
-0.5592915415763855,
-0.4800232946872711,
-0.28570955991744995,
0.015420881099998951,
-0.7906243205070496,
0.9295188784599304,
0.16080857813358307,
-0.32232019305229187,
-0.16836956143379211,
-0.8388896584510803,
-0.5593565106391907,
0.9900741577148438,
0.4814770519733429,
-0.42687028646469116,
-0.03760053589940071,
0.16154274344444275,
0.8137812614440918,
-0.21367089450359344,
0.2106272578239441,
0.024343693628907204,
0.21534410119056702,
0.6065247654914856,
-0.7289473414421082,
-0.1068693995475769,
-0.16838346421718597,
0.3968326151371002,
0.11061881482601166,
-0.30393779277801514,
1.0540927648544312,
-0.49629759788513184,
-0.3907466232776642,
0.12744221091270447,
0.700505256652832,
0.25841039419174194,
0.1361009031534195,
0.30960705876350403,
0.686970055103302,
0.6117539405822754,
-0.28169912099838257,
1.2543010711669922,
0.03281314671039581,
0.2590892016887665,
0.9341563582420349,
-0.14114366471767426,
0.6155068874359131,
0.42837467789649963,
0.12640175223350525,
0.5416644215583801,
0.2985309958457947,
0.02052932418882847,
0.5353973507881165,
0.19917091727256775,
-0.3645804524421692,
-0.48896995186805725,
-0.15748929977416992,
-0.17296229302883148,
0.40386009216308594,
0.2511305809020996,
-0.46448925137519836,
-0.4814087450504303,
0.15803764760494232,
-0.37586262822151184,
0.420699805021286,
-0.5298758745193481,
0.7323237061500549,
0.09443973004817963,
-0.2784298360347748,
0.6566850543022156,
0.10844158381223679,
0.6216329336166382,
-0.41342395544052124,
-0.4582050144672394,
0.24728773534297943,
0.2960423231124878,
-0.06742796301841736,
-1.0942490100860596,
0.23360416293144226,
0.07731069624423981,
-0.31063857674598694,
-0.5103874802589417,
0.8266294002532959,
-0.5463489890098572,
-0.5970425009727478,
0.13706059753894806,
0.6147783994674683,
0.13965074717998505,
0.11218401044607162,
-0.7043909430503845,
0.10218553245067596,
-0.0895962044596672,
0.1343047022819519,
0.01456509716808796,
0.8085058331489563,
-0.18668437004089355,
0.9386240243911743,
0.46173760294914246,
-0.028750160709023476,
0.0484018474817276,
0.04655281826853752,
0.7328405380249023,
-0.6762985587120056,
-0.3069695830345154,
-0.9227609038352966,
0.4192460775375366,
0.003946518991142511,
-0.06257666647434235,
0.7931385636329651,
0.45751720666885376,
0.8748528361320496,
-0.1924598217010498,
0.920387864112854,
0.21050751209259033,
0.3787521719932556,
-0.6527042388916016,
0.5479970574378967,
-0.5672616362571716,
-0.02494545467197895,
-0.35352352261543274,
-0.7775017619132996,
-0.29951250553131104,
0.7822811603546143,
-0.47600799798965454,
-0.14123496413230896,
0.6449914574623108,
0.5461052060127258,
0.02692621387541294,
-0.25789231061935425,
0.6463353037834167,
0.0658969059586525,
0.3447449803352356,
0.6457939147949219,
1.1183407306671143,
-0.12474524229764938,
0.6591020226478577,
-0.027428660541772842,
-0.02680983394384384,
0.06256366521120071,
-0.8803509473800659,
-1.1787830591201782,
-0.6259987354278564,
-0.33997786045074463,
-0.18121880292892456,
-0.2569270431995392,
0.5035263299942017,
0.45107725262641907,
-0.37563538551330566,
-0.016811786219477654,
-0.10071990638971329,
0.26971614360809326,
-0.12685497105121613,
-0.2492625117301941,
0.18144506216049194,
-0.13468065857887268,
-0.6164522171020508,
-0.12123321741819382,
0.8335853815078735,
0.38705676794052124,
-0.536862313747406,
-0.21155713498592377,
-0.0789608359336853,
0.21476569771766663,
0.8956137895584106,
0.2518913447856903,
-0.9939420223236084,
-0.4117797017097473,
0.045913442969322205,
-0.4438474178314209,
0.15614564716815948,
0.5935629606246948,
-0.8309340476989746,
0.778661847114563,
0.5799961686134338,
0.5497077107429504,
0.652003824710846,
0.029433952644467354,
0.576982319355011,
-0.4873180389404297,
0.1941174864768982,
0.11261235922574997,
0.3653581142425537,
0.44769996404647827,
-0.18551214039325714,
0.21461568772792816,
0.33663445711135864,
-0.1262519210577011,
-0.5328288674354553,
0.4617491364479065,
-1.128495454788208,
-0.49942442774772644,
1.1557103395462036,
-0.10548929125070572,
-0.4632112383842468,
-0.08393307775259018,
-0.6992222666740417,
-0.057775381952524185,
0.04349108412861824,
0.512924075126648,
0.7876194715499878,
0.0024105855263769627,
-0.7383365631103516,
-0.5515902042388916,
0.599143385887146,
0.1342470496892929,
-0.8065537810325623,
-0.11738285422325134,
0.7807813882827759,
0.1688440442085266,
0.0502057708799839,
0.7325950860977173,
-0.028490230441093445,
0.35122573375701904,
-0.1629621684551239,
0.2702442407608032,
-0.1437346190214157,
-0.2584291398525238,
-0.13989557325839996,
0.12278207391500473,
-0.09739119559526443,
-0.23102007806301117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06413v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06413v1
|
Large Language Models to the Rescue: Deadlock Resolution in Multi-Robot Systems
| 2024-04-09T16:03:26 | 2024-04-09T16:03:26 |
Kunal Garg, Jacob Arkin, Songyuan Zhang, Nicholas Roy, Chuchu Fan
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL, math.OC
|
Multi-agent robotic systems are prone to deadlocks in an obstacle environment
where the system can get stuck away from its desired location under a smooth
low-level control policy. Without an external intervention, often in terms of a
high-level command, it is not possible to guarantee that just a low-level
control policy can resolve such deadlocks. Utilizing the generalizability and
low data requirements of large language models (LLMs), this paper explores the
possibility of using LLMs for deadlock resolution. We propose a hierarchical
control framework where an LLM resolves deadlocks by assigning a leader and
direction for the leader to move along. A graph neural network (GNN) based
low-level distributed control policy executes the assigned plan. We
systematically study various prompting techniques to improve LLM's performance
in resolving deadlocks. In particular, as part of prompt engineering, we
provide in-context examples for LLMs. We conducted extensive experiments on
various multi-robot environments with up to 15 agents and 40 obstacles. Our
results demonstrate that LLM-based high-level planners are effective in
resolving deadlocks in MRS.
|
[
-0.06736456602811813,
-1.09317946434021,
0.8341749906539917,
-0.0022651285398751497,
-0.05570000037550926,
0.41794437170028687,
-0.30398914217948914,
-0.4194025695323944,
0.230113685131073,
0.5137688517570496,
-0.5999621152877808,
-0.6028578281402588,
-0.888260543346405,
0.14210835099220276,
-0.15659703314304352,
0.6385214328765869,
-0.23250164091587067,
-0.04542502388358116,
0.09434128552675247,
-0.012597179040312767,
-0.5971041917800903,
-0.6513305902481079,
-0.8360443711280823,
-0.4884544610977173,
0.7143170237541199,
0.4413963556289673,
1.2176917791366577,
0.5970881581306458,
0.47081708908081055,
0.49589774012565613,
-0.5717348456382751,
0.4500589668750763,
-0.3377209007740021,
0.4212353825569153,
0.011052681133151054,
-0.23741331696510315,
-0.6763957142829895,
-0.19993969798088074,
0.6085709929466248,
0.9762634634971619,
-0.15793927013874054,
-0.2921971082687378,
0.09511381387710571,
0.43014222383499146,
-0.2986142039299011,
0.30980122089385986,
-0.38099783658981323,
0.32271966338157654,
0.33913344144821167,
-0.2713978886604309,
-0.35399049520492554,
-0.15950894355773926,
-0.12607929110527039,
-0.5542160272598267,
-0.05770125612616539,
0.017837096005678177,
0.6970594525337219,
0.5090291500091553,
-0.057346779853105545,
-0.13964664936065674,
-1.0583387613296509,
0.7559354305267334,
-0.7618283629417419,
0.12785664200782776,
0.2531546950340271,
0.29638826847076416,
-0.7054004073143005,
-0.09772435575723648,
-0.35226982831954956,
-0.059263329952955246,
0.1491711288690567,
0.11494873464107513,
0.04221968725323677,
0.4067479074001312,
0.28627291321754456,
-0.31824761629104614,
-0.5929328203201294,
0.5737408995628357,
-0.22893957793712616,
-0.21269865334033966,
0.3756606876850128,
0.5000272989273071,
0.27086177468299866,
-0.04459964111447334,
-0.0220171045511961,
0.21367290616035461,
-0.5826610326766968,
-0.234141543507576,
0.24716274440288544,
0.7833257913589478,
-0.19438832998275757,
0.48737266659736633,
-0.3374311625957489,
0.8435972332954407,
-0.21545495092868805,
-0.4499647915363312,
-0.02389608882367611,
-0.2511296570301056,
-0.06109579652547836,
-0.18940119445323944,
0.7389483451843262,
0.6532535552978516,
0.4969087541103363,
-0.4363873600959778,
-0.3187287151813507,
-0.08988288789987564,
-0.12747807800769806,
-0.5370861291885376,
0.12701715528964996,
0.6489802598953247,
-0.4939393699169159,
-0.12380265444517136,
-0.34113749861717224,
-0.7289992570877075,
-0.6229110956192017,
-0.3546675443649292,
0.16045798361301422,
0.0197397880256176,
-0.266387015581131,
0.017996257171034813,
-0.22092433273792267,
-0.0022180748637765646,
0.9289267659187317,
-0.783056378364563,
0.12288491427898407,
0.6846122145652771,
1.301952600479126,
-0.012857816182076931,
-0.6541321873664856,
-0.7795013189315796,
0.3391433656215668,
-0.5678710341453552,
0.4570746123790741,
-0.4796280562877655,
-0.206052765250206,
0.1588268280029297,
0.13160689175128937,
-0.17557665705680847,
-0.653494656085968,
-0.1641860157251358,
-0.6785812377929688,
-0.0912044420838356,
0.1517326980829239,
-0.14828471839427948,
-0.027727460488677025,
0.31515130400657654,
-0.5756292343139648,
0.6053088307380676,
0.007575149182230234,
-0.1970706433057785,
-0.06238849461078644,
-0.43451589345932007,
-0.3938378095626831,
-0.18291352689266205,
-0.3254183232784271,
-0.3610994219779968,
-0.38463830947875977,
0.19581714272499084,
0.7412565350532532,
-0.26126864552497864,
0.5504114031791687,
-0.2510994076728821,
-0.30541375279426575,
-0.16992849111557007,
-0.2790767252445221,
0.6248220801353455,
0.0006124105420894921,
0.13808973133563995,
0.5372154712677002,
-0.5158873796463013,
-0.13247022032737732,
0.11030334234237671,
-0.3727380931377411,
0.06395290046930313,
0.23150299489498138,
-0.46442052721977234,
0.4059368669986725,
0.2706620693206787,
-0.2818337082862854,
0.5043649673461914,
-0.15288764238357544,
0.5450202822685242,
1.0245261192321777,
-0.012926964089274406,
0.620866060256958,
-0.39389392733573914,
0.7007240056991577,
0.03684493154287338,
0.1551792025566101,
-0.06916143000125885,
-0.7986531853675842,
-0.4298846423625946,
-0.3290115296840668,
0.05510092154145241,
0.6480478048324585,
-0.8483808040618896,
0.46656182408332825,
-0.026857230812311172,
-0.0709945484995842,
-0.17324107885360718,
0.1474149227142334,
0.14495736360549927,
0.32786911725997925,
0.3937729299068451,
-0.050173938274383545,
-0.14655205607414246,
-0.510319173336029,
0.39288583397865295,
-0.2624940872192383,
-0.3160555958747864,
0.3589934706687927,
0.49533799290657043,
-0.013726534321904182,
0.6392441987991333,
-0.14296948909759521,
-0.3517172336578369,
-0.3562062680721283,
0.16308778524398804,
0.5999919772148132,
0.4423220157623291,
0.3396308720111847,
-0.5568259358406067,
-0.0387260727584362,
0.02630884200334549,
-1.0641366243362427,
0.17505966126918793,
-0.09464618563652039,
-0.15175187587738037,
0.3477496802806854,
0.6942727565765381,
-0.7978185415267944,
0.38945555686950684,
0.6795617938041687,
-0.05012134462594986,
0.5296910405158997,
-0.4735489785671234,
-0.10050372779369354,
-0.9407214522361755,
-0.18577882647514343,
-0.29776468873023987,
-0.24444562196731567,
-0.5373437404632568,
0.2778184413909912,
-0.32813212275505066,
-0.5309386849403381,
-0.5549466609954834,
0.19609004259109497,
-0.6123752593994141,
-0.36467134952545166,
-0.3695424199104309,
0.3878299593925476,
-0.39443621039390564,
0.7221342921257019,
0.05682631582021713,
0.6501073241233826,
0.5981253385543823,
-0.8825310468673706,
0.700496256351471,
0.3456871509552002,
-0.003413375234231353,
0.07477542012929916,
-0.76743084192276,
0.08718519657850266,
-0.28199079632759094,
0.4636552333831787,
-0.9271662831306458,
-0.3096400499343872,
0.6252303719520569,
-0.10830780863761902,
0.19764840602874756,
-0.7923362255096436,
-0.7374732494354248,
-0.5613720417022705,
0.01153264008462429,
0.11330744624137878,
0.33094650506973267,
-0.3731909692287445,
0.8078109622001648,
0.30730822682380676,
-0.2592710852622986,
-0.5892996788024902,
-0.5104939341545105,
0.2733239233493805,
0.158064603805542,
-0.6960409879684448,
0.08183624595403671,
-0.2921874225139618,
-0.020889297127723694,
-0.10950406640768051,
0.024145957082509995,
-0.10888766497373581,
0.32517755031585693,
0.1952899694442749,
0.44903868436813354,
-0.15052759647369385,
0.011716777458786964,
0.08220633864402771,
-0.3300670087337494,
0.03699904680252075,
-0.17593194544315338,
0.8223342299461365,
0.1329074501991272,
-0.510297417640686,
-0.4374276399612427,
0.455689936876297,
0.8380332589149475,
-0.10859505832195282,
0.8323479890823364,
-0.08530814945697784,
-0.4496777057647705,
-0.23661698400974274,
-0.07132842391729355,
-0.3600420653820038,
-0.4922589957714081,
0.4832712411880493,
-0.2979344427585602,
-0.8749244809150696,
0.8816191554069519,
-0.4871152341365814,
0.010917332023382187,
-0.20132745802402496,
0.7903227210044861,
0.1291055828332901,
1.0329809188842773,
0.6003432273864746,
-0.43184134364128113,
0.3266059160232544,
-0.2261229157447815,
0.3241944909095764,
-0.5633553862571716,
-0.10759755223989487,
-0.6887653470039368,
-0.5505333542823792,
-0.5472557544708252,
-0.6093727946281433,
0.37659767270088196,
0.17725814878940582,
-0.19767577946186066,
0.37227994203567505,
-0.653518557548523,
0.7330113053321838,
0.3269714117050171,
0.07905293256044388,
0.3343246579170227,
-0.2788437604904175,
-0.4802115261554718,
0.40293678641319275,
-1.058948040008545,
-0.524429976940155,
0.3595271408557892,
0.4101456105709076,
0.7910683751106262,
0.04882437735795975,
0.571235179901123,
-0.026471061632037163,
-0.09869435429573059,
-0.9165197610855103,
0.8558325171470642,
0.08497772365808487,
-0.3628253638744354,
-0.8455935716629028,
-0.6761659383773804,
-0.9285500049591064,
0.3596981167793274,
-0.04187323898077011,
-1.1833522319793701,
0.0650571882724762,
0.0453723780810833,
-0.6668589115142822,
0.6084182262420654,
-0.44946637749671936,
0.7805403470993042,
-0.1055583506822586,
-0.1879330426454544,
-0.22055870294570923,
-0.8425883650779724,
0.09560152143239975,
0.15430893003940582,
0.12604913115501404,
-0.6035544276237488,
0.16672205924987793,
0.6322883367538452,
-0.44373995065689087,
0.9133486747741699,
-0.2370368242263794,
-0.34050312638282776,
-0.06865426898002625,
0.21090571582317352,
0.9736264944076538,
-0.21922637522220612,
-0.23056355118751526,
0.19550013542175293,
-0.435293585062027,
-0.30693092942237854,
-0.5561085343360901,
0.5345951318740845,
-0.7908326387405396,
-0.5069843530654907,
-0.31841155886650085,
-1.0198276042938232,
0.00701587600633502,
0.2725542187690735,
-0.20748186111450195,
0.3144185543060303,
0.15272894501686096,
-0.06752631813287735,
0.421725869178772,
-0.4325372278690338,
0.8291953206062317,
0.7189671397209167,
-0.41421082615852356,
0.08397481590509415,
0.8216164708137512,
0.5054646134376526,
0.39524045586586,
0.23807339370250702,
0.15959174931049347,
0.0930761992931366,
-0.6334933638572693,
-0.7375192046165466,
0.03829384222626686,
-0.524878978729248,
-0.5387067794799805,
-0.502625584602356,
-0.5056329369544983,
-0.02590625360608101,
-0.26772916316986084,
-0.5522653460502625,
-0.3946162760257721,
-0.26861608028411865,
0.16612184047698975,
0.5300515294075012,
0.8740301132202148,
-0.22115741670131683,
0.41392552852630615,
-0.8456059098243713,
0.5582197904586792,
0.1000351831316948,
0.3125946521759033,
0.3220202624797821,
-0.4588111639022827,
-0.319575697183609,
0.12472683936357498,
-0.30561432242393494,
-0.5476992726325989,
0.3694952428340912,
-0.19864892959594727,
0.31299251317977905,
0.19474542140960693,
0.313789039850235,
0.5135101675987244,
-0.7362120151519775,
0.5236538648605347,
0.18916068971157074,
-0.6706185340881348,
0.43501949310302734,
-0.6560375690460205,
0.2282102406024933,
-0.08191078156232834,
0.31529688835144043,
-0.7165957689285278,
-1.0235066413879395,
-0.23397274315357208,
-1.1622693538665771,
0.7417917847633362,
0.015325500629842281,
-0.035475242882966995,
0.24559423327445984,
0.22315190732479095,
-0.33836042881011963,
0.27370506525039673,
-0.17352202534675598,
-0.33801916241645813,
0.2565762400627136,
0.030931537970900536,
0.17635634541511536,
-0.01456387434154749,
-0.26023513078689575,
0.1589561104774475,
0.2168358862400055,
-0.27009063959121704,
0.5853654742240906,
-0.09101790189743042,
0.052338629961013794,
-0.6256127953529358,
0.34429097175598145,
0.8752966523170471,
0.9184399247169495,
-0.3005814552307129,
-0.05131741985678673,
0.12682528793811798,
0.014976167120039463,
0.42905840277671814,
0.22797568142414093,
-0.3270336985588074,
-0.17249295115470886,
0.3863791823387146,
0.2669808268547058,
0.06840652972459793,
-0.276761919260025,
0.30803802609443665,
0.14201967418193817,
-0.10235708206892014,
0.04993444308638573,
0.08087203651666641,
0.05186942219734192,
0.49486735463142395,
0.44918155670166016,
0.2354612797498703,
-0.30694010853767395,
-0.3820948600769043,
0.09534106403589249,
0.42986127734184265,
-0.18014048039913177,
-0.12137507647275925,
0.6501551866531372,
0.3133452534675598,
-0.39350900053977966,
0.8219757676124573,
-0.1734611541032791,
-0.7121291160583496,
0.9413381814956665,
0.48679035902023315,
0.6217594146728516,
-0.03227999061346054,
0.48766690492630005,
0.2573550045490265,
0.5354432463645935,
-0.2061484456062317,
0.2297142744064331,
0.34478744864463806,
-1.1153007745742798,
-1.0488914251327515,
-0.2851085066795349,
-0.9060173630714417,
0.13464291393756866,
-0.13690288364887238,
-0.05097804218530655,
-0.9475828409194946,
-0.09387645870447159,
-0.16057798266410828,
-0.10776804387569427,
-0.30772891640663147,
-0.26257792115211487,
0.11925124377012253,
0.5697552561759949,
-0.7774820923805237,
0.5971344113349915,
0.4344590902328491,
-0.5251737833023071,
-0.9118796586990356,
-0.027957722544670105,
0.06302934885025024,
-0.7891627550125122,
0.42612144351005554,
0.0667901411652565,
-0.25371870398521423,
-0.15593308210372925,
-0.81114661693573,
-0.6954020261764526,
0.946938693523407,
0.49676087498664856,
-0.6633425354957581,
-0.18609894812107086,
0.011239091865718365,
0.4502122104167938,
-0.17563706636428833,
0.2152232825756073,
0.26673412322998047,
0.5966607332229614,
0.04588257521390915,
-1.133067011833191,
0.2126549780368805,
0.10798260569572449,
-0.14307017624378204,
0.3544844388961792,
-0.9399421215057373,
0.8721861243247986,
-0.4111001193523407,
-0.135069340467453,
0.48940929770469666,
0.6085218787193298,
0.4488103687763214,
0.19715462625026703,
0.30197450518608093,
0.25702229142189026,
0.925426721572876,
-0.02646915428340435,
0.8123757243156433,
-0.4168219566345215,
0.25676560401916504,
1.0266814231872559,
-0.6223006248474121,
0.678011417388916,
0.23821759223937988,
0.07783498615026474,
0.13977035880088806,
0.4723736643791199,
0.1350511759519577,
0.28390443325042725,
0.3300752341747284,
-0.02346757799386978,
-0.26700302958488464,
-0.5457172989845276,
-0.3901641368865967,
0.16573137044906616,
0.22069065272808075,
-0.06822480261325836,
-0.4489845931529999,
0.08799976855516434,
0.09705591946840286,
-0.04113565385341644,
-0.41100746393203735,
0.6343912482261658,
0.00639204028993845,
-0.36892789602279663,
0.6689013242721558,
0.040846627205610275,
0.3221490681171417,
-0.4817083179950714,
-0.385859876871109,
-0.17756807804107666,
0.22547727823257446,
-0.09019039571285248,
-0.8438732624053955,
0.14256177842617035,
-0.1768677979707718,
-0.15419000387191772,
-0.39224258065223694,
0.7443876266479492,
-0.5485146045684814,
-0.1431005746126175,
0.8774353265762329,
0.8092855215072632,
0.26132601499557495,
0.08001506328582764,
-0.6189353466033936,
0.17998731136322021,
-0.39145439863204956,
0.022311195731163025,
0.2503957152366638,
0.6625411510467529,
0.005132659338414669,
1.0571115016937256,
0.4309138059616089,
0.3054707646369934,
0.053433649241924286,
0.3695165514945984,
1.0992310047149658,
-0.6292014718055725,
-0.3034757077693939,
-0.6710200309753418,
0.20654363930225372,
0.19550839066505432,
-0.059693217277526855,
0.5275555849075317,
0.06270558387041092,
0.6885409951210022,
0.007082614116370678,
0.634613573551178,
0.158212810754776,
0.41960012912750244,
-0.7537407279014587,
0.6753459572792053,
-0.32730406522750854,
0.17965565621852875,
-0.4015168249607086,
-0.7442418336868286,
-0.5297837853431702,
0.5765932202339172,
-0.2087162286043167,
0.09814748913049698,
0.5302804708480835,
1.102288842201233,
-0.048857398331165314,
-0.472885400056839,
0.6823354363441467,
0.2640821039676666,
0.282289057970047,
0.5990326404571533,
1.3093960285186768,
-0.21808496117591858,
0.5317131876945496,
0.059648651629686356,
-0.18420585989952087,
-0.19130045175552368,
-0.6682279706001282,
-0.8498926758766174,
0.03193146362900734,
-0.17499198019504547,
-0.40438947081565857,
0.5377853512763977,
1.2667882442474365,
0.7594093084335327,
-0.8162257075309753,
-0.43174195289611816,
-0.02027897909283638,
0.8700705766677856,
-0.28571534156799316,
-0.10422541946172714,
0.1764640212059021,
-0.25490501523017883,
-0.640623152256012,
0.7229424118995667,
0.3586474359035492,
0.13303163647651672,
-0.19234292209148407,
-0.48445552587509155,
-0.32519426941871643,
-0.2861206829547882,
0.5655519962310791,
0.2960215210914612,
-0.5967587828636169,
-0.5024291276931763,
-0.15517792105674744,
-0.18529696762561798,
0.14966033399105072,
0.7147098779678345,
-0.31441453099250793,
0.16063474118709564,
0.5118727087974548,
0.642086386680603,
0.0321718230843544,
-0.05993371084332466,
0.7422506213188171,
-0.8610087037086487,
0.526677131652832,
0.323815256357193,
0.33054473996162415,
0.2184990644454956,
-0.2508498728275299,
0.4585909843444824,
0.17028796672821045,
-0.9175679683685303,
-0.4487147927284241,
0.38032808899879456,
-0.7601800560951233,
-0.3116529881954193,
1.0259852409362793,
-0.10059624165296555,
-0.3234889507293701,
-0.5099735260009766,
-0.19149434566497803,
0.3678138554096222,
-0.9031497240066528,
0.5493106245994568,
0.7017450928688049,
-0.13683386147022247,
-0.2754981815814972,
-0.629136323928833,
0.11004871875047684,
0.1407424956560135,
-0.5044259428977966,
0.2725509703159332,
0.5818178057670593,
-0.34948480129241943,
0.4981275200843811,
0.6539559364318848,
0.1974245011806488,
0.21753428876399994,
-0.2420913577079773,
0.04791675880551338,
-0.022990169003605843,
-1.06658935546875,
-0.22695292532444,
0.08120159059762955,
0.1393091082572937,
-0.3324219286441803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06411v1
|
AgentQuest: A Modular Benchmark Framework to Measure Progress and Improve LLM Agents
| 2024-04-09T16:01:24 | 2024-04-09T16:01:24 |
Luca Gioacchini, Giuseppe Siracusano, Davide Sanvito, Kiril Gashteovski, David Friede, Roberto Bifulco, Carolin Lawrence
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The advances made by Large Language Models (LLMs) have led to the pursuit of
LLM agents that can solve intricate, multi-step reasoning tasks. As with any
research pursuit, benchmarking and evaluation are key corner stones to
efficient and reliable progress. However, existing benchmarks are often narrow
and simply compute overall task success. To face these issues, we propose
AgentQuest -- a framework where (i) both benchmarks and metrics are modular and
easily extensible through well documented and easy-to-use APIs; (ii) we offer
two new evaluation metrics that can reliably track LLM agent progress while
solving a task. We exemplify the utility of the metrics on two use cases
wherein we identify common failure points and refine the agent architecture to
obtain a significant performance increase. Together with the research
community, we hope to extend AgentQuest further and therefore we make it
available under https://github.com/nec-research/agentquest.
|
[
-0.2959350645542145,
-0.4788134694099426,
0.8649687767028809,
0.23325306177139282,
0.14993764460086823,
0.24978935718536377,
-0.1361190378665924,
-0.43574342131614685,
0.08068683743476868,
0.5151118636131287,
-0.7036858797073364,
-0.48630616068840027,
-0.3665822744369507,
0.19808605313301086,
-0.239161878824234,
0.33458220958709717,
-0.24270538985729218,
0.33664470911026,
-0.6247696876525879,
-0.2752513885498047,
-0.49991023540496826,
-0.21936267614364624,
-0.9903476238250732,
-0.7427276372909546,
0.7514212131500244,
0.5387364029884338,
0.5406776666641235,
0.6771248579025269,
0.5108129978179932,
0.4285171926021576,
-0.030207328498363495,
0.4252709448337555,
-0.1295926421880722,
0.7692535519599915,
-0.3165440857410431,
-0.5102667212486267,
-0.9591842293739319,
-0.16572652757167816,
0.7438522577285767,
0.6431032419204712,
-0.26436087489128113,
0.31775373220443726,
-0.11627063900232315,
0.5996536612510681,
-0.48434537649154663,
0.30902615189552307,
-0.25553178787231445,
-0.11952044069766998,
-0.0563773512840271,
-0.30980026721954346,
-0.23014703392982483,
-0.4190567135810852,
-0.033764004707336426,
-0.38221946358680725,
0.004144000820815563,
-0.14617781341075897,
0.3042743504047394,
0.31206125020980835,
-0.5769866704940796,
-0.2458399087190628,
-0.391394704580307,
0.5755794048309326,
-0.5585950016975403,
0.26521873474121094,
0.26792997121810913,
0.775004506111145,
-0.3466959595680237,
-0.8325930833816528,
-0.2762414515018463,
-0.4759734869003296,
0.16028957068920135,
-0.10421133786439896,
-0.03516962379217148,
-0.07110608369112015,
0.13068841397762299,
0.1426405906677246,
-0.5858467221260071,
-0.031225895509123802,
0.12147092074155807,
-0.45553985238075256,
0.8039611577987671,
0.7425587773323059,
0.21296097338199615,
0.20760874450206757,
-0.15539266169071198,
-0.25950169563293457,
-0.5433698296546936,
0.11738590896129608,
0.2188369184732437,
0.32796528935432434,
0.23701441287994385,
0.4386123716831207,
-0.5762172341346741,
0.402677059173584,
-0.2896292507648468,
-0.10280037671327591,
0.4052073359489441,
-0.4240703880786896,
0.18556351959705353,
-0.4339444637298584,
0.37805020809173584,
0.2452848106622696,
-0.11282123625278473,
-0.4197279214859009,
-0.6747334599494934,
0.018402330577373505,
0.3697868585586548,
-0.888812780380249,
0.2303837686777115,
0.33964091539382935,
-0.25326472520828247,
-0.041599273681640625,
-0.11942853033542633,
-0.485013484954834,
-0.5679882168769836,
-0.33457475900650024,
0.3253779709339142,
-0.28963786363601685,
-0.4344725012779236,
0.1218591034412384,
-0.2668847143650055,
0.4751085340976715,
0.6686931848526001,
-0.41453975439071655,
0.5363443493843079,
1.2996783256530762,
0.8908125758171082,
-0.4218008518218994,
-0.5348238348960876,
-0.6464917063713074,
-0.05559108033776283,
-0.3962087035179138,
1.2765312194824219,
-0.43415164947509766,
-0.38887089490890503,
0.07599345594644547,
0.05988253653049469,
-0.014143127016723156,
-0.804736852645874,
0.5558770895004272,
-0.5580445528030396,
-0.5544334650039673,
-0.39989978075027466,
-0.6803725957870483,
-0.1524241864681244,
0.9011090397834778,
-0.5900390148162842,
1.1136982440948486,
0.12841787934303284,
-0.0022142482921481133,
0.2453920990228653,
-0.6635059118270874,
-0.2327374368906021,
0.2106180340051651,
0.043597716838121414,
-0.11256121098995209,
0.18036483228206635,
-0.04747292399406433,
0.23460614681243896,
-0.6569993495941162,
0.013373419642448425,
-0.403018057346344,
-0.4323131740093231,
0.3103496730327606,
-0.22359396517276764,
0.31723055243492126,
0.15581871569156647,
-0.35076549649238586,
0.3182070553302765,
-0.7713302373886108,
0.42052412033081055,
0.014859342947602272,
-0.49301502108573914,
0.09829509258270264,
0.2666268050670624,
-0.15200816094875336,
-0.15582101047039032,
0.5908377170562744,
-0.42250335216522217,
0.20276695489883423,
-0.0018683538073673844,
0.19043248891830444,
0.7343268394470215,
-0.1893194615840912,
0.30009111762046814,
-0.7545920014381409,
0.7657261490821838,
-0.3289804756641388,
0.29474499821662903,
-0.1892976015806198,
-0.1063128188252449,
-0.7766234278678894,
-0.3810923993587494,
0.15527446568012238,
0.2221679389476776,
-0.4971182346343994,
0.20031990110874176,
-0.23674368858337402,
-0.8408082127571106,
-0.21844691038131714,
0.041852179914712906,
0.28139635920524597,
0.1695324182510376,
0.16678018867969513,
-0.6904605031013489,
-0.2478114366531372,
-0.6355016231536865,
-0.2824636697769165,
-0.6007465720176697,
-0.07637747377157211,
0.5050739645957947,
0.3758314549922943,
-0.4345850646495819,
0.7758628726005554,
-0.1492520272731781,
-0.07525193691253662,
-0.3037862181663513,
0.159485325217247,
0.1984325796365738,
0.3109322786331177,
0.44590404629707336,
-0.4724414646625519,
-0.2228127419948578,
-0.13343428075313568,
-0.6042765974998474,
-0.44533663988113403,
0.36978721618652344,
-0.2321256399154663,
-0.09561752527952194,
0.5123776793479919,
-0.6863827109336853,
0.13279521465301514,
0.2602969706058502,
-0.5631352066993713,
0.9131094813346863,
-0.018420403823256493,
0.23198755085468292,
-0.6047415137290955,
0.03452051430940628,
-0.38383784890174866,
-0.6199589967727661,
-0.4221843183040619,
0.4855998456478119,
-0.02776513248682022,
0.14560091495513916,
-0.3609594702720642,
0.7145993113517761,
-0.5084579586982727,
-0.40087437629699707,
-0.5111346244812012,
0.15355949103832245,
0.063681460916996,
0.2145145982503891,
-0.3102726340293884,
0.8356502056121826,
0.7094478607177734,
-0.5450066328048706,
0.7192179560661316,
-0.021263383328914642,
-0.24682030081748962,
0.9038373231887817,
-0.7899556756019592,
0.3211289942264557,
0.13959598541259766,
0.3965075612068176,
-0.9246915578842163,
-0.09944035112857819,
0.12128345668315887,
-0.4788816273212433,
-0.12197522819042206,
0.08619754016399384,
-0.680164098739624,
-0.21908345818519592,
-0.3262931704521179,
0.5111903548240662,
0.2785820960998535,
-0.40776389837265015,
1.0220648050308228,
0.19561202824115753,
-0.055335935205221176,
-0.3582202196121216,
-0.4450751543045044,
0.0979052260518074,
0.1338110864162445,
-0.6095651388168335,
0.02611713670194149,
-0.3396986126899719,
-0.3350158631801605,
0.009165103547275066,
-0.27160289883613586,
-0.14960943162441254,
0.18379226326942444,
0.14464229345321655,
-0.045109570026397705,
-0.45018213987350464,
0.14692330360412598,
-0.3365589678287506,
-0.27580925822257996,
0.35383257269859314,
-0.24655035138130188,
0.6599908471107483,
-0.2868073582649231,
-0.7761983871459961,
-0.2199825644493103,
0.332182914018631,
0.777194082736969,
-0.28728386759757996,
0.1158810630440712,
0.23628364503383636,
-0.2399071902036667,
-0.47200503945350647,
-0.7382965087890625,
-0.11654887348413467,
-0.4669296443462372,
0.5183846354484558,
-0.6132839918136597,
-0.8276302814483643,
0.626532793045044,
-0.5480620861053467,
0.15498049557209015,
0.30917754769325256,
0.6442568898200989,
0.2009253352880478,
1.0485856533050537,
0.6847530603408813,
0.047772444784641266,
0.47358402609825134,
-0.09768377989530563,
-0.4567425847053528,
-0.7240796685218811,
-0.2537776231765747,
-0.8178488612174988,
-0.1990293562412262,
-0.009598965756595135,
-0.8079039454460144,
0.19807976484298706,
-0.13651101291179657,
-0.26019522547721863,
0.35141152143478394,
-0.13291209936141968,
0.46556106209754944,
0.339591383934021,
-0.018424298614263535,
0.5567401647567749,
-0.3781850039958954,
-0.1715770959854126,
0.31149181723594666,
-0.4207034707069397,
-0.6971468329429626,
1.09722101688385,
0.38295722007751465,
0.6806557178497314,
0.32827046513557434,
0.6582129001617432,
0.6481291055679321,
0.4355383515357971,
-0.951674222946167,
0.9231660962104797,
0.3663894832134247,
-0.6573486328125,
-0.3384546637535095,
-0.5077569484710693,
-0.8990578651428223,
0.5182664394378662,
0.3676903247833252,
-0.7953440546989441,
0.16751818358898163,
-0.046387799084186554,
0.05580965429544449,
0.054440319538116455,
-0.3807072639465332,
0.8843717575073242,
-0.3657087981700897,
-0.2979179620742798,
-0.6710932850837708,
-0.1674676239490509,
-0.0708031952381134,
0.021229352802038193,
-0.09515984356403351,
-0.6093927621841431,
-0.48039910197257996,
0.43186163902282715,
-0.967904806137085,
0.528766930103302,
-0.2498355209827423,
-0.02762959711253643,
0.28677478432655334,
0.06432725489139557,
0.7075485587120056,
0.11811475455760956,
-0.5143118500709534,
-0.14046236872673035,
0.14736267924308777,
-0.5868323445320129,
-0.739730954170227,
0.5363702774047852,
-0.5527573227882385,
-0.6110891699790955,
-0.4001953601837158,
-0.501365065574646,
-0.4666460454463959,
0.21823376417160034,
-0.38872942328453064,
0.5509251952171326,
-0.36894506216049194,
-0.06502022594213486,
0.33777374029159546,
0.20078842341899872,
0.42158281803131104,
1.1868211030960083,
-0.2675483524799347,
-0.3208630681037903,
0.7106969356536865,
-0.04791536554694176,
0.1751277595758438,
0.2260654717683792,
-0.10276445746421814,
-0.552733838558197,
-0.7787513732910156,
-0.32632479071617126,
0.13699285686016083,
-0.8765352964401245,
-0.33915504813194275,
-0.37403351068496704,
0.01427755132317543,
-0.28700366616249084,
0.07973965257406235,
-0.6951634287834167,
-0.1878659576177597,
0.018028590828180313,
0.10893386602401733,
0.1294192522764206,
0.78412926197052,
-0.14205293357372284,
0.19854946434497833,
-0.5673559308052063,
0.03732831031084061,
0.3672538995742798,
0.5317388772964478,
0.18788868188858032,
-0.3530133068561554,
-0.2950466573238373,
-0.26615986227989197,
-0.4088982343673706,
-0.6198186278343201,
-0.024112872779369354,
0.06590049713850021,
0.8759239912033081,
0.14057394862174988,
0.0661955252289772,
0.609892725944519,
-0.41342803835868835,
0.6068874597549438,
-0.06849618256092072,
-0.9483530521392822,
0.3439052104949951,
-0.18539026379585266,
0.4532391130924225,
0.9056603908538818,
-0.11363126337528229,
-0.5281722545623779,
-0.4986315667629242,
-0.29836803674697876,
-0.943445086479187,
0.6001760959625244,
-0.08217118680477142,
-0.10247520357370377,
0.15959899127483368,
0.2636474072933197,
0.08497722446918488,
0.2004355490207672,
-0.20409224927425385,
-0.27992528676986694,
0.1943284273147583,
0.11048303544521332,
-0.24877434968948364,
-0.1683158129453659,
-0.24397993087768555,
-0.15017539262771606,
0.743044376373291,
-0.3483826518058777,
0.22879864275455475,
0.2664569914340973,
-0.29163917899131775,
0.09003675729036331,
0.3254489004611969,
0.37618330121040344,
1.086936116218567,
-0.10966888815164566,
0.08862987905740738,
0.14064614474773407,
-0.36663341522216797,
0.44955238699913025,
0.4676899015903473,
0.09418988227844238,
0.1504499465227127,
0.4955347180366516,
0.4057355225086212,
0.020420314744114876,
-1.067859172821045,
0.5507096648216248,
-0.3762796223163605,
-0.19312675297260284,
-0.4453538954257965,
0.24100284278392792,
-0.009623472578823566,
0.9221193194389343,
0.6061193943023682,
-0.11942173540592194,
0.2949875295162201,
-0.47544392943382263,
0.38105309009552,
0.3423163890838623,
-0.5393839478492737,
-0.1444249451160431,
0.4584468603134155,
0.30884993076324463,
-0.7149056792259216,
0.1965048462152481,
-0.39939069747924805,
-0.4433195888996124,
0.8490207195281982,
0.31730759143829346,
1.215698003768921,
0.01960599422454834,
0.43478134274482727,
0.12538142502307892,
0.21527604758739471,
-0.37652215361595154,
0.33763548731803894,
-0.3181741535663605,
-0.5078828930854797,
-0.4686538279056549,
-0.6321646571159363,
-0.9392279982566833,
-0.35975712537765503,
-0.4623711109161377,
0.09785480052232742,
-0.29427218437194824,
-0.3648602068424225,
-0.2299984246492386,
0.377368301153183,
-0.6257744431495667,
-0.03447894752025604,
0.0017520152032375336,
1.315280556678772,
-0.30149200558662415,
0.46299630403518677,
1.077813744544983,
-0.16188988089561462,
-0.8391075730323792,
-0.10428787767887115,
0.21478039026260376,
-0.7926738858222961,
0.2976360321044922,
0.33620283007621765,
-0.43039411306381226,
-0.1869249939918518,
-0.2723926603794098,
-0.8758054971694946,
1.349863886833191,
0.40695515275001526,
-0.4769345819950104,
0.34551748633384705,
0.22759602963924408,
0.6385477781295776,
-0.5990947484970093,
0.7798378467559814,
0.6679733991622925,
0.7382460832595825,
0.1417364776134491,
-0.8571087121963501,
0.26940619945526123,
-0.44459033012390137,
-0.034279849380254745,
0.14139775931835175,
-0.9371581673622131,
0.6774404644966125,
0.1117086112499237,
-0.13212262094020844,
0.4547600746154785,
0.6012725830078125,
0.3382313847541809,
0.6890705823898315,
0.6493910551071167,
0.5136449933052063,
0.7708539962768555,
-0.2676418423652649,
0.9517151117324829,
-0.2881113588809967,
0.2782396376132965,
0.9763217568397522,
-0.42134588956832886,
0.7700089812278748,
0.031784623861312866,
-0.20826059579849243,
0.44760048389434814,
0.7495490908622742,
0.04873074218630791,
0.23871520161628723,
0.3892834484577179,
-0.3777574300765991,
-0.45578208565711975,
-0.356387197971344,
-0.31168368458747864,
0.3073410093784332,
0.11423127353191376,
0.03017289564013481,
-0.35025450587272644,
-0.3681015074253082,
-0.14659453928470612,
-0.0423404686152935,
-0.46778708696365356,
0.7554367780685425,
-0.009247025474905968,
-0.951798677444458,
0.2832520306110382,
-0.09032228589057922,
0.44731947779655457,
-0.74932461977005,
0.08185041695833206,
-0.5471584796905518,
0.42099183797836304,
-0.011496027931571007,
-0.4590367078781128,
0.1299503594636917,
-0.19401420652866364,
-0.12602514028549194,
-0.1971026360988617,
0.6074832677841187,
-0.17523902654647827,
-0.31070563197135925,
0.6092310547828674,
0.8505271077156067,
0.3802899718284607,
-0.15969261527061462,
-0.7965016961097717,
0.19679297506809235,
-0.425708144903183,
-0.39635974168777466,
0.17751730978488922,
0.4373447000980377,
0.09316885471343994,
1.0124614238739014,
0.4404033422470093,
0.34459221363067627,
-0.08255646377801895,
0.35338133573532104,
0.9163585901260376,
-0.7910937666893005,
-0.3071228265762329,
-0.8599075675010681,
0.34535282850265503,
-0.1740962415933609,
-0.32379618287086487,
0.5280436277389526,
0.6394292116165161,
0.4680578112602234,
0.3745988607406616,
0.5883676409721375,
-0.023999100551009178,
0.5585799217224121,
-0.1841222494840622,
0.5155012011528015,
-0.9289347529411316,
0.4507891833782196,
-0.046268243342638016,
-1.1569610834121704,
-0.044599395245313644,
0.054278552532196045,
0.07421881705522537,
0.036950550973415375,
0.7627030611038208,
1.0764718055725098,
0.2658853232860565,
-0.14103522896766663,
0.3062506318092346,
-0.007410779595375061,
0.5043989419937134,
0.48978933691978455,
1.2103205919265747,
-0.17331108450889587,
0.6220799088478088,
0.19516129791736603,
-0.3016131818294525,
-0.28902095556259155,
-0.6692708730697632,
-0.762565016746521,
-0.23959915339946747,
-0.3396909236907959,
-0.23502986133098602,
0.3341623544692993,
0.7771016359329224,
0.7442793250083923,
-0.5479872226715088,
-0.5717806220054626,
-0.047965195029973984,
0.46558335423469543,
-0.5617805123329163,
-0.15143033862113953,
-0.01907213404774666,
-0.7426168918609619,
-0.7215767502784729,
0.5839242935180664,
0.39537835121154785,
-0.16029003262519836,
-0.5757977366447449,
-0.40291669964790344,
0.15966568887233734,
0.26395508646965027,
0.4367694854736328,
0.3762225806713104,
-0.5739597678184509,
-0.1819373369216919,
-0.021325968205928802,
-0.30397385358810425,
-0.00369780114851892,
1.0679874420166016,
-0.5306909084320068,
0.319403737783432,
0.5366029143333435,
0.8407294154167175,
0.5186878442764282,
-0.05350180342793465,
0.7253280878067017,
-0.375182181596756,
-0.17421706020832062,
0.27105557918548584,
0.4305382966995239,
0.2527916133403778,
0.030793553218245506,
0.8144620656967163,
0.1581001579761505,
-0.7943789958953857,
-0.9561716318130493,
0.17275796830654144,
-0.807421088218689,
-0.11266262829303741,
0.9880349636077881,
-0.293965607881546,
-0.32858526706695557,
-0.24214807152748108,
-0.013366617262363434,
0.004750619642436504,
-0.5473604798316956,
0.42479631304740906,
0.7262340188026428,
-0.3041326105594635,
-0.08915585279464722,
-0.3726932406425476,
0.17230598628520966,
0.579359769821167,
-0.9255309700965881,
0.06775060296058655,
0.6874915957450867,
0.25221094489097595,
0.11943407356739044,
0.9573242664337158,
-0.04155074432492256,
0.35345393419265747,
0.23460422456264496,
0.0009617998148314655,
-0.13504810631275177,
-0.2963094115257263,
-0.11316505074501038,
0.26796817779541016,
0.42217838764190674,
-0.05689619109034538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06407v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06407v3
|
Rethinking How to Evaluate Language Model Jailbreak
| 2024-04-09T15:54:16 | 2024-05-07T14:06:23 |
Hongyu Cai, Arjun Arunasalam, Leo Y. Lin, Antonio Bianchi, Z. Berkay Celik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have become increasingly integrated with various
applications. To ensure that LLMs do not generate unsafe responses, they are
aligned with safeguards that specify what content is restricted. However, such
alignment can be bypassed to produce prohibited content using a technique
commonly referred to as jailbreak. Different systems have been proposed to
perform the jailbreak automatically. These systems rely on evaluation methods
to determine whether a jailbreak attempt is successful. However, our analysis
reveals that current jailbreak evaluation methods have two limitations. (1)
Their objectives lack clarity and do not align with the goal of identifying
unsafe responses. (2) They oversimplify the jailbreak result as a binary
outcome, successful or not. In this paper, we propose three metrics, safeguard
violation, informativeness, and relative truthfulness, to evaluate language
model jailbreak. Additionally, we demonstrate how these metrics correlate with
the goal of different malicious actors. To compute these metrics, we introduce
a multifaceted approach that extends the natural language generation evaluation
method after preprocessing the response. We evaluate our metrics on a benchmark
dataset produced from three malicious intent datasets and three jailbreak
systems. The benchmark dataset is labeled by three annotators. We compare our
multifaceted approach with three existing jailbreak evaluation methods.
Experiments demonstrate that our multifaceted evaluation outperforms existing
methods, with F1 scores improving on average by 17% compared to existing
baselines. Our findings motivate the need to move away from the binary view of
the jailbreak problem and incorporate a more comprehensive evaluation to ensure
the safety of the language model.
|
[
-0.2106817364692688,
-0.8475096821784973,
0.5349161028862,
0.19340866804122925,
-0.20724259316921234,
0.33956608176231384,
-0.3778548240661621,
-0.6432256102561951,
0.06505971401929855,
0.749862551689148,
-0.24384772777557373,
-0.49897778034210205,
-0.6560697555541992,
-0.025480078533291817,
-0.4120556712150574,
1.3124127388000488,
0.020309651270508766,
-0.21043364703655243,
-0.10763633996248245,
-0.05967521294951439,
-0.856887936592102,
-0.5032907128334045,
-0.3590255677700043,
-0.07443371415138245,
0.21179382503032684,
0.3537875711917877,
0.6852229833602905,
0.6739287972450256,
0.8326386213302612,
0.3125564754009247,
-0.1282498985528946,
-0.004160932265222073,
-0.4159025549888611,
0.09176637977361679,
0.025052567943930626,
-0.4010609984397888,
-0.21087174117565155,
0.18721476197242737,
0.2418120801448822,
0.33506590127944946,
-0.1937268078327179,
0.14808973670005798,
-0.17345502972602844,
0.7659687399864197,
-0.7950995564460754,
-0.11755038797855377,
-0.7424160838127136,
-0.020083963871002197,
-0.12040514498949051,
0.16642533242702484,
-0.5695197582244873,
-0.5661934614181519,
0.005349041894078255,
-0.07201634347438812,
-0.08809985220432281,
0.060059309005737305,
0.4797171652317047,
0.042213547974824905,
-0.30773988366127014,
-0.3709574341773987,
-0.700029194355011,
0.7184855937957764,
-0.98834228515625,
0.23447227478027344,
0.4379868805408478,
0.47013527154922485,
-0.16626934707164764,
-0.2624208331108093,
-0.34878233075141907,
-0.8623219728469849,
0.11118609458208084,
-0.347944974899292,
-0.22294467687606812,
-0.17705455422401428,
0.19669745862483978,
0.18812230229377747,
-0.37253984808921814,
0.085767962038517,
-0.4680772125720978,
-0.30850932002067566,
0.7869206666946411,
0.17971765995025635,
0.4418964684009552,
-0.46711465716362,
-0.5521842837333679,
0.08040411025285721,
-0.8147103786468506,
0.1363794207572937,
0.8292527794837952,
0.3415974974632263,
-0.12463507801294327,
0.5958820581436157,
0.1882583498954773,
0.5073474645614624,
-0.006333125755190849,
-0.31178992986679077,
0.2874337136745453,
-0.44844016432762146,
0.022123001515865326,
0.060590606182813644,
0.9728643894195557,
0.5000184178352356,
0.44534170627593994,
-0.5118999481201172,
-0.23414944112300873,
0.041046157479286194,
0.5270519256591797,
-0.803827166557312,
-0.020866986364126205,
0.4057021737098694,
-0.3585800230503082,
-0.6483217477798462,
0.1262063831090927,
-0.6956321001052856,
-0.7099416851997375,
0.0732303261756897,
0.224607914686203,
-0.6957219243049622,
-0.29642733931541443,
0.09503459930419922,
-0.04313275218009949,
0.09420685470104218,
0.10385365784168243,
-0.7558953762054443,
0.4511828124523163,
0.7947325706481934,
0.7195999026298523,
-0.11959997564554214,
-0.21686206758022308,
-0.3842660188674927,
-0.01044385600835085,
-0.24884991347789764,
0.4747895896434784,
-0.4366103410720825,
-0.29513680934906006,
-0.25627994537353516,
-0.2946522831916809,
-0.03557963669300079,
-0.6105631589889526,
0.5004867911338806,
-0.49198490381240845,
-0.13767358660697937,
0.09481483697891235,
-0.49707770347595215,
-0.19896043837070465,
0.3393816351890564,
-0.7417917251586914,
0.6219176650047302,
-0.11424100399017334,
-0.9183394312858582,
0.4602096378803253,
-0.3145725429058075,
-0.5732277631759644,
-0.22023151814937592,
0.11791552603244781,
-0.5173073410987854,
0.21276719868183136,
0.10090654343366623,
0.23243123292922974,
-0.305465430021286,
0.8728903532028198,
-0.5158052444458008,
-0.27735936641693115,
0.4875584542751312,
-0.4589725732803345,
0.6245270371437073,
0.3617912828922272,
-0.4367172122001648,
0.1317468136548996,
-0.7003781199455261,
-0.05291508138179779,
0.2455015927553177,
-0.38112685084342957,
-0.4553753733634949,
0.27363917231559753,
-0.018004847690463066,
0.10207386314868927,
0.1321682184934616,
-0.8604459762573242,
-0.023075245320796967,
-0.5993515253067017,
0.5673221945762634,
0.7439009547233582,
-0.034706711769104004,
0.24115024507045746,
-0.21095995604991913,
0.364335298538208,
-0.15945297479629517,
0.4721794128417969,
-0.0343046635389328,
-0.23370936512947083,
-0.3818763494491577,
-0.09166193753480911,
0.20128272473812103,
0.7202445864677429,
-0.2665504813194275,
0.42764851450920105,
-0.27531176805496216,
-0.6764026284217834,
-0.47963428497314453,
0.3355538547039032,
0.7029832601547241,
0.37418052554130554,
0.2976808547973633,
-0.5050563216209412,
-0.5231022238731384,
-0.9070844054222107,
-0.6756956577301025,
-0.5162237286567688,
0.3653743267059326,
0.12960927188396454,
0.515551745891571,
-0.06322163343429565,
0.827750563621521,
-0.13821271061897278,
0.12352333217859268,
-0.6054496169090271,
0.033521369099617004,
0.2097024768590927,
0.6051478981971741,
0.5925185680389404,
-0.48194408416748047,
-0.12936317920684814,
-0.24479496479034424,
-0.7077765464782715,
-0.0984576940536499,
0.03991825878620148,
0.2891775667667389,
0.035825904458761215,
0.39126837253570557,
-0.4159587025642395,
0.5958037972450256,
0.4787752330303192,
-0.5306648015975952,
0.9727563858032227,
0.0865437313914299,
0.24106702208518982,
-0.7189533710479736,
0.03214102238416672,
-0.05869104713201523,
-0.13519607484340668,
-0.740699827671051,
0.4386971890926361,
0.1306716352701187,
-0.04326660558581352,
-0.6448333263397217,
0.35861194133758545,
-0.24424013495445251,
0.02243546023964882,
-0.2814376652240753,
0.1631067842245102,
-0.025211060419678688,
0.060904957354068756,
-0.43189260363578796,
0.571986198425293,
0.1692880243062973,
-0.17580172419548035,
0.45023366808891296,
0.09140748530626297,
-0.588908314704895,
0.09715640544891357,
-0.7288641929626465,
0.33336639404296875,
-0.1592983901500702,
0.041515644639730453,
-1.0443466901779175,
-0.02168104238808155,
0.2478853315114975,
-0.4134199321269989,
0.1509842425584793,
-0.2902800142765045,
-0.6211585402488708,
-0.2828197181224823,
-0.5413224697113037,
0.3547101318836212,
0.15185336768627167,
-0.20618504285812378,
0.1982475370168686,
0.3956068754196167,
-0.04533226788043976,
-0.6757277250289917,
-0.5546095371246338,
0.39625298976898193,
-0.553933322429657,
-0.9043883681297302,
0.09124904870986938,
-0.07707718014717102,
-0.6260794997215271,
-0.16763384640216827,
-0.10854055732488632,
0.06161132827401161,
0.4366103410720825,
0.29077887535095215,
0.43541622161865234,
0.002733515575528145,
-0.17035964131355286,
-0.06858480721712112,
-0.011248255148530006,
0.3313988447189331,
0.08548975735902786,
0.5253875851631165,
-0.3609532117843628,
-0.3123285174369812,
-0.2641095221042633,
0.1330832839012146,
0.5980589389801025,
-0.5248786211013794,
0.8644874095916748,
0.27920955419540405,
-0.13707484304904938,
0.12915398180484772,
-0.7152392268180847,
-0.05649309605360031,
-0.43154820799827576,
0.2463107407093048,
-0.3467767834663391,
-0.9412813186645508,
0.4439390003681183,
0.08082103729248047,
0.19550317525863647,
0.014285041019320488,
0.3796386420726776,
0.2939597964286804,
0.8044767379760742,
0.7063921093940735,
-0.17108981311321259,
0.3363964855670929,
0.11041870713233948,
0.5674372315406799,
-0.797002375125885,
-0.24504244327545166,
-0.6355859637260437,
-0.10286098718643188,
-0.5613117218017578,
-0.13455352187156677,
0.07413619011640549,
0.3910960853099823,
-0.08619502931833267,
0.6910050511360168,
-0.10332661867141724,
0.4832288324832916,
-0.005041469354182482,
0.07606392353773117,
0.3776859939098358,
-0.25273314118385315,
-0.32776767015457153,
-0.004055397119373083,
-0.2489941269159317,
-0.8328503966331482,
1.3517060279846191,
0.5929754376411438,
0.695438802242279,
0.48384955525398254,
0.8080098032951355,
0.3282310962677002,
0.6123421788215637,
-0.8051242828369141,
0.5722635388374329,
-0.09875503927469254,
-0.8305373787879944,
-0.21245089173316956,
-0.41618579626083374,
-0.6876626014709473,
0.26221880316734314,
-0.08142004907131195,
-1.200642466545105,
-0.2071327269077301,
-0.0679895430803299,
-0.4099453389644623,
0.18409816920757294,
-0.8249949216842651,
0.8594005107879639,
-0.4738929569721222,
-0.49452900886535645,
-0.16918006539344788,
-0.7580204606056213,
0.8981996774673462,
-0.33424535393714905,
0.764811098575592,
-0.44583484530448914,
0.26678740978240967,
0.6783763766288757,
-0.5529460906982422,
0.8463121652603149,
-0.19639399647712708,
-0.14070729911327362,
0.25281277298927307,
0.4042634665966034,
0.3562220633029938,
0.17642126977443695,
-0.32304510474205017,
-0.11839425563812256,
-0.002551768207922578,
0.009594880044460297,
-0.5314218401908875,
0.5975433588027954,
-0.5461173057556152,
-0.7670055627822876,
-0.0559961162507534,
-0.4789576828479767,
-0.34215813875198364,
0.20105400681495667,
0.06858106702566147,
0.23254276812076569,
-0.27788859605789185,
0.022299187257885933,
0.33832409977912903,
-0.6033639311790466,
0.4400080442428589,
0.6423090100288391,
-0.6016618609428406,
-0.44102588295936584,
0.5654817819595337,
-0.2649480998516083,
0.4579896628856659,
0.07213585823774338,
0.3684282600879669,
-0.2262023687362671,
-0.8238199353218079,
-0.3894248604774475,
0.19644786417484283,
-0.5962339639663696,
-0.1636875718832016,
-0.45602986216545105,
-0.3331049680709839,
-0.4798234701156616,
0.05620960891246796,
-0.4228898584842682,
-0.18462057411670685,
0.21442435681819916,
-0.2235315591096878,
0.18050427734851837,
0.7157564759254456,
-0.12012745440006256,
0.22548113763332367,
-0.8577772378921509,
0.26899972558021545,
-0.09861104190349579,
0.3224550783634186,
-0.005264820996671915,
-0.6087478399276733,
-0.15784604847431183,
-0.18322277069091797,
-0.22826190292835236,
-1.1731257438659668,
0.2644480764865875,
0.019597474485635757,
0.5558616518974304,
0.3280865550041199,
0.06509791314601898,
0.6133529543876648,
-0.7314602136611938,
0.5266191959381104,
0.282245010137558,
-1.0427041053771973,
0.9014526009559631,
-0.16629062592983246,
-0.16576357185840607,
0.8193471431732178,
-0.07685944437980652,
-0.4718167185783386,
-0.8709356784820557,
-0.43210941553115845,
-1.0308383703231812,
0.43487223982810974,
0.24484729766845703,
0.4255426228046417,
-0.10813593119382858,
0.32834291458129883,
0.2373836487531662,
0.32617709040641785,
-0.9363716244697571,
-0.11543145030736923,
-0.0404711551964283,
0.07687971740961075,
-0.09973142296075821,
-0.23873472213745117,
-0.06554734706878662,
-0.22083494067192078,
0.29790249466896057,
0.32119986414909363,
0.017280787229537964,
-0.21134483814239502,
-0.41173502802848816,
0.03231063857674599,
0.6266335844993591,
0.3950287997722626,
0.658643901348114,
-0.3480790853500366,
0.05527056008577347,
-0.2547699511051178,
-0.6572284698486328,
0.37469807267189026,
0.08314980566501617,
-0.11483446508646011,
-0.17389491200447083,
0.4775833487510681,
0.8239964842796326,
0.10583875328302383,
-0.9024444818496704,
0.7466155886650085,
-0.13347959518432617,
0.12875127792358398,
-0.16582155227661133,
0.2620200216770172,
-0.18085767328739166,
0.09108643978834152,
0.1233903095126152,
0.05639459192752838,
0.18568196892738342,
-0.6546844840049744,
0.40530309081077576,
0.4571060538291931,
-0.37725400924682617,
-0.20329318940639496,
0.5777419209480286,
0.1328606754541397,
-0.3313838243484497,
0.5927906036376953,
-0.06962788850069046,
-0.4675893783569336,
0.6913895606994629,
0.7093983888626099,
1.0407359600067139,
-0.2384594827890396,
0.3207789957523346,
0.28284236788749695,
0.9736204743385315,
0.10313677787780762,
0.17898276448249817,
0.15090209245681763,
-0.9173937439918518,
-0.6993456482887268,
-0.7666634917259216,
-0.12915077805519104,
0.2874515950679779,
-0.6078909039497375,
0.11638474464416504,
-0.7355570793151855,
-0.32537588477134705,
0.03627629205584526,
-0.16340278089046478,
-0.339250773191452,
0.10537531971931458,
0.18550387024879456,
1.0291149616241455,
-0.8329317569732666,
0.6758432388305664,
0.447051465511322,
-0.23489484190940857,
-0.8263332843780518,
0.11196263134479523,
0.23177503049373627,
-0.6351213455200195,
0.4917190372943878,
0.5967662334442139,
-0.10008001327514648,
-0.4153943955898285,
-0.5478352904319763,
-0.729097843170166,
0.5167169570922852,
0.4098562002182007,
-0.6228825449943542,
0.2148820012807846,
0.1406928449869156,
0.41724449396133423,
-0.2842680513858795,
0.05150879546999931,
0.9905200600624084,
0.4992542564868927,
-0.15207026898860931,
-0.9344884753227234,
0.2550615966320038,
-0.4020320177078247,
0.020262356847524643,
0.4356226325035095,
-0.2599864900112152,
0.5612727999687195,
-0.6193776726722717,
-0.16851624846458435,
0.3223873972892761,
0.20630097389221191,
0.5449137687683105,
0.09945632517337799,
0.5325037837028503,
0.686716616153717,
0.3807741701602936,
-0.08614823967218399,
1.026532769203186,
-0.2841850519180298,
0.27593716979026794,
1.1791783571243286,
-0.3210393786430359,
0.851220965385437,
0.6205838918685913,
-0.11253146827220917,
0.5107213854789734,
0.1993442326784134,
-0.0949772521853447,
0.6280169486999512,
0.6265086531639099,
-0.14676503837108612,
-0.13738535344600677,
0.05779276788234711,
-0.08264464139938354,
0.7782354950904846,
0.28370770812034607,
-0.4034408926963806,
-0.3052641451358795,
0.14995956420898438,
0.3452950119972229,
0.12709547579288483,
-0.03594153746962547,
0.7186224460601807,
0.020310839638113976,
-0.6143656969070435,
0.4329261779785156,
0.5530573129653931,
0.4652068018913269,
-0.4415552616119385,
0.2033291757106781,
-0.16222019493579865,
0.05042010918259621,
-0.2157251089811325,
-0.8541078567504883,
0.47980594635009766,
0.6260638236999512,
0.11488726735115051,
0.02348591573536396,
0.7591805458068848,
0.08009815961122513,
-0.4064096212387085,
0.5034894943237305,
0.42306047677993774,
0.22459901869297028,
0.06786000728607178,
-0.6921306252479553,
0.3916406035423279,
-0.021165326237678528,
-0.20247016847133636,
0.261493444442749,
0.06739474087953568,
-0.008385629393160343,
0.6954549551010132,
0.7563270330429077,
0.15541183948516846,
0.12636977434158325,
0.12178903818130493,
0.7849969267845154,
-0.7097591161727905,
-0.34045764803886414,
-1.244596242904663,
0.6168130040168762,
0.036806073039770126,
-0.2679899036884308,
0.7903041243553162,
0.5007456541061401,
0.6160790920257568,
0.29050394892692566,
0.9325473308563232,
-0.3510712683200836,
0.283430278301239,
-0.5958557724952698,
0.6506431698799133,
-0.21595600247383118,
0.8774276971817017,
-0.5969977974891663,
-0.8578534126281738,
-0.22967413067817688,
0.43018609285354614,
-0.663240373134613,
0.0018542353063821793,
0.5754268765449524,
0.5292815566062927,
0.16312718391418457,
0.07406826317310333,
0.196515291929245,
0.07561200857162476,
0.3930618166923523,
0.5765554904937744,
1.1466647386550903,
-0.3735504448413849,
0.560873806476593,
-0.2834113538265228,
-0.2773435711860657,
-0.05078957974910736,
-0.9404783844947815,
-0.863812267780304,
-0.03404873237013817,
-0.14448654651641846,
-0.39415594935417175,
0.25271257758140564,
0.5514883399009705,
0.4887949824333191,
-0.788590669631958,
-0.3969334363937378,
-0.03485214710235596,
0.14196811616420746,
0.01006444450467825,
-0.23241396248340607,
-0.1187971830368042,
-0.41713812947273254,
-0.21958062052726746,
0.5270032286643982,
0.46952903270721436,
-0.15960678458213806,
-0.38502952456474304,
0.01907527633011341,
0.05775218829512596,
0.10266251862049103,
0.533500611782074,
0.09412571042776108,
-0.8143349885940552,
-0.41918858885765076,
-0.15880149602890015,
-0.19608481228351593,
-0.010656176134943962,
0.7617911696434021,
-0.6197773218154907,
0.4010918438434601,
0.17120543122291565,
0.6075888872146606,
0.17282243072986603,
-0.034785348922014236,
0.5798656344413757,
-0.7101172208786011,
0.060823556035757065,
0.14366576075553894,
0.31898292899131775,
0.45458123087882996,
-0.22445258498191833,
0.3206300437450409,
-0.029637014493346214,
-0.3053840398788452,
-0.8431613445281982,
0.4746067225933075,
-0.47638410329818726,
-0.42468971014022827,
1.0831644535064697,
-0.3179243803024292,
-0.17311537265777588,
-0.18577656149864197,
0.09838799387216568,
0.01324945967644453,
-0.3521663248538971,
0.8786132335662842,
0.7329202890396118,
0.0037135505117475986,
-0.2032603621482849,
-0.7347400784492493,
0.22266845405101776,
0.11534418165683746,
-0.838340163230896,
0.16730599105358124,
0.578057050704956,
0.6139236092567444,
0.23586000502109528,
0.36855748295783997,
-0.5620154142379761,
0.1787520945072174,
-0.2845054268836975,
-0.03034829907119274,
-0.06606139242649078,
-0.5691113471984863,
-0.28911253809928894,
0.1483096182346344,
0.2412809282541275,
0.11174643784761429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06405v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06405v2
|
Wu's Method can Boost Symbolic AI to Rival Silver Medalists and AlphaGeometry to Outperform Gold Medalists at IMO Geometry
| 2024-04-09T15:54:00 | 2024-04-11T14:37:29 |
Shiven Sinha, Ameya Prabhu, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru, Siddharth Bhat, Matthias Bethge
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CG, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Proving geometric theorems constitutes a hallmark of visual reasoning
combining both intuitive and logical skills. Therefore, automated theorem
proving of Olympiad-level geometry problems is considered a notable milestone
in human-level automated reasoning. The introduction of AlphaGeometry, a
neuro-symbolic model trained with 100 million synthetic samples, marked a major
breakthrough. It solved 25 of 30 International Mathematical Olympiad (IMO)
problems whereas the reported baseline based on Wu's method solved only ten. In
this note, we revisit the IMO-AG-30 Challenge introduced with AlphaGeometry,
and find that Wu's method is surprisingly strong. Wu's method alone can solve
15 problems, and some of them are not solved by any of the other methods. This
leads to two key findings: (i) Combining Wu's method with the classic synthetic
methods of deductive databases and angle, ratio, and distance chasing solves 21
out of 30 methods by just using a CPU-only laptop with a time limit of 5
minutes per problem. Essentially, this classic method solves just 4 problems
less than AlphaGeometry and establishes the first fully symbolic baseline
strong enough to rival the performance of an IMO silver medalist. (ii) Wu's
method even solves 2 of the 5 problems that AlphaGeometry failed to solve.
Thus, by combining AlphaGeometry with Wu's method we set a new state-of-the-art
for automated theorem proving on IMO-AG-30, solving 27 out of 30 problems, the
first AI method which outperforms an IMO gold medalist.
|
[
-0.6171169281005859,
-0.8509969711303711,
0.758624255657196,
0.09201935678720474,
-0.015911906957626343,
0.19318115711212158,
-0.028954919427633286,
-0.6150071024894714,
-0.08820758759975433,
-0.36747434735298157,
-0.6910008788108826,
-0.1875341236591339,
-0.40800365805625916,
0.250060111284256,
-0.5450629591941833,
0.5565468668937683,
-0.2310895323753357,
0.10667172819375992,
-0.38177403807640076,
-0.46162256598472595,
-0.17863105237483978,
-0.5275614857673645,
-0.455808162689209,
-0.7498042583465576,
0.1518467664718628,
0.287346214056015,
0.8167856335639954,
0.779161274433136,
0.7854849100112915,
0.3406608998775482,
-0.060418594628572464,
0.371736079454422,
-0.08366825431585312,
-0.28801149129867554,
0.19141723215579987,
-0.6435438990592957,
-0.20915290713310242,
0.2551868259906769,
0.5442196130752563,
0.571658194065094,
-0.10586710274219513,
-0.09368497878313065,
0.2142249345779419,
0.9384945034980774,
-0.4172658324241638,
0.08714894950389862,
-0.4084228277206421,
0.08819897472858429,
-0.5034118890762329,
0.026509283110499382,
-0.18809182941913605,
-0.22169750928878784,
-0.07349526137113571,
-1.1160813570022583,
-0.03217554837465286,
0.21810117363929749,
1.1972054243087769,
0.3670302927494049,
-0.3347354829311371,
-0.167659729719162,
-0.8864486813545227,
0.8482557535171509,
-0.6347871422767639,
0.053719282150268555,
0.1592724770307541,
0.646885097026825,
-0.028062384575605392,
-0.5089399814605713,
-0.545398473739624,
-0.4718303084373474,
0.21020328998565674,
0.14694461226463318,
-0.5373600721359253,
0.06478580832481384,
0.642430305480957,
0.425246000289917,
-0.6647147536277771,
0.01846126839518547,
-0.5858156085014343,
-0.20240698754787445,
0.8528477549552917,
0.06343282014131546,
0.5567268133163452,
-0.020648976787924767,
0.02334425412118435,
-0.36761364340782166,
-0.5539740324020386,
0.06164128705859184,
0.28828975558280945,
-0.1590908318758011,
0.15356990694999695,
0.8116874098777771,
-0.4151957035064697,
0.5614664554595947,
0.06684013456106186,
-0.10706670582294464,
-0.007009338121861219,
-0.10438058525323868,
0.022353695705533028,
0.04833000898361206,
0.7979492545127869,
0.01876695454120636,
0.8039930462837219,
-0.10225246846675873,
0.022392695769667625,
0.4661768674850464,
0.09614353626966476,
-0.4649507701396942,
-0.43215492367744446,
0.15365523099899292,
-0.19330137968063354,
0.11241107434034348,
0.18464316427707672,
-0.1646612286567688,
-0.16023018956184387,
-0.4492276906967163,
0.6489920020103455,
-0.7365676760673523,
0.16774187982082367,
-0.13978543877601624,
-0.1417827010154724,
0.1973581165075302,
0.473250150680542,
-0.4812193810939789,
0.18369528651237488,
0.9783514142036438,
0.9332724213600159,
0.11215771734714508,
-0.526014506816864,
-0.5016165971755981,
-0.2059629261493683,
-0.6681656241416931,
0.9541658163070679,
-0.098477303981781,
-0.09567049890756607,
-0.31148773431777954,
-0.3386012613773346,
0.3000831604003906,
-0.6277560591697693,
0.1629454642534256,
-0.05663131922483444,
0.1557871550321579,
-0.365853488445282,
-0.40602487325668335,
-0.4029424786567688,
0.615400493144989,
-0.34795331954956055,
0.9263779520988464,
0.00927992258220911,
-0.3204789459705353,
0.23272046446800232,
-0.6359201669692993,
-0.3496781587600708,
0.15711772441864014,
-0.20188917219638824,
-0.24403375387191772,
0.3253342807292938,
0.5416719913482666,
-0.2345040738582611,
-0.41224008798599243,
-0.03886387497186661,
-0.5159673094749451,
-0.48084521293640137,
0.1180955022573471,
-0.1467895656824112,
1.0966737270355225,
0.036977093666791916,
-0.404288113117218,
-0.06374447792768478,
-0.6206434369087219,
0.397672563791275,
0.40539875626564026,
0.0801730826497078,
-0.35072585940361023,
-0.21231472492218018,
-0.7861899733543396,
0.10234701633453369,
0.05809871479868889,
-0.5980803370475769,
0.34110045433044434,
-0.43425658345222473,
0.32800284028053284,
0.8462997078895569,
-0.3639894723892212,
0.29750585556030273,
-0.5492287874221802,
0.3338147699832916,
-0.2780579626560211,
0.26414456963539124,
0.060976382344961166,
-0.8300247192382812,
-0.7205190062522888,
-0.13981835544109344,
0.19127434492111206,
0.9113641381263733,
-0.8079589605331421,
0.2528204917907715,
-0.08981472998857498,
-0.8281988501548767,
-0.4791383743286133,
0.13939552009105682,
0.36008554697036743,
0.42233699560165405,
0.30526116490364075,
-0.18929433822631836,
-0.1751532256603241,
-0.7350296378135681,
-0.45145362615585327,
-0.6491658091545105,
-0.07837852835655212,
0.3299696743488312,
0.5170290470123291,
-0.06757467240095139,
0.8237326741218567,
-0.5202896595001221,
-0.5475085973739624,
0.18597573041915894,
0.5867682099342346,
0.4182037115097046,
0.5611277222633362,
0.5453724265098572,
-0.15691863000392914,
-0.280067503452301,
0.2938467860221863,
-1.5561598539352417,
-0.36969396471977234,
-0.000879704428371042,
-0.1800825595855713,
0.054596882313489914,
0.3449326753616333,
-0.4468458890914917,
0.3568836748600006,
0.15814150869846344,
-0.2232924997806549,
0.9520518183708191,
-0.46421295404434204,
0.24361202120780945,
-0.3874824047088623,
-0.13841576874256134,
0.33135855197906494,
0.02319532074034214,
-0.2254459410905838,
0.35224124789237976,
-0.062334708869457245,
-0.2178444117307663,
-0.20219066739082336,
0.6308872699737549,
-0.5511801838874817,
0.05168478935956955,
-0.37940675020217896,
-0.2621256113052368,
-0.05011206492781639,
0.4291296899318695,
-0.7074695825576782,
0.5028752088546753,
0.6066996455192566,
-0.6085717082023621,
0.8049063086509705,
0.1271662563085556,
0.05781304091215134,
0.9794727563858032,
-0.7305362224578857,
0.26575767993927,
-0.2992112338542938,
-0.08897906541824341,
-0.9694477319717407,
0.08248663693666458,
-0.023038500919938087,
-0.6039692163467407,
-0.172304168343544,
-0.0823502242565155,
-0.5630239844322205,
-0.8088918924331665,
-0.20258483290672302,
0.579261839389801,
0.5603001713752747,
-0.7318658232688904,
0.7681852579116821,
0.025328660383820534,
0.06281637400388718,
-0.47441592812538147,
-0.6033588647842407,
0.2938074469566345,
-0.3570883274078369,
-0.854625940322876,
0.1430700570344925,
-0.28999513387680054,
-0.8667909502983093,
0.09043613076210022,
-0.206644207239151,
0.056680694222450256,
0.37917935848236084,
-0.1254393309354782,
0.24993778765201569,
-0.10563164204359055,
-0.17748822271823883,
-0.055256329476833344,
-0.4830826222896576,
0.2367081642150879,
-0.41499507427215576,
0.3400086760520935,
-0.6170748472213745,
-0.7102223038673401,
-0.7417312860488892,
0.5112203359603882,
0.5000817179679871,
0.035103484988212585,
0.32019278407096863,
0.32972681522369385,
-0.6895232796669006,
0.056664153933525085,
-0.3099285066127777,
-0.30349963903427124,
-0.480493426322937,
0.159190371632576,
-0.42614006996154785,
-0.2704010009765625,
0.4286653697490692,
-0.1151270717382431,
0.4616193175315857,
0.5633696913719177,
0.049472883343696594,
-0.43255093693733215,
1.6375571489334106,
0.36795270442962646,
-0.04874824732542038,
0.38373687863349915,
-0.6502096652984619,
0.25697219371795654,
-0.5845806002616882,
-0.168190598487854,
-0.6391856074333191,
-0.6052944660186768,
-0.2865639626979828,
0.159265398979187,
0.83600914478302,
0.3710683286190033,
-0.601857602596283,
0.11024432629346848,
-0.7587746381759644,
0.32203248143196106,
0.9968557357788086,
0.05181828513741493,
0.5780053734779358,
0.1794803887605667,
-0.19492655992507935,
-0.39873310923576355,
-0.620200514793396,
-0.05390162020921707,
0.9229311347007751,
-0.0947510302066803,
0.8986269235610962,
0.005295274779200554,
0.6038040518760681,
0.2742922604084015,
0.6012802720069885,
-0.9393473863601685,
0.6777308583259583,
-0.14027680456638336,
-0.5026165246963501,
-0.2595791816711426,
-0.529981791973114,
-0.7021503448486328,
0.2048811912536621,
-0.3150648772716522,
-0.6755598187446594,
-0.14678168296813965,
0.20580285787582397,
-0.06403720378875732,
0.22856776416301727,
-0.5717409253120422,
0.5357406735420227,
-0.4870193302631378,
-0.2737295627593994,
-0.18366730213165283,
-0.28347042202949524,
0.29645028710365295,
0.22356878221035004,
0.29880645871162415,
-0.07784098386764526,
0.3628987669944763,
0.8586904406547546,
-0.7237876057624817,
0.07360751926898956,
-0.08356436342000961,
-0.025179598480463028,
0.41329890489578247,
0.2980072796344757,
0.4911167323589325,
-0.03297210857272148,
0.05901608243584633,
0.1609610766172409,
-0.21695029735565186,
-0.5181729197502136,
-0.7477033734321594,
0.5712440013885498,
-0.7574848532676697,
-0.7739202976226807,
-0.7733485698699951,
-0.7216434478759766,
0.00513121671974659,
0.30908939242362976,
0.44723275303840637,
0.5609182119369507,
0.04249076545238495,
-0.01658332720398903,
0.1882125437259674,
0.32448258996009827,
0.4284360110759735,
0.01734570413827896,
-0.11522768437862396,
-0.4548819363117218,
0.7526446580886841,
0.5315227508544922,
-0.00839531421661377,
-0.08863264322280884,
0.50613933801651,
-0.08340319246053696,
-0.3832719624042511,
-0.6684669256210327,
0.5587034821510315,
-0.8857147693634033,
-0.1938983052968979,
-0.3247801661491394,
-0.36783459782600403,
-0.01261053141206503,
-0.525646448135376,
-0.42470985651016235,
-0.5178090333938599,
0.18445084989070892,
0.2129906564950943,
0.23146288096904755,
0.44687411189079285,
-0.43862834572792053,
0.2084779292345047,
-0.6991950273513794,
0.4470924437046051,
0.5504560470581055,
-0.09089188277721405,
0.10292460024356842,
0.0014248160878196359,
-0.11159195750951767,
0.21990342438220978,
-0.5095205903053284,
-0.8383402824401855,
0.2587997317314148,
0.1545393317937851,
0.6115689277648926,
0.6386609077453613,
-0.06475081294775009,
1.0735409259796143,
-0.24066515266895294,
0.5763372778892517,
0.1717182695865631,
-1.0162144899368286,
0.5405042767524719,
-0.19053393602371216,
0.47193625569343567,
0.41670817136764526,
0.21109528839588165,
-0.2153719961643219,
-0.4769666790962219,
-0.744820237159729,
-0.6901406049728394,
0.4100134074687958,
0.4477859139442444,
-0.2652570307254791,
0.24775315821170807,
0.5718744397163391,
-0.07294487953186035,
-0.32127997279167175,
-0.8963909149169922,
-0.3529643714427948,
-0.029535625129938126,
-0.12816214561462402,
0.28278446197509766,
0.4906148314476013,
-0.47586482763290405,
-0.6782287359237671,
0.9528200030326843,
-0.48703324794769287,
0.3863855302333832,
0.32120880484580994,
-0.25000256299972534,
-0.2031647115945816,
-0.039793334901332855,
-0.04704304784536362,
1.033711314201355,
0.09256945550441742,
0.1046697124838829,
0.17834436893463135,
-0.3390021324157715,
0.35007965564727783,
0.6147189736366272,
-0.4498708248138428,
-0.06880705803632736,
0.5411260724067688,
0.35636234283447266,
-0.5040957927703857,
-0.5525357127189636,
-0.03798627853393555,
0.03757362440228462,
-0.3827480971813202,
-0.2609207332134247,
0.1864652931690216,
-0.33317112922668457,
0.28872594237327576,
1.0289158821105957,
-0.0056373970583081245,
0.08899395167827606,
-0.6332998275756836,
-0.016431493684649467,
0.8514378666877747,
-0.2238006442785263,
-0.22597017884254456,
1.0225799083709717,
-0.2586207389831543,
-0.4296545386314392,
0.8119989037513733,
-0.2310076355934143,
-0.5094990730285645,
1.0003718137741089,
0.5348688364028931,
0.6356279850006104,
-0.14413541555404663,
0.17077045142650604,
0.6790478229522705,
0.4616466164588928,
-0.28653547167778015,
0.3263786733150482,
-0.12201999127864838,
-0.3208610415458679,
-0.3056481182575226,
-0.0968589037656784,
-0.5217934250831604,
-0.3270922303199768,
-0.5298892855644226,
0.11474466323852539,
-0.4811173975467682,
-0.1470341831445694,
0.06516093760728836,
0.39971864223480225,
-0.31594640016555786,
0.08414492011070251,
0.2546862065792084,
0.6732303500175476,
-0.8265361785888672,
0.3203866183757782,
0.7984656095504761,
0.07982846349477768,
-0.6533467173576355,
-0.12152217328548431,
0.30965185165405273,
-0.8889919519424438,
0.3052569627761841,
0.2904667258262634,
0.05026671290397644,
0.05961550772190094,
-0.6612900495529175,
-0.7572056651115417,
1.108081579208374,
0.495138555765152,
-0.3343467116355896,
-0.08327267318964005,
-0.18152804672718048,
0.5014767050743103,
0.031239667907357216,
0.1503811925649643,
0.3842778503894806,
0.637181282043457,
0.21678242087364197,
-1.0276306867599487,
0.035867996513843536,
-0.38683444261550903,
-0.2505686283111572,
0.15223945677280426,
-0.47210368514060974,
1.0087275505065918,
-0.6390419602394104,
-0.31698647141456604,
0.4169910252094269,
1.0613847970962524,
0.8821901679039001,
0.5687329173088074,
0.5781455636024475,
0.950689435005188,
0.940104603767395,
-0.48355573415756226,
1.3404359817504883,
-0.052255332469940186,
0.25897544622421265,
0.1742711365222931,
-0.2624691128730774,
-0.02561076357960701,
0.2238866090774536,
-0.30348411202430725,
0.5757175087928772,
0.3102518618106842,
0.07200151681900024,
0.2577538788318634,
0.2697940170764923,
-0.0745391696691513,
-0.33476436138153076,
0.041731368750333786,
-0.6496469378471375,
0.504285991191864,
0.1613602340221405,
0.3904488682746887,
-0.4827501177787781,
0.23462660610675812,
0.3943246304988861,
0.16829867660999298,
-0.4110059440135956,
0.6758996844291687,
0.2446642816066742,
-0.9867743253707886,
0.780125617980957,
-0.13670963048934937,
0.5215241312980652,
-0.7685126066207886,
-0.19101537764072418,
-0.2505895793437958,
0.719855546951294,
-0.031987518072128296,
-0.809646725654602,
0.25802749395370483,
-0.08600801229476929,
0.33552902936935425,
0.05329606682062149,
0.4625891149044037,
0.16271139681339264,
-0.7989621758460999,
0.14809349179267883,
0.726068377494812,
-0.09155664592981339,
-0.28631123900413513,
-0.6290667057037354,
-0.3536395728588104,
-0.3436994254589081,
0.048268549144268036,
0.07040110230445862,
0.5952051281929016,
-0.42722007632255554,
0.8859321475028992,
0.9421597123146057,
-0.053488973528146744,
0.007331202272325754,
-0.3403807282447815,
0.6696110963821411,
-0.6812694668769836,
-0.7891262769699097,
-1.1653177738189697,
0.0717947855591774,
-0.04966798424720764,
-0.24998901784420013,
0.9173896908760071,
0.5753348469734192,
0.5528070330619812,
0.3969976305961609,
0.7485278844833374,
-0.1054292768239975,
-0.26366057991981506,
-0.38982969522476196,
0.48338693380355835,
-0.9345925450325012,
-0.057948239147663116,
-0.3751838803291321,
-1.0025912523269653,
-0.4906361997127533,
0.8636177182197571,
-0.07792603969573975,
0.047857865691185,
0.8621020913124084,
0.2846162021160126,
0.06648599356412888,
-0.04206287860870361,
-0.12420196086168289,
0.1656142622232437,
0.6986464858055115,
0.8489086627960205,
0.9326698184013367,
-0.5480867028236389,
0.7436387538909912,
-0.5816311240196228,
-0.7113732695579529,
-0.03647451475262642,
-0.7185052633285522,
-0.5771701335906982,
-0.4117289185523987,
-0.3804243505001068,
-0.7788012623786926,
0.1758745014667511,
0.5250847935676575,
0.8058925867080688,
-0.4075413942337036,
-0.19615863263607025,
-0.21184231340885162,
0.2021249681711197,
-1.0530484914779663,
-0.2646501660346985,
0.29936808347702026,
-0.028004398569464684,
-0.9440719485282898,
0.3877524137496948,
0.3145461976528168,
0.24097752571105957,
-0.1501522809267044,
-0.2366017997264862,
-0.13087867200374603,
0.06941582262516022,
0.3704691529273987,
0.6781713366508484,
-0.5192252993583679,
-0.2907017469406128,
0.25430434942245483,
0.023783603683114052,
0.3264370560646057,
0.7059662938117981,
-1.0241917371749878,
0.41437602043151855,
0.7109243273735046,
0.30185800790786743,
0.5916902422904968,
0.16366083920001984,
0.6385298371315002,
-0.23421277105808258,
0.3371962010860443,
0.27340754866600037,
0.7445138692855835,
0.227687805891037,
-0.39760950207710266,
0.7313624024391174,
0.593800961971283,
-0.408575177192688,
-0.8363312482833862,
0.0709509402513504,
-1.0433673858642578,
-0.39073535799980164,
0.7717916965484619,
0.043882761150598526,
-0.41524365544319153,
0.07707411795854568,
-0.20537391304969788,
0.09571924805641174,
-0.04853484034538269,
1.3621925115585327,
0.7993051409721375,
-0.5609811544418335,
0.000537683314178139,
-0.3259728252887726,
0.005299495533108711,
0.5544852614402771,
-1.1860915422439575,
-0.3410211205482483,
0.3373863697052002,
-0.12632255256175995,
0.4759552776813507,
0.6558475494384766,
-0.27311569452285767,
0.606821596622467,
-0.028674166649580002,
-0.23773477971553802,
-0.6364074349403381,
-0.5236912369728088,
-0.03520979359745979,
0.14200522005558014,
-0.12276125699281693,
-0.22708989679813385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06395v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06395v3
|
MiniCPM: Unveiling the Potential of Small Language Models with Scalable Training Strategies
| 2024-04-09T15:36:50 | 2024-06-03T08:54:38 |
Shengding Hu, Yuge Tu, Xu Han, Chaoqun He, Ganqu Cui, Xiang Long, Zhi Zheng, Yewei Fang, Yuxiang Huang, Weilin Zhao, Xinrong Zhang, Zheng Leng Thai, Kaihuo Zhang, Chongyi Wang, Yuan Yao, Chenyang Zhao, Jie Zhou, Jie Cai, Zhongwu Zhai, Ning Ding, Chao Jia, Guoyang Zeng, Dahai Li, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The burgeoning interest in developing Large Language Models (LLMs) with up to
trillion parameters has been met with concerns regarding resource efficiency
and practical expense, particularly given the immense cost of experimentation.
This scenario underscores the importance of exploring the potential of Small
Language Models (SLMs) as a resource-efficient alternative. In this context, we
introduce MiniCPM, specifically the 1.2B and 2.4B non-embedding parameter
variants, not only excel in their respective categories but also demonstrate
capabilities on par with 7B-13B LLMs. While focusing on SLMs, our approach
exhibits scalability in both model and data dimensions for future LLM research.
Regarding model scaling, we employ extensive model wind tunnel experiments for
stable and optimal scaling. For data scaling, we introduce a
Warmup-Stable-Decay (WSD) learning rate scheduler (LRS), conducive to
continuous training and domain adaptation. We present an in-depth analysis of
the intriguing training dynamics that occurred in the WSD LRS. With WSD LRS, we
are now able to efficiently study data-model scaling law without extensive
retraining experiments on both axes of model and data, from which we derive the
much higher compute optimal data-model ratio than Chinchilla Optimal.
Additionally, we introduce MiniCPM family, including MiniCPM-DPO, MiniCPM-MoE
and MiniCPM-128K, whose excellent performance further cementing MiniCPM's
foundation in diverse SLM applications. MiniCPM models are available publicly
at https://github.com/OpenBMB/MiniCPM .
|
[
-0.4949491620063782,
-0.5384588241577148,
0.33371275663375854,
0.03283637762069702,
-0.17746227979660034,
0.03019518405199051,
-0.49306097626686096,
-0.20855174958705902,
0.100068598985672,
0.3962510824203491,
-0.6036105751991272,
0.03577857464551926,
-0.5162754654884338,
-0.20613081753253937,
-0.10633880645036697,
0.6717047691345215,
0.03315707668662071,
0.3292868733406067,
-0.30183905363082886,
-0.24729026854038239,
-0.07215586304664612,
-0.4555389881134033,
-0.9321561455726624,
-0.46727558970451355,
0.5107605457305908,
0.7532539963722229,
0.7014216780662537,
1.23799729347229,
0.41496098041534424,
0.11610004305839539,
-0.07840050756931305,
-0.03411895036697388,
-0.595853865146637,
-0.22940614819526672,
0.16181279718875885,
-0.483628511428833,
-0.38143190741539,
0.1130145788192749,
0.7612242698669434,
1.125489592552185,
-0.3357263207435608,
0.4091385006904602,
0.036535944789648056,
0.7328596115112305,
-0.38871511816978455,
0.1804874688386917,
-0.6704890131950378,
-0.03933587297797203,
-0.2845679819583893,
0.07410281896591187,
-0.5272860527038574,
-0.11964276432991028,
0.04109884798526764,
-0.2650088965892792,
0.3400020897388458,
0.3418400287628174,
0.40998169779777527,
0.38224291801452637,
-0.25193092226982117,
-0.5128085613250732,
-0.6415655612945557,
0.9672626852989197,
-0.5880739092826843,
0.7337231040000916,
0.19007030129432678,
0.45195767283439636,
-0.11763085424900055,
-0.7015782594680786,
-0.3032313585281372,
-0.41576454043388367,
0.0522352010011673,
-0.3285723030567169,
-0.14755117893218994,
0.02413611114025116,
0.38387712836265564,
0.4003294110298157,
-0.6848635077476501,
0.7036886215209961,
-0.07234922796487808,
-0.019318049773573875,
0.12446915358304977,
0.5716592073440552,
0.04978480190038681,
0.22529451549053192,
-0.05714594945311546,
-0.04973931238055229,
-0.904863715171814,
0.12803390622138977,
0.272525817155838,
0.7635127305984497,
-0.42266231775283813,
0.4387568235397339,
0.10028931498527527,
0.8057371377944946,
0.17734044790267944,
-0.4069136381149292,
-0.2876634895801544,
-0.3811776041984558,
-0.29963821172714233,
-0.2849466800689697,
0.5530280470848083,
-0.15751022100448608,
-0.18052436411380768,
0.05563867464661598,
-0.14708039164543152,
-0.08889272809028625,
-0.05159782990813255,
-1.0397813320159912,
-0.545305073261261,
-0.06115337461233139,
-0.752016544342041,
-0.2982093393802643,
-0.560603141784668,
-0.8671768307685852,
-0.32102030515670776,
-0.39703258872032166,
0.03439445048570633,
-0.16764245927333832,
-0.15976494550704956,
-0.06203054264187813,
0.10443312674760818,
0.31405481696128845,
0.28820958733558655,
-1.189868450164795,
0.6503729224205017,
0.5047366619110107,
0.8549427390098572,
-0.2606538236141205,
-0.15112508833408356,
-0.4538312256336212,
0.05047537386417389,
-0.49088671803474426,
0.3730432391166687,
-0.4902309775352478,
-0.30878034234046936,
-0.0399995893239975,
-0.06443134695291519,
0.0013286484172567725,
-0.6910205483436584,
0.11361855268478394,
-0.4715943932533264,
-0.07500620186328888,
-0.27616629004478455,
-0.5208182334899902,
0.4003826081752777,
0.02357938326895237,
-0.8188014626502991,
1.0614657402038574,
0.016295909881591797,
-0.5848864316940308,
0.285897433757782,
-0.585969090461731,
-0.24851985275745392,
0.08419080078601837,
-0.12279601395130157,
-0.41441968083381653,
0.3144872486591339,
-0.04793832451105118,
0.19946017861366272,
-0.6391636729240417,
-0.3881867229938507,
-0.4350735545158386,
-0.28976279497146606,
-0.05941142141819,
-0.18917113542556763,
0.7738567590713501,
0.23408542573451996,
-0.03298758342862129,
-0.21791869401931763,
-0.6633132696151733,
0.058818988502025604,
0.3377462923526764,
-0.4415125846862793,
-0.3133623003959656,
0.02328614704310894,
-0.13003012537956238,
0.2523810565471649,
0.2941459119319916,
-0.19067035615444183,
0.24062393605709076,
-0.34831252694129944,
0.5172922611236572,
0.5558481216430664,
-0.14951273798942566,
0.8394407629966736,
-0.3206344544887543,
0.6213885545730591,
0.03663618862628937,
0.21466411650180817,
0.01892692595720291,
-0.2519042491912842,
-0.9992726445198059,
-0.5434795022010803,
0.40359318256378174,
0.1415645182132721,
-0.8427165746688843,
-0.05812466889619827,
-0.22809258103370667,
-0.7604048252105713,
-0.41502541303634644,
0.4541943073272705,
0.29068392515182495,
0.2871941328048706,
0.2314225137233734,
-0.03576582670211792,
-0.62666255235672,
-0.8568845391273499,
-0.2163829356431961,
-0.15886840224266052,
0.026096375659108162,
0.22019977867603302,
0.44442224502563477,
-0.21880054473876953,
0.9074339866638184,
-0.4503292143344879,
-0.2030680775642395,
-0.6948936581611633,
-0.06145020201802254,
0.16965129971504211,
0.415086030960083,
0.6931942701339722,
-0.5454397201538086,
-0.8952783346176147,
-0.3234521150588989,
-0.2635311782360077,
-0.0987587496638298,
-0.010269278660416603,
0.3080765902996063,
0.06300133466720581,
0.4934353232383728,
-0.42084553837776184,
0.03290178254246712,
0.6111921072006226,
0.4629899859428406,
0.33447933197021484,
-0.3431163430213928,
-0.5316227674484253,
-0.5182663202285767,
-0.20263350009918213,
0.02931845746934414,
-0.4667285978794098,
-0.9070172905921936,
0.14641404151916504,
0.2964489758014679,
-0.3298822045326233,
-0.7599318623542786,
0.6402290463447571,
-0.7106869220733643,
-0.10554409772157669,
-0.47077512741088867,
0.2348753660917282,
-0.4842616319656372,
0.51093989610672,
-0.01402143482118845,
0.7257800698280334,
0.5971179604530334,
-0.6382454633712769,
0.05736713483929634,
-0.20612271130084991,
-0.09696540981531143,
0.16365572810173035,
-0.4363846778869629,
0.35440897941589355,
0.041369371116161346,
0.09407128393650055,
-0.6841700673103333,
0.07909487932920456,
-0.03140878677368164,
-0.007390387821942568,
0.5064616203308105,
-0.5501307845115662,
-0.9948722720146179,
-0.3827351927757263,
-0.5258439779281616,
0.45836037397384644,
0.7555965781211853,
-0.7803449630737305,
0.2700793445110321,
0.6620808839797974,
0.041517872363328934,
-0.04901451990008354,
-0.5293132066726685,
-0.117594875395298,
-0.25139835476875305,
-0.31629785895347595,
-0.015066642314195633,
-0.41976746916770935,
-0.22525011003017426,
-0.30235379934310913,
-0.009946489706635475,
0.061810608953237534,
0.06346344202756882,
0.14869293570518494,
0.1979711353778839,
-0.33396151661872864,
-0.1373089849948883,
0.068848617374897,
-0.19734297692775726,
-0.25038841366767883,
-0.48797523975372314,
0.6803539991378784,
-0.4681711792945862,
-0.14840811491012573,
-0.12753146886825562,
0.1366046667098999,
0.42996957898139954,
0.16013820469379425,
1.038196325302124,
0.3236706256866455,
-0.6379125118255615,
-0.4423634111881256,
-0.28661665320396423,
-0.23315370082855225,
-0.5166127681732178,
0.17282401025295258,
-0.36738044023513794,
-1.104871153831482,
0.3675415515899658,
-0.26958924531936646,
-0.1411246657371521,
0.20041826367378235,
0.9766040444374084,
-0.2317042052745819,
0.9979085326194763,
0.9712363481521606,
-0.09933770447969437,
0.5886449217796326,
-0.2877492606639862,
0.10169623792171478,
-0.7264752984046936,
0.17228931188583374,
-0.4261704385280609,
-0.24551048874855042,
-0.7813539505004883,
-0.6131624579429626,
0.2581796944141388,
0.1848214715719223,
-0.20640693604946136,
0.40602907538414,
-0.08825276792049408,
0.5291589498519897,
0.3101675808429718,
-0.26943832635879517,
0.17933669686317444,
-0.22043830156326294,
-0.27043038606643677,
-0.44336941838264465,
-1.141323447227478,
-0.5629643797874451,
1.0021642446517944,
0.6328313946723938,
1.0971400737762451,
0.12366339564323425,
0.39687174558639526,
0.378110408782959,
0.2725914418697357,
-0.8120333552360535,
0.6601883172988892,
-0.43748101592063904,
-0.38325271010398865,
-0.35410022735595703,
-0.48587438464164734,
-0.7482621073722839,
0.3977905809879303,
0.09682620316743851,
-0.44491466879844666,
0.20374585688114166,
0.4008288085460663,
-0.23023313283920288,
0.39387673139572144,
-0.4986147880554199,
0.7296113967895508,
-0.25364813208580017,
-0.09561436623334885,
-0.10367891192436218,
-0.6774970293045044,
0.2714778482913971,
-0.37406229972839355,
0.35478895902633667,
-0.1529494673013687,
-0.525999128818512,
0.7780988812446594,
-0.4990532696247101,
0.9760924577713013,
-0.2702678442001343,
0.09895693510770798,
0.1478491872549057,
0.19905796647071838,
0.6052953600883484,
-0.01363199669867754,
0.1379680037498474,
0.2545790374279022,
0.033502642065286636,
-0.5201219916343689,
-0.26955777406692505,
0.85622239112854,
-0.706108033657074,
-0.35365423560142517,
-0.35245978832244873,
-0.5334835648536682,
-0.3400920629501343,
0.37669020891189575,
0.06846196949481964,
0.30537647008895874,
-0.12432022392749786,
0.24143217504024506,
0.8582587242126465,
0.019593704491853714,
0.5361695289611816,
0.8278028964996338,
-0.2148703932762146,
-0.09675301611423492,
0.9425188899040222,
0.16924631595611572,
0.5732372999191284,
0.46106863021850586,
0.34263840317726135,
-0.10342557728290558,
-0.8302885890007019,
-0.4756637215614319,
0.5480598211288452,
-0.5926984548568726,
-0.10151495039463043,
-0.4328918159008026,
-0.07517921924591064,
-0.23533807694911957,
-0.06241805851459503,
-0.7805594801902771,
-0.5463942289352417,
-0.37627360224723816,
0.010686243884265423,
-0.04964763671159744,
0.4391613304615021,
-0.36704152822494507,
0.5268216729164124,
-0.37637829780578613,
0.13147324323654175,
0.2537118196487427,
0.11367958039045334,
0.14088129997253418,
-0.66806960105896,
-0.7289515137672424,
0.1348588466644287,
-0.28235095739364624,
-0.49419835209846497,
0.3896942138671875,
0.321818470954895,
0.5698370337486267,
0.2947571575641632,
-0.07816831022500992,
0.5527819991111755,
-0.7812039852142334,
0.809272825717926,
0.16509296000003815,
-0.8303312659263611,
0.5179881453514099,
-0.2044242024421692,
0.01487366110086441,
0.5110371708869934,
0.4543541371822357,
-0.3976009786128998,
-0.32892313599586487,
-0.531852126121521,
-0.4241621196269989,
0.7746902704238892,
-0.14702536165714264,
-0.026164086535573006,
0.17898668348789215,
0.49495208263397217,
0.221999853849411,
0.22848229110240936,
-0.6426827907562256,
-0.39577341079711914,
-0.0885704755783081,
-0.1423524171113968,
-0.108970507979393,
-0.3215159773826599,
-0.14935316145420074,
-0.2121194452047348,
0.4925817847251892,
-0.4609423279762268,
0.1362331658601761,
-0.46577897667884827,
-0.34988075494766235,
-0.23232519626617432,
0.0185700673609972,
0.6837785243988037,
0.6191070675849915,
-0.11558534950017929,
0.3505946397781372,
0.4028054475784302,
-0.32365816831588745,
0.34417733550071716,
-0.2775511145591736,
-0.156889870762825,
-0.18179818987846375,
0.27769210934638977,
0.555209755897522,
0.3982243835926056,
-0.6898040771484375,
0.4861176311969757,
-0.21168111264705658,
0.126593679189682,
-0.3090313673019409,
0.07967842370271683,
0.23066554963588715,
0.10633998364210129,
0.09889768064022064,
-0.12818443775177002,
-0.21330763399600983,
-0.5492866039276123,
0.04800857976078987,
0.4238988757133484,
-0.3914961814880371,
-0.3632659614086151,
0.6379579901695251,
-0.13966162502765656,
-0.29980793595314026,
0.5014892816543579,
-0.3078494071960449,
-0.2246633917093277,
0.5054333209991455,
0.581907331943512,
0.41680529713630676,
-0.16120946407318115,
0.018428213894367218,
-0.0035602396819740534,
0.707413375377655,
-0.2610905170440674,
0.017570070922374725,
0.07525243610143661,
-0.5814521908760071,
0.10583049058914185,
-0.5193477869033813,
-0.7527360916137695,
0.17184582352638245,
-0.8437545895576477,
0.3159886300563812,
-0.7991074323654175,
0.006486064754426479,
-0.1502753645181656,
0.27641841769218445,
-0.7604958415031433,
0.06848256289958954,
0.036059483885765076,
1.2276984453201294,
-0.8045363426208496,
1.3729214668273926,
0.5139760375022888,
-0.25525766611099243,
-0.5115970969200134,
0.009924914687871933,
0.2567965090274811,
-1.0219866037368774,
0.5832491517066956,
-0.21262559294700623,
-0.07185530662536621,
0.035511936992406845,
-0.546996533870697,
-0.8493276238441467,
1.0577936172485352,
0.5622847080230713,
-0.5686532258987427,
-0.08381927013397217,
0.3281705677509308,
0.7511265873908997,
-0.625189483165741,
-0.10788553208112717,
0.7520462870597839,
0.07388995587825775,
-0.04745066538453102,
-0.713193953037262,
0.023692963644862175,
0.21416740119457245,
0.5224510431289673,
0.2622419595718384,
-0.9858793616294861,
0.9174105525016785,
-0.3259158134460449,
0.012013498693704605,
0.28185099363327026,
0.7174733281135559,
0.3429449200630188,
0.05005770921707153,
0.5299793481826782,
0.4075387716293335,
0.6384974718093872,
0.03299136087298393,
0.9884189963340759,
-0.34114086627960205,
0.5516476035118103,
1.1626720428466797,
-0.33069518208503723,
0.9728829264640808,
0.6876522898674011,
-0.2872430086135864,
0.2694382667541504,
0.9341163039207458,
-0.0017308235401287675,
0.8006449341773987,
0.36388498544692993,
0.013967642560601234,
-0.1767694056034088,
-0.002452208660542965,
-0.1746724396944046,
0.12408575415611267,
0.47256550192832947,
-0.14887070655822754,
-0.040033359080553055,
0.2130790501832962,
0.020042072981595993,
-0.17998836934566498,
-0.4701976478099823,
0.5965514183044434,
0.43206748366355896,
-0.020404117181897163,
0.4283713400363922,
0.315889835357666,
0.5123788714408875,
-0.7543517351150513,
0.4081794023513794,
-0.3689368665218353,
0.2805255949497223,
0.1570209562778473,
-0.24516834318637848,
0.180283784866333,
0.031059373170137405,
-0.40617337822914124,
-0.4145880341529846,
0.6796731948852539,
-0.5191922783851624,
-0.43373948335647583,
0.4006912112236023,
0.5176202654838562,
0.028873570263385773,
0.35652413964271545,
-0.6826414465904236,
0.2964073419570923,
-0.27874597907066345,
0.05440036952495575,
0.89280104637146,
0.2341660112142563,
0.23813730478286743,
0.791140079498291,
0.5346461534500122,
0.5261308550834656,
0.3228347897529602,
-0.017092542722821236,
0.8247178196907043,
-0.4605889916419983,
-0.505109429359436,
-0.8127135634422302,
-0.08453793078660965,
0.27297523617744446,
0.15783558785915375,
0.8591140508651733,
0.7501071691513062,
0.872275710105896,
-0.16194260120391846,
0.45343017578125,
0.2254016399383545,
0.5462411046028137,
-0.43751686811447144,
0.6295608878135681,
-0.6169152855873108,
0.45137277245521545,
0.1780887246131897,
-0.6655089259147644,
0.07933023571968079,
0.25960448384284973,
-0.10720780491828918,
0.21074269711971283,
0.6659844517707825,
0.6413346529006958,
-0.07958944141864777,
0.01261003315448761,
0.3825506865978241,
0.21458326280117035,
0.47756263613700867,
0.6083034873008728,
0.6802228689193726,
-0.2604673504829407,
0.5070187449455261,
-0.49343910813331604,
-0.4244178831577301,
-0.316144198179245,
-0.9140603542327881,
-1.0552411079406738,
-0.36492398381233215,
-0.34893375635147095,
0.04253444820642471,
-0.18692563474178314,
1.0033223628997803,
0.8569014668464661,
-0.66778564453125,
-0.643114447593689,
0.2501784563064575,
0.1179022267460823,
-0.20136530697345734,
-0.21165452897548676,
0.17572873830795288,
-0.3703421354293823,
-0.5562831163406372,
0.5650365948677063,
0.3370421528816223,
0.25728777050971985,
-0.5319682359695435,
-0.3203326463699341,
0.18987935781478882,
0.2900526821613312,
0.4671195149421692,
0.4844597578048706,
-0.5405107140541077,
-0.20797574520111084,
-0.15480820834636688,
-0.36607691645622253,
-0.11678200960159302,
1.1908702850341797,
-0.33179110288619995,
0.17314015328884125,
0.18501034379005432,
0.7464064955711365,
0.6876339316368103,
-0.5732921361923218,
0.24834321439266205,
-0.9250047206878662,
0.2669034004211426,
0.17277884483337402,
0.42366018891334534,
0.2544255256652832,
-0.07242945581674576,
0.4446040689945221,
0.38505321741104126,
-0.43374475836753845,
-1.2221426963806152,
0.21335369348526,
-0.8575117588043213,
0.005232470575720072,
0.9110725522041321,
0.036281466484069824,
0.1369452327489853,
0.07528196275234222,
0.3002629578113556,
-0.11923481523990631,
-0.014763464219868183,
0.399048775434494,
0.5782676935195923,
-0.4832906424999237,
-0.5359567999839783,
-0.6554331183433533,
0.7051014304161072,
0.18577812612056732,
-0.6907738447189331,
0.21187494695186615,
0.030421268194913864,
0.40061116218566895,
-0.13426782190799713,
0.7665015459060669,
0.05834106728434563,
0.041151050478219986,
0.18311259150505066,
-0.4124188721179962,
-0.15423844754695892,
-0.45220518112182617,
-0.5048593878746033,
0.09894795715808868,
0.32406702637672424,
-0.0860680341720581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06392v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06392v1
|
Event Extraction in Basque: Typologically motivated Cross-Lingual Transfer-Learning Analysis
| 2024-04-09T15:35:41 | 2024-04-09T15:35:41 |
Mikel Zubillaga, Oscar Sainz, Ainara Estarrona, Oier Lopez de Lacalle, Eneko Agirre
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Cross-lingual transfer-learning is widely used in Event Extraction for
low-resource languages and involves a Multilingual Language Model that is
trained in a source language and applied to the target language. This paper
studies whether the typological similarity between source and target languages
impacts the performance of cross-lingual transfer, an under-explored topic. We
first focus on Basque as the target language, which is an ideal target language
because it is typologically different from surrounding languages. Our
experiments on three Event Extraction tasks show that the shared linguistic
characteristic between source and target languages does have an impact on
transfer quality. Further analysis of 72 language pairs reveals that for tasks
that involve token classification such as entity and event trigger
identification, common writing script and morphological features produce higher
quality cross-lingual transfer. In contrast, for tasks involving structural
prediction like argument extraction, common word order is the most relevant
feature. In addition, we show that when increasing the training size, not all
the languages scale in the same way in the cross-lingual setting. To perform
the experiments we introduce EusIE, an event extraction dataset for Basque,
which follows the Multilingual Event Extraction dataset (MEE). The dataset and
code are publicly available.
|
[
-0.28470563888549805,
-0.33997711539268494,
0.36032938957214355,
0.3991858661174774,
-0.27469971776008606,
0.08516068756580353,
-0.42870715260505676,
-0.9589372873306274,
0.4187234044075012,
0.3291073143482208,
-0.3985845744609833,
-0.28069090843200684,
-0.5605039596557617,
0.13241364061832428,
-0.4800495505332947,
0.7589223980903625,
-0.2685402035713196,
-0.11448784172534943,
0.251911997795105,
-0.18861912190914154,
-0.24704761803150177,
-0.9176622033119202,
-0.8790159821510315,
-0.39102375507354736,
0.4607846736907959,
0.23707976937294006,
0.20859026908874512,
0.5329751968383789,
0.022656014189124107,
0.21258476376533508,
0.12655046582221985,
-0.13816317915916443,
-0.6050659418106079,
-0.10160074383020401,
-0.6720529198646545,
-0.6144551634788513,
0.047378603368997574,
-0.05610058084130287,
0.7049153447151184,
0.537484347820282,
0.06077759340405464,
0.23605011403560638,
0.13886111974716187,
0.4642292857170105,
-0.5025289058685303,
0.3633788526058197,
-0.5684567093849182,
0.22379964590072632,
-0.5563050508499146,
-0.5175859332084656,
-0.4002319872379303,
-0.06307356804609299,
0.20516261458396912,
-0.5552124381065369,
0.28884056210517883,
-0.0005168128991499543,
0.9450246691703796,
0.009797237813472748,
-0.3297790586948395,
-0.38572266697883606,
-0.6060130000114441,
0.879221498966217,
-0.08874961733818054,
0.5606729984283447,
0.16248546540737152,
0.055839452892541885,
0.061101898550987244,
-0.5802975296974182,
-0.3419756591320038,
0.14357531070709229,
-0.00468815304338932,
-0.004981086589396,
-0.3898463845252991,
-0.23417700827121735,
0.006388189271092415,
-0.09107498079538345,
-0.5894773006439209,
0.404217392206192,
-0.5494357943534851,
-0.20155194401741028,
0.6207624673843384,
0.06760682910680771,
0.6939883828163147,
-0.448251336812973,
-0.35284462571144104,
-0.1117921844124794,
-0.7834224104881287,
0.2628861963748932,
0.48929527401924133,
0.4259018301963806,
-0.2625422477722168,
0.3310450613498688,
-0.2712900638580322,
0.4448748230934143,
0.11550183594226837,
0.05195115506649017,
0.2447352111339569,
-0.5831851363182068,
0.1090146005153656,
0.3633486032485962,
0.9425382018089294,
0.077324777841568,
0.7888951301574707,
-0.6708793044090271,
0.30787771940231323,
-0.05118117853999138,
-0.02159077487885952,
-0.5290440917015076,
-0.15547293424606323,
0.030440598726272583,
-0.4915110766887665,
-0.4389534890651703,
0.10167806595563889,
-1.0797696113586426,
0.16514725983142853,
-0.07686726748943329,
0.12793149054050446,
-0.32208749651908875,
-0.42941978573799133,
0.2415027618408203,
-0.2521589398384094,
0.45263126492500305,
0.19552764296531677,
-1.0236554145812988,
0.2183316946029663,
0.7582699656486511,
0.6185890436172485,
-0.8241676092147827,
-0.6942572593688965,
-0.8265218138694763,
0.23205240070819855,
-0.32447192072868347,
0.7901094555854797,
-0.5831567645072937,
-0.154363214969635,
0.002278767293319106,
0.24073268473148346,
-0.45228299498558044,
-0.4236287772655487,
0.45708173513412476,
-0.47705453634262085,
0.44615426659584045,
-0.13508671522140503,
-0.24220463633537292,
-0.25942903757095337,
-0.10013693571090698,
-0.7435340881347656,
1.2388139963150024,
-0.07898277044296265,
-0.37720829248428345,
0.4710702896118164,
-0.2801528871059418,
-0.6087668538093567,
0.12480146437883377,
-0.372580349445343,
0.09472562372684479,
0.11429698020219803,
-0.023678118363022804,
0.47327080368995667,
-0.23419979214668274,
0.24223123490810394,
-0.055660124868154526,
0.08297525346279144,
0.28083544969558716,
-0.45320916175842285,
0.8952645659446716,
0.054808277636766434,
-0.5999751091003418,
-0.2827518582344055,
-1.0314537286758423,
0.0011413630563765764,
-0.02640063688158989,
-0.47507765889167786,
-0.5783793330192566,
-0.17268048226833344,
0.33127662539482117,
0.6248753070831299,
0.3342338800430298,
-0.7315926551818848,
0.013960263691842556,
-0.27897217869758606,
0.004532373510301113,
0.39077526330947876,
0.23498566448688507,
0.5464892387390137,
-0.11491135507822037,
0.6908658742904663,
-0.3979862332344055,
-0.006259346846491098,
0.31157493591308594,
-0.46156758069992065,
-0.16782218217849731,
-0.34506750106811523,
0.6371532082557678,
0.6907184720039368,
-0.928297758102417,
-0.04275693744421005,
-0.34723731875419617,
-0.1972970813512802,
-0.273307204246521,
0.1351393759250641,
0.5947925448417664,
0.1588878184556961,
-0.00017004353867378086,
-0.37529000639915466,
-0.7428520321846008,
-0.5342239141464233,
-0.5621485710144043,
-0.4830583333969116,
0.13045234978199005,
-0.10084937512874603,
0.03856661170721054,
0.33631160855293274,
0.6047307848930359,
-0.022851720452308655,
-0.19480790197849274,
-0.6282151937484741,
0.48819154500961304,
0.022977696731686592,
0.2822163999080658,
1.029689908027649,
-0.8881148099899292,
-0.7477523684501648,
0.6591432094573975,
-0.6094720363616943,
-0.6143032908439636,
-0.0872487872838974,
-0.1352110356092453,
0.5888609290122986,
0.5513938665390015,
-0.3198670446872711,
0.26242950558662415,
0.8933285474777222,
-0.6576226353645325,
0.5892106294631958,
0.09136005491018295,
0.40145471692085266,
-1.2250944375991821,
0.012414446100592613,
-0.17599652707576752,
-0.24160699546337128,
-0.7372443079948425,
-0.09918883442878723,
-0.07833706587553024,
0.06265588849782944,
-0.9062912464141846,
0.9452195763587952,
-0.4526351988315582,
-0.33320537209510803,
-0.19301177561283112,
0.015563440509140491,
0.07771679759025574,
0.6645655035972595,
0.48691555857658386,
0.5203015804290771,
0.44945260882377625,
-0.4975236654281616,
0.31001970171928406,
0.19238315522670746,
-0.38833537697792053,
0.6171878576278687,
-0.26404261589050293,
-0.16506484150886536,
0.24318952858448029,
-0.48829102516174316,
-0.6774749159812927,
0.03307250142097473,
0.32340893149375916,
-0.445380836725235,
0.348198264837265,
-0.5853905081748962,
-0.3526606857776642,
0.372342050075531,
-0.04980224743485451,
0.5076056122779846,
0.29183533787727356,
-0.5986284613609314,
0.5457823872566223,
0.46892601251602173,
-0.569435715675354,
-0.5194013714790344,
-0.7210954427719116,
-0.00918689277023077,
-0.4749974310398102,
-0.35251131653785706,
0.3114531934261322,
0.30712923407554626,
-0.25066491961479187,
0.30033236742019653,
-0.0662803202867508,
-0.25619226694107056,
-0.06870968639850616,
0.08156654983758926,
0.21225020289421082,
-0.16204550862312317,
0.00853011105209589,
-0.14877630770206451,
-0.05662534013390541,
0.1450241059064865,
-0.22807328402996063,
0.6305220723152161,
0.14624136686325073,
-0.34964361786842346,
-0.4264892041683197,
0.5172122120857239,
0.6215120553970337,
-0.2552546262741089,
0.701545000076294,
0.6423133611679077,
-0.24010732769966125,
-0.14206303656101227,
-0.39791804552078247,
0.2235146015882492,
-0.32683682441711426,
0.4393443763256073,
-0.9111494421958923,
-0.5572710633277893,
0.7514296174049377,
-0.036872901022434235,
-0.07772964239120483,
0.692086398601532,
0.6380546689033508,
0.001868999912403524,
0.6315632462501526,
0.6647661328315735,
-0.1880163848400116,
1.0293277502059937,
-0.06537886708974838,
-0.27122363448143005,
-0.5324510335922241,
-0.3343598246574402,
-0.8560124039649963,
-0.13644835352897644,
-0.5324223637580872,
-0.44036465883255005,
0.005147011484950781,
-0.03396731987595558,
0.46949660778045654,
0.5948832035064697,
0.30612966418266296,
0.26679757237434387,
0.3019729554653168,
-0.4485124945640564,
0.5081307888031006,
0.2809549570083618,
-0.05307864770293236,
-0.23250457644462585,
-1.132920503616333,
-0.2500411570072174,
0.9966193437576294,
0.07115251570940018,
0.7497515678405762,
0.0369381308555603,
0.8753144145011902,
0.18814274668693542,
-0.04349379613995552,
-0.5483280420303345,
0.15885959565639496,
-0.2427307516336441,
-0.36541181802749634,
-0.527760922908783,
-0.5646269917488098,
-1.2676984071731567,
0.39779147505760193,
-0.2575143277645111,
-1.0926566123962402,
0.8487712144851685,
-0.5101954936981201,
0.1347954273223877,
0.35670310258865356,
-0.482221782207489,
1.0174143314361572,
-0.4038963317871094,
-0.25702789425849915,
-0.3584250509738922,
-0.21889521181583405,
-0.1611141860485077,
-0.3288646340370178,
0.47674572467803955,
-0.09399833530187607,
0.07750195264816284,
1.0794620513916016,
0.21884317696094513,
0.7663582563400269,
0.354384183883667,
-0.20173972845077515,
0.29356303811073303,
0.3685426414012909,
0.5246878862380981,
-0.1623656302690506,
-0.11853368580341339,
0.329843133687973,
0.3836734890937805,
-0.3326709568500519,
-0.5582572221755981,
0.5371928811073303,
-0.7585253119468689,
-0.16883116960525513,
-0.09261981397867203,
-0.3543006479740143,
-0.031849443912506104,
-0.05196927860379219,
0.5620957016944885,
0.8304808735847473,
-0.5551238656044006,
-0.05193708837032318,
0.3684085011482239,
-0.04646154120564461,
0.5349668860435486,
0.7183786034584045,
-0.2494307905435562,
-0.1649775207042694,
1.1970274448394775,
0.2669849395751953,
0.4277747869491577,
0.48955169320106506,
-0.09750758111476898,
-0.281887948513031,
-0.4412200152873993,
-0.6868067383766174,
0.3024533987045288,
-0.6157854795455933,
0.20642933249473572,
-0.6528103351593018,
0.022212663665413857,
-0.13180652260780334,
-0.1381792575120926,
-0.7232251167297363,
-0.8801841735839844,
-0.3526594340801239,
-0.08610338717699051,
0.14626166224479675,
0.5761867761611938,
-0.3532036542892456,
-0.029870256781578064,
-1.0028773546218872,
0.4237872362136841,
-0.001808631932362914,
0.15738292038440704,
-0.34182095527648926,
-0.5726407766342163,
-0.2278045117855072,
-0.49279600381851196,
0.07368844002485275,
-1.1174412965774536,
0.49790501594543457,
0.347181499004364,
0.9443781971931458,
0.16454727947711945,
-0.0037846730556339025,
0.3533439636230469,
-0.28547051548957825,
0.45962268114089966,
0.23398444056510925,
-0.8347214460372925,
0.4139747619628906,
-0.14575865864753723,
-0.04885033890604973,
0.4189526438713074,
0.5281084179878235,
-0.710034191608429,
-0.5330085158348083,
-0.994184672832489,
-0.5672062039375305,
0.7695796489715576,
0.11829602718353271,
-0.2906315326690674,
0.07596481591463089,
0.22398792207241058,
0.4293343126773834,
-0.0601479597389698,
-0.8940324187278748,
0.0006361391860991716,
0.3521631062030792,
-0.13617154955863953,
-0.11956964433193207,
-0.13817809522151947,
0.0966063067317009,
0.06933408975601196,
0.47649967670440674,
-0.09731369465589523,
-0.06729501485824585,
0.11728218197822571,
-0.30786576867103577,
-0.35068634152412415,
0.4003728926181793,
0.0780949667096138,
0.6337648034095764,
0.02730768918991089,
-0.014931249432265759,
0.32359257340431213,
-0.36937594413757324,
0.06278208643198013,
0.1577478051185608,
0.021579494699835777,
0.3536904752254486,
0.7229787707328796,
0.6087047457695007,
0.6334629058837891,
-0.6461755633354187,
0.2689003646373749,
-0.119893379509449,
-0.23040635883808136,
0.054797254502773285,
-0.21552877128124237,
-0.26029691100120544,
0.6028532981872559,
0.27583932876586914,
-0.4105585813522339,
0.2604219913482666,
-0.9461594820022583,
0.10828186571598053,
0.28306347131729126,
-0.2945556938648224,
-0.6516180634498596,
0.3147145211696625,
0.24489417672157288,
-0.1957942247390747,
0.22031238675117493,
-0.06864436715841293,
-0.7763438820838928,
0.799531877040863,
0.44997045397758484,
0.7385492324829102,
-0.15735580027103424,
0.46557462215423584,
0.30963101983070374,
0.4255012273788452,
0.0711732804775238,
0.48930901288986206,
-0.09823104739189148,
-0.7191166877746582,
-0.8608367443084717,
-0.8212453722953796,
-0.44267818331718445,
-0.02520384080708027,
-0.8458839058876038,
0.4048859179019928,
0.24564440548419952,
0.2196524292230606,
-0.10330699384212494,
0.12919718027114868,
-0.7594422101974487,
-0.30298590660095215,
0.3535483181476593,
0.7681032419204712,
-1.2314966917037964,
0.9310305118560791,
0.6675352454185486,
-0.09127684682607651,
-0.857380211353302,
-0.21246594190597534,
-0.11362134665250778,
-0.49277952313423157,
0.814224898815155,
-0.3363751173019409,
0.06037316471338272,
-0.13856877386569977,
0.19328925013542175,
-1.0606849193572998,
0.6593653559684753,
0.5212623476982117,
-0.3533168137073517,
-0.16096170246601105,
0.34177157282829285,
0.7022649645805359,
-0.5805333256721497,
-0.3453526198863983,
0.5734220743179321,
0.28867611289024353,
-0.06788834929466248,
-1.4271917343139648,
0.019233498722314835,
-0.018631435930728912,
-0.3617923855781555,
0.501298725605011,
-0.45248833298683167,
0.6299065351486206,
0.10094732791185379,
-0.6032842993736267,
-0.15479475259780884,
0.48566094040870667,
-0.07039498537778854,
0.22723637521266937,
0.03535942733287811,
0.34487801790237427,
0.5671984553337097,
0.04233580082654953,
1.1475491523742676,
-0.24407005310058594,
0.27219274640083313,
0.8929883241653442,
-0.11696559190750122,
0.8820827007293701,
0.6713309288024902,
-0.06370081752538681,
0.5645614862442017,
0.4754870533943176,
0.3679770827293396,
0.6818426251411438,
-0.311716765165329,
0.08524210005998611,
-0.09458670765161514,
-0.0770031213760376,
-0.3260526657104492,
0.7293798327445984,
0.47633445262908936,
-0.31568643450737,
-0.509026288986206,
0.20744219422340393,
-0.2529769837856293,
-0.12442469596862793,
-0.4249017834663391,
0.8400465846061707,
-0.025997333228588104,
-0.6282990574836731,
0.5439910292625427,
-0.16116154193878174,
0.38211703300476074,
-0.40667665004730225,
0.02199840173125267,
0.0027304065879434347,
-0.1672385334968567,
-0.08583467453718185,
-0.8341557383537292,
0.5342239737510681,
0.061347704380750656,
-0.14902353286743164,
-0.3575877547264099,
0.7141919136047363,
-0.6934992074966431,
-0.2436113953590393,
0.7942560315132141,
0.9861866235733032,
0.5557931661605835,
0.0737919732928276,
-0.4615843892097473,
0.2074735462665558,
0.09613955020904541,
-0.2704310119152069,
0.6848527193069458,
1.0408143997192383,
-0.36964577436447144,
0.3437076508998871,
0.5577231645584106,
0.7417137026786804,
0.5909278392791748,
0.16651621460914612,
0.47283411026000977,
-0.49923503398895264,
-0.5964829921722412,
-0.7362635731697083,
0.08728737384080887,
0.09888279438018799,
-0.37106749415397644,
0.5413200855255127,
0.42285704612731934,
1.1430389881134033,
-0.10157662630081177,
0.7046932578086853,
-0.20474191009998322,
0.1838776171207428,
-0.742152988910675,
0.28184589743614197,
-0.35207897424697876,
-0.08254344016313553,
-0.12639297544956207,
-0.8503910303115845,
0.18467697501182556,
0.24520596861839294,
-0.34947681427001953,
-0.5802345871925354,
0.7933537364006042,
0.34890711307525635,
-0.06779599189758301,
-0.11536131054162979,
0.5832694172859192,
-0.13647764921188354,
0.09843984991312027,
0.781450629234314,
0.9488030076026917,
-0.27541565895080566,
0.877620279788971,
-0.24823255836963654,
-0.3369405269622803,
-0.15952922403812408,
-0.7853997945785522,
-0.8672887682914734,
-0.8488255739212036,
-0.41245338320732117,
-0.09388319402933121,
0.2798027992248535,
0.7235338687896729,
0.4471342861652374,
-0.8449937701225281,
-0.4354422092437744,
0.25809261202812195,
0.1651308387517929,
-0.3085792660713196,
-0.30468955636024475,
0.3773052990436554,
-0.49622079730033875,
-0.9900401830673218,
0.38214734196662903,
0.1973337084054947,
-0.10401737689971924,
0.15640808641910553,
-0.006944065913558006,
-0.23321811854839325,
-0.14911676943302155,
0.46731066703796387,
0.9009672999382019,
-0.552301287651062,
-0.4744560718536377,
-0.2806195020675659,
-0.19938494265079498,
-0.07267232984304428,
0.7234786152839661,
-0.6480371952056885,
0.15433050692081451,
0.6764641404151917,
0.7538647055625916,
0.793535053730011,
-0.25892874598503113,
0.8425759077072144,
-0.8281252384185791,
0.44617393612861633,
-0.2559511661529541,
0.524506688117981,
0.020109886303544044,
-0.49706897139549255,
0.7089147567749023,
0.35365837812423706,
-0.1472465842962265,
-0.5858891010284424,
0.2846825420856476,
-1.0085581541061401,
-0.2227371633052826,
1.3906797170639038,
-0.07485165446996689,
-0.43946346640586853,
-0.3931226134300232,
-0.16254901885986328,
0.46687185764312744,
0.008347473107278347,
0.7230920195579529,
1.1073921918869019,
-0.40111538767814636,
-0.19183240830898285,
-0.559904158115387,
0.5787844061851501,
0.3094846308231354,
-0.7510212063789368,
0.07782190293073654,
0.1487029641866684,
0.5509430766105652,
0.3859960436820984,
0.5260518193244934,
-0.4259515404701233,
0.6821983456611633,
-0.07141246646642685,
0.30593007802963257,
0.2269263118505478,
-0.6014246940612793,
-0.48780733346939087,
0.4738991856575012,
-0.03409469500184059,
-0.23725412786006927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06390v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06390v2
|
Latent Distance Guided Alignment Training for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-09T15:33:09 | 2024-04-13T05:20:45 |
Haotian Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Ensuring alignment with human preferences is a crucial characteristic of
large language models (LLMs). Presently, the primary alignment methods, RLHF
and DPO, require extensive human annotation, which is expensive despite their
efficacy. The significant expenses associated with current alignment techniques
motivate researchers to investigate the development of annotation-free
alignment training methods. In pursuit of improved alignment without relying on
external annotation, we introduce Latent Distance Guided Alignment Training
(LD-Align). This approach seeks to align the model with a high-quality
supervised fine-tune dataset using guidance from a latent space. The latent
space is generated through sample reconstruction, akin to auto-encoding.
Consequently, we utilize the distance between sample pairs in the latent space
to guide DPO-based alignment training. Extensive experimentation and evaluation
show the efficacy of our proposed method in achieving notable alignment.
|
[
-0.1093660444021225,
-0.5289319753646851,
0.5034234523773193,
-0.35739850997924805,
-0.357847660779953,
0.12171407788991928,
-0.21749305725097656,
-0.37503114342689514,
0.20665766298770905,
0.4781464636325836,
-0.6912882924079895,
-0.41190433502197266,
-0.4569106101989746,
-0.19919422268867493,
-0.10529369860887527,
0.8320357203483582,
-0.0689316838979721,
0.1193833202123642,
-0.110613152384758,
-0.07952017337083817,
-0.2479759305715561,
-0.4578455090522766,
-0.3473513424396515,
-0.12800562381744385,
0.6809260845184326,
0.31075817346572876,
0.820296049118042,
1.059786081314087,
0.6389824151992798,
0.14816372096538544,
-0.07517226040363312,
0.5050859451293945,
-0.4152037501335144,
0.038249045610427856,
-0.062080059200525284,
-0.3311575949192047,
-0.7777281999588013,
0.12215204536914825,
0.8796493411064148,
1.1458001136779785,
-0.21229450404644012,
-0.10899987071752548,
-0.02140735648572445,
0.83355712890625,
-0.5130840539932251,
-0.40206673741340637,
-0.6299571394920349,
0.1564922332763672,
-0.40183982253074646,
-0.002073714742437005,
-0.25475332140922546,
-0.5664911866188049,
0.06877726316452026,
-0.8237476348876953,
0.13576580584049225,
0.26829463243484497,
0.9784862995147705,
0.6089494228363037,
-0.47257667779922485,
-0.08443120867013931,
-0.766678512096405,
0.8003488183021545,
-0.672417938709259,
0.6842380166053772,
0.4622875452041626,
0.1892421543598175,
-0.4227774739265442,
0.07611202448606491,
-0.6378681063652039,
0.08928465098142624,
-0.06158367544412613,
-0.10410788655281067,
0.33151936531066895,
0.020861869677901268,
0.26893481612205505,
0.5807628035545349,
-0.7335306406021118,
0.6270381212234497,
-0.21101853251457214,
-0.2519611716270447,
0.7095221877098083,
0.06404225528240204,
0.2396228313446045,
0.10680999606847763,
-0.39731091260910034,
-0.05875851958990097,
-0.9473312497138977,
-0.22206541895866394,
0.7055171728134155,
0.5318942070007324,
-0.11270101368427277,
0.6588776111602783,
-0.10576873272657394,
1.1169501543045044,
0.379670649766922,
-0.24038530886173248,
0.19437961280345917,
-0.23141294717788696,
-0.11138460040092468,
0.3311886787414551,
0.7555204629898071,
0.4008660912513733,
0.1399783492088318,
-0.10567166656255722,
-0.28420406579971313,
-0.29887154698371887,
0.026521900668740273,
-0.536707878112793,
-0.30569207668304443,
0.04933195561170578,
-0.30149155855178833,
-0.25953975319862366,
-0.14799216389656067,
-0.7461453676223755,
-0.3927864134311676,
-0.6277037858963013,
0.09552783519029617,
-0.3191365599632263,
-0.2833893597126007,
-0.09710793942213058,
0.3574821949005127,
0.42116665840148926,
0.5087414979934692,
-1.434625506401062,
0.07467205822467804,
0.777550220489502,
0.7814078330993652,
-0.36431437730789185,
-0.2739136517047882,
-0.811515748500824,
0.41289767622947693,
-0.5538257956504822,
0.8286822438240051,
-0.42273157835006714,
-0.13901671767234802,
-0.08161219209432602,
-0.14611117541790009,
0.10512583702802658,
-0.4658365249633789,
0.3843996822834015,
-0.5292601585388184,
0.4230729341506958,
-0.3322983980178833,
-0.9649532437324524,
0.17462517321109772,
0.17221605777740479,
-0.5587621331214905,
1.162056565284729,
0.31446853280067444,
-0.8320288062095642,
0.49081504344940186,
-0.30539822578430176,
-0.13346810638904572,
-0.04089827090501785,
-0.2821700870990753,
-0.41690680384635925,
0.12159574776887894,
0.49629777669906616,
0.3304145932197571,
-0.08606870472431183,
0.2943364679813385,
-0.46615830063819885,
-0.32292288541793823,
0.15109200775623322,
-0.3530198335647583,
0.6676778197288513,
0.0032978211529552937,
-0.23786263167858124,
0.18623709678649902,
-0.8895353078842163,
-0.25689393281936646,
-0.02404354326426983,
-0.3646380305290222,
-0.5633472800254822,
-0.13207517564296722,
-0.2027582973241806,
0.22133733332157135,
0.4327102303504944,
-0.48244041204452515,
0.5831689834594727,
-0.7982097268104553,
-0.027758251875638962,
1.1287909746170044,
-0.29165971279144287,
0.7566127181053162,
-0.14934727549552917,
0.4694969654083252,
-0.11333613097667694,
0.030764728784561157,
0.2178405076265335,
-0.11264441162347794,
-0.5048033595085144,
-0.2667114734649658,
0.4827316999435425,
0.3288297951221466,
-0.3533194959163666,
1.030026912689209,
-0.3435114026069641,
-0.42841216921806335,
-0.6230390071868896,
0.2671697437763214,
0.24164573848247528,
0.8466659188270569,
0.27265894412994385,
-0.291323721408844,
-0.4531072974205017,
-0.8841663002967834,
0.1432444155216217,
0.06456774473190308,
0.13067704439163208,
0.2704213559627533,
0.19779027998447418,
-0.11660362780094147,
1.062134027481079,
-0.7828496694564819,
-0.3086375296115875,
0.22238251566886902,
-0.08927104622125626,
-0.011124600656330585,
0.6766891479492188,
0.6239164471626282,
-0.6753993630409241,
-0.5670289397239685,
0.02132156491279602,
-0.5528931021690369,
-0.21755920350551605,
0.16727305948734283,
-0.40696603059768677,
0.29899242520332336,
0.6182610988616943,
-0.2054281383752823,
0.08222170919179916,
0.8921701312065125,
-0.27008891105651855,
0.43776023387908936,
-0.27287155389785767,
0.08875154703855515,
-1.2364921569824219,
0.17987579107284546,
-0.22265522181987762,
-0.26335784792900085,
-0.48687347769737244,
-0.5009804368019104,
-0.06556235998868942,
-0.14289988577365875,
-0.2218678891658783,
0.7804761528968811,
-0.5938893556594849,
-0.3362767994403839,
-0.4127146601676941,
0.3559728264808655,
0.06115163117647171,
0.3422193229198456,
0.2901178002357483,
0.8972069025039673,
0.37211140990257263,
-0.37965208292007446,
0.40972694754600525,
0.31397563219070435,
-0.32115790247917175,
0.7602329850196838,
-0.3180047571659088,
0.398883193731308,
-0.044023603200912476,
0.2895039916038513,
-1.0067445039749146,
-0.21551477909088135,
0.3365824520587921,
-0.1834959089756012,
0.4977039098739624,
-0.16246667504310608,
-0.38063693046569824,
-0.0024968127254396677,
-0.06495437771081924,
0.5255128145217896,
0.3774596154689789,
-0.6822490692138672,
0.3273124694824219,
0.29540568590164185,
-0.13638070225715637,
-0.8957468271255493,
-0.40521883964538574,
-0.18504135310649872,
-0.40117573738098145,
-0.3524935245513916,
0.4101732075214386,
-0.09820390492677689,
-0.0503542497754097,
-0.1255151629447937,
-0.10574346780776978,
-0.1515209823846817,
0.15585950016975403,
0.12996457517147064,
0.34970441460609436,
-0.25372812151908875,
0.33968353271484375,
0.017736904323101044,
-0.14383333921432495,
-0.3779532015323639,
-0.5597841143608093,
0.4777817726135254,
0.255378395318985,
-0.4636140465736389,
-0.5722683668136597,
0.3169819414615631,
0.3012453019618988,
-0.3123166561126709,
0.7105329036712646,
0.5890125632286072,
-0.5853003859519958,
-0.10735243558883667,
-0.6680794954299927,
-0.14936399459838867,
-0.3964218497276306,
0.27804064750671387,
-0.13889168202877045,
-0.9138910174369812,
0.19380395114421844,
-0.1424080729484558,
-0.08542262762784958,
0.36988019943237305,
0.2996269464492798,
-0.31176522374153137,
0.711353600025177,
0.8929423093795776,
-0.17887108027935028,
0.6662883162498474,
0.2566657066345215,
0.12997394800186157,
-1.0190942287445068,
-0.06353528052568436,
-0.5122057199478149,
-0.27243751287460327,
-0.2881794273853302,
-0.507273256778717,
-0.15751680731773376,
0.3911091983318329,
-0.24978269636631012,
0.34558477997779846,
-0.5758570432662964,
0.5066350102424622,
0.3543705940246582,
-0.08773194998502731,
0.16592900454998016,
0.13901545107364655,
-0.21784469485282898,
-0.5328616499900818,
-0.4284803569316864,
-0.545907199382782,
1.0133836269378662,
0.36026760935783386,
0.8022131323814392,
0.20785191655158997,
0.8574898838996887,
0.0001668742625042796,
0.10987905412912369,
-0.8330426812171936,
0.4115825891494751,
-0.3578318655490875,
-0.3270781934261322,
-0.6245154142379761,
-0.3905848562717438,
-0.7086280584335327,
-0.07269423454999924,
-0.20185446739196777,
-0.8734140396118164,
0.20412814617156982,
0.46795791387557983,
-0.5437036752700806,
0.281678706407547,
-0.43126359581947327,
0.824722945690155,
-0.6687082648277283,
-0.34365686774253845,
0.09001383185386658,
-0.7088754177093506,
0.041124384850263596,
-0.33036360144615173,
0.026529407128691673,
-0.41081684827804565,
-0.013029234483838081,
0.7937483787536621,
-0.48572877049446106,
0.9073200225830078,
-0.3498782813549042,
-0.7562103867530823,
-0.17126651108264923,
0.005236742552369833,
0.4949461817741394,
-0.3418015241622925,
-0.031120456755161285,
0.057634033262729645,
-0.3239903450012207,
-0.277332067489624,
-0.5871150493621826,
0.5936804413795471,
-0.7047235369682312,
-0.4941205680370331,
-0.28242170810699463,
-0.7097234725952148,
-0.3008081614971161,
0.2702278196811676,
0.04420452564954758,
0.18676802515983582,
-0.21773050725460052,
-0.08789406716823578,
0.920508861541748,
-0.236113503575325,
0.19247548282146454,
0.39079922437667847,
-0.0824224054813385,
-0.6216302514076233,
0.7110142707824707,
-0.014319959096610546,
0.41034406423568726,
0.8575382828712463,
0.32172736525535583,
-0.5971283912658691,
-0.534674882888794,
-0.523039698600769,
0.43299978971481323,
-0.6113020777702332,
-0.09296484291553497,
-0.333246648311615,
0.04361823573708534,
-0.6897643804550171,
-0.436594158411026,
-0.6665349006652832,
-0.47194957733154297,
-0.42443808913230896,
0.13352274894714355,
0.329519659280777,
0.5711329579353333,
-0.2335594743490219,
0.3771657645702362,
-0.7567413449287415,
0.03912094607949257,
0.21312479674816132,
0.45004433393478394,
-0.23054122924804688,
-0.7408133149147034,
-0.275554358959198,
0.01608176901936531,
0.03890004754066467,
-0.5581087470054626,
0.25567352771759033,
0.22729262709617615,
0.5036070346832275,
0.4649704694747925,
-0.022478532046079636,
0.9186473488807678,
-0.6154235601425171,
0.701434314250946,
0.3450285792350769,
-0.8541240096092224,
0.8606742024421692,
-0.4538452625274658,
0.12721267342567444,
0.5521393418312073,
0.4341530501842499,
-0.5079874396324158,
0.051718372851610184,
-0.3341379463672638,
-0.6835424900054932,
0.6091585755348206,
-0.13384072482585907,
-0.2572494447231293,
0.3192690312862396,
0.7136354446411133,
0.22084607183933258,
0.011953197419643402,
-0.6712218523025513,
-0.07329434156417847,
0.07932564616203308,
-0.5436318516731262,
-0.18118789792060852,
-0.13374680280685425,
-0.26973751187324524,
-0.09403123706579208,
0.750948429107666,
-0.3586237132549286,
0.023202698677778244,
0.11637056618928909,
-0.11697640269994736,
-0.30466389656066895,
0.025171449407935143,
0.7177611589431763,
0.5515167713165283,
-0.24004694819450378,
-0.051173966377973557,
-0.03300474211573601,
-0.3018835484981537,
0.3842645287513733,
0.40805289149284363,
-0.02470034919679165,
-0.2709665298461914,
0.29422855377197266,
0.7388756275177002,
0.0016328309429809451,
-0.4982496500015259,
0.6470115780830383,
0.04868253692984581,
-0.10975541919469833,
-0.30290651321411133,
0.004925838205963373,
0.1396505981683731,
0.1536482721567154,
0.12286096066236496,
-0.341728538274765,
-0.22352032363414764,
-0.11837441474199295,
0.20234975218772888,
0.4061509370803833,
-0.5912810564041138,
-0.22338147461414337,
0.7167848348617554,
0.2066262811422348,
-0.24323002994060516,
0.8130373358726501,
-0.07450874894857407,
-0.32076993584632874,
0.37829267978668213,
0.41789838671684265,
0.7364246249198914,
-0.37294644117355347,
-0.21006892621517181,
0.4607676863670349,
0.08268198370933533,
-0.13438178598880768,
-0.047314222902059555,
-0.17984478175640106,
-0.7974423170089722,
-0.5772162675857544,
-0.9258081316947937,
-0.42980316281318665,
-0.00850155670195818,
-0.5596222281455994,
0.3592347204685211,
-0.30649644136428833,
0.2665959894657135,
-0.0030111116357147694,
0.10585818439722061,
-0.2774590253829956,
0.4232825040817261,
0.38663750886917114,
0.5550533533096313,
-0.9214679598808289,
1.097886323928833,
0.5919345021247864,
-0.2655848562717438,
-0.9322122931480408,
0.22727183997631073,
0.015955891460180283,
-0.7792119383811951,
0.9023076295852661,
0.12944436073303223,
-0.06637769937515259,
-0.045811884105205536,
-0.41672283411026,
-1.1473392248153687,
1.1065621376037598,
0.5321257710456848,
-1.011324405670166,
-0.1589452475309372,
0.12510308623313904,
0.4863066077232361,
-0.5145737528800964,
-0.32845690846443176,
0.2755175530910492,
0.11294709146022797,
0.1126774474978447,
-0.9633393287658691,
0.023676417768001556,
0.14051783084869385,
0.047739919275045395,
0.4568324387073517,
-0.648942232131958,
0.5716967582702637,
-0.13883891701698303,
0.07914166897535324,
0.09097690880298615,
0.7426446080207825,
0.16689354181289673,
-0.16462446749210358,
0.6564168930053711,
0.715302050113678,
1.0210505723953247,
-0.14677079021930695,
0.4911248981952667,
-0.2792520523071289,
0.3692287504673004,
1.5997014045715332,
-0.542325496673584,
0.8212051391601562,
0.580100953578949,
-0.04085228964686394,
0.2978130578994751,
0.8568774461746216,
-0.15663863718509674,
0.5400562286376953,
0.28673261404037476,
-0.12692902982234955,
-0.22486719489097595,
-0.29437828063964844,
-0.30156463384628296,
0.6148519515991211,
0.269226610660553,
-0.30326586961746216,
0.0174554456025362,
-0.2399684488773346,
-0.05893189460039139,
0.3421425521373749,
-0.05247034132480621,
0.90630704164505,
-0.10402531921863556,
-0.6887937188148499,
0.5022183656692505,
-0.2874356210231781,
0.6841467618942261,
-0.5409104824066162,
-0.030192798003554344,
-0.2043263167142868,
0.19487988948822021,
-0.21020682156085968,
-0.620918333530426,
0.4335034191608429,
-0.12077800184488297,
-0.12172434478998184,
-0.27420735359191895,
0.47685933113098145,
-0.6690680384635925,
-0.19276466965675354,
0.20507799088954926,
0.33410918712615967,
0.26361769437789917,
0.2991716265678406,
-0.59608393907547,
-0.11305783689022064,
-0.004372310359030962,
-0.05533939599990845,
0.3650798201560974,
0.5080893635749817,
0.11634253710508347,
0.20054718852043152,
0.6028465032577515,
0.2939589321613312,
-0.23397961258888245,
0.23561477661132812,
0.6378461718559265,
-0.6998063921928406,
-0.3502071499824524,
-0.8321858644485474,
0.30762985348701477,
-0.08649260550737381,
-0.30777299404144287,
0.47574949264526367,
0.6629741787910461,
0.8805153369903564,
0.1389475017786026,
0.5518893599510193,
0.12571312487125397,
0.6311018466949463,
-0.7275253534317017,
0.5402239561080933,
-0.7630268335342407,
0.07470113039016724,
-0.32495352625846863,
-1.1394305229187012,
-0.48666638135910034,
0.7241941094398499,
-0.4082315266132355,
-0.058955300599336624,
0.45501503348350525,
0.8681503534317017,
-0.0954730361700058,
-0.38296470046043396,
0.32737985253334045,
-0.13949577510356903,
0.4184977412223816,
0.56764817237854,
0.7775622606277466,
-0.2843908965587616,
0.3735973834991455,
-0.370198518037796,
-0.2884214222431183,
-0.12098541110754013,
-1.303471326828003,
-0.8724281191825867,
-0.552983820438385,
-0.5858356952667236,
-0.2701312303543091,
0.08330699801445007,
1.179922342300415,
0.7841582894325256,
-0.6139321327209473,
-0.09837710112333298,
-0.062113575637340546,
-0.15802624821662903,
-0.1582551896572113,
-0.13052614033222198,
0.8050879836082458,
-0.16000831127166748,
-0.9889969229698181,
0.2714943587779999,
0.41375306248664856,
0.6423696279525757,
-0.3541359305381775,
-0.11301076412200928,
-0.4615452289581299,
-0.42426013946533203,
0.19586576521396637,
0.18117788434028625,
-0.7625318765640259,
-0.3901221752166748,
-0.008650205098092556,
-0.35847461223602295,
0.3066880404949188,
0.5389045476913452,
-0.34619730710983276,
0.5086649060249329,
0.20128393173217773,
0.8924568295478821,
0.06412673741579056,
0.2048010528087616,
0.8276863694190979,
-0.9614280462265015,
0.27640900015830994,
0.21448588371276855,
0.25719892978668213,
0.7555439472198486,
-0.6844602823257446,
0.5160884857177734,
0.21696574985980988,
-0.7395991086959839,
-0.7668604850769043,
0.3077126741409302,
-0.9615116715431213,
-0.0006752518238499761,
1.1939009428024292,
-0.2364981323480606,
-0.17483915388584137,
0.13134095072746277,
-0.1975630521774292,
0.4543164074420929,
-0.3053475320339203,
0.7275803685188293,
0.7391102313995361,
-0.1221967563033104,
-0.02889508567750454,
-0.23094037175178528,
0.6904649138450623,
0.4123847484588623,
-0.8156993389129639,
0.3992971181869507,
0.6338650584220886,
0.24597881734371185,
0.06504437327384949,
0.7040486931800842,
-0.1051877960562706,
-0.011229557916522026,
-0.05618944391608238,
0.19328716397285461,
0.2519057095050812,
-0.08664039522409439,
-0.6287732124328613,
-0.20155295729637146,
0.4430924654006958,
-0.10707375407218933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06371v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06371v2
|
Model Generation with LLMs: From Requirements to UML Sequence Diagrams
| 2024-04-09T15:07:25 | 2024-07-01T13:16:49 |
Alessio Ferrari, Sallam Abualhaija, Chetan Arora
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG, D.2; K.6.3; D.2.1; D.3.1; D.2.2; D.2.10; D.2.2; I.2; I.2.7
|
Complementing natural language (NL) requirements with graphical models can
improve stakeholders' communication and provide directions for system design.
However, creating models from requirements involves manual effort. The advent
of generative large language models (LLMs), ChatGPT being a notable example,
offers promising avenues for automated assistance in model generation. This
paper investigates the capability of ChatGPT to generate a specific type of
model, i.e., UML sequence diagrams, from NL requirements. We conduct a
qualitative study in which we examine the sequence diagrams generated by
ChatGPT for 28 requirements documents of various types and from different
domains. Observations from the analysis of the generated diagrams have
systematically been captured through evaluation logs, and categorized through
thematic analysis. Our results indicate that, although the models generally
conform to the standard and exhibit a reasonable level of understandability,
their completeness and correctness with respect to the specified requirements
often present challenges. This issue is particularly pronounced in the presence
of requirements smells, such as ambiguity and inconsistency. The insights
derived from this study can influence the practical utilization of LLMs in the
RE process, and open the door to novel RE-specific prompting strategies
targeting effective model generation.
|
[
-0.4827701151371002,
-0.5199522972106934,
0.5846525430679321,
0.10213535279035568,
-0.30681654810905457,
-0.043080270290374756,
0.31549835205078125,
-0.3535456955432892,
-0.15004287660121918,
0.7212622761726379,
-0.6801871061325073,
-0.48025670647621155,
-0.23040415346622467,
0.3428599536418915,
-0.7065169215202332,
0.9052329659461975,
-0.25875359773635864,
-0.47376549243927,
0.08781825006008148,
0.2817692458629608,
-0.8229141235351562,
-0.5385820865631104,
-0.5790106654167175,
-0.5296012163162231,
0.5465717911720276,
0.3700026869773865,
0.7256364226341248,
0.1966402679681778,
0.32371678948402405,
0.26001325249671936,
-0.07153693586587906,
0.30728864669799805,
-0.22117602825164795,
0.6201257705688477,
0.2593749463558197,
-0.26028862595558167,
-0.7408044934272766,
-0.13251999020576477,
0.5506777763366699,
0.5741430521011353,
-0.31388354301452637,
0.1880369633436203,
0.4805605113506317,
0.6853979229927063,
-0.1261260062456131,
0.4727526009082794,
-0.618371844291687,
0.27136939764022827,
0.0027985963970422745,
-0.5059441924095154,
-0.47917646169662476,
-0.2197752743959427,
0.31601765751838684,
-0.6422527432441711,
0.39412909746170044,
0.21451546251773834,
1.1106277704238892,
-0.06904781609773636,
-0.4460882544517517,
-0.466433584690094,
-0.6076797246932983,
0.41634631156921387,
-1.18197500705719,
0.28588852286338806,
-0.07151445001363754,
0.32198795676231384,
-0.6710965037345886,
-0.7750151753425598,
-0.15934067964553833,
-0.26567891240119934,
-0.2159019112586975,
0.11374948173761368,
-0.18494504690170288,
0.12693722546100616,
0.4958820343017578,
0.19978347420692444,
-0.739614725112915,
0.07004552334547043,
-0.30840328335762024,
-0.014716090634465218,
0.6844372153282166,
0.5244691371917725,
0.4292953908443451,
-0.7745361328125,
-0.26136332750320435,
0.19993266463279724,
-1.1370371580123901,
-0.3742833435535431,
0.38318872451782227,
0.4695691168308258,
-0.2161369025707245,
0.9671125411987305,
-0.09869126975536346,
0.6136921644210815,
-0.19080619513988495,
0.14759813249111176,
-0.06113645061850548,
-0.2166033238172531,
-0.37644699215888977,
-0.21281848847866058,
0.7348941564559937,
0.0468263179063797,
0.5397367477416992,
0.023727623745799065,
-0.6414370536804199,
-0.3921695947647095,
0.4825781285762787,
-0.4833964407444,
-0.1936979442834854,
0.3134835362434387,
-0.5496998429298401,
-0.4086371660232544,
-0.10335368663072586,
-0.4480283856391907,
-0.32872092723846436,
-0.7787468433380127,
0.15204209089279175,
-0.5282963514328003,
-0.3949960470199585,
-0.09080933779478073,
-0.14908193051815033,
0.518588125705719,
0.46724140644073486,
-0.6460747718811035,
-0.27305662631988525,
0.6947625875473022,
0.8311793208122253,
0.028571326285600662,
0.02264140173792839,
-0.059692006558179855,
0.33101752400398254,
-0.28397732973098755,
0.8557934165000916,
-0.2729938328266144,
-0.8119171261787415,
0.2625189423561096,
-0.3222701847553253,
-0.098521389067173,
-0.4347746670246124,
0.39323076605796814,
-0.5919105410575867,
0.10552151501178741,
-0.003941101487725973,
-0.7006074786186218,
0.006187241990119219,
0.2992591857910156,
-0.5395873188972473,
0.8107778429985046,
-0.014073008671402931,
-0.7826942801475525,
0.32746952772140503,
-0.7379562854766846,
-0.32098326086997986,
0.3815687894821167,
-0.5469992160797119,
-0.3493061065673828,
0.20648857951164246,
0.023329613730311394,
0.68487948179245,
-0.46573522686958313,
0.4348604381084442,
-0.16720092296600342,
-0.066612608730793,
0.3872562646865845,
-0.5490155220031738,
0.5543159246444702,
0.5438675284385681,
-0.08664772659540176,
0.27735796570777893,
-0.825962483882904,
0.1527555137872696,
0.3806820511817932,
-0.6282454133033752,
0.07903687655925751,
0.2792816758155823,
0.0749654620885849,
0.14572668075561523,
0.05141133815050125,
0.14135660231113434,
0.26542922854423523,
-0.23228803277015686,
0.5402708649635315,
0.6528860330581665,
0.26472121477127075,
0.14611145853996277,
-0.49040234088897705,
0.7127682566642761,
-0.21813395619392395,
-0.01732298545539379,
-0.5812562108039856,
-0.9187042117118835,
-1.0165009498596191,
-0.11758178472518921,
0.12174048274755478,
0.49712005257606506,
-0.6153817772865295,
0.4096027910709381,
-0.18242329359054565,
-0.2592759430408478,
-0.2030458301305771,
-0.11024600267410278,
0.2010246217250824,
0.19495889544487,
-0.2710287570953369,
-0.33826500177383423,
-0.8631294369697571,
-0.7189238667488098,
0.07834868878126144,
-0.4814873933792114,
-0.38893362879753113,
0.25653237104415894,
0.3252331614494324,
-0.10845927149057388,
1.104447841644287,
-0.33748990297317505,
0.05390617996454239,
-0.3963947594165802,
0.49985185265541077,
0.1702720820903778,
0.0977204442024231,
0.2579280436038971,
-0.8801695704460144,
-0.275846004486084,
0.06277299672365189,
-0.9627417922019958,
-0.3988652527332306,
-0.19073939323425293,
-0.0975349172949791,
0.3839041590690613,
0.4155218005180359,
-0.5541410446166992,
0.6034372448921204,
0.39716196060180664,
-0.059417724609375,
0.6818219423294067,
-0.35316285490989685,
0.07636517286300659,
-1.4120250940322876,
0.3154672086238861,
-0.027218716219067574,
-0.23431366682052612,
-0.744117021560669,
0.16774556040763855,
-0.2825741469860077,
-0.5580481886863708,
-0.343995064496994,
0.2509976029396057,
-0.6043181419372559,
-0.1805138736963272,
-0.18039804697036743,
0.21332350373268127,
0.03875085711479187,
0.1869327276945114,
0.2135995477437973,
0.419423371553421,
0.301324725151062,
-0.7179123163223267,
0.237131729722023,
0.29993703961372375,
-0.40032878518104553,
0.5283317565917969,
-0.7172415256500244,
0.10132117569446564,
-0.008700655773282051,
0.0657164677977562,
-1.1053884029388428,
-0.4264061450958252,
0.41073575615882874,
-0.25058454275131226,
0.3184678554534912,
-0.3825713098049164,
-0.7619741559028625,
-0.3883350193500519,
0.35569676756858826,
0.00221931841224432,
0.7298209071159363,
-0.16340376436710358,
0.5878521203994751,
0.06419600546360016,
-0.24657504260540009,
-0.03119642846286297,
-0.40168115496635437,
0.22865119576454163,
-0.32733529806137085,
-0.8607566952705383,
0.1241711899638176,
0.1482841521501541,
-0.10361717641353607,
-0.10751443356275558,
0.08807939291000366,
0.04945734143257141,
0.16102775931358337,
0.6910964250564575,
0.4066699147224426,
-0.4428088366985321,
-0.10895359516143799,
-0.31576061248779297,
-0.22209253907203674,
0.08323031663894653,
-0.21848855912685394,
0.5835391283035278,
0.11126614362001419,
-0.8474913835525513,
-0.44670766592025757,
0.5386981964111328,
0.5598224401473999,
-0.06015781685709953,
0.228172168135643,
0.29415255784988403,
-0.19145207107067108,
-0.3002674877643585,
-0.35947325825691223,
-0.00009060576121555641,
-0.4724394977092743,
0.1150321438908577,
-0.5518226027488708,
-0.6956007480621338,
0.6170660257339478,
-0.04458032548427582,
0.5243232846260071,
0.25495731830596924,
0.6237866878509521,
-0.1018335372209549,
0.9292341470718384,
0.5198764801025391,
0.2548811435699463,
0.43922266364097595,
-0.023632392287254333,
0.3372080624103546,
-0.6534963250160217,
-0.18430763483047485,
-0.4615194499492645,
0.02030337229371071,
-0.5362136363983154,
-0.19340795278549194,
0.39923974871635437,
-0.12722867727279663,
-0.26472383737564087,
0.30788978934288025,
-0.32908138632774353,
0.11947426944971085,
0.47448354959487915,
-0.12281642109155655,
0.45399993658065796,
0.28762391209602356,
-0.2006825953722,
0.12846030294895172,
-0.9350979328155518,
-1.0674548149108887,
0.8465496301651001,
0.27175894379615784,
0.8757320642471313,
0.06702537089586258,
0.873186469078064,
0.3724304437637329,
0.4286864101886749,
-0.5685539245605469,
0.6756536364555359,
0.2190747857093811,
-0.6693965792655945,
-0.26252055168151855,
-0.3907926082611084,
-1.1940664052963257,
0.24315357208251953,
-0.20844602584838867,
-0.5151101350784302,
-0.08246716111898422,
0.3919016420841217,
-0.26966485381126404,
0.12478269636631012,
-0.7055193185806274,
0.7085998058319092,
-0.06013985350728035,
0.27199485898017883,
0.017143290489912033,
-0.4843372702598572,
0.5187321901321411,
-0.27283403277397156,
0.09784536063671112,
-0.341641366481781,
0.25002750754356384,
0.31285548210144043,
-0.502105712890625,
1.1524252891540527,
0.15353937447071075,
-0.5637809634208679,
0.6287800669670105,
0.26028546690940857,
0.7304210066795349,
-0.3285539448261261,
-0.1253560185432434,
-0.12469962984323502,
-0.07201547920703888,
-0.18690820038318634,
-0.3588414788246155,
0.2951892912387848,
-0.3796021342277527,
-0.9624528884887695,
-0.1667192429304123,
-0.570652425289154,
-0.1435984969139099,
0.054285578429698944,
0.35179921984672546,
0.3448897898197174,
-0.39132288098335266,
-0.23684141039848328,
0.525335967540741,
-0.4928129315376282,
0.24950186908245087,
0.5298543572425842,
-0.5447368025779724,
0.0802987813949585,
0.6134337186813354,
0.18714895844459534,
0.5482921600341797,
0.1997283399105072,
-0.14313432574272156,
0.030726341530680656,
-0.5668589472770691,
-0.4226115345954895,
0.06460317224264145,
-0.605202317237854,
-0.1722198873758316,
-0.29646244645118713,
-0.7128985524177551,
-0.46447309851646423,
-0.1317792534828186,
0.023817045614123344,
-0.22309458255767822,
-0.4713383913040161,
0.2012493759393692,
0.39951902627944946,
1.2118141651153564,
0.20691893994808197,
0.27515098452568054,
-1.0582988262176514,
0.31591328978538513,
0.23005418479442596,
0.14064325392246246,
0.22406908869743347,
-0.7175046801567078,
0.10586218535900116,
-0.013392183929681778,
-0.6152470707893372,
-1.1307154893875122,
0.5785890221595764,
-0.04177122935652733,
0.6084922552108765,
0.38503891229629517,
-0.11551995575428009,
0.5352145433425903,
-0.8495591282844543,
0.6498376131057739,
0.06707565486431122,
-0.66868656873703,
0.6689901947975159,
-0.6928216218948364,
0.1348349004983902,
-0.3408818542957306,
0.078229159116745,
-0.7869934439659119,
-0.6081476807594299,
-0.7274797558784485,
-1.0241098403930664,
0.5692103505134583,
0.4783669412136078,
0.2573891878128052,
-0.0012383386492729187,
0.4282071590423584,
0.0035039582289755344,
-0.032882969826459885,
-0.32383108139038086,
-0.08669837564229965,
0.03384484350681305,
-0.18002937734127045,
0.4478333294391632,
-0.4318358600139618,
0.07452293485403061,
0.5362218022346497,
0.6518355011940002,
0.13393406569957733,
0.11736147850751877,
-0.021223243325948715,
0.08283496648073196,
0.10023943334817886,
0.5578152537345886,
0.38682711124420166,
0.49683284759521484,
-0.076722651720047,
-0.09637363255023956,
0.022244906052947044,
0.03980327025055885,
0.18010950088500977,
-0.18493059277534485,
-0.377562016248703,
0.2059924304485321,
0.18789507448673248,
0.6881864666938782,
0.36790454387664795,
-0.5750358700752258,
0.13558369874954224,
0.22931331396102905,
-0.23606213927268982,
-0.26637110114097595,
0.22781985998153687,
0.31568750739097595,
0.278389573097229,
0.15455113351345062,
-0.43392395973205566,
0.10968167334794998,
-0.242552250623703,
0.20470866560935974,
0.4459829330444336,
0.07980307191610336,
-0.1738739311695099,
0.5868141651153564,
0.39227911829948425,
-0.40304040908813477,
0.7928809523582458,
-0.16443264484405518,
-0.06938165426254272,
0.6271449327468872,
0.7104038596153259,
0.8695318102836609,
-0.054826442152261734,
0.3102847933769226,
0.18694466352462769,
0.20264862477779388,
-0.15435557067394257,
0.34272944927215576,
0.22432324290275574,
-0.5706058740615845,
-0.39722341299057007,
-0.5524038076400757,
-0.540075957775116,
-0.0059925043024122715,
-0.5604873895645142,
0.49852144718170166,
-0.19913242757320404,
-0.2787138521671295,
-0.10091233998537064,
-0.6483877897262573,
-0.730120062828064,
-0.15666617453098297,
0.3720954954624176,
0.6031426787376404,
-0.7435688972473145,
0.5823495388031006,
0.5228144526481628,
-0.6763314008712769,
-1.0698277950286865,
-0.29070037603378296,
0.2535654902458191,
-1.0182344913482666,
0.9021567106246948,
-0.0905921682715416,
0.07676486670970917,
-0.025713801383972168,
-0.27087533473968506,
-0.7385145425796509,
1.0696791410446167,
0.30284449458122253,
-0.6986153721809387,
-0.4567500650882721,
0.5669912695884705,
0.3885191082954407,
-0.5266337394714355,
-0.05211423709988594,
0.28643307089805603,
0.320636510848999,
0.3744114339351654,
-0.8012326955795288,
0.2560241222381592,
-0.2250571995973587,
0.44311147928237915,
0.3131372332572937,
-0.2615755796432495,
0.6041790246963501,
-0.289111465215683,
-0.7661430835723877,
0.4475703835487366,
0.5739168524742126,
0.6659064292907715,
0.10576579719781876,
0.3179089426994324,
0.2794022262096405,
0.6224392652511597,
0.03051111288368702,
0.9565404653549194,
-0.22088120877742767,
0.1437898874282837,
1.1476290225982666,
-0.41740813851356506,
0.8467702269554138,
0.3931271433830261,
-0.2009834349155426,
0.39224329590797424,
0.9046819806098938,
-0.18488387763500214,
-0.12701433897018433,
0.458406537771225,
-0.11429036408662796,
-0.31355997920036316,
0.046243663877248764,
-0.47189509868621826,
0.005449642892926931,
0.5037654042243958,
-0.6750236749649048,
-0.3308010399341583,
-0.36912575364112854,
-0.26186391711235046,
-0.3086322546005249,
-0.103252112865448,
0.736181914806366,
0.3996868133544922,
-0.5630286931991577,
0.5231255888938904,
-0.14148114621639252,
0.20764939486980438,
-0.5668594241142273,
-0.22324268519878387,
-0.30443739891052246,
-0.2961229383945465,
-0.19719572365283966,
-0.85600346326828,
0.2069469541311264,
0.3353475332260132,
-0.14605176448822021,
-0.3503101170063019,
0.6484468579292297,
-0.14545072615146637,
-0.5702637434005737,
-0.05885649472475052,
0.729610800743103,
0.5990353226661682,
-0.0011387275299057364,
-0.6968948245048523,
-0.1270180344581604,
0.1345137506723404,
-0.3066789209842682,
0.15818902850151062,
0.8272206783294678,
-0.11849408596754074,
0.7750749588012695,
0.47491222620010376,
-0.04703222215175629,
0.16953401267528534,
0.3715115189552307,
0.44904541969299316,
-0.6050928235054016,
-0.10737190395593643,
-0.7689501643180847,
0.691865086555481,
0.17750729620456696,
-0.11067121475934982,
0.6805152893066406,
0.4334620237350464,
0.4667084515094757,
-0.16772867739200592,
1.0590806007385254,
-0.0737973302602768,
0.18252485990524292,
-0.8195669054985046,
0.7876086831092834,
-0.48486465215682983,
0.6174839735031128,
-0.16954733431339264,
-0.9257189035415649,
-0.32477453351020813,
0.3075581192970276,
-0.049172062426805496,
0.06280084699392319,
0.40757617354393005,
0.9880438446998596,
-0.06516032665967941,
0.12260359525680542,
0.36169135570526123,
-0.08383819460868835,
0.6181159615516663,
0.6086502075195312,
1.1830470561981201,
-0.14724354445934296,
0.6610801815986633,
0.479818731546402,
0.12068593502044678,
-0.37385293841362,
-1.108246088027954,
-0.7270467281341553,
-0.6295142769813538,
-0.3823610842227936,
-0.34195855259895325,
-0.05746576935052872,
0.8926743268966675,
0.6074941158294678,
-0.6756460666656494,
-0.48662522435188293,
-0.3204970359802246,
0.18931235373020172,
0.3501770496368408,
-0.17624427378177643,
0.13738825917243958,
-0.7740457057952881,
-0.4095504879951477,
0.023905528709292412,
0.35815295577049255,
0.6719331741333008,
-0.30842411518096924,
-0.13894394040107727,
0.17473120987415314,
0.24401073157787323,
0.5514594912528992,
0.3973228633403778,
-1.0115288496017456,
-0.19254529476165771,
-0.21537363529205322,
-0.1369147151708603,
0.13722629845142365,
1.088566780090332,
-0.36476197838783264,
0.06504959613084793,
0.5591756701469421,
0.18629831075668335,
0.24467886984348297,
-0.22280248999595642,
0.9863899350166321,
-0.7486018538475037,
-0.2181987315416336,
-0.12924115359783173,
0.6764035820960999,
0.40510430932044983,
0.010956786572933197,
0.5759364366531372,
0.0730552226305008,
-0.5284110903739929,
-0.6947821974754333,
0.6020197868347168,
-0.8241844773292542,
-0.14550715684890747,
1.377200961112976,
-0.08250091224908829,
0.05912306159734726,
-0.2052411288022995,
-0.5309921503067017,
0.35298919677734375,
-0.23441049456596375,
0.7415083050727844,
0.6741450428962708,
-0.2827085256576538,
-0.0002821095986291766,
-0.7669749855995178,
0.3211333751678467,
0.1443934142589569,
-0.9039490222930908,
0.4270695447921753,
0.6504442095756531,
0.2886057198047638,
-0.03444845229387283,
0.4227381944656372,
-0.07860898971557617,
-0.025347884744405746,
-0.06486430019140244,
0.17415279150009155,
0.2226209044456482,
0.07773712277412415,
0.05269994959235191,
0.1938270479440689,
0.5914334654808044,
0.06250304728746414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06367v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06367v1
|
ClinLinker: Medical Entity Linking of Clinical Concept Mentions in Spanish
| 2024-04-09T15:04:27 | 2024-04-09T15:04:27 |
Fernando Gallego, Guillermo López-García, Luis Gasco-Sánchez, Martin Krallinger, Francisco J. Veredas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Advances in natural language processing techniques, such as named entity
recognition and normalization to widely used standardized terminologies like
UMLS or SNOMED-CT, along with the digitalization of electronic health records,
have significantly advanced clinical text analysis. This study presents
ClinLinker, a novel approach employing a two-phase pipeline for medical entity
linking that leverages the potential of in-domain adapted language models for
biomedical text mining: initial candidate retrieval using a SapBERT-based
bi-encoder and subsequent re-ranking with a cross-encoder, trained by following
a contrastive-learning strategy to be tailored to medical concepts in Spanish.
This methodology, focused initially on content in Spanish, substantially
outperforming multilingual language models designed for the same purpose. This
is true even for complex scenarios involving heterogeneous medical
terminologies and being trained on a subset of the original data. Our results,
evaluated using top-k accuracy at 25 and other top-k metrics, demonstrate our
approach's performance on two distinct clinical entity linking Gold Standard
corpora, DisTEMIST (diseases) and MedProcNER (clinical procedures),
outperforming previous benchmarks by 40 points in DisTEMIST and 43 points in
MedProcNER, both normalized to SNOMED-CT codes. These findings highlight our
approach's ability to address language-specific nuances and set a new benchmark
in entity linking, offering a potent tool for enhancing the utility of digital
medical records. The resulting system is of practical value, both for large
scale automatic generation of structured data derived from clinical records, as
well as for exhaustive extraction and harmonization of predefined clinical
variables of interest.
|
[
-0.11205480247735977,
-0.6026340126991272,
0.6207817792892456,
0.0016100043430924416,
-0.5584616661071777,
-0.038437582552433014,
-0.08798056095838547,
-0.7541612386703491,
0.3382808566093445,
0.4271700978279114,
-0.3304935097694397,
-0.7680327296257019,
-0.6714200377464294,
0.39853617548942566,
-0.36845722794532776,
1.1954866647720337,
0.07776357978582382,
0.3000648617744446,
-0.3266696631908417,
-0.28096631169319153,
-0.25467202067375183,
-0.46558696031570435,
-0.7738645076751709,
-0.47893673181533813,
0.7996910214424133,
0.19425083696842194,
0.7902112007141113,
0.8972901105880737,
0.8705083727836609,
0.19214501976966858,
0.1164737269282341,
0.10615836083889008,
-0.2923305332660675,
0.15798550844192505,
-0.48212191462516785,
-0.5083678960800171,
-0.4059619903564453,
-0.7621904611587524,
0.4911580979824066,
0.712693989276886,
0.012082885019481182,
0.07730205357074738,
-0.16072727739810944,
0.8799700736999512,
-0.326703280210495,
0.34956231713294983,
-0.921504557132721,
-0.1113239973783493,
-0.5289610624313354,
-0.5196924209594727,
-0.1401720941066742,
-0.5115197896957397,
0.4444562792778015,
-0.4014299511909485,
0.56580650806427,
0.010925262235105038,
0.9252480268478394,
0.3722059726715088,
-0.3888719379901886,
-0.9554116725921631,
-0.24135632812976837,
0.2644904553890228,
-0.5028155446052551,
0.5099835991859436,
0.23001766204833984,
0.18375517427921295,
-0.18155796825885773,
-0.9067291021347046,
-0.318589985370636,
-0.2535378038883209,
-0.22479206323623657,
-0.05026134103536606,
-0.08181645721197128,
0.1639164835214615,
0.06222032383084297,
0.35496997833251953,
-0.6121153831481934,
-0.014663344249129295,
-0.7146477699279785,
-0.2774064242839813,
0.4733983874320984,
-0.04447996988892555,
0.48588719964027405,
-0.03694503754377365,
-0.31008949875831604,
0.1257510632276535,
-1.1135896444320679,
-0.36453089118003845,
-0.10715930163860321,
0.2941005229949951,
0.11638598144054413,
0.6109448075294495,
0.11508341133594513,
0.3446560800075531,
0.29164454340934753,
-0.27059510350227356,
0.5175209045410156,
-0.30557355284690857,
-0.07639027386903763,
0.5554826855659485,
0.7969264388084412,
0.49163514375686646,
0.021288583055138588,
-0.4174957573413849,
0.14839579164981842,
0.2601010799407959,
0.15544943511486053,
-0.828311026096344,
-0.5485751032829285,
0.44397249817848206,
-0.3643873333930969,
0.027551718056201935,
-0.06741490215063095,
-0.62909996509552,
-0.46282199025154114,
-0.19816233217716217,
0.2000817358493805,
-0.6388365030288696,
0.13489064574241638,
0.20489580929279327,
0.11174947023391724,
-0.2063509225845337,
-0.03600941598415375,
-0.4862309396266937,
0.40528404712677,
0.5041789412498474,
0.8685470819473267,
-0.3492760956287384,
0.06216830387711525,
-0.4202251732349396,
0.3064102530479431,
-0.02219843864440918,
0.786274790763855,
-0.28743961453437805,
-0.36885789036750793,
0.28379836678504944,
0.2872181832790375,
-0.20027421414852142,
-0.8213782906532288,
0.6376011967658997,
-0.37637773156166077,
0.019909102469682693,
-0.05142201483249664,
-0.6535282731056213,
0.11983022838830948,
0.016107913106679916,
-0.9928885698318481,
0.8784313797950745,
-0.19437377154827118,
-0.9967566132545471,
0.3827141523361206,
-0.4864746630191803,
-0.5912064909934998,
0.22354847192764282,
-0.17726977169513702,
-0.4081113934516907,
-0.08482152223587036,
-0.11545832455158234,
0.3667029142379761,
-0.6161007285118103,
0.6044298410415649,
-0.05747722461819649,
-0.17003695666790009,
0.07789069414138794,
0.2599278390407562,
0.5701397061347961,
0.20471073687076569,
-0.12170898169279099,
0.03668474033474922,
-0.8410858511924744,
-0.35664981603622437,
0.11315713077783585,
-0.19622483849525452,
-0.7708926796913147,
-0.14110693335533142,
-0.034488264471292496,
0.4529488980770111,
0.39796513319015503,
-0.5684337019920349,
-0.15858983993530273,
-0.8023983240127563,
0.29817578196525574,
-0.11247296631336212,
0.32824403047561646,
0.2864857017993927,
-0.2513643801212311,
0.2164037972688675,
0.18696700036525726,
-0.056879013776779175,
-0.1312062293291092,
-0.49010464549064636,
-0.8446871042251587,
-0.2310468852519989,
0.5406003594398499,
0.5443326830863953,
-0.7483121752738953,
0.3497787415981293,
-0.4237827956676483,
-0.43445897102355957,
-0.8799089193344116,
-0.034831516444683075,
0.675256073474884,
0.8333924412727356,
0.7403804659843445,
-0.38155999779701233,
-0.587624728679657,
-0.9433853030204773,
-0.09838437288999557,
-0.10584551095962524,
-0.18477632105350494,
0.27247491478919983,
0.6657553911209106,
-0.3908543288707733,
0.5176660418510437,
-0.4026520848274231,
-0.4694119393825531,
-0.19676513969898224,
-0.029944710433483124,
0.2738090455532074,
0.30030253529548645,
0.38151252269744873,
-0.7716132402420044,
-0.6897542476654053,
0.28951579332351685,
-0.701974630355835,
-0.24075369536876678,
0.04265135899186134,
-0.06249677762389183,
-0.027318324893712997,
0.5014491677284241,
-0.2147735059261322,
0.32630616426467896,
0.3675009310245514,
-0.11277270317077637,
0.20313549041748047,
-0.4922647178173065,
0.06913255900144577,
-1.1048260927200317,
0.40531930327415466,
0.22556650638580322,
-0.10010478645563126,
-0.8709426522254944,
-0.011660158634185791,
0.07580945640802383,
0.17371846735477448,
-0.5526559352874756,
0.5295972228050232,
-0.3680809736251831,
0.4169824421405792,
-0.1579735279083252,
0.28434085845947266,
-0.10596857964992523,
0.10233213752508163,
0.25932586193084717,
0.39435312151908875,
0.534760057926178,
-0.6851320862770081,
0.2415744513273239,
0.4868689775466919,
0.03601561859250069,
0.8781818747520447,
-0.8983580470085144,
-0.04605377838015556,
-0.3670930564403534,
0.0339597687125206,
-0.4976722002029419,
-0.002300999825820327,
0.1626996248960495,
-0.276658296585083,
0.2826378047466278,
-0.11445863544940948,
-0.6399543881416321,
-0.22924970090389252,
-0.23692353069782257,
0.370939165353775,
0.08819683641195297,
-0.3548184335231781,
0.11314649134874344,
0.6633999347686768,
-0.44682663679122925,
-0.2200288325548172,
-0.5910753011703491,
0.10226830095052719,
-0.22665594518184662,
-0.4602068066596985,
0.6750127673149109,
-0.09769273549318314,
-0.037115175276994705,
-0.02268371172249317,
-0.2845272719860077,
-0.48252496123313904,
-0.2281993180513382,
0.2232024371623993,
0.4722377061843872,
-0.0449354387819767,
0.5339586734771729,
0.36006537079811096,
-0.14689600467681885,
0.15494833886623383,
-0.23006638884544373,
0.3733021318912506,
0.08482743054628372,
-0.18458016216754913,
-0.3400566577911377,
0.2960123121738434,
0.4263659715652466,
-0.20268377661705017,
0.7771131992340088,
0.3682345449924469,
-0.7379567623138428,
0.23842254281044006,
-0.5231369733810425,
-0.16427505016326904,
-0.31969153881073,
0.31624647974967957,
-0.4231107234954834,
-0.7948492169380188,
0.35963207483291626,
-0.3122507929801941,
0.01989312842488289,
0.5526664853096008,
0.667686402797699,
-0.06003807485103607,
0.5265712738037109,
0.47640809416770935,
0.16729030013084412,
-0.11844778060913086,
0.04255504533648491,
0.3280697762966156,
-0.7030813097953796,
-0.6291105151176453,
-0.6824778318405151,
-0.018832936882972717,
-0.7366749048233032,
-0.388310045003891,
0.670697808265686,
0.049789365381002426,
-0.06401467323303223,
0.6374901533126831,
-0.2679134011268616,
0.13115282356739044,
0.23242755234241486,
0.419697642326355,
0.6364195942878723,
-0.05576002225279808,
-0.505445659160614,
-0.12171482294797897,
-0.7280169129371643,
-0.4251086115837097,
1.2095626592636108,
0.4083796739578247,
0.4241730570793152,
0.025916187092661858,
0.7055640816688538,
0.2074873149394989,
0.3808521628379822,
-0.5442426800727844,
0.17713360488414764,
-0.24931077659130096,
-0.5014504790306091,
0.05578364431858063,
0.03386848792433739,
-1.084958553314209,
0.0711238905787468,
-0.6433463096618652,
-0.5748659372329712,
0.16512222588062286,
0.1414618194103241,
-0.09371474385261536,
0.049292150884866714,
-0.24016036093235016,
0.7714985013008118,
-0.1138748899102211,
-0.4240676760673523,
-0.1788540780544281,
-0.9191670417785645,
0.170527845621109,
-0.3917969763278961,
0.1861790418624878,
0.03438010811805725,
-0.23598036170005798,
0.5264462828636169,
-0.5221971273422241,
0.5207037925720215,
0.23611582815647125,
-0.08565053343772888,
0.127533420920372,
0.05174430459737778,
0.2921231985092163,
0.23061056435108185,
-0.04460644721984863,
0.37459731101989746,
0.3589414656162262,
-0.2091965526342392,
-0.3578825294971466,
0.8516848087310791,
-0.2392617166042328,
-0.006382327992469072,
-0.49541008472442627,
-0.41273829340934753,
-0.24760690331459045,
0.29345113039016724,
0.3269554674625397,
0.556435763835907,
-0.3043736219406128,
0.16055479645729065,
0.8610892295837402,
-0.1575654000043869,
-0.10820145159959793,
0.6335291862487793,
0.2978152334690094,
-0.4447384774684906,
0.5443279147148132,
-0.3519655168056488,
0.12487410753965378,
0.7557254433631897,
-0.015065931715071201,
-0.6101113557815552,
-0.6280543804168701,
-0.22954422235488892,
0.6593925356864929,
-0.5543653964996338,
-0.2611353397369385,
-0.793394148349762,
-0.26971015334129333,
-0.03874443843960762,
-0.1840602457523346,
-0.19492663443088531,
-0.056196991354227066,
-0.05653262138366699,
-0.014803048223257065,
0.15827703475952148,
0.33230096101760864,
0.34417590498924255,
0.1883554309606552,
-0.96913743019104,
0.33684542775154114,
-0.28331223130226135,
0.44425538182258606,
-0.22808361053466797,
-0.07062391936779022,
-0.38294801115989685,
-0.25502800941467285,
0.04433578997850418,
-1.154999852180481,
0.3598212003707886,
0.40435752272605896,
0.5086561441421509,
0.43784213066101074,
-0.024499844759702682,
0.6502598524093628,
-0.8513440489768982,
0.31250154972076416,
0.39877212047576904,
-0.568030834197998,
0.8381023406982422,
-0.06686025112867355,
0.06945107132196426,
0.8763014674186707,
0.8242836594581604,
-0.46622607111930847,
-0.35705143213272095,
-0.7232717275619507,
-0.8590753078460693,
0.12916059792041779,
0.18359914422035217,
-0.44785067439079285,
-0.5443395972251892,
0.4587690532207489,
0.2863597571849823,
0.47784242033958435,
-0.37886616587638855,
-0.6369624137878418,
0.22417953610420227,
-0.6092551946640015,
0.10375287383794785,
-0.17385034263134003,
-0.1784229427576065,
-0.16487915813922882,
0.6454718112945557,
-0.22974808514118195,
0.17389993369579315,
0.6557982563972473,
-0.6040124297142029,
0.04012179374694824,
0.42798903584480286,
0.22553879022598267,
0.6625055074691772,
-0.2330188751220703,
0.09070680290460587,
0.14100463688373566,
-0.6026808023452759,
-0.21690669655799866,
0.30388885736465454,
-0.2719603180885315,
0.4538419842720032,
0.20482756197452545,
0.5312663316726685,
0.543421745300293,
-0.8866090178489685,
0.33357569575309753,
0.22674602270126343,
-0.15129534900188446,
-0.22408542037010193,
-0.23141221702098846,
0.0765538141131401,
0.16144676506519318,
-0.02982615865767002,
-0.1856183558702469,
0.4321327209472656,
-0.49147215485572815,
0.4973602294921875,
0.2185864895582199,
-0.6992530822753906,
-0.39559227228164673,
0.8416295051574707,
0.2443261742591858,
-0.0009422509465366602,
0.20786577463150024,
0.013159451074898243,
-0.1550726592540741,
0.3180144131183624,
0.8509707450866699,
0.6323926448822021,
-0.11843668669462204,
0.07670916616916656,
0.6986438632011414,
-0.03529028967022896,
-0.23794862627983093,
0.16059155762195587,
0.16118010878562927,
-0.48150911927223206,
-0.15273630619049072,
-0.4720920920372009,
-0.29081642627716064,
0.0015231218421831727,
-0.736940324306488,
0.48278218507766724,
-0.24842755496501923,
-0.21656973659992218,
0.07143627107143402,
-0.06903724372386932,
-0.8693104386329651,
0.2844603657722473,
0.11914507299661636,
0.8828443288803101,
-0.7183036804199219,
0.9568042755126953,
1.0005959272384644,
-0.5108291506767273,
-0.22956158220767975,
-0.2261269986629486,
0.1617165356874466,
-0.5526461601257324,
0.46258893609046936,
-0.1252281218767166,
0.03941717371344566,
-0.042180728167295456,
0.1448400765657425,
-0.7432138323783875,
1.2878016233444214,
0.05761468783020973,
-0.7807642221450806,
-0.19508759677410126,
0.23258018493652344,
0.9348494410514832,
-0.618443489074707,
0.3741420805454254,
0.8640003204345703,
0.08709044754505157,
0.19086168706417084,
-1.2251694202423096,
0.36712679266929626,
-0.3171434700489044,
-0.15896674990653992,
0.4086875021457672,
-0.2379252016544342,
0.3301188051700592,
-0.206711083650589,
-0.2967035472393036,
0.17544423043727875,
0.30356234312057495,
0.3554464280605316,
0.5691159963607788,
0.3288319706916809,
0.40079352259635925,
1.0246877670288086,
-0.015244537964463234,
0.6435627937316895,
-0.8096479177474976,
0.25173476338386536,
1.0409555435180664,
-0.4267513155937195,
0.7204755544662476,
0.43025481700897217,
-0.16623201966285706,
0.7807655334472656,
0.22180889546871185,
-0.05219479650259018,
0.5244466662406921,
0.2413049191236496,
-0.38289666175842285,
0.21933172643184662,
-0.46032723784446716,
-0.3745809495449066,
-0.06394217163324356,
0.5683254599571228,
-0.6184963583946228,
-0.27125340700149536,
-0.21302394568920135,
0.2465396374464035,
0.21919095516204834,
-0.3342254161834717,
0.7697110176086426,
0.14727528393268585,
-0.4607976973056793,
0.4111036956310272,
-0.18581506609916687,
0.49321871995925903,
-0.7032008767127991,
-0.06645479053258896,
0.08578497171401978,
0.07193568348884583,
-0.3609069883823395,
-0.4099777340888977,
0.25418952107429504,
0.00609219865873456,
-0.1366102397441864,
0.27623283863067627,
0.8504577875137329,
-0.7845638394355774,
-0.40693598985671997,
0.19600772857666016,
0.5024970769882202,
0.22367560863494873,
0.16602171957492828,
-0.7013146877288818,
-0.1454111784696579,
-0.11244244873523712,
0.5775327086448669,
0.2783353924751282,
0.3970109820365906,
-0.2817666530609131,
0.6477382779121399,
0.688923716545105,
0.48540931940078735,
-0.11855768412351608,
0.36123865842819214,
0.7898216247558594,
-0.7130646109580994,
-0.47258108854293823,
-0.6131294369697571,
0.43710094690322876,
-0.16493216156959534,
-0.26916417479515076,
0.3241274952888489,
0.786276638507843,
0.7862919569015503,
-0.10919857025146484,
0.756306529045105,
0.027144107967615128,
0.5975726842880249,
-0.3628358542919159,
0.48199325799942017,
-0.29411938786506653,
0.23081322014331818,
-0.23858116567134857,
-0.7503997087478638,
-0.625907301902771,
0.2289808988571167,
-0.026729607954621315,
-0.6758180856704712,
1.2979440689086914,
0.6614519357681274,
0.14006978273391724,
-0.24935764074325562,
0.03494831174612045,
0.258085161447525,
0.05503396317362785,
0.7728634476661682,
-0.01707589440047741,
-0.5963079333305359,
0.45780807733535767,
-0.21093666553497314,
-0.1864004135131836,
-0.1255117952823639,
-0.7592445611953735,
-1.0399607419967651,
-0.5600305795669556,
-0.5989615321159363,
-0.455936461687088,
0.4165012240409851,
1.1844813823699951,
0.2477848082780838,
-1.0049854516983032,
0.06901192665100098,
0.1295545995235443,
-0.1076471358537674,
-0.06370960175991058,
-0.09534694999456406,
0.6623668670654297,
-0.1580677479505539,
-0.6932411789894104,
0.24835814535617828,
0.45519617199897766,
-0.18091483414173126,
-0.03496032953262329,
-0.00424334779381752,
-0.2231300324201584,
-0.1907038688659668,
0.4757346212863922,
0.38300004601478577,
-0.6559852361679077,
0.1587921679019928,
-0.003825524589046836,
-0.22360631823539734,
0.12093894183635712,
0.8143352270126343,
-0.8847383260726929,
0.5678993463516235,
0.4144594371318817,
0.550937294960022,
0.4725262224674225,
0.04134908318519592,
0.42176565527915955,
-0.3093663454055786,
0.12803849577903748,
0.22618161141872406,
0.4172952175140381,
0.26496368646621704,
-0.3084096610546112,
0.4915044903755188,
0.2308429628610611,
-0.22384104132652283,
-0.4231446385383606,
0.09879433363676071,
-0.9338269233703613,
0.08613280951976776,
0.87395179271698,
0.01731475256383419,
-0.2109190672636032,
-0.4803199768066406,
-0.20133544504642487,
0.4401996433734894,
-0.17639249563217163,
0.7734067440032959,
0.18939952552318573,
-0.11264222860336304,
0.12959496676921844,
-0.6395491361618042,
0.6031277775764465,
-0.039522215723991394,
-0.6609964966773987,
-0.5118985176086426,
0.3576023280620575,
0.5266904234886169,
0.1745438128709793,
0.7498013973236084,
-0.6337127089500427,
0.23698492348194122,
-0.4101572334766388,
0.14423194527626038,
0.07481544464826584,
-0.2979857921600342,
-0.23351027071475983,
0.11216472834348679,
-0.08991585671901703,
-0.021464180201292038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06364v1
|
SurveyAgent: A Conversational System for Personalized and Efficient Research Survey
| 2024-04-09T15:01:51 | 2024-04-09T15:01:51 |
Xintao Wang, Jiangjie Chen, Nianqi Li, Lida Chen, Xinfeng Yuan, Wei Shi, Xuyang Ge, Rui Xu, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the rapidly advancing research fields such as AI, managing and staying
abreast of the latest scientific literature has become a significant challenge
for researchers. Although previous efforts have leveraged AI to assist with
literature searches, paper recommendations, and question-answering, a
comprehensive support system that addresses the holistic needs of researchers
has been lacking. This paper introduces SurveyAgent, a novel conversational
system designed to provide personalized and efficient research survey
assistance to researchers. SurveyAgent integrates three key modules: Knowledge
Management for organizing papers, Recommendation for discovering relevant
literature, and Query Answering for engaging with content on a deeper level.
This system stands out by offering a unified platform that supports researchers
through various stages of their literature review process, facilitated by a
conversational interface that prioritizes user interaction and personalization.
Our evaluation demonstrates SurveyAgent's effectiveness in streamlining
research activities, showcasing its capability to facilitate how researchers
interact with scientific literature.
|
[
-0.519123911857605,
-0.4062597453594208,
0.40004077553749084,
0.3806751072406769,
-0.11562927812337875,
0.6155019402503967,
0.0034769976045936346,
-0.36027052998542786,
0.4372362792491913,
0.19700218737125397,
-0.2764137387275696,
-0.3781164288520813,
-0.15025456249713898,
0.03452879935503006,
-0.38720932602882385,
1.2668019533157349,
0.2697974443435669,
0.18734389543533325,
-0.8015880584716797,
-0.05467505007982254,
-0.074126236140728,
-0.2784908711910248,
-0.7826873064041138,
-0.6763355135917664,
1.0281726121902466,
0.35732805728912354,
0.5855251550674438,
-0.3817175030708313,
0.8662691116333008,
0.43786102533340454,
-0.027311354875564575,
0.2526407837867737,
-0.4058001637458801,
0.8215752243995667,
0.0113463643938303,
-0.542029082775116,
-0.41361451148986816,
-0.46861714124679565,
0.0028380537405610085,
0.5596732497215271,
-0.21752987802028656,
0.365349143743515,
0.038414597511291504,
0.37128084897994995,
-0.43863439559936523,
0.15067324042320251,
-0.23198507726192474,
-0.09924975037574768,
-0.0513879656791687,
-0.3445480167865753,
-0.12093502283096313,
-0.7647860050201416,
0.35722991824150085,
-0.9060606956481934,
0.28509521484375,
-0.016066087409853935,
0.42163416743278503,
0.08403584361076355,
-0.028302757069468498,
-0.22403085231781006,
-0.9325679540634155,
0.4596129357814789,
-0.4094022214412689,
-0.18973441421985626,
0.25783059000968933,
0.5644253492355347,
0.0022309382911771536,
-0.6342110633850098,
-0.08902740478515625,
-0.40017423033714294,
-0.18781274557113647,
0.31403425335884094,
-0.1528061032295227,
-0.08565928041934967,
-0.16848236322402954,
0.23195458948612213,
-0.6739165782928467,
-0.2493659257888794,
-0.44264963269233704,
-0.20603738725185394,
0.5243202447891235,
0.27761921286582947,
0.3841646909713745,
0.006670414935797453,
-0.16027241945266724,
0.06142987683415413,
0.019889630377292633,
0.24856239557266235,
0.27917590737342834,
0.04039287194609642,
0.2877088785171509,
0.43585795164108276,
-0.25951993465423584,
0.5744494199752808,
-0.052721742540597916,
0.2472534477710724,
-0.03067294880747795,
-0.17229706048965454,
-0.0352848656475544,
-0.07972918450832367,
0.8315207958221436,
0.05274263396859169,
-0.24998556077480316,
-0.16464999318122864,
-0.05738711729645729,
-0.23185133934020996,
0.24152237176895142,
-0.6754629611968994,
-0.704457700252533,
0.2528131604194641,
-0.13325433433055878,
-0.6074832677841187,
-0.013835977762937546,
-0.6246239542961121,
-0.733156681060791,
-0.004505424294620752,
0.1332516372203827,
-0.4334424138069153,
-0.3799927234649658,
-0.10044702142477036,
-0.47880807518959045,
0.008453868329524994,
0.9078420400619507,
-0.2042488008737564,
0.4931178092956543,
0.49479007720947266,
1.0349397659301758,
-0.225436732172966,
0.19872424006462097,
-0.14131970703601837,
0.023684127256274223,
-0.1630730926990509,
1.0007463693618774,
-0.680081844329834,
-0.7470784783363342,
-0.11548447608947754,
-0.3372665047645569,
0.06666959822177887,
-0.38159459829330444,
0.4248048961162567,
-0.9734827280044556,
0.6090269088745117,
-0.16807527840137482,
-0.27456194162368774,
-0.07152937352657318,
0.6647878289222717,
-0.5970433950424194,
0.8978836536407471,
0.15322762727737427,
-0.901658296585083,
0.01634121872484684,
-0.9640524387359619,
-0.086527518928051,
0.686842143535614,
-0.17212969064712524,
-0.265654593706131,
-0.19555608928203583,
0.07074403017759323,
0.10439795255661011,
-0.26522231101989746,
0.10469318181276321,
-0.315618634223938,
-0.41824567317962646,
0.4442535638809204,
-0.05393494293093681,
0.7196428775787354,
0.41856738924980164,
0.03715401515364647,
0.11908423155546188,
-0.5172656774520874,
0.003852525958791375,
0.06272073835134506,
-0.37586545944213867,
-0.7809911966323853,
-0.29367193579673767,
0.39908015727996826,
-0.4703107178211212,
0.49160268902778625,
-0.7318741679191589,
0.27897027134895325,
-0.227306067943573,
0.11129125207662582,
0.41607996821403503,
0.08318359404802322,
0.43776220083236694,
-0.32647520303726196,
0.976184606552124,
-0.2775920629501343,
-0.13097013533115387,
-0.4004201889038086,
-0.42648640275001526,
-0.5108234286308289,
0.015855340287089348,
0.5500414967536926,
0.668489396572113,
-0.5185402035713196,
0.30940693616867065,
-0.13998590409755707,
-0.7711907029151917,
-0.11280320584774017,
-0.016963597387075424,
0.07937712967395782,
0.2713007926940918,
-0.040318239480257034,
-0.19948503375053406,
-0.4877956807613373,
-0.604336678981781,
-0.10021722316741943,
-0.41715237498283386,
-0.30886349081993103,
0.2450038641691208,
0.2706131041049957,
-0.07854882627725601,
1.1569172143936157,
-0.7228203415870667,
-0.32805928587913513,
-0.18683579564094543,
0.43948984146118164,
0.025853842496871948,
0.31993749737739563,
0.3511349856853485,
-0.8579164743423462,
-0.45929697155952454,
0.5134896039962769,
-0.6823471784591675,
-0.3916550278663635,
0.21488554775714874,
-0.08725113421678543,
-0.40635499358177185,
0.2927917540073395,
-0.5608523488044739,
0.0674339160323143,
0.1155494675040245,
-0.2355949878692627,
0.2784454822540283,
-0.1319810152053833,
0.25219982862472534,
-0.9937426447868347,
0.45097121596336365,
-0.10574345290660858,
-0.20460373163223267,
-0.6196163296699524,
-0.2801807224750519,
-0.2607510983943939,
-0.40686365962028503,
0.09965184330940247,
0.44931453466415405,
-0.30452555418014526,
0.36789488792419434,
-0.3027108311653137,
0.17922797799110413,
0.2584364414215088,
0.026060229167342186,
-0.20018033683300018,
0.7908361554145813,
0.2949047088623047,
-0.35604724287986755,
0.30508479475975037,
0.6603760719299316,
-0.12958413362503052,
0.6819658279418945,
-0.7189701199531555,
0.14487992227077484,
-0.4696560204029083,
0.27772200107574463,
-1.130399465560913,
-0.3035236597061157,
0.22698433697223663,
-0.6918017268180847,
-0.08907242864370346,
0.07626776397228241,
0.019916582852602005,
-0.33164042234420776,
-0.3801910877227783,
0.4101886451244354,
0.24200224876403809,
-0.055597949773073196,
0.6189412474632263,
0.3597857654094696,
-0.8729507327079773,
-0.4326416552066803,
-0.3267709016799927,
0.4294525384902954,
-0.2886229157447815,
-0.4178766906261444,
0.05895025655627251,
-0.16831693053245544,
-0.4660503566265106,
-0.01838003098964691,
0.08361726254224777,
-0.25107043981552124,
-0.15904083847999573,
0.09061413258314133,
0.08698558807373047,
-0.011520126834511757,
0.3250179588794708,
-0.0630209892988205,
0.12774358689785004,
0.35029855370521545,
0.08544158190488815,
0.4283442497253418,
-0.024045240134000778,
-0.36917027831077576,
-0.0701356902718544,
0.48144862055778503,
0.6630278825759888,
-0.3093259632587433,
-0.1207047775387764,
0.7690673470497131,
-0.0350118950009346,
-0.020894763991236687,
-0.6758819818496704,
-0.2000153809785843,
-0.46884724497795105,
0.23003660142421722,
-0.3389318287372589,
-1.0228776931762695,
0.6369219422340393,
-0.25304651260375977,
0.28601595759391785,
0.06181235983967781,
0.20437613129615784,
-0.3468376100063324,
1.138413667678833,
0.37219882011413574,
-0.20995169878005981,
0.47913312911987305,
-0.1142764538526535,
0.1313408464193344,
-0.7640665173530579,
-0.6088783740997314,
-0.9705957174301147,
-0.33755892515182495,
-0.040995098650455475,
-0.4242681562900543,
0.7608975768089294,
-0.38330769538879395,
-0.3227802515029907,
-0.2144571989774704,
-0.8087843656539917,
0.29740414023399353,
0.5888990163803101,
0.12416674941778183,
0.3903574049472809,
0.24836771190166473,
0.03097371943295002,
-0.013723215088248253,
-0.562545657157898,
-0.4934886693954468,
0.6202593445777893,
0.05932127684354782,
1.2189844846725464,
0.05942660570144653,
0.7471516728401184,
0.6692258715629578,
0.26448336243629456,
-0.6786748766899109,
0.6697160005569458,
0.26759687066078186,
-0.665112316608429,
-0.362107515335083,
-0.11584263294935226,
-1.29226553440094,
0.4752187132835388,
0.10197971016168594,
-0.6223456859588623,
0.3205648958683014,
0.00048137057456187904,
-0.4742051959037781,
0.06970076262950897,
-0.28330954909324646,
0.2484988570213318,
-0.3619389832019806,
-0.3416426479816437,
-0.2094288468360901,
-0.3777112364768982,
0.4196666181087494,
0.13714297115802765,
-0.01928187906742096,
-0.25927501916885376,
-0.12938684225082397,
0.7798702716827393,
-0.35569244623184204,
0.7792380452156067,
-0.40142717957496643,
0.3186951279640198,
0.19275039434432983,
0.2789309620857239,
0.27666303515434265,
0.24887648224830627,
-0.08797581493854523,
-0.44810211658477783,
0.4604538381099701,
-0.37649255990982056,
-0.5328700542449951,
0.7036229968070984,
-0.8071658611297607,
-0.6211913228034973,
-0.7698922753334045,
-0.4637608528137207,
-0.43063080310821533,
0.26542940735816956,
0.030735298991203308,
0.07218828797340393,
-0.8336515426635742,
0.2709042727947235,
0.844448447227478,
-0.18444107472896576,
0.11894694715738297,
0.3809035122394562,
-0.361061155796051,
-0.35011643171310425,
0.5979702472686768,
-0.30005979537963867,
-0.3623568117618561,
0.45602452754974365,
0.4543507695198059,
-0.29129841923713684,
-0.302492618560791,
-0.305943101644516,
-0.008444108068943024,
-0.477097749710083,
-0.4095637798309326,
-1.0205937623977661,
0.027803193777799606,
-0.3445063531398773,
0.04812683165073395,
0.17181465029716492,
-0.43168577551841736,
-0.10173225402832031,
-0.08565102517604828,
0.5467805862426758,
0.7912967801094055,
0.18757960200309753,
0.3687577247619629,
-0.5753892064094543,
0.18864840269088745,
0.47969430685043335,
0.06093496456742287,
0.013577217236161232,
-0.11792656034231186,
-0.282125860452652,
-0.34469249844551086,
-0.21634820103645325,
-0.8764835596084595,
0.20189985632896423,
0.2609080970287323,
0.5291608572006226,
0.5001317262649536,
0.16000068187713623,
0.44490766525268555,
-0.12790177762508392,
0.8009268641471863,
0.21332894265651703,
-0.2990022301673889,
0.5399870872497559,
-0.7661821842193604,
0.7010788917541504,
0.9678070545196533,
0.42940014600753784,
-0.5637702345848083,
-0.43750911951065063,
-0.452810674905777,
-0.7981085777282715,
0.5211470723152161,
-0.0033985977061092854,
0.11723959445953369,
0.42959240078926086,
0.015618457458913326,
0.2414044886827469,
0.42383772134780884,
-0.3290962278842926,
0.2410423904657364,
-0.1542460024356842,
-0.006762841250747442,
0.1211981549859047,
-0.038637205958366394,
-0.7688689827919006,
-0.37240520119667053,
0.6880303621292114,
-0.26047202944755554,
0.2743362486362457,
0.44634732604026794,
0.05899234861135483,
-0.0036113164387643337,
0.3983074426651001,
0.35459771752357483,
0.7563355565071106,
-0.1947273164987564,
0.027710093185305595,
0.05213077366352081,
-0.5037446618080139,
0.19914749264717102,
0.5039663314819336,
-0.6732317805290222,
0.26367366313934326,
-0.2246702015399933,
0.2400737851858139,
-0.03108765371143818,
-0.4900606870651245,
0.2500714063644409,
-0.44065502285957336,
-0.2566942870616913,
-0.6031027436256409,
0.11031772941350937,
0.38277125358581543,
0.001335641136392951,
0.5333290696144104,
0.30750998854637146,
0.6311416029930115,
0.023776832967996597,
-0.11549053341150284,
0.6399657726287842,
-0.5763219594955444,
-0.21442082524299622,
0.734807014465332,
0.45562314987182617,
-0.46829885244369507,
0.19791290163993835,
0.03648948296904564,
-0.2675439417362213,
0.4948619306087494,
0.0901910737156868,
0.8020952939987183,
-0.25175920128822327,
0.8271003365516663,
0.11479965597391129,
-0.1047159880399704,
0.11899571865797043,
0.29478874802589417,
-0.35964325070381165,
-0.4391429126262665,
-0.05761567875742912,
-0.6164962649345398,
-0.8150677680969238,
0.13641005754470825,
-0.584965705871582,
-0.10232090204954147,
-0.2841181457042694,
-0.2742466628551483,
0.18397173285484314,
-0.04591967910528183,
-0.600651204586029,
0.21469131112098694,
-0.22961454093456268,
0.7672125697135925,
-0.5171705484390259,
0.28663164377212524,
1.3074671030044556,
-0.40636301040649414,
-0.5797715783119202,
-0.5285495519638062,
0.03878961130976677,
-0.3981797695159912,
0.30669304728507996,
-0.19553381204605103,
-0.5226083993911743,
-0.19496777653694153,
-0.470971018075943,
-0.6384006142616272,
0.9506399035453796,
0.005588550120592117,
-0.3199201822280884,
0.19207657873630524,
0.17961838841438293,
0.8886285424232483,
-0.238312229514122,
0.8899569511413574,
0.23946908116340637,
0.6307827234268188,
0.31582337617874146,
-0.5182479023933411,
-0.23106764256954193,
-0.7653130292892456,
-0.027686165645718575,
0.07835651189088821,
-0.7834436297416687,
0.2683824300765991,
0.2590395212173462,
0.12127494066953659,
0.23995119333267212,
0.5563893914222717,
0.24606215953826904,
0.7377114295959473,
0.652003824710846,
0.14882728457450867,
1.0265536308288574,
-0.025795316323637962,
0.5269598960876465,
-0.2841264009475708,
-0.08701581507921219,
0.8135886788368225,
-0.46368372440338135,
0.3470209836959839,
0.2671399712562561,
-0.24403412640094757,
0.8229376077651978,
0.5568794012069702,
0.08926359564065933,
0.1673443764448166,
0.33354705572128296,
-0.9731090664863586,
-0.11516530066728592,
-0.30014070868492126,
-0.37816110253334045,
0.4308071434497833,
0.3183775544166565,
0.007441308815032244,
-0.286603182554245,
0.13310489058494568,
0.050254520028829575,
0.2543472647666931,
-0.053422313183546066,
1.0098834037780762,
-0.167377769947052,
-0.8145979642868042,
-0.06660347431898117,
-0.30451154708862305,
0.5988477468490601,
-0.9578286409378052,
0.16434621810913086,
-0.2848491370677948,
-0.006222248077392578,
-0.4316675066947937,
-0.47629594802856445,
-0.09310272336006165,
-0.111333929002285,
-0.1383991837501526,
-0.2593030035495758,
1.2258601188659668,
-0.35712188482284546,
-0.5555530190467834,
-0.03303886577486992,
0.9295372366905212,
0.3129161298274994,
-0.08690354228019714,
-0.7583819627761841,
0.025809479877352715,
-0.12415091693401337,
-0.5109207630157471,
0.2536134421825409,
0.30675140023231506,
-0.2157895863056183,
0.863381028175354,
0.6457557082176208,
0.39434605836868286,
-0.1752977967262268,
0.4546827971935272,
0.8326258063316345,
-0.5758726596832275,
-0.5970563292503357,
-0.12803521752357483,
0.2901243269443512,
-0.5223626494407654,
-0.3682173490524292,
0.8428146243095398,
0.8619216680526733,
0.3061574101448059,
-0.1876339167356491,
1.3566832542419434,
-0.23990853130817413,
0.8957674503326416,
0.47858336567878723,
0.6507455706596375,
-0.37577763199806213,
0.3083515465259552,
-0.007884079590439796,
-0.8402448296546936,
-0.3583061695098877,
0.42618775367736816,
-0.3366042971611023,
0.16888917982578278,
0.37650296092033386,
0.7761574983596802,
-0.059339769184589386,
0.16433335840702057,
0.06595446914434433,
-0.23980064690113068,
0.5638201236724854,
-0.08591859042644501,
1.0684335231781006,
0.12910819053649902,
0.7661810517311096,
-0.04835103452205658,
-0.2029866874217987,
-0.17414845526218414,
-0.26356059312820435,
-0.7706937789916992,
-0.4117979109287262,
-0.27812284231185913,
0.002694062888622284,
0.3701886236667633,
0.5796574354171753,
0.6426967978477478,
-0.7410549521446228,
-0.6265307664871216,
-0.013016322627663612,
-0.2552827298641205,
-0.1099894642829895,
-0.3239234983921051,
0.15494966506958008,
-0.4798942506313324,
-0.7421775460243225,
0.3364417552947998,
0.399460107088089,
-0.39567917585372925,
-0.6922080516815186,
0.057473089545965195,
-0.22210869193077087,
0.006767665967345238,
0.39071032404899597,
0.5708609223365784,
-0.3803005516529083,
0.24719581007957458,
0.2817351222038269,
-0.17314234375953674,
0.08717837929725647,
1.2237344980239868,
-0.9138314127922058,
0.7009410858154297,
0.885833203792572,
0.8697249293327332,
0.7985879182815552,
0.388444721698761,
0.6698064804077148,
-0.4271209239959717,
-0.2820277810096741,
0.7596746683120728,
-0.1805564910173416,
0.45870083570480347,
-0.6349881291389465,
0.5263347625732422,
-0.14842216670513153,
-1.0287946462631226,
-0.6008391380310059,
-0.03453254699707031,
-1.140297532081604,
-0.24987798929214478,
0.7634075880050659,
-0.026598714292049408,
0.06639377027750015,
-0.6249505281448364,
-0.6816827058792114,
-0.09789493680000305,
-0.7684116363525391,
0.8065934181213379,
0.6190366744995117,
-0.6001465916633606,
-0.3177608847618103,
-0.33251798152923584,
0.49019694328308105,
0.5922626852989197,
-0.8303617238998413,
-0.31430715322494507,
0.49516865611076355,
0.1919855773448944,
0.5267413258552551,
0.850143313407898,
0.07019289582967758,
0.20615185797214508,
-0.2666371464729309,
0.13130955398082733,
-0.06763303279876709,
0.2411564737558365,
-0.12356122583150864,
0.6175240278244019,
0.3627358078956604,
-0.03510907664895058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06357v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06357v2
|
Generalizable Sarcasm Detection Is Just Around The Corner, Of Course!
| 2024-04-09T14:48:32 | 2024-04-10T07:48:08 |
Hyewon Jang, Diego Frassinelli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We tested the robustness of sarcasm detection models by examining their
behavior when fine-tuned on four sarcasm datasets containing varying
characteristics of sarcasm: label source (authors vs. third-party), domain
(social media/online vs. offline conversations/dialogues), style (aggressive
vs. humorous mocking). We tested their prediction performance on the same
dataset (intra-dataset) and across different datasets (cross-dataset). For
intra-dataset predictions, models consistently performed better when fine-tuned
with third-party labels rather than with author labels. For cross-dataset
predictions, most models failed to generalize well to the other datasets,
implying that one type of dataset cannot represent all sorts of sarcasm with
different styles and domains. Compared to the existing datasets, models
fine-tuned on the new dataset we release in this work showed the highest
generalizability to other datasets. With a manual inspection of the datasets
and post-hoc analysis, we attributed the difficulty in generalization to the
fact that sarcasm actually comes in different domains and styles. We argue that
future sarcasm research should take the broad scope of sarcasm into account.
|
[
-0.14743714034557343,
-0.6040419936180115,
0.36325570940971375,
0.4443880021572113,
-0.32990938425064087,
-0.0889119803905487,
-0.24218179285526276,
-0.5541844964027405,
0.18804092705249786,
0.2701804041862488,
-0.5507107377052307,
-0.5617645382881165,
-0.4103286564350128,
0.28265389800071716,
-0.40255922079086304,
1.1837016344070435,
0.4311515688896179,
0.13507038354873657,
-0.04836755245923996,
-0.2778359651565552,
-0.3403782844543457,
-0.5399249196052551,
-0.5983395576477051,
-0.0936688706278801,
0.5495181679725647,
0.15502919256687164,
0.6998883485794067,
0.1821218580007553,
0.7020136117935181,
0.17258745431900024,
-0.041242655366659164,
-0.07402949035167694,
-0.33641889691352844,
0.11086598038673401,
-0.15095922350883484,
-0.5603819489479065,
-0.5577468872070312,
-0.011694510467350483,
0.26052021980285645,
0.40357398986816406,
0.10351656377315521,
0.1901054084300995,
-0.3355013132095337,
0.3565120995044708,
-0.7520557045936584,
0.07016745209693909,
-0.7279419898986816,
-0.03551171347498894,
-0.1935693472623825,
-0.06788257509469986,
-0.5705797076225281,
-0.5310623049736023,
-0.076239213347435,
-0.4556303918361664,
0.4162318706512451,
0.0664902776479721,
0.6587528586387634,
0.29662927985191345,
-0.4290791451931,
-0.2228160947561264,
-0.8268680572509766,
0.7509115934371948,
-0.6633577942848206,
0.06285043060779572,
0.24515597522258759,
0.7854008674621582,
0.13648472726345062,
-0.7510756254196167,
-0.11995747685432434,
-0.22652196884155273,
0.10186885297298431,
-0.016434932127594948,
-0.6215530633926392,
0.01727895811200142,
0.46495047211647034,
0.3018621504306793,
-0.5706172585487366,
-0.18301086127758026,
0.040791645646095276,
-0.24346084892749786,
0.562301754951477,
0.05736349895596504,
0.27034521102905273,
0.07964862883090973,
-0.20343466103076935,
0.1905154436826706,
-0.2260431945323944,
0.23470672965049744,
0.5301278233528137,
0.4164246916770935,
0.0465257465839386,
0.17417798936367035,
-0.448944091796875,
0.262262761592865,
0.02169043757021427,
0.14143523573875427,
0.23870550096035004,
-0.502419114112854,
-0.2977526783943176,
-0.4044788181781769,
0.6052497625350952,
0.35832104086875916,
1.0255799293518066,
-0.23241472244262695,
-0.46582525968551636,
0.23675349354743958,
0.20543605089187622,
-0.39422187209129333,
-0.5109471678733826,
-0.08044931292533875,
-0.3220394551753998,
-0.5287507772445679,
0.03161483630537987,
-0.5785524845123291,
-0.3548017740249634,
-0.023510664701461792,
0.06755457073450089,
-0.14027421176433563,
-0.34479251503944397,
0.07366497814655304,
-0.4899425208568573,
0.027627484872937202,
0.3326612412929535,
-0.5310079455375671,
0.2240752875804901,
0.6752436757087708,
0.6867902874946594,
0.11476144194602966,
-0.05999863147735596,
-0.4376846253871918,
-0.09748189896345139,
-0.1936299055814743,
0.7691770792007446,
-0.786605715751648,
-0.12483464926481247,
-0.02585914358496666,
-0.21991971135139465,
-0.14347009360790253,
-0.47302913665771484,
0.8114466667175293,
-0.39656999707221985,
0.02147241123020649,
-0.381944864988327,
-0.23836645483970642,
0.0010981580708175898,
0.46489280462265015,
-0.8417229652404785,
0.8689025044441223,
0.5496664047241211,
-1.17067289352417,
0.4472109079360962,
-0.511974036693573,
-0.6140643954277039,
-0.006059326231479645,
-0.009367143735289574,
-0.40313565731048584,
0.3195973038673401,
0.35216403007507324,
0.43064627051353455,
-0.4069366157054901,
0.5872982144355774,
-0.7181615829467773,
-0.6723455786705017,
0.6108731627464294,
-0.4519147276878357,
0.9900916218757629,
0.1411503404378891,
-0.5121718645095825,
-0.13646507263183594,
-0.24252575635910034,
0.030616000294685364,
-0.01324448175728321,
-0.08058078587055206,
-0.3402155935764313,
-0.3002716302871704,
0.019647719338536263,
0.2260827273130417,
-0.037244848906993866,
-0.37678974866867065,
-0.03972683474421501,
-0.08742783218622208,
0.3775779902935028,
0.6551848649978638,
-0.31257736682891846,
0.15137113630771637,
-0.38075846433639526,
0.8851689696311951,
0.13828213512897491,
0.6339675784111023,
0.05701562389731407,
-0.6973298192024231,
-0.5161299705505371,
-0.5729084610939026,
0.3993062973022461,
0.6412914991378784,
-0.7687913775444031,
0.2938474416732788,
-0.4666462540626526,
-0.2980584502220154,
-0.13882172107696533,
-0.3332119286060333,
0.5434781908988953,
0.45053762197494507,
0.4082391858100891,
-0.19946172833442688,
-0.31389614939689636,
-0.828137993812561,
-1.0302507877349854,
-0.23560145497322083,
-0.06946609169244766,
0.41676267981529236,
0.4882126450538635,
-0.08850104361772537,
0.9343656897544861,
-0.34776005148887634,
-0.00860074907541275,
-0.30612677335739136,
0.18991748988628387,
-0.13930805027484894,
0.2006436139345169,
0.8728135228157043,
-0.8364313840866089,
-0.6257016062736511,
0.06352299451828003,
-0.724210262298584,
-0.20082101225852966,
0.20059897005558014,
0.04355981573462486,
0.07775919139385223,
0.4731684923171997,
-0.5824123620986938,
0.7787948250770569,
0.05249950289726257,
-0.2460039258003235,
0.8444238305091858,
0.6310567855834961,
0.3019528090953827,
-0.7548723220825195,
0.22496397793293,
0.3125207722187042,
-0.3945283591747284,
-0.8243361115455627,
-0.05548354238271713,
0.015061743557453156,
0.197052463889122,
-0.29574480652809143,
0.6266763210296631,
-0.1765047162771225,
-0.0868513211607933,
0.021829769015312195,
-0.21836966276168823,
-0.04717646539211273,
0.2832987308502197,
-0.5538403391838074,
0.3803647756576538,
0.7580133676528931,
-0.5171551704406738,
0.4643789529800415,
-0.24847140908241272,
-0.1761266589164734,
0.9844930768013,
-0.7240247130393982,
-0.030850030481815338,
0.060888756066560745,
0.9287207126617432,
-1.0657669305801392,
-0.6826497912406921,
0.5916810035705566,
-0.78999924659729,
0.1449516862630844,
-0.29500812292099,
-0.33604395389556885,
-0.6903964877128601,
-0.5789195895195007,
0.6838823556900024,
0.3603271543979645,
-0.45232123136520386,
0.802746057510376,
-0.0029384098015725613,
0.02512933872640133,
-0.9870254397392273,
-1.0370233058929443,
-0.06968037784099579,
-0.5818838477134705,
-0.8359508514404297,
-0.10168422758579254,
-0.21732285618782043,
-0.3957694470882416,
-0.21004828810691833,
-0.14465130865573883,
-0.3784715235233307,
0.1551622897386551,
0.03607725724577904,
0.05161464214324951,
-0.2013207972049713,
0.23345805704593658,
-0.06426692754030228,
0.21022653579711914,
0.21380619704723358,
-0.14077511429786682,
0.24017943441867828,
-0.04371463507413864,
-0.28279000520706177,
-0.8543843030929565,
0.09026232361793518,
0.41558918356895447,
0.17635615170001984,
0.2470662146806717,
0.8416480422019958,
-0.5688599348068237,
-0.48297640681266785,
-0.6519184112548828,
-0.2489430159330368,
-0.4777795672416687,
0.1474853903055191,
-0.3630043566226959,
-0.7635315656661987,
0.7981062531471252,
0.07601557672023773,
-0.1565515398979187,
0.29881414771080017,
0.07699017971754074,
0.1519440859556198,
1.2098854780197144,
0.8087058663368225,
-0.3300425112247467,
0.3632916808128357,
0.04622504115104675,
0.48974543809890747,
-0.5454390048980713,
-0.09872984886169434,
-0.7482424974441528,
-0.5834660530090332,
-0.6102793216705322,
-0.19278939068317413,
-0.03136711195111275,
-0.31825995445251465,
-0.16019700467586517,
0.015493837185204029,
-0.3883529305458069,
0.7512869238853455,
0.3229522407054901,
0.1375095695257187,
0.19499361515045166,
0.20707310736179352,
0.1946348249912262,
0.03382369503378868,
-0.34615692496299744,
-0.26105383038520813,
1.1996634006500244,
0.3849036991596222,
0.6900265216827393,
0.004429088905453682,
0.45807725191116333,
0.5492812991142273,
0.5706526041030884,
-0.8555712699890137,
0.4696226418018341,
-0.536354660987854,
-0.6863915324211121,
-0.09722152352333069,
-0.8174940943717957,
-0.5380282402038574,
0.008084982633590698,
0.4532061517238617,
-0.6814234256744385,
0.0662783533334732,
0.3517886996269226,
-0.2146412432193756,
0.33054789900779724,
-0.832890510559082,
0.6551162004470825,
0.038757674396038055,
0.10601795464754105,
0.2354280650615692,
-0.9832913279533386,
0.6821303367614746,
0.12092532962560654,
0.3145917057991028,
-0.23542097210884094,
0.2201901078224182,
0.46391281485557556,
0.0888628140091896,
0.9496309161186218,
-0.4166170358657837,
0.1785307228565216,
0.42097416520118713,
0.08951330929994583,
0.18296736478805542,
0.08494070917367935,
-0.20465576648712158,
0.02083732560276985,
-0.3536556363105774,
-0.5842381715774536,
-0.5366959571838379,
0.5901871919631958,
-0.4799594581127167,
-0.3364662230014801,
-0.32843706011772156,
-0.5419718027114868,
-0.3447592258453369,
-0.07927680015563965,
0.568433940410614,
0.47477447986602783,
-0.518001139163971,
-0.03419571369886398,
0.5438721179962158,
0.3175019919872284,
0.21095217764377594,
0.12508319318294525,
0.10270663350820541,
-0.3679196536540985,
0.7826944589614868,
-0.1001439243555069,
0.20639848709106445,
0.17411626875400543,
0.20943747460842133,
-0.2269139438867569,
-0.24402274191379547,
-0.09246255457401276,
0.25298771262168884,
-1.0781009197235107,
-0.27255406975746155,
-0.6985012888908386,
-0.010433986783027649,
-0.8190640807151794,
-0.2197272926568985,
-0.01011685375124216,
-0.6934998035430908,
-0.5300266742706299,
0.1331058293581009,
0.2817295789718628,
0.8993959426879883,
-0.03305112570524216,
0.3607868254184723,
-0.21410469710826874,
0.15932834148406982,
0.21166041493415833,
0.1913868933916092,
-0.07286474853754044,
-0.7763931155204773,
-0.021078970283269882,
0.17887704074382782,
-0.21705341339111328,
-0.6726588010787964,
0.19813747704029083,
0.3164709806442261,
0.27770116925239563,
0.3422752022743225,
0.07042741030454636,
0.19751009345054626,
0.0996360182762146,
0.7353783845901489,
0.10697346180677414,
-0.7829453349113464,
0.46694260835647583,
-0.6282775402069092,
0.11000269651412964,
0.6050018072128296,
0.5258235335350037,
-0.2784058153629303,
-0.4705166816711426,
-0.6860446333885193,
-0.6162627339363098,
0.5927883982658386,
0.09395455569028854,
0.3580421209335327,
-0.01125818770378828,
0.5320873260498047,
0.26959139108657837,
0.3941551446914673,
-0.9488786458969116,
0.021292218938469887,
-0.19718284904956818,
-0.3886093497276306,
-0.06091020628809929,
0.05261746793985367,
-0.3198481798171997,
-0.1816987246274948,
0.30184993147850037,
-0.40815189480781555,
0.10528171807527542,
-0.10969092696905136,
-0.0479656457901001,
0.06858690828084946,
0.2408415824174881,
0.4803588390350342,
0.4893004596233368,
-0.11670063436031342,
0.1794666349887848,
-0.12708881497383118,
-0.4125930666923523,
-0.16964130103588104,
-0.03794552758336067,
-0.13742637634277344,
0.15961414575576782,
0.276545912027359,
0.6729870438575745,
0.10437825322151184,
-0.3643597662448883,
0.8162332773208618,
-0.2860125005245209,
-0.14477021992206573,
-0.021332062780857086,
0.11433053016662598,
-0.1915997415781021,
0.17695897817611694,
0.1884346753358841,
0.4785497486591339,
0.5589470863342285,
-0.553200900554657,
0.09742236137390137,
0.572902262210846,
-0.3044471740722656,
-0.8192293643951416,
0.41115838289260864,
0.32241976261138916,
-0.06893431395292282,
0.5799170136451721,
-0.37775155901908875,
-0.8843757510185242,
0.9980209469795227,
0.4749579131603241,
1.2271006107330322,
-0.23311178386211395,
0.598858118057251,
0.150612473487854,
0.4951987564563751,
-0.40225788950920105,
0.37578028440475464,
0.037479374557733536,
-0.43459948897361755,
0.14640504121780396,
-0.24341674149036407,
-0.36445847153663635,
0.07782752811908722,
-0.5937673449516296,
0.4191471040248871,
-0.6975364089012146,
-0.6109779477119446,
0.028322478756308556,
-0.3813953995704651,
-0.8401796221733093,
0.4978770315647125,
0.029996948316693306,
0.956697404384613,
-1.1668580770492554,
0.24165557324886322,
0.7175833582878113,
-0.21067513525485992,
-0.526339590549469,
0.6637517809867859,
0.06480873376131058,
-0.565208375453949,
0.42841532826423645,
0.6218681335449219,
-0.29763463139533997,
-0.13563373684883118,
-0.9886915683746338,
-0.3656429946422577,
0.9460896253585815,
0.6390411257743835,
0.005280641373246908,
-0.11790406703948975,
0.13291583955287933,
0.7691437005996704,
-0.5373765826225281,
0.5613564848899841,
0.7909929156303406,
0.5115717053413391,
0.10721088945865631,
-0.9640312790870667,
-0.05526812747120857,
-0.3184102773666382,
-0.16281388700008392,
-0.1245548352599144,
-0.7176589369773865,
1.208530306816101,
-0.18104188144207,
-0.23918715119361877,
0.1105901449918747,
0.40716496109962463,
-0.014995003119111061,
0.9787971377372742,
0.40636423230171204,
0.7195788621902466,
0.7433918118476868,
-0.3361014127731323,
1.1597867012023926,
0.16456282138824463,
0.3603803217411041,
0.99224454164505,
-0.35660919547080994,
0.39646589756011963,
0.13741075992584229,
0.13119012117385864,
0.48911941051483154,
0.6878878474235535,
0.039941512048244476,
0.29408472776412964,
0.23498809337615967,
-0.23762887716293335,
-0.35644927620887756,
-0.4412510395050049,
-0.5034645199775696,
0.24668945372104645,
0.36893656849861145,
-0.2778168320655823,
0.001994537189602852,
-0.1217503771185875,
0.1635044366121292,
-0.16656729578971863,
-0.38537007570266724,
0.3161431849002838,
-0.050199247896671295,
-0.518918514251709,
0.5113151669502258,
-0.14363639056682587,
0.9935188293457031,
-0.3150486350059509,
0.46618136763572693,
-0.47184640169143677,
0.127129927277565,
-0.35950782895088196,
-0.6100044250488281,
0.1029752716422081,
0.07959641516208649,
0.06732551008462906,
0.3317710757255554,
1.150928258895874,
-0.11215431988239288,
-0.2946350574493408,
0.44163405895233154,
0.3380061089992523,
0.13994446396827698,
-0.40583959221839905,
-0.6964033246040344,
0.06370938569307327,
-0.10007010400295258,
-0.33080053329467773,
0.13521407544612885,
0.8531445264816284,
-0.2538238763809204,
0.8399500846862793,
0.37318548560142517,
-0.3078971803188324,
0.20968937873840332,
0.492703378200531,
1.1191965341567993,
-0.4862656593322754,
-0.688938319683075,
-0.5580821633338928,
0.6857705116271973,
-0.25467029213905334,
-0.5630520582199097,
0.5276404023170471,
0.12944857776165009,
0.75587397813797,
-0.24782367050647736,
1.0032234191894531,
0.15384559333324432,
0.36114707589149475,
-0.19715538620948792,
0.15222488343715668,
-0.6657827496528625,
-0.00625178636983037,
-0.3648214340209961,
-0.7967818975448608,
-0.6409938931465149,
0.3573719263076782,
-0.3835470378398895,
0.8980711698532104,
0.771786093711853,
0.6331217885017395,
-0.38193872570991516,
0.3807697892189026,
0.17720533907413483,
-0.09377723932266235,
0.2274460345506668,
0.43480753898620605,
0.8986002206802368,
-0.2551867663860321,
0.5073740482330322,
-0.23757010698318481,
-0.4845671057701111,
-0.6594556570053101,
-0.6947216391563416,
-1.2661631107330322,
-0.05456756055355072,
-0.4388400614261627,
-0.38032448291778564,
0.1857231706380844,
0.26160088181495667,
0.5284537076950073,
-0.7584066390991211,
0.19423100352287292,
-0.12368699908256531,
0.040915947407484055,
-0.051221705973148346,
-0.3513099253177643,
-0.22349913418293,
-0.22497719526290894,
-0.4276682734489441,
0.02185678854584694,
0.15437209606170654,
-0.1317470371723175,
0.034974802285432816,
0.14659196138381958,
0.0009993506828323007,
0.47077515721321106,
0.3191281259059906,
0.40917056798934937,
-0.6984169483184814,
-0.3394307792186737,
0.2527483105659485,
-0.2918768525123596,
-0.1943701207637787,
1.0217348337173462,
-0.4007265865802765,
0.3904290199279785,
0.6621319055557251,
0.4891221523284912,
-0.2563988268375397,
0.3166229724884033,
0.17450594902038574,
-1.024017095565796,
0.02003645896911621,
0.4844403862953186,
0.11031261831521988,
0.682829737663269,
-0.6598871350288391,
0.6198877096176147,
0.5300583243370056,
-0.7143534421920776,
-1.0512868165969849,
0.4810035824775696,
-0.8957382440567017,
-0.12211597710847855,
1.0713220834732056,
-0.2683630585670471,
-0.07280158996582031,
-0.32532256841659546,
0.14495716989040375,
0.2070186585187912,
-0.570719301700592,
0.792748749256134,
0.7830548286437988,
-0.22910034656524658,
0.3743242919445038,
-0.44404661655426025,
0.6516032814979553,
0.46835678815841675,
-0.8397008180618286,
0.23739364743232727,
0.5412608981132507,
0.3805885314941406,
0.06306581199169159,
0.8778935670852661,
0.04416121914982796,
0.7155460119247437,
-0.2011198103427887,
-0.1997307389974594,
0.36982667446136475,
-0.7325963377952576,
-0.4317340850830078,
-0.10693612694740295,
-0.1613011211156845,
0.09311557561159134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06347v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06347v2
|
RAR-b: Reasoning as Retrieval Benchmark
| 2024-04-09T14:34:48 | 2024-05-12T18:23:41 |
Chenghao Xiao, G Thomas Hudson, Noura Al Moubayed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Semantic textual similartiy (STS) and information retrieval tasks (IR) tasks
have been the two major avenues to record the progress of embedding models in
the past few years. Under the emerging Retrieval-augmented Generation (RAG)
paradigm, we envision the need to evaluate next-level language understanding
abilities of embedding models, and take a conscious look at the reasoning
abilities stored in them. Addressing this, we pose the question: Can retrievers
solve reasoning problems? By transforming reasoning tasks into retrieval tasks,
we find that without specifically trained for reasoning-level language
understanding, current state-of-the-art retriever models may still be far from
being competent for playing the role of assisting LLMs, especially in
reasoning-intensive tasks. Moreover, albeit trained to be aware of
instructions, instruction-aware IR models are often better off without
instructions in inference time for reasoning tasks, posing an overlooked
retriever-LLM behavioral gap for the research community to align. However,
recent decoder-based embedding models show great promise in narrowing the gap,
highlighting the pathway for embedding models to achieve reasoning-level
language understanding. We also show that, although current off-the-shelf
re-ranker models fail on these tasks, injecting reasoning abilities into them
through fine-tuning still appears easier than doing so to bi-encoders, and we
are able to achieve state-of-the-art performance across all tasks by
fine-tuning a reranking model. We release Reasoning as Retrieval Benchmark
(RAR-b), a holistic suite of tasks and settings to evaluate the reasoning
abilities stored in retriever models. RAR-b is available at
https://github.com/gowitheflow-1998/RAR-b.
|
[
-0.2809329330921173,
-0.7176772952079773,
0.6038445830345154,
-0.03957229480147362,
-0.012294202111661434,
0.07340889424085617,
-0.08605167269706726,
-0.5013681650161743,
-0.11499844491481781,
0.4698987305164337,
-0.40772390365600586,
-0.05277536064386368,
-0.837756872177124,
0.2447623759508133,
-0.16921985149383545,
0.5819912552833557,
0.03657921031117439,
0.1448638141155243,
-0.5298383235931396,
-0.06242730841040611,
-0.7333794236183167,
-0.3450075685977936,
-0.25492146611213684,
-0.6883531808853149,
0.5143637657165527,
0.3331836760044098,
0.6218610405921936,
0.6721460223197937,
0.6747103929519653,
0.17208780348300934,
-0.30532434582710266,
0.19033843278884888,
-0.4522306025028229,
0.4854836165904999,
-0.6476974487304688,
-0.5722014307975769,
-0.16343335807323456,
-0.06418424099683762,
0.5095455050468445,
0.6795849204063416,
-0.1727515310049057,
0.18834950029850006,
-0.2006528079509735,
0.7942087054252625,
-0.9684627652168274,
0.10282132029533386,
-0.794884443283081,
-0.1111389622092247,
-0.036026567220687866,
-0.27898794412612915,
-0.8902639150619507,
-0.3405473530292511,
0.000817092543002218,
-0.41194936633110046,
0.21242819726467133,
0.44530194997787476,
1.0314689874649048,
0.6006249189376831,
-0.36023685336112976,
-0.3431899845600128,
-0.6268925070762634,
0.8203279376029968,
-0.34345030784606934,
0.7103455662727356,
0.5505852103233337,
0.4431186020374298,
-0.14544008672237396,
-0.5423480868339539,
-0.3078339099884033,
-0.15759360790252686,
-0.05999261140823364,
0.14708422124385834,
-0.5376441478729248,
-0.23623955249786377,
0.4680546522140503,
0.4136965274810791,
-0.5281882882118225,
-0.24873074889183044,
-0.2143814116716385,
0.13459137082099915,
0.2903004288673401,
0.12919463217258453,
0.1711430549621582,
-0.24267280101776123,
-0.2766542136669159,
-0.14593158662319183,
-0.6297265291213989,
-0.17697499692440033,
-0.008166215382516384,
0.05434347689151764,
0.3399926424026489,
0.9252436757087708,
-0.1844603270292282,
0.6986428499221802,
0.13967010378837585,
0.2286546379327774,
0.09961152076721191,
-0.20895929634571075,
-0.09948444366455078,
-0.15185675024986267,
0.16191533207893372,
-0.009581875056028366,
0.18437126278877258,
-0.34988734126091003,
-0.3951376974582672,
0.15087668597698212,
0.4864133298397064,
-0.6353832483291626,
-0.21158525347709656,
-0.045912206172943115,
-0.6430526971817017,
0.2746753394603729,
-0.05565224587917328,
-0.42704901099205017,
-0.24672797322273254,
-0.2738758623600006,
0.6480331420898438,
-0.592762291431427,
-0.273274689912796,
0.4139330983161926,
-0.38116157054901123,
0.7473341822624207,
0.2334972321987152,
-0.4942092001438141,
0.34818756580352783,
0.8490057587623596,
0.4626753032207489,
0.13458222150802612,
0.029099781066179276,
-0.6698113083839417,
0.21579261124134064,
-0.18237650394439697,
1.1379956007003784,
-1.0628249645233154,
-0.4406698942184448,
-0.10516921430826187,
-0.11334943026304245,
-0.26038435101509094,
-0.7349489331245422,
0.5064074993133545,
-0.8118607997894287,
-0.17613965272903442,
-0.5541723370552063,
-0.7263473272323608,
-0.14615415036678314,
0.5397253632545471,
-0.4824976325035095,
1.1008574962615967,
-0.09503733366727829,
-0.8177893757820129,
0.04328516870737076,
-0.2645725905895233,
-0.2595057785511017,
0.11984103173017502,
-0.05993667617440224,
-0.16954918205738068,
0.3241891860961914,
0.19719207286834717,
0.28952327370643616,
-0.6171748638153076,
0.11705713719129562,
-0.21599282324314117,
-0.5767483115196228,
0.33525678515434265,
-0.11235293745994568,
0.5244141221046448,
0.30764445662498474,
-0.11320602148771286,
-0.34380629658699036,
-0.3456408679485321,
0.19664259254932404,
0.18760782480239868,
-0.2850228548049927,
-0.47870489954948425,
0.09217892587184906,
-0.28585687279701233,
0.13353583216667175,
0.4113674461841583,
-0.6333239674568176,
0.010671980679035187,
-0.29019927978515625,
0.09311917424201965,
0.3269629180431366,
-0.08595273643732071,
0.3736402094364166,
-0.5296167135238647,
0.6139583587646484,
-0.11617404222488403,
-0.16705189645290375,
-0.25990018248558044,
-0.3940899968147278,
-0.6826224327087402,
-0.2069048285484314,
0.28233590722084045,
0.751406729221344,
-0.5948552489280701,
0.28068339824676514,
-0.3880517780780792,
-0.6156448125839233,
-0.7777047157287598,
-0.06277428567409515,
1.0027062892913818,
0.2835896611213684,
0.5886123180389404,
-0.060668088495731354,
-0.34506556391716003,
-0.8850260972976685,
-0.6876152157783508,
-0.04748476669192314,
0.19643422961235046,
0.5636472105979919,
0.6258577108383179,
-0.21104340255260468,
0.7778616547584534,
-0.4264930486679077,
-0.1316400021314621,
-0.5630231499671936,
0.13323074579238892,
0.02454223297536373,
0.506625235080719,
0.08866864442825317,
-0.8279451727867126,
-0.21166706085205078,
0.020089708268642426,
-0.8793812990188599,
-0.1609102189540863,
0.38372159004211426,
-0.0809447169303894,
0.1062568724155426,
0.5679872632026672,
-0.5988127589225769,
0.5003532767295837,
0.16899286210536957,
-0.30995580554008484,
0.41947269439697266,
-0.45885899662971497,
0.1436884105205536,
-0.7664341330528259,
0.1853172481060028,
0.04149480164051056,
-0.0013048478867858648,
-0.4064992070198059,
0.2332524061203003,
0.2521195709705353,
-0.1166735291481018,
-0.0814792662858963,
0.7957079410552979,
-0.7465842962265015,
-0.40483686327934265,
-0.3249773383140564,
0.21250151097774506,
0.2499178647994995,
0.14629769325256348,
0.04830331355333328,
0.6885665059089661,
0.3108895719051361,
-0.4181665778160095,
-0.06666505336761475,
0.5123438239097595,
-0.3591015636920929,
0.6373708248138428,
-0.7153561115264893,
0.41906991600990295,
-0.3336084485054016,
0.248130664229393,
-0.6913968324661255,
0.022014375776052475,
0.12395668774843216,
-0.6477615237236023,
0.45422637462615967,
-0.4739759564399719,
-0.5735655426979065,
-0.1855783611536026,
0.09808507561683655,
0.5037389397621155,
0.5894882678985596,
-0.49815887212753296,
0.909625768661499,
0.2719414532184601,
-0.05873849615454674,
-0.9485372304916382,
-0.7288720011711121,
-0.11545751243829727,
0.14468444883823395,
-0.5717583298683167,
0.5230820178985596,
0.07782622426748276,
-0.3963974118232727,
0.3679618835449219,
-0.42562615871429443,
-0.09043549746274948,
-0.08902766555547714,
0.09568850696086884,
0.021633358672261238,
-0.16237106919288635,
0.09409688413143158,
0.20927898585796356,
-0.43285199999809265,
0.1788841336965561,
-0.007121571805328131,
0.22462037205696106,
-0.1894366443157196,
-0.5120198726654053,
-0.2039559930562973,
0.35225874185562134,
0.18289914727210999,
-0.7639298439025879,
0.7738161683082581,
0.28720274567604065,
-0.3755415976047516,
-0.10273312777280807,
-0.9986357092857361,
-0.1776604950428009,
-0.36691975593566895,
0.18142928183078766,
-0.686631977558136,
-0.9017158150672913,
0.39260122179985046,
-0.30954843759536743,
-0.14351560175418854,
0.146474227309227,
0.26906007528305054,
-0.16530294716358185,
1.0029268264770508,
0.4570062756538391,
0.26313701272010803,
0.2710803151130676,
-0.2913109064102173,
0.3075965344905853,
-1.01198410987854,
-0.6350492835044861,
-0.8894246816635132,
-0.15409110486507416,
-0.39284488558769226,
-0.6543938517570496,
0.13191573321819305,
0.2479649782180786,
-0.3262655735015869,
0.11002208292484283,
-0.44625943899154663,
0.6590646505355835,
0.4736027419567108,
0.2719481289386749,
0.22648444771766663,
-0.23385535180568695,
-0.0672626942396164,
-0.038883183151483536,
-0.5218108296394348,
-0.524170458316803,
0.7506906986236572,
0.11949563026428223,
0.878616452217102,
0.07856638729572296,
0.7547378540039062,
0.2302052080631256,
0.051283955574035645,
-0.6865350604057312,
0.6629149913787842,
-0.2877073884010315,
-0.6801436543464661,
0.13928760588169098,
-0.32144895195961,
-0.8938697576522827,
0.4354793131351471,
-0.09582772850990295,
-0.5886168479919434,
0.27336716651916504,
0.15237024426460266,
0.21939437091350555,
0.1944686323404312,
-0.6357172131538391,
0.9511746764183044,
0.04323730990290642,
-0.335366815328598,
-0.5547415018081665,
-0.6236445307731628,
0.14155815541744232,
0.36121928691864014,
0.14560136198997498,
-0.16274093091487885,
-0.021510781720280647,
0.4879699647426605,
-0.023166006430983543,
0.2612594664096832,
-0.4929233491420746,
0.33977723121643066,
0.1103392243385315,
0.38349398970603943,
0.5571174025535583,
-0.2392573356628418,
-0.31118547916412354,
-0.24039608240127563,
0.08545811474323273,
-0.5841104984283447,
-0.8036713004112244,
0.4509837031364441,
-0.4342859089374542,
-0.9354002475738525,
-0.5274518728256226,
-0.56731116771698,
-0.15591438114643097,
0.05137652903795242,
-0.08194680511951447,
0.6408531069755554,
-0.005935136694461107,
0.5102482438087463,
1.1100188493728638,
-0.2308727204799652,
-0.06755878776311874,
0.6575073599815369,
-0.019202599301934242,
-0.05814094468951225,
0.955685555934906,
-0.20039626955986023,
0.06899207830429077,
0.8864305019378662,
0.10314987599849701,
-0.36700335144996643,
-0.660052478313446,
-0.007375324610620737,
0.412990927696228,
-0.8991594314575195,
-0.4203636050224304,
-0.8459922075271606,
-0.13982869684696198,
-0.03216330707073212,
-0.25690987706184387,
-0.32655030488967896,
-0.21012075245380402,
-0.08916527032852173,
0.00339508056640625,
0.2784220576286316,
0.78736412525177,
-0.09671686589717865,
-0.12242338061332703,
-0.6927298307418823,
0.32838910818099976,
-0.027168678119778633,
0.20281758904457092,
0.04812590777873993,
-0.7775158286094666,
-0.26535123586654663,
-0.06907302886247635,
-0.15260469913482666,
-0.6579518914222717,
0.37865960597991943,
-0.1471177339553833,
0.7624353766441345,
-0.11824040859937668,
0.020364461466670036,
0.6262415647506714,
-0.4867771565914154,
0.381256103515625,
-0.2651924788951874,
-0.8180346488952637,
0.8442257046699524,
-0.1412397027015686,
0.28167974948883057,
0.4976988732814789,
0.38716140389442444,
-0.1292847841978073,
-0.38264328241348267,
-0.4657544493675232,
-0.5381883978843689,
0.717088520526886,
-0.0331631563603878,
-0.07995498180389404,
-0.4226437509059906,
0.47052285075187683,
0.12074828147888184,
-0.20808357000350952,
-0.4340776801109314,
-0.2036028802394867,
-0.24892708659172058,
-0.13640852272510529,
0.2208363115787506,
-0.4446605443954468,
0.3139420449733734,
-0.22254210710525513,
0.6209271550178528,
0.04082365706562996,
0.4878919720649719,
0.16819874942302704,
-0.5598183870315552,
0.07672563195228577,
0.629625141620636,
0.0665234625339508,
0.6516628861427307,
-0.46968135237693787,
0.18258997797966003,
0.030355848371982574,
-0.21388791501522064,
0.12313469499349594,
0.3818452060222626,
0.028591839596629143,
-0.2314823865890503,
0.10303179919719696,
0.4197961091995239,
0.500044584274292,
-0.8113082051277161,
0.4582155644893646,
-0.06311523169279099,
-0.10737718641757965,
-0.22119180858135223,
0.1627347767353058,
0.14576593041419983,
0.5425003170967102,
0.5619906783103943,
0.07098279893398285,
0.13101033866405487,
-0.31656649708747864,
0.09444435685873032,
0.5869646072387695,
-0.3163592517375946,
-0.11439711600542068,
0.6251150369644165,
-0.10133645683526993,
-0.4286384582519531,
0.7162001132965088,
-0.3253987431526184,
-0.30048391222953796,
0.4901421070098877,
0.7526813745498657,
0.6490134000778198,
-0.09759368747472763,
-0.03377247974276543,
0.3766670227050781,
0.28873732686042786,
-0.38096868991851807,
0.48471692204475403,
-0.000009828004294831771,
-0.9014438390731812,
-0.45853373408317566,
-0.4384748637676239,
-0.5583581328392029,
-0.24287326633930206,
-1.154752254486084,
-0.10597237199544907,
-0.2243894785642624,
-0.012962592765688896,
-0.020035214722156525,
0.14062757790088654,
-0.699221670627594,
0.16540728509426117,
-0.23073290288448334,
1.1530239582061768,
-0.4562767744064331,
0.7872311472892761,
0.9172013998031616,
-0.5901510715484619,
-0.4758925139904022,
-0.07980138063430786,
-0.18726445734500885,
-0.6276887059211731,
0.9164550304412842,
0.2962441146373749,
-0.39726564288139343,
0.19368478655815125,
-0.4271920919418335,
-0.7517386078834534,
1.18393075466156,
0.4776572585105896,
-0.3677383363246918,
-0.1559620052576065,
-0.36364617943763733,
0.40061843395233154,
-0.24757809937000275,
0.3809586465358734,
0.5051600337028503,
0.4744653105735779,
0.1330672949552536,
-0.6718254089355469,
0.15923407673835754,
-0.3901293873786926,
0.15035687386989594,
0.2473062425851822,
-0.32893091440200806,
0.600654661655426,
-0.32436904311180115,
-0.2564416527748108,
0.17579513788223267,
0.6287538409233093,
0.575800359249115,
0.35133418440818787,
0.29145553708076477,
0.8597429990768433,
0.5858518481254578,
-0.20115938782691956,
1.3144527673721313,
-0.03386390209197998,
-0.03734598681330681,
0.966025173664093,
-0.4220542311668396,
1.127244234085083,
0.3361479341983795,
0.06235655024647713,
0.7125163078308105,
0.164417564868927,
0.012261536903679371,
0.5801243185997009,
0.10618266463279724,
-0.10595022886991501,
-0.6844590306282043,
-0.2811339199542999,
-0.36511853337287903,
0.4110187590122223,
0.6334515810012817,
-0.16959908604621887,
-0.14393259584903717,
0.005339479073882103,
-0.26175132393836975,
0.5135388374328613,
-0.2505554258823395,
0.7624592185020447,
0.1270758956670761,
-0.7427458167076111,
0.3780525326728821,
-0.07173703610897064,
0.552316427230835,
-0.3663884997367859,
-0.2535557746887207,
-0.23141467571258545,
0.29283449053764343,
0.021584659814834595,
-0.9058319330215454,
0.4462486803531647,
0.07768619060516357,
-0.46007221937179565,
-0.36659950017929077,
1.0105793476104736,
-0.12459016591310501,
-0.23822474479675293,
0.5745466947555542,
0.9123192429542542,
0.25935956835746765,
0.046154335141181946,
-0.7403474450111389,
0.2558515965938568,
-0.20081214606761932,
-0.19035083055496216,
0.4675234854221344,
0.5598341226577759,
0.1197238638997078,
1.0781952142715454,
0.3615097105503082,
-0.1565171629190445,
0.08793427050113678,
0.18438903987407684,
0.8152430653572083,
-0.9622491002082825,
-0.08411898463964462,
-0.43259909749031067,
0.21819517016410828,
0.22225332260131836,
0.184455007314682,
0.5130789279937744,
0.6360206604003906,
0.8845387101173401,
-0.03635945916175842,
0.541836678981781,
-0.2604023218154907,
0.7993236780166626,
-0.46948933601379395,
0.37819918990135193,
-0.6469343900680542,
0.21782523393630981,
-0.06367991119623184,
-0.8191955089569092,
-0.10424508899450302,
0.7429007291793823,
-0.5534307360649109,
0.22087624669075012,
0.7143891453742981,
0.9940198659896851,
-0.05707472190260887,
0.1382247507572174,
0.23261019587516785,
0.03904920071363449,
0.06607197225093842,
0.548179030418396,
1.15260910987854,
-0.40989595651626587,
0.7423660755157471,
0.006974517367780209,
0.03949698805809021,
-0.15007008612155914,
-0.7223756909370422,
-0.8747439384460449,
-0.49542951583862305,
-0.2264125496149063,
-0.2649243474006653,
0.5921704173088074,
0.7695282697677612,
0.26550963521003723,
-0.5529007911682129,
-0.0447542704641819,
-0.013461590744554996,
0.2243509143590927,
-0.4002726674079895,
-0.1889290064573288,
0.15654337406158447,
-0.5025741457939148,
-0.5683463215827942,
0.5717855095863342,
0.2453985959291458,
-0.342553973197937,
0.12855073809623718,
-0.08633872121572495,
-0.4649089574813843,
-0.028601402416825294,
0.3921222984790802,
0.41594991087913513,
-1.08974289894104,
-0.27587175369262695,
0.2622717022895813,
-0.07494182139635086,
-0.02598370797932148,
0.7902028560638428,
-1.0472943782806396,
0.43196040391921997,
0.48223230242729187,
1.049588680267334,
0.7120872735977173,
0.11851239949464798,
0.4978090226650238,
-0.4604404866695404,
-0.19160741567611694,
0.3070707321166992,
0.4386540353298187,
0.35935503244400024,
-0.036291204392910004,
0.5498237013816833,
-0.09256397932767868,
-0.7078283429145813,
-0.9738972187042236,
0.10419636219739914,
-0.9291034936904907,
-0.2914382815361023,
1.0060583353042603,
-0.3316437304019928,
-0.08831281960010529,
-0.37482950091362,
-0.016184508800506592,
0.2687883675098419,
-0.29627612233161926,
0.49030375480651855,
0.4078189432621002,
-0.14225469529628754,
-0.5201488733291626,
-0.4618615210056305,
0.1508062183856964,
0.6510056853294373,
-0.7290420532226562,
0.26924556493759155,
0.4751499891281128,
0.2098708152770996,
0.015603002160787582,
0.5732322931289673,
-0.24568600952625275,
0.45148345828056335,
0.0673971027135849,
-0.1004692018032074,
-0.2652265727519989,
-0.33074960112571716,
-0.10916571319103241,
-0.040859948843717575,
0.2350969761610031,
-0.002041205298155546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06339v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06339v1
|
Finding fake reviews in e-commerce platforms by using hybrid algorithms
| 2024-04-09T14:25:27 | 2024-04-09T14:25:27 |
Mathivanan Periasamy, Rohith Mahadevan, Bagiya Lakshmi S, Raja CSP Raman, Hasan Kumar S, Jasper Jessiman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Sentiment analysis, a vital component in natural language processing, plays a
crucial role in understanding the underlying emotions and opinions expressed in
textual data. In this paper, we propose an innovative ensemble approach for
sentiment analysis for finding fake reviews that amalgamate the predictive
capabilities of Support Vector Machine (SVM), K-Nearest Neighbors (KNN), and
Decision Tree classifiers. Our ensemble architecture strategically combines
these diverse models to capitalize on their strengths while mitigating inherent
weaknesses, thereby achieving superior accuracy and robustness in fake review
prediction. By combining all the models of our classifiers, the predictive
performance is boosted and it also fosters adaptability to varied linguistic
patterns and nuances present in real-world datasets. The metrics accounted for
on fake reviews demonstrate the efficacy and competitiveness of the proposed
ensemble method against traditional single-model approaches. Our findings
underscore the potential of ensemble techniques in advancing the
state-of-the-art in finding fake reviews using hybrid algorithms, with
implications for various applications in different social media and e-platforms
to find the best reviews and neglect the fake ones, eliminating puffery and
bluffs.
|
[
-0.47207534313201904,
-0.6611561179161072,
0.23249226808547974,
0.3118874132633209,
-0.519092857837677,
0.8823238015174866,
0.2860540449619293,
-0.8010224103927612,
0.9763600826263428,
0.2889496982097626,
-0.5524970293045044,
-0.6154040694236755,
-0.21206726133823395,
0.010736735537648201,
-0.42095205187797546,
1.1760740280151367,
0.049400243908166885,
0.5137351155281067,
-0.19508805871009827,
-0.2548231780529022,
-0.021811172366142273,
-0.5543930530548096,
-0.29764071106910706,
0.12993255257606506,
0.24073997139930725,
-0.06990047544240952,
0.4133651852607727,
-0.21992695331573486,
0.057012125849723816,
0.36175355315208435,
0.21570169925689697,
0.5512532591819763,
-0.17707444727420807,
-0.1673346608877182,
0.01489352248609066,
-0.5035309195518494,
-0.44221755862236023,
0.08652021735906601,
0.3257116675376892,
0.08642145246267319,
-0.08702248334884644,
0.22260485589504242,
-0.022718366235494614,
0.5073292851448059,
-0.5472182035446167,
-0.03941783681511879,
-0.7782294750213623,
0.2550559639930725,
0.05308925360441208,
-0.1510208249092102,
-0.41727378964424133,
-0.41389569640159607,
0.0839952901005745,
-0.7230304479598999,
0.334211140871048,
0.37407436966896057,
0.6037319898605347,
-0.18638204038143158,
-0.029971353709697723,
-0.19723524153232574,
-0.9898138642311096,
1.0213505029678345,
-0.4842127561569214,
0.16412726044654846,
-0.08068767189979553,
0.4579712450504303,
0.04004048928618431,
-0.22523246705532074,
-0.8853215575218201,
0.050117239356040955,
-0.1463654786348343,
0.6887413263320923,
-0.423732191324234,
-0.11755892634391785,
-0.5282473564147949,
0.6595369577407837,
-0.555580735206604,
0.09865859150886536,
-0.4062778353691101,
-0.5435774326324463,
0.9288407564163208,
-0.10125356912612915,
0.47418615221977234,
-0.2675476670265198,
-0.7216742038726807,
-0.24683715403079987,
-0.039234597235918045,
0.013667934574186802,
0.9766587018966675,
0.07963034510612488,
0.0028797066770493984,
0.25390174984931946,
-0.18219944834709167,
0.33381372690200806,
0.28921210765838623,
-0.009678239934146404,
0.3793262839317322,
-0.3024725317955017,
-0.39376139640808105,
0.2619202733039856,
0.9880863428115845,
0.3589437007904053,
0.015140035189688206,
-0.054580897092819214,
-0.661176323890686,
0.7828218936920166,
0.537959635257721,
0.02596336230635643,
-0.3016725480556488,
0.493580162525177,
-0.8911527395248413,
-1.0665431022644043,
0.35604768991470337,
-1.350771427154541,
-0.29593005776405334,
-0.25858157873153687,
0.6393773555755615,
-0.21715335547924042,
-0.5398867130279541,
-0.11059536784887314,
-0.5038077235221863,
-0.19768793880939484,
0.1820702701807022,
-0.016482038423419,
0.6239749789237976,
0.6898201107978821,
0.6604335904121399,
-0.07619138062000275,
-0.10489556938409805,
-0.23670808970928192,
-0.3479587137699127,
-0.4812770485877991,
1.1357591152191162,
-0.4444638192653656,
-0.3292286694049835,
0.005754448007792234,
-0.20299440622329712,
-0.22020813822746277,
-0.43416085839271545,
0.8324303030967712,
-0.7336320281028748,
0.3139997124671936,
0.14724797010421753,
-0.5889201164245605,
-0.385149210691452,
0.6344558596611023,
-0.8907778263092041,
1.023864507675171,
-0.21981962025165558,
-0.7389758825302124,
0.3469563126564026,
-0.44917505979537964,
-0.43717703223228455,
0.2569431960582733,
0.2507695257663727,
-0.5804755091667175,
0.4152049720287323,
0.39323750138282776,
0.40990501642227173,
0.3944984972476959,
-0.3714625835418701,
-0.6895674467086792,
-0.23531772196292877,
0.19867251813411713,
-0.2039526104927063,
0.6236025094985962,
0.2711959183216095,
-0.3431808650493622,
0.2454802691936493,
-0.4691348671913147,
0.14913704991340637,
0.08325512707233429,
0.2240467071533203,
-0.6917749643325806,
0.09262537956237793,
0.47454434633255005,
0.12598855793476105,
-0.020339742302894592,
-0.6306664347648621,
0.11297102272510529,
-0.547039270401001,
0.10391313582658768,
0.836859405040741,
0.3865181803703308,
0.5096853375434875,
-0.4820568561553955,
0.8292386531829834,
0.09268243610858917,
0.197684183716774,
0.010345032438635826,
-0.5152763724327087,
-0.46628090739250183,
-0.13023817539215088,
0.4647980332374573,
0.6796607971191406,
-0.9136815667152405,
0.686995804309845,
-0.3049233853816986,
-0.8053498864173889,
-0.844307541847229,
0.012706693261861801,
0.3049498498439789,
0.0555356927216053,
0.23886319994926453,
-0.27183517813682556,
-0.6384928822517395,
-0.8762427568435669,
-0.6497810482978821,
-0.34168118238449097,
0.2663760781288147,
-0.0023737577721476555,
0.37418147921562195,
-0.3633744418621063,
0.76072096824646,
0.2161785066127777,
-0.4026690721511841,
-0.3174763023853302,
0.2151453047990799,
-0.14440183341503143,
0.18366530537605286,
0.4533613324165344,
-0.988206684589386,
-0.4172695577144623,
0.2716711759567261,
-0.22821316123008728,
0.29866430163383484,
-0.16053204238414764,
-0.043395787477493286,
0.6094184517860413,
-0.21958380937576294,
-0.5559367537498474,
0.26126205921173096,
0.7103631496429443,
0.2204701006412506,
0.7256329655647278,
0.1959061324596405,
0.4205321967601776,
-1.0829472541809082,
-0.3471742868423462,
0.49980032444000244,
-0.16942782700061798,
-0.42190489172935486,
0.011428159661591053,
-0.1998092085123062,
0.1311815232038498,
-0.2574147582054138,
0.3826690912246704,
-0.20862074196338654,
-0.0273562204092741,
-0.050997719168663025,
-0.15572205185890198,
-0.06378591060638428,
0.3130171597003937,
0.1858484447002411,
0.15454690158367157,
0.3220254182815552,
-0.3509141206741333,
0.47643348574638367,
-0.05445092171430588,
-0.5801703929901123,
0.7561269402503967,
-0.21823889017105103,
0.15782317519187927,
-0.14715634286403656,
0.9151528477668762,
-1.0854603052139282,
-0.5076174139976501,
0.2812313735485077,
-0.8606647849082947,
-0.05378832295536995,
-0.2640632390975952,
-0.8220755457878113,
-0.7188771367073059,
-0.7671095728874207,
0.11234115064144135,
0.615040123462677,
-0.7692868709564209,
0.9646915197372437,
0.6281424164772034,
0.28050917387008667,
-0.4547174274921417,
-0.45105528831481934,
-0.1827305406332016,
-0.15637484192848206,
-0.8078063726425171,
0.5038834810256958,
0.14888028800487518,
-0.5615607500076294,
-0.059182390570640564,
-0.2234087884426117,
0.1385301798582077,
-0.2475295513868332,
-0.0845397412776947,
0.4293176829814911,
-0.10325084626674652,
0.02224721573293209,
0.20425188541412354,
0.0724099799990654,
-0.006900934502482414,
-0.5869861245155334,
0.45138493180274963,
-0.3337849974632263,
-0.025976229459047318,
-0.5920708775520325,
0.12333778291940689,
0.9174332618713379,
-0.10366147756576538,
0.25658851861953735,
0.5364238619804382,
-0.4870721399784088,
-1.0060584545135498,
-0.7581976652145386,
-0.2927536070346832,
-0.43813472986221313,
0.15970472991466522,
0.1007106825709343,
-0.38844579458236694,
0.4687212407588959,
0.2126135379076004,
0.05639328807592392,
0.3503029942512512,
0.41950875520706177,
-0.36373797059059143,
1.3994864225387573,
0.22406961023807526,
-0.4747673273086548,
0.15911133587360382,
0.020087329670786858,
0.7203894257545471,
-0.16578245162963867,
-0.1702260822057724,
-0.1211240142583847,
-0.6351988315582275,
-0.8902550339698792,
-0.2987825572490692,
0.4843885004520416,
0.0732947438955307,
0.5057244300842285,
0.15644755959510803,
-0.7710888981819153,
0.41961219906806946,
0.7060951590538025,
0.21031048893928528,
0.1719474196434021,
0.5198666453361511,
-0.2333776205778122,
0.2293214201927185,
-0.6778013110160828,
-0.5545061826705933,
0.871631383895874,
0.37617364525794983,
0.24280929565429688,
-0.24976404011249542,
0.5918292999267578,
0.6361880898475647,
0.22784622013568878,
-0.9227828979492188,
0.5675457119941711,
-0.09385661780834198,
-0.4099133610725403,
0.16542643308639526,
-0.28580737113952637,
-0.33600354194641113,
0.22620336711406708,
-0.4223642647266388,
-0.36265453696250916,
-0.11762066185474396,
0.3470413386821747,
-0.5058233141899109,
0.7266157865524292,
-0.6594595313072205,
0.5326694250106812,
-0.5681968927383423,
-0.26403895020484924,
-0.3577178716659546,
-0.45643150806427,
0.7376704216003418,
-0.11491522192955017,
0.6478917598724365,
0.44241759181022644,
0.19726009666919708,
0.6614912748336792,
-0.5216366052627563,
0.9000244140625,
-0.11111452430486679,
0.20317786931991577,
0.6065775752067566,
0.4873145818710327,
0.6282240152359009,
-0.09918332099914551,
0.22177660465240479,
0.2206680029630661,
0.06714071333408356,
-0.38562408089637756,
-0.42630669474601746,
1.0018823146820068,
-0.7076331973075867,
0.07814281433820724,
-0.6734768748283386,
0.16117413341999054,
-0.6137362718582153,
-0.18256711959838867,
0.31368711590766907,
-0.005897354334592819,
-0.20828312635421753,
-0.3010040521621704,
0.5008779168128967,
0.013079476542770863,
0.4695545434951782,
0.11725711822509766,
-0.24617086350917816,
-0.7511756420135498,
1.2681406736373901,
0.051304891705513,
-0.07155565917491913,
0.29312095046043396,
0.4080752730369568,
-0.5040478110313416,
-0.3963293433189392,
-0.7292857766151428,
-0.12233790755271912,
-0.2852647006511688,
-0.11150722950696945,
-0.8030432462692261,
0.17922531068325043,
-0.5105576515197754,
-0.041929345577955246,
-0.30429571866989136,
-0.3728641867637634,
0.1983802169561386,
-0.494208961725235,
0.3532469868659973,
0.8077082633972168,
0.10136011242866516,
0.10708773881196976,
-1.0154211521148682,
0.004278555512428284,
0.2524050772190094,
0.2937697768211365,
0.3236987888813019,
0.18976083397865295,
0.15391382575035095,
0.0973847433924675,
-0.3532780408859253,
-0.8974869251251221,
0.7860817313194275,
-0.3201940059661865,
0.5248337388038635,
0.5634624361991882,
0.09213998168706894,
0.5670163035392761,
0.12363248318433762,
0.9194337725639343,
0.2563628554344177,
-0.7730805277824402,
0.35825276374816895,
-0.5899712443351746,
-0.37309950590133667,
0.30739685893058777,
0.5506462454795837,
-0.32769954204559326,
-0.24273650348186493,
-0.9281455278396606,
-0.6056616306304932,
0.34162482619285583,
0.1717594563961029,
0.1118326410651207,
0.1991291046142578,
-0.22473572194576263,
0.28631192445755005,
0.5117627382278442,
-0.9510724544525146,
-0.05501632019877434,
-0.16021379828453064,
-0.3779612183570862,
0.1080084964632988,
0.08557413518428802,
0.01731797493994236,
-0.21513283252716064,
0.9983919858932495,
-0.04302109405398369,
0.20716015994548798,
0.09312392771244049,
0.10557832568883896,
-0.456874281167984,
0.12775693833827972,
0.21044033765792847,
0.1521109640598297,
0.09308160841464996,
-0.14573965966701508,
0.20994286239147186,
-0.18877539038658142,
-0.2811383903026581,
-0.1664857417345047,
-0.26715773344039917,
0.2929860055446625,
0.29119592905044556,
0.4789630174636841,
0.19173793494701385,
-0.6967923641204834,
0.577918529510498,
0.23234492540359497,
-0.2804246246814728,
-0.6957001090049744,
-0.3187086582183838,
-0.24843308329582214,
-0.20942918956279755,
0.3937201201915741,
0.9046491384506226,
0.25290006399154663,
-0.7493892908096313,
0.23994487524032593,
0.520427942276001,
-0.6067670583724976,
-0.7481653094291687,
0.021364618092775345,
0.30153095722198486,
-0.40057626366615295,
0.20519162714481354,
-0.16273906826972961,
-1.1368612051010132,
0.5114882588386536,
0.07983418554067612,
0.953833281993866,
-0.2676199972629547,
0.698394238948822,
0.19068366289138794,
0.2927647829055786,
-0.2936003804206848,
-0.02949046529829502,
-0.10461252927780151,
-0.8537041544914246,
-0.19837553799152374,
-0.9144361615180969,
-0.20206263661384583,
0.07156383246183395,
-0.3999951183795929,
0.5433347225189209,
-0.6741811037063599,
0.15027065575122833,
-0.06582771241664886,
-0.029491832479834557,
-0.2700521945953369,
0.45051655173301697,
0.27240416407585144,
0.5239667296409607,
-0.9786680340766907,
0.3222826421260834,
0.658549964427948,
-0.309064120054245,
-0.5969924330711365,
0.00942524615675211,
0.43824833631515503,
-0.4952378571033478,
0.014783320017158985,
0.23295874893665314,
-0.32086217403411865,
-0.42376428842544556,
-0.611477792263031,
-0.10018063336610794,
0.5192549228668213,
-0.5517051815986633,
-0.9505000114440918,
0.18008953332901,
-0.11643894761800766,
0.9544567465782166,
-0.3727567791938782,
0.4283754825592041,
0.21717222034931183,
0.45185908675193787,
0.06300371140241623,
-0.7566390633583069,
-0.4206407368183136,
-0.5546411871910095,
-0.44428545236587524,
0.18014274537563324,
-0.7799015045166016,
0.625078558921814,
0.24847346544265747,
-0.2417701780796051,
0.03516070172190666,
0.23997466266155243,
0.5113317966461182,
0.9635561108589172,
0.8344944715499878,
0.7520668506622314,
0.7651374936103821,
0.21127015352249146,
1.288597822189331,
-0.2531684339046478,
0.2914082705974579,
0.6701176762580872,
-0.4156475365161896,
1.1122126579284668,
0.36714115738868713,
-0.10738996416330338,
0.9105085730552673,
0.830954372882843,
-0.2217537760734558,
0.3319094479084015,
0.26199331879615784,
-0.4062391221523285,
-0.5621467232704163,
0.29512014985084534,
0.03497375547885895,
0.24480381608009338,
0.3087000548839569,
-0.44474121928215027,
0.17514143884181976,
-0.047716036438941956,
-0.1836840808391571,
0.2491149604320526,
-0.6483298540115356,
0.8014935851097107,
-0.055963072925806046,
-0.6635997891426086,
-0.04768221825361252,
0.07510662078857422,
1.0845810174942017,
-0.2549051344394684,
-0.12921461462974548,
0.19416768848896027,
0.23646803200244904,
-0.4483754336833954,
-0.31266701221466064,
0.1006767600774765,
-0.25407132506370544,
-0.21496222913265228,
-0.4612492322921753,
0.8364436626434326,
0.03011125698685646,
-1.214821696281433,
0.47268161177635193,
0.5461415648460388,
-0.16231292486190796,
-0.1767052561044693,
-0.7045524716377258,
-0.09424835443496704,
-0.04567071422934532,
0.17727845907211304,
0.23775546252727509,
0.019898060709238052,
-0.34807130694389343,
0.3245786428451538,
0.9967290163040161,
0.06953628361225128,
0.19210229814052582,
-0.30134376883506775,
0.531187891960144,
-0.17826664447784424,
-1.0935542583465576,
-0.562929093837738,
0.3812057673931122,
-0.45559850335121155,
-0.34939834475517273,
0.8720334768295288,
0.7155779600143433,
1.0951826572418213,
-0.3382117450237274,
1.1420186758041382,
0.3118724524974823,
1.002328634262085,
-0.23227563500404358,
1.009413719177246,
-0.4250395596027374,
0.3996875286102295,
-0.522214949131012,
-1.0774316787719727,
-0.19406822323799133,
0.46645504236221313,
-0.40700381994247437,
0.021904457360506058,
0.40521159768104553,
0.8459904193878174,
-0.29826587438583374,
0.6497292518615723,
-0.04948389530181885,
0.3362261652946472,
-0.11327940970659256,
-0.059607360512018204,
1.115958333015442,
-0.5508116483688354,
0.4884244203567505,
-0.5627505779266357,
-0.16723018884658813,
-0.2932821810245514,
-0.37148940563201904,
-0.7756155729293823,
-0.31069719791412354,
-0.4340764284133911,
-0.6961191892623901,
-0.10004390776157379,
1.0819822549819946,
0.897918164730072,
-1.0974664688110352,
-0.03556733578443527,
-0.37361031770706177,
0.1260932981967926,
-0.5199652910232544,
-0.35174086689949036,
0.03679056465625763,
-0.029041891917586327,
-0.8458596467971802,
0.5097712278366089,
0.08702223002910614,
-0.043458327651023865,
-0.5067870020866394,
-0.0011376704787835479,
0.1373300403356552,
0.3871985077857971,
0.5341245532035828,
0.04763766750693321,
-0.9260420799255371,
-0.060853179544210434,
0.06389973312616348,
0.422526478767395,
-0.295982301235199,
0.885206401348114,
-1.0054031610488892,
0.5441548228263855,
0.640270471572876,
0.40194928646087646,
0.250475138425827,
0.18375453352928162,
0.4614979028701782,
-0.5873340964317322,
-0.26990628242492676,
0.7096952795982361,
0.32121390104293823,
0.06338844448328018,
-0.36963212490081787,
-0.02068968489766121,
0.6828754544258118,
-0.04802903160452843,
-0.9483777284622192,
-0.135618194937706,
-1.1858038902282715,
-0.3439027667045593,
0.8767446279525757,
0.34800824522972107,
-0.4912993907928467,
-0.10845260322093964,
-0.26770761609077454,
-0.42454198002815247,
-0.5104983448982239,
1.024558424949646,
0.6791678667068481,
0.012772789224982262,
0.06366761773824692,
-0.005211716517806053,
0.3935142457485199,
0.30502989888191223,
-0.7062772512435913,
-0.5718420147895813,
0.5163716673851013,
0.31161120533943176,
0.584468424320221,
0.15879680216312408,
-0.21283042430877686,
0.3614821135997772,
-0.038287464529275894,
-0.12601733207702637,
0.3318322002887726,
-0.15581004321575165,
-0.19405290484428406,
0.5783599019050598,
-0.7348211407661438,
-0.2163340300321579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06292v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06292v1
|
nEMO: Dataset of Emotional Speech in Polish
| 2024-04-09T13:18:52 | 2024-04-09T13:18:52 |
Iwona Christop
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Speech emotion recognition has become increasingly important in recent years
due to its potential applications in healthcare, customer service, and
personalization of dialogue systems. However, a major issue in this field is
the lack of datasets that adequately represent basic emotional states across
various language families. As datasets covering Slavic languages are rare,
there is a need to address this research gap. This paper presents the
development of nEMO, a novel corpus of emotional speech in Polish. The dataset
comprises over 3 hours of samples recorded with the participation of nine
actors portraying six emotional states: anger, fear, happiness, sadness,
surprise, and a neutral state. The text material used was carefully selected to
represent the phonetics of the Polish language adequately. The corpus is freely
available under the terms of a Creative Commons license (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0).
|
[
-0.47762423753738403,
-0.40102818608283997,
0.32982125878334045,
0.2086741179227829,
-0.17109990119934082,
-0.038132134824991226,
-0.4707903265953064,
-0.5600903630256653,
0.7107503414154053,
0.311488538980484,
-0.9355129599571228,
-0.5344591736793518,
-0.5301225781440735,
0.4858219623565674,
-0.28794947266578674,
0.8106304407119751,
0.13079111278057098,
0.30025264620780945,
0.07157306373119354,
-0.17507551610469818,
-0.12600640952587128,
-0.4529823660850525,
-0.32918816804885864,
-0.18628598749637604,
0.5906875133514404,
0.8439511060714722,
0.41810938715934753,
-0.10562033206224442,
0.257075697183609,
0.30967170000076294,
0.10547900944948196,
0.16429224610328674,
-0.47584107518196106,
0.7191426753997803,
-0.11256225407123566,
-0.3276013433933258,
-0.3996627926826477,
-0.12945660948753357,
0.5841130614280701,
0.24710862338542938,
0.03853414207696915,
-0.042937032878398895,
-0.2974378168582916,
0.7128034830093384,
-0.6389479637145996,
0.1502203792333603,
-0.43889370560646057,
0.4650299549102783,
-0.4556933641433716,
0.023019367828965187,
-0.3431088328361511,
-0.3188113570213318,
0.05702893063426018,
-0.706127405166626,
-0.09531797468662262,
-0.05117247998714447,
0.6012254953384399,
0.007945006713271141,
-0.39134588837623596,
-0.8536117672920227,
-0.6280808448791504,
0.8180285692214966,
-0.8641662001609802,
0.1598890721797943,
0.2910456657409668,
0.20916786789894104,
-0.1275627762079239,
-0.4005835950374603,
-0.6729017496109009,
0.06390561908483505,
0.3285180926322937,
0.31954655051231384,
-0.6230574250221252,
-0.09215458482503891,
0.03148460015654564,
0.2418815791606903,
-0.47173872590065,
-0.13080640137195587,
-0.1239057406783104,
-0.2733728289604187,
0.7522082924842834,
0.5738523602485657,
0.6287288665771484,
-0.231841042637825,
-0.02641092613339424,
-0.2120654284954071,
-0.2343394011259079,
-0.2638443112373352,
0.8744111061096191,
0.6299151182174683,
-0.3521984815597534,
0.6044578552246094,
-0.5524116158485413,
0.5964341163635254,
-0.05901000276207924,
-0.013617121614515781,
0.9168126583099365,
0.1821054220199585,
-0.0008448312291875482,
0.45239266753196716,
0.9044153690338135,
0.43315646052360535,
0.2052481323480606,
0.23293256759643555,
-0.18950948119163513,
0.33903971314430237,
0.2029162347316742,
-0.5500835180282593,
-0.05548882111907005,
0.2100057154893875,
-0.33207276463508606,
-0.24313536286354065,
-0.2105943262577057,
-1.2304893732070923,
-0.4564148783683777,
-0.14890025556087494,
0.0998283177614212,
-0.4877772927284241,
-0.4246346056461334,
0.19984982907772064,
0.19089554250240326,
-0.03425087407231331,
0.16466163098812103,
-1.0130056142807007,
0.3910102844238281,
0.47482138872146606,
0.5957597494125366,
0.3125738203525543,
-0.00988229550421238,
-0.5555108189582825,
-0.4067830741405487,
-0.5774795413017273,
0.7172836065292358,
-0.9591689705848694,
-0.26363828778266907,
0.23734711110591888,
0.2822081446647644,
-0.042873550206422806,
-0.3687921464443207,
0.7114771008491516,
-0.21942995488643646,
0.3307732343673706,
-0.06234065443277359,
-0.5871590971946716,
-0.27702757716178894,
0.20027771592140198,
-0.4778890609741211,
0.6408147811889648,
0.10604562610387802,
-0.5982785820960999,
0.1695200800895691,
-0.7780168056488037,
-0.4004799723625183,
0.24735428392887115,
-0.026378540322184563,
-0.15367096662521362,
0.5202702283859253,
-0.12165635824203491,
0.3621329069137573,
-0.0326027050614357,
-0.04358881339430809,
-0.6091187596321106,
-0.08904989063739777,
0.3414876461029053,
-0.05398273840546608,
0.42721104621887207,
0.7667582035064697,
-0.2382582724094391,
-0.07810094952583313,
-0.8737879395484924,
0.22072671353816986,
0.013045793399214745,
0.05438404530286789,
-0.40683141350746155,
-0.0388171561062336,
0.47561201453208923,
0.6286332607269287,
0.33100444078445435,
-1.1556628942489624,
-0.17914915084838867,
-0.5758404731750488,
0.5230367183685303,
0.2157200276851654,
-0.11728239804506302,
0.40216368436813354,
0.19114172458648682,
0.914472758769989,
-0.12114570289850235,
0.3147876262664795,
0.09855977445840836,
-0.489044725894928,
-0.4466797709465027,
-0.13897386193275452,
0.20250722765922546,
0.4319250285625458,
-0.5741632580757141,
-0.043710626661777496,
0.17843057215213776,
-0.5360023379325867,
-0.569033145904541,
0.012303974479436874,
0.3408384621143341,
0.6196430921554565,
0.04088764265179634,
0.1491180956363678,
-0.9336318969726562,
-0.9942916631698608,
0.03891851007938385,
-0.11632174253463745,
0.14591245353221893,
0.6084245443344116,
0.4666876196861267,
-0.08696667850017548,
0.7141437530517578,
-0.21402029693126678,
-0.3328388035297394,
-0.42498695850372314,
0.10291282087564468,
0.5929926633834839,
0.38862597942352295,
0.39607980847358704,
-0.8760471940040588,
-0.5361037850379944,
0.0642482116818428,
-0.8348646759986877,
-0.2508454918861389,
0.2371235489845276,
-0.20204608142375946,
0.26055359840393066,
0.20053984224796295,
-0.2601870596408844,
0.06922194361686707,
0.9648184776306152,
-0.5712032914161682,
0.16604365408420563,
-0.25678378343582153,
0.06464197486639023,
-1.0926417112350464,
0.07367601990699768,
-0.44082218408584595,
-0.07385901361703873,
-0.8425169587135315,
-0.4024960398674011,
0.06051749363541603,
-0.4302327036857605,
-0.9266031384468079,
0.597510576248169,
-0.31702616810798645,
-0.27606192231178284,
-0.34615039825439453,
0.3590952754020691,
-0.20038944482803345,
0.24810901284217834,
0.11202970892190933,
0.28096672892570496,
0.7381885647773743,
-0.2051764726638794,
0.5157994627952576,
0.7117714881896973,
-0.35708966851234436,
0.9633212089538574,
-0.4541916251182556,
0.284046471118927,
-0.10631134361028671,
-0.018875611945986748,
-0.5725878477096558,
-0.5189157724380493,
0.45592477917671204,
-0.5520559549331665,
-0.003474854165688157,
-0.062240470200777054,
-0.48860061168670654,
-0.12608423829078674,
0.21997769176959991,
0.08978015184402466,
0.4923810064792633,
-0.15545397996902466,
0.7106643915176392,
0.8709964752197266,
-0.6379970908164978,
-0.4453761577606201,
-0.6937588453292847,
0.3810816705226898,
-0.38504889607429504,
-0.6145797967910767,
0.12470105290412903,
-0.03423269838094711,
-0.2726234197616577,
0.22203677892684937,
0.15396293997764587,
-0.20776192843914032,
-0.0779297947883606,
0.6794578433036804,
0.14905332028865814,
-0.08721797168254852,
0.5340099930763245,
0.11706330627202988,
-0.15574926137924194,
-0.0007209013565443456,
0.14062964916229248,
0.7526142001152039,
-0.4915241301059723,
0.15273337066173553,
-0.2973109185695648,
0.6499126553535461,
0.6359617114067078,
-0.02724885381758213,
0.10310862213373184,
0.5805211663246155,
-0.5890252590179443,
-0.22768427431583405,
-0.1968734711408615,
0.18122445046901703,
-0.39644232392311096,
0.2861825227737427,
-0.10853058099746704,
-0.6747896671295166,
0.7689757943153381,
0.0354422889649868,
-0.23843573033809662,
0.36480647325515747,
0.681811511516571,
-0.3569064736366272,
1.0170717239379883,
0.4349699020385742,
-0.18577317893505096,
0.714887261390686,
-0.02029690146446228,
0.04180082678794861,
-0.7798216342926025,
-0.3785170614719391,
-0.49676600098609924,
-0.6868231296539307,
-0.5837646722793579,
-0.14672069251537323,
0.18896032869815826,
-0.594210147857666,
0.06886152923107147,
0.04349939897656441,
-0.22913774847984314,
0.3975848853588104,
0.2818085253238678,
-0.08588241040706635,
-0.07479830086231232,
-0.09716672450304031,
-0.0493643544614315,
-0.23809686303138733,
-0.5371629595756531,
-0.6389253735542297,
0.7433395981788635,
-0.0770486518740654,
0.6280198693275452,
-0.08689878135919571,
0.9403804540634155,
0.14785359799861908,
-0.09030179679393768,
-0.5911087989807129,
0.5495367646217346,
-0.44462838768959045,
-1.020153522491455,
-0.3076220452785492,
-0.2758997678756714,
-0.9160494804382324,
0.04185189679265022,
-0.504430890083313,
-0.6228936910629272,
0.7406539916992188,
0.07987497746944427,
-0.38644811511039734,
-0.0812503919005394,
-0.4072187542915344,
0.7329724431037903,
-0.06678050011396408,
-0.2463182806968689,
-0.40345051884651184,
-0.8054953813552856,
0.016471611335873604,
0.05118115618824959,
0.32951968908309937,
-0.680995523929596,
-0.01780656911432743,
0.9267796277999878,
-0.4537874162197113,
0.687179684638977,
-0.3993065357208252,
0.21898393332958221,
0.2619335651397705,
0.021800192072987556,
0.3966957926750183,
0.18726269900798798,
-0.3382863700389862,
-0.08683161437511444,
-0.14365024864673615,
-0.3308183252811432,
-0.4116078317165375,
0.7453644871711731,
-0.4268246591091156,
0.3935748338699341,
-0.44948112964630127,
-0.6902658343315125,
-0.6463003158569336,
0.39160633087158203,
0.386827677488327,
0.5435344576835632,
-0.48067206144332886,
0.27234116196632385,
0.5321422815322876,
-0.5890401601791382,
0.5558537840843201,
0.7258326411247253,
-0.13951827585697174,
-0.7591256499290466,
0.9251508116722107,
0.07234010845422745,
-0.0666285827755928,
0.04324668273329735,
0.09904544055461884,
-0.29671263694763184,
-0.1294785737991333,
-0.22993654012680054,
0.16966871917247772,
-0.5569419264793396,
-0.17967161536216736,
-0.6696763634681702,
0.19381146132946014,
-0.06928285211324692,
-0.18209990859031677,
-0.6719873547554016,
-0.2928902208805084,
-0.29652100801467896,
-0.3374515473842621,
0.49544599652290344,
0.8187264204025269,
-0.3534142076969147,
-0.10388349741697311,
-0.5521759390830994,
0.1854388266801834,
0.1396026760339737,
0.3656565546989441,
-0.49528875946998596,
-0.11715160310268402,
-0.21005265414714813,
-0.013065814971923828,
0.23662157356739044,
-0.9515498876571655,
1.1502035856246948,
0.4081389307975769,
0.2731867730617523,
0.19898545742034912,
0.5317258238792419,
0.4563741981983185,
-0.4039541780948639,
0.6463527083396912,
0.21739158034324646,
-1.090735673904419,
0.5823107957839966,
-0.41568174958229065,
0.3091718554496765,
0.8665419816970825,
0.1940850168466568,
-0.8307515978813171,
-0.526986300945282,
-0.7188686728477478,
-1.0101897716522217,
0.7530131936073303,
0.17327749729156494,
0.7511206269264221,
-0.236902117729187,
-0.21561644971370697,
0.21878640353679657,
0.3225078880786896,
-0.17351505160331726,
0.1118084043264389,
-0.18347227573394775,
-0.5146665573120117,
-0.21568408608436584,
-0.3354521095752716,
-0.1465918868780136,
0.10856380313634872,
0.6036592721939087,
-0.04915708675980568,
0.4435479938983917,
0.4264121651649475,
-0.31600552797317505,
-0.1663745939731598,
0.29074278473854065,
0.7653929591178894,
0.011756295338273048,
-0.41886013746261597,
0.05640249699354172,
0.17914211750030518,
-0.5133224725723267,
0.11253825575113297,
-0.35077497363090515,
0.09688186645507812,
0.5331559181213379,
0.12309424579143524,
1.0259250402450562,
0.5354254841804504,
-1.0288314819335938,
0.46191704273223877,
-0.0914246216416359,
-0.4659133851528168,
-0.7913710474967957,
-0.2655743956565857,
0.1294299066066742,
0.4681011736392975,
0.08993086963891983,
-0.027212416753172874,
0.5340135097503662,
-0.5569359064102173,
0.1653517186641693,
-0.09462941437959671,
-0.8427197933197021,
-0.4096658229827881,
0.29183706641197205,
0.3338366448879242,
-0.2907394468784332,
0.9916121363639832,
-0.20482958853244781,
-0.38201001286506653,
0.46728864312171936,
0.5069815516471863,
0.9368821978569031,
-0.16775862872600555,
0.47133103013038635,
0.3645560145378113,
-0.06909556686878204,
0.12076883763074875,
1.0495012998580933,
0.22894413769245148,
-0.8222981095314026,
-0.004653455223888159,
-0.3985147476196289,
-0.8486054539680481,
-0.1931057870388031,
-0.8838026523590088,
0.13616830110549927,
-0.5221297144889832,
-0.415190190076828,
-0.41712379455566406,
0.03344759717583656,
-0.49126997590065,
0.21869473159313202,
0.7656053304672241,
0.656518280506134,
-1.0338656902313232,
0.8219063878059387,
0.5950432419776917,
0.034836385399103165,
-0.5942555069923401,
-0.6773369908332825,
0.29955893754959106,
-0.5552266836166382,
0.6999596953392029,
-0.006355690769851208,
-0.17158576846122742,
-0.17283764481544495,
-0.2530710995197296,
-0.9376311302185059,
0.7001118659973145,
0.7020202279090881,
-0.7362151741981506,
0.23387464880943298,
-0.23905080556869507,
0.7882308959960938,
-0.9369925856590271,
0.12237287312746048,
0.13509005308151245,
0.5957605242729187,
-0.1957750916481018,
-0.4644528329372406,
-0.2824676036834717,
-0.8887604475021362,
-0.42428186535835266,
0.12044697999954224,
-0.49470531940460205,
0.8646568655967712,
0.008005887269973755,
-0.22560638189315796,
-0.19593945145606995,
0.4089384377002716,
0.07093610614538193,
0.6160086989402771,
0.6610382199287415,
0.31215962767601013,
0.9324159026145935,
-0.018267538398504257,
0.9639174342155457,
-0.41914165019989014,
0.36086252331733704,
1.1723657846450806,
-0.5411691069602966,
0.9912609457969666,
0.36702030897140503,
0.09434409439563751,
0.6274164915084839,
0.563715398311615,
-0.04572407156229019,
0.6277932524681091,
0.0159438606351614,
-0.44787195324897766,
-0.33388736844062805,
-0.2091524302959442,
-0.43599608540534973,
0.4761381447315216,
0.5203174352645874,
-0.3481820523738861,
-0.05987951532006264,
0.3209901750087738,
-0.006328243296593428,
-0.08202622085809708,
-0.20165342092514038,
0.5561066269874573,
0.020071782171726227,
0.0734405592083931,
0.10503088682889938,
-0.6786258220672607,
0.397075891494751,
-0.47625645995140076,
0.09944730252027512,
-0.24605083465576172,
-0.10612233728170395,
-0.4562033712863922,
-0.6041158437728882,
0.3871091902256012,
0.37486910820007324,
-0.015030264854431152,
-0.3160442113876343,
0.64739590883255,
-0.4240609109401703,
-0.4860517978668213,
0.422992080450058,
0.0224996879696846,
0.5544882416725159,
0.045314811170101166,
-0.5365358591079712,
0.2694947123527527,
-0.31069308519363403,
-0.2944430112838745,
0.21059474349021912,
0.5165801644325256,
0.2761448919773102,
0.6672409772872925,
0.4286770224571228,
0.25186800956726074,
0.13260920345783234,
0.0324450358748436,
0.6198735237121582,
-0.729835033416748,
-0.6808621287345886,
-0.5765050649642944,
0.6097522974014282,
-0.22670011222362518,
-0.7981131076812744,
0.6164343953132629,
0.4741188585758209,
0.5440025329589844,
-0.32234737277030945,
0.6390553712844849,
-0.4726482927799225,
0.5803653001785278,
-0.4137817919254303,
0.633924126625061,
-0.5828578472137451,
-0.3695369064807892,
-0.6650911569595337,
-0.639024555683136,
-0.3341469168663025,
0.7991765141487122,
-0.4362715482711792,
-0.45055273175239563,
0.4396558701992035,
0.5678481459617615,
0.38795143365859985,
0.37522920966148376,
0.7367458343505859,
0.3969760835170746,
-0.1264536827802658,
0.8570533394813538,
1.0073033571243286,
-0.277370423078537,
0.2909160554409027,
-0.37963128089904785,
0.18638229370117188,
-0.5834776163101196,
-0.883726954460144,
-0.19420093297958374,
-0.6517882347106934,
-0.21549813449382782,
-0.11991725116968155,
0.15334968268871307,
1.3193951845169067,
0.7373126745223999,
-0.8367945551872253,
-0.27150222659111023,
0.17388398945331573,
-0.15334978699684143,
-0.07206077128648758,
-0.10963296890258789,
-0.2690271735191345,
-0.33882248401641846,
-1.037406325340271,
0.771049976348877,
0.4803471863269806,
-0.16252774000167847,
0.3565550148487091,
-0.4264666438102722,
0.10701967030763626,
0.07693185657262802,
0.28038328886032104,
0.4926265776157379,
-0.34549450874328613,
-0.020837904885411263,
0.015862151980400085,
0.029279246926307678,
0.14961659908294678,
0.5985140800476074,
-0.5687655210494995,
0.8617842197418213,
0.6725168824195862,
0.08589830249547958,
0.47882145643234253,
-0.5107985734939575,
0.8515968918800354,
-0.2661595642566681,
0.31388214230537415,
0.7838762402534485,
0.5625102519989014,
0.2625446617603302,
-0.2364708036184311,
0.530892550945282,
-0.06360279768705368,
-0.4120289385318756,
-1.0335923433303833,
0.1381499022245407,
-1.2705471515655518,
0.15796062350273132,
0.8268016576766968,
-0.29013288021087646,
-0.3317815661430359,
0.03904270753264427,
-0.27236050367355347,
0.10206945985555649,
-0.8085485696792603,
0.4445802867412567,
0.8832200765609741,
-0.342111200094223,
-0.051191333681344986,
-0.815808892250061,
0.19157840311527252,
0.34400317072868347,
-0.6302235126495361,
0.2540659010410309,
0.624304473400116,
0.34750035405158997,
0.15148232877254486,
0.4714530408382416,
-0.5710892677307129,
0.24930618703365326,
0.28456705808639526,
0.5152530670166016,
0.0596013069152832,
-0.23022210597991943,
-0.7929761409759521,
0.3891565501689911,
-0.3606474995613098,
-0.11920919269323349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06283v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06283v1
|
LLMs' Reading Comprehension Is Affected by Parametric Knowledge and Struggles with Hypothetical Statements
| 2024-04-09T13:08:56 | 2024-04-09T13:08:56 |
Victoria Basmov, Yoav Goldberg, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The task of reading comprehension (RC), often implemented as context-based
question answering (QA), provides a primary means to assess language models'
natural language understanding (NLU) capabilities. Yet, when applied to large
language models (LLMs) with extensive built-in world knowledge, this method can
be deceptive. If the context aligns with the LLMs' internal knowledge, it is
hard to discern whether the models' answers stem from context comprehension or
from LLMs' internal information. Conversely, using data that conflicts with the
models' knowledge creates erroneous trends which distort the results. To
address this issue, we suggest to use RC on imaginary data, based on fictitious
facts and entities. This task is entirely independent of the models' world
knowledge, enabling us to evaluate LLMs' linguistic abilities without the
interference of parametric knowledge. Testing ChatGPT, GPT-4, LLaMA 2 and
Mixtral on such imaginary data, we uncover a class of linguistic phenomena
posing a challenge to current LLMs, involving thinking in terms of alternative,
hypothetical scenarios. While all the models handle simple affirmative and
negative contexts with high accuracy, they are much more prone to error when
dealing with modal and conditional contexts. Crucially, these phenomena also
trigger the LLMs' vulnerability to knowledge-conflicts again. In particular,
while some models prove virtually unaffected by knowledge conflicts in
affirmative and negative contexts, when faced with more semantically involved
modal and conditional environments, they often fail to separate the text from
their internal knowledge.
|
[
-0.4247882664203644,
-0.9261276125907898,
0.9235292077064514,
0.0722365528345108,
-0.30285921692848206,
0.04173215851187706,
0.06438861787319183,
-0.557465672492981,
-0.2557450532913208,
0.5855852961540222,
-0.5154103636741638,
-0.28203627467155457,
-0.5009047985076904,
0.3349539637565613,
-0.3719027042388916,
0.7393964529037476,
-0.18178756535053253,
-0.07381033897399902,
-0.5523158311843872,
-0.32775601744651794,
-0.38071897625923157,
-0.6491330862045288,
-0.4703523516654968,
-0.27276113629341125,
0.6105459332466125,
0.3710862696170807,
0.7324804067611694,
0.30832400918006897,
0.38448259234428406,
0.21124593913555145,
-0.05541175231337547,
0.20171654224395752,
-0.5240642428398132,
0.4330926835536957,
-0.31420424580574036,
-0.878291666507721,
-0.07748322933912277,
0.013034582138061523,
0.5525930523872375,
0.5133965015411377,
0.05155932158231735,
0.004614732228219509,
0.05631030723452568,
0.5153946280479431,
-0.2997325658798218,
0.26111096143722534,
-0.8854732513427734,
-0.19031716883182526,
0.05469431355595589,
-0.4007229208946228,
-0.3046170771121979,
-0.0667446181178093,
0.29320549964904785,
-0.6377261877059937,
0.08336074650287628,
0.6510857343673706,
1.0798457860946655,
0.35506707429885864,
-0.8792353272438049,
-0.5382134914398193,
-0.6529616713523865,
0.44220733642578125,
-0.8556764125823975,
0.34765732288360596,
0.5984499454498291,
0.1945648491382599,
-0.030029192566871643,
-0.3958863317966461,
-1.188132405281067,
-0.6296648383140564,
-0.15568360686302185,
0.16144192218780518,
-0.15548647940158844,
0.04564443230628967,
0.3151029944419861,
0.06452398747205734,
-0.5091373324394226,
-0.014509795233607292,
-0.3992112874984741,
0.04675397649407387,
0.27307605743408203,
0.32335588335990906,
0.6091384291648865,
-0.35092318058013916,
-0.4570825397968292,
-0.11898846179246902,
-0.8574076294898987,
0.2032754272222519,
0.4978260397911072,
0.08929329365491867,
-0.10615617781877518,
0.8730074167251587,
-0.14850664138793945,
0.7841149568557739,
-0.1245131567120552,
-0.2767433822154999,
-0.04391293227672577,
-0.2936203181743622,
-0.19727341830730438,
-0.13846363127231598,
0.4102310240268707,
0.4154278337955475,
0.3124580383300781,
-0.17439782619476318,
-0.3859023451805115,
0.08540704101324081,
0.018363891169428825,
-0.3856159746646881,
0.013877322897315025,
0.2211211770772934,
0.030718963593244553,
-0.037751875817775726,
-0.0865960642695427,
-0.6360520720481873,
-0.2601451277732849,
-0.7040728330612183,
0.620071530342102,
-0.5410965085029602,
-0.07924064993858337,
0.06668127328157425,
-0.04796043783426285,
0.3292022943496704,
0.17902059853076935,
-0.5416283011436462,
0.18920834362506866,
0.636696994304657,
0.728874921798706,
-0.08242304623126984,
-0.28457194566726685,
-0.11839088797569275,
0.33866360783576965,
-0.18163816630840302,
1.0562310218811035,
-0.5922822952270508,
-0.1748114675283432,
-0.14973688125610352,
-0.11224992573261261,
-0.44810521602630615,
-0.3915952742099762,
0.4187922775745392,
-0.7104206681251526,
0.3128867447376251,
-0.5882564187049866,
-0.6617774963378906,
-0.28791069984436035,
0.5191207528114319,
-0.5392963290214539,
0.7290943264961243,
0.11702162772417068,
-1.0211201906204224,
0.24748234450817108,
-0.22347836196422577,
-0.13857200741767883,
-0.2160649299621582,
-0.3039339482784271,
0.027870209887623787,
-0.04342713952064514,
0.1601712554693222,
0.2154833823442459,
-0.5936058759689331,
0.31404203176498413,
-0.4421379268169403,
-0.26197871565818787,
0.5403117537498474,
-0.6150841116905212,
0.6260716319084167,
0.07542172074317932,
-0.151149719953537,
-0.22107337415218353,
-0.5304681658744812,
-0.11806072294712067,
0.03945506364107132,
-0.0018266094848513603,
-0.6454333066940308,
0.11450786888599396,
-0.24650265276432037,
0.40660038590431213,
-0.0782092809677124,
-0.5151770114898682,
0.07589904218912125,
-0.47528645396232605,
0.31661829352378845,
0.7224774360656738,
0.3098208010196686,
0.4348547160625458,
-0.8177884817123413,
0.8258480429649353,
0.2158038169145584,
-0.1365501880645752,
0.07155009359121323,
-0.4682091474533081,
-0.8977328538894653,
-0.09518258273601532,
0.2527448236942291,
0.8602238893508911,
-1.1506924629211426,
-0.05126175656914711,
-0.22815272212028503,
-0.30459117889404297,
-0.3005400598049164,
-0.054042328149080276,
0.2777628004550934,
0.8153532147407532,
0.23534910380840302,
0.48621928691864014,
-0.20768634974956512,
-0.943575382232666,
-0.46734923124313354,
-0.3934873044490814,
0.012918156571686268,
0.433154821395874,
0.4116652011871338,
-0.04463774338364601,
1.0344654321670532,
-0.3511383831501007,
-0.008144496008753777,
-0.31434187293052673,
-0.06825460493564606,
0.03880920261144638,
0.1773243099451065,
0.4731084108352661,
-0.9337344169616699,
-0.4696747660636902,
0.0007920911302790046,
-0.8516156077384949,
-0.32073044776916504,
-0.30167365074157715,
-0.15667621791362762,
0.13731269538402557,
0.6170516610145569,
-0.7133631706237793,
0.2961500585079193,
0.5295045375823975,
-0.5389078259468079,
0.5260498523712158,
-0.21741819381713867,
0.23757362365722656,
-0.9244787096977234,
-0.1668240875005722,
0.17660152912139893,
0.0003249221481382847,
-0.6356068849563599,
0.08464323729276657,
0.18336111307144165,
0.20169110596179962,
-0.4151334762573242,
0.7605130076408386,
-0.4557718336582184,
0.19185109436511993,
-0.010989440605044365,
0.37498408555984497,
0.14899910986423492,
0.3075411319732666,
-0.07430087774991989,
0.7773560881614685,
0.30820661783218384,
-0.6195526123046875,
-0.014905567280948162,
0.12665607035160065,
-0.3384474515914917,
0.5825170278549194,
-0.5009832382202148,
-0.08237514644861221,
-0.46387624740600586,
0.2549777925014496,
-1.001057505607605,
-0.23972082138061523,
0.4378601908683777,
-0.21671545505523682,
0.13996000587940216,
0.06675621122121811,
-0.5906587243080139,
-0.023438835516572,
0.08326227217912674,
0.387313574552536,
0.31526556611061096,
-0.4245491921901703,
0.6443518996238708,
0.2693822979927063,
-0.2445274442434311,
-0.6625441312789917,
-0.7126290202140808,
0.04256964102387428,
-0.5027918815612793,
-0.6715148687362671,
0.21514901518821716,
-0.13272784650325775,
-0.7602944374084473,
0.026997635141015053,
-0.3556235432624817,
-0.1928577423095703,
-0.15786801278591156,
0.15115469694137573,
0.4763488173484802,
-0.29305872321128845,
0.20070381462574005,
0.32137858867645264,
0.09031844139099121,
0.283862829208374,
0.04772251844406128,
0.2154739499092102,
-0.016993848606944084,
-0.4199828505516052,
-0.20978672802448273,
0.20671559870243073,
0.5638675689697266,
0.0223457682877779,
0.9513301849365234,
-0.027414903044700623,
-0.319703072309494,
-0.34716230630874634,
-0.6441253423690796,
-0.08771131932735443,
-0.43864119052886963,
0.18721622228622437,
-0.5726408958435059,
-0.9028928875923157,
0.6407778859138489,
0.3431745171546936,
-0.07141389697790146,
0.2775779366493225,
0.4620293378829956,
-0.23589485883712769,
0.8405776619911194,
0.32535460591316223,
0.2874499261379242,
0.15350942313671112,
0.04424586519598961,
0.5254111289978027,
-0.8345829844474792,
-0.370164155960083,
-0.3976861834526062,
-0.1279197335243225,
-0.26003122329711914,
-0.4480006992816925,
0.3869817852973938,
0.14794515073299408,
-0.047405555844306946,
0.14627547562122345,
0.006956715136766434,
0.5716800689697266,
0.14992263913154602,
0.1501726359128952,
0.5631356835365295,
-0.19045418500900269,
-0.3011963665485382,
-0.057429537177085876,
-0.6681668162345886,
-0.761322021484375,
0.9917699694633484,
0.27341029047966003,
0.6772246956825256,
0.19607068598270416,
0.23966386914253235,
0.12224850058555603,
0.5653244256973267,
-0.5572695732116699,
0.4138410687446594,
0.4032307267189026,
-0.7255107760429382,
-0.1645880490541458,
-0.4006103277206421,
-0.6646498441696167,
0.7514702081680298,
-0.10352779179811478,
-0.619793176651001,
0.40721395611763,
0.1408982276916504,
-0.37677001953125,
0.41084033250808716,
-0.7666253447532654,
0.6349226236343384,
-0.13741245865821838,
0.000850964745040983,
0.07402753084897995,
-0.5414480566978455,
0.6685612201690674,
-0.2773938775062561,
0.40895283222198486,
-0.38476526737213135,
-0.4388599097728729,
0.39608699083328247,
-0.19086694717407227,
0.8324674963951111,
0.11744045466184616,
-0.2378097027540207,
0.4456941485404968,
0.2790977656841278,
0.3886880874633789,
0.4892220199108124,
-0.0929611474275589,
0.0012679236242547631,
0.6392212510108948,
-0.3737129271030426,
-0.7258024215698242,
0.6257500052452087,
-0.7442383766174316,
-0.9540908336639404,
-0.739944577217102,
-0.8365853428840637,
-0.6190815567970276,
-0.07372229546308517,
0.27733537554740906,
0.3884739577770233,
-0.07996483147144318,
-0.022771406918764114,
0.679277241230011,
-0.2590564787387848,
0.08052327483892441,
0.7905039191246033,
-0.16230377554893494,
0.016016412526369095,
0.7773030996322632,
0.17688539624214172,
0.6109031438827515,
0.4008173644542694,
0.06295514106750488,
-0.4465081989765167,
-0.6192113757133484,
-0.2061544507741928,
0.40665173530578613,
-0.8800936937332153,
-0.21071693301200867,
-0.7397016286849976,
-0.12764737010002136,
-0.16557928919792175,
0.07155168801546097,
0.3330113887786865,
-0.24048805236816406,
-0.4166458249092102,
-0.14940007030963898,
0.13986726105213165,
0.7169180512428284,
0.14088433980941772,
0.17956028878688812,
-0.6111934781074524,
0.4086448550224304,
0.23457106947898865,
-0.22854003310203552,
-0.0299567598849535,
-0.8201541900634766,
0.1493050754070282,
0.2160598337650299,
-0.10321053862571716,
-1.2340346574783325,
0.554777204990387,
0.09454028308391571,
0.5514147877693176,
0.21558095514774323,
0.33973753452301025,
0.5423629879951477,
-0.4903400242328644,
0.49252548813819885,
-0.2655000686645508,
-0.8965848684310913,
0.01928594894707203,
-0.5675066113471985,
0.20713463425636292,
0.49442970752716064,
0.5991944670677185,
-0.6948498487472534,
-0.8278218507766724,
-0.49355077743530273,
-0.6540867686271667,
0.6108876466751099,
0.1930570900440216,
0.291716068983078,
-0.1325133889913559,
0.7433441281318665,
0.09604547917842865,
0.0033696473110467196,
-0.8760170936584473,
-0.12559281289577484,
0.10820378363132477,
-0.20861899852752686,
-0.0054178982973098755,
-0.34779635071754456,
-0.10780394077301025,
-0.3362548053264618,
0.5125260949134827,
-0.07802010327577591,
0.09329009056091309,
0.4023261070251465,
-0.34230607748031616,
-0.07520578056573868,
0.1351739913225174,
0.6391701102256775,
1.1563407182693481,
-0.012376880273222923,
0.2843635380268097,
0.37759163975715637,
-0.1463627815246582,
0.27740201354026794,
-0.18163830041885376,
-0.27836713194847107,
-0.32917505502700806,
0.501807689666748,
0.5730380415916443,
0.22279946506023407,
-0.9905187487602234,
0.4525546729564667,
-0.15524417161941528,
-0.2766277492046356,
-0.34696096181869507,
0.04150955379009247,
0.3750079870223999,
0.3052186965942383,
0.3382050096988678,
0.14827869832515717,
-0.13178923726081848,
-0.5772883892059326,
0.2934357523918152,
0.2906491458415985,
-0.15471410751342773,
-0.3327718675136566,
0.4174782633781433,
-0.12570777535438538,
-0.07386209070682526,
0.5170852541923523,
-0.3167795240879059,
-0.5489212274551392,
0.8297523856163025,
0.7546262741088867,
0.26733314990997314,
-0.008409533649682999,
0.17451079189777374,
0.11035124212503433,
0.5521612167358398,
0.12409733235836029,
0.11009057611227036,
0.2784968316555023,
-1.0243825912475586,
-0.39131155610084534,
-0.45953333377838135,
-0.34259921312332153,
0.15550588071346283,
-0.6598017811775208,
0.11224019527435303,
-0.4360286295413971,
0.15220850706100464,
-0.11606436967849731,
-0.2624114155769348,
-0.6740685701370239,
0.18913023173809052,
0.1358499825000763,
0.8589959144592285,
-0.8605948090553284,
1.0136961936950684,
0.38892024755477905,
-0.36289745569229126,
-0.6798006296157837,
0.537360429763794,
0.012818043120205402,
-0.7384971976280212,
0.8050473928451538,
0.0880289077758789,
-0.006176397204399109,
0.02400236204266548,
-0.29187336564064026,
-0.9392880201339722,
0.8809410929679871,
0.4875621497631073,
-0.522550642490387,
-0.2933034300804138,
0.1544753760099411,
0.6156747937202454,
-0.30543607473373413,
0.2834544777870178,
0.6922357678413391,
0.5920773148536682,
-0.03640425577759743,
-0.6476191282272339,
0.1332579106092453,
-0.011087181977927685,
-0.14132727682590485,
-0.01636647805571556,
-0.6053851246833801,
0.8682786226272583,
-0.1509006917476654,
-0.3112378418445587,
-0.08738488703966141,
0.7694090604782104,
0.2543708086013794,
0.28060612082481384,
0.6157220602035522,
0.395598441362381,
0.6673592925071716,
0.004299181047827005,
1.2184070348739624,
-0.3220925033092499,
0.2419614940881729,
0.8992553949356079,
-0.30190667510032654,
0.9173493981361389,
0.5208426117897034,
-0.09001988917589188,
0.46902525424957275,
0.7485568523406982,
0.3160301446914673,
0.3713665306568146,
0.12920288741588593,
-0.46615737676620483,
-0.4159236550331116,
0.21699537336826324,
-0.19275328516960144,
0.3242994248867035,
0.5809445381164551,
0.07840406149625778,
-0.2638949751853943,
0.1439943015575409,
0.07382263988256454,
0.13310986757278442,
0.09436295926570892,
0.4258043169975281,
0.32815617322921753,
-0.7529719471931458,
0.5955506563186646,
0.10190310329198837,
0.549452006816864,
-0.485891193151474,
0.03374883905053139,
-0.21299628913402557,
-0.08574084937572479,
-0.010512110777199268,
-0.7772762179374695,
0.4097355902194977,
-0.10000373423099518,
-0.06319788843393326,
0.06130810081958771,
0.40246516466140747,
-0.45166972279548645,
-0.525970995426178,
0.31398001313209534,
0.8095719814300537,
-0.07049320638179779,
-0.21210525929927826,
-0.8300747871398926,
0.00830303318798542,
0.24818457663059235,
-0.33447110652923584,
0.467864990234375,
0.6185626983642578,
-0.045335762202739716,
0.9530062675476074,
0.6146539449691772,
-0.009514115750789642,
0.10656863451004028,
-0.19866710901260376,
0.8507785797119141,
-0.5973839163780212,
-0.4822109639644623,
-0.801563024520874,
0.10301297903060913,
0.11396881192922592,
-0.4395740032196045,
0.8322699666023254,
0.14268983900547028,
0.7031806111335754,
0.22149667143821716,
0.6901824474334717,
-0.05551232397556305,
0.5276428461074829,
-0.7548860311508179,
0.6408252120018005,
-0.5584471225738525,
0.5485741496086121,
0.0016478170873597264,
-0.9075391888618469,
-0.22999700903892517,
0.4035309851169586,
-0.6884630918502808,
-0.06082921847701073,
1.0502980947494507,
0.7682262659072876,
-0.10131252557039261,
0.2336522787809372,
0.510434627532959,
0.3336324989795685,
0.18961800634860992,
0.4948916733264923,
1.147154450416565,
-0.16867384314537048,
0.46154919266700745,
-0.23987556993961334,
-0.15555554628372192,
0.10954268276691437,
-0.704552173614502,
-1.0894159078598022,
-0.7229233980178833,
-0.07232953608036041,
-0.29093554615974426,
0.22815199196338654,
0.6498040556907654,
0.204928919672966,
-0.7223219871520996,
-0.04154542088508606,
-0.011675274930894375,
0.21168716251850128,
0.21823781728744507,
-0.26876312494277954,
0.19971971213817596,
-0.43774569034576416,
-0.7766062617301941,
0.3680553436279297,
0.11683709919452667,
0.10727740079164505,
-0.2735808491706848,
0.02165774628520012,
-0.24550200998783112,
0.485136479139328,
0.5022096037864685,
0.23543612658977509,
-1.007907509803772,
-0.3966056704521179,
0.022559739649295807,
-0.15675616264343262,
-0.01596345379948616,
0.6621536612510681,
-0.8046911954879761,
0.16517366468906403,
0.6127339005470276,
0.562336802482605,
0.09646300971508026,
0.24374160170555115,
0.6658920645713806,
-0.2479483187198639,
0.1689995676279068,
0.4303179681301117,
0.3583594560623169,
0.20533935725688934,
-0.5446951985359192,
0.09001973271369934,
0.2604868710041046,
-0.5857550501823425,
-0.8825468420982361,
0.1542518138885498,
-0.8365691900253296,
-0.5329384803771973,
1.2989143133163452,
-0.10662669688463211,
-0.26938700675964355,
-0.35909464955329895,
-0.21204674243927002,
-0.04972189664840698,
-0.1492524892091751,
0.7125345468521118,
1.038244366645813,
-0.2416229248046875,
-0.12321529537439346,
-1.09861421585083,
0.4814987778663635,
0.5905584692955017,
-0.8021896481513977,
-0.007412005681544542,
0.44936853647232056,
0.5397091507911682,
-0.32744237780570984,
0.35218361020088196,
0.09663454443216324,
-0.10837589204311371,
0.019998490810394287,
-0.4103236496448517,
0.08532369881868362,
-0.2648331820964813,
-0.23847731947898865,
0.09080523252487183,
0.06272008270025253,
0.46874329447746277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06278v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06278v1
|
Dimensionality Reduction in Sentence Transformer Vector Databases with Fast Fourier Transform
| 2024-04-09T13:02:22 | 2024-04-09T13:02:22 |
Vitaly Bulgakov, Alec Segal
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Dimensionality reduction in vector databases is pivotal for streamlining AI
data management, enabling efficient storage, faster computation, and improved
model performance. This paper explores the benefits of reducing vector database
dimensions, with a focus on computational efficiency and overcoming the curse
of dimensionality. We introduce a novel application of Fast Fourier Transform
(FFT) to dimensionality reduction, a method previously underexploited in this
context. By demonstrating its utility across various AI domains, including
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) models and image processing, this
FFT-based approach promises to improve data retrieval processes and enhance the
efficiency and scalability of AI solutions. The incorporation of FFT may not
only optimize operations in real-time processing and recommendation systems but
also extend to advanced image processing techniques, where dimensionality
reduction can significantly improve performance and analysis efficiency. This
paper advocates for the broader adoption of FFT in vector database management,
marking a significant stride towards addressing the challenges of data volume
and complexity in AI research and applications. Unlike many existing
approaches, we directly handle the embedding vectors produced by the model
after processing a test input.
|
[
-0.7663493156433105,
-0.8045681715011597,
0.4578237235546112,
0.28647032380104065,
-0.26850244402885437,
-0.01778576336801052,
0.14397379755973816,
-0.3243739604949951,
0.2826341688632965,
0.38599714636802673,
-0.42537444829940796,
-0.40682294964790344,
-0.45489659905433655,
-0.1012156531214714,
-0.7228432893753052,
0.662224531173706,
0.042043618857860565,
-0.006327206734567881,
-0.6857666969299316,
-0.28713974356651306,
-0.5833815336227417,
-0.5323216319084167,
-0.7445295453071594,
-0.07467945665121078,
0.33073633909225464,
0.20573939383029938,
0.8143139481544495,
1.103062629699707,
1.2193644046783447,
0.28296011686325073,
0.24896319210529327,
-0.1316322237253189,
-0.46817654371261597,
0.172259122133255,
0.020109523087739944,
-0.4657353162765503,
-0.3289892077445984,
0.0874461680650711,
0.9395750761032104,
0.6743350028991699,
0.030081776902079582,
0.24923504889011383,
-0.4098789393901825,
0.9048505425453186,
-0.508242130279541,
0.5978291034698486,
-0.21235378086566925,
0.5467796325683594,
-0.47158241271972656,
-0.20371626317501068,
-0.11975722014904022,
-0.43116241693496704,
-0.0647469311952591,
-0.6326865553855896,
0.5317139625549316,
0.14620982110500336,
0.4827854335308075,
0.8556433320045471,
-0.5992181897163391,
0.22757740318775177,
-1.3262696266174316,
0.5543943643569946,
-0.07751258462667465,
0.8779488205909729,
0.13410112261772156,
0.520488440990448,
-0.03941294550895691,
-0.7365627884864807,
-0.8375450968742371,
0.23382416367530823,
-0.20232738554477692,
-0.07612522691488266,
-0.35529637336730957,
-0.08452694118022919,
0.41552647948265076,
0.4595614969730377,
-0.7553683519363403,
-0.11087218672037125,
-0.4534136652946472,
-0.12131422013044357,
0.6030580997467041,
0.10679051280021667,
-0.06472711265087128,
-0.2059236466884613,
-0.2793543338775635,
-0.53229159116745,
-0.5164002776145935,
0.32145339250564575,
0.072993703186512,
0.027169520035386086,
0.32108786702156067,
0.678149402141571,
0.17916709184646606,
0.21085740625858307,
-0.08256708830595016,
0.17017588019371033,
0.20282089710235596,
-0.21989233791828156,
-0.05830522999167442,
-0.16787053644657135,
0.6468784213066101,
0.21835364401340485,
-0.240897074341774,
0.007613533176481724,
-0.2219041883945465,
0.13409096002578735,
0.43630415201187134,
-0.941306471824646,
-0.2481311708688736,
0.1438220590353012,
-0.7467583417892456,
-0.22476015985012054,
0.05306078493595123,
-0.8029731512069702,
-0.4537844955921173,
-0.017015423625707626,
0.2794671654701233,
-0.6779372692108154,
0.11755938082933426,
-0.03729863837361336,
-0.0976695641875267,
0.49904897809028625,
0.2491750866174698,
-0.7174314856529236,
0.34980109333992004,
0.9732685685157776,
0.9471127390861511,
-0.3729763627052307,
0.15110903978347778,
-0.8434603810310364,
-0.01900375448167324,
-0.538140058517456,
0.7697634100914001,
-0.5570463538169861,
-0.5759601593017578,
-0.2806697487831116,
-0.48443126678466797,
0.028077341616153717,
-0.5280296802520752,
0.8946393132209778,
-0.42653799057006836,
0.06295103579759598,
-0.16592812538146973,
-0.5595398545265198,
-0.3924667239189148,
-0.07613414525985718,
-0.8303127288818359,
1.020093321800232,
0.15306736528873444,
-0.49167874455451965,
0.3570004999637604,
-0.6955486536026001,
-0.5310543179512024,
0.060397807508707047,
-0.1485740691423416,
-0.7688673138618469,
0.33339378237724304,
0.6319796442985535,
0.7347908616065979,
-0.45265066623687744,
-0.13665804266929626,
-0.10906590521335602,
-0.7140346169471741,
0.06893323361873627,
-0.32198721170425415,
0.24567659199237823,
0.21500977873802185,
0.0910152718424797,
-0.02073770947754383,
-0.9417147636413574,
-0.1868865042924881,
0.2903936505317688,
-0.2080199122428894,
-0.47657254338264465,
0.20318099856376648,
0.12129343301057816,
-0.023749683052301407,
-0.05629171058535576,
-0.5240049958229065,
0.26248762011528015,
-0.5249540209770203,
0.3217929005622864,
0.5400206446647644,
-0.12322994321584702,
0.7019239068031311,
-0.16381151974201202,
0.5916598439216614,
-0.0792393833398819,
0.20389388501644135,
-0.03215066343545914,
-0.24402974545955658,
-0.6848413348197937,
-0.5853242874145508,
0.3241975009441376,
0.8012142777442932,
-1.1785560846328735,
0.37223193049430847,
-0.5523954629898071,
-0.3500102162361145,
-0.6583142280578613,
-0.3576827943325043,
0.09819995611906052,
0.42155513167381287,
0.5502543449401855,
-0.3006253242492676,
-0.27365055680274963,
-1.0831506252288818,
-0.1976696103811264,
-0.14146004617214203,
-0.43939071893692017,
0.3024812936782837,
0.32520392537117004,
-0.31511130928993225,
0.9187151789665222,
-0.7520905137062073,
-0.6483052968978882,
0.09289651364088058,
0.13322556018829346,
-0.0030856162775307894,
0.6000491976737976,
0.8589510917663574,
-1.1209381818771362,
-0.284787118434906,
-0.07125148177146912,
-0.6888393759727478,
0.27019616961479187,
-0.18347778916358948,
0.007978643290698528,
0.15593118965625763,
0.4791056215763092,
-0.7513125538825989,
0.6064059734344482,
0.14541412889957428,
-0.30571916699409485,
0.07265035063028336,
-0.23678238689899445,
0.28877827525138855,
-0.8004675507545471,
-0.22632722556591034,
0.09186582267284393,
-0.3219115436077118,
-0.7445712089538574,
-0.21027114987373352,
0.134113609790802,
-0.3121448755264282,
-0.13424138724803925,
0.11610502004623413,
-0.06712788343429565,
-0.24016307294368744,
0.2695375382900238,
-0.3846698999404907,
-0.047482192516326904,
0.46805572509765625,
-0.2947216033935547,
0.9101959466934204,
0.2895318567752838,
-0.5071619749069214,
0.4177030622959137,
0.931013822555542,
0.04436219483613968,
0.9969030618667603,
-0.671063244342804,
0.10509416460990906,
-0.5148415565490723,
0.257634699344635,
-0.6720123291015625,
0.11070074141025543,
0.20288467407226562,
-0.4599323868751526,
0.2865619659423828,
0.06221466884016991,
-0.3628920912742615,
-0.41086840629577637,
-0.6751028895378113,
0.4124273657798767,
0.5202161073684692,
-0.6837457418441772,
0.8975412845611572,
0.40442413091659546,
-0.09420830756425858,
-0.5427607893943787,
-0.8198864459991455,
-0.11284807324409485,
-0.22115458548069,
-0.8586063981056213,
0.5745185017585754,
-0.08900447189807892,
-0.083055779337883,
0.1290254294872284,
-0.07346335798501968,
-0.0002686690422706306,
-0.1341133564710617,
0.08674650639295578,
0.12015460431575775,
-0.17712631821632385,
0.4302935004234314,
0.2554433345794678,
-0.24824637174606323,
0.19048939645290375,
-0.2842131555080414,
0.33079850673675537,
-0.171113058924675,
-0.17045770585536957,
-0.5464609861373901,
0.6185754537582397,
0.544208824634552,
-0.6492599844932556,
0.8683128356933594,
1.0365663766860962,
-0.3303532302379608,
-0.38287755846977234,
-0.4027673304080963,
-0.05426013842225075,
-0.4731992781162262,
0.30390438437461853,
-0.3532176613807678,
-0.9933459162712097,
0.47010430693626404,
-0.14674025774002075,
-0.11387187987565994,
0.6344431638717651,
0.10778356343507767,
-0.30958178639411926,
0.9574345350265503,
0.7070183753967285,
0.07560703158378601,
0.6392234563827515,
-0.5264723300933838,
0.7183806300163269,
-0.6548035144805908,
-0.1154794991016388,
-0.5455488562583923,
-0.3189453184604645,
-0.6484366655349731,
-0.819537341594696,
0.7296739220619202,
-0.3638261556625366,
-0.19045107066631317,
-0.07691942900419235,
-0.6164634227752686,
0.5052984356880188,
0.5199208855628967,
-0.17699171602725983,
0.07663816958665848,
0.050469283014535904,
0.335376501083374,
-0.19676461815834045,
-0.45181941986083984,
0.05892804265022278,
0.9093148708343506,
0.3878330588340759,
0.2654598355293274,
0.04569272696971893,
0.7193989753723145,
0.60395747423172,
-0.23105108737945557,
-0.8476594090461731,
0.4488450288772583,
-0.6186789274215698,
0.0711297020316124,
-0.5849279165267944,
-0.7763984203338623,
-0.7388895153999329,
0.38534244894981384,
-0.6737238168716431,
-0.12043049931526184,
0.44989314675331116,
-0.1049932986497879,
-0.43781059980392456,
0.41339921951293945,
-0.654738187789917,
0.6248969435691833,
0.20178377628326416,
-0.04105221852660179,
-0.20594733953475952,
-0.38088151812553406,
0.351248562335968,
-0.3812822699546814,
0.15243636071681976,
-0.03789462521672249,
0.07735103368759155,
0.9349270462989807,
-0.6185306310653687,
0.1347629725933075,
-0.3539285361766815,
0.11662856489419937,
-0.013107123784720898,
0.2145642787218094,
0.6492191553115845,
0.16249632835388184,
0.04800470173358917,
0.31255289912223816,
0.22704578936100006,
-0.15093444287776947,
-0.9571088552474976,
0.5683928728103638,
-0.51637864112854,
-0.4990330636501312,
-0.2828737497329712,
-0.8150634169578552,
-0.2749725580215454,
0.061533596366643906,
-0.0580974742770195,
0.3454802334308624,
-0.4088189899921417,
0.5824218988418579,
0.8141750693321228,
-0.4835893511772156,
0.08821512758731842,
-0.03685725852847099,
-0.15332363545894623,
-0.17809532582759857,
1.095088005065918,
0.3994045853614807,
-0.41092973947525024,
0.4664965867996216,
0.14013631641864777,
-0.3217553198337555,
-0.7960266470909119,
0.09287115186452866,
0.27227213978767395,
-0.5566592216491699,
-0.248518705368042,
-0.6932228207588196,
-0.12563130259513855,
-0.6392927765846252,
-0.2159670889377594,
-0.4830971360206604,
-0.8491063117980957,
-0.07512795925140381,
-0.0286854337900877,
0.568608820438385,
0.7457956671714783,
-0.11020782589912415,
0.3539400100708008,
-0.9630593061447144,
0.645063579082489,
0.3872940242290497,
0.561775267124176,
-0.22260598838329315,
-0.017118696123361588,
-0.24576106667518616,
-0.34279385209083557,
-0.07106130570173264,
-0.3716672956943512,
0.583952009677887,
0.34953269362449646,
0.4294919967651367,
-0.0668581947684288,
0.10712293535470963,
0.29036298394203186,
-0.7294090390205383,
0.6441605687141418,
-0.25246313214302063,
-1.0134947299957275,
0.438707560300827,
-0.3359987735748291,
-0.06153946742415428,
0.15999756753444672,
0.2703090310096741,
-0.5650629997253418,
-0.02800285816192627,
-0.35395267605781555,
-0.9232674837112427,
0.6792817711830139,
0.4954790472984314,
-0.05826957896351814,
0.24604332447052002,
0.6063708066940308,
0.02939087152481079,
0.09143157303333282,
-0.030241765081882477,
-0.50113844871521,
-0.18516340851783752,
-0.25892576575279236,
-0.2669164836406708,
-0.3163825273513794,
0.08401630818843842,
-0.5743449926376343,
0.560469925403595,
-0.14712239801883698,
0.8755308985710144,
0.01633404940366745,
0.1436036080121994,
0.08405603468418121,
0.08585179597139359,
0.298221617937088,
0.04709804803133011,
-0.13346223533153534,
-0.08543970435857773,
0.11881446093320847,
-0.7146685123443604,
0.03905617073178291,
0.39009353518486023,
-0.2371131032705307,
-0.26961615681648254,
0.1969800740480423,
0.8202101588249207,
-0.2677527070045471,
-0.10001340508460999,
0.40767815709114075,
-0.5581397414207458,
-0.12445461004972458,
-0.3390316367149353,
0.02209337428212166,
-0.0011576170800253749,
0.7283192276954651,
0.2778305113315582,
0.37231504917144775,
0.4627653956413269,
0.01378067210316658,
0.3643318712711334,
0.40825268626213074,
-0.09323850274085999,
0.004520451184362173,
0.9661495089530945,
0.012040643952786922,
-0.3713556230068207,
0.8762231469154358,
-0.037329092621803284,
-0.18774506449699402,
0.6471292972564697,
0.0007133835460990667,
0.8370847702026367,
-0.31249967217445374,
0.3907957971096039,
0.16450287401676178,
0.21955358982086182,
0.0011309825349599123,
0.148294135928154,
0.009958891198039055,
-0.7627844214439392,
-0.12424851208925247,
-0.8202546834945679,
-0.373716801404953,
-0.3255861699581146,
-0.697057843208313,
-0.11842412501573563,
-0.5153597593307495,
-0.06879767030477524,
0.27789604663848877,
-0.136885404586792,
-0.8740540742874146,
-0.03300800547003746,
-0.050914593040943146,
0.47501060366630554,
-0.5481516718864441,
0.9837391972541809,
0.1736290454864502,
-0.4154033958911896,
-0.41708865761756897,
-0.05675872787833214,
0.038276560604572296,
-0.3369433879852295,
0.6169338226318359,
-0.12577609717845917,
-0.0833234190940857,
-0.11838902533054352,
-0.2523774802684784,
-0.8630963563919067,
1.161708116531372,
0.5198301076889038,
-0.2803809940814972,
0.12730048596858978,
0.5187321305274963,
0.6963608860969543,
-0.25693050026893616,
-0.3695853352546692,
0.9232466816902161,
0.5694600343704224,
0.22645266354084015,
-0.47087615728378296,
-0.09314756840467453,
-0.19402967393398285,
0.6754236221313477,
0.3279111683368683,
-0.4707493484020233,
1.2335407733917236,
0.0807703509926796,
-0.34358838200569153,
-0.31054404377937317,
1.0314966440200806,
-0.16921015083789825,
0.2506287693977356,
0.5426190495491028,
0.4859622120857239,
0.9622781872749329,
-0.30728858709335327,
1.1705570220947266,
0.03577804937958717,
0.3227521479129791,
0.519071102142334,
-0.33943572640419006,
0.788969099521637,
0.3892695903778076,
-0.3029044568538666,
0.0745978131890297,
0.19316120445728302,
-0.1549731194972992,
0.31501588225364685,
-0.08196283876895905,
-0.004192929249256849,
0.026274820789694786,
-0.1436760574579239,
-0.1192145049571991,
0.7118631601333618,
0.3913549780845642,
0.0338284857571125,
0.09395255893468857,
0.5888954997062683,
-0.23604974150657654,
0.3119678795337677,
-0.27450311183929443,
0.4490810036659241,
-0.14117439091205597,
-0.01729220524430275,
0.5492305755615234,
0.06961875408887863,
0.7055408358573914,
-0.24763721227645874,
-0.4143383502960205,
-0.1897120326757431,
0.47304481267929077,
-0.18316633999347687,
-0.6985531449317932,
0.8395576477050781,
-0.17652885615825653,
-0.3666203022003174,
-0.5413784980773926,
0.5700783133506775,
-0.4330924451351166,
-0.6373999118804932,
0.1794268935918808,
0.4806569218635559,
-0.08910168707370758,
-0.26713669300079346,
-0.48888126015663147,
0.003332858206704259,
-0.16344070434570312,
-0.4118780195713043,
0.19662907719612122,
0.5353363752365112,
-0.20914818346500397,
0.7327705025672913,
0.7889469861984253,
-0.02760493941605091,
-0.12398023158311844,
-0.2605697810649872,
0.8007240295410156,
-0.7063612341880798,
-0.4325767755508423,
-0.3123507797718048,
0.018668195232748985,
0.025583090260624886,
0.10665527731180191,
0.5975545644760132,
0.5110281705856323,
0.8772222995758057,
-0.14243242144584656,
0.6752386093139648,
0.10199543833732605,
0.6181392669677734,
-0.5839877128601074,
1.0376187562942505,
-0.5422019362449646,
0.36876213550567627,
0.0036930714268237352,
-0.8964182138442993,
-0.8035193681716919,
0.8127617239952087,
-0.16188780963420868,
-0.05940307304263115,
0.7599132657051086,
0.7037708163261414,
0.12619729340076447,
0.10605612397193909,
0.4736787676811218,
0.17803074419498444,
0.8962965607643127,
0.14980241656303406,
0.31398388743400574,
-0.6761847138404846,
0.433054119348526,
-0.6211661696434021,
0.1217837780714035,
0.03928278014063835,
-0.5326293706893921,
-0.8278475403785706,
-1.0044593811035156,
-0.2595811188220978,
0.10715552419424057,
-0.19781096279621124,
0.9147652387619019,
0.30341899394989014,
-0.7221771478652954,
0.14158502221107483,
0.4237765669822693,
0.11190284043550491,
-0.5117329359054565,
-0.26379457116127014,
0.8901761174201965,
0.021345701068639755,
-0.6377822160720825,
0.4992280602455139,
0.3448818027973175,
0.09982487559318542,
-0.2932605445384979,
0.12628892064094543,
-0.1427006721496582,
0.4065054655075073,
0.8777863383293152,
0.16146932542324066,
-0.018072469159960747,
-0.6155162453651428,
-0.006631297059357166,
0.10663548111915588,
0.3207543194293976,
0.9539006948471069,
-1.01572585105896,
0.1678933948278427,
0.8655259609222412,
0.7906217575073242,
0.7296600937843323,
-0.1206299290060997,
0.5811195969581604,
-0.8363717198371887,
0.3141561448574066,
0.41554370522499084,
0.3710959255695343,
0.42180123925209045,
-0.8392009735107422,
0.7609000205993652,
0.28875067830085754,
-0.47030916810035706,
-0.7208037972450256,
-0.12568700313568115,
-1.0298608541488647,
-0.16115513443946838,
0.5892597436904907,
0.16576671600341797,
-0.46495693922042847,
0.0029333392158150673,
-0.11929280310869217,
0.1593247354030609,
-0.33792704343795776,
0.683330237865448,
0.5182175040245056,
-0.39351874589920044,
-0.30899330973625183,
-0.5509998798370361,
0.6948036551475525,
0.15094488859176636,
-0.7520889639854431,
0.08903273940086365,
0.5417905449867249,
-0.2854635715484619,
0.13833613693714142,
0.6008256673812866,
-0.13131754100322723,
0.10324173420667648,
-0.06729636341333389,
0.21075232326984406,
-0.3639134168624878,
-0.48082026839256287,
-0.6602898240089417,
0.43542230129241943,
-0.3341065049171448,
-0.10891930013895035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06228v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06228v2
|
Understanding Cross-Lingual Alignment -- A Survey
| 2024-04-09T11:39:53 | 2024-06-11T17:33:52 |
Katharina Hämmerl, Jindřich Libovický, Alexander Fraser
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Cross-lingual alignment, the meaningful similarity of representations across
languages in multilingual language models, has been an active field of research
in recent years. We survey the literature of techniques to improve
cross-lingual alignment, providing a taxonomy of methods and summarising
insights from throughout the field. We present different understandings of
cross-lingual alignment and their limitations. We provide a qualitative summary
of results from a large number of surveyed papers. Finally, we discuss how
these insights may be applied not only to encoder models, where this topic has
been heavily studied, but also to encoder-decoder or even decoder-only models,
and argue that an effective trade-off between language-neutral and
language-specific information is key.
|
[
-0.4793708920478821,
-0.31145179271698,
0.13737128674983978,
-0.0935993492603302,
0.03159318491816521,
0.11290524899959564,
-0.11488799750804901,
-0.8013628721237183,
0.26454871892929077,
0.23066899180412292,
-0.3858849108219147,
-0.20310604572296143,
-0.45656153559684753,
0.26819223165512085,
-0.41999340057373047,
0.6146117448806763,
-0.29767268896102905,
0.6804085969924927,
-0.26454272866249084,
-0.5001863837242126,
-0.5047214031219482,
-0.4039234519004822,
-0.37792378664016724,
-0.25175508856773376,
0.4960328936576843,
0.07646877318620682,
0.8754964470863342,
0.7128391265869141,
0.6028441190719604,
0.21279101073741913,
-0.18251635134220123,
-0.018699873238801956,
-0.5764243006706238,
-0.05921124666929245,
-0.4191591143608093,
-0.477491557598114,
-0.3135751485824585,
-0.15827734768390656,
0.7178144454956055,
1.2200177907943726,
0.0003386054595466703,
-0.08986245095729828,
0.17220145463943481,
0.4678219258785248,
-0.6657026410102844,
-0.3226163983345032,
-0.20212534070014954,
0.37333419919013977,
-0.4565803110599518,
-0.06410692632198334,
-0.38549405336380005,
-0.16272060573101044,
0.1909634917974472,
-0.6874922513961792,
0.15608075261116028,
0.1767926961183548,
0.9909581542015076,
-0.004392038565129042,
-0.5782862305641174,
-0.3144785463809967,
-0.6596082448959351,
0.908746600151062,
-0.5577706098556519,
1.0433369874954224,
0.08104226738214493,
0.33996307849884033,
0.25907382369041443,
-0.2241022288799286,
-0.27614954113960266,
0.39076894521713257,
-0.3415488302707672,
0.14400331676006317,
-0.24032887816429138,
-0.1889457255601883,
0.07828015834093094,
0.4020874500274658,
-0.9131322503089905,
0.20203664898872375,
-0.2711724638938904,
-0.2177586853504181,
0.5881962776184082,
0.007808498106896877,
0.5636376142501831,
0.06158771365880966,
-0.4679175317287445,
-0.007000125478953123,
-0.8984175324440002,
0.0166561808437109,
0.4177282750606537,
0.0867331475019455,
-0.11364062875509262,
0.6477825045585632,
-0.018981393426656723,
1.0253815650939941,
0.41072532534599304,
-0.007027669809758663,
0.17094264924526215,
-0.73737633228302,
0.07592195272445679,
0.20914895832538605,
0.4576764404773712,
0.5371695756912231,
0.1710021048784256,
-0.5341260433197021,
-0.16681437194347382,
-0.07927820831537247,
0.1058569997549057,
-0.4064246118068695,
0.1432122439146042,
-0.047425154596567154,
-0.6254027485847473,
0.09870472550392151,
0.07575970143079758,
-0.5232349634170532,
-0.25652015209198,
-0.46662670373916626,
0.08483745157718658,
-0.3687647879123688,
-0.5362766981124878,
0.05012652277946472,
-0.23770025372505188,
0.7866129875183105,
0.13797633349895477,
-1.2076349258422852,
0.2061554193496704,
0.935060977935791,
0.5818372964859009,
-0.16695916652679443,
-0.6970274448394775,
-0.31368735432624817,
0.183524951338768,
-0.568683922290802,
0.592650294303894,
-0.6948833465576172,
-0.10459741204977036,
0.24617312848567963,
0.14725647866725922,
-0.12304218858480453,
-0.39556658267974854,
0.009108017198741436,
-0.6506253480911255,
0.3669264018535614,
-0.6758040189743042,
-0.5891083478927612,
-0.4193672835826874,
0.4565713107585907,
-0.7670996785163879,
0.6648675799369812,
-0.04593949019908905,
-1.0336278676986694,
0.5304856896400452,
-0.19435565173625946,
-0.3232206702232361,
-0.4095292389392853,
-0.14135314524173737,
-0.021198010072112083,
0.266361266374588,
0.410469114780426,
0.18717074394226074,
-0.43695563077926636,
0.14167577028274536,
-0.32643643021583557,
-0.21496018767356873,
0.41948822140693665,
-0.15476924180984497,
1.038818120956421,
0.30759769678115845,
-0.10194720327854156,
-0.1510668843984604,
-0.3994672894477844,
-0.11793725937604904,
-0.11271732300519943,
0.0806228443980217,
-0.5645999312400818,
-0.3561003804206848,
0.12317770719528198,
0.30673137307167053,
0.4762689471244812,
-0.6067313551902771,
0.07976227253675461,
-0.2967500686645508,
0.14756017923355103,
0.13176874816417694,
-0.34104102849960327,
0.8005223870277405,
-0.40037259459495544,
0.749923825263977,
0.12660853564739227,
0.11157307028770447,
0.1002921462059021,
-0.19900135695934296,
-0.303195595741272,
0.18165649473667145,
0.8208009004592896,
0.5774886608123779,
-0.7710906267166138,
0.15777134895324707,
-0.5192511677742004,
-0.3197263777256012,
-0.9439093470573425,
0.28352659940719604,
0.6945843696594238,
0.3673050105571747,
0.15805377066135406,
-0.6642810702323914,
-0.4743445813655853,
-0.8957865834236145,
-0.5078194737434387,
-0.06393586844205856,
0.27365291118621826,
-0.12290224432945251,
0.1437969207763672,
-0.25114336609840393,
0.8861855864524841,
-0.043027374893426895,
0.1921459585428238,
-0.23497901856899261,
0.23234497010707855,
-0.3637301027774811,
0.4646214544773102,
0.760318398475647,
-0.9451464414596558,
-0.6963385343551636,
0.5761860609054565,
-0.7932004332542419,
-0.2634148895740509,
-0.1319396048784256,
-0.15661446750164032,
0.28545722365379333,
0.6079075336456299,
-0.4331912398338318,
0.18755415081977844,
0.7981747984886169,
-0.3159545361995697,
0.09913615882396698,
0.0027408520691096783,
0.3989684581756592,
-0.8062105774879456,
0.1657799482345581,
-0.06352677941322327,
-0.2456568032503128,
-0.9919728636741638,
0.2614041864871979,
0.2918556332588196,
0.0677121952176094,
-0.5178635120391846,
0.4994843900203705,
-0.9176859855651855,
-0.38310104608535767,
-0.04587385058403015,
0.33911168575286865,
0.11236201971769333,
0.2057855874300003,
0.43996724486351013,
0.44980430603027344,
0.610874593257904,
-0.14635133743286133,
0.19506075978279114,
0.4346798360347748,
-0.18394415080547333,
0.8647773265838623,
-0.4244004786014557,
0.07520099729299545,
-0.20582106709480286,
0.023924533277750015,
-0.9892198443412781,
0.05738990008831024,
0.3929256796836853,
-0.45229220390319824,
0.7761011719703674,
-0.27849623560905457,
-0.13243865966796875,
0.25351688265800476,
-0.2637963593006134,
1.0258640050888062,
0.21068616211414337,
-0.667780876159668,
0.5485334992408752,
0.6000699400901794,
-0.27305111289024353,
-0.9698550701141357,
-0.8061445951461792,
0.06329784542322159,
-0.27739182114601135,
-0.7324396371841431,
0.4139863848686218,
0.2301499992609024,
-0.3917900323867798,
0.2768755853176117,
-0.1251230388879776,
0.035623062402009964,
-0.18277348577976227,
-0.2701663374900818,
-0.0032542708795517683,
-0.5010453462600708,
-0.029657267034053802,
-0.12710687518119812,
-0.12837201356887817,
-0.041839372366666794,
-0.2701021730899811,
0.36896222829818726,
0.09458927065134048,
-0.524380624294281,
-0.03259286284446716,
0.6870982050895691,
0.395888090133667,
-0.3540348410606384,
0.38685399293899536,
0.6224179863929749,
-0.4202301502227783,
0.27492597699165344,
-0.4469362795352936,
0.17462970316410065,
-0.3674652576446533,
0.22292736172676086,
-0.48049622774124146,
-0.7638756632804871,
0.7019104957580566,
0.13266736268997192,
0.09478240460157394,
0.3876194655895233,
0.37805095314979553,
0.007963457144796848,
1.1560133695602417,
0.8808415532112122,
-0.09666380286216736,
0.3851347863674164,
0.15169669687747955,
0.4260041415691376,
-0.7837727665901184,
-0.3211723268032074,
-0.588215172290802,
-0.3487532436847687,
-0.7129210233688354,
-0.32353919744491577,
-0.20173141360282898,
0.11103473603725433,
0.020148780196905136,
0.5116651058197021,
-0.3141716420650482,
0.3644217848777771,
0.18957599997520447,
-0.4778251647949219,
0.16295431554317474,
-0.09198249131441116,
-0.07702680677175522,
-0.34002262353897095,
-0.9763176441192627,
-0.22203940153121948,
0.6338863372802734,
0.33710214495658875,
1.1111066341400146,
0.40412038564682007,
0.718137264251709,
-0.28750520944595337,
0.0500546395778656,
-0.7051140069961548,
0.1526818424463272,
-0.1281053125858307,
-0.6841312050819397,
-0.3943304717540741,
-0.39743292331695557,
-1.0076168775558472,
0.3949156701564789,
-0.010039307177066803,
-0.538923442363739,
0.692257821559906,
-0.007365059107542038,
-0.12698152661323547,
0.27342474460601807,
-0.49091237783432007,
1.1288877725601196,
-0.6465227603912354,
-0.1740707904100418,
0.10658056288957596,
-0.7779945135116577,
0.19098611176013947,
-0.0754951685667038,
0.2799588739871979,
0.26920899748802185,
-0.23461207747459412,
0.6957105994224548,
-0.1648714244365692,
0.6752731204032898,
-0.07222297042608261,
-0.6470309495925903,
0.16831143200397491,
0.05249182507395744,
0.0033209167886525393,
-0.3490656316280365,
0.13582050800323486,
0.3557552695274353,
0.39165282249450684,
-0.5808684229850769,
-0.8588258624076843,
0.5371981263160706,
-0.7073466777801514,
-0.41208189725875854,
-0.3485630452632904,
-0.8493860960006714,
-0.3417850732803345,
0.16902728378772736,
0.4193265438079834,
0.4049973785877228,
-0.5149012804031372,
0.04981096088886261,
0.5184691548347473,
-0.06214269623160362,
0.29903748631477356,
0.24859081208705902,
-0.5805783271789551,
-0.44725459814071655,
0.9636063575744629,
0.36627140641212463,
0.47227001190185547,
0.996462881565094,
-0.15589064359664917,
-0.5343101620674133,
-0.40388888120651245,
-0.6475412249565125,
0.411026269197464,
-0.8780678510665894,
-0.01641080714762211,
-0.37607502937316895,
0.028311679139733315,
-0.6801498532295227,
-0.38357657194137573,
-0.2746620178222656,
-0.7530714273452759,
-0.1425786018371582,
0.002760424977168441,
0.05632681027054787,
0.8794337511062622,
-0.2711794674396515,
0.12425195425748825,
-0.8363385796546936,
0.14098699390888214,
0.07551860809326172,
0.2052498757839203,
0.03725408762693405,
-0.38132017850875854,
-0.5126772522926331,
0.16964924335479736,
0.08414951711893082,
-0.9274106621742249,
0.39230042695999146,
0.06312351673841476,
0.7160783410072327,
0.5680928826332092,
-0.09809673577547073,
0.999273955821991,
-0.32335880398750305,
0.777913510799408,
0.3233070969581604,
-1.0985840559005737,
0.11242380738258362,
-0.11688663810491562,
0.4784708023071289,
0.5011213421821594,
0.770125687122345,
-0.9294606447219849,
-0.21967467665672302,
-0.35163789987564087,
-0.4878259003162384,
0.4442603290081024,
-0.14025746285915375,
-0.2355290800333023,
0.25473541021347046,
0.02656998299062252,
0.38750892877578735,
-0.12097035348415375,
-0.6195183396339417,
0.1088729053735733,
-0.2505423426628113,
-0.47584405541419983,
-0.16192017495632172,
-0.0016239640535786748,
-0.29416677355766296,
-0.22292573750019073,
0.5181414484977722,
-0.11738608777523041,
0.08939211815595627,
-0.051454056054353714,
-0.6268224716186523,
-0.27823004126548767,
0.2294485867023468,
0.5975695848464966,
0.925429105758667,
0.15083520114421844,
0.32647067308425903,
0.3322533071041107,
-0.22817672789096832,
0.2025715708732605,
-0.00901838205754757,
-0.16172631084918976,
0.07779762148857117,
0.5392478108406067,
0.6761560440063477,
0.37589365243911743,
-0.42806077003479004,
0.4240140914916992,
-0.11576227098703384,
-0.07972007244825363,
0.20536673069000244,
-0.41069480776786804,
0.18647156655788422,
0.10745278745889664,
-0.07667683809995651,
-0.0801696628332138,
0.10498789697885513,
-0.7257013916969299,
-0.10442759096622467,
0.5601012110710144,
-0.6966807246208191,
-0.5221171379089355,
0.466422438621521,
0.08539944887161255,
-0.11926661431789398,
0.3481127619743347,
-0.0006679286598227918,
-0.5304265022277832,
0.3349120020866394,
0.6863990426063538,
0.6913025975227356,
-0.16394780576229095,
-0.007237324956804514,
0.05269544944167137,
0.28218090534210205,
-0.051319416612386703,
0.3230530917644501,
-0.2163533866405487,
-0.8547633290290833,
-0.33362701535224915,
-0.2752162516117096,
-0.5497614145278931,
-0.44646021723747253,
-1.0188807249069214,
0.23241007328033447,
0.1303848773241043,
0.025052234530448914,
0.08319691568613052,
-0.08028804510831833,
-0.6798920035362244,
0.031432073563337326,
0.17426776885986328,
0.883927047252655,
-0.9250552654266357,
0.7350148558616638,
0.9400973320007324,
-0.22850604355335236,
-0.6663306355476379,
-0.012650953605771065,
0.18854722380638123,
-0.6726771593093872,
0.48879873752593994,
-0.13647399842739105,
-0.2729019820690155,
-0.3816044330596924,
-0.12647145986557007,
-0.9718796610832214,
0.8386357426643372,
0.3940121829509735,
-0.8184073567390442,
-0.18608924746513367,
0.587931215763092,
0.5803125500679016,
-0.45278221368789673,
0.11362682282924652,
0.5944548845291138,
0.4951171278953552,
-0.25359734892845154,
-1.0833845138549805,
0.013144084252417088,
-0.3969663083553314,
0.12503522634506226,
0.47047165036201477,
-0.5604256987571716,
0.6152270436286926,
0.19315573573112488,
-0.26337841153144836,
0.002536917570978403,
0.5397466421127319,
-0.20222407579421997,
0.29912620782852173,
0.35727211833000183,
0.6548283696174622,
0.46871253848075867,
-0.04913284629583359,
0.9067776203155518,
-0.5321935415267944,
0.291733056306839,
0.7441352009773254,
-0.300385445356369,
0.6643003821372986,
0.769740879535675,
0.09441948682069778,
0.10100262612104416,
0.806647539138794,
0.10051999986171722,
0.5026871562004089,
-0.1379755288362503,
0.21792364120483398,
-0.3467041552066803,
-0.08870359510183334,
-0.620498538017273,
0.5300918817520142,
0.23449130356311798,
-0.15703001618385315,
-0.3045293092727661,
-0.0063309380784630775,
-0.2680341899394989,
-0.0024456793908029795,
-0.30475354194641113,
0.9157366752624512,
0.10600940138101578,
-0.8405563831329346,
0.675555408000946,
-0.23269982635974884,
0.6994121670722961,
-0.29810577630996704,
0.09448806196451187,
-0.1967170536518097,
0.03434602543711662,
-0.2684507369995117,
-0.8284754753112793,
0.5836227536201477,
-0.07541152089834213,
-0.12394454330205917,
-0.57960045337677,
0.6917049884796143,
-0.8429856896400452,
-0.30868491530418396,
0.5905295610427856,
0.7514445185661316,
0.1728677600622177,
0.5955931544303894,
-0.5114735960960388,
0.302522748708725,
-0.014884642325341702,
0.29466137290000916,
0.40273380279541016,
0.7818039655685425,
-0.1378074288368225,
0.14011938869953156,
0.09037274122238159,
0.10071668028831482,
0.3064763844013214,
0.052704259753227234,
0.40074416995048523,
-0.8581414818763733,
-0.2900405526161194,
-0.53782719373703,
0.30608847737312317,
-0.01891765370965004,
-0.5228287577629089,
0.9599612951278687,
0.596297562122345,
1.4695242643356323,
0.0014298476744443178,
0.5598933696746826,
0.03245016187429428,
0.39711353182792664,
-0.6066589951515198,
0.6572486162185669,
-0.8027452826499939,
0.015835881233215332,
-0.14492811262607574,
-0.7890780568122864,
-0.48167291283607483,
0.5428635478019714,
-0.37013429403305054,
-0.15216539800167084,
0.5832430720329285,
0.8297290802001953,
-0.36920952796936035,
0.18794561922550201,
0.29210761189460754,
-0.16746379435062408,
-0.06000876426696777,
0.3920655846595764,
1.2880072593688965,
-0.39854881167411804,
0.5269492268562317,
-0.33133551478385925,
0.08602318167686462,
-0.11857502907514572,
-0.6525031924247742,
-0.5766178965568542,
-0.7516995668411255,
-0.4852687418460846,
-0.010223501361906528,
0.17182253301143646,
0.541624903678894,
0.5576171875,
-0.8521597981452942,
-0.47275757789611816,
0.3293321132659912,
0.2778933048248291,
-0.49271124601364136,
-0.06588447839021683,
0.06964462995529175,
-0.28989189863204956,
-0.6716407537460327,
0.1956174224615097,
0.12371405959129333,
-0.05168241634964943,
-0.1669175624847412,
-0.33733728528022766,
-0.2608652710914612,
-0.031018592417240143,
0.32632574439048767,
0.6094964146614075,
-0.8544135093688965,
-0.3750242590904236,
0.34577879309654236,
-0.3002490699291229,
0.35950225591659546,
0.9771008491516113,
-0.15624502301216125,
0.48179158568382263,
0.9732837677001953,
0.864498496055603,
0.40701547265052795,
0.06344901025295258,
0.8733847737312317,
-0.5903911590576172,
-0.21503594517707825,
0.17604316771030426,
0.6808676719665527,
0.6717970967292786,
-0.22068023681640625,
0.4335452616214752,
-0.14594244956970215,
-0.38194823265075684,
-0.784225583076477,
0.3632737100124359,
-1.0010607242584229,
-0.26891589164733887,
0.9037777185440063,
-0.09683424234390259,
-0.3478616178035736,
-0.17364919185638428,
-0.04933668300509453,
0.3760654926300049,
0.19991663098335266,
0.5274292826652527,
0.8095943927764893,
-0.21374733746051788,
-0.38427048921585083,
-0.07449592649936676,
0.2654004693031311,
0.5939955711364746,
-0.5109982490539551,
0.10761543363332748,
0.3581562340259552,
0.30715233087539673,
0.5372883081436157,
0.2704336643218994,
-0.3944357931613922,
0.39733004570007324,
0.1394127905368805,
0.05167414993047714,
0.4943585991859436,
-0.40746045112609863,
-0.8362988233566284,
0.12341618537902832,
0.13416965305805206,
-0.05299455299973488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06224v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06224v1
|
Low-Cost Generation and Evaluation of Dictionary Example Sentences
| 2024-04-09T11:26:59 | 2024-04-09T11:26:59 |
Bill Cai, Clarence Boon Liang Ng, Daniel Tan, Shelvia Hotama
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Dictionary example sentences play an important role in illustrating word
definitions and usage, but manually creating quality sentences is challenging.
Prior works have demonstrated that language models can be trained to generate
example sentences. However, they relied on costly customized models and word
sense datasets for generation and evaluation of their work. Rapid advancements
in foundational models present the opportunity to create low-cost, zero-shot
methods for the generation and evaluation of dictionary example sentences. We
introduce a new automatic evaluation metric called OxfordEval that measures the
win-rate of generated sentences against existing Oxford Dictionary sentences.
OxfordEval shows high alignment with human judgments, enabling large-scale
automated quality evaluation. We experiment with various LLMs and
configurations to generate dictionary sentences across word classes. We
complement this with a novel approach of using masked language models to
identify and select sentences that best exemplify word meaning. The eventual
model, FM-MLM, achieves over 85.1% win rate against Oxford baseline sentences
according to OxfordEval, compared to 39.8% win rate for prior model-generated
sentences.
|
[
-0.10180485993623734,
-0.8177298307418823,
0.42669567465782166,
-0.0857042744755745,
-0.2604200541973114,
-0.45133325457572937,
-0.03269639611244202,
-0.23659895360469818,
0.12378956377506256,
0.28090694546699524,
-0.3830001950263977,
-0.3587949573993683,
-0.3283140957355499,
0.23431181907653809,
-0.6115114092826843,
0.7616316676139832,
-0.005155753344297409,
-0.2004794180393219,
-0.450690358877182,
-0.05788794904947281,
-0.38126081228256226,
-0.3372521996498108,
-0.4272010028362274,
-0.30947813391685486,
0.05698421224951744,
0.4863675534725189,
0.7801971435546875,
0.6136351227760315,
0.6594830751419067,
0.35105445981025696,
0.15330207347869873,
0.1809369921684265,
-0.5274033546447754,
0.048094335943460464,
-0.03120163269340992,
-0.19007575511932373,
-0.3076055347919464,
0.42268794775009155,
0.31039994955062866,
0.7865252494812012,
-0.5300421118736267,
0.018894340842962265,
0.12474113702774048,
0.5425045490264893,
-0.5059023499488831,
-0.048749808222055435,
-1.0771762132644653,
0.0064344643615186214,
0.1708897203207016,
-0.03990153968334198,
-0.0815233364701271,
-0.362745463848114,
0.08262456953525543,
-0.6206388473510742,
0.2919171452522278,
0.21468153595924377,
1.079422116279602,
-0.1141807958483696,
-0.12770645320415497,
-0.8082032203674316,
-0.13933663070201874,
0.6927477121353149,
-0.7839955687522888,
0.2826525568962097,
0.2886459231376648,
0.3899593651294708,
-0.14223235845565796,
-0.7993265986442566,
-0.6075338125228882,
-0.622307300567627,
-0.05455533042550087,
0.21575786173343658,
-0.3399534821510315,
-0.00691352179273963,
-0.133749321103096,
0.47440168261528015,
-0.5517565011978149,
-0.1622883528470993,
-0.217643141746521,
0.015395953319966793,
0.6584382653236389,
0.4437960684299469,
0.026918264105916023,
-0.618385910987854,
-0.29321494698524475,
0.0018495875410735607,
-0.5719128847122192,
0.07078997045755386,
0.4311215579509735,
0.21236233413219452,
-0.05710108205676079,
0.9176805019378662,
-0.5447782278060913,
0.6762857437133789,
0.03301467001438141,
-0.27739664912223816,
0.1903589963912964,
-0.6752834320068359,
-0.4696822464466095,
-0.18470196425914764,
0.6867313385009766,
0.7890504002571106,
0.36764007806777954,
-0.2970268726348877,
-0.47686436772346497,
0.27565720677375793,
0.30805936455726624,
-1.005305528640747,
-0.1553078144788742,
0.11368227750062943,
-0.7388021349906921,
-0.8102124929428101,
-0.059548746794462204,
-0.3404543697834015,
-0.20316928625106812,
-0.13391144573688507,
0.6801797151565552,
-0.6305896043777466,
0.152660071849823,
0.14245180785655975,
-0.3752325773239136,
0.06183808669447899,
0.087678924202919,
-0.6150397062301636,
0.27547040581703186,
0.5180652737617493,
0.8971574902534485,
-0.1374044567346573,
-0.13184912502765656,
-0.5982872843742371,
-0.19692181050777435,
-0.6259458661079407,
0.5868149995803833,
-0.1828523725271225,
-0.5212678909301758,
0.11006712913513184,
-0.28461194038391113,
0.27815380692481995,
-0.6766135692596436,
0.4391631484031677,
-0.04496810585260391,
0.29551753401756287,
0.2553994059562683,
-0.916975200176239,
0.2212871015071869,
0.4430362284183502,
-0.13959284126758575,
0.8949779272079468,
0.26772958040237427,
-0.31696534156799316,
0.4787338674068451,
-0.7154123783111572,
-0.5054879784584045,
0.4647504389286041,
-0.19501470029354095,
-0.3057933449745178,
0.4499843120574951,
-0.05558475852012634,
0.5843252539634705,
-0.34317636489868164,
0.14306913316249847,
-0.24576877057552338,
-0.10918617248535156,
0.2426043152809143,
-0.4165557622909546,
0.5957818031311035,
0.4182000160217285,
-0.3221632242202759,
-0.26250430941581726,
-0.9068545699119568,
0.05969257280230522,
0.1750878542661667,
-0.5048139095306396,
-0.524238646030426,
0.06441140919923782,
0.13944564759731293,
0.19927555322647095,
0.20146077871322632,
-0.5066153407096863,
0.006225815042853355,
-0.861107349395752,
0.23169240355491638,
0.599734902381897,
0.07219116389751434,
0.3463748097419739,
-0.4219919741153717,
0.45323148369789124,
-0.19170396029949188,
0.22792458534240723,
-0.35741978883743286,
-0.5198261737823486,
-0.7887901663780212,
-0.19593603909015656,
0.11771460622549057,
0.38812220096588135,
-0.7021864652633667,
0.6235091686248779,
-0.28284141421318054,
-0.5948869585990906,
-0.7153289318084717,
0.5747634172439575,
0.4257039725780487,
0.7994327545166016,
0.19636152684688568,
-0.2348298877477646,
-0.16759951412677765,
-1.2095168828964233,
-0.3651943504810333,
-0.18520906567573547,
-0.25642862915992737,
0.5083678960800171,
0.4864877462387085,
-0.09110412001609802,
1.1829211711883545,
-0.40018534660339355,
-0.3805621266365051,
-0.20840629935264587,
0.3442377746105194,
0.12801198661327362,
0.307910293340683,
0.5861879587173462,
-0.6020022034645081,
-0.1267796754837036,
-0.22582273185253143,
-0.6656522750854492,
-0.36366310715675354,
-0.16641248762607574,
-0.2204800248146057,
0.216263085603714,
0.2571251392364502,
-0.4012388288974762,
0.4425296187400818,
0.3905656933784485,
-0.5826640725135803,
0.37956035137176514,
-0.038581375032663345,
0.23677174746990204,
-1.1917591094970703,
-0.196181520819664,
-0.03468677029013634,
-0.41268688440322876,
-0.2860988974571228,
0.38630351424217224,
-0.020879412069916725,
-0.1608775109052658,
-0.6051058173179626,
0.5433334112167358,
-0.48755717277526855,
0.16203801333904266,
-0.28369998931884766,
0.5315208435058594,
0.10106252878904343,
0.09993736445903778,
-0.04022839292883873,
0.5572441220283508,
0.2047702521085739,
-0.36595308780670166,
0.6317393183708191,
0.192991241812706,
-0.7889074087142944,
0.6775076389312744,
-0.6901063919067383,
-0.14578837156295776,
0.12158478796482086,
-0.29751527309417725,
-1.1408581733703613,
0.025701776146888733,
-0.12865707278251648,
-0.3675461411476135,
-0.07183954864740372,
0.2544621229171753,
-0.3835950493812561,
-0.3734658658504486,
-0.49351999163627625,
-0.21362483501434326,
0.8742905259132385,
-0.554478108882904,
0.2634648382663727,
0.19464901089668274,
-0.009568355046212673,
-0.175968736410141,
-0.7854287624359131,
0.3144496977329254,
-0.06742127984762192,
-0.6158190965652466,
-0.03324391692876816,
-0.13319618999958038,
-0.5301511883735657,
0.2527965307235718,
-0.049526236951351166,
0.2281864434480667,
0.5030865669250488,
0.30231502652168274,
0.09418176859617233,
-0.3324914574623108,
0.0925091877579689,
0.039188213646411896,
0.13369297981262207,
-0.053281720727682114,
-0.2276671677827835,
0.32974445819854736,
-0.1767796277999878,
-0.17069745063781738,
-0.20216280221939087,
0.4284970164299011,
0.039860259741544724,
0.1677878051996231,
0.6249899864196777,
0.03643091022968292,
-0.42672884464263916,
-0.3228133022785187,
-0.5064265727996826,
-0.12490703910589218,
-0.48144790530204773,
0.3971957266330719,
-0.4917345345020294,
-0.4817894995212555,
-0.05775411054491997,
0.1355074942111969,
0.12355762720108032,
0.5120630860328674,
0.6493353843688965,
-0.23526637256145477,
0.8003622889518738,
0.3519674241542816,
0.19403228163719177,
0.14548489451408386,
-0.3392764627933502,
0.0714203491806984,
-0.324348509311676,
0.21392302215099335,
-0.3416694104671478,
-0.27690428495407104,
-0.24566127359867096,
-0.27212491631507874,
0.3033673167228699,
0.6339377164840698,
0.10292069613933563,
0.3709094524383545,
-0.5044884085655212,
0.5350369215011597,
0.7417915463447571,
-0.10621897131204605,
0.2885572016239166,
0.18618173897266388,
-0.35676252841949463,
0.1987917423248291,
-0.6218734979629517,
-0.849894106388092,
1.230804443359375,
-0.040468331426382065,
0.7979925274848938,
0.15676864981651306,
0.8891335725784302,
0.5944461226463318,
0.5803588628768921,
-0.9473978877067566,
0.49524161219596863,
-0.19477109611034393,
-0.3487473726272583,
-0.23675908148288727,
-0.40804702043533325,
-0.8522041440010071,
0.1879204660654068,
-0.42218586802482605,
-0.3835505247116089,
-0.11871388554573059,
0.30202946066856384,
-0.24224093556404114,
-0.1004958301782608,
-0.8499862551689148,
0.934098482131958,
-0.23903918266296387,
-0.14785240590572357,
-0.004168692044913769,
-0.35065799951553345,
0.5571143627166748,
-0.16274847090244293,
0.2507801353931427,
-0.13894614577293396,
-0.15706339478492737,
0.6881745457649231,
-0.8212757110595703,
0.45840445160865784,
-0.03457913547754288,
-0.0012712181778624654,
0.3319702744483948,
0.3499561548233032,
0.20736944675445557,
-0.042999785393476486,
-0.33333975076675415,
0.20845530927181244,
-0.009228089824318886,
-0.24009226262569427,
-0.4222615361213684,
0.7590749859809875,
-0.47465991973876953,
-0.4751651883125305,
-0.15330509841442108,
-0.5036190748214722,
-0.08405071496963501,
0.09583479166030884,
0.3792877495288849,
0.5892780423164368,
-0.4666449725627899,
0.2539539337158203,
-0.09053803235292435,
-0.15757928788661957,
0.6077131032943726,
0.458278089761734,
-0.16506986320018768,
-0.5998803973197937,
0.6608438491821289,
-0.06528710573911667,
0.5672823786735535,
0.2917850613594055,
0.4103485643863678,
-0.1949968934059143,
-0.44420409202575684,
-0.4501810073852539,
-0.11132677644491196,
-0.538054347038269,
-0.5249100923538208,
-0.5025035738945007,
0.013313071802258492,
-0.5976849794387817,
-0.592536211013794,
-0.039763182401657104,
-0.7170549631118774,
-0.04728377237915993,
-0.15359346568584442,
0.3468962609767914,
0.5343561768531799,
-0.1971457302570343,
0.4793432056903839,
-0.5501748919487,
0.5460397601127625,
0.4953043758869171,
0.057632848620414734,
-0.1760660856962204,
-0.3490729331970215,
-0.323505699634552,
-0.020711401477456093,
-0.6575102210044861,
-0.9145241975784302,
0.5706294775009155,
0.6251882314682007,
0.35938382148742676,
0.678657591342926,
-0.022273872047662735,
0.6761990785598755,
-0.8740443587303162,
1.1839529275894165,
0.5184631943702698,
-1.1101266145706177,
0.7469770312309265,
0.13877668976783752,
0.02067463845014572,
0.4682447016239166,
-0.036243315786123276,
-0.47055238485336304,
-0.6705350279808044,
-0.6366514563560486,
-0.6924145817756653,
0.48149552941322327,
0.4035247564315796,
0.3388480842113495,
-0.584226667881012,
0.3734932541847229,
0.06617503613233566,
0.39116817712783813,
-0.47509145736694336,
-0.2166048139333725,
-0.36311817169189453,
-0.6976706385612488,
-0.301491916179657,
-0.18404275178909302,
-0.08997146785259247,
-0.012145048007369041,
0.6837563514709473,
-0.1156798005104065,
0.03561170771718025,
0.24627280235290527,
-0.37017709016799927,
-0.08898667246103287,
0.26248258352279663,
0.5036333203315735,
0.3953738808631897,
-0.30559420585632324,
0.08286748081445694,
0.040793899446725845,
-0.24485506117343903,
0.19462279975414276,
0.11459675431251526,
-0.34641292691230774,
0.29043370485305786,
0.43988242745399475,
0.5780192017555237,
0.045375097543001175,
-0.89223712682724,
1.0212241411209106,
0.029286261647939682,
-0.39149653911590576,
-0.2184944748878479,
0.10119570791721344,
0.10312008857727051,
-0.0056565687991678715,
0.32260358333587646,
-0.1838904768228531,
0.40157437324523926,
-0.64580237865448,
0.3898639380931854,
0.8278380632400513,
-0.17349311709403992,
0.0850013867020607,
0.6967342495918274,
0.37884581089019775,
-0.5348755121231079,
0.48077481985092163,
-0.394653856754303,
-0.2344679832458496,
0.5355030298233032,
0.455552875995636,
0.7658485174179077,
-0.16037283837795258,
0.14203467965126038,
0.04191920906305313,
0.5840599536895752,
0.24750493466854095,
0.25979092717170715,
-0.10334497690200806,
-0.8146220445632935,
0.015342227183282375,
-1.0117952823638916,
-0.22312936186790466,
0.22405442595481873,
-0.39206215739250183,
0.3785818815231323,
-0.13293711841106415,
0.16507114470005035,
-0.0014231972163543105,
-0.04554527997970581,
-0.6651415228843689,
0.37651506066322327,
0.1752142757177353,
1.1678645610809326,
-0.8507797122001648,
0.635959267616272,
0.3126114010810852,
-0.6137603521347046,
-0.64555424451828,
-0.401497483253479,
-0.166543647646904,
-0.8405079245567322,
0.8152896165847778,
0.19451725482940674,
-0.078243188560009,
-0.1562708020210266,
-0.5385848879814148,
-0.2571222484111786,
0.9863362908363342,
0.2415039837360382,
-0.6618503332138062,
-0.12065307796001434,
0.22632643580436707,
0.31934085488319397,
-0.6870152950286865,
0.3538414239883423,
0.4645020663738251,
0.06953255087137222,
-0.16895294189453125,
-0.7540982961654663,
-0.1816415935754776,
-0.2562199831008911,
0.2797566056251526,
0.027820685878396034,
-0.03918210417032242,
0.8609450459480286,
-0.04550453647971153,
-0.19618377089500427,
0.5239501595497131,
0.49757450819015503,
0.18575507402420044,
0.26305362582206726,
0.6475053429603577,
0.8168799877166748,
0.4506630003452301,
0.0736532136797905,
1.311241865158081,
-0.31607529520988464,
0.37072649598121643,
1.118073582649231,
-0.3557564914226532,
1.0041866302490234,
0.3472409248352051,
0.0352560319006443,
0.31381428241729736,
0.44485875964164734,
-0.01528120692819357,
0.6304244995117188,
0.5091530084609985,
-0.07594072818756104,
-0.3751535713672638,
0.0972786471247673,
-0.15568554401397705,
0.42718151211738586,
0.135190948843956,
-0.5960898399353027,
-0.3963519036769867,
0.21905365586280823,
-0.2103586047887802,
0.19591370224952698,
-0.3595128059387207,
0.9397566318511963,
0.005709538236260414,
-0.2439422458410263,
0.7794718742370605,
0.13061320781707764,
0.9236416220664978,
-0.5182666182518005,
-0.1688043177127838,
-0.5353937149047852,
0.042514413595199585,
0.011773697100579739,
-0.37163978815078735,
0.1420864313840866,
0.33991193771362305,
-0.09313668310642242,
-0.12497211992740631,
0.46904677152633667,
-0.4872203767299652,
-0.8641639947891235,
-0.06619642674922943,
0.513087272644043,
0.49021586775779724,
0.03849727287888527,
-0.6555299758911133,
-0.49757274985313416,
-0.3338293433189392,
-0.32485660910606384,
0.01113076601177454,
0.3340875506401062,
0.24902062118053436,
0.3281519412994385,
0.6222556829452515,
0.4021303355693817,
0.11682373285293579,
-0.09169430285692215,
0.41200393438339233,
-0.5311274528503418,
-0.47379350662231445,
-0.7966374754905701,
0.31707319617271423,
-0.3158586919307709,
-0.40402165055274963,
0.7634149193763733,
1.0128109455108643,
0.7433105707168579,
-0.1448700875043869,
0.7808603644371033,
-0.09189201891422272,
0.5335045456886292,
-0.5485548377037048,
0.917512059211731,
-0.9217101335525513,
-0.01966630481183529,
-0.16995255649089813,
-0.6516295075416565,
-0.07379420846700668,
0.8572527766227722,
0.09492168575525284,
-0.2159498631954193,
0.7088924646377563,
0.9945611953735352,
-0.22969140112400055,
-0.27981775999069214,
0.7517077326774597,
0.2771061658859253,
0.20056171715259552,
0.49780797958374023,
0.8664327263832092,
-0.6238132119178772,
0.6692386269569397,
-0.3404163420200348,
-0.34178560972213745,
-0.22890813648700714,
-1.122137427330017,
-0.6905455589294434,
-0.56147700548172,
-0.28290891647338867,
-0.4719541072845459,
-0.07360823452472687,
1.105403184890747,
0.7915045619010925,
-0.8199746012687683,
-0.393685519695282,
-0.2379455417394638,
-0.038162894546985626,
-0.30292874574661255,
-0.353602796792984,
0.24087080359458923,
-0.7002266049385071,
-0.6831701397895813,
0.6098334789276123,
0.20253732800483704,
-0.1297728717327118,
-0.11890856921672821,
-0.0539601631462574,
-0.11983036249876022,
0.5548299551010132,
0.7807357907295227,
-0.25260990858078003,
-0.9373270869255066,
-0.35542550683021545,
-0.18535466492176056,
-0.2708994150161743,
-0.1581571102142334,
0.6570479273796082,
-0.8601853847503662,
0.297085702419281,
0.16148079931735992,
0.6043831706047058,
-0.005915455054491758,
0.15685464441776276,
0.4436599016189575,
-0.6712750792503357,
-0.01153940986841917,
0.07627061009407043,
0.5127142667770386,
0.43854013085365295,
-0.11470069736242294,
0.5672513842582703,
0.44459599256515503,
-0.2765064537525177,
-0.9662385582923889,
0.11582791060209274,
-0.7517444491386414,
-0.3452301025390625,
1.278840184211731,
-0.10719646513462067,
-0.21657107770442963,
0.34811317920684814,
-0.1898876428604126,
0.01739072985947132,
-0.2480829358100891,
0.8179961442947388,
0.723240852355957,
-0.07438986748456955,
0.07811440527439117,
-0.21809393167495728,
0.472074419260025,
0.2347676306962967,
-0.8138981461524963,
-0.14746080338954926,
0.8113396167755127,
0.41335007548332214,
0.08365655690431595,
0.3084496557712555,
0.19430041313171387,
0.2262316346168518,
0.09955623745918274,
0.33893883228302,
-0.231924369931221,
0.07124308496713638,
-0.47141730785369873,
0.4162988066673279,
-0.06405653059482574,
-0.4456338882446289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06217v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06217v1
|
VI-OOD: A Unified Representation Learning Framework for Textual Out-of-distribution Detection
| 2024-04-09T11:10:00 | 2024-04-09T11:10:00 |
Li-Ming Zhan, Bo Liu, Xiao-Ming Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Out-of-distribution (OOD) detection plays a crucial role in ensuring the
safety and reliability of deep neural networks in various applications. While
there has been a growing focus on OOD detection in visual data, the field of
textual OOD detection has received less attention. Only a few attempts have
been made to directly apply general OOD detection methods to natural language
processing (NLP) tasks, without adequately considering the characteristics of
textual data. In this paper, we delve into textual OOD detection with
Transformers. We first identify a key problem prevalent in existing OOD
detection methods: the biased representation learned through the maximization
of the conditional likelihood $p(y\mid x)$ can potentially result in subpar
performance. We then propose a novel variational inference framework for OOD
detection (VI-OOD), which maximizes the likelihood of the joint distribution
$p(x, y)$ instead of $p(y\mid x)$. VI-OOD is tailored for textual OOD detection
by efficiently exploiting the representations of pre-trained Transformers.
Through comprehensive experiments on various text classification tasks, VI-OOD
demonstrates its effectiveness and wide applicability. Our code has been
released at \url{https://github.com/liam0949/LLM-OOD}.
|
[
-0.27660441398620605,
-0.5009207129478455,
0.7129807472229004,
-0.0642564445734024,
-0.42195507884025574,
-0.16760753095149994,
-0.3875992000102997,
-0.40176916122436523,
0.09481335431337357,
0.9193128943443298,
-0.5134057402610779,
-0.6163725852966309,
-0.3956792950630188,
0.17006078362464905,
-0.4755428731441498,
0.6685905456542969,
-0.09691441804170609,
-0.2617569863796234,
-0.2814524471759796,
-0.38860639929771423,
-0.4383678734302521,
-0.37992990016937256,
0.026600049808621407,
-0.44321364164352417,
0.10638080537319183,
0.4395206868648529,
0.5671141743659973,
0.5640887022018433,
0.601603627204895,
0.4030749499797821,
0.07285619527101517,
0.3225414752960205,
-0.5080682635307312,
0.4666121006011963,
-0.2965785562992096,
-0.7500759363174438,
-0.26752805709838867,
-0.4087420105934143,
0.8481003642082214,
0.2310130000114441,
-0.2708216607570648,
-0.08152355998754501,
-0.023278241977095604,
0.5649499297142029,
-0.9490731358528137,
0.16145576536655426,
-0.6727486252784729,
0.42729300260543823,
-0.3318019509315491,
-0.37294623255729675,
-0.8942117691040039,
-0.047806479036808014,
-0.009972646832466125,
-0.6911635398864746,
0.36580467224121094,
-0.028672361746430397,
0.7734107375144958,
0.296586275100708,
-0.3752489387989044,
-0.30722010135650635,
-0.8121810555458069,
0.9261636734008789,
-0.3579634726047516,
0.25080832839012146,
0.26373711228370667,
0.2131159007549286,
-0.1666635125875473,
-0.7148528695106506,
-0.7916224002838135,
-0.048083946108818054,
-0.07542450726032257,
0.3798460066318512,
-0.18702596426010132,
0.11215396970510483,
-0.03160803020000458,
0.8411945104598999,
-0.41671308875083923,
0.1371704488992691,
-0.05574401468038559,
0.2074485421180725,
0.47333770990371704,
0.03046858124434948,
0.3984968662261963,
-0.24780137836933136,
-0.7560339570045471,
-0.2768217921257019,
-0.16993576288223267,
-0.2275685966014862,
0.5257048010826111,
0.07994955778121948,
-0.17646683752536774,
0.7116581797599792,
0.21714657545089722,
0.4806284010410309,
0.09817405790090561,
0.07666948437690735,
0.4853578805923462,
-0.20952722430229187,
-0.44902312755584717,
-0.022935809567570686,
1.0682941675186157,
0.06600090861320496,
-0.010605844669044018,
-0.009015253745019436,
-0.41779521107673645,
0.02775772660970688,
0.42339837551116943,
-0.5495189428329468,
0.15448732674121857,
-0.2696291208267212,
-0.5631411075592041,
-0.3539704382419586,
0.24690823256969452,
-1.096970558166504,
-0.7368021607398987,
-0.17039568722248077,
0.432613343000412,
-0.5566234588623047,
-0.45782315731048584,
0.520097553730011,
-0.2940593361854553,
0.1796417534351349,
0.0040101828053593636,
-0.9996077418327332,
0.02984704077243805,
0.23600322008132935,
0.652565598487854,
-0.3172997832298279,
-0.14745554327964783,
-0.6614044308662415,
0.029172277078032494,
-0.20118772983551025,
0.9065316319465637,
-0.40206167101860046,
-0.37257370352745056,
0.3073992133140564,
-0.2645176351070404,
-0.28654029965400696,
-0.5762956142425537,
0.7247238159179688,
-0.34222733974456787,
0.3612874448299408,
0.05188848450779915,
-0.45444467663764954,
0.016137372702360153,
-0.053988005965948105,
-0.8566797971725464,
1.2313910722732544,
0.31186795234680176,
-0.9199993014335632,
0.45751139521598816,
-0.52613765001297,
-0.23230883479118347,
-0.018098996952176094,
-0.5138611793518066,
-0.6147366166114807,
0.3326040506362915,
0.413167804479599,
0.433010995388031,
-0.48431017994880676,
0.16209115087985992,
-0.16936025023460388,
-0.3548964858055115,
0.002255764091387391,
-0.811355471611023,
0.7127177715301514,
-0.03841105103492737,
-0.41523146629333496,
-0.026062963530421257,
-0.9150460958480835,
-0.3216373026371002,
0.1435076743364334,
-0.22893933951854706,
-0.44189444184303284,
0.004942615050822496,
0.2513454258441925,
-0.16470910608768463,
-0.1617179960012436,
-0.6200230717658997,
0.3714330494403839,
-0.5818236470222473,
0.3490752577781677,
0.5447012186050415,
-0.20543523132801056,
0.8611341714859009,
0.052446890622377396,
0.6824150085449219,
0.0417744442820549,
0.06420739740133286,
-0.5091232657432556,
-0.6349652409553528,
-0.6433134078979492,
-0.401921808719635,
0.016694137826561928,
0.4813934564590454,
-1.2990522384643555,
0.8244909048080444,
-0.2211650162935257,
-0.12249097973108292,
-0.2866972088813782,
0.2107524424791336,
0.36753809452056885,
0.5352475047111511,
0.6111060976982117,
-0.3137704133987427,
-0.5062831044197083,
-0.4126895070075989,
-0.4043304920196533,
-0.3603205382823944,
0.041377075016498566,
-0.19501669704914093,
0.45086026191711426,
-0.7089335322380066,
1.3492460250854492,
-0.48602741956710815,
-0.9273703694343567,
-0.6103478074073792,
0.3465053141117096,
0.2287617176771164,
0.2697362005710602,
0.7678685784339905,
-1.0516669750213623,
-0.39117860794067383,
0.29202601313591003,
-0.9785447120666504,
-0.025493979454040527,
-0.23122461140155792,
-0.16571442782878876,
0.22533482313156128,
0.8031220436096191,
-0.8015660643577576,
0.8843572735786438,
0.31004494428634644,
-0.32197105884552,
0.2327180951833725,
-0.502326250076294,
-0.2878919839859009,
-1.187652826309204,
-0.33992770314216614,
0.07117694616317749,
-0.43914535641670227,
-0.396737664937973,
0.16523036360740662,
0.20323136448860168,
0.04817584156990051,
-0.3369641602039337,
0.33230099081993103,
-0.42747169733047485,
0.16954348981380463,
0.00973240565508604,
0.12281360477209091,
0.3748916685581207,
0.3399237394332886,
0.1612282693386078,
0.5417526364326477,
0.42783278226852417,
-0.39357542991638184,
0.38778629899024963,
0.27388355135917664,
-0.2155308723449707,
0.8471968770027161,
-0.30928894877433777,
-0.0754879042506218,
-0.7164160013198853,
0.168985515832901,
-1.0502090454101562,
-0.18953046202659607,
0.4612433612346649,
-0.37133705615997314,
0.6175010204315186,
-0.07962584495544434,
-0.4315617084503174,
-0.2115698605775833,
-0.548447847366333,
0.5034384727478027,
0.5439814925193787,
-0.9078020453453064,
1.1321988105773926,
0.2810003161430359,
0.48200905323028564,
-0.7341169714927673,
-1.1728848218917847,
-0.19911149144172668,
-0.1386258751153946,
-0.39899200201034546,
0.6809679269790649,
0.24341188371181488,
0.03439272195100784,
0.21129141747951508,
-0.15501362085342407,
-0.364042729139328,
-0.37450867891311646,
0.05441594123840332,
0.04285244271159172,
-0.5625702142715454,
0.3883899450302124,
0.06293168663978577,
-0.3454270362854004,
0.056392136961221695,
-0.3557963967323303,
0.5265106558799744,
-0.08226998150348663,
-0.463460236787796,
-0.4060785174369812,
0.34432685375213623,
0.44804978370666504,
-0.14589695632457733,
0.5931231379508972,
0.908176839351654,
-0.20976485311985016,
-0.5107507109642029,
-0.2431553453207016,
0.2110264152288437,
-0.5364582538604736,
0.46039217710494995,
0.019628245383501053,
-0.09221978485584259,
0.1473197638988495,
0.158859521150589,
-0.21343405544757843,
0.669649600982666,
0.3830774426460266,
-0.06107988953590393,
0.6369609236717224,
0.9755800366401672,
-0.11894213408231735,
0.8389782309532166,
-0.6226658225059509,
0.1783667802810669,
-0.47671544551849365,
-0.10620518028736115,
-0.3977479338645935,
0.10544756054878235,
-0.4772241413593292,
-0.6975415945053101,
0.1074352040886879,
0.06422188133001328,
0.16389618813991547,
0.3461993932723999,
-0.5318383574485779,
0.5922994017601013,
0.4214245676994324,
0.16827243566513062,
0.5227466225624084,
0.23449312150478363,
-0.11383845657110214,
0.15934374928474426,
-0.3974720537662506,
-0.3814410865306854,
0.9706443548202515,
0.3272266089916229,
0.9050558805465698,
-0.065882109105587,
0.8923020362854004,
0.6566609740257263,
0.276397705078125,
-0.8533420562744141,
0.4398810863494873,
-0.295195609331131,
-0.24541854858398438,
-0.37950679659843445,
-0.47152939438819885,
-0.9844998717308044,
0.40978413820266724,
-0.17625251412391663,
-0.683598518371582,
0.7139912247657776,
0.17198801040649414,
-0.06286521255970001,
0.6582924127578735,
-0.8699984550476074,
0.8041604161262512,
0.0014827226987108588,
0.005823248997330666,
0.15117549896240234,
-0.547526478767395,
0.18930956721305847,
0.2395080327987671,
0.058529794216156006,
0.03032909519970417,
0.054013341665267944,
0.19054828584194183,
-0.33002999424934387,
0.8163281083106995,
-0.11497315764427185,
-0.1856573075056076,
0.4756907820701599,
-0.45019692182540894,
0.33551451563835144,
0.29006466269493103,
-0.176271453499794,
0.023084372282028198,
-0.3567454516887665,
-0.2636394500732422,
-0.40846455097198486,
0.3215147852897644,
-0.7123339176177979,
0.016376815736293793,
-0.6004829406738281,
-0.30500906705856323,
0.08204828947782516,
0.27433186769485474,
1.0254993438720703,
0.4928000867366791,
-0.22251194715499878,
0.32422593235969543,
0.8937363624572754,
-0.45832860469818115,
0.6109382510185242,
-0.02856680564582348,
-0.5004392266273499,
-0.3510534465312958,
1.0309326648712158,
-0.214517742395401,
0.19310501217842102,
0.885047435760498,
0.3359626829624176,
-0.4583897590637207,
-0.3122747838497162,
-0.7384401559829712,
-0.05384865403175354,
-1.1188958883285522,
-0.28943395614624023,
-0.5168601274490356,
-0.1463497430086136,
-0.0941997542977333,
0.03821537271142006,
-0.4138305187225342,
0.17640607059001923,
-0.5879449248313904,
-0.12309657037258148,
0.22688758373260498,
0.8108791708946228,
0.2534562051296234,
0.3379662334918976,
-0.5806021690368652,
0.9330357909202576,
0.21665823459625244,
0.3840393126010895,
-0.30134302377700806,
-0.49409955739974976,
-0.04856494814157486,
-0.049600984901189804,
-0.504631757736206,
-0.8219499588012695,
0.470367431640625,
0.5034036636352539,
0.4713704586029053,
0.6559651494026184,
0.3831944763660431,
0.3055229187011719,
-0.3079372048377991,
0.5843185186386108,
0.5240613222122192,
-1.0583202838897705,
0.27703818678855896,
-0.2402597814798355,
0.11424332112073898,
0.481869637966156,
0.12718777358531952,
-0.16847558319568634,
-0.3209877908229828,
-0.31284675002098083,
-1.0863077640533447,
0.8078773617744446,
0.4850764870643616,
0.34045639634132385,
0.06536506116390228,
0.15125393867492676,
0.5306020975112915,
0.1674523502588272,
-0.9546626210212708,
-0.34817853569984436,
-0.2166217565536499,
-0.49471715092658997,
-0.14709895849227905,
-0.14473050832748413,
0.5091663599014282,
-0.061488520354032516,
0.2825145721435547,
-0.22838206589221954,
0.6066842079162598,
0.4769670069217682,
-0.6285116076469421,
-0.17465920746326447,
0.2923436760902405,
0.33596938848495483,
0.40233150124549866,
-0.2949601113796234,
0.07729006558656693,
-0.16633550822734833,
-1.0006599426269531,
0.12559497356414795,
0.1431911438703537,
-0.12539491057395935,
0.41506868600845337,
0.5079554319381714,
0.8323622941970825,
-0.05547542870044708,
-0.7208355665206909,
0.898681640625,
-0.3037308156490326,
-0.07422530651092529,
-0.37218979001045227,
0.04238046333193779,
-0.3533702492713928,
0.20481958985328674,
0.6392921209335327,
0.4619934558868408,
0.3605843186378479,
-0.6852537989616394,
0.04835541546344757,
0.03822111710906029,
-0.671145498752594,
-0.2726430594921112,
0.537178099155426,
0.02058434672653675,
-0.31122124195098877,
0.3401314318180084,
-0.3461865782737732,
-0.32036134600639343,
0.6690990328788757,
0.33722713589668274,
0.9788730144500732,
-0.030768828466534615,
0.562430739402771,
-0.3372011184692383,
0.37000128626823425,
-0.2779892086982727,
0.3759545683860779,
-0.10004588216543198,
-0.8737766146659851,
-0.3370966613292694,
-0.383378267288208,
-0.25074395537376404,
0.04993016645312309,
-1.0023415088653564,
0.45409563183784485,
-0.08485464751720428,
-0.21608397364616394,
-0.10145346075296402,
-0.7095652222633362,
-0.8415706157684326,
0.1501581370830536,
0.3032695949077606,
0.42259231209754944,
-0.6548377871513367,
0.6462400555610657,
0.7725646495819092,
-0.4806636869907379,
-0.10435790568590164,
0.4791116416454315,
-0.30922433733940125,
-0.6456460952758789,
0.3403998911380768,
0.5540631413459778,
-0.23573137819766998,
-0.11300785094499588,
-0.1784019023180008,
-0.4789372682571411,
0.9150429964065552,
0.9041838645935059,
-0.5511897206306458,
-0.0013246804010123014,
0.45657598972320557,
0.636507511138916,
-0.1391601711511612,
0.4953007698059082,
0.47460484504699707,
0.2759300768375397,
-0.3171064555644989,
-0.5870512127876282,
-0.26433470845222473,
-0.15661445260047913,
0.10659975558519363,
0.5119829177856445,
-0.20537836849689484,
0.9802206754684448,
-0.0504668764770031,
-0.2656213045120239,
0.21827121078968048,
0.654872477054596,
-0.039560046046972275,
0.6939723491668701,
0.5478822588920593,
0.5518316030502319,
0.6583330035209656,
0.04169978201389313,
1.262250304222107,
0.4096841514110565,
0.7230440378189087,
0.7678287029266357,
-0.267299622297287,
0.7531061768531799,
0.5584747791290283,
-0.030147232115268707,
0.6184353828430176,
0.05633559077978134,
0.2775613069534302,
0.6621687412261963,
-0.0032709373626857996,
-0.1804455667734146,
-0.22938533127307892,
0.011169285513460636,
-0.7039271593093872,
0.4460102915763855,
0.3997817933559418,
-0.5878946781158447,
-0.29972508549690247,
0.4527473747730255,
-0.44125989079475403,
0.4308747947216034,
-0.3315109312534332,
0.42942842841148376,
0.0483347587287426,
-0.23007933795452118,
0.5994957089424133,
-0.0025822531897574663,
0.8597308397293091,
-0.42687666416168213,
-0.13293643295764923,
-0.1932934671640396,
0.6434626579284668,
-0.09296542406082153,
-0.6748397946357727,
0.15022550523281097,
-0.2913126051425934,
-0.4212931990623474,
-0.4043198823928833,
0.9275506734848022,
-0.33444660902023315,
-0.44049540162086487,
0.6565770506858826,
0.1944112777709961,
-0.3400765359401703,
-0.3701944351196289,
-0.253020316362381,
-0.1201600730419159,
-0.25203442573547363,
-0.3953896462917328,
0.17239540815353394,
0.9546741247177124,
0.01918892003595829,
0.4033476710319519,
0.24598008394241333,
-0.2999860346317291,
0.17783018946647644,
0.06002257391810417,
0.9038577675819397,
-0.5820484757423401,
-0.731819748878479,
-0.9774296283721924,
0.6163384318351746,
-0.21351358294487,
-0.6459631323814392,
0.5275750756263733,
0.18564370274543762,
0.8726011514663696,
-0.46408170461654663,
0.7422241568565369,
0.11465587466955185,
0.05652240663766861,
-0.725983202457428,
0.505672037601471,
-0.6014994978904724,
0.2757040560245514,
-0.25273969769477844,
-0.9306210875511169,
-0.35497891902923584,
0.5472020506858826,
-0.07467547804117203,
-0.15973000228405,
0.8782712817192078,
0.28575924038887024,
-0.35594508051872253,
0.13981981575489044,
0.4655662178993225,
-0.022200966253876686,
0.15707537531852722,
0.2792956233024597,
1.003859043121338,
-0.7007641196250916,
0.8474066257476807,
-0.13992594182491302,
0.023383349180221558,
-0.5191510915756226,
-1.0289137363433838,
-1.1714739799499512,
-0.4972795844078064,
-0.08910735696554184,
-0.032483115792274475,
-0.010973051190376282,
0.871160626411438,
0.5933099985122681,
-0.6320931315422058,
-0.00032922523678280413,
-0.6557357907295227,
0.3489103317260742,
-0.2550943195819855,
-0.2533421218395233,
0.2570885419845581,
-0.4334847331047058,
-0.6243171691894531,
0.4747026860713959,
0.5911923050880432,
-0.19015267491340637,
-0.26792848110198975,
-0.03360486775636673,
-0.045303333550691605,
-0.005202496889978647,
0.6455137729644775,
0.1280953586101532,
-0.5114684104919434,
0.15600058436393738,
-0.061438027769327164,
-0.13433589041233063,
0.408722847700119,
1.0267220735549927,
-0.7500929236412048,
0.6916974186897278,
0.8552128672599792,
0.7474057674407959,
0.4672539234161377,
-0.18804091215133667,
0.6307404637336731,
-1.1601057052612305,
0.4926491677761078,
0.38579997420310974,
0.5029264688491821,
0.18724003434181213,
-0.49787747859954834,
0.29572153091430664,
0.45506617426872253,
-0.22644935548305511,
-1.0532217025756836,
0.21056555211544037,
-0.8902714252471924,
-0.18491579592227936,
1.0676991939544678,
-0.18260681629180908,
-0.2537817656993866,
-0.44995230436325073,
-0.4999864995479584,
0.13756760954856873,
-0.6180141568183899,
0.4619513154029846,
0.13410848379135132,
0.33706966042518616,
0.025904064998030663,
-0.5375295877456665,
0.2227909117937088,
0.2846614420413971,
-0.8119952082633972,
-0.1996164172887802,
0.051760297268629074,
-0.2935348153114319,
0.3952770233154297,
0.5278557538986206,
0.14862699806690216,
0.180788055062294,
-0.04800267145037651,
0.226652130484581,
0.10215703397989273,
-0.35734179615974426,
-0.31023699045181274,
0.2589626908302307,
-0.2843977212905884,
-0.5825204253196716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06214v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06214v1
|
[Call for Papers] The 2nd BabyLM Challenge: Sample-efficient pretraining on a developmentally plausible corpus
| 2024-04-09T11:04:50 | 2024-04-09T11:04:50 |
Leshem Choshen, Ryan Cotterell, Michael Y. Hu, Tal Linzen, Aaron Mueller, Candace Ross, Alex Warstadt, Ethan Wilcox, Adina Williams, Chengxu Zhuang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
After last year's successful BabyLM Challenge, the competition will be hosted
again in 2024/2025. The overarching goals of the challenge remain the same;
however, some of the competition rules will be different. The big changes for
this year's competition are as follows: First, we replace the loose track with
a paper track, which allows (for example) non-model-based submissions, novel
cognitively-inspired benchmarks, or analysis techniques. Second, we are
relaxing the rules around pretraining data, and will now allow participants to
construct their own datasets provided they stay within the 100M-word or
10M-word budget. Third, we introduce a multimodal vision-and-language track,
and will release a corpus of 50% text-only and 50% image-text multimodal data
as a starting point for LM model training. The purpose of this CfP is to
provide rules for this year's challenge, explain these rule changes and their
rationale in greater detail, give a timeline of this year's competition, and
provide answers to frequently asked questions from last year's challenge.
|
[
-0.13520632684230804,
-0.3306618630886078,
0.27952972054481506,
0.04361347854137421,
-0.2996577322483063,
-0.0442885123193264,
-0.1696447730064392,
-0.7826951742172241,
-0.2917061150074005,
0.4435926079750061,
-0.7438614368438721,
-0.22766782343387604,
-0.5295282602310181,
0.02504129707813263,
-0.5620260834693909,
0.9167608022689819,
-0.23403313755989075,
-0.057299017906188965,
-0.5289393663406372,
0.053665321320295334,
-0.466739296913147,
-0.6800545454025269,
-0.4641665518283844,
-0.023172955960035324,
0.8893789052963257,
0.46646440029144287,
-0.0012142203049734235,
0.6391394734382629,
0.6918219327926636,
0.25210341811180115,
-0.18124373257160187,
0.12445545941591263,
-0.1581922471523285,
0.21093836426734924,
-0.004254558589309454,
-0.3376060128211975,
-0.5953346490859985,
0.43176957964897156,
0.5408164858818054,
0.9645328521728516,
-0.27083200216293335,
0.38833045959472656,
0.16799461841583252,
0.7531991600990295,
-0.8379201889038086,
0.36437010765075684,
-0.7150089144706726,
0.021767811849713326,
-0.5222981572151184,
-0.10632701963186264,
-0.45593133568763733,
-0.1114770844578743,
0.07419499009847641,
-0.6608474850654602,
0.5736666917800903,
-0.10471774637699127,
0.8981392979621887,
0.1192946583032608,
-0.22618737816810608,
-0.5852768421173096,
-0.5937631130218506,
0.574408233165741,
-0.43441152572631836,
0.5200472474098206,
0.3850429356098175,
0.04980499669909477,
0.0033046940807253122,
-0.9920769333839417,
-0.4296342134475708,
-0.34022173285484314,
0.19555482268333435,
0.024031570181250572,
-0.06695743650197983,
-0.12121371924877167,
0.2502858340740204,
-0.19265295565128326,
-0.6755838990211487,
-0.05375154688954353,
-0.47095316648483276,
-0.22762194275856018,
0.7924902439117432,
0.1107805073261261,
-0.1739104837179184,
0.3677864670753479,
-0.2807513475418091,
-0.35165393352508545,
-0.4578436017036438,
-0.2407972514629364,
0.37507736682891846,
0.3118712902069092,
-0.08774667233228683,
0.44553667306900024,
-0.16698426008224487,
0.591517984867096,
-0.0407816581428051,
-0.0216585174202919,
0.5965677499771118,
-0.46146082878112793,
0.05294372886419296,
-0.2720523178577423,
0.4245374798774719,
0.28551122546195984,
0.21640543639659882,
-0.14184677600860596,
-0.3581485450267792,
0.05512280762195587,
0.2025706022977829,
-0.6526165008544922,
-0.14184944331645966,
-0.07284215837717056,
-0.675915539264679,
-0.2565601170063019,
-0.06772836297750473,
-0.9043447971343994,
-0.15336832404136658,
-0.36039069294929504,
0.34268590807914734,
-0.32338470220565796,
-0.27325841784477234,
0.016607295721769333,
-0.09676562249660492,
0.4748738408088684,
0.5114396214485168,
-1.06222403049469,
0.1656474471092224,
0.8335922360420227,
0.5838863849639893,
-0.18683689832687378,
-0.2857235074043274,
-0.47512081265449524,
-0.14527693390846252,
-0.4460708796977997,
0.9344995021820068,
-0.2739216089248657,
-0.3428889513015747,
0.11458446085453033,
-0.06675440073013306,
-0.5112802386283875,
-0.856128990650177,
0.7517204284667969,
-0.5666142106056213,
0.3744899034500122,
-0.23698696494102478,
-0.3222232162952423,
0.27450549602508545,
0.2951076626777649,
-0.3795957565307617,
0.8999750018119812,
0.35198408365249634,
-0.5301744937896729,
0.5395547151565552,
-0.6614463925361633,
-0.4577004909515381,
0.23604077100753784,
-0.0004955466720275581,
-0.4256238043308258,
0.12568679451942444,
-0.2860649526119232,
-0.002967675682157278,
-0.21553222835063934,
0.28885993361473083,
-0.4250733554363251,
-0.025536566972732544,
0.020459596067667007,
-0.32799774408340454,
0.8640285134315491,
0.5124231576919556,
0.01768713817000389,
0.03382115438580513,
-1.0032238960266113,
0.3330581784248352,
0.332040011882782,
-0.541197657585144,
0.12756745517253876,
-0.0320633202791214,
0.3777962028980255,
0.23052991926670074,
0.36101001501083374,
-0.588433563709259,
0.1999991238117218,
-0.08621034026145935,
0.5052974820137024,
0.36900073289871216,
-0.40595075488090515,
0.3665154278278351,
-0.4513506293296814,
0.8201175332069397,
-0.19861924648284912,
0.6916925311088562,
-0.49020782113075256,
-0.3901022970676422,
-0.7283234000205994,
-0.19144415855407715,
0.5950055718421936,
0.5218126773834229,
-0.5276309251785278,
0.33933496475219727,
0.15848655998706818,
-0.4919796288013458,
-0.464270681142807,
0.08628173172473907,
0.33966442942619324,
0.5654518008232117,
0.3569084107875824,
-0.6492546796798706,
-0.8999810218811035,
-0.8358396887779236,
-0.03892745450139046,
-0.37636300921440125,
0.21074990928173065,
0.03843793272972107,
0.5590062737464905,
0.0677306205034256,
0.6619383692741394,
-0.1671738475561142,
-0.5088309645652771,
-0.10630972683429718,
0.192617729306221,
0.02480088174343109,
0.8037717342376709,
0.5546808838844299,
-0.8648750185966492,
-0.32681772112846375,
-0.46751677989959717,
-0.5600091218948364,
-0.4211007356643677,
0.2269091159105301,
0.09935690462589264,
0.4942938983440399,
0.874958872795105,
-0.6332681179046631,
0.4626207947731018,
0.5640208125114441,
-0.39013469219207764,
0.6595654487609863,
-0.28530722856521606,
-0.15907984972000122,
-0.5211279392242432,
0.24871261417865753,
-0.471983939409256,
-0.037847187370061874,
-0.504510223865509,
0.3163541853427887,
0.06393998116254807,
-0.0957774966955185,
-0.7489902973175049,
0.5419396162033081,
-0.48044660687446594,
0.13779011368751526,
-0.35061386227607727,
-0.21680547297000885,
-0.05360104516148567,
0.12264764308929443,
-0.04760168120265007,
0.5349546074867249,
0.2851806879043579,
-0.5060219168663025,
0.26042744517326355,
0.2256530374288559,
-0.4792771637439728,
0.5040322542190552,
-0.6047583222389221,
0.6063433885574341,
-0.15956787765026093,
0.6249791383743286,
-0.888069212436676,
-0.036947112530469894,
0.1021309345960617,
-0.4136212170124054,
0.514545738697052,
0.19755366444587708,
-0.5868662595748901,
-0.6263155341148376,
-0.2375061810016632,
0.4844770133495331,
0.6288436651229858,
-0.2027009278535843,
0.47841769456863403,
0.38179418444633484,
0.14448560774326324,
-0.4440891444683075,
-0.6383547782897949,
0.1408577859401703,
-0.2546885013580322,
-0.34649765491485596,
0.6802127361297607,
-0.5322237610816956,
0.16438432037830353,
0.06480046361684799,
0.12972192466259003,
0.06148673966526985,
0.18865026533603668,
0.04587668552994728,
0.23315736651420593,
-0.07901982963085175,
-0.13966071605682373,
-0.4705754518508911,
-0.2877340614795685,
0.12330867350101471,
-0.4945562183856964,
0.6679030656814575,
0.03668778017163277,
-0.2440768927335739,
-0.2085336148738861,
0.4482806622982025,
0.08987826853990555,
-0.224138543009758,
0.19603775441646576,
0.7097639441490173,
-0.4852825701236725,
-0.04409394785761833,
-0.5136086344718933,
-0.032300736755132675,
-0.44133663177490234,
0.2629840672016144,
-0.22629323601722717,
-0.7874741554260254,
0.10312070697546005,
-0.0037754960358142853,
0.19997747242450714,
0.40745383501052856,
0.8314684629440308,
-0.5771358609199524,
0.8486140370368958,
0.8727049827575684,
0.5370815992355347,
0.5716339945793152,
-0.16503064334392548,
-0.11017477512359619,
-0.8598121404647827,
-0.7402297258377075,
-0.6976084113121033,
-0.3952261209487915,
-0.37862810492515564,
-0.4412437081336975,
0.1482785940170288,
0.1933342069387436,
-0.15578314661979675,
0.26492398977279663,
-0.38357245922088623,
0.29348576068878174,
0.7619132995605469,
-0.07253655046224594,
-0.000731073843780905,
-0.2869361340999603,
-0.2190464586019516,
-0.20987822115421295,
-0.9373096227645874,
-0.39683347940444946,
1.1956708431243896,
0.1147255077958107,
0.3475254476070404,
-0.0874280110001564,
0.6117517352104187,
0.24931716918945312,
0.6302992701530457,
-0.5354439616203308,
0.8233976364135742,
-0.26827332377433777,
-1.1047849655151367,
-0.002738779643550515,
0.08491476625204086,
-1.110205054283142,
0.2478918433189392,
-0.27310851216316223,
-0.7484520673751831,
0.1963202953338623,
0.307584285736084,
-0.32145294547080994,
0.10315363854169846,
-0.5041467547416687,
0.9001268744468689,
-0.36723604798316956,
-0.27782559394836426,
0.0866415947675705,
-0.8494929075241089,
0.1797705739736557,
-0.4464421272277832,
0.21438990533351898,
-0.3571513891220093,
-0.174351304769516,
1.1253584623336792,
-0.5731040835380554,
0.7613459825515747,
-0.25398731231689453,
0.06403595209121704,
0.589040219783783,
-0.3206554353237152,
0.041075851768255234,
-0.24699783325195312,
-0.008977517485618591,
-0.05871008709073067,
0.5039666295051575,
-0.4276093542575836,
-0.17190253734588623,
0.17477290332317352,
-0.4027610719203949,
-0.6807548999786377,
-0.8012835383415222,
-0.4563709795475006,
-0.17819784581661224,
0.27306801080703735,
0.48393145203590393,
0.2737855315208435,
-0.3765099048614502,
0.37591323256492615,
0.19371235370635986,
-0.07788397371768951,
0.6465840339660645,
0.46071285009384155,
-0.48789486289024353,
-0.4744231402873993,
0.6751722693443298,
0.12199808657169342,
0.14571666717529297,
0.26253777742385864,
0.12969601154327393,
-0.41623908281326294,
-0.9003642201423645,
-0.3961104154586792,
0.13049809634685516,
-0.43782559037208557,
-0.1405993551015854,
-0.5370516180992126,
-0.26819026470184326,
-0.6610273718833923,
0.039865147322416306,
-0.4902721047401428,
-0.19508737325668335,
-0.45011240243911743,
0.5494751334190369,
-0.23611211776733398,
0.36630794405937195,
-0.4797559380531311,
0.31574100255966187,
-0.6876339912414551,
0.14726583659648895,
0.2915832996368408,
0.18118916451931,
-0.1612919569015503,
-0.7095884680747986,
-0.28618088364601135,
-0.21780796349048615,
-0.5357487797737122,
-0.4716179072856903,
0.33073678612709045,
0.19428189098834991,
0.4337075352668762,
0.2667751610279083,
-0.13352496922016144,
0.6596484184265137,
-0.7273898720741272,
0.665844738483429,
0.3923642933368683,
-0.595361590385437,
0.49199339747428894,
-0.3500657081604004,
0.3494865894317627,
0.8573570251464844,
0.04444195702672005,
-0.3534488081932068,
0.12569878995418549,
-0.8124859929084778,
-0.8045478463172913,
0.6134293079376221,
-0.024940432980656624,
0.3168874680995941,
0.19157978892326355,
0.4662427604198456,
0.05802677571773529,
0.4383820593357086,
-0.236990287899971,
0.07698515802621841,
0.10926088690757751,
-0.27377355098724365,
0.22920796275138855,
-0.5227254629135132,
-0.11864709854125977,
-0.52192622423172,
0.4365324378013611,
-0.2530740201473236,
0.2581299841403961,
0.15017983317375183,
0.2146034985780716,
-0.15646636486053467,
0.16219253838062286,
0.7919399738311768,
0.7286994457244873,
-0.42717093229293823,
-0.04516616463661194,
0.14321231842041016,
-0.7459489107131958,
0.21572409570217133,
0.4861075282096863,
-0.4965575039386749,
-0.05081063136458397,
0.8881238698959351,
0.6243889927864075,
0.2371457815170288,
-0.9306002855300903,
0.40413224697113037,
-0.03222772106528282,
-0.8713452219963074,
-0.7030085921287537,
0.09250275045633316,
0.005806781817227602,
0.46166563034057617,
0.507536768913269,
-0.09615641087293625,
-0.15579265356063843,
-0.7279222011566162,
0.18725435435771942,
0.5325690507888794,
-0.2851163446903229,
-0.4311695396900177,
1.0075030326843262,
0.02341955341398716,
-0.6118978261947632,
0.44591107964515686,
-0.3110676109790802,
-0.49901261925697327,
0.716745138168335,
0.6226105690002441,
0.6337863206863403,
-0.2037525177001953,
0.14469975233078003,
0.17259159684181213,
0.2823955714702606,
-0.21518822014331818,
0.5847423076629639,
0.2556462287902832,
-0.7848364114761353,
-0.25178834795951843,
-0.529255747795105,
-0.38870394229888916,
0.6510990858078003,
-0.6419768929481506,
0.5192775130271912,
-0.5829988718032837,
-0.4032704532146454,
0.147588849067688,
0.10880076885223389,
-1.0166984796524048,
0.50126713514328,
0.731577455997467,
1.1528263092041016,
-0.3779314160346985,
0.926714301109314,
0.8298340439796448,
-0.15844672918319702,
-0.3996431529521942,
-0.4042881727218628,
0.2149631828069687,
-0.5233508348464966,
0.7305309176445007,
0.07667283713817596,
0.1447203904390335,
-0.017393819987773895,
-0.8845768570899963,
-0.9161123037338257,
0.9816052317619324,
0.2413083165884018,
-0.6676164269447327,
-0.4697144627571106,
-0.061421722173690796,
0.41917410492897034,
-0.7436597347259521,
0.2655641734600067,
0.621041476726532,
0.5526207685470581,
0.3167344927787781,
-0.983084499835968,
-0.44789937138557434,
-0.13834889233112335,
-0.0770767331123352,
-0.25064894556999207,
-0.8608102798461914,
0.9603102803230286,
-0.5048588514328003,
-0.30438876152038574,
0.4404337406158447,
0.8915849924087524,
0.5336398482322693,
0.7745934724807739,
0.8445272445678711,
0.5908770561218262,
0.5480487942695618,
-0.1499340683221817,
0.6497238278388977,
-0.19550292193889618,
0.3229941427707672,
1.2451380491256714,
-0.5697561502456665,
0.88718581199646,
0.4964585602283478,
-0.3995501697063446,
0.2386082261800766,
0.808159589767456,
-0.12820322811603546,
0.6886978149414062,
0.30596089363098145,
-0.05929066240787506,
-0.15763768553733826,
-0.2594420313835144,
-0.6085370779037476,
0.7672737240791321,
0.2680381238460541,
-0.07562968879938126,
-0.31439390778541565,
0.027103662490844727,
0.13762591779232025,
0.16137327253818512,
-0.019639212638139725,
0.5703935623168945,
0.19168898463249207,
-0.6265577673912048,
0.6582425832748413,
0.10660302639007568,
0.7388876080513,
-0.6981897354125977,
0.1415303647518158,
-0.12468981742858887,
0.3412896990776062,
0.138017937541008,
-0.35611650347709656,
0.34212103486061096,
0.13485406339168549,
-0.05660857632756233,
-0.41195330023765564,
0.7114646434783936,
-0.523038387298584,
-0.6590555310249329,
0.29658517241477966,
0.7065520286560059,
-0.021221879869699478,
0.1827256977558136,
-0.9506571888923645,
0.42636796832084656,
-0.43418824672698975,
-0.45491084456443787,
0.36105355620384216,
0.27406588196754456,
-0.1537984311580658,
0.46264198422431946,
0.8558574318885803,
0.23931436240673065,
0.20365439355373383,
0.1235044077038765,
0.7785027623176575,
-0.592849612236023,
-0.3628348708152771,
-0.6102110743522644,
0.14628252387046814,
0.0700165331363678,
-0.6347002387046814,
0.16683003306388855,
0.6921802759170532,
0.9779355525970459,
-0.03157323971390724,
0.718590497970581,
-0.3779260814189911,
0.5474286675453186,
-0.5589604377746582,
0.49337780475616455,
-0.7788509726524353,
-0.22102414071559906,
0.0041308109648525715,
-0.7226596474647522,
-0.37489622831344604,
0.27666419744491577,
0.05481317266821861,
0.26672714948654175,
1.0714051723480225,
0.3999468684196472,
0.25662514567375183,
0.15605781972408295,
0.13468322157859802,
-0.23449668288230896,
0.444015234708786,
0.9401819109916687,
0.9461016654968262,
-0.41753628849983215,
0.5478772521018982,
-0.2591266632080078,
-0.22592346370220184,
-0.3341263234615326,
-1.1866719722747803,
-0.439191073179245,
-1.0240564346313477,
-0.5298944115638733,
-0.4559991657733917,
0.18123985826969147,
0.9166258573532104,
0.9632360339164734,
-0.7745287418365479,
-0.17356301844120026,
0.19504088163375854,
-0.34403330087661743,
-0.2571875751018524,
-0.06498614698648453,
0.2969258725643158,
-0.2144758254289627,
-0.7551993727684021,
0.3750516474246979,
0.06483432650566101,
0.12400395423173904,
-0.13610893487930298,
0.2856403589248657,
-0.5188348293304443,
-0.030194496735930443,
0.7022866010665894,
0.46741950511932373,
-0.4486168324947357,
-0.40663301944732666,
-0.0654224306344986,
-0.34044939279556274,
-0.051060374826192856,
1.109035849571228,
-0.7387068271636963,
0.1775853931903839,
0.3176329433917999,
0.5046995878219604,
0.6297719478607178,
-0.19621987640857697,
0.12964119017124176,
-0.37157538533210754,
0.6882069706916809,
0.43221229314804077,
0.17436933517456055,
0.30109795928001404,
0.030148228630423546,
0.8698117733001709,
0.7826259732246399,
-0.31036871671676636,
-0.9067326784133911,
0.2039172500371933,
-1.161068320274353,
-0.3381664752960205,
0.9571593999862671,
0.06675846129655838,
-0.3698171079158783,
-0.1144542247056961,
0.02460451051592827,
0.39283090829849243,
0.017794746905565262,
0.7301229238510132,
0.9642308950424194,
-0.14722810685634613,
-0.3381701409816742,
-0.8888187408447266,
0.5801687836647034,
0.494529664516449,
-1.030638575553894,
-0.07486747205257416,
0.3281489312648773,
0.08505629003047943,
0.08497042208909988,
1.0180740356445312,
-0.31284359097480774,
0.09235037118196487,
-0.06273848563432693,
0.24005217850208282,
-0.19968563318252563,
-0.6016295552253723,
-0.10815463215112686,
0.3202635645866394,
0.12326742708683014,
-0.3973642587661743
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.