id
stringlengths
33
33
doc_url
stringlengths
33
33
title
stringlengths
13
211
publication_date
timestamp[s]
update_date
timestamp[s]
authors
stringlengths
6
16.6k
category_primary
stringclasses
60 values
category_all
stringlengths
5
132
abstract
stringlengths
123
1.99k
embeddings
listlengths
768
768
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05012v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05012v1
Towards Reliable and Empathetic Depression-Diagnosis-Oriented Chats
2024-04-07T16:35:53
2024-04-07T16:35:53
Kunyao Lan, Cong Ming, Binwei Yao, Lu Chen, Mengyue Wu
cs.AI
cs.AI, cs.CL
Chatbots can serve as a viable tool for preliminary depression diagnosis via interactive conversations with potential patients. Nevertheless, the blend of task-oriented and chit-chat in diagnosis-related dialogues necessitates professional expertise and empathy. Such unique requirements challenge traditional dialogue frameworks geared towards single optimization goals. To address this, we propose an innovative ontology definition and generation framework tailored explicitly for depression diagnosis dialogues, combining the reliability of task-oriented conversations with the appeal of empathy-related chit-chat. We further apply the framework to D$^4$, the only existing public dialogue dataset on depression diagnosis-oriented chats. Exhaustive experimental results indicate significant improvements in task completion and emotional support generation in depression diagnosis, fostering a more comprehensive approach to task-oriented chat dialogue system development and its applications in digital mental health.
[ -0.5375851392745972, -0.8540538549423218, 1.0314772129058838, 0.5002180933952332, -0.0781816840171814, -0.16469787061214447, -0.23178285360336304, -0.0789010226726532, 0.3866709768772125, 0.3820916414260864, -1.0483282804489136, -0.5949192643165588, -0.5986691117286682, 0.5123665928840637, -0.3337414562702179, 0.9088284969329834, 0.33294984698295593, 0.06388957053422928, -0.13132219016551971, 0.20665398240089417, -0.3574221730232239, -0.28926658630371094, -1.3457719087600708, -0.052405595779418945, 0.5101951360702515, 0.47040221095085144, 0.8773150444030762, 0.23747263848781586, 0.5853203535079956, 0.2962125837802887, 0.13408076763153076, 0.22890804708003998, -0.5333080887794495, 0.4547470808029175, -0.11597321182489395, -0.485912948846817, -0.8576285243034363, -0.42802557349205017, -0.15318116545677185, 0.4721029996871948, -0.27971121668815613, -0.2752867043018341, 0.2773994207382202, 0.31997430324554443, -0.22698821127414703, 0.09088817983865738, -0.28767725825309753, 0.4017292559146881, 0.1029200479388237, -0.2862015664577484, -0.056583452969789505, -0.22289864718914032, 0.10156576335430145, -0.7539582252502441, 0.11671720445156097, -0.46403828263282776, 0.42303067445755005, 0.41365930438041687, -0.10397148877382278, -0.44681432843208313, -0.5858396887779236, 0.7296125292778015, -0.6491380333900452, -0.015617890283465385, 0.7960246801376343, 0.5883084535598755, -0.35763847827911377, -0.5654897689819336, -0.4537176787853241, 0.09935310482978821, 0.10194458812475204, 0.36842718720436096, -0.4746076464653015, 0.1905871480703354, 0.05178072676062584, 0.2118794173002243, -0.29760581254959106, 0.011725475080311298, 0.26004964113235474, -0.017947951331734657, 0.5485613942146301, 0.5205906629562378, 0.49376341700553894, -0.4414415657520294, 0.011227866634726524, 0.37770819664001465, -0.058958686888217926, -0.36429935693740845, 0.15978647768497467, 0.3623133599758148, -0.3911515176296234, 0.2868168354034424, -0.14343921840190887, 0.5117565393447876, 0.27404889464378357, -0.3379742205142975, 0.016790667548775673, -0.4473153054714203, -0.04108677804470062, -0.06911403685808182, 0.7484090328216553, 0.7106367349624634, -0.030056584626436234, 0.026632044464349747, 0.006023051217198372, 0.3032394051551819, 0.5402770042419434, -0.6402779221534729, -0.598988950252533, 0.8134182691574097, -0.5466465950012207, -0.4810154139995575, -0.4999485909938812, -0.7886368036270142, -0.6094540357589722, -0.11913704127073288, 0.23218752443790436, -0.5765275359153748, -0.57168048620224, 0.13953401148319244, -0.2957913875579834, -0.46543991565704346, 0.616982102394104, -0.6547463536262512, 0.1929621696472168, 0.7038118243217468, 0.7662411332130432, 0.2902945578098297, 0.2572718858718872, -0.4476941227912903, -0.05667276307940483, -0.18598239123821259, 0.7363259792327881, -0.5222290754318237, -0.36967647075653076, -0.0037267785519361496, -0.2347434014081955, 0.2268296331167221, -0.1702764332294464, 0.7805070281028748, 0.41382652521133423, 0.45004767179489136, -0.07025406509637833, -0.38621625304222107, 0.16838805377483368, 0.718070924282074, -0.2486259639263153, 0.5790519118309021, 0.5213659405708313, -0.8859377503395081, 0.16045013070106506, -0.8295243382453918, -0.054769862443208694, 0.2065969705581665, -0.20964162051677704, -0.14022205770015717, -0.08303292840719223, -0.13550324738025665, 0.8571058511734009, -0.8026590943336487, 0.3144000172615051, -0.5355632901191711, 0.005595207214355469, 0.21576263010501862, -0.31776919960975647, 0.6216082572937012, 0.1207059994339943, -0.2881571054458618, -0.38126587867736816, -0.8222827911376953, 0.07800528407096863, 0.012746546417474747, 0.07665117084980011, -0.3185386061668396, 0.24961678683757782, -0.18180853128433228, 0.35014599561691284, 0.09315004199743271, -0.9401735067367554, -0.2384512722492218, -0.5126586556434631, 0.535734236240387, 0.5022099614143372, -0.0751861110329628, -0.00015582508058287203, -0.3675960600376129, 0.648501455783844, 0.2633354663848877, 0.5475362539291382, -0.506752073764801, -0.7723653316497803, -0.5099940896034241, -0.7718222141265869, -0.11508401483297348, 0.6420363187789917, -0.27692538499832153, 1.0015954971313477, 0.014537596143782139, -0.6441004872322083, -0.4691775441169739, -0.08291429281234741, 0.4548388719558716, 0.7101703882217407, 0.29179391264915466, -0.541846752166748, -0.47461485862731934, -0.7446057796478271, 0.15229299664497375, 0.01989521086215973, -0.2207830250263214, 0.6803053021430969, -0.2186114639043808, -0.7512800097465515, 0.9016842246055603, -0.4784148633480072, -0.5166727304458618, -0.31546711921691895, -0.05563578009605408, 0.14784660935401917, 0.34229639172554016, 0.5643677711486816, -0.6289986968040466, -0.7160030007362366, 0.08124551177024841, -0.8308486938476562, -0.11179234832525253, 0.011694708839058876, -0.4246562421321869, -0.05015963688492775, 0.05438822880387306, -0.7420818209648132, 0.7090681195259094, 0.7325618863105774, -0.5941904783248901, -0.014130634255707264, 0.056308139115571976, 0.23490957915782928, -1.4746135473251343, -0.14006991684436798, 0.004884380381554365, -0.5196160674095154, -0.617831826210022, -0.8631464838981628, -0.4285391569137573, -0.2614871859550476, -0.09267044067382812, 0.2822399437427521, 0.24463236331939697, 0.13550826907157898, -0.2693612277507782, 0.7104381322860718, 0.12726451456546783, 0.21944598853588104, -0.10329489409923553, -0.17386451363563538, 1.0418920516967773, -0.564663290977478, 0.6652944684028625, 0.9939700961112976, 0.20710356533527374, 1.1418489217758179, -0.44616690278053284, -0.11716293543577194, 0.07004683464765549, 0.3839932680130005, -1.0307669639587402, -0.2742062509059906, 0.5039914846420288, -0.5963271260261536, 0.058374714106321335, 0.1763720065355301, -0.28834134340286255, -0.3054772913455963, 0.014374786987900734, 0.3294631242752075, 0.5119868516921997, -0.31833481788635254, 0.5292240381240845, 0.26288464665412903, -0.6326211094856262, -0.10175719112157822, -0.6581662893295288, 0.11270824819803238, -0.2459603250026703, -0.8882685899734497, 0.32103341817855835, 0.05295378714799881, -0.3561006188392639, -0.11330771446228027, 0.07818029820919037, -0.09173951297998428, 0.16696706414222717, 0.3193981945514679, -0.11820374429225922, -0.04501461982727051, 0.5025619864463806, 0.24952498078346252, -0.4212663173675537, 0.17659611999988556, 0.1665095090866089, 0.8308784365653992, 0.21115615963935852, -0.42210686206817627, -0.8596683740615845, 0.6422613859176636, 0.23254331946372986, 0.464571088552475, 0.428318589925766, 0.2326132357120514, -0.21636469662189484, -0.13557292520999908, -0.26563888788223267, -0.46591293811798096, -0.4463953375816345, 0.1498708426952362, -0.4428676664829254, -0.7968574166297913, 0.4011019468307495, -0.27471572160720825, 0.22429263591766357, 0.3205913007259369, 0.6748949289321899, -0.14882583916187286, 1.670332670211792, 0.5374641418457031, 0.4805089235305786, 0.22727647423744202, 0.1982734352350235, 0.7435730695724487, -0.47153279185295105, 0.19955238699913025, -0.473219633102417, -0.14195455610752106, -0.5987821817398071, -0.19583728909492493, 0.4215048849582672, -0.0056542991660535336, -0.3061041831970215, 0.2674799859523773, -0.6607811450958252, -0.1571045070886612, -0.016026334837079048, 0.3911552429199219, 0.27135491371154785, -0.39031684398651123, 0.1654496043920517, -0.20080572366714478, -0.6217468976974487, -0.6784403324127197, 0.9424442052841187, 0.21745087206363678, 0.4243185520172119, 0.05101097747683525, 0.7593757510185242, 0.4436616003513336, 0.1773415207862854, -0.6214446425437927, 0.3256218433380127, -0.13334663212299347, -0.5031765699386597, -0.3830343782901764, -0.5918814539909363, -0.9681998491287231, -0.2552034854888916, 0.05904878303408623, -0.9392222762107849, 0.09292703866958618, 0.3953132927417755, -0.5078625679016113, -0.045075614005327225, -0.42851436138153076, 1.0652546882629395, -0.24971771240234375, 0.20116795599460602, -0.5518071055412292, -0.6806148290634155, 0.3492696285247803, -0.5504995584487915, 0.14966310560703278, -0.6207784414291382, 0.05571245029568672, 0.37738481163978577, -0.39029866456985474, 1.0700759887695312, -0.07250936329364777, -0.3864056468009949, 0.1298072338104248, 0.2754049003124237, -0.004615087062120438, 0.367539644241333, -0.1048445925116539, 0.11028486490249634, 0.26264071464538574, -0.27939295768737793, -0.9591891169548035, 0.4683833420276642, -0.7166019678115845, -0.5355489253997803, 0.15509380400180817, -0.23254001140594482, -0.5532806515693665, 0.05428869649767876, 0.23749704658985138, 0.5420480966567993, -0.3458847403526306, -0.04013099893927574, 0.2659169137477875, -0.421589732170105, -0.04932664334774017, 0.3479911983013153, -0.139143168926239, -0.14882047474384308, 0.7081089019775391, -0.4373819828033447, 0.284679651260376, 0.2379080355167389, 0.3718770444393158, 0.10441417992115021, 0.4146275818347931, 0.05191934108734131, 0.12816421687602997, -0.689241349697113, -0.5921069979667664, -1.0346177816390991, -0.07576949894428253, -0.49666711688041687, -0.3392794728279114, -0.8537415862083435, -0.7575236558914185, -0.46045342087745667, -0.13628369569778442, 0.8476056456565857, 0.5378322601318359, -0.4529922604560852, 0.1148134246468544, -1.1882859468460083, 0.4337354600429535, 0.02584122121334076, 0.36784324049949646, -0.039478231221437454, -0.16298779845237732, -0.0832633450627327, 0.3646068871021271, -0.6433224081993103, -0.6735140085220337, 0.2908056378364563, 0.3693183958530426, 0.3110964000225067, 0.8997319340705872, 0.47842937707901, 0.5224703550338745, -0.14971132576465607, 0.7824376821517944, 0.7977798581123352, -0.9993833303451538, 0.9219237565994263, -0.4619895815849304, -0.18257373571395874, 0.29923364520072937, 0.6913292407989502, -0.8038031458854675, -0.8441839814186096, -0.8816106915473938, -0.5222616195678711, 0.8845738768577576, 0.3359912931919098, 0.3220420479774475, -0.4628894627094269, 0.2190627157688141, 0.47902819514274597, -0.05694189667701721, -0.058592647314071655, -0.08791416883468628, -0.5559961199760437, -0.6291304230690002, -0.18586239218711853, -0.16907243430614471, -0.6621755361557007, -0.13866159319877625, 0.2656392753124237, -0.2552787959575653, 0.7901802062988281, 0.29965758323669434, 0.6336065530776978, -0.30976277589797974, 0.10715094953775406, 0.029837727546691895, 0.5122702717781067, 0.25107502937316895, -0.1855570524930954, -0.1731795370578766, -0.12525029480457306, -0.07326560467481613, 0.010778677649796009, 0.3800186812877655, 0.04093188792467117, -0.030824873596429825, 0.6636552214622498, 0.3177092969417572, -1.0391446352005005, 0.786930501461029, -0.37812909483909607, -0.2946964204311371, -0.3810707628726959, 0.31691524386405945, 0.2210388332605362, 0.5020402073860168, -0.014101378619670868, -0.039549101144075394, 0.11955226212739944, -0.4903838038444519, 0.34255272150039673, 0.20267905294895172, -0.6227281093597412, -0.5927799940109253, 0.24871937930583954, 0.6885024905204773, -0.7767353653907776, 0.7604176998138428, -0.16702698171138763, -0.4634402394294739, 0.3162025511264801, 0.4825610816478729, 1.0395653247833252, 0.016296613961458206, 0.6356416344642639, 0.25690731406211853, -0.48745813965797424, -0.03763321042060852, 0.5790903568267822, -0.4146997630596161, -1.0227371454238892, -0.006003987044095993, -0.4804683327674866, -0.7025822401046753, -0.2932122051715851, -0.49863022565841675, 0.45124635100364685, -0.3114963173866272, -0.7983408570289612, -0.1340225636959076, -0.30659377574920654, -0.3866739571094513, 0.3899426758289337, 0.08415169268846512, 0.4599125385284424, -0.5536588430404663, 0.3130172789096832, 0.41087284684181213, -0.10637016594409943, -0.48708489537239075, -0.0063079167157411575, 0.04906206578016281, -0.4854709804058075, 0.38950443267822266, 0.23122051358222961, 0.09962229430675507, 0.10370365530252457, -0.31276944279670715, -0.8500949144363403, 0.9824330806732178, 0.2794833183288574, -0.3977833092212677, 0.07444527000188828, 0.03233926370739937, 0.7168765664100647, -0.6599339246749878, 0.4030537009239197, 0.6010803580284119, 0.516940176486969, -0.00024328866857104003, -1.2489677667617798, 0.032872360199689865, -0.3412010669708252, -0.15681427717208862, 0.2378346025943756, -0.6509357690811157, 0.6230603456497192, 0.03620533272624016, -0.2786535620689392, 0.31817635893821716, 0.030952150002121925, 0.17860370874404907, 0.1357574313879013, 0.44173529744148254, 0.6455745697021484, 0.6721693873405457, -0.1502278745174408, 1.1121888160705566, -0.8225724697113037, 0.002686565974727273, 0.5396518111228943, -0.33956006169319153, 0.4481160640716553, 0.06177567318081856, 0.05287585034966469, 0.35027259588241577, 0.560763955116272, 0.09621898084878922, 0.21792888641357422, -0.1569916009902954, -0.2843671143054962, -0.6276905536651611, -0.36129388213157654, -0.10430232435464859, 0.5539081692695618, 0.6592195630073547, -0.475409597158432, -0.3284289538860321, 0.26001450419425964, 0.06928930431604385, 0.06306737661361694, -0.05754765123128891, 0.846808910369873, 0.2721615135669708, -0.4796781837940216, 0.4370356798171997, -0.14378401637077332, 0.36476263403892517, -0.41987326741218567, 0.05488152056932449, -0.06793033331632614, 0.3636746108531952, -0.33047381043434143, -0.6850754022598267, 0.4187335669994354, 0.19761022925376892, 0.01704188622534275, -0.40324538946151733, 0.6534415483474731, -0.12767313420772552, -0.3444381654262543, 0.5886507630348206, 0.7032506465911865, 0.46508991718292236, -0.07132015377283096, -0.7525318264961243, 0.01726434752345085, -0.10751446336507797, -0.2774065434932709, 0.3710160553455353, 0.961581289768219, 0.3802526295185089, 0.778784453868866, 0.08830860257148743, -0.12555621564388275, -0.31590384244918823, 0.03494827076792717, 0.9559821486473083, -0.5909726023674011, -0.5236338973045349, -0.4746377468109131, 0.5387511253356934, -0.12238476425409317, -0.5429854393005371, 0.6417364478111267, 0.032889772206544876, 0.43782034516334534, 0.2151644378900528, 1.1210832595825195, -0.4340028464794159, 0.9642034769058228, 0.11715634912252426, 0.5876277685165405, -0.6993135213851929, -0.2978193461894989, -0.5786855816841125, -0.806517481803894, -0.215041846036911, 0.7957456707954407, 0.014889375306665897, -0.04429866001009941, 0.5761480927467346, 0.697292149066925, 0.10298576205968857, 0.4899795353412628, 0.5332119464874268, 0.3072473704814911, 0.3919484615325928, 0.5939045548439026, 1.0724620819091797, -0.17605315148830414, 0.641787052154541, -0.21915149688720703, -0.4590451717376709, -0.2780649662017822, -0.5208665728569031, -0.9168336987495422, -0.49490973353385925, -0.4783143997192383, -0.17233365774154663, -0.00016020303883124143, 0.813737690448761, 0.3099291920661926, -0.42126813530921936, 0.16483846306800842, -0.5214856863021851, -0.21782860159873962, -0.14433646202087402, -0.274352490901947, -0.010296777822077274, -0.628847062587738, -0.6896215081214905, 0.19747738540172577, 0.6506748199462891, -0.19924522936344147, -0.41595932841300964, -0.12725138664245605, 0.4702404737472534, 0.14744825661182404, 0.5897952914237976, 0.11509673297405243, -0.45397910475730896, -0.1062825545668602, -0.22079266607761383, -0.18578681349754333, 0.2245924323797226, 0.8284545540809631, -0.4865794777870178, 0.29244065284729004, 0.2995850741863251, 0.5020434260368347, -0.04448510333895683, 0.23917655646800995, 1.109960675239563, -0.23550663888454437, -0.013962135650217533, 0.709452748298645, 0.004975582472980022, 0.3491826355457306, -0.6084195971488953, 0.3585858941078186, 0.05123632028698921, -0.6713728904724121, -0.8237224817276001, 0.4674668610095978, -0.866314709186554, -0.0806344747543335, 0.9879372715950012, -0.6005678772926331, 0.12131907790899277, -0.6462700366973877, -0.4357202649116516, 0.33233726024627686, -0.5514766573905945, 1.0775785446166992, 0.31573250889778137, -0.7706548571586609, -0.031140286475419998, -0.005098920781165361, 0.7104822993278503, 0.3457636535167694, -0.6935335993766785, 0.16667702794075012, 0.4120824933052063, -0.18268580734729767, 0.3086932301521301, 0.9636863470077515, -0.10905832797288895, 0.33619052171707153, 0.14269517362117767, -0.04848245531320572, 0.5231780409812927, -0.02915900945663452, 0.29124635457992554, 0.08381780982017517, -0.34682393074035645, 0.14756588637828827 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02314v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02314v1
A geometric framework for interstellar discourse on fundamental physical structures
2024-04-07T16:03:01
2024-04-07T16:03:01
Giampiero Esposito, Valeria Fionda
cs.IT
cs.IT, cs.CL, math.IT
This paper considers the possibility that abstract thinking and advanced synthesis skills might encourage extraterrestrial civilizations to accept communication with mankind on Earth. For this purpose, a notation not relying upon the use of alphabet and numbers is proposed, in order to denote just some basic geometric structures of current physical theories: vector fields, one-form fields, and tensor fields of arbitrary order. An advanced civilization might appreciate the way here proposed to achieve a concise description of electromagnetism and general relativity, and hence it might accept the challenge of responding to our signals. The abstract symbols introduced in this paper to describe the basic structures of physical theories are encoded into black and white bitmap images that can be easily converted into short bit sequences and modulated on a carrier wave for radio transmission.
[ -0.7106720209121704, -0.8828144073486328, 0.9575334191322327, 0.3545200228691101, -0.15914614498615265, 0.16755974292755127, 0.14993929862976074, -0.6432580351829529, 0.7254638075828552, 0.2107904702425003, -0.5335192084312439, -0.42551207542419434, -0.4537699520587921, -0.10369081050157547, -0.46656206250190735, 0.45247435569763184, 0.007277269847691059, -0.13930830359458923, -0.06415245682001114, -0.2078360766172409, -0.09252530336380005, -0.6439347267150879, -0.32016459107398987, -0.2002522349357605, 0.48464858531951904, 0.19441990554332733, 0.9219690561294556, 0.3910304307937622, 0.885726273059845, 0.34263792634010315, -0.4048784673213959, 0.06475945562124252, -0.005420949775725603, -0.22290441393852234, -0.37096667289733887, -0.26512423157691956, -0.5536654591560364, 0.11561191827058792, 0.9137012958526611, 1.2579585313796997, 0.11712715774774551, 0.3543166220188141, -0.1701822280883789, 0.7072271704673767, 0.014219245873391628, 0.09777612239122391, -0.3321133852005005, 0.32667839527130127, 0.025713583454489708, -0.43751391768455505, 0.0029855784960091114, -0.39131632447242737, 0.09504768252372742, -0.9784135818481445, 0.1377430558204651, 0.512434720993042, 0.5919735431671143, -0.017341705039143562, -0.2723132371902466, -0.31092458963394165, -0.8287234306335449, 0.07647422701120377, -0.07813281565904617, 0.4794297516345978, 0.4094948172569275, 0.4397534430027008, -0.3739294707775116, -0.6438764929771423, -0.6376521587371826, -0.37699180841445923, -0.21961474418640137, 0.28192171454429626, 0.0016483166255056858, 0.309643030166626, 0.36440104246139526, 0.5037745237350464, -0.3716387152671814, -0.12622344493865967, -1.2411848306655884, -0.0644063726067543, 0.4224805533885956, 0.3839265704154968, 0.24908052384853363, 0.34431010484695435, -0.19160926342010498, 0.07815936207771301, -1.0532736778259277, 0.031368233263492584, 0.5848714709281921, -0.03842896223068237, -0.4590110182762146, 0.6689689755439758, -0.05449299141764641, 0.42880311608314514, 0.1710033118724823, 0.5068152546882629, -0.2836969494819641, -0.11209878325462341, -0.05252645164728165, -0.18713486194610596, 0.4566614627838135, 0.5921818017959595, -0.4094926714897156, -0.37181809544563293, 0.15665650367736816, 0.5734537243843079, 0.4872306287288666, -0.7211867570877075, -0.3016952872276306, 0.2324652522802353, -0.6225146651268005, -0.07778559625148773, 0.48614850640296936, -0.542412281036377, -0.178768128156662, -0.31865525245666504, 0.1449880599975586, -0.050960130989551544, -0.213351309299469, 0.21255742013454437, 0.07002761960029602, 0.13838665187358856, 0.21394522488117218, -1.1232950687408447, 0.4532063603401184, 0.5994282960891724, 0.6981865167617798, 0.6452888250350952, -0.19587264955043793, 0.30498063564300537, 0.3539767861366272, -0.40977227687835693, 1.1369074583053589, -0.3809714913368225, -1.0335055589675903, -0.33736252784729004, 0.020243249833583832, 0.5837241411209106, -0.002629973692819476, 0.5725224018096924, -0.41016438603401184, 0.4145675599575043, -0.5834102034568787, -0.32143351435661316, -0.8357234001159668, 0.138591006398201, -0.5839606523513794, 0.3926045894622803, 0.1584727168083191, -0.3142823278903961, 0.16874711215496063, -1.0135759115219116, -0.22740866243839264, 0.6239359378814697, -0.6232631206512451, -0.19346632063388824, 0.3056682348251343, -0.17676864564418793, 0.12120821326971054, -0.43904221057891846, -0.04551652818918228, -0.47176024317741394, -0.42071056365966797, 0.28736382722854614, -0.06077910214662552, 0.21200157701969147, 0.5289639830589294, -0.3325592577457428, -0.09331458806991577, -0.8023330569267273, 0.3244662880897522, -0.11420806497335434, -0.3981894850730896, -0.06552358716726303, 0.1991731971502304, 0.11052801460027695, 0.31793275475502014, -0.12461387366056442, -0.6834176182746887, 0.43322300910949707, -0.4688768684864044, 0.6386946439743042, 0.7145477533340454, -0.029059631749987602, 0.8337860107421875, -0.27285444736480713, 0.37316110730171204, -0.21218600869178772, 0.013414743356406689, -0.2995049059391022, -0.3065100610256195, -0.7597253918647766, -0.09783586859703064, -0.42438939213752747, 0.20748306810855865, -0.36811932921409607, 0.5157455205917358, -0.16366207599639893, -0.6029125452041626, -0.22458913922309875, -0.37993544340133667, 0.5256192684173584, 0.3838094472885132, 0.32497549057006836, -0.11357365548610687, -0.7560296654701233, -0.7564198970794678, -0.14972566068172455, -0.5051034688949585, 0.06001439318060875, 0.26576074957847595, 0.2890854477882385, -0.17743022739887238, 0.5433568954467773, -0.4115394651889801, 0.07928577810525894, 0.3032585382461548, -0.1233031302690506, 0.30524784326553345, 0.6092119216918945, 0.4315077066421509, -0.7755423784255981, -0.07763314247131348, 0.3292161524295807, -1.0094197988510132, 0.2847539186477661, 0.016444191336631775, -0.3933704197406769, -0.34554553031921387, 0.6932668089866638, -0.5668769478797913, 0.20153489708900452, 0.3222663998603821, -1.0860203504562378, -0.033497635275125504, -0.17438820004463196, 0.3501124382019043, -0.7939063310623169, 0.31969884037971497, 0.11058541387319565, -0.19451257586479187, -0.466142863035202, 0.3081352710723877, -0.20599503815174103, -0.2959060072898865, -0.5506286025047302, 0.36854156851768494, -0.47926726937294006, -0.23437336087226868, -0.1447591781616211, -0.1854277402162552, 0.04560859501361847, 0.3077391982078552, 0.22134873270988464, 0.3647978603839874, 0.3540705144405365, -0.8027217388153076, 0.19700756669044495, 0.5837313532829285, -0.21514299511909485, 0.9217351675033569, -0.9085475206375122, 0.11155929416418076, -0.7414849400520325, 0.4824405014514923, -0.6976470351219177, 0.028088685125112534, 0.4661681652069092, -0.3330388367176056, -0.15781863033771515, -0.12567853927612305, -0.0724850669503212, -0.28569117188453674, 0.13582956790924072, 0.5829440951347351, 0.1534036546945572, -0.1897038370370865, 0.5618152618408203, 0.41808584332466125, -0.2338341474533081, 0.06079418584704399, -0.4956344664096832, -0.03250354155898094, -0.2782701849937439, -0.9449028372764587, 0.4438195526599884, -0.126369908452034, -0.7091532349586487, 0.09338601678609848, 0.08361095190048218, -0.01535133458673954, 0.12254612892866135, 0.6692435145378113, 0.6488547325134277, -0.4219328463077545, -0.17972147464752197, -0.0031406430061906576, -0.29308709502220154, 0.059926312416791916, -0.7562623620033264, 0.2884916663169861, -0.7111833095550537, -0.06787846982479095, -0.41946133971214294, 0.8002605438232422, 0.762116014957428, 0.4127906858921051, 0.2697486877441406, 0.2634665071964264, -0.4749102294445038, 0.41395047307014465, -0.23954501748085022, -0.1901981383562088, -0.5078290700912476, 0.3389620780944824, -0.47648587822914124, -0.7342633605003357, 0.4299718141555786, -0.12866608798503876, 0.4394383132457733, 0.5670902729034424, 0.42784014344215393, -0.642501175403595, 0.789857029914856, 0.874168872833252, 0.47467416524887085, 0.21816478669643402, -0.516667366027832, 0.14428803324699402, -0.8541285991668701, -0.5975940227508545, -0.4945746958255768, -0.442893385887146, -0.2692846655845642, -0.3329470455646515, 0.4984641671180725, 0.12101741135120392, -0.5323106050491333, 0.4748735725879669, -0.8887163996696472, 0.7259325981140137, 0.16357222199440002, -0.14327684044837952, 0.20546847581863403, 0.21282559633255005, 0.027337530627846718, 0.03962269797921181, -0.29342231154441833, -0.9677595496177673, 0.7012248635292053, 0.5727618336677551, 0.9235209822654724, 0.3872285783290863, 0.2819235324859619, 0.18315358459949493, 0.3136298656463623, -0.5286804437637329, 0.3909405469894409, -0.038523927330970764, -0.6695288419723511, 0.2047518789768219, -0.22262170910835266, -0.7387502193450928, 0.5710877776145935, -0.6172833442687988, -0.4124341607093811, 0.3665390908718109, 0.1336263120174408, -0.6830318570137024, 0.22326859831809998, -0.8689826726913452, 0.32867756485939026, -0.006767737213522196, 0.14904142916202545, -0.33536770939826965, -0.5920519232749939, 0.19966982305049896, 0.5014828443527222, 0.5020490288734436, -0.11649812012910843, 0.07733331620693207, 0.5467582941055298, -0.2779369354248047, 0.6048653721809387, -0.07455862313508987, -0.1766425520181656, 0.6449158787727356, 0.34360814094543457, -0.05278376489877701, 0.5630252957344055, 0.37576624751091003, 0.330660343170166, 0.2922760546207428, -0.30848783254623413, -0.36513224244117737, 0.42872098088264465, -0.9179982542991638, -0.45176979899406433, -0.2893553674221039, -0.5467014312744141, 0.040293138474226, 0.12756386399269104, 0.49220970273017883, 0.5548276305198669, -0.40732601284980774, 0.026954757049679756, 0.4890347123146057, 0.036251310259103775, 0.3446178436279297, 0.45947161316871643, -0.45601314306259155, -0.5063136219978333, 0.5120826959609985, -0.046149350702762604, 0.15378770232200623, 0.431258887052536, -0.189402237534523, -0.4597463309764862, -0.23173896968364716, -0.41513538360595703, 0.18857406079769135, -1.013124942779541, 0.11301819235086441, -0.699443519115448, -0.11783579736948013, 0.04818258434534073, -0.7223904728889465, -0.2942483425140381, -0.8813815712928772, -0.03598944842815399, -0.2908064126968384, 0.14333954453468323, 1.1555273532867432, 0.04528138041496277, 0.6503741145133972, -0.692743718624115, 0.43205776810646057, -0.17897187173366547, 0.3861478865146637, -0.3046809434890747, -0.22551363706588745, -0.33845433592796326, 0.1413695216178894, -0.53880774974823, -0.08967527747154236, -0.1514977514743805, -0.029953207820653915, 0.38646310567855835, 0.1344633400440216, -0.7490978240966797, 0.86715167760849, -0.7149593830108643, 0.5291377902030945, 0.6479764580726624, -0.9314053058624268, 0.29460954666137695, -0.3622592091560364, 0.06592565029859543, 0.393648624420166, 0.1646711230278015, -0.6727394461631775, -0.301084965467453, -0.843957781791687, -0.6473990678787231, 0.09202070534229279, -0.039614636451005936, 0.07846329361200333, 0.008069343864917755, 0.4729982614517212, 0.14248034358024597, 0.010161690413951874, -0.9285028576850891, -0.4967518150806427, -0.27358072996139526, -0.07784242928028107, 0.11976475268602371, 0.12294576317071915, -0.49753719568252563, -0.11687516421079636, 0.22581259906291962, 0.010369300842285156, 0.6710082292556763, 0.5608152151107788, -0.014813952147960663, -0.24462783336639404, 0.12771174311637878, 0.7956544756889343, 0.783280611038208, 0.1090473160147667, 0.31622442603111267, -0.33269885182380676, -0.7176501154899597, 0.40305113792419434, -0.14066384732723236, -0.020762622356414795, -0.07522091269493103, 0.16809363663196564, 0.5449656248092651, 0.03336500748991966, 0.03085475228726864, -0.08932674676179886, -0.31546181440353394, -0.3620491027832031, -0.5420747399330139, -0.3175278604030609, 0.0646008849143982, 0.41930991411209106, 0.40642452239990234, 0.393412321805954, 0.03055569715797901, -0.9173051714897156, 0.05401347577571869, 0.4229706823825836, -0.44709280133247375, -0.9492758512496948, 1.0710047483444214, 0.39020970463752747, -0.07269751280546188, 0.1788904368877411, 0.01057337038218975, -0.32392457127571106, 0.4986315667629242, 0.559709370136261, 0.571855902671814, 0.2165514975786209, 0.120679572224617, 0.3624987006187439, 0.5716872811317444, 0.12958727777004242, 0.680191159248352, 0.004354532808065414, -0.3793048560619354, -0.26675280928611755, -0.6761584877967834, -0.4194619059562683, -0.519085705280304, -0.061309926211833954, 0.4308127760887146, -1.2180142402648926, -0.08402597904205322, 0.23790806531906128, -0.18070410192012787, -0.5959705710411072, 0.12419232726097107, 0.6385996341705322, 0.8434394598007202, -0.5836833119392395, 0.3354198634624481, 0.9943177103996277, -0.6009668707847595, -0.6792620420455933, -0.6186836361885071, -0.02476387657225132, -0.44393113255500793, 0.8558493256568909, 0.05799148231744766, -0.30568602681159973, 0.05383003503084183, -0.5246390104293823, -1.0767778158187866, 0.9175766706466675, 0.29587849974632263, -0.46820417046546936, -0.05988019332289696, 0.07657835632562637, 0.31701555848121643, -0.2683650255203247, 0.2794366478919983, 0.20061276853084564, 0.4975438714027405, 0.14991052448749542, -0.5861623287200928, 0.07121884077787399, -0.5629753470420837, 0.09795009344816208, 0.42508208751678467, -0.6862361431121826, 0.9314962029457092, -0.23435981571674347, -0.5342899560928345, 0.3502323031425476, 0.9877240061759949, 0.06664074957370758, 0.1614457368850708, 0.06516595929861069, 0.42794543504714966, 0.40472543239593506, -0.23194415867328644, 0.86286461353302, -0.08516508340835571, 0.4099620580673218, 0.18582375347614288, 0.12151935696601868, -0.08194282650947571, 0.5416776537895203, -0.66188645362854, 0.5236219763755798, 0.4618988037109375, 0.0002598930732347071, 0.41427549719810486, 0.05904977023601532, -0.2718461751937866, 0.22785384953022003, 0.12744037806987762, -0.7146584987640381, 0.5267696380615234, 0.9424683451652527, -0.13924744725227356, -0.23184634745121002, -0.2481871247291565, -0.009677175432443619, 0.1814032793045044, -0.6114203929901123, 0.6656439900398254, 0.40724191069602966, -0.48845618963241577, 0.5537575483322144, 0.12974503636360168, 0.6135171055793762, -0.6091926693916321, -0.2760164439678192, 0.1362130343914032, -0.027820607647299767, -0.47969746589660645, -0.7251968383789062, 0.598827064037323, -0.41101038455963135, -0.16192305088043213, -0.2605043351650238, 0.21357713639736176, -0.34675535559654236, -0.6626656651496887, -0.35181868076324463, -0.046569567173719406, 0.1928236186504364, 0.2590552866458893, -0.28082597255706787, 0.03390781581401825, -0.31931108236312866, 0.19565927982330322, -0.08212939649820328, 0.11106418073177338, -0.08840731531381607, 0.2814139425754547, 0.9818326234817505, 0.22531384229660034, 0.18594792485237122, -0.6354630589485168, 0.8323291540145874, -1.2022687196731567, -1.2326955795288086, -0.7288665175437927, 0.4409320652484894, 0.1860818713903427, -0.4543187618255615, 0.40392935276031494, 0.415519654750824, 0.596794843673706, -0.04471566155552864, 0.8907841444015503, -0.4772214889526367, -0.04238627478480339, -0.6544701457023621, 0.6311357617378235, 0.15650694072246552, 0.20235607028007507, -0.34597381949424744, -1.2818541526794434, -0.5553764700889587, 0.7370583415031433, 0.012422795407474041, -0.25344982743263245, 0.8402262926101685, 0.27445316314697266, -0.025566961616277695, 0.46623870730400085, 0.33529525995254517, 0.059482142329216, 0.6319658756256104, 0.46114382147789, 1.2557097673416138, -0.41623297333717346, 0.21170373260974884, -0.06086821109056473, -0.14787131547927856, 0.07005225867033005, -0.4978540241718292, -0.4748813509941101, -0.7206243872642517, -0.1077064648270607, -0.5295487642288208, -0.2706494629383087, 0.9573513865470886, 0.6552560925483704, -0.2777206599712372, -0.07813354581594467, -0.2457663118839264, -0.22726546227931976, 0.22943934798240662, -0.11482678353786469, 0.3968353867530823, 0.07226133346557617, -0.6334220170974731, 0.46003028750419617, 0.7352080345153809, 0.48045429587364197, -0.4286545217037201, 0.06658639013767242, 0.4019129276275635, 0.05116923898458481, 0.9290512204170227, 0.8299793004989624, -0.5290389657020569, -0.535872757434845, -0.029022566974163055, -0.051120854914188385, -0.05218270421028137, 1.1446541547775269, -0.6813058853149414, 0.015318693593144417, 0.06601130217313766, 0.312471479177475, 0.214712992310524, -0.008792850188910961, 0.5802080035209656, -0.27277934551239014, 0.9919284582138062, 0.36500105261802673, 0.5971856713294983, 0.21328221261501312, -0.5942480564117432, 0.39869070053100586, 0.2872678339481354, -0.41783249378204346, -0.6129773855209351, 0.4709221422672272, -0.89691162109375, -0.14185988903045654, 0.81535804271698, 0.047115493565797806, -0.30813589692115784, -0.2657773196697235, -0.3102276921272278, -0.33687469363212585, 0.06215042248368263, 0.8531091213226318, 0.5590919256210327, -0.12840114533901215, 0.2719188332557678, -0.2822381556034088, 0.22289161384105682, 0.22011330723762512, -0.7430853247642517, -0.3119456470012665, 0.6755837798118591, 0.04462260752916336, 0.48625287413597107, 0.9064924120903015, -0.5929428339004517, 0.3890015482902527, 0.302591472864151, -0.0646900087594986, 0.055512405931949615, -0.40498146414756775, -0.15074759721755981, -0.02604009211063385, -0.043094221502542496, -0.035104718059301376 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04997v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04997v2
Adapting LLMs for Efficient Context Processing through Soft Prompt Compression
2024-04-07T15:44:20
2024-04-18T23:23:53
Cangqing Wang, Yutian Yang, Ruisi Li, Dan Sun, Ruicong Cai, Yuzhu Zhang, Chengqian Fu, Lillian Floyd
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has inaugurated a transformative epoch in natural language processing, fostering unprecedented proficiency in text generation, comprehension, and contextual scrutiny. Nevertheless, effectively handling extensive contexts, crucial for myriad applications, poses a formidable obstacle owing to the intrinsic constraints of the models' context window sizes and the computational burdens entailed by their operations. This investigation presents an innovative framework that strategically tailors LLMs for streamlined context processing by harnessing the synergies among natural language summarization, soft prompt compression, and augmented utility preservation mechanisms. Our methodology, dubbed SoftPromptComp, amalgamates natural language prompts extracted from summarization methodologies with dynamically generated soft prompts to forge a concise yet semantically robust depiction of protracted contexts. This depiction undergoes further refinement via a weighting mechanism optimizing information retention and utility for subsequent tasks. We substantiate that our framework markedly diminishes computational overhead and enhances LLMs' efficacy across various benchmarks, while upholding or even augmenting the caliber of the produced content. By amalgamating soft prompt compression with sophisticated summarization, SoftPromptComp confronts the dual challenges of managing lengthy contexts and ensuring model scalability. Our findings point towards a propitious trajectory for augmenting LLMs' applicability and efficiency, rendering them more versatile and pragmatic for real-world applications. This research enriches the ongoing discourse on optimizing language models, providing insights into the potency of soft prompts and summarization techniques as pivotal instruments for the forthcoming generation of NLP solutions.
[ -0.36081814765930176, -0.7445231080055237, 0.6336296200752258, 0.27451279759407043, -0.4190564751625061, -0.10625133663415909, -0.6540520191192627, -0.12604832649230957, 0.024802491068840027, 0.39789605140686035, -0.6763787269592285, -0.4141997992992401, -0.40640708804130554, 0.46902763843536377, -0.2316669523715973, 1.0643372535705566, 0.059702690690755844, -0.3248746693134308, -0.33744463324546814, -0.2682795822620392, -0.619526207447052, -0.42857590317726135, -0.4260927438735962, -0.12386298179626465, 0.2234424650669098, 0.4232357442378998, 0.7550925612449646, 0.3529210388660431, 0.23934412002563477, 0.4001534581184387, -0.3796260356903076, 0.3043624758720398, -0.4321982264518738, 0.7798984050750732, 0.06592229008674622, -0.05946533754467964, -0.3920077979564667, -0.200204536318779, 0.8489469885826111, 0.9984210133552551, -0.22119806706905365, 0.09601712226867676, 0.5980009436607361, 0.4844658076763153, -0.6452889442443848, 0.1190706342458725, -0.5738062262535095, -0.07971382886171341, 0.12241490185260773, -0.6200454235076904, -0.2995997667312622, -0.2283710539340973, 0.12887141108512878, -0.4210961163043976, 0.13135290145874023, -0.20035837590694427, 0.2856850028038025, 0.35209184885025024, -0.4112210273742676, -0.27627047896385193, -0.6156908273696899, 0.6619760394096375, -0.7815448045730591, 0.071385957300663, -0.243740051984787, 0.20194494724273682, -0.43587037920951843, -0.8579456210136414, -0.39061757922172546, -0.06500722467899323, 0.021127402782440186, -0.02478187344968319, -0.09875550121068954, 0.161050483584404, 0.21309009194374084, 0.334107905626297, -0.44739991426467896, 0.12612104415893555, 0.057081952691078186, -0.3376823663711548, 0.3576589822769165, 0.4220350682735443, 0.23211349546909332, -0.2745288610458374, -0.41788768768310547, 0.09590525180101395, -0.6805375814437866, 0.17589740455150604, 0.06300707161426544, 0.6505885124206543, -0.15961697697639465, 0.4659324884414673, -0.25922444462776184, 0.7717419862747192, -0.20930057764053345, -0.3344739079475403, 0.02029687538743019, -0.4577505886554718, -0.17202076315879822, 0.010473700240254402, 0.6144067645072937, 0.449057936668396, 0.25666627287864685, -0.2567422389984131, -0.348497599363327, -0.1287050098180771, 0.17304286360740662, -0.872136116027832, 0.29622867703437805, 0.4180457890033722, -0.3301902413368225, -0.08440767228603363, -0.260709673166275, -0.6322483420372009, -0.4163227081298828, -0.5262652039527893, 0.14007468521595, -0.32071346044540405, -0.11132965236902237, 0.18884727358818054, -0.027603013440966606, -0.043193455785512924, 0.4640927016735077, -0.8148533701896667, 0.35351186990737915, 0.9182645678520203, 1.1741187572479248, -0.189597025513649, 0.07090453803539276, -0.6540164947509766, 0.15318483114242554, -0.08545728772878647, 0.8256932497024536, -0.3997950255870819, -0.4640246033668518, 0.3076857924461365, -0.03515560179948807, 0.14049367606639862, -0.5601864457130432, 0.7878366708755493, -0.30010515451431274, 0.14785918593406677, -0.0483885332942009, -0.4764905571937561, 0.07539309561252594, 0.3154447376728058, -0.6854914426803589, 0.7916185259819031, 0.09686905890703201, -0.619323194026947, 0.129352405667305, -0.37357082962989807, -0.5736339688301086, 0.33192703127861023, 0.03170605003833771, -0.10798902064561844, 0.4608391225337982, 0.19521978497505188, 0.7430132031440735, -0.35332226753234863, 0.6620418429374695, -0.1215650886297226, -0.45711541175842285, 0.16816894710063934, -0.4456757605075836, 0.5563339591026306, 0.1456495225429535, -0.14627842605113983, 0.32465702295303345, -0.5074620842933655, -0.18669910728931427, 0.020620649680495262, -0.5130465030670166, -0.33687156438827515, -0.05086206644773483, 0.16750949621200562, 0.14052847027778625, 0.38062888383865356, -0.08069800585508347, 0.3927316665649414, -0.543759286403656, 0.5365583300590515, 0.7545682191848755, -0.11584801226854324, 0.775914192199707, -0.14079537987709045, 0.5726540088653564, -0.2336200326681137, 0.1079878881573677, -0.7124873995780945, -0.1313733160495758, -0.40012410283088684, -0.3087989091873169, 0.13925834000110626, 0.5439354181289673, -0.7522693872451782, 0.47209081053733826, -0.4575498700141907, -0.12055745720863342, -0.18893863260746002, 0.2464517056941986, 0.03996184468269348, 0.8123153448104858, 0.26703545451164246, -0.1414824277162552, -0.43340614438056946, -0.8719096779823303, -0.41721010208129883, 0.12420240044593811, -0.32959672808647156, 0.20064860582351685, 0.12425346672534943, -0.06066855043172836, 1.1407089233398438, -0.42715364694595337, -0.347501665353775, -0.8112059831619263, 0.259052574634552, 0.6119484901428223, 0.4592178463935852, 0.46041738986968994, -0.9079916477203369, -0.16133563220500946, -0.5952994227409363, -0.5480329990386963, -0.5648642182350159, -0.33678361773490906, 0.03408447280526161, 0.10934899002313614, 0.5046864151954651, -0.6637054681777954, 0.10851450264453888, 0.4524580240249634, -0.3318707048892975, 0.7064337134361267, -0.20987465977668762, -0.03033490478992462, -1.1002349853515625, 0.08254050463438034, -0.007485233247280121, -0.4353395104408264, -0.7121037244796753, 0.11761046946048737, 0.021410420536994934, -0.11056573688983917, -0.617789089679718, 0.6521461606025696, -0.6038191318511963, 0.10674998909235, -0.48686954379081726, 0.20710456371307373, 0.12560684978961945, 0.4402121603488922, 0.1311727613210678, 0.8261332511901855, 0.3214990198612213, -0.7727671265602112, 0.11602573841810226, 0.07522210478782654, -0.2275068610906601, 0.48887190222740173, -0.64833003282547, -0.1502874493598938, -0.35915040969848633, 0.6140355467796326, -0.8424097299575806, -0.16994088888168335, 0.0032442945521324873, 0.001351296785287559, 0.34201109409332275, -0.184261292219162, -0.6574726700782776, 0.037044622004032135, -0.6810771822929382, 0.4140464961528778, 0.6022348999977112, -0.3651508688926697, 0.9424263834953308, 0.2948130965232849, -0.5858249664306641, -0.30207639932632446, -0.4819285273551941, 0.463981568813324, -0.38443300127983093, -0.5985158681869507, 0.6381804943084717, -0.2299494743347168, -0.3240262269973755, -0.20270280539989471, -0.11699286103248596, 0.240243062376976, 0.3143850564956665, 0.20032763481140137, 0.22159066796302795, -0.08146442472934723, 0.00635794410482049, 0.20488739013671875, -0.29467588663101196, -0.09313870966434479, -0.23954664170742035, 0.5445435643196106, -0.002305084839463234, 0.09785617142915726, -0.156686469912529, 0.579873263835907, 0.40300557017326355, 0.2658141255378723, 0.800858736038208, 0.5124185681343079, -0.4154569208621979, -0.2705836594104767, -0.5031261444091797, -0.17464859783649445, -0.5653064250946045, 0.16632474958896637, -0.19655907154083252, -1.1253582239151, 0.5525396466255188, -0.45045948028564453, 0.3870075047016144, 0.18838462233543396, 0.5725302696228027, 0.24557653069496155, 1.0269217491149902, 0.6519411206245422, 0.0831313282251358, 0.5598292350769043, -0.033498868346214294, 0.14573784172534943, -0.9785214066505432, -0.16678939759731293, -0.4419693648815155, -0.2590107321739197, -0.33756622672080994, -0.28318363428115845, 0.6216551065444946, 0.0544007271528244, 0.03479427099227905, 0.19468536972999573, -0.3857426345348358, 0.44390320777893066, 0.31903374195098877, -0.07145348191261292, 0.20491619408130646, -0.12650996446609497, 0.0037051558028906584, -0.19323278963565826, -0.8900068402290344, -0.7510470151901245, 0.6386693716049194, 0.22257757186889648, 0.5830071568489075, 0.21662653982639313, 0.45078352093696594, 0.37403860688209534, 0.2965461015701294, -0.8527292609214783, 0.8737965822219849, -0.19113841652870178, -0.05030910670757294, -0.008723465725779533, -0.5075616836547852, -0.9630373120307922, 0.3004004657268524, -0.24281392991542816, -0.6343377232551575, -0.03442855179309845, 0.17451998591423035, -0.5618806481361389, 0.011203695088624954, -0.6882923245429993, 0.7050158977508545, -0.02224775403738022, -0.7227548360824585, 0.007736608386039734, -0.6235032677650452, 0.3927227556705475, 0.08210378140211105, 0.37543097138404846, -0.25310274958610535, -0.4959781765937805, 0.6074662804603577, -0.5011257529258728, 0.779537558555603, -0.12787602841854095, -0.3907146155834198, 0.29701247811317444, 0.20395243167877197, 0.4820452332496643, 0.2478003203868866, -0.11338897049427032, -0.05753491818904877, -0.30087488889694214, -0.23323015868663788, -0.702684223651886, 0.7039363980293274, -0.03260108083486557, -0.5787110924720764, -0.26992133259773254, -0.727155327796936, -0.2537723481655121, 0.10257579386234283, 0.15970046818256378, 0.9943828582763672, -0.1524364948272705, 0.09815765917301178, 0.5870212912559509, -0.3875671923160553, 0.7767642736434937, 0.47627976536750793, 0.24635615944862366, -0.2776589095592499, 0.5589556097984314, -0.03364381194114685, 0.04251256585121155, 0.29970496892929077, 0.20466412603855133, -0.4859289824962616, -0.7313855886459351, -0.21063612401485443, 0.04380471631884575, -0.8135565519332886, -0.5416141152381897, -0.7005179524421692, 0.12314119189977646, -0.6777634620666504, -0.4888889193534851, -0.08301263302564621, -0.4396820068359375, -0.4702795445919037, 0.19262459874153137, 0.16643796861171722, 0.4321516454219818, 0.08081011474132538, 0.3134109079837799, -0.8552545309066772, 0.3787117302417755, 0.10666245967149734, 0.18019172549247742, -0.10041127353906631, -0.5948196053504944, -0.032667823135852814, -0.24086281657218933, -0.05132127180695534, -0.9050803184509277, 0.5801289677619934, 0.4539559781551361, 0.31015288829803467, 0.19738136231899261, 0.3820061683654785, 0.613531768321991, -0.6237733364105225, 1.025272011756897, 0.07330923527479172, -0.9080032706260681, 0.5695029497146606, -0.29125383496284485, 0.7990247011184692, 0.7573036551475525, 0.17548131942749023, -0.5478278994560242, -0.35416358709335327, -0.4370797872543335, -1.576442003250122, 0.48315930366516113, 0.0962112545967102, 0.42401859164237976, -0.04002305492758751, 0.5404938459396362, 0.21713745594024658, 0.22342965006828308, -0.47348156571388245, 0.0929739847779274, 0.06648070365190506, -0.5419014096260071, -0.10085548460483551, -0.49075162410736084, -0.08252569288015366, 0.010370256379246712, 0.39380037784576416, -0.4864419102668762, -0.023303667083382607, 0.1904195100069046, -0.44529592990875244, 0.28632107377052307, 0.5696526765823364, 0.6173888444900513, 0.46962782740592957, -0.020407630130648613, 0.4027399718761444, 0.2952064871788025, -0.4019288718700409, 0.09405800700187683, 0.05967690795660019, -0.17131666839122772, 0.05152396112680435, 0.6497625708580017, 0.5492939352989197, 0.7246389389038086, -1.0387089252471924, 0.5529718399047852, -0.3032434582710266, 0.1732051968574524, -0.2131006121635437, 0.18915164470672607, -0.13898424804210663, 0.26754528284072876, 0.6175657510757446, -0.12620338797569275, 0.5475404858589172, -0.5319311022758484, 0.0664510577917099, 0.5033637881278992, 0.08608869463205338, -0.3445115387439728, 0.545405924320221, 0.4092949330806732, -0.24037931859493256, 0.3829444646835327, -0.09076115489006042, -0.6052090525627136, 0.37227579951286316, 0.5266214609146118, 0.9479773044586182, 0.030750419944524765, -0.042907748371362686, 0.24094583094120026, 0.03411164879798889, -0.2932789623737335, -0.02316848561167717, -0.49581900238990784, -0.4210680425167084, -0.650287926197052, -0.7863721251487732, -0.44486528635025024, 0.035051219165325165, -0.4634740948677063, 0.3189472556114197, -0.4397302567958832, -0.2805250585079193, -0.4595640003681183, -0.023997677490115166, -0.5378249883651733, 0.04860338196158409, 0.2752864360809326, 1.1646010875701904, -0.7535114288330078, 0.2581620514392853, 0.575234055519104, 0.09816904366016388, -0.609512209892273, 0.004564220551401377, 0.11800137907266617, -0.42694026231765747, 0.19506442546844482, 0.5788240432739258, -0.09067980945110321, -0.05468560755252838, -0.4904485046863556, -0.5352842807769775, 0.9644370675086975, 0.5826245546340942, -0.5851196050643921, 0.12437578290700912, -0.0736200138926506, 0.5082079172134399, -0.31977131962776184, 0.25963377952575684, 0.6692230701446533, 0.37350893020629883, 0.1365334540605545, -0.7120052576065063, 0.44349217414855957, -0.3702143728733063, 0.005790048744529486, 0.10383430868387222, -0.30244553089141846, 0.4194931983947754, -0.14994150400161743, -0.49074220657348633, 0.11068645864725113, 0.7901763319969177, 0.2921048402786255, 0.23558370769023895, 0.601607084274292, 0.10218033194541931, 0.4076981246471405, -0.11339221149682999, 1.0812029838562012, -0.34677016735076904, 0.03598326817154884, 0.9871218204498291, -0.3466053009033203, 0.5778682827949524, 0.5539191961288452, 0.09905727952718735, 0.45546361804008484, 0.5242910981178284, 0.4558389484882355, 0.47727441787719727, 0.01629888266324997, -0.5231639742851257, -0.15090075135231018, -0.5379428267478943, -0.1498842090368271, 0.24521146714687347, 0.34987151622772217, -0.037331148982048035, -0.320140540599823, 0.08358675986528397, 0.18106816709041595, 0.21260420978069305, -0.28261294960975647, 0.8822334408760071, 0.10501567274332047, -0.9420822858810425, 0.44340890645980835, 0.0670345276594162, 1.1163880825042725, -0.7625405788421631, 0.07578472048044205, -0.24827735126018524, -0.047652728855609894, -0.06936976313591003, -0.7634100914001465, 0.38982531428337097, 0.19963154196739197, 0.046280231326818466, -0.7898217439651489, 0.9756618142127991, -0.4035520851612091, -0.25665321946144104, 0.0800543949007988, 0.33969515562057495, -0.013653893023729324, -0.15945741534233093, -0.604373574256897, 0.3005130887031555, -0.45832163095474243, -0.5271841287612915, 0.31983351707458496, 0.5390073657035828, 0.09798086434602737, 0.6313949227333069, 0.5769539475440979, 0.2432866245508194, -0.39951202273368835, 0.38936150074005127, 1.0017271041870117, -0.6399838328361511, -0.7090760469436646, -1.0509343147277832, 0.6346168518066406, -0.0367107056081295, -0.23421238362789154, 0.5886541604995728, 0.44004446268081665, 0.1862313449382782, 0.2255854606628418, 0.5925379991531372, 0.018147844821214676, 0.12761257588863373, -0.6898704171180725, 0.24602514505386353, -0.5329307913780212, 0.5378588438034058, -0.3095638155937195, -0.9115911722183228, -0.46319064497947693, 0.26420140266418457, -0.1358867585659027, 0.08044980466365814, 0.33857858180999756, 0.5447495579719543, -0.056385889649391174, -0.1023063138127327, -0.010738187469542027, 0.09281928837299347, 0.30858394503593445, 0.5389276146888733, 0.5852256417274475, 0.11263219267129898, 0.45364293456077576, -0.038613494485616684, -0.4284569025039673, -0.3566933274269104, -1.3968967199325562, -0.6589673161506653, -0.5808833241462708, -0.25743284821510315, -0.11385177075862885, -0.1313326060771942, 0.9990746974945068, 0.6387067437171936, -0.4720394015312195, -0.04443833976984024, -0.09951333701610565, 0.09882933646440506, -0.09537138789892197, -0.29940539598464966, 0.20012183487415314, -0.5008857250213623, -0.7212691903114319, 0.5338050723075867, 0.5736916661262512, 0.15138119459152222, -0.376836359500885, -0.041726529598236084, 0.18379077315330505, 0.16157139837741852, 0.8717250227928162, 0.13009673357009888, -0.4099672734737396, 0.12048337608575821, -0.13835428655147552, -0.029236167669296265, -0.20538386702537537, 1.1762584447860718, -1.1356159448623657, 0.07003132998943329, 0.7103723287582397, 0.5207224488258362, -0.04510436952114105, 0.2284139096736908, 0.7873097658157349, -1.0430816411972046, 0.4310952126979828, 0.42066362500190735, 0.4676658511161804, 0.6941582560539246, -0.48642900586128235, 0.3939107060432434, 0.05168839544057846, -0.3197482228279114, -1.169650673866272, 0.232092946767807, -1.1119921207427979, -0.6979200839996338, 1.2508082389831543, 0.04396717622876167, -0.31731554865837097, -0.16454733908176422, -0.2712697982788086, 0.27489137649536133, -0.4519513249397278, 0.6274924278259277, 0.39761701226234436, -0.08906586468219757, -0.0794481486082077, -0.4419000744819641, 0.4821721613407135, 0.5665058493614197, -0.8133326768875122, 0.3021044433116913, 0.6332816481590271, 0.08094000816345215, -0.04577687010169029, 0.6938487887382507, 0.12078346312046051, 0.022471971809864044, -0.4069403111934662, -0.3693976104259491, -0.2644450068473816, -0.31508639454841614, -0.7492572665214539, 0.5843033194541931, -0.2406344711780548, 0.3241954445838928 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04990v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04990v1
MLaKE: Multilingual Knowledge Editing Benchmark for Large Language Models
2024-04-07T15:23:28
2024-04-07T15:23:28
Zihao Wei, Jingcheng Deng, Liang Pang, Hanxing Ding, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
cs.CL
cs.CL
The extensive utilization of large language models (LLMs) underscores the crucial necessity for precise and contemporary knowledge embedded within their intrinsic parameters. Existing research on knowledge editing primarily concentrates on monolingual scenarios, neglecting the complexities presented by multilingual contexts and multi-hop reasoning. To address these challenges, our study introduces MLaKE (Multilingual Language Knowledge Editing), a novel benchmark comprising 4072 multi-hop and 5360 single-hop questions designed to evaluate the adaptability of knowledge editing methods across five languages: English, Chinese, Japanese, French, and German. MLaKE aggregates fact chains from Wikipedia across languages and utilizes LLMs to generate questions in both free-form and multiple-choice. We evaluate the multilingual knowledge editing generalization capabilities of existing methods on MLaKE. Existing knowledge editing methods demonstrate higher success rates in English samples compared to other languages. However, their generalization capabilities are limited in multi-language experiments. Notably, existing knowledge editing methods often show relatively high generalization for languages within the same language family compared to languages from different language families. These results underscore the imperative need for advancements in multilingual knowledge editing and we hope MLaKE can serve as a valuable resource for benchmarking and solution development.
[ -0.31975823640823364, -0.7271419763565063, 0.5130607485771179, 0.38798487186431885, 0.07877063006162643, 0.10229777544736862, -0.48083868622779846, -0.5574970841407776, 0.149943009018898, 0.23368366062641144, -0.6281927227973938, -0.7787648439407349, -0.46273642778396606, 0.4756268858909607, -0.09803961217403412, 0.4803292453289032, -0.1646815985441208, 0.2216130793094635, -0.2895965278148651, -0.45871859788894653, -0.6037623882293701, -0.3222043514251709, -0.6092779636383057, -0.20520779490470886, 0.9162828326225281, 0.510491132736206, 0.7947736382484436, 0.40229782462120056, 0.31925320625305176, 0.25319531559944153, -0.28571757674217224, 0.312050461769104, -0.21453379094600677, 0.15818850696086884, -0.3695405125617981, -0.5368308424949646, -0.5559272766113281, -0.07759934663772583, 0.9977105259895325, 0.9570879340171814, 0.07347729057073593, 0.27547013759613037, -0.1753236949443817, 0.6871058344841003, -0.8367129564285278, -0.015910353511571884, -0.6497220396995544, 0.15396134555339813, -0.2816762328147888, 0.15073998272418976, -0.5100800395011902, -0.48108309507369995, -0.3096955120563507, -0.9470159411430359, -0.1993025541305542, -0.03956408053636551, 0.6136283278465271, 0.14039412140846252, -0.3922569155693054, -0.1743905395269394, -0.3805590569972992, 0.6703824400901794, -0.6454719305038452, 0.8203787207603455, 0.37485483288764954, 0.13581307232379913, -0.1700148582458496, -0.6231887340545654, -0.5031489133834839, -0.056082095950841904, -0.017421888187527657, 0.0434340201318264, -0.29824966192245483, -0.06118832156062126, 0.2215632200241089, -0.13316737115383148, -0.5366886854171753, 0.20409616827964783, -0.14227063953876495, -0.2502078115940094, 0.4582127630710602, 0.08233517408370972, 0.30742573738098145, -0.2602400481700897, -0.21710573136806488, -0.0582268163561821, -0.6527799963951111, 0.02604718506336212, 0.559209942817688, 0.2829258441925049, 0.10034671425819397, 0.7501527667045593, -0.433769553899765, 0.863111674785614, -0.26721492409706116, -0.4477754831314087, 0.16997240483760834, -0.3273184597492218, -0.05024336650967598, 0.03817572444677353, 0.8139436841011047, 0.5358262658119202, 0.36931583285331726, -0.2558521330356598, 0.2599192261695862, -0.33868372440338135, -0.23115625977516174, -0.5891324281692505, -0.07699073106050491, 0.05411092936992645, -0.25450751185417175, -0.08731787651777267, -0.03875945508480072, -0.9576205015182495, -0.519137978553772, -0.2295994758605957, 0.2739154100418091, -0.52559494972229, -0.39504921436309814, 0.3385116755962372, -0.09237149357795715, 0.016835832968354225, 0.5796986818313599, -0.3856768012046814, -0.12784218788146973, 0.49268242716789246, 0.8547561764717102, -0.18498016893863678, -1.023837924003601, -0.35978183150291443, 0.33480775356292725, -0.6211105585098267, 0.8546004891395569, -0.6732062697410583, -0.4682319760322571, 0.004996784031391144, -0.16524852812290192, -0.13604885339736938, -0.5451672673225403, 0.4474843740463257, -0.6352359652519226, -0.0718747228384018, -0.5521557331085205, -0.6333770751953125, -0.12433109432458878, 0.37957197427749634, -0.6398420333862305, 1.139479637145996, -0.1459949016571045, -0.9543758034706116, 0.49862387776374817, -0.6605015993118286, -0.5549378395080566, -0.1806057244539261, 0.25192174315452576, -0.20746935904026031, -0.06279204785823822, 0.2500298321247101, 0.4053299129009247, -0.1032751128077507, 0.2465088963508606, -0.44764384627342224, -0.05006282031536102, 0.25441649556159973, -0.2134093940258026, 0.8476395010948181, 0.19071106612682343, 0.04286995157599449, 0.146855428814888, -0.931422233581543, 0.076488196849823, 0.10158094018697739, -0.7079873085021973, -0.49734437465667725, -0.2996138334274292, 0.05787238851189613, 0.2522042691707611, 0.3180754780769348, -0.5223705768585205, 0.5489808917045593, 0.17042802274227142, -0.19314530491828918, 0.7690902352333069, 0.09352153539657593, 0.2172027975320816, -0.06823819130659103, 0.5469323396682739, -0.025799192488193512, 0.15954247117042542, -0.0500064492225647, -0.6792553067207336, -0.7391433119773865, -0.2675817608833313, 0.7102928757667542, 0.6077566742897034, -0.6489331126213074, 0.11028773337602615, -0.3474612832069397, -0.5236038565635681, -0.677878201007843, 0.5347672700881958, 0.04843052104115486, 0.3120628893375397, 0.2852802872657776, 0.04118284955620766, -0.5722194910049438, -0.9956506490707397, -0.6816740036010742, -0.11952576041221619, 0.11481186747550964, -0.11090223491191864, 0.2666875422000885, -0.361676424741745, 0.9099777936935425, -0.2957736849784851, 0.04726729169487953, -0.295155793428421, 0.24486880004405975, 0.09526289999485016, 0.17624717950820923, 0.473427951335907, -0.5555304884910583, -0.7236764430999756, 0.2611354887485504, -0.9467801451683044, -0.14846576750278473, -0.1372142732143402, -0.24489422142505646, 0.16933821141719818, 0.5933951139450073, -0.8094038963317871, 0.1554572880268097, 0.599044144153595, -0.17497463524341583, 0.8164672255516052, -0.18595892190933228, 0.5058801174163818, -1.1255104541778564, 0.25315994024276733, -0.3809230327606201, -0.15928219258785248, -0.548508882522583, 0.31938880681991577, 0.5100510120391846, -0.014222173020243645, -0.3315590023994446, 0.6543360352516174, -0.36870884895324707, 0.07414521276950836, -0.08123109489679337, 0.14525532722473145, -0.04931534454226494, 0.2668384909629822, -0.04103996232151985, 0.8924246430397034, 0.3285309970378876, -0.4742911458015442, 0.4756690561771393, 0.23642031848430634, -0.733290433883667, 0.6429309844970703, -0.27440354228019714, 0.2364160716533661, -0.09547268599271774, -0.06831488758325577, -0.8012654185295105, -0.19756364822387695, -0.04128444939851761, -0.408282071352005, 0.11719963699579239, -0.23523367941379547, -0.964181661605835, 0.04683537408709526, -0.23065191507339478, 0.206234872341156, -0.06437022238969803, -0.5003555417060852, 0.5647026896476746, 0.09419064223766327, -0.3660430312156677, -0.9645979404449463, -0.636151134967804, 0.46005189418792725, -0.16295212507247925, -0.8124335408210754, -0.05597236379981041, -0.38330501317977905, -0.344056099653244, -0.01584484800696373, 0.02237793430685997, -0.15540757775306702, -0.013929527252912521, -0.3082885444164276, 0.15295790135860443, -0.23298941552639008, 0.26630353927612305, 0.28452861309051514, -0.12368510663509369, -0.09713063389062881, 0.04788857325911522, 0.4138178527355194, 0.09325165301561356, -0.2776573598384857, -0.19229167699813843, 0.4538228511810303, 0.7264311909675598, -0.49377885460853577, 0.8039611577987671, 0.7011970281600952, -0.32862889766693115, -0.08848578482866287, -0.7639740705490112, 0.29630526900291443, -0.3896217942237854, 0.5193397998809814, -0.768617570400238, -0.8616141080856323, 0.570254921913147, -0.4418303966522217, 0.10805877298116684, 0.5036152601242065, 0.432975172996521, 0.06393081694841385, 0.6004449725151062, 0.4547097682952881, -0.24836570024490356, 0.07215515524148941, 0.08060722053050995, 0.07845669239759445, -0.5412313938140869, -0.06291060894727707, -0.5304626226425171, -0.34557750821113586, -0.48110756278038025, -0.5474629402160645, 0.5272071361541748, 0.41957753896713257, 0.07446116209030151, 0.4439771771430969, 0.05110780894756317, 0.6732017993927002, 0.5332886576652527, -0.17204420268535614, 0.7842682003974915, -0.2342282086610794, -0.6445327997207642, -0.10353245586156845, -0.8623597025871277, -0.21976856887340546, 1.330919861793518, 0.1070014089345932, 0.6530070900917053, 0.28314730525016785, 0.46403974294662476, 0.18309317529201508, 0.10337060689926147, -0.5032244920730591, 0.5354841351509094, 0.02066090889275074, -0.8515390753746033, -0.3445264995098114, -0.4376744031906128, -0.7452074289321899, 0.24981878697872162, -0.24449321627616882, -0.5648288726806641, 0.14775580167770386, 0.09648193418979645, -0.08834287524223328, 0.6875528693199158, -0.8853164315223694, 0.9885175228118896, -0.08043167740106583, -0.5255684852600098, -0.34624773263931274, -0.4902554452419281, 0.3560768961906433, -0.21756258606910706, 0.6331884860992432, -0.25867679715156555, -0.11024610698223114, 0.5007314682006836, 0.0502408929169178, 0.607875645160675, -0.16610132157802582, -0.08019929379224777, 0.13178300857543945, 0.36608344316482544, 0.5823305249214172, 0.369515985250473, -0.2330443263053894, 0.391800194978714, 0.07419836521148682, -0.33171704411506653, -0.462331622838974, 0.7466254830360413, -0.7044978737831116, -0.3328428268432617, -0.28361839056015015, -0.7634277939796448, -0.6432943344116211, 0.3336644470691681, 0.15508721768856049, 0.03959091380238533, -0.24781258404254913, 0.062231119722127914, 0.5417240262031555, -0.5106521248817444, 0.2252969890832901, 0.6142346858978271, -0.6490265727043152, -0.4590243399143219, 0.6466971635818481, 0.19404646754264832, 0.26983389258384705, 0.6030393838882446, 0.32674938440322876, -0.009837556630373001, -0.4538520872592926, -0.5176150798797607, 0.10879047214984894, -1.1244221925735474, -0.23507915437221527, -0.8294379711151123, 0.02323799766600132, -0.28761178255081177, -0.08150939643383026, -0.6172589063644409, -0.5607876181602478, 0.323842316865921, -0.041680529713630676, 0.30238279700279236, 0.8493716716766357, -0.3523748517036438, -0.08194077759981155, -0.5382574200630188, 0.43730300664901733, 0.4490731358528137, 0.6617692708969116, -0.07052811980247498, -0.1819089651107788, -0.4522859454154968, -0.21852190792560577, -0.05047597736120224, -0.7782204747200012, -0.27367526292800903, 0.15251009166240692, 0.645565390586853, 0.11764111369848251, -0.05005199462175369, 0.8036146759986877, -0.6530880331993103, 0.5062101483345032, 0.16931016743183136, -0.8206726312637329, 0.4851476550102234, -0.3571527600288391, 0.6739799976348877, 0.6712160110473633, 0.5487079620361328, -1.1195828914642334, -0.25650086998939514, -0.13054485619068146, -0.5476964116096497, 0.44422486424446106, -0.01934976875782013, -0.11603287607431412, 0.16169938445091248, 0.22061662375926971, 0.48321494460105896, 0.1545153558254242, -0.6636253595352173, -0.2984548807144165, -0.007855571806430817, 0.02667403593659401, -0.11209345608949661, -0.2886398434638977, 0.12133631110191345, -0.5831913352012634, 0.7471234798431396, 0.04768732935190201, 0.08128311485052109, 0.1594097912311554, -0.42631614208221436, -0.16451239585876465, 0.6194995641708374, 0.6338125467300415, 0.9331231117248535, -0.16813012957572937, 0.05472605675458908, 0.538655161857605, -0.33674055337905884, 0.053488705307245255, 0.06441851705312729, -0.25277215242385864, 0.22793756425380707, 0.5743750929832458, 0.5122553110122681, 0.348899781703949, -0.5859223008155823, 0.14175568521022797, -0.06746496260166168, -0.22649775445461273, -0.08704117685556412, -0.055037058889865875, 0.5531737208366394, 0.09390813857316971, 0.12757031619548798, 0.28802764415740967, -0.048417408019304276, -0.30989354848861694, -0.029943004250526428, 0.16991876065731049, 0.13404032588005066, -0.16011057794094086, 0.548821210861206, 0.0008197932038456202, -0.11945223808288574, 0.3411537706851959, -0.1325598657131195, -0.19500097632408142, -0.11327843368053436, 0.19980038702487946, 0.5957276225090027, -0.3800332248210907, 0.031616758555173874, 0.7836117744445801, 0.6673605442047119, 0.1961405873298645, -0.016324244439601898, 0.15762706100940704, -0.8811696171760559, -0.6817129850387573, -0.6356988549232483, -0.6462441086769104, 0.2962752878665924, -0.44618019461631775, 0.44648900628089905, -0.4027149975299835, -0.12176885455846786, 0.24376092851161957, -0.1714630126953125, -0.7515355348587036, -0.12452678382396698, -0.08525917679071426, 1.3049644231796265, -0.6587057709693909, 0.9827847480773926, 0.9519312381744385, -0.12185677140951157, -0.36348289251327515, -0.11719579249620438, 0.12607021629810333, -0.6510790586471558, 0.348636656999588, -0.022418199107050896, -0.17261327803134918, -0.21053794026374817, -0.38025400042533875, -0.8550431728363037, 0.802993655204773, 0.7450575232505798, -0.5043883919715881, -0.07947699725627899, 0.4413098096847534, 0.14947468042373657, 0.0020131466444581747, -0.13306227326393127, 0.5864458084106445, 0.9638145565986633, -0.20328110456466675, -0.9705868363380432, -0.5120154023170471, -0.34704890847206116, -0.11130917072296143, 0.05156026408076286, -0.6544296145439148, 0.5717239379882812, -0.05200718343257904, 0.1796637773513794, 0.11154060065746307, 0.39413315057754517, -0.00009112748375628144, 0.034766171127557755, 0.4264638125896454, 0.6997312307357788, 0.7410010099411011, -0.025919953361153603, 0.8371067643165588, -0.3603813946247101, 0.3280980587005615, 1.2065871953964233, -0.3446601331233978, 0.8549275398254395, 0.5780160427093506, -0.490500271320343, 0.4552967846393585, 0.4330728054046631, 0.23195761442184448, 0.19943629205226898, -0.08349793404340744, -0.4185663163661957, -0.49669116735458374, 0.09872391074895859, -0.2826383113861084, 0.657652735710144, 0.040650591254234314, 0.13052719831466675, -0.2688859701156616, 0.20867735147476196, 0.5560905933380127, 0.18933916091918945, -0.1854378581047058, 0.7146259546279907, -0.2863811254501343, -0.6580362319946289, 0.28462740778923035, 0.38864508271217346, 0.7030551433563232, -1.0725797414779663, 0.1448436826467514, -0.256915807723999, 0.2063664197921753, -0.044471871107816696, -0.8021519184112549, 0.2610817551612854, 0.2471301257610321, -0.2569577693939209, -0.1320376843214035, 0.6687666177749634, -0.41763728857040405, -0.9300506114959717, 0.6208987832069397, 0.6771529912948608, -0.08764535188674927, -0.17654365301132202, -0.6366724967956543, 0.28514012694358826, -0.0779552087187767, -0.35953864455223083, 0.3445407450199127, 0.4545442461967468, 0.22916889190673828, 0.6150863170623779, 0.5444886088371277, 0.1869117170572281, 0.39945700764656067, 0.048130255192518234, 0.5461405515670776, -0.5851926803588867, -0.3269977569580078, -0.5699366927146912, 0.6506743431091309, -0.1426735520362854, -0.4597461223602295, 0.9318380355834961, 0.9177824258804321, 1.309145450592041, -0.3050088882446289, 1.0466508865356445, -0.1389397233724594, 0.639918863773346, -0.7047179341316223, 0.9765183329582214, -0.6904930472373962, -0.17906250059604645, -0.48794811964035034, -1.045267939567566, -0.45643478631973267, 0.46436798572540283, -0.21088556945323944, 0.07937213778495789, 0.8346555829048157, 0.6773657202720642, -0.17293290793895721, -0.0012746169231832027, 0.6456568241119385, 0.2838572561740875, -0.04849371314048767, 0.33535856008529663, 0.6407327651977539, -0.378442645072937, 0.5483079552650452, -0.5935424566268921, -0.10026855021715164, 0.15380939841270447, -0.8476346731185913, -1.0289121866226196, -0.582775354385376, -0.2685023248195648, 0.10239312052726746, 0.15268026292324066, 1.0192395448684692, 0.5069631338119507, -0.9016138911247253, -0.44765448570251465, 0.3155103623867035, 0.19975009560585022, -0.34324514865875244, -0.15215694904327393, 0.2942374348640442, -0.5653839707374573, -0.708187460899353, 0.696052610874176, 0.43300312757492065, -0.3840956389904022, -0.02919767238199711, -0.17833563685417175, -0.8097290992736816, -0.14916934072971344, 0.785256028175354, 0.10776416212320328, -0.59151291847229, -0.2890240550041199, 0.13060273230075836, 0.1925605982542038, 0.21378281712532043, 0.8719618320465088, -0.17016997933387756, 0.9143178462982178, 0.15617096424102783, 0.746842086315155, 0.33838725090026855, -0.43575426936149597, 0.3857194483280182, -0.8971775770187378, 0.2131453901529312, -0.17213174700737, 0.5616983771324158, 0.4809695780277252, -0.009293011389672756, 0.45153743028640747, 0.42283210158348083, -0.37185463309288025, -0.513840913772583, 0.12720611691474915, -0.7152658700942993, -0.40251368284225464, 1.1688956022262573, -0.17608173191547394, 0.15688347816467285, -0.10933948308229446, -0.2760534882545471, 0.2278222143650055, -0.04092908650636673, 0.41642826795578003, 1.324901819229126, 0.08739662170410156, -0.4073917865753174, -0.8211770057678223, 0.10824137926101685, 0.3404320478439331, -0.8185458779335022, 0.36447736620903015, 0.4412675201892853, 0.4241113066673279, -0.027652207762002945, 0.3328896164894104, -0.07134804874658585, 0.5628217458724976, 0.08869566768407822, 0.4212661683559418, -0.25165337324142456, -0.44096872210502625, -0.11195861548185349, 0.27097752690315247, 0.43729519844055176, 0.2661770284175873 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04963v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04963v1
SemEval-2024 Task 2: Safe Biomedical Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trials
2024-04-07T13:58:41
2024-04-07T13:58:41
Mael Jullien, Marco Valentino, André Freitas
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Large Language Models (LLMs) are at the forefront of NLP achievements but fall short in dealing with shortcut learning, factual inconsistency, and vulnerability to adversarial inputs.These shortcomings are especially critical in medical contexts, where they can misrepresent actual model capabilities. Addressing this, we present SemEval-2024 Task 2: Safe Biomedical Natural Language Inference for ClinicalTrials. Our contributions include the refined NLI4CT-P dataset (i.e., Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trials - Perturbed), designed to challenge LLMs with interventional and causal reasoning tasks, along with a comprehensive evaluation of methods and results for participant submissions. A total of 106 participants registered for the task contributing to over 1200 individual submissions and 25 system overview papers. This initiative aims to advance the robustness and applicability of NLI models in healthcare, ensuring safer and more dependable AI assistance in clinical decision-making. We anticipate that the dataset, models, and outcomes of this task can support future research in the field of biomedical NLI. The dataset, competition leaderboard, and website are publicly available.
[ 0.2450670599937439, -0.7393293380737305, 0.780923068523407, 0.4506557583808899, -0.12367334216833115, -0.2158472239971161, -0.09385014325380325, -0.49938976764678955, -0.1808415651321411, 0.7610746622085571, -0.4405757784843445, -0.538597822189331, -0.7471696734428406, 0.32977011799812317, -0.09026700258255005, 0.9551671147346497, -0.06428614258766174, 0.1908758282661438, -0.44428232312202454, -0.14504562318325043, -0.501234769821167, -0.5788939595222473, -0.7980366945266724, -0.22041913866996765, 0.7775925993919373, 0.21410591900348663, 0.40336453914642334, 0.47029513120651245, 0.7301235795021057, 0.2066209763288498, -0.005217266734689474, 0.018157511949539185, -0.3047102689743042, 0.28518494963645935, -0.3159748613834381, -0.41794294118881226, -0.6118661761283875, 0.11241771280765533, 0.20953787863254547, 0.8177893757820129, -0.16866803169250488, -0.2088819444179535, 0.16741925477981567, 0.24664241075515747, -0.46200457215309143, -0.020529547706246376, -0.5712217688560486, -0.0075880070216953754, -0.18672752380371094, -0.35712191462516785, -0.5692071914672852, -0.4672965407371521, 0.1864868551492691, -0.45534658432006836, 0.0831974670290947, 0.09484114497900009, 0.604759156703949, 0.4823414385318756, -0.7743147611618042, -0.4029488265514374, -0.3658466637134552, 0.8886391520500183, -1.147761344909668, 0.0747874304652214, 0.7894458174705505, 0.24910606443881989, -0.33325228095054626, -0.9447644352912903, -0.10867676138877869, -0.19179953634738922, 0.046073928475379944, 0.18226461112499237, -0.16738104820251465, 0.3208788335323334, 0.23644128441810608, -0.20012173056602478, -0.6079344749450684, 0.32090073823928833, -0.2625401020050049, -0.21790434420108795, 0.6868706941604614, 0.24429656565189362, 0.2641843259334564, -0.09824424237012863, -0.21419364213943481, 0.18831774592399597, -0.9687314033508301, -0.318274587392807, -0.09033887833356857, 0.3210355341434479, -0.04052615165710449, 0.685090184211731, -0.030384903773665428, 0.20152878761291504, -0.3889841139316559, -0.015614465810358524, 0.4912964701652527, -0.7504120469093323, -0.29440221190452576, 0.1186615601181984, 0.8924813866615295, 0.5717935562133789, -0.15144559741020203, -0.2637716829776764, 0.052509866654872894, 0.2321079671382904, 0.3711439073085785, -0.7240673899650574, -0.08066879957914352, 0.4604176878929138, -0.3417140543460846, -0.503346860408783, -0.4396657943725586, -0.8641459345817566, -0.5427561402320862, -0.1801207959651947, 0.5677581429481506, -0.3678523004055023, 0.11433195322751999, 0.13755102455615997, -0.025183646008372307, 0.05190463736653328, 0.46727636456489563, -0.5292055606842041, 0.3107324540615082, 0.7280204892158508, 0.5099421143531799, -0.11792857944965363, -0.20954354107379913, -0.6513160467147827, 0.22010764479637146, -0.16464994847774506, 0.6426705121994019, -0.36545631289482117, -0.4054742455482483, -0.05354442074894905, 0.3143984079360962, -0.29052141308784485, -0.4431319534778595, 0.9924865365028381, -0.17775875329971313, 0.24890537559986115, -0.33542075753211975, -0.6931894421577454, -0.05146222561597824, 0.09653190523386002, -0.45942559838294983, 0.6616228818893433, -0.300869882106781, -0.8437266945838928, 0.23209317028522491, -0.5563955903053284, -0.6875484585762024, 0.131766676902771, -0.13624010980129242, -0.618586540222168, 0.023559607565402985, 0.10331007838249207, 0.43606331944465637, -0.5347880125045776, 0.6354276537895203, -0.6944672465324402, -0.00846825074404478, 0.1079476922750473, -0.4433914124965668, 0.7412301898002625, 0.2490500956773758, -0.6501937508583069, -0.023259645327925682, -0.6370633244514465, -0.10762898623943329, 0.2029247134923935, -0.1756826490163803, -0.29418227076530457, -0.02284260094165802, -0.03341519460082054, 0.1155460774898529, 0.15999668836593628, -0.6469539403915405, -0.27216583490371704, -0.6683329939842224, 0.6013351082801819, 0.6086387038230896, 0.30991998314857483, 0.34362509846687317, -0.15855109691619873, 0.4773571491241455, -0.31951284408569336, 0.2672295570373535, 0.16308583319187164, -0.7421123385429382, -0.3862661123275757, -0.07423397153615952, 0.5037044286727905, 0.7021421194076538, -0.7277846932411194, 0.38931217789649963, -0.02334471419453621, -0.2665688991546631, -0.19736774265766144, -0.18348418176174164, 0.4184679687023163, 0.6638553142547607, 0.37900564074516296, 0.2166781723499298, -0.6923013925552368, -1.036787509918213, -0.3006947338581085, -0.05384618043899536, -0.21413718163967133, 0.4198106527328491, 0.7457074522972107, -0.6365914940834045, 0.5134977102279663, -0.1573847383260727, -0.18233788013458252, -0.25202107429504395, 0.47370126843452454, 0.1946776807308197, 0.6556332111358643, 0.3115864098072052, -0.5334517359733582, 0.11622990667819977, -0.17951256036758423, -0.9047703742980957, -0.5343809127807617, -0.08907873183488846, -0.23706242442131042, 0.10411074757575989, 0.6314224600791931, -0.2610117793083191, 0.6499909162521362, 0.4793076813220978, -0.4341868758201599, 0.12313279509544373, -0.32353752851486206, 0.16652381420135498, -1.036404013633728, 0.21634192764759064, -0.09383165836334229, -0.2024778127670288, -0.7844441533088684, -0.10585076361894608, -0.02089170180261135, 0.2286728322505951, -0.25184935331344604, 0.5041651129722595, 0.01387467049062252, 0.24327626824378967, -0.26435738801956177, -0.12508338689804077, 0.03258555755019188, 0.15284372866153717, 0.04405039921402931, 0.6132768392562866, 0.23988023400306702, -0.479512482881546, -0.1128992810845375, 0.4966405928134918, -0.09901934862136841, 0.1736339032649994, -1.1003384590148926, 0.10964768379926682, 0.022316034883260727, 0.29436177015304565, -0.5545921325683594, -0.46691158413887024, 0.12090817838907242, -0.47433847188949585, 0.1443306803703308, 0.03081292286515236, -0.49941110610961914, -0.3163098096847534, -0.12399125844240189, 0.3450188636779785, 0.3518848419189453, -0.17566797137260437, 0.35152846574783325, 0.7284479141235352, -0.4928031265735626, -0.44597139954566956, -0.9558926820755005, 0.35831600427627563, -0.17362497746944427, -0.48626625537872314, 0.26334020495414734, 0.01542274747043848, -0.11743319034576416, -0.10569585114717484, 0.18159006536006927, -0.10979300737380981, 0.19124799966812134, 0.45452621579170227, 0.3297724723815918, 0.05685454234480858, 0.12723742425441742, 0.22923339903354645, -0.1501116007566452, 0.31436169147491455, 0.18225444853305817, 0.015651555731892586, -0.06508024781942368, -0.49731385707855225, -0.42127081751823425, 0.4851536154747009, 0.3714149594306946, -0.16248385608196259, 0.5080539584159851, 0.4529149830341339, -0.7768226861953735, 0.1046045571565628, -0.469426691532135, -0.2811492681503296, -0.3969467282295227, 0.3945927023887634, 0.03575245663523674, -1.1556116342544556, 0.039032742381095886, -0.23555469512939453, 0.19732153415679932, 0.3832337558269501, 0.7608897089958191, -0.1549576073884964, 1.3167541027069092, 0.09733112901449203, 0.28196460008621216, -0.2139761745929718, -0.062450241297483444, 0.34200578927993774, -0.7381644248962402, -0.41965681314468384, -0.6610690355300903, -0.11983729898929596, -0.4057909846305847, -0.7168048620223999, 0.6058105230331421, -0.17417952418327332, -0.4185812771320343, 0.17535510659217834, -0.2505890429019928, 0.012681789696216583, 0.6011294722557068, 0.2622023820877075, 0.036051347851753235, -0.15099437534809113, -0.2885494530200958, -0.2231706976890564, -0.6048969626426697, -0.5373417139053345, 1.2005844116210938, 0.4694761335849762, 0.6497319340705872, 0.18703727424144745, 0.7297391295433044, 0.20903030037879944, 0.10605858266353607, -0.4146632254123688, 0.43800777196884155, -0.06480306386947632, -0.7527903318405151, -0.20629432797431946, -0.4618252217769623, -0.9769225716590881, -0.06759165227413177, -0.27329331636428833, -0.6053012609481812, 0.14941050112247467, -0.06588606536388397, -0.5655460953712463, -0.15821778774261475, -0.5396013855934143, 0.9384400844573975, -0.3876569867134094, -0.5342856049537659, -0.08858919143676758, -1.049373745918274, 0.2850814163684845, -0.1421716809272766, 0.33949312567710876, -0.3790627717971802, -0.15414363145828247, 0.6972478032112122, -0.5736204981803894, 0.9029534459114075, -0.20684051513671875, 0.1933714747428894, 0.2056376039981842, -0.20718419551849365, 0.6299787759780884, 0.34224650263786316, -0.21504861116409302, 0.06221162900328636, 0.23385226726531982, -0.3766006827354431, -0.3411920368671417, 0.6232654452323914, -0.5248464941978455, -0.39084136486053467, -0.5037285685539246, -0.21136735379695892, -0.5220084190368652, 0.1936500519514084, 0.31820109486579895, 0.5963471531867981, -0.2346293032169342, 0.37846851348876953, 0.52623450756073, -0.6145599484443665, 0.19132818281650543, 0.3134063184261322, 0.2765803039073944, -0.5598137974739075, 0.6531403064727783, -0.35155001282691956, 0.11605769395828247, 0.20386582612991333, 0.22678141295909882, -0.7016515731811523, -1.0363166332244873, 0.03643591329455376, 0.3496894836425781, -0.6000230312347412, -0.26119866967201233, -0.8832716941833496, -0.18066191673278809, -0.6404542326927185, -0.0895383283495903, -0.35109150409698486, -0.30933964252471924, -0.4770980775356293, -0.15917278826236725, 0.08861822634935379, 0.704411506652832, -0.17088206112384796, -0.03500627353787422, -0.9127742648124695, 0.1261626034975052, 0.21847392618656158, 0.04409053921699524, -0.4832158386707306, -0.5683777332305908, 0.10543125867843628, -0.02098812907934189, 0.08710409700870514, -0.6936734914779663, 0.5689131617546082, 0.21288186311721802, 0.5820346474647522, 0.2726963460445404, 0.1521632820367813, 0.4863181710243225, -0.7910293936729431, 0.591101348400116, 0.21949513256549835, -0.546549916267395, 0.8836725950241089, -0.5013776421546936, 0.2020173817873001, 1.0542054176330566, 0.265936017036438, -0.3369220793247223, -0.47457075119018555, -0.5488438606262207, -0.8289530873298645, 0.48184189200401306, 0.5855630040168762, -0.22819079458713531, -0.18043270707130432, 0.265254408121109, 0.042373206466436386, 0.1737816035747528, -0.43568840622901917, 0.09352032095193863, 0.20652428269386292, -0.464654803276062, 0.07882244139909744, -0.5054787993431091, -0.4374767541885376, -0.2669525146484375, 0.8421599268913269, -0.24633193016052246, 0.37999194860458374, 0.322981595993042, 0.02915397845208645, 0.06392399221658707, 0.3608185946941376, 0.5842568874359131, 0.5028719902038574, -0.20634040236473083, 0.26396048069000244, 0.48617392778396606, -0.368603378534317, -0.000017563117580721155, 0.3716191053390503, -0.01991826482117176, -0.24633502960205078, 0.6096004247665405, 0.6907596588134766, 0.4668233096599579, -0.9875386953353882, 0.7028855085372925, -0.36283746361732483, -0.43781715631484985, -0.4319097101688385, -0.1987072229385376, 0.1330871731042862, 0.25469970703125, -0.06887031346559525, 0.278194785118103, 0.5157953500747681, -0.13652947545051575, 0.4073787331581116, 0.30586037039756775, -0.5136305093765259, -0.3832729160785675, 1.0050647258758545, 0.3459152281284332, 0.0363021083176136, 0.2694258391857147, -0.12817905843257904, -0.34993255138397217, 0.6670086979866028, 0.5107666850090027, 0.670826256275177, 0.00451829144731164, 0.08242104202508926, 0.5240513682365417, 0.3426665663719177, -0.08945196121931076, 0.31279289722442627, 0.5687693357467651, -0.5297873616218567, -0.42126089334487915, -0.4917227625846863, -0.4660973846912384, 0.3657962679862976, -0.36326178908348083, 0.33738353848457336, -0.4217888116836548, -0.2649609446525574, 0.0661422610282898, -0.13589413464069366, -0.354754239320755, 0.21672937273979187, 0.3232654929161072, 0.7826358675956726, -0.669670045375824, 0.7496939301490784, 0.5865626335144043, 0.03601007163524628, -0.7013875246047974, -0.48155856132507324, 0.47663938999176025, -0.48284712433815, 0.4510282576084137, 0.13509729504585266, 0.01133592240512371, -0.24518224596977234, -0.6646304726600647, -0.6943067312240601, 1.1133532524108887, 0.25162026286125183, -0.52911376953125, -0.27583226561546326, 0.27912387251853943, 0.458111435174942, -0.19614560902118683, 0.22671008110046387, 0.6531866192817688, 0.47832798957824707, 0.2889236509799957, -0.7851936221122742, 0.16358955204486847, -0.27435508370399475, -0.1488974541425705, -0.0891486182808876, -0.18770326673984528, 0.40013086795806885, -0.23668645322322845, -0.005339492578059435, 0.4967629015445709, 0.5011250972747803, 0.583991527557373, 0.680608868598938, 0.3945541977882385, 0.7148319482803345, 0.8344934582710266, -0.16791677474975586, 1.0351409912109375, -0.08580148220062256, 0.16831542551517487, 1.1483550071716309, -0.6213934421539307, 0.7538972496986389, 0.44067221879959106, -0.26221534609794617, -0.053418103605508804, 0.5345542430877686, 0.0856388732790947, 0.5682663321495056, -0.11659080535173416, -0.4475034475326538, -0.40329888463020325, -0.3048063814640045, -0.38849470019340515, 0.5037968754768372, 0.6043928265571594, -0.4666842818260193, -0.13600029051303864, 0.1034439206123352, 0.21639752388000488, -0.1636401265859604, 0.22685284912586212, 0.7368941307067871, 0.24098743498325348, -0.6918495297431946, 0.26158177852630615, -0.05448829010128975, 0.41921451687812805, -0.5754852294921875, -0.1536562442779541, 0.06814347952604294, 0.24570688605308533, 0.02039526030421257, -0.47267138957977295, 0.4263856112957001, 0.030461914837360382, 0.30589452385902405, -0.10958979278802872, 0.9173972606658936, -0.3133503496646881, -0.5500573515892029, 0.25744447112083435, 0.28698334097862244, 0.07504085451364517, -0.025092896074056625, -0.8217833638191223, -0.05868438258767128, 0.09108644723892212, -0.12960873544216156, 0.2644776403903961, 0.32599031925201416, -0.014540585689246655, 0.5106029510498047, 0.5250138640403748, 0.13004860281944275, -0.06946666538715363, 0.2019670456647873, 0.5831846594810486, -0.5924144387245178, -0.22355003654956818, -0.6742815375328064, 0.19613400101661682, -0.1965610831975937, -0.29413270950317383, 0.6407012939453125, 0.4851004481315613, -0.0250526275485754, 0.18049179017543793, 0.8161764144897461, 0.11395518481731415, 0.8284549117088318, -0.5296304821968079, 0.7355130314826965, -0.5797787308692932, 0.12870024144649506, -0.10350127518177032, -0.228939026594162, -0.6074492335319519, 0.35695767402648926, -0.36733266711235046, -0.14782269299030304, 0.8741226196289062, 0.7519840598106384, 0.40489739179611206, 0.5261856317520142, 0.18128105998039246, 0.37892094254493713, 0.5104213356971741, 0.7432587742805481, 0.727149486541748, -0.524750292301178, 0.3588339388370514, -0.3460340201854706, -0.35274365544319153, -0.2280498743057251, -1.0240017175674438, -0.8957892060279846, -0.25974589586257935, -0.33686479926109314, -0.38918814063072205, 0.26649758219718933, 1.0480890274047852, 0.4734690189361572, -1.1361420154571533, 0.20438671112060547, -0.4371874928474426, -0.08675619214773178, 0.1797969937324524, -0.1403135508298874, 0.2984886169433594, -0.3446658253669739, -0.7162689566612244, 0.6990645527839661, 0.5120061039924622, -0.07306665182113647, 0.3184249699115753, -0.08835145086050034, -0.45606887340545654, 0.018009420484304428, 0.5721238851547241, 0.2170497328042984, -0.7205292582511902, -0.24075593054294586, 0.05728521570563316, -0.3583229184150696, -0.24520328640937805, 0.6920334100723267, -0.6277067065238953, 0.3430299460887909, 0.4973413646221161, 1.0607569217681885, 0.2552664875984192, -0.1974085122346878, 0.8143928647041321, -0.33596867322921753, 0.04611208662390709, 0.6583833694458008, 0.4973595142364502, 0.14018583297729492, -0.291861355304718, 0.8482962846755981, 0.4140997529029846, -0.9029404520988464, -0.8273721933364868, -0.0577046163380146, -0.9424979090690613, -0.2541694641113281, 1.3739413022994995, -0.026246536523103714, -0.3493693470954895, -0.44785910844802856, -0.15052732825279236, 0.27856457233428955, -0.19062289595603943, 0.3041560649871826, 0.307115763425827, -0.12082945555448532, -0.023828884586691856, -1.0401936769485474, 0.7035170793533325, 0.739490270614624, -1.1165271997451782, -0.17478108406066895, 0.5049154758453369, 0.025837082415819168, -0.2262699455022812, 0.7402559518814087, -0.324062317609787, 0.30872687697410583, -0.19677923619747162, -0.12140262871980667, 0.26775825023651123, -0.23381714522838593, -0.3799453377723694, -0.06178761646151543, -0.021747220307588577, 0.07566231489181519 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04959v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04959v1
A Two Dimensional Feature Engineering Method for Relation Extraction
2024-04-07T13:37:30
2024-04-07T13:37:30
Hao Wang, Yanping Chen, Weizhe Yang, Yongbin Qin, Ruizhang Huang
cs.CL
cs.CL
Transforming a sentence into a two-dimensional (2D) representation (e.g., the table filling) has the ability to unfold a semantic plane, where an element of the plane is a word-pair representation of a sentence which may denote a possible relation representation composed of two named entities. The 2D representation is effective in resolving overlapped relation instances. However, in related works, the representation is directly transformed from a raw input. It is weak to utilize prior knowledge, which is important to support the relation extraction task. In this paper, we propose a two-dimensional feature engineering method in the 2D sentence representation for relation extraction. Our proposed method is evaluated on three public datasets (ACE05 Chinese, ACE05 English, and SanWen) and achieves the state-of-the-art performance. The results indicate that two-dimensional feature engineering can take advantage of a two-dimensional sentence representation and make full use of prior knowledge in traditional feature engineering. Our code is publicly available at https://github.com/Wang-ck123/A-Two-Dimensional-Feature-Engineering-Method-for-Entity-Relation-Extraction
[ -0.30582892894744873, -0.7577152252197266, 0.6840479373931885, 0.4141086935997009, -0.1450062096118927, -0.38881823420524597, 0.010623343288898468, -0.7036734223365784, 0.1824074685573578, 0.7786985635757446, -0.18217043578624725, -0.17014069855213165, -0.5126026272773743, -0.42084747552871704, 0.048563167452812195, 0.7783665657043457, -0.32061415910720825, -0.033130377531051636, -0.5147233605384827, -0.003203524509444833, -0.542596697807312, -0.39776739478111267, -0.01473210472613573, -0.1658439040184021, 0.28143310546875, 0.38614359498023987, 0.7346489429473877, 0.875591516494751, 0.68205726146698, 0.15573590993881226, -0.16341912746429443, 0.36990317702293396, -0.395090788602829, -0.06432119011878967, -0.10204953700304031, -0.36790531873703003, -0.6107537746429443, 0.5185559988021851, 0.25121554732322693, 0.8976681232452393, 0.34235426783561707, 0.12175433337688446, -0.015153605490922928, 0.598207414150238, -0.5003075003623962, 0.714133620262146, -0.5480279326438904, 0.15646864473819733, -0.41163328289985657, 0.017287403345108032, -0.026532117277383804, -0.3387589752674103, 0.22792717814445496, -0.6199862360954285, -0.15484368801116943, -0.0145548265427351, 1.2718119621276855, 0.01580790802836418, -0.4605194926261902, -0.2309764325618744, -0.7267758846282959, 0.3333335220813751, -0.30984172224998474, 0.4873017370700836, 0.4940093159675598, 0.2597602307796478, -0.18852029740810394, -0.8305967450141907, -0.6753476858139038, -0.17623034119606018, -0.7357379794120789, 0.010176683776080608, 0.3000989258289337, -0.25994637608528137, 0.23851647973060608, 0.2997124493122101, -0.5686455965042114, 0.25457924604415894, -0.4430001676082611, -0.05206714943051338, 0.8737704157829285, -0.20838025212287903, 0.5148979425430298, -0.5410059094429016, -0.9174286127090454, -0.09445131570100784, -0.5442344546318054, 0.12295765429735184, 0.11327765882015228, 0.046867307275533676, -0.060774169862270355, 0.6124342083930969, 0.221201092004776, 0.041883938014507294, -0.41628098487854004, 0.09920011460781097, 0.3159562349319458, -0.21677106618881226, 0.055936750024557114, -0.18478131294250488, 1.0027464628219604, 0.36335891485214233, 0.2879815399646759, -0.19095861911773682, -0.03113733045756817, 0.1443241834640503, 0.12518641352653503, -0.8089974522590637, -0.5996389389038086, 0.2086484581232071, -0.5316795110702515, -0.16140197217464447, 0.3069758415222168, -1.0871189832687378, -0.4973353147506714, -0.03577278554439545, 0.1022319495677948, -0.5302737355232239, -0.7428849339485168, -0.3731536269187927, -0.21351604163646698, 0.0539475716650486, -0.1962033212184906, -1.0080831050872803, 0.05992306396365166, 0.9068338871002197, 0.7684941291809082, 0.07869292050600052, -0.238012433052063, -0.46691960096359253, 0.24503165483474731, -0.383591890335083, 0.8678984045982361, -0.3941073417663574, -0.23859824240207672, 0.07739593088626862, -0.7677902579307556, 0.2748510539531708, -0.5028277039527893, 0.36769744753837585, -0.5911343693733215, 0.3513313829898834, -0.1849912703037262, -0.48264819383621216, -0.19892673194408417, -0.0477365143597126, -0.8410277366638184, 0.9822633862495422, 0.4810548722743988, -0.7123126983642578, 0.10030432045459747, -0.4839586913585663, -0.4081440269947052, 0.01833989843726158, -0.6868582367897034, -0.6033015847206116, -0.20328643918037415, 0.5190386176109314, 0.31911569833755493, -0.05361615866422653, -0.11156454682350159, -0.5443263053894043, -0.16489994525909424, -0.05108858644962311, 0.38213855028152466, 1.0440411567687988, 0.2208050936460495, 0.09957843273878098, -0.4407595992088318, -0.6382390260696411, 0.00010801596363307908, 0.17063520848751068, -0.011091690510511398, -0.4755691885948181, -0.08874819427728653, 0.053797945380210876, 0.5611895322799683, 0.5262522101402283, -0.5523213148117065, 0.28327563405036926, -0.9342918395996094, 0.44909268617630005, 0.034561507403850555, 0.3316729664802551, 0.7601937651634216, 0.28444188833236694, 0.053390100598335266, 0.33483195304870605, -0.2916356027126312, -0.1278071105480194, -0.489206999540329, -0.36794283986091614, -0.0716969221830368, 0.5209687352180481, 0.8261423110961914, -0.7952688336372375, 0.6574997901916504, -0.4094856083393097, -0.14380542933940887, -0.3044676184654236, 0.33521565794944763, 0.3919641673564911, 0.11847157776355743, 0.5470325350761414, 0.0637112483382225, -0.7430849075317383, -0.9449753165245056, -0.21911101043224335, -0.39024266600608826, -0.33683478832244873, 0.13025757670402527, 0.1939871609210968, 0.14267215132713318, 1.2682613134384155, -0.8962706923484802, -0.7214277386665344, -0.29007411003112793, 0.1878289431333542, -0.1449129432439804, 0.43046531081199646, 0.788322925567627, -0.8538277745246887, -0.2951122522354126, 0.2807820737361908, -1.2305705547332764, 0.20602582395076752, -0.15052391588687897, -0.3361387848854065, 0.0945492684841156, 0.4810623824596405, -0.8462657928466797, 0.5406286716461182, 0.2033226042985916, -0.12302260100841522, -0.002125883474946022, -0.28034067153930664, -0.23902800679206848, -1.141156792640686, -0.11493934690952301, 0.1220446303486824, 0.14601978659629822, -0.5974492430686951, 0.2762831747531891, 0.39051398634910583, -0.4033668339252472, -0.09525901079177856, 0.2581309676170349, -0.8957021236419678, -0.3473716378211975, -0.18513065576553345, 0.7257596850395203, 0.005916018970310688, 0.75777268409729, -0.01313474029302597, 0.3713470697402954, 0.2459450215101242, -0.3068668246269226, 0.4119721055030823, 0.692020058631897, -0.267936110496521, 0.459461510181427, -0.07413717359304428, 0.5340640544891357, -0.15514029562473297, -0.04396266117691994, -0.9866642951965332, 0.004709294997155666, 0.26653969287872314, -0.49628686904907227, 0.2925029695034027, 0.16986766457557678, -0.47843679785728455, -0.5339030027389526, -0.38571375608444214, -0.19141577184200287, 0.35775551199913025, -0.5772329568862915, 0.4357433319091797, 0.6190861463546753, -0.5384004712104797, -0.24876195192337036, -0.7803840041160583, 0.20483264327049255, -0.010678021237254143, -0.9955086708068848, 0.6279951333999634, 0.6806657910346985, -0.10113837569952011, 0.26068979501724243, -0.23623207211494446, -0.3593854010105133, -0.12910301983356476, 0.050747089087963104, 0.2741614580154419, -0.19402669370174408, 0.08706273883581161, 0.2830560505390167, -0.28643161058425903, 0.3845919966697693, 0.20240892469882965, 0.16039805114269257, 0.5443590879440308, 0.3257739543914795, -0.5840681195259094, 0.5208879709243774, 0.30129289627075195, -0.5135812759399414, 0.19775742292404175, 0.5419871807098389, -0.7291803359985352, -0.1370183229446411, -0.33770430088043213, -0.15651728212833405, -0.36998316645622253, 0.9044177532196045, -0.765648365020752, -0.5991957783699036, 0.3476788103580475, -0.30945074558258057, 0.1983668953180313, 0.31413164734840393, -0.07641837000846863, -0.21114400029182434, 0.7720559239387512, 0.8852363228797913, -0.18717201054096222, 0.08616535365581512, -0.24344660341739655, 0.6952871680259705, -0.9581263065338135, -0.5749279856681824, -0.5794933438301086, -0.42322492599487305, -0.36674609780311584, -0.24821175634860992, 0.37584933638572693, 0.7167937159538269, 0.21661238372325897, 0.7558371424674988, -0.24539078772068024, -0.0217527374625206, 0.18022345006465912, 0.2848793864250183, 0.01728394441306591, 0.2622760236263275, -0.12431555241346359, -0.46665969491004944, -0.1969522088766098, -0.3711942136287689, 0.3308563530445099, 0.6218604445457458, 0.17426657676696777, 0.21191413700580597, 0.5521813035011292, -0.2892969250679016, -0.1966402530670166, -0.4917958676815033, 0.45149296522140503, -0.43538302183151245, -0.09433357417583466, -0.5922626852989197, -0.4935488700866699, -0.8326756358146667, 0.2959425151348114, -0.4003256559371948, -1.0297623872756958, 0.25260502099990845, -0.20271384716033936, -0.33088022470474243, 0.11692354083061218, -0.7623462080955505, 0.7040870189666748, -0.33344388008117676, 0.04469642415642738, -0.09830109030008316, -0.6550291776657104, 0.4193341135978699, 0.027874384075403214, 0.09407750517129898, -0.0038665016181766987, 0.1361714005470276, 0.7233154773712158, -0.6800812482833862, 0.3297513723373413, -0.4792323112487793, -0.11531516164541245, 0.06903953105211258, 0.12053177505731583, 0.6392594575881958, 0.39752158522605896, -0.13720867037773132, 0.2138529270887375, -0.016210559755563736, -0.06116902828216553, -1.3374342918395996, 0.5206762552261353, -0.7281296253204346, -0.48522862792015076, 0.040022093802690506, -0.5758497714996338, -0.4753861427307129, 0.10422680526971817, -0.01000427920371294, -0.102505624294281, -0.05054331570863724, -0.03255148231983185, 0.20303770899772644, -0.08799761533737183, 0.42098838090896606, -0.1808958351612091, -0.4023340344429016, -0.566290020942688, 0.7654140591621399, 0.39673087000846863, -0.3632088601589203, 0.5671267509460449, 0.08821617811918259, -0.43485257029533386, -0.17197388410568237, -0.5960816144943237, 0.16963282227516174, -0.047214705497026443, -0.2565574049949646, -0.9370989203453064, -0.7668667435646057, -0.6496294736862183, 0.29511019587516785, -0.2721790671348572, -0.634808361530304, -0.1384126991033554, -0.16483142971992493, 0.36041000485420227, 0.6214091777801514, 0.130754292011261, -0.1372416913509369, -0.691582202911377, 0.6336004734039307, 0.5665211081504822, 0.18534822762012482, -0.16249671578407288, -0.12853971123695374, -0.15806816518306732, 0.08666718006134033, -0.516524612903595, -1.0263959169387817, 0.09332436323165894, -0.007930697873234749, 0.5631579756736755, 0.4319919943809509, -0.1336158961057663, 0.6571308970451355, -0.3651663362979889, 0.7550280094146729, 0.09969525784254074, -0.6392756104469299, 0.7000607848167419, 0.16290196776390076, -0.22558535635471344, 0.2618670165538788, 0.188369020819664, -0.2474563866853714, -0.15619997680187225, -0.5089019536972046, -0.7236592769622803, 0.7901715040206909, 0.5871520042419434, 0.09355925023555756, 0.28110575675964355, 0.9601453542709351, -0.19549432396888733, -0.016625061631202698, -0.3390750288963318, -0.45285564661026, -0.2788526713848114, -0.08573517203330994, 0.3782528340816498, -0.8877929449081421, 0.408333957195282, 0.08127368986606598, 0.35909485816955566, 0.3834286630153656, 0.3845231533050537, -0.021245235577225685, -0.043006911873817444, 0.021349860355257988, -0.04138921946287155, 0.3115094006061554, 0.6765235066413879, -0.2919809818267822, 0.1243491917848587, -0.02039066143333912, -0.5045661330223083, -0.1869916468858719, 0.7041917443275452, -0.2499808669090271, 0.021214991807937622, 0.48795250058174133, 0.6049851179122925, -0.13005223870277405, 0.39533549547195435, 0.667884349822998, 0.5254921913146973, -0.3265291452407837, -0.11458075791597366, -0.16175082325935364, 0.335883766412735, 0.3042904734611511, 0.09909661114215851, -0.16513030230998993, 0.18746674060821533, -0.6010169386863708, 0.5429147481918335, 0.28104543685913086, -0.504708468914032, -0.05098922550678253, 0.8509538173675537, 0.24930548667907715, -0.4040112793445587, 1.0228447914123535, -0.210779070854187, -0.3623941242694855, 0.4679834842681885, 0.36770424246788025, 0.5865440368652344, -0.10646329075098038, 0.2156209647655487, 0.4973648488521576, 0.14172136783599854, 0.15146096050739288, 0.1073705181479454, 0.1207347959280014, -0.8643966317176819, -0.2547774612903595, -0.3230419158935547, 0.11601079255342484, 0.4447811543941498, -0.6616219282150269, 0.49971210956573486, -0.42739370465278625, 0.16548624634742737, 0.3070935606956482, 0.2276633232831955, -0.3630664050579071, -0.019696759060025215, 0.31624263525009155, 0.7005939483642578, -0.4868519604206085, 0.9920287728309631, 0.9072847366333008, -0.7409939765930176, -0.8861747980117798, -0.021242165938019753, -0.05984479933977127, -0.5644036531448364, 0.7364705204963684, 0.20372989773750305, 0.27450793981552124, -0.3359622359275818, -0.00635469751432538, -0.6621099710464478, 1.1541804075241089, 0.37520506978034973, -0.49857938289642334, -0.24498401582241058, 0.6001473069190979, 0.5042005777359009, -0.5485045909881592, 0.15621580183506012, 0.7587241530418396, 0.3673626482486725, 0.08515972644090652, -0.5973581075668335, 0.2557961940765381, -0.31611397862434387, 0.9316414594650269, 0.2615463435649872, -0.4840475618839264, 0.48264431953430176, -0.18303562700748444, -0.39621129631996155, 0.08741114288568497, 1.2797805070877075, 0.2749428153038025, 0.19370511174201965, 0.6787645816802979, 0.5520055890083313, 0.615938127040863, 0.09089070558547974, 0.3003602623939514, -0.15453188121318817, 0.5291129350662231, 1.2694499492645264, -0.6348169445991516, 1.0293692350387573, 0.3349635601043701, -0.3005940318107605, 0.7018499970436096, 0.3362977206707001, -0.18261457979679108, 0.7273005843162537, 0.19192050397396088, 0.31503504514694214, 0.0614791139960289, 0.3007843792438507, -0.288251131772995, 0.763542115688324, 0.33860287070274353, -0.27164265513420105, -0.4727490246295929, -0.1360165774822235, 0.20497053861618042, 0.6040882468223572, 0.1123436987400055, 0.8678723573684692, 0.282208651304245, -0.3436617851257324, 0.09121289849281311, 0.07262562960386276, 0.045064058154821396, 0.0022982030641287565, -0.6046280264854431, -0.36073803901672363, -0.11107315868139267, -0.24604468047618866, -0.9252504110336304, 0.26704832911491394, -0.3017427623271942, -0.1875770092010498, -0.05938602238893509, 0.46999043226242065, -0.6626701354980469, -0.40264880657196045, 0.3459421396255493, 0.30319473147392273, 0.20389845967292786, -0.12441613525152206, -0.5109575986862183, -0.32857269048690796, 0.07289411127567291, -0.09996283799409866, 0.14577007293701172, 0.7842749357223511, -0.23550420999526978, -0.013826564885675907, 0.337917298078537, 0.21298250555992126, -0.4762832522392273, 0.055947884917259216, 0.8216732740402222, -0.5745684504508972, -0.7561601400375366, -0.7257458567619324, 0.569624662399292, -0.5577326416969299, -0.3419346809387207, 0.3485632836818695, 0.7975117564201355, 0.6056163311004639, 0.2193165123462677, 0.7974399328231812, -0.24082303047180176, 0.6907774209976196, -0.6609163284301758, 0.8172301054000854, -0.17436973750591278, 0.3731791377067566, -0.12896724045276642, -1.2965950965881348, -0.4978501796722412, 0.6505118012428284, -0.21250471472740173, 0.1097952276468277, 1.0687627792358398, 0.7986665368080139, 0.00786545965820551, 0.09498290717601776, 0.12077146768569946, 0.38405945897102356, 0.3279988467693329, 0.6085594296455383, 0.5076967477798462, -0.8053179979324341, 0.8043920993804932, -0.5785340070724487, -0.3530423939228058, 0.0682559534907341, -0.5062394738197327, -1.0577259063720703, -0.6928136944770813, -0.33622831106185913, -0.3355516791343689, -0.08676706999540329, 0.5513671040534973, 0.5270469784736633, -0.5023311972618103, 0.06038696691393852, 0.14136643707752228, -0.03600423410534859, -0.3884337544441223, -0.20662066340446472, 0.9614185094833374, -0.3585795760154724, -0.5387958288192749, 0.1311134546995163, 0.46564242243766785, -0.24175521731376648, -0.3511374592781067, 0.19881726801395416, -0.3632916510105133, -0.5392709374427795, 0.5746316313743591, -0.08593876659870148, -0.46884456276893616, -0.4936780631542206, -0.203843355178833, -0.3101670444011688, 0.2359510362148285, 0.9171019196510315, -0.5364863872528076, 0.26813995838165283, 0.6457011699676514, 0.5146728754043579, 0.8435289263725281, 0.14089015126228333, 0.5127080678939819, -0.8702090382575989, 0.27652525901794434, -0.17263834178447723, 0.19277484714984894, 0.23199117183685303, -0.8765209913253784, 0.6044113636016846, 0.11669347435235977, -0.2933956980705261, -0.3352102041244507, 0.364895761013031, -0.976862907409668, -0.22633127868175507, 0.9978410601615906, -0.25669530034065247, -0.14996324479579926, -0.15229001641273499, -0.15353985130786896, 0.31093689799308777, -0.03988173231482506, 0.9037894010543823, 0.4676022231578827, -0.34137609601020813, -0.5350666046142578, -0.4475514590740204, 0.5759778022766113, -0.05058065056800842, -0.92494136095047, -0.01527547836303711, 0.166362464427948, -0.004122146870940924, 0.5474137663841248, 0.3008604049682617, -0.5379613041877747, 0.1232684850692749, 0.09960166364908218, 0.29676076769828796, -0.31131550669670105, -0.24566276371479034, 0.14169639348983765, 0.3673197627067566, -0.10242520272731781, -0.28438806533813477 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04949v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04949v1
SilverSight: A Multi-Task Chinese Financial Large Language Model Based on Adaptive Semantic Space Learning
2024-04-07T13:02:21
2024-04-07T13:02:21
Yuhang Zhou, Zeping Li, Siyu Tian, Yuchen Ni, Sen Liu, Guangnan Ye, Hongfeng Chai
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.CE
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being applied across various specialized fields, leveraging their extensive knowledge to empower a multitude of scenarios within these domains. However, each field encompasses a variety of specific tasks that require learning, and the diverse, heterogeneous data across these domains can lead to conflicts during model task transfer. In response to this challenge, our study introduces an Adaptive Semantic Space Learning (ASSL) framework, which utilizes the adaptive reorganization of data distributions within the semantic space to enhance the performance and selection efficacy of multi-expert models. Utilizing this framework, we trained a financial multi-task LLM named "SilverSight". Our research findings demonstrate that our framework can achieve results close to those obtained with full data training using only 10% of the data, while also exhibiting strong generalization capabilities.
[ 0.1750236451625824, -0.6341201663017273, 0.4791944622993469, 0.25999605655670166, -0.07136119157075882, 0.23990149796009064, -0.1305847316980362, -0.3717988431453705, -0.16458357870578766, 0.6210957169532776, -0.4027286171913147, -0.744672954082489, -0.7324565052986145, -0.29856371879577637, -0.4265325665473938, 1.1214100122451782, 0.11477073282003403, 0.015351892448961735, 0.1645626425743103, -0.17796117067337036, -0.4698127508163452, -0.20437081158161163, -0.8616622686386108, -0.2070578634738922, 0.12728872895240784, 0.3162600100040436, 0.7488567233085632, 0.5343357920646667, 0.6045824289321899, 0.4595229923725128, 0.12242428958415985, 0.35860103368759155, -0.29612427949905396, -0.3272526264190674, -0.19029375910758972, -0.46501457691192627, -0.7457557320594788, -0.19030968844890594, 0.6833214163780212, 0.7913728356361389, -0.4368104338645935, -0.06882617622613907, 0.03696249797940254, 0.67821204662323, -0.849339485168457, 0.5442972183227539, -0.9904979467391968, 0.12681140005588531, 0.13051366806030273, -0.07001495361328125, -0.46341365575790405, 0.19962385296821594, 0.46027687191963196, -1.0989458560943604, 0.10700895637273788, 0.18150073289871216, 0.5278444290161133, 0.22964069247245789, -0.61827552318573, -0.30367058515548706, -0.4386293590068817, 0.8812738060951233, -0.7386206984519958, 0.38032639026641846, 0.21505743265151978, 0.34675541520118713, 0.06561890244483948, -0.663474440574646, -0.28010275959968567, -0.052186161279678345, 0.1491018384695053, 0.3171831965446472, -0.2440374195575714, -0.08755507320165634, -0.0830640196800232, -0.08868767321109772, -0.337873637676239, 0.14580510556697845, -0.39265313744544983, -0.11078769713640213, 0.7250455617904663, 0.23505789041519165, -0.13203498721122742, 0.3550036549568176, -0.5019879937171936, -0.4219804108142853, -0.38689306378364563, -0.21686309576034546, 0.1565663367509842, 0.5384882688522339, -0.1392410397529602, 0.09671808034181595, -0.18331000208854675, 0.8750308752059937, 0.061743367463350296, -0.34006842970848083, 0.5044162273406982, -0.15867911279201508, -0.5729191899299622, 0.0269016083329916, 0.31746742129325867, 0.24086607992649078, 0.03899626061320305, -0.3357214033603668, -0.371523916721344, 0.015213281847536564, 0.2457999587059021, -0.24401865899562836, -0.4028542637825012, 0.2206391841173172, -0.2751070261001587, 0.04642299562692642, 0.15308259427547455, -0.6038604378700256, -0.5833057165145874, -0.34480899572372437, 0.31317195296287537, -0.5545505881309509, -0.06265456974506378, 0.47923538088798523, -0.1702863574028015, 0.23522424697875977, 0.46356046199798584, -1.0188850164413452, 0.34888654947280884, 0.8507517576217651, 0.8081291913986206, -0.21919813752174377, -0.6439490914344788, -0.9752578139305115, 0.6205824017524719, -0.35261353850364685, 0.8437382578849792, -0.32809603214263916, -0.38154152035713196, -0.0838695839047432, -0.12099912762641907, -0.39396387338638306, -0.44580990076065063, 0.22829191386699677, -0.5697600841522217, -0.15233488380908966, -0.034744247794151306, -0.44165194034576416, -0.29611045122146606, 0.4203944504261017, -0.594271719455719, 0.43983790278434753, 0.25667858123779297, -0.616718590259552, 0.7561426758766174, -0.9578948616981506, -0.4230648875236511, 0.12464071065187454, 0.03707626461982727, -0.3446751534938812, -0.08487104624509811, 0.23969736695289612, 0.6277921795845032, 0.10355029255151749, 0.09960498660802841, -0.49203717708587646, -0.2017797827720642, 0.33571121096611023, -0.28770262002944946, 0.2659156918525696, 0.22804981470108032, -0.2159670889377594, 0.399019330739975, -1.0155019760131836, -0.2696319818496704, 0.018731191754341125, -0.2978995144367218, -0.7500028610229492, 0.18083027005195618, 0.2636964023113251, 0.16828782856464386, 0.4168577790260315, -0.41206270456314087, 0.12081282585859299, -0.9833648204803467, 0.3744097054004669, 1.1420955657958984, -0.40442702174186707, 0.721971333026886, -0.40275898575782776, 0.18559615314006805, 0.4282093644142151, 0.06300196051597595, 0.12394146621227264, 0.04561144486069679, -0.7155089974403381, -0.09935834258794785, 0.06798621267080307, 0.7203234434127808, -0.6780000329017639, 0.17249101400375366, -0.24347709119319916, -0.3596380054950714, -0.49360331892967224, 0.46537280082702637, 0.18157540261745453, 0.21082735061645508, 0.3745180070400238, -0.09017367660999298, -0.28659456968307495, -0.7537738680839539, -0.25112488865852356, -0.12238594889640808, 0.18229976296424866, 0.37437087297439575, 0.5237264037132263, -0.40992581844329834, 0.7187646627426147, -0.8284062147140503, -0.6655587553977966, -0.11867133527994156, 0.1633128821849823, 0.26704493165016174, 0.26090559363365173, 0.5875845551490784, -1.2456234693527222, -0.523157000541687, 0.6513087153434753, -0.4884185492992401, 0.2857287526130676, -0.40789180994033813, -0.11706438660621643, 0.197675883769989, 0.42384228110313416, -0.4450402557849884, 0.26241496205329895, 0.8036652207374573, -0.8373041749000549, 0.3932504653930664, -0.6357216835021973, -0.13975845277309418, -1.3253170251846313, 0.05653446912765503, 0.21533529460430145, -0.18695342540740967, -0.535258412361145, 0.11490518599748611, 0.23521658778190613, 0.09035404771566391, -0.35283178091049194, 0.8923087120056152, -0.3956485986709595, -0.5101994872093201, -0.5540686845779419, 0.3754868507385254, -0.23110570013523102, 0.38282275199890137, -0.03951353579759598, 0.8156158924102783, 0.6894304752349854, -0.5660779476165771, 0.5177600979804993, 0.47090303897857666, -0.36992818117141724, 0.6135481595993042, -0.34613698720932007, -0.23083576560020447, -0.047927118837833405, -0.07419987767934799, -1.2283726930618286, -0.10724706202745438, 0.05245920270681381, -0.13297757506370544, 0.07228541374206543, 0.4076831638813019, -0.2520774006843567, -0.03348135948181152, 0.02142905257642269, 0.041362471878528595, 0.07175746560096741, -0.4406833052635193, 0.9985756874084473, 0.34330281615257263, -0.44046324491500854, -0.8197311758995056, -0.6691104173660278, 0.15304622054100037, -0.3386210799217224, -0.5922319293022156, 0.43024829030036926, -0.05700613930821419, -0.5872472524642944, 0.06595364958047867, -0.020044667646288872, 0.05635619908571243, 0.5663140416145325, 0.0895521491765976, 0.6921452283859253, -0.03025708720088005, 0.28538116812705994, -0.10231801867485046, -0.2998468279838562, -0.1632823944091797, -0.5805867314338684, 0.30133289098739624, -0.08882053196430206, -0.46166113018989563, -0.005940526258200407, 0.1101871132850647, 0.4877592921257019, -0.3515969514846802, 0.8909291625022888, 0.4746359586715698, -0.11553644388914108, -0.4444659352302551, -0.45015770196914673, 0.2691190540790558, -0.51693195104599, 0.8865293264389038, -0.33352819085121155, -0.9978280067443848, 0.7200799584388733, -0.21366004645824432, 0.7974519729614258, 0.6414259076118469, 0.670846164226532, 0.2933809459209442, 1.2166107892990112, 1.0130157470703125, -0.42922887206077576, 0.5021598935127258, -0.18995067477226257, 0.0569244809448719, -0.5810191631317139, -0.1335894912481308, -0.24646858870983124, -0.22973310947418213, 0.021157192066311836, -0.4380893111228943, 0.4336896538734436, -0.40263989567756653, -0.3641565442085266, 0.011509984731674194, -0.09975850582122803, 0.3275110721588135, 0.1904420107603073, -0.034203026443719864, 0.33725684881210327, -0.10358671844005585, 0.0025368088390678167, 0.32982876896858215, -0.5803325176239014, -0.05795792117714882, 1.1430665254592896, 0.3587604761123657, 0.9670869708061218, 0.10758297145366669, 0.25757357478141785, 0.4718970060348511, 0.22180038690567017, -0.6245300769805908, 0.3702772259712219, -0.8646991848945618, -0.15284757316112518, -0.44075825810432434, -0.5820949673652649, -0.8417149186134338, 0.45101800560951233, -0.28603073954582214, -0.6877424716949463, 0.0685320794582367, 0.04447074234485626, -0.7650294899940491, 0.22754956781864166, -0.6624909043312073, 0.7852674126625061, -0.49185842275619507, -0.05139382556080818, -0.3541368842124939, -0.44618892669677734, 0.25326159596443176, -0.6515833735466003, 0.5927040576934814, -0.06946394592523575, -0.2475975751876831, 0.7468976378440857, -0.045159924775362015, 0.9250078797340393, -0.2676462233066559, -0.24367091059684753, -0.1794755607843399, -0.12180761247873306, 0.7481880784034729, -0.07153823226690292, -0.12513288855552673, -0.19883663952350616, 0.024270284920930862, -0.45557767152786255, -0.433391809463501, 0.6629201173782349, -1.0932613611221313, -0.40488749742507935, -0.3642987608909607, -1.1924940347671509, -0.5846296548843384, 0.08413083106279373, -0.2967108488082886, 0.0573987141251564, -0.11850618571043015, 0.20931580662727356, 0.3842815160751343, -0.12485605478286743, 0.3746814429759979, 0.7897074818611145, -0.11387712508440018, -0.3646406829357147, 0.8816519975662231, 0.010169188492000103, 0.31928086280822754, 0.21371671557426453, -0.07421091198921204, -0.39410239458084106, -0.7007980346679688, -0.17669177055358887, 0.12489068508148193, -0.9978510737419128, -0.16948913037776947, -0.6769214868545532, -0.25521743297576904, -0.6467242240905762, -0.5183383822441101, -0.39066797494888306, -0.027565648779273033, -0.46529892086982727, -0.04763871431350708, 0.33432719111442566, 0.4158354699611664, 0.11101873219013214, 0.6568625569343567, -0.9699126482009888, 0.20027750730514526, 0.3672467768192291, 0.23034636676311493, 0.1557953953742981, -0.5909035205841064, -0.640896737575531, 0.05395610257983208, -0.23303239047527313, -0.2221555858850479, 0.7669767737388611, 0.4582494795322418, 0.6788923144340515, 0.5574303269386292, -0.13798139989376068, 0.9492542147636414, -0.2113235890865326, 0.47340863943099976, 0.3036777079105377, -0.9150757193565369, 0.138253316283226, -0.2352360486984253, 0.6314412355422974, 0.39255577325820923, 0.03700118511915207, -0.7077496647834778, -0.5301113128662109, -0.5101534724235535, -0.9382110238075256, 0.6305262446403503, -0.3733915388584137, 0.13950346410274506, 0.3303147852420807, 0.32301604747772217, 0.37655505537986755, 0.21369613707065582, -0.6465064287185669, 0.006725649815052748, -0.07477206736803055, -0.3206532895565033, -0.4257516860961914, 0.1504003405570984, -0.1627984493970871, 0.09087556600570679, 0.8308948874473572, -0.7544152140617371, -0.03682917356491089, -0.1511988788843155, -0.06672731786966324, 0.00014211349480319768, 0.18382389843463898, 0.37182843685150146, 1.0941379070281982, 0.10535892099142075, -0.16050468385219574, 0.5638938546180725, -0.4019359350204468, -0.07657802850008011, 0.5137233138084412, 0.10439011454582214, -0.37870126962661743, 0.4382322132587433, 1.0620557069778442, 0.5613978505134583, -1.0439625978469849, 0.44715142250061035, 0.029848575592041016, -0.6302589774131775, -0.5074424147605896, 0.29307547211647034, 0.06455811113119125, 0.8830711841583252, 0.7741333246231079, 0.18588252365589142, 0.1366165727376938, -0.5331884622573853, 0.3754858672618866, 0.5164199471473694, -0.2467161864042282, -0.1807674765586853, 0.7616168856620789, -0.03659375384449959, 0.3017907440662384, 0.6140187382698059, 0.0886058583855629, -0.43248727917671204, 0.5398223996162415, 0.68160080909729, 0.7093877196311951, -0.05277813598513603, 0.2722181975841522, -0.12450765818357468, -0.1461123824119568, -0.2038746476173401, 0.3039754331111908, 0.1810392290353775, -1.0138033628463745, -0.7023313045501709, -0.8301171064376831, -0.3432116210460663, -0.11160527169704437, -0.39102572202682495, 0.13084794580936432, -0.7162806391716003, -0.11623993515968323, 0.18707764148712158, 0.07016072422266006, -0.5106223821640015, 0.32133328914642334, 0.354250967502594, 1.1979913711547852, -0.9343674182891846, 0.7536723017692566, 0.8200916051864624, 0.2394372820854187, -0.6766073703765869, -0.3192094564437866, 0.023784689605236053, -1.049631953239441, 0.7810247540473938, -0.1695285439491272, -0.049424175173044205, 0.1505202203989029, -0.4219544529914856, -0.9294788241386414, 1.3015702962875366, 0.27079489827156067, -0.6206822395324707, -0.30095359683036804, -0.010549725033342838, 0.3813908100128174, -0.6090535521507263, -0.3374125063419342, 0.46766334772109985, 0.4584265351295471, 0.4893757104873657, -0.856490433216095, -0.5038378834724426, -0.24308574199676514, -0.057590413838624954, 0.3422470688819885, -0.9665239453315735, 1.1427780389785767, -0.15434731543064117, 0.01949373073875904, 0.10655509680509567, 0.9501836895942688, 0.47619545459747314, 0.5210608839988708, 0.766106903553009, 0.4405653476715088, 0.8147328495979309, 0.04841037839651108, 0.6498539447784424, -0.5063255429267883, 0.5421132445335388, 0.9113421440124512, -0.7579912543296814, 1.0170998573303223, 0.42757633328437805, -0.14478251338005066, 0.3925383388996124, 0.455840528011322, -0.31795912981033325, 0.6758301258087158, -0.1487084925174713, -0.1913885772228241, -0.44996917247772217, 0.04727811738848686, -0.09898653626441956, 0.8044947981834412, 0.4602108895778656, -0.23669156432151794, -0.26345953345298767, 0.3434270918369293, -0.2998260259628296, 0.022032923996448517, -0.6269378662109375, 0.960242509841919, 0.13842037320137024, -0.3804921507835388, -0.11440903693437576, 0.3042871952056885, 0.8517266511917114, -1.1135892868041992, 0.04644545540213585, 0.0898154154419899, 0.5469595789909363, -0.050053611397743225, -0.549081027507782, 0.2861296534538269, -0.2977459132671356, 0.03144650161266327, -0.09321040660142899, 0.9700359106063843, -0.3544832468032837, -0.7423384189605713, 0.35434845089912415, 0.4633755385875702, -0.17621074616909027, -0.026566265150904655, -0.8932940363883972, -0.3424595892429352, -0.1581559181213379, -0.1277661919593811, 0.6112160086631775, 0.45563945174217224, -0.04304574057459831, 0.8671286106109619, 0.947109043598175, 0.35548681020736694, -0.11954151839017868, -0.2175714075565338, 0.8325031399726868, -0.6598355174064636, -1.169208288192749, -0.7679522037506104, 0.3914485573768616, -0.1259700059890747, -0.24945658445358276, 0.8509695529937744, 0.4816298186779022, 0.9262225031852722, -0.06537254899740219, 0.939734697341919, 0.35923439264297485, 0.3778488039970398, -0.6441531181335449, 0.6786595582962036, -0.7798004746437073, 0.2443535476922989, -0.2735842168331146, -0.8884609341621399, -0.44177672266960144, 0.6746324300765991, -0.6387216448783875, -0.025548627600073814, 0.304073691368103, 0.450151264667511, -0.1663428246974945, 0.025305286049842834, 0.547096312046051, 0.26997828483581543, 0.13443736732006073, 0.9494595527648926, 0.5408055186271667, -0.21833842992782593, 0.38467884063720703, 0.0937274619936943, -0.04416664317250252, -0.24194015562534332, -0.640118420124054, -0.7338230013847351, -0.5840707421302795, -0.25900572538375854, -0.08354130387306213, 0.008689362555742264, 0.88972008228302, 0.5667398571968079, -0.7150056958198547, -0.46595317125320435, 0.25262072682380676, -0.3359335660934448, -0.43006250262260437, -0.1377943456172943, 0.7118504643440247, -0.2965807318687439, -0.6643339991569519, 0.30435875058174133, 0.7058795690536499, -0.011716563254594803, -0.3342067301273346, -0.38777267932891846, -0.17904549837112427, -0.10552609711885452, 0.7082458734512329, 0.06550092995166779, -0.4165208339691162, -0.4433971047401428, 0.03495513275265694, 0.03508307412266731, -0.19659754633903503, 0.45291975140571594, -0.5343301296234131, 0.2849036157131195, 0.18508067727088928, 1.0213274955749512, 0.1825563758611679, 0.10929238051176071, 0.4324730634689331, -0.6327527165412903, 0.3383032977581024, -0.057941678911447525, 0.44438663125038147, 0.11196240782737732, -0.4354582726955414, 0.3616989254951477, 0.18847422301769257, -0.5017040967941284, -0.3640521168708801, -0.2769566774368286, -0.9270505309104919, -0.7151297926902771, 1.193771243095398, -0.24246187508106232, -0.43710076808929443, -0.2081683725118637, -0.2737228572368622, 0.0692448765039444, -0.27245959639549255, 0.8845801949501038, 0.7804521322250366, 0.10403135418891907, -0.10737022012472153, -0.6566423177719116, 0.07077766954898834, 0.49103590846061707, -0.8019333481788635, 0.34158065915107727, 0.506826639175415, 0.2626391649246216, 0.173680379986763, 0.5554987788200378, 0.2275974154472351, 0.6379052996635437, 0.15275341272354126, -0.2250681221485138, -0.06985313445329666, -0.4236319363117218, -0.290256142616272, 0.36318203806877136, 0.1726102977991104, 0.0293246079236269 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04941v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04941v1
Prompting Large Language Models for Zero-shot Essay Scoring via Multi-trait Specialization
2024-04-07T12:25:35
2024-04-07T12:25:35
Sanwoo Lee, Yida Cai, Desong Meng, Ziyang Wang, Yunfang Wu
cs.CL
cs.CL
Advances in automated essay scoring (AES) have traditionally relied on labeled essays, requiring tremendous cost and expertise for their acquisition. Recently, large language models (LLMs) have achieved great success in various tasks, but their potential is less explored in AES. In this paper, we propose Multi Trait Specialization (MTS), a zero-shot prompting framework to elicit essay scoring capabilities in LLMs. Specifically, we leverage ChatGPT to decompose writing proficiency into distinct traits and generate scoring criteria for each trait. Then, an LLM is prompted to extract trait scores from several conversational rounds, each round scoring one of the traits based on the scoring criteria. Finally, we derive the overall score via trait averaging and min-max scaling. Experimental results on two benchmark datasets demonstrate that MTS consistently outperforms straightforward prompting (Vanilla) in average QWK across all LLMs and datasets, with maximum gains of 0.437 on TOEFL11 and 0.355 on ASAP. Additionally, with the help of MTS, the small-sized Llama2-13b-chat substantially outperforms ChatGPT, facilitating an effective deployment in real applications.
[ -0.36003920435905457, -0.945746898651123, 0.812960684299469, 0.47124427556991577, -0.03720589727163315, 0.13531175255775452, -0.48279762268066406, -0.4166918992996216, 0.3268710672855377, 0.2673206031322479, -0.44792991876602173, -0.7541456818580627, -0.5595434308052063, 0.39860573410987854, -0.21212725341320038, 1.131792426109314, 0.027435127645730972, -0.2697136402130127, -0.21884232759475708, -0.15437956154346466, -0.5017373561859131, -0.42253053188323975, -0.8717784881591797, -0.027309812605381012, 1.060763955116272, 0.9075937867164612, -0.005828994791954756, 0.40025919675827026, 0.29069021344184875, 0.2681974172592163, 0.2708635926246643, 0.22936159372329712, -0.2466350942850113, 0.4411081075668335, 0.3436858355998993, -0.6151030659675598, -0.6671547889709473, 0.1749487966299057, 0.7266025543212891, 0.5625448226928711, -0.0008689328678883612, 0.4417041540145874, 0.2842932641506195, 0.17642435431480408, -0.6119054555892944, 0.229666605591774, -0.6104679703712463, 0.10996639728546143, -0.15957485139369965, -0.22692665457725525, -0.7736252546310425, -0.35470470786094666, -0.032819706946611404, -0.48136845231056213, 0.0840977355837822, -0.068278469145298, 0.4906857907772064, -0.13473713397979736, -0.47820529341697693, -0.025914756581187248, -0.36237576603889465, 1.0790228843688965, -0.600490152835846, -0.1772468090057373, 0.2628321945667267, 0.16845642030239105, 0.13113434612751007, -0.201928973197937, -0.5094125866889954, -0.31922483444213867, 0.013060024008154869, 0.14478367567062378, 0.0423603281378746, 0.2922731339931488, 0.36700862646102905, 0.48057088255882263, -0.7138310670852661, 0.4896920621395111, -0.23179470002651215, -0.0677538514137268, 0.4868283271789551, 0.3741723895072937, -0.04621812328696251, -0.08965957909822464, -0.022848710417747498, -0.14370320737361908, -0.6358495354652405, 0.4928843379020691, 0.4645061194896698, 0.5788283944129944, -0.17509996891021729, 0.6787010431289673, -0.18584005534648895, 0.6676936149597168, 0.16011744737625122, -0.20196084678173065, 0.10647868365049362, 0.11049921065568924, -0.13505491614341736, -0.26486244797706604, 0.9316304922103882, 0.49526941776275635, 0.22320276498794556, 0.14177291095256805, -0.10811904817819595, -0.01275820191949606, 0.20193879306316376, -0.9000917673110962, -0.007565136067569256, 0.34728240966796875, -0.39103272557258606, -0.6345230937004089, -0.36438417434692383, -1.1916804313659668, -0.4728451669216156, -0.14604642987251282, 0.5133613348007202, -0.4753553569316864, -0.04013596102595329, 0.041153647005558014, -0.331318199634552, 0.6450947523117065, 0.35841795802116394, -1.1228864192962646, -0.015088227577507496, 0.5572954416275024, 0.950065553188324, -0.2743001878261566, -0.5046058297157288, -0.7742562890052795, -0.13404293358325958, -0.46805113554000854, 1.2207709550857544, -0.8043302297592163, -0.5815467834472656, 0.22092409431934357, -0.36328667402267456, -0.3506471514701843, -0.18634659051895142, 0.9081200957298279, -0.008034070953726768, 0.2566876709461212, -0.3934458792209625, -0.5490763783454895, -0.042887888848781586, 0.7440143823623657, -0.35366541147232056, 1.2936525344848633, 0.08262220770120621, -0.48274335265159607, 0.40807145833969116, -0.8718602657318115, -0.5088889598846436, 0.13478922843933105, -0.31822311878204346, -0.4554367661476135, 0.3162461221218109, 0.37455400824546814, 0.8614142537117004, -0.23887188732624054, -0.10234323143959045, -0.5962662100791931, -0.38076573610305786, 0.23822395503520966, -0.6451245546340942, 0.2987516224384308, -0.28769582509994507, -0.06214471533894539, 0.02812471054494381, -0.78410404920578, 0.27927371859550476, -0.12197048962116241, -0.5760488510131836, -0.06922019273042679, -0.2648601531982422, -0.22918163239955902, 0.14811579883098602, 0.0877424106001854, -0.7565844655036926, 0.44382983446121216, -0.18261434137821198, 0.16690556704998016, 0.9433211088180542, 0.05043536424636841, 0.2190941572189331, -0.7302671074867249, 0.6993622779846191, -0.25018393993377686, 0.1358897089958191, -0.5922495722770691, -0.725070595741272, -0.8859972357749939, -0.7315749526023865, -0.013124566525220871, 0.6028544306755066, -0.52741938829422, 0.5188376307487488, -0.06964332610368729, -0.6281889081001282, -0.5558582544326782, -0.02364974655210972, 0.37944740056991577, 0.502396285533905, 0.4758540093898773, 0.04687358811497688, -0.16038425266742706, -0.7394870519638062, -0.3289351463317871, -0.20930616557598114, -0.19568796455860138, 0.41996628046035767, 0.32036685943603516, 0.3394760489463806, 0.7421408295631409, -0.8336946964263916, -0.5195672512054443, -0.6370263695716858, 0.6032871007919312, 0.14570195972919464, 0.24630361795425415, 0.8337369561195374, -0.13734230399131775, -0.9178450107574463, -0.14315758645534515, -0.5365064740180969, -0.32273462414741516, -0.18047241866588593, -0.013058683834969997, 0.11871089041233063, 0.30741095542907715, -0.7148286700248718, 0.31533369421958923, 0.5495274662971497, -0.22409124672412872, 1.1510002613067627, -0.004670400638133287, 0.5137608051300049, -1.0413496494293213, 0.1267925500869751, 0.16912268102169037, -0.011554940603673458, -0.6338541507720947, 0.09366551041603088, -0.11040222644805908, -0.04810832813382149, -0.09337441623210907, 0.5933285355567932, -0.07141078263521194, 0.32547903060913086, -0.15342094004154205, -0.2190684676170349, 0.30949291586875916, 0.713142454624176, -0.029353870078921318, 0.7473358511924744, 0.7144321203231812, -0.4573317766189575, 0.048322271555662155, 0.223104327917099, -0.07026533782482147, 0.991349995136261, -0.5818525552749634, 0.11195202171802521, -0.14556559920310974, 0.20276501774787903, -1.0580811500549316, -0.2639080882072449, -0.17181549966335297, -0.5202985405921936, 0.38861608505249023, -0.17933164536952972, -0.16492244601249695, -0.25684040784835815, -0.8765585422515869, 0.06519339978694916, 0.361908882856369, -0.2122868299484253, 0.774697482585907, -0.13088122010231018, -0.4680069386959076, -0.5358248353004456, -0.5685476660728455, 0.14710207283496857, -0.2770223319530487, -0.4857460558414459, 0.06116028502583504, -0.4468567967414856, 0.02731863036751747, -0.2926863133907318, 0.2720983028411865, -0.0883171558380127, -0.14042632281780243, 0.13229654729366302, 0.44341087341308594, -0.5979529023170471, 0.19468259811401367, 0.2524830996990204, -0.1159510612487793, -0.11921945959329605, -0.43819430470466614, 0.31349289417266846, 0.062179084867239, -0.39446261525154114, -0.41402313113212585, 0.9085416793823242, 0.9069262146949768, -0.27571046352386475, 0.8911835551261902, 0.5021399855613708, 0.060743194073438644, -0.43394380807876587, -0.7936280369758606, -0.29835835099220276, -0.4640760123729706, 0.16699492931365967, -0.44509103894233704, -1.154662013053894, 0.3474089503288269, 0.0326932817697525, 0.4233302175998688, 0.3109111785888672, 0.5359055995941162, -0.1736903041601181, 0.9760265350341797, 0.8060435652732849, 0.0066742924973368645, 0.4309030771255493, -0.16098539531230927, 0.5075944662094116, -0.7458637356758118, -0.06486376374959946, -0.83953857421875, -0.2563413381576538, -0.29936039447784424, -0.4844013750553131, 0.6363187432289124, -0.23825551569461823, -0.06648401916027069, 0.02842770330607891, -0.34801360964775085, 0.8024445176124573, 0.4598144590854645, -0.20873168110847473, 0.14384335279464722, 0.01889093779027462, -0.6272185444831848, -0.15527716279029846, -0.48469650745391846, -0.4439839720726013, 1.3912402391433716, 0.2075183093547821, 0.3760155141353607, -0.09429029375314713, 0.7100877165794373, 0.25130555033683777, 0.4831618070602417, -1.0225133895874023, 0.7156358957290649, -0.3908609449863434, -0.3304351568222046, -0.4933970868587494, -0.28916287422180176, -0.3774171471595764, 0.3033658266067505, -0.39511504769325256, -0.8716904520988464, 0.07412458956241608, 0.1910248100757599, -0.7988032698631287, 0.1978691667318344, -0.7201122045516968, 0.8267470002174377, 0.05138674005866051, -0.30373552441596985, -0.16461029648780823, -0.1684114933013916, 0.3789357542991638, -0.1281360536813736, 0.010160974226891994, -0.3039514124393463, 0.10746153444051743, 0.48163124918937683, 0.05652191862463951, 1.0334227085113525, -0.04021616280078888, -0.024012697860598564, 0.1989167481660843, 0.18303225934505463, 0.4173627495765686, -0.12105932086706161, -0.5999019145965576, 0.0792064294219017, -0.04864668846130371, -0.27900153398513794, -0.6217422485351562, 0.6330855488777161, -0.6161237359046936, -0.5165843963623047, -0.22158899903297424, -0.263736367225647, -0.509454071521759, -0.002692287554964423, 0.31923168897628784, 0.5386858582496643, -0.29971805214881897, 0.23682469129562378, 0.6586006283760071, -0.29601967334747314, 0.5868035554885864, 0.8095841407775879, -0.06727079302072525, -0.19991184771060944, 1.0038772821426392, -0.0011146793840453029, 0.19534805417060852, 0.43896883726119995, 0.35005655884742737, -0.3016636371612549, -0.4361569881439209, -0.5500184893608093, 0.10047333687543869, -0.691623330116272, -0.39383795857429504, -0.9079492688179016, -0.15441226959228516, -0.4137832820415497, -0.5805529952049255, -0.23732325434684753, -0.4640407860279083, -0.10560081899166107, -0.4137668013572693, 0.3416766822338104, 0.6593977808952332, -0.0285851638764143, 0.2993936836719513, -0.8802481889724731, 0.1338581144809723, 0.39879220724105835, 0.46397295594215393, 0.1293552815914154, -0.7605783343315125, -0.0831894651055336, -0.3530379831790924, -0.45945337414741516, -0.6897410750389099, 0.1976192146539688, 0.49052515625953674, 0.4499441087245941, 0.702921986579895, -0.0011420443188399076, 0.5253188610076904, -0.43991026282310486, 0.9434614777565002, 0.057169217616319656, -0.8300654888153076, 0.28155285120010376, -0.5459045767784119, 0.2965943515300751, 0.7001897096633911, 0.43080365657806396, -0.8242049813270569, -0.8522307872772217, -0.08228771388530731, -0.6544888019561768, 0.7057667970657349, -0.09184450656175613, 0.4842108190059662, -0.058340586721897125, 0.32736051082611084, 0.41227710247039795, 0.14580056071281433, -0.895837664604187, -0.010852604173123837, -0.11484850943088531, -0.44807496666908264, 0.014034860767424107, -0.447386771440506, 0.05193900689482689, -0.3301512598991394, 0.6257172226905823, -0.5794187188148499, 0.24766263365745544, 0.01745910756289959, 0.18627770245075226, 0.012079836800694466, 0.6752743721008301, 0.5362876057624817, 0.05778739973902702, 0.03423331677913666, -0.01768416352570057, 0.27585411071777344, -0.43057185411453247, 0.19874893128871918, -0.04129257798194885, -0.23011963069438934, -0.2689175009727478, 0.5534194707870483, 0.5996805429458618, 0.22511202096939087, -0.5550143718719482, 0.7774420380592346, -0.2129211723804474, -0.5790109038352966, -0.06841167062520981, 0.10942071676254272, -0.1748998761177063, -0.014735517092049122, 0.40706953406333923, -0.14465932548046112, -0.08583815395832062, -0.3513253331184387, -0.03861914947628975, 0.406989187002182, -0.27921754121780396, -0.24644842743873596, 0.22144629061222076, 0.4802376329898834, 0.006206769496202469, 0.5859996676445007, -0.45932507514953613, -0.4395255744457245, 0.41017264127731323, 0.3625154495239258, 1.0112149715423584, -0.42041781544685364, 0.6539004445075989, 0.5732331871986389, 0.3476010262966156, 0.09405839443206787, 0.4100993275642395, -0.08991070091724396, -0.5891810059547424, -0.7030155658721924, -1.0989446640014648, -0.504366397857666, 0.30347388982772827, -0.2952512204647064, 0.4358088970184326, -0.5438089966773987, 0.01226096972823143, 0.06554584205150604, -0.16546779870986938, -0.41938406229019165, -0.06697460263967514, 0.1971656084060669, 0.8786121010780334, -1.0588064193725586, 0.5881552696228027, 0.6510334610939026, -0.34745344519615173, -0.968805193901062, 0.13304580748081207, 0.29743772745132446, -0.6071786880493164, 0.1691834181547165, 0.5428285598754883, -0.09594752639532089, 0.016011107712984085, -0.331760436296463, -0.3924674093723297, 0.8075811862945557, 0.2683439254760742, -0.25278499722480774, 0.005809543654322624, 0.45596131682395935, 0.5664587616920471, -0.5332792401313782, 0.6999913454055786, 0.4482947885990143, 0.5887540578842163, 0.21687985956668854, -0.771277129650116, -0.16799567639827728, -0.24715164303779602, -0.42525479197502136, -0.02014971524477005, -0.6999565362930298, 0.9866640567779541, -0.16492699086666107, 0.1012849286198616, 0.044332925230264664, 0.25318965315818787, 0.06477780640125275, 0.08767583221197128, 0.39716485142707825, 0.5150908827781677, 0.731988251209259, 0.021793078631162643, 0.7207961082458496, -0.2510138750076294, -0.06966546177864075, 0.7224079966545105, -0.5340426564216614, 1.0190322399139404, 0.18500524759292603, 0.11987722665071487, 0.7362074255943298, 0.24246199429035187, -0.0027938690036535263, -0.06644731760025024, -0.12879504263401031, -0.7100805640220642, -0.4432767629623413, -0.24789422750473022, 0.02054380066692829, 0.9315009713172913, 0.4075617492198944, -0.11730270087718964, -0.2626868486404419, 0.06376556307077408, 0.09022311121225357, 0.02256745845079422, -0.1918865144252777, 0.8113822937011719, 0.061964575201272964, -1.0823200941085815, 0.13307815790176392, 0.21113190054893494, 0.6618151068687439, -0.89284348487854, -0.27155864238739014, -0.5101504921913147, 0.035756003111600876, -0.0793692097067833, -0.9013740420341492, 0.2042558342218399, 0.3469583988189697, -0.2510239779949188, -0.44777411222457886, 0.6682830452919006, -0.4683971405029297, -0.5815339684486389, 0.2270844578742981, 0.4967142939567566, -0.0784032866358757, -0.1934124231338501, -0.34485721588134766, -0.10471150279045105, -0.34850651025772095, -0.2013881504535675, 0.5120599865913391, 0.5959588885307312, -0.03271180018782616, 0.44048410654067993, 0.7628290057182312, 0.01827559806406498, -0.0864066332578659, 0.13208319246768951, 0.7731635570526123, -0.511398196220398, -0.6578906178474426, -0.8887271881103516, 0.6307190656661987, -0.26504969596862793, -0.33096879720687866, 0.7238891124725342, 0.44874265789985657, 0.28402256965637207, -0.0720944032073021, 0.9868831634521484, -0.015091650187969208, 0.7206396460533142, -0.367144376039505, 0.7316058278083801, -0.39475885033607483, -0.02787080407142639, -0.15598326921463013, -0.798217236995697, -0.34812015295028687, 0.43346357345581055, -0.27680230140686035, -0.04510851204395294, 0.8902837634086609, 0.9557101130485535, 0.12906643748283386, 0.027263814583420753, 0.6609464883804321, 0.08531691133975983, 0.39408135414123535, 0.6909010410308838, 0.8749586939811707, 0.1306651383638382, 0.698351263999939, 0.16720038652420044, -0.6878502368927002, -0.3361658751964569, -1.067212700843811, -1.2059402465820312, -0.4036721885204315, -0.17017540335655212, 0.044768206775188446, -0.21436923742294312, 0.929161548614502, 0.48089122772216797, -0.646826446056366, -0.18336130678653717, 0.3876417875289917, 0.08028077334165573, -0.2158728837966919, -0.2848835289478302, 0.05863554775714874, -0.6299129128456116, -0.5122491121292114, 0.3976863920688629, 0.7947741746902466, -0.06699632108211517, -0.31545761227607727, 0.21513132750988007, -0.0004134205519221723, 0.5913646817207336, 0.777803361415863, 0.34400829672813416, -0.32284030318260193, -0.4792691767215729, 0.20441439747810364, -0.10131371021270752, 0.06942526251077652, 1.105430006980896, -0.4421938955783844, 0.0883122980594635, 0.3036216199398041, 0.36571410298347473, 0.016987822949886322, -0.30803152918815613, 0.5371537804603577, -0.965071439743042, 0.01625138148665428, 0.28108566999435425, 0.1840321272611618, 0.33537906408309937, -0.41406717896461487, -0.030819376930594444, 0.12900669872760773, -0.5916356444358826, -0.6201964616775513, 0.12327587604522705, -0.7061122059822083, -0.1375613510608673, 1.020668387413025, -0.4536815881729126, 0.08638213574886322, -0.2345825582742691, -0.32824307680130005, -0.21030662953853607, -0.4699978828430176, 1.1126588582992554, 0.9413111209869385, -0.3010585904121399, -0.27740976214408875, -0.46470773220062256, 0.5700206160545349, 0.4230177104473114, -0.9759874939918518, 0.3029952347278595, 0.44921210408210754, 0.10900302976369858, -0.02342379279434681, 0.9006578326225281, 0.03248497471213341, 0.35312211513519287, 0.05448101460933685, -0.08768057078123093, -0.009383811615407467, -0.48813238739967346, -0.35015326738357544, 0.5277584791183472, 0.3059115409851074, 0.07486454397439957 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04932v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04932v1
Towards Understanding the Influence of Reward Margin on Preference Model Performance
2024-04-07T12:10:04
2024-04-07T12:10:04
Bowen Qin, Duanyu Feng, Xi Yang
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is a widely used framework for the training of language models. However, the process of using RLHF to develop a language model that is well-aligned presents challenges, especially when it comes to optimizing the reward model. Our research has found that existing reward models, when trained using the traditional ranking objective based on human preference data, often struggle to effectively distinguish between responses that are more or less favorable in real-world scenarios. To bridge this gap, our study introduces a novel method to estimate the preference differences without the need for detailed, exhaustive labels from human annotators. Our experimental results provide empirical evidence that incorporating margin values into the training process significantly improves the effectiveness of reward models. This comparative analysis not only demonstrates the superiority of our approach in terms of reward prediction accuracy but also highlights its effectiveness in practical applications.
[ -0.5447309613227844, -0.10520327091217041, 0.24224649369716644, -0.1425875425338745, 0.07847053557634354, -0.11615490913391113, -0.4513838291168213, -0.5022065043449402, 0.16445890069007874, 0.23615090548992157, -0.7169778943061829, -0.35654935240745544, -0.505031168460846, -0.15871864557266235, 0.4487818777561188, 0.8623517155647278, 0.10183399170637131, 0.19284413754940033, -0.3231252133846283, -0.36903825402259827, -0.2700391709804535, -0.9376652836799622, -0.446290522813797, -0.6170117259025574, 0.7451027035713196, 0.49565625190734863, 0.4714330732822418, 0.6644546389579773, 0.3191336989402771, 0.1612781137228012, -0.0007905373349785805, 0.02312278002500534, -0.4630957543849945, -0.008153820410370827, -0.12329203635454178, -0.35700416564941406, -0.25647565722465515, 0.357418030500412, 0.28172096610069275, 0.5290133953094482, -0.3785739243030548, 0.056198712438344955, 0.1400878131389618, 1.1628531217575073, -0.9561203122138977, 0.1779511570930481, -0.1721399873495102, 0.25490182638168335, -0.07875058054924011, -0.2731766700744629, -0.6862408518791199, -0.5415024757385254, 0.3720287084579468, -0.6781068444252014, -0.10689891129732132, -0.2251121997833252, 0.8485007286071777, 0.17195802927017212, -0.22456878423690796, -0.17963282763957977, -0.33546653389930725, 1.0347288846969604, -0.7177589535713196, 0.4241730868816376, 0.4023909866809845, 0.33277028799057007, 0.04131526127457619, -0.2636142075061798, -0.1258247047662735, -0.4190274178981781, -0.07677382975816727, 0.0708061158657074, 0.254928857088089, 0.11730372160673141, 0.11583032459020615, 0.02406684309244156, -0.1679617017507553, 0.263445109128952, -0.0578986220061779, -0.17144840955734253, 0.734429121017456, 0.06919484585523605, 0.05708010122179985, -0.26473769545555115, -0.4217294156551361, -0.8456392884254456, -0.6328918933868408, 1.01994788646698, 0.5361256003379822, 0.5757175087928772, -0.07400533556938171, 0.17312507331371307, -0.36220648884773254, 0.7319555282592773, 0.06349219381809235, -0.3505312204360962, 0.2809923589229584, 0.3475148677825928, 0.10664290189743042, 0.04052473232150078, 0.6559004187583923, 0.7341347336769104, 0.2662034034729004, -0.11157602816820145, -0.3727273643016815, -0.016498485580086708, 0.3899557292461395, -0.6677243113517761, -0.0780738964676857, -0.05678631365299225, -0.6458008885383606, -0.5728867650032043, 0.2884998917579651, -0.5683163404464722, -0.5296676754951477, -0.3322993814945221, 0.10609253495931625, -0.06741435825824738, -0.42796945571899414, -0.06200500205159187, -0.2610935866832733, 0.22079937160015106, 0.17341727018356323, -1.1156340837478638, 0.23395377397537231, 0.7760324478149414, 0.5049509406089783, -0.5491117835044861, -0.23478788137435913, -0.7559217810630798, -0.3175398111343384, -0.230547234416008, 0.9259824156761169, -0.6046515107154846, -0.6841772198677063, 0.14327384531497955, -0.14402221143245697, 0.09623154252767563, -0.7760011553764343, 0.9892330765724182, -0.6851394772529602, -0.005958580877631903, -0.5331620573997498, -0.6709282994270325, -0.13446693122386932, 0.3019219934940338, -0.7425503730773926, 0.8264991641044617, 0.11221656203269958, -0.6488887667655945, 0.7329166531562805, -0.5417845249176025, -0.24240899085998535, -0.08520729094743729, -0.14700229465961456, -0.3751520812511444, 0.07300836592912674, 0.27210745215415955, 0.1998220682144165, -0.015508890151977539, 0.323312371969223, -0.5582561492919922, -0.22706389427185059, 0.7446908950805664, -0.37463101744651794, 0.28072962164878845, -0.02619962953031063, -0.40371668338775635, 0.44450560212135315, -0.3930550813674927, 0.1158042848110199, -0.18612784147262573, -0.6155645251274109, -0.4695967435836792, 0.061024513095617294, 0.15472202003002167, 0.19481123983860016, 0.07078811526298523, -0.5562152862548828, 0.2988843321800232, -0.45322445034980774, 0.04273653030395508, 1.1366819143295288, -0.22618383169174194, 0.654769241809845, -0.24286098778247833, 0.8133254647254944, -0.37886783480644226, 0.16136100888252258, 0.36816510558128357, -0.16778118908405304, -0.5179148316383362, -0.0940198227763176, 0.6397108435630798, 0.27066078782081604, -0.12049857527017593, 0.3257890045642853, 0.01029418408870697, -0.3588005006313324, -0.6363850831985474, -0.026199810206890106, 0.5009302496910095, 0.6790676712989807, 0.41460561752319336, -0.19025389850139618, -0.42027464509010315, -1.1688511371612549, -0.4553786814212799, -0.26759758591651917, 0.10900014638900757, 0.6245965361595154, -0.0007345366175286472, 0.2011287957429886, 1.1220872402191162, -0.5616841316223145, -0.11024517565965652, -0.39955759048461914, 0.21348196268081665, 0.2245301604270935, 0.4281044006347656, 0.26239001750946045, -0.7631596922874451, -0.48733779788017273, -0.1301211565732956, -0.41992881894111633, 0.011443781666457653, 0.22452284395694733, -0.16460692882537842, 0.4085399806499481, 0.09636807441711426, -0.00174801517277956, 0.4366863965988159, 0.5347104668617249, -0.3080684244632721, 0.49045243859291077, -0.19765128195285797, 0.283789724111557, -0.32515838742256165, 0.1808195561170578, 0.2599159777164459, -0.21109114587306976, -0.32526853680610657, -0.26469409465789795, 0.3742626905441284, 0.195062518119812, -0.5089331269264221, 0.6971028447151184, 0.015035790391266346, 0.04467625916004181, -0.5598697066307068, -0.23993976414203644, -0.20673544704914093, 0.8054027557373047, 0.7816812992095947, 0.8190671801567078, 0.062126681208610535, -0.5892261862754822, -0.044231027364730835, 0.025353221222758293, -0.2727825343608856, 0.5308589935302734, -0.5360399484634399, -0.03405348211526871, 0.13242597877979279, 0.3049224019050598, -0.9296018481254578, -0.25269395112991333, 0.19906549155712128, -0.626474916934967, 0.1837833672761917, -0.33330920338630676, 0.13057537376880646, -0.11663264036178589, -0.3631550967693329, 0.29745063185691833, 0.5550385117530823, -0.736048698425293, 0.28509286046028137, 0.6549976468086243, -0.09701099246740341, -0.9943840503692627, -0.2183811515569687, -0.3963507413864136, -0.34199491143226624, -0.16631652414798737, 0.31728318333625793, 0.15757988393306732, -0.18629233539104462, -0.2561090588569641, -0.17784856259822845, 0.24429433047771454, 0.39036646485328674, 0.5352495908737183, 0.4741281270980835, 0.18230660259723663, 0.32360073924064636, -0.0689077153801918, -0.6061305403709412, 0.19090421497821808, -0.18147265911102295, 0.42558160424232483, -0.2909614145755768, -0.2943793833255768, -0.47978484630584717, 0.006560395006090403, 0.14122852683067322, -0.3501390218734741, 0.6036829948425293, 0.35049036145210266, 0.04401961341500282, -0.28585320711135864, -0.5144797563552856, -0.478558212518692, -0.47108006477355957, 0.1791715770959854, -0.1765957623720169, -0.7458224296569824, 0.0890437588095665, 0.14285707473754883, -0.04565875604748726, 0.25779566168785095, 0.29244092106819153, -0.1125238835811615, 1.2460304498672485, 0.6758966445922852, -0.26776817440986633, 0.5646854043006897, -0.12965905666351318, -0.16017849743366241, -0.7065131068229675, -0.32491427659988403, -0.4087772071361542, -0.5212816596031189, -0.5592442154884338, -0.03795134648680687, 0.4010070264339447, 0.15558713674545288, -0.16989244520664215, -0.00396090978756547, -0.6150673031806946, 0.3779498040676117, 0.7458156943321228, 0.20814524590969086, 0.044031769037246704, 0.0011701356852427125, -0.145167276263237, -0.2572183609008789, -0.556978702545166, -0.5609111189842224, 1.0998469591140747, 0.49923208355903625, 0.6885232329368591, -0.008323006331920624, 0.773884117603302, 0.4577094614505768, 0.6641454100608826, -0.8644699454307556, 0.15081501007080078, 0.048739731311798096, -0.3719731569290161, -0.6388285756111145, -0.2452867478132248, -0.7966521382331848, 0.33150094747543335, -0.14675386250019073, -0.6436992287635803, 0.29352763295173645, 0.22755657136440277, -0.5744271278381348, 0.15600627660751343, -0.5680369734764099, 0.9918784499168396, -0.43709495663642883, -0.6500067114830017, -0.241544708609581, -0.6301296353340149, 0.019029837101697922, 0.5391799211502075, 0.17410700023174286, -0.18061833083629608, 0.11915145069360733, 1.2911642789840698, -0.46064892411231995, 0.7321479320526123, -0.5743193030357361, -0.05964121222496033, 0.12305644899606705, -0.06682375818490982, 0.39457201957702637, 0.2262667566537857, -0.3365550935268402, -0.19708923995494843, -0.1405668407678604, -0.4349527359008789, -0.6028967499732971, 0.6521639227867126, -0.9410917162895203, -0.5025152564048767, -0.5441369414329529, -0.5105727314949036, -0.6820976734161377, -0.06811542063951492, 0.07550724595785141, 0.35151612758636475, -0.1644880324602127, 0.01937716268002987, 0.6015485525131226, -0.30218634009361267, 0.5525380373001099, 0.37976348400115967, -0.14510296285152435, -0.5706376433372498, 0.7716971039772034, -0.16534675657749176, 0.2819571793079376, 0.5901862382888794, 0.4465115964412689, -0.7936925888061523, 0.009410238824784756, -0.5652436017990112, 0.16501560807228088, -0.7498166561126709, 0.014193599112331867, -0.34688863158226013, 0.2290368676185608, -0.25456997752189636, -0.3163923919200897, -0.45091715455055237, -0.3353465795516968, 0.01319217961281538, -0.37699267268180847, 0.2534283995628357, 0.8643677234649658, -0.23623807728290558, 0.14160113036632538, -0.65812748670578, -0.2630886137485504, 0.5319533348083496, 0.5160587430000305, 0.3429046869277954, -0.45750391483306885, -0.364806205034256, 0.09534347057342529, -0.1386653184890747, -0.7157507538795471, 0.4663499891757965, -0.4419429302215576, 0.9196398258209229, 0.3387932777404785, 0.2719918191432953, 0.44453322887420654, 0.06388892233371735, 0.6326925158500671, 0.2857387959957123, -0.8420740962028503, 0.3625919818878174, -0.19360321760177612, -0.0015622079372406006, 0.8133745789527893, 0.3469870090484619, -0.5129756927490234, 0.3675116300582886, -0.6540791988372803, -0.7272183895111084, 0.936865508556366, -0.34425103664398193, -0.2785714566707611, 0.25650256872177124, 0.13230660557746887, 0.28781431913375854, 0.22503811120986938, -0.8647870421409607, -0.19124732911586761, -0.21187163889408112, 0.02279718779027462, -0.2962352931499481, -0.249126136302948, -0.16082455217838287, -0.13454096019268036, 0.7684425711631775, -0.10193002969026566, -0.051576558500528336, -0.030320174992084503, -0.2315424680709839, -0.18549011647701263, 0.4792311191558838, 0.6795763373374939, 0.6667559146881104, -0.5835592150688171, 0.02760671079158783, 0.05625276267528534, 0.001305198296904564, 0.3352057933807373, -0.15114183723926544, 0.12399593740701675, -0.27488383650779724, 0.2638761103153229, 0.9721777439117432, -0.0011886010179296136, -0.8252894878387451, 0.6261017918586731, -0.0673748180270195, -0.18792176246643066, -0.1265271157026291, 0.11969473212957382, 0.20467548072338104, 0.04985959827899933, 0.3276975750923157, -0.11369775980710983, 0.0860745906829834, -0.23783378303050995, 0.34547707438468933, 0.43535375595092773, -1.161312460899353, 0.021355055272579193, 0.11361803859472275, 0.4114913046360016, -0.396049827337265, 0.533485472202301, -0.08253613114356995, -0.7160728573799133, 0.5963122844696045, 0.2062208652496338, 0.6667122840881348, -0.09485810995101929, 0.4262063205242157, 0.4914260804653168, -0.2421206384897232, -0.177363321185112, -0.24049364030361176, -0.38526344299316406, -0.6806120872497559, -0.2613830268383026, -0.5464336276054382, -0.4865037500858307, -0.09037283062934875, -1.139079213142395, 0.07613203674554825, -0.27587372064590454, -0.46248722076416016, -0.1997838169336319, -0.08305971324443817, -0.43426254391670227, 0.21095092594623566, 0.4128379821777344, 0.7886612415313721, -0.8072100281715393, 0.7048397064208984, 0.7474773526191711, -0.5140447616577148, -1.188043475151062, -0.09712535887956619, -0.16969120502471924, -0.6661296486854553, 1.0576649904251099, 0.2919315695762634, -0.3056122064590454, -0.34491124749183655, -0.21709395945072174, -0.5050613284111023, 0.8010266423225403, 0.004688463639467955, -0.30724433064460754, 0.11428932100534439, -0.00953499972820282, 0.4011599123477936, -0.4137935936450958, 0.622016429901123, 0.6656884551048279, 0.5421780943870544, -0.14287176728248596, -0.7063171863555908, -0.1789209246635437, -0.22890621423721313, -0.04486881569027901, 0.2920242249965668, -0.5922517776489258, 0.661937415599823, -0.1830403357744217, 0.022660216316580772, -0.20891232788562775, 0.6620072722434998, 0.6421141624450684, 0.13556063175201416, 0.7716429233551025, 0.4736713171005249, 0.6390724778175354, 0.0017669213702902198, 1.0968307256698608, -0.2196597009897232, 0.5151403546333313, 0.8815668225288391, -0.2035498172044754, 1.1037988662719727, 0.6477296352386475, -0.3449113667011261, 0.8122069239616394, 0.9356388449668884, 0.3338122069835663, 0.9152389168739319, 0.42419174313545227, -0.03342224657535553, -0.6268141865730286, -0.3028695583343506, -0.5212042927742004, 0.004993853624910116, 0.07682851701974869, -0.19779686629772186, -0.12173161655664444, -0.028241679072380066, -0.17580729722976685, 0.3723796606063843, -0.25841453671455383, 0.8538716435432434, -0.04092557728290558, -1.1463602781295776, 0.6507229804992676, 0.13607092201709747, 0.913261890411377, -0.4604302644729614, -0.09460332244634628, -0.21538890898227692, 0.42865708470344543, -0.24345284700393677, -0.7494716048240662, -0.30375736951828003, -0.08163405954837799, -0.283939391374588, -0.34485921263694763, 0.46637722849845886, -0.23686154186725616, -0.2453014850616455, 0.3984045088291168, 0.2523355782032013, -0.3770369291305542, 0.0046408758498728275, -0.6162644028663635, -0.053571466356515884, 0.12209314852952957, -0.31100255250930786, 0.505447268486023, -0.08862709999084473, -0.004953861236572266, 0.6871688365936279, 0.6436161994934082, -0.07327999174594879, -0.35593095421791077, 0.07956311851739883, 0.49479779601097107, -0.6878346800804138, -1.011473298072815, -0.8685238361358643, 0.6482239365577698, -0.261231929063797, -0.3724531829357147, 0.4113106429576874, 0.5435267090797424, 0.8437933921813965, -0.2530509829521179, 1.0040922164916992, 0.2630324065685272, 0.8086398243904114, -0.38561534881591797, 0.5195963382720947, -0.5133391618728638, 0.3116076588630676, -0.1928403377532959, -0.465106725692749, -0.04193880036473274, 0.7663113474845886, -0.7707913517951965, 0.052014973014593124, 0.4302326440811157, 0.7941188216209412, 0.14997828006744385, 0.059752095490694046, 0.1263745129108429, -0.5550146698951721, 0.3490937054157257, 0.6367872357368469, 1.1428602933883667, 0.1346321851015091, 0.27624285221099854, -0.5982851982116699, -0.3188152611255646, -0.44276586174964905, -0.8506813049316406, -0.7405182719230652, -0.34623101353645325, 0.04931149259209633, -0.526028573513031, 0.1634417027235031, 1.3325811624526978, 0.9139557480812073, -0.9810547828674316, -0.8178143501281738, 0.03704981133341789, 0.22978778183460236, -0.5437647700309753, -0.20523028075695038, 0.5810684561729431, -0.4481891095638275, -0.5156561732292175, 0.17703746259212494, 0.1605139523744583, -0.18878813087940216, -0.2832491993904114, -0.7342899441719055, -0.15972916781902313, -0.15873460471630096, 0.17800410091876984, 0.4231017529964447, -0.8572394847869873, -0.18616747856140137, 0.1507204920053482, -0.29069292545318604, 0.22605615854263306, 0.9855168461799622, -0.8734021186828613, 0.3051719665527344, 0.5094554424285889, 0.8704610466957092, 0.4329400062561035, 0.43965089321136475, 0.8206433653831482, -0.48712506890296936, 0.06795820593833923, 0.045577406883239746, 0.16254822909832, 0.42730486392974854, -0.2697838246822357, 0.5131816267967224, 0.156752809882164, -0.4315448999404907, -0.816338300704956, 0.26181790232658386, -0.9458189606666565, -0.34714755415916443, 1.2129812240600586, -0.11783526092767715, -0.3137219250202179, 0.31878653168678284, -0.2418629676103592, 0.14178553223609924, -0.9655466079711914, 0.8317423462867737, 0.7090132236480713, -0.38848742842674255, -0.03191788122057915, -0.046625424176454544, 0.8581700325012207, 0.792834997177124, -0.5610664486885071, 0.23406527936458588, 0.2804630994796753, 0.25358471274375916, 0.005334045737981796, 0.4603720009326935, 0.1283756047487259, 0.44843021035194397, -0.38037440180778503, 0.3324359357357025, -0.18122340738773346, -0.12445089221000671, -0.6226703524589539, 0.39359092712402344, 0.629496157169342, -0.2352031022310257 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04925v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04925v1
Multilingual Large Language Model: A Survey of Resources, Taxonomy and Frontiers
2024-04-07T11:52:44
2024-04-07T11:52:44
Libo Qin, Qiguang Chen, Yuhang Zhou, Zhi Chen, Yinghui Li, Lizi Liao, Min Li, Wanxiang Che, Philip S. Yu
cs.CL
cs.CL
Multilingual Large Language Models are capable of using powerful Large Language Models to handle and respond to queries in multiple languages, which achieves remarkable success in multilingual natural language processing tasks. Despite these breakthroughs, there still remains a lack of a comprehensive survey to summarize existing approaches and recent developments in this field. To this end, in this paper, we present a thorough review and provide a unified perspective to summarize the recent progress as well as emerging trends in multilingual large language models (MLLMs) literature. The contributions of this paper can be summarized: (1) First survey: to our knowledge, we take the first step and present a thorough review in MLLMs research field according to multi-lingual alignment; (2) New taxonomy: we offer a new and unified perspective to summarize the current progress of MLLMs; (3) New frontiers: we highlight several emerging frontiers and discuss the corresponding challenges; (4) Abundant resources: we collect abundant open-source resources, including relevant papers, data corpora, and leaderboards. We hope our work can provide the community with quick access and spur breakthrough research in MLLMs.
[ -0.6068504452705383, -0.7373239994049072, 0.3294227123260498, 0.18098539113998413, 0.10412357747554779, 0.2637427747249603, -0.39446738362312317, -0.4852243959903717, 0.22725798189640045, 0.5293090343475342, -0.40116530656814575, -0.34901314973831177, -0.6841951608657837, 0.18355420231819153, -0.33335790038108826, 0.8440362811088562, 0.08298720419406891, 0.29477375745773315, -0.0829201340675354, -0.4288461208343506, -0.3170405626296997, -0.7619746923446655, -0.4700857400894165, -0.08385618776082993, 0.7528091669082642, -0.04586489871144295, 0.4680473506450653, 0.1910776048898697, 0.5439788699150085, 0.3705708682537079, -0.5154585242271423, 0.2331184595823288, -0.21717573702335358, 0.3609834611415863, -0.10435520857572556, -0.12243185192346573, -0.5640197396278381, -0.2672005295753479, 1.136349081993103, 0.9932374954223633, -0.25788915157318115, 0.16412785649299622, 0.18433165550231934, 0.5732204914093018, -0.6205907464027405, 0.060598913580179214, -0.5249775648117065, 0.013117944821715355, -0.4859291613101959, 0.13427136838436127, -0.45804914832115173, -0.07375409454107285, 0.1346265971660614, -0.25826793909072876, -0.03888791427016258, -0.17459021508693695, 0.30720508098602295, -0.3002660274505615, -0.821663498878479, -0.35029855370521545, -0.7498330473899841, 0.9444683194160461, -0.7944702506065369, 0.7760903239250183, 0.1165195181965828, 0.47371017932891846, 0.026034776121377945, -0.8224256634712219, -0.29072046279907227, -0.19667109847068787, 0.022181032225489616, -0.3288446366786957, -0.14042437076568604, -0.2966235876083374, -0.035153910517692566, 0.40417158603668213, -0.5810830593109131, 0.4814462959766388, -0.3751767873764038, -0.29958969354629517, 0.7075439095497131, 0.3129391372203827, 0.13449889421463013, -0.05302802473306656, -0.3384082019329071, 0.20480607450008392, -0.6811500787734985, 0.1193898543715477, 0.08904184401035309, 0.5289363861083984, -0.022368887439370155, 0.43918541073799133, -0.2877306044101715, 1.019930362701416, -0.6539097428321838, -0.3130945563316345, 0.3669414818286896, -0.735105574131012, -0.13671058416366577, -0.4938739836215973, 1.0136672258377075, 0.3330148756504059, -0.1377512812614441, -0.04604548588395119, -0.21107272803783417, -0.47208529710769653, -0.19525186717510223, -0.5755175948143005, 0.26983407139778137, 0.2405608743429184, -0.5141716003417969, 0.15724781155586243, -0.1053619310259819, -1.0541216135025024, -0.4304732084274292, -0.4304903745651245, -0.12042789906263351, 0.007674659136682749, -0.8018444180488586, 0.08537009358406067, 0.11107388883829117, 0.13253019750118256, 0.4412601888179779, -0.7276121377944946, 0.15489082038402557, 0.7314395904541016, 0.9808821082115173, -0.29867491126060486, -0.5096163749694824, -0.3030626177787781, -0.08907279372215271, -0.2116190642118454, 0.6766268610954285, -0.3959556519985199, -0.29279404878616333, 0.4667762517929077, 0.20609119534492493, -0.006883976981043816, -0.30972903966903687, 0.3731399178504944, -0.6981471180915833, 0.2606826424598694, -0.49402713775634766, -0.3063673973083496, -0.22641025483608246, 0.7047388553619385, -0.8643618822097778, 0.8229881525039673, -0.1585017293691635, -0.7235333919525146, 0.12181288003921509, -0.6768988370895386, -0.2526257336139679, 0.14258703589439392, 0.04895048961043358, -0.0787290707230568, 0.01786387339234352, 0.16372832655906677, 0.5077499151229858, -0.47218361496925354, 0.5800303816795349, -0.3999345600605011, 0.1818489134311676, 0.3196239173412323, -0.2981507182121277, 1.1657416820526123, 0.45658934116363525, 0.10228686779737473, 0.34402528405189514, -0.5997591018676758, 0.11563084274530411, 0.03412802517414093, -0.2477782815694809, -0.36132174730300903, 0.051245324313640594, 0.47510698437690735, 0.5367739796638489, 0.4815923571586609, -0.47749873995780945, 0.3526398241519928, -0.06576553732156754, 0.39898669719696045, 0.3789471685886383, -0.1554117351770401, 0.48661962151527405, 0.07712108641862869, 0.5548547506332397, -0.21036186814308167, 0.38683950901031494, -0.3653396666049957, -0.5272594690322876, -0.3652817904949188, -0.047195155173540115, 0.372441828250885, 0.3315058648586273, -0.7430509924888611, 0.16765807569026947, -0.2046351283788681, -0.6026972532272339, -0.4159718453884125, 0.08129037171602249, 0.20998826622962952, 0.12479007244110107, 0.1902262568473816, -0.2351914644241333, -0.5849471688270569, -0.8478731513023376, -0.1349017322063446, -0.03770900145173073, 0.13358716666698456, 0.17279952764511108, 0.43995365500450134, -0.30148863792419434, 0.7543004155158997, -0.35289183259010315, -0.21534058451652527, -0.255889356136322, -0.04099268466234207, 0.07153178006410599, 0.2428690791130066, 0.5847991704940796, -1.0865672826766968, -0.5557302832603455, 0.28202104568481445, -0.664341926574707, 0.2219911366701126, 0.4436022937297821, 0.06526113301515579, 0.4190729558467865, 0.557039201259613, -0.5642502307891846, -0.22311410307884216, 0.6509208679199219, -0.29125067591667175, 0.5343008041381836, 0.03331293165683746, 0.09701317548751831, -1.0610533952713013, 0.3361263573169708, -0.1721317023038864, 0.0960988849401474, -0.8290256857872009, 0.5345052480697632, -0.012497917748987675, 0.11143859475851059, -0.44299519062042236, 0.7746558785438538, -0.6191484332084656, -0.06111535057425499, -0.20033538341522217, 0.21116526424884796, -0.12936682999134064, 0.11707812547683716, 0.09370926022529602, 0.3781302273273468, 0.7369709610939026, -0.5894794464111328, 0.6196053624153137, 0.34559375047683716, -0.3032781481742859, 0.31845203042030334, -0.28690749406814575, -0.2025202214717865, -0.23809899389743805, 0.3339494466781616, -0.815425455570221, -0.17670336365699768, 0.09176801890134811, -0.3339237868785858, 0.3783630430698395, -0.06440334767103195, -0.5090098977088928, -0.6055755615234375, -0.26626038551330566, 0.36935853958129883, 0.20988930761814117, -0.13909459114074707, 0.44743096828460693, 0.8108311295509338, -0.5951898694038391, -0.8558284044265747, -0.5663812756538391, 0.330282062292099, -0.1928441971540451, -0.48388177156448364, -0.0721215084195137, -0.2738547623157501, -0.5100895762443542, -0.1249954029917717, 0.37580540776252747, -0.3117366433143616, 0.07255230098962784, -0.38986867666244507, 0.24230779707431793, -0.3876202404499054, 0.30040714144706726, -0.3773116171360016, 0.25143077969551086, 0.02686906047165394, -0.18255916237831116, 0.6321264505386353, -0.1346692442893982, -0.23755545914173126, 0.10486868768930435, 0.8003668785095215, 0.7260312438011169, -0.8216457366943359, 0.8396580815315247, 0.7695184350013733, -0.4076496958732605, 0.12652049958705902, -0.6607758402824402, 0.06791304796934128, -0.32913970947265625, 0.5767788887023926, -0.2640775144100189, -1.2907425165176392, 0.5828734636306763, -0.03946766257286072, 0.44487258791923523, 0.6283554434776306, 0.8704107403755188, 0.2528636157512665, 0.9048543572425842, 0.8968157768249512, -0.11919348686933517, 0.3518558144569397, 0.01882053166627884, 0.2595897316932678, -0.845386803150177, -0.5343561768531799, -0.8325639963150024, 0.03733784332871437, -0.626112163066864, -0.349138468503952, 0.3164444863796234, -0.029084913432598114, -0.11260924488306046, 0.03869554400444031, -0.27820104360580444, -0.03291739523410797, 0.3304230868816376, -0.4853225350379944, 0.4781527519226074, -0.005702150519937277, -0.14095133543014526, -0.11933036893606186, -0.7307983040809631, -0.4453003406524658, 1.0271533727645874, 0.3874751031398773, 0.4684128761291504, 0.35964128375053406, 0.27384233474731445, -0.10906145721673965, 0.40918129682540894, -0.6221045851707458, 0.35039380192756653, 0.01841774582862854, -1.0026565790176392, -0.6679136157035828, -0.45012760162353516, -1.0931557416915894, 0.7739912271499634, -0.06260399520397186, -0.7221336364746094, 0.008416127413511276, -0.08332604914903641, -0.16177022457122803, 0.5923430919647217, -0.2841423451900482, 0.8674734830856323, -0.2735549807548523, -0.3940848112106323, -0.03639885038137436, -0.8106968998908997, 0.6835458874702454, -0.2799348533153534, 0.6900618672370911, -0.19249606132507324, -0.07471788674592972, 0.6744202375411987, -0.18415167927742004, 0.5718337893486023, -0.19643501937389374, -0.6929538249969482, 0.41167232394218445, -0.1824817806482315, 0.28827303647994995, -0.21092507243156433, -0.13750863075256348, 0.1605496108531952, 0.06492845714092255, -0.27220025658607483, -0.24683775007724762, 0.7234322428703308, -0.2892855703830719, -0.2873525619506836, -0.4682188034057617, -0.5963484644889832, -0.4614024758338928, 0.427346408367157, 0.17417612671852112, 0.4197847843170166, -0.39410462975502014, 0.24351398646831512, 0.37829315662384033, -0.27884000539779663, 0.6422575116157532, 0.7614995837211609, -0.8126736283302307, -0.3667278289794922, 0.8088603019714355, 0.3006317913532257, 0.1719551831483841, 0.3761548101902008, -0.1291055977344513, -0.5288501977920532, -0.6713360548019409, -0.45247882604599, 0.26908349990844727, -0.5789822936058044, -0.12865383923053741, -0.850598931312561, -0.19826288521289825, -0.70064777135849, 0.2664869725704193, -0.3865887522697449, -0.18540185689926147, 0.07460565119981766, 0.26253578066825867, 0.11255753040313721, 0.9654651284217834, 0.019072018563747406, 0.07798922061920166, -1.0403810739517212, 0.03560948744416237, 0.199697807431221, 0.46702292561531067, 0.3529078960418701, -0.22326098382472992, -0.49982750415802, 0.11115806549787521, -0.1784871220588684, -0.5539318919181824, 0.3817915916442871, -0.0613107904791832, 0.6695637106895447, 0.2892463207244873, -0.2060895562171936, 0.39660361409187317, -0.7026288509368896, 0.9724805951118469, 0.4124365746974945, -0.5826985239982605, 0.048899535089731216, -0.3881862461566925, 0.3691599667072296, 0.2692761719226837, 0.6235201954841614, -1.070241093635559, -0.13463574647903442, -0.219501793384552, -0.9359499216079712, 0.47858747839927673, -0.10731811076402664, 0.21225866675376892, 0.23032689094543457, -0.3640196621417999, 0.17035940289497375, 0.45175015926361084, -0.7759182453155518, -0.3064389228820801, 0.22168724238872528, 0.2612657845020294, -0.4174777567386627, -0.35331645607948303, -0.12298781424760818, -0.318092942237854, 0.5863438844680786, -0.13384400308132172, 0.036635156720876694, -0.29203441739082336, -0.07523181289434433, -0.004036657512187958, 0.6393916606903076, 0.7039309144020081, 0.8552129864692688, -0.053050607442855835, 0.09001429378986359, 0.11367405951023102, -0.3067716658115387, 0.1191660538315773, 0.32224562764167786, -0.10495392233133316, 0.1804884672164917, 0.4241894483566284, 0.6909866333007812, 0.2230847030878067, -0.8082826733589172, 0.4563538432121277, -0.014830230735242367, -0.10016151517629623, -0.1957121342420578, -0.5409266352653503, 0.37756845355033875, 0.17094770073890686, 0.44521564245224, -0.036089614033699036, 0.23597535490989685, -0.5325491428375244, -0.028433652594685555, 0.6655025482177734, -0.13758981227874756, -0.2640344798564911, 0.4524008333683014, 0.16087360680103302, 0.024705607444047928, 0.3751448094844818, -0.21401871740818024, -0.4912498891353607, 0.31456032395362854, 0.40132227540016174, 0.5612335801124573, -0.45325085520744324, 0.17601031064987183, 0.41996070742607117, 0.30137011408805847, -0.11675374209880829, 0.20288534462451935, 0.06647785753011703, -0.5512006282806396, -0.6604757308959961, -0.8739997744560242, -0.27071601152420044, 0.2761467695236206, -0.5968422889709473, 0.1273362934589386, 0.09570085257291794, -0.12674075365066528, 0.020243752747774124, 0.010069853626191616, -0.4080142378807068, -0.024840639904141426, 0.33697035908699036, 1.0253996849060059, -0.6175718307495117, 0.6214171648025513, 0.804635763168335, -0.22731061279773712, -0.3481723666191101, -0.32886403799057007, 0.07513311505317688, -0.3243924081325531, 0.4403558373451233, -0.08906082063913345, 0.03700350224971771, -0.21032626926898956, -0.25361761450767517, -1.2113476991653442, 0.7171190977096558, 0.1275341659784317, -0.5245922207832336, -0.23501275479793549, 0.059122975915670395, 0.564510703086853, -0.2349332571029663, 0.029534699395298958, 0.46077316999435425, 0.6304500102996826, 0.07840055972337723, -1.129107117652893, -0.34420132637023926, -0.41078975796699524, -0.027621179819107056, 0.41589751839637756, -0.7389280796051025, 1.1878596544265747, 0.017891142517328262, -0.07335760444402695, 0.3424941599369049, 0.5047916173934937, 0.1564955860376358, 0.3345883786678314, 0.23490168154239655, 0.2773761451244354, 0.5978713035583496, -0.011106179095804691, 1.0918817520141602, -0.12455558031797409, 0.6301333904266357, 0.826363205909729, -0.524753987789154, 0.9798038601875305, 0.3132462799549103, -0.595142126083374, 0.14463648200035095, 0.5929624438285828, 0.02997249737381935, 0.1366151124238968, 0.09352219104766846, -0.4024626314640045, -0.15225210785865784, -0.36540767550468445, -0.7060210704803467, 0.5175526738166809, 0.4384554326534271, -0.2156836837530136, -0.5641347765922546, 0.1773872822523117, 0.031763266772031784, 0.001191282644867897, -0.5726177096366882, 0.6024433970451355, 0.0052487775683403015, -0.7672739028930664, 0.5058616995811462, 0.2609887719154358, 0.7994787693023682, -0.8488338589668274, 0.07566378265619278, -0.07480860501527786, -0.10302605479955673, -0.15461298823356628, -0.7981317043304443, 0.24902135133743286, 0.053102340549230576, -0.1640969216823578, -0.38945692777633667, 0.6522261500358582, -0.648304283618927, -0.44041740894317627, 0.39816635847091675, 0.9750394225120544, 0.0643719732761383, -0.05570964887738228, -0.5801678895950317, 0.26332709193229675, -0.0599791593849659, -0.21597693860530853, 0.3529161512851715, 0.3826901316642761, -0.14776186645030975, 0.5994070172309875, 0.5239477753639221, 0.0845424011349678, 0.3542516529560089, 0.15312206745147705, 0.6595779061317444, -0.6962235569953918, -0.4092656970024109, -0.7162840366363525, 0.5279761552810669, -0.11670426279306412, -0.373256653547287, 1.0123748779296875, 0.7224422097206116, 0.8391835689544678, -0.08559936285018921, 0.833092987537384, -0.1503085494041443, 0.7562165260314941, -0.39712759852409363, 0.8307231068611145, -0.8115718364715576, -0.114102803170681, -0.3232024013996124, -0.8463992476463318, -0.5219814777374268, -0.018656693398952484, 0.050596948713064194, 0.2794348895549774, 0.5725862383842468, 0.45624464750289917, 0.059161387383937836, -0.09766792505979538, 0.3115752637386322, 0.2867950201034546, 0.1569223701953888, 0.2930853068828583, 0.9168857932090759, -0.08504217118024826, 0.2660481333732605, -0.013646554201841354, -0.015024792402982712, -0.3152497112751007, -0.7013540863990784, -0.5266709923744202, -0.9022222757339478, -0.06686453521251678, -0.06483390182256699, -0.37579813599586487, 0.7308586835861206, 0.5904436111450195, -0.8690285086631775, -0.47132954001426697, 0.2388518750667572, 0.18880778551101685, -0.01017727144062519, -0.16962772607803345, 0.30525556206703186, -0.4330381453037262, -0.8379654884338379, 0.23106341063976288, 0.27450719475746155, 0.003398708999156952, -0.7237717509269714, -0.19064271450042725, -0.6106694936752319, -0.30383676290512085, 1.1236509084701538, 0.39980775117874146, -0.8988588452339172, 0.3948870599269867, 0.12820620834827423, -0.2629022002220154, -0.09438692778348923, 0.8597433567047119, -0.3791373074054718, 0.41523510217666626, 0.4040359556674957, 0.6466978788375854, 0.24324984848499298, -0.5910075902938843, 0.38097450137138367, -0.5357834696769714, 0.10109902173280716, 0.28648054599761963, 0.5758146643638611, 0.5772293210029602, -0.0011174181709066033, 0.45777618885040283, 0.12716102600097656, -0.38976922631263733, -1.091369390487671, 0.41802942752838135, -0.7896474599838257, -0.48422902822494507, 1.0095000267028809, 0.006247017066925764, 0.09895994514226913, -0.06429461389780045, -0.10892938077449799, 0.06976733356714249, 0.07164153456687927, 0.277940034866333, 0.9463698267936707, 0.0020424374379217625, -0.2813836336135864, -0.7001940608024597, 0.31415778398513794, 0.1412147432565689, -0.8608660101890564, 0.26175740361213684, 0.6928389668464661, 0.07454382628202438, 0.38330182433128357, 0.723042905330658, -0.3605256676673889, 0.02633349783718586, -0.21272975206375122, 0.09163794666528702, 0.266062468290329, -0.39881283044815063, -0.599979817867279, 0.5452122688293457, 0.30062174797058105, 0.258543461561203 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08679v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08679v1
Your Finetuned Large Language Model is Already a Powerful Out-of-distribution Detector
2024-04-07T10:32:49
2024-04-07T10:32:49
Andi Zhang, Tim Z. Xiao, Weiyang Liu, Robert Bamler, Damon Wischik
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
We revisit the likelihood ratio between a pretrained large language model (LLM) and its finetuned variant as a criterion for out-of-distribution (OOD) detection. The intuition behind such a criterion is that, the pretrained LLM has the prior knowledge about OOD data due to its large amount of training data, and once finetuned with the in-distribution data, the LLM has sufficient knowledge to distinguish their difference. Leveraging the power of LLMs, we show that, for the first time, the likelihood ratio can serve as an effective OOD detector. Moreover, we apply the proposed LLM-based likelihood ratio to detect OOD questions in question-answering (QA) systems, which can be used to improve the performance of specialized LLMs for general questions. Given that likelihood can be easily obtained by the loss functions within contemporary neural network frameworks, it is straightforward to implement this approach in practice. Since both the pretrained LLMs and its various finetuned models are available, our proposed criterion can be effortlessly incorporated for OOD detection without the need for further training. We conduct comprehensive evaluation across on multiple settings, including far OOD, near OOD, spam detection, and QA scenarios, to demonstrate the effectiveness of the method.
[ -0.7101563215255737, -0.8213358521461487, 0.7640426754951477, -0.29718372225761414, -0.3372734487056732, -0.42005446553230286, -0.34418171644210815, -0.1796984076499939, -0.14076387882232666, 0.6400191187858582, -0.4450300931930542, -0.2986640930175781, -0.5123293399810791, 0.08632312715053558, -0.5737953186035156, 0.7561583518981934, 0.31876516342163086, 0.09672113507986069, -0.23703131079673767, -0.24567487835884094, -0.40938499569892883, -0.5910727977752686, -0.8056488037109375, -0.313751757144928, 0.400592565536499, 0.27658283710479736, 0.5702933669090271, 0.31587809324264526, 0.7135005593299866, 0.22448298335075378, -0.21856530010700226, 0.25319597125053406, -0.6118243932723999, 0.029332928359508514, -0.2345099300146103, -0.832976758480072, -0.35282406210899353, -0.29944857954978943, 0.7504450678825378, 0.5992827415466309, -0.23862673342227936, 0.12942583858966827, 0.021623428910970688, 0.6178099513053894, -0.7492332458496094, -0.23360106348991394, -0.8640562295913696, 0.06025242805480957, -0.36119580268859863, -0.44139301776885986, -0.49539583921432495, -0.1831430196762085, -0.14879769086837769, -0.4346258044242859, 0.142586350440979, 0.08821453154087067, 0.4363308250904083, 0.26496410369873047, -0.5052776336669922, -0.22652050852775574, -0.6289523839950562, 0.8476973176002502, -0.8585342168807983, 0.6542635560035706, 0.42623287439346313, 0.45326125621795654, -0.45927929878234863, -0.5020261406898499, -0.896980881690979, -0.3118281662464142, 0.1838655322790146, -0.13397859036922455, -0.17502503097057343, 0.09871132671833038, 0.2371995896100998, 0.8202733993530273, -0.6047220230102539, 0.21994616091251373, -0.19320756196975708, -0.1504925787448883, 0.43654048442840576, -0.011752557009458542, 0.3364869952201843, 0.16178150475025177, -0.008183392696082592, 0.015271292068064213, -0.6993082165718079, -0.16537229716777802, 0.5423533916473389, 0.19182321429252625, 0.07322636991739273, 0.7171740531921387, 0.03357619047164917, 0.7496042847633362, 0.2033395767211914, -0.09121035039424896, 0.06320340186357498, -0.25756072998046875, -0.24640300869941711, -0.11018680036067963, 0.7949551939964294, 0.09618082642555237, 0.1939256489276886, 0.015705566853284836, -0.3732781410217285, -0.1948755532503128, -0.01821327954530716, -0.8654873371124268, -0.10442785173654556, 0.10938803851604462, -0.48916923999786377, -0.17302367091178894, -0.047005441039800644, -0.34316501021385193, -0.6562666893005371, -0.018807444721460342, 0.5582984685897827, -0.31307047605514526, -0.4974933862686157, 0.5332298278808594, -0.003289636690169573, 0.10744931548833847, 0.02453288808465004, -0.7556155323982239, 0.05677320063114166, 0.7277464866638184, 0.6936813592910767, -0.08526849001646042, 0.10836174339056015, -0.9806951880455017, -0.29917624592781067, -0.45781755447387695, 0.5993792414665222, -0.3167378306388855, 0.2956620156764984, 0.11965019255876541, -0.06794074177742004, 0.12046373635530472, -0.7851349711418152, 0.44343796372413635, -0.9161667227745056, 0.31682470440864563, 0.09061546623706818, -0.84520423412323, -0.015987705439329147, 0.4231007695198059, -0.8001797795295715, 0.823265016078949, 0.24817748367786407, -0.8304470181465149, 0.43154290318489075, -0.32211512327194214, -0.2972772717475891, -0.03210626542568207, -0.32691097259521484, -0.45825862884521484, 0.24991348385810852, 0.2581644356250763, 0.4804697632789612, -0.35662204027175903, 0.20385847985744476, -0.6863985657691956, -0.3848375380039215, 0.40252557396888733, -0.701079249382019, 0.9832729697227478, 0.3182029724121094, -0.10054691135883331, -0.19791007041931152, -0.8911603689193726, -0.008909940719604492, -0.1470852941274643, -0.5325070023536682, -0.42450037598609924, -0.05937625467777252, -0.3438073992729187, 0.09500652551651001, 0.1504857838153839, -0.714812159538269, -0.2166929543018341, -0.6808303594589233, 0.49194836616516113, 0.4542160630226135, 0.013412319123744965, 0.6096487045288086, -0.3125181794166565, 0.561722993850708, 0.012401082552969456, 0.17320923507213593, 0.11992118507623672, -0.43144941329956055, -0.6801244616508484, -0.3729413151741028, 0.15296772122383118, 0.47486236691474915, -0.8752041459083557, 0.9430636167526245, 0.06569164991378784, -0.30437377095222473, -0.48142755031585693, 0.25447776913642883, 0.2639763653278351, 0.3863880932331085, 0.21304520964622498, -0.27170777320861816, -0.36757397651672363, -0.402108371257782, -0.17974023520946503, -0.29754388332366943, -0.08239932358264923, 0.07308453321456909, 0.24483834207057953, 0.026936447247862816, 0.9640306830406189, -0.3768894076347351, -0.4782775044441223, -0.6250730156898499, -0.37687453627586365, 0.49063244462013245, 0.32137054204940796, 0.5659588575363159, -0.5901063680648804, -0.2727200984954834, 0.18196715414524078, -0.7924996614456177, -0.07555815577507019, 0.1499907672405243, -0.2701879143714905, 0.09214511513710022, 1.0310561656951904, -0.5336635708808899, 0.3554910123348236, 0.4506087005138397, -0.274636447429657, 0.26570677757263184, -0.2872086763381958, -0.04911583289504051, -1.055192470550537, -0.039386045187711716, -0.21269212663173676, -0.33470380306243896, -0.5685010552406311, 0.26222291588783264, 0.11124265938997269, -0.054801322519779205, -0.4904726445674896, 0.64195317029953, -0.20233432948589325, -0.06412987411022186, -0.07419518381357193, 0.13155275583267212, 0.06018703803420067, 0.09556212276220322, -0.0959671214222908, 0.637251615524292, 0.3058772087097168, -0.747471034526825, 0.3306209146976471, 0.04908738285303116, -0.7509611248970032, 0.6528483629226685, -0.5333343744277954, 0.028279343619942665, -0.539671003818512, 0.12563736736774445, -1.3009648323059082, 0.04900772497057915, 0.2249300181865692, -0.37331053614616394, 0.14379079639911652, -0.3204740285873413, -0.5891101360321045, -0.38114726543426514, -0.23579922318458557, 0.6632403135299683, 0.5262941122055054, -0.6506373882293701, 0.41775426268577576, 0.20843377709388733, 0.09339424967765808, -0.40165460109710693, -0.8337870836257935, -0.49614614248275757, -0.42575493454933167, -0.6130210161209106, -0.021930033341050148, -0.21782733500003815, -0.22160160541534424, -0.2597953975200653, 0.1462361067533493, -0.36683812737464905, 0.24187101423740387, -0.16477824747562408, 0.04825642704963684, -0.5786461234092712, 0.5424022674560547, -0.018962187692523003, 0.16709892451763153, 0.06516862660646439, -0.37664756178855896, 0.7872658967971802, 0.06966172903776169, -0.5443309545516968, -0.3743768334388733, 0.11017311364412308, 0.5622199773788452, -0.28145548701286316, 0.7385975122451782, 0.7509335875511169, -0.3134785592556, -0.1455039381980896, -0.7002241015434265, -0.5034217834472656, -0.4849012792110443, 0.5791960954666138, -0.13274875283241272, -0.660895049571991, 0.4936307370662689, 0.2550312876701355, 0.021101627498865128, 0.294246643781662, 0.27826735377311707, -0.04878263175487518, 0.9124715328216553, 0.7266064882278442, -0.09609857946634293, 0.7922025322914124, -0.22618044912815094, 0.3709179759025574, -0.6375778317451477, 0.16416020691394806, -0.3330136835575104, -0.13927513360977173, -0.40131109952926636, -0.2297031134366989, 0.41799914836883545, 0.49345633387565613, -0.3634334206581116, -0.025984857231378555, -0.20516632497310638, 0.61395663022995, 0.42624813318252563, 0.39590924978256226, 0.5702311992645264, 0.20019082725048065, 0.1856323629617691, 0.2887207865715027, -0.7206348180770874, -0.3776962161064148, 1.427812099456787, 0.5440465807914734, 0.666345477104187, 0.1890716403722763, 0.8857358694076538, 0.21708613634109497, 0.2926062047481537, -0.7766433954238892, 0.5943912863731384, -0.40713781118392944, -0.6754178404808044, -0.6565216779708862, -0.5683391094207764, -0.8334892392158508, 0.1617252081632614, -0.20139196515083313, -0.36780568957328796, 0.2568518817424774, 0.22464317083358765, -0.7859152555465698, 0.4529167115688324, -0.592180073261261, 0.9271203875541687, 0.015809589996933937, 0.0682888925075531, -0.08873428404331207, -0.11124370247125626, 0.5210960507392883, -0.09594911336898804, 0.1587464064359665, -0.23463355004787445, 0.08852510899305344, 0.6743103265762329, -0.6384580135345459, 0.6678386926651001, -0.08623068779706955, -0.39254266023635864, 0.5163144469261169, -0.0421459823846817, 0.45030272006988525, 0.2237306535243988, -0.3549356758594513, -0.07883699983358383, 0.03448285534977913, -0.2123776078224182, -0.5705983638763428, 0.47750869393348694, -0.5865225195884705, -0.3208695650100708, -0.0897928923368454, -0.6082267761230469, -0.16466733813285828, 0.24677957594394684, 0.6863327026367188, 0.6304532289505005, -0.005541367921978235, 0.33202823996543884, 0.8598304986953735, -0.24803116917610168, 0.3654947280883789, 0.44805699586868286, -0.4546954929828644, -0.33144286274909973, 0.7676627039909363, 0.028756875544786453, 0.5136853456497192, 0.45124784111976624, 0.4373542070388794, -0.521673321723938, -0.743956446647644, -0.4780619740486145, 0.23560039699077606, -0.8800494074821472, -0.25914645195007324, -0.42430177330970764, -0.34159040451049805, -0.18091405928134918, 0.19176426529884338, -0.2595885396003723, -0.11338164657354355, -0.36429357528686523, 0.09690610319375992, 0.37970301508903503, 0.5602795481681824, 0.01961265131831169, 0.4345932602882385, -0.4750276505947113, 0.3664718568325043, 0.4922501742839813, 0.25344592332839966, -0.033010248094797134, -1.043330192565918, 0.04823960363864899, 0.11994743347167969, -0.2498875856399536, -0.557694137096405, 0.3039531707763672, 0.4702201187610626, 0.5074470043182373, 0.7254068851470947, 0.4583037197589874, 0.45330870151519775, -0.1801162213087082, 0.4442584216594696, 0.2920704483985901, -0.5863726139068604, 0.27468886971473694, -0.09619675576686859, 0.10510962456464767, 0.4741118550300598, 0.36391693353652954, -0.2256292849779129, -0.6102045178413391, -0.27805793285369873, -0.5026013255119324, 0.5183618664741516, -0.024303201586008072, 0.26062870025634766, -0.30995750427246094, 0.3621779680252075, 0.2563980519771576, 0.3045866787433624, -0.7700920701026917, -0.14569516479969025, 0.3107779324054718, -0.4028095602989197, -0.2753051817417145, -0.3568921685218811, 0.10621526837348938, -0.10596879571676254, 0.44481152296066284, -0.025705508887767792, 0.21837149560451508, 0.07158736139535904, -0.2783970832824707, -0.054729629307985306, 0.4123193621635437, 0.27687519788742065, 0.6906266212463379, -0.46803492307662964, 0.3518564701080322, 0.11133906990289688, -0.5469191074371338, 0.10441904515028, 0.07894211262464523, -0.2548849582672119, -0.03442709520459175, 0.39154931902885437, 0.49905699491500854, -0.08431697636842728, -0.7593671083450317, 0.7648113369941711, -0.0005927477614022791, -0.07446549832820892, -0.36739715933799744, -0.00017227492935489863, -0.14968298375606537, 0.4501481354236603, 0.2608463764190674, -0.09280174225568771, 0.2866821587085724, -0.8369330167770386, 0.30022892355918884, 0.6009719967842102, -0.43251660466194153, -0.04260142147541046, 0.22904138267040253, 0.016078827902674675, -0.08596442639827728, 0.5837354063987732, -0.6013426780700684, -0.33594679832458496, 0.6366909146308899, 0.4963548481464386, 0.5421566367149353, -0.14310435950756073, 0.08540963381528854, 0.10495315492153168, 0.2793615162372589, -0.3033832907676697, 0.6059198975563049, 0.14654238522052765, -0.9981480240821838, -0.4923986792564392, -0.5499206781387329, 0.18531917035579681, 0.6104071736335754, -0.7469877004623413, 0.355480432510376, -0.4594435393810272, -0.21599295735359192, 0.08086799085140228, -0.15645113587379456, -0.6991998553276062, 0.07702367752790451, 0.21085193753242493, 0.7624297142028809, -0.6900357604026794, 0.6427813172340393, 0.48775503039360046, -0.2888994812965393, -0.6189097762107849, 0.08424396067857742, -0.35280099511146545, -0.8569315075874329, 0.6581977605819702, 0.1984841227531433, 0.12453045696020126, 0.18288689851760864, -0.260510116815567, -0.7094008922576904, 0.8775544166564941, 0.793367862701416, -0.8323459029197693, 0.28661197423934937, 0.22802110016345978, 0.3645055592060089, -0.2835621237754822, 0.49397918581962585, 0.7645470499992371, 0.0950460359454155, 0.026430122554302216, -1.050317645072937, -0.14248478412628174, 0.13751159608364105, -0.2526652216911316, 0.46698591113090515, -0.09943214058876038, 1.1706041097640991, -0.32459038496017456, -0.22716140747070312, 0.29299721121788025, 0.6121981143951416, 0.23575592041015625, 0.5226425528526306, 0.6745325326919556, 0.5654485821723938, 0.780730664730072, 0.19434301555156708, 0.945557713508606, -0.15337806940078735, 0.3537188470363617, 0.9209442138671875, -0.08202759176492691, 1.264156460762024, 0.47748351097106934, -0.1759040206670761, 0.13502006232738495, 0.4322996735572815, 0.49465814232826233, 0.7125285863876343, 0.501457154750824, -0.41528239846229553, -0.6387249231338501, -0.0686892420053482, -0.6479034423828125, 0.1761067509651184, 0.16878098249435425, -0.36849644780158997, -0.3013156056404114, 0.3371894359588623, -0.25332769751548767, 0.22457434237003326, -0.7547925710678101, 0.607611894607544, 0.08667504042387009, -0.5602536797523499, 1.0038425922393799, -0.24233752489089966, 0.8011350631713867, -0.3734738826751709, 0.09636196494102478, -0.5278337001800537, 0.660187840461731, -0.2293553352355957, -0.8732098937034607, 0.1534779667854309, -0.35050833225250244, -0.15731576085090637, 0.2670855224132538, 0.6591721177101135, -0.7944490909576416, -0.4588034152984619, 0.10992925614118576, 0.5269778370857239, 0.2596210539340973, -0.6006184816360474, -0.27164000272750854, -0.0024833520874381065, -0.16195064783096313, 0.0530988909304142, 0.35101044178009033, 0.824285089969635, -0.051658835262060165, 0.6893245577812195, 0.6042752265930176, 0.00013543321983888745, 0.3150598108768463, 0.19822119176387787, 0.7918070554733276, -0.24180595576763153, -0.6238091588020325, -0.905137300491333, 0.1237938329577446, -0.05219597741961479, -0.34414952993392944, 0.4701557159423828, 0.39123982191085815, 0.9607281684875488, -0.2759409248828888, 0.770054280757904, 0.05103430151939392, 0.3826417922973633, -0.6930596828460693, 0.710028886795044, -0.7051320672035217, 0.41495010256767273, 0.07966291159391403, -0.9094948768615723, -0.21138262748718262, 0.7012885212898254, -0.4823398292064667, 0.0033111730590462685, 0.6650540828704834, 0.9878391623497009, -0.29012832045555115, -0.18394003808498383, 0.6723589301109314, -0.05884751304984093, 0.28914010524749756, 0.7595731616020203, 1.0682677030563354, -0.6162022948265076, 0.9495965838432312, -0.1562546342611313, -0.2292364090681076, -0.4436191916465759, -0.8794430494308472, -1.453160047531128, -0.47362902760505676, -0.25297051668167114, -0.32641565799713135, 0.023847680538892746, 0.8316256403923035, 0.7644707560539246, -0.8374376893043518, -0.07276713848114014, -0.49789974093437195, 0.2280755490064621, -0.14314310252666473, -0.18414589762687683, 0.16787534952163696, -0.42581096291542053, -0.42780351638793945, 0.29279011487960815, 0.09843701869249344, 0.15301984548568726, -0.4016742706298828, -0.10229150950908661, -0.0007513294694945216, 0.14620594680309296, 0.7130940556526184, 0.27005475759506226, -0.519550621509552, -0.27383244037628174, -0.07991144061088562, -0.20532500743865967, -0.23121829330921173, 0.6820482015609741, -0.5024828314781189, 0.2874743938446045, 0.7990227341651917, 0.6367692947387695, -0.0001876287569757551, -0.3188583552837372, 0.5682275891304016, -0.7588518261909485, 0.22902153432369232, 0.27333855628967285, 0.3731859028339386, 0.15379734337329865, -0.3961244523525238, 0.3423579931259155, 0.03169693425297737, -0.4398193657398224, -1.0959135293960571, 0.3726917505264282, -0.7444531917572021, -0.08625565469264984, 1.3284461498260498, -0.20842842757701874, -0.17474137246608734, -0.44128817319869995, -0.21600091457366943, -0.03146671503782272, -0.3633219003677368, 0.6716398596763611, 0.4733223617076874, 0.19687996804714203, -0.1917252242565155, -0.5972278118133545, 0.5456570982933044, 0.48030218482017517, -0.8518931865692139, 0.019860828295350075, 0.25802847743034363, 0.3343071937561035, 0.10261615365743637, 0.7416154146194458, 0.0030367185827344656, 0.46533289551734924, -0.3201337158679962, -0.025706520304083824, -0.14174330234527588, -0.2280948907136917, -0.32766008377075195, 0.22422683238983154, 0.439944326877594, -0.5434120893478394 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04900v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04900v1
Radial Networks: Dynamic Layer Routing for High-Performance Large Language Models
2024-04-07T09:52:31
2024-04-07T09:52:31
Jordan Dotzel, Yash Akhauri, Ahmed S. AbouElhamayed, Carly Jiang, Mohamed Abdelfattah, Zhiru Zhang
cs.CL
cs.CL
Large language models (LLMs) often struggle with strict memory, latency, and power demands. To meet these demands, various forms of dynamic sparsity have been proposed that reduce compute on an input-by-input basis. These methods improve over static methods by exploiting the variance across individual inputs, which has steadily grown with the exponential increase in training data. Yet, the increasing depth within modern models, currently with hundreds of layers, has opened opportunities for dynamic layer sparsity, which skips the computation for entire layers. In this work, we explore the practicality of layer sparsity by profiling residual connections and establish the relationship between model depth and layer sparsity. For example, the residual blocks in the OPT-66B model have a median contribution of 5% to its output. We then take advantage of this dynamic sparsity and propose Radial Networks, which perform token-level routing between layers guided by a trained router module. These networks can be used in a post-training distillation from sequential networks or trained from scratch to co-learn the router and layer weights. They enable scaling to larger model sizes by decoupling the number of layers from the dynamic depth of the network, and their design allows for layer reuse. By varying the compute token by token, they reduce the overall resources needed for generating entire sequences. Overall, this leads to larger capacity networks with significantly lower compute and serving costs for large language models.
[ -0.5487467646598816, -1.035477638244629, 0.3530716001987457, -0.001999716507270932, -0.11705823987722397, 0.2887880802154541, -0.18895241618156433, -0.4329416751861572, 0.27560585737228394, 0.7288482189178467, -0.5236804485321045, -0.3123953342437744, -0.34840548038482666, -0.11908455938100815, -0.6466574668884277, 0.672917902469635, 0.19322241842746735, -0.21884647011756897, 0.13382171094417572, -0.0742851048707962, -0.2575395107269287, -0.5063526034355164, -1.0166608095169067, -0.3175640404224396, 1.102055311203003, 0.36551088094711304, 0.801733672618866, 0.8317621350288391, 0.6157216429710388, 0.4012982249259949, -0.4861368238925934, 0.09808240830898285, -0.5132920145988464, 0.48942533135414124, 0.009461007080972195, 0.01655816286802292, -0.45131397247314453, -0.4900021255016327, 1.1418551206588745, 1.049038290977478, -0.26516154408454895, 0.13852496445178986, -0.30085882544517517, 0.9183831214904785, -0.34259092807769775, -0.1914271116256714, -0.5371309518814087, 0.38919350504875183, -0.3190363347530365, -0.056927409023046494, -0.27323174476623535, -0.1343594789505005, 0.08750981092453003, -0.2487454116344452, 0.1307683289051056, 0.11575275659561157, 0.6291380524635315, 0.16842857003211975, -0.3051956593990326, -0.06465859711170197, -1.0721908807754517, 0.48720991611480713, -0.7248984575271606, 0.4839307367801666, 0.0835690051317215, 0.4526907205581665, -0.022663919255137444, -0.8891893029212952, -0.3293200731277466, -0.39603883028030396, -0.006702356971800327, -0.16269725561141968, -0.2844110429286957, 0.16047073900699615, 0.479332834482193, 0.3782295286655426, -0.4537665545940399, 0.27737995982170105, -0.38849887251853943, 0.07718437910079956, 0.34265631437301636, 0.08729662001132965, 0.2703360617160797, 0.2615346312522888, -0.30655720829963684, 0.0011498203966766596, -0.741420328617096, 0.014032737351953983, 0.5135437250137329, 0.28753361105918884, 0.06212534382939339, 0.45903438329696655, -0.18681539595127106, 0.9897439479827881, -0.03251640498638153, 0.013662234880030155, -0.04617123305797577, -0.10934565216302872, -0.1242237538099289, 0.16863413155078888, 0.5110751390457153, -0.4717651903629303, 0.10671332478523254, -0.35727575421333313, -0.41473880410194397, -0.3559316396713257, 0.08193422853946686, -0.6295359134674072, -0.35890552401542664, 0.05244258791208267, -0.312493234872818, -0.322724848985672, -0.020803354680538177, -0.5893266797065735, -0.11020208150148392, -0.45838528871536255, 0.26065826416015625, -0.41039571166038513, -0.4568714499473572, 0.47020673751831055, 0.08733712881803513, -0.032812513411045074, 0.2566211521625519, -0.6387548446655273, 0.689943253993988, 0.6177442073822021, 0.8540670871734619, 0.1105865016579628, -0.14506666362285614, -0.794409990310669, 0.35742151737213135, -0.09303054958581924, 0.33374857902526855, -0.6886984705924988, 0.040142763406038284, -0.04776303842663765, -0.22944912314414978, -0.07696210592985153, -0.6890333294868469, 0.3843422532081604, -0.8797765374183655, -0.06877375394105911, -0.03367217257618904, -0.18050247430801392, -0.2378682643175125, 0.1350790113210678, -0.8050575256347656, 1.1556227207183838, -0.09424328058958054, -0.7095898985862732, -0.2539384365081787, -0.30486994981765747, -0.6460106372833252, -0.027768533676862717, 0.23472385108470917, -0.26572784781455994, 0.3706025779247284, 0.003987796604633331, 0.4208243489265442, -0.09371918439865112, 0.40896445512771606, -0.2691197395324707, -0.41677168011665344, 0.3635757863521576, -0.43463125824928284, 0.4845440685749054, 0.15666693449020386, -0.42304879426956177, 0.15011754631996155, -1.1124082803726196, -0.2591800391674042, -0.09541924297809601, -0.4106055796146393, -0.40294185280799866, 0.16692405939102173, -0.034824188798666, 0.32035472989082336, -0.05622035637497902, -0.2678506076335907, 0.0528140552341938, -0.40104591846466064, 0.5741597414016724, 0.7538383603096008, -0.3426046669483185, 0.2891404628753662, -0.1076279878616333, 0.5254274010658264, 0.056805096566677094, 0.07357260584831238, -0.06708522140979767, 0.04235747084021568, -1.167518138885498, -0.4084000587463379, 0.32547348737716675, 0.31806132197380066, -0.7331929802894592, 0.5614914894104004, -0.2662861943244934, -0.47789838910102844, 0.009955351240932941, -0.0727306380867958, 0.4771786034107208, 0.5524218678474426, 0.28590285778045654, -0.49196651577949524, -0.3933483958244324, -0.8954728245735168, -0.07240276783704758, 0.03481385111808777, 0.38632136583328247, 0.5479467511177063, 0.20416778326034546, -0.07453378289937973, 0.6436554789543152, -0.3879208266735077, -0.20703622698783875, -0.5687036514282227, -0.21224400401115417, 0.3110710680484772, 0.4503369927406311, 0.29900112748146057, -0.4503117799758911, -0.33546656370162964, 0.19632656872272491, -0.3482356369495392, -0.10451791435480118, -0.02078467421233654, -0.32486146688461304, -0.0232364721596241, 0.5017233490943909, -0.6025511622428894, -0.007291528861969709, 0.7023889422416687, -0.221523717045784, 0.47611287236213684, -0.29578641057014465, -0.4767504930496216, -0.777262806892395, 0.2812042236328125, 0.23959220945835114, -0.39408454298973083, -0.6732749342918396, -0.069821797311306, -0.34248992800712585, -0.3502967655658722, -0.3198995292186737, 0.702281653881073, -0.6716320514678955, -0.45332974195480347, 0.008024522103369236, 0.08769936859607697, -0.014484594576060772, 0.37132757902145386, -0.10101737827062607, 0.5673025846481323, 0.6077040433883667, -0.6172516345977783, 0.6666848659515381, -0.25129809975624084, -0.22725245356559753, -0.061882030218839645, -0.7586585283279419, 0.02169984206557274, -0.05305175110697746, 0.46611136198043823, -0.9637537002563477, -0.1148255318403244, 0.18233436346054077, -0.2055560201406479, 0.394584059715271, -0.19508598744869232, -0.47176340222358704, -0.3593739867210388, -0.0073744975961744785, 0.7204976677894592, 0.5908252596855164, -0.3595235049724579, 0.6843645572662354, 0.2701813280582428, -0.04738057032227516, -0.8324692249298096, -0.576195478439331, 0.2683386504650116, -0.2989543676376343, -0.8100718259811401, 0.4412553310394287, 0.2615390717983246, -0.18622131645679474, 0.061106037348508835, -0.02278968319296837, -0.09847962856292725, 0.1694987416267395, 0.03767772391438484, -0.12507952749729156, -0.41953015327453613, -0.11343012005090714, 0.1712571382522583, -0.11073271185159683, 0.16161535680294037, -0.41899368166923523, 0.9892926216125488, -0.0186607763171196, -0.45510074496269226, -0.6732762455940247, 0.20502103865146637, 0.717090368270874, -0.38428089022636414, 0.9856051802635193, 0.7280879020690918, -0.18924616277217865, -0.4386187195777893, -0.8457933068275452, -0.16844454407691956, -0.5469924807548523, 0.6516958475112915, -0.23274920880794525, -1.0731068849563599, 0.7308366894721985, -0.14885956048965454, -0.27957361936569214, 0.20507405698299408, 0.40091055631637573, 0.06800255924463272, 0.637070894241333, 0.4897315800189972, -0.16159535944461823, 0.7402324080467224, -0.29268932342529297, 0.38641566038131714, -0.7687172889709473, -0.3143395483493805, -0.5340154767036438, -0.526726484298706, -0.22259926795959473, -0.5099082589149475, 0.4044409394264221, 0.06643705815076828, -0.6046116948127747, -0.10025375336408615, -0.27182409167289734, 0.4982995092868805, 0.5211697220802307, 0.17258459329605103, 0.2797333896160126, 0.5903515219688416, -0.3064029812812805, 0.31417399644851685, -0.9784740805625916, -0.26489487290382385, 0.24590297043323517, 0.6806219220161438, 0.7987751364707947, 0.22119812667369843, 0.4264305531978607, 0.1848216950893402, -0.08649883419275284, -0.6493594646453857, 0.8812212944030762, -0.3100844919681549, -0.311943382024765, -0.43836259841918945, -0.7922685146331787, -0.8171838521957397, 0.19289599359035492, -0.10823960602283478, -0.31577545404434204, -0.04033889248967171, 0.3248773515224457, -0.33364686369895935, 0.7896887063980103, -0.3833130896091461, 0.3887389600276947, -0.40938180685043335, -0.7171175479888916, -0.32150542736053467, -0.614525318145752, 0.26995372772216797, 0.19180706143379211, 0.06231031194329262, 0.037088897079229355, 0.14464913308620453, 0.6788598895072937, -0.32024630904197693, 1.0351516008377075, -0.2440415620803833, -0.026278382167220116, 0.07503344118595123, 0.4079529941082001, 0.5892190337181091, 0.042035575956106186, -0.1465604305267334, 0.19643285870552063, -0.4275965988636017, -0.1757516860961914, -0.31947043538093567, 0.8152675032615662, -0.9366525411605835, -0.4937613606452942, -0.2491728812456131, -0.36664509773254395, -0.12077565491199493, 0.3766672611236572, -0.41581448912620544, 0.8851426839828491, -0.05517498776316643, 0.3006035089492798, 0.878233790397644, -0.661652684211731, 0.46737179160118103, 0.2411254346370697, -0.09271571785211563, -0.40468013286590576, 0.7566971182823181, 0.08720800280570984, 0.3151050806045532, 0.5105712413787842, 0.1963646560907364, -0.3159582018852234, -0.7333062291145325, -0.4570816457271576, 0.6185137629508972, -0.35317566990852356, -0.16889037191867828, -0.6610741019248962, -0.6794763207435608, -0.12437447160482407, -0.15247686207294464, -0.5471168756484985, -0.6041277050971985, -0.2235593944787979, -0.027380909770727158, 0.3384486436843872, 0.7082536220550537, 0.01961367391049862, 0.4457184374332428, -0.8221908211708069, -0.16605614125728607, 0.17198464274406433, 0.5834442973136902, 0.7375377416610718, -0.6309975981712341, -0.4910157024860382, -0.2592114210128784, -0.1540537327528, -0.2654605805873871, 0.5513253211975098, 0.12647941708564758, 0.439784437417984, 0.32763293385505676, -0.13461565971374512, 0.7437761425971985, -0.8228617310523987, 0.5548620223999023, 0.36227723956108093, -0.9410233497619629, 0.18276317417621613, -0.5386328101158142, -0.022458085790276527, 0.029225973412394524, 0.312792032957077, -0.6363256573677063, -0.13679467141628265, -0.4862755239009857, -1.0514142513275146, 0.687014639377594, 0.039564527571201324, 0.3728422522544861, 0.25631430745124817, 0.8003944754600525, -0.085410937666893, 0.006795057561248541, -0.6300441026687622, -0.1710195243358612, 0.1755761057138443, -0.10734677314758301, 0.17646639049053192, -0.5989742875099182, -0.20062482357025146, -0.2092989832162857, 0.46920713782310486, 0.28470778465270996, 0.10807012766599655, -0.06802194565534592, 0.16944654285907745, -0.0862632542848587, -0.03738351911306381, 0.6937255859375, 0.8979423642158508, -0.1942489892244339, 0.4423927664756775, 0.03616109862923622, -0.31524690985679626, 0.2677791118621826, -0.11525470018386841, -0.005873323418200016, 0.07577725499868393, 0.3577272593975067, 1.1072746515274048, 0.11405815929174423, -0.5652552843093872, 0.2334240823984146, -0.02016468718647957, -0.05734986439347267, -0.5830751657485962, 0.21517515182495117, 0.09153658896684647, 0.42380934953689575, 0.2650653123855591, 0.026899782940745354, -0.17464923858642578, -0.22994424402713776, 0.1325516253709793, 0.5380008816719055, -0.4649339020252228, -0.5067722797393799, 0.37278273701667786, 0.35519692301750183, -0.4463009536266327, 0.6513501405715942, 0.4805081784725189, -0.39921361207962036, 0.6056650280952454, 0.50552898645401, 0.5575471520423889, -0.10538168251514435, 0.10808068513870239, 0.3544579744338989, 0.17110459506511688, -0.20897187292575836, -0.3943096995353699, 0.019825750961899757, -0.585054874420166, -0.6456670761108398, -0.6186315417289734, -0.3061199486255646, 0.17438656091690063, -0.5864773392677307, 0.1839389204978943, -0.6142314672470093, -0.2743142545223236, -0.3862886130809784, -0.10800684988498688, -0.29838839173316956, 0.2751457393169403, 0.1003323644399643, 0.9581764936447144, -0.7055445909500122, 0.8185026049613953, 0.5916082859039307, -0.11522475630044937, -0.7553150653839111, -0.25624382495880127, -0.4058209955692291, -0.7385485768318176, 1.1218458414077759, -0.020858045667409897, -0.43476760387420654, 0.09180079400539398, -0.11540653556585312, -1.161952257156372, 0.9411755800247192, 0.3871186077594757, -0.6117461919784546, -0.2536068260669708, 0.13079598546028137, 0.44547054171562195, -0.1278308779001236, 0.21548323333263397, 0.12011583149433136, 0.1515313982963562, 0.34869620203971863, -0.6340143084526062, 0.07247418910264969, 0.049090828746557236, 0.3030991852283478, 0.1939229816198349, -0.8527290225028992, 0.9508114457130432, 0.13427993655204773, -0.029093654826283455, -0.029634295031428337, 0.5701530575752258, 0.32684603333473206, -0.031262755393981934, 0.5635883808135986, 0.5612409114837646, 0.5288788676261902, -0.020430568605661392, 0.7825251817703247, -0.37333205342292786, 0.24049146473407745, 0.6597321033477783, -0.41408711671829224, 0.7872559428215027, 0.4157387316226959, 0.01566745899617672, 0.47304201126098633, 0.38124895095825195, 0.3232002258300781, 0.439784437417984, 0.7621418833732605, -0.41020041704177856, -0.2432359755039215, -0.09584982693195343, -0.5285213589668274, 0.2010793685913086, 0.22386395931243896, -0.45020875334739685, -0.10440343618392944, -0.21567317843437195, 0.15746165812015533, -0.19142821431159973, -0.2221287190914154, 0.5901231169700623, 0.030787300318479538, -0.38938719034194946, 0.6526708006858826, 0.18735148012638092, 0.5598999857902527, -0.7090295553207397, 0.11658094823360443, -0.6698958873748779, 0.42854148149490356, -0.12845470011234283, -0.41706815361976624, 0.3460950553417206, -0.0035017640329897404, -0.2524501085281372, -0.3073599338531494, 0.668316125869751, -0.3341352641582489, -0.7109551429748535, 0.39495474100112915, 0.592660129070282, -0.06145858019590378, 0.31423220038414, -0.6350999474525452, 0.5478160977363586, -0.21150046586990356, -0.5112709999084473, 0.5422946214675903, 0.8874539732933044, 0.15464206039905548, 0.8946934938430786, 0.6942762732505798, 0.6281343698501587, 0.3179900050163269, 0.17071177065372467, 1.2721785306930542, -0.6951094269752502, -0.15033411979675293, -0.8299098610877991, 0.4178963005542755, -0.07381930947303772, 0.019244708120822906, 0.42429831624031067, 0.5349226593971252, 0.8011291027069092, 0.11365624517202377, 0.40729019045829773, 0.264303982257843, 0.4245672821998596, -0.7220867276191711, 0.6924591660499573, -0.6733428239822388, 0.6590229272842407, -0.1628711223602295, -0.96680748462677, -0.5820088982582092, 0.9455093741416931, -0.056911882013082504, 0.22347839176654816, 0.4361768662929535, 0.8406307697296143, -0.5142497420310974, -0.34892719984054565, 0.2818623483181, 0.27949032187461853, 0.6031259894371033, 0.4312242865562439, 0.9116931557655334, -0.1471560001373291, 0.25141698122024536, -0.24970905482769012, -0.2089010328054428, -0.16369391977787018, -0.9047369956970215, -0.9255326390266418, -0.3102591037750244, -0.360191285610199, -0.49245601892471313, 0.2570303678512573, 0.6468074917793274, 0.7554293274879456, -0.39532792568206787, -0.6686072945594788, -0.17698541283607483, 0.08876621723175049, -0.062116146087646484, -0.2007608562707901, 0.5379211902618408, -0.2561897933483124, -0.3486383259296417, 0.15913209319114685, 0.33972978591918945, -0.063151516020298, -0.5860016345977783, 0.1765451729297638, -0.11763249337673187, -0.04627024382352829, 0.769386351108551, 0.21836964786052704, -0.6635854840278625, -0.06449003517627716, 0.059691186994314194, 0.11255038529634476, -0.16041040420532227, 0.9945006966590881, -0.7707493305206299, -0.09344576299190521, 0.39645376801490784, 0.8357295393943787, 0.5124661326408386, -0.11245042830705643, 0.47286257147789, -0.6715975403785706, 0.3815465569496155, 0.3386904299259186, 0.19496676325798035, 0.21292103826999664, -0.16405992209911346, 0.26765182614326477, 0.2666441798210144, -0.5710024833679199, -1.0715608596801758, 0.27894172072410583, -1.0837595462799072, -0.19401182234287262, 1.2533501386642456, -0.06547711044549942, -0.23072853684425354, 0.00770396925508976, -0.19235274195671082, 0.13313710689544678, -0.3380732238292694, 0.6912757754325867, 0.5321394205093384, -0.2008926123380661, -0.5166009068489075, -0.47786256670951843, 0.30973824858665466, 0.5564292669296265, -0.3813580274581909, 0.2984752655029297, 0.6342764496803284, 0.12746907770633698, -0.21559906005859375, 0.4588668942451477, -0.01422919426113367, -0.4685214161872864, -0.3624212145805359, -0.1755904108285904, -0.5247064828872681, -0.6630658507347107, -0.0821068212389946, 0.3159816265106201, 0.1649819165468216, 0.246065154671669 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04892v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04892v1
Elementary fractal geometry. 5. Weak separation is strong separation
2024-04-07T09:21:09
2024-04-07T09:21:09
Christoph Bandt, Michael F. Barnsley
math.DS
math.DS, cs.CL, 28A80, 11A63, 37B10, 54B15, 68Q45
For self-similar sets, there are two important separation properties: the open set condition and the weak separation condition introduced by Zerner, which may be replaced by the formally stronger finite type property of Ngai and Wang. We show that any finite type self-similar set can be represented as a graph-directed construction obeying the open set condition. The proof is based on a combinatorial algorithm which performed well in computer experiments.
[ -0.6049976944923401, -0.887642502784729, 0.2879750430583954, 0.2692813575267792, -0.24212141335010529, -0.20555290579795837, 0.0038076078053563833, -0.5187587738037109, 0.2585841715335846, 0.3683755695819855, -0.40393584966659546, -0.14807546138763428, -0.7386578321456909, 0.2191835641860962, -0.6401141881942749, 1.002632737159729, -0.1459716260433197, -0.16692987084388733, 0.04525041580200195, -0.7212345004081726, -0.041826650500297546, -0.2707343101501465, -0.28511282801628113, -0.17385894060134888, 0.36890214681625366, 0.32222047448158264, 1.1628285646438599, 0.8510813117027283, 0.5993112921714783, 0.41624969244003296, -0.3525846302509308, -0.04918822646141052, -0.6013879179954529, 0.2589260935783386, 0.04814457148313522, -0.2776384949684143, 0.11911296844482422, -0.07377976179122925, 0.8944808840751648, 1.082534670829773, 0.04003892466425896, -0.3936243951320648, 0.32004162669181824, 0.8257122039794922, -0.35452792048454285, -0.04787082225084305, -0.1972709745168686, 0.6105495691299438, -0.5370250344276428, 0.1811603605747223, 0.0850922092795372, -0.3491334617137909, 0.26544442772865295, -0.5772820711135864, 0.5563233494758606, -0.0016776426928117871, 1.148436188697815, 0.10156913101673126, -0.40561625361442566, -0.4539361596107483, -0.717921257019043, 0.8485939502716064, -0.31501033902168274, 0.790847897529602, 0.2793135643005371, 0.32609662413597107, -0.27909013628959656, -0.8804008960723877, -0.423350989818573, 0.28702256083488464, -0.4358067512512207, -0.027963077649474144, -0.21946287155151367, 0.013718528673052788, 0.3940877914428711, 1.2142747640609741, -0.4379343092441559, 0.11669815331697464, -1.0583406686782837, -0.016574684530496597, 0.3827941417694092, 0.18096722662448883, 0.5367341041564941, -0.31002622842788696, -0.41167277097702026, 0.2185688316822052, -0.930520236492157, 0.004773973487317562, 0.3624919354915619, 0.3339884877204895, -0.1343287229537964, 0.5156763792037964, -0.1561083048582077, 0.5821462273597717, 0.10321324318647385, -0.5360695719718933, -0.019177529960870743, -0.32773372530937195, -0.3355734348297119, -0.15813539922237396, 0.6648496389389038, -0.1608828902244568, 0.2835468351840973, -0.18560722470283508, -0.4127174913883209, -0.4396820068359375, -0.3435247242450714, -0.8497165441513062, -0.5944982767105103, 0.2822655737400055, -1.1208587884902954, -0.40490978956222534, 0.460897833108902, -0.5471293330192566, -0.3839186131954193, -0.13846223056316376, 0.2741994857788086, -0.09645742923021317, -0.4889151453971863, -0.22937990725040436, 0.08233616501092911, -0.023269709199666977, 0.11968075484037399, -1.0436371564865112, 0.7780303359031677, 0.7517615556716919, 0.9996544718742371, -0.017961585894227028, -0.3918762803077698, -0.5261193513870239, -0.016056682914495468, -0.29968690872192383, 0.7518911957740784, -0.2326202243566513, -0.4542461633682251, -0.1770474761724472, -0.025463053956627846, 0.18849703669548035, -0.6722090840339661, 0.1374465972185135, -0.3802734911441803, 0.43974488973617554, -0.3238599896430969, -0.5403228402137756, -0.3144433796405792, -0.17498809099197388, -1.1116911172866821, 0.3821462094783783, 0.3700306713581085, -0.675562858581543, 0.5235400199890137, -0.3406548500061035, -0.9859579205513, -0.18817834556102753, -0.4512617290019989, -0.6728199124336243, -0.108956478536129, -0.06385228782892227, 0.2233293354511261, -0.17521271109580994, -0.3247407376766205, -0.915363073348999, -0.14533302187919617, -0.06366828829050064, -0.04019298031926155, 1.0933446884155273, 0.8272403478622437, -0.3637203872203827, 0.08510997146368027, -0.5311770439147949, 0.20696312189102173, 0.051556773483753204, -0.3286758363246918, -0.25648564100265503, 0.2688497006893158, -0.45139849185943604, 0.13509799540042877, 0.24855242669582367, -0.34935176372528076, 0.16549988090991974, -0.2471790313720703, 0.5128017067909241, 0.9481588006019592, 0.12455807626247406, 0.5132752656936646, -0.10402969270944595, 0.13160905241966248, 0.1953161060810089, 0.26838722825050354, 0.4063578248023987, -0.45576411485671997, -0.7404442429542542, -0.4194551408290863, 0.2150297462940216, 0.16338670253753662, -0.08925843238830566, 0.3651585578918457, 0.27826857566833496, -0.1928240954875946, -0.23586499691009521, 0.6572069525718689, 0.4458313584327698, 0.32286661863327026, 0.0410461463034153, -0.17468798160552979, -0.46241337060928345, -0.7833991646766663, 0.22637124359607697, 0.141638845205307, 0.3288557529449463, 0.21662789583206177, 0.20819643139839172, 0.3061629831790924, 0.5779427886009216, -1.0149080753326416, -0.4507010877132416, -0.1448962688446045, -0.01930266246199608, 0.6687772274017334, 0.47241535782814026, 0.8239652514457703, -0.8773519992828369, -0.5154963731765747, 0.06226377934217453, -1.1053409576416016, 0.1752181500196457, 0.38132527470588684, -0.1822156310081482, -0.1900155395269394, 0.5912597179412842, -0.530024528503418, 0.5945505499839783, 0.3478643298149109, -0.5344401001930237, 0.4395744800567627, 0.0646044984459877, 0.017075026407837868, -0.7573217153549194, -0.1733023226261139, -0.15084044635295868, -0.28156840801239014, -0.4958403408527374, 0.3007752597332001, -0.6421420574188232, -0.4796101450920105, -0.4287514090538025, 0.11115004867315292, -0.6052799820899963, -0.5313203930854797, -0.0720275416970253, -0.18166685104370117, -0.23675766587257385, 0.3608419597148895, 0.00850899051874876, 0.5805496573448181, 0.8689237236976624, -0.8248302340507507, 0.28007978200912476, 0.3534676730632782, -0.07103898376226425, 0.70990389585495, -0.9221135377883911, -0.15876223146915436, -0.06560315936803818, 0.08165429532527924, -0.9546868801116943, -0.18576355278491974, 0.2553078532218933, 0.265002965927124, -0.14520911872386932, -0.1853466033935547, -0.3796535134315491, -0.4312446713447571, -0.034428346902132034, 0.5662006735801697, 0.547117292881012, -0.9312694668769836, 0.26308444142341614, 0.004238989669829607, -0.04959922656416893, -0.43279561400413513, -0.3640797436237335, -0.7391592264175415, -0.28572726249694824, -0.8997130990028381, -0.15799811482429504, -0.14834187924861908, -0.7990447878837585, 0.3019404113292694, -0.22241544723510742, -0.6305437088012695, 0.1490914225578308, 0.6280713677406311, -0.12014102935791016, -0.5559308528900146, 0.008569746278226376, 0.17338910698890686, -0.0785798579454422, -0.23580412566661835, -0.26729440689086914, 0.416215717792511, -0.39739862084388733, -0.5062426328659058, -0.3516458570957184, 0.45582178235054016, 0.5700469017028809, -0.0936274603009224, 0.39155319333076477, 0.41214436292648315, -0.5736141800880432, -0.19461731612682343, -0.08360130339860916, -0.18960173428058624, -0.5331013202667236, -0.10258449614048004, -0.7613149881362915, -1.1793031692504883, 0.9186221361160278, 0.2111390084028244, 0.32402172684669495, 0.7634335160255432, 0.3841094970703125, -0.3604733645915985, 0.697504460811615, 0.16692382097244263, -0.11169583350419998, 0.38291096687316895, -0.44324564933776855, 0.3536160886287689, -0.3489108383655548, -0.03603106737136841, -0.649408757686615, -0.609121561050415, -0.5403763055801392, 0.31248730421066284, 0.15127365291118622, 0.7681822776794434, -0.22910673916339874, 0.21658894419670105, -0.5254036784172058, 0.8566664457321167, 0.5547621250152588, -0.036051198840141296, 0.335310161113739, 0.15269356966018677, -0.19745680689811707, -0.17636781930923462, -0.41027578711509705, -0.022230593487620354, 0.8247974514961243, 0.1400304138660431, 0.7066690325737, 0.5066410899162292, 1.2322630882263184, 0.4394228160381317, 0.17817017436027527, -0.5005332827568054, 0.3970334231853485, -0.40723317861557007, -0.7790066599845886, -0.5967626571655273, -0.5805519819259644, -1.1402698755264282, 0.47007235884666443, -0.22050680220127106, -0.7381592988967896, 0.5148806571960449, 0.08684375137090683, -0.2581115961074829, 0.7170896530151367, -0.7009252905845642, 0.7703445553779602, 0.05269354209303856, -0.1836477518081665, -0.28016817569732666, -0.4300042390823364, 0.6496371626853943, 0.0991620197892189, -0.15718282759189606, 0.01539453025907278, 0.5639805197715759, 0.5795959234237671, -1.1807477474212646, 0.5399078130722046, -0.18402977287769318, -0.0914689376950264, 0.9734050631523132, 0.6756253838539124, 0.25025203824043274, 0.13153566420078278, 0.12641599774360657, -0.09445110708475113, -0.04524258151650429, -0.5034923553466797, -0.6805457472801208, 0.746191680431366, -1.0677570104599, -0.5057275891304016, -0.0922892615199089, -0.19327333569526672, 0.3982120156288147, 0.7162964344024658, 0.608595073223114, 0.8186511397361755, -0.17142640054225922, 0.22997930645942688, 0.4643661677837372, 0.6285886168479919, 0.6679770350456238, 0.15708808600902557, -0.2736855149269104, -0.4318242073059082, 1.0837825536727905, 0.4716188609600067, 0.2731006443500519, -0.03502858802676201, 0.40398621559143066, -0.3360966145992279, -0.560928463935852, -0.16082863509655, 0.2255992293357849, -0.7930530309677124, -0.0424141101539135, 0.03141861408948898, -0.5719712376594543, -0.22052694857120514, -0.4720507264137268, -0.29254159331321716, -0.844757616519928, -0.2431512475013733, 0.11190132796764374, -0.011255169287323952, 1.3471758365631104, -0.4946700632572174, -0.08078151196241379, -0.5687434673309326, 0.3514549136161804, 1.0259321928024292, 0.5888048410415649, 0.14786295592784882, -0.13301226496696472, -0.03608908876776695, -0.47590911388397217, -0.34648197889328003, -0.44129446148872375, -0.26992592215538025, 0.28682148456573486, 0.3948799669742584, 1.4230448007583618, -0.15403778851032257, 0.6642656922340393, -0.12536948919296265, 0.30067309737205505, 0.4651479721069336, -0.5601616501808167, 0.5081520676612854, -0.46133163571357727, -0.21336720883846283, 0.49742430448532104, 0.39681848883628845, -0.07895824313163757, -0.37602922320365906, -1.0145936012268066, -0.17724356055259705, 0.057087551802396774, 0.6812296509742737, -0.5344826579093933, -0.07266499847173691, 0.33159467577934265, 0.275204062461853, 0.0032977948430925608, -0.9353391528129578, -0.44392475485801697, -0.4143099784851074, 0.13422036170959473, 0.2570466995239258, -0.2513916790485382, -0.5832616686820984, -0.07479589432477951, -0.026228807866573334, 0.26904845237731934, 0.29102861881256104, 0.28449228405952454, -0.015211003832519054, -0.46399837732315063, 0.17470651865005493, 0.6467202305793762, 0.824088990688324, -0.3584095537662506, 0.4636835753917694, -0.048315927386283875, -0.28943490982055664, 0.33539095520973206, 0.054313722997903824, -0.07701647281646729, -0.30447012186050415, 0.5886679887771606, 0.14467908442020416, -0.13567861914634705, 0.1376708447933197, 0.4396865665912628, 0.4054983854293823, -0.35368502140045166, 0.05743607133626938, 0.38034823536872864, -0.20087599754333496, 0.21627919375896454, 0.05783906206488609, 0.06469123810529709, 0.3043757975101471, -0.46648263931274414, 0.3572726845741272, 0.13654379546642303, -0.5006290674209595, -0.5478904247283936, 0.5681505799293518, 0.26261264085769653, -0.35194432735443115, 1.0373659133911133, -0.43522000312805176, -0.3531172275543213, 0.5965117812156677, 0.7922278046607971, 0.7024790644645691, -0.21774065494537354, -0.019714906811714172, 0.3031262755393982, 0.17661044001579285, 0.06082523241639137, 0.30427899956703186, -0.25474050641059875, -0.6734068989753723, -0.016818271949887276, -0.21421784162521362, -0.2240607589483261, -0.17226389050483704, -0.5176775455474854, 0.19792017340660095, -1.1808977127075195, 0.09494082629680634, 0.02470582164824009, -0.12196750938892365, -0.5570886731147766, 0.2870216369628906, -0.32187700271606445, 0.34933868050575256, -0.974719226360321, 0.29838329553604126, 0.31995776295661926, -0.5246369242668152, -1.0201537609100342, -0.2990019917488098, 0.2824552655220032, -0.5254939794540405, 0.6307888031005859, -0.13046406209468842, -0.09857643395662308, -0.4247400164604187, -0.5206930041313171, -0.964512050151825, 1.051452875137329, 0.007175488863140345, -0.371232271194458, 0.3166217505931854, -0.07976530492305756, 0.455567330121994, -0.378178209066391, -0.1853819489479065, 0.23294934630393982, 0.40616482496261597, 0.12313205748796463, -0.7723190784454346, 0.12135433405637741, -0.1489560753107071, -0.3591880202293396, 0.728929340839386, -1.0318106412887573, 1.1744130849838257, -0.47749820351600647, -0.5079102516174316, -0.001571033732034266, 1.3143061399459839, 0.18042558431625366, 0.21392981708049774, 0.9078274369239807, 1.0777385234832764, 0.8506853580474854, -0.28509870171546936, 0.8810101747512817, -0.14599552750587463, 0.6014057397842407, 0.7451930642127991, -0.03870604187250137, 0.4441656470298767, 0.08323264867067337, -0.4958600401878357, 0.5969800353050232, 0.572022020816803, 0.0019617381040006876, 0.6476842761039734, -0.00006971313268877566, -0.23410959541797638, -0.16307823359966278, 0.1595388948917389, -0.7625455856323242, 0.3320787250995636, 0.1780235469341278, -0.4150882065296173, -0.36526280641555786, -0.543316125869751, 0.2099279761314392, -0.02589629963040352, -0.3317595422267914, 0.3699229657649994, 0.3073638677597046, -0.23494718968868256, 0.2546265125274658, -0.35196176171302795, 0.2457626610994339, -0.3895788788795471, -0.09961116313934326, -0.2266000658273697, -0.019837867468595505, -0.7533679604530334, -1.220215082168579, 0.3995220959186554, -0.4892115294933319, -0.14425547420978546, 0.18701769411563873, 0.9427554607391357, -0.06749022006988525, -0.3421958386898041, -0.025822781026363373, 0.4874408543109894, 0.38988882303237915, 0.6271926760673523, -0.42860692739486694, -0.19847139716148376, 0.022520996630191803, -0.19392526149749756, 0.022091377526521683, 0.6678999662399292, -0.06292599439620972, 0.6118491291999817, 0.562113344669342, 0.06400876492261887, 0.09330663084983826, 0.06500047445297241, 0.9159982800483704, -0.7083470821380615, -0.790553092956543, -0.6069530248641968, 0.03951336443424225, 0.011995729058980942, -0.6554349064826965, 0.8232544660568237, 0.5700121521949768, 0.3187394440174103, 0.1275150179862976, 0.5267911553382874, -0.2500684857368469, 0.31533047556877136, -0.45948001742362976, 0.6266189217567444, -0.24269193410873413, -0.1059756800532341, -0.5495466589927673, -1.2489911317825317, -0.27875086665153503, 0.7635164260864258, -0.19531260430812836, 0.08766559511423111, 1.0016361474990845, 0.3978978097438812, -0.5152482986450195, 0.04856931045651436, 0.057243410497903824, 0.10297957062721252, 0.3838072717189789, 0.3966771066188812, 0.7529141902923584, -0.034466564655303955, 0.6325774192810059, -0.47911620140075684, -0.06407079100608826, 0.13981804251670837, -0.46199384331703186, -0.8873509764671326, -0.5862594246864319, -0.3393459618091583, -0.7302114963531494, -0.07036733627319336, 0.3452111482620239, 0.8982823491096497, -0.7667413949966431, -0.26083460450172424, -0.3462994396686554, 0.8524102568626404, -0.45513367652893066, -0.2237246185541153, 0.744510293006897, 0.06427609920501709, -0.3646104335784912, 0.1907300055027008, 0.38200700283050537, 0.6421393156051636, -0.527860164642334, -0.3463296890258789, 0.2156786471605301, -0.22619906067848206, 0.47645676136016846, 0.9231595396995544, -0.48529142141342163, -0.3935534656047821, -0.493375301361084, -0.2090565264225006, 0.3317142724990845, 0.868033766746521, -0.17732807993888855, 0.42104098200798035, 0.9450031518936157, -0.011739291250705719, 0.4248183071613312, 0.021592797711491585, 0.3358698785305023, -0.4523645043373108, 0.5470989346504211, -0.059449512511491776, 0.6256784200668335, -0.15818198025226593, -0.34863561391830444, 0.8456452488899231, 0.4930267930030823, -0.4384486973285675, -0.5525571703910828, 0.5032460689544678, -0.9231626391410828, -0.04180101677775383, 0.8131212592124939, -0.22947600483894348, -0.2417871057987213, -0.2084256261587143, 0.18756058812141418, -0.29135867953300476, -0.030886400490999222, 0.682299792766571, 0.7812807559967041, -0.41014784574508667, 0.026493119075894356, 0.24168311059474945, 0.3070392906665802, 0.2234397679567337, -0.7928493618965149, -0.5055252909660339, 0.3794126808643341, 0.5899363160133362, 0.3153296411037445, 0.7362655401229858, -0.49100399017333984, 0.4923706352710724, 0.2606871426105499, -0.2737920582294464, -0.058666858822107315, -0.5821025967597961, -0.0531313382089138, 0.7227851152420044, 0.32421818375587463, -0.24312666058540344 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04889v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04889v1
Ethos and Pathos in Online Group Discussions: Corpora for Polarisation Issues in Social Media
2024-04-07T09:10:47
2024-04-07T09:10:47
Ewelina Gajewska, Katarzyna Budzynska, Barbara Konat, Marcin Koszowy, Konrad Kiljan, Maciej Uberna, He Zhang
cs.CL
cs.CL
Growing polarisation in society caught the attention of the scientific community as well as news media, which devote special issues to this phenomenon. At the same time, digitalisation of social interactions requires to revise concepts from social science regarding establishment of trust, which is a key feature of all human interactions, and group polarisation, as well as new computational tools to process large quantities of available data. Existing methods seem insufficient to tackle the problem fully, thus, we propose to approach the problem by investigating rhetorical strategies employed by individuals in polarising discussions online. To this end, we develop multi-topic and multi-platform corpora with manual annotation of appeals to ethos and pathos, two modes of persuasion in Aristotelian rhetoric. It can be employed for training language models to advance the study of communication strategies online on a large scale. With the use of computational methods, our corpora allows an investigation of recurring patterns in polarising exchanges across topics of discussion and media platforms, and conduct both quantitative and qualitative analyses of language structures leading to and engaged in polarisation.
[ -0.7190351486206055, -0.7830166816711426, 0.5554933547973633, 0.20244868099689484, -0.48757824301719666, 0.5096774697303772, -0.41537564992904663, -0.36563804745674133, 0.8290148973464966, 0.291512131690979, -0.3549760580062866, -0.39577046036720276, -1.0403207540512085, 0.24711893498897552, -0.14889805018901825, 1.0112552642822266, -0.005803728476166725, 0.6075940132141113, -0.0009329119930043817, -0.5701159834861755, -0.012074338272213936, -0.9167661666870117, -0.9910413026809692, -0.04642589017748833, 0.665255069732666, 0.29737338423728943, 0.6019368767738342, 0.13457752764225006, 0.3857147693634033, 0.3386605978012085, -0.3450339436531067, -0.1178818792104721, -0.6943173408508301, 0.5124183297157288, -0.2626223862171173, -0.46761584281921387, -0.1749265491962433, 0.3023548126220703, 0.5534976720809937, 0.7413502335548401, -0.12391328811645508, 0.12483633309602737, -0.0009339411044493318, 0.6111133098602295, -0.2861352562904358, 0.017789943143725395, -0.6613276600837708, 0.17209100723266602, -0.07269387692213058, -0.7506768107414246, -0.19562454521656036, -0.7714203596115112, 0.1151307225227356, -0.8241795301437378, 0.18422441184520721, 0.27875635027885437, 0.32757675647735596, -0.18007968366146088, -0.31073692440986633, -0.9030537605285645, -0.8282148838043213, 0.700289249420166, -0.2549608647823334, 0.09502434730529785, 0.5244057774543762, 0.22162865102291107, 0.09636185318231583, -0.5229116678237915, -0.42303261160850525, 0.18412674963474274, 0.2001970410346985, -0.046918291598558426, -0.2623575031757355, -0.10425544530153275, 0.05474985018372536, 0.06599531322717667, -0.18714359402656555, -0.2869266867637634, -0.8792434334754944, -0.1938541978597641, 0.4340508282184601, -0.18034131824970245, 0.2920988202095032, -0.1077198013663292, 0.042418453842401505, -0.0756743922829628, -0.6829001903533936, -0.020786849781870842, 0.8107814788818359, 0.19433531165122986, 0.01837700605392456, 0.5773922801017761, 0.1028345376253128, 0.3013046681880951, 0.5237276554107666, 0.119229756295681, -0.11060628294944763, -0.31281790137290955, 0.17886382341384888, 0.42344871163368225, 0.632928192615509, 0.5174023509025574, 0.2751835286617279, 0.05925281345844269, 0.3634571433067322, 0.5097488164901733, 0.1556137651205063, -0.7369942665100098, -0.06394878774881363, 0.40201815962791443, -0.48154565691947937, -0.6016865968704224, -0.0006909870426170528, -1.0122129917144775, -0.6605856418609619, -0.20546512305736542, -0.044421304017305374, -0.20188044011592865, -0.40495917201042175, 0.05454963818192482, -0.40939146280288696, 0.12898452579975128, 0.3411005735397339, -0.6920410394668579, 0.389280766248703, 0.8953187465667725, 0.8546702265739441, 0.11136282980442047, -0.08577997982501984, -0.4640600085258484, 0.14294952154159546, -0.2617122232913971, 0.8231551647186279, -0.7958605885505676, -0.4339119493961334, 0.19435200095176697, -0.1613311469554901, 0.0732775330543518, -0.08008740097284317, 0.7204552888870239, -0.6020752787590027, 0.9153974652290344, -0.3845483958721161, -0.4752524793148041, 0.021113891154527664, 0.35972535610198975, -0.5019416809082031, 0.7103065848350525, -0.3038650453090668, -0.9777543544769287, 0.1246834546327591, -0.6892500519752502, -0.354990154504776, -0.2160695642232895, -0.43697482347488403, -0.13510870933532715, 0.08016230911016464, -0.09813875705003738, 0.4528646469116211, -0.38766589760780334, 0.4275510609149933, -0.5477755069732666, 0.0058422754518687725, 0.400814414024353, 0.07948091626167297, 0.8815845847129822, 0.27078694105148315, -0.714876651763916, 0.42494845390319824, -0.2799433767795563, -0.26653552055358887, 0.10148318856954575, 0.14030566811561584, -0.8521144986152649, 0.3187434673309326, -0.049878742545843124, 0.2943584620952606, 0.01016775332391262, -0.47908806800842285, 0.045389555394649506, -0.39702537655830383, 1.0822149515151978, 0.8738580942153931, 0.05279819294810295, 0.47898033261299133, -0.17000965774059296, 0.4066613018512726, -0.02766544744372368, 0.5143579244613647, 0.37047213315963745, -0.8910977244377136, -0.685341477394104, 0.026398448273539543, -0.17858171463012695, 0.25649452209472656, -0.6461906433105469, -0.07606697082519531, -0.19686754047870636, -0.30806607007980347, -0.5881322622299194, 0.08731193840503693, 0.30081212520599365, 0.09882625937461853, 0.16337545216083527, -0.2648422122001648, -0.4805334508419037, -0.8165456652641296, -0.17004573345184326, -0.5325878858566284, 0.04350700229406357, 0.18612472712993622, 0.15336643159389496, 0.1826486438512802, 0.854732096195221, -0.3054024577140808, -0.03636431321501732, -0.38017433881759644, 0.7312104105949402, -0.40408357977867126, -0.11048270761966705, 0.35906288027763367, -1.0698051452636719, -0.7343159317970276, -0.13384860754013062, -0.5562465190887451, -0.06499087810516357, 0.1712300032377243, -0.003813365241512656, 0.1138237863779068, 0.4731222987174988, -0.4216640293598175, -0.05999166890978813, 0.6266759634017944, -0.5063517689704895, 0.14840646088123322, 0.20930305123329163, 0.6971536874771118, -1.419657826423645, -0.19120362401008606, 0.120674267411232, -0.15950752794742584, -0.7551193833351135, 0.060802582651376724, -0.41861456632614136, -0.2627972662448883, -0.6673179268836975, 0.19447676837444305, -0.4795822203159332, 0.17278705537319183, -0.23677285015583038, 0.6675307154655457, 0.054442912340164185, 0.22904804348945618, 0.2475595772266388, 0.521592915058136, 0.7314479947090149, -0.37034982442855835, 0.2121226042509079, 0.38942834734916687, 0.17083950340747833, 0.9170637130737305, -0.6324747204780579, 0.3255835175514221, -0.36049705743789673, 0.3709183633327484, -0.8871648907661438, -0.18270082771778107, 0.6641367077827454, -0.5143423676490784, 0.00023159879492595792, -0.2983632981777191, -0.03744053468108177, -0.1378781795501709, -0.855244517326355, 0.5552541017532349, 0.14592234790325165, -0.1356765776872635, 0.6020892858505249, 0.9366181492805481, -0.6638083457946777, -0.44131067395210266, -0.18430480360984802, 0.35804373025894165, -0.7050878405570984, -0.7868098616600037, 0.23488907516002655, -0.07387538254261017, -0.8444016575813293, -0.260881632566452, 0.3378106355667114, 0.030838923528790474, -0.1669912040233612, 0.22906199097633362, 0.17796623706817627, 0.037057921290397644, -0.02659645490348339, 0.12045673280954361, 0.06225568801164627, 0.35445305705070496, -0.1902737319469452, 0.8025404214859009, -0.4248136281967163, -0.13405176997184753, -0.3018134534358978, 0.7084872126579285, 0.6165191531181335, 0.07201650738716125, 0.9725359082221985, 0.30115798115730286, -0.2453470081090927, -0.057090215384960175, -0.6978556513786316, -0.37104037404060364, -0.4396362602710724, -0.03965069726109505, -0.05208994448184967, -0.9938445687294006, 0.6149436235427856, -0.301065057516098, -0.2146308869123459, 0.49302637577056885, 0.5165919661521912, -0.22847220301628113, 0.7044381499290466, 0.5909964442253113, -0.08681833744049072, 0.10274767875671387, 0.008878188207745552, 0.3738589584827423, -0.5180579423904419, -0.15377648174762726, -0.6090980768203735, -0.07553388923406601, -0.6202070116996765, -0.5157438516616821, 0.3514753580093384, -0.028623459860682487, 0.2093045711517334, 0.3783682584762573, -0.7418517470359802, 0.1585782766342163, 0.046701155602931976, 0.02487185224890709, 0.43053701519966125, 0.1410861760377884, 0.128921777009964, -0.22149546444416046, -0.6396703720092773, -0.7648242712020874, 1.057755470275879, 0.2962356209754944, 0.3716946542263031, 0.1811114400625229, 0.4077076017856598, 0.48806947469711304, 0.6294693946838379, -0.7652902603149414, 0.7078028917312622, 0.46862998604774475, -0.8110489845275879, -0.23940633237361908, -0.4567786753177643, -0.8754794597625732, 0.08408021926879883, -0.27777254581451416, -0.5225484371185303, 0.306831032037735, 0.08717413246631622, -0.16649794578552246, 0.4705948531627655, -0.1800500899553299, 0.785174548625946, -0.24071533977985382, -0.46373307704925537, -0.5469813346862793, -0.8881678581237793, 0.06599646061658859, 0.05651681870222092, 0.6189382076263428, 0.11054849624633789, 0.09372765570878983, 1.0822672843933105, 0.02915332466363907, 1.044380784034729, 0.13140827417373657, -0.13346800208091736, 0.5014870762825012, -0.23714695870876312, 0.3657715320587158, -0.07723569869995117, 0.08190414309501648, 0.4140733480453491, 0.20479682087898254, -0.106155626475811, -0.20597951114177704, 0.7078467607498169, -0.8666749000549316, -0.5407958626747131, -0.5976108312606812, -0.10718560963869095, -0.16346916556358337, -0.22223621606826782, 0.32242900133132935, 0.2714102566242218, -0.7383264303207397, 0.17004713416099548, 0.9474272131919861, -0.08174702525138855, 0.21017320454120636, 0.16014990210533142, -0.16717222332954407, -0.833168089389801, 0.9306507110595703, -0.15092290937900543, 0.5016611814498901, 0.028427250683307648, 0.38689863681793213, -0.11426448076963425, -0.12476006150245667, -0.3219696283340454, 0.0832095667719841, -0.9612956047058105, 0.27872011065483093, -0.6364930868148804, 0.22059793770313263, -0.5611816048622131, -0.371663361787796, -0.32407522201538086, -0.7999839186668396, -0.13861456513404846, 0.005343629512935877, 0.35289132595062256, 0.904981255531311, -0.022481275722384453, 0.3029889166355133, -0.2732284665107727, 0.09647524356842041, 0.12261296808719635, 0.0347355417907238, -0.2854628562927246, -0.16670288145542145, 0.18636946380138397, -0.07531142979860306, -0.4818761348724365, -1.3848953247070312, 0.08577839285135269, 0.00771196698769927, 0.31759190559387207, 0.6189620494842529, 0.007149511482566595, 0.12797312438488007, -0.43884551525115967, 0.6264987587928772, 0.4128713607788086, -0.7421899437904358, 0.5631247758865356, -0.708764910697937, -0.5320931077003479, 0.748060405254364, 1.0787068605422974, -0.7278483510017395, -0.728692352771759, -0.7874380350112915, -0.769311249256134, 0.31663161516189575, 0.3967452943325043, -0.12294985353946686, -0.10700943320989609, 0.09836111962795258, 0.2961954176425934, 0.5341042876243591, -0.8121305704116821, -0.39782413840293884, -0.3189737796783447, -0.0184932854026556, 0.024701764807105064, -0.22231870889663696, -0.953295886516571, -0.2979748249053955, 0.69508296251297, -0.0003815850941464305, 0.25079503655433655, 0.18414273858070374, 0.18555952608585358, -0.43252265453338623, 0.5429561734199524, 0.6201041340827942, 0.8813326954841614, -0.1077672466635704, 0.27288785576820374, -0.1625661551952362, -0.4843423664569855, 0.1840871274471283, 0.01144813559949398, -0.3784328103065491, 0.1086525097489357, -0.16453817486763, 0.5229698419570923, 0.24052129685878754, -0.08026778697967529, 0.45256468653678894, -0.2119726538658142, -0.33554819226264954, -0.5009608268737793, -0.5098606944084167, 0.3305612802505493, 0.025256188586354256, 0.45753371715545654, 0.11738932132720947, 0.05184086784720421, -1.152030110359192, -0.05888839438557625, 0.584394633769989, -0.33477258682250977, -0.38252660632133484, 0.6023212671279907, 0.4421409070491791, -0.5602491497993469, -0.05714154243469238, -0.3033686578273773, -0.8925722241401672, 0.3546235263347626, 0.18088701367378235, 0.8981465697288513, -0.18486730754375458, 0.7604658007621765, 0.1654236763715744, 0.404340922832489, -0.06708231568336487, 0.1586408168077469, -0.0689164474606514, -0.5775193572044373, -0.11941847950220108, -0.45698755979537964, -0.903920590877533, -0.16159051656723022, -0.4290049374103546, 0.2419935017824173, -0.5931785702705383, -0.5131563544273376, 0.11361981183290482, -0.15076550841331482, -0.17396055161952972, -0.32473406195640564, 0.2707863450050354, 0.22075290977954865, -1.0065174102783203, 0.43217816948890686, 0.7547727823257446, -0.31811341643333435, -0.33834439516067505, 0.0021263109520077705, 0.1799069046974182, -0.19183331727981567, 0.5569933652877808, 0.058909546583890915, -0.46405863761901855, -0.14525166153907776, -0.5862096548080444, -0.6066380143165588, 0.7590681910514832, 0.2260231226682663, -0.21471472084522247, 0.20789356529712677, 0.5863722562789917, 0.5243605375289917, -0.42336007952690125, 0.3412640690803528, -0.07873928546905518, 0.6181663870811462, 0.08122837543487549, -0.7314613461494446, 0.24044913053512573, -0.365731418132782, -0.4071551561355591, 0.020264064893126488, -0.8981077075004578, 0.7336775660514832, 0.2646850347518921, -0.23906490206718445, -0.392621248960495, 0.569877028465271, 0.0905124843120575, 0.5351967811584473, 0.41940683126449585, 0.17321045696735382, 0.6108952164649963, -0.04497629031538963, 0.7079145312309265, -0.8195816874504089, 0.1980539858341217, 0.6805932521820068, -0.4373263418674469, 0.6837117671966553, 0.775929868221283, 0.013308783993124962, 0.49734991788864136, 0.5590802431106567, 0.42275068163871765, 0.38388898968696594, 0.29788342118263245, -0.4340428411960602, -0.06521551311016083, -0.08267664909362793, -0.44194960594177246, 0.07558221369981766, 0.4231950044631958, -0.24299290776252747, 0.02442062832415104, 0.21073101460933685, 0.1061704009771347, 0.3463839590549469, -0.4169267416000366, 0.5885528326034546, 0.2026282250881195, -0.843187689781189, 0.026693426072597504, 0.2729470133781433, 0.70404052734375, -0.6348029375076294, 0.15763594210147858, 0.02093132585287094, -0.13697753846645355, -0.04848543554544449, -0.4891050457954407, 0.44753068685531616, -0.13810616731643677, 0.23600904643535614, -0.45449283719062805, 0.8851954936981201, -0.22791777551174164, -0.5279685258865356, 0.48374953866004944, 0.47988760471343994, 0.1957058310508728, -0.023271964862942696, -0.6051327586174011, 0.2707858085632324, -0.39695480465888977, -0.21271300315856934, 0.40718600153923035, 0.35098206996917725, -0.0782334953546524, 0.6013899445533752, 0.526643693447113, 0.11870469897985458, 0.09683261811733246, 0.24373513460159302, 1.1937193870544434, -0.3091902732849121, -0.48058462142944336, -0.723888099193573, 0.14314471185207367, -0.5298309326171875, -0.5439703464508057, 0.9740274548530579, 0.4771935045719147, 0.7449604272842407, 0.15404798090457916, 0.6308448910713196, -0.33325207233428955, 0.17678606510162354, -0.2278745174407959, 0.8196819424629211, -0.21071721613407135, 0.13245894014835358, -0.5081797242164612, -0.8622038960456848, 0.04042458534240723, 0.7336176037788391, -0.6835797429084778, -0.31950053572654724, 0.9170265793800354, 0.5095933079719543, -0.11985638737678528, 0.762985110282898, -0.2266046404838562, 0.3602984845638275, 0.14068366587162018, 0.17432598769664764, 1.0140705108642578, -0.18445613980293274, 0.5802198648452759, -0.2497580498456955, -0.4663333594799042, 0.0222147386521101, -0.7369422316551208, -1.236322045326233, -0.7418269515037537, -0.4881502389907837, -0.5811033844947815, 0.40105780959129333, 1.0128107070922852, 0.2024649679660797, -0.8298423290252686, -0.49899619817733765, -0.15059995651245117, 0.0712004005908966, -0.005580744240432978, -0.1908947378396988, 0.12457051873207092, 0.07714527100324631, -0.45166102051734924, 0.2733868360519409, 0.44743257761001587, -0.494856059551239, -0.8628485202789307, -0.06093159690499306, -0.3714059889316559, 0.3045363426208496, 0.7441326975822449, 0.40513795614242554, -0.4821951389312744, -0.22986353933811188, 0.07278260588645935, 0.0332990400493145, 0.2910306453704834, 1.129575490951538, -0.21006539463996887, 0.10055260360240936, 0.4340197741985321, 0.25089433789253235, 0.48456841707229614, 0.10988451540470123, 0.5631107687950134, -0.2183048129081726, 0.2198166698217392, 0.5418722629547119, 0.19391104578971863, 0.659269392490387, -0.2863679528236389, 0.3165498375892639, 0.49874958395957947, -0.4204288423061371, -0.6525747179985046, 0.0690668448805809, -1.0104986429214478, -0.23532967269420624, 1.2464591264724731, 0.15531481802463531, -0.17070701718330383, -0.439828485250473, -0.2768634557723999, 0.24927909672260284, -0.42845073342323303, 1.1953115463256836, 0.9074593186378479, 0.0906069278717041, 0.13599736988544464, -0.5332930088043213, 0.5899888277053833, 0.4466068148612976, -0.7956416606903076, -0.06355994194746017, 0.4538235366344452, 0.2956501543521881, 0.5945828557014465, 0.9125828146934509, -0.13973809778690338, -0.15620432794094086, -0.19382339715957642, -0.17432688176631927, 0.29190710186958313, -0.4292125403881073, 0.07249170541763306, 0.715059757232666, -0.24475739896297455, 0.41539111733436584 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04850v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04850v1
Lucky 52: How Many Languages Are Needed to Instruction Fine-Tune Large Language Models?
2024-04-07T07:44:33
2024-04-07T07:44:33
Shaoxiong Ji, Pinzhen Chen
cs.CL
cs.CL
Fine-tuning large language models for multilingual downstream tasks requires a diverse set of languages to capture the nuances and structures of different linguistic contexts effectively. While the specific number varies depending on the desired scope and target languages, we argue that the number of languages, language exposure, and similarity that incorporate the selection of languages for fine-tuning are some important aspects to examine. By fine-tuning large multilingual models on 1 to 52 languages, this paper answers one question: How many languages are needed in instruction fine-tuning for multilingual tasks? We investigate how multilingual instruction fine-tuned models behave on multilingual benchmarks with an increasing number of languages and discuss our findings from the perspective of language exposure and similarity.
[ -0.5131992101669312, -0.2971513867378235, 0.2750305235385895, 0.27448004484176636, -0.08170247822999954, -0.08336270600557327, -0.5136730670928955, -0.5050546526908875, -0.3675408959388733, 0.5809330344200134, -0.7976146340370178, -0.29360231757164, -0.5274970531463623, 0.22602277994155884, -0.01747101917862892, 1.2098994255065918, 0.14596574008464813, 0.2625565826892853, 0.14327001571655273, -0.11642362177371979, -0.6590017080307007, -0.25501611828804016, -0.4203643798828125, -0.022002747282385826, 0.4121524393558502, 0.9584768414497375, 0.7097252607345581, 0.6172860264778137, 0.717979371547699, 0.3705417215824127, 0.2464214712381363, 0.35023626685142517, -0.5626519918441772, -0.15787893533706665, -0.3743109703063965, -0.9918763041496277, -0.3996943235397339, -0.10714973509311676, 0.7429148554801941, 0.8746753931045532, 0.18483874201774597, 0.5434993505477905, 0.056093327701091766, 0.7141743898391724, -0.832687258720398, 0.1903792768716812, -0.45672088861465454, 0.022712906822562218, -0.38100966811180115, -0.08970661461353302, -0.3800188899040222, -0.35994911193847656, 0.009233543649315834, -0.6783795952796936, 0.2624695301055908, -0.21021291613578796, 0.3874381184577942, 0.28161585330963135, -0.47062453627586365, -0.19164395332336426, -0.5099056363105774, 1.2187072038650513, -0.6751478910446167, 0.37161964178085327, 0.6025589108467102, 0.25987347960472107, 0.10269703716039658, -0.32325679063796997, -0.26219257712364197, 0.06899809837341309, 0.23731303215026855, -0.13333164155483246, 0.3119843304157257, -0.024047885090112686, 0.25414901971817017, 0.3626631200313568, -0.30550724267959595, 0.47732123732566833, -0.4446772634983063, -0.07037226110696793, 0.7618088722229004, 0.36887264251708984, 0.23170866072177887, 0.2376294732093811, 0.08020947873592377, -0.3625543713569641, -0.6038079261779785, -0.05850936844944954, 0.7187600135803223, 0.4831828773021698, -0.47165340185165405, 0.34577012062072754, -0.4130953252315521, 1.0368754863739014, -0.04245196655392647, -0.30691567063331604, -0.05367184802889824, -0.6726246476173401, -0.1743387132883072, 0.08080514520406723, 0.6114296317100525, 0.2927159368991852, 0.8618478178977966, -0.21557508409023285, 0.05292607471346855, -0.24027252197265625, 0.23053434491157532, -0.7888385057449341, -0.070180743932724, 0.09962915629148483, -0.21911406517028809, -0.005811011418700218, 0.0760684683918953, -0.6729127168655396, -0.1004975214600563, -0.36052197217941284, 0.17972509562969208, -0.5807241201400757, -0.14134247601032257, 0.4244639277458191, -0.25990810990333557, 0.3044833540916443, 0.2256399691104889, -1.2678157091140747, 0.18064215779304504, 1.018486738204956, 0.21928896009922028, 0.0353950560092926, -0.9550767540931702, -0.5812310576438904, -0.025036251172423363, -0.6477578282356262, 0.5836820602416992, -0.9106886982917786, -0.10331550985574722, 0.10950353741645813, 0.49650663137435913, -0.17950570583343506, -0.4199742376804352, 0.4676538109779358, -0.44357141852378845, 0.024231208488345146, -0.5382506847381592, -0.6175886392593384, -0.4768933653831482, 0.08631209284067154, -0.710261344909668, 0.5345118641853333, -0.034121137112379074, -0.3975766897201538, 0.3631087839603424, -0.4142211377620697, -0.6967586278915405, 0.14346948266029358, 0.2107774019241333, -0.05598372220993042, 0.49404504895210266, -0.1904086470603943, 0.5622878670692444, -0.22493906319141388, 0.02215173840522766, -0.32893890142440796, -0.6043124198913574, 0.25602787733078003, -0.7180543541908264, 0.8193636536598206, 0.328256756067276, -0.3746534585952759, -0.15277506411075592, -0.772604763507843, 0.35939016938209534, -0.3259948790073395, -0.613926112651825, -0.44178393483161926, -0.09888336062431335, 0.032449908554553986, 0.214304119348526, 0.48019805550575256, -0.28982600569725037, 0.19309265911579132, -0.4314091205596924, 0.2013002187013626, 0.538400411605835, -0.2794874310493469, 0.46765390038490295, -0.19880492985248566, 0.6541100144386292, 0.06683987379074097, 0.0316460095345974, -0.47640493512153625, -0.4481595754623413, -0.7648578882217407, -0.08373619616031647, 0.4807130694389343, 0.5873198509216309, -0.4347469210624695, 0.10715074092149734, -0.19582493603229523, -0.41506609320640564, -0.9003342986106873, 0.46480226516723633, 0.8728088736534119, -0.41400277614593506, 0.16801683604717255, -0.39666947722435, -0.30275240540504456, -0.9014660716056824, -0.3974515497684479, 0.4781707525253296, 0.28486135601997375, 0.181560680270195, 0.30199021100997925, 0.037219561636447906, 0.27757585048675537, -0.47469407320022583, -0.19368168711662292, -0.11134307086467743, 0.08872301131486893, 0.1783456802368164, 0.38469281792640686, 0.8322839736938477, -0.7777634263038635, -0.8067278265953064, 0.34514132142066956, -0.5883603692054749, 0.37750381231307983, 0.01796199381351471, -0.06998144835233688, 0.3795877993106842, 0.35828953981399536, -0.5276972651481628, -0.04331263527274132, 0.6390931010246277, -0.03404206037521362, 0.3222571313381195, -0.529146134853363, 0.3120530843734741, -0.922804057598114, -0.09756536036729813, 0.020732220262289047, -0.03553030639886856, -0.5346804261207581, 0.6384387016296387, 0.2393704205751419, -0.14913618564605713, -0.5784875154495239, 0.4722796678543091, -0.8155232071876526, 0.03507886081933975, -0.3904140889644623, -0.11672940105199814, -0.08876904100179672, 0.36275431513786316, -0.18782265484333038, 0.5804358720779419, 0.8435682654380798, -0.6329461932182312, 0.3526611328125, -0.08724374324083328, -0.5864866971969604, 0.45152950286865234, -0.211107537150383, 0.1620330512523651, 0.03286301717162132, -0.019378885626792908, -0.7315270304679871, -0.5163304209709167, -0.19769740104675293, -0.0025436009746044874, 0.6451895236968994, 0.0012987873051315546, -0.39114952087402344, -0.2176414132118225, -0.3096960186958313, 0.4164700508117676, 0.12374961376190186, -0.279570072889328, 0.12204854190349579, 0.3405590057373047, -0.14600230753421783, -0.923517644405365, -0.6089194416999817, -0.028002772480249405, -0.21485941112041473, -0.2812853455543518, 0.12694019079208374, -0.2810443639755249, -0.23060065507888794, -0.11616138368844986, -0.016308443620800972, -0.2093338668346405, 0.23403942584991455, 0.2608354389667511, -0.13208438456058502, -0.370233952999115, 0.15234367549419403, 0.1716199368238449, -0.0959862619638443, 0.0034177438355982304, -0.1948888897895813, 0.4778089225292206, -0.30376285314559937, -0.44078853726387024, -0.22499996423721313, 0.8246626257896423, 0.7565036416053772, -0.602285623550415, 0.8349102735519409, 0.6744171977043152, -0.32535168528556824, -0.2982269525527954, -0.402992844581604, -0.13086168467998505, -0.482637494802475, 0.7369818687438965, -0.7102267742156982, -0.8004807829856873, 0.42318740487098694, 0.19444318115711212, 0.07242362201213837, 0.45632269978523254, 0.8555101156234741, 0.2841419577598572, 1.0155566930770874, 0.8947455286979675, -0.35514363646507263, 0.38947418332099915, 0.03896947577595711, 0.23863328993320465, -0.10499732941389084, -0.015262093394994736, -0.696263313293457, -0.3153645992279053, -0.9994228482246399, -0.4338202476501465, 0.008143260143697262, 0.026867499575018883, -0.18189111351966858, 0.27116450667381287, -0.38620468974113464, 1.0015321969985962, 0.8894523978233337, 0.07988851517438889, 0.15198342502117157, 0.020514318719506264, -0.06392812728881836, -0.023689523339271545, -0.7401312589645386, -0.24222218990325928, 0.9373752474784851, 0.12538117170333862, 0.8869539499282837, 0.37711745500564575, 0.6459053754806519, -0.28186124563217163, -0.03829468414187431, -0.7009456157684326, 0.46012723445892334, -0.8332797884941101, -1.0183818340301514, -0.3649614751338959, -0.19564621150493622, -0.6703776121139526, -0.209830179810524, 0.01709834858775139, -0.4207530617713928, 0.11963900923728943, 0.07316514849662781, -0.5536967515945435, -0.11668741703033447, -1.085107684135437, 1.129086971282959, -0.3584076762199402, -0.3624665439128876, -0.7449496388435364, -0.830670952796936, 0.4347606897354126, -0.28989657759666443, 0.27691230177879333, 0.035052407532930374, 0.3533373475074768, 0.4407024085521698, 0.10896278917789459, 1.1444472074508667, 0.15421010553836823, -0.29131197929382324, 0.11383846402168274, 0.00785775575786829, 0.40647608041763306, -0.17828457057476044, -0.09451159089803696, 0.008009239099919796, 0.1999945044517517, -0.3692369759082794, -0.17522667348384857, 1.04404616355896, -0.863998293876648, -0.5412987470626831, -0.12777985632419586, -0.8579730987548828, -0.12415077537298203, 0.33700770139694214, 0.31504714488983154, 0.5208350419998169, 0.0355280302464962, 0.2120356559753418, 0.7150183916091919, -0.5016502737998962, 0.6707430481910706, 0.7356545925140381, 0.1585433930158615, 0.16118305921554565, 1.3830013275146484, 0.31644347310066223, 0.47831499576568604, 0.6264991760253906, -0.12361267954111099, 0.008212713524699211, -0.24639466404914856, -0.43246856331825256, 0.4322717785835266, -0.837722897529602, -0.24360525608062744, -0.5144840478897095, -0.06904013454914093, -0.33537057042121887, 0.050584252923727036, -0.5989915132522583, -0.41439852118492126, -0.4258853495121002, 0.18134868144989014, 0.4126049280166626, 0.5953262448310852, -0.12851671874523163, 0.07790099084377289, -1.1741480827331543, 0.4365132451057434, 0.5291630029678345, 0.6393214464187622, -0.058857712894678116, -0.6094690561294556, -0.74803227186203, 0.3537490665912628, -0.3092707395553589, -0.692660927772522, 0.11557292193174362, 0.8300488591194153, 0.6791202425956726, 0.36488309502601624, 0.03333220258355141, 0.8144703507423401, -1.0305501222610474, 0.42247799038887024, -0.12465614825487137, -0.813939094543457, 0.24399255216121674, -0.3529913127422333, 0.4716179668903351, 0.6149880886077881, 0.8117278218269348, -0.4392644166946411, -0.4069593846797943, -0.44686004519462585, -0.4709620177745819, 0.8199433088302612, -0.6135950684547424, 0.5166458487510681, -0.05529818311333656, -0.01623714528977871, 0.2907489240169525, 0.1507672816514969, -0.38322213292121887, -0.2178059220314026, -0.07442678511142731, -0.25721967220306396, -0.1822310835123062, -0.2416152060031891, -0.2808721363544464, -0.012611806392669678, 0.3275052011013031, -0.35174641013145447, 0.1304694563150406, -0.6337271332740784, 0.0026263005565851927, -0.34171262383461, 0.5109347105026245, 0.9605498909950256, 0.7795411944389343, -0.10404416173696518, 0.0371733196079731, 0.23247496783733368, -0.42394930124282837, -0.10911042243242264, 0.08441182971000671, 0.39250707626342773, -0.26376405358314514, 0.3790503442287445, 1.021749496459961, 0.5608940124511719, -0.6863850951194763, 0.1611480414867401, 0.0977562889456749, 0.1792954057455063, 0.12518206238746643, 0.6054193377494812, 0.3300226926803589, 0.18420566618442535, 0.17046749591827393, 0.029412731528282166, 0.12159829586744308, -0.7404710054397583, 0.0951174646615982, 0.5582566857337952, -0.42913222312927246, -0.49705398082733154, 0.4194789230823517, 0.10127980262041092, -0.4129932224750519, 0.6065666079521179, -0.23348687589168549, -0.4062023162841797, 0.7559265494346619, 0.482257604598999, 0.56948322057724, -0.5849016904830933, 0.15503835678100586, 0.41409677267074585, 0.31168994307518005, -0.44730737805366516, 0.18209441006183624, 0.16026680171489716, -0.6484498381614685, -0.851707935333252, -0.7329928874969482, -0.6198675632476807, -0.22130826115608215, -0.7433189749717712, 0.3751133680343628, 0.12696368992328644, 0.09818299114704132, 0.3584757447242737, 0.02304116077721119, -0.942857027053833, 0.31860530376434326, 0.4441780745983124, 0.8926308751106262, -1.0331108570098877, 1.0229955911636353, 0.7786192297935486, 0.005096883047372103, -1.0706301927566528, -0.33010414242744446, 0.0055210222490131855, -0.7410328984260559, 0.5262620449066162, 0.27315473556518555, 0.05519109591841698, 0.21340513229370117, -0.4087912142276764, -0.5492215752601624, 0.37128204107284546, 0.7245155572891235, -0.830809473991394, 0.052348945289850235, 0.21320633590221405, 0.5307918190956116, -0.33560943603515625, 0.10008599609136581, 0.6009507179260254, 0.35634133219718933, -0.3376958966255188, -1.2707581520080566, -0.18014198541641235, -0.13784416019916534, -0.26858147978782654, 0.23502643406391144, -0.7430733442306519, 0.8455880284309387, -0.590078592300415, 0.09293315559625626, -0.09757726639509201, 0.1608479619026184, 0.3448856472969055, 0.05268431082367897, 0.03809273615479469, 0.3761710226535797, 0.47615790367126465, 0.10730113834142685, 1.3131656646728516, -0.5682833790779114, 0.3615966737270355, 1.0757557153701782, -0.09609685093164444, 0.8316153883934021, 0.21521593630313873, -0.294380247592926, 0.004366119857877493, 0.796421468257904, 0.1140882596373558, 0.6874025464057922, -0.018977142870426178, -0.20631927251815796, -0.46275269985198975, -0.16928733885288239, -0.5050738453865051, 0.6795000433921814, 0.33329564332962036, -0.12996266782283783, -0.17378532886505127, 0.15842020511627197, 0.0431574285030365, -0.18408285081386566, -0.32905375957489014, 0.4970140755176544, 0.19534362852573395, -1.1656116247177124, 0.5716754794120789, 0.11209281533956528, 0.46722033619880676, -0.5125858783721924, -0.1157425194978714, -0.4225471615791321, 0.49245592951774597, -0.06512947380542755, -0.8504794836044312, 0.14198680222034454, -0.07381889224052429, -0.33739998936653137, -0.1796533167362213, 0.39045748114585876, -0.6512049436569214, -0.7420473694801331, 0.13524551689624786, 0.3347574770450592, 0.3207826316356659, 0.0016378565924242139, -0.46540260314941406, 0.09083446860313416, 0.14165934920310974, -0.20633570849895477, 0.6358863115310669, 1.0966404676437378, -0.06597971171140671, 0.5995395183563232, 0.46667781472206116, 0.003118857741355896, 0.3975452780723572, 0.18890880048274994, 0.6577844023704529, -0.5836437344551086, -0.4993238151073456, -0.9264766573905945, 0.6175830364227295, 0.2884567379951477, -0.7175765633583069, 0.9651341438293457, 0.40370574593544006, 0.9319761395454407, -0.47622862458229065, 0.5912226438522339, 0.07163294404745102, 0.35325559973716736, -0.38430023193359375, 0.5101814270019531, -0.7319448590278625, 0.026504380628466606, -0.22861501574516296, -0.9964879751205444, -0.2685192823410034, 0.5261547565460205, -0.13936863839626312, 0.0694834515452385, 0.537178099155426, 0.7263617515563965, -0.2886132597923279, -0.023461153730750084, 0.33996835350990295, -0.08562859147787094, -0.19462312757968903, 0.8066276907920837, 0.5598263740539551, -0.42977991700172424, 0.4167833626270294, -0.14984840154647827, -0.09686226397752762, -0.24053284525871277, -0.8624373078346252, -0.5968432426452637, -0.4211694896221161, -0.42820635437965393, 0.17611579596996307, -0.029016833752393723, 0.5636052489280701, 0.7478069067001343, -1.0208970308303833, -0.40352848172187805, 0.23434098064899445, 0.24863722920417786, -0.4783315658569336, -0.1540229469537735, 0.043744198977947235, -0.6789263486862183, -1.090421199798584, 0.32871395349502563, 0.2607627511024475, -0.19660791754722595, -0.25468066334724426, 0.04616781696677208, -0.1348702609539032, -0.18333567678928375, 0.4187905192375183, 0.3689385652542114, -0.4969971776008606, -0.32732078433036804, 0.33748844265937805, -0.36514201760292053, -0.27652567625045776, 0.6242464184761047, -0.24330314993858337, 0.4888322949409485, 0.3950765132904053, 0.6371076107025146, 0.45489808917045593, -0.3310072720050812, 0.7143419981002808, -0.9489836096763611, 0.4289175271987915, -0.16132785379886627, 0.01865381933748722, 0.30459290742874146, -0.15109188854694366, 0.46587011218070984, -0.19150972366333008, -0.7196906805038452, -0.9294732213020325, 0.12428581714630127, -0.8186238408088684, -0.40652406215667725, 1.0501207113265991, -0.21227528154850006, 0.07431040704250336, -0.07403568178415298, 0.0341101810336113, 0.11724943667650223, 0.16005662083625793, 0.526817798614502, 1.1107453107833862, 0.24426265060901642, -0.49989116191864014, -0.8751431703567505, 0.44596371054649353, 0.45555904507637024, -0.6650598049163818, 0.09450405836105347, 0.2681897282600403, 0.30021825432777405, 0.2993597090244293, 0.22100307047367096, 0.32028597593307495, 0.5152066349983215, 0.1729939877986908, 0.007129058241844177, 0.35834360122680664, -0.6646572351455688, -0.2813203036785126, 0.16711769998073578, 0.30214956402778625, -0.2629316747188568 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04846v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04846v1
F-MALLOC: Feed-forward Memory Allocation for Continual Learning in Neural Machine Translation
2024-04-07T07:39:45
2024-04-07T07:39:45
Junhong Wu, Yuchen Liu, Chengqing Zong
cs.CL
cs.CL
In the evolving landscape of Neural Machine Translation (NMT), the pretrain-then-finetune paradigm has yielded impressive results. However, the persistent challenge of Catastrophic Forgetting (CF) remains a hurdle. While previous work has introduced Continual Learning (CL) methods to address CF, these approaches grapple with the delicate balance between avoiding forgetting and maintaining system extensibility. To address this, we propose a CL method, named $\textbf{F-MALLOC}$ ($\textbf{F}$eed-forward $\textbf{M}$emory $\textbf{ALLOC}ation)$. F-MALLOC is inspired by recent insights highlighting that feed-forward layers emulate neural memories and encapsulate crucial translation knowledge. It decomposes feed-forward layers into discrete memory cells and allocates these memories to different tasks. By learning to allocate and safeguard these memories, our method effectively alleviates CF while ensuring robust extendability. Besides, we propose a comprehensive assessment protocol for multi-stage CL of NMT systems. Experiments conducted following this new protocol showcase the superior performance of F-MALLOC, evidenced by higher BLEU scores and almost zero forgetting.
[ 0.11822017282247543, -0.5950982570648193, 0.5368782877922058, 0.4740985929965973, -0.20533324778079987, 0.08377967029809952, -0.3390412926673889, -0.16526487469673157, 0.16528254747390747, 0.30205798149108887, -0.5584520101547241, -0.26353901624679565, -0.5143757462501526, -0.00238547520712018, -0.3299415111541748, 1.0391221046447754, -0.3505061864852905, 0.026256557554006577, -0.18983377516269684, -0.27958062291145325, -0.7570911645889282, -0.37763863801956177, -0.7224048376083374, -0.25223642587661743, 0.8577186465263367, 0.4781801998615265, 0.44860580563545227, 0.6551269888877869, 0.4189174771308899, 0.3602537512779236, 0.012739917263388634, 0.26435086131095886, -0.6369805335998535, 0.32402729988098145, -0.23995697498321533, -0.33905088901519775, -0.42775827646255493, -0.22086882591247559, 1.0251799821853638, 0.6837210059165955, -0.281021386384964, -0.07596477121114731, -0.11942270398139954, 0.6213839054107666, -0.6326899528503418, -0.22457385063171387, -0.9853469729423523, 0.2989672124385834, -0.030659837648272514, -0.2009885013103485, -0.6313453316688538, -0.17567390203475952, 0.18236196041107178, -0.5319478511810303, -0.15487219393253326, 0.18984153866767883, 0.5254563093185425, 0.2198527306318283, 0.02062288299202919, -0.333624929189682, -0.7514058351516724, 0.8753180503845215, -0.31951701641082764, 0.37779155373573303, 0.25192856788635254, 0.23362340033054352, -0.018023904412984848, -0.7348897457122803, -0.30283495783805847, -0.4768749177455902, 0.34054258465766907, 0.1519070267677307, 0.0784745141863823, -0.07020478695631027, -0.023662718012928963, 0.3893897831439972, -0.5910604596138, -0.10831434279680252, -0.44095510244369507, -0.2821098864078522, 0.17461124062538147, 0.0729653537273407, 0.14763224124908447, 0.4792916476726532, -0.8270909190177917, 0.14609965682029724, -0.5749464631080627, -0.6116166710853577, -0.2567908763885498, 0.08906227350234985, 0.30756843090057373, 0.07866283506155014, -0.018325718119740486, 0.30019864439964294, -0.07983361184597015, 0.21470125019550323, 0.3521065413951874, -0.1539873331785202, -0.3840049207210541, 0.08720521628856659, 0.6471969485282898, 0.09794989228248596, 0.22911608219146729, -0.7917667031288147, -0.5398693084716797, -0.4140755832195282, 0.7556422352790833, -0.6610348224639893, -0.09270235896110535, 0.08883018046617508, -0.2580203115940094, -0.14111149311065674, -0.10436854511499405, -0.5596420764923096, 0.06160183623433113, 0.09890511631965637, 0.7215085625648499, -0.6480908393859863, -0.14859910309314728, -0.27266523241996765, 0.26615074276924133, -0.04145745933055878, 0.177027627825737, -0.9680085778236389, 0.24667523801326752, 0.46230095624923706, 1.2491061687469482, -0.4714851975440979, -0.9155745506286621, -0.6006949543952942, 0.316152960062027, -0.25394412875175476, 0.6770598292350769, -0.1533195972442627, -0.3944356441497803, -0.17039237916469574, -0.07153335213661194, -0.4789262115955353, -0.7775095701217651, 0.5443503260612488, -0.3635544776916504, -0.11052439361810684, -0.2595125138759613, -0.21621595323085785, -0.2326071858406067, 0.3561708629131317, -0.42441025376319885, 0.7081162929534912, 0.39161691069602966, -0.16307681798934937, 0.10399461537599564, -0.49138927459716797, -0.4249858260154724, -0.2491186410188675, 0.17904484272003174, -0.44950512051582336, 0.3503781855106354, -0.10245375335216522, 0.37082287669181824, -0.17889398336410522, 0.4131220281124115, -0.22910559177398682, -0.39699476957321167, 0.4054549038410187, -0.49597683548927307, 0.2342478185892105, 0.39026346802711487, -0.39962276816368103, 0.3691198527812958, -0.5007496476173401, -0.00946150440722704, 0.15690071880817413, -0.15128786861896515, -0.12244687229394913, -0.06602166593074799, -0.12805631756782532, 0.3551182448863983, 0.1384115219116211, -0.384214848279953, 0.11183370649814606, -0.4718383252620697, 0.6867337226867676, 0.8737814426422119, -0.16060870885849, 0.7239828705787659, -0.5691851377487183, 0.20133982598781586, 0.38544636964797974, 0.4129125773906708, -0.4003400206565857, -0.20387805998325348, -0.7729763984680176, 0.08831984549760818, 0.0798863023519516, 0.6235459446907043, -0.4358634948730469, 0.08695867657661438, -0.2178582102060318, -0.404407262802124, -0.15171946585178375, 0.17753222584724426, 0.5314435362815857, 0.5718154907226562, 0.7756931185722351, -0.3283935487270355, -0.33874568343162537, -0.6228788495063782, 0.18588224053382874, 0.02452784776687622, 0.18558216094970703, 0.17439082264900208, 0.4697466194629669, -0.33923447132110596, 0.07493097335100174, -0.24875329434871674, -0.48741990327835083, 0.13001614809036255, -0.020563753321766853, -0.018295032903552055, 0.9133663177490234, 0.5402170419692993, -0.46700823307037354, -0.05687875673174858, -0.020720604807138443, -0.5549499988555908, 0.1586848795413971, -0.7256878614425659, -0.5437383651733398, 0.26196202635765076, 0.373389333486557, -0.7953663468360901, 0.13173682987689972, 0.29318711161613464, -0.06621868908405304, 0.743040919303894, -0.22827769815921783, 0.0072853704914450645, -0.7132459878921509, 0.31482434272766113, -0.571824312210083, -0.09126846492290497, -0.46680447459220886, 0.03363365679979324, 0.08739966154098511, 0.1439126580953598, -0.5279114842414856, 0.5310549139976501, -0.3678673505783081, -0.022691233083605766, -0.28949713706970215, 0.29793256521224976, -0.04584690183401108, 0.5829025506973267, -0.18419870734214783, 0.5863440632820129, 0.3299817442893982, -0.5691285133361816, -0.0021845961455255747, 0.10262924432754517, 0.21892085671424866, 0.45459094643592834, -0.16800202429294586, 0.3299834728240967, 0.2568472623825073, 0.12748746573925018, -0.7797701358795166, 0.40839534997940063, 0.4926862120628357, -0.4796847701072693, 0.4145885407924652, 0.3510744273662567, -0.28652775287628174, -0.36539286375045776, -0.06355258822441101, 0.414238303899765, 0.09802849590778351, -0.32740485668182373, 0.5545849204063416, 0.10113319009542465, -0.012587045319378376, -0.7087148427963257, -0.8833737969398499, 0.023054560646414757, -0.018808137625455856, -0.35366278886795044, 0.5438293218612671, -0.2649584114551544, 0.09185894578695297, -0.06238502636551857, -0.5963379740715027, -0.26301586627960205, 0.27623653411865234, 0.22980105876922607, 0.1317678689956665, -0.5679607391357422, 0.14923547208309174, 0.2681300938129425, -0.2693563401699066, 0.06346705555915833, -0.9651906490325928, 0.5351279377937317, -0.3693516254425049, -0.16422128677368164, -0.18975871801376343, 0.47397154569625854, 0.6262152791023254, -0.14573566615581512, 0.6436488032341003, 0.7189919948577881, -0.4474885165691376, -0.2624843120574951, -0.5015898942947388, -0.16634421050548553, -0.4606907367706299, 0.3646681010723114, -0.1835917830467224, -0.780311107635498, 0.58132004737854, -0.2449021339416504, 0.13825015723705292, 0.5282750725746155, 0.5328770875930786, -0.2318929135799408, 0.4063417613506317, 0.5029110908508301, -0.11789601296186447, 0.42624813318252563, -0.28495484590530396, -0.11829544603824615, -0.8113420009613037, -0.26857510209083557, -0.17277094721794128, -0.7038217186927795, 0.12701070308685303, -0.5613119006156921, -0.27805691957473755, 0.43661829829216003, -0.36855122447013855, 0.18531125783920288, -0.5136485695838928, 0.4449644684791565, 0.40894946455955505, -0.032511234283447266, 0.12096086889505386, -0.25545990467071533, -0.5994732975959778, 0.1439545452594757, -0.5997462272644043, -0.11920370906591415, 0.9608931541442871, 0.25623974204063416, 0.2795179784297943, -0.11219774186611176, 0.9003230333328247, 0.0788222923874855, 0.6974944472312927, -0.7954587936401367, 0.5182816982269287, -0.07948756217956543, -0.21053890883922577, 0.029757972806692123, -0.49526238441467285, -0.6540437936782837, 0.12083196640014648, 0.09883103519678116, -0.8401565551757812, 0.05616803839802742, 0.3664279580116272, -0.6033068299293518, 0.5762588977813721, -0.6954206228256226, 0.810077965259552, -0.6410496830940247, -0.3977707624435425, -0.40398335456848145, -0.6579031944274902, 0.2746098041534424, -0.2415536493062973, -0.1959816813468933, 0.141488179564476, -0.1433802992105484, 0.36983922123908997, -0.2570503354072571, 0.47283846139907837, -0.34331655502319336, 0.14436256885528564, 0.28000393509864807, 0.18560251593589783, 0.3201407492160797, 0.22269482910633087, -0.05700488016009331, 0.22725172340869904, -0.18998795747756958, -0.3011741638183594, -0.4067462086677551, 0.9489242434501648, -0.5567808151245117, -0.2798122763633728, -0.4967458248138428, -0.8872056007385254, -0.111167311668396, 0.6368312835693359, -0.06955825537443161, 0.16109009087085724, -0.2522197365760803, 0.1251305490732193, 0.7200800776481628, -0.16776713728904724, 0.4481481909751892, 0.3369233310222626, -0.3653341829776764, -0.8116839528083801, 1.2826000452041626, 0.17553456127643585, 0.4296944737434387, 0.5425370335578918, 0.28945013880729675, -0.1624080091714859, -0.9772247076034546, -0.5259393453598022, 0.18541041016578674, -0.48306822776794434, -0.5677831768989563, -0.8157251477241516, -0.41126471757888794, 0.05596098303794861, -0.48753419518470764, -0.5931410789489746, -0.41914257407188416, -0.2846696972846985, 0.08626799285411835, 0.1698298156261444, 0.2627561688423157, -0.2843884229660034, 0.5126276612281799, -0.9138298630714417, 0.266435444355011, -0.06833317130804062, 0.3396374583244324, 0.25505608320236206, -0.417358934879303, -0.5229585766792297, 0.13161557912826538, -0.7343969941139221, -0.6620544791221619, 0.3319430649280548, 0.48207277059555054, 0.6761915683746338, 0.3899701237678528, -0.2817845642566681, 0.6775362491607666, -0.6671310663223267, 0.4708973467350006, 0.22251686453819275, -0.8570321202278137, 0.4177183508872986, -0.2470157891511917, 0.481182336807251, 0.6441746950149536, 0.3200649619102478, -0.5813656449317932, -0.31678763031959534, -0.47948893904685974, -1.1484078168869019, 0.5181840062141418, 0.030723532661795616, 0.01375880092382431, -0.28198638558387756, 0.49741625785827637, 0.13432301580905914, 0.30094271898269653, -0.3801981210708618, -0.15697172284126282, -0.2984030842781067, -0.09104844927787781, 0.19775418937206268, -0.025958199054002762, 0.12285952270030975, -0.1910979449748993, 0.5359968543052673, -0.14172343909740448, 0.7211251258850098, 0.3252522647380829, -0.5030674934387207, -0.08977587521076202, 0.04372222721576691, 1.0384702682495117, 0.7679852843284607, -0.25625550746917725, -0.04204484820365906, 0.4484415650367737, -0.8563622832298279, 0.044434353709220886, -0.02843426913022995, -0.36874210834503174, -0.17148976027965546, -0.17306220531463623, 0.7330702543258667, 0.6383561491966248, -0.5065014958381653, 0.0942234918475151, 0.1796712875366211, -0.4836917817592621, -0.3384050726890564, -0.010332077741622925, 0.16787748038768768, 0.3404930531978607, 0.4699905216693878, 0.6658489108085632, -0.10333266854286194, -0.3820115625858307, 0.8457125425338745, 0.05590314045548439, -0.6016096472740173, -0.3005625307559967, 0.6074365973472595, 0.007345527410507202, -0.20114539563655853, 0.8929204940795898, -0.21618545055389404, -0.6285499334335327, 0.3606400489807129, 0.976779043674469, 1.1777204275131226, -0.5337022542953491, 0.2080119103193283, 0.41973239183425903, 0.43806180357933044, -0.3786133825778961, 0.20555131137371063, -0.21143890917301178, -0.4816582202911377, -0.41581979393959045, -0.7287665605545044, -0.18876667320728302, 0.007326290477067232, -0.3806895911693573, -0.17255379259586334, -0.9157096147537231, 0.07079076766967773, -0.4903784990310669, 0.010025713592767715, -0.29902026057243347, 0.17848007380962372, 0.3758416473865509, 0.9582600593566895, -0.36115577816963196, 1.2548168897628784, 0.42458975315093994, -0.4739254117012024, -0.4733284115791321, 0.06180093437433243, 0.1786610186100006, -0.724470317363739, 0.5730118155479431, 0.4532228410243988, -0.2999568283557892, 0.26965898275375366, -0.18770059943199158, -0.8291707634925842, 1.2875577211380005, 0.2964162826538086, -0.5940220355987549, -0.0840991735458374, -0.08205979317426682, 0.2513831853866577, -0.4999890625476837, 0.2711792290210724, 0.39784571528434753, 0.5004429221153259, 0.2994539737701416, -0.6207088828086853, 0.12090902030467987, -0.08918841183185577, -0.26389190554618835, 0.28234031796455383, -0.822890043258667, 0.7843477129936218, -0.5233145356178284, -0.23601891100406647, 0.377928227186203, 0.8982404470443726, 0.17730394005775452, 0.45211514830589294, 0.45550113916397095, 0.641105592250824, 0.8867190480232239, -0.24236735701560974, 0.4391449987888336, -0.03477807343006134, 0.1577885001897812, 1.2268259525299072, -0.05260273814201355, 0.9328311681747437, 0.6290274262428284, 0.1834636926651001, 0.15506252646446228, 0.3247371315956116, -0.2126445770263672, 0.5990330576896667, 0.3419349193572998, 0.0009131376864388585, 0.12984180450439453, -0.0027313653845340014, -0.22832463681697845, 0.20553719997406006, 0.5666089653968811, -0.4820929169654846, -0.1538318395614624, 0.10301831364631653, 0.1584392786026001, -0.07525021582841873, -0.4222196638584137, 0.45273661613464355, 0.43083176016807556, -0.7407965660095215, 0.8997393250465393, -0.28055325150489807, 0.6044568419456482, -0.7194297313690186, 0.14793190360069275, -0.4903470277786255, 0.5416972637176514, 0.03503722697496414, -0.5226179957389832, 0.9250588417053223, -0.3511076271533966, -0.38870367407798767, -0.41457509994506836, 0.4234626889228821, -0.5122063755989075, -0.12871509790420532, 0.3362810015678406, 0.25241661071777344, -0.03784079849720001, -0.33889490365982056, -0.981887698173523, 0.08613847196102142, -0.059010833501815796, -0.06333726644515991, 0.41239267587661743, 0.5010254979133606, -0.1277657151222229, 0.7151370048522949, 0.5496878027915955, 0.12873737514019012, 0.28147241473197937, -0.12410200387239456, 0.89289391040802, -0.7295092940330505, -0.23440343141555786, -0.8318865895271301, 0.405602365732193, 0.13838346302509308, -0.541551411151886, 0.39474618434906006, 0.42070627212524414, 0.8181414604187012, -0.0640566498041153, 0.3499538004398346, -0.055258892476558685, -0.12995140254497528, -0.5405840873718262, 1.0586150884628296, -0.5347833633422852, -0.006766489706933498, -0.25980499386787415, -0.9140806794166565, -0.5633742809295654, 0.6431279182434082, -0.19649554789066315, -0.14753597974777222, 1.1842494010925293, 0.5757870674133301, -0.04961906000971794, 0.11485248059034348, 0.3370087146759033, 0.42452892661094666, 0.08146701753139496, 1.1314300298690796, 0.8749098777770996, -0.5388815999031067, 0.8309058547019958, -0.24442316591739655, -0.07271906733512878, -0.1299768090248108, -0.6987177133560181, -0.5388057827949524, -0.5669829249382019, -0.1795496642589569, -0.1371043622493744, 0.22667407989501953, 0.7574357986450195, 0.4966202974319458, -0.8818492293357849, -0.06461769342422485, -0.14892584085464478, 0.15725404024124146, -0.8320486545562744, -0.07467104494571686, 0.1800854355096817, -0.6783801317214966, -0.4172942340373993, 0.5321693420410156, 0.664975643157959, -0.18222832679748535, -0.2646401524543762, -0.2678433060646057, -0.6011260747909546, -0.2861878275871277, 0.5673308372497559, 0.4453841745853424, -0.5406026244163513, -0.1864522248506546, 0.3314816653728485, 0.020082775503396988, 0.25863194465637207, 0.827812910079956, -0.5865805149078369, 0.3522796034812927, 0.38998857140541077, 1.130001425743103, 0.17587421834468842, -0.3345206081867218, 0.7253143191337585, -0.609399676322937, 0.16089655458927155, 0.5341459512710571, 0.1693592071533203, 0.16565938293933868, -0.33151164650917053, 0.20430798828601837, 0.3783533573150635, -0.8517771363258362, -0.7123584151268005, -0.029127461835741997, -1.0905561447143555, 0.04203973338007927, 0.7770823240280151, -0.41491609811782837, -0.3529454171657562, 0.10485563427209854, -0.024916041642427444, 0.2541218400001526, -0.33251461386680603, 0.6428589820861816, 0.4472769498825073, 0.35293149948120117, -0.20566751062870026, -0.8548672199249268, 0.1866193264722824, 0.6654817461967468, -0.5419721603393555, 0.05625215545296669, 0.32262474298477173, 0.042284462600946426, 0.30356305837631226, 0.6979889273643494, -0.2629512548446655, 0.2600201368331909, 0.025169650092720985, -0.23997606337070465, -0.22084179520606995, -0.8779486417770386, -0.050602346658706665, 0.07654408365488052, 0.0007983358227647841, -0.4106137454509735 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04845v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04845v2
SLPL SHROOM at SemEval2024 Task 06: A comprehensive study on models ability to detect hallucination
2024-04-07T07:34:49
2024-04-09T07:21:37
Pouya Fallah, Soroush Gooran, Mohammad Jafarinasab, Pouya Sadeghi, Reza Farnia, Amirreza Tarabkhah, Zainab Sadat Taghavi, Hossein Sameti
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Language models, particularly generative models, are susceptible to hallucinations, generating outputs that contradict factual knowledge or the source text. This study explores methods for detecting hallucinations in three SemEval-2024 Task 6 tasks: Machine Translation, Definition Modeling, and Paraphrase Generation. We evaluate two methods: semantic similarity between the generated text and factual references, and an ensemble of language models that judge each other's outputs. Our results show that semantic similarity achieves moderate accuracy and correlation scores in trial data, while the ensemble method offers insights into the complexities of hallucination detection but falls short of expectations. This work highlights the challenges of hallucination detection and underscores the need for further research in this critical area.
[ -0.3319922983646393, -0.6434140801429749, 0.9741431474685669, 0.14271661639213562, -0.23106984794139862, -0.48195022344589233, 0.05783221870660782, -0.5593593716621399, 0.15005743503570557, 0.9950180053710938, -0.4820837080478668, -0.4570614993572235, -0.538593590259552, 0.3407592177391052, -0.9218751788139343, 0.7786709070205688, -0.0006537451408803463, 0.046984490007162094, -0.43969279527664185, -0.01700872741639614, -0.35663333535194397, -0.7887268662452698, -0.19737742841243744, -0.3332562744617462, 0.19940747320652008, -0.019029920920729637, 0.5596238970756531, 0.17317937314510345, 0.6128342151641846, 0.30168843269348145, 0.11440535634756088, 0.31341037154197693, -0.32994189858436584, 0.5288446545600891, -0.1171669065952301, -0.27976569533348083, -0.14765524864196777, -0.24929910898208618, 0.38747894763946533, 0.49735602736473083, -0.13673551380634308, -0.159309521317482, 0.16922827064990997, 0.4279596209526062, -0.5117009878158569, 0.08205720782279968, -0.9150335788726807, 0.21285977959632874, -0.1325398087501526, -0.5035431385040283, -0.648603618144989, -0.12329941987991333, -0.0534072071313858, -0.1739042103290558, 0.6984726786613464, 0.24381078779697418, 0.7459898591041565, 0.5822631120681763, -0.2889309227466583, -0.7439896464347839, -0.6237415671348572, 0.7470446825027466, -0.8040109872817993, 0.44720372557640076, 0.5711997747421265, 0.1627005785703659, -0.02743614837527275, -0.8022140264511108, -0.6162412762641907, -0.2943023443222046, -0.233132004737854, -0.1274774670600891, 0.048621222376823425, -0.07850337028503418, 0.4129086136817932, 0.2519467771053314, -0.7332472205162048, -0.18467599153518677, -0.5085548162460327, -0.504219114780426, 0.4909307062625885, 0.1881403774023056, 0.34610873460769653, -0.5309627652168274, -0.2244405448436737, -0.02069190703332424, -0.37460973858833313, -0.7424566149711609, 0.33224624395370483, 0.2707569897174835, 0.25989627838134766, 0.5953181982040405, -0.15065225958824158, 0.4639137387275696, -0.3132535517215729, 0.14016790688037872, 0.5060647130012512, -0.4668866693973541, -0.19910793006420135, 0.25387609004974365, 0.5125961303710938, 0.2653329074382782, -0.0996052622795105, -0.3680174648761749, -0.5741204619407654, 0.24608635902404785, 0.5726701617240906, -0.44596314430236816, -0.312696635723114, 0.16940619051456451, -0.579422652721405, -0.6292346715927124, -0.15502886474132538, -0.8171643018722534, -0.6002973914146423, -0.4393986165523529, 0.8400794863700867, -0.5195214152336121, -0.20947426557540894, 0.07173949480056763, -0.2602252960205078, 0.4246220588684082, 0.19583407044410706, -0.6837353110313416, 0.4246123731136322, 0.6102451682090759, 0.8786136507987976, -0.6414424777030945, -0.4827924966812134, -0.4825202524662018, 0.01814720593392849, -0.29623904824256897, 0.993824303150177, -0.4225141108036041, -0.2750534117221832, -0.07897189259529114, 0.17265482246875763, -0.16468194127082825, -0.8409264087677002, 0.8116942644119263, -0.04938948154449463, 0.1469069868326187, -0.3825483024120331, -0.5546143651008606, -0.22651857137680054, -0.08454053103923798, -0.5567628145217896, 0.9411128163337708, -0.06417892873287201, -0.7449346780776978, 0.09808394312858582, -0.14470547437667847, -0.48092859983444214, 0.13452328741550446, -0.4636599123477936, -0.4410467743873596, 0.5354480147361755, -0.03459993749856949, 0.6649245619773865, -0.02738610841333866, 0.3358648419380188, -0.1366981863975525, -0.4747844636440277, 0.19412460923194885, -0.23986762762069702, 0.31386005878448486, 0.39637699723243713, -0.6633748412132263, 0.26817256212234497, -0.7876875996589661, -0.2276218682527542, 0.194634810090065, 0.3270890712738037, -0.4423137903213501, 0.19670461118221283, 0.148029625415802, 0.19575753808021545, 0.13584421575069427, 0.010457265190780163, -0.33473291993141174, -0.2135504186153412, 0.2778199315071106, 0.6710257530212402, 0.2227948158979416, 0.12963201105594635, -0.43108925223350525, 0.13621537387371063, 0.24710790812969208, -0.2248256355524063, -0.12097674608230591, -0.5284019708633423, -0.8585882186889648, 0.3233053386211395, -0.06987732648849487, 0.2021760791540146, -0.8131875991821289, 0.5847254991531372, -0.0048648398369550705, -0.3947373628616333, -0.3253210783004761, -0.13257011771202087, 0.22434993088245392, 0.500471830368042, 0.4883206784725189, -0.09028163552284241, -0.7149139642715454, -0.9313222765922546, -0.17263853549957275, 0.01066113356500864, 0.026304109022021294, 0.011917494237422943, 0.917713463306427, -0.42566758394241333, 0.14546701312065125, -0.43616291880607605, -0.30553728342056274, -0.061874501407146454, 0.44914528727531433, -0.20155233144760132, 0.4766646921634674, 0.5754363536834717, -0.7897443175315857, -0.05222998932003975, -0.05905357748270035, -1.1633347272872925, -0.3268943727016449, -0.22769053280353546, 0.060282643884420395, 0.46972644329071045, 0.6352388858795166, -0.49614444375038147, 0.5135433077812195, 0.40369462966918945, -0.38296130299568176, 0.6321873664855957, -0.1283978372812271, 0.4692654013633728, -1.025195837020874, -0.0860339105129242, -0.4347114562988281, -0.09873168170452118, -0.8897532820701599, 0.2068394422531128, -0.13492083549499512, -0.07574912905693054, -0.2346842736005783, 0.126874640583992, -0.2047896832227707, -0.4103810489177704, -0.5082578063011169, 0.15186549723148346, -0.19044597446918488, 0.3495975732803345, 0.3588412404060364, 0.5780367851257324, 0.2899998426437378, -0.6385626792907715, 0.1956576406955719, 0.13035576045513153, -0.5085387825965881, 0.27189725637435913, -0.5083121657371521, 0.26707860827445984, -0.17275090515613556, -0.1403781622648239, -1.0580952167510986, -0.49760738015174866, 0.193086639046669, -0.47594577074050903, -0.1960953027009964, 0.5276939272880554, -0.5931063890457153, -0.14059768617153168, -0.16803956031799316, 0.12273915112018585, 0.5787320137023926, -0.36314892768859863, 0.5797159075737, 0.23146256804466248, 0.08654102683067322, -0.12102002650499344, -0.8219201564788818, 0.028923451900482178, -0.3792990744113922, -0.4187672734260559, 0.41649129986763, 0.028244581073522568, -0.38353973627090454, -0.2255728393793106, -0.2798239290714264, 0.02631203830242157, 0.1280914545059204, 0.28356412053108215, 0.1232101172208786, -0.12470482289791107, 0.09201622009277344, 0.02204296737909317, 0.12733158469200134, 0.38739797472953796, -0.005666081327944994, 0.8923020362854004, 0.031831737607717514, -0.4894377887248993, -0.298970490694046, 0.32559916377067566, 0.7149322628974915, 0.19109003245830536, 0.7329864501953125, 0.6264084577560425, -0.8003852367401123, -0.26529359817504883, -0.7930229902267456, -0.5724388360977173, -0.3970199227333069, 0.3490016460418701, -0.6240200400352478, -0.4709981083869934, 0.6251904964447021, 0.26077836751937866, -0.2894355058670044, 0.5832471251487732, 0.7243342995643616, 0.1776323914527893, 1.1441309452056885, 0.07011058181524277, 0.2416716367006302, -0.09286464750766754, 0.053315892815589905, 0.46397122740745544, -0.5366880893707275, -0.37183690071105957, -0.7321960926055908, 0.07722342759370804, -0.44132086634635925, -0.561572253704071, 0.12926770746707916, -0.14386752247810364, 0.1887105405330658, 0.4861541986465454, -0.6723148226737976, 0.22910074889659882, 0.41615578532218933, 0.006732604466378689, 0.2554747760295868, 0.08705249428749084, -0.13349966704845428, -0.37459757924079895, -0.22427724301815033, -0.6291952729225159, 0.8080567717552185, 0.06952282786369324, 0.49493855237960815, -0.0411963015794754, 0.9771237373352051, 0.4780675768852234, -0.3775867223739624, -0.3972891867160797, 0.7448423504829407, 0.10157426446676254, -0.32670432329177856, -0.31220272183418274, -0.24175584316253662, -0.49309560656547546, 0.414392352104187, -0.1664598286151886, -0.7685607671737671, 0.1835876703262329, -0.12344548106193542, -0.056355852633714676, 0.03471766412258148, -0.5302408337593079, 0.7664106488227844, -0.0818939134478569, -0.22509348392486572, -0.27391737699508667, -0.4514419436454773, 0.5397962331771851, -0.27671992778778076, 0.15910153090953827, -0.09052199125289917, 0.2482583075761795, 0.6761881113052368, -0.1683676540851593, 0.6430882811546326, -0.03149600327014923, -0.2166355401277542, 0.17973405122756958, 0.2594633996486664, 0.6393061280250549, -0.31943920254707336, -0.11858166754245758, -0.00456444825977087, 0.20141352713108063, -0.2255505919456482, -0.49363914132118225, 0.7894837260246277, -0.598247766494751, -0.5500536561012268, -0.5905936360359192, -0.5628560185432434, 0.002614975208416581, 0.04948247969150543, 0.6610051393508911, 0.12687137722969055, -0.14254793524742126, 0.2633577585220337, 0.7130851149559021, -0.26873698830604553, 0.18077507615089417, 0.11807209253311157, -0.42887163162231445, -0.09376753866672516, 1.0469123125076294, 0.03405097499489784, 0.20186708867549896, 0.0745258778333664, -0.003817691933363676, -0.31460973620414734, -0.7319067716598511, 0.09062151610851288, 0.2663283944129944, -0.9593135714530945, -0.03929233178496361, -0.9093379974365234, -0.5985596179962158, -0.9475668668746948, -0.06182962656021118, -0.14934943616390228, -0.38313087821006775, -0.2967483103275299, -0.10399539768695831, 0.004372398369014263, 0.7547000646591187, 0.09066308289766312, -0.1554853320121765, -0.5391911268234253, 0.4889056980609894, 0.23302827775478363, -0.434882253408432, 0.02054991014301777, -0.6745331883430481, 0.1343812495470047, -0.1664968878030777, -0.2677530348300934, -1.016021728515625, 0.6255282163619995, -0.09809738397598267, 0.6199225187301636, 0.4426073729991913, 0.18779729306697845, 0.6839423775672913, -0.3997853696346283, 0.9910534620285034, -0.013653537258505821, -0.9961761236190796, 0.7879223823547363, -0.10315020382404327, 0.03884569928050041, 0.4201571047306061, 0.40069645643234253, -0.30559834837913513, -0.6583607196807861, -0.6567290425300598, -0.49037599563598633, 0.4899744987487793, 0.6610713601112366, 0.057772181928157806, -0.16376924514770508, 0.1731911152601242, 0.35446828603744507, 0.23672285676002502, -0.8556798100471497, 0.09457099437713623, -0.1235770434141159, -0.11894511431455612, -0.04253255948424339, -0.3758228123188019, 0.044695448130369186, -0.11704552918672562, 0.6175450682640076, -0.005274076014757156, 0.3034890592098236, 0.2306535840034485, -0.2357209473848343, -0.04242146015167236, 0.10137444734573364, 1.0061181783676147, 0.5965416431427002, -0.09980715811252594, 0.5447657704353333, 0.45694246888160706, -0.21973882615566254, -0.1204497218132019, -0.07269017398357391, -0.35075119137763977, 0.36046746373176575, 0.6224085688591003, 0.9033355712890625, 0.24512289464473724, -0.7524948120117188, 0.5038611888885498, 0.14203859865665436, -0.5261305570602417, -0.42068102955818176, 0.13202537596225739, -0.05850987508893013, 0.07826432585716248, 0.23844708502292633, 0.211109459400177, 0.6315762996673584, -0.614160418510437, 0.4470522105693817, 0.17553067207336426, -0.42941179871559143, -0.507041871547699, 0.7140792608261108, -0.16174542903900146, -0.3039018511772156, 0.6414409875869751, -0.2564176619052887, -0.679114580154419, 0.5763946175575256, 0.753007173538208, 0.9164648056030273, -0.35973358154296875, 0.19330468773841858, 0.3059620261192322, 0.22286751866340637, -0.3884878158569336, 0.41009435057640076, -0.13642588257789612, -0.8341788649559021, -0.09135234355926514, -0.8264255523681641, -0.10944755375385284, 0.5410521030426025, -0.7221558690071106, 0.5059861540794373, 0.17447058856487274, 0.14152219891548157, 0.11998660862445831, -0.425287663936615, -0.3904492259025574, -0.039202332496643066, 0.3013084828853607, 0.3266321122646332, -1.1558070182800293, 0.7444927096366882, 0.4378276765346527, -0.3578922748565674, -0.4217710494995117, 0.2147679328918457, 0.16383512318134308, -0.6384715437889099, 0.5769889950752258, 0.32728737592697144, -0.11153429001569748, -0.14375506341457367, -0.37796199321746826, -0.4548834562301636, 0.9342905879020691, -0.003900726092979312, -0.4016435146331787, -0.42218196392059326, 0.2041553258895874, 0.6076626777648926, -0.33711469173431396, -0.1719440072774887, 0.8112399578094482, 0.40316280722618103, 0.36374127864837646, -0.6476615071296692, 0.22759664058685303, -0.039917029440402985, 0.06020393967628479, 0.11034578830003738, -0.15254393219947815, 0.6657147407531738, 0.020270025357604027, -0.12825699150562286, 0.295437753200531, 0.7265531420707703, 0.5096027255058289, 0.6004924178123474, 0.4813964366912842, 0.6295742988586426, 0.7105183601379395, -0.02370286174118519, 0.6573708057403564, -0.36199629306793213, 0.2770808935165405, 1.2345638275146484, -0.6918351054191589, 0.786766767501831, 0.703196108341217, 0.10554294288158417, 0.24388600885868073, 0.48144590854644775, -0.17064990103244781, 0.7945321798324585, 0.14043636620044708, -0.28602123260498047, -0.34833893179893494, -0.15152783691883087, -0.471893310546875, 0.3358476758003235, 0.5284604430198669, -0.6057305335998535, -0.016991160809993744, 0.4019717574119568, -0.4625408351421356, 0.28988540172576904, 0.032463882118463516, 0.7847688794136047, 0.20887212455272675, -0.9756510257720947, 0.4300413727760315, -0.34356847405433655, 0.3683117926120758, -0.2157457321882248, -0.32526805996894836, -0.1502906233072281, 0.1938336044549942, -0.16984736919403076, -0.3452368676662445, 0.792319118976593, -0.23112745583057404, 0.06329476833343506, -0.09755868464708328, 1.018885850906372, -0.25744107365608215, -0.37426191568374634, 0.45880693197250366, 0.43227633833885193, 0.6529818773269653, -0.2644505798816681, -0.3883698582649231, 0.35571011900901794, 0.18801771104335785, 0.11691572517156601, 0.12666666507720947, 0.5772882699966431, -0.07408696413040161, 0.43227335810661316, 0.23429924249649048, 0.09464225172996521, 0.22089257836341858, 0.2456948161125183, 0.4949410557746887, -0.6495277881622314, -0.29003381729125977, -0.8626015186309814, -0.031066954135894775, -0.17631499469280243, -0.11585013568401337, 0.8750250339508057, 0.6551064252853394, 0.8496537208557129, -0.48398786783218384, 0.6997313499450684, -0.0498226135969162, 0.4260340631008148, -0.6590543985366821, 0.5629771947860718, -0.517102837562561, 0.2880488932132721, -0.3684958517551422, -0.9744564294815063, -0.13515563309192657, 0.827694833278656, -0.24391016364097595, -0.2395101636648178, 1.1768690347671509, 1.057991623878479, -0.02513369545340538, 0.3603343665599823, 0.7521073222160339, 0.231231689453125, -0.04466484114527702, 0.3478795886039734, 1.0519905090332031, -0.6168938279151917, 0.46239569783210754, -0.3386470079421997, 0.296063095331192, -0.2573755085468292, -0.49777406454086304, -1.1211398839950562, -1.1812626123428345, -0.33673179149627686, -0.5023665428161621, 0.1711774319410324, 0.5861362218856812, 0.4212729334831238, -1.1924439668655396, -0.151863694190979, -0.5095065832138062, -0.010354111902415752, -0.2221318781375885, -0.30253440141677856, 0.29751232266426086, -0.7583008408546448, -0.7724140286445618, 0.3309866189956665, 0.29488834738731384, 0.3110288381576538, -0.3072516620159149, -0.14450973272323608, -0.08208268135786057, -0.042448677122592926, 0.5404820442199707, -0.3782946467399597, -1.1628566980361938, -0.4691675901412964, 0.06951164454221725, -0.2146809846162796, -0.22049833834171295, 0.7749225497245789, -0.48476430773735046, 0.24408824741840363, 0.9171543717384338, 0.451270192861557, 0.557123064994812, -0.15703138709068298, 0.4466322958469391, -0.34168967604637146, 0.1777750700712204, 0.3405836820602417, 0.39509209990501404, 0.23359304666519165, -0.34135469794273376, 0.8445649147033691, 0.47983500361442566, -0.7719012498855591, -1.1943227052688599, 0.10929153859615326, -0.767066240310669, -0.5045329928398132, 0.9430950284004211, 0.1453508585691452, -0.17330558598041534, -0.24844400584697723, -0.21400344371795654, 0.11012493073940277, 0.15604911744594574, 1.0069258213043213, 0.9830262064933777, -0.12394672632217407, -0.08018789440393448, -0.7865287661552429, 0.6880242824554443, 0.573005199432373, -0.7720288634300232, -0.050654053688049316, 0.4600030183792114, -0.1885707676410675, 0.45275625586509705, 0.385958731174469, -0.005075125023722649, 0.30512911081314087, 0.1501898169517517, 0.0049135503359138966, 0.46191513538360596, -0.42884036898612976, -0.32194310426712036, 0.1844797283411026, -0.1063113659620285, -0.05645157769322395 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04838v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04838v1
Data Bias According to Bipol: Men are Naturally Right and It is the Role of Women to Follow Their Lead
2024-04-07T07:24:45
2024-04-07T07:24:45
Irene Pagliai, Goya van Boven, Tosin Adewumi, Lama Alkhaled, Namrata Gurung, Isabella Södergren, Elisa Barney
cs.CL
cs.CL
We introduce new large labeled datasets on bias in 3 languages and show in experiments that bias exists in all 10 datasets of 5 languages evaluated, including benchmark datasets on the English GLUE/SuperGLUE leaderboards. The 3 new languages give a total of almost 6 million labeled samples and we benchmark on these datasets using SotA multilingual pretrained models: mT5 and mBERT. The challenge of social bias, based on prejudice, is ubiquitous, as recent events with AI and large language models (LLMs) have shown. Motivated by this challenge, we set out to estimate bias in multiple datasets. We compare some recent bias metrics and use bipol, which has explainability in the metric. We also confirm the unverified assumption that bias exists in toxic comments by randomly sampling 200 samples from a toxic dataset population using the confidence level of 95% and error margin of 7%. Thirty gold samples were randomly distributed in the 200 samples to secure the quality of the annotation. Our findings confirm that many of the datasets have male bias (prejudice against women), besides other types of bias. We publicly release our new datasets, lexica, models, and codes.
[ -0.3256855309009552, -0.36249300837516785, 0.2291337102651596, 0.49780187010765076, 0.2459724247455597, 0.253116250038147, -0.1714974045753479, -0.4276815354824066, -0.13064654171466827, 0.5297760367393494, -0.5783567428588867, -0.29914817214012146, -0.713710367679596, 0.11930903047323227, -0.16083009541034698, 1.32374107837677, 0.22055211663246155, 0.7150590419769287, -0.0677381381392479, -0.3359161913394928, -0.46309801936149597, -0.8120903968811035, 0.007038647774606943, -0.36354681849479675, 0.3845283091068268, 0.325823038816452, 0.7487243413925171, 0.2654641270637512, 0.23737724125385284, 0.09968437999486923, -0.3682122528553009, 0.17593026161193848, -0.5884267091751099, -0.11575984954833984, -0.48909205198287964, -0.6534750461578369, -0.3701537549495697, 0.4393341541290283, 0.22064946591854095, 0.829706072807312, 0.04732254892587662, 0.5453584790229797, 0.20813794434070587, 1.0226672887802124, -0.652790367603302, 0.3295096457004547, -0.3528141677379608, -0.07477569580078125, -0.4727562367916107, 0.09436321258544922, -0.4720679819583893, -0.46769577264785767, 0.38038119673728943, -0.3040046691894531, 0.4189842939376831, 0.30881109833717346, 0.7530796527862549, 0.0190900769084692, -0.7341961860656738, -0.4016556739807129, -0.7511718273162842, 0.97269606590271, -0.4158822298049927, 0.38080719113349915, 0.5217777490615845, 0.417819619178772, -0.12706999480724335, -0.3317469358444214, -0.13719351589679718, 0.10069357603788376, 0.10441567748785019, -0.05965554714202881, 0.1754469871520996, -0.2995043992996216, 0.4369869530200958, 0.12995311617851257, -0.14177006483078003, -0.13157594203948975, -0.38651710748672485, -0.30472609400749207, 0.8821960091590881, -0.11727891862392426, 0.24377195537090302, 0.2789147198200226, -0.3240692913532257, -0.1421077698469162, -0.9704062342643738, -0.16436295211315155, 0.8431528806686401, 0.4378017783164978, -0.2376411259174347, 0.5236988067626953, -0.01270478405058384, 0.4595942795276642, -0.15239155292510986, 0.23343606293201447, 0.5762898325920105, -0.6094825267791748, 0.1304856687784195, 0.21327024698257446, 0.8484441041946411, 0.5321273803710938, 0.8245717883110046, 0.07876650243997574, 0.18141226470470428, 0.32795459032058716, 0.05909110978245735, -0.40557992458343506, -0.2261335700750351, -0.10735173523426056, -0.40079188346862793, -0.22491541504859924, 0.09004874527454376, -1.2897988557815552, -0.6878085136413574, 0.09289579838514328, -0.08348551392555237, 0.1527903825044632, -0.17406587302684784, 0.04635298624634743, -0.2569402754306793, 0.04940503463149071, 0.03398044779896736, -0.9785601496696472, 0.2548162639141083, 0.3633265197277069, 0.34152549505233765, 0.05765779688954353, -0.3267877697944641, -0.3716130554676056, 0.08417987823486328, -0.6938449144363403, 0.7819756865501404, -0.6875116229057312, -0.0025811451487243176, 0.13444136083126068, -0.03386629745364189, 0.262345552444458, -0.6656515598297119, 0.7045825719833374, -0.16124983131885529, 0.39281314611434937, -0.8976699709892273, -0.20339392125606537, -0.08438492566347122, 0.01346981804817915, -0.6532762050628662, 1.194359540939331, 0.01659049466252327, -1.1007890701293945, 0.8532115817070007, -0.4254375398159027, -0.37075814604759216, -0.5090851187705994, -0.48050129413604736, -0.5509103536605835, -0.08385483920574188, 0.29991528391838074, 0.023492014035582542, -0.8470432162284851, 0.4205135405063629, -0.5386033654212952, -0.17514021694660187, 0.21195420622825623, -0.29933616518974304, 1.222359299659729, 0.009540390223264694, -0.6110783219337463, -0.02356419712305069, -0.2515173554420471, -0.4314698576927185, -0.19398751854896545, -0.3336102068424225, -0.3763565719127655, 0.1881907433271408, -0.028972970321774483, 0.47454145550727844, -0.14200450479984283, -0.5433527231216431, -0.040367528796195984, -0.024790555238723755, 0.22703319787979126, 0.9490216374397278, -0.18026085197925568, 0.3773089349269867, -0.2109573632478714, 0.2399163693189621, -0.02452581189572811, 0.35521048307418823, 0.35907089710235596, -0.7059708833694458, -0.35354575514793396, -0.11671899259090424, 0.5361649990081787, 0.33961060643196106, -0.5345867872238159, 0.20826639235019684, 0.0034874877892434597, -0.28915974497795105, -0.4843854010105133, 0.17485667765140533, 0.6273508071899414, 0.3570626974105835, 0.1822177618741989, -0.27566948533058167, -0.6732437014579773, -1.2735713720321655, -0.6455489993095398, -0.10483390837907791, -0.0798119604587555, 0.3925938904285431, 0.4781946539878845, -0.07555587589740753, 0.8566872477531433, -0.40635862946510315, -0.5355212092399597, -0.17283110320568085, 0.21248680353164673, 0.15790466964244843, 0.1986798197031021, 0.7909482717514038, -0.6641197800636292, -0.5855986475944519, -0.4228481948375702, -0.740270733833313, -0.6076156497001648, 0.34405770897865295, -0.553601086139679, 0.17723561823368073, 0.3789711892604828, -0.15169969201087952, 0.29859980940818787, 0.6193327903747559, -0.48155826330184937, 0.6532390713691711, 0.2184298038482666, -0.05896306410431862, -0.6637682914733887, -0.1301320344209671, 0.2501757740974426, -0.1078576073050499, -0.6622808575630188, -0.34486839175224304, -0.08405938744544983, 0.3466023802757263, -0.42475423216819763, 0.419624388217926, -0.6995347738265991, -0.2517393231391907, 0.14059026539325714, 0.0786001980304718, 0.05433547496795654, 0.29430142045021057, -0.1124710664153099, 0.6045214533805847, 0.6413031220436096, -0.41418710350990295, 0.0456496961414814, 0.41781938076019287, -0.3894304037094116, 0.3806723952293396, -0.3961586356163025, 0.1876302808523178, -0.31341496109962463, 0.4877278804779053, -1.0598485469818115, -0.040077414363622665, 0.052168991416692734, -0.41626057028770447, 0.02491869032382965, -0.24520550668239594, -0.5395604372024536, -0.4308582842350006, -0.4223523437976837, 0.13282018899917603, 0.3436904549598694, -0.3178764879703522, 0.33327269554138184, 0.9350270628929138, -0.11198215186595917, -0.9216054677963257, -0.8763291239738464, -0.19046398997306824, -0.07609017938375473, -0.25628772377967834, -0.21901263296604156, -0.16012340784072876, -0.41069820523262024, -0.2873407006263733, -0.14800871908664703, -0.045267652720212936, -0.1404256373643875, 0.1721566915512085, 0.39809781312942505, 0.24917082488536835, -0.10107993334531784, -0.16396740078926086, -0.017074039205908775, 0.19957253336906433, -0.022238895297050476, 0.7104237079620361, 0.11374370753765106, -0.1045398861169815, 0.03269977495074272, 0.23824772238731384, 0.5322573781013489, -0.1063113734126091, 0.47453805804252625, 0.3486459255218506, -0.3195469379425049, 0.0418454110622406, -0.47590193152427673, -0.16055923700332642, -0.36687058210372925, 0.1373130977153778, -0.0993807464838028, -0.6410923004150391, 0.5072568655014038, 0.38306134939193726, 0.3111456632614136, 0.18021507561206818, 0.7919238209724426, 0.006380164995789528, 1.510000467300415, 0.5835164189338684, -0.6741571426391602, 0.22956062853336334, -0.09456835687160492, 0.16633906960487366, -0.5728320479393005, -0.18148992955684662, -0.7222508788108826, -0.395790159702301, -0.8835440278053284, -0.1893511861562729, 0.15348973870277405, -0.25566309690475464, -0.41349831223487854, -0.21836324036121368, -0.4719332754611969, 0.35100701451301575, 0.7420067191123962, 0.05121506378054619, 0.02718311734497547, 0.0745561346411705, -0.17113785445690155, -0.2785617709159851, -0.7561166882514954, -0.5409672856330872, 1.3509286642074585, 0.27544060349464417, 0.8991895914077759, 0.048205602914094925, 0.07265772670507431, 0.5178073644638062, 0.5719466805458069, -0.057364773005247116, 0.3992076814174652, -0.23677286505699158, -1.5329010486602783, -0.011856675148010254, -0.25904351472854614, -0.6852367520332336, 0.11985185742378235, -0.24810053408145905, -0.5705307126045227, 0.6142451167106628, 0.2734527587890625, -0.00386888743378222, 0.13301506638526917, -0.73851078748703, 0.5751083493232727, -0.14833980798721313, -0.9489656686782837, 0.14554184675216675, -0.9058684706687927, 0.3997298777103424, 0.15803977847099304, 0.5261746644973755, -0.5623049139976501, 0.36936673521995544, 0.9480124711990356, -0.2451104372739792, 0.7998816967010498, -0.4829862713813782, -0.0394199937582016, 0.20231176912784576, -0.22820140421390533, 0.1941814124584198, -0.23384948074817657, -0.2571200430393219, 0.38858720660209656, -0.21713358163833618, -0.6245566606521606, 0.04374071955680847, 0.22785691916942596, -0.778470516204834, -0.26372310519218445, -0.6340900659561157, -0.48748457431793213, -0.3283267617225647, 0.18354958295822144, 0.4251793324947357, 0.32637402415275574, 0.07140786945819855, 0.09159748256206512, 0.4035840332508087, -0.36662423610687256, 0.10822553932666779, 0.2623617649078369, -0.4610781669616699, -0.08677031099796295, 0.4814985394477844, 0.4054197371006012, 0.31155386567115784, 0.0020780230406671762, 0.32019326090812683, -0.31196460127830505, -0.01823093183338642, -0.5112404227256775, 0.32845810055732727, -0.2997210621833801, -0.00241945986635983, -0.41156652569770813, -0.03581058606505394, -0.43701040744781494, 0.07938241213560104, -0.5384581685066223, 0.003885821672156453, 0.33891943097114563, -0.276669442653656, 0.12771257758140564, 0.7187796235084534, -0.050246987491846085, 0.07545338571071625, -0.29867610335350037, 0.38002970814704895, 0.22073763608932495, 0.35186123847961426, -0.23659665882587433, -0.24925002455711365, -0.10398795455694199, 0.18557748198509216, -0.1260710507631302, -1.092917799949646, 0.3614133596420288, -0.02864357829093933, 0.5932372808456421, 0.234636589884758, 0.18203683197498322, 0.22362612187862396, -0.4460594058036804, 0.6883267164230347, -0.16491176187992096, -0.7012670040130615, 0.4062095880508423, -0.5000819563865662, -0.12182275205850601, 0.717978298664093, 0.5421358942985535, -0.3459564745426178, -0.4925249516963959, -0.6083434224128723, -0.7382853627204895, 0.9594637155532837, 0.11254696547985077, -0.04477802664041519, -0.08706843852996826, 0.0006803415017202497, 0.22460871934890747, 0.7260167002677917, -0.5944585800170898, -0.7402712106704712, -0.00968822743743658, -0.14162680506706238, -0.2494167983531952, -0.663765013217926, -0.4005967974662781, -0.030004648491740227, 0.6048315763473511, -0.0639449879527092, 0.32797154784202576, 0.12302858382463455, -0.12812958657741547, 0.05099625885486603, 0.3733249306678772, 0.36542147397994995, 0.7735966444015503, -0.3857400417327881, 0.2924796938896179, -0.030546560883522034, -0.6725772619247437, 0.36608177423477173, -0.01595347188413143, -0.4775763154029846, 0.08724524080753326, 0.22529201209545135, 0.6681583523750305, -0.2266862839460373, -0.6368453502655029, 0.4938841760158539, -0.016535667702555656, -0.27418938279151917, -0.22239454090595245, -0.1641046106815338, 0.012896799482405186, 0.15902429819107056, 0.4270849823951721, -0.13767769932746887, 0.1898089498281479, -0.9185535311698914, 0.0634804219007492, 0.3791545331478119, -0.7383172512054443, -0.46459338068962097, 0.8351850509643555, 0.24001853168010712, -0.00673625199124217, 0.4581087529659271, -0.18812142312526703, -0.733669638633728, 0.44262346625328064, 0.27827244997024536, 0.5611898303031921, -0.20471732318401337, 0.24588218331336975, 0.26732224225997925, 0.6347725987434387, -0.3014204502105713, 0.5785984992980957, 0.40336740016937256, -0.9669902920722961, -0.25344201922416687, -0.2306688129901886, -0.4123799800872803, 0.0008131889626383781, -0.6749752759933472, 0.3103092908859253, -0.37332651019096375, -0.2615795135498047, 0.05166107043623924, 0.048854343593120575, -0.5654580593109131, 0.07311656326055527, 0.11698076874017715, 0.9065382480621338, -1.512041449546814, 0.5009540319442749, 0.6940155029296875, -0.3185555040836334, -0.4878917932510376, 0.10885707288980484, 0.42856812477111816, -0.5357571244239807, 0.6433829069137573, 0.29396942257881165, 0.14440099895000458, -0.3872968554496765, -0.6666930913925171, -0.5736573338508606, 0.5515803694725037, 0.5635910034179688, -0.36652472615242004, 0.133037269115448, 0.32876724004745483, 0.5894776582717896, -0.38561496138572693, 0.42681121826171875, 0.8037866353988647, 0.6149804592132568, -0.5810832381248474, -0.7754929661750793, -0.2491830736398697, -0.300906777381897, -0.2352638691663742, -0.041632939130067825, -0.929056704044342, 0.8594152331352234, 0.08543933182954788, 0.05939929932355881, -0.6031600832939148, 0.30775186419487, 0.4614434540271759, 0.5216440558433533, 0.5000008344650269, 0.13748423755168915, 0.62325519323349, -0.36013975739479065, 0.9024858474731445, -0.20183277130126953, 0.2443855106830597, 1.345090627670288, -0.7427557110786438, 0.1833362877368927, 0.3683447539806366, -0.37765631079673767, 0.5453839302062988, 0.5907632112503052, 0.07553865015506744, 0.5409418940544128, 0.1090768352150917, -0.026741117238998413, 0.10077210515737534, -0.4553673267364502, -0.17958377301692963, 0.39360377192497253, 0.20560848712921143, -0.46007487177848816, -0.11052923649549484, -0.10841315239667892, 0.4864671528339386, 0.10968775302171707, -0.14560648798942566, 0.414651095867157, -0.10860571265220642, -0.6772165894508362, 0.24392569065093994, -0.31678780913352966, 0.6252782940864563, -0.5050958395004272, 0.11517155915498734, -0.40576037764549255, 0.21187742054462433, -0.3344447910785675, -0.7149307727813721, 0.054264239966869354, 0.02440684847533703, -0.31517302989959717, -0.17364147305488586, 0.7475135326385498, -0.47465935349464417, -0.40615275502204895, 0.4216425120830536, 0.544734001159668, 0.22954782843589783, -0.05512751266360283, -0.5362344980239868, 0.10823879390954971, 0.37075039744377136, -0.22289250791072845, 0.30933380126953125, 0.22774195671081543, -0.4791354238986969, 0.7655282616615295, 0.5092477202415466, 0.36042967438697815, 0.4866032302379608, 0.2933785319328308, 0.6273858547210693, -0.38402920961380005, -0.3405066728591919, -0.884679913520813, 0.29595404863357544, -0.4227452576160431, -0.21882882714271545, 0.9858819842338562, 0.7730896472930908, 0.7817592024803162, 0.12578333914279938, 1.0600367784500122, 0.027620617300271988, 0.9126046299934387, -0.16186892986297607, 0.652825653553009, -0.07437250018119812, 0.03258131071925163, -0.5853851437568665, -1.1211116313934326, -0.055888012051582336, 0.5152831077575684, -0.41459378600120544, 0.31146836280822754, 0.5478911995887756, 0.7775332927703857, 0.1063850075006485, 0.00033625264768488705, -0.14215534925460815, 0.402219295501709, 0.3276519477367401, 0.2400568276643753, 0.6941982507705688, -0.3807588815689087, 0.38338717818260193, -0.22491540014743805, -0.5017876625061035, -0.23773467540740967, -0.7599185109138489, -0.9245334267616272, -0.2650252878665924, -0.20144225656986237, -0.382461816072464, 0.3393997848033905, 0.8063108325004578, 0.7679197192192078, -0.737964928150177, -0.4624401330947876, 0.13560709357261658, 0.28305357694625854, -0.28793901205062866, -0.21689248085021973, 0.21924267709255219, -0.03203658014535904, -0.8327081203460693, -0.17414405941963196, 0.16116289794445038, -0.4464305341243744, -0.3308653235435486, 0.0628257468342781, -0.7000351548194885, 0.16249099373817444, 0.46487361192703247, 0.12255523353815079, -0.1884821206331253, -0.4535323977470398, -0.03408575430512428, -0.1975819319486618, 0.05430202931165695, 0.6183149814605713, -0.36787211894989014, 0.49510395526885986, 0.6463846564292908, 0.25622397661209106, 0.48173412680625916, -0.06478222459554672, 0.7356089949607849, -0.7890107035636902, 0.1287720948457718, -0.205185666680336, 0.3615289032459259, 0.5046093463897705, -0.02692813239991665, 0.9334043860435486, 0.3015267252922058, -0.6000572443008423, -1.0621455907821655, 0.3320420980453491, -0.3830016255378723, -0.09814029932022095, 1.196241021156311, 0.008109007962048054, -0.1544242799282074, -0.5427036881446838, -0.27136826515197754, 0.3222286105155945, -0.4024636447429657, 0.8907939195632935, 0.9985685348510742, -0.24351321160793304, -0.005141711328178644, -1.1407161951065063, 0.6259630918502808, 0.601004958152771, -0.6518757939338684, 0.5983079671859741, 0.5499830842018127, 0.27781304717063904, 0.161282479763031, 0.7823036909103394, -0.3634308874607086, 0.006202169694006443, -0.05552972853183746, 0.3828292191028595, 0.49317821860313416, -0.3634205758571625, 0.025244012475013733, -0.19169403612613678, 0.011897864751517773, -0.18243777751922607 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04818v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04818v1
DWE+: Dual-Way Matching Enhanced Framework for Multimodal Entity Linking
2024-04-07T05:56:42
2024-04-07T05:56:42
Shezheng Song, Shasha Li, Shan Zhao, Xiaopeng Li, Chengyu Wang, Jie Yu, Jun Ma, Tianwei Yan, Bin Ji, Xiaoguang Mao
cs.AI
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
Multimodal entity linking (MEL) aims to utilize multimodal information (usually textual and visual information) to link ambiguous mentions to unambiguous entities in knowledge base. Current methods facing main issues: (1)treating the entire image as input may contain redundant information. (2)the insufficient utilization of entity-related information, such as attributes in images. (3)semantic inconsistency between the entity in knowledge base and its representation. To this end, we propose DWE+ for multimodal entity linking. DWE+ could capture finer semantics and dynamically maintain semantic consistency with entities. This is achieved by three aspects: (a)we introduce a method for extracting fine-grained image features by partitioning the image into multiple local objects. Then, hierarchical contrastive learning is used to further align semantics between coarse-grained information(text and image) and fine-grained (mention and visual objects). (b)we explore ways to extract visual attributes from images to enhance fusion feature such as facial features and identity. (c)we leverage Wikipedia and ChatGPT to capture the entity representation, achieving semantic enrichment from both static and dynamic perspectives, which better reflects the real-world entity semantics. Experiments on Wikimel, Richpedia, and Wikidiverse datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of DWE+ in improving MEL performance. Specifically, we optimize these datasets and achieve state-of-the-art performance on the enhanced datasets. The code and enhanced datasets are released on https://github.com/season1blue/DWET
[ -0.7676461338996887, -0.7783195376396179, 0.3588774800300598, 0.1951259970664978, -0.25289151072502136, 0.3097643256187439, -0.10445669293403625, -1.024884819984436, 0.3630744218826294, 0.12133468687534332, -0.6254838109016418, -0.28801801800727844, -0.376324862241745, 0.13509272038936615, -0.18256105482578278, 0.5801069736480713, -0.18830838799476624, -0.1292683184146881, -0.6264012455940247, -0.3585417568683624, -0.2829630672931671, 0.14432385563850403, -0.6568847894668579, -0.158518984913826, 0.9312694072723389, 0.4147806465625763, 0.9997695088386536, 0.6134727001190186, 0.7592552304267883, 0.32554107904434204, 0.2966322898864746, 0.6048332452774048, -0.34997090697288513, 0.31391963362693787, -0.46385496854782104, -0.243400439620018, -0.7022697925567627, -0.03843614459037781, 0.5142770409584045, 0.4446820020675659, 0.11360766738653183, 0.2294609546661377, -0.08887170255184174, 0.5991777181625366, -0.6426661610603333, 0.26959988474845886, -0.7877265810966492, -0.12658551335334778, -0.4802928566932678, -0.2902761399745941, 0.09396719932556152, -0.09331682324409485, 0.013588741421699524, -0.9105356335639954, 0.06421585381031036, 0.2532908022403717, 0.8893014788627625, 0.2896368205547333, -0.9716182351112366, -0.27912697196006775, -0.34850385785102844, 0.5830094218254089, -0.4544376730918884, 0.4720955789089203, 0.25579187273979187, 0.20021702349185944, -0.29499420523643494, -0.7716550827026367, -1.241376280784607, -0.27885904908180237, -0.1217305064201355, 0.14440485835075378, 0.037988726049661636, 0.22573158144950867, 0.35455822944641113, 0.7790859341621399, -0.25676265358924866, -0.0022317483089864254, -0.10180994868278503, -0.2871212065219879, 0.8001079559326172, 0.08849738538265228, 0.584187924861908, -0.23697054386138916, -0.8072023987770081, -0.127854123711586, -0.5628684163093567, -0.3291832506656647, 0.4386711120605469, -0.047058429569005966, -0.1824348121881485, 0.7101215124130249, -0.11585257202386856, 0.6657268404960632, 0.0902663990855217, -0.34338998794555664, 0.5340619683265686, -0.3947151303291321, 0.09255807101726532, -0.057360827922821045, 0.6876708269119263, 0.8037415146827698, 0.01851237751543522, -0.2507019340991974, -0.017427027225494385, 0.46528929471969604, -0.15515825152397156, -0.7268563508987427, -0.30463287234306335, 0.05076029524207115, -0.32382187247276306, -0.33493077754974365, -0.07210461050271988, -1.1446701288223267, -0.5747908353805542, -0.5160114765167236, 0.5889503955841064, -0.3296531140804291, -0.6734888553619385, -0.11152984946966171, -0.3581269681453705, -0.10210783779621124, 0.2981700301170349, -0.815008819103241, 0.17333057522773743, 0.24977490305900574, 0.560761034488678, -0.25957635045051575, -0.3718969225883484, -0.17904138565063477, 0.6732128858566284, 0.1285935342311859, 0.5527638792991638, -0.6430729627609253, -0.2139674872159958, -0.18042834103107452, -0.08299624174833298, -0.04351689666509628, -0.5331118702888489, 0.3963579535484314, -0.6750128269195557, 0.020875100046396255, -0.2910440266132355, -0.5160837769508362, -0.29563724994659424, 0.2325213998556137, -0.9553325176239014, 1.1659177541732788, 0.048292260617017746, -1.0240594148635864, 0.4289160966873169, -0.7369204163551331, -0.6045722365379333, -0.0928826779127121, -0.4299188256263733, -0.058301061391830444, -0.05988086014986038, 0.08333888649940491, 0.32411906123161316, -0.2958903908729553, 0.41660723090171814, -0.7030803561210632, -0.1425592601299286, 0.009750298224389553, -0.4941365718841553, 0.5201737284660339, 0.11611407995223999, -0.5197192430496216, -0.08042898029088974, -1.2228055000305176, -0.17052288353443146, 0.32740187644958496, -0.3827093839645386, -0.7033728957176208, -0.02873414009809494, 0.06878842413425446, 0.5785433650016785, 0.37707608938217163, -0.6880401372909546, 0.3502153754234314, 0.014055714011192322, 0.2570731043815613, 0.5857868194580078, -0.11515139788389206, 0.5746424198150635, -0.03845783695578575, 0.10172086954116821, 0.34409570693969727, 0.0864252820611, -0.019729020074009895, -0.5081496834754944, -0.7911180257797241, -0.42131227254867554, 0.3245440721511841, 0.5662605166435242, -1.1712645292282104, 0.26986435055732727, -0.26330670714378357, -0.11894995719194412, -0.6781852841377258, 0.2078656107187271, 0.16094325482845306, 0.773514449596405, 0.5888200402259827, -0.2705269753932953, -0.7416340708732605, -1.0706039667129517, 0.22893844544887543, -0.032587144523859024, -0.028677362948656082, 0.5556982159614563, 0.36879056692123413, -0.600303590297699, 0.7437850832939148, -0.4151017367839813, -0.16969841718673706, 0.16761569678783417, -0.03722301125526428, -0.3437725305557251, 0.373798131942749, 0.5693961381912231, -1.4467488527297974, -0.5561491250991821, 0.05875014141201973, -0.9949696063995361, 0.12573885917663574, 0.22999967634677887, -0.5338976979255676, -0.2289462685585022, 0.2240375578403473, -0.6192760467529297, 0.3356451690196991, 0.8135926127433777, -0.28924840688705444, 0.2299993336200714, 0.04494316130876541, 0.5489946603775024, -1.3205220699310303, 0.0991908460855484, 0.1495121568441391, -0.36536461114883423, -0.19082777202129364, 0.07329119741916656, 0.14576856791973114, -0.15735484659671783, -0.05695921182632446, 0.588240921497345, -0.628400444984436, 0.10014177858829498, -0.19236032664775848, 0.499414324760437, 0.34301871061325073, 0.5502844452857971, -0.07483580708503723, 0.7078452706336975, 0.8101163506507874, -0.6687678098678589, 1.0183485746383667, 0.229595348238945, -0.0344545878469944, 0.8180760145187378, -0.20144173502922058, 0.09113571047782898, -0.1917591392993927, 0.25247323513031006, -0.8692413568496704, -0.3137070834636688, 0.184116929769516, -0.0763506144285202, 0.8343128561973572, 0.24499589204788208, -0.3633493483066559, -0.4286573529243469, -0.613586962223053, 0.47285619378089905, -0.00532122328877449, -0.6233251690864563, 0.6720117926597595, 0.5433917045593262, -0.05401616543531418, -0.6803448796272278, -0.6415060758590698, 0.3417262136936188, -0.07441277801990509, -0.8909229636192322, 1.0485368967056274, -0.0805308148264885, -0.1880926489830017, 0.42270392179489136, -0.29071497917175293, -0.03230080008506775, -0.06321936845779419, 0.20197437703609467, 0.4650222957134247, -0.19286005198955536, 0.16910095512866974, 0.18392089009284973, -0.05570215731859207, -0.3748961091041565, -0.06273189187049866, 0.22525028884410858, 0.09626363962888718, -0.35380372405052185, -0.47234079241752625, 0.6627826690673828, 0.7229254245758057, -0.22844719886779785, 0.7676082849502563, 1.0198456048965454, -0.4096638560295105, 0.3835746645927429, -0.7856385111808777, -0.039440736174583435, -0.4617345631122589, 0.4154179096221924, -0.6301009058952332, -0.7450857162475586, 0.5563074350357056, -0.33147671818733215, 0.05082779377698898, 0.5800289511680603, 0.19982104003429413, -0.24852296710014343, 0.8991513252258301, 0.9320727586746216, -0.06470125913619995, 0.5676751732826233, -0.12002266943454742, 0.12457051873207092, -0.9433470964431763, -0.5227147936820984, 0.003737048013135791, -0.6575917601585388, -0.779636025428772, -0.3997892439365387, 0.14557155966758728, 0.42688921093940735, 0.19888877868652344, 0.40899357199668884, -0.31713345646858215, 0.09607820212841034, 0.6325911283493042, 0.4398031234741211, 0.49763554334640503, 0.05649217590689659, -0.26124709844589233, -0.06991270929574966, -0.5779709219932556, -0.28273189067840576, 0.7339847087860107, 0.2740524113178253, 0.9661497473716736, 0.3107411861419678, 0.516278088092804, 0.12311922758817673, 0.19424165785312653, -0.6270633935928345, 0.6558026671409607, 0.034962620586156845, -0.7381983995437622, -0.12683795392513275, -0.6221480369567871, -0.716101884841919, 0.23457929491996765, -0.6020953059196472, -0.4264886677265167, 0.44399550557136536, 0.33703717589378357, 0.18574969470500946, 0.3921760320663452, -0.7524418234825134, 0.7373126745223999, -0.2659614682197571, -0.6691434383392334, -0.5015813112258911, -0.7943961024284363, 0.2758687734603882, 0.09703107178211212, 0.1563624143600464, -0.3793967664241791, -0.35808491706848145, 0.4548357129096985, -0.010192245244979858, 0.49111148715019226, -0.18468962609767914, -0.2579154968261719, 0.24033281207084656, -0.12045715749263763, 0.415296345949173, 0.34284353256225586, -0.018009349703788757, 0.24706007540225983, -0.11380466818809509, -0.3528866469860077, -0.622019350528717, 1.0755062103271484, -0.44169026613235474, -0.5822662711143494, -0.01027442142367363, -0.5998991131782532, -0.3796060085296631, 0.04414929822087288, 0.11640025675296783, 0.6980917453765869, 0.02630617842078209, 0.08905359357595444, 0.7422953248023987, -0.05108417943120003, 0.3866971433162689, 0.3848743736743927, -0.12009534239768982, -0.5000925660133362, 0.8188467025756836, -0.25924164056777954, 0.22748413681983948, 0.6621056795120239, -0.25180163979530334, -0.5241149067878723, -0.2542397975921631, -0.8958052396774292, 0.0810723528265953, -0.6852064728736877, -0.58482426404953, -0.5883297920227051, 0.1363656222820282, -0.25560104846954346, 0.19928377866744995, -0.14184372127056122, -0.3818250298500061, -0.0007904509548097849, 0.00873627234250307, 0.582689642906189, 0.4161129295825958, -0.09208562225103378, -0.4623119831085205, -0.710976779460907, 0.6896026730537415, 0.49603211879730225, 0.6188868284225464, 0.14524836838245392, 0.12917295098304749, -0.036195605993270874, 0.17199212312698364, -0.21972858905792236, -1.080979347229004, -0.46308383345603943, 0.42989838123321533, 0.7325232028961182, 0.264622300863266, -0.05635761842131615, 1.0110152959823608, -0.6081620454788208, 0.4430989921092987, 0.5072765350341797, -0.5903728008270264, 0.6281136274337769, -0.18738731741905212, -0.0920625701546669, 0.6113278269767761, 0.5210519433021545, -0.4243719279766083, -0.23407219350337982, -0.3786161541938782, -0.9701856374740601, 0.207523375749588, 0.13388265669345856, 0.16688592731952667, -0.298419326543808, 0.34554481506347656, 0.04747970402240753, 0.2422567456960678, -0.6762945055961609, -0.5664993524551392, 0.007903102785348892, -0.5302851796150208, 0.29029935598373413, -0.4301833510398865, -0.19936463236808777, -0.4279313087463379, 0.6748719811439514, -0.08538590371608734, 0.21879024803638458, 0.32896697521209717, -0.4521271288394928, -0.13322333991527557, 0.0901649072766304, 0.2110779732465744, 0.6799871325492859, -0.03128216043114662, 0.32811102271080017, 0.17719008028507233, -0.5672858357429504, 0.11257766932249069, 0.43274161219596863, 0.0511254146695137, 0.07885415852069855, 0.17980816960334778, 0.7816810011863708, 0.48493027687072754, -0.38983261585235596, 0.5585100054740906, -0.02220628224313259, 0.04808572679758072, 0.08643107861280441, 0.020496072247624397, 0.19769740104675293, 0.4445362389087677, 0.4245762825012207, 0.20899945497512817, 0.3619539141654968, -0.7470423579216003, 0.3409218192100525, 0.4800789952278137, -0.22219964861869812, -0.2732454240322113, 0.692455530166626, 0.7813409566879272, 0.21905268728733063, 0.3833295404911041, -0.25790390372276306, -0.3423534631729126, 0.2725696861743927, 0.5998356938362122, 0.3945601284503937, -0.04378887638449669, -0.1081131100654602, 0.3232940137386322, -0.07837223261594772, 0.23725542426109314, 0.1826140433549881, -0.39647746086120605, -0.7225866913795471, -0.4499695599079132, -0.7097541689872742, -0.1166999489068985, -0.03958339989185333, -0.6846300959587097, 0.3013521730899811, 0.05762014165520668, -0.29969581961631775, 0.19265921413898468, 0.09575585275888443, -0.7932577729225159, 0.22530898451805115, 0.38684162497520447, 0.9899144172668457, -0.4806153178215027, 0.8805462121963501, 0.9520862102508545, -0.6157479882240295, -0.6308804750442505, -0.14291344583034515, 0.06513944268226624, -0.6394223570823669, 0.3470970392227173, 0.05497825890779495, -0.28270766139030457, 0.25101515650749207, -0.06263221055269241, -0.8621585369110107, 1.413953423500061, 0.48722168803215027, -0.8603780269622803, -0.06839683651924133, -0.3355620801448822, 0.07718612253665924, -0.11766637861728668, 0.042945705354213715, 0.11324518918991089, 0.4853801131248474, 0.3713836371898651, -1.073225975036621, 0.19810044765472412, -0.24531365931034088, 0.04537779465317726, 0.5405317544937134, -0.5297467112541199, 0.3841376006603241, -0.2882367968559265, -0.3554374575614929, -0.031923290342092514, 0.6627739071846008, -0.12642520666122437, 0.5322505235671997, 0.5694286823272705, 0.7506634593009949, 0.8161308169364929, 0.040991801768541336, 0.6985685229301453, -0.3350549638271332, 0.41844868659973145, 0.9024487733840942, -0.4436321556568146, 0.8238113522529602, 0.6367499828338623, -0.2509843111038208, 0.7198765277862549, 0.4393054246902466, -0.035676825791597366, 0.7969374060630798, -0.1714344322681427, -0.7012883424758911, 0.03043440729379654, -0.19862432777881622, -0.5711994767189026, 0.21348245441913605, 0.30856695771217346, -0.20952481031417847, -0.314739465713501, 0.1916894167661667, -0.12674850225448608, 0.13610199093818665, -0.44863781332969666, 0.7912251353263855, 0.04796725884079933, -0.26969775557518005, 0.13019822537899017, -0.023979978635907173, 1.1463569402694702, -0.5486647486686707, -0.23408563435077667, -0.0694417878985405, 0.03458426892757416, -0.5092658400535583, -0.788467526435852, 0.1859760731458664, -0.2584313154220581, -0.3583018481731415, 0.1599675416946411, 1.2306157350540161, -0.8084288835525513, -0.23397208750247955, 0.4974830746650696, 0.2590765655040741, -0.234230637550354, 0.08810918033123016, -0.849033772945404, -0.03524981066584587, 0.005487778689712286, -0.18882523477077484, 0.3698347806930542, 0.5344169735908508, -0.0854860469698906, 0.5221441388130188, 0.5429244637489319, -0.2855299711227417, -0.021032407879829407, 0.26424431800842285, 1.0617412328720093, -0.5724049806594849, -0.047768328338861465, -0.9361431002616882, 0.5657797455787659, -0.5791390538215637, -0.09200260788202286, 0.745110034942627, 0.6819813847541809, 0.9140737652778625, 0.15109537541866302, 0.5802645683288574, -0.5145480036735535, 0.012738450430333614, -0.409582257270813, 0.2410011887550354, -0.7970800399780273, -0.17809520661830902, -0.32095396518707275, -1.1226527690887451, -0.13079951703548431, 0.435065895318985, 0.17816591262817383, 0.020370056852698326, 0.5784659385681152, 0.7894718050956726, -0.402662456035614, -0.035899899899959564, 0.34560707211494446, -0.22801263630390167, -0.048733875155448914, 0.4529455900192261, 0.7954532504081726, -0.5404441952705383, 0.6294127702713013, -0.302205890417099, -0.3967338502407074, -0.145697683095932, -0.9902668595314026, -0.6497182250022888, -0.6395576000213623, -0.6171507835388184, -0.27521905303001404, -0.11874475330114365, 0.670358419418335, 0.794444739818573, -0.5098795890808105, 0.4373762011528015, 0.084456667304039, 0.036473389714956284, -0.06551776081323624, -0.2281201034784317, 0.20338517427444458, 0.0023738443851470947, -0.745884358882904, 0.2571568787097931, 0.7676743865013123, 0.23696400225162506, -0.35850611329078674, 0.023916184902191162, -0.36718159914016724, -0.18276922404766083, 0.7307906746864319, -0.0497489869594574, -0.6284655928611755, -0.2475241869688034, -0.16064806282520294, -0.3142697811126709, 0.0808759480714798, 0.6486514806747437, -0.42903777956962585, 0.5187631249427795, 0.3328174650669098, 0.5053791999816895, 0.6523951292037964, -0.12285805493593216, 0.4109116792678833, -0.861679196357727, 0.4292357563972473, 0.16313162446022034, 0.48564663529396057, 0.559597909450531, -0.49101004004478455, 0.44304078817367554, 0.35253408551216125, -0.2338499277830124, -0.48853743076324463, 0.4436047077178955, -1.1252704858779907, -0.001802208018489182, 0.9510773420333862, -0.18528999388217926, -0.04114680737257004, -0.001875168178230524, -0.32296180725097656, 0.3569567799568176, -0.22360005974769592, 0.5266618132591248, 0.5716896653175354, -0.013514654710888863, -0.08532927930355072, -0.6256900429725647, 0.5084863901138306, -0.09695277363061905, -0.6878403425216675, -0.27991151809692383, 0.575745165348053, 0.4115266501903534, 0.31748995184898376, 0.5265337824821472, -0.23582389950752258, 0.20000040531158447, 0.3117859959602356, 0.11692168563604355, -0.2447400838136673, -0.2177010178565979, 0.2905930280685425, -0.1141345351934433, -0.053269267082214355, -0.4948485493659973 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04817v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04817v1
FRACTAL: Fine-Grained Scoring from Aggregate Text Labels
2024-04-07T05:54:28
2024-04-07T05:54:28
Yukti Makhija, Priyanka Agrawal, Rishi Saket, Aravindan Raghuveer
cs.CL
cs.CL
Large language models (LLMs) are being increasingly tuned to power complex generation tasks such as writing, fact-seeking, querying and reasoning. Traditionally, human or model feedback for evaluating and further tuning LLM performance has been provided at the response level, enabling faster and more cost-effective assessments. However, recent works (Amplayo et al. [2022], Wu et al. [2023]) indicate that sentence-level labels may provide more accurate and interpretable feedback for LLM optimization. In this work, we introduce methods to disaggregate response-level labels into sentence-level (pseudo-)labels. Our approach leverages multiple instance learning (MIL) and learning from label proportions (LLP) techniques in conjunction with prior information (e.g., document-sentence cosine similarity) to train a specialized model for sentence-level scoring. We also employ techniques which use model predictions to pseudo-label the train-set at the sentence-level for model training to further improve performance. We conduct extensive evaluations of our methods across six datasets and four tasks: retrieval, question answering, summarization, and math reasoning. Our results demonstrate improved performance compared to multiple baselines across most of these tasks. Our work is the first to develop response-level feedback to sentence-level scoring techniques, leveraging sentence-level prior information, along with comprehensive evaluations on multiple tasks as well as end-to-end finetuning evaluation showing performance comparable to a model trained on fine-grained human annotated labels.
[ -0.4425896108150482, -1.3156683444976807, 0.43388447165489197, 0.12324999272823334, -0.06936565786600113, -0.24172909557819366, -0.31719326972961426, -0.24206742644309998, -0.21876665949821472, 0.27197402715682983, -0.4680294692516327, -0.7496651411056519, -0.5053641200065613, 0.23507794737815857, -0.17138202488422394, 1.2669990062713623, 0.21343721449375153, -0.09629171341657639, -0.5734087824821472, -0.04449545592069626, -0.27823951840400696, -0.6360552906990051, -0.7111072540283203, -0.4286237359046936, 0.5856562852859497, 0.36038267612457275, 0.4010312259197235, 0.6640458106994629, 0.5435647964477539, 0.396781861782074, -0.2168099284172058, 0.2999299466609955, -0.7152714133262634, 0.1568666696548462, 0.08587620407342911, -0.534853994846344, -0.665047287940979, 0.32858148217201233, 0.8086175322532654, 0.7707842588424683, -0.3536193370819092, 0.3386145532131195, 0.36438798904418945, 0.5966706871986389, -0.4546608626842499, 0.512582540512085, -0.6312273144721985, 0.25567305088043213, -0.13473278284072876, -0.13366183638572693, -0.765516459941864, -0.6117594838142395, 0.019740263000130653, -0.5846258401870728, 0.1369384080171585, 0.310700923204422, 0.6993523240089417, 0.43501731753349304, -0.08305808156728745, -0.45384901762008667, -0.43494153022766113, 1.095956802368164, -0.6491243243217468, 0.0958491712808609, 0.4277570843696594, -0.016848240047693253, -0.09796185791492462, -0.6654472947120667, -0.29517465829849243, -0.34851062297821045, -0.27057865262031555, 0.19552795588970184, -0.43748384714126587, 0.11400432884693146, 0.30147862434387207, 0.5941324234008789, -0.4242350161075592, 0.3100953698158264, -0.10274778306484222, -0.3507359027862549, 0.6250975728034973, 0.39715176820755005, -0.07569025456905365, -0.06392199546098709, -0.2277347445487976, -0.1448570340871811, -0.4415968060493469, 0.27773740887641907, 0.12813478708267212, 0.4512852132320404, -0.08922765403985977, 0.5905914902687073, -0.07940838485956192, 1.0719412565231323, 0.33601054549217224, -0.36216601729393005, 0.16583876311779022, -0.21263745427131653, -0.3250526785850525, 0.16714955866336823, 0.9901715517044067, 0.33036333322525024, 0.20706294476985931, 0.0022032870911061764, -0.3857227563858032, -0.034385018050670624, 0.1540636271238327, -0.909755527973175, -0.3773539960384369, -0.010920071974396706, -0.47195079922676086, -0.4265022277832031, -0.024902544915676117, -0.9085395336151123, -0.3247222900390625, -0.4220852553844452, 0.49914759397506714, -0.5590132474899292, 0.3843207061290741, 0.028173407539725304, 0.24849487841129303, -0.2497672289609909, 0.2702719271183014, -0.8477086424827576, 0.285779744386673, 0.5499113202095032, 1.0426092147827148, 0.18420396745204926, -0.3559193015098572, -1.1750081777572632, -0.020215623080730438, -0.31630340218544006, 0.8966056108474731, -0.7726393938064575, -0.3921988010406494, -0.03475164622068405, -0.4428705871105194, -0.2413019835948944, -0.6235806345939636, 0.4106227457523346, -0.3388882577419281, 0.5029643177986145, -0.11869588494300842, -0.8085344433784485, -0.15523765981197357, 0.3794219493865967, -0.6951981782913208, 1.1282835006713867, 0.05213232338428497, -0.726779580116272, 0.2666260302066803, -0.5591328144073486, -0.5622959136962891, -0.10772106796503067, 0.00010651261254679412, -0.6689639091491699, 0.22960412502288818, 0.2913663387298584, 0.7443764805793762, -0.23285725712776184, 0.03038615919649601, -0.31731554865837097, -0.18405111134052277, 0.11446714401245117, -0.5578654408454895, 0.35266226530075073, 0.35603731870651245, -0.11047808080911636, 0.3096742630004883, -0.818511962890625, 0.054698046296834946, -0.36494383215904236, -0.7983753681182861, -0.35092729330062866, 0.00873635895550251, -0.25493186712265015, 0.02411295659840107, 0.4355611205101013, -0.3212515115737915, 0.32615599036216736, -0.33931511640548706, 0.31088417768478394, 0.6926737427711487, -0.02334260381758213, 0.43313756585121155, -0.3664468228816986, 0.36841291189193726, 0.04232577234506607, 0.12975497543811798, -0.3007507920265198, -0.4818611741065979, -0.7267977595329285, -0.31320130825042725, 0.25865745544433594, 0.485324501991272, -0.5645991563796997, 0.7927600145339966, -0.1416902244091034, -0.4782349169254303, -0.6328586339950562, 0.30904829502105713, 0.5362569093704224, 0.8375681638717651, 0.5522170662879944, -0.009232702665030956, -0.20366287231445312, -0.794956386089325, -0.2677472233772278, -0.167770117521286, -0.026839040219783783, 0.26793569326400757, 0.11888498067855835, 0.08741790056228638, 0.9306198358535767, -1.0064327716827393, -0.731120228767395, -0.3979983627796173, 0.6291341185569763, 0.18840771913528442, 0.16385135054588318, 0.33550477027893066, -0.5649425387382507, -0.3760826885700226, -0.004674112424254417, -0.6281378269195557, -0.38988545536994934, -0.2261234074831009, 0.24052229523658752, 0.2509545683860779, 0.7063118815422058, -0.27688202261924744, -0.012037382461130619, 0.6063586473464966, -0.3343474566936493, 0.34297311305999756, -0.47729459404945374, 0.23385341465473175, -1.021408200263977, -0.0943579226732254, 0.5875178575515747, -0.30459046363830566, -0.3923594057559967, -0.12120026350021362, -0.2265317738056183, 0.17285588383674622, -0.19361425936222076, 0.25149214267730713, -0.44637247920036316, 0.18221797049045563, -0.17895923554897308, 0.049583349376916885, -0.11880404502153397, 0.4319458603858948, -0.21645089983940125, 0.9914504289627075, 0.423528254032135, -0.6474572420120239, 0.21549531817436218, -0.06239436939358711, -0.5640833973884583, 0.39067327976226807, -0.4743134677410126, 0.04803849384188652, -0.1740449070930481, 0.24960453808307648, -1.0310916900634766, -0.17913182079792023, -0.16955092549324036, -0.12343350052833557, 0.18835608661174774, 0.11443439871072769, -0.5506841540336609, -0.24948740005493164, -0.3726613223552704, 0.2303793579339981, 0.5360778570175171, -0.33406761288642883, 0.5881264805793762, 0.5195908546447754, -0.20718176662921906, -0.1855887621641159, -0.5527015924453735, -0.25847679376602173, -0.289797842502594, -0.350119948387146, 0.1337754726409912, -0.09269217401742935, -0.38146546483039856, -0.26245275139808655, 0.08115486800670624, -0.10637512803077698, 0.16317090392112732, 0.07656321674585342, 0.13871946930885315, -0.2817542552947998, 0.30034083127975464, 0.28787872195243835, -0.16446690261363983, -0.11074993759393692, -0.14298002421855927, 0.6588370203971863, -0.49156299233436584, 0.08044491708278656, -0.4767453372478485, 0.26020756363868713, 0.2592200040817261, -0.21187423169612885, 0.7919686436653137, 0.7505818605422974, -0.23512086272239685, -0.22193558514118195, -0.3872796893119812, -0.08020171523094177, -0.45611730217933655, 0.4044387936592102, -0.4767491817474365, -1.3968685865402222, 0.1862616240978241, -0.22421932220458984, 0.1994437724351883, 0.5473988056182861, 0.8268786072731018, -0.22503134608268738, 0.9697080254554749, 0.7232806086540222, -0.29009145498275757, 0.42449161410331726, -0.23665064573287964, 0.2951640188694, -0.5315256714820862, -0.29700520634651184, -0.4930323660373688, -0.31106385588645935, -0.28185734152793884, -0.42482447624206543, 0.5008087158203125, 0.5130325555801392, -0.05426066741347313, 0.05678801238536835, -0.42399755120277405, 0.7011540532112122, 0.3403952121734619, 0.12913447618484497, 0.4098847806453705, 0.07203581929206848, -0.014836315996944904, -0.1281665861606598, -0.7681233286857605, -0.5918605923652649, 0.8165969848632812, 0.38659581542015076, 0.7391741871833801, 0.06504594534635544, 0.776958167552948, 0.5138167142868042, 0.5688436627388, -0.8752813935279846, 0.5489143133163452, -0.5788455009460449, -0.05792933329939842, -0.5290471315383911, -0.7881759405136108, -0.7869123816490173, 0.3144749104976654, -0.19637905061244965, -0.8793484568595886, -0.2514285445213318, 0.3661331832408905, -0.6799080967903137, 0.014346358366310596, -0.969463050365448, 0.8400387763977051, 0.028299501165747643, -0.23749487102031708, -0.24226339161396027, -0.3185563385486603, 0.3539169728755951, -0.2792970538139343, 0.40034690499305725, 0.08213173598051071, 0.039222102612257004, 0.7270299196243286, -0.4623059332370758, 1.086217999458313, 0.10024479776620865, -0.3717917799949646, 0.40567269921302795, 0.0422000028192997, 0.2979736030101776, 0.020518174394965172, -0.3862077295780182, 0.1103835254907608, -0.1603223979473114, -0.15455277264118195, -0.47488248348236084, 0.9440463185310364, -0.7633217573165894, -0.6377776265144348, -0.19504815340042114, -0.7965774536132812, -0.2362256944179535, 0.14735670387744904, 0.28944307565689087, 0.536474347114563, -0.10086807608604431, 0.2658943831920624, 0.8779820203781128, -0.021862074732780457, 0.5740518569946289, 0.17401383817195892, -0.1778992861509323, -0.42017826437950134, 0.9346228837966919, 0.08799518644809723, 0.19418244063854218, 0.6783500909805298, 0.4603355824947357, -0.53251051902771, -0.43322616815567017, -0.21026289463043213, -0.0586763434112072, -0.4367387890815735, -0.44319039583206177, -0.6132635474205017, 0.03469950705766678, -0.3957255184650421, 0.033869314938783646, -0.07592742890119553, -0.2769162952899933, -0.39389878511428833, -0.12003248929977417, 0.344222754240036, 0.8436064124107361, -0.03108483925461769, 0.5592097043991089, -0.8836569786071777, 0.32246729731559753, 0.3041582703590393, 0.3596401810646057, 0.14520469307899475, -0.5955079197883606, -0.33513695001602173, 0.010539506562054157, -0.4608456790447235, -0.5351418256759644, 0.16402177512645721, 0.462626188993454, 0.39023032784461975, 0.39411112666130066, -0.04644858092069626, 0.8486159443855286, -0.6219969391822815, 0.8262115716934204, 0.3683215081691742, -1.1151217222213745, 0.6165512800216675, -0.16983909904956818, 0.4097153842449188, 0.6629703044891357, 0.4054948687553406, -0.1759617030620575, -0.5089928507804871, -0.22644875943660736, -0.8734120726585388, 0.9214021563529968, 0.16976411640644073, 0.03547323867678642, -0.14223282039165497, 0.39971819519996643, 0.18753953278064728, 0.17190471291542053, -0.8589552640914917, -0.22694899141788483, -0.07466648519039154, -0.5712308287620544, -0.2851526141166687, -0.26112645864486694, -0.14001917839050293, -0.3751530349254608, 0.5424215197563171, -0.24504882097244263, -0.23043854534626007, 0.11567652970552444, -0.20196615159511566, 0.004150580149143934, 0.3329976499080658, 0.6452805399894714, 0.3636505901813507, -0.13371533155441284, 0.2379280924797058, 0.20904375612735748, -0.5056443214416504, 0.10622984170913696, 0.09227533638477325, -0.0751667320728302, -0.07496456056833267, 0.6489530205726624, 0.5756470561027527, 0.21179425716400146, -0.38269492983818054, 0.24585215747356415, 0.05256440490484238, -0.1240084320306778, 0.1939849853515625, 0.249458447098732, 0.0688735619187355, 0.18218585848808289, 0.25115227699279785, -0.11356505751609802, 0.21548743546009064, -0.6179078817367554, 0.48708048462867737, 0.10557335615158081, -0.6207414269447327, -0.06485486775636673, 0.6141921281814575, 0.1585337519645691, -0.3624124228954315, 0.5533015131950378, -0.21397186815738678, -0.2668469250202179, 0.476890504360199, 0.49479031562805176, 0.6551486849784851, -0.32590556144714355, 0.3987346887588501, 0.46945613622665405, 0.18419475853443146, -0.16490282118320465, -0.06492988020181656, -0.16707296669483185, -0.4834904074668884, -0.47707629203796387, -1.0569040775299072, 0.05834551155567169, 0.2098637968301773, -0.7378145456314087, 0.08391715586185455, -0.6196356415748596, -0.3451513946056366, 0.25643542408943176, 0.06203863024711609, -0.2553933560848236, 0.4250582754611969, 0.22854405641555786, 0.7834437489509583, -0.9330286383628845, 0.8234888911247253, 0.9124098420143127, -0.577180027961731, -0.8750308752059937, 0.2388336956501007, -0.011426042765378952, -0.45269399881362915, 0.604040265083313, 0.2987048625946045, -0.22655241191387177, 0.2278149425983429, -0.3204992711544037, -0.6846050024032593, 0.9763379096984863, 0.22262407839298248, -0.997320830821991, 0.18190906941890717, 0.22476248443126678, 0.7869430780410767, -0.5005446672439575, 0.4064617156982422, 0.5940065979957581, 0.37856465578079224, -0.06203770637512207, -0.8384043574333191, -0.0997849777340889, 0.008377830497920513, 0.12232973426580429, 0.2561846375465393, -0.7392073273658752, 0.8916409611701965, -0.12772497534751892, 0.07465577870607376, 0.1019364520907402, 0.8639571666717529, 0.42262548208236694, 0.35362836718559265, 0.7189202308654785, 0.7555416822433472, 0.868744432926178, -0.27083516120910645, 1.1518621444702148, -0.13486415147781372, 0.7453935146331787, 1.0663813352584839, -0.08839717507362366, 0.8531206846237183, 0.38412967324256897, -0.20347373187541962, 0.4694242477416992, 0.6859740018844604, -0.06620308756828308, 0.5404121279716492, 0.37788960337638855, -0.2471550703048706, -0.6723157167434692, -0.19001124799251556, -0.15848219394683838, 0.34827354550361633, 0.2943696677684784, -0.27166420221328735, -0.4954814910888672, -0.07887732237577438, 0.09867457300424576, 0.4971466064453125, -0.48467159271240234, 0.9689662456512451, 0.15442794561386108, -0.6227923631668091, 0.4552771747112274, 0.11109120398759842, 0.6748868823051453, -0.5005862712860107, -0.17700935900211334, -0.43825793266296387, 0.39453035593032837, -0.30387550592422485, -0.9389490485191345, 0.22161515057086945, 0.2254200428724289, -0.5612310767173767, -0.1790657788515091, 0.2830071747303009, -0.6143409013748169, -0.8572543859481812, 0.08952654153108597, 0.22965700924396515, 0.1908506453037262, 0.14295022189617157, -0.8109875917434692, 0.13406051695346832, 0.13004763424396515, -0.3496435582637787, 0.4280819594860077, 0.6669415235519409, -0.08423493802547455, 0.6301254034042358, 0.49011367559432983, -0.008960304781794548, 0.009534497745335102, 0.5249110460281372, 0.7862375378608704, -0.5050257444381714, -0.46625953912734985, -1.069379210472107, 0.19773083925247192, -0.14467112720012665, -0.42347368597984314, 0.6116446256637573, 0.9621224403381348, 0.7361539006233215, -0.03054630756378174, 0.6024184226989746, 0.09725453704595566, 0.3657945990562439, -0.8990872502326965, 0.7553173899650574, -0.6075741648674011, 0.4680350720882416, -0.3339691758155823, -1.064605951309204, -0.4547208547592163, 0.6995347738265991, -0.44647231698036194, 0.09190388023853302, 0.712592363357544, 0.5089520812034607, -0.06488155573606491, -0.07814637571573257, 0.3796018064022064, 0.45564112067222595, 0.3795830309391022, 0.6618016362190247, 0.7372949719429016, -0.33650296926498413, 0.6938381195068359, -0.23222792148590088, -0.42647284269332886, -0.04756965860724449, -0.7204688191413879, -0.9279466271400452, -0.5531497001647949, -0.5040240287780762, -0.06660769879817963, -0.09558228403329849, 0.5858939290046692, 0.5264058113098145, -0.7567113637924194, -0.3724147379398346, -0.021691400557756424, 0.09033273160457611, -0.07892914861440659, -0.30748066306114197, 0.3321639895439148, -0.8012287616729736, -0.7558805346488953, 0.13812153041362762, 0.4142020046710968, -0.18085163831710815, -0.05471217632293701, 0.0726175308227539, -0.1936269998550415, -0.04851161688566208, 0.9077467918395996, -0.23722539842128754, -0.7204006910324097, -0.2377234846353531, -0.31925636529922485, -0.2306259721517563, 0.030904293060302734, 0.8140175342559814, -0.7273472547531128, 0.10163182020187378, 0.3028709888458252, 0.3386796712875366, 0.19646047055721283, 0.35870179533958435, 0.4900484085083008, -0.8053699731826782, 0.0950905829668045, 0.21302349865436554, 0.2853100895881653, 0.2555847764015198, -0.4815579354763031, 0.2233467549085617, 0.031588438898324966, -0.45543625950813293, -0.5751323699951172, 0.1072755977511406, -0.9882342219352722, -0.46644750237464905, 1.152512550354004, -0.3770323395729065, -0.2406313270330429, 0.06260409206151962, -0.26102593541145325, 0.13901570439338684, -0.5427889823913574, 1.145916223526001, 0.8386310338973999, -0.3617806136608124, -0.05838949233293533, -0.009420582093298435, 0.5628985166549683, 0.4562056362628937, -0.9837216138839722, 0.14969900250434875, 0.8997626304626465, 0.09109983593225479, 0.3258555829524994, 0.5119454264640808, -0.04695858806371689, -0.016535822302103043, -0.14950890839099884, -0.14461150765419006, -0.10623389482498169, -0.4385581612586975, -0.39033517241477966, 0.6122750043869019, -0.010145249776542187, -0.1806773990392685 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04809v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04809v1
Low-Resource Machine Translation through Retrieval-Augmented LLM Prompting: A Study on the Mambai Language
2024-04-07T05:04:38
2024-04-07T05:04:38
Raphaël Merx, Aso Mahmudi, Katrina Langford, Leo Alberto de Araujo, Ekaterina Vylomova
cs.CL
cs.CL
This study explores the use of large language models (LLMs) for translating English into Mambai, a low-resource Austronesian language spoken in Timor-Leste, with approximately 200,000 native speakers. Leveraging a novel corpus derived from a Mambai language manual and additional sentences translated by a native speaker, we examine the efficacy of few-shot LLM prompting for machine translation (MT) in this low-resource context. Our methodology involves the strategic selection of parallel sentences and dictionary entries for prompting, aiming to enhance translation accuracy, using open-source and proprietary LLMs (LlaMa 2 70b, Mixtral 8x7B, GPT-4). We find that including dictionary entries in prompts and a mix of sentences retrieved through TF-IDF and semantic embeddings significantly improves translation quality. However, our findings reveal stark disparities in translation performance across test sets, with BLEU scores reaching as high as 21.2 on materials from the language manual, in contrast to a maximum of 4.4 on a test set provided by a native speaker. These results underscore the importance of diverse and representative corpora in assessing MT for low-resource languages. Our research provides insights into few-shot LLM prompting for low-resource MT, and makes available an initial corpus for the Mambai language.
[ -0.5208433866500854, -0.9357852935791016, 0.46740472316741943, 0.08597263693809509, -0.5102605223655701, -0.022686930373311043, -0.3244505226612091, -0.23132352530956268, 0.2568957209587097, 0.5844292640686035, -0.47254011034965515, -0.31743860244750977, -0.8574243187904358, 0.8364259004592896, -0.12394433468580246, 0.5310291051864624, -0.24843347072601318, -0.11309286206960678, 0.22719380259513855, -0.5380799174308777, -0.6755948662757874, -0.3451788127422333, -0.596931517124176, -0.18788523972034454, 0.9021593928337097, 0.9041445851325989, 0.6771416664123535, 0.48873141407966614, 0.39251789450645447, 0.13699345290660858, -0.35065028071403503, 0.5627678036689758, -0.4946378767490387, -0.19821618497371674, 0.16936707496643066, -0.7817400097846985, -0.16654524207115173, -0.11048128455877304, 0.6989495754241943, 0.7795636653900146, -0.011519435793161392, 0.4184569716453552, 0.4287845194339752, 0.7413508892059326, -0.9009445309638977, 0.01595260761678219, -0.5639960765838623, 0.03599755838513374, -0.5051229000091553, -0.1690463125705719, -0.5676417350769043, -0.3033509850502014, -0.35022130608558655, -0.5211425423622131, -0.17970307171344757, 0.16272874176502228, 0.5878742933273315, 0.6624661684036255, -0.6776077747344971, -0.28607115149497986, -0.37632885575294495, 0.9652302861213684, -0.54990553855896, 0.18391279876232147, 0.6785162091255188, 0.2733549177646637, -0.20754334330558777, -0.21099093556404114, -0.6077081561088562, -0.1577332764863968, -0.12412308156490326, 0.13092969357967377, -0.33431491255760193, 0.013696515932679176, 0.38387519121170044, 0.21449986100196838, -0.5292378067970276, 0.46220219135284424, -0.4095381796360016, 0.00250157224945724, 0.4468727111816406, 0.2547048032283783, -0.017728423699736595, -0.5837663412094116, -0.05028780922293663, -0.06903918087482452, -0.9626858830451965, -0.0006168558611534536, 0.34639379382133484, 0.6677164435386658, -0.1631959229707718, 1.2022022008895874, -0.1780189573764801, 1.0434545278549194, -0.11867307871580124, -0.49190545082092285, 0.18488183617591858, -0.5727241039276123, -0.20216849446296692, 0.2286350131034851, 0.9023373126983643, 0.40389013290405273, 0.21664965152740479, 0.30034324526786804, -0.20987476408481598, -0.20342080295085907, 0.04727804288268089, -0.746991753578186, 0.3260493278503418, 0.09621387720108032, -0.6078536510467529, -0.3123510181903839, -0.25894829630851746, -0.8072728514671326, -0.4043600559234619, 0.07642059773206711, 0.22818562388420105, -0.5459545254707336, -0.07475674897432327, -0.2380445897579193, 0.2298354059457779, 0.26052969694137573, 0.09042324125766754, -0.909968376159668, 0.01153106614947319, 0.2769381105899811, 1.155929684638977, -0.18537171185016632, -0.27747127413749695, -1.0107817649841309, 0.16531310975551605, -0.4431408643722534, 0.46960708498954773, -0.6441459655761719, -1.1000336408615112, 0.1768476366996765, 0.03398200124502182, -0.10068809241056442, -0.8311482667922974, 0.6520053744316101, -0.3084978461265564, -0.03585122153162956, -0.4399639666080475, -0.2206684798002243, -0.3138846755027771, 0.13537146151065826, -0.6505401134490967, 1.2274421453475952, 0.160183846950531, -0.4334564805030823, 0.2726367115974426, -0.6812877655029297, -0.6962867379188538, -0.028938420116901398, -0.011790954507887363, -0.214378222823143, 0.29733967781066895, 0.5921852588653564, 0.4803561866283417, -0.32105857133865356, -0.16640804708003998, 0.01754164695739746, -0.43699389696121216, 0.2697692811489105, -0.5398691892623901, 0.6054887771606445, 0.47601333260536194, -0.05661703646183014, -0.22692705690860748, -0.5636395812034607, -0.21452553570270538, 0.27237212657928467, -0.6231971383094788, -0.20197531580924988, -0.33811837434768677, -0.1310495138168335, -0.06181471794843674, 0.2477935552597046, -0.3593308627605438, 0.48154333233833313, -0.3636387586593628, 0.31827113032341003, 0.503650963306427, 0.12276974320411682, 0.6186408400535583, -0.2901252508163452, 0.6411793231964111, 0.18157963454723358, -0.06550794839859009, -0.2897668778896332, -0.87184077501297, -0.5866739749908447, -0.33679017424583435, 0.27721965312957764, 0.8589959144592285, -0.9713404178619385, 0.2881535291671753, -0.21023663878440857, -0.3249766528606415, -1.1933783292770386, 0.6513648629188538, 0.21105077862739563, 0.516943097114563, 0.5110707879066467, -0.0691981166601181, -0.34415218234062195, -0.9276935458183289, 0.07416117936372757, -0.17175568640232086, -0.22719767689704895, 0.7553783059120178, 0.24439772963523865, -0.43228673934936523, 0.5178121328353882, -0.3731958568096161, -0.44413813948631287, -0.6147664189338684, 0.21241238713264465, 0.4588050842285156, 0.09910617023706436, 0.6816457509994507, -0.6027920842170715, -0.21202872693538666, 0.09481827169656754, -0.6304642558097839, -0.3309881389141083, 0.06857164949178696, -0.05053100362420082, 0.38921454548835754, 0.260498583316803, -0.48333045840263367, 0.10438383370637894, 0.7534118890762329, 0.4039153754711151, 0.08638540655374527, -0.16423606872558594, 0.40878579020500183, -1.3249685764312744, 0.25837457180023193, -0.14836561679840088, -0.09241817891597748, -0.061727140098810196, 0.02977796643972397, -0.06170729547739029, -0.2908550202846527, -0.7784167528152466, 0.5446737408638, -0.3974740207195282, -0.039264045655727386, -0.37492635846138, 0.5308541655540466, -0.15115024149417877, 0.15791626274585724, -0.26856112480163574, 1.2632801532745361, 0.03296441212296486, -0.8338534832000732, 0.30951428413391113, 0.32746651768684387, -0.14613649249076843, 0.526511549949646, -0.418220579624176, 0.14736171066761017, 0.0900840237736702, 0.03149126470088959, -0.8765278458595276, -0.30479323863983154, 0.4865363836288452, -0.24722322821617126, 0.3280755579471588, -0.48968368768692017, -0.6698370575904846, -0.34221160411834717, 0.07765135169029236, 0.47934648394584656, 0.7054458260536194, -0.420773983001709, 0.28488653898239136, 0.23164886236190796, -0.4046621322631836, -0.6109181046485901, -0.8762832880020142, 0.2641473114490509, -0.04436144232749939, -0.35552915930747986, -0.09721219539642334, -0.0004580427485052496, -0.21194060146808624, -0.06292402744293213, 0.2327757328748703, -0.02758655697107315, 0.2873162031173706, 0.10581781715154648, 0.3319879472255707, -0.507171094417572, -0.00605726707726717, 0.30856430530548096, -0.13595761358737946, -0.297503799200058, -0.3401757776737213, 0.47211167216300964, 0.07433012872934341, -0.3169429302215576, -0.5158278346061707, 0.3404415547847748, 0.19733691215515137, -0.35843756794929504, 1.0057358741760254, 0.6344553232192993, -0.24066220223903656, 0.2393839955329895, -0.5944409966468811, -0.0333210825920105, -0.3802390992641449, -0.017131656408309937, -0.7222102880477905, -0.9516303539276123, 0.26419147849082947, -0.45708054304122925, -0.2059701830148697, 0.34530216455459595, 0.69771808385849, -0.10248811542987823, 0.8228507041931152, 0.6080769300460815, -0.44883206486701965, 0.4373360872268677, -0.36381039023399353, -0.04242151230573654, -0.7977589964866638, 0.0768863707780838, -0.5518268942832947, -0.5490825772285461, -0.7634254693984985, -0.45200350880622864, 0.4101477861404419, 0.32673120498657227, 0.4047195315361023, 0.43093714118003845, -0.31583234667778015, 0.5208210945129395, 0.45278406143188477, 0.1570247858762741, 0.3372337818145752, 0.018053796142339706, -0.38012558221817017, -0.06049614027142525, -0.8059347867965698, -0.9307200908660889, 1.1366440057754517, -0.13171134889125824, 0.4162932336330414, 0.29483890533447266, 1.1160708665847778, 0.12695065140724182, 0.1999630481004715, -0.9890186786651611, 0.5014113187789917, -0.07966318726539612, -0.23157379031181335, -0.22499987483024597, -0.5463564991950989, -1.2917466163635254, 0.1748499721288681, -0.31540244817733765, -0.3361470699310303, -0.05584816262125969, -0.05807250738143921, -0.4987432658672333, 0.2546103000640869, -0.7906123399734497, 0.7617296576499939, -0.1744823455810547, -0.20321080088615417, -0.39108967781066895, -0.4124797284603119, 0.46268266439437866, -0.3124939501285553, 0.3412124812602997, -0.18440108001232147, -0.5102811455726624, 0.3771120011806488, -0.20980502665042877, 0.8018622994422913, -0.0035670027136802673, -0.11067158728837967, 0.6126614809036255, 0.2781120538711548, 0.44556596875190735, 0.048482079058885574, -0.5238274931907654, 0.17843392491340637, -0.09547843784093857, -0.8818513751029968, -0.5363481640815735, 0.5811042785644531, -0.7235009670257568, -0.6832355260848999, -0.1782425194978714, -0.45704585313796997, 0.146436870098114, 0.26558417081832886, 0.3905622661113739, -0.10071390867233276, -0.2632027268409729, 0.02957001142203808, 0.5173349976539612, -0.34697243571281433, 0.2556408643722534, 0.45469456911087036, -0.011116170324385166, -0.4336563050746918, 0.8451591730117798, 0.28294694423675537, 0.19857558608055115, 0.3819929361343384, 0.10913236439228058, -0.06876721233129501, -0.5292739868164062, -1.0118296146392822, 0.4734536409378052, -0.5009270310401917, -0.28308528661727905, -0.29566270112991333, 0.17687483131885529, -0.23408906161785126, -0.21981263160705566, -0.15180909633636475, -0.3703800141811371, -0.43860363960266113, -0.16250474750995636, 0.27676454186439514, 0.9323886632919312, 0.04297507181763649, 0.3797888159751892, -1.1474223136901855, 0.1786005198955536, -0.05588008463382721, -0.30201804637908936, -0.23588834702968597, -0.6844867467880249, -0.20990563929080963, 0.07679276168346405, -0.3053551912307739, -0.9679129719734192, 0.40506014227867126, 0.010962284170091152, 0.5292381644248962, 0.15999455749988556, 0.23003455996513367, 0.7132388949394226, -0.6720993518829346, 0.9260767102241516, 0.09189100563526154, -0.7412084937095642, 1.0621387958526611, 0.04175156354904175, 0.2780606150627136, 0.564582347869873, 0.5191234350204468, -0.510273277759552, -0.3855218291282654, -0.24863788485527039, -0.5607517957687378, 0.49307507276535034, 0.07204322516918182, 0.11525491625070572, -0.25616735219955444, 0.528581976890564, 0.12877397239208221, 0.21663953363895416, -0.33686307072639465, -0.19398079812526703, 0.004203270189464092, -0.28493401408195496, -0.2780883014202118, -0.43984076380729675, -0.15131720900535583, 0.20812633633613586, 0.4562126398086548, -0.3779873549938202, 0.01228365395218134, 0.21125665307044983, -0.5732151865959167, -0.26099973917007446, 0.531917154788971, 0.6416256427764893, 0.24932105839252472, 0.10386094450950623, 0.02808932587504387, 0.8422555327415466, -0.23141591250896454, 0.3875240385532379, 0.1320943832397461, -0.27138084173202515, 0.17914842069149017, 0.28820258378982544, 0.5765297412872314, 0.3640351891517639, -0.5091503262519836, 0.4289613664150238, 0.29840075969696045, 0.16898277401924133, 0.08760710805654526, 0.04972996190190315, -0.11988207697868347, 0.22785916924476624, 0.30482935905456543, 0.02050679549574852, 0.05135196074843407, -0.28553470969200134, -0.18511736392974854, 0.10205458849668503, -0.13323144614696503, -0.10769884288311005, 0.7751714587211609, 0.417967289686203, -0.3061973750591278, 0.6825975179672241, -0.43813320994377136, 0.029831277206540108, 0.08441885560750961, 0.2913420796394348, 0.5046102404594421, -0.25689250230789185, 0.125501811504364, 0.5304669737815857, 0.5795847177505493, -0.05176052078604698, 0.19253915548324585, -0.14807653427124023, -0.43193870782852173, -0.577343761920929, -0.5165961384773254, -0.633172333240509, -0.17236477136611938, -0.5474429726600647, 0.49677157402038574, -0.24053822457790375, -0.3663652837276459, -0.32815468311309814, 0.15779399871826172, -0.6357725858688354, -0.3316788673400879, 0.25473108887672424, 0.96952223777771, -0.6602552533149719, 0.966895580291748, 0.7225069403648376, -0.9911872744560242, -0.5782577395439148, -0.057471130043268204, 0.20272354781627655, -0.9709395170211792, 0.7167333364486694, 0.035085078328847885, -0.27674946188926697, 0.17705567181110382, -0.3898370563983917, -0.4887687563896179, 1.139030933380127, 0.650223970413208, -0.6345450282096863, 0.13934941589832306, 0.3682044744491577, 0.2170986384153366, -0.16017046570777893, 0.1356031894683838, 0.4854486286640167, 0.5746576189994812, 0.02651411108672619, -0.9773597121238708, 0.06095670163631439, 0.14937527477741241, 0.15370796620845795, 0.18633879721164703, -0.7457437515258789, 0.3168913722038269, -0.5975533127784729, -0.2712639570236206, 0.43077903985977173, 0.7582687735557556, 0.4112180769443512, 0.2069660872220993, 0.29119953513145447, 0.3066960573196411, 1.037091851234436, -0.02238183096051216, 1.3852651119232178, -0.3051976263523102, -0.17687124013900757, 0.5599941611289978, -0.5120922923088074, 1.2503602504730225, 0.6836713552474976, -0.15401531755924225, 0.27460718154907227, 0.7087783813476562, 0.1296970695257187, 0.26894235610961914, -0.11816047877073288, -0.5231726765632629, -0.16537652909755707, -0.6084083318710327, -0.26350051164627075, 0.28484758734703064, 0.35951757431030273, -0.24951161444187164, 0.09166920185089111, 0.25079870223999023, 0.11327678710222244, 0.10842873901128769, -0.2511000335216522, 0.7490469813346863, 0.47994449734687805, -0.5982009768486023, 0.9599513411521912, 0.05260270833969116, 0.7079372406005859, -0.43822818994522095, 0.10434537380933762, -0.4154379963874817, 0.00502192135900259, -0.2570539116859436, -0.8880619406700134, 0.3015861511230469, 0.30501165986061096, -0.07529545575380325, -0.12832856178283691, 0.3583749532699585, -0.3502121567726135, -0.5441205501556396, 0.3668818473815918, 0.8601726293563843, 0.42548367381095886, 0.2026916742324829, -0.6125195026397705, 0.23467448353767395, -0.11718053370714188, -0.027161799371242523, 0.388091117143631, 0.5732547640800476, 0.0736255794763565, 0.6013675928115845, 0.678316593170166, 0.14648354053497314, 0.0559457503259182, 0.16550219058990479, 0.6389923095703125, -0.5752108097076416, -0.1342044621706009, -0.8957549929618835, 0.09017693996429443, 0.24631571769714355, -0.2575009763240814, 0.6799415349960327, 0.7567759156227112, 0.793919026851654, -0.023741403594613075, 0.716647744178772, 0.3103906512260437, 0.31445997953414917, -0.8440524935722351, 0.4899936020374298, -0.6542922258377075, 0.190937802195549, -0.1530679613351822, -0.8976112604141235, -0.22323261201381683, 0.45055779814720154, -0.2942093014717102, -0.3391994535923004, 0.5947445631027222, 0.9447087645530701, 0.004070469178259373, -0.24112433195114136, 0.5935003757476807, 0.18629655241966248, -0.03416963294148445, 0.6142884492874146, 0.6666832566261292, -0.44918808341026306, 1.2273530960083008, 0.0009932764805853367, -0.132096067070961, -0.4331763982772827, -0.6401190757751465, -0.6737378239631653, -0.25873079895973206, -0.15020400285720825, -0.3735024034976959, 0.03790148347616196, 1.105114459991455, 0.2451326996088028, -0.7702911496162415, -0.4559172987937927, 0.42725709080696106, 0.3116718828678131, -0.2567286789417267, -0.12800832092761993, 0.01749357022345066, -0.46801018714904785, -0.9939368963241577, 0.8646599650382996, 0.3326824903488159, 0.2175343930721283, -0.05160915479063988, -0.39537376165390015, -0.28745898604393005, -0.13355977833271027, 0.8100399971008301, 0.1743815690279007, -0.959416389465332, -0.0693700760602951, 0.19302041828632355, -0.4229852259159088, 0.16544850170612335, 0.5786383152008057, -0.7376359701156616, 0.298465371131897, 0.3199862837791443, 0.9124870896339417, 0.5548213720321655, -0.29618555307388306, 0.5667141079902649, -0.8754329681396484, 0.621823251247406, -0.05113108828663826, 0.567347526550293, 0.47952979803085327, -0.20815113186836243, 0.7972338795661926, 0.4100908935070038, -0.29564332962036133, -0.6995440125465393, 0.3029553294181824, -0.740011990070343, 0.033334679901599884, 1.1556562185287476, -0.04813957214355469, -0.5040966868400574, 0.12340738624334335, -0.6966601014137268, 0.44220441579818726, -0.5064783692359924, 0.4050166606903076, 0.806100070476532, -0.031384795904159546, -0.45232847332954407, -0.7463284730911255, 0.059664007276296616, 0.48680227994918823, -0.4392028748989105, -0.22038570046424866, 0.29525184631347656, 0.000707284256350249, 0.21566042304039001, 0.5790137648582458, 0.022310934960842133, 0.16035382449626923, -0.11913883686065674, -0.21436358988285065, -0.021712874993681908, 0.2746237516403198, -0.561019778251648, -0.18411418795585632, 0.3374159038066864, -0.34018057584762573 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04793v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04793v1
SqueezeAttention: 2D Management of KV-Cache in LLM Inference via Layer-wise Optimal Budget
2024-04-07T03:08:14
2024-04-07T03:08:14
Zihao Wang, Shaoduo Gan
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.CL
Optimizing the Key-Value (KV) cache of the Large Language Model (LLM) has been considered critical to saving the cost of inference. Most of the existing KV-cache compression algorithms attempted to sparsify the sequence of tokens by taking advantage of the different importance of tokens. In this work, we found that by identifying the importance of attention layers, we could optimize the KV-cache jointly from two dimensions. Based on our observations regarding layer-wise importance in inference, we propose SqueezeAttention to precisely optimize the allocation of KV-cache budget among layers on-the-fly and then incorporate three representative token sparsification algorithms to compress the KV-cache for each layer with its very own budget. By optimizing the KV-cache from both sequence's and layer's dimensions, SqueezeAttention achieves around 30% to 70% of the memory reductions and up to 2.2 times of throughput improvements in a wide range of LLMs and benchmarks. The code is available at https://github.com/hetailang/SqueezeAttention.
[ -0.1690438985824585, -0.4619101285934448, 0.371218204498291, 0.5674836039543152, -0.17773593962192535, -0.03631271421909332, -0.03920941799879074, -0.2641177773475647, 0.37306979298591614, 0.4636569917201996, -0.3287603557109833, -0.049975328147411346, -0.2983076274394989, -0.6228733658790588, -0.2260209172964096, 0.3777848482131958, -0.011084651574492455, 0.0902775451540947, -0.5024161338806152, -0.0030312128365039825, -0.3864462077617645, -0.24836574494838715, -0.2808460593223572, -0.1745356023311615, 0.4459543824195862, 0.7960631847381592, 0.4691323935985565, 0.9096563458442688, 0.27066338062286377, 0.2997053861618042, -0.2890559434890747, 0.21324220299720764, -0.5524829030036926, 0.16183070838451385, -0.020575812086462975, -0.7099261283874512, -0.17890532314777374, 0.10251225531101227, 0.6104713678359985, 0.20552344620227814, -0.07742755860090256, 0.14360864460468292, -0.056753870099782944, 1.047244906425476, -1.136445164680481, -0.09822644293308258, -0.6023762822151184, 0.055419906973838806, -0.14124761521816254, -0.24226608872413635, -0.3184790313243866, -0.4783942997455597, 0.19187229871749878, -0.5731910467147827, 0.22931325435638428, -0.1375192403793335, 0.7985187768936157, 0.41828250885009766, -0.12894117832183838, 0.007069518323987722, -0.6053845882415771, 0.7902520895004272, -0.46417245268821716, 0.3645622432231903, 0.2623063921928406, 0.09078198671340942, -0.056708019226789474, -0.8462405800819397, -0.5686642527580261, 0.03441531956195831, 0.21818548440933228, 0.23648996651172638, -0.03425174206495285, 0.16495013236999512, -0.07033655792474747, 0.3354955315589905, -0.2992549240589142, 0.27734285593032837, -0.41323745250701904, -0.4276878535747528, 0.30965331196784973, 0.07829351723194122, 0.1258658617734909, -0.12799076735973358, -0.6791113615036011, -0.22599674761295319, -0.8760794997215271, 0.003596751717850566, 0.3979083299636841, 0.10618877410888672, 0.12661460041999817, 0.4291679263114929, 0.013652395457029343, 0.2621169090270996, 0.1435537189245224, -0.1752190738916397, 0.08881638199090958, -0.20074273645877838, -0.2864271104335785, 0.1046523004770279, 0.2825816571712494, 0.255572646856308, 0.19668884575366974, -0.40615129470825195, -0.06797561794519424, -0.11674420535564423, 0.5091807246208191, -0.9661345481872559, -0.28365248441696167, 0.4641595184803009, -0.319175660610199, -0.5354888439178467, -0.0963796004652977, -0.9722787737846375, -0.3314869999885559, -0.24855546653270721, 0.45475199818611145, -0.22617533802986145, -0.20839755237102509, 0.17826730012893677, -0.3422756493091583, 0.20424343645572662, 0.33092349767684937, -0.6632606387138367, 0.40867099165916443, 0.6114776730537415, 1.0232820510864258, -0.20024381577968597, -0.05662047490477562, -0.6335405111312866, 0.33049172163009644, -0.16897638142108917, 0.797082781791687, -0.35030731558799744, -0.3155151903629303, 0.05572722479701042, -0.4745185375213623, -0.13834598660469055, -0.8119468092918396, 0.4746576249599457, -0.8348321914672852, -0.36146262288093567, -0.2561076879501343, -0.6667273640632629, -0.10060330480337143, 0.3020351827144623, -1.0304646492004395, 1.2372443675994873, 0.30576378107070923, -0.4811522960662842, 0.15178406238555908, -0.30725109577178955, -0.3912058174610138, 0.081498883664608, 0.05092104896903038, -0.5878443717956543, 0.47026458382606506, 0.326905757188797, 0.31332507729530334, -0.31816181540489197, -0.024976519867777824, -0.25894254446029663, -0.21511824429035187, 0.26962408423423767, -0.036691807210445404, 0.6401921510696411, 0.1015772670507431, -0.4472939372062683, -0.05873559042811394, -0.6720002293586731, 0.29181453585624695, 0.1320827752351761, -0.47921988368034363, -0.3597375452518463, -0.0030112152453511953, 0.3357122242450714, 0.1823866367340088, 0.1856837272644043, -0.16190241277217865, 0.39237579703330994, -0.6063218116760254, 0.7833322286605835, 0.9223182201385498, -0.06344722956418991, 0.8034948706626892, 0.07921364158391953, 0.6576852798461914, 0.28830960392951965, 0.2512561082839966, 0.12183430790901184, -0.1185821071267128, -1.0107173919677734, -0.46557778120040894, 0.508204996585846, 0.521181046962738, -0.41335245966911316, 0.1823509931564331, -0.22868932783603668, -0.22354252636432648, -0.5144835710525513, 0.2063024342060089, 0.3352290689945221, 0.25015419721603394, 0.245713472366333, -0.21429108083248138, -0.44878578186035156, -1.0609599351882935, -0.137287437915802, -0.3170475959777832, 0.42186057567596436, 0.5713732242584229, 0.1847805231809616, 0.07265885919332504, 0.9933197498321533, -0.4234592616558075, -0.28304049372673035, -0.12803174555301666, -0.0418245755136013, -0.1855916827917099, 0.6244340538978577, 0.49426233768463135, -0.8089622259140015, -0.3489920496940613, -0.21856489777565002, 0.18921519815921783, -0.29338061809539795, -0.226694256067276, -0.37710046768188477, 0.12078286707401276, 0.4509405195713043, -1.0004701614379883, 0.46347737312316895, 0.3946291506290436, 0.10973720997571945, 0.8409767150878906, -0.0027046073228120804, -0.2874513566493988, -0.8262639045715332, 0.04036568105220795, -0.27095893025398254, -0.24328292906284332, -0.42268434166908264, 0.31971460580825806, 0.3382969796657562, 0.14979355037212372, -0.3987896740436554, 0.6840812563896179, -0.7072603702545166, -0.07207752019166946, -0.19875559210777283, 0.39286670088768005, 0.16733898222446442, 0.5323374271392822, -0.3443584442138672, 0.9284732937812805, 0.2584979832172394, -0.5270381569862366, 0.147229865193367, -0.05217217653989792, -0.5217053294181824, 0.12172651290893555, -0.535452663898468, 0.42544662952423096, 0.14173705875873566, 0.2503117620944977, -1.2710145711898804, -0.12313054502010345, 0.011888941749930382, -0.2806914448738098, 0.660050094127655, -0.3079567849636078, -0.6776207089424133, -0.34678420424461365, -0.4543284475803375, 0.6154729127883911, 0.44589486718177795, -0.7518659234046936, 0.7151014804840088, 0.7040197849273682, 0.16764402389526367, -0.6498193144798279, -0.7038262486457825, -0.0809437707066536, -0.3703825771808624, -0.6168795228004456, 0.5758702158927917, 0.11972302943468094, 0.0023615576792508364, 0.07286970317363739, -0.5320106744766235, -0.042227257043123245, 0.013893723487854004, 0.16973178088665009, 0.07455400377511978, -0.19833159446716309, 0.23491139709949493, 0.24856486916542053, -0.23393189907073975, 0.029389360919594765, -0.9614523649215698, 0.6368204951286316, 0.15178793668746948, -0.33167412877082825, -0.3664218783378601, 0.1703668236732483, 0.6323916912078857, 0.0038175720255821943, 0.5937334299087524, 0.5474580526351929, -0.21892061829566956, -0.3968198895454407, -1.0446176528930664, -0.11325035244226456, -0.5237787365913391, 0.41742563247680664, -0.2728770971298218, -1.1796348094940186, 0.6285536289215088, -0.38629624247550964, -0.2102346569299698, 0.3210136890411377, 0.7182222604751587, 0.0944342389702797, 0.7355313301086426, 0.27957308292388916, -0.7922770977020264, 0.3002447783946991, -0.4281182289123535, 0.3003259301185608, -0.8263633847236633, -0.21402591466903687, -0.770281195640564, -0.6827147603034973, -0.38864365220069885, -0.977640688419342, 0.3256959021091461, 0.39129212498664856, -0.14597557485103607, 0.0845271572470665, -0.49293968081474304, 0.8010728359222412, 0.5065703988075256, 0.08168787509202957, -0.2630411386489868, 0.14333587884902954, -0.3721941113471985, -0.025657188147306442, -0.7475059628486633, -0.07671602070331573, 0.6150822043418884, 0.3909691870212555, 0.780521035194397, 0.18985238671302795, 0.5508129000663757, 0.03179558366537094, -0.11107642203569412, -1.0032496452331543, 0.45977792143821716, 0.11922421306371689, -0.5608986616134644, -0.0856875479221344, -0.42659029364585876, -0.689561128616333, 0.25223788619041443, 0.4308626353740692, -1.148513674736023, 0.27160441875457764, 0.5429491996765137, -0.3266676664352417, 0.1801656186580658, -0.7400786876678467, 0.5790519714355469, -0.027290763333439827, -0.4887371361255646, -0.6376823782920837, -0.7024282217025757, 0.34395259618759155, 0.31429415941238403, -0.20861685276031494, 0.10663632303476334, -0.3563922643661499, 0.48849332332611084, -0.5886721611022949, 0.932255744934082, -0.39442917704582214, -0.0035714281257241964, 0.4486767053604126, 0.23791521787643433, 0.9800605177879333, 0.10423814505338669, 0.1849498152732849, -0.14170587062835693, -0.15238967537879944, -0.4925544559955597, -0.8196025490760803, 0.9310874342918396, -0.893187403678894, -0.6738640069961548, 0.05384887009859085, -0.5593830347061157, -0.2922731339931488, 0.03435825556516647, -0.08114461600780487, 0.480958491563797, -0.027089543640613556, 0.08777172863483429, 0.8471768498420715, -0.18223370611667633, 0.2275904268026352, 0.11646022647619247, 0.053999803960323334, -0.5123516917228699, 1.0698513984680176, 0.07144781947135925, 0.3411117494106293, 0.7334233522415161, 0.4722423255443573, -0.35984015464782715, -0.553570568561554, -0.42172056436538696, 0.1851848065853119, -0.5908746719360352, -0.5564422607421875, -0.7348055839538574, -0.30745041370391846, -0.41588667035102844, -0.18704505264759064, -0.5640758872032166, -1.008994698524475, -0.29083308577537537, -0.22214987874031067, 0.3794720768928528, -0.0020955551881343126, -0.20450961589813232, 0.428945928812027, -0.7289848923683167, -0.04970921203494072, 0.36166632175445557, 0.16508571803569794, 0.4037293791770935, -0.4876565635204315, -0.5762748718261719, -0.39433732628822327, -0.42186787724494934, -0.6830485463142395, 0.35587990283966064, 0.2321033775806427, 0.4123811721801758, 0.7224951982498169, -0.19831611216068268, 1.1104248762130737, -0.4835635721683502, 0.8169161081314087, 0.15145988762378693, -1.024072289466858, 0.2853829562664032, 0.03703654929995537, 0.3820234537124634, 0.5389193892478943, -0.11111647635698318, -0.3500998318195343, -0.21491676568984985, -0.5092959403991699, -1.2360577583312988, 0.7630851864814758, 0.20323053002357483, 0.3141910433769226, 0.006151030771434307, 0.5499202013015747, -0.2486705332994461, 0.03760416805744171, -0.3376566469669342, -0.24521756172180176, 0.03725932538509369, 0.040332913398742676, 0.46720942854881287, -0.7461285591125488, -0.01583237573504448, -0.2939872741699219, 0.6915603876113892, -0.0915784016251564, 0.49383091926574707, 0.03203948959708214, -0.19237887859344482, -0.08023600280284882, -0.023372629657387733, 0.7365419268608093, 0.3792955279350281, 0.11627413332462311, 0.3809901773929596, 0.05021200329065323, -0.8155094981193542, 0.10965105146169662, -0.04635877162218094, -0.06249622255563736, -0.20050743222236633, 0.03894495964050293, 0.7461785078048706, 0.3518633544445038, -0.6298330426216125, 0.46415117383003235, 0.263945609331131, -0.264715313911438, -0.20149670541286469, 0.13129796087741852, 0.3170650005340576, 0.5078168511390686, 0.141435444355011, -0.1279315948486328, 0.3095161020755768, 0.14199787378311157, 0.06589947640895844, 0.4442282021045685, -0.2948418855667114, -0.2755877673625946, 0.4837401807308197, 0.16329830884933472, -0.035671353340148926, 0.8014113903045654, 0.15532851219177246, -0.9064496159553528, 0.7889981269836426, 0.5855988264083862, 1.1412733793258667, -0.3520701229572296, 0.049913812428712845, 0.4979689121246338, 0.3004995584487915, 0.009046372026205063, 0.07878571003675461, -0.38967466354370117, -0.8270843029022217, -0.5480939149856567, -0.5693312883377075, -0.01443036925047636, 0.3355497419834137, -0.7250638008117676, 0.06044750660657883, -0.39969107508659363, 0.06761033833026886, 0.02276846580207348, 0.0660267323255539, -0.6810803413391113, -0.03985308110713959, -0.1274101287126541, 1.305403470993042, -0.41412869095802307, 0.866215169429779, 0.2921813428401947, -0.08402424305677414, -0.914849042892456, 0.02298961579799652, 0.3776067793369293, -1.0535563230514526, 0.8508413434028625, 0.28188732266426086, -0.2228209674358368, 0.0762205645442009, -0.6690186858177185, -1.1156399250030518, 0.9751633405685425, 0.28493648767471313, -0.5531787276268005, -0.03443197160959244, 0.1335221529006958, 0.03214503824710846, -0.08783653378486633, 0.01975869946181774, 0.6596745848655701, 0.5959298014640808, 0.14836855232715607, -0.5428712368011475, -0.07266402244567871, -0.2645166218280792, 0.40597960352897644, 0.5914483070373535, -0.8912534713745117, 0.3099397122859955, -0.1987907439470291, -0.22830109298229218, 0.25184470415115356, 0.7109741568565369, 0.13506639003753662, -0.09657295048236847, 0.7422791719436646, 0.9899007678031921, 0.5179482698440552, 0.09118883311748505, 0.7982352375984192, -0.2455344796180725, 0.3694531321525574, 0.8775326609611511, -0.2155989706516266, 0.6667467355728149, 0.9311907887458801, -0.3332514464855194, 0.29740411043167114, 0.5994754433631897, 0.20566532015800476, 0.779147744178772, 0.6023983955383301, -0.3481529653072357, -0.1566351056098938, 0.1503901332616806, -0.029117099940776825, 0.33371204137802124, 0.5637675523757935, -0.21780405938625336, -0.07824557274580002, -0.2320346087217331, 0.007102116011083126, -0.5801393985748291, -0.06283305585384369, 0.6805170178413391, 0.03732411935925484, -0.6336464285850525, 0.3112906515598297, 0.02873198688030243, 0.052199605852365494, -0.3667748272418976, 0.10463336110115051, -0.24866224825382233, 0.4604491591453552, 0.042730316519737244, -0.3181413412094116, -0.0591060146689415, -0.22053854167461395, -0.4029345214366913, -0.14071346819400787, 0.8819812536239624, -0.4312850534915924, -0.23818016052246094, 0.19244980812072754, 0.2614237070083618, 0.16992363333702087, -0.09093727171421051, -0.6164237260818481, 0.18662407994270325, -0.1437809020280838, -0.5433793067932129, 0.5439603328704834, 0.483350545167923, 0.04376867413520813, 0.5435840487480164, 0.5007718205451965, 0.15633490681648254, 0.17332205176353455, 0.44687145948410034, 1.2875115871429443, -0.42734062671661377, -0.7178837060928345, -0.8780238628387451, 0.6322342157363892, -0.043962202966213226, -0.21914151310920715, 0.5791397094726562, 0.7628717422485352, 0.6105671525001526, -0.014047646895051003, 0.6272514462471008, 0.03930830955505371, 0.11401082575321198, -0.7997105121612549, 0.49634385108947754, -0.724738359451294, 0.08107475191354752, -0.2106153815984726, -0.8276943564414978, -0.2593749165534973, 0.6470685601234436, 0.06245122104883194, 0.09298018366098404, 0.5273901224136353, 1.0242276191711426, -0.1936960369348526, -0.046795692294836044, 0.078624427318573, 0.12419392913579941, 0.23255255818367004, 0.5001974701881409, 0.7261161804199219, -0.20202037692070007, 0.5323037505149841, -0.2774742543697357, -0.12450002133846283, -0.480040043592453, -0.8159075379371643, -0.7119349837303162, -0.6159282922744751, -0.3707461357116699, -0.4883502721786499, -0.0744839534163475, 0.7118231654167175, 1.0818332433700562, -0.6508835554122925, -0.049649544060230255, -0.2917653024196625, 0.09823375195264816, -0.3819727301597595, -0.31443047523498535, 0.6748572587966919, -0.6281968951225281, -0.5731764435768127, 0.25475984811782837, 0.7059897780418396, -0.2696593999862671, -0.5877071022987366, -0.034245822578668594, -0.056003399193286896, 0.22865065932273865, 0.5310516357421875, 0.15329509973526, -0.9793254733085632, -0.2878870666027069, 0.1116151362657547, -0.14945046603679657, 0.08690369129180908, 1.4821622371673584, -0.7634549736976624, 0.5609031915664673, 0.5474370718002319, 1.0928670167922974, 0.9422007203102112, -0.018212562426924706, 0.3775792717933655, -1.009379267692566, 0.34041646122932434, 0.20704494416713715, 0.1623726189136505, 0.017261754721403122, -0.49947524070739746, 0.394218772649765, 0.26925671100616455, -0.7509683966636658, -0.7792007327079773, 0.09702783823013306, -1.217763066291809, -0.1401616632938385, 1.2100123167037964, -0.04123418778181076, -0.4417725205421448, -0.004955793730914593, -0.18807658553123474, 0.05965590476989746, -0.41948211193084717, 0.9473752975463867, 0.7836639285087585, 0.16575658321380615, -0.5461992025375366, -0.38362759351730347, 0.473333477973938, 0.5439667105674744, -0.6342129707336426, 0.07803314924240112, 0.49792563915252686, 0.03595132380723953, 0.2115614265203476, 0.46439188718795776, -0.14150896668434143, 0.2317701280117035, -0.01243588887155056, -0.12245287746191025, 0.05574772506952286, -0.4070452153682709, -0.03740362450480461, 0.15867699682712555, -0.13568544387817383, -0.36985698342323303 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08677v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08677v1
PMG : Personalized Multimodal Generation with Large Language Models
2024-04-07T03:05:57
2024-04-07T03:05:57
Xiaoteng Shen, Rui Zhang, Xiaoyan Zhao, Jieming Zhu, Xi Xiao
cs.IR
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized the capabilities of text comprehension and generation. Multi-modal generation attracts great attention from both the industry and academia, but there is little work on personalized generation, which has important applications such as recommender systems. This paper proposes the first method for personalized multimodal generation using LLMs, showcases its applications and validates its performance via an extensive experimental study on two datasets. The proposed method, Personalized Multimodal Generation (PMG for short) first converts user behaviors (e.g., clicks in recommender systems or conversations with a virtual assistant) into natural language to facilitate LLM understanding and extract user preference descriptions. Such user preferences are then fed into a generator, such as a multimodal LLM or diffusion model, to produce personalized content. To capture user preferences comprehensively and accurately, we propose to let the LLM output a combination of explicit keywords and implicit embeddings to represent user preferences. Then the combination of keywords and embeddings are used as prompts to condition the generator. We optimize a weighted sum of the accuracy and preference scores so that the generated content has a good balance between them. Compared to a baseline method without personalization, PMG has a significant improvement on personalization for up to 8% in terms of LPIPS while retaining the accuracy of generation.
[ -0.6805937886238098, -0.9244625568389893, 0.6620747447013855, 0.21918022632598877, -0.2835800051689148, -0.062113549560308456, -0.5312421917915344, 0.34225302934646606, 0.15775533020496368, 0.39554810523986816, -0.7917771339416504, -0.6035761833190918, -0.37741705775260925, 0.18229049444198608, 0.16657991707324982, 0.8875429034233093, 0.28765007853507996, 0.03340044245123863, -0.3707018792629242, 0.10311677306890488, -0.5698234438896179, -0.4526105225086212, -0.43735212087631226, -0.39392146468162537, 0.7059521675109863, 0.40555819869041443, 0.637561559677124, 0.4026500880718231, 0.11739391833543777, 0.31222277879714966, 0.16488245129585266, 0.7010995149612427, -0.3886321783065796, 0.43389153480529785, 0.0011834078468382359, -0.0925067886710167, -0.4334711730480194, -0.12004593759775162, 0.5504223704338074, 0.23907272517681122, -0.22029803693294525, 0.06587254256010056, -0.009283043444156647, 0.4905763864517212, -0.4564012587070465, 0.0008872966864146292, -0.6363418102264404, 0.11354737728834152, -0.3115171790122986, -0.5577133297920227, -0.560546875, -0.29602041840553284, -0.018930811434984207, -0.44515419006347656, 0.2324070930480957, 0.30524784326553345, 0.42944711446762085, 0.027484480291604996, -0.8905125856399536, -0.2146420180797577, -0.6535815000534058, 1.056213617324829, -0.7428015470504761, 0.36812010407447815, 0.34411898255348206, 0.4391307830810547, -0.15416273474693298, -0.6494060754776001, -0.894485592842102, -0.6183228492736816, 0.07174137979745865, 0.23814831674098969, -0.06766226142644882, 0.10502069443464279, 0.10664983838796616, 0.40816712379455566, -0.6983109712600708, -0.21130554378032684, 0.009880678728222847, -0.14879731833934784, 0.5967058539390564, 0.2502894103527069, 0.3137339651584625, -0.4878448247909546, -0.581913411617279, -0.18737326562404633, -0.6212792992591858, -0.152525395154953, 0.6874991655349731, 0.17835168540477753, -0.09640241414308548, 0.8667067289352417, -0.2953953742980957, 0.7441176176071167, 0.33798933029174805, -0.6272891759872437, 0.5079658031463623, -0.8283932209014893, -0.10012218356132507, -0.18917712569236755, 1.105718970298767, 0.7116260528564453, 0.24375155568122864, -0.04536093398928642, -0.12025923281908035, -0.2623705565929413, 0.10386311262845993, -0.8002083897590637, -0.10544523596763611, -0.005342382937669754, -0.5298842191696167, -0.3251405656337738, -0.028444353491067886, -0.7355730533599854, -0.3699427843093872, -0.5277445912361145, 0.24766944348812103, -0.41639718413352966, -0.0707758218050003, 0.006284536328166723, 0.06854865700006485, -0.1731664538383484, 0.15799207985401154, -1.0290168523788452, -0.25531378388404846, 0.08376910537481308, 0.7283514142036438, -0.19753235578536987, -0.09512896090745926, -0.5191001296043396, 0.4402589201927185, 0.1140356957912445, 0.7803623080253601, -0.5070482492446899, -0.5848002433776855, 0.23094239830970764, -0.28521955013275146, 0.12856969237327576, -0.38353487849235535, 0.33369961380958557, -0.34230417013168335, 0.5053706765174866, -0.2146545648574829, -0.4129152297973633, -0.10107914358377457, 0.472267210483551, -0.2989870011806488, 0.699390172958374, 0.012373718433082104, -0.6527747511863708, 0.4978065490722656, -0.5144133567810059, -0.27649083733558655, 0.1848534792661667, -0.2035086750984192, -0.34635528922080994, 0.13051088154315948, 0.3999961018562317, 0.9061108827590942, -0.44120311737060547, 0.5366652607917786, -0.4084344804286957, 0.23750102519989014, 0.411943644285202, -0.49172747135162354, -0.06901668012142181, 0.5269319415092468, -0.0273300651460886, 0.35892367362976074, -0.7754729390144348, 0.15612666308879852, 0.23083779215812683, -0.7941114902496338, -0.12972809374332428, 0.21581678092479706, 0.4569326341152191, 0.3878506124019623, 0.5617339015007019, -0.4829031229019165, 0.259408175945282, -0.10285130888223648, 0.44841063022613525, 0.9528381824493408, 0.1079232469201088, 0.4381352961063385, -0.44174641370773315, 0.5732244849205017, 0.1578049212694168, -0.1188560277223587, -0.8290347456932068, -0.339721143245697, -0.38488519191741943, -0.2527921199798584, 0.06101367250084877, 0.2016853392124176, -0.7854675054550171, 0.5266740918159485, -0.1507784128189087, -0.19925415515899658, 0.08143702894449234, 0.666499674320221, 0.3607368469238281, 0.2472568303346634, 0.04137253016233444, -0.1609938144683838, -0.3766540586948395, -0.9946100115776062, 0.03361564502120018, -0.03716126084327698, -0.07878980785608292, 0.9023830890655518, -0.13934865593910217, -0.5572136044502258, 1.012831211090088, -0.9036121368408203, -0.18004798889160156, -0.3903483748435974, 0.190560445189476, -0.06728838384151459, 0.22226569056510925, 0.4383017420768738, -0.9177043437957764, -0.5249733328819275, 0.007171960081905127, -0.4872320592403412, -0.2654556334018707, -0.20633037388324738, -0.10024672001600266, -0.16361398994922638, 0.14063934981822968, -0.3970337212085724, -0.5766618847846985, 0.8578258156776428, -0.3415191173553467, 0.5136460661888123, -0.4108397960662842, 0.06594529002904892, -1.6940909624099731, -0.07132026553153992, 0.4156675338745117, -0.5061956644058228, -0.5000691413879395, -0.015209991484880447, -0.28037020564079285, -0.1922471821308136, -0.4339085519313812, 0.6995546817779541, -0.2696389853954315, 0.3919961750507355, -0.36222782731056213, 0.300828754901886, -0.06720498949289322, 0.4907165765762329, -0.1657748967409134, 0.7205555438995361, 0.29606831073760986, -0.5715304017066956, 0.4644518792629242, 0.3022385537624359, -0.09127026796340942, 0.4878619313240051, -0.4180971384048462, 0.3792901933193207, -0.28938886523246765, 0.09679684787988663, -1.2140860557556152, -0.4523855447769165, 0.12605148553848267, -0.12833231687545776, 0.14885887503623962, 0.1845938116312027, -0.5957183241844177, -0.05774056911468506, -0.4227387309074402, 0.1985766887664795, 0.3774896264076233, -0.5331193208694458, 0.6383227109909058, 0.3023485243320465, -0.3529800772666931, -0.11474154889583588, -0.09947433322668076, 0.11431223154067993, -0.28139621019363403, -0.9618737101554871, 0.468059778213501, -0.6651275753974915, -0.17934143543243408, -0.4422041177749634, 0.27142277359962463, 0.3596051037311554, -0.2566342055797577, 0.36918875575065613, 0.04750872775912285, -0.20003651082515717, 0.2720363140106201, 0.26909327507019043, -0.21067292988300323, -0.29660630226135254, -0.09124670177698135, 0.9478666186332703, 0.10865499824285507, -0.07334567606449127, -0.10732659697532654, 0.37291470170021057, 0.4120878577232361, -0.35670599341392517, 0.5313515067100525, 1.1796131134033203, 0.10119406878948212, -0.270575612783432, -0.8523926138877869, -0.14165045320987701, -0.5203842520713806, 0.2809557020664215, -0.44186246395111084, -1.0049734115600586, -0.035432424396276474, -0.31026607751846313, 0.022074492648243904, 0.10967947542667389, 1.0512844324111938, 0.016710249707102776, 1.4497636556625366, 0.6776842474937439, 0.12956692278385162, 0.7107623219490051, 0.11277616769075394, 0.08730366080999374, -0.7439072132110596, -0.3593815863132477, -0.11863593012094498, -0.33786046504974365, -0.5397213697433472, -0.2584689259529114, 0.5348284244537354, 0.08038438111543655, 0.029451947659254074, -0.01671343483030796, -0.31065869331359863, 0.20298095047473907, 0.7094677090644836, 0.36276721954345703, 0.328551322221756, 0.1860167235136032, -0.23835302889347076, -0.17564217746257782, -0.40261024236679077, -0.6766320466995239, 1.1692805290222168, 0.05555533617734909, 0.8778809905052185, 0.19935017824172974, 0.6215090155601501, 0.6076787710189819, 0.10323987901210785, -0.6760067343711853, 0.5580309629440308, -0.3709263503551483, -0.36479151248931885, 0.038604069501161575, -0.4226415157318115, -0.6291520595550537, 0.3451266884803772, -0.6102573871612549, -0.3711090385913849, -0.23718386888504028, 0.4971466660499573, -0.3230348527431488, -0.1754736453294754, -0.7889608144760132, 0.6128252148628235, -0.38834455609321594, -0.45945248007774353, -0.335064560174942, -0.27632206678390503, 0.6612029075622559, -0.2723372280597687, 0.0020650969818234444, -0.2896564304828644, -0.03443272039294243, 0.379139244556427, -0.044694945216178894, 0.5888327360153198, -0.10065485537052155, 0.028427854180336, 0.02051881141960621, 0.005371390376240015, 0.510154664516449, 0.2546604871749878, 0.042734723538160324, -0.09662909060716629, -0.43762242794036865, 0.01313916314393282, -0.34858012199401855, 1.0201908349990845, -0.5785742998123169, -0.6023805141448975, 0.0006324272253550589, -0.6004549264907837, -0.23856544494628906, 0.28694775700569153, 0.28598538041114807, 0.39357444643974304, -0.16988636553287506, 0.29490378499031067, 0.6092483401298523, -0.5404599905014038, 0.5108757019042969, 0.2795126736164093, -0.37014636397361755, -0.7795310616493225, 1.1634302139282227, -0.27888408303260803, 0.011936195194721222, 0.46748051047325134, 0.6473570466041565, -0.38627055287361145, -0.5375714302062988, -0.4935254156589508, 0.2584737539291382, -0.3912156820297241, -0.05936620011925697, -0.8381400108337402, 0.3047886788845062, -0.4219718873500824, -0.2875441610813141, 0.10095314681529999, 0.08269881457090378, -0.34494084119796753, 0.0719291940331459, 0.02952556312084198, 0.544204592704773, 0.2900421917438507, 0.6361919641494751, -0.874620258808136, 0.5940167307853699, 0.5897009372711182, -0.15638355910778046, -0.42135119438171387, -0.03669204190373421, -0.12268402427434921, -0.04951195418834686, -0.7906874418258667, -0.8313629627227783, 0.5866051316261292, 0.3349478244781494, 0.5377466678619385, 0.947518527507782, -0.2785060405731201, 0.4695126414299011, -0.5935863852500916, 1.0049055814743042, 0.5815674662590027, -0.8406513333320618, 0.4309893548488617, -0.6446753144264221, 0.38258397579193115, 0.1651456356048584, 0.18930378556251526, -0.5175762176513672, -0.07877057790756226, -0.28645798563957214, -0.7812593579292297, 0.5814120769500732, 0.04904696345329285, 0.5328519940376282, -0.1520773023366928, 0.3608357012271881, 0.27920395135879517, 0.482195109128952, -0.7284835577011108, -0.19121234118938446, -0.11748199909925461, -0.260165810585022, -0.5553467273712158, -0.5708669424057007, 0.028332224115729332, 0.24176710844039917, 0.5502474308013916, -0.4502144455909729, 0.07099076360464096, -0.18682248890399933, -0.035868965089321136, 0.023680778220295906, 0.376735121011734, 0.8925395011901855, 0.6993670463562012, -0.08955202251672745, 0.17984282970428467, -0.11327507346868515, -0.07213088870048523, 0.12157946825027466, -0.11258120089769363, -0.19430692493915558, 0.04031579568982124, -0.11858651787042618, 0.705410361289978, 0.08661206066608429, -0.9138441681861877, 0.7027441263198853, -0.10351995378732681, 0.025403371080756187, -0.4530094563961029, 0.12429631501436234, 0.08510513603687286, 0.2219272404909134, 0.06016170233488083, 0.08082102239131927, 0.012239002622663975, -0.36593762040138245, 0.0573921836912632, 0.6606631875038147, 0.06067882105708122, -0.4870263636112213, 0.8099837303161621, 0.400294691324234, -0.14158351719379425, 0.21340960264205933, -0.1467219591140747, -0.06674633920192719, -0.10141893476247787, 0.7316687107086182, 0.9704070091247559, -0.2129860669374466, 0.3973979949951172, 0.37827932834625244, -0.09901010245084763, 0.0931583046913147, 0.08850116282701492, -0.4565543234348297, -0.9239602088928223, -0.37243008613586426, -0.874973475933075, -0.2257184535264969, 0.1269773691892624, -0.23585234582424164, 0.4392479360103607, -0.4348520040512085, -0.48438072204589844, 0.05746975168585777, -0.23222845792770386, -0.5654131174087524, 0.15808960795402527, 0.4990209639072418, 0.40221747756004333, -0.6556312441825867, 0.6495165824890137, 0.8181506991386414, -0.2790577709674835, -0.38106271624565125, -0.11905455589294434, 0.05541558191180229, -0.6350076198577881, 0.5944015383720398, -0.03507229685783386, -0.18623057007789612, -0.0110982870683074, -0.3387908637523651, -0.4392988383769989, 1.0828384160995483, 0.3621625006198883, -0.6018306612968445, -0.1494738608598709, 0.08775947988033295, 0.19977036118507385, -0.5823782086372375, 0.3243558406829834, 0.054832566529512405, 0.6162604093551636, 0.11863589286804199, -0.5796363949775696, -0.02971614897251129, -0.17338860034942627, 0.38652557134628296, 0.1597495973110199, -0.7352358102798462, 0.8819112181663513, -0.14869654178619385, 0.007948878221213818, -0.08647410571575165, 0.4627853333950043, 0.4055931270122528, 0.2990920841693878, 0.5754436254501343, 0.40601930022239685, 0.4252890646457672, -0.007654536049813032, 1.1143449544906616, -0.5308207869529724, 0.08869248628616333, 0.7655735015869141, -0.30334651470184326, 0.5218326449394226, 0.4070320725440979, 0.02764415740966797, 0.27406951785087585, 0.31765010952949524, -0.011539977975189686, 0.5795756578445435, 0.008516991510987282, -0.6085876822471619, -0.6219260692596436, -0.1627187281847, -0.13540486991405487, 0.37343987822532654, -0.03297463804483414, -0.8505972623825073, -0.2336285263299942, 0.4322149455547333, 0.16316378116607666, 0.18734844028949738, -0.02857869863510132, 0.9339950680732727, -0.07297272235155106, -0.627280056476593, 0.10490445047616959, 0.5852817893028259, 0.9379222393035889, -0.8823552131652832, 0.04571651667356491, -0.17017203569412231, 0.22559697926044464, -0.1369093656539917, -0.403700053691864, -0.2620418965816498, -0.12451573461294174, -0.49986398220062256, -0.8297343254089355, 0.7899259328842163, -0.5875522494316101, -0.37580540776252747, -0.14255009591579437, 0.6366006731987, -0.16468656063079834, -0.20293211936950684, -0.4505716562271118, -0.14838048815727234, 0.2177494466304779, -0.382208913564682, 0.4968772828578949, -0.033998891711235046, 0.2772384583950043, 0.7043671011924744, 1.0436842441558838, 0.059735625982284546, 0.4334607422351837, 0.0656767413020134, 0.7562295794487, -0.5467159152030945, -0.484850138425827, -0.9963255524635315, 0.4891319274902344, 0.22207315266132355, -0.5657936930656433, 1.0608022212982178, 0.5589377880096436, 0.6844127178192139, -0.3507899045944214, 0.9291825294494629, -0.15700207650661469, 0.15221796929836273, -0.7018016576766968, 0.406812459230423, -0.6651580929756165, 0.05175425484776497, -0.1960122138261795, -1.2010316848754883, -0.0022285236045718193, 0.25830182433128357, -0.06108412146568298, 0.3261604905128479, 0.4573940336704254, 0.8511728048324585, -0.09459024667739868, -0.2736687958240509, 0.6906231045722961, -0.00573228532448411, 0.6193292140960693, 0.41925379633903503, 0.8105999827384949, 0.05897527560591698, 0.4211036264896393, -0.28860291838645935, -0.1455707550048828, -0.16570927202701569, -0.7470800876617432, -0.9892032146453857, -0.7803761959075928, -0.21027520298957825, -0.2861948609352112, -0.1873903125524521, 1.2401484251022339, 0.904095470905304, -0.3967547118663788, -0.15659940242767334, 0.22852736711502075, -0.18254896998405457, 0.04793645814061165, -0.22622016072273254, 0.01638389751315117, -0.2827787697315216, -1.0662578344345093, 0.6180747151374817, 0.14930762350559235, -0.033075883984565735, -0.6957009434700012, -0.2891690135002136, 0.12662525475025177, 0.06057997792959213, 0.9769439697265625, -0.20304669439792633, -0.7516985535621643, -0.05452888831496239, 0.01706361211836338, -0.019525712355971336, -0.016731465235352516, 1.067723274230957, -0.6061971783638, 0.7308980226516724, 0.7431096434593201, 0.20412252843379974, 0.5223766565322876, 0.3263667821884155, 0.7061919569969177, -0.9736382365226746, -0.14035317301750183, -0.04219498112797737, 0.4793762266635895, 0.284413605928421, -0.29645612835884094, -0.14093588292598724, 0.10418017208576202, -0.6024838089942932, -0.5034236907958984, 0.48074620962142944, -1.2953886985778809, -0.029193323105573654, 1.473624348640442, -0.019966324791312218, 0.2457367181777954, 0.24436847865581512, -0.5411359071731567, 0.008263342082500458, -0.6402743458747864, 0.7312834858894348, 0.5534970164299011, -0.14344020187854767, -0.27959927916526794, -0.41992321610450745, 0.12591877579689026, 0.26076021790504456, -0.7102261781692505, -0.24166378378868103, 0.8074055910110474, 0.28148287534713745, 0.21302948892116547, 0.5765606760978699, 0.07180994004011154, -0.10659423470497131, -0.3249550461769104, 0.24784529209136963, -0.6221483945846558, -0.14819496870040894, -0.29531654715538025, 0.6526567935943604, 0.05173252895474434, -0.09384261816740036 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07999v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07999v1
A Multi-Level Framework for Accelerating Training Transformer Models
2024-04-07T03:04:34
2024-04-07T03:04:34
Longwei Zou, Han Zhang, Yangdong Deng
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.CL
The fast growing capabilities of large-scale deep learning models, such as Bert, GPT and ViT, are revolutionizing the landscape of NLP, CV and many other domains. Training such models, however, poses an unprecedented demand for computing power, which incurs exponentially increasing energy cost and carbon dioxide emissions. It is thus critical to develop efficient training solutions to reduce the training costs. Motivated by a set of key observations of inter- and intra-layer similarities among feature maps and attentions that can be identified from typical training processes, we propose a multi-level framework for training acceleration. Specifically, the framework is based on three basic operators, Coalescing, De-coalescing and Interpolation, which can be orchestrated to build a multi-level training framework. The framework consists of a V-cycle training process, which progressively down- and up-scales the model size and projects the parameters between adjacent levels of models via coalescing and de-coalescing. The key idea is that a smaller model that can be trained for fast convergence and the trained parameters provides high-qualities intermediate solutions for the next level larger network. The interpolation operator is designed to break the symmetry of neurons incurred by de-coalescing for better convergence performance. Our experiments on transformer-based language models (e.g. Bert, GPT) as well as a vision model (e.g. DeiT) prove that the proposed framework reduces the computational cost by about 20% on training BERT/GPT-Base models and up to 51.6% on training the BERT-Large model while preserving the performance.
[ -0.5185446739196777, -0.30038559436798096, 0.2521865665912628, 0.38495272397994995, 0.07492991536855698, 0.18180328607559204, -0.23879474401474, -0.3021600842475891, -0.1463773399591446, 0.3976437449455261, -0.667938232421875, -0.16913491487503052, -0.7396317720413208, -0.3155933618545532, -0.5920798778533936, 0.6706526279449463, 0.2031668871641159, 0.17726187407970428, -0.19076383113861084, -0.011215897276997566, -0.5221953392028809, -0.40641000866889954, -0.6733222007751465, -0.5141680240631104, 0.5121451020240784, 0.2113405019044876, 0.48470163345336914, 0.5264054536819458, 0.609351396560669, 0.30682486295700073, -0.07246949523687363, -0.1811610609292984, -0.5875291228294373, 0.2918890118598938, -0.039318688213825226, -0.35700559616088867, -0.33462801575660706, -0.2175752967596054, 0.6433660984039307, 0.5889062285423279, -0.05950121209025383, 0.12646237015724182, 0.11536552011966705, 0.7767636775970459, -0.647169291973114, 0.3508625328540802, -0.8475719690322876, -0.0008388463757000864, 0.18767409026622772, -0.12379508465528488, -0.3047284185886383, 0.00870346836745739, 0.053325459361076355, -0.4529082775115967, 0.4476454555988312, -0.3468054234981537, 0.7918918132781982, 0.492233544588089, -0.10679925233125687, 0.2066131979227066, -0.7211804986000061, 0.6008938550949097, -0.5860201120376587, 0.5887940526008606, -0.18929262459278107, 0.5238569378852844, 0.2015504091978073, -0.8432846069335938, -0.520271897315979, -0.10639666020870209, -0.10065408051013947, 0.1570391207933426, 0.04851306602358818, 0.1432657390832901, 0.5065923929214478, 0.3700827658176422, -0.3337417244911194, 0.3833499550819397, -0.36693790555000305, 0.23674267530441284, 0.28082606196403503, 0.09550254046916962, -0.09454800933599472, 0.25490298867225647, -0.4934055805206299, -0.3914376199245453, -0.4580041468143463, 0.18760621547698975, 0.3080371916294098, 0.665407657623291, -0.18467257916927338, 0.3018941581249237, -0.19511736929416656, 0.4894583821296692, 0.089043527841568, 0.0920386090874672, 0.4727727174758911, -0.0697154849767685, -0.08078816533088684, -0.03370684012770653, 0.3319152295589447, 0.32406046986579895, 0.26026293635368347, -0.3666588068008423, -0.03514951094985008, 0.12387171387672424, 0.5954890847206116, -1.224433183670044, -0.16510310769081116, 0.2496577799320221, -0.30450043082237244, -0.35730987787246704, -0.1537565141916275, -0.898315966129303, -0.3674793243408203, -0.5403099060058594, 0.3919941186904907, -0.39039334654808044, -0.37412312626838684, 0.22200945019721985, -0.06720902025699615, 0.6236972212791443, 0.22741854190826416, -1.0740678310394287, 0.1654822677373886, 0.7860367298126221, 0.5905566811561584, 0.11997378617525101, -0.40960612893104553, -0.4541807174682617, -0.17838913202285767, -0.18476620316505432, 0.5449132323265076, -0.757602334022522, -0.09107567369937897, 0.15022586286067963, 0.0659635066986084, -0.20901168882846832, -0.19747266173362732, 0.5500321388244629, -0.5413632392883301, 0.19376645982265472, -0.023060109466314316, -0.4463116526603699, -0.15421940386295319, 0.2726643979549408, -0.6191781163215637, 1.3792799711227417, 0.11378317326307297, -0.60834139585495, 0.4712589979171753, -0.823927640914917, -0.307954877614975, 0.004738746676594019, -0.1299036145210266, -0.5946625471115112, 0.2213270366191864, 0.5809903740882874, 0.6342675089836121, -0.6778624057769775, 0.17285187542438507, -0.23071376979351044, -0.40135276317596436, -0.4978640675544739, -0.30828091502189636, 0.5937010645866394, -0.088193878531456, -0.5185466408729553, 0.2634132504463196, -0.9502876400947571, 0.14516235888004303, -0.044856537133455276, -0.2432301789522171, -0.12038567662239075, -0.004343873355537653, -0.10250287503004074, 0.7151784896850586, 0.04995039850473404, -0.4309919774532318, 0.3766142427921295, -0.416376531124115, 0.4597484767436981, 0.7131435871124268, -0.1939990073442459, 0.31382477283477783, 0.04069574549794197, 0.551501989364624, 0.26941773295402527, 0.18715032935142517, -0.5413810610771179, -0.45361319184303284, -0.9473521113395691, -0.23172414302825928, 0.19644659757614136, 0.32474949955940247, -0.6508157253265381, 0.7113713622093201, -0.6444637775421143, -0.6596089601516724, -0.7696341872215271, -0.1349932849407196, 0.309211790561676, 0.5574325919151306, 0.8160864114761353, -0.06697282940149307, -0.2431575357913971, -0.93427574634552, -0.4285877048969269, 0.18231089413166046, -0.038577184081077576, -0.003139750100672245, 0.3636445999145508, -0.20600640773773193, 0.7674169540405273, -0.14565876126289368, -0.18388262391090393, 0.00435103103518486, 0.2095048576593399, 0.3487199544906616, 0.6476973295211792, 0.7123124003410339, -0.9305809140205383, -0.4576587677001953, 0.033356674015522, -0.5488961338996887, 0.11334673315286636, -0.1271185725927353, -0.0482693649828434, -0.43340855836868286, 0.5895500183105469, -0.28318583965301514, 0.35618165135383606, 0.571993350982666, 0.11206593364477158, 0.16664284467697144, -0.1217305064201355, 0.07008209079504013, -1.000458002090454, 0.007761665154248476, 0.08876973390579224, -0.0024073130916804075, -0.7395533919334412, 0.2139263153076172, 0.2361368089914322, -0.26625871658325195, -0.3668842315673828, 0.22866711020469666, -0.22788581252098083, -0.20023542642593384, -0.19381800293922424, -0.20485825836658478, 0.07294077426195145, 0.7979345321655273, 0.08444905281066895, 0.6616134643554688, 1.053432822227478, -0.48877471685409546, 0.13986746966838837, 0.05059988051652908, -0.22188891470432281, 0.6465190052986145, -0.6630178093910217, 0.10300660878419876, -0.33038583397865295, 0.019014697521924973, -0.979226291179657, 0.08634133636951447, -0.2886160612106323, -0.17625124752521515, 0.22753788530826569, -0.25132113695144653, -0.5212773680686951, -0.6694433093070984, -0.20721860229969025, 0.34121039509773254, 0.4873183071613312, -0.9767066240310669, 1.0102205276489258, 0.05438940227031708, 0.22415857017040253, -0.9338435530662537, -0.5662070512771606, 0.02177341841161251, -0.13523399829864502, -0.6729832887649536, 0.5528822541236877, 0.07582399994134903, 0.2521791458129883, -0.09209925681352615, -0.05119113624095917, -0.18464191257953644, 0.09433141350746155, 0.21404783427715302, -0.017292730510234833, -0.22212190926074982, 0.186493381857872, 0.043708886951208115, -0.26153549551963806, -0.01364543754607439, -0.6650087833404541, 0.7245091795921326, -0.31015074253082275, -0.35709095001220703, -0.25825077295303345, 0.29432955384254456, 0.7336139678955078, -0.39770907163619995, 0.85011225938797, 1.0249121189117432, -0.3655117452144623, -0.16848278045654297, -0.5117670297622681, -0.22289226949214935, -0.4950973391532898, 0.5889142751693726, -0.6167328953742981, -0.659034788608551, 0.43311795592308044, -0.3276185989379883, 0.4418277144432068, 0.6431901454925537, 0.8802517056465149, 0.19238081574440002, 1.038037896156311, 0.7954785227775574, -0.05888155475258827, 0.6805282235145569, -0.5324699282646179, 0.25026562809944153, -0.7837768793106079, -0.18353761732578278, -0.5958504676818848, -0.4905182421207428, -0.5321858525276184, -0.4986325800418854, 0.4448097050189972, 0.1545698046684265, -0.23485803604125977, 0.6004732251167297, -0.7152179479598999, 0.5582879781723022, 0.49396631121635437, -0.051047492772340775, 0.0038002636283636093, 0.07300493121147156, -0.1624496728181839, 0.12074963003396988, -0.8671692609786987, 0.08481524139642715, 0.8134268522262573, 0.3804066479206085, 0.7405831813812256, -0.20980018377304077, 0.442600816488266, 0.1043003723025322, 0.22154010832309723, -0.7073872089385986, 0.3182782828807831, -0.3695410192012787, -0.64412522315979, -0.2122044861316681, -0.37333396077156067, -0.7302143573760986, 0.6774898171424866, -0.3564859926700592, -0.6391221880912781, 0.5189442038536072, 0.12382236123085022, -0.07798168063163757, 0.5297896862030029, -0.6384042501449585, 0.8972170352935791, -0.25105229020118713, -0.540988028049469, -0.379935622215271, -0.9203062057495117, 0.2226412296295166, -0.14407646656036377, 0.047843944281339645, -0.19424009323120117, 0.2696813941001892, 0.3561919331550598, -0.2215261310338974, 0.6314932703971863, -0.4937514662742615, -0.16054323315620422, 0.028416931629180908, -0.3387874364852905, 0.5050174593925476, -0.2190629094839096, -0.2611108422279358, 0.3338654637336731, -0.4958235025405884, -0.44695398211479187, -0.566969633102417, 0.5649684071540833, -0.6202459931373596, -0.17855766415596008, -0.007692486513406038, -0.5909173488616943, -0.39263010025024414, 0.18682070076465607, 0.10781999677419662, 0.4511473774909973, 0.0613529197871685, 0.5784304141998291, 0.37876224517822266, -0.16653108596801758, 0.3323688805103302, 0.09689178317785263, -0.004718723241239786, -0.1922769546508789, 0.8325749039649963, -0.08047209680080414, 0.47841930389404297, 0.5302057862281799, 0.11687690764665604, -0.33405154943466187, -0.5246951580047607, -0.31706035137176514, -0.1541503667831421, -0.832098126411438, -0.23155659437179565, -0.755133867263794, -0.4251920282840729, -0.45865097641944885, -0.15829478204250336, -0.47424599528312683, -0.35371050238609314, 0.07281415909528732, -0.016716398298740387, 0.22220967710018158, 0.4003153443336487, 0.11735916882753372, 0.829934298992157, -0.5379325151443481, 0.5566084980964661, 0.42835864424705505, 0.4648650586605072, 0.002658714074641466, -0.3355120122432709, -0.5748324394226074, -0.12743444740772247, -0.3721049427986145, -0.289134681224823, 0.2871030569076538, 0.36811086535453796, 0.5485079288482666, 0.07781974971294403, -0.27811673283576965, 0.9046341776847839, -0.6238602995872498, 0.7478002309799194, 0.46180078387260437, -0.8890786170959473, 0.246928870677948, -0.2207813709974289, 0.14590343832969666, 0.51042640209198, 0.3402498662471771, -0.29676055908203125, -0.3275379240512848, -0.749788224697113, -1.2019627094268799, 0.7299455404281616, 0.13776497542858124, 0.307491272687912, 0.348060667514801, 0.47848209738731384, -0.04467083886265755, 0.3969937562942505, -0.7109414935112, -0.09906259924173355, -0.4964900016784668, -0.1051395833492279, 0.13610365986824036, 0.09041063487529755, 0.0028177041094750166, -0.369638055562973, 0.6660277843475342, -0.5277207493782043, 0.2478507161140442, -0.20207692682743073, -0.20141209661960602, 0.03173353150486946, 0.1499648541212082, 0.14107000827789307, 0.43572065234184265, -0.2559453845024109, -0.02887275069952011, 0.11013960838317871, -0.32041510939598083, 0.17825281620025635, 0.31451815366744995, 0.09374911338090897, -0.31004080176353455, 0.28242895007133484, 1.1415318250656128, 0.3604152202606201, -0.24295805394649506, 0.5898398756980896, -0.20180374383926392, -0.20782265067100525, 0.07269527018070221, 0.25843021273612976, 0.06439186632633209, 0.4366404116153717, 0.31874048709869385, 0.32286110520362854, -0.0775267481803894, -0.11275440454483032, 0.28681644797325134, 0.3703065514564514, -0.510346531867981, -0.20093898475170135, 0.8445673584938049, 0.23872296512126923, -0.15799620747566223, 0.49864742159843445, 0.2647468149662018, -0.5425413250923157, 0.656999945640564, 0.362925261259079, 1.126476764678955, -0.1433188021183014, -0.1907380223274231, 0.504500150680542, 0.44476911425590515, -0.051418233662843704, 0.10947125405073166, -0.1452288031578064, -0.672146201133728, -0.5968553423881531, -0.765066385269165, -0.18819144368171692, 0.08407042175531387, -0.7967096567153931, 0.4538532495498657, -0.2748686671257019, -0.09643711894750595, 0.1983112096786499, -0.25173428654670715, -1.0581365823745728, 0.3433714807033539, 0.25044143199920654, 0.8708987236022949, -0.6825913786888123, 1.1035614013671875, 0.16643480956554413, -0.31403157114982605, -0.5213598608970642, 0.08059564977884293, -0.45839524269104004, -1.0146042108535767, 0.6467933654785156, 0.48331594467163086, -0.28775840997695923, 0.3151797354221344, -0.26653268933296204, -0.6224400401115417, 1.0827443599700928, 0.5627739429473877, -0.9024723768234253, -0.474886417388916, 0.08642750978469849, 0.5990049242973328, -0.5524911880493164, 0.3955143988132477, 0.6077117323875427, 0.42502662539482117, 0.05931336060166359, -0.5854201912879944, -0.2904481291770935, -0.13247711956501007, 0.3332381248474121, 0.10065743327140808, -0.5131617784500122, 1.1039165258407593, -0.01647968776524067, -0.018191691488027573, -0.061925601214170456, 0.564636766910553, -0.07727789878845215, -0.3637388348579407, 0.8165305256843567, 0.6834827661514282, 0.4710219204425812, -0.1868700534105301, 1.0049047470092773, -0.7933446764945984, 0.6277241110801697, 0.9861986041069031, -0.2229849398136139, 0.48072192072868347, 0.36153826117515564, -0.10620341449975967, 0.5480881333351135, 0.35252153873443604, -0.18909317255020142, 0.5269603729248047, 0.17496272921562195, 0.024272266775369644, -0.33134037256240845, 0.10879404097795486, -0.6089245080947876, 0.25576767325401306, 0.448797345161438, -0.4830833971500397, -0.5019722580909729, 0.13919587433338165, -0.3841438591480255, -0.19249239563941956, -0.2863287329673767, 0.6827720403671265, -0.17627717554569244, -0.5163835287094116, 0.6478210687637329, -0.08796275407075882, 0.5505807995796204, -0.7072799205780029, -0.014380330219864845, 0.16547854244709015, 0.3865739107131958, -0.07706808298826218, -0.6164175868034363, 0.024725496768951416, -0.11259680241346359, -0.16494590044021606, -0.4270884692668915, 0.5685948133468628, -0.48869457840919495, -0.6134891510009766, 0.7435481548309326, 0.3919903337955475, -0.14050506055355072, -0.08762731403112411, -0.9730116724967957, -0.058490581810474396, -0.3665878474712372, -0.2677145302295685, 0.16623525321483612, 0.3360196352005005, 0.14826418459415436, 0.3454149663448334, 0.68780916929245, -0.16345049440860748, 0.448541522026062, 0.4277465343475342, 1.1708707809448242, -0.3887037932872772, -0.5049909353256226, -0.7037512063980103, 0.860840380191803, -0.130083367228508, -0.27573978900909424, 0.44035467505455017, 0.4362568259239197, 0.6298407316207886, 0.06351415812969208, 0.7803483009338379, -0.03514418751001358, 0.3652513027191162, -0.486153781414032, 0.278987854719162, -0.6655408143997192, 0.18415333330631256, -0.369223028421402, -1.166662335395813, -0.38408228754997253, 0.49619030952453613, -0.22266142070293427, 0.20338408648967743, 0.35881784558296204, 0.6271790266036987, -0.296407014131546, 0.042773790657520294, 0.2849350571632385, 0.22259801626205444, 0.7493850588798523, 0.4399719536304474, 0.7000510096549988, -0.6393895745277405, 0.28466200828552246, -0.35408419370651245, -0.1491766721010208, -0.15503144264221191, -0.8931930661201477, -0.812706470489502, -0.5254614949226379, -0.11391613632440567, -0.28981518745422363, -0.039993345737457275, 0.8067248463630676, 1.1403567790985107, -0.551295280456543, -0.14550292491912842, -0.47955286502838135, -0.26865145564079285, -0.6049845218658447, -0.22070568799972534, 0.3046952486038208, -0.8685912489891052, -0.7479105591773987, 0.48152491450309753, 0.3388954997062683, -0.23500874638557434, -0.5301294922828674, 0.09188424795866013, -0.1834232658147812, 0.001682309084571898, 0.6846345067024231, 0.10927083343267441, -0.47269588708877563, -0.22722631692886353, -0.14461052417755127, 0.12983933091163635, 0.5105557441711426, 1.0438344478607178, -1.007432222366333, 0.6393898725509644, 0.4075969457626343, 0.9981700778007507, 1.0219577550888062, -0.016166813671588898, 0.4646383225917816, -1.1472891569137573, 0.452764630317688, 0.23635466396808624, 0.30547401309013367, 0.3604862093925476, -0.24775609374046326, 0.5755183100700378, 0.17767708003520966, -0.4463123679161072, -0.792992115020752, 0.24114204943180084, -0.8139949440956116, -0.07897689193487167, 0.6242132782936096, -0.08069402724504471, -0.010784732177853584, 0.19800826907157898, 0.07201045751571655, 0.22738222777843475, -0.18801389634609222, 0.669073760509491, 0.460544615983963, -0.2263294756412506, -0.11199701577425003, -0.45308998227119446, 0.38122767210006714, 0.3318463861942291, -0.9676193594932556, 0.35998865962028503, 0.105492003262043, -0.08483723551034927, 0.393035352230072, 0.3063983619213104, -0.10161951184272766, -0.045025795698165894, 0.07783061265945435, 0.22267046570777893, 0.031214367598295212, -0.8239567279815674, -0.6024764180183411, 0.37411656975746155, -0.35938745737075806, -0.09523682296276093 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04770v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04770v1
Generating Uncontextualized and Contextualized Questions for Document-Level Event Argument Extraction
2024-04-07T00:50:21
2024-04-07T00:50:21
Md Nayem Uddin, Enfa Rose George, Eduardo Blanco, Steven Corman
cs.CL
cs.CL
This paper presents multiple question generation strategies for document-level event argument extraction. These strategies do not require human involvement and result in uncontextualized questions as well as contextualized questions grounded on the event and document of interest. Experimental results show that combining uncontextualized and contextualized questions is beneficial, especially when event triggers and arguments appear in different sentences. Our approach does not have corpus-specific components, in particular, the question generation strategies transfer across corpora. We also present a qualitative analysis of the most common errors made by our best model.
[ -0.5949451327323914, -1.283170223236084, 0.6560963988304138, -0.23029373586177826, -0.41157427430152893, -0.26396387815475464, -0.17772886157035828, -0.2542327046394348, -0.24449077248573303, 0.26474761962890625, -0.5363906621932983, -0.315904438495636, -0.14907100796699524, 0.2287183403968811, -0.5299753546714783, 1.0335558652877808, -0.2568204998970032, -0.07334120571613312, -0.5274588465690613, -0.22240500152111053, -0.4119953215122223, -0.6733207702636719, -0.9760710000991821, 0.0753619521856308, 0.4807904064655304, 0.631598711013794, 0.04775695502758026, -0.0026774792931973934, 0.08447063714265823, 0.20664367079734802, -0.017779789865016937, 0.2979617714881897, -0.04130784049630165, 0.4284787178039551, -0.29768577218055725, -0.22673340141773224, 0.13027511537075043, -0.020900342613458633, 0.5202286839485168, 0.8343615531921387, 0.07936770468950272, 0.28741371631622314, -0.20868954062461853, -0.02866707369685173, -0.8171717524528503, -0.31815892457962036, -0.7555822730064392, 0.11911135166883469, -0.16601157188415527, -0.6849486827850342, -0.38919568061828613, -0.25378528237342834, 0.006001368165016174, -0.46229586005210876, 0.40073227882385254, -0.12783180177211761, 0.8007160425186157, -0.13447526097297668, -0.8330596089363098, -0.48736631870269775, -0.7178377509117126, 0.6170591115951538, -0.4592043459415436, -0.23147563636302948, 0.06579647958278656, 0.0230405256152153, -0.16021554172039032, -1.0187019109725952, -0.5287540555000305, 0.10961540788412094, -0.03245975822210312, 0.3868195712566376, -0.2994101345539093, -0.28367024660110474, 0.41265130043029785, -0.14760752022266388, -0.5792149901390076, -0.16219861805438995, -0.5123646259307861, 0.1397167146205902, 0.6404362916946411, 0.1566684991121292, 0.4049399793148041, -0.6854826807975769, -0.3043993413448334, -0.10881076008081436, -0.570630669593811, 0.29380935430526733, 0.5426722764968872, -0.05844660848379135, 0.24187394976615906, 0.3511047065258026, -0.009591421112418175, 0.602779746055603, 0.51793372631073, 0.06251426041126251, -0.4969464838504791, -0.6409651041030884, 0.05571849271655083, 0.1697510927915573, 0.6398845911026001, 0.5681872963905334, 0.1413414478302002, -0.14742201566696167, 0.2606256604194641, -0.13313844799995422, 0.350815087556839, -0.7906362414360046, 0.3550293445587158, 0.8164069056510925, -0.26004505157470703, -0.4384704530239105, 0.1583254635334015, -1.2142537832260132, -0.13988548517227173, -0.017365681007504463, 0.25840112566947937, -0.24005615711212158, -0.2028786689043045, -0.1832662671804428, -0.6805185675621033, 0.49097540974617004, 0.5245288610458374, -0.8628382682800293, -0.04086563363671303, 0.40005144476890564, 0.044814448803663254, -0.36480236053466797, 0.10226071625947952, -0.7462639808654785, 0.3306770622730255, -0.603795051574707, 1.1588691473007202, -0.5370765328407288, -0.6170958876609802, 0.39658549427986145, 0.14957256615161896, -0.16988728940486908, -0.5598927736282349, 0.5877121686935425, -0.5717440843582153, 0.9000809788703918, -0.4657262861728668, -0.7434828877449036, 0.0714120864868164, 0.2696915864944458, -0.0712975338101387, 1.20595121383667, -0.11223841458559036, -0.8345032930374146, 0.6057754158973694, -0.8601192235946655, -0.553838312625885, 0.4329531490802765, -0.6000464558601379, 0.1957891434431076, 0.01583455130457878, 0.4592333734035492, 0.4168630540370941, -0.24126926064491272, 0.6014460921287537, 0.03045458346605301, 0.3111244738101959, 0.2703365385532379, -0.31940943002700806, 0.6779156923294067, 0.08709607273340225, -0.7977522015571594, -0.0035597828682512045, -0.9728618860244751, 0.1108689233660698, 0.1842898428440094, -0.4685145318508148, -0.47470197081565857, 0.26835668087005615, 0.1803811639547348, 0.1404063105583191, 0.32701539993286133, -0.640079915523529, 0.0457354299724102, -0.22133596241474152, 0.11628184467554092, 0.3712683916091919, 0.8843578696250916, 0.43118444085121155, 0.071755550801754, 0.6483013033866882, 0.2392600178718567, 0.11533026397228241, -0.2648316025733948, -0.5427356958389282, -0.5619818568229675, 0.4575220048427582, 0.030553312972187996, 0.5513742566108704, -0.8015670776367188, 0.010668238624930382, 0.41090643405914307, -0.28361478447914124, 0.054652754217386246, -0.06466429680585861, 0.17039214074611664, 1.0670619010925293, 0.2506949007511139, 0.4140278100967407, -0.6456496715545654, -0.6411243081092834, -0.05995134636759758, -0.44962990283966064, 0.08423478156328201, 0.15885670483112335, 0.5707744359970093, 0.2800436019897461, 1.0921262502670288, -0.6841794848442078, 0.4219147264957428, -0.33236122131347656, 0.7246426343917847, -0.2441169023513794, 0.431354284286499, 0.6033124923706055, -1.0847294330596924, -0.26040270924568176, 0.12958772480487823, -0.9844630360603333, -0.19532282650470734, -0.5131254196166992, -0.09919239580631256, 0.515985906124115, 0.7899178862571716, -0.50331711769104, 0.3958081305027008, -0.08096334338188171, -0.365068256855011, 0.3096763789653778, -0.20121335983276367, 0.3996976613998413, -1.5849422216415405, 0.08156469464302063, -0.2419823855161667, 0.01975317671895027, -0.9227452874183655, 0.20150357484817505, 0.015968749299645424, -0.2268015742301941, -0.7073915004730225, 0.6701995730400085, -0.13157790899276733, 0.26702895760536194, -0.16135092079639435, 0.5860899686813354, 0.3573489189147949, 0.26386719942092896, 0.09666933864355087, 0.5119756460189819, 0.401302307844162, -0.6360370516777039, 0.38445380330085754, 0.2758125960826874, -0.08322940021753311, 0.8907187581062317, -0.657666027545929, 0.24171781539916992, -0.4148235619068146, 0.04193592071533203, -1.236687421798706, -0.30326899886131287, 0.014495116658508778, -0.41983693838119507, 0.21124441921710968, -0.1930108219385147, -0.28558647632598877, -0.08708424866199493, -0.31813323497772217, 0.3852405846118927, 0.24874399602413177, -0.5564482808113098, 0.4572090804576874, 0.4264308512210846, -0.3541855216026306, -0.5364323258399963, -0.46376675367355347, 0.1157359629869461, -0.6237798929214478, -0.8456135392189026, 0.21625402569770813, -0.26284605264663696, -0.4430606961250305, -0.005259564146399498, 0.021333342418074608, 0.0170420091599226, -0.06842102855443954, 0.13919495046138763, 0.15123209357261658, -0.4544981122016907, 0.2115849405527115, 0.30787962675094604, 0.28241968154907227, 0.003860677592456341, -0.15968959033489227, 0.2887662947177887, 0.08044259250164032, -0.33321982622146606, -0.13147014379501343, 1.3881556987762451, 0.268955796957016, -0.20231784880161285, 0.4582290053367615, 0.6121352314949036, -0.6113950610160828, -0.043516408652067184, -0.7963390350341797, -0.08523205667734146, -0.3960045278072357, 0.151927649974823, -0.24982568621635437, -0.8424946069717407, 0.6670277714729309, -0.13016152381896973, 0.4013844430446625, 0.5150348544120789, 0.9101389646530151, -0.351750910282135, 1.1628700494766235, -0.08081359416246414, 0.5037699341773987, 0.3053427040576935, -0.04687615856528282, -0.009229199029505253, -0.6331627368927002, -0.35826295614242554, -0.7036733627319336, -0.0494132824242115, -0.24104043841362, -0.42040911316871643, 0.3458698093891144, 0.4018171429634094, -0.07684417068958282, 0.3880762755870819, -0.19457751512527466, 0.23619163036346436, 0.5018087029457092, -0.6249874830245972, 0.17513708770275116, -0.2186744660139084, -0.2832469344139099, 0.057020675390958786, -0.8325629830360413, -0.8780573606491089, 0.7577431201934814, -0.17659367620944977, 0.17968934774398804, 0.06306760013103485, 0.8566863536834717, 0.05447065085172653, 0.09869624674320221, -0.3128105700016022, 0.3600962162017822, 0.2865850329399109, -1.1702784299850464, -0.5589321851730347, -0.2824738323688507, -1.3717299699783325, 0.5139064788818359, -0.21038281917572021, -1.190720796585083, 0.7930141687393188, -0.1989634484052658, -0.6242252588272095, 0.2674458920955658, -0.7951879501342773, 1.0816435813903809, -0.015259445644915104, -0.1359979212284088, 0.3326174318790436, -0.4688512682914734, 0.2183695286512375, -0.19062583148479462, 0.18711309134960175, 0.16666747629642487, 0.14433416724205017, 1.0634256601333618, -0.26138585805892944, 0.47937941551208496, -0.04990000277757645, -0.08944981545209885, 0.8681578636169434, 0.04268352687358856, 0.3790619969367981, 0.5934239029884338, -0.0001389030076097697, -0.3962746858596802, 0.4808809459209442, -0.09286381304264069, -0.6120339632034302, 0.42418938875198364, -0.5183044672012329, -0.9393259882926941, -0.02575899288058281, -0.45663323998451233, -0.2861190736293793, 0.16393102705478668, 0.49420365691185, 0.9623180031776428, -0.4053640067577362, 0.2301759272813797, 0.6582699418067932, -0.3451806604862213, 0.9874007701873779, 0.5920929312705994, 0.3546599745750427, -0.26517146825790405, 0.3795912563800812, 0.05084437131881714, 0.2012212574481964, 0.39018815755844116, 0.2897791564464569, -0.4127764403820038, -0.2875765860080719, -0.7126350998878479, -0.18850503861904144, -1.0746783018112183, -0.237379789352417, -1.1090260744094849, 0.09648203104734421, -0.6977576017379761, -0.39947792887687683, -0.25311487913131714, -0.6106306314468384, -0.6884899735450745, -0.4893341064453125, 0.05096684768795967, 0.28796467185020447, -0.049889836460351944, 0.00501874927431345, -0.6812735795974731, 0.4224829077720642, 0.5280609130859375, -0.5822436809539795, -0.25598374009132385, -0.10483098030090332, 0.28095826506614685, -0.22926068305969238, -0.819003701210022, -1.3473998308181763, 0.09621062129735947, -0.10314127057790756, 0.6785036325454712, 0.5609498620033264, 0.481681764125824, 0.6435098648071289, -0.5368740558624268, 1.1131834983825684, 0.15289275348186493, -0.8112592697143555, 0.9834787249565125, -0.43360409140586853, 0.16723260283470154, 0.6795119047164917, 0.5974913239479065, -0.4936009347438812, -0.568917989730835, -0.9790000319480896, -0.8633742332458496, 0.74453204870224, 0.07766618579626083, 0.220716655254364, -0.6072589755058289, 0.4108980894088745, -0.037180691957473755, -0.002698593307286501, -0.529620885848999, -0.08017338067293167, -0.11532522737979889, 0.08991241455078125, 0.23500525951385498, -0.2492394894361496, -0.590620756149292, -0.08401306718587875, 0.1100049838423729, -0.23224863409996033, -0.060867682099342346, 0.5768613219261169, 0.04431617632508278, -0.4863864481449127, 0.5890902876853943, 0.9045308828353882, 0.9955345988273621, -0.2841649353504181, 0.1473180502653122, 0.5987509489059448, 0.060091517865657806, 0.11371038854122162, -0.05842557176947594, -0.4397653341293335, 0.1956043243408203, 0.5250517725944519, 0.6188709735870361, 0.3592943251132965, -0.5551583766937256, 0.5588940382003784, -0.3373103737831116, -0.6884849071502686, -0.38198530673980713, -0.23887336254119873, 0.38978344202041626, 0.3436313569545746, 0.5287224650382996, -0.5790630578994751, -0.09399528801441193, -0.97720867395401, 0.33318454027175903, 0.45173171162605286, -0.28807058930397034, 0.08868467807769775, 0.9144558906555176, 0.10625092685222626, -0.0754251554608345, 0.17977340519428253, -0.03817214071750641, -0.30214938521385193, 0.6303067207336426, 0.6419444680213928, 0.4653383791446686, 0.005196773447096348, 0.5428938865661621, 0.43874484300613403, 0.26260876655578613, 0.27287277579307556, 0.45243313908576965, -0.07517345249652863, -0.6877239346504211, -0.1282431036233902, -0.3746984601020813, -0.4853169620037079, 0.31323105096817017, -0.6864403486251831, 0.21772903203964233, -0.34147635102272034, -0.19106397032737732, 0.2897466719150543, 0.024249738082289696, -0.26293668150901794, 0.2857721149921417, 0.055722080171108246, 0.8411754965782166, -0.5567839741706848, 0.3229754567146301, 0.9653971791267395, -0.882965624332428, -0.6648668646812439, -0.05358080193400383, -0.39666691422462463, -0.08117575943470001, 0.6619361042976379, -0.461349219083786, 0.2962267994880676, -0.336079478263855, -0.4174222946166992, -0.7205672860145569, 0.899881899356842, 0.115718312561512, 0.05313967540860176, -0.08268856257200241, 0.138620525598526, 0.5187849402427673, -0.571781575679779, 0.21938841044902802, 0.21603775024414062, 0.5968179106712341, 0.3909730017185211, -0.26079654693603516, 0.2706599235534668, -0.07135923951864243, -0.0582679882645607, 0.0031666771974414587, -0.3162842392921448, 0.8158884644508362, 0.04052862152457237, -0.551202654838562, -0.16503886878490448, 0.7103415131568909, -0.014372279867529869, 0.551461398601532, 0.4163317084312439, 0.07838304340839386, 0.791257381439209, -0.05071647837758064, 1.2032116651535034, -0.13509540259838104, 0.1008734330534935, 0.8965032696723938, -0.3983372151851654, 0.6945940852165222, 0.5725958347320557, 0.38349440693855286, 0.4549739956855774, 0.7202633619308472, 0.20885588228702545, 0.30200323462486267, 0.08641460537910461, -0.2801157832145691, -0.4639074206352234, 0.0047712200321257114, -0.5333486199378967, 0.5119693875312805, 0.16872435808181763, 0.16962486505508423, -0.7024289965629578, 0.07587800174951553, 0.2843780517578125, 0.029910799115896225, 0.2031579613685608, 1.0175505876541138, -0.1275002360343933, -1.3070900440216064, 0.3826839029788971, 0.3727968633174896, 0.18074831366539001, -0.6105638146400452, 0.2011246234178543, -0.5632067918777466, -0.18233716487884521, -0.0753406286239624, -0.4139796793460846, 0.3034232258796692, 0.43277937173843384, -0.16160984337329865, -0.03160349652171135, 0.8637968301773071, -0.4457891881465912, -0.4659973382949829, 0.041642144322395325, 0.679123044013977, 0.12193980813026428, 0.0945008248090744, -0.48280081152915955, -0.320869117975235, -0.20495903491973877, -0.4585665166378021, 0.4913770258426666, 0.6741411685943604, -0.3481079041957855, 0.06678589433431625, 0.7374420762062073, -0.1836475133895874, 0.22667989134788513, 0.14001250267028809, 0.6464756727218628, -0.5078539252281189, -0.1896330863237381, -0.6829757690429688, 0.7740832567214966, -0.4413872957229614, -0.6021084189414978, 0.6253432631492615, 0.35084155201911926, 0.5649486780166626, 0.030601246282458305, 0.5871987342834473, -0.11385317891836166, 0.19522064924240112, -0.19785092771053314, 0.34186315536499023, -0.8011883497238159, -0.1995825618505478, -0.6597402095794678, -0.5090993046760559, -0.07036922872066498, 0.4222589433193207, -0.11043023318052292, -0.12955911457538605, 1.1892069578170776, 0.5770449638366699, 0.22110407054424286, 0.40771475434303284, 0.4503495991230011, -0.4199178218841553, 0.5546985864639282, 0.6510868668556213, 1.0758426189422607, -0.5787347555160522, 0.5653500556945801, 0.05719295144081116, -0.2857935428619385, -0.08119092136621475, -1.0913710594177246, -0.9910460710525513, -1.0241305828094482, -0.7892447710037231, -0.08253537118434906, -0.15028081834316254, 0.8434011936187744, 0.5591912269592285, -0.8822311162948608, -0.14033862948417664, 0.15639936923980713, 0.25318673253059387, 0.2320673018693924, -0.29986369609832764, 0.4091418981552124, -0.6626968383789062, -0.8252426981925964, 0.686333954334259, 0.19513380527496338, -0.10826419293880463, 0.1748131811618805, 0.4250980615615845, -0.7814408540725708, 0.5153352618217468, 0.7453938722610474, 0.36543288826942444, -0.2924235761165619, -0.6343550086021423, -0.22146075963974, 0.16944387555122375, -0.15386727452278137, 0.9840459227561951, -0.19972136616706848, 0.09154185652732849, 0.5062493681907654, 0.7031912803649902, 0.5419679880142212, 0.3203686475753784, 0.6258980631828308, -1.1833778619766235, 0.14431016147136688, 0.0309970173984766, 0.45250868797302246, 0.21969878673553467, -0.581394374370575, 0.28853049874305725, 0.3013395369052887, -0.28394344449043274, -0.8097530603408813, 0.22088849544525146, -1.0722233057022095, -0.551504909992218, 1.61180579662323, 0.020690793171525, -0.006456914357841015, -0.26962554454803467, -0.31000566482543945, 0.33368566632270813, -0.03785582631826401, 0.5254475474357605, 1.0386974811553955, -0.4314987063407898, -0.1305207461118698, -0.6404229998588562, 0.518216073513031, 0.422773540019989, -1.1417946815490723, -0.017501847818493843, 0.4398524761199951, 0.2361878603696823, 0.42216184735298157, 0.7255231738090515, -0.4171886742115021, 0.3174818158149719, -0.09508886188268661, -0.17778536677360535, 0.20411863923072815, -0.20351849496364594, 0.03700645640492439, 0.9541240334510803, -0.33999356627464294, -0.08742562681436539 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04759v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04759v1
What Happens When Small Is Made Smaller? Exploring the Impact of Compression on Small Data Pretrained Language Models
2024-04-06T23:52:53
2024-04-06T23:52:53
Busayo Awobade, Mardiyyah Oduwole, Steven Kolawole
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
Compression techniques have been crucial in advancing machine learning by enabling efficient training and deployment of large-scale language models. However, these techniques have received limited attention in the context of low-resource language models, which are trained on even smaller amounts of data and under computational constraints, a scenario known as the "low-resource double-bind." This paper investigates the effectiveness of pruning, knowledge distillation, and quantization on an exclusively low-resourced, small-data language model, AfriBERTa. Through a battery of experiments, we assess the effects of compression on performance across several metrics beyond accuracy. Our study provides evidence that compression techniques significantly improve the efficiency and effectiveness of small-data language models, confirming that the prevailing beliefs regarding the effects of compression on large, heavily parameterized models hold true for less-parameterized, small-data models.
[ -0.4985100030899048, -0.6308438777923584, 0.24783310294151306, 0.003923862241208553, -0.29784029722213745, -0.25208723545074463, -0.6307002305984497, -0.41179823875427246, 0.14280980825424194, 0.3393156826496124, -0.37368354201316833, 0.009342708624899387, -0.7216482758522034, 0.11823182553052902, -0.36880144476890564, 0.7275146842002869, 0.2504427134990692, -0.04293498396873474, -0.16467247903347015, -0.2596868574619293, -0.6279748678207397, -0.7859461903572083, -0.5123184323310852, -0.27667567133903503, 0.3847746253013611, 0.6608311533927917, 1.029457449913025, 0.866157054901123, 0.4850901961326599, 0.29453590512275696, -0.21166293323040009, -0.1334255486726761, -0.4751754403114319, -0.1542629599571228, 0.22727073729038239, -0.8284699320793152, 0.0905107632279396, 0.27026280760765076, 0.7774864435195923, 0.9521262049674988, -0.2895626425743103, 0.5362169742584229, 0.34204450249671936, 0.7912642955780029, -0.8028409481048584, -0.14144036173820496, -0.3876728415489197, -0.04471457004547119, -0.24821269512176514, 0.0930790975689888, -0.40298306941986084, -0.2670629620552063, -0.17294000089168549, -0.24132591485977173, 0.47808510065078735, 0.08555635064840317, 0.6750324368476868, 0.9169864058494568, -0.4453478753566742, -0.2627674639225006, -0.8853291273117065, 0.7022175192832947, -0.4361552894115448, 0.4227835536003113, 0.23143936693668365, 0.18421579897403717, 0.05860546976327896, -0.7594892978668213, -0.5714174509048462, 0.11598046869039536, -0.35628068447113037, -0.5565720200538635, -0.5711827278137207, 0.048263031989336014, 0.6577377915382385, 0.39859744906425476, -0.35056430101394653, 0.2949959933757782, -0.7253407835960388, -0.03212817758321762, 0.45303910970687866, -0.13666075468063354, 0.2324339896440506, 0.15929466485977173, 0.23954738676548004, -0.42914313077926636, -0.9927274584770203, 0.09688995778560638, 0.5668542981147766, 0.4905417263507843, 0.15098915994167328, 0.5334385633468628, -0.15116044878959656, 1.0314756631851196, 0.04720812663435936, -0.15478414297103882, -0.19029201567173004, -0.10457038879394531, -0.4998466670513153, -0.06218946725130081, 0.7932475805282593, -0.07525210827589035, 0.16017943620681763, 0.05065276846289635, -0.055298272520303726, 0.25463441014289856, 0.14876233041286469, -1.1370831727981567, -0.7772177457809448, -0.09632589668035507, -0.6237570643424988, -0.3652943968772888, -0.0959792509675026, -0.6311600804328918, -0.3876904249191284, -0.2990531325340271, 0.4322613477706909, -0.17377980053424835, 0.07354408502578735, 0.1666148602962494, -0.13515502214431763, -0.43862277269363403, 0.12660545110702515, -0.9604073166847229, 0.5451442003250122, 0.4297451078891754, 0.9857444167137146, 0.4508040249347687, -0.004815054591745138, -0.7901636362075806, -0.362283855676651, -0.151612788438797, 0.5013476014137268, -0.44540849328041077, -0.3631336987018585, -0.2873600423336029, -0.13953916728496552, 0.1670374572277069, -0.7053219676017761, 0.49230092763900757, -0.2739192247390747, -0.15087439119815826, -0.12207762151956558, -0.23231908679008484, -0.030243033543229103, -0.36191174387931824, -0.9875454902648926, 0.6220244765281677, -0.04731901362538338, -0.5654555559158325, 0.27355122566223145, -0.22522486746311188, -0.6340338587760925, -0.3104298412799835, -0.1181817501783371, -0.4136994779109955, 0.7956489324569702, 0.10058245807886124, 0.17050515115261078, -0.7574079632759094, -0.3068282902240753, -0.29802414774894714, -0.3363960087299347, 0.39823856949806213, -0.6230440735816956, 0.566175639629364, 0.22787997126579285, 0.07205762714147568, -0.5609080195426941, -0.587773859500885, 0.34313422441482544, 0.18077422678470612, -0.3627203702926636, -0.42701688408851624, -0.31036388874053955, -0.20827382802963257, 0.45229828357696533, 0.07920460402965546, -0.38849544525146484, 0.7510433793067932, -0.4243166446685791, 0.5484082698822021, 0.29602229595184326, -0.07253486663103104, 0.8014795184135437, -0.21442227065563202, 0.619717001914978, -0.24217696487903595, 0.27356764674186707, 0.31120994687080383, -0.36872291564941406, -0.9559034705162048, -0.15394647419452667, 0.9888045787811279, 0.15735198557376862, -0.7492027282714844, -0.040519971400499344, -0.36675071716308594, -0.5462104082107544, -0.9402860403060913, 0.3430905342102051, 0.33221474289894104, -0.01778404973447323, 0.17161746323108673, -0.24984468519687653, -0.5221871137619019, -0.9909772872924805, -0.23546938598155975, -0.09950178861618042, -0.3216077983379364, 0.22600358724594116, 0.5032359957695007, 0.015531709417700768, 0.8988253474235535, -0.8218091726303101, -0.4781491160392761, -0.12387718260288239, 0.4823828637599945, 0.0662611797451973, 0.626449465751648, 0.6536487936973572, -0.7758896946907043, -0.541157603263855, -0.38056236505508423, -0.04876117780804634, -0.25005123019218445, 0.08917905390262604, 0.20310892164707184, 0.049006931483745575, 0.07624608278274536, -0.7082058191299438, 0.682915449142456, 0.8843674659729004, -0.0995141863822937, 0.38257187604904175, -0.2720668315887451, 0.07548577338457108, -0.4937566816806793, -0.03111378289759159, -0.20327088236808777, -0.045113708823919296, -0.7139385938644409, -0.03455255180597305, 0.1061406135559082, -0.3922666609287262, -0.40134143829345703, 0.3123489022254944, -0.5858408212661743, -0.1945229470729828, -0.4626004695892334, -0.032640695571899414, 0.2225305587053299, 0.3993874192237854, 0.1575421541929245, 1.0201293230056763, 0.2509975731372833, -0.6752804517745972, 0.01682395674288273, 0.2688796818256378, -0.39688730239868164, 0.04414745792746544, -0.7366205453872681, 0.3753628730773926, -0.0909268781542778, 0.14897862076759338, -0.43423810601234436, -0.10413505136966705, -0.1485680490732193, -0.40970292687416077, 0.5639821290969849, -0.601755678653717, -0.7991827726364136, -0.4092496931552887, -0.23914571106433868, 0.5926010608673096, 0.8020818829536438, -0.6242632865905762, 0.24313873052597046, 0.5293758511543274, 0.00006612853758269921, -0.3916195034980774, -1.0556436777114868, -0.08554606884717941, -0.24280039966106415, -0.6105886101722717, 0.07980616390705109, -0.16516424715518951, -0.36462849378585815, 0.00995974987745285, -0.16896197199821472, -0.3701876699924469, 0.3559703826904297, 0.31806087493896484, -0.07813575118780136, -0.03749695420265198, 0.2894863486289978, 0.007927061058580875, 0.01340206153690815, -0.2515225112438202, -0.4617873728275299, 0.7129821181297302, -0.1777028739452362, -0.15950363874435425, -0.503686249256134, 0.097486712038517, 0.1861967146396637, 0.030707547441124916, 1.2775062322616577, 0.23329871892929077, -0.24301950633525848, -0.3461284339427948, -0.27823472023010254, -0.4292028248310089, -0.4938259720802307, -0.20767606794834137, -0.3171165883541107, -0.9942200183868408, 0.14263762533664703, -0.27124109864234924, -0.30216971039772034, 0.33824270963668823, 0.26472896337509155, -0.12063315510749817, 0.9993957877159119, 0.8339915871620178, -0.08777324110269547, 0.44626423716545105, -0.5276792049407959, 0.22538486123085022, -0.5830531120300293, 0.3666451573371887, -0.8796719908714294, -0.6872954368591309, -0.6219616532325745, -0.6643347144126892, 0.303148090839386, 0.7547118663787842, 0.033296674489974976, 0.3990967869758606, -0.6735140085220337, 0.7068972587585449, 0.6198371648788452, -0.08416467905044556, 0.20340095460414886, -0.17179599404335022, 0.3180958032608032, -0.035304002463817596, -1.2127437591552734, -0.3900734484195709, 0.968364953994751, 0.16549161076545715, 0.7904624342918396, 0.36128562688827515, 0.7235159873962402, 0.3787805438041687, 0.2635984718799591, -0.8796300888061523, 0.14406706392765045, -0.46667855978012085, -0.36562463641166687, -0.20604419708251953, -0.5851760506629944, -0.9503839612007141, 0.31442418694496155, -0.35621312260627747, -0.6729364395141602, 0.3840833008289337, 0.534791111946106, -0.7450653314590454, 0.11890425533056259, -1.0677995681762695, 0.8618167638778687, -0.15347646176815033, -0.15628185868263245, -0.24612954258918762, -0.4400586187839508, 0.36628830432891846, -0.34560427069664, 0.3943616449832916, 0.2525409162044525, -0.03731982037425041, 0.8773329257965088, -0.9162583351135254, 0.8034249544143677, -0.14425939321517944, 0.19556590914726257, 0.357654333114624, 0.26787713170051575, 0.6386063694953918, -0.08425568044185638, 0.22294603288173676, 0.31324848532676697, 0.3469831645488739, -0.4225795567035675, -0.9053632616996765, 0.5011982917785645, -0.7045482993125916, -0.5182343125343323, -0.3068528175354004, -0.3493764400482178, -0.08982658386230469, -0.049908678978681564, 0.30741676688194275, 0.5458277463912964, -0.025190766900777817, 0.37907174229621887, 0.5577278137207031, -0.19984878599643707, 0.21433641016483307, 0.6993643045425415, 0.051242779940366745, -0.17770260572433472, 0.7695390582084656, 0.46281570196151733, 0.3198091983795166, 0.14797213673591614, 0.12533511221408844, 0.0862249955534935, -0.5517932176589966, -0.3313634693622589, 0.37407639622688293, -0.5209043622016907, -0.5442095994949341, -0.41543346643447876, -0.008880591951310635, -0.5800589323043823, 0.029738521203398705, -0.6409127712249756, -0.9302338361740112, -0.31871601939201355, 0.14350268244743347, 0.1800267994403839, 0.7477360963821411, -0.3306531012058258, 0.9152360558509827, -1.0126144886016846, 0.052126090973615646, 0.3408125936985016, -0.0024499502032995224, -0.03255133330821991, -0.490005224943161, -0.6158497929573059, 0.23783977329730988, 0.05330711603164673, -0.6131979823112488, 0.4930235743522644, 0.4366438090801239, -0.10611103475093842, 0.3272891342639923, 0.23606441915035248, 0.6482798457145691, -0.6301218867301941, 0.642427384853363, 0.14114078879356384, -0.797711193561554, 0.43032586574554443, 0.24120846390724182, 0.49602851271629333, 0.6900472044944763, 0.12696652114391327, -0.48393937945365906, -0.1046781986951828, -0.8994475603103638, -0.46003907918930054, 0.8020909428596497, 0.3698522746562958, -0.2136446237564087, 0.2511405050754547, 0.2755344808101654, -0.005901917815208435, 0.6155767440795898, -0.4313707947731018, -0.34169620275497437, 0.30908656120300293, -0.20255492627620697, -0.05720782279968262, -0.4658570885658264, -0.22849923372268677, -0.15230271220207214, 0.6555889248847961, -0.1318846195936203, 0.3750428855419159, -0.39289677143096924, -0.39176782965660095, -0.04340701177716255, 0.25541016459465027, 0.3304591476917267, 0.06436194479465485, 0.13728097081184387, 0.24233300983905792, 0.0919027179479599, -0.3690114915370941, 0.31063807010650635, 0.04379699006676674, -0.2437487691640854, -0.05088281258940697, 0.38492026925086975, 0.7766521573066711, 0.06991701573133469, -0.4919140040874481, 0.4723699390888214, -0.5063288807868958, 0.23266199231147766, -0.05766142159700394, 0.20019939541816711, -0.27889034152030945, 0.1781301200389862, -0.008298657834529877, 0.3645588755607605, 0.07652495801448822, -0.4723481237888336, 0.06457313895225525, 0.3280057907104492, -0.033667463809251785, -0.3579176068305969, 0.46938979625701904, 0.055693160742521286, -0.2520793676376343, 0.6001362800598145, -0.028275206685066223, -0.49934959411621094, 0.4425888955593109, 0.12860916554927826, 0.37538766860961914, -0.0733320415019989, 0.10252594202756882, 0.23249158263206482, 0.5430772304534912, -0.3631218373775482, -0.10082864761352539, -0.41521885991096497, -0.5972805619239807, -0.556779682636261, -0.8062126040458679, -0.04445721209049225, -0.009457293897867203, -0.6753426790237427, 0.20096586644649506, -0.37488168478012085, -0.4155079126358032, 0.051209621131420135, 0.3876771628856659, -1.03669273853302, 0.23367689549922943, 0.0849020779132843, 0.9816897511482239, -0.9507184624671936, 1.2533169984817505, 0.48588481545448303, -0.6531166434288025, -1.0333073139190674, -0.004484896548092365, 0.2101966291666031, -0.5211437940597534, 0.8030590415000916, 0.002282563131302595, -0.038813769817352295, 0.07738503068685532, -0.44243124127388, -1.029392123222351, 0.738762378692627, 0.6844809651374817, -0.6013558506965637, 0.006217642221599817, 0.300618439912796, 0.6668938994407654, 0.015360715799033642, -0.10991376638412476, 0.9193681478500366, 0.27342489361763, 0.005258291959762573, -1.1357462406158447, -0.1406913846731186, -0.009959397837519646, -0.061300888657569885, 0.6095263361930847, -0.8472374081611633, 0.8248449563980103, 0.01768607273697853, -0.5869325995445251, 0.20087043941020966, 0.6273303627967834, -0.17617085576057434, -0.08332522958517075, 0.5160319209098816, 0.7593594193458557, 0.9329327344894409, -0.1975366175174713, 1.0813041925430298, -0.42009875178337097, 0.42913416028022766, 1.172271490097046, 0.06007250025868416, 0.7843093276023865, 0.576678991317749, -0.3621514141559601, 0.12794959545135498, 0.35315272212028503, 0.33081668615341187, 0.5882302522659302, 0.17788544297218323, -0.16907790303230286, -0.023684164509177208, -0.35454729199409485, -0.1350276619195938, 0.3539995849132538, 0.30710387229919434, -0.04638922959566116, 0.16750279068946838, 0.3115430176258087, 0.035908766090869904, 0.012759614735841751, -0.24970397353172302, 0.6720941066741943, 0.3107418417930603, -0.4221433699131012, 0.78835529088974, 0.06191430240869522, 0.5922115445137024, -0.3685949146747589, 0.20991995930671692, -0.055978741496801376, 0.1798456907272339, -0.12196177989244461, -0.50447678565979, 0.44259944558143616, 0.12217621505260468, -0.35719120502471924, -0.41734397411346436, 0.8736323118209839, -0.4740428924560547, -0.3249797821044922, -0.02467975951731205, 0.413013219833374, 0.1477375030517578, -0.2560080885887146, -0.2968935966491699, 0.3848283588886261, 0.0007284394814632833, -0.11955327540636063, 0.6318982839584351, 0.5137271881103516, 0.3248945474624634, 0.6805297136306763, 0.48703324794769287, 0.533361554145813, -0.17672787606716156, -0.16853727400302887, 1.0332887172698975, -0.27839991450309753, -0.4052000343799591, -0.6913895010948181, 0.17553623020648956, -0.14573460817337036, 0.07335610687732697, 0.6410320401191711, 0.45058566331863403, 0.8009287714958191, 0.08653411269187927, 0.6680999994277954, -0.35578644275665283, 0.3161785304546356, -0.58152836561203, 0.6689742207527161, -0.562705934047699, 0.3086744546890259, 0.20497320592403412, -0.6815309524536133, -0.17840445041656494, 0.5683755874633789, -0.3415350914001465, -0.18206427991390228, 0.7320214509963989, 0.5544342398643494, -0.03996587544679642, -0.039102133363485336, 0.3836163878440857, 0.2578044533729553, 0.06695397198200226, 0.5011938810348511, 0.5468123555183411, -0.4267105460166931, 0.6618137359619141, -0.8271446228027344, -0.04305519908666611, -0.17609958350658417, -0.5233108997344971, -0.8257291316986084, -0.6404068470001221, -0.3023906648159027, -0.22804217040538788, -0.1620652824640274, 0.8550378084182739, 0.7741864919662476, -0.5820250511169434, -0.04130670800805092, 0.1378951221704483, 0.027265429496765137, -0.1220555454492569, -0.17021198570728302, 0.32628950476646423, 0.022763922810554504, -0.6751108765602112, 0.4583709239959717, 0.03700508177280426, 0.26572027802467346, -0.13487546145915985, 0.03800707310438156, 0.0348379947245121, 0.0347764752805233, 0.2572704255580902, 0.5358670949935913, -0.23407335579395294, -0.387218713760376, -0.40483689308166504, -0.06011413782835007, -0.2774394750595093, 1.1524462699890137, -1.0384432077407837, 0.15445715188980103, 0.4134284555912018, 0.473641037940979, 0.4330800771713257, 0.07851911336183548, 0.7399499416351318, -1.2677853107452393, 0.8611940741539001, 0.23061613738536835, 0.40237149596214294, 0.2744597792625427, -0.4005114734172821, 0.7261013388633728, 0.1235683411359787, -0.6575450301170349, -1.1136265993118286, 0.27066996693611145, -0.30872493982315063, -0.46228018403053284, 1.0760765075683594, -0.026540478691458702, -0.36134541034698486, 0.41321200132369995, -0.21649454534053802, 0.4313502013683319, -0.276641845703125, 0.7329046130180359, 0.7209740877151489, -0.1299109011888504, -0.1732274889945984, -0.6790360808372498, 0.8252125978469849, 0.32271870970726013, -0.4157409369945526, 0.15531237423419952, 0.7760462760925293, -0.04870694503188133, 0.07694514095783234, 0.4273907542228699, 0.5776082277297974, 0.01349301915615797, 0.15098047256469727, -0.2472643107175827, -0.07677410542964935, -0.5079180002212524, -0.6655139923095703, 0.2975734770298004, 0.32401520013809204, 0.02489188127219677 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04748v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04748v1
Multilingual Brain Surgeon: Large Language Models Can be Compressed Leaving No Language Behind
2024-04-06T22:16:32
2024-04-06T22:16:32
Hongchuan Zeng, Hongshen Xu, Lu Chen, Kai Yu
cs.CL
cs.CL
Large Language Models (LLMs) have ushered in a new era in Natural Language Processing, but their massive size demands effective compression techniques for practicality. Although numerous model compression techniques have been investigated, they typically rely on a calibration set that overlooks the multilingual context and results in significant accuracy degradation for low-resource languages. This paper introduces Multilingual Brain Surgeon (MBS), a novel calibration data sampling method for multilingual LLMs compression. MBS overcomes the English-centric limitations of existing methods by sampling calibration data from various languages proportionally to the language distribution of the model training datasets. Our experiments, conducted on the BLOOM multilingual LLM, demonstrate that MBS improves the performance of existing English-centric compression methods, especially for low-resource languages. We also uncover the dynamics of language interaction during compression, revealing that the larger the proportion of a language in the training set and the more similar the language is to the calibration language, the better performance the language retains after compression. In conclusion, MBS presents an innovative approach to compressing multilingual LLMs, addressing the performance disparities and improving the language inclusivity of existing compression techniques.
[ -0.4163655638694763, -0.35334718227386475, 0.32536348700523376, 0.3440466523170471, -0.25375744700431824, 0.15281344950199127, -0.6457588076591492, -0.2960292100906372, 0.6593668460845947, 0.4528394043445587, -0.6844127178192139, -0.35577264428138733, -0.412069171667099, 0.23871691524982452, 0.16882294416427612, 0.7857031226158142, 0.35998040437698364, 0.7477385401725769, -0.26018667221069336, -0.14593403041362762, -0.6532958149909973, -0.575610339641571, -0.669876754283905, -0.4457535445690155, 0.6794489622116089, 0.10616959631443024, 0.5972435474395752, 0.5657551288604736, 0.16746029257774353, 0.31483790278434753, -0.21600507199764252, 0.33106300234794617, -0.33125144243240356, 0.05419919639825821, -0.03375941514968872, -0.5749943852424622, -0.19855855405330658, -0.37262970209121704, 0.5767900943756104, 0.9715316295623779, -0.6132872104644775, -0.03566356748342514, 0.1521071195602417, 0.7423995137214661, -0.5823412537574768, 0.013417807407677174, -0.669495165348053, 0.1520995795726776, -0.2468847632408142, -0.5021262168884277, -0.7179234623908997, -0.38488006591796875, -0.49806398153305054, -0.2250956892967224, -0.014175089076161385, -0.25211092829704285, 0.36415380239486694, 0.43025484681129456, -0.5292832851409912, 0.18212832510471344, -0.26376819610595703, 0.9746306538581848, -0.6149678230285645, 0.5732966661453247, 0.18843477964401245, 0.47543808817863464, 0.057819679379463196, -0.06635425239801407, -0.4614730477333069, 0.2024412304162979, 0.11328230798244476, -0.12448621541261673, 0.11387210339307785, 0.043204400688409805, 0.16821514070034027, 0.20549385249614716, -0.5298630595207214, 0.3725908398628235, -0.36690753698349, -0.5317353010177612, 0.5260747671127319, -0.1186685711145401, 0.2672578692436218, -0.1922847330570221, -0.1965411901473999, -0.42051365971565247, -1.1462019681930542, -0.1565047651529312, 0.6038188934326172, 0.36750081181526184, -0.08446162939071655, 0.25876232981681824, 0.1495198756456375, 1.1319392919540405, -0.3965371549129486, -0.5552780032157898, 0.4396059215068817, -0.02804775908589363, -0.2350744903087616, 0.08596021682024002, 0.5998398661613464, 0.5138950943946838, 0.30927133560180664, -0.14775414764881134, 0.006172481924295425, -0.018276289105415344, 0.020855488255620003, -0.8120793700218201, -0.22687146067619324, 0.2867414057254791, -0.2493131309747696, -0.06914018839597702, -0.40315714478492737, -0.8457764387130737, -0.5065933465957642, -0.26283958554267883, 0.021880922839045525, -0.3534964919090271, -0.35579702258110046, 0.3370857834815979, 0.015057569369673729, -0.009963035583496094, 0.1448878049850464, -1.0618541240692139, 0.0597241185605526, 0.44530004262924194, 0.6680956482887268, 0.014382287859916687, -0.3293062448501587, -0.5924976468086243, 0.372045636177063, -0.3074882924556732, 0.77517169713974, -0.3043072521686554, -0.30059298872947693, 0.07866726815700531, 0.002989288652315736, 0.12330252677202225, -0.6651632785797119, 0.3004501461982727, -0.35706356167793274, -0.1412469893693924, -0.24751563370227814, -0.11434214562177658, -0.38325080275535583, 0.49157771468162537, -0.6592959761619568, 0.5804097652435303, -0.11647751182317734, -0.3572385013103485, 0.14149942994117737, -0.15546885132789612, -0.5373426079750061, 0.13080532848834991, -0.5301337838172913, -0.07565362751483917, 0.25735852122306824, 0.6098031997680664, 0.6125816106796265, -0.32471492886543274, 0.27389007806777954, -0.4329644441604614, -0.2969064712524414, 0.01552517432719469, -0.5388385057449341, 0.9348011612892151, 0.1731453388929367, 0.4223495423793793, -0.3042539656162262, -0.49476951360702515, 0.3807719647884369, -0.08421212434768677, -0.3899829089641571, -0.1455158144235611, -0.13128463923931122, 0.1966879665851593, 0.16371381282806396, 0.19901947677135468, -0.7342426180839539, 0.5520831346511841, -0.5441566109657288, 0.614886999130249, 0.4670279026031494, -0.07926442474126816, 0.20208637416362762, -0.3786609172821045, 0.5876554250717163, -0.16852621734142303, -0.09502188861370087, -0.5018056035041809, -0.2385656237602234, -0.4677025377750397, -0.5961620211601257, 0.40991055965423584, 0.732421338558197, -0.9022736549377441, 0.3722715973854065, -0.6949650645256042, -0.6792729496955872, -0.7455677390098572, 0.10037559270858765, 0.2154814451932907, 0.24711574614048004, 0.23095162212848663, -0.24881502985954285, -0.5772752165794373, -1.1816266775131226, -0.41309770941734314, -0.08995736390352249, -0.22533182799816132, 0.30369487404823303, -0.08430662751197815, -0.07258262485265732, 0.583728551864624, -0.5306804776191711, -0.339853435754776, -0.09472062438726425, 0.11578989773988724, 0.43423333764076233, 0.7010430097579956, 0.5485987067222595, -0.6816291213035583, -0.2970983684062958, -0.006115236785262823, -0.551903247833252, -0.11461759358644485, -0.011474765837192535, 0.29766926169395447, 0.27387988567352295, 0.3645235598087311, -0.595079779624939, 0.08107555657625198, 1.039638638496399, 0.31369251012802124, 0.3520917296409607, -0.4403113126754761, 0.42740851640701294, -1.0421091318130493, 0.028703048825263977, -0.2815071940422058, -0.38891738653182983, -0.4034647047519684, 0.3279559910297394, 0.45265862345695496, -0.21858616173267365, -0.6255794167518616, 0.34630826115608215, -0.7003889083862305, 0.12425098568201065, -0.22624270617961884, -0.10849713534116745, 0.002987576648592949, 0.5398557782173157, 0.12424241006374359, 0.6731769442558289, 0.6221418380737305, -0.5247792601585388, 0.2781243324279785, 0.24337297677993774, -0.4053870737552643, 0.798868715763092, -0.40027564764022827, 0.3093850016593933, -0.4489576518535614, 0.3954281210899353, -0.8303782939910889, -0.12090792506933212, -0.27667099237442017, -0.4074694514274597, 0.7899852991104126, -0.3250487148761749, -0.7591547966003418, -0.30626606941223145, -0.34299296140670776, 0.6210483312606812, 0.3682800829410553, -0.5046162605285645, 0.499601811170578, 0.8346641659736633, -0.2945294678211212, -0.6749857664108276, -1.3116326332092285, 0.3665429353713989, -0.09066207706928253, -0.6147848963737488, 0.43375033140182495, -0.6331347227096558, 0.07561028748750687, -0.507752537727356, -0.06155196949839592, -0.2931922376155853, -0.24316291511058807, -0.13214626908302307, 0.27864333987236023, 0.13360902667045593, 0.15516340732574463, 0.3497973084449768, 0.05571825057268143, -0.158137246966362, -0.0999835878610611, 0.7380744218826294, 0.3498474955558777, -0.3514249622821808, -0.10156720131635666, 0.42644616961479187, 0.46497708559036255, -0.13736329972743988, 0.604126513004303, 0.3680226504802704, -0.5736445784568787, 0.062184497714042664, -0.9498538970947266, -0.43868565559387207, -0.43434423208236694, 0.4834936559200287, -0.43232402205467224, -0.8493387699127197, 0.3034231662750244, -0.16582651436328888, 0.17445722222328186, 0.15101692080497742, 0.5578347444534302, 0.28982552886009216, 1.1494154930114746, 0.6827387809753418, -0.24442870914936066, 0.16455267369747162, 0.10588257759809494, 0.16517029702663422, -0.8069353699684143, -0.17697839438915253, -0.6058762669563293, -0.44813811779022217, -0.4332932233810425, -0.4908641576766968, 0.6382180452346802, 0.08261396735906601, 0.20090816915035248, 0.3258097171783447, -0.5926180481910706, 0.8836234211921692, 0.15053090453147888, 0.171416237950325, -0.007038295269012451, 0.3178396224975586, -0.3361217677593231, -0.33004677295684814, -0.7591181993484497, -0.28122058510780334, 0.9603070020675659, 0.11980625241994858, 0.6016102433204651, 0.22110140323638916, 0.5345243215560913, -0.21480007469654083, 0.4694198966026306, -0.7201340794563293, 0.48541924357414246, -0.2523593008518219, -0.5249964594841003, -0.026511410251259804, -0.6397625207901001, -0.9077885746955872, 0.3889711797237396, -0.07732611149549484, -0.9894390106201172, 0.04713493585586548, 0.1374647617340088, -0.5475907921791077, 0.4537568986415863, -0.6850021481513977, 0.5274491906166077, 0.023518597707152367, -0.27382922172546387, -0.5650599598884583, -0.6850124001502991, 0.3195936679840088, -0.35312512516975403, 0.5600019693374634, -0.010552214458584785, -0.14493592083454132, 0.508074939250946, -0.22842073440551758, 0.6600539684295654, -0.22053594887256622, -0.19104637205600739, -0.19282430410385132, 0.28173670172691345, 0.3525148928165436, 0.1636628955602646, -0.19775475561618805, 0.611173689365387, 0.3035566508769989, -0.36524584889411926, -0.5956118106842041, 1.0605056285858154, -0.30502447485923767, -0.36470431089401245, -0.2329031229019165, -0.8840547204017639, -0.48058760166168213, 0.04477377608418465, 0.13551749289035797, 0.40597254037857056, 0.028096621856093407, 0.18908904492855072, 0.4198141396045685, -0.5176836252212524, 0.48469701409339905, 0.6522772312164307, -0.15394502878189087, -0.8952906131744385, 0.7198216915130615, 0.19775377213954926, -0.02601192519068718, 0.6706673502922058, -0.028065618127584457, -0.10259491950273514, -0.3999641537666321, -0.7881518006324768, 0.3335481286048889, -0.5465580821037292, -0.5609968304634094, -0.5930930972099304, 0.012598329223692417, -0.5901704430580139, -0.058949507772922516, -0.30152928829193115, -0.3071122169494629, 0.30562740564346313, 0.19640426337718964, 0.019238704815506935, 0.3962515890598297, -0.23421253263950348, 0.49459579586982727, -1.0750370025634766, 0.0172806978225708, 0.0042506554163992405, 0.25347933173179626, -0.16719874739646912, -0.1858910173177719, -0.34694749116897583, 0.16193543374538422, -0.3234885036945343, -1.1474709510803223, 0.7456471920013428, 0.1489619016647339, 0.3226868808269501, 0.33674249053001404, -0.25860103964805603, 1.0402500629425049, -0.8482121825218201, 0.8372033834457397, 0.4322132170200348, -0.5352676510810852, 0.134974867105484, -0.026829320937395096, 0.7645779252052307, 0.6425054669380188, 0.27522504329681396, -0.8610607385635376, -0.06071097031235695, -0.09531337767839432, -0.7986539602279663, 0.5851028561592102, -0.38866791129112244, 0.3712035119533539, -0.12420793622732162, 0.33841636776924133, 0.19851109385490417, 0.5786146521568298, -0.8744587302207947, -0.27445483207702637, 0.33173009753227234, -0.446115106344223, -0.31005749106407166, -0.22409214079380035, -0.27746695280075073, -0.2818757891654968, 0.7122822999954224, -0.43924590945243835, 0.3914782702922821, -0.12993469834327698, -0.18063074350357056, -0.14079929888248444, 0.17321211099624634, 0.4536525309085846, 0.28515973687171936, 0.04330705106258392, 0.20018497109413147, 0.34438422322273254, -0.5207558274269104, 0.054207488894462585, 0.21147562563419342, 0.01775750145316124, -0.08082324266433716, 0.03972669690847397, 0.4545072019100189, 0.3517441749572754, -0.8524363040924072, 0.5739288926124573, -0.12423685193061829, 0.039612703025341034, -0.27671873569488525, -0.39232540130615234, 0.07206489145755768, 0.12056882679462433, 0.2349388152360916, 0.3553299903869629, 0.04701615124940872, -0.09596069902181625, 0.03373141214251518, 0.6495875120162964, -0.20208975672721863, -0.22426900267601013, 0.49425774812698364, -0.019287411123514175, -0.2410358339548111, 0.561057984828949, 0.11861111223697662, -0.4046080410480499, 0.21783511340618134, 0.4533360004425049, 0.5670270323753357, -0.5572643280029297, -0.194965198636055, 0.5356680750846863, 0.5839740037918091, -0.16076327860355377, 0.37021905183792114, -0.10463658720254898, -0.741627037525177, -1.1023167371749878, -0.48675158619880676, -0.24273090064525604, 0.31507205963134766, -0.52091383934021, 0.5507602691650391, -0.1435459554195404, -0.06521610915660858, -0.13718406856060028, -0.07972100377082825, -0.5888537764549255, 0.1552991271018982, 0.19763924181461334, 1.1745277643203735, -0.5366760492324829, 0.95499187707901, 0.6505584120750427, -0.02561146952211857, -0.6774584054946899, -0.18530897796154022, 0.2192346304655075, -0.8681132197380066, 0.37807315587997437, 0.4498743414878845, 0.07268710434436798, 0.08336743712425232, -0.4119036793708801, -0.7757462859153748, 0.7133263945579529, 1.1293777227401733, -0.6705009341239929, -0.07665542513132095, 0.14977429807186127, 0.23418082296848297, -0.043939702212810516, 0.4351581037044525, 0.19505615532398224, 0.46471330523490906, -0.06564699113368988, -0.990164577960968, -0.20096558332443237, -0.18198618292808533, -0.13508541882038116, 0.453619122505188, -0.49605539441108704, 0.5257079601287842, 0.010923563502728939, -0.037886861711740494, 0.10648105293512344, 0.4135824739933014, 0.38126638531684875, -0.3447415828704834, 0.6878538131713867, 0.6447464823722839, 0.8141055703163147, 0.015082228928804398, 1.0309040546417236, -0.9379925727844238, 0.14645057916641235, 0.8239663243293762, -0.09022118896245956, 0.8865200877189636, 1.0106843709945679, -0.0212396327406168, 0.33518099784851074, 0.5446712970733643, 0.18619196116924286, 0.47892677783966064, 0.3019554615020752, -0.26376691460609436, -0.32354867458343506, -0.19436906278133392, -0.2321462482213974, 0.29284927248954773, 0.13622644543647766, 0.026248952373862267, -0.17484523355960846, 0.2761850655078888, 0.257907897233963, 0.09063450247049332, -0.3415636718273163, 0.37673237919807434, 0.09558505564928055, -0.943991482257843, 0.7865162491798401, 0.15224102139472961, 0.930899441242218, -0.883929967880249, 0.04262904077768326, -0.03853336349129677, 0.1440175473690033, -0.06667198240756989, -0.5172480940818787, 0.44006603956222534, -0.24986951053142548, -0.09588941931724548, -0.5665295720100403, 0.33262380957603455, -0.8276225328445435, -0.3949035406112671, 0.06655808538198471, 0.4006118178367615, 0.6083884239196777, -0.20384468138217926, -0.32454073429107666, 0.2001245617866516, 0.03933056443929672, -0.06971123069524765, 0.35222122073173523, 0.1697162389755249, 0.3333378732204437, 0.6537089347839355, 0.5602546334266663, 0.7172777652740479, -0.29213058948516846, 0.05797167494893074, 0.6103501319885254, -0.33905938267707825, -0.5764446258544922, -0.8771784901618958, 0.25016912817955017, -0.0740123763680458, -0.22200921177864075, 0.6223491430282593, 0.768775463104248, 0.9444498419761658, -0.19349808990955353, 0.42165884375572205, 0.16615265607833862, 0.5287283062934875, -0.5596562623977661, 0.844609260559082, -0.8206101059913635, 0.13489101827144623, -0.021903421729803085, -0.8108678460121155, -0.6329240798950195, 0.7049071788787842, -0.016088787466287613, 0.04744372516870499, 0.7457962036132812, 1.0008156299591064, 0.023529697209596634, -0.13516932725906372, 0.5340491533279419, 0.09320113062858582, 0.09765760600566864, 0.7203534841537476, 0.2250034213066101, -0.18705600500106812, 0.6000156998634338, -0.1720980554819107, -0.28118106722831726, 0.057046256959438324, -0.9730708599090576, -0.5406947731971741, -0.3764631748199463, -0.2239830642938614, -0.15643250942230225, -0.3503848612308502, 1.061661958694458, 1.2800538539886475, -0.5863695740699768, -0.5540091395378113, 0.26476427912712097, -0.14980021119117737, -0.5072663426399231, -0.12443462014198303, 0.07917162030935287, -0.11215530335903168, -1.174017071723938, 0.749811589717865, 0.3386564552783966, -0.12287291884422302, -0.6107499003410339, 0.005973587278276682, 0.047848667949438095, 0.08396713435649872, 0.3866945803165436, 0.1146194264292717, -0.5829252004623413, -0.05253768712282181, -0.11555016785860062, -0.008106955327093601, 0.10138184577226639, 0.7113361358642578, -1.0729260444641113, 0.6773914098739624, 0.25287389755249023, 0.8176406025886536, 0.40909478068351746, -0.6888989806175232, 0.6521000862121582, -1.248753309249878, 0.6262744665145874, 0.16523660719394684, 0.6171872615814209, 0.655568540096283, -0.3653465211391449, 0.49603599309921265, 0.1381225883960724, -0.5023176670074463, -1.0865063667297363, 0.4102044403553009, -0.8837333917617798, -0.3051769733428955, 1.0772943496704102, 0.07852383702993393, -0.32505112886428833, 0.3723469078540802, -0.48131027817726135, 0.2666782736778259, -0.20110738277435303, 0.7302030920982361, 0.8819449543952942, 0.3040194511413574, -0.17873719334602356, -0.6346433162689209, 0.24788175523281097, 0.655841052532196, -0.6183958649635315, 0.03778811916708946, 0.4781956970691681, 0.15246710181236267, 0.1446731686592102, 0.5499845147132874, -0.22666755318641663, 0.02839861623942852, -0.36637866497039795, 0.5451039671897888, -0.016367770731449127, -0.20204725861549377, -0.7952772974967957, 0.27883273363113403, -0.12110129743814468, 0.12545590102672577 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04735v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04735v1
MACM: Utilizing a Multi-Agent System for Condition Mining in Solving Complex Mathematical Problems
2024-04-06T21:39:01
2024-04-06T21:39:01
Bin Lei
cs.AI
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MA
Recent advancements in large language models, such as GPT-4, have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in processing standard queries. Despite these advancements, their performance substantially declines in \textbf{advanced mathematical problems requiring complex, multi-step logical reasoning}. To enhance their inferential capabilities, current research has delved into \textit{prompting engineering}, exemplified by methodologies such as the Tree of Thought and Graph of Thought. Nonetheless, these existing approaches encounter two significant limitations. Firstly, their effectiveness in tackling complex mathematical problems is somewhat constrained. Secondly, the necessity to design distinct prompts for individual problems hampers their generalizability. In response to these limitations, this paper introduces the \textit{Multi-Agent System for conditional Mining} (\textbf{MACM}) prompting method. It not only resolves intricate mathematical problems but also demonstrates strong generalization capabilities across various mathematical contexts. With the assistance of MACM, the accuracy of GPT-4 Turbo on the most challenging level five mathematical problems in the MATH dataset increase from $\mathbf{54.68\%} \text{ to } \mathbf{76.73\%}$. The code is available in \url{https://github.com/bin123apple/MACM}.
[ -0.5952938199043274, -0.7134338021278381, 1.0754483938217163, 0.5938844680786133, -0.0851067528128624, 0.2601953148841858, -0.1258573979139328, -0.19904497265815735, 0.17103764414787292, 0.49791473150253296, -0.971312940120697, -0.5711957216262817, -0.6359727382659912, 0.3635159432888031, 0.14355957508087158, 1.003328800201416, -0.3193129599094391, -0.1593589186668396, -0.18645742535591125, -0.017298003658652306, -0.6535341739654541, -0.7349052429199219, -1.1277871131896973, -0.33696866035461426, 0.2263227254152298, 0.5948784947395325, 0.7697494626045227, -0.25862187147140503, 0.6848246455192566, 0.3918824791908264, 0.4547974169254303, 0.4591147005558014, -0.12986353039741516, 0.5323127508163452, -0.07572797685861588, -0.6878615617752075, -0.49640122056007385, 0.14511869847774506, 0.38419321179389954, 0.3124360144138336, -0.4162808060646057, -0.10447689145803452, -0.07781561464071274, 0.4676574766635895, -0.37901148200035095, 0.6989814639091492, -0.6764094233512878, 0.07548830658197403, 0.08325188606977463, -0.5969356894493103, -0.42445576190948486, -0.10766977816820145, -0.05505805462598801, -0.7749177813529968, 0.3022242486476898, 0.0683654174208641, 0.9733069539070129, 0.6502653360366821, -0.39564958214759827, -0.3878234028816223, -0.34198176860809326, 0.88279789686203, -0.453590452671051, -0.11640773713588715, 0.75067138671875, 0.5425770878791809, -0.5128087997436523, -0.7194249033927917, -0.5466130375862122, -0.3158420920372009, -0.0372803695499897, 0.2198057770729065, -0.2131243795156479, 0.1999349296092987, 0.6719607710838318, -0.12067494541406631, -0.19156213104724884, -0.34776607155799866, -0.017812008038163185, -0.5248518586158752, 0.28290048241615295, 0.44834184646606445, 0.6405273079872131, -0.3513406813144684, -0.30528032779693604, -0.05197012796998024, -0.20326760411262512, 0.3939536213874817, 0.29434165358543396, 0.23784734308719635, 0.004186808131635189, 0.44634920358657837, -0.21330246329307556, 0.318021684885025, -0.012679447419941425, -0.07011821120977402, 0.3238932490348816, -0.2819424271583557, -0.19273029267787933, -0.05185729265213013, 0.6019579768180847, 0.1940913200378418, 0.3058743476867676, 0.14996305108070374, -0.5572682619094849, 0.3343763053417206, 0.024329926818609238, -0.8941453695297241, -0.49372953176498413, -0.0566156730055809, 0.007087756413966417, 0.11006943136453629, 0.2748100459575653, -0.3416147530078888, -0.21279309689998627, -0.4193492829799652, 0.6609367728233337, -0.4407462477684021, -0.2997118830680847, 0.19628655910491943, -0.23793335258960724, -0.07779701054096222, 0.24243861436843872, -0.508696436882019, 0.4239218831062317, 0.5515308380126953, 0.9646731019020081, 0.309033066034317, -0.24091488122940063, -0.9357502460479736, -0.0560334213078022, -0.32793712615966797, 0.8145402669906616, -0.8202086091041565, -0.4254990518093109, -0.5085511803627014, 0.08029929548501968, -0.17105251550674438, -0.5678477883338928, 0.8560178875923157, -0.4586600661277771, 0.1762438267469406, -0.5215403437614441, -0.012607130222022533, -0.3364344537258148, 0.6201112866401672, -0.5997418165206909, 1.048365592956543, 0.12775251269340515, -0.6255854964256287, 0.300088107585907, -0.878930926322937, -0.3130871057510376, -0.0382637120783329, -0.19299627840518951, -0.5174120664596558, -0.18158483505249023, 0.5490754842758179, 0.3557611107826233, -0.3820645809173584, 0.4577672779560089, -0.49696385860443115, -0.08697088807821274, 0.053371936082839966, -0.1529400646686554, 0.550730288028717, 0.5028530955314636, -0.3646083176136017, 0.12361053377389908, -0.3357185423374176, 0.240583598613739, 0.11265673488378525, -0.06076471135020256, -0.44540050625801086, 0.13491342961788177, -0.7063865065574646, 0.6333186030387878, 0.28511321544647217, -0.27566492557525635, 0.24868544936180115, -0.26137298345565796, 0.4809376299381256, 0.7705757021903992, 0.32950177788734436, 0.15950268507003784, -0.44905778765678406, 0.8934073448181152, 0.2296314537525177, 0.1439991593360901, -0.1820961833000183, -0.6294002532958984, -0.7677727937698364, -0.44594332575798035, 0.19221335649490356, 0.7194250226020813, -1.1648139953613281, 0.03329868242144585, 0.33426544070243835, 0.22548054158687592, -0.3704071342945099, -0.013597494922578335, 0.26128914952278137, 0.44063642621040344, 0.5235806703567505, -0.02311190403997898, -0.6941167712211609, -0.9074039459228516, -0.0017351933056488633, 0.041237737983465195, 0.018469450995326042, 0.18050138652324677, 0.12107651680707932, -0.5938279628753662, 1.1306960582733154, -0.475529283285141, -0.045336153358221054, -0.0276079922914505, 0.35420551896095276, 0.7451720237731934, 0.32121795415878296, 0.43296217918395996, -0.7132851481437683, -0.7031756639480591, -0.12039542198181152, -0.7165464162826538, -0.32937344908714294, 0.11856871098279953, -0.3176385164260864, 0.05829933285713196, 0.4580991566181183, -0.8165178298950195, 0.5357955098152161, 0.4865480065345764, -0.03089902549982071, 0.4082946479320526, -0.4159438908100128, 0.39397284388542175, -0.9360519051551819, -0.08008226007223129, 0.1124626025557518, -0.39382946491241455, -0.40380555391311646, -0.059058673679828644, -0.006952769123017788, -0.5682957172393799, -0.0686093419790268, 0.37185928225517273, -0.7356938123703003, 0.21855908632278442, -0.3874545395374298, -0.01258788164705038, -0.2428114414215088, 0.5387306809425354, -0.2325340360403061, 0.5798717141151428, 0.9199599027633667, -1.105007290840149, 0.3087506890296936, -0.1163523718714714, 0.21823370456695557, 0.7131237387657166, -0.591456413269043, 0.11830225586891174, -0.21447694301605225, 0.45193618535995483, -0.6281554102897644, -0.17259539663791656, 0.606444776058197, -0.630926787853241, 0.1465168446302414, -0.03307937830686569, -0.585705041885376, -0.5256014466285706, -0.4203866422176361, 0.30796322226524353, 0.2782600224018097, -0.44894665479660034, 0.7234657406806946, 0.25282150506973267, -0.4542180001735687, -0.5397487282752991, -0.20026084780693054, 0.22635677456855774, 0.07596844434738159, -0.772443413734436, 0.2150433212518692, -0.34352830052375793, -0.3234986364841461, 0.15912695229053497, -0.33144351840019226, 0.055648863315582275, 0.12715944647789001, 0.3794204294681549, 0.33846914768218994, 0.21583594381809235, 0.18621926009655, 0.29659438133239746, -0.6667651534080505, 0.40785107016563416, -0.2526828944683075, 0.5562979578971863, -0.12896965444087982, -0.36150094866752625, -0.4174402356147766, 0.2533131539821625, 0.34227558970451355, -0.2958400547504425, 0.3962554633617401, 0.2898251414299011, -0.6691598296165466, -0.6177619695663452, -0.24338296055793762, -0.3764500319957733, -0.5152579545974731, -0.1026543453335762, -1.006883144378662, -0.5887631773948669, 0.5924404263496399, -0.12595775723457336, -0.14182806015014648, 0.7265758514404297, 0.5697911977767944, 0.33899056911468506, 1.8278034925460815, 0.5821609497070312, -0.16563546657562256, 0.2370460480451584, -0.25972896814346313, 0.254443883895874, -0.4218621253967285, -0.4066709876060486, -0.5800146460533142, -0.30795153975486755, -0.5614023804664612, -0.19048576056957245, 0.5865345597267151, -0.018385283648967743, -0.1894637793302536, 0.054396096616983414, -0.5875715613365173, 0.3497963547706604, 0.5934030413627625, 0.27212581038475037, 0.1604054719209671, -0.19783999025821686, -0.8693364262580872, 0.26561132073402405, -0.6725715398788452, -0.2926887571811676, 0.6289492845535278, -0.012935974635183811, 0.6261945366859436, 0.14418570697307587, 0.6754257678985596, 0.19205673038959503, 0.4608541429042816, -0.8730888962745667, 0.5856276154518127, 0.30967381596565247, -0.8667991757392883, -0.24396245181560516, -0.8450900316238403, -1.0957685708999634, 0.07988782972097397, -0.19557687640190125, -0.34079092741012573, 0.15938273072242737, 0.18759489059448242, -0.4274468421936035, 0.17906582355499268, -0.7889010906219482, 0.5370211601257324, -0.16226179897785187, 0.09687244892120361, -0.2884714901447296, -0.6825292110443115, 0.41570842266082764, -0.2304292470216751, 0.37863889336586, -0.4438571035861969, -0.12006506323814392, 0.33728545904159546, -0.9889039397239685, 0.571675181388855, -0.6024656295776367, 0.20804806053638458, 0.49965813755989075, 0.19191478192806244, 0.7505881786346436, 0.3525891602039337, -0.3620733916759491, -0.22797539830207825, 0.2319246381521225, -0.614246666431427, -0.6594624519348145, 0.9465563893318176, -0.7767333984375, -0.6861237287521362, -0.8750529289245605, -0.4931982755661011, -0.4897804856300354, 0.30601322650909424, 0.14816249907016754, 0.37101322412490845, 0.3994641602039337, -0.20054593682289124, 0.28449806571006775, 0.05592413991689682, 0.5954359769821167, 0.5678516030311584, -0.11622694134712219, -0.2805456221103668, 1.0161843299865723, -0.15746906399726868, -0.1893107295036316, 0.3413587510585785, 0.2876583933830261, -0.45717886090278625, -0.21727809309959412, -0.10401248931884766, 0.2265286147594452, -0.5989653468132019, -0.5488861799240112, -0.6770198345184326, -0.15060748159885406, -0.13750387728214264, 0.14538441598415375, 0.31361350417137146, -0.2651267945766449, -0.30378133058547974, -0.1708793044090271, 0.3586854934692383, 0.414770245552063, -0.1746641844511032, -0.08291014283895493, -0.88570237159729, 0.53568434715271, 0.524212121963501, 0.41341108083724976, -0.14770007133483887, -0.02681344375014305, -0.05372617766261101, 0.07376401871442795, -0.47847679257392883, -0.76231449842453, 0.41718634963035583, 0.2281826287508011, 0.8012098670005798, 0.2716567814350128, 0.42222627997398376, 0.5476388931274414, -0.29736238718032837, 0.16557444632053375, 0.3356921076774597, -1.1574770212173462, 0.5819480419158936, -0.06601887196302414, 0.02946411445736885, 0.6581700444221497, 0.4357256293296814, -0.5450764894485474, -0.44351017475128174, -0.833814799785614, -0.5624598860740662, 1.0284168720245361, 0.33817580342292786, -0.17676585912704468, -0.2573496699333191, 0.6426253914833069, -0.04448457434773445, 0.22277353703975677, -0.5092366337776184, -0.16914767026901245, -0.34606367349624634, -0.25518426299095154, -0.26748937368392944, 0.10213436186313629, 0.14721111953258514, -0.08328808099031448, 0.7212256789207458, -0.13702881336212158, 0.10414303839206696, 0.3879530131816864, -0.23948492109775543, -0.2529628276824951, 0.24723058938980103, 0.4917995035648346, 0.875092089176178, -0.2523646652698517, 0.4295942783355713, 0.2876783609390259, -0.30084875226020813, 0.38136833906173706, 0.3677590787410736, -0.049716971814632416, -0.06309236586093903, -0.06287423521280289, 0.5893974900245667, 0.010457814671099186, -0.448300302028656, 0.19799430668354034, -0.05280367285013199, -0.383154034614563, 0.010764837265014648, 0.2149183452129364, -0.27764657139778137, 0.07733741402626038, 0.4209234416484833, 0.2546387314796448, 0.34745293855667114, -0.7463685870170593, 0.12004907429218292, 0.6377920508384705, -0.41351568698883057, -0.4640152156352997, 0.5625858306884766, 0.09637609124183655, -0.5159980058670044, 0.6258266568183899, -0.6498552560806274, -0.9426448345184326, 0.8357999920845032, 0.4628821611404419, 0.7125945687294006, -0.28239452838897705, 0.24697324633598328, 0.3261015713214874, 0.4672468900680542, -0.24623113870620728, 0.4818461835384369, -0.043144650757312775, -0.7063823342323303, -0.6052273511886597, -0.29707956314086914, -0.7982711791992188, -0.2792660892009735, -0.25548139214515686, 0.40334972739219666, -0.713009774684906, -0.5509471297264099, -0.17229479551315308, 0.2905270755290985, -0.7034662961959839, 0.4438655376434326, -0.17960479855537415, 0.4285062551498413, -0.39593395590782166, 0.6021042466163635, 0.8231433033943176, -0.35003432631492615, -1.1265202760696411, -0.27550309896469116, -0.01492456067353487, -0.876109778881073, 0.4484673738479614, 0.3035295307636261, -0.5083546042442322, 0.1211085096001625, -0.7677356600761414, -0.447773814201355, 0.7725636959075928, 0.42617183923721313, -0.42640241980552673, 0.1832215040922165, -0.3111250102519989, 0.2665025293827057, -0.13547532260417938, 0.48564842343330383, 0.4087982773780823, 0.9365803003311157, 0.20995907485485077, -0.712944507598877, 0.2448255717754364, -0.5105968117713928, -0.3579731285572052, 0.9092749953269958, -0.6109414100646973, 1.0597543716430664, -0.3745177388191223, -0.36948636174201965, -0.1631612628698349, 0.3100607395172119, 0.5668251514434814, 0.983191192150116, 0.810693085193634, 0.6117837429046631, 1.1334400177001953, -0.1631881445646286, 0.986538827419281, -0.43233177065849304, 0.5205907821655273, 0.4992411434650421, -0.2681506276130676, 0.2581806778907776, 0.045644767582416534, -0.1243465393781662, 0.5860716700553894, 1.0140762329101562, 0.33997443318367004, 0.3339322805404663, 0.39834240078926086, -0.4703828990459442, -0.7271658182144165, 0.13323810696601868, -0.4334840774536133, -0.09488090127706528, 0.5265353918075562, 0.2008078694343567, -0.20282292366027832, -0.038137394934892654, 0.03629600256681442, -0.2108273208141327, -0.4700852632522583, 0.3345106840133667, 0.552108645439148, -0.9683045744895935, 0.19302913546562195, 0.3353641629219055, 0.580881655216217, -0.7940893173217773, -0.2519837021827698, -0.257738322019577, 0.0382346510887146, -0.4028094708919525, -0.20082040131092072, -0.08687014132738113, -0.2044336050748825, -0.4415733516216278, -0.1000722199678421, 0.7265758514404297, -0.07092595100402832, -0.7122796177864075, 0.2309194654226303, 0.5195401310920715, 0.1774987280368805, -0.3851853609085083, -0.8192538022994995, -0.29376891255378723, -0.17989490926265717, 0.255872905254364, -0.09574276208877563, 0.9302651286125183, -0.3843289613723755, 0.8278117179870605, 0.9010001420974731, -0.13139501214027405, -0.15896017849445343, 0.4283907115459442, 0.9064071774482727, -0.9380252957344055, -0.5189110040664673, -1.04434072971344, 0.1327856332063675, 0.1092866063117981, -0.024393167346715927, 0.8183797597885132, 0.4209064245223999, 0.1744685173034668, 0.341619074344635, 0.8069125413894653, 0.18037483096122742, 0.5387258529663086, -0.6886320114135742, 0.2229716181755066, -0.5081263780593872, 0.3727932870388031, -0.44094592332839966, -1.0183534622192383, -0.5394682288169861, 0.41684597730636597, -0.278443306684494, 0.2650662064552307, 1.1182867288589478, 0.6097357869148254, -0.18241773545742035, -0.1092977374792099, 0.10297541320323944, -0.030021892860531807, 0.6471850275993347, 0.632567822933197, 1.05443274974823, 0.15715324878692627, 0.7834230661392212, 0.019754374399781227, -0.5752575993537903, -0.22872509062290192, -0.9506272673606873, -0.7473176717758179, -0.33638373017311096, -0.14280115067958832, -0.2446652501821518, -0.19431765377521515, 1.0715117454528809, 0.7056905627250671, -0.8058297634124756, 0.02406945265829563, -0.20369450747966766, 0.43691009283065796, -0.20416826009750366, -0.22282885015010834, 0.2444504201412201, -0.9365614652633667, -0.563888430595398, 0.35167115926742554, 0.4867960810661316, -0.16507206857204437, -0.0038969027809798717, -0.3538024425506592, 0.04553353041410446, 0.29780101776123047, 0.6420310735702515, 0.3179045021533966, -0.32350999116897583, -0.16058655083179474, 0.20150348544120789, 0.07609957456588745, 0.13078847527503967, 0.9814172983169556, -0.7473152279853821, 0.7099962830543518, 0.33700981736183167, 0.4405803978443146, 1.0042343139648438, 0.16203583776950836, 0.38369104266166687, -0.4354396164417267, 0.0664920061826706, 0.3150753676891327, 0.5461946129798889, 0.1545667052268982, -0.34942832589149475, 0.3501985967159271, 0.3143598437309265, -0.7001006603240967, -0.430732399225235, 0.16590580344200134, -0.9900711178779602, -0.1077360063791275, 0.7722346186637878, 0.20485204458236694, -0.009739108383655548, -0.21735624969005585, -0.6155405044555664, 0.12367251515388489, -0.8821614980697632, 0.5802794098854065, 0.8705142736434937, -0.46776506304740906, -0.0949913039803505, -0.5640234351158142, 0.4293287992477417, 0.41262710094451904, -1.0095795392990112, -0.9128148555755615, 0.4275844991207123, 0.23557212948799133, 0.06589220464229584, 0.8109243512153625, 0.2997710406780243, 0.26732295751571655, -0.24247467517852783, 0.07962328940629959, -0.0683332234621048, -0.4048277735710144, 0.0356287956237793, 0.2978609800338745, 0.24197186529636383, -0.3141876757144928 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04728v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04728v1
Navigating the Landscape of Hint Generation Research: From the Past to the Future
2024-04-06T20:42:46
2024-04-06T20:42:46
Anubhav Jangra, Jamshid Mozafari, Adam Jatowt, Smaranda Muresan
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.HC
Digital education has gained popularity in the last decade, especially after the COVID-19 pandemic. With the improving capabilities of large language models to reason and communicate with users, envisioning intelligent tutoring systems (ITSs) that can facilitate self-learning is not very far-fetched. One integral component to fulfill this vision is the ability to give accurate and effective feedback via hints to scaffold the learning process. In this survey article, we present a comprehensive review of prior research on hint generation, aiming to bridge the gap between research in education and cognitive science, and research in AI and Natural Language Processing. Informed by our findings, we propose a formal definition of the hint generation task, and discuss the roadmap of building an effective hint generation system aligned with the formal definition, including open challenges, future directions and ethical considerations.
[ -0.2772490978240967, -0.6785289645195007, 0.6773613095283508, 0.10174796730279922, 0.02521672658622265, 0.2283013015985489, -0.18786412477493286, -0.31847625970840454, -0.07611248642206192, 0.028988461941480637, -0.928947925567627, -0.3772965371608734, -0.4816167652606964, 0.30009621381759644, -0.6710346937179565, 1.260961890220642, 0.32317492365837097, 0.12485086172819138, -0.7043580412864685, 0.5448006987571716, -0.30337461829185486, -0.3315400183200836, -1.2040709257125854, -0.1501041054725647, 0.43422991037368774, 0.69961017370224, 0.11478663235902786, 0.6106606125831604, 0.4611821174621582, 0.18626847863197327, 0.1820177137851715, -0.08401902765035629, -0.2738596200942993, 0.37183234095573425, -0.15723583102226257, -0.7611610889434814, -0.24439166486263275, -0.07894744724035263, 0.24234135448932648, 0.30749908089637756, 0.026412196457386017, 0.3989899456501007, 0.03948615863919258, 0.6707114577293396, -0.6186507940292358, 0.1462792009115219, -0.4315367341041565, -0.01589844934642315, -0.3471428453922272, -0.46657100319862366, -0.3057546019554138, -0.5765452980995178, 0.20454318821430206, -0.6352247595787048, 0.6483625173568726, -0.10459396988153458, 0.4539680778980255, 0.42464447021484375, -0.156897634267807, -0.7648789882659912, -0.8406586647033691, 0.8014775514602661, -0.7194274663925171, 0.011578576639294624, 0.40708279609680176, 0.7746931314468384, -0.28097450733184814, -0.9341976046562195, -0.1658008098602295, 0.05511686950922012, 0.5406283140182495, 0.11703072488307953, -0.10779615491628647, -0.24569880962371826, 0.1118844598531723, 0.2363954782485962, -0.04294108971953392, -0.23324191570281982, -0.7300314903259277, -0.230597123503685, 0.8171581029891968, 0.04618195816874504, 0.17545802891254425, -0.1983386129140854, -0.3310502767562866, 0.14042966067790985, -0.9208406805992126, 0.2799522280693054, 0.3305400609970093, 0.43995991349220276, 0.20882335305213928, 0.3263852596282959, -0.2776874601840973, 0.6137885451316833, 0.5176094174385071, -0.1886950582265854, -0.5218132138252258, -0.756862998008728, 0.467586487531662, 0.4171762466430664, 0.8001517057418823, 0.3161749243736267, 0.16701678931713104, 0.04900965467095375, -0.09724140167236328, 0.01406885590404272, 0.41630831360816956, -0.5138494968414307, -0.6412157416343689, 0.2392457276582718, 0.16294506192207336, -0.2694990038871765, -0.049607597291469574, -0.948093593120575, -0.410910964012146, -0.16635940968990326, 0.09333402663469315, -0.6008105874061584, -0.3298610746860504, -0.12789501249790192, -0.4098849296569824, 0.17772535979747772, 0.6404411196708679, -0.8249121308326721, 0.1816241592168808, 0.6524097919464111, 0.6036192774772644, -0.0017944637220352888, 0.056754615157842636, 0.012367931194603443, 0.2818061411380768, -0.1263018399477005, 0.8333145976066589, -0.49602797627449036, -0.5291312336921692, 0.04770367592573166, -0.48583197593688965, -0.008839278481900692, -0.2231634110212326, 0.4674187898635864, -0.1853245049715042, 0.6084867715835571, -0.38924095034599304, -0.3764202296733856, -0.16823065280914307, 0.436753511428833, -0.25127872824668884, 1.0587979555130005, -0.11234733462333679, -0.9714705348014832, 0.410570353269577, -0.701906144618988, -0.3273574411869049, 0.3663874864578247, -0.5234521627426147, -0.3232889175415039, -0.1413402408361435, 0.5802701115608215, 0.20394684374332428, -0.445717453956604, 0.37364235520362854, 0.005018342286348343, -0.19302275776863098, -0.21420735120773315, -0.20802903175354004, 0.872647225856781, 0.15476635098457336, -1.0253634452819824, 0.0702657550573349, -0.5011986494064331, 0.14590655267238617, 0.28443488478660583, -0.12478836625814438, -0.3477291166782379, 0.0003863409801851958, -0.46840035915374756, 0.21829956769943237, 0.34951624274253845, -0.37653955817222595, 0.33052295446395874, -0.10385602712631226, 0.7320905327796936, 0.5388094186782837, 0.13151335716247559, 0.43037503957748413, -0.2988772392272949, 0.7689924836158752, -0.041728463023900986, 0.39553993940353394, -0.49994632601737976, -0.5952615141868591, -0.7011090517044067, -0.0427921786904335, 0.11037441343069077, 0.2597346007823944, -0.8599396347999573, 0.3091447651386261, -0.06059436872601509, -0.4464651346206665, -0.7556715607643127, 0.03149356693029404, 0.24860595166683197, 0.3872626721858978, 0.17379337549209595, 0.08431076258420944, -0.4574420750141144, -0.2595892548561096, -0.26615768671035767, -0.08600835502147675, 0.09268911927938461, 0.37442874908447266, 0.44295018911361694, 0.05664091184735298, 1.3940719366073608, -0.15918418765068054, -0.25923123955726624, -0.22106175124645233, 0.10448241978883743, -0.3153727352619171, 0.4826613664627075, 0.2425808161497116, -0.6695945262908936, -0.2113010436296463, -0.4095173478126526, -0.6977016925811768, 0.25163182616233826, -0.02125999517738819, 0.2786262333393097, -0.17540422081947327, 0.7817884683609009, -0.39561033248901367, 0.2029973864555359, 0.10539141297340393, -0.23684930801391602, 0.7608246803283691, -0.1309463381767273, 0.18482889235019684, -0.9856197237968445, 0.010666514746844769, -0.15199653804302216, 0.06096671149134636, -0.34534963965415955, 0.028904905542731285, -0.11911479383707047, -0.0337277390062809, -0.0807490199804306, 0.6043946743011475, -0.5727606415748596, 0.20195792615413666, -0.20066288113594055, 0.5347055196762085, -0.17499016225337982, 0.08617880940437317, -0.3755171597003937, 0.6494545340538025, 0.5788199305534363, -0.7501250505447388, 0.49066755175590515, 0.03660207614302635, -0.021451052278280258, 0.9513468146324158, -0.5494454503059387, 0.35810694098472595, -0.09476867318153381, 0.3851569592952728, -0.734127938747406, -0.24704332649707794, 0.4487023651599884, -0.7198470234870911, 0.13336674869060516, 0.17581184208393097, -0.1865093857049942, -1.0704470872879028, -0.4119115471839905, 0.5646872520446777, 0.2441326528787613, -0.5253299474716187, 0.25459134578704834, 0.0781240239739418, -0.44622603058815, -0.711039662361145, -0.07220285385847092, 0.35773614048957825, -0.10633735358715057, -0.6353654265403748, 0.08102469146251678, -0.03904981538653374, -0.32259994745254517, 0.15929928421974182, -0.15993717312812805, 0.012910592369735241, 0.14239488542079926, 0.2571122944355011, -0.0961373969912529, -0.16770750284194946, 0.11856736987829208, 0.10520064830780029, -0.15502861142158508, 0.44466644525527954, -0.6804454326629639, 0.2273637056350708, 0.08293426036834717, -0.43104588985443115, -0.11028774827718735, 0.1406826227903366, 0.3309989273548126, -0.3890686333179474, -0.09274187684059143, 0.6320032477378845, -0.1896175593137741, -0.5765872001647949, -0.32715708017349243, -0.6836811304092407, -0.46912774443626404, 0.03343956917524338, -0.28837230801582336, -0.6352450251579285, 0.17519105970859528, -0.49161309003829956, 0.14779171347618103, 0.3488406836986542, 0.2020484358072281, -0.12884049117565155, 1.1062079668045044, 1.075804591178894, 0.15110966563224792, 0.5118604898452759, -0.5798912048339844, 0.5787152051925659, -0.6665555238723755, -0.4079923927783966, -0.6221064925193787, 0.037956684827804565, -0.021404702216386795, -0.12736165523529053, 0.3759889304637909, 0.2919638156890869, 0.1440824270248413, -0.029848244041204453, -0.7434207201004028, 0.19256840646266937, 1.3356343507766724, 0.043744198977947235, 0.3085681200027466, -0.31875374913215637, -0.23871394991874695, 0.03960474580526352, -1.0978718996047974, -0.48023393750190735, 1.1423332691192627, 0.018276145681738853, 0.49392905831336975, -0.37062427401542664, 1.0067007541656494, 0.4450441896915436, -0.01187258493155241, -0.7178592085838318, 0.6440876722335815, 0.40594273805618286, -0.7414180636405945, -0.3280923664569855, -0.17484989762306213, -0.9424736499786377, -0.5634849667549133, 0.02744072861969471, -0.6868977546691895, -0.26023486256599426, 0.451254278421402, -0.46971049904823303, 0.21307413280010223, -0.339861124753952, 0.7133114337921143, -0.3168210983276367, -0.38976794481277466, -0.2000902146100998, -0.7423590421676636, 0.582093358039856, 0.22763420641422272, 0.29589197039604187, 0.13801130652427673, 0.47099068760871887, 0.8315608501434326, -0.2321608066558838, 0.9157814383506775, -0.3041829466819763, -0.3550998866558075, 0.8115898370742798, -0.022139649838209152, 0.40152081847190857, -0.24673856794834137, 0.10175607353448868, -0.26343098282814026, 0.3659926652908325, -0.40224987268447876, -0.47902601957321167, 0.5522180795669556, -0.4523443877696991, -0.7743934988975525, -0.2827558219432831, -0.615321695804596, 0.015962030738592148, 0.1909206360578537, 0.7158929705619812, 0.535245418548584, -0.08889099210500717, -0.369888573884964, 0.791978120803833, 0.1416570395231247, 0.4624308943748474, 0.19522447884082794, -0.18857401609420776, -0.17057044804096222, 1.36393141746521, 0.05847301334142685, 0.04860513657331467, 0.06908046454191208, 0.4196082651615143, -0.4059079885482788, -0.7253237366676331, -0.5305562019348145, 0.15959255397319794, -0.8639352321624756, -0.13908852636814117, -0.23041118681430817, -0.2070283144712448, -0.8974806070327759, -0.41743141412734985, -0.2709861099720001, -0.3884037137031555, -0.2921719551086426, -0.21682706475257874, 0.48049888014793396, 1.536242961883545, -0.16043704748153687, 0.31081339716911316, -0.7130119800567627, -0.2454560101032257, 0.33080875873565674, 0.01649826020002365, 0.09653813391923904, 0.012914227321743965, -0.32266339659690857, 0.12842433154582977, -0.25867918133735657, -0.6083464026451111, -0.07755833864212036, 0.1441633403301239, 0.490418940782547, 0.7158336639404297, 0.4475771486759186, 0.29243776202201843, -0.3163389563560486, 1.2992892265319824, 0.2032061368227005, -0.6038289666175842, 0.91122967004776, -0.47634053230285645, 0.5364037156105042, 0.3904864192008972, 0.5159823298454285, -0.489989697933197, -0.7796427011489868, -0.9682525396347046, -0.9032875299453735, 0.36193445324897766, -0.40158623456954956, -0.27312132716178894, 0.04247700050473213, 0.4096563160419464, 0.3697764277458191, 0.461505651473999, -0.3686482608318329, -0.3713625967502594, -0.3332769274711609, -0.7031841278076172, 0.09373629838228226, -0.0278546754270792, -0.4292217493057251, -0.2034704089164734, 0.6409845948219299, -0.4167949855327606, 0.469005823135376, 0.11407357454299927, 0.04216967523097992, -0.18824073672294617, 0.18415507674217224, 0.5726125836372375, 0.6573483347892761, 0.06827455013990402, 0.20769163966178894, -0.5644235014915466, -0.6652287840843201, 0.06312255561351776, -0.03076668083667755, -0.7445369362831116, -0.08492911607027054, 0.16956955194473267, 0.5126706957817078, 0.1859796792268753, -0.3755704462528229, 0.6667921543121338, -0.006521063856780529, -0.19334806501865387, -0.3795779049396515, 0.3620569407939911, -0.16033421456813812, 0.2723841965198517, 0.7039070725440979, 0.052700214087963104, 0.12638475000858307, -0.3186756372451782, 0.3446979224681854, 0.6292693018913269, -0.45971670746803284, -0.615408182144165, 0.6968771815299988, 0.6351814866065979, -0.45539405941963196, 0.4148092567920685, -0.45948341488838196, -0.6966650485992432, 0.5944252610206604, 0.744976818561554, 0.9833371639251709, -0.11466021090745926, 0.5698658227920532, 0.5464702844619751, 0.24620461463928223, -0.07122163474559784, 0.23728713393211365, -0.6191746592521667, -0.17185790836811066, -0.12330532819032669, -0.20745207369327545, -0.31395798921585083, -0.2010192722082138, -0.4680454432964325, 0.1744469851255417, -0.5588005781173706, -0.2854640483856201, -0.18832965195178986, 0.004913991782814264, -0.6261391043663025, 0.3198755085468292, 0.13768945634365082, 0.8500319719314575, -0.5530010461807251, 0.5436844825744629, 0.8937341570854187, -0.28978431224823, -0.7605077028274536, 0.06423190981149673, 0.2720041275024414, -0.5223733186721802, 0.5658189058303833, 0.12641015648841858, -0.2859286963939667, 0.5121716856956482, -0.9038428068161011, -1.0229949951171875, 1.1624213457107544, 0.07740852236747742, -0.3316211998462677, -0.8110645413398743, 0.06626080721616745, 0.3016780614852905, -0.14922355115413666, 0.4445374608039856, 0.5079126954078674, 0.43657708168029785, 0.19452886283397675, -0.6869698166847229, 0.051287923008203506, -0.21119417250156403, -0.5525733828544617, 0.09649115800857544, -0.36086952686309814, 0.5726887583732605, -0.8325825929641724, -0.6092948317527771, 0.044210515916347504, 0.587133526802063, -0.1079619824886322, 0.6757225394248962, 0.09000393748283386, 0.45442134141921997, 0.8350741863250732, -0.37474894523620605, 0.7561109662055969, -0.48034191131591797, -0.05935836583375931, 1.0676846504211426, 0.4788456857204437, 0.5447240471839905, 0.6336987018585205, -0.19703219830989838, 0.5772549510002136, 0.7909716367721558, 0.049784157425165176, 0.44230735301971436, 0.2009948492050171, -0.3619772791862488, 0.022677166387438774, -0.25384780764579773, -0.2986617386341095, 0.1562734991312027, 0.691713273525238, -0.06924035400152206, -0.4810461699962616, 0.12904521822929382, -0.07245976477861404, 0.25360992550849915, -0.6161346435546875, 0.8471964597702026, 0.09967923164367676, -0.8493878841400146, 0.13835839927196503, -0.3935152590274811, 0.832563042640686, -0.6715697646141052, -0.0596555694937706, -0.03781826049089432, 0.10156454145908356, -0.2205881029367447, -0.5122218728065491, -0.20190095901489258, -0.18089380860328674, -0.11291375756263733, -0.1156388446688652, 0.6896806955337524, -0.5649006962776184, -0.2569279670715332, 0.03570840135216713, 0.6306421160697937, -0.09655413031578064, 0.00801857654005289, -0.7951357364654541, -0.3712814450263977, 0.0007072988082654774, 0.07555343955755234, 0.0006006403709761798, 0.578437864780426, -0.10080631822347641, 1.1526955366134644, 0.4422062933444977, 0.25366634130477905, 0.7997351288795471, -0.3577573299407959, 0.3976738452911377, -0.8042755722999573, -0.6637815237045288, -0.42192405462265015, 0.35823002457618713, 0.07678212225437164, -0.5036338567733765, 1.2349178791046143, 0.0018925435142591596, 1.016995906829834, 0.17738324403762817, 1.1111218929290771, -0.30270466208457947, 0.40243715047836304, -0.090469129383564, 0.285519540309906, -0.18222415447235107, -0.013014869764447212, -0.22888994216918945, -0.5159164071083069, 0.028308024629950523, 0.08638046681880951, -0.5327825546264648, 0.13168318569660187, 0.5814528465270996, 0.4248179793357849, 0.4458177983760834, 0.21391244232654572, -0.2844950556755066, -0.140370175242424, 0.47130584716796875, 0.2378920316696167, 0.975371778011322, -0.3765462338924408, 0.6022999286651611, -0.45382046699523926, -0.07255622744560242, -0.40051034092903137, -0.6846149563789368, -0.784305214881897, -0.771430253982544, -0.4430459141731262, -0.14546851813793182, 0.37381431460380554, 0.7867017388343811, 0.5201191902160645, -0.7115054726600647, -0.18442662060260773, -0.5191320776939392, 0.2716000974178314, -0.5491202473640442, -0.2828916907310486, 0.30286118388175964, -0.6039353609085083, -0.7833385467529297, 0.3476047217845917, 0.17854101955890656, 0.11425229161977768, -0.7839409112930298, 0.05080357566475868, -0.2183537781238556, -0.05631357058882713, 0.35413506627082825, 0.6800504922866821, -0.5968194007873535, -0.15452297031879425, 0.16175392270088196, -0.21550391614437103, -0.11923715472221375, 1.0855764150619507, -0.8484060764312744, 0.7019550800323486, 0.29501157999038696, 0.8121190071105957, 0.1958785206079483, -0.012316248379647732, 1.0675480365753174, -0.7496196627616882, -0.3081139624118805, 0.5179628729820251, -0.07954864203929901, 0.6656582355499268, -0.5476711392402649, 0.3513171076774597, 0.22728238999843597, -0.5512543320655823, -0.7465439438819885, 0.05020127445459366, -0.31713631749153137, -0.34146854281425476, 0.7212460041046143, -0.12923626601696014, -0.4360487163066864, -0.26520296931266785, -0.35150447487831116, 0.3017213046550751, -0.49175578355789185, 1.3043543100357056, 0.3442893326282501, -0.21431903541088104, -0.15988533198833466, -0.36549875140190125, 1.1187400817871094, 0.4734194278717041, -0.8022192716598511, -0.15868660807609558, 0.4197217524051666, 0.008946502581238747, 0.5611960291862488, 0.471872478723526, 0.16651727259159088, 0.49992114305496216, 0.19745011627674103, 0.1671553999185562, -0.04156230017542839, -0.8560298085212708, -0.17603103816509247, 0.055856093764305115, 0.1791262924671173, -0.1897241622209549 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04722v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04722v1
PoLLMgraph: Unraveling Hallucinations in Large Language Models via State Transition Dynamics
2024-04-06T20:02:20
2024-04-06T20:02:20
Derui Zhu, Dingfan Chen, Qing Li, Zongxiong Chen, Lei Ma, Jens Grossklags, Mario Fritz
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.SE
Despite tremendous advancements in large language models (LLMs) over recent years, a notably urgent challenge for their practical deployment is the phenomenon of hallucination, where the model fabricates facts and produces non-factual statements. In response, we propose PoLLMgraph, a Polygraph for LLMs, as an effective model-based white-box detection and forecasting approach. PoLLMgraph distinctly differs from the large body of existing research that concentrates on addressing such challenges through black-box evaluations. In particular, we demonstrate that hallucination can be effectively detected by analyzing the LLM's internal state transition dynamics during generation via tractable probabilistic models. Experimental results on various open-source LLMs confirm the efficacy of PoLLMgraph, outperforming state-of-the-art methods by a considerable margin, evidenced by over 20% improvement in AUC-ROC on common benchmarking datasets like TruthfulQA. Our work paves a new way for model-based white-box analysis of LLMs, motivating the research community to further explore, understand, and refine the intricate dynamics of LLM behaviors.
[ -0.368288516998291, -1.0492271184921265, 0.9460102319717407, -0.03073371760547161, -0.3775486648082733, 0.13987934589385986, -0.12245914340019226, -0.46587756276130676, 0.17313319444656372, 0.6680691838264465, -0.6056672930717468, -0.7464243173599243, -0.6811448931694031, -0.025764629244804382, -0.8264319896697998, 0.7549943923950195, 0.08580338954925537, -0.08636075258255005, -0.28262412548065186, 0.5003552436828613, -0.25360941886901855, -0.5903761386871338, -0.41117963194847107, -0.6638119220733643, 0.08525907248258591, -0.009387362748384476, 0.8689188957214355, 0.32551711797714233, 0.20413397252559662, 0.259960800409317, -0.23075458407402039, 0.34788426756858826, -0.6844203472137451, 0.30905991792678833, 0.1292572319507599, -0.4563126564025879, -0.25005003809928894, -0.010786628350615501, 0.45527732372283936, 0.6529515385627747, -0.3950585126876831, 0.1781948208808899, 0.09459365159273148, 0.25945422053337097, -0.4108705520629883, 0.5050264000892639, -0.8306877613067627, 0.18434733152389526, -0.2769407331943512, -0.20684736967086792, -0.8048774600028992, -0.39020252227783203, 0.007822273299098015, -0.37937700748443604, 0.15892034769058228, 0.13299575448036194, 0.6504722237586975, 0.17307564616203308, -0.4573083817958832, -0.08349614590406418, -1.0435562133789062, 0.44918081164360046, -0.7146674990653992, 0.6392683982849121, 0.241688072681427, 0.23338083922863007, -0.5966262817382812, -0.80833500623703, -0.6589467525482178, -0.5143994092941284, 0.149376779794693, 0.04626396298408508, -0.48630964756011963, -0.12504632771015167, 0.1843140423297882, 0.24126355350017548, -0.4694899320602417, 0.040519632399082184, -0.4381679594516754, -0.5137926936149597, 0.4798208475112915, 0.33433523774147034, 0.41121599078178406, -0.16798551380634308, -0.09859270602464676, 0.05703647807240486, -0.5647296905517578, -0.30837059020996094, 0.4324239492416382, 0.3988654613494873, -0.13753126561641693, 0.5153517723083496, -0.006215517409145832, 0.7645259499549866, -0.23972037434577942, -0.15603595972061157, 0.16009452939033508, 0.10814766585826874, 0.10077279061079025, 0.23266483843326569, 1.0029913187026978, 0.26083627343177795, 0.35874322056770325, -0.4574934244155884, -0.1431949883699417, 0.36415132880210876, 0.32157447934150696, -0.9521220922470093, -0.5696553587913513, 0.28473758697509766, -0.4181705117225647, -0.33990979194641113, 0.07407017052173615, -0.9694567322731018, -0.8536516427993774, -0.3399895131587982, 0.4035484194755554, -0.47021639347076416, -0.6134202480316162, 0.34285178780555725, 0.02046043798327446, -0.06959423422813416, 0.27069252729415894, -0.5834963321685791, 0.37291601300239563, 0.9961174130439758, 1.1521438360214233, -0.45155733823776245, -0.31343793869018555, -0.3928447365760803, -0.01681513339281082, -0.6026954650878906, 0.8887080550193787, -0.6141009330749512, -0.46843233704566956, 0.11767040193080902, -0.04918462038040161, 0.03763323277235031, -0.761320173740387, 0.11650166660547256, -0.37443774938583374, 0.04396635666489601, 0.10553610324859619, -0.4179154634475708, -0.3284287452697754, 0.18007296323776245, -0.659650444984436, 1.167015790939331, -0.18355189263820648, -0.6035303473472595, 0.17885485291481018, -0.31579187512397766, -0.2634706199169159, 0.08913302421569824, -0.18481875956058502, -0.4741164445877075, 0.46002304553985596, 0.031474243849515915, 0.3782116770744324, -0.25828254222869873, 0.4929189682006836, -0.550201952457428, -0.46444210410118103, 0.5040582418441772, -0.4600377082824707, 0.8695610761642456, 0.11812257766723633, -0.40478578209877014, 0.19652439653873444, -0.8493338823318481, -0.1785726398229599, 0.24038848280906677, 0.2518649101257324, -0.02599971368908882, 0.3802942633628845, -0.2101496011018753, 0.1204916387796402, 0.046309106051921844, -0.4833904206752777, 0.18831244111061096, -0.2615892291069031, 0.42407557368278503, 0.7712706923484802, 0.1955815553665161, -0.1349051296710968, -0.18639162182807922, 0.7634221911430359, 0.20217245817184448, 0.27917373180389404, 0.11367836594581604, -0.7866373658180237, -0.6959408521652222, -0.11095459759235382, -0.10217861831188202, 0.3653148114681244, -0.6255562901496887, 0.23686030507087708, -0.08259399235248566, -0.5386614799499512, -0.5962862968444824, -0.2301299273967743, -0.10537682473659515, 0.386455774307251, 0.2187027782201767, -0.277762234210968, -0.3729250729084015, -0.7131100296974182, 0.057148899883031845, -0.5126428008079529, 0.25809794664382935, -0.07914755493402481, 0.48628631234169006, -0.2703196704387665, 0.7496256232261658, -0.7762994170188904, -0.07849903404712677, -0.1318269520998001, 0.4050886332988739, 0.42993488907814026, -0.09890272468328476, 0.1013031154870987, -0.48498424887657166, -0.048649244010448456, -0.10980245471000671, -0.5261805653572083, -0.2770574986934662, -0.039805375039577484, -0.13745702803134918, 0.051751941442489624, 0.7565967440605164, -0.4643160402774811, 0.3264145255088806, 0.9020310640335083, -0.4173405170440674, 1.041565179824829, -0.1010257750749588, -0.04087880253791809, -0.8743107318878174, -0.12551584839820862, -0.0935305505990982, -0.19466781616210938, -0.7675674557685852, -0.05834803357720375, -0.2612205445766449, -0.30976882576942444, -0.27650386095046997, 0.15624308586120605, -0.4506241977214813, -0.03291682153940201, -0.4042530059814453, 0.18426969647407532, -0.4013267159461975, 0.25002700090408325, 0.0706838071346283, 0.8159930109977722, 0.6701019406318665, -0.45880043506622314, 0.3422544002532959, 0.2457122504711151, -0.7487953305244446, 0.14060541987419128, -0.23660215735435486, 0.31858909130096436, -0.35491377115249634, 0.09074214845895767, -1.0287439823150635, 0.17065688967704773, 0.5659700036048889, -0.3644469678401947, -0.054469551891088486, -0.2082582265138626, -0.5677409768104553, -0.22087587416172028, -0.14526242017745972, 0.24771347641944885, 0.5907173752784729, -0.47664451599121094, 0.44663941860198975, 0.5887333750724792, 0.055067338049411774, -0.04262682795524597, -0.4029794931411743, 0.2743818163871765, -0.014217798598110676, -0.3280300199985504, 0.06078723818063736, -0.06251788884401321, -0.3260672390460968, -0.0008775356691330671, -0.01058838702738285, 0.06925520300865173, 0.09975526481866837, 0.4906918704509735, 0.42768871784210205, -0.12624478340148926, -0.05501759424805641, -0.37360796332359314, -0.13587073981761932, 0.46753090620040894, -0.412969708442688, 0.971549391746521, -0.007295263931155205, -0.30796173214912415, -0.33407267928123474, -0.16789765655994415, 0.724578320980072, -0.291104793548584, 0.8420164585113525, 0.6147398948669434, -0.4153622090816498, -0.7913269996643066, -0.27287742495536804, -0.18057550489902496, -0.45825469493865967, 0.3931102454662323, -0.32699888944625854, -0.7393927574157715, 0.536859393119812, -0.1900918036699295, -0.2884775996208191, 0.1865951269865036, 0.8569760918617249, 0.2575131952762604, 1.1999595165252686, 0.5955429077148438, 0.1009957566857338, 0.4636562466621399, -0.23602160811424255, 0.5282723903656006, -0.6931787729263306, -0.5300039052963257, -0.3320804238319397, 0.06973636150360107, -0.7279729843139648, -0.5966078042984009, 0.60895174741745, -0.2638110816478729, 0.025572417303919792, 0.0653391107916832, -0.7449877262115479, 0.19840176403522491, 0.2647720277309418, 0.1869397759437561, 0.4439363181591034, 0.09778086096048355, -0.06025039404630661, -0.2005087435245514, -0.4513354003429413, -0.5015959739685059, 1.0356053113937378, 0.16074927151203156, 0.9923341870307922, -0.021644210442900658, 0.7397879362106323, 0.2983870208263397, 0.43461811542510986, -0.9026371836662292, 0.9550693035125732, -0.04113627225160599, -0.465120792388916, -0.3625493049621582, -0.5532441139221191, -1.060827612876892, 0.6587936282157898, -0.39545685052871704, -1.2470585107803345, 0.03178839758038521, 0.15823547542095184, -0.006065052933990955, 0.5404050946235657, -0.449283242225647, 0.9203470945358276, -0.15023009479045868, -0.11505503952503204, -0.1516030728816986, 0.10218360275030136, 0.6566464900970459, -0.12950123846530914, 0.2655273675918579, -0.4349232017993927, 0.11457012593746185, 0.5578538179397583, -0.3503284752368927, 0.8636006116867065, 0.0204309169203043, -0.40982797741889954, 0.3137971758842468, 0.5721402168273926, 0.6095903515815735, -0.2915394604206085, -0.0639960765838623, 0.37602564692497253, 0.118351511657238, 0.16242961585521698, -0.5568596124649048, 0.4810306429862976, -0.5865591764450073, -0.6988816261291504, -0.5283176898956299, -0.5230456590652466, -0.3038390874862671, 0.07647654414176941, 0.249354287981987, 0.5166807174682617, -0.2505378723144531, -0.12663312256336212, 0.3791470527648926, -0.1010582372546196, 0.10301751643419266, 0.4339972138404846, -0.8619840741157532, -0.2499329298734665, 1.18743896484375, 0.31389403343200684, 0.10026849806308746, 0.05691651999950409, 0.32755032181739807, -0.3556627035140991, -0.924138605594635, -0.13782094419002533, 0.5118810534477234, -0.4802607297897339, 0.10754487663507462, -0.4730185270309448, -0.3392203152179718, -0.4325994849205017, 0.35842305421829224, -0.23941214382648468, -0.12793229520320892, -0.2011086642742157, -0.10849469900131226, 0.15491099655628204, 0.913577139377594, 0.09096784889698029, 0.1545572429895401, -0.28778210282325745, 0.5426250696182251, 0.24340440332889557, 0.47438621520996094, 0.21062442660331726, -0.6029555201530457, -0.030803322792053223, -0.19166645407676697, -0.3469957411289215, -1.3299484252929688, 0.3644118905067444, -0.23035018146038055, 0.3764132559299469, 0.5334468483924866, 0.2913125455379486, 0.6419504284858704, -0.6229797601699829, 0.7127864360809326, 0.16302278637886047, -1.0726121664047241, 0.19259113073349, -0.14703913033008575, 0.20290334522724152, 0.1642368882894516, 0.1702863723039627, -0.8683181405067444, -1.009146809577942, -0.5593096017837524, -0.7489404082298279, 0.6782514452934265, 0.019998891279101372, 0.060165759176015854, -0.020436644554138184, 0.003715957747772336, 0.23377078771591187, 0.3809073567390442, -0.9159824252128601, -0.16271434724330902, -0.0903230756521225, -0.1618283987045288, -0.10027889162302017, -0.2722460925579071, -0.09385814517736435, -0.2630256712436676, 0.7473945617675781, -0.06422710418701172, 0.29730460047721863, -0.03168167918920517, -0.2735886573791504, -0.2153465896844864, 0.08756204694509506, 0.38614919781684875, 1.060920000076294, -0.30026769638061523, 0.5791177153587341, 0.06664096564054489, -0.42498135566711426, 0.22327066957950592, 0.1197684183716774, -0.6322368383407593, 0.25353458523750305, 0.426638662815094, 1.031410574913025, 0.11525379121303558, -0.6013253927230835, 0.5274374485015869, 0.27684950828552246, -0.08655925840139389, -0.4587866961956024, 0.07869771867990494, 0.04627058282494545, 0.22269481420516968, 0.12529948353767395, -0.45499882102012634, 0.3105625808238983, -0.875487744808197, 0.21202008426189423, 0.6255844831466675, -0.526581883430481, -0.43620675802230835, 0.9133338928222656, -0.005769181996583939, -0.5401760935783386, 0.7107160091400146, -0.3061552345752716, -0.6471763849258423, 0.45081254839897156, 0.8664438724517822, 1.0682357549667358, -0.1568589061498642, 0.8862668871879578, 0.1651933640241623, 0.6880025267601013, -0.3060365617275238, 0.17606347799301147, 0.08541862666606903, -0.8568798303604126, -0.47972750663757324, -0.6088290214538574, -0.5692163109779358, 0.501971960067749, -0.5758365988731384, 0.25793322920799255, -0.3881899118423462, -0.31289222836494446, -0.06181538850069046, -0.2800133526325226, -0.2662741243839264, 0.008655811659991741, 0.6402451395988464, 0.6094269752502441, -0.9576844573020935, 0.5367320775985718, 0.44891440868377686, -0.03756614029407501, -0.4529035687446594, 0.27426233887672424, 0.21595649421215057, -0.9396190643310547, 0.1263338327407837, 0.3086192011833191, -0.5210221409797668, 0.051220860332250595, -0.5772362351417542, -0.5969729423522949, 0.7587209343910217, 0.7321592569351196, -0.5351028442382812, 0.2714996635913849, 0.23557010293006897, 0.6363962888717651, -0.1394168734550476, 0.20246760547161102, 0.7168033719062805, 0.5543875694274902, -0.06835126131772995, -0.52834153175354, 0.3045921325683594, 0.046431317925453186, -0.055794671177864075, 0.6364398002624512, -0.6557976007461548, 0.6661587953567505, -0.1774885505437851, -0.6323068141937256, -0.20895589888095856, 0.6086430549621582, 0.2284679412841797, 0.30029839277267456, 0.7190253734588623, 0.41340234875679016, 0.8770875930786133, -0.1870790272951126, 0.7411259412765503, -0.5237644910812378, 0.43337497115135193, 0.8157162070274353, -0.2567996680736542, 0.836015522480011, 0.33625879883766174, -0.28566813468933105, 0.6950491070747375, 0.42562806606292725, -0.3275965452194214, 0.140436589717865, 0.4274713099002838, -0.23696370422840118, -0.6425849795341492, -0.17922526597976685, -0.27636727690696716, 0.43935707211494446, 0.11832880228757858, -0.010139002464711666, -0.18835343420505524, -0.17787086963653564, 0.20897498726844788, -0.041081711649894714, -0.03685475140810013, 0.6861488819122314, 0.16227297484874725, -0.6895400285720825, 0.6479389667510986, -0.24322839081287384, 0.3349319398403168, -0.6491933465003967, -0.17224854230880737, -0.09020523726940155, -0.039145346730947495, -0.060725223273038864, -0.7404348254203796, -0.03350774571299553, -0.11339645832777023, 0.10631590336561203, -0.24295198917388916, 0.42868518829345703, -0.6188732981681824, -0.6915068626403809, 0.6188481450080872, 0.4944723844528198, 0.4248797297477722, -0.17939528822898865, -0.5417277216911316, 0.4626524746417999, -0.044000908732414246, -0.09408053010702133, 0.01742338016629219, 0.4064728319644928, -0.06558971107006073, 0.8116786479949951, 0.6669747233390808, 0.6012246608734131, 0.051212456077337265, 0.23488269746303558, 0.5496322512626648, -0.6502833366394043, -0.6078203320503235, -1.0246797800064087, 0.2946456968784332, -0.10504576563835144, -0.22413167357444763, 0.6105850338935852, 0.7085275650024414, 0.7998067736625671, 0.08354438096284866, 0.6867185235023499, 0.24536706507205963, 0.13834421336650848, -0.7206303477287292, 0.7778124213218689, -0.45739731192588806, 0.1240905225276947, -0.18004611134529114, -1.0121272802352905, -0.1284070461988449, 0.37905552983283997, -0.38674142956733704, -0.25000888109207153, 0.8291234374046326, 1.0920919179916382, -0.07527084648609161, -0.04494743049144745, 0.5199910998344421, 0.718146800994873, 0.28695857524871826, 0.3354843258857727, 1.1941745281219482, 0.03031027689576149, 0.8711039423942566, -0.25604745745658875, -0.21559825539588928, -0.2601003348827362, -0.7091094255447388, -0.9179982542991638, -0.9304744601249695, -0.4857158958911896, -0.6664077639579773, 0.05400817468762398, 0.6344407200813293, 0.6648388504981995, -0.8244405388832092, -0.653639554977417, 0.1074841320514679, 0.2982292175292969, -0.2557973265647888, -0.23792578279972076, 0.32590165734291077, -0.20321626961231232, -0.6812617778778076, 0.36736011505126953, 0.4223794937133789, 0.10042690485715866, -0.5998349785804749, 0.10834489017724991, 0.20852826535701752, 0.24970383942127228, 0.5876466035842896, 0.06293348222970963, -0.7938271760940552, -0.2548857033252716, -0.4132404625415802, 0.09417587518692017, 0.027771426364779472, 1.0731300115585327, -0.5575929880142212, 0.8186649084091187, 0.30733510851860046, 0.23418714106082916, 0.8238657116889954, -0.023880554363131523, 0.526472270488739, -0.17386654019355774, 0.2684091627597809, 0.09071359038352966, 0.2113463580608368, 0.27193209528923035, -0.13057321310043335, 0.4096376299858093, 0.41364049911499023, -0.3398875296115875, -1.2919492721557617, 0.3841495215892792, -0.7279583811759949, -0.4941837787628174, 1.1106717586517334, 0.5264922976493835, -0.3939577341079712, -0.11336130648851395, -0.25543537735939026, 0.23660512268543243, -0.2155187427997589, 1.3164314031600952, 0.9239368438720703, -0.2560431957244873, -0.2725372016429901, -0.7170034646987915, 0.5339447855949402, 0.15715907514095306, -0.9743393063545227, 0.2887251377105713, 0.6109510064125061, 0.07326921075582504, 0.10234041512012482, 0.6293919682502747, 0.029509425163269043, -0.06743977963924408, 0.11660289019346237, 0.04130924120545387, -0.3459762930870056, -0.44560134410858154, -0.22998978197574615, 0.3275936245918274, 0.1511380821466446, -0.21114908158779144 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04689v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04689v1
Multicalibration for Confidence Scoring in LLMs
2024-04-06T17:33:37
2024-04-06T17:33:37
Gianluca Detommaso, Martin Bertran, Riccardo Fogliato, Aaron Roth
stat.ML
stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG
This paper proposes the use of "multicalibration" to yield interpretable and reliable confidence scores for outputs generated by large language models (LLMs). Multicalibration asks for calibration not just marginally, but simultaneously across various intersecting groupings of the data. We show how to form groupings for prompt/completion pairs that are correlated with the probability of correctness via two techniques: clustering within an embedding space, and "self-annotation" - querying the LLM by asking it various yes-or-no questions about the prompt. We also develop novel variants of multicalibration algorithms that offer performance improvements by reducing their tendency to overfit. Through systematic benchmarking across various question answering datasets and LLMs, we show how our techniques can yield confidence scores that provide substantial improvements in fine-grained measures of both calibration and accuracy compared to existing methods.
[ -0.3217375576496124, -0.6256613731384277, 0.8646183013916016, 0.3931008279323578, 0.03173011541366577, 0.07767851650714874, -0.4119933843612671, -0.3322110176086426, 0.2701514959335327, 0.18828804790973663, -0.40125274658203125, -0.6646745204925537, -0.44237175583839417, 0.0745898187160492, -0.05936603993177414, 0.6362439393997192, -0.06234709918498993, 0.4023447632789612, -0.5449802279472351, -0.2796671986579895, -0.4413653612136841, -0.7497379183769226, -0.5049735903739929, -0.41121745109558105, 0.8282022476196289, 0.589042603969574, 0.5843611359596252, 0.511041522026062, 0.4003086984157562, 0.22685961425304413, 0.3214041292667389, 0.43803083896636963, -0.4217708110809326, 0.266125351190567, 0.2014266699552536, -0.7246232032775879, -0.37870457768440247, 0.22831572592258453, 0.939257025718689, 0.8016331791877747, -0.14771729707717896, 0.243046835064888, 0.24125103652477264, 0.452231228351593, -0.6528863310813904, 0.22211554646492004, -0.5124910473823547, -0.06556341797113419, -0.024046611040830612, -0.5957071185112, -0.577613890171051, -0.7323790788650513, -0.18509913980960846, -0.37883517146110535, 0.015511013567447662, 0.05296709015965462, 0.13468901813030243, 0.39581844210624695, -0.5508667826652527, -0.4461636245250702, -0.5153700113296509, 1.2529371976852417, -0.5238906741142273, 0.1166546419262886, 0.6943802237510681, 0.3952213227748871, 0.0299679022282362, -0.3439612090587616, -0.2443661093711853, -0.16430743038654327, -0.10326684266328812, 0.18947643041610718, 0.40990471839904785, -0.004896967206150293, 0.17853379249572754, 0.4390305280685425, -0.5316553115844727, 0.010550381615757942, -0.14937900006771088, -0.5185704827308655, 0.6455290913581848, 0.08789584785699844, -0.2631862759590149, 0.041565846651792526, -0.2558348774909973, -0.2223980724811554, -0.7746949791908264, 0.1478014588356018, 0.4279915988445282, 0.6118758320808411, 0.16259823739528656, 0.7207491993904114, -0.04022763669490814, 0.6680882573127747, -0.05745923891663551, -0.4015066623687744, 0.2787138521671295, -0.5646415948867798, 0.18066619336605072, -0.010557790286839008, 0.6128993630409241, 0.7058587074279785, 0.508020281791687, -0.07771694660186768, -0.004865157417953014, 0.003481888910755515, 0.02712860330939293, -0.5951383709907532, 0.042478833347558975, 0.4681875705718994, -0.17257094383239746, -0.04932231456041336, 0.1634339541196823, -0.7947041988372803, -0.22837963700294495, -0.43592631816864014, 0.35431402921676636, -0.08996650576591492, 0.019415197893977165, 0.03509111702442169, 0.054117847234010696, 0.4394436478614807, 0.445088654756546, -0.5839919447898865, 0.2268059402704239, 0.3872116506099701, 0.6917222738265991, -0.10208404064178467, -0.517375111579895, -0.87214595079422, 0.039980147033929825, -0.5324214696884155, 0.8280993700027466, -0.5117021203041077, -0.3718549311161041, 0.17414730787277222, -0.19309040904045105, -0.23657678067684174, -0.37731799483299255, 0.31733715534210205, -0.5650517344474792, 0.12062285840511322, -0.4540359675884247, -0.6759940385818481, -0.18861274421215057, 0.5843596458435059, -0.5735742449760437, 1.3219176530838013, -0.14320315420627594, -0.37706759572029114, 0.17517778277397156, -0.1942223459482193, -0.24719718098640442, -0.10043537616729736, -0.2396901547908783, 0.018360573798418045, 0.04243085905909538, 0.26003706455230713, 0.4931489825248718, -0.35789355635643005, 0.22318324446678162, -0.5175885558128357, -0.2669576406478882, 0.5020893812179565, -0.5859320759773254, 0.1714526265859604, 0.07282456010580063, 0.08565269410610199, -0.04560636356472969, -0.8009413480758667, 0.7832765579223633, -0.4561353325843811, -0.40346869826316833, -0.2831735908985138, -0.054843563586473465, -0.08091022819280624, 0.1652907431125641, 0.5948798656463623, -0.5635877251625061, -0.0029371208511292934, -0.05268267169594765, 0.24076513946056366, 0.5001357793807983, 0.05523168295621872, 0.31307166814804077, -0.6424475312232971, 0.4000069797039032, -0.10697966814041138, 0.0484992191195488, -0.4742266535758972, -0.6670420169830322, -0.6476846933364868, -0.01588263548910618, 0.41484159231185913, 0.6979842782020569, -0.6002703309059143, 0.4144424796104431, -0.05396736413240433, -0.7581682801246643, -0.6441461443901062, 0.2574338912963867, 0.5212849378585815, 0.2801869511604309, 0.5894518494606018, -0.3169018626213074, -0.29436054825782776, -0.6325963735580444, -0.09539974480867386, -0.18493995070457458, 0.12064015865325928, 0.32850849628448486, 0.23540447652339935, 0.12077990174293518, 1.0209378004074097, -0.6489498615264893, -0.2095918506383896, 0.22406674921512604, 0.37711185216903687, 0.07201947271823883, 0.5535512566566467, 0.3696020841598511, -0.6074302792549133, -0.4788946211338043, -0.28860634565353394, -0.659182608127594, -0.030595485121011734, 0.1352526992559433, 0.21259595453739166, -0.13342218101024628, 0.7439987063407898, -0.31302541494369507, 0.2518827021121979, 0.7542527914047241, 0.23374922573566437, 0.6343536972999573, -0.4263245165348053, 0.674381673336029, -1.243114948272705, -0.19467954337596893, 0.20524023473262787, -0.463672399520874, -0.5840697884559631, 0.05495404452085495, 0.09387051314115524, 0.4634890556335449, -0.31339436769485474, 0.5223517417907715, -0.39926740527153015, -0.0006893468089401722, -0.09929299354553223, 0.3753843605518341, 0.24458782374858856, 0.1583566516637802, -0.16675515472888947, 0.9889077544212341, 0.5120972394943237, -0.5216172933578491, 0.5511265397071838, 0.02621922455728054, -0.2942393124103546, 0.6960614323616028, -0.7057112455368042, 0.2906622290611267, -0.19170694053173065, 0.19156673550605774, -1.7184536457061768, -0.2347531020641327, -0.19055376946926117, -0.5088983774185181, 0.16530148684978485, -0.132267564535141, -0.6419493556022644, -0.22843702137470245, -0.5950299501419067, 0.825316309928894, 0.047804128378629684, -0.3373430371284485, 0.4447717070579529, 0.46867504715919495, -0.2157231569290161, -0.599662721157074, -1.0674858093261719, -0.18065237998962402, -0.21458908915519714, -0.5255976915359497, 0.2657123804092407, -0.393277108669281, -0.16340605914592743, -0.34219056367874146, 0.18644367158412933, -0.19709505140781403, -0.17469176650047302, 0.24748925864696503, 0.11949407309293747, -0.32059618830680847, 0.43851137161254883, -0.03632301092147827, -0.22708667814731598, -0.11016004532575607, 0.07179830223321915, 0.631900429725647, -0.1633063107728958, -0.7756462097167969, -0.19210773706436157, 0.6606479287147522, 0.563148021697998, -0.11231784522533417, 0.6743415594100952, 0.5588598251342773, -0.4929632246494293, 0.14503519237041473, -1.075188159942627, -0.4377255141735077, -0.4153740704059601, 0.10324817150831223, -0.5234169960021973, -1.138121247291565, 0.7680116295814514, -0.09456475079059601, 0.09984201192855835, 0.4118148684501648, 0.6127996444702148, -0.047246795147657394, 1.1472158432006836, 0.5376392602920532, -0.04380582273006439, 0.06696489453315735, 0.21067380905151367, 0.05954383686184883, -0.7707019448280334, -0.10900677740573883, -0.7829040288925171, -0.14372442662715912, -0.6415109038352966, -0.7810916900634766, 0.44339996576309204, 0.1079295426607132, 0.07230057567358017, 0.23107163608074188, -0.21297086775302887, 0.5936752557754517, 0.7362794280052185, -0.014674631878733635, 0.37092313170433044, -0.0953838899731636, -0.3306845724582672, -0.2760513126850128, -0.5165327787399292, -0.697895884513855, 1.19231116771698, 0.30482324957847595, 1.012572169303894, 0.06443066895008087, 0.7589712738990784, 0.08747665584087372, 0.3862074613571167, -0.8061142563819885, 0.2645299732685089, 0.0055545540526509285, -0.6063404083251953, -0.44897449016571045, -0.6089260578155518, -0.6712906360626221, 0.21200166642665863, -0.11720383167266846, -0.9116251468658447, 0.0817757323384285, 0.11526323109865189, -0.835548460483551, -0.16640610992908478, -0.9800185561180115, 0.6907171010971069, -0.06292522698640823, -0.1762334108352661, -0.19459158182144165, -0.6279173493385315, 0.2296937108039856, -0.26172831654548645, 0.34576183557510376, -0.3377334177494049, -0.03121560625731945, 0.4628388583660126, -0.013668667525053024, 1.0728436708450317, 0.06029873341321945, -0.11626362055540085, 0.4467245042324066, -0.16276808083057404, 0.17956212162971497, 0.2777101993560791, -0.5654760003089905, 0.07792853564023972, 0.6077682971954346, -0.17267300188541412, -0.5954777598381042, 0.9053957462310791, -0.6872807145118713, -0.40599578619003296, -0.4148845970630646, -0.8576545715332031, -0.494798868894577, -0.031083999201655388, 0.020824942737817764, 0.593911349773407, -0.11556635051965714, 0.21460990607738495, 0.38830888271331787, -0.04872392490506172, 0.4114384353160858, 0.2835231423377991, -0.17476573586463928, -0.7167575359344482, 0.746269702911377, 0.299201637506485, 0.5061396360397339, 0.4332818388938904, 0.09303437173366547, -0.787079393863678, -0.09615609794855118, -0.3323584794998169, 0.4832046627998352, -0.9981271624565125, -0.37940874695777893, -0.15213997662067413, -0.36863020062446594, -0.62171471118927, 0.10785826295614243, -0.3096625506877899, -0.4651625454425812, -0.2699697017669678, 0.02178889513015747, 0.28857359290122986, 0.7859415411949158, -0.07695893943309784, 0.44673067331314087, -0.9959328174591064, -0.09967709332704544, 0.4604824185371399, 0.2394939661026001, -0.2299714982509613, -0.5037832856178284, -0.13987673819065094, 0.17191848158836365, -0.21390514075756073, -0.81429123878479, -0.008495916612446308, 0.3284152150154114, 0.6347936391830444, 0.1465127170085907, 0.09276694804430008, 1.0027333498001099, -0.5519371032714844, 0.6585615873336792, 0.15286153554916382, -0.8053498864173889, 0.39363211393356323, 0.10477886348962784, 0.41934651136398315, 0.9060295224189758, 0.44430211186408997, -0.6692795753479004, -0.3630496561527252, -0.08248104900121689, -0.5465463995933533, 0.3538062274456024, -0.1576118916273117, 0.23226715624332428, -0.10083306580781937, 0.5146308541297913, -0.07703317701816559, 0.3694128692150116, -0.5851309895515442, -0.37395596504211426, 0.1954786777496338, -0.5621117353439331, -0.6018230319023132, -0.5500935316085815, -0.4280771315097809, -0.03692115470767021, 0.4780152440071106, -0.6787263751029968, 0.053798794746398926, 0.2593514621257782, -0.05966564267873764, -0.21502704918384552, 0.3131687343120575, 0.5915868282318115, 0.7706138491630554, -0.09867507219314575, 0.31565061211586, 0.2159907966852188, -0.269818514585495, 0.1766335666179657, 0.11226887255907059, 0.12403616309165955, -0.13449347019195557, 0.289577454328537, 0.21948586404323578, 0.125352144241333, -0.3877645432949066, 0.6616572737693787, -0.22002960741519928, -0.14167547225952148, -0.2886357307434082, -0.12697605788707733, 0.0658051073551178, 0.19560757279396057, 0.36855000257492065, -0.03674788400530815, 0.010906226933002472, -0.40027210116386414, 0.3463810980319977, 0.534450113773346, -0.615198016166687, -0.06723189353942871, 0.2505836486816406, -0.16089430451393127, -0.020984629169106483, 0.24599537253379822, -0.15784375369548798, -0.2774052917957306, 0.48553597927093506, 0.4898208975791931, 0.4121505916118622, -0.6229710578918457, 0.28706178069114685, 0.6002448797225952, 0.4835483431816101, -0.32727235555648804, 0.47596538066864014, 0.03131892904639244, -0.9825049042701721, -0.8442429304122925, -0.6350980997085571, -0.7494559288024902, -0.18452121317386627, -0.7540708184242249, 0.14265842735767365, -0.21198037266731262, -0.4834214150905609, -0.09956111013889313, -0.0007407043012790382, -0.4358510971069336, 0.26429301500320435, 0.16992712020874023, 0.8147439360618591, -0.9112407565116882, 0.7094361782073975, 0.673034131526947, -0.2727991044521332, -0.9826710224151611, -0.07764534652233124, 0.0007375343702733517, -0.9208980798721313, 0.11725080013275146, 0.5814565420150757, -0.3720557987689972, 0.1467125117778778, -0.3346154987812042, -1.160827398300171, 1.0940220355987549, 0.291551798582077, -0.3668942451477051, -0.038509465754032135, 0.3971140384674072, 0.41051286458969116, -0.5623881816864014, 0.7138318419456482, 0.6486545205116272, 0.5674949884414673, 0.4545993208885193, -1.0383356809616089, -0.12625624239444733, 0.006320127751678228, -0.028538886457681656, 0.011148745194077492, -0.5787012577056885, 0.777877151966095, -0.16432349383831024, 0.05089309439063072, 0.2942121624946594, 0.44801706075668335, 0.4568421244621277, 0.31396350264549255, 0.5148869156837463, 0.4731828570365906, 0.9810377359390259, -0.45508018136024475, 0.7923981547355652, -0.5639879107475281, 0.4828507602214813, 1.2228152751922607, -0.3439899981021881, 1.0134499073028564, 0.7340520620346069, -0.25814488530158997, 0.22743496298789978, 0.7492906451225281, 0.26879167556762695, 0.29115456342697144, 0.1777639538049698, -0.33190786838531494, -0.559317946434021, -0.1948767602443695, -0.31125229597091675, 0.35333508253097534, 0.551336944103241, -0.04053954780101776, -0.3763940632343292, -0.05797938257455826, -0.1991206705570221, 0.18576817214488983, -0.28935983777046204, 0.5886669754981995, 0.34081393480300903, -1.0437732934951782, 0.3108137845993042, 0.028087545186281204, 0.504575788974762, -0.5398980379104614, -0.003602029290050268, -0.08229616284370422, 0.3148234784603119, -0.2525983452796936, -1.0233315229415894, 0.22338074445724487, -0.3650966286659241, -0.23718291521072388, -0.13575555384159088, 0.3527718186378479, -0.9109566807746887, -0.6053288578987122, 0.36148780584335327, 0.9051532745361328, 0.30220818519592285, -0.2072789967060089, -0.5945990681648254, -0.0823449119925499, -0.15673308074474335, -0.05313948169350624, 0.0777357891201973, 0.38700219988822937, 0.14669169485569, 0.5557746887207031, 0.6070083379745483, 0.014755130745470524, 0.3427838981151581, 0.4660171866416931, 0.6507550477981567, -0.3611871004104614, -0.10658727586269379, -0.8348129391670227, 0.3934277594089508, 0.0037142285145819187, -0.3998132646083832, 0.8265995979309082, 0.5491187572479248, 0.6150999069213867, 0.2455630600452423, 0.4642553925514221, 0.2312963902950287, 0.7418526411056519, -0.6440659761428833, 0.2832307815551758, -0.6164117455482483, 0.044761624187231064, -0.27563217282295227, -1.0154215097427368, -0.7167789340019226, 0.760444164276123, -0.44755616784095764, 0.28656691312789917, 0.9163559675216675, 1.1855428218841553, 0.24740011990070343, -0.0843753069639206, 0.5624476075172424, -0.1377643644809723, 0.20397458970546722, 0.5270825624465942, 0.9623261094093323, -0.6089634895324707, 0.5021639466285706, -0.22182707488536835, -0.531010627746582, -0.06992688030004501, -0.9665403962135315, -0.7706819772720337, -0.6691280603408813, -0.3062194585800171, -0.26074841618537903, -0.34368956089019775, 0.8830874562263489, 0.8679443597793579, -0.9924244284629822, -0.48972535133361816, 0.46120068430900574, 0.08801540732383728, -0.12298888713121414, -0.1874331384897232, 0.08685042709112167, -0.786289393901825, -0.7255589365959167, 0.3521873950958252, 0.3149572014808655, 0.059093765914440155, -0.5119755864143372, 0.03908922150731087, -0.2996240556240082, 0.13939228653907776, 0.5227655172348022, 0.03016328066587448, -0.6918851137161255, -0.4589628279209137, 0.17055653035640717, -0.4063352048397064, 0.2636525332927704, 0.6008835434913635, -0.377678781747818, 0.4348353445529938, 0.24942849576473236, 0.6408554315567017, 0.3882367014884949, 0.30939561128616333, 0.48823702335357666, -1.1023480892181396, -0.06248227879405022, 0.12070079147815704, 0.432443767786026, 0.571526288986206, -0.19395916163921356, 0.34895357489585876, -0.08923877030611038, -0.8771252632141113, -0.5529959201812744, 0.2773427963256836, -0.8253845572471619, 0.2129274159669876, 1.2227033376693726, -0.30462968349456787, -0.12439148873090744, -0.11526110768318176, -0.18326659500598907, 0.04101541265845299, -0.2679635286331177, 0.5507480502128601, 1.2384555339813232, 0.01422865130007267, -0.12727344036102295, -0.5195450782775879, 0.2683556079864502, 0.4905374348163605, -0.8333917856216431, 0.035612206906080246, 0.6085925102233887, 0.20973239839076996, 0.7171483039855957, 0.7126419544219971, -0.20489747822284698, 0.288880854845047, -0.22068090736865997, 0.014331323094666004, 0.5269299745559692, -0.5038546323776245, -0.3060227632522583, 0.40716591477394104, 0.41916027665138245, -0.19587400555610657 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04676v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04676v1
Order-Based Pre-training Strategies for Procedural Text Understanding
2024-04-06T16:39:07
2024-04-06T16:39:07
Abhilash Nandy, Yash Kulkarni, Pawan Goyal, Niloy Ganguly
cs.CL
cs.CL
In this paper, we propose sequence-based pretraining methods to enhance procedural understanding in natural language processing. Procedural text, containing sequential instructions to accomplish a task, is difficult to understand due to the changing attributes of entities in the context. We focus on recipes, which are commonly represented as ordered instructions, and use this order as a supervision signal. Our work is one of the first to compare several 'order as-supervision' transformer pre-training methods, including Permutation Classification, Embedding Regression, and Skip-Clip, and shows that these methods give improved results compared to the baselines and SoTA LLMs on two downstream Entity-Tracking datasets: NPN-Cooking dataset in recipe domain and ProPara dataset in open domain. Our proposed methods address the non-trivial Entity Tracking Task that requires prediction of entity states across procedure steps, which requires understanding the order of steps. These methods show an improvement over the best baseline by 1.6% and 7-9% on NPN-Cooking and ProPara Datasets respectively across metrics.
[ -0.1327606588602066, -0.8217113018035889, 0.5777761340141296, 0.45040103793144226, -0.3801686465740204, 0.0310040432959795, -0.1654394418001175, -0.16699305176734924, 0.3430195748806, 0.9430562853813171, -0.8687366247177124, -0.6249006986618042, -0.6923412084579468, 0.4459441006183624, -0.38524675369262695, 0.881415069103241, -0.18115004897117615, 0.4274733066558838, 0.06359755247831345, 0.31036773324012756, -0.36796677112579346, -0.5438657999038696, -0.6949498653411865, -0.17679785192012787, 0.4270878732204437, 0.31766536831855774, 0.48723798990249634, 0.9667319059371948, 0.5407907962799072, 0.45040106773376465, 0.07150771468877792, 0.25383880734443665, -0.427289217710495, 0.2828877866268158, -0.11281674355268478, -0.5592780113220215, -0.36378300189971924, 0.02619093842804432, 0.15528981387615204, 0.6828690767288208, -0.28553879261016846, 0.08004473894834518, -0.09870506823062897, 0.4240495264530182, -0.6288576126098633, 0.5032157301902771, -0.4432533085346222, 0.16249610483646393, -0.32120561599731445, -0.5715028643608093, -0.661112368106842, -0.4327554702758789, 0.3875159025192261, -0.9925084710121155, 0.3229747414588928, 0.0768028050661087, 0.8168397545814514, 0.35145723819732666, -0.2961600720882416, -0.6378911733627319, -0.6650978922843933, 0.5934162139892578, -0.5683693885803223, 0.3126220405101776, 0.5274973511695862, 0.20657466351985931, -0.33303943276405334, -1.1677755117416382, -0.572816014289856, 0.13160303235054016, -0.10295291990041733, 0.2813463807106018, 0.43998610973358154, 0.12842167913913727, 0.2753394842147827, 0.4929106831550598, -0.5639070868492126, 0.2741278409957886, -0.041757673025131226, -0.06751099973917007, 0.3525831699371338, 0.14930231869220734, 0.3493291437625885, -0.056670885533094406, -0.26921287178993225, -0.49032890796661377, -0.5403221249580383, -0.040391333401203156, 0.2159586399793625, 0.3679916262626648, 0.15270818769931793, 0.38841912150382996, -0.19199389219284058, 0.7041699290275574, 0.32661402225494385, -0.09306531399488449, 0.4286215603351593, -0.5227730870246887, -0.5405542254447937, 0.33066853880882263, 0.870863676071167, 0.0423906035721302, 0.38138675689697266, -0.006076696794480085, -0.12339466065168381, -0.02722673863172531, 0.5698289275169373, -0.9691310524940491, -0.23772892355918884, -0.23767507076263428, -0.20668764412403107, -0.14857348799705505, 0.23175469040870667, -0.5892894268035889, -0.202142596244812, -0.5523051023483276, 0.05403053015470505, -0.49106088280677795, 0.016407860442996025, 0.13341191411018372, 0.20266246795654297, 0.3711778223514557, 0.4253169000148773, -1.2660456895828247, 0.564732015132904, 0.8461835384368896, 0.7698044776916504, -0.059583116322755814, -0.17228829860687256, -0.710935652256012, 0.06931590288877487, -0.34606972336769104, 0.9403964281082153, -0.599877655506134, -0.43461915850639343, 0.07314489781856537, 0.17245467007160187, -0.29928573966026306, -0.4498229920864105, 0.6544675827026367, -0.5932419300079346, 0.37349772453308105, -0.19170904159545898, -0.5350759625434875, -0.26645591855049133, -0.06820762157440186, -0.5188055634498596, 0.8281688094139099, -0.04723406210541725, -0.5597836971282959, 0.4701289236545563, -0.414727121591568, -0.8207165598869324, -0.0030547252390533686, -0.2779286205768585, -0.29334694147109985, 0.03881920129060745, 0.4462161660194397, 0.4935165345668793, -0.08203122764825821, 0.22769096493721008, 0.1921098828315735, -0.29659146070480347, -0.1393021196126938, -0.278759241104126, 0.5030897855758667, 0.1536364108324051, -0.29246389865875244, 0.4063761532306671, -0.6624327301979065, 0.07698094844818115, 0.11967278271913528, -0.148080974817276, -0.3126433491706848, -0.04265185445547104, -0.07666271179914474, 0.11628389358520508, -0.13897950947284698, -0.06418857723474503, 0.20038902759552002, -0.7843725085258484, 0.39294618368148804, 0.7476937174797058, 0.24275334179401398, 0.8101972341537476, 0.002304121619090438, 0.6250255107879639, 0.126627579331398, 0.11096165329217911, -0.6685972809791565, -0.43138110637664795, -0.6587400436401367, -0.06839317828416824, 0.32459017634391785, 0.9144673347473145, -1.0925848484039307, 0.5364368557929993, -0.32806193828582764, -0.31355345249176025, -0.3311718702316284, -0.14906227588653564, 0.764998733997345, 0.7352713346481323, 0.7021092176437378, -0.6951122879981995, -0.6527283191680908, -0.3592647910118103, -0.43018531799316406, 0.0406106635928154, -0.20072080194950104, -0.05306205153465271, 0.2862538695335388, -0.09685266762971878, 0.5988590121269226, -0.7885919809341431, -0.17753633856773376, -0.19076849520206451, 0.5872483849525452, 0.39669927954673767, 0.46518218517303467, 0.13362044095993042, -0.9259532690048218, -0.6878021359443665, -0.07478714734315872, -0.6680136919021606, 0.043925691395998, -0.22176213562488556, -0.1727806180715561, 0.1760011911392212, 0.5862736701965332, -0.653619647026062, 0.6913381218910217, 0.03002914972603321, -0.10712558776140213, 0.4121696352958679, -0.23283547163009644, 0.3100845515727997, -0.9854459762573242, -0.6468386054039001, 0.16040199995040894, -0.15169188380241394, -1.1046509742736816, -0.27987760305404663, 0.03184458985924721, 0.2615778148174286, -0.5350590944290161, 0.23700165748596191, -0.6329711675643921, 0.08642487972974777, -0.00588018074631691, -0.3451520800590515, -0.04958449676632881, 0.6435738205909729, 0.6263058185577393, 0.7882757782936096, 0.4412786364555359, -0.6895528435707092, -0.021497607231140137, 0.49826616048812866, -0.5936186909675598, 0.27430641651153564, -0.39837509393692017, 0.38942623138427734, -0.09271826595067978, 0.2745892405509949, -0.7676331400871277, 0.021709097549319267, 0.5972203016281128, -0.3689831495285034, 0.6647801399230957, -0.3052396774291992, -0.45155471563339233, -0.1810443252325058, -0.05315686762332916, 0.03655838593840599, 0.3506404757499695, -0.21536000072956085, 0.6776493191719055, 0.02510823681950569, -0.23695756494998932, -0.6076468229293823, -0.5441147685050964, -0.14969496428966522, -0.1653357893228531, -0.271502286195755, 0.6600162386894226, 0.021951723843812943, -0.045240823179483414, -0.37447383999824524, -0.5476917624473572, -0.46881935000419617, -0.09308068454265594, 0.30939847230911255, 0.11101232469081879, -0.4292542040348053, -0.293763130903244, 0.09319647401571274, -0.3209308087825775, 0.24801604449748993, -0.5830078721046448, 0.5585995316505432, 0.20774689316749573, 0.02486255019903183, -0.585200846195221, -0.06981199979782104, 0.07916174829006195, -0.2708483040332794, 0.8764345645904541, 0.34032338857650757, -0.21563422679901123, -0.07381357252597809, -0.34945541620254517, -0.24141855537891388, -0.5451241135597229, 0.10463911294937134, -0.45414477586746216, -0.4504528045654297, 0.21126440167427063, -0.11473728716373444, 0.1531873494386673, 0.12611925601959229, 0.4062686860561371, -0.36851242184638977, 0.5516864061355591, 0.4238903820514679, 0.11109133064746857, 0.8446561098098755, -0.24503809213638306, 0.21472102403640747, -0.38702425360679626, -0.12628714740276337, -0.4988986551761627, 0.1348842978477478, -0.5724368691444397, -0.5385065078735352, -0.015254205092787743, 0.04403303936123848, -0.2910955846309662, 0.6365297436714172, -0.4218808710575104, 0.5326579809188843, 0.48349496722221375, 0.19894133508205414, 0.34707069396972656, 0.18949507176876068, -0.08767668157815933, -0.041179101914167404, -0.45478662848472595, -0.5678849816322327, 0.8841426968574524, 0.04105444997549057, 0.7076311111450195, -0.4021548628807068, 0.9117329120635986, 0.04182155802845955, 0.2595261037349701, -0.8077258467674255, 0.4525073170661926, -0.1516672521829605, -0.027662256732583046, -0.705079972743988, -0.4520745873451233, -1.0174403190612793, 0.22910243272781372, -0.0852411538362503, -0.37494027614593506, -0.025192217901349068, 0.11965439468622208, -0.335295170545578, -0.09635337442159653, -1.0358637571334839, 0.8625354766845703, -0.3058325946331024, -0.14135490357875824, 0.23109900951385498, -0.9039773344993591, -0.026550646871328354, 0.13472995162010193, 0.2045159786939621, 0.30410587787628174, 0.22911150753498077, 0.657724916934967, -0.8899389505386353, 0.6050079464912415, -0.2730834484100342, -0.02573629654943943, 0.33604633808135986, 0.001120274537242949, 0.5112562775611877, 0.046474263072013855, 0.05435648187994957, 0.03617667406797409, -0.17584995925426483, -0.17045141756534576, -0.9243788719177246, 0.21579520404338837, -0.55406254529953, -0.6973512768745422, -0.558910608291626, -0.11981882899999619, -0.05604021996259689, 0.4708469808101654, 0.5991978049278259, 0.49572429060935974, 0.03681771829724312, -0.22805091738700867, 0.960889995098114, -0.056586675345897675, 0.47719135880470276, 0.4606483280658722, 0.02871546894311905, -0.24128098785877228, 0.7612706422805786, 0.3180243968963623, 0.09096347540616989, 0.9312708973884583, 0.02262061834335327, -0.2403390258550644, -0.8263521194458008, -0.3952042758464813, -0.040174804627895355, -0.6121439933776855, -0.2015906721353531, -0.7639390826225281, -0.1913551688194275, -0.527933657169342, -0.13865019381046295, -0.33820679783821106, -0.10414081811904907, -0.5570477843284607, -0.17971326410770416, 0.2615315616130829, 0.7082610130310059, 0.6964493989944458, 0.6550647020339966, -0.6131170988082886, 0.5592824220657349, 0.012304059229791164, 0.29236337542533875, -0.08967623114585876, -0.5369155406951904, -0.05573222041130066, 0.0075185359455645084, -0.24325014650821686, -1.003105878829956, 0.6630915403366089, 0.06115979701280594, 0.3002749979496002, 0.4228631258010864, -0.06756992638111115, 0.9696279168128967, -0.9048159122467041, 0.4541858434677124, 0.17297649383544922, -0.923488974571228, 0.7748735547065735, -0.22715073823928833, 0.3340546786785126, 0.6932677626609802, 0.6535522937774658, -0.2631486654281616, -0.19716213643550873, -0.43864405155181885, -0.937459409236908, 0.9439138174057007, 0.4348887503147125, -0.039635613560676575, -0.0894775465130806, 0.47608882188796997, 0.24337434768676758, 0.28657153248786926, -0.4249935448169708, -0.4307912290096283, -0.5305161476135254, -0.34544837474823, -0.1468796283006668, 0.0012895590625703335, 0.39735543727874756, -0.2772219181060791, 0.594258189201355, -0.10667483508586884, 0.1497712880373001, 0.18679897487163544, -0.49056097865104675, 0.14118735492229462, 0.1591503620147705, 0.5559995174407959, 0.8940430283546448, -0.09709272533655167, -0.09484902024269104, 0.1537027508020401, -0.9639449715614319, 0.10260090231895447, 0.003536777338013053, -0.05860854685306549, -0.04911506921052933, 0.5834596753120422, 0.804417610168457, 0.3903663456439972, -0.23654668033123016, 0.398623526096344, -0.3556225597858429, -0.05292898043990135, -0.3744587302207947, 0.08867522329092026, -0.03596904128789902, -0.07310643047094345, 0.132867693901062, 0.0022486657835543156, 0.2811970114707947, -0.5599607825279236, 0.1825803965330124, -0.1660032570362091, -0.37336432933807373, -0.47755467891693115, 0.16123740375041962, -0.08463140577077866, -0.6094898581504822, 0.9607884287834167, -0.1845351904630661, -0.2856248915195465, 0.6677477955818176, 0.6444856524467468, 0.7429602742195129, -0.5374559164047241, 0.31418851017951965, 0.14893600344657898, 0.11752861738204956, -0.48595723509788513, 0.4239113926887512, -0.15279163420200348, -0.7187020778656006, -0.6436836123466492, -0.6183328032493591, -0.41776448488235474, -0.04174406826496124, -0.8638908863067627, 0.40758395195007324, -0.5860202312469482, 0.03702187538146973, 0.18895593285560608, -0.25534719228744507, -0.8026456236839294, 0.2837533950805664, -0.11111446470022202, 0.7992874979972839, -0.5652704834938049, 0.9046715497970581, 0.7588879466056824, -0.525695264339447, -0.7770071029663086, 0.21265816688537598, 0.01070992462337017, -0.6751309633255005, 0.6847056746482849, 0.42971283197402954, -0.11832720786333084, 0.13166041672229767, -0.3652069866657257, -0.7105759382247925, 0.9067259430885315, 0.1604345589876175, -0.56549072265625, -0.402675598859787, 0.0698467418551445, 0.6696809530258179, -0.4207620620727539, 0.6439333558082581, 0.6145144701004028, 0.32640713453292847, 0.4004029929637909, -0.7396571040153503, -0.10406177490949631, -0.08622295409440994, 0.12658528983592987, 0.3862302601337433, -0.11367891728878021, 0.4492393136024475, 0.09351031482219696, -0.39208757877349854, -0.04144823178648949, 0.9054291844367981, -0.14657847583293915, 0.3781825304031372, 0.5539383292198181, 0.4835233986377716, 0.6614255309104919, -0.15177802741527557, 0.9077708721160889, 0.13425762951374054, -0.02442280203104019, 1.6384413242340088, -0.37007835507392883, 0.5701334476470947, 0.41048574447631836, -0.182930588722229, 0.7828257083892822, 0.9002463817596436, 0.19180262088775635, 0.7570042610168457, 0.38191595673561096, 0.19064576923847198, 0.05045623704791069, -0.04389167204499245, -0.1859826296567917, 0.30076029896736145, 0.4562315344810486, -0.4233211278915405, 0.03658708930015564, -0.0585545152425766, 0.10797194391489029, 0.229314386844635, -0.29670286178588867, 1.1777173280715942, 0.13059741258621216, -0.8009781241416931, 0.5224863290786743, -0.22773125767707825, 0.458884596824646, -0.644930899143219, -0.22698508203029633, -0.22530196607112885, -0.0815223902463913, -0.1930183470249176, -0.711620032787323, 0.25237035751342773, -0.021568791940808296, -0.31603845953941345, -0.9029638171195984, 0.4033532738685608, -0.22197453677654266, -0.3816898763179779, 0.14861896634101868, 0.30917423963546753, 0.03806700184941292, -0.1374521404504776, -0.5287871956825256, -0.2273796647787094, -0.24911276996135712, -0.498152494430542, 0.17671211063861847, 0.5963961482048035, -0.259533166885376, 0.2924523651599884, 0.6367664337158203, -0.1157977283000946, 0.22196370363235474, 0.29241257905960083, 0.7821235060691833, -0.6418741345405579, -0.7792491316795349, -0.9316054582595825, 0.26614099740982056, 0.018707647919654846, -0.12253037095069885, 0.652838408946991, 0.3832911252975464, 1.2494233846664429, -0.33213695883750916, 0.28052568435668945, 0.12384471297264099, 0.3041802644729614, -0.9096192717552185, 0.24087072908878326, 0.20843368768692017, 0.2650623023509979, -0.3164021372795105, -1.0141788721084595, -0.3006734549999237, 0.674406111240387, -0.6393958926200867, -0.059892479330301285, 0.9319137334823608, 0.7322012186050415, -0.01563887670636177, 0.4199368953704834, -0.1298750936985016, 0.23562727868556976, 0.0782792717218399, 0.20418284833431244, 0.959833025932312, -0.2870381474494934, 0.21811231970787048, -0.2879616618156433, -0.12528172135353088, 0.17637620866298676, -0.8347866535186768, -1.0054092407226562, -0.520400881767273, -0.1750539392232895, -0.1432984322309494, 0.17457115650177002, 1.044974684715271, 0.8113232851028442, -1.007209300994873, -0.2676209807395935, -0.5182349681854248, 0.22850075364112854, -0.4931204617023468, -0.19581083953380585, 0.27516329288482666, -0.6501311659812927, -0.6516481041908264, 0.538948118686676, 0.4061807692050934, -0.013012101873755455, 0.27222299575805664, 0.026177017018198967, -0.47659382224082947, -0.06407859921455383, 0.5876290798187256, 0.18133382499217987, -0.7360801100730896, 0.15827295184135437, 0.1978674978017807, 0.06927499920129776, 0.4584481418132782, 1.19352126121521, -0.7242189049720764, 0.4310207664966583, 0.5422990322113037, 0.6004335284233093, 0.7773987650871277, 0.1634519249200821, 0.6566199064254761, -0.6461063623428345, 0.039954155683517456, 0.10286440700292587, 0.10529603809118271, 0.033950358629226685, -0.6807975769042969, 0.67094886302948, 0.061181824654340744, -0.30327531695365906, -0.47235551476478577, 0.2413204163312912, -0.7783152461051941, -0.10272014141082764, 0.7217410206794739, -0.4688550531864166, -0.3002452850341797, -0.2539307475090027, 0.001714880345389247, 0.6493766903877258, -0.4009803831577301, 0.5091749429702759, 0.4600399434566498, -0.18697120249271393, -0.08910748362541199, -0.48720481991767883, 0.7205373644828796, 0.3496517837047577, -1.0058293342590332, -0.21476607024669647, 0.21384243667125702, -0.013293145224452019, 0.2164822369813919, 0.6869386434555054, -0.031075816601514816, -0.0731225311756134, -0.4426204562187195, -0.3736671805381775, -0.04046669229865074, -0.6063966751098633, -0.22474037110805511, -0.11765564233064651, -0.3025234341621399, -0.15353381633758545 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04671v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04671v3
PhyloLM : Inferring the Phylogeny of Large Language Models and Predicting their Performances in Benchmarks
2024-04-06T16:16:30
2024-06-16T14:39:20
Nicolas Yax, Pierre-Yves Oudeyer, Stefano Palminteri
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.PE
This paper introduces PhyloLM, a method adapting phylogenetic algorithms to Large Language Models (LLMs) to explore whether and how they relate to each other and to predict their performance characteristics. Our method calculates a phylogenetic distance metrics based on the similarity of LLMs' output. The resulting metric is then used to construct dendrograms, which satisfactorily capture known relationships across a set of 111 open-source and 45 closed models. Furthermore, our phylogenetic distance predicts performance in standard benchmarks, thus demonstrating its functional validity and paving the way for a time and cost-effective estimation of LLM capabilities. To sum up, by translating population genetic concepts to machine learning, we propose and validate a tool to evaluate LLM development, relationships and capabilities, even in the absence of transparent training information.
[ -0.22215507924556732, -0.4598519504070282, 0.373147189617157, 0.06280454993247986, -0.360611230134964, 0.36723437905311584, -0.2928597331047058, -0.5869121551513672, 0.038756296038627625, 0.6637805104255676, -0.44323691725730896, -0.5062898397445679, -0.44671282172203064, 0.2582685947418213, -0.2664243280887604, 0.39456331729888916, 0.25778263807296753, 0.2371503859758377, -0.3393811583518982, -0.2309514582157135, -0.06622505187988281, -0.8788522481918335, -0.21584321558475494, -0.366630882024765, 0.4452652335166931, 0.33248716592788696, 0.5588573217391968, 1.2590904235839844, 0.5551716685295105, 0.263185054063797, -0.29371485114097595, 0.2694075107574463, -0.5018482208251953, 0.34153348207473755, -0.12985970079898834, -0.555921733379364, -0.30922436714172363, -0.21574640274047852, 0.9010895490646362, 1.1127705574035645, -0.06826306134462357, 0.3847997784614563, 0.13823825120925903, 0.601017951965332, -0.2626250386238098, 0.32467159628868103, -0.8170669674873352, 0.1753285527229309, -0.42059072852134705, -0.24210968613624573, -0.5129894614219666, -0.5987193584442139, 0.41803598403930664, -0.2946806252002716, -0.026416579261422157, 0.3843798339366913, 0.4805532991886139, 0.16203458607196808, -0.08505597710609436, -0.03689011558890343, -0.8169733285903931, 0.8794386386871338, -0.9688119888305664, 0.5493788123130798, 0.17510633170604706, 0.25119486451148987, -0.6140829920768738, -0.6029996871948242, -0.2859828770160675, -0.5460122227668762, 0.02538270317018032, -0.22766344249248505, -0.029181474819779396, 0.258537232875824, 0.25648900866508484, 0.5362488031387329, -0.8575491905212402, 0.3967253565788269, -0.36857739090919495, 0.08812830597162247, 0.713595449924469, 0.006496265530586243, 0.4378347396850586, 0.16736195981502533, -0.1271510124206543, -0.20326665043830872, -0.5963783264160156, -0.21005432307720184, 0.3865988552570343, 0.40550175309181213, 0.0174997691065073, 0.5587478280067444, 0.11035344004631042, 0.6392452120780945, -0.21651874482631683, -0.4977753460407257, 0.2815336585044861, 0.008472612127661705, -0.1373155564069748, 0.38073527812957764, 0.5726831555366516, 0.11487982422113419, 0.5303598046302795, -0.23460912704467773, 0.020382868126034737, -0.13732123374938965, -0.1395886242389679, -0.7670350670814514, -0.5477657318115234, 0.010381203144788742, -0.6297659277915955, -0.12001780420541763, -0.12320083379745483, -1.1368836164474487, -0.5056208372116089, -0.1345432549715042, 0.016926851123571396, -0.5003441572189331, -0.34528008103370667, -0.18831101059913635, -0.1934826374053955, 0.07062427699565887, 0.055258579552173615, -0.9421786069869995, 0.6155760884284973, 0.8796703219413757, 1.0748300552368164, -0.4778561294078827, -0.5906853675842285, -0.2450764775276184, 0.2198142409324646, -0.4192989468574524, 0.5329205989837646, -0.5235937833786011, -0.4692125916481018, -0.21193139255046844, -0.005226241424679756, -0.16239610314369202, -0.8787810206413269, 0.19548144936561584, -0.25229811668395996, -0.09820868819952011, 0.24108463525772095, -0.9677368998527527, -0.5099670886993408, -0.06897225975990295, -0.7560308575630188, 0.8518757224082947, 0.2889268398284912, -0.7480645179748535, 0.33391398191452026, -0.4330158829689026, -0.36415308713912964, 0.5373361110687256, 0.31117749214172363, -0.3879673480987549, 0.11088843643665314, -0.03759939968585968, 0.49696195125579834, -0.28785374760627747, 0.1560853123664856, -0.8805488348007202, -0.07870844751596451, 0.013282481580972672, 0.08307197690010071, 0.8443318605422974, 0.21775782108306885, -0.001681426540017128, 0.26176613569259644, -0.7527709603309631, -0.05425803363323212, 0.08163228631019592, -0.27370473742485046, -0.4794660210609436, 0.32591918110847473, -0.37960734963417053, -0.138505220413208, 0.14569631218910217, -0.31520387530326843, 0.36624690890312195, -0.8110857605934143, 0.6509677171707153, 0.6535812020301819, -0.009447305463254452, 0.36673492193222046, -0.2835597097873688, 0.6010000705718994, -0.4815538227558136, -0.07094491273164749, -0.05784934014081955, -0.5284391641616821, -0.36043378710746765, -0.26443102955818176, 0.38495489954948425, 0.47622328996658325, -0.16771133244037628, 0.4463796019554138, -0.4217439293861389, -0.9169766902923584, -0.14919330179691315, 0.425317645072937, 0.10227292031049728, 0.38330429792404175, 0.1292564570903778, -0.9031159281730652, -0.7781732678413391, -0.5372960567474365, -0.13112157583236694, -0.7718138098716736, 0.17851640284061432, 0.5172377824783325, 0.4632132649421692, -0.08433453738689423, 0.6700043082237244, -0.27945202589035034, 0.19963370263576508, -0.40675148367881775, 0.062465034425258636, 0.2749968469142914, 0.4390682280063629, 0.5392258763313293, -0.32103779911994934, -0.2950749695301056, 0.21188588440418243, -0.6809326410293579, -0.2185375690460205, 0.40327686071395874, 0.07861661911010742, 0.12250552326440811, 0.5443447232246399, -0.5178553462028503, -0.24549280107021332, 0.9093335270881653, -0.040586281567811966, 0.7477269768714905, -0.18741025030612946, -0.27522844076156616, -0.9872157573699951, 0.27886152267456055, 0.20230597257614136, 0.1178385391831398, -0.47309091687202454, 0.08941623568534851, -0.32598915696144104, -0.06571311503648758, -0.36961841583251953, 0.6936100125312805, -0.39756399393081665, -0.7257581353187561, 0.27447807788848877, 0.0073034330271184444, -0.4188569188117981, 0.28011494874954224, -0.05349279195070267, 0.6635589003562927, 0.47322988510131836, -0.47722071409225464, 0.6449429988861084, 0.025470944121479988, -0.49732592701911926, 0.18212787806987762, -0.3437245488166809, 0.05606592819094658, 0.1592130959033966, 0.2938660979270935, -1.0352559089660645, -0.4172731339931488, 0.13261263072490692, -0.37607356905937195, 0.05489121749997139, -0.35878315567970276, -0.567346453666687, -0.603272557258606, -0.13082647323608398, 0.47667622566223145, 0.8048967719078064, -0.548982560634613, 0.49912887811660767, 0.5514513254165649, -0.45234793424606323, -0.1336856335401535, -0.42665842175483704, -0.043182358145713806, -0.7472773194313049, -0.663520872592926, 0.17597319185733795, -0.014931421726942062, -0.5584399104118347, -0.16522057354450226, -0.05565926432609558, -0.2660825550556183, 0.5597466826438904, 0.3356882631778717, 0.2416067123413086, -0.6450941562652588, 0.3510957658290863, -0.38214439153671265, 0.22336742281913757, 0.21166037023067474, -0.7308083176612854, 0.6947950720787048, 0.1981520652770996, -0.23255538940429688, -0.1269393265247345, -0.4138711392879486, 0.8620774745941162, -0.44265952706336975, 0.5165408253669739, 0.062043920159339905, -0.35803723335266113, -0.8281327486038208, -0.24148857593536377, -0.3708314895629883, -0.3847898244857788, 0.5079233050346375, -0.01862500049173832, -0.7311601638793945, 0.2683395743370056, -0.6844925284385681, -0.11510784924030304, 0.28711971640586853, 0.5056455731391907, 0.167928546667099, 1.008895993232727, 0.7366488575935364, -0.38422778248786926, 0.30518874526023865, -0.07882579416036606, 0.018963199108839035, -0.466210275888443, -0.36273717880249023, -0.7227535843849182, -0.19386613368988037, -0.6495603322982788, -0.3334140181541443, -0.009616246446967125, 0.2756994664669037, -0.33435505628585815, 0.43905073404312134, -0.3918052911758423, 0.256840318441391, 0.5239883065223694, -0.4548557698726654, 0.28590449690818787, 0.12048007547855377, -0.46359410881996155, 0.11819398403167725, -0.7381104826927185, -0.5366975665092468, 1.0778765678405762, 0.4900619685649872, 0.5489810109138489, 0.023497294634580612, 0.5868164896965027, 0.316779226064682, 0.35997623205184937, -0.8821361064910889, 0.6973776817321777, -0.5122160315513611, -0.25469058752059937, -0.3319753110408783, -0.5245062708854675, -1.0283347368240356, 0.1743246465921402, 0.0613236166536808, -1.076528787612915, -0.09992565214633942, 0.05111712962388992, -0.13926051557064056, 0.48202353715896606, -0.4155380129814148, 0.8427138924598694, -0.7369603514671326, -0.02779013104736805, -0.3403410315513611, -0.5840966701507568, 0.5750832557678223, -0.2944181263446808, 0.08233286440372467, -0.5376386642456055, -0.00043527170782908797, 0.9837239384651184, -0.45088839530944824, 0.5778749585151672, 0.1353357881307602, -0.019515132531523705, -0.008130308240652084, 0.4419942796230316, -0.006974271964281797, -0.3858184814453125, -0.40867939591407776, 0.3177861273288727, 0.12612920999526978, -0.10827033966779709, -0.23857584595680237, 0.7693238854408264, -0.7686448097229004, -0.4233058989048004, -0.29745009541511536, -0.642522931098938, -0.47753679752349854, 0.2985006272792816, -0.24897150695323944, 0.13754984736442566, -0.22835874557495117, 0.2868404686450958, 0.43362051248550415, -0.22143901884555817, 0.4027946889400482, 0.3669642210006714, -0.5966823697090149, -0.38605549931526184, 0.9123584032058716, 0.16347892582416534, 0.1987917572259903, 0.3800675868988037, 0.4206410050392151, -0.45357635617256165, -0.9208770990371704, -0.4964105486869812, 0.3719121515750885, -0.5037795901298523, 0.040889766067266464, -0.2684011161327362, -0.16397099196910858, -0.10840548574924469, 0.17695501446723938, 0.03750354051589966, -0.34808605909347534, -0.10562555491924286, -0.08196036517620087, 0.4959995746612549, 0.9440729022026062, 0.11452756077051163, 0.20786501467227936, -0.6941537857055664, -0.06791485100984573, 0.26064202189445496, 0.3581165373325348, 0.19167564809322357, -0.5252888798713684, -0.0032389285042881966, 0.02307184971868992, -0.1483667641878128, -0.8638826608657837, 0.7399442195892334, 0.6356528401374817, 0.7346993088722229, 0.2344338446855545, -0.29658541083335876, 0.5263038873672485, -0.3267678916454315, 0.8321218490600586, 0.03739748150110245, -0.7931177616119385, 0.3705476224422455, -0.2679249346256256, -0.19936317205429077, 0.15699249505996704, 0.5151188373565674, -0.4803621768951416, -0.288056343793869, -0.5154868960380554, -0.7468522787094116, 0.6462728977203369, -0.06569953262805939, -0.20525655150413513, 0.23299764096736908, 0.24247995018959045, 0.1294308453798294, 0.19328849017620087, -0.3512946665287018, -0.18514494597911835, 0.10602246224880219, -0.33090054988861084, -0.4895212948322296, -0.08677570521831512, 0.25847381353378296, -0.46363386511802673, 0.6256956458091736, -0.21031473577022552, -0.29614660143852234, -0.18971429765224457, -0.11630025506019592, -0.46026813983917236, -0.07097971439361572, 0.3683532178401947, 1.0244587659835815, -0.294562965631485, 0.35943689942359924, 0.39401450753211975, -0.37363535165786743, 0.1798379272222519, 0.15102891623973846, 0.20338669419288635, 0.18650095164775848, 0.6057376861572266, 0.5337867140769958, 0.03025783598423004, -0.9884713888168335, 0.02712618187069893, 0.37831681966781616, -0.11364436149597168, -0.0320831760764122, 0.10670474916696548, 0.3817107081413269, 0.19039610028266907, 0.24985939264297485, -0.2879548668861389, -0.10947044938802719, -0.7009769082069397, 0.538526177406311, 0.31533077359199524, -0.2168496698141098, -0.35976165533065796, 0.5167063474655151, 0.14455939829349518, -0.5020256638526917, 0.5388844609260559, 0.14242176711559296, -0.7474105358123779, 1.0391701459884644, 0.47023388743400574, 0.8458109498023987, -0.6832491159439087, 0.13303613662719727, 0.3987775444984436, 0.0052945478819310665, -0.29046279191970825, -0.13656805455684662, 0.30662110447883606, -0.5758259296417236, -0.4360097050666809, -1.0049079656600952, -0.4581005871295929, 0.3581983745098114, -0.161615788936615, 0.25853273272514343, -0.7153964638710022, 0.08653261512517929, 0.3793175220489502, 0.16195571422576904, -0.08226925134658813, -0.027604127302765846, 0.5668718218803406, 1.082053542137146, -0.7672802209854126, 1.009872555732727, 0.5973855257034302, -0.1423560082912445, -1.0391947031021118, 0.022433416917920113, 0.25397276878356934, -0.9694347381591797, 0.8923211097717285, 0.1433372050523758, -0.18296565115451813, 0.15845485031604767, -0.3107423484325409, -0.9004553556442261, 0.9555612802505493, 0.5984665751457214, -0.7632496356964111, 0.14998652040958405, 0.16346733272075653, 0.7282870411872864, -0.5960259437561035, -0.0666913166642189, 0.6390261650085449, 0.2681899666786194, -0.01897195167839527, -1.0549660921096802, -0.11581860482692719, -0.10953894257545471, 0.1435277909040451, 0.3111322522163391, -0.30678874254226685, 1.0533838272094727, -0.14554879069328308, -0.3249019384384155, 0.5185232758522034, 0.2855113446712494, 0.3724874258041382, 0.10705484449863434, 0.3759140372276306, 0.5328126549720764, 0.910294234752655, -0.028065424412488937, 0.9179592132568359, -0.8329306244850159, 0.3088882863521576, 0.951423704624176, -0.491242915391922, 0.9296565055847168, 0.3375346064567566, -0.34332162141799927, 0.5473368167877197, 0.8941008448600769, -0.5946464538574219, 0.22012493014335632, 0.7178857922554016, -0.15978926420211792, -0.07236302644014359, -0.3169424533843994, -0.33159637451171875, 0.31677332520484924, 0.37361395359039307, -0.6833871006965637, -0.10249050706624985, -0.46712276339530945, -0.16199804842472076, 0.16797900199890137, -0.4101858139038086, 0.87128746509552, 0.22216346859931946, -0.7886424660682678, 0.7333923578262329, -0.027757948264479637, 0.35356298089027405, -0.4971647262573242, -0.19248823821544647, -0.19036772847175598, 0.3947494924068451, -0.2547377943992615, -0.803177535533905, -0.03355385363101959, -0.3571593165397644, 0.1539178341627121, 0.07473179697990417, 0.7131924629211426, -0.49074363708496094, -0.4841495454311371, 0.5964565277099609, 0.6830437779426575, 0.3143573999404907, 0.4144096076488495, -0.6479918956756592, -0.03789624944329262, -0.09753239899873734, 0.19572879374027252, 0.18073250353336334, 0.27966776490211487, -0.16974195837974548, 1.0763038396835327, 0.6211186647415161, 0.6034748554229736, 0.11250308156013489, -0.14253629744052887, 0.3214966654777527, -0.26061955094337463, -0.30278411507606506, -1.3713165521621704, -0.2199295461177826, 0.15885595977306366, -0.0685654953122139, 0.9910407066345215, 0.6859881281852722, 0.9665895104408264, -0.09294874221086502, 0.8637852072715759, 0.35593903064727783, 0.4998856484889984, -0.31006115674972534, 0.6472301483154297, -0.40205851197242737, 0.21154148876667023, -0.23284634947776794, -1.1914443969726562, -0.33282193541526794, 0.3945736289024353, -0.4369838833808899, -0.12337210029363632, 0.5469235181808472, 0.7972200512886047, -0.07067576795816422, -0.03386927768588066, 0.18065237998962402, 0.42737844586372375, -0.022127892822027206, 0.6296024918556213, 0.9258983135223389, 0.5101643800735474, 0.38956552743911743, -0.41956672072410583, 0.021663857623934746, -0.44525983929634094, -0.8445562720298767, -0.821566104888916, -0.48647844791412354, -0.13947872817516327, -0.2025667130947113, 0.3390567898750305, 0.9886659383773804, 0.8134152889251709, -0.8522793650627136, -0.9339231848716736, -0.23820260167121887, 0.22731617093086243, -0.30104541778564453, -0.1480528712272644, 0.2760854959487915, 0.007844865322113037, -0.4158870279788971, 0.22323955595493317, 0.30787280201911926, 0.18745599687099457, -0.5299088358879089, -0.4145638346672058, 0.022134831175208092, 0.08346503973007202, 0.4409075379371643, 0.47314298152923584, -0.9453582167625427, -0.21542108058929443, -0.26603591442108154, 0.08997687697410583, 0.19885285198688507, 0.617936909198761, -0.579955518245697, 0.3162839114665985, 0.4076310396194458, 0.5892387628555298, 0.13591723144054413, 0.11707539111375809, 0.8266366124153137, -0.4358556568622589, -0.026297710835933685, 0.3769395351409912, 0.4337872862815857, 0.45877817273139954, 0.12672974169254303, 0.6281918287277222, 0.46366289258003235, -0.42968687415122986, -1.0668798685073853, 0.2216654121875763, -0.7777528166770935, -0.42599478363990784, 1.1756367683410645, -0.33209115266799927, -0.38587743043899536, -0.07231635600328445, -0.10038860887289047, 0.22307954728603363, -0.11934763938188553, 0.7095966339111328, 0.5445888042449951, 0.026870183646678925, -0.3154458999633789, -0.3899775743484497, 0.6754658818244934, 0.18755728006362915, -0.8883768320083618, 0.21108980476856232, 0.3014910817146301, 0.38249653577804565, 0.20397387444972992, -0.05496230721473694, 0.07462776452302933, 0.10557876527309418, -0.2086808979511261, 0.026670590043067932, 0.08745419979095459, -0.20312240719795227, -0.3533269464969635, 0.41245684027671814, 0.7669413089752197, 0.20204271376132965 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04659v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04659v1
Multilingual Pretraining and Instruction Tuning Improve Cross-Lingual Knowledge Alignment, But Only Shallowly
2024-04-06T15:25:06
2024-04-06T15:25:06
Changjiang Gao, Hongda Hu, Peng Hu, Jiajun Chen, Jixing Li, Shujian Huang
cs.CL
cs.CL
Despite their strong ability to retrieve knowledge in English, current large language models show imbalance abilities in different languages. Two approaches are proposed to address this, i.e., multilingual pretraining and multilingual instruction tuning. However, whether and how do such methods contribute to the cross-lingual knowledge alignment inside the models is unknown. In this paper, we propose CLiKA, a systematic framework to assess the cross-lingual knowledge alignment of LLMs in the Performance, Consistency and Conductivity levels, and explored the effect of multilingual pretraining and instruction tuning on the degree of alignment. Results show that: while both multilingual pretraining and instruction tuning are beneficial for cross-lingual knowledge alignment, the training strategy needs to be carefully designed. Namely, continued pretraining improves the alignment of the target language at the cost of other languages, while mixed pretraining affect other languages less. Also, the overall cross-lingual knowledge alignment, especially in the conductivity level, is unsatisfactory for all tested LLMs, and neither multilingual pretraining nor instruction tuning can substantially improve the cross-lingual knowledge conductivity.
[ -0.3778286874294281, -0.46638062596321106, 0.19370143115520477, -0.018340665847063065, -0.40902483463287354, 0.13047567009925842, -0.4539146423339844, -0.6053280234336853, 0.2618466019630432, 0.11636194586753845, -0.6557124257087708, -0.3240216076374054, -0.6499987244606018, 0.011079706251621246, 0.026385284960269928, 0.8423086404800415, -0.048418521881103516, 0.5512621402740479, -0.38455551862716675, -0.3450671434402466, -0.9063800573348999, -0.30095916986465454, -0.2854585647583008, -0.5322607159614563, 0.4506247639656067, 0.7170387506484985, 0.6511368751525879, 0.6512286067008972, 0.20110808312892914, 0.33856722712516785, 0.1443885713815689, 0.380552738904953, -0.4995374083518982, -0.12262669950723648, -0.24445345997810364, -0.7402508854866028, -0.396149605512619, -0.06621767580509186, 0.6272488832473755, 0.5736333727836609, -0.12938161194324493, 0.13388670980930328, 0.31265366077423096, 0.6749487519264221, -0.7145408391952515, -0.26898762583732605, -0.4495077431201935, -0.024495966732501984, -0.3886353373527527, -0.41846373677253723, -0.33464616537094116, -0.2646087408065796, 0.2780636250972748, -0.9738515019416809, -0.15549759566783905, 0.11491306871175766, 1.0271549224853516, 0.38316115736961365, -0.5028788447380066, -0.4865436553955078, -0.3779318630695343, 0.9004221558570862, -0.7488094568252563, 0.7620989084243774, 0.0580609105527401, -0.06712254136800766, 0.20389045774936676, -0.19923949241638184, -0.3105463981628418, 0.09276013821363449, -0.4515007734298706, 0.23255093395709991, 0.24227194488048553, -0.12086446583271027, 0.07795447111129761, -0.03339700400829315, -0.593293309211731, 0.5268039107322693, -0.3509522080421448, -0.3684997856616974, 0.4859897196292877, -0.10737773776054382, 0.6407670378684998, 0.30867886543273926, -0.5317737460136414, 0.07488609850406647, -0.892465353012085, 0.166988343000412, 0.7490931153297424, 0.11681083589792252, -0.4024314880371094, 0.3285781145095825, 0.06971310079097748, 1.156748652458191, 0.28908848762512207, -0.6461856365203857, 0.27082282304763794, -0.6089892983436584, 0.1579662561416626, 0.5454104542732239, 0.42268192768096924, 0.3994603455066681, 0.7583948373794556, -0.1934087574481964, 0.2776382565498352, -0.020253991708159447, 0.20139417052268982, -0.6601405143737793, 0.018780097365379333, -0.060723014175891876, -0.26991114020347595, 0.15861457586288452, -0.0976317748427391, -0.6812189221382141, -0.1396140456199646, -0.9210281372070312, 0.43298062682151794, -0.4974615275859833, -0.5370699167251587, 0.11322899907827377, 0.04022035375237465, 0.5193541049957275, -0.03211907297372818, -1.1762982606887817, 0.02030622400343418, 0.8289230465888977, 0.4804495871067047, -0.3034641146659851, -0.8222466111183167, -0.11327176541090012, 0.23648276925086975, -0.2835446000099182, 0.6104635000228882, -0.5819225907325745, -0.018954791128635406, 0.12334689497947693, 0.0009029849315993488, -0.4868745505809784, -0.4825778901576996, 0.007258266676217318, -0.43038806319236755, 0.2084549069404602, -0.534396767616272, -0.6067463159561157, -0.059859804809093475, 0.23110376298427582, -0.518604040145874, 0.6998063921928406, -0.3373180031776428, -0.9205417633056641, 0.7130821943283081, -0.32919934391975403, -0.7075440883636475, -0.4390422999858856, -0.09001630544662476, -0.3780348300933838, -0.15248262882232666, 0.32407626509666443, 0.3041555881500244, 0.0010009605903178453, 0.19152089953422546, -0.15344801545143127, -0.5524907112121582, 0.13306568562984467, -0.018632175400853157, 0.7389931082725525, -0.06287435442209244, -0.4760461747646332, 0.17114414274692535, -0.8023989796638489, 0.15708006918430328, -0.2326509654521942, -0.19013455510139465, -0.5626819729804993, -0.2966369688510895, -0.5915487408638, 0.26072004437446594, 0.5282539129257202, -0.3750021755695343, 0.03216102719306946, -0.5441309809684753, 0.18527831137180328, 0.8620545268058777, -0.2574498951435089, 0.833607017993927, -0.3170631229877472, 0.7509019374847412, 0.38743358850479126, 0.16873638331890106, -0.12549814581871033, -0.3304157257080078, -1.0767074823379517, -0.13881517946720123, 0.5233081579208374, 0.7947006225585938, -0.4963279962539673, 0.2407841831445694, -0.29350560903549194, -0.5128726959228516, -0.982796847820282, 0.4365452527999878, 0.9305372834205627, 0.6295784711837769, 0.24439474940299988, -0.14632189273834229, -0.763839840888977, -0.8846188187599182, -0.5082747936248779, 0.4341464340686798, 0.5332241654396057, 0.08370371907949448, 0.25463640689849854, -0.05361083149909973, 0.5745519995689392, -0.04250456392765045, -0.09412278234958649, -0.016727659851312637, -0.03682368993759155, 0.0635601058602333, 0.5595408082008362, 0.5212162137031555, -0.45502832531929016, -0.8489158153533936, 0.5119066834449768, -0.6431451439857483, -0.052784278988838196, 0.15099003911018372, -0.44558921456336975, 0.5086657404899597, 0.36401692032814026, -0.4575401544570923, 0.09670519083738327, 0.6550099849700928, -0.04790973290801048, 0.479656457901001, -0.13352251052856445, 0.24045586585998535, -1.028950572013855, 0.04656601324677467, -0.3739771544933319, -0.11146136373281479, -0.6599469780921936, -0.04863474518060684, 0.3223062753677368, -0.019500358030200005, -0.5593051910400391, 0.5772474408149719, -0.7923288941383362, -0.20684336125850677, -0.10742121189832687, 0.42039060592651367, 0.005229969974607229, 0.38258302211761475, 0.2064569890499115, 0.8914305567741394, 0.6011435985565186, -0.9061687588691711, 0.11363254487514496, 0.04473324120044708, -0.6097386479377747, 0.8079229593276978, -0.39645516872406006, 0.26893869042396545, -0.10506557673215866, -0.21054191887378693, -0.7516055703163147, 0.11871544271707535, -0.13584306836128235, -0.41653525829315186, 0.7125104665756226, -0.0175747312605381, -0.10264626890420914, 0.13034826517105103, -0.04279399290680885, 0.553775429725647, 0.26283398270606995, -0.7002280354499817, 0.764610767364502, 0.26661258935928345, 0.13180817663669586, -1.3091435432434082, -0.510578989982605, -0.6111876368522644, -0.5178200602531433, -0.9802567362785339, 0.34147846698760986, -0.18544526398181915, -0.1079571321606636, -0.12099544703960419, -0.24246840178966522, 0.14850977063179016, 0.1951514631509781, -0.15480688214302063, 0.13023242354393005, -0.3452405631542206, 0.02814171090722084, 0.11864174157381058, -0.2510680556297302, -0.07831354439258575, -0.4488116204738617, 0.6895395517349243, 0.06502246111631393, -0.37815091013908386, -0.48507028818130493, 0.1550721973180771, 0.25104427337646484, -0.4589977264404297, 0.8027088046073914, 0.7800220251083374, 0.018926745280623436, -0.21641618013381958, -0.6249809265136719, -0.01519263070076704, -0.4611583352088928, 0.1772088259458542, -0.5236520171165466, -0.8866010904312134, 0.5770132541656494, -0.15159493684768677, 0.08639661222696304, 0.01278868317604065, 0.6106376647949219, -0.11584804207086563, 0.7958481907844543, 0.834936261177063, -0.1655268371105194, 0.3618355393409729, 0.14089590311050415, 0.3707957863807678, -0.6524984836578369, -0.22420376539230347, -0.4879147410392761, -0.6746557950973511, -0.5590342283248901, 0.13016587495803833, 0.2936945855617523, 0.2125445455312729, -0.35992592573165894, 0.15475764870643616, -0.24930819869041443, 0.5743656754493713, 0.634659469127655, 0.06697389483451843, 0.16527503728866577, -0.025788910686969757, -0.4273788630962372, -0.2918787896633148, -0.9238427877426147, -0.16418315470218658, 1.1904170513153076, 0.0901004895567894, 0.727546751499176, 0.25822585821151733, 0.8163214921951294, -0.34608936309814453, 0.18512576818466187, -0.4207109212875366, 0.16024987399578094, -0.08952553570270538, -0.5998280048370361, -0.27891165018081665, -0.2665822207927704, -1.0247395038604736, 0.29728183150291443, -0.2544384300708771, -0.5479844212532043, 0.07120265811681747, 0.43443241715431213, -0.09180895239114761, 0.017261536791920662, -0.89378422498703, 1.1108973026275635, -0.7480199337005615, -0.38024821877479553, -0.2750864326953888, -0.714763343334198, 0.49577832221984863, -0.21551582217216492, 0.5705028772354126, 0.1547492891550064, -0.012559911236166954, 0.7058872580528259, -0.326861709356308, 0.954633355140686, -0.24232347309589386, -0.4039556086063385, -0.06276561319828033, -0.27968889474868774, 0.4229874312877655, -0.1387910097837448, 0.15567398071289062, 0.2599157989025116, 0.10457425564527512, -0.44357386231422424, -0.5247058868408203, 0.7589200735092163, -1.1758551597595215, -0.6508992314338684, -0.04301997646689415, -0.7169144749641418, -0.48689472675323486, 0.4645397663116455, 0.5961636900901794, 0.0011394037865102291, -0.11070464551448822, -0.14382943511009216, 0.9651642441749573, -0.16312509775161743, 0.20351840555667877, 0.9311624765396118, -0.17493502795696259, -0.49200382828712463, 0.9077454209327698, 0.2966687083244324, 0.5823782682418823, 0.6217904090881348, 0.09125547856092453, -0.2381049394607544, -0.2989582121372223, -0.4408504366874695, 0.40310755372047424, -0.8234961032867432, -0.12265709787607193, -0.21059778332710266, 0.14312458038330078, -0.6580520868301392, -0.25832298398017883, -0.38508912920951843, -0.11655882000923157, -0.25457924604415894, -0.20138192176818848, 0.0007319414289668202, 0.4259207248687744, -0.10260701179504395, 0.44022274017333984, -0.6517168283462524, -0.046437107026576996, 0.09514729678630829, 0.3906797468662262, -0.02979131042957306, -0.5410765409469604, -0.6008180379867554, 0.1794147491455078, -0.10867683589458466, -0.6187326312065125, -0.0134122958406806, 0.2812652885913849, 0.7395928502082825, 0.39150023460388184, -0.29797351360321045, 1.2421706914901733, -0.6656507253646851, 0.4839015603065491, 0.38566726446151733, -1.1267385482788086, 0.3777579963207245, 0.1356346160173416, 0.3718162477016449, 0.5363056659698486, 0.7213607430458069, -0.3252932131290436, 0.007449126336723566, -0.30075180530548096, -0.5217822790145874, 0.7245091795921326, -0.49620321393013, -0.060787688940763474, 0.37122881412506104, 0.12063112109899521, 0.329012393951416, 0.14848391711711884, -0.7555812001228333, -0.2950143814086914, -0.25536221265792847, -0.3818873465061188, -0.22443681955337524, -0.26240044832229614, -0.3573867380619049, -0.2625489830970764, 0.9206855297088623, -0.023630624637007713, -0.17404188215732574, -0.12701240181922913, -0.46367430686950684, -0.21524375677108765, 0.27160316705703735, 0.9370021224021912, 1.1770150661468506, 0.26821720600128174, -0.10903353244066238, 0.2812826335430145, -0.27744755148887634, 0.2664808928966522, -0.16261595487594604, -0.26240867376327515, -0.07697814702987671, 0.5853979587554932, 0.9083288908004761, 0.6316997408866882, -0.5121110677719116, 0.3973742723464966, 0.0755605697631836, -0.22837816178798676, -0.33808600902557373, 0.08101940155029297, 0.38733533024787903, 0.11010850220918655, -0.32957565784454346, -0.254355251789093, -0.41219064593315125, -0.4041535556316376, 0.024224812164902687, 0.6221671104431152, -0.02340143546462059, -0.22392377257347107, 0.33164748549461365, 0.1808432787656784, -0.0867278054356575, 0.5393927693367004, 0.2564548850059509, -0.4582306742668152, 0.4278460144996643, 0.7769428491592407, 0.22152045369148254, -0.6855695843696594, -0.1565953493118286, 0.4325464963912964, 0.662901759147644, 0.2002480924129486, 0.42382553219795227, -0.17754335701465607, -0.948525071144104, -0.5792626142501831, -0.5490771532058716, -0.204295352101326, -0.10851078480482101, -0.8274703025817871, 0.5513718128204346, -0.19113297760486603, 0.1468181610107422, -0.20869207382202148, -0.004145040642470121, -0.8080511093139648, 0.18519379198551178, 0.055280257016420364, 0.7604861259460449, -0.8414779305458069, 0.9603593349456787, 0.7884889841079712, -0.14501556754112244, -1.039831280708313, -0.2242617905139923, -0.09046132862567902, -1.052229404449463, 0.6489927768707275, 0.24958066642284393, -0.20826581120491028, 0.07339628785848618, -0.16033929586410522, -1.316550374031067, 1.1943062543869019, 0.5968831181526184, -0.8999191522598267, 0.022060774266719818, 0.5016915202140808, 0.3238012492656708, -0.34674930572509766, 0.0830971747636795, 0.6105553507804871, 0.6717389822006226, -0.3210434317588806, -1.2123024463653564, -0.21195577085018158, -0.15716652572155, -0.3185481131076813, 0.37656399607658386, -0.6851562261581421, 0.601786196231842, 0.016877932474017143, -0.20313569903373718, -0.05485757067799568, 0.6630740761756897, 0.2653101086616516, 0.2283240109682083, 0.36763250827789307, 1.010080099105835, 1.0035858154296875, -0.06133070960640907, 0.6114967465400696, -0.8135362267494202, -0.03266783058643341, 1.090077519416809, -0.2753952443599701, 0.5197101831436157, 0.5592634677886963, 0.074849434196949, 0.5943472385406494, 0.5961897373199463, 0.2645576298236847, 0.5838924050331116, 0.11008954048156738, 0.1750517338514328, -0.3145720064640045, 0.126989483833313, -0.6553376317024231, 0.4465736448764801, 0.3034866452217102, -0.14077657461166382, -0.028130531311035156, 0.22173970937728882, 0.3418188989162445, 0.0985623225569725, -0.47069650888442993, 0.8180397748947144, 0.11267140507698059, -1.2476420402526855, 0.9356638193130493, -0.2025947868824005, 0.9178074598312378, -0.751430094242096, 0.19960267841815948, -0.19192470610141754, 0.2874875068664551, -0.46724507212638855, -0.4463912546634674, 0.24344134330749512, -0.20381683111190796, -0.17031307518482208, -0.14147652685642242, 0.7247726917266846, -0.7115365266799927, -0.15207292139530182, 0.5898952484130859, 0.37246716022491455, 0.1069951131939888, 0.6107009053230286, -0.6658974289894104, 0.1294948160648346, 0.08965456485748291, 0.08008071780204773, 0.6703145503997803, 0.48671668767929077, 0.19995373487472534, 0.42458203434944153, 0.5286524295806885, 0.07098875939846039, 0.45952486991882324, 0.1637018471956253, 0.4936266541481018, -0.33093512058258057, -0.4714493751525879, -0.8583793044090271, 0.6901467442512512, 0.11827211827039719, -0.49417126178741455, 0.8924868106842041, 0.41382846236228943, 1.3122907876968384, -0.11000044643878937, 0.5473728775978088, 0.23252291977405548, 0.4637054204940796, -1.0308423042297363, 0.4572359621524811, -0.7362719178199768, 0.13932552933692932, 0.022719362750649452, -0.7822816371917725, 0.14427196979522705, 0.4159165024757385, -0.3185434937477112, 0.0341445691883564, 0.757456362247467, 0.7321310043334961, -0.24400824308395386, -0.1199842020869255, 0.3233715295791626, 0.09402455389499664, -0.136760413646698, 0.5868882536888123, 0.6957908272743225, -0.10306781530380249, 0.5311597585678101, -0.3701879680156708, -0.1778239905834198, 0.06679777055978775, -0.9358235001564026, -1.1179789304733276, -0.4106980264186859, -0.08073251694440842, -0.11447738111019135, 0.2595151364803314, 0.42874112725257874, 0.7231934070587158, -0.6426170468330383, -0.4720517694950104, 0.15598544478416443, 0.15425541996955872, -0.39409539103507996, -0.12479539960622787, 0.19776317477226257, -0.8534510135650635, -0.6816420555114746, 0.44659385085105896, -0.006965836975723505, -0.23603114485740662, -0.3361910879611969, -0.304760217666626, -0.43557101488113403, -0.14810431003570557, 0.3100247383117676, 0.19306334853172302, -0.6658567190170288, -0.06282781809568405, 0.18320584297180176, -0.000053635183576261625, 0.11960937827825546, 0.7294886112213135, -0.32319486141204834, 0.44390201568603516, 0.4018096625804901, 0.7213325500488281, 0.4028816819190979, -0.003769806120544672, 0.7402055859565735, -0.9111828804016113, 0.2592643201351166, -0.20936070382595062, 0.5281261801719666, 0.26841700077056885, -0.4116462469100952, 0.2619033455848694, 0.03624458238482475, -0.6708937287330627, -0.4845550060272217, 0.3423616886138916, -0.6871775984764099, -0.28318679332733154, 0.9759193062782288, -0.26065593957901, -0.252238929271698, -0.01870088465511799, 0.10676515847444534, 0.406973659992218, 0.1258515864610672, 0.5497264862060547, 1.135372519493103, 0.04920397326350212, -0.21030154824256897, -0.3823606073856354, 0.5336192846298218, 0.9521612524986267, -0.6183769106864929, -0.17835865914821625, 0.1635926216840744, 0.5257466435432434, 0.3013683557510376, 0.5036506652832031, -0.04297585040330887, 0.32374462485313416, -0.4822239875793457, 0.07333803176879883, 0.08891282975673676, -0.4775790274143219, -0.2334136962890625, -0.21778467297554016, 0.10461889207363129, -0.027543948963284492 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04656v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04656v1
Binary Classifier Optimization for Large Language Model Alignment
2024-04-06T15:20:59
2024-04-06T15:20:59
Seungjae Jung, Gunsoo Han, Daniel Wontae Nam, Kyoung-Woon On
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
Aligning Large Language Models (LLMs) to human preferences through preference optimization has been crucial but labor-intensive, necessitating for each prompt a comparison of both a chosen and a rejected text completion by evaluators. Recently, Kahneman-Tversky Optimization (KTO) has demonstrated that LLMs can be aligned using merely binary "thumbs-up" or "thumbs-down" signals on each prompt-completion pair. In this paper, we present theoretical foundations to explain the successful alignment achieved through these binary signals. Our analysis uncovers a new perspective: optimizing a binary classifier, whose logit is a reward, implicitly induces minimizing the Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) loss. In the process of this discovery, we identified two techniques for effective alignment: reward shift and underlying distribution matching. Consequently, we propose a new algorithm, \textit{Binary Classifier Optimization}, that integrates the techniques. We validate our methodology in two settings: first, on a paired preference dataset, where our method performs on par with DPO and KTO; and second, on binary signal datasets simulating real-world conditions with divergent underlying distributions between thumbs-up and thumbs-down data. Our model consistently demonstrates effective and robust alignment across two base LLMs and three different binary signal datasets, showcasing the strength of our approach to learning from binary feedback.
[ -0.33610227704048157, -0.32043102383613586, 0.7580007910728455, 0.010513906367123127, -0.5142276883125305, 0.19279669225215912, -0.43572911620140076, -0.23418354988098145, 0.048272643238306046, 0.38447830080986023, -0.5951091647148132, -0.41868361830711365, -0.6309295296669006, -0.08797894418239594, -0.06837552040815353, 1.0339107513427734, 0.06880053132772446, 0.08611153066158295, -0.23128832876682281, -0.022113721817731857, -0.6228812336921692, -0.3678233027458191, -0.5964280962944031, -0.4801639914512634, 0.6708806753158569, 0.6025521159172058, 0.8661128878593445, 0.8615899682044983, 0.49605026841163635, 0.2059316337108612, -0.11448054015636444, -0.1156376376748085, -0.5936774611473083, 0.12003099918365479, 0.03883587568998337, -0.5175738334655762, -0.08229061216115952, -0.25651946663856506, 0.7089201211929321, 0.6689531207084656, -0.08346405625343323, 0.05831272900104523, -0.040812741965055466, 0.8728556036949158, -0.5779304504394531, -0.04440038278698921, -0.6142001748085022, -0.005609073676168919, -0.07370831817388535, -0.2673403024673462, -0.5054762959480286, -0.799859881401062, 0.13568434119224548, -0.26712486147880554, -0.0741666629910469, 0.003205226268619299, 0.7089168429374695, 0.5150666236877441, -0.5979568362236023, -0.21932461857795715, -0.6839596629142761, 0.9435696601867676, -0.6517048478126526, 0.5065453052520752, -0.06755875796079636, 0.11476916074752808, -0.15206976234912872, 0.26220381259918213, -0.5525633096694946, -0.20689739286899567, -0.01613287627696991, -0.04658748582005501, 0.010793260298669338, -0.04968132823705673, 0.0053102970123291016, 0.11218105256557465, -0.5729967355728149, 0.5389642119407654, -0.19761373102664948, -0.17889492213726044, 0.5604560375213623, 0.024633467197418213, 0.008609501644968987, -0.08045768737792969, -0.4460501968860626, -0.35295167565345764, -0.567736029624939, 0.3083268702030182, 0.643467128276825, 0.45996418595314026, 0.04698437824845314, 0.6393636465072632, 0.04732988402247429, 0.6920654773712158, 0.5945355296134949, -0.21517713367938995, 0.32446685433387756, -0.19425851106643677, 0.16763362288475037, 0.5782446265220642, 0.7232189774513245, 0.5779836177825928, 0.17453141510486603, -0.13978813588619232, -0.3299289345741272, 0.364277720451355, 0.30085813999176025, -0.6599112153053284, -0.01194276288151741, 0.4725959897041321, -0.42855915427207947, -0.8526941537857056, -0.1770440936088562, -0.5308293700218201, -0.48655253648757935, -0.7394049167633057, 0.49369165301322937, -0.15362952649593353, -0.3814904987812042, 0.2703752815723419, -0.018679380416870117, 0.4433571994304657, 0.10578256100416183, -1.342557430267334, 0.10207100957632065, 1.2468796968460083, 0.6144043207168579, -0.27556201815605164, 0.10587102174758911, -0.6375560760498047, 0.0019972436130046844, -0.4074804186820984, 0.6289677023887634, -0.5958083868026733, -0.03934033215045929, -0.08326812833547592, -0.3105708360671997, 0.20067906379699707, -0.3773898184299469, 0.6820569038391113, -0.7248169183731079, 0.23656658828258514, -0.32144683599472046, -0.7224254608154297, 0.0016909941332414746, 0.09121786803007126, -0.525831937789917, 1.0964572429656982, -0.07424810528755188, -0.8244122862815857, 0.5662998557090759, -0.40559065341949463, -0.2871316373348236, -0.11856185644865036, -0.18282414972782135, -0.5113586783409119, 0.3003915250301361, -0.018251553177833557, 0.5050192475318909, -0.19361229240894318, 0.4644182324409485, -0.4516623020172119, -0.4705745577812195, 0.40623992681503296, -0.09321241080760956, 0.7500289082527161, 0.01580430008471012, -0.5585043430328369, 0.31091558933258057, -0.490808367729187, -0.024619508534669876, 0.056908391416072845, -0.29214903712272644, -0.4448268711566925, 0.3111579120159149, -0.0019845040515065193, 0.13372105360031128, 0.4320891797542572, -0.5968939065933228, 0.46992361545562744, -0.38083916902542114, 0.32413992285728455, 1.2709003686904907, -0.3975869417190552, 0.5692472457885742, -0.1446344554424286, 0.36618396639823914, -0.042948704212903976, 0.3269904553890228, 0.4318588376045227, -0.11280067265033722, -0.5634939074516296, -0.298982709646225, 0.5938616394996643, 0.43607985973358154, -0.18172192573547363, 0.9364002346992493, -0.581572949886322, -0.32414114475250244, -0.6868799924850464, 0.1199565902352333, 0.25420019030570984, 0.4891575574874878, -0.05261676385998726, -0.3057951331138611, -0.30078715085983276, -1.0729193687438965, 0.28264281153678894, -0.15208664536476135, 0.18486061692237854, 0.13009639084339142, 0.06773147732019424, -0.2511434257030487, 0.8808255791664124, -0.5028733015060425, 0.16154640913009644, -0.07101079821586609, -0.1770796924829483, 0.5448420643806458, 0.33221617341041565, 0.5564572215080261, -0.9379564523696899, -0.5633702874183655, 0.24422599375247955, -0.36087149381637573, -0.23141644895076752, -0.04859161749482155, -0.4453906714916229, 0.4282541275024414, 0.2236970067024231, -0.34870946407318115, -0.11555518954992294, 0.7612003087997437, -0.1290590465068817, 0.6944148540496826, 0.1332618147134781, 0.0766310915350914, -1.0771030187606812, 0.025671876966953278, -0.14992862939834595, -0.32714495062828064, -0.5253231525421143, -0.2549251914024353, 0.24242042005062103, 0.05954694747924805, -0.10185062885284424, 0.43547049164772034, -0.25170230865478516, -0.11321530491113663, -0.4385550022125244, 0.23972544074058533, -0.35096731781959534, 0.5867612957954407, 0.24896517395973206, 0.4600670337677002, 0.6351979374885559, -0.5376287698745728, 0.4378678798675537, 0.35324737429618835, -0.25177431106567383, 0.723804235458374, -0.5244720578193665, 0.28403472900390625, -0.27008575201034546, 0.030059559270739555, -1.251637578010559, -0.051324471831321716, 0.4599139392375946, -0.4590606689453125, 0.4625328481197357, -0.17565762996673584, -0.41625362634658813, -0.046562813222408295, -0.5184341669082642, 0.5586928129196167, 0.7070752382278442, -0.8569853901863098, 0.34720656275749207, 0.26880812644958496, -0.20573025941848755, -1.0034127235412598, -0.16879577934741974, -0.21528136730194092, -0.40085771679878235, -0.46968984603881836, 0.2576367259025574, -0.027597783133387566, -0.05004769563674927, 0.04403189197182655, -0.35773321986198425, 0.41832104325294495, 0.10855593532323837, 0.016779201105237007, 0.6907278895378113, -0.11979751288890839, 0.30687904357910156, 0.10201362520456314, -0.42759883403778076, -0.033224500715732574, -0.46293315291404724, 0.727971613407135, 0.02817421592772007, -0.2982591390609741, -0.3092699944972992, 0.2732675075531006, 0.25997844338417053, 0.04571133852005005, 0.4870735704898834, 0.4292948842048645, 0.01216296199709177, 0.0944489911198616, -0.6703467965126038, -0.16656124591827393, -0.5043420195579529, 0.30621567368507385, -0.23179656267166138, -0.8871239423751831, 0.07044591009616852, 0.09391890466213226, 0.23675940930843353, 0.15707437694072723, 0.6587457060813904, -0.0578906387090683, 1.270073652267456, 0.6602221131324768, -0.43634033203125, 0.6123224496841431, 0.3318634331226349, 0.36387568712234497, -0.7616578340530396, -0.01990247517824173, -0.5702553391456604, -0.6012598872184753, -0.8604339361190796, -0.16061283648014069, 0.2038550078868866, 0.024041777476668358, -0.32613399624824524, 0.42020371556282043, -0.7861278057098389, 0.4893832802772522, 0.7692909836769104, 0.16239170730113983, 0.12506671249866486, 0.056749746203422546, -0.13112902641296387, -0.026053933426737785, -0.5893775820732117, -0.6288368701934814, 1.12138831615448, 0.27583616971969604, 0.8005018830299377, 0.1952500194311142, 1.0459338426589966, 0.13872739672660828, 0.19457127153873444, -1.0979105234146118, 0.5063445568084717, -0.1351011097431183, -0.5165339708328247, -0.3628426492214203, -0.6057063341140747, -0.9515756964683533, 0.057038988918066025, -0.3120748698711395, -0.7347216010093689, 0.1759936362504959, 0.34533870220184326, -0.106510229408741, 0.052950795739889145, -0.6968563795089722, 0.9501088261604309, -0.7099582552909851, -0.29139062762260437, -0.22655482590198517, -0.869647204875946, 0.22998572885990143, -0.21486859023571014, 0.046223774552345276, -0.23652267456054688, -0.14797614514827728, 0.430261492729187, 0.008812529034912586, 0.827852189540863, -0.14933809638023376, -0.312284380197525, -0.30787649750709534, -0.014431001618504524, 0.5239160060882568, -0.3321424722671509, -0.0017534780781716108, 0.034524936228990555, 0.11622137576341629, -0.5319899320602417, -0.6057201027870178, 0.5874128937721252, -0.890163242816925, -0.4617956578731537, -0.39183974266052246, -0.313421368598938, -0.2889327108860016, 0.21498499810695648, 0.00165345030836761, 0.2627527117729187, -0.017758099362254143, 0.14619168639183044, 0.7583262324333191, -0.09576515853404999, 0.15153951942920685, 0.2664288878440857, -0.3051370084285736, -0.4772469997406006, 0.9990595579147339, -0.44030770659446716, 0.46116703748703003, 0.7450069785118103, 0.501837968826294, -0.6342456936836243, -0.5936552882194519, -0.4269882142543793, 0.4119091331958771, -0.7874780893325806, -0.1007533073425293, -0.18780678510665894, 0.1977321058511734, -0.3964121639728546, -0.423502117395401, -0.2650274336338043, -0.3249414265155792, -0.008880606852471828, -0.05647068843245506, 0.17651750147342682, 0.4482153356075287, -0.06341567635536194, 0.1933785080909729, -0.7596777677536011, 0.08317333459854126, 0.18614192306995392, 0.49983978271484375, 0.010006353259086609, -0.3242514431476593, -0.12251565605401993, 0.062223877757787704, -0.16786837577819824, -0.663163959980011, 0.007913729175925255, -0.22926196455955505, 0.5061979293823242, 0.5402467846870422, 0.05327732488512993, 0.31809520721435547, -0.3920459449291229, 0.2960124909877777, 0.5086398124694824, -0.9599494338035583, 0.4298136830329895, -0.3044474124908447, 0.057499174028635025, 0.6858978271484375, 0.652908444404602, -0.7986069321632385, -0.10577414184808731, -0.39152413606643677, -0.6916959881782532, 0.6754878759384155, 0.06747746467590332, 0.12262945622205734, 0.07755955308675766, 0.4106111228466034, 0.4846210777759552, 0.3430256247520447, -0.8228934407234192, -0.25697535276412964, 0.12578506767749786, -0.720163881778717, -0.26426151394844055, -0.3448505699634552, -0.2346729040145874, 0.006730448454618454, 0.8214410543441772, -0.20151585340499878, 0.36024755239486694, -0.3075103759765625, 0.00048492272617295384, -0.1429627537727356, 0.26197558641433716, 0.5360057353973389, 0.39486321806907654, -0.31898924708366394, -0.003940563183277845, -0.3264394998550415, -0.2546963393688202, 0.4579073190689087, 0.06071595475077629, -0.38243111968040466, -0.17582395672798157, 0.05349604785442352, 1.0355255603790283, 0.34491997957229614, -0.5680632591247559, 0.47191691398620605, 0.0035379647742956877, -0.18367983400821686, -0.13694176077842712, 0.09725534170866013, 0.20654019713401794, 0.3410543203353882, 0.25397151708602905, -0.08418450504541397, 0.08183416724205017, -0.3916611075401306, -0.05022421106696129, 0.7728317975997925, -0.32956448197364807, -0.2114642858505249, 0.47713541984558105, 0.2340872883796692, -0.3744373321533203, 0.5256575345993042, -0.008299463428556919, -0.7061766982078552, 0.3837204873561859, 0.30257168412208557, 0.9262718558311462, 0.02352549508213997, 0.29785940051078796, 0.29418838024139404, 0.004989508539438248, -0.2443777173757553, -0.009080070070922375, -0.36450013518333435, -1.1174204349517822, -0.48713207244873047, -0.6769049167633057, -0.6228901147842407, -0.35141345858573914, -0.7410431504249573, 0.6007817387580872, -0.17158664762973785, -0.10299091041088104, 0.42428159713745117, 0.08311192691326141, -0.5108333826065063, -0.010156509466469288, 0.4456057846546173, 0.34807413816452026, -0.8630927801132202, 0.5821659564971924, 0.5311067700386047, -0.03489413857460022, -0.7796279788017273, -0.013633936643600464, 0.012441880069673061, -1.1213427782058716, 0.657089352607727, 0.3868747353553772, -0.20772314071655273, 0.1099807471036911, -0.45206406712532043, -0.8889455199241638, 0.7138762474060059, 0.3558751940727234, -0.8858737945556641, 0.12328509241342545, 0.14741754531860352, 0.35363882780075073, -0.2767835259437561, 0.0700342208147049, 0.6030170917510986, 0.5452801585197449, 0.1980660855770111, -0.8822764158248901, 0.1529356688261032, 0.0546875074505806, -0.062169622629880905, 0.9088777899742126, -0.6274388432502747, 0.09088512510061264, -0.1757984608411789, -0.018047979101538658, -0.16094759106636047, 0.1742379516363144, 0.36050257086753845, 0.03158332034945488, 0.9401442408561707, 0.4982680380344391, 0.7338102459907532, -0.1510867029428482, 0.8916521072387695, -0.06187755614519119, 0.3865199685096741, 0.8780180811882019, -0.42211732268333435, 0.9064722657203674, 0.7718164920806885, -0.24555692076683044, 0.364031046628952, 0.9681680202484131, 0.011073905043303967, 0.7317648530006409, 0.1359342485666275, -0.22549797594547272, -0.4532802402973175, 0.02351093664765358, -0.17525836825370789, 0.40498700737953186, -0.1258414387702942, -0.23857009410858154, 0.1574728637933731, -0.2694397270679474, -0.23188385367393494, -0.16064859926700592, -0.14402619004249573, 1.0041089057922363, -0.2527419626712799, -0.8774248361587524, 0.6280550360679626, -0.21864470839500427, 0.8113030195236206, -0.46831971406936646, 0.30497416853904724, -0.10888444632291794, 0.28859734535217285, -0.139310821890831, -0.7146000266075134, 0.019054168835282326, -0.19289858639240265, -0.3111741542816162, -0.20191626250743866, 0.41500723361968994, -0.48768651485443115, -0.5223254561424255, 0.20111685991287231, 0.03134089708328247, 0.12297529727220535, 0.1351349651813507, -0.6307690143585205, 0.2795950174331665, 0.25355347990989685, -0.14661718904972076, 0.48735401034355164, 0.34289100766181946, -0.0055493880063295364, 0.4765167236328125, 0.6162440776824951, 0.09347878396511078, -0.15238294005393982, 0.07303968071937561, 0.6785786747932434, -0.7737898230552673, -0.45001420378685, -1.0371910333633423, 0.34488093852996826, -0.11790481209754944, -0.04066867008805275, 0.2876979112625122, 0.7147001028060913, 0.8934350609779358, -0.10093850642442703, 0.7430680990219116, -0.06271778792142868, 0.38050225377082825, -0.6314746141433716, 0.10670148581266403, -0.5108734369277954, 0.12683145701885223, -0.3128833472728729, -1.2984250783920288, -0.10244211554527283, 0.6212884187698364, -0.39915555715560913, -0.13417179882526398, 0.6047986745834351, 0.8661743402481079, -0.022909387946128845, -0.15059582889080048, 0.09192286431789398, -0.13173851370811462, 0.20382773876190186, 0.706011176109314, 0.8947897553443909, -0.08877238631248474, 0.5764055252075195, -0.41781747341156006, -0.4874994456768036, -0.4693656861782074, -1.2162528038024902, -0.7154631018638611, -0.5281895399093628, -0.4941733181476593, -0.18798543512821198, -0.03120015375316143, 1.2809985876083374, 0.6122032999992371, -0.7004048228263855, -0.2820189297199249, 0.06314938515424728, 0.262043297290802, -0.3304567039012909, -0.21469266712665558, 0.36748236417770386, -0.39467304944992065, -0.8268138766288757, -0.13604575395584106, 0.23199492692947388, -0.00198379997164011, -0.17423328757286072, -0.1267692595720291, 0.05261645093560219, -0.14832168817520142, 0.4467613101005554, 0.04928724467754364, -0.7052357196807861, -0.6121219992637634, 0.1684548705816269, -0.10843589901924133, 0.26691731810569763, 0.7913529276847839, -0.38460424542427063, 0.379508376121521, 0.418067991733551, 0.8458176255226135, 0.34811878204345703, 0.23703362047672272, 0.6994789242744446, -0.6718171834945679, -0.08515806496143341, 0.2664230465888977, 0.08742109686136246, 0.4572819471359253, -0.4998345971107483, 0.3989914655685425, -0.07197286933660507, -0.7695309519767761, -0.9287417531013489, 0.2524189352989197, -1.3430004119873047, -0.13321897387504578, 1.2091312408447266, 0.5048261284828186, -0.20254310965538025, 0.20572343468666077, -0.5103369951248169, 0.07392057031393051, -0.5885272026062012, 1.1069520711898804, 0.9579683542251587, -0.19381482899188995, -0.11698094755411148, -0.16507703065872192, 0.4133681356906891, 0.6954907178878784, -0.3988315165042877, 0.1986364871263504, 0.6640514135360718, 0.3957604169845581, 0.10903648287057877, 0.5163479447364807, 0.08272635191679001, 0.28353047370910645, -0.40842676162719727, 0.2991618514060974, 0.24768613278865814, 0.10262078791856766, -0.6353002786636353, -0.1611824333667755, 0.3522774875164032, -0.36063152551651 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08676v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08676v3
ALERT: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Assessing Large Language Models' Safety through Red Teaming
2024-04-06T15:01:47
2024-06-24T08:50:22
Simone Tedeschi, Felix Friedrich, Patrick Schramowski, Kristian Kersting, Roberto Navigli, Huu Nguyen, Bo Li
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, I.2
When building Large Language Models (LLMs), it is paramount to bear safety in mind and protect them with guardrails. Indeed, LLMs should never generate content promoting or normalizing harmful, illegal, or unethical behavior that may contribute to harm to individuals or society. This principle applies to both normal and adversarial use. In response, we introduce ALERT, a large-scale benchmark to assess safety based on a novel fine-grained risk taxonomy. It is designed to evaluate the safety of LLMs through red teaming methodologies and consists of more than 45k instructions categorized using our novel taxonomy. By subjecting LLMs to adversarial testing scenarios, ALERT aims to identify vulnerabilities, inform improvements, and enhance the overall safety of the language models. Furthermore, the fine-grained taxonomy enables researchers to perform an in-depth evaluation that also helps one to assess the alignment with various policies. In our experiments, we extensively evaluate 10 popular open- and closed-source LLMs and demonstrate that many of them still struggle to attain reasonable levels of safety.
[ -0.09030146151781082, -0.8240869045257568, 0.19448143243789673, 0.27388477325439453, 0.09098344296216965, 0.01114619430154562, -0.40076783299446106, -0.5579555630683899, -0.33770883083343506, 0.4882431924343109, -0.1043572649359703, -0.6955532431602478, -0.7480953931808472, -0.06802380084991455, -0.7826495170593262, 1.0347012281417847, 0.053490422666072845, -0.1761723905801773, -0.09778370708227158, 0.011832359246909618, -0.3548595905303955, -0.4962903559207916, -0.7369702458381653, -0.06268245726823807, 0.6340361833572388, 0.004629302304238081, 0.735268771648407, 0.5761970281600952, 1.0148028135299683, 0.28229451179504395, -0.18359383940696716, -0.14286503195762634, -0.5403159856796265, 0.1867574006319046, -0.1889926642179489, -0.5619360208511353, -0.5346939563751221, 0.07979636639356613, 0.33657023310661316, 0.6461371183395386, -0.2031981498003006, 0.22994841635227203, 0.0748215988278389, 0.441737562417984, -1.0238934755325317, 0.003110746620222926, -0.969210147857666, -0.12506604194641113, -0.23120547831058502, -0.15316373109817505, -0.5959177613258362, -0.6908539533615112, 0.19375984370708466, -0.1754647046327591, -0.2959967851638794, 0.17087627947330475, 0.6067627668380737, 0.3029775321483612, -0.3270677626132965, -0.04434812068939209, -0.4722512662410736, 0.8637748956680298, -0.5684053897857666, 0.06955696642398834, 0.2369457334280014, 0.6773941516876221, -0.38925039768218994, -0.5757190585136414, -0.23541365563869476, -0.19961552321910858, 0.1489788144826889, -0.06523315608501434, -0.48910585045814514, 0.1129666194319725, 0.04810652136802673, 0.12423401325941086, -0.6418323516845703, 0.5041142106056213, -0.1424751877784729, -0.10408395528793335, 0.7205840945243835, 0.1584423929452896, 0.4812471866607666, 0.16403377056121826, -0.6911961436271667, -0.2919737994670868, -0.8851382732391357, -0.2341737002134323, 0.26465263962745667, 0.6473239660263062, -0.3278525769710541, 0.3723160922527313, -0.13964368402957916, 0.44316932559013367, -0.3553943932056427, -0.07552217692136765, 0.3183442950248718, -0.1931331753730774, -0.4204995632171631, 0.1349884569644928, 1.1052334308624268, 0.8790197372436523, 0.4982064366340637, -0.376644104719162, -0.3655642569065094, 0.3761494755744934, 0.44035133719444275, -0.5236721038818359, -0.1803160011768341, 0.1502595990896225, -0.25670719146728516, -0.6033047437667847, -0.25188812613487244, -0.9889125823974609, -0.756762683391571, 0.08714524656534195, 0.40045005083084106, -0.31051185727119446, -0.27072805166244507, 0.09086131304502487, 0.08002125471830368, 0.22724120318889618, 0.1167072281241417, -0.7898327112197876, 0.33538818359375, 1.107135534286499, 0.6315283179283142, -0.2927027642726898, -0.4466441571712494, -0.6930612921714783, 0.006162701174616814, -0.4922199547290802, 0.6430796980857849, -0.276948481798172, -0.3385787606239319, 0.4298875629901886, -0.10946469753980637, 0.029797768220305443, -0.5276706218719482, 0.5175410509109497, -0.4777351915836334, -0.14048393070697784, 0.15134133398532867, -0.3628348708152771, -0.15648742020130157, 0.6176953911781311, -0.2778150141239166, 0.8920367956161499, -0.11397641152143478, -0.6695066690444946, 0.3754836618900299, -0.5087800025939941, -0.5260904431343079, 0.0602036714553833, -0.21476826071739197, -0.2551712989807129, -0.2183605283498764, -0.1969129592180252, 0.5107027888298035, -0.6509956121444702, 0.3411058783531189, -0.6039224863052368, -0.018126951530575752, 0.2401755154132843, -0.5616578459739685, 0.7890852689743042, 0.07163359969854355, -0.43442386388778687, 0.46927595138549805, -0.5286097526550293, 0.22310365736484528, 0.0157280582934618, -0.25050613284111023, -0.548831045627594, -0.060152698308229446, 0.047336988151073456, 0.23729176819324493, 0.3205459713935852, -0.2763797640800476, -0.22025950253009796, -0.30139482021331787, 0.34964144229888916, 0.906341552734375, -0.015169432386755943, 0.3266012966632843, -0.4118044972419739, 0.402240514755249, -0.2805149257183075, 0.4574960768222809, -0.011953264474868774, -0.19919052720069885, -0.5859347581863403, -0.24647609889507294, 0.29810214042663574, 0.6119446158409119, -0.2818950414657593, 0.7885881662368774, -0.3589751720428467, -0.7749741077423096, -0.18099500238895416, 0.0155341736972332, 0.7439813017845154, 0.1486068218946457, 0.22328497469425201, -0.08756183087825775, -0.5092183947563171, -0.8536258339881897, -0.17896974086761475, -0.22073617577552795, -0.046117547899484634, 0.21256254613399506, 0.6351017355918884, -0.6362054347991943, 0.5558695197105408, -0.3760870397090912, -0.09960538893938065, -0.09364242106676102, 0.20671917498111725, -0.027027398347854614, 0.5229312777519226, 0.6537935137748718, -0.617358386516571, -0.5181868672370911, 0.11850360035896301, -0.9013078212738037, -0.012490437366068363, -0.014836166985332966, -0.22886741161346436, 0.23848775029182434, 0.7169547080993652, -0.3644609749317169, 0.09860669076442719, 0.7914946675300598, -0.27231764793395996, 0.46702778339385986, 0.012068137526512146, -0.11937057971954346, -0.9164857268333435, 0.16057775914669037, 0.11332611739635468, -0.07203545421361923, -0.664962887763977, 0.33651480078697205, 0.14144283533096313, 0.07943558692932129, -0.7762156128883362, 0.4820127785205841, -0.1208292692899704, -0.06213100254535675, -0.11417187750339508, 0.20113711059093475, -0.30997616052627563, 0.06087476387619972, -0.3704916834831238, 0.8647382259368896, 0.8538576364517212, -0.7279614806175232, 0.3725534975528717, -0.03653810918331146, -0.6682226657867432, 0.45306459069252014, -0.7233209609985352, 0.06976999342441559, 0.2153342366218567, -0.04710064083337784, -0.5213958024978638, -0.28179261088371277, -0.06689649820327759, -0.2787296772003174, 0.26616889238357544, -0.004397550132125616, -0.7295922040939331, -0.24309583008289337, -0.3784566819667816, 0.1829397976398468, 0.6030833721160889, -0.40913859009742737, 0.3267214894294739, 0.9267372488975525, -0.10659295320510864, -0.52524334192276, -0.6440424919128418, 0.1606924831867218, -0.5228370428085327, -0.5956844687461853, 0.0905337855219841, -0.07042048126459122, -0.7213848829269409, -0.16309024393558502, -0.07127797603607178, -0.12408292293548584, 0.796099066734314, 0.37752917408943176, 0.34267911314964294, -0.02838319167494774, -0.011001130566000938, -0.5803107619285583, -0.2545044422149658, 0.21284380555152893, 0.11123266071081161, 0.6165280938148499, -0.3420789837837219, -0.21324816346168518, -0.11447025090456009, 0.23465722799301147, 0.7961425185203552, -0.15049894154071808, 0.6834240555763245, 0.3566315174102783, -0.4342690706253052, -0.2667038142681122, -0.37020254135131836, -0.08386349678039551, -0.47736045718193054, 0.4226855933666229, 0.195390522480011, -0.8899503350257874, 0.4083216190338135, -0.13485337793827057, 0.2742299735546112, 0.36026522517204285, 0.5413169860839844, 0.041046012192964554, 0.8648359775543213, 0.6905245184898376, -0.4020285904407501, 0.3701915442943573, 0.11899690330028534, 0.08571696281433105, -0.7044119238853455, -0.22157736122608185, -0.6675676703453064, -0.14049512147903442, -0.5631005764007568, -0.33639097213745117, 0.49390318989753723, -0.06658761203289032, -0.5836122035980225, 0.5207381844520569, -0.42436283826828003, 0.6049401164054871, 0.5781050324440002, -0.29543575644493103, -0.037914834916591644, -0.38254401087760925, -0.030116993933916092, 0.2666338086128235, -0.28998929262161255, -0.6324247717857361, 1.2810328006744385, 0.49447089433670044, 1.1563959121704102, 0.3387127220630646, 0.6410681009292603, 0.3333035409450531, 0.3702327013015747, -0.716317892074585, 0.7769777774810791, -0.30959731340408325, -0.6621625423431396, -0.23485544323921204, -0.5869724154472351, -0.9911201596260071, 0.08627564460039139, -0.36431384086608887, -0.9716261625289917, -0.3372887670993805, -0.018414165824651718, -0.45201024413108826, 0.09480568021535873, -0.7882415652275085, 0.925339937210083, -0.5787410736083984, -0.12029612064361572, -0.10175618529319763, -0.5587843060493469, 0.586260199546814, -0.29016226530075073, 0.28718382120132446, -0.4386442005634308, -0.0065297409892082214, 0.7377118468284607, -0.01714840903878212, 1.033459186553955, 0.21993330121040344, -0.0849127247929573, 0.09063726663589478, 0.21791239082813263, 0.6378737092018127, -0.29347676038742065, -0.13165166974067688, 0.2853114604949951, -0.169836163520813, -0.1391116827726364, -0.2453298419713974, 1.0146828889846802, -0.7301040291786194, -0.6647407412528992, -0.5402131676673889, -0.6833144426345825, -0.28966981172561646, 0.4521201252937317, -0.04192296043038368, 0.2639426290988922, -0.3095024824142456, 0.5548433661460876, 0.6448895335197449, -0.2569078803062439, 0.5419217944145203, 0.6014083027839661, -0.15313467383384705, -0.36657699942588806, 0.7055522799491882, -0.17197774350643158, 0.5811933279037476, 0.3960334360599518, 0.1638585925102234, -0.2837431728839874, -1.016141653060913, -0.016848081722855568, -0.13587288558483124, -0.7913601994514465, -0.4777367115020752, -0.5243844985961914, -0.16065001487731934, -0.39954274892807007, -0.2644486725330353, -0.4767695963382721, 0.043603185564279556, 0.02798151597380638, -0.01921134628355503, 0.36558666825294495, 0.5654631853103638, 0.2086675465106964, 0.048214029520750046, -0.9747206568717957, -0.08770430833101273, 0.41924452781677246, 0.4550013840198517, -0.286040335893631, -0.24630196392536163, -0.12352310121059418, -0.14696502685546875, -0.21146085858345032, -0.31483784317970276, 0.28382885456085205, -0.10257602483034134, 0.873997151851654, 0.3482391834259033, 0.6520965099334717, 0.2478448748588562, -0.6643756031990051, 0.7247031927108765, 0.5390087962150574, -0.8468831777572632, 0.5401366949081421, -0.5605140328407288, 0.1294296830892563, 0.6534132957458496, 0.2729378938674927, -0.48490747809410095, -0.43908002972602844, -0.4875871539115906, -1.085192084312439, 0.4268243610858917, 0.11232669651508331, -0.0730157196521759, -0.30742451548576355, -0.1901756078004837, -0.18268908560276031, 0.20931518077850342, -0.6571378111839294, -0.2989904284477234, 0.2936306595802307, -0.19093124568462372, -0.15168869495391846, -0.20964841544628143, -0.7456913590431213, 0.4309217631816864, 0.5497152209281921, -0.1557333916425705, 0.09010740369558334, -0.2733059525489807, -0.0004448017862159759, -0.175449401140213, 0.4485335052013397, 0.5971577763557434, 0.4033327102661133, -0.30803605914115906, 0.5988324284553528, 0.30395957827568054, -0.28236377239227295, -0.0029432533774524927, 0.0672067403793335, -0.06931041181087494, -0.47321629524230957, 0.6176368594169617, 0.45249614119529724, 0.49339914321899414, -1.012407898902893, 0.5687506198883057, -0.06320763379335403, -0.025876691564917564, -0.18026548624038696, 0.3750475347042084, -0.17315451800823212, 0.20654787123203278, 0.0908370167016983, 0.3101772367954254, -0.10127256065607071, -0.6823844313621521, 0.2857033312320709, 0.6189435720443726, -0.402692049741745, -0.1756824105978012, 0.41236451268196106, 0.5290482044219971, -0.295789897441864, -0.05075538158416748, -0.09824066609144211, -0.4984205365180969, 0.6888974905014038, 0.5247960090637207, 1.2157350778579712, -0.11298158764839172, -0.12528637051582336, 0.2058136761188507, 0.6250605583190918, -0.3135960102081299, -0.1287754476070404, 0.6181080341339111, -0.7106855511665344, -0.07997456938028336, -0.5583732724189758, -0.5367052555084229, 0.30868929624557495, -0.6240907907485962, 0.10965026915073395, -0.6578860878944397, -0.1280788630247116, 0.19597773253917694, -0.14941060543060303, -0.2365521639585495, 0.07819387316703796, 0.2805146872997284, 1.1598048210144043, -0.8157731294631958, 0.6321441531181335, 0.6955235004425049, -0.06501149386167526, -0.6241075396537781, 0.21797209978103638, 0.4355253279209137, -0.8117635250091553, 0.6266319155693054, 0.3434992730617523, -0.17925940454006195, -0.4120177626609802, -0.34098589420318604, -0.7376261949539185, 1.0424869060516357, 0.3107301890850067, -0.6508471965789795, 0.21123774349689484, -0.04183036834001541, 0.477428138256073, -0.295771062374115, 0.01701027899980545, 0.6156579256057739, 0.3759715259075165, -0.1159820407629013, -1.1021043062210083, 0.12247699499130249, -0.077043816447258, -0.03807917237281799, 0.46211251616477966, -0.610497236251831, 0.8618227243423462, -0.11588389426469803, -0.444716215133667, -0.025424016639590263, 0.22381648421287537, 0.09709274768829346, 0.2943170964717865, 0.6009227633476257, 0.4725904166698456, 0.8424935936927795, -0.18986822664737701, 1.237596869468689, -0.47513797879219055, 0.28347787261009216, 1.270818829536438, -0.5456480979919434, 1.1178267002105713, 0.22346405684947968, -0.2582288980484009, 0.02148713357746601, 0.3052223026752472, 0.033424753695726395, 0.6524751782417297, 0.2372787892818451, -0.27363428473472595, -0.4050807058811188, -0.2354344129562378, -0.4137136936187744, 0.44978711009025574, 0.31081780791282654, -0.4370045065879822, -0.3726836144924164, -0.2206668108701706, 0.24517175555229187, 0.30856090784072876, -0.4070405662059784, 0.836470901966095, 0.08708575367927551, -0.7611826062202454, 0.7206288576126099, -0.27582213282585144, 0.8351360559463501, -0.5069716572761536, 0.4271285831928253, 0.11455956846475601, 0.6479241847991943, -0.05071818828582764, -1.071250081062317, 0.3704899549484253, 0.3091162443161011, 0.023813936859369278, -0.06983906775712967, 0.49765369296073914, -0.23823264241218567, -0.24517126381397247, 0.7108913660049438, 0.1010913997888565, -0.13704805076122284, 0.10576698184013367, -0.668832004070282, 0.37230733036994934, -0.18665796518325806, 0.07409708946943283, 0.7035039663314819, 0.3325090706348419, -0.05522722005844116, 1.026200294494629, 0.6342264413833618, -0.010473985224962234, -0.01115489099174738, -0.0174652561545372, 0.877001941204071, -0.6230732202529907, -0.29200953245162964, -0.9781567454338074, 0.29557332396507263, -0.022173065692186356, -0.407837837934494, 0.9785153865814209, 0.36945557594299316, 0.6764833331108093, 0.08566820621490479, 0.8327443599700928, 0.10644860565662384, 0.35195985436439514, -0.5063202381134033, 0.9373902678489685, -0.33952972292900085, 0.37778788805007935, -0.37123653292655945, -0.6301906704902649, -0.7193008065223694, 0.33290719985961914, -0.4896368980407715, -0.3036465644836426, 0.6913315653800964, 0.8474982380867004, 0.37709876894950867, -0.07214496284723282, 0.49071571230888367, 0.32774266600608826, 0.5068881511688232, 0.5606577396392822, 0.9210526347160339, -0.27989497780799866, 0.9508726000785828, -0.16311724483966827, -0.37892240285873413, -0.4749331474304199, -1.0861432552337646, -1.1878496408462524, -0.16660535335540771, -0.5178366303443909, -0.37568673491477966, 0.21494702994823456, 1.076732873916626, 0.6612146496772766, -0.8319130539894104, -0.14356598258018494, -0.29096001386642456, 0.04388878494501114, -0.18024997413158417, -0.20597712695598602, 0.18911287188529968, -0.48640257120132446, -0.6135717630386353, 0.5439074039459229, 0.4824366867542267, 0.18804840743541718, -0.23207694292068481, 0.06001853570342064, -0.17820699512958527, -0.0916547179222107, 0.5111047029495239, 0.24001877009868622, -0.6084105372428894, -0.68822181224823, -0.1670185625553131, -0.5417848825454712, -0.34361085295677185, 0.268565833568573, -0.16416192054748535, 0.26273050904273987, 0.5157580375671387, 0.8796141147613525, -0.31433427333831787, -0.3507555425167084, 0.6791536808013916, -0.6702200174331665, 0.0423324778676033, 0.3902214467525482, 0.5076695680618286, 0.3213833272457123, -0.21453553438186646, 0.7331540584564209, -0.1685577630996704, -0.7386961579322815, -1.166380524635315, 0.2486657351255417, -1.1444437503814697, -0.045299652963876724, 1.532047152519226, -0.48610982298851013, -0.33059874176979065, -0.11150896549224854, 0.196048304438591, 0.05362273380160332, -0.4820464551448822, 0.9344390630722046, 0.3292551636695862, 0.4383872151374817, 0.07233144342899323, -0.5536255240440369, 0.5181398391723633, 0.15848273038864136, -1.145358681678772, 0.5387641191482544, 0.198628768324852, 0.19519872963428497, 0.44919055700302124, 0.09891850501298904, -0.09635823220014572, 0.3612931966781616, 0.09996920078992844, 0.13041585683822632, 0.06990989297628403, -0.4320127069950104, -0.3251475393772125, 0.20904052257537842, 0.07016672939062119, -0.3715192973613739 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04645v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04645v1
HyperTTS: Parameter Efficient Adaptation in Text to Speech using Hypernetworks
2024-04-06T14:34:46
2024-04-06T14:34:46
Yingting Li, Rishabh Bhardwaj, Ambuj Mehrish, Bo Cheng, Soujanya Poria
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
Neural speech synthesis, or text-to-speech (TTS), aims to transform a signal from the text domain to the speech domain. While developing TTS architectures that train and test on the same set of speakers has seen significant improvements, out-of-domain speaker performance still faces enormous limitations. Domain adaptation on a new set of speakers can be achieved by fine-tuning the whole model for each new domain, thus making it parameter-inefficient. This problem can be solved by Adapters that provide a parameter-efficient alternative to domain adaptation. Although famous in NLP, speech synthesis has not seen much improvement from Adapters. In this work, we present HyperTTS, which comprises a small learnable network, "hypernetwork", that generates parameters of the Adapter blocks, allowing us to condition Adapters on speaker representations and making them dynamic. Extensive evaluations of two domain adaptation settings demonstrate its effectiveness in achieving state-of-the-art performance in the parameter-efficient regime. We also compare different variants of HyperTTS, comparing them with baselines in different studies. Promising results on the dynamic adaptation of adapter parameters using hypernetworks open up new avenues for domain-generic multi-speaker TTS systems. The audio samples and code are available at https://github.com/declare-lab/HyperTTS.
[ -0.3016342222690582, -0.6942328810691833, 0.43000996112823486, 0.2684633135795593, -0.3697730302810669, 0.027035467326641083, -0.5559425354003906, -0.1377846747636795, 0.32203713059425354, 0.24692925810813904, -0.41421791911125183, -0.2430706024169922, -0.5398549437522888, 0.18646381795406342, -0.540968120098114, 0.8123092651367188, 0.35223156213760376, -0.27346083521842957, 0.17600755393505096, -0.21846166253089905, -0.36791500449180603, -0.3889957666397095, -0.6787467002868652, -0.41700872778892517, 0.47127601504325867, 0.3109222650527954, 0.6129147410392761, 0.7673047780990601, 0.23372387886047363, 0.335269570350647, -0.19418810307979584, 0.3308466672897339, -0.47848761081695557, 0.44701021909713745, -0.29426783323287964, -0.20474840700626373, -0.35407963395118713, -0.30448800325393677, 1.004204511642456, 0.47589462995529175, -0.07800362259149551, 0.19356729090213776, 0.21593350172042847, 0.6188098788261414, -0.435883492231369, 0.10664290189743042, -0.8736394643783569, 0.0861879289150238, -0.21368780732154846, -0.6115434169769287, -0.6025340557098389, -0.2941586673259735, 0.37020164728164673, -0.7468944787979126, -0.03751542046666145, 0.12865446507930756, 0.49376732110977173, 0.28134724497795105, -0.20410825312137604, 0.07053257524967194, -1.0213780403137207, 0.6516246199607849, -0.628922700881958, 0.8319076299667358, 0.07749004662036896, 0.48794418573379517, -0.38467419147491455, -1.081892728805542, -0.5635185241699219, -0.16278177499771118, 0.17894695699214935, 0.15260577201843262, -0.4418466091156006, 0.12970712780952454, 0.12694944441318512, -0.1174655482172966, -0.676591157913208, 0.13526755571365356, -0.03120584972202778, -0.15416692197322845, 0.07559092342853546, -0.027801236137747765, 0.13674096763134003, -0.10930067300796509, -0.2264980524778366, -0.1921083629131317, -0.568945050239563, -0.37364932894706726, 0.22721877694129944, 0.7619801163673401, -0.07502015680074692, 0.21514903008937836, -0.0760364681482315, 0.8959476947784424, 0.0802164301276207, 0.08088025450706482, 0.15430639684200287, -0.08485795557498932, -0.28011927008628845, 0.1594911515712738, 0.6288361549377441, 0.06258656084537506, 0.41753843426704407, -0.28029265999794006, -0.06057961285114288, -0.4763936698436737, 0.19635164737701416, -0.7885004281997681, -0.14579318463802338, 0.07059106230735779, -0.3538018763065338, -0.09938889741897583, -0.4672890901565552, -0.7715803980827332, -0.3589550256729126, -0.46804091334342957, 0.5729533433914185, -0.2660272419452667, -0.17047671973705292, 0.09524126350879669, -0.42500677704811096, -0.2577831447124481, 0.2361762523651123, -0.9062690734863281, 0.5200297832489014, 0.2896290123462677, 1.0613101720809937, -0.3967881500720978, -0.5187695622444153, -0.6930800676345825, 0.5009822845458984, -0.25969812273979187, 0.6633733510971069, -0.34672093391418457, -0.2510780990123749, -0.10911209136247635, -0.30787932872772217, -0.19640915095806122, -0.7080531120300293, 0.25468504428863525, -0.35664668679237366, -0.09186689555644989, -0.030560653656721115, -0.34880897402763367, 0.2051847279071808, 0.013504710979759693, -0.5841167569160461, 0.8739805817604065, 0.017908988520503044, -0.4227415919303894, -0.06308841705322266, -0.9498094320297241, -0.43218371272087097, 0.14991945028305054, -0.016375385224819183, -0.4112187623977661, 0.13018742203712463, 0.013471916317939758, 0.312588632106781, -0.5846573114395142, 0.159128338098526, -0.10055550932884216, -0.5198801159858704, 0.367361843585968, -0.5767862796783447, 0.44252660870552063, 0.165691077709198, -0.41593000292778015, 0.22189585864543915, -0.8505778908729553, 0.3273695409297943, -0.051590196788311005, -0.44849658012390137, -0.26815348863601685, 0.21376314759254456, 0.44687941670417786, 0.07820045202970505, -0.22578667104244232, -0.31897586584091187, -0.22953130304813385, -0.5632907152175903, 0.74107426404953, 0.742375373840332, 0.00797117967158556, 0.08564669638872147, -0.1971505582332611, 0.12612566351890564, -0.05848579481244087, 0.07361993193626404, 0.1292182356119156, -0.46323469281196594, -0.6913823485374451, -0.25665807723999023, 0.5661463141441345, 0.2842760682106018, -1.059252381324768, 0.34417229890823364, -0.3206081688404083, -0.5302004218101501, -0.10841341316699982, -0.17169010639190674, 0.35160747170448303, 0.46271875500679016, 0.46230190992355347, -0.05596392974257469, -0.6967264413833618, -0.8156493306159973, -0.5430856943130493, -0.3055782914161682, -0.0707012191414833, 0.00962853617966175, 0.272292822599411, 0.07257167994976044, 0.9054743051528931, -0.38285547494888306, -0.07825745642185211, -0.16088975965976715, -0.035834550857543945, 0.058119967579841614, 0.5759420990943909, 0.6432363390922546, -0.7178542017936707, -0.45637431740760803, 0.10762690007686615, -0.3301525413990021, 0.08581003546714783, -0.08561677485704422, -0.19726942479610443, -0.23798087239265442, 0.5821702480316162, -0.254116952419281, 0.25370389223098755, 0.7463825941085815, -0.06035256013274193, 0.6626496911048889, -0.24774077534675598, -0.16421864926815033, -1.1449203491210938, 0.06307481974363327, 0.22503618896007538, -0.4848175644874573, -0.8356945514678955, -0.2917036712169647, -0.2773849666118622, -0.4565236270427704, -0.5556117296218872, 0.5445555448532104, -0.21271875500679016, -0.16327691078186035, -0.42418888211250305, 0.3120676577091217, -0.18726512789726257, 0.6566428542137146, -0.1485377550125122, 0.976922869682312, 0.6030707955360413, -0.642468273639679, 0.6394150257110596, 0.4061082899570465, -0.13572192192077637, 0.5031455755233765, -0.6474019885063171, 0.4721985459327698, 0.2674384117126465, 0.3357802927494049, -0.7387569546699524, 0.015925295650959015, 0.16507619619369507, -0.41302260756492615, -0.021890750154852867, -0.32599401473999023, -0.5005532503128052, -0.08860571682453156, -0.039571139961481094, 0.40015238523483276, 0.43363192677497864, -0.7323022484779358, 0.6324092149734497, 0.3784637749195099, -0.3897418677806854, -0.08741847425699234, -0.7683417201042175, 0.39999163150787354, -0.11538790911436081, -0.18796968460083008, 0.5936336517333984, -0.13424073159694672, 0.1385929137468338, 0.02586817741394043, -0.06757862865924835, -0.37982484698295593, -0.22901587188243866, -0.020330755040049553, -0.211716890335083, -0.419010728597641, 0.24436502158641815, 0.3209385573863983, -0.2058936506509781, -0.07485125958919525, -0.8795132040977478, 0.469555139541626, -0.0278752651065588, -0.23583315312862396, -0.9228872656822205, 0.46859046816825867, 0.8204609155654907, -0.1606280505657196, 0.3725411593914032, 0.4924474060535431, -0.45037004351615906, -0.5542004704475403, -0.15735013782978058, -0.19127748906612396, -0.5608454942703247, 0.7236514687538147, -0.43248221278190613, -0.7928780317306519, 0.16053658723831177, -0.48013025522232056, -0.18546228110790253, 0.25494709610939026, 0.682518720626831, 0.057849980890750885, 0.8194184303283691, 0.4517100155353546, 0.03661615774035454, 0.804762601852417, -0.0448588989675045, 0.0018162248888984323, -0.7925033569335938, 0.1190960630774498, -0.8055177927017212, -0.45864781737327576, -0.7471959590911865, -0.23422272503376007, 0.7876841425895691, -0.6950910091400146, -0.3253227174282074, 0.5567291378974915, -0.5753476619720459, 0.320131778717041, 0.8238081336021423, 0.3262183666229248, 0.02500932663679123, 0.14833267033100128, -0.03393521532416344, 0.010914614424109459, -0.8631083369255066, -0.28657326102256775, 0.7977371215820312, 0.1771257370710373, 0.3306637406349182, 0.18749785423278809, 0.5635661482810974, 0.44094181060791016, -0.17955689132213593, -0.8009716272354126, 0.5901579260826111, -0.43324464559555054, -0.4192853569984436, -0.6189557313919067, -0.5418229699134827, -0.9714613556861877, 0.08818577229976654, -0.37734994292259216, -0.8127837777137756, 0.35440391302108765, 0.29469752311706543, -0.4787467122077942, 0.30315423011779785, -0.7872499823570251, 0.4152657985687256, 0.15880917012691498, -0.302339106798172, -0.337149977684021, -0.6789913773536682, -0.4488700032234192, -0.1979241520166397, -0.15714910626411438, 0.024808909744024277, 0.3268740177154541, 1.2187676429748535, -0.037420909851789474, 0.7973734140396118, -0.4111032783985138, 0.323360800743103, 0.19631119072437286, 0.10483860224485397, 0.43068066239356995, 0.055108968168497086, -0.4760626256465912, -0.19126728177070618, -0.04087233543395996, -0.31349122524261475, -0.9047849774360657, 0.7391474843025208, -0.6734177470207214, -0.4539432227611542, 0.001794920302927494, -0.8717803359031677, -0.768158495426178, 0.4491313695907593, -0.06100643053650856, 1.03463613986969, -0.28700995445251465, 0.43975967168807983, 0.7288994789123535, -0.17968487739562988, 0.6171954870223999, 0.12951163947582245, 0.05875315144658089, -0.5215203762054443, 1.119664192199707, 0.1039932444691658, 0.29501163959503174, 0.4256267845630646, 0.4945819675922394, -0.22094428539276123, -1.0456476211547852, -0.6923661231994629, 0.1334652304649353, -0.4903375208377838, -0.12201502174139023, -0.06825489550828934, -0.24024909734725952, -0.22111235558986664, 0.08794771879911423, -0.573035478591919, -0.5183836817741394, -0.31763187050819397, 0.07867205142974854, 0.3643072247505188, 0.5860158205032349, 0.10416735708713531, 0.5792590379714966, -0.7339171767234802, 0.5333567261695862, 0.5841911435127258, 0.5833783149719238, -0.11659079790115356, -0.7650800943374634, -0.664185106754303, -0.05427095666527748, -0.29431524872779846, -0.7747460603713989, 0.1764259934425354, 0.4240095317363739, 0.4437882602214813, 0.01127538364380598, 0.09631231427192688, 0.6151226162910461, -0.6908218860626221, 0.5195793509483337, 0.28692829608917236, -1.144521713256836, 0.35647091269493103, -0.4178178012371063, 0.31971612572669983, 0.4302484095096588, 0.0663125291466713, -0.6168486475944519, -0.22906751930713654, -0.3796996772289276, -0.6284865736961365, 0.756961464881897, 0.707534909248352, 0.23045220971107483, 0.41692566871643066, 0.5488020181655884, -0.17469975352287292, 0.030159028246998787, -0.2847764790058136, -0.34049516916275024, -0.3351372480392456, -0.44858667254447937, -0.08311222493648529, 0.006728054489940405, -0.27747055888175964, -0.32907140254974365, 0.7512340545654297, -0.3376394808292389, 0.5903481841087341, 0.02142927795648575, 0.03521275892853737, -0.09083312749862671, 0.20655594766139984, 0.7255920171737671, 0.7107475399971008, -0.1770278960466385, 0.30772507190704346, 0.3151508569717407, -0.5127239227294922, 0.22995159029960632, 0.17170046269893646, 0.22485777735710144, 0.27496275305747986, 0.17166905105113983, 1.1613174676895142, 0.07909726351499557, -0.34358248114585876, 0.36633965373039246, -0.1349012851715088, -0.21762719750404358, 0.10003270208835602, 0.07934856414794922, 0.08440376073122025, 0.23122301697731018, 0.3193584084510803, 0.3338286280632019, 0.09206908196210861, -0.45996609330177307, 0.32055673003196716, -0.08499975502490997, -0.5251314640045166, -0.42550814151763916, 0.6016303300857544, 0.5428576469421387, -0.8390949964523315, 0.36089929938316345, 0.01708543486893177, -0.20319905877113342, 0.33837082982063293, 0.8993310928344727, 1.0820313692092896, -0.37250417470932007, 0.046344198286533356, -0.11361921578645706, 0.08297718316316605, 0.14429710805416107, 0.18669737875461578, 0.07236351817846298, -0.5196696519851685, -0.43098679184913635, -0.35772648453712463, -0.7123442888259888, -0.025622304528951645, -0.4404161274433136, 0.22812701761722565, -0.4848410189151764, -0.44504663348197937, 0.23518747091293335, -0.4714394211769104, -0.2460169941186905, 0.5070135593414307, -0.09045378863811493, 0.8563088774681091, -0.644017219543457, 1.060266137123108, 0.6400740742683411, 0.22455042600631714, -0.5913619995117188, 0.4280250370502472, -0.14006340503692627, -0.5410676598548889, 0.44211438298225403, -0.4983665943145752, -0.5451293587684631, 0.45899438858032227, -0.21063795685768127, -0.7860351204872131, 0.7192311882972717, 0.7240077257156372, -0.5644240379333496, -0.06543591618537903, 0.29443809390068054, 0.5481407642364502, 0.004708280321210623, 0.139755979180336, 0.48924577236175537, 0.5731374621391296, -0.1782333254814148, -1.0782673358917236, 0.0756869837641716, -0.18719671666622162, 0.2535298466682434, 0.09382055699825287, -0.5327222943305969, 0.3595285713672638, 0.322893887758255, 0.2607363164424896, 0.008759778924286366, 0.8665976524353027, 0.13444873690605164, 0.1558961421251297, 0.7209675312042236, 0.01332892570644617, 0.5718837976455688, -0.14798715710639954, 0.5688894391059875, -0.21843260526657104, 0.32316625118255615, 0.9819411635398865, -0.04314267262816429, 0.8426920771598816, 0.584000289440155, -0.1750722974538803, 0.41726118326187134, 0.10755852609872818, 0.4274904131889343, 0.5744099617004395, 0.4204573631286621, -0.16941510140895844, -0.1292964518070221, 0.01389047410339117, -0.3202917277812958, 0.6736610531806946, 0.2925836443901062, -0.1362837702035904, -0.04824771359562874, 0.13537301123142242, -0.18224705755710602, 0.025845034047961235, -0.006335067097097635, 0.6497758626937866, 0.036690324544906616, -0.31011492013931274, 0.8271255493164062, -0.05181769281625748, 0.3401735723018646, -0.77836012840271, 0.05085763707756996, 0.16965730488300323, 0.11246130615472794, -0.035647038370370865, -0.5499386191368103, 0.36376458406448364, -0.061159197241067886, -0.333352267742157, -0.29029810428619385, 0.5874345898628235, -0.2080654501914978, -0.04209216684103012, 0.24350735545158386, 0.5939726233482361, -0.14397725462913513, -0.1599544733762741, -0.6907764673233032, 0.15026210248470306, -0.09123839437961578, -0.2940482497215271, 0.32353049516677856, 0.542892336845398, 0.10869938880205154, 0.4728544056415558, 0.6570620536804199, 0.37658077478408813, 0.014580500312149525, 0.32784801721572876, 0.8551456332206726, -0.6933411359786987, -0.6210328936576843, -0.6542918682098389, 0.16800765693187714, -0.08726635575294495, -0.5960489511489868, 0.5770830512046814, 0.6111441850662231, 0.6132686138153076, -0.041268352419137955, 0.8671681880950928, 0.2993699014186859, 0.5883477330207825, -0.5623936653137207, 0.8308733701705933, -0.4880344569683075, -0.061242107301950455, -0.5280426740646362, -0.7881566882133484, -0.41441619396209717, 0.10825680941343307, 0.07859547436237335, 0.06226932629942894, 0.9165592193603516, 0.8011261224746704, -0.13429193198680878, 0.14382173120975494, 0.5546073317527771, 0.2852556109428406, 0.39304929971694946, 0.2328009158372879, 0.7988856434822083, -0.3690219521522522, 0.732998788356781, 0.0023908012080937624, -0.23924551904201508, -0.20544056594371796, -0.7725353240966797, -0.4769435524940491, -0.9141871333122253, -0.44061094522476196, -0.23421955108642578, 0.7117209434509277, 1.0342001914978027, 1.0783565044403076, -0.7207444906234741, -0.6356837153434753, -0.045411210507154465, 0.036691680550575256, -0.4765208959579468, -0.10115658491849899, 0.5359327793121338, -0.1162232980132103, -0.9310322999954224, 0.8992166519165039, 0.40909838676452637, 0.0021662123035639524, 0.13756252825260162, -0.053361568599939346, -0.02448522485792637, 0.41804736852645874, 0.6255929470062256, 0.28684601187705994, -0.2788623869419098, -0.4020887613296509, -0.2279653698205948, 0.13603375852108002, 0.07613515108823776, 0.8958462476730347, -0.567463219165802, 0.5425995588302612, 0.46791887283325195, 0.8738577961921692, 0.5763331651687622, -0.290516197681427, 0.5810855031013489, -0.8506026268005371, 0.12727263569831848, 0.29529789090156555, 0.24710312485694885, 0.18989315629005432, 0.02946944162249565, -0.068695567548275, 0.4149777591228485, -0.5444461703300476, -0.9166306853294373, 0.21615542471408844, -1.1146196126937866, -0.2587471306324005, 1.2755237817764282, 0.07136602699756622, -0.1558641493320465, -0.2861248850822449, -0.2030021697282791, 0.6786824464797974, -0.34256434440612793, 0.5865349173545837, 0.18220511078834534, -0.2589266896247864, 0.2292739897966385, -0.42365825176239014, 0.4836448132991791, 0.5597951412200928, -0.8351694345474243, 0.19745692610740662, 0.03932592272758484, 0.13765788078308105, -0.017255868762731552, 0.4292285740375519, 0.20503681898117065, 0.29250115156173706, -0.14084096252918243, -0.08229994028806686, -0.1951809525489807, -0.5608156323432922, -0.1743394285440445, 0.16765625774860382, 0.11852248013019562, -0.5734047889709473 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04633v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04633v3
Context versus Prior Knowledge in Language Models
2024-04-06T13:46:53
2024-06-16T12:05:34
Kevin Du, Vésteinn Snæbjarnarson, Niklas Stoehr, Jennifer C. White, Aaron Schein, Ryan Cotterell
cs.CL
cs.CL
To answer a question, language models often need to integrate prior knowledge learned during pretraining and new information presented in context. We hypothesize that models perform this integration in a predictable way across different questions and contexts: models will rely more on prior knowledge for questions about entities (e.g., persons, places, etc.) that they are more familiar with due to higher exposure in the training corpus, and be more easily persuaded by some contexts than others. To formalize this problem, we propose two mutual information-based metrics to measure a model's dependency on a context and on its prior about an entity: first, the persuasion score of a given context represents how much a model depends on the context in its decision, and second, the susceptibility score of a given entity represents how much the model can be swayed away from its original answer distribution about an entity. We empirically test our metrics for their validity and reliability. Finally, we explore and find a relationship between the scores and the model's expected familiarity with an entity, and provide two use cases to illustrate their benefits.
[ -0.5718832612037659, -0.7857357859611511, 0.8944239616394043, 0.12904596328735352, 0.07342230528593063, -0.5895538330078125, -0.34803369641304016, -0.5596575140953064, -0.04653118550777435, 0.4125100076198578, -0.17686204612255096, -0.29576101899147034, -0.6114436388015747, -0.35584506392478943, -0.27634674310684204, 0.9165142178535461, -0.09694276005029678, 0.11363036930561066, -0.7362953424453735, -0.28275802731513977, -0.704410195350647, -0.8950790762901306, -0.34998419880867004, -0.30826449394226074, 0.5544874668121338, 0.129241943359375, 0.5623223185539246, 0.1513294279575348, 0.41431596875190735, 0.2848173975944519, 0.07941368967294693, -0.5281957983970642, -0.2394883930683136, 0.25820648670196533, -0.7439517974853516, -0.7538608312606812, -0.25238990783691406, 0.2808569669723511, 0.5549711585044861, 0.9616918563842773, -0.09069178998470306, 0.2556147873401642, 0.1435318887233734, 0.29156357049942017, -0.9724718332290649, 0.06143607944250107, -0.7202311754226685, -0.23075604438781738, -0.1504398137331009, -0.23642221093177795, -0.3153201639652252, -0.10416974127292633, 0.6328065395355225, -0.6031017899513245, -0.06237814575433731, -0.1287044882774353, 0.9975259304046631, 0.20794633030891418, -0.6430705785751343, -0.3537123501300812, -0.8978647589683533, 0.7430878281593323, -0.5810239315032959, 0.658221423625946, 0.5349863767623901, 0.3190593123435974, 0.14426730573177338, -0.7494973540306091, -0.5402101278305054, -0.44361692667007446, -0.39792153239250183, 0.06973487883806229, -0.18090829253196716, -0.28187116980552673, 0.31022605299949646, 0.16081055998802185, -0.3069049119949341, -0.036840178072452545, -0.24295373260974884, -0.21323680877685547, 0.292035847902298, -0.02109723910689354, 0.19721931219100952, -0.10827162116765976, -0.4406028687953949, -0.022623179480433464, -0.8639364242553711, 0.13762137293815613, 0.2312796264886856, 0.1148335412144661, -0.03273972123861313, 0.3153512477874756, -0.2571626603603363, 0.7163743376731873, 0.12203244864940643, 0.07660990208387375, 0.1141146644949913, -0.4543786942958832, -0.014351906254887581, -0.02253505028784275, 0.654217004776001, 0.3509555459022522, 0.3779012858867645, 0.015893034636974335, -0.1854676604270935, 0.037682730704545975, 0.06875046342611313, -0.7029608488082886, -0.016502665355801582, -0.07103817909955978, -0.3806168735027313, 0.23485320806503296, 0.1855236291885376, -0.25563761591911316, -0.03178738057613373, -0.42439767718315125, 0.665106475353241, -0.44183382391929626, -0.6649428009986877, -0.2111203372478485, -0.11171974986791611, 0.196628138422966, 0.4040343761444092, -0.9182170033454895, 0.27042144536972046, 0.6607800126075745, 0.624565064907074, -0.07490476220846176, -0.39699238538742065, -0.46085110306739807, 0.12492392957210541, -0.2669243812561035, 0.8186759352684021, -0.6441155076026917, -0.2567274272441864, -0.023054424673318863, 0.015105359256267548, -0.18648646771907806, -0.31118783354759216, 0.21728141605854034, -0.7070707678794861, 0.5200756192207336, -0.588458776473999, -0.8777638077735901, -0.27199313044548035, 0.21886099874973297, -0.5547526478767395, 0.8213359117507935, 0.275664359331131, -1.0094999074935913, 0.7382419109344482, -0.28220894932746887, -0.37560269236564636, -0.061747465282678604, -0.29101064801216125, 0.27028724551200867, 0.23071938753128052, -0.09007982164621353, 0.5961247086524963, -0.2877509891986847, 0.47388994693756104, -0.3750344216823578, -0.16432496905326843, 0.4455234110355377, -0.2582210302352905, 0.49759072065353394, 0.217844620347023, -0.04742227867245674, -0.19608889520168304, -0.542290449142456, -0.1526327133178711, -0.04144066944718361, -0.3285188674926758, -0.9555352926254272, 0.16363056004047394, -0.30340805649757385, 0.2638110816478729, 0.4005638062953949, -0.2083963304758072, -0.15054287016391754, -0.4112142026424408, 0.13591711223125458, 0.6382707953453064, 0.21277101337909698, 0.8177204728126526, -0.41366440057754517, 0.32679131627082825, 0.21659217774868011, -0.13297319412231445, -0.12805716693401337, -0.47160986065864563, -0.48227745294570923, 0.24659207463264465, 0.3597429692745209, 0.41381919384002686, -0.2703199088573456, 0.324130654335022, -0.3462989926338196, -0.4472605288028717, -0.18908104300498962, -0.03617597371339798, 0.19765006005764008, 0.8560973405838013, 0.27631303668022156, -0.5480107069015503, -0.5598288178443909, -0.7456339001655579, -0.4554007351398468, -0.5608953833580017, -0.07515161484479904, 0.490565687417984, 0.6207371950149536, 0.14363184571266174, 1.1712061166763306, -0.4967818856239319, -0.10211867839097977, -0.2430301159620285, -0.16689366102218628, 0.1977643221616745, 0.5672043561935425, 0.7589086294174194, -0.8072669506072998, -0.50460284948349, -0.07179029285907745, -0.5480017066001892, 0.04244702309370041, 0.14722390472888947, -0.01588359847664833, -0.05297333747148514, 0.4958355724811554, -0.4702805280685425, 0.3207578659057617, 0.4628244936466217, -0.3340710699558258, 0.6968802213668823, -0.021510552614927292, 0.3352946937084198, -1.1313124895095825, 0.2315932959318161, 0.0849875658750534, -0.12040185183286667, -0.8079184889793396, -0.07765186578035355, -0.18786773085594177, 0.3577270209789276, -0.5661353468894958, 0.869691014289856, -0.25735199451446533, -0.1235077828168869, 0.04642217233777046, 0.2225591093301773, 0.06211579963564873, 0.3841974437236786, 0.3990367650985718, 0.6843276023864746, 0.548490583896637, -0.9936604499816895, 0.0776095762848854, 0.06289888918399811, -0.6122843027114868, 0.8782065510749817, -0.7622290849685669, 0.1640821099281311, -0.07947079837322235, 0.047801535576581955, -0.8786365985870361, -0.20662078261375427, 0.17388670146465302, -0.6387647986412048, 0.08911865204572678, -0.262419730424881, -0.1553100198507309, 0.15804749727249146, 0.38701602816581726, 0.4279175400733948, 0.4136279821395874, -0.2871439754962921, 0.5306238532066345, 0.4405839741230011, -0.2584587633609772, -0.4713369905948639, -0.7259295582771301, -0.5137966871261597, -0.41639915108680725, -0.5937443375587463, 0.3177374005317688, -0.07271675765514374, -0.5460236072540283, 0.3520054221153259, -0.08806569129228592, -0.3755722641944885, 0.23437222838401794, 0.2741692364215851, 0.00616591889411211, -0.6125116944313049, 0.36950966715812683, -0.12760578095912933, -0.13555367290973663, 0.2655731737613678, -0.34019872546195984, 0.46204203367233276, -0.17178975045681, -0.6210107207298279, -0.17954851686954498, 0.403641015291214, 0.33008265495300293, -0.17698925733566284, 1.047676920890808, 0.2577199637889862, -0.4867735505104065, 0.18542072176933289, -0.7284449338912964, -0.38095295429229736, -0.37728872895240784, 0.40814584493637085, -0.6624190211296082, -0.8470154404640198, 0.6516882181167603, -0.13037841022014618, -0.2482353299856186, 0.516915500164032, 0.5681023001670837, -0.1581335961818695, 1.000911831855774, 0.6245242953300476, -0.19335803389549255, 0.6961930394172668, 0.046047016978263855, -0.0920262560248375, -0.6549358367919922, -0.10118816047906876, -0.6611674427986145, 0.013491789810359478, -0.21980558335781097, -0.00840645469725132, 0.0161913875490427, 0.5804659128189087, -0.1253310889005661, 0.4262896776199341, -0.05616967752575874, 0.37033209204673767, 0.6806330680847168, -0.07211433351039886, 0.2789001762866974, -0.22171007096767426, -0.3333958387374878, -0.11118333786725998, -0.6352428793907166, -0.487070232629776, 1.1049489974975586, 0.29415440559387207, 0.4015766382217407, 0.244264155626297, 0.39117056131362915, -0.1596897393465042, 0.5184608101844788, -0.5391940474510193, 0.3598612844944, 0.25709885358810425, -0.9234933257102966, -0.32769790291786194, -0.36048614978790283, -0.8544140458106995, 0.28519394993782043, -0.2767386734485626, -0.9640259742736816, 0.1567646712064743, 0.20558740198612213, -0.16753481328487396, -0.06401728093624115, -0.7855571508407593, 1.0165828466415405, -0.06513700634241104, -0.3153333067893982, -0.2378067821264267, -0.5131781697273254, 0.24439874291419983, -0.04036556929349899, 0.343736857175827, -0.03714529052376747, 0.2454928457736969, 0.9058182239532471, -0.46129947900772095, 0.6714224219322205, -0.22537142038345337, 0.014064413495361805, 0.3401939272880554, 0.10096094012260437, 0.34949949383735657, 0.0823683887720108, -0.10184530913829803, 0.09589929133653641, 0.4204901158809662, -0.17528630793094635, -0.978272020816803, 0.5450791120529175, -0.5608739852905273, -0.8940896391868591, -0.24734561145305634, -0.2474513202905655, -0.3449966311454773, 0.27467939257621765, 0.37862759828567505, 0.3830781579017639, -0.4326300621032715, 0.19982564449310303, 0.569442093372345, -0.01715778186917305, 0.051449939608573914, 0.975124716758728, -0.20885694026947021, -0.018427979201078415, 0.5631670951843262, 0.2183646559715271, 0.5750510096549988, 0.4825679659843445, 0.39760157465934753, -0.42318499088287354, -0.28430867195129395, 0.027156133204698563, 0.10894124954938889, -0.9558685421943665, 0.11234883219003677, -0.4064086079597473, -0.26225271821022034, -0.42407310009002686, -0.0007466668612323701, -0.222251757979393, -0.20070871710777283, -0.2606387734413147, -0.20991262793540955, 0.1910087913274765, 0.7324868440628052, -0.20189008116722107, 0.32552096247673035, -0.6180540919303894, -0.36612406373023987, 0.2897544205188751, 0.3114289343357086, -0.04562612250447273, -0.6464025378227234, -0.2723827660083771, 0.08882416039705276, 0.02755500003695488, -1.300150990486145, -0.12048637121915817, 0.01819881983101368, 0.9328250885009766, 0.5888375639915466, -0.09058567136526108, 0.4327920079231262, -0.5009521245956421, 0.7232672572135925, 0.1982267051935196, -0.9424861669540405, 0.6852630376815796, -0.021875137463212013, 0.2625117897987366, 0.7722873091697693, 0.7748298048973083, -0.7116457223892212, -0.6336911916732788, -0.70166015625, -0.341476708650589, 0.49949660897254944, -0.20775927603244781, 0.21382547914981842, -0.03383932635188103, 0.3726111054420471, 0.1211860403418541, 0.11798806488513947, -0.7189974188804626, -0.2389494925737381, -0.09126745909452438, -0.032086096704006195, -0.2970845103263855, -0.3486797511577606, -0.024283962324261665, -0.21461652219295502, 0.40864482522010803, 0.11620412021875381, -0.044890694320201874, 0.10375504195690155, -0.4992808997631073, 0.21992263197898865, 0.2894382178783417, 0.5103421807289124, 0.8299224972724915, -0.1762283593416214, 0.2898872494697571, 0.3713257610797882, -0.35449832677841187, 0.07329897582530975, -0.25892865657806396, -0.2605818808078766, 0.06008622795343399, 0.7057225108146667, 0.8747372627258301, 0.4026237428188324, -0.18147560954093933, 0.8002414703369141, 0.09275507181882858, -0.13658982515335083, -0.18004781007766724, 0.12023962289094925, 0.22421300411224365, 0.024043764919042587, 0.09663493186235428, 0.23044730722904205, 0.05370670557022095, -0.5900389552116394, 0.48608842492103577, 0.43015506863594055, -0.7026202082633972, -0.555105984210968, 0.43101829290390015, -0.0235870610922575, -0.14812032878398895, 0.1772177815437317, 0.005781031679362059, -0.537785530090332, 0.41304099559783936, 0.5161882042884827, 0.35379692912101746, -0.6342791318893433, 0.06775034219026566, 0.5424709320068359, 0.1151958554983139, -0.1759844720363617, 0.0002709041291382164, -0.3213220238685608, -1.061869740486145, -0.36351895332336426, -0.41434577107429504, -0.2116701900959015, 0.1161559447646141, -0.7404546737670898, 0.20663614571094513, -0.30435052514076233, -0.34762823581695557, -0.07142730802297592, -0.1169770210981369, -1.0478023290634155, 0.3410845398902893, -0.3258965015411377, 0.9251939654350281, -0.9801846742630005, 0.7713565230369568, 0.8173554539680481, -0.734174907207489, -1.042148470878601, -0.0007436748128384352, -0.23748748004436493, -0.5813719034194946, 0.9154367446899414, 0.1023145392537117, 0.10562172532081604, -0.09366822987794876, -0.20958353579044342, -1.165744423866272, 0.9552159309387207, 0.3472915589809418, -0.5190343260765076, 0.0927925854921341, -0.11393504589796066, 0.47869136929512024, -0.5874947905540466, 0.602662205696106, 0.6585010886192322, 0.3926882743835449, 0.16044531762599945, -0.9754437804222107, 0.15299002826213837, -0.0026557142846286297, -0.20866768062114716, -0.023125650361180305, -0.233120858669281, 0.7478088736534119, -0.1726425290107727, -0.45407557487487793, -0.2689076066017151, 0.8359329104423523, 0.1221783459186554, 0.35827645659446716, 0.8231914043426514, 0.2775280773639679, 0.8087971806526184, 0.01603151485323906, 0.939854621887207, -0.42372557520866394, 0.2267024666070938, 1.3414151668548584, -0.22622543573379517, 1.0669469833374023, 0.5105387568473816, -0.19830219447612762, 0.7781702280044556, 0.5638114809989929, 0.48286768794059753, 0.6858295202255249, 0.08148299157619476, -0.1172410100698471, -0.31678932905197144, -0.17180675268173218, -0.7473549246788025, 0.37927937507629395, 0.4109642803668976, -0.24022069573402405, -0.10993576794862747, -0.0436055064201355, 0.04804379492998123, 0.1294831931591034, 0.005922466982156038, 0.7750147581100464, 0.2792469263076782, -0.9239203333854675, 0.14380143582820892, -0.1003103032708168, 0.23202037811279297, -0.6644158959388733, 0.22383280098438263, -0.25789573788642883, -0.11304768174886703, -0.055921394377946854, -0.7917107939720154, 0.44735756516456604, -0.3144173324108124, -0.3765028417110443, 0.04237449914216995, 0.7614627480506897, -0.4153899848461151, -0.10593577474355698, 0.37274327874183655, 0.8066107630729675, 0.23674751818180084, -0.1356143206357956, -0.5130223631858826, -0.12546297907829285, -0.42295023798942566, -0.399637907743454, 0.4096074402332306, 0.47160160541534424, -0.002202490111812949, 0.5798763036727905, 0.6251270174980164, 0.2516136169433594, -0.1278771162033081, 0.1800018846988678, 0.659027099609375, -0.3726083040237427, -0.6212770342826843, -0.8899126052856445, 0.42655450105667114, -0.06192297860980034, -0.35310837626457214, 0.8828699588775635, 0.2568141520023346, 0.9666112065315247, 0.16543863713741302, 0.7299359440803528, 0.05800221860408783, 0.44270390272140503, -0.6885144114494324, 0.6790668368339539, -0.6513559222221375, 0.41254377365112305, -0.35142749547958374, -1.0589996576309204, 0.03861149027943611, 0.7159537672996521, -0.8036761283874512, 0.1697225421667099, 0.8521178960800171, 0.6104084849357605, -0.07575776427984238, -0.15417224168777466, 0.35174161195755005, 0.06554411351680756, 0.04169532656669617, 0.7661920785903931, 1.2573702335357666, -0.05594306439161301, 0.3173869848251343, -0.005476575344800949, -0.2743643820285797, -0.12222189456224442, -0.8794476389884949, -0.8812674283981323, -1.0725518465042114, -0.29564690589904785, -0.27427196502685547, -0.13216502964496613, 0.547213613986969, 0.9286504983901978, -0.8457279205322266, -0.05480107665061951, 0.027504663914442062, 0.46272438764572144, -0.06925284117460251, -0.2400146871805191, 0.12965917587280273, -0.2605622112751007, -0.44693097472190857, 0.1670125424861908, 0.1446772664785385, 0.10088224709033966, -0.3110984265804291, -0.21194204688072205, -0.09785472601652145, 0.17363740503787994, 0.3007815480232239, 0.22184525430202484, -0.6277334094047546, -0.6834239959716797, 0.0495775006711483, -0.30682626366615295, -0.11127745360136032, 0.9129788875579834, -0.8387737274169922, 0.1681578904390335, 0.6558224558830261, 0.3097802996635437, 0.3590123653411865, -0.050870202481746674, 0.8333602547645569, -0.7156966328620911, 0.2600560188293457, 0.02878769300878048, 0.5647413730621338, 0.23299260437488556, -0.2772558033466339, 0.23052987456321716, 0.29659295082092285, -0.3597969114780426, -0.6671375036239624, 0.6546719670295715, -0.4615771770477295, -0.4305678606033325, 1.1000697612762451, -0.3771108388900757, -0.11551632732152939, -0.13813096284866333, 0.16596294939517975, -0.09366334974765778, -0.1002560406923294, 0.21629241108894348, 1.1160612106323242, 0.2553168833255768, 0.01340423058718443, -0.5003282427787781, 0.5944598913192749, 0.5796230435371399, -0.4912574589252472, -0.31422287225723267, 0.33150866627693176, 0.6535636186599731, 0.24752208590507507, 1.0344774723052979, 0.1738092005252838, 0.21043047308921814, 0.185726135969162, -0.1436355859041214, 0.20768794417381287, -0.446611225605011, -0.08567900210618973, 0.22363407909870148, 0.22318574786186218, 0.02942664362490177 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04631v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04631v1
On the Limitations of Large Language Models (LLMs): False Attribution
2024-04-06T13:38:15
2024-04-06T13:38:15
Tosin Adewumi, Nudrat Habib, Lama Alkhaled, Elisa Barney
cs.CL
cs.CL
In this work, we provide insight into one important limitation of large language models (LLMs), i.e. false attribution, and introduce a new hallucination metric - Simple Hallucination Index (SHI). The task of automatic author attribution for relatively small chunks of text is an important NLP task but can be challenging. We empirically evaluate the power of 3 open SotA LLMs in zero-shot setting (LLaMA-2-13B, Mixtral 8x7B, and Gemma-7B), especially as human annotation can be costly. We collected the top 10 most popular books, according to Project Gutenberg, divided each one into equal chunks of 400 words, and asked each LLM to predict the author. We then randomly sampled 162 chunks for human evaluation from each of the annotated books, based on the error margin of 7% and a confidence level of 95% for the book with the most chunks (Great Expectations by Charles Dickens, having 922 chunks). The average results show that Mixtral 8x7B has the highest prediction accuracy, the lowest SHI, and a Pearson's correlation (r) of 0.737, 0.249, and -0.9996, respectively, followed by LLaMA-2-13B and Gemma-7B. However, Mixtral 8x7B suffers from high hallucinations for 3 books, rising as high as an SHI of 0.87 (in the range 0-1, where 1 is the worst). The strong negative correlation of accuracy and SHI, given by r, demonstrates the fidelity of the new hallucination metric, which is generalizable to other tasks. We publicly release the annotated chunks of data and our codes to aid the reproducibility and evaluation of other models.
[ -0.20143312215805054, -0.5539028644561768, 0.9267644286155701, 0.3235158324241638, -0.18280550837516785, -0.3940497040748596, -0.23618260025978088, -0.8775225877761841, 0.3006288409233093, 0.7458846569061279, -0.4591386318206787, -0.35668277740478516, -0.6979794502258301, 0.4006534516811371, -0.7916281223297119, 0.9983344078063965, 0.05366146191954613, -0.2887926995754242, -0.23383766412734985, -0.10704369843006134, -0.32118046283721924, -0.6529686450958252, -0.30979642271995544, -0.2521434426307678, 0.893086314201355, 0.23417507112026215, 0.7739548087120056, 0.8800731897354126, 0.6108548045158386, 0.22259247303009033, 0.10885712504386902, 0.11019118875265121, -0.5332922339439392, 0.0348455049097538, -0.12196017056703568, -0.5597406029701233, -0.4521649181842804, 0.04554171487689018, 0.6807268261909485, 0.4529401659965515, -0.03878291696310043, 0.24548575282096863, -0.03622040897607803, 0.6550734639167786, -0.6916122436523438, -0.17685846984386444, -0.8055155873298645, 0.003588789841160178, -0.25584518909454346, -0.3542519807815552, -0.6754133105278015, -0.5464733839035034, -0.05866588279604912, -0.5138671398162842, 0.14748606085777283, 0.38564252853393555, 0.9533553719520569, 0.5614575147628784, -0.17191942036151886, -0.6007274985313416, -0.6851720809936523, 1.066304326057434, -0.7608466148376465, -0.06385403126478195, 0.6308259963989258, 0.20200391113758087, -0.0022133085876703262, -0.231348916888237, -0.773335337638855, -0.3143090307712555, -0.15225644409656525, -0.28312939405441284, -0.23015090823173523, -0.30812540650367737, 0.38887742161750793, 0.5118374824523926, -0.48281386494636536, 0.23731471598148346, -0.3162485659122467, -0.19484201073646545, 0.9270114302635193, 0.25898054242134094, 0.32419824600219727, -0.5329493880271912, -0.35962894558906555, 0.046754445880651474, -0.8404188752174377, -0.5025117993354797, 0.5522366762161255, 0.2644018530845642, 0.06894879043102264, 0.8641306161880493, 0.23760941624641418, 0.45742273330688477, -0.11641017347574234, -0.10679277032613754, 0.2402186542749405, -0.2694126069545746, 0.026021020486950874, 0.28072962164878845, 0.9320833086967468, 0.3432094156742096, 0.4552321434020996, -0.16039308905601501, -0.3264155089855194, 0.10410003364086151, 0.3539150655269623, -0.6290148496627808, -0.048559628427028656, 0.17709146440029144, -0.369820237159729, -0.27885374426841736, 0.03407669439911842, -0.7059041857719421, -0.9835838675498962, -0.11525123566389084, 0.724518895149231, -0.3921447694301605, -0.16548728942871094, 0.15614333748817444, 0.021537791937589645, 0.23748832941055298, 0.32607218623161316, -0.8550600409507751, 0.415494829416275, 0.5245761871337891, 1.1024028062820435, -0.3865702152252197, -0.5295935273170471, -0.5169781446456909, 0.20715884864330292, -0.5342722535133362, 0.7963857054710388, -0.3411489427089691, -0.0192852932959795, -0.12460815906524658, -0.04280262812972069, 0.11427513509988785, -0.7815092206001282, 0.41451337933540344, -0.14598505198955536, 0.01032225787639618, -0.37922078371047974, -0.5177897214889526, -0.33197569847106934, -0.011234483681619167, -0.8671073317527771, 0.9134560823440552, 0.019076764583587646, -0.5605933666229248, 0.11403416842222214, -0.3340971767902374, -0.30015379190444946, -0.06867647916078568, -0.3484245836734772, -0.3443273901939392, 0.3577939569950104, 0.024189196527004242, 0.6338315010070801, -0.39068305492401123, 0.3805043697357178, -0.14489372074604034, -0.7286559343338013, 0.4916917383670807, -0.48514461517333984, 0.8774605393409729, -0.07484772056341171, -0.5525895357131958, 0.03945200517773628, -0.8813235759735107, -0.24715082347393036, 0.24988463521003723, -0.0376531220972538, -0.438622385263443, 0.007382682524621487, 0.21917882561683655, -0.10410775989294052, 0.10791072249412537, -0.4447225332260132, 0.2036859393119812, -0.2988186180591583, 0.15269307792186737, 0.8124666213989258, -0.08255716413259506, 0.06822095811367035, -0.6069686412811279, 0.43810930848121643, -0.2451360821723938, -0.23890316486358643, -0.07203880697488785, -0.4547562599182129, -0.6342650651931763, -0.4696277379989624, 0.3357769250869751, 0.5103800296783447, -0.32432037591934204, 0.7871745824813843, -0.27175894379615784, -0.6171177625656128, -0.6892021298408508, 0.002865823917090893, 0.4098365902900696, 0.04059173911809921, 0.2852569818496704, -0.3289615213871002, -0.5495193004608154, -0.861132800579071, -0.38930749893188477, -0.32780975103378296, -0.38620808720588684, 0.36689668893814087, 0.7862004637718201, -0.14911413192749023, 0.6039957404136658, -0.4407155513763428, -0.7598041296005249, -0.22736810147762299, 0.17833207547664642, 0.24139860272407532, 0.3496493995189667, 0.35155197978019714, -0.4547575116157532, -0.5559421181678772, -0.15358851850032806, -0.9979603290557861, -0.17174281179904938, -0.40971639752388, 0.07978233695030212, 0.47665753960609436, 0.29461175203323364, -0.6167175769805908, 0.5154282450675964, 0.528376042842865, -0.4586731195449829, 0.8716514110565186, -0.09780476242303848, 0.005891428329050541, -0.7739959359169006, 0.03539208695292473, 0.005885054357349873, -0.12273410707712173, -0.4194219410419464, -0.030418843030929565, 0.06605050712823868, 0.23603913187980652, -0.4092417359352112, 0.6494857668876648, -0.4814029037952423, -0.10288485139608383, -0.1277046948671341, 0.32409146428108215, -0.18045668303966522, 0.4959409236907959, 0.0024666411336511374, 0.5383702516555786, 0.3195567727088928, -0.5542848706245422, 0.3606327474117279, 0.20374377071857452, -0.7646982073783875, 0.30208414793014526, -0.6088578104972839, 0.14835307002067566, -0.025699373334646225, 0.18369615077972412, -0.9517035484313965, -0.35799816250801086, 0.2383660078048706, -0.40704113245010376, 0.11951785534620285, 0.43075093626976013, -0.7591807842254639, -0.016133805736899376, -0.43959033489227295, 0.4039574861526489, 0.44948282837867737, -0.5199466943740845, 0.6863933801651001, 0.1715974062681198, -0.011315499432384968, -0.5253687500953674, -0.9173346161842346, 0.2061697095632553, -0.31857192516326904, -0.4012524485588074, 0.29052215814590454, -0.08980527520179749, -0.43497955799102783, 0.18077805638313293, -0.09896796196699142, 0.20082014799118042, -0.16208569705486298, 0.42480042576789856, 0.3167235255241394, -0.15033215284347534, 0.04133792221546173, -0.33233633637428284, -0.17852678894996643, 0.13791713118553162, 0.2245115488767624, 0.45886391401290894, -0.2168533354997635, -0.5146525502204895, -0.5736224055290222, 0.2743150293827057, 0.405454158782959, 0.28669553995132446, 0.8648316860198975, 0.5826339721679688, -0.7431055903434753, -0.08538562804460526, -0.7953423857688904, -0.2345774620771408, -0.43323326110839844, 0.46492522954940796, -0.3462108373641968, -0.6702536940574646, 0.7168852686882019, 0.6256116032600403, -0.07196639478206635, 0.7242564558982849, 0.7235214114189148, 0.24528101086616516, 0.7699076533317566, 0.6883072257041931, -0.2952514588832855, 0.019140323624014854, -0.08746805042028427, 0.42044445872306824, -0.802779495716095, -0.15442028641700745, -0.5381810069084167, -0.3431750237941742, -0.65530925989151, -0.3202749788761139, 0.10416282713413239, -0.0036485514137893915, -0.005613365676254034, 0.41815099120140076, -0.5232779383659363, 0.7424631714820862, 0.5173026323318481, -0.014133917167782784, 0.6532081365585327, 0.14399661123752594, 0.3260095417499542, -0.17452941834926605, -0.3189859986305237, -0.7957785129547119, 1.4046229124069214, 0.4672122597694397, 0.7556384801864624, 0.29856210947036743, 0.6730929017066956, 0.4564879238605499, 0.3293772339820862, -0.9383774399757385, 0.7115932703018188, -0.007614918053150177, -1.06983482837677, -0.6919981241226196, -0.4130513370037079, -0.6183015704154968, 0.17277486622333527, -0.17418897151947021, -1.1569563150405884, 0.15093880891799927, -0.06355586647987366, -0.6555877327919006, 0.3667176365852356, -0.5481363534927368, 0.7032340168952942, -0.032177217304706573, -0.42911988496780396, -0.10171681642532349, -0.4523215889930725, 0.4670567512512207, -0.5325649380683899, 0.10243972390890121, -0.28566282987594604, -0.16238437592983246, 1.003871202468872, -0.19854006171226501, 0.8546876311302185, 0.026964854449033737, -0.24404092133045197, 0.3845597207546234, 0.22533071041107178, 0.7212951183319092, -0.14380352199077606, -0.3837617039680481, 0.3385818302631378, 0.15708355605602264, -0.29375162720680237, -0.5496659874916077, 0.5879510641098022, -0.833384096622467, -0.6035926938056946, -0.793502151966095, -0.6402384042739868, 0.0024107100907713175, 0.14749079942703247, 0.4349961578845978, 0.32358425855636597, -0.01380188949406147, 0.4235614240169525, 0.4291715621948242, -0.2715173661708832, 0.26815009117126465, 0.2877010703086853, -0.3516261577606201, -0.24235156178474426, 1.18796968460083, 0.2951408624649048, 0.191014364361763, 0.05263630300760269, 0.3043959140777588, -0.27836331725120544, -0.6093919277191162, -0.2153479903936386, 0.755994439125061, -0.7199183106422424, -0.06768875569105148, -0.7114074230194092, -0.38764768838882446, -0.2324475795030594, -0.3521663546562195, -0.4443286657333374, -0.2543811500072479, -0.4853529632091522, -0.03563380986452103, 0.24836194515228271, 0.9908913969993591, -0.05263958126306534, 0.4140525460243225, -0.4565296769142151, 0.28415778279304504, -0.04102170094847679, 0.2772505283355713, 0.26610416173934937, -0.9365673065185547, -0.37318721413612366, -0.40363892912864685, -0.3290715515613556, -0.9078546762466431, 0.5465427041053772, 0.05498504266142845, 0.26024383306503296, 0.6406408548355103, 0.3600256145000458, 0.786310613155365, -0.4485587179660797, 0.8377331495285034, 0.34890294075012207, -0.8524214625358582, 0.03866543993353844, -0.20813961327075958, 0.019061917439103127, 0.6026012301445007, 0.6669223308563232, -0.6000562310218811, -0.6695478558540344, -0.6731715202331543, -0.8097140192985535, 0.8106686472892761, 0.23084977269172668, 0.13617002964019775, 0.11342549324035645, 0.2799966633319855, 0.5693585872650146, 0.19381827116012573, -1.2269220352172852, -0.23380695283412933, 0.2157723605632782, -0.3282195031642914, -0.37167683243751526, -0.6270127892494202, -0.07174529880285263, -0.40469956398010254, 0.7278859615325928, 0.022660914808511734, 0.41967737674713135, 0.15630345046520233, -0.06507027894258499, -0.3521261513233185, 0.021603573113679886, 0.5931801199913025, 0.8270947933197021, -0.4571150839328766, 0.34571027755737305, 0.13634072244167328, -0.5259295701980591, 0.11045113205909729, -0.17193610966205597, -0.0782361775636673, 0.04376904293894768, 0.8550987243652344, 0.7209473252296448, -0.11935208737850189, -0.7424746751785278, 0.5668182969093323, 0.32593435049057007, -0.4643886983394623, -0.7596578001976013, 0.04540938884019852, -0.020748499780893326, 0.39328402280807495, 0.47692862153053284, -0.06533393263816833, 0.09406658262014389, -0.6741266846656799, 0.10480821877717972, 0.2389794886112213, -0.41969022154808044, -0.4452994465827942, 0.6358727216720581, -0.2347538024187088, -0.416443794965744, 0.5331339836120605, -0.42624250054359436, -0.3559158146381378, 0.399762362241745, 0.7123404741287231, 0.9933578372001648, 0.013840214349329472, 0.10844069719314575, 0.37971231341362, 0.5403993129730225, -0.31094834208488464, 0.06485188007354736, 0.31768667697906494, -0.6782647371292114, -0.3164297640323639, -0.8128167390823364, -0.2652982771396637, 0.5414965748786926, -0.38400161266326904, 0.33868566155433655, -0.2692585289478302, -0.03788105025887489, -0.013302011415362358, 0.1397922933101654, -0.43000927567481995, -0.15363521873950958, 0.09015093743801117, 0.464342325925827, -1.0693773031234741, 0.6499139070510864, 0.19033439457416534, -0.3810995817184448, -0.6760232448577881, 0.22448155283927917, 0.2206202894449234, -0.755283534526825, 0.36944153904914856, 0.48106512427330017, -0.06477004289627075, 0.03866632282733917, -0.4975498914718628, -0.8707122206687927, 0.9039637446403503, 0.340537428855896, -0.6338809132575989, -0.30147138237953186, 0.15750688314437866, 0.44497355818748474, -0.5116665363311768, 0.16818541288375854, 0.5506083965301514, 0.6097379326820374, 0.13096916675567627, -0.7601114511489868, 0.44739264249801636, 0.04171394184231758, -0.1323055475950241, 0.05804620683193207, -0.4429023861885071, 0.698049008846283, -0.3410767614841461, -0.25701966881752014, 0.21791398525238037, 0.6548183560371399, 0.4923883080482483, 0.4236512780189514, 0.6375442147254944, 0.3557528257369995, 0.8304389119148254, 0.06866461038589478, 1.0731931924819946, 0.030098646879196167, 0.16282182931900024, 1.0878961086273193, -0.22068482637405396, 0.9880363345146179, 0.7676555514335632, -0.3138028383255005, 0.36845269799232483, 0.642551064491272, -0.27278706431388855, 0.39428308606147766, 0.4387350082397461, -0.06469404697418213, -0.08569281548261642, -0.19459481537342072, -0.26415494084358215, 0.20384074747562408, 0.08853808045387268, -0.47520890831947327, 0.20095832645893097, -0.07021418958902359, 0.14423324167728424, 0.03279303014278412, -0.027771666646003723, 0.4439242482185364, 0.31811314821243286, -0.4276076555252075, 0.7766827344894409, -0.07463754713535309, 0.80183345079422, -0.49678367376327515, 0.16182704269886017, 0.003298812545835972, 0.2100122720003128, -0.49373388290405273, -0.5120777487754822, 0.5367879271507263, 0.13050368428230286, -0.11794604361057281, -0.036437515169382095, 0.5005477666854858, -0.2550426125526428, -0.7560469508171082, 0.2976435422897339, 0.3550558090209961, 0.8021007180213928, -0.47168779373168945, -0.19353508949279785, 0.3464655876159668, 0.13535432517528534, -0.6283934116363525, 0.17501048743724823, 0.6804050803184509, 0.030477231368422508, 0.6537513732910156, 0.3090493083000183, 0.4999058246612549, 0.03166433051228523, -0.1812608391046524, 0.4248964786529541, -1.017507791519165, -0.11243125051259995, -1.208044171333313, 0.30817726254463196, 0.11437039822340012, -0.22902214527130127, 1.0161136388778687, 0.5884795784950256, 0.6889144778251648, -0.000097329102572985, 0.7336730360984802, -0.009447772987186909, 0.4422277510166168, -0.44283679127693176, 0.83078533411026, -1.0116850137710571, 0.3972063362598419, -0.38736239075660706, -1.3197011947631836, -0.4618228077888489, 0.7176557183265686, -0.40212109684944153, -0.1389087438583374, 1.1508896350860596, 0.8414859771728516, 0.18888115882873535, 0.020353008061647415, 0.5338270664215088, 0.3289760649204254, 0.14227250218391418, 0.4643751382827759, 0.7316327691078186, -0.4405851364135742, 0.5166164636611938, -0.05047522485256195, -0.2839129865169525, -0.5531253218650818, -0.9895450472831726, -0.8644365668296814, -0.6655945777893066, -0.38464435935020447, -0.33410048484802246, -0.10208624601364136, 0.8216245174407959, 0.3577049970626831, -0.7940413951873779, -0.42510801553726196, 0.12545029819011688, 0.06009300798177719, -0.3120613098144531, -0.22682511806488037, 0.5840042233467102, -0.044000931084156036, -0.6348534822463989, 0.04963522404432297, 0.2007887065410614, 0.024829229339957237, -0.6814327239990234, -0.08525711297988892, -0.1009577140212059, 0.27067312598228455, 0.5474517345428467, -0.06060003861784935, -1.065622329711914, -0.5282332301139832, -0.06971702724695206, -0.2527926564216614, 0.0162750706076622, 0.5609357357025146, -0.4628627300262451, 0.25042685866355896, 0.171585813164711, 0.5984123945236206, 0.5104292035102844, -0.05178285390138626, 0.4346601366996765, -0.3943493366241455, -0.06822948157787323, 0.38470521569252014, 0.06451199948787689, 0.2946164608001709, -0.5105549097061157, 0.5986172556877136, 0.3360742926597595, -0.6647579669952393, -1.266549825668335, 0.07707872241735458, -0.9518312215805054, -0.24886293709278107, 1.4053962230682373, 0.16528700292110443, -0.468649297952652, -0.07133980095386505, -0.014207649044692516, 0.08620821684598923, -0.28423476219177246, 1.0830243825912476, 1.146116018295288, -0.1308058500289917, 0.07546651363372803, -0.9993820786476135, 0.5540503263473511, 0.47753289341926575, -0.5772396326065063, 0.4320322573184967, 0.6495580673217773, -0.12291044741868973, 0.5063223242759705, 0.8939067721366882, -0.11888804286718369, -0.14346139132976532, 0.26076459884643555, 0.36498603224754333, -0.14999423921108246, -0.640333890914917, -0.18167434632778168, 0.15522237122058868, 0.16093355417251587, 0.08457212150096893 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04626v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04626v1
Towards Analyzing and Understanding the Limitations of DPO: A Theoretical Perspective
2024-04-06T13:24:37
2024-04-06T13:24:37
Duanyu Feng, Bowen Qin, Chen Huang, Zheng Zhang, Wenqiang Lei
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), which derives reward signals directly from pairwise preference data, has shown its effectiveness on aligning Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences. Despite its widespread use across various tasks, DPO has been criticized for its sensitivity to the SFT's effectiveness and its hindrance to the learning capacity towards human-preferred responses, leading to less satisfactory performance. To overcome those limitations, the theoretical understanding of DPO are indispensable but still lacking. To this end, we take a step towards theoretically analyzing and understanding the limitations of DPO. Specifically, we provide an analytical framework using the field theory to analyze the optimization process of DPO. By analyzing the gradient vector field of the DPO loss function, we find that the DPO loss function decreases the probability of producing human dispreferred data at a faster rate than it increases the probability of producing preferred data. This provides theoretical insights for understanding the limitations of DPO discovered in the related research experiments, thereby setting the foundation for its improvement.
[ -0.6197987198829651, -0.4798635244369507, 0.7690547704696655, 0.27836886048316956, -0.1298353374004364, -0.06088525429368019, -0.1343061625957489, -0.3480518162250519, -0.2376260757446289, 0.35703495144844055, -0.719723105430603, -0.019728492945432663, -0.5611391663551331, 0.4236105680465698, -0.02417479082942009, 0.6974444389343262, -0.2587745189666748, -0.08882762491703033, -0.4941578507423401, 0.14954154193401337, -0.41790661215782166, -0.6130527257919312, -0.5726173520088196, -0.5101590156555176, 0.2404577136039734, 0.5402535796165466, 0.35434284806251526, 0.6958115100860596, 0.7733871936798096, 0.2672346234321594, -0.13025179505348206, -0.15959317982196808, -0.8247631788253784, 0.08310609310865402, -0.06086250767111778, -0.6147317290306091, -0.3529755175113678, 0.1885235607624054, 0.7163795828819275, 0.8578459024429321, 0.06911513209342957, -0.2319650799036026, 0.23067638278007507, 1.0661587715148926, -0.5275652408599854, -0.011074569076299667, -0.6412566900253296, 0.25558629631996155, -0.050362251698970795, -0.5486648082733154, -0.14495544135570526, -0.05510302633047104, 0.516564667224884, -0.698520302772522, 0.4539010226726532, -0.206369087100029, 0.5569202303886414, 0.30913224816322327, -0.5690922737121582, -0.06126454845070839, -1.013787031173706, 0.8803420662879944, -0.20772965252399445, 0.18520894646644592, 0.6553705930709839, 0.17291434109210968, -0.35073786973953247, 0.004397268872708082, -0.7061011791229248, -0.32538139820098877, -0.027082534506917, 0.03237999230623245, -0.10035835206508636, 0.35788989067077637, 0.3477801978588104, 0.708564043045044, -0.2527848482131958, 0.10295893251895905, -0.1675615906715393, 0.020087501034140587, 0.7929327487945557, 0.33291083574295044, -0.10048811137676239, -0.20266912877559662, -0.6305204629898071, -0.055606283247470856, -0.5620676279067993, 0.3768133819103241, 0.6593121886253357, 0.051478561013936996, 0.12826161086559296, 0.3437954783439636, -0.41229912638664246, 0.7721608281135559, 0.2647682726383209, -0.05421639233827591, 0.1036776676774025, -0.04698437452316284, -0.12655922770500183, -0.4081789255142212, 0.6823370456695557, 0.479033887386322, -0.06210392713546753, -0.024815190583467484, -0.15684033930301666, 0.042462486773729324, 0.12142086029052734, -0.510166585445404, 0.2851819396018982, 0.31699907779693604, -0.37058913707733154, -0.8025685548782349, -0.16990306973457336, -0.9049788117408752, -0.4741939604282379, -0.27253493666648865, 0.11190154403448105, -0.3615771234035492, -0.5049197673797607, 0.2504953444004059, -0.35709264874458313, -0.026569513604044914, 0.020621823146939278, -1.246795415878296, 0.49498024582862854, 0.6601747870445251, 0.7678050398826599, -0.286929190158844, -0.3128184676170349, -0.25874900817871094, -0.059756629168987274, -0.04135116934776306, 0.6319186687469482, -0.4552088975906372, -0.7758079767227173, -0.0804770439863205, -0.45979028940200806, -0.08483635634183884, -0.5224822759628296, 0.9293453693389893, -0.514782726764679, -0.2709941864013672, -0.6644937992095947, -0.6099843382835388, -0.023124009370803833, 0.14414680004119873, -0.7516070604324341, 0.7669607996940613, 0.19156800210475922, -0.7807687520980835, 0.542923092842102, -0.49375513195991516, -0.33929964900016785, -0.039031982421875, -0.3405783176422119, -0.10303148627281189, 0.4469245672225952, -0.26303336024284363, 0.3970029652118683, -0.37915945053100586, 0.4160792827606201, -0.5624507665634155, -0.4899210035800934, 0.46351221203804016, -0.14993751049041748, 0.6880668997764587, 0.22381959855556488, -0.33539170026779175, -0.19982187449932098, -0.9661707878112793, -0.5331538915634155, 0.3216381371021271, -0.3962310552597046, -0.5535550713539124, 0.46801888942718506, -0.4374186396598816, 0.09262624382972717, -0.08018627017736435, -0.638047993183136, 0.3999290466308594, -0.38154980540275574, 0.6545747518539429, 1.1324412822723389, -0.40500685572624207, 0.8107549548149109, -0.13721637427806854, 0.6559493541717529, -0.11588667333126068, 0.2612573504447937, 0.3308373689651489, 0.04629415646195412, -0.4641048312187195, -0.3373644948005676, 0.08971910923719406, 0.5133177638053894, -0.4458509385585785, 0.4629221260547638, -0.13395585119724274, -0.029079699888825417, -0.1578538566827774, 0.04394537955522537, 0.044054850935935974, 1.0948283672332764, 0.10844827443361282, -0.13901865482330322, -0.49550148844718933, -1.1654917001724243, 0.08758863061666489, -0.21119467914104462, 0.1344124972820282, 0.41072049736976624, 0.27551430463790894, -0.026735957711935043, 1.058915376663208, -0.6697579622268677, -0.20167911052703857, -0.22417759895324707, -0.26227766275405884, 0.24978449940681458, 0.3168865144252777, 0.5066148638725281, -0.8535541892051697, -0.3583894371986389, -0.19533836841583252, -0.5197344422340393, -0.25826340913772583, 0.20975802838802338, -0.1375492960214615, -0.013984202407300472, -0.08677923679351807, -0.5748351216316223, 0.339078813791275, 0.5917435884475708, -0.17088009417057037, 0.5742603540420532, -0.019574781879782677, 0.19199499487876892, -0.3982466757297516, 0.19698232412338257, 0.18618860840797424, 0.15068437159061432, -0.715598464012146, -0.31223344802856445, -0.08550246804952621, -0.27403524518013, -0.038768794387578964, 0.48241204023361206, -0.15915405750274658, -0.04919576272368431, -0.44588467478752136, 0.05034086853265762, 0.19263534247875214, 0.4591233432292938, 0.2826807498931885, 0.6123762726783752, 0.5272928476333618, -1.073531150817871, 0.34522831439971924, 0.35387030243873596, 0.032346855849027634, 0.6046385765075684, -0.7178093194961548, 0.06314072012901306, -0.3260441720485687, 0.26859578490257263, -1.0168087482452393, 0.021515386179089546, 0.42361944913864136, -0.3242837190628052, 0.28893396258354187, -0.18119442462921143, -0.05174435302615166, -0.44514045119285583, -0.5630235075950623, 0.47086089849472046, 0.42947548627853394, -0.522584855556488, 0.07659682631492615, 0.2498255968093872, 0.19944757223129272, -0.9399365782737732, -0.3025270104408264, -0.42957139015197754, -0.45893800258636475, -0.6911428570747375, 0.6601930856704712, -0.023140352219343185, -0.42784997820854187, -0.16100355982780457, -0.3250599503517151, 0.12199433892965317, 0.2614935040473938, 0.10728807747364044, 0.24219337105751038, 0.3026292622089386, 0.39508819580078125, 0.049491580575704575, -0.2864704728126526, 0.12853378057479858, -0.15546393394470215, 0.4608389139175415, 0.06711827218532562, 0.041613075882196426, -0.47167813777923584, 0.4800429344177246, 0.18579624593257904, -0.05370998755097389, 0.3046562671661377, 0.040011223405599594, 0.0019947702530771494, -0.3592384159564972, -0.2677077054977417, -0.1803276687860489, -0.5015579462051392, 0.34972909092903137, -0.7096327543258667, -0.6446602940559387, 0.3849242031574249, -0.10818050056695938, -0.23764824867248535, 0.7189335227012634, 0.10470608621835709, 0.03781162574887276, 0.8671851754188538, 0.7465357780456543, -0.03129842132329941, 0.5533441305160522, -0.3509801924228668, -0.06635528802871704, -1.014543890953064, -0.19189907610416412, -0.4669126868247986, -0.4104788601398468, -0.5613366365432739, 0.006349206902086735, 0.16123513877391815, 0.37101489305496216, -0.02232496626675129, 0.05231895670294762, -0.675325334072113, 0.21536920964717865, 0.6148489713668823, 0.13367091119289398, 0.37313777208328247, 0.22109991312026978, -0.060876596719026566, -0.15537381172180176, -0.649012565612793, -0.45694947242736816, 1.1715737581253052, 0.5583581924438477, 0.5648859143257141, -0.20698776841163635, 0.7530733942985535, 0.21533316373825073, -0.1392621546983719, -0.9379117488861084, 0.4569288492202759, -0.06829237937927246, -0.6567111015319824, -0.3937646150588989, -0.5274174809455872, -0.9101778864860535, 0.28681206703186035, -0.18060117959976196, -0.6089023351669312, 0.42381641268730164, 0.572648286819458, -0.2942116856575012, 0.16499386727809906, -0.5066262483596802, 0.7135818600654602, -0.38156694173812866, -0.6915774941444397, -0.18437552452087402, -0.413028359413147, 0.37718161940574646, 0.16987410187721252, 0.06771758198738098, -0.5010285973548889, -0.11699006706476212, 0.6805082559585571, -0.19197973608970642, 0.6103653311729431, -0.34371814131736755, -0.1800810843706131, 0.25060686469078064, 0.003533859271556139, 0.43367651104927063, 0.20408780872821808, -0.3903626501560211, 0.23645642399787903, -0.02289709262549877, -0.40797585248947144, -0.39926648139953613, 0.7217053174972534, -0.7810855507850647, -0.7598915696144104, -0.5540410280227661, -0.35051363706588745, -0.4378989040851593, 0.007676982786506414, 0.4263109266757965, 0.1590668261051178, -0.4525638818740845, -0.3068915903568268, 0.6306883692741394, -0.37061992287635803, 0.19334004819393158, 0.36999499797821045, -0.0928148478269577, -0.27356386184692383, 0.6605886220932007, -0.010528579354286194, 0.22400230169296265, 0.5988268852233887, 0.5465955138206482, -0.33336201310157776, -0.8509675860404968, -0.2604832649230957, 0.3150782287120819, -0.6427299976348877, 0.15088805556297302, -0.20357191562652588, 0.39082616567611694, -0.2533329725265503, -0.023462871089577675, -0.13561907410621643, -0.29154837131500244, -0.38152745366096497, -0.14776301383972168, 0.29214298725128174, 0.5704405307769775, -0.12315479665994644, 0.2750840187072754, -0.43939679861068726, 0.16923579573631287, 0.256249338388443, 0.6945033073425293, -0.16111008822917938, -0.33982184529304504, 0.01802964136004448, 0.1540343165397644, -0.585433304309845, -0.9490516781806946, 0.16029126942157745, -0.15953095257282257, 0.6619848012924194, 0.30089235305786133, 0.1813802570104599, 0.3751589357852936, -0.46109434962272644, 0.4238480031490326, 0.1857832670211792, -1.084707498550415, 0.7261707186698914, -0.5935178995132446, -0.21938946843147278, 0.6210189461708069, 0.5481878519058228, -0.40940362215042114, 0.32197079062461853, -0.610292375087738, -0.8442888259887695, 0.850623607635498, 0.02865021303296089, 0.08930890262126923, 0.0159151554107666, 0.7356959581375122, 0.40710946917533875, 0.2473917007446289, -0.48636525869369507, -0.29445329308509827, 0.030374933034181595, 0.035501811653375626, -0.2078966349363327, -0.47933492064476013, -0.3988895118236542, -0.2937515377998352, 0.5568784475326538, 0.03678348287940025, 0.5555586218833923, 0.531502902507782, 0.14755326509475708, -0.34166818857192993, 0.21113556623458862, 0.8158193230628967, 0.7999845147132874, -0.49933329224586487, -0.02565363235771656, -0.11978118121623993, -0.31417137384414673, 0.4032304883003235, 0.37976017594337463, -0.2527922987937927, -0.1876799464225769, 0.1782025396823883, 1.0348849296569824, -0.2509920299053192, -0.5457519888877869, 0.5318713188171387, -0.027624107897281647, -0.523158073425293, -0.28763291239738464, -0.13789993524551392, -0.3140375316143036, 0.018670283257961273, 0.6272714734077454, 0.012243427336215973, 0.3829963803291321, -0.321564257144928, 0.07493899017572403, 0.5986160039901733, -0.32585108280181885, -0.39861953258514404, 0.6249099969863892, 0.8376814723014832, -0.18495234847068787, 0.34765222668647766, -0.015249225310981274, -0.5641768574714661, 0.6539567708969116, 0.34548047184944153, 0.7522568106651306, 0.017604056745767593, 0.39166781306266785, 0.21833863854408264, -0.0232192762196064, -0.07573281973600388, -0.04812673106789589, -0.24042147397994995, -0.8855418562889099, -0.4370015263557434, -0.6394156217575073, -0.35185784101486206, 0.3369871973991394, -0.6177754402160645, 0.21020741760730743, -0.5250343084335327, -0.38568034768104553, 0.15526911616325378, 0.2038922756910324, -0.7194392085075378, 0.054239895194768906, -0.04910246655344963, 0.46433010697364807, -0.672092616558075, 0.5703150033950806, 0.4839117228984833, -0.1868678331375122, -0.48899415135383606, -0.0055621652863919735, -0.028271082788705826, -1.008786678314209, 1.0827652215957642, -0.0007143449620343745, -0.2963455617427826, -0.05355702340602875, -0.20150317251682281, -0.6505424380302429, 0.8531128168106079, 0.46142080426216125, -0.6911411881446838, 0.1689075529575348, 0.17078493535518646, 0.49590080976486206, -0.2028651386499405, -0.08946739882230759, 0.6293449401855469, 0.34833261370658875, -0.07151517271995544, -0.8722733855247498, 0.17918288707733154, 0.05830581113696098, 0.05957416817545891, 0.480035662651062, -0.7149407267570496, 0.6596260070800781, -0.10989288985729218, -0.14444132149219513, -0.3911289870738983, 0.1386563926935196, 0.09507865458726883, 0.41783466935157776, 0.6714096665382385, 0.347612202167511, 0.441101610660553, 0.0763348937034607, 1.3167270421981812, -0.05960070341825485, 0.6128851175308228, 0.4021521210670471, -0.4484460949897766, 0.6319571137428284, 0.8807748556137085, -0.693057656288147, -0.0018475158140063286, 0.6908507347106934, 0.21696177124977112, 0.5030268430709839, 0.7143375873565674, -0.5220178961753845, 0.026689723134040833, -0.04891194775700569, -0.4110647141933441, 0.6144898533821106, -0.1258210390806198, -0.5039034485816956, 0.3455955684185028, -0.14145255088806152, -0.2558141350746155, 0.3055955767631531, -0.2676754891872406, 0.5157929062843323, -0.0637478306889534, -0.7609926462173462, 0.7446081638336182, -0.11311560124158859, 0.7354381084442139, -0.5114935636520386, 0.07945834845304489, -0.32126584649086, 0.45891451835632324, -0.22388392686843872, -0.4329723119735718, 0.3235126733779907, -0.29262465238571167, -0.30028265714645386, -0.2760832607746124, 0.7921304702758789, -0.26143085956573486, -0.2673829197883606, 0.49541276693344116, 0.20317673683166504, -0.32020702958106995, -0.07410913705825806, -0.5378810167312622, 0.3854219317436218, 0.0992572158575058, -0.47016850113868713, 0.40357476472854614, 0.17437642812728882, 0.4576364755630493, 0.580314576625824, 0.3777581453323364, 0.17129118740558624, -0.4706955850124359, -0.38830193877220154, 0.7299187779426575, -0.5680457949638367, -0.4295036792755127, -1.1114697456359863, 0.3408642113208771, -0.21325978636741638, -0.34370625019073486, 0.5362443923950195, 0.376456081867218, 0.9033767580986023, -0.26306524872779846, 1.162470817565918, -0.15467911958694458, 0.43747052550315857, -0.4395504891872406, 0.2011358141899109, -0.654670774936676, 0.47556254267692566, -0.4139000177383423, -0.7665682435035706, -0.04433959722518921, 0.6613349318504333, -0.5281836986541748, -0.0613451823592186, 0.732611894607544, 0.3357989192008972, 0.22131597995758057, -0.07651108503341675, 0.331307590007782, -0.33747556805610657, 0.18896134197711945, 0.7428247332572937, 0.8979489803314209, -0.1786826103925705, 0.6890038847923279, -0.801339328289032, -0.6529077291488647, -0.28714296221733093, -0.9377508759498596, -0.795073390007019, -0.6854487657546997, -0.09391596913337708, -0.1406230628490448, -0.08731537312269211, 0.6418272256851196, 0.5558227896690369, -0.3203088045120239, -0.49000340700149536, -0.3937017321586609, 0.20005761086940765, -0.4070606231689453, -0.24023395776748657, 0.20224866271018982, -0.11914602667093277, -0.8701692819595337, 0.25820037722587585, 0.23072375357151031, 0.12427756935358047, -0.17190098762512207, -0.3246442675590515, -0.03844289481639862, -0.1395980417728424, 0.7142593860626221, 0.4347292184829712, -0.5203465223312378, -0.2613505721092224, 0.19866497814655304, 0.13844652473926544, 0.009389902465045452, 1.344551920890808, -0.44964319467544556, 0.4637836217880249, 0.6599571108818054, 0.6109710931777954, 0.4585585296154022, 0.057271555066108704, 1.032933235168457, -0.5556519031524658, 0.2894793152809143, 0.32927557826042175, 0.11553872376680374, 0.15323960781097412, -0.6740749478340149, 0.5069724917411804, 0.5982066988945007, -0.5951579809188843, -0.8129823207855225, 0.6608574390411377, -1.0255939960479736, -0.20002257823944092, 1.2602686882019043, 0.12441188097000122, 0.08656297624111176, 0.15087483823299408, -0.29083332419395447, 0.15374450385570526, -0.6053739190101624, 0.8432907462120056, 0.8337417840957642, -0.6736189723014832, 0.08118342608213425, -0.5784851312637329, 1.0015476942062378, 0.6001944541931152, -0.4266088306903839, 0.2957024574279785, 0.5145308971405029, 0.3702315092086792, -0.10300696641206741, 1.0784882307052612, 0.247783362865448, -0.057087939232587814, 0.12334940582513809, -0.16405455768108368, -0.28909802436828613, 0.1210162565112114, -0.6752713918685913, 0.07719440013170242, 0.3695303797721863, -0.49529045820236206 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08675v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08675v1
RecGPT: Generative Personalized Prompts for Sequential Recommendation via ChatGPT Training Paradigm
2024-04-06T12:38:54
2024-04-06T12:38:54
Yabin Zhang, Wenhui Yu, Erhan Zhang, Xu Chen, Lantao Hu, Peng Jiang, Kun Gai
cs.IR
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
ChatGPT has achieved remarkable success in natural language understanding. Considering that recommendation is indeed a conversation between users and the system with items as words, which has similar underlying pattern with ChatGPT, we design a new chat framework in item index level for the recommendation task. Our novelty mainly contains three parts: model, training and inference. For the model part, we adopt Generative Pre-training Transformer (GPT) as the sequential recommendation model and design a user modular to capture personalized information. For the training part, we adopt the two-stage paradigm of ChatGPT, including pre-training and fine-tuning. In the pre-training stage, we train GPT model by auto-regression. In the fine-tuning stage, we train the model with prompts, which include both the newly-generated results from the model and the user's feedback. For the inference part, we predict several user interests as user representations in an autoregressive manner. For each interest vector, we recall several items with the highest similarity and merge the items recalled by all interest vectors into the final result. We conduct experiments with both offline public datasets and online A/B test to demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method.
[ -0.5195232629776001, -0.8532065749168396, 0.4356635510921478, 0.2722371816635132, -0.2183498740196228, -0.05527045950293541, -0.03254646807909012, 0.009635434485971928, 0.2902012765407562, 0.33227798342704773, -0.9099780917167664, -0.4937538504600525, -0.28031396865844727, 0.006869335193186998, -0.47488129138946533, 1.358291745185852, 0.1556381732225418, -0.13541439175605774, 0.056374773383140564, 0.1206895187497139, -1.0292235612869263, -0.36098936200141907, -1.064435362815857, -0.23538564145565033, 0.5586278438568115, 0.5222565531730652, 0.4191901981830597, 0.2359144687652588, 0.20794276893138885, 0.28513196110725403, 0.2213856428861618, 0.09856289625167847, -0.6352900862693787, 0.3759801983833313, -0.1730838119983673, -0.3391280472278595, -0.12819121778011322, -0.09315604716539383, 0.28273141384124756, 0.4422000050544739, -0.5465826392173767, -0.039123471826314926, 0.36187052726745605, 0.7660422325134277, -0.19311079382896423, 0.27831923961639404, -0.5096215605735779, 0.2728996276855469, 0.03933443874120712, -0.2004825472831726, -0.4751298427581787, -0.43071895837783813, 0.6307148337364197, -0.743989884853363, 0.6165241599082947, 0.390704870223999, 0.6039923429489136, 0.10816356539726257, -0.25594189763069153, -0.15457651019096375, -0.8108617663383484, 0.3847716152667999, -0.4175341725349426, 0.26400935649871826, 0.47671782970428467, 0.575775146484375, -0.21836017072200775, -0.9796128273010254, -0.5543066263198853, -0.39969155192375183, -0.1674523651599884, 0.09277814626693726, -0.1319722682237625, 0.06475790590047836, 0.0814385786652565, 0.6177518963813782, -0.8054304718971252, -0.142598494887352, 0.02920863963663578, 0.0482233501970768, 0.3690537214279175, 0.1886056661605835, 0.11881560832262039, 0.016155121847987175, -0.6715443134307861, -0.1574033498764038, -0.49169889092445374, -0.07519499212503433, 0.2478824257850647, 0.2569783926010132, -0.1266646534204483, 0.5192134380340576, -0.5158879160881042, 0.702971875667572, 0.5742121934890747, 0.3711737096309662, 0.3349214792251587, -0.6009840965270996, -0.1268738955259323, -0.11190193146467209, 0.9551058411598206, 0.44638770818710327, 0.37805476784706116, -0.1030256375670433, -0.043059270828962326, -0.25879785418510437, 0.2389911711215973, -0.759273111820221, -0.6413604617118835, -0.05851028487086296, -0.5221974849700928, -0.2927866280078888, 0.07327305525541306, -0.6944898366928101, -0.5388394594192505, -0.18469813466072083, 0.45085278153419495, -0.4045608639717102, -0.015011174604296684, 0.20671483874320984, 0.040520645678043365, -0.04950818419456482, 0.5003423094749451, -1.1666185855865479, 0.16038019955158234, 0.49896708130836487, 0.8485250473022461, -0.20070551335811615, -0.2858753800392151, -0.48478084802627563, -0.19076280295848846, 0.1803773194551468, 1.2210965156555176, -0.716598391532898, -0.7323710918426514, 0.05528924986720085, 0.010654425248503685, -0.024340692907571793, -0.1844373345375061, 0.462336927652359, -0.49441367387771606, 0.7809986472129822, -0.23410338163375854, -0.6442657113075256, -0.30777764320373535, 0.3916917145252228, -0.2998540699481964, 0.9603307247161865, 0.17194631695747375, -0.7712873816490173, 0.4482342004776001, -0.8171234726905823, -0.37053173780441284, 0.36311420798301697, -0.10403414815664291, -0.23660136759281158, -0.1513630896806717, 0.324591726064682, 0.448805034160614, -0.38957515358924866, 0.2693788707256317, -0.3461473286151886, -0.3540804088115692, 0.04243558645248413, -0.6218608021736145, 0.07938487827777863, 0.31752681732177734, -0.09395081549882889, 0.4648227095603943, -0.5500091910362244, -0.22387480735778809, 0.130235493183136, -0.1312316656112671, -0.08863360434770584, 0.06402987986803055, 0.12480410188436508, -0.022250832989811897, 0.333219438791275, -0.47302567958831787, 0.4763799011707306, -0.4103867709636688, 0.5538279414176941, 0.7988319993019104, 0.3742169141769409, 0.4188738763332367, -0.52608722448349, 0.47515183687210083, -0.13864949345588684, 0.11119724810123444, -0.7006140351295471, -0.6593159437179565, -0.63306725025177, 0.12129857391119003, 0.2683597803115845, 0.6508187055587769, -0.7113009095191956, 0.7282699346542358, -0.09169839322566986, -0.20008525252342224, -0.21988646686077118, -0.1451837718486786, 0.1134861409664154, 0.5117584466934204, 0.2766367197036743, -0.5886510610580444, -0.4806474447250366, -0.7396899461746216, -0.10071047395467758, -0.3009682595729828, -0.37754231691360474, 0.5908681154251099, 0.0855654776096344, -0.49954262375831604, 1.106918215751648, -0.8644922375679016, -0.5016270279884338, -0.20841234922409058, 0.4656101167201996, 0.39975792169570923, 0.27998268604278564, 0.2839813232421875, -0.6125394701957703, -0.7522040009498596, -0.10613987594842911, -0.2755286693572998, -0.03068576566874981, -0.22724850475788116, -0.11292778700590134, -0.33055248856544495, 0.14695137739181519, -0.3962782919406891, 0.26916933059692383, 0.13588160276412964, -0.5039897561073303, 0.20074978470802307, -0.46993210911750793, 0.15812286734580994, -1.2916229963302612, -0.2744300663471222, 0.15685606002807617, -0.30457785725593567, -0.5132721662521362, -0.5650116205215454, -0.3948743939399719, -0.2212914526462555, -0.07031145691871643, 0.6731357574462891, -0.01672416180372238, 0.260799765586853, -0.43763765692710876, 0.11068464815616608, -0.19354034960269928, 0.8139118552207947, 0.06981682777404785, 0.7213311195373535, 0.3531101942062378, -0.47537603974342346, 0.4491232633590698, 0.5916646122932434, -0.3974839150905609, 0.667819082736969, -0.8947563767433167, 0.4184066951274872, -0.11235062032938004, 0.5026655197143555, -1.3664377927780151, -0.053412191569805145, 0.44364774227142334, -0.3149104118347168, -0.06267153471708298, -0.33085790276527405, -0.3486221730709076, -0.2940594553947449, -0.1949092000722885, 0.21778886020183563, 0.584761381149292, -0.5282546877861023, 0.4591372609138489, 0.10076194256544113, -0.4097200930118561, -0.32748326659202576, -0.16927163302898407, -0.08631792664527893, -0.12874910235404968, -0.5297317504882812, 0.39518100023269653, -0.4414139986038208, 0.3730444014072418, -0.0806414932012558, 0.20169727504253387, 0.0886005237698555, -0.0817112848162651, 0.37464767694473267, 0.2266242653131485, -0.02233336865901947, 0.13545267283916473, -0.21142202615737915, -0.40205642580986023, -0.19509026408195496, -0.7422779202461243, 0.858749270439148, -0.2755652070045471, -0.3274143636226654, -0.5758216381072998, 0.2912704646587372, 0.05208780616521835, -0.08825062960386276, 0.4586319327354431, 1.070868730545044, -0.022452855482697487, -0.014943008311092854, -0.7252403497695923, -0.37912899255752563, -0.49005863070487976, 0.432379812002182, -0.3096812963485718, -1.1033093929290771, 0.29044944047927856, 0.03494536504149437, 0.12071464955806732, 0.2359139621257782, 0.7319591045379639, -0.14637306332588196, 1.080112099647522, 0.5105236172676086, -0.2774199843406677, 0.9842320084571838, -0.23309653997421265, 0.12115290760993958, -0.6453150510787964, -0.12935148179531097, -0.2142048180103302, -0.2112477421760559, -0.7211506962776184, -0.1329042762517929, 0.20947149395942688, -0.04430785030126572, -0.5113081932067871, 0.22146546840667725, -0.4833470284938812, 0.4126285910606384, 0.830579400062561, 0.2206215262413025, 0.20401038229465485, 0.1140139251947403, -0.04295859485864639, 0.10548916459083557, -0.5914997458457947, -0.18352240324020386, 0.8063342571258545, 0.26433065533638, 0.8460797071456909, -0.18443839251995087, 0.5321927070617676, 0.6766918301582336, 0.24572817981243134, -0.8613470792770386, 0.34328553080558777, -0.12678182125091553, -0.26598185300827026, -0.25956395268440247, -0.21164675056934357, -1.078279733657837, 0.08643677085638046, -0.20694005489349365, -0.6957157850265503, 0.2539352774620056, 0.46246787905693054, -0.6417397856712341, -0.12329806387424469, -0.8756765127182007, 0.8991438746452332, 0.03392871096730232, -0.1729036122560501, -0.29677653312683105, -0.5796117186546326, 0.07694067060947418, 0.05534059926867485, -0.19579081237316132, -0.2000104784965515, 0.25747549533843994, 0.6362522840499878, -0.2885337471961975, 0.9572397470474243, -0.306486576795578, 0.2312198281288147, 0.22762158513069153, 0.0631219819188118, 0.8718456029891968, 0.34421223402023315, 0.22367142140865326, -0.08262335509061813, -0.20663675665855408, -0.10168367624282837, -0.726655900478363, 0.642907440662384, -0.5807422399520874, -0.704829216003418, -0.289425253868103, -0.24641047418117523, -0.28023573756217957, 0.37568262219429016, 0.3247641623020172, 0.4306698143482208, -0.4175909459590912, 0.25512537360191345, 0.5215986371040344, -0.18909163773059845, 0.24527448415756226, 0.6015245318412781, -0.2007390558719635, -0.5485435724258423, 0.8946024179458618, -0.49382731318473816, -0.0930052325129509, 0.6583030223846436, 0.4103887975215912, -0.45327824354171753, -0.5134367346763611, -0.33321622014045715, 0.06272023916244507, -0.4440595507621765, -0.0017953375354409218, -0.6206476092338562, -0.00887331087142229, -0.25752630829811096, 0.02235473319888115, -0.1461150050163269, -0.12022430449724197, -0.33778712153434753, 0.03882630914449692, 0.5536836981773376, 0.9287293553352356, 0.28614625334739685, 0.485243022441864, -0.7657701373100281, 0.39623579382896423, 0.5866150259971619, 0.5245195627212524, -0.01065401453524828, -0.64345383644104, -0.21644891798496246, 0.10222707688808441, -0.3040143549442291, -0.5282914638519287, 0.4956699013710022, 0.2051863968372345, 0.42455151677131653, 0.6222150325775146, 0.05816275253891945, 0.454290509223938, -0.850817084312439, 0.773955762386322, 0.2423703819513321, -0.47015318274497986, 0.5265973806381226, -0.5586461424827576, 0.40238967537879944, 0.6600629687309265, 0.3372318744659424, -0.9486525058746338, 0.029108816757798195, -0.5367180705070496, -0.7474821209907532, 0.7238094806671143, 0.24284628033638, 0.13066008687019348, -0.17611482739448547, 0.3893042504787445, 0.3035125136375427, 0.28605368733406067, -0.36787110567092896, -0.4227053225040436, -0.31527286767959595, -0.3358585238456726, -0.22303542494773865, -0.4852072298526764, 0.19132371246814728, 0.05491779372096062, 0.5200023651123047, 0.009196070954203606, 0.58175128698349, 0.17083477973937988, 0.15290619432926178, 0.3051014244556427, 0.2054535448551178, 0.4179133474826813, 0.22726623713970184, -0.36803239583969116, -0.31752511858940125, 0.10089831054210663, -0.4847067892551422, 0.1516088992357254, 0.30991336703300476, -0.043384190648794174, -0.19490012526512146, -0.12741783261299133, 1.1278934478759766, 0.38126444816589355, -0.18378609418869019, 0.44788265228271484, -0.6247360110282898, -0.07270033657550812, -0.6462113857269287, 0.12335525453090668, -0.08085330575704575, 0.2532651126384735, 0.20493891835212708, 0.2797154486179352, 0.3224851191043854, -0.4184652864933014, 0.1955002248287201, 0.3232588768005371, -0.5177053213119507, -0.3605349361896515, 0.6207517385482788, 0.5952485799789429, -0.5753926634788513, 0.7094056010246277, -0.29279568791389465, -0.24185378849506378, -0.04941433668136597, 0.3411337435245514, 1.3051750659942627, -0.15652334690093994, 0.30168616771698, 0.344085156917572, -0.22706016898155212, -0.3625616431236267, -0.04466787353157997, -0.5984792709350586, -0.9607056975364685, -0.14757505059242249, -0.4530702233314514, -0.47967466711997986, -0.003973630256950855, -0.5550001263618469, 0.3066951334476471, -0.18356552720069885, -0.05313236266374588, -0.11685918271541595, -0.10988673567771912, -0.7017498016357422, -0.1401934027671814, -0.0845794528722763, 0.5660982728004456, -0.5748216509819031, 0.8111841082572937, 0.47562336921691895, -0.3963070809841156, -0.4770985543727875, 0.05564670264720917, -0.11297742277383804, -0.8700919151306152, 0.526966392993927, 0.09494653344154358, -0.02646772749722004, 0.33855772018432617, -0.0898735374212265, -0.7719575762748718, 0.9627681374549866, 0.08522792160511017, -0.7177512645721436, -0.23583385348320007, -0.20714466273784637, 0.4784373939037323, -0.5561474561691284, 0.5158970952033997, 0.39038994908332825, 0.29046544432640076, 0.34126603603363037, -0.8293584585189819, -0.1796620637178421, -0.3471886217594147, 0.15834307670593262, 0.14753596484661102, -0.3677118718624115, 0.6252849102020264, -0.2177554965019226, -0.30182698369026184, 0.22535336017608643, 0.7346743941307068, 0.17467382550239563, 0.1732354760169983, 0.8579245209693909, 0.3130457103252411, 0.6151800751686096, -0.014399830251932144, 1.3035149574279785, -0.2939928472042084, 0.4296633005142212, 1.3948438167572021, -0.2372579127550125, 0.6706108450889587, -0.04417882114648819, -0.22618956863880157, 0.61301189661026, 0.9343206286430359, -0.19516271352767944, 0.7019410133361816, -0.01196992490440607, -0.41811782121658325, -0.054093144834041595, -0.03753834217786789, -0.4410754442214966, 0.07136180996894836, 0.23681524395942688, -0.4153745472431183, -0.10868250578641891, 0.2175898551940918, -0.2647894024848938, -0.27811241149902344, 0.04838883504271507, 1.2179272174835205, -0.011942359618842602, -0.7716004848480225, 0.39331918954849243, -0.13012535870075226, 0.8094589114189148, -0.6432471871376038, -0.23213617503643036, -0.3657098710536957, 0.25270330905914307, 0.03585139662027359, -0.7164897918701172, -0.23386430740356445, -0.173466295003891, -0.37591615319252014, -0.46449294686317444, 0.5982788801193237, -0.6499256491661072, -0.292366087436676, -0.18492794036865234, 0.19855184853076935, 0.11696796119213104, -0.23545360565185547, -0.7711553573608398, -0.5964845418930054, 0.323356956243515, -0.2836974859237671, 0.23580816388130188, 0.35994037985801697, 0.0997549295425415, 0.739639937877655, 0.6651623845100403, -0.09381063282489777, -0.3384286165237427, 0.4549393057823181, 0.5679547786712646, -0.6471253633499146, -0.8895978927612305, -0.7283222675323486, 0.27622875571250916, 0.037405259907245636, -0.33599647879600525, 0.7513629198074341, 0.2941382825374603, 0.8033230900764465, -0.18113340437412262, 0.6871204972267151, 0.08716613799333572, 0.5856518745422363, -0.3910982608795166, 0.35162895917892456, -0.020949527621269226, 0.533767580986023, -0.01668201945722103, -0.8968409299850464, 0.06778167188167572, 0.5816839933395386, -0.3340158462524414, 0.416955828666687, 0.706538736820221, 0.7167257070541382, 0.14057449996471405, 0.30955973267555237, 0.14231689274311066, 0.1619962453842163, 0.33520326018333435, 0.61065673828125, 0.8924427628517151, -0.16185224056243896, 0.3971661925315857, -0.21060805022716522, -0.12213488668203354, -0.42396020889282227, -0.7614888548851013, -0.8914499878883362, -0.9214476346969604, -0.21030355989933014, -0.09967497736215591, 0.08306435495615005, 1.2135531902313232, 0.7514886260032654, -0.8057452440261841, -0.10090033710002899, -0.41407090425491333, -0.03961915895342827, -0.10763099789619446, -0.26843878626823425, 0.4159504175186157, -0.39264625310897827, -0.6478885412216187, 0.4921064078807831, 0.10149343311786652, 0.20471464097499847, -0.2561056613922119, 0.09266787767410278, -0.011111898347735405, -0.40343692898750305, 0.6577293872833252, 0.17662109434604645, -0.5682275295257568, -0.2883826196193695, -0.177790105342865, 0.1744382232427597, 0.16228823363780975, 1.1479992866516113, -1.0520739555358887, 0.6394005417823792, 0.7548478841781616, 0.5275366902351379, 0.8554799556732178, 0.3283308446407318, 0.9993255138397217, -0.7383465766906738, 0.09920589625835419, 0.004799548536539078, 0.38473889231681824, 0.22939172387123108, -0.5225803256034851, 0.3639172613620758, 0.18381083011627197, -0.668035626411438, -0.45434340834617615, 0.2065262794494629, -0.8972574472427368, 0.13411810994148254, 0.993992269039154, -0.282140851020813, 0.318835586309433, -0.30879247188568115, -0.6076022982597351, 0.08131980895996094, -0.819745659828186, 0.8809935450553894, 0.5511086583137512, -0.3009215295314789, -0.1445513367652893, -0.4393009543418884, 0.5694578886032104, 0.29948610067367554, -0.569398045539856, 0.1413608342409134, 0.26866745948791504, 0.25701382756233215, -0.18813207745552063, 0.7571702003479004, 0.2559320628643036, 0.20845910906791687, -0.328901082277298, -0.04439038783311844, -0.18771453201770782, -0.1623353362083435, -0.4054231643676758, 0.16462373733520508, 0.2357485145330429, -0.4169989228248596 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04545v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04545v1
TCAN: Text-oriented Cross Attention Network for Multimodal Sentiment Analysis
2024-04-06T07:56:09
2024-04-06T07:56:09
Ming Zhou, Weize Quan, Ziqi Zhou, Kai Wang, Tong Wang, Dong-Ming Yan
cs.MM
cs.MM, cs.CL
Multimodal Sentiment Analysis (MSA) endeavors to understand human sentiment by leveraging language, visual, and acoustic modalities. Despite the remarkable performance exhibited by previous MSA approaches, the presence of inherent multimodal heterogeneities poses a challenge, with the contribution of different modalities varying considerably. Past research predominantly focused on improving representation learning techniques and feature fusion strategies. However, many of these efforts overlooked the variation in semantic richness among different modalities, treating each modality uniformly. This approach may lead to underestimating the significance of strong modalities while overemphasizing the importance of weak ones. Motivated by these insights, we introduce a Text-oriented Cross-Attention Network (TCAN), emphasizing the predominant role of the text modality in MSA. Specifically, for each multimodal sample, by taking unaligned sequences of the three modalities as inputs, we initially allocate the extracted unimodal features into a visual-text and an acoustic-text pair. Subsequently, we implement self-attention on the text modality and apply text-queried cross-attention to the visual and acoustic modalities. To mitigate the influence of noise signals and redundant features, we incorporate a gated control mechanism into the framework. Additionally, we introduce unimodal joint learning to gain a deeper understanding of homogeneous emotional tendencies across diverse modalities through backpropagation. Experimental results demonstrate that TCAN consistently outperforms state-of-the-art MSA methods on two datasets (CMU-MOSI and CMU-MOSEI).
[ -0.39232632517814636, -0.5661847591400146, 0.463044136762619, 0.5250334143638611, -0.5391767024993896, 0.04188062995672226, -0.42970871925354004, -0.27469736337661743, 0.5415297150611877, 0.23919525742530823, -0.5659115314483643, -0.4701961874961853, -0.5356783270835876, 0.08300445228815079, 0.1394580453634262, 1.0084295272827148, 0.06777916103601456, 0.15018031001091003, 0.028559347614645958, -0.5392176508903503, -0.39841100573539734, -0.2381734848022461, -0.48235517740249634, -0.00625953683629632, 1.0007292032241821, 0.25675585865974426, 0.5007637143135071, 0.2378799170255661, 0.6618760824203491, 0.2734197676181793, 0.022396139800548553, 0.2582606375217438, -0.26908719539642334, 0.2218286544084549, -0.20195642113685608, -0.16378822922706604, -0.5221884846687317, 0.0729905217885971, 0.5706844925880432, 0.4613419473171234, 0.14161331951618195, 0.18259014189243317, 0.08552736043930054, 0.6229268908500671, -0.8965609073638916, 0.1516626477241516, -0.4666858911514282, 0.4165344536304474, -0.2647552192211151, -0.49128854274749756, -0.23102442920207977, 0.27442046999931335, 0.13871216773986816, -0.43968117237091064, -0.09918658435344696, -0.1633722186088562, 0.6325018405914307, 0.2826845347881317, -0.8322907090187073, 0.005971284583210945, -0.5158191919326782, 1.0355279445648193, -0.5098327398300171, 0.43788233399391174, 0.17770227789878845, 0.06678713113069534, 0.23624010384082794, -0.421253502368927, -0.7048854827880859, -0.08107221126556396, -0.009288161993026733, 0.7618127465248108, -0.0268146563321352, 0.15400293469429016, -0.11279395967721939, 0.3233105540275574, -0.6384955048561096, -0.25794291496276855, -0.13803143799304962, -0.12934735417366028, 0.2988300025463104, 0.15538384020328522, 0.39702191948890686, -0.6142153739929199, -0.8514758944511414, -0.2762346863746643, 0.04740406572818756, 0.03990388661623001, 0.11051352322101593, 0.4744413495063782, -0.26458898186683655, 0.6312536001205444, -0.09352168440818787, 0.2801942229270935, 0.03162695840001106, -0.06251472234725952, 0.6266701817512512, -0.6108126044273376, -0.48839041590690613, 0.08388329297304153, 1.246105670928955, 0.352865993976593, -0.16410541534423828, 0.02892102301120758, -0.23883821070194244, 0.26889705657958984, 0.2422715127468109, -0.3700476884841919, 0.21763013303279877, 0.22970011830329895, -0.8604418039321899, -0.3482782542705536, 0.04690137505531311, -1.1421566009521484, -0.25841355323791504, -0.3383651375770569, 0.5419565439224243, -0.05271868407726288, -0.634519100189209, -0.08647441118955612, -0.05831454321742058, 0.08061415702104568, -0.021808018907904625, -0.6461403369903564, -0.07168089598417282, 0.39144366979599, 1.0273627042770386, -0.12163341045379639, -0.26088255643844604, -0.37161189317703247, 0.22420425713062286, -0.08686421066522598, 0.6587260365486145, -0.7745050191879272, -0.2777611315250397, -0.1942366063594818, 0.024628479033708572, -0.46713587641716003, -0.20266501605510712, 0.4999047517776489, -0.3134457468986511, 0.519051194190979, -0.04749632626771927, 0.13781234622001648, -0.34368425607681274, 0.641357421875, -0.8489782810211182, 0.8768573999404907, -0.09411066025495529, -0.7994424104690552, -0.02981973998248577, -0.7415897250175476, -0.49605515599250793, -0.6107399463653564, -0.04967324808239937, -0.5052410364151001, 0.12063893675804138, 0.230925053358078, 0.7037767171859741, -0.43626198172569275, 0.029863733798265457, -0.41310930252075195, -0.042608194053173065, 0.2896590232849121, -0.5896125435829163, 0.5257357954978943, 0.43902134895324707, -0.5041835904121399, 0.3226510286331177, -0.7710831165313721, 0.015569783747196198, -0.14331896603107452, -0.14516884088516235, -0.6397032737731934, -0.332418292760849, 0.584186315536499, 0.6057501435279846, 0.04883821681141853, -0.6042171120643616, -0.1975167840719223, -0.33553361892700195, 0.2868930697441101, 0.6272075772285461, 0.00019883326604031026, 0.44756004214286804, 0.02570745162665844, 0.5839114189147949, 0.5433705449104309, 0.23468700051307678, -0.1970815658569336, -0.2905903458595276, -0.48319950699806213, -0.33991286158561707, -0.04459474980831146, 0.40735670924186707, -0.9093179106712341, 0.20494240522384644, -0.12250645458698273, -0.233526349067688, -0.4041800796985626, 0.36093518137931824, 0.5794038772583008, 0.39694762229919434, 0.3541985750198364, -0.6744133234024048, -0.4706436097621918, -0.876417338848114, -0.07730931043624878, -0.24908272922039032, 0.20878806710243225, 0.15429037809371948, 0.04939313605427742, -0.39864581823349, 0.5862568616867065, 0.06597233563661575, -0.8325889110565186, -0.41990765929222107, 0.4126633107662201, -0.20219360291957855, 0.3486766815185547, 0.4947545528411865, -1.071988821029663, -0.36385950446128845, 0.38842377066612244, -0.7424857020378113, 0.1065896600484848, -0.5588316917419434, -0.2936181426048279, 0.23992788791656494, 0.31946423649787903, -0.46191829442977905, 0.21510545909404755, 0.8055054545402527, -0.37867945432662964, -0.06445932388305664, 0.30940955877304077, 0.3040868639945984, -1.59858238697052, 0.15770387649536133, 0.43769127130508423, -0.09669699519872665, -0.40721890330314636, -0.2892727553844452, 0.009279721416532993, 0.01618049480021, -0.29869088530540466, 0.3343513607978821, -0.49001559615135193, -0.07310241460800171, -0.1984078288078308, 0.3970523476600647, 0.12427810579538345, 0.9657606482505798, 0.12542790174484253, 0.305782288312912, 0.2824474573135376, -0.1536116749048233, 0.49488359689712524, -0.043235015124082565, 0.26871970295906067, 0.7400054931640625, -0.5367740392684937, 0.0789044126868248, -0.17476113140583038, 0.06980413943529129, -1.0811715126037598, 0.06986722350120544, 0.5766629576683044, -0.5034574866294861, 0.32620397210121155, 0.21126659214496613, -0.016037948429584503, 0.0021914837416261435, -0.602611243724823, 0.6778981685638428, -0.23693472146987915, -0.27070897817611694, 1.3037673234939575, 0.31755968928337097, 0.025547122582793236, -0.9265300035476685, -0.8156799077987671, 0.23157313466072083, -0.08743113279342651, -0.5640095472335815, -0.0661701187491417, -0.02454192005097866, -0.22139504551887512, 0.1234043538570404, -0.15626074373722076, -0.15150035917758942, -0.13242223858833313, 0.2972990572452545, 0.1953219175338745, -0.43764403462409973, 0.3942277729511261, 0.06447756290435791, -0.2293008416891098, 0.06528958678245544, -0.11603133380413055, 0.32369399070739746, -0.2285202443599701, -0.03776013106107712, -0.7679973244667053, 0.521826982498169, 0.7355837821960449, -0.5708083510398865, 0.42726653814315796, 0.868205189704895, -0.1763753890991211, -0.12140650302171707, -0.41176673769950867, 0.0112835094332695, -0.36537688970565796, 0.5955528020858765, -0.38551488518714905, -0.5880272388458252, 0.44479915499687195, 0.2420828938484192, -0.2380189299583435, 0.4229692816734314, 0.7319686412811279, -0.19588403403759003, 1.000826358795166, 0.5942978262901306, -0.3122544288635254, 0.8231773376464844, -0.19816993176937103, 0.0624372772872448, -0.8386494517326355, -0.24944545328617096, -0.361392617225647, -0.5180308818817139, -0.5249204635620117, -0.34169772267341614, 0.3041536211967468, -0.592445969581604, 0.014879461377859116, -0.016918161883950233, -0.19277583062648773, 0.3215666115283966, 0.27966955304145813, 0.2811543047428131, 0.1915641576051712, 0.016847709193825722, 0.17331483960151672, 0.06163562834262848, -0.5255830883979797, -0.13782410323619843, 0.9586814641952515, 0.4741135537624359, 0.7789656519889832, -0.017466040328145027, 0.3261222839355469, 0.3176000714302063, 0.15551313757896423, -0.9004058241844177, 0.348213791847229, -0.19578340649604797, -0.4329288899898529, -0.13095541298389435, -0.7655507326126099, -0.7006993889808655, 0.3601526916027069, -0.2440815567970276, -0.17950911819934845, 0.5443999767303467, -0.02575717866420746, -0.18692618608474731, 0.3532227873802185, -0.7380915880203247, 1.0904862880706787, -0.14380095899105072, -0.38928326964378357, -0.34410473704338074, -1.0175011157989502, 0.42229244112968445, 0.2850213348865509, 0.06813876330852509, 0.013609747402369976, -0.2015012949705124, 0.4643420875072479, 0.0738913044333458, 1.0706148147583008, -0.031113319098949432, -0.21089723706245422, 0.13918401300907135, -0.01235860027372837, 0.13345792889595032, 0.16551396250724792, 0.33738550543785095, 0.10414217412471771, -0.10885412991046906, -0.3652084767818451, -0.716417133808136, 0.7751179933547974, -0.9610375761985779, -0.08563799411058426, -0.4714788794517517, -0.46918386220932007, -0.4681415557861328, 0.16908074915409088, -0.008236002177000046, 0.745220422744751, -0.05007579177618027, 0.3270122706890106, 0.8379529714584351, 0.01825735718011856, 0.6876142024993896, -0.0008594104438088834, 0.23652631044387817, -0.6958838701248169, 1.0372494459152222, -0.20591381192207336, 0.3700011372566223, 0.6832787990570068, 0.21587763726711273, -0.19855354726314545, -0.03611436486244202, -0.4151058495044708, 0.24209506809711456, -0.6579464077949524, -0.2818475663661957, -0.9562974572181702, 0.13223248720169067, -0.4086652994155884, 0.14134196937084198, -0.6362193822860718, -0.44561243057250977, -0.3120960295200348, -0.019113454967737198, -0.02232564240694046, 0.40693700313568115, -0.05680116266012192, 0.20598968863487244, -0.8434652090072632, 0.5798491835594177, 0.471562922000885, 0.39314645528793335, 0.07108340412378311, -0.2211969494819641, -0.1962970793247223, -0.01111089438199997, -0.12332742661237717, -0.8560583591461182, 0.4103364050388336, 0.1753721684217453, 0.28055259585380554, 0.5739133954048157, -0.0033100727014243603, 0.4300364851951599, 0.27230918407440186, 0.6520413160324097, 0.5422912836074829, -0.8768554925918579, 0.42355290055274963, -0.4105594754219055, 0.44031354784965515, 0.5617543458938599, 0.27526843547821045, -0.8334557414054871, -0.3683089315891266, -0.21443969011306763, -0.7213826775550842, 0.6650314927101135, 0.1753567010164261, 0.19456467032432556, 0.045082028955221176, -0.06102161854505539, -0.0660163015127182, 0.1951267421245575, -1.0210336446762085, -0.3114229142665863, -0.8234610557556152, -0.8032364249229431, -0.06816820055246353, -0.30401697754859924, -0.14281365275382996, 0.3429011404514313, 0.6422820687294006, -0.44962209463119507, 0.27655065059661865, 0.4519100487232208, -0.16233840584754944, -0.26305314898490906, 0.4042045474052429, 0.6778302192687988, 0.22285428643226624, -0.05213845521211624, 0.3528769016265869, -0.1699763536453247, -0.7323365807533264, -0.1490265130996704, -0.06323754787445068, 0.1364143043756485, -0.08519859611988068, 0.28792715072631836, 0.6774010062217712, 0.0031596061307936907, -0.513279139995575, 0.6268295049667358, -0.3625067174434662, 0.09929489344358444, -0.020272038877010345, -0.39979636669158936, -0.18482308089733124, 0.43085718154907227, 0.21951435506343842, 0.4511878192424774, 0.3155592083930969, -0.8111738562583923, -0.06829690933227539, 0.2810921370983124, -0.9889950752258301, -0.564688503742218, 0.29883378744125366, 0.49104639887809753, 0.19714109599590302, 0.1032973900437355, 0.04868735745549202, -0.550452470779419, 0.6481583118438721, 0.2265019416809082, 1.3328564167022705, -0.10402969270944595, 0.4025264084339142, 0.1313532143831253, 0.5601997375488281, 0.23599497973918915, 0.3536938428878784, -0.15584734082221985, -0.8083354830741882, -0.3191970884799957, -0.21906842291355133, -0.1865672767162323, -0.17908373475074768, -0.5612019300460815, -0.08628516644239426, -0.6097544431686401, -0.2045055329799652, -0.2886212468147278, -0.11585909128189087, -0.3521326184272766, 0.5570108294487, 0.2626875936985016, 0.39213088154792786, -0.7448611259460449, 0.4782739579677582, 0.9022392630577087, -0.6544510722160339, -0.6703507304191589, 0.1401984840631485, 0.2646576464176178, -0.35498958826065063, 0.6039971113204956, 0.20687417685985565, -0.4699171781539917, -0.3785330057144165, -0.25910767912864685, -0.4762727618217468, 0.9263155460357666, 0.03219210356473923, -0.4452497661113739, 0.2179163098335266, 0.17127536237239838, 0.5389491319656372, -0.4386223554611206, 0.4986790120601654, 0.1412714272737503, 0.493215411901474, -0.10510112345218658, -0.8806788921356201, 0.010752219706773758, -0.6327577233314514, 0.10750873386859894, 0.15150557458400726, -1.2044568061828613, 0.6079110503196716, 0.12296544760465622, -0.1601274013519287, -0.27001047134399414, 0.9319031834602356, -0.21612270176410675, 0.7482167482376099, 0.750895619392395, 0.4868898093700409, 0.25760695338249207, -0.010908977128565311, 0.8356747031211853, 0.04723565652966499, 0.15077948570251465, 0.9577303528785706, -0.19179295003414154, 0.6402212977409363, 0.7254980206489563, 0.31599193811416626, 0.500022292137146, 0.4078054428100586, 0.3641771674156189, 0.48686397075653076, -0.4587298631668091, -0.28242433071136475, -0.4795449376106262, -0.36992597579956055, -0.29203134775161743, 0.8395679593086243, 0.12536461651325226, -0.4787490963935852, -0.08430417627096176, 0.5417346954345703, -0.15375590324401855, 0.2394130825996399, -0.5157715678215027, 0.7902560234069824, 0.210205540060997, -0.14745382964611053, -0.013973562978208065, -0.1454996019601822, 0.8450112342834473, -0.681394636631012, 0.1311223804950714, -0.32807403802871704, 0.24481379985809326, -0.1877937763929367, -0.5343608856201172, 0.15851716697216034, -0.28315553069114685, -0.448230504989624, -0.12202291935682297, 0.6584439873695374, -0.5232173800468445, -0.4122311472892761, 0.5524099469184875, 0.32767271995544434, -0.40217354893684387, -0.1280597746372223, -0.6390129923820496, 0.0765814259648323, -0.019758734852075577, -0.6939852237701416, 0.1912364810705185, 0.96829754114151, -0.05428672954440117, 0.5329116582870483, 0.38052040338516235, -0.07116539776325226, -0.041212525218725204, 0.3552743196487427, 0.9645476341247559, -0.8878757357597351, -0.6298816204071045, -0.5890536308288574, 0.46846628189086914, -0.013019182719290257, -0.7161430716514587, 0.6551128625869751, 0.2636444568634033, 0.7582312226295471, 0.010823506861925125, 0.6105243563652039, 0.005821356549859047, 0.2828059494495392, -0.6525168418884277, 0.5982667207717896, -0.923179566860199, -0.015277745202183723, -0.4723872244358063, -0.9729300141334534, -0.5157116055488586, 0.3527309000492096, 0.1294649839401245, 0.2083956003189087, 0.8160920143127441, 0.7526117563247681, -0.15180139243602753, 0.11291654407978058, 0.316509872674942, 0.23807232081890106, 0.0935407355427742, 0.6212812066078186, 1.0035088062286377, -0.40501439571380615, 0.8007634878158569, -0.4445395767688751, -0.16097396612167358, 0.05302085727453232, -0.7290327548980713, -1.060463309288025, -0.5585541725158691, -0.1298910677433014, -0.22290393710136414, -0.11391027271747589, 1.1392037868499756, 0.5160923004150391, -0.6899080276489258, -0.12424615025520325, 0.49031320214271545, 0.1315530389547348, -0.28431129455566406, -0.28900983929634094, 0.31355419754981995, -0.49029219150543213, -0.7393744587898254, 0.2846941649913788, 0.571562647819519, -0.2373725175857544, -0.43004629015922546, 0.041424691677093506, -0.34905722737312317, 0.06508804112672806, 0.6418167352676392, 0.12598028779029846, -0.4727513790130615, -0.1723223626613617, 0.1302470862865448, -0.42871564626693726, 0.13768908381462097, 1.0861245393753052, -0.561974823474884, 0.6758686900138855, 0.7686703205108643, 0.829201340675354, 0.11542735248804092, -0.16084279119968414, 0.48056671023368835, -0.8434237241744995, 0.2708264887332916, 0.22621503472328186, 0.40678170323371887, 0.23469094932079315, -0.3542350232601166, 0.3535151481628418, 0.4414227306842804, -0.22711336612701416, -0.5755815505981445, -0.08188697695732117, -1.7593282461166382, -0.23840737342834473, 1.108295202255249, 0.14269877970218658, -0.5521778464317322, -0.08087621629238129, -0.47369441390037537, 0.30079734325408936, -0.6884217858314514, 0.8692016005516052, 0.3372998833656311, 0.3229069709777832, -0.42920157313346863, -0.12646633386611938, 0.12759247422218323, 0.7871127128601074, -0.8303699493408203, 0.04046732932329178, 0.5431095957756042, -0.1442837417125702, 0.3930245041847229, 0.43905356526374817, -0.18736736476421356, 0.33895939588546753, -0.15592990815639496, 0.22034123539924622, -0.11146889626979828, -0.5595816373825073, -0.4425792694091797, 0.48964938521385193, -0.6260067224502563, -0.37233617901802063 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04538v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04538v1
Soft-Prompting with Graph-of-Thought for Multi-modal Representation Learning
2024-04-06T07:39:44
2024-04-06T07:39:44
Juncheng Yang, Zuchao Li, Shuai Xie, Wei Yu, Shijun Li, Bo Du
cs.AI
cs.AI, cs.CL
The chain-of-thought technique has been received well in multi-modal tasks. It is a step-by-step linear reasoning process that adjusts the length of the chain to improve the performance of generated prompts. However, human thought processes are predominantly non-linear, as they encompass multiple aspects simultaneously and employ dynamic adjustment and updating mechanisms. Therefore, we propose a novel Aggregation-Graph-of-Thought (AGoT) mechanism for soft-prompt tuning in multi-modal representation learning. The proposed AGoT models the human thought process not only as a chain but also models each step as a reasoning aggregation graph to cope with the overlooked multiple aspects of thinking in single-step reasoning. This turns the entire reasoning process into prompt aggregation and prompt flow operations. Experiments show that our multi-modal model enhanced with AGoT soft-prompting achieves good results in several tasks such as text-image retrieval, visual question answering, and image recognition. In addition, we demonstrate that it has good domain generalization performance due to better reasoning.
[ -0.6471548080444336, -1.3222602605819702, 0.7077049612998962, -0.3261899948120117, -0.6246408820152283, -0.04045512154698372, -0.2669433355331421, -0.14269942045211792, 0.4188535213470459, 0.028026655316352844, -0.7573975920677185, -0.25292351841926575, -0.265729695558548, 0.2712278962135315, 0.3319033980369568, 0.9578770995140076, -0.020751576870679855, -0.0359291136264801, 0.14926086366176605, -0.38212013244628906, -0.9369666576385498, -0.21522048115730286, -0.7107111215591431, -0.3117571175098419, 0.9680526256561279, 0.1351052224636078, 0.6684166193008423, 0.20610947906970978, 0.061366815119981766, 0.37659454345703125, -0.009212599135935307, 0.6498896479606628, -0.35466235876083374, 0.44157126545906067, -0.2620907127857208, -0.26544028520584106, -0.9739217758178711, -0.08530642092227936, 0.7171621322631836, 0.7003709673881531, -0.035131387412548065, -0.11319819837808609, 0.27443650364875793, 0.7276020050048828, -0.5503592491149902, 0.2955087423324585, -0.47920820116996765, -0.049752626568078995, 0.18168582022190094, -0.20844389498233795, -0.4103292226791382, -0.2519480288028717, 0.03745574504137039, -0.6986733675003052, 0.07448768615722656, -0.013455637730658054, 0.13339728116989136, 0.13961029052734375, -0.7084030508995056, -0.2892736494541168, -0.34865114092826843, 0.38604071736335754, -0.12918850779533386, 0.4689893424510956, 0.19807511568069458, 0.14831456542015076, -0.045983463525772095, -0.6641373634338379, -0.5812931060791016, -0.12244034558534622, 0.07482980936765671, 0.29716062545776367, 0.1706065833568573, 0.26242518424987793, 0.23944416642189026, 0.17430299520492554, -0.49167826771736145, -0.3327317237854004, -0.18574215471744537, -0.2201635241508484, 0.2076834738254547, 0.12973721325397491, 0.08553464710712433, -0.09164382517337799, -0.6311732530593872, -0.053101737052202225, -0.43751952052116394, 0.07572711259126663, 0.06776122003793716, 0.6808618903160095, -0.07921727001667023, 0.33751729130744934, 0.0668194442987442, 0.8885210156440735, 0.17461059987545013, 0.19585451483726501, 0.5522295832633972, -0.3608204424381256, -0.1510101705789566, -0.13575102388858795, 0.5900967717170715, 0.145294189453125, 0.36429542303085327, 0.007013268303126097, -0.4052456319332123, 0.033266015350818634, 0.2942282259464264, -0.5962697267532349, -0.00747864181175828, -0.0634898990392685, -0.6377477645874023, -0.012392888776957989, 0.09293805062770844, -0.8134598135948181, -0.2693302631378174, -0.38367658853530884, 0.7289813160896301, -0.6416502594947815, -0.5177923440933228, 0.1493413746356964, -0.09743337333202362, -0.33540648221969604, 0.6317926645278931, -0.6658830046653748, 0.29826852679252625, 0.4426100552082062, 0.9904050827026367, 0.04028933495283127, -0.5102788209915161, -0.7329646348953247, 0.0006288140430115163, -0.2042117714881897, 1.0775753259658813, -0.7190263271331787, -0.3234003782272339, -0.11707490682601929, -0.15876951813697815, -0.473755806684494, -0.06030465289950371, 0.24027515947818756, -0.5281942486763, 0.2957580089569092, -0.4577094316482544, -0.34235450625419617, -0.3920253813266754, 0.5492134094238281, -0.9074257016181946, 0.8096587657928467, 0.26550987362861633, -0.5797280073165894, 0.45376458764076233, -0.8384039402008057, -0.4956645965576172, 0.23877087235450745, -0.41678789258003235, -0.3012424409389496, 0.07135865092277527, 0.45182275772094727, 0.3517385721206665, -0.14754579961299896, 0.13631035387516022, -0.40010520815849304, -0.5131736397743225, 0.4699344336986542, -0.5890591740608215, 0.49026939272880554, 0.1956384778022766, -0.1976931095123291, 0.28306064009666443, -0.38451460003852844, 0.1915949136018753, 0.0672706887125969, -0.22169342637062073, -0.3159516751766205, -0.1947125792503357, -0.328666627407074, 0.36725619435310364, 0.0918472483754158, -0.1325819343328476, 0.6957413554191589, -0.17382483184337616, 0.5871711373329163, 1.0970582962036133, 0.29206523299217224, 0.4230663478374481, -0.3201347887516022, 0.5167939066886902, 0.20700222253799438, 0.289391428232193, -0.6269115805625916, -0.7263216376304626, -0.5645031929016113, -0.32795631885528564, 0.307754784822464, 0.38520586490631104, -1.0643808841705322, 0.22499814629554749, 0.08541396260261536, -0.026776829734444618, -0.1788797676563263, 0.12824121117591858, 0.33267369866371155, 0.699705958366394, 0.3855569660663605, -0.4389967620372772, 0.020394477993249893, -0.37052130699157715, -0.05613068863749504, -0.16649678349494934, 0.22722956538200378, 0.4272186756134033, 0.5989519357681274, -0.0520971305668354, 0.7009606957435608, -0.6170752644538879, -0.26985904574394226, -0.13595306873321533, 0.49774807691574097, 0.3416591286659241, 0.35292837023735046, 0.32254475355148315, -0.9319956302642822, -0.24006366729736328, -0.20672442018985748, -0.5118125081062317, 0.1784476339817047, -0.24874497950077057, -0.256287544965744, 0.035867687314748764, 0.33090463280677795, -0.7657262086868286, 0.3444693386554718, -0.12220392376184464, -0.5424599647521973, 0.5172788500785828, -0.3804779648780823, 0.4615921080112457, -0.9268675446510315, -0.1802704781293869, -0.05192381888628006, -0.19432371854782104, -0.2254239171743393, 0.02667170763015747, 0.16281722486019135, -0.32458096742630005, -0.3135055899620056, 0.24922612309455872, -0.6330669522285461, 0.2033088505268097, -0.2710624933242798, 0.16087323427200317, 0.1571703553199768, 0.9231463074684143, -0.08745195716619492, 0.8504540920257568, 0.9864758849143982, -0.7344374060630798, 0.334781676530838, 0.1023373156785965, 0.006384064443409443, 0.8986745476722717, -0.41197699308395386, 0.7162125706672668, -0.3615248501300812, 0.6472137570381165, -1.1733739376068115, 0.005007756873965263, 0.3660165071487427, -0.21890948712825775, 0.32643455266952515, -0.23553527891635895, -0.4436289072036743, -0.4383513033390045, -0.42183929681777954, 0.731232762336731, 0.2275385856628418, -0.39199304580688477, 1.0359644889831543, 0.06327200680971146, -0.10156669467687607, -0.33927255868911743, -0.42716851830482483, -0.2214524745941162, -0.057466041296720505, -0.5885694622993469, 0.23939423263072968, -0.22274290025234222, 0.16046081483364105, 0.025137178599834442, -0.05314652994275093, -0.001884540426544845, -0.2264101654291153, 0.047324325889348984, 0.3964214622974396, -0.34796473383903503, 0.585843563079834, 0.2624308466911316, -0.22026129066944122, -0.13375473022460938, -0.5530794262886047, 0.47290492057800293, -0.5187738537788391, -0.5445520281791687, -0.06393454223871231, 0.5231212377548218, 0.5728710293769836, -0.29284629225730896, 0.415535032749176, 0.6933836936950684, -0.2742117941379547, -0.3750782608985901, -0.28659626841545105, -0.4572402834892273, -0.5127292275428772, 0.07325641065835953, -0.5823689699172974, -0.7760661244392395, 0.5312225818634033, -0.5291690230369568, -0.15000063180923462, 0.09796719253063202, 0.6231011152267456, -0.07486376911401749, 1.4537150859832764, 0.2671041488647461, 0.25920388102531433, 0.5934882164001465, -0.41625770926475525, 0.1162596046924591, -0.7614061236381531, -0.36696305871009827, -0.11161261051893234, -0.5997092723846436, -0.26503053307533264, -0.6045682430267334, 0.7304823994636536, 0.03758325055241585, -0.3154986500740051, -0.20141245424747467, -0.6952025294303894, 0.486177921295166, 0.37117308378219604, 0.7234054207801819, 0.16283361613750458, -0.029072530567646027, -0.5289468765258789, 0.34704118967056274, -0.7164736390113831, -0.08719253540039062, 0.6428755521774292, -0.13699990510940552, 0.7975084781646729, -0.007428206969052553, 0.413519024848938, 0.5123252868652344, 0.023919735103845596, -0.8061534762382507, 0.7211847901344299, 0.12336330860853195, -0.37903735041618347, -0.2441537082195282, -0.418649286031723, -1.0819065570831299, 0.5282176733016968, -0.1185978576540947, -0.5218423008918762, 0.34075927734375, 0.3926532566547394, -0.42322999238967896, 0.32972952723503113, -0.846894383430481, 0.6049807071685791, -0.3017459809780121, -0.4365507960319519, -0.38803747296333313, -0.6554577350616455, 0.00715729221701622, 0.19540874660015106, 0.2496998906135559, 0.06318539381027222, -0.31821209192276, 0.49655961990356445, -0.3539111316204071, 0.9697452187538147, -0.27944305539131165, 0.11255139112472534, 0.8365492820739746, 0.21455208957195282, 0.7329510450363159, 0.04801684617996216, -0.006321057211607695, -0.12833896279335022, -0.7455747723579407, -0.29040348529815674, -0.860889732837677, 0.4791182279586792, -0.40164366364479065, -0.48083341121673584, -0.39068546891212463, -0.594153642654419, -0.23543432354927063, 0.3752210736274719, 0.14367462694644928, 0.9300466179847717, 0.023281894624233246, -0.248432919383049, 0.5915883183479309, 0.3714229464530945, 0.37758320569992065, 0.25433042645454407, -0.24742041528224945, -0.7243800163269043, 0.92667156457901, 0.1610306352376938, 0.24673016369342804, 0.10016225278377533, 0.36812207102775574, -0.4560883939266205, -0.22281001508235931, -0.6377179026603699, 0.30835971236228943, -0.8192334175109863, -0.4043792188167572, -0.5736117959022522, 0.281575083732605, -0.3383539617061615, -0.23759150505065918, -0.001902500749565661, -0.46351000666618347, -0.22098803520202637, -0.1878834217786789, 0.5537781715393066, 0.76102614402771, -0.08066209405660629, 0.04276726767420769, -0.47964784502983093, 0.562057375907898, 0.8285694122314453, 0.5929256677627563, 0.3223172426223755, -0.2646050453186035, -0.016433781012892723, 0.10511353611946106, -0.5292612314224243, -1.096204161643982, -0.08814278244972229, 0.3622696101665497, 0.3908363878726959, 0.4630811810493469, -0.1570132076740265, 0.7430167198181152, -0.4552663564682007, 0.5910828709602356, 0.5168418884277344, -0.8481870889663696, 0.7023530602455139, -0.4939786195755005, 0.4551488757133484, 0.5460792779922485, 0.1525745838880539, -0.3810119032859802, -0.16752880811691284, -0.40826696157455444, -0.7703028321266174, 0.6704561710357666, -0.04897336661815643, 0.23614969849586487, -0.32894793152809143, 0.19758614897727966, 0.4208647310733795, 0.2680791914463043, -0.6424986720085144, -0.2870127260684967, -0.5635385513305664, 0.10534752905368805, 0.45731207728385925, 0.008650139905512333, 0.06240604445338249, -0.4200231432914734, 0.364083856344223, -0.6585570573806763, 0.5641963481903076, 0.31097689270973206, -0.19901324808597565, -0.45415762066841125, 0.3767254054546356, 0.3566979467868805, 0.7360568642616272, -0.06766679137945175, 0.41604167222976685, 0.3429744243621826, -0.3588355779647827, 0.11014309525489807, -0.0983160063624382, -0.01990589313209057, -0.2908545136451721, 0.17312830686569214, 1.0068143606185913, 0.23390795290470123, -0.28308171033859253, 0.47483259439468384, -0.06384783983230591, -0.26491284370422363, 0.22296477854251862, 0.21196363866329193, -0.09651840478181839, 0.3704259693622589, 0.5515645146369934, 0.44194361567497253, 0.2304135113954544, -0.6852186918258667, 0.11431597173213959, 0.25554999709129333, -0.46017783880233765, -0.4934432804584503, 0.6227617263793945, 0.3346851170063019, -0.5227326154708862, 0.8039534687995911, -0.30012694001197815, -0.7341095805168152, 0.4169366657733917, 0.6651082038879395, 0.8577203750610352, -0.1847737729549408, 0.375663161277771, 0.26785367727279663, 0.045647576451301575, 0.0919826552271843, 0.7892211079597473, -0.4345800280570984, -0.5824761390686035, -0.5513071417808533, 0.023994676768779755, -0.2649272084236145, -0.015897030010819435, -0.4746418297290802, 0.3623693287372589, -0.4325902462005615, -0.6432198286056519, -0.1546970009803772, -0.3243982195854187, -0.7292136549949646, 0.14443176984786987, 0.38182568550109863, 0.7720146179199219, -0.8671379089355469, 0.5613492131233215, 0.8537717461585999, -0.6488289833068848, -0.8242172598838806, -0.11194885522127151, -0.12056063115596771, -0.7056524753570557, 0.2584795355796814, 0.38025549054145813, -0.6145597100257874, 0.11266454309225082, -0.5156729221343994, -0.5890325903892517, 0.9826354384422302, 0.3797142207622528, -0.312502920627594, 0.04902910813689232, -0.3394545912742615, 0.27981752157211304, -0.4825921952724457, 0.39760199189186096, 0.026427561417222023, 0.6280925869941711, 0.10765101760625839, -0.6375791430473328, 0.40047016739845276, -0.3648720383644104, -0.3352713882923126, 0.41278958320617676, -0.8998684287071228, 1.2917808294296265, -0.4910362958908081, -0.1965985745191574, -0.43960508704185486, 0.6599801182746887, 0.3139559328556061, 0.44323572516441345, 1.0750467777252197, 0.20063798129558563, 1.0569672584533691, 0.2809543013572693, 0.8486315011978149, -0.0495503693819046, 0.3259197771549225, 0.8179708123207092, -0.3891308903694153, 0.24435637891292572, 0.30216309428215027, -0.031442224979400635, 0.9192460179328918, 0.409196674823761, 0.25910577178001404, 0.5694444179534912, -0.32443681359291077, -0.3453504145145416, -0.5078479647636414, -0.00643027713522315, -0.4686313271522522, 0.13175447285175323, 0.6236433386802673, -0.20021279156208038, -0.24261820316314697, 0.19685408473014832, -0.2723351716995239, -0.15215061604976654, -0.5572075247764587, 0.7541593909263611, 0.17743639647960663, -1.0190738439559937, 0.6100852489471436, -0.45514464378356934, 0.5335623621940613, -0.5482690930366516, -0.36263832449913025, 0.09934310615062714, -0.00017740612383931875, 0.059166327118873596, -0.8566716909408569, -0.32498621940612793, -0.30402871966362, -0.11848185211420059, -0.45574402809143066, 1.1291347742080688, -0.43052467703819275, -0.40240874886512756, 0.2927747368812561, 0.887586772441864, 0.038452763110399246, -0.1933041512966156, -1.0590742826461792, -0.18491952121257782, -0.280796617269516, -0.4598226249217987, 0.18485571444034576, 0.7697263956069946, -0.17767618596553802, 0.46787500381469727, 0.5663067698478699, -0.22971080243587494, -0.10963629186153412, 0.6327874064445496, 1.205025315284729, -0.6030898690223694, -0.8489436507225037, -0.9434058666229248, 0.46152228116989136, 0.013343055732548237, -0.40002673864364624, 0.3184998035430908, 0.24807758629322052, 0.3269709348678589, 0.0420132540166378, 0.6221131086349487, -0.15665699541568756, 0.12896881997585297, -0.5922620296478271, 0.397529661655426, -0.5498532056808472, -0.26481756567955017, -0.3332653045654297, -0.8665403127670288, -0.04800434783101082, 0.6636170744895935, -0.29477399587631226, 0.5104485750198364, 1.2102384567260742, 0.6157585978507996, -0.3299947679042816, 0.3634088933467865, 0.10955747961997986, 0.006045875605195761, 0.02625473588705063, 0.5951695442199707, 0.8422908782958984, -0.02425667643547058, 0.5190874934196472, 0.02007363550364971, -0.2800648808479309, -0.12657515704631805, -0.9574699401855469, -0.901493489742279, -0.862863302230835, -0.21984905004501343, -0.36808037757873535, -0.0313144214451313, 1.098703145980835, 0.674471378326416, -0.4303431510925293, 0.12460801750421524, -0.16559888422489166, 0.3222532868385315, -0.6542987823486328, -0.16015321016311646, 0.5388196706771851, -0.5278740525245667, -0.2838181257247925, 0.39688730239868164, 0.3248887062072754, -0.06609809398651123, -0.15373165905475616, -0.11365733295679092, -0.414389967918396, 0.11230360716581345, 0.670875608921051, -0.0868518054485321, -0.4012206196784973, -0.24445787072181702, -0.09619511663913727, 0.1858150064945221, 0.40248730778694153, 1.4254469871520996, -1.1781724691390991, 0.6742269396781921, 0.5605376362800598, -0.030160171911120415, 0.5234594345092773, 0.16554701328277588, 0.4395826458930969, -0.7973686456680298, 0.24101831018924713, 0.2834307551383972, 0.48645925521850586, 0.12192147970199585, -0.5060615539550781, 0.37553173303604126, 0.3656008541584015, -0.47360479831695557, -0.55978924036026, 0.3958921432495117, -1.0771338939666748, -0.511844277381897, 0.7598626613616943, 0.1472773551940918, -0.4675392508506775, -0.4135794937610626, -0.504767656326294, 0.4653988182544708, -0.8639156222343445, 0.653042733669281, 0.4891824424266815, -0.4452553689479828, -0.06472862511873245, -0.08099357783794403, -0.04449492692947388, 0.27639639377593994, -0.6211445927619934, 0.0729873925447464, 0.6642487049102783, -0.03676316514611244, 0.16330382227897644, 0.9710943102836609, 0.11337950080633163, 0.6208533048629761, 0.051011692732572556, -0.3337886333465576, -0.5107377171516418, -0.4921274483203888, -0.21524685621261597, 0.4268030822277069, -0.11932867020368576, -0.12257598340511322 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04530v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04530v2
A Morphology-Based Investigation of Positional Encodings
2024-04-06T07:10:47
2024-05-30T14:44:10
Poulami Ghosh, Shikhar Vashishth, Raj Dabre, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
cs.CL
cs.CL
Contemporary deep learning models effectively handle languages with diverse morphology despite not being directly integrated into them. Morphology and word order are closely linked, with the latter incorporated into transformer-based models through positional encodings. This prompts a fundamental inquiry: Is there a correlation between the morphological complexity of a language and the utilization of positional encoding in pre-trained language models? In pursuit of an answer, we present the first study addressing this question, encompassing 22 languages and 5 downstream tasks. Our findings reveal that the importance of positional encoding diminishes with increasing morphological complexity in languages. Our study motivates the need for a deeper understanding of positional encoding, augmenting them to better reflect the different languages under consideration.
[ -0.0738702043890953, -0.43573880195617676, 0.7145171165466309, 0.21292153000831604, -0.2456953227519989, -0.014346806332468987, -0.18806500732898712, -0.5603118538856506, 0.2844291627407074, 0.19829578697681427, -0.3158016502857208, -0.34731531143188477, -1.0708683729171753, 0.21542389690876007, -0.40472880005836487, 0.29344719648361206, -0.016571292653679848, 0.4646071791648865, 0.018118422478437424, -0.09293864667415619, -0.45531052350997925, -0.9599810838699341, -0.4341580271720886, -0.3437974452972412, 0.5186594128608704, -0.1435636579990387, 1.0500521659851074, 1.0253369808197021, 0.6364020109176636, 0.427290678024292, -0.358900249004364, -0.11737736314535141, -0.2165212631225586, 0.18626919388771057, -0.21974098682403564, -0.7490030527114868, -0.11313583701848984, -0.2050406038761139, 0.7364855408668518, 1.3257039785385132, -0.05375872924923897, -0.27797240018844604, -0.13176760077476501, 0.45000773668289185, -0.7496034502983093, -0.019268272444605827, -0.4702904224395752, 0.21052059531211853, -0.3823021948337555, -0.27835702896118164, -0.4050747752189636, -0.05340024083852768, 0.25246137380599976, -0.16394230723381042, 0.18020550906658173, -0.6287366151809692, 0.8361048698425293, 0.31308698654174805, -0.33564451336860657, -0.3757933974266052, -0.7579432725906372, 0.6780563592910767, -0.46939778327941895, 0.8864002227783203, 0.37669748067855835, -0.13734354078769684, 0.01713217794895172, -0.7364319562911987, -0.24685892462730408, -0.034709297120571136, -0.38659608364105225, 0.09942746162414551, -0.12263070046901703, 0.14603035151958466, 0.0031999542843550444, 0.45215559005737305, -0.5571500062942505, 0.658580482006073, -0.459228515625, -0.14556685090065002, 0.5807052850723267, 0.1062462106347084, 0.770717442035675, -0.23570983111858368, 0.10087825357913971, -0.4365953803062439, -0.6600264310836792, 0.12238146364688873, 0.40469789505004883, 0.30002862215042114, -0.12402160465717316, 0.7271591424942017, -0.03576632961630821, 0.5368083119392395, 0.1858389675617218, 0.06926847994327545, 0.2312513291835785, -0.2948559820652008, -0.24084801971912384, 0.3570777475833893, 0.7435314059257507, -0.1697043925523758, -0.11819420009851456, -0.09122302383184433, -0.2191600352525711, -0.039445508271455765, 0.6819873452186584, -0.7277990579605103, -0.014704587869346142, 0.0767703428864479, -0.30836251378059387, -0.1679723560810089, 0.14427277445793152, -0.2547895312309265, -0.4031553268432617, -0.3695148229598999, 0.20048201084136963, -0.7539531588554382, -0.33264684677124023, 0.3107537031173706, 0.14812049269676208, 0.5900194644927979, 0.20919159054756165, -1.3303992748260498, 0.15696382522583008, 1.0304415225982666, 0.7757017612457275, -0.17701147496700287, -0.5865005254745483, 0.038501959294080734, -0.15395131707191467, -0.8489490747451782, 0.7303892374038696, -0.9126143455505371, -0.5375166535377502, 0.18211708962917328, 0.16339145600795746, -0.25002068281173706, -0.46359720826148987, 0.3903910219669342, -0.5079947710037231, 0.17186811566352844, -0.02230794169008732, -0.6209548711776733, -0.244246244430542, 0.016379984095692635, -0.7511557340621948, 0.7287864685058594, 0.03640346974134445, -0.47726091742515564, 0.36517828702926636, -0.23890849947929382, -0.718451976776123, 0.124394990503788, -0.40015655755996704, -0.14609062671661377, 0.65967857837677, 0.12288107722997665, 0.5419250726699829, 0.15095101296901703, 0.35136300325393677, 0.12167128175497055, -0.3312451243400574, 0.2669752240180969, -0.48288774490356445, 0.5905634164810181, 0.12728650867938995, -0.25964105129241943, 0.10934431850910187, -0.47613629698753357, -0.21091040968894958, 0.2199019491672516, -0.30421823263168335, -0.42485538125038147, -0.0389045812189579, -0.441689670085907, -0.014572978019714355, 0.39092549681663513, -0.27414947748184204, 0.1508501023054123, -0.6327563524246216, 0.5472948551177979, 0.4707724452018738, -0.15214645862579346, 1.05002760887146, 0.3576134443283081, 0.5555466413497925, 0.19240877032279968, 0.10415835678577423, -0.1374553143978119, -0.538093626499176, -0.8055547475814819, 0.1054389700293541, 0.2946711480617523, 0.46637973189353943, -0.5428066849708557, 0.2511306405067444, -0.4909493923187256, -0.5387593507766724, -0.4806990623474121, -0.1795053780078888, 0.5519330501556396, -0.03408079594373703, 0.1381821483373642, -0.6116898059844971, -0.4257282614707947, -0.8866159319877625, 0.10033343732357025, -0.14395853877067566, 0.1750028282403946, -0.05702797323465347, 0.44776639342308044, -0.2600865960121155, 0.5703483819961548, -0.2834428548812866, 0.30856844782829285, -0.2742544710636139, 0.34252825379371643, 0.33330923318862915, 0.592286229133606, 0.8594905734062195, -0.8207027316093445, -0.22840610146522522, 0.09151852875947952, -0.7927646040916443, 0.3610484004020691, 0.11605604737997055, 0.0645330548286438, 0.09194092452526093, 0.584729790687561, -0.9342897534370422, 0.3433891236782074, 0.6302703619003296, -0.11462028324604034, 0.3514997065067291, -0.6895227432250977, 0.06956227123737335, -0.914169192314148, -0.14701010286808014, -0.2530098557472229, 0.2808764576911926, -1.187712550163269, 0.25983819365501404, 0.22713720798492432, -0.34318429231643677, -0.49884265661239624, 0.36893755197525024, -0.6086395382881165, -0.2916843295097351, -0.1642955243587494, -0.3647998571395874, -0.12508109211921692, 0.49742698669433594, 0.496687650680542, 0.7534171342849731, 0.7028411626815796, -0.721345841884613, -0.15891794860363007, 0.2105533629655838, -0.345763236284256, 0.18469694256782532, -0.5727967619895935, 0.2076391726732254, -0.35393959283828735, -0.11463695764541626, -0.7999036312103271, -0.37897104024887085, 0.14148953557014465, -0.44853267073631287, 0.7854245901107788, -0.36822524666786194, -0.28844812512397766, -0.18817020952701569, -0.1190510019659996, 0.5883713960647583, 0.6434314846992493, -0.189950093626976, 0.1819617599248886, 0.3890046179294586, -0.05543991178274155, -0.6809185743331909, -0.6691500544548035, -0.006332072429358959, -0.3147377371788025, -0.32668352127075195, 0.5649863481521606, 0.1529773622751236, -0.21472617983818054, -0.2764769196510315, -0.32299691438674927, -0.31518250703811646, 0.23551848530769348, 0.1820429265499115, -0.12888292968273163, -0.5465072989463806, 0.0029990808106958866, 0.0934591293334961, -0.025868240743875504, 0.07806579768657684, -0.5764155387878418, 0.9802378416061401, 0.12050793319940567, -0.538544774055481, -0.4427861273288727, 0.2415136843919754, 0.6463266611099243, -0.5067085027694702, 0.7929894328117371, 0.48305946588516235, -0.4543663561344147, 0.15171299874782562, -0.2750018835067749, -0.04535958915948868, -0.5231316685676575, 0.6453372240066528, -0.6816611289978027, -0.7059345245361328, 0.5750545263290405, 0.07900477200746536, -0.3705964684486389, 0.44964876770973206, 0.4145522117614746, -0.15945269167423248, 1.1454535722732544, 0.9186068773269653, -0.024882573634386063, 0.7635022401809692, -0.3159790635108948, 0.2729785442352295, -0.45428985357284546, -0.42671188712120056, -0.6287823915481567, -0.16900667548179626, -0.843736469745636, -0.513194739818573, -0.08645906299352646, 0.2515447437763214, -0.03135589510202408, 0.5284274816513062, -0.5830876231193542, 0.42244353890419006, 0.39996394515037537, 0.1689222902059555, -0.23215624690055847, 0.04757007211446762, 0.07334233075380325, -0.07511178404092789, -0.7320510149002075, -0.42549929022789, 0.7017298340797424, 0.3764376938343048, 0.5494717359542847, -0.012826070189476013, 0.7477198839187622, 0.0756908506155014, -0.4194122850894928, -0.9660004377365112, 0.3717053234577179, -0.571963906288147, -0.17347107827663422, -0.41269606351852417, 0.024179110303521156, -1.4730274677276611, 0.19895817339420319, 0.15277650952339172, -0.6303538680076599, 0.6751963496208191, -0.1337079554796219, -0.2548348307609558, 0.2034558355808258, -0.6649179458618164, 0.8081440925598145, -0.5971443057060242, -0.020499620586633682, -0.2626603841781616, -0.6070103645324707, -0.0758158415555954, 0.11803537607192993, 0.10523471981287003, 0.15858601033687592, 0.011904824525117874, 0.7895954847335815, -0.5267613530158997, 0.8394080400466919, -0.04827064275741577, -0.606490969657898, 0.03083030879497528, 0.30553653836250305, 0.18268319964408875, -0.1280185729265213, 0.018313121050596237, 0.38654690980911255, -0.18675830960273743, -0.4562474191188812, -0.6732528805732727, 0.5042110681533813, -0.981683075428009, -0.7106808423995972, -0.3305250108242035, -0.5032633543014526, -0.08510761708021164, 0.32043200731277466, 0.5886244177818298, 0.7107446789741516, -0.07289014756679535, 0.009600654244422913, 0.8413572311401367, -0.41255635023117065, 0.5301705598831177, 0.05061107128858566, 0.05974840372800827, -0.10382600873708725, 0.8352199792861938, 0.27334064245224, -0.026659045368433, 0.991776168346405, 0.2019415646791458, -0.34365683794021606, -1.225958228111267, -0.36053431034088135, 0.2247113287448883, -0.9249006509780884, 0.17596538364887238, -0.6329935789108276, -0.490966796875, -0.586830198764801, -0.31042760610580444, -0.6165705919265747, -0.29501426219940186, -0.33894819021224976, -0.2510994076728821, 0.13942667841911316, 1.2065656185150146, 0.05806189030408859, 0.36730119585990906, -0.8636093139648438, 0.17208026349544525, 0.2842674255371094, 0.39391693472862244, -0.13798166811466217, -0.5219064950942993, -0.11523258686065674, 0.15113143622875214, 0.3224948048591614, -1.0003464221954346, 0.5094709396362305, 0.13879600167274475, 0.852620005607605, 0.39833131432533264, -0.3953138291835785, 0.7587159872055054, -0.7307860255241394, 0.9140187501907349, 0.10286525636911392, -0.8846424221992493, 0.6312524676322937, -0.15644145011901855, 0.4088495373725891, 0.3038733899593353, 0.6526846885681152, -0.38999661803245544, -0.2268635779619217, -0.5301483869552612, -0.8470951318740845, 0.837862491607666, 0.2751895487308502, 0.5662404298782349, -0.24982917308807373, 0.45434683561325073, 0.37815722823143005, -0.08904363960027695, -0.379416823387146, -0.11462227255105972, -0.40024685859680176, -0.22660157084465027, -0.2639040946960449, -0.6602634787559509, 0.29916974902153015, -0.16707612574100494, 0.11326473951339722, 0.1400567889213562, 0.5316680669784546, 0.12169961631298065, -0.7126928567886353, 0.385983943939209, 0.1762150079011917, 1.024864673614502, 0.6032003164291382, 0.12389999628067017, 0.37882694602012634, 0.07509638369083405, -0.8555203676223755, 0.19768141210079193, -0.1644136607646942, -0.09542448818683624, 0.2173161804676056, 0.6953372955322266, 1.1291916370391846, 0.36173954606056213, -0.32234224677085876, 0.28855910897254944, 0.12334282696247101, -0.034405604004859924, -0.17016419768333435, -0.05846862867474556, -0.03352818265557289, 0.1553840935230255, 0.13198034465312958, -0.03961658477783203, 0.18159236013889313, -0.5377044677734375, 0.12411944568157196, 0.29433518648147583, -0.6432198286056519, -0.7668084502220154, 0.27030521631240845, 0.04452221468091011, -0.4630732536315918, 0.8333142399787903, 0.02029934898018837, -0.6344855427742004, 0.7157500982284546, 0.5629329681396484, 0.7689304947853088, -0.6195788383483887, 0.12392516434192657, 0.4451572895050049, 0.18892315030097961, -0.06303362548351288, 0.1892370879650116, -0.013255340047180653, -0.8286436200141907, -0.4786348342895508, -0.871585488319397, -0.21703310310840607, 0.13718177378177643, -0.5438340902328491, 0.09155275672674179, -0.33064934611320496, -0.025436189025640488, 0.06683573126792908, -0.4107518196105957, -0.5092085003852844, 0.3100675940513611, 0.7560164928436279, 0.6206722259521484, -0.6441458463668823, 0.8189951181411743, 1.0925567150115967, -0.4456482529640198, -0.7135127782821655, -0.21815259754657745, -0.24153511226177216, -1.012197732925415, 0.8885019421577454, 0.29805988073349, -0.3055971562862396, -0.05234714224934578, -0.4684847891330719, -1.1179580688476562, 0.9339421391487122, 0.5131577253341675, -0.18080469965934753, -0.1902100145816803, 0.7222726941108704, 0.8496689796447754, -0.09844443947076797, 0.1651979684829712, 0.4539321959018707, 0.205204039812088, -0.09356987476348877, -0.8506301641464233, -0.07017289102077484, -0.43733105063438416, 0.34810870885849, 0.39569753408432007, -0.22049708664417267, 0.8771443367004395, 0.1276954561471939, -0.48429766297340393, 0.015647435560822487, 0.5992394685745239, -0.1002657562494278, -0.4179249703884125, 0.20925363898277283, 0.37648943066596985, 0.688862681388855, -0.12199262529611588, 1.3330506086349487, -0.3552951514720917, 0.05204787850379944, 0.8302121162414551, -0.004533886909484863, 0.6663734912872314, 0.429837703704834, -0.16885770857334137, 0.40833693742752075, 0.9596190452575684, 0.0011126853059977293, 0.657987654209137, 0.014307841658592224, 0.12724998593330383, -0.18763938546180725, -0.22430674731731415, -0.42013317346572876, 0.7309731245040894, 0.5162302255630493, -0.3687179684638977, 0.02303890511393547, 0.12266983091831207, 0.0013517960906028748, 0.06944651156663895, -0.46870604157447815, 0.817325234413147, 0.10116245597600937, -0.7494521737098694, 0.6356219053268433, -0.04526382312178612, 0.6672472953796387, -0.709884524345398, 0.051565021276474, -0.4728761315345764, 0.056689850986003876, -0.04875142127275467, -1.1185863018035889, 0.3279355466365814, -0.2957215905189514, -0.06765668094158173, -0.6343276500701904, 0.8214243054389954, -0.24358896911144257, -0.2822328209877014, 0.4207915663719177, 0.5033729672431946, 0.3668452203273773, -0.049173351377248764, -0.3196122944355011, -0.05003071948885918, -0.3697150647640228, -0.16825735569000244, 0.32083120942115784, 0.6117027401924133, -0.3693755269050598, 0.5066453814506531, 0.5138238668441772, -0.09099479764699936, 0.5267313718795776, 0.3588223457336426, 0.4008444845676422, -0.6974276304244995, -0.5758858919143677, -1.0001559257507324, 0.39518842101097107, 0.21928203105926514, -0.07567409425973892, 0.526555061340332, 0.314933717250824, 1.0932704210281372, -0.5104429125785828, 0.4163731634616852, -0.09465538710355759, -0.38670650124549866, -0.6400091648101807, 0.7412328124046326, -0.5227222442626953, -0.040754690766334534, 0.009234346449375153, -0.8266366720199585, -0.5051730871200562, 0.499049574136734, -0.45789480209350586, -0.10051839053630829, 0.755569577217102, 0.4560233950614929, -0.26510605216026306, -0.15280643105506897, 0.4994870126247406, -0.091316357254982, -0.02306172251701355, 0.338412880897522, 1.1446000337600708, -0.31080204248428345, 0.39087212085723877, -0.7425811290740967, 0.3914049565792084, -0.13383391499519348, -0.42857909202575684, -0.6834168434143066, -0.7542853355407715, -0.15690240263938904, 0.15283873677253723, -0.04304768890142441, 0.5516354441642761, 0.7526448965072632, -1.0171552896499634, -0.275418221950531, -0.4112952649593353, 0.017566034570336342, -0.29205530881881714, -0.05530381202697754, 0.5386648178100586, -0.5824488997459412, -1.075743317604065, 0.5238694548606873, 0.36517173051834106, 0.4087523818016052, -0.05179448798298836, -0.04112539812922478, -0.18658696115016937, -0.16706392168998718, 0.7821102738380432, 0.13134609162807465, -0.8137595057487488, -0.3247770369052887, 0.4382469654083252, -0.4145653247833252, 0.4822028577327728, 1.0296550989151, -0.502582848072052, 0.11386150121688843, 0.8459858894348145, 0.7092528343200684, 0.36666807532310486, -0.3442721962928772, 0.7889336347579956, -0.8778260350227356, 0.33889731764793396, 0.04922939091920853, 0.5822133421897888, 0.42563214898109436, -0.5089185237884521, 0.5452545285224915, 0.015848111361265182, 0.12508843839168549, -0.6333858966827393, 0.48751044273376465, -0.8944966197013855, -0.40145426988601685, 0.8310152888298035, -0.08379196375608444, -0.2478058785200119, 0.08540921658277512, -0.021504748612642288, 0.5292618274688721, 0.0894736796617508, 0.4657265543937683, 0.5995219349861145, -0.10145996510982513, -0.41686350107192993, -0.19147197902202606, 0.45844346284866333, 0.464581161737442, -0.5644945502281189, -0.2736142575740814, 0.19896705448627472, 0.0108648631721735, 0.5915511846542358, 0.329822301864624, -0.18064358830451965, 0.01827828958630562, 0.19730627536773682, -0.1312645673751831, 0.32276400923728943, -0.4609073996543884, -0.8686941862106323, 0.2762505114078522, 0.2108321189880371, -0.12711665034294128 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04525v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04525v1
IITK at SemEval-2024 Task 10: Who is the speaker? Improving Emotion Recognition and Flip Reasoning in Conversations via Speaker Embeddings
2024-04-06T06:47:44
2024-04-06T06:47:44
Shubham Patel, Divyaksh Shukla, Ashutosh Modi
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
This paper presents our approach for the SemEval-2024 Task 10: Emotion Discovery and Reasoning its Flip in Conversations. For the Emotion Recognition in Conversations (ERC) task, we utilize a masked-memory network along with speaker participation. We propose a transformer-based speaker-centric model for the Emotion Flip Reasoning (EFR) task. We also introduce Probable Trigger Zone, a region of the conversation that is more likely to contain the utterances causing the emotion to flip. For sub-task 3, the proposed approach achieves a 5.9 (F1 score) improvement over the task baseline. The ablation study results highlight the significance of various design choices in the proposed method.
[ -0.7529931664466858, -0.5638387203216553, 0.4668597877025604, 0.1906348168849945, -0.25132453441619873, -0.15270331501960754, -0.05089475214481354, -0.4896923303604126, 0.5688512325286865, 0.6637893319129944, -0.5075801014900208, -0.13247182965278625, -0.6062095165252686, 0.04791795089840889, -0.3389691412448883, 0.5299972891807556, 0.15871915221214294, -0.1517971009016037, -0.06503534317016602, -0.24094940721988678, -0.2216738760471344, -0.4149402379989624, -0.6067215204238892, -0.7560691833496094, 0.1532694399356842, 0.9566421508789062, 0.0568692572414875, 0.059712063521146774, 0.16160891950130463, 0.3181283175945282, -0.19181965291500092, -0.06373617053031921, -0.2840617895126343, 0.31776687502861023, -0.23893548548221588, -0.13563060760498047, -0.492982417345047, -0.10593490302562714, 0.11798319965600967, 0.2460300326347351, -0.33302071690559387, -0.2935495972633362, -0.17126087844371796, 0.6123259663581848, -0.4697093069553375, 0.12693096697330475, -0.575297474861145, 0.20870471000671387, -0.029466910287737846, -0.42597997188568115, -0.7490637302398682, 0.03253769874572754, 0.2534322738647461, 0.16392798721790314, 0.12283186614513397, 0.1039167195558548, 0.46896493434906006, 0.24246282875537872, -0.8318843841552734, -0.16251181066036224, -0.7501316070556641, 0.3597550392150879, -0.5485525727272034, 0.6472477316856384, 0.35146763920783997, 0.1859750896692276, 0.29338833689689636, -0.47737929224967957, -0.7436705231666565, 0.17650100588798523, 0.12143406271934509, 0.2793354094028473, -0.21962572634220123, 0.22400063276290894, 0.41430923342704773, 0.25535547733306885, -0.25869858264923096, -0.2366769164800644, -0.10742675513029099, -0.17754091322422028, 0.5289217233657837, 0.1339457631111145, 0.2029007077217102, -0.08390263468027115, -0.17862530052661896, -0.27936962246894836, -0.6409251093864441, 0.16048564016819, 0.6008355617523193, 0.219380721449852, 0.05829288810491562, 0.4634957015514374, -0.3319929540157318, 0.1905345916748047, 0.3144717514514923, 0.31457996368408203, 0.49621543288230896, -0.14154912531375885, -0.11498615145683289, 0.5351558327674866, 0.3062560260295868, 0.35123321413993835, 0.09438466280698776, 0.32180002331733704, 0.08374244719743729, -0.3001669645309448, 0.5829721093177795, -0.8320209980010986, -0.42901259660720825, 0.313739538192749, -0.36089250445365906, -0.1875356137752533, -0.00526251457631588, -0.9227203726768494, -0.40072867274284363, -0.026323486119508743, 0.7157415747642517, -0.422104150056839, -0.5304656028747559, 0.028259504586458206, 0.07671570777893066, 0.3168036639690399, 0.5085483193397522, -0.8817405700683594, 0.40528032183647156, 0.6678318977355957, 0.28373947739601135, 0.19602008163928986, 0.008097488433122635, -0.47760009765625, -0.0921214297413826, 0.08312739431858063, 1.0541698932647705, -0.7316402196884155, -0.4251902401447296, 0.05150073394179344, 0.3976300358772278, -0.0077810343354940414, -0.3336047828197479, 0.9007869958877563, -0.3347066044807434, 0.3012807369232178, -0.4809640645980835, -0.4501087963581085, -0.4052430987358093, 0.2694039046764374, -0.5696337819099426, 1.0291404724121094, -0.14930221438407898, -0.8129274845123291, -0.08866267651319504, -0.6070379614830017, -0.49713948369026184, 0.014770667999982834, -0.10306679457426071, -0.6821043491363525, 0.05956505611538887, 0.20148657262325287, 0.3428761661052704, 0.01664898917078972, -0.04574010521173477, -0.07168751209974289, -0.41438472270965576, 0.12140855193138123, -0.02347513474524021, 0.1794457584619522, 0.13469694554805756, -0.9344556927680969, -0.008298927918076515, -0.4752165973186493, -0.06754311919212341, -0.0021676986943930387, -0.06077266111969948, -0.2450518161058426, 0.09062416851520538, -0.15240100026130676, 0.11404132843017578, -0.2925114333629608, -0.8216087222099304, 0.0418710932135582, -0.4758956730365753, 0.1976972222328186, 0.8594785928726196, 0.20316384732723236, 0.5673795342445374, 0.16151361167430878, 0.34471604228019714, 0.4579722583293915, 0.022903336212038994, -0.5563459992408752, -0.7498767375946045, -1.1157361268997192, 0.10120130330324173, 0.001491044764406979, 0.5194282531738281, -0.6900704503059387, 0.14734512567520142, 0.05130798742175102, -0.3736400902271271, -0.40370312333106995, -0.5000193119049072, 0.37267571687698364, 0.6763654351234436, 0.34882691502571106, 0.029433639720082283, -0.569578230381012, -1.0483096837997437, -0.4948911666870117, -0.14714668691158295, 0.27131226658821106, 0.6780513525009155, 0.31320953369140625, -0.24157534539699554, 0.5660364627838135, -0.2984730899333954, 0.08118557184934616, -0.2041877657175064, 0.42024126648902893, 0.1576385349035263, 0.425367146730423, 0.12467802315950394, -1.0027607679367065, -0.6398809552192688, 0.029730288311839104, -0.2396630346775055, -0.5142017602920532, 0.020077556371688843, -0.0728280246257782, 0.4144502580165863, 0.672588050365448, -0.2580868899822235, 0.834235429763794, 0.31040385365486145, -0.7187719941139221, 0.17520159482955933, 0.06949102133512497, 0.6097727417945862, -0.82025545835495, -0.24082554876804352, -0.07503989338874817, -0.2641136944293976, -1.0521601438522339, -0.5979541540145874, 0.24153093993663788, -0.17826464772224426, -0.397734671831131, 0.618527352809906, -0.2266838699579239, -0.13033580780029297, -0.36308738589286804, -0.17350462079048157, -0.0739385113120079, 0.6008259654045105, 0.2327050268650055, 0.4334101676940918, 0.12275473773479462, -0.41909435391426086, 0.28157874941825867, 0.3244015872478485, -0.25156763195991516, 0.8538453578948975, -0.5808833241462708, 0.6186192035675049, -0.06463108211755753, 0.19494380056858063, -0.9922609925270081, -0.09229161590337753, 0.2858828008174896, -0.43652933835983276, 0.6146546602249146, -0.07122199237346649, 0.01798943430185318, -0.29253071546554565, -0.11488807201385498, 0.37926962971687317, 0.46745195984840393, -0.650650143623352, 1.1378173828125, 0.32494550943374634, -0.461508572101593, -0.3940931260585785, -0.5352919101715088, 0.12864428758621216, -0.2390279769897461, -0.7679233551025391, 0.5668092966079712, 0.01434546709060669, -0.1835949867963791, -0.12701670825481415, -0.0945541188120842, 0.3863208591938019, -0.1616496443748474, 0.5988980531692505, -0.3077162206172943, 0.1170988529920578, 0.2866814434528351, 0.019594551995396614, -0.42648249864578247, -0.05827505514025688, 0.039662282913923264, 0.5051294565200806, -0.4909456968307495, -0.6787588000297546, -0.23032183945178986, 0.7055738568305969, 0.34747114777565, -0.07767727971076965, 0.6258378624916077, 0.6520490646362305, -0.4483482539653778, -0.3057701885700226, -0.9157078266143799, -0.45416662096977234, -0.4531983435153961, 0.5067644715309143, -0.5703039169311523, -1.1401864290237427, 0.7201584577560425, -0.5071697235107422, -0.4636656939983368, 0.3071781396865845, 0.8760542273521423, -0.19210834801197052, 1.1551003456115723, 0.6997422575950623, 0.1946330964565277, 0.5815038084983826, 0.007310905028134584, 0.7630525827407837, -0.9863684177398682, -0.5959136486053467, -0.6407908797264099, -0.5135347247123718, -0.43592631816864014, -0.5109153389930725, 0.5700420141220093, -0.22512684762477875, -0.46577101945877075, 0.3911151885986328, -0.48709118366241455, 0.290571928024292, 0.4871504604816437, 0.1454790234565735, -0.061165954917669296, -0.24001045525074005, -0.04622317850589752, -0.11238648742437363, -0.3220821022987366, -0.25018027424812317, 0.5021242499351501, 0.5538342595100403, 0.6151009798049927, 0.12239415943622589, 0.8652138113975525, 0.1664094775915146, -0.0359526127576828, -0.5721901059150696, 0.7220321297645569, 0.3048076033592224, -0.5367268919944763, -0.48444727063179016, -0.1451842188835144, -0.4060131311416626, 0.18144026398658752, 0.2222241908311844, -1.1035906076431274, 0.5150711536407471, -0.08810391277074814, -0.01271769404411316, 0.24173520505428314, -0.6734758615493774, 0.8966379761695862, -0.039515115320682526, 0.07066923379898071, -0.43426796793937683, -0.6420674920082092, -0.01354189496487379, 0.26932165026664734, 0.19252239167690277, -0.1301926076412201, 0.28631389141082764, 0.6916890740394592, -0.5439119935035706, 0.6468983292579651, -0.49296900629997253, 0.1618523746728897, 0.41725730895996094, 0.24235166609287262, 0.9415649175643921, -0.1050269678235054, -0.2944760024547577, -0.12890024483203888, -0.28229883313179016, -0.10450222343206406, -0.6794548630714417, 0.4351048469543457, -0.56005859375, -0.6923027634620667, -0.32050541043281555, 0.04706132411956787, -0.3889816999435425, -0.3057096302509308, 0.2648605406284332, 0.24396874010562897, -0.117670938372612, 0.3180024325847626, 0.8948862552642822, -0.43125292658805847, 0.3328350782394409, 0.5111083388328552, 0.19045577943325043, -0.3618328869342804, 0.662980854511261, -0.07970070093870163, 0.013080901466310024, 0.3302667737007141, 0.37317028641700745, -0.2156146615743637, -0.15245705842971802, -0.021128304302692413, -0.039810411632061005, -0.9772199392318726, -0.26371970772743225, -1.0880281925201416, -0.24781467020511627, -0.5878627300262451, -0.21646375954151154, -0.6522335410118103, -0.4612198770046234, -0.09950581192970276, -0.4687844514846802, 0.4704682528972626, 0.4873831570148468, -0.20000410079956055, 0.23340806365013123, -0.4701113700866699, -0.12864930927753448, 0.6834280490875244, 0.35331666469573975, -0.11833247542381287, -1.0037569999694824, -0.1994672417640686, -0.1618296504020691, -0.37439051270484924, -0.9784023761749268, 0.5940908789634705, 0.465639591217041, 0.5632283091545105, 0.48620131611824036, 0.2676730453968048, 0.4551441967487335, -0.47332218289375305, 0.7060272097587585, 0.08892602473497391, -1.1638306379318237, 0.9070961475372314, -0.1690901219844818, 0.23124580085277557, 0.3979952931404114, 0.2896803319454193, -0.8651123046875, -0.027742259204387665, -0.8768605589866638, -0.7993153929710388, 0.9741852283477783, 0.167733296751976, 0.24550142884254456, 0.06128764525055885, 0.13332980871200562, -0.07609110325574875, 0.0427745096385479, -0.5066322088241577, -0.12788242101669312, -0.4157881438732147, -0.20248891413211823, 0.06988530606031418, -0.8847801685333252, -0.08646538853645325, -0.16813065111637115, 0.8361818790435791, -0.2800068259239197, 0.8523940443992615, 0.31967198848724365, 0.13158109784126282, -0.3482467830181122, 0.41607505083084106, 0.6429498195648193, -0.23865924775600433, -0.21060967445373535, 0.5144968032836914, 0.4191453158855438, -0.4308334290981293, -0.03832760080695152, -0.18727801740169525, 0.22572888433933258, -0.1010715514421463, 0.31761452555656433, 1.1220530271530151, 0.44692274928092957, -0.44564107060432434, 0.7448137402534485, -0.043187063187360764, -0.27059686183929443, -0.32909682393074036, -0.27190151810646057, 0.34547534584999084, 0.8626877069473267, 0.3761475384235382, -0.08865180611610413, 0.3698418438434601, -0.5526347160339355, 0.3037661612033844, -0.07592947036027908, -0.5818524956703186, -0.587041974067688, 0.3193657696247101, 0.5503793954849243, -0.6281747221946716, 0.8091039061546326, -0.21639706194400787, -1.4173365831375122, 0.5230311751365662, 0.4596996009349823, 1.115861177444458, -0.6463397741317749, 0.18530799448490143, 0.45587483048439026, 0.09828221052885056, 0.2392219603061676, 0.7179250121116638, -0.23571138083934784, -1.0024962425231934, -0.1283857822418213, -0.20041435956954956, -0.7693681716918945, -0.4731377363204956, -0.46112683415412903, 0.45905300974845886, 0.04067908227443695, -0.09180081635713577, -0.2717118561267853, -0.10937940329313278, -0.6649722456932068, 0.10207733511924744, 0.4116281569004059, 0.7204977869987488, -0.918613612651825, 0.6594299077987671, 0.7120433449745178, 0.09921819716691971, -0.7879598736763, -0.3046528995037079, 0.22011643648147583, -0.6292321681976318, 0.7692239880561829, 0.12459833174943924, 0.12218725681304932, -0.14992772042751312, -0.5660637021064758, -0.5505989789962769, 1.1252020597457886, 0.07464030385017395, -0.33388960361480713, 0.45036789774894714, 0.20608729124069214, 0.35506606101989746, -0.5398511290550232, 0.8388431668281555, 0.3149261772632599, 0.47686299681663513, 0.6335829496383667, -1.0118929147720337, -0.15785659849643707, -0.5249154567718506, -0.32076790928840637, 0.33696508407592773, -0.7913709282875061, 0.775774359703064, -0.10914168506860733, 0.008892204612493515, -0.5971060395240784, 0.5333772301673889, 0.09518136829137802, 0.6769705414772034, 0.7543706297874451, 0.8280782103538513, 0.5268800854682922, -0.23474527895450592, 0.6725347638130188, -0.10681258887052536, 0.24477310478687286, 1.0607093572616577, -0.3907072842121124, 0.9081369042396545, 0.6021085381507874, -0.26984646916389465, 0.5904437899589539, 0.6252468824386597, 0.39737746119499207, 0.6799301505088806, -0.16481178998947144, -0.4620046615600586, -0.6754136681556702, -0.2011602371931076, -0.24893979728221893, 0.6234270334243774, 0.4318591058254242, -0.28780660033226013, 0.04528006166219711, 0.48953282833099365, -0.0950840637087822, -0.18230056762695312, -0.09505925327539444, 0.7790740728378296, 0.3505069315433502, -0.47162944078445435, -0.1028924211859703, -0.1063336655497551, 0.4422849416732788, -0.03296511992812157, -0.14310778677463531, -0.316845566034317, 0.2224719375371933, -0.28792980313301086, -0.7650539875030518, 0.4022832214832306, -0.18845973908901215, 0.08693298697471619, -0.5419566631317139, 1.0701408386230469, -0.4465397596359253, -0.07441256195306778, 0.2589588165283203, 0.2283204197883606, 0.26757484674453735, -0.4296235144138336, -0.3457062542438507, 0.27876293659210205, 0.1499159187078476, -0.740104079246521, 0.2619841396808624, 0.7139010429382324, 0.02137075550854206, 0.6479763984680176, -0.016704965382814407, -0.3692294955253601, -0.12430296093225479, 0.4356454610824585, 0.753131628036499, -0.839621901512146, -0.64812833070755, -0.5621652603149414, 0.6605672240257263, -0.0984392911195755, -0.025860877707600594, 0.48928311467170715, 0.16351090371608734, 0.37312376499176025, -0.12213318049907684, 0.3767335116863251, -0.07874365895986557, 0.7905345559120178, -0.11529389023780823, 0.2945520579814911, -0.35250234603881836, 0.13361430168151855, -0.617919921875, -0.8009645938873291, 0.19694647192955017, 0.7181398868560791, -0.4994528591632843, -0.04272272810339928, 0.6384856700897217, 0.755301296710968, 0.1780576854944229, 0.727400004863739, 0.49490344524383545, 0.25800079107284546, 0.5141160488128662, 0.6398892998695374, 0.9515022039413452, -0.6136731505393982, 0.3060236871242523, -0.4940514862537384, -0.058898795396089554, -0.6775068640708923, -1.105452060699463, -0.6133723855018616, -1.0262188911437988, -0.726399302482605, -0.3223664462566376, -0.13360072672367096, 0.9429176449775696, 0.5945410132408142, -0.9752235412597656, 0.11754684895277023, 0.15750733017921448, 0.09941435605287552, 0.023101162165403366, -0.1746978610754013, 0.07748615741729736, 0.13869193196296692, -0.665233314037323, 0.4007982313632965, 0.7397685647010803, -0.10346284508705139, 0.19839973747730255, -0.27999433875083923, -0.25816741585731506, 0.11815189570188522, 0.49993130564689636, 0.23173919320106506, -0.5001572370529175, -0.8791646361351013, 0.06567622721195221, 0.22646047174930573, -0.035275898873806, 0.8366832137107849, -0.7110126614570618, 0.7435885071754456, 0.6663627624511719, 0.579981803894043, 0.9346959590911865, 0.04809485748410225, 0.5257853269577026, -0.36384499073028564, 0.16432540118694305, 0.5387573838233948, 0.45475834608078003, 0.23784884810447693, -0.3540094792842865, 0.7766245007514954, 0.3067982792854309, -0.9111343622207642, -0.9216824173927307, 0.14624758064746857, -1.063779354095459, 0.16292525827884674, 0.9385671019554138, -0.14404766261577606, -0.12714040279388428, -0.01674359291791916, -0.2807663679122925, 0.199346125125885, -0.4060502350330353, 0.5926216244697571, 0.7407848834991455, -0.6873672008514404, -0.838444709777832, -0.2934325039386749, 0.38910552859306335, 0.5987318754196167, -0.6104722619056702, -0.1835194230079651, -0.012297320179641247, -0.10772169381380081, 0.21334247291088104, 0.7220941185951233, -0.1692030280828476, 0.09586415439844131, 0.03545765206217766, 0.3442598283290863, 0.04107644781470299, -0.3259701728820801, -0.3628177344799042, -0.006037335377186537, -0.2806259095668793, 0.16994787752628326 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04522v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04522v2
Q-PEFT: Query-dependent Parameter Efficient Fine-tuning for Text Reranking with Large Language Models
2024-04-06T06:44:41
2024-04-12T00:18:06
Zhiyuan Peng, Xuyang Wu, Qifan Wang, Sravanthi Rajanala, Yi Fang
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods have been extensively utilized in Large Language Models (LLMs) to improve the down-streaming tasks without the cost of fine-tuing the whole LLMs. Recent studies have shown how to effectively use PEFT for fine-tuning LLMs in ranking tasks with convincing performance; there are some limitations, including the learned prompt being fixed for different documents, overfitting to specific tasks, and low adaptation ability. In this paper, we introduce a query-dependent parameter efficient fine-tuning (Q-PEFT) approach for text reranking to leak the information of the true queries to LLMs and then make the generation of true queries from input documents much easier. Specifically, we utilize the query to extract the top-$k$ tokens from concatenated documents, serving as contextual clues. We further augment Q-PEFT by substituting the retrieval mechanism with a multi-head attention layer to achieve end-to-end training and cover all the tokens in the documents, guiding the LLMs to generate more document-specific synthetic queries, thereby further improving the reranking performance. Extensive experiments are conducted on four public datasets, demonstrating the effectiveness of our proposed approach.
[ -0.20202738046646118, -0.9154409170150757, 0.7143320441246033, 0.0035365198273211718, -0.4524554908275604, 0.23234803974628448, -0.4022747874259949, -0.13994140923023224, 0.24513086676597595, 0.6616353988647461, -0.5514194965362549, -0.49567335844039917, -0.6985160708427429, 0.15387769043445587, -0.33069828152656555, 0.8835544586181641, 0.13355320692062378, -0.24332575500011444, -0.22243806719779968, -0.048412617295980453, -0.3194979727268219, -0.7128830552101135, -0.8644742965698242, -0.07505765557289124, 0.6934142112731934, 0.5725888609886169, 0.33822739124298096, 0.5525138974189758, 0.4056890904903412, 0.2557632029056549, -0.12529079616069794, 0.5022035837173462, -0.8690190315246582, 0.4680139124393463, -0.5038138031959534, -0.5137544274330139, -0.2749401330947876, 0.10484234988689423, 0.9535436630249023, 0.5331650972366333, 0.06380075216293335, 0.10060553252696991, 0.28598272800445557, 0.8548811078071594, -0.8211684226989746, 0.08996390551328659, -1.0446289777755737, -0.2696585953235626, -0.3743225932121277, -0.47436267137527466, -0.5796511769294739, -0.2739098370075226, 0.024766728281974792, -0.5903998017311096, 0.22574445605278015, 0.25754430890083313, 0.7314678430557251, 0.27502575516700745, -0.5301157832145691, 0.17844350636005402, -0.3171232044696808, 0.9051896333694458, -0.5347207188606262, 0.7323941588401794, 0.5962806940078735, 0.10986167937517166, -0.18128184974193573, -0.8664133548736572, -0.29167717695236206, -0.17585448920726776, -0.06699337065219879, -0.06543746590614319, 0.2950619161128998, 0.1301555186510086, 0.07055551558732986, 0.22417117655277252, -0.38316601514816284, -0.07828100770711899, 0.03784337639808655, -0.14218828082084656, 0.4915429353713989, -0.023915419355034828, -0.05485496297478676, 0.18448413908481598, -0.1593131422996521, -0.16925369203090668, -0.8118822574615479, 0.040863342583179474, 0.22107812762260437, 0.520550549030304, 0.38928136229515076, 0.3518252372741699, -0.601094126701355, 0.5963209867477417, 0.6162031888961792, -0.08714497089385986, 0.16116905212402344, -0.46841147541999817, -0.13269905745983124, -0.15302370488643646, 0.48776310682296753, 0.2649795114994049, 0.18367010354995728, -0.49517130851745605, -0.19355915486812592, -0.5561049580574036, 0.2837039828300476, -1.030249834060669, -0.10824891179800034, 0.14448586106300354, -0.2965439260005951, -0.29374128580093384, -0.04703933745622635, -0.6928165555000305, -0.2444673329591751, -0.2307133823633194, 0.6355267763137817, -0.36675313115119934, 0.05453920736908913, -0.1322043091058731, -0.027461586520075798, 0.23590055108070374, 0.3055213391780853, -0.9665402173995972, 0.12515276670455933, 0.7846145629882812, 0.6791040897369385, -0.2785566747188568, -0.54876309633255, -1.1215115785598755, 0.2981819212436676, -0.15186576545238495, 0.923389196395874, -0.9005627036094666, -0.2949622869491577, -0.12291183322668076, 0.1918543428182602, -0.43031489849090576, -0.4774094820022583, 0.8213057518005371, -0.6667256951332092, 0.1418704390525818, -0.4001930058002472, -0.7440600395202637, 0.05505203455686569, 0.5348286032676697, -0.40522125363349915, 1.1946505308151245, 0.02682800404727459, -0.6317466497421265, 0.2636408507823944, -0.28117766976356506, -0.43084368109703064, -0.023613030090928078, -0.05070794001221657, -0.47312822937965393, 0.06939652562141418, 0.5005772709846497, 0.34028178453445435, -0.44109219312667847, 0.2765727937221527, -0.2956072688102722, -0.6144347786903381, -0.11373621225357056, -0.4366362988948822, 0.4039551019668579, -0.10417021811008453, -0.2628008723258972, 0.09803951531648636, -0.5620089173316956, 0.24185453355312347, 0.08029015362262726, -0.6168227791786194, -0.45787593722343445, 0.10950388014316559, -0.05693898722529411, -0.16011078655719757, 0.4026046693325043, -0.5845018029212952, 0.4824784994125366, -0.7673734426498413, 0.46027106046676636, 0.5056971907615662, 0.31759193539619446, 0.6018925905227661, -0.38970765471458435, 0.3312918543815613, -0.364228218793869, 0.05362655967473984, -0.23109357059001923, -0.25346168875694275, -0.4953237771987915, -0.22128930687904358, 0.7030100226402283, 0.31964829564094543, -0.6486111879348755, 0.31756430864334106, -0.08519677072763443, -0.55340176820755, -0.32910487055778503, 0.1264549046754837, 0.452381432056427, 0.5578849911689758, 0.20231738686561584, 0.22828906774520874, -0.14008016884326935, -0.8004984259605408, -0.7516067624092102, -0.010407067835330963, 0.04018041118979454, 0.4261779487133026, 0.16281357407569885, 0.10122931003570557, 0.6528003811836243, -0.6915816068649292, -0.4080944359302521, -0.03856198862195015, 0.060258157551288605, 0.1259101927280426, 0.4991197884082794, 0.3907100558280945, -0.8910971283912659, -0.7672075629234314, -0.2695240080356598, 0.13000445067882538, -0.1958409547805786, -0.07988773286342621, -0.3648466169834137, 0.13518932461738586, 0.8532711863517761, -0.4997955858707428, -0.12771926820278168, 0.3096408247947693, -0.43848568201065063, 0.3777100145816803, -0.3337665796279907, 0.28011465072631836, -0.7828394770622253, 0.1513535976409912, -0.06980554014444351, -0.353677898645401, -0.28144320845603943, 0.3311704397201538, 0.4214484393596649, -0.04251984879374504, -0.3239663243293762, 0.5932772755622864, -0.31380876898765564, 0.4510291516780853, -0.25750017166137695, -0.003412959398701787, 0.23366080224514008, 0.8212209939956665, -0.17893724143505096, 0.7335349917411804, 0.5045294761657715, -0.43644091486930847, -0.06054947152733803, 0.01312190294265747, -0.00413514906540513, 0.3781120479106903, -0.47412675619125366, 0.30663609504699707, -0.00399172306060791, 0.3015454411506653, -1.0054103136062622, 0.015018169768154621, 0.16874118149280548, -0.310308575630188, 0.44251665472984314, -0.43957558274269104, -0.7410191893577576, 0.25661733746528625, -0.6311896443367004, 0.4130744934082031, 0.17388884723186493, -0.6518803834915161, 0.42882609367370605, 0.3983512818813324, -0.24914218485355377, -0.3361949324607849, -0.19654934108257294, 0.028756750747561455, -0.25723734498023987, -0.32079631090164185, 1.09871506690979, -0.09717422723770142, 0.19381433725357056, -0.23560911417007446, -0.2467876374721527, -0.184915691614151, 0.05077439546585083, -0.09872416406869888, -0.2545197606086731, 0.0690886378288269, 0.2888467311859131, 0.5216313600540161, -0.06492016464471817, -0.21506507694721222, -0.30870041251182556, 0.4676617681980133, 0.09898124635219574, -0.24916332960128784, -0.19600968062877655, 0.5174399018287659, 0.8711591362953186, -0.6381582617759705, 0.7853758931159973, 0.41140416264533997, -0.3942236602306366, -0.3171304762363434, -0.5989505648612976, -0.33314231038093567, -0.48121342062950134, 0.27564549446105957, -0.34645915031433105, -0.9682669639587402, 0.2288392186164856, -0.46203818917274475, 0.0047564031556248665, 0.3710258901119232, 0.5285715460777283, -0.01155080646276474, 1.1806198358535767, 0.6745879054069519, -0.09057455509901047, 0.7215921878814697, -0.15445636212825775, -0.03245464712381363, -0.7495473027229309, -0.19017058610916138, -0.6099132299423218, -0.37244296073913574, -0.6918642520904541, -0.2821443974971771, 0.34609556198120117, 0.24868957698345184, -0.3061860501766205, 0.04774044454097748, -0.4220377802848816, 0.7659648060798645, 0.6111319661140442, 0.21815678477287292, 0.36554399132728577, -0.0581064373254776, -0.19342456758022308, -0.0673159509897232, -0.44709888100624084, -0.04154650866985321, 1.2344523668289185, 0.12156236171722412, 0.49184852838516235, 0.006115976255387068, 0.7919591665267944, 0.17480550706386566, -0.09753184765577316, -0.6640545129776001, 0.3471389710903168, -0.42823946475982666, -0.3281030058860779, -0.5065873265266418, -0.30243366956710815, -0.8124738335609436, 0.4777674674987793, -0.22390596568584442, -0.7004601359367371, 0.32470467686653137, 0.1032036617398262, -0.3172655701637268, -0.0708964467048645, -0.7164267301559448, 0.8303950428962708, -0.1428568959236145, -0.4683668911457062, -0.2513193190097809, -0.33084991574287415, -0.053824786096811295, -0.4241822361946106, -0.18621961772441864, -0.03862505778670311, -0.2107965052127838, 0.7203595042228699, -0.34978002309799194, 0.6165046095848083, -0.24251122772693634, -0.04988228902220726, 0.011668343096971512, -0.0558069571852684, 0.9901859760284424, 0.3920260965824127, -0.29913726449012756, -0.12831108272075653, 0.26636630296707153, -0.2781643867492676, -0.6230251789093018, 0.858916699886322, -0.3788045048713684, -0.7209478616714478, -0.08982729911804199, -0.4409545063972473, -0.6146918535232544, 0.49487099051475525, 0.3186509311199188, 0.39592650532722473, 0.049011990427970886, 0.7098930478096008, 0.740155816078186, -0.09770127385854721, 0.23467126488685608, 0.6745865941047668, -0.07170861214399338, -0.3036322593688965, 0.9653449058532715, 0.36252474784851074, -0.08289133012294769, 0.798541784286499, 0.21533335745334625, -0.5677785277366638, -0.7439448237419128, -0.15869276225566864, 0.2668152153491974, -0.2593337595462799, -0.3891250491142273, -0.6451001763343811, -0.11488737165927887, -0.35889461636543274, -0.11402855068445206, -0.5081571340560913, -0.3939347267150879, -0.1974448561668396, 0.13196100294589996, 0.32775163650512695, 0.06919581443071365, 0.36841854453086853, 0.33809182047843933, -0.7137051820755005, 0.3888304531574249, 0.3141884207725525, 0.6516570448875427, -0.08112094551324844, -0.5497576594352722, -0.31379395723342896, -0.18555940687656403, -0.4651322066783905, -0.9059315323829651, 0.3777907192707062, 0.5550902485847473, 0.7003059387207031, 0.08385895937681198, 0.3855224549770355, 0.47610631585121155, -0.5368597507476807, 0.4628486633300781, -0.28003883361816406, -0.7895832657814026, 0.4719718396663666, -0.485144704580307, 0.30183613300323486, 0.9518044590950012, 0.1196560189127922, -0.23899275064468384, -0.65236496925354, -0.4568634033203125, -1.0321760177612305, 0.752899169921875, 0.21993687748908997, 0.10254554450511932, 0.08986678719520569, 0.6904264092445374, 0.09625238925218582, 0.08711107075214386, -0.3240668475627899, -0.14310753345489502, 0.16406771540641785, -0.09721212089061737, -0.020551631227135658, -0.4531532824039459, 0.184891939163208, -0.48404359817504883, 0.6763613224029541, -0.27704447507858276, -0.08897406607866287, 0.29764410853385925, -0.1671668291091919, -0.19636116921901703, 0.3099231719970703, 0.27858269214630127, 0.4912436306476593, -0.49439796805381775, 0.14571061730384827, 0.15393926203250885, -0.415059894323349, -0.01582406647503376, 0.26358646154403687, -0.12742166221141815, -0.07835937291383743, -0.03543274104595184, 0.3403781056404114, 0.40786024928092957, -0.7183006405830383, 0.3889610767364502, -0.13284076750278473, -0.3497951924800873, 0.07699534296989441, 0.21332256495952606, 0.23676931858062744, 0.3832125663757324, 0.5887937545776367, -0.3201788663864136, 0.15874238312244415, -0.44727909564971924, 0.3854362368583679, 0.4975185990333557, -0.08723733574151993, 0.042968716472387314, 0.6139642000198364, 0.30668193101882935, -0.31454718112945557, 0.3850930631160736, -0.1529749482870102, -0.4425080418586731, 0.3985711336135864, 0.5049068331718445, 0.6878035664558411, -0.03464391082525253, 0.053271424025297165, 0.29995736479759216, 0.17534950375556946, -0.13578467071056366, 0.28840142488479614, -0.19395247101783752, -0.40153011679649353, -0.5916608572006226, -0.7088155746459961, -0.5202760696411133, 0.33038970828056335, -0.46357226371765137, 0.22848692536354065, -0.38002824783325195, -0.15070249140262604, 0.03884923830628395, 0.33609330654144287, -0.35729387402534485, 0.10207418352365494, -0.09166485071182251, 0.8903472423553467, -0.4279826581478119, 1.0507750511169434, 0.7380692958831787, -0.16285520792007446, -0.6042468547821045, 0.5387864708900452, -0.4345805048942566, -0.445865660905838, 0.4589309096336365, -0.04067772626876831, -0.041301924735307693, 0.4626249074935913, -0.4321887493133545, -1.1960145235061646, 0.9100172519683838, 0.7163869142532349, -0.7750839591026306, -0.16911667585372925, -0.07854411751031876, 0.39200571179389954, -0.12980864942073822, 0.05813905969262123, 0.6074438095092773, 0.4442638158798218, -0.09083724766969681, -0.8200982809066772, 0.18716618418693542, -0.06331642717123032, -0.2186264842748642, 0.5398035049438477, -0.8886806964874268, 0.7225275635719299, 0.14834904670715332, -0.08385564386844635, -0.10156384855508804, 0.3990428149700165, 0.3430231809616089, 0.323851615190506, 0.5252169370651245, 0.45495060086250305, 0.7866899371147156, 0.09971331804990768, 0.8449053764343262, -0.4718412160873413, 0.5928959250450134, 1.1569898128509521, -0.08804523199796677, 0.9784277677536011, 0.5269914269447327, -0.009066645056009293, 0.09098975360393524, 0.5597482323646545, 0.05424452945590019, 0.8412401080131531, -0.03358467295765877, -0.031224234029650688, -0.49297142028808594, -0.041713424026966095, -0.3142027258872986, 0.5573097467422485, 0.3014000952243805, -0.4884984791278839, -0.49879467487335205, -0.11152207851409912, -0.12361158430576324, 0.04934455826878548, -0.2915533483028412, 0.6963408589363098, 0.01053388137370348, -0.8649160265922546, 0.7877213358879089, 0.3209823966026306, 0.6804163455963135, -0.3694615066051483, -0.1511443704366684, -0.3570863902568817, 0.1811073273420334, 0.01934001035988331, -0.5244828462600708, 0.17138461768627167, -0.005574865732342005, -0.48734936118125916, -0.3623083531856537, 0.8530771732330322, -0.5651408433914185, -0.41873812675476074, 0.04707755893468857, 0.47976112365722656, -0.0695156529545784, -0.7980150580406189, -0.7608501315116882, -0.11866896599531174, 0.015372051857411861, -0.5179606676101685, 0.7739802002906799, 0.4359789490699768, -0.07089756429195404, 0.4529842734336853, 0.6944882869720459, -0.008932134136557579, -0.2124566286802292, 0.026408981531858444, 0.8818373680114746, -0.6127360463142395, -0.6991631388664246, -0.9325281381607056, 0.1045273095369339, 0.04056072235107422, -0.2631632685661316, 0.5355937480926514, 0.49770355224609375, 0.7211669683456421, 0.20677459239959717, 0.4998011589050293, 0.29365941882133484, 0.6692193150520325, -0.6204612255096436, 0.9882258772850037, -0.7541663646697998, 0.17618688941001892, -0.1654110997915268, -0.9878281950950623, -0.2863065302371979, 0.1708177626132965, -0.2958504259586334, -0.07643160223960876, 0.6420555114746094, 0.7250524163246155, 0.05351853743195534, -0.35687941312789917, 0.3405219614505768, 0.1598799228668213, 0.26520949602127075, 0.4693187177181244, 0.40345993638038635, -0.24701546132564545, 0.8118384480476379, -0.22246038913726807, -0.11029350012540817, -0.4506864547729492, -0.8030036687850952, -0.6572649478912354, -0.5918193459510803, -0.360080361366272, 0.04835020750761032, 0.2711423337459564, 0.667266845703125, 0.6461833119392395, -0.6856406331062317, 0.31570348143577576, -0.09018072485923767, 0.29366305470466614, -0.2135537564754486, -0.22460013628005981, 0.7340809106826782, -0.5313793420791626, -0.9744998216629028, 0.5581579208374023, 0.18455442786216736, -0.3669321537017822, 0.11991526931524277, 0.1027454137802124, -0.2275513857603073, 0.1306714415550232, 0.7307188510894775, 0.23731060326099396, -0.5135206580162048, -0.2344127893447876, 0.07357899099588394, -0.027049114927649498, -0.05274003744125366, 0.6821432113647461, -0.9648289084434509, 0.2501264810562134, 0.6899746656417847, 0.838199257850647, 0.5294712781906128, 0.25498709082603455, 0.48059049248695374, -0.9889900088310242, -0.18285150825977325, 0.19177350401878357, 0.28570523858070374, 0.008766904473304749, -0.6223454475402832, 0.31470075249671936, 0.2184617519378662, -0.6097460985183716, -0.9291852712631226, -0.048181865364313126, -0.9729340672492981, -0.5020685195922852, 1.1185132265090942, 0.032729048281908035, 0.007971403189003468, 0.00928045529872179, -0.527941882610321, 0.17287416756153107, -0.6125353574752808, 0.7472032904624939, 0.4504847228527069, -0.1031709834933281, -0.375843346118927, -0.15363681316375732, 0.5202816128730774, 0.5904700756072998, -0.46784281730651855, 0.3051319122314453, 0.16851365566253662, 0.3977051079273224, -0.18773213028907776, 0.632652759552002, -0.10488525032997131, 0.016283035278320312, -0.28846079111099243, -0.597789466381073, -0.21286988258361816, -0.2988722026348114, -0.031676456332206726, 0.6122300028800964, 0.26668882369995117, -0.2620720863342285 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04520v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04520v1
IITK at SemEval-2024 Task 4: Hierarchical Embeddings for Detection of Persuasion Techniques in Memes
2024-04-06T06:28:02
2024-04-06T06:28:02
Shreenaga Chikoti, Shrey Mehta, Ashutosh Modi
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Memes are one of the most popular types of content used in an online disinformation campaign. They are primarily effective on social media platforms since they can easily reach many users. Memes in a disinformation campaign achieve their goal of influencing the users through several rhetorical and psychological techniques, such as causal oversimplification, name-calling, and smear. The SemEval 2024 Task 4 \textit{Multilingual Detection of Persuasion Technique in Memes} on identifying such techniques in the memes is divided across three sub-tasks: ($\mathbf{1}$) Hierarchical multi-label classification using only textual content of the meme, ($\mathbf{2}$) Hierarchical multi-label classification using both, textual and visual content of the meme and ($\mathbf{3}$) Binary classification of whether the meme contains a persuasion technique or not using it's textual and visual content. This paper proposes an ensemble of Class Definition Prediction (CDP) and hyperbolic embeddings-based approaches for this task. We enhance meme classification accuracy and comprehensiveness by integrating HypEmo's hierarchical label embeddings (Chen et al., 2023) and a multi-task learning framework for emotion prediction. We achieve a hierarchical F1-score of 0.60, 0.67, and 0.48 on the respective sub-tasks.
[ -0.6504732966423035, -0.9185377955436707, 0.29701295495033264, 0.5979006886482239, -0.3329610228538513, 0.277843713760376, -0.019938673824071884, -0.15102332830429077, 0.2952725291252136, 0.06920072436332703, -0.7109854221343994, -0.767091691493988, -0.7998794913291931, 0.15080292522907257, 0.012241186574101448, 0.7615423798561096, -0.14102284610271454, -0.09467753022909164, -0.32928815484046936, -0.029424002394080162, -0.31257620453834534, -0.6849473118782043, -0.41233640909194946, -0.22305382788181305, 0.44901731610298157, 0.7443204522132874, 0.20353814959526062, 0.40492862462997437, 0.10603730380535126, 0.3305778503417969, 0.10519939661026001, -0.20174363255500793, -0.2202267199754715, 0.2140640914440155, -0.36720964312553406, -0.20151422917842865, -0.258085161447525, 0.36265644431114197, 0.23064842820167542, 0.03207482770085335, -0.048330169171094894, -0.046457111835479736, 0.3310958445072174, 0.2778147757053375, -0.7733627557754517, 0.27005207538604736, -0.5184891223907471, 0.2555975914001465, -0.3451336920261383, -0.7075376510620117, -0.5353053212165833, -0.14806824922561646, 0.13444998860359192, -0.26951462030410767, -0.2377774715423584, 0.23367083072662354, 0.5394562482833862, 0.09434914588928223, -0.6293236017227173, -0.6085282564163208, -0.1780712902545929, 1.0141820907592773, -0.6457568407058716, 0.29939812421798706, 0.5262218713760376, 0.1627776026725769, -0.008727336302399635, -0.45183873176574707, -0.5365796089172363, 0.19886811077594757, 0.18211674690246582, 0.3457496762275696, -0.5079742670059204, 0.014927391894161701, 0.17472341656684875, 0.009510920383036137, -0.44636237621307373, 0.3825339376926422, -0.1137467473745346, -0.5218918919563293, 0.16269022226333618, -0.0669693872332573, 0.15096376836299896, -0.718808650970459, -0.6301583051681519, -0.3397233486175537, -0.565529465675354, -0.029052941128611565, 0.5249133110046387, -0.13756951689720154, -0.19841603934764862, 0.45893165469169617, -0.18319620192050934, 0.21254871785640717, 0.4011078476905823, -0.3580484390258789, 0.2604215443134308, -0.3616515100002289, -0.07104874402284622, 0.2269318550825119, 0.7981433272361755, 0.28422898054122925, 0.10971588641405106, 0.4306265115737915, 0.038707926869392395, 0.1549054980278015, 0.1085382029414177, -0.9479589462280273, -0.3664480745792389, 0.07691911607980728, -0.6028737425804138, -0.49272438883781433, -0.3215172290802002, -1.3062824010849, -0.3060620129108429, -0.12120386958122253, 0.40780508518218994, -0.46127432584762573, -0.28147369623184204, -0.18906809389591217, -0.15070487558841705, 0.050564639270305634, 0.3393411636352539, -0.8682166934013367, 0.025981195271015167, 0.5957654118537903, 0.5996514558792114, 0.11010134220123291, -0.15021875500679016, -0.2555604577064514, 0.09898544102907181, -0.0736149251461029, 0.9789270162582397, -0.8165504336357117, -0.08635671436786652, 0.1192789226770401, 0.27365320920944214, -0.14800423383712769, -0.3244626522064209, 0.847878098487854, -0.1811739206314087, 0.2511216998100281, -0.320393830537796, -0.7303346991539001, -0.4405108094215393, 0.5618566870689392, -0.6455240845680237, 0.5259010791778564, -0.09970498830080032, -0.7022842764854431, 0.2886374890804291, -0.49608898162841797, -0.3115144968032837, -0.05552908778190613, -0.1997126042842865, -0.563454270362854, -0.25689247250556946, 0.14183878898620605, 1.0030885934829712, -0.12727832794189453, -0.019752198830246925, -0.29772448539733887, -0.032719485461711884, -0.0552460178732872, -0.4169479310512543, 0.26136383414268494, 0.3279096186161041, -0.7289268374443054, 0.002954175928607583, -0.26685428619384766, 0.04138791933655739, -0.14306426048278809, -0.2505309581756592, -0.571450412273407, 0.06498085707426071, -0.10767869651317596, 0.5123712420463562, 0.18049034476280212, -0.6838099956512451, 0.07195618748664856, 0.0600762777030468, 0.2914660573005676, 0.9870266318321228, 0.1920681744813919, 0.3544336259365082, -0.05776606872677803, 0.56145179271698, 0.34536272287368774, 0.13988171517848969, -0.17505811154842377, -0.7767521142959595, -0.22474302351474762, -0.36575552821159363, 0.18709392845630646, 0.552720844745636, -1.033766746520996, 0.46627119183540344, 0.07411647588014603, -0.6221070885658264, -0.14531825482845306, 0.09933397173881531, 0.41571247577667236, 0.31741294264793396, 0.38136959075927734, 0.26363325119018555, -0.7137841582298279, -0.8660516142845154, -0.29413026571273804, -0.12951232492923737, 0.35502731800079346, -0.046505216509103775, 0.7366538047790527, -0.44246360659599304, 0.20018969476222992, -0.1835746169090271, -0.3402051329612732, -0.08957500755786896, 0.6689821481704712, -0.006754004396498203, 0.5821531414985657, 0.7020887732505798, -0.7507770657539368, -0.557523250579834, -0.1238437369465828, -0.7001637816429138, -0.13100731372833252, 0.033659789711236954, 0.01963868737220764, 0.2255120575428009, 0.5561970472335815, -0.03622789680957794, 0.38637569546699524, 0.754183292388916, -0.48337745666503906, 0.5728474855422974, 0.1749841719865799, 0.7713295221328735, -1.2373460531234741, -0.6766281127929688, 0.5814127922058105, 0.06667499244213104, -0.5645716190338135, -0.36418667435646057, 0.29914993047714233, 0.10255603492259979, -0.40241625905036926, 0.3932185173034668, -0.3199615478515625, 0.39433175325393677, -0.15522129833698273, -0.18194127082824707, -0.17345090210437775, 0.6093021631240845, 0.015561646781861782, 0.3308969736099243, 0.6474263668060303, -0.5211946368217468, 0.2674728035926819, 0.10160142928361893, -0.35747405886650085, 1.240397572517395, -0.38754382729530334, 0.061615921556949615, -0.02605275809764862, 0.13041658699512482, -1.2985235452651978, -0.23385366797447205, 0.5499491691589355, -0.48253053426742554, 0.46230795979499817, -0.028531035408377647, -0.5922941565513611, -0.4671779274940491, -0.6231234073638916, 0.3746546804904938, 0.32909712195396423, -0.6537398099899292, 0.3712967336177826, 0.45508483052253723, -0.27971938252449036, -0.6736169457435608, -0.3129969835281372, 0.009738730266690254, -0.49767783284187317, -0.5078601241111755, 0.22077254951000214, -0.045073918998241425, 0.09066380560398102, 0.045430462807416916, 0.012043433263897896, 0.13613280653953552, -0.13964995741844177, 0.40045544505119324, -0.14785699546337128, -0.025631919503211975, 0.17553819715976715, 0.5628283619880676, -0.1843634396791458, -0.042268332093954086, -0.06698720902204514, 0.5446022152900696, -0.28947409987449646, -0.5297247767448425, -0.5765411257743835, 0.482613205909729, 0.5811812281608582, 0.021041156724095345, 0.3259032070636749, 0.6970460414886475, -0.6574512124061584, -0.02629673108458519, -0.7754842042922974, -0.24550805985927582, -0.4697924554347992, 0.5487304329872131, -0.5531402230262756, -0.8728045225143433, 0.2898577153682709, -0.6038575768470764, -0.1148880273103714, 0.5427430868148804, 0.6750941872596741, -0.3284700810909271, 1.3859492540359497, 0.2762770652770996, -0.1625724583864212, 0.3920553922653198, -0.30194351077079773, 0.22988426685333252, -0.5170430541038513, -0.5878820419311523, -0.6758688688278198, -0.6261173486709595, -0.737099826335907, -0.5807613134384155, 0.3904127776622772, -0.07329786568880081, 0.0054465727880597115, 0.31602969765663147, -0.480170339345932, 0.15011724829673767, 0.4296305179595947, -0.0849451944231987, -0.12660673260688782, 0.470159113407135, -0.10931286960840225, -0.5208855867385864, -0.5031660795211792, -0.6045752167701721, 0.7254284620285034, 0.643714427947998, 0.9474335312843323, 0.14368875324726105, 0.7207533121109009, 0.5779759883880615, 0.2437269389629364, -0.920160174369812, 0.5494813323020935, -0.16794106364250183, -0.29950153827667236, -0.20052847266197205, -0.11431808024644852, -1.0554624795913696, 0.05864180624485016, -0.46564537286758423, -0.6203400492668152, 0.3344752788543701, 0.020964598283171654, 0.30217471718788147, 0.42413243651390076, -0.44024819135665894, 0.9666551351547241, -0.06699848175048828, -0.29499343037605286, -0.5948408842086792, -0.26619088649749756, 0.04361903667449951, 0.000779851689003408, 0.3413923978805542, -0.0977540984749794, -0.003970886580646038, 1.1344847679138184, -0.0815914049744606, 0.9172902703285217, -0.3350929617881775, -0.021120388060808182, 0.4802379310131073, -0.07812535017728806, 0.4696211814880371, -0.3466072380542755, -0.18025405704975128, 0.0003782411222346127, 0.05611245334148407, -0.48994964361190796, -0.47065550088882446, 0.8571807742118835, -0.5962081551551819, -0.40893879532814026, -0.40447309613227844, -0.09935173392295837, -0.10414912551641464, -0.07387422025203705, 0.4493376612663269, 0.5179280042648315, -0.32389000058174133, 0.594322681427002, 0.5751771926879883, -0.10641596466302872, 0.3116922080516815, 0.04866976663470268, 0.4723854660987854, -0.5452677607536316, 1.1908602714538574, 0.1433454155921936, -0.12170673161745071, 0.3487425148487091, 0.4759264588356018, -0.7687857747077942, -0.32737311720848083, -0.3198017179965973, 0.012280000373721123, -0.9986585378646851, -0.27358219027519226, -0.70307457447052, 0.15613813698291779, -0.5276350975036621, -0.1673554927110672, -0.016299378126859665, -0.42843419313430786, -0.2876329720020294, -0.2863313555717468, 0.07344841212034225, 0.9086376428604126, -0.10840661078691483, 0.41805383563041687, -0.5430242419242859, -0.06243839114904404, 0.38054120540618896, -0.03335006162524223, -0.05986998975276947, -0.3585164248943329, -0.10835804790258408, 0.05403831601142883, -0.8709539175033569, -1.2246437072753906, 0.26536160707473755, 0.24920134246349335, 0.7918282747268677, 0.8739914894104004, 0.021977810189127922, 0.5233888030052185, -0.2706431448459625, 0.5675975680351257, 0.4749298095703125, -0.8806478381156921, 0.7095842957496643, -0.1549125462770462, -0.10569734871387482, 0.360065221786499, 0.9498283267021179, -0.2744726538658142, -0.46338942646980286, -0.8165200352668762, -0.4851161539554596, 0.24796812236309052, 0.11445912718772888, 0.20228467881679535, -0.3708897531032562, 0.2433982789516449, 0.19418306648731232, 0.346771240234375, -0.71604984998703, -0.20642690360546112, -0.5009137988090515, -0.3378604054450989, 0.08672399073839188, -0.6353567242622375, 0.058068543672561646, -0.35077929496765137, 0.7380261421203613, -0.18169480562210083, 0.11771305650472641, -0.09457843750715256, 0.09072421491146088, -0.14094921946525574, 0.482733815908432, 0.42405247688293457, 0.17894220352172852, -0.10328425467014313, 0.5030844211578369, -0.08448309451341629, -0.38772931694984436, 0.4734402596950531, -0.22762109339237213, 0.2925805151462555, -0.07449037581682205, 0.2148391604423523, 0.672329843044281, 0.33266472816467285, -0.3389888107776642, 0.6160774827003479, 0.18660010397434235, -0.4205593466758728, -0.10217474400997162, -0.3525083065032959, -0.02843381091952324, 0.4343407154083252, 0.18503408133983612, 0.05711320415139198, 0.48082229495048523, -0.7858481407165527, 0.5275182723999023, 0.39673927426338196, -0.45028114318847656, -0.6823018789291382, 0.3630533218383789, 0.35810136795043945, 0.15404118597507477, 0.09226589649915695, -0.4254441261291504, -0.846916913986206, 0.6480775475502014, 0.6402291059494019, 0.7420837879180908, -0.7546331286430359, 0.4465920627117157, 0.7369183301925659, 0.22992460429668427, 0.027187388390302658, 0.4079950749874115, -0.04887263476848602, -0.5542758703231812, -0.13610193133354187, -0.38620179891586304, -0.4177592694759369, 0.18485350906848907, -0.3312114179134369, 0.38954874873161316, -0.4582015872001648, -0.1813143938779831, 0.19580799341201782, 0.001319991541095078, -0.439715176820755, 0.3327372074127197, 0.15819890797138214, 0.7512168288230896, -1.0505132675170898, 0.42846444249153137, 0.9063851237297058, 0.033031217753887177, -0.5999903678894043, -0.020846711471676826, 0.40825995802879333, -0.5250219106674194, 0.4120757281780243, 0.41133788228034973, -0.038593731820583344, 0.03481892868876457, -0.8865732550621033, -0.38105839490890503, 0.9182656407356262, -0.04115300625562668, -0.26219847798347473, 0.2668365240097046, -0.16904258728027344, 0.29924729466438293, -0.5397441387176514, 0.16532213985919952, 0.26723870635032654, 0.6947959065437317, 0.48103076219558716, -0.5224717855453491, 0.15999889373779297, -0.4272964596748352, -0.4422445297241211, 0.00995400920510292, -0.26909399032592773, 0.917932391166687, -0.05213647708296776, -0.016043948009610176, -0.07147549092769623, 0.7156314253807068, 0.3682248592376709, 0.615256667137146, 0.8436661958694458, 0.4311443567276001, 0.7081775665283203, -0.2631569504737854, 0.903509259223938, -0.08617086708545685, 0.3144867718219757, 0.5460705161094666, 0.1410902887582779, 0.8178370594978333, 0.42223840951919556, 0.13959772884845734, 0.8604764938354492, 1.0533868074417114, 0.05143570527434349, 0.7625247240066528, 0.25968870520591736, -0.21229954063892365, -0.3549814820289612, -0.14446492493152618, -0.42704692482948303, 0.46499472856521606, 0.8807570338249207, -0.11790641397237778, -0.21482834219932556, 0.3398858308792114, 0.2844966948032379, 0.06169155612587929, -0.29652708768844604, 0.7953948378562927, -0.019130459055304527, -0.6166296601295471, 0.618438720703125, 0.0844753161072731, 0.8855046629905701, -0.3536292314529419, -0.25171801447868347, 0.40589573979377747, 0.1626831591129303, -0.33648228645324707, -0.9538451433181763, 0.05285074561834335, -0.3640425205230713, 0.08285190910100937, -0.20896779000759125, 1.0524202585220337, -0.5405089259147644, -0.2448827475309372, 0.3721596300601959, 0.5744066834449768, 0.2408735603094101, -0.25950613617897034, -0.9403014779090881, -0.12596753239631653, -0.04546750336885452, -0.22920900583267212, 0.3148924708366394, 0.8394333124160767, -0.24268405139446259, 0.5486985445022583, 0.3541000187397003, -0.26718106865882874, 0.04710892587900162, 0.18591535091400146, 0.6725683808326721, -0.5293251276016235, -0.6792774796485901, -0.888068675994873, 0.3219590187072754, -0.1730831116437912, 0.06815848499536514, 1.000383734703064, 0.26536673307418823, 0.3912440538406372, -0.2651311457157135, 0.8114317655563354, -0.08476008474826813, 0.17615804076194763, -0.3573295474052429, 0.3611331284046173, -0.7773590683937073, -0.15210464596748352, -0.8388372659683228, -0.7852081060409546, 0.1157117411494255, 0.6035088896751404, -0.22835670411586761, -0.043264925479888916, 0.6678376793861389, 0.49343159794807434, 0.04256065562367439, 0.3277604877948761, 0.35878419876098633, 0.23825599253177643, 0.3567875623703003, 0.5245296955108643, 1.1131240129470825, -0.23637451231479645, 0.4783186912536621, -0.6008390784263611, -0.6145960688591003, -0.4953204095363617, -0.8825455904006958, -1.07338547706604, -0.8783625960350037, -0.6303821206092834, -0.270976185798645, -0.1997004896402359, 0.7884877324104309, 0.7489290237426758, -0.9202058911323547, -0.10174829512834549, 0.22475683689117432, 0.3813512325286865, -0.13802297413349152, -0.216517373919487, 0.2827201187610626, -0.11024928838014603, -0.9732208847999573, 0.16831474006175995, 0.5345617532730103, 0.18742066621780396, -0.13151006400585175, -0.11116507649421692, -0.6093306541442871, 0.011895593255758286, 0.8927478194236755, 0.07206080108880997, -0.5914353728294373, -0.5036367774009705, 0.049679387360811234, 0.04207290709018707, -0.1677647978067398, 0.6164950132369995, -0.3369162678718567, 0.5230371356010437, 0.6351438164710999, 0.3296058177947998, 0.16878408193588257, 0.19734163582324982, 0.22822462022304535, -0.7193362712860107, 0.3029099702835083, 0.27402791380882263, 0.5867748856544495, 0.2166384756565094, -0.3683720827102661, 0.42576906085014343, 0.40546467900276184, -0.4878438115119934, -0.4507056474685669, 0.07939371466636658, -0.9407227635383606, -0.1860368400812149, 1.0610476732254028, -0.12439049780368805, -0.2563548982143402, -0.4780246615409851, -0.3699713945388794, 0.07683137059211731, -0.5294287204742432, 0.5382980704307556, 0.8723635077476501, -0.11465062201023102, -0.1854604333639145, -0.3579390347003937, 0.5302963852882385, 0.5131611824035645, -0.9315388798713684, -0.42021334171295166, 0.35548368096351624, 0.14061273634433746, 0.5361900329589844, 0.5385959148406982, -0.09519629180431366, 0.3841414749622345, -0.2921207547187805, 0.06497891992330551, 0.30676472187042236, -0.4175427258014679, 0.10296643525362015, 0.3250603973865509, -0.32550349831581116, -0.4246918857097626 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06652v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06652v1
Large Language Model (LLM) AI text generation detection based on transformer deep learning algorithm
2024-04-06T06:22:45
2024-04-06T06:22:45
Yuhong Mo, Hao Qin, Yushan Dong, Ziyi Zhu, Zhenglin Li
cs.CL
cs.CL
In this paper, a tool for detecting LLM AI text generation is developed based on the Transformer model, aiming to improve the accuracy of AI text generation detection and provide reference for subsequent research. Firstly the text is Unicode normalised, converted to lowercase form, characters other than non-alphabetic characters and punctuation marks are removed by regular expressions, spaces are added around punctuation marks, first and last spaces are removed, consecutive ellipses are replaced with single spaces and the text is connected using the specified delimiter. Next remove non-alphabetic characters and extra whitespace characters, replace multiple consecutive whitespace characters with a single space and again convert to lowercase form. The deep learning model combines layers such as LSTM, Transformer and CNN for text classification or sequence labelling tasks. The training and validation sets show that the model loss decreases from 0.127 to 0.005 and accuracy increases from 94.96 to 99.8, indicating that the model has good detection and classification ability for AI generated text. The test set confusion matrix and accuracy show that the model has 99% prediction accuracy for AI-generated text, with a precision of 0.99, a recall of 1, and an f1 score of 0.99, achieving a very high classification accuracy. Looking forward, it has the prospect of wide application in the field of AI text detection.
[ -0.13988946378231049, -0.9878982901573181, 0.48871439695358276, -0.048602987080812454, -0.33360448479652405, 0.2997823655605316, -0.20716868340969086, -0.37479546666145325, -0.17386841773986816, 0.5648446083068848, -0.5678948163986206, -0.7017578482627869, -0.883492648601532, 0.38995200395584106, -0.652490496635437, 0.7653341889381409, 0.09531574696302414, -0.09594966471195221, 0.062433477491140366, 0.26791825890541077, -0.5397271513938904, -0.2540065348148346, -0.8151199817657471, -0.41352975368499756, 0.12779754400253296, 0.4992268681526184, 0.42861583828926086, 0.5544884204864502, 0.7020917534828186, 0.4337904453277588, -0.31456223130226135, 0.3515678644180298, -0.31365546584129333, 0.22245490550994873, 0.35223910212516785, -0.5567682385444641, -0.5562059283256531, -0.07134614884853363, 0.7903947830200195, -0.30649492144584656, 0.09201499819755554, -0.06014605239033699, 0.00328317703679204, 0.43629759550094604, -0.15586890280246735, 0.007110822480171919, -0.9302782416343689, 0.06937050074338913, -0.3401349186897278, -0.12946665287017822, -0.6104122400283813, -0.12736454606056213, -0.3641825318336487, -0.07415801286697388, 0.2683899402618408, 0.2707740068435669, 0.8177884221076965, 0.5571222305297852, -0.5494216084480286, -0.4542723298072815, -0.7375478148460388, 0.7270870804786682, -1.1676384210586548, 0.25125014781951904, -0.00828332919627428, 0.4211622178554535, -0.1007242426276207, -0.933101236820221, -1.1700776815414429, -0.5068215131759644, 0.078593410551548, 0.09633418172597885, -0.24712076783180237, -0.01565777137875557, 0.21773500740528107, 0.5054107904434204, -0.5515544414520264, 0.5663001537322998, -0.1513480693101883, -0.2820824682712555, 0.8017486929893494, 0.2808564007282257, 0.6631013751029968, -0.1990741342306137, -0.13441744446754456, -0.0254993736743927, -0.840104341506958, -0.15860748291015625, 0.3628332018852234, 0.17102518677711487, -0.37365520000457764, 0.5493496656417847, 0.10725332051515579, 0.5330692529678345, -0.007398294284939766, -0.39660918712615967, 0.3695683181285858, -0.08839962631464005, -0.31051474809646606, 0.04836829751729965, 1.212534785270691, 0.28760120272636414, 0.6761943697929382, 0.14518657326698303, -0.22914505004882812, -0.016612639650702477, 0.031083889305591583, -1.0121210813522339, 0.14310117065906525, -0.08435412496328354, -0.5174738168716431, -0.5015748143196106, -0.057022105902433395, -0.6194097399711609, -0.5045016407966614, -0.10904563218355179, -0.18940772116184235, -0.4604226052761078, -0.12396607547998428, -0.0841086283326149, 0.3533117175102234, 0.3415498435497284, 0.2792428731918335, -0.6383026838302612, -0.29220572113990784, 0.6547735333442688, 0.6207607984542847, -0.3926445543766022, -0.20928187668323517, -0.4027417302131653, 0.002686600899323821, -0.177433043718338, 0.8525646328926086, -0.3906475901603699, -0.2552204132080078, 0.20254455506801605, -0.024020764976739883, 0.06507659703493118, -0.5165569186210632, 0.7921472787857056, -0.554804801940918, 0.3722042739391327, 0.5637567043304443, -0.7963898777961731, -0.13130411505699158, 0.41406407952308655, -0.884901762008667, 0.9972346425056458, -0.07935495674610138, -0.7570115923881531, 0.4933610260486603, -0.5179574489593506, -0.7019152641296387, 0.4234626889228821, -0.12362992018461227, -0.9415062665939331, -0.11383415013551712, 0.5564627647399902, 0.6570160984992981, -0.41521191596984863, 0.5925047993659973, 0.23275744915008545, -0.46829238533973694, 0.25088703632354736, -0.95753014087677, 0.5940980315208435, 0.1590384989976883, -0.43625983595848083, 0.24888908863067627, -0.866590678691864, -0.16923584043979645, 0.20466604828834534, -0.670793354511261, 0.12659333646297455, -0.13592559099197388, 0.3334760069847107, 0.15292486548423767, 0.2464343011379242, -0.5270437002182007, 0.20961502194404602, -0.5759602189064026, 0.3341211676597595, 0.6039623022079468, 0.10472370684146881, 0.3361540138721466, 0.06822512298822403, 0.5776848793029785, 0.14915786683559418, -0.05375415086746216, -0.46061503887176514, -0.789905846118927, -0.964332640171051, -0.24981939792633057, 0.29168787598609924, 0.7684939503669739, -0.812099039554596, 1.088038444519043, -0.25229570269584656, -0.38738590478897095, -0.5413044095039368, 0.2522437572479248, 0.20226474106311798, 0.5001555681228638, 0.10657557100057602, 0.22484715282917023, -0.5130346417427063, -0.7753556966781616, -0.20915265381336212, -0.11926858127117157, -0.045088641345500946, 0.17960652709007263, 0.6955097317695618, -0.6100614666938782, 0.7372650504112244, -0.37201932072639465, -0.4410572052001953, -0.6217862367630005, 0.18544718623161316, 0.3826475739479065, 0.2805888056755066, 0.3927699327468872, -0.8256372213363647, -0.7536680698394775, -0.0016717641847208142, -0.8054203987121582, -0.10771843791007996, -0.2133329063653946, 0.32228684425354004, 0.35807690024375916, 0.848770260810852, -0.478755921125412, 0.5698462724685669, 0.40638551115989685, -0.36108270287513733, 0.25362446904182434, -0.08285775035619736, 0.08563060313463211, -1.5561078786849976, -0.04292844235897064, 0.19903668761253357, -0.48499348759651184, -0.7012850046157837, 0.17198000848293304, 0.18062955141067505, -0.06179368868470192, -0.474119633436203, 0.5497189164161682, -0.15587249398231506, 0.4840148389339447, -0.6429941058158875, 0.11550938338041306, -0.0120895616710186, 0.1528894007205963, -0.16647037863731384, 1.1475577354431152, 0.217389315366745, -0.358442485332489, 0.4772503972053528, 0.21885699033737183, -0.5865918397903442, 0.25086358189582825, -0.4411774277687073, 0.25942376255989075, -0.11763390898704529, 0.18719737231731415, -1.1686201095581055, -0.028125204145908356, 0.2972186803817749, -0.6160385608673096, 0.3785962462425232, 0.4127729833126068, -0.6026747226715088, -0.7459802627563477, -0.08351856470108032, 0.1688099056482315, 0.6123260855674744, -0.599163293838501, 0.6642497777938843, 0.10188234597444534, -0.14414513111114502, -0.36845895648002625, -0.7529988288879395, 0.290487676858902, -0.11760375648736954, -0.8002880215644836, 0.3558022379875183, -0.1601768136024475, -0.033654384315013885, -0.29624903202056885, 0.4317924976348877, -0.06340844184160233, 0.08333685994148254, 0.166981503367424, 0.3375937342643738, -0.3731262981891632, 0.06790687888860703, 0.097469761967659, -0.28606584668159485, -0.04341084882616997, 0.3028421401977539, 0.7906287908554077, 0.08043067902326584, -0.27505967020988464, -0.9440473318099976, 0.08771589398384094, 0.7273070216178894, -0.22388210892677307, 0.6246666312217712, 1.0765196084976196, -0.3838736116886139, -0.28870534896850586, -0.5735271573066711, -0.09681513160467148, -0.5163155794143677, 0.5832368731498718, -0.1681002378463745, -0.9027602076530457, 0.31055018305778503, -0.24987401068210602, -0.18204568326473236, 0.8521853089332581, 0.7763580679893494, 0.07314661890268326, 1.108626127243042, 0.8278024196624756, -0.6500662565231323, 0.4588351845741272, -0.2579846680164337, 0.5199644565582275, -0.6365552544593811, -0.24040719866752625, -0.5392542481422424, -0.19925495982170105, -0.5061163306236267, -0.12373729795217514, 0.04472529888153076, -0.032182857394218445, -0.39611461758613586, 0.04159097373485565, -0.7482085824012756, 0.37528496980667114, 0.7003889679908752, 0.04935188218951225, 0.511081874370575, 0.06919097155332565, 0.11083254218101501, -0.10648433119058609, 0.0001595825597178191, -0.5727568864822388, 1.0991028547286987, 0.4653354585170746, 0.5891371965408325, -0.09919342398643494, 0.5329411029815674, 0.6778067946434021, 0.5031970143318176, -0.9229705929756165, 0.5248029828071594, -0.19633923470973969, -0.3254849910736084, -0.3494828939437866, -0.2018837034702301, -0.6128091812133789, -0.26779574155807495, -0.33589860796928406, -0.5640763640403748, -0.47820883989334106, -0.14859884977340698, -0.09898938238620758, 0.5323513150215149, -0.4156770408153534, 0.4740457236766815, -0.23169541358947754, 0.13961410522460938, -0.0032337973825633526, -0.2364441603422165, 0.5212122201919556, -0.28507283329963684, -0.09109777212142944, -0.04393795505166054, 0.21308793127536774, 0.8173951506614685, -0.17976227402687073, 0.8023706674575806, 0.007863305509090424, -0.43609321117401123, 0.5652044415473938, -0.11317604035139084, 0.9367454648017883, -0.033126138150691986, -0.22495655715465546, 0.15263839066028595, -0.9532318115234375, 0.27759209275245667, -0.2708832621574402, 0.447968453168869, -0.7398961782455444, -0.6223392486572266, -0.25225475430488586, -0.6846340298652649, 0.26307618618011475, 0.43941766023635864, 0.6243448853492737, 0.0020382364746183157, -0.17302268743515015, 0.22228369116783142, 0.5976940989494324, -0.4339136779308319, 0.6733516454696655, 0.4436264634132385, -0.28410032391548157, -0.5847334861755371, 0.6644077301025391, -0.4592510461807251, -0.17189662158489227, 0.5396268367767334, 0.14073824882507324, -0.1747182458639145, -0.6905493140220642, -0.5606899857521057, 0.1101982519030571, -0.42133864760398865, -0.7105997800827026, -0.5415828824043274, -0.7903897166252136, -0.6045255661010742, -0.06281650066375732, -0.028323523700237274, 0.12405932694673538, -0.5763809680938721, -0.06300965696573257, 0.41825366020202637, 0.8528643250465393, 0.6334472298622131, 0.9643303155899048, -0.6799907684326172, 0.44654881954193115, 0.11127600818872452, 0.0014489818131551147, 0.019370727241039276, -0.8261567950248718, -0.06259039789438248, -0.19085560739040375, -0.6280459761619568, -0.642539918422699, 0.739249050617218, 0.11963953077793121, 0.22091002762317657, 0.6151300072669983, -0.29334691166877747, 0.12094205617904663, -0.6805461645126343, 0.8190035223960876, 0.3047272562980652, -1.032183051109314, 0.5002340078353882, -0.22555135190486908, 0.5314742922782898, 0.1668492555618286, -0.13899700343608856, -0.5435287356376648, -0.6042871475219727, -0.40384483337402344, -0.6117957830429077, 0.658018171787262, 0.24708203971385956, 0.24988718330860138, 0.26344555616378784, 0.4201706647872925, -0.09217969328165054, 0.1524685174226761, -1.1420108079910278, -0.35455504059791565, 0.1504833996295929, -0.686885416507721, -0.11525724828243256, -0.5203371644020081, 0.4384952485561371, -0.1552378237247467, 0.7288159728050232, -0.16165074706077576, 0.298078715801239, -0.2219397872686386, -0.04469519108533859, -0.0921190157532692, 0.35725125670433044, 0.6812520027160645, 0.12730544805526733, 0.06913942098617554, -0.2073628455400467, 0.2979590892791748, -0.7800154089927673, 0.3142654597759247, 0.05689220502972603, -0.5042393803596497, 0.02648301236331463, 0.7810192108154297, 0.7163196206092834, -0.4379270374774933, -0.5573233962059021, 0.7285382747650146, -0.09141543507575989, -0.1971341073513031, -0.48813489079475403, 0.2314201295375824, 0.04052077606320381, 0.3099600374698639, 0.5907498002052307, -0.025296157225966454, 0.08607831597328186, -0.15370367467403412, 0.23702043294906616, 0.47585245966911316, -0.3020527958869934, 0.09781715273857117, 0.7355232238769531, 0.2098681777715683, -0.9875800609588623, 0.9223606586456299, -0.1197788417339325, -0.8642361760139465, 1.0456619262695312, 0.9024549126625061, 0.9406553506851196, -0.5328230857849121, 0.14428392052650452, 0.21273262798786163, 0.5157360434532166, 0.22055508196353912, 0.18054556846618652, 0.2939644455909729, -0.9387727379798889, -0.37695032358169556, -0.5664315223693848, -0.10298939794301987, 0.7341134548187256, 0.020321447402238846, 0.5522502064704895, -0.4139796793460846, -0.07870126515626907, 0.10531409084796906, 0.030519044026732445, -0.6681162118911743, 0.41150033473968506, 0.4763317406177521, 0.9672187566757202, -0.908901572227478, 0.9509610533714294, 0.3909702003002167, -0.2271563857793808, -0.7346784472465515, 0.30364686250686646, -0.07090359181165695, -1.0498156547546387, 0.7939414978027344, 0.692063570022583, -0.03260457143187523, 0.11462901532649994, -0.6979344487190247, -0.6873486042022705, 1.0614171028137207, 0.13683941960334778, -0.9745519757270813, 0.050408199429512024, 0.5100510716438293, 0.6149802207946777, -0.5317659378051758, 0.3973635733127594, 0.5655056834220886, 0.7085930109024048, 0.04655396193265915, -0.6714820861816406, 0.07443057000637054, -0.23610515892505646, -0.06482966989278793, 0.22383201122283936, -0.5296303629875183, 0.8648882508277893, 0.045109428465366364, -0.19388949871063232, 0.3269360363483429, 0.7722962498664856, 0.14896875619888306, 0.38219910860061646, 0.29021286964416504, 0.560206413269043, 0.7029297947883606, -0.07465985417366028, 0.7141356468200684, -0.336431086063385, 0.3545987010002136, 0.7432325482368469, -0.3383817970752716, 0.6352027654647827, 0.25560835003852844, -0.05402244254946709, 0.6696800589561462, 0.3707972764968872, -0.48524847626686096, 0.3254404067993164, 0.27616509795188904, -0.28461602330207825, -0.17152336239814758, -0.010461507365107536, -0.32628166675567627, 0.6260589957237244, 0.4095016419887543, -0.9469562768936157, -0.09142361581325531, 0.27897465229034424, 0.054698072373867035, 0.1224031150341034, -0.2431388944387436, 0.9444534778594971, 0.0479692704975605, -0.6483637690544128, 0.39516305923461914, 0.3764815628528595, 1.031449317932129, -0.21735236048698425, -0.09666667133569717, -0.13775278627872467, 0.6018954515457153, -0.07055316865444183, -0.7913034558296204, -0.09657970815896988, 0.023026153445243835, -0.2228975147008896, 0.08605867624282837, 1.1654752492904663, -0.3305469751358032, -1.0011565685272217, 0.2711813449859619, 0.49309003353118896, -0.04861114174127579, -0.10745357722043991, -0.7036417722702026, 0.16972140967845917, 0.2995496094226837, -0.28921276330947876, -0.21086962521076202, 0.6368940472602844, 0.19186800718307495, 0.6349895000457764, 0.535449743270874, -0.04532252624630928, -0.040390659123659134, 0.2786579132080078, 0.662020206451416, -0.608601987361908, -0.3987092673778534, -1.31705904006958, 0.37579432129859924, -0.3371697664260864, -0.35677722096443176, 0.6030246019363403, 0.5278220176696777, 0.3573627769947052, -0.10223216563463211, 0.8778801560401917, 0.210876926779747, 0.3236621022224426, -0.5709843635559082, 1.0474426746368408, -0.44556906819343567, 0.30492088198661804, -0.29421547055244446, -0.9847792983055115, -0.6983952522277832, 0.46199676394462585, -0.12021318823099136, 0.18948403000831604, 0.6499245762825012, 0.73863685131073, 0.03767705708742142, -0.01565617322921753, 0.4203750789165497, 0.1657755970954895, 0.5538334250450134, 0.5394076108932495, 0.7471069097518921, -0.74488365650177, 0.5761798620223999, 0.07838943600654602, -0.14732499420642853, -0.35223016142845154, -0.906657338142395, -1.2906925678253174, -0.4865971803665161, -0.2298341989517212, -0.2885998487472534, -0.24480347335338593, 0.5809351205825806, 0.5006758570671082, -0.8166133165359497, 0.07778472453355789, -0.4110410213470459, 0.2410009503364563, 0.18201029300689697, -0.3132854998111725, 0.5400611162185669, -0.11032861471176147, -0.9419564604759216, 0.3890209197998047, 0.11844787746667862, 0.1553156077861786, -0.3014155328273773, -0.12900632619857788, -0.3303523659706116, -0.03767656907439232, 0.5287362933158875, -0.21900343894958496, -0.7390846014022827, -0.1564142405986786, -0.1408795863389969, -0.33640801906585693, 0.2120104432106018, 0.6633524894714355, -0.6440132856369019, 0.010043645277619362, 0.3571206033229828, 0.7710316181182861, 0.3649790287017822, -0.2371765822172165, 0.25773516297340393, -0.7281898260116577, 0.2319498360157013, 0.14801636338233948, 0.4315917193889618, 0.4535158574581146, -0.822465717792511, 0.2889055013656616, 0.09362049400806427, -0.770639955997467, -0.5845497250556946, 0.13577118515968323, -0.6439021229743958, -0.10928230732679367, 1.09292733669281, 0.06339842081069946, -0.369157075881958, 0.17630678415298462, -0.5360908508300781, 0.6213829517364502, -0.526414155960083, 0.7316327095031738, 0.38985002040863037, 0.1993996948003769, -0.45989665389060974, -0.18712760508060455, 0.4213769733905792, 0.09773927927017212, -1.074483871459961, -0.20897242426872253, 0.28127261996269226, 0.09391965717077255, 0.3823331892490387, 0.42039382457733154, 0.28254666924476624, 0.09021400660276413, -0.27064985036849976, 0.3297058641910553, -0.22775445878505707, -0.3487620949745178, -0.3218221366405487, 0.1469072699546814, -0.07539589703083038, -0.061944443732500076 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07234v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07234v1
Goal-guided Generative Prompt Injection Attack on Large Language Models
2024-04-06T06:17:10
2024-04-06T06:17:10
Chong Zhang, Mingyu Jin, Qinkai Yu, Chengzhi Liu, Haochen Xue, Xiaobo Jin
cs.CR
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
Current large language models (LLMs) provide a strong foundation for large-scale user-oriented natural language tasks. A large number of users can easily inject adversarial text or instructions through the user interface, thus causing LLMs model security challenges. Although there is currently a large amount of research on prompt injection attacks, most of these black-box attacks use heuristic strategies. It is unclear how these heuristic strategies relate to the success rate of attacks and thus effectively improve model robustness. To solve this problem, we redefine the goal of the attack: to maximize the KL divergence between the conditional probabilities of the clean text and the adversarial text. Furthermore, we prove that maximizing the KL divergence is equivalent to maximizing the Mahalanobis distance between the embedded representation $x$ and $x'$ of the clean text and the adversarial text when the conditional probability is a Gaussian distribution and gives a quantitative relationship on $x$ and $x'$. Then we designed a simple and effective goal-guided generative prompt injection strategy (G2PIA) to find an injection text that satisfies specific constraints to achieve the optimal attack effect approximately. It is particularly noteworthy that our attack method is a query-free black-box attack method with low computational cost. Experimental results on seven LLM models and four datasets show the effectiveness of our attack method.
[ -0.20315487682819366, -1.1875544786453247, 0.76063472032547, 0.06517791002988815, -0.2910268008708954, 0.06810759007930756, -0.20809336006641388, -0.11343710869550705, -0.2904829680919647, 0.45668551325798035, -0.445030152797699, -0.8245871663093567, -0.7504265308380127, 0.028380950912833214, -0.36366602778434753, 0.7174147963523865, 0.31863364577293396, -0.13135871291160583, -0.06583093106746674, 0.34340253472328186, -0.5733405947685242, -0.418730765581131, -0.6764664053916931, 0.019318515434861183, 0.6073242425918579, 0.09918418526649475, 0.8370474576950073, 0.4340110421180725, 0.4567451775074005, 0.1997048407793045, -0.3852928876876831, -0.01769302971661091, -0.3626701831817627, 0.33792272210121155, -0.09330707788467407, -0.8294280171394348, 0.08345433324575424, -0.3011569380760193, 0.43878084421157837, 0.45643964409828186, -0.18605667352676392, -0.36571675539016724, 0.08212663233280182, 0.3186659812927246, -0.8548339605331421, -0.04560254141688347, -0.5642248392105103, 0.18541771173477173, -0.3415084481239319, -0.22436435520648956, -0.7564899325370789, -0.17353586852550507, -0.06094130128622055, -0.5859155058860779, 0.05935503914952278, 0.016906222328543663, 1.0100725889205933, 0.22734582424163818, -0.524335503578186, -0.500973641872406, -0.45432326197624207, 0.857437252998352, -0.7702891230583191, 0.15605048835277557, 0.2708677351474762, 0.4985068142414093, -0.6731613874435425, -0.35546812415122986, -0.4324018955230713, -0.26975780725479126, -0.06294698268175125, -0.0391962006688118, -0.5331782698631287, 0.30630600452423096, 0.420282781124115, 0.14322836697101593, -0.6051045656204224, 0.3513321280479431, -0.08864782750606537, -0.2790271043777466, 0.4597006142139435, 0.275596559047699, 0.5730942487716675, -0.4792120158672333, -0.6058374643325806, -0.03356432914733887, -0.8612940907478333, -0.004289343021810055, 0.6070441007614136, 0.44417324662208557, -0.17210884392261505, 0.5138646960258484, -0.3526401221752167, 0.7040938138961792, 0.1484738439321518, -0.31007859110832214, -0.1901785433292389, -0.5599204897880554, -0.14732275903224945, -0.11657851189374924, 1.153709888458252, 0.28003641963005066, 0.17913641035556793, -0.06520477682352066, -0.2285309135913849, -0.14162103831768036, 0.2824495732784271, -1.040540099143982, -0.13179104030132294, 0.25037097930908203, -0.1306174099445343, -0.46434134244918823, -0.18862752616405487, -0.9045693874359131, -0.50044184923172, 0.15059399604797363, 0.34779030084609985, -0.5079513192176819, -0.03589824214577675, 0.08934330195188522, -0.2420802265405655, 0.23119112849235535, 0.1847088634967804, -1.0490670204162598, -0.035645365715026855, 0.6633562445640564, 0.907990574836731, -0.07189834117889404, 0.2089773416519165, -0.7721550464630127, 0.36830607056617737, -0.39632663130760193, 0.6821550130844116, -0.5023036003112793, -0.8278675675392151, 0.2906237840652466, -0.2582293748855591, 0.21455949544906616, -0.3402295708656311, 0.5408767461776733, -0.9146468639373779, 0.4132727384567261, -0.36825838685035706, -0.7570393085479736, -0.08026615530252457, 0.38523760437965393, -0.37034717202186584, 0.5056225061416626, -0.061234429478645325, -0.550546407699585, 0.22900617122650146, -0.6257898807525635, -0.51590895652771, 0.20676328241825104, -0.1998174786567688, -0.3537626266479492, 0.151331827044487, 0.3938851058483124, 0.5019278526306152, -0.23983806371688843, 0.17468838393688202, -0.3458736836910248, -0.09398636221885681, 0.2283545285463333, -0.5725352764129639, 1.1697789430618286, 0.16785132884979248, -0.168096661567688, 0.22900867462158203, -0.496385395526886, 0.15781080722808838, 0.34757131338119507, -0.29731860756874084, -0.49248006939888, -0.16499947011470795, -0.2542577087879181, -0.3269517421722412, 0.21436807513237, -0.2426539808511734, 0.5058355331420898, -0.631669819355011, 0.32399657368659973, 0.6758001446723938, 0.5578394532203674, 0.46081268787384033, 0.14957864582538605, 0.6670461893081665, -0.022765036672353745, 0.46270012855529785, -0.3625181019306183, -0.5714700818061829, -0.16210757195949554, -0.7124742865562439, 0.286271333694458, 0.7911579012870789, -0.8628654479980469, 0.4975724220275879, 0.2130032181739807, -0.3748157024383545, -0.2206404209136963, 0.15580780804157257, 0.4392974376678467, 0.5503697991371155, 0.36111435294151306, 0.04831978678703308, -0.05051741003990173, -0.9293470978736877, -0.17845676839351654, -0.24777787923812866, -0.36414971947669983, 0.1288779377937317, 0.33405402302742004, -0.2260095179080963, 0.7129509449005127, -0.8913607001304626, -0.1413518190383911, -0.16518433392047882, -0.01565631479024887, 0.39628225564956665, 0.3271574378013611, 0.6201144456863403, -0.6014077067375183, -0.7086310386657715, -0.0707985907793045, -0.7878109216690063, -0.2590636610984802, -0.32024243474006653, -0.28932732343673706, 0.011216409504413605, 0.4224008023738861, -0.9415323734283447, 0.49463585019111633, 0.29224756360054016, -0.40279555320739746, 0.6699439287185669, -0.15655137598514557, 0.15084713697433472, -1.164819598197937, -0.141946479678154, 0.03192908316850662, -0.10972844064235687, -1.091737985610962, 0.5318700075149536, 0.2232922911643982, -0.019178340211510658, -0.5505349636077881, 0.6144413948059082, -0.4587867558002472, 0.227794349193573, -0.3224599063396454, 0.021193163469433784, 0.14950168132781982, 0.33907049894332886, -0.38153520226478577, 0.8997807502746582, 0.6620456576347351, -0.5534980297088623, 0.2577870786190033, 0.3413681387901306, -0.3977195620536804, 0.8398488759994507, -0.8975399732589722, 0.11443710327148438, 0.008188195526599884, 0.15163515508174896, -1.030519723892212, -0.22990110516548157, 0.7787026166915894, -0.5577355623245239, 0.5577554702758789, -0.22192001342773438, -0.4753602147102356, 0.042462434619665146, -0.35507604479789734, 0.2904545068740845, 0.7605380415916443, -0.591782808303833, 0.41806527972221375, -0.11159206181764603, -0.10095866769552231, -0.8335012197494507, -0.5552501082420349, 0.581839382648468, -0.3659785985946655, -0.6258049011230469, 0.37114718556404114, -0.07026820629835129, -0.24948154389858246, -0.22282670438289642, 0.3916242718696594, 0.11345995217561722, 0.4236959218978882, -0.07292734831571579, 0.2761852741241455, 0.017218470573425293, -0.24962118268013, 0.20159292221069336, -0.16934794187545776, 0.13223984837532043, -0.18140166997909546, 0.5643466114997864, 0.4897494316101074, -0.6093314290046692, -0.8588626980781555, 0.69202721118927, 0.369626522064209, -0.03286287561058998, 0.7950283885002136, 0.49545031785964966, -0.330697625875473, -0.2533314824104309, -0.28141283988952637, -0.16904699802398682, -0.5033578872680664, 0.5395150780677795, -0.48872676491737366, -0.510948896408081, 0.30825233459472656, 0.24937906861305237, 0.05774776265025139, 0.20955407619476318, 0.5054111480712891, -0.01858232542872429, 1.2163456678390503, 0.41323211789131165, 0.02353827841579914, 0.5112060308456421, -0.2722739577293396, 0.166392520070076, -0.7461943626403809, -0.2148335576057434, -0.5484509468078613, 0.12038946151733398, -0.23348674178123474, -0.3130054175853729, 0.35472196340560913, 0.4733920097351074, -0.04936758056282997, 0.1177346482872963, -0.3034226596355438, 0.482854425907135, 0.7258294224739075, 0.024491840973496437, 0.06973498314619064, 0.16904930770397186, -0.2745426595211029, -0.08606160432100296, -0.6035007834434509, -0.3757452964782715, 1.0845927000045776, 0.3315824866294861, 0.6700442433357239, 0.3960815370082855, 0.7524539232254028, 0.45652657747268677, 0.06204301863908768, -0.8500232100486755, 0.6012950539588928, 0.03481738641858101, -0.31729185581207275, -0.14541567862033844, -0.42141449451446533, -1.055813193321228, 0.16996902227401733, 0.03966909274458885, -0.6994181871414185, 0.19775040447711945, 0.1732417643070221, -0.4778362214565277, 0.1864369511604309, -0.8430375456809998, 0.8377071022987366, -0.23435021936893463, -0.2885800898075104, -0.08934208005666733, -0.5136243104934692, 0.3840099573135376, -0.011268987320363522, -0.05527765676379204, 0.08627239614725113, -0.43241503834724426, 0.24487194418907166, -0.3902209997177124, 0.9047434329986572, -0.5179523825645447, -0.3669702708721161, 0.1827222853899002, 0.08804594725370407, 0.8525339365005493, 0.149587944149971, 0.1821390837430954, 0.2902151644229889, -0.3255658447742462, -0.6830782294273376, -0.7388213872909546, 0.333415150642395, -0.46585339307785034, -1.1968128681182861, -0.2538371980190277, -0.4717208445072174, -0.08362860232591629, 0.22997212409973145, 0.25547000765800476, 0.3816829025745392, -0.24967095255851746, 0.011065902188420296, 0.8761581182479858, -0.643253743648529, 0.43533217906951904, 0.2828233242034912, -0.042194217443466187, -0.6975323557853699, 0.8001959323883057, -0.24310302734375, 0.8829799294471741, 0.5164709091186523, 0.19974584877490997, -0.48171430826187134, -0.8995864391326904, -0.7398142218589783, 0.09385523945093155, -0.7301346063613892, -0.32607388496398926, -0.45027410984039307, 0.06071219965815544, -0.37167078256607056, -0.23774632811546326, 0.11214091628789902, 0.02510235831141472, -0.5340291261672974, 0.14847144484519958, 0.1854802519083023, 0.3939051032066345, 0.11104071885347366, 0.6692377924919128, -0.5494073629379272, 0.309099942445755, 0.2893463373184204, -0.12403320521116257, -0.1088850200176239, -0.5141071081161499, 0.06717881560325623, 0.025890231132507324, -0.3385968506336212, -1.3809714317321777, 0.399208128452301, -0.03222221881151199, 0.477399080991745, 0.8647695183753967, 0.0447256825864315, 0.3186483085155487, -0.5341503620147705, 0.807866632938385, 0.3839389979839325, -0.6528919339179993, 0.6047859191894531, -0.5008149147033691, 0.6995885968208313, 0.24657393991947174, 0.3552018404006958, -0.5601746439933777, -0.49012061953544617, -0.2911379039287567, -0.6123883724212646, 0.3054811954498291, 0.19394487142562866, 0.25366610288619995, -0.2022266983985901, 0.4080289900302887, -0.05789128690958023, 0.1652311235666275, -0.3466257154941559, -0.29462796449661255, 0.10402669757604599, -0.2933376133441925, 0.15513943135738373, -0.48033884167671204, -0.2186882048845291, 0.3168441355228424, 0.6309201121330261, -0.20790055394172668, 0.3344497084617615, 0.02609221637248993, -0.021039655432105064, 0.3182557225227356, 0.4567923843860626, 0.6411944031715393, 0.1894965022802353, 0.17220579087734222, 0.07467374950647354, 0.0947268009185791, -0.38203179836273193, 0.2973625361919403, 0.3291931450366974, -0.818695068359375, -0.06456384807825089, 0.4052797257900238, 0.6707366704940796, 0.04580320790410042, -0.6197450160980225, 0.5704182386398315, -0.1388811618089676, -0.00900450348854065, -0.018193231895565987, 0.19293351471424103, 0.09650672972202301, 0.4032604694366455, 0.4656590223312378, -0.1289757937192917, 0.10332190245389938, -0.2565029561519623, 0.07031526416540146, 0.9598628878593445, -0.3031224012374878, -0.14109620451927185, 0.6218392848968506, -0.006398516241461039, -0.5270319581031799, 0.4680595099925995, -0.35471588373184204, -0.6642948389053345, 0.5744673609733582, 0.4674791991710663, 0.923615574836731, -0.4363628327846527, 0.263244092464447, 0.3791961669921875, 0.316611111164093, 0.15722501277923584, 0.06764215230941772, 0.003075650427490473, -0.3310352563858032, -0.35650163888931274, -0.40205565094947815, -0.24645432829856873, -0.011188999749720097, -0.4074259102344513, 0.2577919661998749, -0.5893674492835999, -0.07268044352531433, -0.09572099149227142, -0.1373257040977478, -0.3347337245941162, -0.08035381138324738, 0.002689284272491932, 0.8258700370788574, -0.43069207668304443, 0.39390599727630615, 0.09647666662931442, -0.4084433913230896, -0.3171033263206482, 0.05760917812585831, 0.08772089332342148, -0.8874247074127197, 0.6353122591972351, 0.12079089134931564, 0.2694469392299652, -0.20084385573863983, -0.4802616238594055, -0.6953970789909363, 0.7305267453193665, 0.40542978048324585, -0.7385707497596741, -0.055030446499586105, 0.2308352142572403, 0.2844966650009155, -0.005230959039181471, 0.0057101864367723465, 0.3294215798377991, 0.3683386445045471, 0.012487783096730709, -0.3683701157569885, 0.2355598509311676, 0.04056399688124657, 0.06704924255609512, 0.4531065821647644, -0.39105868339538574, 0.5017365217208862, -0.5179210305213928, -0.5766515731811523, 0.2954186201095581, 0.9030556678771973, 0.14644019305706024, 0.0005823689280077815, 0.5636439919471741, 0.6375419497489929, 0.837833821773529, 0.021590039134025574, 1.3304256200790405, -0.17433473467826843, 0.09169334173202515, 0.7829428911209106, -0.02189052291214466, 0.7225996255874634, 0.5055783987045288, -0.2447974681854248, 0.2607266902923584, 0.48527517914772034, -0.16159968078136444, 0.787561297416687, 0.33409902453422546, -0.6279703974723816, -0.09683898836374283, -0.2065240442752838, -0.3666467070579529, -0.012836647219955921, 0.3830282986164093, -0.22804482281208038, -0.12943905591964722, 0.16587713360786438, 0.47744613885879517, 0.08231697231531143, -0.05734606087207794, 0.8096938133239746, -0.06798351556062698, -0.6146613955497742, 0.7265552878379822, 0.1733255684375763, 0.6311332583427429, -0.7743654251098633, 0.11228047311306, -0.3100360929965973, 0.11093758791685104, 0.05325951799750328, -0.6308898329734802, -0.08850930631160736, 0.09834248572587967, -0.16815930604934692, 0.07717958092689514, 0.6069074869155884, -0.4495244324207306, -0.3192201256752014, -0.007098616100847721, 0.24095849692821503, -0.12262759357690811, -0.05422653630375862, -0.720316469669342, 0.0519692562520504, 0.08153828978538513, -0.30637019872665405, 0.3322230577468872, 0.15389470756053925, 0.13580289483070374, 0.7401105165481567, 0.7529769539833069, 0.13913533091545105, -0.0027086827903985977, 0.11255131661891937, 0.5907711982727051, -0.43986275792121887, -0.5886691808700562, -1.2019447088241577, 0.3928343653678894, -0.3022497594356537, -0.11272794753313065, 0.8727377653121948, 0.2601757347583771, 0.428371787071228, 0.12045788764953613, 0.8834615349769592, 0.1381499320268631, 0.08224662393331528, -0.6774829030036926, 0.5664133429527283, -0.3853221535682678, 0.34229913353919983, -0.12052547186613083, -0.614683210849762, -0.4185805916786194, 0.2346295714378357, -0.30709946155548096, -0.032012809067964554, 0.5778248310089111, 1.1065354347229004, 0.18530528247356415, -0.18917495012283325, 0.402397096157074, 0.20656056702136993, 0.869278073310852, 0.8091949224472046, 0.9928267002105713, -0.34573599696159363, 0.6966478824615479, -0.14751450717449188, -0.41245943307876587, -0.18248218297958374, -0.9038376212120056, -1.253492832183838, -0.15606041252613068, -0.37201210856437683, -0.37065908312797546, 0.4407212734222412, 0.6168258190155029, 0.5272492170333862, -0.7087889909744263, 0.12609058618545532, -0.04350816458463669, 0.23483704030513763, 0.04492897540330887, -0.2754972279071808, 0.4702831506729126, -0.5642315745353699, -0.794208824634552, 0.5320343971252441, 0.2148887664079666, 0.24586398899555206, -0.6597135663032532, -0.10767380148172379, -0.19442138075828552, 0.21013373136520386, 0.4087781310081482, 0.26651597023010254, -0.8910534381866455, -0.3342253267765045, 0.09950736910104752, -0.2790960371494293, -0.11941400170326233, 0.43831220269203186, -0.44598448276519775, 0.45722129940986633, 0.3799140155315399, 0.9901076555252075, -0.002230198122560978, -0.048097267746925354, 0.6555706262588501, -0.8393462896347046, 0.013464373536407948, 0.04062153771519661, 0.2600538432598114, 0.35177847743034363, -0.6404018998146057, 0.17626772820949554, 0.28223899006843567, -0.3178384006023407, -1.0053229331970215, 0.496125191450119, -0.7996759414672852, -0.5121438503265381, 1.3959766626358032, -0.20936468243598938, -0.30589061975479126, -0.0146143464371562, -0.42094147205352783, 0.028997335582971573, -0.6015990376472473, 0.7004767060279846, 0.5448005795478821, 0.2097112536430359, -0.013344691134989262, -0.7028319835662842, 0.493377149105072, 0.5105475783348083, -0.9334551692008972, 0.027442654594779015, 0.5987102389335632, 0.07716698199510574, 0.15101367235183716, 0.1598532348871231, 0.05109445005655289, 0.4182986915111542, 0.04490603506565094, -0.17827433347702026, -0.15459299087524414, -0.25655075907707214, -0.37410396337509155, 0.6758757829666138, -0.047969751060009, -0.3229038715362549 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04516v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04516v1
Language Models as Critical Thinking Tools: A Case Study of Philosophers
2024-04-06T06:12:13
2024-04-06T06:12:13
Andre Ye, Jared Moore, Rose Novick, Amy X. Zhang
cs.HC
cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.CY
Current work in language models (LMs) helps us speed up or even skip thinking by accelerating and automating cognitive work. But can LMs help us with critical thinking -- thinking in deeper, more reflective ways which challenge assumptions, clarify ideas, and engineer new concepts? We treat philosophy as a case study in critical thinking, and interview 21 professional philosophers about how they engage in critical thinking and on their experiences with LMs. We find that philosophers do not find LMs to be useful because they lack a sense of selfhood (memory, beliefs, consistency) and initiative (curiosity, proactivity). We propose the selfhood-initiative model for critical thinking tools to characterize this gap. Using the model, we formulate three roles LMs could play as critical thinking tools: the Interlocutor, the Monitor, and the Respondent. We hope that our work inspires LM researchers to further develop LMs as critical thinking tools and philosophers and other 'critical thinkers' to imagine intellectually substantive uses of LMs.
[ -0.5137279033660889, -0.7040904760360718, 0.8033100366592407, -0.14637130498886108, -0.12773029506206512, 0.25629568099975586, -0.0584721565246582, -0.2730696499347687, 0.15253257751464844, 0.6610526442527771, -0.4657672643661499, 0.0642746165394783, -0.5164233446121216, -0.07444415241479874, -0.5495912432670593, 0.5864161252975464, -0.05382613092660904, 0.0973537266254425, 0.2887454628944397, -0.12636302411556244, -0.3303714394569397, -0.33069583773612976, -0.5655516386032104, -0.465471088886261, 0.35401687026023865, 0.4623740613460541, 0.7700334191322327, 0.2763797342777252, 0.5689350962638855, 0.3277207911014557, 0.16239763796329498, -0.3035351634025574, -0.30510035157203674, 0.3039083480834961, -0.4595785140991211, -0.38462182879447937, -0.3359585106372833, 0.38327303528785706, 0.5822373628616333, 0.8150798082351685, -0.3339458107948303, 0.4527110457420349, -0.04755273461341858, 0.7201058864593506, -0.43565261363983154, 0.03037409298121929, -0.652068555355072, 0.35933905839920044, 0.0037225272972136736, 0.19862328469753265, -0.3041270971298218, -0.6261244416236877, 0.315988689661026, -0.23701061308383942, 0.15368589758872986, -0.12874862551689148, 0.32075774669647217, 0.21993599832057953, -0.09304898232221603, -0.2844785451889038, -1.0353573560714722, 0.5542321801185608, -1.0154649019241333, 0.31606948375701904, 0.014793861657381058, 0.11379700899124146, -0.06429503113031387, -0.42338645458221436, -0.6446585059165955, -0.15703822672367096, 0.22422458231449127, 0.023619169369339943, 0.11225289106369019, 0.08513905853033066, 0.3304360508918762, 0.6430887579917908, -0.3362291753292084, -0.23697583377361298, -0.6248142123222351, -0.18870022892951965, 0.5350632667541504, 0.3858158588409424, 0.25906455516815186, 0.047980524599552155, -0.2059718370437622, -0.023826628923416138, -0.4975588023662567, 0.15217702090740204, 0.2729097306728363, 0.2035626471042633, 0.5252010822296143, 0.2910712659358978, -0.09603387862443924, 0.5537149906158447, -0.45062416791915894, -0.05023219808936119, -0.11918150633573532, -0.16688577830791473, -0.20576173067092896, -0.14283207058906555, 0.8481799960136414, 0.35410088300704956, 0.5977749228477478, 0.1304217427968979, -0.14981858432292938, 0.13181418180465698, 0.4074648916721344, -0.7014435529708862, -0.5211604833602905, 0.05012024566531181, -0.39091455936431885, -0.20167624950408936, -0.22377601265907288, -0.6428501605987549, -0.44656631350517273, 0.07408855110406876, 0.5512481927871704, -0.2518636882305145, -0.7336476445198059, 0.4517788589000702, -0.13121439516544342, 0.048447929322719574, 0.30863386392593384, -0.6566939353942871, 0.6095030307769775, 0.38859450817108154, 0.6116476655006409, 0.17505420744419098, -0.2363223284482956, 0.12164083868265152, -0.005116963293403387, -0.7065663933753967, 0.6313632726669312, -0.6047280430793762, -0.7109558582305908, 0.1762033998966217, -0.21389850974082947, 0.09005852788686752, -0.4877467155456543, 0.6671360731124878, -0.13430702686309814, 0.4474335014820099, -0.5885807871818542, -0.7294977903366089, -0.4154532551765442, 0.2990208864212036, -0.6495535969734192, 1.1601307392120361, -0.12668366730213165, -0.34525150060653687, 0.16095374524593353, -0.6254309415817261, -0.11769398301839828, 0.42127856612205505, -0.5055850148200989, -0.1189529299736023, 0.18922999501228333, -0.24743762612342834, 0.6896259784698486, -0.5605965256690979, 0.17614291608333588, -0.4642883837223053, -0.10644716024398804, 0.6681417226791382, -0.09085635840892792, 0.6324171423912048, 0.04687638580799103, -0.3208780586719513, -0.09785919636487961, -0.3558412790298462, 0.3826133608818054, 0.37256962060928345, -0.19293247163295746, -0.3012906014919281, 0.3545716404914856, -0.24473853409290314, 0.3420485854148865, -0.006375742144882679, -0.6327166557312012, 0.2478424608707428, -0.4411129951477051, 0.5960605144500732, 0.7526638507843018, -0.11137314885854721, 0.31881019473075867, -0.18285492062568665, 0.5462328791618347, -0.39994221925735474, 0.3822563886642456, -0.10021992027759552, -0.568011462688446, -1.1073027849197388, 0.19901348650455475, -0.09021443128585815, 0.6090244650840759, -0.3095785081386566, -0.10804831236600876, 0.17773129045963287, -0.7944335341453552, -0.6216768026351929, 0.47546687722206116, 0.6233798861503601, 0.6679768562316895, 0.12428479641675949, -0.6228461265563965, -0.15036387741565704, -0.911674439907074, -0.6716553568840027, -0.4162421226501465, 0.3825371563434601, 0.32613861560821533, 0.5520625710487366, 0.22636687755584717, 0.6347255706787109, -0.7334207892417908, -0.1606501191854477, -0.44360285997390747, 0.06831183284521103, 0.22508127987384796, 0.22192706167697906, 0.31188517808914185, -0.3905210494995117, -0.2164071947336197, -0.5539979338645935, -0.6716274619102478, -0.032569121569395065, 0.13315574824810028, 0.062321003526449203, -0.3983684182167053, 0.6425037980079651, -0.5230710506439209, 0.23415976762771606, 0.1888677179813385, -0.2553505003452301, 0.48418065905570984, -0.12518925964832306, -0.2032468169927597, -0.8508136868476868, -0.12726792693138123, -0.051627930253744125, -0.014423863962292671, -0.8594493269920349, 0.1315954327583313, -0.091729536652565, -0.3435559570789337, -0.33017709851264954, 0.5229570269584656, -0.5597630739212036, 0.031258102506399155, -0.3047099709510803, 0.3872497081756592, 0.0059850215911865234, 0.05143072456121445, -0.026300664991140366, 0.6602888703346252, 0.416043758392334, -0.654056191444397, 0.0037714396603405476, -0.13317154347896576, -0.6996774077415466, 0.1872718781232834, -0.42982006072998047, 0.39244288206100464, 0.0322054885327816, -0.037056777626276016, -0.7998486161231995, 0.04726230725646019, 0.49660053849220276, -0.10068374127149582, 0.026933753862977028, 0.11027991026639938, -0.4091498851776123, -0.5607611536979675, -0.25973448157310486, 0.3858194053173065, 0.41821449995040894, 0.14936015009880066, 0.5752913355827332, 0.7173017859458923, -0.3690846562385559, -0.48159661889076233, -0.5955597758293152, -0.011950521729886532, -0.15070249140262604, -0.19461564719676971, -0.1496790051460266, -0.40256109833717346, -0.5829548239707947, 0.08556421101093292, 0.030516335740685463, -0.33456191420555115, 0.393597811460495, 0.1948098987340927, 0.2549814283847809, -0.21137087047100067, 0.3190574049949646, -0.21486243605613708, -0.02597401849925518, 0.42861267924308777, -0.1170867308974266, 0.406192809343338, -0.5369833707809448, -0.44191211462020874, -0.2958310544490814, 0.4245995581150055, 0.4890343248844147, -0.3329455852508545, 0.3001070022583008, 0.24281045794487, -0.3606138229370117, -0.23653747141361237, -0.9749336838722229, -0.3434804081916809, -0.46792295575141907, 0.2346803992986679, -0.26406463980674744, -0.9869357347488403, 0.3165878653526306, -0.33598047494888306, 0.06463730335235596, 0.2791917324066162, 0.6715284585952759, -0.24658945202827454, 0.6094462871551514, 0.8192747831344604, -0.04010346531867981, 0.3865630626678467, -0.4471399486064911, 0.701272189617157, -0.9497441649436951, 0.02731308713555336, -0.18123626708984375, -0.22007620334625244, -0.04545942693948746, -0.5461822748184204, 0.2854920029640198, -0.0381786935031414, -0.03409721329808235, 0.15357203781604767, -0.6325077414512634, 0.5681399703025818, 0.2855530083179474, -0.13373519480228424, 0.12258688360452652, -0.6433709263801575, -0.07058226317167282, -0.14328165352344513, -0.6331490874290466, -0.8557255268096924, 0.9465005397796631, 0.46732690930366516, 0.8875787854194641, 0.05733892694115639, 0.47760868072509766, 0.26185142993927, 0.2790522575378418, -0.9131367206573486, 1.0829628705978394, 0.28686293959617615, -1.078599214553833, -0.46061113476753235, 0.1596566140651703, -0.4717734754085541, 0.3083018362522125, 0.12204472720623016, -0.6712729334831238, 0.1967732459306717, 0.3078620433807373, -0.6897589564323425, 0.48830726742744446, -0.509306788444519, 0.8699356913566589, -0.060315266251564026, -0.11189542710781097, -0.6413031220436096, -0.5511636734008789, 0.40899890661239624, 0.1552276760339737, 0.42658254504203796, -0.5832159519195557, 0.08417175710201263, 0.8436391353607178, -0.08259811997413635, 0.9953571557998657, -0.007611631881445646, -0.16543090343475342, 0.76936936378479, 0.8159933686256409, -0.05450865626335144, -0.01809023693203926, -0.0034797724802047014, -0.07519875466823578, 0.08428321778774261, -0.12551850080490112, -0.46095791459083557, 0.45827561616897583, -0.5166265368461609, -1.0253121852874756, -0.5838451981544495, -0.5493561029434204, -0.14480547606945038, 0.30037587881088257, -0.052902694791555405, 0.3643786311149597, -0.5552432537078857, -0.07496007531881332, 0.8592713475227356, 0.4795646667480469, 0.7431941628456116, 0.8205413222312927, -0.49309366941452026, -0.12726490199565887, 0.6289058327674866, 0.5266833901405334, 0.5311101078987122, 0.0473252534866333, 0.33192285895347595, -0.00957178883254528, -0.35067299008369446, -0.38472893834114075, 0.2426859736442566, -1.0028250217437744, 0.1800379604101181, -0.5760615468025208, -0.28568780422210693, -0.13537658751010895, 0.019060496240854263, -0.640458345413208, -0.5738429427146912, -0.06519395858049393, -0.06791435182094574, 0.0654619038105011, 0.9409005641937256, -0.030179325491189957, 0.103731669485569, -0.5777772665023804, -0.10866055637598038, 0.7086223363876343, 0.18514668941497803, 0.08396214246749878, -0.27381882071495056, -0.16673050820827484, -0.47643280029296875, -0.3627301752567291, -1.1109087467193604, 0.08029550313949585, 0.1076429933309555, 0.5059402585029602, 0.5385987758636475, -0.11787574738264084, 0.30534252524375916, -0.8260640501976013, 0.8626536726951599, -0.06645048409700394, -1.0598118305206299, 0.5694929361343384, -0.17518632113933563, 0.16677148640155792, 0.460378497838974, 0.39528557658195496, -0.6614900231361389, -0.5609649419784546, -0.44662344455718994, -0.32465097308158875, 0.28237485885620117, -0.019299767911434174, 0.40328115224838257, -0.01592967100441456, 0.5857168436050415, 0.2073023021221161, 0.3050679862499237, -0.9400551915168762, 0.019186630845069885, -0.04943813756108284, 0.12911023199558258, -0.3030465245246887, -0.516914427280426, -0.5120224356651306, -0.2188061624765396, 0.5635659694671631, -0.15103259682655334, -0.08922789245843887, 0.6189379692077637, 0.05007253214716911, -0.1761324256658554, 0.5570908784866333, 0.3881787061691284, 0.7681287527084351, 0.05521675944328308, 0.20426981151103973, 0.336896151304245, -0.2786499261856079, 0.17626038193702698, -0.39723703265190125, -0.04247269406914711, -0.17415998876094818, 0.1003158763051033, 0.29629701375961304, 0.16827580332756042, -0.7564321756362915, 0.40052932500839233, -0.18252640962600708, 0.04510101303458214, -0.5581569075584412, 0.32701706886291504, 0.28434425592422485, 0.5247781872749329, 0.10572561621665955, -0.023181311786174774, 0.5056328773498535, -1.0600112676620483, -0.22530896961688995, 0.5664249062538147, -0.5750759840011597, -0.4722135066986084, 0.4126300513744354, 0.26205143332481384, -0.7253898978233337, 0.1701865792274475, -0.032713018357753754, -0.789638102054596, 0.21302057802677155, 0.3843379318714142, 1.0812901258468628, -0.679413914680481, 0.4242485463619232, -0.1291922926902771, 0.673969566822052, -0.21729761362075806, 0.5935044884681702, -0.11272105574607849, -1.0456362962722778, -0.29448720812797546, -0.28546711802482605, -0.8090362548828125, 0.18390876054763794, -0.4783472716808319, -0.04508274048566818, -0.8468267917633057, -0.471250981092453, -0.15765102207660675, 0.046061862260103226, -0.46439215540885925, 0.24467788636684418, 0.2354980856180191, 0.9189748167991638, -0.9781750440597534, 0.7504612803459167, 0.49926307797431946, -0.29534533619880676, -0.8373314738273621, -0.006703251972794533, 0.008559455163776875, -0.5980010628700256, 0.5260254144668579, 0.16474099457263947, -0.703108012676239, -0.21002335846424103, -0.35400140285491943, -0.8438028693199158, 0.6958339810371399, 0.4608789086341858, -0.559119462966919, 0.04259977862238884, -0.023771855980157852, 0.4511486291885376, -0.4461584985256195, 0.21145659685134888, 0.33210083842277527, 0.0715719684958458, -0.42670562863349915, -1.0958555936813354, 0.07854101806879044, -0.3337366580963135, -0.07514839619398117, 0.3504452705383301, -1.030782699584961, 1.1894359588623047, -0.3137851059436798, -0.0046850452199578285, 0.039785806089639664, 0.3816172480583191, -0.23864489793777466, 0.22545917332172394, 0.37219828367233276, 0.5348290801048279, 0.6271450519561768, 0.23634058237075806, 0.7751038670539856, -0.4368327558040619, 0.3273400366306305, 0.9705832004547119, -0.46260201930999756, 0.9064574241638184, 0.38070037961006165, 0.06975459307432175, 0.7228497266769409, 0.3054784834384918, 0.2860760986804962, 0.31735146045684814, 0.07051421701908112, -0.3699117600917816, -0.6204913258552551, -0.0607815720140934, -0.49673590064048767, 0.3159240782260895, 0.6036578416824341, -0.36968669295310974, 0.025761069729924202, -0.10760355740785599, 0.23162752389907837, 0.3741774559020996, -0.29067859053611755, 0.4433091878890991, 0.4257291555404663, -0.5288838744163513, -0.017700042575597763, -0.20569314062595367, -0.19133050739765167, -0.25200438499450684, 0.06429547816514969, 0.04494081810116768, 0.41045793890953064, 0.25433453917503357, -1.2642617225646973, 0.060155704617500305, -0.31415119767189026, -0.13156823813915253, -0.43042153120040894, 0.8915694952011108, 0.07956531643867493, -0.65459144115448, 0.4379172921180725, 0.8562661409378052, 0.3206627368927002, 0.1463458091020584, -0.8948261141777039, 0.19567100703716278, -0.22269143164157867, -0.2723057270050049, 0.046315282583236694, 0.35284188389778137, 0.13296668231487274, 1.138208031654358, 0.2536148428916931, 0.16420488059520721, 0.10678983479738235, 0.16042199730873108, 0.9328226447105408, -0.8258682489395142, -0.11839163303375244, -1.0299166440963745, 0.28537091612815857, -0.19140522181987762, -0.5150346159934998, 0.6519321799278259, 0.50812166929245, 0.87864750623703, -0.047282420098781586, 0.6924038529396057, 0.13579893112182617, 0.7432395219802856, -0.3444468677043915, 0.6538293361663818, -0.25587356090545654, 0.012861724011600018, -0.4160286784172058, -0.8020125031471252, 0.027457410469651222, 0.7438437342643738, -0.551865816116333, -0.1683245152235031, 0.630660891532898, 0.5230612754821777, 0.185729518532753, 0.16079625487327576, 0.319437175989151, 0.3233449459075928, 0.3076757490634918, 0.44456246495246887, 1.0821905136108398, -0.33037787675857544, 0.27101361751556396, -0.2980649769306183, -0.10342919826507568, -0.034143395721912384, -0.7142356038093567, -1.2266896963119507, -0.7188257575035095, -0.24702094495296478, -0.13153159618377686, -0.07059671729803085, 0.8216304779052734, 0.5170570015907288, -0.35236847400665283, -0.7540917992591858, -0.034050215035676956, 0.10521167516708374, 0.16566544771194458, -0.2111208289861679, -0.23857802152633667, -0.22080132365226746, -0.4075199365615845, 0.5277377963066101, 0.6855926513671875, -0.13146261870861053, -0.9791232347488403, 0.25482097268104553, -0.17702923715114594, 0.6810789108276367, 0.34977617859840393, 0.38617002964019775, -1.1271394491195679, -0.46404194831848145, 0.07698097079992294, 0.14048902690410614, 0.0002756424655672163, 1.0398975610733032, -0.7633468508720398, 0.7951753735542297, 0.26191428303718567, 0.23653544485569, 0.19849461317062378, -0.43392467498779297, 0.5071136951446533, 0.1291978508234024, 0.22246170043945312, 0.7708492279052734, 0.4491255283355713, 0.3233078718185425, -0.09761326760053635, 0.45563361048698425, 0.20087434351444244, -0.6996642351150513, -1.0699599981307983, 0.6303458213806152, -0.4750749170780182, -0.2508987486362457, 0.6138936281204224, 0.0029912753961980343, -0.13156455755233765, 0.06239061802625656, -0.2740081548690796, -0.023558061569929123, -0.18977929651737213, 0.9417165517807007, 1.0824077129364014, -0.2756633162498474, -0.4096255898475647, -0.9151240587234497, 0.5715617537498474, 0.7503492832183838, -0.3941357135772705, -0.006177450530230999, -0.020017147064208984, 0.4733932316303253, 0.4030059278011322, 1.0784976482391357, 0.030982548370957375, 0.07337022572755814, -0.09244026243686676, 0.22232607007026672, 0.5459772348403931, -0.42712682485580444, -0.008999199606478214, 0.12441927939653397, 0.43320804834365845, 0.21173341572284698 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04514v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04514v1
Joint Visual and Text Prompting for Improved Object-Centric Perception with Multimodal Large Language Models
2024-04-06T05:59:02
2024-04-06T05:59:02
Songtao Jiang, Yan Zhang, Chenyi Zhou, Yeying Jin, Yang Feng, Jian Wu, Zuozhu Liu
cs.CL
cs.CL
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) such as GPT-4V and Gemini Pro face challenges in achieving human-level perception in Visual Question Answering (VQA), particularly in object-oriented perception tasks which demand fine-grained understanding of object identities, locations or attributes, as indicated by empirical findings. This is mainly due to their limited capability to effectively integrate complex visual cues with textual information and potential object hallucinations. In this paper, we present a novel approach, Joint Visual and Text Prompting (VTPrompt), that employs fine-grained visual information to enhance the capability of MLLMs in VQA, especially for object-oriented perception. VTPrompt merges visual and text prompts to extract key concepts from textual questions and employs a detection model to highlight relevant objects as visual prompts in images. The processed images alongside text prompts are subsequently fed into MLLMs to produce more accurate answers. Our experiments with GPT-4V and Gemini Pro, on three benchmarks, i.e., MME , MMB and POPE, demonstrate significant improvements. Particularly, our method led to a score improvement of up to 183.5 for GPT-4V on MME and enhanced MMB performance by 8.17\% for GPT-4V and 15.69\% for Gemini Pro.
[ -0.7046814560890198, -1.1924575567245483, 0.9697663187980652, 0.1540454775094986, -0.42694446444511414, -0.19563233852386475, -0.3687151074409485, -0.44364720582962036, -0.2527599036693573, 0.4336748719215393, -0.6615355610847473, -0.6503762006759644, -0.28458210825920105, 0.334762841463089, -0.10096684098243713, 0.677412748336792, 0.0076240599155426025, 0.10873956978321075, -0.5940161347389221, -0.04701206088066101, -1.0527143478393555, -0.37298738956451416, -0.5152220129966736, 0.08854600042104721, 0.7299544811248779, 0.47640183568000793, 0.49465620517730713, 0.15985645353794098, 0.4769585132598877, 0.34650927782058716, 0.08216232061386108, 0.4075562357902527, 0.12960277497768402, 0.3123205006122589, -0.27902039885520935, -0.3527597486972809, -0.23440487682819366, -0.4137408435344696, 0.25486329197883606, 0.2512225806713104, 0.05225738137960434, 0.17640963196754456, 0.08489479124546051, 0.5264822840690613, -0.7816777229309082, 0.286896675825119, -0.405489444732666, 0.01628539152443409, 0.08672764152288437, -0.5215721130371094, -0.51305091381073, 0.16470195353031158, 0.2718348801136017, -0.8132023811340332, 0.2802634835243225, 0.04289814457297325, 0.6113061904907227, 0.2704046964645386, -0.19897675514221191, -0.1382112056016922, -0.4189114272594452, 0.7980495095252991, -0.2581785023212433, 0.5015122294425964, 0.2367497682571411, 0.3393464982509613, 0.13818000257015228, -0.6295073628425598, -0.7924475073814392, -0.36602339148521423, 0.020503384992480278, 0.490569144487381, -0.11153276264667511, 0.042922575026750565, 0.33248886466026306, -0.071771040558815, -0.7142101526260376, -0.06020233780145645, -0.20890159904956818, -0.33165982365608215, 0.11212972551584244, 0.13334257900714874, 0.26050248742103577, -0.3697713613510132, -0.5557146072387695, -0.4414905905723572, -0.306659072637558, 0.34019604325294495, 0.02348298765718937, 0.23972433805465698, 0.054382503032684326, 0.7179803252220154, -0.3030816316604614, 0.985492467880249, -0.02462616376578808, -0.041199199855327606, 0.2705616354942322, -0.5296238660812378, -0.2419833242893219, -0.23995065689086914, 0.8100910782814026, 0.8947404623031616, 0.41227585077285767, 0.1821487694978714, -0.07907451689243317, 0.1208399310708046, 0.24396197497844696, -0.662620484828949, -0.1334913671016693, 0.3057990074157715, -0.5559418201446533, -0.05889689549803734, 0.18371863663196564, -0.9635186195373535, -0.4702833592891693, -0.5235980749130249, 0.7951008081436157, -0.4247780740261078, -0.1038103997707367, 0.1685832142829895, -0.4563446044921875, 0.2871072292327881, 0.9407520890235901, -0.9785979390144348, -0.2169836163520813, 0.4290500283241272, 0.5328829884529114, -0.04791656509041786, -0.27522459626197815, -0.8953007459640503, 0.20840394496917725, 0.07252883911132812, 1.0026354789733887, -0.6928683519363403, -0.4358746409416199, -0.09476372599601746, -0.04963080585002899, -0.0031970778945833445, -0.5588104724884033, 0.41912317276000977, -0.15291672945022583, 0.548324465751648, -0.5847620964050293, 0.02313828654587269, -0.1785343736410141, 0.8477199077606201, -0.44558173418045044, 0.9957155585289001, -0.0325683057308197, -0.9317517280578613, 0.3539017140865326, -0.5423088073730469, -0.04143716022372246, 0.07176615297794342, -0.47960591316223145, -0.2122984230518341, -0.061151210218667984, 1.0962998867034912, 0.7466657757759094, -0.2191045582294464, 0.026772141456604004, -0.28083187341690063, -0.35409802198410034, 0.37971922755241394, -0.9098113179206848, 0.04675857350230217, -0.049918897449970245, -0.23649075627326965, 0.5056830048561096, -0.5320876240730286, 0.05696885660290718, -0.03815958648920059, -0.07517704367637634, -0.29329898953437805, -0.17392674088478088, 0.12997795641422272, 0.23648931086063385, 0.4225389063358307, -0.3247202932834625, 0.3810892403125763, -0.019315876066684723, 0.19993910193443298, 0.7050075531005859, 0.0173894502222538, 0.23695750534534454, -0.019512394443154335, 0.42650535702705383, 0.39907413721084595, 0.5820081233978271, -0.536482572555542, -0.8150640726089478, -0.6260488629341125, -0.19229398667812347, -0.11614697426557541, 0.7400550842285156, -1.4754931926727295, -0.10098779946565628, 0.05289161950349808, -0.09170602262020111, -0.3971753716468811, -0.0030138820875436068, 0.4124003052711487, 0.7634072303771973, 0.7186596393585205, -0.08528271317481995, -0.27060139179229736, -0.737352728843689, -0.09800413995981216, -0.46380186080932617, -0.3328520953655243, 0.43124598264694214, 0.3761812448501587, 0.010058416984975338, 0.7162876725196838, -0.5369820594787598, -0.22476541996002197, -0.1973089873790741, 0.22104915976524353, 0.036050885915756226, 0.11379505693912506, 0.4272410273551941, -1.1687997579574585, -0.5182961821556091, 0.1556725800037384, -0.6210872530937195, 0.018967248499393463, 0.00886921864002943, 0.09273115545511246, 0.2069324254989624, 0.5626296401023865, -0.5232073068618774, 0.3264215886592865, 0.34711918234825134, -0.5525256991386414, 0.7818351984024048, -0.3633972406387329, 0.5094321370124817, -1.1162432432174683, -0.051714926958084106, 0.13612544536590576, -0.18479397892951965, -0.5432431697845459, -0.09592647105455399, 0.10260602831840515, 0.08475273847579956, -0.6514247059822083, 0.6940252184867859, -0.38308435678482056, 0.08572005480527878, -0.09778837859630585, 0.41889503598213196, 0.2050909698009491, 0.4758356213569641, 0.13212880492210388, 1.0000373125076294, 0.7833067774772644, -0.47039595246315, 0.46164247393608093, 0.21530504524707794, -0.07188867032527924, 1.0001574754714966, -0.6765472888946533, -0.07755664736032486, -0.5454350113868713, -0.06704305112361908, -0.9696996212005615, -0.31797316670417786, 0.3668833076953888, -0.4491463601589203, 0.06187976524233818, 0.08297781646251678, -0.4495994448661804, -0.501908540725708, -0.4434266686439514, 0.32239142060279846, 0.35453522205352783, -0.5770276784896851, 0.7462762594223022, -0.272095263004303, -0.2741771638393402, -0.8970901370048523, -0.514404833316803, 0.054488420486450195, -0.04019143059849739, -0.5692496299743652, 0.060152724385261536, -0.15778197348117828, -0.02861477993428707, -0.05996537581086159, 0.023736057803034782, 0.03160805627703667, -0.1615360826253891, 0.23170563578605652, 0.6733156442642212, -0.3312746286392212, 0.28855541348457336, -0.09233077615499496, -0.19339489936828613, 0.0007718887645751238, -0.20279647409915924, 0.6379513740539551, -0.2618156671524048, -0.5153334736824036, -0.5717739462852478, 0.40716326236724854, 0.5296952128410339, -0.5281488299369812, 0.529301643371582, 1.1460201740264893, 0.02400742843747139, 0.14588037133216858, -0.601700484752655, -0.4195840358734131, -0.4815061390399933, 0.4155299961566925, -0.5895190834999084, -1.0212206840515137, 0.29013219475746155, 0.20113597810268402, -0.18151922523975372, 0.2912594974040985, 0.6994197964668274, -0.12060593068599701, 1.2796663045883179, 0.348418265581131, 0.2775382101535797, 0.6778855323791504, 0.013790406286716461, -0.06843391060829163, -0.7970685362815857, -0.5234073996543884, -0.34861451387405396, -0.058173805475234985, -0.24144068360328674, -0.7401731014251709, 0.6471667289733887, 0.12342880666255951, 0.06675928086042404, -0.05602215230464935, -0.670576274394989, 0.5209054946899414, 0.7114913463592529, 0.392917662858963, 0.4344831109046936, 0.05647940933704376, -0.20963305234909058, -0.0347520187497139, -0.48673874139785767, -0.32546013593673706, 0.7475563287734985, 0.1137370690703392, 0.565826416015625, -0.09589959681034088, 0.3796694874763489, -0.1783635914325714, 0.2089347541332245, -0.7892113924026489, 0.6745581030845642, -0.1499076932668686, -0.3976714313030243, -0.35594508051872253, -0.3348568081855774, -0.7113972902297974, 0.48082634806632996, -0.6303287744522095, -0.9277509450912476, 0.08156293630599976, 0.28778719902038574, -0.4012943208217621, 0.002188577316701412, -0.841681957244873, 1.0682522058486938, -0.08014268428087234, -0.5028988122940063, 0.06419726461172104, -0.5303173065185547, 0.15240032970905304, 0.31760838627815247, 0.04695719853043556, 0.04367806762456894, -0.13690653443336487, 0.3116850256919861, -0.04721037670969963, 0.8099926710128784, -0.3597235083580017, -0.10165680199861526, 0.2870124876499176, -0.25908011198043823, 0.5069313049316406, 0.24113653600215912, 0.11503162235021591, -0.18736597895622253, 0.03246793895959854, -0.21308109164237976, -0.9157124757766724, 0.4560147523880005, -0.47476688027381897, -0.625978946685791, -0.13739536702632904, -0.6427825093269348, -0.24294458329677582, 0.17682510614395142, 0.3345903754234314, 0.7530969977378845, 0.060896072536706924, 0.30138254165649414, 0.7688181400299072, -0.43055111169815063, 0.4947923421859741, 0.3121318221092224, -0.4161947965621948, -0.45251914858818054, 0.8117421865463257, -0.3619602918624878, 0.22724023461341858, 0.6142358779907227, 0.28119486570358276, -0.6785333752632141, -0.5667519569396973, -0.7120466232299805, 0.06584116071462631, -0.7902892231941223, -0.18264973163604736, -0.8761910200119019, 0.17641335725784302, -0.18262067437171936, -0.08643269538879395, 0.003977954853326082, 0.03119090013206005, -0.40394529700279236, 0.18299861252307892, 0.44978901743888855, 0.3838365077972412, 0.49841222167015076, 0.2193535715341568, -1.0298326015472412, 0.6382999420166016, 0.6972603797912598, 0.135525643825531, -0.10125338286161423, -0.23568665981292725, 0.08155547827482224, 0.04598761349916458, -0.23380205035209656, -0.7967999577522278, 0.11676272749900818, -0.2233368307352066, 0.3243141770362854, 0.29972997307777405, 0.057806771248579025, 0.844005823135376, -0.4049685597419739, 1.0182783603668213, 0.503298819065094, -0.8546664714813232, 0.6097617745399475, -0.4448111653327942, 0.5933402180671692, 0.5389347672462463, 0.10135453939437866, -0.5588072538375854, -0.49048733711242676, -0.20239736139774323, -0.7090910077095032, 0.4923887848854065, 0.27287858724594116, 0.026464097201824188, 0.08173884451389313, 0.13634659349918365, 0.06107211858034134, 0.23339644074440002, -0.6555390954017639, 0.012210536748170853, -0.29311931133270264, -0.48526057600975037, 0.039246220141649246, -0.12366050481796265, 0.07566606998443604, -0.20146901905536652, 0.19442160427570343, -0.42706790566444397, 0.24206075072288513, 0.5294340252876282, 0.042093440890312195, 0.2593768835067749, 0.4837453365325928, 0.6438849568367004, 0.5904977917671204, 0.003731733886525035, 0.22042939066886902, 0.18180212378501892, -0.5491397380828857, -0.050985533744096756, 0.020534630864858627, -0.02113955095410347, -0.06080399081110954, 0.4597114622592926, 0.9363071322441101, -0.15117251873016357, -0.7709676623344421, 0.7298094630241394, -0.4422237277030945, -0.20241831243038177, -0.02644665539264679, 0.19782933592796326, -0.03281361609697342, 0.5231539607048035, 0.3505575954914093, 0.10619722306728363, 0.17432862520217896, -0.5767298340797424, -0.02929944545030594, 0.4258948266506195, -0.4905086159706116, -0.10461890697479248, 0.6827683448791504, 0.15012449026107788, -0.034558676183223724, 0.34773653745651245, 0.05824362859129906, -0.5404582023620605, 0.46292078495025635, 0.42992103099823, 0.5774211883544922, -0.0826684907078743, 0.4783608317375183, 0.35910534858703613, 0.09658624976873398, -0.2025255560874939, 0.6822569370269775, -0.3172691762447357, -0.5265997052192688, -0.5734546184539795, -0.4134005308151245, -0.48202207684516907, 0.006340238265693188, -0.529876172542572, 0.3716338872909546, -0.22800377011299133, -0.09403213113546371, 0.08774160593748093, -0.30873939394950867, -0.5332269072532654, 0.2971232831478119, 0.211691215634346, 0.6623998284339905, -0.658208966255188, 0.5594015717506409, 0.913354218006134, -0.4331692159175873, -0.7780540585517883, 0.18921448290348053, -0.17704884707927704, -0.6115971803665161, 0.6046940684318542, 0.5683459043502808, -0.07242468744516373, -0.009252768941223621, -0.4687495827674866, -0.37913429737091064, 0.9595897197723389, 0.20287197828292847, -0.5959901809692383, 0.05361819267272949, 0.13040585815906525, 0.459152489900589, -0.13055074214935303, 0.5129300355911255, 0.1726425290107727, 0.8411845564842224, 0.2416319102048874, -0.9031045436859131, -0.014905644580721855, -0.18025147914886475, -0.009427718818187714, 0.3516938388347626, -0.47176238894462585, 0.8155056834220886, -0.2230989634990692, 0.04019583389163017, 0.09044443070888519, 0.5760555863380432, 0.49751994013786316, 0.5925703048706055, 0.7262023091316223, 0.12805862724781036, 0.6032879948616028, -0.19173723459243774, 0.9566382169723511, 0.11316744983196259, 0.11856430023908615, 0.8284979462623596, -0.058136727660894394, 1.077764868736267, 0.8721289038658142, 0.049299146980047226, 0.37627965211868286, 0.3976117968559265, 0.04399586468935013, 0.29598772525787354, -0.3251922130584717, -0.46796146035194397, -0.4213000237941742, -0.19281281530857086, -0.341970294713974, 0.4447489082813263, 0.2911890149116516, -0.13475768268108368, -0.16913463175296783, 0.5625126361846924, -0.35212939977645874, 0.16465520858764648, -0.3688819408416748, 0.803284764289856, -0.05797300487756729, -0.9026638865470886, 0.3640921115875244, -0.2239888608455658, 0.7182741165161133, -0.46724656224250793, -0.27407804131507874, 0.024046089500188828, 0.17448437213897705, -0.08717839419841766, -1.139094352722168, -0.0810823068022728, 0.12147486209869385, -0.35612452030181885, -0.22780455648899078, 0.5968974232673645, -0.6469823718070984, -0.4246080219745636, 0.1360081434249878, 0.4795472323894501, -0.0626872256398201, -0.6764621734619141, -0.6862261891365051, 0.12965789437294006, 0.004413193557411432, -0.17562370002269745, -0.00518076354637742, 0.7167248129844666, -0.31940242648124695, 0.6789323687553406, 0.6968204975128174, -0.34744563698768616, -0.04677828773856163, 0.39605599641799927, 0.9093649387359619, -0.6312877535820007, -0.39198580384254456, -0.9478541612625122, 0.7105743885040283, -0.1478431075811386, -0.2771573066711426, 0.7443283200263977, 0.1298571527004242, 0.7062450647354126, -0.4696481227874756, 0.47242680191993713, -0.016104595735669136, 0.1657995879650116, -0.901166558265686, 0.39848899841308594, -0.8152448534965515, 0.11484207212924957, -0.4334941506385803, -1.0631093978881836, -0.3824855089187622, 0.3871604800224304, -0.25486546754837036, 0.028049148619174957, 0.8227302432060242, 0.8546948432922363, -0.06406327337026596, -0.15491953492164612, 0.5784940719604492, -0.09466005861759186, 0.3032005727291107, 0.6118387579917908, 1.1325302124023438, -0.20162175595760345, 0.7933875322341919, -0.1387658417224884, -0.037526972591876984, -0.3333388864994049, -0.7284038662910461, -1.174761176109314, -0.6840552687644958, -0.1399192065000534, -0.09233830869197845, -0.0660259947180748, 0.6637603044509888, 0.43700358271598816, -0.5047122836112976, 0.2776314616203308, -0.06361296027898788, -0.1763429492712021, -0.1603570282459259, -0.2444678395986557, 0.3070993721485138, -0.23450613021850586, -0.809457540512085, 0.1224919930100441, 0.5477054715156555, 0.25634267926216125, -0.30617403984069824, -0.02364940382540226, -0.010498490184545517, -0.17059357464313507, 0.9079528450965881, -0.07104545086622238, -0.9061803817749023, -0.41744720935821533, 0.32132411003112793, -0.014367250725626945, 0.05199281498789787, 0.6325576305389404, -0.918211042881012, 0.751862108707428, 0.7522101402282715, 0.4072771668434143, 0.32504501938819885, 0.296023428440094, 0.3970603346824646, -0.8025616407394409, 0.4906814396381378, 0.11917925626039505, 0.2338634729385376, 0.5204643607139587, -0.4481050670146942, 0.06185416504740715, 0.15190201997756958, -0.2545487880706787, -0.47111576795578003, 0.3085376024246216, -1.3493459224700928, -0.4741608798503876, 0.9636584520339966, 0.14359581470489502, -0.4829704761505127, -0.10202013701200485, -1.0603222846984863, 0.016221893951296806, -0.43031859397888184, 0.5099964141845703, 0.7092027068138123, 0.02225751429796219, -0.6534948945045471, -0.6174425482749939, 0.24157854914665222, 0.6341872811317444, -1.0911064147949219, -0.01814970374107361, 0.6172084808349609, -0.16048681735992432, 0.14202958345413208, 0.47366076707839966, -0.017209447920322418, 0.5570119023323059, -0.08945702761411667, 0.018150750547647476, -0.39558568596839905, -0.5820275545120239, -0.12246342748403549, 0.2552327811717987, -0.16416692733764648, -0.3095867931842804 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04513v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04513v1
IITK at SemEval-2024 Task 1: Contrastive Learning and Autoencoders for Semantic Textual Relatedness in Multilingual Texts
2024-04-06T05:58:42
2024-04-06T05:58:42
Udvas Basak, Rajarshi Dutta, Shivam Pandey, Ashutosh Modi
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
This paper describes our system developed for the SemEval-2024 Task 1: Semantic Textual Relatedness. The challenge is focused on automatically detecting the degree of relatedness between pairs of sentences for 14 languages including both high and low-resource Asian and African languages. Our team participated in two subtasks consisting of Track A: supervised and Track B: unsupervised. This paper focuses on a BERT-based contrastive learning and similarity metric based approach primarily for the supervised track while exploring autoencoders for the unsupervised track. It also aims on the creation of a bigram relatedness corpus using negative sampling strategy, thereby producing refined word embeddings.
[ -0.5216975808143616, -0.40606123208999634, 0.3363834023475647, 0.3444417715072632, -0.4843829274177551, -0.16681453585624695, -0.24244000017642975, -0.7105684280395508, 0.42979517579078674, 0.504792332649231, -0.7202627062797546, -0.525213897228241, -0.4402305483818054, 0.3470163345336914, -0.25578534603118896, 0.9739215970039368, -0.22152826189994812, 0.06065353378653526, -0.349637508392334, -0.6292279958724976, -0.4201567769050598, -0.7696674466133118, -0.36458274722099304, -0.4690992534160614, 0.4718015789985657, 0.38795408606529236, 0.15545639395713806, 0.41620609164237976, 0.6368730068206787, 0.23137594759464264, 0.22259826958179474, -0.07014894485473633, -0.27282610535621643, 0.40638425946235657, -0.5200002193450928, -0.3390386998653412, -0.16951978206634521, -0.14326444268226624, 0.2879268527030945, 0.4353760778903961, 0.3001197278499603, 0.1568930596113205, 0.4000561237335205, 0.5395210385322571, -0.4215720295906067, 0.32525867223739624, -0.6520013809204102, 0.057696226984262466, -0.29395395517349243, -0.19796590507030487, -0.035224203020334244, 0.03651564568281174, 0.011472221463918686, -0.5224117636680603, 0.4641106128692627, 0.0035485110711306334, 0.9465166926383972, 0.45927727222442627, -0.6392122507095337, -0.7501775622367859, -0.19709600508213043, 0.9559500813484192, -0.5949613451957703, 0.3852851688861847, 0.7704469561576843, -0.02896079234778881, 0.2851105034351349, -0.5528647899627686, -0.5673828721046448, -0.03479825705289841, -0.2770248353481293, 0.3924710154533386, 0.2847675681114197, -0.2335672527551651, -0.06644336879253387, 0.15608735382556915, -0.6417331099510193, 0.28581029176712036, -0.10993020236492157, -0.44982099533081055, 0.457199364900589, 0.13009318709373474, 0.0869235172867775, -0.42514654994010925, -0.5061154961585999, -0.04699017107486725, -0.6017408967018127, -0.2659474313259125, 0.5467206835746765, 0.1470746397972107, -0.2608477771282196, 0.43465927243232727, -0.3624960482120514, 0.26924562454223633, -0.21066316962242126, 0.29188060760498047, 0.6669078469276428, -0.9307664036750793, 0.22847309708595276, 0.16112637519836426, 0.5911074280738831, 0.2880604863166809, 0.11932987719774246, 0.1257537603378296, -0.14812782406806946, 0.24642698466777802, 0.01922648400068283, -0.6784394979476929, -0.4131092131137848, -0.004787447862327099, -0.6283730864524841, -0.18157783150672913, -0.12910397350788116, -0.696733295917511, -0.1128574013710022, -0.5062046051025391, 0.6936213970184326, -0.6320415139198303, -0.16962258517742157, -0.36375951766967773, 0.16486850380897522, 0.4276336133480072, 0.2464444786310196, -0.7677860260009766, 0.08532612770795822, 0.6376293897628784, 0.5942864418029785, -0.18473927676677704, -0.5577662587165833, -0.25706297159194946, 0.13650140166282654, -0.08175589889287949, 0.8319469094276428, -0.3605644702911377, -0.12020070850849152, -0.031195025891065598, 0.3642809987068176, 0.11081018298864365, -0.5873605012893677, 0.7023414969444275, -0.36485278606414795, 0.16129545867443085, -0.38039958477020264, -0.6724550127983093, -0.26100659370422363, 0.5445775389671326, -0.6904774904251099, 1.1929023265838623, -0.08586787432432175, -0.860593318939209, 0.4020334780216217, -0.4384145736694336, -0.5857661962509155, -0.005980542860925198, -0.2746722102165222, -0.6103383302688599, -0.22090603411197662, 0.18380175530910492, 0.5452719926834106, -0.009507609531283379, 0.10592267662286758, -0.2607460021972656, -0.3781132698059082, -0.10542122274637222, -0.2479817420244217, 0.6392822265625, 0.41052693128585815, -0.4967961311340332, -0.021362369880080223, -0.759431779384613, -0.1858505755662918, 0.06424932181835175, -0.25363561511039734, -0.7857118844985962, -0.2112756222486496, 0.18822841346263885, 0.33811381459236145, 0.5370062589645386, -0.6548721194267273, -0.17837390303611755, -0.3937494456768036, 0.317454993724823, 0.611585259437561, 0.19974544644355774, 0.15099139511585236, -0.09917335212230682, 0.21187297999858856, 0.4328109622001648, -0.20576322078704834, -0.657860517501831, -0.24897395074367523, -0.9893668293952942, -0.042980726808309555, 0.5504958629608154, 0.5948999524116516, -0.939139723777771, 0.5209143757820129, -0.09156375378370285, -0.23692800104618073, -0.39152154326438904, 0.20017987489700317, 0.5531622171401978, 0.41270849108695984, 0.36442139744758606, -0.2440578043460846, -0.6495969295501709, -1.109492540359497, -0.015349027700722218, 0.01628008671104908, 0.1332462579011917, 0.110759437084198, 0.7333628535270691, -0.4917871654033661, 0.40284866094589233, -0.33347201347351074, -0.4725896418094635, 0.2659006118774414, 0.3614974021911621, 0.10273219645023346, 0.6652331948280334, 0.6895285844802856, -0.892069399356842, -0.702278196811676, 0.02413439191877842, -0.8780803680419922, -0.3054489493370056, 0.37482479214668274, -0.1158570796251297, 0.46294787526130676, 1.203160285949707, 0.015122896060347557, 0.36716538667678833, 0.4120897650718689, -0.31859371066093445, 0.2240111082792282, -0.36490172147750854, 0.3200056850910187, -1.489545464515686, 0.03093831054866314, -0.08934473991394043, -0.241005539894104, -0.19649818539619446, -0.009266044944524765, 0.06406579911708832, -0.06230313703417778, -0.23454411327838898, 0.5446493029594421, -0.33601921796798706, -0.08183600753545761, -0.2439451813697815, 0.03602731227874756, -0.24095559120178223, 0.6252416968345642, 0.050425782799720764, 0.8664889931678772, 0.097541444003582, -0.638275146484375, 0.3845430612564087, 0.36204537749290466, -0.2872355282306671, 0.9130913019180298, -0.47760552167892456, -0.07569637149572372, -0.2734753489494324, 0.054002102464437485, -1.166172742843628, -0.10936151444911957, -0.05735883116722107, -0.6170763373374939, 0.16427408158779144, 0.18568740785121918, -0.6352741122245789, -0.23470528423786163, -0.48996537923812866, 0.7096072435379028, 0.338497132062912, -0.4548865556716919, 0.13520555198192596, 0.3326830565929413, -0.6281623840332031, -0.4504883885383606, -0.9142844676971436, 0.09862227737903595, -0.15808160603046417, -0.3607513904571533, 0.25612014532089233, -0.0630510002374649, -0.12997381389141083, 0.3310520052909851, 0.23671358823776245, -0.1855679601430893, 0.08203306794166565, 0.13847309350967407, 0.05509967729449272, -0.22542622685432434, 0.5321448445320129, 0.03235297277569771, -0.26965299248695374, -0.03941073268651962, -0.3189118802547455, 0.5194828510284424, 0.04960782453417778, -0.34891945123672485, -0.04662349447607994, 0.5872035622596741, -0.0010712676448747516, -0.2268218845129013, 0.5732077956199646, 1.0574991703033447, -0.4401492476463318, 0.10786376893520355, -0.5531669855117798, -0.10472004115581512, -0.39837414026260376, 0.586631715297699, -0.6039007902145386, -1.0397744178771973, 0.7122406959533691, -0.15186743438243866, -0.08962953090667725, 0.7178866267204285, 0.7684817314147949, -0.33298611640930176, 0.7004944086074829, 0.6557794213294983, -0.06986155360937119, 0.3705221116542816, -0.10276386886835098, 0.07652454823255539, -0.6984958648681641, -0.31267017126083374, -0.7194485068321228, -0.1808748096227646, -1.0400995016098022, -0.4029879868030548, 0.2240380197763443, -0.19100090861320496, -0.3551671504974365, 0.5323783159255981, -0.2110556662082672, 0.4032253921031952, 0.6720396280288696, -0.012983116321265697, 0.21378076076507568, -0.01776774227619171, -0.4680681824684143, -0.3757492005825043, -0.45404061675071716, -0.27805712819099426, 0.88999342918396, 0.07965008169412613, 0.4534085988998413, 0.1651013046503067, 0.9399710297584534, 0.49133431911468506, -0.04675120487809181, -0.5644246935844421, 0.4171772301197052, -0.425251305103302, -0.40715640783309937, -0.2511245608329773, -0.20452426373958588, -0.9850690960884094, 0.1004420667886734, -0.177052304148674, -0.3888971209526062, 0.13148356974124908, -0.05334422364830971, 0.2648650109767914, -0.12629619240760803, -0.4961088299751282, 0.7723963856697083, 0.05959654971957207, -0.32373884320259094, -0.3512856960296631, -0.9617804288864136, 0.008624468930065632, -0.3284130096435547, 0.22238507866859436, -0.09314823150634766, -0.23982374370098114, 0.7711477875709534, -0.43334633111953735, 0.7041119337081909, 0.07181110233068466, -0.2765638530254364, 0.1690485030412674, -0.03763941302895546, 0.25104182958602905, -0.043405547738075256, -0.31893402338027954, 0.12442834675312042, 0.07725612074136734, -0.7386540174484253, -0.16172349452972412, 1.053958773612976, -0.6549332737922668, -0.09368743747472763, -0.44537678360939026, -0.2531360983848572, -0.2914072871208191, 0.3648751974105835, 0.49106067419052124, 0.4631688892841339, -0.41652077436447144, 0.20180730521678925, 0.6536791324615479, -0.3263527750968933, 0.6286852359771729, 0.4185013473033905, 0.08610259741544724, -0.5609517097473145, 1.138330101966858, 0.029998768121004105, -0.05557496100664139, 0.5780315399169922, -0.13660888373851776, -0.4593927264213562, -0.3584274649620056, -0.2996995151042938, 0.31306469440460205, -0.8548492789268494, -0.22563762962818146, -0.7019384503364563, -0.2995157241821289, -0.485921710729599, -0.1792633831501007, -0.20271258056163788, -0.3715231120586395, -0.33089762926101685, 0.012182148173451424, 0.13136793673038483, 0.7980492115020752, -0.16982512176036835, -0.05214317515492439, -0.7625213861465454, 0.21360671520233154, 0.28040167689323425, 0.2682909369468689, -0.21958811581134796, -0.5069690346717834, -0.5016719102859497, -0.2511090934276581, -0.18127880990505219, -0.24568013846874237, 0.2107676863670349, 0.26844459772109985, 0.4652039408683777, 0.07571475952863693, 0.26649096608161926, 0.35246405005455017, -0.5633464455604553, 0.8088912963867188, 0.2016141563653946, -0.7951183915138245, 0.6857140064239502, -0.35518407821655273, 0.555951714515686, 0.9396620392799377, 0.49872103333473206, -0.3790833353996277, -0.3410325050354004, -0.5946903228759766, -0.8546533584594727, 0.4946731925010681, 0.3963730037212372, 0.25866127014160156, -0.06434773653745651, 0.16431252658367157, 0.42469558119773865, 0.23458322882652283, -0.759617269039154, -0.2215568572282791, -0.2704484760761261, -0.6984816193580627, -0.2635730803012848, -0.4365648329257965, 0.28523772954940796, 0.08637605607509613, 0.9183859825134277, -0.21374106407165527, 0.25471940636634827, 0.3364471197128296, -0.29720714688301086, 0.23292556405067444, 0.37780436873435974, 0.42388787865638733, 0.4450869858264923, -0.032983649522066116, 0.1969139724969864, 0.35223767161369324, -0.5287711024284363, 0.13670538365840912, 0.3234351873397827, -0.05996279418468475, 0.06224494054913521, 0.7374557256698608, 0.6660804748535156, 0.15439140796661377, -0.5572929382324219, 0.6514673233032227, 0.028889836743474007, -0.3343871533870697, -0.40987321734428406, -0.49545231461524963, 0.126207634806633, 0.17402200400829315, 0.13636864721775055, -0.3288986086845398, 0.3021496534347534, -0.5658484697341919, 0.41609859466552734, 0.15456397831439972, -0.8135202527046204, -0.42769911885261536, 0.3935621976852417, 0.6476935744285583, -0.02515382692217827, 0.33163541555404663, -0.38025858998298645, -0.8497433066368103, 0.7462189793586731, 0.48861581087112427, 0.6836971640586853, -0.3346439301967621, -0.17708158493041992, 0.6916560530662537, 0.2723506987094879, 0.3232131600379944, 0.3756679594516754, -0.21170811355113983, -0.5960267782211304, -0.38405704498291016, -0.5415283441543579, -0.22043050825595856, 0.13100072741508484, -0.6062895655632019, 0.5945631861686707, 0.008555431850254536, 0.20867352187633514, -0.012941338121891022, 0.12493140250444412, -0.7137570381164551, 0.3677286207675934, -0.021058302372694016, 0.5003692507743835, -0.760078489780426, 0.9889965653419495, 0.9926260709762573, -0.29333874583244324, -0.5152144432067871, 0.20391516387462616, -0.03018546849489212, -0.6186177730560303, 0.8742631673812866, 0.22141744196414948, 0.02689455635845661, -0.051718614995479584, -0.250397652387619, -0.5472049713134766, 1.1711432933807373, 0.009092493914067745, -0.5324697494506836, 0.21328306198120117, 0.08458810299634933, 0.5493999123573303, -0.06490103155374527, 0.06305518746376038, 0.31154441833496094, 0.2817181348800659, 0.04436207935214043, -0.9742558002471924, -0.2150663584470749, -0.3678002953529358, -0.08362938463687897, 0.6107111573219299, -0.9234339594841003, 0.8263354301452637, 0.18616314232349396, 0.09075997024774551, 0.2651977837085724, 0.705672025680542, -0.15598255395889282, 0.5010281801223755, 0.45354920625686646, 0.8620181679725647, 0.45345360040664673, 0.11835578083992004, 0.5602346658706665, -0.41413402557373047, 0.5080387592315674, 1.324215292930603, -0.4332926869392395, 0.6879761219024658, 0.43551430106163025, -0.12865835428237915, 0.419784277677536, 0.6698874831199646, 0.10986081510782242, 0.6962267756462097, 0.03216862305998802, -0.3376309275627136, -0.1509566754102707, -0.42622581124305725, -0.5162765383720398, 0.5203957557678223, 0.35679465532302856, -0.36527273058891296, -0.3778640627861023, 0.3532394468784332, -0.10086365044116974, 0.4291890561580658, -0.2569452226161957, 1.0611999034881592, 0.2264503836631775, -0.5240494608879089, 0.214255690574646, -0.023408368229866028, 0.9200431704521179, -0.6019339561462402, -0.31071603298187256, -0.1645386517047882, 0.31216031312942505, -0.038837723433971405, -0.9026240110397339, 0.5060296654701233, -0.20314384996891022, -0.16948136687278748, 0.10602694749832153, 0.9970892667770386, -0.7514331936836243, -0.3892950713634491, 0.5298709869384766, 0.44142308831214905, 0.041771337389945984, 0.27231261134147644, -0.6750510334968567, -0.056189388036727905, 0.03071504831314087, 0.13554948568344116, 0.3827768564224243, 0.8227159976959229, -0.29314103722572327, 0.3256310522556305, 0.26969262957572937, -0.18410614132881165, -0.16908162832260132, 0.1618640422821045, 0.5520420074462891, -0.9528336524963379, -0.9132320284843445, -0.7144596576690674, -0.20848938822746277, -0.04747660458087921, -0.27349287271499634, 0.829185426235199, 0.7512364983558655, 1.109702229499817, -0.0480150505900383, 0.8571811318397522, 0.04862642288208008, 0.8789157867431641, -0.6496619582176208, 0.40062958002090454, -0.6134352087974548, 0.23333854973316193, -0.33802330493927, -1.0675777196884155, -0.037399452179670334, 0.4648864269256592, -0.09822968393564224, -0.2627573609352112, 0.9864382743835449, 0.6089722514152527, -0.26962992548942566, 0.0674213245511055, 0.3405805230140686, 0.08633112907409668, -0.0024882247671484947, 0.680611252784729, 0.6852608323097229, -0.6866022944450378, 0.6038855910301208, -0.34619027376174927, -0.048365894705057144, -0.24946343898773193, -0.9706494808197021, -0.8625759482383728, -1.1199026107788086, -0.3416379392147064, -0.3019244372844696, 0.12059628218412399, 0.9501943588256836, 0.34994351863861084, -1.1015822887420654, -0.16293102502822876, -0.03515451401472092, -0.14833934605121613, 0.3362261950969696, -0.22814226150512695, 0.5422158241271973, -0.3747771382331848, -0.69486403465271, -0.12592492997646332, 0.3817426264286041, 0.10880286991596222, -0.11315827816724777, -0.0031253278721123934, -0.6265230774879456, -0.02712111920118332, 0.6938020586967468, 0.014187798835337162, -0.4034007787704468, -0.4354972839355469, -0.3759091794490814, -0.3265325427055359, -0.058477066457271576, 0.6834759712219238, -0.7508245706558228, 0.361791729927063, 0.6576457023620605, 0.8957178592681885, 0.6340467929840088, -0.027283011004328728, 0.31296491622924805, -0.6973910331726074, 0.5661981701850891, 0.2752370834350586, 0.34970787167549133, 0.49516764283180237, -0.21707232296466827, 1.0370677709579468, 0.27946051955223083, -0.702599287033081, -0.4292289912700653, 0.33646953105926514, -0.738694965839386, -0.21787525713443756, 1.0415815114974976, -0.3565200865268707, -0.19530105590820312, -0.46744677424430847, -0.3134244382381439, 0.2123311311006546, -0.010411020368337631, 0.4487580955028534, 0.9627516269683838, -0.027996545657515526, 0.1457817256450653, -0.4260675311088562, 0.39215680956840515, 0.6599860191345215, -0.8249556422233582, -0.310678094625473, 0.296738862991333, 0.33823543787002563, 0.16333672404289246, 0.6713682413101196, -0.08454494178295135, 0.19771139323711395, -0.028722764924168587, 0.04930386692285538, 0.2294434905052185, 0.07601816207170486, -0.4325851500034332, -0.15091794729232788, -0.13884234428405762, -0.2937897741794586 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04510v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04510v1
IITK at SemEval-2024 Task 2: Exploring the Capabilities of LLMs for Safe Biomedical Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trials
2024-04-06T05:44:53
2024-04-06T05:44:53
Shreyasi Mandal, Ashutosh Modi
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Large Language models (LLMs) have demonstrated state-of-the-art performance in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks across multiple domains, yet they are prone to shortcut learning and factual inconsistencies. This research investigates LLMs' robustness, consistency, and faithful reasoning when performing Natural Language Inference (NLI) on breast cancer Clinical Trial Reports (CTRs) in the context of SemEval 2024 Task 2: Safe Biomedical Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trials. We examine the reasoning capabilities of LLMs and their adeptness at logical problem-solving. A comparative analysis is conducted on pre-trained language models (PLMs), GPT-3.5, and Gemini Pro under zero-shot settings using Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) framework, integrating various reasoning chains. The evaluation yields an F1 score of 0.69, consistency of 0.71, and a faithfulness score of 0.90 on the test dataset.
[ 0.146652489900589, -0.8620668053627014, 0.7564995288848877, 0.23288819193840027, -0.22124364972114563, -0.0706898644566536, -0.06210127845406532, -0.4879530966281891, -0.2484002709388733, 0.7570257186889648, -0.39320626854896545, -0.730682373046875, -0.7625141739845276, 0.4460507035255432, -0.24798661470413208, 0.9480095505714417, -0.09707047790288925, 0.3027079999446869, -0.3020443618297577, -0.30793842673301697, -0.44323238730430603, -0.5050336122512817, -0.6899902820587158, -0.24813199043273926, 0.4394421875476837, 0.04438196122646332, 0.5118293166160583, 0.5953233242034912, 0.7147923707962036, 0.2705222964286804, -0.0014136540703475475, 0.3073893189430237, -0.23200754821300507, 0.460385799407959, -0.44504833221435547, -0.5292503833770752, -0.34466999769210815, 0.09129105508327484, 0.17361831665039062, 0.5012578368186951, -0.08091481775045395, -0.24244976043701172, 0.17874056100845337, 0.4853200614452362, -0.4777876138687134, 0.014828525483608246, -0.8119256496429443, -0.1809019297361374, 0.017272263765335083, -0.1664477437734604, -0.552818775177002, -0.6837595701217651, 0.14413145184516907, -0.6634068489074707, 0.10019602626562119, -0.0822691023349762, 0.895840048789978, 0.45532283186912537, -0.5906603932380676, -0.538047194480896, -0.31258663535118103, 0.785881757736206, -1.119974136352539, 0.034973204135894775, 0.6580365300178528, 0.362073689699173, -0.38459935784339905, -0.7384176254272461, -0.251957505941391, -0.2971445918083191, 0.024214599281549454, 0.20705264806747437, -0.048170559108257294, 0.24258244037628174, 0.2080281674861908, 0.03928188234567642, -0.5991417765617371, 0.22564232349395752, -0.04756765067577362, -0.3868097960948944, 0.5192256569862366, 0.1486150026321411, 0.1896306276321411, -0.27489402890205383, -0.2656790316104889, 0.25709569454193115, -0.8138161301612854, -0.17815212905406952, -0.06427435576915741, 0.34935492277145386, 0.02948259562253952, 0.8477902412414551, -0.1689561903476715, 0.6137651205062866, -0.2941955029964447, -0.24028822779655457, 0.10836046189069748, -0.6664425730705261, -0.38057973980903625, 0.016335397958755493, 0.8251795768737793, 0.2886682450771332, 0.2421359121799469, -0.21331265568733215, 0.15371017158031464, 0.4205020070075989, 0.37322500348091125, -0.6528645157814026, 0.07853052765130997, 0.4079585075378418, -0.3295353949069977, -0.28650012612342834, -0.14637060463428497, -0.32301223278045654, -0.21885798871517181, -0.23367464542388916, 0.8877207636833191, -0.718887209892273, 0.03187480941414833, 0.34137484431266785, 0.0962701290845871, 0.14551854133605957, 0.35949525237083435, -0.4104893207550049, 0.23319539427757263, 0.8669658899307251, 0.5271013379096985, -0.11235977709293365, -0.021182717755436897, -0.7847886085510254, 0.2577567398548126, -0.2032565325498581, 0.7262672185897827, -0.15438279509544373, -0.43058785796165466, -0.0845617949962616, 0.15167774260044098, -0.39271265268325806, -0.5053896307945251, 1.0048680305480957, -0.3243488073348999, 0.21809852123260498, -0.43708574771881104, -0.8129668235778809, -0.05053591728210449, 0.4228198230266571, -0.1872897744178772, 0.6795785427093506, -0.23778791725635529, -0.8149312734603882, 0.35973262786865234, -0.23349978029727936, -0.45328083634376526, -0.07143239676952362, -0.24317537248134613, -0.4930615723133087, -0.083917997777462, 0.12186029553413391, 0.3951404392719269, -0.018786318600177765, 0.3992328345775604, -0.5336615443229675, -0.26146504282951355, 0.43546152114868164, -0.4285155236721039, 0.7392497658729553, 0.29094886779785156, -0.4448288679122925, -0.0629795715212822, -0.6088075637817383, 0.10120377689599991, 0.018448369577527046, -0.3529719412326813, -0.13047102093696594, -0.05596112087368965, -0.4591343402862549, 0.17790305614471436, 0.023795101791620255, -0.746372401714325, 0.10116618126630783, -0.7107876539230347, 0.4441913068294525, 0.5221672654151917, 0.1273643672466278, 0.10453824698925018, -0.38291749358177185, 0.28816142678260803, -0.06748697906732559, 0.08847106248140335, -0.04483191296458244, -0.7219408750534058, -0.6705197691917419, -0.271761417388916, 0.46475645899772644, 0.6238188147544861, -0.8360921740531921, 0.25705891847610474, -0.11466605216264725, -0.18113845586776733, -0.33709052205085754, -0.003514723153784871, 0.6005810499191284, 0.8304155468940735, 0.35166478157043457, 0.17767134308815002, -0.5162289142608643, -0.9585067629814148, -0.5500354766845703, -0.07217688113451004, -0.06322657316923141, 0.14362862706184387, 0.7054738998413086, -0.456214040517807, 0.7928715944290161, -0.06312625110149384, -0.0214520376175642, -0.2643977701663971, 0.3608669638633728, 0.3438079357147217, 0.416450560092926, 0.18737323582172394, -0.5102167129516602, -0.25371044874191284, -0.19694463908672333, -0.8124012351036072, -0.511431872844696, -0.0488365963101387, -0.19241410493850708, 0.3944074511528015, 0.37438973784446716, -0.6791815161705017, 0.7875450253486633, 0.3834497034549713, -0.4672481119632721, 0.37313127517700195, -0.41058480739593506, 0.241291806101799, -1.0498400926589966, 0.00010590668534860015, 0.09122375398874283, -0.48572400212287903, -0.5979996919631958, -0.19986672699451447, -0.0778655931353569, 0.4492151737213135, -0.28296855092048645, 0.4415135979652405, -0.18929697573184967, 0.027615943923592567, -0.3826916813850403, -0.0907493531703949, 0.19131629168987274, -0.06634168326854706, 0.0947745144367218, 0.7206116914749146, 0.20186856389045715, -0.6560513377189636, -0.11289504170417786, 0.4328884780406952, -0.2619122266769409, 0.3586242198944092, -0.8357285857200623, 0.11734291166067123, -0.0013384697958827019, 0.08625845611095428, -0.7295960187911987, -0.2817467153072357, 0.06460971385240555, -0.5206169486045837, 0.20271393656730652, -0.041976142674684525, -0.6466658115386963, -0.29534897208213806, -0.10992603749036789, 0.03614110127091408, 0.4477275609970093, -0.2357257902622223, 0.4791536331176758, 0.23751050233840942, -0.26671427488327026, -0.6323299407958984, -0.9713744521141052, 0.05192802846431732, -0.02510320022702217, -0.6068020462989807, 0.13472217321395874, -0.06414005160331726, -0.368261456489563, -0.08263817429542542, -0.17526845633983612, -0.028165383264422417, -0.01102844625711441, 0.3291046917438507, 0.272726446390152, -0.11512206494808197, -0.011872958391904831, 0.10653523355722427, -0.3232501447200775, -0.00015415494272019714, 0.06725513190031052, -0.0020646629855036736, -0.2326924353837967, -0.7342267632484436, -0.40769463777542114, 0.27885153889656067, 0.40881967544555664, 0.024210164323449135, 0.7451596260070801, 0.3933129906654358, -0.46794945001602173, 0.06113601475954056, -0.660323977470398, -0.22351613640785217, -0.40853798389434814, 0.09790171682834625, -0.22719894349575043, -1.1865553855895996, 0.31876546144485474, 0.0230002012103796, 0.113774374127388, 0.411121666431427, 0.8239567279815674, -0.2585659921169281, 1.0981849431991577, 0.1312168389558792, 0.3656522333621979, -0.3990735709667206, 0.035677239298820496, 0.1898270845413208, -0.6301495432853699, -0.324759840965271, -0.5922362208366394, 0.04858456924557686, -0.3127595782279968, -0.5794860124588013, 0.6547762155532837, 0.09583528339862823, -0.4702141284942627, 0.1501077562570572, -0.3467830419540405, 0.29924526810646057, 0.5172745585441589, 0.18835708498954773, 0.40970054268836975, -0.12418489903211594, -0.3760421574115753, -0.25737860798835754, -0.6556887626647949, -0.7108319401741028, 1.1196690797805786, 0.3473135232925415, 0.5213134288787842, 0.23774270713329315, 0.4315803647041321, -0.034652773290872574, 0.2864776849746704, -0.4622233808040619, 0.4819268584251404, -0.224952831864357, -0.7513670921325684, 0.005531348753720522, -0.5442873239517212, -0.9087066054344177, 0.1902458369731903, -0.321898877620697, -0.6417412161827087, -0.13973641395568848, -0.13489669561386108, -0.4778710603713989, 0.05617901310324669, -0.5225380063056946, 0.7257038354873657, -0.45543786883354187, -0.5376362204551697, 0.026649437844753265, -1.0236049890518188, 0.3839249908924103, -0.006311651319265366, 0.28402549028396606, -0.37578293681144714, -0.07309869676828384, 0.38768208026885986, -0.5671071410179138, 0.6791225671768188, 0.0882459357380867, 0.14293648302555084, 0.4611172676086426, 0.24087809026241302, 0.4354276955127716, 0.2371838539838791, -0.2981491684913635, 0.06901726871728897, 0.30454474687576294, -0.322832852602005, -0.3261410593986511, 0.6221641898155212, -0.5179528594017029, -0.5598364472389221, -0.5779110789299011, -0.5224615931510925, -0.598028302192688, 0.26048606634140015, 0.3404778838157654, 0.42773744463920593, 0.0051399716176092625, 0.377820760011673, 0.8038598895072937, -0.5231026411056519, 0.15644609928131104, 0.7025319933891296, 0.01665601134300232, -0.46602436900138855, 0.4736291766166687, 0.023111041635274887, 0.4023365378379822, 0.3140466809272766, 0.20586010813713074, -0.6083836555480957, -0.9087173938751221, -0.06727374345064163, 0.3498842418193817, -0.6146509647369385, -0.3422729969024658, -0.8119764924049377, -0.3992079794406891, -0.49247756600379944, -0.11588165163993835, -0.3500857651233673, -0.4069848954677582, -0.30989694595336914, -0.22769607603549957, 0.16071051359176636, 0.49782660603523254, -0.12105528265237808, 0.045883309096097946, -0.956894040107727, 0.3681340217590332, 0.1727147251367569, 0.0972445160150528, -0.6877376437187195, -0.6179430484771729, 0.12637747824192047, 0.027163656428456306, -0.11791546642780304, -0.7195133566856384, 0.45113325119018555, 0.09626651555299759, 0.6423599123954773, 0.246759831905365, -0.05329899117350578, 0.2948938012123108, -0.22985093295574188, 0.6511889696121216, 0.062391530722379684, -0.5932090878486633, 0.7288030385971069, -0.7991980314254761, 0.43594998121261597, 0.8983625769615173, 0.22700892388820648, -0.04398488253355026, -0.5640702247619629, -0.5148224830627441, -0.464596152305603, 0.46076980233192444, 0.6673217415809631, -0.2281293421983719, -0.13170655071735382, 0.6000365018844604, 0.3571459650993347, 0.19612754881381989, -0.5631107091903687, 0.03323965147137642, -0.07935390621423721, -0.6174757480621338, 0.10153552889823914, -0.525540828704834, -0.31070518493652344, -0.2474723905324936, 0.7761415839195251, -0.2547757029533386, 0.12502285838127136, 0.36362046003341675, 0.0457635223865509, 0.17335405945777893, 0.4673355519771576, 0.5339440703392029, 0.6169793605804443, -0.3077353239059448, 0.29378440976142883, 0.357398122549057, -0.4703056514263153, 0.04452153295278549, 0.09977946430444717, -0.11246298253536224, -0.16687989234924316, 0.5836756229400635, 0.4237338602542877, 0.19046443700790405, -0.8550091981887817, 0.5862017273902893, -0.2254261076450348, -0.4294949769973755, -0.06985265016555786, 0.04881586879491806, 0.3274223208427429, 0.15870948135852814, 0.011627347208559513, 0.17127491533756256, 0.13359306752681732, -0.3078935146331787, 0.21844080090522766, 0.4923137426376343, -0.4327174127101898, -0.16606459021568298, 0.8519884943962097, 0.01947610266506672, 0.0803389623761177, 0.4455227255821228, 0.005309325642883778, -0.3742721974849701, 0.5797183513641357, 0.6326056122779846, 0.5908415913581848, -0.02099362574517727, 0.17066147923469543, 0.36194708943367004, 0.43162962794303894, -0.19211332499980927, 0.46360138058662415, 0.41359710693359375, -0.8419543504714966, -0.5676159262657166, -0.5864394307136536, -0.510973334312439, 0.14194901287555695, -0.34838029742240906, 0.25198790431022644, -0.388223260641098, -0.38949644565582275, -0.17480161786079407, -0.01730819046497345, -0.3223843574523926, 0.36269640922546387, 0.16794419288635254, 1.016577959060669, -0.44015011191368103, 0.8442532420158386, 0.5723651051521301, -0.11758852005004883, -0.8943440914154053, -0.4795951247215271, 0.37503498792648315, -0.6045353412628174, 0.4796115756034851, 0.19046343863010406, -0.11870124936103821, -0.3272385001182556, -0.5005804896354675, -0.6147504448890686, 1.2016781568527222, 0.5736081004142761, -0.5039888024330139, 0.07722001522779465, 0.4618653357028961, 0.5264943838119507, -0.18357738852500916, 0.26826146245002747, 0.5316057801246643, 0.38510701060295105, 0.41431155800819397, -0.9885069727897644, -0.05679343268275261, -0.12017645686864853, -0.1883280873298645, -0.15152417123317719, -0.3262254297733307, 0.5186401009559631, -0.27833449840545654, 0.05142193287611008, 0.4955281615257263, 0.4654860496520996, 0.8762553930282593, 0.6684534549713135, 0.15404954552650452, 0.8939581513404846, 0.6983009576797485, -0.3408445715904236, 1.0142935514450073, -0.13816691935062408, 0.1308915615081787, 0.9743174314498901, -0.42017582058906555, 0.7086528539657593, 0.37581032514572144, -0.10665279626846313, 0.33908313512802124, 0.4719898998737335, 0.34520649909973145, 0.5567340850830078, -0.16058844327926636, -0.3453388214111328, -0.4852660894393921, -0.0823788270354271, -0.2520264685153961, 0.34421688318252563, 0.48650437593460083, -0.3330174386501312, -0.15719497203826904, -0.04303021356463432, 0.24521826207637787, 0.09129146486520767, -0.1000189259648323, 0.6295680999755859, 0.5036842226982117, -0.6176533699035645, 0.2570584714412689, -0.03159148618578911, 0.4436453580856323, -0.7624949812889099, -0.0024301621597260237, 0.04061400890350342, 0.3621028959751129, -0.09687995165586472, -0.779580295085907, 0.5639145374298096, 0.13296131789684296, 0.15181174874305725, 0.045626040548086166, 1.113796591758728, -0.07767725735902786, -0.5841554999351501, 0.019910156726837158, 0.4896935820579529, -0.03261178359389305, 0.016702886670827866, -0.7990633845329285, 0.13419024646282196, -0.08086902648210526, -0.22336304187774658, 0.27593159675598145, 0.3601047396659851, 0.09198226034641266, 0.8827670812606812, 0.5246506929397583, 0.12173948436975479, 0.05038169398903847, 0.05652439966797829, 0.4522531032562256, -0.463737815618515, -0.1713547259569168, -0.8444645404815674, 0.3927001953125, -0.039102185517549515, -0.2605116665363312, 0.9290182590484619, 0.4867369532585144, 0.1078517735004425, 0.1671167016029358, 0.7734031081199646, 0.3620036542415619, 0.9259324669837952, -0.7706547975540161, 0.594835102558136, -0.21189402043819427, 0.30930638313293457, 0.041770923882722855, -0.43571603298187256, -0.527381956577301, 0.5512365698814392, -0.5683724284172058, 0.0318852998316288, 0.753541111946106, 0.6892940402030945, 0.18716107308864594, 0.4459167718887329, 0.09201819449663162, 0.5143371224403381, 0.42694994807243347, 0.7097229361534119, 0.7829136252403259, -0.4299904704093933, 0.2949085533618927, -0.11743869632482529, -0.10037361085414886, -0.07892907410860062, -1.0341500043869019, -0.8462424278259277, -0.11276227235794067, -0.34849807620048523, -0.6758705377578735, 0.23310062289237976, 0.8852167725563049, 0.5080305933952332, -0.956905722618103, 0.18529145419597626, -0.36912721395492554, -0.052131518721580505, 0.17172947525978088, -0.16689221560955048, 0.29308614134788513, -0.33314934372901917, -0.39881476759910583, 0.5472179055213928, 0.5705143809318542, -0.03959106281399727, 0.1172536239027977, -0.24279111623764038, -0.30926787853240967, 0.2803078889846802, 0.48700442910194397, 0.1755620539188385, -0.7132664918899536, -0.23745402693748474, 0.014884033240377903, -0.4470196068286896, -0.16132669150829315, 0.47187474370002747, -0.892421543598175, 0.43960341811180115, 0.46378013491630554, 0.7908133864402771, 0.35322490334510803, 0.13538353145122528, 0.6133343577384949, -0.19143299758434296, -0.10892096161842346, 0.534643828868866, 0.3732767701148987, 0.355872243642807, -0.14511224627494812, 0.7285260558128357, 0.31090712547302246, -0.8801239132881165, -0.7206875681877136, 0.019594205543398857, -1.1475462913513184, -0.3553125560283661, 1.4364204406738281, -0.060358624905347824, -0.14909568428993225, -0.4317854046821594, -0.20322617888450623, 0.31620651483535767, 0.07262919843196869, 0.5121954083442688, 0.5059480667114258, -0.32495903968811035, 0.0184879582375288, -0.8805785179138184, 0.5415754318237305, 0.6566499471664429, -0.8299543261528015, -0.4283486008644104, 0.32911285758018494, 0.45458289980888367, -0.21736080944538116, 0.8755742311477661, -0.3955896496772766, 0.10075948387384415, -0.20043803751468658, -0.46001550555229187, -0.005562350153923035, -0.0478217750787735, -0.10158304125070572, 0.043364979326725006, 0.026011178269982338, 0.14344851672649384 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04487v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04487v1
KazQAD: Kazakh Open-Domain Question Answering Dataset
2024-04-06T03:40:36
2024-04-06T03:40:36
Rustem Yeshpanov, Pavel Efimov, Leonid Boytsov, Ardak Shalkarbayuli, Pavel Braslavski
cs.CL
cs.CL
We introduce KazQAD -- a Kazakh open-domain question answering (ODQA) dataset -- that can be used in both reading comprehension and full ODQA settings, as well as for information retrieval experiments. KazQAD contains just under 6,000 unique questions with extracted short answers and nearly 12,000 passage-level relevance judgements. We use a combination of machine translation, Wikipedia search, and in-house manual annotation to ensure annotation efficiency and data quality. The questions come from two sources: translated items from the Natural Questions (NQ) dataset (only for training) and the original Kazakh Unified National Testing (UNT) exam (for development and testing). The accompanying text corpus contains more than 800,000 passages from the Kazakh Wikipedia. As a supplementary dataset, we release around 61,000 question-passage-answer triples from the NQ dataset that have been machine-translated into Kazakh. We develop baseline retrievers and readers that achieve reasonable scores in retrieval (NDCG@10 = 0.389 MRR = 0.382), reading comprehension (EM = 38.5 F1 = 54.2), and full ODQA (EM = 17.8 F1 = 28.7) settings. Nevertheless, these results are substantially lower than state-of-the-art results for English QA collections, and we think that there should still be ample room for improvement. We also show that the current OpenAI's ChatGPTv3.5 is not able to answer KazQAD test questions in the closed-book setting with acceptable quality. The dataset is freely available under the Creative Commons licence (CC BY-SA) at https://github.com/IS2AI/KazQAD.
[ -0.5598132014274597, -0.7014769911766052, 0.30972766876220703, -0.05344754084944725, -0.4669494926929474, -0.06137795373797417, -0.03943311795592308, -0.2601173520088196, -0.17370940744876862, 0.7657037377357483, -0.637223482131958, -0.7337524890899658, -0.18128013610839844, 0.15973807871341705, -0.13640540838241577, 0.9907452464103699, -0.20619317889213562, 0.2219071388244629, -0.06238424405455589, -0.27854952216148376, -0.16262756288051605, -0.2967563569545746, -0.19382722675800323, 0.031432054936885834, 0.573279619216919, 0.829361081123352, 0.8835399150848389, 0.36986303329467773, 0.4176747798919678, 0.032439935952425, 0.017721548676490784, 0.11859215050935745, -0.34037208557128906, 0.030972883105278015, 0.1298789530992508, -0.25579434633255005, -0.1147744432091713, -0.1391255110502243, 0.6906992197036743, 0.741881251335144, -0.10176046937704086, 0.5734973549842834, 0.007718689274042845, 0.9987747669219971, -0.8814578652381897, -0.024359624832868576, -0.08665429800748825, 0.13285046815872192, -0.33410510420799255, 0.06661812961101532, -0.3373650908470154, -0.5515895485877991, 0.09466472268104553, -0.8675060272216797, 0.07749108225107193, -0.05605604499578476, 0.9348620176315308, 0.13511572778224945, -0.8254496455192566, -0.3926849663257599, -0.7428543567657471, 0.5371931791305542, -0.7054818272590637, 0.34927475452423096, 0.46824154257774353, 0.6405590772628784, -0.1848195344209671, -0.6842212677001953, -0.8857000470161438, 0.012016497552394867, 0.140604630112648, 0.2927624583244324, 0.14327138662338257, 0.04747225344181061, 0.14222365617752075, 0.6427912712097168, -0.9060815572738647, -0.3906259536743164, -0.7754100561141968, 0.0691765621304512, 0.6839789748191833, 0.26047536730766296, 0.5053517818450928, -0.1895388662815094, -0.2805865406990051, -0.26413875818252563, -0.7920376658439636, 0.32825735211372375, 0.5834186673164368, 0.5498688817024231, 0.32107993960380554, 0.821308434009552, -0.8849480748176575, 0.8857376575469971, -0.16345317661762238, 0.13064132630825043, 0.31367477774620056, -0.5274723768234253, -0.29653772711753845, -0.1424555778503418, 0.7486155033111572, 0.179443359375, 0.011261599138379097, -0.1843537539243698, 0.1872716248035431, -0.3735111355781555, 0.22401578724384308, -0.5777818560600281, -0.39632362127304077, 0.5619429349899292, -0.3661971390247345, 0.04626360535621643, 0.41828545928001404, -0.9138285517692566, -0.3276890516281128, -0.060596857219934464, 0.8461120128631592, -0.3633989989757538, -0.07036367058753967, 0.40903380513191223, 0.053405605256557465, 0.6623530983924866, 0.1938226819038391, -0.6868080496788025, 0.4783041179180145, 0.31038227677345276, 0.5639706254005432, -0.0033735702745616436, -0.14526976644992828, -0.4967646598815918, -0.2690616846084595, -0.621833324432373, 0.807543158531189, -0.35518234968185425, -0.03978903219103813, 0.15436449646949768, 0.117189422249794, -0.14783693850040436, -0.5669933557510376, 0.8473029732704163, -1.0267927646636963, 0.4001586139202118, -0.723959743976593, -0.35795828700065613, -0.351749986410141, 0.11387014389038086, -0.8902742266654968, 1.170317530632019, 0.5537053346633911, -0.7220262289047241, 0.33652710914611816, -0.7612477540969849, -0.0010371888056397438, 0.15119856595993042, 0.13486184179782867, -0.11307847499847412, -0.3910442292690277, 0.37622562050819397, 0.007680393289774656, -0.3268943727016449, -0.18456906080245972, -0.021067533642053604, -0.5447869300842285, 0.11085742712020874, 0.03680804371833801, 1.016410231590271, 0.3884287476539612, -0.04545259848237038, -0.13337291777133942, -0.5568772554397583, 0.44528496265411377, -0.08802671730518341, -0.417851984500885, -0.037561818957328796, -0.1030246764421463, 0.10054837167263031, 0.44405677914619446, 0.010916011407971382, -1.0412564277648926, 0.17800898849964142, -0.39931514859199524, -0.03028404712677002, 0.39563438296318054, 0.19600330293178558, 0.2819112241268158, -0.3497253358364105, 0.8935559391975403, 0.11230850964784622, 0.31222566962242126, 0.14968855679035187, -0.6354268193244934, -0.5953311324119568, 0.07067675143480301, 0.5279313325881958, 0.6475306749343872, -1.136824131011963, 0.08647124469280243, -0.23530517518520355, -0.5191208124160767, -0.9381328821182251, 0.15411774814128876, 0.3733798563480377, 0.44246792793273926, 0.4658772945404053, 0.05462184175848961, 0.07363168895244598, -0.9152773022651672, -0.2581266164779663, -0.10913535952568054, -0.2607080340385437, 0.29429784417152405, 0.641164243221283, 0.5349032282829285, 0.649970293045044, -0.5888687968254089, -0.4723701477050781, -0.06674262136220932, -0.3123672306537628, 0.2813875377178192, 0.14258632063865662, 0.5693488121032715, -1.0872617959976196, -0.9666020274162292, 0.04980256035923958, -0.5545900464057922, 0.03047122061252594, 0.22628046572208405, -0.5300834774971008, 0.07792139053344727, 0.25435659289360046, -0.7730106711387634, 0.44934701919555664, 0.21491552889347076, -0.7829092741012573, 0.563888669013977, 0.09198589622974396, 0.6851905584335327, -1.0636452436447144, 0.24847131967544556, -0.4732288420200348, 0.27382251620292664, -0.776526927947998, 0.4533884525299072, 0.21773281693458557, 0.017921116203069687, -0.6784397959709167, 0.5434944033622742, -0.36465567350387573, -0.10970527678728104, 0.005355869419872761, 0.5242491960525513, 0.1503286063671112, 0.5496761798858643, -0.43091195821762085, 1.0914325714111328, 0.29400208592414856, -0.5903340578079224, 0.6871444582939148, 1.0070258378982544, -0.7675121426582336, 0.4091951847076416, -0.5353490114212036, 0.32907015085220337, -0.2641664445400238, 0.057629264891147614, -1.0402408838272095, -0.4055633246898651, 0.8059518337249756, -0.7569996118545532, -0.1401413530111313, -0.17277789115905762, -0.7000258564949036, -0.3634696900844574, -0.3407245874404907, 0.36740079522132874, 0.46839627623558044, -0.6336979866027832, 0.30680131912231445, 0.11822967976331711, -0.45865461230278015, -1.015873670578003, -0.4494742751121521, -0.14289897680282593, 0.031982749700546265, -0.7236304879188538, -0.018226226791739464, -0.17824065685272217, -0.1800864189863205, 0.3963588774204254, -0.21024587750434875, -0.4539252817630768, -0.035495273768901825, -0.06529822200536728, 0.27506309747695923, -0.6418295502662659, 0.3576124310493469, 0.0887182354927063, 0.22014060616493225, 0.07495445013046265, -0.2846086323261261, 0.35980960726737976, 0.05379046872258186, -0.37874796986579895, -0.1661631464958191, 0.6389830708503723, 0.35632288455963135, -0.404390424489975, 1.0595227479934692, 0.49136826395988464, -0.3514678478240967, -0.03551832586526871, -0.03272390365600586, 0.22012898325920105, -0.42190203070640564, 0.2850853502750397, -0.31898561120033264, -0.7129501700401306, 0.7577254772186279, 0.7138689160346985, 0.2860278785228729, 0.624950110912323, 0.3640613555908203, -0.2042865753173828, 0.8697004318237305, 0.15253062546253204, -0.013226771727204323, 0.053080964833498, -0.11296500265598297, 0.22513283789157867, -0.7779200673103333, -0.4771853983402252, -0.7834163308143616, -0.13638311624526978, -0.33597710728645325, -0.245321124792099, 0.3151131272315979, 0.17882680892944336, -0.23864369094371796, -0.13567522168159485, -0.2043697088956833, 0.748108983039856, 0.6863887906074524, 0.3192538321018219, 0.3869626820087433, -0.07523726671934128, 0.15012799203395844, 0.24742314219474792, -0.5947476029396057, -0.7318212389945984, 1.368040919303894, -0.14782321453094482, 0.37928497791290283, 0.5007253885269165, 0.264456570148468, 0.4898607134819031, 0.16302229464054108, -0.6674968600273132, 0.3510385751724243, 0.02135101705789566, -0.9588618278503418, -0.5929222106933594, -0.41944193840026855, -1.0687381029129028, 0.22227372229099274, -0.18901613354682922, -0.7265500426292419, 0.11453412473201752, -0.025639748200774193, -0.6828401684761047, 0.3829626142978668, -0.4254598617553711, 1.0610703229904175, 0.40636390447616577, 0.017978515475988388, 0.22060222923755646, -0.7457783818244934, 0.5413414835929871, -0.012741620652377605, -0.14051783084869385, -0.103028304874897, -0.04899857938289642, 0.82591712474823, -0.3777537941932678, 0.057495810091495514, -0.33973318338394165, 0.044871892780065536, 0.7250222563743591, -0.13153253495693207, -0.08998588472604752, -0.033345237374305725, -0.12164274603128433, -0.26323211193084717, 0.76563560962677, -1.0633213520050049, -0.867763340473175, 0.34320932626724243, -0.9836155772209167, -0.3331568241119385, -0.4325887858867645, -0.5698049068450928, -0.42525514960289, 0.22298245131969452, 0.24741210043430328, 0.7370551228523254, -0.2692558169364929, 0.33483535051345825, 0.7877551913261414, -0.42314374446868896, -0.1591576486825943, 0.4369824528694153, -0.19188585877418518, -0.4098036587238312, 0.681688666343689, 0.20532317459583282, 0.4686937630176544, 0.22745861113071442, -0.15119004249572754, -0.4490208029747009, -0.6067373752593994, -0.9103458523750305, 0.18416768312454224, -1.0215954780578613, -0.3107694387435913, -0.48608002066612244, -0.4946940243244171, -0.4976550042629242, 0.4010852873325348, 0.06138206645846367, -0.45869702100753784, -0.11299546808004379, -0.11376717686653137, 0.42753931879997253, 0.810063362121582, 0.2557324767112732, 0.3054858148097992, -0.8944650292396545, 0.6799487471580505, 0.14824511110782623, 0.4968889355659485, -0.20601418614387512, -0.700229287147522, -0.46242156624794006, 0.3707106411457062, -0.32608315348625183, -1.0287984609603882, 0.2316480278968811, 0.2556695342063904, 0.46291616559028625, 0.14004236459732056, 0.9027330279350281, 0.2494279146194458, -0.0955037921667099, 1.058622121810913, -0.5609967708587646, -0.45721930265426636, 0.23539835214614868, -0.5194190740585327, 0.5049986243247986, 0.9132062792778015, 0.7779859304428101, -0.7391656041145325, -0.3074410557746887, -0.27554062008857727, -0.5832144618034363, 0.9038996696472168, 0.4428310692310333, 0.007025042548775673, -0.044113095849752426, 0.6160502433776855, 0.2739977240562439, 0.09454172849655151, -0.1581985354423523, -0.539574921131134, -0.11909971386194229, -0.5326091647148132, -0.0854213610291481, -0.17232315242290497, 0.0946633517742157, -0.03825411945581436, 0.8682133555412292, -0.09684353321790695, 0.38159406185150146, 0.4826641380786896, -0.19453342258930206, -0.1632649004459381, 0.3431614935398102, 0.413860946893692, 0.7268883585929871, -0.3668200373649597, -0.291898250579834, -0.09558890014886856, -1.0596688985824585, 0.12244634330272675, 0.11107116937637329, -0.49514979124069214, -0.04831186681985855, -0.06919537484645844, 0.34043917059898376, -0.4834858179092407, -0.8788594007492065, 0.48095086216926575, -0.19654077291488647, -0.6270299553871155, -0.30365753173828125, 0.055912189185619354, -0.06470408290624619, 0.354423463344574, 0.7282174825668335, -0.4145335555076599, 0.34280258417129517, -0.4482012093067169, 0.2613537013530731, 0.097171850502491, -0.4153223931789398, -0.16397318243980408, 0.399605393409729, -0.10334626585245132, -0.2540917992591858, 0.9762330651283264, -0.1986120492219925, -0.5245446562767029, 0.6857898235321045, -0.008966448716819286, 0.40446698665618896, -0.032609257847070694, 0.6006189584732056, 0.46625256538391113, 0.294727087020874, 0.07418836653232574, 1.109563946723938, -0.14275355637073517, -0.6548811197280884, -0.2420467585325241, -0.38080692291259766, -0.6036114692687988, 0.30738529562950134, -1.1769782304763794, -0.025621941313147545, -0.25426214933395386, 0.0777377262711525, -0.11042428761720657, 0.60610431432724, -0.5373192429542542, 0.32591503858566284, -0.169778510928154, 1.2385649681091309, -0.7886072993278503, 0.5432454943656921, 0.7265888452529907, -0.5227841734886169, -0.5822915434837341, 0.12954235076904297, -0.30922719836235046, -0.19446855783462524, 0.27471989393234253, -0.0893213227391243, 0.21636098623275757, 0.12471253424882889, -0.6140460968017578, -0.8646409511566162, 1.0389903783798218, 0.19297412037849426, 0.2601190209388733, 0.11770404130220413, 0.3702605962753296, 0.3823257088661194, -0.05518139898777008, 0.000981605495326221, 0.702896773815155, 0.37180984020233154, -0.0668463408946991, -0.8250495791435242, -0.13496245443820953, -0.613131582736969, -0.686798095703125, 0.43920642137527466, -0.6606442332267761, 0.7299291491508484, -0.3090478181838989, -0.4552272856235504, 0.655120849609375, 0.5802422165870667, 0.10589752346277237, 0.4618300497531891, 0.17889384925365448, 0.2228918969631195, 0.7501165270805359, -0.11207447201013565, 0.8793704509735107, -0.10062973946332932, 0.15743719041347504, 1.0630613565444946, -0.01445192564278841, 0.9680158495903015, 0.29279014468193054, -0.24378657341003418, 0.351509690284729, 0.8689654469490051, 0.15145190060138702, 0.7070701718330383, 0.06511092931032181, -0.48534896969795227, -0.2771318554878235, -0.12540312111377716, -0.41231632232666016, 0.320492684841156, 0.023807384073734283, -0.041021499782800674, -0.2919646203517914, 0.048781055957078934, -0.31190454959869385, 0.21365444362163544, -0.21814969182014465, 0.4019537568092346, -0.18252143263816833, -0.5855804085731506, 0.4241099953651428, -0.06937652826309204, -0.1267973929643631, -0.4899226427078247, -0.13153740763664246, -0.3370784819126129, -0.031056411564350128, 0.017234008759260178, -1.0476332902908325, 0.20093590021133423, -0.12956702709197998, -0.06952027976512909, 0.26345184445381165, 0.39983993768692017, -0.5074124932289124, -0.45990681648254395, -0.19737151265144348, 0.7626933455467224, 0.3426208198070526, -0.13542938232421875, -0.3792972266674042, -0.35570940375328064, -0.22667817771434784, -0.36091068387031555, 0.4228806793689728, 0.619022011756897, 0.058103643357753754, 0.7873472571372986, 0.3796370327472687, 0.03193008899688721, 0.27213919162750244, -0.19144152104854584, 0.9560385346412659, -0.7122041583061218, -0.42421889305114746, -0.26373711228370667, 0.31552907824516296, 0.12299846857786179, -0.5465388298034668, 0.7952337265014648, 0.49831682443618774, 0.9671989679336548, -0.1993066370487213, 0.6780789494514465, 0.030202943831682205, 0.7266415953636169, -0.6372561454772949, 0.9121012687683105, -0.4598120450973511, -0.2791542708873749, -0.18582600355148315, -0.7999195456504822, -0.19444604218006134, 0.38224494457244873, -0.07919573038816452, 0.0244827289134264, 0.5240606665611267, 0.5701540112495422, 0.06752265989780426, 0.30077069997787476, 0.353439062833786, 0.002919828286394477, -0.05511441081762314, 0.7718384861946106, 0.9737431406974792, -0.9893589615821838, 0.8613301515579224, -0.26389503479003906, 0.16279035806655884, 0.06244806572794914, -0.1859520822763443, -0.8944838643074036, -0.8987694382667542, -0.20095212757587433, -0.4593600034713745, 0.24149230122566223, 0.9194460511207581, 0.2651596665382385, -0.8658007979393005, 0.003163901623338461, 0.5417971014976501, 0.10182717442512512, -0.26366010308265686, -0.20371189713478088, 0.6032673120498657, -0.025505932047963142, -0.40446028113365173, 0.025184422731399536, -0.1381571739912033, -0.08121486753225327, -0.10284703969955444, -0.14228881895542145, -0.32914572954177856, 0.13249169290065765, 0.35635384917259216, 0.5174108743667603, -0.588641345500946, -0.358308881521225, 0.5905190706253052, -0.06581788510084152, 0.18216711282730103, 0.43621090054512024, -0.7584602236747742, 0.35756444931030273, 0.5912978649139404, 0.5904643535614014, 0.2393292486667633, 0.3601824939250946, 0.4749206602573395, -0.25137728452682495, -0.3057299554347992, 0.3720303475856781, -0.17435307800769806, 0.17460228502750397, -0.2884616553783417, 0.3676391541957855, -0.11417420208454132, -0.48865169286727905, -0.941236138343811, 0.06604323536157608, -0.8564413785934448, -0.12440617382526398, 0.9913943409919739, -0.3930366635322571, -0.3923352062702179, -0.7032416462898254, -0.25933313369750977, 0.15035556256771088, -0.2710742652416229, 0.8004659414291382, 0.8729549050331116, 0.07437753677368164, -0.28756675124168396, -1.0732641220092773, 0.589664876461029, 0.12480728328227997, -0.7747594118118286, 0.2796294689178467, 0.5633813738822937, 0.2713758051395416, -0.23897384107112885, 0.8022239208221436, -0.31680890917778015, 0.8122966289520264, 0.07532639801502228, 0.04533969610929489, -0.17251963913440704, -0.39450857043266296, -0.28318560123443604, 0.10521558672189713, 0.08247390389442444, -0.4796792268753052 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04475v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04475v1
Length-Controlled AlpacaEval: A Simple Way to Debias Automatic Evaluators
2024-04-06T02:29:02
2024-04-06T02:29:02
Yann Dubois, Balázs Galambosi, Percy Liang, Tatsunori B. Hashimoto
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
LLM-based auto-annotators have become a key component of the LLM development process due to their cost-effectiveness and scalability compared to human-based evaluation. However, these auto-annotators can introduce complex biases that are hard to remove. Even simple, known confounders such as preference for longer outputs remain in existing automated evaluation metrics. We propose a simple regression analysis approach for controlling biases in auto-evaluations. As a real case study, we focus on reducing the length bias of AlpacaEval, a fast and affordable benchmark for chat LLMs that uses LLMs to estimate response quality. Despite being highly correlated with human preferences, AlpacaEval is known to favor models that generate longer outputs. We introduce a length-controlled AlpacaEval that aims to answer the counterfactual question: "What would the preference be if the model's and baseline's output had the same length?". To achieve this, we first fit a generalized linear model to predict the biased output of interest (auto-annotator preferences) based on the mediators we want to control for (length difference) and other relevant features. We then obtain length-controlled preferences by predicting preferences while conditioning the GLM with a zero difference in lengths. Length-controlling not only improves the robustness of the metric to manipulations in model verbosity, we also find that it increases the Spearman correlation with LMSYS' Chatbot Arena from 0.94 to 0.98. We release the code and leaderboard at https://tatsu-lab.github.io/alpaca_eval/ .
[ -0.787851095199585, -0.9651461839675903, 0.44744497537612915, 0.19573388993740082, -0.45939022302627563, 0.052909303456544876, -0.24812977015972137, -0.6334620714187622, 0.5520870685577393, 0.36832061409950256, -0.45378944277763367, -0.27528509497642517, -0.894161581993103, 0.04109214246273041, -0.29467251896858215, 1.1046888828277588, -0.2064896523952484, -0.28208258748054504, -0.14488065242767334, -0.40167224407196045, -0.48045814037323, -0.3192701041698456, -0.7716330885887146, -0.33481279015541077, 0.7499534487724304, 0.18293221294879913, 1.2727935314178467, 0.9301139712333679, 0.5395155549049377, 0.1627788543701172, 0.11600618064403534, 0.3708154261112213, -0.25902023911476135, 0.0625792071223259, 0.24855078756809235, -0.23833505809307098, -0.648155927658081, 0.28454622626304626, 0.3271264135837555, 0.4302351772785187, 0.009266623295843601, 0.49074047803878784, 0.24730642139911652, 0.7543554902076721, -0.749724268913269, 0.28391551971435547, -0.4323219656944275, 0.0143671790137887, -0.013800352811813354, -0.3500654697418213, -0.20268887281417847, -0.3930031955242157, 0.042354878038167953, -0.4132935404777527, -0.15405532717704773, 0.007292929105460644, 0.8530518412590027, 0.9298211932182312, -0.3044210374355316, -0.5076479315757751, -0.8847324252128601, 0.9203545451164246, -0.6476865410804749, 0.37605714797973633, 0.6022957563400269, 0.3881569504737854, 0.08324332535266876, -0.16993610560894012, -0.13746728003025055, -0.5346789360046387, -0.3285277783870697, -0.006532909348607063, -0.32788416743278503, 0.019865408539772034, 0.048280179500579834, 0.04242146015167236, -0.567814826965332, 0.43143242597579956, -0.4713049530982971, -0.39210158586502075, 0.9812127947807312, 0.34274452924728394, -0.000886838068254292, -0.14938072860240936, -0.2529882490634918, 0.12231086939573288, -0.6075009703636169, 0.03497571498155594, 0.5484983921051025, 0.06290262937545776, -0.057228829711675644, 0.5718730688095093, -0.31085580587387085, 0.6622205972671509, 0.1461750566959381, -0.08514506369829178, 0.037191011011600494, 0.13291361927986145, -0.285506933927536, -0.13302581012248993, 0.8586835265159607, 0.4387523829936981, 0.1799931526184082, -0.000496407097671181, -0.1974157840013504, 0.337297260761261, 0.13481846451759338, -0.7145758867263794, 0.028247227892279625, 0.3564504086971283, -0.5563515424728394, -0.3274495601654053, -0.35650789737701416, -0.7106186151504517, -0.345080703496933, -0.4685213565826416, 0.6138529181480408, -0.10092628002166748, 0.39013245701789856, 0.08119048178195953, 0.2923140525817871, 0.0676756203174591, 0.37079083919525146, -0.7340744137763977, 0.5238267779350281, 0.39888665080070496, 0.7390871047973633, -0.46367356181144714, -0.20595945417881012, -0.8171299695968628, -0.23409074544906616, -0.4323212206363678, 0.4781321585178375, -0.38621950149536133, -0.48148980736732483, -0.12778477370738983, -0.34524235129356384, 0.2967216968536377, -0.21051128208637238, 0.27300041913986206, -0.49962684512138367, 0.502260148525238, 0.06901402771472931, -0.5517004132270813, 0.20418404042720795, 0.03790342062711716, -0.5772930979728699, 0.7733936309814453, -0.017646076157689095, -0.5662264227867126, 0.6211369037628174, -0.8172476887702942, -0.07981504499912262, -0.28397032618522644, -0.24343903362751007, -0.5289238691329956, -0.1450008600950241, 0.5010861158370972, 0.09098596125841141, -0.40412551164627075, 0.2834168076515198, -0.30403128266334534, -0.5337519645690918, 0.2609337866306305, -0.6842491030693054, 0.5259760022163391, 0.43630847334861755, -0.4970511198043823, 0.3564148247241974, -0.6744977831840515, 0.021767130121588707, -0.12295404821634293, -0.30450209975242615, -0.20522834360599518, 0.0822036936879158, -0.5152580142021179, -0.0671745166182518, 0.34814590215682983, -0.4282756745815277, 0.23630291223526, -0.13058766722679138, 0.07443834841251373, 0.7482972145080566, 0.023350415751338005, 0.649357795715332, -0.3260016441345215, 0.5714605450630188, -0.36823514103889465, 0.8621407151222229, 0.18472450971603394, -0.1399163007736206, -1.1645985841751099, -0.6010115742683411, 0.39564016461372375, 0.27914801239967346, -0.5217879414558411, 0.599897563457489, 0.11807337403297424, -0.48206591606140137, -0.8439299464225769, 0.49946272373199463, 0.32150202989578247, 0.2716338336467743, 0.5465389490127563, -0.5719627737998962, -0.4445697069168091, -1.1793441772460938, -0.18683628737926483, -0.42184019088745117, -0.22573809325695038, 0.3795696794986725, 0.20886023342609406, -0.3817022442817688, 1.284441351890564, -0.724251925945282, -0.4357828199863434, -0.04307983070611954, 0.20760323107242584, 0.2028064876794815, 0.2647300064563751, 0.7117004990577698, -0.23940345644950867, -0.28228938579559326, -0.6685237288475037, -0.5543184280395508, -0.6153409481048584, -0.12765590846538544, -0.2378462851047516, 0.27221786975860596, 0.13835200667381287, -0.7054827809333801, 0.8652673363685608, 0.30506956577301025, -0.28902480006217957, 0.45706477761268616, -0.20817193388938904, 0.018915340304374695, -0.20255045592784882, -0.21514980494976044, 0.0433897003531456, -0.253069669008255, -0.16059502959251404, -0.24183876812458038, 0.012597380205988884, 0.3728368580341339, -0.3930853009223938, 0.6891730427742004, -0.22958680987358093, -0.18843398988246918, -0.6127586960792542, 0.06976725161075592, 0.27853167057037354, 0.49978235363960266, -0.15851520001888275, 0.6420721411705017, 0.06888250261545181, -0.7008645534515381, 0.5122925043106079, 0.1581226885318756, -0.06994698196649551, 0.22034034132957458, -0.7904729247093201, 0.20579980313777924, -0.060479938983917236, 0.40906333923339844, -0.7548279762268066, -0.025555603206157684, 0.4179818034172058, -0.523395836353302, 0.034486740827560425, -0.1040697917342186, -0.21289245784282684, -0.507792592048645, -0.4001302719116211, -0.03937150537967682, 0.7211748361587524, -0.6032344698905945, 0.4504830241203308, 0.19880178570747375, -0.06215152516961098, -0.6676720380783081, -0.564258337020874, -0.10450044274330139, -0.6077910661697388, -0.3088817894458771, -0.03687481954693794, -0.47511205077171326, -0.46475812792778015, -0.21604248881340027, -0.020147673785686493, 0.03372585400938988, 0.1563827246427536, 0.4231487810611725, 0.473907470703125, 0.25172463059425354, 0.2194354385137558, 0.20774509012699127, -0.22934623062610626, 0.19055306911468506, 0.04071670025587082, 0.5294142365455627, -0.20722509920597076, -0.4923270344734192, -0.37079334259033203, 0.09674657881259918, 0.45327985286712646, -0.17998456954956055, 0.3104677200317383, 0.5741935968399048, 0.011343086138367653, -0.09417574107646942, -0.8085076212882996, -0.2756468951702118, -0.4312777519226074, 0.22105339169502258, -0.10467439144849777, -0.8280712962150574, 0.5200681686401367, 0.44457054138183594, 0.1350308209657669, 0.4715127646923065, 0.6475532650947571, 0.04062840715050697, 1.0960427522659302, 0.6385575532913208, -0.3216216266155243, 0.23071621358394623, -0.23657935857772827, -0.002987092128023505, -0.6575442552566528, 0.0771820992231369, -0.26675382256507874, -0.35843732953071594, -0.3694250285625458, -0.42336684465408325, 0.35077181458473206, -0.04451761767268181, -0.26735249161720276, 0.19298946857452393, -0.5134556889533997, 0.39951568841934204, 0.3043781816959381, -0.018245268613100052, 0.2854917347431183, -0.4298015832901001, 0.24459299445152283, -0.06630763411521912, -0.3672744631767273, -0.5931456685066223, 1.0036216974258423, 0.8062908053398132, 1.0851597785949707, 0.0370195209980011, 0.8024032711982727, 0.7773897647857666, 0.5242390036582947, -1.0075052976608276, 0.3959370255470276, 0.22070007026195526, -0.4467453360557556, -0.5770938992500305, -0.3553255796432495, -0.7993432283401489, 0.24011915922164917, 0.14194396138191223, -0.6529333591461182, 0.26376017928123474, 0.34117555618286133, -0.6595278382301331, 0.011499281972646713, -0.383949339389801, 0.30118370056152344, -0.6435256600379944, -0.6058233380317688, -0.14581823348999023, -0.4919016361236572, 0.11065709590911865, -0.2598566710948944, 0.2538389563560486, -0.5164966583251953, -0.14736559987068176, 0.8434404730796814, -0.4699885845184326, 0.8524240255355835, -0.0789332166314125, -0.07581868767738342, 0.5629079937934875, 0.3565407991409302, 0.3795076608657837, 0.35215479135513306, -0.049764543771743774, 0.08448483049869537, -0.1138700544834137, -0.2543144226074219, -0.6232314109802246, 0.6662193536758423, -0.9068323373794556, -0.8448999524116516, -0.2985815703868866, -0.47646576166152954, -0.3123033046722412, -0.15929760038852692, 0.0876193717122078, 0.0856190025806427, -0.2747507691383362, -0.03168529272079468, 0.1451134830713272, -0.22512343525886536, 0.7085974216461182, 0.6176314949989319, -0.5960132479667664, -0.45263320207595825, 0.3330419957637787, 0.14620980620384216, 0.18606629967689514, -0.11253442615270615, 0.3677331805229187, -0.2983182668685913, -0.06157177314162254, -0.6635328531265259, 0.021904245018959045, -0.5776472687721252, -0.39632952213287354, -0.4334627687931061, -0.1363590657711029, -0.0901503786444664, -0.1404247134923935, -0.5600143671035767, -0.44341373443603516, -0.4052344262599945, -0.2653708755970001, 0.5139669179916382, 0.6905374526977539, -0.26593586802482605, 0.44287195801734924, -0.4986630082130432, 0.21468351781368256, 0.5442635416984558, 0.39140018820762634, -0.18160419166088104, -0.7247183322906494, -0.27258288860321045, 0.04278983920812607, -0.27234163880348206, -0.7018308639526367, 0.7425047159194946, 0.13990232348442078, 0.35081449151039124, 0.42474594712257385, 0.016500959172844887, 0.6251534819602966, -0.2045133411884308, 0.6852107048034668, 0.12389317154884338, -1.034079909324646, 0.6107138991355896, -0.09411519020795822, 0.21511250734329224, 0.5029288530349731, 0.4791755676269531, -0.3127177953720093, -0.406099796295166, -0.5996686220169067, -0.767497181892395, 0.27323266863822937, 0.3549029529094696, 0.11380703747272491, -0.04105982184410095, 0.36429041624069214, 0.37953633069992065, 0.1711190640926361, -0.4266570508480072, -0.22773951292037964, -0.2333272397518158, 0.015023918822407722, 0.025962091982364655, -0.49548202753067017, -0.33239609003067017, -0.165157750248909, 0.5812759399414062, -0.22586701810359955, 0.019158361479640007, 0.31266912817955017, -0.2591181993484497, -0.25846636295318604, 0.39238834381103516, 0.24698665738105774, 1.0675439834594727, -0.5412865877151489, 0.1508776843547821, 0.41870811581611633, -0.1327061504125595, 0.17761380970478058, 0.10610414296388626, -0.23715899884700775, 0.16606125235557556, 0.21005688607692719, 0.962375283241272, -0.39601558446884155, -0.3804396390914917, 0.39638981223106384, -0.05786261335015297, 0.043982554227113724, -0.37694108486175537, 0.062206070870161057, -0.24393118917942047, 0.1121806651353836, 0.3649260103702545, -0.2966047525405884, 0.20866799354553223, -0.20867079496383667, 0.26367875933647156, 0.3602639436721802, -0.6561213135719299, -0.06291159242391586, 0.743367075920105, 0.3324488699436188, -0.18254774808883667, 0.2623024582862854, -0.09561354666948318, -0.23903818428516388, 0.779720664024353, 0.03745892643928528, 0.7978172898292542, -0.1571139693260193, 0.09820535778999329, 0.1567295789718628, 0.3324182331562042, 0.2840539813041687, -0.03785649314522743, 0.026739126071333885, -0.5224252939224243, -0.4921538829803467, -0.7837571501731873, -0.49298036098480225, 0.21840128302574158, -0.7567096948623657, 0.3394002616405487, -0.4756467640399933, -0.6528644561767578, -0.0683208703994751, 0.23499590158462524, -0.8131269812583923, 0.3719661235809326, 0.23806911706924438, 0.8616980314254761, -0.8752807378768921, 0.8210256695747375, -0.07549682259559631, -0.4804552495479584, -0.49797898530960083, -0.3770434260368347, 0.12922564148902893, -0.6980961561203003, 0.6994274258613586, -0.0756126195192337, -0.19104045629501343, -0.5404386520385742, -0.572009265422821, -0.9998393058776855, 1.037664532661438, 0.060593243688344955, -0.6625738143920898, 0.14010924100875854, 0.3065364360809326, 0.6584838032722473, -0.5803699493408203, 0.609524667263031, 1.0001790523529053, 0.4270022511482239, -0.26222240924835205, -1.1549471616744995, -0.20545706152915955, 0.07041433453559875, 0.05993437394499779, 0.10658076405525208, -1.0133628845214844, 0.5018374919891357, -0.13542532920837402, 0.3699582517147064, 0.07572523504495621, 0.8721709847450256, 0.14339594542980194, 0.286094069480896, 0.6336203217506409, 0.23976144194602966, 0.49948614835739136, 0.07379011064767838, 0.8319679498672485, -0.3976457715034485, 0.5511137843132019, 1.454382300376892, -0.24595360457897186, 0.5098430514335632, 0.5614831447601318, -0.14893661439418793, 0.2946763336658478, 0.632151186466217, -0.04285623878240585, 0.37292957305908203, 0.45460882782936096, 0.06429518759250641, -0.21495269238948822, -0.07599005848169327, -0.15316241979599, 0.779891848564148, 0.3153798580169678, -0.5045072436332703, 0.007763546425849199, 0.06617382168769836, 0.35526812076568604, -0.11284876614809036, -0.0493021085858345, 0.6222124695777893, 0.10025829076766968, -0.6056833863258362, 0.5823171734809875, -0.16572731733322144, 0.8380503058433533, -0.6516169905662537, 0.21307356655597687, -0.5681507587432861, 0.09968823194503784, -0.05731534585356712, -0.6256186962127686, 0.4226264953613281, 0.18972790241241455, 0.0615849569439888, -0.02291078492999077, 0.7311158776283264, -0.22961747646331787, -0.2487782984972, 0.5878853797912598, 0.6756742000579834, 0.02575608901679516, 0.219432070851326, -0.6141232848167419, 0.48555150628089905, -0.08730442076921463, -0.5114767551422119, 0.13732600212097168, -0.2098722755908966, -0.3157939016819, 0.8529502749443054, 0.5028637051582336, 0.20038728415966034, -0.14209367334842682, 0.05867564678192139, 0.8751794099807739, -0.44570884108543396, -0.24826380610466003, -1.1076935529708862, 0.11017058044672012, 0.0049635847099125385, -0.27681204676628113, 0.624169111251831, 0.5189447402954102, 0.5065434575080872, 0.10600416362285614, 0.7428842782974243, -0.0066163139417767525, 0.47822675108909607, -0.25778600573539734, 0.7453899383544922, -0.44070297479629517, 0.42511388659477234, -0.027188457548618317, -0.9647935032844543, -0.17249169945716858, 0.3525371253490448, -0.5333487391471863, -0.08520188182592392, 0.3373328745365143, 0.5321051478385925, 0.1988028734922409, -0.4090864956378937, 0.3033987283706665, 0.058012764900922775, 0.6354285478591919, 0.37804198265075684, 0.8909340500831604, -0.16744084656238556, 0.6137705445289612, -0.48742759227752686, -0.3891587257385254, -0.2642817795276642, -0.9375342726707458, -0.7660506367683411, -0.08592338860034943, -0.4716135859489441, -0.349359393119812, 0.26383182406425476, 1.1209867000579834, 0.5590324401855469, -0.5198583602905273, -0.4384572207927704, 0.4791015684604645, -0.1435248851776123, 0.1367645263671875, -0.20602639019489288, 0.5109843015670776, -0.3695918321609497, -0.6531421542167664, 0.17316295206546783, 0.3140462636947632, -0.03218231350183487, -0.5991487503051758, -0.24040986597537994, 0.20393599569797516, 0.5737284421920776, 0.4288625717163086, 0.279864639043808, -0.8490936756134033, -0.5865525603294373, -0.22531168162822723, -0.2548576891422272, 0.18810081481933594, 0.400335431098938, -1.0043543577194214, 0.4657703638076782, 0.30509594082832336, 0.2588980495929718, 0.49977537989616394, 0.03619719669222832, 0.4621056020259857, -0.5615954995155334, 0.29157423973083496, 0.22248288989067078, 0.4862672984600067, 0.2465815544128418, -0.5073193311691284, 0.7239031195640564, -0.32855454087257385, -0.7201991081237793, -0.4697738289833069, 0.15952521562576294, -0.7440792322158813, -0.0896536335349083, 1.2177830934524536, -0.04705308377742767, -0.25031155347824097, 0.28728485107421875, -0.41977331042289734, 0.3865449130535126, -0.44236114621162415, 1.3101950883865356, 0.47519388794898987, -0.49892255663871765, 0.06304162740707397, -0.43404656648635864, 0.7057773470878601, 0.6457177400588989, -0.7626714110374451, 0.005369395483285189, 0.6509262919425964, 0.27787938714027405, 0.2979280650615692, 0.6386600732803345, -0.08456544578075409, 0.18955852091312408, -0.5019399523735046, 0.19208914041519165, -0.13546286523342133, -0.3928975462913513, -0.35626906156539917, -0.2918144762516022, 0.28104138374328613, -0.23595748841762543 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04445v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04445v1
Towards Realistic Few-Shot Relation Extraction: A New Meta Dataset and Evaluation
2024-04-05T23:12:46
2024-04-05T23:12:46
Fahmida Alam, Md Asiful Islam, Robert Vacareanu, Mihai Surdeanu
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.IR
We introduce a meta dataset for few-shot relation extraction, which includes two datasets derived from existing supervised relation extraction datasets NYT29 (Takanobu et al., 2019; Nayak and Ng, 2020) and WIKIDATA (Sorokin and Gurevych, 2017) as well as a few-shot form of the TACRED dataset (Sabo et al., 2021). Importantly, all these few-shot datasets were generated under realistic assumptions such as: the test relations are different from any relations a model might have seen before, limited training data, and a preponderance of candidate relation mentions that do not correspond to any of the relations of interest. Using this large resource, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of six recent few-shot relation extraction methods, and observe that no method comes out as a clear winner. Further, the overall performance on this task is low, indicating substantial need for future research. We release all versions of the data, i.e., both supervised and few-shot, for future research.
[ -0.46918609738349915, -0.6650036573410034, 0.5859529376029968, -0.2005700021982193, -0.24882741272449493, -0.47553750872612, 0.0036544508766382933, -0.5628176927566528, 0.16663025319576263, 0.36349770426750183, -0.8747187852859497, -0.5427303314208984, -0.5733555555343628, 0.3848035931587219, -0.16799162328243256, 0.9950119853019714, 0.4063010811805725, -0.036706916987895966, -0.17234058678150177, -0.3330255448818207, -0.16393744945526123, -0.07647080719470978, -0.23342497646808624, -0.2773698568344116, 0.8434474468231201, 0.555586040019989, 0.5648080110549927, 0.5116457939147949, 0.8956747651100159, 0.08173124492168427, 0.06277045607566833, 0.0536334402859211, -0.7477236986160278, -0.21804599463939667, -0.08450236171483994, -0.20753173530101776, -0.4683678150177002, 0.3280733525753021, 0.47613725066185, 0.6065008640289307, 0.16255053877830505, 0.6047757863998413, -0.13343654572963715, 0.3803507685661316, -1.2888391017913818, 0.24710994958877563, -0.7449052929878235, 0.22338856756687164, -0.6882854700088501, -0.00898798182606697, -0.4346689283847809, -0.15467633306980133, 0.24993331730365753, -0.6420660018920898, -0.002150176092982292, -0.14200082421302795, 1.1420059204101562, 0.005345895420759916, -0.5701688528060913, -0.004626243840903044, -0.7294646501541138, 0.4850228428840637, -0.6146619319915771, 0.1398249864578247, 0.5192631483078003, 0.8768943548202515, -0.15719309449195862, -0.9913839101791382, -0.4477732181549072, -0.04639162868261337, -0.20711539685726166, 0.2540963590145111, -0.29342103004455566, -0.07006260007619858, 0.44703009724617004, 0.1358066350221634, -0.38663291931152344, -0.12155807018280029, -0.3141104578971863, 0.06380192190408707, 0.7357527017593384, 0.4898655116558075, -0.11033591628074646, -0.5476720929145813, -0.2658464312553406, 0.15911206603050232, -0.7815181612968445, -0.1595136970281601, 0.1289815455675125, 0.4727875292301178, -0.11531465500593185, 0.7056713104248047, -0.1873999536037445, 0.6320547461509705, -0.1804143637418747, -0.5900052189826965, 0.011800223961472511, -0.5541637539863586, -0.11098188906908035, -0.3259054124355316, 1.263782024383545, 0.3417072594165802, 0.5804041028022766, -0.1147432029247284, 0.018220188096165657, 0.03145657852292061, -0.03352880850434303, -0.7688426375389099, -0.22544912993907928, -0.054918959736824036, -0.6942038536071777, -0.4833744764328003, 0.35306140780448914, -0.9133850336074829, -0.19893261790275574, 0.25294631719589233, 0.49228933453559875, -0.3068799674510956, -0.429016649723053, -0.46060073375701904, -0.323180228471756, 0.5483218431472778, 0.04418299347162247, -0.7719647884368896, 0.4758576452732086, 0.829587459564209, 0.7766168117523193, -0.15723519027233124, -0.29061198234558105, -0.4599354863166809, 0.21401527523994446, -0.4465233385562897, 0.8645089864730835, -0.7235445380210876, -0.2165834903717041, -0.14657343924045563, -0.2549384832382202, 0.09225558489561081, -0.4800902307033539, 0.438147634267807, -0.5917423963546753, 0.1735781729221344, -0.4644371271133423, -0.4803926348686218, 0.15017403662204742, 0.5526048541069031, -1.0254418849945068, 0.6974097490310669, 0.26260513067245483, -1.0334206819534302, 0.5089908838272095, -0.4511246681213379, -0.1391344964504242, -0.13412611186504364, -0.2845812737941742, -0.42526963353157043, -0.0435524508357048, 0.22075802087783813, 0.455587238073349, -0.4685260057449341, -0.19732186198234558, -0.8844907283782959, -0.30591821670532227, 0.15030395984649658, -0.2217610627412796, 0.8894979953765869, 0.2668658196926117, 0.0977993831038475, -0.5313894748687744, -0.8511457443237305, -0.04860445111989975, 0.1428457647562027, 0.15663735568523407, -0.11606476455926895, -0.39667221903800964, -0.07734226435422897, 0.5606526732444763, -0.020931454375386238, -0.6678714156150818, 0.4577752351760864, -0.26856285333633423, -0.08804856985807419, 0.3685796558856964, 0.6832491159439087, 0.4991878569126129, 0.07597146928310394, 0.8505476713180542, 0.08877785503864288, 0.24661506712436676, -0.27166953682899475, -0.2735556364059448, -0.37914085388183594, -0.2588464021682739, 0.7516897320747375, 0.3329189419746399, -0.7936067581176758, 0.037112534046173096, -0.5444016456604004, -0.49946483969688416, -0.3119838237762451, 0.08499285578727722, 0.49292993545532227, 0.7175110578536987, 0.13824069499969482, -0.16811643540859222, -0.6923651099205017, -0.9704300761222839, -0.4863419532775879, -0.2044326364994049, 0.014190672896802425, 0.29394885897636414, 0.7781375646591187, 0.10831161588430405, 1.5371454954147339, -0.8041272759437561, -0.5146192312240601, -0.3943275809288025, 0.14670851826667786, 0.292573481798172, 0.06744570285081863, 0.8620766401290894, -0.48552125692367554, -0.7659059166908264, -0.05983264371752739, -1.1484079360961914, 0.2696233093738556, 0.04630083590745926, -0.09441906958818436, -0.21366362273693085, 0.009550186805427074, -0.8273982405662537, 0.660810649394989, 0.1558748334646225, 0.07919133454561234, 0.5606288909912109, 0.6915236711502075, 0.008702822960913181, -0.8660218715667725, 0.1752087026834488, 0.10813475400209427, -0.4926571249961853, -0.4901292026042938, 0.05885256454348564, -0.05791591480374336, -0.12674835324287415, -0.8759616017341614, 0.7813547253608704, -0.28344473242759705, -0.29994332790374756, -0.18622685968875885, 0.11334177851676941, -0.14847183227539062, 0.27090394496917725, 0.012266864068806171, 0.3761880099773407, 0.40121015906333923, -0.46879687905311584, 0.38756808638572693, 0.46906614303588867, -0.11663442850112915, 0.38384079933166504, -0.4808509051799774, 0.1762336790561676, -0.041171152144670486, 0.39221495389938354, -0.724211573600769, -0.5025148391723633, 0.5157396197319031, -0.522011399269104, 0.12351058423519135, -0.6438996195793152, -0.5885978937149048, -0.22681710124015808, -0.5748559236526489, 0.17789365351200104, 0.3735318183898926, -0.37899255752563477, 0.3741703927516937, 0.1781562864780426, 0.04215826466679573, -0.7777778506278992, -0.5960536003112793, 0.06528184562921524, -0.29582247138023376, -0.41332703828811646, 0.07616465538740158, 0.40815040469169617, -0.4264802038669586, 0.36088812351226807, -0.22617629170417786, -0.6672574281692505, -0.04552660882472992, 0.09578445553779602, 0.24372327327728271, -0.12099111825227737, 0.10205058008432388, -0.3559783101081848, -0.43081042170524597, -0.00836954265832901, 0.36835968494415283, 0.05322413891553879, 0.17663736641407013, -0.03795181214809418, -0.46383705735206604, 0.06028389930725098, 0.08380241692066193, -0.06479361653327942, 0.7651486992835999, 0.873755156993866, -0.7265684008598328, 0.20870208740234375, -0.4029640555381775, -0.3246953785419464, -0.3043695092201233, 0.24062412977218628, -0.7878287434577942, -0.329437792301178, 0.418759822845459, -0.10329262912273407, 0.20927312970161438, 0.7180124521255493, 0.20531433820724487, -0.3913368880748749, 0.5536153316497803, 0.742216944694519, -0.04527603089809418, 0.34067150950431824, -0.6230549216270447, -0.15510843694210052, -0.6222453117370605, -0.20670360326766968, -0.39172059297561646, -0.3399171531200409, -0.7207915186882019, 0.25878891348838806, 0.46410366892814636, 0.087930828332901, 0.14339695870876312, 0.6961628794670105, 0.16000986099243164, 0.6679590344429016, 0.2544839680194855, 0.20273572206497192, 0.408846378326416, -0.26891374588012695, 0.28611305356025696, -0.4961684048175812, -0.9393214583396912, -0.7378906011581421, 1.4785019159317017, 0.0215909443795681, 0.5357649326324463, -0.005114671774208546, 1.1318007707595825, 0.020746255293488503, 0.5426000952720642, -0.8930175304412842, 0.3331252634525299, -0.046958860009908676, -1.0515810251235962, -0.29329729080200195, -0.6206175088882446, -1.1059924364089966, 0.17699341475963593, -0.6589905619621277, -0.6896476149559021, 0.21930141746997833, 0.026492031291127205, -0.6553332805633545, 0.024622565135359764, -0.4661673307418823, 0.8735045790672302, 0.011781823821365833, -0.6653516888618469, 0.09229359775781631, -1.0892904996871948, 1.018030047416687, -0.023755401372909546, 0.0554504320025444, -0.3281176686286926, -0.0626009851694107, 0.8566450476646423, -0.24671006202697754, 0.5871085524559021, -0.21409595012664795, 0.43628180027008057, 0.530323326587677, 0.21027220785617828, 0.2920093834400177, 0.11967544257640839, -0.3499956429004669, -0.016585785895586014, 0.5067351460456848, -0.4076412618160248, -0.7611523270606995, 0.2913146913051605, -0.35708799958229065, 0.05838582292199135, -0.6259737014770508, -0.19523467123508453, -0.21007734537124634, 0.3879010081291199, 0.634675145149231, 0.28461089730262756, -0.7663018703460693, 0.15131157636642456, 0.07689627259969711, 0.19825756549835205, 0.7310636639595032, 0.15843279659748077, -0.03611602261662483, -0.7220513820648193, 0.5289844870567322, 0.34847795963287354, 0.05216507986187935, 0.17565438151359558, 0.23616169393062592, -0.18017780780792236, -0.030139632523059845, -0.03955591470003128, 0.3573795557022095, -0.5122742652893066, -0.6228176951408386, -0.35954388976097107, -0.005968019831925631, -0.46845003962516785, 0.3450468182563782, -0.6497857570648193, -0.6210984587669373, -0.15989956259727478, -0.034028809517621994, 0.2837351858615875, 0.7998244166374207, -0.08454059809446335, 0.45988351106643677, -1.1437015533447266, 0.7437936663627625, 0.24345910549163818, -0.04767883941531181, -0.2522124648094177, -0.3087673485279083, -0.24279044568538666, -0.13657782971858978, -0.5858823657035828, -1.0931740999221802, 0.32249659299850464, 0.48006781935691833, 0.4222342371940613, 0.7757791876792908, 0.2605329751968384, 1.0004663467407227, -0.5006389021873474, 0.8043825626373291, 0.2521606981754303, -0.5630776882171631, 0.6354197859764099, -0.17781123518943787, 0.01264446135610342, 1.2551488876342773, 0.5742396712303162, 0.0036212122067809105, 0.3500199019908905, -1.2832562923431396, -0.22848346829414368, 0.7614315748214722, 0.4319729208946228, 0.009045558050274849, 0.047783128917217255, 0.7483909130096436, 0.08498841524124146, 0.257211834192276, -0.7109885811805725, -0.40317532420158386, 0.3103204667568207, -0.09148986637592316, 0.20499511063098907, -0.4235244691371918, -0.2998693883419037, -0.052568476647138596, 0.3401525318622589, -0.025593139231204987, 0.24652749300003052, -0.05618571862578392, -0.07970733195543289, -0.019713113084435463, 0.19217711687088013, 0.23565323650836945, 1.050882339477539, -0.5289289355278015, 0.17154379189014435, 0.3177383244037628, -0.17293012142181396, 0.11251793801784515, -0.0404202863574028, -0.04550236091017723, 0.24350206553936005, 1.079073190689087, 0.2916549742221832, 0.32004526257514954, -0.27091559767723083, 0.9512584209442139, 0.22591599822044373, -0.1350802630186081, -0.1900365948677063, -0.1773715317249298, -0.11671340465545654, 0.16918934881687164, 0.28263673186302185, -0.14230084419250488, 0.3146015703678131, -0.8435558080673218, 0.4354558289051056, 0.4771386981010437, -0.1756642609834671, -0.6020665168762207, 0.39010486006736755, 0.17515872418880463, -0.13169480860233307, 0.6437127590179443, -0.4774305522441864, -0.21520520746707916, 0.23121367394924164, 0.2905275821685791, 0.7747324705123901, 0.2919800281524658, 0.09700307995080948, 0.7753871083259583, 0.2573460638523102, 0.014490565285086632, -0.18384015560150146, -0.1260899156332016, -0.6082541346549988, -0.4007974863052368, -0.22397474944591522, -0.43054336309432983, 0.33137890696525574, -0.8072442412376404, 0.7896009087562561, -0.4185936152935028, -0.4429815113544464, -0.1440657675266266, 0.4405418932437897, -0.8826476335525513, 0.09191371500492096, -0.11398879438638687, 0.9298025369644165, -1.0496150255203247, 0.7020989656448364, 0.3913000226020813, -0.7084673643112183, -0.5388501882553101, 0.09066861867904663, 0.29901790618896484, -0.4106734097003937, 0.5663447976112366, -0.009390675462782383, 0.03850427642464638, -0.21862445771694183, -0.8168400526046753, -0.5706102252006531, 1.2130141258239746, 0.8106624484062195, -0.563663899898529, -0.1561340093612671, 0.03789006546139717, 0.3386038541793823, -0.43574321269989014, 0.35541704297065735, 0.8950555324554443, 0.4720868170261383, 0.2501932978630066, -0.7084349393844604, -0.32108762860298157, 0.010692698881030083, -0.30339470505714417, -0.1507503092288971, -0.6370635628700256, 0.387633353471756, -0.2925040125846863, -0.4010997414588928, 0.0954165905714035, 0.7627216577529907, 0.5193202495574951, 0.6335122585296631, 0.2987990379333496, 0.5293956995010376, 0.31221890449523926, -0.034152306616306305, 1.148555874824524, 0.0845932811498642, 0.5752708315849304, 1.5694928169250488, -0.3910595774650574, 0.9627428650856018, 0.5849581360816956, -0.5526506900787354, 0.1218317523598671, 0.8213721513748169, -0.05512460321187973, 0.6778121590614319, -0.47131508588790894, -0.08752348273992538, -0.43513038754463196, -0.07982528954744339, -0.2716541886329651, 0.7718420624732971, 0.04972211271524429, -0.29032227396965027, -0.5606939196586609, -0.35327932238578796, -0.04868290573358536, -0.12633676826953888, 0.23439955711364746, 1.121484398841858, 0.3972059190273285, -0.18777960538864136, 0.23797112703323364, -0.17774951457977295, 0.4397353231906891, -0.6786385178565979, -0.2646860182285309, -0.2229221910238266, -0.21859514713287354, -0.5672405362129211, -0.5236972570419312, 0.29168248176574707, 0.4133050739765167, -0.019207291305065155, 0.3295075297355652, 1.0019420385360718, -0.20469330251216888, -0.5748671293258667, -0.09212177246809006, 0.8110154867172241, 0.35990700125694275, 0.015679538249969482, -0.6382045149803162, -0.09320904314517975, -0.3726581335067749, -0.25300735235214233, 0.16398146748542786, 0.5642796158790588, 0.22321555018424988, 0.421637624502182, 0.4361100494861603, 0.3157961070537567, -0.054995112121105194, -0.16946807503700256, 0.7701427936553955, -0.6512389183044434, 0.10178689658641815, -1.0663301944732666, 0.5179299116134644, -0.16767509281635284, -0.5135396718978882, 0.776923656463623, 0.6146475672721863, 0.3438703715801239, -0.07412238419055939, 0.6183428764343262, -0.19395175576210022, 0.3572719693183899, -0.32940927147865295, 0.3029923737049103, -0.2730173170566559, 0.09331940859556198, -0.7010098695755005, -1.1887558698654175, -0.5025082230567932, 0.5017549395561218, -0.2225075513124466, 0.011384766548871994, 0.709406316280365, 0.5222322940826416, -0.46670645475387573, -0.33908936381340027, 0.4073796570301056, -0.130233496427536, 0.22021804749965668, 0.46233054995536804, 0.8098828792572021, -0.9059417843818665, 0.8883877396583557, -0.6323729753494263, 0.042664505541324615, -0.11933756619691849, -1.0942014455795288, -0.7662486433982849, -0.18496285378932953, -0.3483147919178009, -0.13002632558345795, -0.11465612053871155, 0.9814135432243347, 0.7998061776161194, -0.4389149844646454, 0.031130656599998474, 0.009448948316276073, 0.09120669960975647, -0.17294903099536896, -0.23030585050582886, 0.1893462985754013, -0.09165607392787933, -0.5818403363227844, 0.3223300576210022, 0.16715741157531738, -0.0029842958319932222, -0.05297252535820007, -0.1175614595413208, -0.36506861448287964, -0.4263971447944641, 0.7029438018798828, 0.3653859794139862, -0.46638795733451843, -0.19747863709926605, -0.047898199409246445, -0.060730092227458954, 0.141632542014122, 0.6578139066696167, -0.8445558547973633, 0.35069188475608826, 0.6036181449890137, 0.5012151002883911, 0.8454927802085876, 0.19102811813354492, 0.41075995564460754, -1.11085844039917, 0.1424645036458969, 0.3076205253601074, 0.04203183203935623, 0.11692897230386734, -0.057102229446172714, 1.1106334924697876, 0.3219270706176758, -0.06274870783090591, -1.0242929458618164, 0.1267354041337967, -0.9335432052612305, 0.20307765901088715, 1.1244006156921387, -0.4018281102180481, -0.12616074085235596, 0.1952684372663498, 0.20853768289089203, 0.3213618993759155, -0.19983771443367004, 0.4072100818157196, 0.7206404805183411, -0.5826061367988586, -0.41906774044036865, -0.6032419204711914, 0.38740742206573486, -0.15848612785339355, -1.0207538604736328, -0.10832014679908752, 0.4010877311229706, 0.4974430501461029, 0.11259426176548004, 0.7513686418533325, -0.28659188747406006, 0.5512386560440063, 0.23719759285449982, -0.18414483964443207, -0.103111132979393, -0.537862241268158, -0.3364810049533844, 0.15487731993198395, 0.1279565542936325, -0.39305296540260315 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04393v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04393v1
Counting Like Transformers: Compiling Temporal Counting Logic Into Softmax Transformers
2024-04-05T20:36:30
2024-04-05T20:36:30
Andy Yang, David Chiang
cs.LO
cs.LO, cs.CL, cs.FL, cs.LG
Deriving formal bounds on the expressivity of transformers, as well as studying transformers that are constructed to implement known algorithms, are both effective methods for better understanding the computational power of transformers. Towards both ends, we introduce the temporal counting logic $\textbf{K}_\text{t}$[#] alongside the RASP variant $\textbf{C-RASP}$. We show they are equivalent to each other, and that together they are the best-known lower bound on the formal expressivity of future-masked soft attention transformers with unbounded input size. We prove this by showing all $\textbf{K}_\text{t}$[#] formulas can be compiled into these transformers. As a case study, we demonstrate on paper how to use $\textbf{C-RASP}$ to construct simple transformer language models that, using greedy decoding, can only generate sentences that have given properties formally specified in $\textbf{K}_\text{t}$[#].
[ -0.3969551622867584, -0.26897820830345154, 0.6472514867782593, 0.30442503094673157, -0.010477720759809017, 0.3226757347583771, -0.31574109196662903, -0.6486985683441162, 0.15309996902942657, 0.507040798664093, -0.6014556288719177, -0.198155015707016, -0.6936430931091309, -0.02747184783220291, -0.6019718050956726, 0.9353088736534119, 0.07163713872432709, -0.14810436964035034, 0.15526147186756134, -0.15304917097091675, -0.2708440124988556, -0.3167186975479126, 0.012378881685435772, -0.22929801046848297, 0.34811586141586304, 0.36560532450675964, 0.6277085542678833, 0.3505305051803589, 0.42566126585006714, 0.4041456878185272, 0.0919869914650917, -0.12670856714248657, -0.12699201703071594, 0.3959527611732483, 0.04265987128019333, -0.4082603454589844, -0.47200798988342285, 0.08269959688186646, 0.5736886262893677, 0.5850474238395691, 0.002314545912668109, 0.36185458302497864, -0.08106423914432526, 0.26932546496391296, -0.6818521022796631, 0.4969777762889862, -0.42383643984794617, 0.5212770700454712, -0.08949976414442062, -0.51993328332901, -0.7464159727096558, -0.23665465414524078, 0.06333813816308975, -0.2849711775779724, 0.46647149324417114, -0.24562785029411316, 0.7683418393135071, 0.3293841779232025, -0.496000736951828, -0.2961477041244507, -1.1810914278030396, 1.1852049827575684, -0.5774871110916138, 0.728445291519165, 0.12373851239681244, 0.5701578259468079, 0.28024452924728394, -0.9837386012077332, -0.6275690793991089, -0.19097182154655457, -0.3880698084831238, 0.2019898146390915, -0.18238526582717896, 0.22035853564739227, 0.6811633706092834, 0.40643125772476196, -0.3925668001174927, -0.1260869801044464, -0.607238233089447, -0.23357246816158295, 0.3639692962169647, 0.20172041654586792, 0.03174591436982155, -0.24679279327392578, -0.010888365097343922, 0.02895362861454487, -0.39764681458473206, -0.2786474823951721, 0.15663446485996246, -0.10831116139888763, -0.24510355293750763, 0.6836603283882141, -0.10286366194486618, 0.4975007474422455, 0.21135178208351135, -0.09817152470350266, 0.047714825719594955, -0.19283539056777954, -0.18539434671401978, -0.1959976851940155, 0.35480496287345886, 0.08911069482564926, 0.9026966691017151, -0.5558698177337646, -0.2680572271347046, 0.3648209869861603, 0.2529035806655884, -0.9662899971008301, 0.06771848350763321, 0.011423098854720592, -0.4980616271495819, -0.1351844072341919, 0.008617700077593327, -0.616981565952301, 0.328174352645874, -0.45901793241500854, 0.1719038337469101, -0.15622824430465698, -0.10199963301420212, 0.26464173197746277, -0.16645510494709015, 0.6630429029464722, -0.17690172791481018, -0.8806164264678955, 0.7372223138809204, 0.8180707097053528, 0.6980655789375305, 0.20712345838546753, -0.03717852756381035, -0.7584559917449951, 0.057419393211603165, -0.1967821717262268, 0.8097423911094666, -0.6316452622413635, -0.3085717558860779, 0.2229989767074585, 0.09945712238550186, -0.06191808357834816, -0.3644169867038727, 0.5662342309951782, -0.8725030422210693, 0.05740518867969513, 0.18791520595550537, -0.37601152062416077, 0.07392319291830063, 0.12802794575691223, -0.6262692213058472, 0.7487202286720276, 0.3035603165626526, -0.2206156700849533, 0.48417434096336365, -0.6257447600364685, -0.6707611680030823, 0.17136162519454956, -0.13572421669960022, -0.30982092022895813, 0.36920443177223206, -0.005938728339970112, 0.6151690483093262, -0.25356563925743103, 0.3407481610774994, -0.18202681839466095, -0.27489611506462097, 0.5871008634567261, -0.25738126039505005, 0.7824354767799377, 0.5165263414382935, -0.5764872431755066, -0.05249280482530594, -0.5555273294448853, 0.12594880163669586, 0.03185177221894264, 0.041084371507167816, 0.0501721017062664, 0.18185919523239136, 0.10219240188598633, 0.285148024559021, 0.11653537303209305, -0.7046690583229065, 0.387051522731781, -0.46474704146385193, 0.70907062292099, 0.7675157189369202, -0.09868010878562927, 0.4596555829048157, -0.20856282114982605, 0.7269914150238037, -0.15921518206596375, 0.33776190876960754, -0.13865727186203003, -0.44637686014175415, -0.9200581312179565, -0.07478569447994232, 0.4258674681186676, 0.5463444590568542, -0.8399465084075928, 0.3725610673427582, -0.5954477787017822, -0.5693435072898865, -0.07729906588792801, -0.14012832939624786, 0.2507065534591675, 0.3186372220516205, 0.3221147358417511, -0.13407252728939056, -0.6137797236442566, -0.9358379244804382, -0.26620161533355713, 0.03836958855390549, -0.21524681150913239, 0.30662786960601807, 0.5330039858818054, -0.007036864757537842, 0.9376606345176697, -0.9178935885429382, -0.1919517070055008, -0.40461987257003784, 0.04537184536457062, 0.3723788857460022, 0.4119902551174164, 0.5748034715652466, -0.7771416306495667, -0.673257052898407, -0.34735333919525146, -0.5141046643257141, -0.2570939064025879, 0.08877729624509811, 0.1935563087463379, 0.236524760723114, 0.582991898059845, -0.8551414012908936, 0.4394978880882263, 0.38536515831947327, -0.4734534025192261, 0.5516034960746765, 0.26396191120147705, 0.40039199590682983, -0.6966380476951599, 0.061669718474149704, -0.2588150203227997, -0.4502992630004883, -0.7572646141052246, 0.2395971566438675, 0.043063823133707047, -0.2873487174510956, -0.6807727813720703, 0.6304050087928772, -0.3688574731349945, -0.3021164834499359, 0.0018245126120746136, -0.30707281827926636, -0.27578169107437134, 0.8764141798019409, 0.1464919000864029, 0.391047865152359, 0.37784481048583984, -0.7048338055610657, 0.14833924174308777, -0.11116362363100052, -0.4539455473423004, 0.46890631318092346, -0.9395261406898499, 0.29294413328170776, 0.14829926192760468, 0.35648614168167114, -0.6522268652915955, -0.012733306735754013, 0.19111759960651398, -0.6471890807151794, 0.4839860796928406, -0.5624815821647644, -0.8220827579498291, -0.4684789478778839, -0.26684069633483887, 0.7820888161659241, 0.883916437625885, -0.3374495208263397, 0.7818692922592163, 0.3100923001766205, 0.09216507524251938, -0.6410272717475891, -1.0597708225250244, -0.2203419804573059, 0.02999015711247921, -0.6369760632514954, 0.5142709016799927, -0.14070726931095123, -0.33118799328804016, 0.1319965124130249, -0.01031622476875782, -0.00504374410957098, -0.23570409417152405, 0.11113112419843674, 0.18870989978313446, -0.28559404611587524, -0.10937761515378952, 0.0894467756152153, -0.5628511905670166, 0.05102367699146271, -0.5556197762489319, 0.8748637437820435, -0.1467033475637436, -0.40584537386894226, 0.13093949854373932, 0.4698738157749176, 0.496004194021225, -0.049439240247011185, 0.573074996471405, 0.7508364915847778, -0.6809456944465637, -0.2923290431499481, -0.6462486386299133, -0.3866696059703827, -0.574618935585022, -0.07109934091567993, -0.4290902316570282, -1.1245592832565308, 0.5629819631576538, 0.563588559627533, 0.3477925956249237, 0.8795396685600281, 0.6563640236854553, 0.22275559604167938, 1.2181117534637451, 0.6386807560920715, 0.3144562542438507, 0.47885653376579285, -0.37160059809684753, 0.27748405933380127, -0.45481622219085693, -0.3600011169910431, -0.6499418616294861, -0.5289772152900696, -0.9319252967834473, -0.4229138493537903, 0.2169349640607834, -0.4448602497577667, -0.3706017732620239, 0.6721863746643066, -0.7404181361198425, 0.6102083921432495, 0.4512973129749298, -0.07810387015342712, 0.27042821049690247, -0.05750647187232971, 0.19178637862205505, -0.47786080837249756, -0.6736438870429993, -0.0075805215165019035, 0.8247455358505249, 0.10821132361888885, 0.6376001238822937, 0.13489528000354767, 0.33623701333999634, 0.5550639033317566, 0.5095651149749756, -1.1862884759902954, 0.7767459154129028, -0.3354511559009552, -0.7515074610710144, 0.15828965604305267, -0.5267608165740967, -0.9482826590538025, -0.36614280939102173, -0.008769041858613491, -0.7060657739639282, 0.29448074102401733, 0.032672759145498276, -0.10752754658460617, 0.3636122941970825, -0.8627361059188843, 0.6739701628684998, 0.02113248221576214, 0.10144595801830292, -0.40351536870002747, -0.6292650103569031, 0.32267147302627563, 0.359666645526886, -0.21398763358592987, -0.010312799364328384, -0.3423483669757843, 0.8208219408988953, -0.5170263648033142, 0.7780182957649231, -0.10536748170852661, 0.20185986161231995, 0.7471193075180054, 0.3627014458179474, 0.3824450969696045, -0.16964878141880035, 0.30150261521339417, 0.12411317229270935, 0.06627590954303741, -0.6490699648857117, -0.6976097822189331, 0.7136254906654358, -0.5087783336639404, -0.23924340307712555, -0.7680350542068481, -0.42420703172683716, 0.0008932499913498759, 0.20317311584949493, 0.29102492332458496, 0.8695822954177856, 0.09894007444381714, 0.17963747680187225, 0.6692308783531189, -0.18486379086971283, 0.6588877439498901, 0.8481503129005432, 0.023569202050566673, -0.22269202768802643, 0.8651142120361328, 0.4552915096282959, 0.22828051447868347, 0.9254637956619263, 0.0685364380478859, -0.5553601980209351, -0.046252377331256866, -0.21246232092380524, 0.3003937602043152, -0.6418904662132263, -0.4673954248428345, -0.9373729228973389, -0.5673669576644897, -0.7382386326789856, -0.4306448698043823, -0.24227221310138702, -0.7517756223678589, 0.106255903840065, 0.07394543290138245, 0.5785324573516846, 0.573412299156189, -0.18681609630584717, 0.18201805651187897, -0.9911207556724548, 0.7069562673568726, 0.5015512108802795, 0.8331634998321533, 0.10540151596069336, -0.5853112936019897, -0.17535045742988586, -0.45378464460372925, -0.4538302719593048, -0.8488888144493103, 0.4319651424884796, 0.07028193026781082, 0.2603495717048645, 0.20643779635429382, 0.05554177984595299, 0.43137574195861816, -0.6380177736282349, 0.5821301937103271, 0.07195597141981125, -1.2221143245697021, 0.08765111118555069, -0.141426220536232, 0.6411121487617493, 0.325289785861969, 0.1815500110387802, -0.7012335658073425, -0.38802793622016907, -1.0226649045944214, -0.7065761089324951, 0.6006646156311035, 0.439799427986145, 0.23136106133460999, -0.18435844779014587, -0.0000295174013444921, -0.06465199589729309, 0.19951137900352478, -0.731721818447113, -0.3928247094154358, -0.10809352248907089, -0.2526096999645233, -0.0339047834277153, -0.5631226301193237, 0.3419179618358612, -0.10840685665607452, 0.41315802931785583, 0.07673779129981995, 0.8066815733909607, 0.012800530530512333, -0.3460683226585388, 0.11041101813316345, 0.5727994441986084, 0.5557283163070679, 0.582484781742096, -0.1548372507095337, 0.3522816002368927, 0.17837528884410858, -0.5187291502952576, 0.038157567381858826, 0.2661557197570801, -0.27473992109298706, 0.13884089887142181, 0.3754107654094696, 0.04329438880085945, 0.4242194592952728, -0.749585747718811, 0.3982873558998108, 0.18290483951568604, -0.09729447960853577, -0.6165102124214172, -0.07237479090690613, 0.023062322288751602, 0.2477031797170639, 0.415633887052536, 0.11494049429893494, 0.46589091420173645, -0.503331184387207, 0.4386920928955078, 0.24795736372470856, -0.6973493695259094, -0.30842816829681396, 0.6901513934135437, 0.14089488983154297, -0.5673267841339111, 0.7102609872817993, -0.3595307171344757, -0.8234823346138, 0.9448443055152893, 0.4476920962333679, 1.241411805152893, -0.1299784630537033, -0.0010266982717439532, 0.40547776222229004, 0.4475673735141754, 0.18755878508090973, 0.13611382246017456, -0.5377489328384399, -0.5122019052505493, -1.0759063959121704, -0.4916377663612366, -0.3446349501609802, 0.01624165289103985, -0.6174750328063965, 0.36389222741127014, -0.3456125259399414, -0.05228635296225548, 0.11472544074058533, -0.09884127974510193, -0.9683203101158142, -0.07709211111068726, -0.019312269985675812, 0.716492772102356, -0.6284912824630737, 0.4802030324935913, 0.21287597715854645, -0.06046096608042717, -0.4771302044391632, -0.2466474175453186, -0.2699306607246399, -0.8779492378234863, 0.4280664622783661, 0.35555556416511536, -0.36069899797439575, -0.1257951557636261, -0.8698484897613525, -0.47237804532051086, 0.7959420680999756, 0.1814737170934677, -0.5226041674613953, 0.2390783727169037, 0.08558209240436554, 0.6816467642784119, -0.04602503776550293, 0.37840768694877625, 0.7509012818336487, 0.5594254732131958, -0.021029764786362648, -0.6909897923469543, 0.0875258594751358, -0.4465818405151367, -0.6081846356391907, 0.7847051024436951, -0.5625666975975037, 0.47850915789604187, -0.1961047351360321, -0.6196935176849365, 0.12047038972377777, 0.8258578777313232, -0.0999227985739708, 0.48170018196105957, 0.716767430305481, 0.47907736897468567, -0.16497789323329926, -0.18349361419677734, 1.1159580945968628, -0.37080878019332886, 0.44956260919570923, 0.9655562043190002, 0.1850273460149765, 0.18292495608329773, 0.14113226532936096, -0.32873567938804626, 0.39725229144096375, 0.16146071255207062, -0.1790635883808136, 0.10886862128973007, 0.0377325564622879, -0.09112963080406189, -0.44725272059440613, -0.29122021794319153, -0.30339089035987854, 0.27158981561660767, 0.3590591549873352, -0.4642896354198456, -0.02031659707427025, -0.4098118841648102, 0.14614099264144897, -0.00242833374068141, -0.2971474230289459, 0.41162750124931335, 0.3502269685268402, -0.7946650385856628, 0.3708631992340088, 0.07414064556360245, 0.8527624607086182, -0.6277807354927063, -0.10198349505662918, -0.03257756680250168, 0.19702771306037903, -0.2642327547073364, -1.065809965133667, 0.5709048509597778, 0.18995384871959686, -0.30304646492004395, -0.5265232920646667, 0.9036972522735596, -0.33635300397872925, -0.7904022932052612, 0.12562279403209686, 0.3855690062046051, 0.1731604039669037, 0.16699428856372833, -0.4505153000354767, -0.3547051250934601, -0.16788005828857422, -0.274112731218338, 0.12323394417762756, 0.12148155272006989, 0.11823228001594543, 0.7928819060325623, 0.3828844726085663, -0.010781222023069859, 0.1169518381357193, 0.34811824560165405, 0.6360831260681152, -0.8169264197349548, -0.481393426656723, -0.8070933818817139, 0.2218179553747177, 0.15034203231334686, -0.30288931727409363, 0.41669660806655884, 0.6458156704902649, 0.6325039863586426, -0.3880613446235657, 0.30085858702659607, -0.45102018117904663, 0.438869833946228, -0.437117338180542, 0.33745747804641724, -0.49862998723983765, 0.0661565512418747, -0.27723032236099243, -1.1507232189178467, -0.45071321725845337, 0.24432437121868134, -0.33437591791152954, 0.23088814318180084, 0.6152445077896118, 0.7118926644325256, -0.3964589834213257, -0.1425248384475708, 0.25991806387901306, 0.20518173277378082, 0.3092479407787323, 0.9091897010803223, 0.8624694347381592, -0.3627145290374756, 0.9142265319824219, -0.5090922117233276, -0.04536420851945877, -0.017401158809661865, -0.8751448392868042, -0.726271390914917, -0.6715313196182251, -0.23291313648223877, -0.5754793286323547, -0.38282087445259094, 0.5100938677787781, 0.7444115281105042, -0.7916806936264038, -0.09004413336515427, 0.13808493316173553, 0.42638835310935974, -0.30432364344596863, -0.37754151225090027, 0.31675881147384644, -0.00521131744608283, -0.9384238123893738, 0.010245801880955696, 0.2852286100387573, 0.1000053659081459, -0.33751368522644043, -0.04829835146665573, 0.20827680826187134, 0.26472121477127075, 0.9161083102226257, 0.6364224553108215, -0.38824522495269775, -0.46308377385139465, 0.3643238842487335, 0.004091418813914061, -0.026005234569311142, 1.5428781509399414, -0.9934616088867188, 0.21434751152992249, 0.9414973855018616, 0.248637393116951, 1.027178406715393, -0.3448333144187927, 0.542655348777771, -0.5914182066917419, 0.3448851406574249, 0.7470386028289795, 0.3526771366596222, 0.11305408179759979, -0.06810228526592255, 0.6626614332199097, 0.3319858908653259, -0.5767428874969482, -0.7852305769920349, 0.7537238597869873, -1.358734130859375, -0.023883884772658348, 1.162743330001831, 0.19809643924236298, 0.06424327194690704, -0.35632991790771484, 0.2950575053691864, 0.30199581384658813, -0.46037933230400085, 0.6202951669692993, 0.3349634110927582, -0.013304966501891613, -0.13116317987442017, -0.41791680455207825, 0.2764902412891388, 0.3626270294189453, -0.44049736857414246, -0.4267623722553253, 0.2016032338142395, 0.07091560959815979, 0.4043499231338501, 0.6180600523948669, -0.2333674281835556, 0.321321576833725, -0.00025565666146576405, -0.14597442746162415, 0.03957691416144371, -0.4529120624065399, 0.10931667685508728, 0.17067298293113708, -0.3537134826183319, -0.10331468284130096 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08674v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08674v1
Effects of Different Prompts on the Quality of GPT-4 Responses to Dementia Care Questions
2024-04-05T19:24:57
2024-04-05T19:24:57
Zhuochun Li, Bo Xie, Robin Hilsabeck, Alyssa Aguirre, Ning Zou, Zhimeng Luo, Daqing He
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
Evidence suggests that different prompts lead large language models (LLMs) to generate responses with varying quality. Yet, little is known about prompts' effects on response quality in healthcare domains. In this exploratory study, we address this gap, focusing on a specific healthcare domain: dementia caregiving. We first developed an innovative prompt template with three components: (1) system prompts (SPs) featuring 4 different roles; (2) an initialization prompt; and (3) task prompts (TPs) specifying different levels of details, totaling 12 prompt combinations. Next, we selected 3 social media posts containing complicated, real-world questions about dementia caregivers' challenges in 3 areas: memory loss and confusion, aggression, and driving. We then entered these posts into GPT-4, with our 12 prompts, to generate 12 responses per post, totaling 36 responses. We compared the word count of the 36 responses to explore potential differences in response length. Two experienced dementia care clinicians on our team assessed the response quality using a rating scale with 5 quality indicators: factual, interpretation, application, synthesis, and comprehensiveness (scoring range: 0-5; higher scores indicate higher quality).
[ -0.4768929183483124, -0.8091894388198853, 1.1685773134231567, 0.17494358122348785, -0.33940640091896057, -0.4368387460708618, 0.05253377556800842, -0.5731104612350464, 0.28476205468177795, 0.13143771886825562, -0.8680999875068665, -0.2818628251552582, -0.716217577457428, 0.44476813077926636, 0.15087009966373444, 1.2841817140579224, -0.12219081073999405, 0.09575564414262772, -0.016312599182128906, -0.1686457097530365, -0.9106165170669556, -0.4395630955696106, -0.9896830320358276, -0.11206252127885818, 0.7223321199417114, 0.2121693342924118, 0.6147114634513855, 0.1593089997768402, 0.4909697473049164, 0.22337982058525085, -0.05877339094877243, 0.2163001149892807, -0.23423033952713013, 0.2688789367675781, 0.04353420436382294, -0.20936565101146698, -0.6952892541885376, 0.30584487318992615, 0.05918698012828827, 0.3778454065322876, -0.021905377507209778, 0.22668763995170593, 0.234728142619133, 0.40650251507759094, -0.39137062430381775, 0.08081807941198349, -0.10636730492115021, 0.027031706646084785, 0.04687821865081787, -0.46743685007095337, -0.0972883328795433, -0.5790413618087769, 0.40121254324913025, -0.7671071887016296, 0.41194915771484375, -0.30352726578712463, 1.013000249862671, 0.1445837914943695, -0.4092084467411041, -0.6961638331413269, -0.5392333269119263, 0.3168720304965973, -0.9094924926757812, -0.0028724914882332087, 0.5395157933235168, 0.24132688343524933, 0.08116577565670013, -0.5012484192848206, -0.3036044239997864, -0.06358902901411057, -0.08315090090036392, 0.3673173487186432, -0.3875795900821686, 0.0778174176812172, 0.406547486782074, 0.1800512671470642, -0.7610334753990173, 0.12057922035455704, -0.26977965235710144, -0.47598233819007874, 0.18213531374931335, 0.45750516653060913, 0.4369232654571533, -0.10295882076025009, -0.14277561008930206, 0.10981910675764084, -0.38281553983688354, 0.4402502775192261, 0.3831825256347656, 0.1085904911160469, -0.02688448317348957, 0.5307580232620239, -0.07666872441768646, 0.5613310933113098, 0.2744700610637665, -0.21416375041007996, 0.01607702299952507, -0.5388338565826416, 0.07941985875368118, -0.01503982488065958, 0.5604833960533142, 0.9494147896766663, 0.04496542364358902, 0.04242149367928505, -0.18735681474208832, 0.36351069808006287, 0.2131740301847458, -0.6824053525924683, -0.3869776725769043, 0.419332891702652, -0.6238994002342224, 0.27587199211120605, 0.1866723895072937, -0.5301331281661987, -0.13939520716667175, -0.1488010287284851, 0.31517156958580017, -0.5792183876037598, -0.10711055994033813, 0.38140183687210083, -0.3105887174606323, 0.3683987855911255, 0.6077702045440674, -0.6872711777687073, 0.30285272002220154, 0.48394399881362915, 0.6678299903869629, -0.5972541570663452, -0.09159227460622787, -1.1141496896743774, -0.09391691535711288, -0.1638459712266922, 0.9479125142097473, -0.363821417093277, -0.5935894250869751, 0.04891452193260193, 0.05304299294948578, 0.09637390822172165, -0.5322235822677612, 0.7010026574134827, -0.6718236207962036, 0.6636759638786316, -0.9003309011459351, -0.3383305072784424, 0.06875880062580109, 0.33897989988327026, -0.6705081462860107, 0.7634052634239197, 0.3017713725566864, -0.6945499777793884, 0.5917364358901978, -0.42761337757110596, -0.375762015581131, 0.29180485010147095, -0.22127918899059296, 0.10129065811634064, 0.3167320191860199, 0.4383834898471832, 0.36402466893196106, -0.20147250592708588, 0.0057749757543206215, -0.02188454195857048, -0.2528926432132721, 0.4527795910835266, -0.556043803691864, 0.4625888168811798, -0.04479430615901947, -0.2588586211204529, 0.11251034587621689, -0.3758673667907715, 0.11974166333675385, -0.08578497171401978, -0.48165178298950195, -0.3586784899234772, -0.5698012113571167, -0.3909952938556671, 0.670281708240509, 0.2017834633588791, -0.6271734237670898, 0.013913208618760109, -0.06813506036996841, 0.45003756880760193, 0.8037053942680359, 0.52906733751297, 0.0992475301027298, -0.61027592420578, 0.7479936480522156, 0.10726888477802277, 0.4403941333293915, -0.19677497446537018, -0.9114323258399963, -0.06025950238108635, -0.20748478174209595, -0.1896781325340271, 0.36323416233062744, -0.6553236246109009, 0.03371623530983925, -0.11124775558710098, -0.0036891899071633816, -0.7321030497550964, -0.37667688727378845, 0.5123177170753479, 0.5909287333488464, 0.5971657633781433, -0.2891542613506317, 0.18524596095085144, -0.7895175814628601, -0.18308910727500916, -0.42162013053894043, -0.1794172078371048, 0.5568901896476746, 0.2674725651741028, -0.10523176193237305, 0.7853296399116516, -0.5629432201385498, -0.07438626140356064, -0.03657690808176994, -0.024124670773744583, 0.08678136020898819, -0.009704038500785828, 0.328768253326416, -0.4201308488845825, -0.14978745579719543, -0.5108272433280945, -0.40254178643226624, -0.26518523693084717, -0.060277216136455536, -0.02538195624947548, 0.27264204621315, 0.19182898104190826, -0.9810406565666199, 0.29101642966270447, 0.6818201541900635, -0.4273647367954254, 0.8703626394271851, -0.43982449173927307, 0.510414719581604, -0.9858034253120422, -0.2572694718837738, -0.15351025760173798, 0.28396132588386536, -0.5838432908058167, -0.34613052010536194, -0.18717949092388153, 0.04259917512536049, -0.4209440052509308, 0.5670738816261292, -0.3721524178981781, -0.1742941290140152, 0.026359420269727707, 0.10386375337839127, 0.25658825039863586, 0.20578812062740326, -0.308973491191864, 0.9107421636581421, 0.3831320106983185, -0.6337284445762634, 0.23097333312034607, 0.1934150904417038, 0.05554664134979248, 0.7813670039176941, -0.9675442576408386, 0.20173144340515137, -0.13470079004764557, 0.24909448623657227, -1.4670754671096802, -0.2927745580673218, 0.4524546265602112, -0.33326178789138794, -0.047218214720487595, 0.2472456991672516, -0.27871349453926086, -0.38238370418548584, -0.4562186598777771, 0.40119218826293945, 0.37688204646110535, -0.14024631679058075, 0.49018532037734985, -0.012869560159742832, -0.4651184380054474, -0.12097395956516266, -0.6391125321388245, -0.006436951458454132, -0.32249629497528076, -0.6215897798538208, 0.6544853448867798, -0.4147690534591675, -0.11955171823501587, 0.2457004189491272, -0.5800697207450867, 0.08042645454406738, -0.2041124701499939, 0.15545262396335602, 0.21981602907180786, -0.12328661978244781, 0.02789277955889702, -0.06294595450162888, -0.26028692722320557, 0.29809799790382385, -0.1495419293642044, 0.7089885473251343, -0.16528891026973724, -0.45531776547431946, -0.8223796486854553, 0.6264418363571167, 0.48095589876174927, -0.2780928611755371, 0.38498732447624207, 0.5246130228042603, -0.1747293323278427, 0.045812588185071945, -0.6180629730224609, -0.40364646911621094, -0.5077904462814331, -0.23136813938617706, -0.4143233597278595, -1.2865673303604126, 0.7896527647972107, 0.22211001813411713, 0.013498763553798199, 0.37260279059410095, 0.45165374875068665, -0.3153620660305023, 0.9010561108589172, 0.23163896799087524, 0.06625241786241531, 0.2735997140407562, 0.09163104742765427, 0.1305963695049286, -0.8698083162307739, -0.3909545838832855, -0.33646658062934875, -0.05803515389561653, -0.736718475818634, -0.39201831817626953, 0.459850549697876, -0.21728481352329254, -0.24328987300395966, -0.003662573406472802, -0.49757787585258484, -0.20680180191993713, 0.5376501083374023, 0.5105614066123962, 0.1322692483663559, -0.36032170057296753, 0.16640117764472961, -0.14460135996341705, -0.7491329312324524, -0.6232321262359619, 0.4447742998600006, 0.1629086285829544, 0.6496772170066833, 0.23403964936733246, 0.5784295797348022, 0.277244508266449, 0.04888599365949631, -0.7339189648628235, 0.6722977161407471, -0.003572216723114252, -0.27416762709617615, -0.37768641114234924, -0.5399189591407776, -1.0676017999649048, -0.2936783730983734, 0.18158438801765442, -0.3485177159309387, 0.09442133456468582, -0.004054401069879532, -0.8201781511306763, -0.16946516931056976, -0.4888623356819153, 0.6054211854934692, -0.43531203269958496, 0.029784901067614555, 0.28913578391075134, -0.6783393621444702, -0.0119528379291296, 0.09944792091846466, -0.035852886736392975, -0.21371683478355408, -0.23890581727027893, 0.6856179237365723, -0.34810224175453186, 0.6942905187606812, -0.17419174313545227, -0.22307391464710236, 0.344124436378479, 0.15272660553455353, 0.49921345710754395, 0.2903207838535309, -0.02729102224111557, -0.0902227908372879, -0.014813865534961224, -0.3740682303905487, -0.5809037089347839, 0.7687622904777527, -0.7656238675117493, -0.8518629670143127, -0.3424646258354187, -0.4593976140022278, -0.3430041968822479, -0.011887061409652233, 0.563838005065918, 0.6520504355430603, -0.14928102493286133, -0.4610935151576996, 0.9277281761169434, -0.6402360796928406, 0.38229885697364807, 0.5414723753929138, 0.3931698799133301, -0.2591318190097809, 0.39950141310691833, 0.18770359456539154, 0.3939221501350403, 0.006638424005359411, 0.33222952485084534, -0.13433809578418732, -0.3948458433151245, -0.4558422267436981, 0.5414370894432068, -0.63612300157547, -0.14683052897453308, -0.6343293786048889, 0.11753420531749725, -0.4709192216396332, -0.05668225139379501, 0.0631982609629631, -0.10310068726539612, -0.5236238837242126, -0.34210705757141113, 0.57330322265625, 0.6866005063056946, 0.21971826255321503, 0.04033660888671875, -0.848858118057251, 0.3083146810531616, 0.5880398154258728, 0.4517747163772583, -0.2976738214492798, -0.505497932434082, 0.28494957089424133, -0.15486368536949158, 0.16069114208221436, -1.040313959121704, 0.07732751220464706, -0.041864797472953796, 0.7178218364715576, 0.323526531457901, -0.0007525195251218975, 0.7061907052993774, -0.6047317981719971, 1.437159538269043, 0.3202292025089264, -0.4302683472633362, 0.5248833894729614, -0.5605014562606812, 0.5419011116027832, 0.6580245494842529, 0.498913049697876, -0.5674376487731934, -0.24794207513332367, -0.4954492449760437, -0.9602500200271606, 0.4478708803653717, 0.008742484264075756, 0.3147878646850586, -0.44950658082962036, 0.7323980331420898, 0.32209455966949463, -0.057218022644519806, -0.11018779873847961, -0.2476813942193985, -0.4000178277492523, 0.24650903046131134, 0.16545499861240387, -0.5831077098846436, -0.224307581782341, 0.29293403029441833, 0.25191745162010193, 0.1060415655374527, 0.6954733729362488, 0.2645096480846405, 0.393909752368927, -0.12057143449783325, 0.3048362731933594, 0.6323700547218323, 0.5577462315559387, 0.007493435870856047, 0.1310211420059204, 0.1278872936964035, -0.36258187890052795, 0.09101566672325134, 0.034208498895168304, 0.014982178807258606, 0.1927802711725235, 0.614337682723999, 0.6873949766159058, -0.34992071986198425, -0.206721231341362, 0.43397581577301025, -0.38079583644866943, -0.1240338608622551, 0.07025302201509476, 0.27440062165260315, 0.13620725274085999, -0.022244147956371307, 0.18153813481330872, -0.1766793131828308, 0.2994694411754608, -0.6066840887069702, 0.2856141924858093, 0.2195100635290146, -0.5177475214004517, -0.49938294291496277, 0.5154119729995728, -0.11310824751853943, -0.3309694826602936, 0.6648255586624146, -0.16511110961437225, -0.14980612695217133, 0.3995073139667511, 0.4893576502799988, 0.6196114420890808, -0.4424807131290436, 0.5575839877128601, 0.16750231385231018, 0.11085149645805359, -0.16382701694965363, 0.5919415354728699, 0.2465265542268753, -0.5779252052307129, -0.3581462800502777, -0.3197173774242401, -0.3855006694793701, 0.3046138882637024, -1.0217241048812866, -0.3617747724056244, -0.2757963538169861, -0.7549704909324646, -0.15872208774089813, -0.06777889281511307, -1.0791826248168945, 0.21383585035800934, -0.2745504677295685, 0.8410454988479614, -0.7954388856887817, 0.23542286455631256, 1.076890468597412, -0.725317656993866, -1.0739835500717163, 0.520530104637146, 0.08881097286939621, -0.5761284828186035, 0.564927875995636, 0.20358392596244812, -0.3628259599208832, -0.14195404946804047, -0.22262278199195862, -0.7564059495925903, 1.1237115859985352, 0.14060918986797333, 0.0877685397863388, -0.23673215508460999, 0.10749074071645737, 0.7531754374504089, -0.33189696073532104, 0.12777581810951233, 0.4725021719932556, 0.3732844293117523, -0.022523026913404465, -0.8184823393821716, 0.41749638319015503, -0.23602010309696198, 0.09455648809671402, -0.288767546415329, -0.5920578837394714, 0.913641631603241, -0.08394265919923782, -0.3793259859085083, 0.10867733508348465, 0.40534910559654236, 0.6030541658401489, 0.3651803135871887, 0.2778165638446808, 0.3828204274177551, 0.9035077691078186, -0.28516703844070435, 1.2231388092041016, -0.2190970927476883, -0.21749451756477356, 1.046408772468567, -0.2870372533798218, 0.26842713356018066, 0.5020498037338257, 0.12203487753868103, 0.4838707149028778, 0.8645963668823242, 0.45502224564552307, 0.6450229287147522, 0.16771164536476135, -0.46806323528289795, -0.05594417452812195, -0.41006097197532654, -0.4026060998439789, -0.018606828525662422, 0.44384583830833435, -0.11010389775037766, -0.2706563174724579, 0.15874919295310974, 0.18660275638103485, -0.3274129331111908, -0.14788711071014404, 0.8346355557441711, 0.07600842416286469, -0.8892671465873718, 0.3265695571899414, -0.07902178913354874, 0.6190393567085266, -0.7041864991188049, -0.14943058788776398, -0.5343170166015625, -0.3688341975212097, -0.06951715052127838, -1.1348644495010376, 0.1578104943037033, 0.07564443349838257, -0.41875845193862915, -0.38216251134872437, 0.4836125671863556, -0.013053346425294876, 0.1887507289648056, 0.40685445070266724, 0.8499460220336914, 0.42426255345344543, -0.06178153306245804, -0.7685126662254333, 0.15665213763713837, -0.3435285985469818, -0.5394144058227539, 0.32484346628189087, 0.9970882534980774, -0.3256152272224426, 0.46419557929039, 0.6549879908561707, 0.2248011827468872, 0.00989453960210085, 0.15618398785591125, 1.1507877111434937, -0.36280059814453125, -0.25624892115592957, -0.7564671039581299, 0.4541051983833313, 0.11732667684555054, -0.8148481249809265, 0.7821457982063293, 0.12701447308063507, 0.6146759986877441, -0.024791596457362175, 0.7193130254745483, 0.03469092398881912, 0.21442055702209473, -0.44568899273872375, 0.09536489099264145, -0.21877945959568024, 0.30664506554603577, -0.2414100170135498, -0.669815719127655, -0.23484963178634644, 0.3562244772911072, -0.5602205991744995, 0.4593573212623596, 0.8714244365692139, 0.836646318435669, 0.1942603588104248, -0.15641920268535614, 0.11634599417448044, 0.04192998632788658, 0.5945264101028442, 0.5626468658447266, 0.8271476626396179, 0.06267217546701431, 0.408340722322464, 0.184175044298172, -0.15635725855827332, -0.2153836041688919, -0.7014476656913757, -0.6476153135299683, -0.5408188104629517, -0.11210845410823822, -0.5865668654441833, 0.39282646775245667, 0.74495929479599, 0.2362195998430252, -0.5761523246765137, 0.304574191570282, 0.3029664158821106, -0.549726665019989, -0.3690803647041321, -0.2445404976606369, 0.8487393856048584, -0.24481938779354095, -0.1482936441898346, 0.1967916339635849, 0.40474188327789307, -0.02876138500869274, -0.09506350010633469, -0.08206383883953094, 0.191325381398201, -0.043086908757686615, 0.7055443525314331, 0.01653192937374115, -0.7917530536651611, -0.6343721151351929, 0.5680496096611023, -0.5942854285240173, 0.07771619409322739, 0.7305131554603577, -0.4783332645893097, 0.18127630650997162, 0.5061779618263245, 0.533998429775238, 0.3825273811817169, 0.3698831796646118, 0.42161762714385986, -0.35961249470710754, -0.5539517402648926, 0.4142742156982422, 0.21517404913902283, 0.3672444224357605, -0.6615312695503235, 0.14751343429088593, 0.17170053720474243, -0.6370611786842346, -0.1512220799922943, 0.37931686639785767, -1.1679524183273315, -0.32883918285369873, 1.4847640991210938, -0.3542692959308624, 0.06527548283338547, -0.3264581263065338, -0.4957766532897949, 0.21605029702186584, -0.8366262316703796, 0.7662085294723511, 0.8891054391860962, -0.8118594288825989, -0.18869999051094055, -0.9231643080711365, 0.70356285572052, 0.24838072061538696, -0.8284039497375488, -0.08400555700063705, 0.9151324033737183, 0.42870786786079407, -0.14928708970546722, 1.1155222654342651, -0.2223917841911316, 0.5531956553459167, -0.45848095417022705, -0.3486899435520172, -0.19057166576385498, -0.2404310703277588, -0.5145632028579712, 0.2771180272102356, 0.018353575840592384, -0.09110759198665619 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04361v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04361v1
Deciphering Political Entity Sentiment in News with Large Language Models: Zero-Shot and Few-Shot Strategies
2024-04-05T19:14:38
2024-04-05T19:14:38
Alapan Kuila, Sudeshna Sarkar
cs.CL
cs.CL
Sentiment analysis plays a pivotal role in understanding public opinion, particularly in the political domain where the portrayal of entities in news articles influences public perception. In this paper, we investigate the effectiveness of Large Language Models (LLMs) in predicting entity-specific sentiment from political news articles. Leveraging zero-shot and few-shot strategies, we explore the capability of LLMs to discern sentiment towards political entities in news content. Employing a chain-of-thought (COT) approach augmented with rationale in few-shot in-context learning, we assess whether this method enhances sentiment prediction accuracy. Our evaluation on sentiment-labeled datasets demonstrates that LLMs, outperform fine-tuned BERT models in capturing entity-specific sentiment. We find that learning in-context significantly improves model performance, while the self-consistency mechanism enhances consistency in sentiment prediction. Despite the promising results, we observe inconsistencies in the effectiveness of the COT prompting method. Overall, our findings underscore the potential of LLMs in entity-centric sentiment analysis within the political news domain and highlight the importance of suitable prompting strategies and model architectures.
[ -0.5228279232978821, -0.9137554168701172, 0.9439166784286499, 0.2011783868074417, -0.7291844487190247, 0.14087074995040894, -0.5090421438217163, -0.13709072768688202, 0.4395448565483093, 0.5202499628067017, -0.4022347033023834, -0.8232130408287048, -0.6402530074119568, 0.19043666124343872, -0.365481972694397, 1.1950068473815918, 0.11065055429935455, 0.313725084066391, 0.044626425951719284, -0.15622732043266296, -0.21106679737567902, -0.5793344974517822, -0.348097562789917, -0.39677318930625916, 0.7843245267868042, 0.3456997573375702, 0.5243133306503296, 0.3472721576690674, 0.2330334633588791, 0.05346280708909035, -0.16349655389785767, 0.06628395617008209, -0.5825707316398621, 0.04314585030078888, -0.2703898847103119, -0.5825828313827515, -0.12737786769866943, 0.13418281078338623, 0.5920148491859436, 0.42251792550086975, -0.019095223397016525, -0.024964872747659683, 0.02030058018863201, 0.5895156860351562, -0.7524631023406982, 0.17922446131706238, -1.1358619928359985, -0.03736024349927902, -0.2618330419063568, -0.1245003342628479, -0.592004656791687, 0.028881926089525223, 0.16621091961860657, -0.07626218348741531, -0.023608200252056122, -0.04198619723320007, 0.7431042790412903, -0.033054426312446594, -0.6375179290771484, -0.2880221903324127, -0.552294909954071, 0.9769467711448669, -0.7307661771774292, 0.39653876423835754, -0.03266783431172371, -0.11190127581357956, -0.15973888337612152, -0.13164588809013367, -0.912999153137207, -0.1264808624982834, 0.2399425059556961, 0.1628342568874359, -0.07115631550550461, -0.006682905368506908, -0.06412823498249054, 0.09005735069513321, -0.19537916779518127, 0.06090640276670456, -0.11892222613096237, 0.20303422212600708, 0.43813177943229675, -0.0544506311416626, -0.03426261991262436, -0.9457270503044128, -0.8796727061271667, 0.17071832716464996, -0.982884407043457, -0.08655284345149994, 0.42729291319847107, 0.7327943444252014, -0.22880858182907104, 0.5686427354812622, -0.03273673355579376, 0.6192043423652649, 0.15143705904483795, -0.15577904880046844, 0.027186714112758636, -0.01412728801369667, -0.4618937373161316, 0.1310170590877533, 0.8826383948326111, 0.2236291468143463, 0.1820264309644699, 0.021693069487810135, -0.44432953000068665, 0.20422570407390594, 0.2819215953350067, -0.5031585097312927, 0.1039324700832367, 0.24680323898792267, -0.5352714657783508, -0.5891340970993042, 0.10002271831035614, -1.0832160711288452, -0.6207785606384277, -0.4866054356098175, 0.11381982266902924, -0.31236347556114197, -0.3699711263179779, -0.08958729356527328, 0.012008009478449821, 0.44348323345184326, 0.5597192645072937, -0.5447365045547485, 0.0572383888065815, 0.9182303547859192, 0.9441946744918823, -0.4311826229095459, -0.0679289698600769, -0.4999742805957794, -0.011338898912072182, -0.664768397808075, 1.0832494497299194, -0.7459213137626648, -0.28550654649734497, 0.06990255415439606, -0.24081304669380188, 0.10364708304405212, -0.37658047676086426, 0.3743838369846344, -0.7000086903572083, 0.02094367891550064, -0.4970034956932068, -0.8279552459716797, -0.053549785166978836, 0.643917977809906, -0.6333344578742981, 0.7002266645431519, -0.027456291019916534, -0.8058183789253235, 0.5233755707740784, -0.46234357357025146, -0.3407537639141083, -0.2703694999217987, -0.44218605756759644, -0.35196617245674133, 0.5889594554901123, 0.3127164840698242, 0.7679603099822998, -0.1376408487558365, 0.33277958631515503, -0.5196298360824585, -0.0696939155459404, 0.26870816946029663, -0.3047338128089905, 0.5280268788337708, 0.018111616373062134, -0.3243972361087799, -0.024417847394943237, -0.4975682497024536, -0.26474207639694214, 0.030128980055451393, -0.2003098577260971, -0.3768329322338104, 0.05270624905824661, -0.10609275847673416, 0.28592199087142944, -0.06117904931306839, -0.5918834805488586, 0.3533298671245575, -0.44329825043678284, 0.2147994041442871, 0.8912468552589417, 0.43073275685310364, 0.7817077040672302, 0.13132984936237335, 0.41138899326324463, 0.4260004460811615, -0.22525420784950256, -0.08236435800790787, -0.31334632635116577, -0.40420645475387573, -0.2913796007633209, 0.3537319004535675, 0.41044917702674866, -0.8083953857421875, 0.18126334249973297, -0.23760327696800232, -0.2667875289916992, -0.41044706106185913, 0.09415299445390701, -0.005696775857359171, 0.4840031564235687, 0.29299837350845337, 0.005672757048159838, -0.5448396801948547, -0.6214505434036255, -0.5735856890678406, -0.4308770000934601, 0.32839083671569824, 0.16812580823898315, 0.6678524613380432, -0.04635937511920929, 0.8583266139030457, -0.1824573278427124, -0.2296060174703598, -0.33438828587532043, 0.3287021815776825, 0.18654827773571014, -0.14144890010356903, 0.4582716226577759, -0.6581663489341736, -0.3001428246498108, -0.0825653225183487, -0.5721630454063416, 0.30904421210289, -0.19450150430202484, -0.12632063031196594, 0.6711863875389099, 0.24205374717712402, -0.7930579781532288, 0.3101601302623749, 0.5735847353935242, -0.041961245238780975, 0.371711403131485, 0.5369603037834167, 0.10938981920480728, -1.0754239559173584, -0.3051638901233673, 0.32130172848701477, -0.42194968461990356, -0.5661532282829285, -0.05639144405722618, -0.044269412755966187, 0.17466597259044647, -0.8762727975845337, 0.5328829288482666, -0.380734920501709, 0.010073776356875896, -0.5203018188476562, 0.4387398064136505, -0.05375742167234421, 0.25530827045440674, 0.3049083948135376, 0.48896604776382446, 0.6057400107383728, -0.2665647864341736, 0.2682058811187744, -0.06901749223470688, -0.5827530026435852, 0.6952120065689087, -0.40264421701431274, 0.26647403836250305, -0.48472723364830017, 0.4468260109424591, -0.9817408919334412, -0.13392938673496246, 0.16821277141571045, -0.326177716255188, 0.403156578540802, -0.34200194478034973, -0.6429600715637207, 0.010510333813726902, -0.41577285528182983, -0.05317742004990578, 0.22799834609031677, -0.525839626789093, 0.5108881592750549, 0.46367648243904114, 0.26798638701438904, -0.7770106196403503, -0.6428923606872559, 0.1305980384349823, -0.317136287689209, -0.10975611954927444, 0.0850788950920105, 0.5312734246253967, -0.39190277457237244, 0.18494710326194763, -0.1479616016149521, 0.19633279740810394, -0.22892236709594727, 0.05918845906853676, 0.44598203897476196, -0.2682614326477051, 0.5091122984886169, -0.19059622287750244, 0.11179405450820923, 0.07485727220773697, -0.3393212556838989, 0.6351332068443298, -0.24892638623714447, -0.09341782331466675, -0.3771041929721832, 0.16562923789024353, 0.6729395389556885, -0.20516081154346466, 1.1198054552078247, 0.451436847448349, -0.416340708732605, -0.3412621021270752, -0.5215196013450623, -0.20551031827926636, -0.30231234431266785, 0.2640310227870941, -0.20773036777973175, -0.7193533182144165, 0.45998814702033997, -0.29096636176109314, -0.24135428667068481, 0.4641270041465759, 0.8324768543243408, -0.17606836557388306, 0.908416211605072, 0.38408324122428894, -0.7393496632575989, 0.44581854343414307, -0.354410856962204, 0.4005826711654663, -0.7836369872093201, -0.06845449656248093, -0.4309590756893158, -0.1963532716035843, -0.6325583457946777, -0.28902751207351685, 0.23726430535316467, 0.04225979000329971, -0.1586880385875702, -0.04575793072581291, -0.2797016203403473, 0.5271547436714172, 0.20436915755271912, 0.06764708459377289, 0.07213250547647476, 0.28535667061805725, 0.10176197439432144, 0.03904380276799202, -0.44915980100631714, -0.7585431337356567, 0.9022583961486816, 0.4930236339569092, 0.859127938747406, -0.15090851485729218, 0.9657173752784729, 0.1631639003753662, 0.3523154556751251, -1.133852243423462, 0.35623836517333984, -0.15331819653511047, -0.5083800554275513, -0.3038542568683624, -0.43737658858299255, -0.6483206748962402, 0.271220326423645, -0.34448128938674927, -0.6573446989059448, 0.29438889026641846, -0.21287225186824799, -0.2798439562320709, 0.6627067923545837, -0.1848205029964447, 0.6327979564666748, -0.07826311886310577, -0.12820985913276672, -0.29692381620407104, -0.4543697237968445, 0.3734152317047119, 0.06100437417626381, 0.22939614951610565, -0.4385296404361725, -0.3472175598144531, 0.42160284519195557, -0.007082750555127859, 0.9469914436340332, -0.3154955804347992, -0.29665517807006836, 0.3763992488384247, -0.07083550840616226, 0.5900623798370361, 0.2564994692802429, -0.41303470730781555, 0.3307091295719147, -0.273237407207489, -0.33003294467926025, -0.4874366521835327, 0.9969688057899475, -0.9459999203681946, -0.6824942827224731, -0.3366769850254059, -0.3699301481246948, -0.14213114976882935, -0.03336365520954132, 0.4226020276546478, 0.32127177715301514, -0.35323187708854675, 0.4015886187553406, 0.6954694986343384, 0.08916888386011124, 0.39633291959762573, 0.3052719533443451, -0.20459292829036713, -0.36625340580940247, 0.6069485545158386, 0.3316982388496399, 0.16076061129570007, 0.4838690161705017, 0.16120080649852753, -0.3670521378517151, -0.20886731147766113, -0.6297776103019714, 0.15366709232330322, -0.721753716468811, -0.6576962471008301, -0.6025181412696838, 0.09705474227666855, -0.09187788516283035, -0.14734219014644623, -0.5451647043228149, -0.2301928997039795, -0.4926673173904419, -0.1874641627073288, 0.29032421112060547, 0.7570004463195801, 0.33418530225753784, 0.35904476046562195, -0.5206904411315918, 0.3362019956111908, 0.02741682156920433, 0.3856866657733917, -0.18413615226745605, -0.3661979138851166, 0.010547555983066559, 0.14534054696559906, -0.38486507534980774, -1.5491479635238647, 0.3592849671840668, -0.02030675858259201, 0.2930656969547272, 0.5033178329467773, 0.1915394514799118, 0.46551448106765747, -0.5102419257164001, 1.0677129030227661, 0.14197401702404022, -1.122398018836975, 0.7403188943862915, -0.35720932483673096, 0.09692486375570297, 0.4895068109035492, 0.4978852868080139, -0.18117277324199677, -0.7074136734008789, -0.43580493330955505, -0.5864264965057373, 0.5000580549240112, -0.07713697850704193, 0.5004120469093323, -0.56243497133255, 0.4457332193851471, 0.04480433836579323, 0.35403239727020264, -0.8498152494430542, -0.20341354608535767, -0.18316566944122314, -0.21444056928157806, 0.01190185733139515, -0.2761008143424988, -0.11031544953584671, 0.022894175723195076, 0.7031219601631165, -0.29398781061172485, 0.15471601486206055, 0.30178120732307434, -0.06680203229188919, -0.4088861644268036, 0.5707926750183105, 0.5888371467590332, 0.6775326728820801, 0.03302052617073059, 0.11271893233060837, 0.2619875371456146, 0.1147480309009552, 0.16571593284606934, -0.4290757477283478, -0.17183351516723633, 0.44815772771835327, 0.26259899139404297, 0.9123747944831848, 0.2013639211654663, -0.15593145787715912, 0.8903297185897827, 0.19026964902877808, -0.01825898140668869, -0.30885329842567444, -0.36241933703422546, 0.18536260724067688, 0.3141021132469177, 0.43113502860069275, 0.06798035651445389, 0.06151183694601059, -1.0304044485092163, -0.06805814802646637, 0.8298224806785583, -0.39622795581817627, -0.33978116512298584, 0.39332345128059387, 0.0757472962141037, 0.08835462480783463, 0.3942238688468933, -0.25294792652130127, -0.6408860087394714, 0.506973385810852, 0.49333125352859497, 0.8801784515380859, -0.1404264122247696, 0.4310975670814514, 0.11815790832042694, 0.317676842212677, -0.16004034876823425, 0.2566188871860504, 0.22456713020801544, -0.8421109914779663, -0.5429123044013977, -0.5844070315361023, -0.4370421767234802, 0.19900038838386536, -0.7051732540130615, 0.6028911471366882, -0.6104681491851807, -0.4514394998550415, 0.08183163404464722, 0.3101608157157898, -0.6796008944511414, 0.1945146918296814, 0.5358331799507141, 0.9004205465316772, -0.8465527296066284, 0.8495185971260071, 0.7511117458343506, -0.36097049713134766, -0.7922300696372986, 0.38970664143562317, 0.2291693091392517, -0.6024788618087769, 0.44488048553466797, 0.1312873363494873, -0.12292110174894333, -0.1927628368139267, -0.917205274105072, -0.4908180236816406, 0.7009037137031555, 0.5300020575523376, -0.7141043543815613, -0.00205812300555408, -0.016702774912118912, 0.4732404053211212, -0.8771955966949463, -0.021865108981728554, 0.4147394299507141, 0.37962836027145386, -0.03393293544650078, -0.44385311007499695, 0.008750971406698227, 0.3716621398925781, 0.1022002249956131, 0.46483224630355835, -0.7046830058097839, 0.8270223736763, -0.10536544770002365, -0.17704437673091888, -0.2628227472305298, 0.9144635796546936, 0.29251089692115784, 0.3513975143432617, 0.677251398563385, 0.31931596994400024, 0.7284864783287048, 0.013369639404118061, 1.077265977859497, -0.5833744406700134, 0.4896657168865204, 0.9251883029937744, -0.499780535697937, 1.3532086610794067, 0.5796080231666565, 0.1327090710401535, 1.0180068016052246, 0.3261374533176422, 0.07807358354330063, 0.5490496754646301, 0.138519287109375, -0.49412956833839417, -0.29367607831954956, -0.1750023365020752, -0.03718513622879982, 0.7222292423248291, 0.40587660670280457, -0.46928662061691284, -0.2768890857696533, 0.1809670329093933, 0.1343858242034912, 0.05877680703997612, -0.5645451545715332, 0.9269623160362244, 0.39927273988723755, -0.5463480949401855, 0.2194918394088745, -0.038637254387140274, 0.5336586236953735, -0.18085935711860657, -0.004189008846879005, 0.028129911050200462, -0.08121711015701294, -0.2571769952774048, -1.1414319276809692, 0.2008676677942276, 0.2043754756450653, -0.3539738953113556, -0.01071923691779375, 0.8133999705314636, -0.5238708257675171, -0.44045576453208923, 0.3915708065032959, 0.7305137515068054, 0.02389218471944332, -0.2764776945114136, -0.557956337928772, 0.34461510181427, -0.16733017563819885, -0.5701060891151428, 0.19412729144096375, 0.7121989130973816, 0.057753365486860275, 0.2616526484489441, 0.5309266448020935, 0.3351723551750183, -0.40058839321136475, 0.22115640342235565, 0.9739925861358643, -0.6805601119995117, -0.1996268481016159, -1.2564501762390137, 0.3312437832355499, -0.04785611480474472, -0.020153386518359184, 0.5390002131462097, 0.3808537721633911, 0.8934814929962158, -0.1107349619269371, 0.7570328116416931, 0.2706947922706604, 0.4963178336620331, -0.574608325958252, 0.6273669600486755, -0.3999103903770447, 0.23704414069652557, -0.25978294014930725, -0.9098431468009949, -0.3229796290397644, 0.582558810710907, -0.5923399329185486, -0.06431835889816284, 0.5195764899253845, 0.721412718296051, -0.012261527590453625, -0.08342142403125763, 0.3186247646808624, 0.26512935757637024, 0.05187929794192314, 0.22269274294376373, 0.9803059101104736, -0.054684530943632126, 0.4398134648799896, -0.2652169167995453, 0.11274092644453049, -0.0525837168097496, -1.0354279279708862, -1.0231807231903076, -0.3642113208770752, -0.2601504623889923, -0.44124045968055725, 0.08953315764665604, 1.260979413986206, 0.6276007294654846, -0.7146217226982117, -0.08432184159755707, -0.058677561581134796, 0.320869505405426, 0.3169574439525604, -0.314811110496521, 0.37916451692581177, -0.645636260509491, -0.7828186750411987, 0.06576669961214066, 0.4740159511566162, -0.32965087890625, -0.4151991009712219, 0.10385328531265259, -0.2923305630683899, 0.5438156723976135, 0.8325417637825012, -0.014650065451860428, -1.2037920951843262, -0.5805148482322693, 0.0324445515871048, -0.359930157661438, 0.20924386382102966, 0.7479409575462341, -0.9408475160598755, 0.3658376634120941, 0.443002849817276, 0.45985206961631775, 0.1616867631673813, 0.25373467803001404, 0.4066465497016907, -0.983791708946228, 0.15292073786258698, 0.31607282161712646, 0.459459513425827, 0.5055820941925049, -0.44125622510910034, 0.2327553927898407, 0.06360004842281342, -0.4354010224342346, -0.6952419281005859, 0.16310884058475494, -0.8209629058837891, -0.27656129002571106, 1.3744449615478516, -0.04101283848285675, -0.5191138386726379, 0.2925055921077728, -0.11647123843431473, 0.12617723643779755, -0.630172610282898, 0.6739433407783508, 0.6853238940238953, -0.0012201789068058133, -0.5395098924636841, -0.47443798184394836, 0.2333817183971405, 0.1699753999710083, -0.6596771478652954, -0.16522721946239471, 0.44616129994392395, 0.16553181409835815, 0.03513694182038307, 0.6426493525505066, -0.037827931344509125, 0.09810210019350052, -0.2885008454322815, -0.14022214710712433, 0.4654577076435089, -0.40651214122772217, -0.4941434860229492, 0.21192550659179688, -0.10299166291952133, -0.14882399141788483 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04360v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04360v1
Prompt Public Large Language Models to Synthesize Data for Private On-device Applications
2024-04-05T19:14:14
2024-04-05T19:14:14
Shanshan Wu, Zheng Xu, Yanxiang Zhang, Yuanbo Zhang, Daniel Ramage
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
Pre-training on public data is an effective method to improve the performance for federated learning (FL) with differential privacy (DP). This paper investigates how large language models (LLMs) trained on public data can improve the quality of pre-training data for the on-device language models trained with DP and FL. We carefully design LLM prompts to filter and transform existing public data, and generate new data to resemble the real user data distribution. The model pre-trained on our synthetic dataset achieves relative improvement of 19.0% and 22.8% in next word prediction accuracy compared to the baseline model pre-trained on a standard public dataset, when evaluated over the real user data in Gboard (Google Keyboard, a production mobile keyboard application). Furthermore, our method achieves evaluation accuracy better than or comparable to the baseline during the DP FL fine-tuning over millions of mobile devices, and our final model outperforms the baseline in production A/B testing. Our experiments demonstrate the strengths of LLMs in synthesizing data close to the private distribution even without accessing the private data, and also suggest future research directions to further reduce the distribution gap.
[ -0.40136247873306274, -0.3728741407394409, 0.7579903602600098, 0.17073997855186462, -0.1982707977294922, 0.24511846899986267, -0.40283456444740295, -0.2939012348651886, 0.08095237612724304, 0.33507025241851807, -0.5072665214538574, -0.8030126094818115, -0.332483172416687, 0.17338933050632477, -0.37178361415863037, 0.753523051738739, -0.03641902282834053, -0.09945396333932877, -0.10765952616930008, 0.031127896159887314, -0.2730523645877838, -0.7825575470924377, -0.1596391499042511, 0.0015622671926394105, 0.4959034025669098, 0.4567628502845764, 0.6846928000450134, 0.6189704537391663, 0.27028888463974, 0.29464125633239746, 0.008608291856944561, 0.16625334322452545, -0.5671262145042419, 0.12461194396018982, -0.030279675498604774, -0.42627522349357605, -0.4407046437263489, 0.25768712162971497, 0.7260327339172363, 0.5329751372337341, -0.039050012826919556, 0.17253029346466064, 0.01680923067033291, 0.6388640999794006, -0.5891903042793274, 0.1710030734539032, -0.6981633305549622, 0.13432079553604126, -0.3726485073566437, 0.04329608753323555, -0.5101221799850464, -0.7509854435920715, 0.05998300388455391, -0.4385259747505188, 0.3870546519756317, 0.05016902834177017, 0.7733891606330872, 0.0387008935213089, -0.19332869350910187, 0.14626847207546234, -0.8473745584487915, 0.5418394804000854, -0.6177502870559692, 0.8893803954124451, 0.5339722633361816, 0.2597004473209381, -0.37332990765571594, -0.8094859719276428, -0.8009470701217651, -0.44730842113494873, -0.03341758996248245, -0.22713112831115723, -0.030985817313194275, 0.06700117141008377, 0.21184764802455902, 0.3488788604736328, -0.4135449230670929, 0.44476738572120667, -0.27611076831817627, -0.21590407192707062, 0.8843584060668945, 0.13202694058418274, 0.08941256999969482, 0.22426150739192963, -0.08813443779945374, -0.14124469459056854, -1.2114694118499756, -0.08455482125282288, 0.5397124886512756, 0.4660414755344391, -0.14869850873947144, 0.41337358951568604, -0.4920841157436371, 0.8045387864112854, 0.14861714839935303, -0.21228466928005219, 0.38580599427223206, -0.23611143231391907, -0.15644747018814087, 0.15452271699905396, 0.7851243019104004, 0.2532117962837219, 0.14907264709472656, -0.18927143514156342, -0.5129857063293457, -0.15255437791347504, -0.015027854591608047, -0.7966079711914062, -0.2963498532772064, 0.1810658574104309, -0.29903465509414673, -0.32496264576911926, 0.1428857147693634, -0.7893951535224915, -0.7508772611618042, -0.5958528518676758, 0.3053337633609772, 0.202121302485466, -0.1825433373451233, 0.25883591175079346, 0.3819456994533539, -0.2533382177352905, 0.41450390219688416, -1.0922516584396362, 0.29413866996765137, 0.6250690817832947, 0.9439278244972229, -0.09030284732580185, -0.23008525371551514, -0.8003007173538208, 0.08985627442598343, -0.2824000418186188, 0.5797700881958008, -0.4094621241092682, -0.49457308650016785, 0.08453675359487534, -0.009368816390633583, -0.07069304585456848, -0.5769732594490051, 0.3301657438278198, -0.49961143732070923, 0.4435596466064453, -0.259149968624115, -0.5033169388771057, 0.18639782071113586, -0.025148548185825348, -0.5071691870689392, 0.554578959941864, -0.13287407159805298, -0.7331876158714294, 0.3571246266365051, -0.7351431250572205, -0.5376118421554565, 0.10230826586484909, -0.22770538926124573, -0.5012862682342529, 0.2768208682537079, 0.4747546315193176, 0.8698759078979492, -0.2262067347764969, 0.3905129134654999, -0.5381199717521667, -0.31779441237449646, 0.3973696231842041, -0.23367273807525635, 0.5052905082702637, 0.35228967666625977, -0.31131598353385925, 0.08497639745473862, -0.8842523097991943, -0.09254767000675201, -0.1053691878914833, -0.4427233040332794, -0.2584470510482788, 0.0007072084117680788, -0.18302127718925476, 0.06650249660015106, 0.19856998324394226, -0.764779269695282, 0.08924058079719543, -0.43003684282302856, 0.47988417744636536, 1.0007859468460083, -0.19542062282562256, 0.5703258514404297, -0.12246714532375336, 0.5803758502006531, -0.1856028139591217, 0.21801239252090454, -0.12199046462774277, -0.5072700381278992, -0.23352833092212677, -0.36973196268081665, 0.5373018383979797, 0.32508549094200134, -0.3393624722957611, 0.536210298538208, -0.5548931360244751, -0.4046723544597626, -0.4302777647972107, 0.20934408903121948, 0.2219267338514328, 0.6177607178688049, 0.06653708219528198, -0.1988268792629242, -0.3605247139930725, -0.518596351146698, 0.011225218884646893, -0.1271727830171585, -0.2876785397529602, 0.42428210377693176, 0.08877099305391312, -0.4440084993839264, 1.047461986541748, -0.6038509607315063, -0.2816047668457031, -0.12818993628025055, 0.04648163542151451, 0.18396268784999847, 0.23499178886413574, 0.22646890580654144, -0.698298454284668, -0.5009912252426147, 0.03153812885284424, -0.36872732639312744, -0.312866747379303, 0.09785056114196777, 0.05204177275300026, 0.17904557287693024, 0.3315596580505371, -0.6149375438690186, 0.12677526473999023, 0.7819314002990723, -0.23287688195705414, 0.4909001886844635, -0.31453463435173035, 0.08458423614501953, -1.0736340284347534, -0.006519250106066465, -0.090644471347332, -0.24304448068141937, -0.6122227907180786, -0.1969396322965622, 0.206988126039505, -0.5805518627166748, -0.6767510175704956, 0.7244260907173157, -0.4900238811969757, -0.21968144178390503, -0.08801630884408951, 0.17250648140907288, -0.1666530966758728, 0.044267069548368454, 0.10556899756193161, 1.1291346549987793, 0.5975888967514038, -0.7729417681694031, 0.33509376645088196, 0.30333051085472107, -0.5463526844978333, 0.03128202632069588, -0.6605247259140015, 0.20405533909797668, -0.06932038068771362, 0.3022958040237427, -1.0750607252120972, -0.6088407635688782, -0.017329584807157516, -0.18494461476802826, 0.16160951554775238, 0.03750509396195412, -0.7523198127746582, -0.5198230743408203, -0.24631761014461517, -0.06777184456586838, 0.7551959156990051, -0.9542247653007507, 0.31008580327033997, 0.6098914742469788, -0.22080303728580475, -0.3384062647819519, -0.7801788449287415, -0.16115911304950714, -0.19885128736495972, -0.8363978266716003, 0.3976195454597473, -0.004042610060423613, -0.1407913714647293, -0.27076542377471924, -0.02563594840466976, -0.21821296215057373, 0.264617919921875, 0.3408970236778259, 0.1846235692501068, -0.24042180180549622, 0.35707154870033264, 0.25000080466270447, -0.0431179441511631, 0.10669215768575668, -0.22520707547664642, 0.5064645409584045, 0.13229945302009583, -0.2177254557609558, -0.7133414149284363, -0.27606162428855896, 0.3225938379764557, -0.42799705266952515, 0.7776086330413818, 0.26678910851478577, -0.19135068356990814, -0.2206910401582718, -0.4513918459415436, -0.3895071744918823, -0.5923172235488892, -0.04376079514622688, -0.24057431519031525, -0.9683711528778076, 0.4163547158241272, -0.1403328776359558, 0.015701182186603546, -0.22830280661582947, 0.5167986750602722, 0.14370709657669067, 1.098514199256897, 0.43129798769950867, -0.3133856952190399, 0.7288119792938232, -0.047493211925029755, 0.2541588246822357, -0.37267065048217773, -0.11807636171579361, -0.45642927289009094, -0.1792641580104828, -0.6527805924415588, -0.2634251117706299, 0.31828904151916504, -0.055758584290742874, -0.1089472696185112, 0.19319413602352142, -0.34185683727264404, 0.7152159810066223, 0.5031588077545166, 0.354193776845932, 0.1750657707452774, 0.34284764528274536, -0.06257853657007217, 0.0760759562253952, -0.30926045775413513, -0.47684866189956665, 1.4574174880981445, 0.5143888592720032, 0.9092003703117371, -0.05948987603187561, 1.16448974609375, 0.15695388615131378, 0.45824331045150757, -0.3073447644710541, 0.6260490417480469, -0.24976980686187744, -0.4920133948326111, -0.25725752115249634, -0.5853034257888794, -0.8784148693084717, 0.015979556366801262, -0.18005859851837158, -0.7814787030220032, 0.20511890947818756, 0.3789091408252716, -0.50767982006073, 0.033401694148778915, -1.0021048784255981, 0.8275243639945984, -0.15183493494987488, -0.5171641707420349, -0.02226799912750721, -0.36553123593330383, 0.39473772048950195, -0.3794729709625244, 0.1353447288274765, -0.2263031154870987, 0.11143331229686737, 0.6753153800964355, -0.48169994354248047, 0.7404865026473999, -0.4739273488521576, -0.2626802623271942, 0.19819240272045135, -0.14721821248531342, 0.7315464615821838, 0.20992381870746613, -0.19748781621456146, 0.031993791460990906, -0.5555416941642761, -0.053736619651317596, -0.4697830379009247, 0.8418595790863037, -0.7704042792320251, -0.7592642903327942, -0.037272918969392776, -0.26345333456993103, -0.5162323117256165, 0.11549980193376541, 0.15205448865890503, 0.4583284854888916, -0.05079662799835205, 0.38697874546051025, 0.8488194942474365, -0.4337253272533417, 0.22582599520683289, 0.6510089039802551, -0.31994086503982544, -0.22731302678585052, 0.7556574940681458, 0.02109401673078537, 0.07041876018047333, 0.601435661315918, 0.44901031255722046, -1.009098768234253, -0.6870008111000061, -0.42417141795158386, 0.3264610171318054, -0.46773457527160645, -0.2522716224193573, -0.6909853219985962, -0.022563133388757706, -0.6501962542533875, -0.04977458715438843, -0.3748552203178406, -0.35352256894111633, -0.42205503582954407, -0.4253171980381012, 0.5319735407829285, 0.5394660234451294, -0.21557290852069855, 0.6601420044898987, -0.9907745122909546, 0.36676138639450073, 0.3506110906600952, 0.5126721858978271, -0.23510409891605377, -0.560970664024353, -0.08390716463327408, 0.321076899766922, -0.31193017959594727, -0.6918147206306458, 0.3529701828956604, 0.32053619623184204, 0.44319429993629456, 0.24184951186180115, 0.10583077371120453, 0.5311487317085266, -0.6015775799751282, 0.7209243774414062, 0.19608071446418762, -0.9247134327888489, 0.5218971371650696, -0.45618942379951477, 0.22198088467121124, 0.6368250846862793, 0.5752708315849304, -0.28321373462677, -0.4652795195579529, -0.3652663826942444, -0.5551033616065979, 0.7648133635520935, 0.03002738766372204, 0.4893408417701721, 0.2838175892829895, 0.12007391452789307, 0.16715668141841888, 0.3210691511631012, -0.6340566873550415, -0.2272791713476181, -0.008163008838891983, -0.4127107560634613, -0.33723652362823486, -0.05665469542145729, 0.12760917842388153, -0.30820393562316895, 0.38926705718040466, 0.17073991894721985, 0.21701154112815857, -0.11116641014814377, 0.10358947515487671, -0.017581414431333542, 0.24833333492279053, 0.5511071085929871, 0.8192890882492065, -0.10320152342319489, -0.041683364659547806, -0.10290834307670593, -0.6679705381393433, 0.4659985601902008, 0.49953731894493103, -0.2846703827381134, 0.06530410051345825, -0.05557345971465111, 0.7874003052711487, 0.021972382441163063, -0.5893296003341675, 0.6253095269203186, -0.3000712990760803, -0.07889411598443985, -0.047143980860710144, 0.2249927520751953, 0.07098359614610672, 0.059696000069379807, 0.25106891989707947, -0.2672935426235199, -0.002879614708945155, -0.3351915776729584, 0.2521192133426666, 0.10419778525829315, 0.1380598098039627, -0.533887505531311, 0.8860219120979309, 0.48923948407173157, -0.30502405762672424, 0.5744224190711975, -0.1972021907567978, -0.33416205644607544, 0.17720556259155273, 0.4917161166667938, 0.7574113011360168, -0.5915271639823914, 0.5673978924751282, 0.05650348961353302, -0.012238765135407448, -0.40747156739234924, 0.3331637680530548, -0.172617107629776, -0.62570720911026, -0.41506847739219666, -0.7352320551872253, -0.2775920033454895, 0.5095593333244324, -0.19856001436710358, 0.42853352427482605, -0.7331377267837524, -0.16596609354019165, -0.14531747996807098, 0.02195802889764309, -0.7595896124839783, 0.28496044874191284, 0.26808586716651917, 0.6090931296348572, -0.9038280844688416, 1.0233608484268188, 0.4730560779571533, -0.13895580172538757, -1.0482041835784912, 0.11757108569145203, -0.19211453199386597, -0.5897074937820435, 0.7293643951416016, 0.2626848518848419, 0.13764111697673798, 0.10452063381671906, -0.4362642168998718, -0.8730908632278442, 0.8019049763679504, 0.6051408052444458, -1.0744343996047974, 0.20672044157981873, 0.41777491569519043, 0.6899828314781189, -0.2530824542045593, -0.10308732837438583, 0.2651751935482025, 0.4641727805137634, -0.28518807888031006, -0.9741403460502625, 0.19465060532093048, 0.19897417724132538, -0.0891101285815239, 0.2897348701953888, -0.19175416231155396, 0.8029776811599731, -0.227030411362648, -0.41641491651535034, -0.14021389186382294, 0.6536113023757935, 0.3281361162662506, 0.4812454879283905, 0.3052704632282257, 0.2911282181739807, 1.077873945236206, 0.10028689354658127, 1.0559924840927124, -0.19860140979290009, 0.10478804260492325, 1.112569808959961, -0.678659975528717, 0.8112594485282898, 0.20573748648166656, -0.20489028096199036, 0.2653309106826782, 0.621016800403595, 0.18719276785850525, 0.9025401473045349, 0.3306940495967865, -0.5459291934967041, 0.11016970127820969, 0.08875075727701187, -0.5219210386276245, 0.2143954485654831, 0.14789725840091705, -0.5156755447387695, -0.07268961519002914, 0.3646630048751831, -0.13689090311527252, 0.3260987401008606, -0.3661416172981262, 0.6339977979660034, 0.013734170235693455, -0.41474172472953796, 0.8004228472709656, 0.22238466143608093, 0.5956965088844299, -0.4882861375808716, 0.48234444856643677, -0.4487774074077606, 0.3639325201511383, -0.18461893498897552, -0.5822744369506836, -0.0020319281611591578, 0.19686757028102875, 0.06186719611287117, -0.4129483699798584, 0.5505359172821045, -0.4332456588745117, -0.31618016958236694, 0.04020753130316734, 0.272286593914032, 0.24774083495140076, -0.28526902198791504, -0.5520328879356384, 0.12599682807922363, 0.06155633553862572, -0.3083503544330597, 0.4344881772994995, 0.4349921643733978, -0.012859047390520573, 0.5509445071220398, 0.7879616022109985, 0.1690959930419922, 0.400875449180603, 0.24302880465984344, 1.0259604454040527, -0.3516899645328522, -0.8000977039337158, -0.7087537050247192, 0.3232385218143463, -0.019732890650629997, -0.22298139333724976, 0.8242855668067932, 0.520829439163208, 1.1045221090316772, -0.37714484333992004, 0.8182968497276306, 0.11775760352611542, 0.6819025874137878, -0.6726191639900208, 0.9059742093086243, -0.3415125608444214, 0.28679898381233215, 0.012017558328807354, -1.0520025491714478, -0.23469677567481995, 0.44818127155303955, -0.7333216071128845, -0.17489956319332123, 0.4200892448425293, 1.1009252071380615, -0.4487965404987335, 0.18287861347198486, 0.348388135433197, 0.10020039975643158, 0.29881131649017334, 0.28894874453544617, 0.8856944441795349, -0.2625862956047058, 0.2204996794462204, -0.3952944278717041, -0.12278594076633453, -0.18054470419883728, -0.8122529983520508, -0.9016864895820618, -0.6359323859214783, -0.20245948433876038, -0.08582442253828049, 0.25992053747177124, 0.9538266062736511, 0.9213222861289978, -0.7700299620628357, -0.23742714524269104, -0.3963080048561096, 0.07330448180437088, 0.2586469054222107, -0.15196599066257477, 0.1888304203748703, -0.2126585692167282, -0.6166366934776306, 0.6437711119651794, -0.1905427724123001, 0.45742127299308777, -0.27078497409820557, -0.23058290779590607, 0.2177739292383194, -0.24252748489379883, 0.5307672619819641, 0.22377228736877441, -0.3299292325973511, -0.12150628864765167, -0.05994104966521263, -0.05568158999085426, -0.031384095549583435, 0.9505648016929626, -0.7998121380805969, 0.3480755686759949, 0.6057178974151611, 0.7604478001594543, 0.38883277773857117, 0.25203433632850647, 0.7699304819107056, -1.031347393989563, 0.4243875741958618, 0.14152021706104279, 0.1471613198518753, 0.4878543019294739, -0.5883016586303711, 0.18073953688144684, -0.010566849261522293, -0.6000463962554932, -1.1227797269821167, 0.13671638071537018, -0.41794857382774353, -0.035411085933446884, 1.2288286685943604, -0.4446185231208801, -0.4240875840187073, 0.02327548898756504, -0.02342819608747959, -0.03220415860414505, -0.7052683234214783, 0.9871633648872375, 0.4144972860813141, 0.17927603423595428, 0.05540391802787781, -0.11816699802875519, 0.6659303903579712, -0.0015065270708873868, -0.9880187511444092, 0.44799336791038513, 0.6936783790588379, 0.24257305264472961, -0.058533675968647, 0.8101257085800171, -0.039799027144908905, 0.21795883774757385, -0.2669926881790161, -0.25021857023239136, -0.38539451360702515, -0.6451477408409119, -0.5286802053451538, -0.010876921936869621, 0.09451375156641006, -0.3744576871395111 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04351v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04351v1
Assisting humans in complex comparisons: automated information comparison at scale
2024-04-05T18:44:54
2024-04-05T18:44:54
Truman Yuen, Graham A. Watt, Yuri Lawryshyn
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.8
Generative Large Language Models enable efficient analytics across knowledge domains, rivalling human experts in information comparisons. However, the applications of LLMs for information comparisons face scalability challenges due to the difficulties in maintaining information across large contexts and overcoming model token limitations. To address these challenges, we developed the novel Abstractive Summarization \& Criteria-driven Comparison Endpoint (ASC$^2$End) system to automate information comparison at scale. Our system employs Semantic Text Similarity comparisons for generating evidence-supported analyses. We utilize proven data-handling strategies such as abstractive summarization and retrieval augmented generation to overcome token limitations and retain relevant information during model inference. Prompts were designed using zero-shot strategies to contextualize information for improved model reasoning. We evaluated abstractive summarization using ROUGE scoring and assessed the generated comparison quality using survey responses. Models evaluated on the ASC$^2$End system show desirable results providing insights on the expected performance of the system. ASC$^2$End is a novel system and tool that enables accurate, automated information comparison at scale across knowledge domains, overcoming limitations in context length and retrieval.
[ -0.3923942744731903, -0.646185576915741, 0.5515314340591431, 0.09630763530731201, -0.2249062955379486, 0.2220751792192459, -0.28460776805877686, -0.6991924047470093, 0.05024594068527222, 0.3203659653663635, -0.17287403345108032, -0.6394233107566833, -0.5938882827758789, 0.3965170383453369, -0.7133334279060364, 0.8201058506965637, -0.18025057017803192, 0.007977564819157124, -0.5953105688095093, -0.3441058099269867, -0.0004306663468014449, -0.30963507294654846, -1.2535353899002075, -0.4759970009326935, 0.3137187063694, 0.3916066288948059, 0.7390133738517761, 0.5710367560386658, 0.8511381149291992, 0.384877473115921, -0.1038331687450409, 0.44628357887268066, -0.42540308833122253, 0.39662453532218933, -0.21026602387428284, -0.4348450303077698, -0.6532626748085022, -0.0524248331785202, 0.4099520146846771, 0.7337231040000916, -0.011902094818651676, 0.26770198345184326, -0.00553333992138505, 0.7508047223091125, -0.7808724045753479, 0.18520404398441315, -0.4862612783908844, -0.036885544657707214, 0.24460233747959137, -0.3556927442550659, -0.3554942309856415, -0.448292076587677, -0.05710616707801819, -0.5563525557518005, 0.1327725648880005, 0.2052708864212036, 0.7698438167572021, 0.3372267782688141, -0.7774425745010376, -0.5371170043945312, -0.42123448848724365, 0.5301834344863892, -1.0028314590454102, 0.13773179054260254, 0.1216304749250412, 0.4739407002925873, 0.04589365795254707, -0.6532270312309265, -0.6859025955200195, -0.2662661075592041, -0.15570764243602753, 0.11003188043832779, -0.5136578679084778, 0.15988504886627197, 0.3339918851852417, 0.303356796503067, -0.6657851338386536, 0.2638254463672638, -0.4192988872528076, -0.04235612973570824, 0.6478367447853088, 0.33951762318611145, 0.11991466581821442, -0.28323638439178467, -0.2247815877199173, -0.2382637858390808, -0.8034764528274536, -0.0355682335793972, 0.27031075954437256, 0.15561075508594513, 0.0023783768992871046, 0.7623767852783203, -0.5979967713356018, 0.6758393049240112, -0.046738702803850174, 0.10948135703802109, 0.2019175887107849, -0.27682751417160034, -0.29156944155693054, -0.14404113590717316, 0.7771133780479431, 1.088801383972168, 0.11140750348567963, -0.2840706706047058, -0.49126219749450684, 0.1266285479068756, 0.10912125557661057, -0.9350407719612122, 0.10088838636875153, 0.2788696885108948, -0.7006319165229797, -0.2698407769203186, 0.07460493594408035, -0.4735977351665497, -0.33205440640449524, -0.6508665084838867, 0.5413843989372253, -0.17521832883358002, 0.04885537922382355, -0.08419006317853928, -0.32573843002319336, 0.23271924257278442, 0.5437794327735901, -0.7519566416740417, 0.704488217830658, 0.646377444267273, 1.1628470420837402, -0.6027178764343262, 0.006420329213142395, -0.2494845986366272, 0.12659025192260742, -0.5604405403137207, 1.0100376605987549, -0.39775151014328003, -0.39038923382759094, -0.23345138132572174, -0.256623774766922, 0.38861650228500366, -1.0540845394134521, 0.4477350413799286, -0.5822184681892395, 0.04828380048274994, -0.13281404972076416, -0.5731911659240723, -0.15363015234470367, 0.5145508646965027, -0.5113769769668579, 0.9823219776153564, 0.11311916261911392, -0.7824259400367737, 0.48949915170669556, -0.5973566174507141, -0.43103164434432983, -0.1593044400215149, -0.4592103958129883, -0.34332865476608276, -0.10674241930246353, -0.13267679512500763, 0.4114682376384735, -0.7862064242362976, 0.09831101447343826, -0.1455182135105133, -0.3292246162891388, -0.060177143663167953, -0.1581200510263443, 0.5342082381248474, 0.42059481143951416, -0.3821628987789154, 0.5368752479553223, -0.8194758892059326, 0.13247397541999817, -0.006630013696849346, -0.5169796347618103, -0.3893898129463196, -0.08915748447179794, 0.03196242079138756, 0.1198044866323471, 0.5204849243164062, -0.3523862361907959, 0.1093706414103508, 0.015949159860610962, 0.35274070501327515, 0.47127655148506165, -0.1649274080991745, 0.44994789361953735, -0.29545366764068604, 0.2975011169910431, -0.1723126918077469, -0.04278790205717087, -0.36197108030319214, -0.2389783263206482, -0.7799434065818787, -0.23886147141456604, 0.37806436419487, 0.6293164491653442, -0.49613264203071594, 0.7946031093597412, -0.351961225271225, -0.4090476930141449, -0.2755802869796753, -0.24586056172847748, 0.46055230498313904, 0.5017764568328857, 0.5100653171539307, -0.337593674659729, -0.487081378698349, -1.1209228038787842, -0.17997033894062042, -0.3065527081489563, -0.8668994903564453, 0.3282846212387085, 0.44363370537757874, -0.24311573803424835, 0.9452927112579346, -0.5306838750839233, -0.14975489675998688, -0.18197977542877197, 0.4158376157283783, 0.10426205396652222, 0.23923222720623016, 0.18324610590934753, -0.7051632404327393, -0.3879786431789398, 0.23474866151809692, -1.0900840759277344, -0.2908977270126343, -0.08167781680822372, 0.10586129128932953, 0.13630937039852142, 0.6767551898956299, -0.6661005020141602, 0.440672367811203, 0.09522775560617447, -0.6933923959732056, 0.3991719186306, -0.5267834067344666, 0.7635610699653625, -0.9773536324501038, 0.2985991835594177, -0.2986977994441986, -0.4739472270011902, -0.41576603055000305, 0.07345058023929596, 0.19878073036670685, 0.08675511926412582, 0.13196107745170593, 0.5019869208335876, -0.36265188455581665, -0.5875025391578674, -0.45150384306907654, 0.4021415114402771, 0.13191887736320496, 0.22059787809848785, 0.050985198467969894, 0.6317378878593445, 0.1917084902524948, -0.5410956144332886, 0.49696996808052063, 0.1522926390171051, -0.1508553922176361, 0.5732029676437378, -0.7781655192375183, -0.1361587941646576, -0.030193284153938293, 0.3518119156360626, -1.0203393697738647, -0.06577708572149277, -0.12739455699920654, -0.6933721303939819, 0.24179641902446747, 0.31961768865585327, -0.7737811803817749, -0.02278873138129711, -0.6343516707420349, 0.4865061938762665, 0.5848402976989746, -0.28389596939086914, 0.5985095500946045, 0.25803297758102417, -0.4640651345252991, -0.38177430629730225, -0.5101909041404724, 0.49157464504241943, -0.09494277089834213, -0.6698893904685974, 0.19225062429904938, -0.13994616270065308, -0.7325984835624695, -0.11243470758199692, -0.14956484735012054, 0.23618662357330322, -0.08834648877382278, 0.05943555757403374, 0.3199765086174011, -0.2180434763431549, -0.016249090433120728, 0.38060611486434937, -0.14225277304649353, 0.09822911769151688, -0.22130507230758667, 0.2394312620162964, -0.10963830351829529, -0.39758026599884033, -0.14577935636043549, 0.3972768187522888, 0.780892550945282, 0.12034770846366882, 0.4160948097705841, 0.06803346425294876, -0.4302659034729004, 0.25815361738204956, -0.7047552466392517, -0.25501009821891785, -0.3803161084651947, 0.25011956691741943, -0.37831878662109375, -0.8516175746917725, 0.5880312919616699, -0.12300868332386017, 0.3521715998649597, 0.6248660087585449, 0.5379287600517273, 0.13992883265018463, 1.061140537261963, 0.34455907344818115, 0.10286074131727219, 0.08117057383060455, -0.21828997135162354, 0.15587957203388214, -0.732296884059906, -0.3292071223258972, -0.4670190215110779, -0.43740198016166687, -0.23922564089298248, -0.582727313041687, 0.5059124827384949, 0.24415689706802368, -0.4482632279396057, 0.3577654957771301, -0.39731067419052124, 0.4985028803348541, 0.2630619406700134, -0.1315358430147171, 0.8690386414527893, -0.09470248967409134, 0.029567690566182137, 0.2035207599401474, -0.4309331774711609, -0.6948410272598267, 1.2371959686279297, 0.32085326313972473, 0.7378254532814026, 0.44112420082092285, 0.2246270626783371, 0.7305232286453247, 0.40221503376960754, -0.7223999500274658, 0.6958849430084229, -0.17823491990566254, -0.22708094120025635, -0.6819336414337158, -0.6115589737892151, -0.6692728996276855, 0.3667541742324829, -0.26342907547950745, -0.5920499563217163, 0.018289130181074142, -0.04374801740050316, -0.34510523080825806, 0.2722238004207611, -0.5377935767173767, 0.6170499324798584, 0.07288510352373123, -0.28316617012023926, -0.33738383650779724, -0.9964540600776672, 0.12196353077888489, -0.052503351122140884, 0.06874980032444, -0.1400219202041626, -0.36951959133148193, 0.8119516372680664, -0.6257970333099365, 0.3339426815509796, 0.11805961281061172, -0.08293764293193817, 0.15901246666908264, 0.19891086220741272, 0.4264090657234192, -0.06520703434944153, -0.2169228494167328, 0.2528012692928314, -0.07900188118219376, -0.2917993366718292, -0.8657860159873962, 0.6313856840133667, -0.7354885339736938, -0.30328118801116943, -0.20526006817817688, -0.5145850777626038, 0.015100914053618908, 0.20585939288139343, 0.32526278495788574, 0.48009946942329407, 0.06913574039936066, 0.17931519448757172, 0.6482676267623901, 0.014654427766799927, 0.24424447119235992, 0.9184188842773438, -0.15569643676280975, -0.12103665620088577, 0.6430956721305847, -0.10867661982774734, 0.39946281909942627, 0.8091781139373779, -0.10280168056488037, -0.5169489979743958, -0.5539814829826355, -0.6495267748832703, -0.08154315501451492, -0.8857012987136841, -0.5270510911941528, -0.858281672000885, -0.11460614204406738, -0.4696716070175171, -0.3831833600997925, -0.18163514137268066, -0.5913639068603516, -0.03366566449403763, -0.17858223617076874, 0.17998677492141724, 0.8900435566902161, -0.049947090446949005, 0.05307715758681297, -0.4342750608921051, 0.3782041668891907, 0.09406382590532303, 0.10499271005392075, 0.1274084895849228, -0.6357943415641785, 0.011105440557003021, -0.37767770886421204, -0.2567559480667114, -0.5606597661972046, 0.10130711644887924, 0.09486580640077591, 0.306551456451416, 0.645670473575592, -0.013532559387385845, 0.37933623790740967, -0.3871055841445923, 0.6384801864624023, 0.2754494845867157, -0.9549566507339478, 0.4125522971153259, -0.27555185556411743, 0.49843040108680725, 0.7292078733444214, 0.2848881185054779, -0.5965853333473206, -0.4707053005695343, -0.42325180768966675, -1.2047150135040283, 0.46369469165802, 0.45945191383361816, -0.42503854632377625, 0.057018548250198364, 0.43950706720352173, 0.1875680834054947, 0.289035439491272, -0.3064991533756256, -0.3155514597892761, 0.11613161116838455, -0.2890014946460724, -0.016329769045114517, -0.1461644023656845, 0.09248753637075424, 0.10466507077217102, 0.5354440808296204, -0.3473955988883972, -0.06615552306175232, 0.23780547082424164, -0.02658790908753872, -0.07639656960964203, 0.2543223202228546, 0.3961850106716156, 0.8245492577552795, -0.01452355831861496, 0.4208375811576843, 0.5349535942077637, -0.16072747111320496, 0.1234254240989685, -0.039158646017313004, -0.2948005199432373, 0.05379897356033325, 0.5632452368736267, 0.4313509166240692, 0.3689037561416626, -1.1759990453720093, 0.5570648312568665, -0.32556504011154175, -0.057852812111377716, -0.299105703830719, -0.0007641077972948551, 0.12799318134784698, 0.3021218478679657, 0.5012415647506714, 0.15053842961788177, 0.7161102294921875, -0.5809953808784485, 0.31061112880706787, 0.42507970333099365, -0.09641163796186447, 0.07922247052192688, 0.6407596468925476, 0.17991775274276733, -0.3181813657283783, 0.6078680753707886, -0.3273910582065582, -0.06889808177947998, 0.8034484386444092, 0.2747810482978821, 0.4299127757549286, -0.2345297485589981, -0.13124778866767883, 0.48430657386779785, 0.07943808287382126, -0.21634645760059357, 0.19551628828048706, -0.5111535787582397, -0.494266539812088, -0.2271469533443451, -0.5080464482307434, -0.5267687439918518, -0.12579067051410675, -0.8048389554023743, 0.3976447284221649, -0.4055202305316925, 0.03981183096766472, 0.04912335053086281, -0.12314780056476593, -0.271135151386261, 0.3684842884540558, -0.039039403200149536, 1.1659951210021973, -0.8226938247680664, 0.2617456316947937, 0.5414470434188843, -0.3568284511566162, -0.5398327708244324, -0.15378578007221222, 0.1018226146697998, -0.45700302720069885, 0.6855984330177307, 0.2200261503458023, -0.46497809886932373, -0.23567016422748566, -0.28444230556488037, -0.6025199294090271, 1.4348185062408447, 0.19817480444908142, -0.5084648132324219, -0.1760638952255249, -0.0003994742000941187, 0.796825647354126, -0.5733495354652405, 0.8773739337921143, 0.7864170074462891, 0.38404572010040283, 0.5772721171379089, -0.9909713268280029, 0.25269365310668945, -0.4292739927768707, -0.2865661382675171, 0.23761394619941711, -0.4355165958404541, 0.9129964709281921, -0.3521578907966614, -0.2485077977180481, 0.23795568943023682, 0.6870229244232178, 0.2773574888706207, 0.576987087726593, 0.6525323390960693, 0.45224088430404663, 0.5452096462249756, 0.111496202647686, 0.6358780860900879, -0.3767542243003845, 0.408414363861084, 1.3116947412490845, -0.4105720520019531, 1.0175747871398926, 0.1749560534954071, -0.31352412700653076, 0.42987728118896484, 0.884572446346283, 0.004694262519478798, 0.1992618888616562, 0.4752953052520752, -0.4756815731525421, -0.021461432799696922, -0.2097627818584442, -0.09834848344326019, 0.22173555195331573, 0.39027801156044006, -0.31360554695129395, -0.46908244490623474, -0.391020804643631, -0.08256761729717255, 0.1441674381494522, -0.4155438244342804, 1.0657509565353394, -0.005541910883039236, -0.6386327743530273, 0.4516061544418335, 0.2886641025543213, 0.663114070892334, -0.7453871369361877, -0.16074755787849426, -0.1871017962694168, -0.022367458790540695, -0.476194828748703, -0.6306924819946289, 0.4338231086730957, 0.143032506108284, -0.2999563217163086, 0.0892963781952858, 0.5804265141487122, -0.5163121223449707, -0.22537222504615784, 0.46025630831718445, 0.3383258581161499, 0.4495605230331421, -0.2029758095741272, -0.4897649586200714, 0.03129732981324196, -0.18136100471019745, -0.14139729738235474, 0.19842912256717682, 0.34010589122772217, -0.386430561542511, 0.9364768266677856, 0.39842700958251953, 0.052175842225551605, -0.36916279792785645, 0.22473733127117157, 0.8958345651626587, -0.5830309987068176, -0.6957414150238037, -0.7750487327575684, 0.1946609765291214, -0.46531835198402405, -0.12927116453647614, 0.6242139935493469, 1.1266603469848633, 0.6632444262504578, 0.19007641077041626, 0.9456084966659546, -0.17957572638988495, 0.6062729358673096, -0.3806478679180145, 0.7041312456130981, -0.7251681685447693, 0.4140092432498932, 0.09965697675943375, -0.8555195331573486, -0.21626733243465424, 0.45432615280151367, -0.22327806055545807, -0.015189560130238533, 0.8585062026977539, 0.7854601144790649, -0.055904801934957504, 0.006427921820431948, 0.46376416087150574, 0.25951579213142395, 0.2985822558403015, 0.33559083938598633, 0.48160189390182495, -0.30139660835266113, 0.39423173666000366, 0.46207958459854126, -0.6925760507583618, -0.31506967544555664, -0.5838077664375305, -0.8538232445716858, -0.6467028260231018, -0.0696265697479248, -0.26519903540611267, 0.11866436153650284, 1.1535784006118774, 0.5285524725914001, -0.8742218017578125, -0.26289457082748413, -0.015866950154304504, 0.012129692360758781, 0.18729841709136963, -0.2276603877544403, 0.4272569715976715, -0.2206299751996994, -0.6179075837135315, 0.21399201452732086, 0.7917234301567078, -0.05540817603468895, -0.4451247453689575, 0.03573932871222496, 0.14553752541542053, 0.14093700051307678, 0.770228922367096, 0.09657624363899231, -0.7792681455612183, -0.1502963900566101, -0.1435733437538147, -0.2420247495174408, -0.04308173060417175, 1.2509043216705322, -0.6563964486122131, 0.31219539046287537, 0.5975443124771118, 0.7099184393882751, 0.23695549368858337, 0.1667071431875229, 0.6727375984191895, -0.3593064546585083, -0.20020367205142975, 0.15556882321834564, 0.19569535553455353, 0.44056692719459534, -0.4612748622894287, 0.6884613037109375, -0.15117615461349487, -0.5410636067390442, -0.4407944977283478, 0.29011401534080505, -0.9177785515785217, -0.4170462191104889, 1.0802178382873535, -0.32858699560165405, 0.035154588520526886, -0.250896692276001, -0.2179339975118637, 0.27016687393188477, -0.48061248660087585, 1.0682319402694702, 0.41687166690826416, -0.45550253987312317, 0.2731834352016449, -0.3042994737625122, 0.4028751850128174, 0.2600277364253998, -1.16837739944458, 0.09845754504203796, 0.33970576524734497, 0.19853562116622925, 0.1545780748128891, 0.7131548523902893, -0.04232276231050491, 0.16311217844486237, 0.0749911367893219, 0.18493212759494781, 0.09150759875774384, -0.12276257574558258, -0.33696219325065613, 0.14268909394741058, -0.016533028334379196, 0.1832810342311859 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04332v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04332v1
Scope Ambiguities in Large Language Models
2024-04-05T18:01:02
2024-04-05T18:01:02
Gaurav Kamath, Sebastian Schuster, Sowmya Vajjala, Siva Reddy
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Sentences containing multiple semantic operators with overlapping scope often create ambiguities in interpretation, known as scope ambiguities. These ambiguities offer rich insights into the interaction between semantic structure and world knowledge in language processing. Despite this, there has been little research into how modern large language models treat them. In this paper, we investigate how different versions of certain autoregressive language models -- GPT-2, GPT-3/3.5, Llama 2 and GPT-4 -- treat scope ambiguous sentences, and compare this with human judgments. We introduce novel datasets that contain a joint total of almost 1,000 unique scope-ambiguous sentences, containing interactions between a range of semantic operators, and annotated for human judgments. Using these datasets, we find evidence that several models (i) are sensitive to the meaning ambiguity in these sentences, in a way that patterns well with human judgments, and (ii) can successfully identify human-preferred readings at a high level of accuracy (over 90% in some cases).
[ -0.2685175836086273, -0.7011539340019226, 0.8292570114135742, 0.08318331837654114, -0.17135824263095856, -0.11836442351341248, -0.1864016056060791, -0.9951947331428528, -0.0809810534119606, 0.4781855344772339, -0.512382447719574, -0.2255363017320633, -1.1297500133514404, 0.11053171008825302, -0.6137653589248657, 0.6765068173408508, -0.2482578456401825, -0.2011042684316635, 0.2806715965270996, -0.37179094552993774, -0.474276602268219, -0.6182758212089539, -0.0548173263669014, -0.26155269145965576, 0.5032160878181458, 0.1670820713043213, 1.2976545095443726, 0.5080690383911133, 0.8115183711051941, 0.2732514441013336, -0.005490540526807308, 0.04712304100394249, -0.08377820998430252, 0.27532368898391724, -0.18042318522930145, -0.46575671434402466, -0.37632569670677185, -0.09939401596784592, 0.8042866587638855, 0.9385924339294434, 0.029766486957669258, 0.05916965380311012, -0.1084582731127739, 0.532690167427063, -0.7334503531455994, 0.26401659846305847, -0.7739191055297852, 0.0734509527683258, -0.29922863841056824, 0.36659207940101624, -0.17558935284614563, 0.21740935742855072, 0.4223680794239044, -0.6858845353126526, 0.18026497960090637, -0.11946181207895279, 1.1323041915893555, 0.4622769057750702, -0.8508912920951843, -0.42858392000198364, -0.5505012273788452, 0.8722106218338013, -0.6313836574554443, 0.4566113352775574, 0.37860026955604553, 0.22773726284503937, -0.13920363783836365, -0.41035979986190796, -0.5046696662902832, 0.05642389878630638, -0.1962817907333374, -0.07014814764261246, -0.5738117098808289, -0.058782465755939484, 0.27455875277519226, 0.14852380752563477, -0.5583289861679077, 0.24606014788150787, -0.27900874614715576, -0.09587051719427109, 0.5030528903007507, 0.02180643565952778, 0.10498002171516418, -0.5435325503349304, -0.3968888223171234, -0.18502137064933777, -0.7384639978408813, -0.20285162329673767, 0.7015565037727356, -0.0051983012817800045, 0.023392902687191963, 0.8879859447479248, -0.41130197048187256, 1.2849291563034058, -0.1916719228029251, 0.4734264612197876, 0.23463359475135803, -0.33211374282836914, -0.27087488770484924, -0.47978436946868896, 0.8030304312705994, 0.346875935792923, 0.40737274289131165, -0.2500782012939453, -0.19685319066047668, 0.2548481822013855, 0.24491667747497559, -0.17140503227710724, 0.010586789809167385, 0.015133523382246494, -0.23164509236812592, -0.255551278591156, 0.2584720253944397, -0.5535145401954651, -0.09144831448793411, -0.28165608644485474, 0.5273326635360718, -0.023889916017651558, -0.1641560047864914, 0.4782363176345825, -0.13187934458255768, 0.2939368784427643, 0.3334689736366272, -0.8801072835922241, 0.2393731027841568, 0.5490174293518066, 0.5647338628768921, -0.1068492904305458, -0.5590538382530212, -0.4633685350418091, 0.2929064929485321, -0.09975799173116684, 0.7545714974403381, -0.774368405342102, -0.2450413852930069, -0.2709951400756836, 0.02649533562362194, -0.004584852140396833, -0.3817744255065918, 0.40930891036987305, -0.5736520886421204, 0.3768157362937927, -0.44462499022483826, -0.3853364884853363, -0.25130245089530945, 0.26015111804008484, -0.6001235246658325, 0.4115453362464905, 0.19563360512256622, -0.7948693037033081, 0.6088415384292603, -0.6015854477882385, -0.1715361624956131, -0.1833457499742508, -0.3833319842815399, -0.21385906636714935, 0.26210737228393555, 0.22478745877742767, 0.25151491165161133, -0.3432203233242035, 0.414413720369339, -0.06798253208398819, -0.1753331571817398, 0.44297999143600464, -0.562404990196228, 0.6767746806144714, 0.42789721488952637, -0.27125972509384155, 0.021777179092168808, -0.39997193217277527, 0.08264359086751938, 0.02955225482583046, -0.13936153054237366, -0.3847144842147827, 0.00681870523840189, -0.04949304088950157, 0.13512852787971497, 0.2219039350748062, -0.2804729640483856, 0.3466669023036957, -0.30079901218414307, 0.6959872841835022, 0.49069833755493164, -0.029113877564668655, 0.2707095146179199, -0.3698778450489044, 0.5018810629844666, 0.3756174147129059, 0.0824451670050621, -0.020953446626663208, -0.8204885125160217, -0.6713755130767822, 0.16619417071342468, 0.1376160830259323, 0.5601113438606262, -0.2622189521789551, 0.3567127585411072, -0.3018728792667389, -0.1053570806980133, -0.32384735345840454, 0.10942338407039642, 0.2986645996570587, 0.14345617592334747, 0.305295467376709, -0.3259855806827545, -0.3019546568393707, -1.2253926992416382, -0.7528448700904846, -0.3180099427700043, -0.20237722992897034, 0.32122570276260376, 0.5144869685173035, -0.5926661491394043, 1.2469145059585571, -0.696061909198761, -0.1578763872385025, 0.2692141532897949, 0.4581723213195801, -0.06475389748811722, 0.15152359008789062, 0.39430662989616394, -1.1144568920135498, -0.20290005207061768, -0.08414968848228455, -0.6637535691261292, -0.22990453243255615, -0.08071393519639969, 0.006684883497655392, 0.12348555773496628, 0.33767905831336975, -0.7315049171447754, 0.5256690979003906, 0.6386737823486328, -0.6084908246994019, 0.36711281538009644, -0.17321303486824036, 0.09527643769979477, -0.8363279104232788, -0.22418011724948883, -0.08820545673370361, -0.35115182399749756, -0.5202208757400513, 0.3131771981716156, 0.28590795397758484, 0.3110975921154022, -0.34026411175727844, 0.5626941919326782, -0.5853850245475769, -0.20118576288223267, -0.15564900636672974, 0.309826135635376, 0.1668706089258194, 0.19966597855091095, 0.06929685175418854, 0.5005608201026917, 0.3488385081291199, -0.3929397761821747, 0.23590421676635742, 0.40095314383506775, -0.3918223977088928, 0.2656797468662262, -0.565221905708313, -0.04192429035902023, -0.07443266361951828, 0.22016213834285736, -0.9686393737792969, -0.5854935646057129, 0.3048063814640045, -0.33151134848594666, 0.15962621569633484, -0.04006053879857063, -0.5990358591079712, -0.31916168332099915, 0.09993095695972443, 0.7332296371459961, 0.21473507583141327, -0.39772677421569824, 0.21289493143558502, 0.46155354380607605, 0.1695868968963623, -0.9494057297706604, -0.9517818093299866, 0.2939033806324005, -0.3660016357898712, -0.6750496625900269, 0.003292652778327465, 0.30118945240974426, -0.6594604849815369, 0.2749107778072357, -0.1373792141675949, -0.18420757353305817, 0.027391022071242332, 0.16616208851337433, 0.15370136499404907, 0.060816872864961624, 0.2302832007408142, -0.14337220788002014, 0.01913178153336048, 0.05636553466320038, -0.21844205260276794, 0.09496913105249405, -0.32606300711631775, -0.6923438906669617, 0.1321367770433426, 0.4120349884033203, 0.6481876373291016, -0.08497030287981033, 0.31993502378463745, 0.3459329307079315, -0.47465598583221436, 0.30856165289878845, -0.7947881817817688, 0.07534851878881454, -0.39331749081611633, 0.4972943663597107, -0.5626183152198792, -0.9989524483680725, 0.7299849390983582, 0.4525637924671173, -0.15709136426448822, 0.5454809069633484, 0.6460493803024292, 0.28086361289024353, 0.9624373912811279, 0.3015291094779968, -0.07161900401115417, 0.34551891684532166, -0.03643728047609329, 0.2331404685974121, -1.052663803100586, 0.24280963838100433, -0.25398242473602295, -0.2211844027042389, -0.6924894452095032, -0.5252626538276672, 0.33521848917007446, -0.02542957291007042, -0.175657257437706, 0.3971269726753235, -0.29800280928611755, 0.6303343176841736, 0.3201017379760742, -0.09150867909193039, 0.524773120880127, -0.34763121604919434, 0.04823080822825432, 0.13273827731609344, -0.43592700362205505, -0.548781156539917, 1.2578492164611816, 0.39588862657546997, 0.7421025633811951, 0.6348949670791626, 0.29219958186149597, 0.17323288321495056, -0.02048845775425434, -0.6494390368461609, 0.14723367989063263, -0.32753393054008484, -0.9656312465667725, -0.4100629389286041, -0.46980348229408264, -1.1784170866012573, 0.699060320854187, -0.07469996064901352, -0.949815571308136, 0.5078937411308289, -0.05447390675544739, -0.26943713426589966, 0.267599880695343, -1.187986969947815, 0.9749806523323059, -0.14267514646053314, -0.27686068415641785, 0.029691223055124283, -0.9039369225502014, 0.4979388117790222, -0.260788232088089, 0.3162102699279785, -0.26091375946998596, -0.22134186327457428, 0.23850083351135254, -0.332113653421402, 0.8407301902770996, 0.0982041135430336, -0.3407350480556488, 0.2812616527080536, 0.0725599154829979, 0.7073953747749329, 0.07561342418193817, 0.010132262483239174, 0.405400812625885, 0.04470968618988991, -0.44705891609191895, -0.3311369717121124, 0.5873546004295349, -0.8335955739021301, -0.8000585436820984, -0.621879518032074, -0.9308967590332031, -0.2835623621940613, 0.30374783277511597, 0.5157075524330139, 0.21056756377220154, -0.0310660507529974, -0.07247787714004517, 0.25700464844703674, -0.16155415773391724, 0.24242554605007172, 0.6436395645141602, -0.14490047097206116, 0.24036826193332672, 0.3073166608810425, 0.2790530323982239, 0.7658015489578247, 0.28187718987464905, -0.010678690858185291, -0.23180456459522247, -0.2989218533039093, -0.4320783317089081, 0.19991734623908997, -0.7675269246101379, -0.22090153396129608, -0.7246180176734924, -0.1463211476802826, -0.3156033158302307, -0.06182560324668884, -0.018459049984812737, -0.46186384558677673, -0.272427499294281, 0.06314308941364288, 0.3617081046104431, 1.0993051528930664, -0.05145891383290291, 0.407946914434433, -0.598135769367218, 0.3607901632785797, 0.47920647263526917, 0.32159000635147095, -0.2766670286655426, -0.4976464509963989, 0.004478385206311941, 0.225797638297081, -0.23116540908813477, -1.0423550605773926, 0.34755316376686096, -0.01255382876843214, 0.27345967292785645, 0.15233799815177917, -0.20045502483844757, 0.6878716945648193, -0.471584290266037, 0.6496410369873047, 0.03185926005244255, -1.0970165729522705, 0.2964092791080475, -0.690916121006012, 0.8332979679107666, 0.23746201395988464, 0.043592650443315506, -0.6613782048225403, -0.8803995847702026, -0.5407939553260803, -0.9021567702293396, 0.7076700329780579, 0.25944653153419495, -0.015253610908985138, -0.10127507895231247, 0.5151488184928894, 0.14369657635688782, 0.19754840433597565, -0.7992192506790161, 0.050915949046611786, -0.017501212656497955, -0.10562081634998322, -0.12192828208208084, -0.2817528545856476, -0.14261576533317566, 0.12877926230430603, 0.0050496975891292095, 0.007373730186372995, 0.19190746545791626, 0.22209644317626953, -0.3896172046661377, -0.4684321880340576, 0.48848041892051697, 0.632169246673584, 0.8890131711959839, -0.2581648528575897, 0.32085224986076355, 0.20719265937805176, -0.5451310873031616, 0.16050827503204346, 0.03956395387649536, 0.04356830567121506, -0.14980825781822205, 0.4845298230648041, 0.7387419939041138, 0.45666050910949707, -0.5838462114334106, 0.6426278352737427, -0.26542356610298157, -0.23804707825183868, -0.41307467222213745, 0.07870153337717056, -0.07905011624097824, 0.3737179636955261, 0.32732874155044556, 0.38440820574760437, 0.4275668263435364, -0.5516709089279175, 0.18598927557468414, 0.6339887976646423, -0.06899583339691162, -0.11177252233028412, 0.778433620929718, -0.13786189258098602, -0.0020173988305032253, 0.44756433367729187, -0.38854169845581055, -0.6308565735816956, 0.5584344863891602, 0.2214190810918808, 0.6736993193626404, 0.2450537234544754, -0.10201060771942139, -0.043279822915792465, 0.45333218574523926, -0.18006861209869385, 0.055051494389772415, 0.02669394761323929, -0.8949512243270874, -0.6212107539176941, -0.3969418406486511, -0.5837345123291016, -0.07175275683403015, -0.8621306419372559, 0.21150462329387665, 0.17541766166687012, -0.25113362073898315, 0.09144372493028641, -0.10026166588068008, -0.817747950553894, -0.04497462138533592, 0.1326950192451477, 0.4632038474082947, -0.9825956225395203, 1.0135523080825806, 0.5970743894577026, -0.16985423862934113, -0.6125836968421936, 0.3610326051712036, 0.11751364171504974, -0.8163476586341858, 0.9172887206077576, -0.06098940223455429, -0.18768011033535004, -0.08818608522415161, -0.10687002539634705, -1.2337727546691895, 0.7576869130134583, 0.35643741488456726, -0.7883812189102173, -0.21891357004642487, 0.15896785259246826, 0.4827907085418701, -0.2012944370508194, 0.08179304003715515, 0.6706043481826782, 0.6732646226882935, 0.06772705912590027, -1.1884742975234985, 0.017551781609654427, 0.04955535754561424, -0.13934166729450226, 0.5894309282302856, -0.8309394717216492, 1.0041348934173584, -0.21782557666301727, -0.10199273377656937, 0.07926193624734879, 0.2126544713973999, -0.008949209935963154, -0.07739336788654327, 0.6134511828422546, 0.6469401717185974, 0.6988801956176758, -0.2621360123157501, 1.0262147188186646, -0.07446303218603134, 0.5497500896453857, 1.2546857595443726, -0.26356998085975647, 0.8100469708442688, 0.3506670296192169, -0.36425894498825073, 0.2729462683200836, 0.5878559350967407, -0.012913617305457592, 0.32162606716156006, 0.16478052735328674, -0.1598779708147049, -0.28303062915802, 0.48015767335891724, -0.38001519441604614, 0.7567657828330994, 0.5318930149078369, -0.1228243038058281, -0.41498780250549316, -0.02629626728594303, 0.0021679503843188286, -0.25337669253349304, 0.10235343128442764, 0.4346609115600586, -0.044036440551280975, -0.7885133624076843, 0.4637879729270935, 0.047946635633707047, 0.6369135975837708, -0.5403326749801636, 0.1830841600894928, 0.17429842054843903, 0.1463693380355835, -0.1838657110929489, -0.9972800612449646, 0.5359309315681458, 0.08297178149223328, -0.24095013737678528, -0.1008194163441658, 0.4487142562866211, -0.3562847673892975, -0.48877251148223877, 0.31217822432518005, 0.5043742060661316, 0.25567466020584106, -0.08953198045492172, -0.6559843420982361, 0.12820152938365936, -0.00041288058855570853, -0.2727321684360504, 0.17963725328445435, 0.6625307202339172, -0.2819882333278656, 0.48290976881980896, 0.26415830850601196, 0.11093789339065552, 0.3002566993236542, -0.07751581817865372, 0.702241837978363, -0.8032035827636719, -0.22104288637638092, -0.7787168622016907, 0.18425145745277405, 0.14990568161010742, -0.5621740818023682, 0.792173445224762, 0.24017061293125153, 0.7516111731529236, 0.17215000092983246, 0.7086217403411865, 0.014484263956546783, 0.47157132625579834, -0.4597492218017578, 0.473827987909317, -0.5859177112579346, 0.5352979898452759, -0.18115125596523285, -0.8353846669197083, -0.6418378353118896, 0.7742117643356323, -0.7175573110580444, 0.1934269368648529, 0.6070963144302368, 0.3835086226463318, -0.24282550811767578, -0.0016890399856492877, 0.33072468638420105, 0.48700714111328125, 0.39087069034576416, 0.8238633275032043, 0.8884284496307373, -0.5407541394233704, 0.4017978310585022, 0.10096700489521027, -0.02590685524046421, -0.36655375361442566, -0.9723126888275146, -0.45310571789741516, -0.5504675507545471, -0.21418088674545288, 0.00544577743858099, 0.14028805494308472, 0.4670630097389221, 0.6151607632637024, -0.5853530168533325, -0.17592136561870575, -0.2507016658782959, 0.10311480611562729, 0.11114690452814102, -0.20188695192337036, 0.319520503282547, -0.39167338609695435, -0.8082301616668701, 0.11032760143280029, 0.12655816972255707, 0.11718561500310898, -0.3902079164981842, 0.13967999815940857, -0.2995123863220215, -0.0223093181848526, 0.3739074468612671, 0.1163419634103775, -1.1023094654083252, -0.7244592905044556, -0.06438285112380981, -0.007749819662421942, -0.0653899610042572, 0.5669854283332825, -0.7402262091636658, 0.6150696873664856, 0.21201306581497192, 0.22612519562244415, 0.4031728208065033, 0.06547021865844727, 0.708861231803894, -0.6392781138420105, 0.4082888960838318, 0.0279253963381052, 0.34478360414505005, 0.2780185639858246, -0.5491910576820374, 0.61015385389328, 0.013994739390909672, -0.8093236088752747, -0.8596259951591492, 0.5999066233634949, -0.8843088746070862, -0.5063210725784302, 1.3029155731201172, -0.05937663093209267, 0.05795932933688164, -0.12413159012794495, 0.14814281463623047, 0.0863267257809639, -0.07338541001081467, 0.7751237750053406, 1.398313045501709, -0.26288774609565735, 0.328656405210495, -0.9543050527572632, 0.15559591352939606, 0.5434785485267639, -0.4033566415309906, 0.2411143034696579, 0.6664595603942871, 0.20416606962680817, 0.05515308305621147, 0.2251921445131302, -0.20263506472110748, 0.26593366265296936, -0.1343013346195221, -0.3707197308540344, 0.27596765756607056, -0.06137244030833244, -0.4439226984977722, -0.13384416699409485, 0.3331534266471863, -0.11284536868333817 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04326v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04326v1
Hypothesis Generation with Large Language Models
2024-04-05T18:00:07
2024-04-05T18:00:07
Yangqiaoyu Zhou, Haokun Liu, Tejes Srivastava, Hongyuan Mei, Chenhao Tan
cs.AI
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
Effective generation of novel hypotheses is instrumental to scientific progress. So far, researchers have been the main powerhouse behind hypothesis generation by painstaking data analysis and thinking (also known as the Eureka moment). In this paper, we examine the potential of large language models (LLMs) to generate hypotheses. We focus on hypothesis generation based on data (i.e., labeled examples). To enable LLMs to handle arbitrarily long contexts, we generate initial hypotheses from a small number of examples and then update them iteratively to improve the quality of hypotheses. Inspired by multi-armed bandits, we design a reward function to inform the exploitation-exploration tradeoff in the update process. Our algorithm is able to generate hypotheses that enable much better predictive performance than few-shot prompting in classification tasks, improving accuracy by 31.7% on a synthetic dataset and by 13.9%, 3.3% and, 24.9% on three real-world datasets. We also outperform supervised learning by 12.8% and 11.2% on two challenging real-world datasets. Furthermore, we find that the generated hypotheses not only corroborate human-verified theories but also uncover new insights for the tasks.
[ -0.19221587479114532, -0.8064584136009216, 0.9665091037750244, 0.056884925812482834, 0.006166934967041016, -0.12455932796001434, -0.5697965621948242, -0.22809068858623505, 0.3118359446525574, 0.5212039351463318, -0.38049760460853577, -0.43175244331359863, -0.5862016081809998, 0.024753522127866745, -0.36329981684684753, 0.7229576706886292, 0.1694640815258026, -0.40951570868492126, -0.13413621485233307, 0.0879216119647026, -0.3431163430213928, -0.5261156558990479, -0.5735415816307068, -0.43443119525909424, 0.8227629661560059, 0.43781325221061707, 0.5714831352233887, 0.7738039493560791, 0.252754807472229, 0.22530467808246613, 0.05280957743525505, 0.13159212470054626, -0.5362550020217896, 0.315874844789505, -0.044371575117111206, -0.7050243616104126, -0.17152301967144012, -0.11151549965143204, 0.5341781973838806, 0.6916079521179199, -0.28587833046913147, -0.023742949590086937, 0.004835651721805334, 0.40982159972190857, -0.5594049096107483, 0.3058336675167084, -0.8084503412246704, -0.23716531693935394, -0.2740882933139801, -0.49639880657196045, -0.4851614534854889, -0.13104961812496185, 0.3077014088630676, -0.5933362245559692, 0.32590362429618835, 0.13483603298664093, 0.6594260931015015, 0.043608151376247406, -0.19654273986816406, -0.33635926246643066, -0.6109526753425598, 1.0042299032211304, -0.8314208984375, -0.04972480610013008, 0.33296507596969604, 0.2430136501789093, -0.507763147354126, -0.5756221413612366, -0.6207258701324463, -0.3775409460067749, 0.2175145000219345, -0.2585197389125824, -0.18737879395484924, -0.23593109846115112, 0.4861987829208374, 0.0730811208486557, -0.3270788788795471, 0.4968884587287903, -0.2905363440513611, -0.09181290119886398, 0.9458290338516235, 0.07015824317932129, 0.03956059738993645, -0.2542518973350525, -0.02250370942056179, -0.49320322275161743, -1.2069954872131348, 0.16427822411060333, 0.4950602352619171, 0.6618818044662476, 0.11022795736789703, 0.7728469967842102, -0.38819804787635803, 0.616917073726654, -0.17683722078800201, -0.6010875105857849, 0.30162233114242554, -0.13561660051345825, -0.08354411274194717, 0.0970076397061348, 0.7228325605392456, 0.3650536835193634, 0.12360235303640366, 0.02426677569746971, -0.14819630980491638, 0.09941630065441132, 0.007993324659764767, -0.920933187007904, -0.30484408140182495, 0.47063034772872925, -0.13331769406795502, -0.5262480974197388, -0.1359260529279709, -0.797398567199707, -0.4569079875946045, -0.12425345927476883, 0.5229491591453552, -0.4122946262359619, -0.36567702889442444, 0.3152241110801697, -0.2968675196170807, -0.02087067998945713, 0.3415416479110718, -0.8634034395217896, -0.0485772043466568, 0.6423453092575073, 0.6361790895462036, -0.2347087413072586, -0.36412808299064636, -0.6529598236083984, 0.18551966547966003, -0.5970199704170227, 0.8883329033851624, -0.33867427706718445, -0.3590928316116333, 0.16375160217285156, -0.25089699029922485, 0.1441378891468048, -0.4197213351726532, 0.45935139060020447, -0.3758106231689453, 0.07371214777231216, -0.3184033930301666, -0.7562611103057861, -0.14096517860889435, 0.2259596437215805, -0.6425983905792236, 0.8319079875946045, -0.13240502774715424, -0.762840747833252, 0.7069241404533386, -0.8095666170120239, -0.45725753903388977, 0.23023194074630737, -0.23720748722553253, -0.43605801463127136, 0.006645306013524532, 0.28623443841934204, 0.48311373591423035, -0.49833157658576965, 0.7109414339065552, -0.3343440890312195, -0.11824570596218109, 0.6186337471008301, -0.27490243315696716, 0.4945599436759949, 0.1297946721315384, -0.488861083984375, 0.06639640033245087, -0.36223626136779785, -0.030190447345376015, 0.29122936725616455, -0.27754515409469604, -0.32681888341903687, 0.2553824484348297, -0.1950729489326477, 0.0856337696313858, -0.130294531583786, -0.5845960378646851, 0.4020163118839264, -0.20125076174736023, 0.46239304542541504, 0.6908434629440308, 0.18079234659671783, 0.18536406755447388, -0.48613855242729187, 0.5592079758644104, -0.1274489313364029, -0.3686981499195099, -0.7371457815170288, -0.4401974380016327, -0.4953710436820984, -0.5193836092948914, 0.5875557661056519, 0.24522438645362854, -0.8740068078041077, 0.45110002160072327, -0.35918211936950684, -0.4987848401069641, -0.4070548713207245, 0.09164464473724365, 0.03407200053334236, 0.3640376031398773, 0.18380394577980042, 0.02471015602350235, -0.32728034257888794, -0.8587880730628967, -0.3220606744289398, -0.1665245145559311, -0.3468509316444397, 0.292789489030838, 0.6042031049728394, -0.24122212827205658, 1.0180796384811401, -0.7310701608657837, 0.006835380103439093, -0.33405131101608276, 0.3938131630420685, 0.25200948119163513, 0.29523539543151855, 0.4515306055545807, -0.8831976652145386, -0.06543637067079544, -0.22180625796318054, -0.8335378170013428, 0.13460685312747955, -0.2056741714477539, 0.10780836641788483, 0.30432093143463135, 0.3927372395992279, -0.6841514706611633, 0.2396106868982315, 0.26108318567276, -0.026683200150728226, 0.6244264841079712, -0.12017703056335449, 0.07421962916851044, -1.0350168943405151, 0.10616056621074677, 0.23493564128875732, 0.08534186333417892, -0.5048108696937561, 0.09735637903213501, -0.017248691990971565, -0.09400302171707153, -0.33577069640159607, 0.45484283566474915, -0.30436447262763977, 0.23351344466209412, -0.33033785223960876, -0.017972853034734726, -0.38165807723999023, 0.29709571599960327, 0.18160873651504517, 0.27981361746788025, 0.8827290534973145, -0.735359787940979, 0.2787318229675293, 0.06822005659341812, -0.683402419090271, 0.07637010514736176, -0.6215415596961975, -0.17040319740772247, -0.1730291098356247, 0.45095840096473694, -0.9180265069007874, -0.642006516456604, -0.2741814851760864, -0.5205889344215393, 0.18354816734790802, -0.07019903510808945, -0.741445004940033, -0.578227698802948, -0.3342078924179077, 0.04654562100768089, 0.6757473945617676, -0.7645819783210754, 0.18579067289829254, 0.3906501829624176, -0.5966368317604065, -0.534729540348053, -0.42311665415763855, 0.25803226232528687, -0.6697577834129333, -0.6015010476112366, 0.11001016944646835, 0.025508584454655647, -0.3926275670528412, -0.11635381728410721, 0.1263066530227661, 0.4373336732387543, 0.20482246577739716, 0.03360869735479355, 0.3332313299179077, -0.09975643455982208, 0.35000112652778625, 0.061745673418045044, -0.08988268673419952, 0.22873492538928986, -0.37142515182495117, 0.49385327100753784, 0.264347106218338, -0.2136385291814804, 0.0388173907995224, 0.28043532371520996, 0.3982992470264435, -0.050368040800094604, 0.5237872004508972, 0.32135945558547974, -0.445933997631073, -0.45840921998023987, -0.4148118793964386, -0.4482342600822449, -0.4636134207248688, 0.4087517261505127, -0.43689805269241333, -0.9868990778923035, 0.23992569744586945, -0.2846736013889313, 0.3532932996749878, 0.3921397626399994, 0.7186078429222107, 0.019121743738651276, 0.8949242830276489, 0.6752545237541199, 0.015074302442371845, 0.23410764336585999, -0.30538517236709595, 0.4801161289215088, -0.5875042676925659, 0.03748247027397156, -0.4674419164657593, 0.0007291340734809637, -0.7475137114524841, -0.568079948425293, 0.49035993218421936, 0.029482105746865273, 0.0713202953338623, 0.2845292091369629, -0.12200387567281723, 0.3675495684146881, 0.7646741271018982, -0.10866977274417877, 0.1451641470193863, 0.08313198387622833, 0.01789497584104538, 0.10066203773021698, -0.8611485958099365, -0.5780898332595825, 1.6069817543029785, 0.2686566710472107, 0.8033235669136047, 0.031514283269643784, 0.9649614691734314, 0.3550959825515747, 0.5396566987037659, -0.8919137120246887, 0.3153108060359955, 0.44385769963264465, -0.541624903678894, -0.6195470094680786, -0.5057065486907959, -1.166940689086914, 0.25872939825057983, -0.5258163213729858, -0.8592143654823303, 0.02276858128607273, 0.37136828899383545, -0.39329516887664795, 0.2228105664253235, -0.5619513392448425, 0.6578478813171387, -0.16633154451847076, -0.5949338674545288, -0.15575577318668365, -0.39553359150886536, 0.6153188943862915, -0.3315461575984955, 0.38802170753479004, -0.07860121130943298, 0.33290988206863403, 0.8469613194465637, -0.16207405924797058, 0.7441189289093018, -0.263448029756546, -0.5647063851356506, 0.6383352875709534, 0.15548153221607208, 0.5320064425468445, 0.10101982206106186, -0.2381511628627777, -0.05184464156627655, -0.25133758783340454, -0.36730387806892395, -0.4328758418560028, 0.7199358344078064, -0.28554990887641907, -0.7984112501144409, -0.32183170318603516, -0.7937716841697693, -0.11109603941440582, 0.11732029169797897, 0.42103633284568787, 0.3678831160068512, -0.16293799877166748, 0.37062105536460876, 0.6589134931564331, -0.3474867045879364, 0.4013647139072418, 0.3574718236923218, -0.22371834516525269, -0.013171090744435787, 1.0704387426376343, 0.09665561467409134, 0.2813434302806854, 0.2666204869747162, 0.4011564552783966, -0.5233072638511658, -0.5419906973838806, -0.40707525610923767, 0.14978797733783722, -0.3477119505405426, -0.33750754594802856, -0.5943570733070374, 0.17281581461429596, -0.4256938695907593, -0.21428988873958588, -0.1877354085445404, -0.30586278438568115, 0.165952667593956, -0.21906721591949463, 0.4142436683177948, 0.5472067594528198, -0.40262967348098755, 0.13832108676433563, -0.5515152812004089, 0.30938029289245605, 0.43969932198524475, -0.09012726694345474, 0.11850345134735107, -0.3299601078033447, -0.33199843764305115, 0.33054688572883606, -0.49243831634521484, -0.6284759044647217, 0.7285606861114502, -0.010998294688761234, 0.5409303903579712, 0.29051673412323, 0.021062631160020828, 0.3496747612953186, -0.49866026639938354, 0.7588867545127869, 0.39383623003959656, -0.6622533798217773, 0.5910289287567139, -0.7027699947357178, 0.09040527790784836, 0.10331348329782486, 0.4263010323047638, -0.3089349865913391, -0.4230888783931732, -0.9823406338691711, -0.9530001282691956, 0.3043842911720276, 0.16733500361442566, -0.12611372768878937, 0.00778082013130188, 0.05477903038263321, 0.4147435128688812, 0.42091330885887146, -0.507807195186615, 0.035652417689561844, 0.20727643370628357, -0.035932715982198715, -0.5725558400154114, 0.06479182839393616, -0.29639673233032227, -0.07393451035022736, 0.5680238604545593, -0.623441755771637, 0.3369412422180176, 0.028615815564990044, -0.04958450794219971, -0.3025156259536743, 0.4159141778945923, 0.46865370869636536, 0.8351327776908875, -0.19812722504138947, 0.12267648428678513, -0.05878119915723801, -0.014714590273797512, 0.05122794210910797, 0.2034444957971573, -0.24590258300304413, -0.10432562232017517, 0.5037549138069153, 0.7478619813919067, -0.09316066652536392, -1.1410551071166992, 0.3396278917789459, 0.0816110372543335, -0.3715454936027527, -0.3195290267467499, 0.2812267541885376, 0.3991297781467438, 0.2096807360649109, 0.8283005952835083, -0.2024407982826233, 0.16869914531707764, -0.8363782167434692, 0.1604258418083191, 0.4945526719093323, 0.3942543566226959, -0.3318731188774109, 0.40145933628082275, -0.05079178139567375, -0.24657467007637024, 0.26811811327934265, -0.2814202308654785, -0.5405545234680176, 0.8080261945724487, 0.6899092197418213, 0.5208505392074585, 0.04359658807516098, 0.3550953269004822, 0.5856426358222961, 0.19408820569515228, -0.4400988519191742, 0.04798143357038498, 0.049196984618902206, -0.827931821346283, -0.6857719421386719, -0.7150665521621704, -0.570690929889679, 0.4183655083179474, -0.6614745855331421, 0.2218485325574875, 0.13610520958900452, 0.02535947598516941, 0.38871514797210693, -0.06874517351388931, -0.6121668815612793, 0.14334221184253693, 0.19942694902420044, 0.7527617812156677, -1.0123299360275269, 0.7696591019630432, 0.3527354598045349, -0.029096301645040512, -0.6392980813980103, 0.08756713569164276, -0.007378303911536932, -0.595507800579071, 0.41129985451698303, 0.18649791181087494, 0.16065713763237, -0.2070041298866272, -1.0472630262374878, -1.0707554817199707, 1.0290391445159912, 0.29126739501953125, -0.6261898875236511, 0.15183304250240326, -0.12627193331718445, 0.4808995723724365, -0.5679508447647095, -0.25635385513305664, 0.7763881683349609, 0.562312126159668, 0.14746473729610443, -0.7104561924934387, 0.09057082235813141, -0.0909685492515564, -0.2068859487771988, 0.2215491086244583, -0.27961409091949463, 0.9494104385375977, -0.9218607544898987, -0.04063263162970543, 0.19344115257263184, 0.7575045824050903, 0.8771352767944336, 0.2718546986579895, 0.5576493740081787, 0.49359482526779175, 0.9135612845420837, -0.08344236761331558, 1.3154757022857666, 0.0465790294110775, 0.28846725821495056, 0.9961652159690857, -0.3849096894264221, 0.8994371294975281, 0.49951431155204773, -0.09189809113740921, 0.4803886115550995, 0.72529536485672, -0.047095295041799545, 0.4250997006893158, 0.5691299438476562, -0.04443366453051567, -0.35578247904777527, -0.05355934798717499, -0.1716274470090866, 0.43185240030288696, 0.6299514770507812, -0.0701315626502037, -0.07819285243749619, 0.06840642541646957, 0.15934161841869354, -0.03554530069231987, -0.08447869122028351, 0.5546970963478088, -0.05537501722574234, -1.048783302307129, 0.7512961030006409, 0.013069377280771732, 0.8004047870635986, -0.6237025856971741, -0.24170972406864166, -0.011213190853595734, 0.1490202397108078, 0.04608885198831558, -0.8276897668838501, -0.30760458111763, 0.12417007982730865, 0.07237155735492706, -0.08152300119400024, 0.6489112973213196, -0.6545476317405701, -0.4255436062812805, -0.07204220443964005, 0.5164180397987366, 0.11233942955732346, -0.04835544154047966, -0.1754148155450821, -0.049642857164144516, 0.09889154136180878, -0.3301736116409302, 0.4438308775424957, 0.460080087184906, -0.07325950264930725, 0.8042613863945007, 0.9533781409263611, 0.20761939883232117, -0.08897966891527176, -0.29693862795829773, 0.8408036231994629, -0.7618816494941711, -0.6629461050033569, -0.7582123875617981, 0.3272639513015747, -0.1813177913427353, -0.20388102531433105, 0.8464987277984619, 0.4623062312602997, 0.6042325496673584, -0.15692216157913208, 1.1992101669311523, -0.2132769078016281, 0.6306230425834656, -0.5317628383636475, 0.433214396238327, -0.531527042388916, 0.0848139300942421, -0.33771318197250366, -0.6036140322685242, -0.12799082696437836, 0.3337970972061157, -0.18971170485019684, -0.1694461852312088, 0.6818029880523682, 0.6064842939376831, 0.1058897078037262, -0.01898873597383499, 0.2107221484184265, 0.2603388726711273, 0.6315536499023438, 0.5582494735717773, 0.7376384735107422, -0.17040015757083893, 0.023835979402065277, -0.15676872432231903, -0.4023175835609436, -0.38229212164878845, -1.0497156381607056, -0.8101624250411987, -0.500347912311554, -0.2531939148902893, -0.3063920736312866, -0.19871540367603302, 0.7861735820770264, 0.5675756335258484, -0.6096748113632202, -0.4499281346797943, 0.03627609461545944, 0.0014705683570355177, -0.34678909182548523, -0.2921053171157837, 0.5377788543701172, -0.3325382173061371, -0.7052261233329773, 0.6910206079483032, 0.05243408679962158, -0.09820427745580673, -0.21145087480545044, -0.13930676877498627, -0.2610500752925873, 0.26012375950813293, 0.7660885453224182, 0.5267796516418457, -0.5132636427879333, -0.32025665044784546, 0.09698423743247986, 0.21413365006446838, -0.20664700865745544, 0.898763120174408, -0.8039305210113525, 0.29496443271636963, 0.11245588958263397, 0.6994017362594604, 0.8286169767379761, -0.06358220428228378, 0.7904832363128662, -0.5805570483207703, 0.285307377576828, 0.301238089799881, 0.49632561206817627, 0.46390894055366516, -0.13647113740444183, 0.39572036266326904, 0.09680045396089554, -0.351024329662323, -1.2705020904541016, 0.23604002594947815, -0.7463462352752686, -0.3673866391181946, 1.3776262998580933, -0.16696779429912567, -0.4011034071445465, 0.2854143977165222, -0.0880914181470871, -0.062339987605810165, -0.5090135335922241, 1.0873098373413086, 0.6901077032089233, -0.23110146820545197, 0.20520171523094177, -0.5128347873687744, 0.5422085523605347, 0.3692777454853058, -0.9966266751289368, 0.35167399048805237, 0.5767444372177124, 0.3215022385120392, 0.37721720337867737, 0.37788140773773193, 0.15528282523155212, 0.26302778720855713, 0.11106659471988678, 0.15912726521492004, 0.1020803228020668, -0.5496367812156677, 0.005869705695658922, 0.3205930292606354, 0.11842802166938782, 0.06936722993850708 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04254v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04254v1
Watermark-based Detection and Attribution of AI-Generated Content
2024-04-05T17:58:52
2024-04-05T17:58:52
Zhengyuan Jiang, Moyang Guo, Yuepeng Hu, Neil Zhenqiang Gong
cs.CR
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
Several companies--such as Google, Microsoft, and OpenAI--have deployed techniques to watermark AI-generated content to enable proactive detection. However, existing literature mainly focuses on user-agnostic detection. Attribution aims to further trace back the user of a generative-AI service who generated a given content detected as AI-generated. Despite its growing importance, attribution is largely unexplored. In this work, we aim to bridge this gap by providing the first systematic study on watermark-based, user-aware detection and attribution of AI-generated content. Specifically, we theoretically study the detection and attribution performance via rigorous probabilistic analysis. Moreover, we develop an efficient algorithm to select watermarks for the users to enhance attribution performance. Both our theoretical and empirical results show that watermark-based detection and attribution inherit the accuracy and (non-)robustness properties of the watermarking method.
[ -0.3029131591320038, -0.604335367679596, 0.43269068002700806, 0.00514589948579669, -0.31507760286331177, 0.030615903437137604, 0.27766332030296326, -0.5975565910339355, 0.12023161351680756, 0.3998229205608368, -0.5745315551757812, -0.20498980581760406, -0.5428279638290405, -0.05689604580402374, -0.6951398253440857, 0.8281314969062805, -0.04574637860059738, -0.6789488792419434, -0.3948177099227905, -0.3166266083717346, -0.11955779790878296, -0.4076925218105316, -0.7570406794548035, -0.40266457200050354, 0.520428478717804, 0.26870617270469666, 0.6601986885070801, 0.8813827633857727, 0.43244510889053345, 0.23581629991531372, 0.07450729608535767, 0.21723078191280365, -0.2664327323436737, 0.026448743417859077, -0.2024308145046234, -0.4864891767501831, -0.007995265536010265, 0.17691250145435333, 0.5922356247901917, -0.15034447610378265, 0.13317781686782837, 0.5049450397491455, 0.04293682798743248, 0.4702003002166748, -1.2394436597824097, 0.11621847003698349, -0.7084091305732727, -0.08894476294517517, -0.6336132287979126, -0.37770259380340576, -0.3691331744194031, -0.3293718099594116, -0.2975764572620392, -0.9114856123924255, 0.10116227716207504, 0.2446184754371643, 0.8449676632881165, 0.4545339047908783, -0.17404691874980927, -0.5190994739532471, -0.828383207321167, 0.925800621509552, -0.5596205592155457, -0.12598520517349243, 0.6676540970802307, 0.3513164818286896, 0.05166175216436386, -0.7181758284568787, -0.8619322776794434, 0.05723663792014122, 0.18397782742977142, 0.09081630408763885, -0.49468860030174255, -0.60638427734375, 0.017737943679094315, 0.3102557361125946, -0.27490341663360596, 0.08012384176254272, 0.12528719007968903, -0.2485688030719757, 0.8350252509117126, -0.12533627450466156, 0.4149930775165558, 0.008012054488062859, -0.4693185091018677, -0.20592428743839264, -0.7013886570930481, 0.15884898602962494, 0.6788414120674133, -0.09288407117128372, -0.037364061921834946, 0.708561360836029, 0.12066173553466797, 0.3012886345386505, -0.15511618554592133, 0.10866585373878479, -0.006501416210085154, -0.40165236592292786, 0.25059670209884644, 0.13498152792453766, 1.0188863277435303, 0.06634101271629333, 0.8447608947753906, -0.1516968160867691, -0.3208047151565552, 0.020734725520014763, 0.44553306698799133, -0.459144651889801, -0.47988438606262207, -0.2194433957338333, -0.605597198009491, -0.6879439949989319, 0.2549087107181549, -0.19685257971286774, -0.6939675211906433, 0.1155136451125145, 0.6868259906768799, -0.25553157925605774, -0.4411868751049042, -0.2742747664451599, -0.3475783169269562, 0.06642165780067444, 0.20284482836723328, -0.5446204543113708, 0.037971705198287964, 0.6421173214912415, 0.8215804696083069, -0.5730230212211609, -0.11712528765201569, -0.4979086220264435, 0.6311267614364624, -0.21271073818206787, 1.1298311948776245, -0.5563769936561584, -0.06612006574869156, 0.08984188735485077, -0.2618500888347626, 0.2595202624797821, -0.7979226112365723, 0.2962678074836731, -0.8216761946678162, 0.05614171549677849, -0.3445955216884613, -0.7726478576660156, -0.12025526165962219, 0.1730390340089798, -0.984585165977478, 0.5519739985466003, 0.10385099053382874, -0.8748597502708435, 0.7250254154205322, -0.9080637693405151, -0.5335888266563416, 0.3426103889942169, -0.2670576870441437, -0.7923038005828857, -0.03426665440201759, 0.22437018156051636, 0.1275624930858612, -0.10351935029029846, 0.06869255006313324, -0.06241677328944206, -0.46451637148857117, 0.4728291928768158, -0.7534529566764832, 0.9633532762527466, 0.1726658046245575, -0.35576361417770386, 0.23035427927970886, -0.5996833443641663, 0.01084229163825512, 0.45910513401031494, -0.23584851622581482, -0.42431119084358215, 0.1030251532793045, 0.14691674709320068, -0.3420845568180084, 0.1457621455192566, -0.49749845266342163, 0.05356458202004433, 0.33976972103118896, 0.33067870140075684, 0.7977927923202515, 0.14647960662841797, 0.29847240447998047, -0.2078000009059906, 0.6506320834159851, -0.031047342345118523, 0.19373314082622528, -0.26425567269325256, -0.7268725037574768, -0.09578757733106613, -0.6732699275016785, 0.3686675429344177, 0.6400600671768188, -0.8059474229812622, 0.3453505337238312, -0.09158379584550858, -0.4857528805732727, -0.5631051659584045, 0.16413556039333344, 0.42435094714164734, 0.5826781392097473, 0.5515259504318237, -0.48554685711860657, -0.010897050611674786, -0.9118186831474304, -0.5176925659179688, -0.632532000541687, -0.2486409842967987, 0.5717998743057251, 0.42678019404411316, -0.08951088041067123, 1.118632435798645, -0.5283617973327637, -0.5216376185417175, -0.029623745009303093, 0.6115503907203674, -0.20268212258815765, 0.5560925006866455, 0.7104828357696533, -0.9139239192008972, -0.6405916810035706, -0.358741819858551, -0.8672881126403809, -0.32675671577453613, -0.11219487339258194, 0.14180190861225128, -0.03756692260503769, 0.3682916760444641, -0.4647391736507416, 0.8097468018531799, 0.3921589255332947, -0.30662447214126587, 0.6880484223365784, -0.11126965284347534, 0.4388491213321686, -0.7571666836738586, 0.31285426020622253, -0.0026634037494659424, -0.24926041066646576, -0.15376880764961243, -0.2010798454284668, -0.06451667845249176, -0.16266536712646484, -0.43302974104881287, 0.6079300045967102, -0.18689757585525513, -0.17055360972881317, -0.5714159607887268, -0.3875728249549866, 0.07086080312728882, 0.26029419898986816, -0.00434741098433733, 1.0453928709030151, 0.4572566747665405, -0.43081146478652954, 0.46377867460250854, 0.30097833275794983, -0.43740877509117126, 0.5841752886772156, -0.9143736362457275, 0.07964218407869339, -0.01420355960726738, 0.08196962624788284, -1.1076470613479614, 0.15377750992774963, 0.7687841057777405, -0.5629765391349792, -0.003930192906409502, -0.47869643568992615, -0.8790668249130249, 0.04643239825963974, -0.27878597378730774, 0.7152249813079834, 0.4429487884044647, -0.5492218136787415, 0.4405202567577362, 0.05413560941815376, -0.06979332119226456, -0.16214177012443542, -0.7065905332565308, 0.049417153000831604, -0.5144293308258057, -0.5828277468681335, 0.7250006794929504, 0.07968959957361221, -0.29428452253341675, 0.35283762216567993, -0.010905902832746506, -0.3334353268146515, 0.30327698588371277, 0.3878944516181946, -0.05241775140166283, -0.23353195190429688, -0.41743969917297363, -0.25057774782180786, -0.36972469091415405, 0.09418824315071106, 0.061382319778203964, 0.24685893952846527, 0.144933819770813, -0.9841976761817932, -0.9980833530426025, 0.5223590135574341, 0.32296282052993774, -0.5214393138885498, 0.7427584528923035, 0.8357382416725159, -0.39338183403015137, 0.038475196808576584, -0.3795752227306366, -0.30748826265335083, -0.5143128633499146, -0.1864079087972641, 0.17459985613822937, -0.4490533471107483, 0.7809246778488159, 0.10353770107030869, 0.0803617611527443, 0.5755454897880554, 0.2778841257095337, -0.4909456968307495, 0.9214926958084106, 0.591468334197998, -0.45085278153419495, 0.8509533405303955, -0.09004517644643784, 0.10609783977270126, -0.464764267206192, -0.12641951441764832, -0.59438157081604, -0.39681297540664673, -0.443764328956604, -0.019938694313168526, 0.16646185517311096, 0.039753347635269165, -0.1688036173582077, 0.3312852680683136, -0.3140806257724762, 0.3830428421497345, 0.9927281737327576, 0.11872298270463943, 0.3893873989582062, 0.25018665194511414, 0.615831732749939, 0.05032319575548172, -0.3481789827346802, -0.4334390163421631, 1.0507416725158691, 0.07308531552553177, 0.747438371181488, 0.1823190450668335, 0.5690003037452698, 1.39058256149292, 0.36306384205818176, -0.45782944560050964, 0.27484628558158875, -0.04556763172149658, -0.6826375126838684, -0.43642857670783997, -0.23198717832565308, -0.9973374009132385, -0.4224641025066376, -0.1640446037054062, -0.667460024356842, -0.12261951714754105, 0.36394497752189636, -0.2646923065185547, 0.24127395451068878, -0.5356703996658325, 0.7224891781806946, -0.15507574379444122, -0.5375930666923523, -0.3175344169139862, -0.3189737796783447, -0.1096249669790268, -0.1861896812915802, 0.021088942885398865, 0.0016310570063069463, -0.001269869739189744, 0.9176692962646484, -0.2589804232120514, 0.46692660450935364, -0.5533550977706909, -0.25219786167144775, 0.7552529573440552, 0.05362385883927345, 0.6230301856994629, 0.26090946793556213, 0.007994145154953003, 0.16901825368404388, -0.5608967542648315, -0.2621553838253021, -0.5296396613121033, 0.2792891263961792, -0.5571417808532715, -0.42466336488723755, -0.3301590383052826, -0.17974087595939636, 0.15584005415439606, 0.4241008162498474, 0.3683929145336151, 0.08947358280420303, 0.16347849369049072, 0.1218685507774353, 0.595410168170929, -0.3393802046775818, 0.46656379103660583, 0.5406510829925537, 0.28077661991119385, -0.1658986210823059, 1.2635160684585571, -0.16922715306282043, -0.2291640341281891, -0.005136940162628889, 0.22282913327217102, -0.25615331530570984, -0.7719772458076477, -0.6216267347335815, 0.06694408506155014, -0.5315036773681641, -0.2198975831270218, -0.20443937182426453, -0.3359163701534271, -0.024745192378759384, -0.32967036962509155, -0.6710034012794495, -0.012583629228174686, -0.5209466218948364, 0.41361966729164124, 0.31526845693588257, 0.44983455538749695, 0.05438583716750145, 0.4625047743320465, -0.45747512578964233, 0.5601931810379028, 0.3617081344127655, 0.23606345057487488, -0.016809461638331413, -0.5315344929695129, -0.0650373175740242, 0.19059845805168152, -0.4861847460269928, -0.5486577153205872, -0.02081916108727455, 0.4581758379936218, 0.7172189354896545, 0.7042022943496704, 0.138604074716568, 0.4642990231513977, -0.16647864878177643, 0.9647480845451355, 0.09120294451713562, -0.8467636108398438, 0.7667236328125, -0.07088931649923325, 0.03940829634666443, 0.4740644693374634, 0.3453619182109833, -0.015119456686079502, -0.20221129059791565, -0.7515430450439453, -0.8848254680633545, 0.4983780086040497, 0.6314660310745239, 0.18484345078468323, 0.2749398648738861, 0.4166503846645355, 0.11322198808193207, 0.18883702158927917, -0.4462953507900238, -0.32369381189346313, -0.29041585326194763, -0.048237159848213196, -0.00912376120686531, -0.07071372121572495, -0.06607528030872345, 0.09991861134767532, 0.6368456482887268, -0.21834905445575714, 0.5889766812324524, -0.042629268020391464, -0.2951393723487854, -0.18957555294036865, -0.16199961304664612, 0.36510780453681946, 0.5559746026992798, 0.031733836978673935, -0.01226729340851307, -0.49915698170661926, -0.36941635608673096, 0.10452267527580261, 0.05302263796329498, -0.5552809238433838, -0.10485774278640747, 0.9213911890983582, 0.5659962296485901, -0.5159716606140137, -0.6494274139404297, 0.8567536473274231, -0.06979049742221832, 0.04602091759443283, -0.5827218294143677, 0.38889744877815247, -0.15525151789188385, 0.4759639799594879, 0.7395221590995789, 0.00834360346198082, 0.3247430920600891, -0.47725120186805725, 0.40578076243400574, 0.618502140045166, -0.3242025375366211, -0.4230745732784271, 0.8805727362632751, 0.02426474168896675, -0.2542508542537689, 0.9664119482040405, 0.012434820644557476, -0.5178430676460266, 0.7693538665771484, 0.45591604709625244, 0.8720749616622925, 0.13033710420131683, 0.12299579381942749, -0.04978556931018829, -0.03296007215976715, 0.13869616389274597, 0.2896791994571686, -0.49192699790000916, -1.136308193206787, -0.02714420109987259, -0.25983309745788574, -0.46220287680625916, 0.15059083700180054, -0.7980679869651794, -0.0665661171078682, -0.30656760931015015, -0.44317859411239624, 0.28871914744377136, -0.2116837352514267, -0.5050631165504456, 0.17886774241924286, 0.4043435752391815, 0.617411732673645, -0.9523462653160095, 0.43657708168029785, 0.7454308271408081, -0.3273714482784271, -0.3138783276081085, 0.25820833444595337, 0.1119169145822525, -1.012220025062561, 0.25142982602119446, 0.18623694777488708, -0.10103001445531845, 0.24921897053718567, -0.8629767894744873, -0.5014824867248535, 1.1331709623336792, 0.385978639125824, 0.15845753252506256, 0.4786132872104645, 0.33181291818618774, 0.3043677806854248, -0.29415807127952576, -0.04069290682673454, 0.08593541383743286, 0.5260002613067627, -0.06049187108874321, -0.44029179215431213, 0.048579081892967224, -0.3778410255908966, -0.1564866304397583, -0.24713876843452454, -0.39898452162742615, 0.40296417474746704, -0.053777627646923065, -0.11662878841161728, -0.1567791998386383, 0.7733094096183777, 0.3923614025115967, 0.5564037561416626, 0.6503629088401794, 0.30151838064193726, 0.45412924885749817, 0.1755947470664978, 0.8905389308929443, -0.04207789525389671, 0.08567339926958084, 0.7141560912132263, -0.15573911368846893, 0.5990349054336548, 0.6170918345451355, -0.17011457681655884, 0.4463679790496826, 0.45468196272850037, -0.6024859547615051, 1.029001235961914, 0.18921765685081482, -0.3882942497730255, -0.12215958535671234, -0.756529688835144, -0.27218735218048096, 0.4944427013397217, 0.13676565885543823, -0.7695173621177673, 0.17559441924095154, -0.25053131580352783, 0.018049268051981926, -0.09620536863803864, -0.25829002261161804, 1.010186791419983, -0.16180334985256195, -0.5251516699790955, 0.4390447735786438, 0.15517915785312653, 0.823442816734314, -0.5799990296363831, 0.06060799956321716, -0.14303834736347198, 0.17945334315299988, -0.32670798897743225, -1.0078024864196777, 0.5427086353302002, 0.2950473427772522, -0.2383044958114624, -0.34706470370292664, 1.1436063051223755, -0.060585133731365204, -0.12118581682443619, -0.010416032746434212, 0.3524063229560852, 0.1691100299358368, -0.6490856409072876, -0.5293814539909363, 0.09825458377599716, -0.0032980055548250675, -0.5297639966011047, 0.13355377316474915, 0.18153013288974762, -0.3699639141559601, 1.003940463066101, 0.6821476817131042, -0.0757259801030159, -0.082057885825634, -0.009235035628080368, 0.6374577283859253, -0.28348687291145325, -0.47791042923927307, -0.997407853603363, 0.48534393310546875, -0.032320231199264526, -0.1791262924671173, 0.5853819251060486, 0.5405781269073486, 0.7720061540603638, -0.23200589418411255, 1.1852468252182007, -0.3288625180721283, -0.3087282180786133, -0.1352953314781189, 0.9850090742111206, -0.9007067680358887, -0.07600542157888412, -0.42331206798553467, -0.8855427503585815, -0.061670754104852676, 0.3509058356285095, 0.24335791170597076, -0.08772668242454529, -0.017043231055140495, 0.5993880033493042, -0.30363571643829346, 0.06750890612602234, -0.08297352492809296, -0.7586596012115479, 0.6670928001403809, 0.23843041062355042, 0.7754995822906494, -0.31484127044677734, 0.5292897820472717, -0.17072972655296326, -0.3432132601737976, -0.22179387509822845, -1.1974962949752808, -0.5216220021247864, -0.6073630452156067, -0.7239094376564026, 0.13318991661071777, 0.06007446348667145, 0.22372256219387054, 0.7108825445175171, -1.0517728328704834, 0.32393574714660645, -0.12630975246429443, -0.053198449313640594, -0.622752845287323, -0.17981751263141632, 0.5086528062820435, 0.4291113018989563, -0.19418691098690033, 0.07771273702383041, -0.009081423282623291, 0.33742693066596985, -0.3019961714744568, -0.11913037300109863, 0.006084844004362822, 0.18308399617671967, 0.22056114673614502, 0.4805627167224884, -0.283372700214386, -0.28798118233680725, -0.3019101321697235, 0.004474808927625418, -0.04301241412758827, 0.8990743160247803, -0.47410187125205994, 0.04563393443822861, 0.4700669050216675, 0.7405621409416199, 0.3686453402042389, 0.5612986087799072, 0.38238653540611267, -0.8308142423629761, -0.027384575456380844, 0.19600073993206024, -0.10632681846618652, 0.40242063999176025, -0.41122913360595703, 0.34815773367881775, 0.5932223796844482, -0.3976467549800873, -0.5534256100654602, 0.21657699346542358, -0.5262288451194763, 0.02110380120575428, 0.8893001079559326, -0.6977732181549072, 0.12146031111478806, -0.040303394198417664, 0.17151668667793274, 0.5467140674591064, -0.4929130971431732, 1.0305674076080322, 0.5904397964477539, -0.17104724049568176, -0.14325743913650513, -0.1502465456724167, 0.46799236536026, 0.33253753185272217, -0.7737694978713989, 0.10855628550052643, 0.22372733056545258, 0.25124576687812805, 0.22580620646476746, 0.5054689049720764, -0.06299519538879395, 0.2820999324321747, 0.04491134360432625, -0.007801446132361889, -0.5092623829841614, -0.4492512047290802, 0.2589160203933716, 0.19852666556835175, 0.10150551050901413, -0.4700073003768921 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04251v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04251v2
Who Evaluates the Evaluations? Objectively Scoring Text-to-Image Prompt Coherence Metrics with T2IScoreScore (TS2)
2024-04-05T17:57:16
2024-05-22T20:19:27
Michael Saxon, Fatima Jahara, Mahsa Khoshnoodi, Yujie Lu, Aditya Sharma, William Yang Wang
cs.CV
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
With advances in the quality of text-to-image (T2I) models has come interest in benchmarking their prompt faithfulness-the semantic coherence of generated images to the prompts they were conditioned on. A variety of T2I faithfulness metrics have been proposed, leveraging advances in cross-modal embeddings and vision-language models (VLMs). However, these metrics are not rigorously compared and benchmarked, instead presented with correlation to human Likert scores over a set of easy-to-discriminate images against seemingly weak baselines. We introduce T2IScoreScore (TS2), a curated set of semantic error graphs containing a prompt and a set increasingly erroneous images. These allow us to rigorously judge whether a given prompt faithfulness metric can correctly order images with respect to their objective error count and significantly discriminate between different error nodes, using meta-metric scores derived from established statistical tests. Surprisingly, we find that the state-of-the-art VLM-based metrics (e.g., TIFA, DSG, LLMScore, VIEScore) we tested fail to significantly outperform simple (and supposedly worse) feature-based metrics like CLIPScore, particularly on a hard subset of naturally-occurring T2I model errors. TS2 will enable the development of better T2I prompt faithfulness metrics through more rigorous comparison of their conformity to expected orderings and separations under objective criteria.
[ -0.15209592878818512, -0.5543457865715027, 0.8556678295135498, 0.14211837947368622, -0.4982723891735077, -0.005089679267257452, 0.013520034030079842, -0.5420440435409546, -0.19592991471290588, 0.12964822351932526, -0.49986207485198975, -0.5990961790084839, -0.7537647485733032, 0.3163902163505554, -0.32906219363212585, 0.8901250958442688, -0.1336832344532013, 0.33054861426353455, -0.5093632936477661, -0.5053848624229431, -0.6676105856895447, 0.08831049501895905, -0.5787084698677063, -0.12829536199569702, 0.34899187088012695, 0.4645516574382782, 0.7505015134811401, 0.4143751859664917, 0.7043068408966064, 0.16725307703018188, 0.15873615443706512, 0.34687715768814087, -0.5254806280136108, 0.2275083214044571, -0.28950849175453186, -0.42322880029678345, -0.4597957134246826, 0.22285519540309906, 0.4775354862213135, 0.4257665276527405, 0.37572726607322693, 0.3809717297554016, 0.39924848079681396, 0.4543028175830841, -0.5922427773475647, 0.06956714391708374, -0.21658830344676971, 0.16646966338157654, 0.012743323110044003, -0.36476632952690125, -0.5223779082298279, -0.5962358117103577, 0.37130266427993774, -0.482504665851593, 0.30322426557540894, 0.260494589805603, 0.9986535906791687, 0.29171183705329895, -0.323560506105423, -0.42778831720352173, -0.3618333339691162, 1.0666395425796509, -0.10694689303636551, 0.5003533363342285, 0.4294752776622772, 0.4281775653362274, 0.08212818205356598, -0.6908365488052368, -0.04311397671699524, -0.3725072741508484, -0.060908667743206024, 0.4321240186691284, -0.41328194737434387, -0.13395525515079498, 0.20025324821472168, 0.10591991245746613, -0.657072126865387, 0.07253950834274292, -0.10008324682712555, -0.4959617853164673, 0.36717042326927185, 0.2601255178451538, 0.39533743262290955, -0.242818683385849, -0.541947603225708, -0.1725171059370041, -0.3345696032047272, 0.2493683248758316, 0.04413667693734169, -0.20841705799102783, -0.08461805433034897, 0.8218631148338318, -0.056468766182661057, 0.4154725968837738, 0.22485412657260895, -0.17538054287433624, 0.23736822605133057, -0.7352079749107361, 0.16892528533935547, -0.25673696398735046, 1.0552791357040405, 1.0374454259872437, 0.30351459980010986, -0.3634592294692993, -0.36695992946624756, 0.48354262113571167, 0.08113545924425125, -0.8526740670204163, -0.012480461038649082, 0.23383471369743347, -0.5335562825202942, -0.2416694611310959, 0.05325161665678024, -0.6163667440414429, -0.20524978637695312, -0.22465236485004425, 0.4727049767971039, -0.6027886271476746, -0.07266147434711456, -0.4363066256046295, -0.6716974973678589, 0.16137652099132538, 0.640440046787262, -0.3099246621131897, 0.2503212094306946, 0.8379080891609192, 0.9775985479354858, -0.46033504605293274, -0.41542673110961914, -0.6797907948493958, -0.19515492022037506, -0.7877210378646851, 1.164196252822876, -0.5019038915634155, -0.4302513897418976, -0.1001458540558815, -0.05936116725206375, 0.23475642502307892, -0.4251244366168976, 0.929528534412384, -0.36763110756874084, 0.2997688949108124, -0.5778952240943909, -0.5372159481048584, 0.0369342565536499, 0.49169883131980896, -0.41974011063575745, 1.1466268301010132, 0.3357752859592438, -0.6480154991149902, 0.737342357635498, -0.3644494116306305, -0.04302103444933891, -0.06132223457098007, -0.19484031200408936, -0.451082319021225, 0.3235643804073334, 0.02896096557378769, 0.2513185739517212, -0.5765029788017273, 0.3393506109714508, -0.4089415669441223, -0.4494949281215668, 0.25207850337028503, -0.44000712037086487, 0.5425246953964233, 0.04141242429614067, -0.23133549094200134, -0.012324710376560688, -0.6030134558677673, 0.44308751821517944, -0.0687464252114296, 0.2698637843132019, -0.39131709933280945, -0.031246338039636612, 0.0405166931450367, 0.15150277316570282, 0.1402835249900818, -0.6368223428726196, -0.4125124216079712, -0.022312529385089874, 0.2838546335697174, 0.5572733879089355, 0.11748193949460983, 0.30451372265815735, -0.3460765779018402, 0.09014321118593216, 0.1476268619298935, 0.35845139622688293, -0.27913275361061096, -0.75299471616745, -0.6049836277961731, -0.12357645481824875, 0.024169376119971275, 0.5255351662635803, -0.6650673747062683, 0.5219669342041016, -0.3947703242301941, -0.7716054916381836, -0.47656676173210144, -0.1468515396118164, 0.8488729596138, 0.8858288526535034, 0.4422481954097748, -0.6767386794090271, -0.09005472809076309, -1.014621376991272, -0.49471190571784973, -0.4949405789375305, -0.15541547536849976, 0.4222726821899414, 0.35351476073265076, 0.0027404839638620615, 1.031240701675415, -0.24773433804512024, -0.2218008041381836, 0.20572413504123688, 0.295797735452652, -0.09479430317878723, 0.41276171803474426, 0.6056608557701111, -0.3431931436061859, -0.3347036838531494, -0.38378697633743286, -0.9402953386306763, -0.37879839539527893, 0.2230958491563797, -0.04403497278690338, 0.34583261609077454, 0.24081264436244965, -0.3832773268222809, 0.46575021743774414, 0.4731267988681793, -0.7801995873451233, 0.7146191596984863, -0.19802673161029816, 0.690244734287262, -0.9563996195793152, 0.07972074300050735, 0.16707897186279297, -0.41903626918792725, -0.3268645703792572, -0.12079751491546631, 0.12777243554592133, -0.038199178874492645, -0.22821012139320374, 0.5162841081619263, -0.4539525508880615, -0.45518040657043457, -0.029195163398981094, 0.16290831565856934, 0.5860650539398193, 0.15852710604667664, -0.1130855455994606, 0.9518128037452698, 0.5019603371620178, -0.38846802711486816, 0.2416733205318451, 0.43341320753097534, -0.4698335528373718, 1.4334161281585693, -1.0795567035675049, 0.45891326665878296, -0.06035686656832695, 0.1838979721069336, -1.4062891006469727, -0.0932554081082344, 0.2437286227941513, -0.6854403018951416, 0.2472543716430664, 0.03957671672105789, -0.502246081829071, -0.16286267340183258, -0.5078657269477844, 0.57222980260849, 0.7441961765289307, -0.5235884189605713, 0.38169336318969727, 0.0014437178615480661, 0.2175871878862381, -0.3628738820552826, -0.9525653719902039, 0.3510066568851471, 0.20988161861896515, -0.928363025188446, 0.1809990406036377, 0.014756320044398308, -0.22649458050727844, 0.19860292971134186, 0.021979819983243942, -0.07096759974956512, 0.026713110506534576, 0.33824628591537476, 0.2208634912967682, -0.2524433732032776, 0.08256980031728745, 0.046773966401815414, -0.42875126004219055, 0.1705813854932785, -0.3199276328086853, 0.2161988466978073, -0.2010330706834793, -0.5849568247795105, -0.8934375047683716, 0.3667339086532593, 0.4786836504936218, -0.10498550534248352, 0.2227247655391693, 0.6162332892417908, -0.08101556450128555, 0.10156356543302536, -0.6973544359207153, -0.057531990110874176, -0.4025377631187439, 0.5270928740501404, -0.37508872151374817, -0.6364067792892456, 0.4080548882484436, 0.13790832459926605, 0.05895988643169403, 0.7549131512641907, 0.20116320252418518, -0.4026002585887909, 1.015010952949524, 0.19268882274627686, 0.4478074908256531, 0.3881535530090332, -0.10504952818155289, -0.12336929142475128, -0.7886819839477539, -0.483631432056427, -0.6170087456703186, -0.15068811178207397, -0.4602625370025635, -0.49933764338493347, 0.6167393326759338, -0.0010318061104044318, -0.3294946253299713, 0.25214990973472595, -0.3937719762325287, 0.45608294010162354, 0.4238843619823456, 0.449573278427124, 0.26648497581481934, 0.2172876000404358, -0.03571997210383415, -0.27636876702308655, -0.28757578134536743, -0.6880841255187988, 0.9686343669891357, 0.4432920217514038, 0.5942345261573792, -0.07648314535617828, 0.34749898314476013, 0.6869529485702515, 0.0791422575712204, -0.9468491673469543, 0.6012770533561707, -0.36099374294281006, -0.1526699811220169, -0.0016421698965132236, -0.2306956946849823, -0.6481853127479553, -0.28123244643211365, -0.11191461980342865, -0.6070432662963867, 0.2315092235803604, 0.12074548751115799, -0.1324058473110199, -0.041388772428035736, -0.8058011531829834, 0.8674184083938599, -0.17110231518745422, -0.6378617286682129, -0.2497837245464325, -0.5486412644386292, 0.09826453030109406, 0.1154378280043602, -0.23086661100387573, -0.18264417350292206, -0.653899073600769, 0.7478585243225098, -0.4827037751674652, 0.5964460372924805, -0.1672433316707611, 0.07836439460515976, 0.4668413996696472, 0.3533581495285034, 0.42008134722709656, -0.045335687696933746, -0.15038101375102997, 0.6489343047142029, 0.147294819355011, -0.49103716015815735, -0.6998381614685059, 0.42937910556793213, -0.9719997644424438, -0.33160635828971863, -0.31609874963760376, -0.08063580095767975, -0.37809962034225464, 0.07032576203346252, 0.6171630620956421, 0.9217165112495422, -0.391075998544693, -0.06030180677771568, 0.36327245831489563, -0.06182252615690231, 0.38794276118278503, 0.2837258577346802, 0.17926231026649475, -0.7591052055358887, 0.8157674670219421, 0.13484686613082886, 0.4384326934814453, 0.061989959329366684, 0.21248598396778107, -0.5199716687202454, -0.49720290303230286, -0.7042359709739685, -0.01604882813990116, -0.9142425656318665, -0.2826160490512848, -0.5442705154418945, -0.04140331968665123, -0.14153555035591125, 0.018992071971297264, -0.3378749191761017, -0.25742676854133606, -0.522705078125, 0.14661461114883423, 0.17484356462955475, 0.7422665953636169, 0.2347215861082077, 0.0565284788608551, -0.9096485376358032, 0.22869031131267548, 0.1931125372648239, 0.7538666725158691, -0.17099936306476593, -0.7782775163650513, 0.13032843172550201, -0.16631023585796356, -0.2060764580965042, -0.8277729153633118, -0.09076129645109177, 0.3424611985683441, 0.31767186522483826, 0.38763558864593506, -0.07299439609050751, 0.8267236351966858, -0.5108959674835205, 1.2194093465805054, 0.5565149188041687, -0.9981660842895508, 0.6452373266220093, -0.14150823652744293, 0.1467902511358261, 0.7784252762794495, 0.040743980556726456, -0.4490092396736145, -0.49698272347450256, -0.3672267496585846, -0.3341788053512573, 0.7819644808769226, 0.20730264484882355, 0.04580071568489075, -0.06358541548252106, 0.3796593248844147, 0.30656516551971436, -0.077821746468544, -0.17512200772762299, -0.03474732115864754, -0.43762704730033875, -0.39291203022003174, -0.09292063117027283, -0.692604660987854, -0.03631120175123215, 0.03813391551375389, 0.23117993772029877, -0.21420320868492126, 0.3583669066429138, 0.665031909942627, -0.11347357928752899, -0.3790750205516815, 0.22626619040966034, 0.4182592034339905, 0.6077091097831726, -0.08445914834737778, 0.16056813299655914, 0.0828445628285408, -0.6041713953018188, 0.2981826663017273, -0.3514266908168793, -0.4154048264026642, 0.19775508344173431, 0.716945469379425, 0.9525125622749329, -0.060389578342437744, -0.4826606214046478, 0.95726478099823, -0.24054573476314545, -0.04366715997457504, -0.22550059854984283, 0.04708852991461754, -0.4810454845428467, 0.2495119422674179, 0.26202958822250366, 0.7147786617279053, 0.36137670278549194, -0.4680512249469757, 0.1351666897535324, 0.408245325088501, -0.9471955895423889, -0.6969385147094727, 0.2905879616737366, 0.24812345206737518, -0.46237993240356445, 0.6182490587234497, -0.27450883388519287, -0.4008488655090332, 0.650210976600647, 0.33577513694763184, 1.3310763835906982, -0.01865290477871895, 0.20511071383953094, 0.6642053127288818, 0.37477120757102966, -0.1971888691186905, 0.41357094049453735, -0.08325366675853729, -0.3968765139579773, -0.05004839226603508, -0.27088624238967896, -0.5233718752861023, -0.48379892110824585, -0.6578261256217957, 0.45529821515083313, -0.4514142572879791, -0.5294579863548279, -0.11597452312707901, -0.10872018337249756, -0.7106319665908813, 0.3844539225101471, 0.027440087869763374, 1.054091453552246, -0.8172647356987, 0.2631995975971222, 0.6074250936508179, -0.23515808582305908, -0.675383985042572, 0.17151370644569397, 0.06942092627286911, -0.7872005701065063, 0.5522103309631348, 0.39737996459007263, -0.22920505702495575, -0.2288963943719864, -0.5701755881309509, -0.7042088508605957, 1.2701131105422974, 0.3188335597515106, -0.4639851152896881, 0.14020171761512756, 0.08940248936414719, 0.7631677985191345, -0.3200036883354187, 0.9708722829818726, 0.48408639430999756, 0.4149131178855896, 0.26075613498687744, -0.8286982178688049, 0.18231487274169922, -0.2768855094909668, 0.06131984293460846, -0.08001679182052612, -0.814330518245697, 0.390731543302536, -0.41664350032806396, -0.5013639330863953, 0.35472387075424194, 0.49207887053489685, 0.19115711748600006, 0.8548046946525574, 0.6981177926063538, 0.5939187407493591, 0.6074116826057434, -0.42874276638031006, 1.2150377035140991, -0.23986297845840454, 0.3135603070259094, 0.8910731673240662, -0.10769066959619522, 0.8382219672203064, 0.4930846393108368, -0.16330412030220032, 0.3833775520324707, 0.7923261523246765, -0.3056495189666748, 0.5693386793136597, -0.38557669520378113, 0.24879635870456696, -0.32520791888237, -0.6735410094261169, -0.27608931064605713, 0.24826247990131378, 0.11680751293897629, -0.47858959436416626, -0.3822619616985321, -0.28366145491600037, -0.35784924030303955, 0.021147673949599266, -0.2031116634607315, 1.0029879808425903, 0.13573645055294037, -1.0862224102020264, 0.4512815773487091, -0.29904812574386597, 0.4215851128101349, -0.3971671760082245, 0.07458774000406265, -0.20507803559303284, 0.024619871750473976, -0.4358125627040863, -1.3897526264190674, 0.432129442691803, 0.30013757944107056, -0.3212757408618927, -0.12451400607824326, 0.6124106049537659, -0.221485897898674, -0.47942274808883667, 0.4746123254299164, 0.42857322096824646, 0.2099156677722931, 0.19776293635368347, -0.7685191035270691, 0.07043647021055222, -0.4017377495765686, -0.10626707971096039, -0.17526409029960632, 0.3484043776988983, -0.13438332080841064, 0.3177681267261505, 0.24409790337085724, -0.27043741941452026, -0.3098641335964203, 0.19945763051509857, 0.6792749762535095, -0.4545924663543701, -0.4055066406726837, -0.8588183522224426, 0.39834868907928467, -0.18907955288887024, -0.5632932186126709, 0.6644148230552673, 0.5576605796813965, 0.3671969175338745, 0.04687559977173805, 0.5006405711174011, 0.14806541800498962, 0.4033459424972534, -0.3671477437019348, 0.567145586013794, -0.804142951965332, -0.010230260901153088, -0.39747166633605957, -1.0126248598098755, 0.0537586472928524, -0.08492644131183624, -0.2723189890384674, 0.10457007586956024, 0.8447282910346985, 0.8071185946464539, -0.020942145958542824, 0.032633163034915924, 0.4250805974006653, 0.1160273551940918, 0.1227327436208725, 0.5904632806777954, 1.1250977516174316, -0.6635335087776184, 0.4918757379055023, -0.005815710406750441, -0.4002838134765625, -0.11005271971225739, -0.834568977355957, -0.9812366366386414, -0.4721356928348541, -0.5171322822570801, -0.8430635333061218, 0.14023292064666748, 0.8703899383544922, 0.5216657519340515, -0.927977442741394, 0.14716659486293793, -0.10026510804891586, -0.05296606197953224, -0.045515794306993484, -0.18623016774654388, 0.5527044534683228, -0.4580918550491333, -0.5802263617515564, -0.08505067229270935, 0.6533126831054688, 0.1850939691066742, -0.18522733449935913, -0.18663647770881653, 0.6012295484542847, 0.03398833051323891, 0.4610873758792877, -0.210191547870636, -0.8866004347801208, -0.39716866612434387, 0.2741524577140808, -0.6177228093147278, 0.23805510997772217, 0.4172171354293823, -0.5671282410621643, 0.6832402944564819, 0.8163765072822571, 0.32372698187828064, -0.011499457061290741, 0.055140379816293716, 0.400199294090271, -0.4850611090660095, -0.08243432641029358, 0.23395836353302002, 0.2834921181201935, 0.5184040665626526, -0.18312855064868927, 0.4912533164024353, 0.537047266960144, -0.41075342893600464, -0.7675244212150574, 0.1945541352033615, -1.2841626405715942, 0.16944803297519684, 1.1083219051361084, -0.37870439887046814, -0.4976305365562439, -0.0959511324763298, -0.27355116605758667, 0.153560072183609, -0.44504857063293457, 0.6031861901283264, 0.5515419244766235, 0.1316928267478943, -0.1859600841999054, -0.23330815136432648, 0.48071375489234924, 0.47479763627052307, -0.6861278414726257, -0.4541966915130615, 0.5376213192939758, 0.5317338109016418, 0.35459035634994507, 0.5153119564056396, -0.2696286737918854, 0.7199523448944092, 0.0736386850476265, -0.3672623038291931, -0.172559455037117, -0.17371313273906708, -0.2500723898410797, 0.2062426507472992, 0.07642415910959244, -0.25819358229637146 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04242v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04242v1
Physical Property Understanding from Language-Embedded Feature Fields
2024-04-05T17:45:07
2024-04-05T17:45:07
Albert J. Zhai, Yuan Shen, Emily Y. Chen, Gloria X. Wang, Xinlei Wang, Sheng Wang, Kaiyu Guan, Shenlong Wang
cs.CV
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
Can computers perceive the physical properties of objects solely through vision? Research in cognitive science and vision science has shown that humans excel at identifying materials and estimating their physical properties based purely on visual appearance. In this paper, we present a novel approach for dense prediction of the physical properties of objects using a collection of images. Inspired by how humans reason about physics through vision, we leverage large language models to propose candidate materials for each object. We then construct a language-embedded point cloud and estimate the physical properties of each 3D point using a zero-shot kernel regression approach. Our method is accurate, annotation-free, and applicable to any object in the open world. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach in various physical property reasoning tasks, such as estimating the mass of common objects, as well as other properties like friction and hardness.
[ -0.3321111798286438, -1.0884778499603271, 0.9539896845817566, -0.1267271786928177, -0.2574712932109833, -0.1867295205593109, -0.20589089393615723, -0.7831190824508667, 0.2078324556350708, 0.49635937809944153, 0.0394258089363575, -0.3914202153682709, -0.432298481464386, -0.5050022602081299, -0.17617195844650269, 0.45162275433540344, -0.17283055186271667, -0.20375387370586395, -0.5540926456451416, -0.10364119708538055, -0.1281016618013382, -0.29637208580970764, 0.06776409596204758, -0.23814022541046143, 0.3320244550704956, 0.0609213225543499, 0.8939090371131897, 0.7194600105285645, 0.3250363767147064, 0.23814067244529724, 0.11075463145971298, -0.06877495348453522, -0.03537623956799507, -0.14024218916893005, -0.20924332737922668, -0.34863731265068054, -0.12027645856142044, -0.09953528642654419, 0.5144282579421997, 0.8976309895515442, 0.3590982258319855, 0.06720039993524551, 0.18695023655891418, 0.3678900897502899, -1.010319471359253, 0.222403421998024, -0.6992780566215515, 0.6183305978775024, -0.06425356864929199, -0.20066982507705688, -0.41570985317230225, 0.33112478256225586, 0.061581626534461975, -0.9251957535743713, 0.6920113563537598, -0.1800365298986435, 0.9131953716278076, 0.12516459822654724, -0.1817251443862915, 0.18384909629821777, -0.8653528094291687, 1.1295033693313599, 0.0683535635471344, 0.776190996170044, 0.8445330858230591, 0.4289814233779907, 0.03715309873223305, -0.07343637943267822, -0.4703182876110077, -0.3213852047920227, -0.15009251236915588, 0.23645323514938354, 0.3579939901828766, -0.028748856857419014, -0.049044255167245865, 0.19402943551540375, -0.4195719361305237, -0.1941583901643753, -0.3648137152194977, -0.16257594525814056, 0.7163311243057251, -0.1576131284236908, 0.26898977160453796, -0.040390707552433014, -0.27164801955223083, -0.4026906192302704, -0.329534113407135, 0.048052676022052765, -0.11874993145465851, 0.349527508020401, -0.12386774271726608, 0.9034544229507446, -0.17484652996063232, 0.8295328617095947, -0.22313615679740906, -0.21858598291873932, 0.047402750700712204, -0.08774742484092712, -0.2886166274547577, -0.04060667008161545, 0.7132014632225037, 0.18272776901721954, 0.2095758467912674, -0.32431215047836304, -0.09367398172616959, -0.12745699286460876, 0.16269904375076294, -0.5762182474136353, -0.540250301361084, 0.38688865303993225, -0.42635205388069153, -0.3438180387020111, 0.3106738030910492, -0.5637790560722351, -0.7647185921669006, -0.19147904217243195, 0.5357069373130798, -0.35680124163627625, -0.45841479301452637, 0.20490722358226776, -0.2172970175743103, 0.0687648355960846, 0.5984331965446472, -1.0351420640945435, 0.28360283374786377, 0.7244136929512024, 0.8484042882919312, 0.4248606264591217, -0.4955666959285736, -0.351399302482605, 0.16547298431396484, -0.363254576921463, 1.0227446556091309, -0.6769200563430786, -0.4453614354133606, -0.24313171207904816, -0.24161826074123383, 0.540554940700531, -0.40934741497039795, -0.052439216524362564, -0.04606908559799194, -0.15848854184150696, -0.07392575591802597, -0.04502610117197037, -0.2600400447845459, 0.2693629264831543, -0.7599009871482849, 1.0376527309417725, 0.21840788424015045, -0.576117753982544, 0.8072161674499512, -0.3335508406162262, -0.38135504722595215, 0.2713560163974762, -0.28197649121284485, -0.4240598678588867, 0.5930615663528442, 0.31194424629211426, 0.7567787766456604, -0.1259206235408783, 0.2082621157169342, -0.6550213098526001, -0.2895526885986328, 0.5574263334274292, -0.175421342253685, 0.2764182388782501, 0.2477303445339203, -0.13555021584033966, -0.17093901336193085, -0.7504710555076599, -0.05896354839205742, 0.05078743025660515, 0.05251472443342209, -0.4700079560279846, 0.5749958753585815, 0.17060022056102753, -0.023886865004897118, 0.6636592745780945, -0.8582102656364441, 0.07088011503219604, -0.023630645126104355, -0.23560801148414612, 0.4199036955833435, -0.21001093089580536, 0.7991921305656433, 0.18211574852466583, 0.13794173300266266, 0.2046709805727005, 0.2281693071126938, 0.018062256276607513, -0.5295416712760925, -0.29774975776672363, -0.42967700958251953, -0.21731209754943848, 0.2894706428050995, -0.3744662404060364, 0.3696027398109436, 0.004669839516282082, -0.6047798991203308, -0.2108771651983261, 0.4552591145038605, 0.3392038643360138, 0.5725811123847961, 0.39977142214775085, 0.11678029596805573, -0.2615991532802582, -0.7033416628837585, -0.18204687535762787, -0.22361285984516144, -0.43167033791542053, 0.7054599523544312, 0.15726210176944733, 0.11422103643417358, 1.086136817932129, -0.8758998513221741, -0.013397119008004665, 0.002966040512546897, 0.2632821500301361, 0.03822338953614235, 0.34537389874458313, 0.429095983505249, -0.8174277544021606, -0.39250579476356506, 0.8453076481819153, -1.2488982677459717, 0.01928281970322132, -0.1767333745956421, -0.048947274684906006, 0.1252182275056839, 0.18984083831310272, -0.19684956967830658, 0.4913308024406433, 0.3766249716281891, -0.7111844420433044, 0.2320530116558075, -0.25403356552124023, -0.07774393260478973, -0.5778396129608154, 0.17931169271469116, 0.7884851098060608, -0.12099093198776245, -0.3628627359867096, 0.0691542997956276, 0.05930766835808754, -0.47752565145492554, -0.7150123715400696, 1.0140304565429688, -0.6186183094978333, -0.6215845346450806, -0.20481052994728088, 0.055804621428251266, 0.17340156435966492, 0.4342377483844757, 0.6448422074317932, 0.36740437150001526, 0.8714178800582886, -0.648370623588562, 0.2734962999820709, 0.08174999803304672, -0.38875582814216614, 0.7463818788528442, -0.47470736503601074, -0.08448956161737442, -0.3483927547931671, -0.23256875574588776, -0.4623071253299713, -0.09872831404209137, -0.012036444619297981, -0.4745899736881256, 0.051952410489320755, -0.199576273560524, -0.3583424985408783, -0.03989117592573166, -0.1478402018547058, 0.33626100420951843, 0.18308445811271667, -0.30457913875579834, 0.8932228088378906, 0.3998860716819763, 0.09031444042921066, -0.5831170082092285, -0.5702316164970398, -0.09457610547542572, 0.053717903792858124, -0.5933651328086853, 0.11318440735340118, -0.18956303596496582, -0.5772424936294556, 0.2696835696697235, 0.0892704501748085, -0.6905938386917114, 0.4141969084739685, 0.5386937260627747, 0.1850358247756958, -0.21952606737613678, 0.048843398690223694, -0.21579931676387787, -0.014836546033620834, -0.22276310622692108, -0.3982561230659485, 0.29005810618400574, -0.4813021719455719, -0.18950876593589783, -0.2629571855068207, 0.1393151432275772, 0.48755261301994324, -0.10395833104848862, 0.47377949953079224, 0.39812132716178894, -0.7085092663764954, -0.36558911204338074, -0.5306588411331177, -0.15578773617744446, -0.4346247613430023, 0.566929042339325, -0.6737491488456726, -0.438751757144928, 0.5067853927612305, 0.34767642617225647, -0.11492513120174408, 0.3413553535938263, 0.27531203627586365, -0.4606555104255676, 0.9983544945716858, 0.881282389163971, 0.31394702196121216, 0.5504322648048401, -0.42602163553237915, 0.16749455034732819, -0.5773571133613586, -0.682192862033844, -0.2519127130508423, -0.5267495512962341, -0.2749707102775574, -0.4364219903945923, 0.307527095079422, 0.35994580388069153, -0.19449113309383392, 0.4891466200351715, -0.7464779019355774, 0.6287767291069031, 0.3043709099292755, 0.6647084951400757, 0.06854734569787979, 0.09226936846971512, 0.07240593433380127, 0.039541613310575485, -0.16577719151973724, -0.31999099254608154, 0.8357322216033936, 0.38763490319252014, 0.5947757363319397, -0.4405228793621063, 0.38138967752456665, 0.02894013002514839, 0.15916261076927185, -1.1229175329208374, 0.5478683114051819, -0.24503128230571747, -0.30937138199806213, -0.45238667726516724, -0.53425532579422, -0.7786210775375366, 0.34183281660079956, -0.37573692202568054, -0.8505485653877258, 0.21959778666496277, 0.32270529866218567, -0.18351085484027863, 0.6208203434944153, -0.7293281555175781, 0.8662077188491821, -0.7827319502830505, -0.4759519398212433, -0.10032793134450912, -0.11669576168060303, 0.18232102692127228, -0.09635113179683685, 0.2627996504306793, -0.1946508139371872, -0.05370523780584335, 0.5769528746604919, -0.3983287215232849, 0.8027894496917725, -0.40634748339653015, 0.0490138977766037, 0.568934977054596, 0.48936524987220764, 0.0074729472398757935, 0.09753521531820297, -0.1634998619556427, 0.5220850110054016, 0.10816036909818649, -0.6757366061210632, -0.9758075475692749, 0.640487551689148, -0.9955429434776306, -0.06326375901699066, -0.2591175138950348, -0.6801671981811523, -0.13447198271751404, 0.2524513304233551, 0.06689871847629547, 0.24639026820659637, -0.17539280652999878, 0.0235560555011034, 0.355268269777298, -0.24738961458206177, 0.421325147151947, 0.4115890860557556, -0.2093547135591507, -0.2078254073858261, 1.2664755582809448, 0.15652671456336975, -0.13446547091007233, 0.8243846297264099, 0.7117442488670349, -0.24395492672920227, -0.5049738883972168, -0.11725235730409622, 0.2448074370622635, -0.45345085859298706, -0.019775455817580223, -0.6486256122589111, -0.0640420913696289, -0.09412746876478195, -0.9366307258605957, -0.46156179904937744, -0.42621493339538574, -0.26020047068595886, -0.20753544569015503, 0.4901072382926941, 1.07582426071167, 0.09034527838230133, 0.16008307039737701, -0.7281142473220825, 0.28064635396003723, 0.32780933380126953, 0.690941572189331, -0.2419968545436859, -0.14136892557144165, -0.44825711846351624, 0.21196898818016052, -0.14820125699043274, -0.31927523016929626, 0.4105708599090576, 0.1053285002708435, 0.4033931791782379, 0.5601035952568054, -0.26771241426467896, 0.5686519742012024, -0.1784997135400772, 0.8240834474563599, 0.41060107946395874, -0.947054386138916, 0.8046135902404785, -0.22190697491168976, 0.14038307964801788, 0.45608946681022644, 0.17893086373806, -0.08574242889881134, -0.15236805379390717, -0.7533327341079712, -0.41987141966819763, 0.19803844392299652, -0.14473894238471985, -0.04855472967028618, -0.06840827316045761, 0.14281390607357025, 0.08916763216257095, -0.01242357213050127, -0.6917545199394226, 0.3561209440231323, -0.7074058651924133, -0.21524587273597717, 0.02415766566991806, -0.03161263465881348, 0.07863818109035492, -0.13021868467330933, 0.12648242712020874, -0.33936649560928345, 0.2956507205963135, 0.124903105199337, -0.32611083984375, -0.218512624502182, -0.2431418001651764, 0.6495261192321777, 0.6199454069137573, -0.6389117240905762, 0.4934764504432678, -0.05186745524406433, -0.6678807735443115, -0.15638022124767303, -0.2270401120185852, -0.055798329412937164, -0.010725563392043114, 0.21573983132839203, 0.5664618611335754, 0.2674616873264313, -0.6961646676063538, 0.4956163763999939, 0.26082512736320496, -0.3493718206882477, -0.3926931619644165, -0.31839102506637573, -0.43703126907348633, 0.1337314397096634, 0.2742346525192261, -0.0879923552274704, -0.15479345619678497, -0.6241254210472107, 0.347802996635437, 0.5708298087120056, -0.8538097739219666, -0.7717201709747314, 0.5308824181556702, 0.20779770612716675, 0.021056028082966805, 0.5743312239646912, 0.039642345160245895, -0.22188732028007507, 0.7933198809623718, 0.3028087019920349, 0.9311302304267883, 0.12800510227680206, 0.3162359893321991, 0.3769589364528656, 0.09887811541557312, -0.11481636762619019, 0.4045100212097168, -0.3469163477420807, -1.2050362825393677, -0.38733774423599243, -0.8354259729385376, -0.5201588869094849, -0.09617197513580322, -0.150307297706604, 0.4510589838027954, -1.189858317375183, 0.2408199906349182, -0.03266892582178116, 0.06552644819021225, -0.8052278757095337, 0.5186668038368225, 0.4601384699344635, 0.6689172983169556, -1.2489391565322876, 0.6893610954284668, 0.6817173361778259, -0.7210761904716492, -0.4320164918899536, -0.3878166675567627, -0.21735869348049164, -0.9142389297485352, 0.9244106411933899, 0.011292517185211182, -0.18315356969833374, -0.4104655086994171, -0.6851826906204224, -0.7017443180084229, 1.04289710521698, 0.3872917890548706, -0.13649028539657593, 0.4122178256511688, 0.1407642364501953, 0.17914941906929016, 0.0002768685226328671, 0.431460440158844, 0.017771849408745766, 0.4855608344078064, 0.23515048623085022, -0.7579225897789001, -0.15197083353996277, -0.3218728303909302, -0.19043847918510437, 0.48964643478393555, -0.3455559015274048, 0.885698676109314, -0.1478823721408844, -0.12040094286203384, -0.29104164242744446, 0.7930389046669006, 0.2780156135559082, 0.33962929248809814, 0.4237172603607178, 0.7392755150794983, 0.6927255392074585, 0.13163429498672485, 1.2571173906326294, -0.37587714195251465, 0.4813505709171295, 0.586793065071106, -0.432468980550766, 0.9314481019973755, 0.4277989864349365, -0.03945491462945938, 0.38052132725715637, 0.20129913091659546, -0.21994495391845703, 0.40487927198410034, 0.060323674231767654, -0.5388113260269165, -0.19365626573562622, -0.2785823941230774, 0.12057790905237198, 0.7456194758415222, 0.5558885931968689, -0.17773157358169556, -0.07559183239936829, -0.029903925955295563, -0.1275671273469925, 0.2432311475276947, -0.3080480694770813, 0.6463451385498047, -0.00963831227272749, -0.34013494849205017, 0.4091847836971283, -0.1843804568052292, 0.5435788631439209, -0.4622253179550171, -0.2398943156003952, 0.15750576555728912, 0.02301820181310177, -0.36831235885620117, -1.2500464916229248, 0.4901648759841919, -0.16039320826530457, -0.1394079625606537, -0.3425653278827667, 0.6133643388748169, -0.13497371971607208, -0.8832387924194336, 0.09402231872081757, 0.2407284379005432, 0.422943651676178, -0.46574515104293823, -0.29056042432785034, -0.07665625959634781, -0.48636573553085327, 0.041504159569740295, 0.4791494607925415, 0.5328114032745361, -0.22188220918178558, 0.4896489381790161, 0.5540220737457275, 0.29798051714897156, -0.17481468617916107, -0.21898742020130157, 0.5101983547210693, -0.8938305377960205, -0.3073974847793579, -0.46864667534828186, 0.7079669237136841, -0.10732480883598328, -0.2072588950395584, 0.4151473641395569, 0.6582534313201904, 0.7983333468437195, -0.20069588720798492, 0.9665968418121338, -0.04172614961862564, 0.04415065050125122, -0.5120943784713745, 0.6083348989486694, -0.5554359555244446, -0.1771485060453415, -0.17864614725112915, -1.2261431217193604, -0.6539580821990967, 0.8863574862480164, -0.29527315497398376, -0.09235458076000214, 0.790364146232605, 0.7838496565818787, -0.40637126564979553, -0.3732876777648926, 0.8757303357124329, 0.10002511739730835, 0.30711454153060913, 0.37131258845329285, 0.43649473786354065, -0.18664158880710602, 0.34911221265792847, -0.7674044370651245, -0.38552889227867126, 0.062041446566581726, -1.1125348806381226, -0.690253496170044, -0.5580384731292725, -0.3191835284233093, -0.2074791043996811, -0.4016551673412323, 0.39832237362861633, 0.8449620008468628, -0.6289270520210266, -0.2754426896572113, -0.22368647158145905, -0.1577504426240921, -0.2957902252674103, -0.200115367770195, 0.4419264793395996, 0.20676808059215546, -0.5347630977630615, 0.5175056457519531, 0.3868727385997772, 0.160768523812294, -0.4205501079559326, 0.19299189746379852, 0.18049032986164093, -0.13503830134868622, 0.7655462026596069, 0.6996642351150513, -0.7944048643112183, -0.5852550268173218, 0.09025596082210541, 0.021363673731684685, -0.019706815481185913, 0.8608231544494629, -0.9599961042404175, 0.7330151796340942, 0.8333117961883545, 0.6127642393112183, 0.6536760926246643, -0.06651899218559265, 0.5222736597061157, -0.8841705918312073, 0.6853789687156677, 0.3230663239955902, 0.7693906426429749, 0.46448251605033875, -0.6332406997680664, 0.29340019822120667, 0.24942956864833832, -0.12337900698184967, -0.3712936043739319, 0.268663614988327, -1.4661799669265747, -0.4917059540748596, 0.8420945405960083, 0.05988721549510956, -0.7100451588630676, 0.0176329854875803, 0.03333044424653053, -0.09005361795425415, -0.1682838499546051, 0.8810194730758667, 0.38622304797172546, -0.06365463137626648, -0.7733303308486938, -0.5512427091598511, -0.1319705843925476, 0.3042072355747223, -0.7296911478042603, -0.06239509582519531, 0.4180801212787628, 0.05377615615725517, 0.4103648066520691, 0.31420284509658813, -0.24833375215530396, 0.09710343182086945, 0.10326623916625977, 0.39026927947998047, -0.2599247992038727, -0.7389464974403381, -0.10965285450220108, 0.17468693852424622, 0.19405129551887512, -0.1131923645734787 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04237v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04237v1
Cleared for Takeoff? Compositional & Conditional Reasoning may be the Achilles Heel to (Flight-Booking) Language Agents
2024-04-05T17:36:26
2024-04-05T17:36:26
Harsh Kohli, Huan Sun
cs.CL
cs.CL
The rapid progress of large language models (LLMs) has seen them excel and frequently surpass human performance on standard benchmarks. This has enabled many downstream applications, such as LLM agents, to rely on their sophisticated reasoning to navigate complex task requirements. However, LLMs are known to unexpectedly falter in simple tasks and under seemingly straightforward circumstances - underscoring the need for better and more diverse evaluation setups to measure their true capabilities. To this end, we choose to study compositional and conditional reasoning, two cornerstones of human cognition, and introduce GroundCocoa - a lexically diverse benchmark connecting these reasoning skills to the real-world problem of flight booking. Our task involves aligning detailed user preferences with available flight options presented in a multiple-choice format. Results indicate a significant disparity in performance among current state-of-the-art LLMs with even the best performing model, GPT-4 Turbo, not exceeding 67% accuracy despite advanced prompting techniques.
[ -0.40961822867393494, -0.3670131266117096, 0.8608643412590027, 0.14668743312358856, -0.14961208403110504, 0.4239335060119629, -0.24567022919654846, -0.37153932452201843, 0.0822061076760292, 0.6040807962417603, -0.6369710564613342, -0.5325247645378113, -0.35052385926246643, -0.16651642322540283, -0.305778443813324, 0.7759392261505127, 0.030947905033826828, -0.24967516958713531, -0.6954705715179443, -0.15824268758296967, -0.8409298062324524, -0.851698637008667, -0.7059075236320496, -0.5173289775848389, 0.4840792715549469, 0.3808276653289795, 0.8877190351486206, 0.24243515729904175, 0.2501387894153595, 0.21400925517082214, -0.09490379691123962, 0.10095289349555969, -0.11363677680492401, 0.08485483378171921, -0.48582330346107483, -0.4285471737384796, -0.1321372240781784, 0.17453595995903015, 0.42162397503852844, 0.893412172794342, -0.46939775347709656, -0.5196612477302551, -0.32160964608192444, 0.699962854385376, -0.723296582698822, -0.08381597697734833, -0.7873611450195312, -0.14753276109695435, 0.19583457708358765, 0.06509899348020554, -0.29672032594680786, -0.09932070225477219, 0.036578137427568436, -0.8136678338050842, -0.1513323187828064, 0.07603106647729874, 0.9815287590026855, 0.5675990581512451, -0.7161452174186707, -0.5224089026451111, -0.5418087244033813, 0.666965663433075, -0.3216385245323181, 0.6156288981437683, 0.4317062795162201, 0.41956865787506104, -0.3022291660308838, -0.7627273797988892, -0.5849615335464478, -0.6612690687179565, 0.02655954100191593, 0.27961233258247375, -0.1361539214849472, 0.1405860185623169, 0.24788177013397217, 0.012425310909748077, -0.5495690703392029, 0.3102864623069763, -0.12442284822463989, -0.47061389684677124, 0.4131951332092285, 0.2355271577835083, 0.41696277260780334, 0.1505802422761917, -0.19492357969284058, 0.06287002563476562, -0.5252422094345093, 0.39766064286231995, 0.3393065333366394, 0.19355502724647522, -0.16466683149337769, 0.4616412818431854, -0.6760150790214539, 0.9075237512588501, -0.13457214832305908, -0.10360755771398544, -0.22635692358016968, -0.16652148962020874, -0.49916785955429077, -0.12001629918813705, 0.28421029448509216, 0.40309977531433105, 0.21406888961791992, -0.4109772741794586, -0.28657272458076477, 0.2148534655570984, 0.43455779552459717, -0.5480428338050842, -0.07538574934005737, 0.5246824026107788, 0.005353630054742098, -0.08740402013063431, -0.0035845052916556597, -0.27915048599243164, -0.34131959080696106, -0.6988435387611389, 0.25602033734321594, -0.3052995204925537, -0.05848122760653496, 0.44682320952415466, -0.29271700978279114, 0.33640334010124207, 0.4242081642150879, -0.619084894657135, 0.2587866187095642, 1.0260790586471558, 0.6462617516517639, -0.216537207365036, -0.48416805267333984, -0.47071054577827454, -0.11008688062429428, -0.5227373838424683, 0.9758617281913757, -0.5824668407440186, -0.40524032711982727, 0.021957939490675926, -0.22671742737293243, -0.17162145674228668, -0.549325704574585, 1.0446265935897827, -0.8182113170623779, 0.06950236111879349, -0.808039128780365, -0.36876747012138367, -0.32115277647972107, 0.44818899035453796, -0.42498406767845154, 0.5273833274841309, 0.15006951987743378, -0.3036712110042572, 0.7113297581672668, -0.00377978035248816, -0.6310607194900513, 0.09318821132183075, -0.5940675735473633, -0.1151256337761879, -0.10104188323020935, 0.029215414077043533, 0.028958013281226158, -0.36719152331352234, 0.43492382764816284, -0.19758175313472748, -0.4933788776397705, 0.12216018885374069, -0.05847623571753502, 0.7549933791160583, 0.34987592697143555, -0.14857454597949982, -0.057246673852205276, -0.6208053231239319, 0.09311209619045258, -0.12259072810411453, -0.5385555624961853, -0.10488558560609818, 0.13283085823059082, -0.2540111243724823, 0.47028660774230957, 0.3225114941596985, -0.049460314214229584, 0.25809037685394287, -0.43287840485572815, 0.3442756235599518, 0.6230753660202026, -0.11412588506937027, 0.4105892479419708, -0.4930260181427002, 0.6811614036560059, 0.06450457125902176, 0.003557981224730611, 0.07900954782962799, -0.3611352741718292, -0.7480748295783997, -0.21356609463691711, -0.06859662383794785, 0.48041966557502747, -0.4426386058330536, 0.5880089998245239, -0.19191974401474, -0.5686235427856445, 0.16441373527050018, -0.015271809883415699, 0.17222636938095093, 0.45764410495758057, 0.07383422553539276, 0.023711146786808968, -0.4844842851161957, -0.834736168384552, -0.6375777721405029, -0.23842409253120422, 0.23639510571956635, 0.3330000042915344, 0.29820775985717773, -0.29481199383735657, 1.0046658515930176, -0.4443598985671997, -0.006098726764321327, -0.20615120232105255, -0.13848432898521423, 0.2270001471042633, 0.36221379041671753, 0.6003085970878601, -0.7887122631072998, -0.2438029795885086, 0.15154284238815308, -0.6015987992286682, -0.1637253314256668, -0.29908883571624756, -0.368166446685791, 0.2523401081562042, 0.480520635843277, -0.8874393701553345, 0.24137596786022186, 0.4134281575679779, -0.522193431854248, 0.5828567743301392, -0.10144008696079254, 0.1048617735505104, -0.4977554976940155, 0.08074679970741272, -0.39565208554267883, -0.06830409914255142, -0.3720584511756897, 0.10575439780950546, -0.13294446468353271, -0.19644232094287872, -0.33428579568862915, 0.5622077584266663, -0.39087292551994324, -0.3762754797935486, -0.5326868295669556, 0.0835832953453064, 0.38154342770576477, 0.45601943135261536, 0.2248694896697998, 0.9426646828651428, 0.5894414186477661, -0.7608469128608704, 0.14814899861812592, 0.10479258000850677, -0.09659860283136368, 0.5442734956741333, -0.4429514706134796, 0.1959826499223709, -0.03911279886960983, 0.45106372237205505, -0.9814784526824951, -0.3004014492034912, 0.14048539102077484, -0.21806146204471588, -0.1213454157114029, -0.2868216037750244, -0.14753013849258423, -0.19622378051280975, 0.020221006125211716, 0.2129494696855545, 0.41515421867370605, -0.416005402803421, 0.8582833409309387, 0.2142762690782547, 0.1097017452120781, -0.5842304229736328, -0.39970090985298157, 0.3658164441585541, -0.010237190872430801, -0.6205922365188599, 0.34251850843429565, -0.06364917010068893, -0.4708024859428406, -0.22129714488983154, -0.6427225470542908, -0.17978322505950928, 0.2515324652194977, 0.3947009742259979, 0.16672645509243011, -0.002159146824851632, 0.06753933429718018, 0.17252117395401, 0.0023878903593868017, 0.1289859414100647, -0.6445072889328003, 0.3644963800907135, -0.3688012957572937, -0.43084433674812317, -0.15795019268989563, 0.1858365535736084, 0.7850128412246704, -0.1819748878479004, 0.6755569577217102, 0.09275014698505402, -0.48152056336402893, -0.159969300031662, -0.6818915009498596, 0.03848801553249359, -0.4464161992073059, 0.026410944759845734, -0.8998988270759583, -0.6212881207466125, 0.5442928075790405, 0.08909612149000168, -0.1340438276529312, 0.37130439281463623, 0.4699132740497589, -0.004428741987794638, 0.679164707660675, 0.3732852637767792, 0.16382382810115814, 0.20329289138317108, -0.2702295482158661, 0.2214403599500656, -0.4468822181224823, -0.521446168422699, -0.7183985710144043, 0.12550057470798492, -0.43659454584121704, -0.3239394426345825, 0.1414000540971756, 0.17048481106758118, -0.2545052766799927, 0.1855078786611557, -0.2651737630367279, 0.7580196857452393, 0.3611222803592682, -0.17200392484664917, 0.34944087266921997, -0.1632944494485855, -0.5132598876953125, 0.32131215929985046, -0.4944913387298584, -0.7418766617774963, 0.7670400738716125, -0.05889565125107765, 0.49440330266952515, -0.05442463979125023, 0.3919789493083954, 0.14307916164398193, 0.09113641828298569, -0.8914656639099121, 0.6110743880271912, -0.07987668365240097, -0.6012569665908813, -0.041637320071458817, -0.22933049499988556, -0.6725277304649353, 0.41085830330848694, 0.11790970712900162, -0.5172918438911438, 0.21583358943462372, -0.02463214285671711, -0.578529417514801, 0.007111145183444023, -0.751649022102356, 0.8081504106521606, -0.550365686416626, -0.32753750681877136, -0.1152782067656517, -0.6361379027366638, 0.3231271803379059, -0.1761665791273117, 0.12931764125823975, -0.42341873049736023, -0.35259008407592773, 0.648836076259613, -0.35019221901893616, 0.5959115624427795, -0.18723973631858826, -0.055307481437921524, 0.34484246373176575, 0.3384721875190735, 0.3545849621295929, 0.07115179300308228, -0.2524026036262512, 0.28564101457595825, 0.055463969707489014, -0.36389270424842834, -0.7091023921966553, 0.9031082391738892, -0.9700822830200195, -0.695232093334198, -0.6096447706222534, -0.28467461466789246, -0.5810850858688354, 0.337973028421402, 0.17958417534828186, 0.36376622319221497, -0.04849801957607269, -0.0948183462023735, 0.007770598400384188, -0.10079655796289444, 0.2032168209552765, 0.6886668801307678, -0.062383368611335754, -0.5204352140426636, 0.5914124846458435, 0.09728974103927612, 0.10352052003145218, 0.5202019214630127, 0.20709328353405, -0.664078950881958, -0.7385483980178833, 0.057143524289131165, 0.22208505868911743, -1.1931958198547363, 0.07793593406677246, -0.8827322721481323, -0.023960746824741364, -0.29104286432266235, -0.5292106866836548, -0.36741986870765686, -0.4672757685184479, -0.1665029078722, -0.16679486632347107, -0.2662779688835144, 0.4818923771381378, 0.2575242221355438, 0.28167375922203064, -0.4090573489665985, 0.20365449786186218, 0.4399271309375763, 0.3106805980205536, -0.20695599913597107, -0.5203059315681458, -0.3976288139820099, 0.01671508699655533, -0.37842029333114624, -0.4409056603908539, 0.029950160533189774, -0.08340135961771011, 0.947327733039856, 0.31791818141937256, 0.035252153873443604, 0.5925584435462952, -0.0941731259226799, 0.817199170589447, 0.015237721614539623, -1.0122770071029663, 0.552915632724762, -0.25769034028053284, -0.066693015396595, 0.8385665416717529, 0.27114060521125793, -0.5222716927528381, -0.3519323766231537, -0.5688266158103943, -0.5608506798744202, 0.7762301564216614, 0.27449724078178406, -0.14777962863445282, -0.006813479587435722, 0.3380403518676758, 0.035482246428728104, 0.40039896965026855, -0.6518202424049377, 0.10338034480810165, -0.435714989900589, 0.22289931774139404, -0.34778082370758057, 0.03804603964090347, -0.08405525982379913, -0.27603527903556824, 0.4991598129272461, -0.21070100367069244, -0.03904910758137703, 0.23134706914424896, -0.11807383596897125, 0.06797436624765396, 0.15049119293689728, 1.0581152439117432, 1.0966980457305908, -0.33959725499153137, 0.24885188043117523, -0.12391718477010727, -0.16986238956451416, 0.4798663854598999, -0.15707291662693024, 0.027704842388629913, -0.36307379603385925, 0.4142908751964569, 0.6265695691108704, -0.0002462175616528839, -1.0001482963562012, 0.49058666825294495, -0.01870509423315525, -0.11339729279279709, -0.3218099772930145, 0.21831229329109192, 0.14603669941425323, -0.20560000836849213, 0.1772696077823639, 0.33227917551994324, 0.15626433491706848, -0.4428614377975464, 0.2657972574234009, 0.4731646478176117, -0.04178570583462715, -0.2191241979598999, 0.7420344352722168, 0.48202624917030334, -0.2690660357475281, 0.49797549843788147, -0.2350902110338211, -0.7084550857543945, 0.8939206004142761, 0.09882473200559616, 1.1364109516143799, 0.4183647632598877, -0.015174363739788532, 0.14029951393604279, 0.5035427212715149, 0.0032098882365971804, 0.10896074026823044, -0.16451597213745117, -1.1023790836334229, -0.37118789553642273, -0.4771866798400879, -0.7093102931976318, -0.050242189317941666, -0.3395976126194, 0.389026403427124, -0.5845648050308228, -0.17764952778816223, -0.20521700382232666, 0.2155827283859253, -0.7660974264144897, 0.5420218706130981, 0.2899385988712311, 0.9268407821655273, -0.8057309985160828, 0.6407067179679871, 0.9554237723350525, -0.6653298735618591, -1.1742167472839355, 0.4445335566997528, -0.19151711463928223, -0.7050005197525024, 0.8197488188743591, 0.3146066963672638, -0.39491480588912964, -0.14212718605995178, -0.037818651646375656, -0.462584912776947, 0.8784454464912415, 0.646584153175354, -0.6352532505989075, -0.16264459490776062, 0.11154874414205551, 0.3842166066169739, -0.40399205684661865, 0.4648488759994507, 0.9047916531562805, 0.5034990906715393, 0.30303463339805603, -0.7027133703231812, 0.07306026667356491, 0.14036120474338531, -0.03088993765413761, -0.173533096909523, -0.8285501599311829, 0.7680776715278625, -0.162864550948143, -0.1330733299255371, -0.1594637930393219, 0.3036389946937561, 0.46210378408432007, 0.6189425587654114, 0.7186725735664368, 0.680286169052124, 0.9264206886291504, -0.1434318721294403, 1.373801827430725, -0.37811043858528137, 0.11732564121484756, 0.8501937389373779, -0.8540953397750854, 0.5902369022369385, 0.47259777784347534, -0.264595091342926, 0.5586369037628174, 0.6802771091461182, 0.5182816386222839, 0.5610175132751465, 0.21322087943553925, -0.2697582542896271, -0.7688907980918884, 0.03710399568080902, -0.12824304401874542, 0.7758147716522217, 0.0789637416601181, 0.4147200584411621, -0.15369760990142822, -0.05574100464582443, -0.07638005167245865, 0.20360411703586578, 0.023592250421643257, 0.6970932483673096, 0.18211707472801208, -1.42098069190979, 0.7695498466491699, 0.1539180725812912, 0.3367033898830414, -0.526456892490387, 0.17588740587234497, -0.593299388885498, -0.12458343803882599, -0.20224866271018982, -0.6248270273208618, 0.366169273853302, -0.19058936834335327, -0.053894318640232086, -0.09735364466905594, 0.6436315178871155, -0.09931250661611557, -0.2628333270549774, 0.4853476881980896, 0.4539707601070404, 0.056364256888628006, -0.4419342279434204, -0.49720504879951477, 0.3044884502887726, -0.08920948952436447, 0.04280884191393852, -0.02899995446205139, 0.2665890157222748, -0.1527327448129654, 0.8591321706771851, 0.7506976127624512, 0.1543739289045334, -0.00455142417922616, 0.3735983073711395, 0.9172115325927734, -0.8847659826278687, -0.8849206566810608, -0.8046767711639404, 0.4003446400165558, 0.13159258663654327, -0.14080077409744263, 0.41796061396598816, 0.7922422885894775, 0.6116139888763428, -0.017865784466266632, 0.825271487236023, 0.24145634472370148, 0.2608253061771393, -0.8760554790496826, 0.35097432136535645, -0.5828511714935303, 0.6092501878738403, 0.13360059261322021, -0.65311199426651, -0.09489960223436356, 0.4160018563270569, -0.4567453861236572, 0.2712661027908325, 0.9533924460411072, 0.7153496742248535, 0.009835568256676197, -0.058575596660375595, 0.5859254598617554, -0.2187757045030594, 0.9030446410179138, 0.686724841594696, 1.357704520225525, -0.13637675344944, 0.56145179271698, -0.24347449839115143, -0.013267651200294495, -0.4620577096939087, -1.0077613592147827, -0.7389373779296875, -0.279573917388916, -0.5273921489715576, -0.20792753994464874, 0.1479119062423706, 0.9564153552055359, 0.7817532420158386, -0.48653078079223633, -0.23910893499851227, -0.5384604930877686, 0.5709617137908936, -0.3333907723426819, -0.18175379931926727, -0.05520011857151985, -0.46486273407936096, -0.4617791175842285, 0.6342988014221191, 0.1822664588689804, 0.0944598913192749, 0.008600782603025436, -0.3661591112613678, 0.18389813601970673, 0.4171658456325531, 0.3928341269493103, 0.22379113733768463, -1.033038854598999, -0.2859766185283661, -0.15492850542068481, -0.33483725786209106, -0.0024174428544938564, 1.1011921167373657, -0.8622273802757263, 0.2487066388130188, 0.3931361138820648, 0.7266808152198792, 0.1798005849123001, 0.14011351764202118, 0.4029776453971863, -0.686676561832428, 0.49283188581466675, 0.48741021752357483, 0.3907898962497711, 0.14272598922252655, -0.3763549029827118, 0.3312603533267975, 0.4585822820663452, -0.5982696413993835, -0.8067425489425659, 0.08710984140634537, -1.4508789777755737, -0.3209148943424225, 1.1943033933639526, 0.14202220737934113, 0.2137543112039566, -0.19301995635032654, -0.33835864067077637, -0.09201589226722717, -0.3663197159767151, 0.332553893327713, 0.9274546504020691, -0.061234742403030396, 0.2571815848350525, -0.3258410692214966, 0.40670880675315857, 0.4682711660861969, -1.027327060699463, -0.07347581535577774, 0.6488893628120422, 0.4853493571281433, -0.012794231995940208, 0.9631155133247375, 0.3843178451061249, 0.4855894148349762, 0.16924750804901123, 0.02540571056306362, -0.16138049960136414, -0.6378383040428162, -0.34335583448410034, 0.13355810940265656, 0.570870578289032, -0.23234684765338898 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04234v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04234v3
player2vec: A Language Modeling Approach to Understand Player Behavior in Games
2024-04-05T17:29:47
2024-06-07T22:01:05
Tianze Wang, Maryam Honari-Jahromi, Styliani Katsarou, Olga Mikheeva, Theodoros Panagiotakopoulos, Sahar Asadi, Oleg Smirnov
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
Methods for learning latent user representations from historical behavior logs have gained traction for recommendation tasks in e-commerce, content streaming, and other settings. However, this area still remains relatively underexplored in video and mobile gaming contexts. In this work, we present a novel method for overcoming this limitation by extending a long-range Transformer model from the natural language processing domain to player behavior data. We discuss specifics of behavior tracking in games and propose preprocessing and tokenization approaches by viewing in-game events in an analogous way to words in sentences, thus enabling learning player representations in a self-supervised manner in the absence of ground-truth annotations. We experimentally demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed approach in fitting the distribution of behavior events by evaluating intrinsic language modeling metrics. Furthermore, we qualitatively analyze the emerging structure of the learned embedding space and show its value for generating insights into behavior patterns to inform downstream applications.
[ -0.07301591336727142, -0.6922590136528015, 0.3412788212299347, 0.09584975987672806, 0.04002854973077774, 0.13121606409549713, -0.17176003754138947, -0.3474302589893341, 0.20532873272895813, 0.5865755677223206, -0.745262622833252, -0.519598662853241, -0.2713565528392792, -0.5784254670143127, 0.05253816023468971, 1.0781042575836182, 0.026716165244579315, -0.30818524956703186, -0.4629274010658264, -0.1282421201467514, -0.7821367383003235, -0.7154529690742493, -0.6939890384674072, -0.4903317093849182, 0.04282868281006813, 0.31831756234169006, 0.3825041651725769, 0.4645727574825287, 0.40676283836364746, 0.2912063002586365, 0.10592678189277649, 0.08354264497756958, -1.10575270652771, 0.42873483896255493, -0.2490876019001007, -0.6590570211410522, -0.33601245284080505, 0.16597451269626617, 0.3273506760597229, 0.14554259181022644, -0.29558756947517395, 0.10466138273477554, 0.035528529435396194, 0.25417739152908325, -0.27951857447624207, 0.5890277028083801, -0.24955607950687408, 0.35337138175964355, -0.024288244545459747, -0.20539982616901398, -0.6152428388595581, 0.19488084316253662, 0.05387704819440842, -0.7329279184341431, 0.32958847284317017, -0.15724018216133118, 0.32244542241096497, 0.12242521345615387, -0.33324334025382996, -0.49709245562553406, -1.1721388101577759, 0.9016083478927612, -0.23889867961406708, 0.5295523405075073, 0.6773268580436707, 0.4058821201324463, -0.2586539685726166, -0.5809586048126221, -0.40200403332710266, 0.019610924646258354, -0.04799244925379753, 0.1067730188369751, -0.3120100200176239, -0.07527433335781097, 0.29723310470581055, -0.09916218370199203, -0.3921912908554077, 0.07987021654844284, -0.25930216908454895, -0.15799954533576965, 0.8272401094436646, 0.1876560002565384, 0.2261897772550583, 0.1298810988664627, -0.4711872637271881, -0.0015586845111101866, -0.6215057969093323, 0.7322221994400024, 0.48574748635292053, 0.09730873256921768, -0.13591428101062775, 0.5285468697547913, 0.19458787143230438, 0.13667534291744232, 0.30383333563804626, -0.1963064968585968, 0.2323000580072403, -0.3380638360977173, 0.3318135738372803, -0.08725570887327194, 0.5192126631736755, 0.5875891447067261, 0.14000052213668823, -0.5209006071090698, -0.011415679939091206, -0.0278056338429451, 0.46341171860694885, -0.8739734292030334, -0.6036431789398193, 0.07040003687143326, -0.7020519971847534, -0.3300703763961792, 0.215509831905365, -0.9891387820243835, -0.7351101040840149, 0.044703997671604156, 0.25355827808380127, -0.14322157204151154, -0.36300379037857056, -0.13277259469032288, -0.11017613857984543, 0.47920992970466614, 0.008302449248731136, -1.2317347526550293, 0.47573322057724, 0.7747706174850464, 0.7350783944129944, -0.4851532578468323, 0.024396423250436783, -0.7728744149208069, 0.2914670407772064, -0.15846462547779083, 0.7370312809944153, -0.774179220199585, -0.7848032116889954, 0.1966605931520462, 0.05574101209640503, 0.38064509630203247, -0.3455398976802826, 0.47569742798805237, -0.4565136730670929, 0.13898912072181702, -0.10911904275417328, -0.7619331479072571, -0.046111151576042175, 0.2591565251350403, -0.5564562678337097, 1.0849488973617554, -0.15756051242351532, -0.3071947693824768, 0.4206600785255432, -0.6686217784881592, -0.5176724791526794, 0.2563347816467285, -0.11599533259868622, -0.39462968707084656, 0.3256703019142151, 0.14976604282855988, 0.42861127853393555, 0.23187561333179474, 0.2441999465227127, -0.22626778483390808, -0.49953171610832214, 0.20424272119998932, -0.15089096128940582, 0.1761099249124527, -0.11680296808481216, -0.20642124116420746, 0.08863019198179245, -0.2851792573928833, -0.33237913250923157, 0.09906010329723358, -0.24833199381828308, -0.32716143131256104, 0.9231016635894775, -0.13745516538619995, 0.5030509233474731, -0.03620103746652603, -0.39207878708839417, 0.3740723133087158, -0.3024410307407379, 0.46323198080062866, 0.5100613236427307, 0.0814598798751831, 0.7511462569236755, 0.13654480874538422, 0.5389681458473206, -0.11537737399339676, 0.22556054592132568, -0.488345742225647, -0.5837464332580566, -0.3029032051563263, -0.11425184458494186, -0.061936959624290466, 0.37661322951316833, -0.8231856226921082, 0.3457689583301544, -0.36420053243637085, -0.2690105736255646, -0.34763574600219727, 0.029015617445111275, 0.1753048300743103, 0.32094892859458923, 0.45977136492729187, -0.2277480810880661, -0.5741297006607056, -0.361245721578598, -0.37957504391670227, -0.6346604228019714, 0.009287244640290737, 0.7172592878341675, 0.2841545045375824, -0.4016680121421814, 0.9914079904556274, -0.49766960740089417, -0.6120120882987976, -0.46090206503868103, 0.292291522026062, -0.046606965363025665, 0.5092668533325195, 0.5089656710624695, -0.7871749997138977, -0.20024238526821136, -0.1755070835351944, -0.5532032251358032, -0.04626870155334473, -0.19630347192287445, 0.0741366371512413, -0.11341667920351028, 0.9352083802223206, -0.0834989845752716, 0.7174777388572693, 0.7640349268913269, -0.907150149345398, 0.05318962782621384, -0.2999138832092285, 0.10444317013025284, -0.6854147911071777, -0.20586206018924713, 0.051384516060352325, -0.4765612781047821, -0.8634961247444153, -0.02358579821884632, -0.4665331542491913, 0.17653927206993103, -0.22576233744621277, 0.5224997401237488, -0.22731319069862366, -0.2184745967388153, -0.45556989312171936, 0.027029599994421005, -0.14158858358860016, 0.469136118888855, 0.5210974216461182, 0.7400475740432739, 0.24816454946994781, -0.5911354422569275, 0.5872425436973572, 0.3450862169265747, -0.2486606240272522, 0.46314364671707153, -0.6652848124504089, 0.1526443064212799, -0.285595178604126, 0.21612194180488586, -1.1518763303756714, 0.18555819988250732, 0.22205309569835663, -0.6495102047920227, 0.07635397464036942, -0.9228487610816956, -0.3149101734161377, -0.28005504608154297, -0.1596442312002182, 0.425398051738739, 0.8751621842384338, -0.5950685739517212, 0.7945606112480164, 0.9056881666183472, 0.1940564513206482, -0.025866391137242317, -0.6177929043769836, -0.1577296406030655, -0.3525142967700958, -0.41662436723709106, 0.4116417467594147, -0.1684485375881195, 0.07281375676393509, -0.30873146653175354, -0.04021593928337097, -0.1636171042919159, 0.1880052536725998, 0.5673384666442871, 0.16460058093070984, -0.18876484036445618, 0.35195067524909973, -0.38913583755493164, -0.08554798364639282, 0.24678713083267212, -0.4303863048553467, 0.4874492287635803, 0.16573961079120636, -0.1470014452934265, -0.20454218983650208, 0.14258413016796112, -0.05177672579884529, -0.20872384309768677, 0.5531070828437805, 0.7982229590415955, -0.25790077447891235, -0.224416583776474, -0.3231019079685211, -0.24432745575904846, -0.4892480969429016, 0.5548242330551147, -0.27763402462005615, -1.0898314714431763, 0.6202123165130615, -0.3520800769329071, -0.07881204783916473, 0.3903392255306244, 0.5522674322128296, -0.5062524676322937, 1.3528624773025513, 0.8096116185188293, 0.21287330985069275, 0.6583157777786255, -0.14377260208129883, 0.14731672406196594, -0.6129699349403381, -0.8170686364173889, -0.2086346596479416, -0.37311750650405884, -0.8074787259101868, -0.9875422716140747, 0.0722048208117485, 0.14363010227680206, 0.017446419224143028, 0.32209649682044983, 0.08037509769201279, 0.793788492679596, 0.12070013582706451, -0.008191511034965515, -0.028189336881041527, 0.007210900075733662, 0.0909273773431778, -0.5003377199172974, -0.4549657702445984, -0.1609678566455841, 0.707557737827301, 0.6179825663566589, 0.6850519180297852, 0.530738353729248, 0.5391608476638794, 0.6114550828933716, 0.030336182564496994, -1.1033480167388916, 0.08460204303264618, -0.10992015898227692, -0.6189849972724915, -0.43847185373306274, -0.25424543023109436, -0.8677884340286255, 0.05755233392119408, -0.566048264503479, -1.1405086517333984, 0.12929819524288177, 0.15742893517017365, -0.3897424340248108, 0.19099712371826172, -0.3992624580860138, 0.9322439432144165, -0.1295321136713028, -0.7308986783027649, -0.19273781776428223, -0.1952778846025467, 0.16012884676456451, 0.15147511661052704, 0.42029738426208496, -0.03750009834766388, -0.010642340406775475, 0.848227322101593, -0.13681676983833313, 0.8092986941337585, -0.38567593693733215, -0.02243129536509514, 0.5451638102531433, 0.6232010722160339, 0.8719519376754761, 0.3489571213722229, 0.3088153600692749, 0.009128845296800137, -0.0854402482509613, -0.3329753875732422, -0.6710559129714966, 0.6153960824012756, -0.652406632900238, -0.22767984867095947, -0.25373443961143494, 0.06132299453020096, -0.40090128779411316, -0.06457722187042236, -0.0655858963727951, 0.22109253704547882, -0.7081561088562012, 0.34130600094795227, 0.7992273569107056, -0.17701305449008942, 0.5064756274223328, 0.5583460927009583, -0.32685619592666626, 0.133688285946846, 1.1515913009643555, -0.4556504487991333, -0.45111986994743347, 0.28473925590515137, 0.15923093259334564, -0.5104403495788574, -0.4900260865688324, -0.09143437445163727, 0.19009330868721008, -0.42793044447898865, 0.11076174676418304, -0.547226071357727, 0.2746807336807251, -0.1552933007478714, 0.021260151639580727, -0.4054514765739441, 0.11173581331968307, -0.4408305287361145, -0.29953932762145996, 0.12798550724983215, 1.1309419870376587, 0.05124395340681076, 0.7974981069564819, -0.6285951733589172, 0.22841961681842804, 0.4522530138492584, 0.771790623664856, -0.10065018385648727, -0.7252578735351562, -0.35104089975357056, -0.028023067861795425, -0.09125792980194092, -0.7667643427848816, 0.49679338932037354, 0.2803541421890259, 0.6638832688331604, 0.49881380796432495, -0.4331468641757965, 0.6531736254692078, -0.70975661277771, 1.2331266403198242, 0.26853522658348083, -0.932158350944519, 0.6434634327888489, -0.30930522084236145, -0.03310072794556618, 0.3681301474571228, 0.2852869927883148, -0.8605890870094299, 0.4588872194290161, -0.5083144307136536, -0.622567892074585, 1.0535873174667358, 0.26243793964385986, 0.3534323573112488, -0.035656556487083435, 0.3031817078590393, 0.05622810125350952, -0.06295578181743622, -0.4635944068431854, -0.28918367624282837, -0.2507714033126831, 0.04679002985358238, -0.5638167262077332, -0.48403096199035645, 0.2880871891975403, -0.2108558565378189, 0.44130104780197144, -0.24092908203601837, 0.3224955201148987, -0.1701274961233139, -0.434475839138031, -0.03106742352247238, -0.3607504367828369, 0.3750850260257721, 0.24634034931659698, -0.025382982566952705, -0.03326753154397011, 0.1709756702184677, -0.6049101948738098, -0.05561676621437073, -0.28953149914741516, 0.029804999008774757, -0.19387632608413696, 0.447378545999527, 0.8013389706611633, 0.3368329405784607, -0.6990793943405151, 0.9557000398635864, -0.341603547334671, -0.10909974575042725, -0.31279656291007996, -0.03387581929564476, 0.028493477031588554, 0.44477763772010803, 0.1532949060201645, -0.15504470467567444, 0.4442662298679352, -0.7542508840560913, 0.5436180830001831, 0.2189379334449768, -1.1243083477020264, -0.9195422530174255, 0.5817074179649353, 0.5108595490455627, -0.21003086864948273, 0.6910727620124817, -0.07451501488685608, -0.4304479956626892, 0.3407435417175293, 0.6096032857894897, 0.715186595916748, -0.32786110043525696, 0.5295484066009521, 0.446560263633728, -0.037434760481119156, -0.22385595738887787, 0.08515622466802597, -0.21840184926986694, -0.5481573343276978, -0.6293603181838989, -0.4150816798210144, 0.12122073024511337, -0.10758893936872482, -0.4420420825481415, 0.27022454142570496, -0.2935466468334198, -0.4415837824344635, 0.0016414755955338478, -0.04941321909427643, -0.8944710493087769, -0.22782160341739655, 0.775354266166687, 0.3915880620479584, -1.0125166177749634, 0.7673248648643494, 0.6327618360519409, -0.4941639304161072, -0.3332967162132263, -0.10769756883382797, -0.05793430656194687, -0.6615499258041382, 0.5771021842956543, -0.23381374776363373, -0.06129246950149536, -0.13620778918266296, -0.6008539795875549, -0.717802107334137, 0.8797586560249329, -0.20996882021427155, -0.3247186541557312, -0.15181711316108704, 0.1334768533706665, 0.8785102963447571, -0.5777202844619751, 0.5685648918151855, 0.6652016043663025, 0.1838945597410202, 0.5206241011619568, -0.3673712909221649, -0.36635228991508484, -0.04162948578596115, 0.01892036385834217, 0.13523276150226593, -0.402191698551178, 0.42460963129997253, -0.30842724442481995, -0.15024159848690033, -0.3549044728279114, 0.9093875288963318, -0.04052487015724182, 0.2920628786087036, 0.35346704721450806, 0.04579322412610054, 0.6258739233016968, -0.0749611109495163, 0.8239790797233582, 0.2145887017250061, 0.5906304121017456, 1.0868582725524902, -0.28822001814842224, 0.7441766858100891, 0.37349018454551697, -0.34210002422332764, 0.7248110771179199, 0.31535258889198303, -0.14420373737812042, 0.732311487197876, 0.4003286063671112, 0.1844024956226349, -0.6093091368675232, -0.1892574280500412, 0.1048242449760437, 0.8119913339614868, 0.6055723428726196, -0.24370940029621124, -0.16373103857040405, -0.11838537454605103, -0.12436974048614502, 0.2057255506515503, -0.3967609703540802, 1.3104079961776733, -0.19014684855937958, -0.604132890701294, -0.22176316380500793, 0.005177789833396673, 0.7791799306869507, -0.36189430952072144, -0.4128463566303253, -0.2889985144138336, 0.17555488646030426, -0.11967066675424576, -0.9186586141586304, 0.16397742927074432, 0.15558578073978424, -0.24666789174079895, -0.20705977082252502, 0.6074531078338623, -0.4325491487979889, -0.2426745891571045, 0.42384541034698486, 0.5821301341056824, 0.2991274297237396, -0.03290189057588577, -0.49740976095199585, 0.055620938539505005, -0.049235258251428604, -0.12806548178195953, 0.21741345524787903, 0.3145224153995514, -0.27778592705726624, 0.5309146046638489, 0.46637430787086487, -0.06225826218724251, -0.012478537857532501, -0.1025751456618309, 0.4888286590576172, -0.6359387040138245, -0.8142117857933044, -0.8716110587120056, 0.3878061771392822, -0.023751266300678253, -0.11184286326169968, 0.6443125009536743, 0.6323225498199463, 0.8006618618965149, -0.0478672981262207, 0.7069272398948669, 0.13399799168109894, 0.2707142233848572, -0.2554948627948761, 0.4386616349220276, -0.09194763749837875, 0.20683979988098145, 0.09867390990257263, -0.7994519472122192, -0.04016637057065964, 0.5748189687728882, -0.2111130803823471, -0.04004257544875145, 0.11511822789907455, 0.3022136092185974, -0.24470439553260803, -0.12737180292606354, 0.4596474766731262, 0.03890608996152878, 0.59857577085495, 0.4751386046409607, 0.8958805799484253, -0.40705639123916626, 0.5523505210876465, 0.026578282937407494, -0.13780905306339264, -0.4522297978401184, -0.7704523205757141, -1.331956148147583, -0.7598459720611572, -0.29565924406051636, -0.5604038834571838, 0.19938358664512634, 1.0196177959442139, 0.7607494592666626, -1.0243098735809326, -0.3266911506652832, 0.12801510095596313, -0.01965140551328659, -0.2795293629169464, -0.16025206446647644, 0.215306356549263, -0.04081675410270691, -0.5769877433776855, 0.5451369881629944, -0.04029352217912674, 0.051974061876535416, -0.3047949969768524, -0.4348423182964325, 0.037709325551986694, 0.13508974015712738, 0.8139948844909668, 0.4260200560092926, -0.6046281456947327, -0.36430874466896057, 0.1926266849040985, 0.1205781102180481, 0.08403906971216202, 1.1620711088180542, -1.165004849433899, 0.7478329539299011, 0.5673378109931946, 0.2525912821292877, 0.8283105492591858, 0.23007947206497192, 0.6439286470413208, -0.9375305771827698, 0.06754784286022186, 0.376240074634552, -0.029768865555524826, 0.13596250116825104, -0.2639291286468506, 0.40384218096733093, 0.32221636176109314, -0.11919359862804413, -0.561618983745575, 0.20806343853473663, -0.5859532356262207, -0.15534096956253052, 1.362123727798462, -0.2443564385175705, -0.1469014585018158, -0.13760049641132355, -0.18363997340202332, 0.2701394557952881, -0.5486343502998352, 0.6025921106338501, 0.7112032175064087, -0.11414431035518646, -0.15742450952529907, -0.5008295774459839, 0.939747154712677, -0.2889516353607178, -0.3895682692527771, 0.24841849505901337, 0.4787082076072693, 0.030247652903199196, -0.11984816938638687, 0.38321927189826965, -0.05562147870659828, 0.012189440429210663, -0.09273585677146912, 0.1742406189441681, -0.047362204641103745, -0.3515316843986511, -0.492598295211792, -0.09805431962013245, -0.11389551311731339, 0.0010770722292363644 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04232v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04232v2
Benchmarking and Improving Compositional Generalization of Multi-aspect Controllable Text Generation
2024-04-05T17:26:22
2024-06-03T12:08:20
Tianqi Zhong, Zhaoyi Li, Quan Wang, Linqi Song, Ying Wei, Defu Lian, Zhendong Mao
cs.CL
cs.CL
Compositional generalization, representing the model's ability to generate text with new attribute combinations obtained by recombining single attributes from the training data, is a crucial property for multi-aspect controllable text generation (MCTG) methods. Nonetheless, a comprehensive compositional generalization evaluation benchmark of MCTG is still lacking. We propose CompMCTG, a benchmark encompassing diverse multi-aspect labeled datasets and a crafted three-dimensional evaluation protocol, to holistically evaluate the compositional generalization of MCTG approaches. We observe that existing MCTG works generally confront a noticeable performance drop in compositional testing. To mitigate this issue, we introduce Meta-MCTG, a training framework incorporating meta-learning, where we enable models to learn how to generalize by simulating compositional generalization scenarios in the training phase. We demonstrate the effectiveness of Meta-MCTG through achieving obvious improvement (by at most 3.64%) for compositional testing performance in 94.4% cases.
[ -0.4190872013568878, -0.698280930519104, 0.4079698920249939, 0.22063550353050232, -0.3036660850048065, 0.1084073930978775, -0.31604820489883423, -0.17106366157531738, -0.22532032430171967, 0.23847632110118866, -0.7073923349380493, -0.8048616051673889, -0.5910863876342773, 0.16525280475616455, -0.052273765206336975, 1.0180453062057495, -0.26603972911834717, -0.007979998365044594, -0.3455984890460968, -0.1545427143573761, -0.48798444867134094, -0.4785309135913849, -0.4662071168422699, -0.5024926662445068, 0.34439876675605774, 0.471079021692276, 0.37384483218193054, 0.7017593383789062, 0.6241074204444885, 0.2803420126438141, 0.26734283566474915, 0.3166336119174957, -0.1552494466304779, 0.1365453004837036, -0.04371488839387894, -0.22391961514949799, -0.5570895075798035, 0.3808702528476715, 0.582961916923523, 0.6052244305610657, -0.3627144694328308, 0.18208931386470795, 0.2905985414981842, 0.5224305987358093, -1.0731772184371948, 0.30404242873191833, -0.46637824177742004, 0.28008803725242615, 0.16432921588420868, -0.1665521264076233, -0.5272179841995239, -0.345018208026886, 0.08013254404067993, -0.5761431455612183, 0.5559583902359009, -0.08202680945396423, 0.3244139850139618, 0.03175094723701477, -0.5585048198699951, -0.09553712606430054, -0.6383966207504272, 0.913934051990509, -0.48925143480300903, 0.5953916907310486, 0.2157023400068283, 0.3827230930328369, 0.057888153940439224, -0.8233814239501953, -0.40395990014076233, -0.34834641218185425, -0.08454828709363937, 0.5460507273674011, -0.10615987330675125, 0.2514169216156006, -0.05569735914468765, 0.37697917222976685, -0.7423216104507446, -0.3660816550254822, 0.12814506888389587, -0.308673232793808, 0.572059690952301, 0.19392788410186768, 0.0912603884935379, -0.2747974991798401, -0.357496440410614, -0.43653160333633423, -0.5956020355224609, -0.029778121039271355, 0.25960448384284973, 0.09364412724971771, -0.06645220518112183, 0.3147929310798645, -0.3155745565891266, 0.8280298709869385, 0.2809410095214844, -0.2316187620162964, 0.481167197227478, -0.5956394076347351, -0.3620760142803192, -0.07902022451162338, 1.1013985872268677, 0.41091445088386536, -0.22802601754665375, -0.22568731009960175, 0.12717404961585999, -0.2833310663700104, 0.485272616147995, -0.9289578199386597, -0.35587871074676514, 0.10719822347164154, -0.5535141825675964, -0.2807092070579529, 0.38301295042037964, -0.5796605348587036, -0.022447241470217705, -0.49525681138038635, 0.4136621952056885, -0.6232253909111023, -0.2624157965183258, -0.04700051248073578, -0.1102759838104248, 0.09976793080568314, 0.027982454746961594, -0.903573751449585, 0.021106209605932236, 0.7016229033470154, 0.6784330606460571, -0.5143781900405884, -0.42599135637283325, -0.4668167531490326, 0.5512098670005798, -0.2546660006046295, 0.7020980715751648, -0.6570628881454468, -0.4690471589565277, -0.27218273282051086, -0.07047052681446075, -0.39562371373176575, -0.655647337436676, 0.44636303186416626, 0.0836547240614891, 0.04544467851519585, -0.29524552822113037, -0.20936225354671478, -0.11054136604070663, 0.6599984169006348, -0.5114253163337708, 0.9669488668441772, 0.06038986146450043, -0.6838390827178955, 0.6700834631919861, -0.5038759708404541, -0.465750128030777, -0.3020879030227661, -0.4043232500553131, -0.8843043446540833, 0.3464885652065277, 0.2712920904159546, 0.6042501330375671, -0.2742478549480438, 0.2453218400478363, -0.32966139912605286, -0.15837933123111725, 0.20125944912433624, -0.33671286702156067, -0.026928821578621864, 0.0748336985707283, -0.5537763237953186, 0.08007147908210754, -0.9710534811019897, 0.4605557918548584, -0.2849561274051666, -0.6506877541542053, -0.06233759596943855, 0.12974850833415985, -0.04599921405315399, 0.11248684674501419, -0.012685134075582027, -0.40449732542037964, -0.020378485321998596, -0.019534705206751823, 0.2805045545101166, 0.5161662697792053, 0.08468002080917358, 0.4170643091201782, -0.3831804394721985, 0.5521020293235779, 0.39373642206192017, 0.21919366717338562, -0.19131094217300415, -0.01080485712736845, -0.8385319709777832, -0.32165762782096863, 0.43025046586990356, 0.24167469143867493, -0.9350305795669556, 0.48885729908943176, -0.20377926528453827, -0.6609154939651489, -0.013621685095131397, 0.017872706055641174, 0.7491191625595093, 0.22875544428825378, 0.41468334197998047, -0.24386462569236755, -0.31433600187301636, -1.0604169368743896, -0.476066529750824, 0.004819354508072138, -0.1601940244436264, 0.31689465045928955, 0.3009815514087677, -0.19705484807491302, 0.7154354453086853, -0.6154273748397827, 0.0697217658162117, -0.2874312698841095, 0.8163743019104004, -0.304411381483078, 0.717409610748291, 0.45734333992004395, -0.6593330502510071, -0.5640549659729004, 0.2029780149459839, -0.5069172978401184, -0.2986206114292145, 0.08599209785461426, -0.14979100227355957, 0.14508572220802307, 0.5264131426811218, -0.20438958704471588, 0.1458030492067337, 0.9473168849945068, -0.03730291128158569, 0.7611100077629089, -0.24649934470653534, 0.5416834354400635, -1.1824249029159546, 0.1613273322582245, -0.09665269404649734, -0.3741086423397064, -0.44770604372024536, 0.3753734827041626, 0.388671875, -0.18900248408317566, -0.5274309515953064, 0.06791660189628601, -0.4903324842453003, 0.17752206325531006, -0.4225832223892212, -0.1955968141555786, 0.03426135703921318, 0.6129588484764099, 0.002816487569361925, 0.7810932397842407, 0.2851487696170807, -0.8901355862617493, 0.045578114688396454, -0.20895132422447205, 0.03596898540854454, 0.8666763305664062, -0.5373855233192444, 0.08061990886926651, -0.020337747409939766, 0.4403383433818817, -0.7966753244400024, -0.21075241267681122, 0.20745384693145752, -0.0947362631559372, 0.29507747292518616, 0.10522662103176117, -0.5346372127532959, -0.22375378012657166, -0.3503987789154053, 0.5286349058151245, 0.07067297399044037, -0.4420091211795807, 0.9904378652572632, -0.18696574866771698, -0.034100692719221115, -0.352236807346344, -0.6456910371780396, -0.1853816658258438, 0.008567320182919502, -0.3301258683204651, 0.5161285400390625, -0.2235645353794098, 0.237921804189682, -0.4307768642902374, -0.32657843828201294, -0.05516599118709564, -0.09613848477602005, 0.30092892050743103, -0.3871789276599884, 0.017906544730067253, 0.18514683842658997, 0.4884709417819977, -0.2927992641925812, 0.15996913611888885, -0.2007923424243927, 0.6684004068374634, 0.0031461878679692745, -0.4250386953353882, -0.11052555590867996, 0.3764096200466156, 0.1452733874320984, -0.44416725635528564, 0.39792612195014954, 0.6811513900756836, -0.008046031929552555, -0.42060327529907227, -0.3732840120792389, 0.03007061406970024, -0.4724186956882477, 0.4085312485694885, -0.5075639486312866, -0.7023799419403076, 0.20681814849376678, -0.20709848403930664, 0.03916135057806969, 0.3839779198169708, 0.4362933039665222, 0.10051152855157852, 0.9971774220466614, 0.6519837975502014, 0.3355581760406494, 0.45427751541137695, -0.2907079756259918, -0.1713578999042511, -0.8761733770370483, -0.3303576707839966, -0.37302979826927185, -0.40433114767074585, -0.9131149649620056, -0.4801040589809418, 0.6229883432388306, 0.024057183414697647, -0.1301736980676651, 0.37981680035591125, -0.6510545611381531, 0.5749385952949524, 0.629855751991272, 0.5994749069213867, 0.4914213716983795, -0.2674175798892975, -0.46162232756614685, -0.05104628950357437, -0.6635509133338928, -0.32108062505722046, 1.4149585962295532, -0.11301689594984055, 0.6780413389205933, 0.053351808339357376, 0.8322386741638184, 0.12994904816150665, 0.6078173518180847, -0.42364972829818726, 0.33294230699539185, -0.21442000567913055, -0.4244116246700287, 0.17225736379623413, -0.7625992894172668, -0.7422158718109131, 0.3813627064228058, -0.2785540223121643, -0.3186596930027008, 0.03084690123796463, 0.4712669849395752, -0.15926297008991241, 0.11971922963857651, -0.7345268130302429, 0.892029345035553, -0.09003060311079025, -0.2641301155090332, -0.11835730075836182, -0.395618200302124, 0.5558639168739319, -0.13708558678627014, 0.0011724785435944796, 0.17197591066360474, -0.11036916077136993, 0.6209548115730286, -0.3766586482524872, 0.7264196872711182, 0.05875460430979729, -0.07572083920240402, 0.2574843466281891, 0.14545436203479767, 0.215442955493927, 0.059705015271902084, 0.03004661202430725, 0.11533278226852417, -0.1756727248430252, -0.39607954025268555, -0.43027424812316895, 0.612540066242218, -0.7191905975341797, -0.1347513049840927, -0.28384828567504883, -0.6356065273284912, -0.3658239543437958, 0.12068072706460953, 0.6054182052612305, 0.3624792695045471, -0.5443558692932129, 0.2891775369644165, 0.7550262212753296, -0.3202623724937439, 0.8067986965179443, 0.48472046852111816, 0.08844263851642609, -0.9084421396255493, 0.9031393527984619, -0.17174914479255676, 0.4738668203353882, 0.5729361176490784, 0.40562811493873596, -0.08776386082172394, -0.37041112780570984, -0.27010512351989746, -0.1664421707391739, -0.4544735550880432, -0.4492301940917969, -0.8759866952896118, -0.14491836726665497, -0.32594260573387146, 0.10301478952169418, -0.3281150460243225, -0.1732661873102188, -0.15848492085933685, 0.01756683923304081, -0.24688245356082916, 0.5953376889228821, -0.13246780633926392, 0.9922692775726318, -0.8698801398277283, 0.3143913745880127, 0.5355846285820007, 0.50632643699646, -0.0667867437005043, -0.0196829866617918, -0.2698005437850952, 0.04131819307804108, -1.3083127737045288, -0.6625553965568542, -0.22454753518104553, 0.3452795445919037, 0.45236948132514954, 0.5455984473228455, -0.24340412020683289, 0.44707080721855164, -0.5998597741127014, 0.679915189743042, 0.4414142370223999, -1.2535450458526611, 0.5104723572731018, -0.5188739895820618, 0.5165933966636658, 0.7372518181800842, 0.18084317445755005, -0.43751055002212524, -0.5462866425514221, -0.7992079854011536, -0.6644642949104309, 0.4922495186328888, 0.333710253238678, -0.1288476586341858, -0.14042526483535767, 0.43754521012306213, 0.4072206914424896, 0.6076784133911133, -0.8642944693565369, -0.18560397624969482, -0.29882338643074036, -0.29923251271247864, -0.18598602712154388, -0.07658977061510086, -0.03611590713262558, -0.09501749277114868, 0.43802082538604736, -0.34217190742492676, 0.16249123215675354, 0.12984317541122437, -0.0692288726568222, 0.10646042972803116, 0.4023036062717438, 0.8213896155357361, 0.7509322166442871, -0.1411006599664688, 0.4276144802570343, -0.06523536890745163, -0.6475014686584473, 0.43384331464767456, 0.13067087531089783, 0.02121639996767044, -0.1247159093618393, 0.5193409323692322, 0.5038608312606812, 0.24358156323432922, -0.28372088074684143, 0.6119696497917175, -0.03340991213917732, -0.6024135947227478, 0.21308372914791107, 0.4011317491531372, -0.05535001680254936, -0.10967700183391571, 0.28281503915786743, -0.05565192177891731, 0.2860725224018097, -0.38087198138237, 0.29037168622016907, 0.3438955247402191, -0.31077033281326294, -0.23411473631858826, 0.6121957898139954, 0.37414613366127014, 0.04699193686246872, 0.049214206635951996, -0.22002087533473969, -0.5531662106513977, 0.5226733088493347, 0.5553263425827026, 1.0849839448928833, -0.30120712518692017, 0.4111725389957428, 0.46825602650642395, 0.42440587282180786, -0.07734659314155579, 0.27910858392715454, -0.3094378709793091, -0.3946203589439392, -0.5351499915122986, -0.390604168176651, -0.6499084234237671, 0.06859582662582397, -0.5443410873413086, -0.0025999078061431646, -0.6109420657157898, -0.16784432530403137, -0.29233095049858093, -0.10896393656730652, -0.6977494359016418, 0.5027961134910583, -0.1783088892698288, 0.5907615423202515, -0.9434694051742554, 0.22815124690532684, 0.7096105813980103, -0.21542009711265564, -0.7242535948753357, 0.2768136262893677, -0.33198872208595276, -0.3807709217071533, 0.30068808794021606, 0.4167783260345459, 0.08663029968738556, -0.189475879073143, -0.5843194127082825, -0.5630354881286621, 1.3238166570663452, 0.32588377594947815, -0.5993447303771973, 0.302270770072937, 0.6162293553352356, 0.36567869782447815, -0.48558321595191956, 0.5277625918388367, 0.8106828927993774, 0.651185929775238, 0.12437714636325836, -0.7936025857925415, -0.012832087464630604, 0.03703421726822853, 0.22344420850276947, 0.4711606204509735, -0.9089723229408264, 0.8379961848258972, 0.34366148710250854, -0.060579996556043625, -0.1743159294128418, 0.5740377902984619, 0.5619072318077087, 0.4020875096321106, 0.38978779315948486, 0.9381442070007324, 0.3395579755306244, -0.47928184270858765, 0.9816639423370361, -0.21135903894901276, 0.38819047808647156, 1.3574906587600708, 0.03324338421225548, 0.5363749265670776, 0.3127158284187317, 0.03533244505524635, 0.4320867955684662, 0.597413182258606, 0.1511402577161789, 0.5784602761268616, 0.2620443105697632, -0.3878133296966553, -0.332840234041214, 0.14928042888641357, -0.2746695578098297, 0.48411181569099426, -0.25983574986457825, -0.6179545521736145, -0.4611368775367737, 0.1667584478855133, -0.046458981931209564, -0.0026286360807716846, -0.2990091145038605, 0.9275506138801575, -0.19569025933742523, -0.6501583456993103, 0.3115963041782379, 0.24212448298931122, 0.5198505520820618, -0.6235326528549194, 0.020188376307487488, -0.32010558247566223, 0.27890944480895996, -0.06790146231651306, -0.3000124394893646, 0.17957478761672974, -0.31970882415771484, -0.2530514597892761, -0.17608976364135742, 0.35625141859054565, -0.570473849773407, -0.6271377205848694, -0.004941361490637064, 0.487387090921402, -0.20924635231494904, -0.42485469579696655, -0.6103391051292419, -0.00014551480126101524, -0.20399054884910583, -0.07567361742258072, 0.09374486654996872, 0.5746729969978333, 0.18032680451869965, 0.4080139696598053, 0.3282851576805115, -0.1114184781908989, 0.14991165697574615, -0.08363793045282364, 0.7415711283683777, -0.6937001943588257, -0.46687009930610657, -0.9881157279014587, 0.5194584727287292, -0.001604452496394515, -0.30453038215637207, 0.5986043810844421, 0.955035924911499, 0.8308390974998474, -0.07093606144189835, 0.9941468834877014, -0.1882631480693817, 0.14615608751773834, -0.6925349235534668, 0.7224399447441101, -0.38359153270721436, -0.2410067468881607, -0.4907487630844116, -1.306084394454956, -0.21264797449111938, 0.20338283479213715, -0.03079807572066784, 0.42646124958992004, 1.1043696403503418, 0.5175837278366089, -0.6024868488311768, -0.08809863775968552, 0.303130567073822, -0.19715337455272675, 0.6358858346939087, 0.6672686338424683, 0.6082625985145569, -0.7010480165481567, 0.5684763193130493, -0.291642427444458, -0.4609641134738922, 0.07576624304056168, -1.277939796447754, -1.0599274635314941, -0.39830824732780457, -0.37687626481056213, -0.15072402358055115, -0.09121017903089523, 0.7224816679954529, 0.9810428023338318, -0.5954763293266296, -0.030400225892663002, -0.43699562549591064, -0.0817265436053276, -0.4550919532775879, -0.22336043417453766, 0.27692368626594543, -0.31158795952796936, -0.5953671932220459, 0.0783705934882164, 0.1210816279053688, 0.22596146166324615, -0.1966467946767807, 0.15846964716911316, 0.11702501773834229, -0.06899836659431458, 0.6905584335327148, -0.1950373351573944, -0.3035344183444977, -0.24306267499923706, -0.3500347435474396, -0.07738851755857468, 0.13241848349571228, 1.2783458232879639, -0.41235989332199097, 0.2971230745315552, 0.4386865794658661, 0.5654296875, 0.4275713860988617, 0.34769511222839355, 0.7254520654678345, -1.248199462890625, -0.12125637382268906, -0.1507207602262497, -0.006789631210267544, 0.17581923305988312, -0.11816016584634781, 0.4618415832519531, 0.19442985951900482, -0.5836679935455322, -0.23102761805057526, 0.2806319296360016, -0.9863284230232239, -0.19026441872119904, 1.1385509967803955, -0.08308430761098862, -0.25532224774360657, 0.4386656582355499, -0.03292931243777275, 0.3694077730178833, -0.35030123591423035, 0.7323046326637268, 0.7170801162719727, -0.19412343204021454, -0.23639927804470062, -0.1229381412267685, 0.40492790937423706, 0.32968276739120483, -1.4390513896942139, 0.2138012945652008, 0.5990539193153381, 0.47752201557159424, 0.12052455544471741, 0.5507673621177673, -0.03495202586054802, 0.3844190239906311, -0.2466922551393509, 0.4232402443885803, -0.13413989543914795, -0.39223137497901917, -0.12818774580955505, 0.26271528005599976, -0.2731740474700928, -0.43612316250801086 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04221v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04221v1
How Lexical is Bilingual Lexicon Induction?
2024-04-05T17:10:33
2024-04-05T17:10:33
Harsh Kohli, Helian Feng, Nicholas Dronen, Calvin McCarter, Sina Moeini, Ali Kebarighotbi
cs.CL
cs.CL
In contemporary machine learning approaches to bilingual lexicon induction (BLI), a model learns a mapping between the embedding spaces of a language pair. Recently, retrieve-and-rank approach to BLI has achieved state of the art results on the task. However, the problem remains challenging in low-resource settings, due to the paucity of data. The task is complicated by factors such as lexical variation across languages. We argue that the incorporation of additional lexical information into the recent retrieve-and-rank approach should improve lexicon induction. We demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed approach on XLING, improving over the previous state of the art by an average of 2\% across all language pairs.
[ -0.2315705120563507, -0.3302214741706848, 0.3877353370189667, 0.14976339042186737, 0.02938253991305828, 0.28090158104896545, -0.3217756450176239, -0.5454481244087219, 0.2234189510345459, 0.18157969415187836, -0.28407055139541626, -0.23353390395641327, -0.8544127345085144, 0.3010236322879791, -0.20124618709087372, 0.743415892124176, 0.028119416907429695, 0.04095896705985069, -0.19728562235832214, -0.4663204252719879, -0.45910802483558655, -0.5358351469039917, -0.7317164540290833, -0.2946830093860626, 0.6302241683006287, 0.6500988602638245, 1.0753792524337769, 0.7942599058151245, 0.22787436842918396, 0.24673408269882202, -0.44206926226615906, 0.6563893556594849, -0.6059338450431824, 0.1332840621471405, -0.19862638413906097, -0.675571084022522, -0.24374954402446747, -0.2854977548122406, 0.9597128033638, 1.2600443363189697, -0.155848890542984, -0.21213550865650177, -0.03494090214371681, 0.7371004223823547, -0.9521429538726807, 0.08466901630163193, -0.9197168350219727, 0.047211311757564545, -0.2903396487236023, -0.21379707753658295, -0.4604913890361786, -0.16980841755867004, 0.12815430760383606, -0.4976591467857361, 0.0615270622074604, 0.2312181144952774, 0.6261359453201294, -0.060839422047138214, -0.47027748823165894, -0.5366223454475403, -0.8760825991630554, 0.8486641049385071, -0.3494639992713928, 0.8556350469589233, 0.4415944516658783, 0.1561838984489441, 0.16650579869747162, -0.48216041922569275, -0.44877317547798157, -0.2095777839422226, -0.14757049083709717, 0.1618240624666214, -0.008413581177592278, -0.3270968496799469, 0.44840314984321594, 0.33887821435928345, -0.3823748230934143, 0.41946616768836975, -0.26792898774147034, 0.052698176354169846, 0.5850668549537659, 0.13309086859226227, 0.5081019401550293, 0.139967679977417, -0.16969487071037292, -0.06678611785173416, -0.9232876896858215, 0.000009602461432223208, 0.20519410073757172, 0.657102644443512, -0.07943789660930634, 0.636971116065979, -0.06735604256391525, 0.240945503115654, 0.030356988310813904, -0.04001935198903084, 0.5430610775947571, -0.8168670535087585, 0.10342571139335632, 0.41297027468681335, 0.5085153579711914, 0.09729539602994919, 0.14517438411712646, -0.5384120345115662, -0.38080888986587524, -0.2733306288719177, 0.0622737780213356, -0.6224492788314819, 0.15687386691570282, 0.04232492297887802, -0.11440275609493256, 0.10639344900846481, 0.18264254927635193, -0.561880886554718, -0.3419860005378723, -0.3591652810573578, 0.31129297614097595, -0.35752952098846436, -0.4050738513469696, -0.2140309065580368, -0.22821849584579468, 0.3533291816711426, 0.1519264131784439, -1.47858464717865, 0.38013309240341187, 0.7198126316070557, 0.8811494708061218, -0.27770864963531494, -0.3098032474517822, -0.7514548897743225, 0.12429145723581314, -0.6953492760658264, 0.5384218096733093, -0.4895293414592743, -0.7041953802108765, 0.34249016642570496, 0.17732928693294525, -0.26955533027648926, -0.8577215671539307, 0.22249172627925873, -0.4681317210197449, 0.03016520105302334, -0.5153058171272278, -0.38905900716781616, 0.20872028172016144, -0.036114033311605453, -0.6828543543815613, 1.0323172807693481, 0.017181647941470146, -0.8733333945274353, 0.5174680352210999, -0.445556104183197, -0.4873250424861908, 0.0822923481464386, -0.03145653381943703, -0.23769111931324005, 0.12403135746717453, 0.4544127881526947, -0.04465068504214287, -0.0011101678246632218, 0.005282165016978979, -0.1997867375612259, -0.3341308832168579, 0.30537620186805725, 0.025826411321759224, 1.0010597705841064, 0.11906198412179947, -0.28523746132850647, -0.4101647734642029, -0.36493757367134094, -0.19301138818264008, -0.051343172788619995, -0.11596538126468658, -0.4197889566421509, -0.0527288056910038, -0.24775128066539764, 0.027760405093431473, 0.22421622276306152, -0.6656411290168762, 0.07989155501127243, -0.8454890251159668, -0.07299001514911652, 0.2983075678348541, -0.1477954238653183, 0.8943195939064026, -0.26222556829452515, 0.19418488442897797, 0.3665829598903656, -0.21491551399230957, -0.1291591227054596, -0.5230189561843872, -0.7137418985366821, -0.2814416289329529, 0.6291918754577637, 0.7911726236343384, -0.7486828565597534, 0.3459274470806122, -0.3554895222187042, -0.4881042540073395, -0.5945999026298523, 0.609301745891571, 0.4459474980831146, 0.18009667098522186, 0.38311657309532166, -0.23603297770023346, -0.5487459897994995, -0.8018357157707214, -0.01626909337937832, 0.07403627783060074, 0.14323222637176514, 0.38414910435676575, 0.2532137930393219, -0.4662766456604004, 0.6259161829948425, -0.24285954236984253, -0.0015951639506965876, -0.5558942556381226, 0.13493770360946655, 0.3080451786518097, 0.38273558020591736, 0.6130971312522888, -0.8010527491569519, -0.6279798746109009, 0.585067868232727, -0.9708457589149475, -0.06865482032299042, 0.20266424119472504, -0.41353899240493774, 0.5123721361160278, 0.49472394585609436, -0.32492944598197937, 0.3363896608352661, 0.3652544319629669, -0.025364160537719727, 0.2538147568702698, -0.5502868890762329, -0.0964004173874855, -1.0734989643096924, -0.005371452774852514, -0.08705736696720123, -0.2927250862121582, -0.611993670463562, 0.10204729437828064, 0.3155129551887512, -0.07694733887910843, -0.4405966103076935, 0.5566949844360352, -0.5779004693031311, -0.2593953311443329, -0.29899710416793823, 0.1978483647108078, -0.2655137777328491, 0.19279812276363373, 0.231776624917984, 0.6554643511772156, 0.7264670729637146, -0.5474744439125061, 0.18858124315738678, 0.2823934257030487, -0.10689491778612137, 0.1802259385585785, -0.20944412052631378, 0.09206784516572952, -0.27848032116889954, -0.009383044205605984, -0.840484619140625, -0.040345869958400726, -0.0960863009095192, -0.42064446210861206, 0.4602349102497101, 0.006723127327859402, -0.6273170113563538, -0.14532391726970673, -0.24127943813800812, 0.6011922955513, 0.7153481841087341, -0.9714648723602295, 0.18757762014865875, 0.5588984489440918, -0.41082602739334106, -0.6840802431106567, -0.7216129302978516, -0.04813247174024582, 0.12193310260772705, -0.3617578148841858, 0.5058059692382812, 0.11616005003452301, -0.4661576747894287, 0.03338746726512909, -0.015017874538898468, -0.2037268579006195, 0.10081470757722855, -0.022561119869351387, 0.04387396574020386, -0.2853597104549408, 0.06529480218887329, 0.22703243792057037, -0.010632270947098732, -0.0714816153049469, -0.28710320591926575, 0.25588804483413696, 0.15688946843147278, -0.1444084644317627, -0.5778590440750122, 0.5075103044509888, 0.5696085691452026, -0.25133591890335083, 0.8787994384765625, 0.46704840660095215, -0.5954847931861877, -0.3608315885066986, -0.3205723464488983, -0.03416159749031067, -0.40204599499702454, 0.2692141830921173, -0.19178371131420135, -0.42139145731925964, 0.4924529492855072, 0.013492722064256668, -0.012181985192000866, 0.28092920780181885, 0.945775032043457, 0.06180676445364952, 1.23618483543396, 0.9089859127998352, -0.18197502195835114, 0.38487809896469116, -0.476854532957077, 0.43107980489730835, -0.6108049154281616, -0.3365037739276886, -0.5255128741264343, -0.1490948349237442, -1.0025273561477661, -0.18155644834041595, 0.3152838349342346, -0.06577306240797043, 0.12889985740184784, 0.24899040162563324, -0.07320600748062134, 0.3532005846500397, 0.5743022561073303, 0.1339455246925354, 0.16518953442573547, 0.07571858912706375, -0.5576810240745544, -0.15423189103603363, -0.8773568272590637, 0.07204174250364304, 1.2276710271835327, 0.027903586626052856, 0.43680673837661743, 0.3479561507701874, 1.1704457998275757, -0.022107984870672226, 0.1414894163608551, -0.5675883889198303, 0.09975599497556686, -0.28820058703422546, -0.39899978041648865, -0.2773491144180298, -0.5184192061424255, -1.1127983331680298, 0.13973373174667358, -0.42295151948928833, -0.7894378304481506, 0.24048206210136414, 0.06499011814594269, -0.2497844696044922, 0.22161957621574402, -0.7788715958595276, 0.6917438507080078, -0.2416924238204956, -0.575262188911438, -0.17974554002285004, -0.2587537467479706, 0.13300742208957672, -0.2944502532482147, 0.5486693978309631, 0.23381240665912628, -0.015321426093578339, 0.5122441053390503, -0.5812152028083801, 0.5077945590019226, -0.19902536273002625, -0.12210892140865326, 0.08396504074335098, -0.05403774231672287, 0.25745904445648193, 0.2989019751548767, -0.13010753691196442, -0.06421781331300735, 0.03433167189359665, -0.5994256138801575, -0.8234876990318298, 0.8563937544822693, -0.9195321798324585, -0.39470037817955017, -0.29013219475746155, -0.8176659345626831, -0.38705185055732727, -0.1328398734331131, 0.24433358013629913, 0.6773961186408997, 0.1476442813873291, 0.10904562473297119, 0.6334128379821777, -0.13808573782444, 0.5249583721160889, 0.1050458773970604, -0.2905222475528717, -0.34572234749794006, 1.1183741092681885, 0.36293870210647583, 0.1337103545665741, 0.6096506118774414, 0.21939979493618011, -0.45463746786117554, -0.2867753505706787, -0.42162635922431946, 0.44062912464141846, -0.43509000539779663, 0.07368048280477524, -0.5478823781013489, -0.5231900811195374, -0.716274082660675, -0.3349882662296295, -0.41231298446655273, -0.5211855173110962, 0.21156162023544312, -0.07042162865400314, -0.17374810576438904, 0.7546622157096863, -0.2329045832157135, 0.06216956302523613, -0.7261443734169006, 0.37187495827674866, 0.4594118595123291, 0.05984023958444595, 0.07904596626758575, -0.4723222255706787, -0.5182070136070251, 0.1920536756515503, -0.35795122385025024, -0.8442659378051758, 0.4679100215435028, 0.26462629437446594, 0.9602742195129395, 0.3586746156215668, -0.22439487278461456, 0.5123572945594788, -0.5698972344398499, 0.7743702530860901, 0.1479419767856598, -0.7282670736312866, 0.42011260986328125, 0.006943038664758205, 0.3658909499645233, 0.2534623146057129, 0.7526906132698059, -0.536252498626709, -0.673628032207489, -0.6573407053947449, -0.7764813303947449, 0.6692038774490356, 0.30545854568481445, 0.1931517869234085, -0.10313717275857925, 0.21567730605602264, 0.3189150393009186, -0.027011381462216377, -0.7005385160446167, -0.18785136938095093, 0.06775066256523132, -0.10223744809627533, -0.4292432367801666, -0.41446372866630554, 0.1158607080578804, -0.5843114852905273, 0.5130987763404846, 0.07888663560152054, 0.20466534793376923, -0.0017256552819162607, -0.5509971976280212, -0.029272975400090218, 0.11480705440044403, 0.3472827076911926, 0.9859604239463806, -0.014235985465347767, 0.22357356548309326, 0.572077214717865, -0.1956673115491867, -0.08684007078409195, 0.0543825700879097, -0.10194315016269684, 0.31805160641670227, 0.5514733195304871, 0.7571300864219666, 0.47101667523384094, -0.4012886583805084, 0.5098246335983276, 0.2262948900461197, -0.36562299728393555, -0.2466665357351303, -0.042526841163635254, -0.003985333256423473, 0.20769833028316498, 0.3370714783668518, -0.2709710896015167, -0.050461895763874054, -0.81233811378479, 0.08194461464881897, 0.4238569736480713, -0.24936652183532715, -0.3109414875507355, 0.45633307099342346, 0.0335419587790966, -0.3674144148826599, 0.657478392124176, -0.5558609366416931, -0.6429007053375244, 0.5837420225143433, 0.947992205619812, 0.49052292108535767, -0.21572238206863403, 0.021537169814109802, 0.7048763632774353, 0.13884349167346954, -0.013228693045675755, 0.37632912397384644, -0.3711525797843933, -1.0039910078048706, -0.2644731402397156, -0.4599394202232361, -0.6899443864822388, -0.28597575426101685, -0.6264666318893433, 0.5113946795463562, -0.0835779532790184, 0.2002076804637909, 0.026094436645507812, 0.10715846717357635, -0.6288005709648132, -0.09809369593858719, 0.7766369581222534, 0.7962601780891418, -1.110251784324646, 0.8610613942146301, 0.763613224029541, -0.2746753990650177, -0.6140518188476562, 0.03210219368338585, -0.14770905673503876, -0.815062403678894, 0.9693716764450073, 0.2838934659957886, 0.007597675547003746, -0.049143631011247635, -0.11918604373931885, -0.8660658001899719, 0.9323681592941284, 0.1567847728729248, -0.1107485443353653, -0.1446508765220642, 0.2740667164325714, 0.5156627297401428, -0.4019671082496643, 0.32385095953941345, 0.5888352990150452, 0.3267708718776703, -0.07067430019378662, -0.9718239903450012, -0.1968894898891449, -0.25114789605140686, 0.19723987579345703, 0.2546139359474182, -0.15453645586967468, 0.5949252843856812, -0.29716619849205017, -0.2772757112979889, 0.027410706505179405, 0.663860023021698, 0.14934542775154114, 0.5995782613754272, 0.6716066598892212, 0.6698256731033325, 0.9511641263961792, 0.09774912893772125, 1.0350371599197388, -0.4117412567138672, 0.14395564794540405, 0.6334470510482788, -0.4537859261035919, 0.900791347026825, 0.3762562870979309, -0.11412158608436584, 0.735650360584259, 0.4468647837638855, 0.24121920764446259, 0.5823743343353271, -0.06482446193695068, -0.18000327050685883, -0.25202393531799316, -0.17976941168308258, -0.25209954380989075, 0.5379048585891724, 0.5070592164993286, -0.38707587122917175, -0.40419140458106995, 0.10298778116703033, -0.0343162901699543, 0.2687101662158966, -0.44966498017311096, 0.900210440158844, 0.015018532983958721, -0.8717393279075623, 0.8711848258972168, -0.19031922519207, 0.3860253095626831, -0.2587183713912964, 0.12023793905973434, -0.5796996355056763, 0.028677944093942642, -0.2207169234752655, -0.43611305952072144, 0.26638874411582947, 0.042188264429569244, -0.15882885456085205, -0.30743321776390076, 0.32809558510780334, -0.6443933844566345, -0.6908475160598755, 0.49987733364105225, 0.9570448398590088, 0.0533687025308609, 0.5181309580802917, -0.2549007833003998, -0.25227582454681396, -0.2700570523738861, 0.3356022536754608, 0.3701780140399933, 0.45488035678863525, -0.17280572652816772, 0.41142937541007996, 0.5806366205215454, 0.3315667510032654, 0.33719998598098755, 0.14928533136844635, 0.5098273158073425, -0.602466344833374, -0.565460741519928, -0.8289945721626282, 0.13176774978637695, -0.1876193732023239, -0.17025235295295715, 0.5693683624267578, 0.7848154902458191, 0.9988757371902466, 0.10927095264196396, 0.6303265690803528, 0.0028168130666017532, 0.5610411167144775, -0.5973272323608398, 0.4450812339782715, -0.7365596294403076, 0.001856161281466484, 0.17341023683547974, -0.9004561305046082, -0.4388825297355652, 0.2356230467557907, -0.32733625173568726, -0.21187125146389008, 1.1589072942733765, 1.0666308403015137, -0.24461284279823303, -0.0189281664788723, 0.4651612639427185, 0.19652210175991058, -0.15714885294437408, 0.5595811009407043, 0.9617820978164673, -0.08227165788412094, 0.44630303978919983, -0.6589061617851257, -0.3567051887512207, -0.1812320500612259, -0.5001459121704102, -0.7870273590087891, -0.661686897277832, -0.11451438814401627, -0.33049118518829346, 0.377890020608902, 1.042043924331665, 0.688543438911438, -0.7590467929840088, -0.587870717048645, -0.06523624062538147, 0.4926821291446686, -0.4956497848033905, -0.09535116702318192, 0.14639179408550262, -1.0965251922607422, -1.0729641914367676, 0.34783872961997986, 0.10387895256280899, -0.41197580099105835, 0.010006451979279518, -0.04011192545294762, -0.2796943485736847, -0.10552196204662323, 0.6476693749427795, 0.44191884994506836, -0.3936898112297058, -0.15479668974876404, -0.0007276160758920014, -0.3600929081439972, 0.19602015614509583, 0.7171976566314697, -0.6690218448638916, 0.5713927149772644, 0.4274623990058899, 0.9892926216125488, 0.5084483623504639, -0.21762241423130035, 0.5859367251396179, -0.8084720969200134, 0.3978293836116791, -0.1054936945438385, 0.6513000130653381, 0.36183491349220276, -0.2877578139305115, 0.36900413036346436, 0.46139898896217346, -0.4797547161579132, -0.9380581974983215, 0.14697900414466858, -0.8683081269264221, 0.04673922806978226, 1.3326795101165771, 0.13324035704135895, -0.5251119136810303, 0.09319868683815002, -0.08943912386894226, 0.30712050199508667, -0.009871527552604675, 0.6438532471656799, 0.41620343923568726, -0.07976475358009338, 0.013259739615023136, -0.40603670477867126, 0.25409960746765137, 0.5872753262519836, -0.45214730501174927, -0.01788492500782013, 0.02372564747929573, 0.03507700562477112, 0.2508939504623413, 0.3246774971485138, -0.17241543531417847, 0.5373518466949463, 0.01792597398161888, -0.13255776464939117, 0.2839655876159668, -0.45223602652549744, -0.22505906224250793, -0.002172613050788641, 0.47856268286705017, -0.11322076618671417 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04212v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04212v1
Unlocking Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for Low-Resource Language Translation
2024-04-05T16:42:28
2024-04-05T16:42:28
Tong Su, Xin Peng, Sarubi Thillainathan, David Guzmán, Surangika Ranathunga, En-Shiun Annie Lee
cs.CL
cs.CL
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods are increasingly vital in adapting large-scale pre-trained language models for diverse tasks, offering a balance between adaptability and computational efficiency. They are important in Low-Resource Language (LRL) Neural Machine Translation (NMT) to enhance translation accuracy with minimal resources. However, their practical effectiveness varies significantly across different languages. We conducted comprehensive empirical experiments with varying LRL domains and sizes to evaluate the performance of 8 PEFT methods with in total of 15 architectures using the SacreBLEU score. We showed that 6 PEFT architectures outperform the baseline for both in-domain and out-domain tests and the Houlsby+Inversion adapter has the best performance overall, proving the effectiveness of PEFT methods.
[ -0.4596486985683441, -0.859393298625946, 0.4336031973361969, 0.2504199743270874, -0.4988534450531006, 0.12301795184612274, -0.6210816502571106, -0.3065577745437622, -0.3645867109298706, 0.3262585997581482, -0.2675045430660248, -0.16081459820270538, -0.5409254431724548, 0.238748699426651, 0.007346357684582472, 0.9172219634056091, -0.16656604409217834, 0.05166101083159447, 0.24564696848392487, -0.2928284704685211, -0.23405493795871735, -0.4473715126514435, -0.7673835158348083, -0.3205600678920746, 0.3355034589767456, 0.4410984516143799, 0.7535412311553955, 0.6958361864089966, 0.7218422293663025, 0.24912305176258087, -0.14927208423614502, 0.386880487203598, -0.41037893295288086, -0.05465840548276901, -0.3554847240447998, -0.24433040618896484, -0.67127525806427, -0.26074227690696716, 0.8158358931541443, 0.7993791699409485, -0.03269786760210991, 0.3868674039840698, 0.38426753878593445, 0.9251439571380615, -0.6231792569160461, -0.16696639358997345, -0.7633214592933655, -0.12346195429563522, -0.24458757042884827, -0.28041166067123413, -0.44927290081977844, -0.2949431836605072, 0.15381677448749542, -0.470636785030365, 0.06840798258781433, -0.00012850489292759448, 0.724949836730957, 0.5223290324211121, -0.13492560386657715, 0.03191568702459335, -0.7571189403533936, 1.052034854888916, -0.8064486384391785, 0.6934865117073059, 0.4082053005695343, 0.16503067314624786, -0.08598455041646957, -0.5504401326179504, -0.11588466912508011, -0.21585693955421448, -0.030152855440974236, -0.03626105561852455, -0.17980265617370605, 0.3216148614883423, 0.2369912564754486, 0.3354208767414093, -0.4494283199310303, 0.3097934424877167, -0.3302755355834961, -0.06414835155010223, 0.4037155508995056, 0.027746936306357384, 0.0014672661200165749, 0.054065678268671036, -0.21546126902103424, -0.11903668940067291, -0.6688529253005981, 0.12725971639156342, 0.35118868947029114, 0.5005612969398499, -0.1162852942943573, 0.3265102207660675, -0.25331076979637146, 1.02753746509552, 0.5321117639541626, -0.12314706295728683, 0.17949186265468597, -0.504402756690979, -0.34177330136299133, -0.12744955718517303, 0.6620701551437378, 0.19143469631671906, 0.10354055464267731, -0.3720169961452484, -0.47489815950393677, -0.4852107763290405, 0.24199475347995758, -0.853636622428894, -0.08570846915245056, -0.07114887982606888, -0.6738317012786865, -0.11751366406679153, -0.42499542236328125, -0.6674416661262512, -0.12320615351200104, -0.23311291635036469, 0.49714159965515137, -0.60450279712677, -0.23711644113063812, 0.032571349292993546, 0.005422123707830906, 0.4546992778778076, 0.35352790355682373, -0.852744460105896, 0.4784587025642395, 0.4333077669143677, 0.9145482778549194, -0.5505599975585938, -0.4510132670402527, -0.681134819984436, -0.2908381223678589, -0.38498905301094055, 0.668152928352356, -0.47544628381729126, -0.09494571387767792, -0.4173596501350403, 0.14909020066261292, -0.4493788480758667, -0.6893388032913208, 0.8174223899841309, -0.5242407917976379, -0.4226481318473816, -0.2629464864730835, -0.2541467845439911, -0.18356120586395264, 0.13459353148937225, -0.5646827220916748, 1.0227211713790894, 0.3350581228733063, -0.023059040307998657, 0.1831967532634735, -0.689933180809021, -0.47934597730636597, 0.04016926512122154, 0.12432253360748291, -0.4098537862300873, 0.633576512336731, 0.11633533239364624, 0.5673787593841553, -0.4727448523044586, 0.053094249218702316, 0.011223518289625645, -0.5565896034240723, 0.13454946875572205, -0.8037903904914856, 0.4394420385360718, 0.4045035243034363, -0.47922155261039734, -0.11990580707788467, -0.7050493955612183, 0.21936751902103424, 0.14045582711696625, -0.6636669635772705, -0.4441973567008972, -0.1893264353275299, 0.158934086561203, 0.08019783347845078, 0.1926463097333908, -0.3691299557685852, 0.09446848928928375, -0.66139155626297, 0.6610636115074158, 0.5672420859336853, -0.0880076065659523, 0.8222582340240479, -0.1748487651348114, 0.4503180682659149, -0.21983997523784637, 0.11623957008123398, 0.1018516942858696, -0.34125930070877075, -0.4553791284561157, -0.05322529375553131, 0.4420311748981476, 0.3391112983226776, -0.5922596454620361, 0.2444487363100052, -0.12197082489728928, -0.6837559938430786, -0.5563830733299255, 0.28126248717308044, 0.7057608366012573, 0.552604079246521, 0.3863489329814911, 0.017155678942799568, -0.09826752543449402, -1.1554876565933228, -0.5720420479774475, 0.1419248729944229, 0.1728787124156952, 0.35905152559280396, 0.2809561789035797, 0.14507994055747986, 0.2462991327047348, -0.1047879010438919, 0.036617573350667953, -0.12382163852453232, 0.06283077597618103, 0.5340969562530518, 0.6748631596565247, 0.87734454870224, -0.7773462533950806, -0.7556148767471313, 0.3747250437736511, -0.1186862364411354, -0.007884815335273743, -0.2157333791255951, -0.1448071449995041, 0.38493451476097107, 0.32432645559310913, -0.290617972612381, 0.08992769569158554, 0.7421358823776245, -0.10023647546768188, 0.25599247217178345, -0.4850127696990967, 0.41290217638015747, -0.73639976978302, 0.1571424901485443, -0.18369515240192413, -0.35438841581344604, -0.6737303137779236, 0.25312238931655884, 0.4036240577697754, -0.04623279720544815, -0.7437105178833008, 0.2861197590827942, -0.5518134832382202, 0.13791382312774658, -0.19303959608078003, -0.04909913241863251, -0.09723810106515884, 0.659777820110321, -0.09179604798555374, 1.2177520990371704, 0.24416346848011017, -0.6849657297134399, -0.20841215550899506, -0.12005235999822617, -0.21043311059474945, 0.3605183959007263, -0.6573167443275452, 0.43480199575424194, 0.12479788810014725, -0.3347809612751007, -0.8127302527427673, 0.018766755238175392, 0.1514732539653778, -0.16351479291915894, 0.2895906865596771, -0.29909518361091614, -0.3681791126728058, 0.13737691938877106, -0.2646024823188782, 0.6095522046089172, 0.6326002478599548, -0.49924910068511963, 0.5981447696685791, 0.26804599165916443, 0.02203543297946453, -0.4130552411079407, -0.5712798833847046, -0.23546868562698364, -0.2893792986869812, -0.1650456190109253, 0.6996879577636719, -0.1817692518234253, -0.047722745686769485, -0.22484956681728363, -0.3153913915157318, -0.22803908586502075, 0.35182705521583557, -0.0116468770429492, -0.12498469650745392, -0.43950387835502625, -0.14781945943832397, 0.5323986411094666, -0.05755653232336044, -0.3181189298629761, -0.25875282287597656, 0.7287858128547668, -0.6963654160499573, -0.16467075049877167, -0.26335281133651733, 0.3276309669017792, 0.7656517624855042, -0.3111394941806793, 0.768488883972168, 0.5209053754806519, -0.4877300262451172, -0.20408549904823303, -0.3907429575920105, 0.09658349305391312, -0.49128732085227966, 0.5278875827789307, -0.666376531124115, -0.7583467364311218, 0.4476943612098694, -0.4669649004936218, 0.04012961685657501, 0.4959099590778351, 0.7446810603141785, -0.0922282412648201, 0.9237062335014343, 0.5476269721984863, 0.10144876688718796, 0.4596644341945648, -0.17195142805576324, 0.1742110550403595, -0.9207320809364319, 0.19586366415023804, -0.6225296258926392, -0.5972453951835632, -0.6976763606071472, -0.31052857637405396, 0.25426235795021057, 0.6359776258468628, -0.11377177387475967, 0.7399333119392395, -0.7521709203720093, 0.7513772249221802, 0.5320917367935181, 0.17846223711967468, 0.2639090120792389, 0.056297916918992996, -0.09864842891693115, -0.1085638627409935, -0.7301974296569824, -0.4792134761810303, 1.002794623374939, 0.09214162826538086, 0.5011038184165955, 0.005026340018957853, 0.6000937819480896, 0.017027953639626503, -0.01335249375551939, -0.8282822966575623, 0.38873788714408875, -0.5798513293266296, -0.3930380344390869, -0.4280000627040863, -0.19713978469371796, -0.6894952654838562, 0.19372305274009705, -0.08554238080978394, -0.6686916947364807, 0.4689805507659912, 0.4806489050388336, -0.5713542103767395, 0.26936352252960205, -0.8914388418197632, 0.7680720090866089, -0.570278525352478, -0.3734112083911896, -0.32749760150909424, -0.43105432391166687, -0.1303669661283493, -0.5999100804328918, -0.07649284601211548, -0.15621130168437958, -0.28255003690719604, 0.7004570960998535, -0.12300143390893936, 0.5749594569206238, -0.24945613741874695, 0.022764600813388824, -0.02624531276524067, 0.22873343527317047, 0.6516318917274475, 0.08319170027971268, -0.465750515460968, 0.4394152760505676, 0.18126222491264343, -0.4063947796821594, -0.5095207691192627, 0.7662853002548218, -0.8182308673858643, -0.4154038727283478, -0.02258492261171341, -0.6097617149353027, -0.37420853972435, 0.3736867904663086, 0.46568629145622253, 0.05197262391448021, -0.1710570603609085, 0.5038737058639526, 0.6530103087425232, -0.2848369777202606, 0.4600726366043091, 0.5297709107398987, 0.28505003452301025, -0.35468488931655884, 0.8663135766983032, 0.33240416646003723, 0.43824300169944763, 0.5493446588516235, 0.37616491317749023, 0.02663307823240757, -1.0420894622802734, -0.6088675856590271, 0.02209932543337345, -0.3403107225894928, -0.460147500038147, -0.3917516767978668, -0.15704652667045593, -0.02888856828212738, -0.4483053684234619, -0.869575023651123, -0.5782923102378845, -0.023254122585058212, 0.2018025815486908, 0.3601585030555725, 0.1310860514640808, -0.02401195466518402, 0.5298850536346436, -0.8701852560043335, 0.3200010359287262, -0.10944542288780212, 0.4341210424900055, -0.15255513787269592, -0.6849722862243652, -0.41690167784690857, -0.000031288691388908774, -0.23720023036003113, -0.7114978432655334, 0.1305861622095108, 0.5910040140151978, 0.6949758529663086, 0.24242670834064484, 0.17145337164402008, 0.8726813793182373, -0.6488385200500488, 0.5931881070137024, -0.03729625046253204, -0.9909737706184387, 0.564467191696167, -0.2646985352039337, 0.24901635944843292, 0.8330174088478088, 0.30434274673461914, -0.1441270262002945, -0.019511139020323753, -0.25944778323173523, -0.8560069799423218, 0.7427389025688171, 0.2530716061592102, 0.27607908844947815, 0.26664236187934875, 0.7793005108833313, 0.4336550533771515, 0.07942335307598114, -0.31215187907218933, -0.2607018053531647, -0.008678006939589977, -0.13905896246433258, 0.012869884259998798, -0.03412896394729614, 0.08460867404937744, -0.5100952982902527, 0.5442034006118774, -0.31058037281036377, 0.284271776676178, 0.11466649919748306, -0.24927647411823273, -0.3414285182952881, 0.25156369805336, 0.7484400272369385, 0.644255518913269, -0.3037245273590088, 0.1390751153230667, 0.6253690719604492, -0.5841013789176941, 0.12670260667800903, 0.033208806067705154, -0.30196407437324524, -0.18502816557884216, 0.1596396267414093, 0.7921982407569885, 0.2582704722881317, -0.5294888019561768, 0.13775956630706787, -0.02407214045524597, -0.4306255578994751, 0.06180742010474205, 0.2624285817146301, -0.027677573263645172, 0.32061803340911865, 0.16592952609062195, 0.46928462386131287, 0.19512110948562622, -0.13552765548229218, 0.05257938802242279, 0.3707863390445709, -0.2693467140197754, -0.5015988349914551, 0.5993042588233948, 0.09401354193687439, -0.5659274458885193, 0.4302334487438202, 0.035540349781513214, -0.2062089592218399, 0.34403321146965027, 0.6721081733703613, 0.9336566925048828, -0.28521546721458435, 0.009224992245435715, 0.295154869556427, 0.5647426247596741, -0.17445968091487885, 0.1589452624320984, -0.3375103175640106, -0.5870083570480347, -0.5554449558258057, -0.9734169840812683, -0.3741396963596344, 0.25697141885757446, -0.7396280169487, -0.05833028629422188, -0.3747439682483673, -0.2867443263530731, -0.014748254790902138, -0.04000920057296753, -0.7872768044471741, -0.1070341244339943, -0.15991587936878204, 1.1041014194488525, -0.6408642530441284, 1.0396080017089844, 0.9530190825462341, -0.1336231678724289, -0.7745087742805481, 0.029714765027165413, -0.3473283052444458, -0.8393824696540833, 0.5737726092338562, -0.42502087354660034, -0.32861533761024475, 0.2574750483036041, -0.30968281626701355, -0.9620572328567505, 0.889063835144043, 0.9099040627479553, -0.7474712133407593, -0.05983823537826538, 0.27180910110473633, 0.47347670793533325, -0.015061876736581326, -0.1957205832004547, 0.9629837274551392, 0.5538082718849182, -0.47346749901771545, -1.1194881200790405, 0.07731253653764725, -0.18874795734882355, 0.1525479108095169, 0.4415583610534668, -0.770430326461792, 0.6449055671691895, 0.08018112182617188, 0.09474582970142365, 0.15255476534366608, 0.2893407642841339, 0.21408464014530182, -0.02458440698683262, 0.5792323350906372, 0.22387725114822388, 0.6956507563591003, -0.18387062847614288, 0.9250395894050598, -0.5932462215423584, 0.3486982583999634, 0.9979373812675476, 0.14069406688213348, 0.925199568271637, 0.8137306571006775, -0.08127753436565399, -0.17056822776794434, 0.5238276720046997, 0.103570356965065, 0.8348040580749512, -0.024473467841744423, 0.10263045132160187, -0.48510780930519104, -0.030822928994894028, -0.2507835030555725, 0.40038758516311646, 0.38947558403015137, -0.5290086269378662, -0.20421601831912994, 0.09587565064430237, -0.08796703815460205, 0.02588566392660141, -0.37394487857818604, 0.6585261225700378, 0.22291922569274902, -0.6546220779418945, 1.015669345855713, 0.23659293353557587, 0.5477600693702698, -0.38301554322242737, -0.09571150690317154, -0.2838451564311981, 0.4571680426597595, -0.06895133852958679, -0.5286461710929871, 0.45546334981918335, 0.012700318358838558, -0.20734074711799622, -0.4974168539047241, 0.8585623502731323, -0.04939477518200874, -0.2888489067554474, 0.3971322178840637, 0.762886106967926, 0.06743119657039642, -0.2529844343662262, -0.8624979257583618, 0.0769432932138443, -0.16202674806118011, -0.5389604568481445, 0.5270997881889343, 0.4400741457939148, -0.07565918564796448, 0.16533195972442627, 0.5850510001182556, 0.2741076350212097, 0.05304863676428795, -0.1735045313835144, 0.7803139686584473, -0.47556072473526, -0.1309778243303299, -0.9961184859275818, 0.3091066777706146, 0.10717716813087463, -0.5484668016433716, 0.6961908340454102, 0.5248159766197205, 0.9177402853965759, -0.31375852227211, 0.4774789810180664, 0.06405624747276306, 0.1192852109670639, -0.6296223402023315, 0.9197583198547363, -0.6073875427246094, 0.10060779750347137, -0.2867095470428467, -0.9995632767677307, -0.35182031989097595, 0.6659280061721802, -0.2415430098772049, -0.20989857614040375, 0.6689013838768005, 0.6432846784591675, -0.25848785042762756, -0.3063824474811554, 0.6494114398956299, 0.11946523189544678, 0.10726010054349899, 0.6626228094100952, 0.5770233869552612, -0.6973283886909485, 0.5633276104927063, -0.47211265563964844, -0.24143563210964203, -0.10290958732366562, -0.849800169467926, -0.8028890490531921, -0.5615545511245728, -0.1786479353904724, -0.08271368592977524, 0.2276357114315033, 0.9760706424713135, 0.8430474996566772, -0.9817760586738586, -0.11961578577756882, -0.16395486891269684, -0.04935719072818756, -0.7271454930305481, -0.10505309700965881, 0.5376219749450684, -0.38817182183265686, -0.8646132946014404, 0.7316263914108276, 0.49962183833122253, -0.17575237154960632, 0.11934030055999756, -0.3717207908630371, 0.08989569544792175, 0.11589990556240082, 0.588409423828125, 0.20799362659454346, -0.6290996670722961, -0.24821530282497406, 0.3602367639541626, 0.05982428416609764, 0.16865019500255585, 0.8208112716674805, -0.5544265508651733, 0.09835973381996155, 0.615135669708252, 1.026193618774414, 0.3642398416996002, -0.09073199331760406, 0.6107861399650574, -0.6794440746307373, 0.12737895548343658, 0.2045624852180481, 0.3596068322658539, -0.03903200849890709, -0.4385736584663391, 0.5355312824249268, 0.0005861432291567326, -0.6121531128883362, -0.9706923365592957, 0.03921542689204216, -1.0223802328109741, -0.1932430863380432, 0.8445413708686829, -0.01433506514877081, -0.37740346789360046, -0.012308989651501179, -0.20387013256549835, 0.1800893098115921, -0.4078781008720398, 0.48462891578674316, 0.43547311425209045, -0.3506324887275696, -0.3092053532600403, -0.5572609305381775, 0.6367822885513306, 0.4307090640068054, -0.6073060035705566, 0.08021511882543564, -0.06547287851572037, 0.2671317756175995, 0.14011608064174652, 0.6466842293739319, -0.1807505339384079, 0.3096158504486084, -0.2615843713283539, -0.4184526205062866, -0.18779972195625305, -0.2563697099685669, -0.4419267475605011, 0.16374239325523376, 0.40328219532966614, -0.16800382733345032 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04204v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04204v1
Social Skill Training with Large Language Models
2024-04-05T16:29:58
2024-04-05T16:29:58
Diyi Yang, Caleb Ziems, William Held, Omar Shaikh, Michael S. Bernstein, John Mitchell
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.HC
People rely on social skills like conflict resolution to communicate effectively and to thrive in both work and personal life. However, practice environments for social skills are typically out of reach for most people. How can we make social skill training more available, accessible, and inviting? Drawing upon interdisciplinary research from communication and psychology, this perspective paper identifies social skill barriers to enter specialized fields. Then we present a solution that leverages large language models for social skill training via a generic framework. Our AI Partner, AI Mentor framework merges experiential learning with realistic practice and tailored feedback. This work ultimately calls for cross-disciplinary innovation to address the broader implications for workforce development and social equality.
[ -0.1583051234483719, -0.6263178586959839, 0.5252463221549988, 0.2904517650604248, 0.12881019711494446, 0.536914050579071, -0.3759441375732422, -0.798871636390686, 0.2654065489768982, -0.04949365183711052, -0.5865773558616638, -0.21398164331912994, -0.7792968153953552, -0.16770705580711365, -0.06018000468611717, 0.6841399073600769, 0.20990562438964844, 0.26108068227767944, -0.15607358515262604, -0.4546753466129303, -0.4600999057292938, -0.5308852195739746, -1.073408603668213, -0.5150465965270996, 0.39764171838760376, 0.5589422583580017, 0.625655472278595, 0.40162649750709534, 0.40915024280548096, 0.37619441747665405, -0.2332131415605545, 0.08393162488937378, -0.5765315890312195, -0.1339203417301178, -0.3884355127811432, -0.513947069644928, -0.18268230557441711, 0.11792577803134918, 0.6593606472015381, 0.9873867630958557, -0.15467944741249084, -0.06843999028205872, 0.10218594968318939, 0.609946072101593, -0.1983383446931839, 0.43036606907844543, -0.724372148513794, 0.10520458221435547, -0.17655210196971893, 0.4092942476272583, -0.18986058235168457, -0.22831125557422638, 0.07106893509626389, -0.6406024694442749, 0.29537463188171387, -0.1730022430419922, 0.5922747850418091, 0.02536640875041485, -0.443651407957077, 0.19852890074253082, -0.8976073265075684, 0.5065955519676208, -0.37341102957725525, 0.3302110731601715, 0.4578111171722412, 0.6800714135169983, -0.18511396646499634, -0.3955458104610443, -0.33508163690567017, -0.023239342495799065, 0.22712185978889465, -0.021460631862282753, 0.46283218264579773, 0.09677217155694962, 0.20068375766277313, 0.02726646699011326, -0.05394288897514343, 0.2639736831188202, -0.6963881254196167, 0.3195878267288208, 0.943625807762146, 0.3913204073905945, 0.31583350896835327, 0.4636499285697937, 0.33385321497917175, -0.11771664768457413, -0.6311211585998535, 0.4218938648700714, 0.28916820883750916, 0.2034732699394226, -0.4433913230895996, 0.1704276204109192, -0.17937785387039185, 0.34365180134773254, -0.14486315846443176, -0.09280179440975189, -0.03567035123705864, 0.014135637320578098, 0.23090125620365143, -0.2417413592338562, 0.32097098231315613, 0.24285534024238586, 0.3670426309108734, -0.2568443715572357, 0.05248832702636719, 0.06218111142516136, 0.4134105145931244, -0.39379775524139404, 0.16097155213356018, -0.08859416097402573, -0.45933863520622253, -0.3124295175075531, 0.0452200211584568, -0.5616995096206665, -0.7874582409858704, -0.28886088728904724, 0.06696605682373047, -0.33949315547943115, -0.563045859336853, -0.02979324571788311, -0.372310072183609, 0.29307132959365845, 0.6058172583580017, -0.9629879593849182, 0.406688928604126, 0.8611088395118713, 1.0027668476104736, 0.14448195695877075, -0.4669992923736572, -0.5564274787902832, 0.1528366655111313, -0.30761227011680603, 0.45095083117485046, -0.9027142524719238, -0.32049664855003357, 0.3006085753440857, -0.027876021340489388, 0.07402998954057693, -0.4713357388973236, -0.104393370449543, -0.3014094829559326, -0.28038331866264343, -0.304497629404068, -0.3327644467353821, 0.18183204531669617, 0.15875594317913055, -0.43237388134002686, 0.8713324069976807, 0.5096330642700195, -0.3169039785861969, 0.4649369716644287, -0.8068937659263611, -0.565078616142273, 0.39183998107910156, -0.42243659496307373, -0.15043775737285614, 0.07598499953746796, -0.2512950599193573, 0.3958655893802643, -0.3420545756816864, 0.3502894341945648, -0.7570680379867554, -0.49971023201942444, 0.11822216212749481, 0.03198433294892311, 0.7518519163131714, 0.0032585777807980776, -0.5000760555267334, 0.17111167311668396, -0.7092002034187317, -0.24985651671886444, 0.22721363604068756, -0.45504119992256165, -0.34093916416168213, -0.05452915281057358, 0.03698821738362312, 0.36352819204330444, -0.1744079440832138, -0.5183336734771729, 0.034079138189554214, -0.31639522314071655, 0.7230706810951233, 0.7575598359107971, -0.45656123757362366, 0.5392142534255981, -0.3166983127593994, 0.5260734558105469, -0.11885321885347366, 0.21351449191570282, 0.2886797785758972, -0.4394637942314148, -0.4944351613521576, -0.019151482731103897, -0.2155093550682068, 0.2718159258365631, -1.0694924592971802, 0.4634277820587158, -0.06582777202129364, -0.7051194310188293, -0.7500580549240112, 0.39393624663352966, 0.4629284143447876, 0.039083532989025116, 0.23991401493549347, -0.4617747962474823, -0.39414238929748535, -0.3570914566516876, -0.5540111064910889, -0.17959076166152954, 0.19174902141094208, 0.394485741853714, 0.5866481065750122, -0.0776505395770073, 0.6306920647621155, -0.14829730987548828, -0.46575039625167847, -0.5646620392799377, -0.09332066774368286, 0.014176690950989723, 0.533764123916626, 0.3453436493873596, -0.8606162071228027, -0.68293696641922, 0.10639258474111557, -0.9230207800865173, 0.21936866641044617, 0.04795736446976662, -0.02857232838869095, -0.1395496129989624, 0.9101394414901733, -0.32796210050582886, 0.5581371188163757, 0.40149036049842834, -0.4059912860393524, 0.28157252073287964, -0.20194822549819946, 0.001405262970365584, -0.8140480518341064, 0.11400994658470154, 0.2902536988258362, -0.3210708200931549, -0.7307295799255371, 0.02640661969780922, -0.10591506212949753, -0.518034815788269, -0.3113018870353699, 0.8590245246887207, -0.4354841709136963, -0.06793626397848129, 0.079796202480793, 0.03175694867968559, -0.4244331419467926, 0.30397021770477295, 0.2532216012477875, 0.3480101227760315, 0.4250166416168213, -0.3874708414077759, 0.42828330397605896, 0.4031582772731781, -0.5171985626220703, 0.9420751929283142, -0.9682506918907166, 0.2158132791519165, -0.23074567317962646, 0.32933422923088074, -0.655728280544281, -0.4021104872226715, 0.009173525497317314, -0.1680031716823578, 0.22467966377735138, -0.1249866783618927, -0.045254677534103394, -0.5474019050598145, -0.16494464874267578, 0.36346423625946045, 0.31942108273506165, -0.3874826431274414, 0.5032879114151001, 0.6104216575622559, -0.4765458106994629, -0.5232711434364319, -0.41967353224754333, 0.11314064264297485, 0.1360655426979065, -0.6615757942199707, 0.3305116295814514, -0.012761039659380913, -0.3186556100845337, 0.006646796595305204, 0.250642865896225, -0.22923068702220917, 0.24288779497146606, 0.46315228939056396, 0.045015398412942886, 0.05083397775888443, 0.1166444718837738, 0.14265021681785583, -0.09010942280292511, 0.008035560138523579, 0.09899946302175522, 0.4289804697036743, -0.11307059973478317, -0.6474840044975281, -0.1370478719472885, 0.6316216588020325, 0.6180813908576965, -0.2921537756919861, 1.1296097040176392, 0.3580704629421234, -0.3929196298122406, -0.13119979202747345, -0.6685366630554199, -0.22454312443733215, -0.48681193590164185, 0.8183632493019104, -0.07079937309026718, -1.075393557548523, 0.40699243545532227, -0.024807335808873177, 0.1857292503118515, -0.42868781089782715, 0.2108481377363205, 0.05718246474862099, 0.9692447781562805, 0.9660593867301941, 0.02631564438343048, 0.8788828253746033, -0.1596943885087967, 0.36993733048439026, -0.7159423828125, -0.3730299472808838, -0.2239530086517334, -0.3208453357219696, 0.13491229712963104, -0.2415175884962082, 0.40138325095176697, -0.2077236771583557, -0.2993287444114685, 0.04712855443358421, -0.3209768235683441, 0.3979616165161133, 0.7355695962905884, 0.36222606897354126, 0.08596064150333405, -0.27239862084388733, 0.086241714656353, -0.18186943233013153, -0.6557556390762329, -0.2155560851097107, 0.6364822387695312, 0.568130612373352, 0.546960175037384, 0.05605611577630043, 0.5661441683769226, 0.24103514850139618, 0.6384411454200745, -0.4771327078342438, 0.3910657465457916, 0.029537174850702286, -0.7310083508491516, -0.5477126836776733, -0.33995261788368225, -0.6058579087257385, 0.06828691065311432, -0.37670695781707764, -0.46900030970573425, 0.16504082083702087, 0.11925159394741058, -0.3899003863334656, 0.33341220021247864, -0.6948053240776062, 0.878548264503479, 0.11788198351860046, -0.4423305094242096, -0.3253708481788635, -0.8448519110679626, 0.015719518065452576, -0.06486472487449646, 0.46645429730415344, -0.16437065601348877, 0.3214077353477478, 0.5272608995437622, -0.3121934235095978, 1.245104193687439, -0.31323522329330444, 0.03763046860694885, 0.07385408878326416, -0.148492693901062, 0.5983319282531738, -0.12121090292930603, 0.026050293818116188, 0.004845716059207916, -0.13216784596443176, -0.5706865787506104, -0.5014244914054871, 0.29440200328826904, -0.9790368676185608, -0.6273272037506104, -0.21758966147899628, -0.5819441080093384, -0.3652898967266083, -0.07530724257230759, 0.21419669687747955, 0.0034455384593456984, -0.5995194911956787, 0.37533318996429443, 0.45011407136917114, -0.30828896164894104, 0.1436087191104889, 0.6955450773239136, 0.13094040751457214, -0.16524282097816467, 0.6979511380195618, 0.46849822998046875, 0.36778971552848816, -0.06626946479082108, -0.14319920539855957, -0.019745998084545135, -0.146828755736351, 0.06809103488922119, 0.4401746094226837, -0.6908066272735596, -0.027661237865686417, -0.6481390595436096, -0.5347942113876343, -0.8097338080406189, -0.660347580909729, -0.347206711769104, -0.05065185949206352, 0.09048204869031906, -0.17764504253864288, 0.35429275035858154, 1.0121850967407227, -0.4574049413204193, 0.2531404197216034, -0.6445643305778503, 0.04137144982814789, 0.5324243903160095, 0.58995121717453, 0.43589842319488525, -0.24451439082622528, -0.5373095870018005, 0.09456434100866318, -0.15503601729869843, -0.6182513236999512, 0.1715540587902069, 0.3330942392349243, 0.38060998916625977, 0.3612689971923828, 0.09959926456212997, 0.41128984093666077, -0.7023857831954956, 0.5603137016296387, 0.3798302114009857, -0.8250739574432373, 0.49456682801246643, -0.3540600836277008, -0.15241000056266785, 0.6499006748199463, 0.6492795348167419, -1.0643717050552368, -0.5263920426368713, -0.750512421131134, -0.9623534083366394, 0.7657071948051453, -0.16530220210552216, 0.44947052001953125, -0.022439487278461456, 0.40735486149787903, -0.00196127244271338, 0.13704665005207062, -0.8249213695526123, 0.032832395285367966, -0.09231103956699371, -0.25615444779396057, -0.08452009409666061, -0.015741383656859398, -0.43826785683631897, -0.5887932181358337, 0.37134477496147156, -0.14633925259113312, 0.21606510877609253, -0.037700556218624115, 0.12342925369739532, -0.2793426811695099, 0.13853786885738373, 0.05702204257249832, 0.6944730281829834, 0.22406034171581268, -0.05712223798036575, 0.2870950698852539, -0.28333553671836853, 0.5455198884010315, -0.16946090757846832, 0.4114643931388855, -0.29698219895362854, 0.351077675819397, 0.4851723611354828, 0.30258840322494507, -0.6971545815467834, 0.8156757354736328, -0.09251607209444046, -0.4111095666885376, -0.6270108819007874, 0.6211549639701843, 0.40233051776885986, 0.5412915349006653, 0.2789284586906433, -0.16303563117980957, -0.29193824529647827, -0.7540621757507324, -0.043850287795066833, 0.5240119695663452, -0.6855615377426147, -0.16031190752983093, 0.7705760598182678, 0.6603718996047974, -0.7135433554649353, 0.418529212474823, -0.19872626662254333, -0.34068062901496887, 0.6702160835266113, 0.5298842787742615, 0.48411908745765686, -0.19680912792682648, 0.4393171966075897, -0.12036347389221191, 0.12011648714542389, -0.38632625341415405, 0.14850430190563202, 0.0005521096172742546, -0.8044084906578064, -0.3592197597026825, -0.0924084484577179, -0.7661928534507751, 0.02200964465737343, -0.603950560092926, 0.21372351050376892, -0.7066087126731873, 0.05940981209278107, 0.14442220330238342, -0.18357957899570465, -0.9175981283187866, 0.010231496766209602, -0.09759832918643951, 0.7905020117759705, -1.2498188018798828, 0.7138604521751404, 0.9514918923377991, -0.4657785892486572, -0.6087625026702881, -0.4735909700393677, 0.11767023056745529, -0.879410982131958, 0.7672320008277893, 0.19847843050956726, 0.13484662771224976, 0.061360668390989304, -0.7951387763023376, -0.3293507397174835, 0.9868772029876709, 0.41935575008392334, -0.3322176933288574, -0.35423341393470764, 0.1420947164297104, 0.6108732223510742, -0.5454086065292358, 0.17827671766281128, 0.5598356127738953, 0.1812291443347931, -0.20434211194515228, -0.8392650485038757, 0.008623947389423847, -0.5870949029922485, 0.2726914882659912, -0.1927994042634964, -1.0396772623062134, 0.43352431058883667, -0.1876089870929718, 0.06252796202898026, 0.006586054340004921, 0.5434654355049133, 0.08980002999305725, 0.4017152786254883, 0.45046454668045044, 0.1296250820159912, 0.7202816605567932, -0.002678230172023177, 0.6699469685554504, -0.17415224015712738, 0.1138114258646965, 1.0637322664260864, -0.6102708578109741, 0.5270540118217468, 0.19703683257102966, -0.12077323347330093, 0.5500943660736084, 0.43267908692359924, 0.22508521378040314, 0.2536589801311493, 0.19904367625713348, -0.5571509599685669, -0.2836907207965851, -0.5269805192947388, -0.43009573221206665, 0.25349950790405273, 0.48885223269462585, -0.2849019467830658, 0.048053544014692307, 0.1893540471792221, 0.04837093874812126, 0.4033088982105255, -0.29589685797691345, 0.6694797873497009, 0.34521135687828064, -0.5505509376525879, 0.02604210004210472, -0.24021853506565094, 0.627123236656189, -0.5223259925842285, -0.40826553106307983, -0.09893976151943207, 0.25886499881744385, -0.1272866576910019, -0.6304080486297607, 0.23963092267513275, -0.15080206096172333, 0.017718059942126274, -0.16749636828899384, 0.7421356439590454, -0.5727917551994324, -0.23597215116024017, 0.6263694763183594, 0.6527005434036255, -0.07390064746141434, -0.028320161625742912, -0.5208672285079956, -0.16106414794921875, -0.43240076303482056, 0.2276105433702469, 0.5392066240310669, 0.9342026114463806, 0.1673499047756195, 0.7782119512557983, 0.5326166152954102, 0.43369829654693604, -0.15719527006149292, 0.11745636910200119, 0.9769338965415955, -0.6707351207733154, -0.6709290742874146, -0.5155935287475586, 0.4828782081604004, -0.6267640590667725, -0.6382878422737122, 0.19995678961277008, -0.1612684428691864, 0.7284420728683472, 0.18598760664463043, 0.9515966176986694, -0.2097814679145813, 0.4512794315814972, -0.09578055143356323, 0.6662541031837463, -0.4053712487220764, -0.02763034589588642, -0.6023021936416626, -0.7267797589302063, -0.25077685713768005, 0.8430806398391724, -0.6080750823020935, 0.26084572076797485, 0.45383238792419434, 0.6253933906555176, 0.05944742634892464, -0.1453879326581955, 0.62794029712677, -0.04774986952543259, 0.5275996327400208, 0.7060346603393555, 0.9157058000564575, 0.11842835694551468, 0.28764858841896057, -0.04242357239127159, -0.4441247880458832, -0.33465856313705444, -0.561565101146698, -1.223266363143921, -0.6131885647773743, -0.16525757312774658, -0.5355228185653687, 0.48875921964645386, 1.224938988685608, 0.8743975162506104, -0.2549135386943817, -0.33783307671546936, -0.008049479685723782, 0.17544180154800415, -0.3673113286495209, -0.27878764271736145, -0.14946523308753967, -0.4215072691440582, -0.46476513147354126, 0.14332140982151031, 0.23351414501667023, 0.05266148969531059, -0.24922634661197662, -0.2916290760040283, -0.12501513957977295, -0.15409938991069794, 0.5969796180725098, 0.6951992511749268, -0.15097376704216003, -0.4063245952129364, -0.22559112310409546, 0.009698390029370785, -0.011744003742933273, 0.9160298109054565, -0.34860315918922424, 0.05989844352006912, 0.15672414004802704, 1.0326813459396362, 0.13955771923065186, -0.41231802105903625, 0.9167868494987488, -0.7558350563049316, 0.45832571387290955, 0.21718309819698334, 0.3156135678291321, 0.40996330976486206, -0.589110791683197, 0.8540473580360413, 0.3866369426250458, -0.4221212863922119, -0.8709011673927307, 0.2670745849609375, -0.1731700748205185, -0.2885875403881073, 1.0395816564559937, -0.45636460185050964, -0.08828611671924591, -0.6601495146751404, -0.22321966290473938, 0.3203425705432892, -0.3910635709762573, 1.2050011157989502, 0.8370156288146973, 0.010817441157996655, -0.27386903762817383, -0.518095850944519, 0.5701690912246704, 0.48571518063545227, -0.6497415900230408, 0.0006815355154685676, 0.05906781926751137, 0.10579586029052734, 0.09209542721509933, 1.006921648979187, -0.026670675724744797, 0.5413385033607483, 0.058422207832336426, 0.14016775786876678, 0.020523900166153908, -0.6005874872207642, -0.2120082527399063, -0.20662811398506165, 0.4033558666706085, 0.5418946146965027 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08673v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08673v1
Sentiment analysis and random forest to classify LLM versus human source applied to Scientific Texts
2024-04-05T16:14:36
2024-04-05T16:14:36
Javier J. Sanchez-Medina
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG, 68
After the launch of ChatGPT v.4 there has been a global vivid discussion on the ability of this artificial intelligence powered platform and some other similar ones for the automatic production of all kinds of texts, including scientific and technical texts. This has triggered a reflection in many institutions on whether education and academic procedures should be adapted to the fact that in future many texts we read will not be written by humans (students, scholars, etc.), at least, not entirely. In this work it is proposed a new methodology to classify texts coming from an automatic text production engine or a human, based on Sentiment Analysis as a source for feature engineering independent variables and then train with them a Random Forest classification algorithm. Using four different sentiment lexicons, a number of new features where produced, and then fed to a machine learning random forest methodology, to train such a model. Results seem very convincing that this may be a promising research line to detect fraud, in such environments where human are supposed to be the source of texts.
[ -0.2374192625284195, -0.5314558148384094, 0.428091824054718, 0.11714495718479156, -0.18553856015205383, 0.46463507413864136, -0.0513002835214138, -0.8731635808944702, 0.2306988686323166, 0.6384162306785583, -0.5756286978721619, -0.5566098093986511, -0.5125876069068909, 0.40726232528686523, -0.6081836223602295, 1.4174823760986328, -0.03533531725406647, 0.35047516226768494, -0.6073867678642273, -0.21708470582962036, -0.08601369708776474, -1.0253627300262451, -0.5870981216430664, -0.29538846015930176, 0.6769021153450012, 0.08401872962713242, 0.3305377662181854, 0.18903280794620514, 0.8410127758979797, 0.32174408435821533, -0.06908533722162247, 0.02610922046005726, -0.23683564364910126, 0.04911089316010475, 0.03684702143073082, -0.7332514524459839, -0.30843833088874817, 0.300271213054657, 0.3415602147579193, 0.011039032600820065, -0.06252162158489227, 0.11817017197608948, 0.2809785008430481, 0.47341713309288025, -0.20937928557395935, 0.24864621460437775, -0.4649406671524048, 0.39146825671195984, -0.37815120816230774, -0.6221927404403687, -0.3966330885887146, -0.6162779927253723, 0.30600506067276, -0.49854278564453125, 0.6525548696517944, 0.2976991534233093, 0.780181884765625, 0.17011982202529907, -0.09548263251781464, -0.4732988774776459, -0.531257152557373, 1.1024590730667114, -0.642731785774231, -0.11837760359048843, 0.005262462422251701, 0.34502917528152466, -0.14844711124897003, -0.5006193518638611, -0.5118188261985779, -0.2815682590007782, 0.08064115047454834, 0.2950567603111267, 0.090598925948143, 0.13635823130607605, -0.015042440965771675, 0.244899183511734, -0.3398456275463104, 0.2384602278470993, -0.2859993278980255, -0.3817930221557617, 0.8702607154846191, -0.10374787449836731, 0.26040539145469666, -0.535468339920044, -0.42499592900276184, -0.3556564152240753, -0.5364309549331665, -0.024533797055482864, 0.5736905932426453, 0.2102329581975937, 0.2823003828525543, 0.5245396494865417, -0.13101917505264282, 0.3280567526817322, -0.5050008893013, -0.08643374592065811, 0.2954406142234802, -0.13659808039665222, -0.2634774148464203, 0.12952251732349396, 1.0024608373641968, 0.20359955728054047, 0.39961421489715576, 0.15802431106567383, -0.44913411140441895, 0.35904020071029663, 0.2520087659358978, -0.6108198165893555, -0.40457844734191895, -0.06709560751914978, -0.625870943069458, -1.015978217124939, -0.08786353468894958, -0.8916229009628296, -0.715112566947937, -0.18701623380184174, 0.18631616234779358, -0.3408157527446747, -0.25578027963638306, -0.16863535344600677, -0.14696817100048065, 0.0529613122344017, 0.6050801873207092, -0.6560556888580322, 0.15535803139209747, 0.607660174369812, 0.9353097081184387, -0.22950270771980286, -0.23469096422195435, -0.08522765338420868, -0.5258685350418091, 0.03314507007598877, 1.1938505172729492, -0.36868003010749817, -0.5406675934791565, -0.010510933585464954, -0.4100399315357208, 0.15782257914543152, -0.37111741304397583, 0.874015212059021, -0.6178298592567444, 0.7745885252952576, -0.2410309910774231, -0.4045790731906891, -0.5616647601127625, 0.3529525697231293, -0.46529456973075867, 0.9373524785041809, 0.18211688101291656, -0.9975237846374512, 0.4249919056892395, -0.865796685218811, -0.20004042983055115, 0.19890713691711426, -0.347924143075943, -0.5274142026901245, -0.05293649435043335, -0.001406063442118466, 0.4087245464324951, -0.44937652349472046, 0.3983834385871887, -0.7470929026603699, -0.004934394266456366, 0.7387331128120422, -0.7871730327606201, 0.9554946422576904, 0.4020029604434967, 0.02957439236342907, -0.012665893882513046, -0.5409942269325256, 0.1699807345867157, -0.054780323058366776, -0.3557540774345398, -0.4199550747871399, 0.37278059124946594, 0.3184416890144348, 0.1887182891368866, 0.1559234857559204, -0.725355863571167, 0.18685749173164368, -0.3865290880203247, 0.4014991521835327, 0.8326770663261414, 0.13542772829532623, 0.314811646938324, -0.31028658151626587, 0.4725339710712433, 0.01843290962278843, 0.01617102324962616, -0.0012028142809867859, -0.6516620516777039, -0.7181978225708008, -0.2875482439994812, 0.5857957005500793, 0.8109365105628967, -0.42391636967658997, 0.46123310923576355, -0.1783582717180252, -0.1534547060728073, -0.5985209345817566, 0.01143645215779543, 0.12979261577129364, 0.4014750123023987, 0.17572985589504242, -0.48212340474128723, -0.7255262136459351, -0.6972008943557739, -0.4344789981842041, -0.4490465521812439, -0.17942917346954346, 0.21721293032169342, 0.47636258602142334, -0.11372674256563187, 1.3731343746185303, -0.510527491569519, -0.4575650691986084, 0.13502123951911926, 0.6660544276237488, -0.12012626230716705, 0.2325446754693985, 0.6405454874038696, -0.739499568939209, -0.24395914375782013, 0.2375861555337906, -1.1830146312713623, -0.19940094649791718, -0.0018110638484358788, 0.06407032907009125, 0.4497426748275757, 0.057651862502098083, -0.4795929491519928, 0.2089814841747284, 0.37597185373306274, -0.14081650972366333, 0.47683486342430115, 0.0770263820886612, 0.3158997893333435, -1.0537066459655762, -0.10112538188695908, 0.357797235250473, -0.1748499870300293, -0.46286845207214355, -0.24448837339878082, -0.2945478856563568, -0.05784791707992554, -0.20886503159999847, 0.33913934230804443, -0.25735223293304443, -0.03888365253806114, -0.5175600051879883, 0.0570744127035141, -0.22452807426452637, 0.3303854763507843, 0.09449976682662964, 0.4882621467113495, 0.3604254722595215, -0.19845882058143616, 0.45957639813423157, 0.13089923560619354, -0.35749220848083496, 0.6672702431678772, -0.16936719417572021, 0.07880713790655136, -0.1999044567346573, 0.37642964720726013, -0.730656087398529, -0.41957539319992065, 0.4628065228462219, -0.8247341513633728, 0.11771353334188461, 0.12481265515089035, -0.48610737919807434, -0.3952449858188629, -0.4247567653656006, -0.03224749118089676, 0.6819382309913635, -0.40449297428131104, 0.48795241117477417, 0.2891956865787506, -0.17824292182922363, -0.455397367477417, -0.7229428291320801, 0.1392289400100708, -0.5671162009239197, -0.6900303363800049, 0.05417982116341591, -0.04312571883201599, -0.37203478813171387, 0.24268598854541779, -0.030621672049164772, -0.23270055651664734, 0.26016169786453247, 0.19995541870594025, 0.5500668287277222, -0.32818517088890076, 0.03563997894525528, -0.05833541974425316, -0.00047496240586042404, 0.3851136267185211, -0.210471510887146, -0.023231158033013344, -0.10836062580347061, -0.2278565615415573, -0.44653403759002686, 0.28025490045547485, 0.4679713547229767, -0.01597212441265583, 0.5289005041122437, 0.42476359009742737, -0.1418912261724472, -0.3742062747478485, -0.44335195422172546, -0.29591014981269836, -0.4577883780002594, 0.32709717750549316, -0.006391150876879692, -1.051716685295105, 0.24441733956336975, -0.12682154774665833, 0.13203629851341248, 0.5107982754707336, 0.40917903184890747, -0.590767502784729, 1.0030900239944458, 0.8158425092697144, -0.3299502730369568, 0.48588815331459045, -0.09499459713697433, 0.2811211049556732, -0.45074447989463806, -0.12812727689743042, -0.8496208786964417, -0.268565833568573, -0.7786965370178223, -0.3997608721256256, 0.20161058008670807, -0.03380151465535164, 0.1316988468170166, -0.03592364117503166, -0.8216673135757446, 0.37486687302589417, 0.580610990524292, -0.0638154000043869, 0.3602326512336731, 0.45262372493743896, 0.13451626896858215, -0.0780043676495552, -0.6647850871086121, -0.7597312927246094, 0.8968784809112549, 0.4851553440093994, 0.4853329360485077, -0.3881355822086334, 0.9616835117340088, 0.7457281947135925, 1.2159674167633057, -0.9743704199790955, 0.6307173371315002, 0.003944495227187872, -0.5564016103744507, -0.26646140217781067, -0.50211501121521, -0.6582903265953064, 0.3012426197528839, -0.3497912883758545, -0.5581582188606262, 0.20540782809257507, -0.03602436184883118, -0.1479896605014801, 0.2748068869113922, -0.7429662346839905, 0.5558793544769287, -0.36426645517349243, 0.16585752367973328, -0.30001938343048096, -0.4667591452598572, 0.5085651874542236, -0.3305833637714386, 0.298452228307724, -0.1457398533821106, 0.19489531219005585, 1.0243028402328491, -0.12002833932638168, 1.092199683189392, -0.27352815866470337, -0.015770502388477325, 0.6738733649253845, -0.12532460689544678, 0.4541953504085541, -0.030791107565164566, -0.17551064491271973, 0.23881705105304718, 0.023996463045477867, -0.14608916640281677, -0.4871576130390167, 0.6517173647880554, -1.1746522188186646, -0.43630099296569824, -1.0377836227416992, -0.21308206021785736, -0.13601867854595184, 0.014278577640652657, 0.3720129728317261, -0.07858971506357193, -0.4472961127758026, 0.23949874937534332, 0.6697453856468201, -0.07152174413204193, 0.38418304920196533, 0.4101870059967041, -0.14476396143436432, -0.513911783695221, 1.0643192529678345, 0.14137493073940277, -0.15526235103607178, 0.43249258399009705, 0.18119962513446808, -0.20378828048706055, -0.7122496962547302, -0.19374720752239227, 0.1260935664176941, -0.7181520462036133, -0.5825827717781067, -0.65467369556427, -0.5067850947380066, -0.1244567409157753, -0.15254156291484833, -0.08342843502759933, -0.2899066209793091, -0.5331426858901978, -0.029367202892899513, 0.5995703339576721, 0.6871677041053772, 0.23852410912513733, 0.4776650071144104, -0.9356741905212402, -0.1615832895040512, 0.16176138818264008, 0.14713053405284882, -0.2846177816390991, -0.32610806822776794, -0.23506081104278564, 0.18974615633487701, -0.6917926073074341, -0.878591775894165, 0.769045352935791, 0.03005066327750683, 0.39386820793151855, 0.2600594162940979, -0.05146520957350731, 0.19583989679813385, -0.021178854629397392, 0.6026039123535156, 0.34691405296325684, -0.7390280365943909, 0.3562459349632263, -0.3376404941082001, -0.3401748239994049, 0.4684913754463196, 0.35715579986572266, -0.6738476157188416, -0.4761844277381897, -0.7493273615837097, -0.4535858631134033, 0.8855003714561462, 0.18447919189929962, -0.08152498304843903, 0.36090025305747986, 0.2043219655752182, 0.21540799736976624, 0.34853848814964294, -0.8886433243751526, 0.28058984875679016, -0.33362945914268494, -0.5436093211174011, -0.10951780527830124, -0.13708794116973877, -0.20819737017154694, 0.08436243236064911, 0.6373605132102966, -0.2520451545715332, 0.27374500036239624, 0.2201378345489502, -0.008387061767280102, -0.14273537695407867, 0.25180283188819885, 0.2444363683462143, 0.11335577070713043, -0.2513097822666168, -0.05484156683087349, 0.16211189329624176, -0.5793157815933228, 0.21540296077728271, -0.16734173893928528, -0.5046607255935669, -0.17173320055007935, 0.35538429021835327, 0.531720757484436, 0.028136393055319786, -0.4314627945423126, 0.28565317392349243, -0.007368897087872028, -0.5341001152992249, -0.3530343174934387, 0.282356321811676, -0.12273881584405899, 0.2402980923652649, 0.36050647497177124, 0.8454535603523254, 0.39780399203300476, -0.31202074885368347, 0.007264464627951384, 0.3240153193473816, -0.19399259984493256, -0.4914681017398834, 0.24723586440086365, 0.4391929805278778, -0.41571158170700073, 0.719399094581604, -0.14835013449192047, -0.5176334381103516, 0.6241020560264587, 0.22039589285850525, 1.2653710842132568, -0.1154945120215416, 0.4930282533168793, 0.059252090752124786, 0.22616857290267944, -0.3801232576370239, 0.11637701094150543, 0.05524638667702675, -0.8616027235984802, -0.5284115672111511, -0.9090553522109985, -0.5197383165359497, -0.09761197865009308, -0.3084510266780853, 0.45776915550231934, -0.39067941904067993, -0.12044176459312439, -0.0068159871734678745, 0.13877154886722565, -0.36466699838638306, 0.30133214592933655, 0.25133511424064636, 0.6834025979042053, -1.0880674123764038, 0.9960163831710815, 0.7462235689163208, -0.1467725932598114, -0.3318616449832916, -0.03559185937047005, 0.15504983067512512, -0.4588482677936554, 0.6350452303886414, 0.24194994568824768, -0.2460051029920578, -0.04764460399746895, -0.8168487548828125, -0.8210704922676086, 0.9917960166931152, 0.04397573694586754, -0.39356929063796997, 0.1716926544904709, -0.048285841941833496, 0.9473090767860413, -0.39628586173057556, 0.11419818550348282, 0.20056433975696564, 0.424815833568573, 0.12553207576274872, -0.4108249247074127, -0.3671727478504181, -0.22764140367507935, -0.016419924795627594, 0.20097039639949799, -0.6552989482879639, 0.6264033317565918, 0.20137867331504822, -0.307773619890213, -0.005583453457802534, 1.09126615524292, 0.3038811683654785, 0.5553956627845764, 0.39588382840156555, 0.35015663504600525, 1.0431065559387207, -0.18586882948875427, 0.9126392602920532, -0.08329533785581589, 0.5605635643005371, 0.617529571056366, -0.4052313268184662, 0.8427059054374695, 0.3475011885166168, -0.46807625889778137, 0.5841924548149109, 0.9522556066513062, -0.31808996200561523, 0.47847115993499756, 0.28995469212532043, -0.6443231701850891, -0.006048760376870632, -0.004261337220668793, -0.1461256444454193, 0.5013701319694519, 0.441254585981369, -0.32049643993377686, -0.008578216657042503, 0.18271271884441376, -0.0765116959810257, 0.05280505120754242, -0.10538095235824585, 0.6002427935600281, 0.28776222467422485, -0.6752562522888184, 0.0658806711435318, 0.25469771027565, 0.9579945206642151, -0.49676138162612915, 0.19636574387550354, -0.16626636683940887, 0.2044527232646942, -0.4241030514240265, -0.8130032420158386, 0.3718318045139313, 0.3020695149898529, -0.13823288679122925, -0.4958077073097229, 0.9987800717353821, 0.014075457118451595, -0.5294448137283325, 0.07072944194078445, 0.3611416518688202, 0.24769003689289093, 0.07077644765377045, -0.8732640147209167, -0.3130376636981964, 0.24345721304416656, -0.5407289862632751, 0.4830574095249176, 0.6866056323051453, -0.336029976606369, 0.7854681611061096, 0.8245983719825745, 0.04436168447136879, -0.14016491174697876, -0.02055000700056553, 0.7240429520606995, -0.8310506939888, -0.49758395552635193, -0.8476663827896118, 0.11429852247238159, -0.33277803659439087, -0.23553049564361572, 0.9731788635253906, 0.45589882135391235, 0.525674045085907, -0.10526485741138458, 1.2038573026657104, -0.1936345100402832, 0.4280206263065338, -0.23819980025291443, 0.6478127837181091, -0.2563689053058624, 0.3533910810947418, -0.07176268100738525, -1.0001063346862793, -0.4056878983974457, 0.5777765512466431, -0.20504894852638245, 0.11893747746944427, 0.9138175845146179, 0.7040229439735413, 0.06652458757162094, 0.6515650153160095, -0.011474250815808773, 0.1394769251346588, 0.374677449464798, 0.14286747574806213, 1.0689398050308228, 0.018574975430965424, 0.4419652223587036, -0.12554408609867096, -0.5266250371932983, -0.39024990797042847, -0.9915138483047485, -0.717576801776886, -0.2583012282848358, -0.39667370915412903, -0.44624388217926025, -0.2147361785173416, 0.8363027572631836, 0.3661550283432007, -0.8601135015487671, -0.3689512610435486, -0.34925827383995056, 0.1934836506843567, -0.14622196555137634, -0.29235607385635376, 0.15898241102695465, -0.39518505334854126, -0.47080203890800476, 0.05609879270195961, 0.4335310459136963, 0.17135919630527496, -0.7277259230613708, -0.07686822861433029, 0.19257551431655884, 0.20697925984859467, 0.5689321160316467, 0.3408336639404297, -0.47554564476013184, -0.36887726187705994, 0.1969199776649475, -0.2829660177230835, 0.21979039907455444, 0.9692500233650208, -0.8463360667228699, 0.1718665510416031, 0.7261221408843994, 0.5040628910064697, 0.3276068866252899, -0.043125271797180176, 0.37434643507003784, -0.5610923767089844, -0.11016262322664261, 0.6747184991836548, 0.04177205637097359, 0.40632879734039307, -0.4859655797481537, 0.4349372982978821, 0.6901475787162781, -0.890641987323761, -0.8720055818557739, -0.09627856314182281, -1.1460808515548706, -0.21155492961406708, 0.7878479957580566, -0.07482392340898514, -0.6403747200965881, -0.004992821719497442, -0.4919273555278778, 0.15129609405994415, -0.4433087706565857, 1.2951595783233643, 0.9262551665306091, -0.29593655467033386, 0.08897437900304794, -0.6268985867500305, 0.6614660620689392, 0.41275933384895325, -1.1249628067016602, -0.02658296748995781, 0.4567790925502777, 0.13081154227256775, 0.3616774380207062, 0.7112234234809875, -0.17386919260025024, 0.11139950901269913, -0.03088296391069889, 0.48966071009635925, 0.260428786277771, -0.17975959181785583, -0.2677915394306183, 0.3629400432109833, 0.2060934156179428, -0.04873479902744293 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04316v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04316v2
Parameter Efficient Quasi-Orthogonal Fine-Tuning via Givens Rotation
2024-04-05T15:28:44
2024-06-07T03:54:01
Xinyu Ma, Xu Chu, Zhibang Yang, Yang Lin, Xin Gao, Junfeng Zhao
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
With the increasingly powerful performances and enormous scales of pretrained models, promoting parameter efficiency in fine-tuning has become a crucial need for effective and efficient adaptation to various downstream tasks. One representative line of fine-tuning methods is Orthogonal Fine-tuning (OFT), which rigorously preserves the angular distances within the parameter space to preserve the pretrained knowledge. Despite the empirical effectiveness, OFT still suffers low parameter efficiency at $\mathcal{O}(d^2)$ and limited capability of downstream adaptation. Inspired by Givens rotation, in this paper, we proposed quasi-Givens Orthogonal Fine-Tuning (qGOFT) to address the problems. We first use $\mathcal{O}(d)$ Givens rotations to accomplish arbitrary orthogonal transformation in $SO(d)$ with provable equivalence, reducing parameter complexity from $\mathcal{O}(d^2)$ to $\mathcal{O}(d)$. Then we introduce flexible norm and relative angular adjustments under soft orthogonality regularization to enhance the adaptation capability of downstream semantic deviations. Extensive experiments on various tasks and pretrained models validate the effectiveness of our methods.
[ -0.4171474874019623, -0.7434698939323425, 0.7473032474517822, -0.3948717415332794, -0.6043319702148438, -0.3008812665939331, -0.5706908106803894, -0.34373706579208374, 0.012968246825039387, 0.24475029110908508, -0.8338831067085266, -0.15016141533851624, -0.4755344092845917, -0.07441475242376328, -0.022400669753551483, 1.190008521080017, -0.030678268522024155, 0.09602541476488113, 0.4535065293312073, -0.522040843963623, -0.26418963074684143, 0.09494940936565399, -0.415611207485199, -0.04087138921022415, 0.6729068756103516, 0.4720393717288971, 1.1023657321929932, 0.7223645448684692, 0.5074189305305481, 0.32939058542251587, 0.13035790622234344, 0.485355019569397, -0.9987767338752747, -0.16804760694503784, -0.3881518542766571, -0.8082490563392639, -0.7679485082626343, 0.09315330535173416, 0.8059011697769165, 0.9017016887664795, -0.2217862755060196, 0.2319866567850113, 0.33446207642555237, 0.9491139054298401, -0.6946057081222534, 0.014341090805828571, -0.8653996586799622, 0.05163552612066269, -0.17545272409915924, -0.19259116053581238, 0.3083409070968628, -0.7020426988601685, -0.06556350737810135, -1.4913647174835205, 0.09968344122171402, 0.12699729204177856, 0.9104313850402832, 0.358357697725296, 0.08049366623163223, -0.08059021085500717, -0.8904833793640137, 1.1955994367599487, -0.695522129535675, 0.9442458152770996, 0.7910742163658142, 0.37651437520980835, -0.11897063255310059, -0.6049118041992188, -0.5922211408615112, -0.21755854785442352, 0.154610276222229, 0.2966248393058777, -0.15035106241703033, 0.37425488233566284, 0.19205941259860992, 0.4040190875530243, -0.3796756863594055, -0.07463443279266357, -0.3321554362773895, -0.036643508821725845, 0.5936223864555359, 0.1877976357936859, -0.1508539319038391, 0.3100976347923279, -0.3330836892127991, -0.5133001804351807, -0.6598562598228455, 0.02456619217991829, 0.5676073431968689, 0.2756364047527313, 0.01370136346668005, 0.34763267636299133, -0.5395328402519226, 0.7907270193099976, 0.6951090097427368, -0.43421661853790283, 0.07160637527704239, -0.32145461440086365, -0.045091837644577026, -0.5523058772087097, 0.30186715722084045, 0.5550627708435059, 0.15539129078388214, -0.25683465600013733, -0.45272621512413025, -0.25939634442329407, 0.4735731780529022, -0.41475021839141846, -0.15627847611904144, -0.06944812089204788, -0.8011055588722229, 0.1181890219449997, 0.14508235454559326, -0.7746709585189819, 0.07807465642690659, -0.9714162945747375, 0.8842157125473022, -0.564070463180542, -0.30250033736228943, 0.4601888656616211, -0.12985390424728394, 0.23970229923725128, 0.3722044825553894, -0.704651951789856, 0.09514538943767548, 0.6542392373085022, 0.5245880484580994, 0.08486318588256836, -0.27151307463645935, -0.5446730256080627, 0.004488606937229633, -0.5863876938819885, 0.6045692563056946, -0.2623431384563446, -0.314285546541214, -0.10786743462085724, -0.5607950091362, -0.19204534590244293, -0.6734440326690674, 0.4287496507167816, -0.6997763514518738, -0.2024134397506714, -0.3249782919883728, -0.15578076243400574, -0.24963778257369995, 0.30137577652931213, -0.11350014060735703, 0.9378295540809631, 0.6549493670463562, -0.3145020604133606, 0.44699326157569885, -0.4573279023170471, -0.16042616963386536, -0.08699106425046921, -0.18599237501621246, -0.5760363340377808, 0.564399242401123, -0.0823274701833725, 0.1536920815706253, -0.507537305355072, 0.2078966647386551, -0.6562318205833435, -0.19342568516731262, -0.1952156126499176, -0.1281789094209671, 0.6175386905670166, 0.5523862838745117, -0.2400505393743515, 0.2783423066139221, -1.0374691486358643, 0.517702579498291, -0.22107462584972382, -0.06708279997110367, -0.5520649552345276, -0.12217766791582108, -0.16548281908035278, -0.10117565840482712, 0.12204379588365555, -0.3140852451324463, 0.408308744430542, -0.3470922112464905, 0.2261965125799179, 0.7137054800987244, -0.33251890540122986, 0.695922315120697, -0.5290236473083496, 0.5561397075653076, -0.2741582989692688, 0.42904961109161377, 0.6257492899894714, -0.09880739450454712, -0.6498546004295349, -0.5881058573722839, 0.2766585052013397, 0.3920440077781677, -1.1095911264419556, 0.47994014620780945, -0.2073003500699997, -0.6766294240951538, -0.37588998675346375, 0.17935164272785187, 0.4682110548019409, 0.6359418034553528, 0.49032196402549744, -0.024718955159187317, -0.34183797240257263, -0.8082644939422607, -0.4592220187187195, -0.2581878900527954, -0.5103560090065002, 0.13240912556648254, -0.18566495180130005, -0.21351417899131775, 0.8185033798217773, -0.7958725094795227, -0.5581308603286743, 0.05682141333818436, 0.374160498380661, 0.18747413158416748, 0.4831044673919678, 0.8894521594047546, -0.48608508706092834, -0.4925692677497864, 0.10658271610736847, -0.4618997871875763, -0.3170761168003082, -0.048058200627565384, -0.4619738757610321, -0.34386733174324036, 0.7597072720527649, -0.3431006669998169, 0.42705515027046204, 0.33009395003318787, -0.30421242117881775, 0.4959582984447479, -0.5652529001235962, 0.18441222608089447, -0.5378784537315369, -0.3108043372631073, -0.2932170629501343, -0.4099990725517273, -0.5117745995521545, 0.13006624579429626, 0.27323874831199646, 0.14145898818969727, -0.14466823637485504, 0.16186155378818512, -0.46469277143478394, 0.41659170389175415, -0.37071287631988525, -0.24951820075511932, -0.3117290735244751, 0.5112209320068359, -0.15735062956809998, 0.6216728091239929, 0.6367385387420654, -0.794434130191803, -0.16077695786952972, 0.11313929408788681, -0.028393913060426712, 1.0318374633789062, -0.532649040222168, 0.19443313777446747, -0.19579598307609558, -0.011881005018949509, -0.6464276909828186, 0.22773753106594086, 0.33917349576950073, -0.06780955940485, 0.29532870650291443, -0.14586377143859863, -0.25414222478866577, 0.26507890224456787, -0.7141432762145996, 0.5828759670257568, 0.7099030613899231, -0.46039125323295593, 0.9492368698120117, 0.11545205116271973, 0.022712284699082375, 0.060194551944732666, -0.17571817338466644, -0.5743748545646667, -0.3378545343875885, -0.659459114074707, 0.5207459926605225, 0.033348746597766876, -0.12988081574440002, -0.09174717962741852, -0.2674408555030823, -0.012458328157663345, -0.06567846238613129, -0.08457127213478088, 0.14910270273685455, -0.6255879998207092, -0.08111247420310974, 0.42735210061073303, -0.24965086579322815, -0.2665931284427643, -0.700569212436676, 0.2668673098087311, -0.2855922281742096, -0.16454771161079407, -0.258709192276001, 0.3279256820678711, 0.42957624793052673, -0.12228558212518692, 0.5685884356498718, 0.8186497092247009, -0.2909667491912842, -0.29870346188545227, -0.602324366569519, -0.2549036145210266, -0.5779576897621155, 0.5814948081970215, -0.32336610555648804, -0.7632933855056763, 0.6052922010421753, -0.21260590851306915, -0.052929285913705826, 0.45489439368247986, 0.2936108708381653, -0.2917448878288269, 1.0018359422683716, 0.7314621210098267, 0.06665666401386261, 0.7624977827072144, -0.4314001798629761, 0.4326770603656769, -0.6972739696502686, 0.3347116708755493, -0.645304262638092, -0.5184319615364075, -0.8290082812309265, -0.40186917781829834, 0.8943018913269043, 0.5233707427978516, -0.10077397525310516, 0.2545604109764099, -0.0595674030482769, 0.2846539616584778, 0.6107845306396484, 0.2509084939956665, 0.093970388174057, -0.17580975592136383, 0.13662166893482208, 0.07344301789999008, -0.8011426329612732, -0.19013313949108124, 0.9420450925827026, 0.166395366191864, 0.8934729695320129, -0.02881685458123684, 0.5562912821769714, -0.055082522332668304, 0.017001420259475708, -0.5099161267280579, 0.4307330548763275, -0.36107227206230164, -0.21386857330799103, -0.4905361235141754, -0.4963763952255249, -0.8596341609954834, 0.16090935468673706, -0.29510021209716797, -0.5758845806121826, 0.5025206804275513, 0.6685428619384766, -0.6493582725524902, 0.1914452612400055, -0.66624915599823, 0.2509162425994873, -0.17311106622219086, -0.4463484287261963, -0.6002559661865234, -0.564026415348053, -0.2223053127527237, -0.05909073352813721, 0.2298588901758194, -0.20329615473747253, -0.030636923387646675, 0.6211733818054199, -0.6736328601837158, 0.5149648785591125, -0.6502549648284912, 0.09795545786619186, 0.2438478171825409, 0.033863939344882965, 0.4581568241119385, 0.47311732172966003, -0.09776671975851059, 0.4932801425457001, 0.16617737710475922, -0.29380732774734497, -0.6521141529083252, 0.44025829434394836, -0.815044641494751, -0.5309072732925415, -0.09723933786153793, -0.8591591119766235, -0.6972792744636536, 0.4946088492870331, 0.3768516778945923, 0.3136749565601349, 0.2772473394870758, 0.15829713642597198, 0.6123803853988647, 0.11583936959505081, 0.07710443437099457, 0.3985820412635803, -0.07803084701299667, -0.26166772842407227, 0.9501597881317139, 0.19309180974960327, 0.3581400513648987, 0.21494160592556, 0.6227492690086365, -0.38531455397605896, -0.9404746294021606, -0.36419010162353516, 0.19240809977054596, -0.2687806785106659, -0.691108226776123, 0.030166171491146088, 0.0783730000257492, -0.1861710399389267, -0.3881843686103821, -0.8138280510902405, -0.5399639010429382, -0.32507526874542236, 0.222675159573555, 0.5054065585136414, 0.40015560388565063, -0.45560988783836365, 0.49467772245407104, -0.8491765856742859, 1.0282925367355347, 0.4705698788166046, 0.8239555954933167, -0.11428236961364746, -0.7610974907875061, -0.12265283614397049, 0.3883523643016815, -0.5302472710609436, -0.3872544765472412, -0.054657306522130966, 0.7340111136436462, 0.6118205785751343, 0.6013587117195129, 0.20386041700839996, 1.0663095712661743, -0.5532055497169495, 0.3666798770427704, 0.185757115483284, -0.7200807929039001, 0.21282123029232025, -0.6868178844451904, 0.12752044200897217, 0.8499274849891663, 0.2319120168685913, 0.0017347931861877441, -0.4452921450138092, -0.34004074335098267, -0.7822265028953552, 0.74139004945755, 0.3346931040287018, 0.11477601528167725, 0.27763140201568604, 0.6252856850624084, 0.4835115373134613, -0.10782428085803986, -0.22817768156528473, -0.254916250705719, -0.37302738428115845, -0.3364574611186981, 0.18314850330352783, -0.060255423188209534, -0.01575286127626896, -0.5549124479293823, 0.723029375076294, -0.2967741787433624, 0.3103193938732147, 0.2957117557525635, -0.21473479270935059, -0.23092368245124817, 0.026579326018691063, 0.5372039675712585, 0.8894158601760864, -0.2064560055732727, -0.023269157856702805, 0.21159356832504272, -0.6239043474197388, 0.02552548050880432, 0.15101954340934753, -0.1820731908082962, -0.3366549015045166, 0.09468786418437958, 0.6385969519615173, 0.08067107200622559, -0.2636445462703705, 0.07691197097301483, -0.009850014932453632, -0.4645099639892578, 0.05403364449739456, 0.446856826543808, -0.21786412596702576, 0.523556649684906, 0.5245383977890015, 0.10167314112186432, 0.241721048951149, -0.2659251093864441, -0.0903473049402237, 0.6045913696289062, -0.2330126166343689, -0.5185441374778748, 0.5407497882843018, -0.11318614333868027, -0.27254652976989746, 0.4477231800556183, -0.38367870450019836, -0.4096624553203583, 0.07009503245353699, 0.3053826689720154, 0.7812677621841431, -0.018375355750322342, -0.2970680594444275, 0.47502127289772034, 0.052931882441043854, -0.20777487754821777, 0.48749828338623047, -0.20877806842327118, -0.7102371454238892, -0.11126305907964706, -0.6476088166236877, 0.07841019332408905, 0.15430216491222382, -0.8728085160255432, 0.27267810702323914, -0.6593749523162842, -0.14248940348625183, 0.013970066793262959, -0.4691909849643707, -0.6774067282676697, 0.18022644519805908, -0.05722789093852043, 0.5983396768569946, -0.614561915397644, 0.8775460124015808, 0.7091935276985168, -0.06466018408536911, -0.8447136282920837, 0.2629289925098419, -0.07935041189193726, -0.8431577682495117, 0.2515382766723633, -0.4824830889701843, -0.6772410273551941, -0.0475684255361557, -0.3109699785709381, -0.9322845935821533, 0.8260993361473083, 0.516427755355835, -0.8018627166748047, 0.18259578943252563, 0.4600520431995392, 0.6364176273345947, 0.2486571967601776, -0.04316708818078041, 0.5013419389724731, 0.5481773018836975, -0.4674256443977356, -1.1819318532943726, -0.32752707600593567, 0.0883500725030899, 0.5122358202934265, 0.5612236261367798, -0.6940025091171265, 0.6635082364082336, 0.03453322872519493, 0.25045984983444214, 0.04426862299442291, 0.9459826350212097, 0.09591331332921982, 0.17635270953178406, 1.1455203294754028, 0.42830219864845276, 0.478805810213089, 0.06493200361728668, 0.682212233543396, -0.04382698982954025, 0.5881648659706116, 0.772829532623291, -0.056239716708660126, 0.5936384201049805, 0.8148517608642578, -0.5428342223167419, -0.009287312626838684, 0.00022661250841338187, 0.41550958156585693, 0.9195745587348938, 0.14341449737548828, 0.21940508484840393, -0.19974201917648315, 0.2712008059024811, -0.4977390468120575, 0.7369986176490784, 0.24121028184890747, 0.1492217779159546, -0.4434526562690735, 0.1979232132434845, -0.197718545794487, 0.33243662118911743, -0.6732125878334045, 0.6866800785064697, -0.022224191576242447, -0.7815052270889282, 1.036392092704773, 0.16743314266204834, 0.8312176465988159, -0.9667600989341736, -0.06501053273677826, -0.22568921744823456, 0.5763391256332397, -0.11505112051963806, -0.3756147027015686, 0.6489569544792175, -0.2935577929019928, -0.4140341281890869, -0.5071985125541687, 0.7594061493873596, -0.3565341830253601, -0.5981783866882324, 0.2775528132915497, 0.26777327060699463, -0.5168006420135498, -0.24054358899593353, -0.5261486768722534, -0.07013943046331406, 0.13701090216636658, -0.1806655377149582, 0.5654157400131226, 0.4474100172519684, -0.21019171178340912, 0.05725257098674774, 0.5292676091194153, 0.07315976917743683, 0.20984439551830292, -0.25906503200531006, 0.8417881727218628, -0.42615270614624023, -0.787102222442627, -0.3821563124656677, 0.21915511786937714, 0.42777833342552185, -0.8015508055686951, 0.4187207520008087, 0.2305925190448761, 1.1812061071395874, -0.2642049789428711, 0.2711731493473053, -0.270145058631897, 0.7214183211326599, -0.9596250653266907, 0.8105248808860779, -0.8299623727798462, 0.07844045013189316, -0.12948600947856903, -0.8780525922775269, -0.09175397455692291, 1.004662036895752, -0.2871568202972412, 0.33797985315322876, 0.5169802904129028, 0.9071269631385803, -0.6453667879104614, 0.06921587884426117, 0.42987868189811707, 0.14681975543498993, 0.000282778637483716, 0.2808851897716522, 0.818409264087677, -0.30222246050834656, 0.32013747096061707, -0.5898541212081909, -0.5241210460662842, -0.20141005516052246, -0.9172642827033997, -0.41814228892326355, -0.7025174498558044, -0.37967514991760254, -0.021889887750148773, 0.2552187144756317, 0.805883526802063, 0.9547403454780579, -0.7943769693374634, -0.045881252735853195, -0.09069165587425232, -0.41159701347351074, -0.6790854334831238, -0.1392698585987091, 0.41426795721054077, -0.4102104902267456, -0.4041456878185272, 0.18112222850322723, 0.19919539988040924, -0.42153188586235046, 0.3455953598022461, -0.10583615303039551, 0.03526768088340759, -0.06267595291137695, 0.5274891257286072, 0.30224254727363586, -0.5980697274208069, -0.6947792768478394, 0.07096540927886963, 0.2128833681344986, 0.21861612796783447, 0.888577401638031, -0.4605337679386139, 0.32644134759902954, 0.4180695712566376, 0.569580614566803, 0.37117499113082886, -0.15204991400241852, 0.5943984389305115, -0.5224562287330627, 0.40774261951446533, 0.5503843426704407, 0.15625585615634918, -0.17117245495319366, -0.34920939803123474, 0.32415515184402466, -0.0970601886510849, -0.4507773816585541, -0.5467921495437622, 0.18672852218151093, -1.0869818925857544, -0.14035554230213165, 1.1269028186798096, -0.1495998203754425, 0.06803598999977112, -0.2207123339176178, -0.4571952521800995, 0.4592674970626831, -0.05437251180410385, 1.010108470916748, 0.1660122126340866, -0.3201182186603546, 0.3829441964626312, -0.26582711935043335, 0.6015759110450745, 0.9302502274513245, -0.6787106394767761, -0.06352449208498001, 0.30271604657173157, 0.3610137104988098, -0.0038871949072927237, 0.41904357075691223, -0.2593006193637848, 0.547603964805603, -0.27634134888648987, -0.39572760462760925, -0.0786200538277626, -0.21442911028862, -0.15074586868286133, -0.3130880892276764, 0.46769237518310547, -0.46331578493118286 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04169v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04169v1
Do Sentence Transformers Learn Quasi-Geospatial Concepts from General Text?
2024-04-05T15:22:02
2024-04-05T15:22:02
Ilya Ilyankou, Aldo Lipani, Stefano Cavazzi, Xiaowei Gao, James Haworth
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
Sentence transformers are language models designed to perform semantic search. This study investigates the capacity of sentence transformers, fine-tuned on general question-answering datasets for asymmetric semantic search, to associate descriptions of human-generated routes across Great Britain with queries often used to describe hiking experiences. We find that sentence transformers have some zero-shot capabilities to understand quasi-geospatial concepts, such as route types and difficulty, suggesting their potential utility for routing recommendation systems.
[ -0.3528718650341034, -0.6928896903991699, 1.0424094200134277, -0.11459365487098694, -0.18266116082668304, -0.5501905679702759, -0.12272454798221588, -0.45335525274276733, 0.3227797746658325, 0.5646911859512329, -1.1040672063827515, -0.424435555934906, -0.1806359440088272, -0.00917336717247963, -1.0177688598632812, 0.9520496129989624, -0.11135319620370865, -0.22108224034309387, -0.26665636897087097, -0.04974832385778427, -0.5198657512664795, -0.5680428743362427, -0.17149461805820465, -0.2629934847354889, 0.5377002954483032, 0.4193504750728607, 1.032892107963562, 0.16629227995872498, 0.4231841564178467, 0.27923494577407837, 0.17648370563983917, -0.12466451525688171, -0.134970024228096, 0.32678288221359253, -0.5180889368057251, -0.577430009841919, 0.40401431918144226, 0.07955299317836761, 0.5429722666740417, 0.854102373123169, -0.1860322505235672, 0.20440693199634552, -0.3927009105682373, 0.20174568891525269, -0.3205440640449524, -0.2140302062034607, -0.718656063079834, 0.14116007089614868, -0.15697966516017914, -0.4308532476425171, -0.1804829090833664, -0.19113734364509583, 0.745215117931366, -0.7256607413291931, 0.9479560852050781, 0.7323732376098633, 0.9886391162872314, 0.027140893042087555, -0.4368239939212799, -0.8045080900192261, -0.810302734375, 0.574099600315094, 0.0006906311609782279, 0.20377960801124573, 0.5581674575805664, 0.5931569337844849, -0.08234335482120514, -0.7205362319946289, -0.5198240280151367, -0.03106747567653656, -0.6243159770965576, -0.01801951229572296, -0.21232108771800995, -0.07195758819580078, 0.17530736327171326, 0.32025015354156494, -0.8205817937850952, 0.0649896189570427, -0.5605170726776123, -0.08017872273921967, 0.5478012561798096, 0.5277654528617859, 0.7918842434883118, -0.7452942132949829, -0.22888796031475067, -0.0803101658821106, -0.6677083373069763, 0.39019086956977844, 0.40688788890838623, 0.37241387367248535, -0.21491828560829163, 0.9030013680458069, -0.3286626935005188, 0.938524067401886, -0.2999861538410187, 0.47129079699516296, -0.02012239582836628, -0.2642030119895935, -0.0035438616760075092, 0.10298361629247665, 0.7907515168190002, 0.28358781337738037, 0.43996378779411316, -0.8253280520439148, -0.03878147527575493, 0.033217478543519974, 0.6142675876617432, -0.4999883472919464, -0.44097191095352173, -0.04187232255935669, -0.23749485611915588, 0.07917390018701553, 0.5110538005828857, -0.6311840415000916, 0.05507159233093262, 0.010908297263085842, 0.45820966362953186, -0.42792147397994995, 0.14861132204532623, 0.487694650888443, -0.761038601398468, 0.4888823628425598, -0.024181989952921867, -1.0095614194869995, 0.22397106885910034, 0.35339099168777466, 0.9412329196929932, 0.31387460231781006, -0.6830770373344421, -0.32978034019470215, 0.11161290854215622, -0.06505721807479858, 1.2360808849334717, -0.7804276347160339, -0.8514776825904846, 0.19298122823238373, 0.4593334197998047, -0.19263646006584167, -0.2194376140832901, 0.7752093076705933, -0.6732339262962341, 0.8120938539505005, -0.25663501024246216, -0.1103978231549263, -0.12990669906139374, 0.11761727929115295, -0.37580570578575134, 1.0090522766113281, 0.19182637333869934, -0.7201985120773315, 0.39483240246772766, -0.5669846534729004, -0.7209061980247498, 0.028069809079170227, -0.11263886839151382, -0.03736277297139168, 0.24572879076004028, 0.5174102783203125, 0.2500236928462982, -0.5180903077125549, 0.2003442645072937, 0.2124169021844864, -0.6705194711685181, 0.1156100258231163, -0.1611635684967041, 0.7211487293243408, -0.083616241812706, -0.48602503538131714, -0.03631233051419258, -0.4487829804420471, 0.1307877153158188, 0.1835002601146698, -0.11323690414428711, -0.6564232707023621, 0.20554150640964508, 0.10170014202594757, 0.05860309675335884, -0.18358378112316132, -0.6678869128227234, 0.47528550028800964, -0.7306174635887146, 0.49091607332229614, 0.6170529127120972, 0.06065318360924721, 0.8605099320411682, -0.0630883276462555, 0.5269809365272522, -0.24661830067634583, 0.12380179017782211, -0.2509596049785614, -0.7049173712730408, -0.965957522392273, 0.3987879753112793, -0.07202474027872086, 0.47482433915138245, -0.858048141002655, 0.5505560636520386, -0.48971444368362427, -0.6327834725379944, -0.44973626732826233, -0.17930415272712708, 0.058263156563043594, 0.5692537426948547, 0.7996846437454224, 0.22059780359268188, -0.4703734219074249, -0.7417442798614502, -0.2833403944969177, -0.16659732162952423, -0.521639883518219, 0.357830673456192, 0.3500955104827881, -0.2837015688419342, 1.1301559209823608, -0.926203727722168, -0.2826935946941376, -0.13879913091659546, 0.21393489837646484, 0.08652627468109131, -0.1059701144695282, 0.6593292355537415, -0.99086993932724, -0.23688673973083496, -0.3897649645805359, -0.6297869682312012, -0.15105175971984863, -0.08522435277700424, -0.21458154916763306, -0.2583777904510498, 0.4481362998485565, -0.99873948097229, 0.25847581028938293, 0.2647086977958679, -1.079993486404419, 0.1423809677362442, -0.24745500087738037, -0.03115358203649521, -0.9345848560333252, -0.14268456399440765, 0.18445350229740143, -0.13204804062843323, -0.39440035820007324, 0.1361096054315567, -0.16210588812828064, -0.298669695854187, -0.32575860619544983, 0.30466023087501526, -0.26302680373191833, -0.2070147693157196, 0.031542956829071045, 0.3709774911403656, 0.026276711374521255, 0.05281785503029823, -0.0027929223142564297, 0.8701174259185791, 0.8273396492004395, -0.5736716985702515, 0.4094972014427185, 0.6386250257492065, -0.14840170741081238, 0.571189284324646, -0.6104326844215393, 0.07220039516687393, -0.3305174708366394, 0.23967304825782776, -1.1131619215011597, -0.29220864176750183, -0.12954328954219818, -0.2945687472820282, -0.4445689022541046, -0.07580571621656418, -0.6527476906776428, -0.7360605597496033, 0.024691293016076088, 0.013385170139372349, 0.5743528008460999, -0.5246250629425049, 0.5385317802429199, 0.049556754529476166, 0.10694656521081924, -0.07176855951547623, -0.7394354939460754, -0.012945175170898438, -0.2864847779273987, -0.4270467162132263, 0.21170920133590698, 0.15316078066825867, 0.1223938912153244, 0.20571213960647583, -0.05727934464812279, 0.08350447565317154, -0.023608237504959106, 0.5635015964508057, 0.28138232231140137, -0.06490781903266907, 0.3793715834617615, -0.3251575231552124, -0.10914275795221329, 0.2074076533317566, -0.6587663888931274, 0.8499460220336914, -0.026585351675748825, -0.2951767146587372, -0.09050221741199493, 0.4347499907016754, 0.18451958894729614, 0.016927339136600494, 0.641291081905365, 0.5487356185913086, 0.0950900986790657, -0.1282884180545807, -0.14098095893859863, -0.12752634286880493, -0.5619105100631714, -0.09491817653179169, -0.40910854935646057, -1.328765869140625, 0.18861700594425201, 0.12092792987823486, -0.40482932329177856, 0.8834518194198608, 0.06181623041629791, -0.5181477069854736, 0.49750903248786926, 0.8185058832168579, -0.19858349859714508, 0.014724042266607285, -0.34674370288848877, 0.574310302734375, -0.33061692118644714, -0.33881503343582153, -0.7947103381156921, -0.36636024713516235, -1.0121514797210693, -0.22030335664749146, 0.365486741065979, 0.015925947576761246, -0.4751060903072357, 0.5701119303703308, -0.4814046323299408, 0.615591824054718, 0.719994068145752, -0.07963154464960098, -0.1577310860157013, 0.10264812409877777, -0.12173604965209961, 0.06940468400716782, -0.6558623909950256, -0.28471118211746216, 0.8410424590110779, -0.31319233775138855, 0.7801346778869629, 0.16655433177947998, 0.26512178778648376, 0.31887561082839966, -0.26104623079299927, -0.7611920833587646, 0.5391079783439636, -0.30816179513931274, -0.5158998370170593, -0.41196340322494507, -0.2972187101840973, -0.9350526332855225, -0.25078919529914856, -0.3850676417350769, -0.8438144326210022, -0.14545360207557678, -0.09924814105033875, -0.41232579946517944, 0.34918323159217834, -0.7977200150489807, 0.6888222694396973, -0.42570826411247253, 0.3425890803337097, 0.0938337966799736, -0.8768770098686218, -0.3087683320045471, 0.23059654235839844, -0.20076805353164673, 0.10415514558553696, 0.2818154990673065, 0.5332005023956299, 0.0008286551455967128, 0.475798636674881, -0.22290673851966858, 0.34932902455329895, 0.3561399281024933, 0.07657087594270706, 0.2540820837020874, -0.16926638782024384, 0.08144602924585342, 0.11239387840032578, -0.158628910779953, -0.13534937798976898, -0.815822958946228, 0.6486836075782776, -0.8525807857513428, -0.70970219373703, -0.1515057235956192, -0.3917943239212036, -0.21497057378292084, 0.16402468085289001, 0.4926298260688782, 0.4088238477706909, -0.11930716037750244, 0.13060128688812256, 0.28566932678222656, -0.38245561718940735, 0.44051405787467957, 0.4610563814640045, -0.1506684273481369, 0.034591272473335266, 0.5184040665626526, -0.031070245429873466, 0.1326836496591568, 0.718981146812439, 0.23612330853939056, -0.5461497902870178, -0.15292593836784363, -0.3689230680465698, 0.03465432673692703, -0.5769323110580444, -0.15240217745304108, -0.9249405264854431, -0.21293571591377258, -0.2127542495727539, -0.6038874983787537, 0.28088751435279846, -0.4819031357765198, -0.30935174226760864, -0.43126988410949707, 0.6652997136116028, 0.8848395943641663, 0.35842618346214294, 0.7962373495101929, -0.4680992662906647, 0.6372281908988953, 0.2941615879535675, 0.2656938433647156, -0.42614686489105225, -0.3321170210838318, -0.21522915363311768, -0.05240492895245552, -0.3563290238380432, -0.6104609370231628, 0.2262023389339447, 0.2604134976863861, 0.4688842296600342, 0.22627629339694977, -0.07919128984212875, 0.8743306398391724, -1.0151909589767456, 1.2814724445343018, 0.34885266423225403, -0.6791623830795288, 0.8708387613296509, -0.46837785840034485, 0.3528346121311188, 0.3649196922779083, 0.831941545009613, -0.6989246606826782, -0.26468050479888916, -0.6300768256187439, -0.8761831521987915, 0.6515088677406311, 0.11452866345643997, 0.48614704608917236, -0.1662609726190567, 0.5621157288551331, -0.07718917727470398, 0.06668607890605927, -0.5778258442878723, -0.22045376896858215, -0.5532187223434448, -0.068352110683918, -0.6541653275489807, -0.2477429360151291, 0.0648135170340538, -0.20406028628349304, 0.1972171515226364, -0.03935343772172928, 0.343885213136673, 0.349963515996933, -0.09732499718666077, -0.14548653364181519, 0.7022275328636169, 0.2170470505952835, 0.40883100032806396, -0.3591407537460327, 0.4359329640865326, 0.06211380288004875, -0.2739258408546448, 0.4926126003265381, 0.1553470939397812, -0.47552573680877686, 0.10938313603401184, 0.16922973096370697, 0.6089444160461426, 0.14517700672149658, -0.5237582921981812, 0.4572870433330536, 0.000008973112926469184, -0.15495407581329346, -0.1876930147409439, 0.3349432051181793, 0.1438143402338028, 0.24888789653778076, 0.4902370870113373, 0.13003256916999817, 0.44295284152030945, -0.7999343872070312, 0.3675990104675293, 0.4576829969882965, -0.568832278251648, -0.5543617010116577, 0.7241332530975342, 0.06224130466580391, -0.5762491822242737, 0.9114649295806885, 0.07901997119188309, -0.5622299313545227, 0.1800030767917633, 0.5526291728019714, 1.0013576745986938, -0.010791649110615253, 0.5274834632873535, 0.19107095897197723, 0.5198409557342529, -0.14692816138267517, 0.0053412215784192085, -0.16235636174678802, -0.59322589635849, -0.07049481570720673, -0.9174367785453796, -0.11073262244462967, -0.27394986152648926, -0.5899320244789124, 0.47694551944732666, -0.0831451565027237, -0.05639898031949997, -0.05158020555973053, -0.4305059313774109, -1.0525619983673096, 0.3874446749687195, -0.050724368542432785, 0.8307346105575562, -0.9929320812225342, 0.5001884698867798, 0.8868558406829834, -0.5881420373916626, -0.8045485615730286, 0.49565133452415466, -0.44027361273765564, -0.5472614169120789, 0.7595261931419373, 0.28799962997436523, -0.5437836647033691, -0.1769362986087799, -0.4221477806568146, -0.6291513442993164, 1.0879474878311157, 0.1464948207139969, -0.1459246575832367, -0.7219520807266235, 0.6749082803726196, 0.8122387528419495, -0.41139253973960876, 0.34536582231521606, 0.26821041107177734, 0.07415314018726349, 0.043651919811964035, -0.9218205809593201, -0.13488036394119263, 0.018782759085297585, 0.12666736543178558, 0.22808782756328583, -0.3569403886795044, 0.7854493856430054, 0.13332746922969818, -0.345627099275589, 0.24786032736301422, 0.22701367735862732, -0.28722360730171204, 0.1765040159225464, 0.4217991530895233, 0.6925784349441528, 0.3911641240119934, -0.24238243699073792, 1.3321722745895386, 0.05474786460399628, 0.49195119738578796, 0.9627176523208618, -0.2606046199798584, 0.9436955451965332, 0.44137611985206604, 0.06870143115520477, 1.086060643196106, 0.4645474851131439, 0.148530974984169, 0.939202606678009, 0.09621040523052216, -0.007591851055622101, -0.3357522189617157, 0.08882054686546326, -0.01560921873897314, 0.739214301109314, 0.16451606154441833, -0.2954241633415222, -0.6386317014694214, 0.09351595491170883, -0.20668266713619232, 0.1039755716919899, -0.40861082077026367, 0.6238399744033813, -0.18998979032039642, -0.657274603843689, 0.2885965406894684, 0.01629737764596939, 0.5544543862342834, -0.813448429107666, 0.11637765169143677, 0.0006267893477343023, -0.14680252969264984, -0.13169245421886444, -1.2013263702392578, 0.5865711569786072, 0.02120019495487213, -0.32138851284980774, -0.40209251642227173, 0.6990610957145691, -0.1508522480726242, -0.5042006373405457, 0.2603001594543457, 0.4775671362876892, -0.07017923891544342, -0.09155334532260895, -0.3677797019481659, -0.631852388381958, -0.09907635301351547, -0.07000307738780975, -0.018482781946659088, 0.5676880478858948, 0.02482645772397518, 0.7069764137268066, 0.4410308599472046, 0.09620688110589981, 0.1117071807384491, -0.09184978902339935, 0.9497165083885193, -1.1692591905593872, -0.792445957660675, -0.7220755219459534, 0.44852960109710693, 0.07076503336429596, -0.19148564338684082, 0.9599763751029968, 0.5872450470924377, 1.0673776865005493, -0.18330930173397064, 0.7573683261871338, -0.06875979155302048, 0.49793434143066406, -0.8033931851387024, 0.3650067448616028, -0.43236178159713745, 0.10658286511898041, 0.03903134912252426, -0.9411895275115967, -0.16556531190872192, 0.5935550928115845, -0.7722827196121216, -0.23149314522743225, 0.8410741686820984, 0.7368345856666565, -0.5988081693649292, 0.13821808993816376, 0.0569625124335289, -0.3838277757167816, 0.30105459690093994, 0.3890824317932129, 0.9770245552062988, -0.5730259418487549, 0.5620977282524109, 0.13887566328048706, 0.36621129512786865, 0.18307775259017944, -0.33935487270355225, -0.9826372265815735, -0.8383297920227051, 0.3247531056404114, -0.14509941637516022, 0.1698625534772873, 0.4541110098361969, 0.6410905122756958, -0.5402805805206299, -0.17334112524986267, -0.5007388591766357, -0.19771264493465424, 0.42331206798553467, -0.314018189907074, 0.349116712808609, -0.407280832529068, -0.17727360129356384, 0.3988218605518341, 0.48074984550476074, -0.021387221291661263, -0.4098190367221832, 0.19201552867889404, -0.25765204429626465, 0.01378619484603405, 0.4969099164009094, -0.03515163064002991, -0.6914961934089661, -0.7049268484115601, 0.4013788402080536, 0.10766951739788055, -0.03564365953207016, 1.280084252357483, -0.9157660007476807, 0.4665456712245941, 0.1865483671426773, 0.4227992594242096, 0.38485538959503174, 0.13355761766433716, 0.3710069954395294, -1.008068323135376, 0.558927059173584, 0.005170542746782303, 0.31119537353515625, 0.49090030789375305, -0.4176660478115082, 0.47333696484565735, 0.2786634564399719, -0.48816701769828796, -0.21423035860061646, 0.35934555530548096, -0.7023822069168091, -0.10084744542837143, 1.4049113988876343, 0.06874999403953552, -0.21367773413658142, 0.02062254399061203, -0.1551322489976883, -0.10874224454164505, 0.06869596987962723, 0.6563833355903625, 0.5353010892868042, -0.09440264850854874, -0.18781615793704987, -0.6720789670944214, 0.3332892656326294, 0.007188088726252317, -0.5921345353126526, -0.3635207414627075, 0.5379517078399658, 0.39873865246772766, 0.41331973671913147, 0.4900040626525879, 0.3616536259651184, -0.06728656589984894, -0.3389829695224762, -0.2578442096710205, 0.4073949158191681, -0.45837894082069397, 0.1183621734380722, 0.19512124359607697, -0.018994711339473724, -0.12735812366008759 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04167v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04167v3
Chinese Tiny LLM: Pretraining a Chinese-Centric Large Language Model
2024-04-05T15:20:02
2024-04-09T10:48:19
Xinrun Du, Zhouliang Yu, Songyang Gao, Ding Pan, Yuyang Cheng, Ziyang Ma, Ruibin Yuan, Xingwei Qu, Jiaheng Liu, Tianyu Zheng, Xinchen Luo, Guorui Zhou, Binhang Yuan, Wenhu Chen, Jie Fu, Ge Zhang
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
In this study, we introduce CT-LLM, a 2B large language model (LLM) that illustrates a pivotal shift towards prioritizing the Chinese language in developing LLMs. Uniquely initiated from scratch, CT-LLM diverges from the conventional methodology by primarily incorporating Chinese textual data, utilizing an extensive corpus of 1,200 billion tokens, including 800 billion Chinese tokens, 300 billion English tokens, and 100 billion code tokens. This strategic composition facilitates the model's exceptional proficiency in understanding and processing Chinese, a capability further enhanced through alignment techniques. Demonstrating remarkable performance on the CHC-Bench, CT-LLM excels in Chinese language tasks, and showcases its adeptness in English through SFT. This research challenges the prevailing paradigm of training LLMs predominantly on English corpora and then adapting them to other languages, broadening the horizons for LLM training methodologies. By open-sourcing the full process of training a Chinese LLM, including a detailed data processing procedure with the obtained Massive Appropriate Pretraining Chinese Corpus (MAP-CC), a well-chosen multidisciplinary Chinese Hard Case Benchmark (CHC-Bench), and the 2B-size Chinese Tiny LLM (CT-LLM), we aim to foster further exploration and innovation in both academia and industry, paving the way for more inclusive and versatile language models.
[ 0.0005681649199686944, -0.5973600745201111, 0.44393712282180786, 0.206255704164505, -0.3375963270664215, 0.14574986696243286, -0.7950416207313538, -0.3232154846191406, 0.01315754372626543, 0.28582432866096497, -0.289075642824173, -0.39948010444641113, -0.4541701078414917, -0.08246419578790665, -0.10155870020389557, 0.7744459509849548, 0.2117006480693817, 0.5132046341896057, 0.2573069930076599, -0.17385806143283844, -0.4165307879447937, -0.5527573823928833, -1.0029610395431519, -0.20273073017597198, 0.7096156477928162, 0.552580714225769, 0.6476306319236755, 1.03054940700531, 0.47711530327796936, 0.182439923286438, 0.010050510987639427, 0.029699046164751053, -0.5319331288337708, -0.6271470189094543, 0.10797262191772461, -0.7066888809204102, -0.6297129392623901, 0.12024462223052979, 0.7552993893623352, 0.8377850651741028, 0.00023818253248464316, 0.15943554043769836, 0.23069462180137634, 0.4862285554409027, -0.4200669229030609, 0.05694729462265968, -0.8873807191848755, 0.020608024671673775, -0.5807159543037415, -0.023535504937171936, -0.5995312333106995, -0.23495513200759888, 0.0626412108540535, -0.5090783834457397, 0.08841709047555923, 0.04833456501364708, 0.5242453217506409, 0.1488974392414093, -0.40297654271125793, -0.07083051651716232, -0.49507269263267517, 0.7576606273651123, -0.6442095637321472, 0.3331645131111145, 0.08800788223743439, 0.25341105461120605, 0.12614895403385162, -0.9129369258880615, -0.3281448781490326, -0.4058808982372284, 0.05487768352031708, 0.08951938152313232, 0.32173046469688416, 0.12746377289295197, 0.02237989753484726, 0.3239521384239197, -0.7022972702980042, 0.7003801465034485, -0.2874135375022888, -0.23956410586833954, 0.639664888381958, 0.19098728895187378, 0.3613470494747162, 0.1935914307832718, -0.37471896409988403, 0.09429331868886948, -1.1821285486221313, 0.04523908346891403, 0.12178728729486465, 0.7067129015922546, -0.24342447519302368, 0.3705390691757202, 0.20454467833042145, 0.6660938858985901, 0.007823478430509567, -0.05788443982601166, -0.03465764597058296, -0.5326526165008545, -0.24589072167873383, 0.2439538985490799, 0.8489436507225037, -0.05289105325937271, 0.14180666208267212, 0.03890493884682655, -0.3559097945690155, -0.2893845736980438, 0.005576539319008589, -0.7984437942504883, -0.27838432788848877, 0.18034644424915314, -0.5610164999961853, -0.10307434946298599, 0.02331334538757801, -0.1966053694486618, -0.41329729557037354, -0.3720604479312897, 0.19943051040172577, -0.3205624520778656, -0.36844369769096375, -0.14244788885116577, 0.28614485263824463, 0.5476612448692322, 0.2928197979927063, -1.1195721626281738, -0.07469257712364197, 0.8250613808631897, 0.9630125164985657, -0.45956969261169434, -0.32548218965530396, -0.4053798317909241, 0.17724160850048065, -0.6752117872238159, 0.6415590047836304, -0.25039488077163696, -0.39072665572166443, 0.17788174748420715, 0.09343337267637253, -0.0544634647667408, -0.5647296905517578, 0.33003196120262146, -0.339915007352829, 0.07190420478582382, -0.15802419185638428, -0.2014876753091812, 0.17500318586826324, 0.5147351026535034, -0.7557030320167542, 0.9605866074562073, -0.04140256345272064, -0.6398120522499084, 0.22600258886814117, -0.5194751620292664, -0.5134450197219849, 0.26012134552001953, -0.36488842964172363, -0.10922015458345413, 0.08068414032459259, -0.07830765843391418, 0.3826759457588196, -0.552119791507721, 0.08157437294721603, -0.30346766114234924, -0.5744419097900391, -0.061012256890535355, -0.3575741648674011, 0.9147874116897583, 0.33898138999938965, -0.026476023718714714, 0.35865142941474915, -0.5613164901733398, 0.06294773519039154, 0.3175690770149231, -0.4547637104988098, -0.33311453461647034, -0.23343196511268616, 0.2337646782398224, 0.402204692363739, 0.8561769127845764, -0.2693501114845276, 0.27207547426223755, -0.733049750328064, 0.638627290725708, 0.7172548770904541, -0.5167374610900879, 0.6338320970535278, -0.17673712968826294, 0.33380791544914246, 0.08963996917009354, 0.16759835183620453, -0.10560085624456406, -0.05997830629348755, -0.8944197297096252, -0.20500077307224274, 0.5692012310028076, 0.5145527720451355, -0.7634990811347961, 0.29628416895866394, -0.37277910113334656, -0.5571093559265137, -0.6734132766723633, 0.19503861665725708, 0.2928571105003357, -0.0038881786167621613, 0.049254197627305984, -0.2377919852733612, -0.5409300327301025, -0.8110098242759705, -0.04800625890493393, -0.24967707693576813, -0.14851735532283783, -0.08698615431785583, 0.14366289973258972, -0.05312447249889374, 0.6732912659645081, -0.34221896529197693, -0.39682117104530334, -0.8786464929580688, -0.17368285357952118, 0.19330938160419464, 0.524478554725647, 0.4503411054611206, -0.6671227812767029, -0.7473312616348267, 0.29746103286743164, -0.305874764919281, 0.04166862741112709, -0.21163204312324524, -0.07312820106744766, 0.2603384852409363, 0.7828046679496765, -0.36338236927986145, 0.029243506491184235, 0.5265768766403198, 0.010507560335099697, 0.5621018409729004, -0.3264886140823364, -0.32582059502601624, -1.181710124015808, -0.02053280733525753, -0.24489203095436096, -0.018431099131703377, -0.634399950504303, 0.16991779208183289, 0.32637184858322144, 0.08301983028650284, -0.8055068850517273, 0.6818621158599854, -0.6541668176651001, 0.025929275900125504, -0.5154027342796326, 0.3953108787536621, -0.45563966035842896, 0.5410107374191284, 0.23103448748588562, 0.8130736351013184, 0.3535301089286804, -0.4984133839607239, 0.13375431299209595, -0.03956054151058197, -0.10921615362167358, 0.136842742562294, -0.5265446901321411, 0.20325379073619843, 0.263806015253067, 0.03294841945171356, -0.9767084717750549, 0.08090344816446304, -0.027463434264063835, -0.26409247517585754, 0.5531768798828125, -0.025420313701033592, -0.7327191233634949, -0.3938368856906891, -0.43712639808654785, 0.5712031722068787, 0.35023659467697144, -0.5465562343597412, 0.24465447664260864, 0.3629949390888214, -0.15912239253520966, -0.39424920082092285, -0.8378230333328247, 0.05048571527004242, -0.14190582931041718, -0.4338172674179077, 0.288282573223114, -0.2463814616203308, -0.038645029067993164, -0.31337296962738037, -0.024106279015541077, -0.2363630086183548, 0.31156930327415466, -0.09526749700307846, 0.4565832316875458, -0.5355104207992554, 0.07343655824661255, -0.24510103464126587, -0.15447917580604553, -0.11140080541372299, -0.6555661559104919, 0.6902241110801697, -0.051351774483919144, -0.19568155705928802, -0.24587738513946533, -0.16539740562438965, 0.1738918274641037, -0.20687204599380493, 0.6348702311515808, 0.6903355717658997, -0.4308401346206665, -0.26418161392211914, -0.36784496903419495, -0.08803992718458176, -0.4554668366909027, 0.6526349782943726, -0.20307108759880066, -1.1207191944122314, 0.3216148316860199, -0.10267416387796402, 0.260231614112854, 0.3887082636356354, 0.9319003820419312, 0.12460663914680481, 0.8247396945953369, 1.0661002397537231, -0.48596394062042236, 0.6619553565979004, -0.06098754331469536, 0.23831994831562042, -0.5866806507110596, 0.19717088341712952, -0.3664546012878418, -0.1808554083108902, -0.7873054146766663, -0.5958572626113892, 0.16971446573734283, -0.04305917024612427, -0.39154934883117676, 0.40241050720214844, -0.2866005003452301, 0.5018287301063538, 0.4429900646209717, -0.0566895492374897, 0.26307398080825806, -0.3671657145023346, -0.18542204797267914, -0.03342229872941971, -0.8479907512664795, -0.5532965064048767, 1.2654855251312256, 0.30512720346450806, 0.38419845700263977, -0.05510542541742325, 0.45789581537246704, -0.001963275484740734, 0.4210907816886902, -0.89628666639328, 0.547514021396637, -0.5713618993759155, -0.5525317788124084, -0.42322838306427, -0.10096574574708939, -0.8651363253593445, 0.3702968955039978, 0.13981065154075623, -0.42270126938819885, -0.43099406361579895, 0.043751005083322525, -0.6253471374511719, 0.1833864003419876, -0.6852828860282898, 1.0769267082214355, -0.655790388584137, -0.37447404861450195, -0.2758518159389496, -0.7266680598258972, 0.6064988970756531, -0.4606736898422241, 0.1492447555065155, 0.0552901029586792, -0.33546167612075806, 0.7626075148582458, -0.3171262741088867, 0.8104673027992249, 0.020094094797968864, -0.18137282133102417, 0.3680395781993866, -0.10415317863225937, 0.44151899218559265, -0.0167688075453043, -0.05852552130818367, 0.2982487976551056, 0.005251787602901459, -0.5278408527374268, -0.17627935111522675, 0.517320454120636, -0.8641337156295776, -0.7974047660827637, -0.3938184380531311, -0.40523386001586914, -0.19591322541236877, 0.533801794052124, 0.3369331359863281, -0.08814756572246552, -0.4447479844093323, 0.32476305961608887, 0.5915679931640625, -0.3889816999435425, 0.5594639182090759, 0.664212703704834, -0.10789289325475693, -0.16752490401268005, 0.7865279912948608, 0.34579506516456604, 0.3919360339641571, 0.6752192974090576, 0.18756286799907684, -0.20255035161972046, -0.9516668319702148, -0.2489016205072403, 0.27080678939819336, -0.32632946968078613, 0.08874912559986115, -0.39814066886901855, -0.569834291934967, -0.48443061113357544, -0.08817573636770248, -0.6851921081542969, -0.21795502305030823, -0.278425931930542, -0.1086360514163971, -0.23218023777008057, 0.4691234230995178, -0.0008804172393865883, 0.589226245880127, -0.7269461750984192, 0.09906556457281113, 0.1601269394159317, 0.18308261036872864, 0.0016287561738863587, -0.7786037921905518, -0.8075977563858032, 0.05782848969101906, -0.3561543822288513, -0.21355536580085754, 0.3435027301311493, -0.19513314962387085, 0.5310211181640625, 0.5559086203575134, -0.07087287306785583, 0.6819605231285095, -0.5937513113021851, 1.0847057104110718, 0.2749132812023163, -0.6921489238739014, 0.40116629004478455, -0.38776782155036926, 0.3322409689426422, 0.5200942158699036, 0.057364050298929214, -0.6279430389404297, -0.25505006313323975, -0.3548790216445923, -0.8085120320320129, 1.0016613006591797, -0.14808766543865204, 0.06441070139408112, 0.0954601913690567, 0.16654667258262634, 0.0908740684390068, 0.18059535324573517, -0.9984617233276367, -0.17790637910366058, -0.012914814054965973, -0.33716049790382385, -0.14405317604541779, -0.43846139311790466, -0.015157760120928288, -0.20988285541534424, 0.5583477020263672, -0.44516265392303467, 0.15595947206020355, -0.23148761689662933, -0.2628647983074188, 0.1323409229516983, 0.18417322635650635, 0.49406033754348755, 0.563185453414917, 0.10772880166769028, 0.028996463865041733, 0.4036789834499359, -0.5675778985023499, -0.03568816930055618, -0.03644942119717598, -0.05330178141593933, -0.25086551904678345, 0.4990997910499573, 0.46932730078697205, 0.2207772582769394, -0.7353941202163696, 0.6170012950897217, -0.0021668707486242056, -0.0666634663939476, -0.5852433443069458, -0.010159887373447418, 0.3064121901988983, 0.07977291196584702, 0.2771797478199005, -0.4867931008338928, -0.18952029943466187, -0.46531373262405396, 0.009273305535316467, 0.438975989818573, -0.42681580781936646, -0.4872891306877136, 0.751509964466095, 0.29674023389816284, 0.03609529882669449, 0.5623343586921692, -0.05765172839164734, -0.40486443042755127, 0.7262592911720276, 0.424638569355011, 0.9476876854896545, -0.15197201073169708, -0.109084852039814, 0.363887220621109, 0.6458225250244141, -0.3869796693325043, 0.03976791352033615, 0.13031738996505737, -0.7419871687889099, -0.2032342553138733, -0.4352300465106964, -0.3252342939376831, 0.3171992003917694, -0.36324042081832886, 0.716814398765564, -0.8069354891777039, 0.18516941368579865, -0.382119745016098, 0.45410698652267456, -0.6647607088088989, 0.16617269814014435, 0.5132482647895813, 1.1392316818237305, -0.4973979890346527, 1.5093822479248047, 0.692085862159729, -0.45145413279533386, -1.0867091417312622, 0.14305655658245087, 0.12914782762527466, -1.152626872062683, 0.633115291595459, 0.2868305742740631, 0.2282833456993103, 0.06836125999689102, -0.6301313638687134, -0.792739987373352, 1.3414483070373535, 0.350055992603302, -0.8444841504096985, -0.0874212235212326, 0.3312634825706482, 0.6790047287940979, -0.4665530025959015, 0.32580479979515076, 0.8206965923309326, 0.40185263752937317, 0.00465981662273407, -0.9043436050415039, -0.015193482860922813, 0.024526266381144524, 0.24212411046028137, -0.06548139452934265, -1.353042721748352, 0.9693402051925659, -0.3408617377281189, -0.3108145594596863, 0.3567177355289459, 0.7070338129997253, 0.35854992270469666, 0.17871826887130737, 0.443986713886261, 0.1729939579963684, 0.6778308749198914, -0.23584692180156708, 0.63167405128479, -0.5095583200454712, -0.04149717837572098, 1.1402252912521362, -0.41109415888786316, 0.9247364401817322, 0.4280582070350647, -0.11183580756187439, 0.0655955821275711, 1.0619786977767944, 0.1080498918890953, 0.4086324870586395, 0.2308669537305832, -0.10551673918962479, -0.30457603931427, -0.141826331615448, -0.4125170111656189, 0.5338040590286255, 0.35254427790641785, -0.1219632625579834, 0.023180918768048286, -0.256656676530838, 0.09260550141334534, 0.03564608842134476, -0.5518900156021118, 0.7433828711509705, 0.3659072816371918, -0.40955987572669983, 0.3932419717311859, 0.18114158511161804, 0.9956633448600769, -0.837151288986206, 0.441285103559494, -0.42085814476013184, 0.19320853054523468, -0.09795736521482468, -0.5148506164550781, 0.030985010787844658, 0.040790800005197525, -0.013302774168550968, -0.29267755150794983, 0.4590386152267456, -0.6215999722480774, -0.3675841689109802, 0.3204202651977539, 0.603975772857666, 0.08691252768039703, -0.0077711306512355804, -0.6389458179473877, 0.06652191281318665, 0.16369734704494476, -0.2376924455165863, 0.6046236157417297, 0.8344889879226685, -0.2808719277381897, 0.44455352425575256, 0.6096500754356384, 0.3796294033527374, -0.11996665596961975, 0.11076179891824722, 0.650884747505188, -0.970171332359314, -0.7255883812904358, -0.9359631538391113, 0.29965320229530334, 0.18735291063785553, -0.19816792011260986, 0.7287799119949341, 0.7256951928138733, 1.1631799936294556, -0.11073404550552368, 0.9068307280540466, 0.04543894901871681, 0.2352520227432251, -0.4805961549282074, 0.9520545601844788, -0.5548259019851685, 0.40320712327957153, 0.08866274356842041, -0.8167046308517456, -0.3241419196128845, 0.18487587571144104, -0.3387318253517151, 0.031517524272203445, 0.7454499006271362, 0.649152398109436, 0.28196367621421814, -0.13723593950271606, 0.5182213187217712, 0.42995426058769226, 0.32662636041641235, 0.9931375980377197, 0.799933671951294, -0.24333429336547852, 0.8540664911270142, -0.04166392236948013, -0.11031345278024673, -0.2998572289943695, -0.7769076228141785, -0.8922578692436218, -0.34589171409606934, -0.07484597712755203, 0.13022062182426453, -0.19171708822250366, 1.2072612047195435, 0.5886439085006714, -0.8976055383682251, -0.5135645270347595, 0.09218016266822815, 0.17251372337341309, -0.20332491397857666, -0.15076322853565216, 0.40706759691238403, -0.4851130545139313, -0.9257016777992249, 0.275978684425354, 0.4247298538684845, 0.19415247440338135, -0.31136929988861084, -0.13179948925971985, -0.060952018946409225, -0.08690743148326874, 0.7496649622917175, 0.2743203938007355, -0.6948460936546326, -0.2277933657169342, -0.014208579435944557, -0.6602288484573364, 0.08782429993152618, 0.9724074602127075, -0.5156872272491455, 0.12616369128227234, 0.23300224542617798, 0.8953096270561218, 0.0969371423125267, -0.3779650032520294, 0.6264910101890564, -0.7574542760848999, 0.6298089027404785, 0.10594187676906586, 0.30055901408195496, 0.36616185307502747, -0.31987395882606506, 0.6155908107757568, 0.25666266679763794, -0.3393036425113678, -0.8758350014686584, -0.024250103160738945, -1.0384080410003662, -0.3810252547264099, 1.2466700077056885, -0.058047786355018616, -0.13139498233795166, 0.08007044345140457, -0.2820504307746887, 0.38643744587898254, -0.09659136831760406, 0.592818021774292, 0.8232214450836182, 0.24792379140853882, -0.17645420134067535, -0.45104900002479553, 0.4088493287563324, 0.3839750289916992, -0.5911017060279846, 0.297483891248703, 0.19089484214782715, 0.2348909080028534, -0.17498664557933807, 0.8951016664505005, -0.1976001262664795, 0.29646003246307373, -0.09315747022628784, 0.10664497315883636, -0.0043348935432732105, -0.37380313873291016, -0.3589513897895813, 0.09232524782419205, 0.5233027338981628, -0.2059890329837799 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04163v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04163v1
Dwell in the Beginning: How Language Models Embed Long Documents for Dense Retrieval
2024-04-05T15:16:16
2024-04-05T15:16:16
João Coelho, Bruno Martins, João Magalhães, Jamie Callan, Chenyan Xiong
cs.IR
cs.IR, cs.CL
This study investigates the existence of positional biases in Transformer-based models for text representation learning, particularly in the context of web document retrieval. We build on previous research that demonstrated loss of information in the middle of input sequences for causal language models, extending it to the domain of representation learning. We examine positional biases at various stages of training for an encoder-decoder model, including language model pre-training, contrastive pre-training, and contrastive fine-tuning. Experiments with the MS-MARCO document collection reveal that after contrastive pre-training the model already generates embeddings that better capture early contents of the input, with fine-tuning further aggravating this effect.
[ -0.4960983395576477, -0.5633792877197266, 0.8253769874572754, 0.10967282950878143, -0.2054450660943985, -0.20475788414478302, -0.20168545842170715, -0.17642489075660706, 0.06614144146442413, 0.43305402994155884, -0.2584485113620758, -0.17356345057487488, -0.988417387008667, -0.04069514200091362, -0.6797236204147339, 0.7504688501358032, -0.1047731414437294, 0.13797339797019958, -0.3526492118835449, -0.04017675295472145, -0.5319629907608032, -0.554693341255188, -0.5477314591407776, -0.5109142661094666, 0.5499194264411926, 0.1707475483417511, 0.9504691958427429, 0.49439090490341187, 0.1517311930656433, 0.1797872632741928, -0.055102039128541946, -0.3189181685447693, -0.7343229651451111, 0.38784754276275635, -0.05475591868162155, -0.6743483543395996, 0.4900091588497162, 0.0751359835267067, 0.7241492867469788, 0.8934972286224365, -0.17009791731834412, -0.3075528144836426, 0.1736641526222229, 0.4274146556854248, -0.7336643934249878, -0.04354606941342354, -0.4556885361671448, 0.11596821248531342, -0.20158503949642181, -0.2725749909877777, -1.0260909795761108, -0.198171466588974, 0.3042358458042145, -0.5546354055404663, 0.575823187828064, -0.15315891802310944, 1.0094677209854126, 0.3389841318130493, -0.6107751131057739, -0.4212130606174469, -0.8427988290786743, 0.7614893317222595, -0.35788437724113464, 0.7645620107650757, 0.6591488718986511, -0.052502378821372986, 0.08549904823303223, -0.5418574810028076, -0.6091535687446594, -0.11926853656768799, -0.6142878532409668, -0.12851391732692719, -0.1022200882434845, -0.00041254752431996167, 0.4585827887058258, 0.07174079120159149, -0.5203097462654114, 0.08172129839658737, -0.31551027297973633, 0.060463204979896545, 0.30661365389823914, -0.10948765277862549, 0.2223079651594162, -0.10209770500659943, -0.023860393092036247, -0.49148625135421753, -0.782639741897583, -0.19900020956993103, 0.29909440875053406, 0.2427504062652588, -0.07147090882062912, 0.5078738331794739, 0.312494695186615, 0.44830378890037537, 0.33110183477401733, 0.3751848042011261, 0.03689330071210861, 0.02640850841999054, -0.24524179100990295, 0.09843885153532028, 0.5954408049583435, -0.04299420490860939, 0.2826341390609741, -0.16358733177185059, -0.41511109471321106, 0.011911867186427116, 0.6753250956535339, -0.8618594408035278, -0.05311513692140579, -0.02448248118162155, -0.6056375503540039, -0.1569293737411499, 0.2680816650390625, -0.21906834840774536, -0.4213634133338928, -0.38649189472198486, 0.3753305673599243, -0.49985092878341675, 0.17118245363235474, 0.09625786542892456, 0.009790684096515179, 0.4892057180404663, 0.07538051903247833, -1.1704893112182617, 0.4573487341403961, 0.44257593154907227, 0.7037684917449951, -0.17262399196624756, -0.2883082330226898, -0.2511596977710724, 0.10328663885593414, -0.4736815392971039, 0.6681568026542664, -0.7142061591148376, -0.7084190249443054, 0.48474425077438354, 0.28786730766296387, 0.03320961818099022, -0.5333417057991028, 0.5923628211021423, -0.9575496912002563, 0.5267748236656189, -0.34709563851356506, -0.5011312961578369, 0.0676095262169838, 0.024460922926664352, -0.9582182765007019, 1.0299750566482544, 0.12043784558773041, -0.9050069451332092, 0.5386115312576294, -0.26535436511039734, -0.5396304726600647, -0.4406471848487854, -0.274009108543396, -0.3534211218357086, 0.2915433943271637, 0.17150036990642548, 0.6783088445663452, -0.05231272801756859, 0.17878273129463196, -0.036218468099832535, -0.5338290333747864, 0.07812299579381943, -0.14438287913799286, 0.5887448787689209, 0.1635824590921402, -0.30413660407066345, -0.1703941971063614, -0.7306769490242004, -0.5612197518348694, 0.41737210750579834, -0.3723117709159851, -0.8097248673439026, 0.2631218433380127, 0.01619078405201435, 0.16059549152851105, 0.22585001587867737, -0.43348947167396545, 0.1668749302625656, -0.30736979842185974, 0.03864781931042671, 0.5568251013755798, 0.03303193300962448, 0.966071367263794, -0.1302351951599121, 0.4188285171985626, 0.3891800343990326, -0.03877001628279686, -0.7198675274848938, -0.025341089814901352, -0.9797841906547546, 0.6074449419975281, 0.3328448235988617, 0.27429303526878357, -0.6817939877510071, 0.1805216372013092, -0.2973203957080841, -0.16156531870365143, -0.2850217819213867, 0.04967666044831276, 0.3491808772087097, -0.011208762414753437, 0.3828187882900238, -0.27079710364341736, -0.4296196699142456, -0.9789842367172241, 0.005489950533956289, 0.19621093571186066, -0.18388238549232483, 0.15997104346752167, 0.3834277093410492, -0.3735694885253906, 0.7253084182739258, -0.6320881843566895, -0.10948697477579117, -0.10651843249797821, 0.2681944668292999, 0.1572263091802597, 0.4679526686668396, 0.5457993745803833, -0.8777399063110352, -0.5465608835220337, -0.2796832025051117, -0.6768405437469482, 0.1810649186372757, -0.1808185875415802, -0.06362085044384003, 0.0606389082968235, 0.7619180679321289, -0.8107560276985168, 0.36170026659965515, 0.34278079867362976, -0.354560911655426, 0.09948769956827164, -0.32657188177108765, -0.05103138089179993, -1.0663280487060547, -0.09820511192083359, 0.019756007939577103, -0.12514112889766693, -0.49808889627456665, -0.15504880249500275, 0.2539505064487457, -0.2640834450721741, 0.0012588658137246966, 0.496000736951828, -0.6803988814353943, 0.01264949981123209, -0.3379925787448883, 0.3360743224620819, 0.31431999802589417, 0.2640739977359772, 0.24170857667922974, 0.7776590585708618, 0.09877331554889679, -0.6658527851104736, -0.5626691579818726, 0.3470085561275482, -0.15151938796043396, 0.19561809301376343, -0.799471914768219, 0.31363222002983093, -0.5179056525230408, 0.15917298197746277, -0.8503370881080627, -0.06592433154582977, -0.07207869738340378, -0.3669198751449585, 0.8885806798934937, -0.18813908100128174, -0.4807937741279602, -0.2627083957195282, -0.12078459560871124, 0.46857747435569763, 0.45205366611480713, -0.3934996426105499, 0.36645743250846863, 0.3596956431865692, -0.1537458300590515, -0.587358295917511, -0.6128262877464294, -0.33766236901283264, 0.18740379810333252, -0.246391162276268, 0.7156972885131836, 0.206254243850708, -0.023137183859944344, -0.08887684345245361, 0.2672369182109833, -0.1511874794960022, -0.07435983419418335, 0.17843300104141235, -0.10287792980670929, -0.25308436155319214, 0.3472496569156647, 0.13142673671245575, -0.11793196201324463, 0.19370920956134796, -0.18328113853931427, 0.7133009433746338, 0.333154559135437, -0.44835031032562256, 0.12241893261671066, 0.599429190158844, 0.489044189453125, -0.16023734211921692, 0.976871132850647, 0.3242340683937073, -0.576668918132782, -0.26297664642333984, -0.6509464383125305, -0.38355591893196106, -0.4151861369609833, 0.2567383050918579, -0.10700615495443344, -0.8246919512748718, 0.6593770980834961, 0.140136256814003, -0.1773521602153778, 0.4743526577949524, 0.28801023960113525, -0.21943733096122742, 0.9344520568847656, 1.1127526760101318, 0.01209766510874033, 0.9020861983299255, -0.36993199586868286, 0.17440496385097504, -0.7638720273971558, -0.3824681043624878, -0.6702722311019897, -0.27138903737068176, -0.5576240420341492, -0.5544885993003845, 0.02310474030673504, 0.21837356686592102, -0.5138615965843201, 0.22566470503807068, -0.4515007436275482, 0.6241520047187805, 0.4618341028690338, 0.22193337976932526, -0.06264244019985199, -0.20279496908187866, -0.36639612913131714, -0.35288384556770325, -0.6219433546066284, -0.556532084941864, 1.084943175315857, 0.3487437069416046, 0.9168252944946289, -0.14811614155769348, 0.7489368915557861, 0.27280181646347046, 0.21788053214550018, -0.6746185421943665, 0.07856686413288116, -0.15209974348545074, -0.46729081869125366, -0.3338501751422882, 0.2046191692352295, -1.3510682582855225, 0.09760815650224686, 0.028345825150609016, -0.4072690010070801, 0.6576902270317078, -0.09620344638824463, -0.26370951533317566, -0.004296372644603252, -0.4378926157951355, 0.7900896072387695, -0.14192736148834229, -0.6375284194946289, -0.18009509146213531, -0.7335120439529419, 0.09293830394744873, 0.11447907984256744, -0.000011544286280695815, 0.4381895363330841, 0.12370043992996216, 0.7464312314987183, -0.2238733023405075, 0.8215592503547668, -0.5167244076728821, -0.12468141317367554, 0.11045335233211517, 0.37099489569664, 0.668929398059845, -0.13744215667247772, 0.0031879288144409657, -0.19340115785598755, -0.29805803298950195, -0.4507097005844116, -0.7146117687225342, 0.32885071635246277, -0.9234381318092346, -0.3581658601760864, -0.4357267916202545, 0.15935523808002472, -0.17513948678970337, 0.3281497359275818, 0.4401080310344696, 0.43712615966796875, -0.45642325282096863, 0.5338522791862488, 1.424025297164917, -0.31823331117630005, 0.4401201009750366, 0.42649734020233154, -0.2784896790981293, -0.028023308143019676, 0.31114497780799866, 0.0394299253821373, -0.017566435039043427, 0.711317777633667, 0.017928937450051308, -0.23315741121768951, -0.5446682572364807, -0.07016909867525101, 0.3364599645137787, -0.9803051948547363, -0.14203917980194092, -0.7124825119972229, -0.2759654223918915, -0.2770202159881592, -0.377307265996933, -0.48458975553512573, 0.09575606137514114, -0.6253007054328918, -0.24553847312927246, -0.17102323472499847, 1.1160531044006348, 0.3750552833080292, 0.7419423460960388, -0.703294038772583, 0.1470310389995575, 0.05291728302836418, 0.4350505471229553, 0.18436403572559357, -0.7622078657150269, -0.7740736603736877, -0.2752757966518402, -0.5175554752349854, -0.913593053817749, 0.29770416021347046, -0.08198162913322449, 0.7521559596061707, 0.615028977394104, -0.2932697534561157, 0.20898716151714325, -0.6163504719734192, 0.9851994514465332, -0.06962866336107254, -0.7382102608680725, 0.7433027029037476, -0.46103793382644653, 0.5183839797973633, 0.6259624361991882, 0.9555296301841736, -0.4902636408805847, 0.015055700205266476, -0.5092753171920776, -0.694189727306366, 0.6077434420585632, -0.14511868357658386, 0.4977543354034424, -0.44627436995506287, 0.4371180236339569, 0.20310506224632263, 0.06502264738082886, -1.087870478630066, -0.14256291091442108, -0.3708668053150177, 0.06339921802282333, -0.1973131150007248, -0.6940799355506897, 0.13515833020210266, -0.21041235327720642, 0.5524829030036926, -0.1692063808441162, 0.5532854199409485, 0.32096001505851746, -0.7280048131942749, 0.011644692160189152, 0.2205570936203003, 0.5939699411392212, 0.5127646327018738, -0.03783183917403221, 0.12653759121894836, -0.0880594328045845, -0.2667814791202545, 0.22958098351955414, -0.005031137727200985, -0.41790780425071716, 0.2265135943889618, 0.48054739832878113, 0.9840338826179504, 1.06134831905365, -0.24067310988903046, 0.7695984244346619, 0.03789038583636284, 0.06308954954147339, -0.46636340022087097, -0.323381632566452, 0.017443083226680756, 0.015067034400999546, 0.5385965704917908, -0.22268833220005035, 0.19198589026927948, -0.5283052325248718, 0.29760846495628357, 0.262164831161499, -0.6733821630477905, -0.4039681553840637, 0.7772161960601807, -0.08132074773311615, -0.17668017745018005, 0.7867937088012695, -0.05993059650063515, -0.49211496114730835, 0.1840599775314331, 0.6721798181533813, 0.9892876744270325, -0.4070764482021332, 0.2238045632839203, 0.5329262018203735, 0.27112385630607605, -0.21246813237667084, -0.06112966313958168, -0.12051711976528168, -0.9797773957252502, -0.21875295042991638, -0.8273642063140869, -0.06675998866558075, -0.19069723784923553, -0.6769649982452393, 0.44099071621894836, -0.30470138788223267, -0.18135324120521545, -0.2997643053531647, -0.14217793941497803, -0.9889586567878723, 0.1312786340713501, 0.3674810230731964, 0.7982053160667419, -0.8729956746101379, 0.8946083188056946, 0.40567517280578613, -0.7282290458679199, -0.5751014947891235, 0.12039141356945038, -0.39134645462036133, -0.5926598310470581, 0.8215664625167847, 0.15168896317481995, -0.07281292974948883, -0.03399529308080673, -0.6433464288711548, -0.9567205309867859, 1.0978883504867554, 0.3588726222515106, -0.5383171439170837, -0.5787072777748108, 0.05064018815755844, 0.619587242603302, -0.4071170389652252, 0.5207211971282959, 0.3409658372402191, 0.25981903076171875, -0.1867440789937973, -0.4754720628261566, 0.10602513700723648, -0.17548808455467224, 0.2265358716249466, 0.21993763744831085, -0.6009148955345154, 1.0431933403015137, 0.009509609080851078, -0.4401766061782837, -0.27595335245132446, 0.5024380087852478, -0.1840619295835495, 0.05732450261712074, 0.27921855449676514, 0.5985268354415894, 0.5934591889381409, -0.11681931465864182, 1.4682480096817017, -0.37068668007850647, 0.2207222431898117, 1.1068294048309326, -0.10602396726608276, 1.0320098400115967, 0.5672592520713806, -0.1792018562555313, 0.9220923781394958, 0.6770114302635193, 0.12967270612716675, 0.7496827840805054, 0.14187581837177277, 0.023053882643580437, -0.024053523316979408, 0.10886770486831665, -0.3137865364551544, 0.2610674500465393, 0.4138471782207489, -0.9074864983558655, -0.013999982737004757, 0.19207194447517395, -0.04362703859806061, 0.20767343044281006, 0.11946922540664673, 0.8500376343727112, 0.22388191521167755, -0.7351776957511902, 0.4409402906894684, -0.00034826097544282675, 0.6538652181625366, -0.7222762107849121, 0.017809294164180756, -0.5074574947357178, -0.10016077756881714, -0.030683167278766632, -0.6215057373046875, 0.18348407745361328, -0.5203154683113098, -0.6525641679763794, -0.5120787620544434, 0.8662315607070923, -0.3945598900318146, -0.1672472208738327, 0.7312120795249939, 0.42236754298210144, -0.12482364475727081, -0.21654444932937622, -0.34151792526245117, 0.16951581835746765, -0.34716323018074036, -0.69317626953125, 0.3447066843509674, 0.5032735466957092, -0.09605711698532104, 0.43210509419441223, 0.4883544147014618, -0.2625008225440979, 0.2913699448108673, 0.4115292727947235, 0.9042784571647644, -0.8151589632034302, -0.5469374060630798, -0.7718521952629089, 0.45912596583366394, 0.07776173204183578, 0.08321493864059448, 0.461683064699173, 0.6478326916694641, 1.020275354385376, -0.1851528435945511, 0.6630493998527527, 0.17650172114372253, 0.23923751711845398, -0.5575529932975769, 0.884288489818573, -0.3975517451763153, -0.015836840495467186, -0.21387867629528046, -1.1610887050628662, -0.1661456972360611, 0.7407249212265015, -0.2507142126560211, 0.1284153163433075, 0.8947777152061462, 0.5492748618125916, -0.23992714285850525, -0.18732097744941711, 0.46520042419433594, 0.2377614676952362, 0.17193613946437836, 0.24070075154304504, 0.7891001105308533, -0.7239623665809631, 0.15638843178749084, -0.19421698153018951, 0.17940440773963928, -0.42096972465515137, -0.6952975988388062, -0.5930529236793518, -0.9212622046470642, 0.2385358065366745, -0.4594253897666931, 0.07189561426639557, 0.7032090425491333, 0.6558403372764587, -0.864524245262146, -0.07855251431465149, 0.0273615512996912, 0.14159706234931946, 0.44763144850730896, -0.21620170772075653, 0.34230244159698486, -0.490144282579422, -0.6006633639335632, 0.27199193835258484, 0.05545612797141075, 0.39998936653137207, -0.503467321395874, -0.24526993930339813, -0.3354189395904541, 0.005290404427796602, 0.7352954149246216, 0.1569996476173401, -0.5521163940429688, -0.42469656467437744, 0.17653706669807434, -0.36831700801849365, 0.34347453713417053, 1.2359073162078857, -0.9637500047683716, 0.5029849410057068, 0.35691773891448975, 0.7384971380233765, 0.9129864573478699, -0.14807644486427307, 0.7914302349090576, -0.936691164970398, 0.2994256615638733, 0.21587790548801422, 0.6009296178817749, 0.44356635212898254, -0.438994437456131, 0.22108985483646393, 0.11665555834770203, -0.42712271213531494, -0.6687894463539124, -0.03329523652791977, -0.7211088538169861, -0.19626981019973755, 0.8037125468254089, 0.08517777919769287, 0.019299516454339027, 0.0968763530254364, -0.008788510225713253, 0.513827383518219, -0.15751591324806213, 0.6999887824058533, 1.076779842376709, 0.12313081324100494, -0.2681668996810913, -0.5929064154624939, 0.5204766988754272, 0.41386356949806213, -0.3825155198574066, -0.07553549110889435, 0.42678096890449524, 0.10707079619169235, 0.43563196063041687, 0.6884781718254089, -0.23800741136074066, 0.005665510892868042, 0.325662761926651, 0.022671252489089966, 0.36021679639816284, -0.5720235109329224, -0.4934626817703247, 0.1201368123292923, 0.29788917303085327, 0.19218093156814575 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04113v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04113v1
BEAR: A Unified Framework for Evaluating Relational Knowledge in Causal and Masked Language Models
2024-04-05T14:13:55
2024-04-05T14:13:55
Jacek Wiland, Max Ploner, Alan Akbik
cs.CL
cs.CL
Knowledge probing assesses to which degree a language model (LM) has successfully learned relational knowledge during pre-training. Probing is an inexpensive way to compare LMs of different sizes and training configurations. However, previous approaches rely on the objective function used in pre-training LMs and are thus applicable only to masked or causal LMs. As a result, comparing different types of LMs becomes impossible. To address this, we propose an approach that uses an LM's inherent ability to estimate the log-likelihood of any given textual statement. We carefully design an evaluation dataset of 7,731 instances (40,916 in a larger variant) from which we produce alternative statements for each relational fact, one of which is correct. We then evaluate whether an LM correctly assigns the highest log-likelihood to the correct statement. Our experimental evaluation of 22 common LMs shows that our proposed framework, BEAR, can effectively probe for knowledge across different LM types. We release the BEAR datasets and an open-source framework that implements the probing approach to the research community to facilitate the evaluation and development of LMs.
[ -0.475151002407074, -0.9797276854515076, 0.6262041926383972, 0.1619509756565094, -0.13309097290039062, 0.0025502550415694714, -0.22901825606822968, -0.324907511472702, 0.20467443764209747, 0.7126279473304749, -0.5568255186080933, -0.6521927118301392, -0.4956309497356415, 0.09135062992572784, -0.38333457708358765, 0.8431427478790283, 0.28729620575904846, 0.041928213089704514, -0.4866781532764435, -0.4510384500026703, -0.4822058379650116, -0.4064408242702484, -0.37927037477493286, -0.2813161611557007, 0.42664292454719543, -0.1019347682595253, 0.7592034339904785, 0.35353824496269226, 0.541405200958252, 0.2868117094039917, -0.10687623918056488, 0.13896086812019348, -0.6376240253448486, 0.24065446853637695, -0.5081031322479248, -0.22165711224079132, -0.21651585400104523, 0.023599795997142792, 0.7073389291763306, 1.0964409112930298, -0.03476831316947937, 0.337945818901062, -0.1556466519832611, 0.7546747922897339, -0.9780489206314087, 0.16260898113250732, -0.6084123849868774, -0.1208188533782959, 0.00007462404755642638, -0.03661739081144333, -0.6489052772521973, -0.3250487744808197, 0.2767946720123291, -0.6396483778953552, 0.2092749923467636, 0.35414329171180725, 0.8446804881095886, -0.0020415904000401497, -0.7550265789031982, -0.1795068085193634, -0.4975513219833374, 0.6737760305404663, -0.5209405422210693, 0.6072934865951538, 0.5561755895614624, 0.31857433915138245, -0.1714119017124176, -0.6804078221321106, -0.3277190327644348, -0.26468273997306824, -0.7168981432914734, -0.12997326254844666, -0.08878040313720703, 0.15560974180698395, 0.2215465009212494, 0.42888981103897095, -0.7630237340927124, -0.4332127273082733, -0.20635105669498444, -0.3286857306957245, 0.5491262078285217, 0.13554351031780243, 0.2279057651758194, -0.08113766461610794, -0.2524247467517853, -0.16754315793514252, -0.823489785194397, -0.13103370368480682, 0.2836120128631592, 0.328294575214386, 0.17492076754570007, 0.4413914084434509, -0.18956471979618073, 1.1126195192337036, 0.09685739874839783, 0.03266432508826256, -0.08037008345127106, -0.13779957592487335, -0.5016698241233826, -0.11159127205610275, 0.855370044708252, 0.2825065851211548, -0.0444374717772007, -0.4342186748981476, -0.2765546143054962, -0.057602409273386, 0.2308999001979828, -0.7122921943664551, -0.1775936484336853, 0.06470999866724014, -0.1457240730524063, -0.3023386001586914, 0.12325458973646164, -0.586645245552063, -0.5682364106178284, -0.34330040216445923, 0.6590492725372314, -0.23667025566101074, -0.7153868675231934, 0.3030366599559784, 0.12592308223247528, 0.14802326261997223, -0.02952408604323864, -0.7713601589202881, 0.6037290096282959, 0.7838289737701416, 0.3795360028743744, -0.03787095099687576, -0.10864889621734619, -0.8693452477455139, 0.02598167583346367, -0.5744728446006775, 0.6083722710609436, -0.5119221806526184, -0.1998075246810913, 0.17211668193340302, 0.09127673506736755, -0.24290738999843597, -0.5587962865829468, 0.3881877064704895, -0.9845204949378967, 0.2983267307281494, -0.48042094707489014, -0.7434536814689636, -0.5601059198379517, 0.4106871485710144, -0.8892524242401123, 1.1755175590515137, 0.34809333086013794, -1.0651055574417114, 0.6061777472496033, -0.5648594498634338, -0.38807088136672974, 0.17411687970161438, -0.42487579584121704, -0.3019140064716339, 0.08933233469724655, 0.2851982116699219, 0.530651330947876, -0.6398377418518066, 1.0040571689605713, -0.5883966684341431, -0.3924364149570465, 0.45951011776924133, 0.18205517530441284, 1.2493382692337036, 0.12218392640352249, -0.3701997995376587, 0.10401508212089539, -0.6235287189483643, 0.0020049642771482468, -0.07931441813707352, -0.10247508436441422, -0.6964995861053467, -0.12713466584682465, -0.2630898058414459, -0.22536562383174896, -0.318779855966568, -0.460217148065567, -0.06014116108417511, -0.31680619716644287, -0.10582458227872849, 0.4083096385002136, 0.0356648713350296, 0.44674405455589294, -0.2514607906341553, 0.4697730839252472, -0.2965858280658722, 0.15198259055614471, -0.14675158262252808, -0.24296410381793976, -0.8168672323226929, -0.404958575963974, 0.38362452387809753, 0.30213022232055664, -0.5245687961578369, 0.42769303917884827, -0.22212548553943634, -0.30185648798942566, -0.47821128368377686, 0.11613159626722336, 0.7032411098480225, 0.5629159212112427, 0.17877495288848877, -0.4426036477088928, -0.451961487531662, -0.7021923661231995, -0.6240953803062439, -0.42972511053085327, -0.03481270745396614, 0.48638322949409485, 0.4210197627544403, -0.14528943598270416, 1.176504135131836, -0.41726791858673096, -0.17864184081554413, 0.013862078078091145, 0.49342337250709534, 0.3801071345806122, 0.2761844992637634, 0.6660497784614563, -0.7235091328620911, -0.3882899284362793, 0.02774166874587536, -1.177966594696045, 0.044237129390239716, 0.07490843534469604, -0.25282666087150574, 0.11100604385137558, 0.5482896566390991, -0.5911092162132263, 0.365360289812088, 0.5720373392105103, -0.535049557685852, 0.609716534614563, 0.1812799721956253, 0.26296520233154297, -0.6274719834327698, 0.3612156808376312, -0.2755267024040222, -0.22617107629776, -0.6543816328048706, 0.5681819319725037, 0.1744404137134552, -0.03012176789343357, -0.29625746607780457, 0.9520618915557861, -0.6784804463386536, -0.2659164071083069, 0.036432139575481415, 0.22904177010059357, -0.03090261109173298, 0.3188200294971466, 0.19058625400066376, 0.4356214702129364, 0.8888363838195801, -0.7871262431144714, 0.4566497206687927, -0.01921071857213974, -0.8271894454956055, 0.6015198230743408, -0.4970771074295044, 0.36170274019241333, 0.008786626160144806, -0.11990178376436234, -0.8502997159957886, -0.17891916632652283, 0.30265259742736816, -0.5372592210769653, 0.5326316356658936, -0.09505803138017654, -0.39887434244155884, -0.004135896917432547, -0.016145987436175346, 0.5161673426628113, 0.11773622035980225, -0.4336887001991272, 0.9230188131332397, 0.32190319895744324, 0.019900139421224594, -0.9026301503181458, -0.3417931795120239, 0.0361659973859787, -0.2712351977825165, -0.8352187871932983, -0.18648384511470795, -0.1484093815088272, -0.6058990955352783, 0.2868097126483917, -0.19004739820957184, -0.13644498586654663, 0.15927447378635406, 0.08089063316583633, 0.16802309453487396, -0.6294785141944885, 0.35282570123672485, -0.08086292445659637, -0.04691365361213684, 0.3993317186832428, -0.3633379638195038, 0.24534358084201813, -0.41604316234588623, -0.5736092329025269, 0.07309450209140778, 0.09969428926706314, 0.17851148545742035, -0.1283075511455536, 0.7760028839111328, 0.48639971017837524, -0.37289735674858093, 0.052019234746694565, -0.8934617638587952, -0.5093729496002197, -0.4547728896141052, 0.17323264479637146, -0.5726801156997681, -1.1757616996765137, 0.35495179891586304, -0.07676833122968674, -0.14192040264606476, 0.25630098581314087, 0.12492935359477997, -0.02005673572421074, 0.4660945236682892, 0.841385006904602, -0.07608504593372345, -0.20698657631874084, 0.12137483060359955, 0.30041298270225525, -0.5793686509132385, -0.18447542190551758, -0.5057246685028076, 0.1580686718225479, -0.38218262791633606, -0.27086591720581055, 0.31027528643608093, 0.34646353125572205, -0.41286975145339966, 0.37362825870513916, -0.08898410946130753, 0.4949616491794586, 0.46336695551872253, 0.16556617617607117, 0.5325549840927124, -0.10978789627552032, -0.4333982765674591, -0.06191188842058182, -0.46817561984062195, -0.35950571298599243, 1.2563164234161377, 0.11695767939090729, 0.6405896544456482, 0.2514200508594513, 0.41203591227531433, 0.25163283944129944, 0.8158299922943115, -0.7210530042648315, 0.5990917086601257, 0.3633064925670624, -1.5399495363235474, -0.7462152242660522, -0.5660839676856995, -0.6967980861663818, 0.3938271999359131, -0.18354664742946625, -0.8067626357078552, 0.1244838535785675, 0.13889090716838837, -0.08346142619848251, 0.23061996698379517, -0.3858465552330017, 0.9672627449035645, -0.2492811679840088, -0.349103718996048, 0.05966310203075409, -0.807638943195343, 0.7843080759048462, -0.41611406207084656, 0.41800999641418457, -0.06951886415481567, 0.2175954133272171, 0.7719107270240784, -0.07205318659543991, 0.9374639391899109, -0.031063446775078773, 0.006915671285241842, 0.414611279964447, 0.640536367893219, 0.22312194108963013, 0.18596325814723969, -0.09725983440876007, -0.057221002876758575, 0.1844417154788971, -0.25054752826690674, -0.9381410479545593, 0.2616174817085266, -0.4051186740398407, -0.7069320678710938, -0.5747637748718262, -0.4226864278316498, -0.44888612627983093, 0.2980886399745941, -0.08328081667423248, 0.3568565249443054, -0.633949875831604, 0.4186416566371918, 0.8376783132553101, -0.22823555767536163, 0.00941577646881342, 1.0610096454620361, -0.814638078212738, -0.2859426438808441, 0.6937604546546936, -0.47743695974349976, 0.30445143580436707, 0.7626876831054688, 0.25799819827079773, -0.37579187750816345, -0.06861848384141922, -0.25808101892471313, 0.5205983519554138, -0.7914924025535583, -0.31956127285957336, -0.6967878937721252, -0.04725928604602814, -0.49197787046432495, 0.10048112273216248, -0.32529065012931824, -0.06112572178244591, 0.11629589647054672, -0.2684899866580963, 0.36672160029411316, 0.6595780253410339, -0.27638524770736694, 0.29669803380966187, -0.5830903649330139, 0.00799218937754631, 0.6631461381912231, 0.39801907539367676, -0.3910699486732483, -0.5568050742149353, -0.09084274619817734, 0.006716547533869743, -0.09673317521810532, -1.0071406364440918, 0.27982068061828613, 0.16502974927425385, 0.687255859375, 0.6698120832443237, 0.3802970349788666, 0.4698191285133362, -0.030791329219937325, 0.43104109168052673, 0.269461989402771, -1.1779417991638184, 0.4838559329509735, -0.48284897208213806, -0.14531110227108002, 0.6693505644798279, 0.7666393518447876, -0.5716256499290466, -0.3730500638484955, -0.5310649871826172, -0.30535802245140076, 0.7871025800704956, 0.24103781580924988, -0.08834006637334824, 0.16079770028591156, 0.3469071388244629, 0.0867014080286026, 0.29938822984695435, -0.9333404898643494, -0.3520321249961853, 0.0835568830370903, 0.14366452395915985, -0.28179576992988586, -0.3179442286491394, -0.6515569090843201, -0.22880332171916962, 0.6455774903297424, -0.22749090194702148, 0.20428748428821564, -0.10301338136196136, -0.5131690502166748, -0.1352662891149521, 0.11543435603380203, 0.35599184036254883, 1.034433126449585, -0.7365753650665283, 0.46299824118614197, 0.17179125547409058, -0.31153252720832825, 0.10882794111967087, -0.0027744376566261053, -0.2935992181301117, 0.18586882948875427, 0.6207787990570068, 0.8274372220039368, 0.5001282691955566, -0.6108230352401733, 0.6651879549026489, -0.15167422592639923, -0.3039533793926239, 0.002695143688470125, -0.21966449916362762, 0.3119566738605499, 0.04739044979214668, 0.11785119771957397, -0.3628248870372772, 0.18296216428279877, -0.5932866334915161, 0.38567033410072327, 0.3041996955871582, -0.7245169281959534, -0.29109448194503784, 0.2865636944770813, 0.04667866230010986, -0.08698687702417374, 0.7784918546676636, -0.35341405868530273, -0.44478514790534973, 0.3675902783870697, 0.43511414527893066, 0.8149943947792053, -0.638546347618103, 0.4706346094608307, 0.5549322962760925, 0.6845371723175049, 0.1624598205089569, 0.057689767330884933, -0.17763227224349976, -0.9057484865188599, -0.5296509265899658, -0.7253639698028564, -0.29724904894828796, 0.4127153158187866, -1.0252509117126465, 0.269863486289978, -0.15113931894302368, -0.02787245810031891, -0.2809763252735138, -0.02457994781434536, -0.7008916139602661, 0.4098120629787445, -0.4439608156681061, 0.7781009674072266, -1.0329668521881104, 0.6541080474853516, 0.8328164219856262, -0.40934014320373535, -0.6862109303474426, -0.3176022171974182, 0.15134954452514648, -0.9048739671707153, 0.9118653535842896, 0.13288834691047668, -0.18681053817272186, -0.3487934470176697, -0.6029893159866333, -0.8592154383659363, 0.84900963306427, 0.565077543258667, -0.3492216467857361, 0.3583391010761261, 0.16522526741027832, 0.3030500113964081, -0.4204362630844116, 0.4779433310031891, 0.6180757880210876, 0.5292782187461853, 0.12108365446329117, -0.9206518530845642, 0.3424758315086365, -0.11602453142404556, -0.22578215599060059, 0.1865365356206894, -0.11443012952804565, 0.5895634293556213, -0.17325709760189056, -0.5129498839378357, -0.179304301738739, 0.7171217203140259, 0.28383103013038635, 0.45687299966812134, 0.6531907916069031, 0.4236696660518646, 0.726951003074646, -0.13866065442562103, 0.7870200276374817, -0.1897764950990677, 0.6220872402191162, 1.208402156829834, -0.2755957841873169, 0.5116856098175049, 0.3543078899383545, -0.14155033230781555, 0.2439126819372177, 0.663612425327301, 0.3544169068336487, 0.5712091326713562, 0.4905773997306824, -0.3470318913459778, -0.5255327224731445, -0.02198587730526924, -0.48964956402778625, 0.2203720659017563, 0.4984549283981323, -0.17126737534999847, -0.17272721230983734, -0.19624115526676178, 0.17109568417072296, 0.12426872551441193, 0.15211164951324463, 0.8210335373878479, 0.13101595640182495, -0.8255511522293091, 0.7083191275596619, -0.10796986520290375, 0.0921410620212555, -0.5927102565765381, 0.15837672352790833, -0.5956776142120361, -0.0002018673694692552, 0.019483109936118126, -0.5877867937088013, 0.4397531747817993, -0.2646324038505554, 0.08705655485391617, 0.029249802231788635, 0.7561848759651184, -0.2748449444770813, -0.36736205220222473, 0.5944579243659973, 0.5488749146461487, 0.4017413854598999, -0.40444499254226685, -0.4522639214992523, 0.2694281041622162, -0.1659039556980133, -0.2704615294933319, 0.3766807019710541, 0.6408312916755676, 0.13998554646968842, 0.6386366486549377, 0.4158952236175537, -0.11511866748332977, -0.0012322713155299425, 0.020996050909161568, 0.9877231121063232, -0.6708669662475586, 0.0031716572120785713, -0.5359500646591187, 0.5876967906951904, -0.10944672673940659, -0.20848654210567474, 0.5425314903259277, 0.5605033040046692, 0.9749571084976196, -0.032381877303123474, 0.6376834511756897, -0.06749513745307922, 0.6040903329849243, -0.5917983651161194, 0.7997468113899231, -0.5110613107681274, 0.2326517254114151, -0.4478856921195984, -1.0733273029327393, -0.4399477243423462, 0.803554117679596, -0.2748810648918152, -0.015374493785202503, 1.0986979007720947, 1.040459394454956, -0.2254609614610672, 0.24162557721138, 0.6147297620773315, 0.27413180470466614, 0.1312694102525711, 0.2589549422264099, 0.989368736743927, -0.525284469127655, 0.4856787323951721, -0.21385574340820312, -0.47474560141563416, -0.09480998665094376, -1.2918063402175903, -1.3279584646224976, -0.7895632982254028, -0.34240442514419556, -0.2662743628025055, 0.31368929147720337, 0.3443603515625, 0.9146332144737244, -0.8206168413162231, -0.5997329354286194, 0.0911000594496727, 0.15703542530536652, -0.3103659152984619, -0.20379170775413513, 0.5417795181274414, -0.4258241057395935, -0.15770868957042694, 0.48586589097976685, 0.13933701813220978, -0.44444045424461365, -0.24584749341011047, -0.2860757112503052, -0.29195088148117065, -0.07904598861932755, 0.65553218126297, 0.36656251549720764, -0.739983856678009, -0.22331611812114716, 0.34115085005760193, -0.019926229491829872, -0.39304032921791077, 1.1050726175308228, -0.6614301204681396, 0.8766807913780212, 0.22125586867332458, 0.9769261479377747, 0.7659605145454407, -0.3587912321090698, 0.7152991890907288, -0.6707502007484436, 0.0021334397606551647, 0.26214292645454407, 0.10619769245386124, 0.3851769268512726, -0.23740318417549133, 0.7606619596481323, 0.3339124023914337, -0.4762303829193115, -0.9396595358848572, 0.28524506092071533, -0.8284867405891418, -0.2770003080368042, 1.0405369997024536, -0.47752997279167175, 0.005061502102762461, -0.2382763922214508, 0.13665494322776794, 0.15726597607135773, -0.043877698481082916, 0.75395268201828, 0.8673519492149353, 0.08351985365152359, -0.1308719515800476, -0.5041713714599609, 0.4869536757469177, 0.5113141536712646, -0.6485987901687622, -0.028588058426976204, 0.505156397819519, 0.416920006275177, 0.15107297897338867, 0.7692516446113586, -0.1415480375289917, 0.1649456024169922, -0.06289738416671753, 0.011285561136901379, 0.07042194157838821, -0.46910011768341064, -0.05014997348189354, -0.024728652089834213, -0.0785074234008789, 0.08804665505886078 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04108v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04108v1
Large language models as oracles for instantiating ontologies with domain-specific knowledge
2024-04-05T14:04:07
2024-04-05T14:04:07
Giovanni Ciatto, Andrea Agiollo, Matteo Magnini, Andrea Omicini
cs.AI
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.LO
Background. Endowing intelligent systems with semantic data commonly requires designing and instantiating ontologies with domain-specific knowledge. Especially in the early phases, those activities are typically performed manually by human experts possibly leveraging on their own experience. The resulting process is therefore time-consuming, error-prone, and often biased by the personal background of the ontology designer. Objective. To mitigate that issue, we propose a novel domain-independent approach to automatically instantiate ontologies with domain-specific knowledge, by leveraging on large language models (LLMs) as oracles. Method. Starting from (i) an initial schema composed by inter-related classes andproperties and (ii) a set of query templates, our method queries the LLM multiple times, and generates instances for both classes and properties from its replies. Thus, the ontology is automatically filled with domain-specific knowledge, compliant to the initial schema. As a result, the ontology is quickly and automatically enriched with manifold instances, which experts may consider to keep, adjust, discard, or complement according to their own needs and expertise. Contribution. We formalise our method in general way and instantiate it over various LLMs, as well as on a concrete case study. We report experiments rooted in the nutritional domain where an ontology of food meals and their ingredients is semi-automatically instantiated from scratch, starting from a categorisation of meals and their relationships. There, we analyse the quality of the generated ontologies and compare ontologies attained by exploiting different LLMs. Finally, we provide a SWOT analysis of the proposed method.
[ -0.2585652768611908, -0.8320109844207764, 0.5680757761001587, 0.004837369546294212, 0.23800569772720337, -0.07217087596654892, -0.26395803689956665, -0.5041306018829346, 0.20405325293540955, 1.0443896055221558, -0.15356062352657318, -0.526868462562561, -0.39657828211784363, 0.14031124114990234, -0.4576885998249054, 0.4755653142929077, 0.026844315230846405, -0.10991203784942627, -0.15357238054275513, -0.009495261125266552, -0.14199502766132355, -0.4973198175430298, -0.30461761355400085, -0.1267462819814682, 0.3226131200790405, 0.23096880316734314, 0.6311962604522705, 0.9406599402427673, 0.18412408232688904, 0.3689109981060028, 0.15422549843788147, 0.528495192527771, -0.0905752032995224, 0.1742081493139267, -0.47793933749198914, -0.20580410957336426, -0.6713905930519104, -0.14312390983104706, 0.34173527359962463, 0.8192460536956787, -0.17631420493125916, 0.2315095067024231, 0.25805267691612244, 0.21233659982681274, -0.5014526844024658, 0.44280195236206055, -1.034255862236023, 0.175901859998703, -0.10984554886817932, -0.3395490348339081, -0.5504807829856873, -0.1503511220216751, 0.3408534824848175, -0.8647865653038025, -0.06993091851472855, 0.10221700370311737, 0.6289178729057312, 0.2406024932861328, -0.2701515853404999, -0.4841257333755493, -0.8338565230369568, 0.792317807674408, -0.7991116046905518, 0.23951250314712524, 0.226717010140419, 0.2758317291736603, -0.2956124544143677, -0.7444376349449158, -0.8685865998268127, -0.11716780066490173, -0.11748193949460983, -0.05058857426047325, 0.13076573610305786, -0.14534734189510345, -0.020547913387417793, 0.17181962728500366, -0.4781109094619751, 0.13232673704624176, 0.2713359594345093, 0.17018932104110718, 0.6415466666221619, 0.4865387976169586, 0.5037125945091248, -0.48949339985847473, -0.2419210523366928, 0.09925071895122528, -0.9174671173095703, -0.36481180787086487, -0.056143853813409805, 0.7998855113983154, 0.2651485204696655, 0.8666477203369141, -0.28113049268722534, 0.8140367865562439, 0.13035322725772858, -0.35555946826934814, 0.1857304722070694, -0.3831190764904022, -0.16317881643772125, 0.048184823244810104, 0.6120548248291016, -0.023282235488295555, 0.2549379765987396, -0.3423442542552948, -0.19325780868530273, -0.06106226146221161, 0.26562806963920593, -0.406098335981369, 0.06275688111782074, 0.49696874618530273, -0.05649850517511368, -0.12883372604846954, -0.312597393989563, -0.45288753509521484, -0.36963626742362976, -0.5255835056304932, 0.7597871422767639, -0.3663243353366852, -0.09350036829710007, -0.016045449301600456, 0.2577306926250458, 0.4471754729747772, 0.335704505443573, -0.9148069620132446, 0.15747512876987457, 0.7447120547294617, 0.3467300236225128, -0.057683054357767105, -0.2638348639011383, -0.2838289439678192, 0.8505530953407288, -0.2915319502353668, 0.9625551700592041, -0.633737325668335, -0.24082666635513306, 0.2694399058818817, 0.1471610963344574, 0.23100142180919647, -0.7531998157501221, 0.122185118496418, -0.7153663039207458, 0.10504179447889328, -0.27908435463905334, -0.8613746166229248, 0.05373869091272354, 0.24460722506046295, -0.27236416935920715, 1.0339250564575195, 0.17662392556667328, -0.5385589003562927, 0.5887743234634399, -0.48714491724967957, -0.43306389451026917, 0.4569084048271179, -0.3929287791252136, 0.14944793283939362, -0.22528626024723053, -0.002472400665283203, 0.6670347452163696, -0.7478967308998108, 0.27270787954330444, -0.28960683941841125, 0.24933351576328278, 0.05078662931919098, 0.31720781326293945, 0.6000377535820007, 0.016845177859067917, -0.23123130202293396, -0.061615169048309326, -0.9318763613700867, 0.4181452691555023, 0.2533113658428192, -0.2003360241651535, -0.8011077642440796, 0.06745301932096481, -0.3420941233634949, 0.34568455815315247, 0.29064181447029114, -0.31589099764823914, 0.4946247339248657, -0.6068927645683289, 0.25279486179351807, 0.794308066368103, -0.07276568561792374, 0.5457921624183655, 0.06722542643547058, 0.1569019854068756, -0.021740442141890526, 0.13081486523151398, -0.15140433609485626, -0.2185518592596054, -0.8731275796890259, -0.2279289811849594, 0.2947838008403778, 0.6274457573890686, -0.9204980731010437, 0.8684685230255127, -0.15700770914554596, -0.35502082109451294, -0.13917697966098785, 0.28207671642303467, 0.3275788128376007, 0.5270914435386658, 0.4583839178085327, -0.2836352288722992, -0.3753165006637573, -0.5654392242431641, -0.1223246306180954, 0.04034627228975296, -0.11781640350818634, 0.6191307306289673, 0.4242130517959595, -0.3277544677257538, 1.030252456665039, -0.7936747074127197, -0.5875082612037659, -0.23955494165420532, -0.23830340802669525, -0.05669860541820526, 0.332354336977005, 0.43011894822120667, -0.46308743953704834, -0.7444953918457031, 0.21390746533870697, -1.1744574308395386, -0.1702878773212433, 0.12218181788921356, -0.40225523710250854, 0.15184080600738525, 0.23509027063846588, -0.5788798928260803, 0.27983811497688293, 0.12504540383815765, -0.36617621779441833, 0.5619259476661682, -0.3289780914783478, -0.23096904158592224, -1.1964844465255737, -0.043723225593566895, -0.060308877378702164, 0.14486560225486755, -0.6221702098846436, 0.1216968223452568, -0.12189538776874542, 0.0612228624522686, -0.5263925194740295, 1.0132451057434082, -0.48472005128860474, -0.28631556034088135, -0.08808478713035583, 0.24788551032543182, 0.20836447179317474, 0.35456645488739014, 0.24700652062892914, 0.3661445677280426, 0.6024646162986755, -0.8533504605293274, 0.34083986282348633, 0.4969422519207001, -0.49015817046165466, 0.4197145700454712, -0.6522009372711182, -0.07263901829719543, 0.08250349760055542, 0.1933651566505432, -0.6321491599082947, -0.3530470132827759, 0.337723046541214, -0.031944118440151215, 0.04923887550830841, -0.15328718721866608, -0.7979788184165955, -0.23647473752498627, 0.30653703212738037, 0.07138781994581223, 0.33974215388298035, -0.6735396385192871, 1.0903419256210327, 0.6730222105979919, -0.2640235126018524, -0.4122216999530792, -0.5783792734146118, 0.1268446296453476, -0.07186585664749146, -0.7225989699363708, 0.31378301978111267, 0.019471488893032074, -0.37328892946243286, 0.22277016937732697, 0.16690166294574738, -0.23384055495262146, -0.2802428901195526, 0.28020408749580383, 0.20080362260341644, -0.2973517179489136, 0.3177921772003174, 0.24938750267028809, -0.12418680638074875, -0.178699791431427, -0.8704532384872437, 0.5073896646499634, 0.2546224296092987, -0.32068687677383423, -0.3503158390522003, 0.5342366099357605, 0.3396567404270172, -0.3374496400356293, 0.8561714291572571, 0.13761481642723083, -0.2993859052658081, -0.7578130960464478, -0.5649487972259521, -0.24968576431274414, -0.5141238570213318, 0.17894649505615234, -0.4362100660800934, -0.5053733587265015, 0.626109778881073, -0.20580822229385376, 0.2713838815689087, 0.40337008237838745, 0.7054953575134277, 0.17747485637664795, 0.758685827255249, 0.7498805522918701, 0.4245958626270294, 0.19188810884952545, -0.4490942656993866, 0.24107104539871216, -0.5991242527961731, -0.33809635043144226, -0.4794139862060547, 0.3584393560886383, -0.21158409118652344, -0.7198992371559143, 0.3066771924495697, -0.4348229467868805, -0.41561850905418396, 0.2808510959148407, -0.3802243173122406, 0.38821983337402344, 0.10397150367498398, -0.2355848252773285, 0.4976446330547333, 0.11125541478395462, -0.2871975600719452, 0.07720600813627243, -0.7510347366333008, -0.6789354085922241, 1.2493382692337036, -0.18386736512184143, 0.8203015923500061, 0.15347589552402496, 0.4670124351978302, 0.35230791568756104, 0.5055315494537354, -0.6129011511802673, 0.7854815125465393, -0.5442824959754944, -0.5338739156723022, -0.28379198908805847, -0.48360347747802734, -0.8588007092475891, 0.3217671513557434, -0.14940905570983887, -0.5160583257675171, 0.17397210001945496, 0.1372356414794922, -0.4290322959423065, 0.22131961584091187, -0.656578004360199, 0.6602030396461487, -0.41608554124832153, -0.49723729491233826, 0.19218724966049194, -0.48531123995780945, 0.19455547630786896, -0.49204790592193604, 0.16423773765563965, -0.21459230780601501, -0.1621636301279068, 0.4981206953525543, -0.631232738494873, 0.9085866808891296, -0.11824636906385422, -0.4633465111255646, 0.4936561584472656, 0.16630513966083527, 0.5565279126167297, 0.06304255872964859, -0.1827310174703598, 0.04092077910900116, -0.20999695360660553, -0.29493996500968933, -0.8452517986297607, 0.798034131526947, -0.7790411114692688, -0.6448633074760437, -0.2932746112346649, -0.37517422437667847, -0.4807063043117523, 0.3647381663322449, -0.19343075156211853, 0.4778493642807007, 0.04237549379467964, -0.39081504940986633, 0.5932803750038147, -0.39079198241233826, 0.11606036871671677, 1.012058138847351, -0.40281856060028076, -0.048135921359062195, 0.8845471739768982, 0.4013470709323883, 0.3595367670059204, 0.38572847843170166, 0.09687671065330505, -0.25282275676727295, -0.10871345549821854, -0.4785079061985016, 0.19819125533103943, -0.6502639651298523, -0.17933322489261627, -0.9181647896766663, -0.17125719785690308, -0.4950707256793976, -0.20859241485595703, -0.658355176448822, -0.3562295436859131, -0.18671244382858276, 0.297455370426178, 0.25763848423957825, 0.6609525084495544, 0.15125881135463715, -0.0024103685282170773, -0.8542896509170532, 0.2159532904624939, 0.49608153104782104, 0.22112473845481873, 0.4820528030395508, -0.6568563580513, -0.15923252701759338, -0.2190045416355133, 0.08138633519411087, -0.45513075590133667, 0.6537939310073853, 0.3355388641357422, 0.5650700926780701, 0.4669881761074066, 0.16862186789512634, 0.4888906180858612, -0.641528308391571, 0.7114700675010681, -0.09282810986042023, -0.8260780572891235, 0.43115556240081787, -0.18836210668087006, 0.003003814024850726, 0.23846487700939178, 0.5916749835014343, -0.16972365975379944, -0.36980125308036804, -0.48061779141426086, -1.16746187210083, 0.4561900794506073, -0.1995292752981186, 0.22266127169132233, -0.11470746994018555, 0.6420517563819885, 0.4735194146633148, 0.10039171576499939, -0.3703734278678894, -0.3235791027545929, -0.022489609196782112, -0.013411050662398338, 0.3273378610610962, -0.1436244398355484, -0.257891982793808, -0.06665007770061493, 0.6162318587303162, -0.19950275123119354, 0.07828086614608765, -0.06930691748857498, -0.16736389696598053, 0.05416649580001831, 0.10311563313007355, -0.06655972450971603, 0.9430481195449829, -0.0021945834159851074, 0.21868380904197693, 0.11075777560472488, -0.18733859062194824, 0.29878050088882446, -0.11338479071855545, -0.2147478610277176, -0.2790612280368805, 0.1990371197462082, 0.23177939653396606, -0.047826215624809265, -0.9019747376441956, 0.21799133718013763, -0.08719278126955032, 0.041613008826971054, -0.5615766048431396, 0.12866531312465668, -0.03231874853372574, 0.3212845027446747, 0.37738943099975586, -0.35544002056121826, -0.24524039030075073, -0.49713003635406494, 0.35607442259788513, 0.21194662153720856, -0.0013608403969556093, -0.39384880661964417, 0.45291611552238464, 0.4030798673629761, 0.04802372306585312, 0.3977929949760437, -0.40262049436569214, -0.22772596776485443, 0.2618311941623688, 0.6358327269554138, 0.7282431125640869, -0.38986748456954956, 0.12479942291975021, 0.1109486073255539, -0.03604891523718834, 0.007498936261981726, 0.27494338154792786, 0.06345503777265549, -1.0573890209197998, -0.5792298316955566, -0.9316710829734802, -0.3254683315753937, -0.027626769617199898, -0.3538355827331543, 0.10457434505224228, -0.3646562695503235, -0.0659923329949379, 0.39325541257858276, -0.08240516483783722, -0.6034576892852783, 0.35944664478302, -0.10518557578325272, 0.8158578276634216, -0.8627644181251526, 0.9769678711891174, 0.7885074019432068, -0.4360622465610504, -0.9285905361175537, 0.08114594221115112, -0.18621760606765747, -0.8802842497825623, 1.1407475471496582, -0.5995315313339233, 0.0027380124665796757, -0.11471554636955261, -0.18721823394298553, -0.870890200138092, 0.7625852227210999, 0.12338560074567795, -0.245669424533844, -0.08964885026216507, 0.5339299440383911, 0.5564833283424377, -0.7086312770843506, 0.00959857739508152, 0.40640556812286377, 0.5757765173912048, 0.03258159011602402, -0.6555560231208801, 0.1911974400281906, -0.09153787791728973, 0.04805290699005127, -0.04757550731301308, -0.648847222328186, 0.7591345310211182, -0.21358464658260345, -0.07744581997394562, 0.03811446204781532, 0.7985916137695312, 0.015660960227251053, 0.004450993146747351, 0.39163053035736084, 0.5290346741676331, 0.5930112600326538, 0.21390360593795776, 0.9301285147666931, -0.7225986123085022, 0.2678488492965698, 1.1760154962539673, -0.7906683087348938, 0.7556593418121338, 0.2520337402820587, -0.23958487808704376, 0.28878748416900635, 0.35475170612335205, 0.021541159600019455, 0.5282114148139954, 0.26283857226371765, -0.39064112305641174, -0.38248661160469055, -0.34775060415267944, -0.5373783111572266, 0.678186297416687, 0.6185457110404968, -0.46392953395843506, -0.17649930715560913, -0.03881320357322693, -0.006976207718253136, -0.14409984648227692, -0.08001288771629333, 0.8786531090736389, 0.07996515929698944, -0.41038522124290466, 0.39475199580192566, 0.04368331655859947, 0.18389053642749786, -0.7255843877792358, -0.005880147218704224, -0.2423902004957199, 0.2125946581363678, -0.15152975916862488, -0.7030589580535889, 0.2745579481124878, -0.07209718972444534, -0.22618518769741058, -0.01079421117901802, 0.6500085592269897, -0.47988760471343994, -0.4378368556499481, 0.4244629144668579, 0.8442745208740234, 0.00007171522156568244, 0.20008350908756256, -0.5896337032318115, -0.03487837314605713, -0.297699898481369, -0.3043709993362427, 0.5005386471748352, 0.6965817809104919, -0.00250378530472517, 0.6760393381118774, 0.5918209552764893, 0.1151299774646759, 0.08028014749288559, -0.1368986815214157, 1.0311335325241089, -0.6531181335449219, -0.44149744510650635, -0.43248653411865234, 0.14052115380764008, 0.10652689635753632, -0.09530699998140335, 0.8879295587539673, 0.4404091536998749, 0.7220013737678528, -0.12032818049192429, 1.0047354698181152, -0.37026548385620117, 0.4778725802898407, -0.42134401202201843, 0.7845405340194702, -0.8499135375022888, 0.5672516226768494, -0.32402125000953674, -1.0150357484817505, -0.45737770199775696, 0.2825607359409332, -0.3725939691066742, 0.029358863830566406, 0.3888881802558899, 0.8362508416175842, -0.04839732497930527, -0.24953727424144745, 0.2663921117782593, 0.5170409083366394, 0.267203688621521, 0.17696250975131989, 0.7629871368408203, 0.03896152228116989, 0.3819293677806854, -0.015841668471693993, -0.2779448330402374, -0.32187873125076294, -0.7348909974098206, -0.5762380957603455, -0.569606363773346, -0.257021427154541, -0.4504935145378113, 0.24584871530532837, 0.909881055355072, 0.758819580078125, -0.7709157466888428, -0.20897608995437622, 0.3295346200466156, 0.025192469358444214, -0.0021718740463256836, -0.19854283332824707, 0.754182755947113, -0.2555328905582428, -0.5211479663848877, 0.2880326509475708, 0.5108104944229126, -0.15604040026664734, -0.512211263179779, 0.052001167088747025, 0.03568914905190468, 0.5528784394264221, 0.9014196395874023, 0.4429434835910797, -0.7923740744590759, -0.33291709423065186, -0.2027987539768219, -0.14612609148025513, -0.018968800082802773, 0.6098522543907166, -0.6912794709205627, 0.3702714145183563, 0.4145689904689789, 0.6794183254241943, 0.04537530243396759, -0.10909988731145859, 0.31176522374153137, -0.5893389582633972, 0.0715675875544548, 0.07616608589887619, 0.18162575364112854, 0.15502522885799408, -0.2781204581260681, 0.40079039335250854, 0.14381428062915802, -0.46912068128585815, -0.7574512958526611, 0.19591790437698364, -0.9493007659912109, -0.28413015604019165, 1.123233437538147, -0.2755005657672882, -0.42684176564216614, -0.2300398349761963, 0.22974886000156403, -0.07216164469718933, -0.18714803457260132, 0.925581157207489, 0.07756830006837845, -0.28782978653907776, 0.41546544432640076, -0.3254294991493225, 0.40174227952957153, 0.23535294830799103, -1.069534182548523, 0.2503710985183716, 0.21366018056869507, 0.4316931664943695, 0.22333969175815582, 0.38510140776634216, -0.18670760095119476, -0.19909906387329102, 0.06367625296115875, 0.4726194143295288, 0.1883661150932312, -0.40401479601860046, 0.406495064496994, 0.399591326713562, -0.16775335371494293, 0.3929627537727356 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04103v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04103v1
Improving Factual Accuracy of Neural Table-to-Text Output by Addressing Input Problems in ToTTo
2024-04-05T13:59:12
2024-04-05T13:59:12
Barkavi Sundararajan, Somayajulu Sripada, Ehud Reiter
cs.CL
cs.CL
Neural Table-to-Text models tend to hallucinate, producing texts that contain factual errors. We investigate whether such errors in the output can be traced back to problems with the input. We manually annotated 1,837 texts generated by multiple models in the politics domain of the ToTTo dataset. We identify the input problems that are responsible for many output errors and show that fixing these inputs reduces factual errors by between 52% and 76% (depending on the model). In addition, we observe that models struggle in processing tabular inputs that are structured in a non-standard way, particularly when the input lacks distinct row and column values or when the column headers are not correctly mapped to corresponding values.
[ -0.03628363832831383, -0.7731685638427734, 0.8964268565177917, 0.1254851371049881, 0.0005427835858426988, -0.216228187084198, -0.36390820145606995, -0.3363020718097687, 0.08902011066675186, 0.6688106656074524, -0.5952111482620239, -0.5864906907081604, -0.9372609853744507, 0.16210384666919708, -0.6362667083740234, 1.2505848407745361, 0.15870119631290436, 0.16608110070228577, -0.2935198247432709, 0.005516264121979475, -0.7896203398704529, -0.6444402933120728, -0.43324145674705505, -0.3634518086910248, 0.7225061655044556, 0.748358428478241, 0.6414642333984375, 0.8544455766677856, 0.5697641968727112, 0.35260698199272156, -0.022867919877171516, 0.37504246830940247, -0.6287240386009216, 0.0704861432313919, -0.39715176820755005, -0.6014088988304138, -0.38385412096977234, -0.29970312118530273, 0.7009921073913574, 0.8357192873954773, -0.05363013967871666, -0.013791331090033054, 0.15672874450683594, 0.760614812374115, -0.46389040350914, 0.3991561830043793, -0.6656217575073242, 0.16760677099227905, -0.3187544345855713, -0.4378419816493988, -0.8265719413757324, -0.4368465840816498, -0.12015805393457413, -0.5111854076385498, 0.36799296736717224, 0.011095955967903137, 0.9278294444084167, 0.592195451259613, -0.3373187780380249, -0.5642027258872986, -1.1026418209075928, 0.26541462540626526, -0.8436244130134583, 0.3116138279438019, 0.3689035475254059, -0.010810219682753086, -0.4373007118701935, -0.6460577249526978, -0.7366470694541931, -0.33122169971466064, -0.3909824788570404, 0.1090574711561203, 0.08460796624422073, 0.09610571712255478, 0.4399164617061615, -0.1376032531261444, -0.37959274649620056, -0.008859599009156227, -0.43066543340682983, -0.18008293211460114, 0.5709968209266663, 0.2005065381526947, 0.2967236042022705, -0.3439514636993408, 0.0822889432311058, -0.3737097680568695, -0.4824684262275696, -0.11235925555229187, 0.499436616897583, 0.6000810265541077, 0.23281310498714447, 0.9316976070404053, -0.15289577841758728, 0.8695957064628601, 0.2722446620464325, -0.003601753618568182, -0.17363159358501434, -0.4770808815956116, -0.1661168336868286, 0.40880921483039856, 0.6912738084793091, 0.25038963556289673, 0.08147809654474258, -0.41645386815071106, -0.3813588321208954, 0.025931475684046745, 0.47618138790130615, -0.6886410713195801, -0.24793794751167297, 0.3349907100200653, -0.2535788416862488, -0.4490160644054413, 0.016223734244704247, -1.1269491910934448, -0.8272735476493835, -0.30685341358184814, 0.7897298336029053, -0.1781894564628601, 0.03198154643177986, -0.159249946475029, -0.23965291678905487, -0.1647888422012329, 0.4780746400356293, -0.8618891835212708, 0.5401842594146729, 0.528333306312561, 0.8559727668762207, -0.10908745229244232, -0.2693040668964386, -0.5926961898803711, -0.0991704985499382, -0.8333737254142761, 1.1689189672470093, -0.13603761792182922, -0.1733204871416092, -0.027580304071307182, -0.19665975868701935, -0.274160236120224, -0.7286915183067322, 0.35934293270111084, -0.25353744626045227, 0.27749764919281006, -0.9469705820083618, -0.5482838153839111, -0.0801992416381836, 0.13612258434295654, -0.9704369902610779, 0.6198091506958008, -0.12037549167871475, -0.6351251006126404, 0.34200623631477356, -0.8717305660247803, -0.5100276470184326, -0.47217604517936707, -0.24322476983070374, -0.5133983492851257, 0.4989440143108368, -0.01184101589024067, 0.40528643131256104, -0.3365781903266907, 0.7797127366065979, -0.030491581186652184, -0.3021869957447052, 0.6139181852340698, -0.35013893246650696, 0.65774005651474, -0.24248452484607697, -0.4835444986820221, 0.4384985864162445, -1.1856434345245361, -0.36954110860824585, 0.17271845042705536, -0.25582900643348694, 0.05478554591536522, 0.37904855608940125, 0.10484131425619125, 0.12224128097295761, -0.18568092584609985, -0.49695542454719543, 0.07923561334609985, -0.24779166281223297, 0.3828299045562744, 0.6536926627159119, -0.04417292773723602, 0.4096272885799408, -0.5228663086891174, -0.15350709855556488, 0.4011671245098114, -0.36012113094329834, 0.03678075596690178, -0.5895503163337708, -0.9977805018424988, 0.1731034815311432, 0.7070779204368591, 0.6270992159843445, -0.8897322416305542, 0.3785984218120575, -0.3688107132911682, -0.36854860186576843, -0.1355753242969513, -0.3671573996543884, 0.058739617466926575, 1.2164571285247803, 0.38161852955818176, -0.1716626137495041, -0.29464495182037354, -0.8618322014808655, -0.21333329379558563, -0.22741490602493286, 0.23502007126808167, -0.01858125627040863, 0.7216646671295166, 0.17176394164562225, 0.9051539301872253, -0.20056696236133575, -0.4967137575149536, 0.13711215555667877, 0.4342729151248932, 0.007907253690063953, 0.5451533198356628, 0.21142540872097015, -0.4306515157222748, -0.17676013708114624, 0.0803363174200058, -0.6825501322746277, 0.04698482155799866, -0.5015265941619873, 0.02094665728509426, 0.5022933483123779, 0.27693095803260803, -0.6823108196258545, 0.7962795495986938, 0.2197176218032837, -0.5173078775405884, 0.515105664730072, -0.2291143238544464, 0.3712676465511322, -1.1531449556350708, 0.20618878304958344, -0.09235785901546478, -0.10056404024362564, -0.9657726883888245, -0.37524428963661194, 0.07759208232164383, -0.1367054432630539, -0.2910916805267334, 0.14269442856311798, -0.0775306224822998, -0.20621342957019806, -0.10494954884052277, 0.000046582466893596575, 0.19863662123680115, 0.5681282877922058, 0.15887826681137085, 0.9337897896766663, -0.07159358263015747, -0.4582222104072571, 0.4495038390159607, 0.3403419554233551, -0.2715361416339874, 0.3402586877346039, -0.7631874680519104, 0.22300897538661957, -0.30584439635276794, 0.08757991343736649, -1.5214580297470093, -0.487564355134964, 0.6701074838638306, -0.7474984526634216, 0.6400265693664551, 0.02154030278325081, -0.5755224823951721, 0.3186827301979065, -0.20608274638652802, 0.024652061983942986, 0.14302968978881836, -0.5594640374183655, 0.5715512037277222, 0.12138079106807709, 0.01131637953221798, -0.9241124987602234, -1.007481336593628, 0.2672465145587921, 0.04498807340860367, -0.5508155822753906, 0.5388776659965515, 0.34809789061546326, -0.115740567445755, 0.2501433193683624, -0.030139882117509842, -0.3937701880931854, -0.17568311095237732, -0.03479473665356636, 0.1620071530342102, -0.19794073700904846, 0.37969040870666504, 0.11796072125434875, 0.15888653695583344, 0.5658702850341797, -0.08711522817611694, 0.5190481543540955, 0.175639346241951, -0.10565166175365448, -0.7305333018302917, 0.3598956763744354, 0.6024426817893982, 0.02426641806960106, 0.9968978762626648, 0.28250977396965027, -0.6624367833137512, -0.2783677279949188, -0.47582438588142395, -0.3979712426662445, -0.4236222207546234, 0.8261374235153198, -0.14522138237953186, -0.2568654716014862, 0.8874344229698181, 0.22287556529045105, 0.05883348360657692, 0.8145865201950073, 0.5625699162483215, -0.2717004418373108, 0.7237814664840698, 0.4098862409591675, 0.35876229405403137, 0.1022576168179512, -0.08554904162883759, 0.1809992641210556, -0.44595855474472046, -0.6435038447380066, -1.062960147857666, -0.3036814033985138, -0.6752750277519226, -0.29514795541763306, 0.1305709332227707, -0.6666158437728882, -0.13772423565387726, -0.026285745203495026, -0.7011260390281677, 0.30009832978248596, 0.5475443005561829, 0.36463096737861633, 0.20248988270759583, 0.2302936464548111, 0.1662735641002655, -0.28629177808761597, -1.1487270593643188, -0.19971339404582977, 1.0721629858016968, 0.2665657103061676, 0.6232009530067444, -0.02926030568778515, 0.6418955326080322, 0.22836041450500488, 0.3889157772064209, -0.8560122847557068, 0.30615749955177307, -0.3721044361591339, -0.7101907730102539, -0.44216853380203247, -0.6965868473052979, -0.5284858345985413, -0.15704363584518433, -0.4950285851955414, -0.7314519286155701, 0.6720219254493713, 0.4056861698627472, -0.5245570540428162, 0.5271077752113342, -0.6347411870956421, 0.9026889204978943, -0.15087571740150452, -0.7289097905158997, 0.144356369972229, -0.5302926898002625, 0.5849225521087646, -0.07296493649482727, -0.0038773014675825834, 0.21635636687278748, 0.21768692135810852, 1.1036790609359741, -0.5420362949371338, 1.0602811574935913, -0.058592502027750015, -0.14894285798072815, 0.17971476912498474, 0.04311592876911163, 0.5728051662445068, 0.11111734807491302, -0.12167498469352722, 0.3306719958782196, -0.04595453664660454, -0.023604093119502068, -0.7106388807296753, 0.43971627950668335, -0.966385543346405, -0.7056674957275391, -0.8412591218948364, -0.7763870358467102, -0.2062971293926239, -0.10795307159423828, 0.8165673613548279, 0.6995247602462769, -0.005581611767411232, 0.28784459829330444, 0.9397443532943726, -0.295503169298172, 0.5410789847373962, -0.09490514546632767, -0.14366447925567627, -0.4448179602622986, 0.9576475024223328, 0.8304187059402466, -0.04521939158439636, 0.18334044516086578, 0.1179976612329483, -0.4788748621940613, -0.5231165885925293, -0.7350102066993713, 0.08967962861061096, -0.9340534210205078, -0.43214359879493713, -0.48915132880210876, -0.3405722379684448, -0.3167669177055359, 0.33407294750213623, -0.7132295966148376, -0.6530895829200745, -0.6486385464668274, 0.061879031360149384, 0.34181439876556396, 0.9595521688461304, 0.0006869241478852928, 0.358417272567749, -0.6537821888923645, 0.3908368647098541, 0.3135511577129364, 0.4329168498516083, -0.0177847221493721, -0.9650818109512329, 0.09255212545394897, 0.03334435820579529, -0.09946571290493011, -1.5539530515670776, 0.28791287541389465, 0.2134494036436081, 0.03974694758653641, 0.03906390443444252, -0.04644549638032913, 0.8414398431777954, -0.6652021408081055, 0.6462744474411011, 0.15044443309307098, -1.0970770120620728, 0.3834523856639862, -0.26650041341781616, 0.12073569744825363, 0.49979445338249207, 0.18522706627845764, -0.43318700790405273, 0.0514737032353878, -0.31858399510383606, -0.39874938130378723, 0.840729296207428, 0.24617986381053925, 0.10343282669782639, 0.17848865687847137, 0.6774176359176636, 0.11158031970262527, 0.15131419897079468, -0.7731867432594299, -0.05289389565587044, -0.44467660784721375, -0.12924626469612122, 0.17194996774196625, -0.3714633584022522, -0.2947882115840912, -0.3418401777744293, 0.509869396686554, 0.046624358743429184, 0.5334605574607849, 0.44783374667167664, 0.009445499628782272, -0.45498761534690857, 0.19934116303920746, 1.172428011894226, 0.9069806933403015, -0.11382461339235306, 0.0811840072274208, 0.16181156039237976, -0.2665313482284546, 0.055071648210287094, 0.016151562333106995, -0.4834279417991638, 0.35446375608444214, 0.22967982292175293, 0.775120735168457, -0.16808079183101654, -0.19909891486167908, 0.28276586532592773, -0.18173645436763763, -0.49741989374160767, -0.2452847808599472, -0.07854504138231277, 0.17650143802165985, -0.012472606264054775, 0.23604531586170197, 0.6309950947761536, 0.44964972138404846, -0.8283728957176208, 0.13145077228546143, 0.2383452206850052, -0.29624661803245544, -0.3424169421195984, 0.774505078792572, 0.040887538343667984, -0.576309323310852, 0.9824848175048828, 0.06837668269872665, -0.6023374199867249, 0.7902586460113525, 0.8096106648445129, 0.5359392166137695, -0.12224116176366806, 0.3130069971084595, 0.35404059290885925, 0.6303619146347046, -0.2878425121307373, 0.19971270859241486, 0.3967624306678772, -0.7737320065498352, -0.6159346103668213, -0.12193211913108826, -0.6408808827400208, 0.36898791790008545, -0.6160098910331726, 0.1856095939874649, -0.6536941528320312, -0.44863566756248474, 0.21833699941635132, 0.018353397026658058, -0.5238811373710632, 0.4040485620498657, 0.04920460283756256, 0.44271594285964966, -1.046600103378296, 0.6954993009567261, 0.5866128206253052, -0.42836490273475647, -0.8827729821205139, -0.1553567796945572, -0.3217301666736603, -0.2720324695110321, 0.6359458565711975, -0.08812225610017776, 0.0033940307330340147, -0.23106977343559265, -0.6024383306503296, -0.7471106052398682, 0.4855984151363373, 0.5975375175476074, -0.7515058517456055, -0.09793048352003098, 0.6892650723457336, 0.47036004066467285, -0.10924488306045532, -0.055921852588653564, 0.6646097898483276, 0.721639096736908, -0.027954895049333572, -0.6223003268241882, 0.131879985332489, -0.3282678425312042, -0.03247540444135666, 0.06992679089307785, -0.4499625265598297, 0.8950257897377014, -0.006184012163430452, 0.04483098164200783, -0.2846061885356903, 0.7002948522567749, 0.17018207907676697, 0.5646141767501831, 0.2533527612686157, 0.4147854447364807, 1.0018658638000488, -0.5629305839538574, 0.7830264568328857, -0.06465569883584976, 0.14499428868293762, 1.2698028087615967, -0.43937328457832336, 0.6869028210639954, 0.6564103364944458, 0.18859052658081055, 0.17716233432292938, 0.6230428814888, -0.24113918840885162, 0.36495575308799744, 0.17543943226337433, 0.23143818974494934, 0.21579855680465698, -0.06996617466211319, -0.305911123752594, 0.39960041642189026, 0.5931180715560913, -0.2713504135608673, -0.08280601352453232, -0.16589118540287018, 0.18820996582508087, 0.28314274549484253, -0.05548444017767906, 0.6883741021156311, -0.24678754806518555, -0.896777331829071, 0.49653345346450806, 0.05993786081671715, 0.31121060252189636, -0.25207242369651794, -0.3846697211265564, -0.4505201578140259, -0.03435411676764488, -0.4636927545070648, -0.38974177837371826, 0.8876088857650757, 0.061112381517887115, -0.38479048013687134, 0.035375941544771194, 0.8445693850517273, -0.49329325556755066, -0.59218829870224, -0.05472418665885925, 0.4656100571155548, -0.12822124361991882, -0.1355077028274536, -0.3409551978111267, 0.32541853189468384, -0.03375741466879845, -0.3317031264305115, 0.05356597900390625, 0.5284908413887024, 0.06440586596727371, 0.12808413803577423, 0.5010465383529663, 0.18516023457050323, 0.23319338262081146, -0.3782925009727478, 0.7706783413887024, -0.6364895701408386, -0.1978641003370285, -0.999893307685852, 0.6276710033416748, -0.2218393087387085, -0.5668612718582153, 0.36338213086128235, 0.31015005707740784, 0.7583483457565308, -0.3381642699241638, 0.5116965770721436, 0.0019578728824853897, 0.1841738075017929, -0.6374030709266663, 1.3017622232437134, -0.5072211027145386, 0.24114413559436798, 0.06573590636253357, -1.1118013858795166, -0.4469558000564575, 0.7663059234619141, -0.19066646695137024, 0.009563184343278408, 1.0322716236114502, 0.7449893355369568, 0.15414603054523468, -0.09986832737922668, 0.5282700061798096, 0.4679591953754425, 0.0277455635368824, 0.44370728731155396, 0.8713101148605347, -0.7266903519630432, 0.38638821244239807, -0.6154900789260864, 0.17108942568302155, -0.11257150024175644, -0.8167791962623596, -0.8069061636924744, -0.7590512037277222, -0.426909476518631, -0.6933976411819458, 0.49488574266433716, 0.8336144685745239, 0.6054138541221619, -0.9955361485481262, -0.3887089788913727, -0.1718159317970276, 0.20402920246124268, 0.00100522895809263, -0.1373731940984726, 0.5729877948760986, -0.6316829323768616, -0.5911655426025391, 0.21375906467437744, 0.030668694525957108, -0.2078234702348709, 0.10476068407297134, 0.37964293360710144, -0.13309410214424133, 0.3544912338256836, 0.44195353984832764, 0.0012525779893621802, -0.46980610489845276, -0.49585309624671936, 0.27828752994537354, -0.10935662686824799, 0.5118710398674011, 0.6801769137382507, -0.49968263506889343, 0.4536950886249542, 0.6784453988075256, 0.9168038368225098, 0.3174420893192291, -0.11390341073274612, 0.5472775101661682, -0.7250241041183472, 0.0384661890566349, 0.3074992597103119, 0.12444248050451279, 0.47517701983451843, -0.7193087339401245, 0.27661561965942383, 0.35427919030189514, -0.5360080599784851, -0.996974527835846, -0.2249039113521576, -0.8423817753791809, -0.3128220736980438, 0.8107782602310181, 0.10969877988100052, -0.5589128136634827, 0.06598649173974991, -0.015622425824403763, 0.8069782257080078, -0.24904298782348633, 1.2870770692825317, 1.003783941268921, 0.07480394095182419, -0.10746721178293228, -0.7192366719245911, 0.8364981412887573, 0.7087802886962891, -1.0859252214431763, 0.089359350502491, 0.5058353543281555, 0.19089938700199127, 0.3533073663711548, 0.26197296380996704, -0.08399152010679245, 0.6016885638237, 0.25844812393188477, 0.01707160845398903, -0.021973388269543648, -0.8280556201934814, -0.39543095231056213, 0.34804579615592957, 0.05824675038456917, -0.05193966627120972 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04102v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04102v2
ROPO: Robust Preference Optimization for Large Language Models
2024-04-05T13:58:51
2024-05-28T17:11:53
Xize Liang, Chao Chen, Shuang Qiu, Jie Wang, Yue Wu, Zhihang Fu, Zhihao Shi, Feng Wu, Jieping Ye
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
Preference alignment is pivotal for empowering large language models (LLMs) to generate helpful and harmless responses. However, the performance of preference alignment is highly sensitive to the prevalent noise in the preference data. Recent efforts for this problem either marginally alleviate the impact of noise without the ability to actually reduce its presence, or rely on costly teacher LLMs prone to reward misgeneralization. To address these challenges, we propose the RObust Preference Optimization (ROPO) framework, an iterative alignment approach that integrates noise-tolerance and filtering of noisy samples without the aid of external models. Specifically, ROPO iteratively solves a constrained optimization problem, where we dynamically assign a quality-aware weight for each sample and constrain the sum of the weights to the number of samples we intend to retain. For noise-tolerant training and effective noise identification, we derive a robust loss by suppressing the gradients of samples with high uncertainty. We demonstrate both empirically and theoretically that the derived loss is critical for distinguishing noisy samples from clean ones. Furthermore, inspired by our derived loss, we propose a robustness-guided rejection sampling technique to compensate for the potential important information in discarded queries. Experiments on three widely-used datasets with Mistral-7B and Llama-2-7B demonstrate that ROPO significantly outperforms existing preference alignment methods, with its superiority growing as the noise rate increases.
[ -0.20667479932308197, -0.3743877410888672, 0.3207379877567291, -0.023134924471378326, -0.2574443817138672, -0.14560487866401672, -0.3986946642398834, -0.34879106283187866, 0.06918299943208694, 0.5230172276496887, -0.5255459547042847, -0.23462209105491638, -0.5632566809654236, -0.19904610514640808, -0.12050534784793854, 0.785524308681488, 0.15516772866249084, 0.09496010839939117, -0.2838456332683563, -0.1362655907869339, -0.3028470277786255, -0.1571839153766632, -0.5660584568977356, -0.3438148498535156, 0.47930413484573364, 0.6383655071258545, 0.7739319801330566, 0.9823366403579712, 0.4141136109828949, 0.1788949817419052, -0.21935582160949707, 0.2039913386106491, -0.6867034435272217, 0.4852314293384552, -0.05511441454291344, -0.5290601849555969, -0.41533681750297546, -0.17181579768657684, 0.6842573285102844, 0.6105493903160095, -0.22996686398983002, 0.12546499073505402, 0.24168799817562103, 0.696457028388977, -0.8267763257026672, -0.18554705381393433, -0.8694767355918884, 0.2231866717338562, -0.2297353893518448, -0.165835440158844, -0.36966660618782043, -0.4501834511756897, 0.04412936791777611, -0.7034927606582642, 0.021548060700297356, 0.11740308254957199, 1.0747404098510742, 0.45442596077919006, -0.010777974501252174, -0.19294637441635132, -0.6311293244361877, 1.2104969024658203, -0.5318225026130676, 0.4796164035797119, 0.7456731796264648, 0.008753884583711624, -0.3726844787597656, -0.07378292828798294, -0.35014358162879944, -0.0062340544536709785, 0.2416549175977707, 0.20141594111919403, 0.04923504218459129, -0.17572130262851715, -0.1417655497789383, 0.3183676302433014, -0.5402070879936218, 0.289404958486557, -0.13518930971622467, -0.4013175368309021, 0.3392426669597626, -0.15396220982074738, 0.020664621144533157, 0.11962303519248962, -0.21237044036388397, -0.07327485829591751, -0.526401698589325, 0.2446483075618744, 0.8786603808403015, 0.6759489178657532, 0.1462482511997223, 0.39970892667770386, -0.08114305138587952, 0.8923829197883606, 0.1719127744436264, -0.6320731043815613, 0.10276377201080322, -0.2404797077178955, 0.040126413106918335, -0.016986429691314697, 0.956398606300354, 0.3551572561264038, 0.2875208258628845, 0.05209564045071602, -0.24831724166870117, -0.007350684609264135, 0.18521937727928162, -0.5596854090690613, -0.14197438955307007, 0.2757198214530945, -0.5922499299049377, -0.6602973937988281, -0.2849533259868622, -0.8927810788154602, -0.38128936290740967, -0.2327120453119278, 0.16700749099254608, -0.32379984855651855, -0.20677614212036133, 0.19434136152267456, 0.1550622582435608, 0.10315325111150742, 0.23406504094600677, -1.1371887922286987, 0.09955529868602753, 0.7071294188499451, 0.6448984146118164, -0.2211441993713379, -0.14361082017421722, -0.8742292523384094, -0.011041220277547836, -0.5123865008354187, 0.9373130202293396, -0.7959007620811462, -0.43122634291648865, -0.09241019189357758, -0.4279922544956207, 0.04420565813779831, -0.7489677667617798, 1.0391359329223633, -0.5048597455024719, 0.27923280000686646, -0.3007488250732422, -0.36160290241241455, 0.2180623561143875, 0.2465227246284485, -0.3887472152709961, 1.1130280494689941, 0.06168988719582558, -0.6446223855018616, 0.6606175303459167, -0.11453646421432495, -0.35878825187683105, -0.45060232281684875, 0.09635318070650101, -0.863438606262207, 0.12328016012907028, 0.0933220386505127, 0.02152169495820999, -0.30583786964416504, 0.15793344378471375, -0.6758720874786377, -0.2832333743572235, 0.19021260738372803, -0.18295705318450928, 0.7479644417762756, 0.41790762543678284, -0.005490872077643871, 0.43354395031929016, -0.960125744342804, 0.10336243361234665, 0.05670260637998581, -0.3333432078361511, -0.49127528071403503, 0.27504462003707886, -0.26892733573913574, -0.03915536031126976, 0.1841394156217575, -0.2207796424627304, 0.24138584733009338, -0.24714922904968262, 0.4371221959590912, 1.059348464012146, -0.39669445157051086, 0.6721286773681641, -0.30308154225349426, 0.4937971532344818, -0.23914185166358948, 0.4482288658618927, 0.38589727878570557, -0.34077367186546326, -0.5007842183113098, -0.6110650300979614, 0.25471794605255127, 0.46044790744781494, -0.10203634947538376, 0.6639421582221985, -0.3222677707672119, -0.260896772146225, -0.6652844548225403, 0.46942147612571716, 0.10626744478940964, 0.9665478467941284, 0.23833994567394257, -0.25182774662971497, -0.37254324555397034, -1.0016483068466187, -0.24009110033512115, -0.3299129605293274, -0.035673074424266815, 0.256996214389801, -0.14614981412887573, -0.07669753581285477, 0.8734437227249146, -0.3801864683628082, -0.4143882393836975, -0.004924444947391748, -0.28431302309036255, 0.17590861022472382, 0.4672240614891052, 0.43943312764167786, -0.6120681762695312, -0.5252159833908081, -0.10844610631465912, -0.15234975516796112, -0.5248197317123413, 0.13002720475196838, -0.38389652967453003, 0.004026370123028755, 0.14994819462299347, -0.12452800571918488, -0.011003008112311363, 0.5545411705970764, 0.03483377397060394, 0.38148605823516846, 0.06572090089321136, -0.12068036198616028, -1.0503746271133423, 0.07758290320634842, -0.1739463061094284, -0.3166164755821228, -0.38602039217948914, -0.29080259799957275, -0.00992847140878439, -0.019100695848464966, 0.004855890292674303, 0.3261309862136841, -0.37217122316360474, -0.14537537097930908, -0.4076349437236786, 0.1480732411146164, 0.11753921210765839, 0.2028866559267044, 0.30607274174690247, 0.7737539410591125, 0.6753169894218445, -0.5190216898918152, 0.011229903437197208, 0.25452882051467896, -0.17738693952560425, 0.6513791680335999, -0.3780284821987152, 0.15862871706485748, -0.15551142394542694, 0.07820547372102737, -0.9858935475349426, -0.12680545449256897, 0.5200806260108948, -0.44961532950401306, 0.30222398042678833, -0.4460158348083496, -0.0902055948972702, 0.06564570963382721, -0.5779277086257935, 0.3804805874824524, 0.40713581442832947, -0.5005278587341309, 0.3923748731613159, 0.4016556739807129, -0.21690523624420166, -1.0562320947647095, -0.4104709327220917, -0.2699044644832611, -0.4875096082687378, -0.32752999663352966, 0.09935007244348526, -0.0443737618625164, -0.20819878578186035, -0.128620445728302, -0.43625926971435547, -0.045540764927864075, 0.15034766495227814, 0.1257767677307129, 0.3908562958240509, -0.07144679874181747, 0.02210073545575142, -0.09822601079940796, -0.37917059659957886, -0.1857861578464508, -0.4777524769306183, 0.6483914256095886, 0.13158293068408966, -0.2481476068496704, -0.41317346692085266, 0.37760642170906067, 0.632621169090271, -0.17801962792873383, 0.4409232437610626, 0.5007696151733398, -0.21632370352745056, -0.28784269094467163, -0.38097965717315674, -0.1134897768497467, -0.44450369477272034, 0.25479432940483093, -0.3597152531147003, -0.7286521792411804, 0.5895371437072754, 0.13432563841342926, 0.25231248140335083, 0.126822829246521, 0.3173952102661133, 0.023825587704777718, 0.8124310374259949, 0.4400911331176758, -0.5161323547363281, 0.8647716045379639, 0.2272363007068634, 0.42933836579322815, -0.6426635384559631, 0.10467620939016342, -0.9946408867835999, -0.3219844102859497, -0.3611108064651489, -0.17389969527721405, 0.12377902865409851, 0.17627650499343872, -0.2048991322517395, 0.11548083275556564, -0.7262136340141296, 0.3898695409297943, 0.8349472284317017, -0.10719240456819534, 0.38103795051574707, 0.2910938262939453, 0.1745249480009079, -0.3480755686759949, -0.6582088470458984, -0.5120149254798889, 1.0666970014572144, 0.2556271255016327, 1.1100330352783203, 0.21118120849132538, 0.6162553429603577, 0.01987552084028721, 0.09471245110034943, -1.1507072448730469, 0.29595640301704407, -0.11608733981847763, -0.3082466721534729, -0.29476797580718994, -0.49557608366012573, -0.8013190627098083, 0.21206113696098328, -0.46025165915489197, -0.8296641111373901, 0.4916539490222931, 0.5005044341087341, -0.37988463044166565, 0.21891510486602783, -0.5102427005767822, 0.4944393038749695, -0.16091300547122955, -0.7555786371231079, -0.030157553032040596, -0.6944289803504944, 0.24390900135040283, -0.00916468258947134, 0.2548272907733917, -0.19677148759365082, -0.013113170862197876, 0.5536834001541138, -0.3146737813949585, 0.5694591999053955, -0.0391739197075367, -0.26815328001976013, 0.13818572461605072, 0.13091105222702026, 0.6387108564376831, -0.012640642002224922, -0.4018578827381134, -0.007850682362914085, -0.0005809537833556533, -0.3622658848762512, -0.3357006311416626, 0.8459810614585876, -0.8231974840164185, -0.4199875295162201, -0.2810262441635132, -0.6891673803329468, -0.37386247515678406, 0.4265764653682709, 0.528123676776886, 0.13819698989391327, 0.24428187310695648, 0.11759114265441895, 0.8128325343132019, -0.10468960553407669, 0.162244513630867, 0.27049437165260315, -0.18432536721229553, -0.6103708148002625, 1.1437090635299683, 0.14320455491542816, 0.49706217646598816, 0.37748122215270996, 0.6083568930625916, -0.4031957983970642, -0.7288864254951477, -0.2993316352367401, 0.0855080634355545, -0.46781691908836365, -0.21224479377269745, -0.377164751291275, 0.266769677400589, -0.5486592650413513, -0.30495813488960266, -0.7442510724067688, -0.3247479796409607, -0.26106026768684387, 0.04255635663866997, 0.057451799511909485, 0.17135392129421234, -0.185908243060112, 0.22547917068004608, -0.3646056652069092, 0.31054776906967163, 0.28519344329833984, 0.5867874026298523, -0.3101867437362671, -0.6625708937644958, 0.17808352410793304, -0.22596995532512665, -0.11353614926338196, -0.5888991355895996, 0.4187071621417999, 0.29357394576072693, 0.42079952359199524, 0.8394370675086975, 0.4467889964580536, 0.7798896431922913, -0.10301671177148819, 0.5709993839263916, -0.1362721472978592, -0.7797369956970215, 0.5558912754058838, -0.46644434332847595, -0.07619226723909378, 0.9020068645477295, 0.15434664487838745, -0.15805959701538086, -0.2206716388463974, -0.4502737820148468, -0.9830345511436462, 0.6334834098815918, -0.1275944709777832, -0.008671593852341175, 0.25395792722702026, 0.5424995422363281, 0.19374385476112366, 0.2497364580631256, -0.7893654704093933, -0.25356465578079224, -0.1825634390115738, -0.2622649073600769, 0.20894058048725128, -0.5154173970222473, -0.44993892312049866, 0.10958448797464371, 1.006909728050232, -0.37008675932884216, 0.1296173483133316, 0.10812338441610336, 0.19553178548812866, -0.33290895819664, 0.3320677578449249, 0.6470515727996826, 0.3522079288959503, -0.44662970304489136, 0.14635108411312103, -0.3026497960090637, -0.44000545144081116, 0.04595821350812912, -0.10680040717124939, -0.4465009570121765, -0.2255123406648636, 0.11989157646894455, 0.6449880599975586, -0.22094647586345673, -0.6106473207473755, 0.3762820065021515, -0.07148238271474838, -0.1575935333967209, -0.06007758527994156, 0.09490801393985748, -0.11936038732528687, -0.21081547439098358, 0.08976854383945465, 0.21625277400016785, 0.26917847990989685, -0.3638794422149658, -0.05663438141345978, 0.7031862139701843, -0.6400014162063599, -0.09894261509180069, 0.7054283618927002, -0.01705186814069748, -0.23242269456386566, 0.3573962450027466, 0.13235391676425934, -0.3542654812335968, 0.2718210220336914, 0.5457574129104614, 0.7159770727157593, -0.19063207507133484, -0.0428636372089386, 0.41268759965896606, 0.2723746597766876, -0.3342643082141876, 0.14698605239391327, -0.2764458656311035, -1.0745152235031128, -0.14296545088291168, -0.5225691199302673, -0.562351405620575, 0.11788955330848694, -0.9221071600914001, 0.2516050636768341, -0.608708381652832, -0.14261887967586517, -0.25284793972969055, -0.17545288801193237, -0.028430048376321793, 0.002190551720559597, -0.22819755971431732, 0.47561371326446533, -0.8125534057617188, 0.7016775608062744, 0.6378523707389832, 0.10289571434259415, -0.7165449261665344, 0.18018920719623566, 0.3688700497150421, -0.9056662917137146, 0.1339983344078064, -0.17466114461421967, -0.3916301727294922, -0.1835937350988388, -0.5543152093887329, -0.9982521533966064, 0.5776306986808777, 0.7075842022895813, -0.5178765654563904, 0.5440412163734436, -0.08752842992544174, 0.23489347100257874, -0.1392066925764084, -0.05774461850523949, 0.3295755684375763, 0.4885900914669037, 0.30761855840682983, -0.7960238456726074, -0.23483777046203613, -0.029938427731394768, -0.15006369352340698, 0.3348994851112366, -1.0122344493865967, 0.47947484254837036, -0.11401079595088959, 0.009196548722684383, 0.08845887333154678, 0.5670431852340698, 0.3437897264957428, 0.0797887071967125, 0.7714075446128845, 0.5175653100013733, 1.0478991270065308, -0.09023252874612808, 0.6607836484909058, -0.2893866002559662, 0.27653053402900696, 1.2800593376159668, -0.4780392050743103, 0.7881842255592346, 0.8480033278465271, -0.18004567921161652, -0.07400162518024445, 0.8664783835411072, 0.31672048568725586, 0.6693304181098938, 0.1745413988828659, -0.28353849053382874, -0.5216146111488342, -0.4415630102157593, -0.35788676142692566, 0.3256913125514984, 0.08401687443256378, -0.18716765940189362, 0.09215044975280762, -0.28653937578201294, 0.03079400025308132, 0.3081780970096588, -0.05049021914601326, 0.7451749444007874, -0.14581212401390076, -0.8110159635543823, 0.5469421148300171, -0.29533565044403076, 0.8076252341270447, -0.7960032224655151, 0.35355183482170105, -0.3077584207057953, 0.3656611740589142, -0.26093819737434387, -0.5112168788909912, 0.4178720712661743, -0.2951418161392212, -0.4799177944660187, -0.33502745628356934, 0.759856641292572, -0.47068291902542114, -0.3058481812477112, 0.22584180533885956, 0.11740099638700485, -0.15813571214675903, 0.1528373509645462, -0.49695903062820435, 0.3927876949310303, 0.2564755380153656, -0.27066177129745483, 0.5761180520057678, 0.13502632081508636, -0.09386623650789261, 0.8444092869758606, 0.5981172919273376, 0.3542921841144562, -0.14436589181423187, 0.02914215810596943, 0.6385350823402405, -0.24719375371932983, -0.4698988199234009, -0.6018743515014648, 0.25777357816696167, -0.015522507019340992, -0.3879382014274597, 0.43366068601608276, 0.5624019503593445, 0.6485556960105896, 0.07457141578197479, 0.7922780513763428, 0.1328655332326889, 0.6441344022750854, -0.38641679286956787, 0.4431600570678711, -0.6234129667282104, 0.4629385471343994, -0.3523891270160675, -1.0109399557113647, -0.5527374148368835, 1.0223312377929688, -0.11392311006784439, -0.1647898107767105, 0.20724311470985413, 1.1278231143951416, -0.10302811115980148, -0.25014281272888184, 0.25457438826560974, -0.09893228113651276, 0.3968317210674286, 0.289307177066803, 0.5343493223190308, -0.28879278898239136, 0.6290690898895264, -0.30983901023864746, -0.2606380581855774, -0.15690192580223083, -1.0169895887374878, -0.3824958801269531, -0.3886938989162445, -0.4445330798625946, -0.4862388074398041, -0.029140694066882133, 1.0062291622161865, 0.7720935940742493, -0.8836154937744141, -0.19877375662326813, 0.08050461858510971, 0.42990416288375854, -0.40367844700813293, -0.2547678053379059, 0.3157241940498352, -0.35148003697395325, -1.0778117179870605, 0.479148268699646, 0.2688610851764679, 0.029994087293744087, 0.037179701030254364, -0.02519434317946434, 0.030419308692216873, -0.06897676736116409, 0.2866261899471283, 0.5877635478973389, -0.5929628014564514, -0.49083563685417175, 0.1454918533563614, -0.05871707201004028, 0.14307886362075806, 0.6561193466186523, -0.3503269851207733, 0.6559649705886841, 0.6174113750457764, 0.6111355423927307, -0.034129802137613297, 0.14315682649612427, 0.720919132232666, -0.47974300384521484, 0.28080108761787415, 0.1690886914730072, 0.3733541667461395, 0.27079659700393677, -0.4324797987937927, 0.4856258034706116, 0.21758431196212769, -0.7074636816978455, -1.0945944786071777, 0.22483301162719727, -1.260953426361084, -0.020400257781147957, 1.220438838005066, 0.08320760726928711, -0.049719542264938354, -0.17993520200252533, -0.36345821619033813, -0.13464480638504028, -0.751085102558136, 0.9816756248474121, 0.8361231684684753, -0.2493586242198944, -0.21444310247898102, -0.33172500133514404, 0.5608888864517212, 0.7904123067855835, -0.24868570268154144, 0.25241565704345703, 0.7043096423149109, 0.3972456455230713, 0.17256073653697968, 0.6326273679733276, -0.19014976918697357, -0.0650864765048027, -0.14539898931980133, 0.04947490617632866, 0.04124893993139267, -0.042310599237680435, -0.35814404487609863, 0.43949761986732483, 0.5200121998786926, -0.35028335452079773 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04068v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04068v2
Assessing the quality of information extraction
2024-04-05T12:51:48
2024-05-22T09:04:52
Filip Seitl, Tomáš Kovářík, Soheyla Mirshahi, Jan Kryštůfek, Rastislav Dujava, Matúš Ondreička, Herbert Ullrich, Petr Gronat
cs.CL
cs.CL
Advances in large language models have notably enhanced the efficiency of information extraction from unstructured and semi-structured data sources. As these technologies become integral to various applications, establishing an objective measure for the quality of information extraction becomes imperative. However, the scarcity of labeled data presents significant challenges to this endeavor. In this paper, we introduce an automatic framework to assess the quality of the information extraction/retrieval and its completeness. The framework focuses on information extraction in the form of entity and its properties. We discuss how to handle the input/output size limitations of the large language models and analyze their performance when extracting the information. In particular, we introduce scores to evaluate the quality of the extraction and provide an extensive discussion on how to interpret them.
[ -0.3713356852531433, -0.914683997631073, 0.5977216958999634, 0.19439226388931274, -0.24231286346912384, 0.03497166931629181, -0.42791393399238586, -0.6574647426605225, -0.008706990629434586, 0.4838261008262634, 0.2217911034822464, -0.4815165102481842, -0.9501484036445618, 0.10735313594341278, -0.7756766080856323, 0.8169538378715515, -0.19662684202194214, -0.12798796594142914, -0.06728784739971161, 0.07336081564426422, -0.47663989663124084, -0.2763470709323883, -0.4390003979206085, -0.12645941972732544, -0.03919897601008415, 0.3771463930606842, 0.8191454410552979, 1.1699364185333252, 0.842270016670227, 0.38735395669937134, 0.16669724881649017, -0.038068193942308426, -0.3659217357635498, 0.2525395452976227, -0.5722428560256958, -0.045836713165044785, -0.30189743638038635, 0.20049773156642914, 0.9201677441596985, 0.7643229961395264, -0.28156667947769165, 0.687233567237854, 0.1336030811071396, 0.17189405858516693, -0.5171838402748108, 0.47755008935928345, -0.4257478415966034, -0.022260630503296852, -0.15336216986179352, -0.30589765310287476, -0.3699377477169037, -0.4136140048503876, 0.32667046785354614, -0.3736083507537842, 0.0006945283384993672, 0.2062707394361496, 1.2080302238464355, 0.21072308719158173, -0.33114710450172424, -0.6151903867721558, -1.0124270915985107, 0.8595343232154846, -0.46778303384780884, 0.5092014670372009, 0.35459277033805847, 0.4651435613632202, -0.11286754906177521, -0.824001669883728, -0.48631027340888977, -0.21947695314884186, -0.007926969788968563, -0.07898784428834915, -0.25849649310112, 0.012160670012235641, 0.19853854179382324, 0.7191098928451538, -0.3827971816062927, 0.06714928150177002, -0.4146672785282135, -0.15866084396839142, 0.7324702143669128, -0.2052895426750183, 0.5201395153999329, -0.5099900960922241, -0.22860272228717804, -0.04302482679486275, -0.09879165887832642, -0.06291120499372482, 0.39085790514945984, 0.15684069693088531, 0.5451518893241882, 0.864754855632782, -0.2723168134689331, 0.6690984964370728, -0.10058536380529404, -0.3207070231437683, 0.021534351631999016, -0.5711038708686829, -0.463005006313324, -0.07007952034473419, 0.7697528004646301, 0.09506943076848984, -0.001797259203158319, -0.4869984984397888, -0.70509934425354, -0.4608232080936432, 0.24870477616786957, -0.7599995732307434, -0.22394566237926483, 0.31495413184165955, -0.8072735071182251, -0.08814612776041031, 0.41351866722106934, -1.0751316547393799, -0.09304556995630264, -0.4697725772857666, 0.5929468274116516, -0.30918508768081665, -0.5105934143066406, -0.08417820185422897, -0.22438471019268036, 0.08223692327737808, 0.2995782494544983, -0.6417418718338013, 0.38902461528778076, 0.45164063572883606, 0.6752023696899414, -0.6067192554473877, 0.33169883489608765, -0.7578678131103516, -0.04127129539847374, -0.2792374789714813, 0.7524102926254272, -0.7307693958282471, -0.04354076087474823, -0.330275297164917, -0.012931330129504204, 0.14333273470401764, -0.8114845752716064, 0.633829653263092, -0.7117618322372437, 0.14423169195652008, 0.017391258850693703, -0.8166442513465881, -0.2072766125202179, 0.17011158168315887, -1.026689887046814, 1.136922836303711, 0.5635334849357605, -0.3580430746078491, 0.3673988878726959, -0.6474284529685974, -0.2636708617210388, 0.3438277542591095, 0.0018151518888771534, -0.0788559541106224, 0.10106690227985382, 0.05914481729269028, 0.3577446937561035, -0.7495976686477661, 0.6156136989593506, -0.17244207859039307, -0.11915338784456253, 0.33477187156677246, -0.3185124099254608, 0.6496829390525818, 0.38825494050979614, -0.31479737162590027, -0.18524448573589325, -1.051883339881897, 0.3758102357387543, -0.03953881561756134, -0.8248034119606018, -0.20986326038837433, -0.022539358586072922, 0.08195299655199051, 0.26665613055229187, 0.49846184253692627, -0.6399716734886169, 0.07012632489204407, -0.2754645049571991, 0.31507670879364014, 0.5350537300109863, 0.21117058396339417, 0.5940901041030884, 0.2573963701725006, 0.39041760563850403, -0.2017628401517868, 0.20313569903373718, 0.23484189808368683, 0.041412051767110825, -0.7516260743141174, -0.643781304359436, 1.022350788116455, 0.5456291437149048, -0.667953372001648, 0.9637247920036316, -0.4580673575401306, -0.5160060524940491, -0.6027470827102661, 0.4203036427497864, 0.18639977276325226, 0.387417197227478, 0.42956969141960144, -0.5550392866134644, -0.3453439176082611, -0.7544474601745605, 0.015658413991332054, -0.12211640924215317, -0.2731335759162903, 0.10342288762331009, 0.4710858464241028, 0.09561924636363983, 1.0579184293746948, -0.24470174312591553, -0.01766602322459221, -0.20627433061599731, 0.4294101893901825, 0.3538234531879425, 0.6018664240837097, 0.027340270578861237, -1.0632890462875366, -0.019526908174157143, 0.044022269546985626, -1.0648515224456787, -0.2028988003730774, -0.06291250139474869, -0.21978190541267395, -0.31311172246932983, 0.11959616839885712, -0.6821640133857727, 0.43295004963874817, 0.1759369969367981, -0.031414516270160675, 0.40794992446899414, 0.04059801250696182, 0.3738565444946289, -0.6475911140441895, 0.5841219425201416, 0.1467130035161972, -0.33012163639068604, -0.34658902883529663, 0.21509036421775818, -0.03995504975318909, -0.09621868282556534, -0.14940030872821808, 0.45438912510871887, -0.7247571349143982, -0.703880250453949, -0.10496454685926437, 0.3711463510990143, 0.36578574776649475, 0.11470131576061249, 0.01373797282576561, 0.5739361047744751, 0.10937562584877014, -0.6505221724510193, 0.7183962464332581, 0.04045144468545914, -0.6726459264755249, 0.5501200556755066, -0.6164989471435547, -0.010706773027777672, -0.2880162298679352, -0.23799781501293182, -0.8133814334869385, -0.3249109089374542, -0.0547969676554203, -0.3668294847011566, 0.5812532901763916, -0.14115731418132782, -0.948657751083374, -0.25717929005622864, 0.03930060565471649, -0.03649206459522247, 0.3035658299922943, -0.3769344687461853, 0.572329580783844, 0.7494302988052368, -0.46556177735328674, -0.5267736315727234, -0.09954944252967834, 0.149250790476799, -0.20650072395801544, -0.39083561301231384, -0.009308363310992718, 0.04959974065423012, -0.4625471234321594, 0.29050731658935547, -0.16290169954299927, -0.5486190915107727, 0.3867751657962799, -0.09984758496284485, 0.4028816521167755, -0.2973968982696533, 0.4688543975353241, 0.07185383141040802, 0.07289918512105942, 0.04605390504002571, -0.3825678825378418, 0.2763235569000244, 0.12768889963626862, -0.17282575368881226, -0.3687659204006195, 0.4342779815196991, 0.3628949820995331, -0.4838156998157501, 0.4679863452911377, 0.4218335449695587, -0.7160989046096802, 0.11313684284687042, -0.5354588627815247, 0.13937826454639435, -0.3307839035987854, 0.5536659955978394, -0.27325311303138733, -0.407783180475235, 0.27535027265548706, -0.14338178932666779, -0.009971879422664642, 0.8311177492141724, 0.17534388601779938, 0.021587079390883446, 1.0336788892745972, 0.7508794665336609, 0.026358485221862793, 0.3153129518032074, -0.14349085092544556, 0.4005896747112274, -0.5367397665977478, -0.3544071316719055, -0.8155987858772278, 0.02930915541946888, -0.09769236296415329, 0.03494181111454964, 0.17507275938987732, 0.7263618111610413, -0.013197916559875011, 0.4781564772129059, -0.6657930016517639, 0.3353499174118042, 0.30643558502197266, -0.1531374454498291, 0.5186851024627686, 0.013094553723931313, 0.279258131980896, 0.08606117218732834, -0.1779332458972931, -0.9923163652420044, 0.9764275550842285, 0.5686025023460388, 0.471049964427948, 0.30840885639190674, 0.46268683671951294, 0.6166217923164368, 0.39165616035461426, -0.7853336930274963, 0.2559112310409546, 0.03059583716094494, -0.7058600783348083, -0.5811988711357117, -0.7491065263748169, -0.8124155402183533, 0.017587020993232727, -0.3250986635684967, -1.1254814863204956, 0.2497638463973999, -0.11933688074350357, -0.36029696464538574, -0.03717479854822159, -0.6202473044395447, 0.8005812764167786, -0.3010636866092682, -0.32282206416130066, 0.22760336101055145, -0.47686970233917236, 0.3173063099384308, -0.4805792570114136, 0.23899994790554047, -0.27151811122894287, -0.011614175513386726, 1.0308308601379395, -0.11557915061712265, 0.08550599962472916, -0.17419175803661346, -0.0859619528055191, 0.4517520070075989, 0.23855535686016083, 0.38022559881210327, -0.056910593062639236, -0.41607674956321716, 0.1998874843120575, 0.3884754180908203, -0.2317994385957718, -0.8457750082015991, 0.32119524478912354, -0.48602449893951416, -0.19776950776576996, -0.11840642988681793, -0.225626602768898, -0.02410929650068283, 0.6867283582687378, 0.290757954120636, 0.3557650148868561, -0.22702202200889587, 0.038466017693281174, 0.5747208595275879, -0.3411436676979065, 0.2546418607234955, 0.37047141790390015, -0.1681669056415558, -0.2397495061159134, 1.1628620624542236, 0.5551572442054749, 0.04469718411564827, 0.308112770318985, -0.13450482487678528, -0.7342442870140076, -0.574118435382843, -0.6847114562988281, -0.03896556794643402, -0.9503350257873535, -0.41214844584465027, -0.6873236894607544, -0.43003734946250916, -0.3336625099182129, 0.6818112134933472, -0.38940688967704773, -0.4085889160633087, -0.4968735873699188, -0.16037757694721222, -0.2529880106449127, 0.9534861445426941, 0.05485670268535614, -0.0011558652622625232, -1.0207438468933105, 0.1456519216299057, 0.10019127279520035, 0.2934010326862335, -0.11472896486520767, -0.48916077613830566, -0.13414432108402252, -0.1931370347738266, -0.05563756451010704, -0.8121614456176758, 0.36207181215286255, 0.04528065025806427, 0.739957332611084, 0.409284383058548, 0.10165010392665863, 0.47263893485069275, -0.09441307187080383, 0.6976073980331421, -0.002739128191024065, -1.1059986352920532, 0.5958150625228882, 0.20082879066467285, -0.3056893050670624, 0.574686586856842, 0.4839865267276764, 0.006436881609261036, -0.2835131883621216, -0.7860953211784363, -0.8067944645881653, 0.491461843252182, 0.20411407947540283, -0.259933203458786, -0.04541616886854172, 0.447329580783844, 0.14580664038658142, 0.455956369638443, -0.6080806255340576, 0.08991628885269165, -0.06695413589477539, -0.4011191725730896, 0.1378214955329895, -0.4724196493625641, 0.13749712705612183, 0.09658397734165192, 0.48719337582588196, 0.16983281075954437, 0.25379592180252075, 0.11912555992603302, -0.5555412769317627, -0.09866849333047867, 0.46977847814559937, -0.08941678702831268, 1.111541509628296, -0.2540144622325897, 0.3642648458480835, -0.22300156950950623, -0.20287810266017914, 0.14721621572971344, 0.318946897983551, -0.0774184912443161, 0.11250124126672745, 0.5338946580886841, 0.2683241069316864, -0.17383147776126862, -0.7582978010177612, 0.7059063911437988, -0.10532251000404358, 0.3271404206752777, -0.15915292501449585, 0.08814413845539093, -0.4648503363132477, 0.1336599439382553, 0.4790995419025421, -0.33437618613243103, 0.7162290215492249, -0.47407838702201843, 0.5131367444992065, 0.15264452993869781, -0.38288265466690063, -0.12150853127241135, 0.12124503403902054, -0.04263119772076607, -0.09490736573934555, 0.9256401062011719, -0.3026614189147949, -0.21757109463214874, 0.5302460789680481, 0.2649580240249634, 0.2625780999660492, -0.1505133956670761, 0.08428800106048584, 0.5773630738258362, 0.47188326716423035, -0.3413555324077606, 0.006806180812418461, -0.23863448202610016, -0.49952518939971924, -0.578400194644928, -0.8824272751808167, -0.05689902976155281, 0.26462385058403015, -0.9477241635322571, 0.037472423166036606, -0.25647473335266113, -0.2919550836086273, 0.34962934255599976, 0.21123865246772766, -0.7546786069869995, 0.49066680669784546, -0.20035094022750854, 0.8181610107421875, -0.6432119607925415, 0.67489093542099, 0.2835870385169983, -0.7423827648162842, -0.8599571585655212, -0.28950873017311096, -0.2908318042755127, -0.5102320313453674, 0.9025452136993408, 0.03575548902153969, 0.15418702363967896, 0.03299855440855026, -0.6355206370353699, -1.1895129680633545, 0.7584547996520996, 0.4864656925201416, -0.3576878607273102, -0.012800519354641438, -0.07149878889322281, 0.48862749338150024, -0.19716395437717438, 0.4233267903327942, 1.0460869073867798, 0.6503897309303284, -0.10422997921705246, -0.9967756867408752, 0.09431447088718414, -0.3343396484851837, -0.06192786619067192, 0.18497803807258606, 0.1421857327222824, 0.7264538407325745, 0.21850933134555817, -0.8285211324691772, 0.04355742409825325, 0.7161822319030762, -0.5815418362617493, -0.03083018772304058, 0.5076501965522766, 0.17497040331363678, 1.2238905429840088, -0.008578614331781864, 0.9444926381111145, -0.060865845531225204, 0.5621262788772583, 1.013398289680481, -0.24832499027252197, 0.9630635380744934, 0.16904588043689728, -0.04172574728727341, 0.04734811931848526, 0.681035578250885, -0.2421574890613556, 0.20775870978832245, 0.28689709305763245, -0.012549806386232376, -0.2549009323120117, -0.3728523850440979, -0.03901487961411476, 0.770637571811676, 0.4169803857803345, -0.6919505000114441, -0.2585808336734772, 0.02842632681131363, -0.056080255657434464, -0.10403347760438919, -0.0831979364156723, 0.9895137548446655, -0.24268081784248352, -0.8700440526008606, 0.3486972153186798, 0.25933387875556946, -0.009888905100524426, -0.1189655214548111, -0.42780962586402893, -0.06080475077033043, -0.2797223627567291, -0.2617623805999756, -1.0000135898590088, 0.3108772337436676, 0.16034285724163055, -0.3508623242378235, 0.15794384479522705, 0.6610485315322876, -0.4417443871498108, -0.400216281414032, 0.40642625093460083, 0.46714287996292114, 0.6651090979576111, -0.0462263859808445, -0.5508632659912109, 0.09278619289398193, -0.07847119122743607, -0.20052199065685272, 0.16942746937274933, 0.5602590441703796, 0.06747059524059296, 0.46126067638397217, 0.5371391773223877, 0.40731802582740784, -0.0899028331041336, -0.38298532366752625, 0.6243858337402344, -0.6013152003288269, -0.062437742948532104, -0.7196479439735413, 0.24506284296512604, -0.6644049882888794, -0.22068609297275543, 0.45990484952926636, 0.6077695488929749, 0.5632960200309753, 0.509440004825592, 0.768326997756958, -0.35638663172721863, 0.49941638112068176, -0.6042572855949402, 0.6124199032783508, -0.4574589133262634, 0.2911805510520935, -0.2535591721534729, -1.307508945465088, -0.00282844714820385, 0.5610212683677673, -0.18488849699497223, -0.1733204424381256, 0.5993263721466064, 0.5679875016212463, -0.26834917068481445, -0.03751366212964058, 0.24455779790878296, 0.11739019304513931, 0.316532164812088, 0.26500192284584045, 0.8264567852020264, -0.3572221100330353, 0.5987577438354492, -0.007886512205004692, -0.6834368705749512, 0.01975645124912262, -0.7874359488487244, -0.3776554465293884, -0.6469262838363647, -0.2900936007499695, -0.5079509615898132, -0.24116310477256775, 0.7565269470214844, 0.7422068119049072, -0.6618048548698425, 0.06445591151714325, 0.3725028336048126, 0.22199203073978424, 0.017549363896250725, -0.33059921860694885, 0.6378551721572876, -0.2632344663143158, -0.6635253429412842, 0.27808862924575806, 0.48960262537002563, -0.0006536747678183019, -0.17184783518314362, 0.32016441226005554, -0.1394333392381668, -0.08333776891231537, 0.538357138633728, 0.35753723978996277, -0.285591185092926, -0.5075711011886597, -0.24713002145290375, -0.4051615297794342, 0.22237113118171692, 0.4208481013774872, -0.18567048013210297, 0.6124993562698364, 0.347123920917511, 0.9182833433151245, 0.2881380617618561, 0.1832287609577179, 0.5782260298728943, -0.5119706392288208, -0.48329973220825195, 0.17511136829853058, 0.2430526167154312, 0.4072427749633789, -0.5177342891693115, 0.545639157295227, -0.02595844864845276, -0.49628746509552, -0.8677477836608887, -0.18390825390815735, -0.7680897116661072, -0.15345525741577148, 1.177716612815857, -0.5570692420005798, -0.40761446952819824, -0.37288615107536316, -0.09834923595190048, 0.554251492023468, -0.34689825773239136, 0.7203860282897949, 0.9391143321990967, 0.0137473214417696, 0.004881443455815315, -0.7602065205574036, 0.19170477986335754, -0.10236692428588867, -1.0470529794692993, -0.11660344153642654, 0.569072961807251, 0.3830384910106659, 0.468070924282074, 0.6277973651885986, -0.3850160241127014, 0.045182082802057266, -0.26361215114593506, 0.35601603984832764, 0.29176586866378784, -0.4663951098918915, -0.2207261621952057, 0.5726680159568787, 0.20992295444011688, -0.13164696097373962 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04067v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04067v3
CLUE: A Clinical Language Understanding Evaluation for LLMs
2024-04-05T12:51:37
2024-06-24T12:32:41
Amin Dada, Marie Bauer, Amanda Butler Contreras, Osman Alperen Koraş, Constantin Marc Seibold, Kaleb E Smith, Jens Kleesiek
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Large Language Models (LLMs) are expected to significantly contribute to patient care, diagnostics, and administrative processes. Emerging biomedical LLMs aim to address healthcare-specific challenges, including privacy demands and computational constraints. Assessing the models' suitability for this sensitive application area is of the utmost importance. However, evaluation has primarily been limited to non-clinical tasks, which do not reflect the complexity of practical clinical applications. To fill this gap, we present the Clinical Language Understanding Evaluation (CLUE), a benchmark tailored to evaluate LLMs on clinical tasks. CLUE includes six tasks to test the practical applicability of LLMs in complex healthcare settings. Our evaluation includes a total of $25$ LLMs. In contrast to previous evaluations, CLUE shows a decrease in performance for nine out of twelve biomedical models. Our benchmark represents a step towards a standardized approach to evaluating and developing LLMs in healthcare to align future model development with the real-world needs of clinical application. We open-source all evaluation scripts and datasets for future research at https://github.com/TIO-IKIM/CLUE.
[ 0.29525530338287354, -0.47315800189971924, 0.994179368019104, 0.3871477544307709, -0.4452429711818695, 0.023197833448648453, -0.3707352876663208, -0.6416997313499451, -0.014501211233437061, 0.3225077688694, -0.6698914766311646, -1.0887027978897095, -0.7777878046035767, 0.2274819314479828, -0.2257290482521057, 0.6664644479751587, -0.009033630602061749, 0.5046254396438599, -0.651662290096283, -0.12251034379005432, -0.4963628649711609, -0.06691446900367737, -0.6188151240348816, -0.4600154757499695, 0.5616649985313416, 0.14614833891391754, 0.3001008927822113, 0.8983259201049805, 0.9124877452850342, 0.25101783871650696, -0.18638430535793304, 0.03325480595231056, -0.6128748655319214, 0.12745165824890137, -0.09828633815050125, -0.692367672920227, -0.6138505935668945, -0.0667826235294342, 0.48889681696891785, 1.0792880058288574, -0.13874414563179016, 0.21709448099136353, -0.40535807609558105, 0.5526080131530762, -0.6662437319755554, 0.41113555431365967, -0.5998411774635315, -0.03739982843399048, -0.24255533516407013, -0.10912129282951355, -0.4024706482887268, -0.30611297488212585, 0.354804664850235, -0.5954281091690063, 0.2549355924129486, -0.07902363687753677, 0.40281736850738525, 0.30615729093551636, -0.3232097327709198, -0.5794534683227539, -0.1777896136045456, 0.6157124638557434, -0.9438365697860718, 0.5842968225479126, 0.28550586104393005, 0.387626588344574, -0.24632401764392853, -0.8235659599304199, -0.21086260676383972, -0.36631640791893005, -0.026911327615380287, 0.2465101033449173, -0.057713914662599564, 0.2703474462032318, 0.2154257744550705, 0.3271925151348114, -0.7607364654541016, 0.2924301028251648, -0.20710952579975128, -0.2757236659526825, 0.5956759452819824, 0.44785305857658386, 0.36813437938690186, -0.011129175312817097, -0.3062931299209595, 0.25071585178375244, -0.788638174533844, -0.00945906713604927, -0.3508126437664032, 0.3438531756401062, -0.4895877540111542, 0.41618141531944275, -0.1528579294681549, 0.7216669917106628, -0.4190620183944702, -0.5077784061431885, 0.2100285440683365, -0.3525635600090027, -0.3788211941719055, 0.06747111678123474, 0.7891895174980164, 0.5385794639587402, -0.023129209876060486, -0.49251729249954224, -0.039314161986112595, 0.3270341157913208, 0.0533725880086422, -0.8360698819160461, -0.1165444627404213, 0.5330095887184143, -0.48285529017448425, -0.3038072884082794, -0.5411874055862427, -0.47386783361434937, -0.8125437498092651, -0.001489690039306879, 0.10689213126897812, -0.5247698426246643, 0.02470557764172554, 0.5366679430007935, -0.0178554467856884, 0.25117477774620056, 0.48169782757759094, -0.5911322832107544, 0.26148730516433716, 0.9647741913795471, 0.980375349521637, -0.25469592213630676, 0.01877027563750744, -0.621665894985199, 0.006153447553515434, -0.2865411639213562, 0.8914294838905334, -0.5552398562431335, -0.6178051829338074, 0.033913955092430115, -0.07216974347829819, -0.3373074531555176, -0.7130616307258606, 0.8644081950187683, -0.27097344398498535, -0.23162667453289032, -0.2365218997001648, -0.8961650133132935, 0.193040668964386, 0.21044643223285675, -0.4316187798976898, 0.5255880355834961, 0.08922875672578812, -0.573910117149353, 0.469637930393219, -0.6537474393844604, -0.36395660042762756, 0.6269625425338745, -0.37375473976135254, -0.23112724721431732, 0.25726526975631714, 0.10399549454450607, 0.31121528148651123, -0.7360792756080627, 0.3353341817855835, -0.5688920021057129, -0.5083600282669067, 0.4632764756679535, 0.006620647851377726, 0.6990211606025696, 0.17289139330387115, -0.1285669207572937, 0.19955669343471527, -0.7684524059295654, 0.04731316119432449, 0.046711042523384094, -0.12938201427459717, -0.33571016788482666, -0.018367189913988113, -0.1548728048801422, 0.011881071142852306, 0.3990337550640106, -0.576208233833313, 0.021360863000154495, -0.5461925268173218, 0.3446803092956543, 0.43876487016677856, -0.13663798570632935, 0.03814791887998581, -0.22075331211090088, 0.8299317955970764, -0.16509442031383514, 0.31769657135009766, -0.23844130337238312, -0.5363451242446899, -0.5833254456520081, -0.6377946734428406, 0.2716553211212158, 0.37287670373916626, -0.34394219517707825, 0.2543216049671173, -0.2535805106163025, -0.5337579846382141, -0.9818622469902039, 0.09207594394683838, 0.8315890431404114, 0.539044976234436, 0.2167251855134964, -0.07428871840238571, -0.2825171947479248, -0.8755811452865601, -0.5166564583778381, -0.09978307038545609, -0.18773290514945984, 0.6026979088783264, 0.42216652631759644, -0.43345922231674194, 0.5702311396598816, -0.37882813811302185, -0.27700579166412354, -0.1144939437508583, 0.07215583324432373, 0.30503806471824646, 0.07499013841152191, 0.27959874272346497, -0.274921178817749, -0.2684418559074402, 0.13251422345638275, -0.868742823600769, -0.25212690234184265, 0.2484494149684906, 0.08752446621656418, -0.23846301436424255, 0.6159931421279907, -0.5124474167823792, 0.443970263004303, 0.6777514815330505, -0.4290468394756317, 0.5612468719482422, -0.3254445791244507, -0.17324791848659515, -0.6708985567092896, 0.2384190410375595, -0.21318373084068298, -0.2652578353881836, -0.4955903887748718, 0.17011168599128723, 0.3155072033405304, -0.060949649661779404, -0.3951340615749359, 0.6625331044197083, -0.5594124794006348, -0.0016780149890109897, -0.032785650342702866, 0.47312888503074646, -0.03770775347948074, -0.10474911332130432, -0.023237144574522972, 0.6503254771232605, 0.7133706212043762, -0.4568256139755249, 0.24507583677768707, 0.08331958204507828, -0.796143651008606, 0.5220329165458679, -0.8579719662666321, 0.3094266355037689, 0.026610497385263443, 0.0660509318113327, -0.8874388337135315, -0.12307099997997284, -0.09080521762371063, -0.4299476146697998, 0.1672114133834839, -0.1321771740913391, -0.28192126750946045, -0.2799404263496399, -0.15347613394260406, 0.3271351456642151, 0.21525321900844574, -0.2985745668411255, 0.2621772289276123, 0.423394113779068, -0.10040585696697235, -0.501822829246521, -0.5504376888275146, 0.11236695200204849, -0.04346315935254097, -0.584766685962677, 0.3269636332988739, -0.20484331250190735, -0.34996888041496277, -0.1487005352973938, -0.2371872514486313, 0.10121665149927139, 0.196396142244339, 0.09836886078119278, 0.14000771939754486, -0.3509284257888794, 0.3334178328514099, 0.0299608763307333, -0.19277362525463104, 0.3931139409542084, -0.043402835726737976, 0.353956013917923, -0.06226108595728874, -0.5904987454414368, -0.45068198442459106, 0.10684976726770401, 0.7570377588272095, -0.19369709491729736, 0.4955429434776306, 0.5628844499588013, -0.46822303533554077, -0.16905967891216278, -0.3971841335296631, -0.10141919553279877, -0.4466438889503479, 0.6852650046348572, -0.4014430642127991, -0.7712152004241943, 0.6269501447677612, -0.3277418911457062, -0.1070280522108078, 0.20874886214733124, 0.7170212864875793, -0.14426390826702118, 0.9228730797767639, 0.5375585556030273, 0.20702989399433136, -0.12745019793510437, 0.09031625837087631, 0.3723433315753937, -0.9377691745758057, -0.5561739206314087, -0.5739028453826904, -0.15646488964557648, -0.5114606618881226, -0.7992419600486755, 0.6186161637306213, 0.06760773062705994, 0.31679704785346985, -0.10051921755075455, -0.22015425562858582, 0.2849222719669342, 0.13438114523887634, 0.38260146975517273, 0.49837157130241394, -0.4607203006744385, -0.4701118767261505, -0.12034482508897781, -0.5356916785240173, -0.5491517186164856, 1.2606308460235596, 0.6128602027893066, 0.7672842741012573, 0.28764277696609497, 0.6740834712982178, 0.06816032528877258, 0.6407844424247742, -1.1530160903930664, 0.5642273426055908, -0.19885408878326416, -0.30233949422836304, -0.27761176228523254, -0.3877672553062439, -1.0652376413345337, 0.023861626163125038, -0.012805083766579628, -0.8735473155975342, -0.01913723163306713, -0.05834467336535454, -0.3427315950393677, -0.2325446456670761, -0.6656976342201233, 0.9758155345916748, -0.2870837152004242, -0.20435430109500885, -0.2179337441921234, -0.5701087117195129, 0.4414316415786743, -0.10915710777044296, 0.3843696117401123, -0.5102527737617493, -0.371256560087204, 0.7019248008728027, -0.3862905204296112, 0.7428427934646606, -0.04135064780712128, -0.229675754904747, -0.24015942215919495, 0.063753142952919, 0.27841469645500183, 0.3263762891292572, -0.2552337348461151, 0.03198850527405739, 0.3249250054359436, -0.3839558959007263, -0.662152886390686, 0.725917398929596, -0.4301038980484009, -0.4025469720363617, -0.2982194423675537, -0.8214977383613586, -0.72990882396698, 0.24068018794059753, 0.29662027955055237, 0.6297804117202759, -0.42831698060035706, 0.08390472084283829, 0.7578275799751282, -0.5143873691558838, 0.03808696195483208, 1.0146667957305908, -0.2870863676071167, -0.08810079842805862, 0.5039704442024231, -0.4468822181224823, 0.34639227390289307, 0.501285195350647, 0.45581692457199097, -0.6173025965690613, -1.058087944984436, -0.26959919929504395, 0.6244369149208069, -0.7795085310935974, -0.07072709500789642, -0.5529123544692993, 0.04866423085331917, -0.49626052379608154, 0.04220419377088547, -0.3247034549713135, -0.0640329122543335, -0.07587269693613052, 0.03614480048418045, 0.4644642472267151, 0.8797584772109985, 0.2232501357793808, 0.20734967291355133, -0.7862398624420166, 0.16151665151119232, 0.04949624091386795, 0.7713569402694702, -0.2711978852748871, -0.6175392270088196, -0.3729945719242096, -0.07424613833427429, 0.1297568380832672, -0.7783623933792114, 0.2769091725349426, 0.1329934149980545, 0.7029880285263062, 0.5849913954734802, -0.0644938126206398, 0.7013390064239502, -0.4197137951850891, 0.34771397709846497, 0.267559289932251, -0.8951352834701538, 0.45982983708381653, -0.49000948667526245, 0.4882561266422272, 0.6684116125106812, 0.2121664583683014, -0.6144992709159851, -0.3742503821849823, -0.3854692578315735, -0.625040590763092, 0.5778453946113586, 0.007222424261271954, -0.2996343672275543, 0.0710383802652359, 0.5333656072616577, -0.006573041435331106, 0.20039282739162445, -0.35295379161834717, -0.42161858081817627, 0.5799330472946167, -0.4182542860507965, -0.24661889672279358, -0.2860855460166931, -0.31157976388931274, -0.16410665214061737, 0.12561462819576263, -0.1374267190694809, 0.5171396732330322, 0.15340206027030945, -0.2916155755519867, 0.03955996409058571, 0.26398715376853943, 0.7031927108764648, 0.8193186521530151, -0.5860116481781006, -0.024831622838974, 0.06952574104070663, -0.7015904784202576, -0.31732791662216187, 0.1512906849384308, 0.06681449711322784, 0.14738643169403076, 0.7872609496116638, 0.8100245594978333, 0.45809096097946167, -1.0514233112335205, 0.6403067708015442, -0.3098070025444031, -0.1124272570014, 0.10571475327014923, 0.01976829394698143, 0.45890364050865173, 0.11848863959312439, -0.11037188023328781, -0.35076382756233215, 0.42898571491241455, -0.5256045460700989, 0.1652555763721466, 0.4858803451061249, -0.706151008605957, -0.26501667499542236, 0.4252285659313202, 0.16886109113693237, -0.33041471242904663, 0.38961198925971985, -0.2387526035308838, -0.32689937949180603, 0.6797395944595337, 0.7547958493232727, 0.8870126008987427, -0.1710914522409439, 0.13013552129268646, 0.21502983570098877, 0.4030769467353821, 0.3383358120918274, 0.5145409107208252, 0.14211627840995789, -0.4771016240119934, -0.5650479793548584, -0.6518098711967468, -0.7622082233428955, 0.3477509021759033, -0.8161900639533997, 0.42438530921936035, -0.41138342022895813, -0.06947330385446548, 0.14479464292526245, 0.018708210438489914, -0.7937479615211487, 0.23871591687202454, 0.0993398055434227, 1.1401927471160889, -0.5922409296035767, 0.8986302018165588, 0.7300850749015808, 0.021289046853780746, -0.6007673740386963, -0.20189423859119415, 0.16850461065769196, -1.335635781288147, 0.5703516006469727, 0.2310744673013687, -0.15544013679027557, -0.2628743350505829, -0.36077457666397095, -0.6607351899147034, 0.9560224413871765, 0.5544078946113586, -0.8105722665786743, -0.009629306383430958, 0.26720529794692993, 0.8018811941146851, -0.4419995844364166, 0.588292121887207, 0.9735258221626282, 0.3500705659389496, 0.00012620174675248563, -1.0277011394500732, 0.2423710823059082, -0.3253124952316284, -0.24495430290699005, -0.05238712951540947, -0.3294040858745575, 0.6330655217170715, -0.5448242425918579, -0.33276766538619995, 0.3006592392921448, 0.0350089855492115, 0.42430222034454346, 0.6577407121658325, 0.2990064024925232, 0.43129295110702515, 1.1288915872573853, -0.11841800808906555, 1.115558385848999, -0.41188758611679077, 0.29918885231018066, 1.0965217351913452, -0.4415660798549652, 0.6605783104896545, 0.24791684746742249, -0.492530882358551, 0.29916641116142273, 0.5548887848854065, 0.4782792329788208, 0.400895893573761, 0.5093859434127808, -0.47390496730804443, -0.22182947397232056, -0.4349247217178345, -0.4322245717048645, 0.4504461884498596, 0.9330503940582275, -0.34757137298583984, -0.250679612159729, -0.31767305731773376, -0.03527507185935974, 0.06714823842048645, -0.14501452445983887, 0.7839547991752625, 0.36515867710113525, -0.412982314825058, 0.6888775825500488, -0.12473244965076447, 0.2991059422492981, -0.7760830521583557, 0.12233920395374298, -0.20288784801959991, 0.3133157789707184, -0.19065918028354645, -0.4141837954521179, 0.11748076230287552, 0.07804796099662781, 0.050936926156282425, 0.08072134107351303, 0.5192453265190125, -0.3684547245502472, -0.5351521968841553, 0.5501174330711365, 0.39532023668289185, 0.3755801320075989, 0.02368006482720375, -0.8528984785079956, 0.4029209017753601, -0.18821747601032257, 0.22134296596050262, 0.2938346564769745, 0.6370681524276733, 0.11887975037097931, 0.8610238432884216, 0.585482120513916, 0.34934353828430176, -0.1692463606595993, 0.5583571791648865, 0.6908382773399353, -0.7634812593460083, -0.3127017319202423, -0.8019285202026367, 0.11253822594881058, 0.06378050893545151, -0.4206543266773224, 0.560227632522583, 0.4727024734020233, 0.2713495194911957, 0.103573277592659, 0.7359752655029297, 0.4445149898529053, 0.6966266632080078, -0.6417887806892395, 0.6757754683494568, -0.519966721534729, 0.5208191871643066, -0.3405199944972992, -0.18713022768497467, -0.5950881838798523, 0.4894505441188812, -0.5443419218063354, -0.1207275539636612, 1.019708514213562, 0.64996737241745, 0.26493674516677856, 0.15180575847625732, 0.5549253225326538, 0.3575100898742676, 0.3069303631782532, 0.8363035917282104, 0.8066931962966919, -0.2534894049167633, 0.17108049988746643, -0.20153146982192993, -0.521855354309082, -0.2598465383052826, -1.152227520942688, -1.0506565570831299, -0.09303121268749237, -0.3532254695892334, -0.2032075822353363, 0.15492936968803406, 0.7885963320732117, 0.6595559120178223, -0.8026770949363708, -0.3196771740913391, 0.0049181729555130005, 0.03587397187948227, -0.2601034939289093, -0.10900761932134628, 0.53179532289505, -0.4444732069969177, -0.606748640537262, 0.702246904373169, 0.6497184038162231, -0.31228798627853394, -0.24425578117370605, -0.08632282167673111, -0.06378103047609329, -0.15367065370082855, 0.5769653916358948, 0.11689585447311401, -0.8195386528968811, 0.2131822407245636, 0.33624929189682007, -0.24150437116622925, -0.09687583893537521, 0.9270129203796387, -0.6483385562896729, 0.89622962474823, 0.2053326666355133, 0.7465183734893799, 0.48462623357772827, -0.3358401656150818, 0.6418908834457397, -0.2908644676208496, 0.12931762635707855, 0.374259352684021, 0.4605458676815033, 0.32942086458206177, -0.38842087984085083, 0.37939363718032837, 0.2012595683336258, -0.32464599609375, -0.9784106612205505, 0.003177896374836564, -1.039665699005127, -0.017862968146800995, 0.9602035880088806, -0.39587676525115967, -0.24491140246391296, -0.3802243769168854, 0.15541428327560425, 0.15207186341285706, -0.2134459763765335, 0.6415579915046692, 0.42756083607673645, -0.23261092603206635, 0.09484852105379105, -0.6497713923454285, 0.5863949060440063, 0.5718457698822021, -0.856702983379364, 0.15282782912254333, 0.18009053170681, 0.31115061044692993, -0.21751075983047485, 0.8748785853385925, -0.42888423800468445, 0.44420188665390015, -0.29264509677886963, 0.04034363105893135, 0.21590793132781982, -0.053127747029066086, -0.3877772390842438, -0.377932071685791, 0.2649633586406708, -0.19964289665222168 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04066v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04066v1
VoicePilot: Harnessing LLMs as Speech Interfaces for Physically Assistive Robots
2024-04-05T12:45:10
2024-04-05T12:45:10
Akhil Padmanabha, Jessie Yuan, Janavi Gupta, Zulekha Karachiwalla, Carmel Majidi, Henny Admoni, Zackory Erickson
cs.RO
cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.HC
Physically assistive robots present an opportunity to significantly increase the well-being and independence of individuals with motor impairments or other forms of disability who are unable to complete activities of daily living. Speech interfaces, especially ones that utilize Large Language Models (LLMs), can enable individuals to effectively and naturally communicate high-level commands and nuanced preferences to robots. Frameworks for integrating LLMs as interfaces to robots for high level task planning and code generation have been proposed, but fail to incorporate human-centric considerations which are essential while developing assistive interfaces. In this work, we present a framework for incorporating LLMs as speech interfaces for physically assistive robots, constructed iteratively with 3 stages of testing involving a feeding robot, culminating in an evaluation with 11 older adults at an independent living facility. We use both quantitative and qualitative data from the final study to validate our framework and additionally provide design guidelines for using LLMs as speech interfaces for assistive robots. Videos and supporting files are located on our project website: https://sites.google.com/andrew.cmu.edu/voicepilot/
[ -0.2362276017665863, -0.5378327965736389, 0.6150974035263062, 0.28870272636413574, 0.10261780768632889, 0.12580004334449768, -0.11408732831478119, -0.434166818857193, 0.6317498087882996, 0.6957319974899292, -0.7579363584518433, -0.2842499017715454, -0.4480668306350708, 0.1325197070837021, -0.0627555251121521, 0.30974337458610535, -0.01393023133277893, 0.23666228353977203, -0.09520979225635529, 0.20491288602352142, -0.37540391087532043, -0.5654616355895996, -0.4557904303073883, -0.6819484233856201, 0.591334879398346, 0.5630624294281006, 0.640480101108551, 0.3691527843475342, 0.4494141638278961, 0.34546053409576416, -0.036804962903261185, 0.25466638803482056, 0.036943305283784866, 0.2137185037136078, 0.11762857437133789, -0.4115820825099945, -0.8562725782394409, -0.3117036819458008, 0.4944712519645691, 1.016782522201538, -0.21464285254478455, 0.03854444622993469, 0.26113319396972656, 0.5936679244041443, -0.2513710856437683, 0.2697891592979431, -0.24232134222984314, 0.2101176381111145, -0.09564953297376633, -0.3355543911457062, -0.15404140949249268, -0.29482585191726685, -0.01767873950302601, -0.6672715544700623, -0.3185846209526062, -0.016834044829010963, 0.3432212471961975, 0.6296438574790955, -0.041400011628866196, -0.43626168370246887, -0.6616743803024292, 0.47967785596847534, -0.9265129566192627, 0.33627641201019287, 0.667092502117157, 0.3728736937046051, -0.554565966129303, -0.4249335825443268, -0.7288573980331421, -0.6066301465034485, 0.20289134979248047, 0.09718514233827591, -0.3667163848876953, 0.41595324873924255, 0.19815559685230255, -0.11792156100273132, -0.5544626712799072, 0.4783642292022705, -0.23967425525188446, -0.04868127033114433, 0.49768292903900146, 0.0406540110707283, 0.32873207330703735, -0.4339149594306946, -0.5340505242347717, -0.10230898857116699, -0.5372262597084045, 0.1499382108449936, 0.5806002616882324, 0.8479214906692505, -0.4702353775501251, 1.187890887260437, -0.42191025614738464, 0.7714791297912598, -0.03133607655763626, -0.2902373969554901, 0.6946896910667419, -0.050992775708436966, -0.1992667019367218, 0.07969719171524048, 0.585102379322052, 0.2945375442504883, 0.5012800097465515, -0.08984602987766266, -0.08052758872509003, -0.3738678991794586, 0.28288283944129944, -0.2876405119895935, -0.23103086650371552, 0.5647472143173218, -0.4661846160888672, 0.10498383641242981, -0.09940896928310394, -0.6920416355133057, -0.8770235180854797, -0.6678137183189392, 0.46261361241340637, -0.0956563726067543, -0.3664391040802002, 0.27668413519859314, -0.10629719495773315, 0.07574012130498886, 0.2580872178077698, -0.7662999629974365, 0.22219160199165344, 0.6262286901473999, 0.839423418045044, -0.2803747057914734, -0.1783251166343689, -0.9380874633789062, 0.26993128657341003, 0.004831399768590927, 0.7394832372665405, -0.48806318640708923, -0.6466065645217896, -0.03697264939546585, 0.45646560192108154, -0.08238333463668823, -0.7173976898193359, 0.6241307854652405, 0.05528663098812103, -0.08871851861476898, 0.023944197222590446, -0.35543614625930786, -0.2337765246629715, -0.09306918829679489, -0.5976950526237488, 0.5704233646392822, 0.21726125478744507, -0.07039012014865875, 0.015581457875669003, -1.0594738721847534, -0.6944828629493713, 0.2802250385284424, -0.2126806229352951, -0.20562469959259033, -0.11679955571889877, 0.05564175918698311, 0.7380000948905945, 0.020478736609220505, 0.08092780411243439, -0.3959341049194336, -0.10757722705602646, 0.2607952952384949, -0.4156763255596161, 0.6948730945587158, 0.24367330968379974, -0.36207452416419983, 0.5304166674613953, -0.6938149333000183, 0.012932777404785156, -0.07041731476783752, -0.38978010416030884, 0.28588083386421204, 0.30735644698143005, -0.04825323075056076, -0.08316993713378906, 0.4100486934185028, -0.4828215539455414, 0.13388389348983765, -0.3193132281303406, 0.33247309923171997, 0.5117834210395813, -0.15454113483428955, 0.4211015999317169, -0.40321075916290283, 0.8126063346862793, -0.6669145822525024, 0.14420321583747864, 0.04369731247425079, -0.5908576846122742, -0.5284199118614197, -0.41157111525535583, -0.03142012655735016, 0.645237386226654, -0.7523823976516724, 0.7257461547851562, 0.04685943201184273, -0.2665131092071533, -0.21378499269485474, 0.3237225115299225, -0.06432612985372543, 0.3757566213607788, 0.23848535120487213, -0.019628575071692467, -0.6079363822937012, -0.8413589596748352, 0.3539332151412964, -0.2867680788040161, -0.9186841249465942, 0.41426903009414673, 0.058947477489709854, 0.09326710551977158, 0.830059826374054, -0.046847179532051086, -0.583283543586731, -0.5947153568267822, -0.055997371673583984, 0.21379582583904266, 0.4576166570186615, 0.37563690543174744, -0.5289037823677063, 0.09845468401908875, 0.0006225426332093775, -0.6438549160957336, -0.3996815085411072, -0.14553344249725342, 0.25167614221572876, 0.07630252838134766, 0.3642340302467346, -0.6428192853927612, 0.35462507605552673, 0.8788615465164185, -0.08733753859996796, 0.1751718670129776, -0.2854675054550171, 0.09414290636777878, -0.7323940396308899, 0.12418099492788315, -0.03326987847685814, -0.27484068274497986, -0.5809985399246216, -0.41065898537635803, -0.4995717704296112, -0.3099958002567291, -0.5831981301307678, 0.2332409918308258, -0.46325385570526123, -0.4079853296279907, -0.5587847232818604, 0.39970263838768005, -0.18433408439159393, 0.4861093759536743, 0.18394653499126434, 0.7679654955863953, 0.27859240770339966, -0.4429413080215454, 0.4024467468261719, -0.013992694206535816, -0.11298836022615433, 0.5620157122612, -0.9494628310203552, -0.03811798617243767, 0.1433723419904709, 0.16373321413993835, -1.11464262008667, -0.5815966129302979, 0.7127364277839661, -0.6098302602767944, 0.05375462397933006, 0.09659480303525925, -0.44781261682510376, -0.3172479569911957, -0.14206764101982117, -0.20750389993190765, 0.44392457604408264, -0.340147465467453, 1.0405017137527466, 0.9771787524223328, -0.46932217478752136, 0.11787544190883636, -0.5923374891281128, -0.017826028168201447, -0.19094312191009521, -0.49052202701568604, 0.2066727727651596, -0.14006702601909637, -0.07421907037496567, -0.3666550815105438, 0.10444681346416473, 0.09588870406150818, 0.19719058275222778, 0.5667188167572021, 0.040363557636737823, 0.047301243990659714, 0.043342623859643936, 0.050827596336603165, -0.16186626255512238, 0.11404422670602798, 0.06332951039075851, 0.8790939450263977, 0.07184388488531113, -0.819015383720398, -0.920310378074646, 0.3095446228981018, 0.6105556488037109, -0.02648891694843769, 0.04087268188595772, 0.4056655168533325, -0.39567506313323975, 0.17054930329322815, -0.3092046082019806, -0.06879784166812897, -0.5132598876953125, 0.25829365849494934, -0.31015002727508545, -0.7617197632789612, 0.21953192353248596, -0.24715420603752136, 0.0358615480363369, -0.04071703925728798, 0.6218421459197998, -0.47375982999801636, 1.0599644184112549, 0.44930094480514526, 0.014884176664054394, 0.5793521404266357, 0.12501439452171326, -0.14630641043186188, -1.1605299711227417, -0.432127445936203, -0.7620323300361633, -0.5078454613685608, -0.3595488667488098, -0.9318698048591614, 0.3363085985183716, -0.23022104799747467, -0.200236976146698, 0.26428738236427307, -0.5477214455604553, 0.19256410002708435, 0.4174739718437195, 0.17470483481884003, 0.16045527160167694, 0.004373696632683277, 0.17341665923595428, 0.13398942351341248, -0.6540364623069763, -0.8505396246910095, 0.6357260346412659, 0.6105441451072693, 0.8659842610359192, 0.0759933739900589, 0.3435947597026825, 0.46705543994903564, 0.08706361055374146, -0.8768295049667358, 0.7252621054649353, -0.32678359746932983, -0.14828884601593018, -0.6347295641899109, -0.15301737189292908, -1.079103708267212, 0.04885536804795265, -0.1485642045736313, -1.0600303411483765, 0.26393917202949524, 0.2500265836715698, -0.3983632028102875, 0.19939348101615906, -0.759061872959137, 0.5414222478866577, -0.7499700784683228, -0.14676010608673096, -0.008296440355479717, -0.7935853004455566, -0.06387421488761902, 0.21809037029743195, 0.1393164098262787, -0.4798585772514343, -0.1706567406654358, 0.6247107982635498, -0.19473521411418915, 1.3931716680526733, -0.5442236661911011, -0.20694632828235626, 0.20495043694972992, -0.2686394453048706, 0.30612319707870483, -0.2696323096752167, -0.28023093938827515, 0.26474785804748535, -0.2118608057498932, -0.06264470517635345, -0.404315710067749, 0.5084062814712524, -0.6314626336097717, -0.4410558044910431, -0.09674561768770218, -0.5073023438453674, -0.46578752994537354, 0.004963635932654142, -0.45070499181747437, 0.23801963031291962, 0.18078234791755676, 0.5068638920783997, 0.45358675718307495, -0.31346264481544495, 0.22090332210063934, 0.4457665979862213, -0.40093180537223816, -0.3646547198295593, 0.9849313497543335, -0.0952613428235054, 0.41090068221092224, 0.44934070110321045, 0.3387700021266937, -0.440708190202713, -0.5648526549339294, -0.31669923663139343, 0.2148267775774002, -0.2659243643283844, -0.013473105616867542, -0.4716815650463104, -0.15953806042671204, -0.3667561709880829, -0.10336972028017044, -0.12254533171653748, -0.4918142557144165, -0.6198918223381042, 0.12633951008319855, 0.08389862626791, 0.7268846035003662, -0.15213604271411896, 0.6171075105667114, -0.5176051259040833, 0.6616822481155396, 0.3101598918437958, 0.1330336183309555, -0.09562303125858307, -0.4175059497356415, 0.167134091258049, 0.17791035771369934, -0.32781049609184265, -0.7649633884429932, 0.31913599371910095, -0.10417463630437851, 0.9536927342414856, -0.029778607189655304, 0.06667711585760117, 0.5676387548446655, -0.5151344537734985, 1.0201287269592285, 0.3239262104034424, -0.8598999977111816, 0.6473757028579712, -0.36877328157424927, 0.5243680477142334, 0.3577670454978943, 0.3446583151817322, -0.23405921459197998, -0.279457151889801, -0.18277066946029663, -0.9928197264671326, 0.3687315583229065, 0.05325015261769295, 0.027616366744041443, 0.23165853321552277, 0.16655033826828003, 0.048012297600507736, 0.33274587988853455, -0.4923764765262604, -0.025543231517076492, -0.08356155455112457, -0.41608771681785583, 0.09985512495040894, -0.0853734016418457, -0.17768627405166626, -0.0199723057448864, 0.46365997195243835, -0.4495360851287842, 0.31277796626091003, 0.07627428323030472, 0.2548691928386688, -0.153791144490242, 0.07031919807195663, 0.8534928560256958, 0.6039928197860718, -0.11758220940828323, -0.016101405024528503, 0.02735460177063942, -0.2833605706691742, -0.1757318377494812, 0.2867652177810669, 0.22577683627605438, -0.11317761242389679, 0.15670034289360046, 0.6976982355117798, 0.41340118646621704, -1.058471918106079, 0.2543542981147766, 0.0749296322464943, -0.10545095801353455, -0.5405229330062866, 0.14313501119613647, 0.5053354501724243, 0.5660940408706665, 0.4295286238193512, -0.13437582552433014, 0.1243089884519577, -0.21383492648601532, 0.3138687312602997, 0.5178219079971313, -0.21396781504154205, -0.25679653882980347, 0.5957356095314026, 0.6427576541900635, -0.9482212662696838, 0.04375899210572243, 0.13735812902450562, -0.2735115885734558, 0.42529579997062683, 0.3377501368522644, 0.8698017001152039, -0.22049057483673096, 0.2272496372461319, -0.028126796707510948, 0.33063897490501404, 0.36771711707115173, 0.33763301372528076, -0.343619704246521, -0.3778975009918213, -0.5423867702484131, -0.5465434193611145, -0.9084247350692749, -0.00947666261345148, -0.3848430812358856, 0.19144044816493988, -0.2968366742134094, -0.3492904007434845, -0.11369205266237259, -0.11701657623052597, -0.3876992166042328, -0.0328063890337944, 0.5028654932975769, 0.6886806488037109, -0.40890827775001526, 0.633461594581604, 0.7004538774490356, -0.2526630461215973, -0.8362782597541809, 0.05986485257744789, 0.15931913256645203, -1.188217043876648, 0.7961773872375488, -0.13450610637664795, -0.5804515480995178, -0.14271272718906403, -0.2842428684234619, -0.7560558915138245, 1.0614304542541504, 0.3662509620189667, -0.7767105102539062, -0.11433014273643494, 0.4858857989311218, 0.32217535376548767, -0.4778361916542053, 0.054441798478364944, 0.13159413635730743, 0.6683804988861084, 0.36583128571510315, -1.2663217782974243, -0.20553058385849, 0.008998312056064606, 0.031382009387016296, -0.23984675109386444, -0.6559467911720276, 0.3411180377006531, -0.07455239444971085, 0.049088701605796814, 0.5019252896308899, 0.7359482049942017, 0.6366190910339355, 0.30359336733818054, 0.8891654014587402, -0.10366637259721756, 0.8640931844711304, -0.0867505595088005, 0.7562401294708252, -0.19346585869789124, -0.2161112278699875, 1.2006287574768066, -0.5551989674568176, 1.0399818420410156, 0.5927908420562744, -0.2794225513935089, 0.2772754430770874, 0.22500325739383698, 0.3290392756462097, 0.24274300038814545, 0.5339528322219849, -0.2127338945865631, -0.41542068123817444, -0.4701339900493622, -0.18493765592575073, 0.7330281734466553, 0.4271293580532074, -0.21113857626914978, 0.02166276052594185, 0.5167298316955566, -0.02201710268855095, 0.1524837166070938, 0.000013520641005015932, 0.6659980416297913, 0.05306160822510719, -0.37378883361816406, 0.1170966699719429, -0.5667322278022766, 0.622494101524353, -0.8702235221862793, -0.28915295004844666, 0.2203693687915802, 0.12420186400413513, -0.18819089233875275, -1.0615544319152832, 0.11900024116039276, 0.15646860003471375, -0.040452972054481506, -0.48447510600090027, 0.5896065831184387, -0.2762397527694702, -0.3786654770374298, 0.12533557415008545, 0.5291337370872498, 0.43883463740348816, 0.1895345002412796, -0.6730979084968567, 0.6663278341293335, 0.05776036158204079, -0.21833021938800812, 0.21076370775699615, 0.1706162989139557, 0.3285723626613617, 0.9448283910751343, 0.6121286153793335, 0.39030721783638, -0.049182262271642685, 0.36935022473335266, 0.679485559463501, -0.34495729207992554, -0.17700369656085968, -0.3306882679462433, 0.7973670363426208, -0.09557239711284637, -0.23813632130622864, 0.6248461008071899, 0.3901115357875824, 0.4341178834438324, 0.07486075162887573, 0.6760405898094177, -0.1779378205537796, 0.8280322551727295, -0.7165770530700684, 0.5956192016601562, -0.6783303022384644, 0.35775163769721985, -0.07618452608585358, -0.5398553013801575, -0.28387051820755005, 1.0685118436813354, -0.2144513577222824, 0.23772594332695007, 0.08737282454967499, 0.6516026258468628, 0.2940751910209656, -0.013412394560873508, 0.4931419789791107, -0.07875330746173859, 0.6232914328575134, 0.36718669533729553, 0.8848316073417664, 0.2175954431295395, 0.4113689661026001, -0.19966837763786316, -0.34221363067626953, -0.2493085265159607, -0.965043842792511, -0.6529343128204346, -0.4981529414653778, -0.17394371330738068, 0.045768022537231445, 0.19526515901088715, 1.1142678260803223, 0.9263754487037659, -0.3251700699329376, -0.7189281582832336, -0.013538614846765995, 0.12995848059654236, -0.01811322011053562, -0.2373562604188919, -0.054613932967185974, -0.096934475004673, -0.9537286162376404, 0.8318561315536499, 0.2502119541168213, 0.17614594101905823, -0.6669155955314636, -0.21896962821483612, -0.0563032366335392, -0.2839317321777344, 0.591535747051239, 0.5752877593040466, -1.0028685331344604, -0.6420444846153259, 0.2043091505765915, 0.31342530250549316, 0.04761446267366409, 0.7737066745758057, -0.8755717277526855, 0.46536070108413696, 0.2904241979122162, 0.5960289835929871, 0.22679820656776428, 0.17848317325115204, 0.7026934027671814, -0.5178629159927368, 0.0567145012319088, 0.39020398259162903, 0.34265199303627014, 0.47734972834587097, -0.08269473910331726, 0.4970501661300659, -0.13435718417167664, -0.8230689764022827, -0.8838801383972168, 0.15792851150035858, -1.6272644996643066, 0.05886051803827286, 1.200362205505371, 0.07746902853250504, -0.2035033404827118, -0.09073149412870407, -0.5905367136001587, 0.06601137667894363, -0.4279007613658905, 0.35026484727859497, 0.19111087918281555, -0.8129383325576782, -0.18652305006980896, -0.8399910926818848, 0.18752166628837585, 0.18798239529132843, -1.0551605224609375, 0.12069699913263321, 0.5459958910942078, 0.05515619367361069, 0.3489155173301697, 0.5421136617660522, 0.10828553140163422, 0.13752849400043488, -0.2700764834880829, 0.1662997007369995, -0.23662875592708588, -0.17229701578617096, -0.3059914708137512, 0.34817609190940857, 0.12342484295368195, -0.5938279628753662 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04042v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04042v1
Teaching Llama a New Language Through Cross-Lingual Knowledge Transfer
2024-04-05T11:52:02
2024-04-05T11:52:02
Hele-Andra Kuulmets, Taido Purason, Agnes Luhtaru, Mark Fishel
cs.CL
cs.CL
This paper explores cost-efficient methods to adapt pretrained Large Language Models (LLMs) to new lower-resource languages, with a specific focus on Estonian. Leveraging the Llama 2 model, we investigate the impact of combining cross-lingual instruction-tuning with additional monolingual pretraining. Our results demonstrate that even a relatively small amount of additional monolingual pretraining followed by cross-lingual instruction-tuning significantly enhances results on Estonian. Furthermore, we showcase cross-lingual knowledge transfer from high-quality English instructions to Estonian, resulting in improvements in commonsense reasoning and multi-turn conversation capabilities. Our best model, named \textsc{Llammas}, represents the first open-source instruction-following LLM for Estonian. Additionally, we publish Alpaca-est, the first general task instruction dataset for Estonia. These contributions mark the initial progress in the direction of developing open-source LLMs for Estonian.
[ -0.08949262648820877, -0.8064629435539246, 0.42953670024871826, 0.2343333661556244, -0.5288463234901428, 0.11220242083072662, -0.5776169896125793, -0.6699333190917969, 0.34281811118125916, 0.5405593514442444, -0.292471706867218, -0.5754074454307556, -0.7853859663009644, -0.08498256653547287, -0.28672122955322266, 0.6539860367774963, -0.22418896853923798, 0.22623375058174133, -0.16701547801494598, -0.04854384437203407, -0.7714114189147949, -0.5690754652023315, -0.6448898315429688, -0.23778514564037323, 0.43902331590652466, 0.986572265625, 0.48208311200141907, 0.4593425393104553, 0.12259683758020401, 0.26859816908836365, -0.0058649866841733456, -0.07443724572658539, -0.6597415804862976, -0.3716832399368286, -0.18732713162899017, -0.954674482345581, -0.24108360707759857, -0.14566843211650848, 0.5719559788703918, 0.528335690498352, -0.34843671321868896, 0.3278709053993225, 0.005527707282453775, 0.5011534690856934, -0.5047122836112976, 0.07669321447610855, -0.7708017826080322, 0.09193138033151627, -0.2912442982196808, 0.0023047681897878647, -0.5317871570587158, -0.23220674693584442, 0.025365345180034637, -0.895592451095581, -0.43634796142578125, -0.00039036234375089407, 0.6578954458236694, 0.31537172198295593, -0.49917149543762207, -0.4781581461429596, -0.5838442444801331, 1.0969362258911133, -0.36620551347732544, 0.6877102255821228, 0.4937010109424591, 0.2296055257320404, 0.08761939406394958, -0.6290727257728577, -0.3724164366722107, -0.28013938665390015, -0.027509525418281555, -0.12988010048866272, -0.5143893361091614, -0.42155328392982483, -0.3626976013183594, 0.17402659356594086, -0.10651925206184387, 0.6712118983268738, -0.5756883025169373, 0.12760363519191742, 0.5012441873550415, -0.031913939863443375, 0.27507779002189636, 0.1360832303762436, -0.7030674815177917, 0.04557162523269653, -0.9882605075836182, -0.044726788997650146, 0.4060591161251068, 0.20491912961006165, -0.5492690205574036, 0.4101032614707947, 0.18355654180049896, 0.4058525562286377, 0.23798725008964539, -0.2265135943889618, 0.16226881742477417, -0.404441773891449, -0.0912342369556427, 0.11971551179885864, 0.44967716932296753, 0.10107813775539398, 0.4635550379753113, -0.1403706818819046, 0.0462733656167984, -0.000307626323774457, 0.06931521743535995, -0.40801042318344116, 0.06367678940296173, -0.1817142218351364, -0.46350374817848206, -0.08655101805925369, -0.5546399354934692, -0.7554037570953369, 0.08224596083164215, -0.5263153314590454, 0.5002899765968323, -0.34662753343582153, -0.2946576774120331, 0.40903347730636597, 0.4138216972351074, 0.37683072686195374, 0.48071712255477905, -1.0394067764282227, 0.4033503234386444, 0.7196692228317261, 0.660683810710907, -0.24196957051753998, -0.5481393933296204, -0.5980915427207947, 0.1312791109085083, -0.5094202160835266, 0.7929126620292664, -0.6858622431755066, -0.3941492736339569, -0.08479326218366623, 0.056512147188186646, 0.13962611556053162, -0.3516876995563507, 0.2047555148601532, -0.40851742029190063, 0.4995196461677551, -0.14076226949691772, -0.30622124671936035, -0.28801995515823364, 0.02906835824251175, -0.5054053664207458, 1.1875269412994385, 0.13820461928844452, -0.44791555404663086, 0.0953546017408371, -0.5953109860420227, -0.6672137975692749, -0.07447148859500885, 0.16070115566253662, 0.1667475551366806, 0.034460198134183884, 0.17455275356769562, 0.30984359979629517, -0.6180511116981506, 0.17622877657413483, 0.234137624502182, -0.17069338262081146, -0.3061935603618622, -0.26973044872283936, 0.8719425797462463, 0.2097492814064026, -0.3935278058052063, 0.01234591007232666, -0.7247907519340515, -0.11279860138893127, 0.11565157026052475, -0.6896853446960449, -0.4360804557800293, -0.3323991894721985, -0.12507835030555725, -0.009015075862407684, 0.5907944440841675, -0.4164647161960602, 0.0954536572098732, 0.03805942460894585, 0.09402718394994736, 0.854911208152771, -0.5840315818786621, 0.648891031742096, -0.11105138808488846, 0.9000633955001831, 0.07841584086418152, 0.38740813732147217, -0.11710208654403687, -0.4434437155723572, -1.238232970237732, -0.10601373761892319, 0.3906833827495575, 0.7979974746704102, -0.972429096698761, 0.18670938909053802, -0.08523939549922943, -0.6197922229766846, -0.7501001954078674, 0.5840688943862915, 0.5674042105674744, 0.4549117982387543, 0.470020592212677, -0.41293320059776306, -0.6290604472160339, -0.9557152390480042, -0.10710061341524124, -0.21091149747371674, 0.17347489297389984, 0.14332215487957, 0.2479645311832428, -0.24372079968452454, 0.16376619040966034, -0.13992376625537872, -0.3484213054180145, -0.18643787503242493, -0.07666344195604324, 0.07574804872274399, 0.3650672435760498, 0.747124195098877, -0.1737740933895111, -0.6722023487091064, 0.3133506774902344, -0.4717489182949066, -0.059129636734724045, 0.3139284551143646, -0.4947243332862854, 0.5392229557037354, 0.6479030847549438, -0.440173476934433, 0.04808945581316948, 1.0570892095565796, -0.5110037326812744, 0.4784844219684601, -0.2005113959312439, -0.04660048708319664, -1.0929477214813232, -0.1728319376707077, -0.3592385947704315, -0.24361541867256165, -0.4946001470088959, 0.02746681310236454, -0.32091569900512695, -0.06011178344488144, -0.9276841282844543, 0.7595285177230835, -0.6708992123603821, -0.054489824920892715, -0.19804008305072784, -0.21968868374824524, -0.34251874685287476, 0.6088092923164368, 0.08247721940279007, 0.9468930959701538, 0.6992843747138977, -0.4594786763191223, 0.20735925436019897, 0.3561188578605652, -0.6271158456802368, 0.7083026766777039, -0.41985341906547546, 0.4724271595478058, -0.2621070146560669, 0.07789431512355804, -0.4565431475639343, 0.18171675503253937, 0.26767438650131226, -0.04829433560371399, 0.27715563774108887, -0.36864298582077026, -0.24249614775180817, 0.23609794676303864, -0.06623092293739319, 0.36362987756729126, 0.7681355476379395, -0.8571121692657471, 0.8560166358947754, 0.5690339207649231, -0.43932971358299255, -0.78217613697052, -0.7024919986724854, 0.2526070475578308, -0.24529501795768738, -0.5096544027328491, 0.11898542195558548, 0.05078684538602829, -0.328555166721344, 0.22867871820926666, 0.24973411858081818, -0.05407387763261795, 0.1892452985048294, -0.1359773427248001, 0.2054949551820755, -0.5723556876182556, 0.2910824716091156, 0.07842184603214264, -0.16763438284397125, 0.009779351763427258, -0.5175355672836304, 0.6072585582733154, -0.2507631778717041, -0.3838333487510681, -0.41610634326934814, 0.3808021545410156, 0.4221054017543793, -0.3482220470905304, 0.6791476011276245, 0.5023613572120667, -0.14349870383739471, -0.17636772990226746, -0.6213895678520203, 0.11297767609357834, -0.44133657217025757, 0.4551800489425659, -0.23374177515506744, -0.9982348680496216, 0.22042202949523926, -0.08843507617712021, 0.2018897831439972, 0.19045628607273102, 0.5896504521369934, 0.006542119197547436, 0.3191545307636261, 1.0749437808990479, -0.18677876889705658, 0.6939533352851868, -0.049623288214206696, -0.014076909981667995, -0.4890325367450714, -0.4112759232521057, -0.5549284815788269, -0.5447482466697693, -0.43639662861824036, -0.9190881848335266, 0.16726776957511902, 0.10960393399000168, -0.26337456703186035, 0.33466199040412903, 0.013986431993544102, 0.7530596852302551, 0.8713441491127014, -0.08019235730171204, 0.4304465651512146, 0.31917744874954224, -0.03956444934010506, 0.23115374147891998, -1.0678651332855225, -0.709841251373291, 1.4145094156265259, 0.30932357907295227, 1.0555152893066406, 0.15191254019737244, 0.7305047512054443, 0.013018501922488213, 0.2957078218460083, -0.558482825756073, 0.4380696415901184, -0.5344206690788269, -0.22124645113945007, -0.4555679261684418, -0.22388999164104462, -1.021518588066101, 0.1833576112985611, -0.3286506235599518, -0.49198856949806213, -0.05943233519792557, 0.18771329522132874, 0.003732262412086129, 0.555248498916626, -0.9379172325134277, 0.6324374079704285, -0.8625693917274475, -0.4090105891227722, -0.6260643601417542, -0.3819325268268585, 0.3452140986919403, -0.20855078101158142, 0.5175062417984009, -0.05910203978419304, -0.3175789415836334, 0.753441572189331, -0.17671750485897064, 1.0361405611038208, -0.14508049190044403, -0.6663628816604614, 0.38973841071128845, 0.11550464481115341, 0.588798999786377, -0.12155529856681824, 0.003340906696394086, 0.6192154884338379, -0.15069547295570374, -0.5809957385063171, -0.2959687113761902, 0.6488724946975708, -0.9869498014450073, -0.8882547616958618, 0.11827940493822098, -0.6693666577339172, -0.1305830031633377, 0.10155200213193893, 0.06999699026346207, -0.14241527020931244, -0.27443888783454895, -0.035256195813417435, 0.5744239091873169, -0.42800602316856384, 0.09139420092105865, 0.6646679639816284, -0.2704731523990631, -0.4437028467655182, 0.6135161519050598, -0.007194954436272383, 0.3863774836063385, 0.470927894115448, 0.2961061894893646, -0.11119664460420609, -0.24425244331359863, -0.5462183952331543, 0.3285335898399353, -0.8964902758598328, -0.11980020999908447, -0.37243029475212097, 0.2903888523578644, -0.2083975225687027, -0.2523668110370636, -0.5773912668228149, -0.6223019957542419, -0.49517822265625, -0.22640453279018402, 0.5110170245170593, 0.8465635180473328, -0.3088988661766052, 0.4544370472431183, -0.7229151725769043, 0.06463392078876495, 0.5512573719024658, 0.41147974133491516, 0.16146911680698395, -0.6160556674003601, -0.41555601358413696, 0.05287382751703262, -0.011404206044971943, -0.6174715161323547, 0.0942947119474411, 0.19937418401241302, 0.5284625291824341, 0.06059657782316208, -0.2966541349887848, 0.5166236162185669, -0.6888383030891418, 0.5690474510192871, 0.5473425388336182, -1.154823899269104, 0.37686866521835327, 0.016711605712771416, 0.19751228392124176, 0.3448357880115509, 0.567602276802063, -0.6222608089447021, 0.08268700540065765, -0.4368027150630951, -0.5812379121780396, 0.744966983795166, -0.2832050025463104, 0.5535545945167542, 0.20873959362506866, 0.07553090155124664, 0.5805237293243408, -0.022700486704707146, -0.7131640315055847, -0.06474123895168304, -0.040795374661684036, -0.12244351953268051, -0.3668517470359802, -0.4379977583885193, -0.1242731437087059, -0.2963539958000183, 0.8055360317230225, -0.1103745773434639, 0.1590563803911209, -0.3567741811275482, -0.34194496273994446, -0.4004160761833191, 0.4231133759021759, 0.6629713773727417, 0.6662702560424805, 0.435932993888855, 0.22802004218101501, 0.7895147800445557, -0.28908005356788635, 0.4583216607570648, -0.1024613231420517, -0.0330980010330677, 0.029179735109210014, 0.5289400815963745, 1.1183300018310547, 0.6880751848220825, -0.6193127632141113, 0.34227195382118225, 0.1585974544286728, -0.18719007074832916, -0.3349732458591461, 0.028856920078396797, 0.5497134327888489, 0.3624192476272583, 0.09590953588485718, -0.4106162488460541, -0.5970125794410706, -0.65494304895401, -0.18140587210655212, 0.39644762873649597, -0.15093286335468292, -0.5222375392913818, 0.5706551671028137, 0.5639607906341553, -0.38120147585868835, 0.425966739654541, 0.347680926322937, -0.4710214138031006, 0.4522588551044464, 0.661181628704071, 0.5458842515945435, -0.4976062774658203, 0.21547353267669678, 0.1335817575454712, 0.6336281895637512, 0.07134195417165756, 0.5986075401306152, -0.13443323969841003, -0.4728012681007385, -0.5211306810379028, -0.5390525460243225, -0.48808473348617554, 0.07903198897838593, -0.4787401854991913, 0.7334524393081665, -0.35714954137802124, 0.12977531552314758, -0.32126015424728394, -0.21189196407794952, -0.9543135762214661, -0.12221480160951614, 0.25416746735572815, 1.0590466260910034, -0.9398754835128784, 0.8405016660690308, 0.8733399510383606, -0.11997587978839874, -0.7430549263954163, -0.4981916844844818, -0.2988978922367096, -1.3576020002365112, 0.7738602161407471, -0.2530789077281952, -0.271844744682312, 0.03554535657167435, -0.5670785307884216, -1.199384331703186, 1.0153021812438965, 0.9396781325340271, -0.8299393057823181, -0.18628732860088348, 0.3162994086742401, 0.4369048476219177, -0.27104875445365906, -0.09252110123634338, 0.45484939217567444, 0.5048404932022095, -0.08822585642337799, -1.1575061082839966, -0.19283248484134674, -0.042747613042593, -0.3045929968357086, 0.2540668845176697, -0.8539517521858215, 0.8951425552368164, -0.29003891348838806, -0.20882771909236908, -0.06440678983926773, 0.6794711947441101, -0.0912647619843483, -0.004064990673214197, 0.5477133989334106, 0.8089869022369385, 0.8400917053222656, 0.2958158552646637, 0.8465771675109863, -0.3885895609855652, -0.1670217663049698, 1.127652883529663, -0.21241532266139984, 1.0007566213607788, 0.7488789558410645, -0.14360305666923523, 0.8399196267127991, 0.2195562720298767, 0.25502926111221313, 0.3006364405155182, 0.17892690002918243, -0.15269054472446442, -0.339761346578598, -0.2591633200645447, -0.5012337565422058, 0.840925395488739, 0.2281704992055893, -0.18712052702903748, -0.2406182587146759, 0.13871422410011292, 0.31307095289230347, -0.010250751860439777, -0.44238805770874023, 0.8405870199203491, 0.2700517773628235, -0.6458737850189209, 0.9662976264953613, 0.03271074220538139, 0.9770012497901917, -0.7077320218086243, -0.04432514309883118, -0.49376940727233887, -0.0533396415412426, -0.0875711590051651, -0.542065441608429, 0.13146616518497467, 0.42357105016708374, 0.07498996704816818, -0.32242336869239807, 0.6682063341140747, -0.8400940299034119, -0.6156573295593262, 0.5332165360450745, 0.6776094436645508, 0.3821011185646057, 0.5356999039649963, -0.30823010206222534, 0.012283523567020893, -0.0598369762301445, -0.04958052188158035, 0.3984220623970032, 0.5853208303451538, -0.21669495105743408, 0.6203891038894653, 0.7367996573448181, 0.15300549566745758, 0.2768387198448181, -0.23097160458564758, 0.7207666039466858, -0.4185442328453064, -0.5875111818313599, -0.46633318066596985, 0.3328312635421753, 0.5928351283073425, -0.41866645216941833, 0.5468543171882629, 0.32301780581474304, 1.2748260498046875, -0.24199704825878143, 0.6534361243247986, 0.2183481752872467, 0.1658422350883484, -0.9577542543411255, 0.6189766526222229, -0.5405217409133911, 0.18675723671913147, 0.238981232047081, -0.8654477596282959, 0.26398777961730957, 0.3585805594921112, -0.11041178554296494, -0.1486930251121521, 0.6380661725997925, 0.5417748689651489, -0.2380605936050415, -0.1405472457408905, 0.4038068652153015, 0.13209620118141174, -0.2363538146018982, 0.8319479823112488, 1.002856731414795, -0.18888041377067566, 0.7495301365852356, -0.3298678994178772, -0.17248207330703735, -0.020731518045067787, -1.0455681085586548, -0.8503646850585938, -0.42684465646743774, -0.19867601990699768, 0.11553396284580231, 0.33584296703338623, 0.9494385123252869, 0.6690430045127869, -0.5862494707107544, -0.673958957195282, 0.24489092826843262, 0.060719817876815796, -0.004611573647707701, -0.03912057355046272, 0.273274302482605, -0.41083070635795593, -0.7948744893074036, 0.5666706562042236, -0.03215108439326286, 0.1908254325389862, -0.3762783110141754, -0.277355819940567, -0.40776512026786804, 0.028370119631290436, 0.8281620144844055, 0.2082270383834839, -0.7303062081336975, -0.26787111163139343, 0.12199874967336655, 0.1148487776517868, 0.19484713673591614, 0.6742271780967712, -0.8085965514183044, 0.05957422032952309, 0.13568715751171112, 0.7977572679519653, 0.572587788105011, -0.3928924798965454, 0.7012771964073181, -0.632820188999176, 0.5291093587875366, -0.024438146501779556, 0.2627420127391815, 0.4529368579387665, -0.4426294267177582, 0.588079571723938, -0.07723131030797958, -0.11295688152313232, -0.6361925601959229, 0.11650534719228745, -0.38723525404930115, -0.2850852310657501, 1.220524787902832, -0.09086842089891434, -0.32777196168899536, 0.04133105278015137, -0.19124585390090942, 0.2502879500389099, -0.11668482422828674, 0.8251566886901855, 0.7445889711380005, 0.16373701393604279, -0.2821553647518158, -0.28450047969818115, 0.13652260601520538, 0.8217939138412476, -1.23780357837677, 0.015290514566004276, 0.37200406193733215, 0.4240191876888275, -0.04526393488049507, 0.5726054310798645, -0.032168664038181305, 0.4237370789051056, -0.038222536444664, 0.3901561498641968, -0.2646789252758026, -0.48621952533721924, -0.43504753708839417, -0.3046180009841919, 0.2692500054836273, -0.24714966118335724 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04035v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04035v1
A Dataset for Physical and Abstract Plausibility and Sources of Human Disagreement
2024-04-05T11:37:40
2024-04-05T11:37:40
Annerose Eichel, Sabine Schulte im Walde
cs.CL
cs.CL
We present a novel dataset for physical and abstract plausibility of events in English. Based on naturally occurring sentences extracted from Wikipedia, we infiltrate degrees of abstractness, and automatically generate perturbed pseudo-implausible events. We annotate a filtered and balanced subset for plausibility using crowd-sourcing, and perform extensive cleansing to ensure annotation quality. In-depth quantitative analyses indicate that annotators favor plausibility over implausibility and disagree more on implausible events. Furthermore, our plausibility dataset is the first to capture abstractness in events to the same extent as concreteness, and we find that event abstractness has an impact on plausibility ratings: more concrete event participants trigger a perception of implausibility.
[ -0.5730744004249573, -0.6837677955627441, 0.7817187309265137, 0.10307811945676804, -0.18951378762722015, -0.12741191685199738, -0.04785267263650894, -0.8037514090538025, 0.5857909917831421, -0.2020258903503418, -0.5401098728179932, -0.17071343958377838, -0.28614872694015503, 0.36480334401130676, -0.6452394127845764, 1.1838349103927612, -0.22438575327396393, -0.20226263999938965, -0.5450665354728699, -0.1645684838294983, -0.044027265161275864, -0.597169041633606, -0.28616297245025635, -0.4310464859008789, 0.6716547608375549, 0.5011416673660278, 0.937403678894043, 0.4141647219657898, 0.31939002871513367, 0.27702823281288147, 0.2988753318786621, 0.22322921454906464, -0.4304710030555725, -0.044416721910238266, -0.5894703269004822, -0.24860765039920807, -0.12128909677267075, 0.05829374119639397, 0.496285617351532, 0.7791550159454346, 0.013311636634171009, 0.1081843450665474, -0.09825143218040466, 0.415615051984787, -0.4579463005065918, 0.12296637147665024, -0.7828947901725769, 0.2797544598579407, -0.4857015907764435, -0.058488257229328156, -0.1379474699497223, -0.39598825573921204, 0.21467839181423187, -0.8138911724090576, 0.6483229994773865, -0.08266258984804153, 1.191442608833313, -0.015246559865772724, -0.1807410717010498, -0.3392622768878937, -0.5997475981712341, 0.4779484272003174, -0.30794045329093933, -0.039482198655605316, 0.6761122941970825, 0.1328202188014984, -0.11824532598257065, -0.9212617874145508, -1.1423901319503784, -0.25060978531837463, -0.21296386420726776, 0.0401994064450264, -0.18207721412181854, -0.16587550938129425, 0.17845700681209564, 0.33018794655799866, -0.6076582074165344, -0.10200702399015427, -0.46867963671684265, -0.3652280867099762, 0.9552956819534302, 0.14803825318813324, 0.5998797416687012, -0.23371028900146484, 0.11827865242958069, 0.2043047696352005, -0.690360963344574, 0.037064384669065475, 0.7711286544799805, -0.14471875131130219, -0.19506293535232544, 0.6669029593467712, -0.2974371910095215, 0.42491838335990906, 0.06257332116365433, 0.12831677496433258, 0.3391350209712982, -0.2916020452976227, 0.21672868728637695, 0.14624929428100586, 0.8547518253326416, 0.3213464915752411, 0.3036675751209259, -0.5364654064178467, 0.06339263916015625, 0.19514262676239014, -0.07284525781869888, -0.6192743182182312, -0.8204002380371094, 0.508469820022583, -0.3853525221347809, -0.3902048170566559, 0.4909183979034424, -0.49685555696487427, -0.6331039667129517, -0.3349927067756653, 0.4115537405014038, -0.2354348748922348, -0.3676353991031647, 0.059315696358680725, -0.37571489810943604, -0.1655646115541458, 0.3634272813796997, -0.5722432136535645, 0.07683975994586945, 0.6364477872848511, 0.8407159447669983, 0.012604250572621822, -0.7292177081108093, -0.1133802980184555, 0.0913216769695282, -0.10655853152275085, 1.2209535837173462, -0.5219330787658691, -0.12755832076072693, -0.3718639314174652, 0.21924377977848053, 0.28365254402160645, -0.4630652666091919, 0.8406232595443726, -0.20358096063137054, 0.2610781490802765, -0.15119916200637817, -0.5659272074699402, -0.1716334968805313, -0.07666764408349991, -0.8032769560813904, 0.7644741535186768, -0.29207953810691833, -0.9722493886947632, 0.532945454120636, -0.749366819858551, -0.738097071647644, 0.22679445147514343, -0.4385218024253845, -0.2639622986316681, 0.2659580409526825, -0.12074705958366394, 0.08595135062932968, 0.1234068050980568, 0.4754241406917572, -0.5269809365272522, -0.21869921684265137, 0.6994798183441162, -0.47356611490249634, 0.6462172269821167, -0.10191622376441956, -0.45953473448753357, -0.10136434435844421, -1.0886754989624023, -0.43794476985931396, 0.26111799478530884, -0.0675806775689125, -0.317263126373291, 0.6513544321060181, 0.058959051966667175, 0.5723686218261719, 0.5097315907478333, -0.7065823674201965, 0.011353280395269394, -0.6227830052375793, 0.524461030960083, 0.7478718757629395, 0.22722198069095612, 0.17131708562374115, -0.6583020687103271, 0.029719630256295204, 0.056824542582035065, -0.00930784735828638, -0.13943077623844147, -0.7947835922241211, -0.3665205240249634, -0.28738829493522644, 0.10238970071077347, 0.38716888427734375, -0.5583884119987488, 0.4070530831813812, -0.277525931596756, -0.4820578396320343, -0.4441201686859131, 0.013464574702084064, 0.16876840591430664, 0.8483210206031799, 0.07685338705778122, 0.003565720049664378, -0.8772138357162476, -1.0470409393310547, -0.3655534088611603, -0.5571690797805786, -0.3913547694683075, 0.06386897712945938, 0.8074038028717041, 0.3111637234687805, 1.2297245264053345, -0.28101685643196106, 0.08686007559299469, 0.2914014458656311, 0.6672741770744324, 0.047218985855579376, 0.2073589265346527, 0.374905526638031, -0.9660629034042358, -0.16544197499752045, -0.019796021282672882, -1.0486408472061157, -0.23067042231559753, -0.008710185065865517, -0.014620271511375904, 0.23405791819095612, 0.07005741447210312, -0.33318203687667847, 0.5264039635658264, 0.33142295479774475, -0.5546020269393921, 0.6423863172531128, -0.1307259351015091, 0.1608501821756363, -0.7496199011802673, 0.15317298471927643, -0.013375782407820225, -0.2892555296421051, -0.31388387084007263, -0.10880213230848312, -0.1927814781665802, 0.0813589096069336, -0.6086885333061218, 0.5181273818016052, -0.11822855472564697, 0.015376761555671692, -0.361457496881485, 0.3560769259929657, 0.24394239485263824, 0.053132303059101105, 0.3914676308631897, 0.380587637424469, 0.2491876482963562, -0.5187131762504578, 0.44701066613197327, 0.41991519927978516, -0.4460621774196625, 0.6915926933288574, -0.6518173813819885, 0.15026770532131195, -0.6013582348823547, 0.3348333239555359, -1.0787532329559326, -0.7222518920898438, 0.20357945561408997, -0.438775897026062, -0.3262530565261841, -0.08091247826814651, -0.5669872760772705, -0.15090590715408325, -0.4325683116912842, 0.3018580377101898, 0.1609758585691452, -0.396774560213089, 0.4744482934474945, 0.5070477724075317, -0.45486515760421753, -0.21693848073482513, -0.6377679109573364, 0.3708178699016571, -0.02853885293006897, -0.7671431303024292, 0.18265441060066223, -0.24539831280708313, -0.5717266201972961, 0.2767661511898041, 0.06293492764234543, -0.26106515526771545, -0.06695564091205597, 0.7307313680648804, 0.27165621519088745, 0.06549111008644104, 0.03645814582705498, -0.16283297538757324, 0.015516208484768867, 0.24635711312294006, -0.19337411224842072, 0.17293915152549744, 0.11838868260383606, -0.4399470388889313, -0.6898363828659058, 0.38312917947769165, 0.3952322006225586, 0.3699829578399658, 0.7206463813781738, 0.01521459873765707, -0.719610869884491, 0.3228550851345062, -0.2185051590204239, -0.043339718133211136, -0.39303627610206604, 0.3134787082672119, -0.39360252022743225, -0.46904057264328003, 0.6745144724845886, 0.34090444445610046, 0.39724427461624146, 0.6483949422836304, 0.5978878140449524, -0.499477356672287, 1.0096572637557983, -0.04179162159562111, 0.1452399343252182, 0.14028023183345795, 0.21740224957466125, -0.07724138349294662, -0.15136165916919708, -0.4213981032371521, -0.6627634763717651, -0.6558379530906677, -0.32739531993865967, -0.0833205133676529, 0.09190705418586731, -0.08041068911552429, -0.32606932520866394, 0.02007157914340496, -0.2774728238582611, 0.7346654534339905, 0.16785122454166412, 0.2337331771850586, 0.5357377529144287, 0.11216457188129425, 0.11102784425020218, -0.4575366675853729, -0.4324148893356323, -0.7884481549263, 0.7895341515541077, 0.24928148090839386, 0.245202898979187, 0.2135009616613388, 0.2918105125427246, 0.4103907644748688, 0.6151286363601685, -0.41326820850372314, 0.2896801829338074, 0.0620122104883194, -1.0869559049606323, -0.521661102771759, -0.373007595539093, -0.8714451193809509, -0.2146226465702057, -0.4100416898727417, -0.7603843212127686, 0.3604591488838196, 0.17702725529670715, -0.060588739812374115, 0.3132549822330475, -0.6732866168022156, 0.568524181842804, -0.014723756350576878, -0.3740333020687103, -0.07026513665914536, -0.6930667757987976, 0.4889947474002838, -0.27135565876960754, 0.705888032913208, -0.27588826417922974, -0.0880904570221901, 0.8712693452835083, -0.6985649466514587, 0.903796374797821, -0.12667535245418549, -0.024725649505853653, 0.3023192584514618, 0.15914583206176758, 0.7249331474304199, 0.3082316517829895, -0.1212250292301178, 0.24005724489688873, -0.05586978420615196, -0.7320014238357544, -0.442454993724823, 0.6209408640861511, -0.940039336681366, -0.18637529015541077, -0.3210338056087494, -0.32471778988838196, -0.10419727116823196, 0.05805820971727371, 0.5899321436882019, 0.3628017008304596, -0.2963142991065979, -0.24858541786670685, 0.4713972806930542, 0.031853556632995605, 0.4792921245098114, 0.6302791833877563, -0.04385282099246979, -0.5009288191795349, 1.1905685663223267, 0.38197582960128784, -0.027848362922668457, 0.35388559103012085, 0.2236713320016861, -0.41477465629577637, -0.56763756275177, -0.18467171490192413, 0.08943384140729904, -0.7748259902000427, 0.11804001778364182, -0.49483856558799744, -0.130405455827713, -0.11748056858778, -0.33358481526374817, -0.021602999418973923, -0.8671291470527649, -0.06468087434768677, -0.6062173247337341, 0.397664874792099, 0.847338080406189, -0.2091149240732193, -0.21829663217067719, -0.495532363653183, 0.61551433801651, 0.2797382175922394, 0.24638678133487701, -0.24096783995628357, -0.596247673034668, -0.025574320927262306, 0.041685909032821655, -0.1719135344028473, -0.9374832510948181, -0.10290471464395523, 0.3331310451030731, 0.40480881929397583, 0.6388112306594849, 0.3635299503803253, 0.5652521848678589, -0.4947376847267151, 0.8778890371322632, 0.30214419960975647, -1.0659434795379639, 0.5797470808029175, -0.348676472902298, -0.1653163731098175, 0.7110825181007385, 0.5115296244621277, -0.18387967348098755, -0.5876893401145935, -1.0177990198135376, -1.0995897054672241, 0.5489479899406433, 0.4059029817581177, -0.11613292247056961, -0.11180371791124344, 0.3524915277957916, 0.5187317132949829, 0.1625208556652069, -0.7280439138412476, -0.4614922106266022, -0.5058339834213257, -0.38180768489837646, 0.012004764750599861, -0.1575934737920761, -0.2776001989841461, -0.2718134820461273, 0.6310381889343262, 0.05625622346997261, -0.2889243960380554, 0.427914559841156, -0.29340341687202454, -0.24626746773719788, -0.10380725562572479, 0.8175107836723328, 1.3168931007385254, -0.13236887753009796, 0.5153613090515137, 0.21486406028270721, -0.6155455112457275, 0.2406596541404724, 0.20194996893405914, -0.4052230715751648, 0.3887650966644287, 0.548332154750824, 0.5531958341598511, 0.29558929800987244, -0.8575287461280823, 0.40311479568481445, -0.1273781806230545, -0.49492040276527405, -0.6705427169799805, -0.39450013637542725, 0.042332723736763, -0.07887838035821915, 0.6859116554260254, -0.050946082919836044, 0.3156251609325409, -0.5873096585273743, 0.49857544898986816, 0.009027539752423763, -0.06503988057374954, -0.7721670269966125, 0.8952934741973877, 0.27756279706954956, -0.17634348571300507, 0.22879311442375183, -0.39170902967453003, -0.05489366874098778, 0.42534956336021423, 0.0031617218628525734, 0.5247939825057983, 0.26214173436164856, 0.3600791394710541, 0.3447740375995636, 0.3578298091888428, 0.025938132777810097, 0.26739439368247986, 0.16252774000167847, -0.6953232288360596, -0.5781104564666748, -0.5990108251571655, -0.5890088081359863, 0.3898138403892517, -0.30046606063842773, 0.46574363112449646, -0.4136340022087097, 0.07118895649909973, 0.5021306872367859, 0.022430911660194397, -0.4074583947658539, 0.19007812440395355, 0.18065467476844788, 0.9749490022659302, -1.2749824523925781, 0.3850139081478119, 1.1216044425964355, -0.6763390302658081, -0.5544198751449585, 0.17039763927459717, -0.02266061305999756, -0.4883487820625305, 0.476143479347229, -0.2206382155418396, 0.21327510476112366, -0.19504640996456146, -0.618689239025116, -0.4314493238925934, 0.8401301503181458, 0.6520295739173889, -0.5384950637817383, -0.06933985650539398, 0.21627455949783325, 0.39915958046913147, 0.10799732804298401, 0.2273993194103241, 0.39555445313453674, 0.7943801283836365, 0.05929936096072197, -0.8088115453720093, 0.101865254342556, -0.3103310167789459, -0.3604147434234619, 0.009681680239737034, -0.49634718894958496, 0.5236932635307312, 0.084199458360672, -0.32837924361228943, -0.08984426409006119, 0.8597302436828613, 0.48258620500564575, 0.8301419615745544, 0.6008388996124268, 0.44922584295272827, 1.0020848512649536, -0.237656831741333, 0.9181228876113892, -0.20312373340129852, 0.15118612349033356, 1.1369459629058838, -0.3514903485774994, 0.7072080969810486, 0.4071063995361328, -0.4731581211090088, 0.6854236125946045, 0.5503693222999573, 0.3110666871070862, 0.3862536549568176, 0.272642582654953, -0.662162184715271, -0.12035778909921646, 0.04326511546969414, -0.08394481986761093, 0.3308035433292389, 0.16460834443569183, -0.06313375383615494, -0.4665569067001343, 0.085313580930233, 0.22265209257602692, 0.2041582316160202, -0.32458996772766113, 0.7434424757957458, -0.23065057396888733, -0.49255454540252686, 0.0841982290148735, -0.1426011174917221, 0.43821093440055847, -0.34433677792549133, -0.06126829981803894, -0.2586185336112976, -0.30726468563079834, -0.7306666374206543, -1.0406814813613892, 0.5575172901153564, 0.1968233585357666, -0.5734149813652039, 0.20224560797214508, 0.7465339303016663, -0.13652478158473969, -0.49973994493484497, -0.3253530263900757, 0.2140929102897644, 0.8359832167625427, -0.15721893310546875, -0.2930716276168823, -0.07941707223653793, -0.19908279180526733, -0.3187911808490753, 0.5167959928512573, 0.9150199890136719, -0.2008766382932663, 0.24152123928070068, 0.7435026168823242, 0.12728220224380493, -0.009202297776937485, -0.11529253423213959, 0.5900657176971436, -0.5911276340484619, -0.5462977290153503, -0.9733728170394897, 0.6389306783676147, -0.3925301134586334, -0.33870598673820496, 0.5980189442634583, 0.759752094745636, 0.7045992612838745, 0.20018409192562103, 1.288629174232483, -0.3079708516597748, 0.49578505754470825, -0.1185414046049118, 0.7356311678886414, -0.1605021059513092, 0.0636749342083931, 0.01052914746105671, -0.33604931831359863, -0.10035677254199982, 0.5978975892066956, -0.22312836349010468, -0.18756742775440216, 0.43162035942077637, 0.444528192281723, 0.038814641535282135, 0.23006533086299896, 0.24849794805049896, 0.3845387399196625, 0.0963510125875473, 0.4411226212978363, 1.1120271682739258, -0.09570819139480591, 0.5860429406166077, -0.2482832819223404, -0.4137539565563202, -0.22782209515571594, -1.1902469396591187, -0.6302000880241394, -0.9018093347549438, -0.7973110675811768, -0.6010254621505737, 0.13713400065898895, 0.8101052641868591, 0.39943158626556396, -1.1081664562225342, 0.25620824098587036, -0.37124693393707275, 0.22579239308834076, 0.06187807768583298, -0.33196741342544556, 0.2586306631565094, -0.0036750766448676586, -0.6664755940437317, 0.19589243829250336, 0.2529418468475342, 0.09940359741449356, -0.16458086669445038, 0.03123927302658558, 0.0299407709389925, 0.22107040882110596, 0.42312008142471313, 0.9335782527923584, -0.47288039326667786, -0.5023247599601746, -0.5434567928314209, 0.09198428690433502, -0.1774553656578064, 0.6960349678993225, -0.8626711368560791, 0.09269315749406815, 0.5736503005027771, 0.1971559375524521, 0.28027504682540894, 0.012516372837126255, 0.5569356679916382, -0.9973316192626953, 0.33662134408950806, 0.2526783347129822, 0.40753981471061707, 0.2263401299715042, -0.33442264795303345, 0.3058929145336151, 0.7118681073188782, -0.5117014646530151, -1.076839566230774, 0.23507437109947205, -0.6559965014457703, -0.3480188548564911, 0.7710471153259277, -0.19469955563545227, -0.06139000877737999, -0.8181316256523132, -0.16096633672714233, 0.04503576084971428, -0.16603605449199677, 1.2181363105773926, 1.2642391920089722, -0.5088633298873901, 0.08465230464935303, -0.49957475066185, 0.41559740900993347, 0.00011493274359963834, -0.7023801803588867, 0.011833880096673965, 0.6413457989692688, 0.4398607015609741, 0.3319120705127716, 0.513679563999176, -0.003349622944369912, 0.3294471204280853, 0.07791472226381302, 0.08350466936826706, -0.3392788767814636, -0.18262308835983276, -0.24428418278694153, 0.5786625742912292, 0.07259251177310944, -0.011777444742619991 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04031v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04031v1
Willkommens-Merkel, Chaos-Johnson, and Tore-Klose: Modeling the Evaluative Meaning of German Personal Name Compounds
2024-04-05T11:24:41
2024-04-05T11:24:41
Annerose Eichel, Tana Deeg, André Blessing, Milena Belosevic, Sabine Arndt-Lappe, Sabine Schulte im Walde
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.CY
We present a comprehensive computational study of the under-investigated phenomenon of personal name compounds (PNCs) in German such as Willkommens-Merkel ('Welcome-Merkel'). Prevalent in news, social media, and political discourse, PNCs are hypothesized to exhibit an evaluative function that is reflected in a more positive or negative perception as compared to the respective personal full name (such as Angela Merkel). We model 321 PNCs and their corresponding full names at discourse level, and show that PNCs bear an evaluative nature that can be captured through a variety of computational methods. Specifically, we assess through valence information whether a PNC is more positively or negatively evaluative than the person's name, by applying and comparing two approaches using (i) valence norms and (ii) pretrained language models (PLMs). We further enrich our data with personal, domain-specific, and extra-linguistic information and perform a range of regression analyses revealing that factors including compound and modifier valence, domain, and political party membership influence how a PNC is evaluated.
[ -0.48694393038749695, -0.9539965391159058, 0.6573676466941833, 0.21707728505134583, -0.20939232409000397, 0.32196244597435, -0.40672338008880615, -0.09385810047388077, 0.1919916868209839, 0.26060765981674194, -0.42049774527549744, -0.5459443926811218, -0.9091764688491821, 0.17559927701950073, -0.35591480135917664, 1.073960542678833, -0.16391125321388245, 0.26605507731437683, -0.0692470371723175, 0.1522722691297531, 0.04223174974322319, -1.0001217126846313, -0.19621656835079193, -0.5035111904144287, 0.9089287519454956, 0.06951446831226349, 0.6061151027679443, 0.1442326456308365, 0.5654157996177673, 0.2748783528804779, -0.3519362211227417, -0.3676961660385132, -0.6384155750274658, 0.07338464260101318, -0.3916565775871277, -0.20478856563568115, -0.29803189635276794, 0.14933130145072937, 0.5269931554794312, 1.0521215200424194, -0.0068564931862056255, 0.16971264779567719, 0.03687896206974983, 0.6418666839599609, -0.7107499837875366, 0.253207802772522, -0.30727723240852356, -0.0827840119600296, -0.19832797348499298, -0.06324674934148788, -0.16766291856765747, -0.3290228545665741, 0.3226427137851715, -0.21608850359916687, 0.0236271470785141, -0.000639144389424473, 0.9707812666893005, -0.3467266261577606, -0.662306547164917, -0.3132617175579071, -0.9237037897109985, 0.6431542038917542, -0.44714999198913574, 0.6044852137565613, 0.22489064931869507, 0.2810131311416626, -0.5279078483581543, -0.47296226024627686, -0.5910063982009888, -0.5413872003555298, -0.15874935686588287, 0.16687661409378052, -0.49861910939216614, 0.37622588872909546, 0.09567714482545853, 0.6077861785888672, -0.5258965492248535, -0.11652082949876785, -0.47074592113494873, -0.21666066348552704, 0.6590781211853027, 0.08147308975458145, 0.014076350256800652, -0.28661754727363586, -0.5543287992477417, -0.05989687889814377, -0.5857883095741272, 0.1590757668018341, 0.9477890133857727, 0.636559009552002, -0.31671980023384094, 0.5075724720954895, -0.4517917037010193, 0.4910551607608795, 0.07053529471158981, -0.04718881845474243, 0.40123048424720764, -0.22671662271022797, -0.451689749956131, 0.010958824306726456, 0.6439582109451294, -0.07750653475522995, 0.3562052249908447, -0.3749498128890991, -0.08008217811584473, 0.1785317063331604, 0.12256137281656265, -0.879833996295929, -0.8105078339576721, 0.15917059779167175, -0.6572920680046082, -0.7052873373031616, 0.3438795208930969, -0.6979405283927917, -0.5036144852638245, -0.7695574760437012, 0.4117075800895691, -0.09398053586483002, -0.36507943272590637, 0.07000363618135452, -0.06152733787894249, 0.008654503151774406, 0.40895968675613403, -0.3695105016231537, 0.5073615908622742, 0.6573572754859924, 0.2500982880592346, -0.46319669485092163, -0.30833250284194946, -0.32709482312202454, -0.41396281123161316, -0.25478246808052063, 0.9659157395362854, -0.6652622222900391, -0.8935636281967163, 0.12296006083488464, 0.26767250895500183, 0.07054932415485382, -0.5410820245742798, 0.579888641834259, -0.49704664945602417, 0.4417991042137146, -0.7135301232337952, -0.637021541595459, -0.2730860710144043, 0.03465065732598305, -0.5804844498634338, 0.5383914113044739, 0.4335020184516907, -0.6993082761764526, 0.1313912272453308, -0.5188996195793152, -0.5477681756019592, 0.07014128565788269, -0.1388874053955078, -0.15322640538215637, 0.5093035697937012, -0.5355054140090942, 0.3903631269931793, -0.4666074514389038, 0.3530955910682678, -0.33646753430366516, 0.060811806470155716, 0.8092338442802429, -0.4016103744506836, 0.8850586414337158, 0.11288395524024963, -0.042855486273765564, 0.12038754671812057, -0.6787208318710327, -0.08391176909208298, 0.0005580217693932354, -0.3086134195327759, -0.1665305197238922, 0.014798181131482124, 0.31348228454589844, 0.3362806439399719, 0.12199579179286957, -0.386053204536438, -0.04078309237957001, -0.2790858745574951, -0.0334082655608654, 0.906061589717865, 0.25490787625312805, 0.25820451974868774, -0.22602282464504242, 0.7563061714172363, 0.3043113350868225, -0.049502260982990265, -0.14424940943717957, -0.48136821389198303, -0.666580855846405, -0.05723753944039345, 0.696615993976593, 0.6185059547424316, -0.30223289132118225, 0.3151457905769348, -0.2102670967578888, -0.44696226716041565, 0.11454397439956665, -0.018601886928081512, 0.576928436756134, 0.3606235384941101, 0.01415746845304966, -0.2456439882516861, -0.7405766844749451, -1.3908181190490723, -0.6860918998718262, -0.5595085620880127, -0.058738384395837784, 0.5772014260292053, 0.8219883441925049, -0.18716156482696533, 0.614621639251709, -0.5336352586746216, 0.13115203380584717, -0.0654342919588089, 0.46107012033462524, 0.3206285536289215, 0.13588133454322815, 0.13502366840839386, -0.7907171845436096, -0.4321046471595764, -0.12146832793951035, -0.1523914337158203, -0.255472332239151, -0.038390275090932846, -0.17193381488323212, -0.08159146457910538, -0.015952467918395996, -0.2966243624687195, 0.3063039779663086, 0.5419474840164185, -0.612673819065094, 1.1706202030181885, 0.022996127605438232, 0.16612671315670013, -1.0522487163543701, 0.22670480608940125, 0.06094224378466606, -0.19042503833770752, -0.9112992882728577, -0.040971752256155014, -0.24653060734272003, 0.10685722529888153, -0.7902079224586487, 0.7061881422996521, -0.3535599410533905, 0.2164313793182373, -0.23192478716373444, -0.018620405346155167, -0.25200262665748596, 0.5187042355537415, -0.253775030374527, 0.587844967842102, 0.4181358218193054, -0.6256977915763855, 0.534034788608551, 0.09284571558237076, -0.3109050691127777, 0.7879859805107117, -0.2678753733634949, 0.03389814496040344, -0.1347520649433136, 0.09259452670812607, -1.0406780242919922, -0.5270002484321594, 0.41801488399505615, -0.4194042682647705, 0.29844874143600464, 0.09306748956441879, -0.5930608510971069, -0.37714600563049316, -0.06798529624938965, 0.2788311839103699, 0.4353395104408264, -0.4763767421245575, 0.4318610429763794, 0.5152021050453186, -0.13540342450141907, -0.04338836669921875, -0.30748552083969116, 0.2502693831920624, -0.5839521288871765, -0.32402175664901733, 0.7043293714523315, -0.06428816169500351, -0.6571130156517029, -0.0421292781829834, 0.008919818326830864, -0.317044734954834, 0.28645268082618713, 0.18035584688186646, 0.3958800137042999, 0.11417075246572495, 0.24670149385929108, -0.11098245531320572, -0.26501190662384033, 0.21769744157791138, -0.10924958437681198, 0.44247758388519287, -0.4327445328235626, 0.13099536299705505, -0.40138962864875793, 0.4831075668334961, 0.24563680589199066, -0.09274948388338089, 0.5572781562805176, 0.249109148979187, -0.4459705054759979, -0.07867543399333954, -0.33110418915748596, -0.27358272671699524, -0.39498797059059143, 0.3184334933757782, -0.561718761920929, -0.8914272785186768, 0.7162836194038391, -0.5370593667030334, -0.5300030708312988, 0.35033825039863586, 1.0190309286117554, -0.1313764899969101, 0.89405357837677, 0.7043103575706482, 0.044927097856998444, 0.14419591426849365, 0.11248590052127838, 0.5573601126670837, -0.7006993293762207, -0.09817943722009659, -0.41483041644096375, -0.3944275677204132, -0.9831060767173767, -0.30702266097068787, 0.14751605689525604, 0.03851952776312828, -0.3508819341659546, 0.34380558133125305, -0.26880380511283875, 0.32641005516052246, 0.28048935532569885, -0.2706449329853058, 0.11555880308151245, 0.09367685765028, -0.07586684077978134, -0.16075344383716583, 0.001542954589240253, -0.5147135853767395, 0.8272891640663147, 0.25165852904319763, 0.7127395868301392, 0.03230695798993111, 0.6055031418800354, 0.3322027027606964, 0.37938037514686584, -0.6964516043663025, 0.4229249060153961, -0.06333812326192856, -0.6054641604423523, 0.23227952420711517, -0.41273871064186096, -0.8146268725395203, 0.2252146601676941, -0.16151031851768494, -1.1992675065994263, 0.3393726050853729, 0.01593494601547718, -0.43150848150253296, -0.032878465950489044, -0.37377050518989563, 0.8742012977600098, -0.5645307898521423, -0.25467345118522644, -0.11436489969491959, -0.6005828976631165, 0.59830242395401, -0.17828397452831268, 0.17847681045532227, -0.38260334730148315, -0.03844241425395012, 0.7815372943878174, -0.148556649684906, 0.6887670159339905, -0.027725767344236374, -0.2040529102087021, 0.033089425414800644, 0.29153183102607727, 0.5266923308372498, -0.2978379428386688, 0.16704773902893066, 0.46530401706695557, 0.09960169345140457, -0.04085565730929375, -0.6643067598342896, 0.7053244709968567, -0.5636572241783142, -0.43459680676460266, -0.3382587432861328, -0.32997778058052063, -0.11578968167304993, 0.12503227591514587, 0.40565750002861023, 0.07471252232789993, -0.6036437749862671, 0.2396831065416336, 0.25946369767189026, -0.38921016454696655, -0.12581945955753326, 0.7150726914405823, -0.6018348932266235, -0.5875673890113831, 1.1012979745864868, 0.27573126554489136, -0.017452172935009003, 0.1653142273426056, 0.4204539954662323, -0.2901691496372223, -0.09249906986951828, -0.006189586129039526, 0.43818631768226624, -0.5371356010437012, 0.006519028916954994, -0.4581398665904999, -0.09243789315223694, 0.04763060808181763, -0.048249635845422745, -0.23059281706809998, -0.5396807193756104, -0.2141956388950348, -0.16720542311668396, -0.06316716223955154, 0.476426362991333, 0.09258388727903366, 0.614480197429657, -0.14724701642990112, 0.21816404163837433, -0.02059059776365757, 0.5485625267028809, -0.4769916832447052, -0.34948888421058655, -0.06801265478134155, -0.07310395687818527, -0.5007412433624268, -1.5574383735656738, 0.4209024906158447, -0.10026688128709793, 0.4843079447746277, 0.6411608457565308, 0.014580216258764267, 0.47884824872016907, -0.35717928409576416, 0.8321869373321533, 0.24129414558410645, -1.0220296382904053, 0.19525417685508728, -0.4422245919704437, -0.0908723920583725, 0.5919394493103027, 0.24110440909862518, -0.9398700594902039, -0.28526514768600464, -0.9606457352638245, -0.9660787582397461, 0.6086153388023376, 0.571933925151825, 0.2981524169445038, -0.06773248314857483, 0.1669025868177414, 0.11117611080408096, 0.6545289754867554, -0.5691885352134705, -0.6037788391113281, 0.23454223573207855, 0.002805178053677082, 0.06966409087181091, -0.4332955479621887, -0.2144479602575302, -0.26354992389678955, 0.8806225061416626, 0.1512743979692459, 0.44879186153411865, -0.05552591010928154, 0.18438152968883514, -0.20861013233661652, 0.42827409505844116, 0.7452533841133118, 0.5304230451583862, 0.05304528400301933, 0.3607538640499115, 0.2676353454589844, -0.08592239767313004, 0.24999018013477325, 0.209758460521698, 0.14033111929893494, 0.10987875610589981, 0.03120872937142849, 0.8534045815467834, 0.362700879573822, -0.5944162607192993, 0.5057744979858398, 0.030716154724359512, -0.20233699679374695, -0.6362295746803284, -0.22499679028987885, 0.15303081274032593, -0.03715536370873451, 0.144880473613739, -0.13475127518177032, 0.38476449251174927, -0.41885316371917725, 0.16582944989204407, 0.5011246800422668, -0.22451065480709076, -0.811174213886261, 0.3596254587173462, 0.006729671265929937, -0.7103082537651062, 0.33311033248901367, -0.5162020921707153, -1.0241965055465698, 0.4654996395111084, 0.4521590769290924, 1.1996526718139648, -0.639850914478302, 0.33118683099746704, 0.3244801461696625, -0.0550098642706871, 0.3684869706630707, 0.41762882471084595, -0.19798889756202698, -0.6966382265090942, 0.07029204815626144, -0.8021888732910156, -0.26368653774261475, 0.4218420386314392, -0.5393871068954468, 0.5395973324775696, -0.17426422238349915, -0.34492456912994385, -0.011867430061101913, 0.1124894917011261, -0.6869149804115295, 0.036054931581020355, 0.7419736385345459, 0.5950376391410828, -0.9766992926597595, 0.6488962173461914, 0.6710875630378723, -0.06958264857530594, -0.8703178763389587, -0.004101922735571861, 0.24462902545928955, -0.14326058328151703, 0.8335877060890198, 0.17558208107948303, -0.041610684245824814, -0.10958099365234375, -0.25308433175086975, -1.0831241607666016, 0.6307105422019958, 0.26798129081726074, -0.39507588744163513, -0.10186120122671127, 0.3096736967563629, 0.5792604088783264, -0.32718202471733093, 0.19022807478904724, 0.8568087220191956, 0.9205005764961243, -0.07215962558984756, -0.8002442717552185, -0.16451555490493774, -0.45659059286117554, 0.12967710196971893, 0.26190099120140076, -0.30968523025512695, 1.1069762706756592, 0.0993572399020195, -0.45571261644363403, -0.12631011009216309, 0.5433821678161621, 0.12819859385490417, 0.08237691223621368, 0.4950816333293915, 0.34285968542099, 0.9104793071746826, -0.11985427141189575, 1.2820558547973633, -0.7292826771736145, 0.6102473139762878, 1.072320580482483, -0.23442226648330688, 0.47352373600006104, 0.49840933084487915, -0.6468474268913269, 0.7337430119514465, 0.6501759886741638, -0.2172747552394867, 0.4079752266407013, 0.6116162538528442, -0.29146453738212585, -0.19359618425369263, -0.0816933810710907, -0.0841623917222023, 0.630726158618927, 0.32714882493019104, -0.6796750426292419, -0.48594772815704346, -0.015106530860066414, 0.35373547673225403, -0.23372504115104675, 0.09740843623876572, 0.6555470824241638, 0.28036099672317505, -0.5673666596412659, 0.4135609567165375, 0.31886109709739685, 0.0359635092318058, -0.39875534176826477, 0.12084928154945374, 0.14620299637317657, 0.27217939496040344, -0.17170977592468262, -0.5249779224395752, 0.1575278490781784, 0.03350115567445755, -0.10913702100515366, -0.2369808554649353, 0.5913072824478149, -0.36715930700302124, -0.7838609218597412, 0.4559917747974396, 0.7575129270553589, 0.31128546595573425, -0.23729422688484192, -0.6982811093330383, -0.1773877739906311, -0.1055355966091156, -0.597069501876831, 0.3029112219810486, 0.02871759422123432, -0.12253545224666595, 0.24913910031318665, 0.7676783800125122, 0.265840083360672, -0.08233640342950821, -0.006364962086081505, 0.826897382736206, -0.5036071538925171, -0.5923202037811279, -1.128846287727356, 0.4923073649406433, 0.13038961589336395, -0.38221582770347595, 1.0148154497146606, 0.6868013739585876, 0.8255243897438049, -0.011661315336823463, 0.7955100536346436, 0.10743334889411926, 0.47021886706352234, -0.014889277517795563, 0.8465806841850281, -0.24550296366214752, 0.054250143468379974, -0.5142409801483154, -0.8858824372291565, -0.15915319323539734, 0.5074629187583923, -0.7130365967750549, 0.07627329230308533, 0.5973406434059143, 0.6080055236816406, 0.043072499334812164, 0.2004248946905136, 0.4568486213684082, 0.530056357383728, 0.39726513624191284, 0.3057696521282196, 1.0270309448242188, -0.12444707006216049, -0.08367235958576202, -0.5734283328056335, -0.14779850840568542, -0.3619430661201477, -0.7809661626815796, -0.6760070323944092, -0.7838690876960754, -0.3370283544063568, -0.39654669165611267, 0.11640048027038574, 1.1553634405136108, 0.4821688234806061, -0.802683413028717, -0.456233948469162, -0.2692425549030304, 0.061333440244197845, 0.056342002004384995, -0.24332380294799805, 0.4532569944858551, -0.29256725311279297, -0.6925860047340393, 0.1722331941127777, 0.092312753200531, 0.06690267473459244, -0.47954681515693665, -0.09025902301073074, 0.38576433062553406, 0.47780588269233704, 0.6270952224731445, 0.0907445102930069, -1.0504786968231201, -0.1310451179742813, -0.08162370324134827, -0.057378385215997696, 0.2219633013010025, 1.0112569332122803, -0.9493018388748169, 0.5844992399215698, 0.6152629852294922, 0.08834684640169144, -0.018858881667256355, 0.5010496973991394, 0.5620988011360168, -0.276734858751297, -0.14073467254638672, 0.26866549253463745, 0.38626015186309814, 0.3495959937572479, -0.5213079452514648, -0.02268976904451847, 0.4180828630924225, -0.38597869873046875, -1.042483925819397, 0.5262502431869507, -0.7365134954452515, -0.2860237956047058, 1.3006136417388916, -0.015020639635622501, -0.42522409558296204, 0.022338632494211197, -0.13962021470069885, 0.17754943668842316, -0.4087400436401367, 0.9298275709152222, 0.9282440543174744, -0.19918936491012573, 0.14030501246452332, -0.5591647028923035, 0.5646604895591736, 0.0730130672454834, -0.6956352591514587, 0.3459719121456146, 0.43567007780075073, 0.1240762323141098, 0.2726658284664154, 0.34870481491088867, -0.17378711700439453, 0.34951379895210266, -0.22181139886379242, -0.03289855271577835, -0.03327830508351326, -0.5090422034263611, -0.6089637279510498, 0.2285422384738922, -0.3033367097377777, 0.2603198289871216 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04022v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04022v2
Good Books are Complex Matters: Gauging Complexity Profiles Across Diverse Categories of Perceived Literary Quality
2024-04-05T11:06:07
2024-04-14T17:30:24
Yuri Bizzoni, Pascale Feldkamp, Ida Marie Lassen, Mia Jacobsen, Mads Rosendahl Thomsen, Kristoffer Nielbo
cs.CL
cs.CL
In this study, we employ a classification approach to show that different categories of literary "quality" display unique linguistic profiles, leveraging a corpus that encompasses titles from the Norton Anthology, Penguin Classics series, and the Open Syllabus project, contrasted against contemporary bestsellers, Nobel prize winners and recipients of prestigious literary awards. Our analysis reveals that canonical and so called high-brow texts exhibit distinct textual features when compared to other quality categories such as bestsellers and popular titles as well as to control groups, likely responding to distinct (but not mutually exclusive) models of quality. We apply a classic machine learning approach, namely Random Forest, to distinguish quality novels from "control groups", achieving up to 77\% F1 scores in differentiating between the categories. We find that quality category tend to be easier to distinguish from control groups than from other quality categories, suggesting than literary quality features might be distinguishable but shared through quality proxies.
[ -0.24376443028450012, -0.5688282251358032, 0.16887842118740082, 0.08646955341100693, -0.18093346059322357, 0.4552854597568512, 0.10822819918394089, -0.7194298505783081, 0.058409690856933594, 0.5382303595542908, -0.2030588686466217, -0.4366513788700104, -0.9169188737869263, 0.11443021148443222, -0.29301440715789795, 1.2158632278442383, 0.08428538590669632, -0.05564256012439728, -0.32540860772132874, -0.4139358401298523, -0.11433277279138565, -0.43204280734062195, -0.16165128350257874, -0.4343586266040802, 0.6977705955505371, -0.29487282037734985, 1.2611459493637085, 0.524905264377594, 0.7374666333198547, 0.2625585198402405, -0.3463616967201233, 0.20011301338672638, -0.4512118101119995, 0.2917006313800812, -0.6819557547569275, -0.7544192671775818, -0.0436086431145668, 0.08393777161836624, 0.43565183877944946, 0.7181850671768188, 0.19031676650047302, -0.08463320136070251, 0.3586227595806122, 1.010368824005127, -0.4650874435901642, 0.15563710033893585, -0.13416439294815063, 0.09584511071443558, -0.3716414272785187, -0.42342403531074524, -0.5225663781166077, -0.6859598159790039, 0.21704530715942383, -0.8142365217208862, 0.5486819744110107, 0.40846526622772217, 1.4124643802642822, -0.01234503835439682, -0.6156204342842102, -0.8572660684585571, -1.025547742843628, 0.9486346244812012, -0.38424602150917053, -0.07175346463918686, 0.472512811422348, 0.08801017701625824, -0.32935377955436707, -0.3544486463069916, -0.43616244196891785, -0.1855880171060562, -0.5228720903396606, 0.23166492581367493, -0.47264766693115234, 0.09970203042030334, -0.1307748258113861, 0.7890170812606812, -0.6339114308357239, -0.05468035489320755, -0.14249397814273834, -0.2078421413898468, 0.5490540862083435, 0.11944284290075302, 0.4630841016769409, -0.3266587555408478, -0.014576612040400505, -0.19033677875995636, -0.3533709645271301, 0.8494252562522888, 0.6949917674064636, 0.13648119568824768, 0.3947041928768158, 0.4772379994392395, -0.2728837728500366, 0.4694676101207733, -0.1340419203042984, -0.41719716787338257, 0.31277212500572205, -0.4979148805141449, -0.12500950694084167, -0.24388304352760315, 0.7428345680236816, 0.1710885763168335, 0.3249659836292267, -0.19551756978034973, -0.3596343994140625, -0.17282170057296753, 0.2530229687690735, -0.4701903164386749, -0.27517807483673096, 0.3302609622478485, -0.724102795124054, -0.27066221833229065, 0.23102113604545593, -0.5054583549499512, -0.5008842349052429, -0.41602781414985657, 0.766555905342102, -0.19092537462711334, -0.281395822763443, 0.22323034703731537, -0.4576662480831146, 0.10116402059793472, 0.4404134154319763, -0.8116486668586731, 0.20134660601615906, 0.4780319929122925, 0.6303701400756836, -0.40395650267601013, -0.13753406703472137, -0.22701139748096466, 0.12287984043359756, -0.625785768032074, 0.8242749571800232, -0.3895294666290283, -0.055493585765361786, 0.1212182492017746, -0.02560250088572502, 0.24760694801807404, -0.5712302327156067, 0.8328014612197876, -0.44991233944892883, 0.38524508476257324, -0.22069217264652252, -0.46266788244247437, -0.40802183747291565, 0.32179373502731323, -0.9445116519927979, 0.9506375789642334, 0.21718329191207886, -0.7207834124565125, 0.5319320559501648, 0.1395369917154312, -0.6138750314712524, 0.14305157959461212, -0.10274924337863922, -0.3926037549972534, 0.2928600609302521, 0.1574539989233017, 0.7227932214736938, -0.3877270221710205, 0.31229087710380554, -0.13043303787708282, -0.30060917139053345, 0.5289267301559448, -0.19224248826503754, 0.5723868012428284, 0.3426293134689331, -0.1695300191640854, 0.2034343183040619, -0.8480545878410339, 0.1476738154888153, -0.2155175805091858, -0.456490695476532, -0.7592942118644714, 0.012930793687701225, 0.27579525113105774, -0.23152868449687958, 0.18618333339691162, -0.16345800459384918, 0.40448302030563354, -0.20919902622699738, 0.45011985301971436, 0.3906433582305908, 0.10324012488126755, 0.30910345911979675, -0.6906170845031738, 0.5771476030349731, 0.09563059359788895, 0.15260018408298492, -0.1330372542142868, -0.44437599182128906, -0.5738041400909424, -0.576047956943512, 0.488553911447525, 0.5489711165428162, -0.5435216426849365, 0.714978814125061, -0.006950484588742256, -0.9112747311592102, -0.46280214190483093, 0.03653088957071304, 0.5614855885505676, -0.3857545554637909, 0.09922624379396439, -0.3889765441417694, 0.5571801066398621, -0.7662867307662964, -0.6400730013847351, -0.3246924579143524, -0.13412567973136902, 0.2758122980594635, 0.24597138166427612, 0.14248166978359222, 0.8906412720680237, -0.42159876227378845, -0.3536719083786011, -0.2005988359451294, 0.48853644728660583, 0.3983350694179535, 0.4177701771259308, 0.6387147903442383, -0.990726113319397, -0.17479680478572845, 0.1797572821378708, -0.7390744686126709, -0.12422186881303787, -0.2749646306037903, -0.4285908341407776, -0.2813265919685364, 0.4657135009765625, -0.4301406741142273, 0.117674820125103, 0.10663524270057678, -0.5663472414016724, 0.793737530708313, -0.29690834879875183, 0.6952587366104126, -0.7259249687194824, -0.12673671543598175, 0.11760453134775162, 0.24534590542316437, -0.22870075702667236, 0.21314272284507751, -0.007990776561200619, 0.21191535890102386, -0.07767194509506226, 0.4556756019592285, -0.24125105142593384, 0.16103900969028473, 0.29502102732658386, -0.1887863576412201, 0.47110486030578613, 0.47736409306526184, -0.27576005458831787, 0.18609145283699036, 0.39260974526405334, -0.6193551421165466, 0.26179295778274536, -0.1218562126159668, -0.7370884418487549, 0.6748815178871155, -0.46101638674736023, -0.5236459970474243, -0.31555691361427307, 0.038859881460666656, -1.4614516496658325, -0.48475033044815063, -0.13183298707008362, -0.2846693992614746, 0.5097078680992126, 0.10417134314775467, -0.6860998868942261, -0.08817891776561737, -0.018242204561829567, 0.43640491366386414, 0.2889677584171295, -0.1768023669719696, 0.6336075663566589, 0.12463624030351639, -0.27383750677108765, -0.731362521648407, -0.6404153108596802, -0.2129184901714325, -0.2155887484550476, -0.25792044401168823, 0.40780481696128845, -0.2511241137981415, -0.20817168056964874, 0.1891908198595047, 0.002616023877635598, -0.37242591381073, -0.054826121777296066, 0.28004586696624756, -0.1397133767604828, -0.10926607251167297, 0.48761484026908875, 0.5798441171646118, 0.05731571093201637, -0.3369196951389313, -0.10511985421180725, 0.06569390743970871, -0.10856571048498154, -0.09178654104471207, -0.2964366376399994, 0.4526558518409729, 0.840307891368866, -0.4550786316394806, 0.4498739242553711, 0.5245368480682373, -0.2778991162776947, -0.49792930483818054, -0.2576195299625397, 0.19367316365242004, -0.4182737469673157, 0.1813707798719406, -0.5062904953956604, -0.9588605761528015, 0.42781540751457214, 0.23177669942378998, 0.020820289850234985, 0.6329073905944824, 0.32202717661857605, -0.2927750051021576, 0.5703482627868652, 0.7104390263557434, 0.05130176991224289, 0.4268595278263092, -0.13477501273155212, 0.2532798945903778, 0.000038435013266280293, -0.23353439569473267, -1.037825107574463, -0.4342440366744995, -0.6034267544746399, 0.01991661638021469, 0.17180366814136505, 0.9190903902053833, -0.37454965710639954, 0.19936028122901917, -0.849646270275116, 0.8388140201568604, 0.7783910036087036, 0.03939184173941612, 0.7828457951545715, 0.2173631638288498, -0.016187522560358047, -0.1289094239473343, -0.282795250415802, -1.0239125490188599, 1.021734595298767, 0.47792091965675354, 0.9476252794265747, 0.5190384387969971, 0.5941863059997559, 0.8799201250076294, 0.2704925239086151, -0.9498099088668823, 0.30799275636672974, -0.3443582355976105, -0.7854198217391968, -0.5128074288368225, -0.43148717284202576, -1.2191705703735352, 0.22596034407615662, -0.11455556005239487, -0.46613574028015137, 0.4749574363231659, -0.1366749107837677, -0.48119840025901794, 0.13509304821491241, -0.4730597734451294, 0.7571053504943848, -0.0889011025428772, -0.219625324010849, -0.17687922716140747, -0.4971942901611328, 0.20424984395503998, -0.05011596530675888, 0.302913635969162, -0.15644092857837677, 0.028618445619940758, 0.8953158259391785, 0.12921911478042603, 0.5274969339370728, 0.48235684633255005, 0.07757381349802017, 0.5477381944656372, 0.685577392578125, 0.03291631489992142, -0.2634931206703186, -0.21783196926116943, 0.18184053897857666, 0.5498268008232117, -0.8141864538192749, -0.6363810896873474, 0.44544142484664917, -1.259541392326355, -0.2209475189447403, -0.5918455123901367, -0.3038192391395569, -0.2697412967681885, 0.40032315254211426, 0.5035073161125183, 0.7671948075294495, -0.07023795694112778, 0.2572767436504364, 0.5531833171844482, -0.35110634565353394, 0.34016188979148865, 0.2763942778110504, -0.1276121437549591, -0.6043871641159058, 1.038241982460022, 0.6038642525672913, 0.5058003664016724, 0.784609317779541, 0.3023611605167389, -0.09777432680130005, -0.911296010017395, -0.34171751141548157, 0.19844894111156464, -0.8161347508430481, -0.0840689167380333, -0.6608473658561707, -0.18014606833457947, -0.15317486226558685, -0.2651252746582031, 0.029459204524755478, -0.23905614018440247, -0.2322690486907959, -0.03967279568314552, -0.016969338059425354, 1.0378309488296509, 0.34646472334861755, 0.3721761405467987, -0.7356271147727966, 0.14659032225608826, 0.3750979006290436, 0.24592554569244385, -0.03626059740781784, -0.3806397616863251, -0.41315796971321106, -0.6552138328552246, -0.7167575359344482, -0.5814328789710999, 0.50398850440979, 0.25625669956207275, 0.6000638008117676, 0.559833824634552, 0.5586175918579102, -0.11231233179569244, -0.038288697600364685, 1.0661323070526123, 0.18861930072307587, -0.8021863698959351, 0.4044160842895508, -0.5513997673988342, 0.1358688324689865, 0.6855800151824951, 0.7988082766532898, -0.11202055960893631, -0.8386092185974121, -0.6682868003845215, -0.7226216197013855, 0.4189319610595703, 0.39536523818969727, 0.12172126770019531, 0.2012946754693985, 0.27432864904403687, 0.39336904883384705, 0.566500186920166, -1.149349570274353, -0.16702473163604736, -0.12598340213298798, -0.3108416199684143, -0.44367703795433044, -0.2315169721841812, -0.2732408046722412, -0.11334232985973358, 0.30933642387390137, 0.16116534173488617, -0.0626627579331398, 0.2985309064388275, 0.08686959743499756, -0.16762293875217438, 0.630957305431366, 0.37509968876838684, 0.6560176014900208, -0.23792138695716858, 0.3191397190093994, -0.7896007299423218, -0.6017352938652039, 0.37260258197784424, -0.4475480616092682, -0.003310625907033682, 0.07777267694473267, 1.0228995084762573, 0.32501453161239624, -0.2728416323661804, -0.5224916934967041, 0.3440084755420685, 0.2200884222984314, -0.12518224120140076, 0.21989431977272034, 0.5228888988494873, -0.23022958636283875, 0.39331984519958496, 0.4686731696128845, 0.32666367292404175, 0.31130146980285645, -0.857236921787262, 0.021132927387952805, -0.005114045459777117, -0.39003270864486694, -0.006842965725809336, 0.09627757221460342, 0.3691336214542389, -0.31286200881004333, 0.23467110097408295, -0.4090556204319, -0.35873252153396606, 0.8359638452529907, 0.28881463408470154, 0.6489990949630737, 0.14313609898090363, 0.3376319110393524, 0.3988061547279358, 0.6169806122779846, -0.19715718924999237, -0.17281852662563324, 0.16254352033138275, -0.7075164914131165, -0.02680620551109314, -1.1230337619781494, -0.5824078917503357, 0.14441846311092377, -0.535477876663208, 0.12296973168849945, -0.5312285423278809, 0.03502744063735008, 0.10740625858306885, -0.04737554490566254, -0.47407689690589905, 0.36327821016311646, -0.2829991281032562, 0.46764472126960754, -0.9576296210289001, 0.5909105539321899, 0.3486839830875397, -0.5841671824455261, -0.7404457926750183, 0.26288866996765137, -0.14128033816814423, 0.15092183649539948, 0.6871715784072876, 0.2311948984861374, -0.01904071308672428, 0.08559681475162506, -0.40599989891052246, -0.8171684741973877, 0.7388185858726501, 0.15505103766918182, -0.5435676574707031, 0.03232757747173309, -0.06037047132849693, 0.7427125573158264, -0.1788681447505951, 0.5165569186210632, 0.2106216996908188, 0.45311933755874634, 0.0052610463462769985, -0.8632326722145081, -0.5254307985305786, -0.3101026117801666, -0.1898103803396225, 0.27212536334991455, -0.6204963326454163, 0.8043229579925537, 0.1240226998925209, -0.24836476147174835, 0.15611501038074493, 0.6525871753692627, -0.054605528712272644, 0.666312038898468, 0.1897088587284088, 0.35621631145477295, 1.0823004245758057, -0.3805202841758728, 0.8618208765983582, 0.023654859513044357, 0.541650116443634, 0.7054820656776428, 0.25171536207199097, 0.9146105647087097, -0.015239483676850796, -0.48479440808296204, 0.6395644545555115, 1.1624459028244019, 0.04508966580033302, 0.6211194396018982, 0.5861788392066956, -0.1727057695388794, -0.42531076073646545, 0.1263943612575531, -0.45145946741104126, -0.04548965021967888, 0.3002490699291229, -0.4720773994922638, 0.06487950682640076, 0.4678541123867035, -0.19142726063728333, 0.44183433055877686, -0.4294282793998718, 0.678891658782959, 0.03117733635008335, -0.8888939619064331, 0.5247440338134766, 0.06718859076499939, 0.644075334072113, -0.6025851368904114, 0.17743949592113495, -0.24399317800998688, 0.2342814952135086, -0.4864529073238373, -1.2170867919921875, -0.04975828900933266, -0.439325749874115, -0.9464402198791504, -0.044296715408563614, 0.335004061460495, -0.17959147691726685, -0.5725051164627075, 0.2416200190782547, 0.31561267375946045, 0.35674935579299927, -0.047048419713974, -0.5727037787437439, 0.01677272841334343, -0.17534315586090088, -0.5379459857940674, 0.20771324634552002, 1.0392065048217773, 0.03666472062468529, 0.5982527732849121, 0.3531357944011688, -0.05388821288943291, -0.11748557537794113, 0.05775369703769684, 0.13162784278392792, -0.8673332333564758, -0.7864269614219666, -0.4809083640575409, 0.43280160427093506, 0.10838595032691956, -1.0217138528823853, 0.7701624035835266, 0.2860059142112732, 0.832530677318573, -0.1568000167608261, 0.604823887348175, 0.1874883621931076, 0.3782574534416199, -0.4981449544429779, 0.9436860680580139, -0.7439621686935425, 0.26711559295654297, -0.4807475209236145, -0.8019616603851318, -0.5653486251831055, 0.41960594058036804, -0.14521299302577972, -0.0002566979674156755, 0.8150267601013184, 0.7833011746406555, 0.060453642159700394, -0.014301629737019539, 0.4499213397502899, 0.15730641782283783, 0.5559278726577759, 0.3142881989479065, 0.7923593521118164, -0.27183568477630615, 0.36960506439208984, 0.201415553689003, -0.625092625617981, -0.38499096035957336, -0.841469943523407, -0.8661033511161804, -0.9030278325080872, -0.6062854528427124, -0.7762107253074646, -0.0554032027721405, 0.5429325103759766, 0.4126876890659332, -0.7961233854293823, -0.1952354907989502, -0.04412011429667473, 0.5129622220993042, -0.7016683220863342, -0.28137412667274475, 0.6053638458251953, -0.49485617876052856, -0.664501965045929, -0.37222060561180115, 0.1717199981212616, -0.13902869820594788, -0.451898992061615, -0.019732404500246048, 0.3766537606716156, 0.503852367401123, 0.7174459099769592, -0.029950909316539764, -0.9659634232521057, -0.05086677893996239, -0.4237018823623657, -0.8365487456321716, -0.015939492732286453, 0.8723576068878174, -0.40588632225990295, 0.7188923954963684, 0.7606359720230103, 0.640966534614563, 0.17896431684494019, -0.3428797721862793, 0.16882064938545227, -0.08937865495681763, -0.386270135641098, 0.4075285494327545, 0.14397232234477997, -0.03326166048645973, -0.466926634311676, 0.3959907293319702, 0.5244131684303284, -0.8256422877311707, -0.7344440221786499, 0.24210919439792633, -1.471380591392517, -0.6461434960365295, 1.0705795288085938, -0.24304288625717163, -0.24692504107952118, -0.3619556427001953, -0.504713237285614, -0.20020350813865662, -0.15861575305461884, 0.7684871554374695, 1.4605317115783691, -0.25928306579589844, 0.1159357950091362, -0.4843639135360718, 0.716090977191925, 0.43306002020835876, -0.928154706954956, -0.010765880346298218, 0.4178639054298401, -0.003041765419766307, 0.6239471435546875, 0.11357391625642776, -0.3500242233276367, 0.00900731049478054, -0.2028745412826538, 0.21262332797050476, 0.1594914346933365, -0.549564778804779, -0.20090657472610474, 0.9767987728118896, 0.2298090010881424, 0.3142643868923187 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04003v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04003v1
BuDDIE: A Business Document Dataset for Multi-task Information Extraction
2024-04-05T10:26:42
2024-04-05T10:26:42
Ran Zmigrod, Dongsheng Wang, Mathieu Sibue, Yulong Pei, Petr Babkin, Ivan Brugere, Xiaomo Liu, Nacho Navarro, Antony Papadimitriou, William Watson, Zhiqiang Ma, Armineh Nourbakhsh, Sameena Shah
cs.CL
cs.CL
The field of visually rich document understanding (VRDU) aims to solve a multitude of well-researched NLP tasks in a multi-modal domain. Several datasets exist for research on specific tasks of VRDU such as document classification (DC), key entity extraction (KEE), entity linking, visual question answering (VQA), inter alia. These datasets cover documents like invoices and receipts with sparse annotations such that they support one or two co-related tasks (e.g., entity extraction and entity linking). Unfortunately, only focusing on a single specific of documents or task is not representative of how documents often need to be processed in the wild - where variety in style and requirements is expected. In this paper, we introduce BuDDIE (Business Document Dataset for Information Extraction), the first multi-task dataset of 1,665 real-world business documents that contains rich and dense annotations for DC, KEE, and VQA. Our dataset consists of publicly available business entity documents from US state government websites. The documents are structured and vary in their style and layout across states and types (e.g., forms, certificates, reports, etc.). We provide data variety and quality metrics for BuDDIE as well as a series of baselines for each task. Our baselines cover traditional textual, multi-modal, and large language model approaches to VRDU.
[ -0.3546856641769409, -0.9046814441680908, 0.22655156254768372, 0.44778212904930115, -0.5190010666847229, 0.03309199586510658, -0.21458879113197327, -0.5790050625801086, 0.03317827731370926, 0.5774968862533569, -0.5028517842292786, -0.5877891778945923, -0.5344203114509583, 0.10961342602968216, -0.2723793387413025, 0.9947827458381653, 0.014152697287499905, -0.2053574174642563, -0.20999467372894287, -0.12436848133802414, -0.7414484024047852, -0.30759668350219727, -0.5289499163627625, 0.034987788647413254, 0.4228363633155823, 0.4057404398918152, 0.19365054368972778, 0.40811845660209656, 0.5683448910713196, 0.24245303869247437, 0.3101254403591156, 0.37527045607566833, -0.5684247016906738, 0.39592891931533813, -0.2977215349674225, -0.3002607822418213, -0.26913297176361084, 0.03567958623170853, 0.5606245994567871, 0.21855328977108002, -0.09843166917562485, 0.2943914234638214, 0.03118409961462021, 0.5184256434440613, -0.5569393634796143, 0.7465428709983826, -0.47766414284706116, -0.30714133381843567, -0.5405250787734985, -0.42786434292793274, -0.43836337327957153, -0.008611622266471386, 0.036206915974617004, -0.8159555196762085, 0.5951356291770935, 0.14376360177993774, 1.4432215690612793, 0.16365353763103485, -0.3775150775909424, -0.20554287731647491, -0.5836166143417358, 0.6768020391464233, -0.17132100462913513, 0.6276755928993225, 0.33730679750442505, 0.23201139271259308, 0.012282908894121647, -0.9109647274017334, -0.5349878668785095, 0.3044212758541107, -0.10921107977628708, 0.3231276273727417, -0.350376158952713, 0.03709866851568222, 0.3359159827232361, 0.40741974115371704, -0.4813724458217621, -0.03549040108919144, -0.5523599982261658, -0.06485225260257721, 0.40188083052635193, 0.05071935057640076, 0.02968466654419899, -0.6882011890411377, -0.46357405185699463, -0.35048335790634155, -0.2858390808105469, 0.22072820365428925, 0.11852710694074631, 0.1526682823896408, 0.11997201293706894, 0.4928176999092102, -0.16502851247787476, 0.8211415410041809, -0.16415105760097504, -0.22571253776550293, 0.17081579566001892, -0.8218564987182617, -0.7725919485092163, 0.07722235471010208, 0.7579025626182556, 0.18223661184310913, -0.007647508289664984, -0.35816386342048645, -0.17641885578632355, -0.08419175446033478, 0.5816826224327087, -0.9387722015380859, -0.31823721528053284, 0.34448978304862976, -0.555287778377533, -0.14853732287883759, 0.09907466173171997, -0.9435290098190308, -0.5254032611846924, -0.5170302987098694, 0.17833657562732697, -0.688129723072052, -0.3444331884384155, -0.048457153141498566, -0.5370289087295532, 0.3412749171257019, 0.6938778758049011, -0.6580615639686584, 0.11130429804325104, 0.7494491934776306, 0.9598543643951416, -0.025218069553375244, -0.17724773287773132, -0.8696416020393372, 0.2883123457431793, -0.3249431848526001, 0.9356517791748047, -0.5162013173103333, -0.4756793975830078, -0.27154549956321716, 0.13063234090805054, -0.20913121104240417, -0.4209703803062439, 0.8541331887245178, -0.38994693756103516, -0.17910125851631165, -0.554806649684906, -0.3423946499824524, -0.45712119340896606, 0.2875375747680664, -1.015284776687622, 0.8919450640678406, 0.34805840253829956, -1.032776951789856, 0.9262623190879822, -0.6124523282051086, -0.34196600317955017, 0.586654543876648, -0.8073263168334961, -0.18667547404766083, 0.22351625561714172, 0.34207913279533386, 0.8357502818107605, -0.480551540851593, 0.17822265625, -0.019078493118286133, -0.2882946729660034, -0.1306615024805069, -0.48905110359191895, 1.0130867958068848, 0.17460763454437256, -0.04245061054825783, 0.18757638335227966, -0.8119210004806519, -0.28496822714805603, 0.1908758282661438, -0.40867406129837036, -0.7138464450836182, -0.26110509037971497, 0.7184088230133057, 0.28856807947158813, 0.10682996362447739, -0.7861765027046204, 0.2997014820575714, 0.07851812243461609, 0.29436933994293213, 0.754273533821106, 0.13819734752178192, -0.19286170601844788, -0.2804791033267975, 0.5063362717628479, 0.09873421490192413, -0.034575480967760086, -0.16878366470336914, -0.4848897159099579, -0.2753273546695709, -1.1487737894058228, 0.35745710134506226, 0.37723520398139954, -0.6286796927452087, 0.11073851585388184, -0.7563468217849731, -0.5110327005386353, -0.955873429775238, 0.25791075825691223, 0.06589443236589432, 0.5210224390029907, 0.13078273832798004, -0.4053357243537903, -0.2923964262008667, -1.025474190711975, -0.04253097623586655, -0.05360334739089012, 0.2388504594564438, 0.33918526768684387, 0.2843964695930481, -0.13894429802894592, 1.0339032411575317, -0.33740466833114624, -0.6633619070053101, -0.3104081451892853, 0.6978256702423096, 0.19835439324378967, 0.28031983971595764, 0.5154865384101868, -1.3540804386138916, -0.24879613518714905, 0.10938822478055954, -0.6582927703857422, 0.4260730743408203, -0.6216423511505127, -0.35770636796951294, -0.03079589642584324, 0.2843492329120636, -0.7373674511909485, 0.4491419792175293, 0.15815243124961853, -0.1989857256412506, 0.4886147379875183, -0.20103125274181366, 0.1832917332649231, -1.272508144378662, 0.19384068250656128, 0.5073099136352539, -0.35327643156051636, -0.4147898554801941, -0.04531143605709076, 0.411135733127594, 0.03375885263085365, 0.01549228373914957, 0.479586660861969, -0.4858253300189972, -0.13350209593772888, 0.04542456194758415, 0.02415282279253006, 0.5013021230697632, 0.5376223921775818, 0.288261741399765, 0.9253711700439453, 0.6032286286354065, -0.43690574169158936, 0.502377450466156, 0.620710551738739, -0.6414324641227722, 0.9995132684707642, -0.4609793722629547, -0.03372173011302948, -0.4652242958545685, -0.1494138091802597, -0.9275186061859131, -0.17792554199695587, 0.20071040093898773, -0.18687720596790314, 0.6014695763587952, -0.2671970725059509, -1.0661250352859497, -0.0695861205458641, -0.1869974285364151, -0.042780958116054535, -0.013405445963144302, -0.47602522373199463, 0.6877065300941467, 0.27165716886520386, -0.47025009989738464, -0.570543646812439, -0.5620392560958862, 0.24224837124347687, -0.11518657207489014, -0.6034584045410156, 0.4152076542377472, 0.12450993061065674, -0.13746203482151031, 0.32942530512809753, -0.3709154427051544, -0.4153919219970703, 0.09495498985052109, 0.45928868651390076, 0.46910908818244934, -0.015198701061308384, 0.13784894347190857, 0.03660140931606293, 0.12395879626274109, -0.0025452927220612764, 0.01272004097700119, 0.20016616582870483, -0.12176162749528885, -0.1578834056854248, -0.3075820207595825, 0.5100547671318054, 0.5886405110359192, -0.7039260864257812, 0.6340109705924988, 0.930420994758606, -0.5113080739974976, -0.0817270427942276, -0.6061409711837769, 0.3792523145675659, -0.36647477746009827, 0.49998244643211365, -0.7567254900932312, -0.3673548102378845, 0.1351677030324936, -0.02917601354420185, 0.6264674067497253, 0.5395011901855469, 0.4362236261367798, -0.026980269700288773, 0.45562684535980225, 0.9747604131698608, -0.10837475955486298, 0.637404203414917, -0.4889666736125946, 0.2524852454662323, -0.7662876844406128, -0.581670880317688, -0.5755112171173096, 0.04313570261001587, -0.4092482328414917, -0.3734864890575409, 0.22546236217021942, 0.20072810351848602, 0.40474066138267517, 0.5923532247543335, -0.5435433387756348, -0.006017840467393398, 0.7911508083343506, 0.0775245875120163, 0.25725632905960083, 0.18741236627101898, 0.25153684616088867, 0.037911321967840195, -0.5145976543426514, -0.40179112553596497, 1.0920134782791138, 0.10155396908521652, 0.8049067258834839, 0.051604725420475006, 0.7974083423614502, 0.28082478046417236, 0.2058618813753128, -0.8555848598480225, 0.1662425845861435, -0.15537936985492706, -0.6955246925354004, -0.42992258071899414, -0.41312912106513977, -0.967934787273407, 0.3438129127025604, -0.21088053286075592, -0.8571022748947144, 0.6690325736999512, -0.22011910378932953, -0.3380916714668274, 0.05090003088116646, -0.8252726197242737, 1.1626499891281128, -0.22597257792949677, -0.5851871967315674, -0.23913811147212982, -0.37221038341522217, 0.29014164209365845, -0.37171393632888794, 0.20901332795619965, -0.12073103338479996, 0.1872444748878479, 0.8513001203536987, 0.004268634133040905, 0.4433780014514923, 0.0680801123380661, 0.10002348572015762, 0.08165431767702103, -0.07763104885816574, 0.4688098132610321, 0.24882015585899353, -0.13712328672409058, 0.17045854032039642, 0.4898023009300232, -0.5042513012886047, -0.5045549869537354, 0.5027298927307129, -0.3641054034233093, -0.2682308852672577, -0.6715394258499146, -0.6520588994026184, -0.05165725201368332, 0.5036795139312744, 0.26382991671562195, 0.780586302280426, -0.1040085107088089, 0.42574381828308105, 0.7363376617431641, 0.10836701840162277, 0.23799379169940948, 0.19485008716583252, 0.3082369565963745, -0.18532775342464447, 1.1026215553283691, 0.30246633291244507, -0.25304365158081055, 0.37043991684913635, -0.23999406397342682, -0.4740469455718994, -0.4146023690700531, -0.5749754309654236, 0.19304393231868744, -0.9461663365364075, -0.1036403551697731, -0.9082503914833069, -0.1399310827255249, -0.4539249539375305, 0.034107550978660583, -0.04899175465106964, -0.014705389738082886, -0.37422728538513184, -0.0916995257139206, 0.37918606400489807, 0.7650421261787415, 0.17370007932186127, -0.19954119622707367, -0.8515178561210632, 0.793300449848175, 0.30618762969970703, 0.336235910654068, -0.19551204144954681, 0.016255009919404984, -0.3567306101322174, -0.23312465846538544, -0.10243366658687592, -1.0470582246780396, 0.2977144420146942, 0.11301393806934357, 0.7585520148277283, 0.574156641960144, 0.006128564011305571, 0.8647652864456177, -0.07785601168870926, 0.47776663303375244, 0.03404323756694794, -0.5393708348274231, 0.38769620656967163, -0.15908388793468475, -0.17331981658935547, 0.7825895547866821, 0.6099638938903809, -0.46023812890052795, -0.08261995762586594, -0.732926070690155, -0.8416982889175415, 0.8346720337867737, 0.35461196303367615, -0.12650448083877563, 0.07362615317106247, 0.23332980275154114, 0.4070473909378052, 0.6069316267967224, -0.3336144983768463, -0.11946861445903778, -0.40712636709213257, -0.25002920627593994, -0.08559339493513107, -0.1991833746433258, -0.14639398455619812, -0.12269850820302963, 0.5272244811058044, 0.06999921053647995, 0.2044101059436798, 0.30255401134490967, -0.192526713013649, 0.09471333026885986, 0.33597856760025024, 0.06923255324363708, 1.015381097793579, -0.6066611409187317, -0.02575114741921425, -0.5790667533874512, -0.6838315725326538, -0.29505833983421326, 0.6194008588790894, -0.02812192402780056, 0.3332182765007019, 0.33604881167411804, 0.8656401634216309, -0.1088348999619484, -0.7507249116897583, 0.538363516330719, -0.2929137051105499, -0.07895787805318832, -0.11586521565914154, -0.08588957786560059, -0.2373879998922348, 0.2860373854637146, 0.23076920211315155, -0.0625811293721199, 0.3360113501548767, -0.6150423288345337, 0.1904633641242981, 0.43232986330986023, -0.19640347361564636, 0.06424860656261444, 0.6108464598655701, 0.004523999523371458, 0.055340494960546494, 0.7668383121490479, -0.4224349856376648, 0.08839448541402817, 0.48762059211730957, 0.22684749960899353, 0.8743057250976562, 0.4067440629005432, 0.2879086434841156, 0.2752748727798462, 0.46053454279899597, -0.001625659759156406, 0.5631343126296997, -0.4622129499912262, -0.34336769580841064, -0.2991451025009155, -0.7515878677368164, -0.34246355295181274, 0.4147082567214966, -0.7965452671051025, 0.2973161041736603, -0.3254924416542053, -0.1520547866821289, 0.49984145164489746, 0.28561636805534363, -1.1845537424087524, 0.31978002190589905, -0.18410421907901764, 0.873059868812561, -0.6149244904518127, 0.9533669948577881, 0.7215114235877991, -0.9905126690864563, -0.5401914715766907, -0.008631354197859764, -0.21249550580978394, -0.4693290889263153, 0.7848601341247559, 0.28007349371910095, 0.10409986227750778, 0.12044822424650192, -0.3094797730445862, -0.4073905944824219, 1.073854923248291, 0.19318869709968567, -0.6015247106552124, -0.3861893117427826, -0.3432103991508484, 0.13434439897537231, 0.027151312679052353, -0.07681392878293991, 0.4566080868244171, 0.4013304114341736, -0.10838925838470459, -0.5320826768875122, 0.020939256995916367, -0.4680590033531189, -0.050159260630607605, 0.10630648583173752, -0.5527224540710449, 0.7030741572380066, 0.21667124330997467, -0.2949460744857788, -0.4458388686180115, 0.5315632820129395, 0.07977209240198135, 0.09382826834917068, 0.4685250222682953, 0.44888541102409363, 1.0080426931381226, -0.03559967130422592, 1.0454554557800293, -0.14388884603977203, 0.09165135771036148, 1.1743189096450806, -0.12843258678913116, 0.5988345146179199, 0.406999796628952, 0.1264529675245285, 0.2927215099334717, 0.7600437998771667, -0.41267165541648865, 0.48685771226882935, -0.06893133372068405, -0.03527332469820976, -0.36124587059020996, -0.3488853871822357, -0.07463338971138, 0.359085351228714, 0.4950801432132721, -0.06969122588634491, -0.28447428345680237, 0.004355590790510178, -0.18400631844997406, -0.25102663040161133, -0.049401164054870605, 0.7627100944519043, -0.08359987288713455, -0.32475003600120544, 0.1972377598285675, 0.14055797457695007, 0.32869231700897217, -0.6497226357460022, -0.2860792577266693, -0.005492840893566608, -0.27971455454826355, -0.1542091816663742, -0.8775938749313354, 0.041267260909080505, 0.22008545696735382, -0.21007096767425537, -0.41247183084487915, 0.7405913472175598, -0.2160712331533432, -0.5095644593238831, 0.0549810566008091, 0.3331001102924347, 0.2654188275337219, -0.44054391980171204, -0.6475080847740173, -0.02014891430735588, -0.2626086175441742, -0.279448002576828, 0.10065735876560211, 0.9284715056419373, -0.11125156283378601, 0.4372524321079254, 0.5533095002174377, 0.2847581207752228, 0.20235131680965424, 0.05628770589828491, 0.8726984858512878, -0.5533745884895325, -0.6461624503135681, -0.48550528287887573, 0.3732660114765167, -0.4688899517059326, -0.32656243443489075, 0.6742797493934631, 0.9078412055969238, 0.8672580122947693, 0.14149998128414154, 1.1941708326339722, -0.21761387586593628, 0.14478182792663574, -0.4536909759044647, 0.5702165365219116, -0.8878061771392822, -0.24266964197158813, -0.4657995402812958, -0.8015984892845154, 0.1797664910554886, 0.4226476550102234, -0.049412671476602554, -0.30225151777267456, 0.6347358226776123, 0.5510711669921875, -0.39646077156066895, 0.022572020068764687, 0.189763605594635, -0.02603147365152836, 0.4474826753139496, 0.3300299644470215, 0.2375681847333908, -0.23554494976997375, 0.7703987956047058, -0.49130120873451233, -0.1800210326910019, -0.25933194160461426, -0.6248962879180908, -0.8996531367301941, -0.9876399040222168, -0.47340115904808044, -0.2476741075515747, -0.16583439707756042, 0.8902876377105713, 0.8379697799682617, -0.47998282313346863, 0.03144648298621178, -0.09237954765558243, -0.006385643966495991, -0.5505252480506897, -0.2350027859210968, 0.6513860821723938, -0.35666102170944214, -0.8082075715065002, 0.33073070645332336, 0.5770880579948425, -0.0712122917175293, -0.002050978597253561, 0.39817917346954346, -0.40490463376045227, -0.051674116402864456, 0.4018474817276001, 0.2110491394996643, -0.5618147253990173, 0.14779631793498993, -0.13787253201007843, -0.3112236261367798, 0.34339889883995056, 0.7279584407806396, -0.4411140978336334, 0.9982510209083557, 0.49593761563301086, 1.0140819549560547, 0.7335757613182068, 0.10856068134307861, 0.22112703323364258, -0.7570984959602356, 0.15156437456607819, 0.0192209854722023, 0.38548949360847473, 0.3332709074020386, -0.5923641324043274, 0.4557929039001465, 0.4484577476978302, -0.06187694892287254, -0.6740891337394714, 0.0421760156750679, -1.3890446424484253, -0.38671666383743286, 0.814804196357727, -0.1540796458721161, -0.3014623522758484, -0.384155809879303, -0.49975699186325073, 0.4706959128379822, -0.4995972216129303, 0.5556410551071167, 0.949202835559845, -0.02842421643435955, -0.24846337735652924, -0.9586060047149658, 0.39929500222206116, -0.014577992260456085, -0.9489904046058655, 0.3456701338291168, 0.6664848327636719, 0.047462303191423416, 0.17764027416706085, 0.9934800863265991, 0.017854897305369377, 0.4150751233100891, 0.1969965249300003, 0.0738435909152031, -0.49022379517555237, -0.595840573310852, -0.13884337246418, 0.37721776962280273, 0.045644938945770264, -0.5857442021369934 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03987v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03987v1
Investigating the Robustness of Modelling Decisions for Few-Shot Cross-Topic Stance Detection: A Preregistered Study
2024-04-05T09:48:00
2024-04-05T09:48:00
Myrthe Reuver, Suzan Verberne, Antske Fokkens
cs.CL
cs.CL
For a viewpoint-diverse news recommender, identifying whether two news articles express the same viewpoint is essential. One way to determine "same or different" viewpoint is stance detection. In this paper, we investigate the robustness of operationalization choices for few-shot stance detection, with special attention to modelling stance across different topics. Our experiments test pre-registered hypotheses on stance detection. Specifically, we compare two stance task definitions (Pro/Con versus Same Side Stance), two LLM architectures (bi-encoding versus cross-encoding), and adding Natural Language Inference knowledge, with pre-trained RoBERTa models trained with shots of 100 examples from 7 different stance detection datasets. Some of our hypotheses and claims from earlier work can be confirmed, while others give more inconsistent results. The effect of the Same Side Stance definition on performance differs per dataset and is influenced by other modelling choices. We found no relationship between the number of training topics in the training shots and performance. In general, cross-encoding out-performs bi-encoding, and adding NLI training to our models gives considerable improvement, but these results are not consistent across all datasets. Our results indicate that it is essential to include multiple datasets and systematic modelling experiments when aiming to find robust modelling choices for the concept `stance'.
[ -0.4752642512321472, -0.7008250951766968, 0.6771001219749451, 0.047883301973342896, -0.3664482533931732, -0.45780038833618164, -0.08033426105976105, -0.19570747017860413, 0.0880923941731453, 0.36117038130760193, -0.4872710704803467, -0.795900821685791, -1.0057414770126343, 0.0684051439166069, -0.20233388245105743, 1.0804897546768188, 0.086469866335392, 0.45585566759109497, -0.10184167325496674, -0.6543325185775757, -0.18676753342151642, -0.28716841340065, -0.5014752745628357, -0.20692208409309387, 0.3815627694129944, 0.17152690887451172, 0.8365031480789185, 0.25272336602211, 0.4746186137199402, 0.18845458328723907, -0.28673315048217773, -0.23476234078407288, -0.35959771275520325, -0.2915970981121063, -0.2682301700115204, -0.7719072699546814, -0.6209322214126587, 0.17057481408119202, 0.7779298424720764, 0.5264467000961304, 0.10660932213068008, -0.01619412750005722, 0.05851335823535919, 0.44604137539863586, -0.739351212978363, -0.3750336766242981, -0.6778513789176941, -0.019602617248892784, -0.3007405400276184, 0.2740420401096344, -0.4733700156211853, 0.12558379769325256, 0.15354707837104797, -0.3562115728855133, 0.053461167961359024, -0.06984667479991913, 1.077623963356018, 0.15387174487113953, -0.45702064037323, -0.015212413854897022, -0.4854348599910736, 1.1216015815734863, -0.9852440357208252, 0.6015260219573975, 0.5011991262435913, 0.13165751099586487, -0.0475534126162529, -0.12027882039546967, -0.5588404536247253, -0.02832905389368534, -0.09181337058544159, 0.10921388119459152, -0.6471032500267029, -0.06275062263011932, 0.366578072309494, -0.009576437063515186, -0.5840274095535278, 0.4027436375617981, -0.016645535826683044, -0.11260620504617691, 0.28374409675598145, -0.000989140709862113, 0.07160717993974686, -0.5893184542655945, -0.47659993171691895, 0.1341560333967209, -0.6616455316543579, 0.257224440574646, 0.8165743350982666, 0.510226309299469, -0.5685068964958191, 0.8406425714492798, -0.24162890017032623, 0.7966032028198242, 0.47343507409095764, -0.2649456262588501, -0.041040606796741486, -0.40020447969436646, -0.2889762818813324, -0.32662758231163025, 0.8066876530647278, 0.311810165643692, -0.10128550976514816, 0.15687939524650574, -0.08398133516311646, 0.10788671672344208, 0.3850715458393097, -0.5067399740219116, 0.03896034136414528, 0.30424898862838745, -0.676939845085144, -0.3613080084323883, 0.06776457279920578, -0.4370866119861603, -0.471664696931839, -0.2663303017616272, 0.28846126794815063, -0.571528434753418, -0.3511327803134918, 0.24871088564395905, -0.08681054413318634, 0.61322420835495, 0.35141757130622864, -0.658577024936676, -0.0413864329457283, 0.959293782711029, 0.7473394870758057, -0.5539917945861816, -0.24765633046627045, -0.48203927278518677, -0.10033896565437317, -0.3595796823501587, 0.9256200194358826, -0.5910755395889282, -0.36954060196876526, -0.16035206615924835, -0.21320851147174835, 0.05833471193909645, -0.1415356993675232, 0.6028569936752319, -0.44232043623924255, 0.3002372980117798, -0.2959628105163574, -0.6437441110610962, -0.07344945520162582, 0.8821240067481995, -0.6926633715629578, 0.724277675151825, -0.10083617269992828, -1.3489478826522827, 1.0505210161209106, -0.3551923632621765, -0.29491549730300903, -0.4958372414112091, -0.4365920424461365, -0.6587298512458801, 0.1560545414686203, 0.29809796810150146, 0.3587948679924011, 0.10776006430387497, 0.23127241432666779, -0.7239950895309448, 0.029813025146722794, 0.1732206493616104, -0.3800831735134125, 0.8634000420570374, -0.11282508075237274, -0.1069142147898674, 0.2944091260433197, -0.6866825819015503, -0.3462565243244171, -0.1990680694580078, -0.49414026737213135, -0.5072789192199707, -0.04144756868481636, -0.1531093865633011, 0.21643052995204926, -0.1682417243719101, -0.31168133020401, 0.24961857497692108, -0.4659699499607086, -0.11998482048511505, 0.41903913021087646, 0.08664216101169586, 0.7090402841567993, -0.35329148173332214, 0.7092607021331787, 0.4253595769405365, 0.09919390082359314, 0.08124697208404541, -0.5578237175941467, -0.5956646800041199, -0.36147499084472656, 0.3870961368083954, 0.33608752489089966, -0.5453997254371643, 0.3830501139163971, -0.11177302896976471, -0.21139006316661835, -0.322361558675766, 0.12241769582033157, 0.3293231129646301, 0.4330233633518219, 0.14813077449798584, -0.4579138457775116, -0.637220561504364, -0.9898805618286133, -0.7816450595855713, -0.3626692295074463, 0.25608789920806885, 0.06883338838815689, 0.4864985942840576, -0.19185605645179749, 1.1284054517745972, 0.05104578286409378, -0.1430571973323822, -0.6729917526245117, 0.5038557648658752, 0.3049084544181824, 0.2653532922267914, 1.0183969736099243, -0.8178339004516602, -0.37231355905532837, -0.2310829609632492, -0.5943451523780823, 0.29316237568855286, -0.3374708890914917, -0.30094873905181885, 0.36358651518821716, 0.010409340262413025, -0.7714086174964905, 0.7005778551101685, 0.41124531626701355, -0.009640062227845192, 0.3090011775493622, 0.240117609500885, 0.08918499201536179, -1.141426682472229, -0.24344006180763245, 0.5032433271408081, -0.324942409992218, -0.6396717429161072, -0.010695665143430233, -0.24340423941612244, -0.001731995027512312, -0.8477504849433899, 0.4202536642551422, -0.27697765827178955, -0.38040608167648315, -0.4338551163673401, 0.05042703077197075, 0.08076559007167816, 0.2416646033525467, 0.4112895429134369, 0.4962448477745056, 0.8499752283096313, -0.575704038143158, -0.22730953991413116, 0.23191367089748383, -0.26485490798950195, 0.8713542819023132, -0.5080953240394592, 0.10183465480804443, -0.1773313283920288, 0.3404116630554199, -1.0695321559906006, -0.1366310566663742, 0.45462948083877563, -0.3959982395172119, 0.3571721613407135, -0.9240041375160217, -0.06118016690015793, -0.012952325865626335, -0.5382184982299805, 0.10758941620588303, 0.06113956496119499, -0.31989240646362305, 0.8623262643814087, 0.440600723028183, 0.0799984484910965, -0.945509135723114, -0.7310001254081726, -0.14780937135219574, -0.5411545634269714, -0.4866947531700134, 0.0524434857070446, 0.294181764125824, -0.4677182734012604, -0.03602011129260063, -0.3968293368816376, -0.007323550060391426, 0.0288681723177433, 0.24867071211338043, 0.32026931643486023, -0.37987470626831055, -0.1699140965938568, -0.12563453614711761, -0.18839214742183685, -0.17074991762638092, -0.346865177154541, 0.4531220495700836, -0.17040669918060303, -0.7096147537231445, -0.5904524922370911, 0.3058567941188812, 0.5992202162742615, -0.04876057431101799, 0.7628589272499084, 0.9002968072891235, -0.3214397132396698, -0.14010843634605408, -0.3577320873737335, -0.025733506307005882, -0.3771200478076935, 0.18570910394191742, -0.40046262741088867, -0.4341517388820648, 0.40998050570487976, 0.15449899435043335, 0.0953940600156784, 0.19365616142749786, 0.6703788638114929, -0.36251193284988403, 0.898923397064209, 0.833238422870636, -0.49841293692588806, 0.5553593635559082, -0.47452735900878906, 0.17753417789936066, -0.5499235391616821, 0.2178119719028473, -0.5196777582168579, -0.4011212885379791, -0.658965528011322, -0.43533164262771606, 0.22889137268066406, -0.028570059686899185, 0.10800188779830933, 0.41594362258911133, -0.0628921389579773, 0.30182167887687683, 0.418160617351532, 0.13880227506160736, 0.2545987069606781, -0.05308099091053009, 0.02950977347791195, -0.1409277617931366, -0.6264715790748596, -0.7461395263671875, 1.3087512254714966, 0.25875452160835266, 0.9142757058143616, 0.0641537755727768, 0.9510083794593811, 0.16915306448936462, 0.11542415618896484, -1.144782304763794, 0.4061937630176544, -0.2346992939710617, -0.6599069237709045, -0.12386079877614975, 0.06524002552032471, -0.7303085923194885, 0.3393374979496002, -0.5692287087440491, -0.5486809611320496, 0.45009031891822815, 0.223231241106987, -0.4799579381942749, 0.4577275216579437, -0.3246546983718872, 0.9619731307029724, -0.3749493360519409, -0.5616200566291809, -0.28599265217781067, -0.5649250149726868, 0.27729299664497375, 0.24617545306682587, 0.054292239248752594, -0.08366929739713669, 0.07520856708288193, 0.5818138122558594, 0.016818849369883537, 1.1356303691864014, -0.2602466344833374, -0.1054934486746788, 0.3105809986591339, -0.03385980427265167, 0.36468830704689026, 0.22673030197620392, -0.3521502614021301, 0.2293371707201004, -0.10139124095439911, -0.3992137014865875, -0.3900146484375, 0.4177473485469818, -0.7991780042648315, -0.9529934525489807, -0.5545518398284912, -0.29634639620780945, -0.41773363947868347, 0.3294079601764679, 0.5395002365112305, 0.3434614837169647, -0.49713248014450073, 0.26799169182777405, 0.40190351009368896, 0.10911113023757935, 0.25507327914237976, 0.5227267742156982, -0.17981873452663422, -0.06477072834968567, 0.40128007531166077, -0.13119982182979584, 0.17724686861038208, 0.42992866039276123, 0.30994173884391785, -0.23065981268882751, -1.0719956159591675, -0.3176092803478241, 0.07666060328483582, -0.7115945219993591, -0.008039583452045918, -0.5470569729804993, 0.24091829359531403, -0.32738345861434937, -0.14148251712322235, -0.5857843160629272, -0.33477526903152466, -0.217412531375885, -0.28748103976249695, 0.12313422560691833, 0.47246119379997253, -0.07286661118268967, 0.40810805559158325, -0.4611736536026001, 0.684161365032196, 0.09070044755935669, 0.06284310668706894, -0.5541367530822754, -0.5061516165733337, 0.0168117918074131, 0.15130163729190826, -0.33981218934059143, -0.96968674659729, 0.1365690678358078, -0.10442451387643814, 0.7675373554229736, 0.6742138266563416, 0.09872902929782867, 0.5063725113868713, -0.09404855966567993, 0.7461096048355103, 0.13398043811321259, -0.7975994944572449, 0.7708179354667664, -0.5570951700210571, 0.0319073311984539, 0.8448668718338013, 0.8452434539794922, 0.12727496027946472, -0.39974379539489746, -0.525423526763916, -0.4025702476501465, 0.9300928711891174, 0.13380153477191925, 0.1030830666422844, 0.18885941803455353, 0.054076626896858215, 0.3593645393848419, 0.12871116399765015, -0.8784593343734741, 0.0595039427280426, -0.23839806020259857, 0.07168828696012497, 0.21671037375926971, -0.06518485397100449, -0.48288416862487793, -0.1184806302189827, 0.6341717839241028, -0.2777409851551056, 0.07724805176258087, -0.0853794738650322, -0.29831913113594055, 0.04333439841866493, 0.5170659422874451, 0.3480340242385864, 0.6233572959899902, -0.15471549332141876, -0.06261023133993149, 0.21964401006698608, -0.16630886495113373, -0.05735504999756813, -0.14910511672496796, -0.3935890793800354, 0.24268518388271332, 0.41010746359825134, 1.106868028640747, 0.31446847319602966, -0.0985272228717804, 0.6399086713790894, 0.044270746409893036, -0.013154295273125172, 0.01297689974308014, -0.010703936219215393, -0.08798420429229736, 0.2869565784931183, -0.24062520265579224, 0.44061970710754395, 0.2026776522397995, -0.7576195597648621, 0.1913902908563614, 0.8602250814437866, -0.16603624820709229, -0.4678400456905365, 0.43191733956336975, -0.041110552847385406, -0.04559299722313881, 0.14450885355472565, -0.1639196276664734, -0.43819817900657654, 0.530371367931366, 0.2753731608390808, 0.7791409492492676, 0.37017926573753357, 0.3423815369606018, 0.2713533937931061, 0.1148117333650589, -0.10198179632425308, 0.21424248814582825, -0.06278859078884125, -1.0781468152999878, -0.011232857592403889, -0.33053842186927795, -0.624043345451355, 0.15506692230701447, -0.9732103943824768, 0.8711546063423157, -0.5227178335189819, -0.7411143183708191, 0.25289255380630493, -0.09625544399023056, -0.7732763290405273, 0.06169908121228218, 0.3886609971523285, 0.7546104192733765, -1.0224597454071045, 0.8696664571762085, 1.090765118598938, -0.3748067021369934, -0.58812415599823, 0.5940729975700378, 0.6151720881462097, -0.5479815006256104, 0.2736916244029999, -0.08366736024618149, -0.4463118612766266, -0.5847368240356445, -0.47985273599624634, -0.5872328877449036, 0.8006061911582947, 0.3322230279445648, -0.36024904251098633, -0.02541867457330227, 0.06431692838668823, 0.4514547884464264, -0.48412925004959106, 0.12019821256399155, 0.4367485046386719, 0.46166983246803284, 0.048801664263010025, -0.6560163497924805, -0.43428364396095276, 0.19220185279846191, -0.16182546317577362, -0.16309991478919983, -0.6637800335884094, 0.7820078730583191, -0.19193808734416962, -0.0805075466632843, -0.0012480777222663164, 0.5221764445304871, 0.48010697960853577, 0.5126404166221619, 0.5752631425857544, 0.6479218602180481, 0.3972785174846649, 0.11757328361272812, 1.1696276664733887, -0.2564876973628998, 0.347584068775177, 1.0395240783691406, -0.41597840189933777, 0.98058021068573, 0.5479081869125366, -0.29711759090423584, 0.47879400849342346, 0.52155601978302, 0.028771178796887398, 0.5365117788314819, -0.4835922122001648, 0.0638190507888794, -0.5974127650260925, 0.11749351024627686, -0.08013258874416351, 0.867485761642456, 0.2436017245054245, -0.1366899162530899, -0.44626080989837646, -0.0005484166904352605, 0.05523836240172386, 0.0695626437664032, -0.07640888541936874, 0.7129569053649902, 0.06393948197364807, -0.6906030774116516, 0.31993284821510315, 0.14703699946403503, 0.8904055953025818, -0.688750684261322, 0.3816239833831787, -0.14518524706363678, 0.11709677428007126, -0.35952749848365784, -0.9311009049415588, 0.41746068000793457, 0.24770107865333557, -0.29701662063598633, -0.1329745650291443, 1.0406906604766846, -0.1788032203912735, -0.5444204211235046, 0.20076769590377808, 0.7760329246520996, -0.017555736005306244, 0.28643807768821716, -0.7931395769119263, 0.28686007857322693, -0.09449472278356552, -0.3201559782028198, 0.5418941378593445, 0.32313185930252075, -0.2755158543586731, 0.3469291627407074, 0.5682836771011353, 0.047395411878824234, 0.024578891694545746, 0.21215662360191345, 0.8059269785881042, -0.282540500164032, -0.6341127157211304, -0.8617307543754578, 0.5124361515045166, 0.04353189840912819, -0.3741397559642792, 0.8944740295410156, 0.45228683948516846, 0.8715032339096069, -0.07231903076171875, 0.7604519724845886, 0.04798681661486626, 0.24519574642181396, -0.6503564119338989, 0.47692233324050903, -0.5217809677124023, 0.3847908675670624, -0.28695225715637207, -0.5821186304092407, -0.3432285189628601, 0.74826979637146, -0.6873186826705933, -0.012941085733473301, 0.32563143968582153, 0.8119499683380127, -0.45860692858695984, 0.03360750153660774, 0.20045673847198486, -0.09778926521539688, 0.0765228420495987, 0.2574969232082367, 0.900429368019104, -0.2453167587518692, 0.3580678105354309, -0.29305607080459595, 0.2069319635629654, -0.17960508167743683, -1.102375864982605, -1.190483808517456, -0.33715564012527466, -0.5533726215362549, -0.2250782698392868, 0.026657069101929665, 0.8430687189102173, 1.129909873008728, -0.998022735118866, 0.005294706206768751, -0.01012487057596445, 0.30094221234321594, -0.14547038078308105, -0.1196204125881195, 0.14698125422000885, -0.20133017003536224, -0.7888242602348328, 0.48167383670806885, 0.20149657130241394, 0.014632370322942734, -0.09872715920209885, -0.08013732731342316, -0.47138991951942444, 0.16547659039497375, 0.4140399396419525, 0.43912965059280396, -1.0074260234832764, -0.3623354732990265, -0.018517980352044106, -0.10279242694377899, 0.39494919776916504, 0.9071514010429382, -0.6207979321479797, 0.3129623234272003, 0.7166241407394409, 0.5868632793426514, 0.6626954078674316, 0.4234883189201355, 0.4955417513847351, -1.0319052934646606, 0.5411531329154968, 0.19064517319202423, 0.607169508934021, 0.41086024045944214, -0.1729913204908371, 0.273602694272995, 0.19058752059936523, 0.08089685440063477, -0.8056609630584717, 0.40263837575912476, -1.1952491998672485, -0.13512155413627625, 1.259291410446167, -0.3091520071029663, -0.0937538892030716, -0.08334469050168991, -0.15264973044395447, 0.1792559027671814, -0.24976740777492523, 0.3643534779548645, 0.9121266007423401, -0.47767174243927, -0.16178040206432343, -0.2638811767101288, 0.22123774886131287, 0.5088150501251221, -0.4938528835773468, -0.25589457154273987, 0.49231478571891785, 0.46790456771850586, 0.16742868721485138, 0.4945334494113922, -0.02102854661643505, 0.2395034283399582, 0.010909250006079674, -0.4844740927219391, 0.18886417150497437, -0.4197697639465332, -0.6346597075462341, 0.06361013650894165, 0.185424342751503, -0.39049673080444336 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03977v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03977v1
SEME at SemEval-2024 Task 2: Comparing Masked and Generative Language Models on Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trials
2024-04-05T09:18:50
2024-04-05T09:18:50
Mathilde Aguiar, Pierre Zweigenbaum, Nona Naderi
cs.CL
cs.CL
This paper describes our submission to Task 2 of SemEval-2024: Safe Biomedical Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trials. The Multi-evidence Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trial Data (NLI4CT) consists of a Textual Entailment (TE) task focused on the evaluation of the consistency and faithfulness of Natural Language Inference (NLI) models applied to Clinical Trial Reports (CTR). We test 2 distinct approaches, one based on finetuning and ensembling Masked Language Models and the other based on prompting Large Language Models using templates, in particular, using Chain-Of-Thought and Contrastive Chain-Of-Thought. Prompting Flan-T5-large in a 2-shot setting leads to our best system that achieves 0.57 F1 score, 0.64 Faithfulness, and 0.56 Consistency.
[ 0.04318349435925484, -0.8434876203536987, 0.6559967994689941, 0.5369082689285278, -0.2409062385559082, -0.20398052036762238, -0.12490589171648026, -0.5607969164848328, 0.1497153490781784, 0.8170764446258545, -0.33178263902664185, -0.5351672768592834, -0.5651711821556091, 0.39195501804351807, -0.28682824969291687, 0.8385498523712158, -0.2054053097963333, 0.3102056384086609, -0.27090200781822205, -0.19035524129867554, -0.6790851354598999, -0.3947756588459015, -0.8158961534500122, -0.35402289032936096, 0.4855973720550537, 0.11810853332281113, 0.3896450102329254, 0.38921216130256653, 0.5709999203681946, 0.20940987765789032, 0.1254616230726242, 0.011177321895956993, -0.25086042284965515, 0.3663267195224762, -0.23439866304397583, -0.41887396574020386, -0.5484947562217712, 0.16311213374137878, 0.1238756999373436, 0.6725519895553589, -0.2052232176065445, -0.3007575273513794, 0.11364763230085373, 0.3136900067329407, -0.6655102372169495, -0.09140271693468094, -0.6116947531700134, 0.020727649331092834, -0.01942584104835987, -0.10372964292764664, -0.6822008490562439, -0.49506473541259766, 0.225502148270607, -0.6284297704696655, 0.34565404057502747, 0.11637125164270401, 0.7672533392906189, 0.198300302028656, -0.7439606189727783, -0.47347772121429443, -0.34802135825157166, 0.7968907952308655, -1.0491604804992676, 0.3284246623516083, 0.8348821997642517, 0.1203087791800499, -0.0497402660548687, -0.9191630482673645, -0.42838191986083984, -0.30222466588020325, 0.0018623218638822436, 0.4492477476596832, -0.11586427688598633, 0.291822224855423, 0.21835771203041077, 0.12126211076974869, -0.6519176363945007, 0.08826342225074768, -0.3152688145637512, -0.34094101190567017, 0.57634037733078, -0.007287196349352598, 0.17494750022888184, 0.050528235733509064, -0.4736953675746918, 0.05449410900473595, -0.8651525974273682, -0.40588584542274475, 0.0737270936369896, 0.15895777940750122, -0.11174461245536804, 0.6303766369819641, -0.40032950043678284, 0.46816378831863403, -0.07953495532274246, 0.2808320224285126, 0.3536127209663391, -0.7016779184341431, -0.5126270055770874, 0.1532948762178421, 0.8931460976600647, 0.7719864845275879, 0.13127738237380981, -0.30026841163635254, -0.04599635675549507, 0.25266894698143005, 0.40946638584136963, -0.7178952097892761, -0.06380695849657059, 0.4442490041255951, -0.5160824656486511, -0.46345552802085876, -0.03504447638988495, -0.882590651512146, -0.4011228084564209, -0.2132292538881302, 1.0027626752853394, -0.4182598292827606, -0.03347032889723778, 0.3382805287837982, -0.3502727150917053, 0.1390019953250885, 0.4720528721809387, -0.6856348514556885, 0.49253690242767334, 0.7214838862419128, 0.5778743028640747, -0.1619739681482315, -0.12117288261651993, -0.7321314215660095, 0.1406271755695343, -0.39294227957725525, 0.8000298738479614, -0.38668328523635864, -0.204202339053154, 0.1310003399848938, 0.218197762966156, -0.3827555179595947, -0.53913414478302, 1.0031877756118774, -0.2456807792186737, 0.6180548071861267, -0.46375617384910583, -0.8791645765304565, -0.13719964027404785, 0.2351468950510025, -0.4635453224182129, 0.914824903011322, -0.14868620038032532, -0.6554169654846191, 0.4530129134654999, -0.6724534630775452, -0.6211209893226624, 0.10413943976163864, -0.14362861216068268, -0.4814005196094513, 0.12125317752361298, 0.12752634286880493, 0.3153474032878876, -0.24044381082057953, 0.5039885640144348, -0.42691367864608765, -0.18482622504234314, 0.1946738362312317, -0.46551501750946045, 0.7027565240859985, 0.26774099469184875, -0.8170461058616638, -0.046323880553245544, -0.4624515473842621, 0.028634289279580116, 0.11473138630390167, -0.07837225496768951, -0.33228039741516113, -0.1830407679080963, 0.06376539915800095, 0.12219241261482239, -0.03508030250668526, -0.805592954158783, -0.1373039036989212, -0.5960310697555542, 0.5160241723060608, 0.42933881282806396, 0.17004451155662537, 0.15420149266719818, -0.29189106822013855, 0.3351030945777893, -0.13136275112628937, 0.08756159245967865, -0.10008200258016586, -0.7149470448493958, -0.8016583919525146, -0.022243237122893333, 0.6283206343650818, 0.4194166660308838, -0.7504178285598755, 0.3298438787460327, 0.0012178871547803283, -0.10097654908895493, -0.3209531307220459, -0.4504188001155853, 0.5960519313812256, 0.4274439513683319, 0.3732408881187439, -0.25214266777038574, -0.7156155705451965, -1.18660569190979, -0.26507627964019775, -0.008924187161028385, -0.25193265080451965, -0.0066691008396446705, 0.905266284942627, -0.2755385935306549, 0.49536678194999695, -0.13936056196689606, -0.21418029069900513, -0.18915092945098877, 0.4978218972682953, -0.018664300441741943, 0.6918515563011169, 0.43445876240730286, -0.4845658838748932, -0.2516920268535614, -0.14987866580486298, -0.8823109269142151, -0.44651877880096436, -0.18226175010204315, -0.20294451713562012, 0.13224495947360992, 0.6462046504020691, -0.3819526433944702, 0.8258622884750366, 0.387932687997818, -0.528752863407135, 0.21206505596637726, -0.3094594478607178, 0.594074547290802, -1.0221506357192993, 0.012765576131641865, -0.10808345675468445, -0.3950097858905792, -1.0429632663726807, 0.031140360981225967, 0.15174216032028198, 0.30507901310920715, -0.22836974263191223, 0.4915885329246521, -0.27613207697868347, 0.17094440758228302, -0.2587427496910095, -0.18782925605773926, 0.3651013970375061, 0.23227745294570923, 0.07812248915433884, 0.6343949437141418, 0.33420366048812866, -0.43624112010002136, -0.2064805030822754, 0.4220273494720459, -0.24225296080112457, 0.3837296664714813, -1.0415079593658447, 0.32570400834083557, 0.05672578513622284, 0.15228283405303955, -0.7356911301612854, -0.433197557926178, 0.009484955109655857, -0.3534523844718933, 0.1974373608827591, 0.19847118854522705, -0.4326879680156708, -0.27333271503448486, -0.3751992881298065, 0.36101311445236206, 0.4377821087837219, -0.1531953364610672, 0.3061573803424835, 0.3691633343696594, -0.1367439329624176, -0.2687663435935974, -0.9502480626106262, 0.3620010018348694, -0.07470780611038208, -0.37447163462638855, 0.48704516887664795, -0.036546528339385986, -0.27727293968200684, -0.1780942976474762, -0.12314771860837936, -0.2774318754673004, -0.027918381616473198, 0.19115684926509857, 0.11239709705114365, -0.3526391088962555, -0.12475466728210449, 0.15040503442287445, -0.005438840948045254, 0.16924408078193665, 0.036336567252874374, 0.2711232304573059, -0.059438031166791916, -0.601184606552124, -0.4527534246444702, 0.741993248462677, 0.3422836363315582, -0.10804655402898788, 0.6516259908676147, 0.2760094106197357, -0.8197542428970337, 0.1902356743812561, -0.808988630771637, -0.2733985483646393, -0.3889809846878052, 0.03665520250797272, -0.20785224437713623, -1.0794845819473267, 0.269922137260437, 0.22791177034378052, 0.074590764939785, 0.5503383874893188, 0.7837560772895813, -0.10925164818763733, 1.1336560249328613, 0.21762223541736603, 0.5079953074455261, -0.036075327545404434, -0.0050890278071165085, 0.3138601779937744, -0.7913251519203186, -0.30238962173461914, -0.5978040099143982, 0.0706319585442543, -0.23761498928070068, -0.5323536992073059, 0.5105236172676086, 0.07729968428611755, -0.270599901676178, 0.30138808488845825, -0.3543195128440857, 0.29069438576698303, 0.5900105834007263, 0.31174105405807495, 0.15882527828216553, 0.01996813714504242, -0.2961578667163849, -0.1722220629453659, -0.5330924987792969, -0.497495174407959, 1.1624467372894287, 0.4542960226535797, 0.3502880930900574, 0.14690276980400085, 0.5933256149291992, 0.2696622312068939, 0.21919529139995575, -0.40559524297714233, 0.41553887724876404, -0.10737840086221695, -0.776301920413971, -0.08291806280612946, -0.03870578855276108, -0.9495779871940613, 0.2923547625541687, -0.23570138216018677, -0.683475911617279, 0.18540231883525848, -0.04121098294854164, -0.43239066004753113, -0.1415843516588211, -0.7204968929290771, 0.9732117652893066, -0.06083096191287041, -0.4605792164802551, -0.029100600630044937, -0.8569905161857605, 0.46041104197502136, -0.07435239106416702, 0.05869728699326515, -0.1556684821844101, 0.0031571316067129374, 0.7790594696998596, -0.4165806472301483, 0.7814621925354004, -0.0015000526327639818, 0.12347079813480377, 0.3291418254375458, -0.011689902283251286, 0.5079005360603333, 0.09506919980049133, -0.3519238531589508, 0.16279056668281555, 0.21211712062358856, -0.29859060049057007, -0.4694400131702423, 0.36416706442832947, -0.34918683767318726, -0.4085061848163605, -0.5877840518951416, -0.2103339284658432, -0.22464849054813385, 0.27495259046554565, 0.5552676320075989, 0.8375582695007324, -0.3421729505062103, 0.44816604256629944, 0.7213513851165771, -0.39917704463005066, 0.1600014567375183, 0.435940146446228, 0.15115314722061157, -0.5327053666114807, 0.44977572560310364, -0.300597220659256, 0.5426474809646606, 0.4163529574871063, 0.24419987201690674, -0.5584193468093872, -0.8159310817718506, -0.1321697235107422, 0.23192332684993744, -0.5852136015892029, -0.2689286172389984, -0.9416078925132751, -0.3219158947467804, -0.8046977519989014, -0.08345948159694672, -0.3442631959915161, -0.27427566051483154, -0.03304284065961838, -0.06444559246301651, 0.037715692073106766, 0.7510908842086792, 0.03897358477115631, 0.046731602400541306, -0.5601664781570435, 0.33147740364074707, 0.13014854490756989, 0.10741770267486572, -0.5962750315666199, -0.564684271812439, 0.1056237667798996, 0.17633773386478424, -0.18564055860042572, -0.8897408246994019, 0.19773295521736145, 0.3873952627182007, 0.5627757906913757, 0.34738653898239136, 0.1046745702624321, 0.6499709486961365, -0.6444390416145325, 0.7717168927192688, 0.37873321771621704, -0.8896592259407043, 0.8458735346794128, -0.5047204494476318, 0.3440507650375366, 0.9976046085357666, 0.07019002735614777, -0.49036967754364014, -0.7570368647575378, -0.5927847623825073, -0.5929644107818604, 0.4381674528121948, 0.8725367784500122, -0.145595982670784, -0.2398017793893814, 0.16126033663749695, 0.2980425953865051, 0.23820683360099792, -0.5610775351524353, 0.043668873608112335, -0.07892066985368729, -0.43053847551345825, 0.16614797711372375, -0.5608227252960205, -0.36774393916130066, -0.08632445335388184, 0.5416384935379028, -0.2953481674194336, 0.6262224316596985, 0.5508530139923096, 0.07023826986551285, 0.03189658746123314, 0.48884695768356323, 0.9112213253974915, 0.6494899988174438, -0.2503732442855835, 0.5267722010612488, 0.5336334109306335, -0.6041061282157898, -0.07206591963768005, -0.00896350760012865, -0.22152216732501984, 0.048052143305540085, 0.7666356563568115, 0.8630393743515015, 0.3277268707752228, -0.6375782489776611, 0.796288013458252, -0.2923002243041992, -0.7922433018684387, -0.22840674221515656, -0.0725148469209671, -0.07549960911273956, -0.04998074844479561, -0.07347523421049118, 0.13525870442390442, 0.5063581466674805, -0.39146143198013306, 0.32341891527175903, 0.32496222853660583, -0.617646336555481, -0.38034364581108093, 1.0860055685043335, 0.1253831833600998, -0.06330092996358871, 0.323108971118927, -0.2588423788547516, -0.5426850318908691, 0.7285657525062561, 0.6441841721534729, 0.9542199969291687, -0.11500230431556702, 0.18276505172252655, 0.589103639125824, 0.3800753951072693, -0.3076469600200653, 0.4570964276790619, 0.42659154534339905, -0.6501256227493286, -0.38831764459609985, -0.48058512806892395, -0.2886092960834503, 0.3533586859703064, -0.7652680277824402, 0.17148257791996002, -0.0826806128025055, -0.011459657922387123, 0.3012878894805908, -0.21442551910877228, -0.5048272609710693, 0.23818442225456238, 0.08976026624441147, 1.0101830959320068, -0.8764604330062866, 0.7931219339370728, 0.5353118777275085, -0.11908218264579773, -0.7354431748390198, -0.1812792420387268, 0.2944237291812897, -0.46272480487823486, 0.3573915958404541, 0.38187503814697266, 0.011717604473233223, -0.17995496094226837, -0.5721800923347473, -0.5769979953765869, 1.017302393913269, 0.17866303026676178, -0.35501420497894287, 0.16160771250724792, 0.19797830283641815, 0.5319094657897949, -0.4221533536911011, 0.3904704749584198, 0.6530550718307495, 0.3891328275203705, 0.281915545463562, -1.0430294275283813, 0.18182949721813202, -0.2987153232097626, -0.12031693011522293, -0.015441009774804115, -0.1984827220439911, 0.5343958735466003, -0.10082022845745087, -0.18081167340278625, 0.37597766518592834, 0.6032438278198242, 0.4078354239463806, 0.8168046474456787, 0.60721355676651, 0.6203343868255615, 0.6765458583831787, -0.2393903136253357, 0.9487947821617126, 0.004324353300035, 0.36282649636268616, 1.1533122062683105, -0.7924222350120544, 0.7959261536598206, 0.3799814283847809, -0.2543061673641205, 0.2759532034397125, 0.5372819900512695, 0.10021758079528809, 0.8084448575973511, -0.11882267892360687, -0.4095380902290344, -0.3010938763618469, -0.30753734707832336, -0.35079777240753174, 0.4116173982620239, 0.3195282220840454, -0.209453284740448, -0.1148904338479042, 0.10091817378997803, 0.15181779861450195, -0.016013795509934425, 0.2974076569080353, 0.8362677097320557, 0.19658254086971283, -1.146439790725708, 0.3752530515193939, 0.026728613302111626, 0.3134794533252716, -0.47733694314956665, -0.13750457763671875, -0.15526513755321503, 0.14774589240550995, 0.05615613982081413, -0.6721526384353638, 0.5499324798583984, 0.10669632256031036, 0.1674642413854599, -0.18624554574489594, 0.896003007888794, -0.5592982172966003, -0.5413438081741333, 0.09405513107776642, 0.2605772912502289, 0.13180485367774963, -0.04066871106624603, -0.7653104066848755, -0.07051298767328262, -0.03086703270673752, -0.1398567110300064, 0.09948821365833282, 0.33289581537246704, -0.15616342425346375, 0.3691522479057312, 0.4923955202102661, -0.06508719176054001, 0.042859695851802826, 0.5282297730445862, 0.4787316918373108, -0.5335333347320557, -0.4546746015548706, -0.7729820609092712, 0.360680490732193, -0.3601124584674835, -0.37433263659477234, 0.7202168703079224, 0.7992523312568665, 0.09648923575878143, 0.012964785099029541, 0.6179797053337097, -0.10938519239425659, 0.4784516990184784, -0.7973201870918274, 0.5338555574417114, -0.42162221670150757, -0.087708979845047, -0.04084058105945587, -0.39598193764686584, -0.46581554412841797, 0.5226649045944214, -0.16242709755897522, -0.06513107568025589, 1.2362232208251953, 0.8496277332305908, 0.026640813797712326, 0.5322052836418152, 0.2768212854862213, 0.240785613656044, 0.28676095604896545, 0.7309504747390747, 0.7983819246292114, -0.8405362963676453, -0.03904246911406517, -0.15965542197227478, -0.21947798132896423, -0.15214036405086517, -0.9706151485443115, -0.9876600503921509, -0.4710988700389862, -0.5435760021209717, -0.5674989223480225, 0.17546169459819794, 0.8852599263191223, 0.5821964144706726, -1.2723017930984497, 0.19436131417751312, -0.44262805581092834, -0.16221243143081665, -0.15478885173797607, -0.16172802448272705, 0.301908403635025, -0.23851101100444794, -0.6641198992729187, 0.5253319144248962, 0.5292430520057678, 0.006383461877703667, 0.19772250950336456, -0.09139754623174667, -0.41289713978767395, 0.07990036904811859, 0.5602365136146545, -0.10109592974185944, -0.9584636688232422, -0.44352108240127563, 0.144301176071167, -0.38384494185447693, -0.09330342710018158, 0.772688627243042, -0.46831265091896057, 0.5861968398094177, 0.49319401383399963, 0.6099258065223694, 0.45035043358802795, -0.14241726696491241, 0.8068844676017761, -0.45157524943351746, 0.07836917042732239, 0.3668379485607147, 0.3349207639694214, 0.0959109216928482, -0.21815526485443115, 0.9108012914657593, 0.1480340212583542, -0.7433926463127136, -0.7793015241622925, 0.07284756004810333, -1.1148877143859863, -0.17693735659122467, 1.2171305418014526, -0.0874374657869339, -0.15160293877124786, -0.5047431588172913, -0.1727859377861023, 0.2582772970199585, 0.012035724706947803, 0.3928481936454773, 0.5816522836685181, -0.004044067580252886, -0.06365566700696945, -1.1663081645965576, 0.6227316856384277, 0.6415108442306519, -1.0163137912750244, -0.2535701096057892, 0.3188781440258026, 0.16827088594436646, -0.17350991070270538, 0.9097381234169006, -0.16862080991268158, 0.3303891122341156, 0.08945055305957794, -0.0637858659029007, 0.25755029916763306, -0.07843995094299316, -0.4085676372051239, -0.0777161493897438, -0.3226238191127777, -0.179185152053833 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03969v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03969v1
Transformers for molecular property prediction: Lessons learned from the past five years
2024-04-05T09:05:37
2024-04-05T09:05:37
Afnan Sultan, Jochen Sieg, Miriam Mathea, Andrea Volkamer
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.CL, q-bio.QM
Molecular Property Prediction (MPP) is vital for drug discovery, crop protection, and environmental science. Over the last decades, diverse computational techniques have been developed, from using simple physical and chemical properties and molecular fingerprints in statistical models and classical machine learning to advanced deep learning approaches. In this review, we aim to distill insights from current research on employing transformer models for MPP. We analyze the currently available models and explore key questions that arise when training and fine-tuning a transformer model for MPP. These questions encompass the choice and scale of the pre-training data, optimal architecture selections, and promising pre-training objectives. Our analysis highlights areas not yet covered in current research, inviting further exploration to enhance the field's understanding. Additionally, we address the challenges in comparing different models, emphasizing the need for standardized data splitting and robust statistical analysis.
[ -0.7300313711166382, -0.1939624547958374, 0.6802063584327698, -0.3134346008300781, 0.21611180901527405, 0.11871947348117828, -0.058777954429388046, -0.5407740473747253, -0.13480636477470398, 0.6270318031311035, -0.2812371253967285, 0.1619013100862503, -1.1078896522521973, -0.017786424607038498, -0.2931073307991028, 0.9854909181594849, 0.061674565076828, 0.1277093142271042, -0.10493461042642593, 0.036444004625082016, 0.028824692592024803, -0.5559328198432922, 0.009064734913408756, -0.46055537462234497, 0.5043971538543701, 0.40221887826919556, 0.8259901404380798, 0.7062897682189941, 1.1867238283157349, 0.3122466504573822, -0.2381240576505661, -0.27622947096824646, -0.20822300016880035, -0.04665263369679451, -0.339753121137619, -0.4380888342857361, -0.35062140226364136, 0.4532777965068817, 0.36148276925086975, 1.0665620565414429, 0.10782959312200546, 0.11631161719560623, -0.1055879294872284, 0.7539814114570618, -0.8670527935028076, -0.0364653579890728, -0.8931908011436462, 0.5557037591934204, -0.1455443799495697, -0.24970465898513794, -0.35165077447891235, 0.1535552591085434, 0.5553660988807678, -0.2621288299560547, 0.8135972023010254, -0.16849608719348907, 1.0641748905181885, 0.3854747712612152, -0.8253586888313293, -0.012052611447870731, -1.1790629625320435, 0.8482992649078369, -0.4210626780986786, 0.5921573638916016, 0.14478863775730133, 1.021756887435913, -0.2938673794269562, -0.9960680603981018, -0.41239070892333984, -0.7320942282676697, -0.07540502399206161, 0.07779106497764587, 0.0550028532743454, 0.23912076652050018, 0.16995370388031006, 0.7384483814239502, -0.23060227930545807, -0.05546664819121361, -0.663630485534668, -0.07815582305192947, 0.350946843624115, 0.06866038590669632, -0.14491239190101624, -0.13801012933254242, -0.7327155470848083, -0.45086705684661865, -0.4520178437232971, 0.3272205889225006, 0.23885853588581085, 0.34787222743034363, 0.20567195117473602, 0.7752697467803955, -0.009205849841237068, 0.41410258412361145, 0.13598422706127167, 0.03750629350543022, -0.07675554603338242, -0.4020828306674957, -0.3133476674556732, -0.1759633719921112, 0.5428234934806824, 0.27218011021614075, 0.33181092143058777, -0.10938017070293427, -0.09040887653827667, 0.10314445197582245, 0.45052647590637207, -1.0787819623947144, -0.7158277630805969, 0.32800018787384033, -0.569094717502594, -0.6055029034614563, 0.5308362245559692, -1.225387454032898, -0.6319308876991272, -0.3167721629142761, 0.174402117729187, -0.16758935153484344, -0.17862176895141602, -0.019815746694803238, -0.584770143032074, 0.07281503826379776, -0.10124616324901581, -1.394569754600525, 0.4581597149372101, 0.6439293026924133, 0.66060471534729, -0.3996822237968445, -0.4794585406780243, -0.10781848430633545, -0.04148905351758003, -0.044085174798965454, 0.9423844218254089, -0.9071469902992249, -0.44877102971076965, -0.45297569036483765, 0.16102640330791473, -0.19451601803302765, -0.8410239815711975, 0.26376721262931824, -0.24373859167099, -0.27626553177833557, -0.10775838792324066, -0.4205392003059387, 0.0357322134077549, 0.06337287276983261, -0.82242751121521, 0.44070228934288025, 0.6062363982200623, -0.6369970440864563, 0.7399206161499023, -0.5819427371025085, -0.12090165168046951, -0.2607133686542511, 0.008843237534165382, -0.8355973362922668, 0.4186874032020569, 0.25420325994491577, 0.6010516285896301, -0.22976507246494293, 0.07273710519075394, -0.3840303122997284, -0.06133728101849556, 0.4473519027233124, -0.5700451731681824, 0.41330623626708984, 0.3658495843410492, -0.05874619632959366, 0.19344303011894226, -1.0381826162338257, -0.29411160945892334, -0.15459522604942322, -0.17391662299633026, 0.6971445083618164, 0.022401917725801468, 0.13258959352970123, 0.27364832162857056, -0.04555264487862587, -0.5176949501037598, 0.38183799386024475, -0.21483170986175537, 0.42853906750679016, 0.7634599208831787, 0.060333654284477234, 0.9071084856987, -0.13637152314186096, 0.7147971987724304, 0.3141084909439087, 0.4815514385700226, -0.14541155099868774, -0.4165385961532593, -0.5418702960014343, 0.05880892276763916, 0.5963287949562073, 0.5375410914421082, -0.14208976924419403, 0.12713058292865753, -0.14366821944713593, -0.9629271626472473, -0.10746157914400101, 0.005568936001509428, 0.004730145446956158, 0.3282739818096161, 0.6850084066390991, -0.3420921862125397, -0.509274959564209, -0.954887330532074, -0.5177406072616577, 0.11799203604459763, -0.045106079429388046, 0.2342020571231842, 0.655992329120636, -0.4021203815937042, 0.8501944541931152, -0.7626805305480957, -0.3223473131656647, -0.4047488868236542, -0.061320915818214417, 0.25126537680625916, 0.4280889332294464, 0.5693306922912598, -0.9663850665092468, -0.4778808653354645, 0.3698737621307373, -0.24963639676570892, 0.3526190519332886, 0.08057507127523422, 0.19912411272525787, -0.12256559729576111, 0.2871267795562744, -0.6628025770187378, 0.3398548364639282, 0.7460487484931946, -0.15506812930107117, 0.6251490712165833, -0.21395470201969147, 0.1892738789319992, -0.8068545460700989, 0.03545457869768143, 0.4075832962989807, -0.06293672323226929, -0.8773093223571777, -0.002381435129791498, -0.18558165431022644, -0.2852121591567993, -0.5124005079269409, 0.09969048947095871, -0.2387717068195343, -0.0839790478348732, -0.37814849615097046, -0.8988097906112671, -0.1448216736316681, 0.2915525436401367, -0.018295694142580032, 0.7845961451530457, 0.3837505578994751, -0.45705077052116394, 0.3840736746788025, -0.01593674346804619, -0.0209719967097044, 0.30377626419067383, -0.3601287007331848, -0.07572919130325317, 0.06772065162658691, 0.2216707170009613, -0.5421026349067688, -0.3182266354560852, 0.11846178770065308, -0.5489186644554138, 0.6367847323417664, -0.7169458270072937, 0.1134360134601593, -0.46668511629104614, -0.016873674467206, 0.06299206614494324, 0.4988168478012085, -0.39569228887557983, 1.0158218145370483, 0.2896377146244049, 0.3123783469200134, -0.3811381161212921, -0.43453964591026306, -0.2216769903898239, -0.4375274181365967, -0.3499688506126404, 0.358003705739975, 0.1702287644147873, 0.029327236115932465, -0.32550469040870667, -0.2823074460029602, -0.4589398503303528, 0.1556023210287094, 0.5286473631858826, -0.018739208579063416, -0.036897096782922745, -0.09599369764328003, -0.3673880994319916, -0.8275571465492249, 0.20569828152656555, -0.4738903343677521, 0.4055829644203186, -0.18403376638889313, 0.12399959564208984, -0.09249381721019745, 0.1924373358488083, 0.6319120526313782, -0.41638612747192383, 0.9056735634803772, 0.6479285359382629, 0.004553068429231644, -0.16198214888572693, -0.031145602464675903, -0.556542694568634, -0.5507916212081909, 0.43172013759613037, -0.347513347864151, -0.5434009432792664, 0.08157838881015778, -0.6906565427780151, -0.421646386384964, 0.5370191335678101, 0.5462309122085571, -0.532852828502655, 0.7845179438591003, 1.14310622215271, 0.24010367691516876, 0.4119456112384796, -0.5305780172348022, 0.5463038682937622, -0.4636582136154175, -0.33105430006980896, -0.44045162200927734, -0.5130369067192078, -0.9664021730422974, -0.4862414598464966, 0.4878665804862976, -0.0005143567104823887, -0.3740517795085907, 0.5516133904457092, -0.6676048040390015, 0.44855833053588867, 0.7373082041740417, 0.06724462658166885, -0.020763585343956947, 0.08083754777908325, 0.17899392545223236, -0.012008360587060452, -0.3434145450592041, -0.5029124021530151, 1.4280164241790771, 0.517705500125885, 0.26181137561798096, -0.46704792976379395, 0.22867411375045776, 0.06442698836326599, 0.0908060073852539, -0.7029226422309875, 0.33901017904281616, -0.21612876653671265, -0.7083277106285095, -0.2769399583339691, -0.3541509211063385, -1.0020524263381958, 0.11149458587169647, -0.4089554250240326, -0.5821889042854309, 0.7007770538330078, 0.6869471669197083, -0.2492661327123642, 0.6963382959365845, -0.607735276222229, 0.9979236721992493, -0.18336603045463562, 0.02057347446680069, 0.1330343335866928, -1.0426920652389526, 0.13221262395381927, -0.14553064107894897, -0.31601575016975403, -0.19431380927562714, 0.29492515325546265, 0.3072430193424225, -0.4356192350387573, 0.2541610896587372, -0.213922917842865, 0.07123621553182602, 0.13872647285461426, -0.0596504807472229, 0.28937163949012756, -0.30753186345100403, -0.02673257701098919, 0.12367439270019531, 0.336670458316803, -0.3474886119365692, -0.6049507260322571, 0.36089852452278137, -0.668175458908081, -0.36915430426597595, -0.4999585747718811, -0.3945334553718567, -0.3153288960456848, 0.04112515226006508, 0.5711636543273926, -0.17183825373649597, 0.12907205522060394, 0.26877832412719727, 0.5246241688728333, 0.01846260391175747, 0.3521777391433716, 0.22810602188110352, -0.10900887101888657, -0.2888459861278534, 1.2719532251358032, 0.43500784039497375, 0.3900183141231537, 0.6299391984939575, 0.49720969796180725, 0.20871502161026, -0.8994558453559875, 0.054906003177165985, -0.30002450942993164, -0.5169402360916138, -0.10229772329330444, -0.7246067523956299, -0.34035471081733704, -0.31321218609809875, -0.07722146809101105, -0.8436903953552246, -0.5462420582771301, -0.1252419501543045, -0.4153721034526825, 0.29090455174446106, 0.7277039885520935, -0.16339020431041718, 0.43613043427467346, -0.8098230361938477, 0.5968074798583984, 0.36969953775405884, 0.48337024450302124, -0.31297415494918823, -0.16499309241771698, -0.2958298623561859, 0.2007991522550583, -0.780612051486969, -0.8665241599082947, 0.4129537045955658, 0.1720084398984909, 0.2437838912010193, 0.38725292682647705, -0.22683335840702057, -0.07277601212263107, -0.587073802947998, 0.7695892453193665, -0.11268960684537888, -0.5540326833724976, 0.7556113004684448, -0.34634819626808167, -0.07722511887550354, 0.5485818386077881, 0.6126837730407715, -0.07490323483943939, 0.2009745091199875, -0.6280637383460999, -0.8118914365768433, 0.11132242530584335, 0.4472614824771881, -0.20170080661773682, 0.48764970898628235, 0.14325262606143951, 0.24560612440109253, 0.16159936785697937, -0.6763908267021179, -0.2910362780094147, -0.4973022937774658, -0.053965337574481964, -0.2619372606277466, -0.10601425915956497, 0.1618131548166275, -0.6754772067070007, 0.47361284494400024, -0.11377115547657013, 0.3350423574447632, -0.08727889508008957, 0.1251768171787262, 0.08936665207147598, 0.3325668275356293, 0.3996161222457886, 0.5441991686820984, -0.7251396775245667, 0.14280083775520325, 0.21073539555072784, -0.8279571533203125, 0.4743582606315613, 0.3293937146663666, 0.2931721806526184, -0.4733840227127075, 0.14979660511016846, 0.629660964012146, -0.5419811606407166, -0.4231376647949219, 0.44165393710136414, 0.23859411478042603, -0.2913132607936859, -0.2955920696258545, 0.20175053179264069, -0.23149646818637848, 0.3431330621242523, 0.20559675991535187, 0.754203736782074, 0.3276437819004059, -0.5169526934623718, 0.23850645124912262, 0.2482566237449646, -0.7039157152175903, -0.452961802482605, 0.6157236695289612, 0.08089137077331543, 0.04822112247347832, 0.5934048295021057, 0.25482288002967834, -0.5513898134231567, 0.865500271320343, 0.13694319128990173, 0.7395729422569275, -0.4650701880455017, 0.059218693524599075, 0.028902560472488403, 0.33833685517311096, 0.2077331393957138, -0.006434247829020023, -0.1851586252450943, -0.7791258096694946, 0.1673908829689026, -0.6152908205986023, -0.579409122467041, -0.05475993826985359, -0.3287956118583679, 0.12940405309200287, -0.6048466563224792, -0.3917330801486969, 0.48203685879707336, 0.2131369411945343, -0.810883104801178, 0.5124780535697937, 0.11170252412557602, 0.684924304485321, -1.0750032663345337, 0.8244686126708984, 0.4312888979911804, -0.31096774339675903, -0.6593621373176575, -0.2045832723379135, 0.08137224614620209, -0.19601942598819733, 0.5257855653762817, 0.21333862841129303, 0.05429686978459358, -0.17383188009262085, -0.5410757064819336, -0.8741055727005005, 1.069668173789978, 0.45750099420547485, -0.6392292976379395, 0.07399286329746246, 0.8492995500564575, 0.6044474840164185, -0.19391494989395142, 0.3847959041595459, 1.1857017278671265, 0.58420729637146, 0.11456812918186188, -0.6772260069847107, -0.44692158699035645, -0.17248360812664032, 0.04038982465863228, 0.45219168066978455, -0.3168599307537079, 0.8033172488212585, -0.19945749640464783, -0.015714572742581367, -0.0006791403284296393, 0.7570766806602478, 0.16365061700344086, 0.3494971692562103, 0.19623225927352905, 0.43483978509902954, 0.48549684882164, -0.4561851918697357, 1.3802578449249268, -0.40910735726356506, 0.34049251675605774, 0.8277997374534607, -0.23630958795547485, 0.9312688708305359, 0.7014400362968445, -0.6293085813522339, 0.23895308375358582, 0.5151529312133789, -0.7828330397605896, 0.4746588468551636, 0.3989750146865845, -0.10887601971626282, -0.007915442809462547, -0.11665736883878708, -0.3816815912723541, 0.5478096008300781, 0.2770005464553833, -0.818647027015686, 0.16237662732601166, 0.13006573915481567, -0.5168220400810242, 0.021378519013524055, -0.011213389225304127, 0.5079718828201294, 0.12401989102363586, -0.4429481029510498, -0.10217985510826111, -0.0655885860323906, 0.4639494717121124, -0.47256019711494446, -0.2824417054653168, -0.044625986367464066, 0.5494813323020935, -0.20737920701503754, -0.8432464003562927, 0.3325742483139038, -0.5249987840652466, -0.576475977897644, -0.39767396450042725, 0.8200212717056274, -0.08468815684318542, -0.7273315191268921, 0.24777740240097046, -0.10704208165407181, -0.0815209448337555, -0.36962395906448364, -0.44344016909599304, -0.32002413272857666, -0.27274221181869507, -0.27008968591690063, 0.23720026016235352, 0.14386135339736938, 0.39589953422546387, 0.8185471296310425, 0.7123329043388367, 0.037055470049381256, 0.1156332939863205, -0.3261010944843292, 0.8239815831184387, -0.8290665745735168, -0.037120360881090164, -0.5640897750854492, 0.6133071780204773, 0.03199993818998337, -0.23240865767002106, 0.6549047231674194, 0.5796974897384644, 0.8172375559806824, -0.37735483050346375, 0.6123629808425903, 0.484985888004303, 0.5052468776702881, -0.40136808156967163, 0.5890793800354004, 0.08114233613014221, 0.26394176483154297, -0.13279394805431366, -1.2954603433609009, -0.10316089540719986, 0.3685709834098816, -0.029349463060498238, 0.5144848227500916, 0.6847752332687378, 0.8899649977684021, -0.27812647819519043, 0.09376557171344757, 0.1082361713051796, 0.08840084820985794, 0.7254472970962524, 0.634063720703125, 0.8822236657142639, -0.5762490630149841, 0.23427137732505798, -0.8362475633621216, 0.1001783236861229, -0.062047261744737625, -0.9199674129486084, -0.7879234552383423, -0.5566340088844299, -0.08768690377473831, -0.35665130615234375, -0.10447866469621658, 0.8794568777084351, 0.970547080039978, -1.061758279800415, -0.24287191033363342, -0.6951496601104736, -0.1753859519958496, -0.2611551880836487, -0.1689709722995758, 0.25039413571357727, 0.08961616456508636, -0.43330004811286926, 0.40682822465896606, 0.3622295558452606, 0.693354070186615, -0.4342309236526489, 0.13022111356258392, 0.07445351779460907, -0.045939527451992035, 0.259537935256958, 0.4602642357349396, -0.4538748860359192, 0.050498612225055695, -0.09813175350427628, 0.14798706769943237, 0.4165653884410858, 1.1274917125701904, -0.9233872890472412, 0.3314250409603119, 0.5702751874923706, 0.5171772837638855, 0.5579873323440552, -0.01888982579112053, 1.0256532430648804, -0.41138702630996704, 0.07236015051603317, 0.482535183429718, 0.38043147325515747, 0.2592982351779938, -0.47497138381004333, 0.514189600944519, 0.07868686318397522, -0.7252046465873718, -0.6155691146850586, 0.23464688658714294, -0.9463738799095154, -0.35112419724464417, 0.7233176231384277, 0.13725219666957855, -0.19537976384162903, 0.14121152460575104, -0.0349089615046978, 0.038401998579502106, 0.0625900998711586, 0.5071389079093933, 0.4352855384349823, -0.08420589566230774, -0.5925427079200745, -0.5457488894462585, 0.798362672328949, 0.36971309781074524, -0.8643878102302551, -0.04515824466943741, 0.01862388662993908, -0.017658235505223274, 0.21004220843315125, -0.23923765122890472, 0.10103066265583038, 0.1437283754348755, 0.1291341632604599, -0.14506803452968597, -0.11857888847589493, -1.1291698217391968, -0.39499250054359436, 0.3918357491493225, -0.05042337626218796, 0.11538577079772949 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03938v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03938v1
Data Augmentation with In-Context Learning and Comparative Evaluation in Math Word Problem Solving
2024-04-05T07:57:03
2024-04-05T07:57:03
Gulsum Yigit, Mehmet Fatih Amasyali
cs.CL
cs.CL
Math Word Problem (MWP) solving presents a challenging task in Natural Language Processing (NLP). This study aims to provide MWP solvers with a more diverse training set, ultimately improving their ability to solve various math problems. We propose several methods for data augmentation by modifying the problem texts and equations, such as synonym replacement, rule-based: question replacement, and rule based: reversing question methodologies over two English MWP datasets. This study extends by introducing a new in-context learning augmentation method, employing the Llama-7b language model. This approach involves instruction-based prompting for rephrasing the math problem texts. Performance evaluations are conducted on 9 baseline models, revealing that augmentation methods outperform baseline models. Moreover, concatenating examples generated by various augmentation methods further improves performance.
[ -0.27575552463531494, -0.7929204702377319, 0.25459858775138855, 0.30502796173095703, -0.490709513425827, 0.25651851296424866, -0.16898073256015778, -0.5503872036933899, -0.012039528228342533, 0.29748567938804626, -0.6920016407966614, -0.2294207364320755, -0.6495025157928467, 0.43110451102256775, -0.1279938817024231, 0.6606985330581665, -0.27702853083610535, 0.3176811635494232, -0.7005472183227539, -0.24672460556030273, -1.0449844598770142, -0.6653673052787781, -0.427556574344635, -0.6780254244804382, 0.16937538981437683, 0.49449852108955383, 0.7002291679382324, 0.40872859954833984, 0.9205590486526489, 0.35242849588394165, -0.16714827716350555, 0.5140820145606995, -0.4355368912220001, 0.04243336617946625, -0.09742988646030426, -0.48104625940322876, -0.061153389513492584, -0.141499325633049, 0.4374392330646515, 1.2303882837295532, -0.2879527807235718, 0.049524903297424316, 0.1385045051574707, 0.7568009495735168, -0.5195409655570984, 0.3548460304737091, -0.8281782269477844, 0.15554268658161163, 0.09425374120473862, -0.40650853514671326, -0.09609031677246094, -0.3736400604248047, 0.311050683259964, -0.737780749797821, 0.02717236988246441, -0.1474030464887619, 0.38905391097068787, 0.275483101606369, -0.20839761197566986, -0.4740212559700012, -0.39217931032180786, 0.9086597561836243, -0.8586089611053467, 0.3202984035015106, 0.39880475401878357, 0.1318313181400299, -0.4570900797843933, -0.4408828914165497, -0.6463966965675354, -0.12036516517400742, -0.03729524090886116, 0.0569029301404953, -0.3550622761249542, -0.19950926303863525, 0.4449622929096222, 0.4442557692527771, -0.24197329580783844, 0.05893619731068611, -0.4526563882827759, -0.1103677973151207, 0.6039922833442688, 0.27712956070899963, 0.2421341836452484, -0.13489827513694763, -0.172454372048378, -0.20236653089523315, -0.7101408839225769, 0.06866666674613953, 0.1932162195444107, 0.23560208082199097, -0.037494540214538574, 0.7828418016433716, -0.318545937538147, 0.9377740621566772, -0.19501419365406036, -0.38571104407310486, 0.6550502777099609, -0.05785659700632095, -0.2723402678966522, -0.05706797167658806, -0.0017561897402629256, 0.4773656725883484, 0.07392771542072296, -0.1340116262435913, -0.30044668912887573, 0.24438491463661194, 0.12028180807828903, -0.5304760932922363, 0.2116730660200119, -0.17768296599388123, -0.1429697573184967, -0.3424757421016693, -0.17760714888572693, -0.21777679026126862, -0.19891878962516785, -0.8060747385025024, 0.8140273690223694, -0.5256326198577881, 0.1636037677526474, 0.2957130968570709, -0.20034031569957733, 0.23218990862369537, 0.2485238015651703, -0.5291091799736023, 0.24561896920204163, 0.7853181958198547, 0.6774628758430481, -0.13400903344154358, -0.2611125111579895, -0.41932469606399536, -0.070713110268116, -0.47878941893577576, 0.7894687652587891, -0.8785367012023926, -0.7541685104370117, -0.008502181619405746, -0.255039244890213, 0.2023315280675888, -0.9637078642845154, 0.5569323897361755, -0.3484477400779724, 0.5871254205703735, -0.38303694128990173, -0.7073824405670166, -0.43916743993759155, 0.400180846452713, -0.4953869581222534, 1.3916089534759521, 0.3345528244972229, -0.7023662328720093, 0.21331627666950226, -0.7389311194419861, -0.3825017511844635, 0.05302530527114868, 0.1164989098906517, -0.22006957232952118, 0.49441322684288025, 0.7572024464607239, 0.25921863317489624, -0.20334620773792267, 0.25404417514801025, -0.0395662821829319, -0.5890288949012756, 0.1745210438966751, -0.58420330286026, 0.4869643747806549, -0.021831337362527847, 0.02100120671093464, -0.11506769806146622, -0.898167073726654, -0.07528899610042572, 0.22520127892494202, -0.31244251132011414, -0.4733867347240448, -0.03414956480264664, -0.40155336260795593, 0.05058277025818825, 0.2887316346168518, -0.5499773025512695, 0.2794549763202667, -0.7254398465156555, 0.0012224833481013775, 0.6490228176116943, 0.0392143540084362, 0.2345031350851059, -0.48677682876586914, 0.31459230184555054, 0.026992149651050568, -0.05003231391310692, -0.29787635803222656, -0.7372668385505676, -0.642144501209259, 0.1363881379365921, 0.17908580601215363, 0.6404557824134827, -1.112417459487915, 0.21406236290931702, -0.2996065020561218, -0.38765254616737366, -0.44576871395111084, 0.17910577356815338, 0.3188938498497009, 1.1702258586883545, 0.8117783665657043, -0.18698708713054657, -0.6204788088798523, -0.7198309898376465, -0.27494537830352783, 0.2369760274887085, -0.16143858432769775, 0.352559357881546, 0.2596457600593567, -0.2939157783985138, 1.08777916431427, -0.7285017371177673, -0.34639570116996765, -0.3007091283798218, 0.18014207482337952, 0.3304649293422699, 0.3602360785007477, 0.2328469157218933, -0.6675445437431335, -0.29811763763427734, -0.06954345107078552, -0.5806477069854736, -0.6515629291534424, 0.20442475378513336, 0.19108463823795319, 0.025702064856886864, 0.29089871048927307, 0.04494426026940346, 0.5644633769989014, 0.5274585485458374, -0.027725767344236374, 0.4584510028362274, -0.32528582215309143, 0.1950477957725525, -1.094610571861267, -0.2599243223667145, 0.045630477368831635, -0.04672360420227051, -0.6256466507911682, 0.3643943965435028, 0.00597279192879796, -0.33162233233451843, -0.44058746099472046, 0.3147686719894409, -0.37190115451812744, -0.029701272025704384, -0.5096620321273804, 0.18160848319530487, -0.004489710088819265, 0.36123791337013245, -0.06718174368143082, 1.0655200481414795, 0.3277425765991211, -0.5751490592956543, 0.5265300869941711, 0.24217526614665985, -0.4138188362121582, 0.5594414472579956, -0.5711464285850525, 0.20706376433372498, -0.3821258842945099, 0.23839303851127625, -0.986522376537323, 0.1624675691127777, -0.09639271348714828, -0.3710356652736664, 0.011450141668319702, 0.03405500203371048, -0.44513440132141113, -0.29072991013526917, -0.4499483108520508, 0.6228949427604675, 0.4794744551181793, -0.8348807692527771, 0.35311824083328247, 0.216558039188385, -0.2326960563659668, -0.6823657155036926, -0.6215906739234924, 0.15759895741939545, -0.33050158619880676, -0.5739498138427734, 0.7836984395980835, -0.11700579524040222, -0.2926064431667328, -0.12644724547863007, -0.1399715542793274, -0.026827160269021988, 0.04490995779633522, -0.14720426499843597, 0.4574216306209564, 0.11805282533168793, 0.23391056060791016, 0.2233729362487793, -0.28988561034202576, 0.09792641550302505, 0.08173532783985138, 0.568301796913147, 0.23117895424365997, -0.3395591676235199, -0.09708969295024872, 0.4973674416542053, -0.1694939136505127, -0.24470436573028564, 0.4698764681816101, 0.3271948993206024, -0.7347759008407593, -0.04059896618127823, -0.6052402853965759, -0.14725682139396667, -0.5004202127456665, 0.2625095248222351, -0.5122478008270264, -0.7725328803062439, 0.5227302312850952, -0.22919754683971405, 0.14775143563747406, 0.28294628858566284, 0.4729170501232147, -0.014214305207133293, 1.0405362844467163, 0.5687710046768188, -0.08147116750478745, 0.5204724073410034, -0.3466019928455353, 0.14879658818244934, -1.0561816692352295, -0.268515408039093, -0.2767777144908905, -0.4643104374408722, -0.22951418161392212, -0.6668261289596558, 0.5130671262741089, 0.10703153908252716, 0.2816163897514343, 0.4354493319988251, -0.5330519676208496, 0.7040377259254456, -0.001960182562470436, 0.2167900949716568, 0.47151994705200195, 0.25583016872406006, -0.346236914396286, -0.4905310571193695, -0.5481624007225037, -0.16881468892097473, 1.1841187477111816, -0.00027223711367696524, 0.5470036864280701, 0.286549836397171, 0.6082144975662231, 0.11811523884534836, 0.7623611688613892, -0.8447574377059937, 0.4023604393005371, -0.12009081989526749, -0.18982242047786713, -0.07805818319320679, -0.5890141725540161, -0.9830831289291382, 0.5889854431152344, -0.3871130049228668, -0.7855994701385498, -0.13573487102985382, -0.10349203646183014, 0.10782582312822342, 0.08119112253189087, -0.6986538767814636, 0.2801889181137085, 0.020145535469055176, -0.04299059137701988, -0.38574856519699097, -0.15226033329963684, 0.30824804306030273, -0.07404981553554535, 0.3629971146583557, -0.006497773341834545, -0.21633277833461761, 0.5521498322486877, -0.6892991662025452, 0.4914008677005768, -0.06528599560260773, -0.4579658806324005, 0.14386850595474243, -0.02946234494447708, 0.6423007845878601, -0.035857025533914566, -0.1503269076347351, 0.03698938339948654, -0.19235138595104218, -0.18197374045848846, -0.9887446165084839, 0.7058367133140564, -0.38155415654182434, -0.6981374025344849, -0.20632170140743256, -0.9380136132240295, -0.6232142448425293, -0.20030517876148224, 0.037662867456674576, 0.7435861825942993, 0.2943940758705139, 0.30208081007003784, 0.3302619755268097, -0.15303994715213776, 0.4125879406929016, 0.39907923340797424, -0.2567189931869507, -0.47937721014022827, 0.9816716313362122, 0.2574564814567566, 0.12567466497421265, 0.4182143211364746, 0.5266063809394836, -0.5961651802062988, -0.3841192126274109, -0.3024126887321472, 0.09574472904205322, -0.9045410752296448, -0.405602365732193, -0.19122694432735443, -0.0761357918381691, -0.12623247504234314, -0.38777488470077515, 0.08019780367612839, -0.45765700936317444, -0.26673924922943115, -0.017612911760807037, 0.46123889088630676, 0.3527311086654663, 0.05129256844520569, 0.36382514238357544, -0.6126127243041992, 0.4902154505252838, 0.2633019685745239, 0.39773765206336975, 0.0674765557050705, -0.8229292035102844, -0.07602299749851227, 0.08559219539165497, -0.4384970963001251, -1.0549118518829346, 0.45237278938293457, 0.09705094993114471, 0.46128907799720764, -0.07035065442323685, -0.21732264757156372, 1.1846437454223633, -0.5314463376998901, 0.5309999585151672, 0.18092460930347443, -1.0713344812393188, 0.3299541175365448, 0.04003842920064926, 0.252711683511734, 0.4059672951698303, 0.16457293927669525, -0.5640983581542969, -0.08086029440164566, -0.5918788909912109, -0.8030366897583008, 0.24838171899318695, 0.29146745800971985, 0.4055466949939728, 0.12910737097263336, 0.5624597668647766, 0.15457814931869507, 0.20567846298217773, -0.4234095811843872, -0.2826973497867584, 0.07403657585382462, -0.23119211196899414, -0.0022873093839734793, -0.011112958192825317, -0.011235231533646584, -0.6541249752044678, 0.5644494295120239, -0.25772807002067566, 0.05071019008755684, 0.226267009973526, -0.2963692545890808, 0.08321446180343628, 0.267200231552124, 0.5594393014907837, 0.9381322860717773, -0.015869690105319023, -0.24434363842010498, 0.869637131690979, -0.5333596467971802, 0.08035660535097122, 0.22688868641853333, -0.05173887312412262, 0.093081034719944, 0.3304818272590637, 0.45865529775619507, 0.364776611328125, -0.6790403723716736, 0.2680022418498993, 0.08436821401119232, -0.23968499898910522, -0.01605154015123844, -0.05228287726640701, -0.04234536737203598, -0.11866065859794617, 0.7648919820785522, -0.2309960275888443, 0.40553873777389526, -0.48650646209716797, 0.042849089950323105, 0.5683467984199524, -0.07407800108194351, 0.10114119946956635, 0.20858415961265564, 0.05118843540549278, -0.49390169978141785, 0.3807035982608795, -0.11319845169782639, -0.6639407873153687, 0.5810329914093018, 1.1225166320800781, 0.3108222782611847, -0.027253206819295883, -0.029190290719270706, 0.26743367314338684, 0.10297344624996185, 0.18313366174697876, 0.6229358911514282, -0.15444715321063995, -0.8306624293327332, -0.78374183177948, -0.17054109275341034, -0.692831814289093, 0.2206503003835678, -0.7023128867149353, 0.2733282148838043, -0.24932491779327393, 0.022559842094779015, -0.17412419617176056, 0.2890540063381195, -0.6315054893493652, 0.49230554699897766, 0.06406781077384949, 0.8460202217102051, -0.5063951015472412, 0.4557582139968872, 0.7960318326950073, 0.05538511648774147, -0.816621720790863, -0.03647574037313461, -0.1480276882648468, -0.8085198402404785, 0.3659340739250183, 0.40380674600601196, -0.2304450124502182, 0.07526697963476181, -0.47071847319602966, -0.7787201404571533, 0.9807119369506836, 0.32952287793159485, -0.3989393711090088, 0.31581300497055054, 0.2248264104127884, 0.5035550594329834, -0.34863513708114624, 0.22242328524589539, 0.5189648866653442, 0.30236637592315674, 0.10404309630393982, -0.7839405536651611, -0.16136746108531952, -0.2419843077659607, 0.20946037769317627, 0.28172072768211365, -0.06838905811309814, 0.4745316803455353, -0.19261880218982697, -0.08084037899971008, -0.15459883213043213, 0.7907280921936035, 0.531626284122467, 0.34806904196739197, 0.5708870887756348, 0.8614594340324402, 0.6627709269523621, -0.1226871982216835, 0.9116325378417969, -0.04466205835342407, 0.3867179751396179, 0.9464825987815857, -0.10344776511192322, 0.8914960026741028, 0.7073377966880798, -0.4778294563293457, 0.6036546230316162, 0.4323616623878479, 0.13975562155246735, 0.358918696641922, 0.5077241063117981, -0.2710980176925659, -0.01857885718345642, -0.18993894755840302, -0.7104966044425964, 0.5731988549232483, 0.43874886631965637, 0.1210847944021225, -0.5040434002876282, -0.019182292744517326, -0.06253322213888168, 0.3273666799068451, -0.4417339265346527, 0.6422718167304993, 0.03461853787302971, -0.3856191039085388, 0.5823766589164734, 0.46941685676574707, 0.8439283967018127, -0.539309024810791, -0.41126134991645813, -0.30750980973243713, -0.00547290313988924, -0.23526377975940704, -0.6554314494132996, 0.4879211187362671, 0.037624381482601166, -0.08631622046232224, 0.16414538025856018, 0.5342622399330139, -0.36001336574554443, -0.9252784252166748, 0.02489190176129341, 0.4642965495586395, -0.05827774107456207, 0.08277615904808044, -0.7682868242263794, -0.04163258522748947, -0.1967223733663559, 0.09647803008556366, 0.2597337067127228, 0.24470067024230957, -0.24999256432056427, 0.8612456321716309, 1.049856424331665, 0.038084980100393295, -0.054046306759119034, 0.3248215317726135, 1.1067582368850708, -0.37721768021583557, -0.5461092591285706, -0.7552316784858704, 0.4357638657093048, -0.11072636395692825, -0.3687750995159149, 0.6972470283508301, 0.5379176139831543, 0.9199813604354858, 0.06746074557304382, 0.4125593900680542, 0.28800535202026367, 0.6084200739860535, -0.6076620817184448, 0.019672425463795662, -0.558408796787262, 0.5491194128990173, -0.5314211845397949, -1.1763335466384888, -0.5280674695968628, 0.7263953685760498, -0.4572080373764038, -0.14987675845623016, 0.6065993905067444, 0.5766808986663818, -0.10880376398563385, 0.06866881251335144, 0.2961370348930359, -0.3739430904388428, 0.19072556495666504, 0.5184802412986755, 0.6537896394729614, -0.5738709568977356, 0.3810991644859314, -0.6361716985702515, -0.18703117966651917, -0.0036599303130060434, -0.9988201856613159, -0.5081398487091064, -0.4431435763835907, -0.11423075944185257, -0.051356587558984756, -0.22705160081386566, 1.157344937324524, 0.1872883290052414, -0.576866865158081, -0.15029244124889374, 0.09275466203689575, 0.34376081824302673, -0.4126608967781067, -0.2862078547477722, 0.24601517617702484, -0.4921266436576843, -0.7011108994483948, 0.7472431659698486, 0.18665075302124023, 0.025751331821084023, -0.19121144711971283, 0.14995521306991577, 0.11832175403833389, 0.2628180682659149, 0.7555102109909058, -0.09492165595293045, -0.45623666048049927, -0.11016202718019485, -0.1310855746269226, 0.26775360107421875, 0.266357958316803, 0.9123191833496094, -1.1151374578475952, 0.558984100818634, 0.4341786205768585, 0.995413064956665, 0.18236930668354034, 0.3750101923942566, 0.5046103596687317, -0.9710066914558411, 0.3371012806892395, 0.07506672292947769, 0.5693976879119873, 0.6424818634986877, -0.3075288236141205, 0.41774842143058777, 0.387660413980484, -0.10571230947971344, -0.8854750990867615, 0.18780213594436646, -0.6058073043823242, -0.22411257028579712, 0.8669302463531494, 0.12536267936229706, -0.02036426216363907, -0.028919454663991928, -0.46254223585128784, -0.04824452102184296, -0.15288180112838745, 0.850501298904419, 0.8919280171394348, -0.17027555406093597, -0.014828742481768131, -0.346516877412796, 0.17067252099514008, 0.6263391971588135, -0.914786696434021, -0.28108543157577515, 0.4360837936401367, 0.16503432393074036, 0.05234910920262337, 0.17480796575546265, -0.17932674288749695, 0.14278271794319153, -0.3142803907394409, -0.2884538173675537, -0.30653616786003113, -0.043802306056022644, -0.5154526829719543, -0.03570151701569557, -0.29684463143348694, -0.09528369456529617 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04306v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04306v1
AuditGPT: Auditing Smart Contracts with ChatGPT
2024-04-05T07:19:13
2024-04-05T07:19:13
Shihao Xia, Shuai Shao, Mengting He, Tingting Yu, Linhai Song, Yiying Zhang
cs.CR
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
To govern smart contracts running on Ethereum, multiple Ethereum Request for Comment (ERC) standards have been developed, each containing a set of rules to guide the behaviors of smart contracts. Violating the ERC rules could cause serious security issues and financial loss, signifying the importance of verifying smart contracts follow ERCs. Today's practices of such verification are to either manually audit each single contract or use expert-developed, limited-scope program-analysis tools, both of which are far from being effective in identifying ERC rule violations. This paper presents a tool named AuditGPT that leverages large language models (LLMs) to automatically and comprehensively verify ERC rules against smart contracts. To build AuditGPT, we first conduct an empirical study on 222 ERC rules specified in four popular ERCs to understand their content, their security impacts, their specification in natural language, and their implementation in Solidity. Guided by the study, we construct AuditGPT by separating the large, complex auditing process into small, manageable tasks and design prompts specialized for each ERC rule type to enhance LLMs' auditing performance. In the evaluation, AuditGPT successfully pinpoints 418 ERC rule violations and only reports 18 false positives, showcasing its effectiveness and accuracy. Moreover, AuditGPT beats an auditing service provided by security experts in effectiveness, accuracy, and cost, demonstrating its advancement over state-of-the-art smart-contract auditing practices.
[ -0.3943115770816803, -0.8275803923606873, 0.5115842819213867, -0.2349543571472168, -0.5107104182243347, -0.055995773524045944, 0.03999272361397743, -0.5365486741065979, 0.2644786238670349, 1.0398715734481812, -0.4454539716243744, -0.502041220664978, -0.3804480731487274, 0.07520078122615814, -0.6577604413032532, 1.6792762279510498, -0.035479288548231125, -0.17414961755275726, 0.13950425386428833, 0.2452179342508316, -0.36474284529685974, -0.4117870628833771, -0.32093921303749084, -0.15712112188339233, 0.2784741222858429, 0.43263983726501465, 0.40360027551651, 0.5553457736968994, 0.5346818566322327, 0.36407437920570374, -0.1662820428609848, 0.28624045848846436, -0.22447554767131805, -0.20055529475212097, 0.09776940196752548, -0.3472769558429718, -0.9158430695533752, -0.13278841972351074, 0.31080079078674316, -0.18639270961284637, -0.3602941930294037, 0.044408585876226425, -0.12999334931373596, 0.4848170578479767, -0.5494189858436584, 0.36206021904945374, -0.6012831926345825, -0.10584890097379684, -0.13207077980041504, -0.3715566098690033, -0.33599331974983215, -0.6242160201072693, 0.29618290066719055, -0.3724333941936493, 0.03622885420918465, 0.05052943900227547, 1.0828657150268555, 0.09042609483003616, -0.47541216015815735, -0.6299588680267334, -0.4040960371494293, 0.503462553024292, -0.7076085209846497, 0.5135990381240845, 0.2946825921535492, 0.1472972184419632, 0.07163500040769577, -0.8257895112037659, -0.540199339389801, -0.5920789241790771, -0.012559112161397934, 0.22652070224285126, -0.02952495776116848, 0.35934001207351685, 0.33951041102409363, 0.19936811923980713, -0.5116991400718689, -0.20486333966255188, -0.30983033776283264, -0.2871844172477722, 0.4951539933681488, 0.19161373376846313, 0.24608935415744781, -0.10255171358585358, -0.27401402592658997, 0.0895901694893837, -0.7841162085533142, -0.22200468182563782, 0.7739844918251038, 0.02420646697282791, -0.031854938715696335, 0.4699547290802002, -0.32754018902778625, 0.46601518988609314, -0.17319267988204956, -0.0863165631890297, -0.03684180974960327, -0.35076093673706055, -0.05017222464084625, 0.0879053995013237, 0.5063408613204956, 0.2640822231769562, 0.44268807768821716, -0.31734463572502136, -0.5921833515167236, -0.26334062218666077, 0.24099190533161163, -0.6972037553787231, -0.3327668309211731, 0.35856255888938904, -0.23867081105709076, -0.35091066360473633, 0.3731927275657654, -0.7202761769294739, -0.4679572284221649, -0.5679410099983215, 0.09876095503568649, -0.33675825595855713, -0.09007853269577026, 0.27353572845458984, -0.0721539855003357, 0.33412954211235046, 0.39227694272994995, -0.7028196454048157, 0.5647380352020264, 1.2831916809082031, 0.5920203328132629, 0.43049389123916626, -0.37450236082077026, -0.8004820942878723, -0.08688422292470932, -0.14738665521144867, 0.898300051689148, -0.1673114150762558, 0.027988756075501442, 0.12813851237297058, -0.2641043961048126, 0.10026202350854874, -0.36360111832618713, 0.5347629189491272, -0.7789331674575806, 0.06015017628669739, 0.10189913213253021, -0.5800756812095642, -0.18085679411888123, 0.5835089087486267, -0.4173358976840973, 0.6984640955924988, -0.25593215227127075, -0.7886243462562561, 0.48451390862464905, -0.7702780365943909, -0.11774241924285889, 0.3430652618408203, -0.19870081543922424, -0.5714091658592224, -0.21752282977104187, 0.07157959043979645, 0.36898350715637207, -0.23529908061027527, 0.15024428069591522, -0.24425821006298065, -0.12783049046993256, 0.5032860636711121, -0.18384014070034027, 0.7521445155143738, 0.1748693883419037, -0.47322970628738403, 0.33145850896835327, -0.6424537897109985, 0.347840279340744, -0.04386965185403824, -0.39845168590545654, -0.04740506783127785, 0.1100335642695427, 0.08642160892486572, -0.10606611520051956, 0.31061699986457825, -0.4585259258747101, 0.10805797576904297, -0.20326738059520721, 0.7351757287979126, 0.7783876061439514, 0.0943342074751854, -0.29489460587501526, -0.2396167516708374, 0.3410259783267975, -0.23764410614967346, 0.31585198640823364, -0.06194331496953964, -0.3531942367553711, -0.8494982123374939, -0.47103413939476013, 0.4520660936832428, 0.8559202551841736, -0.2079777717590332, 0.796428918838501, -0.29892170429229736, -0.46124961972236633, -0.1441268026828766, 0.16348931193351746, 0.1736011952161789, 0.12342184782028198, 0.019662708044052124, -0.24358734488487244, -0.6264021396636963, -0.901319682598114, -0.4203490614891052, -0.5833169221878052, -0.03192254155874252, 0.0815117359161377, 0.9596473574638367, -0.3572438657283783, 0.8099938631057739, -0.4543442130088806, -0.2204299420118332, -0.05098763480782509, 0.058007076382637024, 0.173126682639122, 0.24631328880786896, 0.18977880477905273, -0.46712222695350647, -0.35219821333885193, 0.342926949262619, -0.4656449258327484, -0.06589765101671219, -0.04378947243094444, 0.15043234825134277, 0.12459787726402283, 0.6279873251914978, -0.39879390597343445, 0.3829253017902374, 0.3742363750934601, -0.6288059949874878, 0.7470391392707825, -0.3650921583175659, 0.04087699204683304, -0.43697163462638855, 0.19752708077430725, -0.22006314992904663, -0.7270137667655945, -0.4567188322544098, 0.24710047245025635, 0.54012531042099, -0.07849594205617905, -0.2740933895111084, 0.01897265575826168, -0.2040349543094635, 0.069841168820858, 0.11361254006624222, 0.05160322040319443, -0.21610575914382935, 0.3367743194103241, -0.04996513947844505, 0.5825290679931641, 0.2896515429019928, -0.47339341044425964, 0.6126153469085693, -0.03371508792042732, -0.44293445348739624, 0.5061823725700378, -0.7019427418708801, 0.6423202753067017, 0.15689720213413239, 0.1884683072566986, -0.5904716849327087, -0.04459187388420105, 0.11250616610050201, -0.013559839688241482, -0.010578478686511517, -0.4706307053565979, -0.7002713680267334, 0.07486750185489655, -0.3335476517677307, -0.05019908770918846, 0.3826874792575836, -0.4245014786720276, 0.8435986638069153, 0.24893783032894135, -0.04835919663310051, -0.6291577816009521, -0.43847259879112244, 0.3978799283504486, -0.35724398493766785, -0.5704349279403687, -0.2392529547214508, 0.05791066586971283, -0.40175673365592957, -0.15796908736228943, 0.029899632558226585, -0.10461394488811493, 0.1952620893716812, 0.29735761880874634, 0.3550766706466675, -0.10704200714826584, -0.24032531678676605, -0.5584362745285034, -0.21027682721614838, -0.02218584343791008, -0.5068502426147461, 0.4545317590236664, -0.6434336304664612, -0.5645519495010376, -0.6120206713676453, 0.20269721746444702, 0.936377227306366, -0.36480870842933655, 0.37384140491485596, 0.04696414992213249, -0.2766980528831482, -0.09584331512451172, -0.9938278198242188, -0.24414147436618805, -0.46261653304100037, 0.5581104159355164, -0.47584012150764465, -0.6444270014762878, 0.7925764918327332, 0.08664996922016144, 0.33216097950935364, 0.2328527718782425, 0.5632729530334473, 0.25327664613723755, 0.7860094308853149, 0.6353098154067993, -0.08092615008354187, 0.7092077136039734, -0.14430668950080872, 0.26897338032722473, -0.4909461736679077, -0.20480604469776154, -0.7443395256996155, 0.3824426233768463, -0.5796082019805908, -0.209051251411438, 0.3223283290863037, -0.11985822021961212, -0.23278938233852386, 0.46459802985191345, -0.10604692995548248, 0.7169989347457886, 0.2482994645833969, 0.16456753015518188, 0.5806570649147034, -0.29170817136764526, -0.11953949928283691, 0.2070116400718689, -0.4274016320705414, -0.9281641244888306, 1.0936030149459839, 0.5498666167259216, 0.7983500957489014, 0.1729167252779007, 0.8900068998336792, 0.3477729260921478, 0.3022678792476654, -0.8218429088592529, 0.5542396903038025, 0.20646639168262482, -0.6868630051612854, -0.23862968385219574, -0.5360954999923706, -0.6057953834533691, -0.01023572962731123, 0.12071894109249115, -0.6829678416252136, -0.1037181168794632, 0.37756988406181335, -0.2559089958667755, 0.3337962031364441, -0.8889328241348267, 0.6890627145767212, -0.18514567613601685, -0.14449875056743622, -0.25757503509521484, -0.19583414494991302, 0.27686479687690735, -0.14188747107982635, 0.1276027262210846, 0.15145525336265564, -0.32487770915031433, 0.5782284140586853, -0.8275665044784546, 0.8284366726875305, 0.041047386825084686, -0.25538909435272217, 0.5429404377937317, 0.34110766649246216, 1.1430388689041138, 0.5634680390357971, 0.31309786438941956, 0.06309205293655396, 0.14235149323940277, -0.10778734087944031, -0.1910276710987091, 0.6707006096839905, -0.6719219088554382, -0.2813126742839813, -0.42830991744995117, -0.21473176777362823, -0.0030814900528639555, 0.3974206745624542, 0.008821255527436733, 0.3274259567260742, -0.3457110524177551, -0.20052416622638702, 0.6236639618873596, 0.13407549262046814, 0.03577188402414322, 0.7255750894546509, -0.12436273694038391, -0.3741098642349243, 0.788201630115509, 0.07116936147212982, 0.1731485277414322, 0.22124625742435455, 0.13134881854057312, -0.3162841796875, -0.7987716197967529, -0.2567419707775116, 0.2801051437854767, -0.8044508695602417, -0.25040167570114136, -0.5757684707641602, 0.16785141825675964, -0.4908272325992584, 0.19542114436626434, -0.5691697597503662, -0.24035851657390594, 0.2157430797815323, -0.07444805651903152, 0.3754892647266388, 0.8559268712997437, 0.04727935045957565, -0.015161906369030476, -0.7825601100921631, 0.14047303795814514, 0.9012420177459717, 0.7085574865341187, -0.41252338886260986, -0.33853209018707275, -0.13154858350753784, -0.4124784767627716, -0.2971121072769165, -0.8863417506217957, 0.17056001722812653, 0.04928624629974365, 0.22325868904590607, 0.711319625377655, -0.037273798137903214, 0.4332749545574188, -0.4987936019897461, 0.5018206834793091, 0.06858957558870316, -1.3091375827789307, 0.2971545457839966, -0.5028587579727173, -0.044317662715911865, 0.45038139820098877, -0.3671342432498932, -0.97960364818573, -0.5328539609909058, -0.729476273059845, -0.8322195410728455, 0.4738261103630066, 0.12356750667095184, -0.24530178308486938, 0.13090664148330688, 0.24700017273426056, -0.15649987757205963, 0.10908166319131851, -0.5377638339996338, 0.10855865478515625, -0.17515118420124054, 0.029508356004953384, 0.35601940751075745, -0.30361053347587585, -0.4738363027572632, 0.47829997539520264, 0.8576900362968445, -0.24963997304439545, 0.17485809326171875, 0.36448022723197937, -0.02101420797407627, -0.014340829104185104, 0.4330288767814636, 0.6490052938461304, 0.8432554602622986, -0.23642711341381073, 0.13345816731452942, 0.5947891473770142, -0.590531051158905, -0.31783241033554077, 0.08988934010267258, -0.17283408343791962, -0.09622810781002045, 0.5760341286659241, 0.4711761474609375, -0.04928082600235939, -0.8700217604637146, 0.3846908509731293, -0.33354395627975464, -0.38262030482292175, -0.662727415561676, -0.04888457432389259, 0.0001120069355238229, 0.24959522485733032, 0.10748394578695297, -0.13379263877868652, 0.16579803824424744, -0.3439202606678009, 0.2150099128484726, 0.32513436675071716, -0.4270564317703247, -0.2771008014678955, 0.23970988392829895, 0.2767431139945984, -0.21319715678691864, 0.7024450898170471, 0.0390683114528656, -0.8954430818557739, 0.8554618954658508, -0.006128751672804356, 1.078596830368042, 0.24562329053878784, -0.21021032333374023, -0.020041462033987045, 0.6632448434829712, -0.08561539649963379, 0.23631742596626282, 0.09554697573184967, -0.41725558042526245, -0.689238965511322, 0.030086614191532135, -0.5335294604301453, 0.17732912302017212, -0.3723871409893036, 0.4998898208141327, -0.696707010269165, -0.05399417132139206, 0.030559081584215164, 0.10109775513410568, -0.798629105091095, -0.22522516548633575, 0.15590710937976837, 0.844173014163971, -0.6261364817619324, 0.5823819637298584, 0.8219531178474426, -0.08589043468236923, -0.8399790525436401, -0.12490235269069672, 0.2732655107975006, -0.8704501986503601, 0.5437990427017212, -0.04079442843794823, -0.19874471426010132, -0.21699777245521545, -0.5329545140266418, -0.2761044502258301, 0.7928308248519897, 0.36779576539993286, -0.6600132584571838, 0.32760682702064514, 0.0644540786743164, 0.4048927128314972, 0.11400917917490005, 0.5851910710334778, 0.5816400647163391, 0.6670604944229126, -0.47208738327026367, -1.1920535564422607, -0.03709753230214119, -0.07279639691114426, -0.5979066491127014, 0.5179398655891418, -0.7726824879646301, 0.5725076794624329, -0.13307827711105347, -0.12277424335479736, 0.06599573791027069, 0.37480780482292175, 0.11072588711977005, 0.09081100672483444, 0.7087050676345825, 0.48009568452835083, 0.7335320711135864, -0.10067624598741531, 0.8991757035255432, -0.29697078466415405, 0.7957272529602051, 0.7972097396850586, -0.237465962767601, 0.4582361578941345, 0.7055174708366394, -0.15030786395072937, 0.3082314133644104, 0.28693750500679016, 0.046365126967430115, 0.1511991173028946, 0.4173900783061981, -0.32494667172431946, -0.44265881180763245, -0.14385442435741425, -0.1639305055141449, 0.25737500190734863, 0.09643616527318954, -0.1105799600481987, 0.04659850522875786, -0.5447502732276917, 0.24487262964248657, -0.2520677447319031, -0.0945577546954155, 1.0481107234954834, -0.06974274665117264, -0.5389403104782104, 0.272972047328949, 0.024342965334653854, 0.5523030757904053, -1.00235116481781, -0.10008583962917328, -0.07067947089672089, 0.5726473331451416, -0.33736950159072876, -0.4742545485496521, -0.04774349927902222, 0.3426022231578827, 0.1808568686246872, -0.2983315885066986, 0.5218181610107422, -0.2044360190629959, 0.01680433563888073, 0.19312582910060883, 0.32138723134994507, 0.21972785890102386, -0.2976258099079132, -0.6178409457206726, -0.14748597145080566, 0.21092168986797333, -0.43803757429122925, 0.21116825938224792, 0.6689616441726685, -0.07938191294670105, 0.8665447235107422, 0.7305370569229126, 0.3835796117782593, -0.0030445237644016743, 0.01221415400505066, 0.7082620859146118, -0.5296711921691895, -0.8663265109062195, -0.9570282697677612, 0.45614951848983765, -0.15336234867572784, -0.4911949634552002, 0.5298806428909302, 0.6303409337997437, 0.738437294960022, -0.08647970855236053, 0.7808316946029663, 0.07311460375785828, 0.3067694902420044, -0.5798643827438354, 0.5920495390892029, 0.022582611069083214, 0.4471522569656372, -0.12142866849899292, -0.7900954484939575, -0.33052298426628113, 0.4835051894187927, -0.28417181968688965, -0.05015447735786438, 0.8409601449966431, 0.914509654045105, -0.1086760014295578, 0.23433001339435577, 0.21209514141082764, 0.022596005350351334, 0.8591655492782593, 0.2402045875787735, 0.9868998527526855, -0.4293203353881836, 1.0475207567214966, -0.32374250888824463, -0.1802932173013687, -0.41209927201271057, -1.2020056247711182, -0.9095365405082703, -0.08122050762176514, -0.7493256330490112, -0.404527872800827, 0.03635912761092186, 0.94700026512146, 0.8402159214019775, -0.9079012274742126, -0.2999626398086548, -0.23741228878498077, 0.16206789016723633, -0.32953256368637085, -0.21634207665920258, 0.48916366696357727, -0.21279276907444, -0.6298272609710693, 0.1295929253101349, 0.23863045871257782, 0.13824835419654846, -0.22763749957084656, -0.16395272314548492, 0.14986588060855865, -0.026861274614930153, 0.09479419142007828, 0.3391183912754059, -0.4385521411895752, -0.4266265332698822, -0.23525658249855042, -0.1274479180574417, -0.30328887701034546, 1.1812872886657715, -0.18057669699192047, 0.33346647024154663, 0.7646898627281189, 0.4451933205127716, 0.38082683086395264, -0.3266579508781433, 0.39837145805358887, -0.3869921863079071, 0.04389505460858345, 0.3254539966583252, 0.5453101992607117, -0.16530631482601166, -0.4774923324584961, 0.48069706559181213, 0.07341544330120087, -0.8442773818969727, -0.7729434370994568, 0.12971070408821106, -0.8530874252319336, 0.1617654412984848, 0.7788517475128174, -0.3449394106864929, -0.10426762700080872, -0.5402881503105164, -0.41973862051963806, 0.08537903428077698, -0.648249089717865, 0.8986596465110779, 0.8957821726799011, 0.03934894874691963, 0.12748003005981445, -0.8859716653823853, 0.36144062876701355, 0.5825486779212952, -0.8626713752746582, 0.46512967348098755, 0.36059990525245667, 0.4894125163555145, 0.12731972336769104, 0.3044282793998718, -0.26141050457954407, 0.3489944338798523, -0.08703743666410446, 0.17384013533592224, -0.3182218074798584, -0.07703685760498047, -0.3934556543827057, -0.07279979437589645, 0.2604411542415619, -0.03152848035097122 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03921v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03921v2
Simple Techniques for Enhancing Sentence Embeddings in Generative Language Models
2024-04-05T07:07:15
2024-05-15T13:34:14
Bowen Zhang, Kehua Chang, Chunping Li
cs.CL
cs.CL
Sentence Embedding stands as a fundamental task within the realm of Natural Language Processing, finding extensive application in search engines, expert systems, and question-and-answer platforms. With the continuous evolution of large language models such as LLaMA and Mistral, research on sentence embedding has recently achieved notable breakthroughs. However, these advancements mainly pertain to fine-tuning scenarios, leaving explorations into computationally efficient direct inference methods for sentence representation in a nascent stage. This paper endeavors to bridge this research gap. Through comprehensive experimentation, we challenge the widely held belief in the necessity of an Explicit One-word Limitation for deriving sentence embeddings from Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs). We demonstrate that this approach, while beneficial for generative models under direct inference scenario, is not imperative for discriminative models or the fine-tuning of generative PLMs. This discovery sheds new light on the design of manual templates in future studies. Building upon this insight, we propose two innovative prompt engineering techniques capable of further enhancing the expressive power of PLMs' raw embeddings: Pretended Chain of Thought and Knowledge Enhancement. We confirm their effectiveness across various PLM types and provide a detailed exploration of the underlying factors contributing to their success.
[ -0.26416918635368347, -0.9670738577842712, 0.9456255435943604, 0.40532931685447693, -0.34180235862731934, -0.09524520486593246, -0.10801620781421661, -0.046199630945920944, 0.14765870571136475, 0.5206441879272461, -0.6351839303970337, -0.3548641800880432, -0.30594661831855774, 0.18812963366508484, -0.3019549548625946, 0.7414295673370361, -0.13392381370067596, -0.13501915335655212, -0.5110540986061096, 0.09351402521133423, -0.5492440462112427, -0.5742449164390564, -0.18480122089385986, 0.13350868225097656, 0.3442610204219818, 0.11953308433294296, 0.6587672829627991, 0.4697575271129608, 0.01914636604487896, 0.17865502834320068, -0.029116561636328697, 0.34165674448013306, -0.18927927315235138, 0.26109403371810913, 0.07559395581483841, -0.7377942800521851, -0.22802188992500305, 0.20507650077342987, 0.4730997085571289, 0.7718392610549927, -0.2697829008102417, -0.21512939035892487, 0.12602150440216064, 0.3906426429748535, -0.8032101392745972, 0.12461008131504059, -0.6269045472145081, 0.2476019561290741, -0.20313537120819092, -0.1577751189470291, -0.6217218041419983, -0.4720478355884552, 0.16893945634365082, -0.7185240387916565, 0.05525169521570206, 0.16485299170017242, 0.7232310175895691, 0.3150774836540222, -0.47128424048423767, -0.42970526218414307, -0.404285192489624, 0.6141310930252075, -0.6495758891105652, 0.24605290591716766, 0.20850101113319397, 0.04973917827010155, -0.2604560852050781, -0.9585824012756348, -0.68135005235672, -0.5952048301696777, -0.09552109986543655, 0.06318075209856033, -0.3574100434780121, 0.38267967104911804, 0.43763306736946106, 0.3944966495037079, -0.2517838478088379, 0.15401743352413177, 0.25574809312820435, -0.003978523425757885, 0.24268576502799988, 0.026912419125437737, 0.4179486632347107, -0.22378508746623993, -0.48150789737701416, -0.2226586639881134, -0.9810954332351685, -0.0899704098701477, 0.254573792219162, 0.27514317631721497, 0.011370214633643627, 0.7054764628410339, -0.09822031110525131, 0.641632080078125, -0.020641084760427475, 0.4250650405883789, 0.09841886162757874, -0.2744158208370209, -0.2486158013343811, -0.07874535769224167, 0.6354024410247803, 0.043308887630701065, 0.28994515538215637, -0.1683332622051239, -0.1999172866344452, 0.30386772751808167, 0.3452213406562805, -0.5549848079681396, -0.037299759685993195, -0.08750633895397186, -0.15963022410869598, -0.30577516555786133, 0.2608109712600708, -0.5947019457817078, -0.49406328797340393, -0.05476374551653862, 0.31260067224502563, -0.36699143052101135, -0.1315336972475052, 0.3410414159297943, -0.3281751275062561, 0.1617443710565567, 0.17945118248462677, -0.5416038632392883, 0.05323757231235504, 0.7390417456626892, 0.732255220413208, 0.3434944450855255, -0.09390423446893692, -0.6180530786514282, 0.02823231741786003, -0.5560118556022644, 0.7373171448707581, -0.5828519463539124, -0.35382455587387085, 0.36898425221443176, -0.2580871284008026, -0.03512430191040039, -0.39928415417671204, 0.8892759084701538, -0.625124454498291, 0.2888250946998596, -0.4714878797531128, -0.9249445796012878, -0.09764047712087631, 0.012684077955782413, -0.4941353499889374, 0.6628302335739136, -0.03342493996024132, -0.8125545978546143, 0.18504156172275543, -0.5659418702125549, -0.5609362125396729, -0.00960975605994463, -0.2133246511220932, -0.10836341232061386, 0.5762240290641785, 0.5182706117630005, 0.5077657103538513, -0.29667791724205017, 0.39372381567955017, -0.45720070600509644, -0.15397852659225464, 0.4767865538597107, -0.5892332196235657, 0.7432295680046082, 0.1849401891231537, -0.05781129375100136, -0.1674332469701767, -0.3049161732196808, -0.055673591792583466, 0.022539010271430016, -0.0454515665769577, -0.43991661071777344, -0.10841282457113266, -0.15521666407585144, 0.058164749294519424, 0.18027625977993011, -0.4002193212509155, 0.44138506054878235, -0.6729750037193298, 0.48871055245399475, 0.7541395425796509, 0.22840894758701324, 0.5756836533546448, -0.3748563528060913, 0.8538916707038879, 0.11398651450872421, 0.031187210232019424, -0.5309749245643616, -0.35687196254730225, -0.9406043887138367, -0.13758425414562225, 0.3262679874897003, 0.4723770320415497, -0.9436919689178467, 0.4577304422855377, -0.1459653526544571, -0.1412888616323471, -0.8623543381690979, 0.1629890501499176, 0.13409101963043213, 0.3481731712818146, 0.4205232560634613, 0.06487911194562912, -0.7941821813583374, -0.8782134652137756, -0.5532517433166504, -0.0033977413550019264, -0.12882141768932343, 0.05447894707322121, 0.12688212096691132, -0.08957463502883911, 1.200404405593872, -0.7385175824165344, -0.0525989830493927, -0.5053116083145142, 0.07824059575796127, 0.25384485721588135, 0.4379461109638214, 0.5279112458229065, -0.6998710632324219, -0.3204941153526306, -0.49688103795051575, -0.8283660411834717, -0.24383419752120972, -0.49040278792381287, -0.1598322093486786, -0.18321463465690613, 0.5063284039497375, -0.94989413022995, 0.4233338236808777, 0.29592791199684143, -0.36001044511795044, 0.43559086322784424, -0.27131229639053345, -0.08939952403306961, -0.8630341291427612, -0.39509904384613037, -0.010909088887274265, -0.29952341318130493, -0.6074085831642151, 0.19653214514255524, 0.1428394764661789, -0.0921839252114296, -0.20386403799057007, 0.4209090769290924, -0.6370134353637695, 0.34789419174194336, -0.18138062953948975, 0.2381257265806198, 0.05111578479409218, 0.3558177649974823, -0.23842427134513855, 0.767581582069397, 0.7357670664787292, -0.7115827202796936, 0.08937569707632065, 0.3643611967563629, -0.4305998980998993, 0.25656411051750183, -0.7428178191184998, 0.30562591552734375, -0.3208322525024414, 0.34388038516044617, -0.8647572994232178, -0.07208596915006638, 0.4742105305194855, -0.0513664186000824, 0.21474306285381317, -0.08959954231977463, -0.7055003046989441, -0.3840576410293579, -0.47354191541671753, 0.06561674922704697, 0.8489888310432434, -0.6109715104103088, 0.4727150797843933, 0.25366634130477905, -0.0799659863114357, -0.23376616835594177, -0.6038483381271362, 0.33919191360473633, -0.3173866271972656, -0.5529286861419678, 0.550734281539917, 0.03373757377266884, -0.253574937582016, -0.09263042360544205, -0.1743886023759842, 0.11547324806451797, 0.2286260426044464, 0.1848905384540558, 0.2735151946544647, -0.2760668396949768, 0.35574084520339966, 0.604108452796936, -0.09081949293613434, 0.06560925394296646, -0.3616659641265869, 0.45834898948669434, -0.03335215896368027, -0.300748348236084, -0.49183815717697144, 0.25423353910446167, 0.2411666363477707, -0.21890166401863098, 0.8004056811332703, 0.20192265510559082, -0.2955871820449829, -0.4860486388206482, -0.7650119066238403, -0.25249776244163513, -0.5380351543426514, -0.03343788906931877, -0.402214378118515, -1.0191409587860107, 0.15421804785728455, -0.3919246792793274, -0.22478818893432617, 0.2817267179489136, -0.03446706011891365, -0.11352095752954483, 0.8812060356140137, 0.662369966506958, 0.22046735882759094, 0.5252054333686829, 0.001189807546325028, 0.26508036255836487, -0.9035177230834961, 0.16942869126796722, -0.32792162895202637, 0.09003747999668121, -0.5718622803688049, -0.6482025980949402, 0.4323025941848755, 0.5284865498542786, -0.14400313794612885, 0.28065788745880127, -0.1309976726770401, 0.22445373237133026, 0.43870723247528076, 0.2859472632408142, 0.13006903231143951, 0.005135056562721729, -0.4694077968597412, -0.16773082315921783, -0.9734175205230713, -0.7830295562744141, 0.8280116319656372, 0.31283146142959595, 0.6855760812759399, -0.21613375842571259, 0.5788208842277527, 0.264195054769516, 0.17182151973247528, -0.5489073991775513, 0.6286094784736633, -0.18953905999660492, -0.2465173304080963, -0.006364168133586645, -0.3024395704269409, -0.6632896065711975, 0.15731725096702576, -0.18364419043064117, -0.4826665222644806, 0.25998398661613464, 0.13593986630439758, -0.534833550453186, 0.12287737429141998, -0.6250308156013489, 0.7263405919075012, -0.20759691298007965, -0.19771119952201843, -0.18589866161346436, -0.3608328700065613, 0.209711953997612, 0.2595604956150055, 0.0206946711987257, 0.16506008803844452, -0.19229190051555634, 0.6031864881515503, -0.5788218975067139, 1.0905052423477173, -0.28027981519699097, -0.31190425157546997, 0.5201537609100342, 0.06637345999479294, 0.7584344148635864, 0.21026957035064697, -0.002908185590058565, -0.30397528409957886, -0.3191041946411133, -0.25974756479263306, -0.9330736398696899, 0.5532629489898682, -0.32541900873184204, -1.0187463760375977, -0.2506203055381775, -0.2801169157028198, -0.4866822361946106, -0.06834330409765244, 0.09553729742765427, 0.416373074054718, -0.2690039575099945, 0.13731160759925842, 0.7274693846702576, -0.5825486183166504, 0.5803502202033997, 0.1524801403284073, -0.15607143938541412, -0.36618247628211975, 0.3710925281047821, -0.07116467505693436, 0.07298770546913147, 0.5905393362045288, 0.24103137850761414, -0.384190171957016, -0.2254008650779724, -0.1783076822757721, 0.26716431975364685, -0.6957928538322449, -0.22326096892356873, -1.0140398740768433, -0.033522821962833405, -0.6571460962295532, -0.23517566919326782, -0.15448766946792603, -0.5474748015403748, -0.5527282357215881, -0.4981716573238373, 0.46346428990364075, 0.5712203979492188, 0.063754603266716, 0.3869696855545044, -0.6706063151359558, 0.22624364495277405, 0.3853713572025299, -0.02873263880610466, 0.1666155606508255, -0.3436118960380554, 0.03968529775738716, 0.26052990555763245, -0.23388397693634033, -1.0305495262145996, 0.27771538496017456, 0.23305624723434448, 0.6114854216575623, 0.6439263820648193, 0.3482314944267273, 0.8051954507827759, -0.4724326431751251, 0.807360053062439, 0.12793272733688354, -1.073371410369873, 0.8151354193687439, -0.16211649775505066, 0.07249313592910767, 0.33233508467674255, 0.37769898772239685, -0.4978402554988861, -0.3463094234466553, -0.5703376531600952, -0.7001135945320129, 0.18635542690753937, 0.2196916937828064, 0.6527915000915527, -0.4521084427833557, 0.5846689343452454, 0.21193750202655792, 0.44736921787261963, -0.6084507703781128, -0.07323716580867767, -0.1798284649848938, -0.17767640948295593, -0.020897425711154938, -0.4353037476539612, 0.13555018603801727, -0.1226353719830513, 0.455978125333786, -0.007450487930327654, 0.2691338062286377, 0.3345217704772949, -0.4886155128479004, 0.3586333394050598, 0.4813174307346344, 0.3813825249671936, 0.3717195987701416, 0.1378687471151352, 0.2466699779033661, 0.2926301062107086, -0.062099456787109375, 0.057036157697439194, 0.11827763170003891, -0.31068000197410583, 0.02831839770078659, 0.4953415095806122, 1.043152093887329, 0.3474471867084503, -0.659593403339386, 0.6178889870643616, 0.22899627685546875, 0.3229341506958008, -0.35424625873565674, 0.16821010410785675, 0.05755404010415077, 0.24690377712249756, 0.38603270053863525, 0.02054135501384735, 0.02384534478187561, -0.6332855820655823, 0.1961190551519394, 0.4389445185661316, -0.38331976532936096, -0.32429805397987366, 0.7006197571754456, 0.15632133185863495, -0.1970420479774475, 0.7285196781158447, -0.2976589798927307, -0.5721511840820312, 0.4026697874069214, 0.6133037209510803, 1.038320779800415, -0.015330922789871693, 0.6017834544181824, 0.10817327350378036, 0.36822977662086487, -0.2437974065542221, 0.07961974292993546, -0.11912021785974503, -0.8592952489852905, -0.44508978724479675, -0.56145179271698, 0.004883018787950277, -0.19288606941699982, -0.6192023158073425, 0.23606805503368378, -0.3517024517059326, -0.15263479948043823, -0.44916707277297974, -0.2372124344110489, -0.8523157238960266, -0.16715577244758606, 0.13322307169437408, 1.0947989225387573, -0.8424821496009827, 0.6728662252426147, 0.6237446665763855, -0.5429862141609192, -0.505099892616272, 0.195211261510849, -0.4160747528076172, -0.5884934663772583, 0.6063864231109619, 0.3555609881877899, 0.14078928530216217, 0.22102364897727966, -0.6035656929016113, -0.3788450062274933, 0.979567289352417, 0.5937975645065308, -0.6839491128921509, -0.3880234658718109, 0.06757243722677231, 0.5147062540054321, -0.5984669327735901, 0.13065938651561737, 0.3590421676635742, 0.35325202345848083, -0.1562153548002243, -0.4384942948818207, 0.4182460606098175, -0.057174790650606155, 0.39506253600120544, -0.1734738051891327, -0.1425752490758896, 0.7736129760742188, -0.3499625325202942, -0.5993499755859375, 0.317681223154068, 0.9099039435386658, 0.29628700017929077, 0.04939703643321991, 0.5833314061164856, 0.7315525412559509, 0.9088234305381775, 0.012084271758794785, 1.3327295780181885, -0.07235371321439743, 0.14787161350250244, 1.141197681427002, -0.3560184836387634, 0.6476436257362366, 0.4722060263156891, -0.1869400292634964, 0.7339254021644592, 0.4487193822860718, 0.09142549335956573, 0.7671332955360413, 0.39019379019737244, -0.4845362901687622, -0.4828737676143646, -0.30661752820014954, -0.30326682329177856, 0.27417510747909546, 0.3399762213230133, -0.31207168102264404, -0.11881954967975616, 0.42252814769744873, 0.08629997819662094, 0.2058897465467453, -0.09742120653390884, 0.6124807596206665, 0.429004043340683, -0.5652705430984497, 0.199551522731781, -0.11760933697223663, 0.8493713140487671, -0.43104660511016846, -0.15964820981025696, -0.36559638381004333, -0.2118609994649887, 0.22279612720012665, -0.4753793478012085, -0.10148932784795761, 0.11068625003099442, 0.17772820591926575, -0.6655091047286987, 0.7039347887039185, -0.3651631474494934, -0.40867042541503906, 0.10788482427597046, 0.7399634718894958, -0.3182431161403656, -0.29498422145843506, -0.3413577973842621, -0.11304297298192978, -0.19326002895832062, -0.3000510036945343, 0.04094535857439041, 0.6372539401054382, 0.357535183429718, 0.7378164529800415, 0.5329269766807556, 0.09223250299692154, 0.023597244173288345, 0.1760941594839096, 1.0269551277160645, -0.7101759314537048, -0.7033961415290833, -0.9191836714744568, 0.5744636654853821, -0.0916101336479187, -0.2508780360221863, 0.8423789739608765, 0.31697672605514526, 0.5556604266166687, -0.2921809256076813, 0.888218343257904, 0.011252598837018013, 0.2344999760389328, -0.8902221918106079, 0.504991888999939, -0.2864014208316803, 0.38771411776542664, -0.2265882045030594, -0.7342627048492432, -0.1894908845424652, 0.7303840517997742, -0.2907329797744751, -0.031971193850040436, 0.7935110330581665, 0.7030394673347473, 0.058640412986278534, 0.05047903582453728, 0.19435973465442657, 0.41476762294769287, 0.26723015308380127, 0.3765757977962494, 1.251011848449707, -0.4287554919719696, 0.2494172602891922, -0.24025195837020874, -0.08848602324724197, -0.05849415063858032, -1.0527844429016113, -0.9399348497390747, -0.6447067260742188, -0.42923638224601746, -0.1969483643770218, 0.15344040095806122, 0.9701915383338928, 0.3428542912006378, -0.5550276041030884, 0.1233597919344902, -0.6154047846794128, 0.14891037344932556, -0.2554389536380768, -0.22769522666931152, 0.16568031907081604, -0.661641001701355, -0.4829886555671692, 0.6922298073768616, 0.20876091718673706, 0.2341803014278412, -0.17935501039028168, 0.13881422579288483, -0.2806408405303955, 0.16105860471725464, 0.6171649098396301, -0.036534909158945084, -0.7738283276557922, -0.3667648732662201, 0.12335750460624695, 0.0001868854888016358, -0.2049759179353714, 1.1650300025939941, -1.1305698156356812, 0.4144420027732849, 0.40318140387535095, 0.6916253566741943, 0.21746329963207245, 0.0005663917399942875, 0.9272839426994324, -0.8530513644218445, 0.11484383046627045, 0.3551601469516754, 0.43265917897224426, 0.32359009981155396, -0.3437679708003998, 0.3779403567314148, 0.16006308794021606, -0.06650714576244354, -0.9230149984359741, 0.3445422947406769, -0.7733069658279419, -0.28148916363716125, 0.9655376672744751, -0.3078957796096802, 0.14522303640842438, 0.17451147735118866, -0.15378442406654358, 0.5050811171531677, -0.10277111083269119, 0.7039541602134705, 0.6329543590545654, 0.11380383372306824, -0.2882974147796631, -0.4948780834674835, 0.5312294363975525, 0.5114867687225342, -0.8457511067390442, 0.06070498377084732, 0.43180403113365173, 0.04843074455857277, -0.03614836186170578, 0.34516578912734985, 0.1744169294834137, 0.03148718550801277, 0.07563287764787674, -0.24915732443332672, -0.14736337959766388, -0.2064990997314453, -0.3942382335662842, 0.247843936085701, -0.0054552373476326466, -0.0969216451048851 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03912v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03912v1
Forget NLI, Use a Dictionary: Zero-Shot Topic Classification for Low-Resource Languages with Application to Luxembourgish
2024-04-05T06:35:31
2024-04-05T06:35:31
Fred Philippy, Shohreh Haddadan, Siwen Guo
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
In NLP, zero-shot classification (ZSC) is the task of assigning labels to textual data without any labeled examples for the target classes. A common method for ZSC is to fine-tune a language model on a Natural Language Inference (NLI) dataset and then use it to infer the entailment between the input document and the target labels. However, this approach faces certain challenges, particularly for languages with limited resources. In this paper, we propose an alternative solution that leverages dictionaries as a source of data for ZSC. We focus on Luxembourgish, a low-resource language spoken in Luxembourg, and construct two new topic relevance classification datasets based on a dictionary that provides various synonyms, word translations and example sentences. We evaluate the usability of our dataset and compare it with the NLI-based approach on two topic classification tasks in a zero-shot manner. Our results show that by using the dictionary-based dataset, the trained models outperform the ones following the NLI-based approach for ZSC. While we focus on a single low-resource language in this study, we believe that the efficacy of our approach can also transfer to other languages where such a dictionary is available.
[ -0.4238504469394684, -0.4961714744567871, 0.40482214093208313, -0.1557987481355667, -0.45420777797698975, -0.02874644845724106, -0.4376390874385834, -0.032247576862573624, 0.44476792216300964, 0.504730761051178, -0.5063067078590393, -0.5765171051025391, -0.6183054447174072, 0.09111197292804718, -0.48677563667297363, 0.8452984690666199, -0.04598245024681091, -0.17597810924053192, 0.0061791124753654, -0.2831510305404663, -0.3570981025695801, -0.5539986491203308, -0.06978243589401245, -0.1376955658197403, 0.6375577449798584, 0.9862833023071289, 0.4377981722354889, 0.5536870360374451, 0.4622773826122284, 0.21989372372627258, -0.18481950461864471, -0.07835457473993301, -0.5025680661201477, 0.009676452726125717, -0.3054831326007843, -0.3903292417526245, 0.2168421745300293, 0.08976965397596359, 0.37962761521339417, 0.9613893628120422, -0.21499119699001312, 0.07393431663513184, -0.055770061910152435, 0.542625367641449, -1.1048007011413574, 0.08905428647994995, -0.6887199282646179, 0.12098266184329987, -0.5224053263664246, -0.04945937544107437, -0.19253002107143402, 0.1587730199098587, 0.14342263340950012, -0.4641686677932739, 0.45551007986068726, -0.29867029190063477, 0.975316047668457, 0.20506414771080017, -0.2230793833732605, -0.434695303440094, -0.5913745164871216, 1.037487268447876, -0.5644068121910095, 0.27834439277648926, 0.5286340117454529, 0.1541544795036316, 0.21498115360736847, -0.4819774031639099, -0.7910597920417786, -0.1295042335987091, -0.02149089239537716, 0.19237594306468964, -0.1821141391992569, -0.0264987051486969, 0.11090058088302612, 0.32055577635765076, -0.35268259048461914, 0.1300540715456009, -0.31510481238365173, -0.13552238047122955, 0.4034316837787628, -0.006077098194509745, 0.27392008900642395, -0.5627386569976807, 0.061275381594896317, -0.11357241123914719, -0.5672541856765747, -0.12707017362117767, 0.22132229804992676, 0.8112415075302124, -0.06786339730024338, 0.6442704796791077, -0.6832894682884216, 0.8952420353889465, 0.0036904215812683105, -0.14718317985534668, 0.4189758598804474, -0.5458531975746155, -0.013028835877776146, 0.2984805405139923, 0.7016062140464783, 0.20784269273281097, 0.13113655149936676, -0.38221418857574463, 0.00849587470293045, 0.10343464463949203, 0.162714883685112, -0.866952657699585, 0.010893512517213821, 0.15115965902805328, -0.27526918053627014, -0.3560662567615509, 0.10059823095798492, -0.5875946879386902, -0.035214439034461975, -0.039743103086948395, 0.25701722502708435, -0.4663468599319458, -0.2233358919620514, 0.03808889910578728, -0.21100817620754242, 0.08106563985347748, 0.2504614591598511, -1.0389225482940674, 0.03909014165401459, 0.6428520083427429, 1.2580915689468384, 0.09601029008626938, -0.17198078334331512, -0.5498846173286438, 0.1532726287841797, -0.6122891306877136, 0.7650359869003296, -0.43573200702667236, -0.5568766593933105, 0.015138411894440651, -0.06814771145582199, 0.28154510259628296, -0.25492462515830994, 0.7317672967910767, -0.11728940904140472, 0.3399990200996399, -0.38200613856315613, -0.5531704425811768, 0.005885842721909285, 0.22662490606307983, -0.5216007232666016, 0.7146053910255432, 0.36710023880004883, -0.9677529335021973, 0.48674148321151733, -0.6175729632377625, -0.5845791101455688, 0.30738306045532227, -0.27991899847984314, 0.06634197384119034, 0.23212425410747528, -0.0682053491473198, 0.5905332565307617, -0.18824562430381775, 0.34177908301353455, -0.37248456478118896, -0.4036054313182831, -0.11053113639354706, -0.546384871006012, 0.730798602104187, 0.39868828654289246, -0.016563231125473976, -0.3922507166862488, -0.8382081389427185, -0.098268061876297, -0.12499471753835678, -0.2613515853881836, -0.7011829614639282, 0.19680795073509216, 0.19636155664920807, 0.3158467710018158, 0.1935136318206787, -1.0275366306304932, 0.07469754666090012, -0.6672387719154358, 0.5874177813529968, 0.22601203620433807, -0.05955461785197258, 0.6954787969589233, -0.051634471863508224, 0.14423714578151703, 0.1909828633069992, -0.13735102117061615, 0.15056204795837402, -0.5373709797859192, -0.803955614566803, -0.18940460681915283, 0.650346040725708, 0.7021321058273315, -1.1682548522949219, 0.611876904964447, -0.4052875339984894, -0.6727064847946167, -0.48830467462539673, 0.3743872046470642, -0.05280829221010208, 1.0196360349655151, 0.2970826029777527, -0.2518347203731537, -0.2622183561325073, -0.9201966524124146, 0.43791109323501587, -0.286345511674881, -0.33573898673057556, 0.3952083885669708, 0.30709484219551086, -0.019177885726094246, 1.0906959772109985, -0.40715697407722473, -0.4667849540710449, -0.5362502932548523, 0.37652701139450073, 0.4724290668964386, 0.17063595354557037, 0.8769339323043823, -0.7502505779266357, -0.4916706085205078, -0.13371844589710236, -0.6387617588043213, -0.19795803725719452, 0.0008438246441073716, -0.2652600109577179, 0.25709113478660583, 0.1526433676481247, -0.16778774559497833, 0.34236082434654236, 0.18331320583820343, -0.2780342102050781, -0.11840657889842987, -0.24091900885105133, -0.03212181478738785, -1.2447025775909424, 0.0966971293091774, 0.17464330792427063, 0.207088902592659, -0.8441785573959351, -0.17118026316165924, 0.16575738787651062, -0.18274293839931488, -0.7155942916870117, 0.6993895173072815, -0.1200639009475708, 0.2808076739311218, -0.4360370934009552, 0.10803692787885666, -0.2013847827911377, 0.262981116771698, 0.7251377701759338, 0.6847776174545288, 0.7612186074256897, -0.5188778042793274, 0.3621489405632019, 0.49221283197402954, -0.45247921347618103, 0.6308544874191284, -0.31475627422332764, -0.3327796757221222, -0.19982673227787018, -0.18673166632652283, -0.6889121532440186, -0.08713594079017639, 0.41549965739250183, -0.2977513372898102, 0.3559652268886566, -0.2523731291294098, -0.37068700790405273, -0.2822076380252838, -0.3730693459510803, -0.189638152718544, 0.4513825476169586, -0.38087061047554016, 0.2295951098203659, 0.2809010446071625, -0.09414459764957428, -0.8422266840934753, -1.0807008743286133, 0.2523851990699768, -0.19922371208667755, -0.27738168835639954, 0.33682337403297424, 0.086222343146801, -0.1364051252603531, 0.3560609519481659, -0.07590631395578384, -0.6124560832977295, 0.3842078447341919, 0.23021231591701508, 0.22897154092788696, -0.26723212003707886, 0.35331475734710693, -0.0017338425386697054, -0.13936033844947815, -0.5457489490509033, 0.0427461676299572, 0.320178359746933, -0.05550244078040123, -0.272329181432724, -0.42491230368614197, 0.5439808368682861, 0.35224080085754395, -0.07356760650873184, 0.9393908977508545, 0.5172274708747864, -0.31045421957969666, -0.10611917823553085, -0.4225626587867737, -0.021896596997976303, -0.39044246077537537, 0.25485363602638245, -0.33763185143470764, -0.7719693183898926, 0.17470228672027588, 0.017955167219042778, 0.018379658460617065, 0.5544783473014832, 0.48674505949020386, -0.2785043716430664, 0.2912128269672394, 0.8916947841644287, -0.7145717144012451, 0.6631069779396057, -0.4109693765640259, 0.33161619305610657, -0.5480375289916992, 0.31095248460769653, -0.7253470420837402, -0.3082536458969116, -0.6008538603782654, -0.2167847752571106, -0.022170543670654297, 0.42835649847984314, 0.048157189041376114, 0.6908014416694641, -0.38309094309806824, 0.39314568042755127, 0.7031276822090149, -0.04517331346869469, 0.10284092277288437, 0.24265213310718536, 0.18629346787929535, -0.007314028684049845, -0.9909775853157043, -0.5774899125099182, 1.1692986488342285, -0.09815312922000885, 0.5351951718330383, 0.11101020127534866, 1.1709779500961304, 0.22385260462760925, 0.12272759526968002, -0.991466224193573, 0.29039815068244934, -0.7764797210693359, -0.4313083291053772, -0.6133708953857422, -0.5769162774085999, -0.6989116668701172, 0.1447409987449646, -0.27162542939186096, -0.7057850956916809, 0.5397940278053284, -0.09438696503639221, -0.5806438326835632, 0.4328359067440033, -0.8330210447311401, 0.8527994155883789, -0.29757168889045715, -0.33699220418930054, -0.23952366411685944, -0.41661208868026733, 0.1698753833770752, -0.3126365542411804, 0.2948305904865265, -0.30899378657341003, -0.07236605882644653, 0.6842798590660095, -0.6061199307441711, 0.7450657486915588, -0.1326366811990738, -0.05664511024951935, 0.4856155812740326, -0.11598487943410873, -0.15836183726787567, 0.1329931765794754, -0.5087944865226746, 0.6672807931900024, 0.28572651743888855, -0.47347593307495117, -0.6084038615226746, 0.6958644390106201, -0.6449935436248779, -0.3833455443382263, -0.514833390712738, -0.22277510166168213, -0.17151904106140137, 0.20279540121555328, 0.3098369836807251, 0.4790208637714386, -0.2857646048069, 0.25393393635749817, 0.32366639375686646, -0.20203372836112976, 0.6242725253105164, 0.9144963026046753, 0.4428943395614624, 0.13229498267173767, 1.3081731796264648, 0.4900873005390167, -0.0760214775800705, 0.561984658241272, 0.131476491689682, -0.15263445675373077, -0.566048800945282, -0.5233851075172424, 0.067222960293293, -0.5200178027153015, -0.2769247889518738, -0.36927324533462524, -0.30472058057785034, -0.4086467921733856, -0.3131890594959259, -0.3614041805267334, -0.6110234260559082, -0.6218426823616028, 0.1738322675228119, 0.3926314115524292, 0.3377607464790344, -0.5539105534553528, 0.25295335054397583, -0.8051315546035767, 0.6393263339996338, 0.2333533763885498, 0.5532317757606506, -0.23028206825256348, -0.5784311890602112, -0.05922439321875572, 0.2203727513551712, -0.10978462547063828, -0.9487345814704895, 0.3559302091598511, 0.6349895000457764, 0.5782608389854431, 0.6254585981369019, 0.4911172091960907, 0.5064873099327087, -0.6325602531433105, 0.6429280042648315, 0.27166280150413513, -1.0856202840805054, 0.897760808467865, 0.13366438448429108, 0.02832762338221073, 0.8632607460021973, 0.5231955647468567, -1.0710091590881348, -0.3817364275455475, -0.5031220316886902, -0.8406369686126709, 0.9774278998374939, 0.19546376168727875, 0.4606754779815674, -0.38060832023620605, 0.4708358347415924, -0.12496014684438705, 0.29605889320373535, -0.25239139795303345, -0.1846475899219513, -0.40933260321617126, -0.4178764820098877, -0.2756631374359131, -0.38450106978416443, 0.22363881766796112, -0.2219632863998413, 0.7009782791137695, -0.2435915768146515, -0.011298464611172676, 0.1242680549621582, -0.29536792635917664, -0.04366463050246239, 0.5468643307685852, 0.3623489737510681, 0.4807845950126648, -0.5099232196807861, 0.08569416403770447, 0.2714637815952301, -0.3088162839412689, 0.22288420796394348, -0.052948109805583954, -0.39118242263793945, 0.3914453089237213, 0.4553997814655304, 0.5467280745506287, 0.16794271767139435, -0.8102839589118958, 0.7183744311332703, -0.04902215674519539, -0.29416176676750183, 0.15994371473789215, 0.029916927218437195, 0.024227093905210495, -0.04419500753283501, 0.026517020538449287, -0.25711700320243835, 0.1510014533996582, -0.6298168897628784, 0.3243124783039093, 0.30158060789108276, -0.43511533737182617, 0.03276180475950241, 0.17608439922332764, 0.3488434851169586, -0.0869838297367096, 0.8219988942146301, -0.39219585061073303, -0.2862470746040344, 0.4070403575897217, -0.012801425531506538, 0.5290187001228333, -0.03311463072896004, 0.6162415742874146, 0.42272695899009705, 0.244370698928833, -0.1206931546330452, 0.2820143699645996, -0.34612321853637695, -1.0987962484359741, -0.3813077211380005, -0.6945733428001404, -0.5539824962615967, 0.2202683538198471, -0.774304211139679, 0.33572879433631897, -0.3138096332550049, 0.0036592769902199507, 0.24860355257987976, 0.03786426782608032, -0.5301395654678345, -0.09798410534858704, 0.5357120633125305, 1.067840337753296, -1.0268771648406982, 1.2266649007797241, 0.5136862397193909, -0.6384785175323486, -0.27257418632507324, -0.0939105749130249, -0.15040922164916992, -0.564950704574585, 0.9130512475967407, -0.14455421268939972, 0.03198329359292984, -0.27916181087493896, -0.4632340669631958, -0.9142486453056335, 0.7294713258743286, 0.2728257477283478, -0.7906274795532227, 0.1724747121334076, 0.2611863911151886, 0.5797016024589539, 0.06457186490297318, 0.022002825513482094, 0.4198417067527771, 0.3167276382446289, 0.29112401604652405, -0.812863826751709, -0.5157468914985657, -0.14903052151203156, 0.06830976903438568, 0.14714550971984863, -0.36614614725112915, 0.6715901494026184, -0.02134202979505062, -0.37945884466171265, 0.0802280455827713, 0.5754194259643555, -0.287634015083313, 0.0413474477827549, 0.3625074625015259, 0.6900314688682556, 0.6456011533737183, -0.27792346477508545, 0.8881388306617737, -0.5993649363517761, 0.49932974576950073, 1.1521258354187012, -0.7103901505470276, 1.112876296043396, 0.605302095413208, 0.009375905618071556, 0.15331172943115234, 0.656548261642456, -0.26159727573394775, 1.0043306350708008, 0.17376790940761566, -0.3033592402935028, -0.36508819460868835, -0.39444500207901, -0.1790272295475006, 0.59788578748703, 0.46949490904808044, 0.11828460544347763, -0.8982572555541992, 0.14280518889427185, -0.2528975009918213, 0.06206917017698288, -0.26118096709251404, 0.8189023733139038, -0.19144685566425323, -0.007739447057247162, 0.5453658103942871, 0.28036433458328247, 1.0237177610397339, -0.6219326853752136, 0.023323845118284225, -0.33014747500419617, -0.08389144390821457, 0.06358390301465988, -0.9113842844963074, 0.5184052586555481, 0.4122743606567383, -0.25521355867385864, -0.32461658120155334, 0.6085813641548157, -0.5630011558532715, -0.8277016878128052, 0.14891888201236725, 0.6907187104225159, 0.2828681170940399, 0.06265836209058762, -0.6133499145507812, -0.5300194025039673, -0.22089004516601562, 0.13653622567653656, 0.29986828565597534, 0.6699594855308533, 0.08458089828491211, 0.5695340037345886, 0.2561722993850708, 0.3813687562942505, -0.3195233643054962, 0.0172866340726614, 0.6349270939826965, -0.6110861301422119, -0.4902855455875397, -0.7077847123146057, -0.12150922417640686, -0.035768602043390274, -0.29039686918258667, 0.5528116822242737, 0.527661919593811, 1.0567717552185059, 0.12273938208818436, 0.9933395385742188, -0.3317924737930298, 0.7916080951690674, -0.2525409460067749, 0.9480674862861633, -0.6959657669067383, 0.01022034976631403, -0.23018409311771393, -0.5324273705482483, -0.35816478729248047, 0.8367120027542114, -0.3891497850418091, -0.5026669502258301, 0.421747624874115, 0.5682658553123474, -0.18641705811023712, -0.20959526300430298, 0.6205189228057861, -0.1785883605480194, -0.1011667549610138, 0.5726035237312317, 0.8025190234184265, -0.13838481903076172, 0.4491257667541504, -0.8963046669960022, -0.09078652411699295, 0.0021353100892156363, -0.8408055901527405, -0.7600142359733582, -0.6512358784675598, -0.4402124881744385, 0.05682920292019844, 0.013438168913125992, 0.8475639820098877, 0.6287599205970764, -1.2514773607254028, -0.2786840796470642, 0.014851035550236702, 0.25845685601234436, 0.13978154957294464, -0.17232416570186615, 0.3995441794395447, -0.5035741329193115, -0.5995690226554871, 0.3703998625278473, 0.23811396956443787, 0.08667405694723129, -0.04867997020483017, 0.16599319875240326, -0.3524707853794098, -0.1361781805753708, 0.502366304397583, 0.4194504916667938, -0.8336424231529236, -0.284146249294281, -0.18268950283527374, -0.08374546468257904, 0.06072850897908211, 0.7499175071716309, -0.8050387501716614, 0.3403225541114807, 0.4279772937297821, 0.6886150240898132, 0.08917620033025742, -0.3782868981361389, 0.20747298002243042, -0.8702117204666138, 0.6159027814865112, 0.08713918179273605, 0.5536504983901978, 0.22432714700698853, -0.21085423231124878, 0.5452176928520203, 0.37352466583251953, 0.27625367045402527, -0.7109482288360596, 0.01430220901966095, -0.8593155741691589, -0.7032185196876526, 0.9118952751159668, -0.13296076655387878, -0.2967080771923065, -0.16140393912792206, -0.04918961599469185, 0.2837609350681305, -0.4045078456401825, 0.9720997214317322, 1.033989429473877, 0.2615237832069397, -0.008428271859884262, -0.5980414748191833, 0.23384235799312592, 0.1804303526878357, -0.6676834225654602, 0.10685206204652786, 0.3101828694343567, 0.337606817483902, 0.42591679096221924, 0.5885142683982849, 0.28352099657058716, 0.04441968351602554, -0.19799020886421204, 0.11571326851844788, 0.0698828473687172, -0.25756770372390747, -0.5468159317970276, 0.2471923530101776, -0.13435515761375427, -0.37166649103164673 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08672v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08672v1
Taxonomy and Analysis of Sensitive User Queries in Generative AI Search
2024-04-05T05:14:46
2024-04-05T05:14:46
Hwiyeol Jo, Taiwoo Park, Nayoung Choi, Changbong Kim, Ohjoon Kwon, Donghyeon Jeon, Hyunwoo Lee, Eui-Hyeon Lee, Kyoungho Shin, Sun Suk Lim, Kyungmi Kim, Jihye Lee, Sun Kim
cs.IR
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
Although there has been a growing interest among industries to integrate generative LLMs into their services, limited experiences and scarcity of resources acts as a barrier in launching and servicing large-scale LLM-based conversational services. In this paper, we share our experiences in developing and operating generative AI models within a national-scale search engine, with a specific focus on the sensitiveness of user queries. We propose a taxonomy for sensitive search queries, outline our approaches, and present a comprehensive analysis report on sensitive queries from actual users.
[ -0.4269014596939087, -0.911123514175415, 0.2685305178165436, 0.12987743318080902, 0.2703380286693573, 0.053152985870838165, 0.05077278986573219, -0.7337742447853088, 0.1064128428697586, 0.6151185631752014, -0.7318987846374512, -0.3653469681739807, -0.36349934339523315, 0.2090047001838684, -0.5469376444816589, 0.580362856388092, 0.322541207075119, -0.4499994218349457, -0.3726164400577545, -0.3606962263584137, -0.27247950434684753, -0.9328016638755798, -0.7830169200897217, 0.30767130851745605, 0.5477702617645264, 0.1959584653377533, 0.8044971823692322, 0.12316979467868805, 0.9676479697227478, 0.27356603741645813, -0.3308154046535492, -0.10010485351085663, -0.37387144565582275, 0.7293046116828918, -0.33367571234703064, -0.8498635292053223, -0.25033998489379883, -0.1640414446592331, 0.5256045460700989, 0.6080062389373779, -0.29460176825523376, 0.07353855669498444, -0.16512832045555115, 0.35599663853645325, -0.9228060841560364, -0.11268806457519531, -0.8908100724220276, 0.31736457347869873, -0.3768848180770874, -0.09094122052192688, -0.39001956582069397, -0.17794294655323029, 0.33854371309280396, -0.5209154486656189, 0.552797257900238, -0.010798496194183826, 0.4458327889442444, 0.39521166682243347, -0.5997064113616943, -0.5139087438583374, -0.7456348538398743, 0.8100601434707642, -0.5720254182815552, 0.09954718500375748, 0.5302686095237732, 0.29208827018737793, 0.043187178671360016, -0.974807620048523, -0.3230404853820801, -0.10265936702489853, -0.14138957858085632, 0.014583462849259377, -0.5174993276596069, 0.061391331255435944, 0.35831961035728455, 0.5235095620155334, -0.6590099930763245, 0.591697633266449, -0.15685749053955078, -0.2108493447303772, 0.8685452938079834, 0.6131861805915833, 0.44677916169166565, -0.14623241126537323, -0.46265655755996704, 0.272459477186203, -0.6195641160011292, -0.1783066689968109, 0.27824464440345764, 0.39712196588516235, 0.03688379377126694, 0.5721281170845032, -0.43161553144454956, 0.837575376033783, -0.2942853271961212, 0.18036894500255585, -0.13323821127414703, -0.2813520133495331, 0.0031813220120966434, -0.36702439188957214, 0.7907129526138306, 0.16560624539852142, 0.2650242745876312, -0.2723516523838043, -0.4346890449523926, -0.042154643684625626, 0.5864952802658081, -0.7445749044418335, 0.19510063529014587, 0.06959594786167145, -0.39423051476478577, -0.31607988476753235, -0.21608935296535492, -0.6759176850318909, -0.5731934309005737, 0.11886023730039597, 0.11595677584409714, -0.049539245665073395, -0.3159589171409607, -0.2570752501487732, 0.016099706292152405, 0.36142703890800476, -0.03239923715591431, -1.2283432483673096, 0.34535911679267883, 0.6612316966056824, 0.8059417009353638, -0.13648109138011932, 0.00294585176743567, -0.21769027411937714, -0.017350511625409126, 0.1050909087061882, 0.8328655362129211, -0.7987188696861267, -0.9732627272605896, 0.43388333916664124, -0.3639812469482422, -0.28299379348754883, -0.9707860946655273, 0.4148162603378296, -1.129442572593689, 0.04143735021352768, -0.28317221999168396, -0.4209091365337372, 0.037896886467933655, 0.30553609132766724, -0.5816124677658081, 0.8772516250610352, 0.4931022524833679, -0.7162618637084961, 0.30963489413261414, -0.9007142186164856, -0.3960030674934387, 0.67535400390625, -0.2959651052951813, -0.14197100698947906, 0.18055152893066406, 0.15618905425071716, 0.3551352322101593, -0.4303460121154785, 0.04126498103141785, -0.14871296286582947, -0.22110863029956818, 0.5597606897354126, -0.31271490454673767, 0.8953429460525513, 0.508926272392273, -0.17010870575904846, 0.3432598114013672, -0.34589192271232605, -0.019158201292157173, 0.18431036174297333, -0.2615360617637634, -0.37246599793434143, 0.08094963431358337, 0.1906195729970932, -0.08500805497169495, 0.3344193398952484, -0.09725576639175415, 0.3038021922111511, -0.5186966061592102, 0.7110695242881775, 0.7268492579460144, 0.11026769876480103, 0.17647674679756165, -0.19396355748176575, 1.0082287788391113, -0.12589405477046967, 0.4006176292896271, 0.00103952013887465, -0.618684709072113, -0.6151065230369568, 0.04440886899828911, 0.030748678371310234, 0.5400533080101013, -0.6501894593238831, 0.3124491572380066, -0.2419363111257553, -0.25613903999328613, -0.4906466603279114, 0.1555473655462265, 0.28898942470550537, 0.5164186358451843, 0.10172487795352936, -0.5056605339050293, -0.2107626050710678, -1.0912432670593262, -0.159567728638649, -0.48200052976608276, -0.33394891023635864, 1.0538132190704346, 0.34856531023979187, -0.5017836093902588, 0.9032157063484192, -0.658746600151062, -0.4093121290206909, 0.14525476098060608, 0.29960858821868896, -0.12661677598953247, 0.07417351752519608, 0.6422850489616394, -1.2972285747528076, -0.5056660771369934, -0.22679950296878815, -0.8182646036148071, -0.1783711016178131, 0.27744626998901367, -0.1412172168493271, 0.24650681018829346, 0.509143590927124, -0.7224299907684326, 0.3878955543041229, 0.23564335703849792, -0.26468709111213684, 0.4576527178287506, 0.2588416039943695, -0.08602065593004227, -1.073492407798767, 0.2504401206970215, 0.1967897117137909, 0.01837545819580555, -0.7142109274864197, 0.7456973195075989, -0.12676937878131866, -0.3091293275356293, -0.6278489828109741, 0.42759260535240173, -0.37825241684913635, -0.19030801951885223, -0.12687331438064575, 0.06654247641563416, -0.3279317617416382, 0.197853222489357, -0.041412148624658585, 1.3744595050811768, 0.4099554717540741, -0.8198034167289734, 0.45678094029426575, 0.524298906326294, -0.348565936088562, 0.619391679763794, -0.5438164472579956, 0.40938228368759155, 0.11566830426454544, -0.3133027255535126, -0.7059333920478821, -0.49522098898887634, 0.09557854384183884, -0.38111934065818787, 0.15262818336486816, -0.2139560878276825, -0.542916476726532, -0.4315424859523773, -0.15218335390090942, 0.7922567129135132, 0.35368284583091736, -0.3806576132774353, 0.4568639397621155, 0.5807596445083618, -0.4349935054779053, -0.33235883712768555, -0.4243382215499878, 0.3680623173713684, -0.5632447600364685, -0.7997366189956665, 0.39243069291114807, -0.1438591033220291, -0.37987610697746277, 0.04465857148170471, 0.09545764327049255, -0.37733834981918335, 0.7811471223831177, 0.03554888814687729, 0.019792351871728897, -0.3329174816608429, -0.039993662387132645, -0.4010840356349945, 0.04801248759031296, 0.2794501781463623, 0.23222030699253082, 0.619641125202179, -0.08390078693628311, -0.4558548331260681, -0.39836302399635315, 0.5119627118110657, 0.4737017750740051, -0.32630863785743713, 0.6513478755950928, 0.4336296021938324, -0.4256087839603424, -0.19412633776664734, -0.43308427929878235, -0.2670772075653076, -0.5097882151603699, 0.2730850577354431, -0.22040440142154694, -1.3399310111999512, 0.9283124208450317, 0.04618372768163681, -0.39349430799484253, 0.7356898188591003, 0.7432229518890381, -0.2022794932126999, 1.146108865737915, 0.813068687915802, -0.3539328873157501, 0.3513617217540741, -0.0599273256957531, 0.1942581683397293, -0.9733408093452454, -0.3682800829410553, -0.7872934341430664, -0.1962839812040329, -1.007021427154541, -0.09874124825000763, 0.6744313836097717, -0.3170894384384155, -0.2974117696285248, -0.08918267488479614, -0.6467276811599731, 0.18396836519241333, 0.7229138612747192, -0.028947822749614716, 0.09652888774871826, -0.09807253628969193, 0.2729950547218323, -0.13660648465156555, -0.5638710260391235, -0.4163288176059723, 0.9423691630363464, -0.02931336499750614, 0.9697033762931824, 0.6320726275444031, 0.11580169945955276, 0.6036129593849182, 0.45961204171180725, -1.0189626216888428, 0.40893179178237915, -0.1654440462589264, -1.136088252067566, -0.37698620557785034, -0.5387868285179138, -1.1066327095031738, -0.04273912310600281, -0.033407822251319885, -1.0210248231887817, 0.12703493237495422, -0.1338615119457245, -0.5226365923881531, 0.2345559298992157, -0.5409955382347107, 0.659389317035675, -0.3638121485710144, -0.19533316791057587, -0.014926948584616184, -0.7218133807182312, 0.33302757143974304, -0.08517599105834961, -0.15637560188770294, -0.18553426861763, -0.1120920404791832, 0.7246975898742676, -0.02003081515431404, 1.0310745239257812, -0.17920958995819092, -0.029114089906215668, 0.40289026498794556, 0.2472354769706726, 0.2611507475376129, 0.1496642380952835, -0.24471966922283173, 0.041957415640354156, -0.270108163356781, -0.3294941186904907, -0.48555564880371094, 0.7323903441429138, -0.6455690860748291, -1.029607892036438, -0.3962235152721405, -0.5846031904220581, -0.46401333808898926, 0.28315988183021545, 0.3135259747505188, -0.07567926496267319, -0.3823917806148529, 0.21655116975307465, 0.9183578491210938, -0.33393898606300354, 0.20265202224254608, 0.5576629638671875, 0.03022637963294983, 0.0929066613316536, 0.5527154207229614, 0.09365002810955048, 0.007808248046785593, 0.3936237096786499, -0.014417273923754692, -0.3469776213169098, -0.6606016159057617, -0.1350216567516327, -0.11638074368238449, -0.42054125666618347, -0.4318901002407074, -0.44717660546302795, -0.45966678857803345, -0.4164468050003052, -0.016875144094228745, -0.006478696130216122, -0.054595302790403366, -0.7881447076797485, 0.018960312008857727, 0.3902624249458313, 0.46991410851478577, 0.4058097302913666, 0.4946534037590027, -0.5253482460975647, 0.4325697720050812, 0.49065327644348145, 0.5583436489105225, -0.07417397201061249, -0.5632812976837158, -0.03584848344326019, -0.20560328662395477, -0.4388620853424072, -0.6968767046928406, 0.46057385206222534, 0.3833906650543213, 0.696135401725769, 0.6060097217559814, 0.3480198085308075, 0.2560989558696747, 0.08721055090427399, 1.0175881385803223, -0.07354547828435898, -0.5826704502105713, 0.8833613395690918, -0.4607197642326355, 0.09350521862506866, 0.5870102047920227, 0.7908725142478943, -0.668868899345398, -0.15927526354789734, -0.3964441418647766, -1.2304623126983643, 0.7795137763023376, 0.26050886511802673, 0.8465773463249207, 0.015631508082151413, 0.6014775037765503, -0.008970203809440136, 0.12042085081338882, -0.34861525893211365, -0.340938538312912, 0.24284876883029938, 0.1096777692437172, 0.1917380541563034, -0.8170873522758484, -0.28868240118026733, 0.08337846398353577, 0.3016025424003601, -0.18012072145938873, 0.32424047589302063, 0.00831192173063755, -0.16819621622562408, 0.18483655154705048, 0.28291136026382446, 0.22297072410583496, 0.5809071660041809, -0.2902199923992157, -0.016416430473327637, 0.03316371515393257, -0.3431737720966339, -0.06942496448755264, 0.1469092220067978, -0.36254942417144775, -0.5175557136535645, 0.3939563035964966, 0.5994612574577332, 0.07196997851133347, -0.6928158402442932, 0.49531376361846924, -0.2997905910015106, 0.001621236908249557, -0.41398972272872925, 0.27772951126098633, -0.0044920011423528194, -0.07497534900903702, 0.41778725385665894, -0.3644644320011139, 0.6175991296768188, -0.43427735567092896, -0.027484020218253136, 0.6340571641921997, -0.3939816951751709, -0.28734859824180603, 0.9338989853858948, 0.468962162733078, -0.4971352517604828, 1.3087384700775146, -0.006719434168189764, -0.5305429697036743, 0.6735689043998718, 0.5476470589637756, 1.1905122995376587, -0.42596572637557983, -0.02914653718471527, 0.013180982321500778, 0.21174472570419312, 0.5165929198265076, 0.39612025022506714, -0.2574385404586792, -0.9112941026687622, 0.04765533283352852, -0.5183243751525879, -0.7312800884246826, 0.21334809064865112, -1.115463137626648, -0.18371504545211792, -0.4970986843109131, -0.7375928163528442, 0.24532859027385712, -0.10248396545648575, -0.7589903473854065, 0.03889033570885658, 0.03791703283786774, 0.8343641757965088, -0.6351547837257385, 0.07259559631347656, 0.779026448726654, -0.598533034324646, -0.1928214132785797, 0.08898971229791641, -0.016069378703832626, -1.108927607536316, 0.6491607427597046, -0.1343107670545578, -0.0023399884812533855, -0.13216814398765564, -0.6147052049636841, -0.6904934048652649, 0.9407027959823608, 0.2617913782596588, -0.2048899382352829, 0.1363092064857483, 0.4316626191139221, 0.7242263555526733, -0.08697457611560822, 0.16285088658332825, 0.6832799315452576, 0.11861186474561691, -0.15336762368679047, -0.8321235179901123, -0.021803921088576317, -0.3406677842140198, 0.34142574667930603, -0.05965239554643631, -1.0412778854370117, 0.5614357590675354, 0.08786293119192123, -0.4493268132209778, 0.1885005384683609, 0.46727389097213745, -0.10170087218284607, 0.48216667771339417, 0.22886738181114197, 0.5515568852424622, 0.7374852299690247, -0.07870371639728546, 1.2806944847106934, -0.21770904958248138, 0.2796180546283722, 0.7928380966186523, -0.5347915291786194, 0.7326337099075317, 0.26036348938941956, -0.5077205300331116, 0.09081541001796722, 0.7093283534049988, -0.00273271300829947, 0.3165627717971802, 0.3503734767436981, -0.8799208998680115, -0.1743578314781189, -0.6664493083953857, -0.37718504667282104, 0.7257054448127747, 0.6673458218574524, -0.33422839641571045, -0.05029270425438881, -0.10605336725711823, -0.12309612333774567, 0.21504998207092285, -0.20305201411247253, 1.1980582475662231, 0.13592860102653503, -0.3415275812149048, 0.3260999321937561, 0.17407768964767456, 0.8882009983062744, -0.32805365324020386, 0.35001975297927856, -0.6514015793800354, -0.34762153029441833, -0.2870752215385437, -0.7929511070251465, 0.5475159883499146, 0.3359062671661377, -0.35047587752342224, -0.07557064294815063, 0.7875569462776184, 0.4009690284729004, -0.4774600565433502, 0.3471135199069977, 0.5669165253639221, 0.10215841978788376, -0.2858060896396637, -0.7099508047103882, -0.0126381516456604, -0.2230341136455536, -0.41409897804260254, 0.41054633259773254, 0.19948682188987732, -0.32441654801368713, 1.0134539604187012, 0.408732533454895, -0.19251742959022522, 0.0782398208975792, 0.37191444635391235, 0.9015225172042847, -0.8270164728164673, -0.25521618127822876, -0.6078075766563416, 0.14431817829608917, 0.20443207025527954, -0.3773438632488251, 0.46722412109375, 0.6233956217765808, 0.7839780449867249, 0.1153535395860672, 1.0334620475769043, -0.010869480669498444, 0.23231500387191772, -0.38779014348983765, 0.9437482953071594, -0.45376938581466675, 0.4073721766471863, 0.17133034765720367, -0.8174443244934082, -0.5387402176856995, 0.25866562128067017, -0.25225526094436646, 0.2572288513183594, -0.07892236113548279, 1.070700764656067, -0.05685215815901756, -0.15065479278564453, 0.37055376172065735, 0.09591588377952576, 0.4092999994754791, 0.34894970059394836, 1.2610260248184204, -0.0015670609427616, 0.3740116357803345, -0.1651182770729065, -0.04572170600295067, -0.5310004353523254, -0.5535966157913208, -0.40745633840560913, -0.5698135495185852, -0.2727595865726471, 0.011191362515091896, 0.027740279212594032, 0.294979453086853, 0.6239618062973022, -0.879118800163269, -0.08903947472572327, 0.0038453699089586735, 0.20916470885276794, 0.2303491085767746, -0.3109840154647827, 0.17364704608917236, -0.4521181285381317, -0.7128319144248962, 0.2967129945755005, 0.06597641855478287, -0.03888341784477234, -0.37447336316108704, 0.284339040517807, -0.016642896458506584, 0.07340866327285767, 0.5530898571014404, 0.5068625211715698, -0.5364773869514465, -0.13964134454727173, 0.12393128126859665, -0.21876712143421173, 0.02651366963982582, 0.9490729570388794, -0.5381343364715576, 0.6821286678314209, 0.20379193127155304, 0.7470638751983643, 0.5632318258285522, 0.2505330443382263, 0.22908061742782593, -0.8831911683082581, 0.004356931895017624, 0.745692789554596, 0.01256871223449707, 0.4031173586845398, -0.7870125770568848, 0.5594081282615662, 0.14245349168777466, -0.5158491134643555, -0.8526288866996765, 0.4527847170829773, -0.9264715313911438, -0.1424483358860016, 1.0768967866897583, -0.09856816381216049, 0.24885901808738708, 0.013208601623773575, 0.071584552526474, 0.012267052195966244, -0.16818717122077942, 1.0732698440551758, 0.5023866295814514, -0.4880663752555847, 0.15307925641536713, -0.5030387043952942, 0.30805665254592896, 0.26002392172813416, -0.657240629196167, 0.0546705387532711, 0.4920262098312378, 0.09304488450288773, 0.018304146826267242, 0.6665440201759338, -0.12934383749961853, 0.1910238415002823, -0.0732436254620552, -0.09513546526432037, 0.2539522349834442, -0.033673956990242004, -0.4096776843070984, 0.3590332269668579, 0.6633797883987427, 0.09294051676988602 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03887v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03887v3
SAAS: Solving Ability Amplification Strategy for Enhanced Mathematical Reasoning in Large Language Models
2024-04-05T04:25:47
2024-04-24T15:17:17
Hyeonwoo Kim, Gyoungjin Gim, Yungi Kim, Jihoo Kim, Byungju Kim, Wonseok Lee, Chanjun Park
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
This study presents a novel learning approach designed to enhance both mathematical reasoning and problem-solving abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). We focus on integrating the Chain-of-Thought (CoT) and the Program-of-Thought (PoT) learning, hypothesizing that prioritizing the learning of mathematical reasoning ability is helpful for the amplification of problem-solving ability. Thus, the initial learning with CoT is essential for solving challenging mathematical problems. To this end, we propose a sequential learning approach, named SAAS (Solving Ability Amplification Strategy), which strategically transitions from CoT learning to PoT learning. Our empirical study, involving an extensive performance comparison using several benchmarks, demonstrates that our SAAS achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance. The results underscore the effectiveness of our sequential learning approach, marking a significant advancement in the field of mathematical reasoning in LLMs.
[ -0.3897302448749542, -0.8713014125823975, 0.706544041633606, 0.6435962319374084, -0.5090582370758057, 0.5049891471862793, -0.1261579990386963, -0.1933504194021225, 0.24288734793663025, 0.39638563990592957, -0.5802858471870422, -0.23075251281261444, -0.680169403553009, 0.20696625113487244, -0.28540438413619995, 0.6675353646278381, -0.07155454158782959, 0.4756423234939575, -0.3901187479496002, 0.1717539131641388, -0.5860338807106018, -0.5531427264213562, -0.9283581376075745, -0.25523412227630615, 0.4160052239894867, 0.5534147024154663, 0.6090733408927917, 0.5996431708335876, 0.5532086491584778, 0.2803439497947693, -0.11956819146871567, 0.3911380171775818, -0.3779502809047699, 0.4794977307319641, -0.34513962268829346, -0.7479397058486938, -0.257234662771225, -0.5409757494926453, 0.7618953585624695, 0.6629996299743652, -0.39066457748413086, 0.20298556983470917, -0.26173245906829834, 0.8901851177215576, -0.5865938663482666, 0.15507934987545013, -0.7149192690849304, -0.13087745010852814, -0.030402494594454765, -0.3194212019443512, -0.5558105707168579, -0.35704123973846436, 0.2466789335012436, -0.5394623875617981, -0.05460858717560768, -0.16066871583461761, 0.4133158326148987, 0.3965177834033966, -0.05080026388168335, -0.49921658635139465, -0.8905856013298035, 0.8191921710968018, -0.42610135674476624, 0.2498713582754135, 0.17948263883590698, 0.5491436123847961, -0.1579323709011078, -0.5981528759002686, -0.4668092131614685, -0.012110299430787563, 0.3864258825778961, -0.18204756081104279, 0.10346507281064987, -0.28733372688293457, 0.35205674171447754, 0.32485026121139526, -0.36162394285202026, -0.08259440958499908, -0.5684363842010498, 0.06593926250934601, 1.077655553817749, 0.05018394812941551, 0.18847160041332245, 0.27691105008125305, -0.40586474537849426, -0.0599701851606369, -0.8321564793586731, 0.004275694023817778, -0.04882664605975151, 0.440828800201416, 0.12924030423164368, 0.46746012568473816, 0.16581028699874878, 0.4668041169643402, -0.4146134555339813, -0.27024731040000916, 0.3097513020038605, -0.054647136479616165, -0.2720330059528351, 0.13855856657028198, 0.3734847903251648, -0.7965249419212341, 0.2334243804216385, -0.0858369767665863, -0.40006011724472046, 0.28586581349372864, 0.29116567969322205, -0.4637588560581207, -0.0024627691600471735, 0.21054436266422272, 0.0009390493505634367, -0.17401641607284546, -0.08698787540197372, -0.7108015418052673, -0.3645739257335663, -0.4927944839000702, 0.658157467842102, -0.35034412145614624, -0.2644033133983612, 0.15694725513458252, 0.22383025288581848, 0.006945331580936909, 0.18314848840236664, -0.8537678718566895, 0.6230170130729675, 0.951479971408844, 1.0157448053359985, -0.14238356053829193, -0.40390902757644653, -0.8508450984954834, 0.03550070524215698, -0.6339571475982666, 0.7445064783096313, -0.5766427516937256, -0.42421871423721313, -0.09475095570087433, -0.48958486318588257, 0.07229641079902649, -0.5612117052078247, 0.4724828600883484, -0.8568160533905029, -0.32028186321258545, -0.5081812143325806, -0.5188003778457642, -0.028658924624323845, -0.2947482466697693, -0.5321456789970398, 1.0556389093399048, -0.06746480613946915, -0.1253034621477127, 0.10161709040403366, -0.907286524772644, -0.6656339168548584, 0.2860594689846039, -0.37048014998435974, -0.44738027453422546, 0.19199441373348236, 0.28980210423469543, 0.2285533845424652, -0.3750029504299164, 0.30269813537597656, -0.09326626360416412, -0.4793381690979004, 0.351840078830719, -0.13155078887939453, 0.6022763252258301, 0.41462039947509766, -0.4208070635795593, 0.4280932545661926, -0.7000358700752258, 0.02973044104874134, 0.5821093320846558, 0.23641881346702576, -0.23069308698177338, 0.05920972302556038, -0.5631721019744873, 0.38889431953430176, 0.29172495007514954, -0.1811159998178482, 0.3135623335838318, -0.5034883618354797, 0.5095658898353577, 1.004942774772644, 0.11410833895206451, 0.42523571848869324, -0.09235692024230957, 0.6459594368934631, -0.026091111823916435, 0.23247408866882324, -0.2014082968235016, -0.6038041710853577, -0.9666215181350708, -0.3452921211719513, 0.3174847364425659, 0.46440809965133667, -0.8264285922050476, 0.27602332830429077, -0.007640024647116661, -0.49635758996009827, -0.43706977367401123, 0.40839436650276184, 0.5891923904418945, 0.17093001306056976, 0.4710097014904022, -0.197299987077713, -0.6260185241699219, -0.6754967570304871, -0.17932240664958954, 0.12927758693695068, 0.15484246611595154, 0.3005724847316742, 0.5884621739387512, -0.03391335532069206, 0.708429217338562, -0.8052222728729248, -0.39444050192832947, -0.30591699481010437, 0.12089623510837555, 0.09565643966197968, 0.16604384779930115, 0.2886323034763336, -0.9827355742454529, -0.39695101976394653, -0.22422386705875397, -0.6870255470275879, -0.11730936914682388, 0.014471514150500298, -0.1999821960926056, 0.2060515135526657, 0.3046708405017853, -0.33618780970573425, 0.4978558123111725, 0.24779058992862701, -0.30170363187789917, 0.6468901038169861, -0.21931937336921692, -0.0976487398147583, -0.8908628821372986, -0.31044667959213257, 0.06198986992239952, 0.07102926820516586, -0.48485180735588074, 0.2898896634578705, -0.17074821889400482, -0.37484973669052124, -0.30584102869033813, 0.1980343461036682, -0.43228235840797424, -0.6940891742706299, -0.3988269567489624, 0.35768958926200867, -0.19919365644454956, 0.4991292655467987, 0.03208696469664574, 1.3395729064941406, 0.8615630865097046, -0.8081908822059631, 0.3014555275440216, 0.16548337042331696, -0.44056054949760437, 0.1457158625125885, -0.6746325492858887, 0.2791447937488556, -0.010176552459597588, 0.15534645318984985, -1.0140300989151, 0.08869823068380356, -0.31597045063972473, -0.38877832889556885, -0.15939031541347504, 0.17834489047527313, -0.5167848467826843, -0.331299751996994, 0.17217443883419037, 0.5350396037101746, 0.4362473487854004, -0.5682408213615417, 0.9337064027786255, 0.332222044467926, -0.6606720089912415, -0.5948244333267212, -0.5686110854148865, -0.03472587466239929, -0.0003291625762358308, -0.4837719202041626, 0.3166346251964569, 0.1217072606086731, -0.2569788992404938, -0.14053975045681, -0.18129654228687286, 0.015860427170991898, 0.05314047634601593, -0.0402165912091732, 0.39662835001945496, -0.14877650141716003, 0.5288472771644592, 0.20020069181919098, -0.32023781538009644, 0.12532904744148254, -0.3293587863445282, 0.9771164655685425, -0.48001882433891296, -0.4184347689151764, -0.2954353392124176, 0.43006768822669983, 0.766823410987854, -0.7861698269844055, 0.9630967378616333, 0.03931889310479164, -0.45431649684906006, -0.40135127305984497, -0.4292016625404358, -0.19087789952754974, -0.4806070625782013, 0.26548829674720764, -0.7478777766227722, -0.4814654290676117, 0.689321756362915, -0.3163006901741028, 0.15462878346443176, 0.2273637354373932, 0.5178458094596863, 0.1088942214846611, 1.1505898237228394, 0.444242924451828, 0.1400679051876068, 0.46784499287605286, -0.6728554368019104, 0.4410589933395386, -0.6930824518203735, -0.5474023222923279, -0.5134037137031555, -0.1773904711008072, 0.056783925741910934, -0.5234848260879517, 0.3889075815677643, 0.22712020576000214, -0.580674946308136, 0.1375991851091385, -0.40654295682907104, 0.5647653937339783, 0.4073954224586487, 0.2328043431043625, 0.4807915687561035, 0.11340004205703735, -0.3464513123035431, 0.0416821651160717, -0.7063552141189575, -0.3837006390094757, 1.1575630903244019, 0.21413573622703552, 0.4127422273159027, 0.47867196798324585, 0.7546254396438599, 0.18079710006713867, 0.3212645947933197, -0.8015154004096985, 0.79380863904953, -0.09492164850234985, -0.23052896559238434, -0.6869929432868958, -0.5966921448707581, -0.8045623898506165, 0.35138067603111267, -0.3401873707771301, -0.6981518864631653, 0.0499376617372036, -0.03290972113609314, -0.24923299252986908, 0.2091807872056961, -0.726039707660675, 0.38164371252059937, -0.6039403080940247, -0.4972012937068939, -0.6449514627456665, -0.35969722270965576, 0.2154308557510376, -0.24115534126758575, 0.35722804069519043, 0.3189510405063629, -0.36995795369148254, 0.6508241295814514, -0.5419107675552368, 0.48771587014198303, -0.15674136579036713, -0.26581841707229614, 0.4044513702392578, 0.048018306493759155, 0.7249495983123779, -0.030052466318011284, 0.0001719636784400791, -0.03101734071969986, -0.21575330197811127, -0.6437868475914001, -1.1154664754867554, 0.7891135215759277, -0.9360288977622986, -0.8542396426200867, -0.6522696018218994, -0.607918381690979, -0.48610684275627136, 0.2280135452747345, -0.2195788472890854, 0.3801318109035492, 0.2635818421840668, 0.14426693320274353, 0.8919214606285095, 0.08154553920030594, 0.11088825762271881, 0.5062907934188843, -0.4972785711288452, -0.772902250289917, 1.051808476448059, 0.33725231885910034, 0.4668404757976532, 0.1837904155254364, 0.3573259115219116, -0.505527675151825, -0.5775629281997681, -0.24164851009845734, 0.3616013824939728, -0.8069533705711365, -0.03370734304189682, -0.40990498661994934, -0.4557110071182251, -0.3954491913318634, -0.1919594556093216, -0.44533571600914, -0.3468855619430542, -0.1226586252450943, 0.0062753185629844666, 0.41892972588539124, 0.6231464147567749, 0.25448188185691833, 0.16390781104564667, -0.47753867506980896, 0.4510391056537628, 0.3769839107990265, 0.46837130188941956, 0.4194955825805664, -0.4183329939842224, -0.15786242485046387, 0.06946665048599243, -0.3511998653411865, -0.7664583325386047, 0.22618690133094788, 0.015204413793981075, 0.6232170462608337, 0.4015900492668152, -0.13670788705348969, 0.8684718608856201, -0.34656625986099243, 0.5299659371376038, 0.22041907906532288, -1.121841549873352, 0.7562196850776672, 0.02017788589000702, 0.27095404267311096, 0.4374454617500305, 0.5080576539039612, -0.011217846535146236, 0.059127211570739746, -0.7381899952888489, -0.7494410276412964, 0.3390451967716217, 0.3524194061756134, -0.2771684527397156, 0.06527455151081085, 0.42751848697662354, 0.046673282980918884, 0.23252460360527039, -0.33193743228912354, -0.22184167802333832, 0.1228543147444725, 0.004803038202226162, -0.2828204035758972, -0.11098165065050125, -0.13990749418735504, -0.46757715940475464, 1.055159568786621, -0.09412920475006104, 0.09625481069087982, 0.1021132692694664, -0.06647458672523499, -0.13587023317813873, 0.20978818833827972, 0.704004168510437, 1.0511423349380493, 0.2728773355484009, -0.2083374708890915, 0.22303062677383423, -0.6124453544616699, 0.3140721917152405, -0.10131175071001053, -0.13918575644493103, -0.29595375061035156, 0.07456899434328079, 0.8375018835067749, 0.3528762757778168, -0.9352914094924927, 0.3725564479827881, 0.19607894122600555, -0.28528356552124023, -0.42310869693756104, 0.17032243311405182, 0.09611190855503082, 0.37234044075012207, 0.9550580978393555, 0.12290678918361664, 0.034021273255348206, -0.5783240795135498, 0.1928502470254898, 0.3101126253604889, 0.035082731395959854, 0.17578834295272827, 0.23674635589122772, 0.17032702267169952, -0.8006736636161804, 0.4018577039241791, -0.05006302520632744, -0.6585023999214172, 0.8197561502456665, 0.955185055732727, 0.8048421144485474, -0.37769338488578796, 0.2295691967010498, 0.14085842669010162, 0.14703160524368286, -0.25699958205223083, 0.6192276477813721, -0.400585800409317, -0.5400925278663635, -0.7454028725624084, -0.49634045362472534, -0.44482049345970154, 0.1476019024848938, -0.7952861189842224, 0.4246217608451843, -0.7314413189888, -0.07877101004123688, 0.08672548085451126, 0.29824331402778625, -0.38071390986442566, 0.14930269122123718, -0.09943009167909622, 1.1208819150924683, -0.9614281058311462, 0.6273812651634216, 0.6599779725074768, -0.4943382143974304, -0.9643437266349792, -0.08307041972875595, -0.2025904655456543, -0.7768866419792175, 0.5714632868766785, -0.11209467798471451, -0.5977978706359863, 0.2316788285970688, -0.35415151715278625, -1.235345721244812, 1.2273197174072266, 0.44470345973968506, -0.7745901346206665, 0.20532794296741486, -0.08408903330564499, 0.600191593170166, -0.6534333229064941, -0.1553175002336502, 0.5802156925201416, 0.0014610880753025413, 0.6598014831542969, -0.6495407223701477, -0.12200062721967697, -0.21514086425304413, 0.12701310217380524, 0.43089866638183594, -0.7226773500442505, 0.5629055500030518, -0.668700635433197, -0.25260791182518005, 0.2781969904899597, 0.9803245663642883, 0.9237082600593567, 0.5630048513412476, 0.5597784519195557, 0.5878811478614807, 1.0285391807556152, -0.05922560766339302, 0.6936808228492737, -0.041091304272413254, 0.22597844898700714, 1.1004360914230347, -0.4607844650745392, 1.2682483196258545, 0.6055384874343872, -0.4602481424808502, 1.0440846681594849, 0.47503340244293213, 0.21746179461479187, 0.6424261927604675, 0.46400439739227295, -0.5235462188720703, -0.417484849691391, 0.211554616689682, -0.6570510268211365, 0.3744027614593506, 0.8116796612739563, -0.437583863735199, 0.11083216965198517, 0.2693648338317871, -0.38777488470077515, 0.43160945177078247, -0.5710791349411011, 0.7374370694160461, 0.14830081164836884, -0.7840174436569214, 0.591852068901062, -0.2715539038181305, 0.15938721597194672, -0.7564892768859863, -0.20151083171367645, 0.11026464402675629, 0.24724465608596802, -0.16827614605426788, -0.671379029750824, 0.18886706233024597, -0.04486183077096939, -0.06826085597276688, 0.1318289339542389, 0.5127382278442383, -0.22972790896892548, -0.7697929739952087, 0.12750723958015442, 0.40627625584602356, 0.21197785437107086, 0.26268723607063293, -0.6518613696098328, 0.24201567471027374, -0.42100033164024353, 0.1582537442445755, 0.2986600995063782, 0.23444028198719025, -0.2353099286556244, 1.2566227912902832, 0.9899972677230835, 0.2833075523376465, -0.06997105479240417, 0.46250027418136597, 1.0395238399505615, -0.43598473072052, -1.0041730403900146, -0.745439350605011, 0.19356496632099152, -0.21952614188194275, -0.17494972050189972, 0.6046598553657532, 0.6060938835144043, 0.5879064202308655, 0.04050686955451965, 0.7324192523956299, 0.3883346915245056, 0.33883780241012573, -0.5472006797790527, 0.24401189386844635, -0.3075101673603058, 0.7615016102790833, -0.44798192381858826, -1.080945372581482, -0.3773748576641083, 0.6988042593002319, -0.8110129833221436, 0.0627419501543045, 0.8019742965698242, 0.5168896317481995, 0.2795197069644928, 0.5592946410179138, 0.12972688674926758, 0.23091278970241547, 0.2527337670326233, 0.7231168746948242, 0.6962341666221619, -0.3012126684188843, 0.4487913250923157, -0.16028150916099548, -0.7582255005836487, -0.03897256404161453, -0.6898088455200195, -0.7042930722236633, -0.6003867387771606, -0.15008699893951416, -0.4232062101364136, 0.20514068007469177, 1.049910306930542, 0.4066311717033386, -0.8274804949760437, -0.1932002305984497, -0.5806970000267029, 0.1092069074511528, -0.7897030711174011, -0.2002444714307785, 0.4670126736164093, -0.5789095759391785, -0.38383424282073975, 0.3939414918422699, 0.4467017650604248, -0.15666131675243378, -0.8571693301200867, -0.24249355494976044, -0.46313774585723877, 0.4705490171909332, 0.7751674652099609, 0.39960235357284546, -0.7862342000007629, 0.2904980182647705, 0.13855992257595062, 0.18762817978858948, -0.13963425159454346, 1.1497905254364014, -0.9560810327529907, 0.5357673168182373, 0.3440718650817871, 0.9369364976882935, 0.7458988428115845, -0.02334563061594963, 0.5428438186645508, -0.4052704870700836, 0.22240835428237915, 0.3457843065261841, 0.4388027787208557, 0.06991974264383316, -0.4517621099948883, 0.4411827325820923, 0.18890029191970825, -0.4640127718448639, -1.017869472503662, 0.4920193552970886, -0.7707129120826721, -0.2379692792892456, 1.0214403867721558, -0.07489030808210373, -0.13608728349208832, -0.13315090537071228, -0.2188960313796997, 0.06828837841749191, -0.3208796977996826, 1.049581527709961, 0.6379897594451904, -0.2561957836151123, -0.19388075172901154, -0.12460345029830933, 0.25202956795692444, 0.6840803027153015, -0.8199143409729004, -0.109024778008461, 0.1866908073425293, 0.052383437752723694, 0.4572572410106659, 0.41136038303375244, -0.3479773700237274, 0.5742547512054443, -0.024856803938746452, -0.4842449426651001, -0.24620625376701355, -0.9702778458595276, -0.32601994276046753, 0.2264470010995865, 0.02719014137983322, -0.11669109761714935 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03881v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03881v1
A Bi-consolidating Model for Joint Relational Triple Extraction
2024-04-05T04:04:23
2024-04-05T04:04:23
Xiaocheng Luo, Yanping Chen, Ruixue Tang, Ruizhang Huang, Yongbin Qin
cs.CL
cs.CL
Current methods to extract relational triples directly make a prediction based on a possible entity pair in a raw sentence without depending on entity recognition. The task suffers from a serious semantic overlapping problem, in which several relation triples may share one or two entities in a sentence. It is weak to learn discriminative semantic features relevant to a relation triple. In this paper, based on a two-dimensional sentence representation, a bi-consolidating model is proposed to address this problem by simultaneously reinforcing the local and global semantic features relevant to a relation triple. This model consists of a local consolidation component and a global consolidation component. The first component uses a pixel difference convolution to enhance semantic information of a possible triple representation from adjacent regions and mitigate noise in neighbouring neighbours. The second component strengthens the triple representation based a channel attention and a spatial attention, which has the advantage to learn remote semantic dependencies in a sentence. They are helpful to improve the performance of both entity identification and relation type classification in relation triple extraction. After evaluated on several publish datasets, it achieves competitive performance. Analytical experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our model for relational triple extraction and give motivation for other natural language processing tasks.
[ -0.43625372648239136, -0.9722912907600403, 0.4635946750640869, 0.4187464714050293, -0.3251200020313263, 0.1545022428035736, -0.05810447037220001, -1.113929033279419, -0.030741535127162933, 0.5798958539962769, -0.1809954047203064, -0.23909810185432434, -0.6380372643470764, 0.23650170862674713, 0.1445741355419159, 0.7557404041290283, -0.1541871875524521, 0.04060043767094612, -0.27878889441490173, 0.0397491417825222, -0.8583829998970032, -0.047611307352781296, -0.30180904269218445, -0.20630218088626862, 0.1918453723192215, 0.5622569918632507, 0.8203794360160828, 0.30070650577545166, 0.7073777318000793, 0.2624305486679077, 0.1012866199016571, 0.4475782513618469, -0.3335348665714264, 0.1749560534954071, -0.33844348788261414, -0.33573049306869507, -0.4493849575519562, 0.1922065168619156, 0.841574490070343, 0.9919127225875854, 0.15444235503673553, 0.023691438138484955, -0.06431930512189865, 0.5226777791976929, -0.5702423453330994, 0.6241143941879272, -0.5368356704711914, -0.27034932374954224, -0.17369991540908813, 0.050137218087911606, -0.08379742503166199, -0.47486424446105957, 0.40912750363349915, -0.3961557447910309, 0.2800558805465698, -0.018685631453990936, 1.054609775543213, -0.04898504912853241, -0.7318960428237915, -0.042894475162029266, -0.9335213899612427, 0.26328784227371216, -0.1988920122385025, 0.2807619571685791, 0.250643253326416, 0.20166511833667755, -0.08449355512857437, -0.2589104175567627, -0.6351380944252014, 0.08495662361383438, -0.4559458792209625, 0.037942565977573395, -0.2030985951423645, -0.160099059343338, -0.003238681936636567, 0.6116189360618591, -0.25327354669570923, -0.13848307728767395, -0.5716334581375122, 0.17854152619838715, 0.44249972701072693, 0.07947906106710434, 0.6148955225944519, -0.3905666768550873, -0.6484649777412415, 0.4182668924331665, -0.6541793346405029, 0.02211652509868145, -0.013390249572694302, 0.46563106775283813, -0.2247874140739441, 0.7735730409622192, -0.15869031846523285, 0.529018759727478, 0.026394063606858253, 0.0808083713054657, 0.4331669211387634, -0.6632075309753418, -0.12980569899082184, -0.12990403175354004, 0.8591834306716919, 0.45584726333618164, 0.17857015132904053, -0.4667218327522278, 0.102601058781147, 0.24513380229473114, 0.10516542941331863, -0.5872090458869934, -0.35969725251197815, 0.2014957070350647, -0.4427146017551422, 0.0005323592340573668, 0.18687906861305237, -0.9207319021224976, -0.10671146959066391, -0.47152450680732727, 0.2927953600883484, -0.6326305270195007, -0.6359832882881165, 0.27457237243652344, -0.005489168222993612, -0.11302345991134644, -0.21151696145534515, -1.028071403503418, 0.5661413669586182, 0.6497350335121155, 0.8214350342750549, 0.006176955997943878, -0.22031287848949432, -0.7240306735038757, 0.5622239112854004, 0.058869581669569016, 0.7995729446411133, -0.545192301273346, -0.19905434548854828, -0.10176839679479599, -0.033838726580142975, 0.1270139515399933, -0.48571014404296875, 0.0909322202205658, -0.7258026599884033, 0.472726970911026, -0.017292238771915436, -0.37043464183807373, -0.399691641330719, 0.1809510737657547, -1.1303763389587402, 0.9191207885742188, 0.3227689862251282, -0.8829478621482849, 0.4344249963760376, -0.48675066232681274, -0.29856881499290466, 0.43158045411109924, -0.17876432836055756, -0.7905412912368774, -0.042405273765325546, 0.43633216619491577, 0.41708502173423767, -0.496795654296875, 0.15326957404613495, -0.5849657654762268, -0.2785448729991913, -0.25338423252105713, 0.25277841091156006, 0.9647350311279297, -0.29654887318611145, -0.0802634209394455, -0.4393962025642395, -0.8320210576057434, -0.17911605536937714, 0.15835191309452057, -0.3720244765281677, -0.5880142450332642, -0.3166557550430298, -0.30704089999198914, 0.30354610085487366, 0.22758832573890686, -0.701728343963623, 0.4094964563846588, -0.7997161746025085, -0.16880656778812408, -0.06994958966970444, 0.754045844078064, 0.7728278636932373, 0.01876957155764103, 0.2137169986963272, 0.18984581530094147, -0.059150345623493195, 0.2766224145889282, -0.43962225317955017, -0.4397372603416443, -0.3789024353027344, 0.39890211820602417, 0.5410565137863159, -0.9616966843605042, 0.4783037304878235, -0.7192541360855103, -0.17332306504249573, -0.38456979393959045, 0.24450968205928802, 0.5339178442955017, 0.15694323182106018, 0.445511132478714, 0.06062500551342964, -0.787384033203125, -1.0168845653533936, -0.22481903433799744, 0.1073693111538887, 0.0748710110783577, -0.25622057914733887, 0.3913242816925049, 0.01578449457883835, 1.0885441303253174, -0.3664153814315796, -0.34172746539115906, -0.4330088794231415, 0.3047782778739929, 0.1765337884426117, 0.2889106571674347, 0.3527209758758545, -1.1053484678268433, -0.6212412714958191, 0.15822096168994904, -0.7854921817779541, 0.21702693402767181, 0.19147644937038422, -0.2572132349014282, 0.1708814650774002, 0.10302405059337616, -1.0123347043991089, 0.5383753180503845, 0.10826833546161652, -0.23932020366191864, 0.19257113337516785, -0.17142049968242645, -0.27743709087371826, -1.0307217836380005, -0.027461199089884758, -0.04973868653178215, -0.25535690784454346, -0.5861569046974182, -0.009587382897734642, 0.24124841392040253, 0.06805062294006348, -0.03695494309067726, 0.125312939286232, -0.918891191482544, -0.30431532859802246, -0.07884499430656433, 0.5944095253944397, 0.24365048110485077, 0.6735849976539612, 0.07975412905216217, 0.251920610666275, 0.4103047847747803, -0.6257116794586182, 0.5379260182380676, 0.45558443665504456, -0.35922136902809143, 0.5046373605728149, -0.3048788905143738, 0.007383144926279783, -0.16147302091121674, 0.19214634597301483, -0.7553107142448425, -0.09601452946662903, 0.5171697735786438, -0.30172935128211975, 0.34477075934410095, 0.02975773811340332, -0.7321687340736389, -0.4008778929710388, -0.1368628442287445, 0.3015384376049042, -0.24266542494297028, -0.7055795192718506, 0.7594709992408752, 0.6234926581382751, -0.24527351558208466, -0.3456750512123108, -0.5821712613105774, -0.060606151819229126, -0.11285001784563065, -0.8199058175086975, 0.6509003639221191, 0.4780550003051758, -0.23885725438594818, 0.4471137821674347, -0.04196673631668091, 0.13394670188426971, -0.16328148543834686, 0.14036741852760315, 0.7645847797393799, -0.06347917020320892, 0.35032567381858826, -0.39554542303085327, -0.30481916666030884, 0.046082157641649246, -0.05922168493270874, 0.3338012099266052, -0.28548139333724976, 0.3945219814777374, -0.46670323610305786, 0.823573648929596, 0.43885260820388794, -0.4244016110897064, 0.8122579455375671, 0.5154814720153809, -0.646347165107727, 0.22270546853542328, -0.5228684544563293, 0.30234548449516296, -0.32500699162483215, 0.3122722804546356, -0.5899437069892883, -0.6129698157310486, 0.29168081283569336, -0.10813106596469879, -0.14758174121379852, 0.33201730251312256, 0.4288816452026367, 0.1356942057609558, 0.886839747428894, 0.6766589283943176, 0.11873583495616913, 0.11879228800535202, -0.5625720024108887, 0.591352641582489, -0.8573591709136963, -0.6904594302177429, -0.30118528008461, -0.1559952348470688, -0.5265030860900879, -0.1642298847436905, 0.25906839966773987, 0.5524465441703796, -0.1714620441198349, 0.48395392298698425, -0.26731839776039124, 0.5157294273376465, 0.4202632009983063, 0.3811786472797394, 0.33136940002441406, 0.2709716558456421, -0.15619511902332306, 0.05269336327910423, -0.3017946779727936, -0.25702425837516785, 0.5636854767799377, 0.22653703391551971, -0.09750460833311081, 0.7625477910041809, 0.6297083497047424, -0.1681245118379593, 0.044346798211336136, -0.4495815336704254, 0.3447083830833435, -0.024637402966618538, -0.5743764638900757, -0.10837756097316742, -0.5743898749351501, -0.9877342581748962, 0.43338146805763245, -0.6091170907020569, -1.026536464691162, 0.5015539526939392, -0.4348143935203552, -0.6480751633644104, 0.23758019506931305, -0.8594198226928711, 0.7334316968917847, -0.10587771236896515, -0.6652987003326416, 0.02439962886273861, -0.7897456884384155, 0.6737254858016968, 0.1669289618730545, 0.25427961349487305, -0.17597419023513794, -0.09842398762702942, 0.30070748925209045, -0.29340729117393494, 0.5141658186912537, -0.2483806610107422, 0.13400229811668396, 0.035591866821050644, 0.2714315354824066, 0.5343644618988037, 0.26479220390319824, 0.12790615856647491, -0.008356336504220963, -0.06362093240022659, -0.3729601800441742, -0.7862882018089294, 0.3725689649581909, -0.7719781994819641, -0.40992143750190735, -0.18273228406906128, -0.5342471599578857, -0.5983442068099976, 0.38246533274650574, -0.036694131791591644, 0.44658249616622925, -0.04676081985235214, 0.12834642827510834, 0.06170077621936798, 0.17156463861465454, 0.5282053351402283, 0.24719102680683136, -0.5398140549659729, -0.6951972246170044, 0.7294518351554871, -0.22929896414279938, 0.23996393382549286, 0.5279234051704407, -0.08440256118774414, -0.2887692153453827, -0.20342949032783508, -0.01877669431269169, 0.5650274157524109, -0.38199228048324585, -0.5027436017990112, -0.8566721081733704, -0.15262162685394287, -0.5363063216209412, 0.30550482869148254, -0.04882184788584709, -0.3750002086162567, -0.1619470715522766, -0.19518589973449707, 0.1998140662908554, 0.9317877888679504, -0.28540733456611633, 0.14655330777168274, -0.9988393783569336, 0.807184636592865, 0.32793524861335754, 0.47618693113327026, -0.1552434116601944, 0.20259052515029907, -0.26304924488067627, -0.11613965779542923, -0.21933238208293915, -0.857223629951477, 0.37245967984199524, -0.15361885726451874, 0.37420588731765747, 0.08561806380748749, -0.23947563767433167, 0.738579273223877, -0.10251588374376297, 0.5356128811836243, 0.4979345500469208, -0.7585856914520264, 0.40232017636299133, -0.32246091961860657, 0.10593393445014954, 0.5942774415016174, 0.40080076456069946, -0.11469241231679916, -0.26308679580688477, -0.6565947532653809, -0.6966655850410461, 0.9625780582427979, 0.4533710181713104, -0.34659022092819214, -0.11078085750341415, 0.4580027759075165, -0.04451135918498039, -0.24350707232952118, -0.9328070282936096, -0.0675332248210907, 0.2251637727022171, 0.09145917743444443, 0.3655369281768799, -0.6433702111244202, 0.11028601229190826, -0.16920363903045654, 0.6019405722618103, 0.47584354877471924, 0.13619649410247803, 0.06374526023864746, 0.00916831661015749, -0.06505303084850311, -0.0444788783788681, -0.12078030407428741, 0.40916648507118225, -0.4881000518798828, 0.27985766530036926, -0.05259736627340317, -0.1972576379776001, -0.09165459126234055, 0.3922782838344574, 0.1351703554391861, 0.0828675851225853, 0.5103269219398499, 0.528918981552124, 0.4187203347682953, 0.11303525418043137, 0.7723681330680847, -0.11680131405591965, -0.17871740460395813, -0.1692751944065094, -0.29460176825523376, 0.3237072825431824, 0.3559221923351288, -0.04042764753103256, 0.43194881081581116, 0.31459841132164, -0.7448988556861877, 0.2782140076160431, 0.36648547649383545, -0.1330486387014389, 0.11898672580718994, 0.19022038578987122, 0.2935692071914673, -0.3845687508583069, 0.873130202293396, -0.3796941936016083, -0.6927684545516968, 0.3771679401397705, 0.532045304775238, 0.4974091351032257, -0.0968940407037735, 0.044090189039707184, 0.5719594955444336, 0.043750226497650146, 0.012266925536096096, 0.3063601851463318, -0.28615906834602356, -0.8775666952133179, -0.32245203852653503, -0.21043196320533752, 0.09379991143941879, -0.19300130009651184, -0.7498581409454346, 0.6556985974311829, -0.07609012722969055, 0.0858708843588829, 0.1386387199163437, 0.4992375373840332, -0.6838768720626831, -0.032066959887742996, 0.36116594076156616, 0.38847318291664124, -0.5897170305252075, 0.819695770740509, 0.20449143648147583, -0.8065627813339233, -0.8212879300117493, -0.10374027490615845, -0.1449289470911026, -0.2568933069705963, 0.7059088349342346, 0.4187527000904083, -0.28914228081703186, -0.4216132164001465, -0.1765432506799698, -0.9856480360031128, 0.9865527749061584, 0.22508345544338226, -0.3937315344810486, -0.33145570755004883, 0.2446989268064499, 0.2902066111564636, -0.8087508082389832, 0.13317613303661346, 0.8446182012557983, 0.2907548248767853, 0.15576356649398804, -0.6616736650466919, 0.13486641645431519, -0.40984126925468445, 0.3364707827568054, 0.37733182311058044, -0.32283204793930054, 0.668067455291748, -0.15374769270420074, -0.6988605260848999, 0.04499095305800438, 0.5344290137290955, 0.3979194462299347, 0.033335454761981964, 0.6013518571853638, 0.3936130404472351, 0.7120394706726074, 0.06009254977107048, 0.936461865901947, -0.018277015537023544, 0.4465401768684387, 1.6697814464569092, -0.3837284445762634, 0.8478076457977295, 0.29210415482521057, -0.06358864903450012, 0.7970789670944214, 0.35389530658721924, -0.09336830675601959, 0.5599527955055237, -0.12867875397205353, -0.3415066599845886, -0.3187720775604248, 0.061725955456495285, -0.20611001551151276, 0.7427418231964111, 0.6678626537322998, -0.17019356787204742, -0.4738010764122009, -0.07465258240699768, -0.08501707017421722, 0.24025362730026245, -0.059084732085466385, 0.758727490901947, -0.18494762480258942, -0.7460026741027832, 0.2802600562572479, -0.23274627327919006, 0.16843123733997345, -0.07019320875406265, -0.3471529185771942, 0.017033958807587624, 0.2674116790294647, -0.25117966532707214, -0.5905260443687439, 0.48404550552368164, -0.38263705372810364, -0.5164164900779724, -0.06492164731025696, 0.48231035470962524, -0.7412287592887878, -0.6161700487136841, 0.7247920632362366, 0.23547889292240143, -0.06729807704687119, -0.09157724678516388, -0.40834489464759827, -0.06026124954223633, 0.025043679401278496, 0.18642112612724304, -0.3102595806121826, 0.8653918504714966, 0.1418088674545288, 0.19736453890800476, 0.35160571336746216, 0.2801573574542999, -0.08356167376041412, 0.12889732420444489, 0.7707056999206543, -0.5916928052902222, -0.4021095037460327, -0.7985919713973999, 0.5164405107498169, -0.697762668132782, 0.05332208052277565, 0.4954098165035248, 0.7613235116004944, 0.512718141078949, 0.29303112626075745, 0.5052444934844971, -0.0724010169506073, 0.89046710729599, -0.5655300617218018, 0.16860584914684296, -0.37121692299842834, 0.5508270859718323, -0.11801215261220932, -0.9661315679550171, -0.8763885498046875, 0.13247895240783691, -0.5081634521484375, -0.059624556452035904, 0.9537317752838135, 0.5645951628684998, -0.11599935591220856, 0.41473209857940674, -0.039432164281606674, 0.21930529177188873, 0.2979107201099396, 0.7702165842056274, 0.7758603096008301, -0.5768454074859619, 0.8342633843421936, -0.5446587204933167, -0.21095037460327148, -0.07692980021238327, -0.5754891037940979, -0.7521312832832336, -0.5770148634910583, -0.25052085518836975, -0.33980593085289, -0.2817871868610382, 0.705828845500946, 0.45916345715522766, -0.4365371763706207, 0.22085164487361908, -0.34210696816444397, 0.09279514849185944, -0.2036503255367279, -0.24697455763816833, 0.6148613691329956, -0.3914686441421509, -0.6191871762275696, 0.08879152685403824, 0.592488169670105, -0.13794957101345062, 0.007447772193700075, 0.4014537036418915, -0.8915620446205139, -0.5337426662445068, 0.511288583278656, -0.026331251487135887, -0.6863583922386169, -0.4721377193927765, -0.3715662360191345, -0.1684625893831253, 0.14241833984851837, 0.8041924834251404, -0.8135750889778137, 0.6054975390434265, 0.39756810665130615, 0.363316148519516, 0.6407501697540283, 0.1110309436917305, 0.7704648971557617, -0.7106695175170898, 0.06267710030078888, -0.010730806738138199, 0.5300341844558716, 0.533568263053894, -0.640938937664032, 0.6510060429573059, 0.20246046781539917, -0.3986594080924988, -0.1926853507757187, 0.12023105472326279, -1.045871615409851, -0.2838572859764099, 1.0810595750808716, -0.030298776924610138, -0.176876962184906, -0.6275174021720886, -0.12599366903305054, 0.5292074680328369, -0.06830883026123047, 0.6827540993690491, 0.6827766299247742, -0.1935625970363617, -0.26745930314064026, -0.2376227229833603, 0.23618847131729126, 0.015064523555338383, -0.6515881419181824, 0.32512274384498596, 0.5337151288986206, 0.18130894005298615, 0.5222048163414001, 0.3656699061393738, -0.4465827941894531, 0.42141807079315186, 0.009089709259569645, 0.3400004208087921, 0.06912687420845032, -0.4126768708229065, -0.24121539294719696, 0.4593310058116913, -0.3987230658531189, -0.504691481590271 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03868v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03868v1
Extract, Define, Canonicalize: An LLM-based Framework for Knowledge Graph Construction
2024-04-05T02:53:51
2024-04-05T02:53:51
Bowen Zhang, Harold Soh
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
In this work, we are interested in automated methods for knowledge graph creation (KGC) from input text. Progress on large language models (LLMs) has prompted a series of recent works applying them to KGC, e.g., via zero/few-shot prompting. Despite successes on small domain-specific datasets, these models face difficulties scaling up to text common in many real-world applications. A principal issue is that in prior methods, the KG schema has to be included in the LLM prompt to generate valid triplets; larger and more complex schema easily exceed the LLMs' context window length. To address this problem, we propose a three-phase framework named Extract-Define-Canonicalize (EDC): open information extraction followed by schema definition and post-hoc canonicalization. EDC is flexible in that it can be applied to settings where a pre-defined target schema is available and when it is not; in the latter case, it constructs a schema automatically and applies self-canonicalization. To further improve performance, we introduce a trained component that retrieves schema elements relevant to the input text; this improves the LLMs' extraction performance in a retrieval-augmented generation-like manner. We demonstrate on three KGC benchmarks that EDC is able to extract high-quality triplets without any parameter tuning and with significantly larger schemas compared to prior works.
[ -0.31071412563323975, -0.7211223244667053, 0.7139573693275452, 0.026058904826641083, -0.19228169322013855, -0.0030182860791683197, -0.2808644473552704, -0.3037344515323639, 0.27661043405532837, 0.6147406101226807, -0.17823757231235504, -0.9357103109359741, -0.5922909379005432, 0.3738778531551361, -0.25833603739738464, 0.9685582518577576, -0.43444424867630005, -0.2662409842014313, -0.29772597551345825, 0.12594877183437347, -0.1196713075041771, -0.16617520153522491, -0.41763806343078613, -0.18383964896202087, 0.636903703212738, 0.6265599131584167, 0.33084890246391296, 1.0977238416671753, 0.33873289823532104, 0.1631191521883011, 0.12130153924226761, 0.5411044955253601, -0.40385594964027405, 0.40876519680023193, -0.0820888802409172, -0.21821069717407227, -0.7219446897506714, 0.09121681749820709, 0.9835842847824097, 0.8535366654396057, 0.034023839980363846, 0.20189781486988068, 0.27833253145217896, 0.6710668802261353, -0.6185398101806641, 0.8566166162490845, -0.6582379937171936, -0.2545028030872345, -0.14002062380313873, -0.2926090955734253, -0.46923699975013733, -0.582976758480072, 0.0313115268945694, -1.0841304063796997, 0.10923703014850616, -0.057339146733284, 0.8847222924232483, -0.0891166627407074, -0.6129598021507263, -0.40382036566734314, -0.7889301776885986, 0.333120197057724, -0.518536388874054, 0.493164598941803, 0.3907981216907501, 0.23069845139980316, -0.21885398030281067, -0.9838001132011414, -0.5464538335800171, 0.018133679404854774, -0.2072577178478241, 0.07772183418273926, 0.12129919975996017, 0.16532209515571594, 0.12319328635931015, 0.2169078141450882, -0.299407422542572, -0.007483631372451782, -0.5913881659507751, -0.06098269671201706, 0.4115048050880432, 0.12689125537872314, 0.041585490107536316, -0.5851369500160217, -0.26307472586631775, 0.1746496856212616, -1.149877905845642, -0.30935949087142944, 0.3938719928264618, 0.5552658438682556, 0.32127994298934937, 0.7421503663063049, -0.5325345993041992, 0.7380487322807312, 0.13415630161762238, -0.3478506803512573, 0.06479716300964355, -0.4560151994228363, -0.12667971849441528, -0.08277908712625504, 0.805223822593689, 0.20247401297092438, 0.05812304839491844, -0.531547486782074, 0.03678180277347565, -0.3651094138622284, 0.3040662109851837, -0.7300546765327454, -0.3408397436141968, 0.141498863697052, -0.3067235052585602, -0.5892798900604248, 0.08882113546133041, -0.6090382933616638, -0.20223163068294525, -0.6006853580474854, 0.2307060956954956, -0.5173163414001465, -0.18172882497310638, -0.2150242179632187, 0.059787485748529434, 0.11857151240110397, 0.2391214668750763, -0.9519153237342834, 0.3421154022216797, 0.7023738026618958, 0.6305572390556335, -0.5496355295181274, -0.17950619757175446, -0.38533127307891846, 0.7646744251251221, -0.5315824151039124, 0.6935037970542908, -0.2547886371612549, -0.2606361508369446, 0.08764123171567917, 0.10557606816291809, -0.06951520591974258, -0.45614373683929443, 0.27726107835769653, -0.8520134687423706, 0.07518108189105988, -0.296344518661499, -0.5919685959815979, -0.1263558715581894, 0.26184752583503723, -0.5704739689826965, 1.3409126996994019, 0.34743404388427734, -0.719700276851654, 0.5639316439628601, -0.76201331615448, -0.6418204307556152, 0.3956908881664276, -0.40909647941589355, 0.08881355077028275, -0.37877658009529114, 0.2257353961467743, 0.7207565903663635, -0.37272581458091736, 0.49955424666404724, -0.2820318937301636, 0.21457509696483612, -0.40122079849243164, 0.12285181134939194, 0.5625445246696472, 0.21270528435707092, -0.2650291621685028, -0.06440570205450058, -1.027274489402771, 0.1442783921957016, 0.14859230816364288, -0.7254639863967896, -0.3745501637458801, 0.07318053394556046, -0.6620603799819946, 0.09046190977096558, 0.41396671533584595, -0.5949559807777405, 0.45326370000839233, -0.5118389129638672, 0.36325374245643616, 0.8171827793121338, 0.03746649995446205, 0.7388207912445068, 0.13055597245693207, 0.45154789090156555, -0.0941375270485878, -0.12277621775865555, -0.036418840289115906, -0.20433485507965088, -0.9965023994445801, -0.5350353717803955, 0.42150628566741943, 0.39760392904281616, -1.1890385150909424, 0.7255028486251831, -0.8238383531570435, -0.4277339279651642, -0.16428469121456146, 0.31893792748451233, 0.1348169445991516, 0.7020205855369568, 0.19342967867851257, 0.1038065254688263, -0.5087869763374329, -1.1184290647506714, 0.03876146674156189, -0.27260297536849976, -0.04188971966505051, 0.3146507740020752, 0.45428359508514404, 0.19872243702411652, 1.4088163375854492, -0.8592312932014465, -0.2179490178823471, -0.28544822335243225, 0.23142415285110474, -0.05369829386472702, 0.2714395821094513, 0.16312581300735474, -0.3590458929538727, -0.5020790100097656, 0.31171485781669617, -1.2087289094924927, -0.24393361806869507, 0.34077388048171997, -0.42085808515548706, 0.06467977911233902, 0.6730826497077942, -0.530935525894165, 0.2677460312843323, 0.17969270050525665, 0.03639976307749748, 0.4657096564769745, -0.024266961961984634, 0.09004686772823334, -1.3775490522384644, 0.14873866736888885, -0.3073539435863495, -0.21566034853458405, -0.6281765699386597, 0.2612166106700897, 0.35895049571990967, 0.13875815272331238, -0.31590235233306885, 0.32331106066703796, -0.43676427006721497, -0.1207505539059639, 0.002438958967104554, 0.5690039992332458, 0.15175259113311768, 0.4561472237110138, -0.04784904047846794, 0.45989447832107544, 0.291678786277771, -0.7446991205215454, 0.3747297525405884, 0.09880468249320984, -0.012331792153418064, 0.6039188504219055, -0.425503134727478, 0.2214614599943161, -0.02783776819705963, 0.515533983707428, -0.6820870637893677, -0.49810048937797546, 0.5448601841926575, -0.10606729984283447, 0.3652774691581726, -0.2111968994140625, -1.019466519355774, -0.5962799787521362, -0.1131826862692833, 0.26972585916519165, 0.13612033426761627, -0.8052929043769836, 0.8426974415779114, 0.2838384211063385, -0.358634352684021, -0.24685393273830414, -0.20820266008377075, -0.025112316012382507, -0.012080412358045578, -0.9549760222434998, 0.3692200779914856, 0.03506547957658768, 0.07920219749212265, -0.058240458369255066, 0.041862256824970245, 0.012302352115511894, 0.06347882747650146, 0.35052818059921265, 0.2329598218202591, -0.20051544904708862, 0.3651081323623657, 0.5042720437049866, -0.08779939264059067, 0.009964208118617535, -0.8532193899154663, 0.3613828718662262, -0.00017271042452193797, -0.25047266483306885, -0.312646746635437, 0.11777626723051071, 0.43033698201179504, 0.008463139645755291, 0.5063672661781311, 0.22163225710391998, -0.4314827620983124, -0.15118448436260223, -0.5232038497924805, -0.007646891288459301, -0.4818507134914398, 0.1375090777873993, -0.395341157913208, -0.7915676236152649, 0.2777378559112549, -0.2782038450241089, 0.20852375030517578, 0.6107850074768066, 0.4046875834465027, 0.03086230345070362, 0.7148288488388062, 0.4205738306045532, 0.24748551845550537, 0.051174771040678024, -0.10186508297920227, 0.13829968869686127, -0.7796025276184082, -0.23623184859752655, -0.38735431432724, 0.11275055259466171, -0.3118669390678406, -0.24794577062129974, 0.42835938930511475, 0.36739611625671387, -0.06353870779275894, 0.5031205415725708, -0.46255001425743103, 0.4996318221092224, 0.47865796089172363, -0.04599946737289429, 0.5500660538673401, 0.17590993642807007, -0.39899399876594543, 0.16000065207481384, -0.5893988609313965, -0.7133095264434814, 1.498496651649475, 0.2334347814321518, 0.2656129002571106, 0.14153844118118286, 1.040850281715393, 0.002818502252921462, 0.4966108798980713, -0.7056692242622375, 0.7013060450553894, 0.04239385202527046, -0.5293827056884766, -0.31939223408699036, -0.5389516353607178, -0.9038966298103333, 0.22186650335788727, -0.06599901616573334, -0.7150182127952576, -0.09798530489206314, 0.1330806165933609, -0.3395058810710907, 0.39135825634002686, -0.5367998480796814, 0.2628175914287567, 0.16294986009597778, -0.29622286558151245, 0.2698192298412323, -0.5663664937019348, 0.34773513674736023, -0.3513281047344208, 0.40168672800064087, -0.047591667622327805, -0.03424622863531113, 1.0075358152389526, -0.3140104115009308, 0.8077840209007263, -0.130820170044899, -0.4129974842071533, 0.40681901574134827, 0.38638100028038025, 0.8270227313041687, 0.01579790748655796, 0.11117158830165863, 0.14891071617603302, 0.015416770242154598, -0.2554296851158142, -0.7199116349220276, 0.6921614408493042, -0.6508816480636597, -0.5478488206863403, 0.10841713100671768, -0.6359943151473999, -0.307504802942276, 0.6043785810470581, 0.08198884129524231, 0.41088882088661194, -0.17663855850696564, 0.20225100219249725, 0.43779194355010986, 0.0840601921081543, 0.3320291340351105, 0.6541671752929688, -0.4165434241294861, -0.7528347969055176, 0.992207407951355, 0.33142897486686707, 0.5117203593254089, 0.27332547307014465, 0.19967368245124817, 0.004214165266603231, -0.545525074005127, -0.48899123072624207, 0.1946280151605606, -0.8864563703536987, -0.4184727966785431, -0.8260824084281921, -0.2631467580795288, -0.9177619218826294, -0.07098796963691711, -0.35408011078834534, -0.7585993409156799, -0.42673635482788086, -0.35473310947418213, 0.3109210729598999, 1.2128803730010986, -0.28528958559036255, 0.38063234090805054, -0.7144131064414978, 0.294198602437973, 0.3293510377407074, 0.26888155937194824, -0.17181238532066345, -0.21470144391059875, -0.22731022536754608, -0.2076379656791687, -0.408930242061615, -0.6635464429855347, 0.16602754592895508, -0.03339298442006111, 0.46652108430862427, 0.4323000907897949, -0.024603096768260002, 0.41208431124687195, -0.5259536504745483, 0.8906222581863403, 0.166267991065979, -0.5797301530838013, 0.5660117864608765, -0.7084180116653442, -0.033219560980796814, 0.5041570663452148, 0.3984341621398926, -0.22480925917625427, -0.30353349447250366, -0.6695399880409241, -0.9098625183105469, 0.9167917370796204, 0.3982383608818054, -0.24745434522628784, -0.24756784737110138, 0.5453447699546814, 0.37249016761779785, 0.17578230798244476, -0.8036190867424011, -0.4824681580066681, 0.13639380037784576, -0.38160455226898193, 0.3238193988800049, -0.4094381630420685, -0.5406152606010437, -0.13797160983085632, 0.7296097278594971, -0.3261713683605194, 0.04475407302379608, 0.05580942705273628, -0.17009879648685455, -0.06862179189920425, 0.058716729283332825, 0.21791566908359528, 0.5954875946044922, -0.11693867295980453, 0.4058429002761841, -0.02161508984863758, -0.43222561478614807, -0.11997310072183609, 0.40075477957725525, -0.5021437406539917, -0.3710702061653137, 0.4701622724533081, 0.2952485978603363, 0.3405168950557709, -0.07703667134046555, 0.4953688085079193, 0.22736740112304688, -0.6036064624786377, -0.06732073426246643, -0.18579332530498505, 0.0678262934088707, 0.11271108686923981, 0.40935197472572327, -0.3103059232234955, -0.13583770394325256, 0.016423538327217102, 0.2591255307197571, 0.2340235561132431, -0.20525094866752625, -0.23123885691165924, 0.37629127502441406, 0.38731104135513306, 0.003753640688955784, 0.5089516043663025, -0.5054959654808044, -0.4055432975292206, 0.3059724271297455, 0.5220917463302612, 0.606799304485321, 0.06900382786989212, 0.33290964365005493, 0.4512527883052826, 0.3441152274608612, 0.1733599752187729, -0.013064415194094181, -0.30613911151885986, -0.7942970991134644, -0.16281770169734955, -0.56148362159729, 0.19246867299079895, -0.16049440205097198, -0.6190771460533142, 0.3759929835796356, -0.48864006996154785, 0.10304505378007889, -0.021596146747469902, -0.11393219977617264, -0.6386991739273071, -0.20559944212436676, 0.005939948838204145, 0.6947753429412842, -0.7286818027496338, 0.8550416827201843, 0.2795889377593994, -0.5062257051467896, -1.1252481937408447, -0.31284597516059875, -0.004727895837277174, -0.8119122982025146, 0.9561629891395569, -0.10311886668205261, 0.08199924230575562, 0.28468066453933716, -0.6481327414512634, -1.2216875553131104, 1.6197158098220825, 0.21385695040225983, -0.15424823760986328, -0.34077101945877075, 0.27967891097068787, 0.27360981702804565, -0.6759653687477112, -0.0826348289847374, 0.7757833003997803, 0.5595850944519043, 0.20850160717964172, -0.8079185485839844, 0.22669993340969086, 0.1551930010318756, -0.21841000020503998, 0.17392966151237488, -0.18313634395599365, 0.8136298060417175, 0.08832594007253647, -0.5627585053443909, -0.027461141347885132, 0.7118247151374817, 0.21539291739463806, 0.04182282090187073, 0.411718487739563, 0.4606398940086365, 0.9095273017883301, 0.04178941994905472, 0.934475302696228, -0.4081277549266815, 0.32398682832717896, 1.4244661331176758, -0.3467274010181427, 0.6380270719528198, 0.4587065279483795, -0.15606607496738434, 0.5491502285003662, 0.5893913507461548, 0.24543334543704987, 0.41217339038848877, 0.037389736622571945, -0.180533304810524, -0.15079648792743683, 0.014721794985234737, -0.3667495548725128, 0.15530796349048615, 0.4475332498550415, -0.7772571444511414, -0.5083387494087219, -0.2224954217672348, 0.30431875586509705, -0.2752439081668854, -0.10332972556352615, 0.9645849466323853, -0.06386904418468475, -0.6800256371498108, 0.4722393751144409, 0.00275755999609828, 0.17395099997520447, -0.4886597692966461, -0.07746447622776031, 0.0190532598644495, -0.2689945697784424, -0.23577332496643066, -0.5593305826187134, -0.050415679812431335, -0.3015199303627014, -0.22861869633197784, -0.2974851429462433, 0.8031244874000549, -0.4833109676837921, -0.5948090553283691, 0.3087056875228882, 0.6375439763069153, 0.18897700309753418, 0.1708284318447113, -0.14942875504493713, -0.21857039630413055, 0.010547008365392685, -0.18983915448188782, 0.13228164613246918, 0.5358292460441589, -0.026551922783255577, 0.25807255506515503, 0.7400938868522644, 0.09378865361213684, 0.14268817007541656, -0.10893088579177856, 1.0447474718093872, -0.3321206271648407, -0.12980873882770538, -0.5905503034591675, 0.24272873997688293, -0.17500251531600952, -0.044635623693466187, 0.5329630970954895, 0.6477394104003906, 0.5446017384529114, 0.1784030795097351, 0.9272859692573547, -0.40298348665237427, 0.4053671956062317, -0.6137340664863586, 0.530002236366272, -0.35648661851882935, 0.3113974928855896, -0.34368300437927246, -0.9451048970222473, -0.44021788239479065, 0.06505934149026871, -0.4017440676689148, -0.27670353651046753, 0.9950887560844421, 0.883794367313385, 0.047472864389419556, 0.3057478368282318, 0.09764491766691208, 0.24370571970939636, 0.5922093391418457, 0.07211359590291977, 0.5754812955856323, -0.23103263974189758, 0.8150898218154907, -0.2396923005580902, -0.4124714732170105, 0.10751775652170181, -0.9927372336387634, -0.6660793423652649, -0.7328508496284485, -0.1271757036447525, -0.5230677723884583, -0.10832101106643677, 0.840251088142395, 0.6114692687988281, -0.4111140966415405, 0.07951884716749191, -0.14521396160125732, 0.2515891194343567, 0.11789986491203308, -0.2455436736345291, 0.6437366008758545, -0.34118035435676575, -0.36756059527397156, 0.549645721912384, 0.3389602303504944, -0.08359546959400177, -0.281120240688324, 0.10105403512716293, -0.14960400760173798, -0.17093098163604736, 0.863212525844574, 0.1440870314836502, -0.7460740804672241, -0.7222861647605896, -0.1682719886302948, -0.16026972234249115, 0.09329883009195328, 0.9345479607582092, -0.6899042129516602, 0.5930967330932617, 0.29774582386016846, 0.4476991295814514, 0.5197298526763916, -0.07338984310626984, 0.7926881313323975, -0.9439007043838501, -0.3220948874950409, -0.161652073264122, 0.1722659021615982, 0.13027741014957428, -0.47123029828071594, 0.6378483176231384, 0.3995649516582489, -0.3307914137840271, -0.5211523175239563, 0.27917739748954773, -0.8706013560295105, -0.24760296940803528, 1.6278393268585205, -0.09948495775461197, -0.23561625182628632, -0.23353256285190582, -0.0385301299393177, 0.32230624556541443, -0.39728185534477234, 0.3991561830043793, 0.7276046276092529, -0.16579046845436096, 0.6353479027748108, -0.33666956424713135, 0.35096409916877747, -0.2045425921678543, -0.9542485475540161, 0.36237215995788574, 0.5757009387016296, 0.5145408511161804, 0.36707064509391785, 0.6706095337867737, -0.35173720121383667, -0.1765323132276535, -0.15094667673110962, 0.2856934368610382, -0.1612311452627182, -0.49658632278442383, 0.03576447814702988, 0.5481732487678528, -0.12870249152183533, 0.051116473972797394 ]