id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06209v1
|
Elephants Never Forget: Memorization and Learning of Tabular Data in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-09T10:58:21 | 2024-04-09T10:58:21 |
Sebastian Bordt, Harsha Nori, Vanessa Rodrigues, Besmira Nushi, Rich Caruana
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
While many have shown how Large Language Models (LLMs) can be applied to a
diverse set of tasks, the critical issues of data contamination and
memorization are often glossed over. In this work, we address this concern for
tabular data. Specifically, we introduce a variety of different techniques to
assess whether a language model has seen a tabular dataset during training.
This investigation reveals that LLMs have memorized many popular tabular
datasets verbatim. We then compare the few-shot learning performance of LLMs on
datasets that were seen during training to the performance on datasets released
after training. We find that LLMs perform better on datasets seen during
training, indicating that memorization leads to overfitting. At the same time,
LLMs show non-trivial performance on novel datasets and are surprisingly robust
to data transformations. We then investigate the in-context statistical
learning abilities of LLMs. Without fine-tuning, we find them to be limited.
This suggests that much of the few-shot performance on novel datasets is due to
the LLM's world knowledge. Overall, our results highlight the importance of
testing whether an LLM has seen an evaluation dataset during pre-training. We
make the exposure tests we developed available as the tabmemcheck Python
package at https://github.com/interpretml/LLM-Tabular-Memorization-Checker
|
[
-0.10358230024576187,
-0.8189970254898071,
0.4771549105644226,
0.05188199132680893,
-0.024050775915384293,
-0.0689631998538971,
-0.27861401438713074,
-0.2216191589832306,
-0.32269418239593506,
0.7458091378211975,
-0.17441411316394806,
-0.7940449714660645,
-0.4345764219760895,
-0.07750475406646729,
-0.6368764042854309,
1.1575723886489868,
-0.3895193338394165,
-0.15753507614135742,
-0.36851584911346436,
-0.2560020685195923,
-0.3460709750652313,
-0.4673230051994324,
-0.42829909920692444,
-0.5052527189254761,
0.5893297791481018,
0.517683744430542,
0.33999940752983093,
0.990128219127655,
0.517439603805542,
0.18691210448741913,
0.022030306980013847,
0.22455917298793793,
-0.7589274644851685,
0.018672257661819458,
-0.0010832638945430517,
-0.8137149214744568,
-0.3101743459701538,
-0.2652837038040161,
0.8560503125190735,
0.8173826932907104,
-0.31993165612220764,
0.4595510959625244,
0.09402237832546234,
0.7665709257125854,
-0.5680480003356934,
0.32978808879852295,
-1.1794025897979736,
0.27743300795555115,
-0.37525370717048645,
-0.24661493301391602,
-0.44037535786628723,
-0.3784235715866089,
-0.051957160234451294,
-0.6363251805305481,
0.2900203466415405,
0.16118685901165009,
0.823042631149292,
0.15390843152999878,
-0.5675647854804993,
-0.16861492395401,
-0.7186267375946045,
0.9228973388671875,
-0.2993822395801544,
0.44633767008781433,
0.6250074505805969,
0.39086660742759705,
-0.4251890778541565,
-0.5779366493225098,
-0.4865990877151489,
-0.417426198720932,
0.08358336240053177,
-0.07254426926374435,
0.02921922691166401,
-0.07837589830160141,
0.4777277112007141,
0.36820462346076965,
-0.8528056740760803,
0.11142130196094513,
-0.36861321330070496,
-0.12640057504177094,
0.3450168967247009,
0.25031784176826477,
0.3259422779083252,
0.18598021566867828,
-0.2815030813217163,
-0.11590379476547241,
-1.0498168468475342,
-0.0589338093996048,
0.08554420620203018,
0.16809402406215668,
0.07105778157711029,
0.5267509818077087,
0.06563212722539902,
0.622443675994873,
-0.4028902053833008,
-0.2594977021217346,
0.21609151363372803,
0.05876966193318367,
-0.3474205732345581,
0.04102906584739685,
0.3786373734474182,
0.12448742240667343,
0.6121877431869507,
-0.24673904478549957,
-0.2893301546573639,
0.05526560917496681,
0.17200401425361633,
-0.5091502666473389,
-0.2896824777126312,
0.03281410411000252,
-0.23992198705673218,
0.0247944388538599,
-0.4468843638896942,
-0.4661027491092682,
-0.43467026948928833,
-0.24832257628440857,
0.6462683081626892,
-0.502770185470581,
0.047951631247997284,
0.02412458509206772,
0.20455989241600037,
0.11949978768825531,
0.35652023553848267,
-1.0581130981445312,
0.5076432228088379,
0.9061923623085022,
0.5483534336090088,
-0.12648513913154602,
-0.7723925113677979,
-0.5139003396034241,
0.36759141087532043,
-0.8278390765190125,
0.8889461159706116,
-0.32643499970436096,
-0.11490045487880707,
0.1799560934305191,
-0.1709350347518921,
-0.20117835700511932,
-0.9950965046882629,
0.3103351593017578,
-0.4629521071910858,
-0.38554152846336365,
-0.3499886393547058,
-0.8173675537109375,
-0.22675862908363342,
0.4666711986064911,
-0.7278743982315063,
0.8945858478546143,
0.05015551298856735,
-0.5939726829528809,
0.9226880669593811,
-0.217357337474823,
-0.43677806854248047,
-0.09704285860061646,
-0.33895280957221985,
-0.7707064747810364,
-0.01848861761391163,
0.04708200693130493,
0.35452204942703247,
0.04541400447487831,
0.16413965821266174,
-0.4545486867427826,
-0.25394245982170105,
0.3594043254852295,
-0.20180994272232056,
0.31218189001083374,
0.032480210065841675,
0.1599489003419876,
-0.17596639692783356,
-0.7731577157974243,
0.0679185688495636,
0.0910307765007019,
-0.558313250541687,
-0.1067659929394722,
0.0008902063709683716,
-0.01817854307591915,
-0.057408206164836884,
-0.03526286035776138,
-0.3324050307273865,
0.22016780078411102,
0.023227345198392868,
0.20771126449108124,
0.6086175441741943,
0.021864863112568855,
0.31946122646331787,
-0.6945632100105286,
0.28920790553092957,
0.2297089695930481,
-0.23209750652313232,
-0.42782825231552124,
-0.00004697605254477821,
-0.8528228402137756,
-0.052742235362529755,
0.18024404346942902,
0.595742404460907,
-0.5698200464248657,
0.13046391308307648,
-0.268929660320282,
-0.5914763808250427,
-0.009403901174664497,
0.581983208656311,
0.2650931775569916,
0.5835120677947998,
0.20104795694351196,
-0.25275927782058716,
-0.622674822807312,
-0.868057131767273,
-0.6082265377044678,
-0.2646389603614807,
0.02256605215370655,
0.40778303146362305,
0.6914042830467224,
-0.015287428162992,
0.6850292682647705,
-0.30280157923698425,
-0.5537876486778259,
-0.6457993984222412,
0.18764089047908783,
0.178737074136734,
0.44780468940734863,
0.48009827733039856,
-0.2117907553911209,
-0.43004000186920166,
0.07442701607942581,
-0.8478416800498962,
0.07394398003816605,
-0.27162471413612366,
0.09948936104774475,
0.2654043436050415,
0.47548574209213257,
-0.7530081272125244,
0.387460321187973,
0.12025590240955353,
0.11429101228713989,
0.33904412388801575,
-0.3857877552509308,
-0.14365987479686737,
-0.533038318157196,
0.14344850182533264,
-0.0313047356903553,
-0.27357345819473267,
-0.6771339774131775,
-0.2920452654361725,
0.3173205852508545,
-0.025150856003165245,
-0.47253766655921936,
0.5596596002578735,
-0.5410267114639282,
-0.3206116557121277,
0.004325978457927704,
-0.01537854503840208,
-0.07487258315086365,
0.37703773379325867,
-0.028305822983384132,
0.7558532953262329,
0.7281940579414368,
-0.679953932762146,
-0.10550743341445923,
0.2957334816455841,
-0.8147460222244263,
0.33861246705055237,
-0.29877009987831116,
0.17703181505203247,
-0.349295437335968,
0.2605968713760376,
-1.0662755966186523,
-0.1332119256258011,
-0.17969970405101776,
-0.2294589728116989,
0.6066086888313293,
-0.18909911811351776,
-0.6525090932846069,
-0.21438008546829224,
-0.12006732821464539,
0.19864808022975922,
0.2772042155265808,
-0.49681252241134644,
0.2503258287906647,
0.6136239171028137,
-0.008467505685985088,
-0.8278606534004211,
-0.7778077125549316,
0.00011157989501953125,
-0.6160494089126587,
-0.21044620871543884,
-0.11505720019340515,
0.18122375011444092,
-0.13060429692268372,
-0.32914960384368896,
-0.4031991958618164,
-0.41726747155189514,
0.23479777574539185,
0.17583337426185608,
0.12193431705236435,
-0.17501381039619446,
0.4955785572528839,
-0.348684161901474,
-0.01775328628718853,
-0.04125114530324936,
-0.08116817474365234,
0.5970558524131775,
-0.21485915780067444,
-0.2547302842140198,
-0.21994435787200928,
-0.13809840381145477,
0.3175344467163086,
-0.021317826583981514,
0.7402278184890747,
0.5202035307884216,
-0.6034144759178162,
-0.41714152693748474,
-0.7469291090965271,
0.003245499450713396,
-0.42309969663619995,
0.7753608822822571,
-0.24676008522510529,
-0.369009792804718,
0.7835860252380371,
0.14324942231178284,
0.159494549036026,
-0.014722906053066254,
0.3846970200538635,
-0.341327965259552,
0.4666007459163666,
0.6534540057182312,
-0.4180953800678253,
0.5515238642692566,
-0.4240832030773163,
0.062405116856098175,
-0.5905100107192993,
-0.1916222721338272,
-0.5357003808021545,
-0.25558212399482727,
-0.4607490599155426,
-0.08727382123470306,
0.3275596499443054,
-0.015447689220309258,
-0.3873881995677948,
0.1442343294620514,
0.22632159292697906,
0.8514840602874756,
0.09544482082128525,
0.17674291133880615,
0.3483521640300751,
0.20101715624332428,
0.08000550419092178,
-0.07840048521757126,
-0.6865812540054321,
-0.5887381434440613,
1.5492708683013916,
0.399585485458374,
1.1105000972747803,
-0.30316632986068726,
0.6771299242973328,
0.02259221114218235,
0.49028584361076355,
-0.6457533836364746,
0.515960693359375,
-0.1506267935037613,
-0.5034250617027283,
-0.4066668450832367,
-0.6519576907157898,
-1.3168808221817017,
0.16470062732696533,
0.03283846005797386,
-0.8230639696121216,
-0.21632935106754303,
0.43776094913482666,
-0.3180610239505768,
0.4766403138637543,
-0.605970561504364,
0.9303388595581055,
-0.3794914782047272,
-0.39202502369880676,
-0.1635652333498001,
-0.25676801800727844,
0.29548799991607666,
-0.3027333915233612,
0.21284176409244537,
-0.1791091412305832,
-0.03876008465886116,
0.9705222845077515,
-0.08226277679204941,
0.6851389408111572,
0.0374181866645813,
0.04543634131550789,
0.28950247168540955,
0.4208478629589081,
0.3328612446784973,
-0.09698046743869781,
0.12307263165712357,
0.12540565431118011,
-0.11539602279663086,
-0.29896023869514465,
-0.4250641465187073,
0.7151075005531311,
-0.6918691396713257,
-0.4295309782028198,
-0.32310131192207336,
-0.7391322255134583,
-0.2585114538669586,
0.2188652604818344,
0.058352839201688766,
0.34088873863220215,
-0.2582193613052368,
0.3635483384132385,
0.8890348076820374,
-0.229930579662323,
0.3486027419567108,
0.5277768969535828,
-0.3930138647556305,
-0.18887856602668762,
0.9769238233566284,
0.7132645845413208,
0.18148685991764069,
0.47546446323394775,
-0.024679213762283325,
-0.11505243927240372,
-0.6992543935775757,
-0.44361069798469543,
0.2836872935295105,
-0.7798717617988586,
-0.19044454395771027,
-0.5691133141517639,
-0.051452867686748505,
-0.05008427053689957,
0.14021587371826172,
-0.45628273487091064,
-0.405799001455307,
-0.1510910838842392,
-0.2529478073120117,
0.42989450693130493,
0.740729570388794,
-0.06372964382171631,
0.27846559882164,
-0.6362893581390381,
0.30932971835136414,
0.2816922664642334,
0.3840227425098419,
0.12797753512859344,
-0.4882340133190155,
-0.32255062460899353,
-0.23876063525676727,
-0.5509078502655029,
-0.5995140075683594,
0.5403162240982056,
0.5111711025238037,
0.8137492537498474,
0.3784318268299103,
-0.4432509243488312,
0.7016947865486145,
-0.5858017802238464,
0.43507370352745056,
-0.2846246361732483,
-0.7131667137145996,
0.3638935983181,
-0.40439313650131226,
0.18745873868465424,
0.6316551566123962,
0.35665860772132874,
-0.6458092927932739,
-0.23578883707523346,
-0.46624037623405457,
-0.8149667978286743,
0.7445327639579773,
-0.05586637556552887,
-0.059114061295986176,
0.2516898512840271,
0.3860413730144501,
0.30532896518707275,
0.499625027179718,
-0.772676408290863,
-0.22268317639827728,
0.08334321528673172,
-0.0701008215546608,
-0.24927085638046265,
-0.17623288929462433,
0.041002850979566574,
-0.14980675280094147,
0.40505948662757874,
0.10674493759870529,
-0.1565140336751938,
-0.1168784499168396,
-0.6757792830467224,
-0.33314335346221924,
0.278622031211853,
0.41241857409477234,
1.0543509721755981,
-0.22743938863277435,
0.23450586199760437,
0.5655351281166077,
-0.5695552825927734,
0.058084458112716675,
-0.3464116156101227,
-0.07467648386955261,
-0.04431959614157677,
0.4926294684410095,
0.7187255620956421,
0.23486128449440002,
-0.6678723096847534,
0.2810136377811432,
0.13472521305084229,
0.03686809539794922,
-0.5003324747085571,
0.14461839199066162,
0.009814128279685974,
-0.1586558073759079,
0.27413636445999146,
-0.2100391983985901,
-0.016079295426607132,
-0.9781295657157898,
0.42873328924179077,
0.2804606258869171,
-0.0805983915925026,
-0.18328598141670227,
0.3793690502643585,
-0.5979108810424805,
-0.23160241544246674,
0.6765862703323364,
0.11512307077646255,
-0.5445755124092102,
0.8811017870903015,
0.6330252289772034,
0.48515310883522034,
-0.35723546147346497,
-0.03588688746094704,
0.30387863516807556,
0.50982666015625,
-0.10618782043457031,
0.24799200892448425,
-0.1403990238904953,
-0.5984185934066772,
-0.08479369431734085,
-0.3467424511909485,
-0.36606332659721375,
0.6711714267730713,
-0.6321346759796143,
0.26229631900787354,
-0.41761672496795654,
0.007354023400694132,
-0.119154192507267,
0.023368656635284424,
-0.9508349895477295,
0.17314039170742035,
0.16820211708545685,
0.865289568901062,
-1.130914330482483,
0.8038071393966675,
0.4751425087451935,
-0.20368939638137817,
-0.6946002840995789,
0.0013166231801733375,
-0.12778206169605255,
-1.0217372179031372,
0.7534424662590027,
0.233720600605011,
0.428739458322525,
-0.2912455201148987,
-0.5065226554870605,
-0.835249125957489,
0.8502669334411621,
0.4008104205131531,
-0.4449603855609894,
0.19954022765159607,
0.6194515228271484,
0.6701259016990662,
-0.07288198918104172,
0.5015047788619995,
1.0327938795089722,
0.3631149232387543,
-0.16920986771583557,
-1.0463168621063232,
-0.3923913240432739,
0.08175776153802872,
-0.14495322108268738,
0.12174020707607269,
-0.6003411412239075,
1.0285310745239258,
-0.2999834418296814,
-0.10250429064035416,
-0.12358121573925018,
0.4318828284740448,
0.3255366384983063,
0.5147579312324524,
0.3458547294139862,
0.7005025148391724,
0.8793371915817261,
-0.024747885763645172,
0.8913161158561707,
0.11037220060825348,
0.4725835621356964,
1.2744945287704468,
-0.5232460498809814,
0.9152117967605591,
0.4877617359161377,
-0.19456727802753448,
-0.059557635337114334,
0.5752391219139099,
-0.057242926210165024,
0.47384798526763916,
0.4657869338989258,
0.12341925501823425,
-0.24959447979927063,
0.0774550661444664,
-0.3214889466762543,
0.40652143955230713,
0.6008275747299194,
-0.09808507561683655,
-0.7380477786064148,
0.10182546079158783,
0.1401849240064621,
0.002328544622287154,
-0.4586375057697296,
0.9431720972061157,
0.20937830209732056,
-0.4585944414138794,
0.9479537010192871,
-0.5402237772941589,
-0.008782904595136642,
-0.5978310704231262,
-0.08396749943494797,
-0.5222482681274414,
0.41641274094581604,
-0.2859596312046051,
-0.8523166179656982,
0.13662558794021606,
-0.05234457179903984,
0.0015208402182906866,
-0.13148702681064606,
0.4007774889469147,
-0.7085681557655334,
-0.45258021354675293,
0.06367816030979156,
0.39037078619003296,
0.5157614350318909,
0.11506032943725586,
-0.3490733206272125,
0.08395033329725266,
-0.07147448509931564,
-0.28348666429519653,
0.5396199822425842,
0.531299889087677,
-0.14375261962413788,
1.2315281629562378,
0.3379612863063812,
0.3575613498687744,
0.23154398798942566,
0.013873856514692307,
0.6968256235122681,
-0.5712665915489197,
-0.36253443360328674,
-0.9623448848724365,
0.08885661512613297,
0.23788271844387054,
-0.1881026178598404,
0.7871583700180054,
0.9669442176818848,
0.969375491142273,
-0.25714829564094543,
0.6847987771034241,
0.5886005759239197,
0.6243014931678772,
-0.5948241353034973,
0.9545276165008545,
-0.401053786277771,
0.3146775960922241,
-0.16206975281238556,
-0.7804643511772156,
-0.4934685528278351,
0.6938146352767944,
-0.6145836710929871,
-0.08606474846601486,
0.7271594405174255,
0.8381921052932739,
-0.1321193128824234,
-0.21097075939178467,
0.4795779585838318,
0.4209214150905609,
0.36572304368019104,
0.8875060677528381,
0.9956256747245789,
-0.4791926145553589,
0.7678906917572021,
-0.14512433111667633,
0.06025204807519913,
-0.23713576793670654,
-0.7697185277938843,
-1.0548326969146729,
-0.3927837014198303,
-0.18812225759029388,
-0.10509897023439407,
0.09939219802618027,
0.6963407397270203,
0.5089861154556274,
-0.9456691145896912,
-0.5489093065261841,
-0.06115976721048355,
0.3183318078517914,
-0.003858450800180435,
-0.15071555972099304,
0.5811400413513184,
-0.5106276273727417,
-0.284873902797699,
0.21546615660190582,
0.13713690638542175,
0.22231820225715637,
0.032499223947525024,
0.28522616624832153,
0.14973938465118408,
-0.14218537509441376,
0.27890604734420776,
0.34534594416618347,
-0.3487458825111389,
-0.1543879359960556,
-0.2310427576303482,
-0.09694357216358185,
0.5046374797821045,
0.8077023029327393,
-0.7533378601074219,
0.3120654225349426,
0.3505653440952301,
0.5922144651412964,
0.7431552410125732,
-0.30060452222824097,
0.31128397583961487,
-0.6285319924354553,
0.19185109436511993,
0.13245584070682526,
0.6073231101036072,
0.3425832688808441,
-0.19957615435123444,
0.22789965569972992,
-0.20411516726016998,
-0.8140719532966614,
-1.120395302772522,
-0.007466625887900591,
-0.7317908406257629,
0.15515348315238953,
0.9369280338287354,
-0.3174724280834198,
-0.486532986164093,
-0.15268953144550323,
-0.12034092098474503,
0.20495828986167908,
-0.29562196135520935,
1.1751344203948975,
0.6982245445251465,
0.13117048144340515,
-0.1522374004125595,
-0.8548935651779175,
0.6039372086524963,
0.4938957095146179,
-0.9235580563545227,
0.38915905356407166,
0.25902366638183594,
0.6425198912620544,
-0.16284874081611633,
0.43978166580200195,
0.06231154128909111,
0.24482513964176178,
-0.008379172533750534,
-0.1442755162715912,
0.0069947149604558945,
-0.593124508857727,
-0.345276802778244,
0.01190416980534792,
0.2273106724023819,
-0.2922443747520447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06186v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06186v1
|
Clue-Instruct: Text-Based Clue Generation for Educational Crossword Puzzles
| 2024-04-09T10:12:34 | 2024-04-09T10:12:34 |
Andrea Zugarini, Kamyar Zeinalipour, Surya Sai Kadali, Marco Maggini, Marco Gori, Leonardo Rigutini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Crossword puzzles are popular linguistic games often used as tools to engage
students in learning. Educational crosswords are characterized by less cryptic
and more factual clues that distinguish them from traditional crossword
puzzles. Despite there exist several publicly available clue-answer pair
databases for traditional crosswords, educational clue-answer pairs datasets
are missing. In this article, we propose a methodology to build educational
clue generation datasets that can be used to instruct Large Language Models
(LLMs). By gathering from Wikipedia pages informative content associated with
relevant keywords, we use Large Language Models to automatically generate
pedagogical clues related to the given input keyword and its context. With such
an approach, we created clue-instruct, a dataset containing 44,075 unique
examples with text-keyword pairs associated with three distinct crossword
clues. We used clue-instruct to instruct different LLMs to generate educational
clues from a given input content and keyword. Both human and automatic
evaluations confirmed the quality of the generated clues, thus validating the
effectiveness of our approach.
|
[
-0.24848385155200958,
-0.7238142490386963,
0.5921911597251892,
-0.07023356109857559,
-0.40444961190223694,
0.25491195917129517,
-0.44675472378730774,
-0.3281351923942566,
0.08941861242055893,
0.5350792407989502,
-0.7483068108558655,
-0.8327606320381165,
-0.29728421568870544,
0.1550721824169159,
-0.639936089515686,
1.1031805276870728,
-0.06375262886285782,
0.23528733849525452,
-0.7766777873039246,
0.28334733843803406,
-0.38319745659828186,
-0.35781359672546387,
-0.43122780323028564,
-0.21665892004966736,
0.45181432366371155,
0.7147071361541748,
0.31361448764801025,
0.8696340918540955,
0.44996121525764465,
0.15062463283538818,
0.1378571093082428,
0.21758310496807098,
-0.6112856864929199,
0.26416224241256714,
-0.4249473810195923,
-0.49629485607147217,
0.10544393956661224,
0.23890650272369385,
0.3546364903450012,
0.8076571226119995,
-0.1508525013923645,
0.36300235986709595,
0.09409631043672562,
0.31094253063201904,
-0.5795252323150635,
0.014482935890555382,
-0.8373945355415344,
-0.06370020657777786,
-0.4481782615184784,
-0.3038913607597351,
-0.4432830214500427,
-0.45262646675109863,
0.22817863523960114,
-0.6733934879302979,
0.5245774388313293,
-0.06869925558567047,
0.529229998588562,
-0.05186842754483223,
-0.10186263173818588,
-1.0093477964401245,
-0.4574267566204071,
0.5674179196357727,
-0.6594927310943604,
0.22210052609443665,
0.4106793999671936,
0.22415457665920258,
-0.3264327943325043,
-0.6404210925102234,
-0.41259607672691345,
-0.13899865746498108,
0.1002722829580307,
0.10152338445186615,
0.5976324677467346,
-0.16655458509922028,
0.17407725751399994,
0.1333722174167633,
-0.5752139091491699,
0.08391519635915756,
-0.09459352493286133,
0.19447185099124908,
0.7397910952568054,
0.38354232907295227,
0.4813319444656372,
-0.08117682486772537,
-0.29915913939476013,
-0.13763411343097687,
-1.2893222570419312,
0.021368224173784256,
0.42354628443717957,
0.501143217086792,
-0.14359033107757568,
0.7353238463401794,
-0.13434197008609772,
0.7513906359672546,
0.17030474543571472,
-0.3609027862548828,
-0.017644032835960388,
-0.5391741991043091,
0.34979212284088135,
0.5221243500709534,
0.7365539073944092,
0.3848186731338501,
0.3329550623893738,
-0.44079551100730896,
-0.2747778594493866,
0.2942158877849579,
-0.20525607466697693,
-0.8072229623794556,
-0.32225775718688965,
-0.1274302899837494,
-0.22645266354084015,
-0.4892420470714569,
-0.14817090332508087,
-0.9121164083480835,
-0.21779389679431915,
0.03495941311120987,
0.6121813654899597,
-0.31181949377059937,
0.06863279640674591,
0.21591249108314514,
-0.12459557503461838,
0.2748715281486511,
0.14165514707565308,
-1.0730218887329102,
0.2002473622560501,
0.6358309388160706,
0.509577214717865,
-0.08333493769168854,
-0.043968819081783295,
-0.4672694206237793,
0.39923354983329773,
-0.3427220582962036,
0.4846143126487732,
-0.943449854850769,
-0.6718270778656006,
0.3402659595012665,
-0.1373613327741623,
0.21975943446159363,
-0.4896002411842346,
0.4599297046661377,
-0.3230396807193756,
0.7719720602035522,
-0.23157602548599243,
-1.0254136323928833,
0.004652102943509817,
0.15483736991882324,
-0.4705594480037689,
1.0429800748825073,
-0.061261843889951706,
-0.865111231803894,
0.18545736372470856,
-0.5529070496559143,
-0.65194171667099,
0.4105224311351776,
-0.34191298484802246,
-0.09910400211811066,
0.007548633497208357,
0.6433300971984863,
0.45241987705230713,
-0.6288620233535767,
0.4051339328289032,
-0.13405317068099976,
-0.3889295160770416,
0.14697322249412537,
-0.18411307036876678,
0.9761941432952881,
-0.3604751527309418,
-0.4759906232357025,
-0.3339919447898865,
-0.7440931797027588,
-0.11843758076429367,
0.32235798239707947,
-0.31260138750076294,
-0.711201548576355,
0.1730853170156479,
0.00947666447609663,
0.11255670338869095,
0.2744859457015991,
-0.7433263063430786,
0.050366517156362534,
-0.5594062209129333,
0.011716438457369804,
0.43445172905921936,
0.14643944799900055,
0.1322171688079834,
-0.24792011082172394,
0.7257525324821472,
-0.1287064254283905,
-0.08464190363883972,
-0.36262786388397217,
-0.8323702216148376,
-0.5376826524734497,
0.13667580485343933,
0.34214311838150024,
0.5700222849845886,
-1.1581710577011108,
0.34978777170181274,
-0.23764723539352417,
-0.413938045501709,
-0.6524314284324646,
0.3427738845348358,
0.7035115957260132,
0.6437650322914124,
0.14968231320381165,
0.13778042793273926,
-0.23939284682273865,
-0.4875797927379608,
-0.2673450708389282,
0.14745603501796722,
-0.106060691177845,
0.2883549928665161,
0.599847137928009,
0.2015398144721985,
0.8170682787895203,
-0.4108092784881592,
0.004395766649395227,
0.04506460577249527,
0.05242583155632019,
0.004907036200165749,
0.3763965666294098,
0.4662892818450928,
-0.5389830470085144,
-0.5580843687057495,
-0.15212512016296387,
-0.7109172344207764,
0.05411777272820473,
0.14540721476078033,
-0.12754768133163452,
-0.09916699677705765,
0.53021240234375,
-0.2517649531364441,
0.17981860041618347,
0.46025869250297546,
-0.3085058033466339,
0.27959486842155457,
-0.0022393192630261183,
-0.3146328926086426,
-1.3818033933639526,
-0.27724412083625793,
-0.02057855762541294,
0.05475930869579315,
-0.2047692984342575,
0.15264372527599335,
-0.029162289574742317,
-0.2417239099740982,
-0.1420038640499115,
0.4905907213687897,
-0.6029263734817505,
0.17878010869026184,
0.10251948982477188,
0.8033774495124817,
-0.1997213214635849,
0.16408610343933105,
0.18166139721870422,
0.5652811527252197,
0.5913659334182739,
-0.4676859378814697,
0.7074236869812012,
0.3474869728088379,
-0.6835737228393555,
0.6233096718788147,
-0.5662777423858643,
0.43875062465667725,
-0.11863535642623901,
0.15880624949932098,
-0.8954998850822449,
-0.389415979385376,
0.238264262676239,
-0.3827488124370575,
0.3711385130882263,
-0.14811629056930542,
-0.6032091975212097,
-0.33679643273353577,
-0.2109825611114502,
0.3082595467567444,
0.33227667212486267,
-1.0451364517211914,
0.08605318516492844,
0.5347306728363037,
-0.39375922083854675,
-0.640311598777771,
-0.3559311330318451,
0.17351946234703064,
-0.1387956589460373,
-0.45651012659072876,
0.2968232333660126,
-0.2843787670135498,
-0.02349420078098774,
0.4634147584438324,
0.10408812761306763,
0.06868497282266617,
-0.009058208204805851,
0.15386062860488892,
0.36079010367393494,
-0.2895675599575043,
0.5202375650405884,
0.23481541872024536,
0.16233673691749573,
0.39276552200317383,
-0.2434154748916626,
0.31974881887435913,
0.5181628465652466,
-0.3727549612522125,
0.1171841025352478,
0.6824339032173157,
0.2925552427768707,
-0.4514615535736084,
0.2911035120487213,
0.5164658427238464,
-0.4402034282684326,
-0.8553021550178528,
-0.34889423847198486,
-0.527169406414032,
-0.4600785970687866,
0.4778951108455658,
-0.17414870858192444,
-0.8175276517868042,
0.24053074419498444,
-0.22781318426132202,
0.28066447377204895,
-0.025295035913586617,
0.559907853603363,
-0.26000502705574036,
0.8453499674797058,
0.47704774141311646,
0.13258761167526245,
0.3024631142616272,
-0.16201470792293549,
0.06202822923660278,
-0.5870131254196167,
-0.643545389175415,
-0.5854148864746094,
-0.23487603664398193,
-0.6112778186798096,
-0.41637513041496277,
0.26779064536094666,
-0.2976837456226349,
0.1219046413898468,
0.040078479796648026,
-0.5981665849685669,
0.6537023186683655,
0.7194077372550964,
0.3817298710346222,
0.007484829053282738,
0.2162112146615982,
-0.27170783281326294,
-0.021672822535037994,
-0.9768632054328918,
-0.26236239075660706,
1.5140838623046875,
-0.14898335933685303,
1.0948816537857056,
-0.07005167007446289,
1.2529536485671997,
-0.15224041044712067,
0.3522355854511261,
-0.8651100993156433,
0.5935735702514648,
-0.2717415988445282,
-0.8171700239181519,
-0.2906048893928528,
-0.42504945397377014,
-0.8617589473724365,
-0.46819546818733215,
-0.4864107370376587,
-0.42573684453964233,
-0.1680392473936081,
-0.12957394123077393,
-0.23014293611049652,
0.08816249668598175,
-0.39933282136917114,
0.6690633893013,
-0.5016725659370422,
-0.37199896574020386,
-0.21076856553554535,
-0.5648037791252136,
0.48890435695648193,
-0.23307642340660095,
0.1102752834558487,
0.1895201951265335,
-0.0954199880361557,
1.0766428709030151,
-0.19971001148223877,
0.9634895324707031,
-0.03444767743349075,
-0.44131845235824585,
0.3896782398223877,
-0.05182133987545967,
0.6369075179100037,
0.08895066380500793,
0.12974750995635986,
-0.4360567331314087,
-0.21921125054359436,
0.0342402346432209,
-0.576700747013092,
0.9336604475975037,
-0.5607122778892517,
-0.653467059135437,
0.06296002864837646,
-0.8131146430969238,
-0.33138662576675415,
0.0777248665690422,
0.6220584511756897,
0.8979976177215576,
-0.21254700422286987,
0.2957480251789093,
1.1785345077514648,
-0.2928128242492676,
0.578294038772583,
0.4119657278060913,
-0.03673664480447769,
-0.37730661034584045,
1.0036098957061768,
0.1639316827058792,
0.08312101662158966,
0.5992518067359924,
0.25174617767333984,
-0.5653319358825684,
-0.49681857228279114,
-0.415669322013855,
0.3294878900051117,
-0.8186658620834351,
-0.24489448964595795,
-0.18528735637664795,
-0.32420358061790466,
-0.12342888116836548,
-0.2101728469133377,
-0.10776408016681671,
-0.1784559041261673,
-0.10546272248029709,
-0.08649633824825287,
0.5052722096443176,
1.1044690608978271,
0.08381419628858566,
0.27732840180397034,
-0.7246780395507812,
0.37055009603500366,
0.6255418062210083,
0.43771520256996155,
-0.29966598749160767,
-0.40063387155532837,
-0.5959230065345764,
0.2055332064628601,
0.18892371654510498,
-1.1044621467590332,
-0.02222120203077793,
0.2949528396129608,
0.6797903180122375,
0.4446057081222534,
0.1851053088903427,
0.11126472800970078,
-0.6005935668945312,
0.8030297756195068,
0.23684416711330414,
-0.7683836221694946,
0.6803390979766846,
-0.33616286516189575,
0.17668069899082184,
0.3288642168045044,
0.5838024616241455,
-0.4068191349506378,
-0.3910549581050873,
-0.6663485169410706,
-0.7252388000488281,
0.5588186979293823,
-0.042799439281225204,
0.1739571988582611,
-0.08045348525047302,
0.41557303071022034,
0.29574936628341675,
0.2601836025714874,
-0.41742733120918274,
-0.3851078450679779,
0.007413649931550026,
-0.7703858017921448,
-0.08416908979415894,
-0.28779131174087524,
-0.396331250667572,
-0.06255976855754852,
0.5684502124786377,
-0.014897068962454796,
0.02670852653682232,
-0.20220611989498138,
-0.16695138812065125,
-0.12168911099433899,
-0.05572886765003204,
0.49630674719810486,
0.567878246307373,
-0.2330845594406128,
0.014672745019197464,
-0.28917196393013,
-0.7897774577140808,
0.22193774580955505,
-0.02919149398803711,
-0.5150125622749329,
0.45754507184028625,
0.4259141683578491,
0.5271468162536621,
0.49303069710731506,
-0.6613016128540039,
0.4894962012767792,
-0.0677744522690773,
-0.06471598893404007,
-0.24291671812534332,
0.17688564956188202,
0.47443366050720215,
0.049822848290205,
0.11722653359174728,
-0.5902175307273865,
-0.032591916620731354,
-0.4676734209060669,
0.2623398005962372,
0.7573807835578918,
-0.1850968450307846,
-0.26137521862983704,
0.5432075262069702,
0.6405568718910217,
-0.6279543042182922,
0.7711805701255798,
-0.25276979804039,
-0.4727720618247986,
0.537838876247406,
0.8292573690414429,
1.020797848701477,
-0.3374885618686676,
0.42427003383636475,
0.5391783118247986,
0.4272044003009796,
0.1045166552066803,
0.41314658522605896,
-0.07313784211874008,
-0.7760166525840759,
-0.40461382269859314,
-0.313554048538208,
-0.4194558560848236,
0.3471035063266754,
-0.6273010969161987,
0.22946108877658844,
-0.4383063316345215,
0.07335127890110016,
0.04963822662830353,
0.09420497715473175,
-0.8255110383033752,
0.26736345887184143,
0.4711054861545563,
0.8412191271781921,
-0.8719111084938049,
0.8817241191864014,
0.9255991578102112,
-0.2552303969860077,
-0.9324841499328613,
0.07026568800210953,
-0.13985250890254974,
-0.716163158416748,
0.7170501351356506,
-0.08550142496824265,
-0.1135021224617958,
0.20802082121372223,
-1.0384728908538818,
-0.6730716228485107,
0.7547891736030579,
0.24258168041706085,
-0.7828171253204346,
-0.39642512798309326,
0.2865056097507477,
0.17421488463878632,
-0.8050476908683777,
-0.0216092336922884,
0.19009175896644592,
0.2608836591243744,
0.048872608691453934,
-0.4468705952167511,
0.10416145622730255,
-0.12865221500396729,
-0.09743251651525497,
0.06584946811199188,
-0.1221199631690979,
0.5926004648208618,
-0.3568597435951233,
-0.3013814091682434,
0.06930141150951385,
0.5027831196784973,
0.20938299596309662,
0.309496134519577,
0.28992190957069397,
0.749211311340332,
0.6958208680152893,
0.005617338698357344,
0.6157591342926025,
-0.6042572259902954,
0.2739541530609131,
1.4327479600906372,
0.024739347398281097,
0.8982680439949036,
0.49268844723701477,
0.04507453739643097,
0.5623167157173157,
0.6371545195579529,
-0.09957754611968994,
0.5642837285995483,
0.2760830819606781,
-0.42702677845954895,
-0.3485340178012848,
-0.18109354376792908,
-0.5363211631774902,
0.5672877430915833,
0.8215088248252869,
-0.344709187746048,
-0.5929842591285706,
-0.042492322623729706,
0.028691647574305534,
0.28416135907173157,
-0.3665178120136261,
0.6052764654159546,
0.007080120034515858,
-0.6270110011100769,
0.374210387468338,
-0.3394352197647095,
0.7363763451576233,
-0.6418871283531189,
-0.39710044860839844,
-0.39589229226112366,
0.04895707219839096,
0.05793377757072449,
-0.9674239158630371,
-0.5383260846138,
0.11773041635751724,
-0.08166144043207169,
0.12443780899047852,
0.46879151463508606,
-1.1183500289916992,
-0.728004515171051,
0.06638950109481812,
0.4373186528682709,
0.05348566174507141,
0.3336135745048523,
-0.5241754055023193,
-0.390989750623703,
-0.1120084896683693,
0.06889154016971588,
0.20139746367931366,
0.9653357267379761,
0.13900849223136902,
0.62669438123703,
0.5212893486022949,
0.1590345948934555,
0.27410274744033813,
-0.13819889724254608,
0.7377309203147888,
-0.451345294713974,
-0.3664049804210663,
-0.5448058843612671,
0.2566947042942047,
-0.04832614213228226,
-0.39632636308670044,
1.0008881092071533,
0.507182776927948,
1.1088898181915283,
-0.25633737444877625,
0.9940294027328491,
0.09795653820037842,
0.5404310822486877,
-0.5247782468795776,
0.663580060005188,
-0.465685099363327,
0.118004709482193,
-0.30212247371673584,
-0.8089515566825867,
0.00034229332231916487,
0.2799569070339203,
-0.007266755681484938,
-0.037481360137462616,
0.5780031085014343,
0.951431930065155,
-0.01144169457256794,
0.04804474860429764,
0.05446993559598923,
-0.04782041534781456,
0.02432241477072239,
0.685718297958374,
0.9453073740005493,
-0.3532404899597168,
0.6247199177742004,
-0.5349900126457214,
-0.18583829700946808,
-0.3452383875846863,
-0.6908770799636841,
-1.4020718336105347,
-0.7068321704864502,
-0.405416876077652,
-0.29223915934562683,
0.2731155455112457,
0.8166788816452026,
0.35876595973968506,
-0.7557471394538879,
-0.3756377696990967,
-0.04047904536128044,
0.29709169268608093,
-0.08499306440353394,
-0.2343326210975647,
0.5593254566192627,
-0.34477439522743225,
-0.7283700704574585,
0.463436096906662,
0.031073743477463722,
0.08564592897891998,
-0.516323447227478,
0.014293435961008072,
-0.38846927881240845,
0.19789376854896545,
0.3315165638923645,
0.050381727516651154,
-0.5317295789718628,
-0.3622717261314392,
0.21831564605236053,
-0.2599068582057953,
-0.3653876483440399,
0.82285475730896,
-0.8155189752578735,
0.8512288928031921,
0.5209742188453674,
0.7820490598678589,
0.329418808221817,
-0.3345092535018921,
0.6104720830917358,
-0.8783379793167114,
0.13475018739700317,
0.3299281597137451,
0.11625763028860092,
0.5278282761573792,
-0.38330259919166565,
0.465802401304245,
0.42774227261543274,
-0.1915433257818222,
-0.7947316765785217,
0.21544581651687622,
-0.539976179599762,
-0.13922162353992462,
0.9502416253089905,
-0.31045830249786377,
-0.41375499963760376,
-0.0509561225771904,
0.1903502196073532,
0.21767877042293549,
-0.15444771945476532,
0.88746577501297,
0.66826993227005,
0.4987865388393402,
-0.0756847932934761,
-0.2308499813079834,
0.6400036811828613,
0.028330810368061066,
-0.7050286531448364,
0.02183893509209156,
0.19562985002994537,
0.3231016993522644,
0.22234667837619781,
-0.024836191907525063,
0.013474179431796074,
0.329518586397171,
0.3770316243171692,
0.20378009974956512,
-0.06944207102060318,
-0.39137259125709534,
0.2184588611125946,
0.0762973204255104,
-0.28206774592399597,
-0.5686075091362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06162v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06162v2
|
Characterizing Multimodal Long-form Summarization: A Case Study on Financial Reports
| 2024-04-09T09:34:25 | 2024-05-08T04:36:07 |
Tianyu Cao, Natraj Raman, Danial Dervovic, Chenhao Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
As large language models (LLMs) expand the power of natural language
processing to handle long inputs, rigorous and systematic analyses are
necessary to understand their abilities and behavior. A salient application is
summarization, due to its ubiquity and controversy (e.g., researchers have
declared the death of summarization). In this paper, we use financial report
summarization as a case study because financial reports not only are long but
also use numbers and tables extensively. We propose a computational framework
for characterizing multimodal long-form summarization and investigate the
behavior of Claude 2.0/2.1, GPT-4/3.5, and Command. We find that GPT-3.5 and
Command fail to perform this summarization task meaningfully. For Claude 2 and
GPT-4, we analyze the extractiveness of the summary and identify a position
bias in LLMs. This position bias disappears after shuffling the input for
Claude, which suggests that Claude has the ability to recognize important
information. We also conduct a comprehensive investigation on the use of
numeric data in LLM-generated summaries and offer a taxonomy of numeric
hallucination. We employ prompt engineering to improve GPT-4's use of numbers
with limited success. Overall, our analyses highlight the strong capability of
Claude 2 in handling long multimodal inputs compared to GPT-4.
|
[
-0.33486124873161316,
-0.9745088815689087,
0.7626478672027588,
0.6790543794631958,
-0.22114582359790802,
0.16634710133075714,
-0.3405793607234955,
-0.5227662324905396,
0.4372064769268036,
0.43391314148902893,
-0.23688994348049164,
-0.3417106866836548,
-0.8275608420372009,
0.22359707951545715,
-0.44856664538383484,
1.3052074909210205,
-0.13136930763721466,
0.008021888323128223,
-0.32282379269599915,
-0.1523599475622177,
-0.4686497747898102,
-0.7693331241607666,
-0.7074779272079468,
-0.20140907168388367,
0.8187741637229919,
0.22048866748809814,
0.6260640025138855,
0.29056793451309204,
0.6411788463592529,
0.391819030046463,
0.12130523473024368,
0.03282542526721954,
-0.5716172456741333,
0.1333102136850357,
0.281116783618927,
-0.19683881103992462,
-0.9887185096740723,
-0.028424536809325218,
0.8171684741973877,
0.534127414226532,
0.0024797962978482246,
0.07357937097549438,
0.0904935747385025,
0.8565006256103516,
-0.36520931124687195,
0.8109418153762817,
-0.13816815614700317,
-0.08784830570220947,
-0.35190683603286743,
-0.31383588910102844,
-0.4919493496417999,
-0.42651912569999695,
0.15884339809417725,
-0.5097569823265076,
0.011421911418437958,
-0.09638306498527527,
0.44759640097618103,
0.027128268033266068,
-0.8047764301300049,
-0.6170973181724548,
-0.6798496246337891,
0.7817472815513611,
-0.6964892745018005,
0.3230236768722534,
0.5123462080955505,
0.40609240531921387,
0.09088411927223206,
-0.7428277730941772,
-0.3410254120826721,
-0.32705187797546387,
-0.23769213259220123,
0.2803301215171814,
-0.268578439950943,
0.07977033406496048,
0.3822931945323944,
0.17135775089263916,
-0.7655734419822693,
0.14863444864749908,
-0.6510210037231445,
-0.2827828824520111,
0.444038450717926,
0.12787674367427826,
-0.08192569017410278,
-0.1792515516281128,
-0.3634166717529297,
-0.2682482898235321,
-0.3324465751647949,
0.12619420886039734,
0.37006738781929016,
0.2007512003183365,
-0.3807534873485565,
0.6798049211502075,
-0.0881071537733078,
0.49600425362586975,
-0.19823633134365082,
-0.42890143394470215,
0.2959401309490204,
-0.3341725766658783,
-0.295091450214386,
0.314371258020401,
0.6445522904396057,
0.7101908326148987,
0.5359193086624146,
0.028134100139141083,
-0.3954353928565979,
-0.11624625325202942,
0.06596129387617111,
-0.8243957161903381,
-0.03677791729569435,
0.2780088782310486,
-0.5441420078277588,
-0.38419124484062195,
0.032609328627586365,
-0.7782437801361084,
-0.36712175607681274,
-0.47637155652046204,
0.2953319549560547,
-0.38572975993156433,
0.012095660902559757,
0.019866598770022392,
-0.35643306374549866,
0.27736949920654297,
0.4356149137020111,
-1.0080718994140625,
0.41017472743988037,
0.7320013046264648,
0.731743574142456,
-0.17932085692882538,
-0.16296477615833282,
-0.8089504241943359,
0.2881529629230499,
-0.027616802603006363,
0.757963240146637,
-0.4364267587661743,
-0.43051019310951233,
-0.2102898359298706,
-0.08384904265403748,
0.046361733227968216,
-0.4177600145339966,
0.21204160153865814,
-0.6379346251487732,
0.22321705520153046,
-0.32900571823120117,
-0.3480755090713501,
-0.28802645206451416,
0.2582438588142395,
-0.9104984402656555,
0.529395580291748,
0.10036648064851761,
-0.7531742453575134,
0.44009390473365784,
-0.8693583011627197,
-0.568309485912323,
-0.19257530570030212,
-0.1888262927532196,
-0.5481280088424683,
0.11992800235748291,
0.1549891084432602,
0.6742120385169983,
-0.12562742829322815,
0.34649452567100525,
-0.39564049243927,
-0.2284553349018097,
0.5708565711975098,
-0.5140795707702637,
0.3915892243385315,
0.015725767239928246,
0.0640469491481781,
0.24248851835727692,
-0.8249272108078003,
-0.16656920313835144,
0.034362249076366425,
-0.2050219625234604,
-0.37593379616737366,
0.01791376993060112,
0.16643787920475006,
-0.03845119848847389,
0.26134154200553894,
0.013040110468864441,
0.19876067340373993,
-0.05660048499703407,
0.49485769867897034,
0.7857332825660706,
-0.02350820042192936,
0.36740642786026,
-0.39977553486824036,
0.5628368854522705,
-0.044980738312006,
-0.0896158367395401,
-0.5004488825798035,
-0.20662933588027954,
-0.3121000826358795,
-0.5928640365600586,
0.40363895893096924,
0.7058244943618774,
-0.6451335549354553,
-0.12145400792360306,
-0.2369614839553833,
-0.06799054890871048,
0.15425468981266022,
-0.03678712621331215,
0.06209725886583328,
0.29234349727630615,
0.3176114559173584,
-0.2202978879213333,
-0.395897775888443,
-1.3390130996704102,
-0.10460194200277328,
0.0009036206174641848,
-0.1467285454273224,
0.0032061925157904625,
0.4516669511795044,
-0.07243067771196365,
0.7513115406036377,
-0.47914984822273254,
-0.05237819254398346,
-0.43329569697380066,
0.5548017024993896,
0.4179784059524536,
0.1123025193810463,
0.6905766129493713,
-0.7151190042495728,
-0.11261478811502457,
-0.23303422331809998,
-0.9531394839286804,
-0.025104356929659843,
-0.5072348117828369,
0.21469055116176605,
0.2100686877965927,
0.5378883481025696,
-0.6084040403366089,
0.49787962436676025,
0.3587052524089813,
-0.23465947806835175,
0.4219013750553131,
-0.33725228905677795,
0.1426011621952057,
-0.8998400568962097,
0.05369703844189644,
0.28398197889328003,
-0.309661328792572,
-0.4377576410770416,
-0.25739744305610657,
0.2709936201572418,
-0.019801683723926544,
-0.04567380249500275,
0.23856781423091888,
-0.4918287694454193,
-0.34717053174972534,
-0.15335281193256378,
0.14795547723770142,
-0.05332858860492706,
0.4608776569366455,
-0.03581739217042923,
0.5785900354385376,
0.20327529311180115,
-0.5116996169090271,
0.4690656065940857,
-0.04913661256432533,
-0.297497034072876,
0.44597575068473816,
-0.7862827181816101,
-0.13181787729263306,
-0.4652043581008911,
0.3598957657814026,
-1.2445157766342163,
-0.35677775740623474,
0.12962253391742706,
-0.325683057308197,
0.534821629524231,
-0.04345548525452614,
-0.6622118353843689,
-0.08549914509057999,
-0.7202878594398499,
0.6044468879699707,
0.15647290647029877,
-0.017597565427422523,
0.7743964195251465,
0.2435832917690277,
-0.968093752861023,
-0.38114234805107117,
-0.5771949887275696,
0.2771824896335602,
-0.40723878145217896,
-0.8714407682418823,
0.1770859807729721,
-0.11926178634166718,
-0.6719182729721069,
-0.49738532304763794,
-0.13563194870948792,
0.059718016535043716,
-0.022964127361774445,
0.10092571377754211,
0.6238662600517273,
-0.15500526130199432,
0.10150417685508728,
0.0544755682349205,
-0.27310213446617126,
0.36310744285583496,
0.21356408298015594,
0.39659473299980164,
-0.2281060516834259,
-0.20615817606449127,
-0.2806854248046875,
0.5174252390861511,
1.009003758430481,
-0.23120932281017303,
0.31672203540802,
0.45404428243637085,
-0.0364903062582016,
0.05790242180228233,
-0.5284954309463501,
-0.09796896576881409,
-0.41905713081359863,
0.4518207311630249,
-0.1681402325630188,
-0.731805145740509,
0.8284146189689636,
0.16528259217739105,
0.15772970020771027,
0.5741038918495178,
0.6743353009223938,
-0.09364120662212372,
0.7100091576576233,
0.6156046390533447,
0.005636918358504772,
0.3024052381515503,
-0.1629074662923813,
0.24552582204341888,
-0.403225302696228,
-0.39550209045410156,
-0.24985119700431824,
-0.4554140567779541,
-0.5144322514533997,
-0.16804280877113342,
0.6983479857444763,
-0.23735585808753967,
0.2282930165529251,
0.08395463228225708,
-0.006243318319320679,
0.45643213391304016,
0.22907288372516632,
-0.32305318117141724,
0.33249208331108093,
-0.03257443755865097,
0.04636254906654358,
-0.09546073526144028,
-0.26409658789634705,
-0.4167034924030304,
0.8934101462364197,
0.6148211359977722,
0.9745519757270813,
0.3423389494419098,
0.6117252707481384,
0.5384236574172974,
0.2552219033241272,
-0.7821301817893982,
0.47161969542503357,
-0.0018054716056212783,
-0.2287912368774414,
-0.5001090168952942,
-0.6218177080154419,
-0.7545743584632874,
0.24424880743026733,
0.055233169347047806,
-0.41932255029678345,
0.004188340622931719,
0.07325319200754166,
-0.42650583386421204,
-0.09159737080335617,
-0.8268327116966248,
0.7484912276268005,
-0.46309852600097656,
-0.22062063217163086,
-0.24785304069519043,
-0.670126736164093,
0.6585479974746704,
-0.37360405921936035,
0.5012232065200806,
0.08541925251483917,
0.07904689759016037,
0.7229301929473877,
-0.28011518716812134,
0.9712916016578674,
0.0007641007541678846,
-0.5585866570472717,
0.035799141973257065,
0.16677887737751007,
0.6099758744239807,
0.37215542793273926,
0.1765623241662979,
-0.03074691817164421,
0.010266710072755814,
-0.3251194357872009,
-0.7334678173065186,
0.6386735439300537,
-0.4255633056163788,
-0.22976113855838776,
-0.7032599449157715,
-0.6503888964653015,
-0.18973319232463837,
-0.009255225770175457,
0.03455447033047676,
0.7546101212501526,
-0.062264714390039444,
0.07785629481077194,
0.47090065479278564,
-0.31160715222358704,
0.7602135539054871,
0.4124303460121155,
-0.43494296073913574,
-0.6308078169822693,
1.0252857208251953,
0.36913493275642395,
0.16652138531208038,
0.4165894687175751,
0.05847782641649246,
-0.44664499163627625,
-0.2246745377779007,
-0.39795443415641785,
0.297027051448822,
-0.7083303332328796,
0.006559950299561024,
-0.44960159063339233,
-0.06266788393259048,
-0.40113937854766846,
-0.11510922759771347,
-0.04497860372066498,
-0.8250558972358704,
-0.08004502952098846,
-0.2994537353515625,
0.3327045738697052,
0.960875391960144,
0.025238526985049248,
0.014187010005116463,
-0.7875176072120667,
0.6099472641944885,
0.6336450576782227,
0.30294662714004517,
0.13449448347091675,
-0.35576531291007996,
-0.16063252091407776,
-0.20730122923851013,
-0.22213514149188995,
-0.827743411064148,
0.353702187538147,
-0.13765546679496765,
0.43314528465270996,
0.4686899483203888,
-0.24784459173679352,
0.5646188855171204,
-0.16391469538211823,
0.6005356311798096,
0.31384924054145813,
-0.7631809115409851,
0.13276830315589905,
-0.5699308514595032,
0.5093085765838623,
0.3261050879955292,
0.2268860638141632,
-0.48262250423431396,
-0.3291374444961548,
-0.28281518816947937,
-1.0666083097457886,
0.5452004075050354,
0.2692759931087494,
-0.13757231831550598,
-0.0061422972939908504,
0.022241834551095963,
0.3050105571746826,
0.3500378131866455,
-0.7459616661071777,
-0.07494271546602249,
-0.36756783723831177,
0.07282029092311859,
-0.22372864186763763,
-0.6465680599212646,
0.045540470629930496,
-0.1078089103102684,
0.3832344114780426,
0.042213402688503265,
0.10923395305871964,
-0.00717577151954174,
-0.1448422074317932,
0.3977047801017761,
0.39799150824546814,
1.290113091468811,
1.0159472227096558,
-0.2997691333293915,
0.25382399559020996,
0.09995855391025543,
-0.3113662600517273,
-0.2568154036998749,
0.26296156644821167,
0.21306216716766357,
0.0242922343313694,
0.7713059186935425,
0.42694106698036194,
0.4944184422492981,
-0.5421899557113647,
0.529006838798523,
-0.20276956260204315,
-0.28766950964927673,
-0.55198734998703,
-0.4968077540397644,
0.040901970118284225,
0.30677857995033264,
0.3791011571884155,
-0.05144582688808441,
0.33162373304367065,
-0.6032536029815674,
0.17699265480041504,
0.2762832045555115,
-0.11856530606746674,
-0.4481881856918335,
0.47807446122169495,
0.19792059063911438,
0.11035894602537155,
0.825012743473053,
-0.14589382708072662,
-0.22527676820755005,
0.7127472758293152,
0.37929868698120117,
0.8798105716705322,
0.17616510391235352,
0.16040021181106567,
0.006801672745496035,
0.2256019413471222,
0.024461109191179276,
0.30580419301986694,
-0.20165874063968658,
-0.26958924531936646,
-0.9915735125541687,
-0.38127365708351135,
-0.33996066451072693,
0.1722204089164734,
-0.6963287591934204,
0.18465109169483185,
-0.4050370752811432,
-0.3848018944263458,
0.49478140473365784,
-0.5536826252937317,
-0.3350340723991394,
-0.2878795564174652,
0.35050633549690247,
0.5891356468200684,
-0.6138267517089844,
0.4494229853153229,
0.40073561668395996,
-0.25291359424591064,
-0.3012363910675049,
-0.3947364091873169,
0.3123002350330353,
-0.802749752998352,
0.9172878861427307,
0.15745458006858826,
-0.14466610550880432,
-0.47258707880973816,
-0.5070320963859558,
-0.5510001182556152,
0.9964936375617981,
0.19578565657138824,
-0.5296908020973206,
-0.21501046419143677,
0.15687020123004913,
0.31520190834999084,
0.042685817927122116,
0.1968798041343689,
0.33990681171417236,
0.8217407464981079,
0.11035360395908356,
-1.1688542366027832,
-0.19855184853076935,
-0.23829953372478485,
-0.306004136800766,
0.49473482370376587,
-0.7186154723167419,
0.9414312839508057,
-0.4605601727962494,
0.07410398870706558,
-0.17859779298305511,
0.6518191695213318,
0.22305803000926971,
0.6287968754768372,
0.279746949672699,
0.30438846349716187,
0.6835989952087402,
0.048560116440057755,
1.1352403163909912,
-0.14761194586753845,
0.3047948181629181,
0.9042537808418274,
-0.3499617576599121,
0.4347962439060211,
0.5516850352287292,
-0.10908500850200653,
0.17541447281837463,
0.2724466919898987,
-0.1953902244567871,
0.27069976925849915,
0.476445734500885,
-0.17073342204093933,
-0.11159610003232956,
0.2996242046356201,
-0.32551252841949463,
0.5373355746269226,
0.2232096791267395,
-0.5338297486305237,
-0.4251708388328552,
-0.03732650354504585,
0.19300973415374756,
-0.29586389660835266,
-0.2881639897823334,
0.7364274263381958,
0.2723807096481323,
-0.4044917821884155,
0.31202125549316406,
0.26981279253959656,
0.40267330408096313,
-0.8375254273414612,
-0.25469136238098145,
-0.14075228571891785,
0.005736007820814848,
-0.06180562824010849,
-0.6309486031532288,
0.14032937586307526,
-0.03471717983484268,
-0.43526142835617065,
-0.5532121062278748,
0.391470342874527,
-0.2845444083213806,
-0.6955796480178833,
0.008029695600271225,
0.4410266578197479,
0.20857268571853638,
-0.19731448590755463,
0.0021044055465608835,
0.19439764320850372,
-0.010772917419672012,
-0.23843175172805786,
0.48525646328926086,
0.6458770036697388,
-0.43518421053886414,
0.691950261592865,
0.5953369140625,
-0.1357295662164688,
-0.2113358974456787,
0.37116116285324097,
0.7488607168197632,
-0.9638153910636902,
-0.5946846008300781,
-1.3440706729888916,
0.39746183156967163,
-0.08003886789083481,
-0.2551107406616211,
0.8334790468215942,
0.9360480308532715,
0.30840572714805603,
-0.2264729142189026,
0.7857992053031921,
0.22449712455272675,
0.19823798537254333,
-0.8514142632484436,
0.545840322971344,
-0.16189996898174286,
0.38567498326301575,
-0.37360280752182007,
-1.0450876951217651,
-0.37882399559020996,
0.4970921576023102,
-0.31333521008491516,
0.11725134402513504,
0.5702872276306152,
0.4168553948402405,
-0.014162207953631878,
0.08922974020242691,
0.2469301074743271,
0.4373057782649994,
0.3599131405353546,
0.357588529586792,
0.8585138916969299,
0.04244742915034294,
0.5678391456604004,
0.060418613255023956,
-0.30184119939804077,
-0.27571436762809753,
-1.0109463930130005,
-0.9343129992485046,
-0.49444013833999634,
-0.176557719707489,
-0.17201092839241028,
-0.3014623522758484,
0.6761535406112671,
0.3254678547382355,
-0.533262312412262,
-0.38558560609817505,
0.6757290959358215,
0.05711577460169792,
0.055954933166503906,
-0.24176864326000214,
0.3905244767665863,
-0.1543918251991272,
-0.4309132695198059,
0.466008722782135,
0.6698496341705322,
0.39448222517967224,
-0.2655796706676483,
0.12643291056156158,
0.42424941062927246,
-0.026078421622514725,
1.2126039266586304,
0.12076559662818909,
-0.4965725839138031,
-0.15302300453186035,
0.13514520227909088,
0.08817646652460098,
-0.04960251599550247,
1.0935535430908203,
-0.6107964515686035,
0.17291760444641113,
0.4094480872154236,
0.21517014503479004,
0.6672172546386719,
0.19086891412734985,
0.6599723696708679,
-0.484179824590683,
-0.11567291617393494,
0.21786732971668243,
0.4515340030193329,
0.014151941984891891,
-0.18535803258419037,
0.22451533377170563,
0.004094348289072514,
-0.5339599847793579,
-0.6374008655548096,
0.011805523186922073,
-1.5780410766601562,
-0.20391908288002014,
1.0434460639953613,
0.4612219035625458,
-0.08285121619701385,
0.024421855807304382,
-0.3841390907764435,
-0.24114631116390228,
-0.7609743475914001,
0.8220558166503906,
1.0886259078979492,
-0.30126404762268066,
-0.10704623907804489,
-0.8253743052482605,
0.28682348132133484,
-0.01647242344915867,
-0.6536343097686768,
0.34547188878059387,
0.7444663643836975,
0.17733535170555115,
0.23952370882034302,
0.6938267350196838,
-0.3199579417705536,
0.17953133583068848,
-0.24740248918533325,
-0.2332151085138321,
-0.3399876654148102,
-0.2759365439414978,
-0.33759593963623047,
0.4673691391944885,
-0.11809214949607849,
0.1468650996685028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06150v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06150v1
|
(Not) Understanding Latin Poetic Style with Deep Learning
| 2024-04-09T09:21:56 | 2024-04-09T09:21:56 |
Ben Nagy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This article summarizes some mostly unsuccessful attempts to understand
authorial style by examining the attention of various neural networks (LSTMs
and CNNs) trained on a corpus of classical Latin verse that has been encoded to
include sonic and metrical features. Carefully configured neural networks are
shown to be extremely strong authorship classifiers, so it is hoped that they
might therefore teach `traditional' readers something about how the authors
differ in style. Sadly their reasoning is, so far, inscrutable. While the
overall goal has not yet been reached, this work reports some useful findings
in terms of effective ways to encode and embed verse, the relative strengths
and weaknesses of the neural network families, and useful (and not so useful)
techniques for designing and inspecting NN models in this domain. This article
suggests that, for poetry, CNNs are better choices than LSTMs -- they train
more quickly, have equivalent accuracy, and (potentially) offer better
interpretability. Based on a great deal of experimentation, it also suggests
that simple, trainable embeddings are more effective than domain-specific
schemes, and stresses the importance of techniques to reduce overfitting, like
dropout and batch normalization.
|
[
-0.25079742074012756,
-0.3485485315322876,
0.540554940700531,
0.22322453558444977,
-0.5154976844787598,
0.25706905126571655,
-0.663013219833374,
-0.4198816418647766,
0.39492905139923096,
0.4242599904537201,
-0.25554606318473816,
-0.516369640827179,
-0.772904634475708,
0.29332080483436584,
-0.7115148305892944,
1.0601757764816284,
0.001834946102462709,
0.19232910871505737,
-0.24981991946697235,
-0.1986498385667801,
-0.36451300978660583,
-0.07367699593305588,
-1.0176366567611694,
-0.22773362696170807,
0.9415849447250366,
0.2301298975944519,
0.5994099974632263,
0.6259827017784119,
0.5320543050765991,
0.3415369391441345,
-0.2526986598968506,
0.22910276055335999,
-0.5203283429145813,
0.3541679382324219,
0.05800793692469597,
-0.5697122812271118,
-0.09045502543449402,
0.3221004009246826,
0.6112313270568848,
0.6916279196739197,
0.4319387376308441,
0.13163761794567108,
0.08505375683307648,
0.9306842088699341,
-0.4606819450855255,
0.03742038458585739,
-0.5581575036048889,
0.513561487197876,
-0.4424367845058441,
-0.39110270142555237,
-0.5833252668380737,
-0.41386061906814575,
0.26243916153907776,
-0.5264246463775635,
0.2712722420692444,
0.142839252948761,
0.44160133600234985,
0.42472484707832336,
-0.3740757405757904,
-0.26299434900283813,
-0.8579002618789673,
0.7577142119407654,
-0.5206382274627686,
0.19957759976387024,
0.23634229600429535,
0.25643643736839294,
-0.06401746720075607,
-1.033179759979248,
-0.42632636427879333,
-0.21434012055397034,
-0.11302898079156876,
0.31048572063446045,
-0.3791661262512207,
-0.026659643277525902,
0.09159324318170547,
0.3124392628669739,
-0.5440241694450378,
0.1800757497549057,
-0.54964679479599,
0.3710290789604187,
0.6832497119903564,
-0.08585701137781143,
0.29443874955177307,
-0.08610134571790695,
-0.4914417564868927,
0.07325435429811478,
-0.772494375705719,
0.17385220527648926,
0.6964026689529419,
0.27071329951286316,
-0.07758384943008423,
0.37325266003608704,
0.26952674984931946,
0.6812178492546082,
-0.06693709641695023,
0.03146595135331154,
0.11075370758771896,
-0.026637928560376167,
-0.26030755043029785,
0.24625609815120697,
0.905363142490387,
0.10745646804571152,
0.8673780560493469,
-0.5317205190658569,
-0.1530461609363556,
-0.19394835829734802,
0.8230624198913574,
-0.4734943211078644,
-0.4268115162849426,
0.14106298983097076,
-0.46566393971443176,
-0.3039633333683014,
0.17809806764125824,
-0.19594380259513855,
-0.4759249985218048,
-0.8861681222915649,
0.08180853724479675,
-0.46757322549819946,
-0.012270674109458923,
0.028298964723944664,
-0.43525734543800354,
0.1883329153060913,
0.40253588557243347,
-0.8654393553733826,
0.34680894017219543,
0.8903051614761353,
0.8403501510620117,
-0.12774115800857544,
-0.338205486536026,
-0.5078543424606323,
-0.5001863837242126,
-0.73595130443573,
0.5054665803909302,
-0.2297263741493225,
0.13052912056446075,
-0.05917204171419144,
-0.09580733627080917,
-0.3265744149684906,
-0.3375779092311859,
0.7719137072563171,
-0.5996993184089661,
-0.04869771748781204,
-0.12365758419036865,
-0.7212762832641602,
-0.134183868765831,
-0.20695514976978302,
-0.757229208946228,
0.5306426286697388,
-0.22755751013755798,
-0.786820113658905,
0.09085850417613983,
-0.4054679572582245,
-0.38900226354599,
-0.09457380324602127,
-0.20731940865516663,
-0.29406875371932983,
0.5518759489059448,
0.01140571292489767,
0.8050400018692017,
-0.004080268554389477,
0.07597605139017105,
-0.3661820590496063,
-0.6860871911048889,
0.682820200920105,
-0.200007826089859,
1.0845996141433716,
0.4652424454689026,
-0.556766152381897,
0.05592316389083862,
-0.5784569978713989,
-0.0601663775742054,
0.2861330509185791,
0.049417123198509216,
-0.3869783580303192,
-0.19406522810459137,
0.4694463312625885,
-0.1414208561182022,
-0.084088034927845,
-0.6507648229598999,
0.013691320084035397,
-0.541160523891449,
0.639766275882721,
0.8212669491767883,
-0.3787069320678711,
0.3915014863014221,
-0.2662605941295624,
0.7120451331138611,
-0.44443872570991516,
-0.10391756147146225,
0.15488889813423157,
-0.3773450255393982,
-0.6862028241157532,
0.022049538791179657,
0.5108178853988647,
0.38148677349090576,
-0.6310045719146729,
0.22060787677764893,
-0.1781114935874939,
-0.7362442016601562,
-0.7905837893486023,
0.5914034247398376,
0.511043906211853,
0.2804901897907257,
0.21246330440044403,
-0.4085676074028015,
-0.3200354278087616,
-0.7595975399017334,
-0.6257237792015076,
0.22587963938713074,
0.4660710394382477,
0.08568490296602249,
0.5972035527229309,
0.40317124128341675,
0.5779118537902832,
-0.27021369338035583,
-0.17694798111915588,
-0.38238006830215454,
0.07882886379957199,
0.1839330941438675,
0.6071982979774475,
0.7589530944824219,
-0.8296334743499756,
-0.5352638363838196,
0.006651668809354305,
-0.7414161562919617,
0.16986654698848724,
-0.1757999211549759,
-0.03946398198604584,
-0.14341510832309723,
0.773067057132721,
-0.3251926004886627,
0.45667898654937744,
0.10075312852859497,
-0.09805013984441757,
0.3902185559272766,
-0.22391903400421143,
-0.3558339476585388,
-0.9160610437393188,
0.1072729229927063,
0.30548667907714844,
-0.14175008237361908,
-0.8386347889900208,
0.1713247150182724,
0.06055024266242981,
-0.03848195821046829,
-0.5261371731758118,
0.42946743965148926,
-0.4898856282234192,
-0.12503108382225037,
-0.6145827770233154,
0.06994643062353134,
0.41623616218566895,
0.5104103684425354,
0.05626020208001137,
0.45910462737083435,
0.3032178580760956,
-0.3190838396549225,
0.555594801902771,
0.09914448857307434,
-0.5135083794593811,
0.7546419501304626,
-0.8693827986717224,
0.5216603875160217,
-0.6284751892089844,
0.3229692578315735,
-1.1887965202331543,
0.11882215738296509,
0.18614819645881653,
-0.5316286683082581,
0.8437602519989014,
-0.5880024433135986,
-0.559219479560852,
-0.1870022863149643,
-0.2404366135597229,
0.6085503101348877,
0.12528878450393677,
-0.6770157217979431,
0.08952232450246811,
-0.07121866941452026,
-0.04550958052277565,
-0.8205501437187195,
-0.8296528458595276,
0.4033919870853424,
-0.5193784832954407,
-0.5767583250999451,
0.43944546580314636,
0.057232148945331573,
-0.5715484023094177,
0.0018994376296177506,
0.18604087829589844,
-0.04114990681409836,
0.5121299028396606,
0.15777252614498138,
-0.12768137454986572,
-0.3771747052669525,
0.44094040989875793,
-0.03560572490096092,
-0.07400985807180405,
0.13107992708683014,
-0.7186862826347351,
0.21953539550304413,
-0.26013827323913574,
-0.12603041529655457,
-0.933036208152771,
0.38015928864479065,
0.5809348821640015,
-0.6484864950180054,
0.6698483228683472,
0.9564305543899536,
-0.1741618663072586,
-0.33391180634498596,
-0.26970919966697693,
-0.007769131101667881,
-0.3543258607387543,
-0.06430939584970474,
-0.09049034863710403,
-0.48210230469703674,
0.3343895673751831,
0.14354567229747772,
-0.1000499501824379,
0.5490944385528564,
0.1832369863986969,
-0.6977179050445557,
0.36274540424346924,
0.6523690223693848,
0.055003318935632706,
0.6289929151535034,
-0.9190097451210022,
0.034954581409692764,
-1.1009124517440796,
-0.08337683230638504,
-0.7277019023895264,
-0.9641340970993042,
-0.6625264883041382,
-0.01874716207385063,
0.3817193806171417,
-0.2658481001853943,
-0.18223240971565247,
0.32230308651924133,
-0.522163450717926,
0.4589464068412781,
0.8105916380882263,
0.035364389419555664,
0.08695349842309952,
0.0426504909992218,
0.008029109798371792,
-0.09616831690073013,
-0.46452203392982483,
-0.41245660185813904,
1.2562527656555176,
0.31897491216659546,
0.7315321564674377,
0.3669864535331726,
0.8633715510368347,
0.16755931079387665,
0.005460839718580246,
-0.9954451322555542,
-0.049427974969148636,
-0.6299007534980774,
-0.46404796838760376,
-0.21739135682582855,
-0.15229898691177368,
-1.2567801475524902,
0.09429912269115448,
-0.2034410983324051,
-0.5147941708564758,
0.4103928804397583,
-0.023887870833277702,
-0.6985812187194824,
0.42051079869270325,
-0.5493184328079224,
1.074439525604248,
-0.2909005284309387,
-0.11248815059661865,
0.23228929936885834,
-0.8670305013656616,
0.14437590539455414,
0.2662403881549835,
0.0411229208111763,
0.204793319106102,
-0.14468638598918915,
0.7680352330207825,
-0.34789469838142395,
0.9942843914031982,
0.1355152130126953,
0.11896117031574249,
0.3065049946308136,
0.04146929457783699,
0.1953868716955185,
-0.14751790463924408,
-0.017254812642931938,
-0.2758975625038147,
-0.28556299209594727,
-0.4529981017112732,
-0.9268710017204285,
0.7420938611030579,
-1.0254147052764893,
-0.29029086232185364,
-0.3806813657283783,
-0.20560693740844727,
-0.020909447222948074,
0.041550252586603165,
0.42039239406585693,
0.9754931926727295,
-0.07783408463001251,
0.567898154258728,
0.7547408938407898,
0.07079965621232986,
0.6763471364974976,
-0.22569522261619568,
0.07639598101377487,
-0.7109927535057068,
0.7293784022331238,
0.4039515554904938,
0.1323114037513733,
0.49064359068870544,
0.3130473494529724,
-0.3361054062843323,
-0.8437281847000122,
-0.8926886916160583,
0.2736608684062958,
-0.6729027628898621,
0.11883176118135452,
-0.6167092323303223,
-0.2921338677406311,
-0.42752334475517273,
-0.0844418853521347,
-0.26714447140693665,
-0.5806951522827148,
-0.7487409114837646,
-0.22586414217948914,
0.5764768123626709,
1.0566978454589844,
0.43035897612571716,
0.4523300230503082,
-0.36566126346588135,
-0.03311358392238617,
0.027796657755970955,
0.34906885027885437,
0.30285459756851196,
-0.613571286201477,
-0.40367189049720764,
-0.5394033193588257,
-0.36600327491760254,
-0.9105615615844727,
0.2829378843307495,
0.21555356681346893,
0.29229936003685,
0.5873363018035889,
0.16685713827610016,
0.2550678253173828,
-0.5536812543869019,
0.5241189002990723,
-0.0025367827620357275,
-0.6112265586853027,
0.5276796221733093,
-0.32400092482566833,
0.11113400757312775,
0.8385434746742249,
0.4513453543186188,
-0.6393002271652222,
-0.4028250277042389,
-0.7582328915596008,
-0.7756377458572388,
0.4608507752418518,
0.3423333168029785,
0.5991693735122681,
0.20772719383239746,
0.6811878681182861,
0.3226991891860962,
0.3319810628890991,
-0.6374524831771851,
-0.6648821830749512,
-0.3979417085647583,
-0.26848021149635315,
-0.7463539838790894,
-0.0010662281420081854,
-0.17012538015842438,
-0.3867596983909607,
0.5056092143058777,
-0.09570251405239105,
0.16762469708919525,
0.41910994052886963,
-0.08370767533779144,
0.0926867425441742,
0.18292176723480225,
0.9971112608909607,
0.6260363459587097,
0.011962370947003365,
0.38214680552482605,
-0.3516274094581604,
-0.3886113166809082,
-0.1257931888103485,
0.12431154400110245,
-0.22282806038856506,
0.08676110953092575,
0.7700411677360535,
1.262190818786621,
0.028440091758966446,
-0.05621706694364548,
0.582727313041687,
-0.17543025314807892,
-0.10539893060922623,
-1.044040560722351,
0.1261480152606964,
0.18582214415073395,
0.2454644739627838,
0.09323941171169281,
0.45237645506858826,
0.19520969688892365,
-0.5530657768249512,
-0.22762277722358704,
0.4310910701751709,
-0.7845323085784912,
-0.297212153673172,
0.6098055839538574,
0.07058990001678467,
-0.5359328985214233,
0.35561665892601013,
-0.07361425459384918,
-0.4912252426147461,
0.8014509081840515,
0.3603973984718323,
1.2754319906234741,
0.3340070843696594,
0.1392463892698288,
-0.020870180800557137,
0.36702069640159607,
0.3327885568141937,
0.17256991565227509,
-0.1352062225341797,
-0.5423780679702759,
-0.5067909359931946,
-0.3469514846801758,
-0.2972947955131531,
0.20878371596336365,
-0.45517459511756897,
-0.06663167476654053,
-0.8099029660224915,
-0.22704102098941803,
0.37152600288391113,
0.14777672290802002,
-0.950874924659729,
0.059216272085905075,
0.06027030944824219,
0.8529479503631592,
-0.7580797076225281,
0.5297172665596008,
0.7465601563453674,
-0.38064342737197876,
-0.8494113087654114,
-0.028320375829935074,
0.13153216242790222,
-0.3748628497123718,
0.7598192095756531,
0.08370406925678253,
-0.08372782170772552,
0.014813573099672794,
-0.6396718621253967,
-0.5605272650718689,
0.9223171472549438,
0.4795093238353729,
-0.16002815961837769,
0.34976500272750854,
-0.2551601827144623,
0.8530648946762085,
-0.5046199560165405,
0.2775028347969055,
0.15409819781780243,
0.5242170691490173,
-0.04143771529197693,
-0.6451672315597534,
-0.21086184680461884,
-0.5248599648475647,
0.014091795310378075,
0.08666104078292847,
-0.7942434549331665,
0.8819574117660522,
0.03163960203528404,
0.057869892567396164,
0.3746369183063507,
0.9053242206573486,
-0.5272650718688965,
0.786518931388855,
0.23902085423469543,
0.9103273749351501,
0.7840753793716431,
-0.014135089702904224,
1.2652652263641357,
-0.021240081638097763,
-0.046211086213588715,
1.048949956893921,
0.16932260990142822,
0.8023996353149414,
0.3338177502155304,
-0.021011030301451683,
0.5839981436729431,
0.759314775466919,
-0.12076504528522491,
0.2299327552318573,
0.6868242025375366,
-0.25046342611312866,
-0.09820056706666946,
-0.023070797324180603,
-0.41449254751205444,
0.7432540655136108,
-0.16166356205940247,
-0.9171419143676758,
0.23209215700626373,
0.04275933653116226,
0.2508997321128845,
0.4998726546764374,
-0.34672439098358154,
0.8316389322280884,
0.6166633367538452,
-0.796798586845398,
0.4370929002761841,
0.08503887057304382,
0.37677571177482605,
0.10839527100324631,
0.27399179339408875,
-0.032248321920633316,
0.10085541009902954,
-0.33717986941337585,
-0.6255433559417725,
0.15221060812473297,
0.14901939034461975,
-0.17274659872055054,
-0.4237538278102875,
0.6416712403297424,
-0.24324125051498413,
-0.7185806035995483,
0.15664388239383698,
0.5969163775444031,
0.3852989375591278,
-0.03478485718369484,
-0.4697878956794739,
-0.1638987511396408,
-0.4276275932788849,
0.14181207120418549,
-0.012278267182409763,
0.6602154970169067,
0.2052057683467865,
0.3104921579360962,
0.5850360989570618,
0.2747819721698761,
-0.06096862256526947,
0.5431744456291199,
0.4426628649234772,
-0.6099047660827637,
-0.3270387053489685,
-0.9992805123329163,
0.3436647951602936,
-0.09313364326953888,
-0.7092415690422058,
0.6255146265029907,
0.3534366488456726,
0.8197041749954224,
-0.1548469066619873,
0.3918689787387848,
0.6183136701583862,
0.08537794649600983,
-0.7130417227745056,
1.1105420589447021,
-0.7176750898361206,
-0.042889561504125595,
-0.38826510310173035,
-0.810536801815033,
-0.5695887207984924,
0.4338337779045105,
-0.3549042344093323,
0.22686071693897247,
0.6583585739135742,
0.23745034635066986,
-0.08560473471879959,
0.28522226214408875,
0.09343627095222473,
0.012043198570609093,
0.058780182152986526,
0.335798442363739,
0.9506369233131409,
-0.2670690715312958,
0.25124314427375793,
-0.5818480849266052,
0.09607690572738647,
-0.2719721496105194,
-0.9401720762252808,
-0.9212488532066345,
-0.6208099722862244,
-0.3518526554107666,
-0.28286024928092957,
-0.05641564726829529,
1.2424829006195068,
0.6234918832778931,
-0.5484094619750977,
-0.08285519480705261,
-0.020068680867552757,
0.3263528645038605,
-0.33227962255477905,
-0.06875509023666382,
0.6220940351486206,
-0.5145934224128723,
-0.8581668734550476,
0.33976510167121887,
0.04023253172636032,
0.12668341398239136,
-0.45715680718421936,
0.06215972825884819,
0.10062100738286972,
-0.1563248634338379,
0.3923291265964508,
0.16600292921066284,
-0.7715265154838562,
-0.11974767595529556,
0.1271737813949585,
-0.12843899428844452,
0.08867626637220383,
0.9974954128265381,
-0.4372977912425995,
0.587786078453064,
0.4775354564189911,
0.8899291753768921,
0.4010409414768219,
-0.23154214024543762,
0.2942199409008026,
-0.5775032043457031,
-0.2910798192024231,
0.4488626718521118,
0.7784846425056458,
0.4211413562297821,
-0.44787025451660156,
0.4907742440700531,
0.4411080777645111,
-0.4526089131832123,
-0.5745325684547424,
0.08404418081045151,
-1.2614496946334839,
-0.10872451961040497,
1.0119036436080933,
-0.3164796531200409,
-0.4584555923938751,
-0.08370066434144974,
-0.19199278950691223,
0.20812155306339264,
-0.28990256786346436,
0.5157594680786133,
0.7316144108772278,
-0.07774045318365097,
-0.03568074107170105,
-0.8690853118896484,
0.5421803593635559,
0.5126823782920837,
-0.21514807641506195,
-0.36208972334861755,
0.1294713020324707,
0.17262756824493408,
0.22109366953372955,
0.31616103649139404,
0.07680149376392365,
0.5247114896774292,
-0.3829852044582367,
-0.07864545285701752,
-0.2456466108560562,
-0.8156793713569641,
-0.5901407599449158,
0.23307669162750244,
0.42310741543769836,
-0.2589959502220154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06138v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06138v1
|
Cendol: Open Instruction-tuned Generative Large Language Models for Indonesian Languages
| 2024-04-09T09:04:30 | 2024-04-09T09:04:30 |
Samuel Cahyawijaya, Holy Lovenia, Fajri Koto, Rifki Afina Putri, Emmanuel Dave, Jhonson Lee, Nuur Shadieq, Wawan Cenggoro, Salsabil Maulana Akbar, Muhammad Ihza Mahendra, Dea Annisayanti Putri, Bryan Wilie, Genta Indra Winata, Alham Fikri Aji, Ayu Purwarianti, Pascale Fung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) show remarkable human-like capability in various
domains and languages. However, a notable quality gap arises in low-resource
languages, e.g., Indonesian indigenous languages, rendering them ineffective
and inefficient in such linguistic contexts. To bridge this quality gap, we
introduce Cendol, a collection of Indonesian LLMs encompassing both
decoder-only and encoder-decoder architectures across a range of model sizes.
We highlight Cendol's effectiveness across a diverse array of tasks, attaining
20% improvement, and demonstrate its capability to generalize to unseen tasks
and indigenous languages of Indonesia. Furthermore, Cendol models showcase
improved human favorability despite their limitations in capturing indigenous
knowledge and cultural values in Indonesia. In addition, we discuss the
shortcomings of parameter-efficient tunings, such as LoRA, for language
adaptation. Alternatively, we propose the usage of vocabulary adaptation to
enhance efficiency. Lastly, we evaluate the safety of Cendol and showcase that
safety in pre-training in one language such as English is transferable to
low-resource languages, such as Indonesian, even without RLHF and safety
fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.11483059078454971,
-0.8834945559501648,
0.12805074453353882,
0.1260184496641159,
-0.2038586139678955,
0.08589407801628113,
-0.7500611543655396,
-0.40285393595695496,
-0.00037735587102361023,
0.938991904258728,
-0.07658868283033371,
-0.7909440398216248,
-0.5903550982475281,
0.24237708747386932,
-0.04484691098332405,
0.957800567150116,
0.0033944665919989347,
-0.3400338590145111,
0.14562353491783142,
-0.27862340211868286,
-0.15326464176177979,
-0.3926151394844055,
-0.9274465441703796,
-0.16179974377155304,
0.5206308364868164,
0.5451282858848572,
0.8369232416152954,
0.8413643836975098,
0.24360305070877075,
0.26207470893859863,
-0.3838370442390442,
0.3239985406398773,
-0.4899751842021942,
0.20771749317646027,
-0.5497705936431885,
-0.591709315776825,
-0.6009060740470886,
-0.6242271065711975,
0.5468307137489319,
0.9538097381591797,
-0.28726667165756226,
0.1894044727087021,
0.4410107135772705,
0.8510131239891052,
-0.9438043832778931,
0.24337650835514069,
-0.6057219505310059,
-0.10721252858638763,
-0.4889630973339081,
0.1332436054944992,
-0.33602356910705566,
-0.4734049439430237,
-0.09246622771024704,
-0.6241267323493958,
0.013525557704269886,
-0.14573054015636444,
0.5401803851127625,
0.43384796380996704,
-0.38540467619895935,
-0.510555624961853,
-0.62920743227005,
0.7066431641578674,
-0.7339673042297363,
0.40673667192459106,
0.4959646165370941,
0.16431662440299988,
-0.17696622014045715,
-0.4083685874938965,
-0.3495499789714813,
-0.33190786838531494,
0.14746437966823578,
-0.021725405007600784,
0.14398249983787537,
0.4324539005756378,
0.213600754737854,
0.42501625418663025,
-0.6327241063117981,
0.480221152305603,
-0.42171522974967957,
0.13112761080265045,
0.5217955112457275,
0.03619561344385147,
0.22542926669120789,
-0.1579894721508026,
0.043317846953868866,
-0.19570109248161316,
-0.86250901222229,
-0.2025928497314453,
0.6156432032585144,
0.4548632502555847,
-0.09117045253515244,
0.4823904037475586,
-0.20032796263694763,
0.9728223085403442,
-0.1554081290960312,
-0.3369238078594208,
0.10833264142274857,
0.13004793226718903,
-0.10898129642009735,
0.05441632866859436,
0.6280233263969421,
0.031534258276224136,
0.23104242980480194,
0.10196942836046219,
-0.12440279126167297,
0.08695124834775925,
-0.06658530235290527,
-0.6229488849639893,
-0.232511505484581,
0.17705310881137848,
-0.5199114084243774,
-0.2557794749736786,
-0.16759082674980164,
-1.0717840194702148,
-0.16783082485198975,
-0.2873651683330536,
0.14565154910087585,
-0.19978506863117218,
-0.6897399425506592,
0.19005507230758667,
0.2707521915435791,
0.1701618731021881,
0.09797747433185577,
-1.1762603521347046,
0.3235514461994171,
0.6966537833213806,
0.6050637364387512,
-0.15739311277866364,
-0.050415750592947006,
-0.42101478576660156,
0.19922038912773132,
-0.5046350955963135,
0.38306742906570435,
-0.6856039762496948,
-0.5954906940460205,
0.27407312393188477,
0.11219378560781479,
-0.09068024158477783,
-0.6261541843414307,
0.9168088436126709,
-0.5932131409645081,
-0.2602643072605133,
-0.05094609037041664,
-0.48884081840515137,
-0.09358204901218414,
0.16841275990009308,
-0.7149381041526794,
0.9796596169471741,
0.07529260963201523,
-0.6443682909011841,
-0.026496244594454765,
-0.9336991310119629,
-0.581660270690918,
0.07016321271657944,
0.030365215614438057,
-0.29894644021987915,
0.4616715610027313,
0.2005280703306198,
0.3979814052581787,
-0.1784147173166275,
0.1420026272535324,
-0.3187592029571533,
-0.16127339005470276,
0.1724868267774582,
-0.7195731997489929,
0.8842414617538452,
0.5812424421310425,
-0.07000730186700821,
-0.10546267032623291,
-0.8512858748435974,
0.13351531326770782,
0.016918381676077843,
-0.6373576521873474,
-0.612799882888794,
-0.10689860582351685,
0.16912879049777985,
-0.09899348020553589,
0.48600083589553833,
-0.4397946298122406,
0.09909524768590927,
-0.628217875957489,
0.21243178844451904,
0.6785975694656372,
-0.27089521288871765,
0.28265827894210815,
0.1126105934381485,
0.5670242309570312,
-0.09592723846435547,
0.07342421263456345,
-0.254202663898468,
-0.24545443058013916,
-0.9646177887916565,
-0.06067942827939987,
0.41721656918525696,
0.5405226349830627,
-0.9370708465576172,
0.508681058883667,
-0.299388587474823,
-0.33949536085128784,
-0.7090587019920349,
0.4718951880931854,
0.7022621631622314,
0.19110573828220367,
0.010872813872992992,
-0.1745062917470932,
-0.4836244285106659,
-0.5848560333251953,
-0.2663241922855377,
-0.12953387200832367,
-0.05186162143945694,
0.05908430740237236,
0.4375566244125366,
-0.1271073967218399,
0.3854083716869354,
-0.2986717224121094,
-0.0803082063794136,
-0.3957256078720093,
-0.18381044268608093,
0.4853493571281433,
0.4806675910949707,
0.41601234674453735,
-0.60518878698349,
-0.6801474690437317,
0.5915353298187256,
-0.6484829187393188,
-0.06682310253381729,
0.4540974199771881,
-0.006794482469558716,
0.6087437868118286,
0.7517778873443604,
-0.2556133568286896,
0.2546437680721283,
0.9881908893585205,
-0.14110857248306274,
0.32148176431655884,
-0.7904964089393616,
0.04814958944916725,
-1.1274060010910034,
0.08678809553384781,
-0.2577843964099884,
-0.0485992357134819,
-0.5474061965942383,
0.3045315146446228,
0.14763674139976501,
-0.30421876907348633,
-0.5731987357139587,
0.668109655380249,
-0.4546363353729248,
-0.08740665763616562,
-0.5331576466560364,
0.16092921793460846,
-0.2556062936782837,
0.5133457779884338,
0.20183894038200378,
0.6806702613830566,
0.495273232460022,
-0.7776036858558655,
0.1545267403125763,
0.06042826920747757,
-0.38022589683532715,
0.6653620004653931,
-0.7017008662223816,
0.2240692675113678,
-0.2620891332626343,
-0.05503099784255028,
-0.4707622826099396,
-0.6791122555732727,
0.12514464557170868,
-0.07188946008682251,
0.4965149164199829,
-0.3970572054386139,
-0.4517567753791809,
-0.21318455040454865,
0.11059750616550446,
0.4194968342781067,
0.7684242725372314,
-0.8287834525108337,
0.4013434052467346,
0.2646333575248718,
-0.17098136246204376,
-0.5377259254455566,
-0.6242298483848572,
0.06043455749750137,
-0.21057254076004028,
-0.281148225069046,
0.18739618360996246,
0.11219831556081772,
-0.19034895300865173,
0.23190268874168396,
0.1381167322397232,
0.06360849738121033,
0.23792554438114166,
0.07238728553056717,
-0.026324929669499397,
-0.36901894211769104,
0.22157272696495056,
0.449657678604126,
-0.19320476055145264,
-0.1766013205051422,
-0.7458048462867737,
0.38793694972991943,
-0.3047116994857788,
-0.6807083487510681,
-0.26302430033683777,
0.17221172153949738,
0.35948458313941956,
-0.3902580142021179,
0.8798721432685852,
0.5414881706237793,
-0.4163242280483246,
-0.14807933568954468,
-0.36957576870918274,
0.24597948789596558,
-0.47314080595970154,
0.5992862582206726,
-0.5233616828918457,
-0.9443202614784241,
0.3591960370540619,
-0.2528171241283417,
0.2523629367351532,
0.43111440539360046,
0.6223074793815613,
0.1773337870836258,
0.762130856513977,
0.7746997475624084,
0.08282619714736938,
0.546552300453186,
-0.11223123967647552,
-0.038465466350317,
-0.922421395778656,
0.026711776852607727,
-0.7613365650177002,
0.036350928246974945,
-0.9168099761009216,
-0.33246830105781555,
0.47405096888542175,
0.3475874364376068,
-0.28360825777053833,
0.36049583554267883,
-0.4347735345363617,
0.9409999847412109,
0.3082229495048523,
0.0741981640458107,
0.42038464546203613,
0.029298849403858185,
-0.06544569134712219,
0.0550992488861084,
-0.8957908153533936,
-0.817012369632721,
1.4358021020889282,
0.18076802790164948,
1.059478759765625,
0.16082432866096497,
0.8217747807502747,
0.23418940603733063,
0.348745733499527,
-0.33227089047431946,
0.2968471348285675,
-0.7576524615287781,
-0.6399560570716858,
-0.3512602150440216,
-0.2851666212081909,
-1.2471882104873657,
0.4269079864025116,
0.15771858394145966,
-0.6092029809951782,
-0.10351855307817459,
0.2932779788970947,
-0.3068540394306183,
0.4804305136203766,
-0.5565691590309143,
0.9819963574409485,
-0.5387772917747498,
-0.45538318157196045,
-0.4210129678249359,
-0.41039198637008667,
0.3582119941711426,
-0.008101212792098522,
0.31177663803100586,
-0.09272914379835129,
-0.23312503099441528,
0.6149412393569946,
-0.3002931475639343,
0.874176561832428,
-0.09421870112419128,
-0.3104358911514282,
0.32045578956604004,
-0.10282265394926071,
0.4126884937286377,
0.062177423387765884,
-0.3902823328971863,
0.2069694995880127,
0.00397104024887085,
-0.7361814975738525,
-0.4998381733894348,
0.8057209849357605,
-0.9181442260742188,
-0.5297458171844482,
-0.05614763870835304,
-0.14421620965003967,
0.020403947681188583,
0.08057073503732681,
0.13509303331375122,
0.34242427349090576,
-0.4217713475227356,
0.20757408440113068,
1.0992581844329834,
-0.6552202701568604,
0.3717723786830902,
0.29741770029067993,
-0.31366199254989624,
-0.6183456182479858,
0.9313825964927673,
-0.07655305415391922,
0.6395286917686462,
0.5288313031196594,
0.09212353825569153,
-0.36627644300460815,
-0.4399968683719635,
-0.5740712285041809,
0.11061795055866241,
-0.7615483403205872,
-0.04289869964122772,
-0.5348976850509644,
-0.15644480288028717,
-0.229357048869133,
-0.2605079710483551,
-0.6257532835006714,
-0.3472910225391388,
-0.40063121914863586,
0.08147028833627701,
0.3059217631816864,
0.5650497674942017,
-0.16849328577518463,
0.40112677216529846,
-0.7597929239273071,
0.2620270550251007,
0.3225078284740448,
0.3300604522228241,
0.06645943969488144,
-0.5642736554145813,
-0.343307226896286,
0.07993125170469284,
-0.2568359971046448,
-0.46146833896636963,
0.40431705117225647,
0.29742172360420227,
0.5088038444519043,
0.5117217898368835,
0.21474111080169678,
0.5653959512710571,
-0.34744706749916077,
0.5799068212509155,
0.12220032513141632,
-0.7243925929069519,
0.759469747543335,
-0.32672321796417236,
0.22915934026241302,
0.412535160779953,
0.05680379271507263,
-0.4834118187427521,
-0.26982465386390686,
-0.5281640887260437,
-0.6583439707756042,
0.4651239812374115,
-0.014071011915802956,
0.2632075846195221,
-0.2450488656759262,
0.33247658610343933,
0.2812142074108124,
0.03385097533464432,
-0.5094582438468933,
0.1250363141298294,
-0.21449926495552063,
-0.43747037649154663,
-0.12656831741333008,
-0.23046086728572845,
0.1802186220884323,
-0.064869225025177,
0.5437864661216736,
-0.32960665225982666,
-0.04431317001581192,
-0.07242798805236816,
-0.28177890181541443,
-0.034070659428834915,
0.6263338327407837,
0.4930778741836548,
0.5153919458389282,
0.10426927357912064,
0.09933310002088547,
0.51535964012146,
-0.2704489231109619,
0.10934736579656601,
-0.11650209873914719,
-0.0004017276514787227,
-0.027470218017697334,
0.30846312642097473,
0.8677050471305847,
0.43782612681388855,
-0.7365898489952087,
0.12820282578468323,
0.19438739120960236,
0.19508419930934906,
-0.43022382259368896,
0.3831039369106293,
0.03073187731206417,
0.08111626654863358,
-0.0657963752746582,
-0.08129648864269257,
-0.1690797209739685,
-0.4675940275192261,
-0.29372909665107727,
0.22390654683113098,
-0.26219993829727173,
-0.40730521082878113,
0.8555320501327515,
0.5545564293861389,
-0.4034217298030853,
0.6363152265548706,
-0.29161712527275085,
-0.38457104563713074,
0.528651773929596,
0.5495204329490662,
0.9408533573150635,
-0.4192313253879547,
0.10057112574577332,
0.4692958891391754,
0.4124252200126648,
-0.23744840919971466,
0.26744550466537476,
-0.07603197544813156,
-0.5096771717071533,
-0.6599169969558716,
-0.987692654132843,
-0.621343195438385,
0.0036614248529076576,
-0.7338438034057617,
0.2517580986022949,
-0.33101752400398254,
0.04061688110232353,
-0.5692446827888489,
-0.003420598106458783,
-0.8074461817741394,
-0.19053992629051208,
-0.13331066071987152,
0.8880215883255005,
-0.7795243859291077,
1.0495308637619019,
0.6432024836540222,
-0.19390423595905304,
-0.3068428933620453,
-0.16345317661762238,
-0.2984902560710907,
-0.572557270526886,
0.5804706811904907,
-0.04612373933196068,
0.09616755694150925,
0.043073032051324844,
-0.35096943378448486,
-0.7831117510795593,
0.7637768983840942,
0.5868144035339355,
-0.6971702575683594,
0.05077362433075905,
0.3584669232368469,
0.7808652520179749,
-0.27363231778144836,
0.16324259340763092,
0.7349744439125061,
0.3964555561542511,
-0.12060462683439255,
-0.9806906580924988,
-0.2455013394355774,
-0.04984946921467781,
0.5174349546432495,
0.29959574341773987,
-0.6639891862869263,
0.5552585124969482,
-0.2776568531990051,
-0.08157791197299957,
0.4951912462711334,
0.810524046421051,
0.28771448135375977,
0.11887220293283463,
0.30916550755500793,
0.5582571625709534,
0.7922524809837341,
-0.09742080420255661,
1.1383521556854248,
-0.2728036940097809,
0.02450375258922577,
1.0061596632003784,
-0.26017290353775024,
1.0303552150726318,
0.1567518711090088,
-0.23553229868412018,
0.37940892577171326,
0.4296242892742157,
0.46969708800315857,
0.356772780418396,
0.06172977387905121,
-0.37289077043533325,
-0.33608120679855347,
-0.1774313896894455,
-0.3910468518733978,
0.36815857887268066,
0.8640432357788086,
-0.24699395895004272,
-0.270998477935791,
0.32461488246917725,
0.023661503568291664,
0.39360710978507996,
-0.47909173369407654,
0.6466359496116638,
0.12057042866945267,
-0.6434482932090759,
0.8056225180625916,
0.10125195235013962,
0.754607617855072,
-0.38923409581184387,
0.010757558979094028,
-0.3584679961204529,
0.45502564311027527,
-0.13190077245235443,
-0.7157971262931824,
0.42992791533470154,
0.15927834808826447,
0.0700935646891594,
-0.1767292320728302,
0.7374903559684753,
-0.6385585069656372,
-0.479156494140625,
0.05235026776790619,
0.31379035115242004,
0.3474310636520386,
0.1802896112203598,
-0.5278019309043884,
0.42607346177101135,
-0.08656647056341171,
0.031479496508836746,
0.27281105518341064,
0.6454693675041199,
-0.21728123724460602,
0.5847687721252441,
0.6286664605140686,
0.14275991916656494,
0.10866177827119827,
0.013986196368932724,
0.5077253580093384,
-0.6010057330131531,
-0.41963914036750793,
-0.5765365362167358,
0.35547953844070435,
-0.17322960495948792,
-0.4458844065666199,
0.5557323098182678,
0.42637690901756287,
1.2087781429290771,
-0.25218865275382996,
0.7442859411239624,
-0.03263413906097412,
0.5083855986595154,
-0.72625333070755,
0.6843154430389404,
-0.4190931022167206,
0.33608731627464294,
-0.11461270600557327,
-1.047690987586975,
-0.24810051918029785,
0.47707322239875793,
-0.18079115450382233,
-0.015102607198059559,
0.4208497107028961,
0.8542296886444092,
-0.10701052844524384,
-0.06310748308897018,
0.6712093353271484,
0.18602333962917328,
0.3340384364128113,
0.7822712659835815,
0.822576642036438,
-0.31857720017433167,
0.6963546276092529,
-0.059687767177820206,
-0.3427268862724304,
-0.33842891454696655,
-0.7657384872436523,
-1.2024729251861572,
-0.475915789604187,
-0.41666534543037415,
-0.09365357458591461,
0.40580999851226807,
0.9884172081947327,
0.4979115426540375,
-0.8015723824501038,
-0.42201727628707886,
-0.19997218251228333,
0.36853212118148804,
-0.3033912777900696,
-0.1353541761636734,
0.5645777583122253,
-0.5283679962158203,
-0.9702497124671936,
0.2857208251953125,
0.43812498450279236,
-0.08160901814699173,
-0.37978988885879517,
-0.2982345521450043,
0.3855338394641876,
-0.12687118351459503,
0.8613632917404175,
0.7053586840629578,
-0.963526725769043,
-0.13420827686786652,
-0.1299753040075302,
-0.044276993721723557,
-0.24542193114757538,
0.5008994936943054,
-0.5657830834388733,
0.4949243664741516,
0.40251827239990234,
0.8173940181732178,
0.43425363302230835,
-0.3945811688899994,
0.3267432451248169,
-0.5734422206878662,
0.27629444003105164,
0.012770039960741997,
0.23972156643867493,
0.42536279559135437,
0.049166981130838394,
0.6149696707725525,
-0.09477026760578156,
-0.5405917763710022,
-0.6176889538764954,
0.2858124375343323,
-0.6611953973770142,
-0.0901888981461525,
1.2167078256607056,
-0.2803800702095032,
-0.4676046669483185,
-0.19119267165660858,
-0.35329630970954895,
0.2152724713087082,
-0.14172817766666412,
0.7134224772453308,
0.4338257908821106,
0.16261830925941467,
-0.20948593318462372,
-0.6513106822967529,
0.2545766234397888,
0.23538295924663544,
-1.001623511314392,
0.131825253367424,
0.2745044529438019,
0.2732909917831421,
0.008530514314770699,
0.2920902669429779,
-0.34051933884620667,
0.25573334097862244,
0.024689631536602974,
-0.03815660998225212,
0.04734678566455841,
-0.18244455754756927,
-0.39691632986068726,
0.11205150187015533,
0.4886550307273865,
-0.25146278738975525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06137v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06137v1
|
SmurfCat at SemEval-2024 Task 6: Leveraging Synthetic Data for Hallucination Detection
| 2024-04-09T09:03:44 | 2024-04-09T09:03:44 |
Elisei Rykov, Yana Shishkina, Kseniia Petrushina, Kseniia Titova, Sergey Petrakov, Alexander Panchenko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we present our novel systems developed for the SemEval-2024
hallucination detection task. Our investigation spans a range of strategies to
compare model predictions with reference standards, encompassing diverse
baselines, the refinement of pre-trained encoders through supervised learning,
and an ensemble approaches utilizing several high-performing models. Through
these explorations, we introduce three distinct methods that exhibit strong
performance metrics. To amplify our training data, we generate additional
training samples from unlabelled training subset. Furthermore, we provide a
detailed comparative analysis of our approaches. Notably, our premier method
achieved a commendable 9th place in the competition's model-agnostic track and
17th place in model-aware track, highlighting its effectiveness and potential.
|
[
-0.6885543465614319,
-0.4862881004810333,
0.6877799034118652,
0.041706398129463196,
-0.14223480224609375,
-0.011274437420070171,
-0.09063945710659027,
-0.5744284987449646,
0.3535524308681488,
0.6431030035018921,
-0.764662504196167,
-0.2899526357650757,
-0.47750067710876465,
0.5100201368331909,
-0.5730586647987366,
0.6747288703918457,
0.14813128113746643,
0.23899470269680023,
-0.4945189654827118,
-0.24440237879753113,
-0.34964779019355774,
-0.7624583840370178,
-0.28540706634521484,
-0.3651815950870514,
0.19796991348266602,
0.16859112679958344,
0.22909577190876007,
0.1545303761959076,
0.5281269550323486,
0.32400792837142944,
0.19419826567173004,
0.505462646484375,
-0.2691129744052887,
0.21683739125728607,
-0.08699417859315872,
-0.03608123958110809,
-0.4447401762008667,
-0.02179606445133686,
0.29418736696243286,
0.4423377215862274,
-0.12018557637929916,
0.2982867360115051,
-0.021129032596945763,
0.29435738921165466,
-0.7413979172706604,
-0.1265513300895691,
-0.7588213682174683,
0.2793509066104889,
-0.036220937967300415,
-0.4757998585700989,
-0.6935213804244995,
-0.19565272331237793,
-0.0565621554851532,
-0.3236983120441437,
0.5876914262771606,
-0.04142751544713974,
0.684728741645813,
0.6787526607513428,
-0.17598477005958557,
-0.39929383993148804,
-0.6582469344139099,
0.7092805504798889,
-0.6517682075500488,
0.7585675716400146,
0.3702162504196167,
0.6445573568344116,
0.021885285153985023,
-1.0067663192749023,
-0.2604353129863739,
-0.21550951898097992,
-0.17915117740631104,
0.07803182303905487,
0.13847900927066803,
-0.11592701822519302,
0.4381353259086609,
0.38004520535469055,
-0.7661149501800537,
-0.03825266659259796,
-0.5330788493156433,
-0.6021987795829773,
0.6565330624580383,
-0.04061806574463844,
-0.27815738320350647,
-0.11532634496688843,
-0.2953367829322815,
-0.1342298686504364,
-0.3125426769256592,
-0.30234044790267944,
0.36026477813720703,
0.35289818048477173,
0.4470292329788208,
0.3895431458950043,
-0.29184988141059875,
0.3315495550632477,
0.3178727328777313,
0.3154887855052948,
0.639732837677002,
-0.19354306161403656,
-0.4320903718471527,
0.2529732882976532,
0.4884936511516571,
-0.10048616677522659,
-0.13200007379055023,
-0.3564183712005615,
-0.6199350953102112,
0.5000231266021729,
0.4962930381298065,
-0.8464565873146057,
-0.5339133143424988,
0.26277652382850647,
-0.5094478726387024,
-0.6534858345985413,
-0.020121656358242035,
-1.0380725860595703,
-0.7315834164619446,
-0.7092689275741577,
1.0919486284255981,
-0.4490433931350708,
-0.2239762246608734,
0.1739046573638916,
-0.13683727383613586,
0.3685505986213684,
0.31212082505226135,
-0.6537505388259888,
0.518913209438324,
0.4782569110393524,
0.6625084280967712,
-0.46928903460502625,
-0.15322740375995636,
-0.7748468518257141,
-0.18357543647289276,
-0.025446241721510887,
1.037408709526062,
-0.4872840940952301,
-0.2194535881280899,
-0.34356898069381714,
0.5356156826019287,
-0.1441631317138672,
-0.863218367099762,
0.9196261167526245,
0.03251323476433754,
-0.015111272223293781,
-0.2148664891719818,
-0.42787957191467285,
-0.4198451638221741,
0.04771340638399124,
-0.7707801461219788,
0.9932442903518677,
-0.024858569726347923,
-0.5547807812690735,
0.3934396505355835,
-0.4376988112926483,
-0.34022554755210876,
0.22670230269432068,
-0.3373028039932251,
-0.6509039998054504,
0.29717570543289185,
0.4540831744670868,
0.6937348246574402,
0.13086383044719696,
0.161868155002594,
-0.34490707516670227,
-0.7475616335868835,
-0.006124616134911776,
-0.29962727427482605,
0.5419105887413025,
0.23766367137432098,
-0.7476726770401001,
0.23888200521469116,
-0.8736613392829895,
-0.08080960065126419,
0.08545815199613571,
0.33517834544181824,
-0.020199857652187347,
-0.2172376960515976,
-0.0369543693959713,
0.06153993681073189,
0.08611561357975006,
-0.33870741724967957,
-0.14435304701328278,
-0.1273532658815384,
0.3282175064086914,
0.9453470706939697,
0.05875382944941521,
0.20009011030197144,
-0.31266942620277405,
0.473202645778656,
-0.10864891111850739,
0.19651633501052856,
-0.10138820111751556,
-0.12048766016960144,
-0.7948649525642395,
-0.2369796186685562,
0.38627323508262634,
0.27763649821281433,
-0.4610482156276703,
0.4877796769142151,
0.08836044371128082,
-0.44501370191574097,
-0.5418996810913086,
-0.27406439185142517,
-0.2227116823196411,
0.22061733901500702,
0.6591696739196777,
-0.13396842777729034,
-1.107511043548584,
-0.8802040219306946,
-0.06909014284610748,
0.28551819920539856,
0.06568148732185364,
0.2720840275287628,
0.8490116596221924,
-0.7670173048973083,
0.1734113097190857,
-0.25123295187950134,
-0.4292781949043274,
0.017351629212498665,
0.13621895015239716,
-0.023969637230038643,
0.5805734395980835,
0.5292237401008606,
-0.5500850081443787,
0.06825073063373566,
0.04366760328412056,
-1.0410032272338867,
-0.15753383934497833,
-0.07023632526397705,
-0.16903196275234222,
0.30509719252586365,
0.7179632782936096,
-0.14861252903938293,
0.5014950037002563,
0.39072954654693604,
-0.07178471237421036,
0.7515603303909302,
0.006285520736128092,
0.5491684675216675,
-0.8101000785827637,
-0.08957678079605103,
-0.24733813107013702,
-0.2649971842765808,
-0.7891631722450256,
-0.04642390087246895,
0.04286273568868637,
0.014648733660578728,
-0.19362692534923553,
0.07693149149417877,
-0.24627076089382172,
-0.3428111970424652,
-0.2553611993789673,
-0.36985287070274353,
-0.28744158148765564,
0.5985037684440613,
0.38550689816474915,
0.49992114305496216,
0.2691287696361542,
-0.4674959182739258,
0.17492790520191193,
-0.051319822669029236,
-0.09325767308473587,
0.36882710456848145,
-0.5313406586647034,
0.49082431197166443,
-0.08049792796373367,
0.10018101334571838,
-0.8383337259292603,
-0.4772385358810425,
0.033951856195926666,
-0.6964932680130005,
0.09721487760543823,
0.06109394505620003,
-0.47731390595436096,
-0.5261887311935425,
-0.1649421751499176,
0.36280542612075806,
0.639935314655304,
-0.7405204176902771,
0.7950423359870911,
0.5046835541725159,
0.2880762219429016,
-0.19163911044597626,
-0.538146436214447,
-0.2862838804721832,
-0.56968092918396,
-0.4818761348724365,
0.4733509123325348,
-0.0021964083425700665,
0.04002998769283295,
-0.35792461037635803,
-0.48896366357803345,
0.005172187928110361,
0.02355329878628254,
0.4663623869419098,
0.14486677944660187,
-0.19868402183055878,
0.054907798767089844,
-0.01838567852973938,
-0.0635470375418663,
0.1495465636253357,
-0.33094000816345215,
0.6701851487159729,
-0.47610992193222046,
-0.3996737003326416,
-0.43957698345184326,
0.01695285178720951,
0.640064537525177,
-0.19235821068286896,
0.4407472014427185,
0.9658970832824707,
-1.010370135307312,
-0.3735186457633972,
-0.8389214277267456,
-0.6979838609695435,
-0.5473091006278992,
-0.007939106784760952,
-0.5047827363014221,
-0.7155293226242065,
0.5485092997550964,
-0.2650516927242279,
-0.15087026357650757,
0.319729208946228,
0.4992740750312805,
-0.04945490509271622,
1.3751988410949707,
0.17941619455814362,
0.3963986039161682,
-0.015251941978931427,
-0.4389260709285736,
0.27548083662986755,
-0.556327223777771,
-0.39714235067367554,
-0.4846843183040619,
-0.22490161657333374,
-0.6492919325828552,
-0.4661768674850464,
0.17926201224327087,
-0.24302071332931519,
-0.31032833456993103,
0.660159170627594,
-0.8502032160758972,
0.24757926166057587,
0.3033558428287506,
0.22873197495937347,
0.1877107322216034,
0.15150581300258636,
-0.1342332810163498,
-0.23659008741378784,
-0.44180387258529663,
-0.43929412961006165,
1.0801432132720947,
0.10653705149888992,
0.6015688180923462,
-0.22932615876197815,
0.9597809910774231,
0.5844939947128296,
-0.16765709221363068,
-0.5351374745368958,
0.6550187468528748,
-0.10665678977966309,
-0.23228944838047028,
-0.31994229555130005,
-0.11804184317588806,
-0.7147217392921448,
0.43582648038864136,
-0.25432971119880676,
-0.6306585669517517,
0.38816946744918823,
-0.12346192449331284,
-0.4867361783981323,
0.08333675563335419,
-0.49231597781181335,
0.8238915205001831,
-0.1279948204755783,
-0.21673829853534698,
-0.027454104274511337,
-0.3547983765602112,
0.47182929515838623,
-0.29717645049095154,
0.10066279023885727,
-0.02575351856648922,
0.38515204191207886,
0.7398266792297363,
-0.2732177972793579,
0.46827778220176697,
-0.31915032863616943,
0.32676878571510315,
0.11458660662174225,
-0.021884635090827942,
0.6007607579231262,
-0.054361313581466675,
-0.08301541209220886,
0.06736045330762863,
0.3122049570083618,
-0.26379674673080444,
-0.5234480500221252,
0.735174298286438,
-0.5578902363777161,
-0.2360977977514267,
-0.6813095808029175,
-0.2748320996761322,
-0.27167564630508423,
-0.009451749734580517,
0.5271920561790466,
0.45232895016670227,
-0.15197592973709106,
0.4696173071861267,
0.7855589389801025,
-0.01871841959655285,
0.07642976194620132,
0.010151011869311333,
-0.14012448489665985,
-0.4504930377006531,
1.0117179155349731,
0.037632208317518234,
-0.10410210490226746,
-0.10737645626068115,
-0.022582439705729485,
-0.5273152589797974,
-0.5631526708602905,
-0.13029147684574127,
0.3102206289768219,
-0.7063502073287964,
-0.2538929283618927,
-0.9509603381156921,
-0.5813811421394348,
-0.9190951585769653,
-0.24912983179092407,
-0.42437753081321716,
-0.28405195474624634,
-0.2576388120651245,
-0.2954384982585907,
-0.021109677851200104,
0.4078483283519745,
-0.2041938304901123,
0.0764261782169342,
-0.4075254499912262,
0.25133657455444336,
0.22927476465702057,
-0.27397283911705017,
-0.24593697488307953,
-0.7285676002502441,
-0.030886339023709297,
-0.05107497796416283,
-0.2523622512817383,
-0.6661567091941833,
0.6738869547843933,
-0.004565320909023285,
1.0226342678070068,
0.34415581822395325,
0.16109037399291992,
0.8880711793899536,
-0.18088866770267487,
0.5519912838935852,
-0.21524494886398315,
-0.8462372422218323,
0.8988606929779053,
-0.039673250168561935,
-0.0808144211769104,
0.8293525576591492,
0.3087918758392334,
-0.04048639163374901,
-0.2900621294975281,
-0.841835618019104,
-0.45965543389320374,
0.45931005477905273,
0.5951613187789917,
-0.4556293189525604,
0.3262978792190552,
0.2810128927230835,
0.5053072571754456,
0.2641374468803406,
-0.6183772087097168,
0.23653443157672882,
-0.2822122573852539,
-0.23221707344055176,
-0.02773120626807213,
0.10014206916093826,
0.11168291419744492,
-0.41443708539009094,
0.8836808800697327,
-0.2293771356344223,
0.4950852394104004,
0.10625442117452621,
-0.42252957820892334,
0.19210825860500336,
-0.18841423094272614,
0.564344584941864,
0.34222131967544556,
-0.3185649812221527,
0.26022636890411377,
0.6014859676361084,
-0.5463439226150513,
0.2510225772857666,
0.12966623902320862,
-0.1517554372549057,
0.11974352598190308,
0.26487091183662415,
0.7512449622154236,
0.17260506749153137,
-0.6139889359474182,
0.38155755400657654,
-0.06661804020404816,
-0.5158286690711975,
-0.6520229578018188,
0.04403995722532272,
-0.33111831545829773,
0.444375216960907,
0.15036118030548096,
0.45217815041542053,
0.7490776181221008,
-0.31298232078552246,
0.714345395565033,
0.17350661754608154,
-0.5852277874946594,
-0.6475477814674377,
0.6711822152137756,
-0.024872876703739166,
-0.15479637682437897,
0.41007447242736816,
-0.4146162271499634,
-0.6435049772262573,
0.6457951664924622,
0.3498971462249756,
1.0064563751220703,
-0.6245025396347046,
0.2324056327342987,
0.7198754549026489,
0.29082128405570984,
-0.3552008867263794,
0.3377975821495056,
-0.28004977107048035,
-0.7046104669570923,
-0.05222875624895096,
-0.85390305519104,
0.008827080950140953,
0.6140071153640747,
-0.9401288628578186,
0.6697210669517517,
-0.21948932111263275,
-0.19608736038208008,
0.16557778418064117,
0.046195968985557556,
-0.7437178492546082,
0.13800093531608582,
0.21512015163898468,
0.5080434679985046,
-1.0344133377075195,
0.6050140261650085,
0.5544533133506775,
-0.20498697459697723,
-0.3708460032939911,
-0.01774756796658039,
0.2039010375738144,
-0.5107704997062683,
0.19533830881118774,
0.7257999777793884,
-0.22941692173480988,
-0.005190881434828043,
-0.4405205249786377,
-0.5468342304229736,
1.3556456565856934,
0.05301015451550484,
-0.3666521906852722,
-0.16142143309116364,
-0.2073613852262497,
0.4805156886577606,
-0.5026741623878479,
-0.011282847262918949,
1.0901587009429932,
0.34132397174835205,
0.5151486396789551,
-0.6100536584854126,
-0.033965591341257095,
-0.1559174358844757,
-0.3176729083061218,
0.11128214001655579,
-0.302173376083374,
0.3813202679157257,
-0.07126625627279282,
-0.24525043368339539,
0.33782386779785156,
0.7287370562553406,
0.7126314043998718,
0.696998119354248,
0.5711289048194885,
0.5645013451576233,
1.072610855102539,
-0.2262486219406128,
0.36663901805877686,
-0.0567423552274704,
0.2532174587249756,
1.2601585388183594,
-0.3998975157737732,
0.6995258331298828,
0.4882413446903229,
-0.00289224274456501,
0.2870568037033081,
0.9891675114631653,
-0.254982054233551,
0.8230061531066895,
0.11435719579458237,
-0.32299870252609253,
-0.668641984462738,
-0.0003760136023629457,
-0.4312737286090851,
0.5214957594871521,
0.6149823665618896,
-0.3003852963447571,
0.04940764605998993,
0.4623914957046509,
-0.6983867883682251,
-0.12342486530542374,
-0.20846213400363922,
0.6747279167175293,
-0.00841353926807642,
-0.6663378477096558,
0.48286107182502747,
-0.51869136095047,
0.7568686604499817,
-0.015898142009973526,
-0.12548145651817322,
-0.1856643706560135,
0.43328598141670227,
-0.2686077356338501,
-0.09933002293109894,
0.3335774838924408,
-0.2276822179555893,
0.31386202573776245,
0.05337350815534592,
1.0391792058944702,
-0.17990149557590485,
-0.5548915266990662,
0.24476028978824615,
0.3266865611076355,
0.5261039137840271,
-0.3272716701030731,
-0.37972867488861084,
0.20359739661216736,
0.07029981911182404,
0.27573922276496887,
0.12676328420639038,
0.4447801113128662,
-0.13088339567184448,
0.3793831169605255,
0.5146591067314148,
-0.08856970071792603,
0.14704401791095734,
0.29508286714553833,
0.5561933517456055,
-0.6148436665534973,
-0.3954108953475952,
-0.5452424883842468,
0.25252509117126465,
-0.2998650372028351,
0.08887786418199539,
0.6864026188850403,
0.6968281865119934,
0.9864493608474731,
-0.20191119611263275,
0.6087222099304199,
0.30037346482276917,
0.563721776008606,
-0.4201177656650543,
0.5170571208000183,
-0.5457053780555725,
0.2636440694332123,
-0.19559018313884735,
-0.9262807369232178,
-0.055712562054395676,
1.006170630455017,
-0.024727944284677505,
0.07847651839256287,
0.7711434960365295,
1.1700440645217896,
-0.1964402198791504,
0.5831698179244995,
0.49417051672935486,
0.10212436318397522,
0.11069583892822266,
0.4691314697265625,
1.1456300020217896,
-0.6853026747703552,
0.33115848898887634,
-0.40509065985679626,
-0.11761059612035751,
-0.46967849135398865,
-0.41221338510513306,
-1.0387372970581055,
-0.9140273928642273,
-0.426923930644989,
-0.4149326682090759,
0.2257751077413559,
0.7825572490692139,
0.9065406918525696,
-1.2671946287155151,
0.011882500723004341,
-0.28169721364974976,
-0.4431747496128082,
-0.38548368215560913,
-0.1942221224308014,
0.22949521243572235,
-0.38928771018981934,
-0.6360646486282349,
0.6494736671447754,
0.18335753679275513,
0.36626991629600525,
-0.28361770510673523,
-0.22677218914031982,
0.019625864923000336,
0.06912469118833542,
0.681918203830719,
-0.1819358915090561,
-0.8915462493896484,
-0.43037304282188416,
0.42400336265563965,
0.11795509606599808,
-0.18246088922023773,
0.740372359752655,
-1.126549243927002,
0.4048820734024048,
0.7249391078948975,
0.6395017504692078,
0.8507267236709595,
0.03824136033654213,
0.37443357706069946,
-0.29856303334236145,
0.1275544911623001,
0.6000121235847473,
0.3965761363506317,
0.23243434727191925,
-0.5006378889083862,
1.1378575563430786,
0.42550259828567505,
-0.8861463665962219,
-1.4393233060836792,
-0.32080525159835815,
-0.8477092385292053,
-0.23976768553256989,
0.9052058458328247,
0.28513312339782715,
-0.0944180116057396,
-0.04996594414114952,
-0.04932199791073799,
0.057820845395326614,
-0.08387792855501175,
0.8352189064025879,
0.6607998609542847,
-0.49874788522720337,
-0.12848669290542603,
-0.6526858806610107,
0.8404819965362549,
0.2634669840335846,
-0.9207180738449097,
-0.2934052050113678,
0.6641954183578491,
-0.010130827315151691,
0.21778076887130737,
0.4697960615158081,
-0.19174058735370636,
0.6039646863937378,
0.10184753686189651,
-0.11864791065454483,
0.10720660537481308,
-0.741401195526123,
-0.561421811580658,
0.171929731965065,
-0.4974697530269623,
-0.220092311501503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06121v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06121v1
|
Detection of fields of applications in biomedical abstracts with the support of argumentation elements
| 2024-04-09T08:44:02 | 2024-04-09T08:44:02 |
Mariana Neves
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Focusing on particular facts, instead of the complete text, can potentially
improve searching for specific information in the scientific literature. In
particular, argumentative elements allow focusing on specific parts of a
publication, e.g., the background section or the claims from the authors. We
evaluated some tools for the extraction of argumentation elements for a
specific task in biomedicine, namely, for detecting the fields of the
application in a biomedical publication, e.g, whether it addresses the problem
of disease diagnosis or drug development. We performed experiments with the
PubMedBERT pre-trained model, which was fine-tuned on a specific corpus for the
task. We compared the use of title and abstract to restricting to only some
argumentative elements. The top F1 scores ranged from 0.22 to 0.84, depending
on the field of application. The best argumentative labels were the ones
related the conclusion and background sections of an abstract.
|
[
-0.34476736187934875,
-0.5778780579566956,
0.9570354223251343,
0.09983906894922256,
-0.47004976868629456,
-0.1591547429561615,
0.11673489958047867,
-0.4272393584251404,
0.15150129795074463,
0.15283708274364471,
-0.2828197479248047,
-0.9070231318473816,
-0.45961296558380127,
0.5768818855285645,
-0.27991983294487,
1.2546820640563965,
-0.11754601448774338,
0.17527718842029572,
-0.73757404088974,
-0.29745233058929443,
-0.19002975523471832,
-0.4203432500362396,
-0.42782822251319885,
-0.44704315066337585,
0.8806261420249939,
0.14016243815422058,
0.333318829536438,
0.7739959359169006,
0.6006489992141724,
0.37383049726486206,
-0.1135084331035614,
0.020976725965738297,
0.20360182225704193,
0.2654687166213989,
-0.7966724634170532,
-0.37232547998428345,
-0.2946334481239319,
0.05208967626094818,
0.3045687973499298,
0.6012470126152039,
0.4827834367752075,
0.1611577421426773,
-0.4294866621494293,
0.4359920620918274,
-0.5422226190567017,
-0.012526667676866055,
-0.27396726608276367,
0.1818079650402069,
-0.4152871072292328,
-0.6099069118499756,
-0.15111590921878815,
-0.20682929456233978,
0.3442532420158386,
-0.6117746829986572,
0.3272913694381714,
-0.14238975942134857,
1.1315144300460815,
-0.07933716475963593,
-0.13208289444446564,
-0.1941370666027069,
-0.35087570548057556,
0.7805094122886658,
-0.6188982725143433,
0.1800069957971573,
0.23162460327148438,
-0.10031779855489731,
-0.09792688488960266,
-0.6106079816818237,
-0.06403456628322601,
0.022266581654548645,
-0.28370222449302673,
0.25799402594566345,
-0.4904051423072815,
0.4330523908138275,
0.2343960553407669,
0.21050213277339935,
-0.5948306918144226,
-0.09116388112306595,
-0.71857088804245,
-0.5034638047218323,
0.6539096236228943,
0.037136103957891464,
0.31044459342956543,
-0.012442250736057758,
-0.1405031532049179,
0.1396058350801468,
-0.8339953422546387,
0.07491400837898254,
0.0784003958106041,
-0.19691303372383118,
0.03701097518205643,
0.5478317141532898,
-0.32273611426353455,
0.9110480546951294,
0.0764010027050972,
0.013820220716297626,
0.27058523893356323,
-0.506191611289978,
0.06995649635791779,
0.18755552172660828,
0.6686370968818665,
0.3056357502937317,
-0.17614547908306122,
-0.2361305058002472,
0.14994078874588013,
0.07305338978767395,
0.26688671112060547,
-0.9951055645942688,
-0.30702921748161316,
0.7569935917854309,
-0.759615957736969,
-0.5482853651046753,
-0.1752467006444931,
-0.6554693579673767,
-0.3072567582130432,
0.1572456955909729,
0.3090599775314331,
-0.4276390075683594,
0.14659981429576874,
0.025449983775615692,
-0.5041404962539673,
0.15863285958766937,
0.19281741976737976,
-0.589802086353302,
0.0037084706127643585,
0.4495953321456909,
1.0049164295196533,
-0.32425349950790405,
0.027346139773726463,
-0.3089680075645447,
-0.011816424317657948,
-0.30289745330810547,
1.6429779529571533,
-0.737227201461792,
-0.3745444118976593,
-0.27538925409317017,
0.31873369216918945,
-0.02943144179880619,
-0.69783616065979,
0.7316431403160095,
-0.4485122859477997,
-0.08550111949443817,
-0.45609888434410095,
-0.4910012483596802,
-0.4352399706840515,
0.022767702117562294,
-0.5141955614089966,
0.3260832130908966,
0.05107562243938446,
-0.6401345729827881,
0.587174654006958,
-1.010209083557129,
-0.5132267475128174,
0.0471486933529377,
-0.37595072388648987,
-0.5547277927398682,
0.3179852366447449,
0.06770797073841095,
0.40183886885643005,
-0.11995464563369751,
-0.09267618507146835,
-0.31465646624565125,
-0.1680334508419037,
0.4347347319126129,
0.3158419132232666,
0.4977789521217346,
0.32837292551994324,
-0.27711760997772217,
0.345007985830307,
-0.5527567863464355,
-0.05157749727368355,
-0.1852608472108841,
-0.3725645840167999,
-0.5783132314682007,
0.39167800545692444,
-0.28771427273750305,
0.20015102624893188,
-0.06352020800113678,
-0.9647970199584961,
-0.08492796868085861,
-0.5778930187225342,
0.22740164399147034,
0.32630935311317444,
0.32043328881263733,
0.06682861596345901,
-0.3524755537509918,
0.6620709896087646,
0.36953046917915344,
-0.38883572816848755,
-0.42378318309783936,
-0.7170016169548035,
-0.26981016993522644,
-0.3228704333305359,
0.8799106478691101,
0.4493192732334137,
-0.43023577332496643,
0.4251934587955475,
0.3941314220428467,
-0.4249647557735443,
-0.5391780734062195,
-0.1569308042526245,
0.4502159059047699,
0.4767792522907257,
0.3334164023399353,
-0.07273021340370178,
-0.5909576416015625,
-1.1220818758010864,
-0.3384127616882324,
0.01628211699426174,
0.007065927144140005,
0.31990495324134827,
0.5129424333572388,
-0.21170960366725922,
0.9927130937576294,
-0.48903435468673706,
0.07090472429990768,
-0.032541338354349136,
0.354032039642334,
0.27876511216163635,
0.30277445912361145,
0.656534731388092,
-0.9437405467033386,
-0.3089737892150879,
0.38074055314064026,
-0.914151132106781,
-0.8885319232940674,
0.014667459763586521,
-0.23033499717712402,
-0.31417304277420044,
0.4901341497898102,
-0.5494232177734375,
0.3990650475025177,
0.13454890251159668,
-0.5094655156135559,
0.6404236555099487,
-0.1276182383298874,
0.26442793011665344,
-0.7195335626602173,
0.4490039348602295,
0.44621747732162476,
-0.5031037926673889,
-0.5735403299331665,
-0.07005536556243896,
-0.1446024775505066,
-0.06236248463392258,
-0.2811548411846161,
0.4560184180736542,
-0.31518813967704773,
0.2955811321735382,
-0.5029192566871643,
-0.01976092904806137,
0.406728595495224,
-0.2350146770477295,
0.5512468218803406,
0.7449769377708435,
0.47473934292793274,
-0.63536137342453,
0.11024346202611923,
0.14793235063552856,
-0.2801949977874756,
0.276774138212204,
-0.8992175459861755,
-0.24357664585113525,
-0.4230271279811859,
0.06060043349862099,
-1.0765385627746582,
-0.15030424296855927,
-0.0011319821933284402,
-0.20343752205371857,
-0.08777624368667603,
0.1042340025305748,
0.07908185571432114,
-0.15936006605625153,
-0.4410797655582428,
0.2435358613729477,
0.09605497121810913,
0.08383643627166748,
0.35209181904792786,
0.4222450256347656,
-0.568757176399231,
-0.5409764647483826,
-0.363152414560318,
-0.32104286551475525,
-0.44690069556236267,
-0.26397672295570374,
0.8202667236328125,
0.12984523177146912,
-0.4239870607852936,
0.2576051652431488,
-0.2844182252883911,
-0.08789081126451492,
0.07798554748296738,
0.31822511553764343,
0.17134040594100952,
-0.31056222319602966,
0.30119192600250244,
0.5456902980804443,
-0.23659491539001465,
0.11657997220754623,
0.23859156668186188,
0.11516063660383224,
0.00021600256150122732,
-0.17602714896202087,
-0.16010770201683044,
0.7879670858383179,
0.41838958859443665,
-0.1578374207019806,
0.34272077679634094,
0.18039722740650177,
-0.21824660897254944,
0.10063707828521729,
-0.3734603524208069,
-0.20852801203727722,
-0.3890804648399353,
0.5874089002609253,
-0.16980794072151184,
-0.5431030988693237,
0.5927731990814209,
-0.5528314113616943,
0.1563030481338501,
0.8032760620117188,
0.5440109968185425,
-0.24941639602184296,
1.014508605003357,
0.4650551378726959,
0.1779308319091797,
0.10922537744045258,
-0.10288059711456299,
0.19834004342556,
-0.73089998960495,
-0.0422724187374115,
-0.6381692290306091,
-0.28003445267677307,
-0.1512378454208374,
-0.25893640518188477,
0.5822978019714355,
0.1935724914073944,
0.20128735899925232,
0.25865763425827026,
-0.7665174603462219,
0.45809704065322876,
0.07972448319196701,
0.18890953063964844,
0.203261137008667,
0.15739032626152039,
-0.1632061004638672,
0.025983119383454323,
-0.6981084942817688,
-0.6694641709327698,
0.9900774955749512,
0.5517215132713318,
0.16910167038440704,
-0.15069681406021118,
0.7529379725456238,
0.4916706383228302,
0.832448422908783,
-1.0265965461730957,
0.3182258605957031,
-0.32332977652549744,
-1.0067923069000244,
0.10391738265752792,
-0.0794723704457283,
-1.1377301216125488,
0.35967934131622314,
-0.40709105134010315,
-0.7470380067825317,
0.7435387969017029,
0.08175402134656906,
-0.9443979263305664,
-0.15278086066246033,
-0.47134506702423096,
1.054996371269226,
-0.15513737499713898,
-0.3808389902114868,
0.08538185060024261,
-0.2722972631454468,
0.04104701057076454,
-0.1974111944437027,
0.26718035340309143,
-0.12591302394866943,
-0.03505180403590202,
0.9900774955749512,
-0.3239646255970001,
0.4286445081233978,
-0.14477743208408356,
0.1564895063638687,
0.40666770935058594,
-0.42546746134757996,
-0.07424119114875793,
-0.035732463002204895,
-0.23339714109897614,
0.10799407958984375,
0.35416916012763977,
-0.18295028805732727,
-0.23223114013671875,
0.37293699383735657,
-0.31491467356681824,
-0.6836027503013611,
-0.6147539615631104,
-0.3607437312602997,
-0.07543519139289856,
0.4205356538295746,
0.6197670102119446,
0.20323757827281952,
-0.12441352754831314,
0.33436790108680725,
0.7119708061218262,
-0.4424348771572113,
0.22851014137268066,
0.5604425668716431,
0.07089745253324509,
-0.016791215166449547,
0.8106108903884888,
-0.027089431881904602,
-0.18954002857208252,
0.15084189176559448,
0.5467277765274048,
-0.3281552493572235,
-0.9797662496566772,
-0.4483504593372345,
0.16169291734695435,
-0.5889341831207275,
-0.5741197466850281,
-0.803546130657196,
0.052074234932661057,
-0.1775272637605667,
-0.15460635721683502,
-0.13954977691173553,
-0.33133459091186523,
-0.16426220536231995,
-0.03378506377339363,
0.46026769280433655,
0.3918638527393341,
-0.11272825300693512,
0.07459316402673721,
-0.8991789221763611,
0.17793339490890503,
-0.11541404575109482,
0.10227833688259125,
-0.42527833580970764,
-0.04111655429005623,
-0.4442618489265442,
-0.1581389158964157,
-0.6018876433372498,
-1.192797064781189,
0.12010307610034943,
0.32658883929252625,
0.7075623869895935,
0.7097716927528381,
-0.21266908943653107,
0.331394761800766,
-0.4076768755912781,
0.642992377281189,
0.049552470445632935,
-0.5286787152290344,
0.8034922480583191,
-0.3197648227214813,
0.2121516764163971,
0.6674104332923889,
0.76705402135849,
-0.043214526027441025,
-0.27858659625053406,
-0.2664180397987366,
-0.8726199269294739,
0.46171990036964417,
-0.011393867433071136,
-0.3800123929977417,
-0.16644397377967834,
0.6197264194488525,
0.21173220872879028,
0.07054111361503601,
-0.582460343837738,
-0.11976348608732224,
0.12996232509613037,
-0.17244075238704681,
0.4113147258758545,
-0.15883469581604004,
-0.48006537556648254,
-0.32594817876815796,
0.5054842233657837,
-0.11992993205785751,
0.4720281660556793,
0.7628381848335266,
0.13168813288211823,
-0.013027516193687916,
0.4009174406528473,
0.7691421508789062,
0.7066320776939392,
-0.20188477635383606,
0.06077234074473381,
-0.15272055566310883,
-0.610936164855957,
0.19897396862506866,
0.4547867476940155,
-0.2615446448326111,
0.41525551676750183,
0.5679192543029785,
0.3361441195011139,
-0.03804744407534599,
-0.7957364916801453,
0.45675650238990784,
0.39868050813674927,
-0.39029374718666077,
0.16335900127887726,
0.12377818673849106,
0.009792163968086243,
0.5384010076522827,
0.146617129445076,
0.10534307360649109,
0.882313072681427,
-0.6045029759407043,
0.25863003730773926,
0.42017102241516113,
-0.3960593044757843,
-0.3752332329750061,
0.5603107213973999,
0.125870943069458,
0.022859269753098488,
-0.2684450149536133,
-0.023263592272996902,
-0.38598519563674927,
0.6383064389228821,
0.7196981310844421,
0.6071528196334839,
-0.2140565812587738,
0.3025118112564087,
0.12105655670166016,
-0.2983613908290863,
0.13197076320648193,
0.5941232442855835,
-0.1886381208896637,
-0.7058637142181396,
-0.5006176829338074,
-0.6362068057060242,
-0.29506945610046387,
0.27398061752319336,
-0.25903815031051636,
0.19371776282787323,
-0.2571791410446167,
-0.647158145904541,
1.0012950897216797,
-0.2700269818305969,
-0.1733100563287735,
0.29869383573532104,
-0.09761680662631989,
0.8029103875160217,
-0.9480686783790588,
0.6180338859558105,
1.3059982061386108,
-0.3049117922782898,
-0.14472922682762146,
-0.24113135039806366,
-0.08101536333560944,
0.134039506316185,
0.7834083437919617,
-0.0423167422413826,
-0.2257550060749054,
-0.5719213485717773,
-0.3766285479068756,
-0.5966672897338867,
0.7525760531425476,
0.17303842306137085,
-0.31124550104141235,
0.11943555623292923,
-0.2657214403152466,
0.5793348550796509,
-0.4954001009464264,
0.16081449389457703,
0.3816728889942169,
0.49630239605903625,
-0.20443828403949738,
-0.5927862524986267,
0.053688086569309235,
-0.6200894713401794,
-0.26186102628707886,
-0.1361915022134781,
-0.17605999112129211,
0.857735276222229,
-0.02294391207396984,
0.03731433302164078,
0.1246260479092598,
0.39485257863998413,
0.561892569065094,
0.8671247959136963,
0.20477549731731415,
0.15957537293434143,
0.38715338706970215,
-0.19975315034389496,
1.0101239681243896,
-0.2653535008430481,
0.1466670036315918,
0.32561418414115906,
-0.13036717474460602,
0.41918817162513733,
0.44451388716697693,
-0.29020553827285767,
0.737881600856781,
0.7805178165435791,
-0.056110259145498276,
0.7979879975318909,
0.3260708749294281,
-0.4936155378818512,
-0.1851610690355301,
-0.05849827826023102,
-0.5874274969100952,
0.5394642353057861,
0.7904362678527832,
-0.7449020147323608,
-0.2290097028017044,
0.07632517069578171,
0.10994380712509155,
-0.009093153290450573,
-0.3511888086795807,
0.7293031215667725,
0.05074752867221832,
-0.6440407037734985,
0.28105518221855164,
0.4589880108833313,
0.3902285099029541,
-0.590111255645752,
-0.388268381357193,
0.08647023141384125,
0.14440226554870605,
-0.6579610109329224,
-0.4616996943950653,
0.547418475151062,
0.077784463763237,
-0.2825838029384613,
0.4801103174686432,
1.259260892868042,
-0.2090863287448883,
-0.3733709752559662,
-0.04494998976588249,
0.32468292117118835,
0.3158065676689148,
0.016795959323644638,
-0.49171316623687744,
0.02694018930196762,
-0.3512348234653473,
-0.33716148138046265,
0.10972071439027786,
0.39576056599617004,
-0.18185658752918243,
0.10970988124608994,
0.4461100399494171,
0.41990429162979126,
-0.43288153409957886,
-0.5718514323234558,
0.8527690768241882,
-0.5555406212806702,
-0.23948384821414948,
-0.869116485118866,
0.4513155221939087,
-0.48301100730895996,
-0.32120251655578613,
0.6766673922538757,
0.7109535336494446,
0.087015800178051,
-0.29335033893585205,
0.9001389145851135,
0.07384317368268967,
0.5125870704650879,
-0.38649994134902954,
0.7560328245162964,
-0.4693000018596649,
0.05615201219916344,
-0.37614431977272034,
-0.6465685963630676,
-0.6039538383483887,
1.0139113664627075,
-0.4247549772262573,
0.07796622812747955,
0.7774248123168945,
0.3379044532775879,
-0.17843672633171082,
0.18039901554584503,
0.05347621068358421,
0.034030620008707047,
0.12665125727653503,
0.30535635352134705,
0.48906078934669495,
-0.17740191519260406,
-0.1492769569158554,
-0.1931294947862625,
-0.6610843539237976,
-0.17199575901031494,
-0.890942394733429,
-0.8644649386405945,
-0.2868849039077759,
-0.6093462109565735,
-0.5674077868461609,
0.33593079447746277,
0.7364205121994019,
0.7305508255958557,
-1.2303134202957153,
-0.010557650588452816,
-0.04263217747211456,
0.06324606388807297,
-0.4585259258747101,
-0.11588157713413239,
0.5268584489822388,
-0.26702681183815,
-0.3493380844593048,
0.6017442345619202,
0.43709152936935425,
-0.4726628363132477,
0.08226744085550308,
0.38822537660598755,
-0.4600565433502197,
0.2709750235080719,
0.8681817650794983,
0.663023054599762,
-0.34328022599220276,
-0.2718363404273987,
-0.12331411242485046,
0.26846590638160706,
0.10382761061191559,
1.1138964891433716,
-0.7774475812911987,
0.4927249252796173,
0.6155879497528076,
0.5812598466873169,
0.342153400182724,
0.2421381175518036,
0.6867029070854187,
-0.51701819896698,
0.10209953039884567,
0.3131498098373413,
0.27664193511009216,
-0.10735464841127396,
-0.43681085109710693,
0.34741270542144775,
0.3723519742488861,
-0.5701104998588562,
-0.6684427261352539,
-0.12286549061536789,
-0.7099961638450623,
-0.4370376467704773,
0.9758827090263367,
-0.37744346261024475,
-0.3083770275115967,
-0.6531291007995605,
-0.2809385359287262,
0.0909353494644165,
-0.32394176721572876,
0.7641788721084595,
0.7526010274887085,
-0.7219253182411194,
0.03547681123018265,
-0.4589540362358093,
0.7924399375915527,
0.44959551095962524,
-0.8450005650520325,
-0.2635011076927185,
0.334891140460968,
0.2686898410320282,
0.6314752697944641,
0.7400328516960144,
-0.6293838620185852,
0.7006410956382751,
-0.20630308985710144,
-0.06403409689664841,
-0.061044421046972275,
-0.2645384669303894,
-0.3518437445163727,
0.38705167174339294,
0.002132433233782649,
-0.2726503610610962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13057v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13057v1
|
"Hey..! This medicine made me sick": Sentiment Analysis of User-Generated Drug Reviews using Machine Learning Techniques
| 2024-04-09T08:42:34 | 2024-04-09T08:42:34 |
Abhiram B. Nair, Abhinand K., Anamika U., Denil Tom Jaison, Ajitha V., V. S. Anoop
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sentiment analysis has become increasingly important in healthcare,
especially in the biomedical and pharmaceutical fields. The data generated by
the general public on the effectiveness, side effects, and adverse drug
reactions are goldmines for different agencies and medicine producers to
understand the concerns and reactions of people. Despite the challenge of
obtaining datasets on drug-related problems, sentiment analysis on this topic
would be a significant boon to the field. This project proposes a drug review
classification system that classifies user reviews on a particular drug into
different classes, such as positive, negative, and neutral. This approach uses
a dataset that is collected from publicly available sources containing drug
reviews, such as drugs.com. The collected data is manually labeled and verified
manually to ensure that the labels are correct. Three pre-trained language
models, such as BERT, SciBERT, and BioBERT, are used to obtain embeddings,
which were later used as features to different machine learning classifiers
such as decision trees, support vector machines, random forests, and also deep
learning algorithms such as recurrent neural networks. The performance of these
classifiers is quantified using precision, recall, and f1-score, and the
results show that the proposed approaches are useful in analyzing the
sentiments of people on different drugs.
|
[
-0.1935221552848816,
-0.4965243935585022,
0.4843771159648895,
0.057698432356119156,
-0.25550171732902527,
0.009355809539556503,
0.04049314931035042,
-0.5295513868331909,
0.584075391292572,
0.6416682004928589,
-0.2733724117279053,
-0.8387468457221985,
-0.8033015131950378,
0.3633168935775757,
-0.3060092329978943,
1.6508762836456299,
0.22011376917362213,
0.6609073877334595,
-0.08889658004045486,
-0.29128286242485046,
-0.2033289074897766,
-0.845058023929596,
-0.29321977496147156,
-0.4060268998146057,
0.8099685311317444,
0.13011665642261505,
0.7060998678207397,
-0.08541584014892578,
0.8224067687988281,
0.33144405484199524,
-0.006209747865796089,
0.006968011148273945,
-0.09026072919368744,
0.20115399360656738,
-0.14684376120567322,
-0.47373226284980774,
-0.6017841100692749,
0.10589327663183212,
0.003101436886936426,
0.6480852365493774,
0.10296247899532318,
0.09135157614946365,
-0.010214807465672493,
0.7869142293930054,
-0.333802729845047,
-0.17711636424064636,
-0.12242547422647476,
0.5901516675949097,
-0.06841608136892319,
-0.125967338681221,
-0.0695267841219902,
-0.6080424189567566,
0.33511120080947876,
-0.36100587248802185,
0.18342454731464386,
0.027790406718850136,
0.8663926720619202,
0.14632511138916016,
-0.2466786503791809,
-0.5271198153495789,
-0.4437178075313568,
0.6982071995735168,
-0.8294574022293091,
0.0752214640378952,
0.06253976374864578,
0.27375495433807373,
-0.23034816980361938,
-0.6376250982284546,
-0.511568009853363,
-0.07875362783670425,
-0.10897800326347351,
0.26217424869537354,
-0.029360294342041016,
0.19087110459804535,
-0.10597461462020874,
0.557996928691864,
-0.5990833044052124,
0.020712649449706078,
-0.6392238140106201,
-0.27702784538269043,
0.4321599304676056,
0.36382344365119934,
0.3162088990211487,
-0.6365775465965271,
-0.42720502614974976,
0.16838407516479492,
-0.44290974736213684,
0.0032023065723478794,
0.11576871573925018,
0.29837825894355774,
0.13483476638793945,
0.7254430055618286,
-0.19425112009048462,
0.6511697173118591,
-0.09025269001722336,
0.004750897642225027,
0.5848870277404785,
-0.05969124659895897,
-0.6338611841201782,
-0.008691709488630295,
1.10841965675354,
0.7560356855392456,
0.15387330949306488,
0.1353885680437088,
-0.24576880037784576,
0.2776596248149872,
0.37545645236968994,
-0.8851209878921509,
-0.6047680377960205,
0.7018480896949768,
-0.9807577133178711,
-0.8599259853363037,
-0.1673596352338791,
-0.9093155860900879,
-0.8276826739311218,
-0.15709398686885834,
0.4138302505016327,
-0.12095716595649719,
-0.06113271415233612,
0.14206375181674957,
-0.327432781457901,
-0.014472643844783306,
0.19846206903457642,
-0.6952534914016724,
0.14297719299793243,
0.5616423487663269,
0.6803886890411377,
-0.14365115761756897,
-0.19888430833816528,
-0.35889923572540283,
-0.3824058473110199,
-0.21142235398292542,
1.1479921340942383,
-0.14603835344314575,
-0.6159369945526123,
0.01357346773147583,
-0.05494021996855736,
0.11900530010461807,
-0.8677768707275391,
0.4958871006965637,
-0.23315638303756714,
0.5414009690284729,
-0.2947421669960022,
-0.5530734062194824,
-0.06313108652830124,
0.46199434995651245,
-0.3291994333267212,
0.2700284421443939,
0.1628563553094864,
-0.8466484546661377,
0.44711101055145264,
-0.7436270713806152,
-0.5983161926269531,
0.16666291654109955,
-0.15837684273719788,
-0.6977752447128296,
0.5235404968261719,
0.12116566300392151,
0.513462483882904,
-0.09583102911710739,
0.25585806369781494,
-0.5643445253372192,
-0.1792442798614502,
0.6502054929733276,
0.15895742177963257,
0.9164459109306335,
0.7600332498550415,
0.1082414835691452,
0.1580079048871994,
-0.5543817281723022,
0.10818607360124588,
-0.048652663826942444,
-0.4070519506931305,
-0.35761964321136475,
-0.16988219320774078,
0.34515896439552307,
0.4342132806777954,
0.020135488361120224,
-0.5407100915908813,
0.30094844102859497,
-0.7427518963813782,
0.2364010065793991,
0.4895564317703247,
0.5315115451812744,
0.0825483575463295,
-0.08148445934057236,
0.31989407539367676,
0.23665009438991547,
0.3811330795288086,
0.16789978742599487,
-0.6391412019729614,
-0.4781351685523987,
-0.028728775680065155,
0.5484831929206848,
0.7215856909751892,
-0.2619384527206421,
0.5198086500167847,
0.03523235023021698,
-0.005866238847374916,
-0.6928313970565796,
0.19314612448215485,
0.2775125503540039,
0.4741766154766083,
0.2826523184776306,
-0.5485455393791199,
-0.5307798981666565,
-0.7127917408943176,
-0.4642779231071472,
-0.2842555344104767,
-0.19398848712444305,
0.2594183385372162,
0.5895324945449829,
-0.8023868799209595,
0.5804771780967712,
-0.924942672252655,
-0.6302808523178101,
-0.11955470591783524,
0.2760625183582306,
0.12999656796455383,
0.22471678256988525,
0.3796252906322479,
-0.574289083480835,
-0.13431164622306824,
0.17581625282764435,
-0.9053676128387451,
-0.2500399947166443,
0.24665291607379913,
0.03203870356082916,
-0.03733908385038376,
0.12502521276474,
-0.3167003095149994,
0.18006497621536255,
0.4270048439502716,
-0.3116021454334259,
0.20203673839569092,
-0.19665436446666718,
0.33953428268432617,
-1.3447959423065186,
-0.056602753698825836,
0.39816951751708984,
0.05796153098344803,
-0.8086363673210144,
-0.28576138615608215,
-0.291620135307312,
-0.38457050919532776,
-0.27194246649742126,
0.20412154495716095,
-0.045690085738897324,
0.12045972794294357,
-0.3205137848854065,
-0.24071048200130463,
0.3039828836917877,
0.1410103589296341,
0.022406719624996185,
0.06048973649740219,
0.4449438452720642,
-0.3250004053115845,
0.4908473789691925,
0.21689018607139587,
-0.22148814797401428,
0.815105676651001,
-0.4216946065425873,
-0.24991999566555023,
-0.10708949714899063,
0.0911087691783905,
-0.7436041831970215,
-0.6462516188621521,
0.6836270689964294,
-0.6952064037322998,
0.20355167984962463,
-0.2312839925289154,
-0.2559194564819336,
-0.5184915065765381,
-0.26677408814430237,
-0.16870106756687164,
0.407090961933136,
-0.17410066723823547,
0.301988422870636,
0.9080750942230225,
-0.16997428238391876,
-0.4438645839691162,
-0.7549682855606079,
0.16863325238227844,
-0.27825385332107544,
-0.04992097243666649,
0.057069115340709686,
0.10629293322563171,
-0.421570748090744,
0.15667705237865448,
0.22253815829753876,
-0.3014729917049408,
-0.005692433100193739,
0.36879366636276245,
0.2791774272918701,
0.04100186377763748,
0.4522058069705963,
0.21998073160648346,
-0.10354321449995041,
0.40773168206214905,
-0.07013757526874542,
0.15646539628505707,
-0.33813175559043884,
0.08039060980081558,
-0.48784777522087097,
0.5335172414779663,
0.7389140129089355,
-0.06269453465938568,
0.397217333316803,
0.3358970582485199,
-0.3930279314517975,
-0.1833573430776596,
-0.03699101135134697,
-0.3668987452983856,
-0.3747842013835907,
0.4364464282989502,
0.09976141899824142,
-0.43737849593162537,
0.21523086726665497,
-0.24397891759872437,
-0.2072429656982422,
0.3102996051311493,
0.7753357291221619,
-0.5949752926826477,
1.1057871580123901,
0.26350080966949463,
-0.3693244457244873,
-0.01945083774626255,
-0.30432096123695374,
0.2956746816635132,
-0.27667686343193054,
-0.23310460150241852,
-0.3687021732330322,
-0.4223129153251648,
-0.67198246717453,
-0.24435491859912872,
0.6262577772140503,
-0.3734084367752075,
-0.11400298774242401,
-0.2365887463092804,
-0.5786916613578796,
0.2328665405511856,
0.34968301653862,
0.14783354103565216,
-0.03835498169064522,
0.2603890597820282,
-0.06670878827571869,
0.06027704477310181,
-0.3376154899597168,
-0.3674159348011017,
1.07732093334198,
0.5433588027954102,
0.6795211434364319,
-0.31289297342300415,
0.937629222869873,
0.5460580587387085,
0.5776626467704773,
-0.981189489364624,
0.42934903502464294,
-0.5084826946258545,
-0.706312894821167,
0.26756593585014343,
-0.5737872123718262,
-0.7998993396759033,
0.15018083155155182,
-0.5444782376289368,
-0.23846998810768127,
0.15131816267967224,
0.17017383873462677,
-0.6060521602630615,
0.14056256413459778,
-0.9640371799468994,
0.8186663389205933,
-0.4966188371181488,
-0.03578080236911774,
-0.17588071525096893,
-0.8672966957092285,
0.2691880166530609,
0.08952467888593674,
0.2889639735221863,
-0.024787722155451775,
0.3961494565010071,
0.5810429453849792,
-0.7971415519714355,
0.8630410432815552,
-0.38827329874038696,
0.11736327409744263,
0.2267785221338272,
-0.1463080793619156,
-0.2661660313606262,
-0.003817507531493902,
0.14123860001564026,
0.3003063201904297,
-0.03175778687000275,
-0.3178044855594635,
-0.6208499670028687,
1.0068340301513672,
-0.8705446720123291,
-0.2092636525630951,
-0.5746380090713501,
-0.22367021441459656,
-0.26549360156059265,
0.08691228926181793,
0.4385886788368225,
0.4550301432609558,
-0.21471796929836273,
-0.2553132176399231,
0.2916938364505768,
-0.49299994111061096,
-0.1566312462091446,
0.3706642985343933,
-0.30883604288101196,
-0.6626489162445068,
1.0688564777374268,
0.27546849846839905,
-0.21271544694900513,
0.23057496547698975,
0.42249026894569397,
-0.20331013202667236,
-0.4598870873451233,
-0.5189029574394226,
0.07594902068376541,
-0.48533257842063904,
-0.2574656903743744,
-0.6104226112365723,
-0.02900872938334942,
-0.4635671079158783,
0.16668488085269928,
-0.0430736280977726,
-0.309431254863739,
-0.2297428548336029,
-0.03547609969973564,
0.2419973909854889,
1.0127025842666626,
0.03958019241690636,
0.25856253504753113,
-0.9956338405609131,
0.3642582297325134,
0.21144597232341766,
0.5082482099533081,
-0.39954879879951477,
0.0023703218903392553,
-0.23363186419010162,
-0.13327598571777344,
-0.5154666900634766,
-1.157673716545105,
0.6225712895393372,
-0.004485834389925003,
0.2412712424993515,
0.5921433568000793,
0.06834134459495544,
0.22773513197898865,
-0.015199640765786171,
0.7632126212120056,
0.24266324937343597,
-0.5235074758529663,
0.8417647480964661,
-0.14863072335720062,
0.01165001280605793,
0.598226010799408,
0.49136969447135925,
-0.5109725594520569,
-0.4070873558521271,
-0.23852582275867462,
-0.6262588500976562,
0.38546329736709595,
-0.018843406811356544,
-0.079659104347229,
-0.15131130814552307,
0.37749314308166504,
0.142245814204216,
0.19781604409217834,
-0.5276502370834351,
-0.4059370160102844,
-0.41496580839157104,
-0.5690111517906189,
-0.0048952787183225155,
-0.16846275329589844,
-0.09592185914516449,
-0.056575242429971695,
0.6648081541061401,
0.013238755986094475,
0.24074766039848328,
0.28277429938316345,
-0.15151400864124298,
-0.15289948880672455,
0.6406709551811218,
0.22607438266277313,
0.22350026667118073,
-0.5645121932029724,
0.19306635856628418,
-0.028308607637882233,
-0.655567467212677,
0.052566010504961014,
0.3039908707141876,
-0.17947104573249817,
-0.22680753469467163,
0.013272766023874283,
0.26676231622695923,
-0.29281726479530334,
-0.6437920928001404,
0.5033299326896667,
-0.2032404989004135,
-0.13522890210151672,
0.052197180688381195,
-0.10741674154996872,
-0.337459534406662,
0.17681434750556946,
0.11894163489341736,
0.5819330215454102,
0.6776599287986755,
-0.4760798513889313,
0.22200503945350647,
0.2293112725019455,
-0.7764220237731934,
-0.49101629853248596,
0.1718115508556366,
0.34670448303222656,
-0.2832135260105133,
0.6311320066452026,
0.16731514036655426,
-0.5847063660621643,
0.21002867817878723,
0.3045492172241211,
0.9443302154541016,
-0.23759593069553375,
0.5284769535064697,
0.34261354804039,
-0.23586030304431915,
0.2537432014942169,
0.349467396736145,
0.2069365382194519,
-0.5340712070465088,
-0.03613670915365219,
-0.5991297960281372,
-0.4732402563095093,
0.09119844436645508,
-0.4820120632648468,
0.2458914965391159,
-0.5479574799537659,
-0.6187180876731873,
0.2579807937145233,
0.14800691604614258,
-0.34599965810775757,
0.5907399654388428,
0.2231568694114685,
0.39288321137428284,
-1.1729586124420166,
0.6769237518310547,
0.9870389103889465,
-0.5147148966789246,
-0.3069722354412079,
0.059721507132053375,
0.11556041985750198,
-0.38621485233306885,
0.49276959896087646,
0.2541442811489105,
-0.16161401569843292,
-0.45775306224823,
-0.458644837141037,
0.039781879633665085,
0.44482627511024475,
-0.27133384346961975,
-0.26441001892089844,
0.1708487570285797,
0.11140907555818558,
1.025922179222107,
-0.46515893936157227,
-0.057169027626514435,
0.4259180724620819,
0.08328597247600555,
-0.16447581350803375,
-0.41042622923851013,
-0.35244548320770264,
-0.6768409609794617,
-0.31270599365234375,
0.10998471826314926,
-0.19360153377056122,
0.8722405433654785,
-0.5252070426940918,
0.10435337573289871,
-0.09777914732694626,
0.45430853962898254,
0.11508936434984207,
0.6959768533706665,
0.4105445146560669,
0.6245307922363281,
0.7851333022117615,
-0.05083867907524109,
0.9839687347412109,
-0.2302408665418625,
0.5070973634719849,
0.6903673410415649,
-0.36833617091178894,
0.8576987981796265,
0.3748534321784973,
-0.22126828134059906,
0.815168559551239,
0.48728200793266296,
-0.2640780806541443,
0.607953667640686,
0.35734114050865173,
-0.34207695722579956,
-0.14815019071102142,
0.010807190090417862,
-0.41679608821868896,
0.19825103878974915,
0.6458362340927124,
-0.601618766784668,
-0.07352796941995621,
0.4430762529373169,
-0.08915764093399048,
-0.055478621274232864,
-0.40327346324920654,
0.9098018407821655,
0.19044357538223267,
-0.5266702175140381,
0.3320581018924713,
0.10460243374109268,
0.39862680435180664,
-0.33769747614860535,
0.12998232245445251,
-0.283915638923645,
0.5897813439369202,
-0.5280404686927795,
-0.8558493256568909,
0.21986252069473267,
0.21342934668064117,
-0.37740540504455566,
0.07339261472225189,
0.752069354057312,
-0.21253207325935364,
-0.6218499541282654,
0.21107393503189087,
0.34542784094810486,
0.3734467029571533,
0.19458897411823273,
-0.9188075661659241,
0.028938833624124527,
0.057166192680597305,
-0.13683411478996277,
0.4956819713115692,
0.22829347848892212,
-0.04824407771229744,
0.4265390932559967,
0.5597614645957947,
0.4478475749492645,
-0.365017294883728,
0.23266369104385376,
0.756378710269928,
-0.7305134534835815,
-0.3869967758655548,
-0.8043404817581177,
0.42227494716644287,
-0.05625530704855919,
-0.40345045924186707,
0.6014850735664368,
0.6792576909065247,
0.33414873480796814,
-0.42785218358039856,
0.8819964528083801,
0.13157552480697632,
0.942645788192749,
-0.06456972658634186,
1.0498969554901123,
-0.5423563122749329,
0.3281174302101135,
-0.2851110100746155,
-0.4345363676548004,
-0.9455128312110901,
0.6314212083816528,
-0.32790008187294006,
0.026879340410232544,
0.43070244789123535,
0.7388664484024048,
0.3202246427536011,
0.07843528687953949,
0.0687498152256012,
0.48297542333602905,
0.34911882877349854,
0.5240211486816406,
0.9890225529670715,
-0.5027109384536743,
0.2737902104854584,
-0.27037471532821655,
-0.21824327111244202,
-0.38873597979545593,
-0.5581039786338806,
-0.8515956401824951,
-0.3797330856323242,
-0.2778656780719757,
-0.9855456948280334,
0.04221956059336662,
1.261308193206787,
0.528718888759613,
-1.264678716659546,
-0.1650669425725937,
0.1410548985004425,
0.23930875957012177,
0.011883397586643696,
-0.2523508667945862,
0.3068859577178955,
-0.36996954679489136,
-0.46274831891059875,
0.04029533267021179,
0.41269731521606445,
0.12728551030158997,
-0.2507382929325104,
-0.10466955602169037,
0.17978763580322266,
-0.10616401582956314,
0.6322061419487,
0.283845454454422,
-0.614504873752594,
0.07817110419273376,
0.055452391505241394,
-0.4500485956668854,
-0.016719510778784752,
0.9306865930557251,
-0.8316038250923157,
0.7732701897621155,
0.5966352224349976,
0.25388655066490173,
-0.05948607251048088,
0.09834913164377213,
0.5472889542579651,
-0.23319460451602936,
-0.3612426817417145,
0.4220200777053833,
0.4033820927143097,
0.3376706838607788,
-0.3461832106113434,
-0.029676321893930435,
0.31867092847824097,
-0.6972656846046448,
-0.7135559916496277,
-0.1067817360162735,
-0.9067754745483398,
-0.6262288093566895,
0.7107106447219849,
-0.08854998648166656,
-0.3741464912891388,
-0.24622733891010284,
-0.5301864743232727,
-0.05630626901984215,
-0.33932527899742126,
1.0980324745178223,
0.22307758033275604,
-0.2893890142440796,
0.3008984327316284,
-0.3600848615169525,
0.5466249585151672,
0.06402244418859482,
-0.9453694224357605,
-0.0695226714015007,
0.6174264550209045,
0.41572123765945435,
0.20289795100688934,
0.7028712630271912,
-0.3562154173851013,
0.2270658165216446,
-0.3814629316329956,
0.2589525878429413,
0.12975899875164032,
-0.18976497650146484,
-0.6051663160324097,
0.5219177603721619,
-0.022530721500515938,
-0.3453673720359802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06107v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06107v1
|
Exploring the Necessity of Visual Modality in Multimodal Machine Translation using Authentic Datasets
| 2024-04-09T08:19:10 | 2024-04-09T08:19:10 |
Zi Long, Zhenhao Tang, Xianghua Fu, Jian Chen, Shilong Hou, Jinze Lyu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent research in the field of multimodal machine translation (MMT) has
indicated that the visual modality is either dispensable or offers only
marginal advantages. However, most of these conclusions are drawn from the
analysis of experimental results based on a limited set of bilingual
sentence-image pairs, such as Multi30k. In these kinds of datasets, the content
of one bilingual parallel sentence pair must be well represented by a manually
annotated image, which is different from the real-world translation scenario.
In this work, we adhere to the universal multimodal machine translation
framework proposed by Tang et al. (2022). This approach allows us to delve into
the impact of the visual modality on translation efficacy by leveraging
real-world translation datasets. Through a comprehensive exploration via
probing tasks, we find that the visual modality proves advantageous for the
majority of authentic translation datasets. Notably, the translation
performance primarily hinges on the alignment and coherence between textual and
visual contents. Furthermore, our results suggest that visual information
serves a supplementary role in multimodal translation and can be substituted.
|
[
-0.3823474645614624,
-0.6380613446235657,
0.5098000168800354,
0.2511870563030243,
-0.49810078740119934,
-0.21369868516921997,
-0.28015995025634766,
-0.5139914751052856,
-0.061986345797777176,
0.27480030059814453,
-0.4399131238460541,
-0.28143230080604553,
-0.6996762752532959,
0.38694310188293457,
-0.2839941680431366,
0.7272378206253052,
-0.3233621418476105,
0.35439082980155945,
-0.41172048449516296,
-0.5571249723434448,
-0.6342883110046387,
-0.45762792229652405,
-0.028683073818683624,
-0.01255100965499878,
0.8361794948577881,
0.19631589949131012,
0.9412128329277039,
0.9090827107429504,
0.9278086423873901,
0.3793962299823761,
0.5532355308532715,
0.44567036628723145,
-0.22736454010009766,
0.2053099423646927,
0.1578519493341446,
-0.5853369832038879,
-0.38123971223831177,
0.0467337965965271,
0.7097541093826294,
0.6607477068901062,
0.3813784122467041,
0.059998273849487305,
-0.05120789632201195,
0.4632358253002167,
-0.3900424838066101,
0.4207000732421875,
-0.4138193428516388,
0.18088717758655548,
-0.39299437403678894,
-0.36101385951042175,
-0.4647333323955536,
0.11525578796863556,
-0.03978964313864708,
-0.9172974228858948,
-0.004869125317782164,
0.1907503604888916,
0.7694922089576721,
0.38590073585510254,
-1.2192882299423218,
-0.0576980859041214,
-0.6501591801643372,
0.6352096199989319,
-0.27697205543518066,
0.7706302404403687,
0.2300216406583786,
0.5054104328155518,
-0.0001179412065539509,
-0.5650002956390381,
-0.7726628184318542,
-0.17497189342975616,
-0.24157094955444336,
0.4868333339691162,
-0.08106943964958191,
0.04689747840166092,
0.2492585927248001,
0.4075389802455902,
-0.6403229832649231,
0.030725274235010147,
-0.2916262447834015,
-0.3208667039871216,
0.2125442922115326,
0.27431371808052063,
0.7381635904312134,
-0.4443840980529785,
-0.8774610161781311,
-0.4261768162250519,
-0.369041383266449,
0.2867470383644104,
0.0657368153333664,
-0.02827976457774639,
-0.27207520604133606,
0.9222803115844727,
-0.21556146442890167,
0.649918258190155,
-0.49721723794937134,
-0.2780660092830658,
0.35634732246398926,
-0.8919157385826111,
-0.274749755859375,
-0.3750421106815338,
0.9367483258247375,
0.6740696430206299,
0.19897210597991943,
-0.17464251816272736,
-0.38802844285964966,
0.0493197962641716,
0.30863478779792786,
-0.8158949613571167,
0.031800802797079086,
-0.12483909726142883,
-0.5869239568710327,
-0.1944105625152588,
0.314218670129776,
-0.5720505714416504,
0.010739379562437534,
-0.5887407660484314,
0.5180037617683411,
-0.5743056535720825,
-0.1725907027721405,
-0.1966981291770935,
-0.1896810382604599,
0.06142047420144081,
0.5944991707801819,
-0.6026442050933838,
-0.1742086261510849,
0.3905438780784607,
0.7230919599533081,
-0.21486429870128632,
-0.5320457220077515,
-0.4342907965183258,
0.26577550172805786,
-0.5140930414199829,
0.5225629806518555,
-0.47953614592552185,
-0.029231833294034004,
-0.17653274536132812,
0.2436528205871582,
-0.34124940633773804,
-0.3575795590877533,
0.5572537183761597,
-0.444286584854126,
0.27571532130241394,
-0.651344358921051,
-0.12534664571285248,
-0.5005047917366028,
0.35270917415618896,
-0.89531409740448,
0.6038612723350525,
-0.10470902174711227,
-0.3835335671901703,
0.7397377490997314,
-0.502506673336029,
-0.34073612093925476,
-0.05795474722981453,
-0.35738521814346313,
-0.2008153647184372,
0.409396767616272,
0.300586462020874,
0.4966084659099579,
0.014717481099069118,
0.2137187421321869,
-0.3035118877887726,
-0.1964424103498459,
0.8921841382980347,
-0.9640514850616455,
0.5119789838790894,
0.41426971554756165,
-0.30507245659828186,
-0.07573787868022919,
-0.45807719230651855,
-0.26644566655158997,
-0.016594523563981056,
-0.2956456243991852,
-0.3854292035102844,
-0.3694339096546173,
0.43293821811676025,
0.4014973044395447,
0.012731300666928291,
-0.4253386855125427,
0.21813856065273285,
0.19694380462169647,
0.08828562498092651,
0.7218201756477356,
-0.19501745700836182,
0.43945908546447754,
-0.2849595844745636,
0.649813175201416,
0.2898586392402649,
0.1797264665365219,
-0.6814761757850647,
-0.6539318561553955,
-0.5946802496910095,
-0.8601402044296265,
0.3456122577190399,
0.5068157911300659,
-1.1513439416885376,
-0.13990719616413116,
-0.5281577706336975,
-0.07581251859664917,
-0.7343917489051819,
0.1860155463218689,
0.5097469687461853,
0.6074555516242981,
0.4119285047054291,
-0.4305901527404785,
-0.29166969656944275,
-1.174055576324463,
-0.12294839322566986,
0.12419597059488297,
0.18239858746528625,
0.3560948967933655,
0.5038655400276184,
-0.3519991338253021,
0.46828728914260864,
-0.0888705626130104,
-0.46623533964157104,
0.01129823923110962,
0.26292821764945984,
0.008758041076362133,
0.5056238174438477,
0.6425973773002625,
-1.2154107093811035,
-0.35862165689468384,
0.26375827193260193,
-1.2503973245620728,
-0.007932467386126518,
-0.6463330984115601,
-0.18712307512760162,
0.028264213353395462,
0.3693695664405823,
-0.44636109471321106,
0.42256978154182434,
0.7114373445510864,
-0.21004748344421387,
0.1565418392419815,
-0.39365440607070923,
0.9761265516281128,
-0.950900673866272,
0.2255193293094635,
0.0030724480748176575,
-0.5402960181236267,
-0.449063241481781,
0.276803195476532,
0.3003996014595032,
-0.10700909048318863,
-0.36759230494499207,
0.27000442147254944,
-0.6075016260147095,
0.009610963985323906,
0.011673280037939548,
0.0774325504899025,
0.14181149005889893,
0.35768362879753113,
-0.2704915702342987,
0.8849454522132874,
0.31437191367149353,
-0.14585481584072113,
0.4462328255176544,
0.20869261026382446,
-0.20254196226596832,
0.9517042636871338,
-0.44310420751571655,
-0.22844432294368744,
-0.2030515968799591,
0.23333488404750824,
-1.0994880199432373,
-0.5437480211257935,
0.40195831656455994,
-0.40885406732559204,
0.4059814512729645,
0.04065100848674774,
-0.6875640749931335,
0.02740856260061264,
-0.10644731670618057,
0.6590995788574219,
0.2494661808013916,
-0.34437841176986694,
0.4175788164138794,
-0.031625788658857346,
0.07491305470466614,
-0.41627559065818787,
-0.958645224571228,
0.5526692867279053,
-0.1629849672317505,
-0.8311499953269958,
0.1958666294813156,
-0.004173139110207558,
-0.08515813946723938,
-0.13471178710460663,
-0.06073262542486191,
0.03611130639910698,
0.09505454450845718,
0.3260183334350586,
0.39196670055389404,
-0.29464033246040344,
0.16337451338768005,
0.0516083799302578,
-0.31968793272972107,
-0.14170527458190918,
-0.03282551467418671,
0.00017472176114097238,
-0.20632532238960266,
-0.6515306830406189,
-0.7004517316818237,
0.5252570509910583,
0.891015350818634,
-0.4505316913127899,
0.5941877961158752,
1.0099395513534546,
-0.23129300773143768,
0.3945617973804474,
-0.44950658082962036,
0.000967223197221756,
-0.38170790672302246,
0.42730462551116943,
-0.7261002659797668,
-0.4431558847427368,
0.23119035363197327,
0.08081839978694916,
-0.36443960666656494,
0.25924503803253174,
0.4344252645969391,
-0.3309682309627533,
1.1892582178115845,
0.48118487000465393,
0.2835862636566162,
0.5397387742996216,
-0.18245670199394226,
-0.03407570347189903,
-0.8128134608268738,
-0.45225682854652405,
0.049295153468847275,
-0.5696211457252502,
-0.5778953433036804,
-0.6552627086639404,
0.6941372156143188,
0.04944267123937607,
0.3905831575393677,
0.17792174220085144,
-0.19712843000888824,
0.134563148021698,
0.5529000759124756,
0.4094180762767792,
0.5662768483161926,
0.15948083996772766,
-0.30251383781433105,
-0.6243997812271118,
-0.5472776889801025,
-0.5774779319763184,
1.1139469146728516,
0.1164688989520073,
0.5087367296218872,
0.23392218351364136,
0.2570788562297821,
0.19383911788463593,
0.18334974348545074,
-0.5869828462600708,
0.4882385730743408,
-0.11231038719415665,
-0.44644978642463684,
-0.01727180927991867,
-0.4940834641456604,
-0.9599764943122864,
0.5885176062583923,
-0.4290188252925873,
-0.05195848271250725,
0.24928058683872223,
0.2564520537853241,
0.2651916444301605,
0.03777783364057541,
-0.8758558630943298,
1.3437565565109253,
-0.6526667475700378,
-0.31339356303215027,
-0.0823042094707489,
-0.8404247164726257,
0.2820839583873749,
-0.06927941739559174,
0.3911491632461548,
0.2175453007221222,
-0.4114651083946228,
0.18290193378925323,
-0.05684417858719826,
0.6887613534927368,
0.06248750910162926,
0.10375948250293732,
-0.23821112513542175,
0.19909071922302246,
0.25692299008369446,
0.04543635621666908,
0.45559099316596985,
0.17794586718082428,
-0.03686710074543953,
-0.5864973664283752,
-0.6743806600570679,
0.5381269454956055,
-0.4569858908653259,
-0.32396990060806274,
-0.31783971190452576,
-0.86904376745224,
0.05666571110486984,
0.44271448254585266,
0.23420293629169464,
0.6315845251083374,
-0.1294247806072235,
0.5984920859336853,
0.5334100723266602,
0.04880331829190254,
0.38579919934272766,
0.12485936284065247,
-0.23703639209270477,
-0.6147184371948242,
1.1049460172653198,
0.30581408739089966,
0.5097867250442505,
0.5396903157234192,
-0.03580081835389137,
-0.1089572012424469,
-0.37657734751701355,
-1.0372140407562256,
0.020252592861652374,
-0.6770510673522949,
-0.06966058164834976,
-0.663571834564209,
0.5158227682113647,
-0.21236874163150787,
-0.1528366506099701,
-0.15419970452785492,
-0.3795901834964752,
-0.12328829616308212,
0.12650589644908905,
0.09737899154424667,
0.3088407516479492,
-0.11971773952245712,
0.01955576427280903,
-0.8106730580329895,
0.6800206899642944,
0.32927143573760986,
0.05757720768451691,
-0.4029662013053894,
-0.22109311819076538,
-0.25391897559165955,
0.42843958735466003,
-0.1967102736234665,
-0.8721603751182556,
0.27697595953941345,
0.2775936722755432,
0.7355910539627075,
0.45385169982910156,
-0.23131608963012695,
0.9090275764465332,
-0.3338278830051422,
0.576167106628418,
0.2823892831802368,
-0.5624004006385803,
0.30681830644607544,
-0.515209436416626,
0.3934217095375061,
0.4492150545120239,
0.4827932119369507,
-0.7138714790344238,
-0.3386108875274658,
-0.18601812422275543,
-0.5695663094520569,
0.30795949697494507,
0.33352571725845337,
0.06592965871095657,
0.2442592978477478,
-0.19282320141792297,
0.34523218870162964,
0.47495368123054504,
-0.7385671138763428,
-0.012485566549003124,
-0.4963178336620331,
-0.4038901925086975,
-0.154213547706604,
0.10058692842721939,
-0.3215736746788025,
-0.1559107005596161,
0.02207188494503498,
-0.30102550983428955,
0.2619323432445526,
0.22439244389533997,
-0.6095288395881653,
0.03589348495006561,
0.11906569451093674,
0.6407673954963684,
0.41334813833236694,
-0.009783011861145496,
0.40341296792030334,
-0.10912230610847473,
-0.42162367701530457,
0.007346550468355417,
0.09097195416688919,
-0.30000045895576477,
-0.004721744917333126,
0.6651210784912109,
0.715375542640686,
0.19533739984035492,
-0.617640495300293,
0.798712432384491,
0.1438516080379486,
0.04239676892757416,
0.16496995091438293,
-0.28787291049957275,
-0.13033947348594666,
0.33786046504974365,
0.25564050674438477,
0.6546006798744202,
0.2179996222257614,
-0.7115405201911926,
0.07552371174097061,
0.4528332054615021,
-0.6016288995742798,
-0.5105404257774353,
0.745292067527771,
0.1333674043416977,
0.07483171671628952,
0.5356411933898926,
0.07306773960590363,
-0.39507290720939636,
0.3446090817451477,
0.2979784905910492,
0.5917003154754639,
0.0877661183476448,
0.20017008483409882,
-0.013838939368724823,
0.6319393515586853,
0.04727860912680626,
0.06854196637868881,
-0.31052345037460327,
-0.420126348733902,
-0.34806686639785767,
-0.14337287843227386,
-0.17397654056549072,
-0.3934118449687958,
-0.5971251726150513,
0.12702196836471558,
0.2674996554851532,
-0.00836590863764286,
-0.2647281885147095,
-0.6270552277565002,
-0.880243182182312,
0.3147200047969818,
0.1862427145242691,
0.37491509318351746,
-1.0021917819976807,
0.7329566478729248,
0.7737345695495605,
-0.847051739692688,
-0.2434333711862564,
-0.2994522154331207,
0.13178382813930511,
-0.7884144186973572,
0.7207690477371216,
0.20385727286338806,
0.037183988839387894,
-0.20164357125759125,
-0.4126099646091461,
-0.5018673539161682,
1.2539840936660767,
0.6059148907661438,
-0.21784359216690063,
0.24035575985908508,
0.4791642427444458,
0.557729184627533,
-0.4466860592365265,
0.03667807579040527,
-0.2068919688463211,
0.7746240496635437,
-0.04767833277583122,
-0.871214747428894,
0.17974211275577545,
-0.4312435984611511,
0.18450066447257996,
0.05911320820450783,
-0.6009348034858704,
0.6022399067878723,
-0.16218116879463196,
-0.1700989454984665,
-0.12583975493907928,
0.515052080154419,
-0.18656231462955475,
0.4574977457523346,
0.32971784472465515,
0.462132066488266,
0.37862664461135864,
-0.2223956137895584,
1.169601559638977,
0.05332135781645775,
-0.029244786128401756,
0.8330519199371338,
0.27336111664772034,
0.6785858273506165,
1.0016525983810425,
0.20178033411502838,
0.08662812411785126,
0.48695483803749084,
-0.22240066528320312,
0.5470965504646301,
-0.35793337225914,
-0.025074763223528862,
-0.6004056930541992,
-0.2112458348274231,
-0.5956582427024841,
0.6111852526664734,
-0.07241157442331314,
-0.5439603924751282,
-0.048524197190999985,
0.49087074398994446,
0.052723489701747894,
0.2489791065454483,
0.198823481798172,
0.5472854971885681,
0.0030095570255070925,
-0.41772156953811646,
0.456057071685791,
-0.19906042516231537,
0.4140538275241852,
-0.42634862661361694,
-0.25711894035339355,
-0.2347404509782791,
0.02796316333115101,
-0.06422298401594162,
-0.5922461748123169,
0.07384354621171951,
-0.3284721076488495,
-0.20507967472076416,
-0.8364629745483398,
0.36325162649154663,
-0.5262945890426636,
-0.56039959192276,
-0.04702872782945633,
0.740264356136322,
0.05291123688220978,
-0.18693634867668152,
-0.4358496367931366,
0.2517384886741638,
-0.08671129494905472,
-0.22620268166065216,
0.38941922783851624,
0.9884704351425171,
-0.07754457741975784,
0.5252509117126465,
0.794653594493866,
0.018673991784453392,
0.19874925911426544,
-0.2723458707332611,
0.8503512144088745,
-0.5287936925888062,
-0.13515622913837433,
-0.7104474306106567,
0.860239565372467,
-0.09831157326698303,
-0.6209360957145691,
1.1084983348846436,
0.798219621181488,
0.9257136583328247,
-0.2534569799900055,
0.536496102809906,
0.07797261327505112,
-0.2589464783668518,
-0.6499172449111938,
0.6851646304130554,
-0.9390769004821777,
0.03547820821404457,
-0.22701187431812286,
-0.6700928211212158,
-0.4434564709663391,
0.4101582467556,
-0.005756204482167959,
-0.17688123881816864,
0.9074986577033997,
0.8246886730194092,
-0.39103156328201294,
-0.14854910969734192,
0.6397914290428162,
0.06991929560899734,
0.2884562909603119,
0.20128606259822845,
0.764366626739502,
-0.7248778939247131,
0.8691470623016357,
-0.3286626935005188,
-0.4370402693748474,
-0.25317808985710144,
-0.8726683855056763,
-0.7603918313980103,
-0.7669769525527954,
-0.14604485034942627,
-0.06458012014627457,
-0.1472397744655609,
0.713320255279541,
0.567366898059845,
-0.3935735523700714,
-0.15817545354366302,
0.2373664826154709,
-0.14248234033584595,
-0.4632841646671295,
-0.07559052854776382,
-0.07662694901227951,
-0.45160582661628723,
-0.7901243567466736,
0.3996160924434662,
0.6190429329872131,
0.23227180540561676,
-0.20743444561958313,
0.0007804684573784471,
-0.14733204245567322,
-0.30699020624160767,
0.6939655542373657,
-0.14754992723464966,
-0.7460366487503052,
-0.2063707411289215,
0.43889519572257996,
-0.47442999482154846,
0.1680058091878891,
0.9847013354301453,
-0.5648173689842224,
1.1259671449661255,
0.5704966187477112,
0.6205870509147644,
0.5536144375801086,
-0.19456154108047485,
0.8097879886627197,
-0.4819779098033905,
0.25556743144989014,
-0.10629591345787048,
0.4262995719909668,
0.4277537167072296,
0.030102849006652832,
0.5471294522285461,
0.7573460936546326,
-0.3344176411628723,
-0.8804678916931152,
0.23469991981983185,
-1.4582481384277344,
0.007790473289787769,
0.9468091726303101,
-0.1513817310333252,
-0.3436589241027832,
0.026859315112233162,
-0.6155520677566528,
0.22758401930332184,
-0.23822224140167236,
0.5783709287643433,
0.656173825263977,
0.1708858162164688,
-0.3149684965610504,
-0.9137340784072876,
0.06594223529100418,
0.2688041031360626,
-0.6883485317230225,
-0.28721898794174194,
0.7089535593986511,
-0.1714904010295868,
0.028288837522268295,
0.2857198715209961,
-0.2067590206861496,
0.36372894048690796,
0.187825009226799,
-0.050924744457006454,
-0.44204628467559814,
-0.2919885814189911,
-0.17675678431987762,
0.13102839887142181,
-0.29141804575920105,
-0.4776243269443512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06101v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06101v1
|
Making Old Kurdish Publications Processable by Augmenting Available Optical Character Recognition Engines
| 2024-04-09T08:08:03 | 2024-04-09T08:08:03 |
Blnd Yaseen, Hossein Hassani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Kurdish libraries have many historical publications that were printed back in
the early days when printing devices were brought to Kurdistan. Having a good
Optical Character Recognition (OCR) to help process these publications and
contribute to the Kurdish languages resources which is crucial as Kurdish is
considered a low-resource language. Current OCR systems are unable to extract
text from historical documents as they have many issues, including being
damaged, very fragile, having many marks left on them, and often written in
non-standard fonts and more. This is a massive obstacle in processing these
documents as currently processing them requires manual typing which is very
time-consuming. In this study, we adopt an open-source OCR framework by Google,
Tesseract version 5.0, that has been used to extract text for various
languages. Currently, there is no public dataset, and we developed our own by
collecting historical documents from Zheen Center for Documentation and
Research, which were printed before 1950 and resulted in a dataset of 1233
images of lines with transcription of each. Then we used the Arabic model as
our base model and trained the model using the dataset. We used different
methods to evaluate our model, Tesseracts built-in evaluator lstmeval indicated
a Character Error Rate (CER) of 0.755%. Additionally, Ocreval demonstrated an
average character accuracy of 84.02%. Finally, we developed a web application
to provide an easy- to-use interface for end-users, allowing them to interact
with the model by inputting an image of a page and extracting the text. Having
an extensive dataset is crucial to develop OCR systems with reasonable
accuracy, as currently, no public datasets are available for historical Kurdish
documents; this posed a significant challenge in our work. Additionally, the
unaligned spaces between characters and words proved another challenge with our
work.
|
[
-0.4438563883304596,
-0.2987942397594452,
0.5581850409507751,
-0.4903261065483093,
-0.5365149974822998,
-0.054411619901657104,
-0.04108427092432976,
-0.7522402405738831,
-0.08290542662143707,
0.8264026641845703,
-0.08002443611621857,
-0.571804404258728,
-0.4672301411628723,
0.5803012847900391,
-0.06318816542625427,
0.898911714553833,
-0.42913705110549927,
-0.020733127370476723,
0.31510981917381287,
-0.5924274325370789,
0.09233508259057999,
-0.3319898247718811,
-0.46291884779930115,
0.21275272965431213,
0.2503715455532074,
0.4100118577480316,
0.743406355381012,
0.6518413424491882,
0.5847482085227966,
0.31514352560043335,
-0.4956603944301605,
0.47062814235687256,
-0.44441214203834534,
0.20360440015792847,
0.03260144218802452,
-0.21034865081310272,
-0.3069300353527069,
-0.11729344725608826,
0.9995419979095459,
0.3200850188732147,
-0.06937506049871445,
-0.11806143075227737,
0.14088387787342072,
1.019141674041748,
-0.7185619473457336,
-0.028446543961763382,
-0.020251000300049782,
0.2501649856567383,
-0.3285396695137024,
-0.10465247184038162,
-0.20268788933753967,
-0.7177790999412537,
-0.18188060820102692,
-0.7033770084381104,
0.22661830484867096,
-0.1515558362007141,
0.689162015914917,
-0.05894051864743233,
-0.28172504901885986,
-0.7362697124481201,
-0.9846670031547546,
0.6772971153259277,
-0.7182837724685669,
0.7177796959877014,
0.6682981848716736,
0.4708286225795746,
-0.3587709665298462,
-0.767167329788208,
-0.6613231897354126,
-0.36033913493156433,
-0.08729475736618042,
0.0469437800347805,
-0.11286124587059021,
-0.3707596957683563,
0.3800506591796875,
0.6972770094871521,
-0.4915584921836853,
-0.0014973279321566224,
-0.7058298587799072,
-0.04443806782364845,
0.3400641679763794,
0.10295926779508591,
0.33973678946495056,
-0.030171794816851616,
-0.15719081461429596,
-0.27942055463790894,
-0.6346657276153564,
0.06074421480298042,
0.7598095536231995,
0.12746931612491608,
0.24981755018234253,
1.0519487857818604,
-0.5061985850334167,
0.7675326466560364,
0.3159283399581909,
-0.20904873311519623,
0.24019573628902435,
-0.22305500507354736,
-0.17264942824840546,
0.4545915126800537,
0.644238293170929,
-0.0524960421025753,
-0.04655558615922928,
-0.23362964391708374,
-0.11817588657140732,
-0.24161912500858307,
0.2945162057876587,
-0.6978768706321716,
-0.011102044954895973,
-0.10524818301200867,
-0.7610813975334167,
0.04063780605792999,
0.14015771448612213,
-1.087549090385437,
-0.9580331444740295,
-0.06095188483595848,
0.15103885531425476,
-0.7266347408294678,
-0.2232212871313095,
0.1892692893743515,
-0.17658275365829468,
-0.08720343559980392,
0.7453526258468628,
-0.6117585897445679,
0.16345825791358948,
0.270891010761261,
1.091750144958496,
0.15832068026065826,
-0.04725513607263565,
-0.5929459929466248,
0.23204734921455383,
-0.3577613830566406,
0.6123761534690857,
-0.5317370891571045,
-0.6302157044410706,
-0.1542857140302658,
0.14354653656482697,
0.30273517966270447,
-0.39330151677131653,
1.1889094114303589,
-0.5365591645240784,
0.5412065386772156,
-0.004245576914399862,
-0.35733330249786377,
-0.25028398633003235,
0.0760396420955658,
-1.2669401168823242,
1.0471488237380981,
0.35793906450271606,
-0.9393179416656494,
0.29261326789855957,
-0.36172276735305786,
-0.2413840889930725,
0.30169257521629333,
-0.17707321047782898,
-0.743782639503479,
0.23012994229793549,
0.651630699634552,
0.2732354998588562,
-0.308623343706131,
-0.6329793334007263,
-0.11116316169500351,
-0.4800441861152649,
-0.07703330367803574,
-0.2737915515899658,
0.9538803100585938,
0.5730745792388916,
-0.4579788148403168,
-0.5432453155517578,
-1.08858323097229,
-0.14395347237586975,
-0.11301812529563904,
-0.8880331516265869,
-0.37721386551856995,
0.028806274756789207,
0.15794792771339417,
-0.16117815673351288,
0.39968931674957275,
-0.8239685297012329,
0.5282685160636902,
-0.320113867521286,
0.08747247606515884,
0.43379005789756775,
-0.3480978012084961,
0.5550433993339539,
-0.30370333790779114,
0.5197303295135498,
-0.13545988500118256,
-0.1560969352722168,
-0.022761812433600426,
-0.4883045256137848,
-0.5840157270431519,
-0.49680423736572266,
0.31214234232902527,
0.3926313817501068,
-0.9806767106056213,
0.3270188868045807,
-0.2953399121761322,
-0.8694751262664795,
-0.42734092473983765,
0.10477329045534134,
0.019521092996001244,
0.5623154640197754,
0.1164177730679512,
-0.614249050617218,
-0.5504894256591797,
-0.35258594155311584,
-0.03022405318915844,
-0.4084821939468384,
-0.11086340993642807,
0.3802298307418823,
0.0540388785302639,
0.02198123000562191,
0.7598507404327393,
-0.2450064867734909,
-0.7909161448478699,
-0.11340437084436417,
0.5009313821792603,
0.45987439155578613,
0.4386310577392578,
0.3653355836868286,
-0.8837206363677979,
-0.5419343709945679,
0.6463090777397156,
-0.6428223252296448,
0.022923121228814125,
0.24888138473033905,
0.12698058784008026,
0.8853321075439453,
0.5101478099822998,
-0.4226841628551483,
0.7224989533424377,
0.329641729593277,
-0.38642144203186035,
0.6698450446128845,
-0.5223880410194397,
0.6642851233482361,
-0.8219020366668701,
0.4186769425868988,
-0.20621837675571442,
-0.11045783758163452,
-0.3213992416858673,
0.09675455093383789,
0.07025746256113052,
-0.43453606963157654,
-0.4239356517791748,
0.4371194541454315,
-0.7928552031517029,
0.11753134429454803,
-0.09644775092601776,
-0.3884325921535492,
-0.1297203153371811,
0.1243782714009285,
0.5375697612762451,
0.9102304577827454,
0.015279204584658146,
-0.27162009477615356,
0.19411353766918182,
0.17924030125141144,
-1.0455571413040161,
0.6945936679840088,
-0.31218546628952026,
0.33848464488983154,
-0.2668895721435547,
0.002190996427088976,
-0.7401777505874634,
-0.057609111070632935,
0.7051814198493958,
-0.38290196657180786,
0.2387818545103073,
-0.34669172763824463,
-0.8003861904144287,
-0.15243001282215118,
-0.00652769161388278,
0.2955191433429718,
0.5958961248397827,
-0.42482316493988037,
1.071455717086792,
0.2026740312576294,
-0.46043846011161804,
-0.4704126715660095,
-0.35645705461502075,
0.12307678908109665,
-0.19875627756118774,
-0.4995662569999695,
0.007459902670234442,
0.20950433611869812,
0.2104615420103073,
0.24837726354599,
0.16150596737861633,
-0.3829019069671631,
-0.17306450009346008,
0.14695243537425995,
0.19093860685825348,
-0.548866868019104,
0.036192696541547775,
-0.18999604880809784,
-0.04414387792348862,
-0.6794188022613525,
-0.3057343363761902,
0.4017707109451294,
-0.011589322239160538,
-0.40632912516593933,
-0.4745520055294037,
0.46725714206695557,
1.041509747505188,
-0.4390494227409363,
0.9056564569473267,
0.7948487997055054,
-0.4537026286125183,
0.3415442407131195,
-0.7913004159927368,
0.3698157072067261,
-0.45887115597724915,
0.3737865686416626,
-0.1771375983953476,
-0.8878757953643799,
0.21846771240234375,
-0.10044418275356293,
-0.06830933690071106,
0.5589995384216309,
0.5337538123130798,
-0.12132978439331055,
0.9476571679115295,
0.504889726638794,
-0.23302194476127625,
0.4597613215446472,
0.2591557204723358,
0.2784403860569,
-0.8190822005271912,
-0.3129178583621979,
-0.9533296227455139,
-0.11077070236206055,
-0.5196975469589233,
-0.23696832358837128,
0.48135673999786377,
0.28195780515670776,
-0.016001500189304352,
0.2665118873119354,
-0.5812954902648926,
0.5140036940574646,
0.6807717680931091,
0.23142294585704803,
0.4147186279296875,
0.5180755853652954,
-0.0938359946012497,
0.04411618411540985,
-0.3173542618751526,
-0.88701331615448,
1.0098551511764526,
0.19694308936595917,
1.015702247619629,
0.2674274742603302,
0.654280424118042,
0.5101879239082336,
-0.24579422175884247,
-0.4300663471221924,
0.27506840229034424,
-0.3370213210582733,
-0.3767743706703186,
-0.47373390197753906,
-0.504849910736084,
-0.9964759945869446,
-0.19668082892894745,
-0.2814246714115143,
-0.7658151984214783,
0.6412255764007568,
-0.04202014580368996,
-0.5280807018280029,
0.5513015985488892,
-0.5984014272689819,
0.5066118836402893,
-0.13184718787670135,
-0.34467434883117676,
-0.03686961159110069,
-0.36843612790107727,
-0.2742490768432617,
0.04458863288164139,
0.07198074460029602,
0.24076522886753082,
0.14519904553890228,
0.7270967364311218,
-0.46750983595848083,
0.6065638065338135,
-0.02020334079861641,
-0.17719030380249023,
0.34240439534187317,
0.06954996287822723,
0.5888013243675232,
-0.42577216029167175,
-0.5039642453193665,
0.22843331098556519,
0.21518313884735107,
-0.19670991599559784,
-0.501025915145874,
0.39472857117652893,
-1.0046417713165283,
-0.17813313007354736,
-0.7386814951896667,
-0.30575501918792725,
0.31026458740234375,
0.42274215817451477,
0.21598991751670837,
0.4558309316635132,
-0.4921956956386566,
0.06813059747219086,
0.5311222076416016,
-0.17826801538467407,
0.16854366660118103,
0.5934197902679443,
-0.055906880646944046,
-0.7046674489974976,
0.9256777763366699,
0.21009832620620728,
-0.12339887022972107,
0.272128701210022,
0.057215675711631775,
-0.2648340165615082,
-0.6625897288322449,
-0.8699365258216858,
0.004896638449281454,
-0.7599789500236511,
0.06758416444063187,
-0.4318798780441284,
-0.18317581713199615,
-0.6871150135993958,
-0.06091199815273285,
-0.04578905925154686,
-0.6408492922782898,
-0.781592845916748,
0.45861947536468506,
0.21551933884620667,
1.090430498123169,
-0.1088528260588646,
0.24534115195274353,
-1.1133427619934082,
0.3488326668739319,
0.14648844301700592,
0.331583172082901,
0.02966178022325039,
-0.2601655125617981,
-0.4703138768672943,
-0.0033570199739187956,
-0.3292871117591858,
-0.8679182529449463,
0.5296480655670166,
0.2260170578956604,
0.3366076648235321,
0.6023699641227722,
0.09542720764875412,
0.45747509598731995,
-0.760115385055542,
0.6124255657196045,
0.07774949818849564,
-0.6417186856269836,
0.30950167775154114,
-0.15847107768058777,
0.42832618951797485,
0.5034998655319214,
0.5566839575767517,
-0.7325945496559143,
-0.24046367406845093,
-0.20373447239398956,
-0.5647151470184326,
0.9751889109611511,
0.4275907874107361,
-0.3634924590587616,
0.30275702476501465,
0.3203812539577484,
0.3561273217201233,
-0.019714737311005592,
-0.3405275344848633,
0.20600543916225433,
-0.2484181970357895,
-0.3677700161933899,
-0.2848677635192871,
-0.4871080815792084,
0.23521503806114197,
0.15237005054950714,
0.7517974376678467,
0.2684997320175171,
0.29658403992652893,
0.4602435827255249,
-0.3063746988773346,
-0.32540398836135864,
0.34940025210380554,
0.5800174474716187,
0.382293701171875,
-0.4103345572948456,
0.26757994294166565,
-0.23507055640220642,
-0.9828121662139893,
0.21612510085105896,
0.6204086542129517,
-0.25167784094810486,
0.08167192339897156,
0.26482483744621277,
0.7133262157440186,
-0.441081702709198,
-0.5771508812904358,
0.0650051087141037,
-0.2513371706008911,
0.17000141739845276,
-0.3337681293487549,
-0.18188831210136414,
-0.2761732339859009,
0.46199551224708557,
0.688416600227356,
-0.02005366049706936,
0.1586996465921402,
-0.4295130670070648,
-0.0476967990398407,
0.25049346685409546,
-0.4900764226913452,
0.12041541188955307,
0.2757495045661926,
0.0165686197578907,
-0.4330681562423706,
0.8051490187644958,
-0.22544969618320465,
-0.6233509182929993,
0.3607749938964844,
0.24203422665596008,
0.4496893286705017,
-0.41778358817100525,
0.32443976402282715,
0.466910719871521,
0.43915167450904846,
-0.09195725619792938,
0.14170579612255096,
-0.31628841161727905,
-0.3666413128376007,
-0.046002019196748734,
-0.7353370189666748,
-0.35359638929367065,
-0.08192981034517288,
-0.5284651517868042,
0.4870615303516388,
-0.40453919768333435,
-0.13703222572803497,
-0.4256822168827057,
0.24034759402275085,
-0.5531065464019775,
0.24508266150951385,
0.20076894760131836,
0.7440828084945679,
-0.6844373345375061,
0.5248799324035645,
0.7398847341537476,
-0.4615297019481659,
-0.17409077286720276,
-0.42218947410583496,
-0.16791990399360657,
-0.7783905267715454,
0.7719950079917908,
0.0013188219163566828,
-0.15491412580013275,
0.07484140992164612,
-0.1869691014289856,
-0.8758553862571716,
0.7292170524597168,
0.24333533644676208,
-0.5610414147377014,
-0.13441675901412964,
0.5009812116622925,
0.47723588347435,
0.1616930067539215,
0.3123995065689087,
0.20959049463272095,
0.3564828932285309,
0.1649576723575592,
-0.8102182149887085,
0.06446400284767151,
-0.40389153361320496,
-0.2398507446050644,
0.5100048184394836,
0.0640505999326706,
0.6993895173072815,
0.17433515191078186,
-0.5645365715026855,
0.8636466860771179,
0.7486250400543213,
-0.047118235379457474,
0.12240978330373764,
0.486682653427124,
1.032413363456726,
0.7843156456947327,
0.15182022750377655,
1.002781629562378,
0.12011556327342987,
0.11026015877723694,
1.050716757774353,
-0.1798996925354004,
0.8359370231628418,
0.5134639739990234,
-0.1185709685087204,
0.5007457137107849,
0.45157554745674133,
-0.20038405060768127,
0.7548013925552368,
-0.1324842870235443,
-0.5772619843482971,
-0.07405416667461395,
-0.22951942682266235,
-0.6300477385520935,
0.25051090121269226,
0.205134779214859,
-0.696292519569397,
-0.46815940737724304,
-0.061836544424295425,
-0.0935346707701683,
-0.22248272597789764,
-0.27280694246292114,
0.8043695688247681,
-0.29750704765319824,
-0.30542296171188354,
0.40387383103370667,
0.047821056097745895,
0.21984241902828217,
-0.6780520677566528,
-0.3902972340583801,
0.03819712623953819,
0.3849804699420929,
-0.05319221317768097,
-0.6231405138969421,
0.06408048421144485,
0.020382709801197052,
-0.1592470407485962,
0.11476723849773407,
0.7227586507797241,
-0.4269039034843445,
-1.0961074829101562,
-0.36246708035469055,
0.2805176079273224,
0.4091944396495819,
0.031997088342905045,
-0.0795796737074852,
0.26877081394195557,
-0.06463295221328735,
0.15998941659927368,
0.18461158871650696,
0.6172999739646912,
0.10390984266996384,
0.03240852430462837,
0.5578526258468628,
0.5986571311950684,
0.10309445112943649,
-0.5190836191177368,
0.7562748193740845,
-0.23687809705734253,
-0.531963050365448,
-0.6011362671852112,
0.3159119784832001,
0.04023978114128113,
-0.3251194357872009,
0.739098310470581,
0.5997942686080933,
0.814096212387085,
-0.077908456325531,
0.7293611764907837,
-0.09726860374212265,
0.7199479937553406,
-0.7119293808937073,
1.3283178806304932,
-0.63531494140625,
-0.18161934614181519,
-0.4389020502567291,
-0.9758526086807251,
-0.2731601893901825,
0.8547875881195068,
-0.1897156834602356,
-0.09779821336269379,
0.5277044773101807,
0.6708494424819946,
-0.16576285660266876,
0.2349175065755844,
0.137923926115036,
0.06786445528268814,
0.14176347851753235,
0.35154959559440613,
0.845102071762085,
-0.18107113242149353,
0.5548315048217773,
-0.3983023762702942,
-0.32547757029533386,
-0.230960413813591,
-0.9535408616065979,
-0.818350613117218,
-0.9759361147880554,
-0.03959915414452553,
-0.5047029256820679,
0.3673126995563507,
0.5522575378417969,
0.31099802255630493,
-0.7904020547866821,
-0.22409690916538239,
0.017322150990366936,
-0.026756687089800835,
-0.09889978170394897,
-0.08456631004810333,
0.8517889976501465,
0.1438022404909134,
-0.7665650248527527,
0.15023919939994812,
0.05225116387009621,
0.37661197781562805,
-0.02132311649620533,
-0.13040895760059357,
-0.10194163024425507,
-0.5036711096763611,
0.22015483677387238,
0.7078492641448975,
-0.3738839626312256,
-0.07367291301488876,
-0.16542716324329376,
-0.04418470337986946,
0.3737587034702301,
0.8156650066375732,
-0.8025044798851013,
0.9091190099716187,
0.5487838983535767,
0.8238106369972229,
0.43571171164512634,
-0.17890897393226624,
0.5222427845001221,
-0.057027462869882584,
0.07210925221443176,
0.38389939069747925,
0.4183521270751953,
0.5655003786087036,
-0.6486293077468872,
0.46716269850730896,
0.033277012407779694,
-0.5482596158981323,
-0.5627883076667786,
0.058436859399080276,
-0.6379469633102417,
-0.03651098161935806,
0.7780134677886963,
-0.3689485788345337,
-0.5161880254745483,
-0.3464093506336212,
-0.8860536217689514,
0.5195356011390686,
-0.48873260617256165,
1.0477795600891113,
0.7448065280914307,
0.1446465253829956,
-0.3508729934692383,
0.053819794207811356,
0.286061555147171,
0.19502177834510803,
-0.5046043395996094,
-0.26153555512428284,
0.7835854887962341,
-0.1386154294013977,
0.42422789335250854,
0.5306808352470398,
-0.354256272315979,
0.5309076905250549,
-0.09651613980531693,
0.2008812576532364,
-0.32801276445388794,
-0.10435104370117188,
-0.4904027581214905,
0.29840314388275146,
0.10409709066152573,
-0.15840961039066315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15370v1
|
Traitement quantique des langues : {é}tat de l'art
| 2024-04-09T08:05:15 | 2024-04-09T08:05:15 |
Sabrina Campano, Tahar Nabil, Meryl Bothua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This article presents a review of quantum computing research works for
Natural Language Processing (NLP). Their goal is to improve the performance of
current models, and to provide a better representation of several linguistic
phenomena, such as ambiguity and long range dependencies. Several families of
approaches are presented, including symbolic diagrammatic approaches, and
hybrid neural networks. These works show that experimental studies are already
feasible, and open research perspectives on the conception of new models and
their evaluation.
|
[
-0.26502999663352966,
-0.9389926791191101,
0.4566848874092102,
0.2540077567100525,
-0.1439400166273117,
0.616817831993103,
-0.14999400079250336,
-0.811431348323822,
0.4263184666633606,
0.32354769110679626,
-0.05357929319143295,
-0.07069718837738037,
-0.5294333100318909,
0.36276060342788696,
-0.627217173576355,
0.402656227350235,
-0.0019674194045364857,
0.10249389708042145,
-0.03383948281407356,
-0.11466922610998154,
-0.19324234127998352,
-0.6003225445747375,
-1.0726977586746216,
-0.2221536785364151,
0.24071267247200012,
-0.23085086047649384,
1.1186304092407227,
-0.07268750667572021,
0.4116625189781189,
0.39177852869033813,
-0.26891812682151794,
0.05919463187456131,
-0.01352722104638815,
0.31096315383911133,
-0.2319355309009552,
-0.6290145516395569,
-0.29531291127204895,
-0.35339412093162537,
1.0675057172775269,
0.7739328145980835,
0.0043104118667542934,
-0.2359756976366043,
0.014264349825680256,
1.1257625818252563,
-0.5280027389526367,
0.0034660783130675554,
-0.08663112670183182,
0.48227784037590027,
-0.023605206981301308,
-0.14088617265224457,
-0.42258453369140625,
-0.3519029915332794,
0.23933818936347961,
-0.5561293363571167,
0.08174041658639908,
0.08042502403259277,
0.495410293340683,
-0.012237315066158772,
-0.6605215072631836,
0.09894593805074692,
-1.196112871170044,
0.9838546514511108,
-0.9378243684768677,
0.8681402206420898,
0.47581467032432556,
0.0553545281291008,
-0.3153770864009857,
-0.6990246176719666,
-0.5164138674736023,
-0.5228255391120911,
-0.0065417662262916565,
-0.058956630527973175,
-0.6017315983772278,
0.2551557421684265,
0.34349483251571655,
0.7065040469169617,
-0.8107995986938477,
0.0594867467880249,
-0.21974718570709229,
-0.18202535808086395,
0.5411480069160461,
0.021168146282434464,
0.5027104020118713,
-0.2548070251941681,
0.07163120061159134,
-0.12324827164411545,
-0.360105037689209,
0.12911637127399445,
0.14070552587509155,
0.008730383589863777,
-0.0958368107676506,
0.796834409236908,
-0.7948793768882751,
1.0304722785949707,
-0.2744309604167938,
0.2807745933532715,
-0.08418632298707962,
-0.3191467225551605,
-0.2894870638847351,
-0.20664262771606445,
0.9968340992927551,
-0.040040574967861176,
0.006399482488632202,
-0.4292694628238678,
-0.16219262778759003,
0.22174091637134552,
0.1320333629846573,
-0.35921984910964966,
-0.2650856673717499,
0.38912367820739746,
-0.3758605420589447,
-0.0800747498869896,
-0.22584500908851624,
-0.5107536315917969,
-0.25497791171073914,
-0.6131381392478943,
0.27154505252838135,
-0.910575270652771,
-0.49629291892051697,
0.44090110063552856,
-0.4191771149635315,
-0.04932058975100517,
0.0497870109975338,
-0.9457650780677795,
0.5702453255653381,
0.5704736113548279,
0.723631739616394,
-0.040686171501874924,
-0.1582910567522049,
-0.15501129627227783,
0.17014296352863312,
-0.3205154240131378,
0.7026856541633606,
-0.5256368517875671,
-0.34264326095581055,
-0.0515441969037056,
-0.4943999648094177,
0.07149449735879898,
-0.16769270598888397,
0.7715681195259094,
-0.7431865334510803,
0.17921163141727448,
-0.10570031404495239,
-0.6659680604934692,
-0.24318531155586243,
-0.03047499619424343,
-1.1675649881362915,
0.84052973985672,
0.2600565552711487,
-0.8776530027389526,
0.0019207315053790808,
-1.0003591775894165,
-0.5869987607002258,
0.34042200446128845,
-0.2453969269990921,
-0.04011085256934166,
0.465640127658844,
0.19811129570007324,
0.021379323676228523,
-0.33058834075927734,
0.2177915871143341,
0.04069504141807556,
-0.3080453872680664,
0.5591735243797302,
-0.22649036347866058,
1.0106141567230225,
0.42258420586586,
-0.2860279977321625,
0.21186864376068115,
-0.8820724487304688,
0.26658397912979126,
0.16502034664154053,
-0.09103711694478989,
-0.4787057340145111,
0.3936433792114258,
0.11746780574321747,
-0.05484463647007942,
0.22851695120334625,
-0.541652500629425,
0.0355222262442112,
-0.9386934638023376,
0.9570570588111877,
0.3458828926086426,
-0.15565656125545502,
0.7919946312904358,
-0.35110417008399963,
0.5903944969177246,
-0.2630634009838104,
0.27374503016471863,
0.34342160820961,
-0.5827227234840393,
-0.8705068230628967,
0.03376512974500656,
0.5506657958030701,
0.4329172968864441,
-1.15607488155365,
0.4486474394798279,
-0.17962563037872314,
-0.2552628219127655,
-0.3769229054450989,
-0.27565547823905945,
0.1955844908952713,
-0.054925937205553055,
0.2789985239505768,
-0.42272648215293884,
-0.7695921659469604,
-1.0200588703155518,
-0.637726366519928,
-0.31217506527900696,
-0.00470770476385951,
-0.333685964345932,
0.2778649926185608,
-0.16194121539592743,
1.0945069789886475,
-0.26023250818252563,
0.4271235466003418,
-0.000692361150868237,
0.43325382471084595,
-0.03528258576989174,
0.5199042558670044,
0.1610625833272934,
-0.9208974838256836,
-0.12782123684883118,
-0.03474065661430359,
-0.7272422909736633,
0.5383074283599854,
0.15984439849853516,
-0.23948393762111664,
0.33856576681137085,
0.16442282497882843,
-0.6868823170661926,
0.3278641700744629,
0.46933412551879883,
-0.28673121333122253,
0.5167232751846313,
0.1377229392528534,
0.39185911417007446,
-0.7111305594444275,
-0.15143558382987976,
0.31160205602645874,
-0.2713233232498169,
-0.7320667505264282,
0.391713410615921,
-0.05474427714943886,
-0.21308007836341858,
-0.23548217117786407,
0.3609727919101715,
-0.16627050936222076,
-0.02512611262500286,
-0.3680979311466217,
-0.08910079300403595,
0.06992945075035095,
0.33332768082618713,
0.33024483919143677,
0.42195969820022583,
0.5627385973930359,
-0.5546939969062805,
0.5960582494735718,
0.02250155620276928,
-0.08874484151601791,
0.6043575406074524,
-0.5808671116828918,
0.18404152989387512,
0.10161720216274261,
0.06795778125524521,
-0.7212868332862854,
0.09240629523992538,
0.18380148708820343,
-0.6337173581123352,
0.032921697944402695,
0.17862117290496826,
-1.005271553993225,
-0.452593594789505,
-0.2523152828216553,
0.5987623333930969,
0.5100221037864685,
-0.0515739805996418,
0.5703062415122986,
0.40965890884399414,
0.04128994420170784,
-0.09278301149606705,
-0.5607592463493347,
0.38133153319358826,
0.018177347257733345,
-0.6735526323318481,
0.3130928874015808,
0.1584349125623703,
-0.3834516704082489,
0.04810646176338196,
0.16658875346183777,
-0.3239124119281769,
0.1767301857471466,
-0.059001632034778595,
0.06903727352619171,
-0.2939646542072296,
0.2627469301223755,
-0.017871150746941566,
-0.045464836061000824,
0.1975310891866684,
-0.4863760769367218,
0.4656112492084503,
-0.4802186191082001,
-0.0383538119494915,
-0.45564785599708557,
0.6280893683433533,
0.003476575016975403,
-0.29075440764427185,
0.5765226483345032,
0.6171919703483582,
-0.5158955454826355,
-0.21436195075511932,
-0.25538432598114014,
-0.15498296916484833,
-0.4918469488620758,
0.28868624567985535,
-0.27649664878845215,
-1.3487147092819214,
0.06569884717464447,
0.013737832196056843,
-0.18350081145763397,
0.7302832007408142,
0.3248540461063385,
-0.30267956852912903,
1.3106306791305542,
0.9869737029075623,
-0.17672836780548096,
0.5205281376838684,
-0.23577238619327545,
0.8161234259605408,
-0.6686872839927673,
0.30696362257003784,
-0.6800152659416199,
-0.04875274747610092,
-0.7278041243553162,
-0.22680698335170746,
0.3291456997394562,
0.3429754674434662,
-0.17543554306030273,
0.3721091151237488,
-0.7219251990318298,
0.2145525962114334,
0.8236035108566284,
-0.03917315974831581,
0.5461466312408447,
0.2416825294494629,
-0.08251018822193146,
-0.05181646719574928,
-0.8463554382324219,
-0.5865626931190491,
0.8559483885765076,
0.36271169781684875,
0.5339627861976624,
0.09198396652936935,
0.45264944434165955,
0.2729465365409851,
-0.1889560967683792,
-0.6463363766670227,
0.6343879103660583,
-0.10344095528125763,
-0.46373018622398376,
-0.6747063398361206,
-0.543285071849823,
-1.0859378576278687,
0.14686724543571472,
-0.34212809801101685,
-0.8909175992012024,
-0.03567003086209297,
0.07844486087560654,
-0.3501296043395996,
0.4065239131450653,
-0.6802855730056763,
0.5262512564659119,
-0.1571807861328125,
-0.2165289670228958,
-0.5792441368103027,
-0.42820271849632263,
0.5390954613685608,
0.028994670137763023,
0.19815103709697723,
0.11152936518192291,
0.21716094017028809,
0.9437141418457031,
-0.08242977410554886,
0.689742922782898,
0.3185478746891022,
-0.3672182559967041,
0.33523350954055786,
0.3950374126434326,
0.16496028006076813,
0.021060360595583916,
-0.2063949555158615,
0.12271462380886078,
0.661126434803009,
-0.4509807527065277,
-0.5366212129592896,
0.5201526284217834,
-0.6436575055122375,
-0.19003203511238098,
-0.525087296962738,
-0.6490899324417114,
-0.5716304183006287,
0.08141689747571945,
0.19755291938781738,
0.2955508232116699,
-0.3495435416698456,
-0.28505364060401917,
0.43370506167411804,
-0.3372645974159241,
0.4265947937965393,
0.378102570772171,
-0.4086128771305084,
-0.19132253527641296,
0.9623691439628601,
-0.07700346410274506,
0.1236458495259285,
0.7995627522468567,
0.1271451860666275,
-0.19138064980506897,
-0.5334258079528809,
-0.1807027906179428,
0.11817049980163574,
-0.6210457682609558,
0.06460478156805038,
-0.31387409567832947,
-0.556968092918396,
-0.49305638670921326,
-0.01956256851553917,
-0.4104820191860199,
-0.9499112367630005,
-0.055978912860155106,
0.22490255534648895,
0.556050181388855,
0.8153594136238098,
-0.0195323396474123,
0.19966159760951996,
-0.8027963638305664,
0.6667611002922058,
0.3475261330604553,
0.6087797284126282,
0.23347756266593933,
-0.11014188826084137,
-0.5371772050857544,
0.2745855450630188,
-0.4814883768558502,
-0.7033891677856445,
0.24933362007141113,
0.04859844967722893,
0.4765129089355469,
-0.2959877550601959,
0.03986622765660286,
0.13142670691013336,
-0.1929466724395752,
0.8430131673812866,
0.4379974901676178,
-1.2309620380401611,
0.8001317977905273,
-0.3438585698604584,
0.4278910756111145,
0.1663406938314438,
0.48554420471191406,
-0.7554076910018921,
-0.6558775305747986,
-0.7941298484802246,
-0.6079352498054504,
0.20316386222839355,
0.5838227272033691,
-0.25377458333969116,
0.135152205824852,
0.17070834338665009,
-0.24927090108394623,
0.24217048287391663,
-0.8304309248924255,
-0.2707693874835968,
0.13007916510105133,
-0.17192967236042023,
-0.13797125220298767,
-0.20207345485687256,
-0.11890513449907303,
-0.5282166600227356,
0.4798019826412201,
-0.038172442466020584,
0.4823324978351593,
0.2898818850517273,
-0.25403252243995667,
-0.3610207140445709,
0.4456351399421692,
0.31243544816970825,
0.8964132070541382,
0.0054219248704612255,
0.36943528056144714,
-0.08799465745687485,
-0.20050224661827087,
0.014199945144355297,
0.010280418209731579,
-0.3535274565219879,
0.014551668427884579,
0.3201878070831299,
0.721064567565918,
0.181233212351799,
-0.6950682997703552,
0.07327727228403091,
-0.1251910775899887,
-0.1127723976969719,
-0.24088792502880096,
-0.039532311260700226,
0.01817941851913929,
0.2890976369380951,
0.045983392745256424,
0.030488625168800354,
0.8267130851745605,
-0.6168607473373413,
-0.0312846302986145,
0.6136616468429565,
-0.24114477634429932,
-0.40725651383399963,
0.5539447665214539,
0.12031211704015732,
-0.5282731652259827,
0.6251717805862427,
-0.36189785599708557,
-0.5253854393959045,
0.43494749069213867,
0.5338497757911682,
0.9530656933784485,
-0.1351911872625351,
0.3631715774536133,
0.423605740070343,
0.3753679394721985,
0.036114223301410675,
0.6193877458572388,
-0.07188571244478226,
-0.5987710356712341,
-0.8371317982673645,
-0.6384801268577576,
-0.4681535065174103,
-0.27515342831611633,
-0.4848404824733734,
-0.035454001277685165,
-0.42902544140815735,
-0.42376285791397095,
0.09748809784650803,
0.072960264980793,
-0.5014389157295227,
0.031387776136398315,
0.37045103311538696,
0.41125521063804626,
-0.6777772307395935,
0.8582753539085388,
0.5998441576957703,
-0.22738158702850342,
-0.4450088441371918,
-0.4256179928779602,
-0.3711581528186798,
-0.39855071902275085,
0.6989410519599915,
-0.44079235196113586,
-0.30442866683006287,
0.18025879561901093,
-0.5467303395271301,
-0.9787443280220032,
0.4081328809261322,
0.2708631157875061,
-0.5940160751342773,
0.047128450125455856,
0.37080177664756775,
0.8510685563087463,
0.341288298368454,
0.18868644535541534,
0.782897412776947,
0.3132360279560089,
-0.37251046299934387,
-1.1292693614959717,
0.037392742931842804,
-0.44375601410865784,
0.4120030403137207,
0.6229828000068665,
-0.39160966873168945,
0.7659449577331543,
0.2515764832496643,
-0.43381911516189575,
0.29338565468788147,
0.8992763757705688,
0.30197909474372864,
-0.027581986039876938,
0.27221232652664185,
0.7333451509475708,
0.551702618598938,
0.0823899433016777,
1.192091941833496,
-0.26642873883247375,
0.31042686104774475,
0.7219977378845215,
-0.08608918637037277,
1.0242735147476196,
0.7202135920524597,
-0.8873486518859863,
0.5676875710487366,
0.4333043694496155,
0.1849534511566162,
0.24800439178943634,
0.5849291682243347,
-0.4701426923274994,
-0.009668676182627678,
-0.14759059250354767,
-0.18960578739643097,
0.02581249363720417,
0.2842647433280945,
-0.041102293878793716,
-0.013199671171605587,
0.16637323796749115,
-0.5315886735916138,
0.2386188507080078,
-0.25045308470726013,
0.4973113536834717,
0.3180275559425354,
-0.4648796021938324,
0.6515107750892639,
0.39984169602394104,
0.7798676490783691,
-0.3516807556152344,
-0.14539596438407898,
0.24418233335018158,
-0.36974069476127625,
-0.2331482619047165,
-0.5973167419433594,
0.32180556654930115,
-0.3985207974910736,
-0.09624142199754715,
-0.14400430023670197,
0.8219283223152161,
0.12093887478113174,
-0.6562396287918091,
0.2493172436952591,
0.6475935578346252,
-0.04385571926832199,
-0.10653401166200638,
-0.8707278966903687,
0.1496654599905014,
-0.17104767262935638,
0.00549475010484457,
0.1772129386663437,
0.19306334853172302,
-0.1331176608800888,
0.5670037269592285,
0.418854296207428,
0.15791940689086914,
0.23794133961200714,
0.023710384964942932,
0.4592849314212799,
-1.076333999633789,
-0.7024713158607483,
-0.7756853103637695,
0.22531843185424805,
0.10030216723680496,
-0.1803508698940277,
0.724066436290741,
0.5564070343971252,
0.7458201050758362,
0.009116949513554573,
0.654847264289856,
0.04593271762132645,
0.5327497124671936,
-0.7505040764808655,
0.32865652441978455,
-0.24810247123241425,
0.004277605563402176,
-0.23454055190086365,
-0.6957550048828125,
-0.3626596927642822,
0.7291104197502136,
-0.2622922956943512,
-0.00745671009644866,
1.1054110527038574,
0.3891913592815399,
0.3050844669342041,
0.6397968530654907,
0.1769050806760788,
-0.06699257344007492,
0.18984976410865784,
0.8562625050544739,
1.4970277547836304,
-0.6233957409858704,
-0.200477734208107,
-0.7767201066017151,
0.09409187734127045,
-0.02023194171488285,
-0.7390114665031433,
-0.5071460604667664,
-1.0431305170059204,
-0.4764380156993866,
-0.20170705020427704,
-0.033898886293172836,
0.6203235983848572,
0.6594186425209045,
-0.6351110339164734,
-0.6068717837333679,
-0.4321981966495514,
0.32569068670272827,
-0.36891627311706543,
-0.2406807839870453,
0.3827781081199646,
-0.3693789541721344,
-0.6701048016548157,
0.31545883417129517,
0.3746761977672577,
0.03935893997550011,
-0.3284773528575897,
-0.09445290267467499,
-0.18637394905090332,
-0.17173118889331818,
1.0429977178573608,
0.5064882040023804,
-0.7823292016983032,
0.09272076934576035,
-0.089798703789711,
-0.1817985475063324,
0.11042987555265427,
0.8967033624649048,
-0.973182737827301,
0.36292752623558044,
0.6599584221839905,
0.4978722631931305,
0.2715213894844055,
-0.5709272027015686,
0.7746764421463013,
-0.3308282196521759,
0.18217553198337555,
0.860590934753418,
0.40119966864585876,
0.13396665453910828,
-0.25700005888938904,
0.5496601462364197,
0.07270587980747223,
-0.4701702296733856,
-0.7622385025024414,
0.2602767050266266,
-1.055265188217163,
-0.5853996872901917,
0.8284554481506348,
0.6631722450256348,
-0.23096902668476105,
-0.0913347378373146,
-0.11977137625217438,
0.40108442306518555,
-0.21426422894001007,
0.5405977368354797,
0.7470382452011108,
-0.4590460956096649,
-0.3140850067138672,
-0.9390694499015808,
0.49445801973342896,
0.849328339099884,
-0.6960740685462952,
-0.3744221329689026,
0.4053345024585724,
-0.3140178620815277,
0.228719562292099,
0.7481821179389954,
-0.07174545526504517,
0.30098938941955566,
-0.17080476880073547,
0.30171316862106323,
0.6017269492149353,
0.035687655210494995,
-0.7095537781715393,
0.009467721916735172,
0.6837993860244751,
0.2474651336669922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06063v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06063v1
|
All in One: An Empirical Study of GPT for Few-Shot Aspect-Based Sentiment Anlaysis
| 2024-04-09T07:02:14 | 2024-04-09T07:02:14 |
Baoxing Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) is an indispensable and highly
challenging task in natural language processing. Current efforts have focused
on specific sub-tasks, making it difficult to comprehensively cover all
sub-tasks within the ABSA domain. With the development of Generative
Pre-trained Transformers (GPTs), there came inspiration for a one-stop solution
to sentiment analysis. In this study, we used GPTs for all sub-tasks of
few-shot ABSA while defining a general learning paradigm for this application.
We propose the All in One (AiO) model, a simple yet effective two-stage model
for all ABSA sub-tasks. In the first stage, a specific backbone network learns
the semantic information of the review and generates heuristically enhanced
candidates. In the second stage, AiO leverages GPT contextual learning
capabilities to generate predictions. The study conducted comprehensive
comparative and ablation experiments on five benchmark datasets, and the
results show that AiO can effectively handle all ABSA sub-tasks, even with
few-shot data.
|
[
-0.5719882249832153,
-0.890296995639801,
0.6487764716148376,
0.1508396565914154,
-0.6413084268569946,
-0.19926588237285614,
0.07514334470033646,
-0.28832632303237915,
0.34591659903526306,
0.44621482491493225,
-0.7046655416488647,
-0.6809534430503845,
-0.6120396852493286,
0.15540848672389984,
-0.4819768965244293,
1.3953505754470825,
0.015002240426838398,
-0.032553739845752716,
-0.0710330680012703,
-0.12705227732658386,
-0.35556378960609436,
-0.4363563358783722,
-0.7958383560180664,
-0.4255322217941284,
0.29812386631965637,
0.376385897397995,
0.4996492862701416,
0.2662730813026428,
0.6543652415275574,
0.24637871980667114,
0.06713402271270752,
-0.23391270637512207,
-0.18597109615802765,
-0.020396368578076363,
-0.22311806678771973,
-0.506498396396637,
-0.4881329834461212,
0.1326933354139328,
0.36165863275527954,
0.4488380551338196,
-0.0744098573923111,
0.02574152499437332,
0.17771756649017334,
0.6140075325965881,
-0.39042460918426514,
0.19536924362182617,
-0.7739843726158142,
0.11320621520280838,
-0.07753940671682358,
0.16086824238300323,
-0.07704973220825195,
-0.16967716813087463,
0.1740235537290573,
-0.588293731212616,
0.36574453115463257,
-0.005948908627033234,
0.7648033499717712,
0.25154682993888855,
-0.20057056844234467,
-0.18356703221797943,
-0.5935017466545105,
0.8109681606292725,
-0.6645020842552185,
0.004194770008325577,
0.1822204291820526,
-0.01727130450308323,
0.28312915563583374,
-0.5015602707862854,
-0.7162232398986816,
-0.033815350383520126,
-0.238802969455719,
0.5405086874961853,
-0.298164039850235,
0.25851860642433167,
-0.3012309968471527,
0.44400104880332947,
-0.540166437625885,
0.15877249836921692,
-0.09275743365287781,
0.16403894126415253,
0.44973114132881165,
0.04073873162269592,
0.031999606639146805,
-0.6539742946624756,
-0.5741881132125854,
0.029802657663822174,
-0.6648293137550354,
0.03492370620369911,
0.2707757353782654,
0.508510172367096,
-0.23722150921821594,
0.3652445077896118,
-0.22896438837051392,
0.3997782766819,
0.10813402384519577,
-0.07641130685806274,
-0.016060298308730125,
-0.297262579202652,
-0.40271732211112976,
-0.13527925312519073,
1.1587828397750854,
-0.08454272896051407,
0.08902459591627121,
-0.18966107070446014,
-0.2550491392612457,
0.0618782602250576,
0.6745687127113342,
-0.6042536497116089,
-0.048839930444955826,
0.3438708484172821,
-0.3133402168750763,
-0.34465232491493225,
0.14839908480644226,
-0.8366354703903198,
-0.2529938817024231,
-0.5039600133895874,
0.6551644206047058,
-0.5660852789878845,
-0.2867242693901062,
-0.30471542477607727,
0.2655546963214874,
0.18000663816928864,
0.2171267569065094,
-0.6404220461845398,
0.015116823837161064,
0.9964562654495239,
0.9377015829086304,
-0.1971290409564972,
-0.40356865525245667,
-0.03684926778078079,
-0.4395630359649658,
-0.37894806265830994,
1.1589610576629639,
-0.5397102236747742,
-0.4985429048538208,
0.058253731578588486,
-0.3686774969100952,
-0.1311928927898407,
-0.2549199163913727,
0.5431643724441528,
-0.3035581111907959,
0.2987769544124603,
-0.17227678000926971,
-0.41213056445121765,
-0.36283302307128906,
0.6422790288925171,
-0.4117761254310608,
0.6996057629585266,
0.34080106019973755,
-0.747348964214325,
0.49694421887397766,
-0.6825462579727173,
-0.5182490348815918,
-0.09151888638734818,
-0.2963693141937256,
-0.6593295931816101,
0.43174102902412415,
0.4205287992954254,
0.4220280349254608,
-0.36444997787475586,
-0.0938887894153595,
-0.03606230020523071,
-0.0728074237704277,
0.09272204339504242,
-0.3642285168170929,
0.2450830638408661,
0.13526956737041473,
-0.19770120084285736,
0.28333336114883423,
-0.3246768116950989,
-0.13553282618522644,
-0.03718098998069763,
-0.08680097758769989,
-0.1660648137331009,
-0.16719916462898254,
-0.0029877531342208385,
0.3159225881099701,
-0.06090368330478668,
-0.7281823754310608,
0.46604111790657043,
-0.5960419178009033,
0.1537093073129654,
0.6094071865081787,
0.3301793932914734,
0.6137700080871582,
-0.058421723544597626,
0.7503806948661804,
0.4100651144981384,
0.49201151728630066,
-0.29006683826446533,
-0.4005434215068817,
-0.7848781943321228,
-0.4256458878517151,
0.027912447229027748,
0.5221740007400513,
-0.8937244415283203,
0.45415160059928894,
-0.2903486490249634,
-0.408224493265152,
-0.6149998307228088,
0.3943142294883728,
0.5235110521316528,
0.441552072763443,
0.556533932685852,
-0.6752144694328308,
-0.3177860677242279,
-0.9478354454040527,
-0.1430560201406479,
-0.34974852204322815,
-0.10297110676765442,
-0.052410006523132324,
0.5035253167152405,
-0.09310764074325562,
1.4526283740997314,
-0.3691602945327759,
-0.9904826879501343,
-0.7288722395896912,
0.6256279349327087,
0.25713419914245605,
0.19048769772052765,
0.6341401934623718,
-0.5189104080200195,
-0.5222793221473694,
0.12925395369529724,
-0.9134094715118408,
0.24482564628124237,
-0.2549976408481598,
-0.05169136822223663,
0.09868225455284119,
-0.058494605123996735,
-0.741819441318512,
0.4688354432582855,
0.304842084646225,
0.14036500453948975,
0.2514841854572296,
0.19932623207569122,
0.023034418001770973,
-1.212399959564209,
-0.28340426087379456,
0.3469771444797516,
0.07994507253170013,
-0.6590344309806824,
-0.04105672985315323,
-0.2594318389892578,
0.05704589933156967,
-0.6052074432373047,
0.48027917742729187,
0.03398968651890755,
-0.05476672202348709,
-0.6479840874671936,
-0.02798204869031906,
-0.028517862781882286,
0.6908743381500244,
0.07700643688440323,
0.5938024520874023,
0.6873824000358582,
-0.3959156274795532,
0.2874229848384857,
0.2566968500614166,
-0.07230860739946365,
0.7501058578491211,
-0.6077913045883179,
0.4136757254600525,
-0.6137897372245789,
0.23067514598369598,
-0.9520761966705322,
-0.11765364557504654,
0.3185528814792633,
-0.38790449500083923,
0.3270844519138336,
-0.30157411098480225,
-0.27679693698883057,
-0.10454227030277252,
-0.30359596014022827,
0.1641303449869156,
0.3374303877353668,
-0.4004352390766144,
1.0174641609191895,
0.1301640272140503,
-0.34114283323287964,
-0.5465220212936401,
-0.32057762145996094,
-0.09781064093112946,
-0.2656863033771515,
-0.1524624526500702,
0.11579150706529617,
0.43604859709739685,
-0.2106718271970749,
0.19476807117462158,
-0.12968958914279938,
-0.168761745095253,
-0.1686016023159027,
0.29902249574661255,
0.2047552466392517,
-0.08889737725257874,
0.11076312512159348,
-0.08459056168794632,
-0.3010872006416321,
-0.1850680261850357,
-0.2784477472305298,
0.47833988070487976,
-0.3168690800666809,
-0.3540806174278259,
-0.6060177683830261,
0.5599782466888428,
0.26387202739715576,
-0.2585063576698303,
0.4371758699417114,
0.4965384006500244,
-0.09317440539598465,
-0.23157472908496857,
-0.406482994556427,
-0.15015771985054016,
-0.35323861241340637,
0.589609682559967,
-0.44241148233413696,
-0.4488660991191864,
0.4101291596889496,
0.10915971547365189,
0.22538626194000244,
0.543553352355957,
0.3923724591732025,
-0.1551792025566101,
0.8609060645103455,
0.8569942712783813,
-0.7276747822761536,
0.6552530527114868,
-0.4800626337528229,
0.48982471227645874,
-0.7130348682403564,
0.011717780493199825,
-0.40002089738845825,
-0.2123168706893921,
-0.3007660210132599,
-0.02909136936068535,
0.7260959148406982,
0.49297961592674255,
-0.24673250317573547,
0.29241713881492615,
-0.46827009320259094,
0.5065950155258179,
0.4906524419784546,
0.1903432011604309,
0.3468068540096283,
0.05098889023065567,
0.3359052836894989,
0.19548985362052917,
-0.5727619528770447,
-0.5015017986297607,
1.143632411956787,
0.33758842945098877,
0.6804093718528748,
-0.08038317412137985,
0.8092399835586548,
0.08635612577199936,
0.9539241194725037,
-1.3170864582061768,
0.3317769467830658,
-0.5320528149604797,
-0.522409200668335,
-0.27546992897987366,
-0.12422490119934082,
-0.6056125164031982,
0.33850011229515076,
-0.1573999673128128,
-0.5787181258201599,
0.025132952257990837,
0.052481308579444885,
-0.3347214162349701,
0.34614601731300354,
-0.3462064266204834,
0.7113215923309326,
-0.11261513084173203,
-0.2568538784980774,
-0.26136794686317444,
-0.5351269841194153,
0.31063511967658997,
-0.1579972356557846,
0.24840030074119568,
-0.03919161483645439,
0.32174941897392273,
0.4243770241737366,
-0.23970730602741241,
0.9520251154899597,
-0.2510932683944702,
0.11448448896408081,
0.693896472454071,
0.005837725475430489,
0.4527648687362671,
0.11868524551391602,
-0.07411481440067291,
0.42018693685531616,
-0.33479762077331543,
-0.16390979290008545,
-0.5815067887306213,
0.37000739574432373,
-0.8270471096038818,
-0.43180686235427856,
-0.47770220041275024,
-0.17040996253490448,
-0.38367676734924316,
-0.061362434178590775,
0.6534359455108643,
0.23801346123218536,
-0.34354767203330994,
-0.008796604350209236,
0.28903862833976746,
0.21176110208034515,
0.5292252898216248,
0.41234147548675537,
-0.02396080456674099,
-0.2773059010505676,
0.6603835225105286,
-0.09618473798036575,
0.05725369229912758,
0.5301138162612915,
0.1786552220582962,
-0.2624778151512146,
-0.4385059177875519,
-0.613274097442627,
0.08774930983781815,
-0.8736535310745239,
-0.39769747853279114,
-0.5178954005241394,
-0.025181621313095093,
-0.3646765649318695,
-0.11852603405714035,
-0.7652244567871094,
0.07603665441274643,
-0.17303207516670227,
-0.251280277967453,
0.24297447502613068,
0.970237135887146,
0.06282064318656921,
0.8066313862800598,
-0.7229626178741455,
0.37405872344970703,
0.49467673897743225,
0.20327040553092957,
-0.07348382472991943,
-0.31649249792099,
-0.13261769711971283,
-0.07100170850753784,
-0.6730543971061707,
-0.8017199635505676,
0.4578670561313629,
0.40343907475471497,
0.43252044916152954,
0.598829984664917,
-0.2039554864168167,
0.3651033341884613,
-0.21621087193489075,
1.008643627166748,
0.3274775743484497,
-0.990883469581604,
0.6206604242324829,
-0.19424037635326385,
0.10635897517204285,
0.7940735220909119,
0.586331844329834,
-0.4602164626121521,
-0.21841393411159515,
-0.3373521566390991,
-0.9732088446617126,
0.682002067565918,
0.11554191261529922,
0.26999202370643616,
-0.010407831519842148,
0.5598321557044983,
0.417403906583786,
0.22866138815879822,
-0.6655986309051514,
-0.12884849309921265,
-0.7776018977165222,
-0.4270235300064087,
-0.04114171862602234,
0.07442639768123627,
-0.1712590456008911,
-0.053011175245046616,
0.8040344715118408,
-0.5161644220352173,
0.30526670813560486,
0.21652735769748688,
-0.02856564149260521,
0.009803260676562786,
0.7997052669525146,
-0.06071540340781212,
0.4771651327610016,
-0.0498514361679554,
-0.17615650594234467,
0.036949463188648224,
-0.38229745626449585,
0.08105747401714325,
-0.12926793098449707,
-0.29539644718170166,
-0.05233215540647507,
0.6008370518684387,
0.9997643828392029,
-0.03180018067359924,
-0.030435603111982346,
0.6934275031089783,
0.16588085889816284,
-0.11230748146772385,
-0.23070020973682404,
-0.20498281717300415,
-0.38182708621025085,
0.039713598787784576,
0.5624482035636902,
-0.07753073424100876,
0.03941898047924042,
-0.8461190462112427,
0.15634238719940186,
0.5317535996437073,
-0.6947510242462158,
-0.6569532752037048,
0.3893688917160034,
0.21770261228084564,
0.13109903037548065,
0.7189428210258484,
-0.5741901397705078,
-0.7165323495864868,
0.44442954659461975,
0.2592821717262268,
1.3996752500534058,
-0.01658027619123459,
0.46909886598587036,
0.23746177554130554,
0.26245933771133423,
-0.15793216228485107,
0.008627455681562424,
0.004464003723114729,
-0.8209590315818787,
-0.4898141026496887,
-1.028367519378662,
-0.6112857460975647,
0.00037045040517114103,
-0.6145250201225281,
0.04285245016217232,
-0.5084776282310486,
-0.11916226148605347,
-0.09439392387866974,
-0.27233386039733887,
-0.9157350063323975,
0.4301944673061371,
-0.037444207817316055,
0.19573469460010529,
-1.1426531076431274,
0.848708987236023,
0.9336782097816467,
-0.8971179723739624,
-0.6805887222290039,
0.2484128326177597,
0.1514296531677246,
-0.5560915470123291,
0.48636627197265625,
0.08857791125774384,
-0.05333395302295685,
-0.12384634464979172,
-0.4979211688041687,
-0.6058396697044373,
0.7474992275238037,
-0.16953381896018982,
-0.27562007308006287,
0.03614678606390953,
0.47021180391311646,
0.6938521862030029,
-0.623615562915802,
0.3233613967895508,
0.8252866268157959,
0.29433369636535645,
0.14013804495334625,
-0.8721767067909241,
-0.33989331126213074,
0.047217465937137604,
-0.03756337985396385,
0.12725013494491577,
-0.6011607646942139,
1.1901042461395264,
0.08562520891427994,
-0.13464723527431488,
-0.061220116913318634,
0.7378405332565308,
0.02338809333741665,
0.3181315064430237,
0.6258927583694458,
0.6341193318367004,
-0.01485800463706255,
-0.2688209116458893,
1.1544145345687866,
-0.2036730945110321,
0.5838097929954529,
0.8991951942443848,
-0.16752959787845612,
0.8192135095596313,
0.24705471098423004,
-0.3511202931404114,
0.39231887459754944,
0.4417661726474762,
0.36483365297317505,
0.6513423323631287,
-0.12426666915416718,
-0.39743128418922424,
-0.32541191577911377,
-0.198212668299675,
-0.11530838906764984,
0.7679421305656433,
0.22476327419281006,
-0.09776556491851807,
-0.33328574895858765,
0.29548096656799316,
0.15910229086875916,
-0.06446688622236252,
-0.571308434009552,
1.0999170541763306,
0.25605452060699463,
-0.6531172394752502,
-0.10872355103492737,
-0.021389057859778404,
1.0928194522857666,
-0.8645598292350769,
0.16176334023475647,
-0.5998128652572632,
0.20424890518188477,
-0.3425028622150421,
-0.8461039662361145,
0.39322277903556824,
0.08782585710287094,
-0.16867917776107788,
-0.11490355432033539,
0.561888575553894,
-0.17396225035190582,
-0.6685202717781067,
0.1331508606672287,
0.4887152910232544,
0.0183832049369812,
-0.7175175547599792,
-0.5842798948287964,
-0.2936224937438965,
-0.14421236515045166,
-0.6755260229110718,
0.3904126286506653,
0.30288928747177124,
-0.09346351772546768,
0.35023975372314453,
0.3555965721607208,
0.042642105370759964,
-0.3086351454257965,
0.156876340508461,
0.7709327936172485,
-0.5665006041526794,
-0.5484123229980469,
-0.7800666689872742,
0.4684857726097107,
0.1741056740283966,
-0.5850343704223633,
0.62812340259552,
0.3573756515979767,
0.727100670337677,
0.07792042195796967,
1.2103204727172852,
-0.13830025494098663,
0.5192736983299255,
-0.5616753697395325,
0.40681567788124084,
-0.5884875059127808,
0.11155527830123901,
-0.2638891339302063,
-1.188974142074585,
-0.22161588072776794,
0.5777092576026917,
-0.3010473847389221,
0.06748504936695099,
0.7561389207839966,
0.4907394051551819,
0.024191319942474365,
0.2729678153991699,
0.024550708010792732,
0.11103618144989014,
0.49197083711624146,
0.379626601934433,
0.59947270154953,
-0.465798020362854,
0.34769532084465027,
-0.6356272101402283,
-0.21239984035491943,
0.12889347970485687,
-0.7340779900550842,
-0.613676905632019,
-0.4009378254413605,
-0.2337382435798645,
-0.03025796264410019,
-0.13532541692256927,
1.063595175743103,
0.6654238700866699,
-0.8435513377189636,
0.15570542216300964,
-0.20678284764289856,
-0.03107967972755432,
-0.43508580327033997,
-0.2584875226020813,
0.47617071866989136,
-0.6389625668525696,
-0.9399038553237915,
0.4486280381679535,
0.3306615352630615,
-0.11946598440408707,
-0.4392056465148926,
0.32112425565719604,
0.16150136291980743,
0.10413601994514465,
0.7891332507133484,
0.21954527497291565,
-0.6085373163223267,
-0.3988390862941742,
-0.21895717084407806,
0.05447852984070778,
0.28819456696510315,
0.939509928226471,
-0.7767496109008789,
0.3604568541049957,
0.5911101698875427,
0.4641483724117279,
0.45874446630477905,
0.5084279775619507,
0.2526394724845886,
-1.2189525365829468,
0.2537881135940552,
0.2943686246871948,
0.2688394784927368,
0.3175732493400574,
-0.1993238627910614,
0.563860297203064,
0.05509980767965317,
-0.3466040790081024,
-0.22027353942394257,
0.34434762597084045,
-1.0263323783874512,
-0.39037108421325684,
1.0681365728378296,
-0.2147754728794098,
-0.00821014866232872,
-0.1302683800458908,
-0.05012194812297821,
0.14612269401550293,
-0.43635812401771545,
0.8057354092597961,
0.5410097241401672,
-0.6056531667709351,
-0.03988686949014664,
-0.32010939717292786,
0.3336297571659088,
0.4402611553668976,
-1.0686919689178467,
-0.2561214566230774,
0.36068978905677795,
0.28564897179603577,
0.27984899282455444,
0.7895981669425964,
-0.05141526088118553,
-0.15377624332904816,
-0.027571244165301323,
0.2921775281429291,
-0.05942336097359657,
-0.577995240688324,
-0.40802761912345886,
0.525197446346283,
-0.05993197485804558,
-0.28802937269210815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06017v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06017v1
|
Identifying Shopping Intent in Product QA for Proactive Recommendations
| 2024-04-09T04:55:24 | 2024-04-09T04:55:24 |
Besnik Fetahu, Nachshon Cohen, Elad Haramaty, Liane Lewin-Eytan, Oleg Rokhlenko, Shervin Malmasi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Voice assistants have become ubiquitous in smart devices allowing users to
instantly access information via voice questions. While extensive research has
been conducted in question answering for voice search, little attention has
been paid on how to enable proactive recommendations from a voice assistant to
its users. This is a highly challenging problem that often leads to user
friction, mainly due to recommendations provided to the users at the wrong
time. We focus on the domain of e-commerce, namely in identifying Shopping
Product Questions (SPQs), where the user asking a product-related question may
have an underlying shopping need. Identifying a user's shopping need allows
voice assistants to enhance shopping experience by determining when to provide
recommendations, such as product or deal recommendations, or proactive shopping
actions recommendation. Identifying SPQs is a challenging problem and cannot be
done from question text alone, and thus requires to infer latent user behavior
patterns inferred from user's past shopping history. We propose features that
capture the user's latent shopping behavior from their purchase history, and
combine them using a novel Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) model. Our evaluation shows
that the proposed approach is able to identify SPQs with a high score of
F1=0.91. Furthermore, based on an online evaluation with real voice assistant
users, we identify SPQs in real-time and recommend shopping actions to users to
add the queried product into their shopping list. We demonstrate that we are
able to accurately identify SPQs, as indicated by the significantly higher rate
of added products to users' shopping lists when being prompted after SPQs vs
random PQs.
|
[
-0.4058617949485779,
-0.9348925352096558,
0.6516342163085938,
0.3657092750072479,
-0.16569127142429352,
-0.05657633766531944,
0.041489433497190475,
-0.6324272751808167,
0.5278285145759583,
0.49888694286346436,
-1.007543683052063,
-0.1320762038230896,
-0.023251235485076904,
-0.20745967328548431,
-0.4230780303478241,
0.7538956999778748,
0.3424583971500397,
-0.06895304471254349,
-0.3293910026550293,
-0.10393540561199188,
-0.6917325854301453,
-0.4739649295806885,
-1.0267643928527832,
0.03013729117810726,
0.34992343187332153,
0.4397866725921631,
0.6725326180458069,
-0.2650609612464905,
0.0495854876935482,
0.3092220723628998,
-0.09807907044887543,
0.49257075786590576,
-0.3189130127429962,
0.3833134174346924,
0.01890658587217331,
-0.48301631212234497,
-0.7551794052124023,
-0.004716910887509584,
-0.05125372111797333,
0.23826245963573456,
-0.3691868185997009,
0.3923899233341217,
-0.023124482482671738,
0.3575025498867035,
-0.6238626837730408,
-0.04735983535647392,
-0.49801957607269287,
0.18741759657859802,
0.13707523047924042,
-0.30705034732818604,
-0.31088823080062866,
-0.36971646547317505,
0.4660317599773407,
-1.0625758171081543,
0.2718707025051117,
-0.019953003153204918,
0.9967303276062012,
0.15669667720794678,
-0.25990617275238037,
-0.44016921520233154,
-1.137829065322876,
0.6895051002502441,
-0.5300995111465454,
0.6764758229255676,
0.633902907371521,
0.352698415517807,
-0.29167452454566956,
-0.525181770324707,
-0.7406823039054871,
-0.2066226303577423,
-0.0940183773636818,
0.3256586492061615,
-0.45161885023117065,
-0.32850345969200134,
0.0024745366536080837,
0.33762359619140625,
-0.5924655795097351,
-0.37792545557022095,
-0.1296059638261795,
-0.0969967395067215,
0.8938963413238525,
-0.015379088930785656,
0.36179783940315247,
0.18689878284931183,
-0.4538216292858124,
0.21051640808582306,
-0.20902538299560547,
0.5623657703399658,
0.36201798915863037,
-0.03758988156914711,
0.31488800048828125,
0.5227512717247009,
-0.4460507333278656,
0.5393403768539429,
0.6924064755439758,
-0.21926268935203552,
0.15297268331050873,
-0.4820179045200348,
-0.18139193952083588,
0.014050952158868313,
0.5870773792266846,
0.3543885052204132,
0.28779321908950806,
-0.045632634311914444,
-0.08118724077939987,
-0.76520174741745,
0.4828592538833618,
-0.3213745057582855,
-0.13750986754894257,
0.3821756839752197,
-0.4798514246940613,
-0.024895021691918373,
0.4091015160083771,
-0.5549664497375488,
-0.32009896636009216,
-0.3222200274467468,
0.8294834494590759,
0.1530710756778717,
-0.46456167101860046,
0.1841559112071991,
-0.03319113701581955,
0.056532781571149826,
0.1365804821252823,
-0.4895618259906769,
0.42128634452819824,
0.5790958404541016,
0.400787889957428,
0.008420385420322418,
-0.0937252789735794,
-0.6253374218940735,
0.19775035977363586,
-0.2173141986131668,
1.058485746383667,
-0.5694910883903503,
-0.5651260614395142,
-0.05898928642272949,
0.2947506606578827,
-0.18422964215278625,
-0.7068924903869629,
0.6024836301803589,
-0.7726458311080933,
0.31857094168663025,
-0.39220672845840454,
-0.38304468989372253,
-0.34533417224884033,
0.40938910841941833,
-0.4795593321323395,
1.1636934280395508,
0.11654313653707504,
-0.32402274012565613,
0.5512282252311707,
-0.575350284576416,
-0.5597161650657654,
0.28897401690483093,
-0.00183372781611979,
-0.7723832130432129,
0.04965125769376755,
0.2905612885951996,
0.5082502365112305,
-0.04744662344455719,
0.2842617332935333,
-0.34180179238319397,
-0.3523707687854767,
0.6238821148872375,
-0.3280160129070282,
0.7689574956893921,
0.1187453493475914,
-0.532355010509491,
0.2908303737640381,
-0.46500107645988464,
-0.038824744522571564,
0.24174481630325317,
0.03126709908246994,
-0.10219986736774445,
0.3287680149078369,
-0.16678503155708313,
0.08219853788614273,
0.4799995720386505,
-0.28238630294799805,
0.23576441407203674,
-0.22158920764923096,
-0.0338447168469429,
0.6427527070045471,
0.4467099606990814,
0.19688522815704346,
-0.2544480562210083,
0.8733996152877808,
-0.2614749073982239,
0.8646140098571777,
0.11286716908216476,
-0.9790128469467163,
-0.7352365255355835,
-0.17173552513122559,
-0.021488182246685028,
0.5648460388183594,
-0.3967438042163849,
0.6402661800384521,
0.06815150380134583,
-0.6825550198554993,
-0.08615078777074814,
0.0515807643532753,
0.20394833385944366,
0.3966315984725952,
0.34435567259788513,
-0.3494885563850403,
-0.029154203832149506,
-0.7892443537712097,
-0.3965286314487457,
-0.48531627655029297,
-0.4290081858634949,
0.9794861078262329,
-0.3375793695449829,
-0.2812182903289795,
1.1469125747680664,
-0.9008451700210571,
-0.5393608212471008,
-0.22636310756206512,
0.11185645312070847,
0.19483113288879395,
0.02076766826212406,
0.46027976274490356,
-0.9453561305999756,
-0.41454774141311646,
-0.0823451578617096,
-0.09390062838792801,
-0.4294421076774597,
-0.3870450258255005,
-0.12002216279506683,
-0.35669058561325073,
0.24080568552017212,
-0.6505127549171448,
0.5156986713409424,
0.23808301985263824,
-0.4832366108894348,
0.49019983410835266,
-0.24231602251529694,
0.33484944701194763,
-0.9366494417190552,
-0.16697724163532257,
0.18676890432834625,
0.13195310533046722,
-0.6718868017196655,
-0.3084052801132202,
-0.23642422258853912,
-0.14506395161151886,
-0.4405370354652405,
0.2699105441570282,
-0.13905657827854156,
-0.3478894531726837,
0.03114996664226055,
-0.23968614637851715,
0.19909895956516266,
0.5083456039428711,
0.2458040565252304,
0.8388628959655762,
0.22862714529037476,
-0.9745348691940308,
0.11327048391103745,
0.259566992521286,
-0.15801532566547394,
0.5446611642837524,
-0.8135006427764893,
0.08176705241203308,
0.2789669334888458,
0.1907867044210434,
-1.0206233263015747,
0.04584600031375885,
0.5123287439346313,
-0.4722100794315338,
-0.23002733290195465,
-0.23935213685035706,
-0.2932700216770172,
-0.05762000009417534,
0.012774740345776081,
0.39646899700164795,
0.300022691488266,
-0.3773438632488251,
1.2000430822372437,
0.47418564558029175,
-0.45950090885162354,
-0.29227253794670105,
-0.09516169130802155,
-0.3025093376636505,
-0.3229231834411621,
-0.5631251931190491,
0.4051673412322998,
-0.29109200835227966,
0.010278410278260708,
-0.19966551661491394,
-0.2139398455619812,
-0.05935577303171158,
0.31654679775238037,
0.1493353396654129,
0.22513920068740845,
-0.19854485988616943,
0.12303538620471954,
-0.04815742000937462,
-0.23401737213134766,
0.1774349957704544,
-0.11937421560287476,
0.3674061596393585,
0.16013766825199127,
-0.41243427991867065,
-0.5884906053543091,
0.6189448237419128,
0.5342963337898254,
-0.5266788601875305,
0.1901233047246933,
0.8215318918228149,
-0.12941129505634308,
-0.09059365838766098,
-0.7033039927482605,
-0.403219074010849,
-0.5337584018707275,
0.15956613421440125,
-0.38989293575286865,
-0.41532009840011597,
0.48163938522338867,
-0.009732846170663834,
-0.15765687823295593,
0.19306591153144836,
0.6569113731384277,
-0.2664216160774231,
1.589895486831665,
0.4032258093357086,
0.261261910200119,
0.7212637662887573,
-0.021030398085713387,
0.8194817304611206,
-0.5820884108543396,
-0.6640326380729675,
-0.47725507616996765,
-0.36637768149375916,
-0.30601271986961365,
-0.2003261297941208,
0.4684267044067383,
0.24654360115528107,
0.07017068564891815,
0.37060555815696716,
-0.35808706283569336,
0.21618276834487915,
0.945889413356781,
0.3169495761394501,
0.024720022454857826,
-0.033249787986278534,
0.2482629120349884,
0.2796337604522705,
-0.41578108072280884,
-0.1839587390422821,
0.722055196762085,
0.24633733928203583,
0.39076268672943115,
0.18376395106315613,
0.2130536288022995,
0.2432580292224884,
-0.3018081784248352,
-1.1937143802642822,
0.8487918376922607,
-0.011982228606939316,
-0.42729848623275757,
-0.16494682431221008,
0.02877797931432724,
-1.1230210065841675,
-0.2501369118690491,
-0.26931431889533997,
-0.7288669943809509,
0.7832450866699219,
0.27193447947502136,
-0.9344725012779236,
-0.32626721262931824,
-0.8186231255531311,
0.9530413150787354,
-0.7583279013633728,
-0.5654468536376953,
-0.07446402311325073,
-0.2988457679748535,
-0.18027767539024353,
0.17410220205783844,
0.05459095537662506,
-0.2533804774284363,
0.08465944230556488,
0.9284707307815552,
-0.14958219230175018,
0.5169296860694885,
-0.3955216407775879,
-0.09069333225488663,
0.38481849431991577,
0.11617612838745117,
0.5836506485939026,
0.0978149026632309,
0.3932984471321106,
-0.08446618914604187,
0.02994970604777336,
-0.263264536857605,
-0.8164102435112,
0.35148996114730835,
-0.561402440071106,
-0.7062170505523682,
-0.29443252086639404,
0.0010719145648181438,
-0.7148051261901855,
0.062729112803936,
-0.12996350228786469,
0.24907222390174866,
-0.022240236401557922,
0.22717097401618958,
0.7611403465270996,
-0.15339861810207367,
0.13182084262371063,
0.7357226610183716,
-0.20345033705234528,
0.03658146411180496,
1.059592366218567,
0.09138230979442596,
-0.17068886756896973,
0.23126468062400818,
0.5921027660369873,
-0.5780360698699951,
-0.6779106259346008,
-0.3456038534641266,
0.021443752571940422,
-0.32961079478263855,
0.045405760407447815,
-0.7567166090011597,
0.21620748937129974,
-0.37152621150016785,
0.07052800059318542,
-0.1445314586162567,
-0.11515649408102036,
-0.704223096370697,
-0.1243685781955719,
0.3114878535270691,
0.5232862830162048,
0.5186644792556763,
0.34416043758392334,
-0.8204514384269714,
0.5451602339744568,
1.0063766241073608,
0.21078196167945862,
-0.1400434523820877,
-0.2322254329919815,
-0.19374924898147583,
-0.03257228434085846,
-0.22828689217567444,
-1.0590569972991943,
0.318757563829422,
0.2545000910758972,
1.0139142274856567,
1.0105645656585693,
0.2422274500131607,
0.9217987656593323,
-0.056555576622486115,
1.275081753730774,
-0.2346329241991043,
-0.5976840257644653,
0.5776694416999817,
-0.24883969128131866,
0.0031990990974009037,
0.4952310621738434,
0.7498795390129089,
-0.34942176938056946,
-0.06096163019537926,
-0.7100049257278442,
-1.1763144731521606,
0.5781770348548889,
0.11312296241521835,
0.038942642509937286,
0.0019967276602983475,
0.030382845550775528,
0.11230067163705826,
0.2100405991077423,
-0.1427983045578003,
-0.05094815790653229,
-0.15084615349769592,
-0.08045335859060287,
-0.038007933646440506,
-0.34349778294563293,
0.0927647054195404,
-0.12210897356271744,
0.706056535243988,
-0.18213418126106262,
0.29066002368927,
0.24159039556980133,
0.11220768839120865,
0.008929911069571972,
0.29389044642448425,
0.5050595998764038,
0.5645840167999268,
-0.3993569016456604,
-0.4111401438713074,
-0.2446936070919037,
-0.4243103265762329,
-0.14203967154026031,
-0.00016872785636223853,
-0.17172421514987946,
-0.03704143688082695,
-0.09688873589038849,
0.3924148380756378,
0.2922537624835968,
-0.9951467514038086,
0.7088764905929565,
-0.39932456612586975,
0.0100685590878129,
-0.7220509648323059,
0.1710001677274704,
-0.12311527132987976,
0.37207168340682983,
0.64275062084198,
0.1017630472779274,
0.7718452215194702,
-0.7049759030342102,
0.20762072503566742,
0.41381487250328064,
-0.42775464057922363,
-0.3241240084171295,
0.24510458111763,
0.36729803681373596,
-0.6693578958511353,
0.49131399393081665,
-0.19581474363803864,
-0.7067451477050781,
0.4702185392379761,
0.3032046854496002,
1.2521193027496338,
-0.4830465018749237,
0.31100329756736755,
0.24995669722557068,
-0.050671353936195374,
-0.047444868832826614,
0.6193901896476746,
-0.5353578329086304,
-0.7725771069526672,
-0.03001752868294716,
-0.4097025394439697,
-0.4144846498966217,
0.029754431918263435,
-0.9613785147666931,
0.37077680230140686,
-0.17960406839847565,
-0.4194972515106201,
0.05400509759783745,
0.10703632235527039,
-0.5820189118385315,
0.4445265531539917,
-0.17389148473739624,
0.3115149140357971,
-0.8963980078697205,
0.3751320540904999,
0.5290526747703552,
-0.4700387120246887,
-0.9533472061157227,
0.32067906856536865,
-0.11652056127786636,
-0.6463027000427246,
0.2818596065044403,
-0.11451239138841629,
-0.3694991171360016,
-0.29930177330970764,
-0.08607032150030136,
-0.5075572729110718,
1.0965865850448608,
-0.00812919344753027,
-0.691497266292572,
0.1491859257221222,
-0.03884463012218475,
0.48562371730804443,
-0.34783369302749634,
0.7071697115898132,
0.4433484971523285,
0.39867016673088074,
0.1479867696762085,
-0.7259643077850342,
-0.11065641790628433,
-0.441319078207016,
-0.42869502305984497,
-0.03253107890486717,
-0.4604737460613251,
0.5891528725624084,
0.12956596910953522,
-0.17621253430843353,
0.04469318315386772,
0.26089394092559814,
0.4280323088169098,
1.059842824935913,
0.9402024745941162,
0.2692412734031677,
0.6330257058143616,
0.10609989613294601,
0.7548553943634033,
-0.01283908449113369,
0.009902137331664562,
1.119388461112976,
-0.27794450521469116,
1.2832201719284058,
0.3052683174610138,
-0.45169809460639954,
0.5345060229301453,
0.8815453052520752,
0.06990750879049301,
0.43106234073638916,
-0.21995028853416443,
-0.28550413250923157,
-0.49756354093551636,
-0.2605646848678589,
-0.3808036148548126,
0.4473583698272705,
0.323049932718277,
-0.3216885030269623,
0.41658279299736023,
-0.12708397209644318,
-0.22751984000205994,
-0.2554040551185608,
-0.1665315181016922,
1.4232512712478638,
-0.4460641145706177,
-0.685799241065979,
0.2713578939437866,
-0.5080617070198059,
0.31832295656204224,
-0.7355678081512451,
-0.06407293677330017,
-0.2023140788078308,
0.07449501752853394,
-0.387670636177063,
-0.5837405323982239,
0.04826008528470993,
-0.18434129655361176,
-0.20286770164966583,
-0.17507518827915192,
0.626632571220398,
-0.24542680382728577,
-0.5675370693206787,
0.05752415210008621,
0.5341399908065796,
0.2094433605670929,
-0.46410003304481506,
-0.9911273121833801,
-0.2791471481323242,
-0.0030253310687839985,
-0.39244571328163147,
0.17550283670425415,
0.18109993636608124,
-0.08750052750110626,
0.5646219253540039,
0.9147825837135315,
-0.12911218404769897,
0.07864179462194443,
0.11878213286399841,
0.45501941442489624,
-0.3332257866859436,
-0.7794381380081177,
-0.2392808347940445,
0.5903729200363159,
-0.26391613483428955,
-0.3636370003223419,
0.9846521615982056,
0.5863370895385742,
0.8775311708450317,
-0.06865067780017853,
0.32048672437667847,
0.4168260395526886,
0.6179161667823792,
-0.28870856761932373,
0.528952956199646,
-0.7471118569374084,
0.5218051075935364,
-0.1484711915254593,
-0.8944506645202637,
0.06068769469857216,
0.567354142665863,
-0.3460776209831238,
0.2217147797346115,
0.3407430052757263,
0.9318900108337402,
-0.24306955933570862,
0.3012887239456177,
0.12550950050354004,
0.05738355219364166,
0.21373382210731506,
0.15241572260856628,
0.9968345761299133,
-0.2301374077796936,
0.6857839822769165,
-0.19259317219257355,
-0.18508882820606232,
-0.6822429299354553,
-0.637809693813324,
-0.38466691970825195,
-0.521662175655365,
-0.6445399522781372,
0.02967018261551857,
-0.0622912272810936,
1.0089983940124512,
0.9982495903968811,
-0.9181787371635437,
-0.11428152769804001,
-0.035186782479286194,
0.01122787781059742,
-1.000596046447754,
-0.31550005078315735,
0.22452306747436523,
0.08127675205469131,
-0.7070165872573853,
0.758880615234375,
0.3168809711933136,
0.07629305124282837,
-0.254728764295578,
-0.014303469099104404,
-0.15372630953788757,
0.4913571774959564,
0.5835582613945007,
0.3020741045475006,
-0.8808150291442871,
-0.000677597476169467,
0.594532310962677,
0.7045872807502747,
-0.16262346506118774,
1.1139109134674072,
-0.8688424229621887,
0.6691504120826721,
0.6511566042900085,
0.4513922929763794,
0.4003238379955292,
0.1852734088897705,
0.6171896457672119,
-0.5125532746315002,
-0.2743294835090637,
0.5645582675933838,
0.0739293321967125,
-0.24141068756580353,
-0.5436851382255554,
0.11867345869541168,
-0.019033415243029594,
-0.6335621476173401,
-0.6546841263771057,
0.28641894459724426,
-1.3143471479415894,
-0.24409690499305725,
1.0200289487838745,
-0.31949353218078613,
-0.05377694591879845,
-0.5560241341590881,
-0.6666118502616882,
-0.11443120241165161,
-0.5038384795188904,
0.984322190284729,
0.31808167695999146,
-0.4685121178627014,
-0.2573947310447693,
-0.19487802684307098,
0.359358549118042,
0.5541504621505737,
-0.5619087815284729,
-0.1708212047815323,
0.3126828074455261,
-0.009939628653228283,
0.20289397239685059,
0.6572651863098145,
0.1974612921476364,
0.6035606265068054,
-0.32718732953071594,
-0.5721351504325867,
-0.0070932055823504925,
-0.4038229286670685,
0.08730316162109375,
0.5276449918746948,
0.1568814069032669,
-0.38044533133506775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08686v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08686v1
|
Extractive text summarisation of Privacy Policy documents using machine learning approaches
| 2024-04-09T04:54:08 | 2024-04-09T04:54:08 |
Chanwoo Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This work demonstrates two Privacy Policy (PP) summarisation models based on
two different clustering algorithms: K-means clustering and Pre-determined
Centroid (PDC) clustering. K-means is decided to be used for the first model
after an extensive evaluation of ten commonly used clustering algorithms. The
summariser model based on the PDC-clustering algorithm summarises PP documents
by segregating individual sentences by Euclidean distance from each sentence to
the pre-defined cluster centres. The cluster centres are defined according to
General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)'s 14 essential topics that must be
included in any privacy notices. The PDC model outperformed the K-means model
for two evaluation methods, Sum of Squared Distance (SSD) and ROUGE by some
margin (27% and 24% respectively). This result contrasts the K-means model's
better performance in the general clustering of sentence vectors before running
the task-specific evaluation. This indicates the effectiveness of operating
task-specific fine-tuning measures on unsupervised machine-learning models. The
summarisation mechanisms implemented in this paper demonstrates an idea of how
to efficiently extract essential sentences that should be included in any PP
documents. The summariser models could be further developed to an application
that tests the GDPR-compliance (or any data privacy legislation) of PP
documents.
|
[
-0.30841004848480225,
-0.6447163820266724,
0.5119151473045349,
0.03012571670114994,
-0.38448044657707214,
-0.018185371533036232,
-0.15070004761219025,
-0.020726285874843597,
-0.015365773811936378,
0.6865900158882141,
-0.3549223840236664,
-0.7183581590652466,
-0.7393175363540649,
0.06944640725851059,
-0.560417890548706,
1.2912596464157104,
0.2381351888179779,
-0.03900468721985817,
-0.20549361407756805,
0.13073857128620148,
0.024283820763230324,
-0.5895903706550598,
-0.007672212086617947,
-0.1667213886976242,
0.4279524087905884,
0.3997865915298462,
0.5156006217002869,
0.676664412021637,
0.6009711623191833,
0.3019235134124756,
-0.43042343854904175,
0.027943488210439682,
-0.32001030445098877,
-0.3645699620246887,
-0.16859830915927887,
-0.313693642616272,
-0.4084571897983551,
0.1974644958972931,
0.6117188930511475,
0.4720393717288971,
-0.11258479207754135,
-0.09736193716526031,
0.40102413296699524,
0.8796610832214355,
-0.7730178833007812,
0.29113343358039856,
-0.40561673045158386,
0.036541517823934555,
0.2617569863796234,
-0.16840095818042755,
-0.3171839118003845,
-0.5419601202011108,
0.37404391169548035,
-0.22961880266666412,
0.3639914393424988,
-0.22499138116836548,
0.8123635053634644,
0.019958140328526497,
-0.4200284779071808,
-0.5152376294136047,
-0.4422151744365692,
0.7698213458061218,
-0.6363208889961243,
0.1170484721660614,
0.4665051996707916,
0.21935416758060455,
0.054426856338977814,
-0.6523978114128113,
-0.4887974262237549,
-0.16302034258842468,
-0.49194037914276123,
0.17908519506454468,
-0.16430726647377014,
0.018935594707727432,
0.0996367484331131,
0.448390930891037,
-0.555488109588623,
0.39221441745758057,
-0.750902533531189,
-0.16691555082798004,
0.7313188910484314,
0.07823440432548523,
-0.25805431604385376,
-0.2706175446510315,
0.1012093722820282,
-0.09500090777873993,
-0.5198556780815125,
0.18148118257522583,
0.7122315764427185,
0.21630585193634033,
-0.43019741773605347,
0.6011896133422852,
-0.4526089131832123,
0.4896388053894043,
0.19187559187412262,
-0.4202633798122406,
0.18268539011478424,
-0.2849182188510895,
-0.08004845678806305,
0.14189660549163818,
0.9085875153541565,
0.7468402981758118,
0.14951668679714203,
-0.3301619589328766,
0.18367129564285278,
-0.09528959542512894,
0.26455506682395935,
-0.8079833388328552,
-0.4789424538612366,
0.3384898602962494,
-0.9356662631034851,
-0.6803932785987854,
0.4666752219200134,
-1.0721524953842163,
-0.3762704133987427,
-0.4823494255542755,
0.06953082978725433,
-0.07173731178045273,
-0.05003473535180092,
-0.27009105682373047,
-0.36508768796920776,
0.2737921476364136,
0.055912911891937256,
-0.9092986583709717,
0.5166687965393066,
1.0108304023742676,
0.7728990316390991,
-0.5767331719398499,
-0.33349043130874634,
-0.12863507866859436,
0.13313250243663788,
-0.03728625923395157,
0.59515380859375,
-0.46912747621536255,
-0.7598565816879272,
0.009624884463846684,
0.4816323220729828,
0.008034121245145798,
-0.37133780121803284,
0.5594212412834167,
-0.35188740491867065,
0.8444405794143677,
-0.12187067419290543,
-0.5234302878379822,
-0.4113045334815979,
0.1539413332939148,
-0.4876152575016022,
0.6114814877510071,
0.30112892389297485,
-0.9726758599281311,
0.4493677020072937,
-0.9264580607414246,
-0.6469161510467529,
-0.1710672676563263,
-0.06274060159921646,
-0.9174123406410217,
-0.02438754215836525,
0.27163249254226685,
0.7798682451248169,
-0.009849821217358112,
0.21996435523033142,
-0.22606512904167175,
-0.14261291921138763,
0.4064936637878418,
-0.16807176172733307,
0.9511281847953796,
0.31895431876182556,
-0.3089822828769684,
0.38871240615844727,
-0.7269713282585144,
-0.24095448851585388,
-0.0146603649482131,
-0.19786086678504944,
-0.07333119958639145,
0.021248305216431618,
0.04027503728866577,
0.06524597108364105,
0.5527187585830688,
-0.38467535376548767,
-0.38951200246810913,
-0.27659547328948975,
0.5718342065811157,
0.663115382194519,
0.2916915714740753,
0.6910132169723511,
-0.49224016070365906,
0.45237958431243896,
0.07947662472724915,
0.25575581192970276,
-0.38431069254875183,
-0.3723314702510834,
-0.184150829911232,
-0.29040706157684326,
0.4513563811779022,
0.7995014786720276,
-0.03173639252781868,
0.8908746838569641,
-0.28105857968330383,
-0.5604950189590454,
-0.3567376434803009,
-0.08649710565805435,
0.38024675846099854,
0.5935313701629639,
-0.05167311802506447,
-0.12480447441339493,
-0.24381539225578308,
-1.0067425966262817,
-0.3267194330692291,
0.024894535541534424,
-0.1653524786233902,
0.47518283128738403,
0.6534027457237244,
0.046374354511499405,
0.9769272804260254,
-0.6637465357780457,
-0.22350730001926422,
-0.430380254983902,
0.20112791657447815,
0.29432493448257446,
0.5073379874229431,
0.349178284406662,
-1.2410304546356201,
-0.7458157539367676,
0.03094211407005787,
-0.6190947890281677,
0.02596651017665863,
0.07029112428426743,
0.3206298351287842,
0.2223786860704422,
0.1472906470298767,
-0.32706350088119507,
0.7062177658081055,
0.21799255907535553,
-0.1922256201505661,
0.6083453893661499,
-0.6374143958091736,
0.27961254119873047,
-1.0450407266616821,
0.09017616510391235,
0.057262420654296875,
-0.5321662425994873,
-0.6103945374488831,
0.1304038166999817,
0.14147095382213593,
-0.3414785861968994,
-0.4782087504863739,
-0.015529388561844826,
-0.2829100787639618,
-0.1406879425048828,
-0.492287278175354,
0.2842194139957428,
-0.01527771633118391,
0.5361430644989014,
-0.07565861940383911,
0.6827730536460876,
0.6084567308425903,
-0.9380728602409363,
0.029924118891358376,
0.10364332795143127,
-0.1671406626701355,
0.4915432333946228,
-0.5393373370170593,
0.06645838916301727,
-0.32681041955947876,
-0.03153447061777115,
-0.7380748987197876,
-0.41433873772621155,
0.30111241340637207,
-0.4990478456020355,
0.2171119600534439,
0.04942992702126503,
-0.6123303771018982,
-0.4454185366630554,
-0.6175200343132019,
-0.24481214582920074,
0.7716821432113647,
-0.4098099172115326,
0.7162674069404602,
1.0687021017074585,
-0.43649590015411377,
-0.2834078073501587,
-0.5098782181739807,
0.024408170953392982,
-0.7493975758552551,
-0.18600402772426605,
0.42256468534469604,
0.27503204345703125,
-0.11443717032670975,
0.15081247687339783,
0.2014438807964325,
-0.31027868390083313,
0.23484571278095245,
0.5164480209350586,
0.10105898231267929,
0.2836901843547821,
-0.46680665016174316,
0.14850464463233948,
-0.2670217752456665,
0.1292739361524582,
0.027864450588822365,
0.5252246260643005,
-0.12243377417325974,
0.08362351357936859,
-0.8608293533325195,
0.6887862086296082,
0.4093710482120514,
-0.10577502101659775,
0.6588014364242554,
0.45323339104652405,
-0.2590424716472626,
0.27510616183280945,
-0.40009281039237976,
-0.16084593534469604,
-0.4112266004085541,
0.06574048846960068,
-0.173367440700531,
-1.027977705001831,
0.5503730177879333,
-0.22768306732177734,
0.1561029702425003,
0.5524209141731262,
0.6244351863861084,
-0.11899304389953613,
0.8555539846420288,
1.1296253204345703,
-0.4891102612018585,
0.4098087549209595,
-0.16726084053516388,
0.3630967438220978,
-0.5124241709709167,
-0.25178149342536926,
-0.7527613043785095,
0.008386213332414627,
-1.0246833562850952,
0.09275929629802704,
0.4655342102050781,
0.1556638479232788,
0.3089820146560669,
0.4308227002620697,
-0.6543087363243103,
0.6455441117286682,
0.581947386264801,
0.3219181299209595,
0.08249394595623016,
0.1866942048072815,
0.08536068350076675,
0.08783864974975586,
-0.44618189334869385,
-0.729810893535614,
1.3585398197174072,
0.24603892862796783,
0.2527502179145813,
-0.008493784815073013,
0.6418613791465759,
0.5025331974029541,
0.09955774992704391,
-0.29163238406181335,
0.5836138725280762,
-0.4840039610862732,
-0.20444856584072113,
-0.265194833278656,
-0.5185434818267822,
-0.9197560548782349,
0.3308067321777344,
0.019402513280510902,
-1.0904330015182495,
0.19970734417438507,
-0.04397387057542801,
-0.20416153967380524,
0.06630335748195648,
-0.5923930406570435,
0.7401645183563232,
0.06399160623550415,
-0.11434425413608551,
-0.6127079129219055,
-0.7728511691093445,
0.3030821681022644,
-0.11981763690710068,
0.1736954301595688,
0.09111697226762772,
0.12889215350151062,
0.9113183617591858,
-0.39387255907058716,
0.7328177690505981,
-0.26471012830734253,
0.09546283632516861,
0.3666817545890808,
-0.46409016847610474,
0.47232532501220703,
-0.42369312047958374,
0.14955584704875946,
0.08018667995929718,
0.17889250814914703,
-0.2599787414073944,
-0.3423958718776703,
0.5820757746696472,
-0.4982600212097168,
-0.22556713223457336,
-0.2594206631183624,
-0.5600831508636475,
0.10187312215566635,
0.41980883479118347,
0.3452220857143402,
0.1529141366481781,
-0.34666526317596436,
0.40431007742881775,
0.5942508578300476,
-0.20761117339134216,
0.572084903717041,
0.6940900683403015,
-0.16496238112449646,
-0.5063398480415344,
0.8233093619346619,
0.21160101890563965,
-0.22776247560977936,
0.5511477589607239,
0.5143367648124695,
-0.5636669397354126,
-0.42090651392936707,
0.07204130291938782,
0.1461486965417862,
-0.5588671565055847,
0.09841456264257431,
-0.9781302809715271,
-0.2275148630142212,
-0.9826529622077942,
-0.2010813057422638,
0.37923356890678406,
-0.6099377274513245,
-0.3385362923145294,
-0.17834293842315674,
0.17596803605556488,
0.5066439509391785,
-0.32516950368881226,
0.902009904384613,
-0.6142588257789612,
0.5816708207130432,
0.03435193747282028,
-0.061837635934352875,
-0.24992501735687256,
-0.3068405091762543,
-0.0628366470336914,
-0.17307402193546295,
-0.4700623154640198,
-0.961554229259491,
0.4150170087814331,
0.04812496528029442,
0.30619490146636963,
0.6544305682182312,
-0.07199742645025253,
0.2985925078392029,
-0.44046247005462646,
0.8340687155723572,
0.16449089348316193,
-0.5115693211555481,
0.48875802755355835,
-0.4514329731464386,
0.07286641746759415,
0.6806097030639648,
0.4669095575809479,
-0.1207253560423851,
-0.22882860898971558,
-0.8299415707588196,
-0.6446951627731323,
0.47708746790885925,
0.0946764349937439,
-0.08963245898485184,
0.13999292254447937,
0.3351175785064697,
0.17530091106891632,
0.5016342997550964,
-0.5362975001335144,
-0.010371600277721882,
0.1761171966791153,
-0.2920299470424652,
-0.10640385746955872,
-0.41836848855018616,
-0.054365504533052444,
-0.004439602605998516,
0.7839977145195007,
0.07965611666440964,
0.006004282273352146,
-0.02602161467075348,
-0.025109874084591866,
0.3281244933605194,
0.4908178150653839,
0.35991743206977844,
0.8681398034095764,
-0.18413951992988586,
-0.2640356719493866,
-0.02840110845863819,
-0.37133124470710754,
-0.1850186288356781,
0.38574841618537903,
-0.6984301805496216,
0.20559148490428925,
-0.23180145025253296,
0.25530490279197693,
0.07471808791160583,
-0.5333454608917236,
0.7702506184577942,
-0.1522214114665985,
-0.4111211597919464,
-0.3435293436050415,
0.08075819164514542,
-0.2609989643096924,
-0.08207996189594269,
0.1237756609916687,
-0.3318851590156555,
0.501032829284668,
-0.3938972055912018,
0.3870200216770172,
0.3269246220588684,
-0.30144885182380676,
-0.09522157162427902,
0.5491352677345276,
-0.23944410681724548,
-0.43596845865249634,
0.1845775991678238,
-0.34786146879196167,
-0.6311725974082947,
0.5554786324501038,
0.31655359268188477,
0.8757856488227844,
-0.2916816771030426,
0.46307075023651123,
0.05736876279115677,
0.16135327517986298,
-0.08099456131458282,
0.36332350969314575,
-0.4631785452365875,
-0.10379154235124588,
-0.10018115490674973,
-0.2702135145664215,
-0.5031086802482605,
-0.022749489173293114,
-0.9613786339759827,
-0.014139576815068722,
-0.4287159740924835,
-0.02550446428358555,
0.024289313703775406,
0.20896656811237335,
-0.42177271842956543,
0.024738257750868797,
-0.30174344778060913,
0.604322612285614,
-0.8260626196861267,
0.5069959759712219,
0.1103563904762268,
-0.06437814235687256,
-0.4620116651058197,
-0.14484550058841705,
0.08985200524330139,
-0.300324410200119,
-0.10527625679969788,
0.3984925150871277,
0.24014420807361603,
-0.29135575890541077,
-0.388884574174881,
-0.27327436208724976,
0.9621416330337524,
-0.0748579204082489,
-0.6146211624145508,
-0.045710157603025436,
0.4447616934776306,
0.45850682258605957,
-0.37574827671051025,
-0.3701002299785614,
0.8314898014068604,
0.36084863543510437,
-0.22912628948688507,
-0.7632770538330078,
-0.160243421792984,
-0.035184651613235474,
-0.19676658511161804,
0.11080873757600784,
-0.3838322162628174,
0.7778859734535217,
-0.005429185926914215,
-0.18852736055850983,
0.1451062560081482,
0.7450546026229858,
0.15041348338127136,
0.5861887335777283,
0.36069536209106445,
0.6434645652770996,
1.0293036699295044,
0.02496642991900444,
1.2687687873840332,
-0.5461795926094055,
0.22638294100761414,
1.3223114013671875,
-0.3220743238925934,
0.6567885279655457,
0.17974887788295746,
-0.23379889130592346,
0.24233202636241913,
0.5101959705352783,
-0.2579614818096161,
0.8667590022087097,
0.11153139919042587,
-0.26265254616737366,
0.539768636226654,
-0.1543152928352356,
-0.07401426136493683,
0.3637988567352295,
0.257455438375473,
-0.6396342515945435,
-0.40826812386512756,
-0.010355872102081776,
0.2076374590396881,
0.3390076160430908,
-0.651962399482727,
1.2573745250701904,
-0.01418470498174429,
-0.8039991855621338,
-0.2652041018009186,
0.5132615566253662,
0.48113352060317993,
-0.39721715450286865,
0.22097717225551605,
0.17183853685855865,
0.27414676547050476,
-0.22421352565288544,
-0.7125621438026428,
0.5207937955856323,
0.3790903687477112,
-0.30667248368263245,
-0.383766770362854,
0.7899615168571472,
-0.35510727763175964,
-0.6475868225097656,
-0.2339196503162384,
0.1370454579591751,
0.5428400039672852,
-0.1777651160955429,
-0.8776909112930298,
-0.5119556188583374,
0.02255725860595703,
0.275709331035614,
0.48196232318878174,
0.40924695134162903,
0.08249619603157043,
0.14520145952701569,
0.7048592567443848,
0.21492299437522888,
0.004098948556929827,
0.012148067355155945,
0.8430938720703125,
-0.3573298454284668,
-1.3916525840759277,
-1.1036256551742554,
0.3937385678291321,
-0.5052242875099182,
-0.1317293792963028,
0.8474956750869751,
0.9355280995368958,
0.4798542261123657,
0.1382000744342804,
0.8052156567573547,
0.029170555993914604,
1.0086339712142944,
-0.5832225680351257,
0.8276180028915405,
0.0741083100438118,
-0.0749872624874115,
-0.1851150542497635,
-0.8741261959075928,
-0.12278614938259125,
0.5535205006599426,
-0.5016090869903564,
-0.2955429255962372,
0.5730896592140198,
0.9120028018951416,
0.12455985695123672,
0.2243683636188507,
0.04956095665693283,
0.027775941416621208,
0.370779424905777,
0.13314326107501984,
0.34647491574287415,
-0.363803893327713,
0.23148047924041748,
-0.7057458162307739,
-0.3565254211425781,
0.003942857496440411,
-0.9572342038154602,
-1.0596790313720703,
-0.5839812755584717,
-0.4826405942440033,
-0.2959534823894501,
-0.04702456668019295,
0.33500880002975464,
0.7029082775115967,
-0.8425460457801819,
-0.14446184039115906,
-0.17120151221752167,
0.19095999002456665,
-0.09674451500177383,
-0.3057512938976288,
0.7699514627456665,
-0.02082253061234951,
-0.3557104170322418,
0.1726020872592926,
0.47194382548332214,
0.1968914270401001,
-0.2239682525396347,
0.1482890248298645,
0.06834578514099121,
-0.28939348459243774,
0.42503437399864197,
0.19431056082248688,
-0.4056113362312317,
0.2571599781513214,
-0.4485775828361511,
0.12009438872337341,
0.10691895335912704,
0.981330931186676,
-0.5976941585540771,
-0.08056497573852539,
0.34920361638069153,
0.5025612115859985,
0.6243146657943726,
0.4174152612686157,
0.23431396484375,
-0.4934200644493103,
0.28886643052101135,
-0.011625380255281925,
0.2551592290401459,
0.20135799050331116,
-0.6253005266189575,
0.34264761209487915,
-0.20197565853595734,
-0.5560897588729858,
-0.7276110053062439,
0.03242301940917969,
-0.8504735827445984,
-0.4562067687511444,
0.7867035865783691,
-0.38863861560821533,
-0.6942105889320374,
-0.044726788997650146,
-0.06031205132603645,
0.06619615107774734,
-0.3680884838104248,
1.0791432857513428,
0.43487390875816345,
0.0884999930858612,
-0.23948878049850464,
-0.14012035727500916,
0.28241705894470215,
-0.092136912047863,
-0.9109805226325989,
0.182514950633049,
0.4658070206642151,
0.2551548182964325,
0.205347940325737,
0.6443290114402771,
-0.6175490617752075,
0.3080744743347168,
-0.19184863567352295,
-0.5625693798065186,
-0.06682095676660538,
-0.5316649079322815,
-0.657867431640625,
0.6292646527290344,
-0.6472604274749756,
-0.23236232995986938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06004v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06004v1
|
AiSAQ: All-in-Storage ANNS with Product Quantization for DRAM-free Information Retrieval
| 2024-04-09T04:20:27 | 2024-04-09T04:20:27 |
Kento Tatsuno, Daisuke Miyashita, Taiga Ikeda, Kiyoshi Ishiyama, Kazunari Sumiyoshi, Jun Deguchi
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.DS
|
In approximate nearest neighbor search (ANNS) methods based on approximate
proximity graphs, DiskANN achieves good recall-speed balance for large-scale
datasets using both of RAM and storage. Despite it claims to save memory usage
by loading compressed vectors by product quantization (PQ), its memory usage
increases in proportion to the scale of datasets. In this paper, we propose
All-in-Storage ANNS with Product Quantization (AiSAQ), which offloads the
compressed vectors to storage. Our method achieves $\sim$10 MB memory usage in
query search even with billion-scale datasets with minor performance
degradation. AiSAQ also reduces the index load time before query search, which
enables the index switch between muitiple billion-scale datasets and
significantly enhances the flexibility of retrieval-augmented generation (RAG).
This method is applicable to all graph-based ANNS algorithms and can be
combined with higher-spec ANNS methods in the future.
|
[
-0.4524071514606476,
-0.5178688764572144,
0.18670083582401276,
-0.07342862337827682,
-0.3348028361797333,
-0.06442436575889587,
-0.026842547580599785,
-0.18364784121513367,
0.6337205767631531,
0.3574027717113495,
-0.04870956391096115,
-0.3315897285938263,
-0.15814712643623352,
0.12758105993270874,
-0.3479040265083313,
0.2966610789299011,
-0.14928892254829407,
-0.23569224774837494,
-0.4155135750770569,
-0.5744681358337402,
-0.3262116611003876,
-0.633720874786377,
-0.7172081470489502,
0.4588855504989624,
0.19570951163768768,
0.5362486839294434,
0.854109525680542,
1.014143705368042,
0.7671306729316711,
0.28845641016960144,
-0.1169656440615654,
0.3942502439022064,
-0.26834964752197266,
0.38932064175605774,
0.0730203315615654,
-0.650029718875885,
-0.22531890869140625,
-0.37019410729408264,
1.0125962495803833,
0.1184043288230896,
-0.3800370991230011,
0.4010920822620392,
-0.45647186040878296,
1.011350154876709,
-1.0849207639694214,
-0.19134379923343658,
-0.48724016547203064,
0.1331786811351776,
-0.3903236389160156,
-0.15324410796165466,
-0.21804457902908325,
-0.4177790880203247,
-0.20709781348705292,
-0.7304575443267822,
0.22673285007476807,
0.5220776200294495,
0.7640228271484375,
0.7321853041648865,
-0.526106595993042,
-0.0941300317645073,
-0.6169605851173401,
0.8273596167564392,
-0.42949575185775757,
0.40081217885017395,
0.8097417950630188,
0.5122467279434204,
-0.14754869043827057,
-0.7692798376083374,
-0.6078230738639832,
0.05994769558310509,
-0.007384574040770531,
0.048816800117492676,
-0.3287649154663086,
0.10418221354484558,
0.3454633951187134,
0.6720243096351624,
-0.7499960660934448,
-0.18963931500911713,
-0.3638682961463928,
0.030644629150629044,
0.6115368008613586,
0.2067658007144928,
0.1136380285024643,
-0.2923163175582886,
-0.4546493887901306,
-0.22765488922595978,
-0.732103705406189,
-0.2556540369987488,
-0.02530292607843876,
0.24905963242053986,
0.26161184906959534,
0.4460223913192749,
-0.49496015906333923,
0.6929930448532104,
-0.3293154239654541,
0.1204710453748703,
0.15277749300003052,
-0.4299272894859314,
-0.1197650134563446,
0.113279327750206,
0.7069795727729797,
0.30019739270210266,
-0.2011459320783615,
0.05811849609017372,
-0.31293341517448425,
-0.20946165919303894,
0.31168559193611145,
-1.1178138256072998,
-0.493005633354187,
-0.021803751587867737,
-0.9490267634391785,
0.15031135082244873,
0.05232623219490051,
-0.6990941166877747,
0.03431719169020653,
0.052669886499643326,
0.5287203192710876,
-0.3334200978279114,
-0.1532556116580963,
-0.26472753286361694,
0.014494511298835278,
-0.43619319796562195,
-0.26588040590286255,
-0.4663178026676178,
0.6523677110671997,
0.25165387988090515,
1.1946004629135132,
-0.14957545697689056,
0.2472003996372223,
-0.8352084159851074,
0.42385971546173096,
-0.40545904636383057,
0.6872611045837402,
-0.23350973427295685,
-0.46416622400283813,
-0.17219361662864685,
-0.44990068674087524,
0.1895098239183426,
-0.9846881628036499,
0.2410471886396408,
-0.7984820008277893,
-0.2354147583246231,
-0.6228587627410889,
-0.5110882520675659,
-0.3568933606147766,
0.11727923154830933,
-1.0636534690856934,
1.434436559677124,
0.018505271524190903,
-0.6236622929573059,
0.09522531926631927,
-0.5054773092269897,
-0.35154062509536743,
0.16252842545509338,
-0.2207278311252594,
-0.6369413733482361,
0.27196091413497925,
0.381393700838089,
0.054671045392751694,
-0.38340967893600464,
-0.04937634617090225,
-0.17871718108654022,
-0.9051318764686584,
0.13303199410438538,
-0.2674028277397156,
0.5102150440216064,
0.5248777270317078,
-0.009459578432142735,
-0.012580789625644684,
-0.48317840695381165,
0.10983257740736008,
0.3250812888145447,
0.027544917538762093,
-0.636459231376648,
-0.10530488938093185,
-0.594569742679596,
0.19909842312335968,
0.444466233253479,
-0.5089281797409058,
0.3252527415752411,
-0.1415206789970398,
0.33948078751564026,
0.5566859245300293,
0.24023093283176422,
0.4330029785633087,
-0.2894169092178345,
0.39989015460014343,
0.08170482516288757,
0.6960647702217102,
-0.06519582867622375,
-0.32546722888946533,
-0.8242173194885254,
-0.5722193717956543,
0.3790471851825714,
0.1983974277973175,
-0.8032904267311096,
0.21168331801891327,
-0.24988707900047302,
-0.1719130277633667,
-0.4429888427257538,
-0.048509977757930756,
0.260196715593338,
0.25211432576179504,
0.40257349610328674,
-0.4666084945201874,
-0.31594720482826233,
-1.1475893259048462,
0.23462419211864471,
-0.25904762744903564,
-0.10589599609375,
0.6301708221435547,
0.26162320375442505,
0.1909523904323578,
0.9508621692657471,
-0.7463526725769043,
-0.5845316052436829,
0.3327184021472931,
0.07171819359064102,
0.22510363161563873,
0.07997263967990875,
0.6804389953613281,
-1.1256285905838013,
-0.4555933475494385,
-0.6797808408737183,
-0.5386183857917786,
0.09027178585529327,
0.19462978839874268,
-0.38393813371658325,
0.23083262145519257,
0.4939374029636383,
-0.7952214479446411,
0.914219319820404,
0.051655810326337814,
-0.03310728445649147,
0.2190999835729599,
-0.5138830542564392,
0.407477468252182,
-0.936445951461792,
0.07065936923027039,
-0.2636577785015106,
-0.1682150661945343,
-0.1536773443222046,
0.029348362237215042,
0.3431999385356903,
0.03188042342662811,
-0.4952743649482727,
0.5099063515663147,
-0.37141358852386475,
-0.5954723358154297,
-0.21715141832828522,
0.18005679547786713,
0.20716527104377747,
0.10022804141044617,
-0.4166494607925415,
1.5753024816513062,
0.17622794210910797,
-1.064239263534546,
0.35718339681625366,
0.8002143502235413,
-0.11368083208799362,
0.4201090931892395,
-0.39362308382987976,
0.029332997277379036,
-0.3705488443374634,
0.429040789604187,
-0.9178584814071655,
0.25588834285736084,
-0.0247625894844532,
-0.3079325556755066,
0.3124176263809204,
0.048923466354608536,
-1.1205737590789795,
-0.6719023585319519,
-0.4679323732852936,
0.6225629448890686,
0.35457751154899597,
-0.9716549515724182,
0.5380833745002747,
0.3364405930042267,
0.07658669352531433,
-0.4859085977077484,
-0.6450925469398499,
0.08902059495449066,
-0.42395487427711487,
-0.284025639295578,
0.4830727279186249,
-0.2687522768974304,
-0.27396681904792786,
0.35209834575653076,
-0.32385653257369995,
-0.18327653408050537,
-0.11872086673974991,
-0.01723976992070675,
0.32868731021881104,
0.07372488081455231,
0.5161957144737244,
0.047316305339336395,
-0.3161478042602539,
-0.3650071620941162,
-0.35421881079673767,
0.39755144715309143,
-0.06862188130617142,
-0.1440829038619995,
-0.31458309292793274,
0.5660598874092102,
0.13593211770057678,
-0.30309081077575684,
0.7571330666542053,
0.2640943229198456,
-0.33888161182403564,
-0.11340776830911636,
-0.467086523771286,
-0.19952458143234253,
-0.5073089003562927,
0.3519338071346283,
-0.5393802523612976,
-0.7101392149925232,
0.5706859827041626,
-0.08232992887496948,
-0.1700136810541153,
0.4024896025657654,
0.18285150825977325,
-0.10091530531644821,
0.9192892909049988,
0.19519250094890594,
-0.05011160299181938,
0.4323941171169281,
-0.42276057600975037,
0.514020562171936,
-0.9073997735977173,
-0.013580413535237312,
-0.5814061164855957,
-0.6125480532646179,
-0.383902370929718,
-0.39158350229263306,
0.5518730282783508,
0.28399619460105896,
-0.8491775393486023,
0.39789482951164246,
-0.9977802634239197,
0.6034643054008484,
0.8372277617454529,
0.05528835579752922,
0.2599601447582245,
0.2753177583217621,
0.11736997216939926,
-0.1816752552986145,
-0.7773774266242981,
0.2653432786464691,
1.2239959239959717,
-0.18109193444252014,
0.4760424792766571,
0.2878447473049164,
0.7589428424835205,
0.24846120178699493,
-0.07174881547689438,
-0.6036295890808105,
0.6567193269729614,
-0.5846809148788452,
-0.4436553418636322,
-0.039133500307798386,
-0.9602895975112915,
-0.6030762195587158,
0.025956235826015472,
0.352734237909317,
-0.6135463118553162,
0.31873416900634766,
-0.09980081021785736,
-0.5730398297309875,
0.5774096846580505,
-0.39528223872184753,
0.16248303651809692,
-0.3009291887283325,
-0.10899768769741058,
-0.5130699872970581,
-0.5881281495094299,
0.12850961089134216,
0.10335130989551544,
0.028087452054023743,
-0.0795552134513855,
-0.27911192178726196,
1.0487916469573975,
-0.6321321129798889,
0.07196001708507538,
-0.2283075749874115,
0.32424256205558777,
0.5923340320587158,
0.41352972388267517,
0.5771129727363586,
-0.02151527628302574,
-0.11194057017564774,
0.3848223090171814,
0.04962210729718208,
-0.3631856441497803,
-0.800905704498291,
0.8631190657615662,
-0.5714147686958313,
-0.2873894274234772,
-0.45413482189178467,
-0.5226359367370605,
0.07206264138221741,
0.19777174293994904,
0.20526017248630524,
0.1569596379995346,
0.4359402358531952,
0.14094166457653046,
0.7780062556266785,
-0.20702725648880005,
0.519983172416687,
0.3327774703502655,
-0.09483257681131363,
-0.8180809617042542,
1.1233378648757935,
0.35598239302635193,
0.04613601043820381,
0.3349967896938324,
0.014360224828124046,
-0.5395264029502869,
-0.2893381118774414,
-0.3353799879550934,
0.20285139977931976,
-0.6002512574195862,
-1.0808559656143188,
-0.5658307075500488,
-0.16553495824337006,
0.051089074462652206,
0.005714579951018095,
-0.7760780453681946,
-0.8366445899009705,
-0.2047392576932907,
0.10891714692115784,
0.9962248206138611,
0.4395884871482849,
-0.4499574899673462,
0.5278080701828003,
-0.8450413942337036,
0.6399983763694763,
0.094512440264225,
0.5132588148117065,
0.3664979636669159,
-0.21454499661922455,
-0.43573087453842163,
0.11662514507770538,
-0.28431329131126404,
-0.5387407541275024,
0.2476612776517868,
0.47550609707832336,
0.22844859957695007,
0.4070473313331604,
0.4459497332572937,
0.8997469544410706,
0.011721420101821423,
0.6363627314567566,
-0.07876183092594147,
-0.5330665111541748,
0.2286720722913742,
-0.0022611673921346664,
0.014713378623127937,
0.9699383974075317,
0.40964454412460327,
-0.1528155356645584,
0.31022077798843384,
-0.3895176947116852,
-1.2987291812896729,
0.5811398029327393,
0.35052940249443054,
-0.1735682189464569,
-0.21470309793949127,
0.7553724050521851,
-0.24020566046237946,
0.4284193515777588,
0.066167451441288,
-0.6441303491592407,
0.005807983689010143,
-0.25592324137687683,
0.40106457471847534,
-0.44802579283714294,
0.06907525658607483,
-0.4076559245586395,
0.7431091070175171,
0.025736184790730476,
0.8590384721755981,
0.24370157718658447,
0.2207295447587967,
-0.14600488543510437,
-0.3238629400730133,
-0.18951959908008575,
0.2179410606622696,
-0.46449026465415955,
-0.0006376535748131573,
0.0899398997426033,
-0.5447916388511658,
0.12280461937189102,
0.09300178289413452,
-0.5782343745231628,
0.007291646208614111,
-0.5403009057044983,
0.6117657423019409,
0.09788389503955841,
-0.4521736800670624,
0.5108040571212769,
-0.4199781119823456,
-0.09283919632434845,
-0.47347965836524963,
-0.14678050577640533,
-0.3107869625091553,
0.31179678440093994,
0.5593940019607544,
-0.25418591499328613,
0.4265202581882477,
-0.15518826246261597,
0.685297429561615,
0.29263532161712646,
-0.06949173659086227,
0.28192955255508423,
0.8235076665878296,
-0.32710304856300354,
0.07447511702775955,
1.281477928161621,
-0.6646090745925903,
-0.31380513310432434,
0.5194234251976013,
0.5915212035179138,
0.8647469878196716,
-0.24672900140285492,
0.09250187873840332,
0.7366608381271362,
-0.041100651025772095,
-0.2869846820831299,
0.35575276613235474,
-0.4976193308830261,
-0.26019394397735596,
-0.40780067443847656,
-0.715908944606781,
-0.3495495617389679,
-0.16120733320713043,
-0.6930533051490784,
0.014617863111197948,
-0.39014703035354614,
-0.29312261939048767,
-0.5808740258216858,
0.31920334696769714,
-0.34042054414749146,
0.19221696257591248,
-0.32191023230552673,
0.9390566349029541,
-0.27975040674209595,
0.538947582244873,
0.28647586703300476,
-0.45943400263786316,
-0.4627140164375305,
0.021407410502433777,
-0.08892577886581421,
-0.47783541679382324,
0.5837516188621521,
0.11412721872329712,
0.4519886076450348,
-0.007888584397733212,
-0.336662620306015,
-1.4889299869537354,
1.2082668542861938,
-0.070342056453228,
-0.44684600830078125,
0.007735437713563442,
0.0315229669213295,
0.06497681140899658,
-0.06397183239459991,
0.4691714346408844,
0.4243181347846985,
0.42931997776031494,
0.40822288393974304,
-0.476712167263031,
0.1851710081100464,
-0.36453211307525635,
0.27281028032302856,
0.6305111646652222,
-0.9662885069847107,
0.8618550896644592,
0.1352100968360901,
-0.3614480793476105,
0.46431195735931396,
0.8881746530532837,
0.3788853585720062,
0.16774067282676697,
0.4878385066986084,
0.9602669477462769,
0.8075457811355591,
0.1382216513156891,
0.9787634015083313,
-0.2284538596868515,
0.10433647781610489,
0.9681932330131531,
-0.29202818870544434,
0.9969052076339722,
0.17110125720500946,
-0.24562999606132507,
0.054305549710989,
0.4796147048473358,
0.07625014334917068,
0.8062270879745483,
0.25617972016334534,
-0.5397794246673584,
-0.00013648667663801461,
-0.336966335773468,
-0.24090956151485443,
0.2906445562839508,
0.4914901554584503,
0.029374606907367706,
-0.3320014178752899,
0.0379735566675663,
-0.3217383623123169,
-0.15521903336048126,
-0.15832003951072693,
0.6880072355270386,
0.18636350333690643,
0.004452172201126814,
0.877083420753479,
-0.22277532517910004,
0.6427484154701233,
-0.44468024373054504,
-0.03909558430314064,
-0.1702069193124771,
0.13545899093151093,
-0.11436574161052704,
-0.5171881914138794,
0.5216202139854431,
-0.43640902638435364,
-0.12732559442520142,
0.20638373494148254,
0.5496460199356079,
-0.12972573935985565,
-0.25772321224212646,
0.13334329426288605,
0.08165951073169708,
0.26046010851860046,
-0.3326302766799927,
-0.5105835795402527,
0.07370755076408386,
-0.03403257578611374,
-0.2927587330341339,
0.6232402920722961,
0.17362171411514282,
-0.4849274158477783,
0.7441319823265076,
0.6714526414871216,
0.06591974943876266,
-0.026596514508128166,
-0.2634671926498413,
0.8392200469970703,
-0.7301045060157776,
-0.4973565340042114,
-0.17146188020706177,
-0.10042452067136765,
-0.20955823361873627,
-0.01777585968375206,
0.7190782427787781,
0.880966067314148,
0.454948753118515,
0.48167380690574646,
0.46048030257225037,
-0.0022786378394812346,
0.42483383417129517,
-0.21753796935081482,
0.6805821657180786,
-0.8313282132148743,
-0.1854085922241211,
0.2033223807811737,
-1.2340681552886963,
-0.42652609944343567,
0.8028651475906372,
0.12284096330404282,
0.07630724459886551,
0.6632545590400696,
0.6883252263069153,
-0.02624146081507206,
0.11582427471876144,
0.14214737713336945,
0.2528407573699951,
0.33678576350212097,
0.3366602659225464,
0.33577486872673035,
-0.8591731786727905,
0.5392656326293945,
-0.4236302971839905,
-0.28900501132011414,
-0.28998395800590515,
-0.5217727422714233,
-0.38898012042045593,
-0.7167911529541016,
-0.29076454043388367,
-0.1735604703426361,
0.0697660744190216,
0.6412155032157898,
0.6225069165229797,
-0.3940788209438324,
0.1545185148715973,
0.013451976701617241,
-0.295217901468277,
-0.12212588638067245,
-0.23008890450000763,
0.8965057134628296,
-0.007940862327814102,
-0.38256746530532837,
0.5758126974105835,
0.40710586309432983,
0.15792784094810486,
0.061856552958488464,
0.004684900864958763,
-0.14910876750946045,
0.054998595267534256,
0.35022810101509094,
0.4495061933994293,
-0.04088975116610527,
0.14410170912742615,
0.08982941508293152,
0.22151225805282593,
0.23059915006160736,
0.5145285129547119,
-1.0469894409179688,
0.4410116970539093,
0.501366138458252,
0.41223230957984924,
0.9220982789993286,
0.20347416400909424,
0.13969558477401733,
-0.8787869215011597,
0.6849963665008545,
0.2493090033531189,
0.14125019311904907,
0.2440166026353836,
-0.5920566320419312,
0.6145744323730469,
-0.20306791365146637,
-0.7976459860801697,
-0.7047102451324463,
0.15022149682044983,
-0.6641221642494202,
-0.07385380566120148,
0.7708589434623718,
0.1912289708852768,
-0.4474540948867798,
0.1337641328573227,
-0.013537032529711723,
0.31953585147857666,
-0.6086173057556152,
0.9690628051757812,
-0.0013990348670631647,
-0.24986448884010315,
0.03631263226270676,
-0.8506592512130737,
0.4695589244365692,
0.5013829469680786,
-0.24275115132331848,
0.025215789675712585,
0.40046489238739014,
-0.38696521520614624,
0.1485050469636917,
0.7673739790916443,
-0.3147994875907898,
0.1241978257894516,
0.0172464307397604,
0.005960459355264902,
-0.41866183280944824,
-0.3884190618991852,
0.0434274822473526,
-0.056998904794454575,
-0.23952406644821167,
-0.6574159860610962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06003v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06003v1
|
FreeEval: A Modular Framework for Trustworthy and Efficient Evaluation of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-09T04:17:51 | 2024-04-09T04:17:51 |
Zhuohao Yu, Chang Gao, Wenjin Yao, Yidong Wang, Zhengran Zeng, Wei Ye, Jindong Wang, Yue Zhang, Shikun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid development of large language model (LLM) evaluation methodologies
and datasets has led to a profound challenge: integrating state-of-the-art
evaluation techniques cost-effectively while ensuring reliability,
reproducibility, and efficiency. Currently, there is a notable absence of a
unified and adaptable framework that seamlessly integrates various evaluation
approaches. Moreover, the reliability of evaluation findings is often
questionable due to potential data contamination, with the evaluation
efficiency commonly overlooked when facing the substantial costs associated
with LLM inference. In response to these challenges, we introduce FreeEval, a
modular and scalable framework crafted to enable trustworthy and efficient
automatic evaluations of LLMs. Firstly, FreeEval's unified abstractions
simplify the integration and improve the transparency of diverse evaluation
methodologies, encompassing dynamic evaluation that demand sophisticated LLM
interactions. Secondly, the framework integrates meta-evaluation techniques
like human evaluation and data contamination detection, which, along with
dynamic evaluation modules in the platform, enhance the fairness of the
evaluation outcomes. Lastly, FreeEval is designed with a high-performance
infrastructure, including distributed computation and caching strategies,
enabling extensive evaluations across multi-node, multi-GPU clusters for
open-source and proprietary LLMs.
|
[
0.01307786162942648,
-0.6601611971855164,
0.5634315609931946,
0.44710126519203186,
-0.17559467256069183,
0.06035517901182175,
-0.5197908878326416,
-0.3006502687931061,
-0.05438590794801712,
0.27422890067100525,
-0.24731434881687164,
-0.6689620018005371,
-0.47021496295928955,
-0.26812097430229187,
-0.5083191990852356,
0.7750447988510132,
0.03338206559419632,
0.11489056795835495,
-0.49248576164245605,
-0.3791145384311676,
-0.09235088527202606,
-0.40119561553001404,
-0.4460219740867615,
-0.4527018070220947,
0.2784493863582611,
0.23614493012428284,
0.9389091730117798,
0.6763388514518738,
0.5390766859054565,
0.31610801815986633,
-0.04883633926510811,
0.006543525028973818,
-0.5042535662651062,
0.22870858013629913,
-0.4276593327522278,
-0.22483454644680023,
-0.763143002986908,
-0.18344615399837494,
0.7843974232673645,
0.4953846037387848,
-0.4215147793292999,
0.4335109293460846,
0.1758025586605072,
0.7601198554039001,
-0.8770832419395447,
0.35006481409072876,
-0.7046963572502136,
-0.13057450950145721,
-0.2636873126029968,
0.004547609947621822,
-0.5605366826057434,
-0.5738579034805298,
0.1373511254787445,
-0.4482845067977905,
-0.16827377676963806,
-0.0601639449596405,
0.35332486033439636,
0.20891694724559784,
-0.26127877831459045,
-0.16355471312999725,
-0.5775846838951111,
0.9276818633079529,
-0.6445307731628418,
0.5757911205291748,
0.29072538018226624,
0.6557321548461914,
-0.18173843622207642,
-0.6806262731552124,
-0.4226006865501404,
-0.45930781960487366,
0.1486855149269104,
-0.1665831059217453,
-0.3194286823272705,
0.08407947421073914,
-0.29214170575141907,
0.5626131892204285,
-0.6273223161697388,
0.2673676609992981,
0.04565532132983208,
-0.2787993252277374,
0.6242977976799011,
0.22440846264362335,
0.46249333024024963,
-0.23685169219970703,
-0.27623146772384644,
0.15700270235538483,
-0.9436820149421692,
-0.14556322991847992,
0.27298885583877563,
0.5030599236488342,
-0.14279696345329285,
0.43377113342285156,
-0.1718033254146576,
0.365161269903183,
-0.18617799878120422,
0.1417454332113266,
0.4588923752307892,
-0.250729501247406,
-0.4569501578807831,
-0.2661425471305847,
0.989719808101654,
0.2651229202747345,
0.25768157839775085,
-0.39160481095314026,
-0.31965550780296326,
-0.031761642545461655,
0.08182409405708313,
-0.9550883769989014,
-0.02315817028284073,
0.5218020081520081,
-0.6484493017196655,
-0.5463027954101562,
-0.12350534647703171,
-0.9672262668609619,
-0.3793662190437317,
-0.19501882791519165,
0.5221350789070129,
-0.18990746140480042,
-0.506320595741272,
0.08831534534692764,
0.36914584040641785,
0.07482446730136871,
0.3896942436695099,
-0.9494562149047852,
0.308694452047348,
0.9521042108535767,
0.8239513039588928,
-0.3646429181098938,
-0.15388508141040802,
-0.8483197093009949,
0.04988223314285278,
-0.3868367373943329,
0.630888044834137,
-0.7721168994903564,
-0.43950000405311584,
0.021375980228185654,
-0.008483217097818851,
-0.1343912035226822,
-0.5707024931907654,
0.6398937106132507,
-0.7162929773330688,
-0.08131030201911926,
0.09657574445009232,
-0.5632394552230835,
-0.048193592578172684,
0.10045132786035538,
-0.8848979473114014,
0.9592238664627075,
0.20994651317596436,
-0.8066409230232239,
0.15094813704490662,
-0.7458534836769104,
-0.14180950820446014,
0.45645833015441895,
-0.1863035410642624,
-0.1759367734193802,
0.2019789069890976,
0.26124584674835205,
0.22705423831939697,
-0.6447958946228027,
0.5140406489372253,
-0.4669344127178192,
-0.4414670467376709,
-0.06158875301480293,
-0.6027718186378479,
0.9706568121910095,
0.24022212624549866,
-0.5603126883506775,
0.6906803250312805,
-0.7769601345062256,
0.3045057952404022,
-0.24077831208705902,
-0.43538200855255127,
-0.3482517600059509,
0.24795353412628174,
0.08685329556465149,
-0.019839519634842873,
0.272864431142807,
-0.5737119913101196,
-0.006559914443641901,
-0.3256087899208069,
0.05949345603585243,
0.8331709504127502,
-0.2554006576538086,
0.48036935925483704,
-0.07170067727565765,
0.6059662103652954,
-0.1770080327987671,
0.3702530562877655,
-0.019246257841587067,
-0.27335453033447266,
-0.7278033494949341,
-0.48325115442276,
0.3265073299407959,
0.7136347889900208,
-0.6173473000526428,
0.49485835433006287,
-0.5804625749588013,
-0.7912960648536682,
-0.83637535572052,
0.21487857401371002,
0.6142799258232117,
0.35436728596687317,
0.37466850876808167,
-0.0896802768111229,
-0.439795583486557,
-1.0593315362930298,
-0.3355061411857605,
-0.2071986198425293,
-0.2981744110584259,
0.18376223742961884,
0.48693618178367615,
-0.5311828255653381,
0.8881560564041138,
0.07656033337116241,
0.035590965300798416,
-0.22221384942531586,
-0.01685059443116188,
0.16409477591514587,
0.5333213210105896,
0.3979710340499878,
-0.2240816205739975,
-0.27219411730766296,
0.17289035022258759,
-0.7552610039710999,
-0.17929764091968536,
0.2158210426568985,
-0.058069001883268356,
0.1403064876794815,
0.22877274453639984,
-0.4789228141307831,
0.1801947057247162,
0.7207669615745544,
-0.21766191720962524,
0.7192025184631348,
-0.20810481905937195,
0.24919788539409637,
-0.8092820644378662,
0.1645309180021286,
-0.35375121235847473,
-0.26885801553726196,
-0.4892856478691101,
0.4930739998817444,
0.2985556721687317,
0.07173826545476913,
-0.602486252784729,
0.7967910766601562,
-0.28485435247421265,
-0.13894884288311005,
0.13992339372634888,
0.31711965799331665,
-0.13881434500217438,
0.027923744171857834,
-0.2612195611000061,
0.9092897772789001,
0.5871714949607849,
-0.27879810333251953,
0.457461953163147,
0.02105577662587166,
-0.9346804618835449,
0.32505226135253906,
-0.7073414325714111,
0.2404482215642929,
0.0711401030421257,
0.1606171429157257,
-0.7649403214454651,
-0.10242339968681335,
-0.0244698915630579,
-0.11405583471059799,
0.12672138214111328,
-0.1564016044139862,
-0.6090100407600403,
-0.08522753417491913,
-0.46032774448394775,
0.4522855281829834,
0.2998204827308655,
-0.8049142360687256,
0.49072983860969543,
0.2638939321041107,
-0.13836164772510529,
-0.8281198740005493,
-0.7462535500526428,
0.10336721688508987,
0.012932230718433857,
-0.8347587585449219,
-0.13693246245384216,
-0.23638002574443817,
-0.6051297783851624,
-0.002918059006333351,
-0.0033164063934236765,
-0.11670276522636414,
0.2477150559425354,
0.25599735975265503,
0.31342893838882446,
-0.36664608120918274,
0.07397334277629852,
0.1784420758485794,
-0.237384632229805,
-0.20466750860214233,
-0.30456632375717163,
0.3309847414493561,
-0.6198644638061523,
-0.8212836980819702,
-0.5348876118659973,
0.276790589094162,
0.9456666707992554,
-0.2948751449584961,
0.5486553311347961,
0.1996157318353653,
-0.34774279594421387,
-0.3658943772315979,
-0.5688505172729492,
0.2691463828086853,
-0.4975668787956238,
0.42517101764678955,
-0.3214840888977051,
-1.1175732612609863,
0.4874235689640045,
0.1023237556219101,
0.1688438504934311,
0.5031790137290955,
0.9310978651046753,
0.5786026120185852,
0.7743851542472839,
0.4664416015148163,
-0.0633077323436737,
0.09170593321323395,
0.17661596834659576,
0.06569084525108337,
-0.6890106797218323,
-0.40065330266952515,
-0.4428696930408478,
-0.04901272431015968,
-0.298044353723526,
-0.9173856973648071,
0.09566077589988708,
0.08126740902662277,
-0.1099729984998703,
0.06297477334737778,
-0.24534718692302704,
0.7784768342971802,
0.014357030391693115,
-0.32154372334480286,
0.6883341670036316,
-0.0064795175567269325,
-0.5362871289253235,
-0.03877532109618187,
-0.33985424041748047,
-0.8293028473854065,
1.212973713874817,
0.4914032220840454,
0.7481677532196045,
0.24254655838012695,
0.48266807198524475,
0.42310765385627747,
0.8159770965576172,
-0.7610722184181213,
0.5890668630599976,
-0.22541870176792145,
-0.7207112312316895,
-0.15577895939350128,
-0.41400203108787537,
-0.7850552201271057,
0.6415809392929077,
-0.013995829969644547,
-0.9165952205657959,
0.10557925701141357,
-0.024431079626083374,
-0.2575381398200989,
0.5826406478881836,
-0.5464798808097839,
0.7238478064537048,
-0.39977532625198364,
-0.5441485047340393,
-0.5430609583854675,
-0.37412673234939575,
0.5901174545288086,
-0.17437078058719635,
0.4988977909088135,
-0.2098252773284912,
-0.11563526839017868,
0.5442126989364624,
-0.44160032272338867,
0.49142923951148987,
-0.22928577661514282,
-0.20312799513339996,
0.27949610352516174,
0.4392963647842407,
0.20905445516109467,
0.15981628000736237,
-0.6779698729515076,
0.32033395767211914,
0.1516270488500595,
-0.2743281126022339,
-0.5816525220870972,
1.013274908065796,
-0.7169020771980286,
-0.3430732190608978,
-0.16657553613185883,
-0.6423332691192627,
-0.32880932092666626,
0.19013509154319763,
-0.21091477572917938,
0.4646635353565216,
-0.47778332233428955,
0.43899884819984436,
0.4699496626853943,
-0.4623330235481262,
0.5081894993782043,
0.5749014616012573,
-0.6633638739585876,
-0.6337026357650757,
0.8850269317626953,
-0.23281048238277435,
0.31381756067276,
0.412427693605423,
0.2522023320198059,
-0.3165239095687866,
-0.6576194763183594,
-0.7049141526222229,
-0.05664712190628052,
-0.6751702427864075,
-0.1580878496170044,
-0.3424576222896576,
-0.07113341242074966,
-0.21096743643283844,
0.010703264735639095,
-0.5160236954689026,
-0.7029072642326355,
-0.05837617442011833,
-0.31066563725471497,
0.10940288752317429,
0.7918254733085632,
-0.02299482375383377,
0.20473840832710266,
-0.8902580738067627,
0.0016099673230201006,
0.22343051433563232,
0.7320970296859741,
0.41204118728637695,
-0.1994921714067459,
-0.16134051978588104,
-0.1022777408361435,
-0.07083640247583389,
-0.5496869087219238,
0.2134964019060135,
0.26382094621658325,
0.7697010636329651,
0.538489043712616,
-0.14273537695407867,
0.5425907373428345,
-0.546051561832428,
0.8155266046524048,
-0.0009364159195683897,
-1.1939218044281006,
0.2274571657180786,
-0.4752146005630493,
0.01809743233025074,
0.8209471106529236,
0.09191185981035233,
-0.5072059631347656,
-0.2560318112373352,
-0.35002008080482483,
-1.0212382078170776,
0.3178976774215698,
0.02690088003873825,
0.0014014261541888118,
-0.15567082166671753,
0.31116241216659546,
0.2736865282058716,
0.2855361998081207,
-0.6015296578407288,
0.06178058683872223,
-0.07454981654882431,
-0.22369691729545593,
0.11203498393297195,
-0.41331276297569275,
-0.08092053234577179,
-0.21445411443710327,
0.6018986105918884,
-0.05879220366477966,
0.03149375692009926,
-0.08268634974956512,
-0.5548534989356995,
-0.05642540007829666,
0.6841506361961365,
0.4250648021697998,
0.9144265055656433,
-0.2903020679950714,
0.07574228942394257,
0.24615757167339325,
-0.21999023854732513,
0.10667901486158371,
-0.0702546015381813,
-0.1728169023990631,
-0.07993786782026291,
0.5590987801551819,
0.59661865234375,
0.3851108253002167,
-0.8752908110618591,
0.7903686165809631,
-0.18466435372829437,
-0.07995260506868362,
-0.009007832035422325,
-0.1071108877658844,
0.3723129332065582,
0.2164711207151413,
0.3586447536945343,
-0.2615976333618164,
0.020188041031360626,
-0.31433388590812683,
0.524705171585083,
0.5081626176834106,
-0.4028227925300598,
-0.35550734400749207,
0.6220164895057678,
0.40312859416007996,
-0.21218740940093994,
0.6491668820381165,
-0.04727361351251602,
-0.3219861388206482,
0.2092089056968689,
0.4847496747970581,
1.2228590250015259,
-0.5807684659957886,
0.12704437971115112,
0.10682354867458344,
0.46333321928977966,
0.09964188188314438,
0.32153719663619995,
-0.06711424887180328,
-0.34607377648353577,
-0.6350297927856445,
-1.1417700052261353,
-0.5827538967132568,
0.06655500829219818,
-0.5032247304916382,
0.0673341229557991,
-0.5974225401878357,
0.2879527807235718,
-0.5312113165855408,
-0.0982084721326828,
-0.3843318521976471,
-0.041517674922943115,
0.053659725934267044,
1.4238150119781494,
-0.7002790570259094,
0.8835899233818054,
0.33503457903862,
-0.1766892820596695,
-0.6219996213912964,
-0.26487186551094055,
0.19404888153076172,
-0.8331124186515808,
0.6835488080978394,
0.2100180983543396,
-0.543648898601532,
-0.4784366488456726,
-0.16868941485881805,
-0.7526770830154419,
1.1264322996139526,
0.6448895335197449,
-0.8135114908218384,
0.06159243732690811,
0.19362083077430725,
0.6425754427909851,
-0.5495522022247314,
0.6236827969551086,
0.5638625025749207,
0.6035821437835693,
0.02813643403351307,
-1.159409523010254,
0.21584439277648926,
-0.3664235472679138,
-0.02689140848815441,
0.1187860518693924,
-0.5954200625419617,
0.6350255608558655,
-0.18996845185756683,
-0.19118070602416992,
0.31640180945396423,
0.5208451151847839,
0.11686412990093231,
0.09185915440320969,
0.5402305126190186,
0.5732166767120361,
1.0439157485961914,
0.0006623920635320246,
1.1208544969558716,
-0.44077032804489136,
0.49490785598754883,
1.20229971408844,
-0.378652960062027,
1.2609801292419434,
0.22448410093784332,
-0.08938423544168472,
0.6969885230064392,
0.42535656690597534,
0.06390968710184097,
0.35524359345436096,
0.46440526843070984,
-0.6442990303039551,
-0.2327268272638321,
0.11428224295377731,
-0.21401967108249664,
0.25646188855171204,
0.36829087138175964,
-0.20730990171432495,
-0.616459310054779,
-0.373171329498291,
0.0728883296251297,
-0.1214381754398346,
-0.3140711486339569,
0.44909393787384033,
-0.02523943968117237,
-0.40904149413108826,
0.4683769941329956,
0.03923807293176651,
0.6770368814468384,
-0.7397433519363403,
0.33936411142349243,
-0.19517692923545837,
0.4610629081726074,
-0.5128883719444275,
-0.45509079098701477,
0.601235032081604,
0.0796131044626236,
-0.03034110739827156,
-0.17301297187805176,
0.6806649565696716,
-0.4152604043483734,
-0.3856301009654999,
0.6814822554588318,
0.6839501857757568,
0.22058212757110596,
-0.03812522068619728,
-0.5926406383514404,
0.22392326593399048,
-0.17329055070877075,
-0.3514626622200012,
0.5217962265014648,
0.12000451236963272,
-0.28147798776626587,
0.8773282170295715,
0.864844799041748,
0.23008857667446136,
-0.08399952948093414,
0.33946582674980164,
0.7735811471939087,
-0.34298810362815857,
-0.22548727691173553,
-1.163347840309143,
0.5762487053871155,
0.1172594353556633,
0.03017730452120304,
0.6887544393539429,
0.8433520197868347,
0.37041521072387695,
0.07003455609083176,
0.8091962337493896,
0.21525529026985168,
0.32673609256744385,
-0.24006123840808868,
1.1808736324310303,
-0.4348728060722351,
0.4448383152484894,
-0.3795241415500641,
-1.031308889389038,
-0.5895823836326599,
0.5099586248397827,
-0.19587138295173645,
-0.1440483033657074,
0.7232968211174011,
0.8209588527679443,
-0.18520617485046387,
0.10918556153774261,
0.3278641104698181,
0.18078948557376862,
0.6417422294616699,
0.48484987020492554,
0.7339518070220947,
-0.03552109748125076,
0.5952610373497009,
0.13562370836734772,
-0.6323076486587524,
0.035912275314331055,
-1.320175290107727,
-0.6919471025466919,
-0.15678320825099945,
-0.10020284354686737,
-0.22947090864181519,
0.1888001561164856,
1.1272294521331787,
0.6413880586624146,
-0.9988765120506287,
-0.5805748701095581,
0.17437705397605896,
0.328138530254364,
0.032518114894628525,
-0.22599534690380096,
0.5649808049201965,
-0.3574395477771759,
-0.7154480814933777,
0.8316918015480042,
0.6737861037254333,
-0.34387263655662537,
-0.4486125409603119,
-0.10463318973779678,
0.025296499952673912,
0.15838119387626648,
0.8338109850883484,
-0.05723180994391441,
-0.7490258812904358,
-0.41775402426719666,
-0.22738058865070343,
0.02922160178422928,
-0.08263377845287323,
0.8694747090339661,
-0.7704782485961914,
0.5349472165107727,
0.5769798159599304,
1.0167779922485352,
0.10539036989212036,
-0.1530323475599289,
0.6321451663970947,
-0.4537903964519501,
-0.009204576723277569,
0.09261567145586014,
0.41842976212501526,
0.5717155337333679,
0.0063538155518472195,
0.4177212715148926,
0.013077001087367535,
-0.7114354968070984,
-0.9571825861930847,
0.2718566656112671,
-0.8328654766082764,
-0.004421778954565525,
1.1893080472946167,
-0.34073805809020996,
-0.21769413352012634,
-0.05863003060221672,
0.2218959927558899,
-0.04347095265984535,
-0.3299459218978882,
0.5152648091316223,
0.8212588429450989,
-0.09200991690158844,
0.11540496349334717,
-0.6230058073997498,
0.34871864318847656,
0.39334142208099365,
-0.9658660888671875,
0.5678672194480896,
0.6675992012023926,
0.6771062612533569,
0.0450308732688427,
0.578364372253418,
-0.620048999786377,
0.03263374790549278,
-0.22788161039352417,
-0.09943264722824097,
-0.14327086508274078,
-0.2942620813846588,
-0.6606268286705017,
0.28979623317718506,
0.20738880336284637,
0.023341117426753044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.06001v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.06001v2
|
Privacy Preserving Prompt Engineering: A Survey
| 2024-04-09T04:11:25 | 2024-04-11T00:17:18 |
Kennedy Edemacu, Xintao Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have demonstrated significant proficiency
in solving a wide range of general natural language processing (NLP) tasks.
Researchers have observed a direct correlation between the performance of these
models and their sizes. As a result, the sizes of these models have notably
expanded in recent years, persuading researchers to adopt the term large
language models (LLMs) to characterize the larger-sized PLMs. The size
expansion comes with a distinct capability called in-context learning (ICL),
which represents a special form of prompting and allows the models to be
utilized through the presentation of demonstration examples without
modifications to the model parameters. Although interesting, privacy concerns
have become a major obstacle in its widespread usage. Multiple studies have
examined the privacy risks linked to ICL and prompting in general, and have
devised techniques to alleviate these risks. Thus, there is a necessity to
organize these mitigation techniques for the benefit of the community. This
survey provides a systematic overview of the privacy protection methods
employed during ICL and prompting in general. We review, analyze, and compare
different methods under this paradigm. Furthermore, we provide a summary of the
resources accessible for the development of these frameworks. Finally, we
discuss the limitations of these frameworks and offer a detailed examination of
the promising areas that necessitate further exploration.
|
[
-0.6512219309806824,
-0.6134833097457886,
0.5424114465713501,
0.4444328546524048,
0.17289015650749207,
0.06770305335521698,
-0.12936469912528992,
-0.5015904903411865,
-0.4384362995624542,
0.6649490594863892,
-0.6520199179649353,
-0.5141741633415222,
-0.2570556402206421,
0.18557585775852203,
-0.20148956775665283,
1.0562129020690918,
0.1248510330915451,
0.06838518381118774,
-0.2530254125595093,
0.22248797118663788,
-0.5077049732208252,
-0.8012485504150391,
-0.7622577548027039,
0.09288248419761658,
0.24178490042686462,
0.38920944929122925,
0.22493700683116913,
0.31847864389419556,
0.24431906640529633,
0.2622438371181488,
-0.48465272784233093,
0.04977746307849884,
-0.22155405580997467,
0.2822677791118622,
-0.1763460785150528,
-0.15234193205833435,
-0.23353955149650574,
0.1300680786371231,
0.7958229780197144,
0.8703840970993042,
0.016378996893763542,
0.1753462851047516,
0.5953516960144043,
0.6113423705101013,
-0.8796138167381287,
-0.0769735649228096,
-0.3741481602191925,
0.08373672515153885,
0.0650867223739624,
-0.392284631729126,
-0.7472670674324036,
-0.589012861251831,
0.45990365743637085,
-0.17520129680633545,
0.10452145338058472,
0.42562946677207947,
0.46137192845344543,
0.20485588908195496,
-0.29275935888290405,
-0.3653179407119751,
-0.5396667122840881,
1.0153782367706299,
-0.6022481322288513,
0.34722718596458435,
0.8059573769569397,
0.10379180312156677,
-0.22877848148345947,
-0.6807313561439514,
-0.19948089122772217,
-0.5596488118171692,
-0.2652808427810669,
-0.2595558166503906,
-0.06758563965559006,
0.45229262113571167,
0.6592383980751038,
0.3035041391849518,
-0.6743674278259277,
0.45177149772644043,
-0.1193452998995781,
-0.489600270986557,
0.5348941087722778,
0.16493143141269684,
0.28085091710090637,
-0.15654627978801727,
-0.666625440120697,
-0.05219633877277374,
-1.0315691232681274,
0.4457458555698395,
0.38069093227386475,
0.07493004947900772,
-0.07405080646276474,
0.2510143220424652,
-0.21168462932109833,
0.6303708553314209,
0.1251465082168579,
-0.07720533758401871,
-0.07418335229158401,
-0.3356202244758606,
-0.2695247232913971,
0.12962445616722107,
0.6639254093170166,
0.23465004563331604,
0.1362120509147644,
-0.07380300760269165,
-0.1320076733827591,
-0.42462319135665894,
-0.06594336032867432,
-0.6036583185195923,
0.09511177241802216,
0.25478118658065796,
-0.6757843494415283,
0.052963484078645706,
0.24682024121284485,
-0.7003958821296692,
-0.5941244959831238,
-0.4300726056098938,
0.09997528791427612,
-0.305032342672348,
-0.14141346514225006,
0.11491171270608902,
0.15478326380252838,
0.3182118833065033,
0.005571290850639343,
-0.869267463684082,
0.3826260566711426,
0.7980272173881531,
0.7410168647766113,
-0.10687552392482758,
-0.23896333575248718,
-0.5128446221351624,
0.12101122736930847,
-0.06354282796382904,
0.2897593677043915,
-0.2816094160079956,
-0.8634675145149231,
0.22655275464057922,
0.027895180508494377,
0.1220729872584343,
-0.4862211048603058,
0.45115286111831665,
-0.6666558384895325,
0.5314826965332031,
-0.4103570580482483,
-0.7843540906906128,
-0.12286373972892761,
0.44649073481559753,
-0.4097479283809662,
0.4690830111503601,
-0.04943796247243881,
-0.8837533593177795,
0.1649184376001358,
-0.9066131711006165,
-0.12288451939821243,
0.15068523585796356,
-0.1397613286972046,
-0.3679470121860504,
0.003256135620176792,
0.25692370533943176,
0.472076416015625,
-0.10845641046762466,
0.2484683245420456,
-0.07106413692235947,
-0.20257553458213806,
0.43838149309158325,
-0.5327340364456177,
1.166728138923645,
0.49079445004463196,
-0.35132697224617004,
0.34350112080574036,
-0.6322700381278992,
0.060812193900346756,
-0.5168737173080444,
-0.15548157691955566,
-0.47447699308395386,
-0.2478848397731781,
-0.3229103684425354,
0.24057495594024658,
0.3625645339488983,
-0.5903353691101074,
-0.3048689663410187,
-0.6713916659355164,
0.4503992795944214,
1.0021946430206299,
0.30945006012916565,
0.861808717250824,
-0.23615522682666779,
0.8294209241867065,
-0.036584723740816116,
0.609975278377533,
-0.508651614189148,
-0.5321311950683594,
-0.3221762776374817,
-0.23107323050498962,
0.17021609842777252,
0.5584312677383423,
-0.5910311937332153,
0.5478094220161438,
0.20136599242687225,
-0.05602294206619263,
-0.26402321457862854,
-0.05041264742612839,
0.5678597688674927,
0.6666322350502014,
0.08673936128616333,
0.02877194620668888,
-0.42603716254234314,
-0.9788806438446045,
-0.3576567769050598,
-0.09485635906457901,
-0.13560569286346436,
0.283540815114975,
-0.0971541628241539,
0.16896826028823853,
1.263874888420105,
-0.22216077148914337,
-0.1554158329963684,
-0.1339235156774521,
-0.0015893153613433242,
-0.0068071517162024975,
0.8435909748077393,
0.6674856543540955,
-0.8634511232376099,
-0.6381238698959351,
-0.3690939247608185,
-0.6744498014450073,
-0.19709859788417816,
0.05246340110898018,
0.03852768987417221,
0.17815399169921875,
0.7419817447662354,
-0.433124840259552,
0.6700128316879272,
0.5813568830490112,
-0.3500029444694519,
0.36354827880859375,
-0.19222493469715118,
-0.011832521297037601,
-1.023924708366394,
-0.07962553948163986,
-0.038243286311626434,
-0.2330629974603653,
-0.7985835671424866,
0.12863746285438538,
0.2831733822822571,
-0.47058647871017456,
-0.7965778112411499,
0.7626157402992249,
-0.7772210240364075,
0.06349926441907883,
-0.501451849937439,
-0.2615056335926056,
-0.24313606321811676,
0.15811285376548767,
-0.06449192017316818,
0.9534162282943726,
0.8058543801307678,
-0.9890787601470947,
-0.06045346334576607,
0.3262263536453247,
-0.18659164011478424,
0.5132234692573547,
-0.4776175618171692,
0.32216715812683105,
-0.2713412642478943,
0.14350877702236176,
-0.781889796257019,
-0.25158166885375977,
0.4971431493759155,
-0.38917598128318787,
0.29971617460250854,
0.11915717273950577,
-0.5191389918327332,
-0.23734590411186218,
-0.5872268676757812,
0.27278393507003784,
0.6356287002563477,
-0.7939373850822449,
0.45061880350112915,
0.42409735918045044,
-0.43427449464797974,
-0.7466053366661072,
-0.536411464214325,
0.15056554973125458,
-0.5138347744941711,
-0.5395817160606384,
0.17506122589111328,
-0.5419560670852661,
-0.41437777876853943,
-0.19218425452709198,
0.18886663019657135,
-0.26052677631378174,
0.35369595885276794,
0.39638733863830566,
0.2142440527677536,
0.06570031493902206,
0.0016161550302058458,
-0.06657961755990982,
-0.23987977206707,
0.38311558961868286,
-0.07994428277015686,
0.5196611881256104,
-0.11302226036787033,
-0.21094772219657898,
-0.8353344202041626,
0.6383948922157288,
0.1217186450958252,
-0.22377625107765198,
0.7803070545196533,
0.08444114029407501,
-0.39589858055114746,
-0.32983362674713135,
-0.6192547678947449,
-0.5046515464782715,
-0.6076878905296326,
-0.10369227081537247,
0.03741547092795372,
-1.303343653678894,
0.3679018020629883,
-0.16115498542785645,
0.181221604347229,
-0.2157277762889862,
0.2718390226364136,
0.007861643098294735,
1.095517635345459,
0.9718505144119263,
-0.26845499873161316,
0.7158429026603699,
0.14138023555278778,
0.45890477299690247,
-0.7689629793167114,
-0.17433646321296692,
-0.6237285137176514,
-0.04754924029111862,
-0.515842616558075,
0.20952963829040527,
0.4932398498058319,
-0.09471689909696579,
-0.12489145994186401,
0.0804685428738594,
-0.677934467792511,
0.7078107595443726,
0.6607050895690918,
0.04125836119055748,
0.19581875205039978,
-0.03707362338900566,
0.32864654064178467,
-0.060388948768377304,
-0.4168182909488678,
-0.7235434651374817,
0.9002255201339722,
0.49862000346183777,
0.7505662441253662,
-0.016379041597247124,
0.7808540463447571,
0.10178744792938232,
0.3530704379081726,
-0.41626834869384766,
0.9066118001937866,
0.1607792228460312,
-0.7487035989761353,
-0.399909108877182,
-0.3785112798213959,
-0.9396859407424927,
0.04024306684732437,
0.18524222075939178,
-1.0715086460113525,
0.43878382444381714,
0.29110273718833923,
-0.7148621082305908,
0.11729587614536285,
-0.7631744742393494,
0.44370269775390625,
-0.12709270417690277,
-0.3194737732410431,
0.1512010395526886,
-1.0084755420684814,
0.6370455026626587,
-0.05595508590340614,
0.09919644892215729,
0.12854906916618347,
0.04930780827999115,
0.4386121928691864,
-0.2775135040283203,
1.0379623174667358,
-0.5160598754882812,
-0.16656917333602905,
0.3065352439880371,
-0.03147391229867935,
0.4757841229438782,
0.24996981024742126,
-0.0911671370267868,
-0.1122264415025711,
0.027299631386995316,
-0.044041577726602554,
-0.31865599751472473,
0.8437109589576721,
-0.304999440908432,
-0.8184959292411804,
-0.29609283804893494,
-0.7505357265472412,
-0.44933757185935974,
0.05909759923815727,
0.44567856192588806,
0.19726866483688354,
-0.008298038505017757,
0.5191362500190735,
1.158372402191162,
-0.6067451238632202,
0.8717253804206848,
0.6219638586044312,
-0.21463188529014587,
-0.17927952110767365,
0.4781896471977234,
0.09109263122081757,
0.13086238503456116,
0.16787508130073547,
0.2810180187225342,
-0.5486118197441101,
-0.704838752746582,
0.041752416640520096,
0.020095432177186012,
-0.7192724347114563,
-0.20088845491409302,
-0.6614171862602234,
-0.47096696496009827,
-0.595873236656189,
-0.20901499688625336,
0.16430054605007172,
-0.17985962331295013,
-0.6253690123558044,
-0.22313494980335236,
0.18464742600917816,
0.552890956401825,
-0.08640357851982117,
0.47580307722091675,
-0.7596413493156433,
0.08663517236709595,
0.1503472477197647,
0.29829496145248413,
-0.005996405612677336,
-0.2520323395729065,
0.11822773516178131,
-0.3070078194141388,
-0.10360869765281677,
-0.6397020816802979,
0.4128117859363556,
-0.0030159573070704937,
0.7015166878700256,
0.33620649576187134,
0.467247873544693,
0.2896721661090851,
-0.36280494928359985,
1.0923101902008057,
0.049051083624362946,
-0.9400304555892944,
0.6029238104820251,
-0.12072475254535675,
0.14273321628570557,
0.6207035183906555,
0.5319159626960754,
-0.2896144390106201,
-0.3173401653766632,
-0.7587379217147827,
-0.8655766248703003,
0.5617987513542175,
-0.08079086244106293,
0.3195003569126129,
0.03567001223564148,
0.3837710916996002,
0.16678069531917572,
0.35895970463752747,
-0.7159832119941711,
-0.04354333505034447,
0.16066929697990417,
-0.2628040611743927,
0.19379207491874695,
-0.5828607678413391,
-0.16955192387104034,
0.002713348250836134,
0.5709388852119446,
0.07070744037628174,
-0.23581799864768982,
0.1521347314119339,
-0.07452564686536789,
0.36731576919555664,
0.5009334087371826,
0.6139134764671326,
0.7536692023277283,
0.16423681378364563,
-0.025052262470126152,
0.18602867424488068,
-0.37921738624572754,
0.23021750152111053,
0.06300916522741318,
-0.6151506304740906,
-0.14695093035697937,
-0.1402854174375534,
0.5442131161689758,
0.23866991698741913,
-0.5357683300971985,
0.6881124973297119,
-0.14307451248168945,
-0.12659259140491486,
-0.46013832092285156,
-0.0015500005101785064,
-0.30547481775283813,
-0.060636650770902634,
0.19129438698291779,
-0.23837149143218994,
0.35294273495674133,
-0.3316727876663208,
0.17474010586738586,
0.5714069604873657,
-0.3596092462539673,
-0.3077041208744049,
0.6851010322570801,
0.1277487426996231,
-0.514524519443512,
0.5003167390823364,
-0.187064066529274,
-0.12434595823287964,
0.37337374687194824,
0.5171592235565186,
1.0660881996154785,
-0.6068224310874939,
0.10194447636604309,
0.19021613895893097,
0.295335590839386,
-0.17166708409786224,
0.39433056116104126,
-0.33427363634109497,
-0.4478685259819031,
-0.16817598044872284,
-0.339009165763855,
-0.5454498529434204,
0.3675876259803772,
-0.6680014729499817,
-0.08343014121055603,
-1.0872951745986938,
-0.3352045714855194,
-0.40811216831207275,
-0.26810333132743835,
-0.45786720514297485,
-0.0318734236061573,
0.17286932468414307,
1.0685155391693115,
-0.523157000541687,
0.6127257347106934,
0.464465856552124,
-0.07696420699357986,
-0.8607334494590759,
0.07703611999750137,
0.21751491725444794,
-0.3458304703235626,
0.6493126749992371,
0.27975159883499146,
-0.11022627353668213,
0.02219817414879799,
-1.0506106615066528,
-0.7178913354873657,
0.7598342895507812,
0.43648096919059753,
-0.664520800113678,
-0.09538944810628891,
0.14276625216007233,
0.3480662703514099,
-0.2418166995048523,
-0.34875360131263733,
0.48655837774276733,
0.40208399295806885,
-0.46213099360466003,
-0.9145854115486145,
0.022199159488081932,
0.11985263973474503,
0.2335151582956314,
-0.1606035977602005,
-0.4266410171985626,
0.8574188947677612,
0.24255681037902832,
-0.47698304057121277,
0.38568830490112305,
0.6405035257339478,
0.6450880169868469,
0.5334652662277222,
0.5574027895927429,
-0.0075181215070188046,
0.8502010107040405,
-0.004229153506457806,
1.134071946144104,
-0.5269730687141418,
0.07117132097482681,
1.1533732414245605,
-0.586333155632019,
0.4253028929233551,
0.6398093700408936,
0.08928447216749191,
0.05959561467170715,
0.6978750824928284,
0.35355904698371887,
0.5855185985565186,
0.2389877587556839,
-0.5955260396003723,
0.14321263134479523,
-0.567528247833252,
-0.47735849022865295,
-0.010376272723078728,
0.4245098829269409,
-0.5917040109634399,
-0.11144640296697617,
0.5126858949661255,
-0.055343132466077805,
0.24868346750736237,
-0.5134243369102478,
0.8742730617523193,
0.35171401500701904,
-0.6304236054420471,
-0.022612251341342926,
-0.2670571208000183,
0.8661870360374451,
-0.8536846041679382,
0.16525551676750183,
-0.11943310499191284,
0.024034591391682625,
-0.09502127766609192,
-0.6999367475509644,
0.1988210678100586,
0.05985089763998985,
-0.25788214802742004,
-0.679650604724884,
0.8042344450950623,
-0.26493343710899353,
0.03732963651418686,
0.20622101426124573,
0.25802984833717346,
0.15536090731620789,
0.03492733836174011,
-0.5746225714683533,
-0.03329126536846161,
-0.12713375687599182,
-0.23984909057617188,
0.5338454842567444,
0.2482810765504837,
-0.20883099734783173,
0.6697527170181274,
0.6529672741889954,
0.10585533827543259,
0.3594360649585724,
0.1816922426223755,
0.8547144532203674,
-0.5250685811042786,
-0.9343618750572205,
-0.9022240042686462,
0.5310025811195374,
-0.27368131279945374,
-0.32740938663482666,
1.1567354202270508,
0.4315440356731415,
0.859890341758728,
-0.048506151884794235,
0.8681000471115112,
0.2661152482032776,
0.8794087171554565,
-0.8059307336807251,
0.6998472213745117,
0.026069676503539085,
0.42673400044441223,
-0.13541698455810547,
-0.8515161871910095,
-0.41756096482276917,
0.35229647159576416,
-0.4150126278400421,
-0.13342294096946716,
0.481742262840271,
0.9071230888366699,
0.2810860872268677,
0.3152483105659485,
0.3388577699661255,
-0.1147928312420845,
0.5146947503089905,
0.19126412272453308,
1.3210581541061401,
0.06741775572299957,
0.14256693422794342,
-0.2905620038509369,
-0.3081413507461548,
0.026234960183501244,
-1.0539488792419434,
-0.8996859192848206,
-0.45139509439468384,
-0.22989216446876526,
-0.0975494533777237,
-0.02050897851586342,
0.9312012195587158,
0.893574059009552,
-0.8354313373565674,
-0.14147710800170898,
0.006834914907813072,
-0.015072290785610676,
0.05567055195569992,
-0.21596303582191467,
0.18012607097625732,
-0.41449376940727234,
-0.6879245638847351,
0.734487771987915,
0.42454537749290466,
0.2527197003364563,
-0.4633444845676422,
0.019375290721654892,
0.0399448461830616,
-0.14582695066928864,
0.601997435092926,
0.716949999332428,
-0.6478815078735352,
-0.3190046548843384,
0.038070179522037506,
0.028323113918304443,
-0.20616896450519562,
1.0238337516784668,
-0.6615556478500366,
0.3395531177520752,
0.6374092698097229,
0.9305434226989746,
-0.11088674515485764,
0.23240554332733154,
0.5615296363830566,
-1.1185038089752197,
0.4219842851161957,
0.41079622507095337,
0.4324539601802826,
0.41876763105392456,
-0.7636426687240601,
0.26255565881729126,
-0.3837986886501312,
-0.9289533495903015,
-0.992171049118042,
0.5031094551086426,
-0.6051855683326721,
-0.30716678500175476,
0.9279317259788513,
-0.23971861600875854,
-0.19706566631793976,
-0.42783910036087036,
-0.325253963470459,
-0.1907714307308197,
-0.3405317962169647,
0.7261289358139038,
0.6564854979515076,
-0.23195722699165344,
-0.37054306268692017,
-0.4825916290283203,
0.868742048740387,
0.33744576573371887,
-0.7316070795059204,
0.21800123155117035,
0.5131688117980957,
0.29708778858184814,
0.07392153143882751,
0.7551502585411072,
-0.24496300518512726,
0.10223434865474701,
-0.6435918807983398,
-0.26970556378364563,
-0.024055207148194313,
-0.504737913608551,
-0.9397169351577759,
0.50376957654953,
0.18029676377773285,
-0.24966581165790558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05993v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05993v1
|
AEGIS: Online Adaptive AI Content Safety Moderation with Ensemble of LLM Experts
| 2024-04-09T03:54:28 | 2024-04-09T03:54:28 |
Shaona Ghosh, Prasoon Varshney, Erick Galinkin, Christopher Parisien
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) and generative AI become more widespread, the
content safety risks associated with their use also increase. We find a notable
deficiency in high-quality content safety datasets and benchmarks that
comprehensively cover a wide range of critical safety areas. To address this,
we define a broad content safety risk taxonomy, comprising 13 critical risk and
9 sparse risk categories. Additionally, we curate AEGISSAFETYDATASET, a new
dataset of approximately 26, 000 human-LLM interaction instances, complete with
human annotations adhering to the taxonomy. We plan to release this dataset to
the community to further research and to help benchmark LLM models for safety.
To demonstrate the effectiveness of the dataset, we instruction-tune multiple
LLM-based safety models. We show that our models (named AEGISSAFETYEXPERTS),
not only surpass or perform competitively with the state-of-the-art LLM-based
safety models and general purpose LLMs, but also exhibit robustness across
multiple jail-break attack categories. We also show how using
AEGISSAFETYDATASET during the LLM alignment phase does not negatively impact
the performance of the aligned models on MT Bench scores. Furthermore, we
propose AEGIS, a novel application of a no-regret online adaptation framework
with strong theoretical guarantees, to perform content moderation with an
ensemble of LLM content safety experts in deployment
|
[
-0.3653642535209656,
-0.7536888122558594,
0.3084712326526642,
-0.0792180672287941,
-0.01078836526721716,
0.1689106971025467,
-0.11451829969882965,
-0.4718420207500458,
0.09241334348917007,
0.5618563294410706,
-0.3371158540248871,
-0.6346948146820068,
-0.7257949709892273,
0.11724080890417099,
-0.5089275240898132,
1.017914891242981,
-0.33446088433265686,
-0.1429041177034378,
-0.21616604924201965,
-0.23109102249145508,
-0.4859429895877838,
-0.11847367137670517,
-1.0311284065246582,
0.1297655552625656,
0.34090229868888855,
0.31192174553871155,
0.6382662653923035,
0.9037156105041504,
0.6353453397750854,
0.36814385652542114,
0.23378586769104004,
0.40254098176956177,
-0.5580897331237793,
0.24766619503498077,
-0.10972657054662704,
-0.2671785056591034,
-0.7530685663223267,
-0.28348711133003235,
0.27028271555900574,
0.30052027106285095,
-0.46035581827163696,
-0.21524101495742798,
0.3200404644012451,
0.5027951002120972,
-0.6702706813812256,
0.1825426071882248,
-0.5661790370941162,
-0.05026380345225334,
0.039859749376773834,
-0.156845360994339,
-0.26814791560173035,
-0.518639862537384,
0.05895136669278145,
-1.062038540840149,
-0.13835962116718292,
0.42868953943252563,
0.3411290645599365,
0.6595480442047119,
-0.4841008186340332,
-0.29292115569114685,
-0.7693613767623901,
0.510159432888031,
-0.4091610908508301,
0.3341616988182068,
0.5341213941574097,
0.09079600125551224,
-0.12690266966819763,
-0.7278829216957092,
-0.4560486376285553,
-0.00043381316936574876,
0.5885242223739624,
0.22626915574073792,
-0.0503089465200901,
0.3130333721637726,
-0.12806838750839233,
0.05805155634880066,
-0.5110101103782654,
0.3204973340034485,
-0.19948109984397888,
-0.2971592843532562,
0.9082261323928833,
0.47107329964637756,
0.35980480909347534,
0.30313003063201904,
-0.4838156998157501,
-0.2002248466014862,
-0.9645400047302246,
0.0002745472884271294,
0.5310796499252319,
0.03940029442310333,
-0.3730459213256836,
0.37944433093070984,
-0.20747098326683044,
0.45441734790802,
-0.0834135115146637,
-0.24864909052848816,
0.13106314837932587,
-0.29578083753585815,
-0.019536180421710014,
0.3011035621166229,
0.8538233041763306,
0.7214062809944153,
0.17695005238056183,
-0.2093944251537323,
-0.10446453094482422,
0.10547751188278198,
0.4964773952960968,
-0.6742254495620728,
-0.3939836621284485,
0.15106382966041565,
-0.19571657478809357,
-0.4705895483493805,
0.1473320722579956,
-0.8767033815383911,
-0.8744252920150757,
-0.02813800610601902,
0.44101884961128235,
-0.28074902296066284,
-0.2991631329059601,
0.38035839796066284,
0.20849022269248962,
0.1576828956604004,
0.42456746101379395,
-0.8443132042884827,
0.4178292453289032,
0.6183974742889404,
0.7133710980415344,
-0.5963436961174011,
-0.2874961793422699,
-0.47393953800201416,
0.37049880623817444,
-0.26491907238960266,
0.7557599544525146,
-0.3714897334575653,
-0.4548066556453705,
0.18973411619663239,
0.008253971114754677,
-0.22797977924346924,
-0.2907777726650238,
1.008320927619934,
-0.5945289731025696,
-0.3050415515899658,
-0.17540040612220764,
-0.7350112199783325,
-0.3562193512916565,
0.34667345881462097,
-0.7129702568054199,
0.6265786290168762,
-0.02407759428024292,
-0.6639682650566101,
0.3246002793312073,
-0.45738375186920166,
-0.4943532347679138,
0.037165567278862,
-0.2219943106174469,
-0.6246728301048279,
-0.2555471956729889,
0.4190223813056946,
0.22662338614463806,
-0.07268179953098297,
0.10149603337049484,
-0.4727380573749542,
-0.20119597017765045,
0.16975748538970947,
-0.6037845015525818,
0.41687750816345215,
0.18325212597846985,
-0.20762899518013,
0.3814302682876587,
-0.3935391902923584,
-0.14919398725032806,
0.08110330253839493,
-0.5789550542831421,
-0.09034176915884018,
0.3971443176269531,
0.15955248475074768,
-0.01070044469088316,
0.07766716927289963,
-0.5283836722373962,
-0.025429876521229744,
-0.20550143718719482,
0.6446956396102905,
0.8640482425689697,
0.2389005869626999,
0.5475447177886963,
-0.6624178886413574,
0.6628242135047913,
-0.17072942852973938,
0.35270053148269653,
-0.04517073184251785,
-0.5882524847984314,
-0.5907630920410156,
-0.22024469077587128,
0.22833244502544403,
0.8241842985153198,
-0.7977510094642639,
0.6272106170654297,
-0.3581279218196869,
-0.38551947474479675,
-0.4684281051158905,
0.2735517919063568,
0.2389536201953888,
0.4932468831539154,
0.3399546146392822,
-0.4300743639469147,
-0.1778436154127121,
-0.41888129711151123,
-0.1882588118314743,
-0.3402601480484009,
-0.1563749611377716,
0.2812903821468353,
0.18787270784378052,
-0.3875266909599304,
0.7567653656005859,
-0.31005439162254333,
-0.3248683214187622,
-0.2631898522377014,
-0.08702683448791504,
-0.32104289531707764,
0.3475845456123352,
0.582564651966095,
-0.6913033723831177,
-0.24892307817935944,
-0.2897953689098358,
-0.7815215587615967,
0.1352924108505249,
-0.08083385974168777,
-0.056263767182826996,
0.11910427361726761,
0.5073091983795166,
-0.6268784999847412,
0.26592183113098145,
0.44648510217666626,
-0.27106213569641113,
0.06240750104188919,
-0.23901936411857605,
0.32324090600013733,
-1.2357919216156006,
-0.33141860365867615,
0.2791489362716675,
-0.310238778591156,
-0.6710024476051331,
0.34729400277137756,
0.08749084919691086,
-0.039270415902137756,
-0.7490783333778381,
0.31887170672416687,
-0.04080985486507416,
0.09170428663492203,
-0.23522862792015076,
0.14495591819286346,
0.10279947519302368,
0.1684010773897171,
-0.13049323856830597,
0.6691745519638062,
0.7246624231338501,
-0.6909024119377136,
0.502128005027771,
0.4702072739601135,
-0.46166136860847473,
0.35692840814590454,
-0.6609071493148804,
0.16904570162296295,
-0.2264794260263443,
0.30167853832244873,
-0.7455117106437683,
-0.5589004158973694,
0.4235099256038666,
-0.20254142582416534,
0.4722309410572052,
-0.22823594510555267,
-0.08316747099161148,
0.040647242218256,
-0.583073616027832,
0.4847237169742584,
0.23817607760429382,
-0.2611367404460907,
0.6724579930305481,
0.8248551487922668,
-0.5756190419197083,
-0.5543341040611267,
-0.5274653434753418,
0.11017448455095291,
-0.6116355657577515,
-0.6699423789978027,
0.47679051756858826,
-0.3980191946029663,
-0.3051798343658447,
0.008324073627591133,
-0.08784772455692291,
0.07199040800333023,
0.582987904548645,
0.6166220307350159,
0.3740561902523041,
-0.04337814450263977,
-0.11228590458631516,
0.08914045989513397,
-0.20861221849918365,
0.16311362385749817,
-0.12356754392385483,
0.2381063997745514,
-0.11938679218292236,
-0.6021546125411987,
-0.4422686696052551,
0.21836534142494202,
0.3743465542793274,
-0.24349509179592133,
0.7255203723907471,
0.5898335576057434,
-0.5977619290351868,
0.07213421165943146,
-0.2927651107311249,
-0.1368229240179062,
-0.5533575415611267,
0.40522775053977966,
0.22543805837631226,
-1.1489027738571167,
0.5160282850265503,
0.019548246636986732,
0.37711861729621887,
0.5173190832138062,
0.4715057909488678,
-0.23301942646503448,
1.0192503929138184,
0.44582661986351013,
-0.4919096529483795,
0.40756988525390625,
-0.09038493037223816,
0.12637098133563995,
-0.4485708773136139,
-0.2609159052371979,
-0.4329111576080322,
-0.10392453521490097,
-0.63680499792099,
-0.19121181964874268,
0.7459096908569336,
0.0295601487159729,
-0.39168548583984375,
0.04584305360913277,
-0.3305712938308716,
0.500691831111908,
0.15701818466186523,
0.21942968666553497,
0.3238537907600403,
0.07828409969806671,
0.30285927653312683,
0.10332617908716202,
-0.534539520740509,
-0.26445239782333374,
1.4526965618133545,
0.4917207956314087,
1.2727832794189453,
0.42032209038734436,
0.5621129274368286,
0.7332335710525513,
0.36087432503700256,
-0.7141870260238647,
0.2433822751045227,
0.11940187215805054,
-0.5726157426834106,
-0.332906037569046,
-0.47212591767311096,
-0.8265541195869446,
-0.2955607771873474,
-0.554141640663147,
-0.46983733773231506,
-0.055128730833530426,
0.07963936030864716,
-0.8785481452941895,
0.32514214515686035,
-0.4428256154060364,
0.6075880527496338,
-0.42516982555389404,
-0.5171559453010559,
-0.3146977722644806,
-0.4987596571445465,
0.3906649947166443,
-0.2958280146121979,
0.5327941179275513,
-0.2780725657939911,
-0.2713319659233093,
0.7830294370651245,
-0.20411525666713715,
0.7931225895881653,
0.034091051667928696,
0.13200904428958893,
0.5033735036849976,
0.2846396863460541,
0.6183445453643799,
0.39637991786003113,
-0.08369628340005875,
0.23794369399547577,
-0.256991446018219,
-0.11327575892210007,
-0.12318403273820877,
1.1060985326766968,
-1.133518099784851,
-0.6783836483955383,
-0.42312008142471313,
-0.4289790391921997,
-0.03713018074631691,
0.19714343547821045,
0.2577129900455475,
0.3725373148918152,
-0.02634158357977867,
0.24239344894886017,
0.97972172498703,
-0.24190381169319153,
0.6008399128913879,
0.24121834337711334,
0.20423375070095062,
-0.6332749724388123,
1.012715220451355,
0.015028461813926697,
0.03297536447644234,
0.21050822734832764,
-0.13916772603988647,
-0.5601993203163147,
-1.0235365629196167,
-0.7111154794692993,
-0.4677463471889496,
-0.802724301815033,
-0.4874391257762909,
-0.6238529086112976,
-0.4139311611652374,
-0.41016778349876404,
-0.2399768829345703,
-0.30035459995269775,
-0.3790487051010132,
-0.3551875948905945,
-0.335191935300827,
0.6702574491500854,
0.9624367952346802,
0.21504023671150208,
0.20376929640769958,
-0.979086697101593,
0.22514104843139648,
0.3017900586128235,
0.4405902028083801,
-0.37354737520217896,
-0.5405868887901306,
-0.13224294781684875,
-0.19141468405723572,
-0.5937533974647522,
-0.8428659439086914,
0.35310304164886475,
0.4540497362613678,
0.8130764365196228,
0.6815515756607056,
0.4441559314727783,
0.13277976214885712,
-0.4059145450592041,
0.6388536095619202,
-0.0228749867528677,
-0.6113656163215637,
0.2320990264415741,
-0.5911434292793274,
-0.37538865208625793,
0.7917364835739136,
0.5230450630187988,
-0.3860093951225281,
-0.01649055816233158,
-0.21010172367095947,
-1.0526639223098755,
0.3174460828304291,
0.22170020639896393,
0.21612323820590973,
-0.03525753319263458,
0.525016725063324,
0.030482232570648193,
0.04499606788158417,
-0.6250813007354736,
-0.23459216952323914,
-0.34350132942199707,
-0.514072597026825,
-0.008984502404928207,
-0.016373416408896446,
-0.34694167971611023,
0.05936301499605179,
0.7664080262184143,
-0.4084230661392212,
0.17832566797733307,
-0.01996823400259018,
-0.193032905459404,
-0.3559422194957733,
0.2617339789867401,
0.5183951258659363,
0.481028288602829,
0.00032618679688312113,
-0.005056022200733423,
0.5062406063079834,
-0.46656423807144165,
0.2404583841562271,
0.25094395875930786,
-0.3348875343799591,
-0.7311845421791077,
0.3448255658149719,
0.6146872639656067,
0.2592875361442566,
-0.7773336172103882,
0.4691319465637207,
-0.41250383853912354,
-0.06863805651664734,
-0.614206075668335,
0.4911281168460846,
0.006579800508916378,
0.17979560792446136,
0.25738319754600525,
0.29404011368751526,
0.11201175302267075,
-0.20456531643867493,
0.3444420397281647,
0.22403784096240997,
-0.3342317044734955,
-0.06392225623130798,
1.166579008102417,
0.4973143935203552,
-0.22882845997810364,
0.6092015504837036,
-0.1419796645641327,
-0.1696150153875351,
0.72115558385849,
0.07023736834526062,
0.9446513652801514,
-0.4207521677017212,
0.029903650283813477,
0.2053573727607727,
0.4430287480354309,
-0.2748012840747833,
0.2648102641105652,
0.35944125056266785,
-1.0608307123184204,
-0.18526402115821838,
-0.6690671443939209,
-0.601136326789856,
0.018813377246260643,
-0.5684654712677002,
0.20771653950214386,
-0.7439388036727905,
-0.19324783980846405,
-0.29617127776145935,
-0.18729977309703827,
-0.5516294836997986,
0.0405166819691658,
0.2515832483768463,
0.8549264073371887,
-0.8767126798629761,
0.6320593953132629,
0.5416703820228577,
-0.160527765750885,
-0.6903306841850281,
0.07281471788883209,
0.34542006254196167,
-0.6145069003105164,
-0.36955201625823975,
0.19221480190753937,
0.05836249142885208,
0.18792276084423065,
-0.18571601808071136,
-0.9142281413078308,
1.3896194696426392,
0.4726874530315399,
-0.6004437804222107,
0.02189210057258606,
0.2814866900444031,
0.2734033465385437,
-0.48513099551200867,
0.0946166142821312,
0.4291812479496002,
0.3620901107788086,
-0.20215816795825958,
-0.5193126797676086,
-0.032637819647789,
-0.028209982439875603,
-0.3331136405467987,
-0.02818857878446579,
-0.5837334394454956,
0.6073591709136963,
-0.21752820909023285,
-0.09475862234830856,
0.03704573214054108,
0.5888848900794983,
0.27521881461143494,
0.4330332279205322,
0.5228233933448792,
0.8191405534744263,
0.5585991740226746,
-0.16668933629989624,
1.160517692565918,
-0.5758109092712402,
0.10354820638895035,
0.8277109861373901,
-0.42294204235076904,
0.7917954921722412,
0.027277464047074318,
-0.009822101332247257,
0.2947031259536743,
0.9618383646011353,
0.13471001386642456,
0.5204744935035706,
-0.22660760581493378,
-0.6047306060791016,
-0.47490888833999634,
-0.3134496808052063,
-0.33247053623199463,
0.31885483860969543,
0.5832249522209167,
-0.33707141876220703,
-0.005370330065488815,
-0.0948193147778511,
-0.03535081818699837,
0.00891910307109356,
-0.6397615075111389,
0.8506371974945068,
0.04844191297888756,
-0.44398483633995056,
0.14941269159317017,
0.396047979593277,
0.5493892431259155,
-0.4227553606033325,
0.163632333278656,
-0.18385928869247437,
0.16878728568553925,
-0.3266315758228302,
-0.9958484768867493,
0.1756790280342102,
-0.08154278248548508,
0.2644469439983368,
-0.04637227579951286,
0.9319096803665161,
-0.2733725309371948,
-0.43193507194519043,
0.29233434796333313,
0.42143023014068604,
-0.19156968593597412,
0.08500725775957108,
-0.6144839525222778,
0.18778873980045319,
-0.3210594356060028,
-0.25924861431121826,
0.571327269077301,
-0.18999135494232178,
-0.16624261438846588,
0.7580585479736328,
0.500289797782898,
-0.18850469589233398,
0.274382084608078,
-0.10482871532440186,
0.9798849821090698,
-0.16907326877117157,
-0.5842090249061584,
-0.6383830904960632,
0.34369200468063354,
0.09391464293003082,
-0.29137909412384033,
0.5355962514877319,
0.37529829144477844,
1.0565004348754883,
0.2523856461048126,
1.049932599067688,
0.09092649817466736,
-0.02767149917781353,
-0.595346987247467,
1.006988286972046,
-0.26703035831451416,
0.40684354305267334,
-0.02553471177816391,
-0.8271945118904114,
-0.20401977002620697,
0.37944796681404114,
-0.13992854952812195,
0.046990975737571716,
0.20602299273014069,
0.8663432598114014,
-0.06726370006799698,
0.15810617804527283,
0.22120065987110138,
0.038452379405498505,
0.36264678835868835,
0.5471354722976685,
0.695981502532959,
-0.395668625831604,
0.6352145075798035,
-0.06934051960706711,
-0.07970448583364487,
-0.0897509902715683,
-0.8543686866760254,
-0.8130438327789307,
-0.27863723039627075,
-0.4530705213546753,
-0.33946090936660767,
0.18494656682014465,
1.2514071464538574,
0.6750144362449646,
-0.9847754836082458,
0.22003722190856934,
-0.18529760837554932,
-0.024176226928830147,
-0.12687130272388458,
-0.13760603964328766,
0.26878252625465393,
0.22717536985874176,
-0.40105611085891724,
0.7515546083450317,
0.2635432779788971,
0.02175605483353138,
-0.2689920663833618,
-0.6419629454612732,
0.3479190468788147,
0.11976657062768936,
0.19173561036586761,
0.3136852979660034,
-0.418751060962677,
-0.6669045090675354,
-0.15540005266666412,
-0.07393501698970795,
0.033719416707754135,
0.5822340846061707,
-0.19715014100074768,
0.31202781200408936,
0.46553531289100647,
1.2240440845489502,
0.31899356842041016,
-0.015781985595822334,
0.28433361649513245,
-0.6211405992507935,
-0.028296012431383133,
0.11115984618663788,
0.7086414694786072,
0.43383392691612244,
-0.4788295030593872,
0.3238368630409241,
0.2063026875257492,
-0.7234603762626648,
-0.454457551240921,
0.3270304501056671,
-0.9203652739524841,
0.11101674288511276,
1.0924298763275146,
-0.555738627910614,
0.01788375712931156,
-0.43226516246795654,
0.07052279263734818,
0.4336572587490082,
-0.545749306678772,
1.1205668449401855,
0.40560922026634216,
-0.11690527200698853,
-0.39802464842796326,
-0.7657291293144226,
0.6185566186904907,
0.08062267303466797,
-1.0930368900299072,
-0.1293952614068985,
0.3935127258300781,
0.6323751211166382,
-0.07830162346363068,
0.31892868876457214,
-0.004928704351186752,
0.30686646699905396,
-0.14727699756622314,
0.008323990739881992,
-0.3066090941429138,
-0.5735809803009033,
-0.392334908246994,
0.309613436460495,
0.26965582370758057,
0.06923308223485947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05989v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05989v1
|
Event-enhanced Retrieval in Real-time Search
| 2024-04-09T03:47:48 | 2024-04-09T03:47:48 |
Yanan Zhang, Xiaoling Bai, Tianhua Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
The embedding-based retrieval (EBR) approach is widely used in mainstream
search engine retrieval systems and is crucial in recent retrieval-augmented
methods for eliminating LLM illusions. However, existing EBR models often face
the "semantic drift" problem and insufficient focus on key information, leading
to a low adoption rate of retrieval results in subsequent steps. This issue is
especially noticeable in real-time search scenarios, where the various
expressions of popular events on the Internet make real-time retrieval heavily
reliant on crucial event information. To tackle this problem, this paper
proposes a novel approach called EER, which enhances real-time retrieval
performance by improving the dual-encoder model of traditional EBR. We
incorporate contrastive learning to accompany pairwise learning for encoder
optimization. Furthermore, to strengthen the focus on critical event
information in events, we include a decoder module after the document encoder,
introduce a generative event triplet extraction scheme based on prompt-tuning,
and correlate the events with query encoder optimization through comparative
learning. This decoder module can be removed during inference. Extensive
experiments demonstrate that EER can significantly improve the real-time search
retrieval performance. We believe that this approach will provide new
perspectives in the field of information retrieval. The codes and dataset are
available at https://github.com/open-event-hub/Event-enhanced_Retrieval .
|
[
-0.38797134160995483,
-0.9421637058258057,
0.39309966564178467,
-0.02751360833644867,
-0.3641166687011719,
0.4275898039340973,
-0.024990659207105637,
-0.8190738558769226,
0.515873372554779,
-0.1334652155637741,
-0.2968200445175171,
-0.2689474821090698,
-0.24955254793167114,
-0.041780777275562286,
-0.22084642946720123,
0.43594062328338623,
-0.16923488676548004,
-0.07692409306764603,
0.004772408399730921,
-0.06499087065458298,
-0.04987352713942528,
-0.653458297252655,
-0.7868404388427734,
-0.1137721836566925,
0.4962260127067566,
0.13200794160366058,
0.4182523488998413,
0.5904681086540222,
0.729320228099823,
0.04437300190329552,
-0.20655140280723572,
0.3197290301322937,
-0.6225939989089966,
0.3749515414237976,
0.023122351616621017,
-0.5430197715759277,
-0.1448153555393219,
-0.23574423789978027,
0.4664013087749481,
0.12985648214817047,
-0.4811634421348572,
-0.16689929366111755,
0.10406814515590668,
0.3879043757915497,
-1.0553057193756104,
0.045358188450336456,
-0.5272594690322876,
0.3706173896789551,
-0.17933940887451172,
-0.589884877204895,
-0.44437167048454285,
-0.4389248490333557,
0.10078585147857666,
-0.8272431492805481,
0.6296628713607788,
0.20516638457775116,
1.1482460498809814,
0.020083654671907425,
-0.31532326340675354,
-0.10698998719453812,
-0.6468239426612854,
0.543879508972168,
-0.3493057191371918,
0.8060447573661804,
0.04774624481797218,
0.22336094081401825,
0.14798876643180847,
-0.7398841381072998,
-0.7021997570991516,
0.11788750439882278,
0.02694065310060978,
0.5241474509239197,
-0.05238635092973709,
0.06266804784536362,
0.10689418017864227,
0.13544777035713196,
-0.5063744187355042,
-0.013652656227350235,
-0.13541722297668457,
-0.09160862118005753,
0.2635260820388794,
0.2779575288295746,
0.21518512070178986,
0.00688783498480916,
-0.11875076591968536,
-0.20667022466659546,
-0.5006719827651978,
-0.18588456511497498,
0.2365863025188446,
0.10347490757703781,
0.1153155192732811,
0.25033366680145264,
-0.26967117190361023,
0.5317308902740479,
0.32765457034111023,
0.22866585850715637,
0.36615583300590515,
-0.42417699098587036,
0.29040294885635376,
0.24496576189994812,
0.21243230998516083,
0.5411984324455261,
-0.3357812762260437,
-0.2841167151927948,
-0.21965031325817108,
0.09935050457715988,
0.21201124787330627,
-1.1122419834136963,
0.001325711840763688,
0.11030378192663193,
-0.6393322348594666,
-0.1980140209197998,
0.38683512806892395,
-0.9811946749687195,
0.10662253946065903,
-0.15527217090129852,
0.8225221037864685,
-0.2530817985534668,
-0.24831704795360565,
0.2738667130470276,
-0.28056639432907104,
0.7012112736701965,
0.2969621419906616,
-0.27705657482147217,
0.09084401279687881,
0.7206097841262817,
0.8340011835098267,
0.003471244592219591,
0.11726618558168411,
-0.8791406750679016,
0.3581387996673584,
0.01890951208770275,
0.7434470057487488,
-1.0737069845199585,
-0.3801881968975067,
0.1461113840341568,
-0.16424036026000977,
0.09936908632516861,
-0.5157787203788757,
0.572788417339325,
-1.290544867515564,
-0.029791073873639107,
-0.24428707361221313,
-0.46735718846321106,
0.006633668672293425,
0.23798808455467224,
-0.6416977047920227,
1.1720306873321533,
-0.5861045718193054,
-0.5890660285949707,
0.40090322494506836,
-0.5651757717132568,
-0.5240717530250549,
0.10612619668245316,
-0.3735687732696533,
-0.541336178779602,
0.09183263033628464,
0.5042294263839722,
0.28039103746414185,
0.03701755404472351,
0.0869421437382698,
-0.4050928056240082,
-0.5425674915313721,
-0.205608069896698,
-0.12441244721412659,
0.04024931788444519,
0.2579783499240875,
-0.30642253160476685,
-0.5208578109741211,
-0.7474951148033142,
-0.09076585620641708,
0.4153780937194824,
-0.5108576416969299,
-0.46731841564178467,
0.435008704662323,
0.11163431406021118,
-0.054395902901887894,
0.31016671657562256,
-0.8205710649490356,
0.029276147484779358,
-0.467123806476593,
0.024238983169198036,
0.40676742792129517,
0.2690078318119049,
0.22746627032756805,
-0.23598834872245789,
0.26605144143104553,
0.05097924545407295,
0.07372701913118362,
-0.24185849726200104,
-0.3172869086265564,
-0.8006757497787476,
-0.019298629835247993,
0.21689550578594208,
0.702918291091919,
-0.582589864730835,
0.46065133810043335,
-0.362107515335083,
-0.12565916776657104,
-0.9365009069442749,
-0.3511768877506256,
0.518534779548645,
0.4914167523384094,
0.5660690665245056,
-0.2390739470720291,
-0.7121431231498718,
-0.6670459508895874,
-0.38087841868400574,
0.11111104488372803,
-0.04062473773956299,
0.39139464497566223,
0.16683782637119293,
-0.18782708048820496,
0.6897338628768921,
-0.6646156907081604,
-0.18858587741851807,
-0.12119752913713455,
0.32400912046432495,
0.02394837513566017,
0.2770356833934784,
0.23472461104393005,
-1.249674916267395,
-0.480875164270401,
-0.0568278431892395,
-0.7290305495262146,
-0.17264577746391296,
0.019748535007238388,
-0.07271020114421844,
0.13395023345947266,
0.5132287740707397,
-0.0248369462788105,
0.554311990737915,
-0.028184186667203903,
-0.28248849511146545,
0.19625850021839142,
-0.24037720263004303,
0.39634156227111816,
-0.705283522605896,
-0.08795129507780075,
-0.06849905103445053,
-0.21473845839500427,
-0.3031351566314697,
0.41910165548324585,
0.5120968818664551,
0.04010983929038048,
-0.3578266203403473,
0.5525053143501282,
-0.6602892875671387,
-0.026016337797045708,
-0.07065662741661072,
0.5557152628898621,
0.3917018473148346,
0.10749261826276779,
0.13080786168575287,
0.7007564306259155,
0.07408153265714645,
-0.7522512078285217,
0.14493252336978912,
0.39979949593544006,
-0.18574851751327515,
0.595706582069397,
-0.39456406235694885,
0.3332649767398834,
-0.5522944927215576,
0.15829022228717804,
-0.46725404262542725,
-0.12405212968587875,
-0.2651291489601135,
-0.33636364340782166,
0.7020993828773499,
-0.277419775724411,
-0.6064409017562866,
-0.25342169404029846,
-0.5209406018257141,
0.3632466197013855,
0.3869929313659668,
-1.0075820684432983,
0.6425603032112122,
0.3222615122795105,
-0.11591516435146332,
-0.5363732576370239,
-0.6129648089408875,
0.1587829291820526,
0.16866494715213776,
-0.5609863996505737,
0.8191119432449341,
-0.09618697315454483,
-0.038895707577466965,
0.29103884100914,
-0.20554623007774353,
0.14457787573337555,
0.013036658056080341,
-0.3258131742477417,
0.16584745049476624,
-0.14347444474697113,
0.10123619437217712,
0.06253770738840103,
-0.1558241844177246,
-0.42929714918136597,
-0.17997659742832184,
0.4372430741786957,
-0.07882323861122131,
-0.6592286825180054,
-0.5898191332817078,
0.5680994391441345,
0.015440491028130054,
-0.4377886950969696,
0.9169318675994873,
0.7980560660362244,
-0.41197502613067627,
0.13666574656963348,
-1.0668731927871704,
-0.4506400525569916,
-0.4243171513080597,
0.5731297135353088,
-0.5915040969848633,
-0.9297524690628052,
0.5403732657432556,
0.17982253432273865,
-0.15320301055908203,
0.19358709454536438,
0.25541937351226807,
-0.3387645483016968,
1.2920893430709839,
0.29144349694252014,
0.33309900760650635,
0.7482579350471497,
-0.2505985200405121,
0.3070574402809143,
-1.098649501800537,
-0.6517359614372253,
-0.3584766685962677,
-0.4594908654689789,
-0.37186896800994873,
-0.37434977293014526,
0.5219863057136536,
0.3149079382419586,
-0.02562204748392105,
0.062059711664915085,
-0.4411222040653229,
0.5922999382019043,
0.4127381145954132,
0.669298529624939,
0.30803412199020386,
-0.04961906000971794,
-0.22944645583629608,
-0.2830311357975006,
-0.7426230907440186,
-0.20370309054851532,
1.055266261100769,
-0.10072652995586395,
0.6432778239250183,
0.2761177718639374,
0.9184494018554688,
0.1153748631477356,
-0.02728958986699581,
-0.3903040885925293,
0.3099386394023895,
0.20013047754764557,
-0.5110906362533569,
0.023798638954758644,
-0.4001757800579071,
-0.8433918952941895,
0.5351448059082031,
-0.10802656412124634,
-0.41570132970809937,
0.621890664100647,
-0.07767477631568909,
-0.34753066301345825,
0.40336355566978455,
-0.45779526233673096,
0.3509290814399719,
-0.24987073242664337,
-0.7726333737373352,
-0.5740184187889099,
-0.6957153677940369,
-0.3415953814983368,
-0.0786011815071106,
0.3593941926956177,
0.09451935440301895,
-0.4419410228729248,
0.8410184979438782,
0.08184566348791122,
0.47596096992492676,
-0.22974203526973724,
0.3659950792789459,
0.04032651335000992,
0.2927815914154053,
1.2060904502868652,
0.0760272815823555,
-0.36206480860710144,
-0.2866055369377136,
-0.09920179843902588,
-0.5001547932624817,
-0.5493627786636353,
0.7353742718696594,
-0.5566353797912598,
-0.49316754937171936,
-0.1039743423461914,
0.19644330441951752,
0.046996235847473145,
-0.057741932570934296,
0.20131079852581024,
0.8408145308494568,
-0.43344709277153015,
0.3958386480808258,
0.8622767925262451,
-0.09885205328464508,
0.5607563257217407,
0.816632866859436,
-0.09731227904558182,
-0.28938713669776917,
0.9351208209991455,
0.15302330255508423,
-0.019245799630880356,
1.0673342943191528,
-0.09282008558511734,
-0.13185228407382965,
-0.6107956767082214,
-0.0017895048949867487,
0.2610678970813751,
-0.589115560054779,
-0.22713756561279297,
-1.1039211750030518,
0.16505368053913116,
-0.2290858030319214,
-0.5578604936599731,
-0.24117383360862732,
-0.32921117544174194,
-0.6480706334114075,
-0.41238299012184143,
0.028324641287326813,
0.30072399973869324,
-0.3341103196144104,
0.07582162320613861,
-1.0221056938171387,
0.3548486530780792,
0.07668043673038483,
0.4763071537017822,
0.065389484167099,
-0.4328956604003906,
-0.29375216364860535,
-0.4024261236190796,
-0.24000123143196106,
-0.8634947538375854,
0.41466665267944336,
0.4781987965106964,
0.8249905705451965,
0.3494056463241577,
0.24619881808757782,
0.6118171811103821,
-0.3294719159603119,
0.5052559971809387,
-0.08058489114046097,
-0.5047289133071899,
0.7973370552062988,
-0.12939861416816711,
-0.02831895276904106,
0.5444985628128052,
0.38432881236076355,
-0.39738014340400696,
-0.05104094371199608,
-0.6517813205718994,
-1.1242140531539917,
0.8377417325973511,
0.21921014785766602,
-0.0887180045247078,
-0.202325701713562,
0.4327986240386963,
-0.03490852192044258,
0.0862974226474762,
-0.381600022315979,
-0.22128042578697205,
-0.014449164271354675,
-0.2057299017906189,
0.22281379997730255,
-0.5981714725494385,
0.23455683887004852,
-0.07541348785161972,
0.6520457863807678,
0.16939546167850494,
0.44680771231651306,
0.6309863328933716,
-0.4588787257671356,
-0.11495664715766907,
0.27040183544158936,
-0.11998434364795685,
0.32495126128196716,
-0.7611173987388611,
0.11328697949647903,
0.24405066668987274,
-0.43240225315093994,
0.058786846697330475,
0.3921651840209961,
-0.19130456447601318,
-0.09426102787256241,
0.17321977019309998,
0.5873280167579651,
0.4508366286754608,
-0.6151580214500427,
0.6011937260627747,
-0.034756120294332504,
0.1767117828130722,
-0.05774185433983803,
-0.1597709059715271,
-0.15035754442214966,
0.4187457263469696,
0.8193196654319763,
-0.3830665349960327,
0.46306800842285156,
-0.45474866032600403,
0.4544636309146881,
0.26434823870658875,
-0.4729703962802887,
-0.47932544350624084,
0.7985705733299255,
0.6309723854064941,
-0.25691816210746765,
0.5512290596961975,
-0.39781132340431213,
-0.5922144651412964,
0.5490241050720215,
0.7338019013404846,
0.890418291091919,
-0.058976348489522934,
-0.20914433896541595,
0.3911566734313965,
0.2702430486679077,
0.04092811793088913,
0.5942614078521729,
-0.14156211912631989,
-0.7657198309898376,
-0.18814530968666077,
-0.7980305552482605,
-0.3301456868648529,
-0.18317364156246185,
-0.9103386402130127,
0.288311630487442,
0.01443750411272049,
-0.04930952936410904,
-0.2979208528995514,
0.044126469641923904,
-0.851763129234314,
-0.11895338445901871,
0.1348816156387329,
0.8648085594177246,
-0.24675635993480682,
0.43376976251602173,
0.6089656949043274,
-0.5010111331939697,
-0.10993239283561707,
0.23480412364006042,
-0.10201805830001831,
-0.5916885137557983,
0.49281659722328186,
0.14573560655117035,
-0.0949191153049469,
0.4387492537498474,
-0.18655163049697876,
-0.7697996497154236,
1.1104485988616943,
0.10009002685546875,
-1.0032744407653809,
-0.37377581000328064,
-0.5404543280601501,
0.2760489881038666,
-0.20062115788459778,
0.5716155767440796,
0.2910813093185425,
0.4071732759475708,
-0.06435947865247726,
-0.6715530753135681,
0.0008291199919767678,
-0.15163321793079376,
0.006481683813035488,
0.6309414505958557,
-0.729799747467041,
0.29298052191734314,
-0.20901329815387726,
-0.5980212688446045,
-0.3834371864795685,
0.6060542464256287,
0.07976558804512024,
0.5242982506752014,
-0.024284837767481804,
0.6986057162284851,
0.6646668314933777,
-0.06263664364814758,
1.1118509769439697,
-0.2682051658630371,
0.480744332075119,
0.8400680422782898,
-0.390354722738266,
1.1967023611068726,
0.3572990298271179,
-0.22237952053546906,
0.22171981632709503,
0.37549087405204773,
0.24946236610412598,
0.8677710890769958,
-0.28210410475730896,
-0.6144431233406067,
-0.5691875219345093,
-0.018115881830453873,
-0.4750390648841858,
-0.05971519649028778,
0.5734686255455017,
-0.091886505484581,
-0.32710525393486023,
0.17621570825576782,
-0.0791449025273323,
0.059011656790971756,
-0.19891314208507538,
0.9954754114151001,
-0.08949443697929382,
-0.11290090531110764,
0.25429558753967285,
-0.026053311303257942,
0.9653313159942627,
-0.28836140036582947,
-0.05265165492892265,
-0.2615668773651123,
0.19437409937381744,
-0.10410075634717941,
-0.5255881547927856,
0.18129006028175354,
-0.32962024211883545,
-0.11128533631563187,
0.12103613466024399,
0.7639579772949219,
-0.20022058486938477,
-0.38607481122016907,
0.7790741324424744,
0.48836585879325867,
-0.07524903863668442,
-0.09527585655450821,
-0.4579322934150696,
0.17255304753780365,
0.030326779931783676,
-0.4975217878818512,
0.43491822481155396,
0.2096729278564453,
0.2858821749687195,
0.3983479142189026,
0.5618926286697388,
0.008646209724247456,
0.25234654545783997,
0.028040731325745583,
0.7464689016342163,
-0.9604936242103577,
-0.573002815246582,
-0.6058743000030518,
0.08206961303949356,
-0.12006520479917526,
0.4178607165813446,
0.14901316165924072,
0.9638506770133972,
0.9627035856246948,
0.197298064827919,
0.9272316694259644,
-0.07526334375143051,
0.6682273745536804,
-0.46986475586891174,
0.30320051312446594,
-0.6946744322776794,
0.20692561566829681,
0.13903826475143433,
-0.7327312231063843,
-0.4164687693119049,
0.3546006381511688,
-0.08610718697309494,
-0.2550522983074188,
0.4543524980545044,
1.15134596824646,
-0.34727463126182556,
-0.010141020640730858,
0.35963335633277893,
0.17413267493247986,
0.43275609612464905,
0.3362734615802765,
0.9228522777557373,
-0.5711238980293274,
0.8555763363838196,
0.013344274833798409,
-0.2898755967617035,
-1.064731240272522,
-0.7562583088874817,
-0.3703635036945343,
-0.5545501112937927,
-0.3875667154788971,
-0.15073901414871216,
0.7350073456764221,
1.0617117881774902,
0.36204513907432556,
-0.7291020750999451,
0.28667694330215454,
0.16673599183559418,
-0.18363089859485626,
0.07457347214221954,
-0.24273818731307983,
0.3511319160461426,
-0.5467842817306519,
-0.6385496258735657,
0.6696985960006714,
0.38953813910484314,
-0.057362671941518784,
0.4848799705505371,
-0.001324280514381826,
-0.47823163866996765,
0.1330910325050354,
0.5749146938323975,
0.1618681252002716,
-0.534627377986908,
-0.48692747950553894,
-0.08355358988046646,
-0.04741863161325455,
0.3103354275226593,
0.5852141976356506,
-1.033690333366394,
0.7141491770744324,
0.6185964345932007,
0.6804344058036804,
1.1347849369049072,
-0.13036955893039703,
0.514055073261261,
-0.6021286249160767,
0.023486604914069176,
0.35333433747291565,
0.2672126889228821,
0.18978802859783173,
-0.5245014429092407,
0.5735176801681519,
0.46131277084350586,
-0.3190149664878845,
-0.8054394125938416,
0.0604543462395668,
-0.7039880156517029,
-0.023413293063640594,
0.8740692734718323,
0.2267918586730957,
0.09699234366416931,
-0.31224820017814636,
-0.015108983032405376,
0.5172315835952759,
-0.7750924229621887,
0.7106930613517761,
0.2896869480609894,
-0.36710911989212036,
-0.14197061955928802,
-0.5760827660560608,
0.09353563189506531,
0.23966237902641296,
-0.3295086920261383,
-0.2810417115688324,
0.3519986569881439,
0.06126515194773674,
0.08803942054510117,
0.3559999465942383,
-0.2733972370624542,
0.2321535050868988,
-0.05311411991715431,
0.2472206950187683,
-0.09661707282066345,
-0.18947124481201172,
-0.3007926046848297,
0.437216579914093,
-0.15138205885887146,
-0.18328016996383667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05971v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05971v1
|
Does Transformer Interpretability Transfer to RNNs?
| 2024-04-09T02:59:17 | 2024-04-09T02:59:17 |
Gonçalo Paulo, Thomas Marshall, Nora Belrose
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent advances in recurrent neural network architectures, such as Mamba and
RWKV, have enabled RNNs to match or exceed the performance of equal-size
transformers in terms of language modeling perplexity and downstream
evaluations, suggesting that future systems may be built on completely new
architectures. In this paper, we examine if selected interpretability methods
originally designed for transformer language models will transfer to these
up-and-coming recurrent architectures. Specifically, we focus on steering model
outputs via contrastive activation addition, on eliciting latent predictions
via the tuned lens, and eliciting latent knowledge from models fine-tuned to
produce false outputs under certain conditions. Our results show that most of
these techniques are effective when applied to RNNs, and we show that it is
possible to improve some of them by taking advantage of RNNs' compressed state.
|
[
-0.22115309536457062,
-0.2804347574710846,
0.529335618019104,
0.3172031342983246,
-0.24481822550296783,
-0.10755018889904022,
-0.22967837750911713,
-0.5899907946586609,
0.009008912369608879,
0.5728396773338318,
-0.6147654056549072,
0.15887799859046936,
-0.7849262356758118,
0.0963679850101471,
-0.7018979787826538,
1.0340787172317505,
0.031070398166775703,
-0.13299402594566345,
0.1579379290342331,
-0.10622081905603409,
-0.4572012722492218,
-0.1768578290939331,
-0.49484434723854065,
-0.8157615065574646,
0.6691631078720093,
0.17939558625221252,
1.0983948707580566,
0.5958784222602844,
0.532950758934021,
0.32092252373695374,
-0.27885252237319946,
-0.11741233617067337,
-0.46036189794540405,
0.12657606601715088,
-0.2505655884742737,
-0.6629443168640137,
-0.3903891444206238,
-0.040548115968704224,
0.6520078182220459,
0.722772479057312,
-0.3025294840335846,
-0.0006372783682309091,
0.3576352894306183,
0.5185835361480713,
-0.41176852583885193,
0.31467005610466003,
-0.7417976260185242,
0.35232147574424744,
0.07938235998153687,
-0.45117297768592834,
-0.7306495308876038,
-0.17758388817310333,
0.5729679465293884,
-0.789940595626831,
0.19411854445934296,
0.02355186827480793,
0.7865827679634094,
0.5959228277206421,
-0.18305890262126923,
-0.08667923510074615,
-0.9607240557670593,
0.8966675400733948,
-0.8886625170707703,
0.3034772574901581,
0.009219098836183548,
0.5447582006454468,
-0.06400329619646072,
-1.1118738651275635,
-0.5503913164138794,
-0.053138818591833115,
-0.6072958111763,
0.36885443329811096,
-0.5878317356109619,
-0.055388305336236954,
0.2710441052913666,
0.5820618271827698,
-0.30093517899513245,
0.24163709580898285,
-0.3822140097618103,
-0.11417392641305923,
0.2774668037891388,
0.27097904682159424,
0.09194093197584152,
-0.28198057413101196,
-0.34156662225723267,
-0.07228916883468628,
-0.5052050948143005,
-0.1697344034910202,
0.16686385869979858,
0.23293070495128632,
-0.38378989696502686,
0.4658900797367096,
-0.08774349838495255,
0.9364535808563232,
0.22608789801597595,
0.3749252259731293,
-0.006656124256551266,
-0.32700204849243164,
-0.29098618030548096,
-0.1950547695159912,
0.41090941429138184,
0.2793596088886261,
0.4270501434803009,
-0.46373292803764343,
-0.22548988461494446,
-0.08026043325662613,
0.6815700531005859,
-0.5341626405715942,
-0.5265411138534546,
-0.06458695232868195,
-0.8488123416900635,
-0.8330984711647034,
0.028242146596312523,
-0.8627752065658569,
-0.3837534487247467,
-0.43029332160949707,
0.6038693785667419,
-0.2403912991285324,
-0.4333944022655487,
0.16829054057598114,
-0.10423034429550171,
0.5042496919631958,
0.32919952273368835,
-0.8698475956916809,
0.20472444593906403,
0.6488999128341675,
0.8482128381729126,
-0.32012939453125,
-0.35011526942253113,
-0.4197465181350708,
-0.19125011563301086,
-0.1755969524383545,
0.6338818073272705,
-0.49473848938941956,
-0.1330295205116272,
-0.0003473014512564987,
0.08646087348461151,
-0.17472311854362488,
-0.5118670463562012,
0.24015146493911743,
-0.7426684498786926,
0.059073761105537415,
0.2479492425918579,
-0.2403751164674759,
-0.20420566201210022,
-0.08838487416505814,
-0.8711022138595581,
0.5415487289428711,
0.2847968339920044,
-0.458832323551178,
0.028479168191552162,
-0.5063673257827759,
-0.7680468559265137,
-0.3105947971343994,
0.12501879036426544,
-0.35840898752212524,
0.4803348779678345,
0.08356074243783951,
0.48590603470802307,
-0.16684085130691528,
0.28224217891693115,
-0.040045350790023804,
-0.4072786867618561,
0.7221645712852478,
-0.9688751101493835,
0.44037505984306335,
0.3383089601993561,
-0.4904862940311432,
0.1206112802028656,
-0.9319949150085449,
0.06372713297605515,
-0.0765441283583641,
-0.342050164937973,
0.12886293232440948,
-0.1497434824705124,
-0.07002206146717072,
0.18659809231758118,
-0.031552016735076904,
-0.17206385731697083,
0.03226706013083458,
-0.6145541667938232,
0.7597991824150085,
0.8939189314842224,
-0.18743622303009033,
0.8069349527359009,
-0.28427568078041077,
0.70998215675354,
0.10553433746099472,
0.08448668569326401,
-0.31454771757125854,
-0.6918161511421204,
-1.1725913286209106,
0.3765721321105957,
0.24550817906856537,
0.3870832622051239,
-1.0338068008422852,
0.25644487142562866,
-0.5679380893707275,
-0.5048342943191528,
-0.43595069646835327,
-0.28297552466392517,
0.359943687915802,
0.776843249797821,
0.47987130284309387,
-0.18273665010929108,
-0.4723767936229706,
-1.0087714195251465,
-0.49846741557121277,
0.05526912957429886,
0.005939166992902756,
0.3019527196884155,
0.216914564371109,
0.1959497332572937,
0.4759630560874939,
-0.41394954919815063,
0.03777749091386795,
-0.353177011013031,
0.39564114809036255,
0.47691360116004944,
0.48278093338012695,
0.14749883115291595,
-0.9376603960990906,
-0.10203535854816437,
0.20204071700572968,
-0.6657575964927673,
0.02063322253525257,
-0.2931094467639923,
0.17650610208511353,
-0.08519583195447922,
0.45115238428115845,
-0.3136635720729828,
0.6962296962738037,
0.8639009594917297,
-0.38987866044044495,
0.4863986074924469,
-0.11706285923719406,
-0.004736877512186766,
-0.9816028475761414,
-0.06672251969575882,
-0.14175282418727875,
-0.28086480498313904,
-0.8443027138710022,
-0.24097977578639984,
-0.16131936013698578,
-0.02627159282565117,
-0.47685104608535767,
0.5884283781051636,
-0.2721561789512634,
-0.4358122944831848,
-0.3937824070453644,
-0.10287953168153763,
0.12034796923398972,
0.35719916224479675,
0.095731221139431,
0.8381414413452148,
0.4069177806377411,
-0.6921192407608032,
0.17203818261623383,
0.2911921441555023,
-0.6423304080963135,
0.32247501611709595,
-0.8543202877044678,
-0.07056693732738495,
-0.04984700307250023,
0.32341498136520386,
-0.8314181566238403,
0.016616499051451683,
0.27720847725868225,
-0.5298578143119812,
0.37729737162590027,
-0.26794344186782837,
0.13572996854782104,
-0.01741427183151245,
0.3150938153266907,
0.34959307312965393,
0.5892230272293091,
-0.7214092016220093,
1.1193711757659912,
-0.4097112715244293,
-0.006309636868536472,
-0.8282598853111267,
-1.2686989307403564,
-0.027149206027388573,
-0.051059696823358536,
-0.47622212767601013,
0.49576056003570557,
0.22438406944274902,
-0.04889554902911186,
0.3448154926300049,
-0.08585996180772781,
-0.03161368891596794,
0.2720297873020172,
0.3692385256290436,
0.3498712480068207,
-0.7502841949462891,
-0.030405130237340927,
-0.05306192487478256,
-0.5681634545326233,
-0.15140944719314575,
-0.34667953848838806,
0.3528372049331665,
-0.21196329593658447,
-0.22541432082653046,
-0.5699144601821899,
-0.02232861891388893,
0.5966618657112122,
-0.18727941811084747,
0.9163308143615723,
0.6735584735870361,
-0.004000253509730101,
-0.19319257140159607,
-0.3276630938053131,
-0.5021030306816101,
-0.4900237023830414,
0.39580491185188293,
-0.4727267026901245,
-0.7543216943740845,
0.4735724627971649,
-0.12455287575721741,
-0.06310676038265228,
0.5333684086799622,
0.4752318263053894,
-0.041282135993242264,
0.7408633232116699,
0.48161178827285767,
0.21704663336277008,
0.6580647826194763,
-0.21978947520256042,
0.23756015300750732,
-0.9100270867347717,
-0.18042783439159393,
-0.36393803358078003,
-0.7193293571472168,
-0.6356351971626282,
-0.44543376564979553,
-0.06819947808980942,
-0.1841142624616623,
-0.08654946833848953,
0.46711891889572144,
-0.46128523349761963,
0.45291945338249207,
0.3549836277961731,
0.058449577540159225,
0.49602794647216797,
0.1903792917728424,
0.04647781327366829,
-0.18835300207138062,
-0.8695152997970581,
-0.2890511751174927,
1.0137569904327393,
0.4407638609409332,
0.8045791387557983,
0.05848473682999611,
0.017951402813196182,
0.22435709834098816,
0.7262283563613892,
-0.7583714127540588,
0.2878776490688324,
-0.5339705944061279,
-0.2821120619773865,
-0.15561942756175995,
-0.48869940638542175,
-0.9622536897659302,
0.4113132655620575,
-0.4664890468120575,
-0.6201307773590088,
0.5445424318313599,
0.1779663860797882,
-0.26966965198516846,
0.4676421582698822,
-0.6009644865989685,
0.6228597164154053,
-0.208027645945549,
-0.0359683483839035,
-0.3052358031272888,
-0.797089159488678,
0.2194807082414627,
0.17817042768001556,
-0.09716708958148956,
0.23682676255702972,
0.010948319919407368,
0.6058070659637451,
-0.02434711903333664,
0.8094394207000732,
0.08381272107362747,
-0.04681103304028511,
-0.12214653939008713,
0.21795251965522766,
0.4915100634098053,
-0.20837584137916565,
-0.29894596338272095,
0.410561740398407,
-0.3484637439250946,
-0.24314115941524506,
-1.2469180822372437,
0.5306891202926636,
-0.7537060976028442,
-0.5057799220085144,
-0.171336829662323,
-0.6561084389686584,
-0.14284181594848633,
0.14754287898540497,
0.45235103368759155,
0.782538115978241,
0.1619158685207367,
0.3391163647174835,
0.5913013815879822,
-0.1932050585746765,
0.22030991315841675,
0.6093347668647766,
-0.32342463731765747,
-0.10957103967666626,
0.9401235580444336,
-0.1511765718460083,
0.555959165096283,
0.491380512714386,
0.28400155901908875,
-0.16754159331321716,
-0.8331955075263977,
-0.4250173270702362,
0.03422662615776062,
-0.763993501663208,
-0.17288783192634583,
-0.3098295032978058,
-0.49472299218177795,
-0.021077755838632584,
-0.16884657740592957,
-0.48879295587539673,
-0.7210663557052612,
-0.4294203817844391,
-0.09914766252040863,
0.19017896056175232,
1.144403100013733,
-0.013287719339132309,
0.46973711252212524,
-0.8186342716217041,
0.3143540918827057,
0.2541922628879547,
0.46907714009284973,
0.3722536861896515,
-1.1191328763961792,
-0.16642335057258606,
-0.14930972456932068,
-0.08693823963403702,
-0.6799549460411072,
0.20759108662605286,
0.17374403774738312,
0.37785258889198303,
0.4481530487537384,
-0.18345355987548828,
0.5830100178718567,
-0.4553719162940979,
0.5931828618049622,
0.2546016573905945,
-0.83175128698349,
0.43061473965644836,
-0.004210497252643108,
0.14026646316051483,
0.1526481658220291,
0.09311182796955109,
-0.38311004638671875,
-0.32276448607444763,
-0.6923112273216248,
-0.5469148755073547,
0.8072464466094971,
0.33554989099502563,
0.3185023367404938,
0.4387010931968689,
0.706099271774292,
0.21755462884902954,
-0.008605804294347763,
-0.5451505184173584,
-0.5854730606079102,
-0.4394432008266449,
-0.250866174697876,
-0.18734660744667053,
-0.18501459062099457,
0.13363192975521088,
0.03868631273508072,
0.3730107843875885,
0.024003468453884125,
0.3150583803653717,
0.15005531907081604,
0.04128984361886978,
0.08634866029024124,
0.47899147868156433,
0.4791509509086609,
0.7273586988449097,
0.09471458196640015,
0.23933154344558716,
0.09853263199329376,
-0.3037400543689728,
0.15997575223445892,
0.03502035513520241,
-0.30576291680336,
-0.2240363359451294,
0.5343561172485352,
1.0911331176757812,
0.7038576006889343,
-0.11919485032558441,
0.3648064136505127,
-0.10899414867162704,
-0.06679265946149826,
-0.12330615520477295,
0.1390199363231659,
-0.0797409862279892,
0.40645965933799744,
0.20045886933803558,
0.6032288670539856,
-0.018553052097558975,
-0.3953264057636261,
0.17105460166931152,
0.05106855928897858,
-0.7953252196311951,
-0.41916221380233765,
0.5485914349555969,
0.09926499426364899,
-0.2927752137184143,
0.828976035118103,
0.3392915725708008,
-0.5031893253326416,
0.5553625822067261,
0.6941949129104614,
0.7414632439613342,
-0.21665409207344055,
0.08046739548444748,
0.2747333347797394,
0.3319583535194397,
0.01133403554558754,
-0.1372077614068985,
0.0063252560794353485,
-1.057809829711914,
-0.8704897165298462,
-0.5734423398971558,
-0.3872517943382263,
0.09103286266326904,
-1.1676236391067505,
0.009176635183393955,
-0.12442582100629807,
-0.0973421111702919,
0.30585694313049316,
-0.5840853452682495,
-0.7066548466682434,
0.33375445008277893,
-0.05016614496707916,
0.8403623700141907,
-0.8158195614814758,
0.7368236780166626,
0.6212523579597473,
-0.39196085929870605,
-1.0553315877914429,
-0.013987394981086254,
-0.13473373651504517,
-1.0199315547943115,
0.7554908990859985,
-0.13529913127422333,
-0.33579233288764954,
0.08496785908937454,
-0.32974812388420105,
-0.6817889213562012,
1.0705589056015015,
0.2800910472869873,
-0.4598613977432251,
-0.21890048682689667,
0.05720648169517517,
0.5212686061859131,
-0.33482933044433594,
0.21802513301372528,
0.7810707092285156,
0.7313985824584961,
0.12006822228431702,
-0.8412975072860718,
0.05193036049604416,
-0.1659892052412033,
0.04826083406805992,
-0.07862211763858795,
-0.23174327611923218,
0.742864191532135,
-0.23872479796409607,
-0.2908601462841034,
0.43732646107673645,
0.8860059976577759,
-0.2663682699203491,
0.11178417503833771,
0.5060693025588989,
0.4321368634700775,
0.48320725560188293,
-0.3052454888820648,
1.4185221195220947,
-0.10239429771900177,
0.17404118180274963,
1.249250888824463,
0.14875634014606476,
0.9695389270782471,
0.5218403935432434,
-0.2837540805339813,
0.701467752456665,
-0.08048053085803986,
-0.20346646010875702,
0.4268825948238373,
0.06020200997591019,
0.036342084407806396,
-0.3300894796848297,
-0.08758074790239334,
-0.2670741677284241,
0.5230898261070251,
0.3234013617038727,
-0.5555659532546997,
-0.020528893917798996,
0.09542159736156464,
-0.332677960395813,
0.13355353474617004,
-0.1542692333459854,
0.7220659255981445,
0.36632323265075684,
-0.7425822615623474,
0.3264390826225281,
-0.31991446018218994,
0.8246230483055115,
-0.42581894993782043,
-0.21544529497623444,
-0.16642768681049347,
0.3005504310131073,
-0.45059794187545776,
-1.0919080972671509,
0.66495281457901,
-0.26960453391075134,
-0.35771897435188293,
-0.2835121750831604,
1.0556964874267578,
-0.18893712759017944,
-0.4194177985191345,
0.33125001192092896,
0.6495975852012634,
0.17939940094947815,
0.061513304710388184,
-0.4506117105484009,
-0.04229562729597092,
0.06128406897187233,
-0.1753065139055252,
0.27781546115875244,
0.19025348126888275,
0.43470296263694763,
0.9192181825637817,
0.5668759346008301,
0.47973862290382385,
0.21166309714317322,
0.21049535274505615,
0.7879493236541748,
-0.5657972097396851,
-0.2473556101322174,
-0.5946964621543884,
0.5315552949905396,
0.2866501808166504,
-0.22887569665908813,
0.4640602171421051,
0.027336250990629196,
0.42051947116851807,
-0.09789449721574783,
0.577572226524353,
0.2139037549495697,
0.34781262278556824,
-0.8614497184753418,
0.8713029623031616,
-0.5391148924827576,
0.36528751254081726,
0.118328757584095,
-0.9620946049690247,
-0.22236114740371704,
0.592117965221405,
-0.3625766932964325,
0.03861450403928757,
0.5945476293563843,
0.6987614035606384,
-0.23230579495429993,
0.39989277720451355,
0.4589953124523163,
0.42589637637138367,
0.0803103893995285,
0.5363263487815857,
1.1924004554748535,
-0.5764505863189697,
0.9387207627296448,
-0.3043330907821655,
-0.05664597824215889,
-0.14464978873729706,
-1.0135959386825562,
-0.4407895505428314,
-0.5112331509590149,
-0.31943702697753906,
-0.6447920203208923,
0.033767737448215485,
0.07703236490488052,
0.6634057760238647,
-0.9665869474411011,
0.20222227275371552,
-0.2615518569946289,
0.27790239453315735,
-0.28627899289131165,
-0.26756685972213745,
0.20415768027305603,
-0.2526387870311737,
-0.47280198335647583,
0.39752519130706787,
0.26198747754096985,
0.11958979070186615,
-0.3026190996170044,
-0.04266329109668732,
0.4257466197013855,
-0.16340945661067963,
0.5355026125907898,
0.2546512186527252,
-0.9083948731422424,
-0.3555402457714081,
0.11595373600721359,
0.23056161403656006,
0.16634809970855713,
1.155064582824707,
-0.9742076396942139,
0.3846554756164551,
0.26571083068847656,
0.7845845818519592,
0.40377146005630493,
0.03403453156352043,
0.9515225291252136,
-0.41089069843292236,
0.07483445852994919,
0.24945038557052612,
0.34743350744247437,
0.2962518334388733,
-0.08642498403787613,
0.4580809473991394,
-0.20122118294239044,
-0.4195241630077362,
-0.3754592537879944,
0.4634791314601898,
-0.8212985992431641,
-0.046895820647478104,
1.1083462238311768,
-0.40685954689979553,
-0.07554202526807785,
-0.3235614597797394,
0.2348702996969223,
0.30842217803001404,
0.04040538892149925,
0.4508286714553833,
0.47401556372642517,
-0.034469716250896454,
-0.3031078279018402,
-0.48196646571159363,
0.34356093406677246,
0.8141891360282898,
-0.5505325198173523,
0.02594648115336895,
0.1364395171403885,
0.2560802400112152,
0.3221604824066162,
0.06714002788066864,
-0.2893463969230652,
0.3983283042907715,
-0.02886207215487957,
-0.39789092540740967,
-0.15534354746341705,
-0.340482234954834,
-0.9009107947349548,
-0.18731924891471863,
0.07327810674905777,
0.15502920746803284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05970v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05970v1
|
Optimization Methods for Personalizing Large Language Models through Retrieval Augmentation
| 2024-04-09T02:58:05 | 2024-04-09T02:58:05 |
Alireza Salemi, Surya Kallumadi, Hamed Zamani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This paper studies retrieval-augmented approaches for personalizing large
language models (LLMs), which potentially have a substantial impact on various
applications and domains. We propose the first attempt to optimize the
retrieval models that deliver a limited number of personal documents to large
language models for the purpose of personalized generation. We develop two
optimization algorithms that solicit feedback from the downstream personalized
generation tasks for retrieval optimization -- one based on reinforcement
learning whose reward function is defined using any arbitrary metric for
personalized generation and another based on knowledge distillation from the
downstream LLM to the retrieval model. This paper also introduces a pre- and
post-generation retriever selection model that decides what retriever to choose
for each LLM input. Extensive experiments on diverse tasks from the language
model personalization (LaMP) benchmark reveal statistically significant
improvements in six out of seven datasets.
|
[
-0.40186023712158203,
-0.7728344798088074,
0.7129272818565369,
0.19643427431583405,
0.04263639450073242,
0.2847708761692047,
-0.5465035438537598,
-0.29760459065437317,
0.12676601111888885,
0.6204661726951599,
-0.6493368148803711,
-0.22145506739616394,
-0.38301602005958557,
0.23613375425338745,
-0.21743614971637726,
0.7285884022712708,
0.33780741691589355,
0.09508205950260162,
-0.2570098042488098,
0.27734434604644775,
-0.5199654698371887,
-0.6697189211845398,
-0.6469161510467529,
-0.38897430896759033,
0.7762276530265808,
0.32339048385620117,
0.3382493257522583,
0.5784850716590881,
0.41147691011428833,
0.34966129064559937,
-0.3656260669231415,
0.2631566822528839,
-0.8278108835220337,
0.37917155027389526,
-0.482659250497818,
-0.5187410116195679,
0.07735298573970795,
-0.4128675162792206,
0.5759139657020569,
0.6953592896461487,
-0.19233717024326324,
0.2283216118812561,
-0.1133234053850174,
0.7309902310371399,
-0.9180912375450134,
-0.13640640676021576,
-0.6764581203460693,
-0.024755414575338364,
-0.25155988335609436,
-0.6372891068458557,
-0.6075175404548645,
-0.5843160152435303,
0.2122621387243271,
-0.44886618852615356,
0.10461468994617462,
0.2634648382663727,
0.4292932450771332,
0.06500592082738876,
-0.36654025316238403,
-0.349404901266098,
-0.9188387393951416,
1.1472312211990356,
-0.648840069770813,
0.20023119449615479,
0.3847143054008484,
0.3104698657989502,
-0.18998408317565918,
-0.6976070404052734,
-0.2501381039619446,
-0.5636864304542542,
-0.05831174924969673,
-0.09764853119850159,
-0.04407021775841713,
0.13874277472496033,
0.17337532341480255,
0.46758753061294556,
-0.397060364484787,
0.2495131939649582,
-0.21474811434745789,
-0.038605157285928726,
0.7115498781204224,
0.20303140580654144,
0.17384177446365356,
-0.09969225525856018,
-0.2680957317352295,
-0.14623481035232544,
-0.7483436465263367,
-0.124778613448143,
0.6367127895355225,
0.30821797251701355,
0.5074763894081116,
0.6449139714241028,
-0.5997939705848694,
0.8624804019927979,
0.19749745726585388,
-0.07565818727016449,
0.24363873898983002,
-0.49794715642929077,
0.13980630040168762,
-0.03819234296679497,
0.4516782760620117,
-0.06005417928099632,
0.17098769545555115,
-0.4020085036754608,
-0.5437840223312378,
-0.49055951833724976,
0.30750221014022827,
-0.7318642735481262,
0.061892759054899216,
0.1476142257452011,
-0.43051254749298096,
-0.6391335129737854,
-0.00665978854522109,
-0.41952037811279297,
-0.40351805090904236,
-0.460263192653656,
0.506549060344696,
-0.33420541882514954,
0.1452282965183258,
0.14398373663425446,
-0.033027105033397675,
-0.029276780784130096,
0.2593444287776947,
-1.3089580535888672,
0.28902727365493774,
0.6208513975143433,
0.5512065887451172,
-0.16233788430690765,
-0.07237476855516434,
-0.839819073677063,
0.3217502236366272,
-0.15757519006729126,
0.7572563290596008,
-0.7408514022827148,
-0.5854470729827881,
0.2748074233531952,
-0.26183345913887024,
0.2316543012857437,
-0.8335416913032532,
0.4391372799873352,
-1.1505236625671387,
0.1726309210062027,
-0.4324408173561096,
-0.6604078412055969,
-0.09447608143091202,
0.08504738658666611,
-0.5396125912666321,
0.8938563466072083,
0.23438489437103271,
-0.4533112049102783,
0.1148020327091217,
-0.6401419639587402,
-0.4831216037273407,
0.3670220971107483,
0.061090148985385895,
-0.042199231684207916,
0.5458739399909973,
0.11489685624837875,
0.40987908840179443,
-0.35571998357772827,
0.27756932377815247,
-0.160116508603096,
-0.28423935174942017,
0.19689548015594482,
-0.11880320310592651,
0.3673883378505707,
0.3894483149051666,
-0.03402024134993553,
0.23209121823310852,
-0.5970363616943359,
0.19457024335861206,
0.3050410747528076,
-0.8350562453269958,
-0.4964503347873688,
0.3216680586338043,
0.17759309709072113,
-0.05392509698867798,
0.8250945806503296,
-0.6168347001075745,
0.28521886467933655,
-0.5454049110412598,
0.2233840525150299,
0.9431453347206116,
0.0648951381444931,
0.285697340965271,
-0.2687143087387085,
0.5235146880149841,
-0.1674671173095703,
-0.06121402978897095,
-0.3503357768058777,
0.1889650821685791,
-0.4836408793926239,
0.09984257072210312,
0.423387736082077,
0.37851208448410034,
-0.6456575393676758,
0.5402848720550537,
-0.3301582336425781,
-0.11129158735275269,
-0.14502212405204773,
0.47367432713508606,
0.5358082056045532,
0.3154585063457489,
0.2509761154651642,
-0.3049323558807373,
-0.609160304069519,
-0.9578986167907715,
-0.3935651183128357,
0.06012055277824402,
0.014208201318979263,
0.5675163269042969,
0.18678076565265656,
-0.1915854662656784,
0.8829330801963806,
-0.8797826170921326,
-0.1089390218257904,
-0.34489190578460693,
-0.14784781634807587,
0.1862352043390274,
0.2732100486755371,
0.45960307121276855,
-0.7929404973983765,
-0.53602534532547,
0.3113194704055786,
-0.416768342256546,
-0.28568190336227417,
0.056760385632514954,
-0.02440566197037697,
-0.1118682324886322,
0.31736382842063904,
-0.2198413759469986,
-0.09854630380868912,
0.32495033740997314,
-0.07096850872039795,
0.7027034163475037,
-0.5000905990600586,
-0.11595001071691513,
-0.8879748582839966,
0.03382819518446922,
0.04927194118499756,
-0.45252853631973267,
-0.6492977142333984,
0.30155518651008606,
-0.17538981139659882,
0.013039492070674896,
-0.303935170173645,
0.8450673818588257,
-0.5116750001907349,
-0.12263724952936172,
-0.5059205293655396,
0.2303796112537384,
-0.22999362647533417,
0.38809338212013245,
-0.0972437635064125,
0.7676980495452881,
0.16892890632152557,
-0.621090829372406,
0.46300971508026123,
0.3380148708820343,
-0.35608822107315063,
0.3056129813194275,
-0.7314671277999878,
0.35527682304382324,
-0.29608047008514404,
-0.16779056191444397,
-0.7569077610969543,
-0.33250007033348083,
-0.18311181664466858,
-0.1861933469772339,
0.3813306987285614,
0.19016069173812866,
-0.5588194727897644,
-0.23549269139766693,
-0.4639059901237488,
0.17088980972766876,
0.5125245451927185,
-0.9550379514694214,
0.3783828616142273,
0.27630114555358887,
-0.34208744764328003,
-0.40973588824272156,
-0.23668493330478668,
-0.0011515002697706223,
-0.14903555810451508,
-0.6501597166061401,
0.673776388168335,
-0.2623112201690674,
-0.1649031937122345,
-0.18019479513168335,
0.198935866355896,
0.30447739362716675,
0.09770646691322327,
-0.16442719101905823,
-0.01837177202105522,
0.02872529625892639,
0.24098455905914307,
0.20491304993629456,
-0.06228556111454964,
-0.09194090962409973,
-0.2368665635585785,
0.8405913710594177,
0.04581666737794876,
-0.24117794632911682,
-0.046200890094041824,
0.2775457203388214,
-0.15029588341712952,
-0.45904290676116943,
0.7404634952545166,
0.5055068731307983,
-0.1485140323638916,
-0.22783063352108002,
-0.9690174460411072,
-0.2668472230434418,
-0.557572603225708,
0.6282500624656677,
-0.5522371530532837,
-1.0409568548202515,
0.3436134159564972,
-0.389077365398407,
-0.01852400042116642,
0.16280287504196167,
0.7623795866966248,
0.06100644916296005,
1.331681728363037,
0.5838661193847656,
-0.16280025243759155,
0.9038680791854858,
-0.18967820703983307,
0.017598707228899002,
-1.1192729473114014,
-0.3159005343914032,
-0.5347558856010437,
-0.3430846035480499,
-0.47621622681617737,
-0.22943706810474396,
0.18456420302391052,
0.2446003407239914,
-0.3675576448440552,
0.10399880260229111,
-0.513177216053009,
0.537665605545044,
0.9214659929275513,
0.22471408545970917,
0.4820491075515747,
0.3187001347541809,
0.013244714587926865,
-0.0326334573328495,
-0.4861331284046173,
-0.49241364002227783,
1.1087173223495483,
0.056857652962207794,
0.887298583984375,
0.2863994538784027,
0.9973620176315308,
0.33555009961128235,
0.1829933077096939,
-0.6298598647117615,
0.4720146059989929,
-0.38951748609542847,
-0.5247935056686401,
-0.33924582600593567,
-0.6283020377159119,
-1.166490912437439,
0.35126620531082153,
0.01262920256704092,
-1.0315911769866943,
0.15875500440597534,
0.14036902785301208,
-0.2351343035697937,
-0.08328258991241455,
-0.6655287742614746,
0.5722164511680603,
-0.5950430035591125,
-0.48929551243782043,
-0.5512732267379761,
-0.5171783566474915,
0.4615105986595154,
-0.2183322310447693,
-0.06616365164518356,
0.18235109746456146,
-0.23848946392536163,
0.41575872898101807,
-0.437269002199173,
0.37748226523399353,
-0.24014729261398315,
0.13996227085590363,
0.014860509894788265,
-0.0031805916223675013,
0.7652701735496521,
-0.09263542294502258,
-0.3671475052833557,
-0.5393871665000916,
0.010440386831760406,
-0.3340815007686615,
-0.667308509349823,
0.9465561509132385,
-0.7124306559562683,
-0.9779379367828369,
-0.07137756049633026,
-0.2759262025356293,
-0.35463419556617737,
0.36356043815612793,
0.169959157705307,
0.33026477694511414,
-0.2844734489917755,
0.4566199779510498,
0.7100411653518677,
-0.569855809211731,
0.3345511257648468,
0.4762876331806183,
-0.42302748560905457,
-0.38365477323532104,
1.1810775995254517,
-0.1472199261188507,
0.2503170073032379,
0.6245339512825012,
0.48278945684432983,
-0.4951817989349365,
-0.7959280014038086,
-0.04727940261363983,
0.4307309687137604,
-0.7196450233459473,
-0.13591255247592926,
-0.4399721622467041,
0.05316384881734848,
-0.23129938542842865,
0.0008546421304345131,
-0.07413158565759659,
-0.13981132209300995,
-0.47956129908561707,
0.017532791942358017,
0.2244594395160675,
0.7109025716781616,
0.11765609681606293,
0.4607818126678467,
-0.8239489793777466,
0.2370891571044922,
0.22095884382724762,
0.2606061100959778,
0.1405802071094513,
-0.4860328137874603,
-0.34536924958229065,
-0.0558992400765419,
-0.4965763986110687,
-0.6865527033805847,
0.46998998522758484,
0.22061410546302795,
0.7605297565460205,
0.4740326404571533,
-0.11591464281082153,
0.4352366626262665,
-0.5247475504875183,
0.5711542367935181,
0.14543573558330536,
-0.7732559442520142,
0.7130904197692871,
-0.36058834195137024,
0.22693583369255066,
0.5748489499092102,
0.24178099632263184,
-0.4505852460861206,
0.1430772989988327,
-0.38644203543663025,
-0.8137303590774536,
0.682214081287384,
-0.02907780557870865,
0.5522518157958984,
-0.11569184064865112,
0.6764145493507385,
-0.034678179770708084,
0.4363437592983246,
-0.49678051471710205,
-0.20136988162994385,
0.39872971177101135,
-0.15134167671203613,
-0.1182774230837822,
-0.45021939277648926,
0.009732022881507874,
-0.02463856153190136,
0.7802514433860779,
-0.18012575805187225,
-0.04860296472907066,
0.03769225999712944,
-0.2229703664779663,
-0.047722846269607544,
0.16784851253032684,
0.5814021825790405,
0.7237341403961182,
-0.1555607169866562,
-0.318604975938797,
0.1463121771812439,
-0.23258627951145172,
0.19067886471748352,
0.09062367677688599,
-0.3420937657356262,
-0.02940262295305729,
0.08492007851600647,
0.8779432773590088,
0.18440866470336914,
-0.850311815738678,
0.3903799057006836,
0.07261908054351807,
0.11098889261484146,
-0.4149318039417267,
0.22701194882392883,
0.18565146625041962,
0.3556012511253357,
0.5136054754257202,
-0.4012218713760376,
0.3798716068267822,
-0.4324703514575958,
-0.14373460412025452,
0.8063287734985352,
0.06628227978944778,
-0.33747419714927673,
0.753503143787384,
0.11916396766901016,
-0.4466688930988312,
0.4148006737232208,
-0.1475936472415924,
-0.34702634811401367,
0.23964795470237732,
0.5519147515296936,
0.8701715469360352,
-0.33025190234184265,
0.10684606432914734,
0.24360157549381256,
-0.12354400753974915,
-0.23962469398975372,
0.11829466372728348,
-0.10828891396522522,
-0.6701265573501587,
-0.5392846465110779,
-0.8487181663513184,
-0.3438335955142975,
0.09257479757070541,
-0.5635043382644653,
0.3550204634666443,
-0.3556195795536041,
-0.28006958961486816,
-0.006596559192985296,
0.37649989128112793,
-0.7019838690757751,
0.2377074509859085,
0.09278033673763275,
0.6693093776702881,
-0.08669015765190125,
0.6838371753692627,
0.6051303744316101,
-0.5123680830001831,
-0.5406999588012695,
-0.28193625807762146,
-0.35567981004714966,
-0.7942895293235779,
1.13375985622406,
-0.30039507150650024,
-0.1644294559955597,
0.29176580905914307,
-0.3705182373523712,
-0.9626651406288147,
1.020946741104126,
0.48043277859687805,
-0.7634744048118591,
-0.2896963059902191,
-0.039704643189907074,
0.5673618316650391,
-0.36529749631881714,
0.2839834988117218,
0.5348367691040039,
0.4340226948261261,
0.04448765888810158,
-0.5794363021850586,
-0.018846413120627403,
-0.06355608254671097,
0.7792555689811707,
0.2046556919813156,
-0.7801374197006226,
0.5086134672164917,
-0.27417370676994324,
-0.01617634855210781,
0.3530215620994568,
0.5439384579658508,
0.5179244875907898,
-0.0526915043592453,
0.3915078938007355,
0.3756934404373169,
0.6481018662452698,
0.06269081681966782,
1.5963866710662842,
-0.46468591690063477,
0.37382298707962036,
0.9773304462432861,
-0.2610782980918884,
0.8872535228729248,
0.5781518816947937,
-0.38322335481643677,
0.28416648507118225,
0.6502721905708313,
-0.01763252355158329,
0.7295701503753662,
0.5791705250740051,
-0.5868712663650513,
-0.04875125735998154,
-0.20313534140586853,
-0.24275492131710052,
0.10569662600755692,
0.19069698452949524,
-0.6253474354743958,
0.07005969434976578,
0.0885697603225708,
-0.33281809091567993,
0.1749023199081421,
-0.20603735744953156,
1.0104752779006958,
-0.07500352710485458,
-0.7568044066429138,
0.429305762052536,
0.4104978144168854,
0.718193769454956,
-0.6055359244346619,
0.3055746853351593,
-0.34695252776145935,
0.28617095947265625,
-0.32847654819488525,
-0.3733139932155609,
0.002242082729935646,
-0.20086780190467834,
-0.3150425851345062,
-0.3599591553211212,
0.9586668014526367,
-0.4276362955570221,
-0.43490809202194214,
0.32986685633659363,
0.4717702865600586,
-0.027812818065285683,
-0.1892772614955902,
-0.42270275950431824,
0.11076430976390839,
0.05296730622649193,
-0.7927903532981873,
0.6632117629051208,
-0.02539433352649212,
0.0747193768620491,
0.8407080173492432,
0.8597353100776672,
0.4067543148994446,
0.3081488609313965,
0.3072325587272644,
0.9440905451774597,
-0.6669934391975403,
-0.3821871280670166,
-0.7988488674163818,
0.2161262482404709,
-0.018827585503458977,
-0.06548377126455307,
0.7158990502357483,
0.6918128132820129,
0.9959110617637634,
-0.38561949133872986,
0.8988982439041138,
0.1705295741558075,
0.6895241737365723,
-0.6096351146697998,
0.16907653212547302,
-0.7286835312843323,
0.5280771255493164,
-0.19066260755062103,
-1.3271114826202393,
0.022301025688648224,
0.4148973226547241,
-0.6448072195053101,
0.43743059039115906,
0.324185311794281,
0.8497181534767151,
0.12173458933830261,
-0.23368306457996368,
0.37285882234573364,
-0.04874206334352493,
0.3807278573513031,
0.45841681957244873,
0.964287519454956,
-0.12607420980930328,
0.3494897484779358,
-0.34886452555656433,
-0.014106103219091892,
-0.5256253480911255,
-0.5834723711013794,
-0.5851683616638184,
-0.5439317226409912,
-0.1523759812116623,
-0.11346469819545746,
0.2048359364271164,
0.9120182991027832,
0.6680130362510681,
-0.5793294906616211,
-0.3868362307548523,
-0.07068892568349838,
0.07044612616300583,
0.11690903455018997,
-0.24643200635910034,
0.18069705367088318,
-0.7679714560508728,
-1.0072627067565918,
0.5278207659721375,
0.22126802802085876,
-0.22004595398902893,
-0.5289323329925537,
-0.3421888053417206,
-0.18496297299861908,
0.011115326546132565,
0.8796382546424866,
0.3083292841911316,
-0.8123953938484192,
-0.24176934361457825,
0.13624386489391327,
0.0373535118997097,
0.04222866892814636,
0.9505285024642944,
-0.8254113793373108,
0.6014453172683716,
0.7252424359321594,
0.9160043001174927,
0.7986454367637634,
0.475492388010025,
0.6871582269668579,
-0.9444937109947205,
-0.1022329330444336,
0.25457876920700073,
0.28495728969573975,
0.41871386766433716,
-0.6351986527442932,
0.4050973057746887,
-0.04062756896018982,
-0.6451433897018433,
-0.9043433666229248,
0.3480002284049988,
-0.6253006458282471,
-0.27838727831840515,
1.0742303133010864,
-0.003464791923761368,
-0.04017302021384239,
0.28830257058143616,
-0.28099068999290466,
-0.07406443357467651,
-0.318180650472641,
0.6140360236167908,
0.7493012547492981,
-0.26418453454971313,
-0.1547173112630844,
-0.5314804911613464,
0.4358327090740204,
0.6174562573432922,
-0.8475589752197266,
-0.12798984348773956,
0.5267960429191589,
0.31586095690727234,
0.14521615207195282,
0.4882054626941681,
-0.09104710817337036,
0.06585143506526947,
-0.48579853773117065,
-0.042778559029102325,
-0.153024822473526,
0.0158404354006052,
-0.4862092137336731,
0.1519215703010559,
0.457828164100647,
0.14549235999584198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05967v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05967v1
|
JSTR: Judgment Improves Scene Text Recognition
| 2024-04-09T02:55:12 | 2024-04-09T02:55:12 |
Masato Fujitake
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we present a method for enhancing the accuracy of scene text
recognition tasks by judging whether the image and text match each other. While
previous studies focused on generating the recognition results from input
images, our approach also considers the model's misrecognition results to
understand its error tendencies, thus improving the text recognition pipeline.
This method boosts text recognition accuracy by providing explicit feedback on
the data that the model is likely to misrecognize by predicting correct or
incorrect between the image and text. The experimental results on publicly
available datasets demonstrate that our proposed method outperforms the
baseline and state-of-the-art methods in scene text recognition.
|
[
-0.1143430769443512,
-0.47561874985694885,
0.7210608720779419,
-0.0011529414914548397,
-0.2819252908229828,
0.11693662405014038,
0.17432479560375214,
-0.7181541919708252,
-0.22936002910137177,
0.5404719710350037,
-0.17921961843967438,
-0.2973535656929016,
-0.6236779093742371,
0.38464510440826416,
-0.4128359258174896,
0.6677969098091125,
0.11885768175125122,
0.3395054042339325,
-0.3981698751449585,
-0.07291392236948013,
-0.7028850317001343,
-0.1309945285320282,
-0.7677720785140991,
-0.200645312666893,
0.5609663128852844,
0.25247111916542053,
0.5296205878257751,
0.7169312834739685,
0.9467805027961731,
0.473168283700943,
-0.23313754796981812,
0.38398483395576477,
-0.14578860998153687,
0.09583006799221039,
-0.3104322552680969,
-0.21410222351551056,
0.11495114117860794,
-0.23183754086494446,
0.5896122455596924,
0.03987661004066467,
0.36372703313827515,
0.055978287011384964,
0.2749653160572052,
0.7638581395149231,
-0.8676536679267883,
-0.11205191910266876,
-0.3553377091884613,
0.18261687457561493,
-0.16181352734565735,
-0.5887093544006348,
-0.6799331903457642,
-0.4079669415950775,
0.21830472350120544,
-0.3472708761692047,
0.4923248291015625,
0.18537737429141998,
0.9180939197540283,
0.3340742290019989,
-0.46351689100265503,
-0.1024860069155693,
-0.7594387531280518,
0.49927306175231934,
-0.5555062890052795,
0.49935001134872437,
0.30592218041419983,
0.40305617451667786,
-0.022237855941057205,
-0.6965554356575012,
-0.6114147901535034,
-0.0921139046549797,
-0.2922798693180084,
0.290524959564209,
0.037813376635313034,
0.004940364044159651,
0.5018109083175659,
0.3985432982444763,
-0.17663557827472687,
-0.4833603799343109,
-0.22572940587997437,
-0.3699572682380676,
0.26440444588661194,
0.09973369538784027,
0.3127329349517822,
-0.3109726011753082,
-0.5178184509277344,
-0.5789310336112976,
-0.0596165806055069,
0.23907609283924103,
0.002795204985886812,
0.31193411350250244,
0.32591474056243896,
0.5671964883804321,
0.043195512145757675,
0.962661623954773,
0.08483098447322845,
-0.22326980531215668,
0.5503895282745361,
-0.5473195314407349,
-0.33751004934310913,
0.02526874840259552,
0.5299375057220459,
0.9590497016906738,
0.05657551437616348,
0.10543457418680191,
-0.16929340362548828,
0.03394467383623123,
0.5234101414680481,
-0.8314680457115173,
-0.27859732508659363,
-0.21485544741153717,
-0.5559990406036377,
-0.4614125192165375,
0.19357989728450775,
-0.908079206943512,
-0.6696893572807312,
-0.3213033676147461,
0.6083256006240845,
-0.42425644397735596,
0.009396446868777275,
-0.0603473074734211,
-0.7190292477607727,
0.13491162657737732,
0.8985024094581604,
-0.28202372789382935,
0.037712354212999344,
0.1434977948665619,
0.8235189914703369,
0.2318599373102188,
-0.10158490389585495,
-0.481973797082901,
-0.08400261402130127,
-0.531851589679718,
1.2248196601867676,
-0.4982130229473114,
-0.33713048696517944,
-0.2376173883676529,
-0.12311070412397385,
-0.16573119163513184,
-0.46900618076324463,
0.8622872829437256,
-0.3747234046459198,
0.42867475748062134,
-0.4441111385822296,
-0.4311148226261139,
-0.21169881522655487,
0.49435266852378845,
-0.8949869871139526,
1.307042121887207,
-0.07763832807540894,
-1.3054851293563843,
0.6318817138671875,
-0.33671772480010986,
-0.2940561771392822,
0.0807560533285141,
0.008514583110809326,
-0.645990252494812,
0.24143677949905396,
0.7513183951377869,
0.41070041060447693,
0.2716507315635681,
-0.1282835602760315,
-0.20461149513721466,
-0.3793827295303345,
0.44679397344589233,
-0.5319393277168274,
0.3338300883769989,
0.24471250176429749,
0.22833336889743805,
-0.004658161196857691,
-0.7425934076309204,
0.3153609335422516,
-0.04803179204463959,
-0.404033899307251,
-0.7645700573921204,
0.12899748980998993,
0.29264211654663086,
0.131879061460495,
0.3291427493095398,
-0.664673924446106,
-0.23282626271247864,
-0.49330073595046997,
-0.17220865190029144,
0.5002565383911133,
0.18837246298789978,
0.529125988483429,
-0.30127114057540894,
0.14061836898326874,
0.03638242185115814,
-0.17574188113212585,
-0.6486789584159851,
-0.30304962396621704,
-0.8091197609901428,
-0.12668372690677643,
0.7143193483352661,
0.8371784687042236,
-0.937635064125061,
0.46754905581474304,
0.0031569399870932102,
-0.43494364619255066,
-0.19939671456813812,
-0.46428751945495605,
0.9414967894554138,
0.7839906811714172,
0.45376232266426086,
-0.34068360924720764,
-0.8616417050361633,
-0.6939201354980469,
-0.66438227891922,
-0.16270862519741058,
0.06708197295665741,
0.5783877372741699,
0.31444424390792847,
0.07798748463392258,
0.8604100346565247,
-0.38121548295021057,
-0.3144345283508301,
-0.33647850155830383,
0.09781728684902191,
-0.04718489199876785,
0.6576864123344421,
0.44566288590431213,
-0.8092196583747864,
-0.39004531502723694,
0.2675335109233856,
-0.6120752096176147,
0.03803892433643341,
-0.10622135549783707,
-0.04293350130319595,
0.16573432087898254,
0.5764175057411194,
0.06474162638187408,
0.7990239262580872,
0.28381770849227905,
-0.7825825810432434,
0.30428972840309143,
-0.3202328681945801,
1.0026429891586304,
-1.1570082902908325,
-0.12918144464492798,
0.3670330047607422,
-0.7800966501235962,
-0.6092150211334229,
0.09649143368005753,
0.26332390308380127,
0.2077353298664093,
-0.41565006971359253,
0.5296854376792908,
-0.21331055462360382,
-0.40515798330307007,
-0.2776879072189331,
0.06995376944541931,
0.28340616822242737,
0.21947753429412842,
0.1250292956829071,
1.0676277875900269,
0.15305395424365997,
-0.6044033765792847,
-0.1358184814453125,
0.463591605424881,
-0.7340158820152283,
0.7597957253456116,
-0.6188242435455322,
0.21746447682380676,
-0.27521029114723206,
0.163496732711792,
-1.4645397663116455,
-0.43560129404067993,
0.04897255823016167,
-0.762736976146698,
0.24845801293849945,
0.022868767380714417,
-0.5128777623176575,
-0.29564204812049866,
0.029816564172506332,
0.4110538363456726,
0.24073976278305054,
-0.8160498142242432,
0.8280770778656006,
0.14964281022548676,
0.13992276787757874,
-0.6674325466156006,
-0.8308730721473694,
0.15495577454566956,
-0.02932693250477314,
-0.1469731628894806,
0.32689324021339417,
0.24943174421787262,
-0.14109808206558228,
-0.20897257328033447,
-0.19374118745326996,
-0.4103453755378723,
-0.13998329639434814,
0.027323748916387558,
0.39520710706710815,
0.21735000610351562,
0.17920319736003876,
0.22320206463336945,
-0.1685485690832138,
-0.13767343759536743,
0.1891825646162033,
0.2623496949672699,
0.046756673604249954,
-0.076496422290802,
-0.6392451524734497,
-0.13250194489955902,
0.2311023771762848,
-0.08710139989852905,
-0.05115301534533501,
0.4732341766357422,
-0.344262957572937,
0.17865069210529327,
-0.49380508065223694,
0.19384843111038208,
-0.4633255898952484,
0.37062713503837585,
-0.432267427444458,
-0.743518590927124,
0.2558877170085907,
-0.17749257385730743,
-0.23193594813346863,
0.42196810245513916,
0.059528544545173645,
-0.37445205450057983,
1.02511727809906,
0.4305758476257324,
0.22726376354694366,
0.7628389596939087,
0.3845343291759491,
0.12217895686626434,
-0.8870331645011902,
-0.2065146267414093,
-0.93583083152771,
-0.32325491309165955,
-0.273924857378006,
-0.614734411239624,
0.22425256669521332,
-0.05112547054886818,
-0.17179211974143982,
0.5591686964035034,
-0.7714859843254089,
1.258020281791687,
0.4780944287776947,
0.7218371033668518,
0.5778319835662842,
-0.09461334347724915,
-0.44343993067741394,
-0.4800165593624115,
-0.3963523209095001,
-0.4703996777534485,
0.7373649477958679,
0.2847936153411865,
0.4208711087703705,
-0.2049819529056549,
0.6745858192443848,
0.48167890310287476,
0.06867978721857071,
-0.5414637923240662,
0.577549159526825,
-0.2555074691772461,
-0.43238118290901184,
-0.10524120181798935,
-0.3847411870956421,
-0.6254562139511108,
0.22581453621387482,
-0.4633340537548065,
-0.6819862127304077,
0.34959664940834045,
0.2742764353752136,
-0.08414936065673828,
0.20778387784957886,
-0.6709504127502441,
0.8209136724472046,
0.047354135662317276,
-0.29160934686660767,
-0.0549703948199749,
-0.6148105263710022,
0.2767786383628845,
0.21558576822280884,
0.06581608206033707,
0.28200796246528625,
0.05661999434232712,
0.7174696922302246,
-0.3558994233608246,
0.799481987953186,
-0.2444935441017151,
0.04260235279798508,
0.30849912762641907,
0.12462116777896881,
0.5155221819877625,
-0.16776375472545624,
-0.030659768730401993,
-0.04374061897397041,
-0.09473496675491333,
-0.09643995761871338,
-0.6982645988464355,
0.2738479673862457,
-0.35371747612953186,
0.03170682117342949,
-0.6312068700790405,
-0.41426539421081543,
-0.1475864201784134,
0.2376483678817749,
0.4478456676006317,
0.778796911239624,
-0.4491886794567108,
-0.09028369188308716,
0.6199876666069031,
-0.3251610994338989,
0.6485834121704102,
0.1413734257221222,
-0.5457856059074402,
-1.0136220455169678,
0.4887794554233551,
-0.34828782081604004,
0.14356224238872528,
0.6813054084777832,
0.08625470101833344,
-0.5460445284843445,
-0.5764791965484619,
-0.5763031840324402,
-0.4760381579399109,
-0.852227509021759,
-0.6359617114067078,
-0.624274492263794,
-0.1553138792514801,
0.057880982756614685,
-0.14343303442001343,
-0.24974195659160614,
-0.2985416352748871,
-0.23870272934436798,
-0.00271036964841187,
0.4585944712162018,
0.7474594712257385,
0.3538154363632202,
0.38358205556869507,
-0.9870676398277283,
0.15924657881259918,
0.1468236744403839,
0.30690330266952515,
-0.14677968621253967,
-0.7047923803329468,
-0.2951114773750305,
-0.21200594305992126,
-0.1874621957540512,
-0.5365675091743469,
0.45502063632011414,
0.11117767542600632,
0.005066961050033569,
0.16910718381404877,
-0.08209773153066635,
1.1302815675735474,
-0.7661336064338684,
0.5605583190917969,
0.35595911741256714,
-1.2990890741348267,
0.8924429416656494,
-0.3204687237739563,
0.6278616189956665,
0.8798741102218628,
-0.3089218735694885,
-0.11712562292814255,
-0.5816546678543091,
-0.6246413588523865,
-0.4128250181674957,
0.48305198550224304,
0.42877596616744995,
0.12432067841291428,
0.19638638198375702,
0.165792778134346,
-0.1715533584356308,
0.020302142947912216,
-0.6993415355682373,
0.2218775898218155,
-0.1706513911485672,
-0.4321671426296234,
0.08172659575939178,
-0.16759593784809113,
0.27088069915771484,
-0.47145766019821167,
0.21133199334144592,
-0.14300581812858582,
0.5565543174743652,
0.8100039958953857,
0.022081322968006134,
-0.18295221030712128,
0.29004424810409546,
0.378276526927948,
0.40389230847358704,
-0.21420715749263763,
0.10701601207256317,
0.4246850609779358,
-0.7173396944999695,
0.21610167622566223,
-0.12937785685062408,
-0.152308389544487,
0.35479897260665894,
0.5668770670890808,
0.7040292620658875,
0.30666273832321167,
-0.6897090673446655,
0.7907643914222717,
-0.41799771785736084,
-0.4370330274105072,
-0.1345835030078888,
0.36385825276374817,
-0.5721808671951294,
0.6486629247665405,
0.35141780972480774,
1.1354074478149414,
0.5466468334197998,
-0.10596881806850433,
0.41418200731277466,
0.19700101017951965,
-0.6296628713607788,
0.22686201333999634,
0.27599677443504333,
0.0647912323474884,
-0.5410047173500061,
0.2707960307598114,
-0.2419949173927307,
-0.7690799236297607,
0.7744033336639404,
0.6911631226539612,
0.90006422996521,
-0.30346542596817017,
0.02166507951915264,
0.9441682696342468,
0.09448771178722382,
-0.4943176507949829,
0.29071059823036194,
-0.046455055475234985,
-1.0129231214523315,
-0.6677619814872742,
-0.39081066846847534,
-0.6110708713531494,
-0.19399429857730865,
-0.6037321090698242,
0.34522613883018494,
-0.6607580780982971,
-0.2072301208972931,
-0.0991387888789177,
-0.1460934579372406,
-0.37220102548599243,
0.8028703927993774,
-0.18891361355781555,
1.0024011135101318,
-0.5804492235183716,
0.6412428021430969,
0.6251246929168701,
-0.08554346114397049,
-0.7323338985443115,
0.41725674271583557,
-0.19561149179935455,
-0.4215967059135437,
0.7295886278152466,
0.6233078837394714,
-0.2543319761753082,
0.07952648401260376,
-0.5200024843215942,
-0.7947708964347839,
0.8959360718727112,
-0.15088163316249847,
-0.8001903891563416,
0.3940853774547577,
-0.47349148988723755,
0.6295331120491028,
-0.3191491365432739,
0.4765636920928955,
0.36329635977745056,
0.46569469571113586,
0.42712074518203735,
-0.9563561677932739,
0.018643351271748543,
-0.39975443482398987,
0.43920764327049255,
0.545355498790741,
-0.09372521191835403,
0.375045508146286,
-0.41537144780158997,
-0.26765650510787964,
0.4331009089946747,
0.5903329253196716,
0.3324143588542938,
0.8786457180976868,
0.8369019627571106,
0.7986855506896973,
0.6904370784759521,
-0.2930293083190918,
0.9975454807281494,
0.12949492037296295,
0.27350860834121704,
1.2577558755874634,
-0.2734464704990387,
1.046460509300232,
0.21325473487377167,
-0.42035192251205444,
0.6501224637031555,
0.5105023980140686,
-0.2642005383968353,
0.866308331489563,
-0.2198760211467743,
-0.09323194622993469,
-0.24309761822223663,
-0.04627957567572594,
-0.16775605082511902,
0.48576417565345764,
0.18063370883464813,
-0.7054087519645691,
-0.23183085024356842,
0.15934067964553833,
-0.3362410068511963,
0.5758850574493408,
-0.533976674079895,
1.191163182258606,
-0.4251887798309326,
-0.6897479891777039,
0.11784619092941284,
-0.13315032422542572,
0.46135199069976807,
-0.04006097838282585,
-0.19227901101112366,
0.4089824855327606,
0.4731229245662689,
-0.2799831032752991,
-1.0204395055770874,
0.5365561246871948,
0.041840218007564545,
-0.29021409153938293,
-0.10718408226966858,
1.2840392589569092,
-0.29245004057884216,
-0.7642222046852112,
0.04538397863507271,
0.3639935851097107,
-0.10382245481014252,
-0.03235235810279846,
-0.6976993083953857,
-0.007382726296782494,
0.29942357540130615,
0.2543623149394989,
0.03256295621395111,
0.5639715194702148,
0.2313721477985382,
0.2676704227924347,
0.5505329966545105,
-0.3663986623287201,
-0.41370928287506104,
0.12953786551952362,
0.6488380432128906,
-0.8310775756835938,
-0.609937846660614,
-0.7497596144676208,
0.7493131756782532,
-0.5872383117675781,
-0.5499296188354492,
0.6936801671981812,
0.5666453838348389,
0.7761240601539612,
-0.26686835289001465,
0.7163247466087341,
-0.1267215758562088,
0.9923425316810608,
-0.6841098666191101,
0.34770411252975464,
-0.4018585681915283,
0.18591530621051788,
-0.8720811605453491,
-0.7526397705078125,
-0.6144545078277588,
1.0928901433944702,
-0.37126225233078003,
0.20628893375396729,
0.9888205528259277,
0.7949756383895874,
-0.11497098207473755,
0.2456885278224945,
0.1635681837797165,
-0.19704031944274902,
-0.21241813898086548,
0.28619036078453064,
1.0304450988769531,
-0.941297173500061,
0.24567300081253052,
-0.08982681483030319,
-0.020318852737545967,
-0.03191476687788963,
-1.019129753112793,
-1.2372709512710571,
-0.5118446350097656,
-0.37847045063972473,
-0.6035237908363342,
0.11315479874610901,
0.7092434167861938,
0.42707914113998413,
-0.5681612491607666,
0.28991302847862244,
-0.6634058952331543,
0.07685083150863647,
-0.24487558007240295,
-0.2460373193025589,
0.02562684752047062,
-0.5150730609893799,
-0.7095124125480652,
0.18386736512184143,
0.29760226607322693,
0.41199547052383423,
0.18983128666877747,
0.08891419321298599,
-0.1374710351228714,
0.035720400512218475,
0.4728342294692993,
-0.1919250339269638,
-0.37405961751937866,
-0.2627987563610077,
-0.2924737334251404,
-0.23616859316825867,
0.3980594277381897,
0.8939058184623718,
-0.9969671964645386,
0.4662618935108185,
0.8101367950439453,
0.6791083216667175,
0.37728506326675415,
0.2854536473751068,
0.45675238966941833,
-0.8766619563102722,
0.09840250760316849,
0.0891544446349144,
0.3153083324432373,
0.6040783524513245,
-0.5904361009597778,
0.6198752522468567,
0.14331085979938507,
-0.806839644908905,
-0.5719352960586548,
0.22581522166728973,
-1.0912326574325562,
-0.24482035636901855,
0.6144447922706604,
-0.10288920998573303,
-0.4352143704891205,
-0.12626364827156067,
-0.7147378921508789,
0.08247943967580795,
-0.585681676864624,
0.5628300905227661,
0.570464551448822,
0.19414259493350983,
-0.6226853728294373,
-0.2865959405899048,
0.5225679278373718,
0.16927266120910645,
-0.9026980996131897,
-0.048378460109233856,
0.6554321050643921,
-0.0024426078889518976,
0.25808778405189514,
0.5487135648727417,
-0.06232326850295067,
0.44821467995643616,
-0.0013014354044571519,
-0.18948982656002045,
0.13787855207920074,
-0.39671212434768677,
-0.4198378622531891,
-0.1804608404636383,
-0.1689717024564743,
-0.39225801825523376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05966v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05966v1
|
THOUGHTSCULPT: Reasoning with Intermediate Revision and Search
| 2024-04-09T02:53:14 | 2024-04-09T02:53:14 |
Yizhou Chi, Kevin Yang, Dan Klein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present THOUGHTSCULPT, a general reasoning and search method for tasks
with outputs that can be decomposed into components. THOUGHTSCULPT explores a
search tree of potential solutions using Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS),
building solutions one action at a time and evaluating according to any
domain-specific heuristic, which in practice is often simply an LLM evaluator.
Critically, our action space includes revision actions: THOUGHTSCULPT may
choose to revise part of its previous output rather than continuing to build
the rest of its output. Empirically, THOUGHTSCULPT outperforms state-of-the-art
reasoning methods across three challenging tasks: Story Outline Improvement (up
to +30% interestingness), Mini-Crosswords Solving (up to +16% word success
rate), and Constrained Generation (up to +10% concept coverage).
|
[
-0.37680113315582275,
-1.0147781372070312,
1.0169365406036377,
0.008813101798295975,
-0.45107370615005493,
0.29874810576438904,
0.020745549350976944,
0.08242616802453995,
0.35181552171707153,
0.3681415319442749,
-1.0456291437149048,
-0.228239044547081,
-0.2736654579639435,
-0.19432124495506287,
-0.23061895370483398,
1.0939189195632935,
-0.22753380239009857,
-0.09954407066106796,
-0.21837490797042847,
0.20582549273967743,
-0.576036274433136,
-0.40078961849212646,
-1.0114651918411255,
-0.38344839215278625,
0.6505147218704224,
0.4992884397506714,
0.49213945865631104,
0.0829533189535141,
0.719799280166626,
0.23811939358711243,
-0.15212346613407135,
0.2220732569694519,
-0.4899909198284149,
0.520559549331665,
-0.7475335597991943,
-0.3832128942012787,
-0.3537653386592865,
0.017661429941654205,
0.15121711790561676,
0.43186336755752563,
-0.4361143708229065,
0.17265520989894867,
0.07659150660037994,
1.0369070768356323,
-0.7681049108505249,
0.2576262950897217,
-0.6481060981750488,
0.08108685165643692,
-0.14572949707508087,
-0.4879515767097473,
-0.3503299057483673,
-0.24945706129074097,
-0.04628349840641022,
-0.3988128900527954,
0.48595207929611206,
0.23986633121967316,
0.41299229860305786,
0.3294700086116791,
-0.2896522879600525,
-0.4658644199371338,
-0.7030702829360962,
0.6318101286888123,
-0.6777818202972412,
0.416670024394989,
0.061379723250865936,
0.4674818515777588,
-0.5222766995429993,
-0.9348706007003784,
-0.740243136882782,
-0.27818360924720764,
0.010063285939395428,
0.6111025214195251,
-0.04747501760721207,
0.2966541051864624,
0.3741191327571869,
0.6202221512794495,
-0.7074011564254761,
-0.5567970275878906,
-0.14771518111228943,
-0.028208427131175995,
0.6215322017669678,
0.3033851385116577,
0.12986820936203003,
-0.17350906133651733,
-0.092843197286129,
-0.11338116228580475,
-0.6305353045463562,
0.20030662417411804,
0.2669718265533447,
-0.01618141122162342,
0.7044086456298828,
0.7390257716178894,
-0.41195350885391235,
0.4513949751853943,
0.13767288625240326,
-0.007045464124530554,
-0.2777574956417084,
-0.25596559047698975,
-0.36934176087379456,
-0.10487360507249832,
0.5053750276565552,
0.20203836262226105,
-0.2734260559082031,
-0.17776814103126526,
-0.39548954367637634,
0.21695485711097717,
0.5466417670249939,
-0.45175254344940186,
-0.664323091506958,
0.2957940995693207,
-0.1156102642416954,
-0.14805229008197784,
-0.26542437076568604,
-0.2246040552854538,
-0.16008594632148743,
-0.5276337265968323,
0.354152649641037,
-0.6039775609970093,
-0.04294542223215103,
0.17833681404590607,
-0.1471502035856247,
-0.0007720133871771395,
0.8346360921859741,
-0.5419245362281799,
0.48770999908447266,
0.8419862985610962,
0.6243349313735962,
-0.3466705083847046,
-0.10668390989303589,
-0.473122775554657,
-0.015777284279465675,
-0.6279410719871521,
1.2658436298370361,
-0.47718027234077454,
-0.38945722579956055,
-0.4724147915840149,
-0.2131284475326538,
-0.08884956687688828,
-0.3042317032814026,
0.9635410308837891,
-0.4963602125644684,
0.3316335082054138,
-0.5773956179618835,
-0.6158405542373657,
-0.34333959221839905,
0.7732561230659485,
-0.6171413660049438,
1.140772819519043,
0.167518749833107,
-1.062514066696167,
0.0320802740752697,
-0.7443799376487732,
-0.19796815514564514,
0.17154881358146667,
-0.2741583287715912,
-0.2801847755908966,
0.3042706251144409,
0.22398501634597778,
0.19346383213996887,
-0.237177774310112,
0.1539495885372162,
-0.11773095279932022,
-0.48666495084762573,
0.0771411806344986,
-0.34688782691955566,
0.6133415102958679,
0.38574227690696716,
-0.32831013202667236,
0.1717122346162796,
-0.24911093711853027,
0.12159384787082672,
0.21599601209163666,
-0.1974441409111023,
-0.02759014628827572,
0.27212586998939514,
-0.3093801438808441,
0.19323809444904327,
0.17630839347839355,
-0.6322382688522339,
0.470643013715744,
0.0213701743632555,
0.3230639696121216,
0.7251787185668945,
0.5118409395217896,
0.10717212408781052,
-0.4807252585887909,
0.6789699196815491,
0.28609028458595276,
0.02565179020166397,
-0.15674135088920593,
-0.7343912124633789,
-1.0305548906326294,
0.31171274185180664,
0.12833057343959808,
0.5047250986099243,
-1.0882375240325928,
-0.04276222363114357,
-0.05613628774881363,
-0.5535783767700195,
-0.4581906795501709,
-0.28063708543777466,
0.35459044575691223,
0.6284584999084473,
0.4556158483028412,
-0.15656772255897522,
-0.4075009822845459,
-1.0540919303894043,
-0.48475006222724915,
-0.4398880898952484,
0.19693173468112946,
0.08999022096395493,
0.5386755466461182,
-0.19174714386463165,
0.7421808838844299,
-0.7093768119812012,
-0.2627370059490204,
-0.5297733545303345,
0.3033353090286255,
0.34022852778434753,
0.3812870681285858,
0.0045590708032250404,
-0.9745047092437744,
-0.1906266212463379,
0.013952100649476051,
-0.387162446975708,
0.15717409551143646,
-0.39267703890800476,
-0.17849937081336975,
-0.23533229529857635,
0.558426558971405,
-0.8519909977912903,
0.5828647613525391,
0.20403675734996796,
-0.02619549073278904,
0.8250596523284912,
-0.1837688833475113,
0.44671499729156494,
-0.9077963829040527,
-0.07910221815109253,
-0.14676694571971893,
-0.1417955905199051,
-0.4508540630340576,
0.7069531083106995,
0.05063379928469658,
0.0633895993232727,
-0.4796198606491089,
0.11237403750419617,
-0.40955477952957153,
0.029872477054595947,
-0.24212715029716492,
0.3857870101928711,
-0.11138316988945007,
0.7600141763687134,
0.03554361313581467,
0.8802831768989563,
-0.044424157589673996,
-0.40930142998695374,
0.5435830354690552,
-0.19502317905426025,
-0.2074340283870697,
0.4144665002822876,
-0.5448014140129089,
0.5947355628013611,
-0.36229825019836426,
0.4838643968105316,
-1.0622373819351196,
-0.05288130044937134,
0.11232772469520569,
-0.4896010458469391,
0.07246776670217514,
0.037952739745378494,
-0.6238759160041809,
-0.6751092076301575,
-0.4013443887233734,
0.2944679260253906,
0.22917096316814423,
-0.12461256235837936,
0.5413106679916382,
0.06352388858795166,
-0.194647416472435,
-0.4750967025756836,
-0.5535597801208496,
0.026128891855478287,
0.06374891102313995,
-0.3296436667442322,
0.44890257716178894,
-0.5920570492744446,
-0.3228711187839508,
0.24744826555252075,
-0.2924066185951233,
0.03668325021862984,
-0.1437835991382599,
-0.11588302254676819,
0.004937805235385895,
-0.04430268332362175,
0.015577103942632675,
0.3292482793331146,
0.03616683930158615,
0.06809911876916885,
-0.12541675567626953,
0.37392932176589966,
-0.39414477348327637,
-0.6434423923492432,
0.12810342013835907,
0.4310937523841858,
0.17362812161445618,
-0.10416970402002335,
-0.1499892622232437,
0.3597651720046997,
-0.5419168472290039,
-0.36686962842941284,
-0.5868776440620422,
0.017155658453702927,
-0.4573797881603241,
0.3429132103919983,
-0.7906904220581055,
-0.9266915321350098,
0.44133564829826355,
-0.07471263408660889,
0.4091990292072296,
0.580007791519165,
0.7686986327171326,
-0.507592499256134,
0.9352691173553467,
0.3944254517555237,
0.41187214851379395,
0.18302112817764282,
-0.40523067116737366,
0.5299051403999329,
-1.2915769815444946,
-0.29263418912887573,
-0.20450487732887268,
-0.5093446373939514,
-0.5385855436325073,
-0.6700342297554016,
0.1520070880651474,
0.12907181680202484,
0.02679242007434368,
0.5247678756713867,
-0.7699771523475647,
0.7257831692695618,
0.7514156103134155,
0.5123676657676697,
0.40462663769721985,
-0.5283058285713196,
-0.3362712562084198,
-0.19941462576389313,
-0.6375600695610046,
-0.2908494472503662,
0.6975629925727844,
-0.062288932502269745,
0.5299360156059265,
0.15167249739170074,
0.9508790969848633,
0.31330838799476624,
0.4804113209247589,
-1.0447872877120972,
0.8408528566360474,
0.07101501524448395,
-0.6707552075386047,
-0.34731853008270264,
-0.24514424800872803,
-0.7748974561691284,
0.3939465582370758,
0.3270024061203003,
-0.7373483180999756,
0.006468405481427908,
0.13420872390270233,
-0.29848334193229675,
0.5213679075241089,
-0.51768559217453,
0.5136014819145203,
0.10047228634357452,
-0.4541838765144348,
-0.42674630880355835,
-0.4233183264732361,
0.7163753509521484,
-0.07097965478897095,
0.033466409891843796,
0.0015945167979225516,
0.07243101298809052,
0.7217961549758911,
-0.4228062629699707,
0.3008629083633423,
0.11189372092485428,
0.1754874587059021,
0.7312525510787964,
0.704561173915863,
0.7435152530670166,
0.12127870321273804,
0.2145681232213974,
-0.6549970507621765,
-0.022628555074334145,
-0.41697385907173157,
-1.047898769378662,
0.7805456519126892,
-0.268766850233078,
-1.2649171352386475,
-0.7619314193725586,
-0.666321337223053,
-0.2329726219177246,
0.21019664406776428,
0.36555129289627075,
0.0763130709528923,
-0.2853050231933594,
-0.008140665479004383,
0.8315620422363281,
0.18906135857105255,
0.4503311514854431,
0.19413229823112488,
-0.25475162267684937,
-0.3113037347793579,
0.605233371257782,
0.1007784903049469,
0.02862456999719143,
0.6064075231552124,
0.22626197338104248,
-0.17545773088932037,
-0.8135221600532532,
-0.09216710925102234,
0.08726606518030167,
-0.8723130822181702,
-0.35570743680000305,
-0.6786467432975769,
-0.3574737310409546,
-0.20476976037025452,
-0.104791060090065,
-0.493301123380661,
-0.673307478427887,
0.2098601907491684,
-0.20282277464866638,
0.006512210704386234,
0.8252858519554138,
0.08198978006839752,
0.08597097545862198,
-0.4135335385799408,
0.5947651267051697,
0.7631628513336182,
-0.04925547540187836,
-0.03679891675710678,
-0.27502304315567017,
-0.18386302888393402,
0.2464715987443924,
-0.8888227343559265,
-0.8799874782562256,
0.28814101219177246,
-0.3060581088066101,
0.5528709888458252,
0.01284936536103487,
0.1554095447063446,
0.9201865792274475,
-0.6846108436584473,
1.0454328060150146,
0.2616778314113617,
-0.8131123185157776,
0.8589909076690674,
-0.3757525682449341,
0.5029178261756897,
0.5873887538909912,
0.3616575598716736,
-0.7412027716636658,
-0.5398439168930054,
-1.0361711978912354,
-0.5745018124580383,
0.43597686290740967,
0.6251583099365234,
-0.31444835662841797,
-0.08637324720621109,
0.318161278963089,
-0.2349986582994461,
0.04086108133196831,
-0.37322989106178284,
0.11327164620161057,
-0.12399616092443466,
0.10567928105592728,
0.09968996793031693,
-0.07428184896707535,
0.00008464693382848054,
-0.3215082287788391,
0.8160148859024048,
-0.16834427416324615,
0.49153703451156616,
0.5544987916946411,
-0.033591631799936295,
-0.13474929332733154,
0.4178922176361084,
0.6262282729148865,
0.6994279623031616,
-0.4900541305541992,
0.5144892334938049,
0.21579168736934662,
-0.6521660089492798,
0.24718250334262848,
-0.19634748995304108,
-0.036873169243335724,
-0.009028198197484016,
0.287531316280365,
0.3024548292160034,
0.167240709066391,
-0.46138831973075867,
0.4701530635356903,
-0.2764885723590851,
-0.24111774563789368,
-0.29434022307395935,
0.23629838228225708,
0.4013151228427887,
0.38236600160598755,
0.3051263988018036,
0.3874472975730896,
0.7273366451263428,
-0.7106260061264038,
0.3272278308868408,
0.09162302315235138,
-0.5391150712966919,
-0.30461499094963074,
0.5961153507232666,
-0.25512218475341797,
-0.5327908396720886,
0.7971071004867554,
-0.461190402507782,
-0.6586813926696777,
0.5063933730125427,
0.3455810546875,
1.4017683267593384,
-0.20155952870845795,
0.1470426321029663,
0.22390563786029816,
0.4173920452594757,
-0.2025895118713379,
0.45476871728897095,
-0.24699833989143372,
-0.6510270237922668,
-0.702887237071991,
-0.22798742353916168,
-0.9010884761810303,
0.20209117233753204,
-0.5945034027099609,
0.32225820422172546,
-0.49102890491485596,
-0.13977593183517456,
-0.1254594475030899,
0.2445780336856842,
-0.6726033687591553,
0.39922699332237244,
-0.10194487124681473,
0.985157310962677,
-0.38094961643218994,
0.9605734348297119,
0.921531617641449,
-0.4523591101169586,
-0.6101881861686707,
0.12159132957458496,
0.02194659598171711,
-0.5246912837028503,
0.5834482908248901,
-0.12794499099254608,
-0.3048662841320038,
-0.1436023861169815,
-0.5764538049697876,
-0.7311928868293762,
1.0995656251907349,
0.16423587501049042,
-0.6962266564369202,
-0.43445441126823425,
-0.15297585725784302,
0.5374768972396851,
-0.22054535150527954,
0.3041437566280365,
0.6293458938598633,
0.2591091990470886,
0.36078453063964844,
-0.572568953037262,
-0.02673834189772606,
-0.40593236684799194,
0.05718427896499634,
0.16062124073505402,
-0.6995750665664673,
0.8490749001502991,
-0.46065226197242737,
-0.23150217533111572,
-0.16109409928321838,
0.7973770499229431,
0.7965326905250549,
0.38386526703834534,
0.41856348514556885,
0.8954227566719055,
0.5793997645378113,
-0.2473590075969696,
1.0085821151733398,
0.10283433645963669,
0.5092702507972717,
1.464208722114563,
0.04167242348194122,
0.9617304801940918,
0.5797632336616516,
-0.2731286883354187,
0.5054681301116943,
1.0784295797348022,
0.5788858532905579,
0.7175493240356445,
0.3732289671897888,
-0.14718638360500336,
-0.34878018498420715,
0.10987905412912369,
-0.03761785477399826,
-0.07871320843696594,
0.44569215178489685,
0.05602462589740753,
-0.20050661265850067,
-0.2749413549900055,
0.0959385484457016,
0.029604077339172363,
-0.22793790698051453,
0.5155295133590698,
0.28364893794059753,
-1.0122979879379272,
0.21682672202587128,
-0.16649465262889862,
0.0728190466761589,
-0.2756059169769287,
-0.36303234100341797,
-0.5213676691055298,
0.3302626311779022,
-0.17826049029827118,
-1.1440365314483643,
0.35123032331466675,
-0.3891076147556305,
0.05953342467546463,
-0.3618580996990204,
0.6338622570037842,
-0.22532035410404205,
-0.5344583988189697,
-0.10750014334917068,
0.5230960845947266,
0.029538344591856003,
-0.31909170746803284,
-0.9533340334892273,
-0.06896227598190308,
0.24430188536643982,
-0.7321056127548218,
-0.04557877033948898,
0.9447458982467651,
-0.08367696404457092,
0.8016120195388794,
0.6109882593154907,
0.10373697429895401,
-0.16507172584533691,
-0.06578320264816284,
1.2359869480133057,
-0.8634833097457886,
-0.5486797094345093,
-0.676710307598114,
0.5495296120643616,
-0.14139781892299652,
-0.2754666805267334,
0.6265584230422974,
0.7595410346984863,
0.9621044397354126,
0.16344566643238068,
0.7024235129356384,
0.127567321062088,
0.5999065637588501,
-0.532895028591156,
0.19581238925457,
-0.27213120460510254,
0.29626205563545227,
-0.5920250415802002,
-1.3435043096542358,
-0.14931081235408783,
0.45650577545166016,
-0.2996695041656494,
-0.13971848785877228,
1.316421627998352,
0.4117942452430725,
-0.25118693709373474,
0.30882224440574646,
0.47949013113975525,
-0.07531589269638062,
0.6823045611381531,
0.8322077989578247,
0.9724535942077637,
-0.5226651430130005,
0.26519811153411865,
-0.5826135277748108,
-0.2670883536338806,
-0.06362875550985336,
-0.7532981634140015,
-0.788284957408905,
-0.7146096229553223,
-0.5456775426864624,
-0.189027801156044,
0.21499010920524597,
0.6972130537033081,
0.2854401171207428,
-0.7300406098365784,
-0.18487130105495453,
-0.49297818541526794,
0.15570499002933502,
-0.5843636989593506,
-0.2851172387599945,
0.536788284778595,
-0.5812610983848572,
-0.489632785320282,
0.3529045581817627,
0.34806159138679504,
-0.18008092045783997,
-0.2546100616455078,
0.014095093123614788,
-0.2877158224582672,
0.37581783533096313,
0.7301320433616638,
-0.17379403114318848,
-0.8027723431587219,
-0.34273433685302734,
0.2653000056743622,
0.10580757260322571,
0.06518923491239548,
1.261605978012085,
-0.8761064410209656,
0.6631608605384827,
0.8453035354614258,
0.4146600365638733,
1.2016890048980713,
-0.09493015706539154,
0.30966565012931824,
-0.42244234681129456,
-0.11972052603960037,
0.8464936017990112,
0.6339812874794006,
0.08183646202087402,
-0.3057776093482971,
0.9833133816719055,
0.3361857831478119,
-0.678206205368042,
-0.610204815864563,
0.42908909916877747,
-1.1667098999023438,
-0.48925578594207764,
0.8983684182167053,
-0.17210811376571655,
-0.43883606791496277,
0.047860149294137955,
-0.6193565130233765,
0.23316772282123566,
-0.47263118624687195,
0.7199632525444031,
0.7519658803939819,
-0.6606091856956482,
-0.6136810779571533,
-0.5131234526634216,
0.4524753987789154,
0.18834933638572693,
-0.7432049512863159,
0.11014547944068909,
0.24283568561077118,
-0.14031729102134705,
0.2689402401447296,
0.8339565992355347,
-0.2146519422531128,
0.5031443238258362,
0.021574946120381355,
-0.08291401714086533,
0.16878223419189453,
-0.22227689623832703,
0.2260255515575409,
0.08493834733963013,
0.07972589135169983,
0.07453016936779022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05961v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05961v1
|
LLM2Vec: Large Language Models Are Secretly Powerful Text Encoders
| 2024-04-09T02:51:05 | 2024-04-09T02:51:05 |
Parishad BehnamGhader, Vaibhav Adlakha, Marius Mosbach, Dzmitry Bahdanau, Nicolas Chapados, Siva Reddy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large decoder-only language models (LLMs) are the state-of-the-art models on
most of today's NLP tasks and benchmarks. Yet, the community is only slowly
adopting these models for text embedding tasks, which require rich
contextualized representations. In this work, we introduce LLM2Vec, a simple
unsupervised approach that can transform any decoder-only LLM into a strong
text encoder. LLM2Vec consists of three simple steps: 1) enabling bidirectional
attention, 2) masked next token prediction, and 3) unsupervised contrastive
learning. We demonstrate the effectiveness of LLM2Vec by applying it to 3
popular LLMs ranging from 1.3B to 7B parameters and evaluate the transformed
models on English word- and sequence-level tasks. We outperform encoder-only
models by a large margin on word-level tasks and reach a new unsupervised
state-of-the-art performance on the Massive Text Embeddings Benchmark (MTEB).
Moreover, when combining LLM2Vec with supervised contrastive learning, we
achieve state-of-the-art performance on MTEB among models that train only on
publicly available data. Our strong empirical results and extensive analysis
demonstrate that LLMs can be effectively transformed into universal text
encoders in a parameter-efficient manner without the need for expensive
adaptation or synthetic GPT-4 generated data.
|
[
-0.03414526954293251,
-0.34813371300697327,
0.6028825640678406,
0.09160405397415161,
-0.624943733215332,
-0.10863789170980453,
-0.25716179609298706,
-0.31349441409111023,
-0.06245250254869461,
0.6948249340057373,
-0.32216066122055054,
-0.6666605472564697,
-0.982617199420929,
0.07638882100582123,
-0.4969926178455353,
0.8614324927330017,
-0.14245805144309998,
0.14057663083076477,
-0.38756999373435974,
-0.13731391727924347,
-0.34690362215042114,
-0.45775648951530457,
-0.30345672369003296,
-0.4455953538417816,
0.29983535408973694,
0.2064659744501114,
0.356965035200119,
0.5352678298950195,
0.35819727182388306,
0.20126768946647644,
-0.279165118932724,
0.4106861352920532,
-0.8219943046569824,
0.13199730217456818,
-0.23180364072322845,
-0.4545804262161255,
-0.09749813377857208,
-0.026613444089889526,
0.5443990230560303,
0.5999342799186707,
-0.06061634048819542,
-0.2268531173467636,
0.4631824791431427,
0.5811946392059326,
-0.4263024926185608,
0.3334078788757324,
-0.8015758395195007,
-0.07690031081438065,
-0.00028371665393933654,
-0.13091948628425598,
-0.6586201190948486,
-0.06352705508470535,
-0.13425974547863007,
-0.23878808319568634,
0.05851239338517189,
0.05803801119327545,
0.40292075276374817,
0.2913362383842468,
-0.7462201714515686,
-0.30917996168136597,
-0.6838589310646057,
0.8400679230690002,
-0.3853066563606262,
0.5926946401596069,
0.2617294490337372,
0.04710371792316437,
-0.16542859375476837,
-0.7523595690727234,
-0.4272591173648834,
0.03301146626472473,
0.08873256295919418,
0.3708338737487793,
-0.3335874080657959,
-0.07397179305553436,
-0.055114977061748505,
0.1991540491580963,
-0.5191843509674072,
0.2980741858482361,
-0.2891177833080292,
-0.028140489012002945,
0.237484872341156,
0.015622141771018505,
-0.0627758726477623,
-0.10447853803634644,
-0.6619109511375427,
-0.040518831461668015,
-0.8337834477424622,
-0.2665829658508301,
-0.003303864039480686,
0.031261175870895386,
-0.09607625752687454,
0.7278985977172852,
0.0636187344789505,
0.11278561502695084,
-0.32242774963378906,
-0.04426154866814613,
0.060352880507707596,
-0.28547075390815735,
-0.04632985219359398,
-0.04374437779188156,
0.704394519329071,
0.378999799489975,
0.1686985045671463,
-0.2992508113384247,
-0.4417867958545685,
0.1916174739599228,
0.2323564738035202,
-0.9649002552032471,
-0.1489093005657196,
0.16360460221767426,
-0.37905243039131165,
-0.26004350185394287,
0.04094943776726723,
-0.6992584466934204,
-0.5302875638008118,
-0.19263774156570435,
0.35806405544281006,
-0.08145762234926224,
-0.05833645910024643,
0.16530905663967133,
0.05727153271436691,
0.33268022537231445,
0.3846699297428131,
-0.7787694334983826,
0.3519790768623352,
0.6886692047119141,
0.8431311249732971,
-0.3933771550655365,
-0.10398341715335846,
-0.5281962156295776,
0.21193507313728333,
-0.5576183795928955,
0.9132543802261353,
-0.4827599823474884,
-0.4646237790584564,
0.35317718982696533,
0.1773386150598526,
0.19267959892749786,
-0.4981744587421417,
0.5043585300445557,
-0.6530306339263916,
0.07526516914367676,
-0.07720515131950378,
-0.616208553314209,
0.06789983063936234,
0.08687212318181992,
-0.6037567257881165,
1.110416293144226,
0.11881981045007706,
-0.9046215415000916,
-0.13673369586467743,
-0.3016868829727173,
-0.48697206377983093,
-0.0009615769376978278,
-0.08057151734828949,
-0.2198505997657776,
0.27534452080726624,
0.367529034614563,
0.7454686164855957,
-0.4844335913658142,
0.10816002637147903,
-0.12792375683784485,
-0.3870279788970947,
0.369067519903183,
-0.5955870747566223,
0.36893659830093384,
0.07522570341825485,
-0.21174074709415436,
0.06220962107181549,
-0.4407384395599365,
-0.3032224178314209,
0.21840064227581024,
-0.5247752070426941,
-0.4105764329433441,
-0.1133914589881897,
0.20144641399383545,
0.21449217200279236,
0.2900232970714569,
-0.503807008266449,
0.13820353150367737,
-0.6018829941749573,
0.6401739120483398,
0.7364048957824707,
-0.3068874180316925,
0.6566969752311707,
0.14332102239131927,
0.01694185845553875,
-0.04976021125912666,
-0.25720518827438354,
-0.2243049442768097,
-0.6252183318138123,
-0.7951192855834961,
-0.30963969230651855,
0.4519839882850647,
0.5763730406761169,
-0.8688749670982361,
0.5277209877967834,
-0.41226431727409363,
-0.1672440618276596,
-0.5113226175308228,
0.35179436206817627,
0.41451549530029297,
0.28959429264068604,
0.4387558102607727,
-0.11809371411800385,
-0.46485164761543274,
-0.8714642524719238,
-0.18277189135551453,
-0.11036848276853561,
-0.44850876927375793,
0.21528299152851105,
0.6147434115409851,
-0.6617399454116821,
0.3418130576610565,
-0.38747870922088623,
-0.39869025349617004,
-0.6014911532402039,
0.11752090603113174,
0.05478925630450249,
0.28182026743888855,
-0.05883125960826874,
-0.616598904132843,
-0.17574533820152283,
0.012585028074681759,
-0.7237953543663025,
-0.05323413014411926,
-0.0032758626621216536,
-0.019475145265460014,
0.26648128032684326,
0.8538521528244019,
-0.38057488203048706,
0.38216960430145264,
0.9060009717941284,
-0.2654804289340973,
0.0037685977295041084,
-0.6311486959457397,
-0.16396720707416534,
-1.2966796159744263,
-0.1307036280632019,
-0.0930667594075203,
-0.5206683874130249,
-0.571260929107666,
0.018140340223908424,
0.35895588994026184,
-0.11578048765659332,
-0.3526538610458374,
0.7920688986778259,
-0.5634017586708069,
-0.19335094094276428,
-0.4255611300468445,
0.3485899865627289,
-0.03918590769171715,
0.3815964162349701,
0.06698792427778244,
0.6105803847312927,
0.3769698739051819,
-0.37257927656173706,
0.415017306804657,
0.39371246099472046,
-0.43286097049713135,
0.142348974943161,
-0.5622943043708801,
0.38546550273895264,
-0.2730879485607147,
0.37817034125328064,
-1.1155390739440918,
-0.19825977087020874,
0.055812545120716095,
-0.33527764678001404,
0.4204410910606384,
-0.11057748645544052,
-0.5867032408714294,
-0.1898239552974701,
-0.33843857049942017,
0.2171991914510727,
0.8410497307777405,
-1.0356976985931396,
0.6815522313117981,
0.2986524999141693,
-0.185337096452713,
-0.20259307324886322,
-1.151162028312683,
0.2567552328109741,
0.30845460295677185,
-0.42389199137687683,
0.6145840287208557,
-0.07393372803926468,
0.058665916323661804,
0.07933437824249268,
-0.041688647121191025,
0.0620211586356163,
-0.1291557401418686,
0.36911147832870483,
0.13888515532016754,
0.020215535536408424,
0.07383175194263458,
0.21727240085601807,
-0.42287901043891907,
-0.1285281479358673,
-0.43688639998435974,
0.39494848251342773,
0.04741564020514488,
-0.27961617708206177,
-0.44866544008255005,
0.5080425143241882,
0.56790691614151,
-0.32624301314353943,
0.7035104036331177,
0.44221919775009155,
-0.42563581466674805,
-0.32082614302635193,
-0.5500961542129517,
-0.2316858172416687,
-0.4330088496208191,
0.7123758792877197,
-0.26146191358566284,
-1.1540918350219727,
0.16243797540664673,
-0.4826407730579376,
-0.003335697576403618,
0.23315703868865967,
0.7585479021072388,
-0.00309058022685349,
1.0364748239517212,
0.7052986025810242,
-0.004463986959308386,
0.23440435528755188,
-0.19440360367298126,
0.11507915705442429,
-0.8639986515045166,
-0.6088462471961975,
-0.2061496078968048,
-0.015995120629668236,
-0.6167006492614746,
-1.0688451528549194,
0.1573716104030609,
0.14270876348018646,
0.03835006430745125,
0.20474781095981598,
-0.25460541248321533,
0.6399524807929993,
0.27326706051826477,
0.09362522512674332,
0.10575366020202637,
0.24084147810935974,
-0.05086725950241089,
-0.02071729116141796,
-0.4576069116592407,
-0.5167624950408936,
1.3268893957138062,
0.5272629261016846,
0.7246169447898865,
0.13674159348011017,
0.6429396271705627,
0.16062031686306,
0.2643052339553833,
-0.9521861672401428,
0.5156125426292419,
-0.602570116519928,
-0.24803107976913452,
-0.08091635257005692,
-0.2892586290836334,
-0.7791147232055664,
0.5215049386024475,
-0.3487226068973541,
-0.43003302812576294,
0.02300691418349743,
-0.19168612360954285,
0.07562071830034256,
0.4125075042247772,
-0.3720490038394928,
0.6089146137237549,
-0.07383331656455994,
-0.4843199551105499,
-0.25015586614608765,
-0.36597707867622375,
0.16991251707077026,
-0.18282027542591095,
0.2629888355731964,
-0.034138765186071396,
-0.4941284656524658,
0.71909099817276,
-0.0892191007733345,
0.7590113878250122,
0.011234533041715622,
-0.1890738308429718,
0.16908186674118042,
0.15015079081058502,
1.0574895143508911,
0.1057479977607727,
0.03691612556576729,
0.3770958483219147,
-0.4422354996204376,
-0.4799954891204834,
-0.5519357919692993,
0.9444001317024231,
-0.6763208508491516,
-0.4491478502750397,
-0.20778363943099976,
-0.1500411480665207,
-0.26902180910110474,
0.03007754310965538,
0.1223226860165596,
0.47407621145248413,
-0.3743748962879181,
0.5455556511878967,
0.913963794708252,
0.05703947693109512,
0.29463452100753784,
0.3907543122768402,
0.02230329066514969,
-0.5323107242584229,
0.7198407649993896,
-0.26837509870529175,
-0.12857849895954132,
0.7116898894309998,
0.19202153384685516,
-0.6206362843513489,
-0.7225339412689209,
-0.2429332286119461,
0.37881234288215637,
-0.8988949060440063,
-0.1938045173883438,
-0.8274229168891907,
-0.12064122408628464,
-0.47012877464294434,
-0.2643035054206848,
-0.7662161588668823,
-0.08937165886163712,
-0.6804782748222351,
-0.23105885088443756,
-0.011784418486058712,
0.9565824866294861,
0.031506918370723724,
0.1437027007341385,
-0.6012584567070007,
0.3742575943470001,
0.5970260500907898,
0.13959933817386627,
-0.3234338164329529,
-0.801794171333313,
-0.12935326993465424,
-0.3288184404373169,
0.07260391116142273,
-0.7187896966934204,
0.5160617828369141,
-0.044628605246543884,
0.35136088728904724,
0.46330294013023376,
-0.007165555376559496,
0.06465060263872147,
-0.6702216863632202,
0.7166755199432373,
0.32508185505867004,
-0.8153675198554993,
0.24106360971927643,
-0.04059334844350815,
0.21146947145462036,
0.2633485794067383,
0.31301361322402954,
-0.3468683660030365,
-0.061276357620954514,
-0.1638774424791336,
-0.8255321979522705,
0.5622658133506775,
0.33273324370384216,
0.3957306742668152,
0.0728948786854744,
0.4014623463153839,
0.07187389582395554,
-0.08697167038917542,
-0.7340848445892334,
-0.08578009903430939,
-0.36720845103263855,
-0.37394487857818604,
-0.2714207172393799,
-0.8760777711868286,
-0.03739812970161438,
-0.030237974599003792,
0.4043006896972656,
-0.22044073045253754,
0.38035401701927185,
0.13689152896404266,
-0.13372448086738586,
0.27165788412094116,
0.5135142803192139,
0.4023423492908478,
0.18823868036270142,
-0.1328001469373703,
0.5939052104949951,
0.38487666845321655,
-0.22745943069458008,
0.04785531759262085,
0.14696374535560608,
0.05833689123392105,
-0.1623031049966812,
0.5501086115837097,
0.8200176358222961,
0.5572157502174377,
-0.5090681314468384,
0.8905548453330994,
-0.12062018364667892,
-0.33339381217956543,
-0.05520350858569145,
-0.23654161393642426,
0.43643495440483093,
0.4121130704879761,
0.17067287862300873,
-0.1502988338470459,
0.040039315819740295,
-0.4092767536640167,
0.07535912096500397,
0.349221408367157,
-0.5177972912788391,
-0.3902220129966736,
0.7208284735679626,
0.5669914484024048,
0.027171451598405838,
0.3865737318992615,
-0.19836287200450897,
-0.566400945186615,
0.22498725354671478,
0.8689225316047668,
0.8969660997390747,
-0.26177793741226196,
0.07733918726444244,
0.3283143639564514,
0.46401700377464294,
-0.41444265842437744,
0.047621309757232666,
-0.0025194408372044563,
-0.6708389520645142,
-0.23651480674743652,
-0.6061126589775085,
-0.2797258496284485,
0.2847476899623871,
-0.37343451380729675,
0.025190051645040512,
-0.3658742308616638,
0.2335159182548523,
-0.28117281198501587,
-0.08246396481990814,
-0.6913488507270813,
0.03296208754181862,
0.31083381175994873,
0.642307460308075,
-0.8167498111724854,
1.0947794914245605,
0.6559582948684692,
0.03883587196469307,
-0.4049384891986847,
0.03374684602022171,
-0.09346239268779755,
-0.9744542837142944,
0.6162152290344238,
0.3874375820159912,
-0.25212913751602173,
0.057827915996313095,
-0.573889434337616,
-0.7262465357780457,
1.1627975702285767,
0.2736609876155853,
-0.8028002977371216,
0.0015614054864272475,
0.1355726271867752,
0.41952115297317505,
-0.503991425037384,
0.22445444762706757,
0.45302969217300415,
0.2541055679321289,
0.31914815306663513,
-0.36960116028785706,
0.20653030276298523,
-0.04993290826678276,
0.48529186844825745,
-0.0936620756983757,
-0.4484277069568634,
0.6608015894889832,
-0.35920390486717224,
-0.38510003685951233,
0.06456858664751053,
0.8158047199249268,
0.04739171639084816,
0.023558486253023148,
0.2817763090133667,
0.34643030166625977,
0.6731045842170715,
0.02893913723528385,
1.0609161853790283,
-0.16883467137813568,
0.2280762791633606,
0.7768835425376892,
-0.2887510657310486,
1.1736654043197632,
0.520534336566925,
0.0033419071696698666,
0.3115456998348236,
0.26986628770828247,
-0.03646599501371384,
0.7551290392875671,
0.046288080513477325,
-0.2448982298374176,
-0.6245136857032776,
-0.08055698871612549,
-0.08372978866100311,
0.4303933084011078,
0.2200942039489746,
-0.36833885312080383,
-0.10964853316545486,
0.05765052139759064,
0.032382167875766754,
0.2566474974155426,
-0.32103294134140015,
0.8798730969429016,
0.30616143345832825,
-0.3008074164390564,
0.5547971129417419,
0.42067983746528625,
0.9844774007797241,
-0.5618352890014648,
-0.05542414262890816,
-0.4344107210636139,
0.3626474440097809,
-0.07168785482645035,
-0.8564985394477844,
-0.02007085643708706,
0.19438813626766205,
-0.12411986291408539,
-0.2961222529411316,
0.9124919176101685,
-0.6247893571853638,
-0.4151069223880768,
0.6588417887687683,
0.3141215741634369,
0.20054751634597778,
-0.27831006050109863,
-0.4395827651023865,
0.05062518268823624,
0.19693580269813538,
-0.297961950302124,
0.5137208700180054,
0.436241090297699,
0.16038522124290466,
0.6032614707946777,
0.7203652262687683,
-0.005396989174187183,
-0.2968341112136841,
0.06256760656833649,
1.0157324075698853,
-0.6967297792434692,
-0.3277658522129059,
-0.6840097308158875,
0.4127422571182251,
0.13473419845104218,
0.03198625519871712,
0.5131422877311707,
0.565995454788208,
0.7053789496421814,
-0.10783084481954575,
0.7807580232620239,
0.694648265838623,
0.33621838688850403,
-0.8991948962211609,
0.6338428854942322,
-0.7430248260498047,
0.34648197889328003,
0.22963093221187592,
-0.9135124683380127,
-0.319608598947525,
0.4095936715602875,
-0.019648609682917595,
-0.12289772927761078,
0.8091289401054382,
0.85292649269104,
0.003889481071382761,
-0.09355729073286057,
0.6674584150314331,
0.30885884165763855,
0.3483112156391144,
0.682325005531311,
0.7837830781936646,
-0.4293923079967499,
0.815717875957489,
0.006057335529476404,
-0.39916107058525085,
-0.4087623059749603,
-0.8547312021255493,
-1.2248256206512451,
-0.41836756467819214,
-0.24447906017303467,
-0.3337664306163788,
0.22128590941429138,
0.7462884783744812,
0.4038417935371399,
-0.7815326452255249,
0.015418651513755322,
-0.13381707668304443,
0.011523619294166565,
0.25389179587364197,
-0.08993428945541382,
0.4872249960899353,
-0.0803811103105545,
-0.805923581123352,
0.7736756801605225,
0.3967345952987671,
0.16819413006305695,
-0.27696719765663147,
-0.1548456996679306,
0.2669176757335663,
0.3230430483818054,
0.8757709264755249,
-0.042747464030981064,
-0.880630373954773,
-0.09238985925912857,
-0.23572777211666107,
-0.40904146432876587,
0.004779914394021034,
0.7471542954444885,
-0.6717095375061035,
0.4134734869003296,
0.47667649388313293,
0.7444316148757935,
0.7253330945968628,
-0.2473301738500595,
0.21927860379219055,
-0.6535065770149231,
0.20038685202598572,
0.06815342605113983,
0.4545181095600128,
0.48389971256256104,
-0.1075572818517685,
0.331951767206192,
0.2588566243648529,
-0.4253333508968353,
-0.7516117095947266,
0.1857236921787262,
-0.8490962386131287,
-0.5359196662902832,
1.7397074699401855,
-0.06330791860818863,
-0.31010493636131287,
0.021905172616243362,
-0.22263595461845398,
0.18924182653427124,
-0.41977253556251526,
0.2887512743473053,
0.2564122676849365,
0.250567764043808,
-0.15792322158813477,
-0.4327293336391449,
0.320450097322464,
0.2978178560733795,
-0.7605625987052917,
0.49810898303985596,
0.2686183750629425,
0.283257395029068,
-0.1692870557308197,
0.46048399806022644,
-0.2656930387020111,
-0.2593098282814026,
0.2065364122390747,
0.11582785844802856,
-0.3052261173725128,
-0.4590621590614319,
-0.5987222790718079,
0.19551603496074677,
-0.060842715203762054,
-0.020548980683088303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05955v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05955v1
|
VisualWebBench: How Far Have Multimodal LLMs Evolved in Web Page Understanding and Grounding?
| 2024-04-09T02:29:39 | 2024-04-09T02:29:39 |
Junpeng Liu, Yifan Song, Bill Yuchen Lin, Wai Lam, Graham Neubig, Yuanzhi Li, Xiang Yue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multimodal Large Language models (MLLMs) have shown promise in web-related
tasks, but evaluating their performance in the web domain remains a challenge
due to the lack of comprehensive benchmarks. Existing benchmarks are either
designed for general multimodal tasks, failing to capture the unique
characteristics of web pages, or focus on end-to-end web agent tasks, unable to
measure fine-grained abilities such as OCR, understanding, and grounding. In
this paper, we introduce \bench{}, a multimodal benchmark designed to assess
the capabilities of MLLMs across a variety of web tasks. \bench{} consists of
seven tasks, and comprises 1.5K human-curated instances from 139 real websites,
covering 87 sub-domains. We evaluate 14 open-source MLLMs, Gemini Pro, Claude-3
series, and GPT-4V(ision) on \bench{}, revealing significant challenges and
performance gaps. Further analysis highlights the limitations of current MLLMs,
including inadequate grounding in text-rich environments and subpar performance
with low-resolution image inputs. We believe \bench{} will serve as a valuable
resource for the research community and contribute to the creation of more
powerful and versatile MLLMs for web-related applications.
|
[
-0.781338095664978,
-0.6260251402854919,
0.3796311616897583,
0.35257965326309204,
-0.2592150866985321,
-0.05475548282265663,
-0.3738313615322113,
-0.5262818932533264,
-0.4802224338054657,
0.07483852654695511,
-0.6394648551940918,
-0.5655622482299805,
-0.3780817687511444,
0.018359599635004997,
-0.3936295509338379,
0.5739542841911316,
-0.08814121037721634,
0.3113141655921936,
-0.857427179813385,
-0.41742292046546936,
-0.24660061299800873,
-0.3798311650753021,
-0.1686696708202362,
-0.21415339410305023,
0.7317222356796265,
0.17123925685882568,
0.45345208048820496,
0.5153995752334595,
0.6203603148460388,
0.364026814699173,
0.0972788855433464,
0.20213253796100616,
-0.5649480819702148,
0.1784176081418991,
-0.35330358147621155,
-0.37286612391471863,
-0.3692212700843811,
0.17004017531871796,
0.4919709265232086,
0.8488865494728088,
-0.004686405416578054,
0.35127878189086914,
0.039767470210790634,
0.5731745958328247,
-0.9724656343460083,
0.010027286596596241,
-0.46409448981285095,
-0.040069203823804855,
-0.14771617949008942,
-0.0769922211766243,
-0.4624857008457184,
0.027317598462104797,
-0.004103689454495907,
-0.5702868103981018,
0.3187362551689148,
0.0813063532114029,
0.8342819213867188,
0.3315964341163635,
-0.6199529767036438,
0.08959374576807022,
-0.310817688703537,
0.9031080603599548,
-0.5961289405822754,
0.8270339965820312,
0.4468398094177246,
0.5843923091888428,
-0.06635675579309464,
-0.8167064189910889,
-0.5616917014122009,
-0.2631206512451172,
0.21062035858631134,
0.24792031943798065,
-0.24775835871696472,
-0.21008816361427307,
0.3076269328594208,
0.1511119306087494,
-0.7915985584259033,
0.22359511256217957,
-0.033182293176651,
-0.06391512602567673,
0.26508164405822754,
0.1465822011232376,
0.089274100959301,
-0.15533488988876343,
-0.45213112235069275,
-0.2986937463283539,
-0.37819337844848633,
0.3082907199859619,
-0.04391171783208847,
0.05764064937829971,
-0.26348066329956055,
0.5770968198776245,
-0.21104517579078674,
0.8391327857971191,
-0.38856711983680725,
-0.4354409873485565,
0.2314726561307907,
-0.22187787294387817,
-0.23535481095314026,
-0.5904272794723511,
0.6197119355201721,
0.7903643250465393,
0.41168293356895447,
-0.33446696400642395,
-0.24550125002861023,
0.15566614270210266,
0.3952016234397888,
-0.764482855796814,
-0.1211855560541153,
0.11091297119855881,
-0.7380855083465576,
0.03138918802142143,
0.053686145693063736,
-0.7964305877685547,
-0.8932109475135803,
-0.4466923773288727,
0.2116047739982605,
-0.4212661385536194,
-0.26030808687210083,
-0.311533123254776,
-0.590893566608429,
0.20900864899158478,
0.5789507031440735,
-0.45659929513931274,
0.14266498386859894,
0.43985652923583984,
0.6470291614532471,
-0.4776201546192169,
-0.5807403922080994,
-0.3433724045753479,
0.14801040291786194,
-0.10575398802757263,
0.8623973727226257,
-0.520400881767273,
-0.2515445053577423,
0.22228552401065826,
-0.032235048711299896,
0.016795268282294273,
-0.5346656441688538,
0.3828471601009369,
-0.5310667157173157,
-0.21903914213180542,
-0.3247472047805786,
-0.32395437359809875,
-0.25618094205856323,
0.568342387676239,
-0.548462986946106,
0.8025630116462708,
-0.0907391607761383,
-0.550934374332428,
0.5131657123565674,
-0.18929807841777802,
-0.45670580863952637,
-0.16248568892478943,
-0.2205529510974884,
-0.06285418570041656,
0.30316635966300964,
0.2159813940525055,
0.5990395545959473,
-0.566511869430542,
-0.06606440991163254,
-0.7017115950584412,
-0.40873992443084717,
0.5162841081619263,
-0.7482137680053711,
0.45443007349967957,
-0.05069004371762276,
-0.3842080235481262,
0.2721140384674072,
-1.2641230821609497,
0.2885466516017914,
0.13984054327011108,
-0.3983803689479828,
-0.2675658166408539,
0.13435210287570953,
0.6247506737709045,
0.38630253076553345,
0.2018556296825409,
-0.182724729180336,
0.08702033013105392,
0.29495611786842346,
0.2988499402999878,
0.9208129048347473,
-0.3971812427043915,
0.15966229140758514,
-0.1455807089805603,
0.40362119674682617,
-0.18700319528579712,
0.15025685727596283,
-0.25467419624328613,
-0.34702062606811523,
-0.9324407577514648,
-0.501838207244873,
0.22550368309020996,
0.40952399373054504,
-0.5348841547966003,
0.07003819942474365,
-0.41159290075302124,
-0.6389644742012024,
-0.35678327083587646,
0.2632317841053009,
0.5556640625,
0.16329334676265717,
0.5740466713905334,
-0.21217317879199982,
-0.2692354619503021,
-1.1009279489517212,
-0.19577758014202118,
0.2320234775543213,
-0.06782993674278259,
0.4574855864048004,
0.36239710450172424,
-0.5659372806549072,
0.9888349175453186,
-0.14580023288726807,
-0.25336048007011414,
-0.0027382175903767347,
0.4497902989387512,
-0.06661377847194672,
0.3610231280326843,
0.47504353523254395,
-1.0532337427139282,
-0.43667328357696533,
0.059260714799165726,
-1.1537877321243286,
-0.21807506680488586,
0.10795219242572784,
0.17283843457698822,
-0.027490954846143723,
0.4744912087917328,
-0.7293523550033569,
0.3615413010120392,
0.8519085049629211,
-0.053509555757045746,
0.5314700603485107,
-0.06550264358520508,
0.08679313957691193,
-0.6551538109779358,
0.18109020590782166,
0.29304376244544983,
-0.38014426827430725,
-0.2928128242492676,
0.30453425645828247,
0.46335262060165405,
-0.02685694769024849,
-0.3709331154823303,
0.4449993073940277,
-0.8910130858421326,
-0.5137511491775513,
-0.28816094994544983,
0.5052903294563293,
0.10777577757835388,
0.4952608048915863,
-0.38972604274749756,
1.0023361444473267,
0.34306618571281433,
-0.6776551008224487,
0.42107343673706055,
0.03837018087506294,
-0.2686224579811096,
0.842805802822113,
-0.3340197503566742,
0.11091195046901703,
-0.12667429447174072,
0.2752070724964142,
-1.1890242099761963,
-0.15180589258670807,
-0.33605167269706726,
-0.30524778366088867,
0.22411178052425385,
-0.10392197221517563,
-0.62050861120224,
-0.4553222060203552,
-0.4282861351966858,
0.2651093304157257,
0.3343258798122406,
-0.4974946975708008,
0.7048883438110352,
0.2514871656894684,
0.03455355390906334,
-0.5851715803146362,
-0.5857467651367188,
0.19886641204357147,
0.06379954516887665,
-0.8173791766166687,
0.4035561680793762,
-0.20861074328422546,
-0.4686468243598938,
0.06309648603200912,
-0.25574901700019836,
-0.1502629816532135,
0.10147501528263092,
0.4762343466281891,
-0.08845742791891098,
-0.3638501465320587,
0.13061584532260895,
-0.3436971604824066,
-0.10610207915306091,
-0.03463437780737877,
-0.010692177340388298,
0.6910002827644348,
-0.2783440053462982,
-0.7671603560447693,
-0.44159623980522156,
0.17497266829013824,
0.8923929333686829,
-0.4638114273548126,
0.5439572930335999,
1.0815916061401367,
-0.2783088684082031,
-0.19908101856708527,
-0.9620417356491089,
0.12260492146015167,
-0.45047956705093384,
0.29707393050193787,
-0.678081214427948,
-0.7018416523933411,
0.4175383448600769,
-0.33740270137786865,
0.013301549479365349,
0.319021999835968,
0.5492743849754333,
-0.4948989152908325,
0.9935356378555298,
0.7064248323440552,
0.09730757027864456,
0.380816787481308,
-0.13337576389312744,
-0.30010661482810974,
-0.7910469770431519,
-0.16695964336395264,
-0.2863985002040863,
-0.5045403838157654,
-0.4426048994064331,
-0.6618924736976624,
0.29291489720344543,
0.5154485702514648,
0.10730725526809692,
0.10721121728420258,
-0.0455034002661705,
0.18863998353481293,
0.6672701239585876,
0.05292749032378197,
0.1691661775112152,
-0.012311737053096294,
-0.4012436866760254,
-0.14159226417541504,
-0.3432801067829132,
-0.33008310198783875,
1.0103774070739746,
0.0628652572631836,
0.9471591711044312,
0.3084770441055298,
0.09950149804353714,
0.4380252957344055,
0.32598939538002014,
-0.44250157475471497,
0.6337071657180786,
-0.1067788377404213,
-0.37597930431365967,
-0.226273775100708,
-0.15210117399692535,
-0.8781681060791016,
0.8831101059913635,
-0.22659797966480255,
-0.6967642307281494,
0.11726052314043045,
0.14363247156143188,
0.20864734053611755,
0.03719290718436241,
-0.6753584742546082,
1.0551055669784546,
-0.40529578924179077,
-0.9572002291679382,
-0.5173784494400024,
-0.5446057319641113,
0.173423632979393,
0.20162296295166016,
0.4234094023704529,
-0.31219160556793213,
-0.15289165079593658,
0.4059675335884094,
-0.060446493327617645,
0.8624699711799622,
-0.26123660802841187,
-0.09054990112781525,
-0.07130083441734314,
-0.06970683485269547,
0.5031107068061829,
-0.05074990540742874,
0.053443145006895065,
0.0877123698592186,
-0.1504853218793869,
-0.4751009941101074,
-0.45847728848457336,
0.7696346044540405,
-0.6948921084403992,
-0.49871715903282166,
-0.2945231795310974,
-0.4352684020996094,
-0.8306566476821899,
0.34557226300239563,
-0.032109085470438004,
0.5199761986732483,
-0.1954047977924347,
0.6671810746192932,
0.483008474111557,
-0.09848995506763458,
0.6249450445175171,
0.6331616044044495,
-0.3048369288444519,
-0.42845189571380615,
0.9537434577941895,
-0.18619422614574432,
0.007116623688489199,
0.5156705379486084,
0.0492258183658123,
-0.37443721294403076,
-0.7336816787719727,
-0.6772496700286865,
0.029984619468450546,
-1.1372188329696655,
-0.15375164151191711,
-0.7449173331260681,
0.1428782343864441,
-0.4608495831489563,
-0.16332131624221802,
-0.2233392298221588,
-0.07074914127588272,
-0.1586700975894928,
0.09617625921964645,
0.06359495222568512,
0.6363111734390259,
0.0440569669008255,
0.06743402779102325,
-0.9315854907035828,
0.6021029949188232,
0.5082119107246399,
0.38430821895599365,
0.08949613571166992,
-0.13238026201725006,
-0.1939539909362793,
-0.0597301684319973,
-0.10108596831560135,
-0.7003486156463623,
0.032256465405225754,
-0.07158724218606949,
1.075995922088623,
0.591312825679779,
-0.24062426388263702,
1.1387296915054321,
-0.5893566608428955,
0.7622570991516113,
0.33823180198669434,
-0.8153610229492188,
0.13692936301231384,
-0.4972807765007019,
0.5059903264045715,
0.5070429444313049,
0.3576286733150482,
-0.4558383822441101,
-0.02328471839427948,
-0.01873304322361946,
-0.7899587154388428,
0.4208645820617676,
0.06257810443639755,
-0.00847832765430212,
0.25031641125679016,
-0.11668498814105988,
0.0780656561255455,
0.47546350955963135,
-0.8270125389099121,
-0.15230318903923035,
-0.2975444495677948,
-0.027810417115688324,
-0.2531604766845703,
-0.3620360493659973,
-0.14008300006389618,
-0.28439125418663025,
0.30514955520629883,
-0.4019606411457062,
0.027988163754343987,
-0.1329367756843567,
-0.8112081289291382,
-0.0316120907664299,
0.24497784674167633,
0.8121090531349182,
1.249593734741211,
-0.26481950283050537,
0.3550732433795929,
0.15238717198371887,
-0.15445253252983093,
0.009679018519818783,
0.3131072521209717,
0.307555228471756,
-0.1602337807416916,
0.6889744400978088,
0.7451668977737427,
0.4586488902568817,
-1.077629566192627,
0.658912181854248,
0.0018324513221159577,
-0.009648555889725685,
-0.2600380778312683,
-0.1089281365275383,
0.1682908684015274,
0.513756513595581,
0.5329626798629761,
0.010142115876078606,
0.07140149921178818,
-0.51149982213974,
0.22325371205806732,
0.5640562772750854,
-0.4428618550300598,
-0.198429673910141,
0.5548069477081299,
0.30583155155181885,
-0.12253972142934799,
0.37773096561431885,
-0.08486819267272949,
-0.3661859333515167,
0.33795979619026184,
0.6126738786697388,
0.6603946089744568,
0.158334419131279,
-0.17550693452358246,
0.012554280459880829,
0.25659266114234924,
0.1504332274198532,
0.04757453873753548,
-0.1989080309867859,
-0.5565207600593567,
-0.14717228710651398,
-0.7011426091194153,
-0.26667147874832153,
0.12527385354042053,
-0.668940007686615,
0.0002658625890035182,
-0.39711320400238037,
-0.3969349265098572,
0.08050412684679031,
-0.48938247561454773,
-0.922363817691803,
0.38876035809516907,
0.302583783864975,
0.9516758918762207,
-0.37203437089920044,
0.6214845180511475,
0.9545683860778809,
-0.4764338731765747,
0.07386156916618347,
0.08403025567531586,
0.3344007432460785,
-0.8184653520584106,
0.8090173602104187,
0.4231935441493988,
-0.27111107110977173,
-0.0025380465667694807,
-0.25384312868118286,
-0.7224082946777344,
1.1896344423294067,
0.038126733154058456,
-0.5151453614234924,
0.03175535425543785,
0.06906962394714355,
0.43210044503211975,
0.08542940020561218,
0.3013242185115814,
0.044502634555101395,
0.7022631168365479,
-0.41512060165405273,
-1.0152666568756104,
-0.09087226539850235,
-0.5032880902290344,
0.17996414005756378,
-0.11000784486532211,
-0.7199541926383972,
1.170840859413147,
0.10754168778657913,
-0.12809352576732635,
0.06537625193595886,
0.47192054986953735,
0.18456368148326874,
0.21693845093250275,
0.602614164352417,
0.654223620891571,
0.5681270360946655,
-0.009135705418884754,
1.1056116819381714,
-0.1547200232744217,
0.16832292079925537,
0.8890922665596008,
-0.46802639961242676,
1.1456758975982666,
0.5664677619934082,
-0.3651924431324005,
0.3983513116836548,
0.4380415081977844,
-0.16416777670383453,
0.41140514612197876,
0.3503465950489044,
-0.035662923008203506,
-0.6011890769004822,
-0.16593751311302185,
-0.35343384742736816,
0.5248640179634094,
0.30070021748542786,
-0.16763748228549957,
-0.4193378984928131,
0.37323683500289917,
-0.44532009959220886,
0.24373140931129456,
-0.1628977656364441,
0.7145498394966125,
0.04965353012084961,
-0.523245096206665,
0.7362868189811707,
0.21898387372493744,
0.740185022354126,
-0.7147835493087769,
-0.059340327978134155,
-0.11486467719078064,
0.4969979226589203,
0.04575162008404732,
-0.5979255437850952,
-0.474055677652359,
0.12888585031032562,
-0.409901887178421,
-0.533410370349884,
0.8435752987861633,
0.055055610835552216,
-0.22112299501895905,
0.6332598328590393,
0.7893348336219788,
-0.10176823288202286,
-0.2868426442146301,
-0.6565760970115662,
0.4487086236476898,
-0.23520147800445557,
-0.3722405731678009,
0.5908061861991882,
0.4686241149902344,
-0.11624614149332047,
0.9702135920524597,
0.919782280921936,
-0.4597703218460083,
0.42286738753318787,
0.38683146238327026,
0.8409850001335144,
-0.7714374661445618,
-0.23709285259246826,
-0.8541193604469299,
0.5015513300895691,
-0.3597170412540436,
-0.4591180682182312,
1.0832659006118774,
0.719044029712677,
0.6256981492042542,
-0.20822390913963318,
0.8566811680793762,
0.08730185776948929,
0.19438748061656952,
-0.5882959365844727,
0.816667377948761,
-0.9997275471687317,
-0.3234400153160095,
-0.14266735315322876,
-1.0011495351791382,
-0.08175136148929596,
0.5649171471595764,
0.1664673238992691,
0.024720175191760063,
0.8150951862335205,
0.4166954457759857,
-0.23332317173480988,
-0.16754263639450073,
0.6061893701553345,
0.14505892992019653,
0.339647501707077,
0.07564550638198853,
0.995078444480896,
-0.0984615832567215,
0.7284210920333862,
-0.2807893753051758,
-0.20491430163383484,
-0.48726171255111694,
-0.8020026087760925,
-1.206835150718689,
-0.4743543565273285,
0.09299436211585999,
-0.20214799046516418,
0.15903519093990326,
0.7607437968254089,
0.9950929880142212,
-0.7596550583839417,
-0.21116067469120026,
-0.05618767440319061,
-0.17719906568527222,
-0.397310346364975,
-0.16468489170074463,
0.13604585826396942,
-0.38449010252952576,
-0.66327965259552,
0.5719969868659973,
0.35778185725212097,
0.02828996069729328,
-0.4849110543727875,
0.10989349335432053,
-0.3135393559932709,
-0.2836855351924896,
0.8729764223098755,
-0.032957274466753006,
-1.1403744220733643,
-0.0800182968378067,
0.020930450409650803,
-0.45602595806121826,
-0.11176279187202454,
0.7677075266838074,
-0.653090238571167,
0.43292489647865295,
0.3553219437599182,
0.9342246055603027,
0.7030273675918579,
0.059209197759628296,
0.4082982540130615,
-0.7497455477714539,
0.3193364143371582,
0.047330591827631,
0.6033461689949036,
0.4032115340232849,
0.3706793189048767,
0.5645624995231628,
0.43079134821891785,
-0.08218248188495636,
-0.7773123979568481,
-0.03227585181593895,
-1.1510227918624878,
-0.6059051156044006,
1.2351717948913574,
-0.12465671449899673,
-0.027480147778987885,
0.019208308309316635,
-0.07106959074735641,
0.06657538563013077,
-0.13223177194595337,
0.4266560673713684,
0.8123836517333984,
0.009307256899774075,
-0.4770573377609253,
-0.9235309958457947,
0.1647200733423233,
0.295135498046875,
-0.9166240692138672,
0.001232293201610446,
0.7549357414245605,
0.08110865205526352,
0.37123560905456543,
0.43915265798568726,
0.3494962751865387,
0.33071720600128174,
0.23819230496883392,
0.20970718562602997,
-0.23086021840572357,
-0.3007011413574219,
0.1282830536365509,
0.47036805748939514,
0.040134355425834656,
-0.14886733889579773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05943v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05943v1
|
Interplay of Machine Translation, Diacritics, and Diacritization
| 2024-04-09T01:55:05 | 2024-04-09T01:55:05 |
Wei-Rui Chen, Ife Adebara, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We investigate two research questions: (1) how do machine translation (MT)
and diacritization influence the performance of each other in a multi-task
learning setting (2) the effect of keeping (vs. removing) diacritics on MT
performance. We examine these two questions in both high-resource (HR) and
low-resource (LR) settings across 55 different languages (36 African languages
and 19 European languages). For (1), results show that diacritization
significantly benefits MT in the LR scenario, doubling or even tripling
performance for some languages, but harms MT in the HR scenario. We find that
MT harms diacritization in LR but benefits significantly in HR for some
languages. For (2), MT performance is similar regardless of diacritics being
kept or removed. In addition, we propose two classes of metrics to measure the
complexity of a diacritical system, finding these metrics to correlate
positively with the performance of our diacritization models. Overall, our work
provides insights for developing MT and diacritization systems under different
data size conditions and may have implications that generalize beyond the 55
languages we investigate.
|
[
-0.49176353216171265,
-0.7926886081695557,
0.2443411648273468,
0.21646499633789062,
-0.359857976436615,
0.42651423811912537,
-0.5005090832710266,
-0.8912462592124939,
0.027568086981773376,
0.5404685735702515,
-0.1978742629289627,
0.003504498628899455,
-0.9661547541618347,
0.701245129108429,
-0.24217863380908966,
1.2566537857055664,
-0.25365138053894043,
0.07964325696229935,
-0.06741757690906525,
-0.24060560762882233,
-0.4514463245868683,
-1.066218614578247,
-0.5046254396438599,
-0.23568114638328552,
0.6504968404769897,
0.4030039608478546,
0.9771992564201355,
0.8848029971122742,
1.1751595735549927,
0.34043532609939575,
0.020259877666831017,
0.3520744740962982,
-0.22317913174629211,
0.5669489502906799,
0.08210915327072144,
-0.43505534529685974,
-0.3781600594520569,
-0.10258909314870834,
0.6175346374511719,
0.8924754858016968,
0.1617727279663086,
0.29335707426071167,
0.5121184587478638,
0.7215449810028076,
-0.686593770980835,
0.16242772340774536,
-0.298227459192276,
-0.05573904514312744,
-0.5802871584892273,
-0.04113150015473366,
-0.2865481674671173,
-0.1562688648700714,
0.013086074031889439,
-0.5058708190917969,
0.10504334419965744,
0.07604686915874481,
0.7607571482658386,
0.5678147077560425,
-0.3628539443016052,
-0.4796229302883148,
-1.1496278047561646,
0.9425305128097534,
-0.42246073484420776,
0.31254899501800537,
0.5630207657814026,
0.05278664082288742,
0.26620906591415405,
-0.5391671657562256,
-0.3781128525733948,
0.09188777953386307,
-0.17659664154052734,
0.2147047370672226,
-0.10762573778629303,
0.1813923716545105,
0.28384992480278015,
0.5336750745773315,
-0.4653238356113434,
0.5210330486297607,
-0.6645935773849487,
-0.2387702912092209,
0.4409927725791931,
0.3331855237483978,
0.4135982394218445,
0.0334780253469944,
-0.10339979827404022,
0.04107595980167389,
-0.47248533368110657,
-0.03427642211318016,
0.3172251284122467,
0.5821493268013,
-0.19950823485851288,
0.6337822675704956,
-0.006159903481602669,
0.6665146350860596,
-0.42381638288497925,
-0.16810354590415955,
0.18378502130508423,
-0.7219246029853821,
-0.20664964616298676,
-0.045461565256118774,
0.9698287844657898,
0.1559385061264038,
0.46108657121658325,
-0.43141573667526245,
-0.249629408121109,
0.1825541853904724,
0.35002464056015015,
-0.8201670050621033,
-0.04174639284610748,
-0.013823781162500381,
-0.5222291350364685,
-0.02228364162147045,
-0.03669453412294388,
-0.7319400906562805,
-0.3567076027393341,
-0.31613561511039734,
0.3319794833660126,
-0.3432488739490509,
-0.026476386934518814,
-0.024661971256136894,
0.056850314140319824,
-0.25969749689102173,
0.2316974550485611,
-0.9981947541236877,
0.4478732943534851,
0.4319251775741577,
1.0185378789901733,
-0.286401629447937,
-0.39850911498069763,
-0.23047299683094025,
0.10871915519237518,
-0.40021708607673645,
0.37245258688926697,
-0.48562735319137573,
-0.5182947516441345,
0.008501757867634296,
-0.14635561406612396,
-0.47003230452537537,
-0.7282577157020569,
0.69254070520401,
-0.5697792768478394,
0.05562658607959747,
-0.5247617363929749,
-0.21088340878486633,
-0.196930393576622,
-0.014344547875225544,
-0.9575293660163879,
0.9114671349525452,
-0.10494167357683182,
-0.733232855796814,
0.3942111134529114,
-0.8001160025596619,
-0.9427940845489502,
0.08852577209472656,
0.10412145406007767,
-0.6369913816452026,
0.20212095975875854,
-0.09539919346570969,
0.26355287432670593,
-0.33839234709739685,
-0.27304747700691223,
-0.06051510199904442,
-0.5227178931236267,
0.30388373136520386,
-0.4283545911312103,
0.466208279132843,
0.48922494053840637,
-0.3965180516242981,
-0.46015292406082153,
-0.4482947885990143,
-0.03784183785319328,
0.10789722949266434,
-0.789104163646698,
-0.431407630443573,
0.043525997549295425,
0.0033552369568496943,
0.36997300386428833,
0.3680783212184906,
-0.41654759645462036,
0.016594871878623962,
-0.09529343247413635,
0.6577876806259155,
0.32332471013069153,
0.00043410915532149374,
0.4009571373462677,
-0.23389652371406555,
0.6727731823921204,
0.16675059497356415,
0.24534182250499725,
0.16038799285888672,
-0.5298126935958862,
-0.9029013514518738,
-0.2933673858642578,
0.6611220836639404,
0.724633514881134,
-0.7425297498703003,
-0.10967418551445007,
-0.23594346642494202,
-0.1232561245560646,
-0.9614667296409607,
0.12707532942295074,
0.693872332572937,
0.11918997019529343,
0.6109250783920288,
-0.661957859992981,
-0.5615310668945312,
-0.962942361831665,
-0.1895853728055954,
-0.20303142070770264,
0.2713440954685211,
0.17747145891189575,
0.4896433651447296,
0.03951758146286011,
0.39447838068008423,
-0.16594094038009644,
-0.31911104917526245,
-0.2017270028591156,
0.16467636823654175,
0.09980350732803345,
0.4302219748497009,
0.7354491949081421,
-0.7488179802894592,
-0.8577269911766052,
0.17895975708961487,
-0.6893873810768127,
-0.2075459063053131,
0.11533822864294052,
0.12668822705745697,
0.3499537408351898,
0.47103583812713623,
-0.3590083420276642,
0.512973427772522,
0.6855000257492065,
0.08760035037994385,
0.6929495334625244,
-0.4530613422393799,
0.6555516123771667,
-0.8368794322013855,
0.20982305705547333,
-0.2682490944862366,
0.08770690113306046,
-0.9874528050422668,
-0.04749661311507225,
-0.09574415534734726,
0.05339369177818298,
-0.42940008640289307,
0.07668996602296829,
-0.45635440945625305,
-0.10451207309961319,
-0.10963761061429977,
0.17332673072814941,
0.07659225165843964,
0.2771346867084503,
-0.05182841792702675,
1.1643352508544922,
0.13950896263122559,
-0.9043821096420288,
-0.1762218326330185,
0.2550276219844818,
-0.4472333490848541,
0.4913010597229004,
-0.6234158873558044,
-0.07649466395378113,
0.09167852252721786,
-0.12548601627349854,
-0.8427558541297913,
0.04130096361041069,
0.08521899580955505,
-0.42864319682121277,
0.2659541368484497,
-0.3570064604282379,
-0.8669224381446838,
-0.3773481845855713,
0.13203565776348114,
0.4821245074272156,
0.20969900488853455,
0.10251951217651367,
-0.20781157910823822,
0.4977569580078125,
-0.292965829372406,
-0.6460815668106079,
-1.0187296867370605,
0.3974447548389435,
-0.46068331599235535,
-0.16331246495246887,
0.3177908957004547,
-0.25431621074676514,
-0.43774646520614624,
-0.34196752309799194,
0.07105991244316101,
-0.32983601093292236,
0.5580635666847229,
0.26665425300598145,
0.04065026715397835,
0.006101784761995077,
0.18818484246730804,
0.056769851595163345,
0.015026084147393703,
-0.09282250702381134,
-0.15294420719146729,
0.6833246350288391,
0.05193382501602173,
-0.03865246847271919,
-0.4637480676174164,
0.4812716245651245,
0.9279002547264099,
-0.6953278183937073,
1.1329562664031982,
0.7670063376426697,
-0.17848455905914307,
0.2679835259914398,
-0.16424883902072906,
-0.034762442111968994,
-0.39833691716194153,
0.49822354316711426,
-0.9153833389282227,
-0.7114299535751343,
0.682189404964447,
0.12004049867391586,
0.18852952122688293,
0.42501741647720337,
0.9107709527015686,
-0.395395964384079,
1.0185284614562988,
0.6027747392654419,
-0.11480584740638733,
0.5958103537559509,
-0.3934885859489441,
0.3399835526943207,
-0.9510112404823303,
-0.1782337874174118,
-0.9025145769119263,
-0.5702863931655884,
-0.7733286023139954,
-0.22394895553588867,
0.52428138256073,
0.3795475959777832,
-0.14024367928504944,
0.7209460139274597,
-0.3548735976219177,
0.36807867884635925,
0.5996214151382446,
-0.0692133679986,
0.35622501373291016,
-0.07029695808887482,
-0.29953351616859436,
-0.28573840856552124,
-0.7344418168067932,
-0.8366760611534119,
0.970949113368988,
0.1351030319929123,
0.3949187397956848,
0.45778167247772217,
0.7446146011352539,
0.5263583064079285,
0.032893285155296326,
-0.5206100344657898,
0.19184209406375885,
-0.505222737789154,
-0.6486184597015381,
-0.285872220993042,
-0.4896792769432068,
-1.3329585790634155,
0.44417357444763184,
-0.2928537130355835,
-0.4573485255241394,
-0.053246863186359406,
0.026243949308991432,
-0.33121582865715027,
0.4513603746891022,
-0.5930505990982056,
0.6757282614707947,
-0.19742456078529358,
-0.26910606026649475,
-0.3608648478984833,
-0.7346362471580505,
0.06538913398981094,
-0.32919928431510925,
0.5708494186401367,
0.1286660134792328,
-0.023524580523371696,
0.9103650450706482,
-0.17364634573459625,
0.7300565838813782,
0.1723329722881317,
-0.14717406034469604,
0.23965220153331757,
0.46902525424957275,
0.055318523198366165,
-0.2550979554653168,
-0.20786523818969727,
0.6006442904472351,
-0.010054015554487705,
-0.2629522681236267,
-0.16339854896068573,
0.441698282957077,
-0.949953019618988,
-0.43479400873184204,
-0.13113926351070404,
-0.8310192823410034,
0.10434424877166748,
0.44054582715034485,
0.5373652577400208,
0.18678101897239685,
-0.14653174579143524,
0.057915907353162766,
0.6092519760131836,
0.0774407610297203,
0.7602947354316711,
0.34955328702926636,
0.1484425961971283,
-0.435433954000473,
0.7570633292198181,
0.5294992923736572,
0.6056610345840454,
0.5564801096916199,
-0.1062643826007843,
0.002572053810581565,
-0.7659772038459778,
-0.7636660933494568,
0.16982801258563995,
-0.35453373193740845,
-0.13609488308429718,
-0.8185470104217529,
-0.18669752776622772,
-0.291745126247406,
0.04261939972639084,
-0.2909805178642273,
-0.8150169849395752,
-0.4003198742866516,
0.1916680783033371,
0.09896781295537949,
0.7513092756271362,
-0.2777325510978699,
0.5088232159614563,
-0.8790343403816223,
0.16474008560180664,
-0.08213995397090912,
0.042043786495923996,
-0.06947799772024155,
-0.6374512910842896,
-1.0096702575683594,
0.15226368606090546,
-0.5348228216171265,
-0.6219828128814697,
0.2160676121711731,
0.20981751382350922,
0.40325555205345154,
0.3930703401565552,
0.08818668127059937,
0.670069694519043,
-0.8221384882926941,
0.847460150718689,
0.1382746696472168,
-0.8276005387306213,
0.06877662986516953,
0.02716801129281521,
0.1333857923746109,
0.6441366672515869,
0.45325490832328796,
-0.7865750193595886,
-0.7317217588424683,
-0.18853157758712769,
-0.5915067195892334,
0.5594494938850403,
0.45858243107795715,
-0.10806401073932648,
-0.04482773318886757,
0.2335565686225891,
0.19886364042758942,
0.3566131889820099,
-0.3685733675956726,
-0.4679623544216156,
0.12512977421283722,
-0.002836736151948571,
-0.3933207392692566,
-0.11298377811908722,
-0.05960962921380997,
0.014785390347242355,
0.3957631587982178,
0.2684202194213867,
0.0869237408041954,
0.024496793746948242,
-0.5259034633636475,
-0.2296566665172577,
0.3392799198627472,
0.7308011054992676,
0.39094242453575134,
0.06934104114770889,
0.18100260198116302,
-0.012213435024023056,
-0.8376968502998352,
0.14310817420482635,
-0.12321215122938156,
-0.16206683218479156,
-0.12569674849510193,
0.6197734475135803,
0.6722805500030518,
-0.12555725872516632,
-0.1755896955728531,
-0.06238481402397156,
0.06619136035442352,
-0.10913201421499252,
0.2943195402622223,
-0.13154858350753784,
-0.20300327241420746,
0.07341605424880981,
0.014426175504922867,
0.1071241945028305,
0.05467779561877251,
-0.5873857140541077,
-0.032054487615823746,
0.3184759318828583,
-0.40916433930397034,
-0.6234468817710876,
0.8931646347045898,
0.4012497365474701,
-0.47172343730926514,
0.6833528876304626,
0.13189584016799927,
-0.9840308427810669,
0.5454363226890564,
0.4206922948360443,
0.6224261522293091,
-0.5052666068077087,
0.10155756771564484,
0.24627915024757385,
0.8665711879730225,
0.25322967767715454,
0.22577325999736786,
-0.2054484337568283,
-0.5222472548484802,
-0.41870903968811035,
-0.5302449464797974,
-0.4601842164993286,
0.010166932828724384,
-0.8202253580093384,
-0.09144198149442673,
0.0032749841921031475,
-0.8047519326210022,
0.16822867095470428,
0.42470380663871765,
-0.7949711680412292,
0.1499551236629486,
0.21100792288780212,
0.28370046615600586,
-1.002955675125122,
0.6522738337516785,
0.7256857752799988,
-0.6834232211112976,
0.021103618666529655,
-0.17209793627262115,
-0.08677206188440323,
-0.4947966933250427,
0.624630331993103,
-0.006096892990171909,
-0.12121129035949707,
-0.06089678779244423,
0.14403162896633148,
-0.86875319480896,
0.9003217220306396,
0.23988670110702515,
-0.5061581134796143,
0.11638625711202621,
0.8476834893226624,
0.7572687864303589,
-0.07051732391119003,
0.06909308582544327,
0.7126505970954895,
0.5801586508750916,
-0.7085029482841492,
-1.6449456214904785,
-0.24918371438980103,
0.10056859999895096,
-0.1434532254934311,
0.5757441520690918,
-0.9979239106178284,
0.9501029253005981,
-0.49799835681915283,
-0.559414267539978,
0.18261127173900604,
0.1523277312517166,
-0.23936796188354492,
0.13250723481178284,
0.29345542192459106,
0.6272339820861816,
0.5261337161064148,
-0.1480436474084854,
0.8853442072868347,
-0.4911178946495056,
0.17794416844844818,
0.9454887509346008,
-0.32159990072250366,
0.5198925137519836,
0.6427974104881287,
-0.4182069003582001,
0.5521622896194458,
0.8118433952331543,
0.3788018822669983,
0.5637226104736328,
0.2612200975418091,
-0.2519534230232239,
-0.16497375071048737,
-0.282400906085968,
-0.269084632396698,
0.4945760667324066,
0.38456764817237854,
-0.49453914165496826,
0.0245208740234375,
0.10486002266407013,
0.22438305616378784,
0.1750621199607849,
-0.00030739145586267114,
0.7454084753990173,
0.1744190901517868,
-0.6122657656669617,
0.7687786817550659,
0.29170146584510803,
0.19205020368099213,
-0.36791372299194336,
0.16004934906959534,
-0.2324172854423523,
0.10407058894634247,
-0.04578632861375809,
-0.7203145623207092,
0.3886147737503052,
0.04598783329129219,
-0.6252522468566895,
-0.2604740560054779,
0.1657467484474182,
-0.49697205424308777,
-0.13691164553165436,
0.3605388402938843,
0.8190842270851135,
0.33867180347442627,
0.14848820865154266,
-0.5913412570953369,
0.2941548228263855,
-0.18209265172481537,
-0.028060859069228172,
0.46270817518234253,
0.5670273900032043,
-0.35362526774406433,
0.6286884546279907,
0.5288458466529846,
0.27864959836006165,
0.1634242832660675,
0.1041574776172638,
0.5405810475349426,
-0.3003667891025543,
-0.3410257399082184,
-1.0071368217468262,
0.14763695001602173,
0.05346057936549187,
-0.23778174817562103,
0.7893728613853455,
0.8096832633018494,
0.7888763546943665,
-0.10046622902154922,
0.8549383282661438,
-0.0862191841006279,
0.20846545696258545,
-0.33515599370002747,
0.7799268364906311,
-0.45859494805336,
-0.043848998844623566,
-0.3761935234069824,
-1.0055196285247803,
-0.41571852564811707,
0.16798633337020874,
-0.10775458812713623,
-0.1293099969625473,
0.9539717435836792,
0.33552828431129456,
0.06424475461244583,
-0.26827290654182434,
0.4988503158092499,
0.00035135907819494605,
0.19760869443416595,
0.5131107568740845,
0.5403231382369995,
-0.5205662250518799,
0.7538194060325623,
-0.408792644739151,
-0.27952155470848083,
-0.1692306399345398,
-0.4568241536617279,
-0.7590195536613464,
-0.791017472743988,
-0.35126563906669617,
-0.2871590852737427,
0.05654795467853546,
0.39657679200172424,
0.6180772185325623,
-0.714250385761261,
-0.5328296422958374,
0.48683270812034607,
0.15973371267318726,
-0.648841142654419,
-0.1692320853471756,
0.4136173725128174,
-0.3265478312969208,
-1.00191068649292,
0.2797420620918274,
0.36540353298187256,
0.3101503252983093,
-0.11958815902471542,
-0.1548319309949875,
-0.11311063170433044,
0.1474200189113617,
0.839915931224823,
0.21794390678405762,
-0.5421448349952698,
-0.06736773252487183,
-0.012779299169778824,
-0.31018027663230896,
0.06313490867614746,
0.9425730109214783,
-0.41764670610427856,
0.5207266807556152,
0.20666661858558655,
0.4883458912372589,
0.36300185322761536,
-0.013729406520724297,
0.3346988558769226,
-0.6802528500556946,
0.05702429637312889,
0.008209999650716782,
0.18285618722438812,
0.2875877916812897,
-0.22411991655826569,
0.6260027885437012,
0.2925164997577667,
-0.7475512623786926,
-0.9294571280479431,
0.5049899816513062,
-0.39873966574668884,
-0.001996755599975586,
0.7723401784896851,
-0.10921233892440796,
0.21897369623184204,
-0.34884175658226013,
0.18387888371944427,
0.6004782319068909,
0.027296502143144608,
0.9787142276763916,
0.9499214291572571,
-0.02640903927385807,
0.166253924369812,
-0.8056983947753906,
0.6046963930130005,
0.31313082575798035,
-0.6838021278381348,
0.22959880530834198,
0.17708297073841095,
0.10850370675325394,
0.40896743535995483,
0.43833720684051514,
-0.3182393014431,
0.08638059347867966,
-0.2089582085609436,
0.08495885133743286,
0.095459945499897,
-0.5603488683700562,
-0.18885180354118347,
-0.15783822536468506,
-0.05995996296405792,
-0.49023860692977905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05904v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05904v2
|
The Hallucinations Leaderboard -- An Open Effort to Measure Hallucinations in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-08T23:16:22 | 2024-04-17T07:03:17 |
Giwon Hong, Aryo Pradipta Gema, Rohit Saxena, Xiaotang Du, Ping Nie, Yu Zhao, Laura Perez-Beltrachini, Max Ryabinin, Xuanli He, Clémentine Fourrier, Pasquale Minervini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have transformed the Natural Language Processing
(NLP) landscape with their remarkable ability to understand and generate
human-like text. However, these models are prone to ``hallucinations'' --
outputs that do not align with factual reality or the input context. This paper
introduces the Hallucinations Leaderboard, an open initiative to quantitatively
measure and compare the tendency of each model to produce hallucinations. The
leaderboard uses a comprehensive set of benchmarks focusing on different
aspects of hallucinations, such as factuality and faithfulness, across various
tasks, including question-answering, summarisation, and reading comprehension.
Our analysis provides insights into the performance of different models,
guiding researchers and practitioners in choosing the most reliable models for
their applications.
|
[
-0.29892808198928833,
-0.8705579042434692,
0.731253981590271,
0.4765530228614807,
-0.2616487443447113,
-0.1229763850569725,
-0.3154489994049072,
-0.47541046142578125,
0.523238480091095,
0.7351857423782349,
-0.42568475008010864,
-0.8214688301086426,
-0.778874397277832,
0.26556599140167236,
-0.8483025431632996,
0.8916626572608948,
0.16933728754520416,
0.05633469298481941,
-0.21432922780513763,
0.06737635284662247,
-0.6132805347442627,
-0.7477940320968628,
-0.4237748086452484,
-0.3264758884906769,
0.6319265365600586,
-0.07797491550445557,
1.0809857845306396,
0.3326217532157898,
0.8152867555618286,
0.22912350296974182,
0.021542441099882126,
0.280791699886322,
-0.7499443888664246,
0.5066593289375305,
-0.2290782332420349,
-0.32819807529449463,
-0.6470605731010437,
0.047416456043720245,
0.3183531165122986,
0.7924942374229431,
-0.4872986972332001,
0.05501976236701012,
0.18233485519886017,
0.5102565288543701,
-0.4637147784233093,
0.10773922502994537,
-0.7468866109848022,
0.2047702670097351,
0.04785982146859169,
-0.3813154101371765,
-0.5828680396080017,
-0.7906070947647095,
0.01804680936038494,
-0.12098155915737152,
0.18427056074142456,
0.25742998719215393,
0.5413084030151367,
0.33719876408576965,
-0.06680197268724442,
-0.6756774187088013,
-0.7299171686172485,
0.6128883957862854,
-0.5783274173736572,
0.6535259485244751,
0.34211573004722595,
0.3345613479614258,
-0.3223037123680115,
-0.7754355072975159,
-0.37274158000946045,
-0.46338972449302673,
0.001689212047494948,
-0.06923609972000122,
-0.17943330109119415,
-0.10328316688537598,
0.0652381107211113,
0.4068707823753357,
-0.8215239644050598,
0.18584582209587097,
-0.2024659961462021,
-0.16642095148563385,
0.7421067357063293,
0.30906856060028076,
0.2618520259857178,
-0.18190981447696686,
-0.13937294483184814,
-0.09586377441883087,
-0.3199450671672821,
-0.4071976840496063,
0.24695158004760742,
0.41144445538520813,
0.12722207605838776,
0.8253982663154602,
0.054146550595760345,
0.43603453040122986,
-0.21806232631206512,
-0.18709279596805573,
-0.006814048625528812,
-0.061651792377233505,
-0.2297171652317047,
0.3382643461227417,
0.6770829558372498,
0.7032563090324402,
0.3383864760398865,
-0.7511976361274719,
-0.32481175661087036,
0.28422147035598755,
0.5884860754013062,
-0.8201972842216492,
-0.47623029351234436,
0.43628960847854614,
-0.4706841707229614,
-0.34072455763816833,
0.12862932682037354,
-0.9837058186531067,
-0.7737421989440918,
-0.14052268862724304,
0.4395672380924225,
-0.35433709621429443,
-0.1926925927400589,
0.06920329481363297,
-0.035342562943696976,
0.07177233695983887,
0.29705435037612915,
-0.8711264729499817,
0.5429210662841797,
0.7923750281333923,
1.1194443702697754,
-0.7390263080596924,
-0.42056500911712646,
-0.45644089579582214,
-0.19737033545970917,
-0.5938940644264221,
0.8838045597076416,
-0.32394665479660034,
-0.26992475986480713,
-0.005388657562434673,
-0.22029811143875122,
-0.011662573553621769,
-0.9361780285835266,
0.6941520571708679,
-0.33928394317626953,
-0.019090987741947174,
-0.27135735750198364,
-0.5476757287979126,
-0.05182432383298874,
0.37215498089790344,
-0.6208702325820923,
1.0116175413131714,
-0.2754030227661133,
-0.5634967684745789,
0.1782679557800293,
-0.2173471599817276,
-0.012560435570776463,
-0.027755584567785263,
-0.19109562039375305,
-0.1567048281431198,
0.374064177274704,
0.1275658905506134,
0.6132697463035583,
-0.264660120010376,
0.6996030807495117,
-0.0652235671877861,
-0.4482882022857666,
0.4668014347553253,
-0.3027598261833191,
0.5513620376586914,
-0.13179561495780945,
-0.2908714711666107,
0.383828341960907,
-0.7870050668716431,
-0.12290651351213455,
0.06321624666452408,
0.013758018612861633,
-0.25025591254234314,
0.17721058428287506,
-0.03320370987057686,
0.023024534806609154,
0.05838489532470703,
-0.12608259916305542,
0.031048549339175224,
-0.36879947781562805,
0.09807837009429932,
0.8538270592689514,
0.11368951946496964,
-0.07703648507595062,
-0.5187723636627197,
0.30598315596580505,
-0.04831235483288765,
0.027938663959503174,
0.08349643647670746,
-0.7350963354110718,
-0.640341579914093,
-0.16216979920864105,
0.0032315554562956095,
0.3827512860298157,
-0.2679593563079834,
0.6351910829544067,
-0.23377452790737152,
-0.6739985346794128,
-0.5403249263763428,
-0.0875999704003334,
0.032320164144039154,
0.40785446763038635,
0.3482089340686798,
-0.2829790711402893,
-0.49565115571022034,
-0.815066397190094,
-0.3170345723628998,
-0.33204978704452515,
-0.10361567884683609,
0.020573211833834648,
0.6975827217102051,
-0.2732267677783966,
0.3294987380504608,
-0.44867590069770813,
-0.49125930666923523,
-0.038880180567502975,
0.24146555364131927,
0.19774669408798218,
0.03675055876374245,
0.35072776675224304,
-0.42931076884269714,
-0.16394121944904327,
-0.20238333940505981,
-1.0802394151687622,
-0.10406210273504257,
-0.030400551855564117,
-0.09943606704473495,
0.2842990756034851,
0.48204073309898376,
-0.5271770358085632,
0.43054062128067017,
0.8607361912727356,
-0.509890615940094,
0.8279711604118347,
-0.022197214886546135,
0.34739774465560913,
-0.7071641087532043,
0.020314441993832588,
-0.3002123534679413,
0.16585446894168854,
-0.4865967333316803,
0.17331300675868988,
-0.3422529101371765,
0.1045759990811348,
0.06528361886739731,
0.3017294406890869,
-0.2926493287086487,
-0.3939374089241028,
0.004433476831763983,
0.6673513650894165,
-0.15621179342269897,
0.24181319773197174,
-0.10134861618280411,
0.6496087312698364,
0.5314780473709106,
-0.3905971646308899,
0.649567186832428,
0.33184388279914856,
-0.665964663028717,
0.2601969242095947,
-0.32192644476890564,
0.27772659063339233,
-0.07216998189687729,
-0.19780127704143524,
-1.1909570693969727,
-0.3986368179321289,
0.11666753888130188,
-0.3990027904510498,
-0.236322820186615,
0.5292954444885254,
-0.7047110795974731,
-0.21122483909130096,
-0.33779677748680115,
-0.11078871041536331,
0.48756471276283264,
-0.6123430728912354,
0.5010000467300415,
0.2366010993719101,
-0.03575524687767029,
-0.3446309566497803,
-0.6501778364181519,
0.4054655134677887,
-0.04759896919131279,
-0.47622889280319214,
0.2570516765117645,
-0.2179267406463623,
-0.6381508708000183,
-0.013530509546399117,
0.013871326111257076,
0.04146720468997955,
0.0027081859298050404,
0.5164628624916077,
0.16045914590358734,
-0.38975265622138977,
0.1304653286933899,
-0.19554808735847473,
0.19686885178089142,
0.4885560870170593,
0.18710316717624664,
0.7787373065948486,
-0.0020490072201937437,
-0.3190830647945404,
-0.4652137756347656,
0.11783929914236069,
0.6605042219161987,
0.033562470227479935,
0.9646341800689697,
0.1266334503889084,
-0.5322093963623047,
-0.4544597566127777,
-0.6458647847175598,
-0.4847174286842346,
-0.39101335406303406,
0.36220425367355347,
-0.3580896854400635,
-0.6757187247276306,
0.7229612469673157,
0.27866047620773315,
0.041856952011585236,
0.4210309088230133,
0.6810697317123413,
0.18804261088371277,
1.0540651082992554,
0.4473888576030731,
0.2685635983943939,
-0.2265920341014862,
0.195013627409935,
0.597574770450592,
-0.4653237760066986,
-0.6048213243484497,
-0.5263600945472717,
-0.10397700220346451,
-0.4711117446422577,
-0.30400997400283813,
0.1681443303823471,
0.0644100233912468,
0.10757178068161011,
0.06879625469446182,
-0.7453250288963318,
0.37741973996162415,
0.17160074412822723,
-0.06861606985330582,
0.563305675983429,
0.09036725759506226,
-0.016507821157574654,
-0.44398561120033264,
-0.36335763335227966,
-0.9092415571212769,
0.9557144045829773,
0.19250410795211792,
0.6583353281021118,
0.15796290338039398,
0.560745894908905,
0.547353208065033,
0.3035723865032196,
-0.8090744614601135,
0.8705776333808899,
-0.051947783678770065,
-0.3814307451248169,
-0.45717835426330566,
-0.31096145510673523,
-0.61783367395401,
0.43513622879981995,
-0.3749731779098511,
-0.9564027190208435,
-0.11203954368829727,
-0.19784392416477203,
-0.31805381178855896,
0.5478907823562622,
-0.2533164322376251,
0.7547993659973145,
-0.20818963646888733,
-0.09733936935663223,
-0.13786520063877106,
-0.12667866051197052,
0.5498834848403931,
-0.1911415308713913,
0.0383521169424057,
-0.14432264864444733,
0.07474473863840103,
0.8333492279052734,
-0.049476444721221924,
0.7180709838867188,
0.12710371613502502,
-0.3544909358024597,
0.1664634793996811,
0.5333518385887146,
0.2845379710197449,
-0.11770905554294586,
-0.31390878558158875,
0.422428160905838,
-0.16236086189746857,
0.09799758344888687,
-0.6109022498130798,
0.8535562753677368,
-0.7549141645431519,
-0.5250993967056274,
-0.4421333074569702,
-0.5288886427879333,
-0.21883970499038696,
-0.025943981483578682,
0.23108620941638947,
0.1790052354335785,
-0.6630554795265198,
0.20612452924251556,
0.533919095993042,
-0.2092929482460022,
0.19861464202404022,
0.04426196962594986,
-0.8610780239105225,
-0.3338785767555237,
0.6265296339988708,
0.3253621757030487,
0.07183624804019928,
0.018963448703289032,
0.01263654325157404,
-0.14538219571113586,
-0.8893933892250061,
-0.1882018893957138,
0.3899998068809509,
-0.8291308283805847,
0.06207069382071495,
-0.787250280380249,
-0.5158316493034363,
-0.702659010887146,
-0.10320962220430374,
-0.3900807499885559,
-0.1478513926267624,
-0.3497791290283203,
-0.328011155128479,
0.14316359162330627,
0.9087203145027161,
0.11924588680267334,
0.051639314740896225,
-0.3834564685821533,
0.5788747668266296,
0.42192891240119934,
0.4611404836177826,
0.260469526052475,
-0.7038350105285645,
0.006608462426811457,
-0.25160837173461914,
-0.2972975969314575,
-1.0327140092849731,
0.6069668531417847,
-0.17210955917835236,
0.45466122031211853,
0.5883258581161499,
0.1339970827102661,
0.6481217741966248,
-0.3726317584514618,
0.8296303153038025,
0.09871086478233337,
-0.7817919254302979,
0.4449642300605774,
0.03429439663887024,
0.0851055383682251,
0.4751608669757843,
0.6155975461006165,
-0.599837064743042,
-0.812742292881012,
-0.23600924015045166,
-0.47823643684387207,
0.4094659090042114,
0.43955275416374207,
-0.08685137331485748,
-0.16716766357421875,
0.30964019894599915,
0.480775386095047,
0.20847488939762115,
-0.7141909003257751,
-0.06299784034490585,
-0.09913044422864914,
-0.08245894312858582,
-0.024830495938658714,
-0.4957421123981476,
-0.010302445851266384,
-0.14564190804958344,
0.6460540890693665,
0.10992597043514252,
0.07141739875078201,
0.23789319396018982,
-0.04574689269065857,
-0.3885956108570099,
-0.01036533061414957,
0.6667430400848389,
1.0840883255004883,
-0.5617700219154358,
0.38587820529937744,
0.06728129088878632,
-0.6372275352478027,
-0.2214348167181015,
-0.26415589451789856,
-0.07413597404956818,
0.1872832477092743,
0.743769109249115,
0.7268272638320923,
0.10458409786224365,
-0.9268203377723694,
0.3416551947593689,
-0.1353626400232315,
-0.197901651263237,
-0.2890293300151825,
0.24905569851398468,
0.022293105721473694,
0.3158465027809143,
0.4280560314655304,
-0.14327499270439148,
0.2385217696428299,
-0.9011562466621399,
0.23742787539958954,
0.2285526841878891,
-0.5143361687660217,
-0.48320138454437256,
0.6428893804550171,
-0.06017228960990906,
-0.7937423586845398,
0.9089867472648621,
0.052220601588487625,
-0.451262503862381,
0.5829120874404907,
0.564423143863678,
1.0883841514587402,
-0.3182213008403778,
0.37052929401397705,
0.6099987626075745,
0.6860384345054626,
-0.27020853757858276,
0.18761219084262848,
0.32444146275520325,
-0.7106960415840149,
-0.12234985083341599,
-0.7893556952476501,
-0.5125635862350464,
0.36394408345222473,
-0.7780089378356934,
0.27303019165992737,
-0.38500431180000305,
-0.2594858407974243,
0.18634764850139618,
-0.28372710943222046,
-0.17793254554271698,
0.09961345046758652,
0.290864497423172,
0.6684128642082214,
-0.8409175872802734,
0.5924930572509766,
0.19876481592655182,
-0.17797985672950745,
-0.10924085974693298,
0.2763018012046814,
-0.30621016025543213,
-0.5553224682807922,
0.4129006564617157,
0.4084978699684143,
-0.2510054409503937,
-0.21243466436862946,
-0.6853122711181641,
-0.4977259337902069,
0.8032781481742859,
0.19674985110759735,
-0.5309755802154541,
-0.3892936706542969,
0.2168455868959427,
0.7642325758934021,
-0.5474063158035278,
-0.000644223066046834,
0.6025782823562622,
0.5880143046379089,
-0.11484422534704208,
-0.7705903053283691,
0.2290133237838745,
0.15510471165180206,
-0.1404336541891098,
0.019537203013896942,
-0.3879956305027008,
0.8312203288078308,
-0.4275890290737152,
-0.3579958379268646,
0.22123363614082336,
0.6948041319847107,
0.41506820917129517,
0.3225615620613098,
0.3081892132759094,
0.4597358703613281,
0.855002760887146,
-0.15327228605747223,
0.8672298192977905,
-0.24860067665576935,
0.05971422791481018,
1.2141942977905273,
-0.5920757055282593,
0.9752986431121826,
0.5033758282661438,
0.08330253511667252,
0.5010291934013367,
0.27553340792655945,
-0.32839715480804443,
0.5087363123893738,
0.2692115306854248,
0.2015487551689148,
-0.3923293352127075,
-0.0246774572879076,
-0.3062978982925415,
0.37201568484306335,
0.2417685091495514,
-0.38835084438323975,
-0.2418588101863861,
0.12968118488788605,
-0.11849124729633331,
0.3994017243385315,
-0.0751984640955925,
0.815969705581665,
0.1350211203098297,
-0.784597635269165,
0.5749027132987976,
-0.042025126516819,
0.3905111849308014,
-0.41791051626205444,
-0.28714656829833984,
-0.38388052582740784,
0.017382940277457237,
-0.1946563869714737,
-0.8624492287635803,
0.5994558930397034,
0.14887414872646332,
-0.08660557866096497,
-0.025380684062838554,
0.3339356780052185,
-0.125793918967247,
-0.443634957075119,
0.828865110874176,
0.46918654441833496,
0.5964863896369934,
-0.2570042610168457,
-0.38846924901008606,
0.5313555598258972,
-0.2928202152252197,
-0.23729000985622406,
0.04174336418509483,
0.5553646087646484,
-0.02766788750886917,
0.6251521110534668,
0.3880288302898407,
0.27378374338150024,
0.221700057387352,
0.08698873966932297,
0.5627959370613098,
-0.8818934559822083,
-0.20282749831676483,
-1.0729132890701294,
0.14115294814109802,
-0.14376680552959442,
-0.5076785087585449,
1.008991003036499,
0.7507666945457458,
0.5926810503005981,
0.062225520610809326,
0.23991543054580688,
0.18542252480983734,
0.41019096970558167,
-0.4682997763156891,
1.08225417137146,
-0.43856287002563477,
0.16880834102630615,
-0.14861267805099487,
-1.2819864749908447,
-0.5081755518913269,
0.6739305853843689,
-0.11755940318107605,
-0.2370111048221588,
0.8999247550964355,
0.9558274149894714,
0.25011998414993286,
0.18568824231624603,
0.7404273152351379,
0.9045069813728333,
0.06471091508865356,
0.18990099430084229,
0.9391353130340576,
-0.2753232717514038,
0.3823235034942627,
-0.16755373775959015,
-0.13158729672431946,
-0.32140877842903137,
-0.6603298187255859,
-1.318589448928833,
-0.6772986650466919,
-0.3068464994430542,
-0.46173980832099915,
0.4008564352989197,
0.6275553703308105,
0.2863784432411194,
-1.0291906595230103,
-0.42538249492645264,
0.10504723340272903,
0.15909479558467865,
-0.1677393913269043,
-0.23405039310455322,
0.4824090003967285,
-0.1360672116279602,
-0.46073561906814575,
0.29767370223999023,
0.44917863607406616,
-0.12466752529144287,
-0.7503288388252258,
0.06795834004878998,
-0.017347218468785286,
0.46547678112983704,
0.7709765434265137,
-0.36725908517837524,
-1.0975466966629028,
-0.30755847692489624,
0.19412356615066528,
-0.3568240702152252,
0.1724405288696289,
0.4786810874938965,
-0.5774955153465271,
0.37051841616630554,
0.37637731432914734,
0.33949610590934753,
0.1777999848127365,
-0.21600590646266937,
0.11968518048524857,
-0.2503114342689514,
-0.1654605269432068,
0.3738899528980255,
0.0168461911380291,
0.37182608246803284,
-0.27036648988723755,
0.6828286051750183,
0.09960486739873886,
-0.6064456701278687,
-1.4007291793823242,
-0.12088769674301147,
-0.9740645289421082,
-0.44567620754241943,
0.8360552191734314,
0.30602356791496277,
-0.2408546656370163,
0.1070365384221077,
-0.20470072329044342,
0.06582284718751907,
-0.15404155850410461,
1.4292731285095215,
0.9469128847122192,
-0.13108457624912262,
0.12909434735774994,
-0.8505101203918457,
0.4666559100151062,
0.08998528867959976,
-0.7943624258041382,
0.28289154171943665,
0.5692504048347473,
-0.25752055644989014,
0.35884979367256165,
0.5118239521980286,
-0.04621116816997528,
-0.06492243707180023,
0.11062748730182648,
0.20111379027366638,
0.28028109669685364,
-0.8177502751350403,
-0.21891167759895325,
0.7015977501869202,
0.017787648364901543,
0.29464811086654663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05902v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05902v1
|
WILBUR: Adaptive In-Context Learning for Robust and Accurate Web Agents
| 2024-04-08T23:10:47 | 2024-04-08T23:10:47 |
Michael Lutz, Arth Bohra, Manvel Saroyan, Artem Harutyunyan, Giovanni Campagna
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the realm of web agent research, achieving both generalization and
accuracy remains a challenging problem. Due to high variance in website
structure, existing approaches often fail. Moreover, existing fine-tuning and
in-context learning techniques fail to generalize across multiple websites. We
introduce Wilbur, an approach that uses a differentiable ranking model and a
novel instruction synthesis technique to optimally populate a black-box large
language model's prompt with task demonstrations from previous runs. To
maximize end-to-end success rates, we also propose an intelligent backtracking
mechanism that learns and recovers from its mistakes. Finally, we show that our
ranking model can be trained on data from a generative auto-curriculum which
samples representative goals from an LLM, runs the agent, and automatically
evaluates it, with no manual annotation. Wilbur achieves state-of-the-art
results on the WebVoyager benchmark, beating text-only models by 8% overall,
and up to 36% on certain websites. On the same benchmark, Wilbur is within 5%
of a strong multi-modal model despite only receiving textual inputs, and
further analysis reveals a substantial number of failures are due to
engineering challenges of operating the web.
|
[
-0.2627047896385193,
-0.7438459992408752,
0.3471706509590149,
0.3314208686351776,
0.331783264875412,
0.41553786396980286,
-0.3814384341239929,
-0.4134840667247772,
-0.1819908767938614,
-0.21991534531116486,
-0.4782102108001709,
-0.627842903137207,
-0.4263080656528473,
0.20394174754619598,
-0.4510560929775238,
0.9175276160240173,
0.27111974358558655,
-0.08804129809141159,
-0.3656480610370636,
0.164179727435112,
-0.2741004526615143,
-0.408265620470047,
-0.838692843914032,
-0.10179207473993301,
0.47609078884124756,
0.31541892886161804,
0.6035114526748657,
0.6561159491539001,
0.22376464307308197,
0.3856644928455353,
0.129214346408844,
0.21393311023712158,
-0.6512974500656128,
0.14920111000537872,
-0.47060278058052063,
-0.3386361002922058,
-0.49919623136520386,
0.034117721021175385,
0.6316981911659241,
0.7747890949249268,
-0.376323938369751,
-0.2540397047996521,
0.257535845041275,
0.29839104413986206,
-0.9059983491897583,
0.10134553909301758,
-0.7001575827598572,
-0.14370708167552948,
0.24108855426311493,
-0.31565216183662415,
-0.846835732460022,
-0.41272491216659546,
0.3118772506713867,
-0.8990402817726135,
0.34801265597343445,
0.112064890563488,
0.6586852669715881,
0.2608284652233124,
-0.5467979311943054,
-0.516657292842865,
-0.3832536041736603,
1.1702200174331665,
-0.45164406299591064,
0.5577947497367859,
0.39097586274147034,
0.5584056973457336,
-0.42396190762519836,
-0.7680128812789917,
-0.2858518064022064,
-0.44155851006507874,
0.17443840205669403,
0.24000787734985352,
-0.2748182713985443,
-0.23432129621505737,
0.0931352823972702,
-0.03067679889500141,
-0.5785754323005676,
0.2230289727449417,
-0.21060453355312347,
-0.16801762580871582,
0.48666879534721375,
0.2999365031719208,
0.20345796644687653,
0.25584250688552856,
-0.30747514963150024,
-0.5384638905525208,
-0.308045893907547,
0.4436056911945343,
0.3503386974334717,
0.5708017945289612,
-0.08622787147760391,
-0.10786451399326324,
-0.40153807401657104,
0.9041677117347717,
0.5275402665138245,
-0.04619345813989639,
0.17888225615024567,
0.2254541516304016,
-0.2290698140859604,
-0.1961796134710312,
0.4690884053707123,
0.02678392454981804,
-0.020279113203287125,
-0.4098901152610779,
-0.16520115733146667,
-0.20908071100711823,
0.6879197955131531,
-0.6877040266990662,
-0.3513680696487427,
0.33601024746894836,
-0.28256481885910034,
-0.3275093734264374,
0.3225543200969696,
-0.6121914386749268,
-0.18624381721019745,
-0.06867160648107529,
0.36268162727355957,
-0.4585418999195099,
0.05853000283241272,
-0.14990492165088654,
-0.25707530975341797,
0.33225229382514954,
0.6636974215507507,
-0.9404692053794861,
0.06402266025543213,
0.48459774255752563,
0.6829224228858948,
-0.44098755717277527,
-0.7756759524345398,
-0.74977046251297,
0.2887342572212219,
-0.709924578666687,
0.8429148197174072,
-0.7373649477958679,
-0.22727277874946594,
0.20116011798381805,
0.04528476297855377,
-0.08039888739585876,
-0.3569469451904297,
-0.10375330597162247,
-0.5711630582809448,
0.1610528826713562,
-0.11198246479034424,
-0.5083112120628357,
-0.23301519453525543,
0.5850570797920227,
-0.3657682240009308,
0.6891599297523499,
0.2577439248561859,
-0.33159303665161133,
0.3069668412208557,
-0.3288881480693817,
-0.6452541351318359,
-0.18704122304916382,
0.14592090249061584,
-0.1540466696023941,
0.15011046826839447,
0.08954964578151703,
0.48155951499938965,
-0.19091376662254333,
0.07900777459144592,
-0.3780733048915863,
-0.5342557430267334,
0.2679869532585144,
-0.4191463887691498,
0.8099802136421204,
-0.12112139910459518,
-0.3629379868507385,
0.3286820948123932,
-1.0702804327011108,
0.1951950490474701,
0.07778648287057877,
-0.8191322088241577,
-0.340731143951416,
0.23469217121601105,
-0.015670329332351685,
0.004258163273334503,
0.09449237585067749,
-0.24829985201358795,
0.4030669927597046,
-0.4746573567390442,
0.13450360298156738,
1.0150235891342163,
-0.17007793486118317,
0.45445379614830017,
-0.6246763467788696,
0.6479045152664185,
-0.3559252917766571,
0.32299795746803284,
0.06358879059553146,
-0.09551891684532166,
-0.7951104640960693,
-0.08317592740058899,
0.2432631254196167,
0.4829425811767578,
-0.7969301342964172,
0.3174094557762146,
-0.23483486473560333,
-0.5697051882743835,
-0.02528543584048748,
0.030708054080605507,
0.48899444937705994,
0.31978142261505127,
0.6641467213630676,
-0.29763442277908325,
-0.07706116139888763,
-0.5240595936775208,
-0.10865923017263412,
-0.20318983495235443,
-0.22394166886806488,
0.10344203561544418,
0.4262131452560425,
-0.37015801668167114,
0.8097435832023621,
-0.4969332814216614,
-0.25538527965545654,
-0.11914508789777756,
0.2923761010169983,
-0.13735806941986084,
0.5548282265663147,
0.5119020342826843,
-0.8715448975563049,
-0.6956146359443665,
0.15464551746845245,
-0.8564049005508423,
0.13423314690589905,
-0.21395501494407654,
-0.08694569766521454,
0.09185321629047394,
0.4306335747241974,
-0.16124027967453003,
0.18297074735164642,
0.44670364260673523,
-0.049416493624448776,
0.3950624167919159,
-0.1425713449716568,
0.16652938723564148,
-0.9831720590591431,
-0.17623339593410492,
0.15995734930038452,
-0.3125048875808716,
-0.4135558009147644,
0.4258173108100891,
0.19521275162696838,
0.10439466685056686,
-0.48167091608047485,
0.4070034325122833,
-0.5888648629188538,
0.07471450418233871,
-0.4186062812805176,
0.009305662475526333,
-0.09752895683050156,
0.8559852242469788,
-0.2963743805885315,
0.9145439267158508,
0.7237449288368225,
-0.8730267882347107,
0.5767751336097717,
0.3502853214740753,
-0.055399831384420395,
0.7944642901420593,
-0.4146086275577545,
0.24769388139247894,
-0.08258237689733505,
0.3216002881526947,
-0.6882851123809814,
-0.45754432678222656,
0.1745801568031311,
-0.5170003175735474,
0.4539485275745392,
-0.1163501888513565,
0.025058191269636154,
-0.027185222133994102,
-0.6295788288116455,
0.12328051775693893,
0.3708193600177765,
-0.6800917387008667,
0.8043874502182007,
0.22442932426929474,
0.02349465899169445,
-0.6154621839523315,
-0.3780369758605957,
0.0631394237279892,
0.02715916559100151,
-0.2948538661003113,
0.38835182785987854,
-0.4772464632987976,
-0.25463974475860596,
-0.04894966632127762,
-0.09841453284025192,
-0.4263889193534851,
0.43547433614730835,
0.08778621256351471,
-0.1962926983833313,
-0.023857073858380318,
0.17218315601348877,
0.19798550009727478,
0.09548027813434601,
0.06981863081455231,
-0.4589988887310028,
0.14666469395160675,
-0.14988112449645996,
-0.34843409061431885,
-0.39620569348335266,
0.3098132610321045,
0.3929305374622345,
0.02465403452515602,
0.6627511382102966,
0.34307071566581726,
-0.4701814651489258,
-0.9914129972457886,
-0.15103761851787567,
-0.1555946171283722,
-0.505283534526825,
0.3173130750656128,
-0.48461493849754333,
-0.4941016137599945,
0.20473264157772064,
-0.07179895788431168,
0.1633012890815735,
0.24613018333911896,
0.3293381631374359,
-0.22491919994354248,
1.1484493017196655,
0.976839005947113,
0.07585819065570831,
0.6570224761962891,
-0.3402518332004547,
-0.29076969623565674,
-0.6160915493965149,
-0.28103938698768616,
-0.5161927342414856,
-0.06442444771528244,
-0.43510162830352783,
-0.134352445602417,
0.4041930139064789,
0.08727213740348816,
-0.13332661986351013,
0.3324021100997925,
-0.471708744764328,
0.37250640988349915,
0.7887921333312988,
0.2698233127593994,
0.10380753874778748,
0.13562603294849396,
-0.021513503044843674,
0.4311259686946869,
-0.735369086265564,
-0.20710155367851257,
1.078015685081482,
-0.148467019200325,
0.9624977111816406,
0.5881935358047485,
0.4572753310203552,
0.7086860537528992,
0.46781784296035767,
-0.7175896763801575,
0.36513087153434753,
0.06305136531591415,
-0.30724450945854187,
-0.4400637745857239,
-0.3287193179130554,
-0.9903630018234253,
0.3849324882030487,
-0.15643319487571716,
-0.5731923580169678,
0.14925424754619598,
0.44553884863853455,
-0.2319892942905426,
-0.16977408528327942,
-0.5112531185150146,
0.7866082191467285,
-0.1935219168663025,
-0.7960642576217651,
-0.2467067688703537,
-0.5961897969245911,
0.0029072770848870277,
-0.1181885302066803,
0.06892120093107224,
0.19777745008468628,
0.10695259273052216,
0.37754449248313904,
-0.3653501272201538,
0.9277938008308411,
0.009195092134177685,
-0.07621446996927261,
0.08310605585575104,
0.15669363737106323,
0.6750973463058472,
-0.11699551343917847,
-0.086979441344738,
-0.07193277776241302,
-0.24522709846496582,
-0.5966101288795471,
-0.7479997277259827,
0.6852317452430725,
-0.6606398820877075,
-0.7908679842948914,
-0.6940658092498779,
-0.4175467789173126,
-0.5208242535591125,
0.01349705271422863,
0.22936131060123444,
0.5956314206123352,
-0.2442212849855423,
0.4316989779472351,
0.43467894196510315,
-0.3204675316810608,
0.5746850967407227,
0.6854947805404663,
0.1583547741174698,
-0.3163623809814453,
1.1317026615142822,
-0.16664600372314453,
0.19916799664497375,
0.6921618580818176,
0.2145232856273651,
-0.27578720450401306,
-0.6352962255477905,
-0.5341119170188904,
-0.17854830622673035,
-1.0657647848129272,
-0.28326740860939026,
-0.5357387661933899,
-0.045980896800756454,
-0.414826363325119,
-0.6885254979133606,
-0.17580775916576385,
0.058678288012742996,
-0.46630170941352844,
0.0521305575966835,
-0.06915342062711716,
0.7909777164459229,
0.06159048154950142,
0.11534060537815094,
-0.5496930480003357,
-0.10865841805934906,
0.6881831884384155,
0.09566061198711395,
0.41662800312042236,
-0.3660043776035309,
-0.40568357706069946,
0.08187436312437057,
-0.6832340955734253,
-0.9030545949935913,
0.21656541526317596,
0.34628069400787354,
0.6979230642318726,
0.16919654607772827,
0.16963888704776764,
0.8091075420379639,
-0.2861405611038208,
0.6882590651512146,
0.04063788428902626,
-1.1982920169830322,
0.6306240558624268,
-0.4442049562931061,
0.3445056676864624,
0.40665802359580994,
0.5509034991264343,
-0.20717035233974457,
-0.6678072214126587,
-0.22122523188591003,
-0.7670336961746216,
0.6428589224815369,
-0.022829582914710045,
0.12027507275342941,
-0.12476781755685806,
0.10100774466991425,
0.13099099695682526,
0.1591186821460724,
-0.7857498526573181,
0.0823645368218422,
-0.34962281584739685,
-0.42391857504844666,
0.059193000197410583,
0.0016998881474137306,
0.10285104066133499,
-0.19551785290241241,
1.0176292657852173,
-0.6872836947441101,
-0.01920759677886963,
0.1067996397614479,
-0.6818184852600098,
-0.06032101809978485,
0.1726246327161789,
0.5566228032112122,
1.301405668258667,
-0.16730694472789764,
0.06144360080361366,
0.278612345457077,
-0.16997872292995453,
0.1681860238313675,
0.19301076233386993,
-0.14732994139194489,
-0.40162181854248047,
0.6418968439102173,
0.3572539985179901,
0.5106111168861389,
-0.8317080736160278,
0.5690203905105591,
-0.12478012591600418,
0.17230013012886047,
-0.3777477741241455,
0.38384899497032166,
-0.249415785074234,
0.4128414988517761,
0.7711383700370789,
-0.1575382500886917,
0.31840547919273376,
-0.6571047306060791,
0.25486668944358826,
0.42589041590690613,
-0.43363142013549805,
-0.3373321294784546,
0.8568866848945618,
0.40174293518066406,
-0.3479384481906891,
0.49332788586616516,
-0.458371639251709,
-0.4030030369758606,
0.8758426904678345,
0.7743879556655884,
0.7890514135360718,
-0.26013827323913574,
0.3422810435295105,
0.18591569364070892,
0.024974975734949112,
-0.24795213341712952,
-0.10952715575695038,
-0.060342151671648026,
-0.4808637201786041,
-0.013614403083920479,
-0.6830888986587524,
-0.7587986588478088,
-0.1680799424648285,
-0.5910142064094543,
0.032145991921424866,
-0.5939404368400574,
-0.012535423040390015,
-0.035760924220085144,
-0.12290140241384506,
-0.5222480893135071,
0.3503386974334717,
-0.4516303539276123,
0.6655054688453674,
-0.44721561670303345,
0.728676438331604,
0.8284959197044373,
-0.5910782814025879,
-0.7084400653839111,
0.484065979719162,
0.08333293348550797,
-0.38365405797958374,
0.3385668396949768,
0.290498822927475,
-0.42851513624191284,
0.4321545660495758,
-0.4512024223804474,
-0.7259995937347412,
1.0364097356796265,
0.35830000042915344,
-0.38555407524108887,
0.013961929827928543,
-0.5869472622871399,
0.5335962772369385,
-0.21860256791114807,
0.24090972542762756,
-0.16458985209465027,
0.24694213271141052,
-0.14621774852275848,
-0.7327683568000793,
0.03339532017707825,
-0.16291821002960205,
0.012282460927963257,
-0.029832374304533005,
-0.8037375211715698,
1.085819959640503,
-0.12746986746788025,
-0.2673953175544739,
0.08595655858516693,
0.6445353627204895,
0.05408142879605293,
0.29967793822288513,
0.4014306962490082,
0.1252235323190689,
0.7349122762680054,
0.15467453002929688,
1.1426576375961304,
-0.19577758014202118,
0.5462455749511719,
0.9212671518325806,
-0.15477806329727173,
0.7595411539077759,
0.04364006593823433,
-0.15897947549819946,
0.8580966591835022,
0.5612781047821045,
-0.11814321577548981,
0.539711594581604,
0.1283617615699768,
-0.10075943171977997,
-0.35851114988327026,
-0.0018322145333513618,
-0.20232506096363068,
0.6733499765396118,
0.039268650114536285,
-0.08829417079687119,
-0.20131883025169373,
0.15729035437107086,
-0.2089802324771881,
0.46491357684135437,
-0.2791597247123718,
0.7625234723091125,
-0.21026481688022614,
-0.7731033563613892,
0.7791043519973755,
0.285844087600708,
0.6036806106567383,
-0.755700945854187,
-0.36133864521980286,
-0.32849541306495667,
0.2683972418308258,
-0.037153709679841995,
-0.12752015888690948,
-0.06043686717748642,
0.04241720959544182,
-0.260652095079422,
-0.29382869601249695,
0.3759450614452362,
-0.3260873556137085,
-0.46044278144836426,
0.3526213765144348,
0.3830357491970062,
-0.04368530586361885,
0.04759492352604866,
-0.4773934483528137,
0.08975245803594589,
-0.08973944932222366,
-0.2725311815738678,
0.37811601161956787,
0.0917113721370697,
-0.2214220017194748,
0.9835078716278076,
0.7435957193374634,
-0.21227505803108215,
-0.0018422245047986507,
-0.17774778604507446,
0.6391483545303345,
-0.6740494966506958,
-0.7883015871047974,
-0.683147132396698,
0.31616756319999695,
-0.17231887578964233,
-0.2368585169315338,
0.8158411383628845,
0.45298290252685547,
1.2555292844772339,
-0.05476091057062149,
0.8849884271621704,
-0.03234688192605972,
0.07774071395397186,
-0.597821831703186,
0.6030701994895935,
-0.8514941334724426,
0.02332986332476139,
-0.06093950942158699,
-0.9015005230903625,
-0.12595900893211365,
0.7966106534004211,
0.015303941443562508,
0.19846518337726593,
0.7589514255523682,
0.6133439540863037,
-0.17844143509864807,
-0.20593418180942535,
0.4302997887134552,
0.23210538923740387,
0.5063291192054749,
0.7991105914115906,
0.9441584944725037,
-0.24455270171165466,
0.7079219818115234,
-0.1846446841955185,
-0.3296372890472412,
-0.3486279845237732,
-0.8142207860946655,
-1.0023314952850342,
-0.5894097685813904,
-0.18468700349330902,
-0.2703950107097626,
0.4605916738510132,
1.1016229391098022,
0.9269016981124878,
-0.8931335210800171,
-0.19186528027057648,
-0.0322798416018486,
0.3950459361076355,
-0.7457356452941895,
-0.2241145521402359,
0.3447728753089905,
-0.5818641781806946,
-1.0301756858825684,
0.8130196332931519,
0.20029443502426147,
-0.0029141930863261223,
-0.1933448165655136,
-0.1593259871006012,
-0.14830607175827026,
0.11556579917669296,
0.4944007098674774,
0.3070976734161377,
-0.7098588347434998,
-0.6495369076728821,
-0.15288548171520233,
-0.2971782088279724,
0.01388482004404068,
0.5319685339927673,
-0.7912424802780151,
0.4336087703704834,
0.2464117407798767,
0.8811436891555786,
0.2023897022008896,
0.3165842294692993,
0.5333393216133118,
-0.9067833423614502,
0.028703078627586365,
0.1364942193031311,
0.0653882622718811,
0.42349469661712646,
-0.3779022693634033,
0.42023786902427673,
0.3303152918815613,
-0.26402223110198975,
-0.7129397392272949,
0.27449890971183777,
-0.8989145755767822,
-0.8519238233566284,
0.9267270565032959,
-0.24512022733688354,
-0.1608726978302002,
-0.20739991962909698,
0.24546515941619873,
0.19156569242477417,
-0.4854542315006256,
1.2515209913253784,
0.559039294719696,
-0.07422460615634918,
0.1492193639278412,
-0.27147507667541504,
0.38441410660743713,
0.04218036308884621,
-0.9993690252304077,
-0.19496482610702515,
0.759171724319458,
0.5100281238555908,
0.1664121448993683,
0.42772382497787476,
0.6464821696281433,
0.49639376997947693,
0.1918710619211197,
-0.11053583025932312,
-0.348832368850708,
-0.8305774927139282,
-0.2577432096004486,
0.6413722634315491,
0.07265345007181168,
-0.17891885340213776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05893v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05893v2
|
Use of a Structured Knowledge Base Enhances Metadata Curation by Large Language Models
| 2024-04-08T22:29:53 | 2024-04-17T04:17:12 |
Sowmya S. Sundaram, Benjamin Solomon, Avani Khatri, Anisha Laumas, Purvesh Khatri, Mark A. Musen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Metadata play a crucial role in ensuring the findability, accessibility,
interoperability, and reusability of datasets. This paper investigates the
potential of large language models (LLMs), specifically GPT-4, to improve
adherence to metadata standards. We conducted experiments on 200 random data
records describing human samples relating to lung cancer from the NCBI
BioSample repository, evaluating GPT-4's ability to suggest edits for adherence
to metadata standards. We computed the adherence accuracy of field name-field
value pairs through a peer review process, and we observed a marginal average
improvement in adherence to the standard data dictionary from 79% to 80%
(p<0.01). We then prompted GPT-4 with domain information in the form of the
textual descriptions of CEDAR templates and recorded a significant improvement
to 97% from 79% (p<0.01). These results indicate that, while LLMs may not be
able to correct legacy metadata to ensure satisfactory adherence to standards
when unaided, they do show promise for use in automated metadata curation when
integrated with a structured knowledge base.
|
[
-0.18147195875644684,
-0.47385725378990173,
1.1364970207214355,
-0.040139999240636826,
-0.12234612554311752,
-0.08240905404090881,
-0.22541838884353638,
-0.3309805393218994,
-0.13446581363677979,
0.7733480930328369,
-0.13639339804649353,
-1.0947892665863037,
-0.615273654460907,
0.27098724246025085,
-0.43630778789520264,
1.1706092357635498,
-0.349892795085907,
-0.4424799382686615,
-0.23599793016910553,
-0.06756255775690079,
-0.4803069233894348,
-0.6031162142753601,
-0.27165764570236206,
-0.46239230036735535,
0.7465622425079346,
0.1910770833492279,
0.9942901730537415,
0.9584544897079468,
0.6947669386863708,
0.21982760727405548,
-0.19001825153827667,
0.18095234036445618,
-0.19734802842140198,
0.19800962507724762,
-0.4588429629802704,
-0.3032749891281128,
-0.8440654277801514,
0.10951905697584152,
0.865684449672699,
0.9227587580680847,
-0.26195114850997925,
-0.040985286235809326,
0.07514438778162003,
0.6819882392883301,
-0.37511345744132996,
0.18372085690498352,
-0.6270314455032349,
-0.015544299967586994,
-0.40696799755096436,
-0.5160690546035767,
-0.1783909648656845,
-0.22276447713375092,
0.09718862920999527,
-0.8437511324882507,
0.15596146881580353,
-0.1244582086801529,
0.9191796183586121,
0.19850918650627136,
-0.5364760160446167,
-0.36442720890045166,
-0.7175356149673462,
0.27664366364479065,
-0.76938796043396,
0.6045048236846924,
0.6346880793571472,
-0.004361436236649752,
-0.6119274497032166,
-0.9469308257102966,
-0.3538706302642822,
-0.10690955817699432,
-0.17628797888755798,
-0.04315963014960289,
0.16100533306598663,
0.23197077214717865,
0.4613918364048004,
0.37326154112815857,
-0.32930153608322144,
-0.03111325576901436,
-0.4442295432090759,
-0.45668965578079224,
0.2112942337989807,
0.25105568766593933,
0.17860355973243713,
-0.15005040168762207,
-0.06734006106853485,
0.37182989716529846,
-1.0342704057693481,
-0.14713054895401,
0.2559039294719696,
0.1282655894756317,
0.30107611417770386,
0.573669970035553,
-0.03932308405637741,
0.952339768409729,
0.03650379925966263,
-0.36821818351745605,
0.21098893880844116,
-0.5580000877380371,
-0.35169529914855957,
-0.14246870577335358,
0.47492629289627075,
0.3605860769748688,
0.07561670243740082,
-0.28088974952697754,
-0.056307654827833176,
-0.22658772766590118,
0.40842846035957336,
-0.8296236991882324,
-0.5521551370620728,
0.2580548822879791,
-0.473054975271225,
-0.18750688433647156,
-0.05228618159890175,
-0.1806805431842804,
-0.306784451007843,
-0.49986088275909424,
0.5905913710594177,
-0.4303312599658966,
-0.051902543753385544,
0.23116277158260345,
-0.1360105723142624,
-0.1472444236278534,
0.546233594417572,
-0.8648019433021545,
0.39074957370758057,
0.7407786846160889,
1.1898797750473022,
0.02326873317360878,
-0.04777376726269722,
-0.34326788783073425,
0.7718650102615356,
-0.5077165365219116,
0.6554243564605713,
-0.603147566318512,
-0.335003525018692,
-0.29167789220809937,
0.2562675178050995,
0.07364866882562637,
-0.5426077842712402,
0.7457455992698669,
-0.5913745164871216,
0.13810282945632935,
-0.34395208954811096,
-0.6916696429252625,
-0.16254699230194092,
0.5228890180587769,
-0.7543412446975708,
0.9317682385444641,
0.4168423116207123,
-0.718955934047699,
0.6252691745758057,
-0.42948514223098755,
-0.19867780804634094,
0.11160748451948166,
0.053463567048311234,
-0.4447077512741089,
0.028179310262203217,
0.1296565681695938,
0.4891430139541626,
0.05147559940814972,
0.5999473333358765,
-0.2738038897514343,
-0.4683547914028168,
-0.05836673080921173,
0.04719562083482742,
0.3533162772655487,
0.20426727831363678,
-0.10464098304510117,
-0.026928652077913284,
-0.49313274025917053,
-0.01409111637622118,
-0.29207050800323486,
-0.7715821266174316,
-0.6232485771179199,
0.012964600697159767,
-0.2365637868642807,
0.3980598747730255,
-0.047445233911275864,
-0.4880400002002716,
0.5928294062614441,
-0.3102330267429352,
0.2583792507648468,
0.6756220459938049,
0.20420686900615692,
0.24023598432540894,
-0.49032101035118103,
0.2924495041370392,
0.2538597285747528,
-0.022215284407138824,
-0.15681293606758118,
-0.5613735318183899,
-0.25729551911354065,
-0.31219103932380676,
0.6512669324874878,
0.17733067274093628,
-0.48926353454589844,
0.4832784831523895,
-0.5408352017402649,
-0.5117913484573364,
-0.33894291520118713,
0.4995129406452179,
0.08143539726734161,
0.8454490900039673,
0.3128465712070465,
-0.5765841603279114,
-0.7364811301231384,
-0.8199185729026794,
-0.043145645409822464,
-0.15499469637870789,
-0.3106217384338379,
0.4428182542324066,
0.4485286772251129,
-0.4268200397491455,
1.103390097618103,
-0.26258355379104614,
-0.5802304744720459,
0.21089406311511993,
-0.10618754476308823,
0.4952390789985657,
0.2030659317970276,
0.35945186018943787,
-0.5980582237243652,
-0.49262821674346924,
0.019139625132083893,
-0.7423863410949707,
-0.3761006295681,
0.21330787241458893,
-0.15656925737857819,
0.15044981241226196,
0.31339728832244873,
-0.4889009892940521,
0.14379490911960602,
0.7356679439544678,
-0.26667559146881104,
0.3202893137931824,
-0.3243104815483093,
0.20610803365707397,
-1.1065844297409058,
0.36451464891433716,
0.0679718628525734,
-0.4589748978614807,
-0.8770816922187805,
-0.3290708661079407,
0.22873352468013763,
0.20938076078891754,
-0.2672070860862732,
0.28428003191947937,
-0.41175949573516846,
-0.08507414162158966,
-0.16080911457538605,
0.21034790575504303,
0.32522571086883545,
-0.04386023432016373,
0.3560810685157776,
0.704748809337616,
0.2662965655326843,
-0.6549920439720154,
-0.04021196812391281,
0.4318043887615204,
-0.36776357889175415,
0.49583694338798523,
-0.6338247060775757,
0.033831097185611725,
-0.06433995813131332,
0.6540273427963257,
-0.7008577585220337,
-0.3090916872024536,
0.07903404533863068,
-0.10220632702112198,
0.3469761610031128,
-0.41164159774780273,
-0.6339463591575623,
-0.25176212191581726,
-0.22735998034477234,
0.055883005261421204,
0.29863813519477844,
-0.17082512378692627,
0.549220085144043,
0.37814074754714966,
-0.07255334407091141,
-0.3829535245895386,
-0.7204108834266663,
0.4777696132659912,
-0.14910335838794708,
-0.8641576170921326,
0.5911256074905396,
-0.016896994784474373,
-0.12718172371387482,
0.15165019035339355,
-0.11255454272031784,
0.08537112176418304,
0.10522762686014175,
0.15255601704120636,
0.21020349860191345,
-0.17678695917129517,
0.47666338086128235,
-0.4211258888244629,
0.17840616405010223,
0.0634540319442749,
-0.5901175737380981,
0.38871869444847107,
-0.19187015295028687,
-0.23708698153495789,
-0.3540324568748474,
-0.008038436993956566,
0.5277338624000549,
0.05767576023936272,
0.8203757405281067,
0.4300781190395355,
-0.2809631824493408,
0.20531907677650452,
-0.611681342124939,
-0.1480940878391266,
-0.4516621530056,
0.20990139245986938,
-0.42251741886138916,
-1.0868381261825562,
0.4545794725418091,
-0.18031913042068481,
-0.017214646562933922,
0.48759767413139343,
0.6982481479644775,
-0.2930956482887268,
0.7133011817932129,
0.5446829199790955,
0.024735912680625916,
0.12451513111591339,
0.16767720878124237,
0.24018709361553192,
-1.2250192165374756,
-0.11504543572664261,
-0.5019094944000244,
-0.3381524980068207,
-0.6303912401199341,
-0.45855388045310974,
0.5682116150856018,
-0.15952859818935394,
-0.2978868782520294,
0.15618838369846344,
-0.560620129108429,
0.23127226531505585,
0.26146841049194336,
0.32899051904678345,
0.5831868052482605,
-0.11009804904460907,
0.06411367654800415,
-0.05517556145787239,
-0.6056050658226013,
-0.6727491021156311,
1.24079430103302,
0.5856199860572815,
0.6716910600662231,
0.22550548613071442,
0.6761681437492371,
0.13373765349388123,
0.583418071269989,
-0.5376359820365906,
0.15792371332645416,
-0.17081910371780396,
-0.7302702069282532,
-0.2717263400554657,
-0.4438488483428955,
-0.7541271448135376,
-0.03297144174575806,
0.029348094016313553,
-0.497400164604187,
0.21372273564338684,
0.2640400230884552,
-0.21444571018218994,
0.31999778747558594,
-0.34447526931762695,
0.6328698992729187,
-0.12457021325826645,
-0.30014467239379883,
0.4186708629131317,
-0.5721243023872375,
0.41285237669944763,
-0.5278288125991821,
0.3604188561439514,
-0.17417632043361664,
-0.3152235150337219,
0.8015861511230469,
-0.5861857533454895,
0.8053524494171143,
-0.21386314928531647,
-0.31390976905822754,
0.09558046609163284,
0.16918766498565674,
0.7669108510017395,
-0.09418376535177231,
-0.2075759917497635,
0.14871616661548615,
0.22733880579471588,
-0.09601261466741562,
-0.5457437038421631,
0.578890860080719,
-0.6827873587608337,
-0.8853943347930908,
-0.23580974340438843,
-0.6643675565719604,
-0.4378710985183716,
0.33223965764045715,
0.03154728561639786,
0.15651367604732513,
0.0949287861585617,
0.6710324287414551,
1.031772255897522,
-0.028442369773983955,
-0.16083836555480957,
0.6601184606552124,
-0.2307206392288208,
-0.15629985928535461,
0.4018898904323578,
0.3151288628578186,
0.38668403029441833,
0.250935822725296,
0.43923190236091614,
-0.024801069870591164,
-0.9163933992385864,
-0.14964735507965088,
0.21877922117710114,
-0.6390407681465149,
-0.40194395184516907,
-1.0780850648880005,
-0.29228508472442627,
-0.3900822401046753,
-0.11222279816865921,
0.055162105709314346,
-0.37646934390068054,
-0.026833903044462204,
-0.19858060777187347,
0.594603419303894,
0.7625085711479187,
0.12072474509477615,
0.2683577239513397,
-0.938229501247406,
0.11894292384386063,
-0.011984271928668022,
0.5723181366920471,
-0.3669547140598297,
-0.9917880296707153,
-0.2103058397769928,
-0.09519146382808685,
-0.10027827322483063,
-0.833261251449585,
0.2093431055545807,
0.5664897561073303,
0.5474370718002319,
0.09462112188339233,
-0.3012206554412842,
0.5533384084701538,
-0.48485806584358215,
0.5776811242103577,
-0.2564579248428345,
-0.8930355906486511,
0.5415263175964355,
-1.0463846921920776,
0.5300745368003845,
0.5465380549430847,
0.41061636805534363,
-0.9477206468582153,
-0.6137841939926147,
-0.3823283910751343,
-0.7473735213279724,
0.6538338661193848,
0.07900262624025345,
0.06693948805332184,
0.22338441014289856,
0.5032404065132141,
-0.09901230037212372,
0.27263936400413513,
-0.7085963487625122,
0.020395200699567795,
-0.2636552155017853,
-0.29943057894706726,
0.22505401074886322,
-0.44622859358787537,
-0.24813777208328247,
-0.17443446815013885,
0.8282943964004517,
-0.08098430931568146,
-0.13471642136573792,
0.18290509283542633,
0.07634414732456207,
-0.2651626467704773,
0.4029957056045532,
0.41120272874832153,
0.6442815661430359,
-0.4402041733264923,
0.23517842590808868,
0.1793321818113327,
-0.8640269041061401,
0.13110442459583282,
-0.19516320526599884,
-0.39817649126052856,
-0.08236349374055862,
0.2641232907772064,
0.3165449798107147,
0.31354695558547974,
-0.18178826570510864,
0.43302181363105774,
0.05137615278363228,
-0.5723692178726196,
-0.01846715435385704,
0.01746947690844536,
0.44050687551498413,
-0.1851852387189865,
0.0976092591881752,
-0.04171770066022873,
0.210178405046463,
-0.6607982516288757,
0.4203677475452423,
0.2623758018016815,
-0.2490502893924713,
-0.11037179082632065,
0.4979085624217987,
0.019880134612321854,
0.17060448229312897,
0.7199536561965942,
0.3219086527824402,
-0.4630051553249359,
0.33173173666000366,
0.5765690207481384,
0.24686869978904724,
-0.3530214726924896,
0.06669927388429642,
0.2510323226451874,
0.5819823741912842,
-0.33228498697280884,
0.05152752622961998,
0.17207348346710205,
-0.7593303918838501,
-0.45018377900123596,
-0.8133218288421631,
-0.3878479301929474,
0.11617598682641983,
-0.23581334948539734,
0.3209417760372162,
-0.5776199102401733,
-0.29377925395965576,
0.03579753637313843,
0.19022774696350098,
-0.7402722835540771,
0.18926258385181427,
0.002590706804767251,
1.114115595817566,
-0.8682774901390076,
1.1075679063796997,
0.5474569797515869,
-0.41588565707206726,
-1.2779511213302612,
-0.28128913044929504,
0.35195502638816833,
-0.24830114841461182,
0.6499998569488525,
0.07781805098056793,
0.19797314703464508,
-0.016123559325933456,
-0.2827632427215576,
-1.2986027002334595,
1.3632844686508179,
0.1850212961435318,
-0.6066504716873169,
-0.10253844410181046,
-0.021051861345767975,
0.8520975708961487,
-0.29434964060783386,
0.029417041689157486,
0.8788800835609436,
1.0538933277130127,
0.2123572826385498,
-1.0452443361282349,
0.20161880552768707,
-0.17463330924510956,
-0.09071332961320877,
0.5372968912124634,
-0.2960059642791748,
0.6848448514938354,
0.1091025248169899,
0.06388124823570251,
-0.12637856602668762,
0.2802201807498932,
0.33954140543937683,
0.1811523288488388,
0.20642659068107605,
0.6558628678321838,
0.9043431878089905,
-0.278341680765152,
0.8511577844619751,
-0.18250013887882233,
0.04246523976325989,
1.0391395092010498,
-0.6050341725349426,
0.5411410927772522,
0.39336615800857544,
-0.15297165513038635,
0.7059853076934814,
0.6363806128501892,
-0.38712993264198303,
0.33754122257232666,
-0.024803008884191513,
-0.24761678278446198,
-0.1789754182100296,
-0.18453405797481537,
-0.39069312810897827,
0.418070912361145,
0.7014020681381226,
-0.7623357176780701,
-0.1578749418258667,
-0.34534722566604614,
0.4358043968677521,
-0.013696598820388317,
-0.36363622546195984,
0.8709908127784729,
-0.05911584943532944,
-0.7151021361351013,
0.3251310884952545,
-0.01441860105842352,
0.40958335995674133,
-0.6872389316558838,
-0.021687019616365433,
-0.027121534571051598,
0.09423800557851791,
-0.7781490683555603,
-1.0414990186691284,
0.4974370002746582,
-0.09107857942581177,
-0.3332984149456024,
-0.19548405706882477,
0.8707354068756104,
-0.5317286849021912,
-0.42479851841926575,
0.04613012820482254,
0.4373624622821808,
0.25041842460632324,
-0.05357556417584419,
-0.27580052614212036,
0.08298519998788834,
-0.12077980488538742,
-0.2910803556442261,
0.46033725142478943,
0.428966224193573,
-0.3870059847831726,
0.4391697347164154,
0.8305256962776184,
0.41524985432624817,
-0.3065679669380188,
0.03251005336642265,
1.0915406942367554,
-0.48320531845092773,
-0.05530434474349022,
-0.8191415667533875,
0.2642832398414612,
0.10186542570590973,
0.06975289434194565,
0.8770124316215515,
0.5117778778076172,
0.6903952956199646,
0.17663639783859253,
0.9140946865081787,
-0.09389881044626236,
0.5113480687141418,
-0.6387329697608948,
0.7129045724868774,
-0.30657777190208435,
0.5300263166427612,
-0.29458165168762207,
-0.9665066003799438,
-0.7944718599319458,
0.16536150872707367,
-0.5072758197784424,
0.3365275263786316,
0.7480912804603577,
0.8203340768814087,
-0.04066334292292595,
-0.3069629371166229,
0.462510347366333,
0.3867058753967285,
0.6578171253204346,
0.4697021245956421,
0.3012199103832245,
-0.14850105345249176,
0.4318821430206299,
-0.17206719517707825,
-0.20225182175636292,
-0.12322836369276047,
-1.221701741218567,
-0.7995873093605042,
-0.43734824657440186,
-0.01966777816414833,
-0.3876817524433136,
0.41216763854026794,
0.848993182182312,
0.6027778387069702,
-0.7255045771598816,
0.17256872355937958,
0.19929799437522888,
-0.07062342017889023,
0.06166325509548187,
-0.11836732923984528,
0.5163601636886597,
-0.16845886409282684,
-0.36494123935699463,
0.23967435956001282,
0.5795627236366272,
-0.12856554985046387,
-0.08812864124774933,
0.03949742764234543,
-0.2818279564380646,
-0.056437332183122635,
0.4505493938922882,
0.00042797892820090055,
-0.646610677242279,
-0.47788989543914795,
0.030989650636911392,
-0.30358126759529114,
0.17214299738407135,
0.8802535533905029,
-0.9077233672142029,
0.5609886050224304,
0.30913832783699036,
0.39422911405563354,
0.258113294839859,
0.43619662523269653,
0.6917778253555298,
-0.7077364325523376,
-0.24390646815299988,
0.20124679803848267,
0.44735947251319885,
0.6082826256752014,
-0.6971701979637146,
0.6450324654579163,
0.1470586359500885,
-0.9599329233169556,
-0.44005057215690613,
-0.0693417564034462,
-0.7421302199363708,
0.056859567761421204,
1.2154220342636108,
-0.163114532828331,
-0.2506459355354309,
-0.6744533777236938,
-0.19408468902111053,
0.011128008365631104,
-0.25485357642173767,
0.7606845498085022,
1.0224277973175049,
0.029327407479286194,
-0.21260395646095276,
-0.618717610836029,
0.710381031036377,
-0.003435480874031782,
-0.8180731534957886,
0.20338645577430725,
0.7236028909683228,
0.6213434934616089,
-0.038212090730667114,
0.9447925090789795,
-0.48183247447013855,
0.38665837049484253,
-0.5696853995323181,
-0.05029955878853798,
-0.32709985971450806,
-0.16108717024326324,
-0.1978512853384018,
0.07874471694231033,
0.4129054546356201,
0.6883795261383057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05892v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05892v2
|
Eagle and Finch: RWKV with Matrix-Valued States and Dynamic Recurrence
| 2024-04-08T22:20:59 | 2024-04-10T19:34:38 |
Bo Peng, Daniel Goldstein, Quentin Anthony, Alon Albalak, Eric Alcaide, Stella Biderman, Eugene Cheah, Xingjian Du, Teddy Ferdinan, Haowen Hou, Przemysław Kazienko, Kranthi Kiran GV, Jan Kocoń, Bartłomiej Koptyra, Satyapriya Krishna, Ronald McClelland Jr., Niklas Muennighoff, Fares Obeid, Atsushi Saito, Guangyu Song, Haoqin Tu, Stanisław Woźniak, Ruichong Zhang, Bingchen Zhao, Qihang Zhao, Peng Zhou, Jian Zhu, Rui-Jie Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present Eagle (RWKV-5) and Finch (RWKV-6), sequence models improving upon
the RWKV (RWKV-4) architecture. Our architectural design advancements include
multi-headed matrix-valued states and a dynamic recurrence mechanism that
improve expressivity while maintaining the inference efficiency characteristics
of RNNs. We introduce a new multilingual corpus with 1.12 trillion tokens and a
fast tokenizer based on greedy matching for enhanced multilinguality. We
trained four Eagle models, ranging from 0.46 to 7.5 billion parameters, and two
Finch models with 1.6 and 3.1 billion parameters and find that they achieve
competitive performance across a wide variety of benchmarks. We release all our
models on HuggingFace under the Apache 2.0 license. Models at:
https://huggingface.co/RWKV Training code at: https://github.com/RWKV/RWKV-LM
Inference code at: https://github.com/RWKV/ChatRWKV Time-parallel training code
at: https://github.com/RWKV/RWKV-infctx-trainer
|
[
-0.23390035331249237,
-0.57862788438797,
0.13892562687397003,
0.6879856586456299,
-0.07525557279586792,
0.20925864577293396,
0.17315763235092163,
-1.0158857107162476,
0.1496967226266861,
0.3868612051010132,
-0.5944889783859253,
-0.19469475746154785,
-0.49477967619895935,
0.33424586057662964,
-0.6158507466316223,
0.5374420881271362,
0.2787151336669922,
0.093887560069561,
0.06778474897146225,
-0.3220742344856262,
-0.14185172319412231,
-0.2819240391254425,
-0.6176438927650452,
-0.5118491053581238,
0.7197160720825195,
0.2235991507768631,
0.6512354016304016,
1.1990824937820435,
0.5568960309028625,
0.33636391162872314,
-0.1336253434419632,
0.10901816934347153,
-0.2126808613538742,
0.47384771704673767,
0.09297289699316025,
-0.20043650269508362,
-0.4351035952568054,
-0.20284418761730194,
0.8578035235404968,
0.644130527973175,
-0.38207316398620605,
0.21600459516048431,
-0.4423612952232361,
0.806205689907074,
-0.5928322076797485,
0.41482651233673096,
-0.24610958993434906,
0.49141091108322144,
-0.1956191211938858,
-0.006824723444879055,
-0.5598572492599487,
-0.1387867033481598,
0.3006710708141327,
-0.8975667953491211,
0.08377983421087265,
0.21547019481658936,
0.7526835799217224,
0.18291328847408295,
-0.4648934304714203,
0.053115617483854294,
-0.5653094053268433,
1.0857532024383545,
-0.6494466662406921,
0.8607817888259888,
0.0751897394657135,
0.30587562918663025,
-0.3283984363079071,
-1.191855549812317,
-0.3678654730319977,
-0.2692219018936157,
0.3458397388458252,
0.18727748095989227,
-0.1421220302581787,
-0.045586466789245605,
0.08844082802534103,
0.5756388902664185,
-0.6347419619560242,
-0.05147567391395569,
-0.32494792342185974,
0.048947084695100784,
0.6568262577056885,
0.2847323715686798,
-0.0649433508515358,
-0.022064752876758575,
-0.3011557459831238,
-0.3582422435283661,
-0.4651710093021393,
0.3420211374759674,
0.37768450379371643,
0.5576314926147461,
-0.14496129751205444,
0.2874893844127655,
-0.28580528497695923,
0.8068730235099792,
0.2639941871166229,
-0.04342419281601906,
0.43185535073280334,
-0.14247241616249084,
-0.2321634143590927,
-0.09514310210943222,
0.7004528045654297,
-0.1632910519838333,
-0.11596117913722992,
-0.3130374252796173,
-0.050610266625881195,
-0.26180747151374817,
0.41675448417663574,
-0.7298448085784912,
-0.003878501243889332,
0.40240177512168884,
-0.9836855530738831,
-0.5391354560852051,
0.12254022061824799,
-0.6493934392929077,
-0.28430649638175964,
-0.140961691737175,
0.17201659083366394,
-0.3601979911327362,
-0.6566475033760071,
0.338504433631897,
-0.3502523899078369,
0.5263192653656006,
0.16888892650604248,
-0.9733203649520874,
0.31503885984420776,
1.0912543535232544,
0.6962410807609558,
0.011294662021100521,
-0.5043105483055115,
-0.573814332485199,
-0.19609902799129486,
-0.33292996883392334,
0.6545897722244263,
-0.7536717653274536,
-0.307539701461792,
0.08519574999809265,
0.009128724224865437,
0.27270835638046265,
-0.313577800989151,
0.3633771240711212,
-0.7117984294891357,
-0.053357742726802826,
-0.5229092836380005,
-0.2796821594238281,
-0.5392542481422424,
0.2728479206562042,
-0.9354871511459351,
1.142835021018982,
-0.16198499500751495,
-0.7184836268424988,
0.22453026473522186,
-0.629236102104187,
-0.5004985928535461,
-0.05700495466589928,
-0.09828964620828629,
-0.5511986613273621,
-0.1372520476579666,
0.14538875222206116,
0.4434363842010498,
-0.24986961483955383,
-0.24076810479164124,
-0.6687996983528137,
-0.5247060060501099,
0.11134123057126999,
-0.059340495616197586,
0.6670286655426025,
0.613823413848877,
-0.1435297280550003,
0.322613000869751,
-0.9277709722518921,
-0.012121951207518578,
0.14139440655708313,
-0.6739197969436646,
0.11594618111848831,
0.07832100987434387,
0.07074705511331558,
-0.04621581733226776,
0.041774094104766846,
-0.5295461416244507,
0.3770914375782013,
-0.533117413520813,
0.7790830731391907,
0.4471065402030945,
-0.00385775207541883,
0.31546899676322937,
-0.3294762969017029,
0.6935864686965942,
0.211090087890625,
0.39974141120910645,
-0.2653679847717285,
-0.659763753414154,
-0.7421355843544006,
-0.25656798481941223,
0.0711648017168045,
0.7361998558044434,
-0.6403043866157532,
-0.2148744910955429,
-0.1402938812971115,
-0.5137219429016113,
-0.1632539927959442,
-0.31515762209892273,
0.5189988017082214,
0.20329207181930542,
0.3717880845069885,
-0.2517646253108978,
-0.682155430316925,
-0.9749980568885803,
-0.4259861707687378,
-0.27332934737205505,
0.45261135697364807,
0.20465151965618134,
0.37908151745796204,
0.02637365832924843,
0.5863589644432068,
0.09740960597991943,
0.1659114509820938,
-0.2217773050069809,
0.41268840432167053,
0.3992382287979126,
0.2919516861438751,
0.44634777307510376,
-0.7425543069839478,
-0.16905531287193298,
-0.004926604218780994,
-0.7394804954528809,
0.28706300258636475,
0.0789792463183403,
0.17220547795295715,
0.182566836476326,
0.21287678182125092,
-0.5464146733283997,
0.1484854370355606,
0.44080859422683716,
-0.09072677791118622,
0.5781574249267578,
-0.09691651910543442,
0.36772218346595764,
-1.2311570644378662,
0.07229350507259369,
0.0019911157432943583,
-0.2952641546726227,
-0.5139131546020508,
0.4488518536090851,
0.027000807225704193,
-0.006893442943692207,
-0.8396304845809937,
0.37343430519104004,
-0.7253868579864502,
-0.49139559268951416,
-0.08771882206201553,
-0.4879069924354553,
-0.06652931869029999,
0.2525739371776581,
0.1372314691543579,
0.9911792278289795,
0.48249077796936035,
-0.532899022102356,
0.6758360266685486,
0.4469482898712158,
-0.27672815322875977,
0.048029880970716476,
-0.726868748664856,
0.03545268625020981,
-0.09273532032966614,
0.5834832191467285,
-0.44187062978744507,
-0.018599890172481537,
0.260978639125824,
-0.5804802179336548,
0.18424838781356812,
-0.25971415638923645,
-0.2185273915529251,
-0.44902846217155457,
-0.40959012508392334,
0.6483924984931946,
0.3517998456954956,
-0.5121318101882935,
0.7883316874504089,
0.23023459315299988,
0.08274216204881668,
-1.4287693500518799,
-1.1786514520645142,
0.11997626721858978,
-0.2752493619918823,
-0.6716696619987488,
0.2839764654636383,
0.2721973657608032,
-0.025797754526138306,
0.1428544521331787,
0.24216905236244202,
-0.23190359771251678,
-0.22185097634792328,
0.373923122882843,
-0.13712620735168457,
-0.5635403394699097,
0.11509932577610016,
-0.26187753677368164,
-0.1745869666337967,
0.010918513871729374,
-0.5920045971870422,
0.16702575981616974,
-0.5969700813293457,
-0.22103284299373627,
-0.5697669386863708,
0.6246740818023682,
0.6176183223724365,
-0.6121266484260559,
0.6719050407409668,
0.6152284741401672,
-0.3483685553073883,
-0.20456567406654358,
-0.5554121732711792,
-0.3108518719673157,
-0.42660391330718994,
0.4293045401573181,
-0.5773257613182068,
-1.091668725013733,
0.8054260611534119,
0.18155768513679504,
0.4132809340953827,
0.2150651514530182,
0.5314436554908752,
0.16188421845436096,
0.9269493818283081,
0.5505552291870117,
0.035989414900541306,
0.5681346654891968,
-0.438793420791626,
0.08346971124410629,
-0.7316493391990662,
-0.0828905999660492,
-0.3035737872123718,
-0.24517634510993958,
-0.5091317296028137,
-0.272371381521225,
0.1144273653626442,
-0.22852841019630432,
-0.6550053954124451,
0.32964569330215454,
-0.5425715446472168,
0.37683549523353577,
0.5284916162490845,
0.007656164467334747,
0.20563317835330963,
0.011431432329118252,
-0.2057640254497528,
0.1344902515411377,
-0.8865704536437988,
-0.13512611389160156,
1.2500736713409424,
0.6532494425773621,
0.7007606625556946,
0.39779654145240784,
0.525242805480957,
0.4100886285305023,
0.11651395261287689,
-0.6244986057281494,
0.404646635055542,
-0.17883537709712982,
-0.4682313799858093,
-0.10911977291107178,
-0.4537488520145416,
-1.0805414915084839,
0.3466068208217621,
-0.4445616602897644,
-0.37389492988586426,
0.3330232501029968,
0.47025296092033386,
-0.7584224939346313,
0.26778918504714966,
-0.2483643889427185,
0.8274953961372375,
0.10598980635404587,
-0.39959996938705444,
-0.3135807514190674,
-0.7411774396896362,
0.7990441918373108,
0.28017929196357727,
-0.10404207557439804,
0.09743230044841766,
-0.015139173716306686,
0.5118515491485596,
-0.5752918720245361,
0.5976001024246216,
-0.023068733513355255,
0.2533823251724243,
0.2002628743648529,
-0.1989712119102478,
0.6203003525733948,
0.16991469264030457,
-0.3586750328540802,
0.2824845612049103,
0.2709672451019287,
-0.39263907074928284,
-0.4034956097602844,
0.7440327405929565,
-0.9070731997489929,
-0.23950517177581787,
-0.9224154949188232,
-0.5525514483451843,
0.0024670909624546766,
0.24365316331386566,
-0.05441178381443024,
0.6806409955024719,
-0.04044632613658905,
0.5679992437362671,
0.7174509763717651,
-0.2643106281757355,
0.4519512951374054,
0.5809096693992615,
-0.47210660576820374,
-0.591916561126709,
0.5735695362091064,
-0.0940253809094429,
0.03988591581583023,
0.46995797753334045,
0.040718112140893936,
-0.5589479804039001,
-0.6454311609268188,
-0.4662393033504486,
0.3289198577404022,
-0.6246606707572937,
-0.10736317187547684,
-0.7772435545921326,
-0.22766980528831482,
-0.5694690346717834,
0.2199859768152237,
-0.7967631816864014,
-0.5604360699653625,
-0.18623457849025726,
0.11735296249389648,
0.7210627794265747,
0.8640433549880981,
-0.3201062083244324,
0.0649418905377388,
-0.8829552531242371,
0.0896870419383049,
0.2790732979774475,
0.162422314286232,
0.24342574179172516,
-0.4730783700942993,
-0.30708378553390503,
-0.12205903232097626,
-0.29692330956459045,
-0.5623792409896851,
0.30182549357414246,
0.30306756496429443,
0.3574367165565491,
0.3343452215194702,
0.049968935549259186,
0.7802098393440247,
-0.6423420906066895,
0.7949268221855164,
0.025578590109944344,
-0.657318651676178,
0.046000994741916656,
-0.47610557079315186,
0.21423932909965515,
0.13956253230571747,
-0.03128772974014282,
-0.6743265986442566,
-0.2741842567920685,
-0.3456157445907593,
-0.6886463165283203,
0.614108145236969,
-0.04416953772306442,
-0.12150169909000397,
-0.21437188982963562,
0.815707802772522,
-0.012453475035727024,
0.02718399465084076,
-0.4924890995025635,
-0.33016592264175415,
-0.7165472507476807,
-0.24265465140342712,
0.3060336709022522,
-0.21568137407302856,
0.11423563212156296,
-0.003393522696569562,
0.8505767583847046,
0.04517858847975731,
0.5215448141098022,
0.34182819724082947,
0.16232545673847198,
-0.1899607926607132,
-0.012147077359259129,
1.036532998085022,
0.7768405079841614,
-0.2840558588504791,
-0.16260629892349243,
0.1394599825143814,
-0.5558081269264221,
0.16451653838157654,
0.28682830929756165,
0.04589271545410156,
-0.3527680039405823,
0.46676355600357056,
0.8487280607223511,
0.51686692237854,
-0.33802342414855957,
0.38360053300857544,
-0.40811336040496826,
-0.3289448916912079,
-0.8122624754905701,
-0.0066782161593437195,
0.2988804578781128,
0.8032117486000061,
0.3784613609313965,
-0.23239615559577942,
0.12256582081317902,
-0.358462929725647,
0.3437926769256592,
0.48673486709594727,
0.009929867461323738,
-0.11231985688209534,
0.9370956420898438,
0.34149169921875,
-0.3665643036365509,
0.7347062826156616,
-0.10535268485546112,
-0.40442022681236267,
0.5591232180595398,
0.4941151738166809,
0.8031096458435059,
-0.08643491566181183,
-0.049861978739500046,
0.4412073493003845,
0.12449362128973007,
-0.3872062861919403,
0.5741809606552124,
-0.02713809907436371,
-0.6797120571136475,
-0.7125977873802185,
-0.6711578965187073,
-0.571785569190979,
0.35267403721809387,
-0.9165766835212708,
0.12379448860883713,
-0.5647136569023132,
-0.17512087523937225,
0.07813835889101028,
0.1561400145292282,
-0.3890884220600128,
-0.08139462023973465,
-0.04924072325229645,
1.369659423828125,
-0.5856565237045288,
0.9506077766418457,
0.8317118883132935,
-0.5092191696166992,
-0.8548986315727234,
-0.36169731616973877,
0.19296519458293915,
-0.807582437992096,
0.7436347603797913,
0.11125687509775162,
-0.19891415536403656,
0.3163768947124481,
-0.06337327510118484,
-0.9783750176429749,
1.3735969066619873,
0.08151981234550476,
-0.42899289727211,
0.1494990438222885,
0.17020435631275177,
0.1349482238292694,
-0.2913207709789276,
0.17891395092010498,
0.27625080943107605,
0.3843412697315216,
0.3210856318473816,
-0.7304936051368713,
-0.28821492195129395,
-0.29299041628837585,
0.2567221522331238,
0.31528207659721375,
-0.8675569891929626,
0.9897515773773193,
-0.06914021074771881,
-0.06648699939250946,
0.3744674324989319,
1.3067939281463623,
0.4562971293926239,
-0.02272627502679825,
0.4525213837623596,
0.8970581293106079,
0.44517743587493896,
-0.08207811415195465,
0.9135181307792664,
-0.5089049935340881,
0.33949872851371765,
0.8361539244651794,
-0.15592150390148163,
1.0884820222854614,
0.4563787877559662,
-0.15914572775363922,
0.3927939534187317,
0.9248666167259216,
0.005847360473126173,
0.27516666054725647,
0.02001626044511795,
-0.38937485218048096,
-0.3944918215274811,
0.3013899028301239,
-0.7208799719810486,
0.3653147518634796,
0.10285995155572891,
-0.26779600977897644,
-0.10931357741355896,
-0.04145219549536705,
-0.08847042173147202,
-0.1329795867204666,
-0.13109160959720612,
0.43829047679901123,
0.1799021065235138,
-0.6188045740127563,
0.5423020720481873,
0.1898425668478012,
0.581597089767456,
-0.7842562794685364,
-0.2458309680223465,
-0.31433504819869995,
0.5049996972084045,
-0.11290119588375092,
-0.5624865293502808,
0.4122225344181061,
-0.1305096596479416,
-0.5323032736778259,
-0.2605893909931183,
0.46806660294532776,
-0.35962367057800293,
-0.6323933601379395,
0.112975113093853,
0.014428474009037018,
0.2443942427635193,
0.22417618334293365,
-1.0627782344818115,
0.46603477001190186,
-0.4440620243549347,
-0.5135219097137451,
0.2528553903102875,
0.09012539684772491,
-0.027164308354258537,
1.0274180173873901,
0.8672391772270203,
0.10430654883384705,
0.420229971408844,
0.08494080603122711,
0.395050972700119,
-0.8495433330535889,
-0.7081503868103027,
-0.43838971853256226,
0.3313691318035126,
0.20297527313232422,
-0.3004172444343567,
0.4910105764865875,
0.5249132513999939,
0.5745378136634827,
-0.15664219856262207,
0.6096164584159851,
0.16061244904994965,
0.7123384475708008,
-0.23845355212688446,
0.772791862487793,
-0.719048023223877,
-0.0030033872462809086,
0.13955673575401306,
-0.7231695652008057,
-0.4285627007484436,
0.7157458066940308,
0.17299695312976837,
0.14312024414539337,
0.4935687184333801,
0.7451204657554626,
-0.1392662525177002,
0.2899579405784607,
0.00781785324215889,
0.24850521981716156,
0.5907078981399536,
0.7801554799079895,
0.8704072833061218,
-0.6248342990875244,
0.49537983536720276,
-0.2943769097328186,
-0.24013817310333252,
-0.2525596022605896,
-1.4321544170379639,
-0.5265640020370483,
-0.4763941168785095,
-0.2908205986022949,
-0.26568448543548584,
0.33270132541656494,
1.0946571826934814,
0.9493802785873413,
-0.6880671381950378,
-0.280537486076355,
-0.2693648934364319,
-0.2083710879087448,
-0.6308969259262085,
-0.18593013286590576,
0.2046242654323578,
-0.295340359210968,
-0.4941727817058563,
0.7657959461212158,
0.3683953583240509,
-0.14477628469467163,
-0.5785857439041138,
-0.38899660110473633,
-0.4038291275501251,
0.1887383908033371,
0.5607285499572754,
1.029302954673767,
-1.1550017595291138,
-0.43846210837364197,
-0.008744561113417149,
0.09527982771396637,
-0.09263172745704651,
0.577608585357666,
-0.7830360531806946,
0.33776628971099854,
0.5196588039398193,
0.9026652574539185,
0.4899933636188507,
0.07712921500205994,
0.6616540551185608,
-0.3825571537017822,
0.4631269872188568,
0.08966159075498581,
0.2732945382595062,
0.23154766857624054,
-0.1710713505744934,
0.2293711155653,
0.28882890939712524,
-0.7953938245773315,
-0.971477746963501,
0.35773950815200806,
-0.9553444385528564,
-0.013739082030951977,
0.8624545931816101,
-0.2773497402667999,
-0.3871907889842987,
0.018222857266664505,
0.4051258862018585,
0.4381294250488281,
-0.2563152015209198,
0.6623525023460388,
0.6836525201797485,
-0.4182332754135132,
-0.6701330542564392,
-0.7015092968940735,
0.4864669442176819,
0.3846730887889862,
-0.43111464381217957,
-0.09562542289495468,
0.1680016666650772,
0.40302079916000366,
-0.15044339001178741,
0.4031597673892975,
-0.1606045514345169,
0.6424615979194641,
-0.034398168325424194,
0.25103843212127686,
-0.7034646272659302,
-0.2961428761482239,
-0.40697747468948364,
0.07798507809638977,
0.1464870125055313,
-0.4528422951698303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05880v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05880v2
|
Eraser: Jailbreaking Defense in Large Language Models via Unlearning Harmful Knowledge
| 2024-04-08T21:26:22 | 2024-07-03T17:52:00 |
Weikai Lu, Ziqian Zeng, Jianwei Wang, Zhengdong Lu, Zelin Chen, Huiping Zhuang, Cen Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Jailbreaking attacks can enable Large Language Models (LLMs) to bypass the
safeguard and generate harmful content. Existing jailbreaking defense methods
have failed to address the fundamental issue that harmful knowledge resides
within the model, leading to potential jailbreak risks for LLMs. In this paper,
we propose a novel defense method called Eraser, which mainly includes three
goals: unlearning harmful knowledge, retaining general knowledge, and
maintaining safety alignment. The intuition is that if an LLM forgets the
specific knowledge required to answer a harmful question, it will no longer
have the ability to answer harmful questions. The training of Erase does not
actually require the model's own harmful knowledge, and it can benefit from
unlearning general answers related to harmful queries, which means it does not
need assistance from the red team. The experimental results show that Eraser
can significantly reduce the jailbreaking success rate for various attacks
without compromising the general capabilities of the model. Our codes are
available at https://github.com/ZeroNLP/Eraser.
|
[
-0.2513110041618347,
-1.0641175508499146,
0.38005661964416504,
-0.21015888452529907,
-0.16990558803081512,
0.21038295328617096,
-0.13081473112106323,
-0.5746572017669678,
0.03851163759827614,
0.7317430973052979,
-0.1999058574438095,
-0.4712097644805908,
-0.5479685664176941,
-0.3478594720363617,
-0.5070341229438782,
1.2195478677749634,
0.15845778584480286,
-0.06641251593828201,
-0.13816912472248077,
0.12501758337020874,
-0.7352808117866516,
-0.4787944555282593,
-0.7474731802940369,
-0.1804761439561844,
0.3651575744152069,
0.5760207772254944,
0.44982078671455383,
0.7662326693534851,
0.3766877353191376,
0.31207704544067383,
-0.4573739171028137,
-0.1059860959649086,
-0.7635967135429382,
0.4741777777671814,
-0.19821245968341827,
-0.526140034198761,
-0.32917746901512146,
-0.4898929297924042,
0.28192028403282166,
0.36009782552719116,
-0.22629527747631073,
-0.18998874723911285,
-0.032548386603593826,
0.8204056620597839,
-0.8814935088157654,
-0.21171776950359344,
-0.9635135531425476,
-0.018750514835119247,
-0.09097461402416229,
0.1689033955335617,
-0.4578520953655243,
-0.2497546225786209,
-0.13378040492534637,
-0.35647568106651306,
0.06715502589941025,
-0.049921318888664246,
0.641083836555481,
0.06272892653942108,
-0.3732870817184448,
-0.1279851198196411,
-0.8308606147766113,
0.6264799237251282,
-0.6996920704841614,
0.13175912201404572,
0.474579781293869,
0.27312174439430237,
-0.15255174040794373,
-0.24303795397281647,
-0.5131134390830994,
-0.15891188383102417,
0.19949786365032196,
0.09543490409851074,
-0.45718592405319214,
0.1857759952545166,
0.23347261548042297,
0.0667923241853714,
-0.4075939953327179,
0.2150823324918747,
-0.8513659238815308,
-0.26890829205513,
0.44461071491241455,
0.17800329625606537,
0.607593297958374,
-0.01281682588160038,
-0.5191208124160767,
0.30625125765800476,
-1.151499629020691,
-0.011257674545049667,
0.4536442160606384,
0.12859639525413513,
0.01838044449687004,
0.4868146777153015,
-0.14358943700790405,
0.5445098876953125,
-0.06029651314020157,
-0.10057607293128967,
-0.032145582139492035,
0.15022791922092438,
0.008396968245506287,
0.2576574385166168,
0.7676207423210144,
0.3994618356227875,
0.3537268042564392,
-0.43794262409210205,
-0.2639399468898773,
-0.16896091401576996,
0.4628601372241974,
-1.0121933221817017,
-0.2381914108991623,
0.289002001285553,
-0.27175936102867126,
-0.3552391529083252,
0.008729621767997742,
-0.72617506980896,
-0.768661379814148,
0.17407143115997314,
0.4834877550601959,
-0.7400357723236084,
-0.20057058334350586,
0.18994441628456116,
-0.09920383989810944,
0.30460554361343384,
0.25110167264938354,
-0.9754536747932434,
0.48654669523239136,
0.7639151215553284,
0.6457124948501587,
0.09770479053258896,
-0.0933801531791687,
-0.5658490657806396,
0.328345388174057,
-0.2581786513328552,
0.4715365469455719,
-0.26948678493499756,
-0.5206354856491089,
-0.2817820608615875,
-0.28728246688842773,
0.011211741715669632,
-0.5818516612052917,
0.31737929582595825,
-0.6848307847976685,
0.0018726742127910256,
-0.053358402103185654,
-0.7760965824127197,
-0.3670704662799835,
0.34967145323753357,
-0.6700854301452637,
0.48413392901420593,
-0.3856363296508789,
-0.7274159789085388,
0.07004445791244507,
-0.49911603331565857,
-0.6102672815322876,
0.13157054781913757,
0.16397856175899506,
-0.6622148752212524,
0.05830204486846924,
0.192457914352417,
0.35552069544792175,
-0.16209673881530762,
0.4226282238960266,
-0.38325318694114685,
-0.4768942594528198,
0.17453281581401825,
-0.1961180418729782,
0.9573929309844971,
0.4056786298751831,
-0.45574185252189636,
0.1030338779091835,
-0.6258246302604675,
-0.13906073570251465,
0.4418438971042633,
-0.24329350888729095,
-0.6470393538475037,
0.1890787035226822,
-0.4169655740261078,
0.09969489276409149,
0.1932046264410019,
-0.9893156886100769,
0.05864758417010307,
-0.5068527460098267,
0.4688068628311157,
0.9018826484680176,
0.2611444890499115,
0.39033043384552,
-0.3052856922149658,
0.485598087310791,
-0.09307137876749039,
0.21605753898620605,
-0.30191120505332947,
-0.3335897922515869,
-0.808843195438385,
-0.1479317545890808,
0.02527390792965889,
0.7854593992233276,
-0.4254094362258911,
0.31415337324142456,
0.028784649446606636,
-0.5040964484214783,
-0.3629778325557709,
0.4041474461555481,
0.8222305178642273,
0.5247821807861328,
0.4874562919139862,
-0.0897018313407898,
-0.7086612582206726,
-0.8051171898841858,
-0.47740399837493896,
-0.13802190124988556,
0.14254969358444214,
-0.06482747197151184,
0.6487945318222046,
-0.12074180692434311,
0.8331833481788635,
-0.7077917456626892,
-0.280148446559906,
-0.4764662981033325,
-0.2688400149345398,
-0.03881233185529709,
0.6801698207855225,
0.42718517780303955,
-0.599653959274292,
-0.29465508460998535,
-0.11067622154951096,
-0.7804803848266602,
-0.0694873109459877,
0.12056384980678558,
0.13705293834209442,
0.07999759167432785,
0.7112034559249878,
-0.5158578157424927,
0.34186843037605286,
0.11706581711769104,
-0.45625829696655273,
0.6444399952888489,
-0.19531267881393433,
-0.11484091728925705,
-1.110473394393921,
0.061223503202199936,
-0.1819383203983307,
-0.2590717673301697,
-1.0820494890213013,
0.2506605386734009,
0.19074760377407074,
-0.10449650138616562,
-0.6487745642662048,
0.7011504769325256,
-0.3403635323047638,
0.4604608118534088,
-0.2850310802459717,
0.08361300826072693,
-0.0371021144092083,
0.2863781750202179,
-0.18397583067417145,
0.6621043682098389,
0.29842954874038696,
-0.4757712781429291,
0.17642717063426971,
0.3001021146774292,
-0.32119908928871155,
0.2134682685136795,
-0.7782569527626038,
0.3818461298942566,
-0.17441841959953308,
-0.26949045062065125,
-0.7652022838592529,
0.142364963889122,
0.1964031159877777,
-0.38361966609954834,
0.25720638036727905,
-0.4161706566810608,
-0.4069390892982483,
-0.32372185587882996,
-0.40437304973602295,
0.2726161479949951,
0.564060628414154,
-0.47397053241729736,
0.3840821385383606,
0.585395097732544,
-0.28770166635513306,
-0.8270763754844666,
-0.5530895590782166,
0.1487676203250885,
-0.584624707698822,
-0.38990363478660583,
0.17146621644496918,
-0.19043408334255219,
-0.3486783504486084,
-0.08129458874464035,
-0.303512305021286,
-0.23808833956718445,
0.5085917711257935,
0.4609651267528534,
0.4374617338180542,
0.09140709787607193,
0.010959162376821041,
-0.0625341385602951,
-0.16317467391490936,
0.3430931568145752,
-0.22619391977787018,
0.6247174143791199,
-0.21307027339935303,
-0.5096083283424377,
-0.21163296699523926,
0.1358078122138977,
0.4278922379016876,
-0.357891321182251,
0.9736682176589966,
0.03151476010680199,
-0.3932547867298126,
-0.22056888043880463,
-0.7855638861656189,
-0.05817917361855507,
-0.5127518177032471,
0.5489774942398071,
-0.14474326372146606,
-1.29850435256958,
0.7139367461204529,
0.08338595926761627,
0.007920787669718266,
0.18081164360046387,
0.2722734212875366,
0.06460345536470413,
0.9186123013496399,
0.6435253024101257,
-0.4577791690826416,
0.532522976398468,
-0.1440584808588028,
0.36194056272506714,
-0.788966715335846,
-0.42414334416389465,
-0.5193946361541748,
-0.06489874422550201,
-0.20394697785377502,
0.011857411824166775,
0.10974966734647751,
0.5252008438110352,
-0.6759073138237,
0.4178059995174408,
-0.36916428804397583,
1.0727992057800293,
0.4193342924118042,
0.25330519676208496,
0.4223555028438568,
-0.2867897152900696,
-0.15674865245819092,
0.010893100872635841,
-0.4812867343425751,
-0.49229681491851807,
1.110534429550171,
0.3764740228652954,
0.7825775146484375,
0.33053791522979736,
1.025813341140747,
0.1311011016368866,
0.13547612726688385,
-0.5851485729217529,
0.7018671035766602,
-0.09601370245218277,
-0.8613097071647644,
-0.2013361006975174,
-0.5493522882461548,
-0.8269025087356567,
0.3942171335220337,
-0.13883323967456818,
-1.1753753423690796,
-0.3633309602737427,
0.23192349076271057,
-0.3474971652030945,
0.9158273339271545,
-0.6061220765113831,
0.8738041520118713,
-0.5073770880699158,
-0.37759822607040405,
-0.1768409162759781,
-0.6873032450675964,
0.7516802549362183,
-0.37936437129974365,
0.3458676040172577,
-0.015233969315886497,
0.3111642003059387,
1.0311633348464966,
-0.504578173160553,
1.0623139142990112,
-0.574763834476471,
-0.046228159219026566,
0.27628713846206665,
0.42178037762641907,
0.5542311072349548,
0.0012702611275017262,
0.08266628533601761,
-0.13671551644802094,
-0.14929158985614777,
-0.20389235019683838,
-0.3623099625110626,
0.44772061705589294,
-0.5201875567436218,
-0.975201427936554,
-0.14149440824985504,
-0.7051683068275452,
-0.044495053589344025,
0.6929031014442444,
-0.00408061221241951,
0.04771527647972107,
-0.43350160121917725,
0.19064831733703613,
0.9641506671905518,
-0.5206780433654785,
0.4787207841873169,
0.7052559852600098,
-0.37158262729644775,
-0.48113688826560974,
0.9885768294334412,
-0.1406024545431137,
0.47282975912094116,
0.3543616533279419,
0.2808052599430084,
-0.03469310328364372,
-0.9232133030891418,
-0.04039180278778076,
0.1332673728466034,
-0.5908852219581604,
-0.535030722618103,
-0.6419705152511597,
-0.31778109073638916,
-0.16094157099723816,
-0.25563037395477295,
-0.3822099268436432,
-0.4705534279346466,
0.01702585630118847,
-0.2651720643043518,
0.499618798494339,
0.723995566368103,
-0.18638163805007935,
0.414882093667984,
-0.9291331768035889,
0.3338300585746765,
0.21979713439941406,
0.2695336639881134,
0.07612336426973343,
-0.5075775384902954,
-0.25477683544158936,
0.05409996584057808,
-0.5843256115913391,
-0.7727269530296326,
0.37180599570274353,
-0.07124204933643341,
0.6080700755119324,
0.7749477624893188,
0.29100924730300903,
0.5525621771812439,
-0.5984742641448975,
0.42316779494285583,
0.4453223645687103,
-1.0706738233566284,
0.6047999262809753,
-0.45620429515838623,
0.19214452803134918,
0.6758257150650024,
0.17397502064704895,
-0.6037406325340271,
-0.800183117389679,
-0.48363256454467773,
-1.0980056524276733,
0.4916694760322571,
-0.1682976484298706,
0.2901155352592468,
-0.09916970133781433,
0.401882529258728,
-0.06592732667922974,
0.0834457129240036,
-0.853651225566864,
-0.19584499299526215,
-0.0012000198476016521,
-0.06721807271242142,
0.13736601173877716,
-0.4824874699115753,
-0.18456332385540009,
-0.1788182407617569,
0.8361795544624329,
0.4296405613422394,
0.05377304553985596,
-0.22533732652664185,
-0.41659605503082275,
0.07224711775779724,
0.6366473436355591,
0.5124446749687195,
0.41474980115890503,
-0.2510633170604706,
0.09180790930986404,
0.3918723165988922,
-0.6656944751739502,
0.43136176466941833,
-0.058939702808856964,
-0.5994532108306885,
-0.7487979531288147,
0.3461117148399353,
0.6057283878326416,
0.17914921045303345,
-0.8076655864715576,
0.5703237056732178,
0.0208947341889143,
-0.23280124366283417,
-0.24533209204673767,
0.40714970231056213,
0.22245098650455475,
0.0745476558804512,
0.2504560947418213,
0.0037216870114207268,
-0.18583092093467712,
-0.2588163912296295,
0.3410383462905884,
0.600247323513031,
-0.6241412162780762,
-0.12657871842384338,
0.9271550178527832,
0.028014445677399635,
-0.19458834826946259,
0.8187745213508606,
-0.17353297770023346,
-0.8882489800453186,
0.7235752940177917,
1.0206459760665894,
0.6813791394233704,
-0.4094427824020386,
-0.04533190280199051,
0.14188000559806824,
0.4817062318325043,
0.04202621802687645,
0.1093820333480835,
0.26440343260765076,
-0.9471451640129089,
-0.3639645576477051,
-0.3241359293460846,
-0.3882368206977844,
0.36579710245132446,
-0.5874482989311218,
-0.041688334196805954,
-0.7446929812431335,
0.25078514218330383,
-0.18006601929664612,
-0.19526785612106323,
-0.13148918747901917,
0.09769686311483383,
0.014484906569123268,
0.871735155582428,
-0.585136353969574,
0.7129141092300415,
0.41468727588653564,
-0.41570693254470825,
-0.6839873194694519,
-0.2325412631034851,
0.44396501779556274,
-0.616766095161438,
0.6854551434516907,
0.3465340733528137,
-0.2519060969352722,
-0.1671837866306305,
-0.5046819448471069,
-0.6553333401679993,
0.7326081395149231,
0.5700607299804688,
-0.6100568771362305,
0.21211270987987518,
0.08427771925926208,
0.21662244200706482,
-0.09834910184144974,
-0.11677718907594681,
0.4396480917930603,
0.18421699106693268,
-0.10830528289079666,
-0.5340358018875122,
0.17550383508205414,
-0.3882254660129547,
-0.3601331114768982,
0.6302395462989807,
-0.32913529872894287,
0.7763884663581848,
-0.7735840678215027,
-0.11917806416749954,
0.25450992584228516,
0.4725112318992615,
0.3599800169467926,
0.07904879003763199,
0.4388761818408966,
0.880760133266449,
0.7017596364021301,
-0.06907260417938232,
0.8428669571876526,
-0.09905198961496353,
0.19032514095306396,
1.306319236755371,
-0.3495793640613556,
0.7171177864074707,
0.33916905522346497,
0.12639951705932617,
0.21952126920223236,
-0.08324410021305084,
-0.13912054896354675,
0.684950053691864,
0.5202926993370056,
-0.46803322434425354,
-0.07549532502889633,
0.314804345369339,
-0.22776135802268982,
0.5382153391838074,
0.12229421734809875,
0.011104856617748737,
-0.2572898268699646,
0.2083129584789276,
0.8249126672744751,
0.20352764427661896,
-0.39755964279174805,
0.9852392077445984,
-0.10650800168514252,
-0.3182913064956665,
0.6044268608093262,
0.14198990166187286,
0.6285229325294495,
-0.6020194888114929,
0.04417644068598747,
-0.3313915729522705,
0.5501914024353027,
-0.12092452496290207,
-0.6608777046203613,
0.327202171087265,
0.29444828629493713,
-0.1405537724494934,
-0.015692375600337982,
0.8843222260475159,
-0.30037927627563477,
-0.11642422527074814,
0.5642637610435486,
0.3810858428478241,
-0.00008487000013701618,
-0.10363910347223282,
-0.5427408218383789,
-0.20823292434215546,
0.09702935069799423,
-0.1739218831062317,
0.5477243661880493,
0.1415344774723053,
-0.00406276062130928,
0.9769620299339294,
0.6276162266731262,
0.1987408846616745,
-0.0003258240467403084,
0.01663300208747387,
1.0258166790008545,
-0.7637619376182556,
-0.32903817296028137,
-1.177383303642273,
0.5562609434127808,
-0.10092749446630478,
0.16359898447990417,
0.8796381950378418,
0.7866306900978088,
0.8014332056045532,
0.1233765035867691,
0.9034078121185303,
-0.0014664815971627831,
0.5006172060966492,
-0.5503950715065002,
1.2595211267471313,
-0.14274922013282776,
0.5904912948608398,
-0.5328090786933899,
-0.7473331689834595,
-0.6226063370704651,
0.5521978139877319,
-0.46914389729499817,
-0.04916677623987198,
0.4904686510562897,
0.7912108302116394,
0.09009341150522232,
0.05561678484082222,
0.3095886707305908,
0.4051254987716675,
0.6184055805206299,
0.7644253969192505,
1.1100966930389404,
-0.2836640477180481,
0.754904568195343,
-0.3179088532924652,
-0.10433381050825119,
0.160810649394989,
-0.7888091206550598,
-1.0342835187911987,
-0.17645695805549622,
0.03933160752058029,
-0.3224734663963318,
0.5482438802719116,
0.48432794213294983,
0.3340350091457367,
-0.9573721289634705,
-0.2548302710056305,
-0.13807186484336853,
0.30875730514526367,
-0.08449333161115646,
-0.1508377343416214,
0.21457740664482117,
-0.27481287717819214,
-0.1811225265264511,
0.5697660446166992,
0.05950266122817993,
0.07673861086368561,
0.182985320687294,
-0.1835433393716812,
-0.23547951877117157,
-0.14520134031772614,
0.27885663509368896,
0.6594085693359375,
-0.501163899898529,
-0.35139310359954834,
-0.2118348628282547,
0.11937569826841354,
-0.07001529633998871,
0.7006267309188843,
-0.6304718852043152,
0.41707128286361694,
0.1267295777797699,
0.7149372696876526,
0.4867379665374756,
0.03210364654660225,
0.4926067888736725,
-0.7032923698425293,
0.1308823972940445,
0.034412313252687454,
0.5968675017356873,
0.24146558344364166,
-0.3705037832260132,
0.3071114122867584,
-0.047769319266080856,
-0.521061897277832,
-0.765314519405365,
0.31819626688957214,
-0.5431777834892273,
-0.6363282203674316,
0.9733474850654602,
-0.21457736194133759,
-0.13725489377975464,
-0.35373908281326294,
-0.21547380089759827,
0.15136820077896118,
-0.44154903292655945,
0.8942775130271912,
0.3099266588687897,
0.198311448097229,
-0.16256821155548096,
-0.7082048058509827,
0.29413700103759766,
0.354164183139801,
-0.8870429396629333,
0.3988218605518341,
0.5388504266738892,
0.7113364934921265,
0.06971264630556107,
0.5408031344413757,
-0.35664090514183044,
0.31524911522865295,
-0.2790006995201111,
0.31894224882125854,
-0.5602340698242188,
-0.4674166738986969,
-0.4079361855983734,
0.37139442563056946,
0.12231555581092834,
-0.08629143238067627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05875v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05875v1
|
CodecLM: Aligning Language Models with Tailored Synthetic Data
| 2024-04-08T21:15:36 | 2024-04-08T21:15:36 |
Zifeng Wang, Chun-Liang Li, Vincent Perot, Long T. Le, Jin Miao, Zizhao Zhang, Chen-Yu Lee, Tomas Pfister
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Instruction tuning has emerged as the key in aligning large language models
(LLMs) with specific task instructions, thereby mitigating the discrepancy
between the next-token prediction objective and users' actual goals. To reduce
the labor and time cost to collect or annotate data by humans, researchers
start to explore the use of LLMs to generate instruction-aligned synthetic
data. Recent works focus on generating diverse instructions and applying LLM to
increase instruction complexity, often neglecting downstream use cases. It
remains unclear how to tailor high-quality data to elicit better
instruction-following abilities in different target instruction distributions
and LLMs. To this end, we introduce CodecLM, a general framework for adaptively
generating high-quality synthetic data for LLM alignment with different
downstream instruction distributions and LLMs. Drawing on the Encode-Decode
principles, we use LLMs as codecs to guide the data generation process. We
first encode seed instructions into metadata, which are concise keywords
generated on-the-fly to capture the target instruction distribution, and then
decode metadata to create tailored instructions. We also introduce Self-Rubrics
and Contrastive Filtering during decoding to tailor data-efficient samples.
Extensive experiments on four open-domain instruction following benchmarks
validate the effectiveness of CodecLM over the current state-of-the-arts.
|
[
-0.20680563151836395,
-0.6563777923583984,
0.4384419620037079,
0.158670112490654,
-0.10389213263988495,
0.319985955953598,
-0.6141592860221863,
-0.08189664781093597,
0.10698086023330688,
0.8759453892707825,
-0.6989937424659729,
-1.0269486904144287,
-0.30945059657096863,
0.006348072551190853,
-0.2622440755367279,
0.9845563173294067,
-0.1781521737575531,
0.12464895844459534,
-0.47028765082359314,
-0.006713120266795158,
-0.6780019998550415,
-0.5911518931388855,
-0.09030196815729141,
-0.12370515614748001,
0.2243337482213974,
0.6610960960388184,
0.7872791290283203,
1.414482593536377,
0.4460793137550354,
0.20749212801456451,
0.3161203861236572,
0.6728965044021606,
-0.5448762774467468,
0.24676115810871124,
-0.14993725717067719,
-0.4972209632396698,
-0.7597176432609558,
-0.15378215909004211,
0.6023808121681213,
0.4883967339992523,
-0.17524078488349915,
0.3579980432987213,
0.03876436874270439,
0.6771396994590759,
-0.6358198523521423,
0.008685489185154438,
-0.7088074684143066,
-0.1670706421136856,
-0.23269961774349213,
-0.5986288189888,
-0.5632885098457336,
-0.6191810369491577,
-0.2240932434797287,
-0.6384809017181396,
0.3665803074836731,
0.26302966475486755,
0.43926355242729187,
0.4066599905490875,
-0.07175776362419128,
-0.5730273723602295,
-0.7210304141044617,
0.8580822944641113,
-0.8389135003089905,
0.20164169371128082,
0.36030492186546326,
0.15802791714668274,
-0.33971723914146423,
-0.4747539162635803,
-0.25483438372612,
0.19392149150371552,
0.09447821974754333,
0.06808779388666153,
0.18171289563179016,
-0.020272132009267807,
0.08302292972803116,
0.37150323390960693,
-0.8882754445075989,
0.23271824419498444,
-0.35983964800834656,
-0.25926050543785095,
0.6269119381904602,
0.5189105272293091,
0.32142364978790283,
0.37505513429641724,
-0.4358580708503723,
-0.2369898408651352,
-1.0124768018722534,
-0.2431592047214508,
0.6028112173080444,
0.3548167943954468,
-0.08056578040122986,
0.5575600266456604,
-0.11961584538221359,
1.0617234706878662,
0.11192545294761658,
-0.02525246888399124,
0.18187090754508972,
-0.43637746572494507,
-0.1733963042497635,
0.45872047543525696,
0.5433341264724731,
0.3520904779434204,
0.240409255027771,
-0.15065217018127441,
-0.3204740285873413,
0.06936921179294586,
0.534967303276062,
-0.8089943528175354,
-0.4203880727291107,
0.04409438744187355,
-0.24450929462909698,
-0.1903243362903595,
0.19292932748794556,
-0.9080573320388794,
-0.10591363161802292,
-0.6331131458282471,
0.21356120705604553,
-0.2580537796020508,
0.07019457221031189,
0.2698522210121155,
0.2350267618894577,
0.3460013270378113,
-0.06727000325918198,
-1.2334970235824585,
0.4190177917480469,
0.8467552065849304,
0.6429119110107422,
-0.6206411719322205,
-0.05490169674158096,
-0.6272915601730347,
0.37482571601867676,
-0.5837550759315491,
0.71232008934021,
-0.8929555416107178,
-0.15998941659927368,
0.1735086590051651,
0.14387719333171844,
-0.11433275043964386,
-0.637742280960083,
0.34432291984558105,
-0.6773325204849243,
0.13563776016235352,
0.04645606875419617,
-0.7938930988311768,
0.07333069294691086,
0.09863939881324768,
-0.42509767413139343,
0.8477020263671875,
0.19606733322143555,
-0.3812006115913391,
-0.019702164456248283,
-0.44668468832969666,
-0.44488829374313354,
-0.05963226780295372,
-0.04772767797112465,
-0.3340960443019867,
0.19766435027122498,
0.3540772795677185,
0.21872027218341827,
-0.3436828553676605,
0.07152819633483887,
-0.10215859860181808,
-0.5040526390075684,
0.30675211548805237,
-0.41567912697792053,
0.3056798577308655,
0.3040257394313812,
-0.1470147967338562,
0.3168136775493622,
-0.7278959155082703,
0.397882878780365,
-0.12661124765872955,
-0.5309005379676819,
-0.0943560004234314,
0.23259152472019196,
-0.19561655819416046,
-0.07165553420782089,
0.373254656791687,
-0.2796923816204071,
0.40448224544525146,
-0.440913587808609,
0.4356900751590729,
0.7674053907394409,
-0.11354947090148926,
0.6434049010276794,
-0.4211411774158478,
0.7420058846473694,
-0.27435070276260376,
-0.02243950217962265,
-0.4711732268333435,
-0.12637674808502197,
-0.5897898077964783,
-0.28665757179260254,
0.31435427069664,
0.630486249923706,
-0.5210784673690796,
0.41980811953544617,
-0.386083722114563,
-0.18136504292488098,
-0.8177984952926636,
0.50114506483078,
0.5484221577644348,
0.36257031559944153,
0.5143001079559326,
-0.21630775928497314,
-0.7666162848472595,
-0.6805781126022339,
-0.18688049912452698,
0.32153162360191345,
0.029292987659573555,
0.12902742624282837,
0.011759893968701363,
-0.3605765402317047,
0.8675882816314697,
-0.6656836867332458,
-0.034213729202747345,
-0.044932711869478226,
-0.07826787233352661,
0.1250232607126236,
0.6199645400047302,
0.14616082608699799,
-0.5282689332962036,
-0.4188827574253082,
0.03182858228683472,
-0.4784568250179291,
-0.5449846982955933,
0.0034558381885290146,
-0.42929086089134216,
0.3521081209182739,
0.5440127849578857,
-0.1742754578590393,
-0.03220275416970253,
0.8996415734291077,
-0.009932818822562695,
0.3922084867954254,
-0.424780011177063,
0.16624338924884796,
-1.2551053762435913,
-0.1682267189025879,
-0.22787368297576904,
-0.30996444821357727,
-0.618714451789856,
0.01568288914859295,
0.1510915905237198,
0.03328699246048927,
-0.3028126657009125,
0.31954967975616455,
-0.6255073547363281,
-0.1805940419435501,
-0.5241231918334961,
0.047083619982004166,
0.14635047316551208,
0.46849754452705383,
0.03145584091544151,
0.9612211585044861,
0.3984459638595581,
-0.48397544026374817,
0.3035752773284912,
0.06608129292726517,
-0.3109550178050995,
0.26284974813461304,
-0.41405054926872253,
0.5351641774177551,
0.08315002918243408,
0.021980632096529007,
-0.8587989807128906,
-0.5390167832374573,
0.2163173407316208,
-0.18037016689777374,
0.4918796122074127,
-0.1690063178539276,
-0.5734077095985413,
0.01817440614104271,
-0.22188255190849304,
0.5758134126663208,
0.9140788912773132,
-0.6691438555717468,
0.4245316982269287,
0.31959614157676697,
0.011981693096458912,
-0.3588654100894928,
-0.4890606999397278,
-0.12782682478427887,
-0.3063492178916931,
-0.4951237142086029,
0.6847778558731079,
-0.16763044893741608,
0.01698772795498371,
0.01596309058368206,
-0.19777554273605347,
0.015545719303190708,
-0.18259947001934052,
0.2635883092880249,
0.3730632960796356,
-0.4407223165035248,
0.030374109745025635,
0.12991225719451904,
-0.06797681748867035,
0.05473991110920906,
-0.64508455991745,
0.6552211046218872,
0.18385770916938782,
-0.4336872696876526,
-0.1835578829050064,
0.21813781559467316,
0.3555378317832947,
-0.2840355634689331,
0.44209879636764526,
0.49589359760284424,
-0.19925472140312195,
-0.5415326952934265,
-0.3823748826980591,
-0.018361534923315048,
-0.5182262659072876,
0.2237902581691742,
-0.07924871146678925,
-0.7038856148719788,
0.21922388672828674,
-0.17327789962291718,
0.17991706728935242,
0.007827797904610634,
0.7383993864059448,
-0.09400860220193863,
1.306512713432312,
0.4424504339694977,
-0.006723940838128328,
0.3188227713108063,
-0.010641993023455143,
0.14113129675388336,
-0.8457221388816833,
-0.0479280985891819,
-0.3036969006061554,
-0.3552189767360687,
-0.5845052003860474,
-0.6542946100234985,
0.16156503558158875,
0.15330040454864502,
-0.25951218605041504,
0.4522872269153595,
-0.8113319277763367,
0.6281859278678894,
0.4066146910190582,
0.08523274958133698,
0.16971038281917572,
0.09201029688119888,
0.182069793343544,
-0.019384631887078285,
-0.7907382249832153,
-0.816524863243103,
1.0840755701065063,
0.09654726088047028,
1.1115577220916748,
-0.08461272716522217,
0.7848836779594421,
0.3570614159107208,
0.33664411306381226,
-0.44887909293174744,
0.4303077161312103,
-0.354368656873703,
-0.2553771734237671,
0.14181996881961823,
-0.33081892132759094,
-0.8108722567558289,
-0.13696017861366272,
-0.08109863847494125,
-0.4508014917373657,
-0.21354587376117706,
0.6015512943267822,
-0.1317468136548996,
0.04347700625658035,
-0.7158467173576355,
0.8855572938919067,
-0.3585892915725708,
-0.24654832482337952,
-0.041083354502916336,
-0.4860687851905823,
0.4682197570800781,
-0.17655742168426514,
0.35138607025146484,
-0.1584492325782776,
-0.2013964056968689,
0.4478282034397125,
-0.3652549684047699,
0.902341365814209,
0.079890176653862,
-0.20525139570236206,
0.3290361762046814,
0.2440987229347229,
0.4043242931365967,
-0.25021836161613464,
-0.09333912283182144,
-0.06101401895284653,
0.05876757949590683,
-0.3908311724662781,
-0.7520949244499207,
0.9973499774932861,
-0.5753158330917358,
-0.7645140886306763,
0.035474181175231934,
-0.9352960586547852,
-0.12979458272457123,
-0.10602781921625137,
0.18597444891929626,
0.5337968468666077,
-0.062001410871744156,
0.13451017439365387,
0.6938045024871826,
-0.2673388421535492,
0.20571142435073853,
0.4710615873336792,
-0.049872200936079025,
-0.6640030145645142,
1.3051176071166992,
-0.18594786524772644,
0.6022650599479675,
0.5187182426452637,
0.011047367006540298,
-0.19436873495578766,
-0.5609204769134521,
-0.6260755062103271,
-0.08058755099773407,
-0.7069316506385803,
-0.5459973812103271,
-0.1336657702922821,
-0.16976845264434814,
-0.318645715713501,
-0.4091862738132477,
-0.2615976631641388,
-0.10430485755205154,
-0.44726574420928955,
0.10891000926494598,
0.3829765319824219,
0.5192236304283142,
0.19032791256904602,
0.2942911386489868,
-0.8588300943374634,
0.15402448177337646,
-0.09349840879440308,
0.13936910033226013,
-0.31010901927948,
-0.5632731914520264,
-0.4319693446159363,
0.3622647225856781,
-0.3041406273841858,
-0.7361334562301636,
0.5480076670646667,
0.34370729327201843,
0.33354076743125916,
0.09566520899534225,
0.17473769187927246,
0.7369944453239441,
-0.7247469425201416,
0.6666398644447327,
-0.13865508139133453,
-0.9352329969406128,
0.5588389039039612,
-0.1254466474056244,
0.33711305260658264,
0.2939904034137726,
0.16229306161403656,
-0.16935986280441284,
-0.41481277346611023,
-0.1462976485490799,
-0.7233962416648865,
0.7680392861366272,
-0.051283739507198334,
0.4126758575439453,
-0.07063879072666168,
0.5054569244384766,
0.25662773847579956,
0.053224530071020126,
-0.33492833375930786,
-0.03742752969264984,
-0.22925013303756714,
-1.0596998929977417,
0.029624788090586662,
-0.016739441081881523,
-0.3258332908153534,
-0.034125298261642456,
0.5091039538383484,
-0.42414188385009766,
0.11082839965820312,
-0.10297079384326935,
-0.24247248470783234,
-0.15223900973796844,
0.2432752400636673,
0.8697429299354553,
0.7296512722969055,
-0.11721645295619965,
0.2936241030693054,
0.0795682966709137,
-0.3546810746192932,
0.24331367015838623,
-0.16915525496006012,
-0.021226566284894943,
-0.2813471853733063,
0.46942466497421265,
0.7663542032241821,
0.33046936988830566,
-0.9727975726127625,
0.256150484085083,
0.22116543352603912,
-0.22002893686294556,
-0.1196412667632103,
0.7286825776100159,
0.159891739487648,
0.1805882453918457,
0.12439646571874619,
-0.1482098251581192,
-0.25597554445266724,
-0.4904211759567261,
0.21134619414806366,
0.4348028898239136,
-0.10784506052732468,
-0.4511231780052185,
0.6673953533172607,
0.04083162173628807,
-0.6105761528015137,
0.5468350052833557,
0.004173428285866976,
-0.37228450179100037,
0.6106631755828857,
0.9748590588569641,
0.70280921459198,
-0.14146862924098969,
0.02873094193637371,
0.16090576350688934,
0.051325347274541855,
-0.08861801028251648,
0.3471008241176605,
-0.04756317287683487,
-0.6862785816192627,
-0.471073716878891,
-0.7865748405456543,
-0.3505750298500061,
-0.1364404410123825,
-0.7518473863601685,
0.1632704883813858,
-0.35024550557136536,
0.12888993322849274,
-0.3023265302181244,
-0.26216942071914673,
-0.559589147567749,
0.012778468430042267,
0.029103465378284454,
0.7966495752334595,
-0.5816525220870972,
1.0292168855667114,
0.5384181141853333,
-0.029642950743436813,
-0.736996591091156,
0.11586591601371765,
0.027467841282486916,
-1.063286304473877,
0.4840559661388397,
0.1547991931438446,
-0.01118357665836811,
0.23297090828418732,
-0.6393411755561829,
-0.8623971939086914,
1.1488982439041138,
0.5487774610519409,
-0.6438812017440796,
0.056301869451999664,
0.3412003815174103,
0.5651891231536865,
-0.9665582776069641,
-0.2192644625902176,
0.6959031224250793,
0.31340667605400085,
0.03864465281367302,
-0.3382531404495239,
0.13621912896633148,
-0.03438858687877655,
0.1301577389240265,
0.37634193897247314,
-0.19337902963161469,
0.5258309841156006,
-0.14516153931617737,
-0.24171867966651917,
0.15110738575458527,
0.43038344383239746,
0.27784818410873413,
0.16255038976669312,
0.210444837808609,
0.36830934882164,
0.45778995752334595,
-0.1462087333202362,
0.9157506823539734,
-0.7778500914573669,
-0.005177437327802181,
1.216253638267517,
-0.2205718606710434,
0.719877302646637,
0.3327271044254303,
0.15782342851161957,
0.5262874364852905,
0.7693871259689331,
-0.1366148293018341,
0.6285377740859985,
0.395720511674881,
-0.09327813982963562,
-0.1447736620903015,
0.1167067289352417,
-0.11722633987665176,
0.42006006836891174,
0.47951966524124146,
-0.48772332072257996,
0.0062978193163871765,
-0.1617259681224823,
-0.31756487488746643,
0.36350151896476746,
-0.3114561438560486,
0.9101231098175049,
-0.1198468804359436,
-0.9126743674278259,
0.8125285506248474,
0.019065378233790398,
0.36457353830337524,
-0.4675079882144928,
-0.2648172676563263,
-0.19645826518535614,
0.18490171432495117,
-0.3233993351459503,
-0.6947184801101685,
0.3226686120033264,
0.16949006915092468,
-0.43779921531677246,
-0.3064953684806824,
0.5492280125617981,
-0.9143285751342773,
-0.3952794373035431,
0.026949677616357803,
0.19433647394180298,
0.11411738395690918,
0.36085817217826843,
-0.4189821183681488,
0.5266813039779663,
0.0299459770321846,
-0.03335288539528847,
0.452252596616745,
0.2933615446090698,
-0.04479378089308739,
0.3929944336414337,
0.7460392117500305,
0.18668635189533234,
0.336865097284317,
-0.044679682701826096,
0.731227457523346,
-0.5733195543289185,
-0.06342534720897675,
-0.9474111199378967,
0.34713101387023926,
0.09428887814283371,
-0.16850143671035767,
0.5473244786262512,
0.5556703209877014,
1.05266273021698,
-0.219697505235672,
0.4715174734592438,
0.25806546211242676,
0.24840879440307617,
-1.0132757425308228,
0.20925258100032806,
-0.24871434271335602,
0.5148966908454895,
0.18327002227306366,
-1.1481448411941528,
-0.23914368450641632,
0.33452510833740234,
-0.14581868052482605,
-0.05687111243605614,
0.3473314344882965,
1.2463188171386719,
-0.20098255574703217,
-0.11809347569942474,
0.11039890348911285,
-0.1865679919719696,
0.2918942868709564,
0.615433394908905,
0.6773566603660583,
-0.2145663946866989,
0.5112189650535583,
0.01642107591032982,
-0.020556900650262833,
-0.20630060136318207,
-0.8692432045936584,
-0.6941334009170532,
-0.39073681831359863,
-0.3335210382938385,
-0.13310368359088898,
0.16954268515110016,
1.2074981927871704,
0.8378053307533264,
-0.7852473258972168,
-0.29059579968452454,
-0.2895888388156891,
0.12918397784233093,
-0.2829221785068512,
-0.2507997155189514,
0.37696197628974915,
-0.7308417558670044,
-0.8485084176063538,
0.5651666522026062,
0.31834250688552856,
-0.0023466316051781178,
-0.20073683559894562,
-0.46536505222320557,
0.24848465621471405,
0.295297235250473,
0.34178298711776733,
0.17978723347187042,
-0.7388432025909424,
-0.2719746232032776,
0.27017608284950256,
-0.3702276945114136,
0.2544346749782562,
1.1045562028884888,
-0.5000469088554382,
0.5417224764823914,
0.369904100894928,
0.9808593988418579,
0.24422457814216614,
0.3764689266681671,
0.9238436222076416,
-0.9889093637466431,
-0.2661593556404114,
0.12174904346466064,
0.1035039946436882,
0.40776991844177246,
-0.3441879153251648,
0.3679990768432617,
-0.1771422028541565,
-0.6747074723243713,
-0.924524188041687,
0.16150861978530884,
-0.81695955991745,
-0.22740721702575684,
1.1518985033035278,
-0.175444096326828,
-0.3794021010398865,
0.23572203516960144,
-0.14896808564662933,
0.18240191042423248,
-0.13294699788093567,
0.7099534869194031,
0.5245094895362854,
-0.2102130949497223,
-0.13162243366241455,
-0.4987095892429352,
0.5551971793174744,
0.22500427067279816,
-0.8688733577728271,
0.3427862823009491,
0.5461624264717102,
0.3116872310638428,
-0.11851636320352554,
0.13150909543037415,
-0.04873158782720566,
0.16314956545829773,
-0.300432950258255,
0.021865006536245346,
-0.25878557562828064,
-0.3322056829929352,
-0.2523093819618225,
0.04212109372019768,
-0.043775010854005814,
-0.4236765205860138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05868v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05868v1
|
Negative Preference Optimization: From Catastrophic Collapse to Effective Unlearning
| 2024-04-08T21:05:42 | 2024-04-08T21:05:42 |
Ruiqi Zhang, Licong Lin, Yu Bai, Song Mei
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) often memorize sensitive, private, or
copyrighted data during pre-training. LLM unlearning aims to eliminate the
influence of undesirable data from the pre-trained model while preserving the
model's utilities on other tasks. Several practical methods have recently been
proposed for LLM unlearning, mostly based on gradient ascent (GA) on the loss
of undesirable data. However, on certain unlearning tasks, these methods either
fail to effectively unlearn the target data or suffer from catastrophic
collapse -- a drastic degradation of the model's utilities.
In this paper, we propose Negative Preference Optimization (NPO), a simple
alignment-inspired method that could efficiently and effectively unlearn a
target dataset. We theoretically show that the progression toward catastrophic
collapse by minimizing the NPO loss is exponentially slower than GA. Through
experiments on synthetic data and the benchmark TOFU dataset, we demonstrate
that NPO-based methods achieve a better balance between unlearning the
undesirable data and maintaining the model's utilities. We also observe that
NPO-based methods generate more sensible outputs than GA-based methods, whose
outputs are often gibberish. Remarkably, on TOFU, NPO-based methods are the
first to achieve reasonable unlearning results in forgetting 50% (or more) of
the training data, whereas existing methods already struggle with forgetting
10% of training data.
|
[
-0.31020811200141907,
-0.5213775634765625,
0.3715178370475769,
-0.3521614670753479,
-0.2697049379348755,
0.12916578352451324,
-0.34583497047424316,
-0.003920066636055708,
0.059277232736349106,
0.6631232500076294,
-0.6383199095726013,
-0.43486055731773376,
-0.45016688108444214,
-0.21445080637931824,
-0.36828866600990295,
1.2971895933151245,
0.2964259088039398,
0.054960209876298904,
-0.3765948414802551,
-0.062317196279764175,
-0.4557268023490906,
-0.576839804649353,
-0.559502363204956,
-0.6502339243888855,
0.3292614817619324,
0.8263140320777893,
0.6400940418243408,
0.8129593729972839,
-0.04849895462393761,
0.303603857755661,
-0.12215781211853027,
0.07547864317893982,
-1.2776533365249634,
-0.1307980865240097,
-0.13129809498786926,
-0.5540764331817627,
-0.05753219872713089,
0.1312904804944992,
0.35244035720825195,
0.6592006683349609,
-0.31621137261390686,
0.06756634265184402,
0.2109736055135727,
1.0946334600448608,
-0.7620838284492493,
-0.074776291847229,
-0.7928870320320129,
0.2059181183576584,
-0.033548902720212936,
-0.34206655621528625,
-0.540181577205658,
-0.6009319424629211,
0.1657165139913559,
-0.7008711695671082,
0.04923121631145477,
-0.19632062315940857,
0.7681698203086853,
0.35340002179145813,
-0.16086283326148987,
-0.13256531953811646,
-0.6981022357940674,
1.3401206731796265,
-0.7151103615760803,
0.28195008635520935,
0.43757694959640503,
0.10540547221899033,
-0.24887590110301971,
0.1073569506406784,
-0.43318086862564087,
-0.26130303740501404,
0.26556888222694397,
0.1462148129940033,
0.04202695190906525,
0.1837238073348999,
-0.02135787345468998,
0.39552074670791626,
-0.30609530210494995,
0.5301963090896606,
-0.2322179228067398,
-0.2520175576210022,
0.49282506108283997,
-0.11284151673316956,
0.28212419152259827,
-0.2509489357471466,
-0.2375570684671402,
-0.07899432629346848,
-0.9292580485343933,
-0.15461283922195435,
0.6978448629379272,
0.4379426836967468,
0.15176057815551758,
0.6210615634918213,
-0.059535108506679535,
0.4331888258457184,
0.0782025158405304,
-0.43376776576042175,
0.42231452465057373,
-0.00001161365071311593,
-0.08209174871444702,
0.05668790638446808,
0.4925423264503479,
0.41770291328430176,
0.403906911611557,
-0.6407052874565125,
-0.04531314596533775,
0.22751620411872864,
0.2885151207447052,
-0.5598735213279724,
0.0432472750544548,
0.20145416259765625,
-0.3711780905723572,
-0.4750155806541443,
-0.3336027264595032,
-0.8485304713249207,
-0.34650108218193054,
-0.8188270926475525,
0.5640357732772827,
-0.48964282870292664,
-0.001110538956709206,
0.2298685908317566,
0.018010839819908142,
0.04456024616956711,
0.42532631754875183,
-0.8001446723937988,
0.16941611468791962,
0.7914215922355652,
0.7426719665527344,
0.017433378845453262,
-0.276642382144928,
-0.6006382703781128,
-0.11270184069871902,
-0.32997050881385803,
0.4149002730846405,
-0.3598462641239166,
-0.4427765905857086,
-0.12357828766107559,
-0.30812427401542664,
0.11546410620212555,
-0.6469503045082092,
0.6136208176612854,
-0.5106294751167297,
0.3900519013404846,
-0.2465355396270752,
-0.6095081567764282,
-0.3852353096008301,
0.3276965320110321,
-0.3175364136695862,
0.7387601733207703,
-0.04384847730398178,
-0.49266496300697327,
0.34323546290397644,
-0.46482136845588684,
-0.3577248156070709,
-0.308022677898407,
-0.03227255493402481,
-0.8229471445083618,
0.2550269067287445,
-0.15780644118785858,
0.3609245717525482,
-0.48120296001434326,
0.40701180696487427,
-0.6989626884460449,
-0.3123343884944916,
-0.14939938485622406,
-0.32960355281829834,
0.7018817663192749,
-0.00927869975566864,
-0.2736990749835968,
-0.0828966572880745,
-0.8923553824424744,
-0.07669147104024887,
0.3502485156059265,
-0.26009073853492737,
-0.737931489944458,
0.19075842201709747,
-0.36172983050346375,
0.2470943182706833,
0.22886279225349426,
-0.47881969809532166,
0.3074811100959778,
-0.6133310198783875,
0.5437361001968384,
1.1435366868972778,
-0.12450164556503296,
0.7203345894813538,
-0.5366859436035156,
0.457177996635437,
-0.264836847782135,
0.2426484078168869,
0.24869665503501892,
0.045055221766233444,
-0.9584199786186218,
0.08296219259500504,
0.021272514015436172,
0.5262475609779358,
-0.6708357930183411,
0.549383282661438,
-0.1997535228729248,
-0.5344777703285217,
-0.4262159466743469,
0.4706355035305023,
0.6780371069908142,
1.1542195081710815,
0.5204528570175171,
-0.1861361861228943,
-0.45989683270454407,
-0.9323914051055908,
-0.14369186758995056,
-0.1337396651506424,
0.2943454384803772,
0.41886478662490845,
0.251258909702301,
-0.266420841217041,
0.5775609016418457,
-0.577692449092865,
-0.27400559186935425,
-0.1638287603855133,
0.058171454817056656,
0.41336363554000854,
0.3969055116176605,
0.4482731819152832,
-0.7212867140769958,
-0.3802739977836609,
0.01128895953297615,
-0.6153107285499573,
0.004980043042451143,
-0.14263546466827393,
-0.2830204963684082,
0.2882043719291687,
0.1777268350124359,
-0.16487018764019012,
0.1941925585269928,
0.40900278091430664,
0.17697322368621826,
0.6837323307991028,
-0.14186716079711914,
-0.19408409297466278,
-1.043899655342102,
0.11659560352563858,
-0.18854404985904694,
0.03270212933421135,
-0.7248010039329529,
-0.28851431608200073,
-0.15749894082546234,
-0.12333134561777115,
-0.533505380153656,
0.40621235966682434,
-0.4482330083847046,
0.10699517279863358,
-0.19226083159446716,
-0.0055610910058021545,
-0.261756956577301,
0.6586251854896545,
0.04406283423304558,
0.7413504719734192,
0.5028674602508545,
-0.6603550910949707,
-0.22846323251724243,
0.4900502860546112,
0.024818861857056618,
0.17127589881420135,
-0.36598271131515503,
0.3328177034854889,
-0.5659139156341553,
-0.2265060395002365,
-0.8934956192970276,
0.06944689154624939,
0.05599039047956467,
-0.2702084183692932,
0.45554280281066895,
-0.44072505831718445,
-0.12726089358329773,
-0.11554233729839325,
-0.8739085793495178,
0.40409159660339355,
0.5444759726524353,
-0.8286129236221313,
0.21272458136081696,
0.5416351556777954,
0.06459444016218185,
-1.136914610862732,
-0.46761202812194824,
-0.010470929555594921,
-0.6694834232330322,
-0.2618451714515686,
0.293550968170166,
-0.13621537387371063,
0.1312747299671173,
-0.26659801602363586,
-0.10259739309549332,
0.25685784220695496,
0.07536519318819046,
0.22975926101207733,
0.5272433161735535,
0.0626547709107399,
0.1578100621700287,
0.09300494939088821,
-0.4521644413471222,
-0.14648665487766266,
-0.29003769159317017,
0.8123161196708679,
-0.05657094344496727,
0.015468780882656574,
-0.400967001914978,
0.1226988360285759,
0.6497533321380615,
0.10092684626579285,
0.7450402975082397,
0.07667803764343262,
-0.2020179033279419,
-0.38413769006729126,
-0.3941926062107086,
-0.09381528943777084,
-0.5243009924888611,
0.30916956067085266,
0.174233540892601,
-0.6542744636535645,
0.3335539400577545,
-0.3201121389865875,
0.17089800536632538,
0.18952909111976624,
0.31363242864608765,
0.051443640142679214,
0.7705814838409424,
0.7449796795845032,
-0.530426561832428,
0.6539694666862488,
-0.5773136615753174,
0.2466091364622116,
-0.8375744819641113,
-0.1910131275653839,
-0.5229472517967224,
-0.3191808760166168,
-0.5635311603546143,
-0.10392429679632187,
0.2504807114601135,
0.4482957422733307,
-0.515792965888977,
0.5031455159187317,
-0.5696775317192078,
0.652545154094696,
0.6287969946861267,
0.09185897558927536,
0.32212844491004944,
0.15768615901470184,
0.08743404597043991,
-0.24740003049373627,
-0.6085761189460754,
-0.46386197209358215,
1.3499704599380493,
0.12945109605789185,
0.8906667232513428,
0.061899084597826004,
1.1636017560958862,
0.07229465991258621,
0.5179157853126526,
-1.1411892175674438,
0.3831759989261627,
-0.5945651531219482,
-0.17369602620601654,
-0.5168181657791138,
-0.6101678013801575,
-0.6542313694953918,
-0.04299420863389969,
-0.2746829688549042,
-0.9264299869537354,
0.3066943287849426,
0.5717137455940247,
-0.14017125964164734,
0.22445479035377502,
-0.8090786933898926,
0.6124932169914246,
-0.39603468775749207,
-0.5091175436973572,
-0.13875792920589447,
-0.5004872679710388,
0.4101673364639282,
-0.27045199275016785,
0.15175308287143707,
-0.03249310329556465,
0.05735798180103302,
0.860546886920929,
-0.5251208543777466,
0.7889356017112732,
-0.2705141007900238,
-0.08583004772663116,
-0.029153699055314064,
0.1898135095834732,
0.645666241645813,
0.1516968458890915,
-0.37728217244148254,
0.27159252762794495,
-0.5126336812973022,
-0.25377002358436584,
-0.6578495502471924,
0.6984323263168335,
-1.023100733757019,
-0.5562788248062134,
-0.20962873101234436,
-0.2836335301399231,
-0.43826958537101746,
0.5350925326347351,
0.4556761682033539,
0.28661245107650757,
-0.07143335789442062,
0.06851272284984589,
0.49489888548851013,
-0.32054150104522705,
0.39786288142204285,
0.5185964703559875,
-0.10238449275493622,
-0.6954569220542908,
1.387604832649231,
0.32983139157295227,
0.48623719811439514,
0.6204731464385986,
0.5272210836410522,
-0.47317856550216675,
-0.9353952407836914,
-0.1283067911863327,
0.4863044321537018,
-0.4981195330619812,
-0.4528546929359436,
-0.35516297817230225,
-0.06501918286085129,
-0.11583898216485977,
-0.49870920181274414,
-0.6409164071083069,
-0.44770827889442444,
-0.6075313687324524,
-0.13374774158000946,
0.09251260757446289,
0.42180997133255005,
-0.28352072834968567,
0.21194268763065338,
-0.5033101439476013,
0.29766926169395447,
0.12156520783901215,
0.1857878416776657,
0.2788254916667938,
-0.5915332436561584,
-0.041332364082336426,
0.04329363629221916,
-0.5498507618904114,
-0.47344568371772766,
0.6886001825332642,
0.24904660880565643,
0.39863094687461853,
0.913907527923584,
0.2921716868877411,
0.8120240569114685,
-0.5111392736434937,
0.25803056359291077,
0.5836700797080994,
-1.0003825426101685,
0.48597028851509094,
-0.5003122687339783,
-0.11968319863080978,
0.8640106320381165,
0.6006792187690735,
-0.5017110705375671,
0.03767365217208862,
-0.4486842155456543,
-1.1189656257629395,
0.7837140560150146,
-0.12265162914991379,
0.23254410922527313,
0.13110896944999695,
0.5576806664466858,
0.5218056440353394,
0.3827597200870514,
-0.6246005892753601,
-0.3479863405227661,
-0.2828436493873596,
0.030974814668297768,
-0.5364984273910522,
-0.28897860646247864,
-0.08941192179918289,
-0.18710416555404663,
0.9357331991195679,
-0.28567543625831604,
0.09540179371833801,
-0.20338043570518494,
-0.048093102872371674,
-0.10332129150629044,
0.40696561336517334,
0.483773797750473,
0.3451850414276123,
-0.2969333231449127,
-0.14147624373435974,
0.07106868177652359,
-0.3347789943218231,
0.41749951243400574,
-0.1916804164648056,
-0.5597290396690369,
-0.5593865513801575,
0.04962027445435524,
0.6107925772666931,
0.11127455532550812,
-0.5533769726753235,
0.3982662558555603,
0.09611950814723969,
-0.16121625900268555,
-0.32588252425193787,
0.15640424191951752,
0.04039914533495903,
-0.3731788098812103,
0.18248450756072998,
0.2662203907966614,
0.251287579536438,
-0.5616495609283447,
0.13775743544101715,
0.6354708671569824,
-0.27070194482803345,
-0.31015634536743164,
0.5154324769973755,
0.07497371733188629,
-0.29351016879081726,
0.7782665491104126,
0.013068176805973053,
-0.4795028865337372,
0.4191703498363495,
0.8187562227249146,
0.8006274104118347,
-0.06806765496730804,
0.49906083941459656,
0.29226574301719666,
0.07128442078828812,
-0.38353654742240906,
0.018906356766819954,
-0.060994330793619156,
-1.007673740386963,
-0.4497464597225189,
-0.6448897123336792,
-0.39761778712272644,
0.6229192614555359,
-0.8466769456863403,
0.3337295353412628,
-0.6615682244300842,
0.0894339457154274,
-0.05223318561911583,
0.03449288010597229,
-0.26569440960884094,
0.24265719950199127,
-0.2245643138885498,
0.5359344482421875,
-0.8748005032539368,
0.46932509541511536,
0.397053062915802,
-0.28865310549736023,
-0.5332701802253723,
-0.005368321668356657,
0.30721762776374817,
-1.1253937482833862,
0.30257394909858704,
0.28194254636764526,
-0.17636644840240479,
-0.02110801637172699,
-0.42324572801589966,
-0.97049480676651,
0.7296721935272217,
1.0419549942016602,
-0.7483974695205688,
-0.11500976979732513,
0.16359810531139374,
0.3942369818687439,
0.027241075411438942,
-0.05205937474966049,
0.3985751271247864,
0.3221342861652374,
0.07824598997831345,
-0.5530072450637817,
-0.06867288798093796,
-0.08592318743467331,
-0.052333664149045944,
0.694938600063324,
-0.8571727275848389,
0.5806474685668945,
-0.5057684779167175,
-0.22919388115406036,
0.06358113884925842,
0.1984194666147232,
0.032490383833646774,
0.2547621726989746,
0.5295263528823853,
0.8633888959884644,
0.7684475779533386,
0.15095815062522888,
0.7674141526222229,
-0.09855446964502335,
0.6220781803131104,
1.180491328239441,
-0.08359228074550629,
0.627481997013092,
0.6794328689575195,
-0.07237224280834198,
0.08740975707769394,
0.4839668869972229,
0.18558834493160248,
0.7935160994529724,
0.3425177335739136,
-0.06511584669351578,
-0.26901188492774963,
-0.36746758222579956,
-0.17619089782238007,
0.4738512635231018,
0.08572296798229218,
-0.12221131473779678,
-0.37273770570755005,
-0.06822645664215088,
0.24814927577972412,
0.26792988181114197,
-0.30588388442993164,
0.8939008712768555,
0.108295738697052,
-0.5276505351066589,
0.926310658454895,
-0.30224841833114624,
0.7049478888511658,
-0.503064751625061,
0.02348986268043518,
-0.30140921473503113,
0.38681384921073914,
-0.35906362533569336,
-0.2275342047214508,
0.342178076505661,
-0.21060964465141296,
-0.25823986530303955,
-0.294681191444397,
0.38167956471443176,
-0.37293168902397156,
-0.27586817741394043,
0.6100261807441711,
0.17363964021205902,
-0.07539444416761398,
0.20344771444797516,
-0.6411418318748474,
-0.24334725737571716,
0.3004412353038788,
-0.05737066641449928,
0.6272579431533813,
-0.09583127498626709,
0.04999987781047821,
0.7764601707458496,
0.8682627081871033,
0.1405182033777237,
-0.3988494873046875,
-0.022721918299794197,
0.9766206741333008,
-0.5502204895019531,
-0.40713366866111755,
-0.8722763657569885,
0.31831225752830505,
0.0300101637840271,
-0.40072622895240784,
0.7604266405105591,
0.6288173794746399,
1.0730401277542114,
0.07463745772838593,
0.8074089884757996,
0.35802239179611206,
0.4814249277114868,
-0.6330884695053101,
0.7061927318572998,
-0.8243093490600586,
0.23298139870166779,
-0.48447954654693604,
-0.9745528697967529,
-0.33980101346969604,
0.44002172350883484,
-0.6461372375488281,
-0.006579067558050156,
0.3347230851650238,
0.782823383808136,
-0.07811534404754639,
-0.10258959978818893,
0.44241949915885925,
0.09845151007175446,
0.2545213997364044,
0.6255965828895569,
0.7282097935676575,
-0.2530187964439392,
0.3807511031627655,
-0.47218838334083557,
-0.32080650329589844,
-0.09796881675720215,
-0.9916473031044006,
-0.7759650349617004,
-0.31611430644989014,
-0.1895386427640915,
-0.44118285179138184,
0.16789641976356506,
0.9055662155151367,
0.6286155581474304,
-0.8551154136657715,
-0.18524067103862762,
-0.504169225692749,
0.2860375940799713,
0.07426390796899796,
-0.24368944764137268,
0.4391874372959137,
-0.2049528807401657,
-0.679252028465271,
0.5016772747039795,
0.4041095972061157,
0.17487916350364685,
-0.11533866077661514,
-0.36085039377212524,
0.03505415841937065,
-0.0635334774851799,
0.5178913474082947,
0.8401637077331543,
-0.36268818378448486,
-0.11594782769680023,
-0.026668056845664978,
0.4651954472064972,
0.29324814677238464,
0.6143487691879272,
-0.5892107486724854,
0.5012166500091553,
0.4236675798892975,
0.8563805818557739,
0.3228379786014557,
0.22287584841251373,
0.5909301042556763,
-0.4815334975719452,
0.03796727955341339,
0.33104220032691956,
0.21462419629096985,
0.28458335995674133,
-0.6514645218849182,
0.33260786533355713,
0.10475753247737885,
-0.5253363847732544,
-1.0492699146270752,
0.1848314106464386,
-0.8277484774589539,
-0.2318468689918518,
0.9902430176734924,
0.10967329144477844,
-0.27087846398353577,
-0.0987834706902504,
-0.08598491549491882,
0.16549962759017944,
-0.894162654876709,
1.3353958129882812,
0.39100030064582825,
-0.3463119566440582,
0.16187387704849243,
-0.1644805520772934,
0.4902447462081909,
0.668346643447876,
-0.7341930270195007,
0.30454373359680176,
0.42840519547462463,
0.36524876952171326,
0.2864760160446167,
0.48669472336769104,
-0.222137451171875,
0.11139289289712906,
-0.4404140114784241,
-0.1325911581516266,
-0.2884235680103302,
-0.5757033824920654,
-0.6129302978515625,
0.14537356793880463,
0.005607729312032461,
-0.04019388183951378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05866v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05866v1
|
GeniL: A Multilingual Dataset on Generalizing Language
| 2024-04-08T20:58:06 | 2024-04-08T20:58:06 |
Aida Mostafazadeh Davani, Sagar Gubbi, Sunipa Dev, Shachi Dave, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
LLMs are increasingly transforming our digital ecosystem, but they often
inherit societal biases learned from their training data, for instance
stereotypes associating certain attributes with specific identity groups. While
whether and how these biases are mitigated may depend on the specific use
cases, being able to effectively detect instances of stereotype perpetuation is
a crucial first step. Current methods to assess presence of stereotypes in
generated language rely on simple template or co-occurrence based measures,
without accounting for the variety of sentential contexts they manifest in. We
argue that understanding the sentential context is crucial for detecting
instances of generalization. We distinguish two types of generalizations: (1)
language that merely mentions the presence of a generalization ("people think
the French are very rude"), and (2) language that reinforces such a
generalization ("as French they must be rude"), from non-generalizing context
("My French friends think I am rude"). For meaningful stereotype evaluations,
we need to reliably distinguish such instances of generalizations. We introduce
the new task of detecting generalization in language, and build GeniL, a
multilingual dataset of over 50K sentences from 9 languages (English, Arabic,
Bengali, Spanish, French, Hindi, Indonesian, Malay, and Portuguese) annotated
for instances of generalizations. We demonstrate that the likelihood of a
co-occurrence being an instance of generalization is usually low, and varies
across different languages, identity groups, and attributes. We build
classifiers to detect generalization in language with an overall PR-AUC of
58.7, with varying degrees of performance across languages. Our research
provides data and tools to enable a nuanced understanding of stereotype
perpetuation, a crucial step towards more inclusive and responsible language
technologies.
|
[
-0.48881784081459045,
-0.5718532204627991,
0.35384324193000793,
0.3873388171195984,
0.1951860636472702,
0.12876679003238678,
-0.4326186776161194,
-0.08051501214504242,
-0.007221139036118984,
0.43055060505867004,
-0.2926405370235443,
-0.8335505127906799,
-0.6284627914428711,
0.2158852219581604,
-0.29714974761009216,
0.8856814503669739,
0.07261970639228821,
0.09381334483623505,
-0.35047635436058044,
-0.46267837285995483,
-0.12226713448762894,
-0.891471803188324,
-0.5377510190010071,
-0.27178964018821716,
0.28809142112731934,
0.41066035628318787,
0.45720502734184265,
0.06384918093681335,
0.24178682267665863,
0.282710462808609,
0.07379644364118576,
-0.021718963980674744,
-0.5047008395195007,
0.3518688976764679,
0.019053207710385323,
-0.3605118691921234,
-0.2792811393737793,
0.17352278530597687,
0.6315168738365173,
0.7089194059371948,
-0.017077447846531868,
0.18659593164920807,
0.12274421751499176,
0.5357457995414734,
-0.43312886357307434,
0.16088378429412842,
-0.5176301598548889,
0.05915345251560211,
-0.28144845366477966,
-0.0019748914055526257,
-0.2001982182264328,
-0.37190577387809753,
-0.1434529423713684,
-0.4699420928955078,
0.694511353969574,
-0.2556972801685333,
0.5234004259109497,
0.04902330040931702,
-0.6443073749542236,
-0.4840824007987976,
-0.6769415736198425,
0.9382695555686951,
-0.45610228180885315,
0.643695592880249,
0.48786041140556335,
0.14793726801872253,
-0.021420592442154884,
-0.604056715965271,
-0.37753307819366455,
-0.12893597781658173,
-0.163543239235878,
0.03466401994228363,
-0.0070720878429710865,
0.039243634790182114,
0.4140465557575226,
0.34225210547447205,
-0.8217175602912903,
-0.002172141568735242,
-0.39497819542884827,
-0.452206552028656,
0.41131478548049927,
-0.28238511085510254,
0.7609706521034241,
-0.01686953566968441,
0.008105420507490635,
0.08761511743068695,
-0.8307454586029053,
-0.09732182323932648,
0.6498696804046631,
0.1658327728509903,
-0.37159377336502075,
0.22452817857265472,
-0.02615535631775856,
0.38104721903800964,
-0.00516144372522831,
0.05146545544266701,
0.6934794187545776,
-0.4273860454559326,
-0.03281322121620178,
-0.2132851630449295,
0.707371711730957,
0.32248562574386597,
1.094825267791748,
-0.19467416405677795,
-0.028604961931705475,
0.26617467403411865,
-0.12702517211437225,
-0.5701334476470947,
-0.15645574033260345,
0.025053635239601135,
-0.23745861649513245,
-0.2338530421257019,
-0.02914772555232048,
-0.8581260442733765,
-0.36185556650161743,
-0.06778255105018616,
-0.515387237071991,
-0.21863895654678345,
-0.19172179698944092,
-0.04176275059580803,
-0.15354841947555542,
0.4470893442630768,
-0.04000820219516754,
-1.0516308546066284,
0.20712126791477203,
0.5935290455818176,
0.7174580097198486,
0.2245522141456604,
-0.22202196717262268,
-0.5299695134162903,
0.2066996693611145,
-0.21921424567699432,
0.8349522352218628,
-0.8248475193977356,
-0.5283236503601074,
0.36842262744903564,
0.10770180076360703,
-0.06953982263803482,
-0.8840213418006897,
0.606499969959259,
-0.35400840640068054,
0.39078488945961,
-0.23272380232810974,
-0.44842174649238586,
-0.022776979953050613,
0.29104748368263245,
-0.6080048680305481,
0.8967982530593872,
0.1601424366235733,
-0.7697948217391968,
0.8448350429534912,
-0.48335108160972595,
-0.5404529571533203,
0.1266808807849884,
-0.587451696395874,
-0.44648149609565735,
0.15287600457668304,
0.5278189182281494,
0.31827089190483093,
-0.13069424033164978,
0.4747207760810852,
-0.4709867835044861,
-0.1368037909269333,
-0.08165091276168823,
-0.2900896966457367,
0.7442038059234619,
0.2455277442932129,
-0.18753990530967712,
-0.20171025395393372,
-0.45907580852508545,
-0.23014657199382782,
-0.03562857583165169,
-0.2631765902042389,
-0.6706451177597046,
-0.05921488255262375,
-0.04743385314941406,
0.18698889017105103,
0.02403191663324833,
-0.5273250937461853,
0.14080384373664856,
-0.38020431995391846,
0.22112005949020386,
0.7182824611663818,
-0.06549737602472305,
0.5882028937339783,
-0.14485138654708862,
0.6921614408493042,
0.08861450850963593,
0.251153826713562,
0.027701538056135178,
-0.6085451245307922,
-0.565727949142456,
-0.3058640956878662,
0.021423202008008957,
0.4725867807865143,
-0.6422261595726013,
0.19888392090797424,
-0.3471086621284485,
0.16275328397750854,
-0.38034263253211975,
0.6170766949653625,
0.24722550809383392,
0.17080889642238617,
0.06081158295273781,
-0.18997342884540558,
-0.6942581534385681,
-1.214210033416748,
-0.3184358775615692,
-0.21599748730659485,
-0.3081020712852478,
0.3153572976589203,
0.31753087043762207,
-0.34408843517303467,
1.0263283252716064,
-0.07633685320615768,
-0.19897975027561188,
-0.37227943539619446,
0.29670536518096924,
0.16886447370052338,
0.15029525756835938,
0.9378940463066101,
-0.7980598211288452,
-0.49019166827201843,
-0.03521272912621498,
-1.2946990728378296,
-0.5038442015647888,
0.09786593914031982,
0.3552441895008087,
0.0004935413016937673,
0.6811559200286865,
0.14100727438926697,
0.010374444536864758,
0.6883934140205383,
-0.293231338262558,
0.36327728629112244,
-0.09363880008459091,
0.23906882107257843,
-0.9702079892158508,
-0.09243892878293991,
0.32930323481559753,
-0.08312047272920609,
-0.8473573327064514,
-0.04281844571232796,
-0.14999179542064667,
-0.04110104590654373,
-0.3473075032234192,
0.7005266547203064,
-0.5049080848693848,
0.033101342618465424,
0.22647225856781006,
0.00686999037861824,
-0.17248915135860443,
0.18468077480793,
-0.12167606502771378,
1.0221022367477417,
0.4898182451725006,
-0.4518512487411499,
0.2511416971683502,
0.0725296139717102,
-0.4532094895839691,
0.668536901473999,
-0.5937750339508057,
0.3133123815059662,
-0.5480949878692627,
0.06202254444360733,
-0.9717118144035339,
-0.11316627264022827,
0.3377639651298523,
-0.45472362637519836,
0.07326484471559525,
-0.2943395972251892,
-0.47880327701568604,
-0.3833605647087097,
-0.35769227147102356,
0.669943630695343,
0.3300345540046692,
-0.3867749273777008,
0.3909093141555786,
0.38328737020492554,
-0.2839151918888092,
-0.6579655408859253,
-0.7376881837844849,
0.1971198320388794,
-0.4774869680404663,
-0.7693246006965637,
-0.3061853349208832,
-0.144024059176445,
-0.6697496175765991,
-0.44212982058525085,
0.16063861548900604,
-0.11797402054071426,
0.16491039097309113,
0.13822193443775177,
-0.13294753432273865,
-0.034138310700654984,
0.22090113162994385,
0.12832050025463104,
0.06386508047580719,
0.014166359789669514,
-0.3710280954837799,
0.7028139233589172,
-0.23993034660816193,
-0.24741943180561066,
-0.007327327039092779,
0.34548163414001465,
0.5904055833816528,
0.010045546106994152,
0.5439513325691223,
0.5555714964866638,
-0.1428253948688507,
-0.098141148686409,
-0.7097650766372681,
-0.1436152458190918,
-0.4430028796195984,
0.32365426421165466,
-0.6291332244873047,
-0.8320168852806091,
0.8046131730079651,
0.09312409162521362,
-0.009202892892062664,
0.2120947390794754,
0.5279625654220581,
-0.06400716304779053,
0.8185579180717468,
0.6676096320152283,
-0.4443703591823578,
0.29783788323402405,
-0.23734936118125916,
0.24650408327579498,
-0.5447005033493042,
-0.0690319761633873,
-0.45368239283561707,
-0.11716614663600922,
-0.8193000555038452,
-0.3847063183784485,
0.38517236709594727,
-0.21061427891254425,
-0.13227558135986328,
-0.029127027839422226,
-0.15009136497974396,
0.4972861409187317,
0.26342758536338806,
-0.2511099874973297,
0.4256831407546997,
0.40739527344703674,
-0.33084654808044434,
-0.17025864124298096,
-0.6069487929344177,
-0.6746405363082886,
1.3341054916381836,
0.36251771450042725,
0.7129182815551758,
0.06521967798471451,
0.724658727645874,
0.7267822027206421,
0.7167288064956665,
-0.5210724472999573,
0.4485051929950714,
-0.5150601267814636,
-0.6206514835357666,
-0.07027481496334076,
-0.47654640674591064,
-0.9348356127738953,
0.1917281299829483,
0.22199104726314545,
-0.6001571416854858,
0.44672131538391113,
0.23892097175121307,
0.1019873172044754,
0.1352943778038025,
-0.630102813243866,
0.650886595249176,
-0.12333454191684723,
-0.2325066328048706,
0.0215030238032341,
-0.3387376368045807,
0.6020315885543823,
-0.03971119970083237,
0.8036189079284668,
-0.09631822258234024,
0.12867207825183868,
0.6958290934562683,
0.019662700593471527,
0.9313321113586426,
-0.20084813237190247,
-0.5149308443069458,
0.013922858983278275,
-0.09134051203727722,
0.22334174811840057,
0.050884246826171875,
-0.08962590992450714,
0.3058113157749176,
-0.3493843972682953,
-0.5866658687591553,
-0.6529478430747986,
0.6402036547660828,
-0.7680142521858215,
-0.4438459277153015,
-0.19187816977500916,
-0.4890906512737274,
-0.27731308341026306,
-0.20948155224323273,
0.5820622444152832,
0.30241382122039795,
-0.6743212342262268,
-0.18142889440059662,
0.7545439600944519,
-0.5317093729972839,
0.059959035366773605,
0.24450597167015076,
-0.3520786464214325,
-0.34939590096473694,
0.9141182899475098,
0.0057520512491464615,
0.22326380014419556,
0.06385979056358337,
0.08928953111171722,
-0.2195044755935669,
-0.27734583616256714,
-0.36815670132637024,
0.49809250235557556,
-0.7076786160469055,
0.36043381690979004,
-0.6726483106613159,
-0.0016076293541118503,
-0.8125404715538025,
-0.2902410924434662,
0.01669900119304657,
-0.11608714610338211,
0.04118703678250313,
-0.11178615689277649,
-0.17524154484272003,
0.8077975511550903,
-0.19886121153831482,
0.30313780903816223,
-0.3955763280391693,
0.18623432517051697,
0.4572702646255493,
0.2033427506685257,
-0.2854386866092682,
-0.5698083639144897,
0.06905990093946457,
0.055847425013780594,
0.16591420769691467,
-0.6224299669265747,
0.352285236120224,
0.42052727937698364,
0.8229948878288269,
0.7003912925720215,
-0.2812475562095642,
-0.02954956889152527,
-0.25946393609046936,
0.6477272510528564,
0.08509986847639084,
-0.612677812576294,
0.43890026211738586,
-0.4723416566848755,
0.19128316640853882,
0.4676539897918701,
0.5042806267738342,
-1.17642343044281,
-0.7757168412208557,
-0.5912632942199707,
-0.6735270023345947,
0.2856319546699524,
0.09364914149045944,
0.41700688004493713,
-0.34133270382881165,
0.1624627709388733,
0.08947572857141495,
0.28317856788635254,
-0.8240402340888977,
-0.3993331789970398,
-0.23161596059799194,
-0.1218332052230835,
-0.404218852519989,
-0.593462347984314,
-0.15954333543777466,
-0.1638227254152298,
0.36692386865615845,
-0.1413598656654358,
0.1544249802827835,
-0.1441107988357544,
-0.537672758102417,
0.24305938184261322,
0.6392828226089478,
0.5659626126289368,
0.568878173828125,
-0.19464585185050964,
0.44202062487602234,
-0.06364384293556213,
-0.5057927966117859,
0.4303203821182251,
-0.03229469433426857,
-0.39378684759140015,
0.14505931735038757,
0.444186270236969,
0.399708092212677,
-0.08918594568967819,
-0.42313987016677856,
0.5629647970199585,
-0.04569755494594574,
-0.30989477038383484,
-0.35430458188056946,
-0.35501328110694885,
-0.132951021194458,
-0.08095841109752655,
0.10820422321557999,
-0.259614497423172,
0.24181897938251495,
-0.7642293572425842,
0.483964204788208,
0.4916072189807892,
-0.2479260265827179,
-0.5938302278518677,
0.36302629113197327,
0.5260659456253052,
0.042060736566782,
0.7499515414237976,
-0.38616862893104553,
-0.6581038236618042,
0.6689639687538147,
0.33156755566596985,
1.1037700176239014,
-0.5193728804588318,
0.6355859041213989,
0.3094138205051422,
0.6255052089691162,
0.23865164816379547,
0.23735235631465912,
-0.03857965022325516,
-1.3370782136917114,
-0.1836901307106018,
-0.6361855864524841,
0.05527915433049202,
0.2308165431022644,
-0.40072101354599,
0.05557342246174812,
-0.4290420413017273,
-0.07175281643867493,
-0.09237851947546005,
-0.45723769068717957,
-0.8359740972518921,
-0.058878667652606964,
0.344610333442688,
0.5060777068138123,
-1.5573450326919556,
0.6608892679214478,
0.8642411828041077,
-0.32375863194465637,
-0.04511696472764015,
0.19903188943862915,
0.24805989861488342,
-0.9886549711227417,
1.012447714805603,
0.13334977626800537,
-0.00020091891929041594,
-0.17933689057826996,
-0.5176292657852173,
-0.43389472365379333,
0.428813636302948,
0.32901328802108765,
-0.508722722530365,
0.10722637921571732,
0.42049840092658997,
0.5990750193595886,
-0.36932459473609924,
0.30892086029052734,
0.7896628975868225,
0.7353285551071167,
-0.10741560906171799,
-0.7051573395729065,
-0.17005912959575653,
-0.23194877803325653,
0.08769531548023224,
0.05591344088315964,
-0.3726043999195099,
0.6502082943916321,
-0.08050404489040375,
-0.43183180689811707,
-0.25042521953582764,
0.3299567997455597,
-0.041158225387334824,
0.40391871333122253,
0.3941372036933899,
0.5437732934951782,
0.8958728909492493,
-0.023872224614024162,
0.9103096127510071,
-0.22159916162490845,
0.24548861384391785,
1.014613389968872,
-0.28755584359169006,
-0.03064291924238205,
0.39324864745140076,
-0.21470816433429718,
0.5475043058395386,
0.3714832365512848,
0.06246242672204971,
0.2724986672401428,
0.5156880617141724,
-0.6764732003211975,
-0.2012130320072174,
-0.2818893790245056,
-0.3073384761810303,
0.31704890727996826,
0.5494566559791565,
-0.5259603261947632,
-0.48807957768440247,
0.4770539700984955,
0.17824040353298187,
0.3021242916584015,
-0.0826038122177124,
0.6747865080833435,
0.02347380295395851,
-0.3215150833129883,
0.5542103052139282,
-0.3265722393989563,
0.8728247880935669,
-0.4531564712524414,
0.21857674419879913,
-0.7619839310646057,
0.06685801595449448,
-0.21956433355808258,
-0.5034540891647339,
0.23243297636508942,
-0.061993613839149475,
-0.4174918830394745,
-0.2260177880525589,
0.6341100335121155,
-0.5783693194389343,
-0.5934668183326721,
0.4601251184940338,
0.8729850649833679,
0.3618583381175995,
0.005481885280460119,
-0.4846811890602112,
-0.09694414585828781,
0.17729124426841736,
-0.022509587928652763,
0.2427992820739746,
0.35767099261283875,
-0.35867977142333984,
0.6842615604400635,
0.24058672785758972,
0.17399322986602783,
0.1927775889635086,
0.748298704624176,
0.5951133966445923,
-0.2629292607307434,
-0.10553787648677826,
-0.8601374626159668,
0.10514179617166519,
-0.24805711209774017,
-0.16821633279323578,
0.7585672736167908,
0.6931220293045044,
0.9331761598587036,
-0.08319088816642761,
1.3780745267868042,
-0.003041924675926566,
0.20522327721118927,
-0.27704811096191406,
0.3521295189857483,
-0.49728506803512573,
0.3678790032863617,
-0.2036331593990326,
-0.9401602745056152,
-0.48639652132987976,
0.572898805141449,
-0.766645073890686,
0.20176775753498077,
0.49384504556655884,
0.9586494565010071,
-0.20213891565799713,
-0.18710897862911224,
0.5701910257339478,
0.2459477037191391,
0.4753945767879486,
0.19811026751995087,
0.8510904908180237,
-0.07807527482509613,
0.4082576036453247,
0.09928956627845764,
-0.4818171262741089,
0.1879134625196457,
-0.5461595058441162,
-0.9287518858909607,
-0.5174274444580078,
-0.22826771438121796,
-0.15684957802295685,
0.34179553389549255,
0.6756458282470703,
0.48557376861572266,
-1.0867819786071777,
-0.6028004288673401,
0.007296208757907152,
0.30591416358947754,
0.08908405900001526,
-0.2466784417629242,
-0.07296300679445267,
-0.7429097890853882,
-0.9435836672782898,
0.21107645332813263,
0.33731308579444885,
0.004597875755280256,
-0.27619409561157227,
-0.0485607385635376,
-0.2413424551486969,
-0.0959475040435791,
0.6882667541503906,
0.4134345054626465,
-0.5050477981567383,
-0.3598005175590515,
-0.13806933164596558,
0.022287672385573387,
0.09189232438802719,
1.2212225198745728,
-0.6006917953491211,
0.5809335112571716,
0.43439996242523193,
0.2613271474838257,
0.17322491109371185,
-0.050489187240600586,
0.9648336172103882,
-1.2660160064697266,
0.29444169998168945,
0.14390820264816284,
0.39025530219078064,
0.6098933815956116,
-0.10072914510965347,
0.6441073417663574,
0.6655822992324829,
-0.48944178223609924,
-0.46665748953819275,
0.49829956889152527,
-0.33377882838249207,
-0.23187917470932007,
1.3002957105636597,
-0.0548076368868351,
0.08250590413808823,
-0.5726159811019897,
0.08179669082164764,
0.08159491419792175,
-0.5140180587768555,
0.7080848813056946,
0.8606107234954834,
0.15124236047267914,
-0.16935402154922485,
-0.6035037040710449,
0.5795013308525085,
0.3332849144935608,
-0.5951692461967468,
0.20096595585346222,
0.6146698594093323,
0.5660691261291504,
0.15918628871440887,
0.7645748853683472,
-0.0010727675398811698,
-0.04511534795165062,
-0.2826560139656067,
0.31481289863586426,
0.32420769333839417,
-0.17992520332336426,
-0.42775025963783264,
0.08295103907585144,
-0.07434974610805511,
-0.18385259807109833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05843v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05843v2
|
Softmax Attention with Constant Cost per Token
| 2024-04-08T20:14:10 | 2024-04-27T19:03:14 |
Franz A. Heinsen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We propose a simple modification to the conventional attention mechanism
applied by Transformers: Instead of quantifying pairwise query-key similarity
with scaled dot-products, we quantify it with the logarithms of scaled
dot-products of exponentials. Our modification linearizes attention with
exponential kernel feature maps, whose corresponding feature function is
infinite dimensional. We show that our modification is expressible as a
composition of log-sums of exponentials, with a latent space of constant size,
enabling application with constant time and space complexity per token. We
implement our modification, verify that it works in practice, and conclude that
it is a promising alternative to conventional attention.
|
[
-0.25437450408935547,
-0.836310625076294,
0.4031895697116852,
0.3221040964126587,
-0.17020179331302643,
-0.326447069644928,
-0.4350230395793915,
-0.39493390917778015,
0.5712355971336365,
0.4552318751811981,
-0.5997368097305298,
-0.19402866065502167,
-0.24707767367362976,
-0.09335041791200638,
-0.3449464738368988,
1.0378882884979248,
0.009764308109879494,
-0.44287797808647156,
-0.11942771077156067,
-0.7401701807975769,
-0.0010809331433847547,
-0.5233075022697449,
-0.8600992560386658,
0.2496335804462433,
1.0940083265304565,
0.3201936185359955,
1.0563687086105347,
0.6498796343803406,
0.8165141344070435,
0.3265235126018524,
-0.2691831886768341,
-0.00676555885002017,
-0.7416141629219055,
0.032809194177389145,
-0.041295573115348816,
-0.5965697765350342,
-0.9934098124504089,
0.10984714329242706,
0.8086429238319397,
1.0629253387451172,
0.22572806477546692,
0.5729525089263916,
0.22047755122184753,
0.7659521102905273,
-0.6106219291687012,
-0.0338103324174881,
-0.6929494738578796,
0.4810596704483032,
0.22764617204666138,
-0.3132605254650116,
-0.29502055048942566,
-0.17371512949466705,
0.05105315521359444,
-0.8272998332977295,
0.6372541189193726,
-0.07550100237131119,
0.6027452945709229,
0.652483344078064,
-0.6569452881813049,
-0.059449441730976105,
-0.8489766716957092,
0.9999483823776245,
-0.23888367414474487,
0.4738907814025879,
-0.019121350720524788,
0.029101397842168808,
0.2169593721628189,
-1.050516963005066,
-0.4796060025691986,
-0.2541488707065582,
-0.11940363794565201,
0.013670961372554302,
-0.02076900005340576,
0.1662619560956955,
0.544196605682373,
0.4633428454399109,
-0.3996841311454773,
-0.19613716006278992,
-0.15466360747814178,
-0.22013528645038605,
0.5686060190200806,
0.5050801038742065,
0.10345820337533951,
0.3895314037799835,
-0.7333894371986389,
-0.024667983874678612,
-0.7529085278511047,
0.1390061229467392,
0.09189856052398682,
0.08494503796100616,
0.11184153705835342,
0.35363343358039856,
-0.08028281480073929,
0.6386147737503052,
0.5510531067848206,
-0.054172541946172714,
0.28920865058898926,
-0.4233986437320709,
-0.31640464067459106,
0.030560661107301712,
0.18629726767539978,
0.5587447881698608,
0.1904999166727066,
-0.3159962594509125,
-0.2555510401725769,
0.0531197115778923,
0.32126522064208984,
-0.787354052066803,
0.3002176582813263,
0.42330169677734375,
-0.6064218282699585,
-0.22879905998706818,
-0.2694556415081024,
-0.6143671870231628,
0.11208032816648483,
-0.40244510769844055,
0.7298114895820618,
-0.01867241971194744,
-0.16539143025875092,
0.2068970799446106,
0.07978687435388565,
0.5172374248504639,
0.012708277441561222,
-0.917253851890564,
0.4910773038864136,
0.7671215534210205,
0.8859739303588867,
-0.19943268597126007,
-0.02052474208176136,
-0.7254102230072021,
0.03633098304271698,
-0.33994796872138977,
0.7520943284034729,
-0.46615973114967346,
-0.3382333219051361,
0.029763925820589066,
0.0038252335507422686,
-0.09729428589344025,
-0.6135890483856201,
0.4759094715118408,
-0.5074433088302612,
0.10122041404247284,
0.13133405148983002,
-0.32220950722694397,
0.012273037806153297,
0.14662882685661316,
-0.7571719288825989,
0.9641634821891785,
0.5064099431037903,
-0.3689511716365814,
0.5330857038497925,
-0.7877056002616882,
-0.6381556987762451,
0.36945363879203796,
0.2891239821910858,
-0.7234004139900208,
0.22822488844394684,
0.15848378837108612,
0.2813444137573242,
0.2470957338809967,
-0.09597836434841156,
-0.4432596266269684,
-0.5982871651649475,
0.388362318277359,
-0.3051184415817261,
0.6462818384170532,
0.253325492143631,
-0.6541681289672852,
0.3325698971748352,
-0.8050047159194946,
0.12239967286586761,
0.22526006400585175,
-0.20361730456352234,
-0.22375787794589996,
-0.06786041706800461,
0.2617207169532776,
-0.05376742407679558,
0.5474045276641846,
-0.3140871524810791,
0.4881851077079773,
-0.6584981083869934,
0.5245622992515564,
0.8101322054862976,
0.02643168717622757,
0.8837949633598328,
0.1475878357887268,
0.5371284484863281,
-0.10215155780315399,
0.9852825403213501,
-0.3750111758708954,
-0.1961243748664856,
-1.1066598892211914,
-0.5384086966514587,
0.3277282416820526,
0.0794152095913887,
-0.07702957093715668,
0.33366450667381287,
-0.3670332729816437,
-0.10349690914154053,
-0.4013470411300659,
0.3473256528377533,
0.10418607294559479,
0.31651827692985535,
0.2143472135066986,
-0.5828902721405029,
-0.24203306436538696,
-1.073717474937439,
-0.3128884434700012,
0.15715986490249634,
-0.3737325668334961,
0.6413606405258179,
0.09936751425266266,
-0.26445499062538147,
0.8836625814437866,
-0.680304229259491,
-0.6941287517547607,
0.03728019446134567,
-0.11466797441244125,
0.6141126155853271,
0.3191797733306885,
0.772370457649231,
-1.1601909399032593,
-0.8212623596191406,
-0.174148291349411,
-0.2760794162750244,
0.09654239565134048,
-0.3052845001220703,
0.15634861588478088,
0.1454390436410904,
0.6406888365745544,
-0.7543169856071472,
0.47009822726249695,
0.21121414005756378,
-0.7351829409599304,
0.033484507352113724,
-0.1866081804037094,
-0.02173163928091526,
-0.572039783000946,
0.2723982632160187,
-0.0052370172925293446,
-0.3814404010772705,
-0.6336263418197632,
0.488308310508728,
0.26700088381767273,
-0.41157066822052,
-0.6761683225631714,
0.518900454044342,
-0.41073042154312134,
-0.04321727901697159,
-0.11258621513843536,
0.21378585696220398,
-0.19441361725330353,
1.0603997707366943,
-0.4077906906604767,
0.7092135548591614,
0.38127392530441284,
-0.6555045247077942,
0.4775625765323639,
0.06428806483745575,
0.14040507376194,
0.7874345779418945,
-1.0359169244766235,
0.5188060402870178,
-0.25546109676361084,
0.3731190264225006,
-1.2764334678649902,
0.05431108549237251,
0.00315149687230587,
-0.3548937439918518,
0.41374728083610535,
-0.07470487058162689,
-0.5952823162078857,
-0.38928404450416565,
-0.8253198266029358,
0.45415639877319336,
0.6098034381866455,
-0.3922366201877594,
0.8550045490264893,
0.0601700060069561,
-0.16836409270763397,
-0.28095054626464844,
-0.6582576632499695,
0.18612244725227356,
-0.3724585175514221,
-0.7023180723190308,
0.3433082699775696,
-0.2845676839351654,
-0.027844998985528946,
0.26651531457901,
-0.2680552005767822,
0.15887241065502167,
0.06311330199241638,
0.28454601764678955,
0.12727755308151245,
-0.4569180905818939,
0.25335243344306946,
-0.15592439472675323,
-0.4200798571109772,
-0.11605142802000046,
-0.6588485240936279,
0.2160032093524933,
-0.09106386452913284,
-0.1803002655506134,
-0.1288049966096878,
0.5847241282463074,
0.8488151431083679,
-0.12551449239253998,
0.45074760913848877,
0.8644322752952576,
-0.22828033566474915,
-0.11420456320047379,
-0.6287778615951538,
-0.4431283473968506,
-0.6042388677597046,
0.3194025754928589,
-0.34644806385040283,
-1.1616201400756836,
0.5625340342521667,
-0.058362167328596115,
0.0963301956653595,
0.6436254382133484,
0.592886745929718,
0.06004650890827179,
1.414273977279663,
0.8950220942497253,
-0.09482891857624054,
0.480949729681015,
-0.22511936724185944,
0.45904919505119324,
-0.8153454065322876,
-0.1058804914355278,
-0.42612162232398987,
-0.9713770747184753,
-0.5555270910263062,
-0.12239952385425568,
0.6544347405433655,
-0.3683897852897644,
-0.30312663316726685,
0.26188793778419495,
-0.839644730091095,
0.39495670795440674,
0.5234633684158325,
0.23159576952457428,
-0.06680599600076675,
-0.0016226526349782944,
0.14624124765396118,
-0.3512389063835144,
-0.9199642539024353,
0.06630101799964905,
1.2827067375183105,
0.35406067967414856,
0.5560886859893799,
-0.005087575875222683,
0.11016184091567993,
0.4065603017807007,
0.5010504722595215,
-0.7721680402755737,
0.6167615652084351,
-0.07177489250898361,
-0.6208171844482422,
-0.5153202414512634,
-0.3201392590999603,
-1.1706353425979614,
0.09399046748876572,
-0.05839862674474716,
-0.6424568891525269,
0.30667608976364136,
0.3431202173233032,
-0.4438309967517853,
0.0064618512988090515,
-1.123918056488037,
0.7107192873954773,
-0.14811067283153534,
-0.64544677734375,
-0.48110562562942505,
-0.48557084798812866,
-0.172647163271904,
-0.20347753167152405,
0.010035715065896511,
0.14900602400302887,
-0.7000885605812073,
0.7074401378631592,
-0.4200761914253235,
0.9520073533058167,
-0.1599777787923813,
-0.040097229182720184,
0.20955367386341095,
-0.0028345633763819933,
0.7289495468139648,
0.17381033301353455,
0.4224315583705902,
-0.3041815459728241,
-0.6390820741653442,
-0.7481802701950073,
-0.845544159412384,
0.882535994052887,
-0.4228765070438385,
-0.813249945640564,
0.015418795868754387,
-0.6782845258712769,
-0.148196741938591,
0.009538967162370682,
-0.13310283422470093,
0.61283278465271,
0.2078559249639511,
0.6264371275901794,
0.9826318621635437,
0.06361661851406097,
0.48956236243247986,
0.5153530836105347,
0.09459191560745239,
-0.2630760669708252,
0.7776474952697754,
0.10880247503519058,
0.06397980451583862,
0.38733431696891785,
0.16695472598075867,
-0.4439852237701416,
-0.0010648202151060104,
0.04175901040434837,
0.04004184529185295,
-0.5139669179916382,
-0.19053159654140472,
-0.8322146534919739,
-0.05250149592757225,
-0.4608798921108246,
-0.399264395236969,
-0.401540070772171,
-0.6859346628189087,
-0.13709761202335358,
-0.03404828533530235,
0.6844227313995361,
0.20578400790691376,
-0.3022052049636841,
0.010013521648943424,
-0.5057938098907471,
0.5495049953460693,
1.0700421333312988,
0.6775172352790833,
0.07610512524843216,
-0.7110403776168823,
-0.3366268277168274,
-0.3005743622779846,
-0.33746615052223206,
-0.4141896069049835,
0.13138143718242645,
0.5549271106719971,
0.4777574837207794,
0.5238229632377625,
-0.04774344339966774,
0.41953837871551514,
-0.5924620032310486,
0.861985445022583,
0.49630454182624817,
-0.9010820984840393,
0.3529731333255768,
-0.09143679589033127,
0.4511711895465851,
0.08514563739299774,
0.20425041019916534,
-0.3703400194644928,
-0.4769468605518341,
-0.9029970169067383,
-1.2111315727233887,
0.4559899568557739,
0.2832772433757782,
0.7059884667396545,
0.2331969290971756,
0.4007813632488251,
-0.20828990638256073,
-0.10855165123939514,
-0.5183378458023071,
-0.5151946544647217,
-0.12336825579404831,
-0.33101439476013184,
-0.13350456953048706,
-0.6494280695915222,
-0.07274644821882248,
-0.3149893581867218,
0.1877070665359497,
-0.11687734723091125,
0.4796692728996277,
0.5084192156791687,
-0.007377429399639368,
-0.32299742102622986,
0.15008673071861267,
0.800492525100708,
0.5862519145011902,
-0.3069145381450653,
0.3205610513687134,
0.4823046624660492,
-0.5973706841468811,
0.10364688187837601,
-0.15920856595039368,
-0.06700774282217026,
0.11520249396562576,
0.18159283697605133,
0.5994094610214233,
0.596383810043335,
-0.37910592555999756,
0.5474663972854614,
0.12321112304925919,
-0.4603618383407593,
-0.15896688401699066,
0.06498880684375763,
0.050615545362234116,
0.31653663516044617,
0.8038131594657898,
-0.11233294010162354,
0.4407822787761688,
-0.4293833374977112,
0.40410372614860535,
0.2923797070980072,
-0.932296872138977,
-0.3490607440471649,
1.204131007194519,
0.3392362594604492,
-0.7438713312149048,
0.23418530821800232,
0.15202772617340088,
-0.6584402918815613,
0.9216926693916321,
0.3462282419204712,
0.9410256147384644,
-0.3228267729282379,
-0.07890653610229492,
0.3146912157535553,
0.41798830032348633,
0.4462972581386566,
0.013177677057683468,
-0.3998277187347412,
-0.18415845930576324,
-0.6090595722198486,
-0.1985207349061966,
-0.15487982332706451,
0.13959386944770813,
-0.34666332602500916,
0.12048844993114471,
-0.560135543346405,
-0.3675885498523712,
0.18381209671497345,
-0.1105121374130249,
-1.0102131366729736,
0.3256520628929138,
-0.0009187484974972904,
0.66098952293396,
-0.42860445380210876,
0.40400615334510803,
0.5426896214485168,
-0.2813990116119385,
-0.4291079342365265,
-0.08497917652130127,
-0.3132200539112091,
-0.7680927515029907,
0.7216116189956665,
0.09084172546863556,
-0.04214516282081604,
0.08461160212755203,
-1.0324491262435913,
-0.7826308012008667,
0.8369066715240479,
0.18738599121570587,
-0.6071851253509521,
0.263425350189209,
0.12574200332164764,
0.6741438508033752,
-0.25960493087768555,
0.005831500049680471,
0.1752103716135025,
0.4360724091529846,
-0.2898866832256317,
-0.5431115031242371,
0.08376789838075638,
-0.197419673204422,
0.013139528222382069,
0.2606753408908844,
-1.0206855535507202,
0.5490058660507202,
-0.18116740882396698,
-0.3813883364200592,
-0.34538641571998596,
0.593356192111969,
-0.35843417048454285,
0.35266754031181335,
0.9155416488647461,
0.5943471789360046,
0.005239646881818771,
0.1237836703658104,
0.9186389446258545,
-0.37719738483428955,
0.8596637845039368,
0.5956175923347473,
-0.20512980222702026,
0.462501585483551,
0.8328936100006104,
-0.49947234988212585,
0.04115651920437813,
0.23032830655574799,
-0.046938929706811905,
0.5113954544067383,
0.23895178735256195,
-0.25015100836753845,
-0.17521502077579498,
-0.1826646625995636,
-0.3086903393268585,
-0.13390693068504333,
0.40301451086997986,
-0.32972219586372375,
-0.015498998574912548,
-0.026175782084465027,
-0.2848305404186249,
0.07530376315116882,
-0.48520371317863464,
0.7613776922225952,
0.15379448235034943,
-0.3284740149974823,
0.7777503728866577,
-0.2799176573753357,
0.7243583798408508,
-0.5495944619178772,
0.04030871391296387,
-0.5975189208984375,
0.45472925901412964,
-0.11071787029504776,
-0.5952644944190979,
0.3147070109844208,
-0.10295553505420685,
-0.11193272471427917,
-0.31110987067222595,
0.6518793702125549,
-0.35799506306648254,
-0.5168478488922119,
0.14263242483139038,
-0.2125885784626007,
-0.29234588146209717,
-0.17362824082374573,
-0.6722074151039124,
-0.03892917558550835,
-0.05888671427965164,
-0.6535536050796509,
0.2670172452926636,
0.406800776720047,
0.2734505236148834,
0.7378615736961365,
0.6495187878608704,
-0.2437567561864853,
0.14490285515785217,
-0.01268129050731659,
0.7376179099082947,
-0.6963911056518555,
-0.7144959568977356,
-0.5523384213447571,
0.3453387916088104,
-0.14023302495479584,
-0.4356374740600586,
0.5226984620094299,
0.49676358699798584,
0.47281861305236816,
-0.28010064363479614,
0.30595284700393677,
0.30728936195373535,
0.2558952569961548,
-0.23762758076190948,
0.44793587923049927,
-1.0476932525634766,
-0.22522833943367004,
0.026249656453728676,
-1.4478551149368286,
-0.5512402057647705,
0.19290311634540558,
0.24610741436481476,
-0.2015790045261383,
0.9048703908920288,
0.8086704611778259,
-0.36575421690940857,
-0.5653603076934814,
0.513778567314148,
0.25073865056037903,
-0.0380452498793602,
0.9564682841300964,
0.3104614317417145,
-0.3478517234325409,
0.9635074734687805,
0.10599876195192337,
-0.2978418469429016,
-0.610579788684845,
-0.6080368757247925,
-0.6396597623825073,
-0.6259687542915344,
-0.5773635506629944,
-0.2002241462469101,
-0.03614531084895134,
0.4558953642845154,
0.7409044504165649,
-0.641111433506012,
0.45106634497642517,
0.17660266160964966,
0.06913848966360092,
-0.46916577219963074,
-0.24762608110904694,
0.7561240792274475,
-0.584954559803009,
-0.756459653377533,
-0.1232791617512703,
0.8364773988723755,
-0.13102920353412628,
-0.3685416579246521,
0.1750534623861313,
0.374237984418869,
0.4029342532157898,
0.8810253739356995,
0.25567954778671265,
-0.5111458897590637,
-0.522429883480072,
0.3949022591114044,
-0.3945406973361969,
0.22748912870883942,
1.177428126335144,
-0.5709637999534607,
0.41040295362472534,
0.3164384067058563,
0.5975669622421265,
0.9118518829345703,
-0.3771657645702362,
0.34705010056495667,
-0.9503886699676514,
0.8972119688987732,
0.20032192766666412,
0.18574848771095276,
0.18081378936767578,
-0.659022867679596,
0.656140923500061,
0.2654689848423004,
-0.42246025800704956,
-0.6159502267837524,
0.26003363728523254,
-1.402382493019104,
-0.05727158486843109,
1.1103655099868774,
-0.00817284919321537,
-0.5805131793022156,
-0.11220508068799973,
-0.30235669016838074,
-0.1622179001569748,
-0.2782330811023712,
0.8251664638519287,
0.2045176774263382,
0.3576117157936096,
-0.043607570230960846,
-0.1599113494157791,
0.28273987770080566,
0.7590039968490601,
-0.13078324496746063,
-0.2388969361782074,
0.07133848965167999,
0.19962535798549652,
0.2549411654472351,
0.49617984890937805,
-0.31445226073265076,
0.4567054808139801,
0.1422746330499649,
-0.05085260793566704,
0.23485930263996124,
-0.026921221986413002,
-0.32052725553512573,
0.49530813097953796,
-0.17906993627548218,
-0.33125394582748413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05839v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05839v2
|
ÚFAL LatinPipe at EvaLatin 2024: Morphosyntactic Analysis of Latin
| 2024-04-08T20:05:25 | 2024-05-29T16:37:39 |
Milan Straka, Jana Straková, Federica Gamba
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present LatinPipe, the winning submission to the EvaLatin 2024 Dependency
Parsing shared task. Our system consists of a fine-tuned concatenation of base
and large pre-trained LMs, with a dot-product attention head for parsing and
softmax classification heads for morphology to jointly learn both dependency
parsing and morphological analysis. It is trained by sampling from seven
publicly available Latin corpora, utilizing additional harmonization of
annotations to achieve a more unified annotation style. Before fine-tuning, we
train the system for a few initial epochs with frozen weights. We also add
additional local relative contextualization by stacking the BiLSTM layers on
top of the Transformer(s). Finally, we ensemble output probability
distributions from seven randomly instantiated networks for the final
submission. The code is available at
https://github.com/ufal/evalatin2024-latinpipe.
|
[
-0.34414181113243103,
-0.15267817676067352,
0.38186267018318176,
0.4834073781967163,
-0.34880396723747253,
0.3484540283679962,
-0.053671762347221375,
-0.4951697587966919,
0.4982503652572632,
0.6243401169776917,
-0.3803498446941376,
-0.6355108618736267,
-0.40091270208358765,
0.46163830161094666,
-0.31707778573036194,
0.8683926463127136,
-0.1045786589384079,
0.34132203459739685,
-0.31410565972328186,
-0.16658057272434235,
-0.3339248299598694,
-0.5229567885398865,
-0.47301721572875977,
-0.3487119674682617,
0.7139118313789368,
0.32888126373291016,
0.16510017216205597,
0.5762885212898254,
0.3434693217277527,
0.3880305886268616,
-0.03547133132815361,
0.057905398309230804,
-0.14192059636116028,
0.5528991222381592,
-0.44654345512390137,
-0.3681662082672119,
-0.5144118070602417,
-0.42947205901145935,
0.6291323900222778,
0.9393803477287292,
0.13739453256130219,
0.06333409994840622,
0.1422155648469925,
0.53956538438797,
-0.5832832455635071,
0.2335161715745926,
-0.9140918850898743,
-0.0010473732836544514,
-0.5978795886039734,
-0.3883245885372162,
-0.5564182996749878,
0.2664959728717804,
-0.054445091634988785,
-0.23541085422039032,
0.1601869761943817,
0.002885476453229785,
0.6837995052337646,
0.43774962425231934,
-0.2997010350227356,
-0.002812725491821766,
-0.6402612924575806,
0.5763625502586365,
-0.1851525604724884,
0.4886266589164734,
-0.00844228733330965,
-0.04399150237441063,
-0.12965551018714905,
-1.074526071548462,
-0.019060106948018074,
0.34127476811408997,
-0.07860148698091507,
0.1801278442144394,
-0.33542966842651367,
0.36580631136894226,
-0.34022796154022217,
0.33052143454551697,
-0.6524269580841064,
0.004191088955849409,
-0.691890299320221,
-0.2634506821632385,
0.5795401930809021,
-0.08293162286281586,
0.18830525875091553,
-0.1774047166109085,
-0.38014206290245056,
0.20498552918434143,
-0.7477414011955261,
-0.0656028687953949,
0.27678561210632324,
0.4785640835762024,
-0.06463727355003357,
0.3687623143196106,
0.03159492462873459,
0.49866798520088196,
0.10509052872657776,
0.5299153327941895,
0.41637030243873596,
-0.11526849120855331,
-0.30867043137550354,
0.21896275877952576,
0.9601384997367859,
-0.19016264379024506,
0.19338756799697876,
-0.10114197432994843,
-0.20106811821460724,
-0.09029673039913177,
0.39436256885528564,
-0.5117168426513672,
-0.24660305678844452,
0.40309378504753113,
-0.13602542877197266,
-0.11050312221050262,
0.07347802072763443,
-0.9723190665245056,
0.03957526013255119,
-0.6131712794303894,
0.0718487873673439,
-0.19622711837291718,
-0.08400590717792511,
0.05888115614652634,
0.0672198235988617,
-0.2875331938266754,
0.23785652220249176,
-0.993843674659729,
0.49035874009132385,
1.0306247472763062,
0.9303937554359436,
-0.4015907645225525,
-0.5070520639419556,
-1.067980408668518,
-0.19537954032421112,
0.025093737989664078,
1.219551920890808,
-0.47694891691207886,
-0.0542006641626358,
0.05522178113460541,
0.17013771831989288,
-0.42357712984085083,
-0.5809178352355957,
0.6957510709762573,
-0.3688729405403137,
-0.0024436835665255785,
0.31486865878105164,
-0.5893325209617615,
0.09699475020170212,
-0.2802846133708954,
-0.6444541811943054,
0.9088879227638245,
0.34292516112327576,
-0.7284510135650635,
-0.1402362734079361,
-0.7031018137931824,
-0.18568909168243408,
0.675633430480957,
-0.3787488341331482,
-0.14029403030872345,
0.14879751205444336,
-0.2589012384414673,
0.40982353687286377,
0.23741935193538666,
0.5399929881095886,
-0.1574992686510086,
-0.16625331342220306,
-0.1575242280960083,
-0.25373920798301697,
1.0433399677276611,
0.3300315737724304,
-0.5798145532608032,
0.5239402055740356,
-0.8645281195640564,
-0.02651788853108883,
-0.2236069142818451,
-0.15732961893081665,
-0.10677730292081833,
-0.35791364312171936,
0.44029268622398376,
0.08646637201309204,
0.108709916472435,
-0.4562927782535553,
0.05694833770394325,
-0.5201619267463684,
0.36355841159820557,
0.8267497420310974,
-0.14861920475959778,
0.30230599641799927,
0.2272864282131195,
0.7348722815513611,
-0.25912097096443176,
-0.07382948696613312,
-0.2590862214565277,
-0.3935464322566986,
-0.7120667099952698,
-0.26155605912208557,
0.7109622359275818,
0.4003047049045563,
-0.4048989713191986,
0.35832586884498596,
-0.1787424236536026,
-0.36450299620628357,
-0.3759062886238098,
0.32413992285728455,
0.5419396758079529,
0.285167396068573,
0.3056841790676117,
-0.5083380937576294,
-1.0645751953125,
-0.9488861560821533,
-0.006684967782348394,
-0.16506049036979675,
-0.048941295593976974,
-0.2286706417798996,
0.595487654209137,
-0.20029662549495697,
0.6452580690383911,
-0.22277693450450897,
-0.4752114713191986,
-0.5963535308837891,
0.33797192573547363,
0.07271815836429596,
0.516750156879425,
0.6758114695549011,
-0.6589387059211731,
-0.607842206954956,
0.20895658433437347,
-0.3060222566127777,
-0.5677992105484009,
0.2862105369567871,
-0.34339603781700134,
0.17241325974464417,
0.48307347297668457,
-0.4987945854663849,
0.16996172070503235,
0.8333497643470764,
-0.5848448872566223,
0.5340421795845032,
-0.13742695748806,
-0.18700841069221497,
-1.12699556350708,
0.10772714018821716,
-0.0635991021990776,
-0.4774242043495178,
-0.586866557598114,
-0.04566202685236931,
0.0026441230438649654,
-0.04721131920814514,
-0.8667377233505249,
0.6562319993972778,
-0.305181086063385,
-0.23970074951648712,
-0.1571410894393921,
-0.1295655369758606,
0.22727496922016144,
0.6062444448471069,
0.1307573765516281,
0.6949059963226318,
0.5201642513275146,
-0.15652693808078766,
0.48271405696868896,
0.10171440988779068,
0.016094889491796494,
0.4541325271129608,
-0.7451722025871277,
0.04477043077349663,
0.05781174451112747,
0.3504345417022705,
-0.7022407054901123,
-0.419173926115036,
0.24349339306354523,
-0.371187686920166,
0.3547782301902771,
-0.47935742139816284,
-0.1959758996963501,
-0.051850005984306335,
-0.15000639855861664,
0.498134970664978,
0.03439448028802872,
-0.48143085837364197,
0.6241284012794495,
0.49725258350372314,
-0.35002651810646057,
-0.26469236612319946,
-0.33414822816848755,
0.09459284693002701,
-0.25791701674461365,
-0.7098488807678223,
0.7300332188606262,
-0.12829923629760742,
-0.5436981320381165,
0.008622652851045132,
0.10274010896682739,
-0.2734907269477844,
0.1637033075094223,
0.40888580679893494,
0.21160759031772614,
-0.2098226398229599,
0.05109034851193428,
0.016910910606384277,
-0.32092535495758057,
0.022779293358325958,
-0.5252891182899475,
0.9563422203063965,
-0.46962970495224,
-0.2623147964477539,
-0.5412861704826355,
0.5364642143249512,
0.64848393201828,
-0.31190574169158936,
0.3227226138114929,
0.3835277557373047,
-0.37800103425979614,
0.01707102172076702,
-0.16671901941299438,
0.2913402318954468,
-0.4393483102321625,
0.22265489399433136,
-0.3152489960193634,
-0.977120041847229,
0.41633936762809753,
0.042300544679164886,
0.1853533834218979,
0.7032705545425415,
0.5597134828567505,
-0.06587906181812286,
0.9572960138320923,
0.6112427115440369,
0.03581816330552101,
0.33604326844215393,
-0.28104153275489807,
-0.27435365319252014,
-0.7420729994773865,
-0.2661445140838623,
-0.7925395965576172,
-0.17011629045009613,
-0.5231227874755859,
-0.21922481060028076,
0.2826460897922516,
-0.03294014558196068,
0.08911792933940887,
0.4915325343608856,
-0.4636593759059906,
0.4757118821144104,
0.5244437456130981,
-0.5605465769767761,
0.12427852302789688,
0.15895609557628632,
-0.5303548574447632,
-0.07319005578756332,
-0.34885579347610474,
-0.3824366331100464,
1.0374051332473755,
0.3527213931083679,
0.16395273804664612,
-0.15094690024852753,
0.9450947046279907,
0.4380187690258026,
0.12421274930238724,
-0.7569189667701721,
0.34001702070236206,
-0.37283238768577576,
-0.1467146873474121,
-0.04910677671432495,
-0.2450823038816452,
-1.32869291305542,
0.51362144947052,
0.27379053831100464,
-0.9143723249435425,
0.023289687931537628,
0.15469969809055328,
-0.40912243723869324,
0.052271850407123566,
-0.5883967876434326,
0.9919591546058655,
-0.4407839775085449,
-0.48895418643951416,
0.1254483014345169,
-0.6987499594688416,
-0.046913739293813705,
0.14965863525867462,
0.35671383142471313,
0.06922078132629395,
0.12041104584932327,
0.8401343822479248,
-0.3168087303638458,
0.7702677249908447,
0.01891627348959446,
-0.15127722918987274,
0.11373396962881088,
-0.013534869998693466,
0.03347613662481308,
0.2546458840370178,
0.09517914801836014,
0.29123303294181824,
0.007529326714575291,
-0.4478674829006195,
-0.4230935573577881,
0.7812671065330505,
-0.5753308534622192,
-0.347633957862854,
-0.6786000728607178,
-0.1877446472644806,
-0.2322758436203003,
0.1850520670413971,
0.35404181480407715,
0.8024113178253174,
-0.16101334989070892,
0.2815479338169098,
0.4573233127593994,
0.39801517128944397,
0.4147329330444336,
0.09583418071269989,
-0.4486200213432312,
-0.6795372366905212,
0.8928177356719971,
-0.07519038766622543,
0.047400448471307755,
0.47986629605293274,
0.07141446322202682,
-0.17838862538337708,
-0.5514368414878845,
-0.6641912460327148,
0.4738338887691498,
-0.48990753293037415,
-0.27854952216148376,
-0.7806999087333679,
-0.6199990510940552,
-0.5875348448753357,
-0.044011835008859634,
-0.7589207887649536,
-0.4177408814430237,
-0.32563793659210205,
-0.11825449019670486,
0.004270268138498068,
0.882107138633728,
-0.24505294859409332,
0.17186857759952545,
-0.8098912835121155,
-0.23605231940746307,
0.16062715649604797,
0.154352068901062,
-0.6167900562286377,
-0.28405648469924927,
-0.28606560826301575,
-0.2102164924144745,
-0.6518969535827637,
-0.6222584247589111,
0.5280042886734009,
0.37103989720344543,
0.37818247079849243,
0.48815569281578064,
-0.12283994257450104,
0.5169217586517334,
-0.6627988815307617,
0.9036825895309448,
0.20770706236362457,
-0.96675705909729,
0.7407516837120056,
-0.27348360419273376,
0.4170825481414795,
0.6792349815368652,
0.4179467260837555,
-0.6527098417282104,
-0.6449986696243286,
-0.8082133531570435,
-0.9761672019958496,
0.42874568700790405,
0.34220972657203674,
0.053309276700019836,
-0.05479932948946953,
0.04045717045664787,
0.3555530309677124,
-0.028918037191033363,
-0.4901682138442993,
-0.29546740651130676,
-0.034445758908987045,
-0.37159135937690735,
0.1316351443529129,
-0.15353445708751678,
-0.0656772181391716,
-0.4348549544811249,
0.6701604723930359,
-0.33026206493377686,
0.24322257936000824,
0.06517783552408218,
-0.15288886427879333,
-0.215118408203125,
0.37673419713974,
0.9609062075614929,
0.8447025418281555,
-0.21295662224292755,
0.6819872856140137,
-0.11439958214759827,
-0.5724273920059204,
-0.15799501538276672,
0.244401752948761,
-0.21002677083015442,
0.5439488291740417,
0.5915276408195496,
0.9419355988502502,
0.5783705711364746,
-0.8008368015289307,
0.28652480244636536,
-0.306396484375,
-0.35170915722846985,
-0.726749837398529,
-0.022473985329270363,
-0.018733322620391846,
0.12724043428897858,
0.4429842233657837,
0.3043782413005829,
0.13427869975566864,
-0.3997160792350769,
0.36643728613853455,
0.2612413167953491,
-0.6014694571495056,
-0.9554911851882935,
0.4473734498023987,
0.40489423274993896,
-0.41587579250335693,
-0.08352361619472504,
-0.2748115658760071,
-1.0530130863189697,
0.39514145255088806,
0.4918489456176758,
0.9368427991867065,
-0.3477800190448761,
0.38977938890457153,
0.3291141390800476,
-0.3300761282444,
0.17305654287338257,
0.20770344138145447,
-0.1140579953789711,
-0.4200378358364105,
-0.36826029419898987,
-0.9247499704360962,
-0.3039517104625702,
0.49876898527145386,
-0.5263970494270325,
0.459716260433197,
-0.15583035349845886,
0.29085949063301086,
0.029792089015245438,
0.0908336192369461,
-0.5338447093963623,
0.013917114585638046,
0.04562561959028244,
0.5856028199195862,
-0.8344431519508362,
0.5731399059295654,
0.8200169801712036,
-0.1370517611503601,
-0.5774559378623962,
-0.174333855509758,
0.37494897842407227,
-0.5803073048591614,
0.8156632781028748,
0.3169322907924652,
-0.14670930802822113,
-0.08391792327165604,
-0.3202996253967285,
-1.0037870407104492,
0.937713623046875,
0.5403278470039368,
-0.40678319334983826,
-0.05278482288122177,
0.1973218023777008,
0.6466056108474731,
-0.7339202761650085,
0.32235848903656006,
0.5621912479400635,
0.2255355268716812,
0.212024986743927,
-1.105071783065796,
-0.5508760213851929,
-0.6216109991073608,
-0.11569150537252426,
0.27556928992271423,
-0.570443332195282,
0.8058627843856812,
0.39511096477508545,
-0.4020237624645233,
0.09285182505846024,
0.8524383902549744,
0.1559334099292755,
0.3717174232006073,
0.5127425789833069,
0.6997751593589783,
0.6486649513244629,
0.03846248611807823,
0.6053025722503662,
-0.19632591307163239,
0.3631119132041931,
1.4492332935333252,
-0.18114762008190155,
0.9665561318397522,
0.6454235315322876,
-0.14172223210334778,
0.5316405296325684,
0.6793292760848999,
0.28880274295806885,
0.33571892976760864,
0.23012377321720123,
-0.4205038547515869,
-0.2016087919473648,
-0.6018446087837219,
-0.4934844672679901,
0.8177856802940369,
0.25680801272392273,
-0.4447825253009796,
-0.4452486038208008,
0.07223334163427353,
0.06742708384990692,
0.08210069686174393,
-0.22409921884536743,
0.5472736954689026,
0.11561721563339233,
-0.8968867063522339,
0.5101223587989807,
-0.22434282302856445,
0.5394433736801147,
-0.3908887803554535,
0.03643188625574112,
-0.365192174911499,
0.15733376145362854,
-0.29390594363212585,
-0.6793904304504395,
0.6733492612838745,
0.19511905312538147,
0.06648493558168411,
-0.5517863035202026,
0.6479129791259766,
-0.4935060143470764,
-0.49845781922340393,
0.6019362211227417,
0.4718392789363861,
0.27522334456443787,
-0.03298138082027435,
-0.41580045223236084,
0.3270951509475708,
-0.048146769404411316,
-0.12277694791555405,
0.48447903990745544,
0.5493890643119812,
0.048434045165777206,
0.4014974534511566,
0.36714068055152893,
0.3360026180744171,
-0.024082565680146217,
0.515591025352478,
0.7485167384147644,
-0.10444798320531845,
-0.23436112701892853,
-0.6794915795326233,
0.7630775570869446,
-0.10496603697538376,
-0.45674577355384827,
0.38245823979377747,
0.7585614323616028,
1.101443886756897,
0.06964589655399323,
0.527326226234436,
0.08031924068927765,
0.3071865737438202,
-0.47270822525024414,
0.5631094574928284,
-0.6457956433296204,
0.133757546544075,
-0.17623646557331085,
-1.041414499282837,
-0.5167036056518555,
0.26559093594551086,
0.06954588741064072,
-0.4239966869354248,
1.0746997594833374,
0.46897560358047485,
-0.17583006620407104,
0.01275950763374567,
0.415363073348999,
-0.07207386940717697,
0.19991663098335266,
0.5718380808830261,
0.6093449592590332,
-0.1538742482662201,
0.534769594669342,
-0.45757758617401123,
-0.21744439005851746,
-0.2573775053024292,
-0.6948304176330566,
-0.6431589722633362,
-1.0571271181106567,
-0.391556054353714,
-0.17148925364017487,
0.019489053636789322,
1.3247331380844116,
0.5254974961280823,
-1.0159058570861816,
-0.3583716154098511,
-0.4204966127872467,
0.06589271128177643,
0.11421801894903183,
-0.26184332370758057,
0.23527021706104279,
-0.562299907207489,
-0.9994545578956604,
0.5635583996772766,
0.698034405708313,
-0.15959668159484863,
-0.38222619891166687,
-0.05812864750623703,
-0.2915688157081604,
-0.30203694105148315,
0.4212181568145752,
0.4024145305156708,
-0.7257688045501709,
-0.4340778887271881,
-0.03580218926072121,
-0.012720638886094093,
0.34447601437568665,
0.9369367361068726,
-0.6015671491622925,
0.22058320045471191,
0.5605324506759644,
0.7079502940177917,
0.19854846596717834,
-0.17088764905929565,
0.6052483916282654,
-0.674524188041687,
0.05549152195453644,
0.35045334696769714,
0.813474178314209,
0.16733916103839874,
-0.28087759017944336,
0.6609888672828674,
0.45714980363845825,
-0.6667418479919434,
-0.7127430438995361,
0.3405797481536865,
-1.199652075767517,
0.06063542142510414,
1.0969178676605225,
-0.4218984842300415,
-0.4491684138774872,
-0.46972113847732544,
-0.28596341609954834,
0.19436246156692505,
-0.41449421644210815,
0.6154807806015015,
0.6182745099067688,
-0.32970795035362244,
-0.40682870149612427,
-0.19588440656661987,
0.4461319148540497,
0.6148598194122314,
-1.0365945100784302,
-0.09207761287689209,
0.4480702579021454,
0.13655529916286469,
0.5141017436981201,
0.6020870208740234,
-0.024246370419859886,
0.3020610213279724,
-0.40248095989227295,
-0.04268013685941696,
0.19575197994709015,
-0.7283027768135071,
-0.49267056584358215,
0.4354761838912964,
-0.1818021833896637,
-0.03770992159843445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05829v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05829v1
|
SambaLingo: Teaching Large Language Models New Languages
| 2024-04-08T19:48:36 | 2024-04-08T19:48:36 |
Zoltan Csaki, Bo Li, Jonathan Li, Qiantong Xu, Pian Pawakapan, Leon Zhang, Yun Du, Hengyu Zhao, Changran Hu, Urmish Thakker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Despite the widespread availability of LLMs, there remains a substantial gap
in their capabilities and availability across diverse languages. One approach
to address these issues has been to take an existing pre-trained LLM and
continue to train it on new languages. While prior works have experimented with
language adaptation, many questions around best practices and methodology have
not been covered. In this paper, we present a comprehensive investigation into
the adaptation of LLMs to new languages. Our study covers the key components in
this process, including vocabulary extension, direct preference optimization
and the data scarcity problem for human alignment in low-resource languages. We
scale these experiments across 9 languages and 2 parameter scales (7B and 70B).
We compare our models against Llama 2, Aya-101, XGLM, BLOOM and existing
language experts, outperforming all prior published baselines. Additionally,
all evaluation code and checkpoints are made public to facilitate future
research.
|
[
-0.42547962069511414,
-0.42891454696655273,
0.19781647622585297,
0.3517075479030609,
-0.062256138771772385,
0.2836640477180481,
-0.5345501899719238,
-0.4261612892150879,
0.10576814413070679,
0.6487375497817993,
-0.19663190841674805,
-0.21838565170764923,
-0.6411970257759094,
0.1655760258436203,
-0.11929503828287125,
0.9998576045036316,
-0.39166685938835144,
0.16540059447288513,
0.020487911999225616,
-0.19698964059352875,
-0.6680670976638794,
-0.35115936398506165,
-0.6976724863052368,
-0.3371330201625824,
0.4068383574485779,
0.6534603834152222,
0.7000712156295776,
0.6424143314361572,
0.31710973381996155,
0.2177056223154068,
-0.23969310522079468,
0.07031168043613434,
-0.7163549661636353,
-0.2104307860136032,
-0.3012148141860962,
-0.5627232193946838,
-0.5005684494972229,
-0.0810459703207016,
0.9732887148857117,
0.9468292593955994,
-0.056662511080503464,
0.18871715664863586,
0.2002253234386444,
0.6194053292274475,
-0.6084652543067932,
-0.12388765066862106,
-0.7115042805671692,
-0.0220451969653368,
-0.0928061380982399,
-0.04928198829293251,
-0.5156835913658142,
-0.42210203409194946,
0.12338154762983322,
-0.7044240236282349,
-0.15144701302051544,
-0.10950490832328796,
0.7474455237388611,
0.28541669249534607,
-0.6028931736946106,
-0.6108328104019165,
-0.5898808240890503,
0.8414673209190369,
-0.4506300091743469,
0.21399712562561035,
0.3423359990119934,
0.40416237711906433,
-0.30235201120376587,
-0.14677883684635162,
-0.16448315978050232,
-0.31536704301834106,
0.18133871257305145,
-0.06189553439617157,
-0.08746255934238434,
-0.1454697549343109,
-0.2522216737270355,
0.28315743803977966,
-0.37770408391952515,
0.5956392884254456,
-0.25758734345436096,
0.029529983177781105,
0.6320421695709229,
-0.14726421236991882,
-0.05968600884079933,
-0.08309894055128098,
-0.3718767762184143,
-0.00727459229528904,
-0.7598962783813477,
-0.205794095993042,
0.2878400683403015,
0.28816431760787964,
-0.19041676819324493,
0.19093723595142365,
0.14177550375461578,
0.7548057436943054,
-0.046829648315906525,
-0.24975310266017914,
0.1658456027507782,
-0.060250457376241684,
-0.26020196080207825,
-0.1135893240571022,
0.32958564162254333,
0.28549671173095703,
0.5531894564628601,
-0.1134759783744812,
-0.10029961913824081,
-0.368560254573822,
0.009745407849550247,
-0.38985612988471985,
0.010885453782975674,
-0.09625585377216339,
-0.1803242266178131,
-0.21213850378990173,
-0.551758348941803,
-0.5503442883491516,
-0.7292339205741882,
-0.35769587755203247,
0.29820382595062256,
-0.2982134222984314,
-0.38616690039634705,
0.11161049455404282,
0.19352911412715912,
0.4272996485233307,
0.6265211701393127,
-0.9616004824638367,
0.29190343618392944,
0.599705696105957,
0.7818267941474915,
-0.5187087655067444,
-0.5276690721511841,
-0.406124085187912,
0.21217238903045654,
-0.6411592960357666,
0.8131992816925049,
-0.4505557715892792,
-0.3518933951854706,
0.01506296917796135,
0.26015594601631165,
0.012800142168998718,
-0.8142462372779846,
0.5590676665306091,
-0.46709126234054565,
-0.005703458096832037,
-0.2767300605773926,
-0.399808406829834,
-0.03020135872066021,
0.1922033727169037,
-0.35904788970947266,
0.8843117356300354,
0.38332676887512207,
-0.33239227533340454,
0.32076090574264526,
-0.5497438907623291,
-0.41996705532073975,
0.09832654893398285,
0.06480830907821655,
0.03340088203549385,
0.20556648075580597,
0.19985006749629974,
0.472953200340271,
-0.4340966045856476,
0.3520888388156891,
-0.20726457238197327,
-0.4484766721725464,
0.3889962434768677,
-0.15687505900859833,
0.8440569043159485,
0.4089089632034302,
0.16262070834636688,
0.09880945831537247,
-0.48777955770492554,
-0.1416473686695099,
0.07839540392160416,
-0.5954521894454956,
-0.2476881444454193,
-0.3757283389568329,
-0.032252706587314606,
0.01367111410945654,
0.12844960391521454,
-0.059614889323711395,
0.4290185570716858,
-0.23546616733074188,
0.37033340334892273,
1.0153839588165283,
-0.24837450683116913,
0.7755618095397949,
-0.34956368803977966,
0.8668823838233948,
-0.12439374625682831,
0.1754855364561081,
-0.17159403860569,
-0.14460310339927673,
-1.0124280452728271,
-0.21711061894893646,
0.44843870401382446,
0.44444891810417175,
-0.6330150365829468,
0.19544263184070587,
-0.3845277428627014,
-0.35822975635528564,
-0.6151190400123596,
0.5107350945472717,
0.12919685244560242,
0.13837943971157074,
0.004063805565237999,
-0.39732712507247925,
-0.6818333864212036,
-0.7391427159309387,
-0.059103500097990036,
-0.036402150988578796,
-0.027849532663822174,
0.26611343026161194,
0.33982476592063904,
-0.5453008413314819,
0.6877161264419556,
-0.3122744858264923,
-0.05271909385919571,
-0.4014337360858917,
-0.31527048349380493,
0.25909337401390076,
0.39027830958366394,
0.7887571454048157,
-0.2740805745124817,
-0.65411376953125,
0.22912541031837463,
-0.5186556577682495,
-0.08447042852640152,
-0.045759979635477066,
-0.3620612323284149,
0.5373225212097168,
0.36677929759025574,
-0.1430446207523346,
-0.2716001272201538,
0.9081212878227234,
0.32620272040367126,
0.516465961933136,
-0.31449228525161743,
-0.17575551569461823,
-1.2479864358901978,
-0.11706102639436722,
-0.03171877935528755,
-0.07578930258750916,
-0.6778039932250977,
0.056042931973934174,
0.02303718402981758,
-0.26093152165412903,
-0.46417587995529175,
0.8600592017173767,
-0.9340088963508606,
-0.402786523103714,
-0.6299052834510803,
0.11488135159015656,
-0.3692258298397064,
0.2913881540298462,
0.016414271667599678,
0.713748037815094,
0.7812912464141846,
-0.5492754578590393,
0.23597514629364014,
0.09568510204553604,
-0.3200571835041046,
0.2849194407463074,
-0.2779805660247803,
0.34504953026771545,
-0.20626689493656158,
0.14498892426490784,
-0.8485718369483948,
-0.43820279836654663,
0.07695581763982773,
-0.2363194227218628,
0.5553666949272156,
-0.5994781851768494,
-0.3816850483417511,
-0.23123954236507416,
-0.17596836388111115,
0.20767179131507874,
0.6544129848480225,
-0.5921081304550171,
0.29158511757850647,
0.6274929046630859,
-0.1907590925693512,
-0.5047918558120728,
-0.5489041805267334,
0.2448897808790207,
-0.30065837502479553,
-0.47246047854423523,
-0.2324773371219635,
0.027028489857912064,
-0.25166910886764526,
-0.24714194238185883,
0.011623010039329529,
-0.1850774735212326,
0.4755029082298279,
-0.0568610355257988,
0.13179461658000946,
-0.22928370535373688,
0.12781177461147308,
0.0640382394194603,
-0.02656509168446064,
-0.23609153926372528,
-0.33198195695877075,
0.6557715535163879,
-0.1555144488811493,
-0.1373179405927658,
-0.15639710426330566,
0.027269504964351654,
0.2725427746772766,
-0.07867032289505005,
0.6744439005851746,
0.5047112107276917,
-0.29069000482559204,
-0.13402393460273743,
-0.5277923941612244,
0.20112042129039764,
-0.48824748396873474,
0.48301756381988525,
-0.2758741080760956,
-1.0682201385498047,
0.36311185359954834,
-0.506936252117157,
-0.0949043408036232,
0.014591189101338387,
0.7255144715309143,
-0.13617463409900665,
0.3235195279121399,
0.9791151881217957,
-0.32467129826545715,
0.5110679864883423,
-0.07987286895513535,
-0.11758362501859665,
-0.8612741231918335,
0.11603543907403946,
-0.22264665365219116,
-0.22047510743141174,
-0.699470579624176,
-0.9139689207077026,
0.12993399798870087,
0.351215124130249,
0.024693118408322334,
0.4613281488418579,
-0.13128116726875305,
0.6300925612449646,
0.18271933495998383,
-0.2688639760017395,
0.20006364583969116,
0.18471446633338928,
0.3695085048675537,
0.20553962886333466,
-0.7935107350349426,
-0.703478217124939,
1.3180011510849,
0.45880356431007385,
0.8773363828659058,
0.24164675176143646,
0.6273696422576904,
0.11184371262788773,
0.7986562252044678,
-0.6803788542747498,
0.35528111457824707,
-0.21085824072360992,
-0.6344195008277893,
-0.3949722349643707,
-0.327314555644989,
-1.1945897340774536,
0.383683979511261,
-0.07125365734100342,
-0.5920564532279968,
0.006711158901453018,
0.09365224093198776,
-0.017357023432850838,
0.11937308311462402,
-0.9136334657669067,
0.6189212799072266,
-0.5338490605354309,
-0.41329240798950195,
-0.009301109239459038,
-0.4971177875995636,
0.5330298542976379,
-0.5659279227256775,
0.5623250007629395,
-0.2682010233402252,
-0.19883720576763153,
0.7118839025497437,
0.1057782769203186,
0.71844083070755,
-0.03982683643698692,
-0.5139745473861694,
0.20772893726825714,
-0.014167914167046547,
0.4566771686077118,
-0.11998412013053894,
-0.35021236538887024,
0.0281264316290617,
-0.13727697730064392,
-0.9294654726982117,
-0.34859001636505127,
0.7499426007270813,
-0.8723279237747192,
-0.7599288821220398,
-0.3186197578907013,
-0.9312297105789185,
-0.41099071502685547,
0.10059405863285065,
-0.07085063308477402,
-0.2953459918498993,
-0.22801101207733154,
-0.11224355548620224,
0.5859965682029724,
-0.5890312790870667,
0.17855150997638702,
0.6710688471794128,
-0.488826721906662,
-0.3634345531463623,
0.7793907523155212,
0.22868521511554718,
0.542996346950531,
0.2488749921321869,
0.35557258129119873,
0.015158658847212791,
-0.6926144361495972,
-0.5514166355133057,
0.505143404006958,
-0.6318453550338745,
0.043656907975673676,
-0.31869420409202576,
0.07742363214492798,
-0.7204559445381165,
-0.3903336524963379,
-0.23294086754322052,
-0.32372960448265076,
-0.24121151864528656,
0.048912473022937775,
0.21567633748054504,
0.6644271016120911,
-0.09007489681243896,
0.561262845993042,
-0.6373956799507141,
-0.14355377852916718,
0.0594186931848526,
0.14896035194396973,
0.06498962640762329,
-1.0010807514190674,
-0.5294099450111389,
-0.05864467844367027,
-0.2460111677646637,
-0.8142601251602173,
0.30367162823677063,
0.2529265284538269,
0.710924506187439,
0.3664979338645935,
-0.07546132057905197,
0.6796945929527283,
-0.36689862608909607,
0.32486215233802795,
0.08070512115955353,
-0.8671888709068298,
0.5785290598869324,
-0.4614102244377136,
0.22830739617347717,
0.37764570116996765,
0.7415494322776794,
-0.6949083805084229,
0.04743805527687073,
-0.15650929510593414,
-0.3970595598220825,
0.7056123614311218,
-0.009113340638577938,
0.26485925912857056,
0.24866653978824615,
0.6742938160896301,
0.3356289863586426,
0.22868578135967255,
-0.7844364643096924,
-0.014260745607316494,
0.09307325631380081,
0.08681380748748779,
-0.480643093585968,
-0.3425231873989105,
-0.043182406574487686,
-0.20533449947834015,
0.5405386090278625,
-0.3224184513092041,
0.040841467678546906,
-0.4465092718601227,
-0.4613145887851715,
-0.14039766788482666,
0.39676663279533386,
0.49639055132865906,
0.7602341175079346,
0.030781127512454987,
0.09046272933483124,
0.6777738928794861,
-0.1817781925201416,
0.47355732321739197,
-0.010455056093633175,
-0.01138477772474289,
-0.20914657413959503,
0.5687288045883179,
0.8471424579620361,
0.11561963707208633,
-0.8657302856445312,
0.25839972496032715,
0.4129183292388916,
0.051905665546655655,
-0.21166080236434937,
0.07295948266983032,
0.3216126561164856,
0.06786669045686722,
0.22529935836791992,
-0.3649236559867859,
-0.2223607450723648,
-0.8499055504798889,
-0.09174396097660065,
0.3097805380821228,
-0.21252653002738953,
-0.3028464615345001,
0.11845555901527405,
0.26316824555397034,
-0.2832350730895996,
0.3212358355522156,
-0.36351799964904785,
-0.4234974682331085,
0.3731115758419037,
0.6327573657035828,
0.5057566165924072,
-0.578210711479187,
0.30837148427963257,
0.1574435532093048,
0.6231056451797485,
-0.06535344570875168,
-0.004529821220785379,
0.014119749888777733,
-0.7354937791824341,
-0.5043896436691284,
-0.6961424350738525,
-0.56414395570755,
0.09092970192432404,
-0.6893776655197144,
0.4143609404563904,
-0.4828251898288727,
0.05898448824882507,
-0.35745254158973694,
0.20580275356769562,
-0.2696116268634796,
-0.08565445989370346,
0.09395086765289307,
0.9215585589408875,
-1.063677191734314,
1.029058814048767,
0.9677386283874512,
-0.15928828716278076,
-0.42865779995918274,
-0.027100520208477974,
-0.10687127709388733,
-1.2172722816467285,
0.5355276465415955,
-0.16600200533866882,
0.21248477697372437,
-0.07900933921337128,
-0.470030277967453,
-1.142600655555725,
0.9444788098335266,
0.8624261617660522,
-0.6099563837051392,
-0.07041490823030472,
0.28706473112106323,
0.7083888053894043,
-0.20028334856033325,
-0.07166898995637894,
0.7460564374923706,
0.3019503355026245,
0.15357975661754608,
-0.8933430910110474,
-0.07718350738286972,
0.06459193676710129,
0.12286414951086044,
0.22124779224395752,
-0.8470185399055481,
0.6388396620750427,
-0.23107655346393585,
0.03308580443263054,
0.31101980805397034,
0.5485807061195374,
0.21421688795089722,
0.08057131618261337,
0.40602603554725647,
0.286356657743454,
0.915216863155365,
0.09784182906150818,
0.8610945343971252,
-0.08466597646474838,
0.21782651543617249,
1.2277920246124268,
-0.6403421759605408,
0.7535121440887451,
0.5149381756782532,
-0.3297581374645233,
0.2352382391691208,
0.8926659822463989,
-0.0913219079375267,
0.25976231694221497,
0.7030973434448242,
-0.022291768342256546,
-0.1781410127878189,
-0.32870203256607056,
-0.33746397495269775,
0.2783317565917969,
0.3283204138278961,
-0.07932337373495102,
-0.17519797384738922,
0.330267071723938,
0.2778215706348419,
-0.07711975276470184,
-0.2738724648952484,
0.5358400344848633,
0.0013568743597716093,
-0.6474067568778992,
0.9404782652854919,
-0.020240992307662964,
0.6744048595428467,
-0.4661967158317566,
0.4316769242286682,
-0.7074633836746216,
0.24987681210041046,
-0.16650108993053436,
-0.6450228691101074,
0.15342772006988525,
0.26054155826568604,
0.1287030428647995,
-0.17383895814418793,
0.5374714732170105,
-0.285216748714447,
-0.5251272320747375,
0.3455706536769867,
0.4193841516971588,
0.6893640160560608,
0.18794502317905426,
-0.4156855344772339,
0.3154999315738678,
0.047649212181568146,
0.18681927025318146,
0.7102115750312805,
0.43425416946411133,
-0.2751882076263428,
0.91949462890625,
0.49747800827026367,
0.14368051290512085,
0.3052562177181244,
0.028476977720856667,
0.7841426730155945,
-0.4395826458930969,
-0.08086561411619186,
-0.38688790798187256,
-0.056725047528743744,
0.21277251839637756,
-0.3097134530544281,
1.0026262998580933,
0.6286997199058533,
1.0169166326522827,
-0.20700229704380035,
0.7201135754585266,
0.39828482270240784,
0.23081925511360168,
-0.5157720446586609,
0.5537148118019104,
-0.5598060488700867,
0.4081500470638275,
-0.3938361406326294,
-1.0070929527282715,
0.017320657148957253,
0.4207123816013336,
-0.325387567281723,
0.08474776893854141,
0.4641903042793274,
0.6454924941062927,
0.052718088030815125,
-0.32817500829696655,
0.3888990879058838,
0.25632065534591675,
0.2247498780488968,
0.7805586457252502,
1.1480751037597656,
-0.31035441160202026,
0.6276527047157288,
-0.0032939710654318333,
-0.5096070170402527,
-0.3158928453922272,
-0.9324541687965393,
-0.8749561309814453,
-0.35840150713920593,
-0.387993723154068,
-0.005939469672739506,
0.21749477088451385,
0.7503272294998169,
0.6186296939849854,
-0.5895671844482422,
-0.7794393301010132,
-0.0019506115932017565,
0.05028405413031578,
0.03894627466797829,
-0.08480954170227051,
0.2779467701911926,
-0.4498700201511383,
-0.7720147967338562,
0.34857064485549927,
0.145525261759758,
0.36681029200553894,
-0.3580063581466675,
-0.41052189469337463,
-0.2567194402217865,
0.018249962478876114,
0.5845815539360046,
0.2796473801136017,
-0.6227864027023315,
-0.02037687972187996,
0.07721215486526489,
0.052456095814704895,
0.08203128725290298,
0.6838140487670898,
-0.42015665769577026,
0.08435176312923431,
0.17325113713741302,
1.0010818243026733,
0.5647578239440918,
-0.3223625719547272,
0.5209211707115173,
-0.604795515537262,
0.2807682454586029,
-0.0066945506259799,
0.25727421045303345,
0.6225506067276001,
-0.006607134826481342,
0.588307797908783,
0.07882664352655411,
-0.41763144731521606,
-1.1290591955184937,
0.30807116627693176,
-0.8225154876708984,
-0.33999916911125183,
1.3939592838287354,
-0.09113693982362747,
-0.12231585383415222,
-0.03265976533293724,
-0.3124120831489563,
0.15990948677062988,
-0.0016241900157183409,
0.6211167573928833,
0.8132935166358948,
-0.10364656895399094,
-0.26487475633621216,
-0.3870464861392975,
0.18443043529987335,
0.5084518790245056,
-0.9293752908706665,
0.21155814826488495,
0.19505268335342407,
0.4063011109828949,
-0.033148616552352905,
0.6869364976882935,
0.11473806202411652,
0.04611891880631447,
-0.25140300393104553,
0.08980216830968857,
0.26966366171836853,
-0.19524964690208435,
-0.8080162405967712,
-0.19477306306362152,
0.6474436521530151,
-0.018785493448376656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08685v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08685v1
|
Neural Sequence-to-Sequence Modeling with Attention by Leveraging Deep Learning Architectures for Enhanced Contextual Understanding in Abstractive Text Summarization
| 2024-04-08T18:33:59 | 2024-04-08T18:33:59 |
Bhavith Chandra Challagundla, Chakradhar Peddavenkatagari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Automatic text summarization (TS) plays a pivotal role in condensing large
volumes of information into concise, coherent summaries, facilitating efficient
information retrieval and comprehension. This paper presents a novel framework
for abstractive TS of single documents, which integrates three dominant
aspects: structural, semantic, and neural-based approaches. The proposed
framework merges machine learning and knowledge-based techniques to achieve a
unified methodology. The framework consists of three main phases:
pre-processing, machine learning, and post-processing. In the pre-processing
phase, a knowledge-based Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD) technique is employed
to generalize ambiguous words, enhancing content generalization. Semantic
content generalization is then performed to address out-of-vocabulary (OOV) or
rare words, ensuring comprehensive coverage of the input document.
Subsequently, the generalized text is transformed into a continuous vector
space using neural language processing techniques. A deep sequence-to-sequence
(seq2seq) model with an attention mechanism is employed to predict a
generalized summary based on the vector representation. In the post-processing
phase, heuristic algorithms and text similarity metrics are utilized to refine
the generated summary further. Concepts from the generalized summary are
matched with specific entities, enhancing coherence and readability.
Experimental evaluations conducted on prominent datasets, including Gigaword,
Duc 2004, and CNN/DailyMail, demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed
framework. Results indicate significant improvements in handling rare and OOV
words, outperforming existing state-of-the-art deep learning techniques. The
proposed framework presents a comprehensive and unified approach towards
abstractive TS, combining the strengths of structure, semantics, and
neural-based methodologies.
|
[
-0.12140635401010513,
-0.6627948880195618,
0.40110722184181213,
0.14037717878818512,
-0.5336527824401855,
0.03552846983075142,
-0.16246765851974487,
-0.36204248666763306,
0.19194722175598145,
0.3151862323284149,
-0.2519013285636902,
-0.6679992079734802,
-0.5952847003936768,
0.18076907098293304,
-0.6242132782936096,
1.0110009908676147,
0.0032874091994017363,
-0.23713643848896027,
-0.20931856334209442,
-0.25574028491973877,
-0.361824631690979,
-0.4298272728919983,
-0.39022064208984375,
-0.3138740360736847,
0.43550142645835876,
0.2509680688381195,
0.3399365544319153,
0.6940443515777588,
0.4678509533405304,
0.3375975489616394,
-0.29560020565986633,
0.2593485713005066,
-0.31112128496170044,
0.1614324450492859,
-0.08080749958753586,
-0.16372983157634735,
-0.7251812815666199,
-0.39871057868003845,
0.6480314135551453,
0.8260172605514526,
0.18729384243488312,
0.06895896792411804,
0.4551990032196045,
0.7542639374732971,
-0.5835074782371521,
0.1922154277563095,
-0.34624433517456055,
0.3024153709411621,
0.31895890831947327,
-0.30802440643310547,
-0.21795713901519775,
-0.2800742983818054,
0.5840122103691101,
-0.5936493873596191,
0.27027636766433716,
-0.3459429442882538,
0.5202226638793945,
0.32425934076309204,
-0.5280188322067261,
-0.348227322101593,
-0.420987069606781,
0.5012446045875549,
-0.9679105281829834,
-0.021321387961506844,
0.003184514120221138,
-0.028122244402766228,
0.20936784148216248,
-0.8466709852218628,
-0.2683255672454834,
0.040845837444067,
-0.2006501704454422,
0.4392448663711548,
0.017330322414636612,
0.19124211370944977,
-0.11959432065486908,
0.5249825716018677,
-0.7290493845939636,
-0.024117453023791313,
-0.3981563150882721,
0.06459012627601624,
0.4898132085800171,
0.13153600692749023,
0.20844249427318573,
-0.12558411061763763,
-0.3644050359725952,
0.27156493067741394,
-0.3602941632270813,
-0.02975863590836525,
0.009103369899094105,
0.37143442034721375,
-0.14135737717151642,
0.5878540873527527,
-0.4383055567741394,
0.633810818195343,
0.08855487406253815,
0.26677772402763367,
0.19298787415027618,
-0.46162739396095276,
-0.41669878363609314,
0.31122180819511414,
0.6945180296897888,
0.4973692297935486,
0.27835091948509216,
-0.4287213087081909,
-0.09867797791957855,
-0.013411707244813442,
0.20510253310203552,
-0.7654168605804443,
0.05466924607753754,
0.35955289006233215,
-0.6290374398231506,
-0.47640523314476013,
-0.02863394282758236,
-0.6663203239440918,
-0.224663645029068,
-0.695634663105011,
0.29208722710609436,
-0.3914709985256195,
-0.1441681981086731,
0.025202840566635132,
-0.22815649211406708,
0.08088807761669159,
0.29292216897010803,
-0.7624327540397644,
0.23532269895076752,
0.5219641923904419,
1.0664154291152954,
-0.46305185556411743,
-0.13662107288837433,
-0.3085160255432129,
0.4105173349380493,
-0.1347917914390564,
0.756648063659668,
-0.16889218986034393,
-0.13092000782489777,
0.011149021796882153,
-0.3622058629989624,
-0.0925477147102356,
-0.26554352045059204,
0.31316524744033813,
-0.6538987755775452,
0.32996830344200134,
0.17611585557460785,
-0.6379750370979309,
-0.4475022554397583,
0.5136631727218628,
-0.5460376739501953,
0.5908798575401306,
-0.14922192692756653,
-0.7657498121261597,
-0.013767276890575886,
-0.8508496880531311,
-0.856985867023468,
-0.19295363128185272,
-0.09404406696557999,
-0.28652510046958923,
0.2228579968214035,
0.30587849020957947,
0.6380648016929626,
-0.031036511063575745,
0.4213949143886566,
0.0019735770765691996,
-0.3105781376361847,
-0.04134269058704376,
-0.21506211161613464,
0.42460688948631287,
0.21223263442516327,
-0.2771206200122833,
0.49648359417915344,
-0.8399567008018494,
0.049922455102205276,
-0.09081608057022095,
-0.32287541031837463,
-0.3443739414215088,
-0.014462318271398544,
0.0387042798101902,
0.2769306004047394,
0.24973604083061218,
-0.04678260162472725,
-0.060817964375019073,
-0.941195547580719,
0.6543536186218262,
0.374778151512146,
0.16781248152256012,
0.8604283928871155,
-0.10933161526918411,
0.29174020886421204,
0.20716989040374756,
-0.3691357970237732,
-0.8744685649871826,
-0.1650814265012741,
-0.5438699722290039,
-0.0648077130317688,
0.2315382957458496,
0.6263757348060608,
-0.4203486442565918,
0.5844266414642334,
-0.44262343645095825,
-0.03322666883468628,
-0.13213098049163818,
-0.12187368422746658,
0.5266963243484497,
0.7164885401725769,
0.41629692912101746,
-0.24008741974830627,
-0.628790557384491,
-0.661304235458374,
-0.31960517168045044,
0.28841713070869446,
-0.11711620539426804,
0.014890356920659542,
0.36252060532569885,
-0.10599221289157867,
0.9377158284187317,
-0.40671610832214355,
-0.5517904758453369,
-0.5020490884780884,
0.43444013595581055,
0.22583217918872833,
0.5156150460243225,
0.27490973472595215,
-0.9894387125968933,
-0.27507591247558594,
-0.021222349256277084,
-1.1216870546340942,
0.2625831961631775,
-0.12990766763687134,
0.0855153352022171,
0.25615447759628296,
0.6878560185432434,
-0.3403366506099701,
0.6116564869880676,
0.10833897441625595,
-0.37538281083106995,
0.12748651206493378,
-0.34686094522476196,
-0.03673044592142105,
-1.4780137538909912,
0.37752196192741394,
0.05158286169171333,
-0.16550388932228088,
-0.6064172983169556,
0.25593340396881104,
0.1029534712433815,
-0.17936579883098602,
-0.29475221037864685,
0.41223999857902527,
-0.4931122660636902,
-0.20351450145244598,
-0.5173832774162292,
0.205375075340271,
0.20138780772686005,
0.7130606174468994,
0.1585846245288849,
0.35132262110710144,
0.11413372308015823,
-0.9732866883277893,
0.09811237454414368,
0.3844408690929413,
-0.1332850158214569,
0.22633275389671326,
-0.8912323713302612,
-0.11990723758935928,
-0.5080167651176453,
0.21563392877578735,
-1.1365329027175903,
-0.2737564444541931,
0.1772817075252533,
-0.7096521854400635,
0.3055233657360077,
0.11821883916854858,
-0.20040403306484222,
0.09768680483102798,
-0.26705560088157654,
0.5873696804046631,
0.1880093514919281,
-0.1954347938299179,
0.9113665223121643,
0.21283699572086334,
-0.5939741134643555,
-0.6579131484031677,
-0.9562416672706604,
0.34282949566841125,
0.013385560363531113,
-0.5462009906768799,
0.6612294316291809,
0.07891086488962173,
-0.24509139358997345,
0.18430960178375244,
-0.1874362826347351,
-0.2621538043022156,
0.1429840624332428,
-0.015484120696783066,
0.26434600353240967,
-0.21566784381866455,
0.225211963057518,
0.33668604493141174,
-0.1460617184638977,
0.03301100805401802,
-0.6902859807014465,
0.420852392911911,
-0.15894140303134918,
0.15851369500160217,
-0.26206228137016296,
0.7214374542236328,
0.45306187868118286,
-0.45072218775749207,
0.38097289204597473,
0.41455551981925964,
-0.48175713419914246,
0.05983723700046539,
-0.14031408727169037,
-0.1250171810388565,
-0.33064427971839905,
0.7353404760360718,
-0.22827354073524475,
-0.7338237166404724,
0.5430336594581604,
0.073545902967453,
0.3005264401435852,
0.6093040108680725,
0.5463789701461792,
-0.14037171006202698,
0.8845372796058655,
0.7489558458328247,
-0.33326852321624756,
0.37918493151664734,
-0.3530477285385132,
0.004911978729069233,
-0.7063261866569519,
-0.1477658897638321,
-0.2182883769273758,
-0.4318453073501587,
-0.12036348134279251,
-0.0966479629278183,
0.14167222380638123,
-0.015338851138949394,
-0.18707850575447083,
0.09834175556898117,
-0.5521286129951477,
0.5039682984352112,
0.3621324896812439,
0.07450965791940689,
0.6065989136695862,
0.03851411119103432,
-0.19895091652870178,
0.20665214955806732,
-0.6412323713302612,
-0.39071840047836304,
1.1872950792312622,
0.2525739073753357,
0.29335322976112366,
0.05076028034090996,
0.5400053262710571,
0.4973812699317932,
0.22407573461532593,
-0.8826265335083008,
0.34533584117889404,
-0.159797802567482,
-0.25562936067581177,
-0.4154929518699646,
-0.33898475766181946,
-0.7042280435562134,
0.42203518748283386,
0.009337837807834148,
-0.4875084161758423,
0.12252764403820038,
0.1734185665845871,
-0.586703896522522,
-0.008352824486792088,
-0.6985740661621094,
0.7472872734069824,
-0.1596660315990448,
-0.2937842309474945,
-0.2905997335910797,
-0.9252185225486755,
0.5294772386550903,
0.15770122408866882,
0.1002948060631752,
0.14278052747249603,
-0.26921191811561584,
0.5304773449897766,
-0.1575327217578888,
0.7735217213630676,
0.15228642523288727,
-0.1449594795703888,
0.11743644624948502,
-0.33359119296073914,
0.43346062302589417,
0.05551654472947121,
-0.01717122085392475,
-0.031061628833413124,
-0.2947886288166046,
-0.2876570522785187,
-0.4753279685974121,
0.5693826675415039,
-0.4594029188156128,
-0.16266055405139923,
-0.47687190771102905,
-0.6933051943778992,
-0.09747114777565002,
0.5582071542739868,
0.5089266300201416,
0.6880863904953003,
-0.4309203028678894,
-0.005132220685482025,
0.9167131185531616,
-0.075738824903965,
0.7404559254646301,
0.32252275943756104,
-0.030118122696876526,
-0.6302053928375244,
0.7343711853027344,
0.034964434802532196,
0.03294316679239273,
0.8124814033508301,
-0.10074494779109955,
-0.32915523648262024,
-0.7800691723823547,
-0.3644782602787018,
-0.1954318881034851,
-0.684797465801239,
-0.17430046200752258,
-1.0333263874053955,
-0.2565663158893585,
-0.7570779323577881,
-0.12840871512889862,
0.07042728364467621,
-0.5072292685508728,
-0.4146665930747986,
-0.13362880051136017,
-0.06435847282409668,
0.6068747043609619,
0.2616260349750519,
0.1204073503613472,
-0.8844597935676575,
0.7640281915664673,
0.0975281149148941,
0.30397921800613403,
0.25089678168296814,
-0.7312954664230347,
-0.29953843355178833,
-0.08104979246854782,
-0.09894797950983047,
-0.7138787508010864,
0.5845018029212952,
0.38777685165405273,
0.19686289131641388,
0.4209621250629425,
0.23108235001564026,
0.347470760345459,
-0.4621114134788513,
0.39641931653022766,
0.1879025250673294,
-0.8044581413269043,
0.6228211522102356,
-0.6048542261123657,
0.8008779287338257,
0.5990814566612244,
0.15576009452342987,
-0.5219505429267883,
-0.31955957412719727,
-0.40158334374427795,
-1.2572295665740967,
0.6938329339027405,
0.2526044249534607,
0.03510944917798042,
0.08070264011621475,
0.34841713309288025,
-0.024767253547906876,
0.4479341506958008,
-0.5985237956047058,
-0.24390514194965363,
-0.2975379526615143,
-0.682462215423584,
-0.15490341186523438,
-0.2913108468055725,
0.06377531588077545,
-0.1071431040763855,
0.5941026210784912,
-0.2925910949707031,
0.24492335319519043,
0.489279568195343,
-0.5881054401397705,
0.2895559072494507,
0.432935893535614,
0.814561665058136,
0.7061489224433899,
-0.23632557690143585,
-0.04370979592204094,
0.02198067121207714,
-0.46185773611068726,
-0.07325108349323273,
0.42929792404174805,
-0.4032742977142334,
0.13248267769813538,
0.3734706938266754,
0.5173359513282776,
0.43760186433792114,
-0.6041722297668457,
0.5217844843864441,
-0.2000657320022583,
-0.37395963072776794,
-0.3793197274208069,
-0.2609061896800995,
0.027591804042458534,
0.16084009408950806,
0.49360325932502747,
0.3598555326461792,
0.6147304177284241,
-0.44008538126945496,
0.21587449312210083,
0.07039064168930054,
-0.37852397561073303,
-0.24019013345241547,
0.5879356861114502,
0.555863082408905,
0.030915331095457077,
0.3005865812301636,
-0.06274539977312088,
-0.4326552152633667,
0.7984876036643982,
0.3843856155872345,
1.1118659973144531,
0.1284935027360916,
-0.0288897342979908,
0.3524807095527649,
0.0835704579949379,
0.02392543852329254,
0.1790943443775177,
-0.41785040497779846,
-0.42589956521987915,
-0.5896961688995361,
-0.3199198842048645,
-0.12860016524791718,
0.09066272526979446,
-0.6564469933509827,
-0.08648214489221573,
-0.4885706901550293,
0.2048613727092743,
0.10072419792413712,
-0.23171548545360565,
-0.33002862334251404,
0.35739895701408386,
0.15537813305854797,
0.8966916799545288,
-0.40507128834724426,
0.5074472427368164,
0.7487041354179382,
-0.4708724319934845,
-0.4218015968799591,
0.26023414731025696,
-0.027243778109550476,
-0.4014604091644287,
0.39145344495773315,
0.4412139058113098,
-0.03219005465507507,
0.2722415030002594,
-0.0719500258564949,
-0.757922887802124,
1.049259901046753,
0.058567967265844345,
-0.5949167609214783,
-0.44205087423324585,
0.08591881394386292,
0.506791889667511,
-0.3543604612350464,
0.19898204505443573,
0.409177303314209,
0.23810414969921112,
0.23102115094661713,
-0.39647868275642395,
-0.016476236283779144,
-0.6132378578186035,
-0.018778951838612556,
0.21635060012340546,
-0.3696540594100952,
0.48859432339668274,
-0.4234243631362915,
-0.12994767725467682,
0.18887510895729065,
1.0290061235427856,
-0.04538552463054657,
0.5641288757324219,
0.1364164650440216,
0.6468507647514343,
0.6454401612281799,
0.09052733331918716,
0.8372337222099304,
-0.4569559693336487,
0.07475043833255768,
1.4720046520233154,
-0.04432031884789467,
0.6879193186759949,
0.31255102157592773,
0.3039511442184448,
0.18267466127872467,
0.38490280508995056,
0.18124723434448242,
0.6696392297744751,
0.09155086427927017,
-0.2917444705963135,
0.15669052302837372,
-0.000687930267304182,
-0.42162853479385376,
0.26763734221458435,
0.30591943860054016,
-0.8494147062301636,
-0.3163907825946808,
0.10988033562898636,
-0.2741684317588806,
0.2815832495689392,
-0.6755945682525635,
1.2686501741409302,
0.209263414144516,
-0.8614141345024109,
0.227250337600708,
0.12733061611652374,
0.751020073890686,
-0.559249222278595,
0.06566626578569412,
-0.20735755562782288,
0.5078184008598328,
-0.3008771240711212,
-0.5201501250267029,
0.4936119019985199,
0.07236489653587341,
-0.6512279510498047,
-0.2553726136684418,
0.9622867703437805,
-0.581667423248291,
-0.5082922577857971,
0.008296008221805096,
0.31041574478149414,
-0.21860794723033905,
-0.39646586775779724,
-0.4513040781021118,
-0.3816237449645996,
-0.1086089015007019,
-0.2059955894947052,
0.27361923456192017,
0.5353175401687622,
0.15101616084575653,
0.3019929826259613,
0.26670587062835693,
-0.13411085307598114,
-0.25697413086891174,
0.22438669204711914,
0.7176467776298523,
-0.7631690502166748,
-1.047404408454895,
-0.9364709258079529,
0.6709147095680237,
-0.24948182702064514,
-0.37966373562812805,
0.5871753096580505,
0.6677839159965515,
0.46557584404945374,
-0.03249650076031685,
1.072677493095398,
0.09921733289957047,
0.45876631140708923,
-0.4946710765361786,
0.8528289198875427,
-0.3842400312423706,
0.17222681641578674,
-0.25939512252807617,
-0.7534765005111694,
-0.47146257758140564,
0.40606123208999634,
-0.1956723928451538,
-0.024602804332971573,
0.5956375002861023,
0.28109902143478394,
-0.022001294419169426,
0.061217837035655975,
0.14067599177360535,
0.08076377213001251,
0.030561745166778564,
0.5790336728096008,
0.5393736958503723,
-0.5479834079742432,
0.7060897946357727,
0.13107506930828094,
-0.17450366914272308,
-0.20313335955142975,
-0.850084125995636,
-1.050930142402649,
-0.5474295616149902,
-0.2794475555419922,
-0.16747726500034332,
0.2831787168979645,
0.870150089263916,
0.4546346068382263,
-0.8688728213310242,
0.054397109895944595,
-0.5103999972343445,
0.04542338848114014,
-0.09360764175653458,
-0.21514639258384705,
0.568778395652771,
-0.6311950087547302,
-0.5890378355979919,
0.19302628934383392,
0.49449339509010315,
0.15584710240364075,
0.040750280022621155,
0.10284097492694855,
-0.15313535928726196,
-0.09788674116134644,
0.8487873077392578,
0.33012229204177856,
-0.47388389706611633,
0.3325476050376892,
0.0009899016004055738,
-0.20210009813308716,
0.033206384629011154,
0.7768092751502991,
-0.8566725254058838,
0.21482576429843903,
0.6697648763656616,
0.9845802187919617,
0.3481466770172119,
0.12220504879951477,
0.91937255859375,
-0.8640843629837036,
0.1396314799785614,
0.5567173361778259,
0.24793922901153564,
0.18722423911094666,
-0.46294769644737244,
0.3602997660636902,
-0.0020004159305244684,
-0.18524664640426636,
-0.41730526089668274,
0.09535643458366394,
-0.8770447373390198,
-0.5194300413131714,
0.8489518761634827,
-0.19674141705036163,
-0.062308210879564285,
-0.19110795855522156,
-0.0775795504450798,
0.49190881848335266,
-0.49060913920402527,
0.9111586809158325,
0.3904964327812195,
0.12863442301750183,
-0.17544502019882202,
-0.08312945067882538,
0.41753607988357544,
0.48556891083717346,
-0.9363560080528259,
0.023933637887239456,
0.47190165519714355,
-0.04651337489485741,
0.13150407373905182,
0.5037239789962769,
-0.15017352998256683,
0.3878132700920105,
-0.5310912728309631,
-0.05525975301861763,
-0.5000384449958801,
-0.2735946774482727,
-0.7327377200126648,
0.4490455687046051,
-0.5678379535675049,
-0.17129722237586975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05720v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05720v1
|
Language-Independent Representations Improve Zero-Shot Summarization
| 2024-04-08T17:56:43 | 2024-04-08T17:56:43 |
Vladimir Solovyev, Danni Liu, Jan Niehues
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Finetuning pretrained models on downstream generation tasks often leads to
catastrophic forgetting in zero-shot conditions. In this work, we focus on
summarization and tackle the problem through the lens of language-independent
representations. After training on monolingual summarization, we perform
zero-shot transfer to new languages or language pairs. We first show naively
finetuned models are highly language-specific in both output behavior and
internal representations, resulting in poor zero-shot performance. Next, we
propose query-key (QK) finetuning to decouple task-specific knowledge from the
pretrained language generation abilities. Then, after showing downsides of the
standard adversarial language classifier, we propose a balanced variant that
more directly enforces language-agnostic representations. Moreover, our
qualitative analyses show removing source language identity correlates to
zero-shot summarization performance. Our code is openly available.
|
[
-0.25406983494758606,
-0.345517098903656,
0.2626155614852905,
0.09492148458957672,
-0.2584526538848877,
0.2647605538368225,
-0.4343065321445465,
-0.19781838357448578,
0.2815072238445282,
0.4190698266029358,
-0.3403123915195465,
-0.33171266317367554,
-0.6873401999473572,
0.048438046127557755,
-0.38092687726020813,
1.425045132637024,
0.04248818755149841,
-0.03873277083039284,
-0.14548546075820923,
-0.4048028588294983,
-0.4667990505695343,
-0.39257532358169556,
-0.6848816275596619,
-0.41075167059898376,
0.5643776655197144,
0.3397848904132843,
0.4124743938446045,
0.5517130494117737,
0.15875869989395142,
0.23110929131507874,
0.2489849328994751,
-0.2127877175807953,
-0.9553957581520081,
0.20022134482860565,
-0.26347246766090393,
-0.6444860696792603,
-0.2647080421447754,
-0.12691153585910797,
0.7790609002113342,
0.8385733962059021,
0.06220487132668495,
0.08230935037136078,
0.13705319166183472,
0.6818393468856812,
-0.9674376845359802,
0.4306561052799225,
-0.7313075661659241,
0.04275728762149811,
-0.04629970341920853,
-0.24498046934604645,
-0.39794689416885376,
-0.011644603684544563,
-0.12329808622598648,
-0.5588671565055847,
0.5498684048652649,
-0.6137798428535461,
0.7206259369850159,
0.2682546079158783,
-0.3734697103500366,
-0.04018937423825264,
-0.8481495976448059,
0.6475595235824585,
-0.6466166377067566,
0.10345139354467392,
0.22667807340621948,
0.25175219774246216,
0.31578245759010315,
-0.3432900011539459,
-0.26737016439437866,
-0.12176117300987244,
-0.09948871284723282,
0.4709013104438782,
-0.09874004870653152,
0.13037844002246857,
0.06690255552530289,
0.5361936092376709,
-0.5256898999214172,
-0.01843947172164917,
-0.5109483599662781,
-0.11402435600757599,
0.7642378807067871,
0.08028332889080048,
0.146950826048851,
-0.113443523645401,
0.06486357003450394,
0.03820972517132759,
-0.7683264017105103,
0.08934663236141205,
0.1560765951871872,
0.6276128888130188,
-0.14058473706245422,
0.5053229331970215,
-0.5579088926315308,
0.4201951324939728,
0.29733434319496155,
0.18846963346004486,
-0.07867511361837387,
-0.2968585789203644,
-0.23121920228004456,
0.2730656862258911,
0.9400684237480164,
0.11489934474229813,
0.4551640748977661,
-0.4436085522174835,
-0.03727026283740997,
-0.05881526321172714,
0.13353337347507477,
-0.8473931550979614,
-0.3372645080089569,
0.15252748131752014,
-0.046608638018369675,
-0.25896984338760376,
0.007012616842985153,
-0.20984987914562225,
-0.3387495279312134,
-0.16512060165405273,
0.6463137865066528,
-0.5473711490631104,
-0.3310592770576477,
0.07342690229415894,
-0.2733513116836548,
0.15877678990364075,
0.2953871488571167,
-1.0453532934188843,
0.12350285053253174,
0.27046963572502136,
0.7058498859405518,
0.09160639345645905,
-0.3826166093349457,
-0.6097500920295715,
0.369349867105484,
-0.46811941266059875,
0.6212002038955688,
-0.08284261077642441,
-0.2772201895713806,
-0.042743485420942307,
0.006468807812780142,
0.07870274782180786,
-0.3923512101173401,
-0.11202677339315414,
-0.3906902074813843,
0.316329687833786,
-0.35534754395484924,
-0.5606064796447754,
-0.2700551152229309,
0.1331234872341156,
-0.4864126741886139,
0.2953195869922638,
0.2045835256576538,
-0.5344644784927368,
0.34049397706985474,
-0.37226638197898865,
-0.5797749161720276,
0.15226493775844574,
-0.48273512721061707,
-0.26902949810028076,
0.43704941868782043,
0.31578823924064636,
0.5914738774299622,
0.11555255204439163,
0.171638622879982,
-0.18035006523132324,
-0.438775897026062,
-0.1777391880750656,
-0.43998846411705017,
0.7797154784202576,
0.10855026543140411,
-0.21893666684627533,
0.09245623648166656,
-0.7743752002716064,
-0.08969226479530334,
0.3484961986541748,
-0.1774965524673462,
-0.4333900511264801,
-0.15714006125926971,
-0.33954423666000366,
-0.09986306726932526,
0.27077552676200867,
-0.39921337366104126,
0.2977362275123596,
-0.601095974445343,
0.056662846356630325,
0.45242446660995483,
0.21993374824523926,
0.8666642308235168,
-0.23608025908470154,
0.5808603167533875,
0.22481516003608704,
-0.40654006600379944,
-0.7718709707260132,
0.01727437414228916,
-0.8161581158638,
-0.1437571942806244,
0.31976407766342163,
0.5016040802001953,
-1.0205415487289429,
-0.042577650398015976,
-0.2646312117576599,
-0.28628286719322205,
-0.551706850528717,
0.17281995713710785,
0.5975637435913086,
0.3619706928730011,
0.2589213252067566,
-0.35545456409454346,
-0.4204019606113434,
-0.736301064491272,
-0.3859718441963196,
0.019623195752501488,
-0.08475429564714432,
-0.28684574365615845,
0.21742920577526093,
0.1734905242919922,
0.7816213965415955,
-0.5940317511558533,
-0.4011556804180145,
-0.6563854217529297,
0.3617141842842102,
0.04898194596171379,
0.5384143590927124,
0.8416773676872253,
-0.25191688537597656,
-0.6925938725471497,
0.016222111880779266,
-1.0134111642837524,
0.10905288904905319,
-0.4692792296409607,
0.08002249151468277,
0.26816096901893616,
0.48427945375442505,
-0.6043140292167664,
0.32052096724510193,
0.23424500226974487,
-0.1915297657251358,
0.41652432084083557,
-0.3905235230922699,
0.12997685372829437,
-0.9917212128639221,
0.11487314850091934,
-0.16172944009304047,
-0.4936203956604004,
-0.6644332408905029,
0.32913464307785034,
0.10992724448442459,
-0.3558451533317566,
-0.40959447622299194,
0.38416242599487305,
-0.6959589719772339,
0.14788465201854706,
-0.33397457003593445,
0.13019415736198425,
0.03745114058256149,
0.7253639698028564,
0.039828453212976456,
0.6153196096420288,
0.7916022539138794,
-0.6573069095611572,
-0.1036255955696106,
0.11972469836473465,
0.028709612786769867,
0.3132673501968384,
-0.5557054281234741,
-0.14064791798591614,
-0.6823495030403137,
-0.022427596151828766,
-0.7859228849411011,
-0.3415440022945404,
0.08167582750320435,
-0.6692032217979431,
0.8693600296974182,
-0.27142056822776794,
-0.07934276759624481,
0.1237647607922554,
-0.49775874614715576,
0.2871948480606079,
0.46605876088142395,
-0.15879258513450623,
0.27576616406440735,
0.1974722146987915,
-0.3603120446205139,
-0.6982135772705078,
-0.9014049768447876,
-0.10237018018960953,
0.1324007362127304,
-0.14625512063503265,
0.24848036468029022,
0.1776677519083023,
0.016547271981835365,
0.20012925565242767,
-0.22537192702293396,
-0.03926429897546768,
0.0445525236427784,
0.04476388171315193,
-0.005941870156675577,
-0.3865208029747009,
0.08643341809511185,
0.10973212122917175,
-0.20763231813907623,
-0.1420038491487503,
-0.19871549308300018,
0.39600351452827454,
0.017691053450107574,
-0.20806899666786194,
-0.16220778226852417,
0.7066400647163391,
0.6239538192749023,
-0.4355848729610443,
0.7096791863441467,
0.5522550940513611,
-0.27119606733322144,
-0.1800457239151001,
-0.30486223101615906,
-0.010583898052573204,
-0.3883938193321228,
0.5898381471633911,
-0.2018142193555832,
-0.9345732927322388,
0.7890757322311401,
0.334247887134552,
0.21189817786216736,
0.6594969630241394,
0.4745386242866516,
-0.14524126052856445,
0.8523346185684204,
0.9559178948402405,
-0.3061745762825012,
0.5978342890739441,
-0.5928953886032104,
0.14165134727954865,
-0.5375695824623108,
0.1496611088514328,
-0.10403569042682648,
-0.2028590440750122,
-0.40183237195014954,
-0.08961407840251923,
0.23464249074459076,
0.44625699520111084,
-0.28272733092308044,
0.34236109256744385,
-0.30506640672683716,
0.7809271812438965,
0.4777313470840454,
-0.15729200839996338,
0.33751556277275085,
0.054906781762838364,
0.11084805428981781,
0.10922934114933014,
-0.9146683216094971,
-0.07034959644079208,
1.1878852844238281,
-0.0772186890244484,
0.6130818128585815,
0.06368761509656906,
1.2215639352798462,
0.15112322568893433,
0.27076664566993713,
-0.7526153922080994,
0.4024137556552887,
-0.5088854432106018,
-0.49096423387527466,
-0.15234375,
-0.6691787838935852,
-0.9079090356826782,
0.25549980998039246,
0.024900950491428375,
-0.595897376537323,
0.10972348600625992,
0.2077171504497528,
-0.8369611501693726,
0.21829472482204437,
-0.8620959520339966,
0.8808839917182922,
-0.035869549959897995,
-0.3478074371814728,
-0.24284423887729645,
-0.41066089272499084,
0.5852486491203308,
0.19068486988544464,
-0.1365537941455841,
-0.10392943769693375,
0.2829381823539734,
0.4290086030960083,
-0.3664073348045349,
0.8244652152061462,
-0.31945085525512695,
0.10103589296340942,
0.45933786034584045,
0.2996697425842285,
0.18548710644245148,
0.08722003549337387,
0.17254243791103363,
0.044592443853616714,
0.0597291961312294,
-0.421006441116333,
-0.5728733539581299,
0.7473572492599487,
-0.689132809638977,
-0.5671025514602661,
-0.3807987868785858,
-0.5233484506607056,
-0.2134426385164261,
0.4157097041606903,
0.584336519241333,
0.44391438364982605,
-0.4114435911178589,
0.17366456985473633,
0.4898889362812042,
-0.1086597591638565,
0.7097566723823547,
0.6649575233459473,
-0.2776804566383362,
-0.3300653100013733,
1.1359398365020752,
0.5041990280151367,
0.3552027940750122,
0.508127748966217,
-0.024807121604681015,
-0.035631585866212845,
-0.5781913995742798,
-0.5515799522399902,
0.15542221069335938,
-0.7176680564880371,
-0.38786351680755615,
-0.4897822141647339,
-0.4309815764427185,
-0.5701622366905212,
-0.32298338413238525,
-0.5813978910446167,
-0.7322854399681091,
-0.39305299520492554,
-0.07144325971603394,
0.2088606357574463,
0.6545507311820984,
-0.22566205263137817,
0.33958882093429565,
-0.865172803401947,
0.6030484437942505,
0.3877217173576355,
0.27042195200920105,
0.081341452896595,
-0.42599552869796753,
-0.5639380216598511,
0.0016653607599437237,
-0.36774179339408875,
-0.8131649494171143,
0.34375,
0.5266388654708862,
0.5487214922904968,
0.4715954661369324,
0.2154131382703781,
0.8014448881149292,
-0.3607300817966461,
0.7070568799972534,
0.4463638663291931,
-0.8657344579696655,
0.48111146688461304,
-0.6091362833976746,
0.9777253270149231,
0.8110504150390625,
0.38004544377326965,
-0.5413163304328918,
-0.8713642358779907,
-0.5010879039764404,
-0.7678161263465881,
0.9198791980743408,
0.17684036493301392,
0.19316479563713074,
-0.044261593371629715,
0.3408125340938568,
0.17525343596935272,
0.15514053404331207,
-0.8249534964561462,
-0.2714439928531647,
-0.4479205012321472,
-0.2755226492881775,
-0.33594465255737305,
-0.1984221637248993,
0.10275153815746307,
-0.2610476613044739,
0.49725645780563354,
-0.21186910569667816,
0.2151569426059723,
0.22760510444641113,
-0.398897260427475,
-0.12212879210710526,
0.2949298918247223,
0.500956118106842,
0.3526509404182434,
-0.12291046231985092,
0.14198793470859528,
-0.03584665060043335,
-0.3403463363647461,
0.18992920219898224,
0.12853659689426422,
-0.5085753202438354,
0.0929744765162468,
0.5169782638549805,
0.6862918734550476,
0.2620149552822113,
-0.40107738971710205,
0.560735285282135,
-0.061222076416015625,
-0.17594094574451447,
-0.06810169667005539,
0.2094862163066864,
0.08968131989240646,
0.004993679467588663,
0.33322635293006897,
0.3615264296531677,
0.09531407058238983,
-0.6774206161499023,
0.1571846902370453,
0.35321909189224243,
-0.3183894753456116,
-0.510216236114502,
0.6928516626358032,
0.15058566629886627,
0.18511635065078735,
0.26801568269729614,
-0.6857442259788513,
-0.2484852522611618,
0.4511352479457855,
0.38068127632141113,
1.1864449977874756,
-0.3666492700576782,
0.23311345279216766,
0.5421996712684631,
0.1748696267604828,
0.04701625928282738,
0.2000414878129959,
-0.36607837677001953,
-0.647783100605011,
-0.662577748298645,
-0.31251633167266846,
-0.1872229278087616,
0.00527595542371273,
-0.7432960867881775,
0.2308320552110672,
-0.48755353689193726,
0.09393471479415894,
-0.155427485704422,
-0.039510805159807205,
-0.6542758345603943,
-0.0908830314874649,
0.2813781499862671,
0.42756208777427673,
-0.6029955744743347,
0.7476227283477783,
0.5855700373649597,
-0.863041877746582,
-0.6285709142684937,
-0.1092785969376564,
0.027043579146265984,
-0.5710040926933289,
0.2928124666213989,
0.025825902819633484,
-0.18594834208488464,
0.006249038968235254,
-0.3343014419078827,
-0.7056313157081604,
0.9487338662147522,
0.8725115060806274,
-0.5360501408576965,
-0.09086944162845612,
0.1711931675672531,
0.42810899019241333,
-0.21166802942752838,
0.10666082799434662,
0.38934585452079773,
-0.16190864145755768,
-0.028980204835534096,
-0.7826414108276367,
-0.19784210622310638,
-0.06745656579732895,
-0.16591855883598328,
0.1861208826303482,
-0.5819370746612549,
0.923055112361908,
-0.2794409990310669,
-0.586323618888855,
-0.08635002374649048,
0.6459493637084961,
-0.1318821758031845,
0.23568788170814514,
-0.1391276717185974,
0.5907658338546753,
0.4572291970252991,
-0.020622050389647484,
1.0027540922164917,
-0.36511683464050293,
0.3666756749153137,
1.6802164316177368,
0.06702449917793274,
0.7588284015655518,
0.2920827269554138,
0.0726720318198204,
0.1634034663438797,
0.05454317107796669,
0.3226657211780548,
0.8117251992225647,
-0.14813102781772614,
-0.45948657393455505,
-0.10750208795070648,
0.115195132791996,
-0.4049074351787567,
0.6899407505989075,
0.11735038459300995,
-0.3385040760040283,
-0.8573237061500549,
0.15182806551456451,
0.12271229177713394,
0.12398795038461685,
-0.6229147911071777,
1.1223423480987549,
0.019371984526515007,
-0.7714986205101013,
0.9299443960189819,
-0.08416830748319626,
0.6086080074310303,
-0.8641713261604309,
0.05768296495079994,
-0.5808626413345337,
0.299965500831604,
-0.16013333201408386,
-0.6005443334579468,
0.6505447626113892,
0.06270533800125122,
-0.3012358546257019,
-0.4248802363872528,
0.7538198828697205,
-0.841823399066925,
-0.3787236511707306,
0.04920501634478569,
0.6371662020683289,
0.040990374982357025,
-0.4600362181663513,
-0.27965542674064636,
-0.25696665048599243,
0.2481432408094406,
-0.027060816064476967,
0.44512805342674255,
0.5771850943565369,
0.07563818246126175,
0.39789411425590515,
0.2493099719285965,
0.1663978397846222,
0.160946786403656,
0.3012875020503998,
0.7590206265449524,
-0.7227969169616699,
-0.5206750631332397,
-0.9118945598602295,
0.5371474027633667,
0.14102569222450256,
-0.1790752410888672,
0.754833459854126,
0.5315913558006287,
0.9354050159454346,
-0.4162932336330414,
0.8472893238067627,
-0.06258741766214371,
0.09206422418355942,
-0.3946762681007385,
1.2941431999206543,
-0.45609235763549805,
-0.10335104912519455,
-0.07507243752479553,
-0.6270022392272949,
-0.5282770395278931,
0.429530531167984,
-0.10749980807304382,
-0.20781469345092773,
0.44799014925956726,
0.5262159109115601,
-0.07920466363430023,
-0.3483024835586548,
0.6242187023162842,
0.16825571656227112,
0.27173739671707153,
0.765131950378418,
0.6558383107185364,
-0.564886748790741,
0.6074225306510925,
-0.39385706186294556,
-0.12695445120334625,
-0.08365491032600403,
-0.8572553396224976,
-0.8100131154060364,
-0.5406244993209839,
-0.6298385262489319,
0.2067662924528122,
-0.06910470128059387,
0.5643529891967773,
0.6560593843460083,
-0.866412341594696,
-0.2905830144882202,
-0.2953498363494873,
0.11865682154893875,
-0.2162463217973709,
-0.23960088193416595,
0.10251002013683319,
-0.8123285174369812,
-0.4460361897945404,
0.380787193775177,
0.5413516759872437,
0.21963824331760406,
-0.45209717750549316,
0.029605600982904434,
0.1094883382320404,
-0.023358700796961784,
0.8126505613327026,
0.6837143898010254,
-0.4080701768398285,
-0.0830128863453865,
-0.2440165877342224,
0.055887620896101,
0.13230259716510773,
0.8623089790344238,
-0.9426737427711487,
0.6804262399673462,
0.5467691421508789,
0.5906409621238708,
0.4807588458061218,
-0.26025766134262085,
0.7389421463012695,
-1.1868672370910645,
0.4202471375465393,
0.3371484577655792,
0.4208579957485199,
0.3163324296474457,
-0.332402765750885,
0.1502489447593689,
0.04394108057022095,
-0.15112493932247162,
-0.4801941514015198,
0.14760777354240417,
-0.8971835970878601,
-0.2659244239330292,
0.6653775572776794,
-0.3368968069553375,
-0.16015617549419403,
0.07106795907020569,
0.00024685118114575744,
0.46913692355155945,
-0.2829725742340088,
0.6792212724685669,
0.6269465088844299,
-0.05730351060628891,
-0.4184613525867462,
-0.34028294682502747,
0.4569947421550751,
0.4006333649158478,
-0.44111230969429016,
0.28838902711868286,
0.47059768438339233,
0.32897478342056274,
0.22389662265777588,
0.9902649521827698,
-0.25018686056137085,
0.3591804802417755,
0.08905156701803207,
0.2741313576698303,
-0.3172917366027832,
-0.2672129273414612,
-0.6328158974647522,
0.3962235748767853,
0.12648607790470123,
-0.302912175655365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05719v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05719v1
|
Ferret-UI: Grounded Mobile UI Understanding with Multimodal LLMs
| 2024-04-08T17:55:44 | 2024-04-08T17:55:44 |
Keen You, Haotian Zhang, Eldon Schoop, Floris Weers, Amanda Swearngin, Jeffrey Nichols, Yinfei Yang, Zhe Gan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Recent advancements in multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have been
noteworthy, yet, these general-domain MLLMs often fall short in their ability
to comprehend and interact effectively with user interface (UI) screens. In
this paper, we present Ferret-UI, a new MLLM tailored for enhanced
understanding of mobile UI screens, equipped with referring, grounding, and
reasoning capabilities. Given that UI screens typically exhibit a more
elongated aspect ratio and contain smaller objects of interest (e.g., icons,
texts) than natural images, we incorporate "any resolution" on top of Ferret to
magnify details and leverage enhanced visual features. Specifically, each
screen is divided into 2 sub-images based on the original aspect ratio (i.e.,
horizontal division for portrait screens and vertical division for landscape
screens). Both sub-images are encoded separately before being sent to LLMs. We
meticulously gather training samples from an extensive range of elementary UI
tasks, such as icon recognition, find text, and widget listing. These samples
are formatted for instruction-following with region annotations to facilitate
precise referring and grounding. To augment the model's reasoning ability, we
further compile a dataset for advanced tasks, including detailed description,
perception/interaction conversations, and function inference. After training on
the curated datasets, Ferret-UI exhibits outstanding comprehension of UI
screens and the capability to execute open-ended instructions. For model
evaluation, we establish a comprehensive benchmark encompassing all the
aforementioned tasks. Ferret-UI excels not only beyond most open-source UI
MLLMs, but also surpasses GPT-4V on all the elementary UI tasks.
|
[
-0.5731778144836426,
-0.6742055416107178,
0.5696855783462524,
0.25661152601242065,
-0.1710198074579239,
0.15899376571178436,
-0.2183789759874344,
-0.16927126049995422,
0.12388263642787933,
0.45904257893562317,
-0.6721075773239136,
-0.5382121801376343,
-0.0004202386480756104,
-0.06454308331012726,
-0.11160371452569962,
0.7660306692123413,
0.037988513708114624,
-0.12564964592456818,
-0.7037273645401001,
-0.15727120637893677,
-0.42238447070121765,
-0.5290052890777588,
-0.12962694466114044,
-0.47532472014427185,
0.48903581500053406,
0.7092223763465881,
0.9581140279769897,
0.4291844666004181,
0.2544243037700653,
0.2756403982639313,
0.024261070415377617,
0.41102316975593567,
-0.5482067465782166,
0.13842783868312836,
-0.21482792496681213,
-0.21374571323394775,
-0.38474634289741516,
0.1628909707069397,
0.4554147720336914,
0.5111884474754333,
0.22979916632175446,
0.05285981297492981,
-0.04131055995821953,
0.6136108040809631,
-0.5803301334381104,
0.13053618371486664,
-0.5986670851707458,
0.07383347302675247,
0.1558304727077484,
-0.13014379143714905,
-0.5096216201782227,
0.17998206615447998,
-0.23075732588768005,
-1.0656059980392456,
0.07425971329212189,
0.15043587982654572,
0.7803253531455994,
0.35969260334968567,
-0.850269079208374,
0.008640198037028313,
-0.3917340338230133,
0.8827657103538513,
-0.26889947056770325,
0.8015066981315613,
0.39839911460876465,
0.24900266528129578,
-0.3784100115299225,
-0.7251800298690796,
-0.6607896685600281,
-0.5482173562049866,
-0.00671541178599,
0.03230159357190132,
0.16482992470264435,
0.2294941544532776,
0.4243224561214447,
0.5325961112976074,
-0.4871068298816681,
-0.20758585631847382,
-0.1079767718911171,
-0.4576086699962616,
0.44311192631721497,
0.15367281436920166,
0.4323231279850006,
-0.014591849409043789,
-0.5012351274490356,
0.18239864706993103,
-0.5839805006980896,
0.38808685541152954,
-0.09339488297700882,
-0.07432026416063309,
-0.27591389417648315,
0.7292953133583069,
-0.4754841923713684,
0.65337073802948,
0.26439276337623596,
-0.30648791790008545,
0.43027397990226746,
-0.5021885633468628,
-0.2870038151741028,
-0.37791678309440613,
0.6759291291236877,
0.6676455140113831,
0.108831986784935,
-0.2574617862701416,
0.014524392783641815,
-0.11077772080898285,
0.2617776691913605,
-0.738211452960968,
-0.2654426097869873,
0.2113957405090332,
-0.6110592484474182,
-0.378121942281723,
-0.27322039008140564,
-0.4971481263637543,
-0.8479099273681641,
-0.4973011910915375,
0.13035568594932556,
-0.3165655732154846,
-0.40004515647888184,
-0.12310049682855606,
-0.008570676669478416,
0.33549752831459045,
0.6787776947021484,
-0.9207932949066162,
0.07957292348146439,
0.44815701246261597,
0.7441633343696594,
-0.19385428726673126,
-0.24513423442840576,
-0.8544142246246338,
-0.04942169785499573,
-0.2729989290237427,
0.752299427986145,
-0.5472596883773804,
-0.33235546946525574,
-0.37951743602752686,
0.03238469734787941,
-0.21480195224285126,
-0.12885773181915283,
0.7202345728874207,
-0.2479788362979889,
-0.006267474964261055,
-0.016564853489398956,
-0.1059110164642334,
-0.5154257416725159,
0.44854283332824707,
-0.5143822431564331,
1.1029878854751587,
0.12742450833320618,
-0.9145973324775696,
0.14868570864200592,
-0.5493109226226807,
-0.39757609367370605,
-0.09352002292871475,
-0.3541874289512634,
-0.13219203054904938,
0.17349471151828766,
0.4502424895763397,
0.5515326857566833,
-0.16593027114868164,
0.05674191191792488,
-0.49890002608299255,
-0.37362879514694214,
0.1848917156457901,
-0.43133628368377686,
0.5427021980285645,
0.2665044069290161,
-0.3621334433555603,
0.3477318584918976,
-0.8198413252830505,
0.3632194697856903,
-0.13062992691993713,
-0.3074949383735657,
-0.2756524384021759,
0.10175689309835434,
0.21098554134368896,
0.5332574248313904,
0.22958464920520782,
-0.5137836337089539,
0.1344144642353058,
-0.1076277419924736,
0.6142764687538147,
0.3652327060699463,
-0.31051966547966003,
0.8523519039154053,
-0.2375137060880661,
0.4424078166484833,
-0.01782308518886566,
0.20528092980384827,
-0.6894513964653015,
-0.4477052390575409,
-0.7072044014930725,
-0.5188865065574646,
0.12462660670280457,
0.6142457723617554,
-0.9972221255302429,
0.0462370440363884,
-0.4645850658416748,
-0.34165439009666443,
-0.09364209324121475,
0.2515728175640106,
0.2784540057182312,
0.6271724700927734,
0.24068918824195862,
0.026467587798833847,
-0.25747448205947876,
-0.7263661026954651,
0.005785476882010698,
-0.09489233791828156,
-0.2105388194322586,
0.5393363833427429,
0.5382990837097168,
-0.5468538403511047,
1.1260101795196533,
0.01357139740139246,
-0.1585995852947235,
-0.22181297838687897,
-0.008190435357391834,
0.24962806701660156,
0.4573113024234772,
0.5262822508811951,
-0.9905520081520081,
-0.35334664583206177,
0.5408638119697571,
-0.8603276014328003,
-0.13080917298793793,
-0.4406718313694,
-0.20791785418987274,
-0.06828545778989792,
0.4090930223464966,
-0.8663220405578613,
0.58079993724823,
0.4388916492462158,
-0.632962703704834,
0.6114612817764282,
-0.06438332796096802,
0.2685313820838928,
-0.8598492741584778,
0.01142113097012043,
0.0971946269273758,
-0.5606785416603088,
-0.6837769746780396,
0.32325953245162964,
0.4224292039871216,
-0.19724667072296143,
-0.4799802303314209,
0.7201029062271118,
-0.4779561161994934,
-0.20892120897769928,
-0.2946001887321472,
0.0373980775475502,
0.4466039538383484,
0.620128870010376,
0.12877868115901947,
1.0570778846740723,
0.21560117602348328,
-0.41275539994239807,
0.5506186485290527,
0.25911039113998413,
-0.10375390946865082,
0.5959044098854065,
-0.5958301424980164,
0.16131003201007843,
0.016592951491475105,
0.3080558180809021,
-1.0715256929397583,
-0.3361985981464386,
0.11141368746757507,
-0.578657329082489,
-0.040263377130031586,
-0.17035162448883057,
-0.3084895610809326,
-0.2054954171180725,
-0.5443170070648193,
0.14443348348140717,
0.11061938107013702,
-0.6430969834327698,
1.3056854009628296,
0.15613913536071777,
-0.13094662129878998,
-0.7045068144798279,
-0.353596568107605,
0.028621092438697815,
-0.248310849070549,
-0.9977643489837646,
0.3836371898651123,
-0.045076366513967514,
-0.323144793510437,
-0.32422947883605957,
-0.32938534021377563,
-0.1698334515094757,
0.24164947867393494,
0.7693138718605042,
0.15073804557323456,
-0.3160427510738373,
0.23501281440258026,
0.26083600521087646,
0.032542504370212555,
-0.01263895258307457,
0.005189648363739252,
0.3204062581062317,
-0.3715817928314209,
-0.40309938788414,
-0.44911402463912964,
0.27875030040740967,
1.076944351196289,
-0.3627922236919403,
0.3949532210826874,
0.8998109698295593,
-0.31263428926467896,
0.3208247125148773,
-0.5626326203346252,
0.08510885387659073,
-0.4689253866672516,
0.1635497808456421,
-0.8610848188400269,
-0.761543333530426,
0.6057915687561035,
-0.3550053536891937,
0.4214403033256531,
0.17374560236930847,
0.5042421221733093,
-0.33713772892951965,
1.223364233970642,
0.522997260093689,
0.013149639591574669,
0.5107693672180176,
-0.2433767318725586,
-0.10015052556991577,
-0.9336592555046082,
-0.43177977204322815,
-0.2627532482147217,
-0.051507893949747086,
-0.17035438120365143,
-0.668070912361145,
0.24645042419433594,
0.36697620153427124,
-0.5199695229530334,
-0.17934268712997437,
-0.24888622760772705,
0.5453996658325195,
0.615136444568634,
0.36219340562820435,
0.45651954412460327,
0.1995033174753189,
-0.5727062821388245,
-0.04261324927210808,
-0.5132079124450684,
-0.6509898900985718,
0.9170795679092407,
0.7516517043113708,
1.0856287479400635,
-0.04806235060095787,
0.28334948420524597,
0.38680508732795715,
0.4366259276866913,
-0.9480690956115723,
0.4232412874698639,
0.13840250670909882,
-0.42286235094070435,
-0.1825263798236847,
-0.2152809053659439,
-0.3895915448665619,
0.8753670454025269,
-0.5498400926589966,
-0.698315441608429,
0.04703374579548836,
0.16041839122772217,
-0.2454337626695633,
-0.017284566536545753,
-0.9502116441726685,
0.9130145311355591,
-0.4394146800041199,
-0.696370005607605,
-0.06809993088245392,
-0.4291917085647583,
0.4837227761745453,
0.16864614188671112,
0.4954245984554291,
-0.38834282755851746,
-0.12244033813476562,
0.30533188581466675,
-0.4262675344944,
0.6952672004699707,
-0.17946968972682953,
-0.1438160091638565,
0.01025660615414381,
0.06070919707417488,
0.37370195984840393,
0.493986040353775,
-0.02401687577366829,
0.06500376760959625,
-0.07851891964673996,
-0.23109962046146393,
-0.6947348713874817,
0.7923611998558044,
-0.6966310739517212,
-0.49829545617103577,
-0.3013322949409485,
-0.6872355341911316,
-0.2085351049900055,
0.2972654700279236,
0.08134330064058304,
0.6059930920600891,
-0.041460853070020676,
0.3873933255672455,
0.7521042823791504,
-0.3282260596752167,
0.11371784657239914,
0.2539694309234619,
-0.5828418731689453,
-0.41813191771507263,
0.7255011796951294,
-0.5078845620155334,
-0.006886580493301153,
0.38599586486816406,
-0.09892065823078156,
-0.6921938061714172,
-0.34922078251838684,
-0.9064636826515198,
0.007429783698171377,
-0.7724003791809082,
-0.19984669983386993,
-0.6952944397926331,
0.0335547961294651,
-0.254800409078598,
-0.24272415041923523,
-0.18332326412200928,
-0.45329549908638,
-0.4157898426055908,
-0.0060961428098380566,
0.3846947252750397,
0.42493388056755066,
0.06678511947393417,
0.42973190546035767,
-0.6400365233421326,
0.798483669757843,
0.4285212755203247,
0.15098316967487335,
-0.22634045779705048,
-0.5947561860084534,
-0.1587069183588028,
0.4793567657470703,
-0.5268993377685547,
-0.6647021174430847,
0.13276487588882446,
0.4434681832790375,
0.7432378530502319,
0.4658568799495697,
0.10234586149454117,
0.7674585580825806,
-0.5957597494125366,
0.7372626662254333,
0.463655561208725,
-0.9313913583755493,
0.41713258624076843,
-0.517926812171936,
0.38145413994789124,
0.31218835711479187,
0.04494275152683258,
-0.4281558096408844,
-0.24299220740795135,
-0.05025497078895569,
-0.6023446917533875,
0.48255255818367004,
0.31497859954833984,
0.40990954637527466,
0.21242935955524445,
0.2213398516178131,
-0.0625743567943573,
-0.05229688063263893,
-0.8068912625312805,
-0.09886054694652557,
-0.6809628009796143,
-0.28246188163757324,
0.019652921706438065,
-0.18706898391246796,
0.0031992520671337843,
-0.5023273229598999,
0.3689655661582947,
-0.4060133099555969,
0.31078702211380005,
0.043667107820510864,
-0.6516390442848206,
0.2894899547100067,
0.25743815302848816,
0.7037194967269897,
0.6531537175178528,
0.05925014615058899,
0.1837923675775528,
0.16367699205875397,
-0.6698707938194275,
0.3447192311286926,
0.1328744888305664,
0.2588975727558136,
0.17566385865211487,
0.1857537031173706,
0.719011127948761,
0.3616013824939728,
-0.8175797462463379,
0.5083743929862976,
-0.25839316844940186,
-0.29817357659339905,
-0.29024410247802734,
0.06062547490000725,
0.03734031319618225,
0.3952944874763489,
0.6653863191604614,
-0.1747860312461853,
0.17120632529258728,
-0.3468724489212036,
0.15072296559810638,
0.4361668527126312,
-0.19701595604419708,
-0.018406422808766365,
0.7605175375938416,
0.6652474403381348,
0.019240444526076317,
0.7064314484596252,
0.0022251729387789965,
-0.503736674785614,
0.5554383397102356,
0.36620333790779114,
0.44884416460990906,
-0.07402495294809341,
0.35472390055656433,
0.2320544421672821,
0.2793351113796234,
0.21791596710681915,
0.3236987888813019,
-0.49846914410591125,
-0.665569543838501,
-0.7333734631538391,
-0.35699597001075745,
-0.4320988059043884,
0.2256481945514679,
-0.5391629934310913,
0.1077493354678154,
-0.4884188771247864,
-0.34363579750061035,
0.1251228004693985,
-0.16242283582687378,
-0.5675410628318787,
0.24232451617717743,
0.15392617881298065,
1.0183820724487305,
-0.504045307636261,
0.7081475257873535,
1.0054212808609009,
-0.1725665032863617,
-0.5357266068458557,
-0.21276380121707916,
0.04534976929426193,
-0.4693092703819275,
0.7442736625671387,
0.584692656993866,
-0.34801316261291504,
-0.015266455709934235,
-0.3800998032093048,
-0.6543682217597961,
1.0650914907455444,
0.2641792595386505,
-0.47961392998695374,
-0.11051416397094727,
-0.04218616709113121,
0.1454385221004486,
-0.4538643956184387,
0.5764096975326538,
0.3284286558628082,
0.23042064905166626,
0.01622936688363552,
-1.1273399591445923,
-0.1680857539176941,
-0.6077346801757812,
0.087241992354393,
0.024095242843031883,
-0.23182182013988495,
0.8569707274436951,
-0.41313299536705017,
-0.07994438707828522,
0.15862268209457397,
0.675412654876709,
0.30113229155540466,
0.630001962184906,
0.4809800982475281,
0.4059275686740875,
0.6406702995300293,
-0.1343269795179367,
0.6605587005615234,
-0.18535800278186798,
0.28077349066734314,
1.1417698860168457,
-0.27585017681121826,
0.745749831199646,
0.5126318335533142,
0.08755667507648468,
0.5284198522567749,
0.7629812359809875,
0.5562992691993713,
0.5157886743545532,
-0.018174320459365845,
-0.3883061110973358,
-0.5749332308769226,
-0.03798883408308029,
-0.4724319577217102,
0.4255395233631134,
0.7690284848213196,
-0.4524070918560028,
-0.2815306484699249,
0.6007393002510071,
-0.3395878076553345,
0.20064802467823029,
-0.650469183921814,
0.6782799363136292,
-0.03002483956515789,
-0.21177171170711517,
0.8992739915847778,
0.059828147292137146,
0.7296683192253113,
-0.19111944735050201,
-0.2547500729560852,
-0.33355847001075745,
0.05204671248793602,
-0.43458300828933716,
-0.8171488642692566,
0.010112473741173744,
0.15754789113998413,
-0.396047979593277,
-0.2583977282047272,
1.054073691368103,
-0.14316654205322266,
-0.23924948275089264,
-0.15875916182994843,
0.4419804811477661,
0.1470581293106079,
-0.4203324615955353,
-0.7142073512077332,
0.23518981039524078,
0.06626305729150772,
-0.166598379611969,
0.10201199352741241,
0.4112350344657898,
-0.33862510323524475,
1.1208139657974243,
0.7273616790771484,
-0.6102517247200012,
0.17883120477199554,
-0.10567796975374222,
1.089843511581421,
-0.520417332649231,
-0.5356852412223816,
-0.6061355471611023,
0.7578207850456238,
-0.29473158717155457,
-0.11677440255880356,
0.6357935070991516,
0.6177010536193848,
0.6292735934257507,
-0.14887259900569916,
0.8713029026985168,
-0.010707875713706017,
0.35830554366111755,
-0.6324381828308105,
0.6407470107078552,
-0.5594509243965149,
-0.02675391361117363,
0.002114009577780962,
-0.7849137783050537,
-0.047839563339948654,
1.1529905796051025,
-0.41331207752227783,
-0.16814285516738892,
0.520840048789978,
0.59243243932724,
-0.3757725954055786,
-0.04669054597616196,
0.4723481237888336,
-0.19886301457881927,
0.1725330948829651,
0.5886224508285522,
1.1459004878997803,
-0.21611244976520538,
0.5896636843681335,
-0.2105308622121811,
-0.2955823242664337,
-0.330839067697525,
-0.7748667597770691,
-1.2664275169372559,
-0.4658542275428772,
-0.053616564720869064,
-0.27173542976379395,
-0.13060030341148376,
0.9349961280822754,
0.954709529876709,
-0.4543614983558655,
0.11379005759954453,
-0.040200915187597275,
0.3804873526096344,
0.030559036880731583,
-0.22175370156764984,
-0.11721716821193695,
-0.27997592091560364,
-0.5064371228218079,
0.3377210795879364,
0.16173110902309418,
0.058121562004089355,
-0.23487049341201782,
-0.35929733514785767,
0.10979888588190079,
-0.31834331154823303,
1.0705770254135132,
0.30686941742897034,
-0.9553965926170349,
-0.16789817810058594,
0.21118080615997314,
-0.22612057626247406,
-0.019871914759278297,
0.825573742389679,
-0.9884205460548401,
0.49478432536125183,
0.2681002914905548,
0.6446799039840698,
0.3698873221874237,
0.14492705464363098,
0.5595957040786743,
-0.6688095331192017,
0.4155314564704895,
0.03497030586004257,
0.28194260597229004,
0.26963531970977783,
-0.441114217042923,
0.505461573600769,
-0.04324907436966896,
-0.32131028175354004,
-0.7332698106765747,
0.19058917462825775,
-0.9995271563529968,
-0.14036035537719727,
1.2925533056259155,
-0.34383901953697205,
-0.028767669573426247,
-0.4958318769931793,
-0.678642213344574,
-0.16009113192558289,
-0.4302571415901184,
0.39247092604637146,
0.639305055141449,
-0.13795486092567444,
-0.6611737012863159,
-0.7083596587181091,
0.19598785042762756,
0.02782558836042881,
-0.8503282070159912,
-0.07945172488689423,
0.7921114563941956,
0.2764640152454376,
0.16588668525218964,
0.6640777587890625,
0.12918035686016083,
0.6553559303283691,
-0.1396133452653885,
-0.0034417309798300266,
-0.40470677614212036,
-0.30805936455726624,
-0.13480500876903534,
-0.12590226531028748,
0.021003205329179764,
-0.39116182923316956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05783v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05783v1
|
Responsible Generative AI: What to Generate and What Not
| 2024-04-08T17:53:21 | 2024-04-08T17:53:21 |
Jindong Gu
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In recent years, generative AI (GenAI), like large language models and
text-to-image models, has received significant attention across various
domains. However, ensuring the responsible generation of content by these
models is crucial for their real-world applicability. This raises an
interesting question: \textit{What should responsible GenAI generate, and what
should it not?} To answer the question, this paper investigates the practical
responsible requirements of both textual and visual generative models,
outlining five key considerations: generating truthful content, avoiding toxic
content, refusing harmful instruction, leaking no training data-related
content, and ensuring generated content identifiable. Specifically, we review
recent advancements and challenges in addressing these requirements. Besides,
we discuss and emphasize the importance of responsible GenAI across healthcare,
education, finance, and artificial general intelligence domains. Through a
unified perspective on both textual and visual generative models, this paper
aims to provide insights into practical safety-related issues and further
benefit the community in building responsible GenAI.
|
[
-0.07558757811784744,
-0.5829758048057556,
0.5038744807243347,
0.09896361827850342,
-0.15182334184646606,
-0.5619982481002808,
0.2274230271577835,
-0.5608123540878296,
-0.3398441970348358,
0.6444395780563354,
-0.481770396232605,
-0.19415414333343506,
-0.5414978861808777,
-0.02336920239031315,
-0.5609530806541443,
1.168270468711853,
-0.003508571535348892,
-0.214105024933815,
-0.6551313996315002,
0.09777215868234634,
-0.8816184401512146,
-0.39313462376594543,
-0.88482266664505,
-0.18116633594036102,
0.7475361824035645,
0.4631991386413574,
0.5905591249465942,
0.7985625267028809,
0.5546678900718689,
0.31713545322418213,
0.32916125655174255,
0.09150484949350357,
-0.6496948599815369,
0.25652459263801575,
-0.278216153383255,
-0.29517024755477905,
-0.4068171977996826,
0.16953234374523163,
0.3526993691921234,
0.36194321513175964,
-0.03603086248040199,
0.2554626166820526,
-0.019971651956439018,
0.7478150129318237,
-0.6929696202278137,
0.303116112947464,
-0.3151824474334717,
0.13581040501594543,
-0.4293958842754364,
-0.33321863412857056,
-0.5919836163520813,
-0.407376766204834,
-0.09947536140680313,
-0.8913886547088623,
0.5137367248535156,
-0.24357420206069946,
0.8467621803283691,
0.4827420115470886,
-0.6658810377120972,
-0.30234113335609436,
-1.0487474203109741,
0.6708036661148071,
-0.4712127149105072,
0.14258235692977905,
0.43896210193634033,
0.2623532712459564,
-0.11854805797338486,
-1.030426263809204,
-0.5146454572677612,
0.03953688591718674,
0.07774697989225388,
0.4281007945537567,
-0.20184949040412903,
0.15281982719898224,
0.24974799156188965,
0.3849448561668396,
-0.391238808631897,
0.29503920674324036,
-0.5200091004371643,
-0.04908856377005577,
0.9881957173347473,
0.2376038283109665,
0.757279634475708,
-0.12143002450466156,
-0.20876768231391907,
-0.3152916729450226,
-1.0654274225234985,
-0.21803763508796692,
0.6243529319763184,
-0.08230007439851761,
-0.348202645778656,
0.7340588569641113,
0.08932913839817047,
0.35386788845062256,
-0.003931345418095589,
-0.011281103827059269,
-0.07253118604421616,
-0.6086918711662292,
-0.07903045415878296,
0.19584587216377258,
0.7092342972755432,
0.5039743781089783,
0.6708874106407166,
-0.14928916096687317,
-0.14034737646579742,
0.23084411025047302,
0.8656017184257507,
-0.8636020421981812,
-0.3379010856151581,
0.40895238518714905,
-0.5260459184646606,
-0.5526581406593323,
0.14482298493385315,
-0.5606416463851929,
-0.27236682176589966,
-0.5234066247940063,
0.11377736181020737,
-0.3708730638027191,
-0.3552756905555725,
-0.36525216698646545,
-0.3834998905658722,
0.24610309302806854,
0.2400696575641632,
-1.1172316074371338,
-0.38683825731277466,
0.6567357778549194,
0.15602342784404755,
-0.03850901871919632,
-0.1763344258069992,
-0.5123457908630371,
0.6441873908042908,
-0.7036780714988708,
0.4698867201805115,
-0.03694538772106171,
-0.40603041648864746,
0.24115000665187836,
-0.1302369385957718,
-0.012565240263938904,
-0.3308141827583313,
0.4497515857219696,
-0.28903186321258545,
-0.010184851475059986,
-0.24574802815914154,
-0.6105439066886902,
-0.07542917132377625,
0.11071255058050156,
-0.8098164796829224,
0.21699361503124237,
0.033291444182395935,
-0.7507320642471313,
0.6519775390625,
-0.8501008749008179,
-0.7168486714363098,
0.46323633193969727,
-0.32570844888687134,
-0.6033127307891846,
0.20253942906856537,
-0.012131317518651485,
0.5432094931602478,
-0.09296638518571854,
0.7932726144790649,
0.00902180839329958,
0.09971726685762405,
0.3063863217830658,
-0.81121826171875,
0.781738817691803,
0.3806464970111847,
-0.34581273794174194,
0.3261029124259949,
-0.6918060779571533,
-0.003653930965811014,
0.24376238882541656,
-0.1454973667860031,
-0.20455718040466309,
0.23061934113502502,
0.30617955327033997,
-0.161227747797966,
0.13963575661182404,
-0.2848219573497772,
-0.21216493844985962,
0.059491682797670364,
0.5696886777877808,
0.8650742769241333,
0.2568741738796234,
0.41534051299095154,
-0.28188568353652954,
0.5160550475120544,
0.014278179965913296,
0.5955942869186401,
-0.14953495562076569,
-0.6821271777153015,
-0.4222028851509094,
-0.20290113985538483,
0.1699105203151703,
0.46458372473716736,
-1.0369150638580322,
0.23960864543914795,
-0.1382133662700653,
-0.5642014145851135,
-0.3824670612812042,
0.020734768360853195,
0.3178769052028656,
0.6292417645454407,
0.03993020951747894,
-0.05703164264559746,
-0.3286747634410858,
-0.6906164288520813,
0.05595046654343605,
-0.37416693568229675,
0.24821503460407257,
0.24049629271030426,
0.3719126880168915,
-0.42540907859802246,
0.735783576965332,
-0.23421722650527954,
-0.40330639481544495,
-0.49390360713005066,
0.35041260719299316,
-0.44525146484375,
0.8064467310905457,
0.7771052718162537,
-1.239116907119751,
-0.19408224523067474,
-0.05797277390956879,
-1.3688135147094727,
0.07284732162952423,
-0.6728525757789612,
-0.03464794158935547,
0.11023332923650742,
0.46883589029312134,
-0.8755906224250793,
0.7729089260101318,
0.3837466835975647,
-0.1152806431055069,
0.25817587971687317,
-0.36807334423065186,
0.07845664024353027,
-1.2876273393630981,
0.3915005624294281,
0.16502954065799713,
-0.15705636143684387,
-0.9012185335159302,
0.551701009273529,
-0.1980876326560974,
-0.35531777143478394,
-0.4120948016643524,
0.401119589805603,
-0.18013069033622742,
0.17731614410877228,
-0.11936488747596741,
-0.23973384499549866,
-0.006815571803599596,
-0.062444981187582016,
0.01190275326371193,
0.9410300850868225,
0.5213375687599182,
-0.8661690354347229,
0.44475769996643066,
0.4269845187664032,
-0.26612135767936707,
0.49695277214050293,
-0.8972612619400024,
0.020180417224764824,
-0.46010634303092957,
0.015959428623318672,
-0.263832688331604,
-0.5874184370040894,
0.48343193531036377,
-0.5927484631538391,
0.33959364891052246,
0.22411960363388062,
-0.5426982641220093,
-0.27209264039993286,
0.08628323674201965,
0.7312175631523132,
0.6169893145561218,
-0.4065883755683899,
0.5530948042869568,
0.5814333558082581,
-0.14004845917224884,
-0.32406872510910034,
-0.8154879212379456,
0.05339371785521507,
-0.32356858253479004,
-0.41057854890823364,
0.35637280344963074,
0.029353441670536995,
-0.2111479490995407,
0.12408623099327087,
0.33173930644989014,
-0.020142005756497383,
0.23934438824653625,
0.5855315923690796,
0.21256539225578308,
0.09107926487922668,
0.030866986140608788,
0.03154895827174187,
-0.4147964417934418,
0.2755826711654663,
0.028666364029049873,
0.06444952636957169,
0.09745892882347107,
-0.3318684697151184,
-0.6403864026069641,
0.8726959824562073,
0.530229926109314,
-0.33103352785110474,
0.5767074227333069,
0.6331431269645691,
-0.38539785146713257,
-0.012884660623967648,
-0.274575412273407,
-0.05869786813855171,
-0.4424741864204407,
0.14877423644065857,
0.17933450639247894,
-0.6230973601341248,
0.31233516335487366,
0.31498128175735474,
0.22633327543735504,
0.6465526819229126,
0.7498941421508789,
-0.2381373643875122,
1.1994465589523315,
0.753404438495636,
0.06982671469449997,
0.4282097816467285,
-0.2184784710407257,
0.5044599771499634,
-0.4380054771900177,
-0.5019587874412537,
-0.393069326877594,
0.12518395483493805,
-1.0736987590789795,
-0.03561793640255928,
0.5190120935440063,
-0.36443081498146057,
-0.31913796067237854,
0.22036601603031158,
-0.6284480094909668,
0.25067394971847534,
0.8594818711280823,
-0.11394211649894714,
0.10817887634038925,
-0.06755512952804565,
0.4736999273300171,
0.11449461430311203,
-0.860526978969574,
-0.5824731588363647,
0.9359967708587646,
0.38430657982826233,
0.9473174214363098,
0.011227810755372047,
0.7042927742004395,
0.4567055404186249,
0.4451574981212616,
-0.6133275628089905,
0.4737945795059204,
-0.359646737575531,
-0.8204718828201294,
-0.33057016134262085,
-0.6009781956672668,
-1.0992416143417358,
-0.3765515983104706,
0.017610328271985054,
-0.11032257229089737,
0.27811557054519653,
0.5682234764099121,
-0.22828291356563568,
0.1305360496044159,
-0.6789516806602478,
0.9813796281814575,
-0.340793251991272,
-0.04232511296868324,
-0.3373105227947235,
-0.6104413270950317,
0.432974636554718,
0.1628740131855011,
-0.23199722170829773,
0.17986932396888733,
0.5150585770606995,
0.428714781999588,
-0.20412899553775787,
1.1108019351959229,
0.13763853907585144,
-0.049369219690561295,
0.7752834558486938,
-0.3610159754753113,
0.2630460560321808,
0.03050972707569599,
0.4107166528701782,
0.15891672670841217,
0.05242931842803955,
-0.3908742070198059,
-0.22356478869915009,
0.38687705993652344,
-0.9939371347427368,
-0.6424176692962646,
-0.5082630515098572,
-0.5186684131622314,
0.22183430194854736,
0.3101057708263397,
0.6830984950065613,
0.4020977020263672,
-0.5107905864715576,
0.25375500321388245,
1.0277280807495117,
-0.3306453227996826,
0.36564722657203674,
-0.0923302173614502,
0.1528060883283615,
-0.194353848695755,
1.3049288988113403,
0.04267405346035957,
0.23567262291908264,
0.17227040231227875,
0.006914475001394749,
-0.12352252751588821,
-0.3253377079963684,
-0.751658022403717,
-0.03221824765205383,
-0.7846705913543701,
-0.23986192047595978,
-0.3017529547214508,
-0.6593340635299683,
-0.606275737285614,
-0.06687384843826294,
-0.28808683156967163,
0.07776428759098053,
-0.8394392132759094,
-0.25400668382644653,
0.166738361120224,
0.7519169449806213,
-0.18339289724826813,
-0.07333788275718689,
-0.832432210445404,
0.5995634198188782,
0.659172534942627,
0.001582750934176147,
-0.11598636955022812,
0.23903144896030426,
0.15716704726219177,
0.1416555941104889,
-0.46048349142074585,
-0.5398043990135193,
0.172149196267128,
0.12325820326805115,
0.8231134414672852,
0.8211753964424133,
0.2500649094581604,
0.2610277235507965,
-0.5530868172645569,
0.7835424542427063,
0.4086613953113556,
-0.5470873713493347,
0.7245736122131348,
-0.4154818654060364,
0.06660833954811096,
0.38774895668029785,
0.35590988397598267,
-0.31054216623306274,
-0.42031022906303406,
-0.665052592754364,
-0.6429714560508728,
0.03059942089021206,
0.4573601484298706,
0.7216631174087524,
-0.2932552397251129,
0.2935326397418976,
0.03203768655657768,
0.12049175053834915,
-0.763988733291626,
0.012638618238270283,
-0.7037370204925537,
-0.24540413916110992,
0.15342023968696594,
-0.20721286535263062,
-0.5058549046516418,
0.018465738743543625,
0.5162156224250793,
-0.20254580676555634,
0.3669760525226593,
0.08201855421066284,
0.2327428162097931,
-0.23695772886276245,
0.1938415914773941,
0.6964921355247498,
0.608851432800293,
0.22985249757766724,
-0.010368396528065205,
-0.4970230162143707,
-0.4561348557472229,
0.10207971185445786,
-0.010427361354231834,
-0.7030351161956787,
-0.25181445479393005,
0.3989195227622986,
0.9473271369934082,
-0.43739497661590576,
-0.5873703360557556,
0.5394936800003052,
0.013608727604150772,
-0.14050030708312988,
-0.5096186995506287,
0.3866116404533386,
-0.1783580631017685,
-0.2489003688097,
0.01903989166021347,
0.18933752179145813,
0.0794401466846466,
-0.7386687994003296,
0.0867198035120964,
0.2799690067768097,
-0.2052507996559143,
-0.2977321445941925,
0.9506041407585144,
0.44945964217185974,
0.05337667837738991,
1.1844583749771118,
-0.040245894342660904,
-0.07463718205690384,
0.8994527459144592,
0.6556573510169983,
0.9278488755226135,
-0.18856438994407654,
0.8123506307601929,
0.27495789527893066,
0.33272576332092285,
-0.0457480251789093,
0.20936082303524017,
0.11381373554468155,
-0.8778160810470581,
-0.3898712992668152,
0.01424506213515997,
-0.3497031033039093,
0.14866939187049866,
-0.8831011056900024,
-0.1280023455619812,
-0.3274933695793152,
-0.2066941112279892,
-0.044412802904844284,
-0.6560680270195007,
-0.6440631747245789,
0.6679381728172302,
0.19868990778923035,
0.42554494738578796,
-0.9049713015556335,
0.41399404406547546,
0.6188924908638,
-0.7747864127159119,
-0.8814205527305603,
-0.0033609606325626373,
-0.15846581757068634,
-0.6253945231437683,
0.3733064830303192,
0.1638159155845642,
0.2546544373035431,
-0.10055550932884216,
-0.8616946935653687,
-0.3773660659790039,
1.007022738456726,
0.43351998925209045,
-0.37742215394973755,
-0.32918721437454224,
0.4916735887527466,
0.5292589664459229,
-0.2861436605453491,
-0.3971444070339203,
0.10164608806371689,
0.355202317237854,
0.1844114065170288,
-0.19205084443092346,
0.01573406159877777,
-0.32396379113197327,
0.3843069076538086,
-0.05531829223036766,
-0.42456793785095215,
0.6662716269493103,
-0.4138602614402771,
-0.4864219129085541,
0.053776390850543976,
0.7575376629829407,
0.3879142999649048,
0.6138156056404114,
0.09820196032524109,
0.6485084295272827,
0.45944321155548096,
-0.09752532839775085,
1.5711231231689453,
-0.11971431970596313,
-0.2133549451828003,
0.7447203397750854,
-0.14324603974819183,
0.2245468944311142,
0.43855002522468567,
0.44412586092948914,
-0.036386605352163315,
0.6968217492103577,
-0.3628571927547455,
0.6386598348617554,
-0.13012494146823883,
-0.32856297492980957,
-0.3494155704975128,
-0.4582369029521942,
-0.5990983247756958,
0.5041635632514954,
0.20301644504070282,
-0.5477346777915955,
-0.0295717790722847,
0.028649041429162025,
-0.1156337782740593,
0.030004238709807396,
-0.2746775448322296,
0.9201451539993286,
0.28829190135002136,
-0.8935002088546753,
-0.1466071903705597,
0.05197633057832718,
-0.12215787917375565,
-0.2966541647911072,
-0.3849262595176697,
-0.09273362159729004,
0.03403865918517113,
-0.07317078113555908,
-0.6882300972938538,
0.5970979332923889,
0.18293073773384094,
-0.32217687368392944,
-0.5180106163024902,
0.9906541109085083,
-0.15139031410217285,
-0.603119432926178,
-0.19692564010620117,
0.36783111095428467,
0.018615322187542915,
0.11581126600503922,
-0.5147268176078796,
-0.08288466930389404,
-0.2512681782245636,
0.06513360887765884,
0.28953295946121216,
0.45457014441490173,
-0.3475847542285919,
0.700920581817627,
0.7432633638381958,
0.022388054057955742,
-0.13981686532497406,
0.32136258482933044,
0.5939103960990906,
-0.31583085656166077,
-0.5442827939987183,
-0.4982292354106903,
0.7370300889015198,
0.0074473279528319836,
-0.6075249314308167,
0.43222394585609436,
0.23374101519584656,
0.629209578037262,
-0.29919904470443726,
0.961688220500946,
-0.3420256972312927,
-0.1638391762971878,
-0.7151370048522949,
1.133353590965271,
-0.3970065712928772,
-0.27061697840690613,
-0.005722556728869677,
-0.7470492720603943,
-0.16144412755966187,
0.5109235048294067,
-0.02075151354074478,
0.18189764022827148,
0.19348736107349396,
0.419612318277359,
0.333234578371048,
-0.08632932603359222,
0.4679829180240631,
-0.19434374570846558,
0.49547278881073,
0.34252747893333435,
0.7894039154052734,
-0.4939798414707184,
0.2643420398235321,
-0.0578252337872982,
0.034191861748695374,
0.0069998325780034065,
-1.0468393564224243,
-0.6489117741584778,
-0.6812003254890442,
-0.7272498607635498,
-0.21615822613239288,
-0.01585417240858078,
0.28279998898506165,
0.7542651295661926,
-0.7923851609230042,
0.20495009422302246,
-0.7588805556297302,
0.0797937661409378,
-0.3700624704360962,
-0.2208242267370224,
0.10830144584178925,
-0.28864291310310364,
-0.6562010645866394,
0.07085008919239044,
0.23673848807811737,
0.4002421200275421,
-0.35199564695358276,
0.0419422872364521,
0.2657436728477478,
0.10244456678628922,
0.6127926707267761,
0.5272665619850159,
-0.5656043887138367,
-0.5305542349815369,
-0.22477439045906067,
-0.43827900290489197,
-0.17611290514469147,
0.8216984868049622,
-0.35743361711502075,
0.45836037397384644,
0.5000463128089905,
0.7478724122047424,
0.015860356390476227,
0.11077791452407837,
0.9702088832855225,
-0.6084452271461487,
-0.1942911297082901,
0.4075176417827606,
0.09304209053516388,
0.4989103078842163,
-0.8288851976394653,
0.6770703792572021,
0.07382933050394058,
-0.7962878346443176,
-0.6638026833534241,
0.5890564918518066,
-0.938978374004364,
0.002441969932988286,
0.8259847164154053,
-0.3055773079395294,
-0.037227023392915726,
0.0803089290857315,
0.009682797826826572,
0.6293691992759705,
0.08879143744707108,
1.0289256572723389,
0.23929038643836975,
0.06598811596632004,
-0.5790062546730042,
-0.7430644035339355,
0.6038603186607361,
0.25496071577072144,
-1.2395117282867432,
-0.046929288655519485,
0.5582696795463562,
0.08708031475543976,
0.13953445851802826,
0.517458975315094,
-0.1379743218421936,
0.587406575679779,
0.10980135202407837,
0.19697882235050201,
0.01680169440805912,
-0.5911727547645569,
0.21836599707603455,
0.03610993176698685,
-0.28044986724853516,
-0.3416658341884613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05694v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05694v2
|
Comprehensive Study on German Language Models for Clinical and Biomedical Text Understanding
| 2024-04-08T17:24:04 | 2024-05-08T08:53:53 |
Ahmad Idrissi-Yaghir, Amin Dada, Henning Schäfer, Kamyar Arzideh, Giulia Baldini, Jan Trienes, Max Hasin, Jeanette Bewersdorff, Cynthia S. Schmidt, Marie Bauer, Kaleb E. Smith, Jiang Bian, Yonghui Wu, Jörg Schlötterer, Torsten Zesch, Peter A. Horn, Christin Seifert, Felix Nensa, Jens Kleesiek, Christoph M. Friedrich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent advances in natural language processing (NLP) can be largely
attributed to the advent of pre-trained language models such as BERT and
RoBERTa. While these models demonstrate remarkable performance on general
datasets, they can struggle in specialized domains such as medicine, where
unique domain-specific terminologies, domain-specific abbreviations, and
varying document structures are common. This paper explores strategies for
adapting these models to domain-specific requirements, primarily through
continuous pre-training on domain-specific data. We pre-trained several German
medical language models on 2.4B tokens derived from translated public English
medical data and 3B tokens of German clinical data. The resulting models were
evaluated on various German downstream tasks, including named entity
recognition (NER), multi-label classification, and extractive question
answering. Our results suggest that models augmented by clinical and
translation-based pre-training typically outperform general domain models in
medical contexts. We conclude that continuous pre-training has demonstrated the
ability to match or even exceed the performance of clinical models trained from
scratch. Furthermore, pre-training on clinical data or leveraging translated
texts have proven to be reliable methods for domain adaptation in medical NLP
tasks.
|
[
-0.10488374531269073,
-0.8228989243507385,
0.9677010178565979,
0.07359948754310608,
-0.36292269825935364,
-0.11893393099308014,
-0.2617018520832062,
-0.6070675253868103,
-0.1214938536286354,
0.7045774459838867,
-0.4951760470867157,
-0.6662346720695496,
-0.9189444184303284,
0.28540748357772827,
-0.11581910401582718,
1.233244776725769,
-0.33941835165023804,
0.6614218950271606,
-0.4170369803905487,
-0.31093156337738037,
-0.49594685435295105,
-1.0208110809326172,
-0.5742054581642151,
-0.5769026279449463,
0.5182061791419983,
-0.1071779802441597,
0.6039252281188965,
0.4684019386768341,
0.775000274181366,
0.17399942874908447,
0.10577549785375595,
-0.08358584344387054,
-0.3617069125175476,
-0.1339547485113144,
-0.3952501118183136,
-0.2833887040615082,
-0.6444319486618042,
0.01795198582112789,
0.5502527356147766,
1.1881879568099976,
-0.01212269626557827,
-0.25819504261016846,
-0.09715399891138077,
0.4329390525817871,
-0.17239022254943848,
0.08695676177740097,
-0.5006937980651855,
-0.04945552349090576,
-0.1434527188539505,
-0.25996407866477966,
-0.6304377913475037,
-0.1342998743057251,
0.6603879332542419,
-0.788475751876831,
0.4027850031852722,
-0.19613587856292725,
1.252341628074646,
0.1030111312866211,
-0.6085764765739441,
-0.6907739639282227,
-0.6464117765426636,
0.49036911129951477,
-0.8001880049705505,
0.6078782081604004,
0.5519545674324036,
0.09849747270345688,
-0.24805264174938202,
-1.1060758829116821,
-0.21961231529712677,
-0.2596415579319,
-0.3971002995967865,
0.19792619347572327,
-0.39420777559280396,
0.2980949878692627,
-0.15355712175369263,
0.03603102266788483,
-0.7331182956695557,
0.33311501145362854,
-0.3139854073524475,
-0.019304592162370682,
0.22345690429210663,
-0.04008062556385994,
0.48300427198410034,
0.1044822484254837,
-0.26635226607322693,
0.07418248057365417,
-0.6984442472457886,
-0.283792108297348,
-0.38791656494140625,
0.12155149132013321,
-0.19458886981010437,
0.2915148437023163,
0.20757007598876953,
0.8823772668838501,
-0.12166529893875122,
-0.048050351440906525,
0.32299184799194336,
-0.5846570730209351,
-0.33146995306015015,
-0.3420187532901764,
0.34892186522483826,
-0.04683701694011688,
0.5913025736808777,
-0.5411907434463501,
0.008782556280493736,
0.0786392092704773,
0.6906347870826721,
-0.710129976272583,
-0.3977168798446655,
0.3600711226463318,
-0.6428213715553284,
0.0029385092202574015,
-0.37506434321403503,
-0.2556259334087372,
-0.11552251130342484,
-0.5495315790176392,
0.519531786441803,
-0.6468257308006287,
-0.010259603150188923,
0.6685843467712402,
0.05313233658671379,
0.03373849764466286,
0.30967703461647034,
-0.7765257954597473,
0.48853006958961487,
0.4869920015335083,
0.6447497010231018,
-0.4665752947330475,
-0.1331155002117157,
-0.3563092052936554,
0.20926988124847412,
-0.2980702817440033,
0.8540940284729004,
-0.4525816738605499,
-0.3846210539340973,
0.17511188983917236,
0.2780854403972626,
-0.45511651039123535,
-0.6055442690849304,
0.5074613094329834,
-0.6054360866546631,
0.24552099406719208,
0.202478289604187,
-0.7689981460571289,
-0.10487182438373566,
0.09051661193370819,
-0.43978291749954224,
0.31831493973731995,
0.2374383956193924,
-0.6473739743232727,
0.3651024401187897,
-0.7754472494125366,
-0.7366377711296082,
0.16203555464744568,
-0.004790437873452902,
-0.34291258454322815,
0.35248419642448425,
0.32728898525238037,
0.6351118087768555,
-0.1466483473777771,
0.44170257449150085,
-0.18049933016300201,
-0.006416104733943939,
0.20063626766204834,
-0.038546573370695114,
0.5571756362915039,
-0.014655625447630882,
0.07725059241056442,
0.18005238473415375,
-0.615241289138794,
0.024949824437499046,
0.10717922449111938,
-0.15491540729999542,
-0.5908817052841187,
0.06870275735855103,
0.22928933799266815,
0.140554741024971,
-0.01815970055758953,
-0.14712147414684296,
-0.03646251559257507,
-0.6075170040130615,
0.33018702268600464,
0.3527508080005646,
0.11872809380292892,
0.3637540638446808,
-0.3224942088127136,
0.6927773356437683,
0.10949017852544785,
0.09542006999254227,
-0.2777135372161865,
-0.30803796648979187,
-0.5099732279777527,
-0.4610982835292816,
0.5999356508255005,
0.5598503947257996,
-0.6748557090759277,
0.33481091260910034,
-0.5758575797080994,
-0.5126731991767883,
-0.6623081564903259,
-0.15119364857673645,
0.5081008076667786,
0.7823767066001892,
0.6350528001785278,
-0.47204598784446716,
-0.25509294867515564,
-0.7793028950691223,
-0.1856493204832077,
-0.0913415402173996,
-0.22752530872821808,
0.5134329795837402,
0.71518474817276,
-0.7076897025108337,
0.7148864269256592,
-0.4675348699092865,
-0.27695053815841675,
-0.2786836624145508,
0.21663783490657806,
0.2548219561576843,
0.3990785777568817,
0.6044888496398926,
-0.8110490441322327,
-0.4516569674015045,
0.27050310373306274,
-0.8339714407920837,
-0.1508794128894806,
-0.30116698145866394,
-0.04478071630001068,
0.09267759323120117,
0.3249483108520508,
-0.4275469183921814,
0.3732130229473114,
0.7464476227760315,
-0.4441654682159424,
0.4682891070842743,
-0.6260095834732056,
-0.09481973201036453,
-0.977371871471405,
0.27678367495536804,
-0.03479445353150368,
-0.6374676823616028,
-1.1912529468536377,
0.07791048288345337,
0.07954560965299606,
0.06853345781564713,
-0.43015196919441223,
0.8765671849250793,
-0.4607498347759247,
0.19773907959461212,
-0.38704660534858704,
-0.011792660690844059,
0.1323082000017166,
0.0871007964015007,
0.5949239730834961,
0.47576597332954407,
0.5439426898956299,
-0.7728656530380249,
-0.18939776718616486,
0.5368891358375549,
-0.2777140140533447,
0.4038862884044647,
-0.8135529160499573,
0.21780738234519958,
-0.316275030374527,
0.37297627329826355,
-0.5597646236419678,
-0.2829594016075134,
0.012250903062522411,
-0.39557090401649475,
0.35499560832977295,
-0.12373620271682739,
-0.4145425260066986,
-0.17155709862709045,
0.4743938744068146,
0.2938174903392792,
0.4877552092075348,
-0.3003492057323456,
0.6417633295059204,
0.5037343502044678,
-0.5703423619270325,
-0.0969012975692749,
-0.5363848209381104,
-0.03841138258576393,
-0.007617258466780186,
-0.5558580756187439,
0.8550414443016052,
-0.06445252895355225,
-0.046824224293231964,
0.044167857617139816,
0.010816211812198162,
-0.5220448970794678,
0.23699508607387543,
-0.006758044008165598,
0.44586804509162903,
-0.3340409994125366,
0.32738280296325684,
0.21152333915233612,
-0.1581871658563614,
-0.09573994576931,
-0.358512818813324,
0.5262945890426636,
0.1780146062374115,
-0.2911642789840698,
-0.40126660466194153,
0.44008708000183105,
0.35676807165145874,
-0.046076852828264236,
0.8630860447883606,
0.41021791100502014,
-0.5747501254081726,
0.015758348628878593,
-0.36102691292762756,
-0.3408926725387573,
-0.3497903347015381,
0.674110472202301,
-0.401498407125473,
-0.9193260669708252,
0.2847549021244049,
-0.21973881125450134,
-0.022084593772888184,
0.3390030562877655,
0.836049497127533,
-0.3369382321834564,
0.9377868175506592,
0.9804067611694336,
0.22529906034469604,
0.11203911155462265,
0.31642237305641174,
0.14542977511882782,
-0.2945663332939148,
0.016134796664118767,
-0.4931547939777374,
0.23728783428668976,
-0.25396010279655457,
-0.4469042420387268,
0.3316189646720886,
0.1353377252817154,
0.04495038092136383,
0.2644953429698944,
-0.24071770906448364,
0.13108767569065094,
0.057387880980968475,
0.21560238301753998,
0.19950276613235474,
0.0536670908331871,
-0.10564246773719788,
-0.16838423907756805,
-0.7189077734947205,
-0.5666119456291199,
1.0912851095199585,
0.6187071800231934,
0.3808112144470215,
-0.2580837607383728,
0.5397557616233826,
0.15546926856040955,
0.6871178150177002,
-0.5494110584259033,
-0.04518260434269905,
-0.49232742190361023,
-0.6551386713981628,
-0.010468724183738232,
-0.21260017156600952,
-1.1721693277359009,
0.15328164398670197,
-0.16316284239292145,
-0.431505024433136,
0.03475681692361832,
0.06370988488197327,
-0.3361493945121765,
-0.19979797303676605,
-0.7403562068939209,
0.9789785146713257,
-0.3520023226737976,
0.2675042748451233,
-0.12012158334255219,
-0.7127743363380432,
-0.08361738175153732,
-0.6907069087028503,
0.5179163813591003,
0.03668075427412987,
-0.06967723369598389,
0.6910219788551331,
-0.08718971163034439,
0.7700194120407104,
-0.11350324749946594,
-0.03225506842136383,
-0.13893763720989227,
-0.11051300913095474,
0.26633989810943604,
0.05909973010420799,
0.12567119300365448,
0.39660584926605225,
0.4968146085739136,
-0.6862033605575562,
-0.4541950821876526,
0.2148982435464859,
-0.7374709844589233,
-0.5483329892158508,
-0.38816213607788086,
-0.4489724934101105,
-0.6197962760925293,
0.2676635980606079,
0.3171394467353821,
0.24744710326194763,
-0.4934418797492981,
-0.03304881975054741,
0.5888965725898743,
-0.4114668071269989,
-0.006768661551177502,
0.9578001499176025,
-0.11275464296340942,
-0.17788425087928772,
0.40807557106018066,
-0.2287224978208542,
0.4714395999908447,
0.23911753296852112,
0.014852801337838173,
-0.21986453235149384,
-0.9747306108474731,
-0.29587870836257935,
0.5448485016822815,
-0.7139180898666382,
0.049269989132881165,
-0.8496891260147095,
-0.32756105065345764,
-0.44460737705230713,
-0.3612114489078522,
-0.022336529567837715,
-0.08098139613866806,
-0.5274693369865417,
-0.0513630211353302,
0.22178001701831818,
0.6690064668655396,
0.18290266394615173,
0.5812905430793762,
-1.2433854341506958,
0.45839089155197144,
-0.2050401270389557,
0.26363733410835266,
-0.3590538501739502,
-0.8170382380485535,
-0.369045615196228,
-0.09547457098960876,
0.11670289188623428,
-0.9062564373016357,
0.5937627553939819,
0.3539501428604126,
0.560967206954956,
0.19723080098628998,
-0.333720862865448,
0.630943238735199,
-0.9474509954452515,
0.5205406546592712,
0.024551065638661385,
-0.8182827830314636,
0.4936511516571045,
-0.38402479887008667,
0.26080891489982605,
0.6261845827102661,
0.8192557692527771,
-0.5644894242286682,
-0.1929885745048523,
-0.5227702856063843,
-0.6122792959213257,
0.5622611045837402,
0.13794107735157013,
0.2992953360080719,
0.010022914037108421,
0.5855756998062134,
0.44260042905807495,
-0.015142467804253101,
-0.6856883764266968,
-0.09060005098581314,
0.16802926361560822,
-0.46499571204185486,
-0.273001492023468,
-0.020462771877646446,
-0.2733142375946045,
-0.20023484528064728,
0.41962331533432007,
-0.19244162738323212,
0.3228294551372528,
0.2878020405769348,
-0.3679911196231842,
0.39661961793899536,
0.2302088439464569,
0.5114418864250183,
0.8895761966705322,
-0.08598592132329941,
-0.13176925480365753,
0.10423331707715988,
-0.6566042900085449,
0.14019739627838135,
0.38922226428985596,
0.12625600397586823,
0.39668354392051697,
0.6976861953735352,
0.7479963898658752,
0.24419543147087097,
-0.793826162815094,
0.34409815073013306,
-0.08183261007070541,
-0.1944897621870041,
-0.16598522663116455,
-0.306034654378891,
0.14843374490737915,
-0.19336144626140594,
0.07360800355672836,
-0.1409534364938736,
-0.18123187124729156,
-0.3605498671531677,
0.5253006815910339,
0.12026657909154892,
-0.5733598470687866,
-0.5789728760719299,
0.6016313433647156,
0.0008482334669679403,
-0.16500219702720642,
0.5271586179733276,
0.32606908679008484,
-0.3057834804058075,
0.43705883622169495,
0.9253688454627991,
0.5638975501060486,
-0.08694998919963837,
0.29022660851478577,
0.024611007422208786,
-0.0937696248292923,
-0.09968332946300507,
0.21837186813354492,
0.2575652599334717,
-0.8250818848609924,
-0.5662800669670105,
-0.6218644976615906,
-0.3428851366043091,
0.10079105943441391,
-0.7011074423789978,
0.27364593744277954,
-0.2526610195636749,
-0.3768917918205261,
0.428463339805603,
-0.3781636357307434,
-0.988115131855011,
0.6293779015541077,
0.012621286325156689,
0.9331681132316589,
-0.7288900017738342,
1.3101145029067993,
0.7425177693367004,
-0.3734513521194458,
-0.33969682455062866,
-0.04298074543476105,
-0.19499480724334717,
-0.8456619381904602,
0.731102705001831,
-0.11217442154884338,
0.24284806847572327,
0.18118470907211304,
-0.32053133845329285,
-0.6942610740661621,
0.5286727547645569,
0.11889786273241043,
-0.4312174320220947,
-0.47313714027404785,
0.20471155643463135,
0.9137547612190247,
-0.5808311104774475,
-0.08654773980379105,
0.7594953179359436,
0.2594512701034546,
-0.35522180795669556,
-0.9774501919746399,
-0.1147637739777565,
-0.17003311216831207,
-0.17969760298728943,
-0.0825914591550827,
0.22276094555854797,
0.5588080883026123,
-0.08576760441064835,
-0.18943116068840027,
0.18532808125019073,
0.34391674399375916,
0.24926701188087463,
0.26155173778533936,
0.3542589545249939,
0.23840732872486115,
0.8218110203742981,
-0.04507824406027794,
1.255599021911621,
-0.35165372490882874,
0.12170416116714478,
0.972284734249115,
-0.6125621199607849,
0.7381409406661987,
0.35784414410591125,
-0.20588622987270355,
0.5789434909820557,
0.6324043869972229,
0.0003388650366105139,
0.6568951606750488,
0.11075438559055328,
-0.2494266927242279,
-0.16732631623744965,
-0.13960595428943634,
-0.4586932957172394,
0.32178181409835815,
0.5729910135269165,
-0.533295750617981,
0.000028055059374310076,
0.41641494631767273,
0.29889509081840515,
0.025084543973207474,
-0.0937734842300415,
0.9849802255630493,
0.27996826171875,
-0.7071748375892639,
0.6778149008750916,
0.08348043262958527,
0.3415413796901703,
-0.9089824557304382,
0.20018653571605682,
-0.011686861515045166,
0.2764398157596588,
0.05988144129514694,
-0.32159945368766785,
0.3771068751811981,
0.07005111128091812,
-0.30973100662231445,
-0.3263360857963562,
0.710420548915863,
-0.15661105513572693,
-0.5414914488792419,
0.4182518720626831,
0.6394141316413879,
0.22119012475013733,
0.0291884858161211,
-0.6089068055152893,
-0.19965951144695282,
-0.10828116536140442,
-0.06580711156129837,
0.5954928398132324,
0.3587968945503235,
-0.09146133810281754,
0.4557032585144043,
0.736396849155426,
0.42984405159950256,
-0.17687523365020752,
0.24568818509578705,
0.7655382752418518,
-0.5935345888137817,
-0.38513025641441345,
-0.7265607118606567,
0.3329301178455353,
0.04383598640561104,
-0.216822549700737,
0.33482468128204346,
0.20620615780353546,
0.7844105362892151,
-0.37094977498054504,
0.8223454356193542,
0.39290851354599,
0.641788899898529,
-0.6389268040657043,
0.8912113308906555,
-0.5925772190093994,
-0.1794780045747757,
-0.06248611584305763,
-0.3519558310508728,
-0.6300202012062073,
0.5372287631034851,
-0.3044820725917816,
0.0722360834479332,
0.9720611572265625,
0.3095201849937439,
-0.007225747685879469,
-0.12846241891384125,
0.3290219306945801,
0.21772290766239166,
0.36203262209892273,
0.5386123657226562,
0.262387216091156,
-0.20421592891216278,
0.11302635818719864,
0.15516772866249084,
-0.2775416374206543,
0.013028900139033794,
-0.7603485584259033,
-0.8997887372970581,
-0.4799521863460541,
-0.31041792035102844,
-0.4242921471595764,
0.30594006180763245,
0.6682543754577637,
0.9414917826652527,
-1.0548865795135498,
0.1659342646598816,
0.015738435089588165,
-0.3328350782394409,
-0.14706595242023468,
-0.0973513051867485,
0.6870311498641968,
-0.6471188068389893,
-0.6441340446472168,
0.4763493239879608,
0.3358645737171173,
0.31888890266418457,
0.1346026510000229,
0.05881262943148613,
-0.11211267113685608,
0.2945209741592407,
0.624428927898407,
0.2605419456958771,
-0.689651608467102,
-0.0739486888051033,
0.21056003868579865,
-0.3884375989437103,
0.211435928940773,
0.9858176112174988,
-0.8560531139373779,
0.42591583728790283,
0.16815699636936188,
0.8986732959747314,
0.4829661548137665,
0.06167025491595268,
0.9212154150009155,
-0.3753633499145508,
0.20718598365783691,
0.5160741806030273,
0.2815284729003906,
0.24843692779541016,
-0.14646027982234955,
0.5356564521789551,
0.15757323801517487,
-0.4901740849018097,
-0.8207095265388489,
0.17724013328552246,
-0.7348437309265137,
-0.6793220043182373,
0.9560908675193787,
-0.5184270143508911,
0.009960189461708069,
-0.5363602638244629,
-0.08012060075998306,
0.24730491638183594,
0.33105382323265076,
0.694182813167572,
0.915597677230835,
-0.14428502321243286,
0.21583326160907745,
-0.8403666019439697,
0.6787908673286438,
0.6123446822166443,
-1.0669440031051636,
-0.1480128914117813,
0.2347717583179474,
0.281734436750412,
-0.11262019723653793,
1.011779546737671,
-0.3887815773487091,
0.23540601134300232,
-0.3990978002548218,
-0.04366205260157585,
0.31414735317230225,
-0.33079794049263,
-0.5411001443862915,
-0.04042332246899605,
-0.08232945948839188,
0.18251968920230865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05692v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05692v1
|
Evaluating Mathematical Reasoning Beyond Accuracy
| 2024-04-08T17:18:04 | 2024-04-08T17:18:04 |
Shijie Xia, Xuefeng Li, Yixin Liu, Tongshuang Wu, Pengfei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The leaderboard of Large Language Models (LLMs) in mathematical tasks has
been continuously updated. However, the majority of evaluations focus solely on
the final results, neglecting the quality of the intermediate steps. This
oversight can mask underlying problems, such as logical errors or unnecessary
steps in the reasoning process. To measure reasoning beyond final-answer
accuracy, we introduce ReasonEval, a new methodology for evaluating the quality
of reasoning steps. ReasonEval employs $\textit{validity}$ and
$\textit{redundancy}$ to characterize the reasoning quality, as well as
accompanying LLMs to assess them automatically. Instantiated by base models
that possess strong mathematical knowledge and trained with high-quality
labeled data, ReasonEval achieves state-of-the-art performance on human-labeled
datasets and can accurately detect different types of errors generated by
perturbation. When applied to evaluate LLMs specialized in math, we find that
an increase in final-answer accuracy does not necessarily guarantee an
improvement in the overall quality of the reasoning steps for challenging
mathematical problems. Additionally, we observe that ReasonEval can play a
significant role in data selection. We release the best-performing model,
meta-evaluation script, and all evaluation results at
https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/ReasonEval.
|
[
-0.1618826538324356,
-0.864536464214325,
0.7379120588302612,
0.3728332817554474,
-0.1948360949754715,
0.13417354226112366,
-0.22697925567626953,
-0.0860162228345871,
-0.01836235448718071,
0.2918453812599182,
-0.41678738594055176,
-0.7462438344955444,
-0.695239782333374,
0.03460649028420448,
-0.3518456220626831,
0.7560222148895264,
-0.1636151820421219,
0.20595067739486694,
-0.8364615440368652,
-0.14670485258102417,
-0.4979046881198883,
-0.5259634256362915,
-0.4001374840736389,
-0.6128091812133789,
0.17283445596694946,
0.3048149645328522,
0.8745134472846985,
0.4519292116165161,
0.8787901401519775,
0.3181631863117218,
-0.07642417401075363,
0.39087939262390137,
-0.6082391738891602,
0.25816047191619873,
-0.5059015154838562,
-0.526454508304596,
-0.6346444487571716,
0.06664744764566422,
0.36481043696403503,
0.7183846235275269,
-0.415493905544281,
0.3619002103805542,
-0.15761445462703705,
0.8415036797523499,
-0.6099153757095337,
0.1367986500263214,
-0.4547630250453949,
-0.29060471057891846,
-0.15911158919334412,
-0.24648331105709076,
-0.43196386098861694,
-0.8113901615142822,
0.12334936857223511,
-0.3086213767528534,
-0.1615753173828125,
-0.2922629415988922,
0.5951933860778809,
0.5044820308685303,
-0.05236857756972313,
-0.42427903413772583,
-0.5525181293487549,
0.9804973006248474,
-0.6938944458961487,
0.5197839140892029,
0.516294002532959,
0.6501553058624268,
-0.19120578467845917,
-0.6268442273139954,
-0.382394939661026,
-0.38978302478790283,
0.19408826529979706,
0.17025457322597504,
-0.29401305317878723,
-0.20050683617591858,
0.37190335988998413,
0.1649322211742401,
-0.5152069330215454,
-0.3104311227798462,
-0.2058856338262558,
-0.07880870997905731,
0.828120231628418,
0.20524796843528748,
0.2368508279323578,
0.024218805134296417,
-0.04359932243824005,
0.04614431783556938,
-0.8075640797615051,
-0.04859023168683052,
0.05781824141740799,
-0.06972280144691467,
0.37012577056884766,
0.6762190461158752,
-0.14476512372493744,
0.7062880396842957,
-0.0665392354130745,
-0.19433480501174927,
0.26224029064178467,
-0.2787107527256012,
-0.2552192211151123,
-0.1109091117978096,
0.38870370388031006,
0.3119237720966339,
0.2672705352306366,
-0.028947146609425545,
-0.2895548939704895,
0.35187289118766785,
0.15160222351551056,
-0.8201110363006592,
-0.5328639149665833,
0.31076228618621826,
-0.18994270265102386,
-0.20507369935512543,
-0.12048346549272537,
-0.369909405708313,
-0.26532986760139465,
-0.7796334624290466,
0.4633883833885193,
-0.4666141867637634,
-0.17028895020484924,
0.2333642542362213,
0.274934321641922,
-0.09277777373790741,
0.6922046542167664,
-0.5013192892074585,
0.18145348131656647,
0.9602089524269104,
0.7167240381240845,
-0.21806733310222626,
-0.31582170724868774,
-0.7020827531814575,
-0.5294957756996155,
-0.8653106689453125,
0.9748929738998413,
-0.7293499708175659,
-0.14071406424045563,
-0.2763151228427887,
-0.476306289434433,
-0.03933316841721535,
-0.6761069893836975,
1.1056591272354126,
-0.9122134447097778,
0.052319567650556564,
-0.5260984897613525,
-0.8167603015899658,
-0.3044561445713043,
0.5426226258277893,
-0.36088910698890686,
0.9122154712677002,
0.11702559888362885,
-0.40764790773391724,
0.3995020091533661,
-0.6557321548461914,
-0.22222910821437836,
0.10485844314098358,
-0.09779545664787292,
-0.374644011259079,
0.2290956974029541,
0.34041082859039307,
0.15502506494522095,
-0.5067809820175171,
0.42939555644989014,
-0.3026849925518036,
-0.203010693192482,
0.4263346493244171,
-0.6021367311477661,
0.8021568655967712,
0.1411472111940384,
-0.04847127944231033,
0.33915698528289795,
-0.6816132068634033,
0.4518541395664215,
-0.030117614194750786,
-0.27348506450653076,
-0.2896406352519989,
0.16577693819999695,
-0.5426592230796814,
0.42827335000038147,
0.35350674390792847,
-0.29496508836746216,
-0.14338898658752441,
-0.4011460244655609,
0.39025571942329407,
0.7680565714836121,
-0.1846623718738556,
0.10024691373109818,
-0.43337878584861755,
0.592308521270752,
-0.30743512511253357,
0.14523954689502716,
-0.24313800036907196,
-0.3849641978740692,
-0.8267239928245544,
-0.004854047205299139,
0.483064740896225,
0.6643604636192322,
-0.4231862723827362,
0.6098641157150269,
-0.30099159479141235,
-0.8485616445541382,
-0.4846995770931244,
0.197676882147789,
0.42051181197166443,
0.9011250138282776,
0.6362576484680176,
0.24441255629062653,
-0.3696218430995941,
-0.6132270097732544,
-0.39601680636405945,
-0.2597694993019104,
0.03278057277202606,
0.053806014358997345,
0.6069086194038391,
-0.229575052857399,
0.8221437931060791,
-0.24568723142147064,
0.012775810435414314,
-0.18286864459514618,
-0.011282847262918949,
0.5316489934921265,
0.34046506881713867,
0.25790664553642273,
-0.47702571749687195,
-0.305951863527298,
-0.07298622280359268,
-0.9255780577659607,
-0.4523347318172455,
0.08556962758302689,
-0.4564148485660553,
0.13487660884857178,
0.26859667897224426,
-0.5500263571739197,
0.4485039710998535,
0.3831557333469391,
-0.3306359052658081,
0.8214820623397827,
-0.20500816404819489,
0.4420020580291748,
-0.5939227938652039,
0.012591087259352207,
0.01700795441865921,
-0.21269051730632782,
-0.3667754530906677,
0.09200270473957062,
0.21534742414951324,
0.08742987364530563,
-0.1748010218143463,
0.2857128083705902,
-0.29656195640563965,
-0.19272038340568542,
-0.08938945829868317,
0.32847970724105835,
0.052632007747888565,
0.1298542469739914,
0.01130384486168623,
0.7028089761734009,
0.619483232498169,
-0.47520527243614197,
0.6853898763656616,
0.2061517983675003,
-0.4485066831111908,
0.8503897190093994,
-0.7998753786087036,
0.10542427003383636,
-0.04778781905770302,
-0.003493892028927803,
-1.0673727989196777,
-0.12962894141674042,
-0.05267979949712753,
-0.7459763884544373,
-0.008543356321752071,
-0.13041622936725616,
-0.3391839265823364,
-0.26361721754074097,
-0.08591081947088242,
0.25463441014289856,
0.5247882008552551,
-0.8105731010437012,
0.5135899186134338,
0.24881824851036072,
-0.2020658701658249,
-0.48972415924072266,
-0.5566607713699341,
0.1356976479291916,
-0.09170174598693848,
-1.0057045221328735,
0.05952287092804909,
-0.336413711309433,
-0.5975582599639893,
-0.1621238738298416,
-0.37940871715545654,
-0.035535287111997604,
0.007786450907588005,
-0.08930440992116928,
0.49450430274009705,
-0.3060959577560425,
0.3156256675720215,
0.13125988841056824,
-0.4622511565685272,
0.5007209181785583,
-0.3065590560436249,
0.2918858826160431,
-0.44728028774261475,
-0.7562915086746216,
-0.5202546715736389,
-0.14420126378536224,
0.638843834400177,
-0.34286317229270935,
0.38461393117904663,
-0.16315722465515137,
-0.5417631268501282,
-0.10940979421138763,
-0.6992505192756653,
-0.004867489915341139,
-0.40492022037506104,
0.25594136118888855,
-0.48288896679878235,
-0.46656906604766846,
0.41591277718544006,
-0.06440360099077225,
0.28377586603164673,
0.6149658560752869,
0.45815354585647583,
-0.043677136301994324,
1.1681654453277588,
-0.04780779033899307,
0.3531879782676697,
-0.11284978687763214,
-0.11592608690261841,
0.16574057936668396,
-0.6604326963424683,
-0.39686888456344604,
-0.5604127645492554,
-0.12085641920566559,
-0.13628092408180237,
-0.6096019744873047,
0.24239599704742432,
0.4418422281742096,
-0.25221455097198486,
0.15678584575653076,
-0.4902375042438507,
0.8623393774032593,
0.12278471142053604,
0.028623206540942192,
0.5063081979751587,
0.022006813436746597,
-0.14577580988407135,
-0.44459402561187744,
-0.4520263671875,
-0.7864401936531067,
1.2401247024536133,
0.2479139119386673,
0.747276782989502,
0.24159187078475952,
0.5864629745483398,
0.31329545378685,
0.7266201376914978,
-0.7417859435081482,
0.5813456177711487,
0.04874693974852562,
-0.30335065722465515,
-0.4421366751194,
-0.6376374363899231,
-0.6249545216560364,
0.5131701827049255,
0.06475485116243362,
-0.43828222155570984,
-0.14333458244800568,
0.18420450389385223,
-0.36640945076942444,
0.0871259793639183,
-0.5183575749397278,
0.8175808787345886,
-0.5800742506980896,
-0.48804864287376404,
-0.3373374938964844,
-0.29772669076919556,
0.43509429693222046,
-0.2107374519109726,
0.14337342977523804,
-0.14610075950622559,
-0.0323251336812973,
0.6135619878768921,
-0.8474355340003967,
0.2015753984451294,
-0.014620041474699974,
-0.11619314551353455,
0.3295421898365021,
0.4982713460922241,
0.5309268236160278,
0.17561231553554535,
-0.3942367136478424,
0.35285621881484985,
-0.07407442480325699,
-0.4110974967479706,
-0.9685807824134827,
0.9082812070846558,
-0.5657957792282104,
-0.7171886563301086,
-0.4494105577468872,
-0.19185984134674072,
-0.3831702470779419,
0.1326356828212738,
0.09391916543245316,
0.451534241437912,
0.07147721946239471,
0.10452600568532944,
0.7314959168434143,
0.06075393408536911,
0.06898628175258636,
0.29963845014572144,
-0.3342894911766052,
-0.5779039859771729,
0.8400002717971802,
0.24721576273441315,
0.29764631390571594,
0.3596132695674896,
0.4455816149711609,
-0.7613914608955383,
-0.7390412092208862,
-0.4601816236972809,
0.16048042476177216,
-0.9935150742530823,
-0.1984420120716095,
-0.3471626043319702,
-0.30753087997436523,
-0.1699257642030716,
-0.045500967651605606,
-0.4267539083957672,
-0.5183037519454956,
-0.24147933721542358,
-0.19285400211811066,
0.1129712462425232,
0.39183270931243896,
-0.056021321564912796,
-0.24320074915885925,
-0.6722737550735474,
0.1589609980583191,
0.3688523769378662,
0.17849890887737274,
-0.1308165341615677,
-0.8636950254440308,
0.19090178608894348,
0.045077137649059296,
-0.20231500267982483,
-0.5998093485832214,
0.3794759511947632,
-0.0033685967791825533,
0.790990948677063,
0.3274776339530945,
-0.04219543933868408,
0.9425923228263855,
-0.34162330627441406,
0.4189011752605438,
0.25712713599205017,
-1.1700222492218018,
0.8348062038421631,
-0.026246899738907814,
0.24498209357261658,
0.5823612809181213,
0.23619996011257172,
-0.1751329004764557,
0.019200081005692482,
-0.552218496799469,
-0.4796840250492096,
0.4512997269630432,
0.4280267655849457,
-0.16373763978481293,
-0.08887013047933578,
0.37147217988967896,
-0.049274686723947525,
0.07302407920360565,
-0.255023330450058,
0.07086729258298874,
-0.151912659406662,
-0.07174784690141678,
0.12000824511051178,
-0.2775237560272217,
-0.08627943694591522,
-0.29917019605636597,
0.6823129653930664,
0.0015797552186995745,
-0.08234298974275589,
0.3081621527671814,
-0.3662623167037964,
-0.1974712610244751,
0.2694675624370575,
0.8373159766197205,
1.6255683898925781,
-0.04672345891594887,
0.08432240039110184,
0.31590351462364197,
-0.2536340355873108,
-0.017496028915047646,
0.16135036945343018,
-0.003939099609851837,
0.01686948724091053,
0.6586408615112305,
0.3488044738769531,
-0.04200611263513565,
-0.817612886428833,
0.5280879139900208,
0.04180257394909859,
-0.1440357118844986,
-0.4509316086769104,
0.12404832243919373,
0.014579004608094692,
0.25162264704704285,
0.39220285415649414,
0.4127922058105469,
0.11103495210409164,
-0.14059635996818542,
0.26285478472709656,
0.36989539861679077,
-0.22873073816299438,
-0.27561771869659424,
0.5655364394187927,
0.1140117421746254,
-0.4392038881778717,
0.735436737537384,
-0.09082794189453125,
-0.6184847950935364,
0.7254760265350342,
0.32132238149642944,
0.7080608606338501,
-0.4423096179962158,
0.14418672025203705,
0.5583914518356323,
0.4792041480541229,
-0.21165035665035248,
0.47596222162246704,
0.015154700726270676,
-0.6092313528060913,
-0.8486422896385193,
-0.5640445351600647,
-0.5386624932289124,
0.015742210671305656,
-0.44141697883605957,
0.2608067989349365,
-0.5817983746528625,
-0.14603252708911896,
-0.16295090317726135,
-0.10943955183029175,
-0.3453279435634613,
0.3443549871444702,
-0.153939887881279,
1.0118699073791504,
-0.5704668164253235,
0.4516008496284485,
0.5379428267478943,
-0.2099151611328125,
-0.5397005677223206,
-0.31044307351112366,
0.019686125218868256,
-0.793100118637085,
0.8351609706878662,
0.11507392674684525,
-0.35577017068862915,
-0.22882525622844696,
-0.49080920219421387,
-0.8449435234069824,
0.8567020893096924,
0.5612211227416992,
-0.734409749507904,
0.3728066682815552,
-0.04092474654316902,
0.7020856738090515,
-0.23584994673728943,
0.5794323682785034,
0.7341775298118591,
0.4717382490634918,
0.605313241481781,
-0.6898608803749084,
-0.15219151973724365,
-0.321840763092041,
-0.12179633975028992,
0.23086963593959808,
-0.2609114944934845,
0.7486169338226318,
-0.5799961686134338,
-0.10533978044986725,
-0.005309063009917736,
0.6493044495582581,
0.8719996213912964,
0.4178042709827423,
0.3522009551525116,
0.8278486728668213,
1.1473274230957031,
-0.3577585220336914,
0.9959999322891235,
-0.11965642869472504,
0.4073714315891266,
1.1574745178222656,
-0.3831787705421448,
0.882203996181488,
0.22580979764461517,
-0.45723801851272583,
0.37950921058654785,
0.6392887234687805,
0.16006825864315033,
0.21014094352722168,
0.4671655595302582,
-0.1475083976984024,
-0.9262977838516235,
0.13125604391098022,
-0.39453598856925964,
0.09732074290513992,
0.5756149291992188,
-0.22020085155963898,
-0.4327625334262848,
-0.3852235674858093,
-0.051213353872299194,
0.3987247943878174,
-0.369902104139328,
0.25109991431236267,
0.007344464771449566,
-0.758362352848053,
0.7984429597854614,
-0.09855400025844574,
0.0921158418059349,
-0.3977227509021759,
-0.3387027084827423,
-0.35931000113487244,
0.24664735794067383,
-0.43106338381767273,
-0.9879067540168762,
0.4717455804347992,
0.06959235668182373,
-0.028442146256566048,
-0.04398534819483757,
0.6791107654571533,
-0.2126033902168274,
-0.7493038177490234,
0.027189116925001144,
0.5207040309906006,
0.3063577115535736,
-0.13166075944900513,
-0.8296410441398621,
0.11123868823051453,
-0.20473508536815643,
-0.15195581316947937,
-0.14754065871238708,
0.5218406915664673,
-0.22668224573135376,
0.9370031952857971,
1.0264594554901123,
0.07390163838863373,
-0.1281089186668396,
0.3724730312824249,
0.77089524269104,
-0.526125967502594,
-0.39440304040908813,
-1.2030376195907593,
0.43259498476982117,
-0.2694832682609558,
-0.4345591962337494,
0.8572731614112854,
0.5652912855148315,
0.5882874131202698,
0.3044067621231079,
0.5872908234596252,
0.3838098347187042,
0.5846996903419495,
-0.6195809245109558,
0.4554471969604492,
-0.323916494846344,
0.6244515180587769,
-0.37629666924476624,
-1.0089529752731323,
-0.7397475242614746,
0.9679602980613708,
-0.6886760592460632,
0.11549089103937149,
0.7067569494247437,
0.6588295698165894,
0.02127237617969513,
0.18792486190795898,
0.5503531694412231,
0.17184679210186005,
0.46032214164733887,
0.7021458745002747,
1.2932586669921875,
-0.31122732162475586,
0.5837084650993347,
0.08125696331262589,
-0.5042273998260498,
-0.07398603856563568,
-0.9458896517753601,
-1.0578701496124268,
-0.09278269112110138,
-0.5557262301445007,
-0.5413506031036377,
0.03038894385099411,
0.9063735604286194,
0.6117475628852844,
-0.9099690318107605,
0.0028833188116550446,
-0.4686700999736786,
0.4029327630996704,
-0.2575680613517761,
-0.20641328394412994,
0.5927654504776001,
-0.46110308170318604,
-0.4389740526676178,
0.5252203941345215,
0.4821047782897949,
-0.3008396625518799,
-0.3015997111797333,
-0.244522362947464,
0.17499050498008728,
0.2564127445220947,
0.753762423992157,
0.04531996697187424,
-0.8275645971298218,
0.016358507797122,
0.23455710709095,
0.04488752782344818,
0.13681907951831818,
0.5409255623817444,
-0.6015598177909851,
0.6119263768196106,
0.8153883814811707,
0.8162686228752136,
0.16267147660255432,
0.2075713723897934,
0.23777297139167786,
0.023342624306678772,
-0.616742730140686,
0.42811572551727295,
0.43502917885780334,
0.376399427652359,
-0.08332344889640808,
0.6068192720413208,
0.26925942301750183,
-0.7972484230995178,
-0.6956618428230286,
0.07700775563716888,
-0.5708221793174744,
-0.12503015995025635,
0.9660546183586121,
-0.2879766821861267,
-0.16995099186897278,
0.058344271034002304,
-0.25286075472831726,
-0.25454315543174744,
-0.3521538972854614,
0.859272837638855,
1.0443722009658813,
-0.4573456346988678,
-0.23825593292713165,
-0.5238191485404968,
0.2976091504096985,
0.5310075879096985,
-1.1299738883972168,
0.08714833110570908,
0.7909181118011475,
0.29535573720932007,
0.40572601556777954,
0.3766508400440216,
-0.36559879779815674,
0.5773787498474121,
-0.3008861541748047,
-0.4557132124900818,
-0.07639776170253754,
-0.46265819668769836,
-0.31470271944999695,
0.25658631324768066,
0.09587854146957397,
0.058494407683610916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05659v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05659v2
|
VietMed: A Dataset and Benchmark for Automatic Speech Recognition of Vietnamese in the Medical Domain
| 2024-04-08T16:43:52 | 2024-05-28T05:27:48 |
Khai Le-Duc
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, eess.AS
|
Due to privacy restrictions, there's a shortage of publicly available speech
recognition datasets in the medical domain. In this work, we present VietMed -
a Vietnamese speech recognition dataset in the medical domain comprising 16h of
labeled medical speech, 1000h of unlabeled medical speech and 1200h of
unlabeled general-domain speech. To our best knowledge, VietMed is by far the
world's largest public medical speech recognition dataset in 7 aspects: total
duration, number of speakers, diseases, recording conditions, speaker roles,
unique medical terms and accents. VietMed is also by far the largest public
Vietnamese speech dataset in terms of total duration. Additionally, we are the
first to present a medical ASR dataset covering all ICD-10 disease groups and
all accents within a country. Moreover, we release the first public large-scale
pre-trained models for Vietnamese ASR, w2v2-Viet and XLSR-53-Viet, along with
the first public large-scale fine-tuned models for medical ASR. Even without
any medical data in unsupervised pre-training, our best pre-trained model
XLSR-53-Viet generalizes very well to the medical domain by outperforming
state-of-the-art XLSR-53, from 51.8% to 29.6% WER on test set (a relative
reduction of more than 40%). All code, data and models are made publicly
available: https://github.com/leduckhai/MultiMed.
|
[
-0.16545407474040985,
0.02821812592446804,
0.46463286876678467,
0.032480936497449875,
-0.37988996505737305,
-0.021437523886561394,
-0.28339746594429016,
-0.39195704460144043,
0.008709722198545933,
0.8100362420082092,
0.03819047659635544,
-0.653832733631134,
-0.8002586960792542,
0.24956034123897552,
-0.27730581164360046,
0.7885239124298096,
-0.013110717758536339,
0.5413919687271118,
0.06261434406042099,
-0.6808129549026489,
-0.09136839956045151,
-0.9047455191612244,
-0.4052309989929199,
-0.11412196606397629,
0.4710305631160736,
0.3849777281284332,
0.3930680453777313,
0.8047583103179932,
0.6746209859848022,
0.30092981457710266,
0.04236409068107605,
0.30628105998039246,
-0.18704046308994293,
-0.1176948994398117,
0.11165859550237656,
-0.011937723495066166,
-0.6169154644012451,
0.09555552899837494,
0.7348059415817261,
0.3248947560787201,
-0.029849085956811905,
0.15519914031028748,
-0.18028153479099274,
0.5495509505271912,
-0.28740182518959045,
0.14321665465831757,
-0.5290396809577942,
-0.152021124958992,
-0.1587512195110321,
-0.22575582563877106,
-0.10816821455955505,
-0.39015233516693115,
0.410007119178772,
-0.5054931640625,
0.031117279082536697,
-0.3113659620285034,
0.8238948583602905,
0.48646554350852966,
-0.7059195041656494,
-0.042730867862701416,
-0.7462317943572998,
0.43791505694389343,
-0.21554532647132874,
0.43862849473953247,
0.42396655678749084,
0.7566189169883728,
0.23766034841537476,
-0.8242172598838806,
-0.0754774957895279,
-0.375416100025177,
0.05812402814626694,
0.25296318531036377,
-0.4202164113521576,
0.21170325577259064,
0.2388077676296234,
0.2839720547199249,
-0.8268561363220215,
0.10804030299186707,
-0.7159695029258728,
-0.2144239991903305,
0.7750231027603149,
-0.023625003173947334,
0.1033327728509903,
0.05689217895269394,
-0.4903166890144348,
0.1065596416592598,
-0.7188287973403931,
-0.303548663854599,
-0.3227936327457428,
0.36902812123298645,
-0.39296722412109375,
0.5936968326568604,
-0.2938503324985504,
0.7202091813087463,
-0.4030664563179016,
-0.05184073746204376,
0.6872718334197998,
-0.2740205228328705,
-0.3178088665008545,
0.27857062220573425,
0.8061730861663818,
0.3945794999599457,
0.5862842202186584,
0.172823965549469,
-0.2879835069179535,
0.4499962031841278,
0.21145497262477875,
-0.6132078766822815,
-0.3679245114326477,
0.4079657793045044,
-0.5392504930496216,
0.18697720766067505,
0.2505636215209961,
-0.27438420057296753,
-0.45402011275291443,
-0.6199845671653748,
0.4487340748310089,
-0.15689466893672943,
-0.21587182581424713,
0.28630390763282776,
-0.10855656862258911,
-0.08500112593173981,
0.08257471024990082,
-0.12110637128353119,
0.5274208188056946,
0.6155638098716736,
0.8026702404022217,
-0.3091690242290497,
-0.2023564726114273,
-0.7175649404525757,
0.12051662057638168,
-0.228836327791214,
0.8601426482200623,
-0.23474469780921936,
-0.5397705435752869,
-0.14733614027500153,
0.15445876121520996,
-0.030610250309109688,
-1.1338942050933838,
0.410145103931427,
-0.07296962291002274,
0.08654135465621948,
0.04225767403841019,
-0.6666620373725891,
0.008305881172418594,
-0.18004120886325836,
-0.6758390069007874,
0.48848962783813477,
0.06381278485059738,
-0.6431610584259033,
0.3167315125465393,
-0.6393733620643616,
-0.16728927195072174,
0.19763007760047913,
-0.4598487615585327,
-0.5543102622032166,
0.09452420473098755,
0.033840078860521317,
0.35278600454330444,
-0.5555852651596069,
0.14643695950508118,
0.005232228897511959,
-0.37627002596855164,
0.2848415672779083,
-0.3793722093105316,
0.7969091534614563,
0.39651235938072205,
-0.03291050344705582,
0.2937282621860504,
-0.9981905817985535,
0.11443573981523514,
0.022432005032896996,
-0.4671243131160736,
-0.39932313561439514,
-0.36541038751602173,
0.3048289120197296,
0.4942260682582855,
-0.04406904801726341,
-0.6519125699996948,
-0.026217041537165642,
-0.34654954075813293,
0.4332420825958252,
0.3695843815803528,
0.041244860738515854,
-0.05287348851561546,
-0.49600502848625183,
0.37757909297943115,
0.2054351568222046,
0.18547971546649933,
-0.07140117138624191,
-0.6538203358650208,
-0.38573989272117615,
-0.8746517300605774,
0.4251280426979065,
0.52089923620224,
-0.4516240060329437,
0.5494853258132935,
-0.3170924484729767,
-0.6080531477928162,
-1.1517750024795532,
-0.39748427271842957,
0.6070898175239563,
0.5820944309234619,
0.46775224804878235,
-0.2270970195531845,
-0.779772937297821,
-0.8469551205635071,
-0.1846340447664261,
-0.3040027916431427,
-0.5537223815917969,
0.4472712278366089,
0.3151096999645233,
-0.7918623089790344,
0.6755183935165405,
-0.5590620040893555,
-0.5789195895195007,
0.16567254066467285,
-0.11842700839042664,
0.19448153674602509,
0.3327304422855377,
0.40398722887039185,
-0.9130762815475464,
-0.4959656596183777,
0.03846454247832298,
-0.642080545425415,
-0.3656083345413208,
0.3868788778781891,
0.16331729292869568,
0.2842942178249359,
0.25485894083976746,
-0.4498954117298126,
0.4442194104194641,
0.7250794172286987,
-0.34675532579421997,
0.31337133049964905,
-0.5665494799613953,
0.10488519072532654,
-1.0006216764450073,
0.30523017048835754,
-0.14105474948883057,
-0.3497522175312042,
-0.655185878276825,
-0.3000353276729584,
0.03387271240353584,
-0.20405201613903046,
-0.43443724513053894,
0.6084672212600708,
-0.30088376998901367,
-0.09788655489683151,
-0.4003707468509674,
-0.24025382101535797,
-0.10404127836227417,
-0.11881833523511887,
0.3768819272518158,
0.6203970313072205,
0.6812726259231567,
-0.62973552942276,
0.49883830547332764,
0.07639866322278976,
-0.2612781524658203,
0.5692343711853027,
-0.9918307065963745,
0.03098452277481556,
0.101670041680336,
0.21786385774612427,
-0.5911527276039124,
-0.15388017892837524,
-0.0285435002297163,
-0.6068731546401978,
0.054461389780044556,
-0.16598474979400635,
-0.2636033892631531,
-0.4859991669654846,
0.04321025311946869,
0.37115299701690674,
0.6436665058135986,
-0.45637059211730957,
0.274563193321228,
1.0157420635223389,
-0.13852940499782562,
-0.15128697454929352,
-0.2466956228017807,
-0.04608501121401787,
-0.39495983719825745,
-0.1991262584924698,
0.37169337272644043,
-0.08438071608543396,
-0.30360081791877747,
-0.3170351982116699,
-0.06719298660755157,
-0.6163266897201538,
-0.23523765802383423,
0.4772408902645111,
0.32493317127227783,
-0.3570372462272644,
0.28206881880760193,
-0.3964449465274811,
-0.6235821843147278,
0.0389956496655941,
-0.3425770699977875,
0.32859930396080017,
-0.021635614335536957,
-0.28326335549354553,
-0.653869092464447,
0.32952573895454407,
0.7698740363121033,
-0.12392439693212509,
0.08413469046354294,
0.36817386746406555,
-0.7415448427200317,
0.41685956716537476,
-0.5029793381690979,
0.09097123891115189,
-0.3664694130420685,
0.4063430726528168,
-0.2873087227344513,
-0.726934015750885,
0.12248888611793518,
0.02099616266787052,
-0.05153055116534233,
0.49401092529296875,
0.6272434592247009,
0.13266368210315704,
0.985645055770874,
0.25750330090522766,
-0.4756121039390564,
0.009325895458459854,
-0.03591384366154671,
-0.4023636281490326,
-0.4561583995819092,
-0.1973811686038971,
-0.6885955333709717,
0.11667466908693314,
-1.043677568435669,
-0.7142463326454163,
0.580544114112854,
-0.5584684610366821,
-0.4604167640209198,
0.27368253469467163,
-0.8083016276359558,
0.11070921272039413,
0.5999692678451538,
0.1317039430141449,
0.42694348096847534,
-0.07186626642942429,
0.09180743992328644,
-0.12582919001579285,
-0.3618565797805786,
-0.49137723445892334,
1.1893202066421509,
0.2195298671722412,
0.7776188254356384,
-0.49909019470214844,
0.7200495600700378,
0.21014085412025452,
0.023890074342489243,
-0.6572807431221008,
0.21352306008338928,
-0.6416909098625183,
-0.38214895129203796,
-0.11393944919109344,
-0.6919646859169006,
-1.1260452270507812,
-0.07104954123497009,
-0.0017082109116017818,
-0.15829972922801971,
0.04778192937374115,
0.1654893010854721,
-0.33533525466918945,
0.004420141689479351,
-0.5732852220535278,
0.4997785687446594,
-0.3080117702484131,
0.3865934908390045,
-0.0473146066069603,
-0.8812723159790039,
-0.19476473331451416,
-0.2712334394454956,
-0.027916857972741127,
-0.2498171627521515,
-0.1999392807483673,
0.7193585634231567,
-0.5606399774551392,
0.29987141489982605,
-0.45949608087539673,
0.17599573731422424,
0.15255451202392578,
-0.6808544397354126,
0.0546627976000309,
0.1806129515171051,
0.11719043552875519,
0.6612442135810852,
-0.04994157701730728,
-0.21489830315113068,
-0.10502979159355164,
0.44923049211502075,
-0.9827710390090942,
-0.13801422715187073,
-0.6385666728019714,
-0.09310207515954971,
-0.16192083060741425,
0.15703338384628296,
0.5949368476867676,
0.47655993700027466,
-0.3574322462081909,
0.07076776027679443,
0.600252091884613,
-0.4281966984272003,
-0.19568565487861633,
0.8802152276039124,
-0.06662654876708984,
-0.7652664184570312,
1.1171295642852783,
0.42891690135002136,
-0.06328391283750534,
0.38765254616737366,
0.1768501251935959,
-0.2979336082935333,
-0.2206665724515915,
-0.24338868260383606,
0.41443750262260437,
-0.2992464005947113,
-0.2733915150165558,
-0.9421172142028809,
-0.8824041485786438,
-0.3832073509693146,
0.11666834354400635,
-0.5654608607292175,
-0.3338998854160309,
-0.1473977416753769,
-0.07414240390062332,
0.5760943293571472,
0.9198898673057556,
-0.21298976242542267,
0.20109286904335022,
-0.7521803975105286,
0.890688419342041,
0.3532268702983856,
0.290134459733963,
-0.6256577968597412,
-0.5553320050239563,
-0.11834737658500671,
0.0006080062012188137,
0.1591641902923584,
-0.33700644969940186,
0.5375003218650818,
0.2961237132549286,
0.32486414909362793,
0.4797150492668152,
0.1343846470117569,
0.5569705367088318,
-0.8254643082618713,
0.3178962767124176,
0.06828858703374863,
-0.4826520085334778,
0.564555287361145,
-0.0762317106127739,
0.5062938928604126,
0.4943462610244751,
0.5113744735717773,
-0.6513291001319885,
-0.3180340826511383,
-0.5682061910629272,
-0.7777668237686157,
0.4409593939781189,
0.13776396214962006,
-0.2760382294654846,
0.18682655692100525,
0.07849492877721786,
0.2651197612285614,
0.24088527262210846,
-0.005206185858696699,
-0.3923571705818176,
-0.12057415395975113,
-0.24180497229099274,
-0.4656555652618408,
-0.12306033819913864,
-0.22142919898033142,
-0.5095206499099731,
0.3887106478214264,
0.06429503858089447,
0.6476635932922363,
0.19626812636852264,
0.024168429896235466,
0.17257292568683624,
0.036319103091955185,
0.6207671165466309,
0.6835792660713196,
-0.1276007741689682,
0.26159095764160156,
0.024222517386078835,
-0.9375949501991272,
0.3144693076610565,
0.5862092971801758,
0.2246178239583969,
0.47640588879585266,
0.2622104287147522,
0.6333250999450684,
-0.09344486892223358,
-0.8753216862678528,
0.5222300887107849,
-0.4483301341533661,
0.03732325881719589,
-0.5370407700538635,
-0.07739900797605515,
-0.16151201725006104,
0.08195390552282333,
0.4002014100551605,
-0.014797174371778965,
0.24084410071372986,
0.00869813933968544,
0.6402402520179749,
0.029826022684574127,
-0.7786508798599243,
-0.38688960671424866,
0.6676297187805176,
0.11682480573654175,
-0.3174140453338623,
0.6956065893173218,
0.46505990624427795,
-0.39159131050109863,
0.5917852520942688,
0.25583842396736145,
0.8079026937484741,
-0.645573616027832,
0.16386932134628296,
0.25419729948043823,
-0.015464907512068748,
-0.10013017803430557,
0.6929184794425964,
0.2717668414115906,
-0.3603239357471466,
-0.00698456633836031,
-0.2792973220348358,
-0.510628879070282,
0.21951648592948914,
-0.8705689311027527,
0.5685614943504333,
-0.1529868096113205,
-0.35643112659454346,
0.1898602396249771,
0.0693560391664505,
-0.5041499733924866,
0.6165519952774048,
0.16410504281520844,
0.8671168088912964,
-0.6219649910926819,
1.0220404863357544,
0.8505461812019348,
0.09258689731359482,
-0.3097863495349884,
-0.08187898993492126,
0.3040381371974945,
-1.0622539520263672,
0.21641305088996887,
0.4757845103740692,
-0.07077530026435852,
-0.09069990366697311,
-0.32608214020729065,
-0.6206555366516113,
0.7998132109642029,
0.5150670409202576,
-0.5118946433067322,
0.02154296264052391,
0.2918477952480316,
0.786530613899231,
-0.5478019118309021,
-0.055942434817552567,
0.6021789312362671,
0.1991594433784485,
-0.07468981295824051,
-1.173885464668274,
-0.16860388219356537,
-0.3455597162246704,
-0.05375627055764198,
-0.043676797300577164,
-0.5932877063751221,
0.6866872906684875,
-0.1989191174507141,
-0.045537203550338745,
0.10363276302814484,
0.35289812088012695,
0.6381216049194336,
0.5383147597312927,
0.44779476523399353,
0.21623310446739197,
0.959322988986969,
-0.04022858291864395,
0.7432308793067932,
-0.41701433062553406,
0.009944399818778038,
1.051447868347168,
-0.4398059844970703,
0.6675046682357788,
0.03787451237440109,
0.08925862610340118,
-0.2131662219762802,
0.5254711508750916,
0.07089917361736298,
0.5956317782402039,
0.19821421802043915,
-0.34061962366104126,
-0.11959001421928406,
-0.3925444483757019,
-0.8307978510856628,
0.8141568303108215,
0.29849356412887573,
-0.47315606474876404,
0.32960280776023865,
0.3128435015678406,
-0.02260752208530903,
-0.059591904282569885,
-0.25362396240234375,
1.0543164014816284,
0.28685659170150757,
-0.21454615890979767,
0.7696741819381714,
-0.2839493751525879,
0.5039045810699463,
-0.6104716658592224,
-0.08332724124193192,
0.18102647364139557,
0.3308447599411011,
-0.046696197241544724,
-0.4866766035556793,
0.26221513748168945,
0.0762486606836319,
-0.13355478644371033,
-0.036505911499261856,
0.6055989861488342,
-0.5680041909217834,
-0.34719565510749817,
0.5487335324287415,
0.3318033516407013,
0.4026026129722595,
-0.35203036665916443,
-0.4582046568393707,
0.09138958156108856,
-0.35371673107147217,
0.20999345183372498,
0.24152441322803497,
0.4992296099662781,
0.06405771523714066,
0.5064214468002319,
0.14718198776245117,
0.5462599992752075,
-0.2762982249259949,
0.1809883564710617,
0.9785320162773132,
-0.6672427654266357,
-0.5205545425415039,
-0.5503429174423218,
0.37623533606529236,
-0.06318999081850052,
-0.649837851524353,
0.48074206709861755,
0.8683257102966309,
0.8165729641914368,
0.04286285117268562,
0.8318856954574585,
0.437250018119812,
0.9835360050201416,
-0.27630615234375,
1.127907633781433,
-0.5448637008666992,
-0.1749952733516693,
-0.20620431005954742,
-0.47409528493881226,
-0.4266059398651123,
0.5194581747055054,
0.08280187845230103,
0.09448792040348053,
0.3975144326686859,
0.5029556155204773,
0.1385508030653,
-0.15693238377571106,
0.6783245205879211,
0.35623008012771606,
0.04094235971570015,
0.4960797429084778,
0.7522761225700378,
-0.3229066729545593,
0.3754478693008423,
-0.1102321669459343,
-0.386959433555603,
-0.3974204957485199,
-0.06456500291824341,
-0.6198724508285522,
-0.8421403765678406,
-0.37154150009155273,
-0.31280389428138733,
0.4135447144508362,
1.256272792816162,
0.867279589176178,
-0.9992333054542542,
-0.4544239342212677,
0.4813326597213745,
-0.18489257991313934,
-0.3068123757839203,
-0.09115210920572281,
0.5039575695991516,
0.39650142192840576,
-0.5490744113922119,
0.5012607574462891,
0.48755764961242676,
0.2093266397714615,
0.24951253831386566,
-0.1861768513917923,
0.07037155330181122,
-0.227458193898201,
0.5165404081344604,
0.35744380950927734,
-0.40087729692459106,
-0.14142543077468872,
0.02371414564549923,
-0.5252139568328857,
0.5161203742027283,
0.8521654009819031,
-0.7902753949165344,
0.6906024217605591,
0.21360112726688385,
0.3986680209636688,
0.12525895237922668,
0.11374156177043915,
0.6063700914382935,
-0.4677865207195282,
0.1582813858985901,
0.5415749549865723,
0.29588788747787476,
0.2791869640350342,
-0.13228696584701538,
0.6717439889907837,
0.1512918621301651,
-0.8523673415184021,
-0.9476794004440308,
-0.034719593822956085,
-0.749484658241272,
0.03633049875497818,
1.0180916786193848,
-0.307931512594223,
0.045493606477975845,
-0.6145610809326172,
-0.30679139494895935,
0.5117179751396179,
-0.4737076461315155,
0.7502180337905884,
-0.028406495228409767,
-0.20506401360034943,
0.22860081493854523,
-0.45147040486335754,
0.6909719705581665,
-0.18022863566875458,
-0.9139143228530884,
0.10872645676136017,
0.6178460121154785,
0.17486241459846497,
-0.10162444412708282,
1.027112603187561,
-0.2597965896129608,
0.5282943844795227,
-0.22726963460445404,
-0.07500793784856796,
0.09528566896915436,
-0.7469704151153564,
-0.7474581003189087,
-0.06334743648767471,
0.03265425190329552,
-0.4745160937309265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05656v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05656v2
|
Causality Extraction from Nuclear Licensee Event Reports Using a Hybrid Framework
| 2024-04-08T16:39:34 | 2024-04-22T15:25:20 |
Shahidur Rahoman Sohag, Sai Zhang, Min Xian, Shoukun Sun, Fei Xu, Zhegang Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Industry-wide nuclear power plant operating experience is a critical source
of raw data for performing parameter estimations in reliability and risk
models. Much operating experience information pertains to failure events and is
stored as reports containing unstructured data, such as narratives. Event
reports are essential for understanding how failures are initiated and
propagated, including the numerous causal relations involved. Causal relation
extraction using deep learning represents a significant frontier in the field
of natural language processing (NLP), and is crucial since it enables the
interpretation of intricate narratives and connections contained within vast
amounts of written information. This paper proposed a hybrid framework for
causality detection and extraction from nuclear licensee event reports. The
main contributions include: (1) we compiled an LER corpus with 20,129 text
samples for causality analysis, (2) developed an interactive tool for labeling
cause effect pairs, (3) built a deep-learning-based approach for causal
relation detection, and (4) developed a knowledge based cause-effect extraction
approach.
|
[
-0.2474423348903656,
-0.7625608444213867,
0.848633348941803,
0.04893403872847557,
-0.284501314163208,
-0.14961910247802734,
-0.12190283834934235,
-0.6164026260375977,
0.07034864276647568,
0.5373244881629944,
-0.36780399084091187,
-0.3944151997566223,
-0.530730128288269,
-0.0219175536185503,
-0.10229148715734482,
1.1567161083221436,
-0.020275136455893517,
0.07007445394992828,
-0.2415868639945984,
0.08332589268684387,
-0.6279993057250977,
-0.311236172914505,
-0.5483142137527466,
-0.7219833135604858,
0.5624794363975525,
0.30750977993011475,
0.4886169731616974,
0.3227539658546448,
0.44937068223953247,
0.2878403961658478,
0.212116539478302,
0.1425294727087021,
-0.34821829199790955,
-0.06335323303937912,
-0.21646392345428467,
-0.26010754704475403,
-0.39219632744789124,
0.12585997581481934,
0.7043209075927734,
0.52861088514328,
0.06411924958229065,
-0.1677531749010086,
0.023099103942513466,
0.43641310930252075,
-0.6674281358718872,
0.4527933895587921,
-0.5170727968215942,
0.19497767090797424,
-0.05906371399760246,
-0.7702794075012207,
-0.6303250193595886,
-0.1583142727613449,
0.027439314872026443,
-0.6927299499511719,
0.13218197226524353,
-0.08763445168733597,
0.9279099106788635,
0.060133110731840134,
-0.7217298746109009,
-0.1637076735496521,
-1.0664141178131104,
0.7855650782585144,
-0.9076876640319824,
0.3205089867115021,
0.17817217111587524,
0.15296608209609985,
-0.42003190517425537,
-0.6312119364738464,
-0.49218806624412537,
-0.22795715928077698,
-0.42466142773628235,
0.22502350807189941,
0.012298263609409332,
0.10559730976819992,
0.22125554084777832,
0.4585162401199341,
-0.6678207516670227,
0.560094952583313,
-0.3415611684322357,
-0.2650853991508484,
0.7231644988059998,
0.24800297617912292,
0.4567747712135315,
-0.5431631207466125,
-0.7314482927322388,
-0.050636060535907745,
-0.5939887166023254,
-0.38900378346443176,
0.5357310175895691,
0.1372458040714264,
-0.3966730237007141,
0.37151896953582764,
-0.13339123129844666,
0.5597515106201172,
-0.42711034417152405,
-0.1891031414270401,
0.12817560136318207,
-0.3691977560520172,
-0.4943855106830597,
0.32031193375587463,
1.0888826847076416,
0.09024836868047714,
-0.006498943082988262,
-0.39158180356025696,
0.1483755260705948,
-0.032597433775663376,
0.016503987833857536,
-0.4603898823261261,
-0.28965866565704346,
0.2928631901741028,
-0.5853528380393982,
-0.4547674357891083,
0.40623560547828674,
-1.0724493265151978,
-0.6183030009269714,
-0.4425713121891022,
0.2825251817703247,
-0.42363959550857544,
-0.7348949909210205,
0.03614401817321777,
-0.47373563051223755,
0.4302625060081482,
-0.12779073417186737,
-0.4433620274066925,
0.13648627698421478,
0.6531930565834045,
0.625332236289978,
-0.22014780342578888,
-0.22335004806518555,
-0.6700870990753174,
0.3821912407875061,
0.15271592140197754,
0.738106906414032,
-0.2377498298883438,
-0.3178764283657074,
-0.08641721308231354,
-0.29610398411750793,
-0.31262850761413574,
-0.49019891023635864,
0.5843247771263123,
-0.7519959211349487,
0.15636038780212402,
0.13625195622444153,
-0.7366337180137634,
-0.04347936064004898,
-0.07530274987220764,
-0.737748384475708,
0.8343589305877686,
-0.12792886793613434,
-1.0523130893707275,
0.5758324861526489,
-0.36552202701568604,
-0.5964946150779724,
0.1932143121957779,
-0.5162193179130554,
-0.5737748742103577,
-0.013765640556812286,
-0.07372868061065674,
0.5063070058822632,
-0.4116542935371399,
0.7397552728652954,
-0.4005211591720581,
0.1964607536792755,
0.32350075244903564,
-0.3126915693283081,
0.7210960984230042,
0.13077151775360107,
-0.44655635952949524,
0.3761180639266968,
-1.1742675304412842,
-0.31898269057273865,
0.043535131961107254,
-0.2521987557411194,
-0.5178341269493103,
0.24034012854099274,
0.20525291562080383,
0.5175356864929199,
0.048155833035707474,
-0.6254156231880188,
-0.23591648042201996,
-0.3968610465526581,
-0.21595360338687897,
0.46022090315818787,
0.5667007565498352,
0.5197860598564148,
-0.047552622854709625,
0.37844058871269226,
0.187867671251297,
0.10750044882297516,
0.07634899020195007,
-0.3458348214626312,
-0.5436108112335205,
0.03035634011030197,
-0.07448582351207733,
0.6399831771850586,
-0.9142815470695496,
0.7715242505073547,
0.01256911177188158,
-0.3227689862251282,
0.17603141069412231,
0.1053827702999115,
0.4279733896255493,
0.9832273125648499,
0.24563513696193695,
0.13682518899440765,
-0.8876787424087524,
-0.8855913877487183,
-0.2977578043937683,
-0.20215833187103271,
-0.09934812784194946,
0.129778653383255,
0.452297180891037,
0.045023784041404724,
1.0270243883132935,
-0.7413151264190674,
-0.5091175436973572,
-0.34753504395484924,
0.5098828673362732,
0.29704412817955017,
0.4558292329311371,
0.29345449805259705,
-1.0772124528884888,
-0.019730955362319946,
0.31190288066864014,
-1.3276079893112183,
0.14985226094722748,
-0.49762609601020813,
0.07746230810880661,
0.005998322274535894,
0.7395538687705994,
-0.29136937856674194,
0.31687217950820923,
0.21212798357009888,
-0.25268831849098206,
0.7870752215385437,
-0.37399056553840637,
0.025932246819138527,
-1.1425983905792236,
0.2514239251613617,
0.20639385282993317,
0.0794917568564415,
-0.49909287691116333,
-0.14576880633831024,
-0.1674257218837738,
-0.11689815670251846,
-0.38854649662971497,
0.16721229255199432,
-0.4187310039997101,
-0.24933543801307678,
-0.29624974727630615,
-0.03811279684305191,
-0.06407546252012253,
0.24830646812915802,
0.3579350709915161,
0.1696513295173645,
0.17196325957775116,
-0.5874204635620117,
0.2268679141998291,
0.04163287580013275,
-0.2040424793958664,
0.2506023943424225,
-0.35201096534729004,
-0.16379113495349884,
-0.014969906769692898,
0.2228652387857437,
-0.6368115544319153,
-0.2544489800930023,
0.2235354632139206,
-0.22440484166145325,
0.40131086111068726,
-0.07337106764316559,
-0.5253071784973145,
0.022937297821044922,
-0.055642906576395035,
0.2532573640346527,
0.31545716524124146,
-0.2446477711200714,
0.9544195532798767,
0.5437981486320496,
0.02619636245071888,
-0.37603679299354553,
-0.44123879075050354,
0.04803597927093506,
-0.17776378989219666,
-0.5796656012535095,
0.1518268883228302,
0.45805975794792175,
-0.19860082864761353,
0.20817287266254425,
0.09121282398700714,
-0.2987339496612549,
0.17431464791297913,
0.5014791488647461,
0.40311774611473083,
-0.44160279631614685,
-0.06655612587928772,
-0.02433626912534237,
-0.5162131190299988,
0.5887749791145325,
0.10720247030258179,
0.5943636894226074,
0.04027430713176727,
-0.003050168277695775,
-0.6651703715324402,
0.6119678020477295,
0.5137782692909241,
-0.18691740930080414,
1.0082496404647827,
0.5323286652565002,
-0.4539281725883484,
-0.18367114663124084,
-0.38265329599380493,
-0.27706706523895264,
-0.42228373885154724,
0.29610398411750793,
0.10883495211601257,
-0.5275529623031616,
0.6600819230079651,
-0.40636637806892395,
-0.16760194301605225,
0.9401602149009705,
0.2987685799598694,
-0.0029021191876381636,
0.3542637526988983,
0.5856578350067139,
-0.24604660272598267,
0.28829628229141235,
-0.2590220868587494,
0.231424942612648,
-0.5525896549224854,
-0.6289778351783752,
-0.429763525724411,
0.01585596799850464,
-0.3091488182544708,
0.0638655349612236,
0.5926640033721924,
-0.04105771705508232,
-0.11639124155044556,
0.2883399426937103,
0.10056602209806442,
0.15983152389526367,
0.10558600723743439,
0.13746225833892822,
0.6414053440093994,
-0.21277236938476562,
-0.0999828577041626,
-0.09086950868368149,
-0.6796004772186279,
-0.3147183358669281,
0.565535306930542,
0.2094477415084839,
0.22086888551712036,
-0.0161866657435894,
0.9864178895950317,
0.22913886606693268,
0.29259592294692993,
-0.40333810448646545,
0.4187858998775482,
0.10915801674127579,
-0.4366987943649292,
-0.3459235429763794,
-0.8142185807228088,
-0.8482762575149536,
-0.029972996562719345,
-0.504967212677002,
-0.594279944896698,
0.4462250769138336,
0.0685034841299057,
-0.2439000904560089,
0.41419142484664917,
-0.6172608733177185,
0.9634066820144653,
-0.14533309638500214,
-0.06938285380601883,
-0.3975061774253845,
-0.6440466046333313,
0.8559581637382507,
-0.08793216198682785,
0.5264198184013367,
-0.05673441290855408,
0.221540629863739,
0.7704359292984009,
-0.3603958487510681,
0.9608703255653381,
-0.13968780636787415,
-0.06481251120567322,
0.08945351839065552,
-0.06706573814153671,
0.5545499324798584,
0.23780152201652527,
-0.14030644297599792,
0.21597690880298615,
-0.287480890750885,
0.01283583976328373,
-0.3815113306045532,
0.8475427031517029,
-0.616495668888092,
-0.047931522130966187,
-0.6116160154342651,
-0.5011067986488342,
-0.3348481059074402,
0.4037656784057617,
0.38100963830947876,
0.4640483856201172,
-0.37408193945884705,
-0.08446000516414642,
0.5839654207229614,
-0.5068780779838562,
0.7337583303451538,
0.5198619961738586,
0.020834682509303093,
-0.36866655945777893,
0.9388801455497742,
-0.05205542966723442,
0.17248916625976562,
0.3891551196575165,
0.3301796317100525,
-0.055070746690034866,
-0.4552288353443146,
-0.17264148592948914,
0.3332393169403076,
-0.5689257383346558,
-0.4707737863063812,
-0.7542263269424438,
-0.43806183338165283,
-0.21550393104553223,
-0.18848064541816711,
-0.36811041831970215,
0.02414943464100361,
-0.7117489576339722,
-0.350267231464386,
0.3173467218875885,
0.5340040326118469,
-0.30449023842811584,
0.17279338836669922,
-0.9536242485046387,
0.5421620607376099,
-0.023732533678412437,
0.07899586856365204,
0.11724638193845749,
-0.030758654698729515,
-0.1552848070859909,
-0.3175702393054962,
-0.18296071887016296,
-0.9385119080543518,
0.4757262170314789,
0.20266057550907135,
0.5950121879577637,
0.499372661113739,
0.34982192516326904,
0.3199097812175751,
-0.30235910415649414,
0.5773168802261353,
0.679118812084198,
-0.6741299629211426,
0.7507126331329346,
-0.6658061146736145,
-0.08005796372890472,
0.38987651467323303,
0.43078935146331787,
-0.22218899428844452,
-0.4232443869113922,
-0.9359189867973328,
-1.1219332218170166,
0.5542362332344055,
0.1747337132692337,
-0.4194898307323456,
-0.03275308385491371,
0.4224943518638611,
-0.004359016194939613,
-0.17733609676361084,
-0.7181830406188965,
-0.5337511301040649,
0.3268563747406006,
0.15980806946754456,
-0.04956778883934021,
-0.27407434582710266,
-0.03586721047759056,
-0.036614127457141876,
0.7897495031356812,
0.06257515400648117,
-0.036286793649196625,
0.2522853910923004,
-0.3147739768028259,
-0.18020287156105042,
0.34632056951522827,
0.45596152544021606,
0.8250053524971008,
-0.43973520398139954,
0.14074274897575378,
0.07008260488510132,
-0.23456509411334991,
-0.11363283544778824,
0.2760560214519501,
-0.1404905617237091,
-0.052322182804346085,
0.763826847076416,
0.4650263786315918,
0.7265135049819946,
-0.4226192533969879,
0.4820187985897064,
0.09426616877317429,
0.010840724222362041,
-0.5274714827537537,
0.017353849485516548,
0.026522234082221985,
0.16012559831142426,
0.5632275342941284,
-0.12432798743247986,
0.6030862331390381,
-0.5701395869255066,
0.7227524518966675,
0.2684354782104492,
-0.46042802929878235,
-0.10519445687532425,
0.604108989238739,
0.2847362756729126,
0.15717698633670807,
0.4127359688282013,
0.1118025854229927,
-0.2316945642232895,
0.8950512409210205,
0.4929100275039673,
0.9894688725471497,
0.01163035910576582,
0.5079928040504456,
0.43065908551216125,
0.31136977672576904,
0.2154303789138794,
0.17238108813762665,
0.33852043747901917,
-0.7702699303627014,
-0.7801805138587952,
-0.6133192181587219,
-0.24024641513824463,
0.461431086063385,
-1.003061294555664,
0.2858581840991974,
-0.4750363826751709,
0.16854578256607056,
0.40070921182632446,
-0.08118229359388351,
-0.40078088641166687,
0.2148674726486206,
0.24435830116271973,
0.42426860332489014,
-1.463324785232544,
0.7285950779914856,
0.17244413495063782,
-0.7355412244796753,
-1.1251344680786133,
-0.325381338596344,
0.017279839143157005,
-0.22015735507011414,
0.7186266183853149,
-0.16633780300617218,
0.14373920857906342,
-0.1781689077615738,
0.050865888595581055,
-0.5567620396614075,
0.9323656558990479,
0.4140429198741913,
-0.5759698748588562,
0.2760159373283386,
0.25803080201148987,
0.38067156076431274,
-0.16638705134391785,
0.011345336213707924,
0.5997744202613831,
0.521600604057312,
-0.11885244399309158,
-0.7535247802734375,
0.3249726891517639,
0.07502321898937225,
-0.3593100607395172,
0.5362871289253235,
-0.2995056211948395,
0.38436463475227356,
0.10892775654792786,
-0.20897015929222107,
-0.3702939748764038,
0.9979050755500793,
0.19310736656188965,
0.8392734527587891,
0.366008460521698,
0.43464934825897217,
0.48804351687431335,
0.22595970332622528,
1.2450052499771118,
0.2527303993701935,
0.46534571051597595,
1.3758440017700195,
-0.3859937787055969,
0.7151668071746826,
0.6128540635108948,
0.05632910877466202,
0.7149906158447266,
0.2859395444393158,
0.053584929555654526,
0.5594609379768372,
-0.20688796043395996,
-0.2964220345020294,
-0.3520311713218689,
-0.06875215470790863,
-0.4736059606075287,
0.3151206076145172,
0.19285458326339722,
-0.6347759366035461,
-0.7172818779945374,
-0.04369392618536949,
0.013270366005599499,
-0.028572915121912956,
-0.11664335429668427,
0.9142928719520569,
0.3969214856624603,
-0.3887248635292053,
0.07643797993659973,
-0.07456236332654953,
0.27646002173423767,
-0.5662760734558105,
-0.22130343317985535,
0.12564155459403992,
0.27978286147117615,
-0.6037652492523193,
-0.4520265460014343,
0.5597802996635437,
-0.2797413170337677,
-0.5145382285118103,
0.05128758028149605,
0.9754195809364319,
-0.18763256072998047,
-0.36429762840270996,
0.5920759439468384,
0.3009781837463379,
-0.0817534476518631,
0.05923651158809662,
-0.3773386478424072,
0.04215056821703911,
-0.14770016074180603,
0.009698229841887951,
0.5865435600280762,
0.23032018542289734,
0.1285165399312973,
0.09195736050605774,
0.8856081962585449,
0.24865899980068207,
-0.01471901498734951,
0.07477554678916931,
0.9817567467689514,
-0.4964239299297333,
-0.3951698839664459,
-0.8324569463729858,
0.7033271789550781,
-0.6575309038162231,
-0.5799500942230225,
0.7688597440719604,
0.7942672967910767,
0.3626422882080078,
-0.18124733865261078,
0.7951701283454895,
-0.045025784522295,
0.11961773037910461,
-0.7872864007949829,
0.7313504815101624,
-0.05371902883052826,
0.4413682818412781,
-0.4174940288066864,
-0.6705045700073242,
-0.470674604177475,
0.1059984564781189,
-0.5427638292312622,
-0.45845553278923035,
0.7773680686950684,
0.43539124727249146,
-0.2281397134065628,
0.24189883470535278,
0.17043635249137878,
0.2332153469324112,
0.4573668837547302,
0.4608088433742523,
0.7432821393013,
-0.5440782308578491,
0.3102670907974243,
-0.3017437160015106,
-0.39928027987480164,
-0.17398881912231445,
-1.2335408926010132,
-0.562346339225769,
-0.5634557604789734,
-0.7375521659851074,
-0.3560875356197357,
-0.3583604395389557,
0.42287054657936096,
0.2642919719219208,
-0.9227607250213623,
-0.1386558562517166,
-0.2905975878238678,
0.31775331497192383,
-0.17905643582344055,
-0.33575108647346497,
0.6453568339347839,
-0.34432512521743774,
0.08625497668981552,
0.7482355833053589,
0.36403897404670715,
-0.43738704919815063,
0.06010190024971962,
-0.06501160562038422,
-0.5853167176246643,
-0.29067859053611755,
0.36946460604667664,
0.6456794738769531,
-0.34742194414138794,
-0.2740570604801178,
-0.5821822285652161,
0.15144355595111847,
-0.2092050164937973,
1.1478521823883057,
-0.5969642400741577,
0.15296554565429688,
0.4077056348323822,
0.6128305792808533,
0.7134357690811157,
-0.5413087606430054,
0.9314514994621277,
-0.789783239364624,
0.26346737146377563,
0.305171400308609,
0.4691013991832733,
0.09995272755622864,
-0.9352908134460449,
0.336319237947464,
0.45653897523880005,
-0.4362705945968628,
-0.7705391049385071,
0.14384745061397552,
-1.2632687091827393,
-0.2793520987033844,
1.2760734558105469,
-0.09762987494468689,
0.012689094059169292,
-0.43835508823394775,
0.1658383309841156,
0.5092348456382751,
-0.028194017708301544,
0.556611180305481,
0.20705124735832214,
-0.48821914196014404,
0.06499937921762466,
-0.43496575951576233,
0.4270476996898651,
0.05801613628864288,
-1.0784727334976196,
-0.08104028552770615,
0.7095510363578796,
0.4151749014854431,
0.14032228291034698,
0.32239413261413574,
-0.23653671145439148,
0.38070493936538696,
-0.03798345848917961,
0.03808942064642906,
-0.16686104238033295,
-0.2738560736179352,
-0.4214075803756714,
0.5354232788085938,
-0.4340340197086334,
-0.07703819125890732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08684v1
|
Is English the New Programming Language? How About Pseudo-code Engineering?
| 2024-04-08T16:28:52 | 2024-04-08T16:28:52 |
Gian Alexandre Michaelsen, Renato P. dos Santos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.CY, J.4; K.3; I.2
|
Background: The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into daily life,
particularly through chatbots utilizing natural language processing (NLP),
presents both revolutionary potential and unique challenges. This intended to
investigate how different input forms impact ChatGPT, a leading language model
by OpenAI, performance in understanding and executing complex, multi-intention
tasks. Design: Employing a case study methodology supplemented by discourse
analysis, the research analyzes ChatGPT's responses to inputs varying from
natural language to pseudo-code engineering. The study specifically examines
the model's proficiency across four categories: understanding of intentions,
interpretability, completeness, and creativity. Setting and Participants: As a
theoretical exploration of AI interaction, this study focuses on the analysis
of structured and unstructured inputs processed by ChatGPT, without direct
human participants. Data collection and analysis: The research utilizes
synthetic case scenarios, including the organization of a "weekly meal plan"
and a "shopping list," to assess ChatGPT's response to prompts in both natural
language and pseudo-code engineering. The analysis is grounded in the
identification of patterns, contradictions, and unique response elements across
different input formats. Results: Findings reveal that pseudo-code engineering
inputs significantly enhance the clarity and determinism of ChatGPT's
responses, reducing ambiguity inherent in natural language. Enhanced natural
language, structured through prompt engineering techniques, similarly improves
the model's interpretability and creativity. Conclusions: The study underscores
the potential of pseudo-code engineering in refining human-AI interaction and
achieving more deterministic, concise, and direct outcomes, advocating for its
broader application across disciplines requiring precise AI responses.
|
[
-0.2648613750934601,
-1.04929780960083,
0.46349960565567017,
0.19693386554718018,
0.12944620847702026,
0.28661975264549255,
-0.14693854749202728,
-0.8301770091056824,
-0.03938319906592369,
-0.06975872069597244,
-0.3811836242675781,
-0.035114482045173645,
-0.3359818160533905,
0.15918272733688354,
-0.24955417215824127,
0.933751106262207,
-0.29638299345970154,
0.07214940339326859,
-0.1507965326309204,
0.36367934942245483,
-0.6986149549484253,
-0.7852852940559387,
-0.6045254468917847,
-0.1280195564031601,
0.015615511685609818,
0.31646421551704407,
0.9048790335655212,
0.06853944063186646,
0.5605905055999756,
0.3784005045890808,
0.2743546664714813,
0.039379339665174484,
-0.29310864210128784,
-0.30444684624671936,
0.005791753064841032,
-0.5923967361450195,
-0.21127016842365265,
0.24215516448020935,
0.27635982632637024,
0.47814708948135376,
0.03412925451993942,
0.15147779881954193,
0.34155014157295227,
0.370861679315567,
-0.27157339453697205,
0.7463453412055969,
-0.3276222348213196,
0.0733303353190422,
-0.005524913780391216,
-0.1535339504480362,
-0.4505859911441803,
-0.3243224322795868,
0.07994341105222702,
-0.6320299506187439,
-0.2395147681236267,
0.17702236771583557,
1.0717706680297852,
0.41156715154647827,
0.11071697622537613,
-0.736198365688324,
-1.0635199546813965,
0.6293116807937622,
-0.822216272354126,
0.38797593116760254,
0.440420538187027,
0.22333014011383057,
-0.20276199281215668,
-0.7554850578308105,
-0.8585940003395081,
-0.49633559584617615,
-0.32325902581214905,
0.21099089086055756,
-0.2582792639732361,
0.2846081554889679,
0.23139214515686035,
0.2998064458370209,
-0.9326376914978027,
-0.009780566208064556,
-0.4786990284919739,
-0.18334069848060608,
0.5500183701515198,
-0.13720165193080902,
0.9165263175964355,
-0.2086227834224701,
0.07310017198324203,
0.1392500102519989,
-0.30703285336494446,
0.4248429536819458,
0.33494916558265686,
0.15734121203422546,
-0.3470001220703125,
0.788540780544281,
-0.1153276339173317,
0.6573230624198914,
-0.33189746737480164,
0.20155972242355347,
0.10947810858488083,
-0.5346115231513977,
-0.26779577136039734,
-0.01899651437997818,
0.9230127334594727,
0.16196057200431824,
0.6105189919471741,
-0.05388825014233589,
-0.10974270105361938,
0.3291010558605194,
0.3689135015010834,
-0.47470495104789734,
-0.4732917547225952,
0.16505469381809235,
-0.5854368209838867,
-0.2599608302116394,
0.11741717159748077,
-0.47260749340057373,
-0.06960416585206985,
-0.4787972569465637,
0.4008271098136902,
-0.45410066843032837,
-0.07738650590181351,
0.2282758504152298,
-0.016354430466890335,
0.5887725949287415,
0.08707590401172638,
-0.48662859201431274,
0.2596757709980011,
0.6352303624153137,
0.9371030926704407,
0.06992305815219879,
-0.24982476234436035,
-0.08298029750585556,
-0.30118513107299805,
-0.22166594862937927,
0.8409284353256226,
-0.7805439233779907,
-0.5905609726905823,
-0.21295265853405,
-0.4162340462207794,
-0.3440873324871063,
-0.1810266375541687,
0.41869908571243286,
-0.497631311416626,
0.6463608145713806,
0.2540038228034973,
-0.3442308008670807,
-0.06673486530780792,
0.2979338765144348,
-0.47793859243392944,
0.8930082321166992,
0.11607406288385391,
-0.5820477604866028,
0.06659059971570969,
-1.2064799070358276,
-0.574186384677887,
0.3691015839576721,
-0.5626230835914612,
-0.17799867689609528,
0.02695079892873764,
-0.030601177364587784,
0.06914541125297546,
-0.14272239804267883,
0.3881130814552307,
0.057856909930706024,
-0.5604282021522522,
0.28942668437957764,
-0.7367377281188965,
0.5010361075401306,
0.3217945396900177,
-0.32662495970726013,
0.1072283536195755,
-0.7635753154754639,
0.2973730266094208,
0.1967642456293106,
-0.30195945501327515,
0.07698531448841095,
0.2083270102739334,
0.11495453119277954,
0.4298973083496094,
0.3783065676689148,
-0.484443724155426,
0.3866560161113739,
-0.7339361906051636,
0.6528306603431702,
0.5560963153839111,
-0.061715468764305115,
0.46188104152679443,
-0.39073920249938965,
0.7763780951499939,
-0.498958945274353,
0.29462188482284546,
-0.15129756927490234,
-0.9075749516487122,
-0.3485552668571472,
-0.10600335150957108,
0.22290635108947754,
1.0022937059402466,
-0.9010489583015442,
0.10031445324420929,
0.000046342356654349715,
-0.2902052104473114,
-0.4238716959953308,
-0.23110784590244293,
0.33900102972984314,
0.4832930564880371,
0.33904147148132324,
-0.1815316528081894,
-0.7653259038925171,
-0.856105625629425,
-0.2898677885532379,
-0.6062635183334351,
-0.35829460620880127,
0.42267605662345886,
0.24410560727119446,
-0.2728663682937622,
1.2657604217529297,
-0.5381726026535034,
-0.009252157993614674,
-0.6789586544036865,
0.5203738808631897,
0.3386073410511017,
0.34095078706741333,
0.5189790725708008,
-0.7543808817863464,
-0.5929786562919617,
0.11361154168844223,
-0.7079402804374695,
-0.07406332343816757,
-0.2834305763244629,
-0.03511067479848862,
0.007579328026622534,
0.38873252272605896,
-0.7733017802238464,
0.8536717295646667,
0.5244928002357483,
-0.0272050853818655,
0.7139880061149597,
-0.2039332389831543,
0.4340796172618866,
-0.8567497134208679,
0.05828440189361572,
-0.21575194597244263,
0.18152780830860138,
-0.6873687505722046,
0.11827787756919861,
0.06075584143400192,
-0.5380880832672119,
-0.7442752122879028,
0.4895516335964203,
-0.2807508111000061,
0.13137543201446533,
-0.39084121584892273,
-0.21717959642410278,
-0.19993014633655548,
0.6595660448074341,
0.23771345615386963,
1.2809518575668335,
0.33718186616897583,
-0.5052386522293091,
0.05982355773448944,
0.18065054714679718,
-0.22495202720165253,
0.1941864788532257,
-0.9883609414100647,
0.3346531391143799,
-0.09597010910511017,
0.004135220777243376,
-1.241734266281128,
-0.1343754082918167,
0.31159237027168274,
-0.7305184006690979,
0.10628531128168106,
-0.059139180928468704,
-0.521571159362793,
-0.4147516191005707,
-0.18242928385734558,
0.3548721969127655,
0.7356956601142883,
0.048310860991477966,
0.6180408596992493,
0.10914907604455948,
-0.24469594657421112,
-0.03173644840717316,
-0.6014423966407776,
0.27695006132125854,
0.1795671135187149,
-0.7185644507408142,
0.2375369817018509,
-0.2920176684856415,
-0.3569922149181366,
-0.21014855802059174,
-0.04367832839488983,
-0.3580167293548584,
0.1274605691432953,
0.15155166387557983,
0.502642035484314,
-0.3135359585285187,
-0.25490108132362366,
-0.2519771158695221,
-0.057877570390701294,
0.1383652687072754,
-0.1691078543663025,
0.7864665389060974,
-0.2162638157606125,
-0.41076192259788513,
-0.7118409872055054,
0.28850921988487244,
0.346089631319046,
-0.4117729365825653,
0.7443093657493591,
0.20512986183166504,
-0.21357156336307526,
-0.01556391641497612,
-0.018026137724518776,
-0.10617831349372864,
-0.5408209562301636,
0.3829290270805359,
-0.5422579050064087,
-0.6932858228683472,
0.2918466627597809,
0.08022720366716385,
0.29807841777801514,
0.1890397071838379,
0.4119459390640259,
-0.5110252499580383,
0.9867041707038879,
0.7709141373634338,
-0.3300097584724426,
0.5989857316017151,
-0.07750183343887329,
0.9819729328155518,
-0.2684295177459717,
0.028008345514535904,
-0.6945860981941223,
-0.27703797817230225,
-0.6241734027862549,
-0.3485151529312134,
0.24900032579898834,
-0.18133670091629028,
0.15757131576538086,
0.5112605690956116,
-0.48326849937438965,
0.5138369798660278,
0.43180418014526367,
-0.1714254766702652,
0.11389321088790894,
-0.48206621408462524,
0.06247639283537865,
0.0973893404006958,
-0.8018739223480225,
-0.7410387396812439,
0.9055953621864319,
0.32500943541526794,
0.7189478278160095,
0.1121366024017334,
0.545377790927887,
0.4606216847896576,
0.22669051587581635,
-0.7618080377578735,
0.4284319281578064,
0.16619090735912323,
-0.3182402551174164,
-0.23957736790180206,
-0.33963432908058167,
-0.9770399928092957,
-0.1326744705438614,
0.03630226477980614,
-0.836914598941803,
-0.14602550864219666,
0.1571882963180542,
-0.4001910984516144,
-0.037786420434713364,
-1.3658010959625244,
0.8391388058662415,
-0.44833317399024963,
-0.12212488800287247,
0.10535474121570587,
-0.5917232632637024,
0.23941592872142792,
0.00006772708729840815,
0.6094890832901001,
0.4095562696456909,
0.33714911341667175,
0.5659981966018677,
-0.26490283012390137,
0.8594058752059937,
0.11871428787708282,
-0.03376792371273041,
0.46671542525291443,
0.17589934170246124,
0.5745074152946472,
0.06381785124540329,
-0.019882114604115486,
0.36540287733078003,
0.08603973686695099,
-0.3649546205997467,
-0.7457022070884705,
0.3929022252559662,
-0.8866984248161316,
-0.448560506105423,
-0.3991495966911316,
-0.4710773229598999,
-0.3749313950538635,
0.18064142763614655,
0.20805540680885315,
0.2534297704696655,
-0.2595776319503784,
-0.23538082838058472,
0.4682556688785553,
-0.5427563786506653,
0.5885366201400757,
0.42402124404907227,
-0.07493744790554047,
0.2276124805212021,
0.9910386204719543,
0.1259004920721054,
0.20449033379554749,
0.5176270604133606,
0.11788467317819595,
-0.11492322385311127,
-0.4467029869556427,
-0.5351789593696594,
0.04500162973999977,
-0.4089556038379669,
0.17204801738262177,
-0.6857215762138367,
-0.5438590049743652,
-0.5854323506355286,
-0.34622278809547424,
-0.39655449986457825,
-0.22814340889453888,
-0.15859583020210266,
0.053563859313726425,
-0.10581617802381516,
0.8543574810028076,
0.37408581376075745,
0.29714709520339966,
-0.7467238306999207,
0.4868522882461548,
0.04490622878074646,
0.3207760751247406,
-0.20050476491451263,
-0.3011784851551056,
-0.06899229437112808,
0.20525115728378296,
-0.13790957629680634,
-1.0310993194580078,
0.1539417803287506,
0.10690607875585556,
0.7029554843902588,
0.018457479774951935,
-0.090761698782444,
0.5758190751075745,
-0.6345826387405396,
1.128477931022644,
-0.12655366957187653,
-0.8229041695594788,
0.5443626046180725,
-0.12178130447864532,
0.566565215587616,
0.4388998746871948,
0.335107684135437,
-0.670589029788971,
-0.47295287251472473,
-0.5300225019454956,
-0.7530797719955444,
0.6925740838050842,
0.6390290856361389,
0.20376154780387878,
0.00991783756762743,
0.1542288213968277,
-0.2009662240743637,
0.26440921425819397,
-0.8713514804840088,
-0.23757252097129822,
-0.2261008620262146,
-0.4446742534637451,
0.25144723057746887,
-0.09442714601755142,
0.48073533177375793,
-0.019519757479429245,
0.5204973816871643,
0.07407993078231812,
0.5746383666992188,
-0.0531497485935688,
-0.36507648229599,
0.4602728486061096,
0.3853386342525482,
0.767764687538147,
0.6310638785362244,
0.08727993071079254,
-0.12431326508522034,
-0.20887994766235352,
-0.6380672454833984,
-0.11055834591388702,
0.16204632818698883,
-0.2874976694583893,
-0.14140640199184418,
0.5195555686950684,
0.3786434829235077,
0.2049776017665863,
-0.8023959994316101,
0.3045184910297394,
-0.39162275195121765,
-0.04918810725212097,
-0.15603511035442352,
0.15627038478851318,
-0.3043106496334076,
-0.20040936768054962,
0.09858627617359161,
0.24287807941436768,
0.33456796407699585,
-0.6434304714202881,
0.2883022129535675,
0.3703621029853821,
-0.37981387972831726,
-0.4509902894496918,
0.6028279066085815,
0.2273734211921692,
-0.7854330539703369,
0.6534312963485718,
-0.5102702975273132,
-0.5703275203704834,
0.6204468607902527,
0.4362570643424988,
0.8028052449226379,
-0.10338762402534485,
0.2841171324253082,
0.1667860448360443,
0.6368880271911621,
0.28644683957099915,
0.42565008997917175,
-0.16138185560703278,
-0.6819642186164856,
-0.7338274121284485,
-0.4630725681781769,
-0.29598966240882874,
0.07221617549657822,
-0.06347808986902237,
0.3538852632045746,
-0.47065186500549316,
0.19239754974842072,
-0.26981261372566223,
-0.2763743996620178,
-0.7732793688774109,
0.10290008783340454,
0.22643539309501648,
0.5179226398468018,
-0.7186483144760132,
0.7150083780288696,
1.0197417736053467,
-0.7325199246406555,
-1.2742640972137451,
0.2071172446012497,
0.07756545394659042,
-0.8802983164787292,
0.4962957501411438,
0.08745123445987701,
-0.1007954552769661,
-0.07721138745546341,
-0.4818139374256134,
-0.81085205078125,
0.36590853333473206,
0.027784131467342377,
-0.396101176738739,
-0.34595078229904175,
0.5125569701194763,
0.6710465550422668,
0.14088673889636993,
0.8047167062759399,
0.5592854619026184,
0.4403536915779114,
-0.11223825812339783,
-1.4702829122543335,
-0.4648679196834564,
-0.644095778465271,
-0.1271595060825348,
0.30165034532546997,
-0.3898797929286957,
0.47825366258621216,
0.10087266564369202,
-0.325658917427063,
-0.03778490051627159,
0.46957793831825256,
0.06089873984456062,
0.36399906873703003,
0.10403618216514587,
0.037507303059101105,
0.49947014451026917,
0.06971783190965652,
1.1396843194961548,
-0.5503275394439697,
0.08572787791490555,
1.0814611911773682,
-0.2659108340740204,
0.5183054208755493,
0.3915432095527649,
-0.5378596782684326,
0.406749963760376,
0.3898863196372986,
0.4205199182033539,
0.28083717823028564,
0.33249431848526,
0.053640879690647125,
0.37554144859313965,
0.05491352826356888,
-0.20939818024635315,
0.5968486666679382,
0.10791456699371338,
0.005447722505778074,
-0.09845160692930222,
0.36550867557525635,
0.04715346172451973,
0.13893719017505646,
-0.09017176181077957,
0.8283053636550903,
-0.11897026002407074,
-0.6180244088172913,
0.1850678026676178,
0.2321825474500656,
0.8101494312286377,
-0.6187406182289124,
-0.3248746693134308,
-0.16143202781677246,
-0.13318601250648499,
-0.2108217477798462,
-0.7873053550720215,
0.5396334528923035,
0.12920919060707092,
-0.029523411765694618,
-0.39190059900283813,
0.6147132515907288,
-0.00013667260645888746,
-0.5186662077903748,
-0.26785027980804443,
0.4285087287425995,
0.26156291365623474,
-0.14083455502986908,
-0.7661558389663696,
0.12461613863706589,
0.14523331820964813,
-0.20054876804351807,
0.1343662142753601,
0.321853369474411,
-0.25661149621009827,
0.535500168800354,
0.7433777451515198,
0.03985578566789627,
0.09786420315504074,
-0.01224713958799839,
0.7281373143196106,
-0.47643718123435974,
-0.7359700202941895,
-0.8206420540809631,
0.5053803324699402,
0.20016607642173767,
-0.2789689600467682,
0.674180269241333,
0.6569322943687439,
0.9332640171051025,
-0.07001736760139465,
0.9432570338249207,
-0.4313758313655853,
0.12779603898525238,
-0.5094661712646484,
0.5883582830429077,
-0.08345520496368408,
0.40743300318717957,
-0.4027804136276245,
-0.8020799160003662,
-0.06658774614334106,
0.7160447239875793,
-0.6665148138999939,
0.13932664692401886,
0.6589678525924683,
0.632327139377594,
-0.010613420978188515,
0.3133446276187897,
0.37419241666793823,
0.06762707978487015,
0.7318498492240906,
0.5864670276641846,
0.9194185733795166,
-0.32272037863731384,
0.4481242597103119,
-0.08956333994865417,
-0.4407418668270111,
0.19626818597316742,
-0.4821998178958893,
-0.6644378900527954,
-0.42892590165138245,
-0.2082570493221283,
0.1065073236823082,
0.006655441597104073,
0.9673031568527222,
0.5241487622261047,
-0.7425119280815125,
-0.2800959050655365,
-0.2506559193134308,
-0.1498396098613739,
-0.15144853293895721,
-0.33762234449386597,
0.13006259500980377,
-0.5315912961959839,
-0.723714292049408,
0.45363661646842957,
0.399863600730896,
-0.06440339237451553,
-0.12008209526538849,
-0.11826972663402557,
-0.19880281388759613,
0.30113404989242554,
0.7197720408439636,
0.3872707784175873,
-0.48483994603157043,
-0.19275443255901337,
0.44066059589385986,
0.031335003674030304,
0.18131615221500397,
0.9881695508956909,
-0.8167329430580139,
0.39317405223846436,
0.4169715344905853,
0.7315696477890015,
0.13609212636947632,
0.15913140773773193,
0.6902149319648743,
-0.6078085899353027,
0.22867469489574432,
0.37521976232528687,
0.1308836191892624,
-0.08508659899234772,
-0.6901305913925171,
0.3206060826778412,
0.08371774107217789,
-0.5713648200035095,
-0.6121516823768616,
0.2739693224430084,
-0.5530195236206055,
-0.456320196390152,
0.942733645439148,
0.09676514565944672,
-0.15574471652507782,
-0.5480194687843323,
-0.7595812082290649,
0.0946013480424881,
-0.36885568499565125,
0.6607452630996704,
0.9738458395004272,
-0.6888450384140015,
-0.33381232619285583,
-0.9013422727584839,
0.467318058013916,
0.5432521104812622,
-1.0004992485046387,
-0.3901853859424591,
0.45562052726745605,
-0.14908312261104584,
0.14406542479991913,
0.7420504093170166,
-0.029510751366615295,
0.3223196566104889,
-0.18437713384628296,
0.1807258278131485,
-0.03513989970088005,
-0.16820497810840607,
0.007233709562569857,
0.1579226553440094,
0.28570830821990967,
-0.26825883984565735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08683v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08683v1
|
Text clustering applied to data augmentation in legal contexts
| 2024-04-08T16:18:33 | 2024-04-08T16:18:33 |
Lucas José Gonçalves Freitas, Thaís Rodrigues, Guilherme Rodrigues, Pamella Edokawa, Ariane Farias
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Data analysis and machine learning are of preeminent importance in the legal
domain, especially in tasks like clustering and text classification. In this
study, we harnessed the power of natural language processing tools to enhance
datasets meticulously curated by experts. This process significantly improved
the classification workflow for legal texts using machine learning techniques.
We considered the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) data from the United
Nations 2030 Agenda as a practical case study. Data augmentation
clustering-based strategy led to remarkable enhancements in the accuracy and
sensitivity metrics of classification models. For certain SDGs within the 2030
Agenda, we observed performance gains of over 15%. In some cases, the example
base expanded by a noteworthy factor of 5. When dealing with unclassified legal
texts, data augmentation strategies centered around clustering prove to be
highly effective. They provide a valuable means to expand the existing
knowledge base without the need for labor-intensive manual classification
efforts.
|
[
-0.32179757952690125,
-0.5521727800369263,
0.38778841495513916,
-0.20032761991024017,
-0.5412545204162598,
0.34703880548477173,
-0.2941046953201294,
-0.5744038820266724,
-0.08718417584896088,
0.7469277381896973,
-0.3542743921279907,
-0.8947728276252747,
-0.727632999420166,
0.27180251479148865,
-0.5286458730697632,
1.1579463481903076,
0.1730155050754547,
0.08981688320636749,
-0.4622640907764435,
-0.39693981409072876,
-0.6957097053527832,
-0.38396650552749634,
-0.2274823933839798,
-0.3009181022644043,
0.14684225618839264,
0.3423894941806793,
0.603212833404541,
0.9620586633682251,
0.606665849685669,
0.35466790199279785,
-0.25337857007980347,
0.2606736421585083,
-0.3953438401222229,
-0.00976579636335373,
-0.2638145387172699,
-0.4332108795642853,
-0.1576588898897171,
0.06378300487995148,
0.47209611535072327,
0.6798068881034851,
-0.1509285867214203,
0.1131533533334732,
-0.00920584425330162,
0.927497923374176,
-0.3946821093559265,
0.20666906237602234,
-0.6407137513160706,
0.267450213432312,
-0.13038715720176697,
-0.28413715958595276,
-0.14512889087200165,
-0.35658201575279236,
0.09241191297769547,
-0.5301434397697449,
0.39249318838119507,
0.030396869406104088,
0.47019022703170776,
0.6591306924819946,
-0.4061119854450226,
-0.5088956356048584,
-0.5108478665351868,
0.8604722023010254,
-0.6495195031166077,
0.16984957456588745,
0.12953190505504608,
0.07058097422122955,
-0.3455064594745636,
-0.7565211653709412,
-0.5734841227531433,
0.07233722507953644,
-0.22502566874027252,
0.1031602993607521,
-0.17898161709308624,
0.35573843121528625,
0.39344504475593567,
0.33080267906188965,
-0.4946979880332947,
0.39237797260284424,
-0.5762297511100769,
-0.1466902643442154,
0.917847752571106,
0.009057258255779743,
0.25933754444122314,
-0.2668903172016144,
-0.10222562402486801,
0.015032068826258183,
-0.38925811648368835,
0.07053259015083313,
0.4406995475292206,
0.5273861885070801,
0.12047246843576431,
0.6658558249473572,
-0.2271534651517868,
0.8457444310188293,
-0.015241030603647232,
-0.16497665643692017,
0.3086097538471222,
-0.6625399589538574,
-0.04528160020709038,
0.4515354335308075,
0.40652909874916077,
0.5900273323059082,
0.03425741568207741,
-0.2002280205488205,
-0.08144886791706085,
0.14676371216773987,
0.5929190516471863,
-0.6609475016593933,
-0.045674193650484085,
0.19790606200695038,
-0.7284510731697083,
-0.3883974254131317,
0.543290913105011,
-0.8560377955436707,
-0.6635012626647949,
-0.9199146032333374,
-0.07328634709119797,
-0.13263998925685883,
0.2729376256465912,
0.1779593527317047,
-0.34680798649787903,
0.12021919339895248,
0.17819301784038544,
-0.7368337512016296,
0.1298738270998001,
0.9490808248519897,
0.6700953245162964,
-0.23752176761627197,
0.371432900428772,
-0.5029778480529785,
0.24544154107570648,
-0.3248537480831146,
0.7860599160194397,
-0.9374741315841675,
-0.4516099989414215,
0.04774634167551994,
-0.033032435923814774,
0.16329823434352875,
-0.6113135814666748,
1.1943168640136719,
-0.3564043939113617,
0.19514551758766174,
-0.2532457709312439,
-0.772961437702179,
-0.36425334215164185,
0.11834187805652618,
-0.5973886847496033,
1.075875163078308,
-0.03311009705066681,
-0.6571844816207886,
1.1757405996322632,
-1.072940468788147,
-0.6684004664421082,
0.5471096634864807,
-0.35165923833847046,
-0.7057380080223083,
0.18455840647220612,
0.39461255073547363,
0.6867491602897644,
-0.13576269149780273,
0.516197681427002,
-0.0523136742413044,
-0.4185720980167389,
-0.10301047563552856,
-0.05247500166296959,
0.6495048999786377,
0.2336341142654419,
-0.21834564208984375,
0.28486454486846924,
-0.821494996547699,
0.09163769334554672,
-0.2758811116218567,
-0.5135309100151062,
-0.4967285990715027,
0.10000970959663391,
-0.03160097822546959,
0.07003036886453629,
0.2521995007991791,
-0.6355976462364197,
0.15821050107479095,
-0.3768223226070404,
0.4637533724308014,
0.6313258409500122,
0.15525585412979126,
0.4771416187286377,
-0.3245275616645813,
0.2883794605731964,
-0.04718079790472984,
-0.06776802986860275,
-0.12477687001228333,
-0.704432487487793,
-0.47309187054634094,
-0.17652468383312225,
0.5106022953987122,
0.5990961790084839,
-0.5333123803138733,
1.0763517618179321,
-0.649451494216919,
-0.5853431820869446,
-0.6951586008071899,
0.1218930333852768,
-0.10854178667068481,
0.4258454740047455,
0.4762282073497772,
-0.1769346445798874,
-0.7797512412071228,
-0.6095809936523438,
-0.6315136551856995,
-0.10789325833320618,
-0.022207962349057198,
0.23999378085136414,
0.5703354477882385,
-0.6198366284370422,
1.23871910572052,
-0.25652357935905457,
-0.396400511264801,
-0.09713859111070633,
0.26198896765708923,
0.3633347749710083,
0.5527614951133728,
0.5055660605430603,
-1.4613882303237915,
-0.4596446454524994,
0.43390631675720215,
-0.6283746361732483,
-0.15921662747859955,
-0.19076721370220184,
0.24786005914211273,
0.0819491520524025,
0.44215187430381775,
-0.17656517028808594,
0.690561056137085,
-0.0387088768184185,
-0.498505562543869,
0.4533446431159973,
-0.48064887523651123,
0.405953973531723,
-0.8704127073287964,
-0.05591628700494766,
0.18241743743419647,
-0.4005143940448761,
-0.8386011123657227,
0.06943395733833313,
0.047719936817884445,
0.012369801290333271,
-0.12373854219913483,
0.1279216855764389,
-0.23751521110534668,
-0.13638950884342194,
-0.5196034908294678,
0.055875010788440704,
-0.20498712360858917,
-0.04815486818552017,
-0.21548154950141907,
0.7962150573730469,
0.5892513394355774,
-0.8116090893745422,
0.5269021987915039,
0.4220051169395447,
-0.38786178827285767,
0.889256477355957,
-0.3944254219532013,
0.08733849972486496,
-0.5043582320213318,
0.06030341982841492,
-0.5538459420204163,
-0.025745723396539688,
-0.04658828675746918,
-0.3574245274066925,
0.05205574259161949,
-0.2223009318113327,
-0.7519821524620056,
-0.659902811050415,
-0.30169862508773804,
-0.16106846928596497,
0.5260993838310242,
-0.6862320899963379,
0.5389934778213501,
0.69718337059021,
-0.15439242124557495,
-0.37175145745277405,
-0.8015456199645996,
0.3642624616622925,
-0.8114694356918335,
-0.2879883348941803,
0.6024279594421387,
0.024579167366027832,
-0.23824098706245422,
0.20498917996883392,
-0.10507012158632278,
-0.010357584804296494,
-0.0657668486237526,
0.4464224576950073,
0.023404238745570183,
0.3431834876537323,
0.18622994422912598,
0.2678062319755554,
-0.20432749390602112,
0.09992268681526184,
-0.5402242541313171,
0.2267155796289444,
0.1322820633649826,
-0.12173296511173248,
-0.4170227348804474,
0.2781493067741394,
0.3798017203807831,
-0.08663664758205414,
0.7064688801765442,
0.6246919631958008,
-0.4486292600631714,
-0.018983561545610428,
-0.45967140793800354,
0.011915693990886211,
-0.5022549033164978,
0.09907679259777069,
-0.03558725491166115,
-1.2859606742858887,
0.4002104699611664,
-0.3745977580547333,
0.35235595703125,
0.5331534147262573,
0.39544811844825745,
-0.09223006665706635,
0.9183641672134399,
0.7827925682067871,
-0.4394533336162567,
0.6083984375,
-0.04016447812318802,
0.3935859501361847,
-0.5447466373443604,
-0.29820680618286133,
-0.8413904905319214,
-0.2387690395116806,
-0.9038872122764587,
-0.4877205491065979,
0.35480138659477234,
-0.03569527342915535,
0.24846360087394714,
0.4813673198223114,
-0.8169932961463928,
0.6694208383560181,
0.3477984666824341,
-0.07410112768411636,
0.35123196244239807,
0.41429489850997925,
-0.09014628827571869,
-0.22258952260017395,
-0.7185071706771851,
-0.7792222499847412,
1.12295663356781,
0.1504271775484085,
0.2615039646625519,
-0.228156179189682,
0.7609166502952576,
0.9420817494392395,
0.1494801789522171,
-0.732233464717865,
0.5308476090431213,
-0.46847718954086304,
-0.23895470798015594,
-0.28809821605682373,
-0.5828762650489807,
-1.1538132429122925,
0.24136103689670563,
-0.431491494178772,
-0.661781907081604,
0.35901883244514465,
-0.31961286067962646,
-0.23222261667251587,
0.26136326789855957,
-0.5136193633079529,
0.4588744640350342,
-0.014153307303786278,
-0.1348922997713089,
-0.5224528908729553,
-0.4326894283294678,
-0.20619545876979828,
-0.2939469814300537,
0.42629289627075195,
0.014817136339843273,
-0.09795499593019485,
1.0262874364852905,
-0.48971304297447205,
0.5568914413452148,
-0.2888878285884857,
-0.20733703672885895,
0.45035520195961,
-0.724173903465271,
0.657830536365509,
-0.027212772518396378,
-0.29921624064445496,
0.004503590986132622,
-0.1161026582121849,
-0.3661119341850281,
-0.5006886124610901,
0.5874983072280884,
-0.17002539336681366,
-0.3801082372665405,
-0.31223776936531067,
-0.5399200916290283,
-0.0011623951140791178,
0.36600303649902344,
-0.13294225931167603,
0.048876069486141205,
-0.07581987231969833,
0.40880051255226135,
0.5037732720375061,
0.022427231073379517,
0.5698193311691284,
0.4823005497455597,
0.26247289776802063,
-0.48933690786361694,
0.9304012656211853,
0.320850133895874,
-0.362762451171875,
0.22680912911891937,
0.21307384967803955,
-0.6477928161621094,
-0.9166849851608276,
-0.24957525730133057,
-0.10453125834465027,
-0.6810590028762817,
-0.3112137019634247,
-0.5670929551124573,
0.041958894580602646,
-0.5557173490524292,
-0.26071447134017944,
0.2660692632198334,
-0.33981049060821533,
-0.3346399664878845,
-0.46616604924201965,
0.5909399390220642,
0.7037256360054016,
0.05682409927248955,
0.17950472235679626,
-1.0202100276947021,
0.2771410048007965,
0.10663612931966782,
0.2484283745288849,
-0.5233357548713684,
-0.29730838537216187,
-0.23463456332683563,
0.14481504261493683,
0.011784067377448082,
-0.470768541097641,
0.362864226102829,
0.1138913482427597,
0.6115767359733582,
0.43180736899375916,
0.08995436131954193,
1.0098707675933838,
-0.4346933960914612,
0.6636614799499512,
0.08597781509160995,
-0.6977025270462036,
0.49878913164138794,
-0.49070754647254944,
0.16734826564788818,
0.8359991908073425,
0.05643791705369949,
-0.4612710475921631,
-0.22358502447605133,
-0.6752805709838867,
-0.7822136878967285,
0.5161483883857727,
0.2885473966598511,
0.21370191872119904,
0.4159330725669861,
0.8283495903015137,
0.3262317180633545,
0.5181637406349182,
-0.3900340497493744,
-0.026765089482069016,
0.28012165427207947,
-0.31061020493507385,
0.03184740990400314,
0.07292772829532623,
-0.004770566243678331,
-0.5718072652816772,
0.6337787508964539,
-0.2525365650653839,
-0.031996697187423706,
0.004836410284042358,
-0.013863012194633484,
-0.0067464192397892475,
0.40339240431785583,
0.2562454342842102,
0.7305200695991516,
0.2760257422924042,
-0.18806768953800201,
0.3196602165699005,
-0.5986025929450989,
0.1656675636768341,
0.2741215229034424,
-0.5166037082672119,
-0.04542839899659157,
0.2296362966299057,
0.7003254294395447,
-0.14245052635669708,
-0.9004015922546387,
0.051095448434352875,
-0.015851059928536415,
-0.411293089389801,
-0.021326296031475067,
0.18969209492206573,
-0.36659273505210876,
0.20581641793251038,
0.5699777007102966,
0.19851388037204742,
0.46663954854011536,
-0.3930121064186096,
0.49845752120018005,
0.34833255410194397,
-0.38968712091445923,
0.28702566027641296,
0.36610451340675354,
0.07203018665313721,
-0.10601532459259033,
0.16796176135540009,
-0.3290693163871765,
-0.5814582109451294,
0.5280005931854248,
0.4706070125102997,
0.48917126655578613,
0.08746073395013809,
0.3200054466724396,
0.37688061594963074,
0.224222794175148,
-0.21026496589183807,
0.28067097067832947,
-0.3043659031391144,
-0.45119914412498474,
-0.5522167086601257,
-0.5258427858352661,
-0.22549550235271454,
-0.21276840567588806,
-0.6317533850669861,
0.07496194541454315,
-0.25151678919792175,
-0.14329947531223297,
-0.09879031032323837,
0.45198434591293335,
-0.47317805886268616,
0.43177488446235657,
-0.21003299951553345,
0.5233007669448853,
-0.6845408082008362,
0.41873544454574585,
0.9225141406059265,
0.07056209444999695,
-0.1471448391675949,
-0.002651351736858487,
-0.08906516432762146,
-0.38568994402885437,
0.1805286705493927,
0.43786874413490295,
0.19657118618488312,
0.044162318110466,
-0.5639377236366272,
-0.41778644919395447,
0.9174822568893433,
0.06217833608388901,
-0.6975171566009521,
0.39597851037979126,
0.6672422885894775,
0.814055323600769,
-0.38651397824287415,
-0.4497932493686676,
0.9934659004211426,
0.8525181412696838,
0.10598111897706985,
-0.5007433295249939,
-0.029526686295866966,
-0.2448541522026062,
0.018488408997654915,
0.4796055555343628,
-0.10405745357275009,
0.13407482206821442,
-0.1218249499797821,
-0.333342969417572,
-0.19934527575969696,
0.7630961537361145,
0.11304949223995209,
0.44054946303367615,
0.6613281965255737,
0.9889957308769226,
1.3844047784805298,
-0.3830249309539795,
0.8753673434257507,
-0.20827336609363556,
0.2625817358493805,
0.5826466679573059,
-0.14933618903160095,
0.4086131751537323,
0.34060272574424744,
-0.3474292457103729,
0.3847094178199768,
0.5284703969955444,
-0.5178059339523315,
0.3983228802680969,
0.19962187111377716,
-0.2618391811847687,
-0.07112713903188705,
-0.5876250863075256,
-0.11087839305400848,
0.31293985247612,
0.520153820514679,
-0.23647034168243408,
-0.13772746920585632,
0.18743570148944855,
-0.13969232141971588,
0.5801106691360474,
-0.630549967288971,
1.0942178964614868,
-0.2446780651807785,
-0.44743630290031433,
-0.10881773382425308,
0.2386196106672287,
0.8109970092773438,
-0.1466897875070572,
-0.15497539937496185,
0.28154176473617554,
0.012183943763375282,
-0.5223332047462463,
-0.9367277026176453,
0.5424060225486755,
0.4494544267654419,
-0.19747702777385712,
-0.4359474778175354,
1.020336627960205,
-0.31987276673316956,
-0.6347763538360596,
0.05525822937488556,
0.021844390779733658,
0.10130057483911514,
-0.035245027393102646,
-0.908947229385376,
-0.27160778641700745,
0.026885613799095154,
0.4899251461029053,
0.1295080929994583,
0.41043755412101746,
-0.2693529427051544,
0.4788915514945984,
0.9813019633293152,
0.12892365455627441,
0.03686228021979332,
0.06468311697244644,
0.9907844066619873,
-0.564702033996582,
-0.9531753063201904,
-0.829896092414856,
0.5660059452056885,
-0.6781275272369385,
0.04306145757436752,
0.8907678723335266,
0.8164950609207153,
0.7105554342269897,
0.20165330171585083,
0.979712724685669,
-0.22940167784690857,
0.5681988596916199,
-0.6290915608406067,
0.6058565378189087,
-0.15767675638198853,
0.15599071979522705,
-0.2519521415233612,
-0.9447022676467896,
-0.49625763297080994,
0.4956113398075104,
-0.5768268704414368,
0.052796948701143265,
0.19973857700824738,
0.475409597158432,
0.22372885048389435,
0.2505653500556946,
0.13432417809963226,
-0.2917228937149048,
0.48075902462005615,
0.0076152607798576355,
0.30493247509002686,
-0.34231898188591003,
0.2613036632537842,
-0.10151953995227814,
-0.08178063482046127,
-0.018632542341947556,
-0.8195015788078308,
-0.9551612138748169,
-0.46499425172805786,
-0.43966689705848694,
0.0485641248524189,
0.06989463418722153,
0.7557283043861389,
0.722294270992279,
-1.0328091382980347,
0.119111068546772,
-0.6088613271713257,
0.22618693113327026,
-0.16919852793216705,
-0.2271558791399002,
0.37247955799102783,
-0.33785825967788696,
-0.7071961164474487,
0.5128455758094788,
0.3401756286621094,
0.1810498982667923,
-0.03412158787250519,
-0.16481660306453705,
-0.156844824552536,
-0.1344432830810547,
0.5426939725875854,
0.12965846061706543,
-0.34643763303756714,
-0.04514020308852196,
-0.5494863986968994,
0.32958486676216125,
0.1867828518152237,
1.0919963121414185,
-0.8584969639778137,
0.6160863637924194,
0.4371192455291748,
0.9066230058670044,
0.2759372889995575,
0.5745863914489746,
0.4845126271247864,
-0.7323052287101746,
0.2631341516971588,
0.24864943325519562,
0.31467553973197937,
0.40843701362609863,
-0.5034613609313965,
0.6518052220344543,
0.165344700217247,
-0.5069501399993896,
-0.7362456321716309,
-0.07830208539962769,
-0.6676442623138428,
-0.22796624898910522,
0.7356017231941223,
0.014427279122173786,
-0.05387011542916298,
-0.4169582426548004,
-0.37323427200317383,
0.25392553210258484,
-0.4350025951862335,
0.8953220248222351,
0.6033825278282166,
-0.02331523783504963,
0.09068366140127182,
-0.5079280734062195,
0.5063952207565308,
0.24618904292583466,
-1.3120445013046265,
0.016499841585755348,
0.6264535188674927,
-0.18451280891895294,
0.32981106638908386,
0.042212679982185364,
-0.24843250215053558,
0.008666272275149822,
-0.43838974833488464,
-0.2878178358078003,
0.025058679282665253,
-0.24078743159770966,
-0.5353774428367615,
0.24393679201602936,
-0.4845430254936218,
0.018992410972714424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05632v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05632v2
|
Fighting crime with Transformers: Empirical analysis of address parsing methods in payment data
| 2024-04-08T16:04:26 | 2024-04-09T09:30:46 |
Haitham Hammami, Louis Baligand, Bojan Petrovski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the financial industry, identifying the location of parties involved in
payments is a major challenge in the context of various regulatory
requirements. For this purpose address parsing entails extracting fields such
as street, postal code, or country from free text message attributes. While
payment processing platforms are updating their standards with more structured
formats such as SWIFT with ISO 20022, address parsing remains essential for a
considerable volume of messages. With the emergence of Transformers and
Generative Large Language Models (LLM), we explore the performance of
state-of-the-art solutions given the constraint of processing a vast amount of
daily data. This paper also aims to show the need for training robust models
capable of dealing with real-world noisy transactional data. Our results
suggest that a well fine-tuned Transformer model using early-stopping
significantly outperforms other approaches. Nevertheless, generative LLMs
demonstrate strong zero-shot performance and warrant further investigations.
|
[
-0.1971644163131714,
-0.8506469130516052,
0.5664721727371216,
-0.03527107089757919,
-0.07787232100963593,
-0.022014468908309937,
0.10265450924634933,
-0.8435548543930054,
-0.10672838985919952,
0.8610376119613647,
-0.2842368483543396,
-0.44889163970947266,
-0.6441071629524231,
0.033439524471759796,
-0.6493605375289917,
0.9037150740623474,
0.3866256773471832,
-0.04813879728317261,
0.10484492778778076,
-0.0029660463333129883,
-0.33965665102005005,
-0.7806110978126526,
-0.7471053004264832,
-0.27049851417541504,
0.26986777782440186,
0.38245654106140137,
0.6240835189819336,
0.7360164523124695,
0.9379031658172607,
0.39650678634643555,
-0.06260658800601959,
-0.2590360939502716,
-0.31870022416114807,
0.19189074635505676,
-0.28687775135040283,
-0.6206228137016296,
-0.3818451762199402,
-0.11996299773454666,
0.1267865151166916,
0.46629276871681213,
-0.2458590269088745,
0.030782192945480347,
-0.42729610204696655,
0.6553381085395813,
-0.6581231951713562,
0.11404793709516525,
-0.6126120686531067,
0.09003015607595444,
-0.37434136867523193,
-0.16169126331806183,
-0.7582353949546814,
-0.2984431982040405,
-0.06269475817680359,
-0.20870694518089294,
0.6157050728797913,
-0.006829382851719856,
0.9010748267173767,
0.018770107999444008,
-0.318728506565094,
-0.4797189235687256,
-1.195553183555603,
0.4217536151409149,
-0.21576948463916779,
0.3542619049549103,
0.37362465262413025,
0.5068022608757019,
-0.10632658004760742,
-0.6797784566879272,
-0.19769476354122162,
0.032337553799152374,
-0.22383449971675873,
0.02469288371503353,
-0.6488839983940125,
0.06441687047481537,
0.6591182351112366,
0.6014382839202881,
-0.023077011108398438,
0.2823457419872284,
-0.43545660376548767,
-0.16332915425300598,
0.5156478881835938,
0.2954409420490265,
-0.002833726815879345,
-0.07707300037145615,
-0.46871471405029297,
-0.32376736402511597,
-0.7630732655525208,
0.46643275022506714,
0.964622437953949,
0.25160208344459534,
-0.37425968050956726,
0.5097476243972778,
-0.15731626749038696,
0.5934545397758484,
0.14983907341957092,
-0.31847578287124634,
0.06706687808036804,
0.017677823081612587,
-0.30101048946380615,
0.08615310490131378,
0.9167307019233704,
0.11221232265233994,
0.16560931503772736,
-0.2478480190038681,
-0.5653643608093262,
-0.002842174144461751,
0.3705284893512726,
-0.6197397708892822,
-0.2648252546787262,
0.3238430321216583,
-0.5205028057098389,
-0.5100594758987427,
0.1143687516450882,
-1.1150612831115723,
-0.35089951753616333,
-0.18765538930892944,
-0.21449381113052368,
-0.378775954246521,
-0.026535868644714355,
0.19941343367099762,
-0.030542101711034775,
0.6586071252822876,
0.10635633021593094,
-1.3169678449630737,
0.2534191906452179,
0.8881771564483643,
0.6684563159942627,
0.3041156232357025,
0.1964636743068695,
-0.6926308870315552,
0.27003172039985657,
-0.026667743921279907,
0.9516430497169495,
-0.3949173390865326,
-0.2710680365562439,
0.2548791766166687,
0.01337609812617302,
0.13680307567119598,
-0.7381506562232971,
0.7154269814491272,
-0.7603668570518494,
-0.35759347677230835,
0.11304136365652084,
-0.27911633253097534,
0.49261489510536194,
0.4810505509376526,
-0.8730131387710571,
0.5993290543556213,
0.36520618200302124,
-0.5733474493026733,
0.2797265350818634,
-0.5374512672424316,
-0.6325616240501404,
0.1639212965965271,
0.2715974450111389,
-0.6125286221504211,
0.43734198808670044,
0.3652116656303406,
0.41162341833114624,
-0.26160159707069397,
0.33911940455436707,
-0.010908680967986584,
-0.18542098999023438,
0.4682953655719757,
-0.7661527991294861,
0.8370299339294434,
0.3771304488182068,
-0.059053678065538406,
-0.08739253133535385,
-1.0409756898880005,
-0.7952420115470886,
0.2953506410121918,
-0.09309636801481247,
-0.13547556102275848,
0.12342271208763123,
0.10705123096704483,
-0.02051437459886074,
0.24412062764167786,
-0.8212490081787109,
0.2755337357521057,
-0.40291714668273926,
0.5810242891311646,
0.6848909854888916,
-0.14017248153686523,
0.35195299983024597,
-0.2183695286512375,
0.6286612153053284,
0.2552819848060608,
0.16698263585567474,
-0.60927814245224,
-0.2974621653556824,
-0.7816806435585022,
-0.3622106611728668,
0.3584166169166565,
0.7472509741783142,
-0.5924618244171143,
0.14054222404956818,
-0.41311320662498474,
-0.34818235039711,
-0.440573513507843,
-0.1764685958623886,
0.009639166295528412,
0.4036393165588379,
0.3047899901866913,
-0.09822817146778107,
-0.6441537141799927,
-1.0154391527175903,
-0.3888550102710724,
-0.22626148164272308,
-0.23488938808441162,
0.0514487698674202,
0.16995763778686523,
-0.08472525328397751,
1.0370796918869019,
-0.6055678725242615,
-0.16625237464904785,
-0.638097882270813,
0.12122396379709244,
0.2680186331272125,
0.2692092955112457,
0.3794064223766327,
-0.7424958348274231,
-0.1309540569782257,
-0.20707477629184723,
-0.5046220421791077,
-0.14566722512245178,
-0.40682971477508545,
0.029975714161992073,
-0.06516807526350021,
0.42184990644454956,
-0.6216864585876465,
0.4876420497894287,
0.1103038340806961,
-0.2648420035839081,
0.33859938383102417,
-0.2159368395805359,
-0.08366965502500534,
-0.8403613567352295,
-0.13320061564445496,
0.282908171415329,
-0.4969344437122345,
-1.069885492324829,
0.2004256546497345,
0.029122501611709595,
-0.3735102415084839,
-0.49066096544265747,
0.0943199098110199,
-0.18916895985603333,
-0.17457729578018188,
-0.1275729387998581,
-0.25877058506011963,
-0.23122072219848633,
0.2264302372932434,
0.26196080446243286,
0.7313650846481323,
0.3244563341140747,
-0.17856286466121674,
0.5219144225120544,
0.36618196964263916,
-0.6435319781303406,
0.6922445893287659,
-0.4827360510826111,
-0.06441417336463928,
-0.09126918762922287,
0.00419484032317996,
-0.9258071184158325,
-0.3491399884223938,
0.16224978864192963,
-0.1258421093225479,
0.3220933675765991,
-0.48118242621421814,
-0.7099857330322266,
-0.3847190737724304,
0.11278530955314636,
0.6066178679466248,
0.7204720973968506,
-0.6563408374786377,
0.5720117688179016,
0.16897663474082947,
-0.05680709332227707,
-0.47976580262184143,
-0.5059419870376587,
0.42282333970069885,
-0.48047935962677,
-0.5921186804771423,
0.20448246598243713,
0.5955739617347717,
-0.3564099073410034,
-0.4212821424007416,
0.21926164627075195,
-0.018131203949451447,
0.4341821074485779,
0.034493859857320786,
0.353363037109375,
-0.08109251409769058,
-0.26804694533348083,
-0.4372032582759857,
-0.8011889457702637,
0.4474414587020874,
0.14312240481376648,
0.6781968474388123,
0.22040998935699463,
-0.2105453610420227,
-0.41764146089553833,
0.4622909724712372,
0.5250088572502136,
-0.40587612986564636,
0.8865849375724792,
0.0758948028087616,
-0.08433201164007187,
-0.018992077559232712,
-0.666000247001648,
0.05169723182916641,
-0.5354725122451782,
-0.04487898573279381,
-0.37549087405204773,
-0.7318081259727478,
0.7960613965988159,
-0.31000208854675293,
-0.16488148272037506,
0.2668931782245636,
0.48371779918670654,
-0.017822282388806343,
0.571365475654602,
0.8867642283439636,
-0.05289885029196739,
0.49556732177734375,
0.009992382489144802,
1.0348926782608032,
-0.3366810083389282,
-0.31640496850013733,
-0.8094837665557861,
-0.10609661787748337,
-0.7459021210670471,
-0.09468480944633484,
0.28805461525917053,
0.08831244707107544,
-0.04003516584634781,
0.6208086013793945,
-0.27147459983825684,
0.7502201795578003,
0.36632636189460754,
0.015546325594186783,
0.2881346344947815,
0.23303253948688507,
0.17217066884040833,
0.21887174248695374,
-0.2944341003894806,
-0.39066222310066223,
0.9042413234710693,
0.6756656169891357,
0.9044432640075684,
0.07654344290494919,
0.4620746076107025,
0.21274434030056,
0.18862465023994446,
-0.7875151038169861,
0.43287450075149536,
-0.40557917952537537,
-0.28867265582084656,
-0.15436390042304993,
-0.4220503270626068,
-1.0127816200256348,
0.0960942879319191,
0.053924091160297394,
-0.682035505771637,
0.43133747577667236,
-0.12593145668506622,
-0.40490803122520447,
0.6058488488197327,
-0.27039870619773865,
0.760861337184906,
0.00022824374900665134,
-0.4177362322807312,
0.33834242820739746,
-0.6312928199768066,
0.40570753812789917,
0.008454115130007267,
0.43502771854400635,
-0.11427100747823715,
0.49487853050231934,
0.29639413952827454,
-0.5151255130767822,
0.8233624696731567,
-0.12546595931053162,
-0.45181146264076233,
0.40778738260269165,
-0.07557832449674606,
0.8299803137779236,
-0.2450914978981018,
0.138483464717865,
0.4181126654148102,
-0.29073989391326904,
-0.2833980917930603,
-0.37392061948776245,
0.31973573565483093,
-0.4734087884426117,
-0.2958481013774872,
-0.20617377758026123,
-0.7408732771873474,
-0.14413239061832428,
-0.18617939949035645,
0.42533406615257263,
0.5191289186477661,
-0.06287582963705063,
0.30963319540023804,
0.8372735381126404,
-0.0684586837887764,
0.6483107209205627,
0.3574819564819336,
0.19179879128932953,
-0.27078405022621155,
0.5819103717803955,
-0.15040835738182068,
0.10869303345680237,
0.5038334131240845,
0.05404236167669296,
-0.35986581444740295,
-0.37680134177207947,
-0.4041862189769745,
-0.0007842715713195503,
-0.6224748492240906,
-0.44629135727882385,
-0.7654546499252319,
-0.2496563345193863,
-0.5468310713768005,
-0.4486854374408722,
-0.39968591928482056,
-0.26244375109672546,
0.06274476647377014,
-0.050525203347206116,
0.19571629166603088,
0.6175951957702637,
-0.16132348775863647,
0.71735018491745,
-0.9681820869445801,
0.6681416034698486,
0.11240456998348236,
0.533728837966919,
-0.06289941817522049,
-0.26408591866493225,
-0.41799023747444153,
-0.12331398576498032,
-0.34381303191185,
-1.0095946788787842,
0.4092828631401062,
-0.3667123317718506,
0.28158676624298096,
0.6261904835700989,
0.00515751913189888,
0.5966151356697083,
-0.5619009733200073,
0.7147837281227112,
0.29091134667396545,
-0.8815538883209229,
0.5497967600822449,
-0.4752906858921051,
0.10985565185546875,
0.3937925398349762,
0.2172776758670807,
-0.5255362391471863,
-0.3708028793334961,
-0.5685873031616211,
-1.0595118999481201,
0.7551124095916748,
0.30112960934638977,
0.2723180651664734,
-0.19145402312278748,
0.33399835228919983,
-0.06599139422178268,
0.17124532163143158,
-0.9614688754081726,
-0.3246024549007416,
-0.019069047644734383,
-0.177275151014328,
0.07418875396251678,
-0.6438465118408203,
-0.060315169394016266,
-0.09931719303131104,
0.3354528248310089,
0.23527629673480988,
0.38949719071388245,
-0.2888721227645874,
0.04151877760887146,
-0.08709470182657242,
0.5426638126373291,
0.46403422951698303,
0.35098591446876526,
0.0029954633209854364,
-0.07830257713794708,
-0.24687065184116364,
-0.5872980952262878,
0.6523919105529785,
0.014997703023254871,
-0.5397657155990601,
-0.08834484219551086,
0.5216608643531799,
0.7611479759216309,
-0.010514385998249054,
-0.7290108799934387,
0.9111055135726929,
0.0597250759601593,
-0.19928622245788574,
-0.6486227512359619,
0.12121713906526566,
-0.4162992537021637,
0.22311921417713165,
0.31522250175476074,
0.1331351399421692,
0.2250051647424698,
-0.5850103497505188,
0.06466339528560638,
0.39277383685112,
-0.48997631669044495,
-0.1688729226589203,
0.6908633708953857,
0.05459853261709213,
-0.6575678586959839,
0.94645756483078,
-0.10704834759235382,
-0.438176691532135,
0.7921053171157837,
0.9590120911598206,
1.0483574867248535,
-0.3586376905441284,
0.11096735298633575,
0.1431667059659958,
0.4483281373977661,
-0.26679736375808716,
0.0017082656268030405,
-0.29439619183540344,
-0.8538920283317566,
-0.4768514633178711,
-0.7894183397293091,
-0.30507248640060425,
0.2942449748516083,
-0.9415820837020874,
0.354588121175766,
-0.3655514121055603,
0.022386742755770683,
-0.18278323113918304,
-0.7053333520889282,
-0.7679104208946228,
-0.0320168100297451,
0.32675501704216003,
0.7536336779594421,
-0.8976144790649414,
0.6994834542274475,
0.4354294538497925,
0.040105003863573074,
-0.41333314776420593,
-0.2168882042169571,
-0.1996699571609497,
-0.5792607069015503,
0.7015158534049988,
0.42445290088653564,
0.01880125142633915,
-0.3911203444004059,
-0.709221601486206,
-0.5422551035881042,
0.7268660664558411,
0.28122612833976746,
-0.9282292723655701,
-0.043450046330690384,
1.0164170265197754,
0.597894549369812,
-0.31328535079956055,
0.2201395332813263,
1.0863827466964722,
0.11043619364500046,
0.4629218280315399,
-0.3804788589477539,
-0.3999141752719879,
-0.0878821313381195,
-0.174150750041008,
0.8209241032600403,
-0.6558525562286377,
0.832412838935852,
0.2025584727525711,
0.0024786870926618576,
-0.033395130187273026,
0.44671064615249634,
0.0224457960575819,
0.34494343400001526,
0.4297742545604706,
1.0642648935317993,
0.44754528999328613,
-0.41725707054138184,
1.0537137985229492,
-0.28792262077331543,
0.4805243909358978,
0.9561823606491089,
-0.521143913269043,
0.651595950126648,
0.3067431151866913,
-0.296217143535614,
0.49420320987701416,
0.24569348990917206,
-0.4525228440761566,
0.46678051352500916,
0.22739124298095703,
-0.1961868554353714,
-0.25646522641181946,
0.11945640295743942,
0.22036418318748474,
0.7433785796165466,
0.418637752532959,
-0.37685614824295044,
-0.4303303360939026,
0.2627007067203522,
-0.12608854472637177,
-0.09157152473926544,
-0.3806155323982239,
0.9117177128791809,
-0.14784358441829681,
-0.2656670808792114,
-0.12067984789609909,
0.32160699367523193,
0.4526411294937134,
-0.5296013951301575,
0.09315798431634903,
-0.4479553997516632,
0.10430799424648285,
0.036430079489946365,
-0.5166653394699097,
0.5167477130889893,
0.4434654414653778,
-0.34016627073287964,
-0.5611540675163269,
0.7414036989212036,
-0.11620719730854034,
-0.5098530650138855,
0.16588257253170013,
-0.059835128486156464,
0.14575116336345673,
-0.024140601977705956,
-0.35356733202934265,
-0.10372840613126755,
-0.08522706478834152,
-0.08577568829059601,
0.4421602785587311,
0.5013367533683777,
0.1684150993824005,
0.5400855541229248,
0.8521162271499634,
-0.08350867033004761,
-0.12704679369926453,
-0.04039059579372406,
0.6231783628463745,
-0.8166845440864563,
-0.7250145673751831,
-1.1349265575408936,
0.5519969463348389,
-0.15631650388240814,
-0.12225545197725296,
0.5606893301010132,
0.7699311375617981,
0.8708633184432983,
-0.056153926998376846,
0.1914713978767395,
0.17454785108566284,
0.4106060266494751,
-0.6468743085861206,
0.23478224873542786,
0.055589962750673294,
0.7416539788246155,
-0.03183244913816452,
-1.1200931072235107,
-0.1990835964679718,
0.6066504716873169,
-0.48337510228157043,
-0.3396732807159424,
0.22013787925243378,
0.5122672319412231,
-0.2701586186885834,
0.16344381868839264,
0.392404705286026,
0.027837831526994705,
0.5286083221435547,
0.5240752100944519,
1.0500361919403076,
-0.6099264025688171,
0.48146918416023254,
-0.48007360100746155,
0.24394148588180542,
-0.218427836894989,
-0.8723010420799255,
-0.6683775186538696,
-0.00769253121688962,
-0.18857018649578094,
-0.2943136692047119,
-0.4301225543022156,
0.5540319085121155,
0.3835810124874115,
-0.8012239933013916,
-0.29608678817749023,
-0.04027896374464035,
-0.21068330109119415,
0.02848822809755802,
-0.21227794885635376,
0.21939027309417725,
-0.4521670937538147,
-0.5581450462341309,
0.3160351812839508,
0.5239383578300476,
0.33338892459869385,
-0.20189684629440308,
0.5709174275398254,
0.30603083968162537,
0.2973325550556183,
0.6800153851509094,
-0.050085246562957764,
-0.45583575963974,
-0.1292254775762558,
-0.16230081021785736,
-0.16985894739627838,
0.36780792474746704,
1.335778832435608,
-0.6729047894477844,
0.10547726601362228,
0.279468297958374,
0.6349239349365234,
0.3858589828014374,
0.5863440632820129,
0.28093934059143066,
-0.6934484243392944,
0.4963875114917755,
0.06371639668941498,
0.4837545156478882,
0.16210535168647766,
-0.7383032441139221,
0.4751470685005188,
0.12233445793390274,
-0.6724510192871094,
-0.782433271408081,
0.35653266310691833,
-0.640268087387085,
-0.23403294384479523,
0.7224132418632507,
-0.2222871333360672,
-0.3198697865009308,
-0.4189610183238983,
0.17859695851802826,
-0.16147832572460175,
-0.2350732684135437,
0.6592225432395935,
0.7648395895957947,
0.020776554942131042,
-0.3950684666633606,
-0.5584394931793213,
0.31126657128334045,
0.08732239902019501,
-0.65666663646698,
0.2525688111782074,
0.5953434109687805,
-0.005689798388630152,
0.32590216398239136,
0.4454982578754425,
-0.25148260593414307,
0.15876297652721405,
0.12315095961093903,
-0.00841456837952137,
-0.06332924216985703,
-0.5024775266647339,
-0.6148558855056763,
0.7420920133590698,
-0.24495413899421692,
0.12834122776985168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05624v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05624v1
|
LTNER: Large Language Model Tagging for Named Entity Recognition with Contextualized Entity Marking
| 2024-04-08T15:54:02 | 2024-04-08T15:54:02 |
Faren Yan, Peng Yu, Xin Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The use of LLMs for natural language processing has become a popular trend in
the past two years, driven by their formidable capacity for context
comprehension and learning, which has inspired a wave of research from
academics and industry professionals. However, for certain NLP tasks, such as
NER, the performance of LLMs still falls short when compared to supervised
learning methods. In our research, we developed a NER processing framework
called LTNER that incorporates a revolutionary Contextualized Entity Marking
Gen Method. By leveraging the cost-effective GPT-3.5 coupled with context
learning that does not require additional training, we significantly improved
the accuracy of LLMs in handling NER tasks. The F1 score on the CoNLL03 dataset
increased from the initial 85.9% to 91.9%, approaching the performance of
supervised fine-tuning. This outcome has led to a deeper understanding of the
potential of LLMs.
|
[
-0.6708141565322876,
-0.8954909443855286,
0.43037593364715576,
-0.06027175486087799,
-0.2580532729625702,
0.07764404267072678,
-0.39580562710762024,
-0.8157829642295837,
0.07151447981595993,
0.5105935335159302,
-0.36515888571739197,
-0.6478885412216187,
-0.5139331817626953,
0.28325873613357544,
-0.26586660742759705,
0.9604763388633728,
0.028704233467578888,
0.17287378013134003,
0.03653991222381592,
-0.0024792817421257496,
-0.5280145406723022,
-0.4837169945240021,
-1.2735929489135742,
-0.5194266438484192,
0.837652325630188,
0.3929859697818756,
0.23067939281463623,
0.6633353233337402,
0.6387631893157959,
0.19883155822753906,
-0.1631108820438385,
0.12124038487672806,
-0.3323020935058594,
0.3535984456539154,
-0.2586718499660492,
-0.2863996624946594,
-0.5705760717391968,
-0.21059922873973846,
0.807029664516449,
0.6808503270149231,
-0.02199706993997097,
-0.007742871530354023,
0.020863063633441925,
0.7101151347160339,
-0.399301141500473,
-0.033197540789842606,
-0.8068858981132507,
0.11841655522584915,
-0.35577404499053955,
-0.46443822979927063,
-0.6568681001663208,
0.050372250378131866,
0.0982246920466423,
-0.4373258948326111,
0.35228481888771057,
0.258075088262558,
0.6777164340019226,
0.4910948574542999,
-0.36441418528556824,
-0.37078261375427246,
-0.6934831738471985,
0.9271942973136902,
-0.7248080372810364,
0.6425803303718567,
0.05021027848124504,
0.12641221284866333,
-0.412249356508255,
-0.9194907546043396,
-0.36241528391838074,
-0.14413297176361084,
-0.06610386818647385,
-0.21844793856143951,
-0.1854245662689209,
0.1474701166152954,
0.5689253807067871,
0.101725734770298,
-0.5157267451286316,
0.5100075006484985,
0.015408729203045368,
0.07223305851221085,
0.4770207107067108,
0.04863253980875015,
0.22046317160129547,
-0.11356854438781738,
-0.5873132348060608,
0.1695709079504013,
-0.846382737159729,
-0.15879316627979279,
0.08375876396894455,
0.46624645590782166,
0.12905457615852356,
0.5312943458557129,
-0.2759797275066376,
0.9705920219421387,
-0.022326115518808365,
-0.2954753041267395,
0.1733628362417221,
-0.01343193557113409,
-0.41056492924690247,
0.2530863881111145,
0.6882815957069397,
0.4827885925769806,
0.4247564375400543,
-0.3715679943561554,
-0.4024644196033478,
-0.15050141513347626,
-0.04965309798717499,
-0.9049952030181885,
-0.10481543838977814,
-0.14925630390644073,
-0.22017556428909302,
0.08114097267389297,
-0.20167940855026245,
-0.8103314638137817,
-0.29402217268943787,
-0.5399678945541382,
0.03689391911029816,
-0.29736971855163574,
-0.07200631499290466,
0.03569134324789047,
0.08472856134176254,
0.49281877279281616,
0.4483221471309662,
-0.8110560178756714,
0.31484806537628174,
0.8003796935081482,
0.8472006916999817,
-0.2870853841304779,
0.0930340588092804,
-0.7144266366958618,
0.22214284539222717,
-0.1692200005054474,
0.9196127653121948,
-0.6216627955436707,
-0.20801573991775513,
-0.2444790154695511,
-0.10686682164669037,
-0.10728026926517487,
-0.5775129199028015,
0.5129126310348511,
-0.9629933834075928,
0.022671392187476158,
-0.1653456836938858,
-0.8633267879486084,
-0.05521947890520096,
0.45919206738471985,
-0.7049474120140076,
1.1045048236846924,
-0.08778316527605057,
-0.8294342756271362,
0.5741262435913086,
-0.6997460722923279,
-0.4047331213951111,
0.4600842297077179,
-0.25564998388290405,
-0.21024414896965027,
-0.11741524189710617,
0.2692648470401764,
0.7694088220596313,
-0.4684827923774719,
0.5187836289405823,
-0.057481952011585236,
-0.41716718673706055,
0.17932888865470886,
-0.33795180916786194,
0.2551893889904022,
0.023030119016766548,
-0.356050580739975,
0.14972780644893646,
-0.8480117917060852,
0.09588906168937683,
-0.006467978470027447,
-0.5445996522903442,
-0.4598764181137085,
0.008625112473964691,
0.16810593008995056,
0.25450655817985535,
0.07001503556966782,
-0.3639909625053406,
0.17990568280220032,
-0.5862941741943359,
0.4590851366519928,
0.6006916165351868,
0.12874609231948853,
0.7186694145202637,
-0.0400194376707077,
0.4442804455757141,
-0.3934871256351471,
-0.31992748379707336,
0.06050538271665573,
-0.4245012104511261,
-0.9939827919006348,
-0.31520724296569824,
0.5724923014640808,
0.4119526743888855,
-0.7851190567016602,
0.48328736424446106,
-0.42911580204963684,
-0.34073588252067566,
-0.17868009209632874,
0.1496666818857193,
0.21943695843219757,
0.7836779952049255,
0.5926937460899353,
0.013292625546455383,
-0.8231343626976013,
-0.8661618828773499,
-0.2776932716369629,
0.30001676082611084,
-0.08896789699792862,
0.11516532301902771,
0.6474786400794983,
-0.3660103380680084,
1.0585347414016724,
-0.34553760290145874,
-0.7202743291854858,
-0.4479699432849884,
0.10705263912677765,
0.2564544379711151,
0.6302363276481628,
0.12558378279209137,
-0.8391441702842712,
-0.5726969242095947,
0.0425589345395565,
-0.605273962020874,
-0.00922151654958725,
0.09532742202281952,
0.15926454961299896,
0.5353695154190063,
0.9947376251220703,
-0.5197775959968567,
0.1407957226037979,
0.4423653185367584,
-0.11108063906431198,
0.12408227473497391,
0.0010095522738993168,
-0.2102876901626587,
-1.041244387626648,
0.16791094839572906,
0.2956511080265045,
-0.4028158187866211,
-0.7221279144287109,
0.02080990932881832,
-0.13676564395427704,
0.2638682425022125,
-0.4673582911491394,
0.9160364270210266,
-0.6446453332901001,
-0.08877246826887131,
-0.3644443154335022,
0.2874564826488495,
-0.18341444432735443,
0.21585893630981445,
0.1416604071855545,
0.7560601830482483,
0.22092141211032867,
-0.5734893083572388,
0.2153988480567932,
-0.16422903537750244,
-0.3600938320159912,
0.578801155090332,
-0.6908007860183716,
0.3130914568901062,
-0.15792693197727203,
0.3769620358943939,
-0.5654852986335754,
-0.3821026086807251,
0.38289254903793335,
-0.3158053755760193,
0.5704215168952942,
-0.3956139087677002,
-0.6628734469413757,
0.003393779741600156,
0.04876340925693512,
0.27344897389411926,
0.30946528911590576,
-0.5582694411277771,
0.9284921288490295,
0.3732733130455017,
-0.00756895961239934,
-0.6804341673851013,
-0.7457501292228699,
0.1792200654745102,
-0.4459502696990967,
-0.34374910593032837,
0.5819193720817566,
0.06682752817869186,
-0.1797810196876526,
0.0691910833120346,
-0.1950741708278656,
0.14976060390472412,
0.17332245409488678,
0.22584237158298492,
0.18862250447273254,
-0.236917182803154,
0.37945079803466797,
-0.3287491202354431,
-0.49426165223121643,
-0.003975009545683861,
0.023052694275975227,
0.7745760083198547,
-0.1279664784669876,
-0.11901148408651352,
-0.287876158952713,
0.043314073234796524,
-0.04989511892199516,
-0.18751409649848938,
0.7694787383079529,
0.7045508623123169,
-0.6736543774604797,
-0.4555782675743103,
-0.6780985593795776,
-0.02937287651002407,
-0.4313194453716278,
0.2912091314792633,
-0.48102834820747375,
-1.4382573366165161,
0.28968626260757446,
-0.19130034744739532,
-0.15967439115047455,
0.44535115361213684,
0.23834198713302612,
-0.15880385041236877,
0.9010571241378784,
0.6419878005981445,
-0.17167425155639648,
0.5095557570457458,
-0.16870912909507751,
0.43061068654060364,
-1.1049864292144775,
-0.24421517550945282,
-0.4936463534832001,
-0.3792745769023895,
-0.7727466225624084,
-0.5455188751220703,
0.05297623947262764,
0.38241347670555115,
-0.29049235582351685,
0.1646909862756729,
-0.5891886353492737,
0.6948879957199097,
0.5433552861213684,
-0.22801637649536133,
0.46547558903694153,
-0.00863712653517723,
0.028496352955698967,
-0.1671328842639923,
-0.5318796634674072,
-0.6878963708877563,
0.8382403254508972,
0.3785801827907562,
0.7604885101318359,
-0.06970561295747757,
0.7289502620697021,
0.2317364364862442,
0.6575189232826233,
-0.8470595479011536,
0.8125723600387573,
-0.06699132919311523,
-0.5624216198921204,
-0.3285543918609619,
-0.44995129108428955,
-0.9411072731018066,
0.21534211933612823,
-0.15044660866260529,
-0.9630564451217651,
-0.09454498440027237,
0.07008329778909683,
-0.05977468937635422,
0.43291738629341125,
-0.45599088072776794,
0.7352507710456848,
-0.14922571182250977,
-0.2728974223136902,
0.16051778197288513,
-0.612814724445343,
0.16970239579677582,
-0.13606701791286469,
0.22866769134998322,
-0.4007212221622467,
-0.25280076265335083,
0.9026458859443665,
0.20106925070285797,
0.6722895503044128,
-0.3099558353424072,
-0.11225658655166626,
-0.01166370790451765,
-0.08594738692045212,
0.7019492387771606,
0.3769317865371704,
-0.18885476887226105,
0.0661008358001709,
-0.39152342081069946,
0.017760517075657845,
-0.5114444494247437,
1.0289782285690308,
-0.29848846793174744,
-0.4686164855957031,
-0.7068155407905579,
-0.5749587416648865,
-0.09502231329679489,
0.42021578550338745,
0.1820683479309082,
0.2367507368326187,
-0.20312513411045074,
0.3655737042427063,
0.8197802305221558,
-0.12226095795631409,
0.6197521686553955,
0.4626356363296509,
-0.28745222091674805,
-0.5087738633155823,
0.664088785648346,
0.11608918756246567,
0.047771554440259933,
0.7525458335876465,
-0.31672948598861694,
-0.34784135222435,
-0.6970101594924927,
-0.18361259996891022,
0.27375996112823486,
-0.970735490322113,
-0.43012216687202454,
-0.8470292091369629,
-0.21602456271648407,
-0.20215605199337006,
-0.4121226370334625,
-0.26023197174072266,
-0.02775382250547409,
-0.5763053894042969,
-0.03382151201367378,
0.20667380094528198,
0.6733707785606384,
0.22810104489326477,
0.4442242980003357,
-0.5207285284996033,
0.24951079487800598,
0.05779686197638512,
0.49487608671188354,
-0.13540513813495636,
-0.3730294704437256,
-0.07833035290241241,
-0.09379471838474274,
0.10442982614040375,
-0.4593028128147125,
0.4591425061225891,
0.15405455231666565,
0.5337924957275391,
0.18618066608905792,
-0.03237564116716385,
0.7007408738136292,
-0.5746358036994934,
0.440560907125473,
0.09488562494516373,
-0.8621085286140442,
0.48511210083961487,
-0.21991442143917084,
0.30968907475471497,
0.4252204895019531,
0.36566630005836487,
-0.6067343950271606,
0.01077304221689701,
-0.39650341868400574,
-1.1913926601409912,
0.5784580111503601,
-0.10792752355337143,
0.019095750525593758,
-0.1479276567697525,
0.4078724980354309,
-0.11790311336517334,
0.03941064327955246,
-1.0529881715774536,
-0.3096145689487457,
0.5584321022033691,
-0.19556081295013428,
-0.41064101457595825,
-0.362747460603714,
0.007571629714220762,
-0.19337882101535797,
0.7859416604042053,
-0.3448251783847809,
0.20428617298603058,
0.23442687094211578,
-0.3804718255996704,
-0.08741196990013123,
0.569514811038971,
0.4699777066707611,
0.6075487732887268,
-0.3157830238342285,
0.352125346660614,
0.421652227640152,
0.07040055841207504,
0.06429468840360641,
0.38929876685142517,
-0.3164008855819702,
0.05025957152247429,
0.38420817255973816,
0.8107616901397705,
0.45429477095603943,
-0.6799768805503845,
0.15748606622219086,
-0.09196875244379044,
-0.13276082277297974,
-0.5734900236129761,
0.22208239138126373,
0.354332834482193,
0.36128711700439453,
0.4361377954483032,
0.050820499658584595,
0.16369250416755676,
-0.01648794300854206,
0.16569054126739502,
0.5430694222450256,
-0.49557191133499146,
0.04507625475525856,
0.5395134091377258,
0.005611815024167299,
-0.36126673221588135,
0.5439496636390686,
-0.2813103199005127,
-0.36086317896842957,
0.4016985595226288,
0.6741986274719238,
0.7165517807006836,
-0.006889644078910351,
-0.08722401410341263,
0.4943581223487854,
0.32677653431892395,
-0.19821418821811676,
0.0888504683971405,
-0.004227954428642988,
-0.8530033230781555,
-0.7374657988548279,
-0.9380343556404114,
-0.31823456287384033,
0.33493778109550476,
-0.5650842189788818,
0.34577345848083496,
-0.4589315950870514,
-0.3017530143260956,
0.2654575705528259,
-0.030853528529405594,
-0.7664542198181152,
0.49066659808158875,
0.2811395823955536,
0.895361602306366,
-0.4292561411857605,
0.8563544154167175,
0.7656378746032715,
-0.2113679200410843,
-0.7302425503730774,
-0.15604591369628906,
-0.23839683830738068,
-0.4200071394443512,
1.126011610031128,
0.6980172991752625,
-0.11521671712398529,
0.6369146108627319,
-0.41842877864837646,
-1.129251480102539,
1.126364827156067,
0.18242959678173065,
-0.8569953441619873,
-0.26707351207733154,
0.11174234002828598,
0.6157011985778809,
-0.5536389350891113,
0.05355815961956978,
0.6239413022994995,
0.429500937461853,
0.003277681302279234,
-0.6462774276733398,
0.10388588160276413,
-0.04485839977860451,
0.27245423197746277,
0.5379148125648499,
-0.21790510416030884,
0.5549792647361755,
-0.08252090960741043,
-0.4526236951351166,
-0.05755823478102684,
0.6702815890312195,
0.3259565532207489,
0.4265119731426239,
0.48856082558631897,
0.8259680867195129,
0.6702682375907898,
-0.3384309709072113,
0.8433369994163513,
-0.10981826484203339,
0.4195106327533722,
1.4190452098846436,
-0.5036066770553589,
1.0602716207504272,
0.7511575818061829,
0.06581749767065048,
0.3625022768974304,
0.4769204556941986,
-0.18998423218727112,
0.2763546109199524,
0.2954319417476654,
-0.3950076699256897,
-0.2647324800491333,
-0.40696635842323303,
-0.30252954363822937,
0.35598888993263245,
0.43869054317474365,
-0.5306447744369507,
-0.21565483510494232,
0.14210236072540283,
0.1468086540699005,
-0.02473447471857071,
-0.3019256889820099,
0.8654412627220154,
0.2864970564842224,
-0.5822941064834595,
0.3362072706222534,
0.1749599725008011,
1.0143914222717285,
-0.36900344491004944,
-0.19601964950561523,
0.009282127022743225,
0.25229963660240173,
-0.17935925722122192,
-0.7566421627998352,
0.1494036614894867,
0.08570312708616257,
-0.26782146096229553,
-0.446524977684021,
0.9900317788124084,
-0.3323986828327179,
-0.3484955430030823,
0.6920572519302368,
0.512451708316803,
0.05446119233965874,
0.024337152019143105,
-0.5598770976066589,
0.12626929581165314,
-0.1072762981057167,
-0.451874703168869,
0.3710053861141205,
0.13005535304546356,
0.022921711206436157,
0.9153812527656555,
0.7582724094390869,
-0.0029581738635897636,
0.00812075100839138,
0.26725414395332336,
0.8110195398330688,
-0.8985976576805115,
-0.1379188448190689,
-1.0024473667144775,
0.4233395755290985,
-0.12383610755205154,
-0.1859700083732605,
0.7118220925331116,
0.6421450972557068,
1.2770286798477173,
0.08903555572032928,
0.5280092358589172,
-0.2122855931520462,
0.6513547897338867,
-0.7536509037017822,
0.4069474935531616,
-0.39786839485168457,
0.439313143491745,
-0.17720238864421844,
-1.1685751676559448,
-0.7967833876609802,
0.5208935141563416,
-0.5344241857528687,
0.2708876430988312,
0.547859251499176,
0.8130111694335938,
0.10746512562036514,
-0.14900240302085876,
0.26000362634658813,
-0.1084655374288559,
0.5137920379638672,
0.38418224453926086,
0.8738043308258057,
-0.3522939682006836,
0.18263939023017883,
-0.3611946702003479,
0.20490998029708862,
-0.28310245275497437,
-1.0478382110595703,
-1.0275071859359741,
-0.2922929525375366,
-0.3358656167984009,
-0.10165168344974518,
0.10505050420761108,
1.1056363582611084,
0.5458770394325256,
-0.7453165054321289,
0.031853798776865005,
-0.4045174717903137,
0.038866154849529266,
0.20500418543815613,
-0.30859360098838806,
0.21865278482437134,
-0.5235801935195923,
-0.7882401347160339,
0.5525772571563721,
0.28596940636634827,
0.05093337595462799,
0.08684052526950836,
-0.22729530930519104,
-0.4560939371585846,
-0.5095992684364319,
0.5399606823921204,
0.0996243953704834,
-0.9245616793632507,
-0.25142261385917664,
-0.013835802674293518,
-0.16954679787158966,
0.10774718225002289,
0.6359981894493103,
-0.7199254631996155,
0.19137269258499146,
0.3065569996833801,
0.7195211052894592,
0.45623835921287537,
-0.03861777111887932,
0.3461345136165619,
-0.7839450836181641,
0.03307794779539108,
0.4489426910877228,
0.40928757190704346,
0.687275767326355,
-0.28608834743499756,
0.7390744090080261,
0.12360391020774841,
-0.7518813014030457,
-0.9622548222541809,
0.03341040015220642,
-1.0254993438720703,
-0.016498997807502747,
1.2189652919769287,
0.058425821363925934,
0.034182339906692505,
-0.01641598530113697,
-0.13993586599826813,
0.3864750266075134,
-0.4740627110004425,
0.15039175748825073,
0.38461196422576904,
-0.15113285183906555,
-0.51651930809021,
-0.9008645415306091,
0.5713481903076172,
0.20767785608768463,
-0.7861036062240601,
-0.2997499406337738,
0.4623616337776184,
0.5510257482528687,
0.04198150336742401,
0.6392695307731628,
0.26607346534729004,
-0.07515637576580048,
-0.4139058291912079,
0.3712944984436035,
0.09753086417913437,
-0.27731436491012573,
-0.37909260392189026,
0.3593966066837311,
0.3152380883693695,
0.1830381602048874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05623v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05623v2
|
AnchorAL: Computationally Efficient Active Learning for Large and Imbalanced Datasets
| 2024-04-08T15:53:46 | 2024-05-24T19:46:14 |
Pietro Lesci, Andreas Vlachos
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Active learning for imbalanced classification tasks is challenging as the
minority classes naturally occur rarely. Gathering a large pool of unlabelled
data is thus essential to capture minority instances. Standard pool-based
active learning is computationally expensive on large pools and often reaches
low accuracy by overfitting the initial decision boundary, thus failing to
explore the input space and find minority instances. To address these issues we
propose AnchorAL. At each iteration, AnchorAL chooses class-specific instances
from the labelled set, or anchors, and retrieves the most similar unlabelled
instances from the pool. This resulting subpool is then used for active
learning. Using a small, fixed-sized subpool AnchorAL allows scaling any active
learning strategy to large pools. By dynamically selecting different anchors at
each iteration it promotes class balance and prevents overfitting the initial
decision boundary, thus promoting the discovery of new clusters of minority
instances. In experiments across different classification tasks, active
learning strategies, and model architectures AnchorAL is (i) faster, often
reducing runtime from hours to minutes, (ii) trains more performant models,
(iii) and returns more balanced datasets than competing methods.
|
[
0.0005315138259902596,
-0.7103949189186096,
-0.14029203355312347,
0.12070661783218384,
-0.19758422672748566,
0.39178815484046936,
-0.21230192482471466,
-0.4235576391220093,
0.2853507697582245,
-0.22558562457561493,
-0.1765560507774353,
-0.3097619116306305,
-0.40937918424606323,
-0.24225814640522003,
-0.45195242762565613,
0.8646873235702515,
-0.1566767543554306,
0.007770518772304058,
-0.18233226239681244,
-0.6907406449317932,
-0.37496596574783325,
-0.27482277154922485,
-0.7549823522567749,
-0.37828221917152405,
0.6508579850196838,
0.6594882607460022,
0.7878513932228088,
0.9702741503715515,
0.34484919905662537,
0.2716088891029358,
-0.18817515671253204,
0.1528143584728241,
-0.7160849571228027,
0.22964157164096832,
-0.4182685613632202,
-0.540884256362915,
-0.36871156096458435,
0.11184477806091309,
0.7612544298171997,
0.9098915457725525,
-0.1356154829263687,
0.4358598589897156,
0.03446931391954422,
0.7143094539642334,
-1.400689959526062,
0.18048317730426788,
-0.6640484929084778,
0.3176704943180084,
-0.32928481698036194,
0.07329223304986954,
-0.14086273312568665,
-0.0048589627258479595,
0.13655690848827362,
-0.5871352553367615,
0.432443231344223,
-0.04893682897090912,
0.40899038314819336,
0.47402673959732056,
-0.5380885601043701,
-0.09437347948551178,
-0.5401841998100281,
0.9493451118469238,
-0.2389124035835266,
0.17269736528396606,
0.2426869124174118,
0.25698795914649963,
0.3824797570705414,
-0.7019926309585571,
-0.148706316947937,
0.10843107849359512,
0.15913212299346924,
0.28389185667037964,
-0.29612913727760315,
0.02940310165286064,
0.2752554714679718,
0.6708322763442993,
-0.3756125271320343,
0.28697413206100464,
-0.6952028274536133,
0.11019826680421829,
0.6883909702301025,
-0.08297821134328842,
0.16450266540050507,
0.441631019115448,
-0.24422363936901093,
-0.051672473549842834,
-0.7012664675712585,
0.1691616177558899,
0.3163548707962036,
0.720268726348877,
0.10099652409553528,
0.5295976400375366,
-0.15124358236789703,
0.8296247720718384,
0.2774609923362732,
-0.06797623634338379,
0.5631572008132935,
0.2572861611843109,
-0.04244265332818031,
0.7849260568618774,
0.15253502130508423,
0.22858893871307373,
0.0007642944110557437,
0.021049296483397484,
-0.21479108929634094,
0.20515096187591553,
0.34864625334739685,
-0.6110579371452332,
-0.40057992935180664,
0.2903366684913635,
-0.329931378364563,
-0.5397635698318481,
-0.06353599578142166,
-0.3358495533466339,
-0.4229632318019867,
-0.2358800619840622,
0.5129331350326538,
0.037605516612529755,
-0.23054422438144684,
-0.24623249471187592,
0.07342076301574707,
-0.052698250859975815,
0.5562969446182251,
-0.6368325352668762,
0.182169109582901,
0.3769456148147583,
1.0044422149658203,
-0.7030296325683594,
-0.20062808692455292,
-0.6891001462936401,
0.23241721093654633,
-0.23694252967834473,
0.3889264166355133,
-0.6968499422073364,
0.015880554914474487,
0.18566486239433289,
0.1448706090450287,
-0.2060099095106125,
-0.5697820782661438,
0.4448064863681793,
-0.6901715397834778,
-0.08778628706932068,
-0.025641627609729767,
-0.36247551441192627,
-0.28519999980926514,
0.26188337802886963,
-0.9736667275428772,
0.8803861737251282,
0.19296550750732422,
-0.6370041370391846,
0.36404407024383545,
-0.45081961154937744,
-0.6855548024177551,
0.09506447613239288,
0.07846727967262268,
-0.8075098991394043,
0.028986692428588867,
0.05652206391096115,
0.2472536861896515,
0.012541904114186764,
-0.0808078944683075,
-0.4885081648826599,
-0.5700227618217468,
0.00363444397225976,
-0.251722127199173,
0.5750136375427246,
0.37636953592300415,
-0.7105367183685303,
0.08912265300750732,
-0.4699483811855316,
-0.051596008241176605,
0.10757315158843994,
-0.5639069080352783,
-0.39418599009513855,
0.2381480187177658,
-0.009354864247143269,
0.07923408597707748,
0.09407650679349899,
-0.5962631702423096,
0.25049760937690735,
-0.04771163687109947,
0.26343193650245667,
0.7051763534545898,
-0.201634019613266,
0.7088397145271301,
-0.30463674664497375,
0.5751484036445618,
0.019113710150122643,
0.0029753786511719227,
-0.299797385931015,
-0.2610643208026886,
-0.7755005955696106,
-0.5614074468612671,
0.5823607444763184,
0.5560027360916138,
-0.5102172493934631,
0.13587607443332672,
0.060501035302877426,
-0.4365229904651642,
-0.5770421028137207,
0.36877986788749695,
0.5054113864898682,
0.38911810517311096,
0.6852467656135559,
-0.1635034829378128,
-0.29199373722076416,
-0.7197282910346985,
0.06958576291799545,
-0.010526633821427822,
0.3666881322860718,
0.25584203004837036,
0.2696811258792877,
-0.006311047822237015,
0.7167420387268066,
-0.4916251599788666,
-0.44452598690986633,
-0.07772272080183029,
0.15401063859462738,
0.25802940130233765,
0.6071365475654602,
0.5692281126976013,
-1.0791875123977661,
-0.731846809387207,
-0.06388156861066818,
-0.8911625742912292,
-0.11262675374746323,
0.06390491127967834,
-0.055328626185655594,
0.02961874008178711,
0.6168769598007202,
-0.40810543298721313,
0.4471743702888489,
0.45081576704978943,
-0.060597676783800125,
-0.26110219955444336,
0.14482297003269196,
-0.1377994269132614,
-0.6153727769851685,
0.05902595818042755,
-0.04271073266863823,
0.09546398371458054,
-0.3792765438556671,
0.0745387077331543,
0.3822573721408844,
-0.2925879657268524,
-0.5368982553482056,
0.5293567776679993,
-0.7915328741073608,
0.054490260779857635,
-0.4604005813598633,
-0.21613726019859314,
-0.3992660939693451,
0.4753248393535614,
-0.05295899510383606,
0.45732948184013367,
0.7440144419670105,
-0.6024389863014221,
0.5724010467529297,
0.014809409156441689,
0.07213228940963745,
0.6389816403388977,
-0.6709803938865662,
-0.1412021666765213,
-0.2931937873363495,
0.23176820576190948,
-0.9265454411506653,
-0.2618730664253235,
-0.023464545607566833,
-0.23440106213092804,
0.6717516779899597,
-0.571190595626831,
0.18843859434127808,
-0.48809924721717834,
-0.3710571825504303,
1.15396249294281,
0.4920649230480194,
-0.9046595692634583,
0.5873546004295349,
0.7160899043083191,
0.11285459250211716,
-0.9992978572845459,
-0.3520822525024414,
-0.4145660698413849,
-0.19130508601665497,
-0.27004483342170715,
0.1609579175710678,
0.35741111636161804,
-0.18159031867980957,
0.24379907548427582,
-0.48184674978256226,
0.007582054939121008,
0.3102230429649353,
0.47570791840553284,
-0.021144641563296318,
-0.19798336923122406,
0.3691108822822571,
0.09094052761793137,
-0.1294960379600525,
-0.33956626057624817,
-0.4519667625427246,
0.14083199203014374,
-0.2644045054912567,
-0.7730594873428345,
-0.06729614734649658,
0.19098424911499023,
0.7538269758224487,
-0.534247636795044,
0.8490242958068848,
0.4098280966281891,
-0.554312527179718,
-0.6106086373329163,
-0.27454859018325806,
0.017171809449791908,
-0.42461127042770386,
0.44291993975639343,
0.09169109910726547,
-0.7235470414161682,
0.33500733971595764,
-0.002021826570853591,
0.6200652718544006,
0.37189429998397827,
0.5763494372367859,
-0.06389852613210678,
1.0800544023513794,
0.30857327580451965,
-0.2502075135707855,
0.640269935131073,
-0.3619217276573181,
0.2372649610042572,
-0.3818480968475342,
-0.16277800500392914,
-0.16496333479881287,
-0.9671899080276489,
-0.07268598675727844,
-0.6090371012687683,
0.5953521132469177,
0.07887180894613266,
-0.27618613839149475,
-0.2461635172367096,
-0.6356107592582703,
0.5185470581054688,
0.8011474609375,
0.2928801476955414,
0.12734857201576233,
0.104951411485672,
0.22083808481693268,
0.16061744093894958,
-0.9245375394821167,
-0.06813718378543854,
1.1826720237731934,
0.3098163604736328,
1.0985163450241089,
0.13091158866882324,
0.392764687538147,
0.685667872428894,
0.6858491897583008,
-0.8517743349075317,
0.12103015929460526,
0.07092730700969696,
-0.8763920664787292,
-0.4006117880344391,
-0.2906039357185364,
-1.3214266300201416,
0.3030151426792145,
-0.5371067523956299,
0.028989767655730247,
0.3331867754459381,
0.7729973196983337,
-0.13018108904361725,
0.7230495810508728,
-0.5027381777763367,
0.6416500210762024,
-0.36830297112464905,
-0.9003235697746277,
-0.30339720845222473,
-0.6036874651908875,
0.2939836084842682,
-0.4340853691101074,
0.01822245679795742,
-0.11235342174768448,
-0.13221344351768494,
0.7763981819152832,
-0.4861653745174408,
0.9977343082427979,
-0.44274210929870605,
0.22323107719421387,
0.6247369647026062,
-0.09252806752920151,
0.4479866623878479,
-0.21224917471408844,
-0.10405045747756958,
-0.06913160532712936,
-0.6246470808982849,
-0.8719238638877869,
-0.3529888689517975,
0.7572578191757202,
-0.840816855430603,
-0.05755730718374252,
-0.7231398224830627,
-0.3814486265182495,
-0.05882452428340912,
0.04707653447985649,
-0.05192525312304497,
0.3213609457015991,
-0.059603963047266006,
0.480582594871521,
0.911105215549469,
0.06410493701696396,
0.4388231337070465,
0.49881047010421753,
0.4430679678916931,
-0.2706615924835205,
0.9372226595878601,
0.42547231912612915,
0.055655378848314285,
0.29108351469039917,
-0.10713428258895874,
-0.13770000636577606,
-0.7367025017738342,
-0.42904043197631836,
0.07406069338321686,
-0.5218871831893921,
-0.7572786211967468,
-0.5863733291625977,
-0.21742752194404602,
-0.00970952957868576,
-0.5846248865127563,
-0.6712071895599365,
-0.6710770726203918,
-0.04882917180657387,
-0.4755401313304901,
0.1362369954586029,
0.3703124225139618,
-0.3329448699951172,
0.43439626693725586,
-0.5205097794532776,
0.2376232147216797,
0.7279112339019775,
0.22233562171459198,
0.31873857975006104,
-0.318513959646225,
-0.5246514081954956,
0.1032317578792572,
-0.36975568532943726,
-0.6745372414588928,
0.055044595152139664,
0.4303533434867859,
0.9474725127220154,
0.7743147611618042,
0.42660853266716003,
0.35762783885002136,
-0.2687101364135742,
0.17708677053451538,
0.2938898801803589,
-0.7130374908447266,
0.613265872001648,
-0.3268203139305115,
0.153161883354187,
0.8136958479881287,
0.7819892764091492,
-0.10026939958333969,
-0.23807837069034576,
-0.7054409980773926,
-1.3530396223068237,
0.8063858151435852,
0.17074884474277496,
-0.10977241396903992,
0.02217078022658825,
0.3113609552383423,
-0.26725590229034424,
0.33482325077056885,
-0.9519102573394775,
-0.2974368631839752,
-0.25106891989707947,
-0.4812723696231842,
-0.054647840559482574,
-0.07782509922981262,
-0.31854382157325745,
-0.2764018774032593,
0.9087608456611633,
-0.3673947751522064,
-0.1384337991476059,
-0.09489687532186508,
-0.4790339469909668,
-0.4965592324733734,
-0.2279464304447174,
-0.05903057008981705,
0.7195936441421509,
-0.3229655921459198,
0.4866774380207062,
0.5292295813560486,
-0.5575350522994995,
0.2207580953836441,
0.01170718390494585,
-0.24237193167209625,
-0.25557541847229004,
0.641417384147644,
0.5163527131080627,
0.3620986044406891,
-0.7627831697463989,
0.7458410859107971,
0.1631081998348236,
-0.03356646001338959,
-0.17977167665958405,
0.2838515341281891,
-0.1548766940832138,
0.3782615661621094,
0.7466422915458679,
0.07096346467733383,
-0.1500617414712906,
-0.603294849395752,
0.2825183570384979,
0.45100486278533936,
-0.8003023266792297,
-0.1604125201702118,
0.6888906359672546,
0.553395688533783,
-0.07619716227054596,
0.8638772964477539,
-0.04696660488843918,
-0.5190898776054382,
0.6356578469276428,
0.5223399996757507,
0.6321419477462769,
-0.7091769576072693,
-0.05760444700717926,
0.7080061435699463,
0.2311108112335205,
-0.2744569778442383,
-0.06673762947320938,
-0.1795673668384552,
-0.6630715727806091,
-0.2056097835302353,
-0.6513926982879639,
-0.5541277527809143,
-0.22056011855602264,
-0.8480944633483887,
0.20927315950393677,
-0.5469467043876648,
0.050547607243061066,
-0.20227894186973572,
-0.13456979393959045,
-0.14794544875621796,
0.20756924152374268,
0.31769391894340515,
0.7583910822868347,
-1.4671345949172974,
0.396602600812912,
1.1974743604660034,
-0.07763845473527908,
-0.4998219907283783,
-0.5327291488647461,
-0.013895679265260696,
-0.9657968282699585,
0.32472023367881775,
0.2705262005329132,
0.1216660663485527,
-0.11392120271921158,
-0.7615665197372437,
-0.9871355891227722,
1.0319616794586182,
0.043581876903772354,
-0.2893722653388977,
0.019809233024716377,
-0.28353244066238403,
0.3385483920574188,
-0.334485799074173,
0.07325390726327896,
0.08816627413034439,
0.295480877161026,
0.45025232434272766,
-0.6076856255531311,
-0.00900146085768938,
-0.6050383448600769,
-0.5516583323478699,
0.4798618257045746,
-0.9007775783538818,
1.1802163124084473,
-0.1975516825914383,
0.012075602076947689,
-0.5829519033432007,
0.8355292081832886,
0.4842618405818939,
0.6371498107910156,
0.8522647023200989,
0.6906574964523315,
1.0694739818572998,
-0.06831388920545578,
0.5541446805000305,
-0.18970292806625366,
0.27159789204597473,
0.7652029395103455,
-0.28578150272369385,
0.5324065089225769,
0.1159278005361557,
-0.07272591441869736,
0.15428507328033447,
0.7899808287620544,
-0.230887308716774,
0.6040608882904053,
0.2912472188472748,
-0.515305757522583,
-0.48693642020225525,
0.06236739829182625,
-0.351551353931427,
0.3583260178565979,
0.3700893819332123,
-0.19396492838859558,
-0.45312806963920593,
0.0936436653137207,
-0.029402004554867744,
-0.059965647757053375,
-0.9115650653839111,
0.3544062077999115,
-0.07956202328205109,
-0.5942139029502869,
0.45815426111221313,
0.09224405884742737,
0.4699147343635559,
-0.4158036708831787,
-0.25380295515060425,
-0.1701154112815857,
0.5477041602134705,
-0.5710284113883972,
-0.4018663763999939,
-0.19561907649040222,
-0.1939617395401001,
-0.256062775850296,
-0.099542036652565,
0.688155472278595,
-0.5089687705039978,
-0.4872324466705322,
0.10928806662559509,
0.5912726521492004,
-0.014291786588728428,
-0.09396868199110031,
-0.6951290965080261,
-0.15282805263996124,
0.08702230453491211,
-0.14929071068763733,
0.29965493083000183,
0.3156997859477997,
-0.7319302558898926,
0.6797921061515808,
0.7170554995536804,
-0.0695924386382103,
0.23245812952518463,
-0.4068165123462677,
1.1067678928375244,
-0.3975357413291931,
-0.5946003794670105,
-0.4213011860847473,
0.2929553985595703,
-0.13225629925727844,
-0.07177206128835678,
0.7068400979042053,
0.9113767147064209,
0.6558164358139038,
0.2385212481021881,
0.6758878231048584,
-0.10689131170511246,
0.5151468515396118,
-0.3212208151817322,
0.39974260330200195,
-0.6742927432060242,
0.13050486147403717,
-0.020742544904351234,
-1.140123963356018,
-0.3239671587944031,
1.0581640005111694,
-0.0897681936621666,
-0.00027648251852951944,
0.4681209921836853,
0.41767066717147827,
-0.7225108742713928,
-0.0655345544219017,
-0.15156204998493195,
0.1582801789045334,
0.043828707188367844,
0.5404133796691895,
1.0503828525543213,
-0.1430206149816513,
0.3546436131000519,
-0.12164027243852615,
-0.642952561378479,
-0.46430161595344543,
-0.6386110186576843,
-1.052383303642273,
-0.22608983516693115,
-0.6184711456298828,
-0.3866833448410034,
0.21196401119232178,
0.9155358672142029,
0.9129717946052551,
-0.9726649522781372,
-0.1474623829126358,
0.20322126150131226,
0.46651116013526917,
-0.3236417770385742,
-0.17416580021381378,
0.5795024633407593,
-0.35046109557151794,
-0.8401764631271362,
0.33191537857055664,
0.008393708616495132,
0.06980465352535248,
-0.008563335053622723,
0.019574111327528954,
-0.4807218909263611,
-0.2933052182197571,
0.42661887407302856,
0.8791248202323914,
0.14856183528900146,
0.27601826190948486,
-0.42115503549575806,
0.06524418294429779,
-0.07884975522756577,
0.735475480556488,
-0.8471003770828247,
0.2865062654018402,
0.4478521943092346,
0.8058575391769409,
0.8871291279792786,
0.34930920600891113,
0.4062965512275696,
-0.7703301906585693,
0.5305842161178589,
0.5673767328262329,
0.37851354479789734,
0.08912970125675201,
-0.28307655453681946,
0.8750612735748291,
0.36739885807037354,
-0.33617404103279114,
-1.0668693780899048,
-0.15514953434467316,
-1.0324394702911377,
-0.4365462064743042,
0.9762056469917297,
-0.18533948063850403,
-0.37086424231529236,
-0.28779587149620056,
0.07449698448181152,
0.13715410232543945,
-0.2714754343032837,
0.738524317741394,
0.18265390396118164,
-0.23622509837150574,
0.20309753715991974,
-0.2372472584247589,
0.3997569978237152,
0.5690090656280518,
-0.38299399614334106,
-0.09775977581739426,
0.6232891082763672,
0.025530826300382614,
0.2994953393936157,
0.4184032082557678,
0.04641028121113777,
0.47043463587760925,
-0.17273887991905212,
0.06521977484226227,
-0.3007233440876007,
-0.6304753422737122,
-0.24472850561141968,
0.737677276134491,
-0.045313552021980286,
-0.30179256200790405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05622v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05622v1
|
How to Evaluate Entity Resolution Systems: An Entity-Centric Framework with Application to Inventor Name Disambiguation
| 2024-04-08T15:53:29 | 2024-04-08T15:53:29 |
Olivier Binette, Youngsoo Baek, Siddharth Engineer, Christina Jones, Abel Dasylva, Jerome P. Reiter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ME
|
Entity resolution (record linkage, microclustering) systems are notoriously
difficult to evaluate. Looking for a needle in a haystack, traditional
evaluation methods use sophisticated, application-specific sampling schemes to
find matching pairs of records among an immense number of non-matches. We
propose an alternative that facilitates the creation of representative,
reusable benchmark data sets without necessitating complex sampling schemes.
These benchmark data sets can then be used for model training and a variety of
evaluation tasks. Specifically, we propose an entity-centric data labeling
methodology that integrates with a unified framework for monitoring summary
statistics, estimating key performance metrics such as cluster and pairwise
precision and recall, and analyzing root causes for errors. We validate the
framework in an application to inventor name disambiguation and through
simulation studies. Software: https://github.com/OlivierBinette/er-evaluation/
|
[
-0.6414168477058411,
-0.4034717082977295,
0.5374208092689514,
0.013099098578095436,
-0.28607162833213806,
0.1364460289478302,
-0.31144168972969055,
-0.5569683909416199,
0.5269145369529724,
0.1858576536178589,
-0.32687896490097046,
-0.6094256043434143,
-0.1717585325241089,
0.22476495802402496,
-0.6889060139656067,
0.85545414686203,
-0.11355755478143692,
0.029167745262384415,
-0.49311724305152893,
-0.5531360507011414,
-0.4040643870830536,
-0.47744131088256836,
-0.6147981882095337,
-0.42707177996635437,
0.4506942331790924,
0.5918909311294556,
0.2508373558521271,
0.7274898886680603,
0.613261878490448,
0.2695160508155823,
-0.014053093269467354,
0.003694480052217841,
-0.42286917567253113,
0.21660439670085907,
-0.44723591208457947,
-0.2926572859287262,
-0.44289886951446533,
-0.045881349593400955,
0.6425702571868896,
0.9318937659263611,
-0.3169476389884949,
0.5379979610443115,
-0.05962317809462547,
0.717022716999054,
-0.5729134678840637,
0.09481261670589447,
-0.6374539136886597,
0.14303210377693176,
-0.39536893367767334,
-0.12142667919397354,
-0.3900538384914398,
-0.15024426579475403,
0.3700864315032959,
-0.6031885743141174,
0.6689051389694214,
0.5603218674659729,
0.8096492290496826,
0.08516522496938705,
0.06344351917505264,
-0.18268528580665588,
-0.8683586716651917,
0.6989083886146545,
-0.1806897521018982,
0.5419642925262451,
-0.06925763189792633,
0.4581010341644287,
-0.019630197435617447,
-0.6854859590530396,
-0.3358176052570343,
-0.016995461657643318,
0.027221085503697395,
-0.2465575486421585,
-0.23268888890743256,
0.09712465107440948,
0.2983459532260895,
0.5503427982330322,
-0.39122453331947327,
0.3231811821460724,
-0.43140944838523865,
-0.24916839599609375,
0.4614371955394745,
0.23182713985443115,
0.029636157676577568,
0.035385213792324066,
-0.5846646428108215,
-0.05896320939064026,
-0.7125768661499023,
-0.12353746592998505,
0.22725072503089905,
0.4286147654056549,
0.4613267183303833,
0.6249244213104248,
-0.24558965861797333,
0.6356621980667114,
0.2964802086353302,
0.06356363743543625,
0.4816507399082184,
-0.08495092391967773,
-0.4380394220352173,
0.37707090377807617,
0.495439350605011,
0.4702822268009186,
-0.22903120517730713,
-0.5049737691879272,
-0.5317066311836243,
0.0031812700908631086,
0.42908158898353577,
-0.8290042877197266,
-0.44812947511672974,
0.3603381812572479,
-0.4347010552883148,
-0.1665504425764084,
0.07205607742071152,
-0.8256720900535583,
-0.34435829520225525,
-0.5875210165977478,
0.7476535439491272,
-0.28118696808815,
-0.04036349803209305,
-0.17075081169605255,
-0.32167455554008484,
-0.317331463098526,
0.17291799187660217,
-0.8145203590393066,
0.3612023591995239,
0.6865546703338623,
0.6440613269805908,
-0.06728611141443253,
-0.3073040246963501,
-0.4815272092819214,
0.09154615551233292,
-0.2153858095407486,
1.0880827903747559,
-0.44054022431373596,
-0.5222083330154419,
-0.42384177446365356,
-0.04437093809247017,
0.07490677386522293,
-1.0138710737228394,
0.5225883722305298,
-0.6431096792221069,
-0.25786855816841125,
-0.21532955765724182,
-0.63322514295578,
-0.09353052824735641,
0.08905169367790222,
-0.8886299133300781,
0.8332931995391846,
0.0253201425075531,
-0.7372962236404419,
0.7994014024734497,
-0.48556089401245117,
-0.12104254215955734,
0.17801299691200256,
-0.47881898283958435,
-0.5431059002876282,
0.198807492852211,
-0.0895068570971489,
0.25649356842041016,
-0.6531348824501038,
0.22506840527057648,
-0.31289148330688477,
-0.4239663779735565,
-0.2565496563911438,
0.06931639462709427,
0.46351704001426697,
0.07658647745847702,
-0.2563571035861969,
0.09590189158916473,
-1.0181822776794434,
0.04711329564452171,
-0.09603942185640335,
-0.2539415657520294,
-0.6385383009910583,
-0.052227601408958435,
-0.24963806569576263,
-0.474151611328125,
0.013800997287034988,
-0.5555213689804077,
-0.14269603788852692,
0.06928223371505737,
0.013976778835058212,
0.543433666229248,
-0.05390642210841179,
0.43591201305389404,
-0.3115973472595215,
0.3623385429382324,
0.15272662043571472,
-0.01983153074979782,
-0.1752697378396988,
-0.1882276087999344,
-0.7356936931610107,
-0.3152908682823181,
0.9636573195457458,
0.3179500102996826,
-0.7532839775085449,
0.40546900033950806,
-0.4992256462574005,
-0.8623026013374329,
-0.49217310547828674,
0.09417988359928131,
0.37903401255607605,
0.8257322311401367,
0.4789019227027893,
-0.654693603515625,
-0.6925185322761536,
-1.2373030185699463,
-0.38039764761924744,
-0.42988109588623047,
-0.45900487899780273,
0.33039891719818115,
0.4321160912513733,
-0.024001052603125572,
0.9502227902412415,
-0.127681702375412,
-0.1929629147052765,
0.1940406858921051,
0.36074885725975037,
0.10158815234899521,
0.5182665586471558,
0.4665282368659973,
-0.7926919460296631,
-0.13001970946788788,
-0.24514420330524445,
-0.5784500241279602,
-0.17109724879264832,
0.0582929290831089,
-0.12663257122039795,
-0.16394881904125214,
0.307433158159256,
-0.2280389815568924,
0.4487094581127167,
0.20415152609348297,
-0.06304756551980972,
0.8436661958694458,
-0.006689297500997782,
0.3660191595554352,
-0.638148307800293,
0.5563274621963501,
0.22488979995250702,
-0.15453080832958221,
-0.41066083312034607,
-0.06592287123203278,
-0.023016583174467087,
-0.111294686794281,
-0.24831968545913696,
0.22948817908763885,
-0.6856626868247986,
-0.34242022037506104,
0.15039744973182678,
0.42557185888290405,
0.2158883959054947,
0.014837091788649559,
-0.08081080764532089,
0.6782352328300476,
0.3988703787326813,
-0.7822777032852173,
0.6966719627380371,
0.09313880652189255,
-0.6862573623657227,
1.1646381616592407,
-0.6299930810928345,
0.027872329577803612,
-0.22665441036224365,
-0.04051408916711807,
-0.6657159328460693,
-0.09120572358369827,
0.19266457855701447,
-0.06868137419223785,
0.5988789200782776,
-0.06602930277585983,
-0.573103129863739,
-0.39853596687316895,
-0.24330291152000427,
0.4284573793411255,
0.0035794368013739586,
-0.8673217296600342,
0.5142970681190491,
0.5823441743850708,
-0.02826465480029583,
-0.4051969647407532,
-0.6039135456085205,
-0.04094114899635315,
-0.576054036617279,
-0.35272976756095886,
0.660995602607727,
0.15650996565818787,
-0.3152282238006592,
0.3357553780078888,
-0.5093361139297485,
-0.2729681730270386,
0.20543242990970612,
0.16672953963279724,
0.36868780851364136,
-0.23251762986183167,
0.7078896164894104,
0.13644161820411682,
-0.2341194897890091,
0.08321399986743927,
-0.04205117002129555,
-0.01124490238726139,
-0.06597220152616501,
-0.5253600478172302,
-0.15318071842193604,
0.22619518637657166,
0.38939690589904785,
-0.1878110021352768,
0.5517718195915222,
0.10073553025722504,
-0.6976073384284973,
-0.2616325318813324,
-0.608593761920929,
-0.2400723546743393,
-0.3350788652896881,
0.2583387792110443,
-0.8116451501846313,
-0.6253320574760437,
0.6617152690887451,
-0.3940272927284241,
0.06800179928541183,
0.5608835220336914,
0.326439768075943,
0.11530463397502899,
0.5620594024658203,
0.5750908851623535,
0.015664519742131233,
0.3425123989582062,
0.05152149125933647,
0.4140644371509552,
-1.0936402082443237,
-0.21084651350975037,
-0.922325074672699,
-0.4847796857357025,
-0.18973009288311005,
-0.3498533368110657,
0.38662612438201904,
0.4595794081687927,
-0.25256186723709106,
0.6747203469276428,
-0.7552627325057983,
0.6062111258506775,
0.3889889419078827,
0.09947352111339569,
0.6445819735527039,
0.15963055193424225,
-0.3323777914047241,
-0.1351371854543686,
-0.5924989581108093,
-0.7838969826698303,
1.0570204257965088,
0.34473738074302673,
0.739687442779541,
-0.008352086879312992,
0.9792317748069763,
0.1735241711139679,
0.7333186864852905,
-0.7031860947608948,
0.3332914710044861,
-0.019144071266055107,
-0.8594213724136353,
-0.5076026916503906,
-0.4511885941028595,
-0.6836838126182556,
0.17591138184070587,
0.025754479691386223,
-1.1295886039733887,
0.7050407528877258,
0.1096247136592865,
-0.6904448866844177,
0.3667716085910797,
-0.7329251766204834,
0.8753902912139893,
-0.039383646100759506,
-0.29107171297073364,
-0.11280717700719833,
-0.2472652941942215,
0.26538169384002686,
-0.301605224609375,
0.009577345103025436,
-0.21144115924835205,
-0.10571009665727615,
0.8657405972480774,
-0.4004676640033722,
0.3875901997089386,
-0.22714510560035706,
0.11695303022861481,
0.4774836301803589,
0.08906581252813339,
0.0741887018084526,
0.12792985141277313,
-0.4250542223453522,
0.15915969014167786,
0.2361782342195511,
-0.08592242002487183,
-0.5474611520767212,
0.894599437713623,
-0.24011307954788208,
-0.46319684386253357,
-0.11435285955667496,
0.05302325263619423,
-0.09649766236543655,
0.3130788505077362,
0.13602536916732788,
0.36313149333000183,
-0.5615648031234741,
0.19680526852607727,
0.598892331123352,
0.14151445031166077,
-0.049123648554086685,
0.624092161655426,
-0.29789137840270996,
-0.29810407757759094,
0.8707050681114197,
0.3371707797050476,
-0.19414548575878143,
0.1362437754869461,
-0.41252273321151733,
-0.3938828110694885,
-0.33977553248405457,
-0.9137353301048279,
-0.03846810758113861,
-0.66237473487854,
-0.5977164506912231,
-0.36921414732933044,
0.20043732225894928,
0.22407642006874084,
0.2519122362136841,
-0.5092636942863464,
-0.39684218168258667,
-0.415149062871933,
-0.14576974511146545,
0.17639650404453278,
0.5541301369667053,
-0.13216905295848846,
-0.05381332337856293,
-0.6597039699554443,
0.19102060794830322,
0.24814465641975403,
0.9991439580917358,
0.12813900411128998,
-0.18307846784591675,
-0.3846946656703949,
-0.14141349494457245,
-0.3845008313655853,
-0.9043127298355103,
-0.272357314825058,
0.21785765886306763,
0.6314260959625244,
0.2436179220676422,
0.21699108183383942,
0.8679513335227966,
-0.582981526851654,
0.4410976469516754,
0.17481665313243866,
-1.062279224395752,
0.4994824528694153,
0.22263017296791077,
-0.5629754662513733,
0.9917884469032288,
0.30451637506484985,
-0.3655962347984314,
0.033289242535829544,
-0.6578713059425354,
-1.0561009645462036,
0.49875572323799133,
-0.03535247594118118,
-0.3684135377407074,
-0.10963880270719528,
0.6821587085723877,
0.039225269109010696,
0.4388222396373749,
-0.11768140643835068,
-0.4460243284702301,
0.2859135866165161,
0.03873807191848755,
-0.07607477158308029,
-0.18215814232826233,
-0.2930662930011749,
-0.03880639746785164,
0.836642861366272,
0.04925336688756943,
0.23516418039798737,
0.5118860006332397,
-0.17925935983657837,
-0.16536960005760193,
0.2533179223537445,
0.0659504160284996,
0.8367030024528503,
-0.2916301488876343,
-0.017472095787525177,
0.04489419236779213,
0.03313060477375984,
0.27949947118759155,
0.5085745453834534,
-0.13861891627311707,
0.4187718331813812,
-0.11686661839485168,
0.5843020081520081,
0.4377497732639313,
-0.6188461780548096,
0.32938215136528015,
-0.06635818630456924,
0.12587760388851166,
-0.20294182002544403,
-0.09653446078300476,
0.13364166021347046,
0.33287668228149414,
0.4455222189426422,
-0.06052377074956894,
0.5337560176849365,
-0.3412885069847107,
0.3966812491416931,
0.09059567004442215,
-0.5383548736572266,
-0.11287941783666611,
0.8001137375831604,
0.3331267833709717,
-0.2610476016998291,
0.6062798500061035,
-0.28238314390182495,
-0.28180503845214844,
0.7686082720756531,
0.15016472339630127,
0.8393834233283997,
-0.265826940536499,
0.12527665495872498,
0.39646703004837036,
0.241689071059227,
-0.08450090885162354,
-0.013515478931367397,
-0.142700657248497,
-0.4948367476463318,
-0.19754910469055176,
-0.47859621047973633,
-0.6932277679443359,
-0.03838814049959183,
-0.9814377427101135,
0.48569297790527344,
-0.4509696364402771,
-0.47724732756614685,
0.4586559236049652,
-0.10316500812768936,
-0.9117836356163025,
0.1756388396024704,
-0.025816243141889572,
1.185534954071045,
-0.7479885816574097,
0.28415238857269287,
1.105573058128357,
-0.4463333189487457,
-0.6523123383522034,
-0.34914129972457886,
0.034152839332818985,
-0.12286391854286194,
0.49587875604629517,
0.30391785502433777,
0.05915039777755737,
-0.024297110736370087,
-0.148263618350029,
-0.4462147653102875,
1.2727952003479004,
0.287872314453125,
-0.8876752853393555,
0.06888485699892044,
-0.29392704367637634,
0.7280346751213074,
-0.5585921406745911,
0.3596697449684143,
0.9189339280128479,
0.3190043866634369,
-0.24680595099925995,
-1.2245899438858032,
-0.02064565382897854,
-0.15354718267917633,
0.22348791360855103,
0.42517486214637756,
-0.6060835123062134,
0.5720328092575073,
-0.13970302045345306,
-0.6868100166320801,
0.2872510552406311,
0.49116402864456177,
0.2707783579826355,
0.6882562041282654,
0.6351548433303833,
1.0316189527511597,
0.9069294333457947,
-0.24215173721313477,
0.6831958293914795,
-0.2783350348472595,
0.74502032995224,
1.3597826957702637,
-0.3754194676876068,
0.7417318224906921,
0.6718918085098267,
-0.4047829210758209,
0.5048454999923706,
0.6968368291854858,
-0.24883845448493958,
0.22874857485294342,
0.6379570960998535,
-0.5433564782142639,
-0.013588071800768375,
-0.3451143801212311,
-0.334557443857193,
0.21991366147994995,
0.26674652099609375,
-0.6463132500648499,
-0.37759116291999817,
-0.28529903292655945,
-0.37965670228004456,
0.04312305524945259,
-0.24543888866901398,
0.637740433216095,
-0.11877882480621338,
-0.23741751909255981,
0.15930430591106415,
-0.043839361518621445,
0.2372443974018097,
0.06310345977544785,
-0.18836350739002228,
0.05098523944616318,
0.10569042712450027,
-0.35144495964050293,
-0.5337792634963989,
0.3318639397621155,
0.08742949366569519,
-0.5390704274177551,
0.21360668540000916,
0.47376155853271484,
-0.20402945578098297,
-0.21654736995697021,
0.25953930616378784,
0.5103248953819275,
0.5097609758377075,
-0.08348879963159561,
-0.5369058847427368,
0.04563729465007782,
-0.06260412186384201,
-0.18438206613063812,
0.12836532294750214,
0.5793671011924744,
-0.045553792268037796,
0.5704213976860046,
0.3135063946247101,
0.06798699498176575,
-0.17692634463310242,
0.11736182123422623,
1.0191444158554077,
-0.413891077041626,
-0.1273978352546692,
-0.46323829889297485,
0.4875592887401581,
-0.10232343524694443,
-0.06370601058006287,
0.3942190110683441,
0.9388201832771301,
1.0959277153015137,
0.07024252414703369,
0.5343311429023743,
-0.3765958249568939,
1.040776252746582,
-0.08987212926149368,
0.4156692922115326,
-0.39221611618995667,
0.7008025646209717,
-0.3054331839084625,
-1.2080204486846924,
-0.3227175772190094,
0.4685341715812683,
-0.30290237069129944,
0.0062838210724294186,
0.35238611698150635,
0.6759462356567383,
-0.2638276517391205,
-0.007228894159197807,
0.13785533607006073,
-0.008563589304685593,
0.3364584743976593,
0.28654247522354126,
0.5684612393379211,
-0.6294525861740112,
0.4179631173610687,
-0.6272995471954346,
-0.3705989718437195,
-0.3937718868255615,
-0.8879662156105042,
-0.36880624294281006,
-0.5269045829772949,
-0.5064332485198975,
-0.29380562901496887,
0.12270709127187729,
0.7876459360122681,
0.545525074005127,
-0.8728954195976257,
0.0049142902716994286,
0.2287166714668274,
0.2662230134010315,
-0.06893178820610046,
-0.28049200773239136,
0.37630000710487366,
-0.1543709933757782,
-0.9088530540466309,
0.23211431503295898,
0.3902820348739624,
0.03716767951846123,
-0.27485114336013794,
0.28450703620910645,
0.33395493030548096,
-0.42634662985801697,
0.28432169556617737,
0.5043927431106567,
-0.5526538491249084,
-0.4266904592514038,
-0.3541059195995331,
0.06998937577009201,
0.061707329005002975,
0.8999826312065125,
-1.005731463432312,
0.9509158134460449,
0.24785135686397552,
0.6908201575279236,
0.1225140243768692,
0.4458472430706024,
0.37449586391448975,
-0.5627233982086182,
-0.06753706932067871,
0.24157777428627014,
0.33802422881126404,
0.36398711800575256,
-0.2965744137763977,
0.6014710664749146,
0.2641308009624481,
-0.6803992986679077,
-0.9971629977226257,
-0.025006325915455818,
-0.5732123255729675,
0.26426318287849426,
0.3474443256855011,
-0.5257810950279236,
-0.2735346555709839,
-0.014497690834105015,
-0.006157584488391876,
0.17187581956386566,
-0.41492635011672974,
0.8421958088874817,
0.8038158416748047,
-0.3954618573188782,
0.09056171774864197,
-0.33886629343032837,
0.1324680894613266,
0.3301716148853302,
-0.402923047542572,
-0.09238608926534653,
0.7027618288993835,
0.4732329547405243,
0.6038376092910767,
0.35579320788383484,
-0.1996346116065979,
0.27562767267227173,
0.1816180795431137,
0.45419010519981384,
0.15973186492919922,
-0.5030148029327393,
-0.4297645390033722,
-0.0473996102809906,
0.22650396823883057,
-0.41023513674736023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05600v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05600v1
|
SpeechAlign: Aligning Speech Generation to Human Preferences
| 2024-04-08T15:21:17 | 2024-04-08T15:21:17 |
Dong Zhang, Zhaowei Li, Shimin Li, Xin Zhang, Pengyu Wang, Yaqian Zhou, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Speech language models have significantly advanced in generating realistic
speech, with neural codec language models standing out. However, the
integration of human feedback to align speech outputs to human preferences is
often neglected. This paper addresses this gap by first analyzing the
distribution gap in codec language models, highlighting how it leads to
discrepancies between the training and inference phases, which negatively
affects performance. Then we explore leveraging learning from human feedback to
bridge the distribution gap. We introduce SpeechAlign, an iterative
self-improvement strategy that aligns speech language models to human
preferences. SpeechAlign involves constructing a preference codec dataset
contrasting golden codec tokens against synthetic tokens, followed by
preference optimization to improve the codec language model. This cycle of
improvement is carried out iteratively to steadily convert weak models to
strong ones. Through both subjective and objective evaluations, we show that
SpeechAlign can bridge the distribution gap and facilitating continuous
self-improvement of the speech language model. Moreover, SpeechAlign exhibits
robust generalization capabilities and works for smaller models. Code and
models will be available at https://github.com/0nutation/SpeechGPT.
|
[
-0.1933417022228241,
0.03205674886703491,
0.1362273097038269,
-0.08044485002756119,
-0.09025824815034866,
-0.0013849037932232022,
-0.5046736598014832,
-0.030629271641373634,
0.04796251282095909,
0.24122989177703857,
-0.5287391543388367,
-0.5702279210090637,
-0.37867996096611023,
-0.30885595083236694,
0.00736602395772934,
0.8423037528991699,
0.36896464228630066,
0.2120750993490219,
-0.24535420536994934,
-0.2851049602031708,
-0.8053097128868103,
-0.5160618424415588,
-0.5988773107528687,
-0.6893383264541626,
0.38255172967910767,
0.5343364477157593,
0.8962500691413879,
0.9600929617881775,
0.21393820643424988,
0.312934935092926,
0.1984870880842209,
-0.16017337143421173,
-0.3690469563007355,
0.21859847009181976,
-0.041663508862257004,
-0.3175414204597473,
-0.31407585740089417,
0.003888985374942422,
0.5911033153533936,
0.7906855940818787,
-0.7614923119544983,
0.0032060404773801565,
0.1312914490699768,
0.8532686829566956,
-0.5333942770957947,
0.005549983121454716,
-0.591764509677887,
0.04186257719993591,
-0.4688554108142853,
0.0038230870850384235,
-0.2320931851863861,
-0.40284204483032227,
0.23163065314292908,
-0.4722728431224823,
0.5581933259963989,
-0.061377182602882385,
0.7046094536781311,
0.7944750189781189,
0.05604798346757889,
0.04441338777542114,
-0.7371365427970886,
0.7173306345939636,
-0.9442107677459717,
0.6037635207176208,
0.48581287264823914,
0.3873378038406372,
0.014056307263672352,
-0.4181958734989166,
-0.24193984270095825,
-0.04520261660218239,
0.2771151661872864,
0.07082505524158478,
-0.24964594841003418,
0.0764060765504837,
-0.2316902130842209,
0.1888158768415451,
-0.8512884378433228,
0.3083750307559967,
-0.27255600690841675,
-0.33144471049308777,
0.6862331628799438,
-0.083733931183815,
0.19337233901023865,
-0.2529928386211395,
-0.0768636018037796,
-0.3275422751903534,
-0.6389017701148987,
0.11898547410964966,
0.6277151703834534,
0.5382875800132751,
-0.1103864312171936,
0.3157956004142761,
-0.07038035988807678,
0.838193416595459,
0.3558529317378998,
-0.047391377389431,
0.4041437804698944,
-0.015538224950432777,
-0.059357717633247375,
0.7298746109008789,
0.73567795753479,
0.23478800058364868,
0.25182515382766724,
-0.16056780517101288,
-0.07787274569272995,
0.3550006151199341,
0.319293737411499,
-0.2540145516395569,
-0.4784829616546631,
0.16112390160560608,
-0.3715258240699768,
-0.3478924334049225,
-0.04401558265089989,
-0.45270270109176636,
-0.5522408485412598,
-0.45786359906196594,
0.18594492971897125,
-0.02449302189052105,
-0.6374884247779846,
0.38186338543891907,
-0.010381551459431648,
0.0619632825255394,
-0.01383481826633215,
-1.3702906370162964,
0.03925550729036331,
0.7361835241317749,
0.709318220615387,
-0.18702876567840576,
-0.06990770250558853,
-0.5205989480018616,
0.10582159459590912,
-0.3706592619419098,
0.9794022440910339,
-0.522674024105072,
-0.312895804643631,
-0.008489021100103855,
-0.3115774691104889,
-0.08104777336120605,
-0.872101902961731,
0.546031653881073,
-0.3085426688194275,
0.40084466338157654,
-0.037908006459474564,
-0.7102794647216797,
0.23271474242210388,
-0.04759050905704498,
-0.42203789949417114,
0.9035536050796509,
0.14023597538471222,
-0.6463245153427124,
0.43503060936927795,
-0.7276548743247986,
-0.29122576117515564,
0.18063846230506897,
-0.33701279759407043,
-0.4734534025192261,
-0.008062048815190792,
0.28151920437812805,
0.19157637655735016,
-0.06632111221551895,
0.5452781319618225,
-0.4626448154449463,
-0.18940319120883942,
0.3070966601371765,
-0.37783166766166687,
0.47598811984062195,
0.5074923038482666,
-0.560477614402771,
0.38449570536613464,
-0.5014905333518982,
0.14455516636371613,
-0.10305355489253998,
-0.40945297479629517,
-0.0889696553349495,
0.1217997670173645,
-0.15671087801456451,
-0.06481190025806427,
-0.010060817003250122,
-0.30755138397216797,
0.18746106326580048,
-0.7733234167098999,
0.8704259395599365,
0.9775069355964661,
-0.4012901484966278,
0.9890636801719666,
-0.19627735018730164,
0.6036956310272217,
0.06929212808609009,
0.15548130869865417,
0.01861289143562317,
-0.5190218687057495,
-0.6014149188995361,
0.13618877530097961,
0.7405456304550171,
0.2101231813430786,
-0.3768428564071655,
0.6001951098442078,
-0.37469375133514404,
-0.08213283121585846,
-1.1158767938613892,
0.2364574670791626,
0.20860043168067932,
0.6929495930671692,
0.09770464897155762,
-0.4021569490432739,
-0.5083346366882324,
-0.7594744563102722,
-0.2808508574962616,
-0.3715524673461914,
-0.19981078803539276,
0.04090619087219238,
-0.3525095283985138,
-0.04225892201066017,
0.9876646995544434,
-0.3900422155857086,
-0.3606953024864197,
-0.03771856427192688,
0.11047565937042236,
0.05172886699438095,
0.6776602268218994,
0.30654680728912354,
-0.6397220492362976,
-0.2501649260520935,
-0.20339329540729523,
-0.35318523645401,
-0.24995781481266022,
0.0983247235417366,
-0.2793422043323517,
0.23830045759677887,
0.37705299258232117,
-0.035582561045885086,
0.34703290462493896,
0.8829671144485474,
-0.23867927491664886,
0.23233725130558014,
-0.10941631346940994,
-0.12164755165576935,
-0.9288297295570374,
-0.16280074417591095,
0.05482502654194832,
-0.4668465554714203,
-0.5091311931610107,
-0.48346593976020813,
-0.21303924918174744,
-0.3651038706302643,
-0.2678217589855194,
0.39952942728996277,
-0.2143707424402237,
-0.32394570112228394,
-0.1634722650051117,
0.3616921007633209,
-0.09502477943897247,
0.24818594753742218,
-0.033428702503442764,
0.8860936760902405,
0.6555200219154358,
-0.5292507410049438,
0.2314692586660385,
0.2605266273021698,
-0.22519445419311523,
0.5324097871780396,
-0.6305700540542603,
0.28987935185432434,
-0.09402823448181152,
0.020273495465517044,
-1.118332028388977,
-0.44586822390556335,
0.4107358753681183,
-0.7066266536712646,
0.4160784184932709,
-0.23279574513435364,
0.03550562262535095,
-0.2078154981136322,
-0.011658153496682644,
0.4617037773132324,
0.6372305154800415,
-0.7460189461708069,
0.2853260636329651,
0.6143471002578735,
-0.18048888444900513,
-0.551219642162323,
-0.5122408270835876,
0.11630856990814209,
-0.22707878053188324,
-0.9396716356277466,
0.47400209307670593,
-0.18327176570892334,
-0.11016318202018738,
-0.001902999822050333,
-0.05219505354762077,
0.1355016529560089,
-0.19255714118480682,
0.23127056658267975,
-0.06972596049308777,
-0.3751353323459625,
0.6325010061264038,
-0.09761958569288254,
-0.4866931736469269,
-0.2529793083667755,
-0.7935888171195984,
0.6767117381095886,
-0.2253715544939041,
-0.3979485332965851,
-0.4923447072505951,
0.28561922907829285,
0.10152364522218704,
-0.27852222323417664,
0.11671409755945206,
0.6291632652282715,
-0.07107295095920563,
-0.02604859694838524,
-0.5585962533950806,
-0.20232592523097992,
-0.5327862501144409,
0.05331181734800339,
-0.18203070759773254,
-0.7964824438095093,
-0.007046667393296957,
-0.017882755026221275,
-0.001449118833988905,
0.261792927980423,
0.42548951506614685,
-0.1857784539461136,
1.524260401725769,
0.7190064191818237,
-0.3410648703575134,
0.6456784009933472,
-0.16263237595558167,
0.23786142468452454,
-0.58482426404953,
0.00842093676328659,
-0.561809778213501,
-0.46834424138069153,
-0.48969224095344543,
-0.17943134903907776,
0.20670102536678314,
0.08623792976140976,
-0.3375244438648224,
0.1889522820711136,
-0.8923934102058411,
0.37283989787101746,
0.774869978427887,
0.03214051574468613,
0.08680728822946548,
0.2856341302394867,
-0.12155697494745255,
-0.3831357955932617,
-0.9842829704284668,
-0.3874884843826294,
0.7853267192840576,
0.3307586908340454,
0.8671719431877136,
0.17241981625556946,
0.8795792460441589,
0.40669432282447815,
0.1935507208108902,
-0.7677492499351501,
0.07175352424383163,
-0.32831472158432007,
-0.40844807028770447,
-0.275507390499115,
-0.572686493396759,
-0.9675990343093872,
-0.11815448850393295,
0.0635644942522049,
-0.5982188582420349,
0.3447552025318146,
0.6676249504089355,
-0.5351359248161316,
-0.05336425080895424,
-0.8853551149368286,
1.0244581699371338,
-0.30208081007003784,
-0.26771649718284607,
-0.32066991925239563,
-0.7074099779129028,
0.05776016041636467,
0.34891632199287415,
0.06753675639629364,
-0.42674124240875244,
0.2512480914592743,
0.6923272609710693,
-0.3441443145275116,
0.7928292751312256,
-0.38550832867622375,
-0.0847371444106102,
0.07854898273944855,
-0.05536392331123352,
0.08543148636817932,
-0.06081986427307129,
-0.30476388335227966,
0.16073621809482574,
-0.39272287487983704,
-0.5639887452125549,
-0.6414892673492432,
0.7161000370979309,
-0.7952220439910889,
-0.6624435782432556,
-0.1813148856163025,
-0.32956936955451965,
-0.2824443578720093,
0.009722516871988773,
0.48327377438545227,
0.6348251700401306,
0.012209474109113216,
-0.07951391488313675,
0.6077817678451538,
-0.07117205858230591,
0.5727817416191101,
0.14575576782226562,
-0.05714592710137367,
-0.7064746022224426,
0.9352425336837769,
-0.10114942491054535,
0.29012203216552734,
-0.03731366619467735,
0.5749741196632385,
-0.795229971408844,
-0.3323665261268616,
-0.7181622385978699,
0.31247833371162415,
-0.6783685088157654,
-0.3519081175327301,
-0.23063267767429352,
-0.03483972325921059,
-0.94810551404953,
-0.17946617305278778,
-0.5178161859512329,
-0.3502362370491028,
-0.44509968161582947,
-0.07708093523979187,
0.2019052952528,
0.8473908305168152,
-0.49758777022361755,
0.6779547929763794,
-0.48539042472839355,
0.12701043486595154,
0.46984606981277466,
0.5138031840324402,
-0.11499202251434326,
-0.658074140548706,
-0.027047792449593544,
0.24731561541557312,
-0.3984830379486084,
-0.7384755611419678,
0.4968893826007843,
0.4275442957878113,
0.4204060733318329,
0.6643362045288086,
0.13014978170394897,
0.9710226058959961,
-0.39573076367378235,
0.840474009513855,
0.5757001042366028,
-1.020574927330017,
0.6102929711341858,
-0.3671343922615051,
0.6185278296470642,
0.5634916424751282,
0.056916166096925735,
-0.8889885544776917,
0.01616853103041649,
-0.6740081310272217,
-0.6975337862968445,
0.5713993906974792,
0.11987830698490143,
0.09183953702449799,
0.14223811030387878,
0.37364837527275085,
-0.1923668533563614,
0.19595858454704285,
-0.5901896953582764,
-0.20924684405326843,
-0.7598671317100525,
-0.5204654335975647,
-0.1340869814157486,
0.0989253968000412,
-0.2801823914051056,
-0.32892486453056335,
0.6978761553764343,
-0.3894469141960144,
0.2753029465675354,
0.05908237770199776,
-0.04885623976588249,
-0.2877677083015442,
0.2532253563404083,
0.7291461229324341,
0.598994255065918,
0.07267123460769653,
0.21199828386306763,
-0.34253549575805664,
-0.0530526265501976,
0.28662845492362976,
0.07030007988214493,
-0.02747114934027195,
0.07442054152488708,
-0.12140960246324539,
0.9919398427009583,
0.36752986907958984,
-0.24106186628341675,
0.5610669255256653,
-0.2947141230106354,
-0.1599685102701187,
-0.22590187191963196,
0.19025516510009766,
0.3808056116104126,
0.11209108680486679,
-0.027453964576125145,
0.46610546112060547,
0.11152413487434387,
-0.1199210062623024,
0.3232903480529785,
0.3389737010002136,
-0.7301496863365173,
-0.21892471611499786,
0.919894814491272,
0.3674056828022003,
-0.630081295967102,
0.8121026158332825,
-0.201724112033844,
-0.49358463287353516,
0.3823702335357666,
0.5629720687866211,
0.9825573563575745,
-0.5416431427001953,
0.5578199028968811,
0.3679425120353699,
-0.16279658675193787,
-0.23663093149662018,
-0.003953857813030481,
-0.3221372961997986,
-0.8113799691200256,
-0.3893938660621643,
-0.4569742977619171,
-0.07589061558246613,
-0.16191092133522034,
-0.6393447518348694,
0.2764846980571747,
-0.29968419671058655,
-0.46368762850761414,
0.08453300595283508,
-0.3411416709423065,
-0.5524978041648865,
-0.14252567291259766,
0.3415416181087494,
0.3467191457748413,
-0.7037131190299988,
0.8560200333595276,
0.3993586301803589,
-0.3211852014064789,
-1.093247413635254,
-0.011902449652552605,
0.1799967736005783,
-0.9818660020828247,
0.449128657579422,
0.21082773804664612,
-0.2113340198993683,
0.30651065707206726,
-0.6567239165306091,
-0.9612883925437927,
0.6288338303565979,
0.5782569646835327,
-0.733798086643219,
0.009758811444044113,
0.2983364462852478,
0.3843620717525482,
-0.5118393301963806,
-0.09822101891040802,
0.6596919894218445,
0.3812495768070221,
0.09301498532295227,
-0.7335999608039856,
-0.3142363429069519,
-0.09398385882377625,
0.286888986825943,
0.2480793595314026,
-0.38949835300445557,
0.27868643403053284,
-0.35476720333099365,
-0.5026103258132935,
-0.051132455468177795,
0.5483718514442444,
0.11406554281711578,
0.08368019014596939,
0.8430137634277344,
0.7768192887306213,
0.8183720111846924,
-0.1537339985370636,
0.6839142441749573,
-0.26959845423698425,
0.30173999071121216,
1.3587173223495483,
-0.17219918966293335,
0.7736091613769531,
0.24972189962863922,
-0.03237811475992203,
0.49470943212509155,
0.8481687903404236,
0.1948879063129425,
0.6492294669151306,
0.3131854236125946,
-0.4055033326148987,
-0.5627138614654541,
-0.3153385519981384,
-0.41481906175613403,
0.5239728093147278,
0.15441559255123138,
-0.14934566617012024,
-0.24713477492332458,
0.02827887050807476,
-0.14149954915046692,
0.212021142244339,
-0.1008581593632698,
1.0658000707626343,
0.07113590091466904,
-0.8802223801612854,
0.8638675212860107,
-0.26043805480003357,
0.6368680596351624,
-0.46216484904289246,
-0.034192390739917755,
-0.343191534280777,
0.3010510802268982,
-0.30355304479599,
-0.42270979285240173,
0.20095868408679962,
-0.10149721801280975,
-0.23756001889705658,
-0.334958553314209,
0.634972333908081,
-0.7286957502365112,
-0.11461382359266281,
0.15258486568927765,
0.01913844607770443,
0.09224619716405869,
-0.012732253409922123,
-1.0040940046310425,
0.055471036583185196,
0.15537098050117493,
0.21095186471939087,
0.20903414487838745,
0.06788891553878784,
0.15685686469078064,
0.5423754453659058,
0.6611907482147217,
0.2446431964635849,
0.2382345348596573,
0.75653076171875,
0.560497522354126,
-0.4597187340259552,
-0.6928321123123169,
-0.631659746170044,
0.571344792842865,
-0.09831075370311737,
-0.4407704770565033,
0.30419036746025085,
0.21832171082496643,
0.8786176443099976,
0.12429416179656982,
0.7541576623916626,
0.1811317801475525,
0.5545711517333984,
-0.29436925053596497,
0.6536681652069092,
-0.34666454792022705,
0.336683988571167,
-0.1522175818681717,
-0.7818319201469421,
-0.3162437975406647,
0.7500981688499451,
-0.3004065752029419,
-0.0022475935984402895,
0.29026228189468384,
1.0548958778381348,
-0.030278433114290237,
-0.16448834538459778,
0.44604602456092834,
-0.1754635125398636,
0.4153711497783661,
0.23176391422748566,
0.8896745443344116,
-0.32558754086494446,
0.6078069806098938,
-0.2719752788543701,
-0.10937000811100006,
-0.020111195743083954,
-0.8947399854660034,
-0.2724986970424652,
-0.6153228878974915,
-0.6050268411636353,
-0.37746429443359375,
0.17298616468906403,
1.022932529449463,
1.298285961151123,
-0.6657344102859497,
-0.5692320466041565,
-0.2123989462852478,
0.038736581802368164,
-0.17721816897392273,
-0.30577895045280457,
0.14441920816898346,
-0.7457699775695801,
-0.5160290598869324,
0.35320818424224854,
0.23907087743282318,
0.17284207046031952,
-0.4370180368423462,
-0.35518360137939453,
0.2801060974597931,
-0.2823260426521301,
0.1632162481546402,
0.4611777067184448,
-0.8932449817657471,
-0.1938771903514862,
0.14740166068077087,
0.08765871077775955,
0.573434591293335,
1.1743981838226318,
-0.8397184014320374,
0.776408314704895,
0.3555503487586975,
0.6678865551948547,
0.36506006121635437,
0.17337937653064728,
1.0168893337249756,
-1.0071065425872803,
-0.03299182653427124,
0.22144097089767456,
0.180839404463768,
0.8463956713676453,
-0.4076630771160126,
0.36829179525375366,
0.07432766258716583,
-0.8543972969055176,
-0.6614492535591125,
0.26319620013237,
-0.7611753940582275,
-0.17955268919467926,
0.9624580144882202,
0.1391705721616745,
-0.18770350515842438,
-0.12145427614450455,
-0.12574583292007446,
0.3473146855831146,
-0.7284396290779114,
0.9130982160568237,
0.4015866219997406,
-0.2360452115535736,
-0.17029839754104614,
-0.22570110857486725,
0.8114972114562988,
0.7037855982780457,
-0.5100911855697632,
0.24715541303157806,
0.45264166593551636,
0.4020965099334717,
0.12124967575073242,
0.8346737623214722,
-0.08332958817481995,
0.21085187792778015,
-0.22690041363239288,
0.2900676131248474,
0.42427968978881836,
-0.2950764000415802,
-0.9396167397499084,
-0.102909617125988,
0.30565977096557617,
-0.3477180004119873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05590v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05590v1
|
MedExpQA: Multilingual Benchmarking of Large Language Models for Medical Question Answering
| 2024-04-08T15:03:57 | 2024-04-08T15:03:57 |
Iñigo Alonso, Maite Oronoz, Rodrigo Agerri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have the potential of facilitating the
development of Artificial Intelligence technology to assist medical experts for
interactive decision support, which has been demonstrated by their competitive
performances in Medical QA. However, while impressive, the required quality bar
for medical applications remains far from being achieved. Currently, LLMs
remain challenged by outdated knowledge and by their tendency to generate
hallucinated content. Furthermore, most benchmarks to assess medical knowledge
lack reference gold explanations which means that it is not possible to
evaluate the reasoning of LLMs predictions. Finally, the situation is
particularly grim if we consider benchmarking LLMs for languages other than
English which remains, as far as we know, a totally neglected topic. In order
to address these shortcomings, in this paper we present MedExpQA, the first
multilingual benchmark based on medical exams to evaluate LLMs in Medical
Question Answering. To the best of our knowledge, MedExpQA includes for the
first time reference gold explanations written by medical doctors which can be
leveraged to establish various gold-based upper-bounds for comparison with LLMs
performance. Comprehensive multilingual experimentation using both the gold
reference explanations and Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) approaches show
that performance of LLMs still has large room for improvement, especially for
languages other than English. Furthermore, and despite using state-of-the-art
RAG methods, our results also demonstrate the difficulty of obtaining and
integrating readily available medical knowledge that may positively impact
results on downstream evaluations for Medical Question Answering. So far the
benchmark is available in four languages, but we hope that this work may
encourage further development to other languages.
|
[
-0.3128030300140381,
-0.5477315783500671,
0.8552709221839905,
0.04552021995186806,
-0.20501817762851715,
0.10013832896947861,
-0.18302394449710846,
-0.46148058772087097,
0.10973995923995972,
0.43066129088401794,
-0.7112732529640198,
-0.39604589343070984,
-0.5732107162475586,
0.3982587158679962,
0.14828164875507355,
0.8097487688064575,
-0.35395529866218567,
0.6166635155677795,
-0.4502457082271576,
-0.5656545758247375,
-0.1384507268667221,
-0.8184939622879028,
-0.5696261525154114,
-0.44952577352523804,
0.6733977794647217,
0.18760696053504944,
0.6711580157279968,
0.4118919372558594,
0.5522149205207825,
0.23772118985652924,
-0.0888841301202774,
0.47731202840805054,
0.0352877676486969,
0.02601083554327488,
-0.2180013507604599,
-0.5603120923042297,
-0.3202797472476959,
-0.06265184283256531,
0.6644951701164246,
0.903540313243866,
-0.10550159215927124,
0.17743755877017975,
-0.2810599207878113,
0.8094846606254578,
-0.49088841676712036,
0.09203851968050003,
-0.5205905437469482,
0.11882846802473068,
-0.1462201178073883,
-0.3785039782524109,
-0.1416904628276825,
-0.3545437157154083,
-0.12154029309749603,
-0.44446393847465515,
-0.024989860132336617,
0.04244956374168396,
0.7712756991386414,
0.47487762570381165,
-0.6037212014198303,
-0.1821853220462799,
-0.453104168176651,
0.7102684378623962,
-0.8985386490821838,
0.48737359046936035,
0.24875444173812866,
0.5815351605415344,
-0.09113959968090057,
-0.8759258389472961,
-0.5737261176109314,
-0.22314809262752533,
0.15255841612815857,
0.16111108660697937,
-0.10078223049640656,
-0.0566246323287487,
0.12857770919799805,
0.3653266727924347,
-0.7564302086830139,
-0.027635104954242706,
-0.2886313199996948,
-0.1571526676416397,
0.4945048391819,
0.16666634380817413,
0.20053128898143768,
0.12631691992282867,
-0.2637570798397064,
0.03583526611328125,
-0.9378200173377991,
-0.1265833079814911,
-0.10198983550071716,
0.0878334566950798,
-0.12960071861743927,
0.5492043495178223,
-0.1277453750371933,
0.5314463973045349,
-0.3626236915588379,
-0.30030542612075806,
0.6454955339431763,
-0.25514525175094604,
-0.05403082072734833,
-0.3048498034477234,
0.7043282985687256,
0.3572518229484558,
0.32042619585990906,
-0.21314910054206848,
0.12053819745779037,
0.03346904367208481,
0.008374880068004131,
-0.7014918923377991,
-0.0862930417060852,
0.4151376485824585,
-0.548675000667572,
0.22111468017101288,
-0.3144952952861786,
-0.7410222291946411,
-0.5134086012840271,
-0.09467847645282745,
0.36072564125061035,
-0.07927483320236206,
-0.1861106902360916,
0.2209099382162094,
0.19488386809825897,
0.16375073790550232,
0.19585926830768585,
-0.44467785954475403,
0.4166018068790436,
0.6416518092155457,
0.518506646156311,
-0.27875372767448425,
-0.3672032356262207,
-0.6116450428962708,
-0.07459822297096252,
-0.3885475993156433,
0.914668083190918,
-0.37938618659973145,
-0.024830367416143417,
0.04914919659495354,
0.16964107751846313,
-0.05906040221452713,
-0.9106419086456299,
0.6819267868995667,
-0.4492120146751404,
0.30796584486961365,
-0.2673739492893219,
-0.5808947682380676,
-0.325475811958313,
0.4686199426651001,
-0.5156248211860657,
0.8434246182441711,
0.0836958959698677,
-0.6535444855690002,
0.2287224978208542,
-0.39776742458343506,
-0.28233546018600464,
0.23895296454429626,
-0.5163097977638245,
-0.35701149702072144,
-0.007707963231950998,
0.4645712673664093,
0.31131765246391296,
-0.7176048755645752,
0.3345837891101837,
-0.21628890931606293,
-0.21464882791042328,
0.42357468605041504,
-0.5751984715461731,
0.554791271686554,
0.17709560692310333,
-0.159645676612854,
-0.02756592445075512,
-0.6060576438903809,
0.4176260232925415,
0.1654706597328186,
-0.38418126106262207,
-0.22698500752449036,
-0.023617520928382874,
-0.0805283710360527,
0.5754641890525818,
0.1435542106628418,
-0.4576384425163269,
-0.04337975010275841,
-0.5031473636627197,
0.25383874773979187,
0.3385190963745117,
0.11109911650419235,
-0.20676057040691376,
-0.577214241027832,
0.8658581376075745,
-0.1487777680158615,
0.15721942484378815,
-0.106838159263134,
-0.6212989091873169,
-0.46090567111968994,
-0.14134064316749573,
0.5661429762840271,
0.7248793840408325,
-0.845985472202301,
-0.17735449969768524,
-0.2639023959636688,
-0.28931573033332825,
-0.8975697159767151,
0.25703132152557373,
0.54057776927948,
0.3800625503063202,
0.43131309747695923,
-0.20622746646404266,
-0.3776271343231201,
-1.1073110103607178,
-0.625170111656189,
-0.35355252027511597,
-0.04959779605269432,
0.6292857527732849,
0.45375096797943115,
-0.2236618846654892,
0.29398107528686523,
-0.15071076154708862,
-0.14094187319278717,
-0.22387543320655823,
-0.15039607882499695,
0.4798245131969452,
0.1965099722146988,
0.5470300316810608,
-0.9390006065368652,
-0.40432190895080566,
0.04225333780050278,
-0.5235903263092041,
-0.4205998182296753,
0.014035716652870178,
0.038294099271297455,
0.2192854881286621,
0.5648804903030396,
-0.4729617238044739,
-0.05159628763794899,
1.0482146739959717,
-0.2753865122795105,
0.6155186891555786,
-0.40288805961608887,
0.38367053866386414,
-1.067658543586731,
0.25771579146385193,
-0.03772604838013649,
-0.25911563634872437,
-0.4978707730770111,
0.31456324458122253,
0.29286110401153564,
0.07920973002910614,
-0.5637553930282593,
0.9730758666992188,
-0.37280550599098206,
0.05440506711602211,
-0.22019098699092865,
0.23090317845344543,
0.09662912040948868,
0.4109064042568207,
-0.06176314875483513,
0.7817031741142273,
0.2669404149055481,
-0.42111730575561523,
0.2908485531806946,
0.25828132033348083,
-0.34421706199645996,
0.5614017248153687,
-0.6751067638397217,
-0.20683835446834564,
-0.0360824391245842,
0.044365569949150085,
-0.9382449388504028,
0.03128325939178467,
0.14565926790237427,
-0.5267021656036377,
0.2701687812805176,
-0.27518314123153687,
-0.7988060116767883,
-0.46052905917167664,
0.05007509887218475,
0.5504563450813293,
0.45815712213516235,
-0.4906686246395111,
0.5317690968513489,
0.458667516708374,
-0.48022598028182983,
-0.7108665704727173,
-0.6069080829620361,
0.24681253731250763,
-0.1749827265739441,
-0.48557382822036743,
0.25843051075935364,
-0.4482140839099884,
-0.43154823780059814,
-0.2832813858985901,
-0.23895777761936188,
-0.3037148118019104,
0.038126878440380096,
-0.006734899245202541,
0.2708938717842102,
-0.3268633484840393,
0.4465964138507843,
0.12761753797531128,
-0.27429333329200745,
0.3847402036190033,
0.014622055925428867,
0.35795217752456665,
-0.10711749643087387,
-0.6453831195831299,
-0.1435302495956421,
0.5071489214897156,
0.8029253482818604,
-0.43944311141967773,
0.6863396167755127,
0.27894747257232666,
-0.4144521951675415,
0.08316226303577423,
-0.8750969171524048,
0.0194710660725832,
-0.3886578679084778,
0.536779522895813,
-0.48153236508369446,
-0.7475234866142273,
0.481021523475647,
-0.43963226675987244,
0.3275299370288849,
0.5885639786720276,
0.7798888087272644,
0.04492955654859543,
1.3744781017303467,
0.3717968165874481,
0.14539165794849396,
-0.24792462587356567,
0.25643229484558105,
-0.14037588238716125,
-0.7012641429901123,
-0.23753425478935242,
-0.6932101845741272,
-0.04952988773584366,
-0.6510389447212219,
-0.6014057993888855,
0.7822965979576111,
-0.16246739029884338,
-0.1426323801279068,
-0.3304094970226288,
-0.12651017308235168,
0.41847652196884155,
0.3728508949279785,
0.07476707547903061,
0.48227766156196594,
-0.14979802072048187,
-0.4985255300998688,
-0.24371938407421112,
-0.9406519532203674,
-0.469271183013916,
1.0666189193725586,
0.44092831015586853,
0.6479865312576294,
0.12651613354682922,
0.41199883818626404,
-0.05202370136976242,
0.39825835824012756,
-0.6164717674255371,
0.3235199451446533,
-0.31969353556632996,
-0.701525092124939,
0.1267152577638626,
-0.613014817237854,
-0.9688661694526672,
0.5334128737449646,
-0.3396908938884735,
-0.3284178674221039,
-0.23960241675376892,
-0.05437495559453964,
-0.39910995960235596,
0.2740619480609894,
-0.48761186003685,
0.8922213315963745,
-0.40800583362579346,
-0.3393356204032898,
-0.0025531023275107145,
-0.7337366342544556,
0.21476984024047852,
-0.2226402759552002,
0.5766485929489136,
-0.17714928090572357,
-0.32662370800971985,
0.6386516690254211,
-0.39471349120140076,
0.5283759832382202,
-0.03705884516239166,
-0.18947993218898773,
-0.19215382635593414,
-0.12776853144168854,
0.19174785912036896,
0.18245470523834229,
-0.21962982416152954,
0.18611466884613037,
0.5371550917625427,
-0.5135184526443481,
-0.45800313353538513,
0.6235613226890564,
-0.5684417486190796,
-0.5710774064064026,
-0.3968989849090576,
-0.6372746229171753,
-0.6729668974876404,
0.16824983060359955,
0.07308316975831985,
0.34453099966049194,
0.028210150077939034,
-0.04218233376741409,
0.7365930080413818,
-0.6279401779174805,
0.03707676753401756,
0.8589103817939758,
-0.26464372873306274,
-0.4143033027648926,
0.5413522124290466,
-0.03181111067533493,
0.13733695447444916,
0.4027850329875946,
0.31858766078948975,
-0.4815188944339752,
-0.7367748022079468,
-0.7604078054428101,
0.7583520412445068,
-0.831093430519104,
-0.10076064616441727,
-0.6795916557312012,
-0.20770896971225739,
-0.10870473831892014,
0.14627015590667725,
-0.3371017575263977,
-0.3981824517250061,
0.18569859862327576,
0.2934461236000061,
0.2313271164894104,
0.5139418244361877,
0.04320855066180229,
-0.2306339591741562,
-1.1341890096664429,
0.5547563433647156,
0.20028284192085266,
0.5852829217910767,
-0.234344482421875,
-0.5255619287490845,
-0.2455979734659195,
-0.06448999792337418,
0.013864822685718536,
-0.9196382164955139,
0.33077189326286316,
0.17452877759933472,
0.9796583652496338,
0.19360384345054626,
0.03703964501619339,
0.6408311724662781,
-0.7808951139450073,
0.6817333698272705,
-0.1009313315153122,
-0.6075026392936707,
0.28952330350875854,
-0.02909565530717373,
0.5628401637077332,
0.7128910422325134,
0.5114285945892334,
-0.8082394599914551,
-0.44076165556907654,
-0.48652195930480957,
-0.825955331325531,
0.27297964692115784,
-0.06411387771368027,
0.06480801105499268,
-0.08386028558015823,
0.5945777893066406,
0.29664918780326843,
0.2699478566646576,
-0.664794385433197,
-0.5919818878173828,
0.4818696975708008,
-0.2492780238389969,
-0.2788841426372528,
-0.24719637632369995,
-0.31657543778419495,
-0.14185449481010437,
0.7988978028297424,
-0.2744704782962799,
0.025842269882559776,
0.19266937673091888,
0.015548684634268284,
-0.1669130027294159,
0.38023239374160767,
0.6024605631828308,
1.009592056274414,
0.14717701077461243,
0.14280416071414948,
0.47570186853408813,
-0.42238762974739075,
0.014885137788951397,
0.4540490508079529,
0.09101809561252594,
0.2575649917125702,
0.3573495149612427,
0.31109994649887085,
0.05164296180009842,
-1.2859851121902466,
0.5530548095703125,
-0.32078123092651367,
-0.3309894800186157,
-0.37261927127838135,
-0.2602623999118805,
0.18850241601467133,
0.47939249873161316,
0.4307246506214142,
-0.20448514819145203,
0.028026839718222618,
-0.4187893569469452,
0.23710086941719055,
0.5965521931648254,
-0.3570626378059387,
0.028237810358405113,
0.8412765860557556,
0.036230042576789856,
-0.08174656331539154,
0.3247331380844116,
0.12420013546943665,
-0.5935639142990112,
0.5469784140586853,
0.33974236249923706,
0.37867504358291626,
-0.31839606165885925,
-0.051975835114717484,
0.40589648485183716,
0.44023263454437256,
0.0622640922665596,
0.7595566511154175,
0.28884294629096985,
-0.462581604719162,
-0.8484972715377808,
-0.39017435908317566,
-0.7384839057922363,
0.3183607757091522,
-0.4873875081539154,
0.04348551854491234,
-0.07493098080158234,
0.002627829322591424,
0.06470659375190735,
0.2830561697483063,
-0.5949528217315674,
0.3511497378349304,
0.2717408239841461,
1.1428298950195312,
-0.7312567830085754,
0.6447294354438782,
0.9425365328788757,
-0.0019880246836692095,
-0.6242036819458008,
-0.12349484860897064,
0.024121319875121117,
-0.9253561496734619,
0.31937432289123535,
0.14697663486003876,
0.1206708699464798,
-0.27357593178749084,
-0.33245033025741577,
-0.670166552066803,
0.6797727346420288,
0.43573006987571716,
-0.31627383828163147,
-0.022506926208734512,
0.16945867240428925,
0.6609557867050171,
-0.27859216928482056,
0.29246020317077637,
0.45525842905044556,
0.5394360423088074,
-0.03880880028009415,
-1.1434423923492432,
0.02708347514271736,
-0.6677254438400269,
-0.40825870633125305,
0.22865194082260132,
-0.49731141328811646,
0.8478149771690369,
-0.34550589323043823,
-0.048356689512729645,
0.41272953152656555,
0.17425696551799774,
0.4499424397945404,
0.3370923101902008,
0.3136269450187683,
0.4186294972896576,
0.7197719812393188,
-0.12635432183742523,
1.1829798221588135,
-0.5301754474639893,
0.10844375193119049,
1.0634647607803345,
-0.379874587059021,
0.9187535643577576,
0.640049397945404,
-0.33490103483200073,
0.42299678921699524,
0.6316518187522888,
0.14653582870960236,
0.2507687509059906,
0.3183545172214508,
-0.4092831611633301,
-0.4310496747493744,
-0.04765739291906357,
-0.6188216209411621,
0.2645879089832306,
0.4658244550228119,
-0.4974765479564667,
-0.2204107940196991,
0.03850221633911133,
0.004847007803618908,
0.12101440876722336,
-0.3429108262062073,
0.8229669332504272,
0.07748515903949738,
-0.733291506767273,
0.8237996101379395,
0.04249010235071182,
0.3367971181869507,
-0.778408408164978,
-0.26618441939353943,
-0.2909374535083771,
0.25610876083374023,
-0.03904484584927559,
-0.6411836743354797,
0.10880456864833832,
-0.02154381573200226,
-0.09473150968551636,
0.0736667737364769,
0.2918602526187897,
-0.5848290920257568,
-0.504103422164917,
0.18913187086582184,
1.011086344718933,
0.5693618059158325,
-0.10911200195550919,
-0.9158444404602051,
-0.1398104727268219,
-0.16812893748283386,
-0.08651462197303772,
0.3725323975086212,
0.49014580249786377,
-0.04608805477619171,
0.9224443435668945,
0.44680067896842957,
0.3943440914154053,
-0.0009833368239924312,
0.23793146014213562,
0.7815054059028625,
-0.4379335939884186,
-0.3612450361251831,
-0.8026320338249207,
0.2954491078853607,
0.21304866671562195,
-0.23132215440273285,
0.5818260312080383,
0.5637037754058838,
0.7012624144554138,
0.07604878395795822,
0.7656240463256836,
0.3413222134113312,
0.9916844964027405,
-0.6188570857048035,
0.7327545285224915,
-1.0546098947525024,
0.20079559087753296,
-0.19783072173595428,
-0.722245454788208,
-0.5516765117645264,
0.32771337032318115,
0.006065118592232466,
0.20608478784561157,
0.9075549244880676,
0.600958526134491,
0.11013993620872498,
-0.18659895658493042,
0.4990553855895996,
0.2288707196712494,
-0.03394924849271774,
0.8801398277282715,
0.6824997067451477,
-0.535545825958252,
0.7224907875061035,
-0.1777864247560501,
-0.2844441831111908,
-0.04338735714554787,
-0.7835622429847717,
-0.8224497437477112,
-0.5245345234870911,
-0.34834954142570496,
-0.37844136357307434,
0.16652154922485352,
0.9727337956428528,
0.5909490585327148,
-0.8423935770988464,
-0.019754566252231598,
0.4239864647388458,
0.011909082531929016,
-0.47531041502952576,
-0.09010668098926544,
0.46222248673439026,
-0.09813380241394043,
-0.7418631315231323,
0.44437655806541443,
0.15991030633449554,
-0.0362548865377903,
-0.24328047037124634,
-0.13573229312896729,
-0.21853262186050415,
0.12228609621524811,
0.4720366597175598,
0.5029491782188416,
-0.8330594897270203,
0.10272610932588577,
0.09496797621250153,
-0.13146349787712097,
0.28685876727104187,
0.7457991242408752,
-0.8830748796463013,
0.48104798793792725,
0.1955241709947586,
0.946864664554596,
0.2217452973127365,
-0.11610816419124603,
0.503082275390625,
-0.5260188579559326,
-0.14531169831752777,
0.3597642183303833,
0.5513019561767578,
0.30058589577674866,
0.010071330703794956,
0.5280022621154785,
0.002382456324994564,
-0.5818398594856262,
-0.690899133682251,
0.1294451206922531,
-0.694636881351471,
-0.5090024471282959,
1.1958578824996948,
-0.24128329753875732,
-0.08438972383737564,
-0.3954256474971771,
-0.3310246765613556,
0.1604941487312317,
0.18089060485363007,
0.8394055366516113,
0.6291196346282959,
-0.050497666001319885,
-0.4602736234664917,
-0.97850501537323,
0.39565509557724,
0.8003639578819275,
-1.1646655797958374,
0.1547984629869461,
0.3900271952152252,
0.2975119650363922,
-0.04420356824994087,
0.7638200521469116,
-0.5431132316589355,
0.6708994507789612,
-0.22103647887706757,
-0.015250883996486664,
0.09325305372476578,
-0.23743394017219543,
-0.5083650350570679,
0.09994252026081085,
0.2520677447319031,
0.07156126946210861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05587v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05587v2
|
Enhancing Software-Related Information Extraction via Single-Choice Question Answering with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-08T15:00:36 | 2024-04-19T23:19:17 |
Wolfgang Otto, Sharmila Upadhyaya, Stefan Dietze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
This paper describes our participation in the Shared Task on Software
Mentions Disambiguation (SOMD), with a focus on improving relation extraction
in scholarly texts through generative Large Language Models (LLMs) using
single-choice question-answering. The methodology prioritises the use of
in-context learning capabilities of GLMs to extract software-related entities
and their descriptive attributes, such as distributive information. Our
approach uses Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) techniques and GLMs for
Named Entity Recognition (NER) and Attributive NER to identify relationships
between extracted software entities, providing a structured solution for
analysing software citations in academic literature. The paper provides a
detailed description of our approach, demonstrating how using GLMs in a
single-choice QA paradigm can greatly enhance IE methodologies. Our
participation in the SOMD shared task highlights the importance of precise
software citation practices and showcases our system's ability to overcome the
challenges of disambiguating and extracting relationships between software
mentions. This sets the groundwork for future research and development in this
field.
|
[
-0.5878373384475708,
-0.5552871227264404,
0.740177571773529,
-0.04877973720431328,
-0.20432284474372864,
0.16496384143829346,
-0.042249344289302826,
-0.4973389804363251,
0.10221048444509506,
0.7162818312644958,
-0.5163836479187012,
-0.39961349964141846,
-0.48059409856796265,
0.2001512050628662,
-0.3643796145915985,
1.2113617658615112,
-0.02829810604453087,
0.18649592995643616,
-0.576641321182251,
-0.3718203604221344,
-0.2113165706396103,
-0.43009987473487854,
-0.5184648633003235,
-0.24893860518932343,
0.838666558265686,
0.3462695777416229,
0.5996514558792114,
0.30208829045295715,
0.8796526789665222,
0.16158892214298248,
-0.031379904597997665,
0.03997418284416199,
-0.22481730580329895,
0.3378622531890869,
-0.36007899045944214,
-0.2433902770280838,
-0.4163815975189209,
0.0005829197471030056,
0.5854238867759705,
0.6069138050079346,
-0.05054375156760216,
0.7641753554344177,
0.22091330587863922,
0.5178143382072449,
-0.5546759963035583,
0.20554374158382416,
-0.618349015712738,
-0.15770752727985382,
-0.4412156343460083,
-0.3915233016014099,
-0.44600722193717957,
-0.27073580026626587,
0.25800377130508423,
-0.8633345365524292,
0.14877866208553314,
0.17279937863349915,
1.0220295190811157,
0.3702101707458496,
-0.08443519473075867,
-0.5650280714035034,
-0.7317821979522705,
0.8832997679710388,
-0.5218585133552551,
0.193097323179245,
0.24451884627342224,
0.31868159770965576,
-0.364675372838974,
-0.8176808953285217,
-0.3415181636810303,
-0.25624942779541016,
0.024560388177633286,
0.13174834847450256,
-0.10611459612846375,
-0.049599021673202515,
0.3263443410396576,
0.3788839876651764,
-0.3672366738319397,
-0.09439154714345932,
-0.5667476058006287,
-0.028294432908296585,
0.6905812621116638,
-0.08881726861000061,
0.5726526975631714,
-0.17047014832496643,
-0.5578598976135254,
0.46099773049354553,
-1.0249028205871582,
-0.24618160724639893,
0.08159860223531723,
0.36357152462005615,
0.28197115659713745,
0.5994069576263428,
0.3527566194534302,
0.6557492017745972,
-0.4003039300441742,
-0.07893407344818115,
0.24171729385852814,
-0.4352231025695801,
-0.24939048290252686,
-0.14813949167728424,
0.6452325582504272,
0.00027030412456952035,
-0.11579691618680954,
-0.5364393591880798,
0.036562588065862656,
-0.0899699404835701,
0.23520848155021667,
-0.5362207293510437,
-0.05978744849562645,
0.32834476232528687,
-0.5280241370201111,
-0.2132488638162613,
0.35763293504714966,
-0.7581369280815125,
-0.49484536051750183,
-0.3197583854198456,
0.5986835956573486,
-0.33247748017311096,
-0.3950778841972351,
-0.1809292584657669,
-0.5697252154350281,
0.2275877445936203,
0.398835152387619,
-0.4971303343772888,
0.37920305132865906,
0.6977808475494385,
0.5513232946395874,
-0.527373731136322,
-0.4290936589241028,
-0.7918158769607544,
0.5220258831977844,
0.015684593468904495,
0.5696907639503479,
-0.5781237483024597,
-0.3309420049190521,
-0.16685131192207336,
-0.15296690165996552,
0.2930336892604828,
-0.964637815952301,
0.11343753337860107,
-0.9573007822036743,
0.30099284648895264,
-0.41906267404556274,
-0.6113659143447876,
0.07768450677394867,
0.2277568280696869,
-0.8076835870742798,
1.333660364151001,
0.28826165199279785,
-1.168473482131958,
0.35082972049713135,
-0.795950710773468,
-0.15670764446258545,
0.4173734486103058,
-0.5932902693748474,
-0.1664736270904541,
0.005319550167769194,
-0.103241927921772,
0.35345739126205444,
-0.7393215298652649,
0.4580641984939575,
-0.4594251811504364,
-0.2371300756931305,
0.12680961191654205,
0.1343405544757843,
1.0479689836502075,
0.354582816362381,
-0.14088934659957886,
0.2781054675579071,
-0.7738245725631714,
-0.2421320378780365,
0.11487362533807755,
-0.4407349228858948,
-0.7600634694099426,
-0.06615888327360153,
-0.08741683512926102,
0.14355160295963287,
0.3291647136211395,
-0.6386433243751526,
0.4697398245334625,
-0.08116147667169571,
0.1487797647714615,
0.5106949210166931,
0.23590624332427979,
0.4868311583995819,
0.0005306230159476399,
0.6573889255523682,
0.0470157153904438,
0.1259748488664627,
0.13894090056419373,
-0.34264689683914185,
-0.35980790853500366,
-0.4618106484413147,
0.5616062879562378,
0.34274330735206604,
-1.2192672491073608,
0.026408806443214417,
-0.23884530365467072,
-0.3096937835216522,
-0.6355746984481812,
0.24768929183483124,
0.31518688797950745,
0.41965436935424805,
0.5039811730384827,
-0.31898394227027893,
-0.7717781066894531,
-0.5472350716590881,
-0.19805440306663513,
-0.3302922248840332,
-0.3601727783679962,
0.4158318042755127,
0.46001359820365906,
-0.13864241540431976,
1.3669079542160034,
-0.875245988368988,
-0.08165345340967178,
-0.2903953492641449,
0.20259031653404236,
-0.003721945220604539,
0.03432457521557808,
0.39612507820129395,
-1.1483054161071777,
-0.6104599833488464,
-0.1832515001296997,
-0.9497770071029663,
-0.06349198520183563,
0.1448129266500473,
-0.22206473350524902,
-0.09435529261827469,
0.6905390024185181,
-0.4262636601924896,
0.14246046543121338,
0.10608936846256256,
-0.10567200928926468,
0.7181361317634583,
-0.1464192271232605,
-0.048226241022348404,
-1.1045379638671875,
0.2687213718891144,
-0.038623809814453125,
0.010361596941947937,
-0.47946271300315857,
0.4983974099159241,
0.02918902039527893,
0.026439348235726357,
-0.4836733341217041,
0.6549713611602783,
-0.8112082481384277,
-0.4756515622138977,
-0.20317363739013672,
0.5086489915847778,
-0.07503309100866318,
0.030497746542096138,
-0.17919304966926575,
1.0206352472305298,
0.7011357545852661,
-0.7356293201446533,
0.3024434447288513,
0.18396461009979248,
-0.02206272818148136,
0.4050872325897217,
-0.45231327414512634,
-0.014336912892758846,
-0.20484930276870728,
-0.04393209144473076,
-0.6111484169960022,
0.013053619302809238,
0.19745756685733795,
-0.4434364438056946,
0.26670897006988525,
-0.2080499827861786,
-0.5253713726997375,
-0.27537721395492554,
-0.36633577942848206,
0.03690005838871002,
0.21448297798633575,
-0.5349786877632141,
0.5296273231506348,
0.8420286774635315,
-0.5717543363571167,
-0.6354920268058777,
-0.3397556245326996,
0.043827760964632034,
-0.3313908874988556,
-0.389414519071579,
0.5527498126029968,
-0.15659567713737488,
-0.558440625667572,
0.15019124746322632,
-0.28859028220176697,
-0.2692560851573944,
0.41739314794540405,
0.1881888210773468,
0.878230094909668,
-0.1585618406534195,
0.553950846195221,
-0.15840283036231995,
-0.13755621016025543,
0.07708196341991425,
-0.1921895444393158,
0.34339308738708496,
0.18268734216690063,
-0.07248660176992416,
0.38448089361190796,
0.5212959051132202,
0.3416998088359833,
-0.45022717118263245,
0.7006415128707886,
0.5680724382400513,
-0.23991623520851135,
-0.07556664198637009,
-0.26978203654289246,
-0.08556624501943588,
-0.3832666873931885,
0.18656384944915771,
-0.4242475628852844,
-1.1997828483581543,
0.47065478563308716,
-0.23161444067955017,
0.2455425262451172,
0.5913882851600647,
0.19496476650238037,
-0.18649448454380035,
0.5729296207427979,
0.8593335747718811,
-0.4269980192184448,
0.39286598563194275,
-0.12381856888532639,
-0.01929536834359169,
-1.1249842643737793,
0.10157416015863419,
-0.8548719882965088,
0.1615094542503357,
-0.2835640609264374,
-0.4391669034957886,
0.3829616904258728,
0.28942447900772095,
-0.2163110375404358,
0.25668665766716003,
-0.4975675046443939,
0.2679460942745209,
0.5536283850669861,
-0.11124562472105026,
0.4085327982902527,
0.07218169420957565,
-0.12359925359487534,
0.014228034764528275,
-0.3903611898422241,
-0.6852227449417114,
1.1850485801696777,
0.13627658784389496,
0.5669452548027039,
0.249813973903656,
0.9624090790748596,
0.2874493896961212,
0.6167194843292236,
-0.5766144394874573,
0.6985636353492737,
0.013265621848404408,
-0.7869147658348083,
-0.48481687903404236,
-0.48932206630706787,
-0.9975790977478027,
0.16085350513458252,
-0.04854348674416542,
-0.8922574520111084,
-0.19984067976474762,
-0.07889091968536377,
-0.47524169087409973,
0.016142964363098145,
-0.29369300603866577,
0.7779345512390137,
0.06596061587333679,
-0.3575562834739685,
-0.026302194222807884,
-0.8327710032463074,
0.06100508198142052,
0.039560142904520035,
0.3214939534664154,
0.08631020784378052,
-0.1515405774116516,
0.7188671231269836,
0.02096790261566639,
0.25000613927841187,
-0.3004097640514374,
-0.24259451031684875,
0.41181835532188416,
-0.17352022230625153,
0.38315197825431824,
-0.03653809800744057,
-0.3139468729496002,
0.12125442177057266,
0.10545393079519272,
-0.22177951037883759,
-0.5334347486495972,
0.6494928598403931,
-0.7068066000938416,
-0.6100655794143677,
-0.5903614163398743,
-0.6674938797950745,
-0.25841742753982544,
0.3303477466106415,
0.13394781947135925,
0.26552560925483704,
-0.22644366323947906,
0.12842269241809845,
0.7636930346488953,
-0.2182133048772812,
0.39547738432884216,
0.5724539160728455,
-0.6361031532287598,
-0.29945918917655945,
0.9412851333618164,
0.30159229040145874,
0.19632214307785034,
0.3340313732624054,
-0.07135356962680817,
-0.12710899114608765,
-0.5739063620567322,
-0.5378902554512024,
0.34479591250419617,
-0.5538920164108276,
-0.1459139585494995,
-0.7082592248916626,
-0.20685572922229767,
-0.290851354598999,
0.11841433495283127,
0.02080145850777626,
-0.22280752658843994,
-0.5399816036224365,
-0.0583764910697937,
0.2330043911933899,
0.7753883600234985,
0.41322222352027893,
-0.3012300133705139,
-1.0199459791183472,
0.4251403510570526,
0.041386112570762634,
0.1261778473854065,
-0.07144267857074738,
-0.35469889640808105,
-0.24441586434841156,
-0.31917276978492737,
-0.19374074041843414,
-1.1307456493377686,
0.16327516734600067,
-0.0499655120074749,
0.7919883728027344,
0.02264256402850151,
0.35832178592681885,
0.686039388179779,
-0.5809818506240845,
0.9599823355674744,
0.18680700659751892,
-0.6111667156219482,
0.5929386615753174,
-0.24853534996509552,
0.16174907982349396,
0.745542585849762,
0.8357052803039551,
-0.21487106382846832,
-0.4279245138168335,
-0.741881787776947,
-0.9552279114723206,
0.5825817584991455,
0.061682410538196564,
-0.1610913723707199,
0.12855811417102814,
0.38652852177619934,
0.2692919969558716,
0.471129834651947,
-0.7033886909484863,
-0.5970923900604248,
0.5475962162017822,
-0.12447713315486908,
0.0496772900223732,
-0.33499807119369507,
-0.24715973436832428,
-0.17869015038013458,
0.9857017397880554,
-0.1135326698422432,
0.07904659956693649,
0.1718786358833313,
-0.20882153511047363,
0.17950832843780518,
0.610549807548523,
0.27297377586364746,
0.8225197196006775,
-0.14438025653362274,
0.41914960741996765,
0.10863126814365387,
-0.5737636685371399,
-0.059409406036138535,
0.26281440258026123,
-0.5167900919914246,
0.21184034645557404,
-0.15997174382209778,
0.23723450303077698,
-0.06792716681957245,
-0.4751918613910675,
0.32788047194480896,
0.04011566564440727,
0.11882021278142929,
-0.3253539204597473,
0.013295944780111313,
0.3820677697658539,
0.2809322774410248,
0.7784613966941833,
-0.09864377230405807,
0.45208939909935,
-0.5919445753097534,
0.2801264524459839,
0.5275622606277466,
-0.4909556210041046,
-0.018887469545006752,
0.3572002649307251,
0.05079204589128494,
-0.10929273068904877,
0.24629716575145721,
-0.5406101942062378,
-0.17561684548854828,
0.5933008790016174,
0.6716558933258057,
0.7347663640975952,
0.05216264724731445,
0.3092113733291626,
0.275771826505661,
0.03233161196112633,
0.01876482553780079,
0.420592725276947,
-0.17859122157096863,
-0.48504960536956787,
-0.28179800510406494,
-0.5492631196975708,
-0.5315976142883301,
0.12151259928941727,
-0.9141483902931213,
0.3715297281742096,
-0.1521800011396408,
-0.1711495965719223,
0.4057573676109314,
0.12272340804338455,
-0.3117579519748688,
0.011257040314376354,
-0.0870082750916481,
0.7930765748023987,
-0.6307362914085388,
1.035007119178772,
1.1189398765563965,
-0.8706095814704895,
-1.0353479385375977,
0.11452050507068634,
-0.10507525503635406,
-0.08204830437898636,
0.7733771800994873,
-0.15596090257167816,
-0.10436726361513138,
0.13488444685935974,
-0.634136974811554,
-0.9940583109855652,
1.2773821353912354,
0.5948160886764526,
-0.19163069128990173,
-0.07022815942764282,
-0.28152012825012207,
0.384097158908844,
-0.3789477050304413,
0.36394014954566956,
0.34510520100593567,
0.2244463860988617,
0.3133845627307892,
-0.7849028706550598,
0.01716274954378605,
-0.3408311903476715,
0.00625380827113986,
0.40642914175987244,
-0.21711741387844086,
0.6537160277366638,
-0.13624519109725952,
-0.3538994789123535,
-0.05462166666984558,
0.7218703031539917,
0.5827814340591431,
0.46533411741256714,
0.33843448758125305,
0.18473462760448456,
0.8720873594284058,
0.061613596975803375,
0.875252902507782,
-0.17969268560409546,
0.48856475949287415,
1.5272414684295654,
-0.5924872159957886,
1.037130355834961,
0.9760286808013916,
-0.41880613565444946,
0.5630476474761963,
0.4727865755558014,
-0.03634272888302803,
0.3711598515510559,
0.3194841742515564,
-0.4618474245071411,
0.007713319733738899,
-0.1964670866727829,
-0.6290472745895386,
0.05785083398222923,
0.12404932081699371,
-0.48872795701026917,
-0.27164024114608765,
0.1756599396467209,
0.1948661357164383,
-0.08919520676136017,
-0.37266501784324646,
0.8696097135543823,
0.10609361529350281,
-0.7650747895240784,
0.05718442052602768,
-0.09820635616779327,
0.6220082640647888,
-0.7010135054588318,
-0.09992318600416183,
0.08832896500825882,
-0.0787949487566948,
-0.31895363330841064,
-0.5903995037078857,
0.3028305172920227,
0.20034143328666687,
-0.5430753231048584,
-0.09224234521389008,
1.0610835552215576,
-0.34145617485046387,
-0.18640738725662231,
0.4002583920955658,
0.5639724731445312,
0.30569887161254883,
-0.07560860365629196,
-0.5576475858688354,
-0.012601417489349842,
-0.03516800329089165,
-0.05747715383768082,
0.6487916707992554,
0.34379300475120544,
0.14239275455474854,
0.6134122014045715,
0.5397208333015442,
0.35713300108909607,
-0.06153322756290436,
0.08015855401754379,
1.0174686908721924,
-0.524799644947052,
-0.27969124913215637,
-0.8324625492095947,
0.5101872682571411,
-0.39390048384666443,
0.0010499524651095271,
1.181509017944336,
0.7627347111701965,
0.8495079278945923,
-0.18153677880764008,
0.901563286781311,
-0.26537784934043884,
0.7550511360168457,
-0.11185530573129654,
0.5898531675338745,
-0.6376389265060425,
0.6354690790176392,
-0.5792989730834961,
-0.9522525072097778,
-0.3202684819698334,
0.25696370005607605,
-0.36811062693595886,
-0.2107442170381546,
0.6269149780273438,
0.751156747341156,
0.026127135381102562,
-0.018351994454860687,
0.1678902506828308,
-0.036226529628038406,
0.16464641690254211,
-0.03946130350232124,
0.7787139415740967,
-0.4399023950099945,
0.44805672764778137,
0.31096822023391724,
-0.2096455991268158,
-0.05472146347165108,
-0.8566439151763916,
-0.3695825934410095,
-0.6491613984107971,
-0.6115322709083557,
-0.4224253296852112,
0.019534584134817123,
1.0197980403900146,
0.17902861535549164,
-0.7840195298194885,
-0.18509875237941742,
-0.026504388079047203,
0.2687830924987793,
-0.23315909504890442,
-0.2619084417819977,
0.3073410391807556,
-0.4201221764087677,
-0.3869759440422058,
0.2372736781835556,
0.6982900500297546,
-0.3385159969329834,
-0.5008576512336731,
-0.12123944610357285,
-0.6210622787475586,
-0.1258465200662613,
0.5821138024330139,
0.2818392217159271,
-0.5764539837837219,
-0.2661905884742737,
0.16982689499855042,
-0.46761709451675415,
-0.017650287598371506,
0.7000489234924316,
-0.6081222891807556,
0.31674090027809143,
0.33739906549453735,
0.6900809407234192,
0.31801724433898926,
-0.11441551148891449,
0.4223363995552063,
-0.700217068195343,
-0.3320089876651764,
0.20299993455410004,
0.2183651179075241,
0.18416760861873627,
-0.31574079394340515,
0.7289496064186096,
0.09591415524482727,
-0.6475757360458374,
-0.9933506846427917,
0.24928902089595795,
-0.8410311937332153,
-0.42387333512306213,
1.2904390096664429,
-0.5107961297035217,
-0.14765720069408417,
-0.5548551082611084,
-0.4561319649219513,
0.3321922719478607,
-0.06342487037181854,
0.6341363787651062,
0.6732164025306702,
-0.07520642131567001,
-0.1590314507484436,
-0.6251071691513062,
0.4591064155101776,
0.07883214950561523,
-1.0803022384643555,
0.04516937583684921,
0.5680265426635742,
0.45201408863067627,
0.5680704116821289,
0.8740577101707458,
-0.34856969118118286,
0.2661856412887573,
-0.12806084752082825,
0.4193553626537323,
0.019808372482657433,
-0.38807380199432373,
-0.22181114554405212,
0.551655113697052,
0.503033459186554,
-0.18650762736797333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05569v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05569v2
|
360$^\circ$REA: Towards A Reusable Experience Accumulation with 360° Assessment for Multi-Agent System
| 2024-04-08T14:43:13 | 2024-06-26T11:42:10 |
Shen Gao, Hao Li, Chengrui Huang, Quan Tu, Zhiliang Tian, Minlie Huang, Shuo Shang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MA
|
Large language model agents have demonstrated remarkable advancements across
various complex tasks. Recent works focus on optimizing the agent team or
employing self-reflection to iteratively solve complex tasks. Since these
agents are all based on the same LLM, only conducting self-evaluation or
removing underperforming agents does not substantively enhance the capability
of the agents. We argue that a comprehensive evaluation and accumulating
experience from evaluation feedback is an effective approach to improving
system performance. In this paper, we propose Reusable Experience Accumulation
with 360$^\circ$ Assessment (360$^\circ$REA), a hierarchical multi-agent
framework inspired by corporate organizational practices. The framework employs
a novel 360$^\circ$ performance assessment method for multi-perspective
performance evaluation with fine-grained assessment. To enhance the capability
of agents in addressing complex tasks, we introduce dual-level experience pool
for agents to accumulate experience through fine-grained assessment. Extensive
experiments on complex task datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of
360$^\circ$REA.
|
[
-0.45036014914512634,
-0.6248329877853394,
0.42649683356285095,
0.6005544066429138,
0.18237589299678802,
0.6161805987358093,
-0.09422699362039566,
-0.49693259596824646,
0.2509128153324127,
0.4146527945995331,
-0.4806543290615082,
-0.3881111741065979,
-0.23104675114154816,
-0.17204494774341583,
0.012567702680826187,
0.8209365010261536,
-0.0318993516266346,
-0.13198286294937134,
-0.2790389358997345,
-0.15900453925132751,
-0.6062403917312622,
-0.592121958732605,
-0.7388916015625,
-0.7195045948028564,
0.4557190239429474,
0.4468168318271637,
0.6850901246070862,
0.10474655777215958,
0.2663046717643738,
0.4469049274921417,
0.3700573742389679,
0.6929640173912048,
-0.4330415725708008,
0.19790425896644592,
-0.4138094484806061,
-0.12698055803775787,
-1.0603492259979248,
0.19701796770095825,
0.7264626622200012,
0.47093021869659424,
-0.4613747000694275,
-0.004422564525157213,
0.05607357993721962,
0.6180402636528015,
-0.9181761145591736,
0.3500688076019287,
-0.184056356549263,
0.2763898968696594,
0.2136455923318863,
-0.5086133480072021,
-0.4406653344631195,
-0.06171621382236481,
0.039706550538539886,
-0.8306334614753723,
-0.23308904469013214,
0.01194518432021141,
0.2740119397640228,
-0.2106088548898697,
-0.07629062235355377,
-0.1562248021364212,
-0.9076743721961975,
0.9318349957466125,
-0.48441070318222046,
0.3246999680995941,
-0.058375243097543716,
0.4945846498012543,
-0.17971469461917877,
-0.5270026922225952,
-0.5173292756080627,
-0.3086799085140228,
0.34508857131004333,
0.2887671887874603,
-0.2943032383918762,
0.05277001112699509,
-0.2758761942386627,
0.40307196974754333,
-0.16710259020328522,
0.33223459124565125,
-0.25490525364875793,
-0.11357954889535904,
0.734549343585968,
0.48948878049850464,
0.17294077575206757,
0.1043618693947792,
-0.6383494138717651,
-0.3077314794063568,
-0.4046877324581146,
0.23730698227882385,
0.28731802105903625,
0.4301539361476898,
0.24423928558826447,
0.34779655933380127,
-0.4334683120250702,
0.25123342871665955,
0.10983186215162277,
-0.21655574440956116,
0.5748261213302612,
-0.13144974410533905,
-0.5307524800300598,
-0.2657569348812103,
0.49573877453804016,
0.49747875332832336,
0.14425162971019745,
-0.6881858110427856,
-0.45498374104499817,
-0.00538012757897377,
0.9361340403556824,
-0.6731008291244507,
0.081685371696949,
0.32358652353286743,
-0.3183373808860779,
-0.2524959146976471,
0.2244560569524765,
-0.9362578988075256,
-0.3261597752571106,
-0.40447551012039185,
0.3229992687702179,
-0.32796400785446167,
-0.6202955842018127,
0.20782089233398438,
-0.15932606160640717,
0.2550583481788635,
0.6626073718070984,
-0.30593323707580566,
0.42411932349205017,
1.1658812761306763,
0.5255962610244751,
-0.3439826965332031,
-0.8702455163002014,
-0.6926016211509705,
0.06505164504051208,
-0.24794864654541016,
0.8934742212295532,
-0.622379720211029,
-0.22327904403209686,
0.2974834442138672,
0.01708099991083145,
0.0320403054356575,
-0.8461329340934753,
0.07839662581682205,
-0.747291624546051,
-0.04694024473428726,
0.07538565993309021,
-0.31385284662246704,
-0.08352910727262497,
0.6053401231765747,
-0.4490951895713806,
1.1117262840270996,
0.29727908968925476,
-0.19850872457027435,
0.5977050065994263,
-0.8938891887664795,
0.12576431035995483,
0.24365150928497314,
-0.05745119974017143,
-0.011304080486297607,
0.18047748506069183,
-0.04044554755091667,
0.27358385920524597,
-0.03994079679250717,
0.020676584914326668,
-0.2661481201648712,
-0.1816907525062561,
0.1596931517124176,
-0.2943325936794281,
0.12123631685972214,
0.2969087064266205,
-0.21608246862888336,
0.27605608105659485,
-0.7421844601631165,
0.5326990485191345,
-0.32074686884880066,
-0.582712709903717,
-0.2957279086112976,
-0.1745873987674713,
0.17780055105686188,
0.35607439279556274,
0.43792787194252014,
-0.4948529005050659,
0.4170278012752533,
-0.38764652609825134,
-0.10765384137630463,
0.7744846940040588,
-0.061659518629312515,
0.6105160713195801,
-0.46332666277885437,
0.8612751960754395,
0.27128732204437256,
0.13873177766799927,
-0.015764489769935608,
-0.02835424244403839,
-0.41320502758026123,
-0.39077290892601013,
-0.21748974919319153,
0.5131596326828003,
-0.878488302230835,
0.43196749687194824,
-0.26033899188041687,
-0.7787148952484131,
-0.3156869411468506,
0.4241730272769928,
0.6970445513725281,
-0.023841284215450287,
0.46897801756858826,
-0.7110973000526428,
-0.1855037808418274,
-0.9779695868492126,
-0.3261488676071167,
-0.20343929529190063,
-0.01988646760582924,
0.11499444395303726,
0.3326326012611389,
-0.43081584572792053,
0.8168515563011169,
-0.30901917815208435,
-0.34195539355278015,
-0.3157063126564026,
0.18080009520053864,
-0.10429135710000992,
0.7086817026138306,
0.23037800192832947,
-0.35536903142929077,
0.009654263965785503,
0.19991476833820343,
-0.9460582137107849,
0.19387604296207428,
-0.14002487063407898,
-0.3436015248298645,
0.23396435379981995,
0.16623595356941223,
-0.4275205433368683,
0.3513636291027069,
0.4493539333343506,
-0.6028597950935364,
0.6496081948280334,
-0.5850181579589844,
0.25375306606292725,
-0.5425118803977966,
-0.1141280010342598,
0.046969879418611526,
-0.48927223682403564,
-0.453740656375885,
0.3793186843395233,
-0.1076178327202797,
0.20696094632148743,
-0.41427847743034363,
0.5169332027435303,
-0.527189314365387,
-0.3157308101654053,
-0.650831401348114,
0.45263203978538513,
0.24699953198432922,
0.8253195285797119,
-0.18791888654232025,
0.4586588442325592,
0.4054260849952698,
-0.5361648797988892,
0.4910123646259308,
-0.26497623324394226,
-0.39502304792404175,
0.9188770651817322,
-0.29256924986839294,
0.2278377264738083,
0.008951596915721893,
0.25384390354156494,
-0.7928469181060791,
0.24824440479278564,
0.2225906252861023,
-0.07528108358383179,
0.2008131891489029,
0.5732687711715698,
-0.38382938504219055,
-0.23157362639904022,
-0.5550371408462524,
0.4860207736492157,
0.031629957258701324,
-0.41333892941474915,
0.8653125762939453,
0.4819858968257904,
0.00579277565702796,
-0.7138214111328125,
-0.48572057485580444,
0.14164051413536072,
-0.14483405649662018,
-0.7274462580680847,
0.12405038625001907,
0.3107742369174957,
-0.3665805459022522,
-0.1609644740819931,
-0.0833481103181839,
0.012470387853682041,
0.05451946333050728,
0.5345876216888428,
0.019674737006425858,
-0.16949956119060516,
0.058307576924562454,
0.14968284964561462,
-0.09201789647340775,
0.013376915827393532,
-0.026013631373643875,
0.5687912702560425,
-0.7344038486480713,
-0.48632168769836426,
-0.6849615573883057,
0.6463844180107117,
0.7324790954589844,
-0.20256945490837097,
0.5196102261543274,
0.3236618638038635,
-0.5140746831893921,
-0.24473494291305542,
-0.7865111827850342,
0.06701114773750305,
-0.41719576716423035,
0.7642362713813782,
-0.6324018836021423,
-0.6825852990150452,
0.6710725426673889,
-0.34627023339271545,
0.32578447461128235,
0.5035677552223206,
0.5963265299797058,
0.19985423982143402,
0.6907683610916138,
0.8048927783966064,
-0.04558464512228966,
0.3278774321079254,
-0.568351686000824,
0.029071267694234848,
-1.0241875648498535,
-0.6118049025535583,
-0.25055408477783203,
-0.12658199667930603,
-0.4074321389198303,
-0.690991997718811,
0.15955433249473572,
-0.0062622735276818275,
-0.4816370904445648,
-0.04535657912492752,
-0.4466042220592499,
0.21627177298069,
0.22121591866016388,
0.07492916285991669,
0.669175386428833,
-0.11320265382528305,
0.27169495820999146,
0.17165738344192505,
-0.6319710612297058,
-0.9199090600013733,
0.7380487322807312,
0.7138685584068298,
0.6925567388534546,
-0.012625661678612232,
0.7941880822181702,
0.6159176826477051,
0.7964537143707275,
-0.8081513047218323,
0.27068352699279785,
0.22112669050693512,
-0.28636643290519714,
-0.5760204792022705,
-0.20718929171562195,
-0.8502304553985596,
0.6431621313095093,
0.04145171865820885,
-0.7872208952903748,
0.48897141218185425,
-0.06710516661405563,
-0.5884454846382141,
0.1399356722831726,
-0.7856960296630859,
0.7531923055648804,
-0.09873899072408676,
-0.48897287249565125,
-0.5197370052337646,
-0.08657200634479523,
0.06193612515926361,
-0.14519496262073517,
0.37648722529411316,
0.15549369156360626,
-0.2894436717033386,
0.8940500617027283,
-0.426824152469635,
0.7417951822280884,
-0.629811704158783,
-0.34326812624931335,
0.29614078998565674,
0.1350397765636444,
0.438096284866333,
0.14793112874031067,
-0.3223738372325897,
-0.03917602822184563,
0.1725064069032669,
-0.4125256836414337,
-0.9384209513664246,
0.9737018346786499,
-1.059533953666687,
-0.6193654537200928,
-0.43241578340530396,
-0.7077991962432861,
-0.4461985230445862,
0.009596006013453007,
-0.40574970841407776,
0.4083499312400818,
-0.38424527645111084,
0.01575620472431183,
-0.1396753042936325,
-0.15329474210739136,
0.2643653154373169,
0.4836330711841583,
-0.43248799443244934,
-0.35900479555130005,
0.7998189330101013,
0.2166944444179535,
0.3386455774307251,
-0.06357764452695847,
-0.026721319183707237,
-0.08005259931087494,
-0.29663389921188354,
-0.27145034074783325,
0.02112569287419319,
-0.47455114126205444,
-0.36610496044158936,
-0.6071636080741882,
0.019456086680293083,
-0.3568853735923767,
-0.28025662899017334,
-0.8487185835838318,
-0.15635104477405548,
0.16963423788547516,
-0.20147456228733063,
-0.12259514629840851,
0.8525460362434387,
-0.316532164812088,
0.48565971851348877,
-0.47779712080955505,
0.18011866509914398,
0.23764994740486145,
0.26973146200180054,
0.5945333242416382,
-0.1415901631116867,
-0.5141197443008423,
0.18346478044986725,
-0.7729266285896301,
-0.5334334373474121,
0.5630062222480774,
0.02974562719464302,
0.8579211235046387,
0.46933218836784363,
-0.04005913436412811,
0.8116401433944702,
-0.2711542546749115,
0.7717780470848083,
0.1831197291612625,
-0.9555298686027527,
0.07801079750061035,
-0.05458918213844299,
0.2776753008365631,
0.8022422790527344,
0.03960828483104706,
-0.42510074377059937,
-0.8859442472457886,
-0.7733398079872131,
-1.0940747261047363,
0.7672170996665955,
-0.11169968545436859,
0.1523509919643402,
0.22097177803516388,
0.49736902117729187,
0.06614023447036743,
0.3951714038848877,
-0.32741692662239075,
-0.13746502995491028,
-0.3681699335575104,
0.3708803057670593,
-0.05952521786093712,
-0.2489587515592575,
-0.10137413442134857,
-0.08980390429496765,
0.7057770490646362,
-0.08858321607112885,
0.3110204041004181,
0.34213581681251526,
0.014370078220963478,
0.09166023135185242,
0.38164690136909485,
0.29394155740737915,
1.2519160509109497,
-0.29005181789398193,
0.20495565235614777,
0.20019878447055817,
-0.27116894721984863,
0.08519057929515839,
-0.30124619603157043,
0.5325618982315063,
-0.5206927061080933,
0.419816255569458,
0.2785116732120514,
0.21014799177646637,
-0.6064311861991882,
0.32189515233039856,
0.07513902336359024,
-0.027962790802121162,
-0.5220440626144409,
0.009035979397594929,
0.08293485641479492,
0.6722854375839233,
0.6702967882156372,
-0.027050191536545753,
0.21199160814285278,
-1.0622320175170898,
0.28103312849998474,
0.29971927404403687,
-0.5681909918785095,
-0.07796841114759445,
-0.13446113467216492,
0.28385499119758606,
-0.49557918310165405,
0.6233848929405212,
-0.22108995914459229,
-0.5483950972557068,
0.6107242107391357,
0.3632032573223114,
0.7747899889945984,
-0.40672430396080017,
0.4322061836719513,
0.05733995884656906,
0.14879801869392395,
-0.09343519061803818,
0.17510801553726196,
-0.22205018997192383,
-0.8188353180885315,
-0.4590469002723694,
-0.5769566297531128,
-0.4988725483417511,
-0.21864178776741028,
-0.8170873522758484,
-0.2187148928642273,
-0.558281421661377,
-0.12837520241737366,
0.06189467012882233,
0.4611315131187439,
-0.7486307621002197,
0.2756548523902893,
-0.07221181690692902,
0.9431668519973755,
-0.7204737067222595,
0.7227140665054321,
0.5031763315200806,
-0.3696492910385132,
-0.7607178092002869,
-0.282665491104126,
-0.38204318284988403,
-0.9200323224067688,
0.7270439863204956,
0.1780826300382614,
-0.6981747150421143,
-0.5618798732757568,
-0.3342975974082947,
-0.3009408116340637,
1.172528862953186,
0.08083821833133698,
-0.35044798254966736,
-0.1330416053533554,
-0.05519530922174454,
0.9687657356262207,
-1.0825074911117554,
0.4343263506889343,
0.6166450381278992,
0.6209176182746887,
0.056696001440286636,
-0.8396584987640381,
0.11253120005130768,
-0.45898377895355225,
0.032790280878543854,
-0.20136070251464844,
-0.856496274471283,
0.7271173596382141,
-0.12190002202987671,
-0.08497685194015503,
0.07550819218158722,
1.059281826019287,
0.6785152554512024,
0.8997991681098938,
0.6810442209243774,
0.30291852355003357,
0.862650454044342,
0.4491043984889984,
1.0675435066223145,
-0.25921493768692017,
0.5241797566413879,
1.1965680122375488,
-0.3179504871368408,
0.921468198299408,
0.6707058548927307,
-0.03147240728139877,
0.8244161009788513,
0.305536687374115,
0.22159938514232635,
0.35679471492767334,
0.5923742055892944,
-0.1905873715877533,
-0.7720024585723877,
-0.0791463702917099,
-0.2736971378326416,
0.7136815786361694,
0.1835579127073288,
-0.12130323797464371,
-0.45612832903862,
0.1469377875328064,
0.10538744926452637,
0.21050120890140533,
-0.38034605979919434,
0.6217612028121948,
0.03801949694752693,
-0.7908935546875,
0.1675688624382019,
0.12366275489330292,
0.7660792469978333,
-0.22677990794181824,
-0.14118874073028564,
-0.171208456158638,
0.488686203956604,
-0.46588996052742004,
-0.537589967250824,
0.41324102878570557,
-0.15079036355018616,
-0.2979044020175934,
-0.3391273319721222,
0.4435631036758423,
-0.210200235247612,
-0.5567362308502197,
0.5922548770904541,
0.9726866483688354,
0.25870612263679504,
-0.33930662274360657,
-0.37679222226142883,
-0.13069583475589752,
-0.44346562027931213,
-0.41824981570243835,
0.4199625253677368,
0.7030683159828186,
-0.1162058636546135,
0.8472061157226562,
0.43705496191978455,
0.1644139289855957,
-0.09802080690860748,
0.02652462013065815,
1.0756477117538452,
-0.6213631629943848,
-0.49436745047569275,
-0.5427871942520142,
0.3988056480884552,
-0.12028979510068893,
-0.29983633756637573,
0.6265733242034912,
0.770425021648407,
0.6910660862922668,
0.060704220086336136,
0.73457270860672,
0.1761363446712494,
0.3837098777294159,
-0.09032858908176422,
0.6771433353424072,
-0.8542474508285522,
0.25348958373069763,
-0.558438777923584,
-0.8359619379043579,
0.05496039614081383,
0.4759601056575775,
-0.3599337637424469,
0.25879159569740295,
0.5269213318824768,
0.8346908688545227,
0.10062012821435928,
0.057683177292346954,
0.5403984189033508,
0.013132484629750252,
0.6715329885482788,
0.7557874321937561,
1.1717342138290405,
-0.45915529131889343,
0.10576550662517548,
-0.22039800882339478,
-0.6216738820075989,
-0.03403080999851227,
-0.6266993880271912,
-0.39159032702445984,
-0.5372312664985657,
-0.4408089220523834,
-0.2887231409549713,
-0.009176747873425484,
0.9209638237953186,
0.6412951350212097,
-0.5417762398719788,
-0.5960643291473389,
0.44808605313301086,
0.19456131756305695,
-0.6178392171859741,
-0.26244840025901794,
0.308427095413208,
-0.4832501709461212,
-0.8491314053535461,
0.5295073390007019,
0.3854859471321106,
-0.6139446496963501,
-0.8305389285087585,
-0.3903791606426239,
-0.18292434513568878,
-0.07583966851234436,
0.8984445929527283,
0.34699004888534546,
-0.4712506830692291,
-0.3935074508190155,
-0.11694422364234924,
-0.024413514882326126,
0.01294263917952776,
0.9460502862930298,
-1.033983826637268,
0.41257062554359436,
0.3540450632572174,
0.5697540640830994,
0.27370956540107727,
0.176261767745018,
0.78266441822052,
-0.2931399643421173,
-0.05050160363316536,
0.10900621116161346,
0.03761036694049835,
0.166503444314003,
-0.4945299029350281,
0.2901345491409302,
-0.07056017220020294,
-0.6111454963684082,
-0.7523766160011292,
-0.3550957441329956,
-1.3796477317810059,
-0.02120356447994709,
1.0543148517608643,
-0.528886616230011,
-0.1944328099489212,
-0.27539536356925964,
-0.08342143893241882,
0.12156464904546738,
-0.8186891078948975,
0.8499303460121155,
0.5456716418266296,
-0.5113512277603149,
0.22280088067054749,
-0.3080907464027405,
0.13691572844982147,
0.4173482656478882,
-1.0030899047851562,
0.17213718593120575,
0.5236173272132874,
0.21580789983272552,
0.7750557661056519,
0.7962932586669922,
-0.2835661470890045,
0.23561757802963257,
-0.08642525225877762,
0.20597708225250244,
-0.48547619581222534,
-0.7607585191726685,
-0.2541479468345642,
0.8506762981414795,
0.058949220925569534,
-0.3634091019630432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05567v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05567v1
|
Dense Training, Sparse Inference: Rethinking Training of Mixture-of-Experts Language Models
| 2024-04-08T14:39:49 | 2024-04-08T14:39:49 |
Bowen Pan, Yikang Shen, Haokun Liu, Mayank Mishra, Gaoyuan Zhang, Aude Oliva, Colin Raffel, Rameswar Panda
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) language models can reduce computational costs by
2-4$\times$ compared to dense models without sacrificing performance, making
them more efficient in computation-bounded scenarios. However, MoE models
generally require 2-4$\times$ times more parameters to achieve comparable
performance to a dense model, which incurs larger GPU memory requirements and
makes MoE models less efficient in I/O-bounded scenarios like autoregressive
generation. In this work, we propose a hybrid dense training and sparse
inference framework for MoE models (DS-MoE) which achieves strong computation
and parameter efficiency by employing dense computation across all experts
during training and sparse computation during inference. Our experiments on
training LLMs demonstrate that our DS-MoE models are more parameter-efficient
than standard sparse MoEs and are on par with dense models in terms of total
parameter size and performance while being computationally cheaper (activating
30-40% of the model's parameters). Performance tests using vLLM show that our
DS-MoE-6B model runs up to $1.86\times$ faster than similar dense models like
Mistral-7B, and between $1.50\times$ and $1.71\times$ faster than comparable
MoEs, such as DeepSeekMoE-16B and Qwen1.5-MoE-A2.7B.
|
[
-0.5465056896209717,
-1.0166409015655518,
0.4450860619544983,
0.13370050489902496,
-0.2178848683834076,
0.17664675414562225,
-0.47088298201560974,
-0.4791963994503021,
0.2645813822746277,
0.4483102560043335,
-0.4631209671497345,
-0.015896320343017578,
-0.6582005023956299,
0.00441192789003253,
-0.36196455359458923,
0.5007409453392029,
0.12015943229198456,
0.056563884019851685,
-0.2609144151210785,
0.03270011767745018,
-0.4720695912837982,
-0.25358983874320984,
-0.46374014019966125,
-0.09230025112628937,
0.4482349455356598,
0.3429395854473114,
0.6970821022987366,
0.6496939659118652,
0.04671129211783409,
0.3705713450908661,
0.06223738566040993,
0.247889444231987,
-0.7784702777862549,
0.23641104996204376,
0.16844451427459717,
-0.42007607221603394,
-0.40140053629875183,
-0.183172807097435,
0.6107139587402344,
0.9540996551513672,
-0.3312813639640808,
-0.3703353703022003,
-0.02982478402554989,
0.35353973507881165,
-0.8694373965263367,
-0.022516952827572823,
-0.9579228162765503,
-0.10484398901462555,
-0.04891584813594818,
-0.13633234798908234,
-0.39719846844673157,
0.10723547637462616,
0.03283132612705231,
-0.7190473079681396,
0.4404465854167938,
0.09215198457241058,
0.7184149622917175,
0.4988434314727783,
-0.21586494147777557,
0.21627667546272278,
-0.6740467548370361,
1.2009553909301758,
-0.885025143623352,
0.5883172154426575,
0.49967139959335327,
0.11445904523134232,
-0.11739440262317657,
-0.2668326497077942,
-0.4793671667575836,
-0.18422406911849976,
0.19542068243026733,
0.1501634567975998,
0.09957856684923172,
0.2445794641971588,
0.12963725626468658,
0.576567530632019,
-0.43711602687835693,
0.39614349603652954,
-0.3617140054702759,
-0.014306595548987389,
1.0381979942321777,
0.30189087986946106,
-0.054972074925899506,
0.2461196333169937,
-0.29449790716171265,
0.1641501933336258,
-0.5108973383903503,
-0.4598539173603058,
0.2658350467681885,
0.04138736426830292,
-0.08972932398319244,
0.3426141142845154,
-0.3079976737499237,
0.8272836804389954,
0.2863754332065582,
-0.5232657194137573,
0.034624479711055756,
-0.17626848816871643,
-0.021497635170817375,
-0.17554067075252533,
0.8127236366271973,
0.22938363254070282,
0.3330647945404053,
-0.5271775722503662,
-0.5099348425865173,
-0.14001889526844025,
0.17933353781700134,
-1.0038657188415527,
-0.47383901476860046,
0.024896932765841484,
-0.2679101228713989,
-0.09272494167089462,
-0.38475173711776733,
-0.6323524713516235,
-0.16995833814144135,
-0.4498519003391266,
0.46272042393684387,
-0.6339362859725952,
-0.5734970569610596,
0.2944319546222687,
0.09857397526502609,
-0.24760574102401733,
0.578152060508728,
-1.2462459802627563,
0.4625750780105591,
0.5339179039001465,
0.6977180242538452,
-0.29113587737083435,
-0.35311001539230347,
-0.17573198676109314,
0.319559782743454,
-0.31402963399887085,
0.8240670561790466,
-0.6604887843132019,
-0.5817602276802063,
-0.3758719861507416,
-0.7656444311141968,
-0.42709216475486755,
-0.6675444841384888,
0.16325069963932037,
-0.42641183733940125,
-0.0065321484580636024,
-0.1983778327703476,
-0.8152871131896973,
-0.2737685441970825,
-0.1466045379638672,
-0.5801562070846558,
1.331757664680481,
0.1615496277809143,
-0.6163318157196045,
0.5607568025588989,
-0.12370044738054276,
-0.5025597214698792,
0.17948052287101746,
-0.501459538936615,
-0.2526826858520508,
0.212598517537117,
0.2744337022304535,
0.7931024432182312,
-0.4918426275253296,
0.5234330892562866,
-0.7393075823783875,
-0.549557626247406,
0.1516866236925125,
-0.5795320868492126,
0.7039477229118347,
0.41383132338523865,
-0.2698410451412201,
-0.19764821231365204,
-0.9038191437721252,
-0.11427798122167587,
0.08744972199201584,
-0.45888498425483704,
-0.4367237091064453,
0.20634712278842926,
-0.036494188010692596,
-0.07932046800851822,
0.28416773676872253,
-0.3188460171222687,
0.23579514026641846,
-0.18091368675231934,
0.4476138949394226,
0.7524558901786804,
-0.18170978128910065,
0.8208813667297363,
-0.2854573130607605,
0.334506630897522,
0.08514193445444107,
-0.006560169626027346,
-0.005765572655946016,
-0.6622202396392822,
-0.7949318289756775,
-1.0640794038772583,
0.3767072856426239,
0.45778220891952515,
-0.7751684784889221,
0.6589314341545105,
-0.240568146109581,
-0.48933011293411255,
-0.6947681307792664,
0.32405349612236023,
0.1617334634065628,
0.6090846061706543,
0.2760782539844513,
-0.0898413136601448,
-0.29029610753059387,
-0.8941767811775208,
-0.15882085263729095,
-0.1007668748497963,
0.16649892926216125,
0.4578094482421875,
0.49102914333343506,
-0.1752023845911026,
1.184425950050354,
-0.41154325008392334,
0.4404906630516052,
-0.4116092920303345,
0.1422804594039917,
-0.08909468352794647,
0.7214537262916565,
0.799968957901001,
-0.6494255661964417,
-0.585673987865448,
-0.1734342873096466,
-0.6675949692726135,
-0.27195847034454346,
-0.04121986776590347,
-0.01101464219391346,
0.06234327331185341,
0.2741841971874237,
-0.49088117480278015,
0.22699123620986938,
0.4907437860965729,
0.15025551617145538,
0.4402354061603546,
-0.23487943410873413,
-0.01727404072880745,
-1.025325059890747,
-0.3077654242515564,
0.008959365077316761,
-0.10210330039262772,
-0.4686744511127472,
0.15586017072200775,
-0.06962835788726807,
-0.05826069414615631,
0.023278893902897835,
0.6459305882453918,
-0.6718980669975281,
-0.11220785975456238,
-0.22708837687969208,
-0.24356979131698608,
-0.0015655249590054154,
0.6870467662811279,
0.1692686676979065,
1.0967469215393066,
0.9709142446517944,
-0.5927448868751526,
0.19014765322208405,
-0.2785551846027374,
-0.4390629827976227,
0.3913620114326477,
-0.7067565321922302,
-0.06785948574542999,
0.0025035894941538572,
0.25666770339012146,
-0.9246169924736023,
-0.2552819848060608,
0.07809201627969742,
-0.21112950146198273,
0.4776226878166199,
-0.0819801464676857,
-0.7327347993850708,
0.011994545347988605,
-0.0868014320731163,
0.7482017874717712,
0.6112119555473328,
-0.3025256395339966,
0.8580858707427979,
0.36183056235313416,
-0.2673264443874359,
-0.5406572818756104,
-0.7725646495819092,
-0.006847926881164312,
-0.20509174466133118,
-0.8614190816879272,
0.22873525321483612,
-0.1711404025554657,
-0.3898344337940216,
0.07871979475021362,
0.13803794980049133,
-0.6396830081939697,
0.563302755355835,
-0.06111302226781845,
-0.03708752617239952,
-0.44991427659988403,
-0.09023622423410416,
0.5384662747383118,
-0.15927250683307648,
-0.20601807534694672,
-0.10167188942432404,
0.43807145953178406,
0.05365826562047005,
-0.5142008662223816,
-0.3473574221134186,
0.7745805382728577,
0.3351497948169708,
-0.1659442037343979,
0.9442712068557739,
0.609574019908905,
-0.4088969826698303,
-0.41202911734580994,
-1.0055100917816162,
-0.46464309096336365,
-0.4221092760562897,
0.5365381836891174,
-0.4807884991168976,
-0.81972336769104,
0.5681056380271912,
0.1667603850364685,
0.2033076286315918,
0.47194766998291016,
0.792749285697937,
0.10962649434804916,
1.053218126296997,
0.38202789425849915,
-0.27904799580574036,
0.48234885931015015,
-0.3489221930503845,
0.14285090565681458,
-0.4827682375907898,
-0.06931878626346588,
-0.22296741604804993,
-0.35506942868232727,
-0.09640353173017502,
-0.5931656360626221,
0.341377317905426,
0.31890374422073364,
0.13965870440006256,
0.08418093621730804,
-0.12162675708532333,
0.35144203901290894,
0.6033901572227478,
0.19046273827552795,
0.15229561924934387,
0.17379441857337952,
-0.03567999228835106,
-0.02276519127190113,
-1.3779631853103638,
-0.09739705175161362,
1.0303575992584229,
0.24212265014648438,
0.9775187969207764,
-0.17081543803215027,
0.7223716974258423,
0.06835336983203888,
0.17105872929096222,
-0.6706166863441467,
0.695981502532959,
0.000042946510802721605,
-0.8400603532791138,
-0.12577880918979645,
-0.7708296179771423,
-0.5863432288169861,
0.5721784830093384,
-0.4188852310180664,
-0.35670703649520874,
0.30905166268348694,
0.24913635849952698,
-0.4625060558319092,
0.5361649990081787,
-0.9849733114242554,
0.4492614269256592,
-0.23646824061870575,
-0.5464557409286499,
-0.6491249799728394,
-0.3328036069869995,
0.5216531157493591,
-0.22982069849967957,
0.037104181945323944,
-0.21047687530517578,
-0.2452378123998642,
0.5337747931480408,
-0.659425675868988,
0.9035065174102783,
-0.08137238770723343,
-0.06088439002633095,
0.2455402910709381,
-0.0012405136367306113,
0.2758842706680298,
0.10150562971830368,
-0.36048224568367004,
0.2967706322669983,
-0.4803987443447113,
-0.727206289768219,
-0.5096476674079895,
0.7072560787200928,
-0.9345778822898865,
-0.3336580693721771,
-0.08052767068147659,
-0.9511187076568604,
-0.33040472865104675,
0.014831854961812496,
0.44722723960876465,
0.6545981168746948,
0.17621181905269623,
0.1729533076286316,
1.0441398620605469,
0.004362249746918678,
0.05819810554385185,
0.5336112380027771,
0.17480862140655518,
-0.419138640165329,
1.0108506679534912,
0.4838760495185852,
0.35630953311920166,
0.2910878658294678,
0.012924610637128353,
-0.14323288202285767,
-0.8999873995780945,
-0.6254124045372009,
0.2670225203037262,
-0.36297592520713806,
0.024559274315834045,
-0.9441221356391907,
-0.19264750182628632,
-0.3723044991493225,
-0.41447535157203674,
-0.6049640774726868,
-0.40149956941604614,
-0.4501425623893738,
0.1626255363225937,
0.4538795053958893,
0.5270442366600037,
0.03533387929201126,
0.5949809551239014,
-0.5750681161880493,
0.18618322908878326,
0.42935416102409363,
0.3454325497150421,
0.2590988278388977,
-0.6130269169807434,
-0.45620572566986084,
0.07752084732055664,
0.01828988455235958,
-0.6144348978996277,
0.14838020503520966,
0.34731027483940125,
0.8140422105789185,
0.7504425644874573,
-0.04787835851311684,
0.935383141040802,
-0.4853847622871399,
0.6444661021232605,
0.007175919134169817,
-0.5446982383728027,
-0.06283185631036758,
-0.4715733230113983,
-0.2204481065273285,
0.6198275685310364,
0.230953186750412,
0.25875306129455566,
-0.49043911695480347,
-0.7576332688331604,
-0.8436015844345093,
0.5646541714668274,
0.1771460622549057,
-0.026484284549951553,
0.009474643506109715,
0.5078795552253723,
0.4166085124015808,
0.2625400424003601,
-0.33381786942481995,
-0.23731465637683868,
0.11798791587352753,
-0.2225344032049179,
-0.08439115434885025,
-0.641469419002533,
0.09316366165876389,
-0.4543493390083313,
0.6165815591812134,
0.06162049248814583,
0.138521209359169,
-0.20986682176589966,
-0.3479880392551422,
-0.07682987302541733,
-0.06857020407915115,
0.5798591375350952,
0.5964179635047913,
-0.2189684361219406,
-0.01521327905356884,
0.37061718106269836,
-0.2794552743434906,
-0.11122924089431763,
0.178745836019516,
-0.27118411660194397,
0.041708435863256454,
0.4471316933631897,
1.1052871942520142,
0.6878851652145386,
-0.6685786247253418,
0.4219229221343994,
0.12530416250228882,
-0.4630809724330902,
-0.008708574809134007,
0.5008577108383179,
0.11493642628192902,
0.10144180804491043,
0.3570997416973114,
0.21821805834770203,
0.2467534989118576,
-0.13975584506988525,
-0.046721238642930984,
0.41852185130119324,
0.2241552472114563,
-0.3461013436317444,
0.751030683517456,
0.4736333191394806,
0.07652362436056137,
0.4951399862766266,
-0.12811478972434998,
-0.39803823828697205,
0.42218470573425293,
0.4127338230609894,
0.7520507574081421,
-0.22214248776435852,
-0.2470124214887619,
0.14661480486392975,
0.16803580522537231,
-0.25568366050720215,
0.15856832265853882,
-0.36920860409736633,
-0.6701422929763794,
-0.7165451645851135,
-0.4577341377735138,
-0.4017479717731476,
-0.013513521291315556,
-0.5566056966781616,
0.016752950847148895,
-0.5463530421257019,
0.0018273864407092333,
-0.3068203330039978,
0.022383665665984154,
-0.3555440306663513,
0.3209799826145172,
0.15723426640033722,
0.8579036593437195,
-0.9300978779792786,
0.7687139511108398,
0.5984735488891602,
-0.13985326886177063,
-0.5947116017341614,
-0.34472179412841797,
-0.24357737600803375,
-0.9517021179199219,
0.38149070739746094,
0.02194724604487419,
-0.13427315652370453,
0.05759831517934799,
-0.6368972063064575,
-0.7269719839096069,
0.9463980793952942,
0.6589059233665466,
-0.6559820771217346,
0.08887849748134613,
-0.06837456673383713,
0.2779236137866974,
-0.1958412230014801,
0.4558354914188385,
0.34558114409446716,
0.16031920909881592,
0.01757553033530712,
-0.7747133374214172,
-0.40284913778305054,
-0.31395432353019714,
0.07020994275808334,
0.1515827178955078,
-0.7706310749053955,
1.3168476819992065,
-0.06490229070186615,
0.004243551287800074,
0.1733330935239792,
1.2005184888839722,
0.4213683605194092,
0.15112774074077606,
0.6962640285491943,
0.8892195820808411,
0.6557570099830627,
0.1683977097272873,
1.039440631866455,
-0.6206672787666321,
0.30207404494285583,
0.7498027086257935,
-0.33829474449157715,
0.7850373983383179,
0.3056296408176422,
-0.1774502396583557,
0.3192709684371948,
0.732148289680481,
0.20030635595321655,
0.35640183091163635,
-0.1896549016237259,
-0.44882580637931824,
-0.7464547753334045,
0.21587254106998444,
-0.494078129529953,
-0.05673186480998993,
0.4885273873806,
-0.023787131533026695,
-0.19746671617031097,
-0.11082738637924194,
0.09436789155006409,
0.01254204474389553,
-0.3085680902004242,
0.6253034472465515,
0.048043590039014816,
-0.4832933247089386,
0.7959527969360352,
0.08233247697353363,
0.9163087606430054,
-0.6040336489677429,
0.20173068344593048,
-0.26344338059425354,
0.13861821591854095,
-0.11679781228303909,
-0.5209547877311707,
-0.034152768552303314,
0.025849098339676857,
-0.3734024465084076,
-0.1622534990310669,
0.6948104500770569,
-0.6756816506385803,
-0.5411683917045593,
0.18469920754432678,
0.4375080168247223,
0.18516363203525543,
-0.22951562702655792,
-0.9295254349708557,
-0.07979477941989899,
-0.21696843206882477,
-0.25858137011528015,
0.4892122745513916,
0.5571998357772827,
0.06476100534200668,
0.8488916158676147,
0.514142632484436,
0.12330255657434464,
0.7143421769142151,
0.03282347694039345,
1.00400972366333,
-0.14990954101085663,
-0.6036715507507324,
-0.6384974718093872,
0.40712255239486694,
-0.012495066039264202,
-0.29119423031806946,
0.7595242261886597,
0.6424074769020081,
0.7843624949455261,
-0.050943344831466675,
0.9101393818855286,
-0.01534340437501669,
0.5045915246009827,
-0.7123161554336548,
0.6506168842315674,
-0.8576861619949341,
0.2345074713230133,
-0.06811659038066864,
-0.9212539792060852,
0.05583161488175392,
0.6887111067771912,
-0.5053679943084717,
0.5550661683082581,
0.19469797611236572,
0.8052488565444946,
-0.48856133222579956,
-0.11870841681957245,
0.3746792674064636,
0.3387307822704315,
0.04591744393110275,
0.5017608404159546,
0.7939339876174927,
-0.2185152769088745,
0.11477746814489365,
-0.5963256359100342,
-0.22346414625644684,
-0.5988000631332397,
-0.5524879097938538,
-0.9787507057189941,
-0.40214529633522034,
-0.3300733268260956,
0.04559963569045067,
-0.05417337641119957,
0.9306605458259583,
0.9791892766952515,
-0.6718982458114624,
-0.3362407386302948,
-0.05409254506230354,
-0.11350198835134506,
-0.14501312375068665,
-0.21684987843036652,
0.012412513606250286,
-0.3637333810329437,
-0.8291708827018738,
0.5032958984375,
0.34710991382598877,
-0.11120390892028809,
-0.5331364870071411,
-0.31781041622161865,
-0.03654126822948456,
0.19417846202850342,
0.4614674150943756,
0.134732186794281,
-0.732658863067627,
0.1821068525314331,
-0.22427143156528473,
-0.16246633231639862,
-0.09307099878787994,
0.6427785754203796,
-0.6636205911636353,
0.43271583318710327,
0.588520348072052,
1.0282347202301025,
0.3735254406929016,
-0.09535541385412216,
0.6420857310295105,
-0.4805549085140228,
0.4998890459537506,
0.3480381965637207,
0.599157989025116,
0.18110330402851105,
-0.21757182478904724,
0.1528107076883316,
0.6892560720443726,
-0.4652705490589142,
-0.9014385938644409,
0.16074107587337494,
-1.05936861038208,
-0.3548831343650818,
1.2795705795288086,
0.025643115863204002,
-0.13612163066864014,
-0.1559460312128067,
-0.23372957110404968,
-0.0582616962492466,
-0.6141172647476196,
0.6668733954429626,
0.5912891626358032,
0.08970502763986588,
-0.25041213631629944,
-0.5121949911117554,
0.014904096722602844,
0.9014223217964172,
-0.42501890659332275,
-0.16590304672718048,
0.41951048374176025,
0.36193469166755676,
-0.2803639769554138,
0.7133821845054626,
0.3881864845752716,
0.1833304613828659,
0.30315572023391724,
0.028128134086728096,
-0.2648119032382965,
-0.48359087109565735,
-0.07054948061704636,
-0.05581096559762955,
0.016918621957302094,
0.1481524258852005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05560v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05560v1
|
Chinese Sequence Labeling with Semi-Supervised Boundary-Aware Language Model Pre-training
| 2024-04-08T14:32:52 | 2024-04-08T14:32:52 |
Longhui Zhang, Dingkun Long, Meishan Zhang, Yanzhao Zhang, Pengjun Xie, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chinese sequence labeling tasks are heavily reliant on accurate word boundary
demarcation. Although current pre-trained language models (PLMs) have achieved
substantial gains on these tasks, they rarely explicitly incorporate boundary
information into the modeling process. An exception to this is BABERT, which
incorporates unsupervised statistical boundary information into Chinese BERT's
pre-training objectives. Building upon this approach, we input supervised
high-quality boundary information to enhance BABERT's learning, developing a
semi-supervised boundary-aware PLM. To assess PLMs' ability to encode
boundaries, we introduce a novel ``Boundary Information Metric'' that is both
simple and effective. This metric allows comparison of different PLMs without
task-specific fine-tuning. Experimental results on Chinese sequence labeling
datasets demonstrate that the improved BABERT variant outperforms the vanilla
version, not only on these tasks but also more broadly across a range of
Chinese natural language understanding tasks. Additionally, our proposed metric
offers a convenient and accurate means of evaluating PLMs' boundary awareness.
|
[
-0.36647406220436096,
-0.6793866753578186,
0.23449109494686127,
0.48239266872406006,
-0.3390108048915863,
-0.02149006724357605,
-0.3132835030555725,
-0.4656710624694824,
-0.14094308018684387,
0.5928798317909241,
-0.2540748417377472,
-0.7673589587211609,
-0.34200751781463623,
-0.1322997808456421,
-0.15318328142166138,
0.9498085975646973,
0.07495812326669693,
0.0017036834033206105,
-0.12856873869895935,
0.26287299394607544,
-0.3170565068721771,
-0.6635750532150269,
-0.41099077463150024,
-0.46738898754119873,
0.30693989992141724,
-0.007252386771142483,
0.6386256217956543,
0.8737398386001587,
0.5098085403442383,
0.18132880330085754,
-0.28964897990226746,
0.44414299726486206,
-0.0685877725481987,
-0.3826201558113098,
0.042951904237270355,
-0.21938616037368774,
-0.7241429090499878,
-0.1740681529045105,
1.1440075635910034,
0.9661738276481628,
0.09755482524633408,
0.11934690922498703,
0.2798762917518616,
0.669707179069519,
-0.4550956189632416,
0.13376857340335846,
-0.327108770608902,
0.5027757287025452,
-0.6252648830413818,
-0.148199200630188,
-0.7310672402381897,
-0.1741860806941986,
0.38863688707351685,
-0.49873408675193787,
0.0025992291048169136,
-0.10435015708208084,
1.0729200839996338,
0.26995569467544556,
-0.21979369223117828,
0.3248998820781708,
-0.6865313053131104,
0.4411165416240692,
-0.7705792188644409,
0.7759228944778442,
0.41182270646095276,
-0.024403976276516914,
-0.23737549781799316,
-0.8081566095352173,
-0.3103760778903961,
0.026797164231538773,
-0.14564922451972961,
0.34690725803375244,
0.1042090505361557,
0.26940733194351196,
0.24415771663188934,
0.38632267713546753,
-0.6667540073394775,
0.3053600490093231,
-0.31138232350349426,
-0.6435162425041199,
0.6342573165893555,
0.011777406558394432,
0.41849175095558167,
-0.13734550774097443,
-0.8318912386894226,
0.015316612087190151,
-0.5383360385894775,
0.3549383878707886,
0.2474292367696762,
0.5285072326660156,
-0.2588261067867279,
0.21049803495407104,
0.005662206094712019,
1.232986569404602,
-0.13665823638439178,
0.16696003079414368,
0.31060582399368286,
-0.10741909593343735,
-0.1255086213350296,
0.08940012753009796,
0.8886650800704956,
0.35756829380989075,
0.15880610048770905,
-0.1851060539484024,
-0.3128948509693146,
-0.14586293697357178,
-0.030702780932188034,
-0.6779860854148865,
-0.5472977161407471,
0.16373571753501892,
-0.0810362845659256,
0.43267378211021423,
0.41293978691101074,
-0.4450012445449829,
-0.2950543165206909,
-0.17452296614646912,
0.16431014239788055,
-0.5861356854438782,
-0.11545287817716599,
0.23446856439113617,
-0.11287861317396164,
0.5133007168769836,
0.22168304026126862,
-0.47830814123153687,
-0.0692439153790474,
0.5162137150764465,
1.03128981590271,
-0.359308660030365,
-0.41241323947906494,
-0.6576331257820129,
-0.02942974865436554,
-0.3432583212852478,
0.8973492980003357,
-0.43825235962867737,
-0.49183687567710876,
-0.05707274377346039,
0.04006268084049225,
0.12320994585752487,
-0.6394014954566956,
0.5225306153297424,
-0.4855363667011261,
0.054803960025310516,
-0.22122743725776672,
-0.6418085694313049,
-0.14497892558574677,
0.10639888048171997,
-0.5754761099815369,
1.1691373586654663,
-0.11088601499795914,
-0.8664090633392334,
0.2168118953704834,
-0.535021185874939,
-0.8115678429603577,
0.32593804597854614,
0.16816113889217377,
-0.3380768299102783,
-0.19716714322566986,
0.06692364811897278,
0.5122721195220947,
0.12263399362564087,
0.292275995016098,
-0.08253445476293564,
-0.21219679713249207,
0.1930619776248932,
-0.37078607082366943,
0.8268470764160156,
0.15855245292186737,
0.055551111698150635,
0.14226675033569336,
-0.6217750310897827,
0.21208477020263672,
-0.12441407144069672,
-0.32156291604042053,
-0.5276764035224915,
-0.2513989210128784,
-0.1363086849451065,
0.12298424541950226,
0.6568361520767212,
-0.4362832009792328,
-0.2108784168958664,
-0.5911183953285217,
0.059834420680999756,
0.6763274073600769,
-0.10152915120124817,
0.4210576117038727,
-0.282081663608551,
0.049639973789453506,
0.20077510178089142,
0.03414151817560196,
-0.08511778712272644,
-0.48208168148994446,
-0.687335193157196,
-0.2761412560939789,
0.5742889046669006,
0.626750648021698,
-0.6604297161102295,
0.8996281027793884,
0.02692323550581932,
-0.633706271648407,
-0.5476316809654236,
0.19179068505764008,
0.5259285569190979,
0.39743441343307495,
0.4214063584804535,
-0.8618639707565308,
-0.5408591032028198,
-0.6463454365730286,
-0.29855871200561523,
-0.06517284363508224,
-0.024746088311076164,
0.07790237665176392,
0.11156483739614487,
-0.05462149903178215,
1.1067923307418823,
-0.5245591402053833,
-0.318010151386261,
-0.20158268511295319,
0.30816760659217834,
0.09477874636650085,
0.42260298132896423,
0.16574136912822723,
-0.9421980977058411,
-0.5976549386978149,
0.04911487177014351,
-0.5594861507415771,
-0.4447234272956848,
-0.1317625194787979,
-0.4881093204021454,
0.049749333411455154,
0.15111006796360016,
-0.12811338901519775,
0.44243425130844116,
0.4375719428062439,
-0.24499371647834778,
0.6012659668922424,
-0.3836052119731903,
-0.3303922116756439,
-0.6703186631202698,
0.006769873667508364,
0.47597187757492065,
-0.19133061170578003,
-1.116114616394043,
-0.24575087428092957,
0.3807337284088135,
0.286602258682251,
-0.7669628858566284,
0.6894835829734802,
-0.6446332335472107,
-0.18733227252960205,
-0.2852850556373596,
0.1687246412038803,
0.06872834265232086,
0.5606078505516052,
0.659276008605957,
0.4300457239151001,
0.5366695523262024,
-0.8828911781311035,
0.18508459627628326,
0.22504037618637085,
-0.29297730326652527,
0.3243541419506073,
-0.42324012517929077,
0.22810733318328857,
0.0203211959451437,
0.14839090406894684,
-0.862249493598938,
0.09445958584547043,
0.07933646440505981,
-0.4148638844490051,
0.21178707480430603,
-0.05125966668128967,
-0.5442814826965332,
-0.37875622510910034,
-0.1843414157629013,
0.31025978922843933,
0.6669230461120605,
-0.5056973695755005,
0.26922938227653503,
0.5238476991653442,
-0.015526763163506985,
-0.48456448316574097,
-0.6980205178260803,
-0.23135904967784882,
-0.051392823457717896,
-0.33855104446411133,
0.3845226764678955,
-0.0554431676864624,
0.16031618416309357,
-0.2527657747268677,
-0.18554358184337616,
-0.2468104064464569,
0.172539621591568,
0.12426644563674927,
0.2063262015581131,
-0.07509826868772507,
-0.07249560207128525,
-0.03839237615466118,
-0.025687027722597122,
0.15667375922203064,
-0.5419700741767883,
0.5737630724906921,
-0.21176016330718994,
-0.14357571303844452,
-0.5474852919578552,
-0.1486724317073822,
0.01206911075860262,
-0.8632370829582214,
0.49990084767341614,
0.6346451640129089,
-0.6881116032600403,
-0.49149468541145325,
-0.13338814675807953,
-0.06547723710536957,
-0.43281304836273193,
0.36845850944519043,
-0.3595253527164459,
-0.7565099596977234,
0.6290106177330017,
-0.22975528240203857,
0.18140263855457306,
0.3460327982902527,
0.4698394536972046,
-0.20056836307048798,
0.721200168132782,
0.838459312915802,
-0.0016610263846814632,
0.4983772039413452,
-0.1319342702627182,
0.09354079514741898,
-0.9447087645530701,
-0.2803671956062317,
-0.1435643583536148,
0.0015428437618538737,
-0.3132129907608032,
-0.6349236965179443,
0.2282295525074005,
-0.034359514713287354,
-0.1387282758951187,
0.4269504249095917,
-0.5604667067527771,
0.32353854179382324,
0.5654515027999878,
0.2609064280986786,
0.25673946738243103,
-0.29256293177604675,
-0.0040787598118186,
-0.08299162983894348,
-0.6086171865463257,
-0.5178374648094177,
0.4413776695728302,
0.38824883103370667,
0.7803849577903748,
-0.1405593752861023,
0.5454287528991699,
0.4579043686389923,
0.11067068576812744,
-0.5208531618118286,
0.6723482608795166,
-0.4737450182437897,
-0.4259333312511444,
-0.49291667342185974,
-0.368347704410553,
-0.8746169209480286,
0.3449878394603729,
0.029190653935074806,
-0.9300901889801025,
-0.08672896027565002,
0.12501411139965057,
-0.5043115615844727,
0.4535832703113556,
-0.534369170665741,
1.0769685506820679,
-0.5542513728141785,
-0.24224358797073364,
0.5127367973327637,
-0.9115978479385376,
0.10942094773054123,
-0.30117493867874146,
0.07986501604318619,
-0.24736270308494568,
0.11211870610713959,
1.0349376201629639,
-0.3908628225326538,
1.1666392087936401,
-0.3171447813510895,
-0.39244845509529114,
0.5689741969108582,
-0.07040882855653763,
0.14326810836791992,
-0.2895013988018036,
0.20327875018119812,
0.36573025584220886,
-0.13986584544181824,
-0.33067646622657776,
-0.3601933717727661,
0.13248544931411743,
-0.6040936708450317,
-0.608592689037323,
-0.3412754237651825,
-0.6630244851112366,
-0.16739492118358612,
0.39643189311027527,
0.29855793714523315,
0.19658342003822327,
-0.16965188086032867,
-0.2044355571269989,
0.7434505820274353,
-0.46874457597732544,
0.18380175530910492,
0.4536162316799164,
-0.2399042844772339,
0.08678916841745377,
0.8895621299743652,
0.3274022936820984,
0.28133487701416016,
0.6871979236602783,
0.1991734802722931,
-0.46880945563316345,
-0.3585100471973419,
-0.4228372573852539,
0.1270523965358734,
-0.510348379611969,
-0.01621098816394806,
-0.6358996033668518,
-0.7733244299888611,
-0.2894146144390106,
0.14148899912834167,
-0.5019346475601196,
0.10226500779390335,
-0.0383264496922493,
0.03283264487981796,
0.1921822875738144,
0.5308476686477661,
-0.1804051399230957,
0.4980740249156952,
-0.998633086681366,
0.032169159501791,
-0.13114511966705322,
0.4347510039806366,
-0.17710936069488525,
-0.9672046899795532,
-0.5312753915786743,
0.1987553983926773,
-0.27640092372894287,
-0.954547643661499,
0.32804155349731445,
0.18446318805217743,
0.5260559320449829,
0.44431424140930176,
0.43072783946990967,
0.5856022834777832,
-0.586449921131134,
0.7591782808303833,
-0.06312001496553421,
-1.1379464864730835,
0.7340821027755737,
-0.04321206733584404,
0.555830717086792,
-0.1708415150642395,
0.33578747510910034,
-0.6265401840209961,
-0.6541094779968262,
-0.46810901165008545,
-0.8158003687858582,
0.5849015712738037,
-0.08838917315006256,
0.0012573323911055923,
0.20325303077697754,
0.09708680957555771,
0.3306643068790436,
-0.03515666350722313,
-0.6919962167739868,
-0.29677483439445496,
-0.15148302912712097,
-0.07317185401916504,
-0.04631979763507843,
0.06418261677026749,
0.15699204802513123,
-0.327095627784729,
0.5532822608947754,
0.03779258579015732,
0.1919073909521103,
0.2795166075229645,
-0.37554022669792175,
0.26289379596710205,
0.18980900943279266,
0.33983418345451355,
0.38645946979522705,
-0.277106374502182,
0.41209542751312256,
0.4660370647907257,
-0.44671082496643066,
0.052808139473199844,
0.3675980567932129,
-0.14726290106773376,
0.20320799946784973,
0.3569854497909546,
0.8309294581413269,
-0.3794004023075104,
-0.5793136954307556,
0.346140056848526,
0.1931675523519516,
0.00459981057792902,
-0.13504888117313385,
-0.12284071743488312,
0.011020345613360405,
0.09000343084335327,
0.17826297879219055,
-0.2524387538433075,
0.23561133444309235,
-0.16939547657966614,
0.6096345782279968,
0.22806555032730103,
-0.6238532662391663,
-0.5921581387519836,
0.5279946327209473,
0.23414088785648346,
-0.15152311325073242,
0.45552417635917664,
-0.33501869440078735,
-0.8742743730545044,
0.5434688329696655,
0.5686440467834473,
0.536034882068634,
-0.3956594169139862,
0.2261047512292862,
0.19121000170707703,
0.4660060405731201,
-0.03497401997447014,
0.3336542248725891,
-0.12343020737171173,
-1.0129927396774292,
-0.45168066024780273,
-0.5443788170814514,
-0.4997899830341339,
0.006706458982080221,
-0.7582594156265259,
0.17478682100772858,
-0.6741663217544556,
-0.48348215222358704,
-0.07212905585765839,
-0.08581078052520752,
-0.6920798420906067,
0.5146702527999878,
0.6447267532348633,
0.9909119606018066,
-0.9502227902412415,
0.8643766641616821,
1.0650184154510498,
-0.09869907796382904,
-0.692741870880127,
0.08678139001131058,
-0.2539812922477722,
-0.6623445153236389,
0.5821691751480103,
0.44635578989982605,
-0.11511427164077759,
0.05341864004731178,
-0.2629965543746948,
-0.4162006378173828,
0.6419084072113037,
0.26618441939353943,
-0.36712056398391724,
0.22975432872772217,
0.3312504291534424,
0.5952246785163879,
-0.05993286147713661,
0.19111524522304535,
0.5938798785209656,
0.5640736222267151,
-0.11452704668045044,
-1.0020549297332764,
0.005038106814026833,
-0.2815990149974823,
0.11106187850236893,
0.3470318019390106,
-0.9292957782745361,
0.6232208609580994,
-0.36063066124916077,
-0.6153388619422913,
-0.1557159423828125,
1.1892716884613037,
-0.007407716941088438,
0.3973448574542999,
0.5799385905265808,
0.3661479651927948,
1.00089693069458,
-0.45254725217819214,
0.6014135479927063,
-0.26688656210899353,
0.1957935243844986,
1.096578598022461,
-0.3565831184387207,
0.721502959728241,
0.1744404286146164,
-0.19329680502414703,
0.38052380084991455,
1.131464958190918,
-0.003196439705789089,
0.5452956557273865,
0.5037053227424622,
-0.000123864650959149,
-0.41460782289505005,
-0.5798574090003967,
-0.34497320652008057,
0.3955431580543518,
0.33652713894844055,
0.01572851836681366,
-0.07508339732885361,
-0.027213403955101967,
-0.023585323244333267,
0.15531490743160248,
-0.23466888070106506,
0.8012683987617493,
0.2436496615409851,
-0.3824825584888458,
0.4957384765148163,
0.07767349481582642,
0.7916943430900574,
-0.5333841443061829,
0.14168670773506165,
-0.34969714283943176,
0.040357910096645355,
-0.32877087593078613,
-1.1708592176437378,
-0.00920065212994814,
0.18343518674373627,
0.17984971404075623,
-0.10733640938997269,
0.6260542273521423,
-0.795447587966919,
-0.22898413240909576,
0.3344312310218811,
0.687248945236206,
0.4586116671562195,
0.08823518455028534,
-0.5406544208526611,
-0.1849888265132904,
-0.05411284789443016,
-0.17623218894004822,
0.04661984369158745,
0.6922507882118225,
-0.25495705008506775,
0.47400879859924316,
0.3937683701515198,
0.3672046959400177,
0.17117583751678467,
0.17811110615730286,
0.546757698059082,
-0.8600592017173767,
-0.785431444644928,
-1.0315877199172974,
0.6937229037284851,
-0.17604714632034302,
-0.26098722219467163,
0.738802433013916,
0.6800728440284729,
1.2501530647277832,
0.10036356002092361,
1.0248773097991943,
0.18816323578357697,
0.1327666938304901,
-0.5745843648910522,
0.6261733174324036,
-0.5109213590621948,
0.10892565548419952,
-0.16148951649665833,
-0.9818779826164246,
-0.5133335590362549,
0.5402312874794006,
-0.4092978537082672,
0.03848922252655029,
0.5233880281448364,
0.6313956379890442,
0.08020255714654922,
-0.0008467657607980072,
0.4283231496810913,
0.11834161728620529,
0.09184101969003677,
0.8440409302711487,
1.120116114616394,
-0.09255906939506531,
0.11467313021421432,
-0.4223957657814026,
-0.425932377576828,
0.15807393193244934,
-0.8230366110801697,
-1.091050624847412,
-0.7175723910331726,
-0.35271161794662476,
-0.10888918489217758,
0.17391453683376312,
0.7987157106399536,
0.7205304503440857,
-0.7344701886177063,
-0.2953174114227295,
0.6048843860626221,
0.01875428482890129,
-0.26316332817077637,
-0.15335588157176971,
0.6502150297164917,
-0.24752119183540344,
-0.7578939199447632,
-0.0036699525080621243,
0.36315226554870605,
0.3397332727909088,
-0.048893313854932785,
-0.26414141058921814,
-0.08433865755796432,
-0.08981551229953766,
0.343701034784317,
0.358574777841568,
-0.5947446227073669,
-0.2729139029979706,
0.019049903377890587,
-0.24149926006793976,
0.22921429574489594,
0.48317620158195496,
-0.3913842439651489,
0.6101040244102478,
0.45355913043022156,
1.0190144777297974,
0.19074702262878418,
0.182309091091156,
0.6311247944831848,
-0.9677419662475586,
0.06090028956532478,
0.018156027421355247,
0.3932226002216339,
0.6410762667655945,
-0.41839703917503357,
0.3997473120689392,
0.17635075747966766,
-0.1865687221288681,
-0.7940431833267212,
0.1267956793308258,
-0.8687111139297485,
-0.10421045869588852,
1.0705231428146362,
-0.4532894790172577,
-0.32240593433380127,
0.13290870189666748,
-0.15773551166057587,
0.6881874203681946,
-0.20967592298984528,
0.3107151985168457,
0.748528003692627,
-0.036255717277526855,
-0.0780058279633522,
-0.3660021722316742,
0.41603145003318787,
0.6049609780311584,
-0.7388615608215332,
0.21872715651988983,
0.1451297402381897,
-0.10495088994503021,
0.12366912513971329,
0.5969612002372742,
-0.05736738443374634,
0.2840721607208252,
-0.3084705173969269,
0.4333975315093994,
0.07230255752801895,
-0.47066622972488403,
-0.026937335729599,
-0.29577094316482544,
0.2522256076335907,
-0.30723509192466736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05545v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05545v1
|
Evaluating Interventional Reasoning Capabilities of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-08T14:15:56 | 2024-04-08T14:15:56 |
Tejas Kasetty, Divyat Mahajan, Gintare Karolina Dziugaite, Alexandre Drouin, Dhanya Sridhar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ME
|
Numerous decision-making tasks require estimating causal effects under
interventions on different parts of a system. As practitioners consider using
large language models (LLMs) to automate decisions, studying their causal
reasoning capabilities becomes crucial. A recent line of work evaluates LLMs
ability to retrieve commonsense causal facts, but these evaluations do not
sufficiently assess how LLMs reason about interventions. Motivated by the role
that interventions play in causal inference, in this paper, we conduct
empirical analyses to evaluate whether LLMs can accurately update their
knowledge of a data-generating process in response to an intervention. We
create benchmarks that span diverse causal graphs (e.g., confounding,
mediation) and variable types, and enable a study of intervention-based
reasoning. These benchmarks allow us to isolate the ability of LLMs to
accurately predict changes resulting from their ability to memorize facts or
find other shortcuts. Our analysis on four LLMs highlights that while GPT- 4
models show promising accuracy at predicting the intervention effects, they
remain sensitive to distracting factors in the prompts.
|
[
-0.11624857038259506,
-1.096838116645813,
1.1336637735366821,
0.29508769512176514,
0.08262480795383453,
-0.28657978773117065,
-0.4097335934638977,
-0.21077978610992432,
-0.36377066373825073,
0.3941718637943268,
-0.24617619812488556,
-0.37470537424087524,
-0.8049412965774536,
0.33979737758636475,
-0.22326457500457764,
0.5917249321937561,
-0.18668530881404877,
0.23846164345741272,
-0.12426114082336426,
0.03429688513278961,
-0.8768360018730164,
-0.27429407835006714,
-0.6913508176803589,
-0.3225141763687134,
0.8733808994293213,
0.3910607695579529,
0.49418747425079346,
0.5031284689903259,
0.5739386677742004,
0.4224684238433838,
-0.030330227687954903,
0.15308591723442078,
-0.4701947569847107,
-0.05460447445511818,
-0.47837936878204346,
-0.44177743792533875,
-0.08443755656480789,
-0.07051936537027359,
0.7630300521850586,
0.6983256936073303,
0.10530918091535568,
-0.004845816176384687,
0.17321515083312988,
0.37464168667793274,
-0.6318671107292175,
0.4147367775440216,
-0.6850943565368652,
-0.38930729031562805,
0.052086472511291504,
-0.18897171318531036,
-0.4423271417617798,
-0.5066336989402771,
0.19303596019744873,
-0.39449912309646606,
0.06179337576031685,
-0.09196043759584427,
0.3839336633682251,
0.544411301612854,
-0.5258549451828003,
-0.48395034670829773,
-0.7772127389907837,
0.794170081615448,
-0.8806096315383911,
0.20826831459999084,
0.5929944515228271,
0.2593661844730377,
-0.4912409782409668,
-0.7233054041862488,
-0.3389514684677124,
-0.5193443298339844,
-0.16323041915893555,
-0.1435445249080658,
-0.2839933931827545,
0.015245171263813972,
0.7755224108695984,
-0.02974845841526985,
-0.23521734774112701,
0.3473106026649475,
-0.264576256275177,
-0.20466746389865875,
0.688080906867981,
0.22807841002941132,
0.14070838689804077,
-0.1400163471698761,
-0.22299620509147644,
0.17382708191871643,
-0.7594210505485535,
-0.029107622802257538,
0.24212239682674408,
0.13288025557994843,
-0.07787153869867325,
0.6213822960853577,
-0.05085273087024689,
0.7165074348449707,
-0.026245644316077232,
-0.21853497624397278,
-0.050875283777713776,
-0.38002800941467285,
-0.43254759907722473,
-0.164958193898201,
0.7760800719261169,
0.2317977398633957,
0.1081310287117958,
-0.15080533921718597,
-0.08350370824337006,
-0.1448454111814499,
0.08989832550287247,
-0.6613920331001282,
0.0011252101976424456,
0.1078881174325943,
-0.1623842865228653,
0.07059024274349213,
-0.33168232440948486,
-0.30363351106643677,
-0.5114629864692688,
-0.45314377546310425,
0.5531938076019287,
-0.3908799886703491,
-0.07076093554496765,
0.33242034912109375,
-0.21628130972385406,
0.06856248527765274,
0.4824450612068176,
-0.6793860793113708,
0.012287716381251812,
0.6872984766960144,
0.6509979367256165,
-0.011839128099381924,
-0.303032249212265,
-0.49111422896385193,
0.1934308558702469,
-0.4160903990268707,
0.934088945388794,
-0.62211674451828,
-0.48022642731666565,
0.09989778697490692,
0.19654366374015808,
-0.4750744700431824,
-0.4299223721027374,
0.6239129900932312,
-0.448294460773468,
-0.0720929279923439,
-0.8440448045730591,
-0.7746944427490234,
-0.08670349419116974,
0.17682892084121704,
-0.6571520566940308,
0.48690706491470337,
-0.1284051537513733,
-0.7375606298446655,
0.5732964277267456,
-0.5757905840873718,
-0.39630115032196045,
-0.1902104616165161,
-0.1722903698682785,
-0.4123786687850952,
0.07091682404279709,
0.2768672704696655,
0.44565272331237793,
-0.5617231130599976,
0.768710196018219,
-0.6018423438072205,
-0.2318800538778305,
0.6636847853660583,
-0.7851938009262085,
0.5323066115379333,
0.016845183447003365,
-0.3811360001564026,
0.26058897376060486,
-0.4953882694244385,
-0.4451533555984497,
-0.08207879960536957,
-0.23564982414245605,
-0.3924718201160431,
0.12848582863807678,
-0.5037701725959778,
0.10121627897024155,
0.18781524896621704,
-0.46598193049430847,
0.16574808955192566,
-0.06949847936630249,
0.24868649244308472,
0.8053321838378906,
0.4634488821029663,
0.04545574635267258,
-0.2776488959789276,
0.3600645959377289,
-0.31984227895736694,
0.2540436089038849,
-0.040385037660598755,
-0.49479812383651733,
-0.3940138816833496,
-0.514991819858551,
0.0570683516561985,
0.17508240044116974,
-0.8539762496948242,
0.138086199760437,
-0.11384348571300507,
-0.37691953778266907,
0.1026008278131485,
0.06828239560127258,
0.45012497901916504,
0.705003559589386,
0.3582497239112854,
0.1060565859079361,
-0.24913489818572998,
-0.9115937948226929,
-0.5581304430961609,
-0.22093887627124786,
-0.0891536995768547,
0.49275457859039307,
0.7560836672782898,
-0.11824400722980499,
0.7760172486305237,
-0.35012635588645935,
0.13587918877601624,
-0.13370518386363983,
0.5652769804000854,
0.1655898541212082,
0.32193130254745483,
0.3551054894924164,
-0.3667503595352173,
-0.2534749507904053,
-0.18474045395851135,
-0.9127559065818787,
-0.5160195827484131,
-0.3910786509513855,
0.10963066667318344,
-0.053974658250808716,
0.7130155563354492,
-0.6429905891418457,
0.3720308542251587,
0.20801685750484467,
-0.24407535791397095,
0.7475591897964478,
-0.45700618624687195,
0.2838553786277771,
-0.35272958874702454,
0.3260567784309387,
0.022873124107718468,
0.187954381108284,
-0.5671145915985107,
-0.3931823670864105,
0.04022404924035072,
0.19681155681610107,
-0.28056657314300537,
0.6964787840843201,
-0.47976985573768616,
-0.1973682940006256,
-0.20118938386440277,
0.015763767063617706,
-0.1985694319009781,
0.35805830359458923,
0.08649327605962753,
0.811569333076477,
0.2671993672847748,
-0.5822257399559021,
-0.018802909180521965,
0.07780672609806061,
-0.5250268578529358,
0.4410494267940521,
-0.7357008457183838,
-0.09167765825986862,
-0.028829889371991158,
0.1302279382944107,
-0.9050254821777344,
-0.4084838330745697,
0.020570896565914154,
-0.034211449325084686,
0.09376242011785507,
-0.09734120219945908,
-0.5582055449485779,
-0.4509167969226837,
-0.14096638560295105,
0.17030549049377441,
0.028407393023371696,
-0.3395572900772095,
0.4811873137950897,
0.26966312527656555,
-0.19170819222927094,
-0.42251020669937134,
-0.33144140243530273,
0.13615182042121887,
-0.45117804408073425,
-0.3900015652179718,
-0.1889750361442566,
-0.10757122933864594,
-0.3524472713470459,
-0.06541655212640762,
0.012076228857040405,
0.12051019817590714,
0.2674139440059662,
0.15844233334064484,
0.1134629026055336,
0.054783888161182404,
0.46457964181900024,
0.13428768515586853,
-0.11288616806268692,
0.4318336248397827,
0.19158366322517395,
0.22345919907093048,
-0.0006919823354110122,
-0.8494987487792969,
-0.1506791114807129,
0.034756701439619064,
0.679389238357544,
-0.24370037019252777,
0.6367756128311157,
0.37674733996391296,
-0.21775181591510773,
0.08135784417390823,
-0.8093318939208984,
-0.19990865886211395,
-0.40771472454071045,
0.40438637137413025,
-0.2600748836994171,
-0.8789137601852417,
0.49629074335098267,
-0.311818927526474,
0.028032056987285614,
0.3033396899700165,
0.7773703336715698,
0.3113239109516144,
1.1274112462997437,
0.058688610792160034,
0.059861183166503906,
0.35738447308540344,
-0.11380776017904282,
0.21615386009216309,
-0.9694355726242065,
-0.2672274708747864,
-0.4970701336860657,
-0.0018225967651233077,
-0.3919220268726349,
-0.6525824069976807,
0.6353265643119812,
0.13660506904125214,
-0.5196995139122009,
0.08937063813209534,
-0.07048342376947403,
0.23120325803756714,
0.3696301579475403,
0.0630931556224823,
0.3194758892059326,
-0.3614906072616577,
0.06979163736104965,
0.23756973445415497,
-0.6876375675201416,
-0.5683793425559998,
1.1617292165756226,
0.4532473683357239,
0.8454515933990479,
0.1329270452260971,
0.3073750138282776,
0.22525998950004578,
0.8301892876625061,
-0.6622282266616821,
0.5322904586791992,
0.39787524938583374,
-0.47267043590545654,
-0.4762443006038666,
-0.42453643679618835,
-1.0804283618927002,
0.12173416465520859,
-0.17869411408901215,
-0.719505786895752,
0.3719967305660248,
0.2223493903875351,
-0.3299080431461334,
0.123050756752491,
-0.8056221604347229,
0.8352874517440796,
-0.37846481800079346,
-0.6517120599746704,
-0.481094092130661,
-0.24140845239162445,
0.4656951129436493,
-0.2949930429458618,
0.2274540513753891,
-0.13010273873806,
-0.01850009523332119,
0.49879127740859985,
-0.31549501419067383,
1.0077605247497559,
-0.28974947333335876,
-0.2909148633480072,
0.21278175711631775,
-0.1168847382068634,
0.5474972724914551,
0.05861112102866173,
-0.1503334492444992,
0.1955019235610962,
-0.21071909368038177,
-0.2290123850107193,
-0.7993356585502625,
0.6923044323921204,
-0.4653986692428589,
-1.074643611907959,
-0.2077965885400772,
-0.7414450645446777,
-0.5158585906028748,
0.09647541493177414,
-0.11945492774248123,
0.5005428791046143,
-0.35601332783699036,
0.14925110340118408,
0.48528701066970825,
-0.38520175218582153,
0.40910786390304565,
0.8827790021896362,
-0.03951598331332207,
-0.26300370693206787,
0.523570716381073,
0.28495731949806213,
0.3451261520385742,
0.08198878169059753,
0.48551416397094727,
-0.4543156325817108,
-0.741741955280304,
-0.35383808612823486,
0.5633032321929932,
-0.6471251249313354,
-0.029092587530612946,
-0.4895778000354767,
0.2928895354270935,
-0.18243099749088287,
-0.0058682928793132305,
-0.04498337209224701,
0.008462531492114067,
-0.11213859915733337,
-0.042123910039663315,
0.294132262468338,
0.8787151575088501,
-0.3559429347515106,
0.04510566592216492,
-0.6578696966171265,
0.047340814024209976,
0.6026440262794495,
0.2812381684780121,
0.24197494983673096,
-0.41297659277915955,
-0.4195968508720398,
-0.06347736716270447,
-0.12112278491258621,
-1.0081244707107544,
0.11118333041667938,
-0.23986275494098663,
0.6981512308120728,
0.4565248489379883,
-0.10463307797908783,
0.6314493417739868,
-0.6604644656181335,
0.6098277568817139,
0.06810522079467773,
-0.7401130199432373,
0.40985023975372314,
-0.5667915940284729,
0.3942398726940155,
0.13098226487636566,
0.5289345383644104,
-0.2870177924633026,
-0.4499344825744629,
-0.4488097131252289,
-0.49275606870651245,
0.43959811329841614,
0.09645173698663712,
-0.26477697491645813,
-0.41473591327667236,
0.2556682527065277,
-0.12609124183654785,
0.22329632937908173,
-0.3148411512374878,
0.19879555702209473,
0.10264231264591217,
0.013474718667566776,
-0.048786014318466187,
-0.3699781596660614,
-0.2893761098384857,
-0.2144090086221695,
0.5918886661529541,
-0.142765074968338,
0.09192600846290588,
0.29649078845977783,
-0.029845720157027245,
-0.0899900272488594,
0.36444664001464844,
0.783296525478363,
0.7874601483345032,
-0.013117613270878792,
-0.01867625303566456,
0.37649446725845337,
-0.12471666932106018,
0.01866999641060829,
0.25070860981941223,
-0.018141964450478554,
-0.30672499537467957,
0.8939305543899536,
0.9351569414138794,
0.48619821667671204,
-0.7886515855789185,
0.44818612933158875,
-0.04228973016142845,
-0.06385724991559982,
-0.15458816289901733,
0.1018325462937355,
0.1199776902794838,
0.47938093543052673,
0.07253644615411758,
-0.0708465725183487,
0.2095845490694046,
-0.4529748558998108,
0.06779909133911133,
0.6228420734405518,
-0.12517163157463074,
-0.3448401987552643,
0.4656508266925812,
0.05445033311843872,
-0.10119020938873291,
0.22941671311855316,
0.0025153730530291796,
-0.39169952273368835,
0.719612181186676,
0.5361570715904236,
0.7614427208900452,
-0.4104198217391968,
0.055637117475271225,
0.5488007664680481,
0.3961929380893707,
-0.11567312479019165,
0.032637063413858414,
0.12575773894786835,
-0.6703351140022278,
-0.8800613284111023,
-0.215973362326622,
-0.3982972204685211,
0.43840494751930237,
-0.4270726442337036,
0.04447692632675171,
-0.306865394115448,
-0.314012348651886,
0.1442173272371292,
-0.24809753894805908,
-0.7263464331626892,
-0.007482020650058985,
-0.08887182176113129,
0.7698438167572021,
-1.1054836511611938,
0.5971040725708008,
0.30133524537086487,
-0.503219723701477,
-0.9503025412559509,
-0.016182050108909607,
0.0032995527144521475,
-0.7398930191993713,
0.7844082117080688,
-0.05533473938703537,
-0.07760797441005707,
-0.30578848719596863,
-0.5687740445137024,
-0.9594438076019287,
0.8877514600753784,
0.433276891708374,
-0.5509121417999268,
0.17154240608215332,
0.2392546534538269,
0.5909416675567627,
-0.18238934874534607,
0.465891033411026,
0.8499352931976318,
0.8978049159049988,
-0.0803379938006401,
-0.9880580306053162,
0.170091450214386,
0.05856248363852501,
-0.007641928270459175,
0.018510136753320694,
-0.3034053146839142,
0.7718259692192078,
-0.30468183755874634,
-0.1253879964351654,
-0.042840663343667984,
0.3453506529331207,
0.27510401606559753,
0.247964546084404,
0.4761062562465668,
0.3874783515930176,
0.7945452928543091,
0.031911544501781464,
1.296852707862854,
-0.2643587589263916,
0.19631630182266235,
1.0936357975006104,
-0.41048866510391235,
0.52847820520401,
0.4299681484699249,
-0.027048442512750626,
0.5147179365158081,
0.3125336766242981,
0.09134514629840851,
0.37161514163017273,
0.16352491080760956,
-0.3500863015651703,
-0.33208778500556946,
-0.24333886802196503,
-0.06616649776697159,
0.23821686208248138,
0.5262354612350464,
-0.38153499364852905,
-0.20582979917526245,
0.05140938237309456,
0.3418544828891754,
0.013770490884780884,
-0.30393868684768677,
0.6966972947120667,
0.029072638601064682,
-1.0283735990524292,
0.5456258058547974,
-0.07011691480875015,
-0.07745787501335144,
-0.6804614067077637,
-0.33512404561042786,
-0.008664717897772789,
0.1676294207572937,
0.02409791573882103,
-0.8368643522262573,
0.2261989414691925,
0.09051638096570969,
-0.001560745295137167,
0.051430583000183105,
0.7551635503768921,
-0.34374096989631653,
-0.32554617524147034,
0.24871689081192017,
0.5547590255737305,
-0.015624450519680977,
0.14938759803771973,
-0.6144682765007019,
0.1640833020210266,
-0.07441017031669617,
-0.34717971086502075,
0.16210021078586578,
0.5101916790008545,
-0.4191029667854309,
0.6589329242706299,
0.8138307929039001,
0.2359243780374527,
-0.2062506526708603,
0.3299146890640259,
0.7656175494194031,
-0.4776831865310669,
-0.0929650291800499,
-0.9326772689819336,
0.27957919239997864,
-0.21132686734199524,
-0.1773892492055893,
0.9676833748817444,
0.31617259979248047,
0.3562277853488922,
-0.08288341760635376,
0.8009459376335144,
0.23683622479438782,
0.4555627107620239,
-0.6777331829071045,
0.22495292127132416,
-0.2465682029724121,
0.5153976678848267,
-0.27115586400032043,
-0.4297720193862915,
-0.2119249552488327,
0.4075653553009033,
-1.2211369276046753,
0.061727482825517654,
0.7275568246841431,
0.8926429152488708,
0.09239719063043594,
0.10459832102060318,
0.3261411488056183,
0.5556719303131104,
0.5513496994972229,
0.4046609103679657,
0.9433386921882629,
0.14110806584358215,
0.04284822195768356,
0.19225583970546722,
-0.46434223651885986,
-0.14150922000408173,
-1.1423046588897705,
-1.0109739303588867,
-0.3063647449016571,
-0.08516330271959305,
0.025191454216837883,
0.09072034806013107,
0.6811084151268005,
0.1327032744884491,
-0.4972396492958069,
-0.11979612708091736,
-0.13806995749473572,
0.38237836956977844,
-0.2615891993045807,
-0.16432885825634003,
0.7709026336669922,
-0.476453959941864,
-0.5870738625526428,
0.5095160007476807,
0.365518182516098,
-0.4018995463848114,
-0.32524529099464417,
-0.01672598160803318,
-0.30194419622421265,
0.45530906319618225,
0.6604949235916138,
0.33404284715652466,
-0.7088844180107117,
-0.620922863483429,
-0.20097516477108002,
0.05064307525753975,
-0.32937708497047424,
1.067918300628662,
-0.6257835030555725,
0.42919421195983887,
0.48323288559913635,
0.6307803392410278,
0.3069438636302948,
-0.17908772826194763,
0.6655293703079224,
-0.3006300926208496,
-0.08506736904382706,
0.026417521759867668,
0.7358611822128296,
0.40734726190567017,
-0.17134004831314087,
0.4972798824310303,
0.19212156534194946,
-0.876205563545227,
-0.6772489547729492,
0.24159465730190277,
-0.33261838555336,
-0.3354153335094452,
1.3641504049301147,
-0.38232049345970154,
-0.04646024480462074,
-0.40459394454956055,
-0.27919477224349976,
0.23323774337768555,
-0.13817380368709564,
0.8118119835853577,
0.6331400871276855,
-0.25312191247940063,
0.004135302733629942,
-0.6000067591667175,
0.6036587953567505,
0.3374093770980835,
-0.8716752529144287,
0.28827744722366333,
0.8227518796920776,
0.2990722954273224,
0.02542865090072155,
0.7590984106063843,
-0.08313024789094925,
0.33746030926704407,
-0.19738741219043732,
-0.20620732009410858,
-0.11821102350950241,
-0.2151229828596115,
-0.32024431228637695,
-0.14842264354228973,
0.17794036865234375,
0.32034045457839966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05540v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05540v1
|
OPSD: an Offensive Persian Social media Dataset and its baseline evaluations
| 2024-04-08T14:08:56 | 2024-04-08T14:08:56 |
Mehran Safayani, Amir Sartipi, Amir Hossein Ahmadi, Parniyan Jalali, Amir Hossein Mansouri, Mohammad Bisheh-Niasar, Zahra Pourbahman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The proliferation of hate speech and offensive comments on social media has
become increasingly prevalent due to user activities. Such comments can have
detrimental effects on individuals' psychological well-being and social
behavior. While numerous datasets in the English language exist in this domain,
few equivalent resources are available for Persian language. To address this
gap, this paper introduces two offensive datasets. The first dataset comprises
annotations provided by domain experts, while the second consists of a large
collection of unlabeled data obtained through web crawling for unsupervised
learning purposes. To ensure the quality of the former dataset, a meticulous
three-stage labeling process was conducted, and kappa measures were computed to
assess inter-annotator agreement. Furthermore, experiments were performed on
the dataset using state-of-the-art language models, both with and without
employing masked language modeling techniques, as well as machine learning
algorithms, in order to establish the baselines for the dataset using
contemporary cutting-edge approaches. The obtained F1-scores for the
three-class and two-class versions of the dataset were 76.9% and 89.9% for
XLM-RoBERTa, respectively.
|
[
-0.5307280421257019,
-0.9887388944625854,
0.0534079484641552,
0.07432842999696732,
-0.4020352065563202,
0.4329252243041992,
-0.5532357692718506,
-0.3460485339164734,
-0.015531320124864578,
0.37004533410072327,
-0.3179761469364166,
-0.5858525633811951,
-0.8226589560508728,
0.09654715657234192,
-0.6756918430328369,
1.2001519203186035,
0.2567601501941681,
-0.06872529536485672,
0.3154144883155823,
-0.3265540897846222,
-0.20377971231937408,
-0.41403231024742126,
-0.4959023594856262,
0.24611182510852814,
0.3615124523639679,
0.5646048188209534,
0.9167025685310364,
0.2634827494621277,
0.42670950293540955,
0.28508061170578003,
-0.00988942850381136,
0.12293073534965515,
-0.8079808950424194,
0.14306555688381195,
-0.4358833134174347,
0.27191245555877686,
-0.4463634490966797,
-0.04669710248708725,
0.439818799495697,
0.39827147126197815,
0.0007056325557641685,
0.5143263339996338,
0.2195287048816681,
0.6990867257118225,
-0.8574063181877136,
-0.30930694937705994,
-0.6112006902694702,
-0.04245694726705551,
-0.5942307710647583,
0.19460903108119965,
-0.4085981845855713,
-0.46385011076927185,
-0.2397383153438568,
-0.6179978251457214,
-0.21996736526489258,
-0.3339168429374695,
0.5993402004241943,
0.025721143931150436,
-0.4064047932624817,
-0.18702393770217896,
-0.723350465297699,
0.8692247867584229,
-0.6646024584770203,
0.2185041457414627,
0.35499709844589233,
0.22538024187088013,
0.042266152799129486,
-0.21798957884311676,
-0.6467412114143372,
0.10772750526666641,
0.02209407649934292,
0.215257927775383,
-0.6675692200660706,
-0.3938972055912018,
0.11745425313711166,
0.3714306950569153,
-0.580790102481842,
0.20881801843643188,
-0.47065502405166626,
0.3580540716648102,
0.8425174951553345,
0.07046042382717133,
0.46877455711364746,
-0.10277220606803894,
-0.3945936858654022,
-0.01863727904856205,
-0.5057346224784851,
-0.31179094314575195,
0.6285103559494019,
0.5752503275871277,
-0.2021336406469345,
0.6633815169334412,
-0.635395884513855,
0.5013370513916016,
0.22904150187969208,
0.12161003053188324,
0.46131572127342224,
0.02349206805229187,
-0.051335111260414124,
-0.15481041371822357,
1.0405009984970093,
0.7266517877578735,
0.607141375541687,
-0.01993734762072563,
-0.08723554760217667,
0.3213488459587097,
0.5378199219703674,
-0.4488936960697174,
-0.1352733075618744,
0.28291431069374084,
-0.3099520802497864,
-0.4846044182777405,
-0.08581358939409256,
-0.9297548532485962,
-0.866362452507019,
-0.07083640992641449,
0.24191197752952576,
-0.6232545971870422,
-0.307351678609848,
-0.3378000259399414,
-0.03200763836503029,
0.06361427903175354,
0.19819922745227814,
-0.41739511489868164,
0.6304627060890198,
0.5212299227714539,
0.6130291223526001,
-0.28480833768844604,
0.1332661211490631,
-0.19040881097316742,
-0.18941938877105713,
-0.5146839022636414,
0.6746709942817688,
-0.6514474749565125,
-0.285343736410141,
0.1341249644756317,
-0.2877427637577057,
0.24402914941310883,
-0.4138469398021698,
1.0601160526275635,
-0.7173156142234802,
0.1490510106086731,
0.004219050984829664,
-0.34114396572113037,
-0.3097458481788635,
-0.030150840058922768,
-0.35854995250701904,
1.3606160879135132,
0.1944091022014618,
-1.020566701889038,
0.08223062753677368,
-0.5598897337913513,
-0.5147474408149719,
0.35368674993515015,
0.11295104026794434,
-0.3819287419319153,
0.05730399489402771,
0.27467963099479675,
0.41423559188842773,
-0.21724283695220947,
0.03244036063551903,
-0.37823179364204407,
-0.19964823126792908,
0.3341030776500702,
-0.07579275220632553,
0.94911789894104,
0.6531533598899841,
-0.4685157835483551,
-0.1119474247097969,
-0.8584963083267212,
0.03780603036284447,
0.3638518154621124,
-0.03361174091696739,
-0.7423917651176453,
0.39270177483558655,
0.2738857865333557,
0.31418418884277344,
-0.029797768220305443,
-0.8417742252349854,
-0.38232627511024475,
-0.1635865569114685,
0.03629005700349808,
0.959301769733429,
0.10922842472791672,
0.090888112783432,
-0.23932352662086487,
0.4772022068500519,
-0.07427384704351425,
0.24131883680820465,
0.3474416434764862,
-0.3182930648326874,
-0.41107386350631714,
-0.019141945987939835,
-0.11541789770126343,
0.5357409119606018,
-0.6890949010848999,
0.3675248324871063,
-0.31741082668304443,
-0.8549891710281372,
-0.08098115026950836,
0.06475742161273956,
0.7652013301849365,
0.3428557217121124,
0.41797885298728943,
-0.15789450705051422,
-0.6631187200546265,
-0.9291292428970337,
-0.5818531513214111,
-0.10930393636226654,
0.1991608440876007,
0.31691423058509827,
0.2760084569454193,
0.1079615131020546,
0.6309185028076172,
-0.2925735414028168,
-0.3611917495727539,
-0.1458008885383606,
0.11741114407777786,
0.13341070711612701,
0.4527851343154907,
0.48793327808380127,
-0.6791665554046631,
-1.0825692415237427,
0.03408835455775261,
-0.614529550075531,
-0.30059191584587097,
0.3122422695159912,
-0.24202868342399597,
0.16416622698307037,
0.262131929397583,
0.06783508509397507,
0.41459909081459045,
0.6925921440124512,
-0.29901090264320374,
0.3293575048446655,
0.5719427466392517,
0.5449223518371582,
-1.0407296419143677,
-0.1252397894859314,
0.34015947580337524,
-0.20974403619766235,
-0.8283385038375854,
0.21301360428333282,
-0.08436183631420135,
-0.10164298862218857,
-0.6029165387153625,
0.4277254343032837,
-0.28314459323883057,
0.2720288634300232,
-0.01350140105932951,
0.18914064764976501,
-0.46716248989105225,
0.28566280007362366,
-0.08381611853837967,
0.8113420605659485,
0.3922002613544464,
-0.21168871223926544,
0.3372024595737457,
0.29950016736984253,
-0.3922577202320099,
0.7395458221435547,
-0.36592531204223633,
0.3104897737503052,
0.07228747010231018,
-0.23531371355056763,
-0.9832456111907959,
-0.23491911590099335,
0.5816441774368286,
-0.7526369690895081,
-0.13123410940170288,
-0.0366847887635231,
-0.5363948941230774,
-0.29415106773376465,
-0.44547736644744873,
0.4184200167655945,
0.6134225726127625,
-0.3600298762321472,
0.3772646486759186,
0.9137575030326843,
-0.3867645263671875,
-0.621224045753479,
-0.23929640650749207,
0.13689126074314117,
-0.4728764593601227,
-0.30624762177467346,
-0.01361439935863018,
0.18620790541172028,
-0.6393175721168518,
0.028121262788772583,
0.1848069131374359,
-0.17415976524353027,
0.051059942692518234,
0.5089851021766663,
-0.05769956484436989,
-0.2204909771680832,
-0.07902824133634567,
-0.15098059177398682,
0.3588132858276367,
0.13203607499599457,
0.17099955677986145,
0.4139018654823303,
0.011567597277462482,
-0.059112630784511566,
-0.2541472911834717,
0.311030775308609,
0.16667822003364563,
-0.06576407700777054,
0.6818222999572754,
0.40544581413269043,
-0.4795351028442383,
-0.2077769637107849,
-0.412647545337677,
0.27307045459747314,
-0.40309348702430725,
0.5226272344589233,
-0.05945361778140068,
-0.43570569157600403,
0.37760770320892334,
0.1716613471508026,
0.1195526123046875,
0.4944460391998291,
0.6274242997169495,
-0.13815751671791077,
1.0368003845214844,
0.2639891505241394,
-0.22875994443893433,
0.47633039951324463,
0.08125746995210648,
0.09943851083517075,
-0.6591082811355591,
0.19899079203605652,
-0.6045026183128357,
-0.054277170449495316,
-0.500715434551239,
-0.345691442489624,
0.21479974687099457,
-0.11307723075151443,
-0.3824518918991089,
0.3585602641105652,
-0.17643719911575317,
0.5824145078659058,
0.07512668520212173,
0.2645411491394043,
0.05079667642712593,
0.3549061119556427,
0.10280942171812057,
-0.16684465110301971,
-0.28249305486679077,
-0.597966730594635,
1.307650089263916,
0.15995919704437256,
0.5816791653633118,
0.5589107871055603,
0.3175177276134491,
1.058377981185913,
0.4290049970149994,
-0.4120095670223236,
0.40375304222106934,
-0.6163058280944824,
-0.6833874583244324,
-0.3150401711463928,
-0.20916150510311127,
-0.5181106328964233,
0.14710065722465515,
-0.24185925722122192,
-0.9146216511726379,
0.15979322791099548,
0.044622037559747696,
-0.28559064865112305,
0.40774208307266235,
-0.497314989566803,
0.5778664946556091,
-0.20769643783569336,
-0.7626333832740784,
-0.26446443796157837,
-0.5277533531188965,
0.6174567341804504,
-0.28772449493408203,
0.8549408912658691,
-0.32145488262176514,
0.04323701560497284,
0.9114810228347778,
-0.5040022134780884,
0.8641621470451355,
-0.16378815472126007,
-0.04228516295552254,
0.12344543635845184,
0.03634214401245117,
0.1777815967798233,
-0.37043747305870056,
-0.2908773124217987,
0.1672907918691635,
-0.39439311623573303,
-0.5069094896316528,
-0.05767576023936272,
0.5268610119819641,
-0.8622331023216248,
-0.3615996241569519,
-0.5204446315765381,
-0.22417618334293365,
-0.3520233631134033,
0.33945131301879883,
0.10658534616231918,
0.5565406084060669,
-0.6535874009132385,
0.12573964893817902,
0.46527913212776184,
-0.37388840317726135,
0.08243318647146225,
0.5432491302490234,
-0.24509868025779724,
-0.4173397719860077,
0.9837055206298828,
-0.03247969225049019,
0.41417253017425537,
-0.15684783458709717,
-0.09479199349880219,
-0.07533764839172363,
-0.3578057289123535,
-0.578980565071106,
0.0005249335081316531,
-0.7349635362625122,
-0.3590567111968994,
-0.6113806366920471,
-0.22361670434474945,
-0.4417879283428192,
-0.14077140390872955,
-0.4092090427875519,
-0.3782516419887543,
0.03761991858482361,
0.03789385408163071,
0.4206112325191498,
1.1587966680526733,
-0.2524835467338562,
0.4650588035583496,
-0.40387412905693054,
0.5560502409934998,
-0.1810552179813385,
0.3930494487285614,
-0.15567995607852936,
-0.8812106847763062,
-0.4433027505874634,
0.15794852375984192,
-0.41295626759529114,
-1.1869174242019653,
0.26836591958999634,
0.23480354249477386,
0.26961520314216614,
0.6629011631011963,
0.45423826575279236,
0.607227623462677,
-0.47521811723709106,
0.5971792340278625,
-0.02962692640721798,
-0.7096433043479919,
0.49613964557647705,
-0.6066584587097168,
-0.0980711355805397,
0.38784873485565186,
0.7127854824066162,
-0.6988828182220459,
-0.7654759287834167,
-0.6343288421630859,
-0.8139412999153137,
1.0070106983184814,
0.3497920036315918,
0.2857559621334076,
-0.34204795956611633,
0.016987888142466545,
-0.007673641201108694,
-0.189878448843956,
-0.575933039188385,
-0.6008524298667908,
-0.16834717988967896,
0.0079658729955554,
-0.22966866195201874,
-0.4504114091396332,
-0.10909892618656158,
-0.13037630915641785,
0.9910269975662231,
0.2680218517780304,
-0.16866914927959442,
-0.29228752851486206,
-0.4068335294723511,
-0.29345789551734924,
0.35788479447364807,
0.353348046541214,
0.8072302341461182,
-0.40896743535995483,
0.05925891175866127,
0.17575520277023315,
-0.5207180976867676,
0.11817121505737305,
0.02119593508541584,
-0.06086833402514458,
-0.007665128447115421,
-0.00036557362182065845,
0.34789609909057617,
0.07549471408128738,
-0.7231218814849854,
0.6639638543128967,
0.00879207905381918,
0.1818091869354248,
-0.5632107853889465,
-0.15725119411945343,
-0.16071900725364685,
-0.028241707012057304,
0.37278276681900024,
0.05632556229829788,
0.31780263781547546,
-0.5455430746078491,
0.24376799166202545,
0.2241169512271881,
-0.6186357140541077,
-0.2593437135219574,
0.4368742108345032,
0.1417543888092041,
-0.17857418954372406,
0.32349732518196106,
-0.23094168305397034,
-0.7186650633811951,
0.29586976766586304,
0.3347358703613281,
0.6051533818244934,
-0.37750953435897827,
0.5047109127044678,
0.6953670382499695,
0.3948437571525574,
0.48879867792129517,
0.25653076171875,
-0.0135252820327878,
-0.7749614715576172,
-0.020178575068712234,
-0.5856723785400391,
-0.18819788098335266,
0.16880977153778076,
-0.9584197402000427,
0.2415720671415329,
-0.6790729761123657,
-0.28988322615623474,
0.16857792437076569,
-0.07628478109836578,
-0.43319565057754517,
0.35357922315597534,
0.4171863794326782,
0.6634995937347412,
-1.1836960315704346,
0.5173118114471436,
0.7669582962989807,
-0.5252123475074768,
-0.320205956697464,
-0.12164226919412613,
0.4925565719604492,
-0.9048138856887817,
0.648345947265625,
-0.2120097428560257,
-0.09578031301498413,
0.023622997105121613,
-0.4878986179828644,
-0.7801294326782227,
0.1429981142282486,
-0.1796489804983139,
-0.25181177258491516,
0.5208658576011658,
0.2723856568336487,
0.6156657934188843,
-0.11150520294904709,
0.30400383472442627,
0.5985249280929565,
0.12261628359556198,
-0.34328505396842957,
-0.5585879683494568,
0.17152374982833862,
-0.6550361514091492,
-0.07571666687726974,
0.16470877826213837,
-0.5572677850723267,
0.8978692293167114,
0.16960322856903076,
-0.6626859307289124,
0.11000267416238785,
0.32129454612731934,
-0.015998242422938347,
-0.10557730495929718,
0.4587392210960388,
0.7374510765075684,
0.19317498803138733,
-0.04971875995397568,
0.9200927019119263,
-0.14787966012954712,
0.1841454803943634,
1.2349259853363037,
-0.16212119162082672,
1.0639195442199707,
-0.009988175705075264,
-0.4795985817909241,
0.5546482801437378,
0.5326099395751953,
0.16559694707393646,
0.3844328820705414,
0.2615063488483429,
-0.21040938794612885,
-0.0036758927162736654,
-0.38743969798088074,
-0.40231937170028687,
0.4402052164077759,
0.621167004108429,
-0.4261392056941986,
-0.4516221880912781,
-0.02181173861026764,
0.42246708273887634,
0.5885149836540222,
-0.3179631531238556,
1.0912578105926514,
-0.3219170868396759,
-0.1950301080942154,
0.5494205355644226,
0.2876253128051758,
0.5212829113006592,
-0.15253013372421265,
0.015827935189008713,
-0.36495429277420044,
0.17231601476669312,
-0.40702176094055176,
-0.8420544266700745,
0.34541571140289307,
0.7618843913078308,
-0.07821572571992874,
-0.03189535439014435,
0.4447220265865326,
-0.06979502737522125,
-0.5769904851913452,
0.2335771918296814,
0.3671950101852417,
0.36749202013015747,
-0.1251906454563141,
-0.7522189021110535,
0.2424219250679016,
-0.13835947215557098,
-0.05319003388285637,
0.17738482356071472,
0.44009119272232056,
-0.35776978731155396,
0.1463405042886734,
0.6436182260513306,
0.2905195951461792,
0.227559432387352,
-0.004924684297293425,
1.1342533826828003,
-0.48676154017448425,
-0.32388246059417725,
-0.735713541507721,
0.46885836124420166,
-0.40899375081062317,
-0.4120447635650635,
1.0070979595184326,
0.7900528311729431,
0.9236359000205994,
0.21541856229305267,
0.8726993203163147,
-0.4380267262458801,
1.3395495414733887,
-0.29178905487060547,
0.8166357278823853,
-0.5214925408363342,
0.15038195252418518,
-0.734289824962616,
-0.6395057439804077,
-0.2057296633720398,
0.5474892258644104,
-0.48031386733055115,
0.06974264979362488,
0.3980611562728882,
0.6139752864837646,
-0.11387868225574493,
0.08474696427583694,
0.2512708604335785,
0.6111582517623901,
-0.03552606329321861,
0.3370542824268341,
1.2031733989715576,
-0.5172905921936035,
0.2794472873210907,
-0.6607982516288757,
-0.3595004677772522,
-0.22355788946151733,
-0.5912503004074097,
-0.9231076240539551,
-0.5709413886070251,
-0.2832803726196289,
-0.4585389196872711,
0.5969361662864685,
0.7192046046257019,
0.326343297958374,
-1.066851019859314,
-0.45000579953193665,
0.459766685962677,
-0.02848142199218273,
-0.06736405193805695,
-0.2604832053184509,
0.3836420476436615,
-0.14629386365413666,
-0.6784939169883728,
-0.017995992675423622,
0.0917779728770256,
-0.4544678032398224,
0.04952457174658775,
0.036069583147764206,
-0.5113500952720642,
0.05211995542049408,
0.6636674404144287,
0.4121938645839691,
-0.7580687999725342,
-0.29315871000289917,
-0.16051852703094482,
-0.2511955499649048,
0.14712218940258026,
0.24002471566200256,
-0.6933408975601196,
0.3917168080806732,
0.14393608272075653,
0.502597451210022,
-0.13570620119571686,
0.5593340396881104,
0.2973577678203583,
-0.790299117565155,
0.08359142392873764,
0.07020899653434753,
0.17318369448184967,
0.44739991426467896,
-0.2557326853275299,
0.5127354860305786,
-0.036234401166439056,
-0.2671053111553192,
-0.8682539463043213,
-0.044032275676727295,
-0.6181384325027466,
-0.27596431970596313,
1.182700276374817,
-0.22413581609725952,
-0.10997460037469864,
-0.32507070899009705,
-0.17258501052856445,
0.29984772205352783,
-0.719565749168396,
0.8484386801719666,
0.6072049140930176,
0.20635876059532166,
-0.028772873803973198,
-0.5020343065261841,
0.5912526845932007,
0.347988098859787,
-0.7380235195159912,
0.15803313255310059,
0.8543633818626404,
0.21740758419036865,
-0.06196439266204834,
0.4862741231918335,
-0.24302710592746735,
0.46590808033943176,
-0.011986169032752514,
0.1177511140704155,
0.19152596592903137,
-0.029073037207126617,
-0.2730245590209961,
0.07606208324432373,
-0.15146207809448242,
-0.10774464160203934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05530v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05530v1
|
Best-of-Venom: Attacking RLHF by Injecting Poisoned Preference Data
| 2024-04-08T13:59:02 | 2024-04-08T13:59:02 |
Tim Baumgärtner, Yang Gao, Dana Alon, Donald Metzler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is a popular method for
aligning Language Models (LM) with human values and preferences. RLHF requires
a large number of preference pairs as training data, which are often used in
both the Supervised Fine-Tuning and Reward Model training, and therefore
publicly available datasets are commonly used. In this work, we study to what
extent a malicious actor can manipulate the LMs generations by poisoning the
preferences, i.e., injecting poisonous preference pairs into these datasets and
the RLHF training process. We propose strategies to build poisonous preference
pairs and test their performance by poisoning two widely used preference
datasets. Our results show that preference poisoning is highly effective: by
injecting a small amount of poisonous data (1-5% of the original dataset), we
can effectively manipulate the LM to generate a target entity in a target
sentiment (positive or negative). The findings from our experiments also shed
light on strategies to defend against the preference poisoning attack.
|
[
-0.32550862431526184,
-0.5543095469474792,
0.1901104599237442,
-0.3279092013835907,
-0.2762085199356079,
0.045662444084882736,
-0.0639716163277626,
-0.42237719893455505,
0.29153886437416077,
0.9209437966346741,
-0.35220903158187866,
-0.2712353765964508,
-0.37656542658805847,
-0.09160890430212021,
-0.22244766354560852,
1.3925573825836182,
0.32232046127319336,
0.0015734307235106826,
0.09892837703227997,
-0.2989184558391571,
-0.3788038194179535,
-0.9708018898963928,
-0.6048970818519592,
-0.49568602442741394,
1.1879726648330688,
0.5218825936317444,
0.9793092608451843,
0.6367442607879639,
0.2902621626853943,
0.19151988625526428,
0.12740178406238556,
0.07388186454772949,
-0.8147426247596741,
0.21644647419452667,
-0.5071553587913513,
-0.44502606987953186,
-0.03389360010623932,
0.15645945072174072,
0.17342208325862885,
0.2015322893857956,
-0.291176974773407,
-0.3718544542789459,
-0.08570922166109085,
0.9111559987068176,
-0.8226172924041748,
-0.23335792124271393,
-0.8048967123031616,
0.267313688993454,
-0.299267441034317,
-0.4727631211280823,
-0.8982529044151306,
-0.30229711532592773,
0.17616547644138336,
-0.3730420470237732,
-0.2408781796693802,
0.18908977508544922,
0.8403657674789429,
0.37252137064933777,
-0.42735323309898376,
-0.16214780509471893,
-0.5785698294639587,
0.8166726231575012,
-0.6699346303939819,
-0.040216244757175446,
0.268058717250824,
0.33577364683151245,
-0.6544210314750671,
-0.3416436016559601,
-0.3255448341369629,
-0.43230703473091125,
-0.19656740128993988,
0.09510307759046555,
-0.1129453107714653,
0.36335864663124084,
0.20853424072265625,
0.022689249366521835,
-0.5881370306015015,
0.147685706615448,
-0.14258526265621185,
-0.2753245532512665,
0.846339225769043,
0.16577060520648956,
0.4991680681705475,
-0.5209948420524597,
-0.5540959239006042,
-0.4690192639827728,
-0.8392844796180725,
-0.15958160161972046,
0.9536072015762329,
0.6435546875,
0.25266677141189575,
0.44451338052749634,
0.03787481039762497,
0.7046732902526855,
0.15075726807117462,
0.15827804803848267,
-0.051202237606048584,
0.10678169131278992,
-0.16853384673595428,
0.6422840356826782,
1.0057313442230225,
0.6245706081390381,
0.4848330020904541,
-0.31621065735816956,
-0.26229485869407654,
0.19227847456932068,
0.6688212752342224,
-0.7258749604225159,
-0.48545461893081665,
0.4973192811012268,
-0.12266627699136734,
-1.024295687675476,
-0.2437608689069748,
-1.0812739133834839,
-1.008814811706543,
0.3908281624317169,
0.5837997794151306,
-0.3832785487174988,
-0.35117894411087036,
-0.0017060793470591307,
-0.3257634937763214,
0.18156921863555908,
-0.23743054270744324,
-1.2286098003387451,
0.1371016651391983,
0.7039532661437988,
0.4138079285621643,
-0.3454662263393402,
-0.3052998185157776,
-0.8805671334266663,
0.074115090072155,
-0.3646378517150879,
0.9540777802467346,
-0.4801071286201477,
-0.5612866282463074,
0.02822796441614628,
-0.3012250065803528,
0.4161398410797119,
-1.0231900215148926,
0.5659977793693542,
-0.8224644660949707,
0.20011723041534424,
-0.30285313725471497,
-0.4337640702724457,
-0.0064755212515592575,
0.28318241238594055,
-0.5771401524543762,
0.6286411285400391,
0.024149145931005478,
-1.1443374156951904,
0.3911188244819641,
-0.4223748445510864,
-0.36543169617652893,
-0.1643076241016388,
0.004954972770065069,
-0.29379916191101074,
-0.40916815400123596,
0.0641264021396637,
0.3820332884788513,
0.27484074234962463,
0.13709640502929688,
-0.6771257519721985,
-0.20925964415073395,
0.3135988414287567,
-0.22336068749427795,
0.643172562122345,
0.41176748275756836,
-0.13544730842113495,
0.4661962389945984,
-0.5067325234413147,
-0.19147203862667084,
0.2896813154220581,
-0.34335657954216003,
-0.6488746404647827,
0.19468797743320465,
0.02703266590833664,
0.09456110745668411,
-0.11983964592218399,
-0.46451637148857117,
0.2302825003862381,
-0.8178953528404236,
0.36255836486816406,
1.0781160593032837,
0.5574772357940674,
0.4709472954273224,
-0.6429545283317566,
0.3958682119846344,
0.2009735107421875,
0.3627025783061981,
0.21061009168624878,
-0.09260832518339157,
-0.5619069337844849,
0.07990561425685883,
0.08516981452703476,
0.34082889556884766,
-0.9346275329589844,
0.15436477959156036,
0.0008286729571409523,
-0.6637731194496155,
-0.2687493562698364,
-0.11237145215272903,
0.45751917362213135,
0.9003470540046692,
0.35146501660346985,
-0.35945698618888855,
-0.398184597492218,
-0.8983107805252075,
-0.6712204217910767,
-0.2812681794166565,
0.31831690669059753,
0.5178637504577637,
0.15790195763111115,
-0.11018320173025131,
1.0051321983337402,
-0.3853524923324585,
-0.11502696573734283,
-0.10954701155424118,
-0.043608564883470535,
0.127640962600708,
0.45144593715667725,
0.5566939115524292,
-0.6550659537315369,
-0.41612592339515686,
-0.22956494987010956,
-0.5417621731758118,
0.10291139036417007,
-0.06134951487183571,
-0.3979480266571045,
0.2542503774166107,
0.03571010008454323,
-0.0392199344933033,
0.08648524433374405,
0.29731273651123047,
-0.20549960434436798,
0.6529666185379028,
0.1182752251625061,
0.22130852937698364,
-0.8948884606361389,
-0.03061102144420147,
0.1639266312122345,
-0.27698108553886414,
-0.8696469068527222,
0.34212231636047363,
0.015993483364582062,
0.053757574409246445,
-1.0936598777770996,
0.5246080756187439,
0.14186732470989227,
0.20272767543792725,
-0.11242098361253738,
0.05571625754237175,
-0.2841338813304901,
0.5942829251289368,
0.006628657225519419,
0.6968727707862854,
0.35620948672294617,
-0.5586293339729309,
0.7317672967910767,
-0.07577775418758392,
-0.1073828861117363,
0.36831963062286377,
-0.40953701734542847,
0.4112822115421295,
-0.08124447613954544,
0.09802918881177902,
-0.6743329763412476,
-0.6156933903694153,
0.6772002577781677,
-0.38496333360671997,
0.3142995238304138,
-0.37922900915145874,
-0.46042704582214355,
0.023472227156162262,
-0.5151521563529968,
0.21264417469501495,
0.4414004683494568,
-0.8187902569770813,
0.4647403061389923,
0.5502506494522095,
0.22261911630630493,
-1.0099420547485352,
-0.7178494930267334,
0.15176613628864288,
-0.778545618057251,
-0.36540746688842773,
0.1583428531885147,
0.07098300755023956,
-0.40660130977630615,
-0.0038336419966071844,
0.1440153867006302,
0.22788821160793304,
0.10718514770269394,
0.19900386035442352,
0.21459746360778809,
0.33674323558807373,
-0.05639153718948364,
-0.1291656643152237,
-0.28852394223213196,
0.33448994159698486,
0.11077495664358139,
0.6013162136077881,
0.2201278954744339,
-0.32112619280815125,
-0.32899558544158936,
0.18814587593078613,
0.631868839263916,
-0.04174439609050751,
0.4317611753940582,
-0.041445568203926086,
-0.1246594712138176,
-0.37947356700897217,
-0.13183464109897614,
-0.7053375244140625,
-0.5143393874168396,
0.34460628032684326,
0.1600978970527649,
-0.3631955087184906,
0.11539037525653839,
0.023973388597369194,
0.15223482251167297,
0.12332046031951904,
0.3217366337776184,
-0.07834376394748688,
1.1704260110855103,
0.10505356639623642,
-0.857488214969635,
0.5484197735786438,
-0.20669780671596527,
0.04440658167004585,
-0.5339219570159912,
0.008208192884922028,
-0.1356504112482071,
-0.38565054535865784,
-0.5974185466766357,
0.03330394998192787,
0.594637393951416,
-0.2638721466064453,
-0.5442556738853455,
0.16715143620967865,
-0.580093264579773,
0.696965754032135,
0.48356664180755615,
0.40010881423950195,
0.015821553766727448,
0.073700912296772,
-0.31683090329170227,
-0.06029035151004791,
-0.689399242401123,
-0.30068764090538025,
1.1783305406570435,
0.4229981303215027,
0.905930757522583,
0.10878445953130722,
0.979254424571991,
0.29855477809906006,
0.1499955952167511,
-0.9614319205284119,
0.3902096152305603,
-0.0435837022960186,
-0.5473276972770691,
-0.2240748405456543,
-0.25289639830589294,
-0.9640793204307556,
0.1890181303024292,
-0.19561487436294556,
-0.5667927861213684,
-0.01468468364328146,
0.48719653487205505,
-0.5517634749412537,
0.46547219157218933,
-0.8611322045326233,
0.7570886611938477,
-0.34531959891319275,
-0.6828415393829346,
-0.4175683557987213,
-0.7280188798904419,
0.5408797860145569,
0.19085226953029633,
0.08477777242660522,
0.19529348611831665,
0.19062043726444244,
0.8200362920761108,
-0.43525996804237366,
0.7637425661087036,
-0.37461769580841064,
0.06353503465652466,
0.05092073976993561,
0.29703497886657715,
0.6113680005073547,
0.04718981310725212,
-0.33248111605644226,
-0.3029748201370239,
-0.07989905029535294,
-0.5519669055938721,
-0.7454288601875305,
0.6041486263275146,
-0.8455215096473694,
-0.7021297812461853,
-0.8647501468658447,
-0.23035310208797455,
-0.49619823694229126,
-0.07270707935094833,
0.23576714098453522,
0.3934885859489441,
-0.009348840452730656,
-0.3012833595275879,
0.8235784769058228,
-0.3332740068435669,
0.4098525643348694,
0.23946397006511688,
-0.345584899187088,
-0.5357913970947266,
1.2692301273345947,
-0.21525171399116516,
0.5804445743560791,
0.08521950244903564,
0.5331667065620422,
-0.34644272923469543,
-0.2742052972316742,
-0.54118812084198,
0.23356491327285767,
-0.6285774111747742,
-0.1483004093170166,
-0.47941190004348755,
-0.11352422088384628,
-0.20271478593349457,
-0.03305831179022789,
-0.36669766902923584,
0.2659994959831238,
-0.3444598317146301,
-0.07940439134836197,
0.593619167804718,
0.9452776908874512,
-0.28039050102233887,
0.1507977545261383,
-0.6781724691390991,
-0.07839755713939667,
0.5434314608573914,
0.2022603303194046,
0.1471787542104721,
-0.42946362495422363,
0.011805875226855278,
0.08180190622806549,
-0.3636960983276367,
-1.4734643697738647,
0.6362873315811157,
-0.24748781323432922,
0.45488831400871277,
0.7559569478034973,
0.42093542218208313,
0.41616031527519226,
-0.17170323431491852,
0.8725268244743347,
0.0485440269112587,
-0.48734837770462036,
0.5960670113563538,
-0.5839393734931946,
-0.1098744124174118,
0.47467607259750366,
0.61635422706604,
-0.8851404786109924,
-0.361333429813385,
-0.5492162108421326,
-0.7187345027923584,
0.7544712424278259,
-0.3200953006744385,
0.21233271062374115,
0.09707614779472351,
0.47822171449661255,
-0.015316150151193142,
0.022430183365941048,
-0.5428272485733032,
-0.45786890387535095,
-0.1456930786371231,
-0.02060079760849476,
-0.06715336441993713,
-0.4115632176399231,
-0.275165319442749,
-0.1161377876996994,
0.7068744897842407,
0.22252041101455688,
-0.1109919622540474,
-0.005971135571599007,
-0.03679240122437477,
-0.1276664435863495,
0.3135259747505188,
0.3876798152923584,
0.08749962598085403,
-0.37409719824790955,
0.32785025238990784,
-0.0327242910861969,
-0.3332642912864685,
0.35307732224464417,
-0.4201657474040985,
0.15519702434539795,
-0.5289044380187988,
0.14416036009788513,
0.4858526289463043,
0.20831851661205292,
-0.8359310030937195,
0.38229209184646606,
-0.07419714331626892,
0.21679973602294922,
0.04849864915013313,
0.42603081464767456,
-0.048326246440410614,
-0.07225850224494934,
0.07771030813455582,
0.024005301296710968,
0.11151593178510666,
-0.8489490151405334,
0.4345790147781372,
0.3478274345397949,
-0.6584291458129883,
-0.03046266920864582,
0.15520472824573517,
0.0979977697134018,
-0.22265185415744781,
0.5773079991340637,
-0.1328050047159195,
-0.8917068243026733,
0.34709200263023376,
0.3352212905883789,
0.5965872406959534,
-0.43652376532554626,
0.2829308807849884,
0.3813363313674927,
-0.023334966972470284,
0.3155191242694855,
0.022971104830503464,
0.042832523584365845,
-0.8724948167800903,
-0.025990931317210197,
-0.28448164463043213,
-0.5457131266593933,
0.2800489664077759,
-0.7218154072761536,
0.23443995416164398,
-0.6612056493759155,
-0.021973740309476852,
-0.048928212374448776,
-0.28395771980285645,
0.09061785787343979,
-0.0058473385870456696,
-0.181100994348526,
0.6001672744750977,
-0.7832315564155579,
0.75174880027771,
0.4989984631538391,
-0.5662535429000854,
-0.9664830565452576,
0.06932328641414642,
0.38281431794166565,
-0.733589768409729,
0.6439348459243774,
-0.15987320244312286,
-0.12796524167060852,
0.08549536764621735,
-0.6736979484558105,
-0.4675900936126709,
0.41902583837509155,
0.3061848282814026,
-0.23331820964813232,
0.13116109371185303,
-0.058959513902664185,
0.38594862818717957,
0.07184873521327972,
0.22584068775177002,
0.8605417013168335,
0.40276506543159485,
-0.052173782140016556,
-0.471993625164032,
-0.07324378937482834,
-0.14846807718276978,
-0.31329742074012756,
0.3600288927555084,
-0.6219472885131836,
0.5248770713806152,
-0.3137614130973816,
-0.3050386607646942,
-0.3732609450817108,
0.5170711874961853,
0.16886426508426666,
-0.11857552826404572,
0.8853924870491028,
0.7684116959571838,
0.5964056849479675,
0.2653617560863495,
0.9445180892944336,
-0.20311549305915833,
0.2142525464296341,
1.0819703340530396,
-0.3104226887226105,
1.0564005374908447,
0.6323722004890442,
0.02548149973154068,
0.5610024929046631,
0.9183086156845093,
0.02891336753964424,
1.0524448156356812,
0.6503978371620178,
-0.3931063413619995,
-0.19165457785129547,
-0.22521120309829712,
-0.28099682927131653,
0.3270305097103119,
0.23997244238853455,
-0.10141480714082718,
-0.318134605884552,
0.2546125054359436,
0.4136160910129547,
0.2215268760919571,
-0.1073325127363205,
1.1448891162872314,
-0.1879204958677292,
-0.9438046813011169,
0.6814959049224854,
-0.14947989583015442,
0.8285208940505981,
-0.3937522768974304,
0.1073332130908966,
-0.25404059886932373,
0.19849054515361786,
-0.43187129497528076,
-0.7953740358352661,
0.30713367462158203,
0.07950390130281448,
0.10396979004144669,
0.014294757507741451,
0.7249503135681152,
-0.28453606367111206,
0.3538855314254761,
0.48679885268211365,
-0.17178533971309662,
0.1741434633731842,
-0.12316422164440155,
-0.6104981303215027,
-0.0700361430644989,
0.08607061952352524,
-0.1942729502916336,
0.6794266104698181,
-0.23092298209667206,
0.26522496342658997,
0.729861855506897,
0.7133221626281738,
0.5053725838661194,
0.0022299084812402725,
-0.020505353808403015,
1.0770463943481445,
-0.6165320873260498,
-0.41248342394828796,
-1.0632262229919434,
0.33051392436027527,
-0.1270146518945694,
-0.03334283083677292,
0.6399369239807129,
0.4536004662513733,
0.9603298306465149,
0.14659477770328522,
0.8412162661552429,
0.21151365339756012,
0.41245049238204956,
-0.27200621366500854,
1.2462050914764404,
-0.5206445455551147,
-0.036147721111774445,
-0.18720796704292297,
-0.36925506591796875,
-0.09510038793087006,
0.30876362323760986,
-0.2980826497077942,
-0.0446392223238945,
0.6824876666069031,
1.2394486665725708,
0.23701493442058563,
0.005837664473801851,
0.24054740369319916,
0.3599555194377899,
0.5941373109817505,
0.813162624835968,
1.0437003374099731,
-0.09523659199476242,
0.44689759612083435,
-0.720851480960846,
-0.41010966897010803,
-0.36440014839172363,
-0.9431445598602295,
-0.9315046072006226,
-0.4395667612552643,
-0.04280179366469383,
-0.8997223973274231,
0.23428718745708466,
1.2505742311477661,
0.6996437311172485,
-0.9549427032470703,
-0.238406702876091,
0.0819961279630661,
0.31634554266929626,
0.02735414169728756,
-0.24073132872581482,
0.1469888687133789,
-0.35144251585006714,
-0.5164017677307129,
0.41019126772880554,
0.17254717648029327,
-0.016528571024537086,
-0.5219632387161255,
-0.21078044176101685,
-0.19204962253570557,
0.05226242542266846,
0.30526119470596313,
0.5201742053031921,
-0.7418929934501648,
-0.548865020275116,
-0.25254008173942566,
-0.34278830885887146,
0.005138794891536236,
0.7564200162887573,
-0.8327658176422119,
0.8071914911270142,
0.5554379820823669,
0.6902908086776733,
-0.0731550008058548,
-0.07983417063951492,
0.5620114207267761,
-0.595332145690918,
0.0521540604531765,
0.42815929651260376,
0.2005598545074463,
0.24691885709762573,
-0.7653206586837769,
0.2117149382829666,
0.2782644033432007,
-0.6558760404586792,
-1.085206389427185,
0.29770609736442566,
-0.8933796286582947,
-0.3331146538257599,
1.4030888080596924,
0.09458932280540466,
-0.4466972053050995,
-0.10672948509454727,
-0.3371546268463135,
0.2457970380783081,
-0.7789387106895447,
1.0279499292373657,
0.47828027606010437,
-0.3064444959163666,
0.2788960337638855,
-0.3145715594291687,
0.8592144250869751,
0.4260250926017761,
-0.9213901162147522,
0.17605140805244446,
0.30699869990348816,
0.4384203851222992,
-0.014262010343372822,
0.20927199721336365,
-0.10053415596485138,
0.22274906933307648,
-0.1927473098039627,
-0.05048172175884247,
-0.05285879597067833,
-0.3008832037448883,
-0.5548779964447021,
0.1970817744731903,
0.2162613868713379,
-0.17494115233421326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05508v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05508v1
|
Synergy of Large Language Model and Model Driven Engineering for Automated Development of Centralized Vehicular Systems
| 2024-04-08T13:28:11 | 2024-04-08T13:28:11 |
Nenad Petrovic, Fengjunjie Pan, Krzysztof Lebioda, Vahid Zolfaghari, Sven Kirchner, Nils Purschke, Muhammad Aqib Khan, Viktor Vorobev, Alois Knoll
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, D.2.1; D.2.2; D.2.4; I.2.7; I.2.2; I.7.0
|
We present a prototype of a tool leveraging the synergy of model driven
engineering (MDE) and Large Language Models (LLM) for the purpose of software
development process automation in the automotive industry. In this approach,
the user-provided input is free form textual requirements, which are first
translated to Ecore model instance representation using an LLM, which is
afterwards checked for consistency using Object Constraint Language (OCL)
rules. After successful consistency check, the model instance is fed as input
to another LLM for the purpose of code generation. The generated code is
evaluated in a simulated environment using CARLA simulator connected to an
example centralized vehicle architecture, in an emergency brake scenario.
|
[
-0.47564035654067993,
-0.6389590501785278,
0.8229715824127197,
0.20581242442131042,
0.004499799106270075,
0.04858754575252533,
-0.16868345439434052,
-0.5828548073768616,
-0.002638895297423005,
0.4614332318305969,
-0.8334585428237915,
-0.406122088432312,
0.008996023796498775,
0.10622888803482056,
-0.4705556035041809,
0.5574255585670471,
-0.5710519552230835,
0.2007296085357666,
-0.2810656726360321,
-0.04081409052014351,
-0.3036169111728668,
-0.48186057806015015,
-0.4088805913925171,
-0.2119395136833191,
0.11939183622598648,
0.28626152873039246,
0.4945036470890045,
0.5555693507194519,
0.6262910962104797,
0.39675524830818176,
0.32196593284606934,
-0.061668116599321365,
-0.14735619723796844,
0.1579102873802185,
-0.42465606331825256,
-0.08134821802377701,
-0.8546701073646545,
-0.19943934679031372,
0.2930254340171814,
0.5018270611763,
-0.4081306457519531,
0.25753137469291687,
-0.019047299399971962,
0.12358573824167252,
-0.7809322476387024,
0.20811045169830322,
-0.3691692650318146,
-0.41779911518096924,
0.009571303613483906,
0.10561547428369522,
-0.11529578268527985,
-0.28126218914985657,
-0.26057174801826477,
-0.5210319757461548,
-0.25424113869667053,
0.15272758901119232,
0.8125060796737671,
0.3902308940887451,
-0.4252205789089203,
-0.24998190999031067,
-0.9427186250686646,
0.8332550525665283,
-1.0238604545593262,
0.4661838114261627,
-0.15474127233028412,
0.456306129693985,
-0.2008965164422989,
-0.6936294436454773,
-1.1575164794921875,
-0.21253067255020142,
0.20953606069087982,
0.21552051603794098,
0.1621067374944687,
0.206607386469841,
0.05451497435569763,
0.3196902275085449,
-0.527431845664978,
0.618326723575592,
-0.4025169610977173,
-0.14068405330181122,
0.8712950944900513,
0.5864902138710022,
0.3792308270931244,
0.1230517029762268,
-0.6424001455307007,
0.02562905289232731,
-0.7545612454414368,
-0.3100579082965851,
0.27694013714790344,
0.18848739564418793,
-0.19701431691646576,
0.8118038177490234,
-0.3176046311855316,
0.6736260652542114,
-0.2576058804988861,
-0.4348856210708618,
0.3945942223072052,
-0.6549323797225952,
-0.763565182685852,
0.08539503812789917,
0.947733998298645,
0.42639485001564026,
-0.11334695667028427,
0.09403999149799347,
-0.6240536570549011,
0.2032547891139984,
0.22628569602966309,
-0.5935772657394409,
0.31198832392692566,
0.34761500358581543,
-0.470689594745636,
-0.42607542872428894,
0.17633791267871857,
-0.48932474851608276,
0.06705637276172638,
-0.7339603304862976,
0.15305458009243011,
-0.033286336809396744,
-0.34209534525871277,
0.3713203966617584,
-0.020218169316649437,
0.6142568588256836,
0.18470531702041626,
-0.5973688960075378,
0.3147980570793152,
0.637610137462616,
0.575843334197998,
-0.2503366470336914,
-0.3901520073413849,
-0.18570441007614136,
0.6152243614196777,
-0.04128153622150421,
0.7554027438163757,
-0.39038988947868347,
-0.4840450882911682,
0.03567621856927872,
0.2102707475423813,
0.0907001942396164,
-0.46821290254592896,
0.3429454267024994,
-0.46143481135368347,
0.007280340883880854,
0.11719073355197906,
-0.5103845000267029,
-0.18530438840389252,
0.14197422564029694,
-0.44486212730407715,
0.827016294002533,
0.3838309943675995,
-0.42792201042175293,
0.3371660113334656,
-0.698913037776947,
-0.5460550785064697,
0.05861587077379227,
-0.5594653487205505,
-0.5218368172645569,
-0.07059147953987122,
-0.12685392796993256,
0.3554002642631531,
-0.683236300945282,
0.539860188961029,
-0.6163397431373596,
0.09775325655937195,
-0.2552397549152374,
-0.10014688223600388,
0.7702957391738892,
0.21774129569530487,
-0.44413992762565613,
0.4619186520576477,
-0.806896984577179,
0.05525757372379303,
0.07707583904266357,
-0.3250553011894226,
-0.22912834584712982,
0.013428709469735622,
0.3992486298084259,
0.41752541065216064,
0.593780517578125,
-0.525959849357605,
0.35804322361946106,
-0.2227727472782135,
0.2364831566810608,
0.6783151626586914,
0.07036164402961731,
0.41322511434555054,
-0.28907084465026855,
0.535659670829773,
-0.06497472524642944,
0.014318055473268032,
-0.024064525961875916,
-0.3490240275859833,
-0.8641881942749023,
-0.17307010293006897,
0.04043697938323021,
0.8531861901283264,
-0.4490078389644623,
0.9097814559936523,
0.20704889297485352,
-0.27929413318634033,
-0.4990259110927582,
0.23082296550273895,
0.16338826715946198,
0.06228695064783096,
-0.0824647769331932,
-0.3566226661205292,
-0.8781896829605103,
-1.2463457584381104,
0.5824959874153137,
-0.24732738733291626,
-0.28677603602409363,
0.03909187391400337,
0.6903697848320007,
-0.4875338673591614,
1.0602185726165771,
-0.27000463008880615,
-0.2081979662179947,
-0.4358913004398346,
0.09549380838871002,
-0.10900092869997025,
0.6748653650283813,
0.6962823271751404,
-0.5096358060836792,
-0.1910100132226944,
0.3637406826019287,
-1.05057954788208,
-0.3836897909641266,
-0.056080203503370285,
-0.13124464452266693,
0.31530603766441345,
0.7662258148193359,
-0.4610195457935333,
0.4830031096935272,
0.7626203894615173,
0.021094199270009995,
0.793296217918396,
-0.3882993161678314,
0.22309914231300354,
-1.3086118698120117,
0.2787519693374634,
-0.08794678002595901,
-0.34455549716949463,
-0.33969056606292725,
0.23019292950630188,
-0.05172122269868851,
-0.10244116932153702,
-0.4499780237674713,
0.18926070630550385,
-0.6318114995956421,
-0.3276882767677307,
-0.5302789211273193,
0.11409389972686768,
-0.38501521944999695,
0.06861575692892075,
0.2158261090517044,
1.0430750846862793,
0.6817960739135742,
-0.7207193374633789,
0.34577175974845886,
0.07296866178512573,
-0.36085107922554016,
0.6445387601852417,
-0.9549345970153809,
0.01866648718714714,
0.014003219082951546,
-0.25094521045684814,
-0.4833090007305145,
-0.3777306377887726,
-0.19484367966651917,
0.1513424813747406,
0.34343597292900085,
0.1759204864501953,
-0.9721210598945618,
-0.5938830375671387,
0.26350274682044983,
0.1785001903772354,
0.6008614897727966,
-0.39926397800445557,
0.5023446679115295,
0.8204621076583862,
-0.42792874574661255,
0.2320132851600647,
-0.39894822239875793,
-0.037280499935150146,
-0.07493183761835098,
-0.982481062412262,
0.34432685375213623,
-0.1471572369337082,
-0.7014309167861938,
-0.14796099066734314,
0.12748314440250397,
-0.25505301356315613,
0.26035457849502563,
0.3068191409111023,
0.5666232705116272,
-0.5100792050361633,
0.07215902209281921,
0.2781580090522766,
-0.04170878976583481,
0.13242609798908234,
-0.28028082847595215,
0.7426840662956238,
-0.10655516386032104,
-0.4895746111869812,
-0.5629838109016418,
0.5975437164306641,
0.7963725328445435,
-0.44360801577568054,
0.8464380502700806,
0.15529966354370117,
-0.27864566445350647,
-0.4135970175266266,
-0.21727725863456726,
-0.26989391446113586,
-0.5530840158462524,
0.33915314078330994,
-0.49183088541030884,
-0.7401897311210632,
0.5850142240524292,
-0.3330642580986023,
0.17219765484333038,
0.37871965765953064,
0.9981284737586975,
0.0934181660413742,
1.1499824523925781,
1.176937460899353,
-0.20334959030151367,
0.19074411690235138,
0.039269011467695236,
0.30664053559303284,
-0.48834314942359924,
-0.08058135956525803,
-0.4456421136856079,
-0.12067316472530365,
-0.44873303174972534,
-0.26204913854599,
0.40554916858673096,
0.06689082086086273,
-0.26211896538734436,
0.5628060698509216,
-0.39435312151908875,
0.35599449276924133,
0.5024778842926025,
-0.1712721586227417,
0.44100600481033325,
-0.3276774287223816,
-0.34861329197883606,
0.17691896855831146,
-0.8449684977531433,
-0.7232113480567932,
0.6911394596099854,
0.010904477909207344,
0.7546837329864502,
-0.07522822916507721,
0.6848580837249756,
0.12321234494447708,
0.3810326159000397,
-0.5383390784263611,
0.5907425284385681,
0.39588961005210876,
-0.5843318700790405,
-0.14630332589149475,
-0.2541830837726593,
-0.5313193202018738,
-0.21444129943847656,
-0.02753574587404728,
-0.7731373906135559,
0.06111571937799454,
-0.08032070845365524,
-0.28683191537857056,
0.293245404958725,
-0.5432407855987549,
0.9240326881408691,
-0.2564128339290619,
-0.23860663175582886,
-0.28234583139419556,
-0.47264447808265686,
0.5473318696022034,
-0.20258226990699768,
0.2582224905490875,
0.13000153005123138,
0.04152928292751312,
0.3541913628578186,
-0.7381083369255066,
0.7268286943435669,
0.26411405205726624,
-0.49232718348503113,
0.42330294847488403,
0.06874297559261322,
0.5773225426673889,
-0.049280643463134766,
-0.05190294608473778,
-0.24289153516292572,
-0.4865749776363373,
-0.15490034222602844,
-0.47105759382247925,
0.9116321206092834,
-0.5258083343505859,
-0.6818623542785645,
-0.09275046736001968,
-0.7125967144966125,
0.06262631714344025,
0.42750099301338196,
0.026208117604255676,
0.15013690292835236,
-0.26323646306991577,
-0.26649409532546997,
0.2626734972000122,
-0.27228492498397827,
0.6295895576477051,
0.7445818781852722,
-0.5543541312217712,
-0.15686386823654175,
0.6230108737945557,
-0.1147618219256401,
0.6395782828330994,
-0.03468990698456764,
-0.42256462574005127,
0.1884390264749527,
-0.4788660407066345,
-0.41642192006111145,
0.28039824962615967,
-0.4744994640350342,
-0.12628628313541412,
-0.41633933782577515,
-0.41961511969566345,
-0.5058838725090027,
-0.5082876682281494,
-0.6783543825149536,
-0.4203821122646332,
-0.03865332528948784,
-0.03732452541589737,
0.0038677467964589596,
1.2139533758163452,
-0.054757118225097656,
0.3582340478897095,
-0.6271811127662659,
-0.05865158513188362,
0.12306927889585495,
0.13519440591335297,
-0.2589380741119385,
0.09033410996198654,
-0.2458621859550476,
-0.01480047032237053,
-0.5560789704322815,
-0.664327085018158,
0.3084017336368561,
-0.3722289502620697,
0.6227967739105225,
0.42585238814353943,
0.1030418649315834,
0.40737706422805786,
-0.34879398345947266,
0.5615564584732056,
0.3535197675228119,
-0.8796494007110596,
0.5875621438026428,
-0.34126755595207214,
0.2972983121871948,
0.3344328701496124,
0.20334528386592865,
-0.2230224609375,
-0.8470330834388733,
-0.49265778064727783,
-0.8446753621101379,
0.21991713345050812,
0.22834926843643188,
-0.4032555818557739,
0.02115580067038536,
-0.09412837028503418,
0.1744408756494522,
0.4274519979953766,
-0.3778698146343231,
-0.12573598325252533,
0.38890373706817627,
-0.2520240843296051,
0.1071677878499031,
0.05586038529872894,
0.05994591489434242,
-0.05301191657781601,
0.7546004056930542,
0.02946309559047222,
0.11757811158895493,
0.37560680508613586,
-0.06923507899045944,
-0.07659519463777542,
0.27652350068092346,
0.8612959384918213,
0.5319029092788696,
0.05007532611489296,
-0.24922031164169312,
0.0841994360089302,
-0.1466592401266098,
0.2015293687582016,
-0.00039102608570829034,
-0.4765011668205261,
-0.10831066220998764,
0.03485860675573349,
0.49706360697746277,
0.03669000044465065,
-0.7536347508430481,
0.22224153578281403,
0.33045655488967896,
-0.3485393524169922,
-0.4978313744068146,
0.13385306298732758,
0.16852912306785583,
0.3494164049625397,
0.009707079268991947,
0.10714703798294067,
0.1621510088443756,
-0.5137798190116882,
0.3664892315864563,
0.24677230417728424,
-0.4126470685005188,
-0.4407912492752075,
0.8751429319381714,
0.3093821108341217,
-0.12436316162347794,
0.38740023970603943,
-0.5156877636909485,
-0.6595498323440552,
0.8744983077049255,
0.6303767561912537,
0.937099814414978,
-0.32715892791748047,
-0.1113109216094017,
0.40261995792388916,
0.42357611656188965,
-0.10878903418779373,
0.583065390586853,
0.2937694191932678,
-0.672364354133606,
-0.7476688027381897,
-0.5405861139297485,
-0.2588863968849182,
0.020039059221744537,
-0.4221220016479492,
0.6872069835662842,
-0.5020924806594849,
-0.09355025738477707,
-0.13416539132595062,
-0.48718947172164917,
-0.5840355753898621,
-0.07949217408895493,
0.2650918960571289,
0.9545263051986694,
-0.7034163475036621,
0.9811728000640869,
0.8424157500267029,
-0.609402060508728,
-0.8410793542861938,
-0.20977386832237244,
0.28167909383773804,
-0.5837833285331726,
0.9125732183456421,
0.10875254124403,
-0.2130579650402069,
0.032632339745759964,
-0.3746732473373413,
-0.7166376113891602,
1.285692572593689,
0.16079804301261902,
-1.029860496520996,
-0.09768576920032501,
0.22995716333389282,
0.3123379945755005,
-0.8249843716621399,
-0.05417764186859131,
0.625277578830719,
0.5751421451568604,
-0.23670563101768494,
-1.5729643106460571,
0.028151731938123703,
-0.09152959287166595,
0.011274023912847042,
0.38055741786956787,
-0.6354979872703552,
0.7812263369560242,
-0.2641184329986572,
-0.3517093062400818,
0.31985363364219666,
0.7209264636039734,
0.353257954120636,
0.19359566271305084,
0.37186798453330994,
0.7027711272239685,
0.5328981280326843,
0.2529534101486206,
1.1352981328964233,
-0.6978628039360046,
0.49179235100746155,
1.1565074920654297,
-0.8966648578643799,
0.8639245629310608,
0.6940284371376038,
-0.13582846522331238,
0.5500386953353882,
0.13898247480392456,
-0.05030856281518936,
0.2949066758155823,
0.2730952799320221,
-0.34353575110435486,
-0.3711105287075043,
-0.18744033575057983,
-0.32121360301971436,
0.4565180540084839,
0.10147135704755783,
-0.3853117525577545,
-0.3962947130203247,
0.2777973413467407,
-0.13726498186588287,
0.08426565676927567,
-0.4130389094352722,
0.7318025231361389,
0.20965619385242462,
-0.3904888927936554,
0.19375887513160706,
0.17610710859298706,
0.30012571811676025,
-0.3392542004585266,
0.2604122459888458,
0.1414279341697693,
0.4887862503528595,
-0.017039723694324493,
-0.663430392742157,
0.4396570324897766,
-0.19752198457717896,
-0.474578320980072,
-0.1736210584640503,
0.6042746901512146,
-0.4335212707519531,
-0.639028012752533,
0.39919769763946533,
0.5201570987701416,
-0.1423303484916687,
0.3137631416320801,
-0.5509397983551025,
0.2083730399608612,
-0.17526333034038544,
-0.03616657108068466,
0.14047808945178986,
0.39224758744239807,
0.016296740621328354,
0.8054093718528748,
0.47618502378463745,
0.0656924620270729,
-0.06480201333761215,
0.11764232069253922,
0.9919230937957764,
-0.5871219038963318,
-0.3794678747653961,
-0.800275444984436,
0.7084937691688538,
-0.1331544667482376,
-0.04742930084466934,
0.9245996475219727,
0.8105313181877136,
0.8837599158287048,
-0.11361289769411087,
1.230194330215454,
-0.3919752836227417,
0.1295919269323349,
-0.5751775503158569,
0.579367458820343,
-0.5079120397567749,
0.3638862371444702,
-0.18889698386192322,
-0.9392601847648621,
-0.23088712990283966,
0.4322810471057892,
-0.1619006097316742,
-0.15448500216007233,
0.6993704438209534,
1.039266586303711,
-0.33384159207344055,
-0.1352955400943756,
0.35913076996803284,
0.21031230688095093,
0.22999592125415802,
0.7033687233924866,
0.6350411772727966,
-0.34545257687568665,
0.1742800772190094,
-0.1572517454624176,
-0.2505219280719757,
0.10422930866479874,
-0.6869009733200073,
-0.8585569858551025,
-0.31346917152404785,
-0.4339633882045746,
-0.24588876962661743,
-0.14382410049438477,
0.9877576231956482,
0.7683664560317993,
-0.8067605495452881,
-0.6911408305168152,
-0.38880518078804016,
0.022775137796998024,
0.047778673470020294,
-0.1898716539144516,
-0.3017963469028473,
-0.42395782470703125,
-0.7056542038917542,
0.5027636885643005,
0.5929290056228638,
0.3070123791694641,
-0.7539132833480835,
-0.307854562997818,
0.11057573556900024,
-0.06955641508102417,
0.4106948971748352,
0.07197302579879761,
-0.33543825149536133,
-0.13267582654953003,
0.05503527820110321,
-0.26725199818611145,
-0.04806962236762047,
1.1535358428955078,
-0.46301478147506714,
0.1581035703420639,
0.41199687123298645,
0.22838124632835388,
0.12279878556728363,
-0.15927185118198395,
1.5218207836151123,
-0.2912195026874542,
0.3789394497871399,
-0.15076079964637756,
0.5402855277061462,
0.029219750314950943,
-0.12400523573160172,
0.1849682629108429,
0.16956177353858948,
-0.7695468664169312,
-0.7356396317481995,
0.6441255211830139,
-1.0114840269088745,
-0.2917099595069885,
0.9399166107177734,
0.030856136232614517,
-0.48365363478660583,
-0.15721045434474945,
-0.18827536702156067,
0.0920519307255745,
-0.30483195185661316,
0.46307480335235596,
0.3641008734703064,
0.3602216839790344,
-0.06661438196897507,
-0.5297093987464905,
0.1986876279115677,
-0.0776657909154892,
-1.099442720413208,
-0.07275693863630295,
0.3525386452674866,
0.08375298231840134,
0.22692765295505524,
0.1524510383605957,
0.11672040820121765,
0.5148845314979553,
0.18578986823558807,
0.6862729787826538,
0.1266523003578186,
-0.11142352968454361,
-0.0664682611823082,
0.0772809237241745,
-0.026897786185145378,
0.17813502252101898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05502v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05502v1
|
PetKaz at SemEval-2024 Task 3: Advancing Emotion Classification with an LLM for Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction in Conversations
| 2024-04-08T13:25:03 | 2024-04-08T13:25:03 |
Roman Kazakov, Kseniia Petukhova, Ekaterina Kochmar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
In this paper, we present our submission to the SemEval-2023 Task~3 "The
Competition of Multimodal Emotion Cause Analysis in Conversations", focusing on
extracting emotion-cause pairs from dialogs. Specifically, our approach relies
on combining fine-tuned GPT-3.5 for emotion classification and a BiLSTM-based
neural network to detect causes. We score 2nd in the ranking for Subtask 1,
demonstrating the effectiveness of our approach through one of the highest
weighted-average proportional F1 scores recorded at 0.264.
|
[
-0.642445981502533,
-0.8833404183387756,
0.6160128116607666,
0.3026968240737915,
-0.3300616443157196,
-0.1516628861427307,
0.008754515089094639,
-0.655245304107666,
0.18613196909427643,
0.5161423087120056,
-0.8502177596092224,
-0.29455429315567017,
-0.6493644714355469,
0.06830448657274246,
0.021085627377033234,
0.9628222584724426,
0.0023470520973205566,
0.2399737536907196,
-0.2711719572544098,
-0.15303713083267212,
-0.38369375467300415,
-0.7592010498046875,
-0.7720010280609131,
-0.3308202624320984,
0.8038502931594849,
0.7949478030204773,
0.2845871150493622,
-0.20182520151138306,
0.5890591144561768,
0.3053179383277893,
0.1574554592370987,
0.12110178917646408,
-0.13046640157699585,
0.42558854818344116,
0.03649112209677696,
-0.19461484253406525,
-0.8752111792564392,
0.16066893935203552,
0.2275230586528778,
0.29251784086227417,
-0.141069233417511,
-0.13165989518165588,
-0.015744712203741074,
0.7197251319885254,
-0.3246794641017914,
0.21729910373687744,
-0.35409051179885864,
0.35402876138687134,
-0.4280199706554413,
-0.7398441433906555,
-0.3501374423503876,
-0.23312701284885406,
0.21400760114192963,
-0.1312287598848343,
0.3066444396972656,
0.16736723482608795,
0.7897516489028931,
0.06189853698015213,
-0.6962931752204895,
-0.3641359806060791,
-0.3968612849712372,
0.5700770020484924,
-0.6233110427856445,
0.24294795095920563,
0.4440881013870239,
-0.02461562678217888,
-0.16197173297405243,
-0.5689229965209961,
-0.4755045473575592,
0.15949304401874542,
0.18684296309947968,
0.4766020178794861,
-0.3500717580318451,
0.20387941598892212,
0.23503054678440094,
0.4130854606628418,
-0.781244158744812,
-0.06366118788719177,
-0.4809213876724243,
-0.3114513158798218,
0.6859155297279358,
0.5007594227790833,
0.3374757170677185,
-0.08562081307172775,
-0.46366119384765625,
0.08114542067050934,
-0.727300763130188,
0.001563035766594112,
0.5173020958900452,
0.13012290000915527,
-0.05630180612206459,
0.4113484025001526,
-0.17878085374832153,
0.4147530496120453,
-0.044279567897319794,
0.17052558064460754,
0.47873654961586,
-0.6327313780784607,
-0.16774024069309235,
0.2677583396434784,
0.9685236811637878,
0.44660860300064087,
-0.02248535491526127,
0.13126066327095032,
0.07403738796710968,
-0.2059779018163681,
0.24723540246486664,
-0.9747124910354614,
-0.333196759223938,
0.24438118934631348,
-0.5213243365287781,
-0.5745300054550171,
-0.16620491445064545,
-1.2505038976669312,
-0.5571479201316833,
-0.18137437105178833,
0.7527643442153931,
-0.12039952725172043,
-0.4880422055721283,
0.02407645620405674,
0.1045491173863411,
0.35729169845581055,
0.475339412689209,
-0.8313243985176086,
0.24638383090496063,
0.523108720779419,
0.6722450256347656,
-0.11390633136034012,
-0.23093761503696442,
-0.6605193614959717,
-0.5206523537635803,
-0.33519449830055237,
0.9486571550369263,
-0.4194757044315338,
-0.24402005970478058,
-0.14961794018745422,
0.2752448618412018,
0.022371094673871994,
-0.4963783621788025,
0.6807667016983032,
-0.3566599488258362,
0.6088586449623108,
-0.4767288565635681,
-0.26140114665031433,
-0.329847127199173,
0.29496124386787415,
-0.5543534755706787,
1.0984413623809814,
0.061067529022693634,
-0.7257976531982422,
0.1770182102918625,
-0.8730543851852417,
-0.46168258786201477,
0.1712655872106552,
0.04852196201682091,
-0.5214444398880005,
0.1214558407664299,
-0.04312039911746979,
0.6767756342887878,
-0.6382167935371399,
0.2654483914375305,
-0.4169953167438507,
-0.11649516224861145,
0.25913310050964355,
-0.46029725670814514,
0.5360177159309387,
0.28688809275627136,
-0.5942379236221313,
0.24763809144496918,
-0.5532070994377136,
-0.18689215183258057,
0.15467248857021332,
-0.25658607482910156,
-0.07441103458404541,
0.050906699150800705,
-0.13232117891311646,
0.67755526304245,
0.055158425122499466,
-0.6671832799911499,
-0.010936892591416836,
-0.2479574978351593,
0.2422802448272705,
0.8737004399299622,
0.4624958038330078,
0.195720374584198,
-0.16420060396194458,
0.6658308506011963,
0.2705914378166199,
0.14353662729263306,
-0.12292531132698059,
-0.6807646751403809,
-1.0064207315444946,
0.01688520424067974,
0.10103221982717514,
0.40049540996551514,
-0.5180429816246033,
0.11887335777282715,
0.16911979019641876,
-0.5665022730827332,
-0.08824758976697922,
-0.02935393713414669,
0.2794528305530548,
0.685133159160614,
0.23511195182800293,
-0.3343159854412079,
-0.6370322108268738,
-0.8707256317138672,
-0.06508669257164001,
-0.008441840298473835,
0.3286511301994324,
0.4062213599681854,
0.5053597688674927,
0.03414075821638107,
0.4471428096294403,
-0.257904052734375,
0.017771422863006592,
-0.18005657196044922,
0.6596574783325195,
0.036026738584041595,
0.40343984961509705,
0.5065670609474182,
-0.8850750923156738,
-0.5755143761634827,
-0.08811840415000916,
-0.7212509512901306,
-0.5221028923988342,
0.14420628547668457,
-0.32719045877456665,
0.2713567018508911,
0.584264874458313,
-0.37996307015419006,
0.49648019671440125,
0.47396427392959595,
-0.6354553699493408,
0.46429115533828735,
0.21867364645004272,
0.5381377339363098,
-1.228201985359192,
-0.27815842628479004,
0.07053784281015396,
-0.21473219990730286,
-0.8059297800064087,
-0.6722519397735596,
-0.2912980318069458,
-0.28202345967292786,
-0.5030550360679626,
0.28415611386299133,
-0.13262829184532166,
-0.09831427037715912,
-0.22178536653518677,
0.1314631849527359,
-0.04540027678012848,
0.6983125805854797,
0.17727230489253998,
0.5738044381141663,
0.40794530510902405,
-0.3625752627849579,
0.7996129989624023,
0.158999964594841,
-0.2139362245798111,
0.7854558229446411,
-0.4419809579849243,
0.359661340713501,
0.08175605535507202,
-0.013585937209427357,
-1.2584930658340454,
-0.4126017689704895,
0.5568464398384094,
-0.5646198987960815,
0.2287752628326416,
0.09541413933038712,
-0.43952226638793945,
-0.21822980046272278,
-0.17842966318130493,
0.14657455682754517,
0.3019484281539917,
-0.46406805515289307,
0.6901873350143433,
0.3226974606513977,
-0.7798364162445068,
-0.15986229479312897,
-0.5699604153633118,
0.0717015415430069,
-0.4708196818828583,
-0.7012358903884888,
0.2269718050956726,
-0.1865493655204773,
-0.009813321754336357,
-0.09592889249324799,
-0.13338619470596313,
0.050663888454437256,
0.21225912868976593,
0.4222208261489868,
0.16337928175926208,
-0.2843610644340515,
0.13928058743476868,
-0.2958104610443115,
-0.24796131253242493,
0.38467440009117126,
0.38619452714920044,
0.6238470673561096,
-0.568901538848877,
-0.37194857001304626,
-0.19519394636154175,
0.5679472088813782,
0.7453234195709229,
-0.24762272834777832,
0.3336445093154907,
0.8435903191566467,
-0.2924758195877075,
0.055312737822532654,
-0.5728156566619873,
0.03192038834095001,
-0.447192519903183,
0.47518524527549744,
-0.3316143751144409,
-1.219429850578308,
0.40522146224975586,
-0.3408451974391937,
-0.43122583627700806,
0.5013864636421204,
0.9425814747810364,
-0.3506213426589966,
1.3528692722320557,
0.3596540093421936,
-0.009287052787840366,
0.5395684242248535,
0.18005582690238953,
0.3502219021320343,
-0.8713065385818481,
-0.4282577335834503,
-0.42021915316581726,
-0.309751033782959,
-0.4989306628704071,
-0.22791790962219238,
0.4880824685096741,
-0.06282847374677658,
-0.0967826321721077,
0.19294148683547974,
-0.31610116362571716,
0.18463237583637238,
0.5292479991912842,
0.0003240439691580832,
-0.14647528529167175,
-0.08245902508497238,
0.056033093482255936,
-0.07988343387842178,
-0.5241307020187378,
-0.11427375674247742,
0.8430497646331787,
0.344085693359375,
0.2004876285791397,
0.37817829847335815,
0.7707490921020508,
0.26380056142807007,
0.2546066641807556,
-0.764028787612915,
0.736053466796875,
0.266548752784729,
-0.7387950420379639,
-0.11573497205972672,
-0.33956971764564514,
-0.8361778259277344,
0.40593117475509644,
-0.09010957181453705,
-1.0798815488815308,
0.16185030341148376,
-0.08717671781778336,
-0.316072016954422,
-0.0853656530380249,
-0.6462876796722412,
1.31807541847229,
-0.3719801902770996,
-0.4979358911514282,
-0.23737972974777222,
-0.7547489404678345,
0.49495941400527954,
-0.14768192172050476,
0.1434125304222107,
-0.5107502341270447,
0.27033865451812744,
0.9148346781730652,
-0.44468408823013306,
0.7061872482299805,
-0.39421263337135315,
0.1294659972190857,
0.4034624993801117,
0.06900577992200851,
0.4424779713153839,
-0.1706290990114212,
0.014997829683125019,
-0.13597983121871948,
0.003408661810681224,
-0.1799282282590866,
-0.5472900867462158,
0.42241111397743225,
-0.44408097863197327,
-0.4172443747520447,
-0.6939337849617004,
-0.0951358824968338,
-0.37799593806266785,
-0.1412191390991211,
0.27415958046913147,
0.5879845023155212,
-0.2081698775291443,
0.4821479618549347,
0.45262444019317627,
-0.22637414932250977,
0.7009422779083252,
0.6238203048706055,
0.008317138999700546,
-0.6547521948814392,
1.0709195137023926,
-0.22226661443710327,
0.06899135559797287,
0.00934023316949606,
0.4993192255496979,
-0.21276742219924927,
-0.317423939704895,
-0.10680790990591049,
-0.13503797352313995,
-0.7350212335586548,
-0.4934808909893036,
-0.49332916736602783,
-0.1414349377155304,
-0.3115559220314026,
-0.005388801451772451,
-0.37621942162513733,
-0.08613434433937073,
-0.22700564563274384,
-0.11269398778676987,
0.2732299566268921,
0.6215708255767822,
-0.36733195185661316,
0.16700847446918488,
-0.9578139781951904,
-0.005933656357228756,
0.5346798300743103,
0.06481879949569702,
-0.36167243123054504,
-0.3562506139278412,
-0.17846903204917908,
-0.27975550293922424,
-0.5499924421310425,
-1.079594612121582,
0.5299475789070129,
0.15065684914588928,
0.4772372841835022,
0.3361634612083435,
-0.05276050046086311,
0.8059173226356506,
-0.0515485480427742,
1.1224278211593628,
0.37666550278663635,
-0.9073759913444519,
0.8145018815994263,
-0.49198442697525024,
0.026837807148694992,
0.43546950817108154,
0.3662225902080536,
-0.7066309452056885,
0.001639468828216195,
-0.8416140079498291,
-0.7536970973014832,
1.2440142631530762,
0.38678795099258423,
-0.09573840349912643,
-0.05060724541544914,
0.022822188213467598,
-0.16504515707492828,
0.1641368269920349,
-0.6549009084701538,
0.022639192640781403,
-0.1029551550745964,
-0.3753008246421814,
-0.005041539669036865,
-0.6444752216339111,
0.04370541125535965,
-0.25326839089393616,
0.8331043124198914,
-0.07941539585590363,
0.7036954164505005,
0.20736952126026154,
0.011751157231628895,
-0.3492434620857239,
0.3720351457595825,
0.9113330841064453,
0.13547196984291077,
-0.30904924869537354,
0.32407739758491516,
0.40549373626708984,
-0.28360965847969055,
0.06360846012830734,
0.11677844077348709,
0.45494285225868225,
-0.2111532986164093,
0.38110363483428955,
0.9222808480262756,
0.23183515667915344,
-0.458492636680603,
0.9443159103393555,
-0.19825772941112518,
-0.5065442323684692,
-0.28598082065582275,
-0.11319495737552643,
0.047382812947034836,
0.6078224778175354,
0.03938044607639313,
0.10338526219129562,
0.5126020908355713,
-0.547039806842804,
0.31143906712532043,
0.15859635174274445,
-0.5909900665283203,
-0.6423003673553467,
0.348642498254776,
0.4511697590351105,
-0.21952931582927704,
0.36837613582611084,
-0.4772378206253052,
-1.1309088468551636,
0.6770806312561035,
0.4339558184146881,
1.1294796466827393,
-0.44643348455429077,
0.08311048895120621,
0.4869142174720764,
-0.09609786421060562,
0.06861325353384018,
0.5940695405006409,
-0.26937729120254517,
-0.9321686625480652,
-0.324651837348938,
-0.45984962582588196,
-0.6189574599266052,
0.3638877272605896,
-0.5636109709739685,
0.26735854148864746,
-0.12199275940656662,
0.02212214097380638,
0.09942860156297684,
0.13967745006084442,
-0.5687782764434814,
0.24118834733963013,
0.5181976556777954,
0.23708997666835785,
-1.0344955921173096,
0.6169171929359436,
0.6775414943695068,
-0.4579966962337494,
-0.7779629230499268,
-0.2824157178401947,
0.469495564699173,
-0.4392889142036438,
0.870143473148346,
0.2680680751800537,
-0.17935031652450562,
-0.12612007558345795,
-0.6226242780685425,
-0.5426831841468811,
1.0373361110687256,
-0.058700427412986755,
-0.22530001401901245,
0.2604278326034546,
0.020556963980197906,
0.3335822522640228,
-0.4193108379840851,
0.32285916805267334,
0.4390619397163391,
0.41092023253440857,
0.33881181478500366,
-0.8403218984603882,
-0.1385326385498047,
-0.6756904721260071,
-0.38132327795028687,
0.3469916582107544,
-0.8681566715240479,
0.7592571973800659,
0.26352664828300476,
0.08996254205703735,
-0.28397735953330994,
0.39751166105270386,
0.07397942990064621,
0.5190163254737854,
0.5600610375404358,
0.49764347076416016,
0.6240960955619812,
-0.3293420374393463,
0.6793610453605652,
-0.06447742879390717,
0.469948410987854,
1.2312921285629272,
-0.3153572678565979,
0.6634399890899658,
0.38207995891571045,
-0.26023754477500916,
0.371806263923645,
1.0746625661849976,
0.03874242305755615,
0.7195327877998352,
-0.06090478226542473,
-0.5514905452728271,
-0.5775361061096191,
-0.01842699944972992,
-0.30044254660606384,
0.8681132793426514,
0.5731000304222107,
-0.25891754031181335,
-0.08771328628063202,
0.20639874041080475,
0.22693045437335968,
-0.6253530383110046,
-0.07132727652788162,
0.8917045593261719,
0.057497791945934296,
-0.6993171572685242,
0.005825838074088097,
-0.22253216803073883,
0.4112441837787628,
-0.3064776062965393,
-0.17097057402133942,
-0.23806746304035187,
0.16652868688106537,
-0.2270742505788803,
-0.7108532786369324,
0.39112499356269836,
-0.12169034034013748,
0.11090180277824402,
-0.28723204135894775,
1.078005313873291,
-0.4861299693584442,
-0.12207237631082535,
0.20881907641887665,
0.3810511827468872,
0.3491629362106323,
-0.3285076916217804,
-0.6793694496154785,
0.10311802476644516,
-0.07382871210575104,
-0.7423317432403564,
0.3400653898715973,
0.6945127248764038,
0.13655342161655426,
0.1904570460319519,
0.5729179382324219,
-0.2522554099559784,
-0.0968485176563263,
0.13337914645671844,
0.7358733415603638,
-0.7943456172943115,
-0.24337005615234375,
-0.9997739791870117,
0.5768758058547974,
-0.20223815739154816,
-0.4043475389480591,
0.46671807765960693,
0.5010672211647034,
0.3417815864086151,
0.05860866978764534,
0.761226236820221,
-0.2951561510562897,
0.3690132200717926,
-0.42664533853530884,
0.25513824820518494,
-0.8755557537078857,
-0.1163114607334137,
-0.4981490671634674,
-0.7929571866989136,
-0.18474619090557098,
0.6569116115570068,
-0.32327747344970703,
-0.14011849462985992,
0.9428457617759705,
0.8429079055786133,
0.2097720056772232,
0.5311481952667236,
0.3965289890766144,
0.0721520408987999,
0.3048073947429657,
0.9966381788253784,
1.232191562652588,
-0.3884027898311615,
0.5164926052093506,
-0.374078631401062,
-0.14724424481391907,
-0.6483832001686096,
-0.9726222157478333,
-0.8194191455841064,
-0.9164397716522217,
-0.5477190017700195,
-0.40328240394592285,
-0.22417205572128296,
1.0200563669204712,
0.6134988069534302,
-0.8627517819404602,
0.18292948603630066,
-0.32422661781311035,
-0.11360599100589752,
0.24469301104545593,
-0.25071513652801514,
0.14168395102024078,
-0.4464744031429291,
-0.5341435670852661,
0.5394437313079834,
0.5674020648002625,
0.016556015238165855,
0.09939165413379669,
-0.22592799365520477,
-0.10806089639663696,
-0.029383109882473946,
0.7120691537857056,
0.1946825385093689,
-0.637551486492157,
-0.6417893767356873,
-0.08745327591896057,
-0.0858546644449234,
0.2106333076953888,
0.8012031316757202,
-0.2904265820980072,
0.5977828502655029,
0.7144501209259033,
0.35765206813812256,
0.8854630589485168,
-0.016090838238596916,
0.6473221182823181,
-0.6016725897789001,
-0.0014291256666183472,
0.3345695734024048,
0.4131311774253845,
0.1893104612827301,
-0.41122931241989136,
0.9061235785484314,
0.5147973299026489,
-0.9267562031745911,
-0.7349997758865356,
0.19397851824760437,
-1.2246021032333374,
0.19485537707805634,
1.0795634984970093,
-0.14034321904182434,
-0.1771797090768814,
-0.059297237545251846,
-0.4556056559085846,
0.32125750184059143,
-0.21327055990695953,
0.31654107570648193,
1.1382575035095215,
-0.7909110188484192,
-0.6315392255783081,
-0.6939938068389893,
0.51767897605896,
0.641843318939209,
-1.106096863746643,
-0.07349506765604019,
0.47929859161376953,
0.19974130392074585,
0.05806349217891693,
0.7971975207328796,
-0.35506412386894226,
0.43969836831092834,
0.022116437554359436,
0.27506986260414124,
-0.018308144062757492,
-0.3398473560810089,
-0.3540915846824646,
0.2513103485107422,
-0.10929947346448898,
-0.20448556542396545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05483v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05483v1
|
PetKaz at SemEval-2024 Task 8: Can Linguistics Capture the Specifics of LLM-generated Text?
| 2024-04-08T13:05:02 | 2024-04-08T13:05:02 |
Kseniia Petukhova, Roman Kazakov, Ekaterina Kochmar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
In this paper, we present our submission to the SemEval-2024 Task 8
"Multigenerator, Multidomain, and Multilingual Black-Box Machine-Generated Text
Detection", focusing on the detection of machine-generated texts (MGTs) in
English. Specifically, our approach relies on combining embeddings from the
RoBERTa-base with diversity features and uses a resampled training set. We
score 12th from 124 in the ranking for Subtask A (monolingual track), and our
results show that our approach is generalizable across unseen models and
domains, achieving an accuracy of 0.91.
|
[
-0.5903130769729614,
-0.7564767599105835,
0.5820419192314148,
0.07597704231739044,
-0.43165192008018494,
0.13608427345752716,
-0.25871098041534424,
-0.4185728132724762,
0.4587746262550354,
0.6409366130828857,
-0.7752348184585571,
-0.5976255536079407,
-0.7738417983055115,
0.5087073445320129,
-0.17732496559619904,
1.0137087106704712,
0.00943766999989748,
-0.22622685134410858,
-0.1039942130446434,
-0.10691414028406143,
-0.3755961060523987,
-0.891283392906189,
-0.4500451982021332,
-0.2798788845539093,
0.5714132189750671,
0.3364958167076111,
0.20860245823860168,
0.23203912377357483,
0.3553332984447479,
0.28219637274742126,
-0.05177036672830582,
0.4109509587287903,
-0.1851090043783188,
0.38797706365585327,
-0.1590312421321869,
-0.27571171522140503,
-0.5062941908836365,
0.09003236889839172,
0.6414502263069153,
0.367652952671051,
0.14722219109535217,
0.03485308587551117,
0.14220955967903137,
0.18261761963367462,
-0.32512331008911133,
-0.08452387899160385,
-0.7457741498947144,
0.3703587055206299,
-0.40780505537986755,
-0.4776395857334137,
-0.7492508292198181,
0.20064429938793182,
-0.22926533222198486,
-0.2875513434410095,
0.30145782232284546,
-0.004086603410542011,
0.7543151378631592,
0.10874150693416595,
-0.6155487895011902,
-0.4165731966495514,
-0.4263972342014313,
0.9148119688034058,
-0.5227440595626831,
0.23660747706890106,
0.41655606031417847,
0.0958956778049469,
-0.2140512466430664,
-0.49609309434890747,
-0.26199203729629517,
-0.17705342173576355,
0.11408412456512451,
0.19856400787830353,
-0.16402511298656464,
-0.2006653994321823,
0.26212844252586365,
0.4281468391418457,
-0.7059137225151062,
-0.07978014647960663,
-0.20177948474884033,
-0.4063524305820465,
0.5997071266174316,
0.19377616047859192,
0.4081241190433502,
-0.0012985520297661424,
-0.25311580300331116,
0.1568603664636612,
-0.5859750509262085,
-0.1934131681919098,
0.5808149576187134,
0.36449822783470154,
-0.058561891317367554,
0.6246211528778076,
-0.09565232694149017,
0.4127289354801178,
-0.014745821245014668,
-0.17420491576194763,
0.5754364728927612,
-0.6157901883125305,
0.02210303768515587,
-0.1305808573961258,
0.9243447184562683,
-0.16112324595451355,
0.15369948744773865,
-0.1339699923992157,
-0.19195182621479034,
-0.047467462718486786,
0.3184930086135864,
-0.6561795473098755,
-0.15895327925682068,
0.07972264289855957,
-0.30154865980148315,
-0.536529541015625,
-0.05267556756734848,
-0.7540754079818726,
-0.2488107681274414,
0.06939336657524109,
0.3867087960243225,
-0.1724238097667694,
-0.3265738785266876,
0.11510877311229706,
0.09639641642570496,
0.1638268083333969,
0.24870486557483673,
-0.6678292155265808,
-0.09855536371469498,
0.5008260607719421,
0.6021233797073364,
-0.31380873918533325,
-0.5948305130004883,
-0.5854471921920776,
-0.058841221034526825,
-0.190912127494812,
0.9300596117973328,
-0.4394882321357727,
-0.2623055577278137,
-0.027925923466682434,
0.39873117208480835,
-0.047755055129528046,
-0.439105361700058,
0.5634686350822449,
-0.2552233040332794,
0.4115903973579407,
-0.09871608763933182,
-0.3902890384197235,
-0.14195005595684052,
0.46056026220321655,
-0.5618468523025513,
1.2647955417633057,
0.09286744892597198,
-0.6516159176826477,
0.3660232424736023,
-0.46835169196128845,
-0.6304489374160767,
0.1621607393026352,
-0.14577938616275787,
-0.9247415661811829,
0.023649411275982857,
0.15475745499134064,
0.41878753900527954,
-0.06559713184833527,
0.3365563750267029,
-0.21116390824317932,
-0.2143383026123047,
0.2611450254917145,
-0.6282616853713989,
0.6119214296340942,
0.1803450584411621,
-0.6482053399085999,
0.013501408509910107,
-0.6880213022232056,
0.07518267631530762,
0.1812153309583664,
-0.6570441126823425,
-0.06786824762821198,
-0.21869659423828125,
0.09809920936822891,
0.40379658341407776,
0.35738661885261536,
-0.5580233335494995,
0.34127992391586304,
-0.11161568015813828,
0.20261025428771973,
0.453204482793808,
0.14492753148078918,
0.29421716928482056,
-0.1906755566596985,
0.9013586044311523,
0.0024718702770769596,
-0.23092278838157654,
-0.4194616675376892,
-0.6979015469551086,
-0.7408599257469177,
-0.3490208685398102,
0.5044006109237671,
0.4983307421207428,
-0.6199922561645508,
0.4866553246974945,
0.055303651839494705,
-0.40718644857406616,
-0.23245903849601746,
0.011791178956627846,
0.3282393515110016,
-0.1782011091709137,
0.2480621635913849,
-0.4469274580478668,
-0.7618149518966675,
-0.8174706697463989,
-0.23881903290748596,
0.2793664038181305,
0.1422100067138672,
0.1300976723432541,
0.8849228620529175,
-0.20536497235298157,
0.24618887901306152,
-0.24048535525798798,
-0.20215852558612823,
-0.3799435496330261,
0.4256139397621155,
0.08240759372711182,
0.47569555044174194,
0.6357141733169556,
-0.7353276014328003,
-0.5752390623092651,
0.06621481478214264,
-0.900073230266571,
-0.42250117659568787,
0.22519107162952423,
-0.09229691326618195,
0.037374984472990036,
0.5175909996032715,
-0.5729151368141174,
0.2538762390613556,
0.5281593799591064,
-0.5482457876205444,
0.4200490117073059,
-0.08195309340953827,
0.45725035667419434,
-1.4041645526885986,
-0.2315734326839447,
-0.2549392580986023,
-0.5458057522773743,
-0.7303661108016968,
0.024080771952867508,
-0.079341821372509,
-0.22511880099773407,
-0.45359140634536743,
0.2521037459373474,
-0.5803155303001404,
-0.14908277988433838,
-0.6230199337005615,
0.019302666187286377,
-0.10754046589136124,
0.37959831953048706,
-0.09624280035495758,
0.9795433282852173,
0.22663703560829163,
-0.36230117082595825,
0.12906023859977722,
0.027782106772065163,
-0.07032168656587601,
0.5414838194847107,
-0.20864394307136536,
0.3673078417778015,
-0.04702203348278999,
0.037954725325107574,
-0.9800521731376648,
-0.1336973011493683,
0.27291208505630493,
-0.7531648874282837,
0.247325137257576,
-0.19344612956047058,
-0.39969319105148315,
-0.22681701183319092,
-0.2456803321838379,
0.24401013553142548,
0.34931740164756775,
-0.15903611481189728,
0.7075707316398621,
0.6412612199783325,
-0.23076291382312775,
-0.6654926538467407,
-0.8831928968429565,
0.2790154218673706,
-0.25154462456703186,
-0.38760024309158325,
0.3412556052207947,
-0.06381623446941376,
0.13982225954532623,
0.04476470127701759,
0.030117923393845558,
-0.060479503124952316,
0.3676259219646454,
0.03330658748745918,
-0.07246899604797363,
-0.4763573706150055,
-0.173726424574852,
-0.10930480062961578,
-0.17554409801959991,
-0.09447137266397476,
-0.3592962920665741,
0.8748868107795715,
0.005580672528594732,
-0.39278072118759155,
0.03761032596230507,
0.7008429765701294,
0.6557005047798157,
-0.44277676939964294,
0.4992765486240387,
0.8378713726997375,
-0.38181936740875244,
-0.4434262216091156,
-0.18667194247245789,
0.14373338222503662,
-0.4277850091457367,
0.3807288408279419,
-0.6926456093788147,
-1.3348709344863892,
0.4463258683681488,
0.05014907196164131,
-0.14021888375282288,
0.6636045575141907,
1.044223427772522,
0.010890623554587364,
1.1033704280853271,
0.7631469964981079,
0.025507429614663124,
0.36300259828567505,
-0.18053069710731506,
0.1966596096754074,
-0.7149955034255981,
-0.046084992587566376,
-0.5372710227966309,
-0.13396084308624268,
-0.8526397943496704,
-0.3788401186466217,
0.18578234314918518,
-0.24874410033226013,
0.12256686389446259,
0.6453696489334106,
-0.6373242139816284,
0.4367779791355133,
0.6443598866462708,
-0.1528918296098709,
0.17432352900505066,
0.09155555069446564,
-0.39304810762405396,
-0.12769904732704163,
-0.35606497526168823,
-0.5089156031608582,
1.1944178342819214,
0.08791668713092804,
0.2995316982269287,
0.1897491216659546,
0.9484974145889282,
0.543958306312561,
0.12872394919395447,
-0.6470819711685181,
0.6271093487739563,
-0.290548175573349,
-0.6485470533370972,
-0.07153351604938507,
-0.17139875888824463,
-1.1014515161514282,
0.7255436778068542,
-0.10800302028656006,
-0.6029493808746338,
-0.12321712076663971,
-0.14844448864459991,
0.1046358123421669,
0.12539660930633545,
-0.38023871183395386,
1.1033467054367065,
-0.14805984497070312,
-0.10296072065830231,
-0.0856514424085617,
-0.1601591557264328,
0.18577580153942108,
-0.26576635241508484,
0.2147497832775116,
-0.5383509397506714,
-0.07924528419971466,
0.5501067638397217,
-0.060907114297151566,
0.7426763772964478,
-0.13791993260383606,
-0.1514267772436142,
0.3865128457546234,
0.13086096942424774,
0.42158904671669006,
-0.21945074200630188,
0.14303073287010193,
-0.04301361367106438,
-0.3484143316745758,
-0.35129374265670776,
-0.18935760855674744,
0.45962658524513245,
-0.4281772971153259,
-0.4097496569156647,
-0.6786216497421265,
-0.3994993567466736,
-0.10239441692829132,
0.2450772523880005,
0.5151398777961731,
0.30098938941955566,
-0.21663746237754822,
0.3514100909233093,
0.4713674485683441,
-0.17143648862838745,
0.4025154113769531,
0.6120558977127075,
-0.2363002747297287,
-0.5674116611480713,
0.9433351755142212,
0.09383008629083633,
-0.05514948442578316,
0.4419666826725006,
0.04579857736825943,
-0.10460946708917618,
-0.8175392150878906,
-0.4145124852657318,
0.08451473712921143,
-0.770115315914154,
-0.1985359638929367,
-0.8107779622077942,
-0.40731412172317505,
-0.3271659016609192,
-0.12241701036691666,
-0.3008952736854553,
-0.2484748363494873,
-0.21358437836170197,
-0.10564611107110977,
0.06700174510478973,
0.7782989144325256,
0.06564442068338394,
0.27897605299949646,
-0.6152325868606567,
0.12604428827762604,
0.033300112932920456,
-0.13462136685848236,
-0.5431240797042847,
-0.7608714699745178,
-0.3365384638309479,
-0.20638954639434814,
-0.4453650116920471,
-0.8313193321228027,
0.5726391077041626,
0.083159439265728,
0.782127320766449,
-0.17543360590934753,
-0.22313205897808075,
0.24605336785316467,
-0.5914434194564819,
0.9879781603813171,
-0.09914986789226532,
-0.681609034538269,
0.7507487535476685,
-0.46911144256591797,
0.577398419380188,
0.5049647092819214,
0.37958988547325134,
-0.4037110209465027,
-0.9485136866569519,
-0.6724479794502258,
-0.6674927473068237,
0.6206524968147278,
0.42787280678749084,
0.28347691893577576,
0.029712503775954247,
-0.03848687931895256,
0.1324363648891449,
0.41327428817749023,
-1.1002923250198364,
-0.2050035297870636,
0.006041408982127905,
-0.5957300662994385,
-0.1285046637058258,
-0.3847538232803345,
0.23425593972206116,
0.03755975514650345,
0.7419863939285278,
-0.13568070530891418,
0.4850524365901947,
-0.008473863825201988,
-0.2597210705280304,
0.11839447915554047,
0.5935315489768982,
0.9879192113876343,
0.29760003089904785,
0.1410788595676422,
0.520278811454773,
0.2920473515987396,
-0.6871278882026672,
0.3608461022377014,
0.03234514966607094,
-0.4695962071418762,
0.2760378420352936,
0.29192832112312317,
0.5972815752029419,
0.06273599714040756,
-0.4659028947353363,
0.5382720232009888,
0.034993160516023636,
-0.4671371579170227,
-0.3634621202945709,
-0.18786680698394775,
-0.011322656646370888,
0.2995440363883972,
0.1893889307975769,
-0.01790117286145687,
0.2949577867984772,
-0.4304197430610657,
0.6260035634040833,
0.4190424084663391,
-0.2576780915260315,
-0.5797602534294128,
0.657133936882019,
0.13325458765029907,
-0.32895997166633606,
-0.06975282728672028,
-0.613785445690155,
-0.9891902208328247,
0.6944068670272827,
0.6847952604293823,
1.1557799577713013,
-0.3423018157482147,
0.052953291684389114,
0.3847901225090027,
0.47047123312950134,
0.1336062252521515,
0.5115852355957031,
0.022308623418211937,
-0.798194408416748,
-0.4566165506839752,
-0.563977837562561,
-0.4379257261753082,
0.5359031558036804,
-0.11056958138942719,
0.5165094137191772,
-0.125149667263031,
-0.21930542588233948,
0.2529933750629425,
0.01583418808877468,
-0.40773287415504456,
0.06083980202674866,
0.31540578603744507,
0.3497978150844574,
-0.9229129552841187,
0.7465027570724487,
0.8597927093505859,
-0.5314840078353882,
-0.613002598285675,
-0.11377610266208649,
0.24774976074695587,
-0.6073535084724426,
0.4020525813102722,
0.2813566327095032,
-0.21916870772838593,
-0.04803938418626785,
-0.2705857753753662,
-0.8118239641189575,
0.8214609026908875,
0.29668086767196655,
-0.16128751635551453,
0.147764652967453,
0.3432520627975464,
0.3881153464317322,
-0.5918172597885132,
0.2738801836967468,
0.2818635404109955,
0.3682170510292053,
-0.2521114647388458,
-1.0166016817092896,
-0.2631918787956238,
-0.49090152978897095,
-0.2976608872413635,
0.43253093957901,
-0.6101797819137573,
1.0842695236206055,
0.41056591272354126,
-0.052659858018159866,
0.013060410507023335,
0.47647327184677124,
0.24081075191497803,
0.17342476546764374,
0.277271568775177,
0.7330360412597656,
0.6310604214668274,
-0.19900669157505035,
0.7875737547874451,
-0.28552335500717163,
0.5940683484077454,
0.9462628364562988,
-0.1009739488363266,
0.6261097192764282,
0.12194988876581192,
-0.3064192831516266,
0.3248082399368286,
0.7247991561889648,
-0.3028296232223511,
0.6054060459136963,
0.04647701606154442,
-0.5752764344215393,
-0.3299427032470703,
-0.10200514644384384,
-0.3006228804588318,
0.6322645545005798,
0.2751811146736145,
-0.5025960206985474,
-0.2615368366241455,
0.3910670280456543,
0.12380745261907578,
-0.02126050554215908,
-0.1860477179288864,
0.7401949763298035,
0.21321561932563782,
-0.7765463590621948,
0.4396345615386963,
0.17964540421962738,
0.9657721519470215,
-0.4787958264350891,
-0.05165548995137215,
-0.07746948301792145,
0.20601403713226318,
0.0031270391773432493,
-0.9050386548042297,
0.275385320186615,
0.13916125893592834,
-0.2205372303724289,
-0.40969282388687134,
1.1523756980895996,
-0.7904571294784546,
-0.4346106946468353,
0.19938847422599792,
0.642347514629364,
0.43292689323425293,
-0.12785547971725464,
-0.5558332204818726,
0.027495425194501877,
0.14025843143463135,
-0.27444761991500854,
0.3351656496524811,
0.6781794428825378,
0.012365601025521755,
0.3260387182235718,
0.41425031423568726,
-0.05022893100976944,
0.2890174984931946,
0.15381167829036713,
0.4254531264305115,
-0.7091295123100281,
-0.4374984800815582,
-0.9301306009292603,
0.3396071791648865,
0.07940235733985901,
-0.3600916266441345,
0.8487256765365601,
0.8240498304367065,
0.9553616642951965,
-0.3087872266769409,
1.100111722946167,
-0.022649291902780533,
0.480085551738739,
-0.5239545106887817,
0.41599875688552856,
-0.559174120426178,
-0.06743613630533218,
-0.0273575522005558,
-0.9306250810623169,
-0.03605913743376732,
0.5270513892173767,
-0.11445069313049316,
-0.034738939255476,
0.8907384872436523,
0.5820098519325256,
-0.1250796616077423,
-0.14874646067619324,
0.6196068525314331,
-0.27037790417671204,
0.12896455824375153,
0.6987504959106445,
1.1457563638687134,
-0.4613059163093567,
0.7053588628768921,
-0.16203424334526062,
0.2001299113035202,
-0.26572927832603455,
-0.8240326642990112,
-0.8924604654312134,
-0.5521429777145386,
-0.36019524931907654,
-0.3215625584125519,
-0.10118088871240616,
0.6804158091545105,
0.4781113564968109,
-1.0642387866973877,
-0.19230811297893524,
0.014719365164637566,
-0.012169514782726765,
0.07877033203840256,
-0.16729041934013367,
0.023650258779525757,
-0.43569326400756836,
-0.91725093126297,
0.5704089999198914,
0.5152167081832886,
0.16824796795845032,
-0.20722658932209015,
0.09015157073736191,
-0.32283419370651245,
-0.053606994450092316,
0.6788486242294312,
-0.06178664043545723,
-0.6848245859146118,
-0.4590936601161957,
0.13708850741386414,
-0.3362009525299072,
0.36260873079299927,
0.839344322681427,
-0.3160226345062256,
0.22035188972949982,
0.5435134172439575,
0.6265661716461182,
0.7574675679206848,
-0.1642952412366867,
0.4758511483669281,
-0.8793686032295227,
0.31700676679611206,
0.3339506983757019,
0.5470873117446899,
0.35158735513687134,
-0.3032231032848358,
0.6734092235565186,
0.6116558909416199,
-0.5435584783554077,
-0.7642589211463928,
0.3258112072944641,
-0.9253413081169128,
-0.22656598687171936,
1.1303246021270752,
-0.1960524022579193,
-0.2526458203792572,
-0.32812872529029846,
-0.2572825849056244,
0.13189765810966492,
-0.15063835680484772,
0.1407168209552765,
1.031121015548706,
-0.06986173242330551,
-0.5626510381698608,
-0.8053598403930664,
0.3583262264728546,
0.3325750529766083,
-0.992944061756134,
-0.2710740566253662,
0.2763594686985016,
0.4481433033943176,
0.3504999876022339,
1.0126444101333618,
-0.2157551497220993,
0.3794209659099579,
0.23642142117023468,
0.3089503049850464,
0.027942702174186707,
-0.3466089367866516,
-0.27803391218185425,
0.44456273317337036,
0.16704435646533966,
-0.2533659338951111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05449v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05449v2
|
RoT: Enhancing Large Language Models with Reflection on Search Trees
| 2024-04-08T12:31:23 | 2024-04-11T05:21:00 |
Wenyang Hui, Chengyue Jiang, Yan Wang, Kewei Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capability in
reasoning and planning when integrated with tree-search-based prompting
methods. However, since these methods ignore the previous search experiences,
they often make the same mistakes in the search process. To address this issue,
we introduce Reflection on search Trees (RoT), an LLM reflection framework
designed to improve the performance of tree-search-based prompting methods. It
uses a strong LLM to summarize guidelines from previous tree search experiences
to enhance the ability of a weak LLM. The guidelines are instructions about
solving this task through tree search which can prevent the weak LLMs from
making similar mistakes in the past search process. In addition, we proposed a
novel state selection method, which identifies the critical information from
historical search processes to help RoT generate more specific and meaningful
guidelines. In our extensive experiments, we find that RoT significantly
improves the performance of LLMs in reasoning or planning tasks with various
tree-search-based prompting methods (e.g., BFS and MCTS). Non-tree-search-based
prompting methods such as Chain-of-Thought (CoT) can also benefit from RoT
guidelines since RoT can provide task-specific knowledge collected from the
search experience.
|
[
-0.18244315683841705,
-0.6822913885116577,
0.8376715779304504,
0.15569037199020386,
-0.3985910713672638,
0.2121850997209549,
-0.1762736290693283,
-0.31424686312675476,
0.39108750224113464,
0.6974417567253113,
-0.6221188902854919,
-0.4716792106628418,
-0.3284570574760437,
0.07653495669364929,
-0.5021107196807861,
0.750211775302887,
-0.10040074586868286,
0.006458214018493891,
-0.0533333420753479,
0.09267854690551758,
-0.41476690769195557,
-0.19081875681877136,
-0.6208635568618774,
-0.2895016372203827,
0.523667573928833,
0.3614160716533661,
0.8016870617866516,
0.3782695233821869,
0.35849979519844055,
0.1673775166273117,
-0.5089726448059082,
0.435443252325058,
-0.638145387172699,
0.5951136350631714,
-0.40949347615242004,
-0.44488027691841125,
-0.3718396723270416,
-0.3322676122188568,
0.554648220539093,
0.37533578276634216,
-0.3666583001613617,
-0.04920659586787224,
-0.10374775528907776,
0.7069109082221985,
-0.794387936592102,
0.31206566095352173,
-0.9963809847831726,
0.04432147741317749,
-0.1964016556739807,
-0.6891584992408752,
-0.8051721453666687,
-0.5582728385925293,
0.1915435791015625,
-0.5083522796630859,
0.22711904346942902,
-0.07733725011348724,
0.5121371150016785,
0.1369922012090683,
-0.1897713840007782,
-0.2444860190153122,
-0.7725346684455872,
0.6884788870811462,
-0.8653726577758789,
0.32600831985473633,
0.42842280864715576,
0.2540706694126129,
-0.5382483601570129,
-0.5506064295768738,
-0.22980423271656036,
-0.2743131220340729,
-0.009693676605820656,
0.08793830871582031,
0.095086969435215,
0.343129962682724,
0.3421911895275116,
0.287016361951828,
-0.2833915650844574,
-0.19780249893665314,
0.06318720430135727,
-0.2569020390510559,
0.4841436445713043,
0.2594508230686188,
0.31602680683135986,
-0.011167172342538834,
-0.01695418916642666,
-0.34836387634277344,
-1.1428972482681274,
0.1271888166666031,
0.0521998256444931,
0.4392569661140442,
0.36943182349205017,
0.6033449172973633,
-0.33418890833854675,
0.6068415641784668,
-0.21233370900154114,
-0.46297529339790344,
-0.16088378429412842,
-0.21227237582206726,
-0.12185956537723541,
-0.06151660904288292,
0.2662715017795563,
0.20413708686828613,
0.3250408172607422,
-0.0514935702085495,
-0.5001987218856812,
-0.043904297053813934,
0.2972707152366638,
-0.7913546562194824,
-0.27644187211990356,
-0.21782410144805908,
-0.49772173166275024,
-0.31065407395362854,
0.037791505455970764,
-0.8572041988372803,
-0.4849008321762085,
-0.20185384154319763,
0.2724212110042572,
-0.42687880992889404,
-0.36448371410369873,
0.06846358627080917,
-0.17983931303024292,
0.33764731884002686,
0.7774674296379089,
-0.6221028566360474,
0.42802414298057556,
0.671851634979248,
0.6896675825119019,
-0.07980126142501831,
-0.2176484912633896,
-0.7866995334625244,
0.3268051743507385,
-0.6244350075721741,
0.5334636569023132,
-0.9567949175834656,
-0.5358477234840393,
0.3667592704296112,
-0.1818215250968933,
0.17090293765068054,
-0.6766886711120605,
0.47791972756385803,
-0.7686042785644531,
0.06372830271720886,
-0.32768720388412476,
-0.14510881900787354,
-0.5150468945503235,
0.28335511684417725,
-0.7609164118766785,
1.4473323822021484,
0.1847931146621704,
-0.660809338092804,
0.3174121379852295,
-0.5944568514823914,
-0.7091312408447266,
0.15557464957237244,
-0.274591863155365,
-0.37365981936454773,
0.40710875391960144,
0.5758286714553833,
0.27188998460769653,
-0.4476151466369629,
0.5729662775993347,
-0.3004574179649353,
-0.38372287154197693,
-0.014331832528114319,
-0.45815497636795044,
0.7637306451797485,
-0.15094994008541107,
-0.5895452499389648,
0.22305019199848175,
-0.22796876728534698,
0.36817118525505066,
0.05415157973766327,
-0.47094619274139404,
-0.25797364115715027,
0.5173072814941406,
-0.2770019769668579,
0.06375566124916077,
0.07925163209438324,
-0.14638715982437134,
0.4892244338989258,
-0.5149562954902649,
0.33090347051620483,
0.7783201932907104,
-0.06051991134881973,
0.08202663064002991,
-0.3716074824333191,
0.6470651626586914,
-0.13657866418361664,
0.13875360786914825,
-0.4844508171081543,
-0.44813674688339233,
-0.7489733099937439,
-0.12431944161653519,
-0.04421716928482056,
0.3334335386753082,
-0.8414465188980103,
0.12221352010965347,
-0.31738486886024475,
-0.26199477910995483,
-0.4588029980659485,
0.09244831651449203,
0.3563959002494812,
0.11125735193490982,
0.5680418014526367,
-0.24845358729362488,
-0.7658450603485107,
-0.552291989326477,
-0.2095666527748108,
-0.5051172375679016,
0.12591512501239777,
0.5947532653808594,
0.3084625005722046,
-0.2556785047054291,
1.10061514377594,
-0.5180870294570923,
-0.19359862804412842,
-0.347460001707077,
-0.056620582938194275,
0.0948919951915741,
-0.19972483813762665,
0.18665845692157745,
-0.6167296767234802,
-0.5579099059104919,
-0.11680962890386581,
-0.3975706398487091,
-0.16088257730007172,
0.0048531354404985905,
-0.024755580350756645,
0.38454318046569824,
0.5245805382728577,
-0.7193066477775574,
0.5801252126693726,
0.4344556927680969,
-0.30828285217285156,
0.7100802063941956,
-0.028516031801700592,
-0.07763253897428513,
-0.7175140380859375,
0.08733890950679779,
-0.3273722231388092,
-0.38573965430259705,
-0.2507755756378174,
0.2558472156524658,
-0.04282652214169502,
0.049952805042266846,
-0.41640758514404297,
0.6206791996955872,
-0.565236508846283,
-0.20794518291950226,
-0.2818616032600403,
0.03784623742103577,
0.010042287409305573,
0.3751015067100525,
0.14924558997154236,
0.8367733955383301,
0.635753870010376,
-0.5130552053451538,
0.08804204314947128,
0.15487506985664368,
-0.32490378618240356,
0.13688868284225464,
-0.19869457185268402,
0.2209542691707611,
-0.06153247877955437,
0.5878335237503052,
-0.8121436238288879,
-0.009962880983948708,
-0.0695372223854065,
-0.039597347378730774,
0.31446608901023865,
-0.16525882482528687,
-0.52106773853302,
-0.42853325605392456,
-0.6832671761512756,
0.4827410876750946,
0.4388877749443054,
-0.7848605513572693,
0.8432313799858093,
0.10626459121704102,
-0.1585896611213684,
-0.5590630173683167,
-0.3448062241077423,
0.2075689435005188,
-0.057969510555267334,
-0.4818272292613983,
0.47501930594444275,
0.019580338150262833,
-0.2061813473701477,
0.03172945976257324,
-0.40595903992652893,
0.051441337913274765,
0.05969981476664543,
0.1921308934688568,
0.2681543231010437,
-0.3772643506526947,
-0.1496589183807373,
0.04153026267886162,
0.09765444695949554,
0.1534012109041214,
-0.17683184146881104,
0.727008044719696,
0.001333758351393044,
-0.3572307229042053,
-0.427902489900589,
0.08764953911304474,
0.7249357104301453,
-0.36861419677734375,
0.48957446217536926,
-0.01086997240781784,
-0.15125931799411774,
-0.5318867564201355,
-0.8389771580696106,
-0.5235511660575867,
-0.5083785057067871,
0.2874237596988678,
-0.3532407879829407,
-0.946919858455658,
0.20365604758262634,
-0.42002296447753906,
0.07017556577920914,
0.2390562891960144,
0.444804310798645,
-0.18581177294254303,
1.256814956665039,
0.62156742811203,
-0.376102089881897,
0.5836524963378906,
-0.19833479821681976,
0.25937074422836304,
-1.0136173963546753,
-0.1591196060180664,
-0.407386839389801,
-0.24404607713222504,
-0.37444624304771423,
-0.6958281397819519,
0.22333301603794098,
0.20846328139305115,
-0.11335013806819916,
0.08810108155012131,
-0.5174501538276672,
0.6006697416305542,
0.40220701694488525,
0.10538014024496078,
0.41663268208503723,
0.02362094260752201,
-0.30496567487716675,
-0.03229835629463196,
-0.6718976497650146,
-0.475872665643692,
0.8849031925201416,
0.27033013105392456,
0.9260135293006897,
-0.07141973078250885,
0.7356047630310059,
0.149931401014328,
0.5041095018386841,
-0.8542569279670715,
0.9236353635787964,
0.025381142273545265,
-0.5122890472412109,
-0.6317876577377319,
-0.4514673948287964,
-0.8059934377670288,
0.25783219933509827,
0.2201792597770691,
-0.6797165274620056,
-0.13183419406414032,
0.11238165944814682,
-0.03690090775489807,
0.48350057005882263,
-0.20971858501434326,
0.22329489886760712,
-0.3654538094997406,
0.006521322764456272,
-0.47444528341293335,
-0.2656617760658264,
0.29906347393989563,
0.10747857391834259,
0.11357473582029343,
-0.05576283112168312,
0.059467218816280365,
0.570268988609314,
-0.495776504278183,
1.0407103300094604,
-0.4165966212749481,
0.009173098020255566,
0.5719096660614014,
0.7039294838905334,
1.2881414890289307,
-0.0855790451169014,
-0.15355046093463898,
-0.30525609850883484,
-0.013466829434037209,
0.07268967479467392,
-0.6109622716903687,
0.46553051471710205,
-0.4399104714393616,
-0.8354694843292236,
-0.2646278142929077,
-0.5050246119499207,
-0.211531400680542,
0.27852559089660645,
-0.06028379127383232,
0.27236491441726685,
-0.19595740735530853,
0.2409191131591797,
0.6892693638801575,
-0.24197106063365936,
0.42688849568367004,
0.6791412234306335,
-0.7785548567771912,
-0.3908331096172333,
0.8698756694793701,
-0.015797583386301994,
0.14319446682929993,
0.4246779680252075,
0.527363657951355,
-0.26659783720970154,
-0.6750514507293701,
-0.09228571504354477,
0.30592766404151917,
-0.6596068143844604,
-0.5959404110908508,
-0.32927271723747253,
-0.369718074798584,
-0.1283993273973465,
-0.05751078948378563,
-0.26310616731643677,
-0.26256370544433594,
-0.06380873173475266,
-0.10727272927761078,
0.39190512895584106,
0.8881670832633972,
0.41685086488723755,
0.17871466279029846,
-0.4782911539077759,
0.28075629472732544,
0.25761285424232483,
0.4316917955875397,
0.2211901843547821,
-0.4383802115917206,
-0.022254578769207,
0.05756568908691406,
-0.42908287048339844,
-0.9563011527061462,
0.33684855699539185,
0.14249002933502197,
0.51842200756073,
0.4364396333694458,
0.12264352291822433,
0.8227367997169495,
-0.5954475402832031,
0.6103003621101379,
0.011803727596998215,
-0.9305770397186279,
0.7665824890136719,
-0.3227916955947876,
0.3185652792453766,
0.5936830639839172,
0.12672066688537598,
-0.6645385026931763,
-0.6980098485946655,
-0.5345065593719482,
-0.8486082553863525,
0.897273063659668,
0.01435048971325159,
0.06647779047489166,
0.05921313539147377,
0.37348178029060364,
-0.08257053047418594,
0.1344466209411621,
-0.8807548880577087,
0.023268818855285645,
0.01732620783150196,
0.03225838765501976,
0.29432588815689087,
-0.5671872496604919,
-0.25429046154022217,
-0.3663941025733948,
0.7999076247215271,
-0.37197527289390564,
0.014894208870828152,
0.19269973039627075,
-0.1568443328142166,
-0.4515385627746582,
0.09904783964157104,
0.500763475894928,
0.6427446603775024,
0.00954535510390997,
0.40895363688468933,
0.411133348941803,
-0.357236385345459,
0.11669889092445374,
-0.3518098294734955,
-0.5542823076248169,
0.06138284131884575,
0.4991617500782013,
0.6209743618965149,
0.420904278755188,
-0.6850667595863342,
0.3494909703731537,
0.1880447119474411,
-0.12750878930091858,
-0.09676077216863632,
0.29491135478019714,
0.12387949973344803,
0.15260298550128937,
0.41983312368392944,
-0.20255474746227264,
0.14066509902477264,
-0.6014050245285034,
0.10378880053758621,
0.7289398908615112,
-0.2607262432575226,
-0.25405219197273254,
0.14563246071338654,
0.17468047142028809,
-0.6326574683189392,
0.8342275619506836,
-0.14678125083446503,
-0.8962486982345581,
0.39894863963127136,
0.7689120173454285,
0.9999438524246216,
-0.5376893281936646,
0.5026121139526367,
0.2860521078109741,
0.38567227125167847,
-0.46840861439704895,
0.5189217329025269,
-0.127982497215271,
-0.5740665793418884,
-0.8119727373123169,
-0.5498003959655762,
-0.4649540185928345,
0.36273276805877686,
-0.43709176778793335,
0.4076381325721741,
-0.5376824140548706,
0.04246688634157181,
-0.5698109865188599,
-0.013832350261509418,
-0.4352979063987732,
0.04858781769871712,
-0.09869137406349182,
1.1997886896133423,
-0.5931275486946106,
0.8036702275276184,
0.5070375800132751,
-0.04906812310218811,
-0.9534553289413452,
0.3087387681007385,
0.004288488533347845,
-0.8174718618392944,
0.6168999671936035,
0.2547580599784851,
-0.4484061896800995,
-0.2013910859823227,
-0.5827552080154419,
-1.1643062829971313,
1.0626521110534668,
0.4721425473690033,
-0.5801191926002502,
-0.24190503358840942,
0.10715784877538681,
0.6262345910072327,
-0.2561294138431549,
0.5080130696296692,
0.4515215754508972,
0.628348171710968,
0.35572344064712524,
-0.8985480666160583,
0.22793936729431152,
0.04032387584447861,
0.18164807558059692,
0.48060548305511475,
-0.45421481132507324,
0.4893556535243988,
-0.2092852145433426,
-0.40688180923461914,
-0.008701895363628864,
0.3760966360569,
0.48005637526512146,
0.25015655159950256,
0.5635953545570374,
0.5071477293968201,
0.829615592956543,
0.014109528623521328,
0.9033320546150208,
-0.14451070129871368,
0.13371625542640686,
1.319312334060669,
-0.5421000123023987,
1.1564874649047852,
0.4853454828262329,
-0.2811688184738159,
0.6421744227409363,
0.49205482006073,
0.2133650779724121,
0.6365926861763,
0.2824499011039734,
-0.32547569274902344,
-0.3505980968475342,
-0.14849822223186493,
-0.2768007516860962,
0.17204129695892334,
0.3487476110458374,
-0.36458832025527954,
-0.4015774726867676,
-0.32931962609291077,
-0.04966149106621742,
-0.023517990484833717,
-0.20901229977607727,
0.8398815393447876,
0.07123707234859467,
-0.9225684404373169,
0.4711171090602875,
0.006345483940094709,
0.4987455904483795,
-0.46106842160224915,
-0.25699612498283386,
-0.20058874785900116,
-0.017763692885637283,
-0.3556918203830719,
-0.761507511138916,
0.3135777711868286,
-0.19857123494148254,
-0.1695166975259781,
-0.49787360429763794,
0.6830913424491882,
-0.338504433631897,
-0.37132757902145386,
0.65987229347229,
0.41159048676490784,
0.031856317073106766,
-0.2606047987937927,
-0.5674278736114502,
0.2927040159702301,
0.16977323591709137,
-0.44315052032470703,
0.11333096027374268,
0.5114174485206604,
-0.399426132440567,
0.8719485402107239,
0.6362449526786804,
0.21847274899482727,
0.0034188060089945793,
0.16534309089183807,
1.1174577474594116,
-0.8585060238838196,
-0.19882847368717194,
-0.8855526447296143,
0.3478182554244995,
0.12164682149887085,
0.028101321309804916,
0.47444984316825867,
0.7704986929893494,
0.7266796231269836,
0.14674052596092224,
0.5869104862213135,
0.056034039705991745,
0.5651084780693054,
-0.7093966007232666,
0.40155327320098877,
-0.36886855959892273,
0.38841116428375244,
-0.23429836332798004,
-1.3833138942718506,
-0.19927841424942017,
0.6871281862258911,
-0.4451870918273926,
0.15128175914287567,
0.8317948579788208,
1.0439351797103882,
0.011678497307002544,
0.09313703328371048,
0.29530787467956543,
0.39163413643836975,
0.6080384850502014,
0.3287610411643982,
1.1276978254318237,
0.031881898641586304,
0.5954667925834656,
0.026625510305166245,
-0.01650061272084713,
-0.5704436898231506,
-0.8975769281387329,
-0.7864459753036499,
-0.5025244951248169,
-0.15802179276943207,
-0.2618559002876282,
0.10701737552881241,
0.7107702493667603,
0.730035126209259,
-0.6704475283622742,
-0.4061709940433502,
-0.41089025139808655,
0.36962032318115234,
-0.26659083366394043,
-0.2787237763404846,
0.29753634333610535,
-0.4158477783203125,
-0.1855839490890503,
0.8587457537651062,
0.5113086700439453,
-0.15523502230644226,
-0.43146222829818726,
-0.4192241132259369,
-0.15006017684936523,
0.11912507563829422,
0.6513277292251587,
0.22734621167182922,
-1.1136311292648315,
-0.3292692303657532,
-0.004234714433550835,
-0.015002868138253689,
0.2654208540916443,
1.2437126636505127,
-0.9618310332298279,
0.5846838355064392,
0.5037146806716919,
0.5232349038124084,
0.9223147034645081,
-0.14720912277698517,
0.5966775417327881,
-0.5931915640830994,
-0.1479554921388626,
0.6811555624008179,
0.2691906690597534,
0.2467406690120697,
-0.24799059331417084,
0.6621970534324646,
-0.09756682813167572,
-0.3932132422924042,
-0.9756748080253601,
0.2992630898952484,
-0.665810227394104,
-0.3411601185798645,
1.2258163690567017,
0.05849280580878258,
-0.12302084267139435,
0.002249840646982193,
-0.5480967164039612,
-0.02772790752351284,
-0.4167943000793457,
0.9249695539474487,
0.8056750893592834,
-0.1327192336320877,
-0.23883798718452454,
-0.38426023721694946,
0.7901572585105896,
0.6989001631736755,
-0.8411257266998291,
0.43348562717437744,
0.4090505838394165,
0.14567364752292633,
0.12278798222541809,
0.7377433180809021,
-0.1555004119873047,
0.32770591974258423,
-0.41397541761398315,
-0.1551429033279419,
0.1467345654964447,
-0.8193808197975159,
-0.20769797265529633,
0.016305122524499893,
0.6211850047111511,
0.5088099241256714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05446v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05446v1
|
XL$^2$Bench: A Benchmark for Extremely Long Context Understanding with Long-range Dependencies
| 2024-04-08T12:29:07 | 2024-04-08T12:29:07 |
Xuanfan Ni, Hengyi Cai, Xiaochi Wei, Shuaiqiang Wang, Dawei Yin, Piji Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance across
diverse tasks but are constrained by their small context window sizes. Various
efforts have been proposed to expand the context window to accommodate even up
to 200K input tokens. Meanwhile, building high-quality benchmarks with much
longer text lengths and more demanding tasks to provide comprehensive
evaluations is of immense practical interest to facilitate long context
understanding research of LLMs. However, prior benchmarks create datasets that
ostensibly cater to long-text comprehension by expanding the input of
traditional tasks, which falls short to exhibit the unique characteristics of
long-text understanding, including long dependency tasks and longer text length
compatible with modern LLMs' context window size. In this paper, we introduce a
benchmark for extremely long context understanding with long-range
dependencies, XL$^2$Bench, which includes three scenarios: Fiction Reading,
Paper Reading, and Law Reading, and four tasks of increasing complexity: Memory
Retrieval, Detailed Understanding, Overall Understanding, and Open-ended
Generation, covering 27 subtasks in English and Chinese. It has an average
length of 100K+ words (English) and 200K+ characters (Chinese). Evaluating six
leading LLMs on XL$^2$Bench, we find that their performance significantly lags
behind human levels. Moreover, the observed decline in performance across both
the original and enhanced datasets underscores the efficacy of our approach to
mitigating data contamination.
|
[
-0.31510838866233826,
-0.579190194606781,
0.9176486730575562,
0.29677996039390564,
-0.29513922333717346,
-0.23401352763175964,
-0.5117461085319519,
-0.9571969509124756,
-0.4214010238647461,
0.6174792051315308,
-0.3957057297229767,
-0.3277980387210846,
-0.561407744884491,
0.09487579762935638,
-0.26082974672317505,
0.6539526581764221,
-0.3702686131000519,
-0.15418671071529388,
-0.2965009808540344,
-0.3755550682544708,
-0.47913095355033875,
-0.3418043255805969,
-0.448164165019989,
-0.2296711951494217,
0.5897599458694458,
0.19317984580993652,
0.4384121596813202,
0.9729928374290466,
0.3290373384952545,
0.17154331505298615,
-0.24503181874752045,
0.135214701294899,
-0.7677475214004517,
0.11386164277791977,
-0.27945810556411743,
-0.5276685953140259,
-0.22737954556941986,
-0.0980743020772934,
0.8435736298561096,
0.8078159689903259,
0.25731515884399414,
0.04112958163022995,
0.190659761428833,
0.8979105949401855,
-0.8109875321388245,
0.337342768907547,
-0.28197404742240906,
0.07395798712968826,
-0.4585720896720886,
0.18507599830627441,
-0.5248420834541321,
0.2701670825481415,
0.11258837580680847,
-0.602109968662262,
-0.2336253821849823,
0.19777525961399078,
0.568840742111206,
0.2344169169664383,
-0.7889286279678345,
0.025052417069673538,
-0.5018040537834167,
0.9837791323661804,
-0.504166305065155,
0.5302554965019226,
0.6594935655593872,
0.379634827375412,
-0.17808957397937775,
-0.6363055109977722,
-0.501548707485199,
-0.11181307584047318,
-0.14431829750537872,
0.12140046805143356,
-0.010444015264511108,
-0.12901264429092407,
0.521109402179718,
0.054623156785964966,
-0.38922345638275146,
0.30401504039764404,
-0.06280285865068436,
0.16474062204360962,
0.4937572777271271,
0.31834495067596436,
-0.041511449962854385,
-0.24824972450733185,
-0.5550869703292847,
-0.03560909256339073,
-0.8208025097846985,
0.30930662155151367,
-0.08119161427021027,
0.1793055534362793,
-0.20442822575569153,
0.2807949483394623,
-0.22071485221385956,
0.7701157331466675,
-0.4201734960079193,
-0.13857969641685486,
0.1354389637708664,
-0.4846520721912384,
-0.14554227888584137,
-0.2845838665962219,
0.5037593841552734,
0.3806869685649872,
0.12429167330265045,
-0.2614849805831909,
-0.2747613787651062,
-0.44629403948783875,
-0.08242281526327133,
-0.910407543182373,
0.2953677475452423,
0.22426936030387878,
-0.4370698928833008,
0.3063200116157532,
-0.0396425761282444,
-0.7445263266563416,
-0.5924577116966248,
-0.5386272072792053,
0.20204101502895355,
-0.5261539220809937,
0.022416802123188972,
-0.019868601113557816,
0.119402676820755,
0.25512656569480896,
0.2788756787776947,
-0.7877826690673828,
0.39048704504966736,
0.9232861399650574,
0.8101631999015808,
-0.3433513939380646,
-0.4767221510410309,
-0.7549380660057068,
0.43415194749832153,
-0.36412104964256287,
0.7654837965965271,
-0.5072891116142273,
-0.317749947309494,
0.0011152859078720212,
0.11069302260875702,
0.17185208201408386,
-0.5278813242912292,
0.7461580038070679,
-0.4066861867904663,
-0.06775711476802826,
-0.42285972833633423,
-0.6811479926109314,
-0.19842912256717682,
0.1245780810713768,
-0.6886099576950073,
1.0723100900650024,
0.3907887935638428,
-0.5963535904884338,
0.3538811504840851,
-0.4505062699317932,
-0.613915741443634,
0.07614670693874359,
-0.43384677171707153,
-0.08133377879858017,
0.008613839745521545,
0.1233704462647438,
0.4974040389060974,
-0.6369177103042603,
0.15521518886089325,
-0.35244548320770264,
-0.6558738946914673,
0.07920772582292557,
-0.35499221086502075,
0.5648224949836731,
0.02677001804113388,
-0.6266273856163025,
-0.11146235466003418,
-0.8911504745483398,
-0.001037973677739501,
-0.09122910350561142,
-0.2689669728279114,
-0.5976967215538025,
0.18696318566799164,
0.3629149794578552,
0.14300566911697388,
0.2970997989177704,
-0.47730591893196106,
-0.16618794202804565,
-0.13263113796710968,
0.5505570769309998,
0.8543168902397156,
-0.4157414138317108,
0.16128751635551453,
-0.24766816198825836,
0.2376081794500351,
0.0005865157581865788,
-0.16765622794628143,
-0.44855087995529175,
0.11949669569730759,
-0.40374547243118286,
-0.36665424704551697,
0.16841061413288116,
0.40147796273231506,
-0.358171284198761,
0.4652283191680908,
-0.44062137603759766,
-0.15378855168819427,
0.13200226426124573,
0.2107718288898468,
0.4997026026248932,
0.5629209280014038,
0.47916513681411743,
0.03205249458551407,
-0.3836635649204254,
-0.9570824503898621,
-0.30071568489074707,
0.09478868544101715,
-0.2663043439388275,
0.6624443531036377,
0.46715131402015686,
-0.310515433549881,
0.8216943740844727,
-0.43235480785369873,
-0.37644675374031067,
-0.1307993084192276,
-0.05112389847636223,
0.2597188949584961,
0.2365012764930725,
0.4381137192249298,
-0.6449224352836609,
-0.5333727598190308,
0.02820424549281597,
-0.6322808265686035,
-0.051922641694545746,
-0.11266476660966873,
-0.17247828841209412,
0.32410863041877747,
0.8033087849617004,
-0.41340580582618713,
0.23555803298950195,
0.5350289940834045,
-0.4539659321308136,
0.6265367269515991,
-0.19847580790519714,
-0.10466606914997101,
-1.091830849647522,
0.2963855266571045,
0.16263802349567413,
-0.35353347659111023,
-0.27803054451942444,
0.1325201392173767,
0.6417784094810486,
0.1776784509420395,
-0.36163145303726196,
0.7116320133209229,
-0.6104627251625061,
-0.16178445518016815,
-0.25063878297805786,
0.3054288923740387,
0.05467221885919571,
0.26898810267448425,
0.08686515688896179,
0.7450024485588074,
0.22835202515125275,
-0.2602260410785675,
0.12760864198207855,
0.14016784727573395,
-0.7642764449119568,
0.5953523516654968,
-0.5366179347038269,
-0.07771887630224228,
0.08658146113157272,
0.7360692620277405,
-0.9195405840873718,
-0.10207927972078323,
-0.24702323973178864,
0.02856774814426899,
0.3835858106613159,
0.06398586183786392,
-0.7147971987724304,
-0.282172828912735,
-0.3094307482242584,
0.6234551668167114,
0.3987056612968445,
-0.8082420825958252,
0.459753155708313,
0.16298329830169678,
-0.16850601136684418,
-0.9207205176353455,
-0.6921627521514893,
0.3723592758178711,
-0.14564763009548187,
-0.5987211465835571,
0.4297780394554138,
-0.021855365484952927,
-0.3837537169456482,
-0.10555000603199005,
-0.18002940714359283,
-0.01096343994140625,
-0.05295613408088684,
0.29831066727638245,
0.11074494570493698,
-0.2604900598526001,
0.21799686551094055,
-0.04176899045705795,
-0.10973111540079117,
0.24159687757492065,
-0.0468766875565052,
0.41577810049057007,
0.0807599127292633,
-0.014322806149721146,
-0.1829172968864441,
0.4895002245903015,
0.7857288718223572,
-0.0450432263314724,
0.6167379021644592,
0.38425517082214355,
-0.40801262855529785,
-0.3603782653808594,
-0.6085428595542908,
0.1428062468767166,
-0.4276884198188782,
0.8085359334945679,
-0.6587805151939392,
-0.8535460233688354,
0.5953928828239441,
-0.07357056438922882,
0.11620428413152695,
0.3809812664985657,
0.25599971413612366,
0.0025870883837342262,
0.8073137998580933,
0.6111564636230469,
-0.40966734290122986,
0.4191890060901642,
0.01851772330701351,
-0.14393149316310883,
-1.0435152053833008,
0.007677235174924135,
-0.35587817430496216,
-0.2319486141204834,
-0.2841792404651642,
-0.6282793283462524,
0.07429789006710052,
0.0762799084186554,
-0.21766448020935059,
0.2854625880718231,
0.017986221238970757,
0.6963664293289185,
0.21913602948188782,
0.13511374592781067,
0.22675733268260956,
-0.31764137744903564,
-0.11984801292419434,
0.044151242822408676,
-0.22241099178791046,
-0.2719532549381256,
1.340790033340454,
0.46940386295318604,
0.5760520696640015,
0.07323335111141205,
0.33508092164993286,
0.14992743730545044,
0.10066220909357071,
-0.6066587567329407,
0.48059356212615967,
-0.44529110193252563,
-0.3174833655357361,
-0.42127788066864014,
-0.46943509578704834,
-1.0235059261322021,
0.15101800858974457,
0.188190296292305,
-0.8305084705352783,
0.06372940540313721,
-0.283223956823349,
-0.26971951127052307,
0.22077101469039917,
-0.43101027607917786,
0.7868130803108215,
-0.40820732712745667,
-0.7644861936569214,
-0.33820608258247375,
-0.7761771082878113,
0.29870760440826416,
-0.323740690946579,
0.32986316084861755,
-0.22629496455192566,
-0.42323872447013855,
0.7954934239387512,
-0.43062078952789307,
0.5637235045433044,
-0.047557633370161057,
-0.2864857316017151,
-0.17218130826950073,
-0.16347187757492065,
0.6796631217002869,
0.22457477450370789,
-0.2201266884803772,
0.08696016669273376,
0.12980133295059204,
-0.6440064311027527,
-0.30544403195381165,
0.8868987560272217,
-0.7509380578994751,
-0.4445972740650177,
-0.2833595275878906,
-0.8869705200195312,
-0.5677508115768433,
0.407280832529068,
0.1640235036611557,
0.5429205894470215,
-0.1392914056777954,
0.49084416031837463,
0.6735578179359436,
-0.13716907799243927,
0.4617583751678467,
0.7511545419692993,
-0.0873648151755333,
-0.13541603088378906,
0.4987984299659729,
0.11355716735124588,
0.20403707027435303,
0.5756850242614746,
0.0014522649580612779,
-0.49296244978904724,
-0.6526413559913635,
-0.41579368710517883,
0.2162409871816635,
-0.6796746850013733,
0.03756500035524368,
-0.5599048733711243,
-0.06124361976981163,
-0.23992620408535004,
-0.10969987511634827,
-0.13437218964099884,
-0.026518983766436577,
-0.27946847677230835,
0.05323716625571251,
0.19984851777553558,
0.7388595342636108,
-0.009743237867951393,
-0.01668700762093067,
-0.6852023601531982,
0.3712889850139618,
0.17816561460494995,
0.6837596893310547,
0.160413458943367,
-0.5548186302185059,
-0.6137409210205078,
-0.2277185022830963,
-0.0689491406083107,
-0.3755488395690918,
0.040407873690128326,
0.026119226589798927,
0.5002623200416565,
0.5770285129547119,
0.14697040617465973,
0.7485355734825134,
-0.6711833477020264,
0.7049492001533508,
0.11675496399402618,
-0.9165970087051392,
0.10564722865819931,
-0.48664045333862305,
0.6003015041351318,
0.7404283285140991,
0.244818314909935,
-0.6282034516334534,
-0.21217218041419983,
-0.11266577988862991,
-1.0469255447387695,
0.7586895823478699,
-0.12522020936012268,
0.04427675902843475,
0.14907558262348175,
0.454539030790329,
0.3961124122142792,
-0.24370521306991577,
-0.573235809803009,
-0.07925956696271896,
0.2383325845003128,
-0.03472645580768585,
-0.530945897102356,
-0.4091808497905731,
-0.15265990793704987,
-0.15302254259586334,
0.36997556686401367,
-0.1440531462430954,
-0.048863109201192856,
0.09724730253219604,
-0.22249123454093933,
-0.09495020657777786,
0.25044864416122437,
0.6248876452445984,
0.9630506634712219,
-0.3580843210220337,
0.22219884395599365,
0.3282272219657898,
-0.4124796986579895,
-0.005830120295286179,
0.5179517269134521,
0.3278852105140686,
-0.2807128429412842,
0.4525924324989319,
0.6186730861663818,
0.292261004447937,
-1.124995470046997,
0.40339550375938416,
-0.1563713252544403,
-0.12841206789016724,
-0.4574277400970459,
-0.05517399311065674,
0.39245718717575073,
0.2147970050573349,
0.5524596571922302,
-0.32301145792007446,
-0.027559367939829826,
-0.5802356600761414,
0.3983213007450104,
0.2814420163631439,
-0.5579649209976196,
-0.01736276037991047,
0.5477485060691833,
0.19609510898590088,
0.1129327118396759,
0.49831390380859375,
0.07594462484121323,
-0.2641596794128418,
0.6632480621337891,
0.5661259889602661,
0.48257938027381897,
0.20632198452949524,
-0.39617857336997986,
0.23203422129154205,
-0.005207459907978773,
-0.2928517460823059,
0.1717800348997116,
-0.31900593638420105,
-0.3158528804779053,
-0.5436674356460571,
-0.43616631627082825,
-0.41964486241340637,
0.5670091509819031,
-0.689245343208313,
0.1964152306318283,
-0.22070518136024475,
0.19917669892311096,
0.08246191591024399,
0.2566298842430115,
-0.47991570830345154,
0.26273113489151,
0.19901017844676971,
1.1460368633270264,
-0.5286911725997925,
0.9929019808769226,
0.3785681128501892,
0.009389176964759827,
-0.5404625535011292,
0.2599354386329651,
-0.060661278665065765,
-0.7530964016914368,
0.7454642057418823,
0.647998034954071,
-0.03745464235544205,
-0.2894326150417328,
-0.22289898991584778,
-0.7859178781509399,
1.2156219482421875,
0.13905343413352966,
-0.9663172960281372,
-0.020802343264222145,
0.39244505763053894,
0.607602059841156,
-0.24524946510791779,
0.2818525731563568,
0.8558075428009033,
0.5380052924156189,
-0.31221136450767517,
-0.7722633481025696,
0.41532811522483826,
-0.28470614552497864,
-0.02934182807803154,
0.380119264125824,
-0.8538863062858582,
0.7712154984474182,
-0.05013580247759819,
-0.10740464925765991,
0.3943707048892975,
0.5570443272590637,
0.21331577003002167,
0.384583055973053,
0.6573663353919983,
0.552121639251709,
0.48610827326774597,
0.06015070155262947,
0.9703630805015564,
-0.5627442598342896,
0.21038253605365753,
1.3635233640670776,
-0.44382795691490173,
1.1723978519439697,
0.33582350611686707,
-0.33347415924072266,
0.4367748200893402,
0.643014132976532,
0.08037123084068298,
0.24057170748710632,
0.4325145184993744,
-0.33159440755844116,
-0.19677571952342987,
-0.06812267005443573,
-0.4760465919971466,
0.2522686719894409,
0.4418216049671173,
-0.49073633551597595,
-0.1890190988779068,
0.017571326345205307,
0.09311240166425705,
0.14284874498844147,
-0.15440723299980164,
0.5679640769958496,
0.25450262427330017,
-0.8483167290687561,
0.6836566925048828,
-0.09801916778087616,
0.6573256254196167,
-0.6085127592086792,
0.23692528903484344,
-0.23379386961460114,
0.40964335203170776,
0.0010348272044211626,
-1.0519007444381714,
-0.09202851355075836,
-0.06403973698616028,
-0.32918745279312134,
-0.1283455193042755,
0.28350821137428284,
-0.23961219191551208,
-0.2824930250644684,
0.7766842842102051,
0.32524263858795166,
0.033478666096925735,
-0.14124087989330292,
-0.5595422983169556,
0.099945068359375,
-0.18656103312969208,
-0.524505615234375,
0.716310441493988,
0.5193508863449097,
-0.046998608857393265,
0.41576912999153137,
0.45684191584587097,
-0.023469088599085808,
-0.4223369061946869,
-0.017845887690782547,
0.6800293922424316,
-0.8721802234649658,
-0.5377652049064636,
-0.8406579494476318,
0.06327788531780243,
-0.1065668985247612,
-0.4540424942970276,
0.6014952063560486,
0.7923405170440674,
0.701359212398529,
0.2916410565376282,
0.8161096572875977,
0.13223853707313538,
0.6069108247756958,
-0.451465904712677,
0.7598469853401184,
-0.8769196271896362,
0.23149263858795166,
-0.12320926785469055,
-0.9293561577796936,
-0.2105218917131424,
0.07133200019598007,
-0.4580925703048706,
-0.058519307523965836,
0.8764338493347168,
0.4278019368648529,
-0.10924901813268661,
0.023220114409923553,
0.4567181169986725,
0.41481679677963257,
0.2990439832210541,
0.9574294090270996,
0.6573045253753662,
-0.21140709519386292,
0.7463520765304565,
-0.20057478547096252,
-0.4606946110725403,
-0.2702603340148926,
-0.8549836277961731,
-0.8800860047340393,
-0.5750586986541748,
0.15192435681819916,
-0.3306930363178253,
0.12475185096263885,
0.6492208242416382,
0.7997136116027832,
-0.6797639727592468,
-0.3684552013874054,
-0.13307103514671326,
-0.11035898327827454,
-0.2258528172969818,
-0.22755031287670135,
0.6615769863128662,
-0.3218816816806793,
-0.7567242383956909,
0.42679208517074585,
0.34591832756996155,
-0.16983984410762787,
-0.09071695059537888,
-0.05949162319302559,
0.007204309105873108,
0.10615868121385574,
0.8209057450294495,
0.43199828267097473,
-0.7121242880821228,
-0.3829538822174072,
-0.044454049319028854,
-0.22628648579120636,
0.15484677255153656,
0.7255522608757019,
-0.7687538266181946,
0.3580399453639984,
0.4699915051460266,
0.698223888874054,
0.6516361236572266,
-0.004569397773593664,
0.609063982963562,
-0.3527893126010895,
0.005548195447772741,
0.033565957099199295,
0.5260676145553589,
0.08683914691209793,
-0.35816606879234314,
0.6221765279769897,
-0.037216927856206894,
-0.7110726833343506,
-0.8804920315742493,
0.15075072646141052,
-1.180574893951416,
-0.6670105457305908,
1.2901941537857056,
-0.4455050826072693,
-0.33673152327537537,
-0.24072472751140594,
-0.23703956604003906,
0.06643466651439667,
-0.4135046899318695,
0.8088772892951965,
0.7850701808929443,
-0.3377630114555359,
-0.1624273955821991,
-0.6253446340560913,
0.2767617404460907,
0.7709633708000183,
-0.9850471615791321,
0.7216986417770386,
0.46916890144348145,
0.18410004675388336,
-0.05903993174433708,
0.347083181142807,
-0.13320088386535645,
0.324510782957077,
-0.07683539390563965,
-0.4069768190383911,
0.02129233069717884,
-0.08665690571069717,
-0.07112386077642441,
0.14878997206687927,
-0.1312880665063858,
0.19669656455516815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05428v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05428v1
|
Language Models on a Diet: Cost-Efficient Development of Encoders for Closely-Related Languages via Additional Pretraining
| 2024-04-08T11:55:44 | 2024-04-08T11:55:44 |
Nikola Ljubešić, Vít Suchomel, Peter Rupnik, Taja Kuzman, Rik van Noord
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The world of language models is going through turbulent times, better and
ever larger models are coming out at an unprecedented speed. However, we argue
that, especially for the scientific community, encoder models of up to 1
billion parameters are still very much needed, their primary usage being in
enriching large collections of data with metadata necessary for downstream
research. We investigate the best way to ensure the existence of such encoder
models on the set of very closely related languages - Croatian, Serbian,
Bosnian and Montenegrin, by setting up a diverse benchmark for these languages,
and comparing the trained-from-scratch models with the new models constructed
via additional pretraining of existing multilingual models. We show that
comparable performance to dedicated from-scratch models can be obtained by
additionally pretraining available multilingual models even with a limited
amount of computation. We also show that neighboring languages, in our case
Slovenian, can be included in the additional pretraining with little to no loss
in the performance of the final model.
|
[
-0.4281385838985443,
-0.18621447682380676,
0.31497886776924133,
0.12361609935760498,
-0.09775933623313904,
0.011417888104915619,
-0.51991868019104,
-0.5835292935371399,
0.28930604457855225,
0.7224326729774475,
-0.33513087034225464,
0.026630748063325882,
-0.683305025100708,
0.3672979772090912,
-0.31206944584846497,
0.6339899897575378,
-0.2461143583059311,
0.6027328968048096,
-0.2809532582759857,
-0.23751652240753174,
0.09305261075496674,
-0.6642602682113647,
-0.14265203475952148,
-0.3826240301132202,
0.4920540452003479,
-0.03777163848280907,
0.5687215924263,
0.7550913095474243,
0.47418755292892456,
0.23419663310050964,
0.0013741774018853903,
-0.001357356901280582,
-0.4023269712924957,
0.2431877702474594,
0.057132888585329056,
-0.5034329295158386,
-0.14513733983039856,
0.011259128339588642,
0.4710683226585388,
1.191059947013855,
-0.008994368836283684,
0.37228426337242126,
0.10564814507961273,
0.7407947778701782,
-0.6470164060592651,
0.1530892699956894,
-0.4481673240661621,
0.14381754398345947,
-0.42971551418304443,
-0.01685098372399807,
-0.3322746455669403,
-0.5811614990234375,
0.1175846979022026,
-0.7180587649345398,
0.007109362166374922,
-0.1721859723329544,
0.9174458384513855,
0.3182903230190277,
-0.2079099863767624,
-0.30810075998306274,
-0.8584408760070801,
0.5895727872848511,
-0.6052938103675842,
1.0081913471221924,
0.5437594652175903,
0.10392230749130249,
-0.11763754487037659,
-0.702857255935669,
-0.23783425986766815,
-0.18782076239585876,
0.16200920939445496,
0.03659655153751373,
-0.11063164472579956,
-0.10005149990320206,
0.2410237342119217,
0.1373472809791565,
-0.6615127325057983,
-0.10270588845014572,
-0.4795171320438385,
-0.048482637852430344,
0.30434051156044006,
-0.04933638125658035,
0.24677979946136475,
0.38651931285858154,
0.14070551097393036,
-0.11928950250148773,
-1.1649903059005737,
-0.27921921014785767,
0.7289175987243652,
0.2309688776731491,
0.08870407193899155,
0.74050372838974,
-0.2326061725616455,
0.9029712677001953,
-0.11107157915830612,
-0.02409946545958519,
0.16774173080921173,
-0.6132809519767761,
0.06631593406200409,
-0.057428862899541855,
0.608924150466919,
-0.08533254265785217,
0.7009279131889343,
-0.41592592000961304,
0.0024473501835018396,
0.3398853540420532,
0.09618856757879257,
-0.9125925302505493,
-0.5613020062446594,
-0.1435755342245102,
-0.45972010493278503,
0.1743544340133667,
-0.3727352023124695,
-0.512446939945221,
-0.16118958592414856,
-0.30381202697753906,
0.31805700063705444,
-0.2611919045448303,
-0.3964332044124603,
0.3998238146305084,
-0.12699688971042633,
0.14438658952713013,
0.10487127304077148,
-0.9236348867416382,
0.49386700987815857,
0.4797007143497467,
0.720069169998169,
0.1615043580532074,
-0.2937565743923187,
-0.2617625892162323,
0.13538356125354767,
-0.5041128993034363,
0.6557431817054749,
-1.116231918334961,
-0.20448558032512665,
-0.051714375615119934,
-0.04243972525000572,
0.053717341274023056,
-0.6414154171943665,
0.09477131068706512,
-0.6996625661849976,
0.004984412807971239,
-0.6368224620819092,
-0.6176463961601257,
-0.0052724797278642654,
0.25128769874572754,
-0.822666585445404,
0.9977479577064514,
0.24681459367275238,
-0.9659257531166077,
0.6408888101577759,
-0.3855540454387665,
-0.6309953927993774,
0.22204439342021942,
-0.06685778498649597,
0.006306932773441076,
0.16220404207706451,
0.09719308465719223,
0.29048019647598267,
-0.5449607968330383,
0.3744329810142517,
-0.5371062159538269,
-0.17142944037914276,
-0.12196433544158936,
-0.26019319891929626,
0.6837848424911499,
0.49839285016059875,
0.051593195647001266,
-0.11006712168455124,
-0.8108050227165222,
-0.00997956097126007,
0.06434854865074158,
-0.7992516756057739,
-0.4969181418418884,
0.21937236189842224,
0.04374067485332489,
0.2236320525407791,
0.2994198501110077,
-0.6116557121276855,
0.16059455275535583,
-0.43529486656188965,
0.42217618227005005,
0.23555117845535278,
-0.3808733820915222,
0.5597773790359497,
-0.08196671307086945,
0.6919742822647095,
-0.05354525148868561,
0.07785414159297943,
-0.27049365639686584,
-0.45514965057373047,
-0.9162977933883667,
0.012270200066268444,
0.6601895689964294,
0.2512821853160858,
-0.807004988193512,
0.30035272240638733,
-0.3560446798801422,
-0.5238423943519592,
-0.8924731016159058,
0.10838369280099869,
0.5451978445053101,
0.08776528388261795,
0.19353309273719788,
-0.5585816502571106,
-0.7840463519096375,
-0.7566184401512146,
-0.3931252658367157,
0.07320515066385269,
-0.047645870596170425,
0.0554971769452095,
0.5532045364379883,
-0.0704779177904129,
0.8169901371002197,
-0.2470432072877884,
0.2622789740562439,
-0.3453134000301361,
-0.3060576021671295,
0.10216191411018372,
0.6161145567893982,
0.6959160566329956,
-0.6616343855857849,
-0.6564136147499084,
0.20787957310676575,
-0.5906141400337219,
0.0542757511138916,
0.33120664954185486,
0.16635966300964355,
-0.061762697994709015,
0.5400789380073547,
-0.4115051329135895,
0.07475253194570541,
0.8575319647789001,
0.07467814534902573,
0.506458044052124,
-0.4959932267665863,
-0.006971700582653284,
-0.9456593990325928,
0.18388284742832184,
-0.12619240581989288,
-0.12592683732509613,
-0.8533937931060791,
0.11460991948843002,
-0.041345324367284775,
-0.2674064338207245,
-0.26576411724090576,
0.6749621033668518,
-0.805128812789917,
-0.12088743597269058,
-0.21735136210918427,
-0.2370045781135559,
-0.08489907532930374,
0.26739779114723206,
0.45962995290756226,
0.6686971187591553,
0.8082485198974609,
-0.5956478118896484,
0.36416929960250854,
0.08212105929851532,
-0.70856112241745,
-0.019346782937645912,
-0.7052589654922485,
0.12435326725244522,
-0.13002832233905792,
0.26069018244743347,
-0.31310275197029114,
-0.3659917712211609,
0.41232532262802124,
-0.26084887981414795,
0.4588868319988251,
-0.49342080950737,
-0.5325608849525452,
-0.39887529611587524,
-0.03914317861199379,
0.5003114938735962,
0.5490680932998657,
-0.4908316731452942,
0.5795640349388123,
0.6974982619285583,
-0.3146958649158478,
-0.26809895038604736,
-0.6315644979476929,
0.08232910186052322,
-0.20073889195919037,
-0.4846535623073578,
-0.10556299239397049,
-0.17397408187389374,
-0.073087178170681,
0.1587429940700531,
-0.05826970562338829,
-0.21084311604499817,
0.21627581119537354,
-0.01935032568871975,
-0.3467990458011627,
-0.47393128275871277,
0.001643292373046279,
0.0021912800148129463,
-0.17406293749809265,
0.014896707609295845,
-0.653423547744751,
0.8154363036155701,
0.02575521729886532,
-0.32673248648643494,
0.1240132600069046,
0.4344708323478699,
0.2933276295661926,
-0.7056745290756226,
0.9284051060676575,
0.31395021080970764,
-0.5235743522644043,
0.17444363236427307,
-0.6624182462692261,
-0.027790002524852753,
-0.447343111038208,
0.4852222204208374,
-0.5963428020477295,
-0.684531033039093,
0.6011496186256409,
-0.26461416482925415,
-0.29482412338256836,
0.10115401446819305,
0.5367635488510132,
0.34006014466285706,
1.0459988117218018,
0.8267507553100586,
-0.18249386548995972,
0.5233858227729797,
0.011564097367227077,
0.17956089973449707,
-0.6834126710891724,
-0.30661430954933167,
-0.858222246170044,
0.1749717742204666,
-0.6117008924484253,
-0.48128440976142883,
0.12444564700126648,
0.027593841776251793,
-0.22992894053459167,
0.6664336323738098,
-0.2145196497440338,
0.853319525718689,
0.6303717494010925,
-0.07312512397766113,
-0.010506663471460342,
-0.12126655876636505,
-0.30225929617881775,
-0.03625747933983803,
-0.936485767364502,
-0.5823013782501221,
1.215277910232544,
0.05339046195149422,
1.006504774093628,
-0.2261120080947876,
0.638177216053009,
-0.4438474476337433,
0.21890585124492645,
-0.3665684461593628,
0.16791047155857086,
-0.2803618907928467,
-0.7934576869010925,
-0.021305449306964874,
-0.564708411693573,
-0.763546884059906,
0.28900396823883057,
-0.12457144260406494,
-0.5728839039802551,
0.2714262008666992,
0.2964826822280884,
-0.14454065263271332,
0.23630541563034058,
-0.6677671670913696,
0.91302490234375,
-0.37391021847724915,
-0.3675723671913147,
-0.005579716991633177,
-0.8152263164520264,
-0.021214231848716736,
-0.3587741255760193,
0.3083956837654114,
-0.13044731318950653,
0.18984022736549377,
0.9165873527526855,
-0.2549055814743042,
0.4878504276275635,
-0.2977035641670227,
-0.05283716693520546,
-0.03583834320306778,
0.1330820769071579,
0.327367901802063,
-0.206439808011055,
-0.2388458400964737,
0.017238928005099297,
0.220814511179924,
-0.45182687044143677,
-0.38233643770217896,
0.506290853023529,
-0.5974774956703186,
-0.4652349352836609,
-0.18826919794082642,
-0.29921260476112366,
-0.31509673595428467,
0.4629310667514801,
0.4389900863170624,
0.47112396359443665,
-0.17246194183826447,
0.15399567782878876,
0.520776093006134,
-0.1924712061882019,
0.2539924085140228,
0.4388448894023895,
-0.03836847096681595,
-0.2529800236225128,
1.0070587396621704,
0.13511088490486145,
0.20051690936088562,
0.22276559472084045,
0.25175273418426514,
-0.0663171336054802,
-0.7389997243881226,
-0.41307997703552246,
0.29202505946159363,
-0.5824933648109436,
-0.1407112032175064,
-0.8927792310714722,
0.05664575472474098,
-0.4955909550189972,
-0.22588884830474854,
-0.8774890303611755,
-0.2873727083206177,
-0.2789645195007324,
0.15878857672214508,
0.13490773737430573,
0.9375299215316772,
-0.1171499565243721,
0.19196322560310364,
-0.8846831917762756,
0.07398808002471924,
-0.07759282737970352,
0.4624979794025421,
0.17979533970355988,
-0.3449825644493103,
-0.5970020890235901,
0.3876141309738159,
0.029139671474695206,
-0.748790979385376,
0.6031665802001953,
0.5246196389198303,
0.6578735709190369,
0.4903477430343628,
-0.007727164775133133,
0.8706700801849365,
-0.9088427424430847,
0.5719338655471802,
0.11508916318416595,
-0.8383781909942627,
0.30108997225761414,
-0.11619821935892105,
0.39069175720214844,
0.6429898738861084,
0.8986033797264099,
-0.6067240834236145,
-0.43529605865478516,
-0.17035961151123047,
-0.6941125988960266,
0.6831214427947998,
-0.003573303110897541,
0.4134204089641571,
-0.1256849467754364,
0.29749855399131775,
0.40491199493408203,
0.18045522272586823,
-0.8226417899131775,
-0.04324926435947418,
-0.26378944516181946,
-0.15361721813678741,
-0.23615457117557526,
-0.20806194841861725,
0.03380192443728447,
-0.48657017946243286,
0.6127716302871704,
-0.09532292187213898,
0.06195161119103432,
-0.24302591383457184,
-0.3561178147792816,
-0.1683969795703888,
0.048871610313653946,
0.4146084785461426,
0.5429283976554871,
-0.009653734043240547,
0.21011076867580414,
0.1821400672197342,
-0.43479111790657043,
0.21545353531837463,
0.0014098177198320627,
0.10783422738313675,
-0.1891881376504898,
0.34714576601982117,
0.7408472299575806,
0.3699854016304016,
-0.6256276965141296,
0.31951671838760376,
-0.132569819688797,
0.030350441113114357,
-0.06992752850055695,
-0.0026619713753461838,
0.4706476330757141,
0.258931040763855,
-0.02245938405394554,
0.15181905031204224,
0.08754615485668182,
-0.5039674639701843,
0.01875660941004753,
0.412507563829422,
-0.27026379108428955,
-0.664893388748169,
0.7046170234680176,
0.2474488914012909,
-0.06145733594894409,
0.6381161212921143,
-0.2293047159910202,
-0.7578796148300171,
0.4346446394920349,
0.7417246103286743,
0.5468897819519043,
-0.37280234694480896,
-0.07008499652147293,
0.31550332903862,
0.40291672945022583,
-0.5382160544395447,
0.286898672580719,
-0.2460383176803589,
-0.928900420665741,
-0.21922780573368073,
-0.9872663617134094,
-0.2402721494436264,
-0.21304762363433838,
-0.7995288372039795,
0.14480507373809814,
-0.021941669285297394,
-0.10978896170854568,
0.03689894080162048,
0.03620269522070885,
-0.9129798412322998,
0.06945573538541794,
0.17116236686706543,
0.9121602177619934,
-1.056098461151123,
1.2067514657974243,
0.7412322759628296,
-0.3043278157711029,
-0.4604395925998688,
-0.32043594121932983,
-0.37218302488327026,
-0.723534882068634,
0.7558629512786865,
0.1143772304058075,
-0.11675114184617996,
0.026215165853500366,
-0.3391556739807129,
-1.103355050086975,
0.37325647473335266,
0.930608332157135,
-0.836194634437561,
-0.3548259735107422,
0.09096395969390869,
0.6888436675071716,
-0.30749085545539856,
0.24900218844413757,
0.6392085552215576,
0.5217323899269104,
0.04040374234318733,
-0.8831228017807007,
-0.16455470025539398,
-0.3773488998413086,
-0.07254278659820557,
0.42506617307662964,
-0.3252912163734436,
0.836525022983551,
-0.12565341591835022,
-0.23848888278007507,
0.06059134751558304,
0.42710667848587036,
-0.25397613644599915,
-0.18165697157382965,
0.025267740711569786,
0.3238714337348938,
0.568514347076416,
-0.05860124155879021,
1.2073606252670288,
-0.6476671695709229,
0.19954773783683777,
1.0797995328903198,
-0.5306839346885681,
0.7299349308013916,
0.3559420108795166,
-0.3001149594783783,
-0.06312540173530579,
0.861075758934021,
-0.0992918610572815,
0.7947806119918823,
0.35214853286743164,
-0.18804602324962616,
-0.4339739978313446,
-0.13567276298999786,
-0.5973506569862366,
0.430132120847702,
0.212611123919487,
-0.23098692297935486,
-0.17413374781608582,
0.31835100054740906,
0.19579118490219116,
-0.07473219186067581,
-0.05355635657906532,
0.763248860836029,
0.018381858244538307,
-0.6456212401390076,
0.4026133418083191,
-0.14353781938552856,
0.5729214549064636,
-0.7752840518951416,
0.21039806306362152,
-0.3002806007862091,
0.20853610336780548,
0.14366909861564636,
-0.3312440812587738,
0.3727509081363678,
0.1920350044965744,
-0.015730760991573334,
-0.2666819393634796,
0.4836679995059967,
-0.8197914361953735,
-0.6215426325798035,
0.615195095539093,
0.4009958803653717,
0.37419793009757996,
0.019524358212947845,
-0.37821054458618164,
0.35583019256591797,
-0.24100518226623535,
-0.3138757050037384,
0.33696413040161133,
0.23873686790466309,
0.15200291574001312,
0.6682361364364624,
0.5036222338676453,
0.5154316425323486,
0.46258220076560974,
-0.027715928852558136,
1.0630476474761963,
-0.4122806191444397,
-0.22747941315174103,
-0.8082354664802551,
0.024068472906947136,
0.36844635009765625,
-0.2434794157743454,
0.8192916512489319,
0.8091480731964111,
1.313266634941101,
-0.3632865846157074,
0.6962463855743408,
0.11586414277553558,
0.22660115361213684,
-0.571762204170227,
1.0187679529190063,
-0.6428161859512329,
-0.07899904251098633,
-0.1524861752986908,
-1.0892397165298462,
-0.40238937735557556,
0.6651903390884399,
-0.14030516147613525,
0.26767098903656006,
0.463672399520874,
0.6311513185501099,
-0.18956509232521057,
-0.027293812483549118,
0.3812667727470398,
-0.04876650869846344,
0.23621290922164917,
0.4695569574832916,
0.7858935594558716,
-0.23128008842468262,
0.21355637907981873,
-0.2598228454589844,
0.02464497648179531,
0.06424233317375183,
-0.7455652952194214,
-0.8393999338150024,
-0.7188097834587097,
-0.3097825348377228,
0.014706425368785858,
0.39682742953300476,
0.9888219237327576,
0.9579854607582092,
-0.899841845035553,
-0.4011841416358948,
0.058215416967868805,
-0.23716314136981964,
0.05303925648331642,
-0.002893466269597411,
0.008895080536603928,
-0.15620069205760956,
-0.584444522857666,
0.531791627407074,
0.23679810762405396,
0.010147776454687119,
-0.18017755448818207,
-0.341918021440506,
-0.24045926332473755,
0.32527226209640503,
0.3960612416267395,
0.4598477780818939,
-0.5859631896018982,
-0.22173568606376648,
-0.01949496567249298,
0.2081332504749298,
0.07780827581882477,
0.9116726517677307,
-0.8016610145568848,
0.6620796322822571,
0.2911672592163086,
0.6200283765792847,
0.7259215116500854,
-0.40512701869010925,
0.8664104342460632,
-0.5024588704109192,
0.28917211294174194,
0.206629678606987,
0.5616423487663269,
0.5490626692771912,
0.05521998926997185,
0.3837398290634155,
-0.044757913798093796,
-0.28920865058898926,
-1.0169137716293335,
0.25049421191215515,
-0.4108598530292511,
-0.2544880509376526,
0.8919438123703003,
-0.48101553320884705,
-0.35925543308258057,
-0.16096022725105286,
0.1892140954732895,
0.44671785831451416,
0.05644679814577103,
0.3887341022491455,
0.7278217077255249,
0.1467570960521698,
-0.0968484953045845,
-0.28236374258995056,
0.6014190912246704,
0.08523982018232346,
-0.854326069355011,
0.2468651831150055,
0.18667083978652954,
0.4974539875984192,
0.10171382129192352,
0.4252837300300598,
-0.09107664972543716,
0.03795818239450455,
0.503584623336792,
0.20670753717422485,
-0.10074713826179504,
-0.734507143497467,
-0.3115620017051697,
-0.018828878179192543,
0.19665361940860748,
0.04005775973200798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05415v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05415v2
|
Relation Extraction Using Large Language Models: A Case Study on Acupuncture Point Locations
| 2024-04-08T11:33:00 | 2024-04-15T00:45:32 |
Yiming Li, Xueqing Peng, Jianfu Li, Xu Zuo, Suyuan Peng, Donghong Pei, Cui Tao, Hua Xu, Na Hong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In acupuncture therapy, the accurate location of acupoints is essential for
its effectiveness. The advanced language understanding capabilities of large
language models (LLMs) like Generative Pre-trained Transformers (GPT) present a
significant opportunity for extracting relations related to acupoint locations
from textual knowledge sources. This study aims to compare the performance of
GPT with traditional deep learning models (Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) and
Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers for Biomedical Text
Mining (BioBERT)) in extracting acupoint-related location relations and assess
the impact of pretraining and fine-tuning on GPT's performance. We utilized the
World Health Organization Standard Acupuncture Point Locations in the Western
Pacific Region (WHO Standard) as our corpus, which consists of descriptions of
361 acupoints. Five types of relations ('direction_of,' 'distance_of,'
'part_of,' 'near_acupoint,' and 'located_near') (n= 3,174) between acupoints
were annotated. Five models were compared: BioBERT, LSTM, pre-trained GPT-3.5,
fine-tuned GPT-3.5, as well as pre-trained GPT-4. Performance metrics included
micro-average exact match precision, recall, and F1 scores. Our results
demonstrate that fine-tuned GPT-3.5 consistently outperformed other models in
F1 scores across all relation types. Overall, it achieved the highest
micro-average F1 score of 0.92. This study underscores the effectiveness of
LLMs like GPT in extracting relations related to acupoint locations, with
implications for accurately modeling acupuncture knowledge and promoting
standard implementation in acupuncture training and practice. The findings also
contribute to advancing informatics applications in traditional and
complementary medicine, showcasing the potential of LLMs in natural language
processing.
|
[
-0.03854965418577194,
-0.6929649114608765,
0.8038608431816101,
0.07134993374347687,
-0.12747587263584137,
-0.27832508087158203,
-0.5223443508148193,
-0.752733051776886,
-0.08501719683408737,
0.2146148979663849,
-0.12967811524868011,
-0.8172674179077148,
-0.638962984085083,
0.203007772564888,
-0.48752352595329285,
0.6832737922668457,
-0.1918996423482895,
0.13456308841705322,
-0.1151323914527893,
-0.18859881162643433,
-0.3012508451938629,
-0.6606331467628479,
-0.4748110771179199,
-0.6184578537940979,
0.32106631994247437,
0.017878588289022446,
1.0005906820297241,
0.4465421140193939,
0.7737990021705627,
0.31497684121131897,
-0.09877508878707886,
0.05145331472158432,
-0.2068329155445099,
-0.03653988614678383,
-0.2822490930557251,
-0.25752803683280945,
-0.2823966443538666,
0.05839860811829567,
0.5855239629745483,
0.8565364480018616,
-0.046493787318468094,
0.03305760771036148,
-0.12614557147026062,
0.4034495949745178,
-0.3076576590538025,
0.208020880818367,
-0.5011351108551025,
0.23372642695903778,
0.08734815567731857,
-0.1491623818874359,
-0.2022954672574997,
-0.44799530506134033,
0.5086472630500793,
-0.5206916928291321,
0.4208829402923584,
-0.13056680560112,
1.3632148504257202,
0.3043248653411865,
-0.23088492453098297,
-0.14904291927814484,
-0.7622978687286377,
0.4794907867908478,
-0.6324023008346558,
0.6179704070091248,
0.29484298825263977,
0.16788171231746674,
-0.026681669056415558,
-0.8279625773429871,
-0.2869339883327484,
-0.46399760246276855,
-0.608479917049408,
0.08130645006895065,
-0.1197286918759346,
0.1738189458847046,
0.5953140258789062,
0.6207053661346436,
-0.44830071926116943,
0.23436027765274048,
-0.22605404257774353,
0.10051288455724716,
0.4612252116203308,
-0.14394016563892365,
0.18158632516860962,
-0.4605282247066498,
-0.35280343890190125,
-0.04253261908888817,
-1.008104920387268,
-0.12839673459529877,
-0.23173224925994873,
0.12172549962997437,
-0.16467991471290588,
0.4761025905609131,
0.05038553476333618,
0.6988354325294495,
0.2864603102207184,
-0.2422652244567871,
0.18512877821922302,
-0.3341005742549896,
-0.3151203989982605,
-0.12123965471982956,
1.3301278352737427,
-0.008189018815755844,
0.4703028202056885,
-0.3191974461078644,
-0.02089872397482395,
-0.24373237788677216,
0.10395987331867218,
-0.7008605599403381,
-0.42955252528190613,
-0.010209410451352596,
-0.7703793048858643,
-0.048924658447504044,
0.07954710721969604,
-0.16539064049720764,
-0.23621058464050293,
-0.48049014806747437,
0.21754366159439087,
-0.7995924949645996,
-0.3732417821884155,
-0.11995593458414078,
0.25764933228492737,
0.3347626328468323,
0.10399606823921204,
-0.7649142742156982,
0.14139069616794586,
0.6203201413154602,
1.0228276252746582,
-0.17459522187709808,
-0.4329926371574402,
-0.16132239997386932,
0.13744506239891052,
-0.02783745899796486,
0.6656200885772705,
-0.47360527515411377,
-0.49057185649871826,
0.17462149262428284,
-0.01790173165500164,
-0.25698012113571167,
-0.9308969378471375,
0.340314120054245,
-0.45775362849235535,
0.0830383449792862,
-0.0713028833270073,
-0.5165422558784485,
0.07935257256031036,
0.1638433188199997,
-0.692767322063446,
0.9094433188438416,
0.3545047342777252,
-0.6067202091217041,
0.3698922395706177,
-0.622338056564331,
-0.8858180046081543,
-0.038231004029512405,
-0.39313217997550964,
-0.45042404532432556,
-0.05747988075017929,
0.5431222915649414,
0.6805744767189026,
-0.3617831766605377,
0.45535963773727417,
-0.040830470621585846,
-0.2985328137874603,
0.2823927104473114,
-0.2377777099609375,
0.550149142742157,
0.09206759929656982,
-0.2389257252216339,
0.2732788920402527,
-0.5923346281051636,
-0.35584548115730286,
0.08003968745470047,
-0.1603279858827591,
-0.3917761445045471,
-0.012578273192048073,
-0.26561439037323,
0.4125094413757324,
0.09715034067630768,
-0.39317524433135986,
0.1443656086921692,
-0.44883230328559875,
0.3205941915512085,
0.40558865666389465,
0.13936413824558258,
0.3396456241607666,
0.014799260534346104,
0.3969112038612366,
0.1943340003490448,
0.09304732084274292,
0.061490852385759354,
-0.21310076117515564,
-0.5174432396888733,
0.10769601911306381,
0.2496727555990219,
0.28532955050468445,
-0.8935990333557129,
0.5782026648521423,
-0.6131522059440613,
-0.5107463002204895,
-0.627399206161499,
0.12404105067253113,
0.3607948422431946,
0.8629843592643738,
0.6279764771461487,
-0.09380998462438583,
-0.24667297303676605,
-0.7361548542976379,
-0.2857741415500641,
-0.18098047375679016,
-0.31152021884918213,
0.409817099571228,
0.12727656960487366,
-0.27839139103889465,
0.793434202671051,
-0.6318514943122864,
-0.5078874826431274,
-0.06388264149427414,
0.08568640053272247,
0.6185706257820129,
0.2311786413192749,
0.6010389924049377,
-0.7018149495124817,
-0.69390469789505,
0.27623000741004944,
-0.8835459351539612,
0.17500384151935577,
-0.19045108556747437,
-0.12104080617427826,
0.013155912980437279,
0.41443249583244324,
-0.9776928424835205,
0.3146064877510071,
0.46780282258987427,
-0.2411307543516159,
0.5250669717788696,
-0.17684222757816315,
0.15723830461502075,
-1.0349806547164917,
0.4819466471672058,
0.29895079135894775,
-0.2987731099128723,
-0.4852505326271057,
0.02989295683801174,
0.28342172503471375,
-0.17817749083042145,
-0.45336464047431946,
0.16389557719230652,
-0.6544403433799744,
0.03737500309944153,
-0.09853694587945938,
-0.01801835000514984,
-0.2412286251783371,
0.2928728759288788,
0.5967511534690857,
0.6622644066810608,
0.4329734742641449,
-0.659106969833374,
0.4929772615432739,
0.52655428647995,
-0.31991487741470337,
0.36558297276496887,
-0.6534256935119629,
0.1457272619009018,
0.23161061108112335,
0.06076014041900635,
-0.5562883019447327,
-0.06291692703962326,
0.0653751790523529,
-0.4073440730571747,
0.5671983957290649,
-0.17389705777168274,
-0.52353835105896,
-0.3818013072013855,
-0.012190207839012146,
0.37015628814697266,
0.4716099202632904,
-0.5652015209197998,
0.36857661604881287,
0.11459874361753464,
-0.14674539864063263,
-0.569301187992096,
-0.25234732031822205,
-0.06961282342672348,
-0.10499023646116257,
-0.4160543382167816,
0.40974876284599304,
0.3166504204273224,
-0.04659437760710716,
0.10522503405809402,
-0.024837208911776543,
0.028338739648461342,
-0.009018086828291416,
0.19523784518241882,
0.22900907695293427,
-0.31243589520454407,
0.5687442421913147,
-0.08352411538362503,
-0.2365017533302307,
0.17006739974021912,
0.043863892555236816,
0.6887000203132629,
-0.023498864844441414,
-0.2936377227306366,
-0.31615886092185974,
0.21957804262638092,
0.3502103090286255,
-0.3509911596775055,
0.8108663558959961,
0.7095546126365662,
-0.5040308237075806,
0.4317430853843689,
-0.6382285356521606,
-0.17762695252895355,
-0.42268237471580505,
0.5100379586219788,
-0.44069206714630127,
-0.7035117745399475,
0.3323057293891907,
-0.23367944359779358,
-0.10803662985563278,
0.7577581405639648,
0.43206658959388733,
0.11515899002552032,
0.7581055760383606,
0.488252729177475,
-0.4858853816986084,
0.49645063281059265,
-0.3802133798599243,
0.40588608384132385,
-0.8756837844848633,
-0.1671271175146103,
-0.28871840238571167,
-0.12280678749084473,
-0.5461820363998413,
-0.04243973270058632,
0.4317278265953064,
0.018435582518577576,
-0.30207502841949463,
0.5412428379058838,
-0.45296528935432434,
0.2830153703689575,
0.4813261032104492,
0.2662195861339569,
0.3867455720901489,
0.03924812749028206,
-0.08463461697101593,
0.03110208734869957,
-0.5243417620658875,
-0.2573876678943634,
1.144775629043579,
0.4812328517436981,
0.6701766848564148,
0.05055096000432968,
0.7188138365745544,
-0.46261826157569885,
0.7992971539497375,
-0.9852548837661743,
0.24987828731536865,
-0.27163535356521606,
-0.2799816429615021,
-0.4061484932899475,
-0.6431398391723633,
-1.154684066772461,
0.1357663869857788,
-0.35955560207366943,
-0.38296636939048767,
0.030351795256137848,
0.08369138091802597,
-0.593517541885376,
0.3652860224246979,
-0.6186178922653198,
0.7187128663063049,
-0.37375640869140625,
-0.3404746353626251,
-0.09795048832893372,
-0.7831258177757263,
0.04251589626073837,
0.06030139699578285,
0.03483254089951515,
-0.04663792997598648,
0.3323974609375,
0.5199143290519714,
-0.14728540182113647,
0.43203043937683105,
-0.20116235315799713,
-0.24842649698257446,
-0.08123914152383804,
-0.10421427339315414,
0.3230997323989868,
0.008664630353450775,
-0.22140027582645416,
0.47454822063446045,
0.06818009167909622,
0.09639348834753036,
-0.4590795338153839,
0.9375490546226501,
-0.9606770277023315,
-0.5835273861885071,
-0.3817524313926697,
-0.5863099694252014,
-0.2891436815261841,
0.3463316559791565,
0.5229763984680176,
0.19051772356033325,
-0.20059214532375336,
0.005653847008943558,
0.47937896847724915,
-0.4536326825618744,
0.37329360842704773,
0.3320062458515167,
-0.019771333783864975,
-0.19283288717269897,
0.5072017312049866,
0.10779338330030441,
0.14010240137577057,
0.5683026909828186,
0.147390216588974,
-0.32197874784469604,
-0.5332692265510559,
-0.08546657115221024,
0.6712824106216431,
-0.49177876114845276,
-0.5369421243667603,
-0.5500505566596985,
-0.55060875415802,
-0.6700443625450134,
0.15316760540008545,
-0.2685869038105011,
0.07092905789613724,
-0.4674099385738373,
-0.1728566586971283,
0.2971334755420685,
0.6262452602386475,
0.051797278225421906,
0.2935522496700287,
-1.0329813957214355,
0.5319690108299255,
0.06927590817213058,
0.5024764537811279,
0.029860595241189003,
-0.211487278342247,
-0.4520837366580963,
-0.05239439383149147,
-0.4322201609611511,
-0.9527405500411987,
0.5828694701194763,
0.23345690965652466,
0.38419055938720703,
0.6472636461257935,
-0.2814610004425049,
1.053200602531433,
-0.722934901714325,
0.5547887682914734,
0.46930131316185,
-0.6205317974090576,
0.592919111251831,
-0.18095563352108002,
0.4521586000919342,
0.5123646259307861,
0.6568436026573181,
-0.6267427802085876,
-0.06566307693719864,
-0.6137614250183105,
-0.8445226550102234,
0.5063395500183105,
0.01189747266471386,
-0.08268874883651733,
-0.23682157695293427,
0.7996171712875366,
0.04982347413897514,
0.10969133675098419,
-0.9205598831176758,
-0.3817055821418762,
0.15079571306705475,
-0.35103315114974976,
-0.29454198479652405,
-0.17504547536373138,
-0.23719339072704315,
-0.5432065725326538,
0.3607824444770813,
0.04951519891619682,
0.4562211334705353,
0.4268267750740051,
-0.44409826397895813,
-0.35712888836860657,
0.09644421190023422,
0.1221955269575119,
0.9927768111228943,
-0.10470907390117645,
0.26887235045433044,
0.2652214765548706,
-0.5021139979362488,
-0.00723268510773778,
0.5699021816253662,
0.054846860468387604,
0.2541460692882538,
0.7197883129119873,
0.5461820363998413,
0.23133930563926697,
-0.2996969223022461,
0.6023615002632141,
0.05413059890270233,
-0.05899066850543022,
-0.4465327858924866,
-0.11627431958913803,
0.07764619588851929,
0.13601598143577576,
0.24541465938091278,
-0.1170312836766243,
0.24306049942970276,
-0.466711163520813,
0.06668184697628021,
0.4616691470146179,
-0.5489060878753662,
-0.34908607602119446,
0.5129216313362122,
0.05668288841843605,
-0.23450370132923126,
0.8825994729995728,
0.3112969398498535,
-0.42985206842422485,
0.2814686596393585,
0.4936094582080841,
0.5925202965736389,
-0.5035926103591919,
-0.044533371925354004,
0.5917131900787354,
0.054254353046417236,
-0.02695627324283123,
-0.20006896555423737,
-0.13375817239284515,
-0.6260183453559875,
-0.5715599060058594,
-0.5737566351890564,
-0.1221100315451622,
0.16870523989200592,
-0.7789167165756226,
0.17352120578289032,
-0.15434598922729492,
-0.29032883048057556,
-0.16115857660770416,
0.07021263241767883,
-1.114309310913086,
0.13942529261112213,
0.06499283760786057,
0.6837702989578247,
-0.7316269874572754,
1.0425786972045898,
0.8069102764129639,
-0.3885010778903961,
-1.0575065612792969,
0.0835842564702034,
-0.5112351775169373,
-0.8768873810768127,
0.574690580368042,
0.18873724341392517,
0.09387914836406708,
-0.19226552546024323,
-0.3193226754665375,
-0.9247025847434998,
1.3295027017593384,
0.41210609674453735,
-0.7726396918296814,
-0.34982776641845703,
0.2899515926837921,
0.7514837980270386,
0.025748983025550842,
0.2888958752155304,
0.9174344539642334,
0.0725584328174591,
0.006532580126076937,
-1.292256236076355,
0.3959499001502991,
-0.10535021871328354,
-0.20325252413749695,
0.4898660182952881,
-0.40866392850875854,
0.6592549681663513,
-0.170254647731781,
-0.3090778887271881,
0.14963370561599731,
0.4394659101963043,
0.24327389895915985,
0.03657780587673187,
0.2912481129169464,
0.5427215695381165,
0.5410774350166321,
-0.1517704278230667,
1.1946839094161987,
-0.42158743739128113,
0.43055790662765503,
0.9554327726364136,
-0.12329407036304474,
0.8578418493270874,
0.5867811441421509,
-0.4143376648426056,
0.5102891325950623,
0.5997820496559143,
0.10532637685537338,
0.4401657283306122,
-0.1227051243185997,
-0.16225048899650574,
-0.15037047863006592,
0.04422086104750633,
-0.691646158695221,
0.21043530106544495,
0.4130960702896118,
-0.8502342700958252,
-0.03891570493578911,
-0.2178490310907364,
0.11949747800827026,
-0.045228611677885056,
-0.2880958318710327,
1.02390456199646,
0.5898125171661377,
-0.7752500176429749,
0.5413959622383118,
-0.30058231949806213,
0.5348246693611145,
-0.6792951822280884,
-0.19259341061115265,
0.024482524022459984,
0.2578313648700714,
-0.32867559790611267,
-0.6306052803993225,
0.0670013353228569,
-0.2393702268600464,
0.12924791872501373,
-0.1712225079536438,
0.856001615524292,
-0.5814194679260254,
-0.4447227120399475,
0.4194634258747101,
0.33527931571006775,
-0.03068559616804123,
-0.1267315000295639,
-0.5443282127380371,
-0.436151385307312,
-0.2029821127653122,
-0.28518548607826233,
0.2503238320350647,
0.4338544011116028,
0.2002679407596588,
0.3934159278869629,
0.6687920093536377,
0.4796529710292816,
-0.4176221191883087,
0.20313218235969543,
0.8824027180671692,
-0.7882179021835327,
-0.10617237538099289,
-0.9349590539932251,
0.04406989738345146,
-0.19003991782665253,
-0.21805529296398163,
0.6029912829399109,
0.36503732204437256,
0.5744014978408813,
-0.13397668302059174,
0.6101750135421753,
0.22492466866970062,
0.6614484190940857,
-0.6103207468986511,
0.7553236484527588,
-0.13560868799686432,
0.18154454231262207,
-0.4693676233291626,
-1.0019704103469849,
-0.6419790983200073,
0.9650072455406189,
-0.7041548490524292,
0.09068620204925537,
0.8095093965530396,
0.22112230956554413,
-0.2995963990688324,
-0.36441367864608765,
0.24928084015846252,
0.3216457962989807,
0.42962440848350525,
0.8045029640197754,
0.8185021281242371,
-0.3397996723651886,
0.4060612916946411,
-0.4223446846008301,
-0.2001350373029709,
-0.03837033733725548,
-0.534261167049408,
-0.7858100533485413,
-0.1838456243276596,
-0.21673811972141266,
-0.21539127826690674,
-0.25073370337486267,
1.0745280981063843,
0.4950515925884247,
-0.7010501027107239,
-0.2566639482975006,
0.1485443413257599,
-0.08432407677173615,
-0.26285320520401,
-0.18015621602535248,
1.035726547241211,
-0.22242872416973114,
-0.45341625809669495,
0.0515117347240448,
0.1635381430387497,
0.047172628343105316,
-0.015099864453077316,
-0.09323029965162277,
-0.320273220539093,
-0.6381292343139648,
0.7599075436592102,
0.20523442327976227,
-0.59446120262146,
-0.5066913962364197,
0.2208327203989029,
-0.012996576726436615,
0.2744026482105255,
0.7633326053619385,
-0.7707462906837463,
0.17268188297748566,
0.08391376584768295,
0.29100343585014343,
0.5750474333763123,
0.11217848211526871,
0.7497942447662354,
-0.6665515303611755,
0.149638831615448,
0.2864290177822113,
0.5924111008644104,
0.4477488398551941,
-0.5533586740493774,
0.5088942646980286,
-0.020995907485485077,
-0.5329935550689697,
-0.3534509837627411,
0.29123473167419434,
-0.7409184575080872,
-0.2527250051498413,
1.4912785291671753,
-0.32974758744239807,
0.15697355568408966,
-0.09007659554481506,
-0.2369016855955124,
0.6373283863067627,
0.09300752729177475,
0.8796287178993225,
0.430541068315506,
-0.45193806290626526,
-0.14610609412193298,
-0.27502143383026123,
0.6415420174598694,
0.3519955277442932,
-0.6203877329826355,
-0.11607097089290619,
0.3013250529766083,
0.3920215368270874,
0.32013314962387085,
0.51688551902771,
-0.3444966971874237,
0.23483315110206604,
-0.6004055142402649,
0.1186385303735733,
0.028964122757315636,
-0.02071823738515377,
-0.3231055438518524,
0.09595277160406113,
0.3822636902332306,
-0.08104000240564346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05411v1
|
Know When To Stop: A Study of Semantic Drift in Text Generation
| 2024-04-08T11:25:30 | 2024-04-08T11:25:30 |
Ava Spataru, Eric Hambro, Elena Voita, Nicola Cancedda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we explicitly show that modern LLMs tend to generate correct
facts first, then "drift away" and generate incorrect facts later: this was
occasionally observed but never properly measured. We develop a semantic drift
score that measures the degree of separation between correct and incorrect
facts in generated texts and confirm our hypothesis when generating
Wikipedia-style biographies. This correct-then-incorrect generation pattern
suggests that factual accuracy can be improved by knowing when to stop
generation. Therefore, we explore the trade-off between information quantity
and factual accuracy for several early stopping methods and manage to improve
factuality by a large margin. We further show that reranking with semantic
similarity can further improve these results, both compared to the baseline and
when combined with early stopping. Finally, we try calling external API to
bring the model back to the right generation path, but do not get positive
results. Overall, our methods generalize and can be applied to any long-form
text generation to produce more reliable information, by balancing trade-offs
between factual accuracy, information quantity and computational cost.
|
[
-0.47301721572875977,
-0.8716476559638977,
0.9269081354141235,
-0.019020671024918556,
-0.27951735258102417,
0.16077572107315063,
-0.3560259938240051,
-0.45703616738319397,
0.13948333263397217,
0.39547649025917053,
-0.9119644165039062,
-0.623878538608551,
-0.7219865322113037,
0.035462114959955215,
-0.7077761292457581,
1.1327571868896484,
0.03812925145030022,
-0.14275573194026947,
-0.6059675812721252,
0.058645304292440414,
-0.46986034512519836,
-0.0703154057264328,
-0.7116337418556213,
-0.2519676685333252,
0.7254840731620789,
0.5071249604225159,
0.5902302861213684,
0.9302432537078857,
0.4125184714794159,
0.2796521484851837,
-0.24948090314865112,
0.2670689821243286,
-0.9097497463226318,
0.48683133721351624,
-0.302737295627594,
-0.5080509185791016,
-0.022784484550356865,
0.10239746421575546,
0.4906851649284363,
0.6745758056640625,
-0.2093116044998169,
0.31483879685401917,
-0.22519457340240479,
0.5653538107872009,
-0.5249882936477661,
0.029059981927275658,
-0.6683753728866577,
-0.05749743431806564,
-0.6464380025863647,
-0.4265315532684326,
-0.6234009265899658,
-0.5580037832260132,
0.08019513636827469,
-0.4991566240787506,
0.5694135427474976,
0.03200818598270416,
0.9653868675231934,
0.5158720016479492,
-0.2907834053039551,
-0.5276864171028137,
-0.6360524296760559,
0.9883317351341248,
-0.7279183268547058,
0.3640139102935791,
0.23178310692310333,
-0.066264808177948,
-0.17603647708892822,
-0.5896050333976746,
-0.7640619874000549,
-0.21787753701210022,
0.19549152255058289,
0.24941027164459229,
0.01998896338045597,
-0.3516579270362854,
0.4481014907360077,
-0.016809342429041862,
-0.33401769399642944,
0.22279714047908783,
-0.6257563829421997,
-0.246327206492424,
0.7097529172897339,
0.20106592774391174,
0.3472565710544586,
-0.14406920969486237,
-0.6042993068695068,
0.03813900798559189,
-0.9126680493354797,
-0.11891435086727142,
0.5335471034049988,
0.06338081508874893,
0.24314789474010468,
0.7430636286735535,
-0.34141096472740173,
0.6004922986030579,
0.25240379571914673,
-0.5536956191062927,
0.17430004477500916,
-0.37530288100242615,
0.1553703248500824,
0.3498148024082184,
0.7339680194854736,
0.6860758066177368,
0.2555404603481293,
-0.3979159891605377,
-0.0009625089005567133,
0.12914294004440308,
0.30085882544517517,
-0.6869702935218811,
0.09799904376268387,
0.27642637491226196,
-0.5517057180404663,
-0.5598238706588745,
-0.046806685626506805,
-0.861344039440155,
-0.08299309760332108,
-0.5660629868507385,
0.12203330546617508,
-0.5827105045318604,
-0.10879547894001007,
-0.10914568603038788,
-0.4105677008628845,
0.26004621386528015,
0.37746408581733704,
-0.7253026366233826,
-0.0273429024964571,
0.5777875185012817,
1.0037907361984253,
-0.5011698603630066,
-0.3652457296848297,
-0.4323703944683075,
0.2558611035346985,
-0.5515355467796326,
0.9751524925231934,
-0.13369737565517426,
-0.3437654674053192,
-0.02638520672917366,
-0.12107809633016586,
0.20193155109882355,
-0.40150460600852966,
0.5678104758262634,
-0.6580192446708679,
0.4895878732204437,
-0.32757067680358887,
-0.7830908298492432,
0.04022541269659996,
0.18092021346092224,
-0.6725495457649231,
0.8756704926490784,
-0.27388325333595276,
-0.8732447624206543,
1.0507962703704834,
-0.3922298848628998,
-0.6139060854911804,
-0.1401914656162262,
0.037931010127067566,
-0.3808779716491699,
0.10433943569660187,
-0.2878890037536621,
0.3073577880859375,
-0.23661069571971893,
0.28905585408210754,
-0.233822301030159,
0.13938774168491364,
0.2301705777645111,
-0.2798331677913666,
0.6669915914535522,
0.21527518332004547,
-0.334663450717926,
-0.05192054063081741,
-0.8503310084342957,
0.0802353248000145,
0.03759894520044327,
-0.5440036058425903,
-0.33225446939468384,
0.4888186454772949,
-0.2488546073436737,
0.2918406128883362,
0.2206171303987503,
-0.8886237144470215,
-0.15292535722255707,
-0.12363776564598083,
0.12106487154960632,
0.7483970522880554,
0.16491544246673584,
0.14807620644569397,
-0.7418123483657837,
0.21518640220165253,
0.07575269043445587,
-0.08275263756513596,
-0.06482918560504913,
-0.7339211106300354,
-1.013222575187683,
-0.008559041656553745,
0.2664581537246704,
0.6235030293464661,
-0.7075494527816772,
0.5950031876564026,
-0.5385552048683167,
-0.4859704375267029,
-0.1900239884853363,
0.28398552536964417,
0.1610749065876007,
0.9058065414428711,
0.4750414490699768,
-0.20145583152770996,
-0.3829028606414795,
-0.49149107933044434,
-0.34115687012672424,
-0.2953353226184845,
0.09387055784463882,
-0.20111988484859467,
0.4429624080657959,
-0.029541069641709328,
1.4020766019821167,
-0.6431028842926025,
0.2763420343399048,
-0.11119231581687927,
0.3846571147441864,
-0.17084576189517975,
0.31237488985061646,
0.30109915137290955,
-0.8013904690742493,
-0.19394907355308533,
-0.3989061713218689,
-0.9110395908355713,
-0.10694570094347,
-0.36983463168144226,
-0.42698386311531067,
0.41997823119163513,
0.6919185519218445,
-0.992464005947113,
0.3587460219860077,
0.01716727949678898,
-0.541064977645874,
0.5605484843254089,
0.012624075636267662,
0.13612797856330872,
-0.9385698437690735,
-0.12112974375486374,
0.0339665450155735,
-0.3088071048259735,
-0.4339117407798767,
-0.3214614987373352,
-0.15168370306491852,
0.19651448726654053,
-0.5657190680503845,
0.3744124174118042,
-0.18657878041267395,
0.14600111544132233,
-0.2361016422510147,
0.34668847918510437,
-0.00831732526421547,
-0.07907145470380783,
0.0773942619562149,
0.6339427828788757,
-0.018596893176436424,
-0.8218918442726135,
0.5086262822151184,
0.2572656273841858,
-0.6335509419441223,
0.7262263894081116,
-0.3836749494075775,
-0.15913189947605133,
-0.3708746135234833,
0.033927690237760544,
-0.8459287285804749,
-0.32273581624031067,
0.006748674903064966,
-0.6789814233779907,
0.4305049479007721,
0.24600350856781006,
-0.3722357451915741,
-0.170712411403656,
-0.36243388056755066,
-0.07396025955677032,
0.6909143924713135,
-0.5121999979019165,
0.16800017654895782,
0.31410279870033264,
-0.3486618995666504,
-0.5056489706039429,
-0.8560792803764343,
0.12660269439220428,
-0.3318539559841156,
-0.9830655455589294,
0.569688081741333,
-0.09451793879270554,
-0.6541617512702942,
0.25548505783081055,
0.014598163776099682,
0.15786145627498627,
-0.14084213972091675,
-0.072223961353302,
0.19539064168930054,
-0.1268213391304016,
0.507564902305603,
0.1975902020931244,
-0.3044847548007965,
0.37169018387794495,
-0.2348063588142395,
0.35518863797187805,
0.6251438856124878,
-0.04687458276748657,
-0.29493939876556396,
0.1559751182794571,
0.5672335624694824,
0.08858469128608704,
1.0843054056167603,
0.5722712874412537,
-0.13686655461788177,
-0.2899974584579468,
-0.6451679468154907,
0.1021314337849617,
-0.4036949574947357,
0.20826134085655212,
-0.1464511901140213,
-0.531754195690155,
0.4012773036956787,
-0.16801249980926514,
0.2789419889450073,
0.9475336670875549,
0.9698122143745422,
-0.318290650844574,
0.6606707572937012,
0.6329770684242249,
0.22908660769462585,
0.33118849992752075,
-0.026897476986050606,
0.1483839601278305,
-0.31541112065315247,
-0.42174309492111206,
-0.37922734022140503,
-0.0948873832821846,
-0.6313343644142151,
-0.4220043420791626,
-0.013529988937079906,
0.06630940735340118,
-0.17984333634376526,
-0.11102978140115738,
-0.40317922830581665,
0.5716277956962585,
0.40919893980026245,
0.16836437582969666,
0.3301313519477844,
-0.13615457713603973,
0.05948023498058319,
-0.0674201250076294,
-0.46885961294174194,
-0.435836523771286,
1.090836524963379,
0.03446955606341362,
0.6801960468292236,
0.24805568158626556,
0.8611620664596558,
0.7739149928092957,
0.5671465396881104,
-0.7541124224662781,
0.4662819504737854,
0.04021373391151428,
-0.6870469450950623,
-0.5241860747337341,
-0.6389973759651184,
-0.7128505110740662,
-0.22858327627182007,
-0.09027128666639328,
-0.38010966777801514,
-0.13929153978824615,
-0.07462461292743683,
-0.14968544244766235,
0.16916026175022125,
-0.5283676385879517,
0.7228519916534424,
-0.21748314797878265,
-0.4222126007080078,
-0.17528806626796722,
-0.8212301135063171,
0.6296417117118835,
-0.20045901834964752,
0.3457759916782379,
-0.45143911242485046,
-0.29569533467292786,
0.9713941812515259,
-0.7455006837844849,
0.7392010688781738,
-0.008936501108109951,
-0.16253067553043365,
0.611331582069397,
-0.023466812446713448,
0.4103265106678009,
-0.18660610914230347,
-0.06274387985467911,
0.044590748846530914,
-0.1570606529712677,
-0.3797707259654999,
-0.35242345929145813,
0.6582674980163574,
-0.6123602986335754,
-0.3937591314315796,
-0.3196139335632324,
-0.41756102442741394,
0.05518345534801483,
0.2851276993751526,
1.034364104270935,
0.22865799069404602,
-0.20015092194080353,
-0.02704114094376564,
0.8943122625350952,
-0.17085541784763336,
0.45457085967063904,
0.34735211730003357,
-0.11045525223016739,
-0.4094409942626953,
1.039673924446106,
0.41052892804145813,
0.6094305515289307,
0.2028125673532486,
0.2507163882255554,
-0.5397183895111084,
-0.36632630228996277,
-0.6236478090286255,
0.21374882757663727,
-0.9726187586784363,
-0.21562373638153076,
-0.31398385763168335,
-0.15904219448566437,
-0.4562440514564514,
-0.19399185478687286,
-0.15433719754219055,
-0.5904171466827393,
-0.2763325273990631,
-0.2618817090988159,
0.5724891424179077,
0.7887491583824158,
-0.10451848804950714,
0.15831582248210907,
-0.6716182827949524,
0.20025353133678436,
0.15041649341583252,
0.02314664237201214,
-0.13948488235473633,
-0.47747737169265747,
-0.24052555859088898,
-0.30599597096443176,
-0.5157933831214905,
-0.9273780584335327,
0.09520098567008972,
0.24304351210594177,
0.6268249750137329,
0.4163496196269989,
0.13754910230636597,
0.2497982680797577,
-0.49296629428863525,
0.8849802613258362,
0.31888696551322937,
-0.9172634482383728,
0.5967501997947693,
-0.5135652422904968,
0.3991536498069763,
0.4400981664657593,
0.5171747207641602,
-0.5801809430122375,
-0.6146178841590881,
-0.6172546148300171,
-0.8046781420707703,
0.33712950348854065,
0.18233302235603333,
0.004779896233230829,
-0.3672175705432892,
0.3463333547115326,
0.23029343783855438,
0.22095626592636108,
-0.5426961183547974,
-0.2744714617729187,
-0.1923295557498932,
-0.4931032359600067,
0.06284663081169128,
-0.40109288692474365,
-0.16191136837005615,
0.041694771498441696,
0.7087956070899963,
-0.04617702215909958,
0.09358386695384979,
0.021464485675096512,
-0.3961368501186371,
-0.22914521396160126,
0.15257534384727478,
0.8543238639831543,
1.1063451766967773,
-0.02065904065966606,
0.13079620897769928,
0.2661457359790802,
-0.40474995970726013,
0.24456368386745453,
-0.2685745656490326,
-0.8308621048927307,
0.2584655284881592,
0.6604146361351013,
0.49439874291419983,
0.15063954889774323,
-0.6721839904785156,
0.3902100622653961,
0.2406381070613861,
-0.1610892415046692,
-0.26331183314323425,
0.17260771989822388,
0.23409348726272583,
-0.09888800978660583,
0.1249321699142456,
0.12369131296873093,
-0.07498627156019211,
-0.46120187640190125,
0.5274926424026489,
0.22807574272155762,
-0.10469973832368851,
-0.007640363648533821,
0.7220858931541443,
0.24173258244991302,
-0.18836046755313873,
0.67363041639328,
-0.3651071786880493,
-0.3466348946094513,
0.6699625253677368,
0.48013928532600403,
0.7257394790649414,
-0.034811895340681076,
0.4422149062156677,
0.37820348143577576,
0.2513897120952606,
-0.2803889513015747,
0.043860260397195816,
-0.16193298995494843,
-0.8369183540344238,
-0.7996705174446106,
-0.7072123289108276,
-0.35817399621009827,
-0.17415140569210052,
-0.68405681848526,
0.48592299222946167,
-0.44323939085006714,
-0.5038387179374695,
0.14588099718093872,
-0.24615666270256042,
-0.39904624223709106,
0.3939304053783417,
0.30583229660987854,
0.9303614497184753,
-0.6098721623420715,
0.45327794551849365,
0.25661519169807434,
-0.5129362940788269,
-0.20516790449619293,
0.2010563313961029,
0.2991105914115906,
-0.3873812258243561,
0.8891203999519348,
0.30864229798316956,
-0.38739120960235596,
-0.12037570774555206,
-0.8717814087867737,
-1.0250368118286133,
1.1878154277801514,
0.029386721551418304,
-0.4464838206768036,
-0.11795955896377563,
-0.055171940475702286,
0.3324923515319824,
-0.11556453257799149,
0.024259382858872414,
0.8578510880470276,
0.47705069184303284,
0.47932299971580505,
-0.469982385635376,
0.0777880996465683,
0.06446278095245361,
-0.12183675169944763,
0.48066720366477966,
-0.8359788060188293,
0.7932175993919373,
-0.3396397531032562,
-0.4179966449737549,
0.20082592964172363,
0.6814379096031189,
0.2035120278596878,
0.6027975082397461,
0.5188896059989929,
1.0235987901687622,
0.8785160779953003,
-0.17570462822914124,
0.8772463202476501,
-0.3848581910133362,
0.3848126530647278,
0.9240263104438782,
-0.15656127035617828,
0.7378761172294617,
0.3219245374202728,
-0.17002010345458984,
0.7283594608306885,
0.7441684007644653,
0.03917039558291435,
0.5443538427352905,
0.1260812133550644,
-0.42267850041389465,
-0.4359528720378876,
-0.059095922857522964,
-0.2420911341905594,
0.4485549032688141,
0.2939770221710205,
-0.4487735331058502,
-0.4448145925998688,
-0.03991581127047539,
0.5594941973686218,
-0.04286697506904602,
-0.128635436296463,
0.6626837849617004,
-0.14714862406253815,
-0.9181855916976929,
0.3194805085659027,
0.01044409442692995,
0.5543088912963867,
-0.46049782633781433,
0.22516530752182007,
-0.05307425558567047,
0.048030029982328415,
-0.2062803953886032,
-0.8591217994689941,
0.45944926142692566,
0.18051721155643463,
-0.780909538269043,
-0.29450953006744385,
0.8685482144355774,
-0.42163825035095215,
-0.63392573595047,
0.08043894171714783,
0.5007145404815674,
0.1511692851781845,
0.4562200605869293,
-0.4069409668445587,
0.11649401485919952,
-0.011645399034023285,
-0.30743497610092163,
0.16900770366191864,
0.6135748624801636,
0.07158811390399933,
0.6700372695922852,
0.9664828777313232,
0.20416474342346191,
0.3512808680534363,
-0.10689770430326462,
0.54566890001297,
-0.8685904145240784,
-0.5374792218208313,
-1.031421422958374,
0.42374739050865173,
-0.4788611829280853,
-0.684406042098999,
0.8209894895553589,
0.49742600321769714,
0.9304711818695068,
0.1370508074760437,
0.9106054306030273,
-0.23699694871902466,
0.852142333984375,
-1.0420154333114624,
0.7130938768386841,
-0.3736911118030548,
0.05863523110747337,
-0.006766337901353836,
-0.8380054235458374,
-0.18868796527385712,
0.40748831629753113,
-0.4621206521987915,
0.06754450500011444,
0.6783691048622131,
0.5135767459869385,
0.3193528652191162,
-0.08528686314821243,
0.15363238751888275,
0.27883416414260864,
0.430428683757782,
0.11438192427158356,
1.0883535146713257,
-0.04792574420571327,
0.4174603819847107,
-0.039263755083084106,
-0.1416110098361969,
-0.08263379335403442,
-0.8559343218803406,
-0.48965996503829956,
-0.2601970136165619,
-0.5031090378761292,
-0.6453194618225098,
-0.07564104348421097,
0.525990903377533,
0.5894928574562073,
-0.4461025297641754,
0.08658863604068756,
-0.16195407509803772,
0.4009425640106201,
0.15728436410427094,
-0.2752980589866638,
0.14149688184261322,
-0.9477440118789673,
-0.3892782926559448,
0.2201085388660431,
0.2619169354438782,
-0.049207903444767,
-0.39042362570762634,
-0.1917831152677536,
-0.11133965849876404,
0.3353102207183838,
0.6946374177932739,
0.3841891586780548,
-0.6571733355522156,
-0.3054490387439728,
-0.16777652502059937,
-0.1756172627210617,
0.016818072646856308,
0.873335063457489,
-0.8589664697647095,
0.4909772574901581,
0.695507287979126,
0.3872529864311218,
0.41742342710494995,
0.23243683576583862,
0.4762592315673828,
-0.4282912313938141,
0.02318049594759941,
0.06101056933403015,
0.060110900551080704,
0.452381432056427,
-0.4261995255947113,
0.39531511068344116,
0.7475974559783936,
-0.6721129417419434,
-0.6862713098526001,
0.3367389738559723,
-0.7407116293907166,
-0.13654828071594238,
0.9802719950675964,
0.02827560156583786,
-0.4114878475666046,
-0.3246111571788788,
0.18327586352825165,
0.31252071261405945,
-0.267129510641098,
0.8797945976257324,
1.021422266960144,
-0.3086274266242981,
0.01672828570008278,
-0.5989404916763306,
0.7346439957618713,
0.15511183440685272,
-0.9535232186317444,
-0.1102641224861145,
0.6357579827308655,
0.5305888056755066,
0.5577741861343384,
0.5379827618598938,
0.07189062982797623,
0.276452898979187,
0.2766839861869812,
-0.08116801828145981,
0.17710405588150024,
-0.4885210692882538,
0.28735780715942383,
-0.03472292795777321,
0.030536707490682602,
-0.14003513753414154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05406v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05406v2
|
PerkwE_COQA: Enhanced Persian Conversational Question Answering by combining contextual keyword extraction with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-08T11:14:58 | 2024-04-15T12:38:33 |
Pardis Moradbeiki, Nasser Ghadiri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, 68T07, J.3; I.2.7; I.2.1
|
Smart cities need the involvement of their residents to enhance quality of
life. Conversational query-answering is an emerging approach for user
engagement. There is an increasing demand of an advanced conversational
question-answering that goes beyond classic systems. Existing approaches have
shown that LLMs offer promising capabilities for CQA, but may struggle to
capture the nuances of conversational contexts. The new approach involves
understanding the content and engaging in a multi-step conversation with the
user to fulfill their needs. This paper presents a novel method to elevate the
performance of Persian Conversational question-answering (CQA) systems. It
combines the strengths of Large Language Models (LLMs) with contextual keyword
extraction. Our method extracts keywords specific to the conversational flow,
providing the LLM with additional context to understand the user's intent and
generate more relevant and coherent responses. We evaluated the effectiveness
of this combined approach through various metrics, demonstrating significant
improvements in CQA performance compared to an LLM-only baseline. The proposed
method effectively handles implicit questions, delivers contextually relevant
answers, and tackles complex questions that rely heavily on conversational
context. The findings indicate that our method outperformed the evaluation
benchmarks up to 8% higher than existing methods and the LLM-only baseline.
|
[
-0.584743320941925,
-1.1092607975006104,
0.6648718118667603,
0.01387602649629116,
-0.45295989513397217,
0.5629708170890808,
-0.3259270191192627,
-0.23429666459560394,
0.1820487082004547,
0.5564966797828674,
-0.7420830130577087,
-0.5822693705558777,
-0.036248672753572464,
-0.07267042249441147,
-0.3048442602157593,
0.36373862624168396,
0.24079327285289764,
0.21128734946250916,
-0.3782038986682892,
0.09825675934553146,
-0.6331344246864319,
-0.5277866721153259,
-0.5672006011009216,
-0.11658533662557602,
0.32057228684425354,
0.9649457931518555,
0.8288136720657349,
0.02833878993988037,
0.3604232668876648,
0.26172345876693726,
-0.16942539811134338,
0.18090800940990448,
-0.4382617473602295,
0.32215821743011475,
-0.020364081487059593,
-0.0697682648897171,
-0.44973668456077576,
-0.35686951875686646,
0.36373284459114075,
0.5896671414375305,
-0.24066221714019775,
0.22733470797538757,
0.024888882413506508,
0.3783178925514221,
-0.6713618636131287,
-0.1547297090291977,
-0.7132365703582764,
-0.02107100374996662,
-0.09177742153406143,
-0.43324923515319824,
0.09474103897809982,
-0.3698452413082123,
0.3240991532802582,
-0.5539616346359253,
-0.23615813255310059,
-0.1895565241575241,
0.7169498801231384,
0.2133910059928894,
-0.5539004802703857,
-0.2780224084854126,
-0.6847872734069824,
0.7582781314849854,
-0.7647545337677002,
0.3511787950992584,
0.13154810667037964,
0.47893965244293213,
-0.2761791944503784,
-0.5618247985839844,
-0.8661532998085022,
-0.18666332960128784,
0.04877500236034393,
0.3710772693157196,
0.06887301057577133,
-0.0280841626226902,
0.084069162607193,
0.2918318510055542,
-0.5387409329414368,
-0.26556020975112915,
-0.3003212511539459,
-0.09376229345798492,
0.6770264506340027,
0.46141019463539124,
0.31705787777900696,
-0.3821956217288971,
-0.4576617181301117,
-0.10091524571180344,
-0.7355682253837585,
0.43204423785209656,
-0.021713871508836746,
0.18278588354587555,
-0.1626625657081604,
0.3885829448699951,
-0.7469055652618408,
0.3382764160633087,
0.36018773913383484,
-0.06455498933792114,
-0.10585658997297287,
-0.5475479364395142,
-0.09850593656301498,
0.06779071688652039,
0.7173364162445068,
0.14152899384498596,
0.040142253041267395,
-0.2581577003002167,
0.2516547739505768,
-0.5658158659934998,
0.14429888129234314,
-0.8204811215400696,
-0.18598489463329315,
0.7409886121749878,
-0.03709004074335098,
-0.1375707983970642,
0.023216206580400467,
-0.7849264740943909,
-0.3181818425655365,
-0.07828735560178757,
0.17877861857414246,
-0.09577946364879608,
-0.31294867396354675,
0.1106136366724968,
0.11590095609426498,
0.6427671313285828,
0.666592538356781,
-0.7986351251602173,
0.32400351762771606,
0.644395112991333,
0.4376102387905121,
-0.2863718569278717,
0.37225431203842163,
-0.3896482586860657,
0.25144997239112854,
-0.39858993887901306,
0.6266586184501648,
-0.6927274465560913,
-0.4947361350059509,
-0.047322291880846024,
-0.26205378770828247,
0.03704359382390976,
-0.5712305903434753,
0.6380065083503723,
-1.0268100500106812,
0.21094921231269836,
-0.22647088766098022,
-0.14696969091892242,
-0.28814697265625,
0.5567919015884399,
-0.2764171063899994,
1.0459462404251099,
-0.06543606519699097,
-0.5073035359382629,
-0.0931135043501854,
-0.795964777469635,
-0.2082975208759308,
0.5637893080711365,
-0.1555406004190445,
-0.09735250473022461,
0.01577056758105755,
0.644815981388092,
0.52315753698349,
-0.3770428001880646,
0.4991053640842438,
-0.025823673233389854,
-0.4235835075378418,
0.5644638538360596,
-0.27235785126686096,
0.5365167260169983,
0.39646872878074646,
-0.2680337429046631,
0.23692841827869415,
-0.6228287816047668,
0.4358251094818115,
-0.05288718268275261,
-0.49822163581848145,
-0.3556883931159973,
0.12729141116142273,
0.045850593596696854,
0.29129207134246826,
0.6146531701087952,
-0.6812552213668823,
-0.15043190121650696,
-0.7001219391822815,
0.14272835850715637,
0.24939768016338348,
0.18307413160800934,
0.5059662461280823,
-0.03503333032131195,
0.8012533783912659,
-0.1290699541568756,
0.033211879432201385,
-0.019414259120821953,
-0.1750933974981308,
-0.7128131985664368,
-0.29651227593421936,
0.28487083315849304,
0.7937149405479431,
-1.0004814863204956,
0.24508747458457947,
-0.4681951701641083,
-0.6132967472076416,
-0.013936984352767467,
0.06348311901092529,
0.2431432157754898,
0.4235059916973114,
0.2453053593635559,
-0.20959633588790894,
-0.4196552336215973,
-0.5818185210227966,
-0.40531131625175476,
-0.09133121371269226,
0.07855681329965591,
0.8056157827377319,
0.3282153606414795,
0.049083199352025986,
1.0358492136001587,
-0.4796343743801117,
0.2531912326812744,
-0.48707863688468933,
-0.2631779611110687,
0.45756515860557556,
0.34640583395957947,
-0.11606086790561676,
-1.218502402305603,
-0.6430261135101318,
-0.03999950364232063,
-0.47199374437332153,
-0.12094912678003311,
-0.08972851932048798,
-0.3435624837875366,
-0.2944510877132416,
0.547788679599762,
-0.3870018720626831,
0.20274773240089417,
0.6480464935302734,
-0.4524623453617096,
0.502657413482666,
0.18922805786132812,
0.3733910024166107,
-1.3348428010940552,
0.10061922669410706,
-0.36028024554252625,
-0.4962213337421417,
-0.8831037282943726,
0.5248669981956482,
-0.0975734144449234,
-0.3558594882488251,
-0.6864596605300903,
0.6846242547035217,
-0.20898836851119995,
0.20062647759914398,
-0.14746734499931335,
0.28097373247146606,
-0.13737520575523376,
0.5687353610992432,
0.20071707665920258,
0.9805231690406799,
0.3023420572280884,
-0.5999391078948975,
0.4787408113479614,
0.6181374192237854,
-0.2377026230096817,
0.33742815256118774,
-0.736543595790863,
0.34998953342437744,
0.2767728567123413,
0.2811809480190277,
-1.318174123764038,
-0.2632730305194855,
0.2632545530796051,
-0.4291495382785797,
-0.23907820880413055,
0.1818544864654541,
-0.486765056848526,
-0.2495955377817154,
-0.2883695065975189,
0.4320680797100067,
0.1098567396402359,
-0.38795483112335205,
0.7540621757507324,
0.36371004581451416,
-0.6179173588752747,
-0.19394314289093018,
-0.31118935346603394,
0.49745750427246094,
-0.41767993569374084,
-0.6954260468482971,
0.1177729144692421,
-0.04754598066210747,
-0.0991324633359909,
-0.44004544615745544,
-0.10990060865879059,
-0.41834762692451477,
0.5584680438041687,
0.12651844322681427,
0.17156058549880981,
-0.14652705192565918,
0.19327808916568756,
0.23154862225055695,
0.036242470145225525,
-0.0647176131606102,
-0.03847021982073784,
0.8843634128570557,
0.04927143454551697,
-0.07070211321115494,
-0.6751599311828613,
0.5947626233100891,
0.6013094782829285,
-0.4552196264266968,
0.6499249935150146,
0.6091724038124084,
-0.0943242758512497,
0.40134894847869873,
-0.5415315628051758,
-0.34577682614326477,
-0.5210055708885193,
0.47148340940475464,
-0.7334139347076416,
-1.294253945350647,
0.49469348788261414,
-0.5723035335540771,
-0.02423594333231449,
0.1263178288936615,
0.642052948474884,
-0.4300738275051117,
1.0556843280792236,
0.4756093919277191,
0.0891212522983551,
0.5267029404640198,
0.1253768503665924,
0.37296849489212036,
-0.9796484112739563,
-0.28326529264450073,
-0.5808818936347961,
-0.03579983115196228,
-0.5851384997367859,
-0.512876570224762,
0.8632717728614807,
0.24109682440757751,
-0.3291770815849304,
0.09697244316339493,
-0.14875085651874542,
0.09698836505413055,
0.41781818866729736,
0.2960314154624939,
0.5541418194770813,
0.16091763973236084,
-0.12995457649230957,
0.04767800122499466,
-0.8283441662788391,
-0.6138054132461548,
0.9486173987388611,
0.14702323079109192,
0.6781142950057983,
0.5827475786209106,
0.6193299293518066,
0.03922278434038162,
-0.013202305883169174,
-0.5814753174781799,
0.7579900622367859,
0.11101936548948288,
-0.6033117175102234,
-0.5917263627052307,
-0.3541799783706665,
-0.9490201473236084,
0.49276646971702576,
-0.5224482417106628,
-0.9009567499160767,
0.19575810432434082,
-0.03582340106368065,
-0.8307964205741882,
-0.22288046777248383,
-0.3064589500427246,
0.7716756463050842,
-0.2812207043170929,
-0.44931870698928833,
-0.4872066080570221,
-0.4302973747253418,
0.2700284719467163,
-0.040663812309503555,
0.20376186072826385,
-0.08035320043563843,
-0.12538361549377441,
0.6409351229667664,
-0.4244454503059387,
0.4882591962814331,
-0.09290310740470886,
-0.21597014367580414,
0.2335609793663025,
-0.06119189411401749,
0.5209106802940369,
0.26461413502693176,
0.02514261193573475,
-0.010027412325143814,
0.48452845215797424,
-0.46236053109169006,
-0.5409359335899353,
0.6143618822097778,
-0.5817436575889587,
-0.8723285794258118,
-0.20275448262691498,
-0.678165078163147,
-0.6884378790855408,
-0.10407198965549469,
-0.23514826595783234,
0.6033207178115845,
-0.2537855803966522,
0.4242715537548065,
0.7405887246131897,
-0.5350406765937805,
0.35614684224128723,
0.5512378215789795,
-0.02025775983929634,
-0.40615490078926086,
0.4958533048629761,
-0.44245555996894836,
0.24433079361915588,
0.4572817087173462,
0.3560229241847992,
-0.42637646198272705,
-0.5767929553985596,
-0.4952830970287323,
-0.0991305336356163,
-0.29781848192214966,
-0.06658326834440231,
-0.9512500166893005,
-0.07060743123292923,
-0.592572033405304,
-0.05918726325035095,
-0.1638185679912567,
-0.42496269941329956,
0.02963653951883316,
0.3209972083568573,
0.1505461484193802,
0.3464803397655487,
0.2401238977909088,
0.4190211892127991,
-1.0959689617156982,
0.42855483293533325,
0.6258231997489929,
-0.2631553113460541,
0.09632555395364761,
-0.45376265048980713,
-0.3414002060890198,
0.11431208997964859,
-0.45565518736839294,
-1.033656358718872,
0.37286269664764404,
0.1824321746826172,
0.37239763140678406,
0.16961511969566345,
0.3432963490486145,
1.006466031074524,
-0.2700439691543579,
1.0516043901443481,
0.07318947464227676,
-0.8775009512901306,
0.5017073154449463,
-0.605717658996582,
0.810908317565918,
0.8674001693725586,
0.253235787153244,
-0.7721956372261047,
-0.40386566519737244,
-0.4492270052433014,
-1.1210358142852783,
0.3912407159805298,
-0.0026615143287926912,
0.5422422885894775,
0.19760988652706146,
0.4594905376434326,
-0.30379921197891235,
0.3207719922065735,
-0.44529277086257935,
0.001342238043434918,
0.12628482282161713,
-0.2619602680206299,
0.11438164860010147,
-0.38523560762405396,
0.0687500461935997,
-0.4898458421230316,
0.6043789982795715,
-0.2525114119052887,
0.16626714169979095,
0.4441888928413391,
-0.2017500251531601,
0.07302127033472061,
0.6648743748664856,
0.40898260474205017,
0.6717416644096375,
-0.11578202992677689,
-0.3040306568145752,
0.5682983994483948,
-0.49145978689193726,
-0.06819683313369751,
-0.1326058804988861,
-0.07295873761177063,
-0.37872275710105896,
-0.02769712172448635,
0.25845733284950256,
0.24623380601406097,
-0.9797893166542053,
0.5220100283622742,
-0.3553619980812073,
0.17654730379581451,
-0.5987353324890137,
0.097102090716362,
0.36372026801109314,
0.5509811639785767,
0.747933566570282,
-0.43591490387916565,
0.4032388925552368,
-0.7348142862319946,
0.04362291842699051,
0.6740125417709351,
-0.5397046804428101,
0.0034883772023022175,
0.48138582706451416,
0.5187332034111023,
0.05911426991224289,
0.31035593152046204,
-0.08175366371870041,
-0.9150277972221375,
0.4331863522529602,
0.3102324903011322,
0.7058848142623901,
-0.034639351069927216,
0.16175559163093567,
0.5289596319198608,
-0.25440293550491333,
0.4504612386226654,
0.6896607279777527,
-0.5877647995948792,
-0.7708921432495117,
-0.5868653655052185,
-0.6499897837638855,
-0.6429075598716736,
0.06938102096319199,
-0.5674536228179932,
-0.12551376223564148,
-0.2597048282623291,
0.06168900802731514,
-0.5734259486198425,
0.6282740831375122,
-0.4885779023170471,
0.40048208832740784,
0.24737240374088287,
0.8898518681526184,
-0.44963833689689636,
0.6444672346115112,
0.8884389400482178,
0.1333787888288498,
-1.1034153699874878,
0.3129412829875946,
-0.29214996099472046,
-0.3609904944896698,
0.5158725380897522,
-0.27158042788505554,
-0.35372909903526306,
0.2560005486011505,
-0.7972634434700012,
-0.9978360533714294,
1.2003318071365356,
-0.06370105594396591,
-0.6070377826690674,
0.26282721757888794,
0.2400854527950287,
0.3674752414226532,
-0.36653319001197815,
0.290864497423172,
0.522018313407898,
0.4088292717933655,
0.43191370368003845,
-0.9340945482254028,
0.31091153621673584,
-0.04676946625113487,
-0.11088873445987701,
-0.22013400495052338,
-0.6922113299369812,
0.4711838662624359,
0.0007706366013735533,
-0.4369983375072479,
0.7564529776573181,
0.7757365703582764,
0.3113100528717041,
0.2176484763622284,
0.4378354847431183,
0.16826340556144714,
0.6600207686424255,
-0.12789340317249298,
0.9249431490898132,
-0.5390958786010742,
0.19624435901641846,
1.0317740440368652,
-0.03091980144381523,
1.1712392568588257,
0.5437291264533997,
-0.04518189653754234,
0.6862656474113464,
0.6303479671478271,
0.578123152256012,
0.6422428488731384,
0.20933149755001068,
-0.4810032844543457,
-0.6923521161079407,
-0.2077099233865738,
-0.07976426929235458,
0.9003874063491821,
0.4270429015159607,
0.38495516777038574,
-0.28096312284469604,
-0.04259452223777771,
0.1345350295305252,
0.3033532500267029,
-0.3158462345600128,
1.0960055589675903,
-0.05260332673788071,
-0.7385034561157227,
0.5397592782974243,
0.04280344024300575,
0.7196822166442871,
-0.43422454595565796,
-0.01831374503672123,
-0.2364894598722458,
-0.1524309366941452,
-0.18865171074867249,
-0.47286954522132874,
0.08326875418424606,
0.07016008347272873,
0.07378249615430832,
-0.12916898727416992,
0.684321403503418,
-0.5374805927276611,
-0.35880953073501587,
-0.13132242858409882,
0.8509054780006409,
0.27152228355407715,
-0.3540598154067993,
-0.7911363840103149,
-0.18364126980304718,
-0.05521734058856964,
-0.010692439042031765,
0.027771886438131332,
0.2226540744304657,
-0.22780925035476685,
0.5934004187583923,
0.8747977018356323,
0.048337340354919434,
-0.09846027940511703,
-0.12073717266321182,
0.842440664768219,
-0.7487767338752747,
-0.5846672654151917,
-0.5873342156410217,
0.49206241965293884,
-0.2903279960155487,
-0.33081284165382385,
0.8700534105300903,
0.47945353388786316,
0.37166163325309753,
0.2404225468635559,
0.571953535079956,
-0.01577380672097206,
0.7578995227813721,
-0.3711261451244354,
0.6151207089424133,
-0.6384045481681824,
0.40535834431648254,
-0.23424987494945526,
-0.771587073802948,
-0.04743727296590805,
0.41177356243133545,
-0.5874073505401611,
-0.3050217926502228,
0.46853402256965637,
0.9213480353355408,
0.07850214838981628,
-0.013273924589157104,
0.4836817681789398,
0.11293681710958481,
0.32104918360710144,
0.7383458018302917,
1.1372405290603638,
-0.49654439091682434,
0.4717618227005005,
0.16955091059207916,
-0.039566755294799805,
-0.17848989367485046,
-0.5400869250297546,
-0.7527777552604675,
-0.4495672285556793,
-0.24728794395923615,
-0.19399064779281616,
0.26972636580467224,
0.8434301614761353,
0.8248224854469299,
-0.9727898836135864,
-0.22421696782112122,
0.1857713907957077,
0.05067160725593567,
-0.0067314584739506245,
-0.2652937173843384,
0.44598978757858276,
-0.09434593468904495,
-0.805885910987854,
0.4458059072494507,
0.2530938982963562,
-0.34618079662323,
-0.2408515065908432,
-0.05949383229017258,
-0.32074493169784546,
0.39629605412483215,
0.4620741605758667,
0.18204426765441895,
-0.5199248790740967,
-0.22254721820354462,
0.14239035546779633,
-0.24472829699516296,
0.08156236261129379,
0.6432828307151794,
-1.0228979587554932,
0.2634030878543854,
0.5474273562431335,
0.6410982012748718,
0.5586269497871399,
0.44901368021965027,
0.6293042898178101,
-0.5330525636672974,
-0.020156478509306908,
0.2612811028957367,
-0.21591049432754517,
0.39077118039131165,
-0.536323070526123,
0.10353831201791763,
-0.1549292355775833,
-0.2586568593978882,
-0.2939319908618927,
0.26737502217292786,
-1.0269783735275269,
-0.34687650203704834,
1.2035799026489258,
-0.08286546170711517,
-0.14441031217575073,
-0.5178725123405457,
-0.24296484887599945,
-0.026156393811106682,
-0.4947831928730011,
0.6805554628372192,
0.4079659581184387,
-0.001275557791814208,
-0.36627528071403503,
-0.6745981574058533,
0.302435040473938,
0.6750954389572144,
-0.856736958026886,
-0.36950090527534485,
0.3804916739463806,
0.2940804064273834,
0.056529950350522995,
0.7420740127563477,
-0.24821005761623383,
0.6481935977935791,
-0.5724169015884399,
-0.18001733720302582,
0.13003778457641602,
0.02117316983640194,
-0.25012749433517456,
0.37015631794929504,
0.027995316311717033,
-0.10271768271923065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05405v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05405v1
|
Physics of Language Models: Part 3.3, Knowledge Capacity Scaling Laws
| 2024-04-08T11:11:31 | 2024-04-08T11:11:31 |
Zeyuan Allen-Zhu, Yuanzhi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Scaling laws describe the relationship between the size of language models
and their capabilities. Unlike prior studies that evaluate a model's capability
via loss or benchmarks, we estimate the number of knowledge bits a model
stores. We focus on factual knowledge represented as tuples, such as (USA,
capital, Washington D.C.) from a Wikipedia page. Through multiple controlled
datasets, we establish that language models can and only can store 2 bits of
knowledge per parameter, even when quantized to int8, and such knowledge can be
flexibly extracted for downstream applications. Consequently, a 7B model can
store 14B bits of knowledge, surpassing the English Wikipedia and textbooks
combined based on our estimation.
More broadly, we present 12 results on how (1) training duration, (2) model
architecture, (3) quantization, (4) sparsity constraints such as MoE, and (5)
data signal-to-noise ratio affect a model's knowledge storage capacity. Notable
insights include:
* The GPT-2 architecture, with rotary embedding, matches or even surpasses
LLaMA/Mistral architectures in knowledge storage, particularly over shorter
training durations. This arises because LLaMA/Mistral uses GatedMLP, which is
less stable and harder to train.
* Prepending training data with domain names (e.g., wikipedia.org)
significantly increases a model's knowledge capacity. Language models can
autonomously identify and prioritize domains rich in knowledge, optimizing
their storage capacity.
|
[
-0.3518674671649933,
-0.6039620041847229,
0.6172614097595215,
0.08473455160856247,
0.2144387662410736,
-0.4243519902229309,
-0.2052517682313919,
-0.5630441904067993,
-0.4215683341026306,
0.5960659384727478,
0.03604555130004883,
0.2491663098335266,
-0.6271082758903503,
-0.2127717286348343,
-0.5752434730529785,
0.8748704195022583,
0.10155611485242844,
0.24757014214992523,
-0.18892808258533478,
-0.165962353348732,
-0.34883493185043335,
-0.46214550733566284,
-0.5339668393135071,
-0.3202063739299774,
0.29737722873687744,
0.28199219703674316,
0.9651749730110168,
0.9897388815879822,
0.5491176247596741,
0.24529603123664856,
-0.4228917360305786,
-0.21083636581897736,
-0.5063596963882446,
-0.05824141204357147,
-0.041219312697649,
-0.48723697662353516,
-0.40524566173553467,
-0.05614537373185158,
0.8555359244346619,
0.7728570103645325,
-0.3182278871536255,
-0.13354311883449554,
-0.020086629316210747,
0.8075535297393799,
-0.3872857391834259,
0.2757253050804138,
-0.6384876370429993,
-0.1683090627193451,
-0.10281399637460709,
0.14877668023109436,
-0.29181891679763794,
-0.1640654057264328,
0.30935874581336975,
-0.6227567195892334,
0.20294281840324402,
0.17360545694828033,
0.897258460521698,
0.044592875987291336,
-0.7011706829071045,
-0.30919715762138367,
-0.628873884677887,
0.8717944622039795,
-0.7775734066963196,
0.5965576767921448,
0.5794826149940491,
0.3151831328868866,
0.011502276174724102,
-0.6365836262702942,
-0.6577550768852234,
-0.20340341329574585,
-0.0168252345174551,
-0.3918421268463135,
-0.20088879764080048,
0.13319216668605804,
0.48049843311309814,
0.5160582661628723,
-0.35412049293518066,
0.015701865777373314,
-0.8049272894859314,
-0.26037636399269104,
0.5321601629257202,
0.028342127799987793,
0.39497119188308716,
0.093558169901371,
-0.008530489169061184,
-0.16393588483333588,
-0.8225710988044739,
-0.20198003947734833,
0.2759920358657837,
0.18944692611694336,
-0.11544191092252731,
0.6310369372367859,
-0.13437111675739288,
0.8346399664878845,
-0.1648823618888855,
-0.3767484426498413,
-0.06785213202238083,
-0.3118794560432434,
-0.033398859202861786,
-0.2826257348060608,
0.9374693632125854,
0.1237926185131073,
0.4948154389858246,
-0.1535121202468872,
-0.08923111110925674,
-0.6233557462692261,
0.3155233860015869,
-0.8134700655937195,
-0.0034749421756714582,
-0.1553160548210144,
-0.3633977472782135,
-0.1547693908214569,
-0.09557594358921051,
-0.2843126654624939,
-0.5537238121032715,
-0.28464847803115845,
0.5909425616264343,
-0.7260801792144775,
-0.4763573110103607,
0.3315771222114563,
-0.19482864439487457,
0.21704261004924774,
-0.007030544802546501,
-1.4423972368240356,
0.6167556047439575,
0.6620587110519409,
0.8719780445098877,
0.26655977964401245,
-0.3671613931655884,
0.15265360474586487,
0.11311555653810501,
-0.3785598576068878,
0.29059678316116333,
-0.2188609391450882,
-0.131587952375412,
0.025513196364045143,
-0.20484445989131927,
0.05274590477347374,
-0.38258326053619385,
-0.1411900669336319,
-0.7599162459373474,
0.023089323192834854,
-0.4950910210609436,
-0.8495630621910095,
-0.30386054515838623,
-0.14063748717308044,
-0.9970476031303406,
0.7185181379318237,
0.27091044187545776,
-0.6750983595848083,
0.3434971868991852,
-0.49648457765579224,
-0.5615946054458618,
-0.11991079896688461,
-0.06279811263084412,
-0.20516347885131836,
0.34944280982017517,
-0.27704596519470215,
0.5009534358978271,
-0.6840802431106567,
0.200076624751091,
-0.36066392064094543,
0.07775448262691498,
0.25560808181762695,
-0.37752559781074524,
0.9336482286453247,
0.44347628951072693,
-0.042885370552539825,
-0.31387633085250854,
-0.6805784106254578,
-0.15122897922992706,
0.0991641953587532,
-0.5170828700065613,
-0.25422635674476624,
0.13815799355506897,
-0.29212725162506104,
-0.015056997537612915,
0.3590486943721771,
-0.36306414008140564,
0.3023989200592041,
-0.2174513339996338,
0.6638510227203369,
0.3862961530685425,
-0.04897139221429825,
0.8255273103713989,
-0.15532709658145905,
0.3763177990913391,
-0.06274674832820892,
0.132230743765831,
0.17848704755306244,
-0.4672388732433319,
-0.6827671527862549,
0.26163551211357117,
0.1593976467847824,
0.22241424024105072,
-0.4323907494544983,
-0.06853333860635757,
-0.4657822251319885,
-0.5293352603912354,
-0.2126169353723526,
0.23232123255729675,
0.2621203064918518,
0.35452190041542053,
0.09609746187925339,
0.01693546399474144,
-0.43703973293304443,
-0.9131478071212769,
-0.17367048561573029,
-0.44803184270858765,
0.08932991325855255,
0.24262583255767822,
0.4369725286960602,
0.1436048299074173,
0.8580320477485657,
-0.24993078410625458,
-0.028638167306780815,
-0.33658429980278015,
-0.11260348558425903,
0.17396681010723114,
0.4082670211791992,
0.6021385192871094,
-0.7865593433380127,
-0.34198620915412903,
0.45625245571136475,
-0.6877167820930481,
0.06942810118198395,
0.15475589036941528,
0.20434531569480896,
0.12158365547657013,
0.4115065038204193,
-0.7012753486633301,
0.06392443925142288,
0.4916103184223175,
-0.35407117009162903,
0.4690716862678528,
-0.3197254538536072,
-0.07384181767702103,
-1.0385440587997437,
-0.29667404294013977,
-0.09457512944936752,
-0.13726221024990082,
-0.8000125885009766,
0.07396581023931503,
0.329894095659256,
-0.059298090636730194,
-0.37902313470840454,
0.6896631121635437,
-0.5317400693893433,
-0.18167942762374878,
-0.3429493010044098,
-0.0026274756528437138,
-0.033372994512319565,
0.24500951170921326,
0.09231451153755188,
0.856255829334259,
0.5987729430198669,
-0.9011542797088623,
0.32634320855140686,
-0.08439598977565765,
-0.47249943017959595,
0.17946888506412506,
-0.535302460193634,
-0.11162452399730682,
0.27051815390586853,
-0.10427600145339966,
-0.6239049434661865,
-0.33893048763275146,
-0.37387195229530334,
-0.35668256878852844,
0.3492821753025055,
-0.26093870401382446,
-0.6875715255737305,
-0.20240691304206848,
0.1309429556131363,
0.5307802557945251,
0.6067081689834595,
-0.1671411097049713,
0.5556449294090271,
0.8455923795700073,
0.05114114284515381,
-0.40938055515289307,
-0.751580536365509,
-0.25258669257164,
-0.16356724500656128,
-0.6071568131446838,
-0.10937339812517166,
0.005500842817127705,
-0.49664634466171265,
0.14288051426410675,
-0.23118248581886292,
-0.444502592086792,
0.15647567808628082,
0.07950935512781143,
0.0037350784987211227,
-0.32171255350112915,
0.3644278943538666,
-0.06976096332073212,
0.1428990662097931,
0.3482356667518616,
-0.6766666173934937,
0.6002399325370789,
-0.6392103433609009,
-0.0526973195374012,
-0.1374824494123459,
-0.07953613996505737,
0.7098477482795715,
0.12117980420589447,
1.134210228919983,
0.47158297896385193,
-0.44654762744903564,
0.164351224899292,
-0.5760738253593445,
-0.025551311671733856,
-0.4519746005535126,
0.5058762431144714,
-0.49003201723098755,
-1.0820814371109009,
0.5856788158416748,
0.3321048617362976,
0.005898605566471815,
0.7512853741645813,
0.7451396584510803,
0.05930511653423309,
0.7243173718452454,
0.8024852275848389,
-0.3924191892147064,
0.664479672908783,
-0.3552238345146179,
0.19043435156345367,
-0.6733008623123169,
-0.14012689888477325,
-0.4462718069553375,
0.01973053626716137,
-0.5844703912734985,
-0.3026873469352722,
0.22149357199668884,
0.39623454213142395,
-0.536071240901947,
0.6292667388916016,
-0.1902218461036682,
0.7245118618011475,
0.48256686329841614,
-0.05735115706920624,
0.1589733064174652,
0.1368330717086792,
0.15114963054656982,
0.14004634320735931,
-0.9444307088851929,
-0.2673015296459198,
1.3655489683151245,
0.6110079288482666,
0.6792150735855103,
0.4425545036792755,
0.2141517698764801,
0.014125887304544449,
0.1137978583574295,
-0.8530235290527344,
0.5226751565933228,
0.049461908638477325,
-1.0693466663360596,
-0.6285622715950012,
-0.7403335571289062,
-0.7618664503097534,
0.04655546322464943,
0.01322410348802805,
-0.6750836372375488,
0.04908093810081482,
0.13875743746757507,
-0.11694542318582535,
0.7016734480857849,
-0.8979889154434204,
0.6257702112197876,
-0.2845896780490875,
-0.19655905663967133,
-0.548770546913147,
-0.5399547219276428,
0.269448846578598,
-0.04490364342927933,
0.32864683866500854,
0.0020809960551559925,
-0.005120826885104179,
1.0875251293182373,
-0.6899831295013428,
0.5986528396606445,
-0.16635863482952118,
-0.26672986149787903,
0.4884571135044098,
0.2867538630962372,
0.19993162155151367,
-0.1838935911655426,
-0.0025541731156408787,
0.19673068821430206,
0.3686118721961975,
-0.5173049569129944,
-0.5473647713661194,
0.5588794350624084,
-1.0212982892990112,
-0.5494908094406128,
-0.2356197088956833,
-0.8433050513267517,
-0.33755335211753845,
0.4539492130279541,
0.24499326944351196,
0.3722665309906006,
0.18178680539131165,
0.5931403636932373,
0.9404433369636536,
0.06240164116024971,
0.40382835268974304,
0.6693055629730225,
-0.2749902904033661,
-0.1795656383037567,
1.0185792446136475,
0.5326468348503113,
0.6125622987747192,
0.5369296073913574,
0.4430564343929291,
-0.36855584383010864,
-0.6349356770515442,
0.14504948258399963,
0.42024463415145874,
-0.7461274266242981,
-0.15797622501850128,
-0.5294939279556274,
-0.5441586971282959,
-0.7674509286880493,
0.09450158476829529,
-0.4197077453136444,
-0.7341601252555847,
-0.11823268979787827,
-0.12587007880210876,
0.6123532652854919,
1.1186343431472778,
-0.4291647970676422,
0.6193660497665405,
-0.5412675738334656,
0.10673931241035461,
0.3900282382965088,
0.5020000338554382,
0.17743279039859772,
-0.8899192214012146,
-0.7768707871437073,
-0.102994903922081,
-0.12871702015399933,
-0.8616555333137512,
0.17638690769672394,
0.08294326066970825,
0.34309569001197815,
0.5951458215713501,
-0.33865615725517273,
0.6315191984176636,
-0.44913747906684875,
0.5093307495117188,
0.25665998458862305,
-0.8676784038543701,
0.3487356901168823,
-0.4037999212741852,
0.012391098774969578,
0.16535817086696625,
0.38171255588531494,
-0.43488985300064087,
-0.18476250767707825,
-0.7550677061080933,
-0.4996156692504883,
0.5937210917472839,
-0.05778633430600166,
0.24390701949596405,
0.10620730370283127,
0.6757401823997498,
-0.047715846449136734,
0.14127078652381897,
-0.8610560894012451,
0.0007922091172076762,
-0.17552484571933746,
-0.07657621800899506,
0.16226810216903687,
-0.6896457672119141,
-0.0706610158085823,
-0.1664935052394867,
0.7833259105682373,
0.19647198915481567,
0.24580007791519165,
-0.24086569249629974,
-0.12334112823009491,
0.11029524356126785,
0.23661136627197266,
0.6294148564338684,
0.7477383017539978,
-0.041722722351551056,
0.10252753645181656,
0.15996785461902618,
-0.8904286026954651,
0.2277703732252121,
-0.192841574549675,
-0.036295242607593536,
-0.416303813457489,
0.4253093898296356,
0.8966781497001648,
0.12095721065998077,
-0.4290734529495239,
0.32438936829566956,
0.017461121082305908,
-0.33090415596961975,
-0.2852441966533661,
0.1624072939157486,
0.017177226021885872,
0.2699947655200958,
0.2665288746356964,
-0.1441996544599533,
0.11050398647785187,
-0.3931499719619751,
0.03759537637233734,
0.25882241129875183,
-0.3306531012058258,
-0.3463277220726013,
0.6101706027984619,
-0.1530470848083496,
-0.06598366796970367,
0.6148141026496887,
-0.16894501447677612,
-0.25498270988464355,
0.37971022725105286,
0.6143280267715454,
0.35775864124298096,
-0.1623251736164093,
0.026395004242658615,
0.4301115572452545,
0.5439666509628296,
-0.4230095446109772,
0.10837242752313614,
-0.00781979039311409,
-0.9971625208854675,
-0.3658556342124939,
-0.5595112442970276,
-0.3261738419532776,
0.29732877016067505,
-0.8404125571250916,
-0.03314642235636711,
-0.5596269965171814,
-0.19387376308441162,
-0.1903926134109497,
0.36806541681289673,
-0.5632649064064026,
0.1495901346206665,
-0.04934175685048103,
1.0640772581100464,
-0.9182965755462646,
0.94588702917099,
0.3705230951309204,
-0.4984912872314453,
-1.1547582149505615,
-0.4391443729400635,
0.19352243840694427,
-1.0022039413452148,
0.47911447286605835,
-0.26920828223228455,
0.15942351520061493,
0.13414913415908813,
-0.5854727625846863,
-1.1487351655960083,
1.125294804573059,
0.535217821598053,
-0.7013902068138123,
-0.08603609353303909,
0.06253808736801147,
0.5587834119796753,
-0.19204537570476532,
0.054461389780044556,
0.7084152698516846,
0.22726581990718842,
-0.06362386047840118,
-1.000952959060669,
-0.10601748526096344,
-0.11094190180301666,
0.05811823531985283,
0.21548369526863098,
-0.5733292102813721,
0.8699984550476074,
-0.2854941785335541,
-0.03806919977068901,
-0.0004769690567627549,
0.7445618510246277,
0.25883081555366516,
-0.15905532240867615,
0.38187986612319946,
0.6916770935058594,
0.7775843739509583,
-0.18173032999038696,
1.4966895580291748,
-0.4729340076446533,
0.4531848728656769,
0.752393364906311,
-0.06845765560865402,
0.6683402061462402,
0.48419320583343506,
-0.4073786437511444,
0.2792954444885254,
0.5438007712364197,
0.08086568117141724,
0.4696207344532013,
0.005451624747365713,
-0.11218667775392532,
0.0313817635178566,
-0.07724294811487198,
-0.3340919613838196,
0.11775156855583191,
0.3793345093727112,
-0.20017416775226593,
0.17768052220344543,
-0.016701681539416313,
0.38915184140205383,
-0.295521080493927,
-0.3884168565273285,
0.7650655508041382,
0.134934201836586,
-0.33824509382247925,
0.43362224102020264,
-0.10671204328536987,
-0.060087233781814575,
-0.6565226912498474,
0.30718085169792175,
-0.23520305752754211,
0.09458200633525848,
-0.00835129152983427,
-0.956264317035675,
0.14445523917675018,
-0.08313547074794769,
-0.42178985476493835,
-0.22546948492527008,
0.707848072052002,
-0.3215414881706238,
-0.40676945447921753,
0.03797559812664986,
0.4855503439903259,
0.3482358157634735,
-0.004562449175864458,
-0.28714096546173096,
0.07849407941102982,
-0.1470664143562317,
-0.4132673740386963,
0.46515509486198425,
0.8936910629272461,
-0.055078454315662384,
0.9343703389167786,
0.20987722277641296,
0.5233336091041565,
0.4097070097923279,
0.07715225219726562,
0.7108235955238342,
-0.6363709568977356,
-0.23319466412067413,
-0.7269924879074097,
0.12965144217014313,
0.016250206157565117,
-0.034042321145534515,
0.6605506539344788,
0.5870131254196167,
0.7615888714790344,
0.08816710859537125,
0.8502128720283508,
-0.43903979659080505,
0.18713831901550293,
-0.6454333066940308,
0.8037579655647278,
-0.4463837146759033,
0.31356552243232727,
0.28492772579193115,
-0.7341647148132324,
-0.15374435484409332,
0.6314155459403992,
-0.49604764580726624,
0.1619056612253189,
0.6879526972770691,
0.6052088141441345,
-0.017662115395069122,
-0.1833556443452835,
0.481884241104126,
0.4768047332763672,
0.29621797800064087,
0.5048922896385193,
0.49296268820762634,
-0.5147551894187927,
0.7330285906791687,
-0.20953162014484406,
-0.05801402032375336,
-0.1561116725206375,
-0.5440433621406555,
-0.7064735889434814,
-0.9369832277297974,
-0.10782289505004883,
-0.5652018785476685,
-0.32840999960899353,
0.271173894405365,
0.9381880164146423,
-0.6740285754203796,
-0.6041910648345947,
-0.32232391834259033,
0.1761803925037384,
-0.1915789097547531,
-0.2215651273727417,
0.1302499771118164,
-0.45899340510368347,
-0.2453620880842209,
0.2585391700267792,
0.10398812592029572,
0.44473034143447876,
-0.3349759876728058,
-0.3523639440536499,
0.0735304206609726,
0.07670764625072479,
0.46811795234680176,
0.49779650568962097,
-0.6887022256851196,
-0.2533201277256012,
-0.028521481901407242,
-0.17194049060344696,
-0.2846182584762573,
0.9105805158615112,
-0.39886099100112915,
0.4096076190471649,
0.5227032899856567,
0.5934076309204102,
0.6557905673980713,
-0.5843583941459656,
0.7970515489578247,
-0.5645110607147217,
0.16217957437038422,
-0.20969483256340027,
0.6550040245056152,
0.15466341376304626,
-0.04906595125794411,
0.5940260887145996,
0.1794227659702301,
-0.68916916847229,
-0.7305200099945068,
0.2814050316810608,
-0.7761402726173401,
-0.24276025593280792,
1.2042264938354492,
0.02700791135430336,
-0.15901896357536316,
0.1466151922941208,
0.13952192664146423,
0.2051084041595459,
-0.1019294261932373,
0.6842888593673706,
1.1075451374053955,
-0.05568605288863182,
-0.4041486084461212,
-0.8863286972045898,
0.6054988503456116,
0.18781396746635437,
-0.4194139838218689,
0.17322155833244324,
0.4308699071407318,
0.49283093214035034,
0.22892418503761292,
0.7125040888786316,
-0.2504468560218811,
0.16545549035072327,
0.27689409255981445,
-0.05710924044251442,
-0.08303318172693253,
-0.457598477602005,
-0.4143131375312805,
0.11197540909051895,
0.21886815130710602,
0.26653727889060974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05399v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05399v1
|
SafetyPrompts: a Systematic Review of Open Datasets for Evaluating and Improving Large Language Model Safety
| 2024-04-08T10:57:25 | 2024-04-08T10:57:25 |
Paul Röttger, Fabio Pernisi, Bertie Vidgen, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The last two years have seen a rapid growth in concerns around the safety of
large language models (LLMs). Researchers and practitioners have met these
concerns by introducing an abundance of new datasets for evaluating and
improving LLM safety. However, much of this work has happened in parallel, and
with very different goals in mind, ranging from the mitigation of near-term
risks around bias and toxic content generation to the assessment of longer-term
catastrophic risk potential. This makes it difficult for researchers and
practitioners to find the most relevant datasets for a given use case, and to
identify gaps in dataset coverage that future work may fill. To remedy these
issues, we conduct a first systematic review of open datasets for evaluating
and improving LLM safety. We review 102 datasets, which we identified through
an iterative and community-driven process over the course of several months. We
highlight patterns and trends, such as a a trend towards fully synthetic
datasets, as well as gaps in dataset coverage, such as a clear lack of
non-English datasets. We also examine how LLM safety datasets are used in
practice -- in LLM release publications and popular LLM benchmarks -- finding
that current evaluation practices are highly idiosyncratic and make use of only
a small fraction of available datasets. Our contributions are based on
SafetyPrompts.com, a living catalogue of open datasets for LLM safety, which we
commit to updating continuously as the field of LLM safety develops.
|
[
-0.2035352736711502,
-0.38833847641944885,
0.4943065941333771,
0.2380068451166153,
-0.1974749118089676,
-0.08204284310340881,
-0.23601387441158295,
-0.42443281412124634,
-0.06581325829029083,
0.5417922735214233,
-0.39558589458465576,
-0.8231499195098877,
-0.6860465407371521,
0.17032650113105774,
-0.48448655009269714,
1.0208683013916016,
-0.28849005699157715,
-0.019122853875160217,
-0.09519369155168533,
-0.0542183481156826,
-0.3314407467842102,
-0.6449218392372131,
-0.44813090562820435,
-0.0663163885474205,
0.9009242057800293,
0.33353278040885925,
0.6671965718269348,
0.5146622061729431,
0.8328672647476196,
0.1250903457403183,
-0.23765291273593903,
-0.050082821398973465,
-0.5395098924636841,
0.15184997022151947,
-0.14657412469387054,
0.03874018415808678,
-0.3796325922012329,
-0.07530377060174942,
0.5806242823600769,
1.009387493133545,
-0.41139769554138184,
-0.007855311967432499,
0.17439304292201996,
0.7100915312767029,
-0.853998064994812,
0.179372638463974,
-0.29259154200553894,
0.09787189960479736,
-0.3635700047016144,
-0.1287524402141571,
-0.3857915997505188,
-0.7314956188201904,
0.012883429415524006,
-0.31855347752571106,
-0.17368635535240173,
0.19983810186386108,
0.2707929313182831,
-0.018049392849206924,
-0.5953041315078735,
-0.2767811119556427,
-0.6083475947380066,
0.7825636863708496,
-0.6966626048088074,
0.4148136377334595,
0.14796201884746552,
0.4436625838279724,
-0.42398178577423096,
-0.4896325170993805,
-0.2928229868412018,
-0.2401079684495926,
0.1796271800994873,
-0.10127406567335129,
-0.0911543071269989,
0.01761484518647194,
0.2682441771030426,
0.30860280990600586,
-0.7451945543289185,
0.3942515552043915,
-0.4672331213951111,
-0.34554415941238403,
0.8967186212539673,
0.5739321708679199,
0.3678398132324219,
0.1772005707025528,
-0.34100016951560974,
-0.30016401410102844,
-1.405236005783081,
-0.2523403763771057,
0.44027817249298096,
0.3503349721431732,
-0.07142007350921631,
0.5719147324562073,
-0.30770060420036316,
0.5624009370803833,
-0.77858966588974,
-0.2672230899333954,
0.5290356278419495,
-0.37321537733078003,
-0.09964688867330551,
0.18226414918899536,
1.0134599208831787,
0.6904644966125488,
0.6201323866844177,
-0.22952046990394592,
-0.21729154884815216,
-0.015202243812382221,
0.14711618423461914,
-0.45937836170196533,
-0.11756289005279541,
0.37263214588165283,
-0.18994946777820587,
-0.3289315700531006,
0.10348504781723022,
-0.6152661442756653,
-0.5566993951797485,
-0.2648959457874298,
0.06300760060548782,
-0.1699119657278061,
-0.4796218276023865,
0.42165854573249817,
0.2666204869747162,
-0.04156002402305603,
0.20075653493404388,
-0.5788859724998474,
0.20862336456775665,
0.7445176243782043,
0.8215880990028381,
-0.3468707501888275,
-0.34308794140815735,
-0.15861289203166962,
0.21549232304096222,
-0.6267427206039429,
0.745668351650238,
-0.13240377604961395,
-0.47852805256843567,
0.4236716628074646,
0.18682189285755157,
0.07480284571647644,
-0.6439639925956726,
0.6419557332992554,
-0.23139415681362152,
0.012549659237265587,
-0.3700539171695709,
-0.3189614713191986,
0.04160666838288307,
0.1610967069864273,
-0.8042535781860352,
0.8455758094787598,
-0.2079695463180542,
-1.0019855499267578,
0.4518037438392639,
-0.35777953267097473,
-0.6034784317016602,
-0.2734540104866028,
-0.14795736968517303,
-0.39125296473503113,
-0.039516959339380264,
0.08684884756803513,
0.354513943195343,
-0.3808818459510803,
0.3702618479728699,
-0.6258306503295898,
-0.2345951795578003,
0.2777496576309204,
-0.40260714292526245,
0.7313836812973022,
0.19217637181282043,
0.056591521948575974,
0.29640212655067444,
-0.3941560387611389,
0.07074196636676788,
0.02831338159739971,
-0.35931676626205444,
-0.42347216606140137,
0.08793310075998306,
0.21097493171691895,
0.3613704741001129,
0.02763739787042141,
-0.4983656406402588,
-0.2215110808610916,
-0.2685036361217499,
0.21658563613891602,
0.7579514980316162,
0.28502732515335083,
0.2273445874452591,
-0.5737899541854858,
0.4009741544723511,
0.0764835998415947,
0.6207265257835388,
-0.07603023201227188,
-0.31680184602737427,
-0.47302958369255066,
0.007286092732101679,
0.2261560708284378,
0.47702792286872864,
-0.6003632545471191,
0.7420338988304138,
-0.2161744385957718,
-0.5763015747070312,
-0.2925921082496643,
-0.05083167925477028,
0.46101900935173035,
0.26347866654396057,
0.09509339183568954,
-0.45646438002586365,
-0.4337187111377716,
-0.9097949862480164,
-0.20971277356147766,
-0.19222241640090942,
-0.08123829960823059,
0.02112579718232155,
0.4515337646007538,
-0.11406151950359344,
0.7135952711105347,
-0.4309898614883423,
-0.19386926293373108,
-0.19545839726924896,
-0.14717712998390198,
0.20383046567440033,
0.4836145043373108,
0.4130076766014099,
-0.30313801765441895,
-0.4453049898147583,
-0.1971721649169922,
-0.9746586084365845,
-0.059140611439943314,
0.22140054404735565,
-0.14879846572875977,
0.3284775912761688,
0.5901487469673157,
-0.6140729784965515,
0.05389939993619919,
0.6209802627563477,
-0.08402737975120544,
0.5231009125709534,
0.07753772288560867,
-0.008100815117359161,
-0.7104012370109558,
0.18280017375946045,
0.1304461658000946,
0.07432609796524048,
-0.6158708930015564,
0.12002759426832199,
-0.01640561781823635,
0.08756547421216965,
-0.8192316293716431,
0.5121131539344788,
-0.3471038341522217,
0.07203888893127441,
-0.11526502668857574,
0.08494402468204498,
-0.2755202353000641,
-0.12796343863010406,
-0.045446109026670456,
0.7019967436790466,
0.8126177787780762,
-0.5508383512496948,
0.25783368945121765,
0.18094365298748016,
-0.8292618989944458,
0.2213224321603775,
-0.5834435224533081,
0.12172149866819382,
0.04798205941915512,
0.41082456707954407,
-0.47529202699661255,
-0.5251336693763733,
0.3713201880455017,
-0.00815244298428297,
0.1699107587337494,
0.0298377126455307,
-0.8140844106674194,
-0.48305681347846985,
-0.41328877210617065,
0.09050147235393524,
0.5513080358505249,
-0.312441349029541,
-0.03385606408119202,
0.8008024096488953,
-0.565385639667511,
-0.6882932186126709,
-0.492727667093277,
0.08679348230361938,
-0.30901068449020386,
-0.5132203698158264,
-0.25657904148101807,
-0.11794272810220718,
-0.5877189636230469,
-0.12897808849811554,
-0.3332335352897644,
-0.009671451523900032,
0.18843317031860352,
0.19448794424533844,
0.12281607836484909,
0.12144967913627625,
0.13084717094898224,
0.04953218251466751,
-0.4029942452907562,
0.4253053069114685,
0.10191913694143295,
0.3403681218624115,
0.08273319900035858,
-0.5384664535522461,
-0.17669636011123657,
0.3820521831512451,
0.42467668652534485,
-0.02555413730442524,
0.6712310314178467,
0.05758945643901825,
-0.34550976753234863,
-0.3821221590042114,
-0.28065717220306396,
-0.1953718215227127,
-0.4590708911418915,
0.25310322642326355,
0.05270841345191002,
-0.9194088578224182,
0.20425595343112946,
-0.12653285264968872,
0.3609614074230194,
0.17205597460269928,
0.6132907271385193,
-0.3126218020915985,
0.752334713935852,
0.4762933850288391,
-0.1780269891023636,
0.1956840455532074,
0.16210944950580597,
0.31910377740859985,
-0.4336335062980652,
-0.534598171710968,
-0.4160952568054199,
0.02970377914607525,
-0.4761086106300354,
-0.33592861890792847,
0.5906195640563965,
-0.1673426628112793,
-0.3608416020870209,
0.06214112415909767,
-0.10096821933984756,
0.5380901098251343,
0.23490935564041138,
0.20084305107593536,
0.4189911484718323,
0.03945838287472725,
-0.17202797532081604,
-0.11376272141933441,
-0.6566012501716614,
-0.6780433058738708,
1.2291415929794312,
0.5015364289283752,
1.1235953569412231,
0.041222039610147476,
0.6318089365959167,
0.17619022727012634,
0.48784101009368896,
-0.6116260886192322,
0.6946200728416443,
-0.21050365269184113,
-0.7550882697105408,
-0.246318519115448,
-0.5741989612579346,
-0.9795264005661011,
0.03307117149233818,
-0.07498826086521149,
-0.47888076305389404,
-0.06174657866358757,
0.13430730998516083,
-0.2545241713523865,
0.23565910756587982,
-0.47409525513648987,
0.6273900270462036,
-0.49144455790519714,
-0.40523761510849,
-0.03375325724482536,
-0.6929053664207458,
0.7205768823623657,
-0.3659207224845886,
0.42569851875305176,
-0.5037937164306641,
0.10006317496299744,
0.7675971388816833,
-0.320497989654541,
0.843897819519043,
-0.02705289050936699,
-0.4709550440311432,
0.32502204179763794,
0.08583307266235352,
0.3732156455516815,
-0.10779357701539993,
-0.16143164038658142,
0.4310971200466156,
-0.06947516649961472,
-0.2312900274991989,
-0.3265230059623718,
0.851306140422821,
-0.34982335567474365,
-0.5952403545379639,
-0.6411958336830139,
-0.4435366690158844,
-0.5123798251152039,
0.14303550124168396,
-0.0129054244607687,
0.23946914076805115,
-0.28973570466041565,
0.30289843678474426,
0.8053066730499268,
-0.5415633916854858,
0.3120148479938507,
0.6513758301734924,
-0.31769272685050964,
-0.36429867148399353,
0.706244707107544,
0.24398168921470642,
0.36351925134658813,
-0.055095940828323364,
0.07447142153978348,
-0.39567506313323975,
-0.9250943660736084,
-0.12342679500579834,
0.14411179721355438,
-0.8519973158836365,
-0.12848994135856628,
-0.35617318749427795,
-0.39389145374298096,
-0.3171527683734894,
0.12138061970472336,
-0.23239868879318237,
-0.1801941841840744,
-0.025436272844672203,
-0.3505685329437256,
0.4813133776187897,
0.949736475944519,
-0.2593524158000946,
0.05487646162509918,
-0.8069059252738953,
0.08614100515842438,
-0.060988929122686386,
0.688608705997467,
-0.17690584063529968,
-0.20976518094539642,
-0.28149160742759705,
-0.2273925542831421,
-0.09703218191862106,
-0.6563305258750916,
0.338094562292099,
-0.23801828920841217,
0.8050848841667175,
0.3680783212184906,
0.4307625889778137,
0.14490386843681335,
-0.6201022267341614,
0.5498075485229492,
0.4238821864128113,
-0.39280620217323303,
0.46097755432128906,
-0.6419118046760559,
-0.04308532923460007,
0.6968675255775452,
0.8640366196632385,
-0.6227040886878967,
-0.2671172022819519,
-0.16607099771499634,
-1.201136827468872,
0.46072936058044434,
0.2618192136287689,
0.029032332822680473,
-0.030031535774469376,
0.03621987998485565,
0.28001344203948975,
0.11910847574472427,
-0.5408816933631897,
-0.13987375795841217,
0.3273959457874298,
-0.40696170926094055,
-0.13333846628665924,
-0.23993617296218872,
-0.5890874862670898,
-0.020742904394865036,
0.6085850596427917,
-0.14400888979434967,
0.05137627571821213,
-0.16637128591537476,
-0.0015814058715477586,
-0.28383681178092957,
0.4424511790275574,
0.24157345294952393,
0.7493417859077454,
-0.24436861276626587,
0.258243203163147,
0.19684134423732758,
-0.5782491564750671,
0.2659038007259369,
-0.03986455127596855,
-0.15946798026561737,
-0.08237507939338684,
0.46959540247917175,
0.5049893856048584,
0.3899308443069458,
-1.0308873653411865,
0.4858062267303467,
0.12563663721084595,
-0.21463224291801453,
-0.48314908146858215,
0.39213666319847107,
0.0434066578745842,
-0.04324987530708313,
0.12411904335021973,
-0.20652851462364197,
0.02280876412987709,
-0.5851415395736694,
0.2762356102466583,
0.15145158767700195,
-0.23254646360874176,
-0.10200708359479904,
0.21827225387096405,
0.38017624616622925,
-0.16600103676319122,
0.5258284211158752,
0.3115449547767639,
0.007208986673504114,
0.5686081051826477,
0.11657926440238953,
0.7281734347343445,
-0.2406790405511856,
0.11042580753564835,
0.31243762373924255,
0.705366313457489,
-0.42908376455307007,
0.6077332496643066,
0.7113179564476013,
-0.4640142023563385,
-0.3449721336364746,
-0.618172824382782,
-0.6828697323799133,
0.4728791415691376,
-0.637553870677948,
0.3009668290615082,
-0.5806728005409241,
-0.09995388239622116,
-0.3816201984882355,
-0.26234057545661926,
-0.2745928466320038,
0.21292895078659058,
0.12269977480173111,
1.3425287008285522,
-1.1776481866836548,
0.6663309931755066,
0.5362955331802368,
-0.35779428482055664,
-0.5679426789283752,
0.283403605222702,
0.1949005424976349,
-0.42581555247306824,
0.19139666855335236,
0.2418537437915802,
0.18298092484474182,
-0.21971715986728668,
-0.616961658000946,
-0.8970084190368652,
1.0937583446502686,
0.5478891134262085,
-1.1702054738998413,
-0.0689624771475792,
0.4939054846763611,
0.4561574161052704,
-0.21194832026958466,
-0.090764120221138,
0.69694584608078,
0.5213505625724792,
-0.16390497982501984,
-1.0808088779449463,
0.10912993550300598,
-0.0920398160815239,
-0.2037515491247177,
0.08201109617948532,
-0.5700232982635498,
0.5468186736106873,
-0.24724160134792328,
-0.25533950328826904,
-0.012136311270296574,
0.16234639286994934,
0.6436793804168701,
0.5709264874458313,
0.4763670265674591,
0.6571246385574341,
0.5573428869247437,
-0.22291299700737,
1.2532213926315308,
-0.1180676594376564,
0.27060389518737793,
1.2336519956588745,
-0.7196583151817322,
0.9821617007255554,
0.3275790214538574,
-0.3587372303009033,
0.18309767544269562,
0.8154420256614685,
0.1867445558309555,
0.7052701115608215,
0.370548814535141,
-0.39053380489349365,
-0.393607497215271,
-0.12687823176383972,
-0.4528466463088989,
0.08249007910490036,
0.45043855905532837,
-0.5326417684555054,
-0.4080785810947418,
0.02632872574031353,
0.11640720814466476,
-0.12275034189224243,
-0.13456153869628906,
0.7678065896034241,
0.330220103263855,
-0.3938676416873932,
0.4360203444957733,
-0.2515406310558319,
0.2573617398738861,
-0.6719784140586853,
0.1186881735920906,
-0.3124529719352722,
0.13871259987354279,
-0.2223719209432602,
-1.3651543855667114,
0.3711758852005005,
0.17086003720760345,
0.12026043236255646,
-0.2706751525402069,
0.6861451268196106,
-0.21495811641216278,
-0.4073646664619446,
0.4294963777065277,
0.5300915241241455,
0.3646546006202698,
0.013906764797866344,
-0.45733657479286194,
0.48514828085899353,
-0.44498518109321594,
-0.31200626492500305,
0.5376610159873962,
0.24697628617286682,
-0.3259190022945404,
0.7067487835884094,
0.628653347492218,
0.0885751023888588,
0.045717570930719376,
0.20266608893871307,
1.162548542022705,
-0.6846727132797241,
-0.2789830267429352,
-0.5359316468238831,
0.5759328007698059,
0.05207274854183197,
-0.3419400155544281,
0.6946117281913757,
0.4768678545951843,
0.8120376467704773,
-0.012241299264132977,
1.1205979585647583,
0.01478336937725544,
0.5938045978546143,
-0.7483393549919128,
0.9962813854217529,
-0.28144219517707825,
0.3620973527431488,
-0.09005042165517807,
-0.8160695433616638,
-0.5769762396812439,
0.33891481161117554,
-0.4474204182624817,
0.14072643220424652,
0.8175493478775024,
0.928974986076355,
0.10788387060165405,
-0.0030840926337987185,
0.34040069580078125,
0.30875930190086365,
0.18318800628185272,
0.6195258498191833,
1.032460331916809,
-0.2368428111076355,
0.44994181394577026,
-0.25117358565330505,
-0.08601299673318863,
-0.2548378109931946,
-1.092206358909607,
-0.8097467422485352,
-0.2988538146018982,
-0.4030506908893585,
-0.30154865980148315,
0.4994734525680542,
0.8490658402442932,
0.5987516045570374,
-0.9145241379737854,
-0.22701850533485413,
-0.14279797673225403,
-0.03269949182868004,
0.0953272357583046,
-0.16936975717544556,
0.16761769354343414,
-0.11235948652029037,
-0.33751922845840454,
0.6100594997406006,
0.18094973266124725,
0.02842773124575615,
-0.4754960834980011,
-0.24856813251972198,
0.0716797262430191,
-0.07120087742805481,
0.5993428826332092,
0.37523582577705383,
-0.5215250849723816,
-0.27803561091423035,
-0.2381599247455597,
-0.29582375288009644,
-0.2271628975868225,
0.7345454692840576,
-0.26329928636550903,
0.16430826485157013,
0.5903013348579407,
0.39648735523223877,
-0.03583225980401039,
-0.48066797852516174,
0.5011040568351746,
-0.5353162884712219,
-0.08976496756076813,
0.26458483934402466,
0.5117537379264832,
0.41398847103118896,
-0.14875778555870056,
0.7103976607322693,
0.15123409032821655,
-0.4329318106174469,
-1.093553066253662,
0.18333423137664795,
-0.8901885747909546,
-0.14757613837718964,
1.462440013885498,
-0.2727218568325043,
-0.2048957794904709,
-0.4185018539428711,
-0.03212472051382065,
0.026640137657523155,
-0.28926652669906616,
0.925652801990509,
0.5068562626838684,
-0.09593039751052856,
-0.07275674492120743,
-0.8532757759094238,
0.48658329248428345,
-0.046586405485868454,
-1.1925586462020874,
0.46834930777549744,
0.6795669198036194,
0.6163496375083923,
-0.1575402170419693,
0.5285884737968445,
-0.4320671558380127,
0.2671809792518616,
-0.1350819617509842,
0.15992823243141174,
0.01000753790140152,
-0.7552623748779297,
-0.44261568784713745,
0.1845332682132721,
0.10376253724098206,
0.2410270869731903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05365v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05365v2
|
NLP Progress in Indigenous Latin American Languages
| 2024-04-08T10:04:55 | 2024-05-12T13:39:42 |
Atnafu Lambebo Tonja, Fazlourrahman Balouchzahi, Sabur Butt, Olga Kolesnikova, Hector Ceballos, Alexander Gelbukh, Thamar Solorio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The paper focuses on the marginalization of indigenous language communities
in the face of rapid technological advancements. We highlight the cultural
richness of these languages and the risk they face of being overlooked in the
realm of Natural Language Processing (NLP). We aim to bridge the gap between
these communities and researchers, emphasizing the need for inclusive
technological advancements that respect indigenous community perspectives. We
show the NLP progress of indigenous Latin American languages and the survey
that covers the status of indigenous languages in Latin America, their
representation in NLP, and the challenges and innovations required for their
preservation and development. The paper contributes to the current literature
in understanding the need and progress of NLP for indigenous communities of
Latin America, specifically low-resource and indigenous communities in general.
|
[
-0.18317043781280518,
-0.4005184769630432,
0.19714514911174774,
0.5226634740829468,
0.1342255026102066,
0.7545360326766968,
-0.40599188208580017,
-0.8414520621299744,
0.6112855076789856,
0.6203582882881165,
-0.2961709797382355,
-0.47848039865493774,
-0.776972234249115,
0.39559847116470337,
-0.21014587581157684,
0.5670676231384277,
0.13435491919517517,
-0.3069002628326416,
0.04108727350831032,
-0.34174633026123047,
-0.6452500820159912,
-0.21401181817054749,
-0.7169580459594727,
-0.09868331253528595,
0.416058212518692,
0.34191060066223145,
0.9208977818489075,
0.7314635515213013,
0.6089787483215332,
0.29069164395332336,
-0.49306586384773254,
-0.1709931641817093,
0.05471164733171463,
0.44690388441085815,
-0.3119553327560425,
-0.4286021590232849,
-0.33091866970062256,
-0.40052586793899536,
0.7967941761016846,
1.0268099308013916,
-0.02964063547551632,
0.35314616560935974,
-0.05550381541252136,
0.8495206236839294,
-0.33691397309303284,
0.13619381189346313,
-0.5557968616485596,
0.3830280601978302,
-0.6075311899185181,
-0.20198224484920502,
-0.14676736295223236,
-0.6579119563102722,
0.061713434755802155,
-0.16278760135173798,
0.22225801646709442,
-0.0482313297688961,
0.175222709774971,
0.44787076115608215,
0.03323404863476753,
-0.1436588615179062,
-0.8813731670379639,
0.7618759274482727,
-0.6482309103012085,
0.1388300210237503,
0.44164398312568665,
0.044187240302562714,
-0.09710259735584259,
-0.522800862789154,
-0.3445136547088623,
0.005299121607095003,
0.11598987132310867,
-0.19509652256965637,
-0.3675180971622467,
-0.24720752239227295,
0.2477971315383911,
0.3598037660121918,
-0.689831554889679,
0.5082129240036011,
-0.8948716521263123,
-0.06075107306241989,
0.5457789301872253,
-0.07774119079113007,
0.27976641058921814,
0.009092072956264019,
-0.008256019093096256,
0.21984051167964935,
-0.8346312046051025,
-0.132687047123909,
0.3182593584060669,
0.5356981754302979,
0.19528372585773468,
0.4798630177974701,
-0.17897988855838776,
0.8618813157081604,
-0.6724399924278259,
-0.16495230793952942,
0.3970063626766205,
-0.3062106966972351,
-0.05435165390372276,
-0.04570569097995758,
0.5974829196929932,
-0.11889650672674179,
-0.2753850221633911,
-0.25171133875846863,
-0.03193512558937073,
-0.034308720380067825,
0.00002159086216124706,
-0.15314121544361115,
0.35910969972610474,
0.24346469342708588,
-0.3670978844165802,
0.12192797660827637,
-0.11527646332979202,
-0.8088164925575256,
-0.1848393827676773,
-0.15091091394424438,
-0.15601366758346558,
-0.04346068948507309,
-0.5974233150482178,
0.2183123230934143,
-0.3595479726791382,
0.20692399144172668,
0.350653737783432,
-1.0299913883209229,
0.47338804602622986,
0.8913264274597168,
0.9812312126159668,
0.007092270068824291,
-0.18718235194683075,
-0.07951412349939346,
-0.158264622092247,
-0.0676974207162857,
0.7613878846168518,
-0.6532139182090759,
-0.3350858986377716,
0.2995802164077759,
-0.13504359126091003,
-0.08705141395330429,
-0.7727058529853821,
0.9494550824165344,
-0.38802433013916016,
-0.15288323163986206,
-0.4149613678455353,
0.04100460186600685,
0.05849083513021469,
0.08152114599943161,
-0.660241961479187,
0.9721150398254395,
0.2208406627178192,
-0.5506429672241211,
0.2169625610113144,
-0.7288826704025269,
-0.31088507175445557,
0.5340848565101624,
0.11509224027395248,
-0.1381193846464157,
0.22451750934123993,
-0.013856981880962849,
0.02509373426437378,
-0.13872464001178741,
0.04872947558760643,
-0.10329589992761612,
-0.40279388427734375,
0.09368868917226791,
-0.2871624231338501,
1.0808770656585693,
0.40016767382621765,
-0.469023197889328,
-0.17054706811904907,
-0.46561169624328613,
-0.026870710775256157,
-0.14386825263500214,
-0.41392308473587036,
-0.4633534848690033,
0.21118655800819397,
-0.012880404479801655,
0.2933402955532074,
0.4247722029685974,
-0.6212835311889648,
0.30316081643104553,
-0.32627978920936584,
0.45030295848846436,
0.39816826581954956,
-0.38699963688850403,
0.5184245109558105,
-0.05285532772541046,
0.7507035136222839,
-0.4732285141944885,
0.3707655072212219,
-0.2298375815153122,
-0.8539695143699646,
-0.8043539524078369,
0.34817343950271606,
0.542422890663147,
0.5830390453338623,
-0.634672224521637,
0.45772725343704224,
-0.2660130262374878,
-0.18433353304862976,
-0.8444210290908813,
0.23342882096767426,
0.08239748328924179,
0.27382490038871765,
0.4279225170612335,
-0.48066145181655884,
-0.7166326642036438,
-0.6394292116165161,
-0.0380079410970211,
-0.3990800678730011,
-0.19541962444782257,
-0.13053616881370544,
0.2718333899974823,
-0.21706999838352203,
0.8625356554985046,
-0.2690124213695526,
-0.5569453835487366,
-0.441397100687027,
0.2888970673084259,
0.15753693878650665,
0.6553391814231873,
0.4302199184894562,
-0.7066128849983215,
-0.5086072683334351,
0.28167498111724854,
-0.566171407699585,
-0.20002031326293945,
0.3094702661037445,
0.22129878401756287,
0.20862363278865814,
0.42904117703437805,
-0.16732151806354523,
0.4098561704158783,
0.6559241414070129,
-0.4669298231601715,
-0.0013700127601623535,
-0.14540991187095642,
-0.00570362014696002,
-0.5156744122505188,
0.07271739840507507,
-0.13189880549907684,
-0.12531563639640808,
-0.6426709294319153,
0.09997177124023438,
-0.4620453715324402,
-0.15534614026546478,
-0.33427467942237854,
0.4743007719516754,
-0.4642755091190338,
-0.19697993993759155,
-0.45015937089920044,
0.1771339774131775,
-0.30018654465675354,
-0.15129615366458893,
0.5141690969467163,
0.4031497836112976,
0.49188801646232605,
-0.34970930218696594,
0.04445728659629822,
0.13788338005542755,
0.13512833416461945,
0.33137816190719604,
-0.7145259976387024,
0.06211814284324646,
-0.032618992030620575,
0.05889292061328888,
-0.2714097201824188,
0.1737917959690094,
0.11428060382604599,
-0.5808672308921814,
0.16768261790275574,
-0.2520172595977783,
-0.40836310386657715,
-0.6091731786727905,
-0.22226065397262573,
0.3638518154621124,
0.450179785490036,
-0.048898402601480484,
0.08205857127904892,
0.6374856233596802,
-0.7398626208305359,
-0.9653148055076599,
-0.7892817854881287,
0.6474117040634155,
-0.24484269320964813,
-0.6879621744155884,
0.1628471463918686,
0.12709148228168488,
-0.7189314961433411,
-0.21306495368480682,
0.37454596161842346,
-0.18421301245689392,
0.21011783182621002,
-0.12593038380146027,
-0.05557086318731308,
-0.3358953893184662,
0.26051703095436096,
0.2927726209163666,
-0.05504954978823662,
0.19998900592327118,
-0.4316585659980774,
0.7002580165863037,
-0.3693472445011139,
-0.015314064919948578,
-0.10645794868469238,
0.8548129200935364,
0.08329267799854279,
-0.21168453991413116,
0.8910036683082581,
0.6428386569023132,
-0.4600977599620819,
0.12029877305030823,
-0.6999248266220093,
0.294295072555542,
-0.39589324593544006,
-0.016181349754333496,
0.13463281095027924,
-1.178020715713501,
0.6859856247901917,
-0.05815623700618744,
0.015699727460741997,
0.711539089679718,
0.15713801980018616,
0.1373978853225708,
0.2351251244544983,
1.1371780633926392,
-0.1356804519891739,
0.3261980712413788,
-0.2589825391769409,
0.119498111307621,
-0.9263831973075867,
-0.27176961302757263,
-1.3669772148132324,
-0.21687495708465576,
-0.6443080306053162,
-0.659974217414856,
0.027113884687423706,
-0.11886505037546158,
0.3129906952381134,
0.6570261716842651,
-0.6507769823074341,
0.4719846844673157,
0.8372622728347778,
-0.26703739166259766,
0.7559953331947327,
-0.14702662825584412,
0.29754477739334106,
-0.40039581060409546,
-0.7069075107574463,
-0.6779060959815979,
0.8111874461174011,
0.4742480516433716,
0.49324098229408264,
0.21721483767032623,
0.8439670205116272,
0.7632908821105957,
0.26632338762283325,
-0.5828043818473816,
0.19531932473182678,
-0.0027351516764611006,
-0.481538325548172,
-0.40686577558517456,
-0.25480467081069946,
-1.2968635559082031,
0.08837565779685974,
-0.1206108033657074,
-0.7808319926261902,
0.5962828397750854,
-0.1122267097234726,
-0.1923578828573227,
0.30680128931999207,
-0.6271851062774658,
0.7628435492515564,
-0.013066908344626427,
-0.21012942492961884,
-0.21478502452373505,
-0.9395284652709961,
0.16085931658744812,
0.027585161849856377,
0.4029579162597656,
-0.015413230285048485,
-0.15224550664424896,
0.6969969272613525,
-0.341964989900589,
0.7751663327217102,
-0.19968338310718536,
-0.08183404803276062,
0.5756155252456665,
-0.1014387309551239,
0.06020481139421463,
0.09085623174905777,
-0.15947456657886505,
0.21953080594539642,
-0.368145614862442,
-0.6175408959388733,
-0.11151603609323502,
0.6026788949966431,
-0.3604239821434021,
-0.5284104943275452,
-0.6562485694885254,
-0.14391280710697174,
0.2070692777633667,
0.12145508825778961,
-0.0634813904762268,
-0.15380284190177917,
-0.32574254274368286,
0.0270310677587986,
0.710459291934967,
-0.3576304614543915,
0.8713961839675903,
0.40118977427482605,
-0.10237479209899902,
-0.2482832670211792,
0.8541381359100342,
0.2133595049381256,
0.27934569120407104,
0.3860556483268738,
-0.061460189521312714,
-0.2815779447555542,
-1.0285561084747314,
-0.21980226039886475,
0.18615175783634186,
-0.49003732204437256,
-0.2415238320827484,
-0.6877954602241516,
-0.044556763023138046,
-0.6351370811462402,
-0.27738499641418457,
-0.27409645915031433,
-0.6929023265838623,
-0.2786462903022766,
-0.03284887596964836,
-0.03729381039738655,
0.9434736967086792,
-0.40971869230270386,
0.26416122913360596,
-0.7044859528541565,
-0.018418921157717705,
0.30937132239341736,
0.13231226801872253,
-0.16770359873771667,
-0.3176197111606598,
-0.33616238832473755,
-0.13613104820251465,
-0.34686610102653503,
-0.37038978934288025,
0.5036543607711792,
0.1906253844499588,
0.3300635814666748,
0.14132121205329895,
0.19510146975517273,
0.36613497138023376,
-0.305101603269577,
0.848784863948822,
0.14425772428512573,
-0.884569525718689,
0.9483451247215271,
-0.24653510749340057,
0.5432949066162109,
0.6611423492431641,
0.2918780446052551,
-1.0203146934509277,
-0.7614012956619263,
-0.8721503615379333,
-1.1446987390518188,
0.509573221206665,
0.22158050537109375,
0.3021867871284485,
-0.17776185274124146,
-0.2637712061405182,
0.2916884422302246,
0.2405136227607727,
-1.0753573179244995,
-0.11086293309926987,
-0.22532965242862701,
0.3765909969806671,
0.25047388672828674,
0.05067046359181404,
-0.046800579875707626,
-0.23826205730438232,
0.17318707704544067,
-0.14914359152317047,
0.46566733717918396,
0.17677445709705353,
-0.1465371698141098,
-0.11190023273229599,
0.5527560710906982,
0.7243907451629639,
0.8422401547431946,
-0.25631478428840637,
0.13046032190322876,
0.027695195749402046,
-0.693413257598877,
-0.11602029949426651,
0.045516278594732285,
-0.5747041702270508,
0.3784486949443817,
0.4292030930519104,
0.6518593430519104,
-0.22535981237888336,
-0.48562538623809814,
0.2809186279773712,
-0.3157421946525574,
0.05095098167657852,
-0.6666097044944763,
-0.05926340073347092,
-0.06372740119695663,
0.1545025110244751,
0.9791557192802429,
0.6771608591079712,
0.14601390063762665,
-0.6553477644920349,
-0.28485751152038574,
0.2609301805496216,
-0.43078550696372986,
-0.37322503328323364,
0.6510424017906189,
0.35791832208633423,
-0.5908482670783997,
0.350291907787323,
-0.2153959423303604,
-0.4166395962238312,
0.5926620364189148,
0.593542754650116,
0.9722017049789429,
0.020620791241526604,
0.4452730417251587,
0.437635213136673,
0.7949534058570862,
-0.15911778807640076,
0.0721253976225853,
-0.226375013589859,
-0.3908389210700989,
-0.6360291242599487,
-0.7818190455436707,
-0.5470163226127625,
-0.15334075689315796,
-0.33414068818092346,
0.17469698190689087,
-0.37077900767326355,
-0.3352656364440918,
-0.29250970482826233,
0.04031878709793091,
-0.26400789618492126,
-0.08769446611404419,
0.3585676848888397,
0.9472739100456238,
-0.8857448101043701,
0.6211618781089783,
0.16829222440719604,
-0.31696459650993347,
-0.00026356990565545857,
-0.06342238187789917,
-0.22792981564998627,
-0.3626961410045624,
0.5637883543968201,
-0.051246095448732376,
0.010565993376076221,
-0.21505963802337646,
-0.32852867245674133,
-0.9709667563438416,
0.8420090675354004,
0.43035703897476196,
-0.11779296398162842,
0.21450674533843994,
0.37669339776039124,
0.9885360598564148,
-0.2650291919708252,
0.1552359163761139,
0.5147585868835449,
0.6753525137901306,
-0.033567365258932114,
-0.990462601184845,
-0.22815504670143127,
-0.30496805906295776,
0.24047787487506866,
0.15371350944042206,
-0.686428427696228,
0.5805191397666931,
-0.07593122869729996,
-0.25058963894844055,
-0.05049867555499077,
0.9457822442054749,
-0.03703952208161354,
0.3425114154815674,
0.025242649018764496,
0.4587450921535492,
0.5631234645843506,
-0.46559596061706543,
0.7850746512413025,
0.27575430274009705,
-0.15047518908977509,
0.854452908039093,
-0.07313381135463715,
0.9120188355445862,
0.5130587816238403,
-0.6374402046203613,
0.45085087418556213,
0.3578958213329315,
0.2362476885318756,
-0.10715146362781525,
0.17618650197982788,
-0.6732627153396606,
0.23156307637691498,
-0.5857551693916321,
-0.590165376663208,
0.40133416652679443,
0.5940720438957214,
-0.29651668667793274,
0.03260671719908714,
-0.11154939234256744,
0.1634710282087326,
0.44595685601234436,
-0.46311506628990173,
0.404843270778656,
-0.008836920373141766,
-0.8901451826095581,
0.43644416332244873,
0.03217413276433945,
0.9378717541694641,
-0.5065802335739136,
0.062386997044086456,
-0.35102805495262146,
-0.27871787548065186,
-0.47710904479026794,
-0.611796498298645,
1.0935295820236206,
0.13138116896152496,
-0.13956885039806366,
-0.4495997130870819,
0.66558837890625,
-0.29671749472618103,
-0.3303225338459015,
0.43141669034957886,
0.5640016794204712,
0.08767838776111603,
0.1373433917760849,
-0.4495387673377991,
0.19035372138023376,
0.013697135262191296,
0.3483067452907562,
0.361130028963089,
0.20010940730571747,
-0.1818103939294815,
0.5795281529426575,
0.43806344270706177,
0.5294995307922363,
0.5035756826400757,
0.15667131543159485,
0.6708210110664368,
-0.7591536045074463,
-0.058933280408382416,
-0.5923706889152527,
0.433520644903183,
-0.2670571506023407,
-0.4707735776901245,
0.6304928660392761,
0.4757898449897766,
0.8476830720901489,
-0.030752506107091904,
0.6868533492088318,
-0.6774621605873108,
0.5949405431747437,
-0.2436579465866089,
0.5670694708824158,
-0.024703871458768845,
0.4479266107082367,
-0.4274516701698303,
-0.9544181227684021,
-0.7959708571434021,
0.33046871423721313,
0.12207502126693726,
-0.26019495725631714,
0.6680771112442017,
0.30447959899902344,
0.28165900707244873,
-0.07377104461193085,
0.14566968381404877,
-0.11591289937496185,
0.08007912337779999,
0.09938028454780579,
0.545719563961029,
-0.4695110619068146,
0.32941851019859314,
-0.4335956275463104,
-0.22773431241512299,
0.13079532980918884,
-0.7646496295928955,
-0.3172670304775238,
-0.5168909430503845,
-0.5213431119918823,
-0.12577983736991882,
-0.1781768500804901,
0.7309884428977966,
0.15548662841320038,
-0.7537218928337097,
-0.5720371007919312,
0.01668352074921131,
0.740881621837616,
-0.48905906081199646,
-0.22764405608177185,
-0.04743541404604912,
-0.35995206236839294,
-1.0258302688598633,
0.48560991883277893,
0.7174813747406006,
0.1199590414762497,
-0.5579466819763184,
0.0005198260769248009,
-0.48715487122535706,
-0.45411446690559387,
0.7397230267524719,
1.1533113718032837,
-0.4484792649745941,
-0.004300369415432215,
0.09283403307199478,
0.20296134054660797,
0.27726560831069946,
0.8394395112991333,
-0.9418781399726868,
0.2673848569393158,
0.48415887355804443,
0.43438461422920227,
0.4560261368751526,
-0.36037036776542664,
0.6119982600212097,
-0.886507511138916,
0.41820940375328064,
0.8135932683944702,
0.23033507168293,
0.6335915923118591,
-0.013156497851014137,
0.7697401642799377,
0.40243464708328247,
-0.6460737586021423,
-0.7835878133773804,
0.24657833576202393,
-0.9122382402420044,
0.18891912698745728,
0.6813099980354309,
-0.06428107619285583,
-0.22428414225578308,
-0.8182525634765625,
-0.03268171101808548,
-0.011881531216204166,
-0.4147305488586426,
0.8222554326057434,
0.41971760988235474,
-0.07629431784152985,
-0.2505508363246918,
-0.3926743268966675,
0.4988308548927307,
0.12998488545417786,
-0.7081851959228516,
0.025796115398406982,
0.2531723976135254,
-0.33558985590934753,
0.7389616966247559,
0.9302018880844116,
-0.4026573598384857,
0.015061112120747566,
0.08693056553602219,
-0.05760503187775612,
0.6979089975357056,
-0.23345842957496643,
-0.43701326847076416,
0.2328956574201584,
0.43978768587112427,
0.4347771406173706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05337v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05337v1
|
Towards Objectively Benchmarking Social Intelligence for Language Agents at Action Level
| 2024-04-08T09:25:32 | 2024-04-08T09:25:32 |
Chenxu Wang, Bin Dai, Huaping Liu, Baoyuan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Prominent large language models have exhibited human-level performance in
many domains, even enabling the derived agents to simulate human and social
interactions. While practical works have substantiated the practicability of
grounding language agents in sandbox simulation or embodied simulators, current
social intelligence benchmarks either stay at the language level or use
subjective metrics. In pursuit of a more realistic and objective evaluation, we
introduce the Social Tasks in Sandbox Simulation (STSS) benchmark, which
assesses language agents \textbf{objectively} at the \textbf{action level} by
scrutinizing the goal achievements within the multi-agent simulation.
Additionally, we sample conversation scenarios to build a language-level
benchmark to provide an economically prudent preliminary evaluation and align
with prevailing benchmarks. To gauge the significance of agent architecture, we
implement a target-driven planning (TDP) module as an adjunct to the existing
agent. Our evaluative findings highlight that the STSS benchmark is challenging
for state-of-the-art language agents. Furthermore, it effectively discriminates
between distinct language agents, suggesting its usefulness as a benchmark for
evaluating both language models and agent architectures.
|
[
0.004359468352049589,
-0.7652537226676941,
0.5256665349006653,
0.290893018245697,
0.012633002363145351,
0.6261749267578125,
-0.36480823159217834,
-0.16299551725387573,
0.03053274378180504,
0.13811878859996796,
-0.41674113273620605,
-0.6595839858055115,
-0.5312253832817078,
-0.19242285192012787,
-0.41268622875213623,
0.6233459711074829,
0.20112773776054382,
-0.21760186553001404,
-0.4378345310688019,
-0.18159867823123932,
-0.16619034111499786,
-0.5040165185928345,
-1.00384521484375,
-0.46765774488449097,
0.3693927824497223,
0.3163997232913971,
0.785801887512207,
0.6044984459877014,
0.31616923213005066,
0.44978493452072144,
0.08794502913951874,
0.03275168314576149,
-0.7270955443382263,
0.18005771934986115,
-0.35673218965530396,
-0.21990668773651123,
-0.5776840448379517,
0.047038961201906204,
0.8519910573959351,
0.5733639597892761,
-0.19671028852462769,
0.3867659866809845,
-0.05792419984936714,
0.3999391198158264,
-0.7724878191947937,
0.419307678937912,
-0.6460108757019043,
-0.19781357049942017,
0.11623264104127884,
0.03759108483791351,
-0.4093632996082306,
-0.23932009935379028,
-0.13990384340286255,
-0.08680634945631027,
0.09578303247690201,
-0.06763246655464172,
0.8089413046836853,
0.12189455330371857,
-0.1873398721218109,
0.1448851078748703,
-0.8128705024719238,
0.759496808052063,
-0.41406306624412537,
0.3979596197605133,
0.18889667093753815,
0.5109254717826843,
0.012618196196854115,
-0.3242793679237366,
-0.27334797382354736,
-0.5491475462913513,
0.11529295146465302,
-0.045005083084106445,
-0.2334657609462738,
-0.13089586794376373,
0.3190930485725403,
-0.32017776370048523,
-0.49083536863327026,
-0.32606083154678345,
-0.24980853497982025,
0.00045194983249530196,
0.9326775074005127,
0.15896020829677582,
0.13733115792274475,
-0.060859210789203644,
-0.2987290918827057,
-0.3023916482925415,
-0.36587613821029663,
0.2202983796596527,
0.27523475885391235,
0.3414669632911682,
-0.3060593903064728,
0.3876500725746155,
-0.608552098274231,
0.02854047529399395,
-0.1504094898700714,
0.13918805122375488,
0.3542488217353821,
-0.31894639134407043,
0.17803660035133362,
-0.15230053663253784,
0.5534330010414124,
0.44308581948280334,
0.595377504825592,
-0.5795803070068359,
-0.4686890244483948,
0.5031118392944336,
0.6770544052124023,
-0.5541767477989197,
0.14277562499046326,
0.2178034782409668,
-0.25435447692871094,
-0.31636500358581543,
-0.19083631038665771,
-0.40768542885780334,
-0.1841755360364914,
-0.21214714646339417,
0.18587662279605865,
-0.3966307044029236,
-0.5730421543121338,
-0.08225477486848831,
-0.3320169150829315,
0.45454782247543335,
0.1584216058254242,
-0.4242209792137146,
0.9191123843193054,
0.9887933731079102,
0.6115259528160095,
-0.21900220215320587,
-0.7517577409744263,
-0.609614372253418,
0.3525030016899109,
-0.4725528955459595,
1.1641877889633179,
-0.6032825708389282,
-0.29727703332901,
0.12170617282390594,
-0.2955622375011444,
-0.048836879432201385,
-0.4469658434391022,
0.3372451066970825,
-0.17782577872276306,
-0.5884949564933777,
-0.34725627303123474,
-0.2835579216480255,
0.23403066396713257,
0.6256749033927917,
-0.20829150080680847,
1.2567548751831055,
0.3297556936740875,
0.01461923960596323,
0.44769221544265747,
-0.4834078252315521,
-0.5462102890014648,
0.24381013214588165,
-0.45087480545043945,
-0.03745877742767334,
0.14930517971515656,
-0.3052145838737488,
0.6596179604530334,
-0.43624213337898254,
0.6231959462165833,
-0.3753480017185211,
-0.5601897239685059,
0.3331955373287201,
-0.24307498335838318,
0.3890644609928131,
-0.06922947615385056,
-0.6421343684196472,
0.28780749440193176,
-0.5616210699081421,
0.27418455481529236,
0.2148423194885254,
-0.022396665066480637,
-0.19982470571994781,
0.424559086561203,
-0.13502071797847748,
0.23544619977474213,
0.20716096460819244,
-0.5598434209823608,
-0.19790436327457428,
-0.06615009158849716,
0.1752697378396988,
0.9344788789749146,
-0.219217911362648,
0.49114271998405457,
-0.5052630305290222,
0.3711276352405548,
-0.4268868863582611,
0.5030118227005005,
0.6472311019897461,
-0.2664588987827301,
-0.4742353558540344,
-0.16666387021541595,
-0.016289973631501198,
0.2970708906650543,
-0.5815637707710266,
0.31803539395332336,
-0.6709160804748535,
-0.955769419670105,
-0.33050352334976196,
0.020634187385439873,
0.8485227823257446,
-0.037815604358911514,
0.0748138576745987,
-0.4126631021499634,
0.0481596477329731,
-0.9123262763023376,
-0.46887513995170593,
-0.5789904594421387,
0.21615451574325562,
0.46336835622787476,
0.48933538794517517,
-0.003123989561572671,
0.8012755513191223,
-0.1733664572238922,
0.19039727747440338,
-0.6250436902046204,
0.1083279475569725,
-0.2135147899389267,
0.42347100377082825,
0.5835742354393005,
-0.6941058039665222,
-0.46242114901542664,
-0.049193479120731354,
-0.6356909275054932,
-0.2797147035598755,
0.24756190180778503,
-0.3024134933948517,
0.06250270456075668,
0.46489474177360535,
-0.7736773490905762,
0.4884492754936218,
0.3195331394672394,
-0.42942288517951965,
0.49213624000549316,
-0.1296740025281906,
0.31412723660469055,
-0.7342361807823181,
0.21385712921619415,
0.053454626351594925,
-0.18683701753616333,
-0.7101592421531677,
0.17037974298000336,
0.12915921211242676,
-0.13242696225643158,
-0.5775997042655945,
0.8066070079803467,
-0.3256070613861084,
-0.562215268611908,
-0.08104057610034943,
0.293617308139801,
-0.2199205607175827,
0.5975981950759888,
-0.021129246801137924,
0.6529191732406616,
0.4167923629283905,
-0.4636181592941284,
0.30923929810523987,
-0.15932103991508484,
-0.2146894335746765,
0.7399695515632629,
-0.9839298725128174,
0.19720491766929626,
-0.10751643776893616,
0.07985527813434601,
-0.8053574562072754,
0.06815508008003235,
0.21451815962791443,
-0.48738181591033936,
-0.03240645304322243,
0.037009380757808685,
-0.6423593759536743,
-0.1275842785835266,
-0.4336048662662506,
0.33756789565086365,
0.716025710105896,
0.07555027306079865,
0.9468133449554443,
0.570641815662384,
0.005150637123733759,
-0.4830663800239563,
-0.2733566164970398,
0.01829155534505844,
-0.07605203241109848,
-0.5296081900596619,
0.3699333369731903,
0.020436886698007584,
-0.621445894241333,
0.1503896564245224,
-0.12768378853797913,
0.1616355925798416,
0.2568559944629669,
0.4274221956729889,
-0.015658028423786163,
-0.1126711517572403,
-0.19716612994670868,
0.0026231214869767427,
-0.2742193341255188,
0.32510557770729065,
0.3232099115848541,
0.7817636728286743,
-0.28069475293159485,
-0.5230240225791931,
-0.08012233674526215,
0.4279179275035858,
0.4453936517238617,
-0.32125216722488403,
0.4885762929916382,
0.2335367500782013,
-0.474269837141037,
-0.42040789127349854,
-0.7619263529777527,
0.01980789192020893,
-0.46507036685943604,
0.4671432375907898,
-0.5502147674560547,
-0.24777662754058838,
0.5031202435493469,
-0.21598593890666962,
0.1778048872947693,
0.13112738728523254,
0.2219424843788147,
0.21231693029403687,
1.0858830213546753,
0.3578980267047882,
-0.16668269038200378,
0.5294550061225891,
-0.1763528734445572,
0.04914966598153114,
-0.576980471611023,
-0.1989063173532486,
-0.8303319811820984,
-0.28356102108955383,
-0.09598714113235474,
-0.6828318238258362,
0.07166677713394165,
-0.33571088314056396,
-0.37503939867019653,
0.5789921879768372,
-0.2667960524559021,
0.5299877524375916,
0.5352281928062439,
0.01835956797003746,
-0.09635845571756363,
-0.05659259855747223,
0.08281707018613815,
0.5169419646263123,
-0.524145781993866,
-0.8364071846008301,
0.8764694929122925,
0.1617344617843628,
0.4653758704662323,
0.016741760075092316,
0.8167082667350769,
0.67629474401474,
0.567929744720459,
-0.44701987504959106,
1.2248923778533936,
0.12676121294498444,
-0.5464268326759338,
-0.41453689336776733,
-0.32552143931388855,
-0.8287425637245178,
0.2256121039390564,
-0.1072874516248703,
-0.9513640403747559,
0.014837450347840786,
-0.16722546517848969,
-0.040648456662893295,
-0.18644125759601593,
-0.9063348770141602,
1.2433699369430542,
-0.20726552605628967,
-0.5689530968666077,
-0.7326880693435669,
-0.4893847107887268,
-0.4013899564743042,
0.5248487591743469,
0.23224902153015137,
-0.7786022424697876,
-0.29065629839897156,
0.520808756351471,
-0.034418486058712006,
0.7848832011222839,
-0.37424835562705994,
0.30961382389068604,
0.18236547708511353,
0.04012143984436989,
0.5068674087524414,
-0.20136471092700958,
-0.4055933356285095,
0.18498031795024872,
0.012705997563898563,
-0.8796050548553467,
-0.5260436534881592,
0.6543978452682495,
-0.9689623713493347,
-0.5981874465942383,
-0.3950728178024292,
-0.420848548412323,
-0.3342134356498718,
-0.060723211616277695,
-0.5066526532173157,
0.4616495668888092,
-0.7918887734413147,
0.15731114149093628,
0.16370289027690887,
0.023553427308797836,
0.3593384623527527,
0.860572099685669,
0.1279958039522171,
-0.0956762358546257,
0.8615869283676147,
0.05156908184289932,
0.5193243026733398,
0.4682022035121918,
0.08661150932312012,
-0.2308306097984314,
-0.6293514966964722,
-0.30947816371917725,
0.2580249309539795,
-0.7408324480056763,
0.03883817046880722,
-0.6591871380805969,
-0.2785870134830475,
-0.573360025882721,
-0.4216576814651489,
-0.6035178303718567,
0.058905456215143204,
0.4688514173030853,
-0.09689200669527054,
-0.12426090985536575,
0.7282440662384033,
0.06832081824541092,
0.022448135539889336,
-0.4706840515136719,
0.20351020991802216,
0.1034398004412651,
0.32041624188423157,
-0.015077921561896801,
0.015043104998767376,
-0.17750024795532227,
0.08635503798723221,
-0.17125383019447327,
-0.7466153502464294,
-0.0464392751455307,
-0.029620932415127754,
0.9120563864707947,
0.36652421951293945,
0.23123879730701447,
0.6167583465576172,
-0.5090667605400085,
0.6388888359069824,
-0.3468632996082306,
-1.0290735960006714,
0.5922591090202332,
-0.3388977348804474,
0.22939254343509674,
0.7690013647079468,
0.1180778369307518,
-0.4155435264110565,
-0.8412318825721741,
-0.9821487665176392,
-0.595186710357666,
0.7847894430160522,
0.4011080861091614,
0.22998222708702087,
-0.23335802555084229,
0.25028905272483826,
-0.20669777691364288,
0.3716570734977722,
-0.6308509111404419,
-0.09972764551639557,
0.23851194977760315,
-0.1606016904115677,
-0.37449461221694946,
-0.1874568909406662,
-0.053739022463560104,
-0.06632449477910995,
0.6450603008270264,
-0.09542442858219147,
0.14907437562942505,
-0.14321252703666687,
-0.08760472387075424,
-0.19510051608085632,
0.21544943749904633,
0.364707350730896,
0.8136276602745056,
-0.19833315908908844,
0.18829865753650665,
0.19209933280944824,
-0.26654893159866333,
0.1755509227514267,
0.2355576753616333,
-0.18645602464675903,
-0.21031486988067627,
0.39546653628349304,
0.4065302014350891,
0.5592944025993347,
-1.0772868394851685,
0.6428359746932983,
-0.20103900134563446,
-0.05510389059782028,
-0.3483307659626007,
0.46296027302742004,
0.0428694412112236,
0.565892219543457,
0.28405696153640747,
-0.019910644739866257,
0.0920015349984169,
-0.8160443902015686,
0.009117494337260723,
0.6998956203460693,
-0.4630294740200043,
-0.2951936721801758,
0.26747897267341614,
0.3802661597728729,
-1.0006434917449951,
0.16975419223308563,
-0.5571572184562683,
-0.43708330392837524,
0.9156935214996338,
0.2744539976119995,
1.063219666481018,
-0.3821777105331421,
0.6508307456970215,
0.08085961639881134,
0.5508139133453369,
-0.015360497869551182,
0.44190487265586853,
-0.27870702743530273,
-0.8115817308425903,
-0.050168346613645554,
-0.47343677282333374,
-0.5054789781570435,
-0.32261911034584045,
-0.4329805076122284,
0.2610173225402832,
-0.37202900648117065,
-0.1608608216047287,
0.009842493571341038,
0.24264544248580933,
-0.6961032152175903,
0.07038173079490662,
0.11631842702627182,
0.7866500616073608,
-0.8797608017921448,
0.680747389793396,
0.9752523303031921,
-0.006788725033402443,
-0.6560630798339844,
-0.06340692192316055,
-0.140182763338089,
-0.9393580555915833,
0.4835117757320404,
0.1858479529619217,
-0.4693233072757721,
-0.16346882283687592,
-0.4037458598613739,
-0.7975807785987854,
1.0699926614761353,
0.35010480880737305,
-0.06294126063585281,
-0.10841702669858932,
0.3786889612674713,
0.7316105365753174,
-0.4526054561138153,
0.48165932297706604,
0.5771106481552124,
0.31554386019706726,
-0.11594109982252121,
-0.6844746470451355,
0.4118385910987854,
-0.7210203409194946,
0.05452651157975197,
0.20685577392578125,
-0.9151776432991028,
0.6897467970848083,
0.1127852201461792,
-0.42306238412857056,
-0.054190121591091156,
0.4763583242893219,
0.43058234453201294,
0.5930100083351135,
0.8077360391616821,
0.15921802818775177,
0.13411898910999298,
-0.10373736917972565,
1.130528211593628,
-0.5557689070701599,
0.043261416256427765,
0.7909849882125854,
-0.765440821647644,
0.9084197282791138,
0.2576371133327484,
-0.15825101733207703,
0.3570767641067505,
0.27509239315986633,
0.31972041726112366,
0.4527658224105835,
0.4366905391216278,
-0.2015964239835739,
-0.3361557722091675,
-0.4293069839477539,
-0.18818087875843048,
0.5062724947929382,
0.2718331515789032,
0.12012223899364471,
-0.22899065911769867,
-0.436628133058548,
-0.1363902986049652,
0.32219401001930237,
-0.20578068494796753,
0.8596175909042358,
-0.22094766795635223,
-0.9326154589653015,
0.3039115071296692,
-0.01989656127989292,
0.13925187289714813,
-0.7943215370178223,
-0.013745587319135666,
-0.14262275397777557,
0.35240715742111206,
0.29186657071113586,
-0.5619384050369263,
0.21162620186805725,
0.09083924442529678,
0.20858077704906464,
-0.4739348888397217,
0.8200245499610901,
-0.1688040792942047,
-0.21250641345977783,
0.7484163641929626,
0.7802613973617554,
0.22275596857070923,
-0.21152183413505554,
-0.9371083974838257,
0.28948235511779785,
-0.49556607007980347,
-0.2667609751224518,
0.3462563157081604,
0.6254945397377014,
0.029337944462895393,
0.80870521068573,
0.4301386773586273,
0.24725952744483948,
-0.34119099378585815,
0.23431679606437683,
0.9571824073791504,
-0.6280573606491089,
-0.5479069948196411,
-0.815387487411499,
0.48431864380836487,
-0.6539921760559082,
-0.3895820081233978,
0.5987679362297058,
0.5695214867591858,
0.8427718877792358,
0.11856847256422043,
0.48742160201072693,
-0.2322971671819687,
0.36196842789649963,
-0.015220929868519306,
0.6060663461685181,
-0.5903503894805908,
0.08938656002283096,
-0.6231665015220642,
-0.9490782022476196,
0.41270703077316284,
0.5061601400375366,
-0.4335487186908722,
0.11193178594112396,
0.7099545001983643,
0.8551502823829651,
0.08466292917728424,
-0.1431795358657837,
0.544825553894043,
-0.07003092765808105,
0.2573184370994568,
0.4827759563922882,
1.09807550907135,
-0.10664643347263336,
0.4655541777610779,
-0.4160606861114502,
-0.3952866494655609,
-0.05888861045241356,
-0.6226526498794556,
-1.269352912902832,
-0.52189701795578,
-0.4210546612739563,
-0.2564808428287506,
0.5277929306030273,
1.156507968902588,
0.9065038561820984,
-0.4887309968471527,
-0.7539396286010742,
0.17082920670509338,
0.33788245916366577,
-0.7253285050392151,
-0.21775482594966888,
0.02072462998330593,
-0.22677196562290192,
-0.7558810114860535,
0.28101497888565063,
0.5177538990974426,
-0.1662873923778534,
-0.3097643256187439,
-0.1845228672027588,
-0.2555278241634369,
0.35297438502311707,
0.6348598599433899,
0.18782472610473633,
-0.6741758584976196,
-0.5421522855758667,
0.02515292353928089,
-0.4528045654296875,
-0.2529563307762146,
0.7187058925628662,
-0.6701506972312927,
-0.13507124781608582,
0.20760314166545868,
0.6161829829216003,
0.17443662881851196,
0.11202144622802734,
0.6125370860099792,
-0.7853735089302063,
0.07389868795871735,
0.39547431468963623,
0.12084648013114929,
0.09268985688686371,
-0.19199512898921967,
0.7229025363922119,
0.07929118722677231,
-0.455876886844635,
-0.9751235842704773,
0.04999212548136711,
-0.9985034465789795,
-0.13019712269306183,
1.4153341054916382,
-0.13772734999656677,
-0.498475044965744,
-0.16717255115509033,
-0.09249972552061081,
0.21750354766845703,
-0.8272587060928345,
0.9477079510688782,
0.6547049283981323,
0.11288309842348099,
-0.09146541357040405,
-0.38158470392227173,
0.3178558051586151,
0.4275079369544983,
-1.0215095281600952,
0.23282158374786377,
0.40973299741744995,
-0.02004987746477127,
0.22666780650615692,
1.2096526622772217,
0.24207083880901337,
0.3623650074005127,
0.3716115355491638,
0.08882462233304977,
0.258171021938324,
-0.4858261048793793,
0.3824174106121063,
0.2665351927280426,
0.07099658250808716,
-0.014010539278388023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05333v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05333v3
|
PORTULAN ExtraGLUE Datasets and Models: Kick-starting a Benchmark for the Neural Processing of Portuguese
| 2024-04-08T09:22:41 | 2024-05-08T19:32:42 |
Tomás Osório, Bernardo Leite, Henrique Lopes Cardoso, Luís Gomes, João Rodrigues, Rodrigo Santos, António Branco
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Leveraging research on the neural modelling of Portuguese, we contribute a
collection of datasets for an array of language processing tasks and a
corresponding collection of fine-tuned neural language models on these
downstream tasks. To align with mainstream benchmarks in the literature,
originally developed in English, and to kick start their Portuguese
counterparts, the datasets were machine-translated from English with a
state-of-the-art translation engine. The resulting PORTULAN ExtraGLUE benchmark
is a basis for research on Portuguese whose improvement can be pursued in
future work. Similarly, the respective fine-tuned neural language models,
developed with a low-rank adaptation approach, are made available as baselines
that can stimulate future work on the neural processing of Portuguese. All
datasets and models have been developed and are made available for two variants
of Portuguese: European and Brazilian.
|
[
-0.19908565282821655,
-0.5340313911437988,
0.05710836872458458,
0.18716156482696533,
-0.16663464903831482,
-0.04968710243701935,
-0.5790728330612183,
-0.5892470479011536,
0.4207838475704193,
0.5963878035545349,
-0.17083823680877686,
-0.2590436041355133,
-0.6837972402572632,
-0.11606866121292114,
-0.4260346293449402,
1.1153786182403564,
0.2259034365415573,
0.3368183374404907,
0.1752694845199585,
-0.3145886957645416,
-0.559492826461792,
-0.5896521210670471,
-0.9427496194839478,
-0.2285449206829071,
0.6282563209533691,
0.337312787771225,
0.5374598503112793,
0.8110340237617493,
0.30575811862945557,
0.2128966748714447,
-0.22364315390586853,
0.14775583148002625,
-0.728588342666626,
0.07252144068479538,
-0.2286718338727951,
-0.5555622577667236,
-0.3995613157749176,
-0.13114891946315765,
0.4435840845108032,
0.7584831118583679,
-0.25698065757751465,
0.2861679792404175,
0.13621145486831665,
0.5176385641098022,
-0.29316097497940063,
0.7416130304336548,
-0.7175723910331726,
-0.09765396267175674,
-0.19175861775875092,
-0.13332447409629822,
-0.23505203425884247,
-0.4090716540813446,
-0.060106564313173294,
-0.5194888114929199,
0.2592896819114685,
-0.31309056282043457,
0.7098803520202637,
0.13633617758750916,
-0.4079624116420746,
0.018529338762164116,
-0.7424772381782532,
0.3170104920864105,
-0.3550194799900055,
0.43991348147392273,
0.07990718632936478,
0.5410654544830322,
0.03345327079296112,
-0.6151045560836792,
-0.09291096031665802,
-0.33445730805397034,
0.018257850781083107,
0.18000689148902893,
-0.31378069519996643,
-0.17465610802173615,
0.2625078856945038,
0.07345792651176453,
-0.8313130140304565,
0.18566322326660156,
-0.8454931378364563,
-0.13466234505176544,
0.6499933004379272,
-0.18871402740478516,
-0.1293480545282364,
0.335454523563385,
-0.1982487291097641,
-0.32888275384902954,
-1.1108094453811646,
0.009746120311319828,
0.333398699760437,
0.6351152062416077,
-0.07179869711399078,
0.24732083082199097,
-0.2660619616508484,
0.9515148401260376,
-0.42874473333358765,
0.3895466923713684,
0.26582571864128113,
0.12982091307640076,
-0.20280325412750244,
0.19029976427555084,
0.45714089274406433,
0.3323320746421814,
0.43358996510505676,
-0.08479442447423935,
-0.46525999903678894,
0.26294708251953125,
0.13372087478637695,
-0.4322091042995453,
-0.3807198405265808,
-0.0066712782718241215,
-0.24007728695869446,
-0.21108953654766083,
-0.35724979639053345,
-0.36769458651542664,
-0.26461389660835266,
-0.47989699244499207,
0.2593826651573181,
-0.16977249085903168,
-0.19805774092674255,
0.013793363235890865,
-0.031996745616197586,
0.22594445943832397,
0.04818873852491379,
-0.7379801869392395,
0.48642677068710327,
0.8387134075164795,
0.7452031970024109,
-0.2704468071460724,
-0.4281295835971832,
-0.42813733220100403,
0.10492537170648575,
-0.43329665064811707,
1.057401418685913,
-0.46876099705696106,
-0.2535431683063507,
0.16644476354122162,
0.5238285064697266,
0.049214377999305725,
-0.49426716566085815,
0.9703530669212341,
-0.5254325866699219,
0.11868929117918015,
-0.2642407715320587,
-0.28029343485832214,
-0.6778602004051208,
0.22202621400356293,
-0.5930019617080688,
1.170599341392517,
0.05891239270567894,
-0.18802686035633087,
0.17628712952136993,
-0.49900394678115845,
-0.5901868343353271,
0.28067123889923096,
-0.24080386757850647,
0.0929754450917244,
0.4725048542022705,
0.18532437086105347,
0.46493443846702576,
-0.798652172088623,
0.4272121489048004,
-0.0765935406088829,
-0.21404677629470825,
-0.15591907501220703,
-0.4060530364513397,
0.8151687383651733,
0.2874979078769684,
0.026244139298796654,
0.12511806190013885,
-0.8029451966285706,
0.07894530892372131,
-0.018241312354803085,
-0.015213778242468834,
-0.14586873352527618,
-0.08508355915546417,
0.3278525471687317,
0.43388909101486206,
0.4006965160369873,
-0.38815611600875854,
0.13324351608753204,
-0.44987860321998596,
0.7564247250556946,
0.3865266442298889,
-0.43835943937301636,
0.27660706639289856,
-0.2689763009548187,
0.5380010008811951,
0.12659090757369995,
-0.037508923560380936,
-0.15560045838356018,
-0.6241949200630188,
-0.5957509875297546,
0.2239898294210434,
0.5449087619781494,
0.6309018135070801,
-0.7551882266998291,
0.16449595987796783,
-0.6374414563179016,
-0.8873633742332458,
-0.40523770451545715,
-0.19431903958320618,
0.418131023645401,
0.6209211945533752,
0.36727362871170044,
-0.523948073387146,
-0.4704476296901703,
-1.1388877630233765,
-0.07973114401102066,
0.004366348497569561,
0.03568074852228165,
0.4751477539539337,
0.3376332223415375,
0.37725546956062317,
0.3650282323360443,
-0.40013256669044495,
-0.3107665777206421,
-0.07340702414512634,
0.05859168991446495,
0.7128152251243591,
0.7840413451194763,
0.7852219343185425,
-0.6355681419372559,
-0.36326590180397034,
0.13607646524906158,
-0.5559424757957458,
-0.2538345456123352,
0.29917046427726746,
-0.04915742576122284,
0.20362497866153717,
0.5697767734527588,
-0.16941876709461212,
0.0474369190633297,
0.760353684425354,
-0.07141420990228653,
0.09354111552238464,
-0.6345393657684326,
0.012006079778075218,
-1.046961784362793,
0.22817350924015045,
-0.10214584320783615,
-0.2023816704750061,
-0.671457827091217,
-0.004065859597176313,
-0.0020159005653113127,
-0.3341737985610962,
-0.6857771277427673,
0.5190001130104065,
-0.5003437995910645,
-0.3681434690952301,
-0.38779908418655396,
-0.028126565739512444,
-0.06752873957157135,
0.4917495846748352,
0.5107275247573853,
0.5556363463401794,
0.8253403306007385,
-0.4551856517791748,
0.4996539056301117,
0.05683251842856407,
-0.08738017827272415,
0.2655596435070038,
-1.1235430240631104,
0.0945110023021698,
-0.13512711226940155,
0.15268291532993317,
-1.0478107929229736,
0.078630730509758,
0.17128662765026093,
-0.4685806632041931,
0.33962929248809814,
-0.7310068011283875,
-0.2085333615541458,
-0.3759170174598694,
0.08844205737113953,
0.06362926214933395,
0.567859947681427,
-0.429025799036026,
0.36454156041145325,
0.611655592918396,
-0.26461368799209595,
-0.5339646339416504,
-0.8405681848526001,
0.19082336127758026,
-0.22816303372383118,
-0.43089228868484497,
0.4539016783237457,
0.22465434670448303,
0.25512444972991943,
-0.326450377702713,
0.32659798860549927,
-0.2869541347026825,
0.029215969145298004,
0.18212004005908966,
0.17526839673519135,
-0.4568493366241455,
0.14647676050662994,
0.20930391550064087,
-0.3042619824409485,
0.15590427815914154,
-0.6733832359313965,
0.5780445337295532,
0.12043672800064087,
0.272106409072876,
0.33611977100372314,
0.12546829879283905,
0.2955669164657593,
-0.332708477973938,
0.6779599189758301,
0.47008827328681946,
-0.5203962326049805,
-0.13975882530212402,
-0.3221626281738281,
-0.40901774168014526,
-0.365981787443161,
0.20893697440624237,
-0.6250452995300293,
-0.635583221912384,
0.712058961391449,
0.03651413694024086,
0.0011308299144729972,
0.3731253147125244,
0.5830955505371094,
0.16487136483192444,
0.7008411884307861,
0.8242568969726562,
-0.21572807431221008,
0.4083041846752167,
-0.18313923478126526,
-0.23303864896297455,
-0.5498236417770386,
0.2518788278102875,
-0.8166477084159851,
-0.47061070799827576,
-0.9979149103164673,
-0.36531296372413635,
0.29913774132728577,
-0.07328949123620987,
-0.0738949254155159,
0.9334567785263062,
-0.6492303609848022,
0.6556954383850098,
0.5169810056686401,
0.06646221876144409,
0.10201980918645859,
0.10336615890264511,
-0.16850759088993073,
0.20183052122592926,
-1.0279793739318848,
-0.49278518557548523,
1.3512873649597168,
-0.041716624051332474,
0.4461819529533386,
0.02002868615090847,
0.16753551363945007,
0.29860714077949524,
0.20012500882148743,
-0.3229190707206726,
0.3826873302459717,
-0.44176727533340454,
-0.6628414392471313,
0.06783846765756607,
-0.16843551397323608,
-1.17929208278656,
0.29699862003326416,
-0.11175835877656937,
-0.7023984789848328,
0.3044239282608032,
0.27108126878738403,
-0.4060764014720917,
-0.20943814516067505,
-0.7763799428939819,
1.147657871246338,
-0.39933833479881287,
-0.8083909749984741,
-0.18657293915748596,
-0.7477694749832153,
0.13663142919540405,
0.14709487557411194,
-0.050388120114803314,
-0.2755534052848816,
-0.22895881533622742,
0.7525396943092346,
-0.0818503275513649,
0.5348522067070007,
-0.2448042631149292,
-0.23881296813488007,
0.18840694427490234,
0.1506764441728592,
0.35415175557136536,
0.12985152006149292,
-0.18580442667007446,
0.6211810111999512,
0.11318754404783249,
-0.45213231444358826,
-0.29924774169921875,
0.8414158821105957,
-0.6800675392150879,
-0.24539268016815186,
-0.5414418578147888,
-0.4800715744495392,
-0.17656396329402924,
0.20492348074913025,
0.11773377656936646,
0.4014597237110138,
-0.41459769010543823,
0.07198644429445267,
0.25880250334739685,
-0.05817946419119835,
0.5897164940834045,
0.9699100255966187,
-0.4088960587978363,
-0.1872689127922058,
1.031699776649475,
0.28314995765686035,
-0.17465436458587646,
0.41285479068756104,
-0.08522238582372665,
-0.3861137628555298,
-0.7391905784606934,
-0.6976284980773926,
-0.060743141919374466,
-0.43192994594573975,
-0.144099622964859,
-0.45061686635017395,
0.0014583789743483067,
-0.5058203339576721,
0.1530808061361313,
-0.45800021290779114,
-0.5952495336532593,
0.02012445777654648,
0.06539546698331833,
0.5051912069320679,
0.7673372030258179,
-0.3556150794029236,
0.39693450927734375,
-1.0764800310134888,
0.05444718524813652,
-0.09724192321300507,
0.17948806285858154,
-0.39235225319862366,
-0.7354028224945068,
-0.3886617422103882,
0.1767570525407791,
0.043065253645181656,
-0.8037508130073547,
0.7468456029891968,
0.19452688097953796,
0.5189000964164734,
0.10774656385183334,
-0.5382660031318665,
0.16369010508060455,
-0.5492363572120667,
0.6070563793182373,
-0.36519742012023926,
-0.48209381103515625,
0.5403580665588379,
-0.6264117956161499,
0.16008716821670532,
0.5521798133850098,
0.8196656107902527,
-0.5549359917640686,
0.3965374827384949,
-0.7136635780334473,
-0.7486861348152161,
0.6184280514717102,
0.17872165143489838,
-0.07559723407030106,
0.10296787321567535,
0.24839012324810028,
0.32510051131248474,
0.45469969511032104,
-0.3991699516773224,
-0.07762052863836288,
0.15412074327468872,
0.1392797827720642,
-0.6844860315322876,
0.026186132803559303,
-0.23876424133777618,
-0.34091082215309143,
0.7521020770072937,
-0.4924812316894531,
0.1991099864244461,
-0.3588300347328186,
-0.3626781702041626,
0.1856553852558136,
-0.08491871505975723,
0.6676753759384155,
0.6264047026634216,
-0.05278802290558815,
-0.17113637924194336,
0.2467326521873474,
-0.43456462025642395,
0.006628955714404583,
0.6021062731742859,
-0.3427541255950928,
0.05412769317626953,
-0.03957754746079445,
0.7392703294754028,
0.23878926038742065,
-0.6108660101890564,
0.22968916594982147,
-0.20683665573596954,
0.36557480692863464,
-0.3891735076904297,
0.1239190474152565,
0.32624056935310364,
0.10020036995410919,
0.056145668029785156,
0.019741404801607132,
0.20276997983455658,
-0.39126691222190857,
0.06355510652065277,
0.09798189997673035,
-0.5489250421524048,
-0.41338059306144714,
0.6673539876937866,
0.44584640860557556,
-0.2545141577720642,
0.4214661419391632,
-0.09626369178295135,
-0.46609506011009216,
0.8394175171852112,
0.3146849572658539,
0.7596758008003235,
-0.1426970660686493,
0.06274154037237167,
0.38214030861854553,
0.38530123233795166,
-0.11782534420490265,
0.8751729726791382,
-0.03228481486439705,
-0.8030084371566772,
-0.2999243438243866,
-0.5752042531967163,
-0.30458250641822815,
0.044960614293813705,
-0.6670594811439514,
0.5399844646453857,
-0.1552615463733673,
-0.038408759981393814,
-0.03567497059702873,
-0.24358375370502472,
-0.6336207389831543,
0.4347922205924988,
0.4481213688850403,
0.8946272134780884,
-1.0672751665115356,
1.0852084159851074,
0.9519813060760498,
-0.3753888010978699,
-0.5314038991928101,
-0.7587253451347351,
-0.18554286658763885,
-0.9797881245613098,
0.6814838647842407,
0.13369961082935333,
0.12757830321788788,
0.11336829513311386,
-0.30071452260017395,
-1.0118709802627563,
0.6963214874267578,
0.5805562138557434,
-0.8150779604911804,
0.10304654389619827,
0.35702723264694214,
0.8518252372741699,
-0.5877424478530884,
0.9702068567276001,
1.0843712091445923,
0.3374447226524353,
-0.2296103835105896,
-0.9102455973625183,
-0.2724389135837555,
-0.48778611421585083,
0.08053573966026306,
0.09645979106426239,
-0.8636766076087952,
0.8960248827934265,
0.3634270429611206,
0.19344134628772736,
-0.2029537707567215,
0.6439935564994812,
-0.15644241869449615,
-0.21768242120742798,
0.2207234799861908,
0.5965443849563599,
0.5037750601768494,
-0.5231236815452576,
0.8985263109207153,
-1.0022903680801392,
0.08708903193473816,
1.5946191549301147,
-0.3570142388343811,
0.8397811055183411,
0.18998317420482635,
-0.026744598522782326,
0.18536078929901123,
0.6780850291252136,
-0.13416054844856262,
0.10680927336215973,
0.31421521306037903,
-0.055985838174819946,
0.17418479919433594,
-0.5335035920143127,
-0.7014310956001282,
1.0321824550628662,
0.5424646735191345,
-0.5958912372589111,
-0.3128558397293091,
-0.030643047764897346,
-0.011309497058391571,
-0.0760122761130333,
-0.3394903838634491,
0.708840548992157,
-0.08810237050056458,
-0.985582709312439,
0.7659429907798767,
-0.09218913316726685,
0.44901978969573975,
-0.5818010568618774,
-0.11975123733282089,
-0.3471556007862091,
0.195236936211586,
0.046028174459934235,
-0.7799156308174133,
0.2776362895965576,
-0.014897720888257027,
0.057332996279001236,
-0.5461435317993164,
0.869486927986145,
-0.5821436047554016,
-0.5283946990966797,
0.42267918586730957,
0.8988499641418457,
0.6488519310951233,
-0.20515476167201996,
-0.8110537528991699,
0.164141446352005,
-0.178521990776062,
-0.2313789576292038,
0.1558281034231186,
0.25258034467697144,
-0.06963273137807846,
0.3391062915325165,
0.5666229128837585,
0.4478056728839874,
0.1399519145488739,
0.2007448822259903,
0.7315689325332642,
-0.6682398319244385,
-0.5428644418716431,
-0.5072895288467407,
0.09101295471191406,
-0.009815093129873276,
-0.8507185578346252,
0.565193235874176,
0.9193496108055115,
1.158239483833313,
-0.3025895059108734,
0.6073868274688721,
-0.06193895265460014,
0.5400581955909729,
-0.3438769578933716,
1.0472922325134277,
-0.3602834939956665,
-0.08262316882610321,
0.19543121755123138,
-1.154312014579773,
0.06117558479309082,
0.2723904252052307,
-0.19881924986839294,
0.14394386112689972,
0.5986487865447998,
1.1134370565414429,
-0.05401376262307167,
0.14385531842708588,
0.4482315182685852,
0.3907530605792999,
0.08508733659982681,
0.960175633430481,
0.44739624857902527,
-0.7184880971908569,
0.3228601813316345,
-0.5031692385673523,
-0.0520559698343277,
-0.05905626341700554,
-1.1058028936386108,
-0.3910559117794037,
-0.47163620591163635,
-0.19834713637828827,
-0.3313099145889282,
0.44009485840797424,
0.7840778231620789,
0.7690902948379517,
-1.0126420259475708,
-0.7416996955871582,
-0.19779972732067108,
-0.18514427542686462,
-0.3511381447315216,
-0.08720133453607559,
0.15264570713043213,
-0.11716322600841522,
-0.861573338508606,
0.6665031909942627,
0.21676062047481537,
-0.062316011637449265,
-0.23188947141170502,
0.2485608160495758,
-0.3393495976924896,
-0.19225727021694183,
0.50153648853302,
0.6247254014015198,
-0.12421577423810959,
-0.07434950023889542,
-0.22381103038787842,
-0.019802147522568703,
0.2245735228061676,
0.8414062261581421,
-1.111810326576233,
0.2249615490436554,
0.6416486501693726,
0.6086267232894897,
0.5619357228279114,
-0.41897904872894287,
0.898402988910675,
-0.6160399913787842,
0.6341331601142883,
0.3251895010471344,
0.6485026478767395,
0.3442813754081726,
-0.10918481647968292,
0.9378727674484253,
0.2369239777326584,
-0.3232339024543762,
-0.6270174384117126,
-0.12108828872442245,
-0.9261481761932373,
0.0621824786067009,
0.8465737104415894,
-0.2658177316188812,
-0.5363140106201172,
0.14837627112865448,
-0.1736668348312378,
0.46852821111679077,
-0.45965316891670227,
0.4796042740345001,
0.536405086517334,
-0.020061319693922997,
0.09128771722316742,
-0.6025310158729553,
0.3784259855747223,
0.5962071418762207,
-0.924793004989624,
0.168413907289505,
0.4643203616142273,
-0.07634804397821426,
-0.01904689520597458,
0.16664151847362518,
0.00045277774916030467,
0.45201972126960754,
0.12286077439785004,
0.058803100138902664,
0.05032402649521828,
-0.6297987103462219,
-0.7165924310684204,
0.24407382309436798,
-0.22814132273197174,
0.12221445888280869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05281v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05281v1
|
Multi-Task Learning for Features Extraction in Financial Annual Reports
| 2024-04-08T08:13:40 | 2024-04-08T08:13:40 |
Syrielle Montariol, Matej Martinc, Andraž Pelicon, Senja Pollak, Boshko Koloski, Igor Lončarski, Aljoša Valentinčič
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For assessing various performance indicators of companies, the focus is
shifting from strictly financial (quantitative) publicly disclosed information
to qualitative (textual) information. This textual data can provide valuable
weak signals, for example through stylistic features, which can complement the
quantitative data on financial performance or on Environmental, Social and
Governance (ESG) criteria. In this work, we use various multi-task learning
methods for financial text classification with the focus on financial
sentiment, objectivity, forward-looking sentence prediction and ESG-content
detection. We propose different methods to combine the information extracted
from training jointly on different tasks; our best-performing method highlights
the positive effect of explicitly adding auxiliary task predictions as features
for the final target task during the multi-task training. Next, we use these
classifiers to extract textual features from annual reports of FTSE350
companies and investigate the link between ESG quantitative scores and these
features.
|
[
-0.2833813428878784,
-0.38778457045555115,
0.2195839136838913,
0.3511819541454315,
-0.3568337857723236,
0.3956086337566376,
-0.24206702411174774,
-0.9709336161613464,
0.10076641291379929,
0.6835927367210388,
-0.5273776054382324,
-0.4073159396648407,
-0.7679009437561035,
0.2778335213661194,
-0.2510157823562622,
1.5064473152160645,
0.05277864634990692,
-0.05667775496840477,
-0.31172439455986023,
-0.21999335289001465,
-0.3271659016609192,
-0.544648289680481,
-0.6993497014045715,
-0.1659567803144455,
0.45304223895072937,
0.37367314100265503,
-0.010889088734984398,
0.4496074318885803,
0.4429962635040283,
0.3558966815471649,
0.29129040241241455,
0.3670741021633148,
-0.05215303227305412,
0.1467362940311432,
0.05289310961961746,
-0.28881776332855225,
-0.42663782835006714,
0.1786128580570221,
0.3544706404209137,
0.05137989670038223,
0.01976286992430687,
0.5581279993057251,
0.5774883031845093,
0.4940876364707947,
-0.5517063736915588,
1.1559990644454956,
-0.2689919173717499,
0.02193463034927845,
-0.2754724621772766,
-0.47780922055244446,
-0.4205295145511627,
-0.10955960303544998,
0.4521056115627289,
-0.6680652499198914,
0.335178941488266,
0.17556677758693695,
0.8823794722557068,
0.04558952897787094,
-0.5898628234863281,
-0.7131330370903015,
-0.3576546609401703,
1.13671875,
-0.2871759235858917,
0.36676594614982605,
0.4000489413738251,
0.016574200242757797,
0.6253889203071594,
-0.5092442035675049,
-0.07552049309015274,
-0.06627698242664337,
-0.3631669580936432,
0.32252970337867737,
-0.02333608642220497,
-0.10907046496868134,
-0.10238447785377502,
0.29292675852775574,
-0.1866151988506317,
-0.1309756636619568,
-0.4713137745857239,
-0.20271669328212738,
0.9033469557762146,
-0.04955316334962845,
-0.24061591923236847,
-0.1188482940196991,
-0.5553381443023682,
-0.492624968290329,
-0.3556493818759918,
0.30711743235588074,
0.37209683656692505,
0.8299541473388672,
-0.0543297603726387,
0.19578315317630768,
-0.0941438227891922,
0.10228902846574783,
0.12930402159690857,
-0.3969119191169739,
0.684140145778656,
-0.4372127056121826,
0.011102312244474888,
0.289527952671051,
0.43344876170158386,
0.15893177688121796,
0.22842971980571747,
-0.3164631426334381,
-0.44466158747673035,
0.030056530609726906,
0.4259338080883026,
-0.3740489184856415,
-0.15314655005931854,
0.19912342727184296,
-0.5854854583740234,
-0.5039258599281311,
0.5453535914421082,
-0.9646104574203491,
-0.309431791305542,
-0.6274965405464172,
0.19400142133235931,
-0.28767460584640503,
-0.08870221674442291,
-0.16981935501098633,
-0.5590226054191589,
0.27604636549949646,
0.42567479610443115,
-0.6719418168067932,
0.36195364594459534,
0.6493625640869141,
0.4168124198913574,
-0.08633170276880264,
-0.3565623164176941,
-1.0378836393356323,
0.39252781867980957,
0.1738821119070053,
1.0198675394058228,
-0.4392920136451721,
-0.21710892021656036,
-0.06738125532865524,
0.11273456364870071,
-0.15684804320335388,
-0.46251189708709717,
0.44372743368148804,
-0.12955670058727264,
0.39863136410713196,
-0.5254986882209778,
-0.12039266526699066,
-0.5426348447799683,
0.024051550775766373,
-0.5911635160446167,
1.1268157958984375,
0.08646088093519211,
-0.8694952130317688,
0.8580229878425598,
-0.8461021184921265,
-0.7386768460273743,
0.03943214565515518,
-0.19864296913146973,
-0.6527748703956604,
-0.011079668067395687,
0.36895185708999634,
0.7342747449874878,
-0.3685823678970337,
0.3334983289241791,
-0.20738185942173004,
0.003041903953999281,
0.403370201587677,
-0.3461415767669678,
0.2418656349182129,
0.07269640266895294,
-0.41180869936943054,
0.28205880522727966,
-0.7985708117485046,
-0.1317545473575592,
0.00007087778794812039,
-0.3769337236881256,
-0.4255562424659729,
0.2581627070903778,
0.7268726229667664,
0.26610738039016724,
0.4850710928440094,
-0.4496895372867584,
-0.1739443689584732,
-0.057925399392843246,
0.5118871331214905,
0.8123767971992493,
0.04714959114789963,
0.0574004128575325,
-0.7219315767288208,
0.48855283856391907,
0.29651573300361633,
0.005737814120948315,
-0.2878161668777466,
-0.4753519296646118,
-0.4491916000843048,
-0.4959580898284912,
0.1704590767621994,
0.9168601036071777,
-0.5620790719985962,
0.438256174325943,
-0.016541820019483566,
-0.31683292984962463,
-0.3827400505542755,
0.34278154373168945,
0.5285637974739075,
0.08152063935995102,
0.35201841592788696,
-0.34325847029685974,
-0.3800472021102905,
-0.7244524359703064,
-0.5828864574432373,
-0.19883254170417786,
-0.06517690420150757,
0.21020087599754333,
0.6064658164978027,
0.4056660234928131,
0.5986432433128357,
-0.8382366895675659,
-0.5435702800750732,
-0.2212429791688919,
0.8673067092895508,
-0.13724812865257263,
0.22308196127414703,
0.4483237862586975,
-1.10512375831604,
-0.36345815658569336,
0.29471299052238464,
-0.5067188739776611,
0.2250753939151764,
-0.3227827847003937,
0.4894465208053589,
0.023078037425875664,
0.35126402974128723,
-0.10662293434143066,
0.2334515005350113,
0.19351455569267273,
-0.3733570873737335,
0.3788488805294037,
-0.21905215084552765,
0.37891125679016113,
-0.9175071716308594,
0.018820995464920998,
0.9341554045677185,
-0.3169766366481781,
-0.43069085478782654,
-0.14920026063919067,
0.14451105892658234,
0.006210679188370705,
0.007011687848716974,
0.42715728282928467,
-0.443430632352829,
-0.11335224658250809,
-0.07312111556529999,
0.050393085926771164,
0.16407549381256104,
0.6519330739974976,
-0.12339384108781815,
0.7436949610710144,
0.5250004529953003,
-0.45396655797958374,
0.13773933053016663,
0.2347966879606247,
-0.19428445398807526,
0.656686544418335,
-0.12455940246582031,
0.011918819509446621,
-0.402617484331131,
-0.06777988374233246,
-1.2374204397201538,
-0.06718819588422775,
-0.044504765421152115,
-0.39507776498794556,
0.4770219922065735,
0.4080645442008972,
-0.4085393249988556,
-0.175253763794899,
-0.5699432492256165,
-0.20095732808113098,
0.020282184705138206,
-0.0890144407749176,
0.9296714067459106,
0.574089765548706,
-0.762302041053772,
-0.6500362753868103,
-0.7926174998283386,
-0.16174647212028503,
-0.6711089015007019,
-0.24603162705898285,
0.46161603927612305,
0.4138084053993225,
-0.06602951139211655,
0.047399476170539856,
-0.2882430851459503,
-0.2468092292547226,
0.254795104265213,
0.41264015436172485,
0.5057433247566223,
-0.12450321763753891,
-0.08521661162376404,
0.06318244338035583,
-0.16376417875289917,
0.022151414304971695,
-0.08045411109924316,
-0.013767545111477375,
-0.3265407681465149,
0.11258820444345474,
-0.37122607231140137,
0.455584853887558,
0.5055105686187744,
-0.8307855129241943,
0.6666348576545715,
0.6530361175537109,
-0.3383508026599884,
-0.19032850861549377,
-0.6996550559997559,
-0.14827071130275726,
-0.47387993335723877,
0.32810935378074646,
-0.1430330127477646,
-0.9064233303070068,
0.6589824557304382,
-0.04791342467069626,
0.3258073925971985,
0.9029452800750732,
0.016062024980783463,
-0.13210433721542358,
0.722449541091919,
0.9494401216506958,
-0.11140812933444977,
0.6245677471160889,
-0.11150897294282913,
0.08812616020441055,
-0.37253203988075256,
-0.5025225281715393,
-0.7705977559089661,
-0.21367265284061432,
-0.4083041250705719,
0.03659728541970253,
0.2765512466430664,
-0.04585113003849983,
0.08762340992689133,
0.49835294485092163,
-0.36792340874671936,
0.18889638781547546,
0.35571739077568054,
0.2504507303237915,
0.16891814768314362,
-0.07564513385295868,
0.029221760109066963,
-0.09165599942207336,
-0.26328644156455994,
-0.2969171404838562,
0.993226170539856,
0.5092053413391113,
0.46122899651527405,
-0.3122991621494293,
0.7901598215103149,
0.4958372116088867,
0.601311206817627,
-0.5553709864616394,
0.20261503756046295,
-0.7911650538444519,
-0.2393912672996521,
-0.31482478976249695,
-0.5633147358894348,
-0.510823667049408,
0.14189113676548004,
-0.38523802161216736,
-0.6274192333221436,
0.2590692639350891,
-0.21919074654579163,
-0.6476545929908752,
-0.16746404767036438,
-0.8393704295158386,
0.7531276941299438,
-0.3737351596355438,
0.009964958764612675,
-0.2208450436592102,
-0.27638155221939087,
0.17590992152690887,
-0.3507605493068695,
0.556204617023468,
-0.026595942676067352,
-0.2550259828567505,
0.8463795185089111,
0.3067662715911865,
1.1209229230880737,
-0.1099381297826767,
-0.11929430812597275,
0.07417634129524231,
-0.6898889541625977,
0.5216107964515686,
0.050057992339134216,
0.21944895386695862,
0.0064913202077150345,
0.155008465051651,
-0.19385601580142975,
-0.1630832701921463,
0.3988383710384369,
-0.5412720441818237,
-0.24502335488796234,
-0.7519322633743286,
-0.6082788705825806,
-0.4176255762577057,
-0.09055056422948837,
-0.12828068435192108,
0.4495909512042999,
-0.03310978040099144,
0.4206632077693939,
0.13732323050498962,
-0.11435172706842422,
0.7039300799369812,
0.1684248447418213,
0.18771633505821228,
-0.8323312401771545,
1.0736744403839111,
0.46870750188827515,
-0.10478147864341736,
0.4458054006099701,
0.21456502377986908,
-0.5262250304222107,
-0.47445234656333923,
-0.08399610966444016,
0.10690882056951523,
-0.6079645156860352,
-0.3924320340156555,
-0.5307759642601013,
-0.23141589760780334,
-0.509992241859436,
-0.04161703586578369,
-0.028107455000281334,
-0.16956129670143127,
-0.41100144386291504,
-0.09925945848226547,
0.4563162624835968,
0.8826993107795715,
0.1557212918996811,
0.19847536087036133,
-1.2163703441619873,
0.4742307662963867,
0.2815861105918884,
0.08956146985292435,
0.12413474172353745,
-0.12188449501991272,
-0.5239436626434326,
-0.286454975605011,
-0.7279261350631714,
-0.6563941240310669,
0.5416169762611389,
0.3899754285812378,
0.6362903714179993,
0.5802136063575745,
-0.1217251867055893,
0.6444594264030457,
-0.09644460678100586,
0.46780961751937866,
0.2902669906616211,
-0.9020321369171143,
0.33157041668891907,
-0.35240209102630615,
0.25842908024787903,
0.7245874404907227,
0.582056999206543,
-0.25136324763298035,
-0.6320652961730957,
-0.6362659335136414,
-0.8059703707695007,
0.824117124080658,
0.02512906678020954,
-0.2788742780685425,
-0.03129757568240166,
0.2892378270626068,
0.3309154212474823,
0.7523221969604492,
-0.6376298069953918,
-0.2561935484409332,
-0.0025444081984460354,
-0.3334957957267761,
-0.17694607377052307,
-0.13739150762557983,
0.1290595531463623,
-0.1534370332956314,
0.4677152633666992,
-0.32767900824546814,
-0.022273501381278038,
0.0614081434905529,
0.18073397874832153,
-0.10963285714387894,
0.2484051138162613,
0.32406216859817505,
0.9314448833465576,
-0.1182122603058815,
-0.2776830494403839,
0.1420668661594391,
-0.5699815154075623,
-0.15379026532173157,
0.5392401218414307,
0.2122037410736084,
-0.1761060208082199,
0.6530866026878357,
0.45811089873313904,
0.7039070129394531,
-0.6026545763015747,
0.5139051079750061,
0.08052558451890945,
-0.4951882064342499,
-0.2726042866706848,
-0.1325036585330963,
-0.06713754683732986,
0.6780117154121399,
0.9300394058227539,
0.37452268600463867,
0.3450015187263489,
-0.9279538989067078,
0.5387126207351685,
0.20319312810897827,
-0.390356183052063,
-0.16667480766773224,
0.5096681118011475,
0.20835164189338684,
0.27302002906799316,
0.2899557054042816,
-0.17547713220119476,
-0.6389541029930115,
0.7358356714248657,
0.21745269000530243,
1.201167106628418,
-0.2873620092868805,
0.327380508184433,
0.1346709132194519,
0.11854570358991623,
-0.38044217228889465,
0.7079290151596069,
-0.14410528540611267,
-0.5190311670303345,
-0.7794186472892761,
-0.7244551777839661,
-0.30024269223213196,
0.0573042556643486,
-1.0046836137771606,
0.38852202892303467,
-0.426125705242157,
-0.18717198073863983,
0.5483277440071106,
0.24259532988071442,
-0.6671174168586731,
0.30389776825904846,
0.2531416714191437,
0.4682706892490387,
-0.8758390545845032,
0.6847348809242249,
0.6211775541305542,
-0.36747074127197266,
-0.38650450110435486,
0.007313176989555359,
0.21215392649173737,
-0.4552231729030609,
0.7115216851234436,
0.5568863749504089,
-0.05203791707754135,
-0.38501426577568054,
-0.15941683948040009,
-0.577491283416748,
0.9778155088424683,
0.10440787672996521,
-0.5255687832832336,
-0.38006797432899475,
-0.03372561186552048,
0.1403355598449707,
-0.6439462304115295,
-0.24076500535011292,
0.2830449640750885,
0.671333372592926,
0.006611953489482403,
-1.0757017135620117,
-0.08623689413070679,
-0.15311682224273682,
-0.4317860007286072,
0.49882301688194275,
-0.7625820636749268,
0.8255565166473389,
0.14961960911750793,
-0.20824110507965088,
-0.3653544783592224,
0.6581934690475464,
0.040083933621644974,
0.6682043671607971,
0.6573670506477356,
0.3535926043987274,
0.8640047907829285,
-0.1996583491563797,
0.8709134459495544,
-0.3955056369304657,
0.3722369968891144,
0.8807446360588074,
-0.29203176498413086,
1.0954678058624268,
0.23559798300266266,
-0.03234155476093292,
0.2802554965019226,
0.4174959659576416,
-0.2623138129711151,
0.7420719265937805,
-0.017370574176311493,
-0.1701723337173462,
-0.05255676060914993,
-0.02532201074063778,
-0.04539615288376808,
0.7402499318122864,
0.4673515856266022,
-0.34291133284568787,
-0.20910687744617462,
0.34924396872520447,
-0.23057521879673004,
0.027739273384213448,
-0.43012842535972595,
1.0099906921386719,
0.18482449650764465,
-0.49470996856689453,
-0.22789080440998077,
0.2147773951292038,
0.9713574051856995,
-0.7145621180534363,
-0.11992286145687103,
0.3906610608100891,
0.10763390362262726,
-0.172782301902771,
-0.8061882853507996,
0.6529622077941895,
0.13553036749362946,
-0.057104818522930145,
-0.8608677387237549,
0.6537469625473022,
-0.38881421089172363,
-0.4470427334308624,
0.31137028336524963,
0.47249141335487366,
-0.3017660677433014,
-0.5238521099090576,
-0.7089323997497559,
-0.4311254620552063,
0.022350935265421867,
-0.16634899377822876,
0.4408353567123413,
0.8328544497489929,
0.12260528653860092,
0.4236922562122345,
0.6014098525047302,
-0.036632928997278214,
-0.3078826665878296,
-0.20516270399093628,
0.9286278486251831,
-1.0657670497894287,
-0.9630810022354126,
-0.6309065222740173,
0.48615214228630066,
-0.14173652231693268,
-0.6652090549468994,
0.7001766562461853,
0.7322874069213867,
0.8637814521789551,
-0.14985324442386627,
0.8658288717269897,
0.2910093367099762,
0.3401172459125519,
-0.6629765033721924,
0.6631826162338257,
-0.41472500562667847,
-0.08983007073402405,
-0.21887852251529694,
-0.8826363682746887,
-0.024640044197440147,
0.3082273006439209,
-0.2299005687236786,
0.04560668393969536,
0.8382901549339294,
0.08489197492599487,
-0.03328542038798332,
0.6218739748001099,
0.14091569185256958,
-0.09262976050376892,
-0.024004636332392693,
0.2195105403661728,
0.40463492274284363,
-0.27921590209007263,
0.6149471402168274,
-0.38480129837989807,
-0.04062101989984512,
-0.029275737702846527,
-0.8889186978340149,
-0.8302890658378601,
-0.8893797397613525,
-0.6826154589653015,
-0.07963982224464417,
-0.18404744565486908,
0.6113334894180298,
0.4618633985519409,
-0.9537180066108704,
-0.42056506872177124,
0.36167556047439575,
-0.41273587942123413,
-0.6407135725021362,
-0.3014112412929535,
0.2978149354457855,
-0.39355775713920593,
-0.440471887588501,
0.2656785845756531,
0.5803439617156982,
-0.09831602871417999,
-0.19905516505241394,
0.41506117582321167,
-0.237693190574646,
-0.057674478739500046,
0.5752300024032593,
-0.016274845227599144,
-0.4153550863265991,
-0.4324452877044678,
-0.12879885733127594,
0.14799022674560547,
0.01903372071683407,
0.9242290258407593,
-0.4751060903072357,
-0.2818092107772827,
0.3252192735671997,
0.7633289098739624,
0.6093352437019348,
0.04362547770142555,
0.3847945034503937,
-0.9124433398246765,
0.07451929152011871,
0.08412069082260132,
0.31867045164108276,
0.05969306081533432,
-0.7216435074806213,
0.19854024052619934,
0.07252383232116699,
-0.28357717394828796,
-0.4403300881385803,
-0.37978699803352356,
-1.0886119604110718,
-0.4042138457298279,
0.6724745631217957,
-0.3176788091659546,
-0.36961284279823303,
-0.28221040964126587,
-0.015764152631163597,
0.04339197278022766,
-0.6865774393081665,
0.531695544719696,
1.121711015701294,
-0.09218659996986389,
-0.4052761495113373,
-0.8536945581436157,
0.5358209013938904,
-0.09912111610174179,
-0.9974713921546936,
0.2022683024406433,
0.33812084794044495,
0.06052348017692566,
0.47823280096054077,
0.3265520930290222,
-0.1345786452293396,
0.31091493368148804,
0.08380692452192307,
-0.2288784235715866,
-0.12925384938716888,
-0.8175677061080933,
-0.31665003299713135,
0.6648333668708801,
-0.11381098628044128,
-0.15974798798561096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08001v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08001v1
|
Xiwu: A Basis Flexible and Learnable LLM for High Energy Physics
| 2024-04-08T07:37:31 | 2024-04-08T07:37:31 |
Zhengde Zhang, Yiyu Zhang, Haodong Yao, Jianwen Luo, Rui Zhao, Bo Huang, Jiameng Zhao, Yipu Liao, Ke Li, Lina Zhao, Jun Cao, Fazhi Qi, Changzheng Yuan
|
hep-ph
|
hep-ph, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, hep-ex, physics.comp-ph, I.2.7
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are undergoing a period of rapid updates and
changes, with state-of-the-art (SOTA) model frequently being replaced. When
applying LLMs to a specific scientific field, it's challenging to acquire
unique domain knowledge while keeping the model itself advanced. To address
this challenge, a sophisticated large language model system named as Xiwu has
been developed, allowing you switch between the most advanced foundation models
and quickly teach the model domain knowledge. In this work, we will report on
the best practices for applying LLMs in the field of high-energy physics (HEP),
including: a seed fission technology is proposed and some data collection and
cleaning tools are developed to quickly obtain domain AI-Ready dataset; a
just-in-time learning system is implemented based on the vector store
technology; an on-the-fly fine-tuning system has been developed to facilitate
rapid training under a specified foundation model. The results show that Xiwu
can smoothly switch between foundation models such as LLaMA, Vicuna, ChatGLM
and Grok-1. The trained Xiwu model is significantly outperformed the benchmark
model on the HEP knowledge question-and-answering and code generation. This
strategy significantly enhances the potential for growth of our model's
performance, with the hope of surpassing GPT-4 as it evolves with the
development of open-source models. This work provides a customized LLM for the
field of HEP, while also offering references for applying LLM to other fields,
the corresponding codes are available on Github.
|
[
0.010751280933618546,
-0.6188732981681824,
0.5760258436203003,
0.2539668679237366,
-0.02336525358259678,
0.19047807157039642,
-0.08400958776473999,
-0.435391902923584,
-0.1343385875225067,
0.3251141309738159,
-0.217335045337677,
-0.4003618061542511,
-0.4305790662765503,
-0.07933762669563293,
-0.5896105766296387,
0.5160449147224426,
-0.3018627464771271,
0.01365785300731659,
-0.08826495707035065,
-0.20958440005779266,
-0.01609848625957966,
-0.46843743324279785,
-0.3952941298484802,
-0.854590654373169,
0.33358556032180786,
0.31242695450782776,
0.640937089920044,
0.8153324723243713,
0.6182043552398682,
0.21933427453041077,
-0.14407683908939362,
-0.09712011367082596,
-0.7290012836456299,
-0.2816450893878937,
-0.4359910786151886,
-0.37725022435188293,
-0.6432345509529114,
0.018673263490200043,
0.8088607788085938,
0.8499785661697388,
-0.14135435223579407,
0.09675972908735275,
-0.08811844885349274,
0.3669109344482422,
-0.5210272073745728,
-0.0018131424440070987,
-0.8245415091514587,
0.18687750399112701,
-0.30019038915634155,
-0.3706601858139038,
-0.4968615472316742,
-0.12768177688121796,
0.12062294781208038,
-0.7670506238937378,
-0.13361918926239014,
0.16421470046043396,
0.8861978650093079,
-0.20235420763492584,
-0.5683269500732422,
0.3876357078552246,
-0.5482537150382996,
1.004068374633789,
-0.7365635633468628,
0.5973846316337585,
0.024935424327850342,
0.3720000684261322,
-0.31144019961357117,
-0.9577562212944031,
-0.3134683668613434,
-0.11798709630966187,
0.1703239381313324,
-0.013930870220065117,
-0.025542624294757843,
0.01162651740014553,
0.2129768431186676,
0.42589956521987915,
-0.5029730200767517,
0.2644023895263672,
-0.12261264771223068,
-0.02509358897805214,
0.5030273795127869,
0.1857304722070694,
0.028947077691555023,
-0.08317866921424866,
-0.5557481050491333,
-0.16848737001419067,
-1.165602684020996,
-0.22311051189899445,
0.25972065329551697,
0.1446172446012497,
-0.05997411906719208,
0.3558976650238037,
-0.3896462023258209,
0.3997357189655304,
-0.04075808823108673,
-0.1354680061340332,
0.23645427823066711,
0.12870009243488312,
-0.5844988822937012,
-0.24508622288703918,
0.5859643816947937,
0.03928329423069954,
-0.28142866492271423,
-0.18852469325065613,
-0.2201284021139145,
-0.11342962086200714,
0.0731516182422638,
-0.8750684857368469,
-0.291187047958374,
0.00319826602935791,
-0.6400877833366394,
-0.26336565613746643,
-0.2536032199859619,
-0.234749898314476,
-0.1898811310529709,
-0.1633225977420807,
0.5952825546264648,
-0.5687649846076965,
-0.32855260372161865,
0.14058701694011688,
-0.06635706126689911,
0.23123160004615784,
0.3521089553833008,
-0.9788058996200562,
0.2523781657218933,
0.4892927408218384,
0.6627733707427979,
-0.2392115592956543,
-0.4207649827003479,
-0.751876950263977,
0.3582887649536133,
-0.18618367612361908,
0.36176666617393494,
-0.42788925766944885,
-0.5038876533508301,
-0.11504469811916351,
-0.07718832045793533,
0.2716383934020996,
-0.3507821559906006,
0.3527231514453888,
-0.7267075777053833,
-0.04948000609874725,
-0.2576826512813568,
-0.8419695496559143,
-0.22883562743663788,
0.1982862651348114,
-0.2702314853668213,
0.969538152217865,
0.40837860107421875,
-0.4987025856971741,
0.07567006349563599,
-0.5689274072647095,
-0.4247216284275055,
0.38286158442497253,
-0.26495692133903503,
-0.3039216995239258,
-0.01057154405862093,
-0.2509313225746155,
0.5283374786376953,
-0.34802159667015076,
0.14075127243995667,
-0.1519429087638855,
-0.302595853805542,
-0.008829268626868725,
-0.22654084861278534,
0.8422318696975708,
0.29343152046203613,
-0.4498707950115204,
0.38386794924736023,
-1.0602518320083618,
0.2464359551668167,
0.22842082381248474,
-0.5731915831565857,
-0.27903833985328674,
0.14273954927921295,
-0.09459441900253296,
-0.008089860901236534,
0.1712985783815384,
-0.4190819263458252,
0.2637803554534912,
-0.33244550228118896,
0.4476328194141388,
0.6898844242095947,
-0.28142181038856506,
0.33182206749916077,
-0.1432521641254425,
0.2335454821586609,
-0.277214378118515,
-0.03651600331068039,
-0.3522585928440094,
-0.36515089869499207,
-0.6200128197669983,
0.2585844099521637,
0.046754367649555206,
0.3440327048301697,
-0.5943505764007568,
0.5002734065055847,
0.26843708753585815,
-0.5325432419776917,
-0.2179342359304428,
0.17555424571037292,
0.20064574480056763,
0.7160347700119019,
0.6031597852706909,
0.22666646540164948,
-0.5867540836334229,
-0.45329880714416504,
-0.18180714547634125,
-0.24390168488025665,
0.04174195975065231,
0.07514525204896927,
0.4575626254081726,
-0.34005051851272583,
0.7488807439804077,
-0.5598155856132507,
0.19435106217861176,
-0.1996413916349411,
0.1801730990409851,
0.21872755885124207,
0.4158422648906708,
0.4638076722621918,
-0.8111684322357178,
-0.4605582654476166,
0.43180012702941895,
-1.1390942335128784,
0.13065771758556366,
0.2006368786096573,
-0.47483551502227783,
-0.2520684599876404,
0.44423648715019226,
-0.40614062547683716,
0.09274724125862122,
0.5105644464492798,
-0.34977632761001587,
0.6174744367599487,
-0.23506972193717957,
0.2430071234703064,
-0.9817756414413452,
0.17632772028446198,
0.28538817167282104,
-0.5192002654075623,
-0.652846097946167,
0.7502391934394836,
0.37024158239364624,
0.022079095244407654,
-0.8550090789794922,
0.574708104133606,
-0.6131414175033569,
-0.05959630757570267,
-0.5807225108146667,
-0.22588597238063812,
-0.1152602955698967,
0.22863826155662537,
0.23487427830696106,
0.5497838854789734,
0.6283780336380005,
-0.793116569519043,
0.4555381238460541,
0.2945168614387512,
-0.5056394934654236,
0.21353167295455933,
-0.5303508043289185,
0.11476459354162216,
0.13859479129314423,
0.058398012071847916,
-0.2834153473377228,
-0.1973869502544403,
-0.1237778291106224,
-0.12040573358535767,
0.29657578468322754,
0.0299312025308609,
-0.38770896196365356,
-0.34649109840393066,
-0.06535153836011887,
0.14979751408100128,
0.8772886395454407,
-0.7686491012573242,
0.44934114813804626,
0.33293062448501587,
0.05283533036708832,
-0.6401684284210205,
-0.3594985604286194,
-0.01380772702395916,
-0.18516328930854797,
-0.834120512008667,
0.689755916595459,
-0.39644673466682434,
-0.3595670461654663,
-0.16709554195404053,
-0.01910933293402195,
0.04883429408073425,
0.3573839068412781,
-0.03006419911980629,
0.33127108216285706,
-0.4960244596004486,
-0.006563609000295401,
0.01702255941927433,
-0.10404396057128906,
0.04057544842362404,
-0.5281779766082764,
0.5872057676315308,
-0.18839779496192932,
-0.16731473803520203,
-0.21338680386543274,
0.18249578773975372,
0.37362179160118103,
0.1909177154302597,
0.5730337500572205,
0.5144172310829163,
-0.6463435292243958,
-0.154748797416687,
-0.17225053906440735,
-0.13727635145187378,
-0.5227751135826111,
0.4228353202342987,
-0.47677427530288696,
-0.7617216110229492,
0.291718989610672,
-0.38308483362197876,
0.5974287390708923,
0.44482484459877014,
0.8519604206085205,
-0.24784213304519653,
0.8734918832778931,
1.1091644763946533,
-0.19169628620147705,
0.5224080681800842,
-0.4267326891422272,
0.0686858594417572,
-0.7261974811553955,
-0.062099065631628036,
-0.4393702745437622,
-0.11079686880111694,
0.04297568276524544,
-0.3682187497615814,
0.41886579990386963,
0.13631457090377808,
-0.2852901816368103,
0.4120604693889618,
-0.19624081254005432,
0.3964390456676483,
0.325277715921402,
-0.10725677758455276,
0.4597739577293396,
0.0009268115391023457,
0.05831850692629814,
0.12807776033878326,
-0.6562913060188293,
-0.3707163333892822,
0.9604632258415222,
0.6318479776382446,
1.0814101696014404,
0.06294045597314835,
0.7095674276351929,
0.04706918075680733,
0.2975880205631256,
-0.6804759502410889,
0.6197426319122314,
-0.12475316971540451,
-0.47197625041007996,
-0.5160895586013794,
-0.5689239501953125,
-0.7186943292617798,
0.4523904621601105,
-0.0899132639169693,
-0.6706146001815796,
-0.18038058280944824,
0.23309925198554993,
-0.3848539888858795,
0.7142258882522583,
-0.3887988328933716,
0.5698423385620117,
-0.2486492097377777,
-0.42553770542144775,
-0.4120224118232727,
-0.5100683569908142,
0.42211851477622986,
0.0012250507716089487,
0.06114377826452255,
-0.3368794620037079,
0.30702662467956543,
0.7896789312362671,
-0.5207356810569763,
0.52515709400177,
-0.08980747312307358,
-0.46502622961997986,
0.2561815083026886,
-0.1146053746342659,
0.5877907872200012,
0.03614720329642296,
-0.46230655908584595,
0.2101643979549408,
-0.30020958185195923,
-0.2512655258178711,
-0.2134651392698288,
0.8849707841873169,
-1.06082022190094,
-0.7677122354507446,
-0.1113247275352478,
-0.801123321056366,
-0.24826569855213165,
0.5554525852203369,
0.5455719232559204,
0.12588775157928467,
-0.33680459856987,
0.365569531917572,
1.022666573524475,
-0.17895209789276123,
0.3023010194301605,
0.5629307627677917,
-0.360892653465271,
0.06540517508983612,
0.9120506644248962,
0.11300420016050339,
0.32966065406799316,
0.6015629172325134,
0.5978219509124756,
0.054134171456098557,
-0.6632324457168579,
-0.4583807587623596,
0.1029045358300209,
-0.8672831654548645,
-0.39841604232788086,
-0.8062074780464172,
-0.499490350484848,
-0.7066994309425354,
-0.48960354924201965,
-0.21698716282844543,
-0.17625552415847778,
-0.3684333264827728,
-0.1629304587841034,
0.4242197871208191,
0.4625188112258911,
0.15899743139743805,
0.4408823847770691,
-0.8868432641029358,
0.5447818636894226,
0.22018902003765106,
0.18600575625896454,
-0.097353495657444,
-0.5511767268180847,
-0.416694313287735,
-0.1436813622713089,
-0.34135082364082336,
-0.7042389512062073,
0.24004000425338745,
0.18552516400814056,
0.751173198223114,
0.2750014066696167,
0.030367257073521614,
0.26930689811706543,
-0.37394392490386963,
0.6153852939605713,
0.5090344548225403,
-0.9758975505828857,
0.5596155524253845,
-0.5446834564208984,
0.4703504741191864,
0.20637840032577515,
0.6330521702766418,
-0.44300374388694763,
-0.22381485998630524,
-0.38157761096954346,
-0.7093506455421448,
0.49503111839294434,
-0.07703666388988495,
0.05580978840589523,
0.21835219860076904,
0.5021899342536926,
0.4685015380382538,
0.14583875238895416,
-0.8981441855430603,
-0.31553322076797485,
-0.13719360530376434,
-0.016151145100593567,
0.3861607313156128,
-0.095308817923069,
-0.20836414396762848,
-0.21996505558490753,
1.1370824575424194,
-0.6479374170303345,
0.08209887146949768,
-0.3269014358520508,
-0.3039948642253876,
-0.5713558197021484,
0.27159151434898376,
-0.03587254509329796,
0.7231125831604004,
-0.28185054659843445,
-0.12820853292942047,
0.19121994078159332,
-0.32776376605033875,
0.3592819273471832,
-0.036135897040367126,
-0.2917924225330353,
-0.24745050072669983,
0.06666368991136551,
0.8225172162055969,
0.31940168142318726,
-0.5082116723060608,
0.19392520189285278,
0.2564384639263153,
-0.5745379328727722,
-0.07921236008405685,
0.3297353982925415,
0.20745037496089935,
0.27448028326034546,
0.3933168649673462,
-0.16575689613819122,
0.13174521923065186,
-0.9247713088989258,
0.07322947680950165,
0.22955910861492157,
-0.0014043597038835287,
-0.24243171513080597,
0.7737489342689514,
0.33165961503982544,
0.07212541252374649,
0.5186548233032227,
-0.13180075585842133,
-0.2760964334011078,
0.4244912564754486,
0.9463964104652405,
0.5607861876487732,
-0.20872272551059723,
0.12149474024772644,
0.11961938440799713,
0.05776084586977959,
-0.2618711292743683,
0.532167375087738,
0.12615332007408142,
-0.7607647776603699,
-0.3302978575229645,
-0.5700545907020569,
-0.6971955895423889,
0.2366030514240265,
-0.5907918214797974,
0.6211751699447632,
-0.7195651531219482,
0.05960574001073837,
-0.02830595150589943,
0.10289858281612396,
-0.47570452094078064,
0.2741539776325226,
0.2557283341884613,
1.2929167747497559,
-0.582403302192688,
1.2901034355163574,
0.7389488816261292,
0.008898443542420864,
-0.72147136926651,
-0.17708030343055725,
0.08660395443439484,
-0.8291028141975403,
0.7461410760879517,
-0.15797024965286255,
-0.13613781332969666,
0.1637600213289261,
-0.5579106211662292,
-1.19694983959198,
1.2926743030548096,
0.3864372670650482,
-0.925304651260376,
-0.4004324972629547,
-0.3703526258468628,
0.21106049418449402,
-0.12821412086486816,
0.07042457163333893,
0.6262582540512085,
0.35907718539237976,
0.19157564640045166,
-0.6073678135871887,
-0.07071198523044586,
-0.08310584723949432,
-0.31127607822418213,
0.3888743221759796,
-1.1302553415298462,
1.1378737688064575,
-0.354626327753067,
-0.12027950584888458,
0.28815510869026184,
1.232935905456543,
0.4356038272380829,
0.31719139218330383,
0.3912748396396637,
0.34413275122642517,
0.965587317943573,
0.06887827813625336,
0.7423388361930847,
-0.34086260199546814,
0.509863018989563,
0.7096483111381531,
-0.9599655866622925,
0.8180322051048279,
0.21325808763504028,
-0.19492454826831818,
0.5671254396438599,
0.20065173506736755,
-0.01326074916869402,
0.3831222653388977,
0.284616082906723,
-0.23436538875102997,
-0.2539205849170685,
0.24667133390903473,
-0.526066780090332,
0.22572433948516846,
0.584148108959198,
-0.011189842596650124,
-0.24076513946056366,
0.177135169506073,
0.09017393738031387,
-0.008285533636808395,
-0.4080640971660614,
0.3070051670074463,
0.4642259180545807,
-0.19219069182872772,
0.5238943099975586,
0.3505973219871521,
0.8286557197570801,
-1.007044792175293,
0.06172969937324524,
0.03730347752571106,
0.14782598614692688,
-0.47849202156066895,
-0.690538763999939,
0.10304949432611465,
0.108866848051548,
-0.24425290524959564,
-0.2536494731903076,
0.9738045930862427,
-0.23758572340011597,
-0.3256000876426697,
0.3125903308391571,
0.4108172357082367,
-0.005217198748141527,
0.326470285654068,
-0.5233719944953918,
0.15592941641807556,
-0.13116373121738434,
-0.3950062096118927,
0.5808373689651489,
0.11225888878107071,
-0.2358318567276001,
0.6919946074485779,
0.5183311700820923,
-0.009982757270336151,
-0.10993214696645737,
0.1436752825975418,
0.7936106324195862,
-0.850632905960083,
-0.7049563527107239,
-0.5003646612167358,
0.29754671454429626,
0.026716215535998344,
-0.1584233194589615,
0.8206661343574524,
0.3831152617931366,
0.6510539650917053,
0.2572349011898041,
1.2222107648849487,
-0.029141314327716827,
0.48177197575569153,
-0.7833734154701233,
0.727250337600708,
-0.45215028524398804,
0.2134527564048767,
-0.1998797208070755,
-0.8902810215950012,
-0.14937350153923035,
0.6312206983566284,
0.0893908143043518,
-0.07095365971326828,
0.7707335352897644,
0.18076279759407043,
-0.06399955600500107,
-0.02110723778605461,
0.760851263999939,
0.3884717524051666,
0.7930696606636047,
0.660876989364624,
0.7703478932380676,
-0.5785060524940491,
0.26619186997413635,
-0.12076595425605774,
-0.43325185775756836,
-0.561882495880127,
-0.9987051486968994,
-0.6907131671905518,
-0.20361705124378204,
-0.6003426313400269,
-0.20208331942558289,
-0.0023849850986152887,
1.0328361988067627,
0.9679215550422668,
-0.49325883388519287,
-0.4826575815677643,
0.11384979635477066,
-0.15148423612117767,
-0.3506024181842804,
-0.1931176632642746,
0.1797516644001007,
-0.14728178083896637,
-0.5277875661849976,
1.0384851694107056,
0.4361391067504883,
0.07896295189857483,
-0.46887022256851196,
-0.3796156942844391,
-0.15612833201885223,
0.05134938284754753,
0.8271291255950928,
0.49114370346069336,
-0.3783101737499237,
-0.27328965067863464,
0.3507276773452759,
-0.15603190660476685,
0.1612214595079422,
1.0010261535644531,
-0.8881771564483643,
-0.03578118607401848,
0.5661930441856384,
0.8096049427986145,
0.4510500431060791,
-0.4593135118484497,
0.792889416217804,
-0.5463663339614868,
-0.04132131487131119,
0.0264055784791708,
0.811275064945221,
0.2988692820072174,
-0.7137793302536011,
0.4365800619125366,
0.3411828577518463,
-0.5511577129364014,
-0.7238383889198303,
0.2214204967021942,
-0.86359703540802,
-0.40761619806289673,
1.1840630769729614,
-0.3426460325717926,
-0.21093785762786865,
0.14545853435993195,
0.05904227867722511,
0.1953483372926712,
-0.11146162450313568,
0.6417603492736816,
0.46307507157325745,
-0.1809651106595993,
-0.010329103097319603,
-0.27348414063453674,
0.14301525056362152,
0.4917760193347931,
-1.0566298961639404,
0.14381958544254303,
0.12863357365131378,
0.3782320022583008,
0.04264729470014572,
0.7302657961845398,
-0.08613318204879761,
0.4630518853664398,
0.017360592260956764,
0.16890504956245422,
0.04726233705878258,
-0.46846815943717957,
-0.2216717004776001,
0.26107603311538696,
0.20734506845474243,
0.20962205529212952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08681v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08681v1
|
EFSA: Towards Event-Level Financial Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-04-08T07:36:26 | 2024-04-08T07:36:26 |
Tianyu Chen, Yiming Zhang, Guoxin Yu, Dapeng Zhang, Li Zeng, Qing He, Xiang Ao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we extend financial sentiment analysis~(FSA) to event-level
since events usually serve as the subject of the sentiment in financial text.
Though extracting events from the financial text may be conducive to accurate
sentiment predictions, it has specialized challenges due to the lengthy and
discontinuity of events in a financial text. To this end, we reconceptualize
the event extraction as a classification task by designing a categorization
comprising coarse-grained and fine-grained event categories. Under this
setting, we formulate the \textbf{E}vent-Level \textbf{F}inancial
\textbf{S}entiment \textbf{A}nalysis~(\textbf{EFSA} for short) task that
outputs quintuples consisting of (company, industry, coarse-grained event,
fine-grained event, sentiment) from financial text. A large-scale Chinese
dataset containing $12,160$ news articles and $13,725$ quintuples is publicized
as a brand new testbed for our task. A four-hop Chain-of-Thought LLM-based
approach is devised for this task. Systematically investigations are conducted
on our dataset, and the empirical results demonstrate the benchmarking scores
of existing methods and our proposed method can reach the current
state-of-the-art. Our dataset and framework implementation are available at
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/EFSA-645E
|
[
-0.023182455450296402,
-0.7911425232887268,
0.12044024467468262,
0.5709061622619629,
-0.28134414553642273,
0.3218050003051758,
0.24825558066368103,
-0.6539204716682434,
0.5096849203109741,
0.04523376747965813,
-0.3932763934135437,
-0.5617464184761047,
-0.4555020034313202,
-0.04846931993961334,
-0.4531600773334503,
1.2967257499694824,
-0.027114663273096085,
-0.20812596380710602,
0.050104763358831406,
0.1832726001739502,
0.2858974039554596,
-0.41931721568107605,
-1.1531436443328857,
0.01695369742810726,
0.5445118546485901,
0.20513363182544708,
0.22808468341827393,
0.033383406698703766,
0.6977340579032898,
0.2328045815229416,
-0.26694363355636597,
0.01306989323347807,
-0.45783719420433044,
-0.12099101394414902,
0.04987216740846634,
-0.2834005653858185,
-0.9060927629470825,
0.24925710260868073,
0.4224150776863098,
0.3857814371585846,
-0.37217727303504944,
0.3031819760799408,
0.19915875792503357,
0.7821553349494934,
-0.5812158584594727,
0.6544879078865051,
-0.22750772535800934,
0.33046478033065796,
-0.3224168121814728,
-0.32533204555511475,
-0.36921635270118713,
-0.19704686105251312,
0.4291869103908539,
-0.6586379408836365,
-0.07586676627397537,
0.23394256830215454,
1.1992628574371338,
-0.06116688996553421,
-0.38701513409614563,
-0.40697532892227173,
-0.5790440440177917,
0.7969662547111511,
-0.5165998339653015,
0.26493027806282043,
0.1088702529668808,
0.18261905014514923,
-0.00910844188183546,
-0.7396357655525208,
-0.3396187722682953,
0.15685825049877167,
0.2104509472846985,
0.29929229617118835,
-0.4004732370376587,
0.08210545033216476,
0.12130709737539291,
0.7673008441925049,
-0.0883205235004425,
-0.11955339461565018,
-0.15984685719013214,
-0.07136283069849014,
0.6481814980506897,
0.1429249346256256,
0.020678596571087837,
-0.3113795518875122,
-0.6508753299713135,
-0.22408843040466309,
-0.6517184376716614,
0.6467289924621582,
0.34541574120521545,
0.31061580777168274,
-0.26582473516464233,
0.14173875749111176,
-0.6075113415718079,
0.10875635594129562,
0.36163556575775146,
-0.33343443274497986,
0.554000973701477,
-0.5294026136398315,
-0.46398547291755676,
0.020889978855848312,
0.5674870014190674,
0.43424150347709656,
0.175643652677536,
0.022414017468690872,
-0.5278229713439941,
-0.4073062837123871,
-0.10223720222711563,
-0.8241087198257446,
-0.2091638594865799,
0.3098785877227783,
-0.7926130294799805,
-0.6800559163093567,
0.3369046151638031,
-1.2568451166152954,
-0.3468339443206787,
-0.0712968185544014,
0.4853323996067047,
0.0686057060956955,
-0.37571531534194946,
0.045042432844638824,
-0.15455973148345947,
0.733834445476532,
0.1310979425907135,
-0.6499499678611755,
0.25430554151535034,
0.8203256130218506,
0.7155385613441467,
0.21648502349853516,
0.03182189166545868,
-0.8403075337409973,
0.14156097173690796,
-0.24662061035633087,
0.9379178881645203,
-0.516851544380188,
-0.34546422958374023,
0.1537257432937622,
-0.1994204819202423,
0.09990500658750534,
-0.31224045157432556,
0.4890798032283783,
-0.473572701215744,
0.0339176282286644,
-0.46471264958381653,
-0.2834186553955078,
-0.3118106722831726,
0.2620704174041748,
-0.5346983671188354,
0.9538328051567078,
0.07926478981971741,
-0.7337817549705505,
0.7214611768722534,
-0.7770203351974487,
-0.5954560041427612,
-0.26497647166252136,
-0.15313275158405304,
-0.3548097014427185,
-0.016935192048549652,
0.48233887553215027,
0.6620453596115112,
-0.4763151705265045,
0.24311743676662445,
-0.6746203303337097,
-0.09929938614368439,
0.4318782389163971,
-0.3318387269973755,
0.38651397824287415,
0.22722017765045166,
-0.3491605222225189,
0.019044293090701103,
-0.9131577014923096,
-0.4180276095867157,
0.09483753889799118,
-0.05461924523115158,
-0.574146032333374,
0.3816603422164917,
0.16879582405090332,
0.24186882376670837,
0.5615578889846802,
-0.782163679599762,
-0.05220247060060501,
-0.8491351008415222,
0.3148280382156372,
0.9675686359405518,
0.2745780050754547,
0.4338182210922241,
-0.056866176426410675,
0.5343325734138489,
0.33535608649253845,
0.4204515516757965,
-0.19399218261241913,
-0.2850662171840668,
-0.6717285513877869,
-0.1741374135017395,
0.16294637322425842,
0.48243388533592224,
-0.40798693895339966,
0.09730520844459534,
-0.0322541669011116,
-0.1523749679327011,
-0.23652489483356476,
-0.025704102590680122,
0.13789448142051697,
0.27779266238212585,
0.13241921365261078,
0.18861672282218933,
-0.5397123098373413,
-0.808465838432312,
-0.3909129500389099,
-0.40099039673805237,
0.037803854793310165,
-0.1399531066417694,
0.16261956095695496,
0.20144101977348328,
0.777780294418335,
-0.7833335995674133,
-0.6121195554733276,
0.04130055755376816,
0.34654539823532104,
0.4380652606487274,
0.22958412766456604,
0.7857688069343567,
-0.7546345591545105,
-0.1695014238357544,
0.4072769284248352,
-0.4900629222393036,
0.0394323393702507,
-0.42479267716407776,
-0.09112486988306046,
0.2949279248714447,
0.49769917130470276,
-0.18324771523475647,
0.4648113548755646,
0.2350374162197113,
-0.6066387891769409,
-0.02610115148127079,
0.32553327083587646,
0.0031428008805960417,
-1.2994884252548218,
-0.03577949106693268,
0.51111900806427,
0.16806559264659882,
-0.5311908721923828,
-0.04811543598771095,
-0.2398136705160141,
0.2273682802915573,
-0.03045971505343914,
0.4286975860595703,
-0.13132353127002716,
-0.24893219769001007,
-0.23685352504253387,
0.19002197682857513,
0.04273246228694916,
0.49818360805511475,
-0.24463988840579987,
0.329208642244339,
0.48058125376701355,
-0.19181793928146362,
0.20800621807575226,
-0.021138712763786316,
-0.020349951460957527,
0.6071641445159912,
-0.5195440649986267,
-0.10408902168273926,
0.08225907385349274,
0.1935310959815979,
-1.2602444887161255,
0.09536377340555191,
0.42344430088996887,
-0.4322538375854492,
0.25880417227745056,
0.41654276847839355,
-0.21077513694763184,
-0.2066776156425476,
-0.5952713489532471,
0.047986797988414764,
0.09551206231117249,
-0.5346410274505615,
1.0999228954315186,
0.4761641323566437,
-0.5236660838127136,
-0.8164920806884766,
-0.4861328899860382,
0.00153162085916847,
-0.32928749918937683,
-0.49070385098457336,
0.23437491059303284,
0.1900782734155655,
-0.4470568895339966,
-0.04679957032203674,
-0.383928120136261,
-0.015299875289201736,
0.18100495636463165,
0.21835856139659882,
0.6242929100990295,
-0.24992641806602478,
-0.09188651293516159,
0.31580647826194763,
-0.25807562470436096,
0.3452622890472412,
-0.16826596856117249,
0.011508076451718807,
-0.4521033763885498,
0.09665456414222717,
-0.5302208065986633,
0.2304205596446991,
0.30850523710250854,
-0.21777266263961792,
0.5096967816352844,
0.46503183245658875,
-0.7348908185958862,
-0.23191560804843903,
-0.3724197745323181,
0.3307541012763977,
-0.520829975605011,
0.34754079580307007,
-0.4651505649089813,
-0.9472551345825195,
0.9345231056213379,
0.1477959007024765,
0.4709084630012512,
0.9134135246276855,
0.40845927596092224,
-0.11307451874017715,
0.9555713534355164,
0.6597020626068115,
-0.3352893888950348,
0.4948152005672455,
-0.18929354846477509,
0.4873436689376831,
-0.4425032436847687,
-0.3928675353527069,
-0.6202813982963562,
-0.3758170008659363,
-0.4386700391769409,
0.036545079201459885,
0.07781530171632767,
0.059619441628456116,
-0.1386154294013977,
-0.08292247354984283,
0.008964646607637405,
0.37346819043159485,
0.06049453839659691,
-0.1317417025566101,
0.16095823049545288,
-0.13285453617572784,
0.05448604002594948,
0.2964825928211212,
-0.3398253917694092,
-0.2343670278787613,
0.9110226035118103,
0.828310489654541,
0.4906536936759949,
-0.11180426925420761,
1.0217269659042358,
0.30067670345306396,
0.6317756175994873,
-0.9804254770278931,
0.3561818301677704,
-0.4120156764984131,
-0.17044278979301453,
-0.30116188526153564,
-0.5509710311889648,
-0.38284894824028015,
-0.047757312655448914,
-0.039636220782995224,
-0.49670201539993286,
0.7586648464202881,
-0.2804616391658783,
-0.8892596364021301,
0.03242718428373337,
-0.4085266590118408,
0.6179043054580688,
0.30796903371810913,
0.03512656316161156,
-0.10799683630466461,
-0.12430717051029205,
0.5310731530189514,
-0.4164430499076843,
0.5908957123756409,
-0.12078607082366943,
-0.1737828552722931,
0.9873283505439758,
-0.14905743300914764,
1.0082041025161743,
-0.40268027782440186,
-0.60372394323349,
0.3755117952823639,
-0.2922418415546417,
0.5999397039413452,
0.2567935883998871,
0.006303997710347176,
-0.030082372948527336,
0.3977607488632202,
-0.32376062870025635,
-0.4824243485927582,
0.7510004043579102,
-0.7357954978942871,
-0.33223044872283936,
-0.5847781300544739,
-0.3222510814666748,
-0.2615453600883484,
-0.27943262457847595,
-0.2759660482406616,
0.5273921489715576,
-0.23230868577957153,
0.15221455693244934,
0.10199569165706635,
-0.03971599042415619,
0.7781527638435364,
0.4558050334453583,
-0.42831841111183167,
-0.6730405688285828,
1.1296758651733398,
0.19786454737186432,
-0.21260109543800354,
0.4427298903465271,
0.26719680428504944,
-0.3805027902126312,
-0.5646076202392578,
-0.0034507736563682556,
-0.09621808677911758,
-0.7921127080917358,
-0.45814090967178345,
-0.4406551420688629,
-0.14298680424690247,
-0.4469051659107208,
-0.2537612020969391,
-0.19226497411727905,
-0.40293195843696594,
-0.5996867418289185,
-0.5524557828903198,
0.32961714267730713,
0.724956750869751,
-0.1435835212469101,
0.18275758624076843,
-1.0911327600479126,
0.2771278917789459,
0.20041432976722717,
0.24050135910511017,
0.33117416501045227,
-0.40461084246635437,
-0.4042357802391052,
-0.19823145866394043,
-0.3519767224788666,
-0.747650146484375,
0.4168072044849396,
0.40656226873397827,
0.4835735261440277,
1.298677682876587,
0.1971040666103363,
0.8054470419883728,
0.11855896562337875,
0.8200144171714783,
0.3519878387451172,
-1.0661534070968628,
0.498222678899765,
-0.3287249803543091,
-0.24849697947502136,
0.3886365294456482,
0.18657620251178741,
-0.47105520963668823,
-0.6336594223976135,
-0.644251823425293,
-0.9624561071395874,
0.7995438575744629,
0.07802645862102509,
0.04184042662382126,
-0.4164062440395355,
0.633587121963501,
-0.022918451577425003,
0.13770967721939087,
-0.6532920598983765,
-0.008856192231178284,
-0.14557531476020813,
-0.3542161285877228,
0.11485286056995392,
-0.3297019898891449,
0.11497993767261505,
-0.1542518138885498,
0.7002122402191162,
-0.22384566068649292,
-0.05435645207762718,
0.18994957208633423,
0.3825896382331848,
-0.3826107680797577,
0.0038771096151322126,
0.23992840945720673,
0.6046447157859802,
-0.35313671827316284,
-0.17612671852111816,
0.1909417361021042,
-0.43186071515083313,
-0.008777080103754997,
0.3460279405117035,
-0.028479458764195442,
-0.3251132667064667,
0.3468513488769531,
0.35011497139930725,
0.6690492630004883,
-0.6203399300575256,
0.6007546186447144,
-0.15722882747650146,
-0.33289679884910583,
-0.3648090958595276,
-0.23389460146427155,
-0.08668331056833267,
0.7453494668006897,
0.9213958382606506,
-0.13563090562820435,
0.41580697894096375,
-0.5658891797065735,
0.4607914686203003,
0.19356165826320648,
-0.38105273246765137,
-0.6111196279525757,
0.4105023145675659,
0.636012077331543,
0.3777475655078888,
0.29292410612106323,
-0.26722094416618347,
-0.43466895818710327,
0.8134439587593079,
0.218370258808136,
1.4692925214767456,
-0.12704454362392426,
0.3523544669151306,
0.3309726417064667,
0.32075709104537964,
0.008243970572948456,
0.7580164074897766,
0.12101607769727707,
-0.8002524375915527,
-0.7216281890869141,
-1.2487573623657227,
-0.2112530618906021,
-0.0654534175992012,
-0.916448175907135,
0.09716647863388062,
-0.748292088508606,
-0.14310650527477264,
0.3100058138370514,
0.20549705624580383,
-0.26784849166870117,
0.219004824757576,
0.3924042284488678,
0.9765964150428772,
-0.7849031686782837,
0.5367830395698547,
0.6660848259925842,
-0.5151791572570801,
-0.6192253828048706,
0.11881857365369797,
0.05709464102983475,
-0.39868801832199097,
0.7693607807159424,
0.18876101076602936,
-0.04570579156279564,
-0.1782243847846985,
-0.36430808901786804,
-0.8492686748504639,
1.0823655128479004,
-0.30877065658569336,
-0.5375914573669434,
-0.26106634736061096,
0.09885997325181961,
0.3777892589569092,
-0.7799591422080994,
-0.2433483749628067,
0.7078033685684204,
0.519692063331604,
0.32360512018203735,
-0.6037970781326294,
0.031570930033922195,
-0.4694463908672333,
-0.25283920764923096,
0.42145001888275146,
-0.9646070599555969,
0.76645827293396,
-0.05630071088671684,
-0.23538070917129517,
-0.04546996206045151,
1.3249653577804565,
0.0443534292280674,
0.9563750624656677,
0.6187589764595032,
0.3517138957977295,
0.8266324400901794,
-0.2624865770339966,
0.7500300407409668,
-0.29957079887390137,
0.5804946422576904,
0.6208142638206482,
-0.38924241065979004,
1.1530354022979736,
0.5056540369987488,
-0.473713755607605,
0.35542505979537964,
0.9068037867546082,
0.15750795602798462,
0.36512354016304016,
0.0797501727938652,
-0.11940278857946396,
-0.27679070830345154,
-0.04441174864768982,
-0.0781361386179924,
0.6058869957923889,
0.4713216722011566,
-0.3581330180168152,
-0.19694596529006958,
0.05980796739459038,
-0.12773749232292175,
-0.21521596610546112,
-0.6570717692375183,
0.8311691284179688,
0.49545013904571533,
-0.03252561017870903,
-0.23899322748184204,
0.11812641471624374,
0.7150824069976807,
-0.44628196954727173,
0.13292443752288818,
-0.15926386415958405,
0.10413063317537308,
-0.15265792608261108,
-0.650883138179779,
0.5061571002006531,
0.051680345088243484,
-0.16369414329528809,
-0.15091051161289215,
0.7610910534858704,
-0.05377303063869476,
-0.5480620861053467,
0.395350843667984,
0.3672877848148346,
-0.19998155534267426,
-0.08930475264787674,
-0.4876946806907654,
-0.33185333013534546,
0.06826659291982651,
-0.6616762280464172,
0.5300561785697937,
0.7454802989959717,
0.1246279925107956,
0.1867004781961441,
0.9212507009506226,
-0.2329990267753601,
-0.32688456773757935,
0.11144517362117767,
0.9201927781105042,
-1.0722908973693848,
-0.8611391186714172,
-0.6769993305206299,
0.12101241946220398,
0.04773066192865372,
-0.6046187877655029,
0.38035833835601807,
0.46568283438682556,
0.6353116035461426,
0.19929787516593933,
0.4337572753429413,
0.10575044900178909,
0.23303115367889404,
-0.6148672699928284,
0.6409754157066345,
-0.5769950151443481,
0.25500333309173584,
-0.562615156173706,
-0.7837111949920654,
-0.1831638664007187,
0.4553806185722351,
-0.2975766658782959,
-0.2205875962972641,
0.598388135433197,
0.4340585172176361,
0.28624799847602844,
0.7725129723548889,
0.0940459743142128,
0.2176642119884491,
0.3050679564476013,
0.46554556488990784,
0.9658337831497192,
-0.45745477080345154,
0.4809635877609253,
-0.3206365406513214,
-0.3913581967353821,
-0.18037523329257965,
-0.981385350227356,
-0.6313738822937012,
-0.47735920548439026,
-0.44553592801094055,
-0.14210140705108643,
-0.3942776024341583,
0.9642919898033142,
-0.12018783390522003,
-0.9390448331832886,
-0.2401963472366333,
0.35267895460128784,
-0.11967365443706512,
-0.3772817552089691,
-0.3440621495246887,
0.5229781866073608,
-0.5883817076683044,
-0.778145968914032,
0.1672925055027008,
0.5801823139190674,
-0.0040104081854224205,
-0.2412438690662384,
0.21135598421096802,
-0.05026339739561081,
0.46174076199531555,
0.9461968541145325,
0.047929659485816956,
-0.5351358652114868,
-0.46235862374305725,
0.1680985987186432,
0.1081056296825409,
-0.20282940566539764,
0.5600205063819885,
-0.298129677772522,
0.014552113600075245,
0.5945559144020081,
0.7073121666908264,
0.1901589035987854,
-0.07535787671804428,
0.46132856607437134,
-0.631560206413269,
-0.06351033598184586,
-0.13214744627475739,
0.48552483320236206,
-0.3320130705833435,
-0.5953388214111328,
0.2676287889480591,
0.1730414479970932,
-0.18212029337882996,
-0.7798139452934265,
-0.4720121920108795,
-1.225480318069458,
-0.05896221473813057,
1.0057576894760132,
-0.3755914270877838,
-0.571444034576416,
0.12462160736322403,
0.05368458852171898,
0.10764130204916,
-0.7116078734397888,
0.7758615016937256,
0.9450935125350952,
-0.03196002542972565,
-0.003481972496956587,
-0.3220519423484802,
0.5243383646011353,
0.14479447901248932,
-0.8092735409736633,
0.28544852137565613,
0.36281251907348633,
-0.0898987278342247,
0.3021670877933502,
0.6695998311042786,
-0.22147217392921448,
0.4740392863750458,
-0.03736652061343193,
-0.16493859887123108,
0.053929947316646576,
-0.5163043737411499,
-0.37621450424194336,
0.690933108329773,
-0.16337385773658752,
-0.28335320949554443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05250v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05250v1
|
Interpreting Themes from Educational Stories
| 2024-04-08T07:26:27 | 2024-04-08T07:26:27 |
Yigeng Zhang, Fabio A. González, Thamar Solorio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reading comprehension continues to be a crucial research focus in the NLP
community. Recent advances in Machine Reading Comprehension (MRC) have mostly
centered on literal comprehension, referring to the surface-level understanding
of content. In this work, we focus on the next level - interpretive
comprehension, with a particular emphasis on inferring the themes of a
narrative text. We introduce the first dataset specifically designed for
interpretive comprehension of educational narratives, providing corresponding
well-edited theme texts. The dataset spans a variety of genres and cultural
origins and includes human-annotated theme keywords with varying levels of
granularity. We further formulate NLP tasks under different abstractions of
interpretive comprehension toward the main idea of a story. After conducting
extensive experiments with state-of-the-art methods, we found the task to be
both challenging and significant for NLP research. The dataset and source code
have been made publicly available to the research community at
https://github.com/RiTUAL-UH/EduStory.
|
[
-0.30876970291137695,
-0.560928463935852,
0.5218186974525452,
-0.000003043919377887505,
-0.5715824365615845,
0.36816978454589844,
-0.06989773362874985,
-0.3480958640575409,
0.26084187626838684,
0.6564949154853821,
-1.0268956422805786,
-0.6549488306045532,
-0.5320112705230713,
0.3542592227458954,
-0.4833996891975403,
1.1354738473892212,
-0.2626616656780243,
-0.41645127534866333,
-0.7405481338500977,
-0.040984369814395905,
-0.6132129430770874,
-0.19085679948329926,
-0.5264661312103271,
-0.46486926078796387,
0.7484935522079468,
0.5892935395240784,
0.24567410349845886,
0.9968820214271545,
0.5035539865493774,
-0.006036374252289534,
-0.24869652092456818,
0.09505044668912888,
-0.5327325463294983,
0.3261162340641022,
-0.30554768443107605,
-0.5023735165596008,
0.024755695834755898,
0.09503750503063202,
0.36472105979919434,
0.7859563827514648,
-0.09655946493148804,
0.3487815260887146,
0.49697914719581604,
0.899607241153717,
-0.5099020600318909,
0.4184439182281494,
-0.535216748714447,
0.4141835570335388,
-0.0857623815536499,
-0.5956248641014099,
-0.5480020046234131,
-0.10681027173995972,
0.39605075120925903,
-0.9155687093734741,
0.3966311514377594,
0.12295085191726685,
0.695366621017456,
0.4078229069709778,
-0.36284181475639343,
-0.832278311252594,
-0.31575116515159607,
0.736236035823822,
-0.10058129578828812,
0.1766061782836914,
0.9332945942878723,
0.04509222134947777,
0.42877158522605896,
-0.9353829026222229,
-0.37020981311798096,
0.05659172683954239,
-0.17740751802921295,
0.5520395636558533,
-0.04223356023430824,
-0.24404917657375336,
0.08484087139368057,
0.31911155581474304,
-0.8130559921264648,
-0.287898451089859,
-0.5960301160812378,
0.18651962280273438,
0.33806008100509644,
0.4486595094203949,
0.2627770006656647,
-0.5328339338302612,
-0.40600502490997314,
-0.038147762417793274,
-0.36311018466949463,
0.29691141843795776,
0.23580068349838257,
0.29598966240882874,
-0.1358761042356491,
0.6452232003211975,
-0.073904849588871,
0.7574225068092346,
-0.32915034890174866,
-0.21021968126296997,
-0.00807054154574871,
-0.38027340173721313,
-0.014163084328174591,
0.34005922079086304,
0.09241335839033127,
0.6080136299133301,
0.6476173996925354,
-0.0690283551812172,
-0.11698057502508163,
0.036905545741319656,
0.5911222100257874,
-0.4801613390445709,
-0.31940147280693054,
0.17277228832244873,
-0.496625691652298,
-0.5233407616615295,
-0.07380002737045288,
-0.9086138606071472,
-0.49545517563819885,
-0.7674157619476318,
0.13019761443138123,
-0.5651909112930298,
0.07180789113044739,
0.3881931006908417,
-0.33860552310943604,
0.12275608628988266,
0.014697904698550701,
-1.0651503801345825,
0.005615281406790018,
0.9599826335906982,
0.7962960004806519,
-0.021272942423820496,
-0.2479686141014099,
-0.008716775104403496,
0.14661827683448792,
-0.2950935661792755,
0.7737745642662048,
-0.8242208361625671,
-0.18747620284557343,
0.16510121524333954,
-0.20993393659591675,
-0.3687170147895813,
-0.21449576318264008,
0.9220311641693115,
-0.5069886445999146,
0.3364640474319458,
-0.024264322593808174,
-0.5946977734565735,
-0.30291748046875,
0.32584893703460693,
-0.5113116502761841,
0.6750770211219788,
0.037286415696144104,
-0.9756009578704834,
0.18547052145004272,
-0.616763174533844,
-0.5159288644790649,
-0.2021293044090271,
0.054760292172431946,
0.09789638966321945,
0.22471442818641663,
0.7146570682525635,
0.000012840854651585687,
-0.21707555651664734,
0.33531156182289124,
0.20230431854724884,
-0.31322503089904785,
-0.03280132636427879,
-0.4944986402988434,
0.9330851435661316,
0.4830194413661957,
0.02751477248966694,
-0.26618051528930664,
-0.7342261075973511,
-0.13118323683738708,
0.2977343201637268,
0.15583421289920807,
-0.528184175491333,
0.23228004574775696,
-0.021052982658147812,
0.01913728378713131,
0.14154204726219177,
-0.1260744035243988,
-0.045192766934633255,
-0.22275792062282562,
0.30780407786369324,
0.5684689879417419,
0.11028026044368744,
0.3625246584415436,
-0.3497399091720581,
0.9561432003974915,
-0.30255427956581116,
-0.12100106477737427,
-0.8983802795410156,
-0.5111231207847595,
-0.25715336203575134,
-0.17986594140529633,
0.2322762906551361,
0.5284977555274963,
-1.0469160079956055,
0.2717891335487366,
-0.2313232570886612,
-0.19196298718452454,
-0.6377608180046082,
-0.13919399678707123,
0.17565961182117462,
0.7151813507080078,
0.4568709135055542,
0.17026227712631226,
-0.3850069046020508,
-0.6194141507148743,
-0.5918110609054565,
-0.406136155128479,
-0.4529332220554352,
0.29867732524871826,
0.38287538290023804,
0.09725884348154068,
1.1181031465530396,
-0.8209426999092102,
-0.30607905983924866,
-0.3662424683570862,
0.14748065173625946,
0.27288317680358887,
0.4734722673892975,
0.509053111076355,
-0.6283908486366272,
-0.41227489709854126,
-0.1096845418214798,
-1.0195485353469849,
-0.2357965111732483,
-0.3840290307998657,
-0.31712251901626587,
-0.4398191273212433,
0.3511488735675812,
-0.28168246150016785,
0.1759694218635559,
0.3968658149242401,
-0.8606897592544556,
0.5230376124382019,
0.11584693938493729,
0.03950922191143036,
-0.9331684708595276,
-0.10959401726722717,
0.13414837419986725,
-0.01824451982975006,
-0.3869186341762543,
0.35374751687049866,
0.0031161298975348473,
-0.18139250576496124,
0.02111455798149109,
0.4347284138202667,
-0.015262017957866192,
0.16746017336845398,
-0.16834236681461334,
0.5679896473884583,
0.6564632654190063,
0.23668983578681946,
0.28043949604034424,
0.5724930167198181,
0.5219350457191467,
-0.17084646224975586,
0.2899692952632904,
0.5697030425071716,
-0.3909553587436676,
0.98578941822052,
-0.6222715377807617,
0.21595889329910278,
-0.5068759322166443,
0.5664303302764893,
-0.6216602921485901,
-0.24476654827594757,
0.4784725308418274,
-0.5779702067375183,
0.13804180920124054,
-0.24700471758842468,
-0.5756228566169739,
-0.3323323130607605,
-0.10359752923250198,
0.05731874704360962,
0.2832234799861908,
-0.9598010778427124,
0.37070295214653015,
0.13300494849681854,
-0.2993939518928528,
-0.7240622043609619,
-0.5209054946899414,
0.23774948716163635,
-0.583956241607666,
-0.4129389226436615,
0.027012361213564873,
0.03776073083281517,
-0.3606789708137512,
-0.05411503091454506,
-0.5595994591712952,
-0.38076141476631165,
0.08601178228855133,
-0.03566351160407066,
0.29448220133781433,
-0.4945124387741089,
0.17630907893180847,
0.49337688088417053,
-0.3221648335456848,
0.4948429465293884,
-0.449345201253891,
0.2436516433954239,
0.13372300565242767,
-0.06135006621479988,
-0.2724148631095886,
0.2721506357192993,
0.3881432116031647,
-0.33258378505706787,
0.922256588935852,
0.507860004901886,
-0.4017951190471649,
-0.3098299503326416,
0.24094992876052856,
-0.518835723400116,
-0.40963509678840637,
0.16558882594108582,
-0.6227450370788574,
-0.4997560679912567,
0.3298104703426361,
0.293256551027298,
0.4302866458892822,
0.4344481825828552,
-0.09416260570287704,
-0.7106489539146423,
0.598726749420166,
0.1895550936460495,
0.1753053069114685,
0.33669012784957886,
-0.13888141512870789,
-0.10667761415243149,
-0.7304639220237732,
-0.3015735149383545,
-0.6088179349899292,
-0.5229661464691162,
-0.15778614580631256,
-0.20251008868217468,
-0.07622750103473663,
0.2017064243555069,
-0.03823370859026909,
0.20849065482616425,
-0.4027167558670044,
0.7824736833572388,
0.3571450114250183,
0.10838724672794342,
0.6987225413322449,
0.3286547064781189,
0.1003374308347702,
-0.38376662135124207,
-0.4295600950717926,
-0.8380091190338135,
1.0794591903686523,
0.5829460024833679,
0.505750834941864,
-0.14073318243026733,
0.616969645023346,
0.28992462158203125,
0.21550603210926056,
-0.6431292295455933,
0.32006630301475525,
-0.2496732622385025,
-0.8798434734344482,
-0.22527433931827545,
-0.35091453790664673,
-1.1572271585464478,
0.5095520615577698,
-0.08260893076658249,
-0.6640874147415161,
0.057101935148239136,
-0.19349607825279236,
-0.1467915028333664,
0.21390505135059357,
-0.3909395933151245,
0.9095541834831238,
0.11793651431798935,
0.08795095980167389,
-0.2780175507068634,
-0.868256688117981,
0.24160853028297424,
-0.399769127368927,
0.2680654227733612,
-0.09944149851799011,
-0.08188062906265259,
0.8780489563941956,
0.1729864925146103,
0.6126779913902283,
0.06812252849340439,
-0.18236571550369263,
0.4582981765270233,
-0.09830386936664581,
0.23365968465805054,
0.35336288809776306,
-0.2683804929256439,
-0.10766575485467911,
0.1868036389350891,
-0.584685742855072,
-0.5191637277603149,
0.4322313964366913,
-0.5641030073165894,
-0.44907209277153015,
-0.3727280795574188,
-0.8269034028053284,
-0.2216373234987259,
-0.03277624770998955,
-0.08303109556436539,
0.692427933216095,
0.14389824867248535,
0.6089242696762085,
0.7058075666427612,
-0.180626779794693,
0.16741707921028137,
0.47290292382240295,
-0.44351670145988464,
-0.04573966562747955,
0.9486709237098694,
-0.14355672895908356,
0.12565568089485168,
0.4293639659881592,
0.2867566645145416,
-0.4716479182243347,
-0.6810933947563171,
-0.7247686982154846,
0.01231386885046959,
-0.8448855876922607,
0.09455375373363495,
-0.6509184837341309,
-0.20724211633205414,
-0.019622057676315308,
-0.45641782879829407,
-0.054498542100191116,
-0.32358577847480774,
-0.7636439204216003,
-0.5026077628135681,
0.25560519099235535,
0.6202045679092407,
0.03796609863638878,
0.3414974510669708,
-0.7366425395011902,
0.6443687677383423,
0.033620208501815796,
0.1405935287475586,
-0.2835594713687897,
-1.0609577894210815,
-0.3673507869243622,
0.00036305052344687283,
-0.25929439067840576,
-0.619327187538147,
0.279689222574234,
0.28634804487228394,
0.28907161951065063,
0.6132432818412781,
0.5018911957740784,
0.49398887157440186,
-0.32895132899284363,
0.6614779233932495,
0.0005941260606050491,
-0.5563812851905823,
0.6582167744636536,
-0.5236287713050842,
0.18734431266784668,
0.8322701454162598,
0.2662864327430725,
-0.6896750330924988,
-0.5187147855758667,
-0.5447201728820801,
-0.782090961933136,
0.763230562210083,
0.3753056526184082,
0.43978071212768555,
0.26541009545326233,
0.5411469340324402,
0.4086373448371887,
0.3003356158733368,
-0.3101927638053894,
-0.5579464435577393,
-0.4095204770565033,
-0.5559074282646179,
-0.31459808349609375,
0.01824061945080757,
-0.21371927857398987,
-0.20650409162044525,
0.375732421875,
-0.13399267196655273,
-0.20773236453533173,
-0.10410867631435394,
-0.3461829721927643,
-0.1780027598142624,
0.04100949689745903,
0.3676532208919525,
1.1305066347122192,
-0.26025786995887756,
0.1832510232925415,
-0.013352046720683575,
-0.9263045787811279,
-0.10205765068531036,
0.1200048178434372,
-0.21880164742469788,
0.0627136379480362,
0.9288317561149597,
0.8366252779960632,
0.16072621941566467,
-0.6924418807029724,
-0.021938398480415344,
-0.19941897690296173,
-0.1881089210510254,
-0.16485773026943207,
0.1916116625070572,
0.11314231157302856,
0.30405619740486145,
0.6910627484321594,
-0.06899324804544449,
0.027237046509981155,
-0.44990891218185425,
0.5646897554397583,
-0.21561700105667114,
-0.5856653451919556,
-0.2641788721084595,
0.5562167167663574,
0.18617765605449677,
-0.16819944977760315,
0.9173149466514587,
0.0026453465688973665,
-0.2315898984670639,
0.8940343260765076,
0.7355720400810242,
0.88624107837677,
0.16607017815113068,
0.6477693915367126,
0.509660542011261,
0.6619780659675598,
0.42192184925079346,
0.021304821595549583,
-0.0027484267484396696,
-0.5782235264778137,
-0.4054482579231262,
-0.8469544649124146,
-0.3382886052131653,
0.1647709310054779,
-1.1439677476882935,
-0.09583736956119537,
-0.1139412447810173,
0.45561128854751587,
-0.05637761205434799,
-0.009510078467428684,
-0.3232267498970032,
0.4540170729160309,
0.33551424741744995,
0.9480915069580078,
-1.0039896965026855,
0.6603368520736694,
0.9387726783752441,
-0.13069383800029755,
-0.3287171423435211,
0.5494046807289124,
0.04670806601643562,
-0.7282958626747131,
0.24796096980571747,
0.15631602704524994,
0.13061188161373138,
0.5157424807548523,
-0.25959935784339905,
-0.48897576332092285,
0.9551851749420166,
-0.01578846201300621,
-0.5830064415931702,
-0.11567102372646332,
0.14556589722633362,
0.7474599480628967,
-0.6077141761779785,
-0.013178066350519657,
0.9315828680992126,
0.6685431599617004,
0.06346554309129715,
-0.17198546230793,
-0.43529337644577026,
0.04135145619511604,
-0.44874194264411926,
-0.32615533471107483,
0.11498026549816132,
0.37848058342933655,
-0.14578130841255188,
-0.17780053615570068,
-0.20746564865112305,
0.973260760307312,
0.6319035887718201,
1.0770549774169922,
0.4086243510246277,
0.4550414979457855,
0.7707691192626953,
-0.1753021776676178,
1.1066715717315674,
-0.2853471040725708,
0.43708834052085876,
1.0584205389022827,
0.2779136598110199,
0.560687243938446,
0.5038187503814697,
-0.3978951573371887,
0.43309345841407776,
1.0867246389389038,
0.24559728801250458,
0.7251781821250916,
0.24502664804458618,
-0.19577226042747498,
0.02433113567531109,
-0.15189120173454285,
-0.3410760462284088,
0.4427850544452667,
0.43170276284217834,
-0.31206387281417847,
-0.34274783730506897,
0.2236727923154831,
-0.14503321051597595,
0.40444886684417725,
-0.5416630506515503,
0.7073409557342529,
0.3760427236557007,
-0.6176041960716248,
0.21506480872631073,
-0.2463332563638687,
0.29218339920043945,
-0.32672399282455444,
0.04242953285574913,
-0.31256407499313354,
-0.09552109986543655,
-0.006161010358482599,
-1.265848994255066,
0.3399132788181305,
0.11329086869955063,
-0.2812037169933319,
-0.4205273389816284,
0.555433988571167,
-0.574622392654419,
-0.4591186046600342,
0.01725589670240879,
0.6292271614074707,
0.15506064891815186,
-0.17807777225971222,
-0.8165724277496338,
0.04470176249742508,
0.2417249083518982,
-0.4220620095729828,
0.20980525016784668,
0.6352527737617493,
0.39987972378730774,
0.4180438220500946,
0.5269067883491516,
-0.39918017387390137,
-0.21370427310466766,
0.2808800935745239,
0.5369048714637756,
-0.6841272711753845,
-0.7410303354263306,
-0.6633074879646301,
0.5804241895675659,
0.20008833706378937,
-0.5095677971839905,
0.5206425786018372,
0.31777724623680115,
0.5026481747627258,
-0.30082789063453674,
0.6319242119789124,
0.22624358534812927,
0.45854607224464417,
-0.5251449942588806,
0.87682044506073,
-0.6835309267044067,
0.24806927144527435,
-0.09789767861366272,
-1.1236454248428345,
-0.09107399731874466,
0.7261619567871094,
-0.02676147036254406,
-0.32321104407310486,
1.0551564693450928,
0.11259160190820694,
-0.022995108738541603,
0.7867661714553833,
0.15949231386184692,
-0.26271677017211914,
0.0529027096927166,
0.1477399468421936,
1.1820611953735352,
-0.14084529876708984,
0.4776099920272827,
-0.2876650393009186,
-0.0804738849401474,
-0.13302133977413177,
-0.5952965617179871,
-1.0147249698638916,
-0.7216923236846924,
-0.2874261438846588,
-0.2272312194108963,
0.24718508124351501,
0.676011323928833,
0.10257746279239655,
-0.711711049079895,
0.060097917914390564,
-0.132210835814476,
0.4913690388202667,
-0.38066911697387695,
-0.24612818658351898,
0.38516655564308167,
-0.5070584416389465,
-0.9220520257949829,
0.5272220969200134,
-0.03530823439359665,
-0.37205520272254944,
-0.07274914532899857,
-0.04452233761548996,
0.12444274127483368,
0.35708579421043396,
0.6405851244926453,
-0.09766093641519547,
-0.6220349073410034,
-0.3386957049369812,
0.01522977277636528,
-0.13013072311878204,
0.1252926141023636,
0.9833465814590454,
-0.6677859425544739,
0.5865893363952637,
0.3149380385875702,
0.7094680666923523,
0.5257661938667297,
0.36663058400154114,
0.28901436924934387,
-0.7903035283088684,
-0.3342275619506836,
0.5086275339126587,
0.09967035800218582,
0.004403485916554928,
-0.12110312283039093,
0.7101249098777771,
0.3489782512187958,
-0.15111936628818512,
-0.9076424241065979,
0.07148119807243347,
-0.804702877998352,
-0.3483887314796448,
0.8227405548095703,
-0.2691028118133545,
-0.053744837641716,
-0.5401665568351746,
-0.19105631113052368,
0.01950577273964882,
-0.15715253353118896,
0.6403483152389526,
0.9835971593856812,
0.17503924667835236,
-0.4307596981525421,
-0.9008829593658447,
0.14650048315525055,
0.2681349217891693,
-0.8945608139038086,
0.2656068801879883,
0.3134288787841797,
-0.06599211692810059,
0.10576134920120239,
0.042465392500162125,
0.03223412483930588,
0.12446258962154388,
0.38962310552597046,
-0.19999971985816956,
-0.17090140283107758,
-0.7270463705062866,
-0.23230943083763123,
0.2708476483821869,
-0.5681654810905457,
-0.02143295854330063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05245v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05245v1
|
Supervised Gradual Machine Learning for Aspect Category Detection
| 2024-04-08T07:21:46 | 2024-04-08T07:21:46 |
Murtadha Ahmed, Qun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect Category Detection (ACD) aims to identify implicit and explicit
aspects in a given review sentence. The state-of-the-art approaches for ACD use
Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) to address the problem as a multi-label
classification task. However, learning category-specific representations
heavily rely on the amount of labeled examples, which may not readily available
in real-world scenarios. In this paper, we propose a novel approach to tackle
the ACD task by combining DNNs with Gradual Machine Learning (GML) in a
supervised setting. we aim to leverage the strength of DNN in semantic relation
modeling, which can facilitate effective knowledge transfer between labeled and
unlabeled instances during the gradual inference of GML. To achieve this, we
first analyze the learned latent space of the DNN to model the relations, i.e.,
similar or opposite, between instances. We then represent these relations as
binary features in a factor graph to efficiently convey knowledge. Finally, we
conduct a comparative study of our proposed solution on real benchmark datasets
and demonstrate that the GML approach, in collaboration with DNNs for feature
extraction, consistently outperforms pure DNN solutions.
|
[
-0.47267547249794006,
-1.0948799848556519,
0.9141987562179565,
0.13026970624923706,
-0.4124196171760559,
0.06283234059810638,
0.0584135428071022,
-0.27004870772361755,
-0.03177480027079582,
0.7450453042984009,
-1.008951187133789,
-0.7720142602920532,
-0.38768330216407776,
0.18634524941444397,
-0.3997248113155365,
1.2168231010437012,
-0.1397974193096161,
-0.24065011739730835,
-0.21821852028369904,
-0.12453586608171463,
-0.14167901873588562,
-0.4536023437976837,
-0.7297855615615845,
-0.6240202188491821,
0.649539589881897,
0.26506251096725464,
0.5364044904708862,
0.5146577954292297,
0.5584449172019958,
0.34332212805747986,
-0.22000399231910706,
0.480498731136322,
0.05660485476255417,
0.3799942433834076,
0.1085534617304802,
-0.3436425030231476,
-0.43151724338531494,
0.08108789473772049,
0.5021699666976929,
1.1689749956130981,
0.10375411063432693,
-0.19696354866027832,
0.1861705183982849,
0.8904352188110352,
-0.024879874661564827,
0.7544202208518982,
-0.3348061740398407,
0.5054527521133423,
0.05180972069501877,
0.05408912152051926,
-0.2571065425872803,
-0.2707291841506958,
0.238883838057518,
-0.6391997337341309,
0.5518766641616821,
0.015061195939779282,
0.8071920275688171,
0.3406771719455719,
-0.5281810164451599,
-0.36540091037750244,
-0.6305190920829773,
0.4616980254650116,
-0.6426363587379456,
0.4860098361968994,
0.5485531687736511,
-0.11330217123031616,
-0.4328349530696869,
-0.7970215678215027,
-0.7455485463142395,
-0.5002015233039856,
-0.37899404764175415,
-0.15556742250919342,
0.11161539703607559,
0.20674680173397064,
0.06620024144649506,
0.7775467038154602,
-0.46674197912216187,
0.14570818841457367,
-0.007244099862873554,
-0.15523603558540344,
0.6308189630508423,
0.11732438951730728,
-0.11048781126737595,
-0.4716484546661377,
-0.14065507054328918,
-0.11939598619937897,
-0.3917114734649658,
0.08277330547571182,
0.23156750202178955,
0.31842881441116333,
-0.03622637689113617,
0.6065425276756287,
-0.5232380628585815,
0.5411691069602966,
0.6479255557060242,
0.057022035121917725,
0.3694072365760803,
-0.3964870274066925,
-0.18182826042175293,
-0.011484812945127487,
1.013599157333374,
0.02993161976337433,
-0.15511630475521088,
-0.02092180773615837,
-0.396122545003891,
0.06201416999101639,
0.29241201281547546,
-0.7285206913948059,
-0.5298104286193848,
0.2890923321247101,
-0.4136190712451935,
-0.5060161352157593,
0.015517575666308403,
-0.44213882088661194,
-0.5019416809082031,
-0.7086654305458069,
0.2332620471715927,
-0.32542863488197327,
-0.17869660258293152,
-0.07388767600059509,
0.29659777879714966,
-0.18482734262943268,
0.3163488507270813,
-0.561531662940979,
0.011834035627543926,
1.1110413074493408,
0.9441661238670349,
-0.32215383648872375,
0.2071308195590973,
-0.6214423775672913,
-0.28854528069496155,
-0.4485781490802765,
0.44345030188560486,
-0.4830372929573059,
-0.34546801447868347,
0.07918471843004227,
0.48932498693466187,
0.33477580547332764,
-0.27277395129203796,
0.2638455033302307,
-0.583318829536438,
0.20201651751995087,
0.32676050066947937,
-0.5406831502914429,
-0.5473685264587402,
0.6528360843658447,
-0.791804313659668,
1.0030115842819214,
0.19557112455368042,
-0.7231334447860718,
0.6493757367134094,
-0.34223949909210205,
-0.505298912525177,
-0.12297888100147247,
-0.3256247341632843,
-0.9360983371734619,
0.04281649366021156,
0.3320540189743042,
0.8853991031646729,
0.2374502569437027,
0.6553836464881897,
-0.4632851481437683,
0.16982732713222504,
0.37479275465011597,
-0.4329546391963959,
0.23298396170139313,
0.23044216632843018,
-0.07565084844827652,
0.5550907254219055,
-0.7406412363052368,
-0.32751384377479553,
-0.36661094427108765,
-0.25922417640686035,
-0.4773011803627014,
0.026662319898605347,
-0.3138355314731598,
0.35992729663848877,
0.18630751967430115,
-0.4524412751197815,
0.5625914931297302,
-0.2625882625579834,
0.2141416072845459,
0.7058624625205994,
0.5402371883392334,
0.5829871296882629,
0.06511799246072769,
0.32766225934028625,
0.7728115320205688,
0.4554542303085327,
-0.02171928435564041,
-0.39144274592399597,
-1.108202338218689,
0.06569664180278778,
0.3192054331302643,
0.16159804165363312,
-1.49820876121521,
0.8834312558174133,
-0.16084779798984528,
-0.09034226834774017,
-0.5420607924461365,
0.4550369381904602,
0.5114273428916931,
0.5091850161552429,
0.20845720171928406,
-0.930525004863739,
-0.09947822988033295,
-0.9492021799087524,
0.4194903075695038,
-0.5945896506309509,
-0.09434489905834198,
0.43531954288482666,
0.385424941778183,
-0.2725037634372711,
1.068766474723816,
-0.6796556115150452,
-0.6092744469642639,
-0.12736253440380096,
0.7250186204910278,
0.41380858421325684,
0.506756603717804,
-0.01734175719320774,
-1.17081880569458,
-0.11899186670780182,
0.12251289188861847,
-0.9610303640365601,
-0.010550122708082199,
-0.4124768376350403,
-0.10765618085861206,
0.061501938849687576,
0.5091012716293335,
-0.2102268636226654,
0.31957951188087463,
0.20855285227298737,
-0.44392991065979004,
0.4466645419597626,
-0.23190827667713165,
0.0604347325861454,
-0.9882389903068542,
-0.40331098437309265,
0.5587677359580994,
-0.5727761387825012,
-0.5044266581535339,
-0.17795805633068085,
0.03584642708301544,
0.18490296602249146,
-0.5394035577774048,
0.23972459137439728,
-0.36374393105506897,
0.13649235665798187,
-0.31431496143341064,
-0.09679048508405685,
0.13919387757778168,
0.7382726669311523,
0.4710403084754944,
0.38945138454437256,
0.360782265663147,
-0.7754981517791748,
0.35373246669769287,
0.22832630574703217,
-0.08374611288309097,
0.5413355827331543,
-0.14316925406455994,
0.21970348060131073,
-0.3200612962245941,
0.44895878434181213,
-0.7270197868347168,
0.026113685220479965,
0.6754539012908936,
-0.247844398021698,
0.6161322593688965,
-0.5156868696212769,
-0.40832436084747314,
-0.5700671076774597,
-0.3346647322177887,
0.18733638525009155,
0.19566108286380768,
-0.3559750020503998,
0.4127449095249176,
0.09050732105970383,
-0.1311846226453781,
-0.2167111039161682,
-0.5250868797302246,
0.011100364848971367,
-0.10518874228000641,
-0.3759293258190155,
0.27552634477615356,
0.09823719412088394,
-0.03159351646900177,
0.4622938334941864,
-0.30814987421035767,
-0.47142237424850464,
-0.03133460134267807,
0.5074928402900696,
0.11628367006778717,
-0.3288005292415619,
0.2042308747768402,
0.004283360671252012,
-0.10177343338727951,
0.09266050904989243,
-0.2839585840702057,
0.3783230781555176,
-0.16992349922657013,
-0.2682567834854126,
-0.5445098876953125,
0.2286497950553894,
0.1682145744562149,
0.03688282519578934,
0.636684000492096,
0.8166385889053345,
-0.08066359907388687,
-0.17585799098014832,
-0.3569951355457306,
-0.3827665448188782,
-0.5146922469139099,
0.4676094651222229,
-0.5275745987892151,
-0.9550154209136963,
0.11144571751356125,
-0.22716642916202545,
-0.052781857550144196,
0.4975191354751587,
0.17872072756290436,
-0.02494013123214245,
0.8402867317199707,
1.2107264995574951,
-0.2535375654697418,
0.6707097291946411,
-0.5415887832641602,
0.12524910271167755,
-1.2857892513275146,
-0.5157947540283203,
-0.2033688724040985,
-0.16679765284061432,
-0.7754558324813843,
-0.5406002998352051,
0.2805611789226532,
0.21653185784816742,
-0.11782342940568924,
0.11629560589790344,
-0.6141369342803955,
-0.022715717554092407,
0.21031750738620758,
0.6801996827125549,
0.6009876728057861,
-0.1501767486333847,
0.041388798505067825,
0.03050255961716175,
-0.38286909461021423,
-0.38336920738220215,
0.882850706577301,
0.3245071470737457,
0.6607730388641357,
-0.04612002149224281,
0.835424542427063,
0.5827775001525879,
0.5480216145515442,
-1.0822947025299072,
0.5430994033813477,
-0.44326770305633545,
-0.1365724354982376,
-0.21610446274280548,
-0.6526389718055725,
-0.8990760445594788,
0.0874856561422348,
-0.049235258251428604,
-0.43720149993896484,
0.3915075659751892,
-0.05186903849244118,
-0.19297190010547638,
0.1294323056936264,
-0.32769930362701416,
0.6056574583053589,
-0.11288011074066162,
-0.4409772455692291,
0.09529978781938553,
-0.7682002782821655,
0.5257343649864197,
-0.24686063826084137,
0.12723538279533386,
-0.25106099247932434,
0.06820974498987198,
0.7921491265296936,
-0.3661871552467346,
0.9418046474456787,
-0.021420208737254143,
-0.03571058064699173,
0.16785429418087006,
0.1857498437166214,
0.24815267324447632,
0.3913988769054413,
-0.009942435659468174,
0.12113451212644577,
-0.4235212504863739,
0.08836730569601059,
-0.6814402341842651,
0.791996955871582,
-0.559508204460144,
-0.7167078852653503,
-0.6550763845443726,
-0.4873587191104889,
-0.26976361870765686,
-0.00920249056071043,
-0.47480836510658264,
0.42089858651161194,
0.040551118552684784,
-0.004253031220287085,
0.688452422618866,
-0.07300645858049393,
0.6374178528785706,
0.7116929292678833,
-0.495140016078949,
-0.07475978881120682,
0.7809454202651978,
-0.25441640615463257,
0.07964392006397247,
0.3129148781299591,
0.09769979864358902,
-0.32554614543914795,
-0.3890807032585144,
-0.5302881002426147,
0.103429414331913,
-0.6238197684288025,
-0.19485969841480255,
-0.776498019695282,
-0.5130335688591003,
-0.10473985970020294,
0.20257343351840973,
-0.2966676950454712,
-0.16114836931228638,
-0.4840337634086609,
0.06316259503364563,
0.6131469011306763,
0.818376898765564,
0.14326271414756775,
0.14574232697486877,
-0.6507651209831238,
0.7182015180587769,
0.30289122462272644,
0.19870547950267792,
-0.005226219538599253,
-0.5312188267707825,
0.11362279206514359,
-0.07074354588985443,
-0.5152719616889954,
-0.488933801651001,
0.42699095606803894,
0.31950998306274414,
0.22676241397857666,
0.711814820766449,
0.16430750489234924,
0.5229864120483398,
-0.5071329474449158,
0.8761840462684631,
0.20057371258735657,
-0.5049640536308289,
0.6994644403457642,
0.14842531085014343,
0.27871254086494446,
0.6803818345069885,
0.6863192915916443,
-0.582984447479248,
-0.49639591574668884,
-0.6177075505256653,
-0.9558587074279785,
0.5483480095863342,
0.3660348355770111,
-0.01074622105807066,
-0.019526755437254906,
0.5822997689247131,
0.33429858088493347,
0.4895649254322052,
-0.5205580592155457,
-0.4562340974807739,
0.04969925433397293,
-0.48802128434181213,
-0.0999969020485878,
-0.09860249608755112,
0.2201688140630722,
-0.3458036482334137,
0.8291248679161072,
-0.2234710156917572,
0.050741370767354965,
0.4446018636226654,
-0.08669868111610413,
0.19151714444160461,
0.2912241518497467,
-0.06613513082265854,
0.34577128291130066,
-0.21176615357398987,
0.324785053730011,
-0.389554500579834,
-0.6268823146820068,
0.48558279871940613,
0.284527987241745,
-0.32140982151031494,
0.12089051306247711,
0.2596953511238098,
0.7089822888374329,
0.16658131778240204,
0.14017991721630096,
0.3584643602371216,
-0.1147761344909668,
-0.03074893169105053,
0.012278071604669094,
-0.03851648047566414,
-0.2036624252796173,
0.398377388715744,
0.28936582803726196,
-0.051731791347265244,
0.3721843361854553,
-0.8320997357368469,
0.7836714386940002,
0.1963137686252594,
-1.0816891193389893,
-0.2655559182167053,
0.38307875394821167,
0.230047345161438,
-0.22893555462360382,
0.88970547914505,
-0.6238832473754883,
-0.7578951120376587,
0.6779300570487976,
0.0415009967982769,
1.084633708000183,
0.09156875312328339,
0.604741096496582,
0.04912789165973663,
0.10751473903656006,
-0.16335968673229218,
-0.05124247446656227,
-0.31192585825920105,
-0.5787122845649719,
-0.4793567955493927,
-1.0319511890411377,
-0.30439841747283936,
0.14520536363124847,
-0.6337332725524902,
-0.053425900638103485,
-0.4238791763782501,
-0.1058729737997055,
0.21120548248291016,
0.1933438628911972,
-0.7649664282798767,
0.18590913712978363,
0.2438504993915558,
0.2429453432559967,
-0.9607546329498291,
1.036877155303955,
0.49554187059402466,
-0.6216542720794678,
-0.7176221013069153,
0.13807155191898346,
0.08255138993263245,
-0.32605040073394775,
0.7536451816558838,
0.45527884364128113,
0.1636691838502884,
-0.2261962890625,
-0.16286832094192505,
-0.23150403797626495,
0.8572291731834412,
-0.44041210412979126,
-0.8558205962181091,
0.33711421489715576,
0.1081022173166275,
0.48807650804519653,
-0.4315830171108246,
0.04581008851528168,
0.5811883211135864,
0.39404401183128357,
0.33518412709236145,
-0.6389533281326294,
0.1245754137635231,
-0.0511108860373497,
-0.03296555578708649,
0.36608174443244934,
-0.3841598927974701,
0.5972349047660828,
0.14872996509075165,
0.1258324384689331,
-0.08853979408740997,
1.090576171875,
0.0812642052769661,
0.6326921582221985,
0.8000859618186951,
0.3654591739177704,
0.6380215883255005,
-0.23137620091438293,
0.8684576153755188,
0.05894649401307106,
0.4233880341053009,
1.0152993202209473,
-0.1933773159980774,
0.673599362373352,
0.4438965618610382,
-0.22442470490932465,
0.5905593037605286,
1.1489640474319458,
-0.04305819049477577,
0.7568212151527405,
0.18556900322437286,
-0.5048527121543884,
-0.3782876431941986,
-0.3974674940109253,
-0.049631260335445404,
-0.05278885364532471,
0.4306917190551758,
-0.46501657366752625,
-0.07339364290237427,
0.29622429609298706,
-0.04741230607032776,
-0.16243161261081696,
-0.5643267631530762,
1.170593500137329,
0.46950283646583557,
-0.548909068107605,
0.03852134197950363,
-0.21127736568450928,
0.8427048325538635,
-0.494798868894577,
-0.3208227753639221,
-0.4585980474948883,
0.1962554156780243,
-0.3195006549358368,
-1.1543254852294922,
0.1550234705209732,
-0.0615706592798233,
-0.3927759528160095,
-0.12832830846309662,
0.5621069669723511,
-0.7778666615486145,
-0.9899336695671082,
-0.03954513370990753,
0.340167373418808,
0.16425424814224243,
-0.19301818311214447,
-0.7388332486152649,
-0.22799430787563324,
-0.08455857634544373,
-0.3580976724624634,
0.2297017127275467,
0.9141735434532166,
-0.41759103536605835,
0.6512978076934814,
0.5958755016326904,
-0.02462862804532051,
-0.2098526954650879,
0.2290433645248413,
1.0948889255523682,
-0.5263108611106873,
-0.5667195916175842,
-0.8528781533241272,
0.3293004035949707,
-0.15629006922245026,
-0.031401198357343674,
0.5506247282028198,
0.5290615558624268,
0.5084994435310364,
0.08746767789125443,
0.3690520226955414,
-0.2246972769498825,
-0.160366952419281,
-0.8711377382278442,
0.5972666144371033,
-0.51541668176651,
0.4001308083534241,
-0.12668539583683014,
-0.9627553820610046,
-0.4410686194896698,
0.4301927089691162,
-0.1272682100534439,
-0.07701635360717773,
0.9407399892807007,
0.7005609273910522,
-0.23948173224925995,
-0.1101519763469696,
0.09448012709617615,
0.3225778639316559,
0.5819976329803467,
0.49533191323280334,
0.7785043120384216,
-0.14336435496807098,
0.1777263879776001,
-0.7688332200050354,
-0.18557468056678772,
-0.0535634383559227,
-0.984318196773529,
-0.9443588852882385,
-0.8137812614440918,
-0.9712664484977722,
-0.31373435258865356,
0.005663141142576933,
0.6017917990684509,
0.7161962389945984,
-0.6694435477256775,
0.37678760290145874,
-0.18269005417823792,
0.375049352645874,
-0.3032221794128418,
-0.29687345027923584,
0.7638091444969177,
-0.31704044342041016,
-0.45840421319007874,
0.1798497587442398,
0.23664043843746185,
-0.11490404605865479,
-0.6260154843330383,
0.1642076075077057,
-0.288838267326355,
-0.3194078505039215,
0.6494918465614319,
-0.0731871947646141,
-0.7499950528144836,
-0.48125529289245605,
-0.45435741543769836,
-0.0989065021276474,
0.2212853729724884,
0.8158245086669922,
-0.9739884734153748,
0.43122604489326477,
0.22779229283332825,
0.4477197527885437,
0.8360164761543274,
0.1470298320055008,
0.3533517122268677,
-1.2484540939331055,
0.3369919955730438,
0.33504951000213623,
0.06797489523887634,
0.5264517068862915,
-0.6236310601234436,
0.6062245965003967,
0.12060806900262833,
-0.4252919554710388,
-0.3618497848510742,
0.15003827214241028,
-1.257964015007019,
-0.31658583879470825,
1.1777466535568237,
-0.43071189522743225,
-0.4549270272254944,
-0.3522716164588928,
-0.019099215045571327,
0.3580275774002075,
-0.5327196717262268,
0.8830389976501465,
0.4133661687374115,
-0.37754762172698975,
-0.18999436497688293,
-0.545416533946991,
0.5218327045440674,
-0.04798242449760437,
-0.7122846245765686,
-0.2591640055179596,
0.6012697219848633,
0.23316100239753723,
0.09915617108345032,
0.29419124126434326,
0.1385020911693573,
-0.0565718412399292,
-0.29896482825279236,
-0.004921610001474619,
-0.32630735635757446,
-0.39072301983833313,
-0.39317670464515686,
0.08682043105363846,
0.04820939525961876,
-0.3719613552093506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05243v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05243v1
|
Product Description and QA Assisted Self-Supervised Opinion Summarization
| 2024-04-08T07:15:06 | 2024-04-08T07:15:06 |
Tejpalsingh Siledar, Rupasai Rangaraju, Sankara Sri Raghava Ravindra Muddu, Suman Banerjee, Amey Patil, Sudhanshu Shekhar Singh, Muthusamy Chelliah, Nikesh Garera, Swaprava Nath, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In e-commerce, opinion summarization is the process of summarizing the
consensus opinions found in product reviews. However, the potential of
additional sources such as product description and question-answers (QA) has
been considered less often. Moreover, the absence of any supervised training
data makes this task challenging. To address this, we propose a novel synthetic
dataset creation (SDC) strategy that leverages information from reviews as well
as additional sources for selecting one of the reviews as a pseudo-summary to
enable supervised training. Our Multi-Encoder Decoder framework for Opinion
Summarization (MEDOS) employs a separate encoder for each source, enabling
effective selection of information while generating the summary. For
evaluation, due to the unavailability of test sets with additional sources, we
extend the Amazon, Oposum+, and Flipkart test sets and leverage ChatGPT to
annotate summaries. Experiments across nine test sets demonstrate that the
combination of our SDC approach and MEDOS model achieves on average a 14.5%
improvement in ROUGE-1 F1 over the SOTA. Moreover, comparative analysis
underlines the significance of incorporating additional sources for generating
more informative summaries. Human evaluations further indicate that MEDOS
scores relatively higher in coherence and fluency with 0.41 and 0.5 (-1 to 1)
respectively, compared to existing models. To the best of our knowledge, we are
the first to generate opinion summaries leveraging additional sources in a
self-supervised setting.
|
[
-0.6492742896080017,
-0.3872108459472656,
0.2978813946247101,
0.11273932456970215,
-0.4694044888019562,
0.1143927127122879,
0.07903723418712616,
-0.5336110591888428,
0.8748453259468079,
0.5974684953689575,
-0.7595039010047913,
-0.5049604177474976,
-0.23509147763252258,
0.47928059101104736,
-0.38542914390563965,
1.7402805089950562,
0.07916539162397385,
0.08195105195045471,
-0.23354534804821014,
-0.2701309323310852,
-0.021035097539424896,
-0.6551409363746643,
-0.4460975229740143,
0.17589141428470612,
0.2893669903278351,
0.2775397002696991,
0.5091975927352905,
0.31096985936164856,
0.46754300594329834,
0.26785075664520264,
0.10702721029520035,
0.6218839883804321,
-0.4693140685558319,
0.1632421910762787,
0.019639959558844566,
-0.5248186588287354,
-0.8779683709144592,
0.13813412189483643,
0.10509862005710602,
0.23088738322257996,
-0.25014054775238037,
0.3640155792236328,
0.14554938673973083,
0.9085950255393982,
-0.6333094835281372,
0.18104782700538635,
-0.2822761535644531,
0.3088088929653168,
0.449691504240036,
-0.19960205256938934,
-0.24927760660648346,
-0.5094374418258667,
0.18436825275421143,
-1.0189056396484375,
0.5779135227203369,
-0.11200743913650513,
0.6193450689315796,
0.24341095983982086,
-0.3337208032608032,
-0.47685614228248596,
-0.825187087059021,
0.5788744688034058,
-0.8957902789115906,
0.1017470732331276,
0.2578294575214386,
0.47120600938796997,
0.1593557447195053,
-0.6043499112129211,
-0.7670653462409973,
0.2577209770679474,
-0.27227091789245605,
0.8990955352783203,
0.07216154038906097,
-0.009101847186684608,
-0.13775010406970978,
0.6770791411399841,
-0.4482870399951935,
-0.4216994047164917,
-0.6759880185127258,
-0.11206700652837753,
0.9849521517753601,
0.2821817696094513,
-0.21704252064228058,
-0.2863112986087799,
-0.3157111406326294,
-0.1337072104215622,
-0.7098403573036194,
0.14087854325771332,
0.5416340231895447,
0.02723926119506359,
-0.16236339509487152,
0.67802894115448,
-0.5964407920837402,
0.4202965199947357,
0.2615697681903839,
-0.20689059793949127,
0.5834941864013672,
-0.5328130722045898,
-0.24496597051620483,
-0.003401106223464012,
0.9545318484306335,
0.8167681694030762,
0.036912381649017334,
0.1709650456905365,
-0.296863317489624,
-0.05449088662862778,
0.4380212724208832,
-0.9348069429397583,
-0.3133690059185028,
0.43513017892837524,
-0.8194892406463623,
-0.5849515199661255,
0.20262138545513153,
-0.8693395853042603,
-0.3973599076271057,
-0.4567820727825165,
0.21838942170143127,
0.05957823991775513,
-0.2417888641357422,
0.20070382952690125,
-0.27970248460769653,
0.0019930934067815542,
0.2722165882587433,
-0.7319942712783813,
0.40547066926956177,
0.3317927420139313,
0.6794203519821167,
-0.16490091383457184,
-0.13926614820957184,
0.0054478938691318035,
0.1883968710899353,
-0.4806542694568634,
0.9678456783294678,
-0.05788204073905945,
-0.5174488425254822,
-0.02458677440881729,
0.1776607781648636,
0.21865610778331757,
-0.5360379815101624,
0.18797482550144196,
-0.4575018882751465,
0.5154500603675842,
-0.16222621500492096,
-0.627364993095398,
-0.2803226709365845,
0.5668007135391235,
-0.7167040705680847,
0.6266618371009827,
-0.036156799644231796,
-0.7844555377960205,
0.29375702142715454,
-0.5653350353240967,
-0.6874337196350098,
-0.2233235090970993,
-0.2570851147174835,
-0.6110894083976746,
0.11039631813764572,
0.788480818271637,
0.5281645059585571,
-0.07297311723232269,
-0.15128165483474731,
-0.33709442615509033,
-0.10527428239583969,
0.45297515392303467,
-0.08145111799240112,
0.40206849575042725,
0.41460174322128296,
-0.006144068203866482,
0.1403055340051651,
-0.7872253060340881,
-0.02744763158261776,
0.17260996997356415,
-0.22900761663913727,
-0.03683050721883774,
-0.0963321253657341,
-0.1021222174167633,
0.3233878016471863,
0.20137403905391693,
-0.5196927189826965,
0.12865319848060608,
-0.6444842219352722,
0.3295767903327942,
0.6913025379180908,
0.5060344338417053,
0.2689847946166992,
-0.38692861795425415,
0.8283094167709351,
-0.02957548201084137,
0.6731868386268616,
-0.5090000033378601,
-0.3885188400745392,
-0.7066498398780823,
-0.3757269084453583,
0.21206921339035034,
0.44672125577926636,
-0.9120640754699707,
0.4454323351383209,
-0.24693472683429718,
-0.2596837282180786,
-0.8476942777633667,
0.1910051703453064,
0.38638997077941895,
0.5502969026565552,
0.537445068359375,
-0.25248655676841736,
-0.6009035110473633,
-1.2700003385543823,
-0.03741500526666641,
-0.21999189257621765,
-0.3625541031360626,
0.11645230650901794,
0.2996785044670105,
-0.04222831502556801,
1.0276542901992798,
-0.7476244568824768,
-0.6546250581741333,
-0.5816097259521484,
-0.04437189921736717,
0.28541234135627747,
0.12740522623062134,
0.5311126112937927,
-0.6608898639678955,
-0.32363957166671753,
-0.14949963986873627,
-0.8217819333076477,
0.13410310447216034,
-0.35268089175224304,
0.15479475259780884,
0.17420892417430878,
0.21047870814800262,
-0.5133798122406006,
0.33820056915283203,
0.47463613748550415,
0.1280033141374588,
0.5456284880638123,
-0.36626136302948,
0.5323324203491211,
-1.553911805152893,
-0.28899040818214417,
0.0459342785179615,
-0.1171497330069542,
-0.24348147213459015,
-0.27432695031166077,
-0.09965372830629349,
0.09570363163948059,
-0.3086733818054199,
0.09089509397745132,
-0.19515235722064972,
0.018158644437789917,
-0.38126686215400696,
0.18907511234283447,
0.48533791303634644,
0.6349347233772278,
0.09164466708898544,
0.6831958293914795,
0.12936438620090485,
-0.5279937386512756,
0.402249813079834,
0.4121180772781372,
-0.09183236211538315,
0.5403134822845459,
-0.8438218235969543,
-0.027165450155735016,
-0.2075284719467163,
0.5305814743041992,
-0.811893105506897,
-0.41678130626678467,
0.25843754410743713,
-0.6414398550987244,
0.05171471834182739,
-0.13433395326137543,
-0.45716962218284607,
-0.44109758734703064,
-0.6752976775169373,
0.2191503942012787,
0.602124810218811,
-0.6938660144805908,
0.5220882892608643,
0.7327932119369507,
-0.1635417938232422,
-0.40848496556282043,
-0.6572449207305908,
-0.04024842008948326,
-0.1731482446193695,
-0.42921993136405945,
0.20356877148151398,
-0.07209469377994537,
-0.0054135737009346485,
-0.12068162858486176,
-0.10456474870443344,
0.11627122759819031,
-0.3005991578102112,
0.23954598605632782,
0.3480479419231415,
-0.051761072129011154,
0.42842793464660645,
0.3255549669265747,
-0.12426024675369263,
0.305144727230072,
-0.10812752693891525,
0.017137430608272552,
-0.2025623917579651,
-0.11359038949012756,
-0.4797407388687134,
0.5262874364852905,
0.2708459198474884,
-0.3352930247783661,
0.4791710674762726,
0.16100378334522247,
-0.13839392364025116,
-0.5346888899803162,
-0.3460771143436432,
-0.3896510601043701,
-0.4689827859401703,
0.36972931027412415,
-0.3869795799255371,
-0.5916762351989746,
0.4534061551094055,
0.10719787329435349,
0.003609461011365056,
0.6634430289268494,
0.5709318518638611,
-0.5564151406288147,
1.2469500303268433,
0.46148112416267395,
0.05579269677400589,
0.22395966947078705,
-0.49674561619758606,
0.5300408601760864,
-0.6754250526428223,
-0.28933262825012207,
-0.12141812592744827,
-0.18756277859210968,
-0.6737477779388428,
-0.05017155781388283,
0.5569791793823242,
-0.09054771810770035,
0.1911420226097107,
0.1361391544342041,
-0.7797345519065857,
0.5242587924003601,
0.4165755808353424,
0.2809564173221588,
0.4284476041793823,
0.06775151193141937,
0.26510557532310486,
0.10873627662658691,
-0.6310354471206665,
-0.44769012928009033,
1.389045000076294,
0.3106539249420166,
0.7003832459449768,
-0.15778681635856628,
0.7191005349159241,
0.5167275071144104,
0.35734978318214417,
-0.6489108800888062,
0.42000752687454224,
-0.09172546118497849,
-0.48710283637046814,
-0.00702587328851223,
-0.3089011609554291,
-0.6567509174346924,
0.18618500232696533,
-0.44452354311943054,
0.018935179337859154,
0.26962751150131226,
0.36185845732688904,
-0.7809631824493408,
-0.11331939697265625,
-0.8152878880500793,
0.6804772019386292,
-0.24182473123073578,
-0.06610323488712311,
-0.34199240803718567,
-0.7418921589851379,
0.3631488084793091,
0.10995114594697952,
0.42813485860824585,
0.11165701597929001,
0.0793440118432045,
0.8382276892662048,
-0.5370381474494934,
0.6654531359672546,
0.023426668718457222,
0.04630530998110771,
0.5708999037742615,
-0.08546076714992523,
0.3264300227165222,
0.24181315302848816,
0.32552212476730347,
0.0993628054857254,
0.07689318805932999,
-0.279252290725708,
-0.8265288472175598,
0.4867264926433563,
-0.7249289155006409,
-0.3528164029121399,
-0.3982783257961273,
-0.3476799726486206,
-0.4233289957046509,
-0.13979925215244293,
0.2426399290561676,
0.3679617941379547,
-0.1440228372812271,
-0.021309230476617813,
0.5430089235305786,
-0.21862836182117462,
0.21844780445098877,
0.5254027843475342,
-0.2248581051826477,
-0.9715922474861145,
0.8768414855003357,
-0.002613265300169587,
0.24587611854076385,
0.17129549384117126,
0.1988690346479416,
-0.31909531354904175,
-0.5803138613700867,
-0.6522683501243591,
0.17025822401046753,
-0.7253955602645874,
-0.3586727976799011,
-0.7737602591514587,
-0.22934624552726746,
-0.546409010887146,
-0.0665067806839943,
-0.4626723825931549,
-0.6809223294258118,
-0.03348616510629654,
-0.6023787260055542,
0.4017391800880432,
1.020927906036377,
0.08072739094495773,
0.4917229115962982,
-0.908268928527832,
0.6681065559387207,
0.35256150364875793,
0.25488269329071045,
-0.27095749974250793,
-0.33715394139289856,
-0.49637702107429504,
0.2731625437736511,
-0.2725333869457245,
-0.8844033479690552,
0.5876943469047546,
0.044511135667562485,
0.2720899283885956,
0.5952643156051636,
0.4089784324169159,
0.6309264302253723,
-0.07180380821228027,
0.8437506556510925,
0.2793098986148834,
-0.4950494170188904,
0.6985903978347778,
-0.36919498443603516,
0.23456305265426636,
0.5820480585098267,
0.2906850278377533,
-0.05220350623130798,
-0.5965176820755005,
-0.6098621487617493,
-0.8055506944656372,
0.5836091637611389,
0.23918651044368744,
0.18010251224040985,
-0.17141379415988922,
0.19122542440891266,
0.4551810026168823,
0.49014872312545776,
-0.6161669492721558,
-0.21437682211399078,
-0.5675560832023621,
-0.6031461954116821,
-0.08551041036844254,
-0.3374699056148529,
-0.2911827862262726,
-0.003245905041694641,
0.9179219007492065,
-0.2559267580509186,
-0.07382248342037201,
0.490543395280838,
0.010746391490101814,
0.18963858485221863,
0.20515994727611542,
0.3123851716518402,
0.4414997398853302,
-0.18823304772377014,
0.04055613651871681,
0.08500993251800537,
-0.3921797573566437,
-0.25531062483787537,
0.12310919165611267,
-0.3179142475128174,
-0.05177969112992287,
0.27321895956993103,
0.40514659881591797,
-0.23965096473693848,
-0.6027450561523438,
0.565477192401886,
-0.3350999653339386,
-0.032721150666475296,
-0.372502863407135,
-0.2070925086736679,
-0.12706966698169708,
0.17302900552749634,
0.2998414933681488,
0.24210087954998016,
0.6254208087921143,
-0.46539101004600525,
0.14924447238445282,
0.0935133844614029,
-0.10639341920614243,
-0.3539452850818634,
0.3534480929374695,
0.3950425386428833,
0.2375916987657547,
0.3827335834503174,
-0.30771321058273315,
-0.35356003046035767,
0.6708123087882996,
0.3785441815853119,
0.9525309801101685,
-0.10649603605270386,
0.4857487976551056,
0.5435407757759094,
0.2944243848323822,
0.07668299227952957,
0.25925490260124207,
-0.2495739609003067,
-0.5350731015205383,
-0.35162702202796936,
-0.46146160364151,
-0.3658837080001831,
-0.2568212151527405,
-0.7490498423576355,
0.07139952480792999,
-0.274634450674057,
-0.1184554249048233,
-0.057953741401433945,
-0.23908603191375732,
-0.2960891127586365,
0.5760897397994995,
-0.10645247995853424,
0.34125983715057373,
-0.8640809655189514,
0.4623987376689911,
0.35474976897239685,
-0.7244726419448853,
-0.6177831888198853,
-0.2374090999364853,
-0.15248268842697144,
-0.4495992660522461,
0.030752932652831078,
0.2144838124513626,
-0.25775018334388733,
-0.4625726044178009,
-0.24415111541748047,
-0.45248183608055115,
0.9810783863067627,
0.1649475395679474,
-0.4277784526348114,
0.2766362130641937,
0.2084897756576538,
0.9732158184051514,
-0.6749426126480103,
0.3193022906780243,
0.39502692222595215,
-0.06166600063443184,
0.0708981454372406,
-0.6321837306022644,
-0.056653041392564774,
-0.5816556215286255,
-0.338454008102417,
-0.13755130767822266,
-0.5329869389533997,
0.5590357184410095,
-0.39748308062553406,
-0.22746890783309937,
-0.13116689026355743,
0.5629467964172363,
0.21777790784835815,
0.4277544915676117,
0.2617056369781494,
0.42230525612831116,
0.36287814378738403,
0.20658579468727112,
1.3342951536178589,
-0.340252548456192,
0.32939913868904114,
1.6164861917495728,
0.0036882166750729084,
0.8751125335693359,
0.3903055191040039,
-0.3488469421863556,
0.3595910370349884,
0.7537810802459717,
-0.07214755564928055,
0.6595451831817627,
-0.033563148230314255,
-0.0208305511623621,
-0.12271049618721008,
-0.03722631186246872,
-0.4344644248485565,
0.2649102210998535,
0.16402587294578552,
-0.6337388157844543,
0.006300917826592922,
0.0003749715688172728,
-0.21836745738983154,
0.1167154386639595,
-0.37101680040359497,
1.2407526969909668,
0.041513510048389435,
-0.6588453054428101,
0.3176625669002533,
-0.213868647813797,
0.43059444427490234,
-0.5678670406341553,
-0.2439109832048416,
-0.4569801688194275,
0.30409345030784607,
-0.43194010853767395,
-0.8017492890357971,
0.4650735557079315,
-0.038724131882190704,
-0.3460656404495239,
-0.3792726993560791,
0.40344560146331787,
-0.3364553153514862,
-0.7686524987220764,
0.03657903894782066,
0.5104301571846008,
0.09540083259344101,
-0.08514740318059921,
-0.4153706729412079,
-0.4205203950405121,
-0.0005977261462248862,
-0.36564046144485474,
0.16071131825447083,
0.2710663974285126,
0.11653836071491241,
0.4845150411128998,
0.6527607440948486,
0.047091588377952576,
-0.024266572669148445,
0.22793512046337128,
0.8104372620582581,
-0.3569049537181854,
-0.8915606141090393,
-0.5390724539756775,
0.4199894964694977,
-0.4320470988750458,
-0.31130239367485046,
0.9765774607658386,
0.9397842288017273,
0.9292274713516235,
-0.5125031471252441,
0.9892994165420532,
0.13534869253635406,
0.6567683815956116,
-0.4455532133579254,
0.8647106289863586,
-0.4146058261394501,
0.38524672389030457,
0.07526455819606781,
-0.734581470489502,
-0.11538197100162506,
0.5320585370063782,
-0.019177714362740517,
-0.09524758160114288,
0.6783981323242188,
0.7966670393943787,
0.12591569125652313,
0.43817129731178284,
-0.007637029513716698,
0.24878475069999695,
0.10704494267702103,
0.23908153176307678,
0.8217474818229675,
-0.5788799524307251,
0.6367790102958679,
-0.47922462224960327,
-0.16116514801979065,
0.06389934569597244,
-0.48353952169418335,
-1.0373642444610596,
-0.5068880319595337,
-0.5302077531814575,
-0.5186147093772888,
-0.0018552258843556046,
0.9825592637062073,
0.7214751243591309,
-1.1480984687805176,
-0.08229393512010574,
0.053920961916446686,
-0.010181616991758347,
-0.4084290862083435,
-0.20101426541805267,
0.4914112687110901,
-0.3265032172203064,
-0.5463253855705261,
0.2727465033531189,
0.24020811915397644,
0.07941829413175583,
-0.33415552973747253,
-0.11985255032777786,
0.3384307622909546,
0.22823430597782135,
0.6605828404426575,
0.018533622846007347,
-0.5711367726325989,
0.09027998149394989,
0.13224954903125763,
0.19815127551555634,
0.18261423707008362,
0.8558697700500488,
-0.9526278972625732,
0.8211134076118469,
0.4319821298122406,
0.48958250880241394,
0.6266220808029175,
0.21451325714588165,
0.765484094619751,
-0.6285983920097351,
-0.11743330210447311,
0.2867280840873718,
0.33580482006073,
0.28649795055389404,
-0.380561888217926,
0.3722516596317291,
-0.061255451291799545,
-0.22147813439369202,
-0.5018025040626526,
0.14827542006969452,
-1.0176100730895996,
-0.2301541566848755,
0.9721412062644958,
-0.20650890469551086,
-0.20334137976169586,
0.0854337215423584,
-0.4470595121383667,
0.11171404272317886,
-0.3532794117927551,
1.4388641119003296,
0.27566859126091003,
-0.18367254734039307,
0.032194338738918304,
-0.3268685042858124,
0.5903075933456421,
0.12178389728069305,
-1.182776689529419,
-0.09727776050567627,
0.7206094861030579,
0.24931660294532776,
0.08412313461303711,
0.5859516859054565,
-0.3313670754432678,
0.32661333680152893,
0.015356753952801228,
0.22733622789382935,
-0.3471418619155884,
-0.32149744033813477,
-0.3426269292831421,
0.3740766942501068,
-0.46766534447669983,
-0.4852834641933441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05225v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05225v1
|
LayoutLLM: Layout Instruction Tuning with Large Language Models for Document Understanding
| 2024-04-08T06:40:28 | 2024-04-08T06:40:28 |
Chuwei Luo, Yufan Shen, Zhaoqing Zhu, Qi Zheng, Zhi Yu, Cong Yao
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Recently, leveraging large language models (LLMs) or multimodal large
language models (MLLMs) for document understanding has been proven very
promising. However, previous works that employ LLMs/MLLMs for document
understanding have not fully explored and utilized the document layout
information, which is vital for precise document understanding. In this paper,
we propose LayoutLLM, an LLM/MLLM based method for document understanding. The
core of LayoutLLM is a layout instruction tuning strategy, which is specially
designed to enhance the comprehension and utilization of document layouts. The
proposed layout instruction tuning strategy consists of two components:
Layout-aware Pre-training and Layout-aware Supervised Fine-tuning. To capture
the characteristics of document layout in Layout-aware Pre-training, three
groups of pre-training tasks, corresponding to document-level, region-level and
segment-level information, are introduced. Furthermore, a novel module called
layout chain-of-thought (LayoutCoT) is devised to enable LayoutLLM to focus on
regions relevant to the question and generate accurate answers. LayoutCoT is
effective for boosting the performance of document understanding. Meanwhile, it
brings a certain degree of interpretability, which could facilitate manual
inspection and correction. Experiments on standard benchmarks show that the
proposed LayoutLLM significantly outperforms existing methods that adopt
open-source 7B LLMs/MLLMs for document understanding. The training data of the
LayoutLLM is publicly available at
https://github.com/AlibabaResearch/AdvancedLiterateMachinery/tree/main/DocumentUnderstanding/LayoutLLM
|
[
-0.3617931008338928,
-0.8145418167114258,
0.6844310164451599,
0.36096298694610596,
-0.4082186818122864,
0.15412519872188568,
-0.28211545944213867,
-0.04208271577954292,
-0.01137859933078289,
0.7297458052635193,
-0.8169186115264893,
-0.9337126016616821,
-0.28658998012542725,
-0.24204668402671814,
-0.13150903582572937,
0.7387557625770569,
-0.3183508813381195,
0.2476377636194229,
-0.3161749541759491,
0.06634834408760071,
-0.6592108607292175,
-0.2735242247581482,
-0.2708301246166229,
-0.3169507384300232,
0.3790089190006256,
0.3373667597770691,
0.401703417301178,
1.048828125,
0.44662657380104065,
0.30649182200431824,
-0.28317561745643616,
0.6295735836029053,
-0.43773236870765686,
-0.11798672378063202,
-0.11956711858510971,
-0.5341927409172058,
-0.7447057366371155,
0.06612062454223633,
0.6885657906532288,
0.7244946956634521,
-0.08171068131923676,
-0.02379152923822403,
0.05978972837328911,
0.7457917332649231,
-0.6777749061584473,
0.07885605096817017,
-0.5913237929344177,
0.242396280169487,
-0.07437652349472046,
-0.6151246428489685,
-0.7957850694656372,
-0.34394901990890503,
-0.18951767683029175,
-0.866008996963501,
0.24428816139698029,
0.46899327635765076,
0.6138758659362793,
0.24654830992221832,
-0.2447281926870346,
-0.5767587423324585,
-0.38300734758377075,
0.5897284150123596,
-0.44860202074050903,
0.5561010241508484,
0.5284426212310791,
0.022793665528297424,
-0.11415768414735794,
-0.5719879865646362,
-0.2491161823272705,
0.006524623371660709,
-0.3772922158241272,
0.48068124055862427,
0.4181438684463501,
0.21081015467643738,
0.24605023860931396,
0.6335785388946533,
-0.897076427936554,
0.2989688813686371,
-0.15222357213497162,
-0.23843976855278015,
0.26508620381355286,
0.06790223717689514,
0.45457515120506287,
0.06048358976840973,
-0.37899449467658997,
-0.002840030239894986,
-0.45965489745140076,
-0.39345598220825195,
0.36328163743019104,
-0.05295208469033241,
-0.17185620963573456,
0.2467549592256546,
0.21008677780628204,
0.9372302293777466,
0.10741924494504929,
-0.2674240469932556,
0.009341496042907238,
-0.3547476530075073,
-0.6714618802070618,
0.21623018383979797,
0.3227318823337555,
0.18179519474506378,
0.024657215923070908,
-0.17125605046749115,
-0.12939487397670746,
-0.4351135194301605,
0.45917508006095886,
-0.7735499739646912,
-0.342329204082489,
0.04259893670678139,
-0.5012077689170837,
-0.1373349279165268,
0.06634537875652313,
-0.3892204165458679,
-0.5230246186256409,
-0.6042666435241699,
0.3868778645992279,
-0.7484115958213806,
0.08566528558731079,
0.22727294266223907,
-0.05073144659399986,
0.5262373685836792,
0.8173931241035461,
-0.840370237827301,
0.08346975594758987,
0.9090007543563843,
0.8103997111320496,
-0.15912093222141266,
-0.42254742980003357,
-0.48875731229782104,
0.4515169560909271,
-0.40977758169174194,
0.9315162301063538,
-0.3356097638607025,
-0.48317277431488037,
0.010054701007902622,
-0.07658444344997406,
-0.46692198514938354,
-0.47437170147895813,
0.5649943947792053,
-0.5927495956420898,
0.7024418711662292,
0.18240845203399658,
-0.814247190952301,
-0.013421205803751945,
0.5600401759147644,
-0.5660819411277771,
0.5958855152130127,
-0.09124699234962463,
-0.8285642862319946,
0.21565304696559906,
-0.5885318517684937,
-0.6930655241012573,
-0.05182260274887085,
-0.12839411199092865,
-0.5062912106513977,
0.028770333155989647,
0.4164431393146515,
0.22980861365795135,
0.25879257917404175,
-0.1220085471868515,
0.021227072924375534,
-0.49655696749687195,
-0.07047274708747864,
-0.3672427833080292,
0.5634331107139587,
0.3255169093608856,
0.09468352049589157,
0.3407750725746155,
-0.6671441793441772,
0.1614866703748703,
-0.04394020512700081,
-0.5089111924171448,
-0.24783071875572205,
-0.35296717286109924,
0.056403689086437225,
-0.10943653434515,
0.4611760675907135,
-0.05328396335244179,
0.24016010761260986,
-0.6016047596931458,
-0.033309455960989,
0.7553499937057495,
-0.16390326619148254,
0.8911899328231812,
-0.2175302952528,
0.536429762840271,
-0.2840816378593445,
0.13617245852947235,
-0.7847266793251038,
-0.032160434871912,
-0.7909353971481323,
-0.23585523664951324,
0.20310965180397034,
0.5019521117210388,
-0.3249852955341339,
0.6462387442588806,
0.004205739125609398,
-0.03387852758169174,
-0.300128698348999,
0.3726538419723511,
0.7885726690292358,
0.40970566868782043,
0.3330693244934082,
-0.17168109118938446,
-0.4810198247432709,
-0.6507788300514221,
-0.39275386929512024,
0.1598329097032547,
0.11649899184703827,
0.30674561858177185,
0.074678935110569,
-0.019467193633317947,
0.5000321865081787,
-0.7494016885757446,
-0.4780104160308838,
-0.431661993265152,
0.1651715785264969,
0.19838112592697144,
0.39532697200775146,
0.16319577395915985,
-0.678916871547699,
-0.5537223219871521,
0.1565513014793396,
-0.6061491370201111,
-0.07661911100149155,
-0.2573535740375519,
-0.47850167751312256,
0.21446341276168823,
0.7217463254928589,
-0.5817669034004211,
0.3085176348686218,
0.2051367610692978,
-0.23290365934371948,
0.46254289150238037,
-0.6831635236740112,
-0.20653337240219116,
-1.320579171180725,
-0.25723138451576233,
-0.1372995227575302,
-0.15909966826438904,
-0.48683804273605347,
0.22633954882621765,
0.7090988755226135,
-0.09134893864393234,
-0.47321444749832153,
0.6747070550918579,
-1.0046314001083374,
-0.07317592203617096,
-0.37784773111343384,
0.3049388527870178,
0.5798748135566711,
0.40016016364097595,
0.004219749942421913,
0.7591022849082947,
-0.05693890154361725,
-0.24244484305381775,
-0.16461415588855743,
0.33829307556152344,
-0.45381784439086914,
0.5607937574386597,
0.08192822337150574,
0.4381542205810547,
-0.22536559402942657,
0.48515424132347107,
-0.8655417561531067,
-0.22965870797634125,
-0.03831549361348152,
-0.09376928210258484,
0.8063175678253174,
-0.20363391935825348,
-0.43590226769447327,
-0.2530238926410675,
-0.38302725553512573,
-0.09931527078151703,
0.12551862001419067,
-0.6204184293746948,
0.8146638870239258,
0.14061179757118225,
0.14897160232067108,
-0.5132154822349548,
-0.43309423327445984,
-0.19668073952198029,
-0.29324546456336975,
-0.7724767327308655,
0.4639948308467865,
-0.057425059378147125,
-0.13554076850414276,
-0.3994496464729309,
-0.54642653465271,
-0.03216426447033882,
0.18848924338817596,
0.255825012922287,
0.11437752842903137,
-0.2524559199810028,
0.20663408935070038,
0.2379477322101593,
-0.14113521575927734,
-0.0013514599995687604,
-0.6028020977973938,
0.8079869151115417,
0.13079527020454407,
-0.4951201379299164,
-0.3448495864868164,
0.16999602317810059,
0.3216820955276489,
-0.4602656662464142,
0.7018924355506897,
0.829939067363739,
-0.14729663729667664,
-0.4429462254047394,
-0.6510947346687317,
0.13864028453826904,
-0.5014829039573669,
0.4844237267971039,
-0.3893899917602539,
-0.7241312265396118,
0.2806851267814636,
-0.3867541551589966,
0.14673128724098206,
0.14443747699260712,
0.5435694456100464,
-0.4799591898918152,
0.714684009552002,
0.6661993265151978,
-0.03633040934801102,
0.6015329957008362,
-0.3272957503795624,
0.06132331117987633,
-1.011529564857483,
-0.30525705218315125,
-0.475132018327713,
-0.3369848132133484,
-0.2272835671901703,
-0.7536581158638,
0.14375536143779755,
0.31397607922554016,
-0.15042230486869812,
0.009746739640831947,
-0.258005291223526,
0.9280454516410828,
0.4194300174713135,
0.07192879915237427,
0.48137882351875305,
-0.04695228114724159,
-0.3162543773651123,
0.18924732506275177,
-0.4696660041809082,
-0.647495448589325,
0.6969624757766724,
0.29015201330184937,
1.1529394388198853,
-0.09785860031843185,
0.6701863408088684,
0.018113331869244576,
0.12918312847614288,
-0.744909942150116,
0.3907308578491211,
-0.2768550217151642,
-0.18135231733322144,
-0.22393879294395447,
-0.14368730783462524,
-0.7634238004684448,
0.3665953576564789,
0.1935715526342392,
-0.7437039017677307,
-0.2632129490375519,
0.28010740876197815,
-0.07867441326379776,
0.2538321912288666,
-0.9734739661216736,
0.8869274258613586,
-0.6448065042495728,
-0.20615927875041962,
-0.23060518503189087,
-0.4489392042160034,
0.23898738622665405,
-0.05312284082174301,
0.25052139163017273,
0.1252036690711975,
0.24347887933254242,
0.4939640462398529,
-0.4732796251773834,
0.6354438066482544,
-0.0766618549823761,
-0.4508514702320099,
-0.1073864996433258,
0.10465166717767715,
0.5520744323730469,
0.172471821308136,
-0.14872370660305023,
-0.32091885805130005,
-0.3062897324562073,
-0.2387724071741104,
-0.787140965461731,
0.8344899415969849,
-0.8421568870544434,
-0.8612576723098755,
0.09550929814577103,
-0.8680529594421387,
-0.2135753482580185,
0.466302752494812,
0.33965903520584106,
0.46978268027305603,
-0.3469950258731842,
0.1692074090242386,
1.1397188901901245,
-0.34989988803863525,
0.24432678520679474,
0.5159187912940979,
-0.4113875925540924,
-0.1635226160287857,
0.7854599356651306,
-0.20193302631378174,
-0.0314708910882473,
1.0882854461669922,
0.11439945548772812,
-0.4417128562927246,
-0.7476794719696045,
-0.5090934038162231,
0.12531544268131256,
-0.7402426600456238,
-0.14201121032238007,
-0.8251453638076782,
-0.31578582525253296,
-0.14549797773361206,
-0.3849903345108032,
-0.13706311583518982,
-0.23872743546962738,
-0.35697680711746216,
-0.12655028700828552,
-0.009486040100455284,
0.5745020508766174,
0.44299376010894775,
0.5486322641372681,
-0.576366662979126,
0.2964133024215698,
0.1801673024892807,
0.5024228096008301,
-0.04150965437293053,
-0.6964693665504456,
-0.614921510219574,
-0.13366113603115082,
-0.6536898016929626,
-0.5649033188819885,
0.14111065864562988,
0.08016122877597809,
0.6426125764846802,
0.5375000834465027,
-0.28860411047935486,
0.7320849895477295,
-0.530360996723175,
0.12244872003793716,
-0.09550874680280685,
-0.8621013760566711,
0.9104236960411072,
-0.40452340245246887,
0.5668409466743469,
0.4443003237247467,
0.07916206866502762,
-0.3955572545528412,
-0.3235161006450653,
-0.25295019149780273,
-0.5880962014198303,
0.9911381602287292,
0.08905439078807831,
-0.032521698623895645,
0.4626729488372803,
0.42131897807121277,
0.10210748016834259,
0.015302415937185287,
-0.35997575521469116,
0.04514284431934357,
-0.1387069970369339,
-0.3387703597545624,
0.05928665027022362,
-0.15193429589271545,
-0.06983713060617447,
-0.10858182609081268,
0.5150030255317688,
-0.18509230017662048,
-0.021810589358210564,
-0.11961696296930313,
-0.70759117603302,
-0.02455439232289791,
0.3820393681526184,
0.857415497303009,
1.0018234252929688,
-0.4018329679965973,
0.11114713549613953,
0.21295391023159027,
-0.7105733156204224,
0.04557833448052406,
0.07383314520120621,
0.0015894774114713073,
-0.19944041967391968,
0.6321074366569519,
1.1081950664520264,
0.18613359332084656,
-0.23429714143276215,
0.23526343703269958,
-0.23299723863601685,
-0.42095381021499634,
-0.07658910751342773,
0.31147265434265137,
0.3750244975090027,
0.07814183086156845,
0.11048851907253265,
-0.288421094417572,
-0.14754967391490936,
-0.2945846617221832,
0.05589868873357773,
0.4382183253765106,
-0.32965245842933655,
-0.0444391593337059,
0.4040912687778473,
0.24273459613323212,
-0.5607323050498962,
0.5757864117622375,
-0.006608925759792328,
-0.2995434105396271,
0.7167413234710693,
0.7643617391586304,
0.71729576587677,
-0.07588529586791992,
0.24961645901203156,
-0.043778471648693085,
0.3451381027698517,
0.23442238569259644,
0.09397909790277481,
-0.24825376272201538,
-0.6999357342720032,
-0.5038670301437378,
-0.8917639255523682,
-0.41469138860702515,
0.31138449907302856,
-0.5511103868484497,
0.17426040768623352,
-0.628288209438324,
0.4254794418811798,
-0.10160297900438309,
0.2756161391735077,
-0.5674254298210144,
0.27733492851257324,
0.24421775341033936,
1.2782678604125977,
-0.4372791349887848,
0.9180780649185181,
0.9357497096061707,
0.09300417453050613,
-0.8051527738571167,
0.39447125792503357,
0.028857966884970665,
-0.956004798412323,
0.40172719955444336,
0.47910019755363464,
-0.20931939780712128,
0.05841450393199921,
-0.18501994013786316,
-0.5102647542953491,
1.0973849296569824,
0.17671753466129303,
-0.6462963223457336,
-0.08290474861860275,
0.011371213011443615,
0.47095242142677307,
-0.4586135447025299,
0.2892971336841583,
0.4083064794540405,
0.5910098552703857,
0.13033956289291382,
-0.5621216893196106,
-0.08920638263225555,
-0.19848209619522095,
0.20843741297721863,
0.45626479387283325,
-0.7228366732597351,
0.49145177006721497,
-0.1455843299627304,
-0.12256940454244614,
0.06557663530111313,
0.5040761828422546,
0.3789404630661011,
0.3723190724849701,
0.407370924949646,
0.6444501876831055,
0.9914723634719849,
-0.04869444668292999,
0.9231171607971191,
-0.30216798186302185,
0.1512080878019333,
1.4403269290924072,
-0.2709137797355652,
0.3237369954586029,
0.23951873183250427,
0.04181164130568504,
0.21314121782779694,
0.676555871963501,
0.24866077303886414,
0.4621700644493103,
0.22101923823356628,
0.08525798469781876,
-0.3692724108695984,
0.23371586203575134,
-0.4764287769794464,
0.4822145402431488,
0.5540068745613098,
-0.6636817455291748,
-0.25709712505340576,
-0.044682446867227554,
0.06389856338500977,
0.19313721358776093,
-0.3700590431690216,
1.092098593711853,
0.15967530012130737,
-0.3644830882549286,
0.34133705496788025,
0.1799391806125641,
0.3377193212509155,
-0.5098100304603577,
0.15017324686050415,
-0.5967609286308289,
0.30824771523475647,
-0.2311808168888092,
-0.9224375486373901,
0.11234673857688904,
-0.2280912846326828,
-0.4824501574039459,
-0.6324963569641113,
0.8603314161300659,
-0.3203459084033966,
-0.5792334675788879,
0.23620060086250305,
0.5517909526824951,
-0.1929721087217331,
-0.10171391069889069,
-0.5002989172935486,
0.16026560962200165,
0.06897249817848206,
-0.06732209771871567,
0.6543763279914856,
0.7051166892051697,
-0.12777487933635712,
0.35837215185165405,
0.476449579000473,
-0.12422528862953186,
-0.035288531333208084,
0.5111243724822998,
0.7825266718864441,
-0.5128079056739807,
-0.7461753487586975,
-0.888702392578125,
0.26509562134742737,
-0.2448243647813797,
-0.05464717745780945,
0.7378242611885071,
0.8317340016365051,
0.8024331331253052,
-0.047582823783159256,
0.5433770418167114,
0.62331223487854,
0.22862954437732697,
-1.0914191007614136,
1.0584490299224854,
-0.5292586088180542,
0.2738547921180725,
-0.27741682529449463,
-1.147902488708496,
-0.3355158865451813,
0.661350429058075,
-0.5426802039146423,
-0.06380830705165863,
0.801243007183075,
0.7032251954078674,
-0.3239167034626007,
0.16323643922805786,
0.33209410309791565,
0.21698778867721558,
0.28065064549446106,
0.24993181228637695,
0.8702431917190552,
0.0025140789803117514,
0.5160068273544312,
-0.10724842548370361,
-0.16634643077850342,
-0.33291712403297424,
-0.7360267639160156,
-1.0936176776885986,
-0.22993674874305725,
-0.06439216434955597,
-0.021139949560165405,
0.12946312129497528,
0.5219882726669312,
0.7207704186439514,
-0.46446460485458374,
-0.21949918568134308,
-0.016420813277363777,
0.5884140133857727,
0.12105116993188858,
-0.19322632253170013,
0.6400085687637329,
-0.5576789975166321,
-0.5016005039215088,
0.4329991936683655,
0.7680928111076355,
-0.12005358934402466,
-0.2130737155675888,
-0.17184431850910187,
-0.16143059730529785,
0.006063646636903286,
0.571516215801239,
-0.11837869137525558,
-0.6339122653007507,
0.18670141696929932,
-0.01930752396583557,
-0.15471328794956207,
0.27361100912094116,
0.9271125793457031,
-0.24027661979198456,
0.5087214708328247,
0.4653155505657196,
0.5566774606704712,
0.6436308026313782,
0.2400347739458084,
0.517657458782196,
-1.0302550792694092,
0.2610531747341156,
-0.21538010239601135,
0.46088647842407227,
0.2614006996154785,
-0.6618441939353943,
0.346497118473053,
-0.21436375379562378,
-0.3235374987125397,
-0.3947131335735321,
0.19366003572940826,
-0.8462616205215454,
-0.40948486328125,
0.8786598443984985,
-0.16106072068214417,
-0.38022470474243164,
0.08038097620010376,
-0.6005210280418396,
0.24355663359165192,
-0.19375666975975037,
0.6737023591995239,
0.6431072950363159,
-0.15019108355045319,
-0.36157873272895813,
-0.18477612733840942,
0.27217209339141846,
0.41481664776802063,
-1.0851948261260986,
0.018096603453159332,
0.40260279178619385,
-0.10926485061645508,
0.1951897144317627,
0.6284525990486145,
0.01176479086279869,
0.15260206162929535,
-0.4170868694782257,
-0.24115848541259766,
-0.2875194549560547,
-0.38876232504844666,
-0.06593628227710724,
0.12256061285734177,
0.05286835879087448,
-0.16416044533252716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05221v1
|
LLM Reasoners: New Evaluation, Library, and Analysis of Step-by-Step Reasoning with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-08T06:35:09 | 2024-04-08T06:35:09 |
Shibo Hao, Yi Gu, Haotian Luo, Tianyang Liu, Xiyan Shao, Xinyuan Wang, Shuhua Xie, Haodi Ma, Adithya Samavedhi, Qiyue Gao, Zhen Wang, Zhiting Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generating accurate step-by-step reasoning is essential for Large Language
Models (LLMs) to address complex problems and enhance robustness and
interpretability. Despite the flux of research on developing advanced reasoning
approaches, systematically analyzing the diverse LLMs and reasoning strategies
in generating reasoning chains remains a significant challenge. The
difficulties stem from the lack of two key elements: (1) an automatic method
for evaluating the generated reasoning chains on different tasks, and (2) a
unified formalism and implementation of the diverse reasoning approaches for
systematic comparison. This paper aims to close the gap: (1) We introduce
AutoRace for fully automated reasoning chain evaluation. Existing metrics rely
on expensive human annotations or pre-defined LLM prompts not adaptable to
different tasks. In contrast, AutoRace automatically creates detailed
evaluation criteria tailored for each task, and uses GPT-4 for accurate
evaluation following the criteria. (2) We develop LLM Reasoners, a library for
standardized modular implementation of existing and new reasoning algorithms,
under a unified formulation of the search, reward, and world model components.
With the new evaluation and library, (3) we conduct extensive study of
different reasoning approaches (e.g., CoT, ToT, RAP). The analysis reveals
interesting findings about different factors contributing to reasoning,
including the reward-guidance, breadth-vs-depth in search, world model, and
prompt formats, etc.
|
[
-0.38976672291755676,
-0.6127673387527466,
0.9826151132583618,
0.08479245752096176,
-0.11667764186859131,
0.1495295763015747,
-0.04942392557859421,
-0.29383009672164917,
-0.10741134732961655,
0.3605266511440277,
-0.6124832034111023,
-0.4762708246707916,
-0.46833932399749756,
0.2686085104942322,
-0.4316675662994385,
0.6824564337730408,
-0.46820902824401855,
-0.09519866853952408,
-0.2731510102748871,
-0.021115664392709732,
-0.3232583701610565,
-0.35710135102272034,
-0.5784282684326172,
-0.4900817275047302,
0.6204127073287964,
0.3384968042373657,
0.5401523113250732,
0.5855872631072998,
0.49449220299720764,
0.3686503469944,
0.05436280742287636,
0.3337770402431488,
-0.02160036563873291,
0.32687658071517944,
-0.4143543243408203,
-0.14427568018436432,
-0.48081400990486145,
0.0012095043202862144,
0.2824231684207916,
0.377673864364624,
-0.045235153287649155,
0.4198240041732788,
-0.23288951814174652,
0.72198086977005,
-0.6657281517982483,
0.04637502506375313,
-0.5331141352653503,
-0.01602381467819214,
-0.05351482331752777,
-0.49192872643470764,
-0.3996886610984802,
-0.29446467757225037,
0.11392231285572052,
-0.5154154896736145,
0.030801132321357727,
0.19935715198516846,
0.4758587181568146,
0.5486730337142944,
-0.5722352266311646,
-0.758823812007904,
-0.6599823832511902,
0.7053254842758179,
-0.8003808856010437,
0.2744636535644531,
-0.030941825360059738,
0.4420327842235565,
-0.40081986784935,
-0.6982095241546631,
-0.4162900447845459,
-0.4784211218357086,
0.048485055565834045,
-0.030488213524222374,
-0.2226942479610443,
0.019720271229743958,
0.3043918013572693,
0.5063908100128174,
-0.5343530178070068,
0.14318327605724335,
-0.08197959512472153,
-0.2059156894683838,
0.8176538944244385,
0.35595980286598206,
0.43710097670555115,
-0.1665496826171875,
-0.21809889376163483,
-0.007168466225266457,
-0.5887652039527893,
-0.08214076608419418,
0.44496291875839233,
-0.1391976922750473,
0.14360029995441437,
0.5916996598243713,
-0.3621861934661865,
0.7898621559143066,
0.13526111841201782,
-0.1956542283296585,
0.007211298681795597,
-0.36907798051834106,
-0.2261148989200592,
-0.16120727360248566,
0.9244272112846375,
0.1878204643726349,
0.29050785303115845,
-0.22377242147922516,
-0.3698205053806305,
-0.0874498188495636,
0.14578877389431,
-0.7261309623718262,
-0.4040306806564331,
0.34977424144744873,
-0.4311407208442688,
-0.311309814453125,
-0.09701863676309586,
-0.48840588331222534,
-0.32054266333580017,
-0.7237503528594971,
0.28192782402038574,
-0.22883886098861694,
-0.11849620938301086,
0.2517692744731903,
-0.02380663901567459,
0.39079511165618896,
0.6893870830535889,
-0.5813930034637451,
0.3410911560058594,
0.6263971924781799,
0.6371632218360901,
-0.5450034141540527,
-0.4281103014945984,
-0.5559337735176086,
0.04260968416929245,
-0.33469799160957336,
1.1166621446609497,
-0.42832469940185547,
-0.053329020738601685,
-0.25341424345970154,
-0.09298495948314667,
-0.040327202528715134,
-0.4381364583969116,
0.6527533531188965,
-0.5086872577667236,
0.16264790296554565,
-0.38064339756965637,
-0.6439900994300842,
-0.17011769115924835,
0.551656186580658,
-0.645565390586853,
1.1016967296600342,
-0.21389240026474,
-0.7636579275131226,
0.2769660949707031,
-0.7933229804039001,
-0.4309121370315552,
0.03105938993394375,
-0.1829155683517456,
0.07623088359832764,
0.22744837403297424,
0.3842812776565552,
0.26224327087402344,
-0.7651032209396362,
0.45649808645248413,
-0.13094434142112732,
-0.21516193449497223,
0.2699704170227051,
-0.512887716293335,
0.9671415686607361,
0.31013861298561096,
-0.5769385695457458,
0.5688858032226562,
-0.8187811374664307,
0.05563513934612274,
0.24157844483852386,
-0.33420124650001526,
-0.16155926883220673,
0.25651249289512634,
-0.41554707288742065,
0.2919144332408905,
0.3880557119846344,
-0.23849977552890778,
0.31063732504844666,
-0.0820554867386818,
0.33968353271484375,
0.8188624978065491,
-0.03672439232468605,
0.2675906717777252,
-0.004343422129750252,
0.7118073105812073,
-0.22667554020881653,
0.3015173077583313,
-0.38368093967437744,
-0.3405689597129822,
-0.9462643265724182,
-0.0733257532119751,
0.1454431414604187,
0.6611239314079285,
-0.4786320924758911,
0.5981630086898804,
0.021465998142957687,
-0.593128502368927,
-0.2954252064228058,
0.19744746387004852,
0.3021586537361145,
0.18307974934577942,
0.4343557059764862,
-0.25419914722442627,
-0.5576151013374329,
-0.7158719301223755,
-0.37846800684928894,
-0.34635716676712036,
0.025924712419509888,
0.053617555648088455,
0.6106166243553162,
-0.45305174589157104,
0.8414941430091858,
-0.17593376338481903,
0.33060696721076965,
-0.34298864006996155,
0.13350382447242737,
0.12479675561189651,
0.19757840037345886,
0.0987747311592102,
-0.2586517632007599,
-0.1845298409461975,
-0.0700128898024559,
-0.7979073524475098,
-0.35267964005470276,
-0.15873552858829498,
-0.24804550409317017,
0.1549091339111328,
0.5367600321769714,
-0.4888533353805542,
0.12507875263690948,
0.3611966669559479,
-0.4766746461391449,
0.8529137372970581,
-0.2480369657278061,
0.094035804271698,
-0.6509544849395752,
0.11625438183546066,
0.002853025682270527,
-0.20363686978816986,
-0.2971498668193817,
0.2735675275325775,
-0.21849769353866577,
0.06567686051130295,
-0.08620872348546982,
0.7134389281272888,
-0.6099294424057007,
-0.14733606576919556,
-0.265405535697937,
0.16348160803318024,
0.03804934397339821,
0.18849268555641174,
-0.12736836075782776,
0.4771021604537964,
0.5601496696472168,
-0.6290415525436401,
0.7384757399559021,
-0.0716409832239151,
-0.23212823271751404,
0.31169024109840393,
-0.6742695569992065,
0.33240967988967896,
0.14418219029903412,
0.47268402576446533,
-0.9983804821968079,
-0.17627054452896118,
0.303994745016098,
-0.28396230936050415,
0.07067844271659851,
-0.11761204898357391,
-0.7187930941581726,
-0.6675981283187866,
-0.10867360979318619,
0.46535471081733704,
0.3913029134273529,
-0.6542469263076782,
0.6254811882972717,
0.2884744703769684,
-0.0586501844227314,
-0.5194700956344604,
-0.30692964792251587,
0.21819669008255005,
-0.20596612989902496,
-0.5275712013244629,
-0.06243181973695755,
-0.34210923314094543,
-0.6067799925804138,
-0.09146147966384888,
-0.4530073404312134,
0.05693565681576729,
0.1860942244529724,
0.008698894642293453,
0.22849565744400024,
-0.08741410076618195,
-0.07107073813676834,
0.0401671938598156,
-0.4974573254585266,
0.4991234242916107,
-0.5682218074798584,
0.3350653350353241,
-0.33745208382606506,
-0.7174471020698547,
-0.30361655354499817,
0.08207925409078598,
0.6158550977706909,
-0.35707396268844604,
-0.02384495548903942,
0.44138726592063904,
-0.004546838346868753,
-0.2639103829860687,
-0.8138022422790527,
0.03376232087612152,
-0.4238741993904114,
0.02233596332371235,
-0.4177529811859131,
-0.9063949584960938,
0.36239296197891235,
-0.2555938959121704,
0.22067397832870483,
0.5601198077201843,
0.8652505874633789,
0.09689903259277344,
0.9193721413612366,
0.19666513800621033,
-0.005721806548535824,
-0.10746161639690399,
0.08211676776409149,
0.30953142046928406,
-0.5431749224662781,
-0.2701044976711273,
-0.3925767242908478,
-0.15585173666477203,
-0.36435359716415405,
-0.7131440043449402,
0.04624393209815025,
0.12122034281492233,
-0.2921554744243622,
0.12064321339130402,
-0.6915023922920227,
0.632382333278656,
0.25396037101745605,
-0.39791804552078247,
0.6435261964797974,
-0.04257062450051308,
-0.5209125876426697,
0.2572243809700012,
-0.6237139701843262,
-0.6790024042129517,
1.0176966190338135,
0.41202640533447266,
0.8456422090530396,
-0.16793788969516754,
0.8398071527481079,
0.2395712286233902,
0.3897830545902252,
-0.9619953036308289,
0.7174601554870605,
0.14455360174179077,
-0.5174798369407654,
-0.19899818301200867,
-0.5116066932678223,
-0.6150464415550232,
0.2758876383304596,
0.22633543610572815,
-0.6002798676490784,
-0.04062441736459732,
0.21267712116241455,
-0.1917385756969452,
0.2836570143699646,
-0.34524816274642944,
0.8555811047554016,
-0.6636275053024292,
-0.2222343534231186,
-0.07564283162355423,
-0.59044349193573,
0.5453090071678162,
0.056172583252191544,
0.24416658282279968,
-0.2769358456134796,
0.11481938511133194,
0.5780466198921204,
-0.6427217125892639,
0.5824915170669556,
-0.1355929672718048,
-0.5019784569740295,
0.6324124932289124,
0.39354208111763,
0.6331257224082947,
-0.07436122745275497,
-0.099895179271698,
-0.13694775104522705,
0.0014714474091306329,
-0.15866625308990479,
-0.6392386555671692,
0.6405864953994751,
-0.33961722254753113,
-0.6980319023132324,
-0.5083306431770325,
-0.7073390483856201,
-0.037201181054115295,
0.14485464990139008,
0.07445239275693893,
0.3168209195137024,
-0.0680624395608902,
-0.27781030535697937,
0.5892909169197083,
-0.21775035560131073,
0.30482059717178345,
0.5720638036727905,
-0.4781951308250427,
-0.36835727095603943,
0.7198610305786133,
-0.20645615458488464,
0.11506035923957825,
0.27435871958732605,
0.27562829852104187,
-0.39909255504608154,
-0.6006702184677124,
-0.6560569405555725,
0.21187491714954376,
-0.9138309955596924,
-0.08487745374441147,
-0.46306103467941284,
-0.07693219184875488,
-0.041461341083049774,
-0.06867751479148865,
-0.40314579010009766,
-0.4419185221195221,
0.1904481202363968,
-0.08912070840597153,
0.3885640501976013,
0.9280208945274353,
-0.11507700383663177,
-0.09050771594047546,
-0.5135763883590698,
0.35435476899147034,
0.4437183141708374,
0.11601289361715317,
0.1954748034477234,
-0.3679437041282654,
-0.13372457027435303,
-0.4413089156150818,
-0.3466857075691223,
-0.8047868013381958,
0.12237465381622314,
-0.2741345167160034,
0.7384275794029236,
0.08697871118783951,
-0.07707303017377853,
0.799220860004425,
-0.5291350483894348,
0.5247695446014404,
0.13398508727550507,
-1.1042875051498413,
0.627633273601532,
-0.18628297746181488,
0.18747708201408386,
0.4798452854156494,
0.304522842168808,
-0.29873159527778625,
-0.3135561943054199,
-0.5672990083694458,
-1.021070122718811,
0.3996051251888275,
0.21749946475028992,
-0.35249224305152893,
-0.06380584090948105,
0.38960957527160645,
0.12658126652240753,
-0.10100551694631577,
-0.788363516330719,
-0.27817970514297485,
-0.052291110157966614,
-0.16221363842487335,
0.13772010803222656,
-0.2110263854265213,
-0.03134894743561745,
-0.477265864610672,
0.6334018707275391,
-0.2572057843208313,
0.10568647086620331,
0.25780174136161804,
-0.3301527202129364,
-0.16670584678649902,
0.4233205020427704,
0.20328882336616516,
0.8841447830200195,
-0.027466237545013428,
0.26087087392807007,
0.1973843276500702,
0.04138201102614403,
0.4265284836292267,
0.20347365736961365,
-0.23807191848754883,
0.03363342955708504,
0.36783021688461304,
0.7058363556861877,
0.0802248865365982,
-0.8521291613578796,
0.33056607842445374,
-0.09046884626150131,
-0.22158057987689972,
-0.4764549434185028,
0.11870540678501129,
0.18884725868701935,
0.3203775882720947,
0.29807859659194946,
-0.08346430957317352,
0.4154629707336426,
-0.3958641290664673,
0.1606212556362152,
0.3349410891532898,
-0.2258714884519577,
-0.25878670811653137,
0.5131688117980957,
0.13470177352428436,
-0.15667541325092316,
0.4709598124027252,
-0.6161211729049683,
-0.4479121267795563,
0.5148450136184692,
0.51088547706604,
1.0434077978134155,
-0.29345688223838806,
0.1877165138721466,
0.48653674125671387,
0.500602126121521,
-0.28612232208251953,
0.16254915297031403,
-0.23568210005760193,
-0.5345954298973083,
-0.9580278396606445,
-0.7629728317260742,
-0.5282610654830933,
0.08772769570350647,
-0.515354573726654,
0.2102382928133011,
-0.2706283926963806,
0.19771450757980347,
-0.2880195081233978,
-0.10228759050369263,
-0.5214084386825562,
0.20270884037017822,
0.20838980376720428,
0.9748415350914001,
-0.7076653242111206,
0.7512096166610718,
0.8273666501045227,
-0.30224600434303284,
-0.9014933705329895,
0.039178479462862015,
0.07383152097463608,
-0.586178183555603,
0.6834830641746521,
0.1805722713470459,
-0.31381869316101074,
-0.04031806439161301,
-0.39613574743270874,
-0.8439291715621948,
1.0861234664916992,
0.2879657447338104,
-0.7490813732147217,
-0.19315968453884125,
-0.04796589910984039,
0.3674514591693878,
-0.5338375568389893,
0.5115496516227722,
0.9536574482917786,
0.7116128206253052,
0.34574058651924133,
-0.9114922285079956,
0.3246098458766937,
-0.3599693477153778,
-0.17516781389713287,
0.21593907475471497,
-0.18751581013202667,
0.6308674216270447,
-0.3295435905456543,
0.021410122513771057,
0.1394062340259552,
0.4226280748844147,
0.8611459136009216,
0.3721590042114258,
0.5937729477882385,
0.7016891837120056,
0.852584183216095,
0.08566346019506454,
1.0855153799057007,
-0.24645493924617767,
0.3860873281955719,
1.148984432220459,
-0.378019779920578,
0.5107247233390808,
0.30551761388778687,
-0.22301749885082245,
0.696147084236145,
0.6685060262680054,
-0.10421120375394821,
0.05967678129673004,
0.5954784750938416,
-0.035288628190755844,
-0.5961486101150513,
0.3155456781387329,
-0.09099502116441727,
0.27450916171073914,
0.29459261894226074,
-0.20261543989181519,
-0.444860577583313,
-0.49569058418273926,
-0.02973788045346737,
-0.21937322616577148,
-0.3066316545009613,
0.6150698661804199,
0.1536065936088562,
-0.6773402690887451,
0.6096779704093933,
-0.037673983722925186,
0.4466092586517334,
-0.46006152033805847,
0.07181350141763687,
-0.04814152419567108,
0.04489828646183014,
-0.3300511837005615,
-0.5995534658432007,
0.2928502857685089,
0.33813244104385376,
0.05338391661643982,
-0.10642910748720169,
0.9370489120483398,
0.01248108223080635,
-0.5839825868606567,
0.5495674014091492,
0.7078213691711426,
0.37549257278442383,
-0.061685848981142044,
-0.9886892437934875,
0.06140276417136192,
0.11785828322172165,
-0.513529360294342,
0.023490404710173607,
0.7546062469482422,
-0.14427641034126282,
0.8783906102180481,
0.7344934344291687,
-0.04135654494166374,
0.12534275650978088,
0.2217409461736679,
0.7958901524543762,
-0.9129173755645752,
-0.14080806076526642,
-1.09970223903656,
0.608177661895752,
0.06738700717687607,
-0.19306792318820953,
0.8802635669708252,
0.6427072882652283,
0.5086595416069031,
0.10864557325839996,
0.9345762729644775,
-0.14960306882858276,
0.3504512906074524,
-0.5895631313323975,
0.2629725933074951,
-0.6169050335884094,
0.4380923807621002,
-0.24739329516887665,
-1.025879144668579,
-0.22707246243953705,
0.6305080652236938,
-0.3645617663860321,
0.03061128966510296,
0.9855868816375732,
0.4671677052974701,
-0.11336699873209,
-0.07789469510316849,
-0.012033077888190746,
0.30006277561187744,
0.4769894480705261,
0.5562052130699158,
1.126766562461853,
-0.27766695618629456,
0.6146649718284607,
0.056580375880002975,
-0.18092553317546844,
-0.07521463185548782,
-1.1590474843978882,
-0.829291045665741,
-0.2561686336994171,
-0.45460253953933716,
-0.20680555701255798,
-0.0968799889087677,
0.9093940854072571,
0.35514435172080994,
-0.7846224904060364,
-0.515758752822876,
-0.5667794942855835,
0.15428078174591064,
-0.07784366607666016,
-0.18146578967571259,
0.2799151837825775,
-0.7700180411338806,
-0.4145616590976715,
0.7261254191398621,
0.5723901391029358,
-0.3564983308315277,
-0.5352737903594971,
-0.3715571463108063,
0.03201288357377052,
0.0559992790222168,
0.7034245133399963,
0.2555534839630127,
-1.046791911125183,
-0.022557007148861885,
-0.043173596262931824,
0.10833890736103058,
0.029395749792456627,
1.0973217487335205,
-0.7923877239227295,
0.41145414113998413,
0.5580633878707886,
0.5276784300804138,
0.49495425820350647,
-0.15723979473114014,
0.6916288733482361,
-0.07633624970912933,
-0.19581350684165955,
0.17321419715881348,
0.47680580615997314,
0.3522771894931793,
0.023337502032518387,
0.6532983183860779,
0.17875775694847107,
-0.882323145866394,
-0.7175726890563965,
0.4419964849948883,
-0.907660961151123,
-0.3128701448440552,
1.2668637037277222,
-0.13444657623767853,
-0.18028615415096283,
-0.17692750692367554,
-0.18796806037425995,
0.2298714518547058,
-0.22352401912212372,
0.6400215029716492,
0.6676760315895081,
-0.36117157340049744,
-0.09995973110198975,
-0.5799322128295898,
0.3649553954601288,
0.30343854427337646,
-1.0566208362579346,
0.21209000051021576,
0.676196813583374,
0.5208091139793396,
0.1333942413330078,
0.604038655757904,
-0.2701134979724884,
0.13967497646808624,
-0.2999313771724701,
0.19813323020935059,
-0.0768168643116951,
-0.43729206919670105,
-0.21668794751167297,
-0.03942640498280525,
0.4006192982196808,
0.3234395682811737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05210v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05210v1
|
Bidirectional Long-Range Parser for Sequential Data Understanding
| 2024-04-08T05:45:03 | 2024-04-08T05:45:03 |
George Leotescu, Daniel Voinea, Alin-Ionut Popa
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The transformer is a powerful data modelling framework responsible for
remarkable performance on a wide range of tasks. However, they are limited in
terms of scalability as it is suboptimal and inefficient to process
long-sequence data. To this purpose we introduce BLRP (Bidirectional Long-Range
Parser), a novel and versatile attention mechanism designed to increase
performance and efficiency on long-sequence tasks. It leverages short and long
range heuristics in the form of a local sliding window approach combined with a
global bidirectional latent space synthesis technique. We show the benefits and
versatility of our approach on vision and language domains by demonstrating
competitive results against state-of-the-art methods on the Long-Range-Arena
and CIFAR benchmarks together with ablations demonstrating the computational
efficiency.
|
[
-0.21362406015396118,
-0.3459537625312805,
0.4445412755012512,
0.5775544047355652,
-0.26869019865989685,
0.11619020253419876,
-0.29720982909202576,
-0.4470619559288025,
-0.15455447137355804,
0.2930768132209778,
-0.4958052635192871,
-0.19604498147964478,
-0.4369280934333801,
0.00873496662825346,
-0.4347788691520691,
0.7372003197669983,
0.140669584274292,
-0.3192427456378937,
-0.13790376484394073,
-0.010521759279072285,
-0.3925410211086273,
-0.2433663010597229,
-0.7322337627410889,
-0.25571408867836,
0.829326868057251,
0.4922706186771393,
0.8619171977043152,
0.3347833454608917,
1.0983637571334839,
0.2572554349899292,
-0.18163816630840302,
-0.052600499242544174,
-0.36669498682022095,
0.22458486258983612,
-0.5826532244682312,
-0.43809932470321655,
-0.28521063923835754,
-0.3658750057220459,
1.0637948513031006,
1.0677493810653687,
0.018480343744158745,
0.20642568171024323,
0.12747368216514587,
1.1946141719818115,
-0.7627174854278564,
0.046381402760744095,
-0.48460647463798523,
0.4091663062572479,
-0.3653542101383209,
-0.09329380095005035,
-0.6912538409233093,
-0.17031706869602203,
0.3014098107814789,
-0.17426714301109314,
0.3797062337398529,
-0.10550060868263245,
0.7226870656013489,
0.5842414498329163,
-0.3331919312477112,
0.16151884198188782,
-0.9183549284934998,
0.6284158229827881,
-0.6091334223747253,
0.8082684278488159,
-0.05223129317164421,
0.7275632619857788,
0.09018760174512863,
-1.0866756439208984,
-0.6075844168663025,
0.1074710488319397,
-0.29854461550712585,
0.28265783190727234,
-0.28106042742729187,
-0.12403770536184311,
0.4592929184436798,
0.3258160650730133,
-0.9537445306777954,
0.02666962333023548,
-0.23339791595935822,
0.04470217600464821,
0.5194166898727417,
0.1193678006529808,
-0.29650723934173584,
-0.28449293971061707,
-0.5313413739204407,
-0.10528861731290817,
-0.5877084732055664,
0.31385788321495056,
0.08277039974927902,
0.26147475838661194,
-0.10589857399463654,
0.5674388408660889,
-0.19276584684848785,
0.9686766266822815,
0.2720920741558075,
0.21874193847179413,
0.20573964715003967,
-0.24302487075328827,
-0.36648282408714294,
-0.1182842031121254,
0.6540674567222595,
0.34939438104629517,
-0.155920147895813,
-0.20525230467319489,
0.007416272535920143,
0.1458810269832611,
0.25659310817718506,
-0.8222709894180298,
0.048078637570142746,
0.23937465250492096,
-0.41137439012527466,
-0.18564370274543762,
-0.11517051607370377,
-1.0873068571090698,
0.15571507811546326,
-0.15282705426216125,
0.039825309067964554,
-0.2514992654323578,
0.08158987015485764,
0.3011702597141266,
0.01046269852668047,
0.4077129662036896,
0.23324309289455414,
-0.8420107960700989,
0.1528715193271637,
0.6667079925537109,
0.9385648965835571,
-0.37149736285209656,
-0.25184065103530884,
-0.7729785442352295,
0.4538336396217346,
-0.12213025242090225,
0.7687331438064575,
-0.6855440139770508,
-0.3516325056552887,
-0.19888724386692047,
0.04258935526013374,
-0.19300882518291473,
-0.5221386551856995,
0.6135293245315552,
-0.7540435194969177,
0.23768317699432373,
-0.08476578444242477,
-0.19290614128112793,
-0.0610499233007431,
-0.04914727061986923,
-0.5850783586502075,
0.9678374528884888,
0.14117199182510376,
-0.8612279891967773,
0.24073641002178192,
-0.8071930408477783,
-0.7681074738502502,
0.2910808324813843,
0.09320706874132156,
-0.4195738732814789,
0.2042248696088791,
0.17142507433891296,
0.4823978841304779,
-0.1565408855676651,
0.552237331867218,
0.0034241562243551016,
-0.14916309714317322,
0.2899278402328491,
-0.6930414438247681,
0.4195048213005066,
0.23873329162597656,
-0.27974265813827515,
0.09919903427362442,
-0.9019198417663574,
-0.32192838191986084,
0.039424195885658264,
-0.3509039878845215,
-0.1527475267648697,
0.26069214940071106,
0.13562478125095367,
0.3412375748157501,
0.38745105266571045,
-0.4619150757789612,
0.18349884450435638,
-0.7971601486206055,
0.39923906326293945,
0.6153616905212402,
-0.2359035164117813,
0.5039527416229248,
-0.11896764487028122,
0.31405767798423767,
0.3361310064792633,
0.1563824713230133,
-0.4448392689228058,
-0.34082135558128357,
-0.6878575086593628,
-0.1644057035446167,
0.15142878890037537,
0.7180523872375488,
-0.8423539996147156,
0.44248655438423157,
-0.5020438432693481,
-0.18299713730812073,
-0.5067636966705322,
-0.11126139760017395,
0.23818746209144592,
0.7565429210662842,
0.4046238362789154,
-0.4290723502635956,
-0.48888349533081055,
-1.01394522190094,
-0.18605780601501465,
0.2182231843471527,
-0.014356911182403564,
0.3010374903678894,
0.26231062412261963,
-0.38957729935646057,
1.0873297452926636,
-0.8318089246749878,
-0.18778058886528015,
-0.2720298171043396,
0.010130195878446102,
0.7010051608085632,
0.48716452717781067,
0.1979016214609146,
-1.0798403024673462,
-0.7106531262397766,
0.23779717087745667,
-0.6644401550292969,
-0.16093619167804718,
-0.26457786560058594,
-0.1969130039215088,
0.18713386356830597,
0.463570773601532,
-0.9483487606048584,
0.5381357073783875,
0.4911806285381317,
-0.3870610296726227,
0.2789352238178253,
0.09240851551294327,
-0.01619151420891285,
-1.0909502506256104,
0.4254308342933655,
0.04036076366901398,
-0.49918636679649353,
-0.7470130324363708,
0.21965733170509338,
0.18278391659259796,
-0.3847484886646271,
-0.5291128754615784,
0.31314706802368164,
-0.2738228142261505,
-0.4040042757987976,
-0.14425183832645416,
0.12412458658218384,
0.17032572627067566,
0.44895240664482117,
0.34121695160865784,
0.8413707613945007,
0.4860018193721771,
-0.18428604304790497,
0.43795788288116455,
0.3087099492549896,
-0.1481366604566574,
0.45080432295799255,
-0.7649115920066833,
0.20401594042778015,
-0.379116415977478,
0.1639600694179535,
-1.2523717880249023,
-0.061228420585393906,
0.10644600540399551,
-0.32244130969047546,
0.4963288903236389,
-0.40890267491340637,
-0.2830072045326233,
-0.7419804334640503,
-0.11594749242067337,
0.5716656446456909,
0.5755887031555176,
-0.7066506147384644,
0.5820448994636536,
-0.0690552368760109,
-0.38424572348594666,
-0.6831578016281128,
-0.7145077586174011,
0.2361498475074768,
-0.1182638630270958,
-0.8253706097602844,
0.4750130772590637,
-0.04486776888370514,
-0.08389712125062943,
-0.35168150067329407,
0.02788235805928707,
0.15857133269309998,
-0.2937197983264923,
0.17355963587760925,
0.17632967233657837,
-0.3040114939212799,
-0.2441091686487198,
0.09525248408317566,
-0.47087010741233826,
-0.0980323851108551,
-0.34859198331832886,
0.5726845860481262,
-0.11532469093799591,
-0.3455654978752136,
-0.5407004356384277,
0.5436920523643494,
0.6511597037315369,
-0.45717644691467285,
0.23635068535804749,
0.5093889832496643,
-0.07852689176797867,
-0.30223608016967773,
-0.3566302955150604,
0.09788356721401215,
-0.5885553359985352,
0.2294243723154068,
-0.3566169738769531,
-0.8012531399726868,
0.3431020677089691,
-0.15417392551898956,
0.0028783660382032394,
0.1853049397468567,
0.6344760060310364,
-0.07012177258729935,
0.8638005256652832,
0.5238059759140015,
-0.15755635499954224,
0.3678939640522003,
-0.22022058069705963,
0.5304648876190186,
-0.8128803372383118,
-0.06587553769350052,
-0.3845345377922058,
-0.36473944783210754,
-0.26900073885917664,
-0.8397616744041443,
0.4754301905632019,
-0.21436259150505066,
0.057403046637773514,
0.15355677902698517,
-0.6108404397964478,
0.5097301006317139,
0.40272700786590576,
-0.003652521874755621,
0.2107411026954651,
-0.04809432476758957,
0.09394656121730804,
-0.1963263750076294,
-0.5373093485832214,
-0.20138366520404816,
0.7670411467552185,
0.5562114119529724,
0.7905490398406982,
0.1798393428325653,
0.48209908604621887,
0.3036203682422638,
0.000059668054745998234,
-0.9295933246612549,
0.8034470081329346,
-0.4630616307258606,
-0.1068580225110054,
-0.3836340308189392,
-0.24668052792549133,
-1.0724278688430786,
0.4589996635913849,
0.30406486988067627,
-0.5644146800041199,
0.37881311774253845,
0.18893291056156158,
-0.3573992848396301,
0.12021230906248093,
-0.675257682800293,
0.780401349067688,
-0.0036293300800025463,
-0.9239425659179688,
-0.17017094790935516,
-1.109579086303711,
0.07909975200891495,
0.04802241548895836,
-0.011795016005635262,
0.07818116247653961,
0.17000657320022583,
0.5045074820518494,
-0.13696537911891937,
0.8182379603385925,
-0.40817493200302124,
-0.04830204322934151,
-0.00929892249405384,
0.04241164028644562,
0.5884985327720642,
0.06178295239806175,
0.09386806190013885,
0.12452229112386703,
-0.4429900050163269,
-0.2852683663368225,
-0.563679039478302,
0.4188975393772125,
-0.2185623049736023,
-0.6442739367485046,
-0.4076966941356659,
-0.7344921231269836,
-0.306805282831192,
0.3247925341129303,
-0.012675639241933823,
0.3338112235069275,
0.03693578019738197,
0.21231044828891754,
0.6090864539146423,
-0.04601798579096794,
0.9939638376235962,
0.44509977102279663,
-0.04460125416517258,
-0.21043704450130463,
0.741014301776886,
-0.24042527377605438,
0.22750844061374664,
0.8390288949012756,
0.08805304020643234,
-0.27496686577796936,
-0.5493428707122803,
-0.3717249929904938,
0.2027926743030548,
-0.6386483907699585,
-0.27745312452316284,
-0.40948471426963806,
-0.3082088232040405,
-0.3379719853401184,
-0.4371829330921173,
-0.337411493062973,
-0.5024407505989075,
-0.132790207862854,
0.18392841517925262,
-0.1906619518995285,
0.3001105487346649,
-0.16018642485141754,
0.4103144407272339,
-0.8328068256378174,
0.6357648968696594,
0.511161208152771,
0.3336879312992096,
-0.04574071243405342,
-0.3859002888202667,
-0.3798929452896118,
-0.13959142565727234,
-0.39271408319473267,
-0.7317213416099548,
0.6606541275978088,
0.07549843192100525,
0.33181747794151306,
0.5101673603057861,
-0.42043745517730713,
0.7294743061065674,
-0.9571185111999512,
0.8163158893585205,
0.21579596400260925,
-1.0514988899230957,
0.8559715747833252,
-0.18180640041828156,
0.6933010816574097,
0.3887762427330017,
0.384825199842453,
-0.5124214291572571,
-0.3452208638191223,
-0.23511673510074615,
-0.9869404435157776,
0.673000156879425,
0.19693732261657715,
-0.22296540439128876,
0.15190644562244415,
0.21678979694843292,
0.17255114018917084,
0.22336602210998535,
-0.5300884246826172,
-0.1702798306941986,
-0.1762864738702774,
-0.26664888858795166,
-0.2741728127002716,
-0.26731061935424805,
0.021770792081952095,
-0.31210166215896606,
0.339046835899353,
-0.35022294521331787,
0.39948326349258423,
0.37707966566085815,
-0.22619931399822235,
-0.17201484739780426,
0.41762539744377136,
0.5323184132575989,
0.6455823183059692,
-0.1786225289106369,
0.1921430081129074,
-0.1042320653796196,
-0.62135249376297,
-0.020561696961522102,
0.49632030725479126,
-0.2550126016139984,
0.06754064559936523,
0.42696428298950195,
0.7619301676750183,
0.17324458062648773,
-0.49752557277679443,
0.5880383253097534,
0.0383959598839283,
0.02791495807468891,
-0.11932699382305145,
-0.1554783433675766,
0.031153377145528793,
0.5917075872421265,
0.586207926273346,
0.20565341413021088,
0.47268620133399963,
-0.21484823524951935,
0.31334128975868225,
0.24236585199832916,
-0.05405530706048012,
-0.4818555414676666,
0.7909355759620667,
0.12598413228988647,
-0.31731387972831726,
0.46716633439064026,
0.17827656865119934,
-0.40886247158050537,
0.47696226835250854,
0.6525363922119141,
0.8859831690788269,
-0.37256529927253723,
0.10753059387207031,
0.07216067612171173,
0.038580309599637985,
0.17130258679389954,
0.38241565227508545,
-0.5295681357383728,
-0.6927868723869324,
-0.7082239389419556,
-0.8250983953475952,
-0.42586731910705566,
-0.2543875575065613,
-0.8677250742912292,
-0.015126200392842293,
-0.341240257024765,
-0.04380270838737488,
0.5914294123649597,
-0.3424011468887329,
-0.6432487964630127,
0.18945761024951935,
0.4140709936618805,
1.0306180715560913,
-0.7064393162727356,
0.7948939800262451,
0.4866103231906891,
-0.016154427081346512,
-0.21174930036067963,
0.16510745882987976,
-0.5110600590705872,
-0.8567556142807007,
1.0985815525054932,
0.261145681142807,
-0.17975975573062897,
-0.02612941525876522,
-0.4137541651725769,
-0.91303950548172,
0.8548855185508728,
0.08309725672006607,
-1.2148774862289429,
-0.3556068241596222,
0.48942670226097107,
0.5885235071182251,
-0.14021781086921692,
-0.20200590789318085,
0.6733043789863586,
0.48102378845214844,
0.32712405920028687,
-0.9837705492973328,
-0.03217523172497749,
-0.1290266513824463,
0.2383318990468979,
0.4340278208255768,
-0.8028566241264343,
0.42867136001586914,
-0.4016365706920624,
-0.16923248767852783,
-0.2635570764541626,
0.9185301661491394,
-0.041499461978673935,
0.5360316634178162,
0.377118855714798,
0.8066808581352234,
0.3657403588294983,
-0.08282680064439774,
0.6768943071365356,
-0.3194052278995514,
0.4467543661594391,
1.0577515363693237,
-0.7511013746261597,
1.0055464506149292,
0.8006333112716675,
-0.4999600350856781,
0.5474417805671692,
0.09320331364870071,
0.022722378373146057,
0.9101974964141846,
-0.10258682817220688,
-0.44622620940208435,
-0.08492405712604523,
0.28395891189575195,
-0.033135052770376205,
0.49385902285575867,
0.481845498085022,
-0.3281872868537903,
-0.42870667576789856,
0.25727757811546326,
-0.2731204628944397,
-0.051949385553598404,
-0.3003194332122803,
0.6938029527664185,
0.06675666570663452,
-0.7485914826393127,
0.6273866295814514,
-0.0649687722325325,
0.5282970070838928,
-0.5314280986785889,
-0.029978107661008835,
-0.180572971701622,
0.35499176383018494,
-0.26925376057624817,
-1.1643285751342773,
0.678620457649231,
-0.26158589124679565,
-0.3787212371826172,
-0.4382827877998352,
0.8266919851303101,
-0.4706297814846039,
-0.4645654261112213,
0.10313678532838821,
0.3167968988418579,
-0.22741015255451202,
0.22353622317314148,
-0.6265449523925781,
0.04608716443181038,
0.003412282792851329,
-0.43874022364616394,
0.07993612438440323,
0.26901403069496155,
0.06238372251391411,
0.7448318004608154,
0.7744140625,
0.05206216499209404,
-0.018854906782507896,
0.3161325454711914,
1.0167596340179443,
-0.964902937412262,
-0.792256772518158,
-0.8062190413475037,
0.6835598349571228,
-0.04787541553378105,
-0.03795619308948517,
0.657273530960083,
0.8564375042915344,
0.6842528581619263,
-0.126337930560112,
0.7077639698982239,
0.07257215678691864,
0.6052548289299011,
-0.5455944538116455,
0.2058066576719284,
-0.41074591875076294,
0.12320829182863235,
-0.06603164225816727,
-0.6835948824882507,
-0.6084238290786743,
0.6169770359992981,
-0.512418806552887,
-0.26825231313705444,
0.7163550853729248,
0.6577461957931519,
-0.297627329826355,
-0.042066704481840134,
0.4842250943183899,
0.29241782426834106,
0.24900846183300018,
0.9555084705352783,
0.7999117374420166,
-0.19141550362110138,
0.23860111832618713,
-0.2884497046470642,
-0.15532107651233673,
-0.09385210275650024,
-0.7671858072280884,
-1.0298945903778076,
-0.617053210735321,
-0.05071413889527321,
-0.16548843681812286,
0.1599585860967636,
0.48782089352607727,
0.7500059008598328,
-0.5721244215965271,
-0.2065766155719757,
-0.006816052366048098,
0.10724005848169327,
-0.08940546214580536,
-0.3417172431945801,
0.4943360686302185,
-0.38950157165527344,
-0.6023504137992859,
0.584486722946167,
0.8724364638328552,
-0.018304623663425446,
-0.27575820684432983,
0.3273647725582123,
-0.059291474521160126,
-0.04186265543103218,
1.080782175064087,
0.23024871945381165,
-0.4103805720806122,
-0.23900043964385986,
-0.225186288356781,
0.08313827961683273,
0.40934810042381287,
0.9242072701454163,
-0.926137387752533,
0.23924238979816437,
0.5408803820610046,
0.5412762761116028,
0.8596339225769043,
0.07951431721448898,
0.3796391487121582,
-0.8396471738815308,
0.5231927633285522,
0.4992809295654297,
0.46319377422332764,
0.4604822099208832,
-0.605083703994751,
0.43986159563064575,
0.29416680335998535,
-0.6696740984916687,
-0.8898811936378479,
0.4936525821685791,
-1.3250865936279297,
-0.2268509566783905,
1.0258572101593018,
-0.007647845894098282,
-0.397500216960907,
0.008686849847435951,
-0.1326451599597931,
-0.11967434734106064,
-0.357979416847229,
0.5231377482414246,
0.2735871970653534,
-0.23728090524673462,
-0.42312490940093994,
-0.2662540376186371,
0.4443929195404053,
0.49375981092453003,
-0.8600443601608276,
0.35837870836257935,
0.5566304922103882,
0.14353151619434357,
0.30751362442970276,
0.4948452413082123,
-0.08573810011148453,
0.4418499767780304,
-0.18255069851875305,
-0.2649875283241272,
0.25011956691741943,
-0.7229405045509338,
-0.5566199421882629,
0.4476583003997803,
-0.2134302258491516,
-0.15479089319705963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05188v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05188v1
|
Have You Merged My Model? On The Robustness of Large Language Model IP Protection Methods Against Model Merging
| 2024-04-08T04:30:33 | 2024-04-08T04:30:33 |
Tianshuo Cong, Delong Ran, Zesen Liu, Xinlei He, Jinyuan Liu, Yichen Gong, Qi Li, Anyu Wang, Xiaoyun Wang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Model merging is a promising lightweight model empowerment technique that
does not rely on expensive computing devices (e.g., GPUs) or require the
collection of specific training data. Instead, it involves editing different
upstream model parameters to absorb their downstream task capabilities.
However, uncertified model merging can infringe upon the Intellectual Property
(IP) rights of the original upstream models. In this paper, we conduct the
first study on the robustness of IP protection methods in model merging
scenarios. We investigate two state-of-the-art IP protection techniques:
Quantization Watermarking and Instructional Fingerprint, along with various
advanced model merging technologies, such as Task Arithmetic, TIES-MERGING, and
so on. Experimental results indicate that current Large Language Model (LLM)
watermarking techniques cannot survive in the merged models, whereas model
fingerprinting techniques can. Our research aims to highlight that model
merging should be an indispensable consideration in the robustness assessment
of model IP protection techniques, thereby promoting the healthy development of
the open-source LLM community.
|
[
-0.6414093375205994,
-0.6085748672485352,
0.2921103537082672,
-0.16261599957942963,
-0.546325147151947,
0.23694519698619843,
0.06694699078798294,
-0.8717588782310486,
-0.24820415675640106,
0.8746634721755981,
-0.012955844402313232,
-0.06954285502433777,
-0.7657588720321655,
-0.30363547801971436,
-0.6882919073104858,
1.0563185214996338,
0.083966463804245,
0.14362090826034546,
-0.3338019549846649,
-0.2033492475748062,
-0.3387487232685089,
-0.8096873760223389,
-0.5409303307533264,
-0.10688280314207077,
0.08075105398893356,
-0.13440623879432678,
0.49415716528892517,
0.5603448152542114,
0.7169802784919739,
0.39290010929107666,
-0.4746800363063812,
-0.003200474428012967,
-0.17865081131458282,
0.27911320328712463,
-0.2242857962846756,
-0.45973777770996094,
-0.5836372971534729,
0.08989407122135162,
0.5722272992134094,
0.7229493260383606,
0.06067279726266861,
0.23687811195850372,
0.47259578108787537,
0.4832835793495178,
-1.005988597869873,
-0.2170465737581253,
-0.6101765036582947,
0.0521690770983696,
-0.379292368888855,
0.22684597969055176,
-0.445030152797699,
-0.23441044986248016,
-0.10461772233247757,
0.17885002493858337,
-0.10619204491376877,
-0.028043894097208977,
0.9113670587539673,
0.24107222259044647,
-0.6509026288986206,
0.23395484685897827,
-1.0938200950622559,
0.8313248157501221,
-1.2321404218673706,
0.05259019508957863,
0.29864320158958435,
0.5192933678627014,
0.10689514130353928,
-0.6784839630126953,
-0.8017815351486206,
-0.030985120683908463,
0.1661272943019867,
-0.08141636103391647,
-0.7395040392875671,
0.01633012294769287,
0.4480484426021576,
0.4830535054206848,
-0.3001934885978699,
0.5182260274887085,
-0.5778740048408508,
-0.21299734711647034,
0.6052893996238708,
-0.14023932814598083,
0.5099717378616333,
0.21542514860630035,
-0.6859175562858582,
-0.21848993003368378,
-0.8696267604827881,
0.18114598095417023,
0.7913939356803894,
0.3317870497703552,
-0.20760297775268555,
0.8758624792098999,
-0.04529368132352829,
0.7550762295722961,
-0.06290195137262344,
-0.18173156678676605,
-0.29665902256965637,
-0.4227612614631653,
-0.3096347153186798,
-0.08539914339780807,
0.9519799947738647,
0.3390375077724457,
0.32595762610435486,
-0.13651399314403534,
-0.2903229296207428,
-0.2748589813709259,
0.24898289144039154,
-0.6542158126831055,
0.07531575858592987,
0.3525558412075043,
-0.6490094065666199,
-0.503434419631958,
-0.08292781561613083,
-0.5106129050254822,
-0.34198611974716187,
-0.1401567906141281,
0.3270435631275177,
-0.2411632239818573,
-0.6513296365737915,
0.04909491911530495,
0.031947117298841476,
0.4490620195865631,
0.2803538739681244,
-0.7866129279136658,
0.35056930780410767,
1.1565613746643066,
0.8937661051750183,
-0.10526701807975769,
-0.19581785798072815,
-0.5673234462738037,
0.14708028733730316,
-0.17453701794147491,
0.6737681031227112,
-0.15246640145778656,
-0.444052129983902,
0.08488436043262482,
-0.3216530978679657,
-0.11625294387340546,
-0.597213864326477,
0.20004211366176605,
-0.9323971271514893,
0.38940346240997314,
0.07946829497814178,
-0.7008169889450073,
-0.17937615513801575,
0.24619296193122864,
-0.9345664978027344,
0.510126531124115,
-0.09158191829919815,
-1.107326865196228,
0.1323092132806778,
-0.3157501816749573,
-0.2569032907485962,
0.23849241435527802,
0.15063373744487762,
-0.5652396082878113,
-0.010546366684138775,
-0.0713038370013237,
0.41933122277259827,
-0.3268466591835022,
0.27907484769821167,
-0.7314865589141846,
-0.12676861882209778,
0.43482086062431335,
-0.6042520403862,
1.1689391136169434,
0.25629058480262756,
-0.2753274738788605,
0.023312795907258987,
-0.5346869826316833,
0.25533780455589294,
-0.2544897496700287,
-0.18999025225639343,
-0.45238083600997925,
-0.1754888892173767,
-0.0018224159721285105,
0.23153819143772125,
0.4764610230922699,
-0.3445441424846649,
0.42352548241615295,
0.024245131760835648,
0.5679233074188232,
0.5725314021110535,
0.004626967012882233,
0.5451251864433289,
-0.4111425280570984,
0.6155001521110535,
-0.009912127628922462,
-0.01685013435781002,
-0.10847113281488419,
-0.7357102036476135,
-0.5377475619316101,
-0.3635152578353882,
0.8705395460128784,
0.6042773127555847,
-0.4813412129878998,
0.6574083566665649,
-0.4849824607372284,
-0.6091556549072266,
-0.3115047514438629,
0.18938422203063965,
0.5940898656845093,
0.31011971831321716,
0.2222377210855484,
-0.48827046155929565,
-0.23833999037742615,
-0.8687970638275146,
-0.22926978766918182,
-0.5220007300376892,
-0.26028743386268616,
0.08462531119585037,
0.484732061624527,
0.059656303375959396,
0.8144152164459229,
-0.11088407784700394,
-0.05542897805571556,
-0.3019949793815613,
0.19646264612674713,
-0.08446192741394043,
0.8657643795013428,
0.6079750061035156,
-0.9269421100616455,
-0.47923529148101807,
0.2288755476474762,
-0.7165511846542358,
-0.07487011700868607,
0.08179938793182373,
-0.020930027589201927,
0.10095884650945663,
0.5347601771354675,
-0.6502769589424133,
0.29040583968162537,
0.8335067629814148,
-0.27441003918647766,
0.6230917572975159,
-0.05356865003705025,
0.2535167336463928,
-1.2930694818496704,
-0.015919188037514687,
-0.03951748088002205,
-0.21792402863502502,
-0.7258978486061096,
0.6230884194374084,
0.08362571895122528,
-0.41553834080696106,
-0.6273927092552185,
0.5388008952140808,
-0.31540602445602417,
0.19000467658042908,
-0.5047309994697571,
-0.43320539593696594,
-0.23953387141227722,
-0.01031982060521841,
-0.394638329744339,
0.6083226799964905,
0.7367185354232788,
-0.4256877303123474,
0.20765992999076843,
-0.055227335542440414,
-0.37077170610427856,
0.6834500432014465,
-0.6157122850418091,
0.2817245125770569,
0.14084406197071075,
-0.16617809236049652,
-1.031144618988037,
-0.08089268952608109,
0.16973116993904114,
-0.12017162144184113,
0.6733095049858093,
-0.616363525390625,
-0.44500666856765747,
-0.16713061928749084,
-0.277452290058136,
0.38138940930366516,
0.6393477916717529,
-0.7227439284324646,
0.6983383297920227,
0.20403258502483368,
-0.33100032806396484,
-0.6371720433235168,
-0.7830190062522888,
0.20607246458530426,
-0.5524539351463318,
-1.0107500553131104,
0.5180119872093201,
-0.005780785344541073,
-0.3055998384952545,
0.3642033636569977,
0.008935085497796535,
-0.5673481822013855,
0.1400451511144638,
0.26970168948173523,
0.385460764169693,
-0.2903781831264496,
-0.5233181118965149,
0.2075435072183609,
-0.0662141814827919,
-0.24625355005264282,
0.053817372769117355,
0.42313113808631897,
0.14778365194797516,
-0.592535674571991,
-0.5897356271743774,
0.5144944190979004,
0.9356382489204407,
-0.5858674645423889,
0.7673865556716919,
0.29598119854927063,
-0.554597020149231,
0.04749467596411705,
-0.7129183411598206,
-0.07442009449005127,
-0.4565727412700653,
0.09331219643354416,
-0.09306328743696213,
-1.2406409978866577,
0.5910540223121643,
-0.1279839724302292,
0.12350855022668839,
0.10321477055549622,
0.1362399160861969,
-0.14756108820438385,
1.0038434267044067,
0.976962149143219,
-0.5843399167060852,
0.4190834164619446,
-0.12078715860843658,
0.5396303534507751,
-0.8785358667373657,
0.06845385581254959,
-0.5512322187423706,
-0.3493776023387909,
-0.656035304069519,
-0.1586907058954239,
0.002497259760275483,
0.47897499799728394,
-0.20079311728477478,
0.4333218038082123,
-0.2528684139251709,
0.47638243436813354,
0.6322133541107178,
0.09219197928905487,
0.4683108329772949,
0.14104439318180084,
0.18936018645763397,
-0.2100502997636795,
-0.40683457255363464,
-0.6388668417930603,
1.0702017545700073,
0.3450345993041992,
0.5766627192497253,
0.18791842460632324,
0.8829583525657654,
0.25593408942222595,
0.3256222903728485,
-0.4650300443172455,
0.7092347741127014,
-0.2275887429714203,
-0.6179155707359314,
-0.27942973375320435,
-0.4133339822292328,
-0.7914279103279114,
0.48568692803382874,
-0.466467946767807,
-1.0670783519744873,
0.2275436818599701,
0.18951590359210968,
-0.28133437037467957,
0.7678710222244263,
-0.6067711710929871,
0.727762758731842,
-0.314571350812912,
-0.3906904458999634,
-0.09116098284721375,
-0.2964695394039154,
0.864090621471405,
-0.4759674072265625,
0.1063527911901474,
0.0236665029078722,
0.13670925796031952,
0.5934740304946899,
-0.712722659111023,
0.8652915358543396,
-0.046484556049108505,
-0.14967331290245056,
0.22312606871128082,
0.10651759803295135,
0.39672109484672546,
-0.5392825603485107,
0.14316798746585846,
0.38279205560684204,
-0.012361000292003155,
-0.2410626858472824,
-0.499737411737442,
0.5941745638847351,
-0.3476760983467102,
-0.7817045450210571,
-0.33803418278694153,
-0.23602166771888733,
0.03506070375442505,
0.49379485845565796,
0.3392273485660553,
0.2061493992805481,
0.23648080229759216,
0.4159429967403412,
0.3952827453613281,
0.06813791394233704,
0.5291347503662109,
0.5423706769943237,
-0.08053578436374664,
-0.5025114417076111,
0.727000892162323,
0.19091247022151947,
0.4034043550491333,
0.08139508217573166,
0.1637697070837021,
-0.0058387042954564095,
-0.8869647979736328,
-0.13655796647071838,
0.1283682882785797,
-0.5556431412696838,
-0.4139477610588074,
-0.3859710395336151,
-0.49262237548828125,
-0.22256512939929962,
0.07414582371711731,
-0.48271340131759644,
-0.2775534689426422,
0.22324912250041962,
0.07870280742645264,
0.05678920820355415,
0.5414602756500244,
-0.01864449307322502,
0.5329408049583435,
-1.0091215372085571,
0.02085094526410103,
0.5270557999610901,
0.18130725622177124,
0.13599072396755219,
-0.3538769781589508,
-0.17319463193416595,
0.1906379610300064,
-0.38621315360069275,
-0.9454489350318909,
0.34847286343574524,
0.014496090821921825,
0.5119984149932861,
0.5918910503387451,
0.11194682866334915,
0.471801221370697,
-0.4327392280101776,
0.7562739849090576,
0.17604942619800568,
-1.1122428178787231,
0.19785833358764648,
-0.1877371221780777,
0.058619074523448944,
0.3725658655166626,
0.49035894870758057,
-0.04138125851750374,
-0.587309718132019,
-0.5796886682510376,
-0.9921913743019104,
0.20614458620548248,
0.24284911155700684,
0.23601655662059784,
0.5102347135543823,
0.17127475142478943,
-0.32964465022087097,
0.3535124361515045,
-0.9266383051872253,
-0.035205211490392685,
0.2550560534000397,
0.12598620355129242,
0.3306054472923279,
-0.27428802847862244,
-0.4233741760253906,
-0.11882205307483673,
0.44142717123031616,
0.16016364097595215,
-0.14164887368679047,
-0.5731041431427002,
0.10925628989934921,
0.007530053611844778,
0.16714856028556824,
0.10516611486673355,
0.2666204571723938,
0.0017180690774694085,
0.22299805283546448,
-0.0668458491563797,
-0.4580325782299042,
0.17772214114665985,
0.15988928079605103,
-0.40365198254585266,
-0.28235360980033875,
0.7182919383049011,
0.5586822628974915,
0.09730974584817886,
-0.4432808756828308,
0.6388372182846069,
-0.20573510229587555,
-0.15456198155879974,
0.25411149859428406,
0.35813799500465393,
-0.043691474944353104,
0.48778316378593445,
0.2379700243473053,
0.07580897957086563,
0.13133157789707184,
-0.2784159779548645,
-0.045310087502002716,
0.8586457371711731,
-0.04521442577242851,
-0.15885616838932037,
0.8436737060546875,
-0.0229974202811718,
-0.03377164155244827,
0.584246814250946,
0.01160203292965889,
-0.7606776356697083,
0.5554929971694946,
0.5341079831123352,
1.0525877475738525,
-0.4217410683631897,
-0.20217053592205048,
0.2635699212551117,
0.40725627541542053,
-0.33418673276901245,
0.007334122899919748,
-0.28489506244659424,
-0.8359016180038452,
-0.6170369982719421,
-0.25016993284225464,
-0.7265576124191284,
0.25160887837409973,
-0.837199866771698,
0.24311523139476776,
-0.2563454210758209,
-0.43887221813201904,
0.08515927195549011,
-0.24325336515903473,
-0.3303416967391968,
0.09542860090732574,
0.20135095715522766,
0.647207498550415,
-1.0799765586853027,
0.9410985708236694,
0.5796130299568176,
-0.07522884756326675,
-0.8175824880599976,
0.14560134708881378,
-0.10026302188634872,
-0.23796701431274414,
0.5572872757911682,
0.20229928195476532,
0.1354658603668213,
-0.14166775345802307,
-0.7800414562225342,
-0.8745601773262024,
1.0065075159072876,
0.6095418930053711,
-0.42138227820396423,
0.15785615146160126,
0.1790941208600998,
0.4406048655509949,
-0.19772405922412872,
-0.23834653198719025,
0.301632285118103,
0.35247156023979187,
-0.024013541638851166,
-1.0290077924728394,
0.07821299135684967,
-0.4148775339126587,
-0.019300878047943115,
0.1697695404291153,
-0.37680408358573914,
1.0065404176712036,
-0.20113734900951385,
-0.4375511109828949,
0.30304235219955444,
0.44098082184791565,
0.1318214237689972,
0.2170502245426178,
0.7265064120292664,
0.7053317427635193,
0.8001853227615356,
-0.16703054308891296,
1.1525652408599854,
-0.6588660478591919,
0.3910408914089203,
0.9847027063369751,
-0.4626827538013458,
1.1987035274505615,
0.4016316831111908,
-0.2531410753726959,
0.11822941899299622,
0.27572202682495117,
-0.14443939924240112,
0.4760774075984955,
-0.1647101193666458,
-0.4898962080478668,
-0.25851067900657654,
0.061939481645822525,
-0.6543842554092407,
0.5486424565315247,
-0.10683829337358475,
-0.12194149941205978,
-0.17027519643306732,
0.026420172303915024,
0.06318025290966034,
0.046509213745594025,
-0.04494592174887657,
0.8172305822372437,
-0.029545152559876442,
-0.4983188807964325,
0.4423806369304657,
-0.020558655261993408,
0.8421995639801025,
-0.6669971346855164,
0.052943456918001175,
-0.16505067050457,
0.09198424220085144,
-0.17388391494750977,
-0.7352109551429749,
0.2143842875957489,
0.1677418053150177,
-0.004118188284337521,
-0.15985450148582458,
0.8153771162033081,
-0.558632493019104,
-0.24187947809696198,
0.2549991309642792,
0.45167630910873413,
0.002719837473705411,
-0.13411547243595123,
-0.4407988488674164,
0.24991978704929352,
-0.1256425976753235,
0.19249385595321655,
0.6035664677619934,
0.027181366458535194,
-0.1515883505344391,
0.7667775750160217,
0.8115478157997131,
0.36021146178245544,
0.15227805078029633,
-0.24733424186706543,
0.8225166201591492,
-0.37271609902381897,
-0.42047789692878723,
-1.0114600658416748,
0.6752155423164368,
-0.22638878226280212,
0.044831983745098114,
0.9589330554008484,
0.5027783513069153,
1.0099372863769531,
-0.17238695919513702,
1.007917881011963,
0.09884835034608841,
0.1328245997428894,
-0.6151059865951538,
1.1214576959609985,
-0.4924424886703491,
0.34096112847328186,
-0.18271134793758392,
-1.1011632680892944,
-0.16331250965595245,
0.21502038836479187,
-0.10178487747907639,
0.08406607061624527,
0.26653236150741577,
0.5763891935348511,
-0.1946083903312683,
-0.24720598757266998,
0.42223644256591797,
-0.15330034494400024,
0.4961404502391815,
0.3372810184955597,
0.7463668584823608,
-0.33803656697273254,
0.2369987964630127,
-0.6764647364616394,
-0.2412305772304535,
-0.05262908712029457,
-1.1535379886627197,
-0.79015052318573,
-0.534436047077179,
-0.7272191643714905,
-0.4795342683792114,
-0.011482524685561657,
0.4108407199382782,
0.8034967184066772,
-0.8227116465568542,
-0.22237549722194672,
0.14579015970230103,
0.19663558900356293,
-0.18786774575710297,
-0.12629416584968567,
0.17937125265598297,
0.08049478381872177,
-1.075316071510315,
0.2067815661430359,
0.2550990581512451,
0.5995056629180908,
-0.33153995871543884,
0.17442719638347626,
-0.03747529536485672,
0.0021416821982711554,
0.31163161993026733,
0.677535891532898,
-0.4126581847667694,
-0.008809491991996765,
-0.3478643298149109,
-0.2576565444469452,
-0.259302020072937,
0.7578073143959045,
-0.2757539749145508,
0.7734062075614929,
0.6356796026229858,
0.8074809312820435,
0.06956981867551804,
0.17013706266880035,
0.7702592611312866,
-0.5398687124252319,
0.29175999760627747,
0.061859216541051865,
0.7206894755363464,
0.5182463526725769,
-0.1919889748096466,
0.3845331370830536,
-0.080540232360363,
-0.33308249711990356,
-1.3269622325897217,
0.30125856399536133,
-0.9327821731567383,
0.004468167666345835,
0.8938611149787903,
-0.35234835743904114,
-0.019060054793953896,
0.2834389805793762,
-0.08264446258544922,
0.21050505340099335,
0.2688545882701874,
0.7666873335838318,
0.7505664825439453,
0.1578255444765091,
-0.022554099559783936,
-0.4616599678993225,
0.12989553809165955,
0.18371833860874176,
-0.7928749322891235,
-0.1786338984966278,
0.05120992287993431,
0.177272230386734,
0.2656955420970917,
0.03810390457510948,
-0.23547181487083435,
0.28031715750694275,
-0.04581806808710098,
0.1373184472322464,
-0.2602446973323822,
-0.09184613823890686,
-0.7116289734840393,
0.1294383406639099,
0.40356090664863586,
-0.3288826048374176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05182v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05182v1
|
DLoRA: Distributed Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning Solution for Large Language Model
| 2024-04-08T04:14:02 | 2024-04-08T04:14:02 |
Chao Gao, Sai Qian Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DC
|
To enhance the performance of large language models (LLM) on downstream
tasks, one solution is to fine-tune certain LLM parameters and make it better
align with the characteristics of the training dataset. This process is
commonly known as parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT). Due to the scale of
LLM, PEFT operations are usually executed in the public environment (e.g.,
cloud server). This necessitates the sharing of sensitive user data across
public environments, thereby raising potential privacy concerns. To tackle
these challenges, we propose a distributed PEFT framework called DLoRA. DLoRA
enables scalable PEFT operations to be performed collaboratively between the
cloud and user devices. Coupled with the proposed Kill and Revive algorithm,
the evaluation results demonstrate that DLoRA can significantly reduce the
computation and communication workload over the user devices while achieving
superior accuracy and privacy protection.
|
[
-0.5483564734458923,
-1.1194278001785278,
0.6731047034263611,
0.22186653316020966,
-0.12827765941619873,
0.12549085915088654,
-0.39763760566711426,
-0.4754275679588318,
0.12569169700145721,
0.6960821151733398,
-0.6827032566070557,
-0.637340247631073,
-0.3733243942260742,
0.05891643464565277,
-0.7185339331626892,
0.8977189660072327,
0.05736714228987694,
-0.310859739780426,
-0.06187991797924042,
-0.07278599590063095,
-0.07442178577184677,
-0.2998998761177063,
-1.003526210784912,
0.030400069430470467,
0.6207485198974609,
0.554545521736145,
0.9889784455299377,
0.8149203062057495,
0.6485756039619446,
0.41441452503204346,
-0.2648087739944458,
0.5230745077133179,
-0.7726976871490479,
0.5933797955513,
-0.0797516331076622,
-0.36290308833122253,
-0.7966223955154419,
-0.31380605697631836,
0.7624775171279907,
0.9120803475379944,
-0.17142850160598755,
0.16235627233982086,
-0.05671672523021698,
0.7287778854370117,
-0.7746402621269226,
-0.14665035903453827,
-0.40168213844299316,
-0.2786880135536194,
-0.30694520473480225,
0.05925915390253067,
-0.24850301444530487,
-0.5316404104232788,
0.040435612201690674,
-0.6764292120933533,
0.10748455673456192,
0.01729179546236992,
0.798833966255188,
0.4472247064113617,
0.0014927805168554187,
0.1152094155550003,
-0.8383554220199585,
0.8180696964263916,
-0.5615010857582092,
0.4355056583881378,
0.4280642867088318,
0.13455811142921448,
-0.26065894961357117,
-0.6733477711677551,
-0.4858696162700653,
0.107834093272686,
0.0005698917666450143,
-0.17822527885437012,
-0.06913714855909348,
0.14771975576877594,
0.07713361084461212,
0.4495285153388977,
-0.3949282765388489,
0.43031901121139526,
-0.07963477075099945,
0.022439859807491302,
0.6361729502677917,
0.2512224316596985,
0.24138718843460083,
0.42176586389541626,
-0.20932090282440186,
-0.023763107135891914,
-0.8128703236579895,
-0.339092880487442,
0.47621604800224304,
0.4524547755718231,
-0.08760924637317657,
0.15086369216442108,
-0.6513819694519043,
0.7141991853713989,
0.23878617584705353,
-0.14813055098056793,
0.27679315209388733,
-0.20825952291488647,
-0.44882580637931824,
-0.10030758380889893,
0.6001793146133423,
0.2722843885421753,
0.007188416086137295,
-0.19675329327583313,
-0.27252358198165894,
-0.29504284262657166,
-0.16556359827518463,
-0.8949387073516846,
-0.1500381976366043,
0.40657755732536316,
-0.35807159543037415,
-0.23631244897842407,
-0.26895323395729065,
-1.1486430168151855,
-0.6067377328872681,
-0.4195367097854614,
0.2298378050327301,
-0.11861598491668701,
-0.45582643151283264,
0.2284926176071167,
0.27795249223709106,
-0.03854014724493027,
0.6602204442024231,
-1.1457949876785278,
0.6061360239982605,
0.9964826703071594,
0.7381671667098999,
-0.33941030502319336,
-0.4455970525741577,
-0.8922824859619141,
0.23277924954891205,
-0.10010021179914474,
0.4386448860168457,
-0.4242885410785675,
-0.1720830500125885,
0.03092551790177822,
-0.045192498713731766,
-0.04951589182019234,
-0.5608874559402466,
0.37657177448272705,
-0.797481894493103,
0.04196437820792198,
-0.32343900203704834,
-0.6783736944198608,
-0.053436048328876495,
0.18893855810165405,
-0.70658278465271,
0.7928315997123718,
-0.07854519784450531,
-0.7090244293212891,
0.3192588984966278,
-0.579585075378418,
-0.2506670653820038,
0.28281503915786743,
-0.018266018480062485,
-0.6701733469963074,
-0.08165034651756287,
0.4091973602771759,
0.6067105531692505,
-0.43508124351501465,
0.2628559470176697,
-0.5840353965759277,
-0.5619824528694153,
-0.26505303382873535,
-0.25875306129455566,
0.8257965445518494,
0.25397107005119324,
-0.5639858841896057,
0.316845178604126,
-0.6634055972099304,
0.04405782371759415,
-0.028762374073266983,
-0.2972467541694641,
-0.5407647490501404,
-0.047132182866334915,
0.3782082796096802,
-0.3847953975200653,
0.6959715485572815,
-0.580799400806427,
0.23068846762180328,
-0.568318784236908,
0.3886204659938812,
0.7693084478378296,
-0.15759634971618652,
0.5158571004867554,
-0.30737540125846863,
0.3057703971862793,
-0.31504666805267334,
0.519010603427887,
0.09898433089256287,
-0.2987927198410034,
-0.6339553594589233,
-0.9460926055908203,
0.16724684834480286,
0.2689719498157501,
-0.03501959145069122,
0.42725107073783875,
-0.1438419669866562,
-0.6723029613494873,
-0.535065770149231,
0.4678516685962677,
0.31367602944374084,
0.3062732517719269,
0.08524125814437866,
0.34139707684516907,
-0.4291568696498871,
-1.0807856321334839,
0.2253059297800064,
0.04428938776254654,
-0.015518944710493088,
0.332349956035614,
0.29193252325057983,
-0.6036246418952942,
0.8932718634605408,
-0.5354571342468262,
-0.3136228919029236,
0.0006321794935502112,
0.03603723645210266,
0.20508968830108643,
0.31383755803108215,
0.6235253214836121,
-0.9582490921020508,
-0.6308557987213135,
0.23674701154232025,
-0.42286476492881775,
-0.4328005611896515,
0.11552973836660385,
-0.1772172898054123,
0.3951905071735382,
0.341388076543808,
-0.36880677938461304,
-0.09651605784893036,
0.9507085680961609,
-0.27564963698387146,
0.2025027573108673,
-0.5300044417381287,
0.4278077483177185,
-1.0640559196472168,
0.10453219711780548,
-0.5168581008911133,
-0.6062468886375427,
-0.3743393123149872,
0.4494960606098175,
0.06027683615684509,
-0.13530002534389496,
-0.4638867676258087,
0.39062583446502686,
-0.2031913846731186,
-0.04671551659703255,
-0.3607572615146637,
0.1190730556845665,
-0.17864945530891418,
0.21383218467235565,
0.024944892153143883,
1.0658777952194214,
0.8226374387741089,
-0.5132434964179993,
0.4431728720664978,
0.04636041447520256,
0.012920514680445194,
0.6991305947303772,
-0.7467599511146545,
0.1726791113615036,
0.06285775452852249,
-0.2527490556240082,
-0.7052175998687744,
-0.40706464648246765,
-0.03393058106303215,
0.13253360986709595,
-0.15239721536636353,
0.15705496072769165,
-0.8773894906044006,
0.12940733134746552,
-0.32296326756477356,
0.33723610639572144,
0.4936610460281372,
-0.831695020198822,
0.37895113229751587,
0.5996364951133728,
-0.03576795011758804,
-0.23945020139217377,
-0.2017868161201477,
0.0389244519174099,
-0.5189183354377747,
-0.8491636514663696,
0.612433135509491,
-0.33520668745040894,
-0.4899289608001709,
-0.15138724446296692,
0.2689855694770813,
-0.29428771138191223,
0.328233003616333,
0.4362736642360687,
-0.1577099859714508,
0.00858221109956503,
0.09421844780445099,
0.22930754721164703,
-0.014520274475216866,
-0.2856203019618988,
0.08287151157855988,
0.6442020535469055,
-0.43368202447891235,
-0.3876705467700958,
-0.6811879277229309,
0.5690312385559082,
0.9189081192016602,
-0.2930416762828827,
0.9321747422218323,
0.493725448846817,
-0.4442196488380432,
-0.37877511978149414,
-0.594125509262085,
-0.11846476793289185,
-0.5726392865180969,
0.24336105585098267,
-0.19372808933258057,
-1.0556178092956543,
0.7470816373825073,
-0.43861454725265503,
0.06241780146956444,
0.150573268532753,
0.79522705078125,
-0.12705479562282562,
0.8738669753074646,
1.0525530576705933,
-0.4297448396682739,
0.5801116228103638,
-0.0774296373128891,
-0.08145292103290558,
-0.2963108718395233,
0.06644235551357269,
-0.44073840975761414,
-0.25211936235427856,
-0.42885348200798035,
-0.04261988401412964,
0.4745995104312897,
0.21973752975463867,
-0.5215031504631042,
0.5017633438110352,
-0.5012332201004028,
0.5493300557136536,
0.7144829630851746,
0.3090868890285492,
0.5123541355133057,
-0.01776907406747341,
0.12060583382844925,
0.0801476389169693,
-0.14977355301380157,
-0.26182740926742554,
0.756622850894928,
0.28859421610832214,
0.8096603155136108,
0.20656639337539673,
1.1522531509399414,
0.35304370522499084,
-0.09503364562988281,
-0.4727383255958557,
0.5985810160636902,
-0.16092082858085632,
-0.4743695557117462,
-0.5951035022735596,
-0.3758942186832428,
-0.8870000243186951,
-0.1907818466424942,
0.04290665686130524,
-0.8526721000671387,
0.058967724442481995,
-0.02016015537083149,
-0.39876464009284973,
0.24458205699920654,
-0.6015032529830933,
0.6487500071525574,
-0.003054126398637891,
-0.6000723242759705,
-0.6401708722114563,
-0.22944897413253784,
0.10367050766944885,
-0.5714408755302429,
0.15177521109580994,
-0.084495909512043,
-0.18054260313510895,
0.7875971794128418,
-0.7101771831512451,
0.8519735336303711,
-0.3048945963382721,
-0.1899999976158142,
-0.11591855436563492,
0.046317826956510544,
0.615595281124115,
0.4076814353466034,
-0.3717935383319855,
0.08881858736276627,
0.14743615686893463,
-0.25967225432395935,
-0.4893316924571991,
1.0884666442871094,
-0.9720397591590881,
-0.5374223589897156,
-0.12660323083400726,
-0.5810715556144714,
-0.10251951962709427,
0.2826696038246155,
-0.14020198583602905,
-0.07067439705133438,
0.02475343644618988,
0.39574435353279114,
0.8782141208648682,
-0.21391671895980835,
0.5395632982254028,
0.7897705435752869,
-0.17072175443172455,
-0.40555423498153687,
0.450038880109787,
-0.11891848593950272,
0.2471708059310913,
0.4572746455669403,
0.07091087102890015,
-0.03512737154960632,
-0.5472297072410583,
-0.30038848519325256,
0.2237463742494583,
-0.5021886825561523,
-0.232956200838089,
-0.4579199552536011,
0.012002251110970974,
0.14139188826084137,
-0.44617465138435364,
-0.8457280993461609,
0.008180209435522556,
-0.3269777297973633,
0.07887780666351318,
0.9031480550765991,
0.5867356061935425,
-0.07042796909809113,
0.6465724110603333,
-0.619955837726593,
0.1418403536081314,
0.30414190888404846,
0.634844958782196,
-0.20035579800605774,
-0.19320102035999298,
-0.22294867038726807,
0.15429337322711945,
-0.0430697463452816,
-0.556354820728302,
0.3033128082752228,
0.38914042711257935,
0.46984046697616577,
0.2667619585990906,
0.19063115119934082,
0.8591976165771484,
-0.303561806678772,
0.4576253294944763,
-0.1726987212896347,
-1.1740590333938599,
0.6639841794967651,
-0.5709210634231567,
0.13748547434806824,
0.7062157392501831,
0.07443585991859436,
-0.35847917199134827,
-0.5044652819633484,
-0.17195634543895721,
-0.8903560638427734,
0.5521254539489746,
0.12769897282123566,
0.26941412687301636,
0.26410919427871704,
0.3142234683036804,
0.28952234983444214,
-0.024961357936263084,
-0.2153167575597763,
-0.3404007852077484,
0.4324536621570587,
-0.21542833745479584,
0.17838850617408752,
-0.16745813190937042,
-0.2726173400878906,
-0.29934918880462646,
0.5340514183044434,
0.03979431092739105,
-0.014510540291666985,
-0.015265239402651787,
0.146157905459404,
-0.38031554222106934,
0.11411499977111816,
0.4411858916282654,
0.6722845435142517,
-0.34381335973739624,
-0.1269814819097519,
0.17902596294879913,
-0.39228320121765137,
0.09377847611904144,
0.29696911573410034,
-0.5298136472702026,
-0.25001659989356995,
0.1953570693731308,
0.3622335195541382,
0.10804048180580139,
-0.898962676525116,
0.42769330739974976,
-0.2422315776348114,
-0.2982252538204193,
-0.28992199897766113,
0.1671275943517685,
0.3029232323169708,
0.5407513380050659,
0.28276392817497253,
-0.04050784558057785,
0.11857365071773529,
-0.2055375874042511,
0.515269935131073,
0.25086984038352966,
0.0016347868368029594,
-0.17481161653995514,
0.8796842098236084,
0.3332297205924988,
-0.36302077770233154,
0.649546205997467,
0.015104558318853378,
-0.2256830334663391,
0.4606102705001831,
0.4327285587787628,
0.7347001433372498,
-0.06872382760047913,
0.23588323593139648,
0.032929860055446625,
-0.01674647442996502,
-0.1618146449327469,
0.44160255789756775,
-0.044685959815979004,
-0.4811113476753235,
-0.4671529531478882,
-0.8983701467514038,
-0.5781742930412292,
0.2315283566713333,
-0.4298771917819977,
0.22237703204154968,
-0.6313245296478271,
0.021215440705418587,
-0.05562340095639229,
0.06132686138153076,
-0.569581925868988,
-0.03543040156364441,
0.1725129336118698,
0.7402429580688477,
-0.7188034057617188,
1.182390809059143,
0.5457607507705688,
-0.2744368314743042,
-0.7028587460517883,
0.06681375950574875,
-0.1266493797302246,
-0.6300110816955566,
0.8561640977859497,
-0.1095067486166954,
-0.22888389229774475,
-0.0011425470001995564,
-0.19908760488033295,
-1.0451840162277222,
1.0339725017547607,
0.7515482902526855,
-0.9871094822883606,
0.40810588002204895,
0.28313636779785156,
0.757758378982544,
-0.01499120146036148,
-0.08749362081289291,
0.4124980866909027,
0.55440354347229,
-0.14112509787082672,
-1.2893608808517456,
0.08640445023775101,
0.08049707859754562,
-0.23329676687717438,
0.3411094844341278,
-0.6323156356811523,
0.8257468342781067,
0.05588507279753685,
0.016613535583019257,
0.14592763781547546,
0.4798189699649811,
0.14689229428768158,
0.12206597626209259,
0.6287789344787598,
0.5213453769683838,
1.1111186742782593,
0.1688423603773117,
0.6883872151374817,
-0.5034831762313843,
0.6118310689926147,
0.8634950518608093,
-0.43994322419166565,
1.0322706699371338,
0.4356725215911865,
-0.20507167279720306,
0.010104970075190067,
0.6493822932243347,
0.12306582182645798,
0.8109451532363892,
-0.0329485721886158,
-0.5518357753753662,
-0.28668737411499023,
-0.1110842227935791,
-0.28707098960876465,
0.396732360124588,
0.19518010318279266,
-0.45024344325065613,
-0.3999520242214203,
0.21282759308815002,
0.14671462774276733,
0.4039548635482788,
-0.4350198209285736,
0.7379236817359924,
-0.20291556417942047,
-0.33767765760421753,
0.802977442741394,
0.19207064807415009,
0.7510033845901489,
-0.4264589250087738,
0.15593372285366058,
-0.3409980237483978,
0.5728151798248291,
-0.27026522159576416,
-0.5478855967521667,
0.6263381838798523,
-0.04907665029168129,
-0.3231728672981262,
-0.37696900963783264,
0.37312570214271545,
-0.30119097232818604,
-0.3173064589500427,
0.7238408327102661,
0.33417677879333496,
0.03269732743501663,
-0.25458455085754395,
-0.6202081441879272,
0.4168051779270172,
-0.22068405151367188,
-0.3908759653568268,
0.4823022186756134,
0.11981760710477829,
0.05219946801662445,
0.7508934140205383,
0.5050235390663147,
0.18207459151744843,
-0.15355157852172852,
0.2285700887441635,
1.0618352890014648,
-0.1369311362504959,
-0.36293816566467285,
-1.0801351070404053,
0.1483755260705948,
-0.16284048557281494,
-0.23880447447299957,
0.7475578784942627,
0.5383309125900269,
0.8665984272956848,
-0.10066776722669601,
0.5430344343185425,
-0.12899602949619293,
0.615976095199585,
-0.23176565766334534,
0.9381482005119324,
-0.6050028800964355,
0.35783475637435913,
-0.244475319981575,
-0.8733922243118286,
-0.5787885785102844,
0.29875272512435913,
-0.35146617889404297,
-0.16619670391082764,
0.40002915263175964,
1.1489830017089844,
-0.23569394648075104,
-0.01971038058400154,
0.5066193342208862,
0.0024637356400489807,
0.2853584289550781,
0.4544353783130646,
0.2114250808954239,
-0.27584946155548096,
0.38141605257987976,
-0.47239255905151367,
-0.4035431444644928,
-0.1627252697944641,
-0.7001137733459473,
-0.892702043056488,
-0.5859205722808838,
-0.2910296320915222,
0.18828819692134857,
0.4643162786960602,
0.9104077219963074,
1.0366204977035522,
-0.9145781993865967,
-0.10802595317363739,
-0.43087348341941833,
0.022491686046123505,
-0.3629835546016693,
-0.16704928874969482,
0.6966367959976196,
-0.14124855399131775,
-1.1298953294754028,
0.4227994382381439,
0.3216516375541687,
-0.38621261715888977,
-0.40634799003601074,
-0.17971810698509216,
0.06182345375418663,
-0.23495785892009735,
0.3183617889881134,
0.028811536729335785,
-0.7123273611068726,
-0.2701019048690796,
-0.03662031516432762,
-0.2608726918697357,
-0.2342854142189026,
0.3024345934391022,
-0.6491239666938782,
0.2667728066444397,
0.6071333885192871,
1.0336177349090576,
0.30538228154182434,
0.09654871374368668,
0.7380825281143188,
-0.7359927892684937,
0.059974487870931625,
0.060689859092235565,
0.3790646493434906,
0.17838478088378906,
-0.6747317314147949,
0.22248440980911255,
0.0644126757979393,
-0.9032306671142578,
-0.7639397382736206,
0.17116929590702057,
-1.0109838247299194,
-0.3107432723045349,
0.9550026655197144,
-0.3171105682849884,
-0.19853658974170685,
0.05744460970163345,
-0.3650429844856262,
0.025825053453445435,
-0.5615679025650024,
0.8428265452384949,
0.3275592625141144,
0.169952854514122,
-0.38524070382118225,
-0.27160292863845825,
0.6345702409744263,
0.40016305446624756,
-0.9584518074989319,
0.4447243809700012,
0.27134576439857483,
0.29993805289268494,
-0.03349442034959793,
0.6217442750930786,
0.1082412526011467,
0.11897224187850952,
-0.20812903344631195,
-0.16960757970809937,
-0.3076034188270569,
-0.35159850120544434,
-0.07701504975557327,
0.3704853355884552,
0.15278297662734985,
-0.35888829827308655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05160v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05160v1
|
Linguistic Changes in Spontaneous Speech for Detecting Parkinsons Disease Using Large Language Models
| 2024-04-08T03:00:10 | 2024-04-08T03:00:10 |
Jonathan Crawford
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Parkinsons disease is the second most prevalent neurodegenerative disorder
with over ten million active cases worldwide and one million new diagnoses per
year. Detecting and subsequently diagnosing the disease is challenging because
of symptom heterogeneity with respect to complexity, as well as the type and
timing of phenotypic manifestations. Typically, language impairment can present
in the prodromal phase and precede motor symptoms suggesting that a
linguistic-based approach could serve as a diagnostic method for incipient
Parkinsons disease. Additionally, improved linguistic models may enhance other
approaches through ensemble techniques. The field of large language models is
advancing rapidly, presenting the opportunity to explore the use of these new
models for detecting Parkinsons disease and to improve on current linguistic
approaches with high-dimensional representations of linguistics. We evaluate
the application of state-of-the-art large language models to detect Parkinsons
disease automatically from spontaneous speech with up to 73% accuracy.
|
[
-0.2729533612728119,
-0.8733882904052734,
0.5522700548171997,
0.5621353387832642,
-0.15378646552562714,
-0.2763224244117737,
-0.5717400312423706,
-0.45901718735694885,
0.533288836479187,
0.2510225772857666,
-0.30817800760269165,
-0.3137906789779663,
-0.6383997797966003,
0.2510448396205902,
-0.5182998776435852,
0.552284300327301,
0.1409098356962204,
0.6382828950881958,
0.5440701842308044,
-0.10790367424488068,
-0.2513854205608368,
-0.44517236948013306,
-0.8939346075057983,
-0.46329185366630554,
0.3445597290992737,
0.008934518322348595,
0.7212042808532715,
0.07029762864112854,
0.03891808167099953,
0.28463125228881836,
-0.51829594373703,
-0.2972486913204193,
-0.10290144383907318,
0.43738800287246704,
-0.10540468245744705,
-0.30264702439308167,
-0.522201418876648,
-0.15160121023654938,
0.6848916411399841,
1.0182255506515503,
-0.23009517788887024,
-0.32426753640174866,
0.10081787407398224,
0.31408601999282837,
0.005471419543027878,
0.2119920402765274,
-0.24648000299930573,
0.4690310060977936,
-0.4035576283931732,
-0.11880624294281006,
-0.37718644738197327,
-0.2567121982574463,
0.5213812589645386,
-0.591071367263794,
0.12486594170331955,
-0.3180772662162781,
0.34647098183631897,
0.055287085473537445,
-0.3023037612438202,
-0.14548452198505402,
-0.6515315175056458,
0.2091989368200302,
-0.8063369989395142,
0.5230035781860352,
0.38413500785827637,
0.44318875670433044,
-0.6767527461051941,
-0.5422617197036743,
-1.0482978820800781,
-0.7610263824462891,
0.404595285654068,
-0.16607701778411865,
-0.2526416778564453,
0.022165434435009956,
0.26041531562805176,
0.2699744999408722,
-1.0277564525604248,
0.8057384490966797,
0.1378786414861679,
-0.4452551305294037,
0.39585408568382263,
0.18164874613285065,
0.731803834438324,
-0.2733955681324005,
0.27937474846839905,
0.06301476061344147,
-0.4821823537349701,
-0.4072084426879883,
0.4478454887866974,
0.3039432466030121,
-0.07799850404262543,
0.6052321791648865,
-0.6130073070526123,
1.012709379196167,
-0.016264917328953743,
-0.13572901487350464,
0.4043048322200775,
0.03939962387084961,
-0.11437029391527176,
0.09765695035457611,
0.8129530549049377,
0.1537189483642578,
0.11666996031999588,
-0.27120527625083923,
0.07727974653244019,
-0.048610370606184006,
-0.22809842228889465,
-0.5655707120895386,
-0.7520018219947815,
0.5148711800575256,
-0.4424573481082916,
-0.17203174531459808,
-0.5968512892723083,
-0.7819891571998596,
-1.045382022857666,
-0.20077039301395416,
0.4855365455150604,
-0.45892539620399475,
-0.789983332157135,
0.029901402071118355,
-0.2519412934780121,
0.0027364427223801613,
0.25729355216026306,
-0.978354811668396,
-0.08706676214933395,
0.35418039560317993,
0.8581469655036926,
-0.05809555575251579,
-0.21964788436889648,
-0.5111610293388367,
-0.16115659475326538,
-0.5238414406776428,
0.811305820941925,
-0.21770748496055603,
-0.2416623830795288,
-0.14157699048519135,
0.11643333733081818,
-0.16460184752941132,
-0.7293761968612671,
0.21124599874019623,
-0.22114035487174988,
0.2405046671628952,
0.14499029517173767,
-0.3611181676387787,
0.021407475695014,
-0.015060285106301308,
-0.8109840750694275,
0.8709097504615784,
0.19162164628505707,
-0.4074474573135376,
0.5459372997283936,
-0.5755870342254639,
-0.4257834255695343,
0.4446583390235901,
-0.008678331971168518,
-0.328618586063385,
0.13579560816287994,
-0.18024064600467682,
0.5363304018974304,
-0.16303420066833496,
0.756689190864563,
-0.27931997179985046,
0.22977018356323242,
0.34960827231407166,
-0.5990692973136902,
0.6937640905380249,
0.07734865695238113,
-0.31393787264823914,
0.2047620713710785,
-0.7865988612174988,
-0.07795882225036621,
-0.08410966396331787,
-0.14695103466510773,
-0.2679799497127533,
0.4369921088218689,
-0.11050257086753845,
0.26685428619384766,
0.110341377556324,
-0.29502055048942566,
0.35384711623191833,
-0.6923878788948059,
0.09415635466575623,
0.5478941202163696,
0.040526196360588074,
0.28590595722198486,
-0.10739974677562714,
0.2919498383998871,
0.18959444761276245,
0.02937823161482811,
0.018901390954852104,
-0.9330881237983704,
-0.44833579659461975,
-0.28702840209007263,
0.556108295917511,
0.6625932455062866,
-0.584418535232544,
0.7034186124801636,
-0.33836567401885986,
-0.3997340202331543,
-0.03824769705533981,
-0.3364288806915283,
-0.13058407604694366,
0.3405579924583435,
0.2375403195619583,
-0.44514200091362,
-0.5334200263023376,
-0.7292942404747009,
-0.289194792509079,
0.1257586032152176,
-0.4064977765083313,
-0.03388622775673866,
0.27300482988357544,
-0.23458056151866913,
0.5505093932151794,
-0.3380725383758545,
-0.36616870760917664,
-0.4419597089290619,
0.5201981067657471,
0.19081051647663116,
0.5458230376243591,
0.2954564392566681,
-0.508288562297821,
-0.4927656948566437,
0.48133668303489685,
-0.8473554849624634,
-0.08834954351186752,
-0.02050217241048813,
0.3211459219455719,
0.32192692160606384,
0.45967620611190796,
-0.6343497037887573,
0.38110804557800293,
0.7669290900230408,
-0.4084789454936981,
0.601989209651947,
-0.4484187960624695,
-0.07299789041280746,
-0.8059666156768799,
-0.04617556557059288,
0.24478061497211456,
-0.18466410040855408,
-0.7950108051300049,
-0.324078768491745,
-0.2561693787574768,
-0.34771230816841125,
0.07262171804904938,
0.13290825486183167,
-0.4988803267478943,
0.13802264630794525,
-0.35422417521476746,
0.12097357213497162,
-0.42728307843208313,
-0.12086395919322968,
0.18829692900180817,
0.2764684557914734,
1.1400014162063599,
-0.8010420799255371,
0.625992476940155,
-0.20251135528087616,
-0.7840182781219482,
0.2066659778356552,
-0.5555775165557861,
-0.18608306348323822,
-0.22217285633087158,
0.6139342784881592,
-0.9769450426101685,
-0.6423642039299011,
0.27222761511802673,
-0.4337584972381592,
0.5396252274513245,
-0.055424775928258896,
-0.7078931331634521,
-0.3528234660625458,
0.17169086635112762,
-0.029928483068943024,
0.3625653088092804,
-0.3636617064476013,
0.5294054746627808,
0.6583631038665771,
-0.40725165605545044,
-0.17487981915473938,
-0.7441390156745911,
0.3300298750400543,
0.06255248188972473,
-0.73056960105896,
0.377931147813797,
0.260532408952713,
-0.07701803743839264,
-0.18003825843334198,
-0.14139112830162048,
-0.20549096167087555,
0.15890055894851685,
-0.1177859678864479,
-0.12830209732055664,
-0.19414487481117249,
0.1858857125043869,
0.10360206663608551,
-0.1552940160036087,
-0.21812547743320465,
-0.3054625391960144,
1.1002293825149536,
0.4613111615180969,
0.05229116976261139,
-0.9476212859153748,
0.45992666482925415,
0.7440162897109985,
0.0020552482455968857,
0.9368043541908264,
0.3375185430049896,
-0.5833156108856201,
-0.3406371474266052,
-0.230449378490448,
-0.25489503145217896,
-0.3710801899433136,
0.6233254671096802,
-0.3953199088573456,
-0.44144153594970703,
0.674665093421936,
-0.45357584953308105,
-0.6148877143859863,
0.21155603229999542,
0.706086277961731,
0.15329338610172272,
1.4239884614944458,
0.49961352348327637,
-0.07585224509239197,
0.48013222217559814,
-0.07072032988071442,
0.5540590286254883,
-0.6992413401603699,
-0.2608337700366974,
-0.6094980239868164,
0.10523365437984467,
-0.7240352034568787,
-0.37969568371772766,
0.563824474811554,
-0.0654958114027977,
0.21151839196681976,
0.08139270544052124,
-0.2625087797641754,
0.4239555597305298,
-0.053747210651636124,
0.2353247106075287,
-0.0012927658390253782,
-0.12862344086170197,
-0.16577178239822388,
-0.3158082365989685,
-0.8426588773727417,
-0.35970985889434814,
1.0603119134902954,
0.14300072193145752,
0.4717247486114502,
0.39062047004699707,
0.177089124917984,
0.3647269010543823,
0.4650293290615082,
-0.9575735330581665,
0.49442243576049805,
-0.43429920077323914,
-0.3585519790649414,
-0.6344505548477173,
-0.4856887459754944,
-1.0877591371536255,
0.45951637625694275,
-0.09521395713090897,
-1.101481556892395,
0.27628421783447266,
0.24658294022083282,
-0.2170899659395218,
0.2201305627822876,
-0.6347570419311523,
1.2573155164718628,
-0.10437766462564468,
0.01811039447784424,
-0.212229922413826,
-0.5254295468330383,
0.5788493752479553,
-0.11826485395431519,
0.103183813393116,
-0.028120774775743484,
0.2831760346889496,
0.8076509833335876,
-0.21500535309314728,
0.7763088941574097,
-0.2949073910713196,
-0.45476630330085754,
-0.2765059769153595,
0.14974983036518097,
0.540962815284729,
-0.1308051496744156,
-0.3466057777404785,
0.1275295913219452,
-0.35642194747924805,
0.0835861936211586,
-0.6362423896789551,
0.8714181780815125,
-0.3545057475566864,
-0.3870055675506592,
-0.7880212664604187,
-0.35367536544799805,
-0.40458178520202637,
0.061696190387010574,
0.38977155089378357,
0.7662509083747864,
-0.32735562324523926,
-0.16409294307231903,
0.9227381348609924,
-0.5526382327079773,
0.3088151216506958,
0.6007194519042969,
-0.2922038435935974,
-0.21197263896465302,
1.0116395950317383,
0.44274210929870605,
0.27167612314224243,
0.06018400937318802,
0.3958902657032013,
-0.4775216281414032,
-0.7873740196228027,
-0.5343495607376099,
0.106911301612854,
-0.41666144132614136,
0.34681564569473267,
-0.7277081608772278,
0.19492731988430023,
-0.6330702900886536,
0.4184688627719879,
-0.11844376474618912,
-0.5509798526763916,
-0.4675019681453705,
0.3095054030418396,
0.24369125068187714,
0.49555352330207825,
-0.3487556576728821,
0.2627255618572235,
-0.5168165564537048,
0.8225865960121155,
0.20788626372814178,
0.3366491496562958,
-0.05110684782266617,
-0.8012133836746216,
0.12295834720134735,
0.21975047886371613,
0.014765284955501556,
-1.376290202140808,
0.7983700633049011,
0.419767290353775,
0.726318359375,
0.19747823476791382,
-0.12605798244476318,
0.5688863396644592,
-0.4326021373271942,
0.8044174313545227,
0.3477376699447632,
-0.9888796806335449,
0.5917815566062927,
-0.2707279324531555,
0.3422964811325073,
0.01022105012089014,
0.8201079368591309,
-0.8243749141693115,
-0.4116823077201843,
-0.6317021250724792,
-0.8146081566810608,
0.6406102776527405,
-0.10194234549999237,
-0.04353158921003342,
0.028684422373771667,
0.023557372391223907,
-0.015698647126555443,
-0.2926849126815796,
-0.5807488560676575,
-0.12775355577468872,
0.18900099396705627,
-0.06577941030263901,
-0.3539045453071594,
-0.11134913563728333,
-0.17671681940555573,
-0.6366307139396667,
0.6554572582244873,
-0.09234663844108582,
0.46415671706199646,
0.22057384252548218,
-0.15228012204170227,
-0.16822659969329834,
0.17233094573020935,
0.67457115650177,
0.6661689877510071,
0.02995290607213974,
-0.07844717055559158,
0.28027328848838806,
-0.3927619457244873,
0.042981673032045364,
0.3768521249294281,
-0.23933127522468567,
0.40271544456481934,
-0.0950198844075203,
0.7712278962135315,
0.11712218075990677,
-0.7299813628196716,
0.7032322287559509,
0.07145464420318604,
-0.005661471746861935,
-0.6143022179603577,
-0.08282104879617691,
0.034163471311330795,
0.11209312081336975,
0.24135281145572662,
0.3059503734111786,
0.17136335372924805,
-0.7053657174110413,
0.14603954553604126,
0.5706992149353027,
-0.0899069681763649,
-0.3935176432132721,
0.512171745300293,
0.19934719800949097,
-0.4900275468826294,
0.6015642285346985,
-0.38218310475349426,
-0.6832404136657715,
0.5325055122375488,
0.5565592050552368,
0.7075625658035278,
-0.5774717330932617,
0.3534601032733917,
0.0698128268122673,
0.2550075948238373,
-0.5015179514884949,
0.29689934849739075,
0.16633155941963196,
-0.6777937412261963,
-0.7230117917060852,
-0.5247595310211182,
-0.32677188515663147,
0.4704555571079254,
-0.38272470235824585,
0.27708113193511963,
-0.3646959960460663,
-0.3063380718231201,
0.45789089798927307,
-0.3431696593761444,
0.12773209810256958,
0.10850470513105392,
0.2865807116031647,
0.647773802280426,
-0.8693015575408936,
1.2273088693618774,
0.5431063771247864,
-0.05826185643672943,
-0.4498369097709656,
0.3073909282684326,
0.05142823979258537,
-0.1297377496957779,
0.8572033047676086,
0.20828519761562347,
0.07642870396375656,
0.10877425223588943,
-0.5279573798179626,
-0.6769611239433289,
0.4035813510417938,
0.316950261592865,
-0.6261224150657654,
0.42741474509239197,
-0.062145382165908813,
0.7171407341957092,
0.12804223597049713,
-0.02484024129807949,
0.5416890978813171,
0.5106449127197266,
-0.17759545147418976,
-1.4546011686325073,
-0.14203645288944244,
-0.041715603321790695,
-0.017325207591056824,
0.6213303804397583,
-0.11368829756975174,
0.8559225797653198,
-0.02795604057610035,
-0.28821268677711487,
0.18827663362026215,
0.5586953163146973,
0.09914086014032364,
0.19285763800144196,
0.37864986062049866,
0.7184316515922546,
1.0892010927200317,
-0.17846491932868958,
1.0900342464447021,
-0.337504118680954,
0.21075695753097534,
0.5046788454055786,
-0.5420609712600708,
0.8117735981941223,
-0.08566715568304062,
-0.010961315594613552,
0.37995946407318115,
0.21982502937316895,
0.3603554964065552,
0.3194689154624939,
0.7255936861038208,
-0.9139711856842041,
-0.33583661913871765,
0.08771340548992157,
-0.5962387919425964,
0.4308798313140869,
0.8101117014884949,
-0.29875919222831726,
-0.2366591989994049,
0.31005528569221497,
0.17928925156593323,
-0.06401783972978592,
0.002873250050470233,
0.6042932271957397,
-0.317398339509964,
-0.6777085065841675,
0.7412745952606201,
0.048687174916267395,
0.7986888885498047,
-0.7970419526100159,
-0.0814463272690773,
-0.04050179943442345,
0.2144106775522232,
-0.08831316977739334,
-0.6330324411392212,
0.28273582458496094,
-0.04583585262298584,
-0.0933258906006813,
-0.16399109363555908,
0.3626244366168976,
-0.529390275478363,
-0.1827523112297058,
0.08591257035732269,
0.06308811157941818,
0.4149017632007599,
-0.39483627676963806,
-0.39315155148506165,
0.13715451955795288,
-0.2511899769306183,
-0.05693046748638153,
0.5499851703643799,
0.5701956748962402,
-0.14825385808944702,
0.8852073550224304,
0.6366742849349976,
0.40152180194854736,
0.21935667097568512,
0.273922324180603,
0.5314943790435791,
-0.4958688020706177,
-0.41903984546661377,
-0.5745139122009277,
0.23445965349674225,
-0.34900879859924316,
-0.632928729057312,
0.5841642022132874,
0.2892099916934967,
0.3735591471195221,
-0.1539221554994583,
0.6754083633422852,
-0.32985419034957886,
0.407194584608078,
-0.5747160911560059,
0.9275157451629639,
-0.2937352955341339,
0.03850178420543671,
-0.12005899846553802,
-0.592939019203186,
-0.7967971563339233,
0.8534667491912842,
-0.3410432040691376,
-0.23999138176441193,
0.7291650176048279,
0.9178744554519653,
0.22580735385417938,
0.17684312164783478,
0.23117142915725708,
0.7468546628952026,
0.2656024396419525,
0.30449405312538147,
0.900323212146759,
-0.09033729881048203,
0.068189337849617,
-0.2240276038646698,
-0.6096990704536438,
-0.19175122678279877,
-0.8446899652481079,
-0.3033023476600647,
-0.6133422255516052,
-0.7792575359344482,
-0.5153591632843018,
0.26475024223327637,
0.6642365455627441,
0.6277344226837158,
-0.7953638434410095,
-0.18745018541812897,
-0.3050296902656555,
0.07926461100578308,
-0.4067804515361786,
-0.2524961233139038,
0.19953200221061707,
0.06549881398677826,
-0.5900811553001404,
0.958270788192749,
0.18536591529846191,
0.35757628083229065,
-0.3255861699581146,
0.156016007065773,
-0.21476930379867554,
-0.5410273671150208,
0.9749095439910889,
0.6001054644584656,
-0.64874267578125,
-0.2017059326171875,
-0.29957079887390137,
0.012804953381419182,
-0.40040576457977295,
0.7765863537788391,
-0.7990269064903259,
0.4495570957660675,
0.8902451395988464,
0.13256314396858215,
0.24926957488059998,
-0.37031659483909607,
0.7650215029716492,
-0.16068701446056366,
0.39179033041000366,
0.6334258913993835,
0.2399687021970749,
0.3530910313129425,
-0.2323424518108368,
-0.11519194394350052,
0.5298514366149902,
-0.5328316688537598,
-1.042055368423462,
0.2028047889471054,
-1.235239028930664,
-0.2846302390098572,
0.9617629051208496,
0.07388629764318466,
-0.01409747265279293,
-0.6417860388755798,
-0.053832054138183594,
0.1774350255727768,
-0.08244376629590988,
0.7428957223892212,
0.5208151340484619,
-0.5024591088294983,
0.0342663936316967,
-0.6137221455574036,
0.6250453591346741,
0.456211119890213,
-0.48761796951293945,
-0.0005022922996431589,
0.6260764002799988,
0.39894768595695496,
-0.06335139274597168,
0.5216727256774902,
-0.15305683016777039,
0.4278642535209656,
0.11978629976511002,
0.040454912930727005,
0.5561429262161255,
-0.17801623046398163,
-0.6042413711547852,
0.10647381097078323,
-0.0647757276892662,
0.0713718831539154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05159v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05159v1
|
Semantic Stealth: Adversarial Text Attacks on NLP Using Several Methods
| 2024-04-08T02:55:01 | 2024-04-08T02:55:01 |
Roopkatha Dey, Aivy Debnath, Sayak Kumar Dutta, Kaustav Ghosh, Arijit Mitra, Arghya Roy Chowdhury, Jaydip Sen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
In various real-world applications such as machine translation, sentiment
analysis, and question answering, a pivotal role is played by NLP models,
facilitating efficient communication and decision-making processes in domains
ranging from healthcare to finance. However, a significant challenge is posed
to the robustness of these natural language processing models by text
adversarial attacks. These attacks involve the deliberate manipulation of input
text to mislead the predictions of the model while maintaining human
interpretability. Despite the remarkable performance achieved by
state-of-the-art models like BERT in various natural language processing tasks,
they are found to remain vulnerable to adversarial perturbations in the input
text. In addressing the vulnerability of text classifiers to adversarial
attacks, three distinct attack mechanisms are explored in this paper using the
victim model BERT: BERT-on-BERT attack, PWWS attack, and Fraud Bargain's Attack
(FBA). Leveraging the IMDB, AG News, and SST2 datasets, a thorough comparative
analysis is conducted to assess the effectiveness of these attacks on the BERT
classifier model. It is revealed by the analysis that PWWS emerges as the most
potent adversary, consistently outperforming other methods across multiple
evaluation scenarios, thereby emphasizing its efficacy in generating
adversarial examples for text classification. Through comprehensive
experimentation, the performance of these attacks is assessed and the findings
indicate that the PWWS attack outperforms others, demonstrating lower runtime,
higher accuracy, and favorable semantic similarity scores. The key insight of
this paper lies in the assessment of the relative performances of three
prevalent state-of-the-art attack mechanisms.
|
[
-0.3110578656196594,
-1.2213901281356812,
0.39097651839256287,
-0.03117784857749939,
-0.055326368659734726,
0.05801745504140854,
0.04791754111647606,
-0.6129299402236938,
-0.10044888406991959,
0.6188533306121826,
-0.6036449670791626,
-0.27547481656074524,
-0.9905154705047607,
-0.047366246581077576,
-0.8042888045310974,
1.1006861925125122,
0.23002736270427704,
0.08763351291418076,
0.21600838005542755,
-0.12898407876491547,
-0.30737051367759705,
-0.8149040341377258,
-0.47064295411109924,
0.03359953686594963,
0.6574345231056213,
-0.40624549984931946,
1.208548665046692,
0.15909209847450256,
0.7548058032989502,
0.3142979145050049,
-0.12135426700115204,
-0.20541808009147644,
-0.36603298783302307,
0.26582834124565125,
-0.12184891849756241,
-0.4415295124053955,
-0.10115853697061539,
-0.13862431049346924,
0.429071307182312,
0.5526134371757507,
0.257822722196579,
-0.20742228627204895,
0.06800325214862823,
0.6458137035369873,
-0.8133894801139832,
-0.32456979155540466,
-1.0427526235580444,
0.06152167543768883,
-0.37602290511131287,
0.04060627520084381,
-0.6534208059310913,
-0.12399360537528992,
0.39588993787765503,
-0.36927396059036255,
0.3556956946849823,
-0.18777957558631897,
1.0670552253723145,
0.3951336443424225,
-0.2656485438346863,
-0.5928521156311035,
-0.6126617789268494,
0.8322523236274719,
-0.617324948310852,
0.021446572616696358,
0.28289729356765747,
0.20896944403648376,
-0.5218361020088196,
-0.6866093873977661,
-0.3831186294555664,
-0.2119348645210266,
-0.16436007618904114,
0.15871389210224152,
-0.7219409942626953,
0.19272710382938385,
0.13191279768943787,
0.19615036249160767,
-0.5927200317382812,
0.1683759242296219,
-0.05359858274459839,
-0.29400908946990967,
0.4988190233707428,
-0.07277629524469376,
0.46936464309692383,
-0.2493889331817627,
-0.7750409245491028,
-0.2713809013366699,
-0.3587351143360138,
-0.07813604176044464,
0.686855137348175,
0.12435228377580643,
0.23468011617660522,
0.5875675678253174,
0.011812650598585606,
0.7498392462730408,
-0.42350953817367554,
0.07003811001777649,
-0.31658661365509033,
-0.28469640016555786,
-0.3117068409919739,
0.10712721943855286,
0.8178800940513611,
0.1091386079788208,
-0.03158128261566162,
-0.38710740208625793,
-0.23102419078350067,
0.33452388644218445,
0.7608703374862671,
-0.4080006778240204,
-0.16926278173923492,
0.20470237731933594,
-0.5608396530151367,
-0.7323668599128723,
0.2307278960943222,
-0.7082754373550415,
-0.5028240084648132,
0.26299482583999634,
0.8115131855010986,
-0.5592180490493774,
0.07696884870529175,
0.02968042902648449,
-0.5169296264648438,
0.43069177865982056,
0.2181958705186844,
-0.8518152236938477,
0.4688291847705841,
0.760821521282196,
0.5922818183898926,
-0.09533168375492096,
-0.178937628865242,
-0.2679772675037384,
0.20574459433555603,
-0.24018403887748718,
0.40081605315208435,
-0.146264910697937,
-0.3276805281639099,
-0.06621982157230377,
-0.3188455402851105,
-0.29210954904556274,
-0.15914052724838257,
0.6882431507110596,
-0.757007360458374,
0.30819225311279297,
-0.09627249091863632,
-0.5128208994865417,
-0.42107218503952026,
0.39734145998954773,
-0.9028697609901428,
0.8225445747375488,
-0.021965011954307556,
-1.251554012298584,
0.19680538773536682,
-0.7385472059249878,
-0.4659833312034607,
-0.12562060356140137,
0.1117628812789917,
-0.4630930423736572,
0.13924840092658997,
0.20037254691123962,
0.499713659286499,
-0.06706085056066513,
0.0870245024561882,
-0.31503280997276306,
-0.3687420189380646,
0.5558497309684753,
-0.9292758703231812,
0.9841403365135193,
0.11551804095506668,
-0.5340427756309509,
0.11772383749485016,
-0.693851113319397,
-0.06895022094249725,
0.4863893389701843,
0.029150525107979774,
-0.5990303158760071,
0.18214237689971924,
-0.06694521009922028,
0.04965358227491379,
0.30296027660369873,
-0.5551528930664062,
-0.08046900480985641,
-0.8093987107276917,
0.3372228145599365,
0.7456312775611877,
0.13254085183143616,
0.31017938256263733,
-0.21020710468292236,
0.32135850191116333,
-0.424688458442688,
0.5021353960037231,
0.009433883242309093,
-0.6934793591499329,
-0.43713730573654175,
-0.18025042116641998,
0.5670120716094971,
0.7161500453948975,
-0.8351778388023376,
0.2745600938796997,
0.19240356981754303,
-0.6009249687194824,
-0.5151736736297607,
-0.054522402584552765,
0.45719587802886963,
0.3881930112838745,
0.41292136907577515,
-0.04541097953915596,
-0.19790427386760712,
-0.8269104957580566,
-0.718249499797821,
-0.19463232159614563,
-0.17082636058330536,
-0.029840057715773582,
0.4812089204788208,
-0.27736759185791016,
0.837574303150177,
-0.40320274233818054,
-0.3680264353752136,
-0.28049716353416443,
0.19931979477405548,
-0.11081754416227341,
0.3936363458633423,
0.7030549645423889,
-1.0713179111480713,
-0.19234931468963623,
-0.24456584453582764,
-0.6349122524261475,
0.2473326325416565,
-0.24822290241718292,
-0.14788931608200073,
0.42588669061660767,
0.24761152267456055,
-0.3710174858570099,
0.6618471741676331,
0.5798734426498413,
-0.35465681552886963,
0.3884817957878113,
-0.24047783017158508,
-0.13585588335990906,
-0.596868634223938,
-0.04753189533948898,
-0.38792791962623596,
0.12538103759288788,
-0.8384122848510742,
0.4521167278289795,
-0.021046748384833336,
-0.15642988681793213,
-0.46888887882232666,
0.3194666802883148,
-0.03618336468935013,
0.0243977103382349,
-0.003939472604542971,
0.08134911954402924,
0.09403952956199646,
0.36257824301719666,
-0.17297308146953583,
0.2291470170021057,
0.4858761727809906,
-0.3705742657184601,
0.26505720615386963,
0.07069720327854156,
-0.19143998622894287,
0.10377461463212967,
-0.7473416328430176,
0.09268416464328766,
0.014105800539255142,
0.2514151632785797,
-0.9938231706619263,
-0.05112626031041145,
0.42777618765830994,
-0.7476637959480286,
0.5105113387107849,
0.10274818539619446,
-0.7407280802726746,
-0.002849519718438387,
-0.6213321089744568,
-0.17642828822135925,
0.16769348084926605,
-0.5451445579528809,
0.7275102734565735,
0.08123760670423508,
-0.03144602105021477,
-1.000611424446106,
-0.8803465962409973,
0.48765498399734497,
-0.197142094373703,
-0.7510662078857422,
0.485086590051651,
0.20055043697357178,
-0.35734832286834717,
0.020650630816817284,
-0.0686928853392601,
-0.031268633902072906,
0.7991882562637329,
0.06888150423765182,
0.4017563462257385,
0.11216504871845245,
-0.28019630908966064,
-0.12530137598514557,
-0.23656947910785675,
0.3309464454650879,
-0.12060865014791489,
0.34447386860847473,
0.10493512451648712,
-0.42068663239479065,
-0.3902306854724884,
0.5583265423774719,
0.4500998854637146,
-0.04954569786787033,
0.992804229259491,
0.7621002793312073,
-0.34471628069877625,
-0.1866258829832077,
-0.3804834187030792,
-0.15158069133758545,
-0.4636605679988861,
0.48513221740722656,
-0.27540168166160583,
-0.5378588438034058,
0.3469597101211548,
0.29397809505462646,
0.135793998837471,
0.5571682453155518,
0.22991952300071716,
-0.051617152988910675,
1.223555088043213,
0.42177632451057434,
-0.191045880317688,
0.29982051253318787,
-0.18720249831676483,
0.18303662538528442,
-0.4602029323577881,
-0.33386123180389404,
-0.6187719702720642,
-0.1737799346446991,
-0.8216824531555176,
-0.07474009692668915,
0.13114626705646515,
0.01787375658750534,
0.10097624361515045,
0.405719518661499,
-0.45148521661758423,
0.2066340446472168,
0.6734656095504761,
0.031144794076681137,
-0.08312457799911499,
-0.08875692635774612,
-0.2014591544866562,
-0.13170702755451202,
-0.8093405961990356,
-0.48465895652770996,
1.1121938228607178,
0.5935245156288147,
0.6774969100952148,
0.36344313621520996,
0.6577997207641602,
0.4540502429008484,
-0.028559161350131035,
-0.6702907085418701,
0.5013417601585388,
-0.4932588040828705,
-0.6098059415817261,
-0.24371381103992462,
-0.30573415756225586,
-0.9788215160369873,
0.4746847152709961,
-0.3128063380718231,
-0.6435036063194275,
-0.01329011656343937,
-0.31745073199272156,
-0.1364043802022934,
0.5120335817337036,
-0.8365734815597534,
0.921390175819397,
-0.40854135155677795,
-0.2400015890598297,
-0.07443995028734207,
-0.9893591403961182,
0.24646572768688202,
-0.22894977033138275,
0.14593061804771423,
0.3012523055076599,
-0.05107790604233742,
0.7358577847480774,
-0.46314629912376404,
0.9335546493530273,
-0.26691848039627075,
-0.13884538412094116,
-0.012153023853898048,
0.2600487172603607,
0.5889462828636169,
-0.15276038646697998,
0.05826617032289505,
0.42625463008880615,
-0.2634207606315613,
-0.5197731852531433,
-0.5981441736221313,
0.5429959893226624,
-0.6154069900512695,
-0.5652682185173035,
-0.6364077925682068,
-0.27431520819664,
-0.17490315437316895,
0.167242169380188,
0.3908240497112274,
0.5372399687767029,
-0.28525763750076294,
0.2981824278831482,
0.8140211701393127,
-0.513878345489502,
0.6746615767478943,
0.3987637460231781,
0.34495222568511963,
-0.40759238600730896,
0.9611895680427551,
0.018678609281778336,
0.6539331674575806,
0.636283278465271,
0.14262764155864716,
-0.34382766485214233,
-0.6389107704162598,
-0.39177843928337097,
-0.0954660102725029,
-0.7324020266532898,
-0.23430119454860687,
-0.8063306212425232,
-0.1572580635547638,
-0.47115185856819153,
-0.42247357964515686,
-0.13693849742412567,
-0.4953978955745697,
-0.11061907559633255,
0.09295154362916946,
0.1343168467283249,
0.8145464062690735,
0.3020395040512085,
0.29026350378990173,
-0.5180683135986328,
0.4645416736602783,
0.5110926032066345,
-0.038477957248687744,
-0.045431412756443024,
-0.2179499715566635,
0.10804366320371628,
-0.10730794817209244,
-0.4504060447216034,
-1.0908864736557007,
0.3611307442188263,
-0.14445538818836212,
0.5466936230659485,
0.3881568908691406,
0.2749522030353546,
0.17892985045909882,
-0.27841857075691223,
0.978222131729126,
0.07460400462150574,
-0.930985152721405,
0.6760220527648926,
-0.19787709414958954,
0.20931409299373627,
0.43139567971229553,
0.2915554940700531,
0.04583289101719856,
-0.8138769268989563,
-1.0063624382019043,
-0.9900174140930176,
0.8491623401641846,
0.6092764735221863,
-0.006297891028225422,
0.19816988706588745,
-0.05583268404006958,
0.012914386577904224,
0.13404794037342072,
-0.830166220664978,
-0.48577237129211426,
-0.2908822000026703,
-0.09401372075080872,
0.24433937668800354,
-0.2906118333339691,
-0.1650240123271942,
0.2308385670185089,
0.6831974387168884,
0.17081134021282196,
0.20097535848617554,
0.34443938732147217,
-0.08897863328456879,
0.44974252581596375,
0.14613604545593262,
0.5399283170700073,
0.12001119554042816,
-0.20596081018447876,
0.08887334913015366,
0.10932215303182602,
-0.6062740087509155,
-0.18644608557224274,
0.3500284254550934,
-0.37796157598495483,
0.24235573410987854,
0.6942090392112732,
0.637237012386322,
0.39697012305259705,
-0.601992130279541,
0.7082350850105286,
-0.38323497772216797,
-0.23249876499176025,
-0.2594468891620636,
0.07317959517240524,
-0.353287011384964,
0.019541624933481216,
0.431140661239624,
0.5448323488235474,
0.32010361552238464,
-0.46511828899383545,
0.04025230556726456,
0.7792404890060425,
-0.5627408027648926,
0.10679291188716888,
0.7657449841499329,
-0.17074289917945862,
-0.1645878702402115,
0.21637891232967377,
-0.04255834221839905,
-1.0263783931732178,
0.7035117745399475,
0.42508557438850403,
0.9163528084754944,
-0.23169922828674316,
0.16175289452075958,
-0.17989085614681244,
0.7480204105377197,
0.14770758152008057,
-0.11079136282205582,
-0.24000369012355804,
-0.4605327844619751,
-0.09634766727685928,
-0.49300235509872437,
-0.5211480259895325,
0.150384321808815,
-0.803078293800354,
0.11221455037593842,
-0.5791483521461487,
0.01400379091501236,
0.20134736597537994,
0.11429961025714874,
-0.139780655503273,
0.31698402762413025,
0.18052153289318085,
0.6391865611076355,
-0.409563809633255,
0.8257432579994202,
0.3923627436161041,
-0.19680877029895782,
-0.40725088119506836,
0.26394277811050415,
0.12664449214935303,
-0.4775683283805847,
0.6639913320541382,
0.16150948405265808,
-0.2135755717754364,
-0.3713778257369995,
-0.3198908567428589,
-0.5990977883338928,
0.7056840658187866,
0.24980874359607697,
-0.13010866940021515,
-0.07131590694189072,
0.1533980816602707,
0.4112577736377716,
0.2023652344942093,
-0.000054276159062283114,
0.47643449902534485,
0.434974730014801,
-0.15801875293254852,
-0.5747373700141907,
-0.012051090598106384,
-0.05027871951460838,
-0.005356740206480026,
0.2762325704097748,
-0.5336019396781921,
0.6946084499359131,
0.011656256392598152,
-0.17056414484977722,
0.1366775631904602,
0.40744632482528687,
-0.1293499618768692,
0.26209592819213867,
0.45060786604881287,
0.39609038829803467,
0.5395346283912659,
-0.3289569914340973,
1.287441611289978,
-0.02213316597044468,
0.14083725214004517,
0.6961040496826172,
-0.1482856720685959,
0.7778083086013794,
0.27190953493118286,
-0.07572449743747711,
0.4274362027645111,
0.17114175856113434,
-0.23920553922653198,
0.6531832814216614,
0.22802093625068665,
-0.14598271250724792,
0.2538527250289917,
0.3489176332950592,
-0.2702229619026184,
0.5480467677116394,
0.5733150243759155,
-0.3437935709953308,
-0.15647970139980316,
0.21198000013828278,
0.34420856833457947,
0.2097085863351822,
-0.13047794997692108,
0.9768950343132019,
-0.25609123706817627,
-0.34953323006629944,
0.3866746425628662,
0.4502476751804352,
0.8839156031608582,
-1.2465975284576416,
0.15095040202140808,
0.22610726952552795,
0.2647814154624939,
-0.08058560639619827,
-0.42494454979896545,
0.37778612971305847,
0.005663089919835329,
-0.21468032896518707,
-0.24538110196590424,
0.9861718416213989,
0.08671664446592331,
-0.30705249309539795,
0.6199976801872253,
-0.1961122751235962,
-0.24327349662780762,
-0.21603724360466003,
-1.0290676355361938,
0.14536882936954498,
-0.01953749917447567,
-0.17072831094264984,
0.5519735813140869,
0.20932462811470032,
0.13458357751369476,
0.5756667256355286,
0.6996430158615112,
0.1216040849685669,
0.14091099798679352,
0.035204652696847916,
0.6412749886512756,
-0.5701471567153931,
-0.5761190056800842,
-0.9931595921516418,
0.10653959214687347,
-0.32048189640045166,
-0.09530321508646011,
1.1545324325561523,
0.3389699459075928,
0.7699915170669556,
0.10899679362773895,
0.7350802421569824,
0.01374010555446148,
0.5499191880226135,
-0.66796875,
0.9911572933197021,
-0.20480741560459137,
0.44656750559806824,
-0.7096336483955383,
-0.43806788325309753,
-0.4948599934577942,
0.35507017374038696,
-0.13627630472183228,
-0.15486158430576324,
0.7134578824043274,
0.5320270657539368,
0.45377063751220703,
0.36832207441329956,
0.2121700644493103,
0.19076906144618988,
0.4231177866458893,
0.3791947066783905,
0.8650715351104736,
-0.7753851413726807,
0.6873891949653625,
-0.3695399761199951,
-0.18288922309875488,
-0.1366908997297287,
-0.657076358795166,
-0.9083200097084045,
-0.27208366990089417,
-0.22323058545589447,
-0.38737261295318604,
0.28751739859580994,
0.20978142321109772,
0.35264337062835693,
-0.6901795864105225,
0.21618802845478058,
-0.10374081879854202,
0.3012244403362274,
-0.2829076945781708,
-0.33212533593177795,
0.5871865153312683,
-0.3941114842891693,
-0.5461629629135132,
0.5039225220680237,
0.17833824455738068,
0.10074552893638611,
-0.4784225821495056,
0.2992977499961853,
-0.22781716287136078,
0.2991919219493866,
0.4251129925251007,
-0.017383091151714325,
-0.8730037212371826,
-0.018632397055625916,
-0.11218749731779099,
-0.13443419337272644,
-0.579445481300354,
0.812164843082428,
-0.7925967574119568,
0.4998054504394531,
0.197190061211586,
0.9127208590507507,
-0.03338035196065903,
-0.04748937115073204,
0.4214228093624115,
-0.8526994585990906,
0.24922850728034973,
0.38184916973114014,
0.15141262114048004,
0.25207629799842834,
-0.6505821347236633,
0.27144595980644226,
0.2356550395488739,
-0.3120940923690796,
-0.9886438250541687,
0.08628416806459427,
-0.7419058680534363,
-0.9669833183288574,
0.7884954810142517,
-0.14539024233818054,
-0.25919726490974426,
-0.3572781980037689,
-0.2681589126586914,
-0.06709828972816467,
-0.11873500049114227,
0.7340347766876221,
0.6944559812545776,
0.17200687527656555,
0.5916568636894226,
-0.7488595843315125,
0.5725958943367004,
0.5342807173728943,
-0.3538892865180969,
-0.020567892119288445,
0.14501677453517914,
-0.12974455952644348,
0.31220656633377075,
0.02627289667725563,
-0.36851704120635986,
0.15685535967350006,
0.3094909191131592,
-0.45897531509399414,
0.10693300515413284,
-0.2830478549003601,
-0.4083392024040222,
0.7213084697723389,
-0.26863333582878113,
-0.37563157081604004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05144v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05144v1
|
Enhancing Clinical Efficiency through LLM: Discharge Note Generation for Cardiac Patients
| 2024-04-08T01:55:28 | 2024-04-08T01:55:28 |
HyoJe Jung, Yunha Kim, Heejung Choi, Hyeram Seo, Minkyoung Kim, JiYe Han, Gaeun Kee, Seohyun Park, Soyoung Ko, Byeolhee Kim, Suyeon Kim, Tae Joon Jun, Young-Hak Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Medical documentation, including discharge notes, is crucial for ensuring
patient care quality, continuity, and effective medical communication. However,
the manual creation of these documents is not only time-consuming but also
prone to inconsistencies and potential errors. The automation of this
documentation process using artificial intelligence (AI) represents a promising
area of innovation in healthcare. This study directly addresses the
inefficiencies and inaccuracies in creating discharge notes manually,
particularly for cardiac patients, by employing AI techniques, specifically
large language model (LLM). Utilizing a substantial dataset from a cardiology
center, encompassing wide-ranging medical records and physician assessments,
our research evaluates the capability of LLM to enhance the documentation
process. Among the various models assessed, Mistral-7B distinguished itself by
accurately generating discharge notes that significantly improve both
documentation efficiency and the continuity of care for patients. These notes
underwent rigorous qualitative evaluation by medical expert, receiving high
marks for their clinical relevance, completeness, readability, and contribution
to informed decision-making and care planning. Coupled with quantitative
analyses, these results confirm Mistral-7B's efficacy in distilling complex
medical information into concise, coherent summaries. Overall, our findings
illuminate the considerable promise of specialized LLM, such as Mistral-7B, in
refining healthcare documentation workflows and advancing patient care. This
study lays the groundwork for further integrating advanced AI technologies in
healthcare, demonstrating their potential to revolutionize patient
documentation and support better care outcomes.
|
[
-0.1633010059595108,
-0.7838621139526367,
0.9154367446899414,
0.19389168918132782,
-0.44706612825393677,
-0.1104353591799736,
-0.1451132893562317,
-0.39320117235183716,
0.026561113074421883,
0.504180908203125,
-0.3154521584510803,
-0.9430043697357178,
-0.6125460863113403,
0.060905151069164276,
-0.5611624121665955,
0.916508674621582,
-0.12735362350940704,
0.2124377340078354,
-0.19519156217575073,
-0.029006347060203552,
-0.45751509070396423,
-0.5175298452377319,
-0.6178657412528992,
-0.7282224893569946,
0.4773100018501282,
0.16842801868915558,
0.5618891716003418,
0.9246962070465088,
0.8591305613517761,
0.32128334045410156,
0.03457657992839813,
0.28812965750694275,
-0.1869734525680542,
0.29933106899261475,
0.41524434089660645,
-0.5577889680862427,
-0.7792538404464722,
-0.4318007826805115,
0.6536155343055725,
0.28678014874458313,
-0.39394837617874146,
0.20113669335842133,
-0.22610895335674286,
0.9020980000495911,
-0.24443994462490082,
0.22124789655208588,
-0.18106220662593842,
0.04213564842939377,
-0.3341124355792999,
-0.5266355872154236,
-0.15394273400306702,
-0.44997209310531616,
0.08271042257547379,
-0.6262031197547913,
0.37025758624076843,
-0.15647172927856445,
0.5696291327476501,
0.44525474309921265,
0.026929855346679688,
-0.6776677966117859,
-0.8453587293624878,
0.22364650666713715,
-0.7773065567016602,
0.26346564292907715,
0.3233407735824585,
0.475699782371521,
-0.108432836830616,
-0.9079334139823914,
-0.24224939942359924,
-0.44104117155075073,
-0.014398920349776745,
0.44608086347579956,
-0.11126729846000671,
0.49246904253959656,
0.3677939772605896,
0.5573030114173889,
-0.3782554566860199,
0.17951369285583496,
-0.5059784650802612,
-0.050096265971660614,
0.7432403564453125,
0.5197778344154358,
0.42171838879585266,
-0.08016423135995865,
-0.05049535259604454,
0.0673326924443245,
-0.4323076009750366,
0.014608399011194706,
0.05026001110672951,
-0.10730455815792084,
-0.43173643946647644,
0.49572670459747314,
-0.11193130165338516,
0.3941372036933899,
0.04169547185301781,
-0.5805449485778809,
0.17985521256923676,
-0.1599242240190506,
-0.23705022037029266,
0.45413222908973694,
0.7122766971588135,
0.39074864983558655,
-0.05698389932513237,
-0.11022229492664337,
-0.24983860552310944,
0.11886096745729446,
0.5273046493530273,
-0.7692598700523376,
-0.3748118281364441,
0.6721727848052979,
-0.7445846796035767,
-0.2584376335144043,
-0.0015760784735903144,
-0.4378246068954468,
-0.6257793307304382,
-0.6106125712394714,
-0.029939349740743637,
-0.7344310879707336,
-0.016232537105679512,
-0.09741640090942383,
-0.4035611152648926,
-0.11257178336381912,
0.8601446747779846,
-0.48430249094963074,
0.20426374673843384,
0.7582398653030396,
0.7336196899414062,
-0.1440303474664688,
-0.02601907029747963,
-0.4111812114715576,
0.11130671203136444,
-0.4322885572910309,
0.9401400685310364,
-0.12763051688671112,
-0.7085996270179749,
0.2190372794866562,
-0.4537968933582306,
0.13672521710395813,
-0.9170655608177185,
0.7397763133049011,
-0.04237143322825432,
-0.32252880930900574,
0.07664293050765991,
-0.515819787979126,
-0.0021380295511335135,
0.2014738917350769,
-0.8265646696090698,
0.7550622224807739,
0.4033562242984772,
-0.46266090869903564,
0.10422685742378235,
-0.4996877908706665,
-0.5245046615600586,
0.35386788845062256,
-0.6001085638999939,
-0.5196550488471985,
0.357104629278183,
0.13329876959323883,
0.4254002571105957,
-0.6780533194541931,
0.31988728046417236,
0.14107190072536469,
-0.37892454862594604,
0.3509105443954468,
-0.520994246006012,
0.3331077992916107,
0.058524079620838165,
-0.27305498719215393,
0.1913342922925949,
-0.85194331407547,
-0.2532961368560791,
-0.28715425729751587,
-0.6052323579788208,
-0.06332790851593018,
-0.22849318385124207,
0.09180688858032227,
0.19706524908542633,
0.1631181687116623,
-0.2150879204273224,
0.2584807574748993,
-0.43464744091033936,
0.2359304577112198,
0.6198116540908813,
0.36427241563796997,
0.46352195739746094,
-0.9932941794395447,
0.777992844581604,
0.018794653937220573,
0.422956645488739,
-0.5337200164794922,
-0.3361055254936218,
-0.5627015829086304,
-0.5961908102035522,
0.13840746879577637,
0.5101844072341919,
-0.37381356954574585,
0.448742538690567,
-0.15126001834869385,
-0.8921173810958862,
-0.8399929404258728,
0.11772522330284119,
0.4005624055862427,
0.9316123723983765,
0.34193184971809387,
-0.1279587298631668,
-0.1673935204744339,
-0.7559056878089905,
0.046704959124326706,
-0.25998252630233765,
0.2970021665096283,
0.37671300768852234,
0.03572545945644379,
-0.567146360874176,
0.548323392868042,
-0.33129507303237915,
-0.4425416588783264,
-0.6037716269493103,
0.2049461156129837,
0.3249984085559845,
0.3262394070625305,
0.14323776960372925,
-0.5145366787910461,
-0.33682799339294434,
0.1672985553741455,
-1.0482432842254639,
-0.3270837068557739,
-0.6116495132446289,
-0.24680545926094055,
0.13141947984695435,
0.49778011441230774,
-0.7645737528800964,
0.7993254065513611,
0.00722956657409668,
0.11510118842124939,
0.41622456908226013,
-0.8468045592308044,
0.2703759968280792,
-0.9333375096321106,
0.2918722331523895,
-0.025589656084775925,
0.010548553429543972,
-0.719977855682373,
-0.4250970780849457,
0.25614073872566223,
-0.014661183580756187,
-0.1336556375026703,
0.6964903473854065,
-0.4166429340839386,
0.38239994645118713,
-0.30205249786376953,
-0.11250349879264832,
-0.008823195472359657,
0.08788865059614182,
-0.1564393937587738,
0.16281716525554657,
0.3285481929779053,
-0.7284293174743652,
0.3230522871017456,
0.34881827235221863,
0.05901554226875305,
0.6325900554656982,
-0.6243138313293457,
-0.31583791971206665,
-0.25652754306793213,
0.42061904072761536,
-0.7172282338142395,
-0.2435346096754074,
0.08274339139461517,
-0.5359781384468079,
0.4135209023952484,
0.1536148488521576,
-0.4990721046924591,
-0.4107359051704407,
-0.3806842267513275,
0.21025200188159943,
0.8459763526916504,
-0.04315786808729172,
0.941184401512146,
0.203507199883461,
-0.36210542917251587,
-0.20003332197666168,
-0.5994025468826294,
-0.07396382838487625,
-0.1492716521024704,
-0.461342453956604,
0.3420037627220154,
-0.045821648091077805,
-0.36876338720321655,
-0.24812935292720795,
-0.1662500947713852,
0.005239448510110378,
0.1594315618276596,
0.7785567045211792,
0.5526756048202515,
-0.07309643179178238,
0.3531365692615509,
0.384761244058609,
-0.1873219907283783,
0.20689232647418976,
-0.04058607667684555,
0.5958088636398315,
0.34268707036972046,
-0.6486288905143738,
-1.278815746307373,
0.5478760600090027,
0.9433420300483704,
-0.2082497775554657,
0.48279261589050293,
0.6780726909637451,
-0.47795671224594116,
-0.22609026730060577,
-0.9422228932380676,
0.01572694629430771,
-0.3792618215084076,
0.3221762478351593,
0.18223029375076294,
-0.48658671975135803,
0.5964581370353699,
-0.3876258432865143,
0.3770829737186432,
0.5794005393981934,
0.6031681895256042,
-0.2628650963306427,
0.8326335549354553,
0.40388011932373047,
-0.20017455518245697,
0.33816617727279663,
-0.47264978289604187,
0.2780073881149292,
-0.9406765699386597,
-0.500082790851593,
-0.6612357497215271,
-0.13885195553302765,
-0.412441611289978,
-0.45028433203697205,
0.8581234812736511,
0.3105631470680237,
-0.1825949102640152,
-0.4479077160358429,
-0.7036412954330444,
-0.22476495802402496,
0.49029186367988586,
0.26304763555526733,
0.3800358772277832,
-0.06449192017316818,
0.08134949207305908,
0.2627244293689728,
-0.6923955678939819,
-0.5657711625099182,
1.176474690437317,
0.3747003376483917,
0.9802554845809937,
-0.27325472235679626,
1.2060050964355469,
0.7113941311836243,
0.6011990308761597,
-0.6004074215888977,
0.18287740647792816,
-0.11375167220830917,
0.012742255814373493,
-0.19732418656349182,
-0.09908541291952133,
-0.8583129048347473,
-0.15769998729228973,
-0.24458779394626617,
-0.4168435335159302,
-0.1926526576280594,
0.6422873735427856,
-0.4784190058708191,
-0.13438226282596588,
-0.5831606984138489,
0.5149295926094055,
-0.552201509475708,
-0.03919766843318939,
-0.2658679783344269,
-0.5325863361358643,
0.4114254415035248,
-0.3241509199142456,
0.26013699173927307,
0.09311285614967346,
-0.05799051374197006,
0.41093018651008606,
-0.6355463266372681,
0.6227489709854126,
0.046116903424263,
-0.35044220089912415,
0.27496305108070374,
-0.18171988427639008,
0.36863112449645996,
0.25810736417770386,
-0.19964411854743958,
0.20240844786167145,
-0.26943865418434143,
0.06659288704395294,
-0.7038028240203857,
0.5632269978523254,
-0.7588239312171936,
-0.43209409713745117,
-0.25423887372016907,
-0.4776049256324768,
0.17902518808841705,
0.189801886677742,
0.48642557859420776,
0.9219235181808472,
-0.2706677317619324,
-0.33712238073349,
0.6082308292388916,
-0.45985713601112366,
0.2740333676338196,
0.4184947609901428,
0.11118107289075851,
-0.5125245451927185,
0.8803768157958984,
0.18894901871681213,
0.08503536880016327,
0.49884334206581116,
0.24821233749389648,
-0.47082921862602234,
-0.659712553024292,
-0.624578058719635,
0.5927068591117859,
-0.7575454115867615,
-0.1727188378572464,
-0.9011356830596924,
-0.47887182235717773,
-0.5508862137794495,
-0.6062154173851013,
-0.0416630394756794,
-0.19080273807048798,
-0.47657349705696106,
0.058070749044418335,
0.24254776537418365,
0.9766445159912109,
0.15483848750591278,
0.4286763370037079,
-1.268196702003479,
0.7770705819129944,
-0.21240292489528656,
-0.0284838005900383,
0.32027313113212585,
-0.35707607865333557,
-0.29552584886550903,
-0.20296186208724976,
-0.4268655478954315,
-0.7469858527183533,
0.2811029255390167,
-0.023992348462343216,
0.9875431060791016,
0.593578040599823,
-0.13328543305397034,
0.6010724306106567,
-0.4737265706062317,
0.7405925393104553,
0.47171396017074585,
-0.7126104235649109,
0.7897810935974121,
-0.4054209291934967,
0.48247718811035156,
0.5140561461448669,
0.029668176546692848,
-0.5662233829498291,
-0.6251097321510315,
-0.9733161330223083,
-1.0437273979187012,
0.4653579592704773,
0.08669106662273407,
-0.19211606681346893,
0.003182422835379839,
0.5477488040924072,
0.048344701528549194,
0.3157902956008911,
0.09288256615400314,
-0.47651514410972595,
0.09446067363023758,
-0.7627696394920349,
-0.07346947491168976,
-0.06389384716749191,
-0.2844102382659912,
0.017466064542531967,
0.4143228232860565,
0.18732501566410065,
0.2886439561843872,
0.5151023268699646,
-0.09475166350603104,
-0.0287874024361372,
0.2227001041173935,
0.8404444456100464,
0.7953217029571533,
0.24378740787506104,
-0.1722639501094818,
-0.16045650839805603,
-0.7441409826278687,
0.089470274746418,
0.45225319266319275,
-0.304058700799942,
0.15955497324466705,
0.7147192358970642,
0.5731468796730042,
-0.20670168101787567,
-0.9584839940071106,
0.3509597182273865,
-0.19000473618507385,
-0.16743455827236176,
-0.5483273863792419,
0.31049418449401855,
0.2734227478504181,
0.2827334702014923,
0.10907341539859772,
-0.0160068366676569,
0.2296093851327896,
-0.2912927269935608,
0.16364306211471558,
0.1528244912624359,
-0.26352909207344055,
-0.040536727756261826,
0.541069507598877,
0.22183726727962494,
-0.5527711510658264,
0.6089180111885071,
0.3102591037750244,
-0.2165074199438095,
0.9401730895042419,
0.5040958523750305,
0.7366543412208557,
-0.2953943908214569,
0.18078750371932983,
0.20059838891029358,
0.09430134296417236,
-0.3716709017753601,
0.286789208650589,
-0.3194487988948822,
-0.02343417890369892,
0.027037275955080986,
-0.604017972946167,
-0.34187957644462585,
-0.0419517420232296,
-0.6432009339332581,
0.3048727512359619,
-0.6608351469039917,
-0.21027719974517822,
-0.14346212148666382,
-0.27777430415153503,
-0.6814887523651123,
0.32228031754493713,
0.32599982619285583,
0.9196101427078247,
-0.5197532176971436,
0.4142458736896515,
0.6422617435455322,
-0.4988681375980377,
-1.154937744140625,
-0.09274448454380035,
0.1957567185163498,
-0.7346763014793396,
0.3644755780696869,
0.2020789235830307,
-0.1315506398677826,
-0.1807168573141098,
0.07494843751192093,
-0.34615400433540344,
1.4410443305969238,
0.08758842200040817,
-0.6061307191848755,
-0.03241180256009102,
0.25176531076431274,
0.9137717485427856,
-0.25541603565216064,
0.5781323313713074,
0.5694345235824585,
0.34026825428009033,
-0.23800420761108398,
-0.8140450716018677,
-0.07273397594690323,
-0.36888206005096436,
-0.0985405370593071,
0.25730568170547485,
-0.7833224534988403,
0.7529799342155457,
-0.15131211280822754,
0.0009766875300556421,
0.04447539895772934,
0.5202675461769104,
0.4773656129837036,
0.6779950857162476,
0.050427407026290894,
0.6867388486862183,
1.1111351251602173,
0.16555707156658173,
1.3080973625183105,
-0.38070443272590637,
-0.3491649627685547,
0.8557127118110657,
-0.3211013376712799,
0.4530157148838043,
0.25627079606056213,
0.19701726734638214,
0.44461381435394287,
0.31940728425979614,
0.1844259649515152,
-0.021889349445700645,
0.4746564030647278,
-0.5993944406509399,
-0.01273221056908369,
-0.22912999987602234,
-0.4430534541606903,
0.18021591007709503,
0.47347381711006165,
-0.8486979007720947,
-0.06553451716899872,
-0.1751527637243271,
0.16038787364959717,
0.07284941524267197,
-0.5760754942893982,
1.0404374599456787,
0.3046376407146454,
-1.049651861190796,
0.5181452035903931,
-0.15104295313358307,
0.23896460235118866,
-0.7415896058082581,
-0.4354936182498932,
-0.28969547152519226,
0.27038148045539856,
-0.4643697440624237,
-0.3180098235607147,
-0.15195071697235107,
0.3191961348056793,
-0.3753378093242645,
-0.25665006041526794,
0.5074985027313232,
-0.2509241998195648,
-0.6162453293800354,
0.003998106811195612,
0.4886511266231537,
0.08794057369232178,
0.07442308217287064,
-0.6639461517333984,
0.1665385216474533,
0.016694340854883194,
0.14763563871383667,
0.21690237522125244,
0.6747540235519409,
-0.11866520345211029,
0.740954577922821,
0.5322977304458618,
0.6705227494239807,
-0.017767013981938362,
0.5453855395317078,
0.9291380047798157,
-0.6519798040390015,
-0.6187191605567932,
-0.9852294921875,
0.7506871223449707,
-0.1409696340560913,
-0.47415152192115784,
0.3116989731788635,
0.714287281036377,
0.2030208557844162,
0.19254697859287262,
1.2921805381774902,
0.3646620810031891,
0.5176013708114624,
-0.5349976420402527,
0.9317860007286072,
-0.4008396863937378,
0.24532727897167206,
-0.244508758187294,
-0.4095834493637085,
-0.278573215007782,
0.21310223639011383,
0.040774229913949966,
-0.18436652421951294,
0.7732133269309998,
0.5429810285568237,
0.19630111753940582,
-0.28481578826904297,
0.08985771983861923,
-0.02888605184853077,
0.8204141855239868,
0.522855818271637,
0.7274084687232971,
-0.22804220020771027,
0.3379634916782379,
-0.28167006373405457,
-0.33656251430511475,
-0.30211499333381653,
-0.3886719346046448,
-0.8802880644798279,
-0.23863527178764343,
-0.16639384627342224,
-0.18750730156898499,
-0.022821150720119476,
0.8596386313438416,
0.2797316014766693,
-0.21797294914722443,
-0.12633253633975983,
-0.0653027594089508,
-0.05498495325446129,
-0.024993648752570152,
-0.09123552590608597,
0.6559115648269653,
-0.2978453040122986,
-0.3253619968891144,
0.06293821334838867,
0.8138731718063354,
0.22248804569244385,
-0.1007380560040474,
-0.1641424149274826,
0.3365701138973236,
-0.16495783627033234,
0.1842329502105713,
0.12076560407876968,
-0.8710896372795105,
0.47317466139793396,
-0.1342362016439438,
-0.4399684965610504,
0.22138729691505432,
1.041888952255249,
-0.42708611488342285,
0.3703469932079315,
0.5643050074577332,
0.8951609134674072,
0.17298918962478638,
0.5816143155097961,
0.4985644221305847,
0.14476324617862701,
-0.17406730353832245,
0.42784711718559265,
0.2934688627719879,
0.27648332715034485,
-0.878143310546875,
0.14789548516273499,
0.02951815165579319,
-0.6202014684677124,
-0.5670267343521118,
-0.26211243867874146,
-1.2531665563583374,
0.13853605091571808,
0.9865331649780273,
-0.08579977601766586,
-0.27088844776153564,
-0.2520959675312042,
-0.6426576972007751,
0.5348652005195618,
-0.660041868686676,
0.9322995543479919,
0.29328423738479614,
-0.7464116811752319,
0.0309683158993721,
-0.6980183720588684,
0.6663022041320801,
0.16357605159282684,
-1.2508453130722046,
0.02884877659380436,
0.5665033459663391,
-0.07735802978277206,
-0.006009605713188648,
1.1881951093673706,
-0.21802747249603271,
0.7093414664268494,
-0.21967406570911407,
-0.0276360884308815,
-0.1922863870859146,
-0.14279094338417053,
-0.4549126625061035,
0.20178546011447906,
0.11773157119750977,
-0.022212492302060127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05143v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05143v1
|
Plug and Play with Prompts: A Prompt Tuning Approach for Controlling Text Generation
| 2024-04-08T01:54:28 | 2024-04-08T01:54:28 |
Rohan Deepak Ajwani, Zining Zhu, Jonathan Rose, Frank Rudzicz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Transformer-based Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown exceptional
language generation capabilities in response to text-based prompts. However,
controlling the direction of generation via textual prompts has been
challenging, especially with smaller models. In this work, we explore the use
of Prompt Tuning to achieve controlled language generation. Generated text is
steered using prompt embeddings, which are trained using a small language
model, used as a discriminator. Moreover, we demonstrate that these prompt
embeddings can be trained with a very small dataset, with as low as a few
hundred training examples. Our method thus offers a data and parameter
efficient solution towards controlling language model outputs. We carry out
extensive evaluation on four datasets: SST-5 and Yelp (sentiment analysis),
GYAFC (formality) and JIGSAW (toxic language). Finally, we demonstrate the
efficacy of our method towards mitigating harmful, toxic, and biased text
generated by language models.
|
[
-0.328888475894928,
-0.8638424873352051,
0.6192046999931335,
0.38523218035697937,
-0.2703806459903717,
-0.0010189650347456336,
-0.3009483218193054,
0.20185503363609314,
-0.08200724422931671,
0.6367160081863403,
-0.8686856031417847,
-0.3724331557750702,
-0.2936754524707794,
0.4256962239742279,
0.02984197996556759,
1.0575915575027466,
0.17561282217502594,
-0.027540341019630432,
-0.1422615647315979,
0.22636105120182037,
-0.9406131505966187,
-0.11006047576665878,
-0.8596163392066956,
-0.2324058562517166,
0.8047931790351868,
0.5628294944763184,
0.6651842594146729,
0.7487512230873108,
0.16075032949447632,
0.21161088347434998,
-0.1522410660982132,
0.39070144295692444,
-0.4274747669696808,
0.46302515268325806,
-0.14945538341999054,
-0.5166962146759033,
0.12719079852104187,
-0.022289570420980453,
0.3386911153793335,
0.27626633644104004,
-0.0318225622177124,
-0.13155464828014374,
-0.032259199768304825,
0.23556897044181824,
-0.37060749530792236,
-0.03963516652584076,
-0.7778128981590271,
0.08805790543556213,
-0.20600152015686035,
-0.531115710735321,
-0.909285306930542,
-0.6773704886436462,
-0.36341989040374756,
-0.35999569296836853,
0.24336059391498566,
0.4174724221229553,
0.6974906325340271,
0.4192810654640198,
-0.507853627204895,
-0.6070470809936523,
-0.6054429411888123,
0.8098999857902527,
-0.7747525572776794,
0.01360541395843029,
0.20593030750751495,
0.270513117313385,
-0.3982074558734894,
-0.5147250294685364,
-0.40916669368743896,
-0.3010881543159485,
-0.2178703099489212,
0.09192245453596115,
-0.12393008917570114,
-0.08527933061122894,
0.4995553493499756,
0.0033051043283194304,
-0.5369605422019958,
0.3979756534099579,
0.09045790135860443,
-0.33996522426605225,
0.5133906602859497,
0.5110557079315186,
0.4553212821483612,
-0.4402695894241333,
-0.07704988121986389,
-0.04769580811262131,
-1.1340059041976929,
0.33938100934028625,
0.5339050889015198,
0.8414658904075623,
-0.05080664902925491,
0.6487205028533936,
0.1808866560459137,
0.6807488799095154,
0.42005932331085205,
-0.2576841413974762,
-0.2330683171749115,
-0.22811934351921082,
-0.07561087608337402,
0.005657150875777006,
1.08407461643219,
0.3822233974933624,
0.2630833685398102,
0.07460077852010727,
-0.42570313811302185,
0.2050616443157196,
0.352777898311615,
-0.802164614200592,
-0.05123518034815788,
0.014400586485862732,
-0.16656050086021423,
-0.7375796437263489,
-0.2838641405105591,
-0.7124812602996826,
-0.6585753560066223,
-0.23655040562152863,
0.24336455762386322,
-0.41796231269836426,
0.05426091328263283,
-0.16747643053531647,
-0.05538153275847435,
0.2088838368654251,
0.14745259284973145,
-1.0556082725524902,
0.039598725736141205,
0.4159891903400421,
0.7492700815200806,
-0.30179738998413086,
0.16824853420257568,
-0.9481874108314514,
-0.007603935897350311,
-0.5799979567527771,
0.5660116672515869,
-0.6830692291259766,
-0.6905176639556885,
0.43000125885009766,
0.04401537775993347,
0.04562990367412567,
-0.43106529116630554,
0.587617039680481,
-0.6248406767845154,
0.7098693251609802,
-0.26295343041419983,
-0.5096544623374939,
0.3856748044490814,
-0.1911470890045166,
-0.5477419495582581,
1.0084247589111328,
0.0144186494871974,
-0.7768958806991577,
0.4665253162384033,
-0.29689398407936096,
-0.7178018093109131,
0.10059206932783127,
-0.29447832703590393,
-0.46218812465667725,
0.23243750631809235,
0.41689884662628174,
0.41490671038627625,
-0.3057921528816223,
0.4307464063167572,
0.19450148940086365,
-0.19477809965610504,
0.14099864661693573,
-0.39217686653137207,
0.5971118211746216,
0.18613594770431519,
-0.38575929403305054,
0.35295161604881287,
-0.6175577640533447,
-0.17960643768310547,
-0.048562388867139816,
-0.3133784234523773,
-0.16837768256664276,
-0.014638097025454044,
-0.009540392085909843,
0.39872145652770996,
0.05579659715294838,
-0.3459964096546173,
0.2951909005641937,
-0.3354981541633606,
0.44842514395713806,
0.7284761071205139,
0.2645510733127594,
0.5047772526741028,
-0.3175988793373108,
0.9019067287445068,
0.17898426949977875,
-0.1509704738855362,
-0.7403940558433533,
-0.5776407122612,
-0.6876815557479858,
-0.11991323530673981,
0.2709347903728485,
0.5290898680686951,
-1.1207435131072998,
0.7289029359817505,
0.21151159703731537,
-0.4411567449569702,
-0.49697479605674744,
0.0306073110550642,
0.17211830615997314,
0.64277583360672,
0.06209432706236839,
0.32149356603622437,
-0.14452382922172546,
-0.6308048963546753,
-0.25879231095314026,
-0.0002914128126576543,
-0.3748641908168793,
0.5801893472671509,
0.10602676123380661,
0.09653016179800034,
1.1103042364120483,
-0.5014936327934265,
0.017706668004393578,
-0.37394851446151733,
0.22740694880485535,
0.3510643243789673,
0.5295266509056091,
0.3729495108127594,
-0.4424571692943573,
-0.5645354390144348,
-0.16868005692958832,
-0.40287449955940247,
-0.6781933307647705,
-0.5020419359207153,
-0.09434103220701218,
0.1607917994260788,
0.770432710647583,
-0.5445781946182251,
0.042571451514959335,
0.38409584760665894,
-0.6441336274147034,
0.4520747661590576,
-0.12538105249404907,
0.06457657366991043,
-1.0852617025375366,
-0.041979581117630005,
0.10622009634971619,
-0.5816325545310974,
-0.6151185035705566,
-0.10876566916704178,
0.27993160486221313,
-0.365310400724411,
-0.4803719222545624,
0.43055272102355957,
-0.1571350395679474,
0.49227067828178406,
-0.35489392280578613,
0.13713525235652924,
0.12451677024364471,
0.3728688955307007,
-0.08510302007198334,
1.131073236465454,
0.5584188103675842,
-0.8248900175094604,
0.18744157254695892,
0.3875320255756378,
-0.11449719965457916,
0.47919806838035583,
-0.8415784239768982,
0.04693014174699783,
-0.25049474835395813,
0.016465861350297928,
-1.1076362133026123,
-0.210013747215271,
0.24765443801879883,
-0.2549964487552643,
0.4482392966747284,
0.1778244823217392,
-0.5352569818496704,
-0.3398820757865906,
-0.21037784218788147,
-0.1464213877916336,
0.8366727828979492,
-0.6529216766357422,
0.33170583844184875,
0.11593545973300934,
-0.4666331112384796,
-0.005206650123000145,
-0.4651806354522705,
-0.13691337406635284,
-0.5436893105506897,
-0.3985532224178314,
0.24168266355991364,
-0.3073773980140686,
0.018905997276306152,
-0.47240522503852844,
0.392035573720932,
0.42041805386543274,
0.010867197997868061,
0.20958822965621948,
0.1398349106311798,
-0.1282554715871811,
0.38060280680656433,
0.6964840292930603,
-0.21778006851673126,
0.060675691813230515,
-0.033549726009368896,
0.7269749641418457,
0.44501635432243347,
-0.2248849868774414,
-0.3181443512439728,
0.3501492738723755,
0.400147020816803,
-0.2582945227622986,
0.4625347852706909,
0.4206901788711548,
0.0654686763882637,
-0.5631335973739624,
-0.16560302674770355,
-0.4042454957962036,
-0.5777653455734253,
-0.04417504742741585,
-0.14773361384868622,
-1.1554876565933228,
0.3376435935497284,
-0.29924583435058594,
0.22298669815063477,
0.31031885743141174,
0.8872114419937134,
0.053049199283123016,
1.4147789478302002,
0.7901360988616943,
0.05050644651055336,
0.5675923824310303,
0.4269910454750061,
0.20898176729679108,
-0.34112879633903503,
0.0671451985836029,
-0.6920765042304993,
-0.1968948096036911,
-0.9824249148368835,
-0.23717136681079865,
0.3158048987388611,
0.06486199796199799,
-0.3995213508605957,
0.1048569530248642,
-0.4822463393211365,
0.5328734517097473,
0.5815351009368896,
0.06091463193297386,
0.20832395553588867,
-0.14903748035430908,
-0.28496095538139343,
-0.28029441833496094,
-0.826224684715271,
-0.772148847579956,
0.5768393278121948,
0.39008042216300964,
0.8354455828666687,
-0.1590500771999359,
0.5076125860214233,
0.3310267925262451,
0.01597748138010502,
-0.6818495988845825,
0.44494616985321045,
-0.09346476197242737,
-0.37757524847984314,
-0.20988225936889648,
-0.46725931763648987,
-0.7052819132804871,
-0.1510336548089981,
-0.12246761471033096,
-0.4696753919124603,
0.017757173627614975,
0.20876216888427734,
-0.4963543117046356,
-0.003256042255088687,
-0.6576030254364014,
0.5401832461357117,
0.08792166411876678,
-0.41037169098854065,
0.13643860816955566,
-0.44352269172668457,
0.3317428231239319,
-0.10080292820930481,
0.11245676875114441,
0.04010948911309242,
-0.09776555746793747,
0.41908589005470276,
-0.275754451751709,
0.9273402690887451,
-0.2587534189224243,
-0.5393187403678894,
0.24221351742744446,
0.2941114902496338,
0.8416845798492432,
0.3389086425304413,
-0.014471725560724735,
-0.38836807012557983,
-0.4321008324623108,
-0.178878515958786,
-0.36609306931495667,
0.7797229886054993,
-0.5061713457107544,
-0.5806607007980347,
-0.11745721846818924,
-0.4885653257369995,
-0.28880009055137634,
0.27104100584983826,
0.7408153414726257,
0.44724777340888977,
-0.08870195597410202,
-0.16528728604316711,
0.8452392816543579,
-0.7759342789649963,
0.7522205114364624,
0.36801669001579285,
-0.462634801864624,
-0.3875378966331482,
0.958367109298706,
-0.24646075069904327,
0.29215481877326965,
0.20975331962108612,
0.37553903460502625,
-0.3134981393814087,
-0.10493310540914536,
-0.6979828476905823,
0.1523190438747406,
-0.3414020240306854,
-0.5459175705909729,
-0.49376925826072693,
-0.037616293877363205,
-0.3271121680736542,
-0.39966657757759094,
0.05172329396009445,
-0.19225843250751495,
-0.6900544166564941,
-0.05628998577594757,
0.5936751961708069,
0.9497193694114685,
0.2714656591415405,
0.9703468084335327,
-0.5294596552848816,
0.17087991535663605,
0.283376008272171,
0.4189143180847168,
-0.3225838243961334,
-0.4257628619670868,
-0.19350218772888184,
-0.18877871334552765,
-0.381670206785202,
-0.9010877013206482,
0.6168397665023804,
0.07767821848392487,
0.21972964704036713,
0.49529439210891724,
0.08111199736595154,
0.09391424804925919,
-0.9133642911911011,
1.2418960332870483,
0.16276077926158905,
-0.9298859238624573,
0.8455228209495544,
-0.6809560060501099,
0.5926686525344849,
0.3426431119441986,
0.31102851033210754,
-0.44628652930259705,
-0.8207038044929504,
-0.4971563518047333,
-0.6171557307243347,
0.8334717154502869,
0.05677679926156998,
0.47129395604133606,
-0.317583829164505,
0.2540561258792877,
0.32037124037742615,
0.41373738646507263,
-0.4539109766483307,
-0.11294975131750107,
-0.22156991064548492,
-0.33222612738609314,
-0.07108131051063538,
-0.263689786195755,
-0.07497773319482803,
0.02948336862027645,
0.6915938854217529,
-0.31385019421577454,
0.053354065865278244,
-0.28482484817504883,
-0.10340472310781479,
-0.36565572023391724,
0.23810821771621704,
0.6585549712181091,
0.16491957008838654,
0.2686619460582733,
0.11854664981365204,
-0.020871076732873917,
-0.2530692219734192,
0.2446557730436325,
-0.27703991532325745,
-0.8199664354324341,
0.18720419704914093,
0.16209109127521515,
1.1053862571716309,
0.07880586385726929,
-0.5072720050811768,
0.3979366421699524,
-0.27680912613868713,
0.022617807611823082,
0.21066395938396454,
0.3718931972980499,
0.07314477860927582,
0.04602592810988426,
-0.027553627267479897,
-0.07805169373750687,
-0.17927037179470062,
0.04913541302084923,
0.16210022568702698,
0.41747668385505676,
-0.5421205163002014,
-0.2241339534521103,
0.805242657661438,
0.3733518123626709,
-0.495261549949646,
0.5783673524856567,
-0.2220587432384491,
-0.1865278035402298,
0.39789140224456787,
0.9445571303367615,
0.7335805892944336,
-0.34244590997695923,
0.4921623766422272,
0.4742696285247803,
0.35604631900787354,
0.1848447471857071,
0.33539459109306335,
0.18291619420051575,
-0.6623486280441284,
-0.4740692675113678,
-0.6089478135108948,
-0.3903374969959259,
0.17436818778514862,
-0.541205644607544,
0.6077987551689148,
-0.573921799659729,
-0.19380396604537964,
-0.26226556301116943,
-0.16515497863292694,
-0.5106890797615051,
0.07903186231851578,
0.04731948301196098,
1.040388584136963,
-1.1887518167495728,
0.5323524475097656,
0.37489819526672363,
-0.30243995785713196,
-0.8155454397201538,
0.002500811591744423,
-0.09820644557476044,
-0.5020512342453003,
0.276782751083374,
0.20426855981349945,
0.135947585105896,
0.408676415681839,
-0.7706554532051086,
-0.3963218331336975,
0.841254711151123,
0.3123053014278412,
-0.7501920461654663,
0.0767972394824028,
0.22625358402729034,
0.40170684456825256,
-0.4552876353263855,
0.3616924285888672,
0.7946226000785828,
0.4363871216773987,
0.005075077060610056,
-0.4706712067127228,
0.2273736596107483,
-0.13522619009017944,
0.3162786364555359,
0.1516236960887909,
-0.48664945363998413,
0.6957064270973206,
-0.0318727046251297,
-0.37157586216926575,
-0.007153987418860197,
0.7287313342094421,
0.453553706407547,
-0.18152344226837158,
0.6007512807846069,
0.09577237814664841,
0.8164546489715576,
-0.2061292976140976,
0.9021304249763489,
-0.5873560905456543,
0.048200126737356186,
0.7862666845321655,
-0.27319857478141785,
0.31735026836395264,
0.629575252532959,
0.0916249081492424,
0.42336636781692505,
0.6810286641120911,
-0.0008072812343016267,
0.6536931395530701,
0.2868364155292511,
-0.3292587697505951,
-0.3128213882446289,
-0.5105761289596558,
-0.11380865424871445,
0.12163852900266647,
0.2824946641921997,
-0.4615330100059509,
-0.19573251903057098,
0.31711411476135254,
0.14999058842658997,
0.26253512501716614,
-0.3009934723377228,
0.9895442724227905,
0.072776660323143,
-0.680823564529419,
0.251281201839447,
-0.03208598122000694,
0.8674659729003906,
-0.7045674324035645,
0.019560202956199646,
-0.41361135244369507,
-0.25868454575538635,
0.07688788324594498,
-0.5958419442176819,
0.04057472199201584,
0.261528879404068,
-0.28233984112739563,
-0.5834609866142273,
0.7920627593994141,
-0.4872587025165558,
-0.5295521020889282,
-0.21986089646816254,
0.5593132376670837,
-0.3260481357574463,
0.29370805621147156,
-0.2084205150604248,
-0.008068275637924671,
0.1050223633646965,
-0.4603796899318695,
0.1675538718700409,
0.7650967836380005,
-0.11795739829540253,
0.3488803207874298,
0.5655398964881897,
0.2360173463821411,
0.06384598463773727,
0.25230756402015686,
1.028296709060669,
-0.7164384722709656,
-0.7291176319122314,
-0.8546475172042847,
0.7177104353904724,
0.11758885532617569,
-0.4612850844860077,
0.7247540354728699,
0.28968051075935364,
0.35342299938201904,
-0.2756849527359009,
0.888187825679779,
-0.13403849303722382,
0.625404417514801,
-0.6277762055397034,
0.7229435443878174,
-0.27040114998817444,
0.1827128678560257,
-0.22679708898067474,
-0.6810578107833862,
-0.3245909512042999,
0.41831082105636597,
-0.09771084040403366,
-0.020500296726822853,
0.5021346807479858,
1.1156240701675415,
0.12422550469636917,
0.009947117418050766,
0.36319631338119507,
0.07443167269229889,
0.6726723313331604,
0.18093076348304749,
0.9132336378097534,
0.052905574440956116,
0.18604925274848938,
-0.11962031573057175,
-0.2989051938056946,
0.029900722205638885,
-1.2074471712112427,
-1.0162875652313232,
-0.37555909156799316,
-0.09875855594873428,
-0.3912091851234436,
-0.3271385729312897,
0.9210379719734192,
0.2834666073322296,
-0.9867174029350281,
-0.07366764545440674,
-0.4191373586654663,
0.2046770453453064,
0.007721406873315573,
-0.2743322253227234,
0.11621710658073425,
-0.8810095191001892,
-0.6869614124298096,
0.5578566193580627,
0.1328987330198288,
0.0023218421265482903,
-0.4866112172603607,
-0.014942956157028675,
0.23304350674152374,
0.41321584582328796,
0.607265055179596,
-0.12858830392360687,
-0.48013702034950256,
-0.3458927571773529,
0.2908213436603546,
-0.3479859232902527,
-0.07333355396986008,
1.1634622812271118,
-0.850297749042511,
0.30738699436187744,
0.5760807394981384,
0.3855219781398773,
0.011690731160342693,
-0.06385196000337601,
0.9901837110519409,
-1.1586966514587402,
0.062030065804719925,
0.17233046889305115,
0.1304592341184616,
0.38067659735679626,
-0.6072065234184265,
-0.023821843788027763,
-0.1666797250509262,
-0.6992361545562744,
-0.7251795530319214,
0.4884197413921356,
-0.5815083384513855,
-0.11999876797199249,
1.2258599996566772,
0.10513956844806671,
-0.06202895566821098,
0.13665466010570526,
-0.6330755949020386,
0.44345757365226746,
-0.523935854434967,
0.7165848016738892,
0.35554438829421997,
-0.009937322698533535,
-0.263414204120636,
-0.32972127199172974,
0.9357106685638428,
0.20130005478858948,
-0.8276499509811401,
0.26184704899787903,
0.6153346300125122,
-0.06732328236103058,
0.08073166012763977,
0.37436193227767944,
0.12752757966518402,
-0.00724040949717164,
-0.26079607009887695,
-0.10712814331054688,
-0.0716942772269249,
-0.46894514560699463,
-0.7853445410728455,
0.06798951327800751,
0.11480148881673813,
0.18395192921161652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05133v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05133v1
|
EcoVerse: An Annotated Twitter Dataset for Eco-Relevance Classification, Environmental Impact Analysis, and Stance Detection
| 2024-04-08T01:21:11 | 2024-04-08T01:21:11 |
Francesca Grasso, Stefano Locci, Giovanni Siragusa, Luigi Di Caro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Anthropogenic ecological crisis constitutes a significant challenge that all
within the academy must urgently face, including the Natural Language
Processing (NLP) community. While recent years have seen increasing work
revolving around climate-centric discourse, crucial environmental and
ecological topics outside of climate change remain largely unaddressed, despite
their prominent importance. Mainstream NLP tasks, such as sentiment analysis,
dominate the scene, but there remains an untouched space in the literature
involving the analysis of environmental impacts of certain events and
practices. To address this gap, this paper presents EcoVerse, an annotated
English Twitter dataset of 3,023 tweets spanning a wide spectrum of
environmental topics. We propose a three-level annotation scheme designed for
Eco-Relevance Classification, Stance Detection, and introducing an original
approach for Environmental Impact Analysis. We detail the data collection,
filtering, and labeling process that led to the creation of the dataset.
Remarkable Inter-Annotator Agreement indicates that the annotation scheme
produces consistent annotations of high quality. Subsequent classification
experiments using BERT-based models, including ClimateBERT, are presented.
These yield encouraging results, while also indicating room for a model
specifically tailored for environmental texts. The dataset is made freely
available to stimulate further research.
|
[
-0.6987669467926025,
-0.6438125371932983,
0.37459173798561096,
0.27896055579185486,
-0.274259090423584,
0.07902437448501587,
-0.22708621621131897,
-0.6437663435935974,
0.47394511103630066,
0.5673455595970154,
-0.7822789549827576,
-0.6159341335296631,
-0.7551835775375366,
0.404052197933197,
-0.33890432119369507,
1.117252230644226,
0.4219958782196045,
-0.3453400135040283,
0.056009866297245026,
-0.5273280143737793,
-0.21837562322616577,
-0.10653569549322128,
-0.5161911249160767,
0.15241843461990356,
0.832187831401825,
0.14135323464870453,
0.6595785617828369,
0.33596768975257874,
0.497219055891037,
0.26036813855171204,
-0.3953908085823059,
0.020654896274209023,
-0.49746716022491455,
0.13315895199775696,
-0.43206509947776794,
0.15922126173973083,
-0.2143164873123169,
0.1988528072834015,
0.5009799599647522,
0.7097821235656738,
0.06076658144593239,
0.40243616700172424,
0.228429913520813,
0.13075034320354462,
-0.5995941758155823,
0.22463661432266235,
-0.6347256302833557,
0.035909634083509445,
-0.0686035305261612,
-0.404190331697464,
-0.17965067923069,
-0.14212475717067719,
-0.046156302094459534,
-0.8421574831008911,
0.09228270500898361,
0.2087213099002838,
0.7408168911933899,
0.42304661870002747,
-0.11789558082818985,
-0.08808308094739914,
-0.6020477414131165,
0.931129515171051,
-0.5025071501731873,
0.2631990909576416,
0.16059914231300354,
-0.04896398261189461,
0.07484354078769684,
-0.3866916596889496,
-0.8329556584358215,
0.7593914270401001,
0.11478646844625473,
0.38285255432128906,
-0.3341690003871918,
-0.0729411169886589,
0.011876282282173634,
0.06728871166706085,
-0.23658643662929535,
0.18183811008930206,
-0.13457921147346497,
-0.05171830952167511,
0.4704122841358185,
-0.0442672073841095,
0.2736711800098419,
-0.8499309420585632,
-0.2944730818271637,
-0.14597420394420624,
-0.5441918969154358,
0.14625833928585052,
0.4860902428627014,
0.784146785736084,
0.08836610615253448,
0.4242267608642578,
-0.07414355129003525,
0.45216017961502075,
-0.5523784756660461,
0.19362832605838776,
-0.002390788635239005,
-0.1412525475025177,
-0.18017040193080902,
-0.20258505642414093,
0.6865290999412537,
0.7449109554290771,
-0.2135011851787567,
0.1641930341720581,
-0.2862662374973297,
-0.2881772220134735,
0.1646355390548706,
-0.5898603796958923,
-0.3322960436344147,
0.48252081871032715,
-0.3602970838546753,
-0.3949223756790161,
0.29326310753822327,
-1.2318336963653564,
-0.6236511468887329,
-0.6049149632453918,
0.17573441565036774,
-0.02649281919002533,
-0.4107918441295624,
-0.12620626389980316,
-0.40991902351379395,
0.14593131840229034,
0.57218337059021,
-0.3854323923587799,
0.00522632198408246,
1.1536335945129395,
0.9647659659385681,
0.5342955589294434,
0.06338932365179062,
-0.10417488217353821,
0.06616012752056122,
-0.10512930899858475,
1.2039165496826172,
-0.7528356909751892,
-0.30299487709999084,
0.2032885104417801,
0.182487353682518,
0.19176475703716278,
0.008311988785862923,
0.6051955223083496,
-0.2896497845649719,
0.04924402013421059,
-0.6111955642700195,
-0.48883089423179626,
-0.49833256006240845,
0.17595385015010834,
-0.8550021648406982,
0.7834892868995667,
-0.13113726675510406,
-1.2395877838134766,
0.6544264554977417,
-0.9718818068504333,
-0.2977813482284546,
0.43425852060317993,
0.07039950042963028,
-0.24600404500961304,
-0.1971815824508667,
0.3007850646972656,
0.48249518871307373,
0.049595899879932404,
0.16408997774124146,
-0.7868419885635376,
0.03392159193754196,
-0.28255754709243774,
-0.11592308431863785,
1.4013599157333374,
0.12539342045783997,
-0.061933740973472595,
-0.19763091206550598,
-0.506784975528717,
-0.082682304084301,
-0.0947640985250473,
-0.11492075771093369,
-0.4781590700149536,
0.3429422974586487,
0.628674328327179,
0.12075348198413849,
0.10402143746614456,
-0.8374608755111694,
-0.07333376258611679,
-0.07024523615837097,
0.7578805685043335,
0.9745726585388184,
0.32592058181762695,
0.05987202003598213,
-0.2975074350833893,
0.20517320930957794,
-0.371969610452652,
0.21231117844581604,
-0.13696962594985962,
-0.7983244061470032,
-0.4101867377758026,
-0.31601494550704956,
0.022387808188796043,
0.7197047472000122,
-0.3710426986217499,
0.6980406641960144,
-0.4630983769893646,
-0.3073079288005829,
-0.4779953062534332,
-0.00046552723506465554,
-0.39396408200263977,
0.3323463797569275,
0.4753343164920807,
0.40298202633857727,
-0.8673855662345886,
-0.8055431246757507,
-0.421274870634079,
-0.2644539177417755,
-0.005496330559253693,
0.23799529671669006,
0.7058244943618774,
-0.3732593357563019,
1.364687204360962,
-0.3058479428291321,
-0.26458293199539185,
-0.08469196408987045,
0.5719332695007324,
0.17673078179359436,
0.3076114058494568,
0.6943454146385193,
-0.8382089138031006,
-0.17696084082126617,
0.053966861218214035,
-0.5830131769180298,
-0.288768470287323,
0.09407912194728851,
-0.3021344840526581,
0.05137595534324646,
0.1859569549560547,
-0.35880088806152344,
0.2628127634525299,
0.3445463180541992,
-0.10715610533952713,
-0.0695008784532547,
0.26574191451072693,
0.16449178755283356,
-1.0729026794433594,
0.30889466404914856,
0.2832026779651642,
-0.2902246117591858,
-0.4350222945213318,
-0.10900737345218658,
-0.3240717053413391,
-0.14846836030483246,
-0.24691134691238403,
0.5266004800796509,
0.24132928252220154,
0.08485449105501175,
-0.15615782141685486,
0.07214982062578201,
0.15187835693359375,
-0.0035300764720886946,
0.31190359592437744,
0.05424949526786804,
0.18946070969104767,
-0.17578217387199402,
0.14973460137844086,
0.5964705944061279,
0.15457481145858765,
0.6544569134712219,
-0.2313854694366455,
0.13907532393932343,
-0.3818560242652893,
0.5727088451385498,
-0.890102744102478,
-0.29027897119522095,
0.14195886254310608,
-0.24544212222099304,
-0.08263611793518066,
-0.30797988176345825,
-0.8790133595466614,
-0.43075284361839294,
-0.5660657286643982,
-0.22967368364334106,
0.27444136142730713,
-0.6924702525138855,
0.5843423008918762,
0.581669807434082,
-0.5115078687667847,
-0.42880284786224365,
-0.44406506419181824,
0.42338842153549194,
-0.40816766023635864,
-0.3589373528957367,
-0.16057999432086945,
0.2757802903652191,
-0.4245390295982361,
0.22855988144874573,
-0.05155300348997116,
0.12206142395734787,
0.4184471666812897,
0.27291393280029297,
0.0017712039407342672,
0.13617271184921265,
0.06283571571111679,
0.025798488408327103,
0.1380014568567276,
0.3617999255657196,
-0.5161266326904297,
0.08277775347232819,
-0.16493594646453857,
0.4000929296016693,
-0.14258697628974915,
0.6223176717758179,
0.2634069621562958,
0.0379253625869751,
0.8131915926933289,
0.5491188764572144,
-0.9605279564857483,
-0.44863924384117126,
-0.14053168892860413,
0.1557527333498001,
-0.4146861433982849,
0.09762614965438843,
0.379238098859787,
-0.7386227250099182,
0.5124555826187134,
-0.03939006105065346,
0.6659879684448242,
0.8052659630775452,
0.18202738463878632,
-0.681401789188385,
0.569492757320404,
0.8794425129890442,
-0.035278160125017166,
0.44101905822753906,
-0.5232411026954651,
0.4835267663002014,
-0.792993426322937,
-0.07517717778682709,
-0.5587747097015381,
-0.18960101902484894,
-0.7631538510322571,
-0.31310731172561646,
-0.022212501615285873,
-0.12794484198093414,
-0.4603487551212311,
0.36581337451934814,
-0.5546629428863525,
0.39510807394981384,
0.2802129089832306,
0.10699997842311859,
0.02872934751212597,
-0.12947624921798706,
0.41827163100242615,
-0.07635360956192017,
-0.35741329193115234,
-1.048822045326233,
0.6133924722671509,
0.30592215061187744,
0.16895756125450134,
0.25442489981651306,
0.6521955132484436,
0.6687526106834412,
0.8597808480262756,
-0.6101770997047424,
0.5895071029663086,
-0.2107239067554474,
-0.5742496848106384,
-0.419269323348999,
-0.32711875438690186,
-0.7953320741653442,
0.09254709631204605,
-0.2926042973995209,
-0.809884250164032,
0.35913315415382385,
-0.16289983689785004,
-0.548763632774353,
0.5187151432037354,
-0.30680739879608154,
0.7126797437667847,
0.14866918325424194,
-0.38873064517974854,
-0.1254781037569046,
-0.7030828595161438,
-0.012118304148316383,
-0.2162795215845108,
0.7811384797096252,
-0.39474183320999146,
-0.2672196626663208,
0.7752731442451477,
-0.3992163836956024,
1.1821727752685547,
-0.412962406873703,
-0.18058185279369354,
0.2996816337108612,
-0.14748696982860565,
0.2443036139011383,
0.385165810585022,
-0.01945948228240013,
0.27072542905807495,
-0.17115949094295502,
-0.3778010606765747,
-0.015322854742407799,
0.633858323097229,
-0.7448071241378784,
-0.5166598558425903,
-0.4106995761394501,
-0.26076024770736694,
-0.29047033190727234,
0.16529075801372528,
0.1103481650352478,
0.17077231407165527,
-0.24868720769882202,
0.0594397634267807,
0.40425315499305725,
-0.4266144633293152,
0.6673314571380615,
0.22198434174060822,
-0.22470687329769135,
-0.6014304161071777,
0.9663221836090088,
0.423077791929245,
-0.22212566435337067,
0.5201897025108337,
0.43825197219848633,
-0.22958789765834808,
-0.25605902075767517,
0.04085199162364006,
-0.24720899760723114,
-1.1267000436782837,
-0.6062918305397034,
-1.103129267692566,
-0.05566433072090149,
-0.36216509342193604,
-0.42776963114738464,
-0.033888932317495346,
-0.2429766058921814,
-0.2774057984352112,
-0.49036696553230286,
0.8867087364196777,
0.9676893949508667,
-0.4553319215774536,
0.11373909562826157,
-0.5629106760025024,
0.03062278777360916,
0.16251787543296814,
0.28982946276664734,
-0.23894859850406647,
0.045865368098020554,
-0.16318412125110626,
0.1850888431072235,
-0.3271361291408539,
-0.7168096303939819,
0.5682387948036194,
0.4394359290599823,
0.214882031083107,
0.5115766525268555,
0.28752443194389343,
0.4351445138454437,
-0.24652086198329926,
0.8021490573883057,
-0.10753921419382095,
-1.0037771463394165,
0.7552493810653687,
-0.8116785287857056,
-0.04734405502676964,
0.498136430978775,
0.40168094635009766,
-0.5170851945877075,
-0.7527554631233215,
-0.8052585124969482,
-1.2356735467910767,
0.6534835696220398,
0.3667748272418976,
0.10056595504283905,
-0.31784987449645996,
-0.06288313865661621,
0.41798636317253113,
0.30475756525993347,
-0.3793126940727234,
0.0826299637556076,
-0.6154156923294067,
-0.11935563385486603,
-0.1528763622045517,
0.1904195249080658,
-0.2925581634044647,
-0.33279407024383545,
0.5111624002456665,
-0.10355966538190842,
0.25516802072525024,
0.2191706895828247,
0.06011457368731499,
-0.18424931168556213,
0.15535323321819305,
0.1882539838552475,
0.24464671313762665,
-0.6213473081588745,
0.14521414041519165,
0.0003097285225521773,
-0.5066635608673096,
-0.19460342824459076,
0.3015618920326233,
-0.19359777867794037,
0.049422651529312134,
0.5111053586006165,
0.4215841591358185,
0.3109513819217682,
-0.47382134199142456,
0.268134742975235,
0.2020060122013092,
-0.11415041983127594,
-0.4265710413455963,
-0.447800874710083,
0.10332925617694855,
0.011860756203532219,
0.5558018684387207,
0.36287349462509155,
0.6140729188919067,
-0.4817540645599365,
0.27168747782707214,
0.11380992829799652,
-0.12964089214801788,
-0.46125754714012146,
0.7904220223426819,
0.4834834635257721,
-0.11758191883563995,
0.6211130619049072,
-0.22228874266147614,
-0.9287506937980652,
0.7384315729141235,
0.032589882612228394,
1.0297605991363525,
0.22396482527256012,
0.3582962453365326,
0.6370954513549805,
0.3647423982620239,
0.12461717426776886,
0.5145702362060547,
0.08175195008516312,
-0.7915492057800293,
-0.36588433384895325,
-0.8199731111526489,
-0.6447569131851196,
0.12459394335746765,
-0.6661216020584106,
0.17907311022281647,
-0.8651446104049683,
-0.28488489985466003,
0.32194966077804565,
0.1344670057296753,
-0.8154413104057312,
0.21837501227855682,
0.36895719170570374,
0.7465653419494629,
-1.2313836812973022,
0.23950281739234924,
0.9927785396575928,
-0.1953912079334259,
-0.3826940059661865,
0.2917904555797577,
0.1977975070476532,
-0.3214494287967682,
0.43233707547187805,
0.6840701103210449,
-0.027082588523626328,
0.1388205736875534,
-1.0034070014953613,
-0.6372331380844116,
0.9172714352607727,
0.019388698041439056,
-0.3058244287967682,
0.7024471759796143,
0.06208958104252815,
0.6269351243972778,
-0.33873629570007324,
0.05508807674050331,
0.4277339279651642,
0.9186582565307617,
-0.2647086977958679,
-0.3998388946056366,
-0.05132727324962616,
-0.5473276972770691,
-0.09385375678539276,
0.2511707544326782,
-0.8047125339508057,
0.535291314125061,
0.0578816719353199,
-0.36340558528900146,
-0.36206117272377014,
0.4986000061035156,
0.09150068461894989,
0.3121543526649475,
0.7251256108283997,
0.6733419895172119,
0.8752275705337524,
-0.2611920237541199,
1.0825488567352295,
-0.2340971976518631,
0.8129281997680664,
0.6880099773406982,
-0.41748639941215515,
1.1849439144134521,
0.45838889479637146,
-0.25549209117889404,
0.20763801038265228,
0.9492813944816589,
0.02229277417063713,
0.5953972935676575,
0.1299278736114502,
-0.2317637950181961,
-0.3658919930458069,
-0.4646984338760376,
0.24490392208099365,
0.11011654138565063,
0.7002299427986145,
0.20188550651073456,
-0.3819999694824219,
0.16410109400749207,
0.040497686713933945,
-0.042373817414045334,
-0.40500232577323914,
0.6354370713233948,
0.11736949533224106,
-0.18806329369544983,
-0.3369276821613312,
-0.31116414070129395,
0.6128787398338318,
0.07600808888673782,
-0.2922998368740082,
-0.018793683499097824,
-0.2635190784931183,
-0.43835484981536865,
-1.2379131317138672,
0.6417970061302185,
0.01988740637898445,
0.006697566714137793,
-0.6248024702072144,
0.33480873703956604,
-0.11138985306024551,
-0.5107975602149963,
0.45941266417503357,
0.25524675846099854,
-0.10179409384727478,
0.04971059039235115,
-0.6156479716300964,
-0.11406824737787247,
-0.2583714723587036,
-0.35999709367752075,
-0.1491817831993103,
0.7482321858406067,
0.1159469485282898,
0.3489992022514343,
0.5695907473564148,
-0.32108253240585327,
-0.08737911283969879,
0.04174109175801277,
0.7873892188072205,
-0.5848775506019592,
-0.5433308482170105,
-0.571290910243988,
0.3977281153202057,
-0.3471890389919281,
-0.4287104308605194,
0.6718863248825073,
0.48336052894592285,
0.5697155594825745,
0.22876445949077606,
1.2645680904388428,
-0.49372950196266174,
0.6026310324668884,
-0.02326185815036297,
0.5359900593757629,
-0.5160337686538696,
0.41743943095207214,
-0.27086958289146423,
-0.8398917317390442,
-0.39213842153549194,
0.681913435459137,
-0.21813254058361053,
0.01591305248439312,
0.2939004898071289,
0.2189505398273468,
0.1572561264038086,
0.5831191539764404,
-0.07625553756952286,
0.2900960147380829,
0.44985413551330566,
0.14252880215644836,
0.8730132579803467,
-0.04055766388773918,
0.16609932482242584,
-0.4668772518634796,
-0.029303353279829025,
-0.2998298704624176,
-1.2505664825439453,
-0.6528545618057251,
-0.5860344171524048,
-0.4719879627227783,
-0.3091045320034027,
0.0056752776727080345,
1.1272534132003784,
0.2338746041059494,
-0.8505197763442993,
0.3271513283252716,
-0.254985511302948,
0.011007843539118767,
-0.2230587601661682,
-0.2843247652053833,
0.5413679480552673,
-0.08662817627191544,
-0.6923365592956543,
-0.09736321121454239,
0.4965343475341797,
-0.16941165924072266,
-0.2681541442871094,
0.3562975823879242,
-0.3157826066017151,
0.3172725439071655,
0.5107424259185791,
0.3469531536102295,
-0.7154397368431091,
-0.7920773029327393,
-0.06462360918521881,
0.15358318388462067,
-0.10774753242731094,
0.3516516089439392,
-0.5737488269805908,
0.16258472204208374,
0.46104931831359863,
0.5587977170944214,
-0.30752938985824585,
-0.04830818995833397,
0.3991391360759735,
-0.8237162232398987,
-0.07718603312969208,
0.5820325016975403,
0.5600343942642212,
0.6484588980674744,
-0.5103879570960999,
0.5770549774169922,
0.3408225178718567,
-0.48798948526382446,
-0.8470858931541443,
-0.365779310464859,
-1.085494041442871,
-0.3509005904197693,
1.1804277896881104,
-0.07322560250759125,
-0.3289717733860016,
-0.37609970569610596,
0.020104359835386276,
0.024934418499469757,
-0.6686887145042419,
0.6813526153564453,
0.9305896759033203,
0.11478361487388611,
-0.18300579488277435,
-0.6989231109619141,
0.2113950401544571,
-0.00428762985393405,
-0.7860190272331238,
0.2957497537136078,
0.34427395462989807,
0.1291329264640808,
0.31137216091156006,
0.23108838498592377,
0.34419485926628113,
-0.04951111599802971,
-0.07528740167617798,
0.3307633697986603,
0.3518778681755066,
-0.14633184671401978,
-0.07095862179994583,
-0.021696696057915688,
-0.35384079813957214,
0.07935161888599396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08680v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08680v1
|
Automating Research Synthesis with Domain-Specific Large Language Model Fine-Tuning
| 2024-04-08T00:08:29 | 2024-04-08T00:08:29 |
Teo Susnjak, Peter Hwang, Napoleon H. Reyes, Andre L. C. Barczak, Timothy R. McIntosh, Surangika Ranathunga
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.IR
|
This research pioneers the use of fine-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) to
automate Systematic Literature Reviews (SLRs), presenting a significant and
novel contribution in integrating AI to enhance academic research
methodologies. Our study employed the latest fine-tuning methodologies together
with open-sourced LLMs, and demonstrated a practical and efficient approach to
automating the final execution stages of an SLR process that involves knowledge
synthesis. The results maintained high fidelity in factual accuracy in LLM
responses, and were validated through the replication of an existing
PRISMA-conforming SLR. Our research proposed solutions for mitigating LLM
hallucination and proposed mechanisms for tracking LLM responses to their
sources of information, thus demonstrating how this approach can meet the
rigorous demands of scholarly research. The findings ultimately confirmed the
potential of fine-tuned LLMs in streamlining various labor-intensive processes
of conducting literature reviews. Given the potential of this approach and its
applicability across all research domains, this foundational study also
advocated for updating PRISMA reporting guidelines to incorporate AI-driven
processes, ensuring methodological transparency and reliability in future SLRs.
This study broadens the appeal of AI-enhanced tools across various academic and
research fields, setting a new standard for conducting comprehensive and
accurate literature reviews with more efficiency in the face of ever-increasing
volumes of academic studies.
|
[
-0.4673345983028412,
-0.7124651670455933,
0.46214404702186584,
-0.01045970432460308,
-0.02940463088452816,
0.07623349130153656,
-0.24783509969711304,
-0.534184992313385,
0.06166193634271622,
0.6459497213363647,
-0.3665885925292969,
-0.5381651520729065,
-0.1686072200536728,
0.2818642556667328,
-0.5301050543785095,
1.1641632318496704,
-0.2981484830379486,
0.3594290614128113,
0.15301020443439484,
-0.04638977721333504,
-0.14817075431346893,
-0.30450060963630676,
-0.3713602125644684,
-0.5874305963516235,
0.6753735542297363,
0.10347756743431091,
0.6977248787879944,
0.31120529770851135,
0.7969930171966553,
0.28923386335372925,
0.05758392810821533,
0.5866305232048035,
-0.563843846321106,
0.2787622809410095,
-0.28006285429000854,
-0.32485753297805786,
-0.7688348293304443,
-0.08148384839296341,
0.6062280535697937,
0.6677650213241577,
-0.009465486742556095,
0.3520749807357788,
0.3798120319843292,
0.9599416255950928,
-0.4920355975627899,
0.11665928363800049,
-0.925086259841919,
0.12329765409231186,
0.0077167097479105,
-0.5228139758110046,
-0.40477755665779114,
-0.410399854183197,
0.1045893132686615,
-0.7123769521713257,
0.2816503345966339,
0.32104820013046265,
0.8028829097747803,
0.3959069550037384,
0.06616493314504623,
-0.42079025506973267,
-1.1643179655075073,
0.8034990429878235,
-0.9212751984596252,
-0.058353882282972336,
0.07045203447341919,
0.17903777956962585,
-0.20529745519161224,
-0.6619186401367188,
-0.47580379247665405,
-0.22920621931552887,
-0.27979186177253723,
-0.1476719230413437,
0.10841426253318787,
0.17417162656784058,
0.21860922873020172,
0.4126032292842865,
-0.5008434653282166,
0.039997272193431854,
-0.5483084321022034,
-0.09677261859178543,
0.7973361611366272,
0.5161006450653076,
0.09566036611795425,
0.10274030268192291,
0.13687890768051147,
0.23122957348823547,
-0.8042458295822144,
-0.22276045382022858,
0.12641975283622742,
0.28491613268852234,
0.5112301111221313,
0.7757996916770935,
-0.4683506488800049,
0.5504820942878723,
0.02198537066578865,
0.03475925698876381,
0.13875383138656616,
-0.5790488123893738,
-0.453097939491272,
-0.06493689119815826,
0.8322417140007019,
0.5021212100982666,
0.275192528963089,
-0.1439439356327057,
-0.6252228021621704,
0.02259720116853714,
0.3603951930999756,
-0.8216517567634583,
-0.04579094052314758,
0.19736972451210022,
-0.38593196868896484,
-0.3497830331325531,
-0.19000127911567688,
-0.5822955369949341,
-0.38013434410095215,
-0.8624691367149353,
0.46942201256752014,
-0.26836860179901123,
0.002471372252330184,
0.3862000107765198,
0.22388319671154022,
0.3236415386199951,
0.5761476159095764,
-0.6153508424758911,
0.36994099617004395,
0.7706079483032227,
0.8737120032310486,
-0.3688241243362427,
-0.27568647265434265,
-0.2725692689418793,
0.2574807107448578,
-0.5725728869438171,
0.6777472496032715,
-0.401644229888916,
-0.16403214633464813,
0.20263224840164185,
-0.060965582728385925,
0.08555684238672256,
-0.4804081916809082,
0.3747868835926056,
-0.6832076907157898,
0.13771313428878784,
-0.05461251363158226,
-0.479235976934433,
-0.0573493167757988,
0.36184680461883545,
-0.48075228929519653,
0.8159340620040894,
-0.05104523524641991,
-0.65096515417099,
0.18539956212043762,
-0.5035592317581177,
-0.4030429422855377,
-0.06616660207509995,
-0.03904382511973381,
-0.5498051047325134,
0.14775334298610687,
0.2355939745903015,
0.3262630105018616,
-0.5809824466705322,
0.46019551157951355,
-0.2613540291786194,
-0.3873775005340576,
0.27694588899612427,
-0.11164078861474991,
0.4954494833946228,
0.36064255237579346,
-0.5245854258537292,
0.39107292890548706,
-0.6513532996177673,
0.12772540748119354,
-0.06465191394090652,
-0.013081394135951996,
-0.34815168380737305,
-0.04750446602702141,
0.2887539565563202,
-0.09602000564336777,
0.13721507787704468,
-0.19449317455291748,
0.2593306005001068,
-0.6618525385856628,
0.4954962432384491,
0.5333976745605469,
0.12626811861991882,
0.6133292317390442,
-0.5323059558868408,
0.3476065397262573,
-0.40206390619277954,
0.24193458259105682,
-0.14223094284534454,
0.009950640611350536,
-0.9289805889129639,
-0.0029271570965647697,
0.43871569633483887,
0.378548264503479,
-0.44179680943489075,
0.6156430244445801,
-0.11153760552406311,
-0.5629160404205322,
-0.7499768733978271,
0.07944367080926895,
0.25903838872909546,
0.2773042619228363,
0.17753027379512787,
-0.4444875717163086,
-0.47903239727020264,
-0.7461568117141724,
-0.3222496211528778,
-0.03475083410739899,
-0.022757798433303833,
0.2554573118686676,
0.6263993978500366,
-0.246857687830925,
0.9026491641998291,
-0.42811697721481323,
-0.8932054042816162,
-0.13109995424747467,
0.27444976568222046,
0.051871418952941895,
0.37505021691322327,
0.3123786151409149,
-0.45267367362976074,
-0.5682533383369446,
0.2018795609474182,
-0.7975540161132812,
-0.2526744306087494,
-0.3876939117908478,
-0.041646141558885574,
0.3855193555355072,
0.8146648406982422,
-0.5452221035957336,
0.36308813095092773,
0.0009108741069212556,
0.0006391055067069829,
0.6073911190032959,
-0.13259269297122955,
0.27858269214630127,
-0.6285563111305237,
0.38595208525657654,
-0.15459927916526794,
0.07899714261293411,
-0.5174816846847534,
0.1262420266866684,
-0.19909346103668213,
0.05205288529396057,
-0.11301741003990173,
0.43271684646606445,
-0.676179826259613,
-0.06941169500350952,
-0.40574127435684204,
0.13874472677707672,
0.07449647784233093,
0.17941179871559143,
-0.1842910498380661,
0.7898438572883606,
0.36513906717300415,
-0.6425017714500427,
-0.06908164918422699,
0.2500004470348358,
-0.46098196506500244,
0.1843753457069397,
-0.8453410863876343,
-0.09674456715583801,
-0.13639922440052032,
0.22602881491184235,
-0.6378269791603088,
-0.2588340938091278,
0.2041088193655014,
-0.34489578008651733,
0.15666627883911133,
0.06871398538351059,
-0.6598461270332336,
0.011518417857587337,
-0.3801296055316925,
0.19212594628334045,
0.3592027425765991,
-0.020701587200164795,
0.7917944192886353,
0.5476759672164917,
-0.4961565136909485,
-0.3552725315093994,
-0.5709997415542603,
0.32946306467056274,
-0.019510453566908836,
-0.38777875900268555,
0.41568025946617126,
-0.2849363088607788,
-0.5114599466323853,
-0.20596668124198914,
0.14783090353012085,
0.0653235912322998,
-0.04554587975144386,
-0.013972396962344646,
0.37499821186065674,
-0.21698735654354095,
-0.1464824080467224,
0.12319814413785934,
0.11197514832019806,
0.28608864545822144,
-0.22132842242717743,
0.3538092374801636,
-0.09011392295360565,
-0.45915061235427856,
-0.4834270179271698,
-0.006548471748828888,
0.9392814040184021,
-0.29586270451545715,
0.21833164989948273,
0.5994834303855896,
-0.206792950630188,
-0.5159003734588623,
-0.6135571599006653,
-0.5471344590187073,
-0.47258272767066956,
0.08910931646823883,
-0.17291323840618134,
-1.0000054836273193,
0.48282164335250854,
-0.06740263849496841,
0.45169344544410706,
0.3298298120498657,
0.7581912875175476,
0.14861556887626648,
1.0570921897888184,
0.4723395109176636,
-0.1736840009689331,
0.4033571183681488,
-0.1779627650976181,
0.450260728597641,
-0.956574559211731,
-0.022186636924743652,
-0.7424163818359375,
-0.3360947370529175,
-0.5461862087249756,
-0.43176111578941345,
0.7441413402557373,
-0.2213701754808426,
-0.06207810342311859,
-0.34222686290740967,
-0.8050201535224915,
0.5633537769317627,
0.26757606863975525,
-0.15416114032268524,
0.6150854825973511,
0.16261465847492218,
-0.061354368925094604,
0.002190549857914448,
-0.5334515571594238,
-0.660938560962677,
1.1523492336273193,
0.29759079217910767,
1.0499869585037231,
-0.4250934422016144,
0.5394946336746216,
0.3411632776260376,
0.38981491327285767,
-0.6739194393157959,
0.6305010318756104,
0.20418718457221985,
-0.6529555320739746,
-0.593315064907074,
0.005440798122435808,
-0.797330915927887,
0.347812294960022,
-0.0913650244474411,
-0.24302837252616882,
-0.07480143010616302,
0.063151054084301,
-0.3902108669281006,
0.11376237124204636,
-0.2487277239561081,
0.23721271753311157,
-0.08156415820121765,
-0.5347899794578552,
-0.5188553929328918,
-0.5456595420837402,
0.4762910306453705,
-0.19546213746070862,
0.18146194517612457,
-0.10118813812732697,
0.14634256064891815,
0.4361187517642975,
-0.25124478340148926,
0.9763070940971375,
0.054610662162303925,
-0.23800235986709595,
0.12972529232501984,
0.35819244384765625,
0.5152646899223328,
0.2101220041513443,
-0.08553384989500046,
-0.0053381724283099174,
-0.0771351307630539,
0.007028663996607065,
-0.29318639636039734,
0.8392618298530579,
-0.6707351207733154,
-0.7301375865936279,
-0.5757638812065125,
-0.8460083603858948,
-0.2651470899581909,
0.43180617690086365,
-0.07612713426351547,
0.20203618705272675,
-0.33129438757896423,
0.07545887678861618,
0.9876953363418579,
-0.22725136578083038,
0.10529115796089172,
0.8924355506896973,
-0.432939350605011,
-0.4380359351634979,
0.720203697681427,
0.11474903672933578,
0.05881178751587868,
0.28215262293815613,
-0.0474931001663208,
0.10316428542137146,
-1.1452462673187256,
-0.5106456279754639,
0.3348914384841919,
-0.4747962951660156,
-0.1928439736366272,
-0.7920560240745544,
-0.4350508153438568,
-0.5533214211463928,
-0.28284507989883423,
-0.28931286931037903,
-0.37209731340408325,
-0.4085991680622101,
0.158857062458992,
0.14480067789554596,
0.8869845271110535,
0.1565195620059967,
-0.09621473401784897,
-0.644708514213562,
0.3996516168117523,
-0.09830593317747116,
0.35313543677330017,
0.15310761332511902,
-0.6336514949798584,
-0.3586556017398834,
-0.20765672624111176,
-0.20835033059120178,
-0.2711105942726135,
0.6112370491027832,
0.24960431456565857,
0.26293957233428955,
0.005209697410464287,
0.20756486058235168,
0.6154564023017883,
-0.8024067282676697,
0.7578151226043701,
-0.17766554653644562,
-0.7379217743873596,
0.39199215173721313,
-0.5674012899398804,
0.3403412401676178,
0.6975186467170715,
0.22883446514606476,
-0.08471336960792542,
-0.83196622133255,
-0.12719151377677917,
-1.0063120126724243,
0.45611336827278137,
0.13204734027385712,
-0.04026072099804878,
0.5141201019287109,
0.2830426096916199,
0.28509941697120667,
0.23940928280353546,
-0.5700250864028931,
-0.10528505593538284,
0.2462441474199295,
-0.03051452711224556,
-0.09103179723024368,
-0.15235772728919983,
-0.538811445236206,
-0.3603627383708954,
1.0277036428451538,
-0.4076835513114929,
-0.1140366643667221,
0.5000709295272827,
-0.2866237163543701,
-0.35162046551704407,
0.2597625255584717,
0.5630533695220947,
0.9955474734306335,
-0.12522299587726593,
-0.14159969985485077,
-0.017943842336535454,
-0.2565869390964508,
-0.09118598699569702,
0.218674898147583,
-0.909661054611206,
0.16131585836410522,
0.011312010698020458,
0.4490658938884735,
0.014333612285554409,
-0.6605415940284729,
0.011082718148827553,
-0.15092654526233673,
-0.33713456988334656,
-0.5837073922157288,
0.1702696830034256,
-0.09547486901283264,
0.16144248843193054,
0.4696866273880005,
0.14498338103294373,
0.5408126711845398,
-0.17024338245391846,
0.09823496639728546,
0.6457497477531433,
-0.12381082028150558,
-0.22677400708198547,
0.5292454361915588,
0.2085639089345932,
-0.01772989332675934,
0.23279322683811188,
0.019437164068222046,
-0.21984928846359253,
0.3609049618244171,
0.10635283589363098,
0.9739398956298828,
0.04439321905374527,
0.12706804275512695,
0.365112841129303,
0.6455985307693481,
-0.20812371373176575,
0.10431457310914993,
0.2459772229194641,
-0.39858418703079224,
-0.5305174589157104,
-0.919015109539032,
-0.6071315407752991,
0.26846426725387573,
-0.6225808262825012,
0.3948265016078949,
-0.48489898443222046,
0.017464671283960342,
0.31107765436172485,
-0.09716226160526276,
-0.3570365905761719,
0.06293092668056488,
-0.0007630480686202645,
0.7541192173957825,
-0.5743579864501953,
0.7947872877120972,
0.46675506234169006,
-0.3674736022949219,
-0.6557644605636597,
0.03574177250266075,
0.09045497328042984,
-0.42219966650009155,
0.37548506259918213,
-0.08053028583526611,
-0.474035382270813,
-0.05136517807841301,
-0.5765500664710999,
-0.8204808831214905,
1.1164424419403076,
0.0834105908870697,
-0.8856324553489685,
-0.0850381925702095,
0.3170124590396881,
1.028066873550415,
-0.4644900858402252,
0.25692489743232727,
0.6813766956329346,
0.5041186809539795,
-0.15773800015449524,
-1.1281330585479736,
0.07091917842626572,
-0.14198486506938934,
0.14501288533210754,
-0.03724732622504234,
-0.5940681099891663,
0.4517824351787567,
-0.11325560510158539,
0.004534649662673473,
0.2283308506011963,
0.7364628314971924,
0.2010997086763382,
0.4456828534603119,
0.24062639474868774,
0.2608256936073303,
0.6932183504104614,
0.15116025507450104,
0.6522064805030823,
-0.7065185904502869,
0.15164773166179657,
0.9491409063339233,
-0.8268238306045532,
0.5909225940704346,
0.6173932552337646,
-0.0430527925491333,
0.34566035866737366,
0.4113321304321289,
-0.17284061014652252,
0.30366984009742737,
0.41268253326416016,
-0.13774599134922028,
0.03565278276801109,
-0.3236408233642578,
-0.2838870584964752,
0.05312512814998627,
0.4702245593070984,
-0.4857032895088196,
-0.006140933837741613,
0.05705590546131134,
-0.0322391614317894,
0.15703950822353363,
-0.49565035104751587,
0.9485709071159363,
0.12880204617977142,
-1.1530554294586182,
0.8787607550621033,
0.07373354583978653,
0.6933270692825317,
-0.7009891867637634,
0.16771331429481506,
-0.15780054032802582,
0.3079807162284851,
-0.3588810861110687,
-0.6882063746452332,
0.5008067488670349,
-0.021359143778681755,
-0.36767640709877014,
-0.40347999334335327,
0.9281169772148132,
-0.39565008878707886,
-0.5516466498374939,
0.20524053275585175,
0.6061106324195862,
-0.0569552443921566,
0.10331463068723679,
-0.7495856881141663,
0.4111585021018982,
0.13926203548908234,
-0.4614032506942749,
0.6278641819953918,
0.5664046406745911,
-0.11459750682115555,
0.7432257533073425,
0.7157056331634521,
0.3647642731666565,
-0.1314336061477661,
0.33077535033226013,
0.9705883860588074,
-0.5737828612327576,
-0.20839901268482208,
-0.6060755252838135,
0.22121860086917877,
0.08427945524454117,
-0.12574802339076996,
0.6669221520423889,
0.5836222171783447,
0.9524651169776917,
-0.29138997197151184,
1.1217199563980103,
-0.02726656384766102,
0.645900309085846,
-0.5634067058563232,
0.9798047542572021,
-0.47435253858566284,
0.48556602001190186,
-0.1812509000301361,
-0.7846842408180237,
-0.565863311290741,
0.4337172210216522,
-0.21913453936576843,
-0.284629762172699,
0.8059449791908264,
1.2825583219528198,
0.07207724452018738,
-0.10483922809362411,
0.09053757786750793,
0.4367999732494354,
0.42052537202835083,
-0.01624506711959839,
0.5645755529403687,
-0.320073664188385,
0.437423437833786,
-0.009556928649544716,
-0.06031382456421852,
-0.2248617708683014,
-0.7539954781532288,
-0.9778854250907898,
-0.5139882564544678,
-0.3904922306537628,
-0.4772357642650604,
0.2696506083011627,
0.8171976208686829,
0.34186026453971863,
-1.1151500940322876,
-0.444784551858902,
-0.14003886282444,
-0.011209014803171158,
-0.05631524696946144,
-0.27446162700653076,
0.2602938711643219,
-0.8183025121688843,
-0.7828951478004456,
0.19009430706501007,
0.46470907330513,
-0.251079261302948,
-0.7933448553085327,
-0.08580853790044785,
0.0019248613389208913,
0.24671190977096558,
0.5045792460441589,
0.015758220106363297,
-0.9080787301063538,
0.19617687165737152,
0.02795848436653614,
-0.4050484299659729,
-0.05449657514691353,
1.123408317565918,
-0.5964824557304382,
0.30256956815719604,
0.6262290477752686,
0.6681323051452637,
0.33768218755722046,
-0.2841992974281311,
0.8563196659088135,
-0.1733245700597763,
-0.2830016613006592,
0.5787283778190613,
0.2430753856897354,
0.3956868648529053,
-0.2839008867740631,
0.6353743672370911,
-0.11685541272163391,
-0.9705808162689209,
-1.131938099861145,
0.02424643188714981,
-0.8692246079444885,
-0.3052334189414978,
1.2548140287399292,
0.10750363022089005,
-0.19921618700027466,
-0.2547447681427002,
-0.4431866705417633,
-0.0356835275888443,
-0.30499908328056335,
1.3202892541885376,
0.5947619080543518,
-0.19949820637702942,
0.15016961097717285,
-0.5840243101119995,
0.8187382221221924,
0.6548284888267517,
-0.9011278748512268,
0.353272944688797,
0.6496956944465637,
0.2962588369846344,
0.0860707014799118,
0.6351680159568787,
-0.37544575333595276,
0.16343411803245544,
-0.5173330307006836,
0.15576738119125366,
0.06007598713040352,
-0.2248612493276596,
-0.3858399987220764,
0.2023274153470993,
0.32931503653526306,
0.6416675448417664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05091v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05091v4
|
MM-MATH: Advancing Multimodal Math Evaluation with Process Evaluation and Fine-grained Classification
| 2024-04-07T22:16:50 | 2024-07-02T12:46:23 |
Kai Sun, Yushi Bai, Ji Qi, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To advance the evaluation of multimodal math reasoning in large multimodal
models (LMMs), this paper introduces a novel benchmark, MM-MATH. MM-MATH
consists of 5,929 open-ended middle school math problems with visual contexts,
with fine-grained classification across difficulty, grade level, and knowledge
points. Unlike existing benchmarks relying on binary answer comparison, MM-MATH
incorporates both outcome and process evaluations. Process evaluation employs
LMM-as-a-judge to automatically analyze solution steps, identifying and
categorizing errors into specific error types. Extensive evaluation of ten
models on MM-MATH reveals significant challenges for existing LMMs,
highlighting their limited utilization of visual information and struggles with
higher-difficulty problems. The best-performing model achieves only 31%
accuracy on MM-MATH, compared to 82% for humans. This highlights the
challenging nature of our benchmark for existing models and the significant gap
between the multimodal reasoning capabilities of current models and humans. Our
process evaluation reveals that diagram misinterpretation is the most common
error, accounting for more than half of the total error cases, underscoring the
need for improved image comprehension in multimodal reasoning.
|
[
-0.4577043354511261,
-0.8907508850097656,
0.5857522487640381,
0.16040687263011932,
-0.06061255931854248,
0.13238847255706787,
-0.09431125223636627,
-0.05085846409201622,
-0.5116996169090271,
0.07011359930038452,
-0.8631695508956909,
-0.354138046503067,
-0.7499847412109375,
-0.08501651883125305,
0.031260885298252106,
0.4611412286758423,
-0.2227533906698227,
0.5390902161598206,
-0.7526620030403137,
-0.32703879475593567,
-0.429069459438324,
-0.4696947932243347,
-0.353256493806839,
-0.38381025195121765,
0.5314779877662659,
0.5312283635139465,
0.7766465544700623,
0.3010125756263733,
1.01357102394104,
0.3889525234699249,
0.26015082001686096,
0.5678105354309082,
-0.29451271891593933,
-0.27559080719947815,
-0.09631545096635818,
-0.41284316778182983,
-0.6080494523048401,
0.23624871671199799,
0.44281476736068726,
0.9246339797973633,
-0.1591646671295166,
0.501309335231781,
-0.21079309284687042,
0.7342003583908081,
-0.9355618357658386,
0.46166616678237915,
-0.39825206995010376,
0.20106492936611176,
-0.16361287236213684,
-0.15686503052711487,
-0.548194169998169,
-0.31299811601638794,
0.0007511280127801001,
-0.5891258120536804,
-0.012829015962779522,
-0.1466069221496582,
0.5404858589172363,
0.2456178516149521,
-0.5177040696144104,
-0.2332191914319992,
-0.5583733916282654,
0.9572778940200806,
-0.21143484115600586,
0.6674143075942993,
0.3110138177871704,
1.1292791366577148,
-0.0723850354552269,
-0.725123941898346,
-0.5780783295631409,
-0.08084850013256073,
0.45996591448783875,
0.3849898874759674,
-0.40045878291130066,
-0.11457888036966324,
0.4555523693561554,
0.17184388637542725,
-0.3523646593093872,
-0.18645061552524567,
-0.561202883720398,
-0.24104756116867065,
0.3816194534301758,
0.47199881076812744,
0.08493538945913315,
-0.04969452694058418,
-0.2716880440711975,
-0.3703780174255371,
-0.27726665139198303,
0.19550387561321259,
0.10652600973844528,
0.00033138063736259937,
-0.06512261927127838,
0.9276342391967773,
-0.13284321129322052,
0.6357643604278564,
-0.35828104615211487,
-0.3681020736694336,
0.40221595764160156,
-0.20619718730449677,
-0.37896519899368286,
-0.5528888702392578,
0.5521700382232666,
0.9404335021972656,
0.3810191750526428,
0.20526087284088135,
-0.1258019208908081,
0.6910962462425232,
0.11178896576166153,
-0.9702685475349426,
-0.0761745348572731,
-0.3049684464931488,
-0.5158143043518066,
0.031288571655750275,
-0.1464582085609436,
-0.7994287014007568,
-0.18979884684085846,
-0.5648900866508484,
0.7738012075424194,
-0.5136803388595581,
0.10924610495567322,
0.25307396054267883,
-0.17073306441307068,
-0.3402150273323059,
0.9257842898368835,
-0.46196916699409485,
0.2405654937028885,
0.8133289217948914,
0.8191974759101868,
0.09254499524831772,
-0.39361193776130676,
-0.38551774621009827,
-0.1618974208831787,
-0.3132888376712799,
0.8415277004241943,
-0.7677696347236633,
-0.24126146733760834,
-0.4051938056945801,
-0.1331547349691391,
-0.20008015632629395,
-0.6987127065658569,
0.7319396734237671,
-0.17894265055656433,
0.19503290951251984,
-0.004511088598519564,
-0.3564019799232483,
-0.4521418809890747,
0.5668971538543701,
-0.38609448075294495,
0.7633397579193115,
0.23367677628993988,
-0.31519031524658203,
0.3816980719566345,
-0.699446976184845,
0.22390948235988617,
-0.27749142050743103,
-0.17860466241836548,
-0.39658910036087036,
0.3283197581768036,
0.29165807366371155,
0.4871879816055298,
-0.427608460187912,
0.21863897144794464,
-0.9076628684997559,
-0.37837424874305725,
0.4631052613258362,
-0.9186804890632629,
0.38117364048957825,
0.3712119162082672,
0.14991562068462372,
0.050882577896118164,
-0.922721803188324,
0.19197998940944672,
0.05201471596956253,
-0.074639230966568,
-0.2702471613883972,
-0.1950574517250061,
-0.2624492645263672,
0.5887438058853149,
0.25138506293296814,
-0.39814144372940063,
0.11593125015497208,
0.17954541742801666,
0.3450942933559418,
0.9355250597000122,
-0.3556419909000397,
0.35014116764068604,
-0.46089112758636475,
0.3155675530433655,
0.2965838611125946,
0.4650612771511078,
-0.6091292500495911,
-0.7096885442733765,
-0.7708911895751953,
-0.4477972388267517,
0.3245234787464142,
0.43466272950172424,
-0.7028400301933289,
-0.1550704538822174,
-0.2697170376777649,
-0.729275107383728,
-0.5260821580886841,
0.030622458085417747,
0.5349847674369812,
0.5534505248069763,
0.4466829299926758,
-0.4663928747177124,
-0.2253175973892212,
-0.9438374638557434,
-0.04098266735672951,
0.17873536050319672,
-0.06221369281411171,
0.5319013595581055,
0.6335068345069885,
-0.5588282942771912,
0.5907736420631409,
-0.5761415362358093,
-0.2100093513727188,
0.38576239347457886,
0.5167997479438782,
0.21675118803977966,
0.3752700388431549,
0.3850894272327423,
-0.6223357319831848,
-0.30574753880500793,
0.024370241910219193,
-0.774354875087738,
-0.16266648471355438,
0.19458721578121185,
-0.18427425622940063,
-0.029517654329538345,
0.1908499002456665,
-0.45659223198890686,
0.5393469333648682,
0.5033196210861206,
-0.4748973250389099,
0.6889702677726746,
-0.29664531350135803,
0.3996081054210663,
-0.5886398553848267,
-0.08883187919855118,
0.1812829226255417,
0.05897236242890358,
-0.16532418131828308,
0.16961656510829926,
0.35652515292167664,
-0.3554427921772003,
-0.30653032660484314,
0.5326947569847107,
-0.38333550095558167,
-0.3666047751903534,
0.11479156464338303,
-0.06459139287471771,
0.04941686615347862,
0.5614843964576721,
-0.42698943614959717,
0.7007144689559937,
0.43864139914512634,
-0.30223292112350464,
0.5062370300292969,
-0.27765029668807983,
-0.44012030959129333,
1.002988576889038,
-0.31704580783843994,
-0.014128084294497967,
-0.1989535093307495,
0.08287548273801804,
-1.0845893621444702,
-0.06780953705310822,
0.02248346619307995,
-0.4961871802806854,
0.005979347974061966,
-0.12553636729717255,
-0.5906684398651123,
-0.542615532875061,
-0.27776697278022766,
0.5581038594245911,
0.3452100455760956,
-0.2969436049461365,
0.6785305738449097,
0.05416860058903694,
0.03178197517991066,
-0.5151724219322205,
-0.44743722677230835,
-0.11265786737203598,
-0.02305511198937893,
-0.8785682916641235,
-0.06087043136358261,
-0.5044083595275879,
-0.4180452823638916,
-0.05042576789855957,
-0.2236793041229248,
-0.43278661370277405,
0.02256813645362854,
0.22938272356987,
0.36750221252441406,
-0.2805717885494232,
0.031015565618872643,
0.09032046794891357,
-0.4551035761833191,
0.14281640946865082,
0.35920587182044983,
0.49442726373672485,
-0.30492308735847473,
-0.8484411835670471,
-0.2944757342338562,
0.2019742876291275,
1.0128854513168335,
-0.12200140953063965,
0.1766418069601059,
0.7211244702339172,
-0.5187971591949463,
0.09767040610313416,
-0.5887482762336731,
0.016400950029492378,
-0.41130053997039795,
0.3348662555217743,
-0.739829957485199,
-0.6470900177955627,
0.3806001842021942,
-0.3345099091529846,
0.12270782142877579,
0.435586154460907,
0.48669156432151794,
-0.11769111454486847,
1.543708086013794,
0.2927361726760864,
0.4956996738910675,
0.155867338180542,
-0.21111765503883362,
-0.232442244887352,
-0.6069960594177246,
-0.3673073649406433,
-0.34225162863731384,
-0.477714478969574,
-0.20994074642658234,
-1.137254238128662,
0.6002668738365173,
0.21111264824867249,
-0.1584794968366623,
-0.013981633819639683,
-0.2237870693206787,
0.46258875727653503,
0.35739216208457947,
0.22296945750713348,
0.4117368459701538,
0.07521159201860428,
-0.657589852809906,
-0.5503721833229065,
-0.37565356492996216,
-0.4779350459575653,
1.1974163055419922,
0.41953611373901367,
0.7672245502471924,
0.2959064543247223,
0.23480089008808136,
0.2117769569158554,
0.6747574210166931,
-0.9317604303359985,
0.6214533448219299,
-0.2933640480041504,
-0.6696064472198486,
-0.03214951977133751,
-0.7300531268119812,
-0.7022026181221008,
0.5904096961021423,
-0.39582210779190063,
-0.5012526512145996,
-0.2569858431816101,
-0.1101733148097992,
-0.24934257566928864,
0.17743080854415894,
-1.2564103603363037,
1.0957616567611694,
-0.1694246083498001,
-0.437751442193985,
-0.47132250666618347,
-0.31147006154060364,
0.7495768666267395,
-0.16449718177318573,
0.696631669998169,
-0.5179799199104309,
0.002169047947973013,
0.46772584319114685,
-0.5068031549453735,
0.5492488741874695,
-0.1977711021900177,
0.18638285994529724,
0.07905755192041397,
0.24845029413700104,
-0.11768170446157455,
-0.07114602625370026,
0.04250325635075569,
0.1331864595413208,
0.11943965405225754,
-0.28651484847068787,
-1.0268338918685913,
0.5421204566955566,
-0.6201704144477844,
-0.18134796619415283,
-0.34531429409980774,
-0.7192392945289612,
-0.33594855666160583,
0.1645660102367401,
-0.2723386287689209,
0.7414655685424805,
0.06166967377066612,
0.2677524983882904,
0.4024585783481598,
-0.1039123386144638,
0.4880208969116211,
0.37402263283729553,
-0.3946337103843689,
-0.6907084584236145,
0.9216725826263428,
0.238853320479393,
0.12222745269536972,
0.25302109122276306,
0.440306156873703,
-0.33729088306427,
-0.18100690841674805,
-0.8208242654800415,
-0.011842021718621254,
-0.9727594256401062,
-0.27303236722946167,
-0.4909473657608032,
-0.11679317057132721,
0.011783512309193611,
-0.09754126518964767,
-0.4355047345161438,
-0.4679114520549774,
0.00946347787976265,
0.4243774712085724,
-0.18954668939113617,
0.36427366733551025,
-0.0029699255246669054,
0.2404317855834961,
-0.9231477379798889,
0.37514710426330566,
0.7155848741531372,
0.5494796633720398,
0.0434376522898674,
-0.33924832940101624,
-0.07927755266427994,
0.10699103772640228,
-0.7552884817123413,
-0.41479799151420593,
-0.0262343417853117,
0.17520388960838318,
0.570313572883606,
0.5808069705963135,
-0.40629130601882935,
1.350934386253357,
-0.7988267540931702,
0.3412342667579651,
0.7416626811027527,
-1.0293699502944946,
0.2394210249185562,
-0.1355036348104477,
0.5061298608779907,
0.3054211735725403,
0.2675986588001251,
-0.2883546054363251,
0.12213528901338577,
-0.5902803540229797,
-0.2602449655532837,
0.5011354088783264,
0.1984931230545044,
-0.011142040602862835,
0.08930124342441559,
-0.1218627393245697,
0.22012506425380707,
0.21300436556339264,
-0.5229775905609131,
-0.0777990072965622,
-0.08674437552690506,
-0.2626878321170807,
-0.25746604800224304,
-0.2429635226726532,
-0.1775275319814682,
-0.5855382084846497,
0.07824806123971939,
-0.29022955894470215,
0.3458832800388336,
-0.19247043132781982,
-0.2670363187789917,
-0.24215102195739746,
0.27924028038978577,
1.0086642503738403,
1.1102169752120972,
-0.3199698328971863,
0.38575324416160583,
0.2818589508533478,
-0.4569116532802582,
0.05793961510062218,
0.3319428563117981,
0.24640384316444397,
0.012551214545965195,
0.4006699323654175,
0.5126775503158569,
0.6029524207115173,
-0.8025064468383789,
0.6557402014732361,
-0.3193361163139343,
-0.3040126860141754,
-0.10666097700595856,
-0.0642872005701065,
-0.06062724441289902,
0.4505294859409332,
0.4444315731525421,
0.6393636465072632,
0.26564162969589233,
-0.6077901124954224,
0.2552887499332428,
0.46002906560897827,
-0.2741924822330475,
-0.30625662207603455,
0.42621639370918274,
0.010703095234930515,
-0.17343947291374207,
0.233287051320076,
-0.14176377654075623,
-0.3596029281616211,
0.5424047112464905,
0.36568108201026917,
0.5428923964500427,
-0.23333744704723358,
0.0710175409913063,
0.5241564512252808,
0.21539075672626495,
0.08340995013713837,
0.35696807503700256,
-0.14397834241390228,
-0.593830943107605,
-0.4842129051685333,
-0.49042871594429016,
-0.6893627643585205,
-0.2883138358592987,
-0.4900030493736267,
0.3903806805610657,
-0.6338455080986023,
-0.4545191824436188,
0.3816379904747009,
-0.06739898025989532,
-0.6181140542030334,
0.40727970004081726,
0.20068958401679993,
0.8213164806365967,
-0.47938621044158936,
0.4319351315498352,
0.721916139125824,
-0.11922963708639145,
-0.2365908920764923,
-0.6629654765129089,
0.1511353701353073,
-1.0113633871078491,
0.8116069436073303,
0.5563799738883972,
-0.21572694182395935,
-0.279757559299469,
-0.46122050285339355,
-0.5358367562294006,
1.0956562757492065,
0.3116613030433655,
-0.5382009148597717,
0.14945240318775177,
-0.027599386870861053,
0.38887813687324524,
-0.2904564440250397,
0.8692023754119873,
0.23634880781173706,
0.4623970091342926,
0.45696955919265747,
-1.0587197542190552,
-0.3841734230518341,
-0.42336082458496094,
-0.022259481251239777,
0.32127729058265686,
-0.5833860039710999,
1.158354640007019,
-0.31296306848526,
-0.14524583518505096,
-0.0000906613131519407,
0.3729638159275055,
0.5851264595985413,
1.1207973957061768,
0.5837990045547485,
1.0217787027359009,
0.45318496227264404,
-0.4451095461845398,
0.6444494724273682,
0.16232280433177948,
0.38984379172325134,
0.8961285948753357,
-0.05488188564777374,
0.88973069190979,
0.36123204231262207,
-0.452639102935791,
0.4337056875228882,
0.543921947479248,
-0.052062153816223145,
0.34058570861816406,
0.31825190782546997,
-0.07954122871160507,
-0.4804772138595581,
0.0434170626103878,
-0.48964086174964905,
0.5965582728385925,
0.5528706908226013,
-0.14597491919994354,
-0.6600521802902222,
0.006500046234577894,
-0.08667398244142532,
0.06558039039373398,
-0.6763580441474915,
0.34741657972335815,
0.03499962016940117,
-0.45803970098495483,
0.3878869116306305,
0.13537746667861938,
0.5804901719093323,
-0.41960883140563965,
-0.28389251232147217,
-0.07423734664916992,
0.6106669306755066,
-0.0646175965666771,
-0.7536954283714294,
0.24481087923049927,
-0.11376483738422394,
-0.2792831063270569,
-0.1254822462797165,
0.5467526912689209,
-0.14027263224124908,
-0.8646056056022644,
0.04186812788248062,
0.7038509249687195,
0.07776954770088196,
-0.0761617049574852,
-0.9169349670410156,
0.1475120633840561,
-0.47979533672332764,
0.14656637609004974,
0.23421895503997803,
0.8339105844497681,
-0.2955484986305237,
0.9070587754249573,
0.999791145324707,
-0.5138170123100281,
0.2227015495300293,
0.2231345921754837,
0.7723442316055298,
-0.6166951060295105,
-0.20700310170650482,
-0.99748295545578,
0.5951576232910156,
-0.06702585518360138,
-0.4221053123474121,
0.8341359496116638,
0.6739767789840698,
0.8893730640411377,
-0.22927333414554596,
0.18254487216472626,
0.40334317088127136,
0.3888150155544281,
-0.48347190022468567,
0.46598222851753235,
-0.7785723209381104,
-0.06897293031215668,
-0.7246801257133484,
-0.9282609820365906,
-0.43972235918045044,
0.6632094383239746,
-0.3398273289203644,
0.21244093775749207,
0.7199580669403076,
0.3940228521823883,
-0.44421449303627014,
-0.10314423590898514,
0.6928627490997314,
-0.28470274806022644,
0.028327802196145058,
0.8265495896339417,
1.2522759437561035,
-0.458318829536438,
0.5676475763320923,
-0.5328876972198486,
-0.4900275766849518,
-0.2385576367378235,
-0.7105206847190857,
-0.981511116027832,
-0.3801494240760803,
-0.2076827436685562,
-0.19014842808246613,
-0.4014476239681244,
0.8080512285232544,
0.779440701007843,
-0.4129575490951538,
-0.34318870306015015,
0.3433810770511627,
0.10943491756916046,
-0.28163009881973267,
-0.22381363809108734,
-0.042406074702739716,
-0.11180692911148071,
-0.9035196900367737,
0.17456093430519104,
0.5903816223144531,
0.1713728904724121,
-0.32514676451683044,
-0.11248408257961273,
0.029041029512882233,
0.055857088416814804,
1.043210744857788,
-0.3258304297924042,
-0.7682936191558838,
0.034864798188209534,
-0.005115701351314783,
-0.12941798567771912,
0.09850797802209854,
0.7550501227378845,
-0.41089558601379395,
0.93694669008255,
0.2947639226913452,
0.5092967748641968,
0.5459955334663391,
-0.13783511519432068,
0.23058494925498962,
-0.3015328645706177,
0.1644521951675415,
0.042920760810375214,
0.5978296399116516,
0.17253650724887848,
0.2793373465538025,
0.5736821889877319,
0.6264315843582153,
-0.31492188572883606,
-0.9873974919319153,
0.1608528196811676,
-1.0792189836502075,
-0.20538504421710968,
0.6278391480445862,
-0.23564504086971283,
-0.3753369450569153,
0.22043055295944214,
-0.25792232155799866,
0.05882864072918892,
-0.2504872977733612,
0.7351105809211731,
1.0440552234649658,
-0.060031622648239136,
-0.5139775276184082,
-0.8242940306663513,
-0.07508160173892975,
0.34119123220443726,
-0.8206571936607361,
-0.3633985221385956,
0.8331252336502075,
0.06704996526241302,
0.4022010266780853,
0.34642112255096436,
-0.29787319898605347,
0.5970543026924133,
0.1436513215303421,
-0.11718589067459106,
-0.29633262753486633,
-0.5773297548294067,
-0.15837828814983368,
0.37504565715789795,
-0.25499212741851807,
-0.1843847781419754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05090v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05090v1
|
How Bad is Training on Synthetic Data? A Statistical Analysis of Language Model Collapse
| 2024-04-07T22:15:13 | 2024-04-07T22:15:13 |
Mohamed El Amine Seddik, Suei-Wen Chen, Soufiane Hayou, Pierre Youssef, Merouane Debbah
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The phenomenon of model collapse, introduced in (Shumailov et al., 2023),
refers to the deterioration in performance that occurs when new models are
trained on synthetic data generated from previously trained models. This
recursive training loop makes the tails of the original distribution disappear,
thereby making future-generation models forget about the initial (real)
distribution. With the aim of rigorously understanding model collapse in
language models, we consider in this paper a statistical model that allows us
to characterize the impact of various recursive training scenarios.
Specifically, we demonstrate that model collapse cannot be avoided when
training solely on synthetic data. However, when mixing both real and synthetic
data, we provide an estimate of a maximal amount of synthetic data below which
model collapse can eventually be avoided. Our theoretical conclusions are
further supported by empirical validations.
|
[
-0.41477224230766296,
-0.834407389163971,
0.4778825640678406,
-0.19564767181873322,
-0.08434216678142548,
0.28509095311164856,
-0.22741203010082245,
-0.40643879771232605,
-0.15567563474178314,
0.639609158039093,
-0.6310555934906006,
-0.20324166119098663,
-0.6377508044242859,
0.025497905910015106,
-1.0501773357391357,
1.1032744646072388,
0.16316425800323486,
0.18045547604560852,
-0.39430204033851624,
0.00444086454808712,
-0.4818688929080963,
-0.8758977651596069,
-0.7501175403594971,
-0.5128474235534668,
0.0339493602514267,
0.12968236207962036,
0.5049216747283936,
0.6385499835014343,
0.26385682821273804,
0.3803933262825012,
0.037961848080158234,
-0.09358113259077072,
-1.0069628953933716,
0.3453696668148041,
-0.08021219819784164,
-0.8134511709213257,
-0.19342972338199615,
0.2822723090648651,
0.8772836923599243,
1.0789365768432617,
-0.34313929080963135,
-0.15015247464179993,
0.10242601484060287,
0.6015199422836304,
-0.29712873697280884,
0.2285785973072052,
-0.8970732688903809,
0.04654048755764961,
-0.07738959044218063,
-0.13967716693878174,
-0.6241030097007751,
-0.4227525591850281,
0.20308294892311096,
-0.2210826426744461,
0.7367688417434692,
-0.17110611498355865,
0.6310617327690125,
0.018702538684010506,
-0.21214209496974945,
0.020541951060295105,
-1.2001681327819824,
0.886584460735321,
-0.5354500412940979,
0.5155718326568604,
0.3985150456428528,
0.6270942091941833,
-0.4301793575286865,
-0.4360913634300232,
-0.9286168217658997,
-0.3904675543308258,
0.12188615649938583,
-0.026056047528982162,
-0.18568117916584015,
0.015676341950893402,
0.23348696529865265,
0.43485012650489807,
-0.5618203282356262,
-0.12263017892837524,
-0.6841911673545837,
0.04526577517390251,
0.41664841771125793,
0.34385624527931213,
0.5361019968986511,
0.11956886202096939,
-0.059117384254932404,
-0.44202038645744324,
-0.9070912003517151,
-0.27702996134757996,
0.7169556617736816,
0.5288702249526978,
-0.12154106795787811,
0.6024530529975891,
-0.03644391521811485,
0.3290247619152069,
-0.12603075802326202,
-0.18157990276813507,
0.2745840847492218,
-0.4148196280002594,
-0.2857134938240051,
-0.23564249277114868,
0.6768427491188049,
0.15803633630275726,
0.6022695302963257,
-0.38868221640586853,
-0.29203149676322937,
0.22976140677928925,
0.36660993099212646,
-0.3823981285095215,
-0.44474977254867554,
0.2328898310661316,
-0.1294327825307846,
-0.5088496804237366,
-0.06720953434705734,
-0.3107021152973175,
-0.21429072320461273,
-0.1895008534193039,
0.12290885299444199,
-0.5069200992584229,
-0.5139890313148499,
0.09546951204538345,
-0.10965249687433243,
-0.34691616892814636,
-0.09817782044410706,
-0.7911823987960815,
0.6668301820755005,
0.594464123249054,
0.6762974858283997,
0.10094508528709412,
-0.6042814254760742,
-0.19710078835487366,
-0.2853753864765167,
-0.4671008586883545,
0.622271716594696,
-0.3121739625930786,
-0.5757133364677429,
0.14967262744903564,
0.26867610216140747,
-0.24705272912979126,
-0.7790602445602417,
0.21140868961811066,
-0.31009721755981445,
0.15827755630016327,
0.31437948346138,
-0.5958731770515442,
-0.10852585732936859,
0.14484643936157227,
-0.8370761275291443,
0.6606998443603516,
0.05122114717960358,
-0.7059354782104492,
0.44934147596359253,
-0.10596519708633423,
-0.40411368012428284,
-0.37690648436546326,
-0.0846036747097969,
-0.687827467918396,
0.1638244390487671,
-0.44218069314956665,
0.22948810458183289,
-0.31104782223701477,
0.2868655025959015,
-0.6788342595100403,
-0.2985600233078003,
0.606358528137207,
-0.5093411207199097,
0.732887327671051,
0.09355270862579346,
-0.13696110248565674,
-0.41674432158470154,
-1.0443938970565796,
0.020154649391770363,
0.2931942939758301,
-0.11740541458129883,
-0.20923081040382385,
0.20398099720478058,
-0.13721488416194916,
0.19376729428768158,
-0.3773305416107178,
-0.47516685724258423,
0.21186672151088715,
-0.7876638770103455,
0.40838977694511414,
0.4481886029243469,
0.16419637203216553,
0.5209226608276367,
-0.30684465169906616,
0.7043435573577881,
-0.026290368288755417,
-0.16868969798088074,
-0.14264653623104095,
-0.28841811418533325,
-0.7672889232635498,
0.18130144476890564,
0.46282586455345154,
0.38971808552742004,
-0.3856153190135956,
0.1796763390302658,
-0.45651525259017944,
-0.648739218711853,
-0.2832578122615814,
-0.02250387892127037,
0.44233447313308716,
0.29038622975349426,
0.08671295642852783,
-0.027935095131397247,
-0.9310083389282227,
-1.0491158962249756,
-0.3467114567756653,
-0.41809535026550293,
0.07659444212913513,
-0.36202913522720337,
0.8241996169090271,
-0.29625627398490906,
0.8200243711471558,
-0.29653042554855347,
0.16965840756893158,
-0.6490606069564819,
0.2727774977684021,
0.12190502136945724,
0.6870502829551697,
0.3539639115333557,
-0.3763348162174225,
0.06799297034740448,
-0.1053728461265564,
-0.5087581872940063,
0.3383488655090332,
-0.2717871069908142,
0.2326289564371109,
0.4840671420097351,
0.19231566786766052,
-0.7440080642700195,
0.5729171633720398,
0.7454814314842224,
0.0392349548637867,
1.024398684501648,
-0.19119048118591309,
-0.031107572838664055,
-0.8055984377861023,
-0.037789810448884964,
0.009058928117156029,
0.00626348564401269,
-0.8656427264213562,
-0.1977674514055252,
-0.20661883056163788,
-0.1888982206583023,
-0.3393324017524719,
0.41406476497650146,
-0.11438455432653427,
-0.007187749724835157,
-0.2270757108926773,
-0.11099673062562943,
-0.19255857169628143,
0.12218190729618073,
0.11579335480928421,
0.5567044019699097,
0.3825211822986603,
-0.5980049967765808,
0.051594655960798264,
0.19599032402038574,
-0.3243389427661896,
-0.06320338696241379,
-0.8054112792015076,
-0.07201552391052246,
-0.15547950565814972,
0.42041197419166565,
-0.9953615069389343,
-0.46948522329330444,
0.22102461755275726,
-0.7130833864212036,
0.4494708776473999,
-0.3620574474334717,
-0.5676162838935852,
-0.2503289580345154,
-0.26115551590919495,
0.4872843623161316,
0.532166600227356,
-0.5502894520759583,
-0.010589438490569592,
0.38520577549934387,
0.1560749113559723,
-0.384449303150177,
-1.0888911485671997,
-0.07031051069498062,
-0.1200471818447113,
-0.7795742750167847,
-0.04000938683748245,
0.07813384383916855,
-0.45256471633911133,
-0.007894815877079964,
0.04187460243701935,
-0.23561912775039673,
-0.03806690126657486,
0.34339648485183716,
0.07204923033714294,
-0.04353582113981247,
0.22868959605693817,
-0.08427764475345612,
-0.08098751306533813,
0.3151836693286896,
0.21062497794628143,
0.7135874032974243,
0.027783093973994255,
-0.24985799193382263,
-0.3899146020412445,
0.18171557784080505,
0.7584668397903442,
0.079966239631176,
1.4279617071151733,
-0.05123922601342201,
-0.44693854451179504,
-0.5621616840362549,
-0.15313461422920227,
-0.3463025391101837,
-0.42351147532463074,
0.49121493101119995,
-0.2702808380126953,
-0.13579878211021423,
0.5671023726463318,
0.15791121125221252,
-0.180677130818367,
0.30224886536598206,
0.3903781473636627,
-0.2570781707763672,
1.338262915611267,
0.8096437454223633,
0.3423140048980713,
0.2971472442150116,
-0.8421390652656555,
0.4124740958213806,
-0.4187758266925812,
-0.2756008803844452,
-0.3077518343925476,
0.22399315237998962,
-0.8794012069702148,
-0.17030760645866394,
0.11748681962490082,
0.0432761013507843,
-0.36896297335624695,
0.304836630821228,
-0.24403506517410278,
0.6043152809143066,
0.43484312295913696,
-0.12140137702226639,
0.05642051249742508,
0.16696485877037048,
0.1575329601764679,
0.0703272596001625,
-0.8289244771003723,
-0.5052378177642822,
1.088477373123169,
0.49298524856567383,
0.8640483021736145,
-0.20700815320014954,
0.8306553959846497,
0.1375182420015335,
0.13265563547611237,
-0.5946159362792969,
0.3559209406375885,
-0.042367056012153625,
-0.5715909600257874,
-0.2593427002429962,
-0.5411981344223022,
-1.0356969833374023,
-0.01835118979215622,
-0.18327587842941284,
-0.49359700083732605,
0.19588136672973633,
0.4071944057941437,
0.015996752306818962,
0.3494005799293518,
-0.8282757997512817,
0.8209050297737122,
-0.05137501657009125,
0.0013849000679329038,
-0.11218070983886719,
-0.35383340716362,
0.8814738392829895,
-0.24971115589141846,
0.435566246509552,
0.0035568869207054377,
0.5921576619148254,
0.73097825050354,
-0.6734007000923157,
0.9691239595413208,
-0.04283658787608147,
0.008228795602917671,
0.10092861205339432,
0.31092369556427,
0.6113932132720947,
-0.319837749004364,
0.09434635192155838,
0.14332666993141174,
0.16110825538635254,
-0.4690842926502228,
-0.769413948059082,
0.4759562611579895,
-0.8326316475868225,
-0.24466997385025024,
-0.6156995892524719,
-0.34138739109039307,
-0.5066195726394653,
-0.043911129236221313,
0.4705846905708313,
0.6203104853630066,
-0.1897473931312561,
-0.08523346483707428,
0.29043594002723694,
-0.28790995478630066,
-0.03454255685210228,
0.13288891315460205,
-0.2800086438655853,
-0.39250388741493225,
1.0717954635620117,
0.5106993317604065,
0.7881983518600464,
-0.39962947368621826,
0.04639964923262596,
-0.36970362067222595,
-0.9064844250679016,
-0.07467956095933914,
0.5094481706619263,
-0.7537190914154053,
0.07846332341432571,
-0.32131150364875793,
-0.4116886556148529,
-0.4688946604728699,
0.06268928200006485,
-0.5096052289009094,
-0.7637995481491089,
-0.025990653783082962,
-0.3449334502220154,
-0.05482269451022148,
1.0123240947723389,
-0.021073423326015472,
0.3467930853366852,
-0.7846946120262146,
-0.04033159092068672,
-0.1084437221288681,
0.3801136612892151,
0.1764199286699295,
-0.5683768391609192,
-0.45850589871406555,
0.3382788598537445,
-0.1793704628944397,
-0.7741338014602661,
0.6626601815223694,
0.20868901908397675,
0.6499817371368408,
0.434366375207901,
0.010575058870017529,
0.4914422035217285,
-0.618003249168396,
0.7551195025444031,
0.39973264932632446,
-0.6274964213371277,
0.4839913547039032,
-0.6391133069992065,
0.2963842749595642,
0.39039677381515503,
0.32573840022087097,
-0.5884302258491516,
-0.9421257972717285,
-0.863761842250824,
-0.8446710705757141,
0.6688372492790222,
0.33787354826927185,
0.2923809289932251,
-0.3420311510562897,
0.26924389600753784,
0.3234931528568268,
0.0635153129696846,
-0.6797257661819458,
-0.38481107354164124,
-0.1455133855342865,
0.04671604558825493,
-0.17318306863307953,
-0.355866014957428,
0.004356504883617163,
-0.35407754778862,
0.7182297706604004,
0.26308366656303406,
0.1350829303264618,
-0.4253399968147278,
-0.17323578894138336,
-0.14051774144172668,
-0.082260861992836,
0.5293630957603455,
0.8249136209487915,
-0.25841188430786133,
0.16411930322647095,
0.07287143170833588,
-0.4029548764228821,
0.34852999448776245,
-0.33931949734687805,
-0.2580714523792267,
-0.10054563730955124,
0.6405293345451355,
0.5966495275497437,
0.3924585282802582,
-0.8473374843597412,
0.12391681969165802,
0.007162299007177353,
-0.25709542632102966,
-0.5791055560112,
0.19290342926979065,
-0.004063082858920097,
-0.11231954395771027,
0.24095895886421204,
0.41945087909698486,
-0.030335353687405586,
-1.0684319734573364,
0.47179916501045227,
0.30524182319641113,
0.06475789099931717,
-0.7535040974617004,
0.6154128909111023,
0.07092887908220291,
-0.18180638551712036,
0.6885110139846802,
-0.045253172516822815,
-0.6495562791824341,
0.6097428798675537,
0.8693467974662781,
0.8484172224998474,
-0.25503504276275635,
0.41043606400489807,
0.6244680881500244,
0.4551481604576111,
-0.31979280710220337,
-0.005679455120116472,
0.44503816962242126,
-0.8857815861701965,
-0.3531235158443451,
-0.6186766624450684,
-0.3195018172264099,
0.38840165734291077,
-0.5714603066444397,
0.14592203497886658,
-0.44495832920074463,
-0.15450242161750793,
-0.0581938736140728,
-0.23761186003684998,
-0.46558958292007446,
0.5183363556861877,
0.13444694876670837,
0.6045585870742798,
-1.0849308967590332,
0.8104549646377563,
0.30728501081466675,
-0.600364625453949,
-0.29404962062835693,
0.10784933716058731,
0.016224989667534828,
-0.5897683501243591,
0.8701615333557129,
0.06257151067256927,
-0.37381109595298767,
-0.4282466173171997,
-0.48172661662101746,
-0.8204294443130493,
0.3895091414451599,
0.6546958088874817,
-0.3202492296695709,
-0.0838388055562973,
0.6642538905143738,
0.84579998254776,
-0.2619631290435791,
-0.02386803925037384,
0.9286501407623291,
0.22427323460578918,
0.007306068204343319,
-0.8856528401374817,
-0.27621886134147644,
-0.16073626279830933,
-0.03723125532269478,
0.3292276859283447,
-0.15443679690361023,
0.9305592179298401,
-0.24403537809848785,
-0.6947738528251648,
0.2953711450099945,
0.13939079642295837,
0.1858062893152237,
0.23520538210868835,
0.5323273539543152,
0.566282331943512,
0.5063328146934509,
-0.08093161880970001,
1.4617946147918701,
-0.25368472933769226,
0.519037663936615,
1.2190403938293457,
0.24772703647613525,
0.9303845167160034,
0.17939572036266327,
-0.5616014003753662,
0.20261253416538239,
0.6523399353027344,
0.1308600902557373,
0.4692675471305847,
0.3747742176055908,
-0.09869499504566193,
-0.3328854441642761,
0.25204312801361084,
-0.17182402312755585,
0.42712706327438354,
0.2758795917034149,
-0.3434508144855499,
-0.21174155175685883,
0.13480226695537567,
-0.07557912170886993,
0.1964419037103653,
0.1588324010372162,
0.4173978567123413,
0.012777406722307205,
-0.505803644657135,
1.1653474569320679,
-0.200203999876976,
0.015139956958591938,
-0.39680397510528564,
-0.1353614330291748,
-0.3222755789756775,
0.3090221583843231,
-0.21589557826519012,
-0.5794090628623962,
0.5942347049713135,
-0.15052680671215057,
-0.34214985370635986,
0.0737493708729744,
0.42662620544433594,
-0.6530939936637878,
-0.6226970553398132,
0.16340045630931854,
0.40931710600852966,
0.30695614218711853,
0.11671667546033859,
-0.4614129066467285,
0.4383262097835541,
-0.11809654533863068,
-0.15238820016384125,
0.3900270164012909,
0.17002613842487335,
0.19152814149856567,
0.9608731865882874,
0.6820700168609619,
0.25823453068733215,
0.19420254230499268,
-0.07581792026758194,
0.6608167886734009,
-0.6095376014709473,
-0.22582609951496124,
-0.7707833051681519,
0.48817333579063416,
-0.044541895389556885,
-0.1391720175743103,
0.7985414266586304,
0.5004510283470154,
1.0000276565551758,
0.06085694953799248,
1.033687710762024,
0.37462735176086426,
0.7129825949668884,
-0.47865960001945496,
0.8361592292785645,
-0.5127168893814087,
0.4850284159183502,
-0.06336105614900589,
-0.8483452796936035,
-0.2265673279762268,
0.3989773392677307,
-0.4848841428756714,
0.22082185745239258,
0.7009592652320862,
0.690895676612854,
-0.09704587608575821,
-0.15495583415031433,
0.5238427519798279,
0.5296714305877686,
0.4313172996044159,
0.021233342587947845,
0.9642587304115295,
-0.23755311965942383,
0.5529534220695496,
-0.6248469948768616,
0.11227919161319733,
-0.16633403301239014,
-0.37169045209884644,
-0.8223578929901123,
-0.9412930607795715,
-0.21867059171199799,
-0.6327088475227356,
0.16377496719360352,
0.6715297102928162,
0.6404195427894592,
-0.9698055982589722,
-0.2703160345554352,
-0.35740402340888977,
0.009241954423487186,
-0.023300547152757645,
-0.19206388294696808,
0.21484336256980896,
-0.5813111662864685,
-0.744178295135498,
0.43070703744888306,
-0.020960507914423943,
0.2894858419895172,
-0.6012187004089355,
-0.04518953338265419,
0.08043047785758972,
0.22995609045028687,
0.5276302695274353,
0.545016348361969,
-0.6382967829704285,
-0.3009907603263855,
-0.26820993423461914,
0.17906656861305237,
-0.0006056289421394467,
0.662360668182373,
-0.8647981286048889,
0.6991893649101257,
0.4919205904006958,
0.41920313239097595,
0.26829802989959717,
-0.09649024903774261,
1.0790114402770996,
-0.7316644787788391,
0.1092693954706192,
0.12730470299720764,
0.40420201420783997,
0.2495349943637848,
0.03279014676809311,
0.493167906999588,
0.41335707902908325,
-0.4151483476161957,
-1.4650310277938843,
0.26855364441871643,
-0.4849928915500641,
-0.233659029006958,
0.942603349685669,
0.11587991565465927,
-0.44878268241882324,
-0.09486646205186844,
0.14179116487503052,
0.14103800058364868,
-0.1908888965845108,
1.0865894556045532,
0.76481693983078,
-0.3029577136039734,
0.015082653611898422,
-0.8619359731674194,
0.5656852722167969,
0.21362698078155518,
-0.5146870017051697,
0.4453994035720825,
0.3882114589214325,
0.5033674836158752,
0.13815568387508392,
0.26542991399765015,
0.03691400587558746,
0.42043307423591614,
0.4760344624519348,
-0.11758854985237122,
0.10624842345714569,
-0.4080808758735657,
-0.4405544400215149,
0.04391065984964371,
0.024031637236475945,
-0.07141371816396713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05089v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05089v1
|
SEER-MoE: Sparse Expert Efficiency through Regularization for Mixture-of-Experts
| 2024-04-07T22:13:43 | 2024-04-07T22:13:43 |
Alexandre Muzio, Alex Sun, Churan He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The advancement of deep learning has led to the emergence of
Mixture-of-Experts (MoEs) models, known for their dynamic allocation of
computational resources based on input. Despite their promise, MoEs face
challenges, particularly in terms of memory requirements. To address this, our
work introduces SEER-MoE, a novel two-stage framework for reducing both the
memory footprint and compute requirements of pre-trained MoE models. The first
stage involves pruning the total number of experts using a heavy-hitters
counting guidance, while the second stage employs a regularization-based
fine-tuning strategy to recover accuracy loss and reduce the number of
activated experts during inference. Our empirical studies demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method, resulting in a sparse MoEs model optimized for
inference efficiency with minimal accuracy trade-offs.
|
[
-0.7792279124259949,
-0.735410749912262,
0.19521357119083405,
0.1438688486814499,
-0.1625673919916153,
-0.000436401111073792,
-0.3652164340019226,
-0.32208094000816345,
0.24307219684123993,
0.3864520490169525,
-0.44971662759780884,
0.034739889204502106,
-0.8078063130378723,
-0.12804260849952698,
0.008691403083503246,
0.7188863158226013,
0.16821883618831635,
0.08919788151979446,
-0.17465728521347046,
0.1734575778245926,
-0.7381995320320129,
0.09100668877363205,
-0.7310815453529358,
-0.1460421234369278,
0.7111673951148987,
0.6467592716217041,
0.7691638469696045,
0.4848841726779938,
0.47422802448272705,
0.28296324610710144,
-0.11451391875743866,
0.3747287094593048,
-0.978240966796875,
0.254904568195343,
-0.015994425863027573,
-0.5641210079193115,
-0.5029943585395813,
-0.15678247809410095,
0.5685775279998779,
0.8527018427848816,
-0.4033993184566498,
-0.18513968586921692,
0.2463710606098175,
0.43546661734580994,
-1.0378283262252808,
0.11179526150226593,
-0.7717498540878296,
0.12053712457418442,
0.042836856096982956,
-0.17583048343658447,
-0.3861573040485382,
0.08045721054077148,
0.2119390070438385,
-0.9758930206298828,
0.4677157402038574,
-0.15610989928245544,
0.5295692682266235,
1.0666868686676025,
-0.00990773644298315,
0.3352319300174713,
-0.7211088538169861,
1.161807656288147,
-0.620573103427887,
0.3879728615283966,
0.47826921939849854,
0.23945452272891998,
-0.08603274822235107,
-0.3677096664905548,
-0.37311241030693054,
0.22252285480499268,
0.0979418084025383,
0.33072155714035034,
0.05625259503722191,
0.028361668810248375,
0.019200801849365234,
0.28897297382354736,
-0.2837991714477539,
0.22076979279518127,
-0.46790143847465515,
0.010256776586174965,
0.6013228297233582,
0.04347679018974304,
-0.3254547417163849,
0.33139511942863464,
-0.35574108362197876,
0.12177849560976028,
-0.3995378315448761,
-0.36846160888671875,
0.17145223915576935,
0.06260459870100021,
0.12364473193883896,
0.3029712736606598,
-0.22532184422016144,
0.683236837387085,
0.31469404697418213,
-0.19472795724868774,
-0.26028814911842346,
-0.019098564982414246,
-0.10804980248212814,
-0.01640583574771881,
0.6204820871353149,
0.35726502537727356,
0.41828230023384094,
-0.21059580147266388,
-0.2314775139093399,
-0.04405113309621811,
0.3288426101207733,
-1.1065208911895752,
-0.775474488735199,
-0.0805424153804779,
-0.348678320646286,
-0.3116741478443146,
-0.12494571506977081,
-0.9478632211685181,
-0.5315297842025757,
-0.2739497125148773,
0.5684645175933838,
-0.42205363512039185,
-0.45627039670944214,
0.23790553212165833,
-0.1612538993358612,
-0.2022128850221634,
0.6424998641014099,
-0.6679351329803467,
0.3749326169490814,
0.7984322905540466,
0.589823305606842,
0.055772989988327026,
-0.10985330492258072,
-0.6382922530174255,
0.350585013628006,
-0.5544918179512024,
0.6305201649665833,
-0.9607128500938416,
-0.548443615436554,
-0.48802343010902405,
-0.7641292214393616,
-0.10994402319192886,
-0.7596269845962524,
0.0446973480284214,
-0.4922991991043091,
-0.02614915557205677,
-0.21980087459087372,
-0.46696409583091736,
-0.47329071164131165,
0.007147334516048431,
-0.4280148148536682,
1.2265249490737915,
0.016246888786554337,
-0.5444132089614868,
0.6460500955581665,
-0.41527241468429565,
-0.41221317648887634,
0.2051195651292801,
-0.3209090232849121,
-0.17654000222682953,
0.4700443744659424,
0.32716304063796997,
0.7044669985771179,
-0.35781776905059814,
0.39886054396629333,
-0.33374807238578796,
-0.5712856650352478,
-0.03301781415939331,
-0.3748919367790222,
0.3198379874229431,
0.4015486538410187,
-0.13500413298606873,
0.1506916582584381,
-0.7280584573745728,
-0.31903767585754395,
-0.14043357968330383,
-0.3503991663455963,
-0.4990331828594208,
0.37047380208969116,
-0.06707703322172165,
0.001590989762917161,
0.28339043259620667,
-0.22557732462882996,
0.20981766283512115,
-0.07829146832227707,
0.4046384394168854,
0.7156877517700195,
-0.000003786034994845977,
0.565566897392273,
-0.3705408573150635,
0.24545827507972717,
0.2487696409225464,
0.13221822679042816,
-0.2523578703403473,
-0.6831339001655579,
-1.0212733745574951,
-0.9496784210205078,
0.5294501781463623,
0.49221959710121155,
-0.7617377042770386,
0.6203782558441162,
-0.3346554636955261,
-0.4193207323551178,
-0.6376325488090515,
0.295276015996933,
0.40319058299064636,
0.6684408783912659,
0.47856372594833374,
-0.21278798580169678,
-0.3799116611480713,
-0.9194315075874329,
0.04796873405575752,
0.1823563128709793,
-0.05398017540574074,
0.3221018612384796,
0.27534881234169006,
-0.152186781167984,
0.9502684473991394,
-0.5314241051673889,
-0.2116013616323471,
0.0010356669081375003,
0.1489146500825882,
0.013742486014962196,
1.0356343984603882,
0.46863996982574463,
-0.738844096660614,
-0.5545578598976135,
-0.09629068523645401,
-0.7006720900535583,
0.10587739944458008,
-0.11868502199649811,
-0.33813872933387756,
-0.32077547907829285,
0.30533626675605774,
-0.5467561483383179,
0.4426411986351013,
0.15403026342391968,
0.03780565410852432,
0.04623706638813019,
-0.19958831369876862,
-0.010234415531158447,
-0.7404732704162598,
-0.1959189921617508,
0.018389534205198288,
-0.22254128754138947,
-0.4134187400341034,
0.23275072872638702,
-0.16395525634288788,
-0.10047502815723419,
0.03676386550068855,
0.5864466428756714,
-0.42229756712913513,
0.13022063672542572,
-0.06120723485946655,
-0.3277795910835266,
0.004166886676102877,
0.6180235147476196,
0.1701110303401947,
0.8779721856117249,
0.8600888252258301,
-0.7893622517585754,
-0.03486638516187668,
0.058766767382621765,
-0.268116295337677,
0.6865226626396179,
-0.5469269156455994,
0.13848327100276947,
-0.04934729263186455,
0.04565070569515228,
-0.8680814504623413,
-0.4227884113788605,
0.39190787076950073,
-0.2635433077812195,
0.7753899693489075,
-0.2843116819858551,
-0.48714977502822876,
-0.02284228801727295,
-0.30153805017471313,
0.4791184663772583,
0.8300337791442871,
-0.1092706173658371,
0.945024311542511,
0.3908761441707611,
-0.47182613611221313,
-0.5900500416755676,
-0.6919819712638855,
-0.00444744573906064,
0.039270222187042236,
-0.6932488083839417,
0.23644372820854187,
-0.051105938851833344,
-0.23076319694519043,
0.22147922217845917,
-0.2677466571331024,
-0.44707173109054565,
0.3311927318572998,
-0.016424918547272682,
0.0007836073054932058,
-0.38372549414634705,
-0.18964891135692596,
0.4777587652206421,
-0.33572515845298767,
-0.2073938399553299,
-0.23414292931556702,
0.311114639043808,
0.19560809433460236,
-0.43021702766418457,
-0.6400636434555054,
0.5916144847869873,
0.35977184772491455,
-0.3359161615371704,
0.9249145984649658,
0.6777805089950562,
-0.5929468870162964,
-0.23918402194976807,
-1.1156928539276123,
-0.3279895782470703,
-0.4578595459461212,
0.5277392268180847,
-0.38361409306526184,
-0.6226527094841003,
0.533833384513855,
-0.09432239085435867,
0.25370049476623535,
0.5293495059013367,
0.5409520864486694,
0.04669586569070816,
0.972507894039154,
0.3690144419670105,
-0.08449432253837585,
0.462380588054657,
-0.4512801766395569,
0.052253607660532,
-0.4912082552909851,
-0.34691569209098816,
-0.2876121401786804,
-0.675314724445343,
0.05635596439242363,
-0.8491429686546326,
0.34256887435913086,
0.4113820791244507,
-0.27913039922714233,
-0.2379312366247177,
-0.48191460967063904,
0.6482608318328857,
0.6878629922866821,
0.4806080460548401,
0.06332192569971085,
0.011170723475515842,
0.1564701944589615,
-0.0018924050964415073,
-1.1958938837051392,
-0.18119598925113678,
0.9764542579650879,
0.2511609196662903,
0.9163203835487366,
-0.1444767564535141,
0.7253543734550476,
0.15128202736377716,
0.13461466133594513,
-0.8173103332519531,
0.6610820293426514,
-0.02456728182733059,
-0.6772805452346802,
-0.29091620445251465,
-0.6119464635848999,
-0.6344106793403625,
0.3632093667984009,
-0.35406365990638733,
-0.4037400186061859,
0.6371005773544312,
0.3439996540546417,
-0.6275429129600525,
0.4194733202457428,
-0.8086299300193787,
0.6021433472633362,
0.15687274932861328,
-0.5936766266822815,
-0.7595298886299133,
-0.5570915937423706,
0.3638458251953125,
-0.30694907903671265,
-0.06135708466172218,
-0.08612468838691711,
-0.4933528006076813,
0.8616266250610352,
-0.6626321077346802,
0.8549275398254395,
-0.5418552756309509,
0.19678910076618195,
0.4075443148612976,
0.23452378809452057,
0.5316973924636841,
0.11394988745450974,
-0.2530643343925476,
0.3233100473880768,
-0.3884422779083252,
-0.7009770274162292,
-0.41696688532829285,
0.6159714460372925,
-0.6994659900665283,
-0.3895214796066284,
-0.01845463179051876,
-0.9015726447105408,
-0.3022305965423584,
0.2728649079799652,
0.2252735048532486,
0.4335991144180298,
0.07223381847143173,
0.5363604426383972,
1.0816407203674316,
0.020104942843317986,
0.016003118827939034,
0.37998732924461365,
0.16110026836395264,
-0.351200670003891,
1.1541646718978882,
0.3809542953968048,
-0.25039032101631165,
0.3801012337207794,
0.15581873059272766,
0.19879008829593658,
-0.989336371421814,
-0.19336383044719696,
0.10275312513113022,
-0.32921209931373596,
-0.21471300721168518,
-0.6115663647651672,
0.0673084482550621,
-0.13493625819683075,
-0.4975523054599762,
-0.605869710445404,
-0.21813133358955383,
-0.6624661684036255,
0.12261916697025299,
0.32426968216896057,
0.5924468636512756,
-0.1539108157157898,
0.5459476113319397,
-0.6789992451667786,
0.4328393042087555,
0.38674110174179077,
0.4473942816257477,
0.3226562440395355,
-0.40991130471229553,
-0.4433888792991638,
-0.11703295260667801,
-0.0936591848731041,
-0.46906915307044983,
0.21901577711105347,
0.3190862834453583,
0.7507947087287903,
0.9589880704879761,
0.11687566339969635,
0.9946022033691406,
-0.40435731410980225,
0.3686998784542084,
0.169253870844841,
-0.5600340962409973,
0.11202853918075562,
-0.49443578720092773,
-0.3262346684932709,
0.6943804621696472,
0.159105122089386,
0.18249058723449707,
-0.3205738663673401,
-0.44828933477401733,
-0.7939091324806213,
0.7446340918540955,
0.19204044342041016,
-0.01536866370588541,
0.04485095292329788,
0.3386286497116089,
0.4006517231464386,
0.2880476415157318,
0.2150038629770279,
-0.16120603680610657,
0.006009586621075869,
-0.3538116216659546,
-0.11867149919271469,
-0.6997019648551941,
-0.2557794451713562,
-0.45833972096443176,
0.5900319814682007,
0.274904727935791,
0.1443413347005844,
-0.005738315638154745,
-0.32684382796287537,
-0.06161123886704445,
-0.1299024373292923,
0.4273034930229187,
0.8285543322563171,
-0.27966535091400146,
-0.004629169590771198,
0.26187241077423096,
-0.5716233253479004,
-0.2517033517360687,
0.2630121111869812,
-0.3337309956550598,
-0.1527019739151001,
0.22346527874469757,
0.7597371339797974,
0.7871777415275574,
-0.44635146856307983,
0.2779773771762848,
0.26358309388160706,
-0.3728514015674591,
0.032844267785549164,
0.5045806765556335,
-0.018331408500671387,
0.46066856384277344,
0.6938526034355164,
0.8139112591743469,
0.21957194805145264,
0.05785772204399109,
0.19561287760734558,
0.2867788076400757,
-0.3047519624233246,
-0.23162955045700073,
0.8881279230117798,
0.6491456627845764,
-0.09442219138145447,
0.33335214853286743,
-0.12757806479930878,
-0.31907182931900024,
0.614337682723999,
-0.08239790052175522,
0.7129859924316406,
-0.2865420877933502,
-0.42920368909835815,
0.15696462988853455,
0.14437717199325562,
-0.2756222188472748,
0.288388192653656,
-0.21417422592639923,
-0.5891187787055969,
-0.6004223823547363,
-0.2969634234905243,
-0.34824150800704956,
-0.11297567933797836,
-0.901857316493988,
0.08369748294353485,
-0.6812655925750732,
-0.14834029972553253,
-0.07252084463834763,
-0.07664486765861511,
-0.8306953310966492,
-0.022275900468230247,
0.22165241837501526,
0.8799906969070435,
-0.5854917168617249,
0.5128228664398193,
0.5432577133178711,
0.009121069684624672,
-0.5192475318908691,
-0.2418883740901947,
-0.10394164174795151,
-0.7104389667510986,
0.4399913549423218,
0.16853435337543488,
-0.10783255845308304,
0.28614020347595215,
-0.6146534085273743,
-0.4898957908153534,
0.763927698135376,
0.3995828628540039,
-0.7726997137069702,
0.16044244170188904,
-0.6401591300964355,
0.11646618694067001,
-0.13873590528964996,
0.2725045382976532,
0.2986886203289032,
0.5603955388069153,
0.15901270508766174,
-0.7264703512191772,
-0.29638391733169556,
-0.36628636717796326,
0.06952543556690216,
0.34550249576568604,
-0.6524928212165833,
1.1078253984451294,
-0.20486389100551605,
0.19969536364078522,
-0.0038676599506288767,
1.0372679233551025,
0.1459258496761322,
0.28117913007736206,
0.556957483291626,
0.7739928960800171,
0.8615495562553406,
0.11333218216896057,
0.8986380100250244,
-0.41534632444381714,
0.22897668182849884,
0.9789263010025024,
-0.28002774715423584,
0.7789706587791443,
0.3213423788547516,
-0.3964073359966278,
0.06926632672548294,
0.7012118101119995,
-0.09470660239458084,
0.6022101044654846,
-0.13088038563728333,
-0.26381438970565796,
-0.8252041339874268,
0.18486368656158447,
-0.5140247344970703,
0.06333135813474655,
0.5425954461097717,
0.0458969883620739,
-0.135841503739357,
-0.09664645045995712,
0.07413317263126373,
-0.22173325717449188,
-0.5715236663818359,
0.7844025492668152,
-0.20389516651630402,
-0.6433782577514648,
0.46048402786254883,
-0.15090295672416687,
0.9780122637748718,
-0.48069918155670166,
-0.18234729766845703,
-0.15025779604911804,
0.31024202704429626,
-0.1309657245874405,
-0.5080487728118896,
-0.02536587044596672,
-0.009632705710828304,
-0.4162645936012268,
0.029780399054288864,
0.7251034379005432,
-0.5062816739082336,
-0.8052002787590027,
0.040976859629154205,
0.5525559186935425,
0.45061594247817993,
-0.3947843015193939,
-0.5745169520378113,
-0.47271299362182617,
-0.16353647410869598,
-0.40478086471557617,
0.4883982837200165,
0.5954622626304626,
0.07126319408416748,
0.6883688569068909,
0.5520951151847839,
-0.018401065841317177,
0.5162404179573059,
-0.10722071677446365,
1.010514736175537,
-0.1821412891149521,
-0.527110755443573,
-0.6393065452575684,
0.539968729019165,
0.046178046613931656,
-0.0774882510304451,
0.5668861269950867,
0.7634007930755615,
0.6756414771080017,
-0.18598122894763947,
0.6598185300827026,
0.008006357587873936,
0.5624411702156067,
-0.39567703008651733,
0.866777777671814,
-0.7135563492774963,
0.1987072229385376,
-0.11682463437318802,
-0.7318807244300842,
-0.2237238883972168,
0.830620527267456,
-0.332045316696167,
0.34212079644203186,
0.0065598031505942345,
0.9241434931755066,
-0.4125787615776062,
-0.2810618579387665,
0.3484492897987366,
0.2768060564994812,
-0.11659406125545502,
0.4595739543437958,
0.7560932040214539,
-0.10986524075269699,
0.4777000844478607,
-0.5289609432220459,
-0.2958347201347351,
-0.6725377440452576,
-0.650302529335022,
-0.9202294945716858,
-0.10254507511854172,
-0.49689236283302307,
0.19620053470134735,
-0.09667772054672241,
0.7001118659973145,
1.053087830543518,
-0.821708083152771,
0.05340198799967766,
0.04815611243247986,
0.05380656197667122,
-0.41903170943260193,
-0.1479281485080719,
0.14902466535568237,
-0.31106188893318176,
-0.8018379211425781,
0.4960581064224243,
0.2486390918493271,
-0.39808666706085205,
-0.1773921400308609,
-0.37830665707588196,
-0.05115673691034317,
0.13961705565452576,
0.47304943203926086,
0.02601112611591816,
-0.7325947880744934,
0.04831364005804062,
-0.17277072370052338,
0.16078802943229675,
0.04960278049111366,
0.6614671945571899,
-0.834071934223175,
0.6414061188697815,
0.6344319581985474,
0.8106749653816223,
0.46058762073516846,
0.027571214362978935,
0.5057782530784607,
-0.5508210062980652,
0.5840977430343628,
0.36431193351745605,
0.4363883137702942,
-0.013785325922071934,
-0.3146912455558777,
0.6581178903579712,
0.47450077533721924,
-0.4271099865436554,
-1.025925874710083,
-0.1146102026104927,
-1.1010185480117798,
-0.42435845732688904,
0.9143239259719849,
-0.16359321773052216,
0.2459486871957779,
-0.23600241541862488,
-0.24203146994113922,
0.30503222346305847,
-0.7487260699272156,
0.4767588675022125,
0.5079557299613953,
-0.04641934856772423,
-0.3776884973049164,
-0.6341756582260132,
0.1551448255777359,
0.6395315527915955,
-0.34173548221588135,
-0.3031691908836365,
0.5690614581108093,
0.2547853887081146,
0.05090121552348137,
0.4798327684402466,
0.4421228766441345,
0.09226418286561966,
0.42547160387039185,
0.06603354215621948,
-0.5567284822463989,
-0.6919502019882202,
0.05785607174038887,
0.10664668679237366,
-0.12036296725273132,
-0.3389361500740051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05088v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05088v1
|
How much reliable is ChatGPT's prediction on Information Extraction under Input Perturbations?
| 2024-04-07T22:06:19 | 2024-04-07T22:06:19 |
Ishani Mondal, Abhilasha Sancheti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we assess the robustness (reliability) of ChatGPT under input
perturbations for one of the most fundamental tasks of Information Extraction
(IE) i.e. Named Entity Recognition (NER). Despite the hype, the majority of the
researchers have vouched for its language understanding and generation
capabilities; a little attention has been paid to understand its robustness:
How the input-perturbations affect 1) the predictions, 2) the confidence of
predictions and 3) the quality of rationale behind its prediction. We perform a
systematic analysis of ChatGPT's robustness (under both zero-shot and few-shot
setup) on two NER datasets using both automatic and human evaluation. Based on
automatic evaluation metrics, we find that 1) ChatGPT is more brittle on Drug
or Disease replacements (rare entities) compared to the perturbations on widely
known Person or Location entities, 2) the quality of explanations for the same
entity considerably differ under different types of "Entity-Specific" and
"Context-Specific" perturbations and the quality can be significantly improved
using in-context learning, and 3) it is overconfident for majority of the
incorrect predictions, and hence it could lead to misguidance of the end-users.
|
[
-0.2959417700767517,
-0.8708868622779846,
0.5440289974212646,
0.08210010081529617,
-0.19655053317546844,
0.0854734554886818,
-0.2881847023963928,
-0.43975287675857544,
-0.11075425893068314,
0.1376924067735672,
-0.21695005893707275,
-0.26923808455467224,
-0.9250936508178711,
0.17077921330928802,
-0.4332718253135681,
1.2205580472946167,
0.1320754736661911,
0.16161145269870758,
-0.0005386431002989411,
0.2816563844680786,
-0.5746858716011047,
-0.6961187720298767,
-0.6976505517959595,
-0.23569676280021667,
0.5855685472488403,
0.48782452940940857,
0.7240961790084839,
0.3572556972503662,
0.813793420791626,
0.18046365678310394,
-0.20964132249355316,
-0.3430885970592499,
-0.5713282823562622,
0.3744073808193207,
-0.06960710883140564,
-0.3926393389701843,
-0.23562321066856384,
-0.25737255811691284,
0.5921083092689514,
0.34467896819114685,
-0.18019455671310425,
0.0462445504963398,
0.49908140301704407,
0.2228219211101532,
-0.3931364119052887,
0.2905608117580414,
-1.0094754695892334,
-0.042190924286842346,
-0.2953663766384125,
-0.0984177514910698,
-0.3204289376735687,
-0.0436505451798439,
0.49347612261772156,
-0.4378361701965332,
0.12416812032461166,
-0.11043165624141693,
1.3198152780532837,
0.4967798590660095,
-0.10654524713754654,
-0.2832118272781372,
-0.8712695837020874,
0.5934981107711792,
-0.41041094064712524,
0.3479210138320923,
0.4738215208053589,
0.5772002339363098,
-0.5817470550537109,
-0.7341862916946411,
-0.5335540175437927,
-0.33306652307510376,
0.0645599365234375,
0.22426046431064606,
-0.11256979405879974,
-0.02677508257329464,
0.5044955015182495,
0.2698464095592499,
-0.3804510533809662,
0.10254065692424774,
-0.15853743255138397,
-0.3525935113430023,
0.17038065195083618,
-0.107368603348732,
0.4578530192375183,
-0.4486447274684906,
-0.585732638835907,
-0.0686861053109169,
-0.7524946928024292,
0.0986444279551506,
0.3559463620185852,
0.17648035287857056,
0.21500524878501892,
0.5361200571060181,
-0.039021190255880356,
0.3109051287174225,
0.16057388484477997,
-0.17624086141586304,
0.07877279072999954,
-0.36568117141723633,
-0.13376455008983612,
0.13435226678848267,
0.9849103093147278,
0.06645846366882324,
0.13338257372379303,
-0.4366091191768646,
-0.2470252364873886,
-0.15123802423477173,
0.11869040131568909,
-0.7684435844421387,
-0.5177307724952698,
0.16452375054359436,
-0.2515106797218323,
-0.3697319030761719,
0.10770241916179657,
-0.9881390929222107,
-0.42338091135025024,
0.04398980364203453,
0.5407859086990356,
-0.7646804451942444,
-0.11275360733270645,
-0.1380261927843094,
-0.10567066818475723,
0.27028241753578186,
0.44173064827919006,
-0.723193883895874,
0.24579238891601562,
0.5052149891853333,
0.6940735578536987,
-0.45896023511886597,
-0.2010771483182907,
-0.4985875189304352,
-0.29860273003578186,
0.17329470813274384,
1.1426209211349487,
-0.5021172165870667,
-0.24553461372852325,
-0.6202282905578613,
-0.1786220222711563,
-0.2631945013999939,
-0.48851075768470764,
0.6918848156929016,
-0.3257553279399872,
0.08277153968811035,
-0.3473844528198242,
-0.46176430583000183,
0.008426140062510967,
0.279670387506485,
-0.6743404269218445,
0.6431850790977478,
0.011349444277584553,
-1.0031658411026,
0.7263092398643494,
-0.4734830856323242,
-0.2218398004770279,
0.15981246531009674,
-0.2869769036769867,
-0.6300461888313293,
-0.13521994650363922,
0.33335649967193604,
0.16668637096881866,
-0.20354314148426056,
0.2807273268699646,
-0.35847529768943787,
-0.40732496976852417,
0.6221586465835571,
-0.9451851844787598,
0.6745750904083252,
0.056954652070999146,
-0.44507357478141785,
-0.2850957214832306,
-0.7875702977180481,
-0.08933824300765991,
0.08091209828853607,
-0.5623301863670349,
0.14130622148513794,
0.20385800302028656,
-0.025877056643366814,
0.1930212378501892,
-0.11196964979171753,
-0.6956876516342163,
0.16177129745483398,
-0.41049814224243164,
0.31229516863822937,
0.5180225372314453,
0.39950695633888245,
0.19568687677383423,
-0.01610669493675232,
0.6077380180358887,
0.013348542153835297,
0.008802947588264942,
-0.10382013767957687,
-0.5327927470207214,
-0.3238578140735626,
-0.20630376040935516,
0.8857269287109375,
0.7402615547180176,
-0.6583805680274963,
0.14063861966133118,
-0.3238823115825653,
-0.5107173323631287,
0.01721552386879921,
-0.12313615530729294,
0.3307114839553833,
0.764714777469635,
0.3182665705680847,
-0.3724285960197449,
-0.5735582709312439,
-0.5851107835769653,
-0.31970325112342834,
-0.3241238594055176,
-0.1617213487625122,
0.24846170842647552,
0.4964725971221924,
-0.2788166403770447,
0.8992859125137329,
-0.05196869745850563,
-0.12059124559164047,
-0.1836923360824585,
0.1566442847251892,
0.1747405230998993,
0.38675594329833984,
0.1761336475610733,
-0.7487965226173401,
-0.38752758502960205,
-0.07861389964818954,
-0.5719814300537109,
0.12732040882110596,
-0.06382013112306595,
0.13749350607395172,
-0.09858039021492004,
0.1308722048997879,
-0.6370432376861572,
0.6036537885665894,
0.3345319628715515,
-0.0317993238568306,
0.7493119835853577,
0.17829470336437225,
-0.04636289179325104,
-0.9588395357131958,
0.05546868219971657,
0.011698376387357712,
-0.071721151471138,
-0.4150092601776123,
-0.24372127652168274,
-0.25257959961891174,
-0.19387316703796387,
-0.21379323303699493,
0.3028262257575989,
-0.3272085189819336,
-0.021678786724805832,
-0.018224749714136124,
0.17021827399730682,
-0.24880827963352203,
0.2412385493516922,
-0.10538890212774277,
0.7341144680976868,
0.6070889234542847,
-0.4544980823993683,
0.21126635372638702,
0.24088017642498016,
-0.305448979139328,
0.4094560146331787,
-0.8238099813461304,
0.16485457122325897,
-0.06958181411027908,
0.13496097922325134,
-0.9745290875434875,
-0.44261065125465393,
0.3869267404079437,
-0.9725880026817322,
0.5385267734527588,
-0.4419287145137787,
-0.3683203160762787,
0.1496439129114151,
0.09412023425102234,
0.0772605761885643,
0.360841304063797,
-0.3603363633155823,
0.44089341163635254,
0.5241320729255676,
-0.07468198239803314,
-0.8381690979003906,
-0.568098783493042,
0.1563645452260971,
-0.19791767001152039,
-0.44003206491470337,
-0.01903853937983513,
0.17584076523780823,
-0.17589910328388214,
0.0018391829216852784,
-0.46098703145980835,
-0.12493766099214554,
0.29688939452171326,
0.5032138824462891,
0.31506308913230896,
-0.23478132486343384,
0.32483014464378357,
-0.24731899797916412,
-0.3048348128795624,
-0.08144577592611313,
-0.13278529047966003,
0.546768069267273,
-0.30145400762557983,
-0.3309967517852783,
-0.20137262344360352,
-0.14741145074367523,
0.3223125636577606,
-0.026088772341609,
0.4602368474006653,
0.6523273587226868,
-0.42607277631759644,
0.16742447018623352,
-0.40358805656433105,
-0.24319811165332794,
-0.3880016505718231,
0.5507774353027344,
-0.4092462956905365,
-0.5382887721061707,
0.5410299301147461,
-0.049563199281692505,
-0.04890913516283035,
0.602839469909668,
0.3281676471233368,
-0.2142457365989685,
0.8442423343658447,
0.2960320711135864,
-0.08095606416463852,
0.3944854140281677,
0.028293561190366745,
0.2515254020690918,
-0.776560366153717,
-0.12870731949806213,
-0.54429692029953,
-0.14963416755199432,
-0.8378635048866272,
0.020608287304639816,
0.33443498611450195,
0.10446162521839142,
-0.023990854620933533,
0.42084360122680664,
-0.47625234723091125,
0.3026181161403656,
0.32696521282196045,
0.10443785786628723,
0.12385524809360504,
0.2906131446361542,
-0.1479293256998062,
-0.09085212647914886,
-0.6668068170547485,
-0.7793347835540771,
1.1790508031845093,
0.47527235746383667,
0.7787465453147888,
0.008815165609121323,
0.7344823479652405,
-0.06349153071641922,
0.1542932242155075,
-0.9717966318130493,
0.3043232858181,
-0.009509093128144741,
-0.5199956297874451,
-0.4139153063297272,
-0.40336427092552185,
-1.1956018209457397,
0.07388811558485031,
-0.5406761765480042,
-1.1833072900772095,
0.4050711989402771,
0.23801490664482117,
-0.5106782913208008,
0.24397094547748566,
-0.7247509956359863,
0.6543274521827698,
-0.15296363830566406,
-0.21414309740066528,
0.28760024905204773,
-0.7311477065086365,
-0.022696081548929214,
-0.12306295335292816,
-0.031787000596523285,
-0.10968230664730072,
0.14645777642726898,
0.6520763635635376,
-0.18442922830581665,
0.5155846476554871,
-0.09998618066310883,
0.2250330150127411,
0.2232876420021057,
0.20307877659797668,
0.46062171459198,
0.3500272035598755,
-0.21977390348911285,
0.39017438888549805,
0.11656752228736877,
-0.20769821107387543,
-0.6532341837882996,
0.42661812901496887,
-0.674204409122467,
-0.49904078245162964,
-0.4719589054584503,
-0.03903236240148544,
-0.38836953043937683,
0.33358442783355713,
0.9346879720687866,
0.6025778651237488,
-0.1856144517660141,
0.32854583859443665,
0.700213611125946,
-0.1802234649658203,
0.3257136642932892,
0.0038129074964672327,
0.04831309989094734,
-0.34098127484321594,
0.9727582335472107,
0.4246678352355957,
0.20882326364517212,
0.3672860562801361,
0.14922921359539032,
0.03231445327401161,
-0.6476539969444275,
-0.459746778011322,
-0.11338001489639282,
-0.605583667755127,
-0.2174656242132187,
-0.5898247361183167,
-0.3520708680152893,
-0.03695182129740715,
0.42786452174186707,
-0.4082905352115631,
-0.44075968861579895,
-0.2287037968635559,
-0.08815620839595795,
-0.07317768782377243,
0.6281965970993042,
0.19723635911941528,
0.24816201627254486,
-0.6270111203193665,
0.0410262793302536,
0.21264533698558807,
0.4022631347179413,
-0.4082748293876648,
-0.4780132472515106,
0.07483270019292831,
0.06677916646003723,
-0.16368255019187927,
-1.1446062326431274,
0.027740921825170517,
0.14228734374046326,
0.6225576400756836,
0.44864988327026367,
-0.14638200402259827,
0.5371220707893372,
-0.20164898037910461,
0.7621764540672302,
-0.06157159060239792,
-0.5753252506256104,
0.4107922613620758,
-0.1928628534078598,
0.22690987586975098,
0.7065325975418091,
0.29022687673568726,
-0.33829331398010254,
-0.38034483790397644,
-0.9142906665802002,
-0.8433482646942139,
0.46534764766693115,
0.31647127866744995,
-0.06337548792362213,
0.0732496976852417,
0.466291606426239,
0.27508512139320374,
0.017257293686270714,
-0.7168199419975281,
-0.037349455058574677,
-0.22792108356952667,
0.06196621060371399,
0.23417718708515167,
-0.4867766797542572,
0.4036898910999298,
0.038323596119880676,
0.6932494044303894,
0.11953531205654144,
0.5404086709022522,
0.3816488981246948,
-0.15601348876953125,
-0.054574597626924515,
0.3526054918766022,
0.18899191915988922,
0.6372932195663452,
-0.26243868470191956,
0.1923547238111496,
0.19656963646411896,
-0.8597448468208313,
-0.16662941873073578,
0.17824675142765045,
-0.3124556243419647,
0.080347441136837,
0.3022928535938263,
0.7464700937271118,
-0.006975907366722822,
-0.5744267106056213,
0.47978100180625916,
-0.4879642128944397,
0.11238066852092743,
-0.4554334282875061,
0.05777391791343689,
-0.39731621742248535,
0.07748180627822876,
0.3509460985660553,
0.4955987334251404,
0.27485474944114685,
-0.2969014346599579,
0.32830584049224854,
0.5399301648139954,
-0.5914414525032043,
-0.4392971992492676,
0.5267267227172852,
-0.23471367359161377,
-0.2608245313167572,
0.7290967106819153,
-0.2752476632595062,
-0.6421617269515991,
0.48468467593193054,
0.4307059645652771,
0.7588785290718079,
-0.15503448247909546,
0.04874882847070694,
0.5515242218971252,
0.3711739778518677,
-0.05301223322749138,
-0.09452454000711441,
-0.013389901258051395,
-0.8871289491653442,
-0.36979442834854126,
-0.5554492473602295,
-0.5629594922065735,
0.2531839609146118,
-0.40249156951904297,
0.455778032541275,
-0.31171858310699463,
-0.5842822790145874,
0.19641470909118652,
-0.06678413599729538,
-0.6173376441001892,
0.25857672095298767,
0.08589406311511993,
0.4620727002620697,
-0.43063825368881226,
0.5840997099876404,
0.679664134979248,
-0.6047767996788025,
-1.1793047189712524,
0.49681758880615234,
0.08779459446668625,
-0.5684970617294312,
0.4941892623901367,
0.01806461252272129,
-0.03381997346878052,
-0.26389479637145996,
-0.5962154269218445,
-1.218496561050415,
0.7818343043327332,
0.5889677405357361,
-0.5046129822731018,
-0.1089036837220192,
-0.15071675181388855,
0.48844602704048157,
0.08618582785129547,
0.5183931589126587,
0.38448449969291687,
0.3724752962589264,
0.30126652121543884,
-1.1903958320617676,
-0.013739321380853653,
-0.23262648284435272,
-0.2473946362733841,
0.07133153080940247,
-0.2514156103134155,
0.7344153523445129,
-0.2525925636291504,
-0.6566973924636841,
-0.1247379332780838,
0.20009365677833557,
-0.05165209248661995,
-0.03182925283908844,
0.4471789300441742,
0.29142501950263977,
0.7953842282295227,
-0.35129132866859436,
1.1203521490097046,
-0.16437292098999023,
0.45932143926620483,
1.2116665840148926,
0.0821509137749672,
0.8772517442703247,
0.4311974346637726,
-0.2711390256881714,
0.4776483178138733,
0.603421151638031,
-0.23278675973415375,
0.33734118938446045,
0.014770878478884697,
0.04448315128684044,
-0.009834127500653267,
0.22644782066345215,
-0.11558636277914047,
0.7498528361320496,
0.4835670292377472,
-0.32505151629447937,
-0.1582120656967163,
-0.1643439680337906,
0.09130242466926575,
-0.592440664768219,
0.0549197718501091,
0.932483434677124,
-0.03130766376852989,
-0.6774786114692688,
0.513254702091217,
-0.3180532455444336,
0.3681425154209137,
-0.3585939407348633,
-0.1380595862865448,
0.06637752801179886,
0.098326675593853,
-0.41904905438423157,
-0.6692391037940979,
0.1858483999967575,
-0.19428987801074982,
0.09728715568780899,
0.24543997645378113,
1.2880709171295166,
-0.08135001361370087,
-0.20829862356185913,
-0.049812544137239456,
0.4435044527053833,
0.4050869047641754,
-0.28270649909973145,
-0.4966675639152527,
-0.17184767127037048,
0.07827451825141907,
-0.3851625323295593,
0.3930351734161377,
0.43056613206863403,
0.09665262699127197,
0.5917471051216125,
0.4919534921646118,
0.4166695177555084,
0.06784434616565704,
-0.38681718707084656,
0.6617345809936523,
-0.2836414873600006,
-0.06350869685411453,
-1.107020378112793,
0.37051576375961304,
-0.2130657583475113,
-0.34899023175239563,
0.6976792216300964,
0.3502005636692047,
0.5625975728034973,
0.2729640603065491,
0.8566069006919861,
-0.09564746916294098,
0.39334583282470703,
-0.2679794132709503,
0.6921396255493164,
-0.06036903336644173,
0.43978992104530334,
-0.449477881193161,
-0.9060036540031433,
-0.19378554821014404,
0.5599385499954224,
-0.37448644638061523,
-0.02726341225206852,
0.7385565042495728,
0.52791827917099,
0.03743303567171097,
0.12340167909860611,
0.2574932277202606,
0.3477765619754791,
0.26271581649780273,
0.2884742021560669,
0.7766185998916626,
-0.39920711517333984,
0.7667840123176575,
-0.2312963604927063,
-0.21926529705524445,
-0.14279577136039734,
-0.8218972682952881,
-0.40874096751213074,
-0.45648568868637085,
-0.2773767113685608,
-0.5842034816741943,
0.11351672559976578,
0.7628189325332642,
0.5356088876724243,
-0.912646472454071,
0.21061579883098602,
-0.12695352733135223,
0.2902579605579376,
-0.06177487596869469,
-0.20621706545352936,
0.38564491271972656,
-0.3851689100265503,
-0.5118943452835083,
0.14173533022403717,
0.36118075251579285,
-0.02183401584625244,
0.023691369220614433,
0.2206444889307022,
0.19080379605293274,
-0.1437307894229889,
0.3465501368045807,
0.49087849259376526,
-0.5380986332893372,
-0.3909186124801636,
0.0237897802144289,
-0.11040278524160385,
0.4032079577445984,
0.3946172595024109,
-0.6781145930290222,
0.5848062634468079,
0.3555903434753418,
0.7336075901985168,
0.41122549772262573,
0.2054675668478012,
0.572785496711731,
-0.4463994801044464,
-0.23423822224140167,
0.32298097014427185,
0.533968448638916,
0.2477458268404007,
-0.6108464002609253,
0.4639785885810852,
0.2189284861087799,
-0.8251884579658508,
-0.6536445021629333,
0.05806495249271393,
-0.8975806832313538,
0.15025287866592407,
1.4132094383239746,
-0.3079097270965576,
-0.2969844341278076,
-0.2688446044921875,
-0.39564159512519836,
0.3320348560810089,
-0.6248480677604675,
0.7910069823265076,
0.8044253587722778,
-0.39555418491363525,
-0.17256398499011993,
-0.62156742811203,
0.41965410113334656,
0.31233927607536316,
-0.5136744379997253,
-0.15662933886051178,
0.27288973331451416,
0.5922751426696777,
0.31864801049232483,
0.396337628364563,
-0.33730995655059814,
0.31198328733444214,
0.1719816029071808,
-0.11757439374923706,
0.12134994566440582,
-0.04287891462445259,
-0.27198269963264465,
0.28569296002388,
0.4144071936607361,
-0.14871062338352203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05086v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05086v1
|
A Note on LoRA
| 2024-04-07T22:00:50 | 2024-04-07T22:00:50 |
Vlad Fomenko, Han Yu, Jongho Lee, Stanley Hsieh, Weizhu Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
LoRA (Low-Rank Adaptation) has emerged as a preferred method for efficiently
adapting Large Language Models (LLMs) with remarkable simplicity and efficacy.
This note extends the original LoRA paper by offering new perspectives that
were not initially discussed and presents a series of insights for deploying
LoRA at scale. Without introducing new experiments, we aim to improve the
understanding and application of LoRA.
|
[
-0.17827779054641724,
-0.7706195116043091,
0.6253629326820374,
0.16980800032615662,
-0.14243453741073608,
-0.15169864892959595,
-0.21744637191295624,
-0.537908673286438,
0.45256316661834717,
0.7216264009475708,
-0.07360835373401642,
-0.44479742646217346,
-0.6738254427909851,
-0.11883413791656494,
-0.6597945690155029,
0.9895854592323303,
0.12966038286685944,
-0.41767990589141846,
0.192816823720932,
-0.3943702280521393,
-0.19350557029247284,
-0.4933171272277832,
-0.8434350490570068,
-0.44791558384895325,
1.1239207983016968,
0.7054406404495239,
0.6114254593849182,
0.5300797820091248,
0.7516666054725647,
0.2186630219221115,
-0.2690628468990326,
-0.0010766061022877693,
-0.8224939703941345,
-0.1688317060470581,
-0.13556984066963196,
-0.9143038988113403,
-0.8327257633209229,
0.0031596289481967688,
0.9308796525001526,
1.112966775894165,
-0.28757238388061523,
0.4035031497478485,
0.19067969918251038,
0.8935984373092651,
-0.6816520690917969,
-0.3044898211956024,
-0.8156400918960571,
-0.053309522569179535,
-0.19042199850082397,
-0.13260799646377563,
-0.6010663509368896,
-0.36381033062934875,
0.012527892366051674,
-0.6248360872268677,
-0.41319775581359863,
-0.07674100250005722,
0.43146294355392456,
0.3979904353618622,
-0.48550477623939514,
-0.014968190342187881,
-1.000952124595642,
0.6408405303955078,
-0.829902708530426,
-0.18098066747188568,
0.06984883546829224,
0.6068354249000549,
-0.25322529673576355,
-0.626499354839325,
-0.2680281698703766,
-0.06241464614868164,
0.37895411252975464,
-0.15858136117458344,
-0.38060733675956726,
-0.21606223285198212,
0.3498377203941345,
0.3986533284187317,
0.14682647585868835,
0.7233336567878723,
-0.28072822093963623,
0.3680034577846527,
0.43520453572273254,
0.030254453420639038,
-0.0957469716668129,
-0.030941084027290344,
-0.17774848639965057,
0.16737283766269684,
-1.0295779705047607,
0.05450303107500076,
0.005996169056743383,
0.7430082559585571,
-0.3943486213684082,
0.7172115445137024,
-0.31511059403419495,
0.5391194820404053,
-0.046368155628442764,
-0.40279731154441833,
0.09131283313035965,
-0.05064947158098221,
-0.10806901752948761,
0.040215104818344116,
0.3892892003059387,
0.270715594291687,
0.06904521584510803,
0.017657890915870667,
-0.16384686529636383,
0.0280632134526968,
0.08570758998394012,
-0.745398759841919,
0.007558595389127731,
-0.12967714667320251,
-0.5449554324150085,
-0.4053976237773895,
-0.38506314158439636,
-0.8281356692314148,
-0.6999467611312866,
0.06075066328048706,
0.6823976635932922,
0.12825262546539307,
0.11705134809017181,
-0.0343845933675766,
0.20172536373138428,
0.6692108511924744,
0.8576217293739319,
-0.9670925736427307,
0.7010005712509155,
0.6846652626991272,
0.8937411904335022,
-0.39158421754837036,
-0.20265983045101166,
-0.9107493758201599,
0.14936284720897675,
-0.37908679246902466,
1.1484768390655518,
-0.2696908116340637,
-0.39058804512023926,
-0.03897692263126373,
0.0026577101089060307,
-0.06016482785344124,
-0.5472407937049866,
0.6842619180679321,
-0.4280543327331543,
0.06916698068380356,
-0.39195898175239563,
-0.19744081795215607,
-0.0840415507555008,
-0.04440918192267418,
-0.6541422605514526,
1.0012123584747314,
0.48246076703071594,
-0.6964195370674133,
0.11594418436288834,
-1.2950390577316284,
-0.4159591495990753,
-0.12296797335147858,
0.24523304402828217,
-0.25418686866760254,
0.5218037366867065,
0.16611555218696594,
0.06379921734333038,
-0.3249482810497284,
-0.5832827091217041,
-0.44201624393463135,
-0.5636500716209412,
0.44718870520591736,
-0.100121408700943,
0.5721765756607056,
0.283576637506485,
-0.09127262234687805,
-0.01356554962694645,
-0.7837324738502502,
-0.07812533527612686,
0.15448135137557983,
-0.7048050165176392,
-0.534432590007782,
0.23104925453662872,
-0.010213845409452915,
-0.03626526892185211,
0.4034881591796875,
-0.3067406117916107,
0.5518922805786133,
-0.47322389483451843,
0.64366215467453,
0.8114938139915466,
-0.12658503651618958,
0.6691425442695618,
-0.22191010415554047,
0.5020274519920349,
-0.017134960740804672,
0.2516716420650482,
0.048847150057554245,
-0.4047369062900543,
-1.2171745300292969,
-0.2519298195838928,
0.5083974599838257,
0.5034639239311218,
-0.4783245921134949,
0.24321074783802032,
-0.4070507287979126,
-0.4819421172142029,
-0.5779905915260315,
0.6158644556999207,
-0.014145619235932827,
0.2869040369987488,
0.1764589101076126,
-0.1878986358642578,
-0.4757152795791626,
-0.7821357250213623,
-0.22640199959278107,
-0.2932041585445404,
0.49156618118286133,
0.07767367362976074,
0.5089689493179321,
-0.3713909387588501,
0.9293906688690186,
-0.5151581168174744,
-0.12880851328372955,
-0.5788904428482056,
-0.0958423838019371,
0.545013964176178,
0.2604016065597534,
0.7042999863624573,
-0.3605668246746063,
-0.5716897249221802,
0.11573097109794617,
-0.7708195447921753,
-0.10878220200538635,
0.23525983095169067,
-0.20187091827392578,
0.16992498934268951,
0.5965466499328613,
-0.2667727470397949,
0.3282637596130371,
0.9151967167854309,
-0.07294842600822449,
-0.12114129215478897,
-0.35191085934638977,
-0.23608362674713135,
-1.3733038902282715,
0.060985688120126724,
-0.14843596518039703,
-0.4252864420413971,
-0.7671535611152649,
0.11325287073850632,
-0.2642785608768463,
-0.17434677481651306,
-0.4347096383571625,
0.6865932941436768,
-0.3087611198425293,
-0.5297623872756958,
-0.4955563545227051,
0.5165469646453857,
-0.20166510343551636,
0.21836185455322266,
-0.28234198689460754,
0.7516576051712036,
0.36228492856025696,
-0.614256739616394,
-0.07145886868238449,
0.28436970710754395,
-0.5298639535903931,
0.6686162948608398,
-0.5758102536201477,
0.41471898555755615,
-0.07479934394359589,
0.10517029464244843,
-0.8863455057144165,
-0.27203261852264404,
0.0722360610961914,
0.0974850207567215,
-0.09507229179143906,
-0.38731181621551514,
-0.3989505469799042,
-0.23803859949111938,
-0.5237296223640442,
0.2242276817560196,
0.8855701088905334,
-0.6607142686843872,
0.5505465865135193,
0.6556288003921509,
-0.16732357442378998,
-0.3760530352592468,
-0.7920188307762146,
0.2119893878698349,
-0.7804458737373352,
-0.11538587510585785,
-0.04412297531962395,
-0.301512211561203,
-0.6481679677963257,
-0.2570182681083679,
0.048977967351675034,
0.0932728722691536,
0.7522602677345276,
0.2515062987804413,
-0.015082918107509613,
-0.7574260830879211,
-0.26023873686790466,
-0.08547666668891907,
-0.15883956849575043,
-0.24661707878112793,
0.1372312307357788,
0.20702849328517914,
-0.022114023566246033,
-0.24714148044586182,
-0.39089974761009216,
0.3186122477054596,
0.6436320543289185,
0.3301268517971039,
0.803379476070404,
0.16348955035209656,
-0.18036425113677979,
-0.5279579758644104,
-0.2499653398990631,
0.2626451551914215,
-0.5187151432037354,
0.320361852645874,
-0.20818506181240082,
-0.8405008316040039,
0.6452730894088745,
-0.4170739948749542,
-0.001199461636133492,
0.6561679244041443,
0.37639138102531433,
-0.4310856759548187,
0.5324280858039856,
1.3692708015441895,
-0.3149893581867218,
0.7668255567550659,
-0.14626942574977875,
0.5176095962524414,
-1.1447793245315552,
0.15077123045921326,
-0.9064465165138245,
-0.46997204422950745,
-0.842995822429657,
-0.6237450242042542,
0.5321541428565979,
0.45031023025512695,
-0.08736958354711533,
0.21457190811634064,
-0.11991748958826065,
0.4956855773925781,
0.2376769781112671,
-0.024584626778960228,
0.7246193885803223,
0.20457321405410767,
0.6081961989402771,
0.10320731997489929,
-0.7888383865356445,
-0.41271135210990906,
1.1075299978256226,
0.5023805499076843,
1.105844497680664,
0.5810973048210144,
0.9295980930328369,
0.40414685010910034,
0.6598706245422363,
-1.0834442377090454,
0.6295006275177002,
-0.536695122718811,
-0.24750827252864838,
-0.6611963510513306,
-0.13088196516036987,
-1.1691958904266357,
0.3195219337940216,
-0.12245205044746399,
-0.965674102306366,
0.11709806323051453,
0.08543496578931808,
-0.6608166098594666,
0.22881485521793365,
-0.7258392572402954,
0.47327369451522827,
-0.13646124303340912,
0.01640825718641281,
-0.26009318232536316,
-0.17408402264118195,
0.3077448308467865,
-0.5059622526168823,
0.48802778124809265,
-0.1603717803955078,
-0.3846699595451355,
1.141552209854126,
-0.33832088112831116,
0.9395203590393066,
-0.21123085916042328,
-0.7150558829307556,
0.28558996319770813,
-0.15302029252052307,
0.694053053855896,
-0.32394900918006897,
-0.2918020784854889,
-0.21344630420207977,
-0.18034027516841888,
-0.5301079750061035,
-0.6467389464378357,
1.0914883613586426,
-1.09691321849823,
-0.7146267294883728,
-0.3504844605922699,
-0.660908043384552,
-0.475190132856369,
0.19683389365673065,
-0.19400270283222198,
0.15300269424915314,
-0.5183340311050415,
0.25528445839881897,
0.7177422046661377,
-0.22399687767028809,
0.6200664639472961,
0.4603428542613983,
-0.7488706707954407,
-0.22931566834449768,
0.6526488661766052,
0.3697335124015808,
0.4726513624191284,
0.5827342867851257,
0.25571778416633606,
0.1020844578742981,
-0.8726712465286255,
-0.17212292551994324,
0.4789039194583893,
-1.1257164478302002,
0.13946934044361115,
-0.40734851360321045,
-0.13305094838142395,
-0.07403888553380966,
-0.24394457042217255,
-0.5559976100921631,
-0.8427698612213135,
-0.12928931415081024,
0.1643487811088562,
0.6899320483207703,
1.0947613716125488,
0.039503347128629684,
0.7120946049690247,
-0.2654419243335724,
0.5120689272880554,
0.5516793727874756,
0.15619197487831116,
-0.26828232407569885,
-1.1200642585754395,
-0.5170548558235168,
-0.17385493218898773,
0.06441432237625122,
-0.258749395608902,
0.12352573871612549,
0.37682461738586426,
0.6418898701667786,
0.02780943736433983,
-0.04823781177401543,
0.6857903599739075,
-0.3136679530143738,
0.7271862626075745,
-0.0538640022277832,
-0.7604454159736633,
0.5665217638015747,
-0.5013521909713745,
0.3981420397758484,
0.5806059241294861,
0.00026508542941883206,
-0.266746461391449,
0.25787243247032166,
-0.19672183692455292,
-0.7101574540138245,
0.52138751745224,
-0.21706943213939667,
0.5025611519813538,
0.47452837228775024,
0.40672141313552856,
0.15624971687793732,
0.05380505695939064,
-0.8358297944068909,
-0.23546990752220154,
0.20290017127990723,
0.020758744329214096,
-0.4936656951904297,
-0.49540093541145325,
-0.2456933557987213,
-0.22093814611434937,
0.3898601531982422,
-0.4079679846763611,
0.43141794204711914,
-0.18988680839538574,
-0.36551010608673096,
-0.10765543580055237,
0.6270837783813477,
0.5142920017242432,
0.7789481282234192,
-0.1466870903968811,
0.24265925586223602,
0.5071648955345154,
-0.24022166430950165,
0.09652114659547806,
-0.37852877378463745,
-0.2847188115119934,
-0.3302937150001526,
0.49190160632133484,
0.8721405863761902,
0.6382311582565308,
-0.36548081040382385,
0.34024184942245483,
0.3380240201950073,
-0.1002475693821907,
-0.2058500498533249,
0.18272627890110016,
0.25095242261886597,
0.24500203132629395,
0.33389991521835327,
-0.03202011436223984,
-0.2562426030635834,
-1.0237396955490112,
-0.28199243545532227,
0.18794383108615875,
-0.28497904539108276,
-0.3216499090194702,
0.22052960097789764,
0.3987632691860199,
-0.27217531204223633,
0.18866267800331116,
0.2779134511947632,
0.0010494132293388247,
0.29891830682754517,
0.7927969098091125,
0.67607581615448,
-0.19617052376270294,
0.2065228521823883,
-0.09273838996887207,
0.3021649420261383,
-0.2832338511943817,
0.43514975905418396,
0.20939478278160095,
-0.5807516574859619,
-0.48627880215644836,
-0.6247394680976868,
-0.6366683840751648,
0.10989293456077576,
-0.7226974964141846,
0.2425687462091446,
-0.6652634739875793,
-0.11687021702528,
0.08975425362586975,
-0.05032487213611603,
-0.24131512641906738,
-0.39201462268829346,
0.2681087553501129,
1.2345407009124756,
-0.94540935754776,
1.2515017986297607,
0.4066797196865082,
-0.10642349720001221,
-0.4711109399795532,
0.20516251027584076,
-0.27056047320365906,
-1.0195633172988892,
0.5424286723136902,
-0.3029341697692871,
-0.5809940099716187,
0.19924499094486237,
-0.5474322438240051,
-1.172689437866211,
1.0270335674285889,
0.6374377608299255,
-0.2391175627708435,
-0.17593155801296234,
0.11166863888502121,
0.7005160450935364,
-0.6388840079307556,
-0.3032456636428833,
0.6084105968475342,
0.37292444705963135,
-0.1584075391292572,
-0.9303700923919678,
-0.11411184817552567,
-0.006189410574734211,
0.17842330038547516,
-0.06412217020988464,
-0.8077349066734314,
0.8953860998153687,
-0.48254719376564026,
0.2615307569503784,
0.706490695476532,
0.673306941986084,
-0.07572443783283234,
0.1271364688873291,
0.43901652097702026,
0.4109688699245453,
0.8882773518562317,
0.20609146356582642,
1.1802700757980347,
0.1035352423787117,
0.1631069779396057,
1.1905018091201782,
-0.7227544784545898,
1.3989133834838867,
0.7448263168334961,
-0.3970116376876831,
0.8577381372451782,
0.25897255539894104,
0.2812793552875519,
0.5866215825080872,
0.18327824771404266,
-0.050309423357248306,
-0.19480110704898834,
-0.3285175859928131,
-0.418147474527359,
0.7008237838745117,
0.3609597980976105,
-0.16406293213367462,
-0.14125627279281616,
-0.09925835579633713,
0.07034409046173096,
0.13111324608325958,
-0.831378698348999,
0.7936354279518127,
0.37867283821105957,
-0.34121546149253845,
0.8640265464782715,
-0.15108804404735565,
0.5074059367179871,
-0.4964923560619354,
0.00739662442356348,
-0.3977195918560028,
0.32942497730255127,
-0.31746044754981995,
-0.40478214621543884,
-0.03413918986916542,
0.24489429593086243,
-0.23714016377925873,
0.11321569234132767,
0.49233484268188477,
0.06954452395439148,
-0.5987319946289062,
0.4094288945198059,
0.7709004878997803,
0.23951710760593414,
0.3255378305912018,
-0.5418955087661743,
0.3239920437335968,
-0.2824946641921997,
-0.2860811948776245,
0.7696965336799622,
0.5507321953773499,
-0.32853052020072937,
0.8478749990463257,
0.4303193986415863,
0.04290000721812248,
0.020263975486159325,
0.13681660592556,
0.9331119656562805,
-0.9035652279853821,
-0.4875573515892029,
-0.564456045627594,
0.29924464225769043,
0.06389045715332031,
-0.010391106829047203,
1.0100429058074951,
0.3946229815483093,
0.1926354020833969,
0.12736018002033234,
0.9381820559501648,
0.04452238604426384,
0.8512891530990601,
-0.6895414590835571,
0.36965319514274597,
-0.4928491711616516,
0.570572555065155,
-0.4258626103401184,
-1.0392557382583618,
-0.2124570608139038,
0.5352094173431396,
-0.5002279877662659,
0.05744323506951332,
1.032975435256958,
0.5701866745948792,
-0.1441342830657959,
-0.5084835886955261,
0.43841227889060974,
0.6203075051307678,
-0.10135684162378311,
0.5086641907691956,
1.0182267427444458,
-0.6456459760665894,
0.38076654076576233,
0.06653398275375366,
-0.08304562419652939,
-0.6459845900535583,
-1.1820130348205566,
-0.8914180397987366,
-0.18835777044296265,
-0.44880396127700806,
-0.3318072557449341,
0.096663698554039,
0.8517657518386841,
0.6728243827819824,
-0.7905570864677429,
-0.4295758008956909,
0.4929456412792206,
0.282050222158432,
-0.1826719045639038,
-0.01725318469107151,
0.2618754804134369,
0.0544307716190815,
-0.745135486125946,
0.7645407319068909,
0.2621085047721863,
-0.04714681953191757,
-0.37249547243118286,
-0.18736998736858368,
-0.18250788748264313,
0.2654421329498291,
0.8011645078659058,
0.5367591977119446,
-0.6408462524414062,
-0.5615091323852539,
-0.2954099476337433,
-0.3141915798187256,
0.4015941619873047,
0.7283380031585693,
-0.6255359053611755,
-0.2343979775905609,
0.21340321004390717,
0.5666848421096802,
0.5020220875740051,
-0.003910867962986231,
0.30496951937675476,
-0.17382089793682098,
0.3213883638381958,
-0.3801002502441406,
0.3440183699131012,
0.5760044455528259,
-0.1851302534341812,
0.6344045400619507,
0.02747611701488495,
-0.22597377002239227,
-1.2840240001678467,
0.24847465753555298,
-1.6150569915771484,
-0.01732631027698517,
1.2214596271514893,
-0.03531936928629875,
-0.47339460253715515,
-0.006063489243388176,
-0.1807679384946823,
-0.15764223039150238,
-0.27778738737106323,
0.811030387878418,
0.14874401688575745,
-0.0676359012722969,
-0.3060011863708496,
-0.689407229423523,
0.24500718712806702,
0.1766139715909958,
-1.1488536596298218,
0.11337736248970032,
-0.06979101151227951,
0.3593902885913849,
0.10732759535312653,
0.7339481115341187,
0.04405907168984413,
-0.016656501218676567,
-0.18082784116268158,
-0.32636016607284546,
0.40011218190193176,
-0.22331534326076508,
-0.9521180987358093,
0.335730642080307,
1.1737406253814697,
0.25694411993026733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05083v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05083v1
|
HaVTR: Improving Video-Text Retrieval Through Augmentation Using Large Foundation Models
| 2024-04-07T21:46:47 | 2024-04-07T21:46:47 |
Yimu Wang, Shuai Yuan, Xiangru Jian, Wei Pang, Mushi Wang, Ning Yu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
While recent progress in video-text retrieval has been driven by the
exploration of powerful model architectures and training strategies, the
representation learning ability of video-text retrieval models is still limited
due to low-quality and scarce training data annotations. To address this issue,
we present a novel video-text learning paradigm, HaVTR, which augments video
and text data to learn more generalized features. Specifically, we first adopt
a simple augmentation method, which generates self-similar data by randomly
duplicating or dropping subwords and frames. In addition, inspired by the
recent advancement in visual and language generative models, we propose a more
powerful augmentation method through textual paraphrasing and video stylization
using large language models (LLMs) and visual generative models (VGMs).
Further, to bring richer information into video and text, we propose a
hallucination-based augmentation method, where we use LLMs and VGMs to generate
and add new relevant information to the original data. Benefiting from the
enriched data, extensive experiments on several video-text retrieval benchmarks
demonstrate the superiority of HaVTR over existing methods.
|
[
-0.2860284745693207,
-1.1572744846343994,
0.333792507648468,
-0.10423540323972702,
-0.5328057408332825,
0.09149229526519775,
-0.27075085043907166,
-0.2519819438457489,
0.25507351756095886,
0.8265324234962463,
-0.2601560056209564,
-0.4941836893558502,
-0.690431535243988,
-0.16450922191143036,
-0.8585760593414307,
0.8496974110603333,
0.06832748651504517,
-0.0989939421415329,
-0.16412533819675446,
-0.26465436816215515,
-0.497681200504303,
-0.4855250120162964,
-0.1976523995399475,
-0.20871779322624207,
0.1666584461927414,
0.19439087808132172,
0.9580227732658386,
1.0576136112213135,
0.8345668911933899,
0.2782445549964905,
-0.044800322502851486,
0.29353734850883484,
-0.4980432987213135,
0.04313834756612778,
0.021880004554986954,
0.1057370975613594,
-0.10286819189786911,
-0.6494598388671875,
0.8242619633674622,
0.302273154258728,
-0.012279670685529709,
-0.13017459213733673,
-0.06209905445575714,
0.5236813426017761,
-0.8138923645019531,
-0.2005288153886795,
-0.606160581111908,
0.3907676339149475,
0.06684938818216324,
-0.5811222195625305,
-0.21118366718292236,
-0.1838914006948471,
0.5482856631278992,
-0.572080135345459,
0.5714915990829468,
-0.24641118943691254,
0.6764696836471558,
0.42289233207702637,
-0.4026002287864685,
-0.093671053647995,
-0.7312418818473816,
0.5549601316452026,
-0.2618654668331146,
0.6556128263473511,
0.32618358731269836,
0.328227162361145,
0.42045682668685913,
-0.8980600833892822,
-0.4922710061073303,
-0.24294325709342957,
0.0735827386379242,
-0.11246402561664581,
0.10532703995704651,
0.044850125908851624,
0.19193200767040253,
0.7900635004043579,
-0.4764918386936188,
-0.29163989424705505,
-0.3039324879646301,
-0.10851234197616577,
0.5155044794082642,
-0.0505860261619091,
0.36788734793663025,
-0.5750316977500916,
-0.5700430274009705,
-0.5104807615280151,
-0.4321790337562561,
-0.2648119330406189,
0.04038892686367035,
0.09865585714578629,
-0.017025018110871315,
0.8031888008117676,
-0.07277289032936096,
0.7664304971694946,
-0.3073335886001587,
-0.15093928575515747,
0.4731411933898926,
-0.26589512825012207,
-0.6418237686157227,
0.06732308864593506,
0.6393471956253052,
0.3065706491470337,
0.14019383490085602,
-0.07060138881206512,
-0.22025863826274872,
-0.1717371642589569,
0.4672110080718994,
-0.7552048563957214,
-0.3095208704471588,
-0.5039762258529663,
-0.5957453846931458,
-0.4620908796787262,
0.49566397070884705,
-1.0169131755828857,
-0.3330453336238861,
-0.30289533734321594,
1.1389985084533691,
-0.5440928339958191,
-0.03895627334713936,
0.11589669436216354,
-0.22270311415195465,
0.3146967887878418,
0.4012135863304138,
-0.856245219707489,
0.22980476915836334,
0.4090083837509155,
0.761497437953949,
-0.3023928105831146,
-0.2528533339500427,
-1.0128754377365112,
0.2251066416501999,
-0.2005162537097931,
0.5311983227729797,
-0.9371996521949768,
-0.47319677472114563,
0.3646898865699768,
-0.05556122213602066,
0.4401435852050781,
-0.6177479028701782,
0.5371392965316772,
-0.5618106126785278,
0.25533854961395264,
-0.2290814071893692,
-0.3364863693714142,
-0.23997649550437927,
0.14520221948623657,
-0.8422530889511108,
1.261204481124878,
0.11178678274154663,
-0.6775033473968506,
0.2664260268211365,
-0.2407739907503128,
-0.624346137046814,
0.03854737430810928,
-0.5834395289421082,
-0.6484968066215515,
0.0963926687836647,
0.4250514805316925,
0.48559844493865967,
-0.16871976852416992,
0.18363280594348907,
0.12583574652671814,
-0.5251591205596924,
-0.08958099037408829,
-0.7156282663345337,
0.003977977205067873,
0.08206460624933243,
-0.1336248368024826,
0.05645578354597092,
-0.7421299815177917,
-0.20554564893245697,
-0.24011845886707306,
-0.27450695633888245,
-0.3620281219482422,
-0.15487506985664368,
0.20582976937294006,
0.10360831767320633,
0.09428606927394867,
-0.15801478922367096,
-0.024273578077554703,
-0.4205063283443451,
0.24083106219768524,
0.527434766292572,
0.12177302688360214,
0.5410906076431274,
-0.14723069965839386,
0.4496060311794281,
-0.1630815863609314,
-0.08424152433872223,
-0.6097782254219055,
-0.141096830368042,
-0.6196025609970093,
-0.21442916989326477,
-0.03201011195778847,
0.30246713757514954,
-1.0235615968704224,
0.24207128584384918,
-0.44215866923332214,
-0.20532602071762085,
-0.44735410809516907,
0.42476242780685425,
0.49991390109062195,
0.6231028437614441,
0.8398244976997375,
-0.44446563720703125,
-0.8361701965332031,
-0.7506656050682068,
0.005849631503224373,
0.0018124316120520234,
-0.11565735936164856,
0.39743709564208984,
0.46811574697494507,
-0.23920392990112305,
0.8539848327636719,
-0.6416926383972168,
-0.4013589918613434,
-0.16965097188949585,
0.22227641940116882,
-0.15228897333145142,
0.2961709797382355,
0.2533179819583893,
-1.2911595106124878,
-0.4210350215435028,
0.28914663195610046,
-0.9037539958953857,
0.3537934422492981,
0.034719761461019516,
0.09384562820196152,
-0.16153857111930847,
0.5374323725700378,
-0.5846542716026306,
0.7310819625854492,
0.14484988152980804,
-0.013063515536487103,
0.5675379633903503,
-0.4208937883377075,
0.6338281631469727,
-1.1122056245803833,
-0.2714003026485443,
0.11395519226789474,
-0.18651507794857025,
-0.45729178190231323,
0.013360542245209217,
-0.004028615541756153,
-0.21370084583759308,
-0.6358115673065186,
0.6046164035797119,
-0.24218624830245972,
-0.37217608094215393,
-0.48346954584121704,
0.0159926675260067,
0.020252961665391922,
0.2024422138929367,
0.27854007482528687,
0.9762210845947266,
0.7024069428443909,
-0.7900029420852661,
0.7379108667373657,
0.6398301720619202,
-0.4921628534793854,
0.2678179144859314,
-0.5884084701538086,
-0.25118184089660645,
-0.5024164915084839,
-0.046078309416770935,
-0.7407227754592896,
-0.8124590516090393,
-0.1488669216632843,
-0.5567076802253723,
0.14667236804962158,
-0.09514649212360382,
-0.3332136571407318,
-0.3182373046875,
-0.19818967580795288,
0.4823072850704193,
0.8591813445091248,
-0.8686367869377136,
0.6968063116073608,
0.3003305494785309,
-0.05407652631402016,
-0.8779606819152832,
-0.646300196647644,
0.30174121260643005,
-0.32304930686950684,
-0.5389070510864258,
0.9704042673110962,
0.16094404458999634,
-0.09381337463855743,
0.012166500091552734,
-0.26095128059387207,
-0.23394736647605896,
-0.43403705954551697,
-0.09045630693435669,
0.09938348829746246,
-0.11857976019382477,
0.4275384247303009,
-0.16131138801574707,
0.18270117044448853,
-0.1895551234483719,
-0.2000398486852646,
0.5113149881362915,
0.09411592036485672,
-0.17276693880558014,
-0.14511056244373322,
0.4080974757671356,
0.24835102260112762,
-0.43764448165893555,
0.3069167733192444,
1.0294612646102905,
-0.5632067322731018,
-0.1274530589580536,
-0.7463667392730713,
-0.2741042971611023,
-0.4508489966392517,
0.795479953289032,
-0.43998053669929504,
-1.1221284866333008,
0.1602751463651657,
0.4921272099018097,
-0.3185008764266968,
0.20017050206661224,
0.5993658304214478,
0.03279128298163414,
0.86578768491745,
0.8218984007835388,
0.19560100138187408,
0.8220974802970886,
-0.30575835704803467,
-0.23263828456401825,
-0.4643833339214325,
-0.36842188239097595,
-0.17718619108200073,
0.07748954743146896,
-0.41996702551841736,
-0.7034684419631958,
0.3600119352340698,
-0.16798877716064453,
-0.1544012576341629,
0.47855210304260254,
-0.5118232369422913,
0.7432002425193787,
0.3024926781654358,
0.5741351246833801,
0.4240756630897522,
0.6512578129768372,
0.08516797423362732,
-0.3070005476474762,
-0.3050464689731598,
-0.2885465621948242,
0.8775575757026672,
0.4425866901874542,
1.0076595544815063,
0.12191176414489746,
0.5114375352859497,
0.6513570547103882,
0.026086362078785896,
-0.7735865712165833,
0.527703583240509,
-0.4904598891735077,
-0.21495534479618073,
-0.23797066509723663,
-0.36661994457244873,
-0.4818960726261139,
0.25445717573165894,
-0.42702022194862366,
-0.5598015785217285,
0.12603700160980225,
0.14852210879325867,
-0.25943443179130554,
0.20887456834316254,
-0.2880244851112366,
0.7962659597396851,
-0.16091138124465942,
-0.7918294668197632,
-0.27591732144355774,
-0.7094969749450684,
0.2761420011520386,
-0.03806722164154053,
0.08199271559715271,
0.5861010551452637,
0.012569773010909557,
0.6475972533226013,
-0.5420318841934204,
0.47308775782585144,
0.0224564578384161,
-0.14340156316757202,
0.4306460916996002,
-0.1362542361021042,
0.6255741119384766,
0.08423839509487152,
0.044174887239933014,
-0.5767531991004944,
-0.5860841870307922,
-0.16645485162734985,
-0.8848928809165955,
0.6153720617294312,
-0.720819354057312,
-0.5535429120063782,
-0.09169407933950424,
-0.3337744176387787,
0.03186175972223282,
0.11858823150396347,
0.3371497392654419,
0.6872063875198364,
-0.271585077047348,
0.7562503814697266,
1.1448521614074707,
-0.2736482620239258,
0.4486325681209564,
-0.06410814821720123,
-0.29148954153060913,
-1.047514796257019,
1.0795035362243652,
-0.19759461283683777,
0.1965218037366867,
0.8442007899284363,
-0.05302152782678604,
-0.4451696276664734,
-0.443398118019104,
-0.24645844101905823,
0.1081375926733017,
-1.0048242807388306,
-0.10326316207647324,
-0.9077802896499634,
-0.4079361855983734,
-0.3995574116706848,
-0.18137916922569275,
-0.24193032085895538,
-0.12943612039089203,
-0.4057401716709137,
-0.39838019013404846,
0.5412045121192932,
0.40417152643203735,
0.10674484074115753,
0.6823513507843018,
-0.8631753325462341,
0.6708495020866394,
0.6177845001220703,
0.15254080295562744,
-0.13094842433929443,
-0.9785324335098267,
-0.47577086091041565,
-0.20020371675491333,
-0.35276874899864197,
-0.8305079340934753,
0.7783024907112122,
0.31036126613616943,
0.2544914782047272,
0.3346098065376282,
-0.42083412408828735,
0.9051424264907837,
-0.42252063751220703,
0.7067181468009949,
0.3824186623096466,
-0.7578940391540527,
0.5951608419418335,
-0.4649510383605957,
-0.014189621433615685,
0.49156859517097473,
0.33990755677223206,
-0.22923561930656433,
0.3051418662071228,
-0.5853388905525208,
-0.8124721646308899,
0.1969234049320221,
0.3773082494735718,
0.5629832148551941,
0.05630708858370781,
0.43624556064605713,
0.2378244698047638,
0.362565815448761,
-0.9254359006881714,
0.05967564880847931,
-0.6443617939949036,
-0.33446362614631653,
-0.04609416052699089,
-0.17621107399463654,
0.15830768644809723,
-0.30417266488075256,
0.5253718495368958,
-0.13504669070243835,
0.2496299147605896,
0.4070814251899719,
-0.39967525005340576,
-0.15063084661960602,
0.3497551679611206,
0.13883979618549347,
0.44310474395751953,
-0.32558122277259827,
0.27242520451545715,
0.32321855425834656,
-0.5476970672607422,
0.38238343596458435,
0.07284374535083771,
-0.19197675585746765,
0.2280772179365158,
0.3968465328216553,
1.1238024234771729,
0.34986644983291626,
-0.8942158818244934,
0.733335018157959,
0.2669128179550171,
-0.37726718187332153,
-0.43956297636032104,
0.25703179836273193,
-0.6303368210792542,
0.14966295659542084,
0.755803108215332,
-0.07365026324987411,
0.3998025059700012,
-0.6165516376495361,
0.8137302398681641,
0.4694482684135437,
-0.6980878710746765,
-0.04241429641842842,
0.6869540214538574,
0.07732520997524261,
-0.5446376800537109,
0.3823205828666687,
0.09985581785440445,
-0.33787572383880615,
0.42163026332855225,
0.5334606170654297,
0.8280904293060303,
-0.1184932291507721,
0.4738953411579132,
0.371759831905365,
0.1218256950378418,
-0.4818616509437561,
0.14687907695770264,
-0.3446417450904846,
-0.35609740018844604,
-0.845729410648346,
-0.7053589820861816,
-0.28151440620422363,
0.3044480085372925,
-0.6282785534858704,
0.7077494859695435,
-0.0976555198431015,
-0.04208550974726677,
-0.297751784324646,
-0.21733812987804413,
-0.5241355299949646,
0.6562027335166931,
0.09390947222709656,
0.7794950604438782,
-0.7699387073516846,
0.8019428253173828,
0.7484906315803528,
-0.5585528016090393,
-0.33423754572868347,
0.11844920367002487,
-0.4815526008605957,
-0.5718929171562195,
0.7443425059318542,
0.37544798851013184,
0.011913007125258446,
0.28850671648979187,
-0.3158867657184601,
-0.7508479356765747,
1.1111624240875244,
0.13904502987861633,
-0.3644907772541046,
-0.6648542284965515,
0.22477832436561584,
0.5484577417373657,
-0.5258020758628845,
0.21543174982070923,
0.45054933428764343,
0.23732838034629822,
0.5287511348724365,
-0.5029772520065308,
-0.27793002128601074,
-0.20165550708770752,
0.2314307987689972,
0.15442995727062225,
-0.31618058681488037,
0.6371110081672668,
-0.19245374202728271,
-0.010908775962889194,
0.11478982865810394,
1.0407350063323975,
0.06713232398033142,
0.2869613468647003,
0.3430785834789276,
0.7438769936561584,
0.31568166613578796,
0.1245216652750969,
0.8482831120491028,
0.32496604323387146,
0.394543319940567,
1.0590252876281738,
0.05640583485364914,
0.8027774095535278,
0.5384768843650818,
0.03328654170036316,
0.35677018761634827,
0.33951547741889954,
-0.20817358791828156,
0.762731671333313,
-0.14255903661251068,
-0.6168739199638367,
-0.512944757938385,
-0.134165421128273,
-0.37135154008865356,
0.5114635229110718,
0.24848321080207825,
-0.7555725574493408,
-0.14356353878974915,
0.5643979907035828,
-0.42625704407691956,
0.3316589295864105,
-0.33037200570106506,
0.7508992552757263,
-0.008918867446482182,
-0.5309246182441711,
0.5316332578659058,
-0.17506060004234314,
0.6342108249664307,
-0.44729846715927124,
-0.27299079298973083,
0.04302302747964859,
0.06583734601736069,
-0.17381101846694946,
-0.6182085871696472,
0.21559222042560577,
0.19997018575668335,
-0.16872777044773102,
0.02675185352563858,
0.8290144205093384,
-0.6447476148605347,
-0.4121769666671753,
0.15223121643066406,
0.3703824281692505,
-0.15848515927791595,
-0.016662368550896645,
-0.4821488559246063,
0.35266175866127014,
0.012045767158269882,
-0.07546353340148926,
0.16326427459716797,
0.39695075154304504,
0.00990981049835682,
0.6160374879837036,
0.366524875164032,
-0.13110452890396118,
-0.16301453113555908,
0.15412162244319916,
0.9752038717269897,
-0.926942765712738,
-0.514277994632721,
-1.0903761386871338,
0.4985073506832123,
-0.20692960917949677,
0.002659399760887027,
0.6985206007957458,
0.5739825367927551,
0.8161835074424744,
-0.2211129069328308,
1.0653059482574463,
-0.05158694088459015,
0.18646374344825745,
-0.8593873977661133,
0.19603189826011658,
-0.6279429197311401,
0.1945856809616089,
-0.7461330890655518,
-1.1863489151000977,
-0.38077911734580994,
0.704217791557312,
-0.20769765973091125,
0.22843199968338013,
0.6411569714546204,
0.8834746479988098,
-0.28302237391471863,
0.010489828884601593,
0.389055997133255,
0.1772622913122177,
0.2628557085990906,
0.2261970341205597,
0.9193224906921387,
-0.8317897915840149,
0.9049549102783203,
-0.1824190765619278,
-0.11815132200717926,
-0.514971137046814,
-0.8100917935371399,
-0.9441857933998108,
-0.5485496520996094,
-0.28825780749320984,
-0.3138796389102936,
0.46343690156936646,
0.995323657989502,
0.7330867648124695,
-0.31071847677230835,
-0.07512671500444412,
-0.3304401636123657,
-0.10862209647893906,
0.03681226819753647,
-0.24244576692581177,
0.49934762716293335,
-0.1301000565290451,
-0.6530551910400391,
0.528780460357666,
0.324001669883728,
0.41104656457901,
-0.27474796772003174,
-0.30031871795654297,
-0.08782543241977692,
-0.2429288625717163,
0.9181873202323914,
0.2893102169036865,
-0.5710520148277283,
-0.4382917881011963,
0.2686261832714081,
0.1458314210176468,
0.3359544575214386,
0.9184281229972839,
-1.105711579322815,
0.4981445372104645,
0.7503710985183716,
1.0358296632766724,
0.7984223365783691,
0.4612881541252136,
0.5012327432632446,
-0.9823294281959534,
0.054957084357738495,
0.07293540984392166,
0.22138121724128723,
0.6919702887535095,
-0.22141529619693756,
0.3734118938446045,
0.3322218954563141,
-0.39919427037239075,
-0.9653024077415466,
0.23750543594360352,
-0.8978351950645447,
-0.11123958230018616,
1.104041337966919,
0.37213343381881714,
-0.1406853348016739,
0.16545060276985168,
-0.4414357841014862,
0.3419647514820099,
-0.2109764814376831,
0.7542302012443542,
0.48148056864738464,
0.16025377810001373,
-0.5792537331581116,
-0.5304004549980164,
0.5572556257247925,
0.41461774706840515,
-0.6820868849754333,
0.09076664596796036,
0.6469922661781311,
-0.08139518648386002,
-0.09095025807619095,
0.4820975661277771,
-0.16547906398773193,
0.5169119238853455,
-0.27161678671836853,
-0.08244859427213669,
-0.15443316102027893,
-0.7614873647689819,
-0.2820601761341095,
0.34573987126350403,
-0.2016194611787796,
0.10353634506464005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05073v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05073v1
|
QRscript: Embedding a Programming Language in QR codes to support Decision and Management
| 2024-04-07T21:02:55 | 2024-04-07T21:02:55 |
Stefano Scanzio, Gianluca Cena, Adriano Valenzano
|
cs.NI
|
cs.NI, cs.CL
|
Embedding a programming language in a QR code is a new and extremely
promising opportunity, as it makes devices and objects smarter without
necessarily requiring an Internet connection. In this paper, all the steps
needed to translate a program written in a high-level programming language to
its binary representation encoded in a QR code, and the opposite process that,
starting from the QR code, executes it by means of a virtual machine, have been
carefully detailed. The proposed programming language was named QRscript, and
can be easily extended so as to integrate new features. One of the main design
goals was to produce a very compact target binary code. In particular, in this
work we propose a specific sub-language (a dialect) that is aimed at encoding
decision trees. Besides industrial scenarios, this is useful in many other
application fields. The reported example, related to the configuration of an
industrial networked device, highlights the potential of the proposed
technology, and permits to better understand all the translation steps.
|
[
-0.36863625049591064,
-0.38359031081199646,
0.6691089272499084,
-0.005037704017013311,
-0.39074772596359253,
0.3466160297393799,
0.10600710660219193,
-0.3642284572124481,
0.24456597864627838,
0.39381933212280273,
-0.37345120310783386,
-0.5366665124893188,
-0.3095851540565491,
0.002560549881309271,
-0.3623606264591217,
0.8161334991455078,
-0.318080872297287,
-0.11466558277606964,
-0.10288428515195847,
-0.10144893825054169,
-0.3635982573032379,
-0.8077307343482971,
-0.6470382213592529,
-0.3473495543003082,
0.2612740695476532,
0.35540497303009033,
0.8539189696311951,
0.7670575380325317,
0.5904272794723511,
0.2914751470088959,
0.26552531123161316,
-0.33337369561195374,
-0.08586333692073822,
0.11891678720712662,
-0.3177817761898041,
-0.6605338454246521,
-0.3243910074234009,
-0.5730968713760376,
0.5167273879051208,
0.167665034532547,
-0.0717087984085083,
0.19266797602176666,
-0.3367755711078644,
0.8168234825134277,
-0.34836456179618835,
0.16243061423301697,
-0.16562731564044952,
0.692439079284668,
0.03291398286819458,
-0.3402833342552185,
-0.12125083059072495,
-0.6373286843299866,
-0.06432275474071503,
-0.3228054642677307,
0.013398523442447186,
0.1277848184108734,
0.4570441246032715,
0.07113761454820633,
-0.42875924706459045,
-0.14876709878444672,
-1.2090752124786377,
0.7302678823471069,
-0.5036866664886475,
0.4439222514629364,
0.20060715079307556,
0.9070016741752625,
0.043307285755872726,
-1.020796537399292,
-0.6696537733078003,
0.13861814141273499,
0.089190274477005,
0.004583681467920542,
-0.35751259326934814,
0.20183803141117096,
0.2365492433309555,
0.006616842467337847,
-0.25034692883491516,
-0.06783117353916168,
-0.4138147234916687,
-0.10552512854337692,
0.2751598358154297,
0.3491155207157135,
0.08768031001091003,
0.14088523387908936,
-0.17648746073246002,
-0.18917080760002136,
-0.3073100745677948,
0.17176271975040436,
0.12742887437343597,
0.2662758529186249,
-0.06749815493822098,
0.7561845779418945,
-0.5819185376167297,
0.32578572630882263,
0.07638461887836456,
-0.07759823650121689,
0.17892421782016754,
-0.3811942934989929,
-0.34047961235046387,
0.30442652106285095,
0.699209451675415,
0.31161367893218994,
0.10727245360612869,
0.03118809312582016,
-0.6434234976768494,
0.16984380781650543,
0.34371089935302734,
-0.7483130097389221,
-0.33909258246421814,
0.5449091196060181,
-0.6084527373313904,
-0.34644246101379395,
-0.04055669903755188,
-0.3458000719547272,
-0.26003456115722656,
-0.06418156623840332,
0.3337263762950897,
-0.34333130717277527,
-0.2820635735988617,
0.37187665700912476,
-0.34597647190093994,
0.5581601858139038,
0.43464821577072144,
-0.5878306031227112,
0.3569909334182739,
0.6574224829673767,
0.6123997569084167,
0.35561883449554443,
0.09251967817544937,
-0.45759162306785583,
0.27224084734916687,
-0.3395135700702667,
0.8220442533493042,
-0.602388322353363,
-0.5930070281028748,
-0.036721862852573395,
-0.1946733593940735,
0.2920604646205902,
-0.521212637424469,
0.5580998063087463,
-0.5934776663780212,
-0.08052169531583786,
0.0987601950764656,
-0.05552209913730621,
-0.30876243114471436,
0.2379726767539978,
-0.45497944951057434,
0.7164596915245056,
0.4150713384151459,
-0.6248025894165039,
0.17591315507888794,
-0.63934326171875,
-0.7266537547111511,
0.22515279054641724,
-0.5137695074081421,
-0.7876651883125305,
-0.13176696002483368,
-0.09855398535728455,
0.2927209734916687,
-0.3018273711204529,
-0.0879780501127243,
-0.21807235479354858,
-0.2363121509552002,
0.5195474028587341,
0.06910523027181625,
0.5366501808166504,
0.3040972948074341,
-0.21261490881443024,
0.26537996530532837,
-0.2795366048812866,
0.5566361546516418,
0.08888188749551773,
-0.4227278530597687,
-0.01265625562518835,
0.3035062849521637,
0.25019344687461853,
0.34278860688209534,
0.41919440031051636,
-0.5394196510314941,
0.16610576212406158,
-0.056118953973054886,
0.5758571028709412,
0.28009212017059326,
0.041194938123226166,
0.33446693420410156,
-0.32498109340667725,
0.9317415356636047,
-0.12267766892910004,
0.6488845944404602,
0.06967297196388245,
-0.29227912425994873,
-0.5207358598709106,
-0.005491429939866066,
0.27342718839645386,
0.6333358883857727,
-0.844038724899292,
0.4292656481266022,
0.030419228598475456,
-0.28532496094703674,
-0.21909663081169128,
-0.07982876896858215,
0.376839280128479,
0.15930087864398956,
0.14908507466316223,
-0.3539591431617737,
-0.9153527021408081,
-0.9311558604240417,
0.22572501003742218,
-0.28064653277397156,
0.15573367476463318,
-0.03292477875947952,
0.23729802668094635,
-0.451538622379303,
1.174567699432373,
-0.3943963646888733,
-0.3063308894634247,
-0.5593949556350708,
-0.39267587661743164,
0.383193701505661,
0.6949940323829651,
0.3841710686683655,
-1.0761913061141968,
-0.5788262486457825,
0.6451305747032166,
-0.6707445979118347,
0.19450810551643372,
0.0019706718157976866,
-0.20249246060848236,
-0.14847132563591003,
0.6783812642097473,
-0.4652084410190582,
0.351813405752182,
0.41700106859207153,
-0.15703421831130981,
0.9433020353317261,
-0.3490886986255646,
0.05925491824746132,
-0.9518274664878845,
-0.08087446540594101,
-0.07460043579339981,
-0.3390049636363983,
-0.43906280398368835,
0.09601715207099915,
0.16174674034118652,
-0.32854366302490234,
-0.6280504465103149,
0.14380507171154022,
-0.22527070343494415,
-0.45983994007110596,
-0.07121928036212921,
-0.12315185368061066,
0.03513948619365692,
0.3774772584438324,
0.1118321344256401,
0.693715512752533,
0.8297243118286133,
-0.6994720101356506,
0.6406579613685608,
0.1369466930627823,
-0.15132029354572296,
0.4736405909061432,
-0.6519405245780945,
-0.07154477387666702,
-0.08346199989318848,
-0.028970427811145782,
-0.4669094979763031,
0.15939123928546906,
0.3974352180957794,
-0.5230076313018799,
0.03889733925461769,
-0.454286128282547,
-0.5930047035217285,
-0.35610195994377136,
-0.25121742486953735,
0.3715076744556427,
0.7692403793334961,
-0.0577586367726326,
0.6450073719024658,
0.445233017206192,
0.12774619460105896,
-0.21301396191120148,
-0.6446629762649536,
-0.01566733419895172,
-0.38772156834602356,
-0.2510608434677124,
0.230818971991539,
0.023530790582299232,
-0.19494667649269104,
0.37637054920196533,
-0.37498411536216736,
-0.17431101202964783,
-0.13244199752807617,
0.14776349067687988,
-0.1540031135082245,
-0.5647045969963074,
0.021640367805957794,
0.12710519134998322,
-0.40934523940086365,
-0.05183697119355202,
-0.8784213066101074,
0.34961774945259094,
-0.13396359980106354,
-0.4507938027381897,
-0.5395564436912537,
0.518505871295929,
0.741081178188324,
-0.5945103168487549,
0.3269827663898468,
0.30614399909973145,
-0.3376847803592682,
-0.4329977333545685,
0.12631340324878693,
0.2538764476776123,
-0.5987885594367981,
0.4554193317890167,
-0.5410591959953308,
-0.533635139465332,
0.4889947474002838,
-0.5044065117835999,
-0.10289210826158524,
0.13833709061145782,
0.38625359535217285,
-0.2432868927717209,
1.3607312440872192,
0.9901552796363831,
0.24041444063186646,
0.9751211404800415,
-0.31314876675605774,
0.46721911430358887,
-0.7795253992080688,
-0.30166327953338623,
-0.6242745518684387,
-0.05565181374549866,
-0.4520728290081024,
-0.5343047976493835,
0.5809330344200134,
0.4165920913219452,
-0.3497680127620697,
0.46370887756347656,
-0.5857284069061279,
0.4352410137653351,
0.6168285012245178,
0.011338535696268082,
0.06877116858959198,
-0.016667440533638,
-0.24970437586307526,
0.33441758155822754,
-0.8687024712562561,
-0.6864357590675354,
0.6562408804893494,
0.41209471225738525,
0.8118405938148499,
0.29811009764671326,
0.9037324786186218,
0.5398685932159424,
-0.3144701421260834,
-1.081787109375,
0.5318939089775085,
-0.11012285202741623,
-0.1683599054813385,
-0.36384329199790955,
-0.09363467246294022,
-1.0049107074737549,
0.11225947737693787,
-0.27833646535873413,
-0.6872565150260925,
0.20326660573482513,
0.03871750459074974,
-0.6075769066810608,
0.15552407503128052,
-0.9913209080696106,
1.0025585889816284,
-0.5549597144126892,
-0.15563653409481049,
-0.33244457840919495,
-0.2664622366428375,
-0.07052897661924362,
-0.10799618065357208,
0.11979784071445465,
0.04596834257245064,
0.09766779094934464,
0.6964026093482971,
-0.6018638610839844,
0.7410656809806824,
-0.02918652631342411,
0.05022526904940605,
0.4211408197879791,
0.32964062690734863,
0.4233984351158142,
-0.13241887092590332,
-0.23879796266555786,
-0.25050023198127747,
0.6050134301185608,
-0.31415149569511414,
-0.7031541466712952,
0.1090010553598404,
-0.5599018931388855,
-0.40792229771614075,
-0.47386816143989563,
-0.01016797311604023,
-0.19784463942050934,
0.6686034202575684,
-0.12975271046161652,
0.7864943146705627,
-0.21347123384475708,
0.1902218461036682,
0.4964532256126404,
-0.4467483460903168,
0.24519430100917816,
0.40806224942207336,
-0.6878455877304077,
-0.1768878847360611,
0.9527482986450195,
-0.13727377355098724,
0.11123228073120117,
0.906497061252594,
0.3620797097682953,
-0.476751446723938,
-0.8451428413391113,
-0.5042757987976074,
-0.1322559118270874,
-0.8123999238014221,
-0.4396201968193054,
-0.4794696867465973,
-0.12689216434955597,
-0.3386252224445343,
-0.453989714384079,
-0.27590590715408325,
-0.47294387221336365,
0.11939767003059387,
-0.12019182741641998,
0.5421479344367981,
0.7769095301628113,
0.06041089817881584,
0.5018191933631897,
-1.0639655590057373,
0.42774635553359985,
0.20274420082569122,
0.6127703785896301,
-0.052609968930482864,
0.25785350799560547,
-0.8952024579048157,
0.0066866339184343815,
-0.13212715089321136,
-0.7555283308029175,
0.31083396077156067,
0.10272497683763504,
0.7484202980995178,
0.30479857325553894,
0.3431788980960846,
0.1366175413131714,
-0.3422706723213196,
0.24985738098621368,
0.3482711613178253,
-0.890779435634613,
0.6052860617637634,
-0.35591280460357666,
0.27760007977485657,
0.3053843379020691,
-0.04113784804940224,
-0.7913110852241516,
-0.25422000885009766,
-0.4966500699520111,
-0.5738518238067627,
0.6992955207824707,
0.001757706282660365,
-0.13002406060695648,
0.10561742633581161,
-0.029827609658241272,
-0.12242596596479416,
0.35721591114997864,
-0.44396477937698364,
-0.12400367110967636,
-0.23274464905261993,
-0.14180497825145721,
0.18845725059509277,
-0.05528789386153221,
0.004502666182816029,
-0.13777482509613037,
0.2731388807296753,
-0.031708162277936935,
0.5871644020080566,
0.09996455907821655,
0.15544794499874115,
-0.04195626825094223,
0.1759311705827713,
0.1711956411600113,
0.3760199546813965,
-0.060043685138225555,
0.2701018154621124,
-0.2515273094177246,
-0.45385217666625977,
0.06694821268320084,
-0.3185756206512451,
-0.16004617512226105,
-0.20554667711257935,
0.06996424496173859,
0.6246713399887085,
-0.20491628348827362,
-0.8344928026199341,
0.2922719717025757,
0.0018002631841227412,
0.018804091960191727,
-0.45019254088401794,
0.12910327315330505,
0.042308952659368515,
0.7106263041496277,
0.23419462144374847,
0.025034502148628235,
0.29349175095558167,
-0.8029706478118896,
0.472444087266922,
0.2427966296672821,
-0.29148682951927185,
-0.23258477449417114,
0.5288721323013306,
0.27405887842178345,
-0.5512495040893555,
0.263712078332901,
-0.7213003635406494,
-0.9454655051231384,
0.9818069934844971,
0.8083386421203613,
1.0906305313110352,
0.07041577249765396,
0.4916916489601135,
0.32720282673835754,
0.4358467161655426,
0.01759086735546589,
0.6246994137763977,
-0.22635763883590698,
-0.7830852270126343,
-0.24764321744441986,
-0.7075613141059875,
-0.580603837966919,
-0.7648554444313049,
-0.3873976767063141,
0.24708448350429535,
-0.9767006635665894,
-0.2273532599210739,
-0.24676024913787842,
-0.1218872144818306,
-0.6368517875671387,
0.22426027059555054,
-0.0684465691447258,
0.6469374895095825,
-0.4856104552745819,
1.343856692314148,
0.9375001192092896,
-0.3757902979850769,
-0.5472238063812256,
-0.001444934168830514,
-0.18999388813972473,
-0.6377811431884766,
0.5991224646568298,
-0.19524997472763062,
-0.4492932856082916,
0.15396437048912048,
-0.15300574898719788,
-0.8563894629478455,
0.7742176055908203,
0.0033010730985552073,
-0.46225064992904663,
0.3606395721435547,
0.2403937131166458,
0.5539371371269226,
-0.20642423629760742,
-0.03259187936782837,
0.4931238293647766,
0.37319570779800415,
-0.038234442472457886,
-0.882080078125,
0.2427215427160263,
-0.15797150135040283,
0.07612383365631104,
0.5495029091835022,
-0.4657549262046814,
0.9075930714607239,
-0.41422194242477417,
-0.6658453345298767,
-0.23059995472431183,
0.4927749037742615,
-0.22899062931537628,
0.2176073044538498,
0.05397984758019447,
0.1036771759390831,
0.5207018852233887,
0.2007179707288742,
1.0757330656051636,
-0.22812911868095398,
0.1951291412115097,
0.6552180051803589,
-0.158790722489357,
0.886728048324585,
0.3086549937725067,
-0.4702388644218445,
0.4656580984592438,
0.40489518642425537,
0.17188449203968048,
0.5970460176467896,
-0.014612795785069466,
-0.4916992783546448,
-0.05598682910203934,
-0.040876567363739014,
-0.23306982219219208,
0.22713740170001984,
0.6236938834190369,
-0.038628239184617996,
-0.18577297031879425,
-0.020888229832053185,
-0.3964163064956665,
0.016714956611394882,
-0.45734381675720215,
0.7282019853591919,
0.09437988698482513,
-0.121658556163311,
0.4149009883403778,
0.4044365882873535,
0.5138795971870422,
-0.678155243396759,
-0.155734121799469,
0.06663282960653305,
0.28236451745033264,
-0.5283213257789612,
-1.1550788879394531,
0.6255170702934265,
-0.1988460272550583,
-0.07785897701978683,
-0.28150996565818787,
0.4751717150211334,
-0.22307975590229034,
-0.3400059640407562,
0.1426292508840561,
0.45682138204574585,
0.21906006336212158,
0.10825768113136292,
-0.7738879919052124,
0.20595288276672363,
0.18728476762771606,
0.3365289270877838,
0.2728102505207062,
0.9976076483726501,
-0.23983652889728546,
0.7266183495521545,
0.571955680847168,
-0.06938890367746353,
0.06359018385410309,
-0.14225715398788452,
0.6101006865501404,
-0.9681228995323181,
-0.8378130793571472,
-0.3815777897834778,
0.28106212615966797,
0.3104900121688843,
0.11347927898168564,
0.7936697006225586,
0.7391488552093506,
0.8919721245765686,
-0.03367072343826294,
1.3402791023254395,
-0.45023179054260254,
0.08094990253448486,
-0.6012467741966248,
0.40928947925567627,
-0.21334803104400635,
0.12239758670330048,
-0.13822586834430695,
-0.6621407866477966,
-0.3514341711997986,
0.7298624515533447,
-0.22589366137981415,
-0.047476474195718765,
0.8183351755142212,
0.7269148826599121,
-0.07717398554086685,
-0.3017471134662628,
0.49885138869285583,
-0.21313022077083588,
0.36876603960990906,
0.6739321351051331,
0.7194002270698547,
-0.2065170407295227,
0.6291884183883667,
-0.38062605261802673,
-0.08327788859605789,
-0.39206987619400024,
-0.8742249011993408,
-0.4741585850715637,
-0.5561926960945129,
-0.4407775402069092,
-0.3257080912590027,
-0.13586121797561646,
0.8801619410514832,
0.33367836475372314,
-0.7829388380050659,
-0.47478368878364563,
-0.10644741356372833,
0.5101078748703003,
-0.6997948288917542,
-0.08383367210626602,
0.28850385546684265,
-0.01650499552488327,
-0.5286160707473755,
0.14683371782302856,
0.24672503769397736,
0.33431476354599,
-0.21701619029045105,
-0.32523247599601746,
0.25955721735954285,
-0.22461435198783875,
0.7849847078323364,
0.7968857884407043,
-0.23120315372943878,
-0.30493417382240295,
-0.12660855054855347,
-0.04913860186934471,
0.20643967390060425,
1.0876606702804565,
-0.8460249304771423,
0.6339902281761169,
0.649535059928894,
0.5333528518676758,
0.5736843943595886,
-0.10965429246425629,
0.7237913012504578,
-0.5143460035324097,
0.08113013207912445,
0.36769574880599976,
0.2497696876525879,
0.18090520799160004,
-0.346989244222641,
0.12764772772789001,
-0.10403641313314438,
-0.043816834688186646,
-0.532735288143158,
0.5521402359008789,
-1.0593100786209106,
-0.25815725326538086,
0.9791803956031799,
0.3068813979625702,
-0.28960737586021423,
-0.6301954984664917,
-0.6271688938140869,
0.28501367568969727,
-0.470082551240921,
0.3154074251651764,
-0.0028139979112893343,
-0.4527144432067871,
-0.21694278717041016,
-0.570137083530426,
0.42634832859039307,
-0.11749467998743057,
-0.5132064819335938,
0.11160589754581451,
0.26671701669692993,
-0.06545178592205048,
0.13042926788330078,
1.0150352716445923,
-0.26774686574935913,
0.32070988416671753,
0.5011264681816101,
0.6236287355422974,
-0.05877743288874626,
-0.1358785182237625,
-0.38689175248146057,
-0.024244291707873344,
0.5845431089401245,
-0.5307665467262268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05046v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05046v1
|
FGAIF: Aligning Large Vision-Language Models with Fine-grained AI Feedback
| 2024-04-07T19:00:45 | 2024-04-07T19:00:45 |
Liqiang Jing, Xinya Du
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) have demonstrated proficiency in
tackling a variety of visual-language tasks. However, current LVLMs suffer from
misalignment between text and image modalities which causes three kinds of
hallucination problems, i.e., object existence, object attribute, and object
relationship. To tackle this issue, existing methods mainly utilize
Reinforcement Learning (RL) to align modalities in LVLMs. However, they still
suffer from three main limitations: (1) General feedback can not indicate the
hallucination type contained in the response; (2) Sparse rewards only give the
sequence-level reward for the whole response; and (3)Annotation cost is
time-consuming and labor-intensive. To handle these limitations, we propose an
innovative method to align modalities in LVLMs through Fine-Grained Artificial
Intelligence Feedback (FGAIF), which mainly consists of three steps: AI-based
Feedback Collection, Fine-grained Reward Model Training, and Reinforcement
Learning with Fine-grained Reward. Specifically, We first utilize AI tools to
predict the types of hallucination for each segment in the response and obtain
a collection of fine-grained feedback. Then, based on the collected reward
data, three specialized reward models are trained to produce dense rewards.
Finally, a novel fine-grained feedback module is integrated into the Proximal
Policy Optimization (PPO) algorithm. Extensive experiments are conducted on
hallucination and general benchmarks, demonstrating the superior performance of
our proposed method. Notably, compared with previous models trained with the
RL-based aligning method, our proposed method is effective even with fewer
parameters.
|
[
-0.48295795917510986,
-0.8990834951400757,
0.453425794839859,
0.0808304101228714,
-0.16357946395874023,
-0.37732169032096863,
-0.46735185384750366,
-0.4892541766166687,
0.05262167006731033,
0.4431040585041046,
-0.6514129638671875,
-0.25141292810440063,
-0.2142554372549057,
-0.11279360949993134,
0.010841524228453636,
0.9034762978553772,
-0.14238370954990387,
0.22483184933662415,
-0.20952266454696655,
-0.20898392796516418,
-0.585960865020752,
-0.22956427931785583,
-0.7023917436599731,
-0.439284086227417,
0.6500453352928162,
0.3168356120586395,
0.8833758234977722,
0.5986716747283936,
0.7781531810760498,
0.3333583474159241,
0.18952296674251556,
0.6715085506439209,
-0.3619616627693176,
-0.27886831760406494,
-0.2240825742483139,
-0.15989184379577637,
-0.3242496848106384,
-0.31464695930480957,
0.4290062487125397,
0.42774471640586853,
-0.3115125000476837,
-0.23000191152095795,
0.20133943855762482,
0.6067657470703125,
-0.7631283402442932,
0.21921661496162415,
-0.4945273697376251,
0.36860764026641846,
0.0011883246479555964,
-0.3036009967327118,
-0.31825941801071167,
-0.3210775554180145,
0.09118880331516266,
-0.8250460028648376,
-0.03244172781705856,
0.12800264358520508,
0.9761666655540466,
0.7644902467727661,
0.038961805403232574,
-0.05202903598546982,
-0.777571976184845,
0.9217537641525269,
-0.6912076473236084,
0.28232061862945557,
0.4584065079689026,
0.42630714178085327,
-0.0726667270064354,
-0.24929599463939667,
-0.6871579885482788,
-0.39553511142730713,
-0.1973722279071808,
-0.03538786247372627,
0.15713642537593842,
0.18656013906002045,
-0.005510314833372831,
0.28921371698379517,
-0.5066941380500793,
0.473480224609375,
-0.17609834671020508,
-0.2660481035709381,
0.7627398371696472,
0.3465309739112854,
-0.09050196409225464,
0.17032411694526672,
-0.4742145538330078,
-0.31437787413597107,
-0.26362136006355286,
0.15191985666751862,
0.06534339487552643,
0.5537013411521912,
0.14272330701351166,
0.6541978120803833,
-0.27974027395248413,
0.9008048176765442,
0.3627811670303345,
-0.16139458119869232,
0.31819844245910645,
-0.26916739344596863,
-0.36067095398902893,
0.1803625524044037,
0.9897177219390869,
0.656549870967865,
0.30188891291618347,
-0.18861883878707886,
-0.6106114983558655,
0.10296259820461273,
0.42666131258010864,
-0.7529359459877014,
0.037191011011600494,
0.2477528303861618,
-0.49119505286216736,
-0.5570494532585144,
0.050922222435474396,
-0.8929886817932129,
-0.6288862824440002,
-0.42586225271224976,
0.882603108882904,
-0.3757138252258301,
-0.04736132174730301,
0.01320088841021061,
0.26774972677230835,
0.409643292427063,
0.5079444050788879,
-1.3175711631774902,
0.10953211039304733,
0.7234720587730408,
0.7940345406532288,
-0.15610741078853607,
-0.5863077044487,
-1.079895257949829,
-0.018364664167165756,
-0.3532307744026184,
0.6319775581359863,
-0.6942660808563232,
-0.021727897226810455,
0.295369029045105,
0.11316914856433868,
0.08929112553596497,
-0.723533034324646,
0.23112615942955017,
-0.21048730611801147,
-0.011444024741649628,
-0.1056385487318039,
-0.2722167670726776,
-0.103661447763443,
0.494802862405777,
-0.4747874438762665,
0.840736448764801,
0.2330584079027176,
-0.49416619539260864,
0.18327169120311737,
-0.3050406277179718,
-0.22223469614982605,
0.05473020300269127,
-0.5610450506210327,
-0.49162614345550537,
0.17676346004009247,
0.4272579252719879,
0.5821292996406555,
-0.16442912817001343,
0.6096518635749817,
-0.30779340863227844,
-0.5788783431053162,
0.20224784314632416,
-0.4528282880783081,
0.1120937243103981,
0.14064013957977295,
-0.6840797066688538,
0.6073933839797974,
-0.6895880699157715,
-0.16369564831256866,
-0.015547486953437328,
-0.08430610597133636,
-0.16864259541034698,
0.2878097891807556,
0.16262474656105042,
0.052075229585170746,
0.17530155181884766,
-0.2855270802974701,
0.4183758795261383,
-0.4733890891075134,
0.30939552187919617,
0.9717367887496948,
-0.2937052249908447,
0.5537139177322388,
-0.32931041717529297,
0.2486061304807663,
0.04911602661013603,
0.39020922780036926,
0.09901229292154312,
-0.050056055188179016,
-0.7310743927955627,
-0.03262322023510933,
0.10072695463895798,
0.5837006568908691,
-0.9173544645309448,
0.4238371253013611,
-0.13795138895511627,
-0.28474554419517517,
-0.5629105567932129,
0.023348867893218994,
0.5216087698936462,
0.46567919850349426,
0.48789528012275696,
-0.3143504559993744,
-0.2079235017299652,
-0.9035874605178833,
0.22723732888698578,
-0.10649269819259644,
0.013343707658350468,
0.3326266407966614,
0.32152053713798523,
-0.3919593095779419,
0.6801331639289856,
-0.47247618436813354,
-0.9237099885940552,
0.14758841693401337,
0.08190608769655228,
-0.2706022262573242,
0.6547839045524597,
0.41751185059547424,
-0.7384811639785767,
0.03617246076464653,
0.48114916682243347,
-0.6042234897613525,
-0.0103373471647501,
-0.25261083245277405,
-0.035715892910957336,
0.43470966815948486,
0.5700154304504395,
-0.46007388830184937,
0.36018142104148865,
0.44463950395584106,
-0.285163551568985,
0.37460437417030334,
-0.20767556130886078,
0.02702348120510578,
-0.6735108494758606,
-0.019512860104441643,
0.07375774532556534,
-0.15670309960842133,
-0.34761732816696167,
-0.011164197698235512,
-0.1821001172065735,
0.040157802402973175,
-0.42801401019096375,
0.7231210470199585,
-0.09273558855056763,
0.020967233926057816,
-0.34298187494277954,
0.09991199523210526,
-0.18061552941799164,
0.9186415672302246,
0.31565985083580017,
0.6218187212944031,
0.3299713432788849,
-0.5999950766563416,
0.39938485622406006,
0.11536965519189835,
-0.1880359947681427,
0.7087438702583313,
-0.457737535238266,
-0.21109670400619507,
-0.17808526754379272,
0.051095008850097656,
-0.5545555949211121,
-0.4118863344192505,
0.5379718542098999,
-0.1779053509235382,
0.2696835994720459,
0.2541053593158722,
-0.0430687740445137,
-0.12395098060369492,
-0.30058467388153076,
0.4774688184261322,
0.20021937787532806,
-0.599286675453186,
0.7850125432014465,
0.23377707600593567,
0.14971086382865906,
-0.7699028253555298,
-0.6235443949699402,
-0.31577417254447937,
-0.08534637838602066,
-0.36520978808403015,
0.519935667514801,
-0.10953544080257416,
-0.14605426788330078,
0.14911285042762756,
-0.12012482434511185,
0.025889968499541283,
0.0021583125926554203,
0.26919037103652954,
0.32069870829582214,
-0.27154576778411865,
0.05857779085636139,
-0.3076971173286438,
-0.09063689410686493,
-0.23833021521568298,
-0.3684435784816742,
0.6213146448135376,
-0.4251560866832733,
-0.4094076156616211,
-0.5694332718849182,
0.26673850417137146,
0.5060633420944214,
-0.4623492658138275,
0.5881068110466003,
1.0605989694595337,
-0.49856093525886536,
-0.20887848734855652,
-0.516183614730835,
-0.34233811497688293,
-0.46452608704566956,
0.5358777642250061,
-0.13427942991256714,
-1.0135550498962402,
0.22910024225711823,
0.2386266142129898,
0.14157481491565704,
0.3099706768989563,
0.5985203385353088,
0.12001604586839676,
1.2498449087142944,
0.5603769421577454,
-0.08656754344701767,
0.6082091331481934,
-0.18720315396785736,
0.3116263747215271,
-0.631978452205658,
-0.7281743288040161,
-0.26918500661849976,
-0.5211381912231445,
-0.35086873173713684,
-0.49260401725769043,
-0.0033309420105069876,
0.15706881880760193,
-0.3291473388671875,
-0.07533562928438187,
-0.7723018527030945,
0.44051089882850647,
0.5115472674369812,
0.17159503698349,
-0.06658998131752014,
0.10213212668895721,
0.07804375886917114,
0.11210265010595322,
-0.5342093110084534,
-0.2881038188934326,
0.5632036924362183,
0.32925963401794434,
0.9369979500770569,
-0.18094515800476074,
0.6538219451904297,
0.16954125463962555,
0.10957635194063187,
-1.0936610698699951,
0.5683587789535522,
-0.3465832769870758,
0.017482273280620575,
-0.5736095309257507,
-0.3371799886226654,
-0.6500293016433716,
0.22230735421180725,
-0.35825639963150024,
-0.8947445154190063,
0.3963001072406769,
0.3721197247505188,
-0.7946299910545349,
0.15165886282920837,
-0.3698021471500397,
1.0601482391357422,
-0.5678061842918396,
-0.7040373682975769,
-0.035423267632722855,
-0.5777477622032166,
0.27131131291389465,
0.0195483285933733,
0.12831836938858032,
0.010420126840472221,
0.16400079429149628,
0.5142671465873718,
-0.6867207884788513,
0.8370152115821838,
-0.4526859521865845,
-0.24807295203208923,
-0.019999166950583458,
-0.06285355240106583,
0.6074970364570618,
0.06137891858816147,
0.30011647939682007,
-0.09966588765382767,
-0.00006466427294071764,
-0.18671204149723053,
-0.6159605383872986,
0.7491687536239624,
-0.7461270689964294,
-0.4586033225059509,
-0.4544449746608734,
-0.7116690278053284,
-0.24476779997348785,
0.11452741920948029,
0.1341288983821869,
0.5566943883895874,
-0.06213673949241638,
0.12391099333763123,
0.6492596864700317,
-0.14680281281471252,
0.47427183389663696,
0.29282575845718384,
-0.5380557179450989,
-0.655005931854248,
1.3836584091186523,
-0.14113156497478485,
0.03316983953118324,
0.5183947682380676,
0.2631056606769562,
-0.12623564898967743,
-0.5663145184516907,
-0.44862738251686096,
0.03138607740402222,
-0.3769887089729309,
-0.4154059886932373,
-0.2409428209066391,
-0.2885820269584656,
-0.16657456755638123,
-0.4626333713531494,
-0.44682949781417847,
-0.023090898990631104,
-0.4056890606880188,
0.30218079686164856,
0.13546901941299438,
0.4038424789905548,
-0.10048603266477585,
0.39030715823173523,
-0.6522250175476074,
0.4013146460056305,
0.4162162244319916,
0.49474090337753296,
0.1588805764913559,
-0.207830548286438,
-0.2581213116645813,
0.2147562950849533,
-0.2052282989025116,
-0.4298354685306549,
0.25046712160110474,
0.21996308863162994,
0.27884918451309204,
0.7822169661521912,
0.03600560873746872,
1.070783019065857,
-0.5044571757316589,
0.7930888533592224,
0.31523001194000244,
-0.7777358889579773,
0.4658246338367462,
-0.11501114070415497,
0.043268125504255295,
0.6736243367195129,
0.016157807782292366,
-0.35891634225845337,
-0.2593574821949005,
-0.20751610398292542,
-0.813725471496582,
0.8409750461578369,
0.023131825029850006,
-0.06992127001285553,
0.0610601082444191,
0.2857867181301117,
0.011346384882926941,
0.10042128711938858,
-0.7123816609382629,
0.20576117932796478,
-0.3385571539402008,
-0.49340909719467163,
-0.0780491903424263,
0.04170091077685356,
-0.2801474928855896,
-0.32084110379219055,
0.7832485437393188,
-0.4328767657279968,
0.15768545866012573,
0.34037625789642334,
-0.06804133951663971,
-0.21380630135536194,
-0.011739671230316162,
0.9857080578804016,
0.3868097960948944,
-0.24483853578567505,
0.09775020182132721,
-0.13136593997478485,
-0.29881566762924194,
0.165106400847435,
0.22166363894939423,
-0.27234572172164917,
-0.19547995924949646,
0.24753698706626892,
1.1705117225646973,
0.10439201444387436,
-0.7905002236366272,
0.6619100570678711,
-0.0681065246462822,
-0.4047727882862091,
-0.33563530445098877,
0.30108362436294556,
-0.39267364144325256,
0.8009364604949951,
0.16971610486507416,
0.19004441797733307,
-0.17116327583789825,
-0.4263090491294861,
0.15233054757118225,
0.7619143724441528,
-0.6970938444137573,
-0.06759289652109146,
0.8094836473464966,
0.12355579435825348,
-0.4969785213470459,
0.6028908491134644,
-0.20353731513023376,
-0.4589483439922333,
0.5256834030151367,
0.4821101725101471,
0.8024094104766846,
-0.1392136812210083,
0.47310248017311096,
0.2994596064090729,
0.2063675820827484,
-0.41109710931777954,
0.1297507882118225,
-0.05312187969684601,
-0.6448409557342529,
-0.42396280169487,
-0.94980388879776,
-0.1577434241771698,
0.39238348603248596,
-0.5755753517150879,
0.21263176202774048,
-0.40487539768218994,
-0.08437103033065796,
0.022365905344486237,
-0.0432918481528759,
-0.4720219671726227,
0.22462570667266846,
0.39098238945007324,
0.5795257687568665,
-0.8385927677154541,
0.6914731860160828,
0.541752278804779,
-0.6381007432937622,
-0.9520081281661987,
0.14265945553779602,
-0.06714550405740738,
-0.8256221413612366,
0.49529698491096497,
0.44878247380256653,
-0.21837164461612701,
-0.035345274955034256,
-0.5482591986656189,
-0.6255216598510742,
0.9888620972633362,
0.1449885070323944,
-0.7926779389381409,
-0.18113106489181519,
0.06792385131120682,
0.3952793478965759,
-0.4889460802078247,
-0.0611855573952198,
0.49532416462898254,
0.6406601667404175,
0.13582471013069153,
-0.7767188549041748,
0.0358453132212162,
-0.2048594057559967,
0.28946974873542786,
0.40455785393714905,
-0.7805556654930115,
0.5500836968421936,
-0.11584299802780151,
0.14650574326515198,
0.2492644190788269,
0.6997320055961609,
0.21714496612548828,
0.41841933131217957,
0.5997505187988281,
0.6679960489273071,
0.6311643123626709,
-0.20377151668071747,
0.7092952132225037,
0.0619664266705513,
0.26404550671577454,
1.0160114765167236,
-0.24220889806747437,
0.9482956528663635,
0.81802898645401,
0.07715149223804474,
0.19254595041275024,
0.7118837237358093,
-0.32305726408958435,
0.8107149004936218,
0.16102002561092377,
-0.0222795233130455,
-0.20957031846046448,
-0.40060532093048096,
-0.2918633222579956,
0.5381948947906494,
0.1696290820837021,
-0.14968819916248322,
0.02953789383172989,
0.30458778142929077,
-0.2566710114479065,
0.0070229824632406235,
-0.5503469109535217,
0.8168004155158997,
-0.15522660315036774,
-1.093247890472412,
0.7601990699768066,
-0.1568833291530609,
0.7255528569221497,
-0.5678198933601379,
-0.10224522650241852,
-0.33402785658836365,
0.5544014573097229,
-0.4405770003795624,
-0.463360071182251,
0.31384122371673584,
-0.18996043503284454,
-0.130612313747406,
0.06324436515569687,
0.3392403721809387,
-0.7678109407424927,
-0.42276012897491455,
0.17015323042869568,
-0.042985156178474426,
-0.11064284294843674,
-0.04398595541715622,
-0.44151070713996887,
0.3760897219181061,
0.06881831586360931,
-0.05405760556459427,
0.34512922167778015,
0.2651069462299347,
-0.2963477671146393,
0.36391881108283997,
0.3967880606651306,
0.14168892800807953,
-0.14278678596019745,
0.20998577773571014,
0.7184848189353943,
-0.4357687830924988,
-0.28103381395339966,
-0.9895421266555786,
0.4359716773033142,
0.030376870185136795,
-0.2256365567445755,
0.1898176670074463,
0.3077905774116516,
0.9710125923156738,
-0.04424498975276947,
0.3718581795692444,
-0.03198856860399246,
-0.2141195386648178,
-0.8554319739341736,
0.43195652961730957,
-0.9784699082374573,
0.1735178530216217,
-0.33530062437057495,
-1.1622964143753052,
-0.44868794083595276,
0.9614401459693909,
-0.09254980087280273,
-0.17526651918888092,
0.5977555513381958,
1.0530153512954712,
-0.08476592600345612,
-0.22049418091773987,
0.17731249332427979,
0.021110117435455322,
0.20049059391021729,
0.7331547737121582,
0.878578245639801,
-0.1721150130033493,
0.5646661520004272,
-0.47971513867378235,
-0.1051458790898323,
-0.5357394814491272,
-0.7028248310089111,
-0.6374968886375427,
-0.7107601761817932,
-0.362110435962677,
-0.22792354226112366,
-0.052979134023189545,
0.8752843737602234,
0.616434633731842,
-0.8589422106742859,
-0.07150836288928986,
-0.3295484781265259,
-0.15453875064849854,
-0.47732117772102356,
-0.25448286533355713,
0.4412553012371063,
-0.5588759779930115,
-0.7176668643951416,
0.17436981201171875,
0.45528286695480347,
0.10675729066133499,
-0.4508572518825531,
-0.5583657622337341,
0.03752211108803749,
-0.05262886360287666,
0.5443243980407715,
0.29877692461013794,
-1.1816414594650269,
-0.5464509725570679,
-0.09515799582004547,
-0.0844016820192337,
0.038406774401664734,
0.6403405070304871,
-0.7779932022094727,
0.4080888032913208,
0.28469276428222656,
1.0305906534194946,
0.2522408068180084,
0.0655101016163826,
0.44129037857055664,
-0.5868125557899475,
0.358943909406662,
0.32968971133232117,
0.26810526847839355,
0.3206460773944855,
-0.3421647846698761,
0.41292688250541687,
-0.09158118069171906,
-0.6698213815689087,
-0.9682286381721497,
0.1825743317604065,
-1.128583312034607,
-0.3075309991836548,
0.9997191429138184,
0.2515204846858978,
-0.41415396332740784,
0.37977463006973267,
-0.5519018173217773,
0.16746695339679718,
-0.1890297532081604,
0.8921341896057129,
0.46582621335983276,
-0.03185337781906128,
-0.23114652931690216,
-0.3925561010837555,
0.7279987335205078,
0.6832231879234314,
-0.7329074144363403,
0.08837801963090897,
0.8351539969444275,
-0.2413185089826584,
0.2965222895145416,
0.5326655507087708,
0.0431901179254055,
0.2884894907474518,
-0.21816620230674744,
-0.06742687523365021,
-0.25181102752685547,
-0.666816771030426,
-0.5280877947807312,
0.195784330368042,
0.09966783970594406,
-0.42641526460647583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.05019v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.05019v1
|
Shortcut-connected Expert Parallelism for Accelerating Mixture-of-Experts
| 2024-04-07T17:17:23 | 2024-04-07T17:17:23 |
Weilin Cai, Juyong Jiang, Le Qin, Junwei Cui, Sunghun Kim, Jiayi Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC
|
Expert parallelism has been introduced as a strategy to distribute the
computational workload of sparsely-gated mixture-of-experts (MoE) models across
multiple computing devices, facilitating the execution of these increasingly
large-scale models. However, the All-to-All communication intrinsic to expert
parallelism constitutes a significant overhead, diminishing the MoE models'
efficiency. Current optimization approaches offer some relief, yet they are
constrained by the sequential interdependence of communication and computation
operations. To address this limitation, we present a novel shortcut-connected
MoE architecture with overlapping parallel strategy, designated as ScMoE, which
effectively decouples communication from its conventional sequence, allowing
for a substantial overlap of 70% to 100% with computation. When compared with
the prevalent top-2 MoE architecture, ScMoE demonstrates training speed
improvements of 30% and 11%, and inference improvements of 40% and 15%, in our
PCIe and NVLink hardware environments, respectively, where communication
constitutes 60% and 15% of the total MoE time consumption. On the other hand,
extensive experiments and theoretical analyses indicate that ScMoE not only
achieves comparable but in some instances surpasses the model quality of
existing approaches in vision and language tasks.
|
[
-0.590363621711731,
-0.7556429505348206,
0.7206854820251465,
0.34305715560913086,
-0.47212472558021545,
0.22839191555976868,
-0.29772475361824036,
-0.5531249046325684,
0.5057240724563599,
0.1113286167383194,
-0.6168984770774841,
0.04748820886015892,
-0.8888755440711975,
-0.0037488790694624186,
0.006939489394426346,
0.4300512671470642,
-0.015017936937510967,
-0.17862682044506073,
-0.6987426280975342,
-0.18345746397972107,
-0.5846537351608276,
-0.05373724177479744,
-0.42257410287857056,
0.028864184394478798,
0.4214501678943634,
0.5795859694480896,
0.6642112135887146,
1.0095783472061157,
0.5844487547874451,
0.3451869785785675,
0.12363694608211517,
0.367899626493454,
-0.5135079622268677,
0.22642837464809418,
-0.4449712336063385,
-0.3498830795288086,
-0.5818421244621277,
-0.26498958468437195,
0.42853638529777527,
0.7171539068222046,
-0.24815115332603455,
-0.03210705146193504,
0.0576310008764267,
0.6478908658027649,
-0.9974116086959839,
0.15948174893856049,
-0.7789252400398254,
-0.3812576234340668,
-0.5831447243690491,
-0.28395789861679077,
-0.18808256089687347,
0.06161998584866524,
0.22422225773334503,
-0.5842896103858948,
0.008802658878266811,
-0.027471086010336876,
0.3437751829624176,
0.45322734117507935,
-0.41432082653045654,
-0.08652949333190918,
-0.5390620827674866,
0.8488427996635437,
-0.5982217788696289,
0.20618365705013275,
0.012229213491082191,
0.5995749831199646,
-0.03047037497162819,
-0.44683316349983215,
-0.33156052231788635,
0.21584048867225647,
0.2995666265487671,
0.31797948479652405,
-0.2854697108268738,
0.27873289585113525,
0.027252336964011192,
0.14813940227031708,
-0.21173438429832458,
0.22748662531375885,
-0.6693423390388489,
0.04356549307703972,
0.7455132007598877,
0.30841290950775146,
-0.08867917209863663,
0.17431914806365967,
-0.5361261367797852,
0.20206104218959808,
-0.5534486770629883,
-0.13307924568653107,
0.20028993487358093,
-0.1062982827425003,
0.13537323474884033,
0.2464553713798523,
-0.7397511005401611,
0.8268887400627136,
0.07246152311563492,
-0.08979053795337677,
0.13772666454315186,
-0.21938256919384003,
-0.07826625555753708,
-0.11206889152526855,
0.8089860081672668,
0.528447687625885,
-0.09029076248407364,
-0.30769336223602295,
-0.0637274906039238,
0.06458301097154617,
0.21902400255203247,
-0.9052899479866028,
-0.30152907967567444,
0.09322900325059891,
-0.3005085587501526,
-0.2999301254749298,
-0.08014487475156784,
-0.7655713558197021,
-0.06958118081092834,
-0.08327390253543854,
0.5697863698005676,
-0.0851789340376854,
-0.37128394842147827,
0.2255008965730667,
-0.235556960105896,
-0.35959482192993164,
0.2535281479358673,
-1.022276520729065,
0.4153585731983185,
0.6838858127593994,
0.8243520855903625,
-0.3045901954174042,
-0.2768075466156006,
-0.5404720902442932,
0.48207011818885803,
-0.20848630368709564,
0.7698260545730591,
-0.73725426197052,
-0.6265755295753479,
-0.565826416015625,
-0.4082401394844055,
-0.39045897126197815,
-0.507914662361145,
0.3302648961544037,
-0.4196215569972992,
0.004705002065747976,
-0.17299287021160126,
-0.579645574092865,
-0.15721984207630157,
0.05590515956282616,
-0.24367375671863556,
0.9872351288795471,
-0.22078795731067657,
-0.773838460445404,
-0.032378338277339935,
-0.8264167308807373,
-0.28113123774528503,
-0.05654304474592209,
-0.48676586151123047,
-0.14031265676021576,
0.34624817967414856,
0.3596968650817871,
0.6430416107177734,
-0.4818810522556305,
0.13016444444656372,
-0.7524630427360535,
-0.5132631659507751,
-0.2272409200668335,
-0.4189243018627167,
0.45859745144844055,
0.20501621067523956,
-0.4246477782726288,
0.04155650734901428,
-0.7060108780860901,
-0.014996261335909367,
0.011156228370964527,
-0.01974404789507389,
-0.5312359929084778,
0.1732579618692398,
-0.3883882462978363,
0.36581674218177795,
0.46480727195739746,
-0.6063457131385803,
0.41879764199256897,
-0.20044900476932526,
0.6356071829795837,
0.9607003331184387,
0.05233464017510414,
0.47107192873954773,
-0.2148592323064804,
0.3018249273300171,
0.18355639278888702,
0.4800877869129181,
-0.1942383199930191,
-0.8017527461051941,
-0.6173081398010254,
-0.6677214503288269,
0.12176301330327988,
0.6666074395179749,
-0.9557402729988098,
0.24620497226715088,
-0.6071836948394775,
-0.6360861659049988,
-0.6689610481262207,
0.1564664989709854,
0.578725278377533,
0.5237579941749573,
0.40864622592926025,
-0.496807336807251,
-0.04855279624462128,
-1.3659074306488037,
-0.3823321759700775,
0.14394304156303406,
-0.1471499651670456,
0.6289627552032471,
0.17175330221652985,
-0.05235689505934715,
0.9392399787902832,
-0.6498764157295227,
-0.024323245510458946,
0.04036315903067589,
0.22330214083194733,
0.041118744760751724,
0.668356716632843,
0.6867417097091675,
-0.4642197787761688,
-0.6237290501594543,
0.10900869965553284,
-0.6836957335472107,
-0.2197544425725937,
0.05751045420765877,
-0.43904680013656616,
-0.3426159918308258,
0.33902132511138916,
-0.7739578485488892,
0.34934598207473755,
0.42933687567710876,
0.3031061887741089,
0.3269455134868622,
-0.1290515810251236,
0.25346091389656067,
-1.1958696842193604,
-0.35929498076438904,
-0.360857754945755,
-0.08525026589632034,
-0.5332642793655396,
0.2204095423221588,
-0.00008864723349688575,
-0.030288347974419594,
-0.4952978491783142,
0.38730451464653015,
-0.5692682266235352,
-0.23352977633476257,
-0.5710506439208984,
0.04705945402383804,
-0.08938416838645935,
0.6327780485153198,
-0.02658579684793949,
0.9111931324005127,
1.021011471748352,
-0.27249664068222046,
0.12909658253192902,
-0.1120486855506897,
-0.12808240950107574,
0.5205948352813721,
-0.802614688873291,
0.29466861486434937,
0.16348521411418915,
0.014748706482350826,
-0.5641725659370422,
-0.25349846482276917,
0.17194749414920807,
-0.30682387948036194,
0.05389869958162308,
-0.03867235407233238,
-0.42453533411026,
-0.2340269535779953,
-0.22773602604866028,
1.0927507877349854,
0.6426748037338257,
-0.28018853068351746,
1.001469373703003,
0.17548376321792603,
-0.3891962468624115,
-0.5231935977935791,
-0.46466031670570374,
0.1025514230132103,
0.009562181308865547,
-1.0996818542480469,
0.4137633740901947,
-0.08596660941839218,
-0.11463350057601929,
0.052281707525253296,
-0.277437686920166,
-0.34905749559402466,
0.15987740457057953,
0.15324972569942474,
0.12325718253850937,
-0.19619008898735046,
-0.2816496789455414,
0.643971860408783,
-0.09043297916650772,
-0.009768436662852764,
-0.24910207092761993,
0.2831825017929077,
0.03226105123758316,
-0.6714329719543457,
-0.8021737933158875,
0.8359747529029846,
0.762382984161377,
-0.2786514163017273,
0.6059243679046631,
0.2351280152797699,
-0.17362824082374573,
-0.0322229228913784,
-0.8267757892608643,
-0.36761757731437683,
-0.5527579188346863,
0.40411460399627686,
-0.3243682384490967,
-0.7770602703094482,
0.3737107515335083,
-0.24992792308330536,
0.06850245594978333,
0.25479820370674133,
0.324480265378952,
-0.26588404178619385,
1.037979006767273,
0.5577921271324158,
-0.18575334548950195,
0.5248239636421204,
-0.10853966325521469,
0.23435518145561218,
-0.4541730284690857,
-0.07408203929662704,
-0.1813563108444214,
-0.39188504219055176,
-0.2552000880241394,
-0.8187130093574524,
0.6936681866645813,
0.3844977617263794,
0.10373997688293457,
0.1508997529745102,
-0.3208893835544586,
0.6911065578460693,
0.7469343543052673,
0.3806591033935547,
0.10793802887201309,
-0.01021590270102024,
-0.06692010909318924,
0.10741919279098511,
-1.1087042093276978,
-0.02745022438466549,
1.0299427509307861,
0.1275901347398758,
0.4070626199245453,
-0.3411897122859955,
0.834886908531189,
0.22938385605812073,
0.11153052002191544,
-0.4601716995239258,
0.7217468023300171,
0.027235614135861397,
-0.4336506128311157,
0.0011144466698169708,
-0.4251624643802643,
-0.3200599253177643,
0.5109138488769531,
-0.1699817180633545,
-0.6122978329658508,
0.5514003038406372,
0.2535092532634735,
-0.27006953954696655,
0.4676700532436371,
-0.7373231053352356,
0.5866554379463196,
-0.034242693334817886,
-0.5707409381866455,
-0.8221905827522278,
-0.9207376837730408,
0.5414877533912659,
-0.06803416460752487,
0.15811288356781006,
-0.1207941398024559,
-0.005304703488945961,
0.7104855179786682,
-0.7215138673782349,
0.7662031054496765,
-0.12551695108413696,
0.4396132230758667,
0.13317269086837769,
-0.061374224722385406,
0.760485053062439,
-0.146915003657341,
0.11354516446590424,
0.3787500858306885,
-0.4521121680736542,
-0.9843199849128723,
-0.8257551789283752,
0.5696413516998291,
-0.6608169674873352,
-0.8089373111724854,
-0.1484801471233368,
-0.7964509129524231,
-0.4321671724319458,
0.3745826184749603,
0.15364663302898407,
0.5295493006706238,
0.27079910039901733,
0.29347264766693115,
0.6348090171813965,
0.33271610736846924,
0.33508968353271484,
0.4695550501346588,
0.5122918486595154,
-0.46522289514541626,
1.0499117374420166,
-0.09169169515371323,
0.6288776993751526,
0.19430457055568695,
-0.22667816281318665,
0.1369864046573639,
-0.6522126197814941,
-0.45247703790664673,
0.12819890677928925,
-0.47215425968170166,
-0.06311032921075821,
-0.6803608536720276,
-0.08347870409488678,
0.008074949495494366,
-0.49582672119140625,
-0.8500672578811646,
-0.5904990434646606,
-0.29312074184417725,
0.022196417674422264,
0.12118162959814072,
0.49190789461135864,
-0.05858384072780609,
0.7473774552345276,
-0.912785530090332,
0.18978804349899292,
0.5212135314941406,
0.016497431322932243,
0.22792840003967285,
-0.02526671439409256,
-0.4733763337135315,
0.1786133497953415,
-0.5435075759887695,
-0.7804845571517944,
-0.21675507724285126,
0.23485445976257324,
0.7519954442977905,
0.9665084481239319,
0.10952543467283249,
1.0225862264633179,
-0.5039061903953552,
0.5475385785102844,
0.3858911097049713,
-0.8876545429229736,
0.23582996428012848,
-0.5142167806625366,
0.024874024093151093,
0.6340810656547546,
0.23133909702301025,
-0.03364286571741104,
-0.6521028876304626,
-0.5694215893745422,
-0.7764049172401428,
0.5705614686012268,
0.4600985646247864,
-0.21912585198879242,
-0.09609513729810715,
0.055951397866010666,
0.1736794114112854,
0.42651355266571045,
0.05441117659211159,
-0.074424609541893,
-0.02554209530353546,
-0.20751577615737915,
0.3054456114768982,
-0.22951571643352509,
-0.37823453545570374,
-0.22011040151119232,
0.4357762932777405,
-0.017811158671975136,
0.43729108572006226,
-0.004197048023343086,
-0.052926186472177505,
0.27121472358703613,
0.10491885244846344,
0.6117669939994812,
0.9623804688453674,
-0.1902403086423874,
-0.13976731896400452,
0.12310798466205597,
-0.30995869636535645,
-0.16105622053146362,
0.1673559546470642,
-0.10934916883707047,
-0.027271611616015434,
0.3246316909790039,
0.9966618418693542,
0.5393151640892029,
-0.4055342674255371,
0.7556234002113342,
0.27627792954444885,
-0.34656476974487305,
0.46639880537986755,
0.26336464285850525,
0.20818355679512024,
0.4873697757720947,
0.5178608298301697,
0.8185004591941833,
0.24051938951015472,
-0.093915656208992,
0.0599261112511158,
0.419216126203537,
-0.0028812787495553493,
-0.30774417519569397,
0.9883212447166443,
0.7258244156837463,
-0.10180757939815521,
0.427685022354126,
0.19521749019622803,
-0.47838154435157776,
0.6936126351356506,
-0.12378809601068497,
0.8778063654899597,
-0.16662204265594482,
-0.21671530604362488,
-0.14672942459583282,
0.1731342375278473,
-0.050591498613357544,
0.3508323132991791,
-0.5988857746124268,
-0.28553903102874756,
-0.3793455958366394,
-0.13518725335597992,
-0.3986457586288452,
-0.6917084455490112,
-0.9443060159683228,
0.1334492415189743,
-0.20503486692905426,
0.05388743802905083,
-0.30679282546043396,
-0.3461594879627228,
-0.6803538799285889,
0.033790674060583115,
-0.08565167337656021,
1.1436513662338257,
-0.94790118932724,
1.0659531354904175,
0.3885568380355835,
0.009650536812841892,
-0.3549124002456665,
-0.08813474327325821,
-0.2424568384885788,
-0.8054234981536865,
0.4159773290157318,
0.1840842366218567,
-0.30891135334968567,
0.05192168056964874,
-0.14701314270496368,
-0.5464193224906921,
1.3242698907852173,
0.26124900579452515,
-0.8223288059234619,
-0.1000932902097702,
0.01656113937497139,
0.18776442110538483,
-0.36541780829429626,
0.6416719555854797,
0.21175186336040497,
0.24141480028629303,
-0.07700943946838379,
-1.119097113609314,
-0.07683052867650986,
-0.3026813268661499,
0.20193138718605042,
0.07479778677225113,
-0.9759572744369507,
0.7431045770645142,
-0.0895349383354187,
-0.034866612404584885,
0.05625930428504944,
1.0823580026626587,
0.4340907037258148,
0.4181367754936218,
0.8177869915962219,
0.5296133756637573,
0.5196374654769897,
0.138027161359787,
0.6709129810333252,
-0.6638121008872986,
0.12968504428863525,
0.8463501334190369,
-0.0757303535938263,
0.9079006314277649,
0.7068511247634888,
-0.034995321184396744,
0.37027251720428467,
0.7223957180976868,
0.35376596450805664,
0.9523754119873047,
-0.5054726004600525,
-0.4489538371562958,
-0.675247073173523,
0.07916673272848129,
-0.7187846302986145,
0.0776401162147522,
0.3373749852180481,
-0.297163724899292,
-0.3821803331375122,
0.1934569925069809,
-0.19786690175533295,
-0.14900830388069153,
-0.4378986060619354,
0.5903592705726624,
-0.058620527386665344,
-0.4079816937446594,
0.42211174964904785,
-0.1418781578540802,
0.8089535236358643,
-0.6430270671844482,
0.09552254527807236,
-0.2814163863658905,
0.07580012083053589,
0.05329838767647743,
-0.5319768786430359,
0.07343198359012604,
-0.476958692073822,
-0.4568413496017456,
-0.10877794772386551,
0.5859673619270325,
-0.4785129427909851,
-0.42416441440582275,
0.25361889600753784,
0.443917840719223,
0.19651247560977936,
-0.09593577682971954,
-0.501043975353241,
0.03813527524471283,
-0.2507776618003845,
-0.1479857712984085,
0.5235119462013245,
0.2380620688199997,
-0.3648401200771332,
0.9263172149658203,
0.5126399993896484,
-0.005256767850369215,
0.56837397813797,
-0.5252071022987366,
1.3554112911224365,
-0.313286155462265,
-0.9063761234283447,
-0.5819920897483826,
0.4204309582710266,
-0.2730712890625,
-0.15910521149635315,
0.7580206990242004,
0.5152530670166016,
0.818513810634613,
-0.18366147577762604,
0.7887448668479919,
0.002080352511256933,
0.3016194999217987,
-0.44244587421417236,
0.4440579414367676,
-0.7840244174003601,
0.18999598920345306,
-0.18339848518371582,
-0.8068790435791016,
0.18007893860340118,
0.10893791913986206,
-0.3807011842727661,
-0.04362768307328224,
0.5596767067909241,
0.7722035646438599,
-0.7070187330245972,
0.09798702597618103,
0.21958953142166138,
0.2039191573858261,
0.23587842285633087,
0.806717574596405,
0.4386960566043854,
-0.1994771808385849,
0.5443321466445923,
-0.5428592562675476,
-0.48562297224998474,
-0.5464755296707153,
-0.8502311110496521,
-0.8431253433227539,
-0.2292361557483673,
-0.2383994460105896,
0.3645016551017761,
0.38238054513931274,
0.7886413931846619,
1.0240682363510132,
-0.3742729723453522,
-0.0993569865822792,
-0.07058712840080261,
-0.08925390243530273,
-0.5730365514755249,
-0.14031457901000977,
0.2511942386627197,
-0.03276240825653076,
-0.7910403609275818,
0.8021148443222046,
0.6571078896522522,
-0.4455637037754059,
-0.12486530095338821,
-0.07298676669597626,
0.18952301144599915,
0.3389149606227875,
0.48778921365737915,
0.2926838994026184,
-0.774133563041687,
0.06760817766189575,
-0.21903344988822937,
0.032625652849674225,
0.009763091802597046,
0.9583029747009277,
-0.46895632147789,
0.7748359441757202,
0.7877005338668823,
0.9159085154533386,
0.3669394552707672,
0.3247423470020294,
0.7088600397109985,
-0.6406943798065186,
0.5290946364402771,
0.1367889642715454,
0.4154852628707886,
-0.14438295364379883,
-0.30096641182899475,
0.04515266790986061,
0.6909629702568054,
-0.6502215266227722,
-0.802632749080658,
0.19144463539123535,
-1.219423770904541,
-0.3315490782260895,
0.6635722517967224,
-0.2664070725440979,
-0.4118528664112091,
0.04188193753361702,
-0.14099791646003723,
-0.13544148206710815,
-0.5016381144523621,
0.7982704043388367,
0.5551233291625977,
-0.2887890338897705,
-0.13841421902179718,
-0.5951980948448181,
0.07680458575487137,
0.7801902294158936,
-0.6091758012771606,
-0.18194179236888885,
0.3527711033821106,
0.3667772710323334,
-0.17366556823253632,
0.7913117408752441,
0.2195667177438736,
0.4968339800834656,
-0.027102025225758553,
-0.008883814327418804,
-0.7169649004936218,
-0.6267909407615662,
0.26542791724205017,
0.23471549153327942,
-0.3773520290851593,
-0.8253383636474609
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.