id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12788v1
|
REXEL: An End-to-end Model for Document-Level Relation Extraction and Entity Linking
| 2024-04-19T11:04:27 | 2024-04-19T11:04:27 |
Nacime Bouziani, Shubhi Tyagi, Joseph Fisher, Jens Lehmann, Andrea Pierleoni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extracting structured information from unstructured text is critical for many
downstream NLP applications and is traditionally achieved by closed information
extraction (cIE). However, existing approaches for cIE suffer from two
limitations: (i) they are often pipelines which makes them prone to error
propagation, and/or (ii) they are restricted to sentence level which prevents
them from capturing long-range dependencies and results in expensive inference
time. We address these limitations by proposing REXEL, a highly efficient and
accurate model for the joint task of document level cIE (DocIE). REXEL performs
mention detection, entity typing, entity disambiguation, coreference resolution
and document-level relation classification in a single forward pass to yield
facts fully linked to a reference knowledge graph. It is on average 11 times
faster than competitive existing approaches in a similar setting and performs
competitively both when optimised for any of the individual subtasks and a
variety of combinations of different joint tasks, surpassing the baselines by
an average of more than 6 F1 points. The combination of speed and accuracy
makes REXEL an accurate cost-efficient system for extracting structured
information at web-scale. We also release an extension of the DocRED dataset to
enable benchmarking of future work on DocIE, which is available at
https://github.com/amazon-science/e2e-docie.
|
[
-0.21229968965053558,
-0.4221523702144623,
0.6451505422592163,
-0.25539276003837585,
-0.28076454997062683,
-0.15041068196296692,
-0.3376244604587555,
-0.8030458688735962,
-0.05107051134109497,
0.13137662410736084,
-0.29913032054901123,
-0.7765586972236633,
-0.7546876072883606,
0.26446717977523804,
-0.6014114618301392,
0.8460745811462402,
0.00007615306094521657,
-0.33781594038009644,
-0.48140913248062134,
0.00945177674293518,
0.0532425232231617,
0.012846476398408413,
-0.6103582978248596,
-0.3174406588077545,
0.6054123640060425,
0.37239131331443787,
0.3908647298812866,
0.7567142844200134,
0.3573572337627411,
0.2507612109184265,
-0.18439443409442902,
0.22582776844501495,
-0.5571044087409973,
0.49779441952705383,
-0.6111546754837036,
-0.19554607570171356,
-0.3823350965976715,
0.1865387260913849,
0.45939111709594727,
0.7964905500411987,
-0.054502226412296295,
0.13105204701423645,
0.005382790230214596,
0.43994706869125366,
-0.664005696773529,
0.45132362842559814,
-0.5061360001564026,
-0.34590640664100647,
-0.14052098989486694,
0.022286832332611084,
-0.5213634967803955,
-0.2258477360010147,
0.24247203767299652,
-1.0016425848007202,
0.11367234587669373,
0.07353120297193527,
1.3468633890151978,
0.2492748349905014,
-0.3555748164653778,
-0.6299290657043457,
-0.6438766717910767,
0.6323598623275757,
-0.544337809085846,
0.5527465343475342,
0.15785951912403107,
0.015385793522000313,
-0.06695474684238434,
-1.2782847881317139,
-0.5302311778068542,
0.06854917854070663,
-0.19572050869464874,
0.3176259696483612,
-0.18965665996074677,
0.27104586362838745,
0.42761147022247314,
0.21186545491218567,
-0.3463405668735504,
-0.03376462683081627,
-0.3051421046257019,
0.27094700932502747,
0.24560168385505676,
-0.4237522780895233,
0.3925999402999878,
-0.41340896487236023,
-0.42868784070014954,
-0.22563844919204712,
-0.3988034725189209,
-0.03907918184995651,
0.19887033104896545,
-0.020418696105480194,
0.30527958273887634,
0.617687463760376,
0.05949637293815613,
0.5273453593254089,
0.029968559741973877,
-0.18056978285312653,
-0.057801518589258194,
-0.19825322926044464,
-0.2645259499549866,
-0.09160813689231873,
0.7220330238342285,
0.28724223375320435,
0.4941348731517792,
-0.6011332273483276,
-0.2993631362915039,
-0.08681659400463104,
0.1922995150089264,
-1.0480865240097046,
0.09831788390874863,
0.5313064455986023,
-0.5536326766014099,
-0.19639740884304047,
0.1651710718870163,
-1.0528684854507446,
-0.06595239043235779,
-0.3151702880859375,
-0.060180675238370895,
-0.8345393538475037,
-0.2880387604236603,
-0.05839183181524277,
-0.39802253246307373,
0.2223588079214096,
0.32493335008621216,
-0.781072735786438,
0.5366433262825012,
0.7980194091796875,
0.7392503619194031,
-0.014004482887685299,
-0.10305333882570267,
-0.6406295299530029,
0.5034822821617126,
-0.24286404252052307,
1.0168207883834839,
-0.8201037645339966,
-0.4254249036312103,
0.08064882457256317,
0.02409943751990795,
-0.45298638939857483,
-0.4975197911262512,
1.123071551322937,
-0.5595138072967529,
0.3556373417377472,
-0.06887460500001907,
-0.9881986975669861,
-0.07482779771089554,
0.018594568595290184,
-0.6612018942832947,
1.1572803258895874,
0.6043832898139954,
-0.9575941562652588,
0.3148435652256012,
-0.4488515853881836,
-0.3862677216529846,
0.11509744077920914,
-0.3443184494972229,
-0.24084465205669403,
0.01609533093869686,
0.05945700407028198,
0.28830501437187195,
-0.8581256866455078,
0.34563401341438293,
-0.1723570078611374,
-0.2570549249649048,
-0.2394265979528427,
0.2829881012439728,
0.6962283253669739,
0.37662574648857117,
-0.17646712064743042,
0.037439197301864624,
-1.042413592338562,
0.07202114164829254,
0.01963168941438198,
-0.37994322180747986,
-0.8229955434799194,
-0.10165311396121979,
0.1310282200574875,
0.2414747178554535,
0.22964148223400116,
-0.8251031637191772,
0.3511536121368408,
-0.3206294775009155,
0.4298997223377228,
0.42325568199157715,
-0.06426222622394562,
0.6543281078338623,
-0.1544136106967926,
0.35790878534317017,
-0.31919416785240173,
-0.0037759249098598957,
-0.3123166561126709,
-0.19742654263973236,
-0.4266708791255951,
-0.5696960091590881,
0.7989838123321533,
0.6867473125457764,
-0.583239734172821,
0.41627344489097595,
-0.6649801135063171,
-0.26865658164024353,
-0.3833015263080597,
-0.01823270320892334,
0.5026195049285889,
0.8336542248725891,
0.22980521619319916,
-0.11291342973709106,
-0.38387688994407654,
-0.7428992390632629,
0.031044552102684975,
-0.32446548342704773,
-0.48004215955734253,
0.2961632013320923,
0.5051784515380859,
0.10161643475294113,
0.9826446175575256,
-0.48667991161346436,
-0.2736497223377228,
0.03750908747315407,
0.5652216672897339,
0.3168821632862091,
0.20868510007858276,
0.47077614068984985,
-0.8143024444580078,
-0.5166230797767639,
0.1958557516336441,
-1.2288302183151245,
-0.2483338713645935,
-0.04395443573594093,
0.04825527220964432,
0.05764371529221535,
0.5842533707618713,
-1.1171295642852783,
0.19407035410404205,
0.10296647995710373,
-0.1293661892414093,
0.33542025089263916,
-0.1993435174226761,
-0.05256369337439537,
-1.3893533945083618,
0.43050137162208557,
0.16759322583675385,
-0.09863995760679245,
-0.4594748914241791,
0.16726236045360565,
0.2669547498226166,
-0.39540940523147583,
0.047331832349300385,
0.3318031430244446,
-0.8264804482460022,
-0.29245907068252563,
0.00943087600171566,
0.2839474380016327,
0.33280691504478455,
0.2815402150154114,
0.1572672426700592,
0.7602179646492004,
0.3233051002025604,
-0.11644314229488373,
0.21782684326171875,
0.4603400230407715,
-0.18483079969882965,
0.7384429574012756,
-0.6993177533149719,
0.38817524909973145,
-0.21409104764461517,
-0.03541663661599159,
-0.686943769454956,
-0.15816664695739746,
0.0557100847363472,
-0.5058535933494568,
0.9574187397956848,
-0.4535004198551178,
-0.4578588008880615,
-0.02644864283502102,
-0.339471697807312,
0.00959082879126072,
0.3771931231021881,
-0.501343309879303,
0.9864661693572998,
0.36752861738204956,
-0.36992037296295166,
-0.7584109902381897,
-0.07679487019777298,
0.3446088135242462,
-0.01523936539888382,
-1.0820438861846924,
0.7784249186515808,
0.193661168217659,
-0.35680317878723145,
0.3966464400291443,
-0.39091166853904724,
-0.4822065532207489,
-0.2287914752960205,
0.24552226066589355,
0.3020177483558655,
-0.07128017395734787,
0.24558845162391663,
0.06427872180938721,
-0.24128039181232452,
0.11886779963970184,
-0.6114242672920227,
0.2614246904850006,
0.14440611004829407,
0.23938365280628204,
-0.14609099924564362,
0.7783375978469849,
0.8820491433143616,
-0.3382682204246521,
0.7159064412117004,
0.4252319931983948,
-0.7808603644371033,
-0.317218542098999,
-0.27142134308815,
-0.021957168355584145,
-0.3477722704410553,
0.2487565129995346,
-0.7195553779602051,
-0.384905070066452,
0.33735963702201843,
-0.5893142819404602,
0.04983466491103172,
0.46521076560020447,
-0.1912047266960144,
-0.2148268073797226,
0.241571307182312,
0.8877144455909729,
0.050756968557834625,
0.09228197485208511,
-0.25359046459198,
0.32316625118255615,
-0.8175705671310425,
-0.5565297603607178,
-0.8105279207229614,
0.2670716941356659,
-0.4688814878463745,
-0.22630129754543304,
0.21707145869731903,
0.5940732955932617,
0.3336711525917053,
0.6194115877151489,
-0.5333750247955322,
0.15115346014499664,
0.6179892420768738,
-0.19361360371112823,
0.3552144765853882,
0.006254254840314388,
-0.3142837882041931,
0.05947365611791611,
-0.5867689847946167,
-0.42546823620796204,
1.0759532451629639,
0.17805169522762299,
0.748384952545166,
-0.02645104005932808,
0.7453438639640808,
0.2634718418121338,
0.10923589020967484,
-0.781095027923584,
0.4736475646495819,
-0.18758735060691833,
-0.3727547526359558,
-0.5064525604248047,
-0.19025835394859314,
-0.8074151277542114,
-0.11680875718593597,
-0.2656944990158081,
-0.7236048579216003,
0.5847341418266296,
-0.4172562062740326,
0.03088219091296196,
0.28950947523117065,
-0.7057210803031921,
0.7181041240692139,
0.37102222442626953,
-0.6989231109619141,
-0.053123679012060165,
-0.7415966391563416,
0.03888671100139618,
-0.22724226117134094,
0.15522398054599762,
-0.020429523661732674,
-0.0845632404088974,
0.6297274231910706,
-0.5441364049911499,
0.40863800048828125,
-0.007856637239456177,
-0.07939232885837555,
0.2821260392665863,
-0.08995711803436279,
0.8834413886070251,
0.08542587608098984,
-0.24145379662513733,
0.2504631280899048,
0.15292611718177795,
-0.24941223859786987,
-0.6397333741188049,
0.6602888107299805,
-0.6215994954109192,
-0.285587877035141,
-0.7534555792808533,
-0.6021767258644104,
0.04104100912809372,
0.3655713200569153,
0.2742346227169037,
0.5630768537521362,
-0.18031667172908783,
0.11148291826248169,
0.8743422627449036,
-0.08728396147489548,
0.664836049079895,
0.6098219156265259,
0.0972549170255661,
-0.35518577694892883,
0.6696007251739502,
0.16155101358890533,
-0.03667379170656204,
0.7811167240142822,
-0.24230033159255981,
-0.4193706810474396,
-0.557934582233429,
-0.3005692958831787,
0.31491613388061523,
-0.7460563778877258,
-0.1808590143918991,
-0.851168155670166,
-0.3406246304512024,
-0.5982840061187744,
-0.03762215003371239,
-0.40022534132003784,
-0.5388404726982117,
-0.18588502705097198,
-0.15082353353500366,
-0.0973094254732132,
0.6829965114593506,
-0.09700511395931244,
-0.20210562646389008,
-0.6647814512252808,
0.2376558929681778,
0.3137829601764679,
0.33640530705451965,
-0.4759710729122162,
-0.11871424317359924,
-0.012099899351596832,
-0.6295488476753235,
0.21219436824321747,
-1.0469086170196533,
0.08528975397348404,
0.3114456534385681,
0.291217565536499,
0.32257750630378723,
0.26735708117485046,
0.1752774864435196,
-0.4159298241138458,
0.24331018328666687,
0.12268997728824615,
-0.7146117687225342,
0.44888395071029663,
-0.5767844915390015,
0.017059404402971268,
0.4632360637187958,
0.5394594073295593,
-0.5241105556488037,
-0.0002342060033697635,
-0.4824615716934204,
-0.9924231171607971,
0.5459216833114624,
0.4762912094593048,
-0.4317241609096527,
-0.2922399044036865,
0.6815133690834045,
-0.0711822435259819,
-0.0008001122623682022,
-0.4555314779281616,
-0.13294008374214172,
0.08357702940702438,
-0.22305044531822205,
0.5487549304962158,
-0.7747666835784912,
-0.13373051583766937,
0.06214910373091698,
0.639083981513977,
-0.07707098126411438,
0.3072649836540222,
0.581079363822937,
-0.26497700810432434,
-0.27944472432136536,
0.5956067442893982,
0.13249269127845764,
1.0241674184799194,
-0.7692655324935913,
0.09177196770906448,
-0.09887532889842987,
-0.3457687795162201,
-0.18626128137111664,
0.8915852308273315,
-0.4234432876110077,
0.3246116042137146,
0.6433302760124207,
0.09784511476755142,
0.1448059380054474,
-0.507870078086853,
0.6272273659706116,
-0.17938928306102753,
-0.21594300866127014,
-0.5181791186332703,
-0.3450995981693268,
0.16703180968761444,
0.18782642483711243,
0.40728384256362915,
0.013657492585480213,
0.11917061358690262,
-0.39897340536117554,
0.6392825245857239,
0.17698974907398224,
-0.5412824749946594,
-0.23798726499080658,
0.9183908700942993,
0.38832592964172363,
-0.09223033487796783,
0.7870432138442993,
-0.2581164836883545,
0.020335450768470764,
0.4825288951396942,
0.49010521173477173,
0.8358216881752014,
-0.26115068793296814,
0.29764264822006226,
0.6243113875389099,
0.3524491786956787,
0.24223779141902924,
0.06592772156000137,
-0.028489645570516586,
-0.48106905817985535,
-0.6724919080734253,
-0.8899106383323669,
-0.2683180272579193,
0.1067844107747078,
-0.8609083294868469,
0.29918721318244934,
-0.20414935052394867,
0.1585371494293213,
0.37297868728637695,
0.0008775661699473858,
-0.3426143527030945,
0.1838836371898651,
-0.0020991889759898186,
1.3005527257919312,
-0.4946550726890564,
1.1968315839767456,
0.6656474471092224,
-0.7833001613616943,
-0.5988613367080688,
-0.1501884162425995,
-0.257011741399765,
-0.38782405853271484,
0.6583772897720337,
0.13863801956176758,
-0.1688648909330368,
0.14699095487594604,
-0.21285007894039154,
-0.6770625710487366,
1.3158575296401978,
0.41165292263031006,
-0.8016819357872009,
-0.7268699407577515,
0.07750965654850006,
0.386009156703949,
-0.46404579281806946,
0.6018891334533691,
0.37357401847839355,
0.4848947823047638,
0.13475114107131958,
-0.7372720241546631,
0.23247434198856354,
-0.528366208076477,
-0.05651471018791199,
0.4546119272708893,
-0.4050847589969635,
0.7158373594284058,
-0.03809311240911484,
-0.5784122347831726,
-0.06433326750993729,
0.6340152025222778,
-0.35285815596580505,
0.296098917722702,
0.7455424666404724,
0.8731392025947571,
0.9179604053497314,
-0.11833525449037552,
1.2041056156158447,
-0.6983117461204529,
0.29989176988601685,
1.2086859941482544,
-0.4615103602409363,
0.6243156790733337,
0.2720288932323456,
0.013704609125852585,
0.5836523175239563,
0.5727968811988831,
0.02526925504207611,
0.44702133536338806,
-0.11645319312810898,
-0.6189345121383667,
-0.10817021131515503,
-0.6559973955154419,
-0.1860751360654831,
0.21240054070949554,
0.3339693248271942,
-0.5071422457695007,
-0.4549919664859772,
-0.36665135622024536,
0.37317323684692383,
0.30009353160858154,
0.19171927869319916,
0.6660136580467224,
0.20427480340003967,
-0.8573113083839417,
0.32024115324020386,
-0.004388432949781418,
0.05871599540114403,
-0.7927659153938293,
-0.3543376624584198,
-0.13607752323150635,
0.08734358847141266,
-0.10503875464200974,
-0.6093297004699707,
0.28475499153137207,
-0.0728079155087471,
-0.4836156666278839,
-0.27723532915115356,
1.1962753534317017,
-0.5140047669410706,
-0.10219955444335938,
0.9000198841094971,
0.5179458260536194,
0.019232142716646194,
-0.22596576809883118,
-0.4829730689525604,
-0.27007007598876953,
-0.18421484529972076,
-0.3143611550331116,
0.22047390043735504,
0.552871584892273,
0.02844661846756935,
0.3965007960796356,
0.6925469040870667,
-0.19245107471942902,
-0.2527712285518646,
0.10406714677810669,
1.1964709758758545,
-0.6284334063529968,
-0.11580836027860641,
-0.40830570459365845,
0.30702319741249084,
-0.6655077338218689,
-0.29894572496414185,
0.1992286592721939,
0.9187206029891968,
0.6589393615722656,
0.2565324306488037,
0.8435276746749878,
-0.4309922754764557,
0.6251740455627441,
-0.43305692076683044,
0.38271570205688477,
-0.3799401819705963,
0.2924475371837616,
-0.10460518300533295,
-1.0927361249923706,
0.11905070394277573,
0.19698603451251984,
-0.033632323145866394,
-0.32704535126686096,
1.489516258239746,
0.5041893124580383,
-0.17073088884353638,
0.0498180016875267,
0.2891348898410797,
0.2535317540168762,
0.2922438979148865,
0.6248652338981628,
0.4513476490974426,
-0.4096391797065735,
1.0113052129745483,
-0.21858607232570648,
-0.45075613260269165,
0.4175091087818146,
-0.8450217247009277,
-0.9969350695610046,
-0.6769919395446777,
-0.2883793115615845,
-0.5044516921043396,
0.463830828666687,
0.6432918906211853,
0.7511370182037354,
-0.5581751465797424,
0.02069644257426262,
-0.09062075614929199,
0.12017139792442322,
0.0066201346926391125,
-0.21138092875480652,
0.5829290151596069,
-0.5279720425605774,
-1.1309856176376343,
0.5369908809661865,
0.5849747657775879,
-0.35887110233306885,
0.3674164414405823,
0.15029233694076538,
-0.5595072507858276,
-0.11978539824485779,
0.4462994635105133,
0.38540348410606384,
-0.36974379420280457,
-0.33197787404060364,
0.11889973282814026,
-0.20062506198883057,
0.1506611406803131,
0.7721983790397644,
-0.5117287635803223,
0.5213033556938171,
0.5140209197998047,
0.6313163638114929,
0.916124701499939,
0.03493845462799072,
0.8219764828681946,
-0.615074872970581,
0.03219810500741005,
0.03807036951184273,
0.4084490239620209,
0.15787248313426971,
-0.40267375111579895,
1.1737509965896606,
0.5451687574386597,
-0.5158967971801758,
-0.40150949358940125,
0.2493317574262619,
-1.1676602363586426,
-0.5927829742431641,
0.9527830481529236,
-0.5816408395767212,
-0.4409203827381134,
-0.142074853181839,
0.05739453434944153,
0.5698109865188599,
-0.5344049334526062,
0.6504700779914856,
0.6215685606002808,
0.09090642631053925,
-0.2723024785518646,
-0.5514282584190369,
0.4536988437175751,
0.20028814673423767,
-0.9493284225463867,
-0.05998802185058594,
0.5196825265884399,
0.29804855585098267,
0.377458781003952,
0.477755069732666,
-0.10576359927654266,
0.052600376307964325,
0.19298197329044342,
0.3562886714935303,
-0.30786803364753723,
-0.4619349241256714,
0.18027152121067047,
0.5278561115264893,
-0.07363434880971909,
-0.06331944465637207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12753v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12753v1
|
AutoCrawler: A Progressive Understanding Web Agent for Web Crawler Generation
| 2024-04-19T09:59:44 | 2024-04-19T09:59:44 |
Wenhao Huang, Chenghao Peng, Zhixu Li, Jiaqing Liang, Yanghua Xiao, Liqian Wen, Zulong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Web automation is a significant technique that accomplishes complicated web
tasks by automating common web actions, enhancing operational efficiency, and
reducing the need for manual intervention. Traditional methods, such as
wrappers, suffer from limited adaptability and scalability when faced with a
new website. On the other hand, generative agents empowered by large language
models (LLMs) exhibit poor performance and reusability in open-world scenarios.
In this work, we introduce a crawler generation task for vertical information
web pages and the paradigm of combining LLMs with crawlers, which helps
crawlers handle diverse and changing web environments more efficiently. We
propose AutoCrawler, a two-stage framework that leverages the hierarchical
structure of HTML for progressive understanding. Through top-down and step-back
operations, AutoCrawler can learn from erroneous actions and continuously prune
HTML for better action generation. We conduct comprehensive experiments with
multiple LLMs and demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework. Resources of
this paper can be found at \url{https://github.com/EZ-hwh/AutoCrawler}
|
[
-0.2317933589220047,
-0.8341485261917114,
0.37187692523002625,
0.19928187131881714,
-0.0786491259932518,
0.3134760558605194,
-0.024258967489004135,
-0.4218044877052307,
-0.0772218406200409,
0.06443209201097488,
-0.6414721608161926,
-0.49912315607070923,
-0.4344378113746643,
-0.0751834511756897,
-0.7922114729881287,
0.8136862516403198,
-0.06383300572633743,
-0.32212916016578674,
-0.2815563976764679,
0.20211999118328094,
-0.20348705351352692,
-0.11526105552911758,
-0.8406053781509399,
-0.2518022954463959,
0.5364322662353516,
0.23648110032081604,
1.0330904722213745,
1.2048847675323486,
0.5398271679878235,
0.5735523700714111,
0.20197206735610962,
-0.08478929847478867,
-0.43875157833099365,
0.6666280031204224,
-0.6263124942779541,
-0.4888031780719757,
-0.5873970985412598,
-0.2814698815345764,
0.4877639710903168,
0.5831560492515564,
-0.4710387587547302,
0.16313783824443817,
0.11299160867929459,
0.6538493633270264,
-0.8469923734664917,
0.14943824708461761,
-0.6490799784660339,
0.2367558479309082,
-0.008540038950741291,
-0.1086486354470253,
-0.2301255613565445,
-0.3634324371814728,
0.1310555636882782,
-0.6890700459480286,
0.373176246881485,
-0.22353492677211761,
0.6537384390830994,
0.5305383801460266,
-0.44090545177459717,
-0.4690978229045868,
-0.7530699968338013,
0.6777474284172058,
-0.44579437375068665,
0.4945138692855835,
0.08509942889213562,
0.5262424349784851,
-0.2267407327890396,
-1.167817234992981,
-0.8311450481414795,
-0.023588716983795166,
0.19385862350463867,
0.28273308277130127,
-0.6640410423278809,
-0.24887238442897797,
-0.17303045094013214,
0.5021688938140869,
-0.8548632860183716,
0.3264180123806,
0.025668809190392494,
-0.16343528032302856,
0.40877044200897217,
0.466715931892395,
0.4089037775993347,
0.06686601787805557,
-0.3057916760444641,
-0.24351611733436584,
-0.16551771759986877,
0.09821604937314987,
0.3396359086036682,
0.0031226701103150845,
0.13093125820159912,
0.5195924639701843,
-0.17375928163528442,
0.7811604738235474,
0.3882007300853729,
-0.32367920875549316,
0.14904770255088806,
-0.21266555786132812,
-0.21767403185367584,
-0.4621712863445282,
0.46864908933639526,
0.43617933988571167,
0.24610500037670135,
-0.24015891551971436,
-0.28803667426109314,
0.2511630654335022,
0.8702576160430908,
-0.6793640851974487,
-0.2742196023464203,
0.42982184886932373,
-0.6270691752433777,
-0.47235316038131714,
0.02011418156325817,
-0.975886881351471,
-0.3152978718280792,
-0.10909365862607956,
0.1783524751663208,
-0.4982456862926483,
-0.22319729626178741,
-0.002209038706496358,
-0.43084609508514404,
0.6592147946357727,
0.44792455434799194,
-0.40695586800575256,
0.26546624302864075,
0.5157383680343628,
0.9053850769996643,
-0.2979050278663635,
-0.541511595249176,
-0.6393979787826538,
0.4614117443561554,
-0.21915219724178314,
0.8398422598838806,
-0.5456869602203369,
-0.2267095297574997,
0.36061879992485046,
-0.04880915954709053,
-0.0899205431342125,
-0.36489924788475037,
-0.1130736917257309,
-0.870622456073761,
0.16229993104934692,
0.5380836725234985,
-0.2650514841079712,
-0.3559507727622986,
0.5906689763069153,
-0.7664430737495422,
0.6954941749572754,
0.18189634382724762,
-0.5418047904968262,
0.29383954405784607,
-0.4988371729850769,
-0.8232734799385071,
0.3709001839160919,
0.08470746129751205,
-0.45379438996315,
-0.0636649876832962,
0.0019860570318996906,
0.0032847209367901087,
-0.03735603764653206,
-0.09311223030090332,
-0.0348392091691494,
-0.12495587021112442,
0.09852477163076401,
-0.13330072164535522,
0.46435970067977905,
0.1563871055841446,
-0.5920345187187195,
0.20334866642951965,
-0.7083192467689514,
0.029842359945178032,
0.5081527829170227,
-0.7500728368759155,
0.1317102164030075,
0.4690589904785156,
-0.010226291604340076,
0.23372958600521088,
0.499911904335022,
-0.19332236051559448,
0.23318904638290405,
-0.22769376635551453,
0.34067222476005554,
0.85527104139328,
0.0263796616345644,
0.4915986657142639,
-0.4583278298377991,
0.9040265083312988,
-0.15378065407276154,
0.2752392888069153,
-0.3008710741996765,
-0.10857556015253067,
-1.133791208267212,
-0.1462535411119461,
0.174367755651474,
0.5747334361076355,
-0.7406294345855713,
0.5938237309455872,
-0.23326422274112701,
-0.6107128858566284,
-0.0840686485171318,
0.19941642880439758,
0.4167143702507019,
0.23422391712665558,
0.43818578124046326,
-0.5517999529838562,
-0.5088677406311035,
-0.6342598795890808,
-0.4601212441921234,
-0.2019701451063156,
-0.1841316968202591,
0.03415693715214729,
0.44135624170303345,
-0.7476716041564941,
1.0864372253417969,
-0.4181004762649536,
-0.44782137870788574,
-0.4531421661376953,
0.2585754096508026,
-0.043157678097486496,
0.44461771845817566,
0.1994943767786026,
-1.0876929759979248,
-0.4474852383136749,
-0.1845753937959671,
-0.7674537897109985,
0.09316303580999374,
-0.19275324046611786,
-0.08274383097887039,
0.17814253270626068,
0.33022207021713257,
-0.6132003664970398,
0.466850608587265,
0.5075421333312988,
0.037901200354099274,
0.3809616267681122,
-0.22173385322093964,
-0.3227795958518982,
-0.8707481026649475,
-0.15456336736679077,
0.2493024319410324,
-0.48845770955085754,
-0.7313874363899231,
0.5469236969947815,
-0.04133034497499466,
-0.09794003516435623,
-0.26670730113983154,
0.10317881405353546,
-0.5945731997489929,
-0.05657435953617096,
-0.4449318051338196,
0.3017411530017853,
-0.060705725103616714,
0.37545931339263916,
-0.07946926355361938,
0.864594578742981,
0.5020254850387573,
-0.9138832688331604,
0.3012143671512604,
0.16714948415756226,
0.22470952570438385,
0.42010611295700073,
-0.5013073682785034,
0.36436694860458374,
-0.2009681761264801,
0.3892523944377899,
-0.9317712187767029,
-0.5646837949752808,
0.1332497000694275,
-0.5541055798530579,
0.21602928638458252,
-0.32375991344451904,
-0.5777360796928406,
-0.6957252025604248,
-0.6207247972488403,
0.08329465240240097,
0.6579822301864624,
-0.4863061308860779,
0.931522011756897,
0.6741116046905518,
-0.25547540187835693,
-0.3019830584526062,
-0.42976635694503784,
0.17044071853160858,
-0.04159253090620041,
-0.7315958142280579,
0.31701892614364624,
-0.15954461693763733,
-0.2886066138744354,
-0.07264112681150436,
-0.43180975317955017,
-0.373267263174057,
0.12059696763753891,
0.2201802283525467,
-0.026686368510127068,
-0.09582210332155228,
0.04982609301805496,
0.04831652343273163,
-0.08259524405002594,
0.0842764675617218,
-0.5679973363876343,
0.9463036060333252,
-0.25168755650520325,
-0.3546481728553772,
-0.611225962638855,
0.22863760590553284,
0.5912913084030151,
-0.38978010416030884,
0.41801711916923523,
0.500057578086853,
-0.2943401634693146,
-0.40167349576950073,
-0.28061652183532715,
0.26378944516181946,
-0.5945167541503906,
0.23052068054676056,
-0.37334007024765015,
-0.5270742177963257,
0.3571826219558716,
-0.39940598607063293,
0.06662821024656296,
0.5896199941635132,
0.7441492676734924,
-0.3579638600349426,
1.353623867034912,
0.9811140298843384,
-0.08393945544958115,
0.6301649808883667,
-0.44220295548439026,
0.005959010683000088,
-0.5251168012619019,
-0.3212229013442993,
-0.4417164623737335,
-0.3677334487438202,
-0.7685485482215881,
-0.3419431447982788,
0.3195335268974304,
0.20580659806728363,
-0.26248812675476074,
0.3762274384498596,
-0.5122828483581543,
0.2569188177585602,
0.47756844758987427,
0.07751529663801193,
0.31628572940826416,
0.04312129691243172,
0.09795431792736053,
0.45749613642692566,
-0.6187907457351685,
-0.7478137016296387,
0.5974027514457703,
0.3822427988052368,
0.8961181044578552,
0.25982949137687683,
0.5597445368766785,
0.46673545241355896,
-0.04403147101402283,
-0.9869068264961243,
0.6474779844284058,
0.07241861522197723,
-0.4401297867298126,
-0.4304945468902588,
-0.0949576199054718,
-1.1896531581878662,
0.4864374101161957,
0.2747005224227905,
-0.4312913119792938,
0.19932325184345245,
0.3444758653640747,
0.10097893327474594,
0.15028028190135956,
-0.16723094880580902,
0.549446165561676,
-0.09496602416038513,
-0.4109976887702942,
-0.45873865485191345,
-0.6294348239898682,
-0.07275303453207016,
-0.05670592188835144,
0.4513586461544037,
0.33595237135887146,
-0.5248497724533081,
0.3758050799369812,
-0.5597585439682007,
0.895279049873352,
-0.27495354413986206,
-0.27103590965270996,
0.29160675406455994,
0.6331259608268738,
0.7793858647346497,
-0.0541517548263073,
0.12633945047855377,
-0.017171157523989677,
-0.5849224925041199,
-0.3238067030906677,
-0.34971997141838074,
0.24370186030864716,
-0.5574975609779358,
-0.6132523417472839,
-0.5289092659950256,
-0.48321396112442017,
0.09688976407051086,
0.4834636449813843,
0.16313479840755463,
0.17460580170154572,
-0.15376797318458557,
0.18082205951213837,
0.4051346182823181,
0.09369539469480515,
0.7365675568580627,
0.7321815490722656,
-0.07229913026094437,
-0.16314846277236938,
0.7459946870803833,
-0.23734378814697266,
-0.05428450182080269,
0.2838146388530731,
-0.047464486211538315,
-0.09335445612668991,
-0.8075889348983765,
-0.5014554858207703,
-0.1691909283399582,
-0.7481068968772888,
-0.41744858026504517,
-0.745285153388977,
-0.15305431187152863,
-0.1457788348197937,
-0.41206592321395874,
-0.07982239872217178,
-0.13163605332374573,
-0.1784089058637619,
0.15890593826770782,
0.07445192337036133,
0.8718443512916565,
-0.23296387493610382,
0.46013110876083374,
-0.6805367469787598,
0.5934880971908569,
0.5238975882530212,
0.04828813672065735,
0.2588806748390198,
-0.1871246099472046,
-0.2793070673942566,
-0.054103389382362366,
-0.6521591544151306,
-0.8362889289855957,
0.5169194340705872,
0.28601783514022827,
0.5918152332305908,
0.4025405943393707,
-0.1923515498638153,
0.7394419312477112,
-0.5934284329414368,
0.7436872124671936,
0.09922073036432266,
-1.1731020212173462,
0.663632869720459,
-0.4755380153656006,
0.4796530604362488,
0.5072195529937744,
0.5327963829040527,
-0.380980908870697,
-0.7664695978164673,
-0.13945356011390686,
-1.2003755569458008,
0.4262121319770813,
0.2775823473930359,
0.08337175101041794,
-0.09350463002920151,
0.14140918850898743,
0.2465582937002182,
0.2941356599330902,
-0.7535079717636108,
0.06303896754980087,
-0.5272297263145447,
-0.19837044179439545,
0.1760425865650177,
0.03776322677731514,
0.12659887969493866,
-0.028924984857439995,
0.5092552900314331,
-0.400587260723114,
0.15787780284881592,
0.13028152287006378,
-0.988958477973938,
-0.5013172626495361,
0.20719730854034424,
-0.00698833866044879,
0.9969912171363831,
0.056863781064748764,
0.14416901767253876,
0.13576428592205048,
-0.7036347985267639,
0.2253834754228592,
0.05461275577545166,
-0.142732173204422,
-0.33597657084465027,
0.684645414352417,
0.12011400610208511,
-0.019733360037207603,
-0.659147322177887,
0.4319199025630951,
-0.0009668397251516581,
0.1380825787782669,
-0.6135627627372742,
0.37802037596702576,
-0.10786284506320953,
0.5629538297653198,
0.6659921407699585,
-0.08128727972507477,
0.4752269387245178,
-0.6363917589187622,
0.29097780585289,
0.2871668338775635,
-0.31751686334609985,
-0.2949161231517792,
0.5478870272636414,
0.1761496365070343,
-0.661226212978363,
0.7163437008857727,
-0.21481351554393768,
-0.7228480577468872,
0.5931097269058228,
0.7443500757217407,
0.9421676993370056,
-0.3214683532714844,
0.13311900198459625,
-0.059831634163856506,
0.23391775786876678,
0.2009221613407135,
0.30101269483566284,
-0.35864150524139404,
-0.45942965149879456,
-0.3041946589946747,
-0.7209406495094299,
-0.4697651267051697,
-0.18644170463085175,
-0.8706302046775818,
-0.2413415163755417,
-0.3722168803215027,
-0.08007947355508804,
0.02579852007329464,
-0.22643332183361053,
-0.7565423846244812,
0.32367706298828125,
-0.06351257860660553,
0.9596124887466431,
-0.19365087151527405,
0.6442011594772339,
0.9294887185096741,
-0.6849525570869446,
-0.1771257519721985,
0.791267991065979,
0.15438611805438995,
-0.7351328730583191,
0.5780602693557739,
0.28004923462867737,
-0.6499022245407104,
0.3066994249820709,
-0.4511440098285675,
-0.7324084043502808,
1.306418776512146,
-0.17622974514961243,
-0.8194454312324524,
-0.35518354177474976,
0.05582993105053902,
0.6180282235145569,
-0.2710632383823395,
0.06421831250190735,
0.23265959322452545,
0.5322893261909485,
-0.13022595643997192,
-0.6613571047782898,
0.14128896594047546,
-0.2779143452644348,
0.31962674856185913,
0.16352081298828125,
-0.6492096185684204,
0.9993202090263367,
-0.12315412610769272,
-0.48704859614372253,
0.3638361096382141,
0.5272677540779114,
0.08379995077848434,
0.2681790888309479,
0.9780158996582031,
0.5754840970039368,
0.5483001470565796,
0.3182981610298157,
0.9549561738967896,
-0.27960190176963806,
0.3781275451183319,
0.871152400970459,
-0.365890771150589,
0.7641147971153259,
0.037891633808612823,
-0.2061682641506195,
1.1522053480148315,
0.433586448431015,
-0.1345568746328354,
0.5835580229759216,
0.17981617152690887,
-0.08284439891576767,
-0.3666703701019287,
0.18806135654449463,
-0.15903402864933014,
0.7960430383682251,
0.09540457278490067,
-0.24630863964557648,
-0.5839781761169434,
0.0003307186416350305,
-0.012413007207214832,
0.1281169205904007,
-0.3725721836090088,
1.1642379760742188,
-0.27800452709198,
-0.4155491292476654,
0.335015207529068,
0.11689738184213638,
0.47526100277900696,
-0.474880188703537,
-0.09578665345907211,
-0.1274174153804779,
0.4003603160381317,
-0.20782262086868286,
-0.816986620426178,
0.23856791853904724,
0.2901066243648529,
-0.36729153990745544,
-0.28538596630096436,
0.9218646883964539,
0.05932094529271126,
-0.15290910005569458,
0.5192701816558838,
0.6278815269470215,
0.0003004352911375463,
-0.10697199404239655,
-0.6741759777069092,
0.09049893915653229,
-0.19901826977729797,
-0.5124082565307617,
0.3260895907878876,
0.28090983629226685,
0.03548886254429817,
0.8601576685905457,
0.8067395687103271,
-0.2644127309322357,
0.025223685428500175,
-0.11764192581176758,
1.2845737934112549,
-0.8603296875953674,
-0.5992603302001953,
-0.9584750533103943,
0.7433913350105286,
-0.09383553266525269,
0.12046650052070618,
0.8265056014060974,
0.8368602395057678,
0.8725376725196838,
0.1483100801706314,
0.9520348310470581,
-0.17407791316509247,
0.30028730630874634,
-0.2238713502883911,
0.7218341827392578,
-0.5706691741943359,
-0.2978280186653137,
0.06281872093677521,
-1.0936553478240967,
-0.1472771316766739,
0.6995601654052734,
0.1801024228334427,
-0.04253608360886574,
0.5616334080696106,
0.38208597898483276,
-0.07749499380588531,
-0.252599835395813,
-0.00928391981869936,
0.3576039969921112,
0.3672062158584595,
0.2645597755908966,
0.9902730584144592,
-0.1380017101764679,
0.9398409128189087,
-0.0666094720363617,
-0.38460081815719604,
-0.21081465482711792,
-0.6821880340576172,
-0.8332703709602356,
-0.44862329959869385,
-0.06952191889286041,
-0.3093915283679962,
0.3123756945133209,
0.44103679060935974,
0.8196600675582886,
-0.46637117862701416,
-0.38437822461128235,
-0.5847733616828918,
0.06976576149463654,
-0.1942720264196396,
-0.2710278034210205,
-0.09069652110338211,
-0.8035315871238708,
-0.7035625576972961,
0.63062983751297,
0.38665491342544556,
-0.07656065374612808,
-0.42450377345085144,
0.04081103578209877,
-0.14905187487602234,
0.1948271095752716,
0.6055560111999512,
0.20510435104370117,
-0.5136637091636658,
-0.029187966138124466,
-0.18349429965019226,
0.035530004650354385,
0.27395352721214294,
0.8619004487991333,
-1.031213402748108,
0.38010966777801514,
0.45855021476745605,
0.3787030279636383,
0.7349575757980347,
0.0746723935008049,
0.6710953116416931,
-0.41685712337493896,
-0.16354858875274658,
0.33981436491012573,
0.23971869051456451,
0.1455007791519165,
-0.3369864225387573,
0.4575090706348419,
-0.03761409968137741,
-0.43450304865837097,
-0.712090253829956,
0.6075194478034973,
-0.6397063732147217,
-0.6291501522064209,
0.8439852595329285,
-0.05984380468726158,
-0.2840649485588074,
-0.17193125188350677,
0.2222728580236435,
0.5601694583892822,
-0.4095969498157501,
0.6816763281822205,
0.135092094540596,
-0.11782943457365036,
-0.05049024149775505,
-0.15655693411827087,
0.14045687019824982,
-0.20119363069534302,
-0.9236201643943787,
-0.20192307233810425,
0.49985939264297485,
0.3548506498336792,
0.4345019459724426,
0.27208101749420166,
0.12968100607395172,
0.44007235765457153,
0.12830688059329987,
0.2783600687980652,
-0.051562435925006866,
-0.559714674949646,
-0.4862058162689209,
0.4754963219165802,
-0.09630740433931351,
-0.33231422305107117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12744v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12744v2
|
Beyond Human Norms: Unveiling Unique Values of Large Language Models through Interdisciplinary Approaches
| 2024-04-19T09:44:51 | 2024-05-10T06:09:02 |
Pablo Biedma, Xiaoyuan Yi, Linus Huang, Maosong Sun, Xing Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized the
AI field but also pose potential safety and ethical risks. Deciphering LLMs'
embedded values becomes crucial for assessing and mitigating their risks.
Despite extensive investigation into LLMs' values, previous studies heavily
rely on human-oriented value systems in social sciences. Then, a natural
question arises: Do LLMs possess unique values beyond those of humans? Delving
into it, this work proposes a novel framework, ValueLex, to reconstruct LLMs'
unique value system from scratch, leveraging psychological methodologies from
human personality/value research. Based on Lexical Hypothesis, ValueLex
introduces a generative approach to elicit diverse values from 30+ LLMs,
synthesizing a taxonomy that culminates in a comprehensive value framework via
factor analysis and semantic clustering. We identify three core value
dimensions, Competence, Character, and Integrity, each with specific
subdimensions, revealing that LLMs possess a structured, albeit non-human,
value system. Based on this system, we further develop tailored projective
tests to evaluate and analyze the value inclinations of LLMs across different
model sizes, training methods, and data sources. Our framework fosters an
interdisciplinary paradigm of understanding LLMs, paving the way for future AI
alignment and regulation.
|
[
-0.2861958146095276,
-0.6724686622619629,
0.5915377140045166,
-0.08561766892671585,
0.16793867945671082,
0.40029799938201904,
-0.2766087055206299,
-0.6411792635917664,
0.1652929037809372,
0.5167909860610962,
-0.4717365801334381,
-0.3268621563911438,
-0.6177395582199097,
-0.09664840251207352,
-0.2535296082496643,
0.9698591828346252,
0.44126924872398376,
-0.05792292207479477,
-0.33043229579925537,
-0.2899544835090637,
-0.00864570215344429,
-0.7964451313018799,
-0.2371947318315506,
-0.490561306476593,
0.4884410798549652,
0.37665289640426636,
0.7470897436141968,
0.6016872525215149,
0.2714426815509796,
0.1921638548374176,
-0.26537516713142395,
0.018153874203562737,
-0.5211819410324097,
-0.33471378684043884,
-0.21450752019882202,
-0.30805984139442444,
-0.7456647753715515,
0.4010734558105469,
0.7797067165374756,
1.017446756362915,
0.0532584972679615,
0.1910610944032669,
0.11318974941968918,
0.6881230473518372,
-0.5015150308609009,
0.15339727699756622,
-0.5908446907997131,
-0.13562381267547607,
-0.17805424332618713,
0.07788190245628357,
-0.15555505454540253,
-0.6683999300003052,
-0.08928345143795013,
-0.2440679520368576,
-0.17663951218128204,
-0.24708044528961182,
1.0950026512145996,
0.23969058692455292,
-0.6371882557868958,
0.04192286357283592,
-0.6599095463752747,
1.0073189735412598,
-0.5975039005279541,
0.364047646522522,
0.10992810875177383,
0.003642244962975383,
-0.10572121292352676,
-0.17023196816444397,
-0.6606669425964355,
-0.2748647630214691,
0.06836781650781631,
-0.1854815036058426,
-0.05879027396440506,
-0.07380131632089615,
-0.07976564019918442,
0.4869585633277893,
-0.17223311960697174,
0.5174561738967896,
-0.2522958815097809,
0.010642992332577705,
1.0626314878463745,
0.49289366602897644,
0.29746145009994507,
0.18054956197738647,
-0.17811283469200134,
-0.2807501256465912,
-0.9434563517570496,
0.5922145247459412,
0.497418075799942,
0.2796076238155365,
-0.04631003364920616,
0.4764308035373688,
0.03121322952210903,
0.35407137870788574,
-0.04470577463507652,
-0.44187894463539124,
0.49207165837287903,
-0.15972352027893066,
0.023300107568502426,
-0.03253836929798126,
0.7561200857162476,
0.344836562871933,
0.6868259310722351,
-0.1056014820933342,
-0.1398656666278839,
-0.05887436121702194,
0.23515303432941437,
-0.5418885946273804,
0.13134151697158813,
0.2479589879512787,
-0.629365086555481,
-0.6554189324378967,
-0.18141397833824158,
-0.5352241396903992,
-0.5822896361351013,
-0.6177757382392883,
0.1087542250752449,
-0.48923346400260925,
-0.6545783877372742,
-0.06278714537620544,
0.048044171184301376,
0.4278399646282196,
0.3256223797798157,
-0.9967771768569946,
0.4356498718261719,
0.8491740226745605,
0.5728045105934143,
-0.40643346309661865,
-0.43379080295562744,
-0.2682720124721527,
-0.16740259528160095,
-0.432708740234375,
0.713707685470581,
-0.7954303622245789,
-0.6142795085906982,
-0.22564513981342316,
-0.19510459899902344,
0.4450450837612152,
-0.5770618319511414,
0.2984529137611389,
-0.655522882938385,
-0.4154784083366394,
-0.32424652576446533,
-0.616416335105896,
-0.02006451226770878,
0.43414753675460815,
-0.5276435017585754,
0.9682199358940125,
0.2115248590707779,
-0.42075836658477783,
0.6345587968826294,
-0.7532119750976562,
-0.3232453763484955,
0.3654421865940094,
-0.4476674497127533,
-0.09104197472333908,
0.18394823372364044,
-0.20531417429447174,
0.48211854696273804,
-0.5567350387573242,
0.3813443183898926,
-0.503331184387207,
0.046329353004693985,
0.419267863035202,
-0.45320338010787964,
0.901878833770752,
0.01316617988049984,
-0.13307088613510132,
0.350816935300827,
-0.882192075252533,
0.3181212246417999,
0.09077052772045135,
-0.2981708347797394,
-0.4067918062210083,
0.02936474233865738,
0.2035330832004547,
0.39554810523986816,
0.41896191239356995,
-0.6707656979560852,
0.15522707998752594,
-0.342018723487854,
0.3479219675064087,
1.1298789978027344,
-0.3854532837867737,
0.6883952617645264,
-0.3302399516105652,
0.3738984167575836,
-0.22063982486724854,
0.06774774193763733,
0.1944630891084671,
-0.3441193401813507,
-0.43495339155197144,
-0.5968645215034485,
-0.24133749306201935,
0.6051093935966492,
0.23876766860485077,
0.7481368184089661,
-0.42640435695648193,
-0.6402115225791931,
-0.6086006760597229,
0.17968831956386566,
0.04628792032599449,
0.3341645300388336,
0.16690821945667267,
-0.06494241952896118,
-0.19172759354114532,
-1.1652686595916748,
-0.32280710339546204,
-0.3476155400276184,
-0.26255345344543457,
0.46362367272377014,
0.5045472383499146,
-0.4027107357978821,
1.1924433708190918,
-0.505118727684021,
-0.04872730001807213,
-0.21965795755386353,
-0.04602818191051483,
0.3353581428527832,
0.23909766972064972,
0.2493426501750946,
-0.6793754696846008,
-0.12147338688373566,
0.13139711320400238,
-0.7950625419616699,
-0.1865120232105255,
-0.011072792112827301,
0.2408723533153534,
0.07108622044324875,
0.4744427502155304,
-0.18162763118743896,
0.34030911326408386,
0.41013649106025696,
-0.5108826160430908,
0.6455106139183044,
-0.11511889845132828,
0.055576324462890625,
-0.9877901077270508,
0.2905293107032776,
-0.04776667058467865,
-0.014911020174622536,
-0.37823086977005005,
0.09421966224908829,
0.013515080325305462,
0.21384428441524506,
-0.24490202963352203,
0.9057984948158264,
-0.22521786391735077,
0.015338694676756859,
-0.4317970275878906,
-0.13519775867462158,
-0.09409862011671066,
0.11570868641138077,
0.17577771842479706,
0.645821213722229,
0.26309365034103394,
-0.5436195135116577,
0.4495254158973694,
0.22841551899909973,
-0.19078809022903442,
1.0019575357437134,
-0.6456649899482727,
-0.05450669676065445,
-0.2844384014606476,
-0.06072508171200752,
-0.5955645442008972,
0.020992249250411987,
-0.24253912270069122,
-0.37963977456092834,
0.032295167446136475,
-0.09000062942504883,
-0.3887421190738678,
0.14282213151454926,
-0.21428440511226654,
0.4440385699272156,
0.6575676202774048,
-0.2320915013551712,
0.5174048542976379,
1.0061688423156738,
-0.4392785429954529,
-0.5226508975028992,
-0.363161563873291,
0.42586973309516907,
-0.32556989789009094,
-0.6831957101821899,
0.3201580047607422,
-0.2395218312740326,
-0.8894872069358826,
-0.10301286727190018,
0.32894065976142883,
-0.20593920350074768,
0.2900434136390686,
0.40378591418266296,
0.33210837841033936,
-0.01419020351022482,
0.20813794434070587,
0.04772784933447838,
-0.2246263027191162,
0.2608453333377838,
-0.40823835134506226,
0.34912338852882385,
-0.7360360622406006,
-0.2776487171649933,
-0.150250643491745,
0.459726482629776,
0.8390359282493591,
-0.3671857714653015,
0.7995754480361938,
0.5506131649017334,
-0.48433375358581543,
-0.060741689056158066,
-0.607902467250824,
-0.3077452480792999,
-0.4285390079021454,
0.4732236862182617,
-0.3127516508102417,
-1.2333439588546753,
0.5289118885993958,
-0.012201406061649323,
0.014634496532380581,
0.3557891547679901,
0.8527259826660156,
0.010442322120070457,
0.6576182842254639,
0.9747551679611206,
-0.1843254119157791,
0.10713512450456619,
-0.07501471042633057,
0.3571166396141052,
-0.8577897548675537,
-0.5226381421089172,
-0.2781010568141937,
-0.1911536306142807,
-0.5075445175170898,
-0.21471723914146423,
0.7551364302635193,
-0.04553986340761185,
-0.487109899520874,
-0.09963218122720718,
-0.3013157248497009,
0.5122861862182617,
0.39763742685317993,
-0.0887894481420517,
0.33120760321617126,
-0.28760239481925964,
0.0597200021147728,
-0.06642983108758926,
-0.34593626856803894,
-1.0105512142181396,
1.1764018535614014,
0.493728905916214,
0.867485761642456,
0.0852375477552414,
0.5067440867424011,
0.2103119045495987,
0.46231505274772644,
-1.0465439558029175,
0.4697124660015106,
0.14793451130390167,
-0.6731521487236023,
-0.6773266792297363,
-0.31638103723526,
-0.856657862663269,
0.07520267367362976,
-0.23748484253883362,
-1.069258689880371,
0.0936480164527893,
-0.03746766597032547,
-0.6471635699272156,
0.5415612459182739,
-0.25462010502815247,
0.6867815256118774,
-0.416083425283432,
-0.4286380410194397,
-0.3981783390045166,
-0.7212316989898682,
0.48327404260635376,
-0.20705989003181458,
0.411786288022995,
-0.4375375509262085,
-0.15404298901557922,
0.49233806133270264,
-0.2425205558538437,
0.9113624691963196,
0.4560181498527527,
-0.5376748442649841,
0.05593716725707054,
0.30244722962379456,
0.1223355084657669,
0.29016056656837463,
-0.14650844037532806,
0.3959035575389862,
0.3325139582157135,
-0.4964809715747833,
-0.2439095377922058,
0.9266932606697083,
-1.0742050409317017,
-0.5217410922050476,
-0.41598913073539734,
-0.8534529805183411,
-0.17806006968021393,
0.27106454968452454,
-0.16147851943969727,
0.22440391778945923,
-0.6774568557739258,
-0.02453838847577572,
0.8366072177886963,
-0.39657530188560486,
0.3934921622276306,
0.34474101662635803,
0.10216823220252991,
-0.1098300889134407,
0.7355096936225891,
-0.08540958911180496,
0.3349045217037201,
0.38623103499412537,
0.39081552624702454,
-0.41727739572525024,
-0.2482091337442398,
-0.16979993879795074,
0.1880953013896942,
-0.6722604632377625,
0.16371475160121918,
-0.7456204891204834,
-0.18196465075016022,
-0.4744061827659607,
-0.5349608659744263,
-0.6826373934745789,
-0.09520166367292404,
-0.29468780755996704,
-0.10034164786338806,
0.46054309606552124,
1.0092856884002686,
-0.3250502347946167,
-0.21144022047519684,
-1.222458004951477,
0.019883977249264717,
0.41079995036125183,
0.44640854001045227,
0.005849290639162064,
-0.4084680676460266,
0.016287777572870255,
0.13327716290950775,
0.009279907681047916,
-0.6307864189147949,
0.5868847966194153,
-0.07965264469385147,
0.6731981635093689,
0.4677269160747528,
-0.016162438318133354,
0.28193944692611694,
-0.6074109673500061,
0.752061665058136,
-0.017517585307359695,
-1.1829168796539307,
0.22286134958267212,
-0.34422898292541504,
-0.051366087049245834,
0.4967116117477417,
0.3125716745853424,
-0.7889584302902222,
0.1546623557806015,
-0.6832017302513123,
-0.9186065196990967,
0.390990674495697,
0.05451694130897522,
0.32310977578163147,
0.07117164880037308,
0.5550830364227295,
0.16880767047405243,
0.03683125227689743,
-0.6234402060508728,
-0.061778850853443146,
-0.03476715087890625,
-0.29725441336631775,
-0.2349451333284378,
-0.19246906042099,
-0.3883606493473053,
-0.3133423328399658,
0.33725082874298096,
-0.22546067833900452,
-0.05241871997714043,
-0.030518434941768646,
-0.013160177506506443,
0.011376352980732918,
0.5912123918533325,
0.488240510225296,
0.7903455495834351,
-0.17900313436985016,
0.259944349527359,
0.3656202256679535,
-0.17987088859081268,
0.5381783843040466,
-0.21346215903759003,
0.35725829005241394,
-0.6867835521697998,
0.42113715410232544,
0.2699756622314453,
-0.22576236724853516,
-0.9714561700820923,
0.5865303874015808,
0.2575368583202362,
0.12060084193944931,
-0.6479709148406982,
-0.08205904811620712,
0.18246540427207947,
0.21229824423789978,
0.263674795627594,
-0.11312228441238403,
-0.03170650079846382,
-0.7429682612419128,
0.30704984068870544,
0.49563416838645935,
-0.5240182876586914,
-0.5918745398521423,
0.4938869774341583,
0.2795764207839966,
-0.2933739721775055,
0.5515730977058411,
-0.21283729374408722,
-0.35611602663993835,
0.7194281816482544,
0.19644127786159515,
0.8445941209793091,
-0.026410112157464027,
0.10930687189102173,
0.020648349076509476,
0.49566054344177246,
0.1096954420208931,
0.17076987028121948,
0.22448241710662842,
-1.2085286378860474,
-0.38257062435150146,
-0.6101575493812561,
-0.32275083661079407,
0.11777561157941818,
-0.5615407228469849,
0.08381085842847824,
-0.5283471345901489,
0.1468152105808258,
-0.034311387687921524,
-0.11059590429067612,
-0.5411505103111267,
0.22099445760250092,
0.3351033627986908,
0.6509180068969727,
-0.9366787672042847,
0.7923203706741333,
0.6296619772911072,
-0.23833489418029785,
-0.6252040863037109,
-0.1602610945701599,
0.4049835801124573,
-0.968729555606842,
1.1354098320007324,
-0.06889475882053375,
-0.4337101876735687,
0.01882218010723591,
-0.5289121866226196,
-0.7922057509422302,
1.0258903503417969,
0.29364123940467834,
-0.2657868564128876,
-0.02232205681502819,
0.39586639404296875,
0.48230937123298645,
-0.5096084475517273,
0.3187960386276245,
0.8037509918212891,
0.4447225034236908,
-0.06515663862228394,
-1.1111150979995728,
0.06387241929769516,
-0.4078957736492157,
-0.011192209087312222,
0.12405122071504593,
-0.6986186504364014,
0.8989483118057251,
-0.3502885699272156,
0.10792865604162216,
-0.14404812455177307,
0.2422793209552765,
0.2471303939819336,
-0.06334876269102097,
0.33612489700317383,
0.5777468681335449,
0.8059355020523071,
0.2875588834285736,
0.914245069026947,
-0.28644993901252747,
0.1900353580713272,
0.6891017556190491,
-0.4980631470680237,
0.5951685309410095,
0.48891451954841614,
-0.24521802365779877,
0.4317364990711212,
0.5240459442138672,
0.22006390988826752,
-0.004471006337553263,
0.33049243688583374,
-0.27922648191452026,
-0.6671491265296936,
-0.4187610447406769,
-0.15128786861896515,
0.6372634172439575,
0.45525261759757996,
-0.18831530213356018,
-0.10168459266424179,
-0.19043295085430145,
0.3284921944141388,
0.3437914550304413,
-0.25956133008003235,
0.705631673336029,
0.170606791973114,
-0.33417996764183044,
0.5000044107437134,
-0.07349862903356552,
0.6630836129188538,
-0.5302274227142334,
0.04146549105644226,
-0.17362037301063538,
0.38396117091178894,
-0.10959747433662415,
-1.1257811784744263,
0.2777656316757202,
-0.13012905418872833,
-0.20212280750274658,
-0.5143406987190247,
0.33934637904167175,
-0.11795191466808319,
-0.5600314736366272,
0.23740394413471222,
0.6737025380134583,
0.00013547575508709997,
-0.11145460605621338,
-0.4485650062561035,
-0.05757463350892067,
-0.3320355713367462,
0.09606319665908813,
0.4209878146648407,
0.4929150938987732,
-0.20178766548633575,
0.8295468091964722,
0.5754847526550293,
0.08991483598947525,
-0.3511750102043152,
-0.18174193799495697,
0.9476504325866699,
-0.8112194538116455,
-0.494451105594635,
-1.1743032932281494,
0.5403931140899658,
-0.14662794768810272,
-0.5673173666000366,
0.5154286623001099,
0.40391096472740173,
0.8564099073410034,
0.2052791267633438,
0.9982612133026123,
0.04406920075416565,
0.2773168683052063,
-0.2763381898403168,
0.9255288243293762,
-0.5653291940689087,
0.3039785623550415,
-0.517448902130127,
-0.5296554565429688,
-0.4116062819957733,
0.4533045291900635,
-0.2517929673194885,
-0.07798409461975098,
0.328315407037735,
0.7569087743759155,
0.2007564753293991,
-0.26278379559516907,
0.5279771685600281,
0.0022685378789901733,
0.6812350749969482,
0.5789148211479187,
1.0844407081604004,
0.07553694397211075,
0.21626625955104828,
0.10235720872879028,
-0.6467422246932983,
-0.12625116109848022,
-0.8436509370803833,
-1.0451911687850952,
-0.6187400221824646,
-0.1587635725736618,
-0.34627798199653625,
-0.21298696100711823,
1.3540738821029663,
0.7541875243186951,
-0.6528428792953491,
-0.5687773823738098,
0.14363643527030945,
0.14802804589271545,
-0.05197801813483238,
-0.24939866364002228,
0.20253172516822815,
-0.16415449976921082,
-0.6088710427284241,
0.2529679536819458,
0.6117432713508606,
0.07938620448112488,
-0.43613123893737793,
-0.15478792786598206,
0.0012378385290503502,
0.3573623299598694,
0.7357396483421326,
0.25287172198295593,
-0.687204897403717,
-0.47057780623435974,
0.2065751701593399,
-0.18657541275024414,
0.13600866496562958,
0.8280999660491943,
-0.6307092905044556,
0.13059966266155243,
0.3498137295246124,
0.7726580500602722,
-0.17436160147190094,
-0.3411400020122528,
0.6292999982833862,
-0.30315443873405457,
0.13324129581451416,
0.6414552330970764,
0.2841024696826935,
0.20015235245227814,
-0.5006113052368164,
0.1772264689207077,
0.3175770938396454,
-0.5043772459030151,
-0.6770946979522705,
0.7066682577133179,
-0.8304059505462646,
-0.42942723631858826,
1.3604177236557007,
-0.05173114314675331,
-0.003635034430772066,
-0.1409033238887787,
-0.058285750448703766,
-0.04187953472137451,
-0.3649846613407135,
1.015799880027771,
0.5308012366294861,
-0.22732751071453094,
-0.2605469524860382,
-0.07330168038606644,
0.4112447500228882,
0.22482119500637054,
-1.0163120031356812,
0.08341759443283081,
0.5087512731552124,
0.48570090532302856,
0.15634746849536896,
0.3978976905345917,
-0.41910266876220703,
-0.07748645544052124,
-0.16602537035942078,
0.4556986391544342,
-0.06757769733667374,
-0.09895094484090805,
-0.368610143661499,
0.24312493205070496,
0.3842644691467285,
0.2544213533401489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12728v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12728v2
|
Relevant or Random: Can LLMs Truly Perform Analogical Reasoning?
| 2024-04-19T09:15:07 | 2024-06-23T05:18:50 |
Chengwei Qin, Wenhan Xia, Tan Wang, Fangkai Jiao, Yuchen Hu, Bosheng Ding, Ruirui Chen, Shafiq Joty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Analogical reasoning is a unique ability of humans to address unfamiliar
challenges by transferring strategies from relevant past experiences. One key
finding in psychology is that compared with irrelevant past experiences,
recalling relevant ones can help humans better handle new tasks.
Coincidentally, the NLP community has also recently found that self-generating
relevant examples in the context can help large language models (LLMs) better
solve a given problem than hand-crafted prompts. However, it is yet not clear
whether relevance is the key factor eliciting such capability, i.e., can LLMs
benefit more from self-generated relevant examples than irrelevant ones? In
this work, we systematically explore whether LLMs can truly perform analogical
reasoning on a diverse set of reasoning tasks. With extensive experiments and
analysis, we show that self-generated random examples can surprisingly achieve
comparable or even better performance, e.g., 4% performance boost on GSM8K with
random biological examples. We find that the accuracy of self-generated
examples is the key factor and subsequently design two improved methods with
significantly reduced inference costs. Overall, we aim to advance a deeper
understanding of LLM analogical reasoning and hope this work stimulates further
research in the design of self-generated contexts.
|
[
-0.15332503616809845,
-0.6948546171188354,
1.0427849292755127,
-0.12129652500152588,
-0.27228471636772156,
-0.25163522362709045,
-0.06292906403541565,
-0.535754382610321,
0.20922929048538208,
0.34208452701568604,
-0.7089108824729919,
-0.2786705791950226,
-0.09911635518074036,
0.2221982628107071,
-0.3556098937988281,
0.7793431878089905,
0.27438315749168396,
0.05664817988872528,
-0.3654552102088928,
-0.26103779673576355,
-0.4625542461872101,
-0.7890552878379822,
-0.6917958855628967,
-0.6360544562339783,
0.5304685831069946,
0.14278466999530792,
0.39207887649536133,
0.7634031176567078,
0.42787694931030273,
0.3202113211154938,
0.02190053090453148,
0.043621838092803955,
-0.454170286655426,
0.37080061435699463,
-0.6105815172195435,
-0.7786951661109924,
-0.02762819081544876,
0.09354787319898605,
0.367257684469223,
0.5921266674995422,
-0.21812309324741364,
0.3468768894672394,
-0.017658259719610214,
0.5628326535224915,
-0.32950541377067566,
-0.169664204120636,
-1.1395469903945923,
0.06404048949480057,
0.00046520205796696246,
-0.543574869632721,
-0.22820590436458588,
-0.29371124505996704,
-0.17212145030498505,
-0.7109099626541138,
0.27906671166419983,
0.0917997881770134,
0.45327192544937134,
0.21468673646450043,
-0.18002265691757202,
-0.5467016696929932,
-0.8317807912826538,
0.7506033778190613,
-1.0502264499664307,
-0.045483577996492386,
-0.010919744148850441,
0.38133668899536133,
-0.4827522039413452,
-0.927672266960144,
-0.7248449921607971,
-0.1828785389661789,
0.10964667052030563,
0.01960429921746254,
-0.04111164063215256,
-0.20742283761501312,
0.5886002779006958,
0.42301830649375916,
-0.26386114954948425,
0.14806412160396576,
-0.36796584725379944,
-0.06219977140426636,
0.2925698459148407,
0.36385270953178406,
0.22655920684337616,
-0.15656785666942596,
-0.1463131308555603,
-0.054833609610795975,
-0.9887702465057373,
0.061822131276130676,
0.47482284903526306,
0.04059483855962753,
0.05740606412291527,
0.4002830684185028,
-0.19793321192264557,
0.8687388300895691,
0.09351351112127304,
-0.27113276720046997,
0.169064000248909,
-0.19871178269386292,
0.21032069623470306,
-0.07869617640972137,
0.5881219506263733,
0.45767223834991455,
0.4783591330051422,
-0.2422219216823578,
-0.15775223076343536,
-0.09790527820587158,
0.3888927102088928,
-0.478096067905426,
-0.2047179788351059,
0.18932141363620758,
-0.7742261290550232,
-0.24087326228618622,
-0.20276430249214172,
-0.3932318389415741,
-0.15275980532169342,
-0.43776291608810425,
0.46006929874420166,
-0.32958272099494934,
-0.12731266021728516,
0.02877960354089737,
-0.39461246132850647,
0.14385420083999634,
0.42738887667655945,
-0.891938328742981,
0.05013767629861832,
0.6950835585594177,
0.5029585361480713,
-0.28863823413848877,
-0.4969104528427124,
-0.21728232502937317,
0.10124528408050537,
-0.2736484408378601,
0.9780407547950745,
-0.43325376510620117,
-0.18998022377490997,
-0.17342416942119598,
-0.39560309052467346,
0.14116033911705017,
-0.9301285147666931,
0.3624582886695862,
-0.4620361328125,
0.1008322462439537,
-0.5498661398887634,
-0.5612311363220215,
-0.09758251160383224,
0.12146389484405518,
-0.4072466492652893,
0.7866829633712769,
-0.061911266297101974,
-0.4516785144805908,
0.49405935406684875,
-0.2572540044784546,
-0.3301185369491577,
0.046706169843673706,
-0.6198832988739014,
-0.025174524635076523,
0.2866464853286743,
-0.044124677777290344,
0.47635364532470703,
-0.4031936526298523,
0.21549387276172638,
-0.7946590781211853,
-0.4108925759792328,
0.602631688117981,
-0.3775332272052765,
0.5342452526092529,
0.477122962474823,
-0.3264457583427429,
-0.19646784663200378,
-0.7003025412559509,
0.297396183013916,
0.300943523645401,
0.05160267651081085,
-0.42979511618614197,
0.02863321080803871,
-0.44498586654663086,
0.594932496547699,
0.17361102998256683,
-0.4057568609714508,
0.11655456572771072,
-0.3181818425655365,
0.625935971736908,
0.6943998336791992,
0.18278303742408752,
0.3107195794582367,
-0.7535876035690308,
0.36167895793914795,
-0.0037534579169005156,
-0.30910539627075195,
-0.4456285536289215,
-0.6559563279151917,
-0.34235879778862,
-0.317160964012146,
0.13227565586566925,
0.34403491020202637,
-0.6072236895561218,
0.21864373981952667,
-0.15978921949863434,
-0.25477078557014465,
-0.5718942284584045,
0.16840726137161255,
0.16801655292510986,
0.8526058197021484,
0.2829075753688812,
-0.13422176241874695,
-0.4711002707481384,
-0.9661546945571899,
-0.5682966709136963,
-0.28957340121269226,
-0.2756665050983429,
0.5144705176353455,
0.25303414463996887,
0.10830728709697723,
1.0335558652877808,
-0.23268423974514008,
-0.11552868038415909,
-0.14192934334278107,
0.12680748105049133,
0.4716430604457855,
0.20687592029571533,
0.8647233247756958,
-0.46427834033966064,
-0.03076205402612686,
-0.14614054560661316,
-1.284058690071106,
-0.43484291434288025,
-0.5705399513244629,
0.19532376527786255,
-0.29321444034576416,
0.8661521077156067,
-0.5450429916381836,
0.14056967198848724,
0.2916645109653473,
-0.0014245730126276612,
0.45138832926750183,
-0.6287578344345093,
0.17611843347549438,
-1.013480305671692,
-0.06587789207696915,
-0.14260977506637573,
-0.2290283590555191,
-0.287664532661438,
0.23778456449508667,
-0.14989522099494934,
-0.04061122238636017,
-0.44220900535583496,
0.8234559297561646,
-0.41583487391471863,
-0.13164664804935455,
-0.42391902208328247,
0.1279904693365097,
-0.23887090384960175,
0.23390954732894897,
-0.09195573627948761,
0.906575620174408,
0.3327336311340332,
-0.6521181464195251,
0.10387731343507767,
-0.2681708037853241,
-0.33465003967285156,
0.5366535782814026,
-0.6454604268074036,
-0.03780534863471985,
0.0012516501592472196,
0.31895384192466736,
-0.7996063828468323,
0.038583263754844666,
0.09736019372940063,
-0.3004966974258423,
0.001582370139658451,
0.18504458665847778,
-0.7088579535484314,
-0.49981024861335754,
-0.08739609271287918,
0.6360140442848206,
0.9600321650505066,
-0.7057046294212341,
0.5432205200195312,
0.1779002994298935,
-0.09145626425743103,
-0.3519440293312073,
-0.5563122034072876,
-0.051023900508880615,
-0.5178415775299072,
-0.16902995109558105,
0.21022985875606537,
-0.06215621531009674,
-0.32869550585746765,
0.11033055931329727,
-0.3334544003009796,
0.22757647931575775,
0.30894234776496887,
0.29977157711982727,
-0.1476859152317047,
-0.3644977807998657,
0.16774941980838776,
-0.006501493975520134,
0.043375831097364426,
0.4282703995704651,
-0.4462796449661255,
0.26356303691864014,
-0.03443029895424843,
-0.7970631718635559,
-0.17346306145191193,
0.37555959820747375,
0.2669364809989929,
0.25212210416793823,
0.6085918545722961,
0.24850568175315857,
-0.3930460214614868,
-0.5007891654968262,
-0.7770311832427979,
-0.5346933603286743,
-0.4889349937438965,
0.15956036746501923,
-0.6762940883636475,
-0.9393064975738525,
0.7793585658073425,
-0.18526387214660645,
0.015586181543767452,
0.40235820412635803,
0.7701513767242432,
-0.5627738237380981,
0.5668399333953857,
0.10675391554832458,
0.14972497522830963,
0.35720208287239075,
0.14760878682136536,
0.2576877176761627,
-0.6953639984130859,
0.005931478459388018,
-0.23843130469322205,
-0.25011733174324036,
-0.6034108996391296,
-0.502491295337677,
0.20135311782360077,
0.15044091641902924,
0.0680922418832779,
0.17951391637325287,
-0.45958104729652405,
0.4501606225967407,
0.6319813132286072,
0.2563053369522095,
0.3560762405395508,
0.06772270798683167,
-0.49465227127075195,
-0.11912600696086884,
-0.997026264667511,
-0.7388131618499756,
1.2607626914978027,
0.16941764950752258,
0.7768908143043518,
-0.012342794798314571,
0.9053893089294434,
0.34280622005462646,
0.6183710694313049,
-0.3516235947608948,
0.6827183961868286,
0.06542331725358963,
-0.6317911148071289,
-0.12618079781532288,
-0.5398844480514526,
-1.142883539199829,
0.29164913296699524,
-0.33090877532958984,
-0.9724541902542114,
-0.06063353642821312,
0.5432491302490234,
-0.1545729786157608,
0.4561193585395813,
-0.6946180462837219,
0.5568475723266602,
-0.07727804780006409,
-0.13450448215007782,
-0.3682408332824707,
-0.5673166513442993,
0.37100842595100403,
-0.3477255403995514,
0.3043983578681946,
-0.27856576442718506,
0.10554462671279907,
0.4928625226020813,
-0.1190112829208374,
0.7457352876663208,
0.28886109590530396,
-0.07841172814369202,
0.636663019657135,
0.17831028997898102,
0.22332212328910828,
0.000029704788175877184,
-0.33897390961647034,
0.3407699465751648,
0.030367840081453323,
-0.284160315990448,
-1.058806300163269,
1.065589189529419,
-0.4317520260810852,
-1.1340453624725342,
-0.2666299045085907,
-0.7033969163894653,
0.0037197177298367023,
-0.010623845271766186,
0.13587456941604614,
0.2103978991508484,
-0.05281359702348709,
0.2742554247379303,
0.597701907157898,
-0.07527406513690948,
0.4165104627609253,
0.5126950144767761,
-0.00942569226026535,
-0.15280920267105103,
0.8013231754302979,
0.08613555133342743,
0.3917182683944702,
0.5608764290809631,
0.28039154410362244,
-0.31413885951042175,
-0.5394477844238281,
-0.4126594364643097,
0.3608953654766083,
-1.0967875719070435,
-0.09460984915494919,
-0.7684234380722046,
-0.07416895776987076,
-0.22073428332805634,
-0.23463174700737,
-0.23206081986427307,
-0.6922653317451477,
-0.22630126774311066,
0.10522656887769699,
0.18683232367038727,
0.5894619822502136,
-0.36941322684288025,
-0.01630435138940811,
-0.5820915102958679,
0.6509870886802673,
0.6366877555847168,
0.03708231821656227,
0.3232727646827698,
-0.6488332748413086,
0.13983193039894104,
0.16671812534332275,
-0.43072614073753357,
-0.8801207542419434,
0.05057912319898605,
-0.041104789823293686,
1.1466848850250244,
0.30986687541007996,
0.05329308286309242,
0.6108041405677795,
-0.7356697916984558,
0.6564473509788513,
0.1132865622639656,
-0.5414859652519226,
0.36425164341926575,
-0.5151001811027527,
0.47510862350463867,
0.5063851475715637,
0.20572809875011444,
-0.1637324094772339,
-0.6090822219848633,
-0.9735256433486938,
-0.7629335522651672,
0.3889423906803131,
0.42259445786476135,
0.1916714757680893,
-0.3395672142505646,
0.897097110748291,
0.11713846027851105,
0.3329124450683594,
-0.912092924118042,
-0.5628762245178223,
0.14065957069396973,
-0.2917494773864746,
0.03385327383875847,
-0.1452181488275528,
-0.16136689484119415,
-0.046344514936208725,
0.2959584593772888,
-0.11396432667970657,
0.45137712359428406,
0.1690979152917862,
0.08817070722579956,
-0.0021826273296028376,
0.1721569448709488,
0.7519508004188538,
0.7752569317817688,
-0.2383144497871399,
0.3701087236404419,
0.5244590640068054,
-0.00638754665851593,
0.15881238877773285,
-0.13532565534114838,
-0.18246473371982574,
-0.13443619012832642,
0.42823290824890137,
0.1817619800567627,
0.20460449159145355,
-0.7596197128295898,
0.2195962518453598,
0.019432513043284416,
-0.002233438426628709,
-0.1369566023349762,
0.34060168266296387,
0.31940317153930664,
0.2664192318916321,
0.6828324794769287,
0.08619742095470428,
0.34246399998664856,
-0.8780874609947205,
0.34620359539985657,
0.6340872049331665,
0.10989929735660553,
-0.19700150191783905,
0.8942328691482544,
-0.04349225014448166,
-0.6975671052932739,
0.2781277894973755,
-0.18301300704479218,
-0.15961752831935883,
0.9993886947631836,
0.925317108631134,
0.709537148475647,
-0.022874420508742332,
-0.11425670981407166,
0.3380791246891022,
0.20911632478237152,
-0.1281549334526062,
0.03865572065114975,
-0.21527555584907532,
-0.7897626161575317,
-0.31819310784339905,
-0.5187669992446899,
-0.3992854654788971,
0.3511861264705658,
-0.591433048248291,
0.04084219038486481,
-0.25815269351005554,
-0.09521663188934326,
0.068942129611969,
-0.6363717317581177,
-0.63759446144104,
0.3398352861404419,
-0.06363143026828766,
0.588388204574585,
-0.837852418422699,
0.7436342835426331,
0.8011506795883179,
-0.02563471719622612,
-0.7167342305183411,
0.17762021720409393,
-0.18475842475891113,
-1.0417165756225586,
0.6434336304664612,
0.0203134473413229,
-0.12368422001600266,
-0.19872413575649261,
-0.28024134039878845,
-0.8808035254478455,
1.0201666355133057,
0.44047829508781433,
-0.34005627036094666,
0.09772053360939026,
0.005446997005492449,
1.0125322341918945,
-0.6148166656494141,
0.4894174039363861,
0.18355095386505127,
-0.034438807517290115,
0.13065683841705322,
-0.6861553192138672,
0.3003459572792053,
-0.1249457597732544,
0.028191251680254936,
-0.015326980501413345,
-0.4329761564731598,
0.5970183610916138,
-0.5566250085830688,
0.07480615377426147,
0.13264581561088562,
0.7854607105255127,
0.8712884783744812,
0.4979155659675598,
0.359941303730011,
0.5014206767082214,
0.38317203521728516,
0.2852030396461487,
1.100677490234375,
-0.36062490940093994,
0.06388366222381592,
1.4233535528182983,
-0.3062771260738373,
0.7213007211685181,
0.748287558555603,
0.028098465874791145,
0.3843827545642853,
0.5063679814338684,
0.1584494411945343,
0.6080036163330078,
0.31178465485572815,
-0.17752820253372192,
-0.5051982402801514,
0.11187852919101715,
-0.618338406085968,
0.14650428295135498,
0.33465442061424255,
-0.596645712852478,
-0.45771098136901855,
-0.13675761222839355,
-0.3166395425796509,
0.37526342272758484,
-0.14776241779327393,
0.6465805172920227,
0.4689817726612091,
-0.7356362342834473,
0.2994266748428345,
-0.194098562002182,
0.35522329807281494,
-0.5310518145561218,
-0.4554170072078705,
-0.10645211488008499,
0.04075419157743454,
0.04738844558596611,
-0.8634305000305176,
0.2701531946659088,
-0.3662331700325012,
-0.36621883511543274,
-0.449688583612442,
0.7046945691108704,
-0.1245153620839119,
-0.25535455346107483,
0.07809960842132568,
0.853762149810791,
0.3639400899410248,
0.2576690912246704,
-0.7184152007102966,
-0.42316263914108276,
0.04744089022278786,
-0.09907761961221695,
0.7172542810440063,
0.9538366794586182,
-0.08032383024692535,
1.2323551177978516,
0.7863835692405701,
0.3723691701889038,
-0.009031563065946102,
-0.24476608633995056,
0.777718722820282,
-0.7501228451728821,
-0.33010333776474,
-0.8273318409919739,
0.10789575427770615,
-0.06369368731975555,
-0.4090576469898224,
0.8288124203681946,
0.3664737641811371,
0.8648159503936768,
-0.46365827322006226,
0.6299872994422913,
0.14416255056858063,
0.4770734906196594,
-0.6587169170379639,
0.3419780135154724,
-0.5399225950241089,
0.6789000630378723,
-0.1622300148010254,
-0.8875331282615662,
-0.04878761246800423,
0.9141553044319153,
-0.39885783195495605,
0.2513888478279114,
0.8369348645210266,
0.712190568447113,
-0.19631239771842957,
-0.11325354874134064,
0.6565556526184082,
0.01942535862326622,
0.12191883474588394,
0.485935777425766,
1.0030052661895752,
-0.18563929200172424,
0.4390692412853241,
-0.1537642925977707,
0.15222954750061035,
-0.0640346109867096,
-1.292171835899353,
-1.0543997287750244,
-0.46776095032691956,
-0.2749355137348175,
-0.151678204536438,
0.19266846776008606,
0.9680257439613342,
0.596846342086792,
-0.586829423904419,
-0.10466790944337845,
-0.19121426343917847,
0.3312388062477112,
-0.2913527488708496,
-0.22108355164527893,
-0.07596947997808456,
-0.44215822219848633,
-0.3184027671813965,
0.3010199964046478,
0.2958138883113861,
0.12470869719982147,
-0.006294082384556532,
0.2573041021823883,
0.14773736894130707,
0.19943676888942719,
0.3690980076789856,
0.4899590313434601,
-1.0642136335372925,
-0.3873453438282013,
-0.1924688071012497,
-0.23657284677028656,
0.07260782271623611,
1.0179924964904785,
-1.0655461549758911,
0.3246176242828369,
0.36083701252937317,
0.7034639716148376,
0.4111357629299164,
0.08407071977853775,
0.6661661863327026,
-0.41533827781677246,
0.15085352957248688,
0.2971033453941345,
0.5240654945373535,
0.09530048817396164,
-0.4239632487297058,
0.46879178285598755,
0.3071087896823883,
-0.5710729360580444,
-0.7290586233139038,
0.43026113510131836,
-0.9805856347084045,
-0.4174412488937378,
1.4240169525146484,
-0.33745360374450684,
-0.11040230095386505,
-0.04856027290225029,
0.026353878900408745,
-0.10806107521057129,
-0.31859350204467773,
1.1195192337036133,
0.6691632270812988,
-0.3431393504142761,
-0.1566677838563919,
-0.5916891098022461,
0.33405977487564087,
0.7565006017684937,
-0.8579399585723877,
-0.2645849883556366,
0.18451997637748718,
0.5401944518089294,
0.08844120800495148,
0.6905773282051086,
0.14134113490581512,
0.3551647365093231,
0.01668214425444603,
-0.09341473877429962,
0.044584717601537704,
0.06174231320619583,
-0.23214109241962433,
0.23693475127220154,
0.1921069175004959,
0.08921321481466293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12726v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12726v2
|
Evaluating Character Understanding of Large Language Models via Character Profiling from Fictional Works
| 2024-04-19T09:10:29 | 2024-07-02T14:01:27 |
Xinfeng Yuan, Siyu Yuan, Yuhan Cui, Tianhe Lin, Xintao Wang, Rui Xu, Jiangjie Chen, Deqing Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance and
spurred numerous AI applications, in which role-playing agents (RPAs) are
particularly popular, especially for fictional characters. The prerequisite for
these RPAs lies in the capability of LLMs to understand characters from
fictional works. Previous efforts have evaluated this capability via basic
classification tasks or characteristic imitation, failing to capture the
nuanced character understanding with LLMs. In this paper, we propose evaluating
LLMs' character understanding capability via the character profiling task,
i.e., summarizing character profiles from corresponding materials, a widely
adopted yet understudied practice for RPA development. Specifically, we
construct the CroSS dataset from literature experts and assess the generated
profiles by comparing ground truth references and their applicability in
downstream tasks. Our experiments, which cover various summarization methods
and LLMs, have yielded promising results. These results strongly validate the
character understanding capability of LLMs. Resources are available at
https://github.com/Joanna0123/character_profiling.
|
[
-0.27304452657699585,
-0.5788910388946533,
0.7342236042022705,
-0.028820736333727837,
-0.14174336194992065,
0.45384904742240906,
-0.2609464228153229,
-0.5534546971321106,
0.30195653438568115,
1.0307546854019165,
-0.5675291419029236,
-0.5179756283760071,
-0.4521991014480591,
0.3513798117637634,
-0.16809624433517456,
0.8832129836082458,
-0.04009735584259033,
-0.0268015805631876,
-0.4987674653530121,
-0.15317250788211823,
-0.6966712474822998,
-0.3908085525035858,
-0.4142627716064453,
-0.5020132660865784,
0.658362090587616,
0.23645637929439545,
0.5494934320449829,
0.5215263366699219,
0.3292599022388458,
0.3344578444957733,
-0.039716508239507675,
0.6314815282821655,
-0.7966399788856506,
0.4166744351387024,
-0.33087557554244995,
-0.6784394979476929,
-0.29330432415008545,
0.22277088463306427,
0.9582429528236389,
0.6304910182952881,
0.31006795167922974,
0.27655258774757385,
0.10735113173723221,
0.4336465299129486,
-0.5235674381256104,
0.43956154584884644,
-0.4530291259288788,
0.20678187906742096,
-0.14892753958702087,
-0.30365222692489624,
-0.5877094268798828,
-0.11014304310083389,
-0.09260575473308563,
-0.6023504137992859,
0.4503632187843323,
0.20161332190036774,
0.5703915953636169,
-0.0007430619443766773,
-0.3714534640312195,
-0.4451483488082886,
-0.7642909288406372,
0.7442958950996399,
-0.5917633175849915,
0.0525984913110733,
0.3313891887664795,
0.4394383132457733,
-0.07749935239553452,
-0.34205400943756104,
-0.6035237312316895,
-0.5745734572410583,
-0.4855027198791504,
0.05017338693141937,
0.04341602325439453,
-0.06761064380407333,
0.43125033378601074,
0.5007554292678833,
-0.649614155292511,
0.29856348037719727,
-0.2295471876859665,
-0.2678917646408081,
0.6854487061500549,
0.2656506896018982,
0.28562644124031067,
-0.07833364605903625,
-0.09937819093465805,
-0.1415472775697708,
-0.5745912790298462,
-0.03837894648313522,
0.47637566924095154,
0.26466450095176697,
-0.10489198565483093,
0.7225006818771362,
0.14852739870548248,
0.30427151918411255,
-0.07275643944740295,
-0.246359184384346,
0.16383764147758484,
-0.27476999163627625,
-0.23445327579975128,
-0.15915128588676453,
0.5715765953063965,
0.18116064369678497,
0.9150571227073669,
-0.34815457463264465,
-0.18464519083499908,
-0.38550737500190735,
0.32690057158470154,
-0.8692651391029358,
0.11107461154460907,
0.183108389377594,
-0.5892347693443298,
-0.18298745155334473,
-0.14825883507728577,
-0.7163581848144531,
-1.0280423164367676,
-0.19930288195610046,
0.08613557368516922,
-0.43618348240852356,
-0.17268724739551544,
-0.24544696509838104,
-0.19924837350845337,
0.41136083006858826,
0.293070524930954,
-0.8525437116622925,
-0.03288428857922554,
0.8198085427284241,
0.9593687057495117,
-0.16176488995552063,
-0.40746909379959106,
-0.6428594589233398,
0.12631244957447052,
-0.5044267773628235,
0.8953573107719421,
-0.5293925404548645,
-0.5813747048377991,
-0.01430710218846798,
-0.07432884722948074,
-0.29417166113853455,
-0.5395416617393494,
0.5107887387275696,
-0.5528651475906372,
-0.15008147060871124,
-0.37148305773735046,
-0.5388778448104858,
-0.18017752468585968,
0.35580962896347046,
-0.9063049554824829,
0.5991659164428711,
0.05898874253034592,
-0.5373179912567139,
0.1826385110616684,
-0.35128939151763916,
-0.42130738496780396,
0.187898188829422,
-0.23323415219783783,
-0.1984950304031372,
0.302885502576828,
0.3027958869934082,
0.8186892867088318,
-0.2382405400276184,
0.25800803303718567,
-0.3063298761844635,
-0.6044227480888367,
0.5616374611854553,
-0.40762561559677124,
0.6577454805374146,
0.09498070180416107,
0.0940689891576767,
-0.03929121419787407,
-0.5157796740531921,
-0.2797999083995819,
0.21629966795444489,
0.05440305918455124,
-0.3952846825122833,
-0.06555093824863434,
-0.06230583041906357,
-0.1723204255104065,
0.2258836030960083,
-0.31336596608161926,
0.03487761318683624,
-0.11263683438301086,
0.011267662979662418,
0.5928482413291931,
0.05051228031516075,
0.07550578564405441,
-0.49182799458503723,
0.8323396444320679,
-0.5472186803817749,
-0.36531704664230347,
-0.41785892844200134,
-0.15274587273597717,
-0.5289053916931152,
-0.5980984568595886,
0.2859170436859131,
0.4474649429321289,
-0.7222610116004944,
0.5472570657730103,
-0.30032530426979065,
-0.7227239608764648,
-0.23053130507469177,
0.05485297739505768,
0.6951106786727905,
0.3803720772266388,
0.22467513382434845,
-0.19032444059848785,
-0.189971923828125,
-0.8958056569099426,
-0.7815555930137634,
-0.5106562376022339,
-0.30424875020980835,
0.5736173987388611,
0.49843430519104004,
-0.07281272858381271,
0.8429497480392456,
-0.35819071531295776,
-0.2790537178516388,
-0.7432453036308289,
0.3265038728713989,
0.0635080635547638,
0.22012768685817719,
0.7608785033226013,
-0.38286182284355164,
-0.47907644510269165,
-0.029368091374635696,
-0.8274638652801514,
-0.23073290288448334,
-0.37972864508628845,
0.08145324885845184,
-0.13071970641613007,
0.47261765599250793,
-0.3872286081314087,
0.2650229334831238,
0.5482137203216553,
-0.5248655676841736,
0.827686071395874,
-0.20387305319309235,
0.40495914220809937,
-0.8054236769676208,
0.46079158782958984,
0.22734175622463226,
-0.4848218262195587,
-0.5762135982513428,
0.23184634745121002,
-0.1685711294412613,
-0.05495899170637131,
-0.13310874998569489,
0.7079574465751648,
-0.6223008036613464,
-0.5551785230636597,
-0.199920192360878,
0.3182053565979004,
0.29542607069015503,
0.3947623074054718,
0.10572943091392517,
1.0066859722137451,
0.1087716594338417,
-0.3027333617210388,
0.17922170460224152,
0.2230202555656433,
-0.6258428692817688,
0.6475419998168945,
-0.5792211294174194,
0.07413779944181442,
-0.22469428181648254,
0.33879098296165466,
-1.0442514419555664,
-0.1253606081008911,
0.1107184886932373,
-0.26862505078315735,
0.3770952522754669,
-0.38351887464523315,
-0.7276513576507568,
0.1587938368320465,
-0.18149428069591522,
0.23022624850273132,
0.3083975911140442,
-0.2632981836795807,
1.0794788599014282,
0.4280599057674408,
-0.221962109208107,
-0.6468040943145752,
-0.6209703087806702,
0.11295698583126068,
-0.42047980427742004,
-0.46581441164016724,
0.3675224483013153,
-0.1205492839217186,
-0.5038509964942932,
-0.38269415497779846,
0.008757118135690689,
-0.03837096691131592,
0.14939601719379425,
-0.0483592264354229,
0.010718796402215958,
-0.17546303570270538,
-0.05109110847115517,
0.06826415657997131,
0.11011839658021927,
0.15184779465198517,
0.5697914958000183,
0.4378792345523834,
0.010039446875452995,
-0.19189903140068054,
-0.41485852003097534,
0.11275554448366165,
0.7573747634887695,
-0.2641630172729492,
0.6832385659217834,
0.6569481492042542,
-0.018646882846951485,
-0.3276166319847107,
-0.5559746026992798,
0.024233268573880196,
-0.4276459813117981,
0.5693598389625549,
-0.4403304159641266,
-0.7534491419792175,
0.9960592985153198,
0.027089891955256462,
0.19109532237052917,
0.559345543384552,
0.3668411076068878,
-0.1439354419708252,
0.6409593820571899,
0.6061578989028931,
-0.050209276378154755,
0.45948073267936707,
-0.05664462596178055,
-0.1045914888381958,
-0.8226760029792786,
-0.20691156387329102,
-0.6855430006980896,
-0.29131877422332764,
-0.5978089570999146,
-0.7201786637306213,
0.25925442576408386,
-0.1916932910680771,
0.11301912367343903,
0.29712390899658203,
0.2340959906578064,
0.925883412361145,
0.04280925914645195,
0.020088262856006622,
0.47958970069885254,
-0.05307382717728615,
0.07651274651288986,
0.12803314626216888,
-0.1533454805612564,
-0.7940658926963806,
0.9563374519348145,
0.8437193632125854,
0.7737082242965698,
0.09892082959413528,
0.37678447365760803,
0.7359083294868469,
0.25704988837242126,
-0.8167737126350403,
0.6750868558883667,
-0.31879156827926636,
-0.5430899858474731,
-0.4465804398059845,
-0.46729883551597595,
-0.5323171019554138,
0.514008104801178,
-0.17187927663326263,
-0.6946998238563538,
0.34876134991645813,
0.007440891582518816,
-0.3151203691959381,
0.18012335896492004,
-0.5215789079666138,
0.8346097469329834,
-0.1563235968351364,
-0.13770827651023865,
-0.5567930340766907,
-0.42229342460632324,
0.5444852113723755,
-0.120211161673069,
0.030402176082134247,
-0.19496627151966095,
0.04695560038089752,
0.7020646929740906,
-0.00595112144947052,
1.0199320316314697,
-0.14143820106983185,
-0.45991095900535583,
0.18709763884544373,
0.2742486894130707,
0.4590233862400055,
0.15878039598464966,
-0.4679860472679138,
0.3747113347053528,
0.22454793751239777,
-0.362169086933136,
-0.7716479897499084,
0.5450539588928223,
-0.6509038805961609,
-0.3604598939418793,
-0.5200872421264648,
-0.6823707818984985,
-0.48373058438301086,
0.09803345054388046,
-0.14921808242797852,
0.3498110771179199,
-0.7516554594039917,
0.17666731774806976,
0.7313812375068665,
-0.3356294333934784,
0.16806623339653015,
0.6425859332084656,
-0.27762821316719055,
-0.18541941046714783,
0.8299731612205505,
-0.01502269972115755,
0.19329527020454407,
0.419638454914093,
0.2134132981300354,
-0.2933388650417328,
-0.6572577357292175,
-0.48529770970344543,
0.6199789047241211,
-0.7024385929107666,
0.10698828846216202,
-0.5383741855621338,
-0.2123706042766571,
-0.2654136121273041,
-0.07336501777172089,
-0.1750093698501587,
-0.021319178864359856,
-0.41393277049064636,
0.0766126736998558,
0.03129826486110687,
0.9127739071846008,
0.4299773871898651,
0.3290380835533142,
-0.745977520942688,
0.31465306878089905,
0.0717337429523468,
0.2192416936159134,
0.05924999713897705,
-0.8368942141532898,
-0.4454634189605713,
-0.17107215523719788,
-0.015201115980744362,
-0.7468162178993225,
0.4599596858024597,
0.24198126792907715,
0.7939918637275696,
0.5250755548477173,
-0.08587966859340668,
0.5719836354255676,
-0.31762173771858215,
0.6779175996780396,
-0.4772658944129944,
-0.977759063243866,
0.019763296470046043,
-0.34160253405570984,
0.03921651467680931,
0.8103166818618774,
0.2767719030380249,
-0.6556551456451416,
-0.41467446088790894,
-0.2624608278274536,
-0.20183579623699188,
0.7120225429534912,
0.3642182946205139,
0.19093000888824463,
0.48016491532325745,
0.5767854452133179,
0.30099812150001526,
0.2169741690158844,
-0.5538100600242615,
-0.07260533422231674,
0.1452607959508896,
-0.09916830062866211,
-0.5217822194099426,
-0.44199231266975403,
0.07713750004768372,
0.18742045760154724,
0.5229137539863586,
-0.31679996848106384,
0.1542818397283554,
-0.015775587409734726,
-0.48565858602523804,
0.1164259985089302,
0.04209999740123749,
0.7126794457435608,
0.9123033285140991,
-0.27465641498565674,
0.05282268673181534,
0.051101140677928925,
-0.6890052556991577,
-0.27245616912841797,
-0.014412352815270424,
0.07550451904535294,
-0.09777539223432541,
1.0938302278518677,
0.6551634669303894,
0.04027020186185837,
-1.028767466545105,
0.3162723183631897,
-0.25015100836753845,
0.035196222364902496,
-0.23302431404590607,
0.24522948265075684,
-0.17836914956569672,
0.5053075551986694,
0.34771543741226196,
-0.38073521852493286,
0.0012614118168130517,
-0.7824026942253113,
0.10071244835853577,
0.4933837950229645,
-0.17227885127067566,
-0.2339187115430832,
-0.04655744507908821,
0.24595247209072113,
-0.1572733223438263,
0.40766841173171997,
-0.1346874088048935,
-0.4543246924877167,
0.9154987931251526,
0.4869886636734009,
0.9614260792732239,
-0.15747064352035522,
0.40050798654556274,
0.11156746000051498,
0.5099202394485474,
0.23407888412475586,
-0.11494693160057068,
0.03365476801991463,
-0.8206079006195068,
-0.612420916557312,
-0.5520672798156738,
-0.6919817924499512,
0.28222984075546265,
-0.358381450176239,
0.2590949833393097,
-0.4426235258579254,
0.35845082998275757,
-0.06813453882932663,
0.37800419330596924,
-0.5020421147346497,
-0.022419990971684456,
0.07190102338790894,
0.7845088839530945,
-1.1624348163604736,
0.528717577457428,
0.36128053069114685,
-0.45443201065063477,
-0.3486138880252838,
0.6410814523696899,
-0.2402409315109253,
-0.9140962362289429,
0.5666057467460632,
0.32456791400909424,
-0.08964001387357712,
-0.05641023442149162,
-0.20112289488315582,
-0.5592563152313232,
1.188881754875183,
0.5898445844650269,
-0.4878423511981964,
-0.16149266064167023,
0.25766560435295105,
0.7300623655319214,
-0.6590836048126221,
0.7295898795127869,
0.6688653230667114,
0.4629665017127991,
0.10560643672943115,
-0.657844603061676,
0.13859300315380096,
-0.19072212278842926,
-0.14834977686405182,
-0.3801293671131134,
-0.708078145980835,
0.6020646095275879,
0.012631401419639587,
-0.2772807776927948,
0.2152462601661682,
0.8716832995414734,
0.4354974627494812,
0.33496519923210144,
0.7317295670509338,
0.045759595930576324,
0.8126423954963684,
0.38959282636642456,
0.8951122760772705,
-0.16996963322162628,
0.20859600603580475,
1.022564172744751,
-0.3841925859451294,
0.4331791400909424,
0.1366296261548996,
-0.0933304876089096,
0.7275111675262451,
0.5370005965232849,
-0.22410058975219727,
0.22153639793395996,
0.28942710161209106,
-0.16361352801322937,
-0.3915817141532898,
-0.24867509305477142,
-0.16816112399101257,
0.7193248867988586,
0.342957466840744,
-0.6771823167800903,
-0.2552669644355774,
-0.08227618038654327,
0.011780297383666039,
0.2761639654636383,
-0.3434431254863739,
0.608047366142273,
-0.02192816138267517,
-0.6013362407684326,
0.23020486533641815,
0.12897789478302002,
0.29634714126586914,
-0.541047215461731,
-0.27076756954193115,
-0.3727041482925415,
-0.06949470192193985,
0.05524255335330963,
-0.8818678855895996,
0.22947165369987488,
0.3999398350715637,
-0.2013656198978424,
-0.23122218251228333,
0.6311593055725098,
-0.2823832631111145,
-0.5072364807128906,
0.0431644432246685,
0.43270641565322876,
0.37925657629966736,
-0.11400766670703888,
-0.43433770537376404,
0.10214033722877502,
-0.18564258515834808,
-0.17988814413547516,
0.3704202175140381,
0.42528772354125977,
0.0037333047948777676,
0.47823119163513184,
0.3115561604499817,
0.0831712931394577,
-0.6083670854568481,
0.037153106182813644,
0.6573095917701721,
-0.48811718821525574,
-0.5187340974807739,
-0.8678774833679199,
0.3878340423107147,
-0.13926419615745544,
-0.32512062788009644,
0.8496153354644775,
0.498211145401001,
0.5162779092788696,
-0.06748437881469727,
0.8068017959594727,
0.18636265397071838,
0.5531586408615112,
-0.766726016998291,
0.9212325215339661,
-0.3432920277118683,
0.48563921451568604,
-0.24686655402183533,
-0.9663434028625488,
-0.07063444703817368,
0.5332489609718323,
-0.3462587296962738,
0.30376988649368286,
0.6116816997528076,
0.6940664052963257,
-0.15707354247570038,
-0.002621556632220745,
0.5039423704147339,
0.17752736806869507,
0.4699164628982544,
0.23549772799015045,
0.6972278356552124,
-0.014345907606184483,
0.14660543203353882,
0.09909133613109589,
-0.3989275395870209,
-0.3113766014575958,
-1.0827335119247437,
-1.5940521955490112,
-0.3331114649772644,
-0.0978127047419548,
-0.3363070785999298,
0.04811595007777214,
0.6967545747756958,
0.4109826385974884,
-0.6622881293296814,
-0.2651675045490265,
0.14607448875904083,
0.3588224947452545,
-0.19625124335289001,
-0.21324025094509125,
0.33304595947265625,
-0.12969724833965302,
-0.9460147023200989,
0.7771416902542114,
-0.09793166071176529,
-0.20553871989250183,
-0.9836614727973938,
0.008734256960451603,
0.060171909630298615,
0.41171005368232727,
0.4395577311515808,
0.3763982951641083,
-0.6376893520355225,
-0.24978865683078766,
-0.08522579073905945,
0.007558384444564581,
-0.28022852540016174,
1.2680927515029907,
-0.6610286235809326,
0.3784828782081604,
0.6848188638687134,
0.7349997162818909,
0.34967389702796936,
0.15748997032642365,
0.7666427493095398,
-0.8565082550048828,
-0.341346800327301,
0.2580675780773163,
0.3271694481372833,
0.18385010957717896,
-0.7146703004837036,
0.3511829376220703,
0.2565375864505768,
-0.5906498432159424,
-0.8533676862716675,
0.39891743659973145,
-0.8461759090423584,
-0.2920895516872406,
1.122963547706604,
-0.503607988357544,
-0.14873754978179932,
-0.06898896396160126,
-0.14105667173862457,
0.27149802446365356,
-0.19813822209835052,
0.6360698342323303,
0.7170102000236511,
-0.12557275593280792,
-0.15594831109046936,
-0.5337070822715759,
0.2690444886684418,
0.18889641761779785,
-0.9189216494560242,
0.6741564869880676,
0.6222509145736694,
0.12415044754743576,
0.19536752998828888,
0.41728562116622925,
0.020777488127350807,
-0.1496916115283966,
-0.324807345867157,
-0.035765524953603745,
-0.34969016909599304,
-0.4920349717140198,
-0.21338027715682983,
0.1896626353263855,
-0.011100531555712223,
0.23927000164985657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12720v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12720v1
|
PDF-MVQA: A Dataset for Multimodal Information Retrieval in PDF-based Visual Question Answering
| 2024-04-19T09:00:05 | 2024-04-19T09:00:05 |
Yihao Ding, Kaixuan Ren, Jiabin Huang, Siwen Luo, Soyeon Caren Han
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Document Question Answering (QA) presents a challenge in understanding
visually-rich documents (VRD), particularly those dominated by lengthy textual
content like research journal articles. Existing studies primarily focus on
real-world documents with sparse text, while challenges persist in
comprehending the hierarchical semantic relations among multiple pages to
locate multimodal components. To address this gap, we propose PDF-MVQA, which
is tailored for research journal articles, encompassing multiple pages and
multimodal information retrieval. Unlike traditional machine reading
comprehension (MRC) tasks, our approach aims to retrieve entire paragraphs
containing answers or visually rich document entities like tables and figures.
Our contributions include the introduction of a comprehensive PDF Document VQA
dataset, allowing the examination of semantically hierarchical layout
structures in text-dominant documents. We also present new VRD-QA frameworks
designed to grasp textual contents and relations among document layouts
simultaneously, extending page-level understanding to the entire multi-page
document. Through this work, we aim to enhance the capabilities of existing
vision-and-language models in handling challenges posed by text-dominant
documents in VRD-QA.
|
[
-0.45073992013931274,
-0.974860668182373,
0.7210653424263,
0.1229032650589943,
-0.18334494531154633,
0.004112470895051956,
0.46715113520622253,
-0.2675063908100128,
-0.06409509479999542,
0.4576016366481781,
-0.665412962436676,
-0.38618433475494385,
-0.4882158637046814,
0.154215008020401,
-0.35843610763549805,
0.5370761752128601,
-0.2578734755516052,
0.35171937942504883,
-0.6515090465545654,
-0.3761863708496094,
-0.3328484296798706,
-0.1481320559978485,
-0.14067547023296356,
0.3994733691215515,
0.9282487630844116,
0.37505847215652466,
0.602425217628479,
0.4595007002353668,
0.6477171778678894,
0.2549189031124115,
0.05021278187632561,
0.2590295970439911,
-0.259807288646698,
0.09638833999633789,
-0.13487648963928223,
-0.5066518783569336,
-0.35241827368736267,
-0.2007187008857727,
0.8724008798599243,
0.48360416293144226,
0.1298849731683731,
0.14364086091518402,
0.005674693267792463,
0.5793624520301819,
-1.0676857233047485,
0.17425522208213806,
-0.2816655933856964,
0.08829692751169205,
-0.05438325181603432,
-0.6728835105895996,
-0.35053613781929016,
-0.070200115442276,
0.10070870071649551,
-1.0581278800964355,
0.4236606955528259,
0.0711400955915451,
1.1152719259262085,
0.09336110204458237,
-0.9879892468452454,
-0.13258174061775208,
-0.4581104815006256,
0.41519883275032043,
-0.04139216989278793,
0.7958494424819946,
0.456980437040329,
0.3816196918487549,
0.15223613381385803,
-0.7871088981628418,
-1.0578514337539673,
0.11007502675056458,
0.24448561668395996,
0.4166054129600525,
-0.10597909986972809,
-0.056573666632175446,
0.21741774678230286,
0.43427741527557373,
-0.9995602369308472,
-0.3581409156322479,
-0.4439558684825897,
-0.01993536204099655,
0.06758006662130356,
0.30418387055397034,
0.5630919337272644,
-0.5025523900985718,
-0.4058951735496521,
-0.5613886117935181,
-0.2733343541622162,
0.08180448412895203,
0.1684107929468155,
-0.16470398008823395,
0.25952211022377014,
0.9477362036705017,
-0.15510274469852448,
0.7085532546043396,
-0.37838980555534363,
-0.18068167567253113,
0.1587701439857483,
-0.6430438160896301,
-0.3071407079696655,
-0.5798795819282532,
0.6413460969924927,
0.47121188044548035,
-0.03485976159572601,
0.03691225126385689,
-0.07305335253477097,
-0.33669888973236084,
0.4224027097225189,
-0.6310691833496094,
-0.15668509900569916,
0.1353934109210968,
-0.3787080645561218,
-0.06905313581228256,
0.025672003626823425,
-1.1201003789901733,
-0.589600145816803,
-0.2839473485946655,
0.8748726844787598,
-0.5229392051696777,
-0.19391269981861115,
-0.03195860981941223,
-0.660535991191864,
0.47028687596321106,
0.8664657473564148,
-0.6647732853889465,
-0.011121383868157864,
0.32923588156700134,
0.7501052021980286,
-0.16217313706874847,
-0.4440500736236572,
-0.5885602831840515,
0.3759329617023468,
-0.28616902232170105,
0.7768622040748596,
-0.44281941652297974,
-0.3941870927810669,
0.05656884238123894,
0.0485660545527935,
-0.25846242904663086,
-0.40181082487106323,
0.49513891339302063,
-0.7887977957725525,
0.48885801434516907,
-0.5092418789863586,
-0.10548748821020126,
-0.35483047366142273,
0.7623602747917175,
-0.9330295324325562,
0.847884476184845,
0.39672988653182983,
-1.2161682844161987,
0.42657017707824707,
-0.2232317328453064,
-0.17525477707386017,
-0.16020406782627106,
-0.4203987717628479,
-0.1541922688484192,
-0.15460653603076935,
0.6114001274108887,
0.35676854848861694,
-0.3275351822376251,
-0.30643025040626526,
-0.25435101985931396,
-0.045627690851688385,
0.0700894221663475,
-0.5829998850822449,
0.5417250990867615,
0.0834064930677414,
0.06275131553411484,
0.34054845571517944,
-0.8204138278961182,
-0.1213449016213417,
0.25730884075164795,
-0.3870478570461273,
-0.3765965402126312,
-0.25310206413269043,
0.4157100021839142,
0.3390153646469116,
0.16660583019256592,
-0.4115123152732849,
0.24899275600910187,
0.293563574552536,
0.053644437342882156,
0.5319720506668091,
0.2690425515174866,
0.4272672235965729,
-0.2558455169200897,
0.8352600932121277,
0.2743903398513794,
0.24688223004341125,
-0.4538545310497284,
-0.41680365800857544,
-0.6655042767524719,
-0.5437238812446594,
0.131566122174263,
0.64961838722229,
-1.365312933921814,
-0.4169984459877014,
-0.35629457235336304,
-0.17786529660224915,
-0.5154780745506287,
0.19166947901248932,
0.2952192425727844,
0.7281031608581543,
0.5270029306411743,
-0.28437870740890503,
-0.030230717733502388,
-1.0410875082015991,
0.11796870827674866,
-0.24423547089099884,
-0.09136615693569183,
0.39736607670783997,
0.47925373911857605,
-0.12621398270130157,
0.5775401592254639,
-0.47313493490219116,
-0.3688376545906067,
-0.05229354277253151,
0.2966425120830536,
-0.4573768079280853,
0.2602140009403229,
0.41876092553138733,
-1.5965402126312256,
-0.2402178794145584,
-0.16810694336891174,
-0.7740049958229065,
0.28049609065055847,
-0.349435031414032,
-0.23669221997261047,
-0.12589624524116516,
0.330606073141098,
-0.6574329733848572,
0.44320592284202576,
0.2706022560596466,
-0.36644813418388367,
0.47620320320129395,
-0.216754749417305,
0.7155611515045166,
-1.1004279851913452,
0.0018071692902594805,
0.2614012360572815,
-0.10882128775119781,
-0.26705655455589294,
0.24113290011882782,
0.39408737421035767,
-0.2461363524198532,
-0.49418342113494873,
0.595169186592102,
-0.41108739376068115,
-0.179765984416008,
0.0822693333029747,
0.36721503734588623,
0.6118975877761841,
0.5663577318191528,
0.12247206270694733,
1.0089149475097656,
0.3351022005081177,
-0.342849463224411,
0.09612094610929489,
0.5656133890151978,
-0.14325392246246338,
0.7133815884590149,
-0.40083619952201843,
-0.2301255762577057,
-0.5617403388023376,
0.12249987572431564,
-1.3320446014404297,
-0.23825538158416748,
0.17998769879341125,
-0.385900616645813,
0.29267358779907227,
-0.09804229438304901,
-0.7277373671531677,
-0.2100868672132492,
-0.28977927565574646,
0.564960777759552,
-0.09148087352514267,
-0.39602556824684143,
1.0004396438598633,
0.1981220543384552,
-0.288319855928421,
-0.8809870481491089,
-0.4171757400035858,
0.09962659329175949,
0.18072575330734253,
-0.8959177732467651,
0.1169234961271286,
-0.016140375286340714,
-0.11112286150455475,
0.06636400520801544,
-0.17310026288032532,
-0.37456560134887695,
-0.2076505571603775,
0.2174416333436966,
0.3082171082496643,
-0.31752029061317444,
0.1231883242726326,
-0.006173527333885431,
0.1481797695159912,
-0.1729680299758911,
0.0548311285674572,
0.21141667664051056,
-0.0664220005273819,
-0.43462875485420227,
-0.3351054787635803,
0.7901730537414551,
0.8986868262290955,
-0.6935434341430664,
0.5981364250183105,
0.8215102553367615,
-0.28603774309158325,
0.06467875093221664,
-0.5035483241081238,
0.2363157868385315,
-0.3727629780769348,
0.5174422264099121,
-0.7279103994369507,
-0.7555714249610901,
0.40380606055259705,
0.201930969953537,
0.08384779095649719,
0.5204712748527527,
0.5195696353912354,
-0.3831450641155243,
1.0143030881881714,
0.8190309405326843,
0.5504351854324341,
0.4631243944168091,
-0.3468998074531555,
-0.26666784286499023,
-0.9584060311317444,
-0.695412278175354,
-0.5477247834205627,
0.03172214329242706,
-0.1605965495109558,
-0.7658098936080933,
0.5298378467559814,
0.26202845573425293,
-0.015006516128778458,
0.11298368126153946,
-0.4235213100910187,
0.13997504115104675,
0.5419740080833435,
0.11390111595392227,
0.4524943232536316,
-0.20811469852924347,
-0.2375510334968567,
-0.02279338799417019,
-0.6189742088317871,
-0.39138585329055786,
0.7504740357398987,
0.18740975856781006,
0.8239834904670715,
0.31205934286117554,
0.12611721456050873,
0.10275505483150482,
-0.010320788249373436,
-0.5555090308189392,
0.3333202302455902,
0.23601022362709045,
-0.5469518899917603,
-0.2461000382900238,
-0.47754934430122375,
-0.8225732445716858,
0.7501469254493713,
-0.47447669506073,
-0.6521061658859253,
0.5686466097831726,
-0.06643306463956833,
-0.026707660406827927,
0.22554801404476166,
-0.7456640601158142,
1.2955132722854614,
-0.25208815932273865,
-0.5025447010993958,
-0.042200908064842224,
-0.4899989366531372,
0.36172932386398315,
0.05580561235547066,
0.06717027723789215,
0.11363475024700165,
-0.32227715849876404,
0.6803972721099854,
-0.10632355511188507,
0.26391467452049255,
0.11376715451478958,
-0.20979219675064087,
0.11501444876194,
0.1258886307477951,
0.19956786930561066,
0.19049608707427979,
0.066839300096035,
-0.3298681974411011,
0.7789300680160522,
-0.7101377248764038,
-0.9739158153533936,
0.5117664933204651,
-0.685791015625,
-0.4557139277458191,
-0.6615249514579773,
-0.6119236350059509,
-0.4305139183998108,
0.4071933627128601,
0.12923415005207062,
0.6635541319847107,
-0.0949593186378479,
0.3440404236316681,
1.0436224937438965,
-0.370945006608963,
0.05117174610495567,
0.49561208486557007,
-0.3254428505897522,
-0.2981037497520447,
0.9598897695541382,
0.08380939811468124,
0.07502661645412445,
0.894690752029419,
-0.25249937176704407,
-0.5069272518157959,
-0.6968406438827515,
-0.8294001817703247,
-0.015928475186228752,
-1.0042558908462524,
0.07026698440313339,
-1.1400940418243408,
0.014665440656244755,
-0.3606812059879303,
-0.031011376529932022,
0.05455244705080986,
-0.39066657423973083,
-0.4185563623905182,
0.06091707944869995,
-0.04997038096189499,
0.5035616755485535,
0.314523845911026,
-0.13931800425052643,
-0.9637606739997864,
1.1092945337295532,
0.5491019487380981,
0.21716181933879852,
0.04455110430717468,
-0.24140477180480957,
0.05437490716576576,
-0.19647344946861267,
-0.4575296640396118,
-1.0410327911376953,
0.2328646183013916,
-0.012138795107603073,
0.4706246554851532,
0.1267995983362198,
0.11737710982561111,
0.5456210374832153,
-0.3606390953063965,
0.7230202555656433,
0.24819578230381012,
-0.280145525932312,
0.3406673073768616,
-0.5850493907928467,
0.5433526635169983,
0.601682186126709,
0.781543493270874,
-0.4389491379261017,
-0.13022981584072113,
-0.33074134588241577,
-0.9314287900924683,
0.2981938421726227,
0.21285554766654968,
0.03412317484617233,
0.06318464875221252,
0.16951678693294525,
0.015595503151416779,
0.3154618442058563,
-0.43629157543182373,
0.15201468765735626,
-0.5285470485687256,
-0.16235387325286865,
0.08838016539812088,
-0.22560089826583862,
-0.2187711000442505,
-0.12097646296024323,
0.42688634991645813,
-0.3835369944572449,
0.14047615230083466,
0.4973815977573395,
-0.3406086564064026,
0.018982432782649994,
0.42985185980796814,
0.5316890478134155,
1.0305241346359253,
-0.31626012921333313,
0.2144334316253662,
-0.20530566573143005,
-0.5779410004615784,
-0.05165489390492439,
0.15782877802848816,
-0.07710140198469162,
-0.1519010215997696,
0.4293999969959259,
0.6581780910491943,
-0.12124352902173996,
-0.9704225063323975,
0.8961776494979858,
-0.5340681672096252,
-0.282979279756546,
-0.21179836988449097,
-0.13269563019275665,
-0.044922783970832825,
0.2982272803783417,
0.7105359435081482,
-0.17741473019123077,
0.35563212633132935,
-0.7074124813079834,
0.4352640211582184,
0.4502299427986145,
-0.5470245480537415,
0.1819629818201065,
0.8030707240104675,
0.06550652533769608,
0.012557423673570156,
0.6428743600845337,
0.1361384242773056,
-0.22931335866451263,
0.6607345342636108,
0.1315159648656845,
0.36554259061813354,
0.5975673794746399,
0.5103523135185242,
0.14582742750644684,
0.2202816754579544,
0.2875722348690033,
0.5716371536254883,
-0.21289236843585968,
-0.3965906798839569,
-0.2842312455177307,
-0.6029636859893799,
-0.41631606221199036,
0.03365084156394005,
-0.7662551999092102,
0.0004116656200494617,
-0.47358906269073486,
-0.017238186672329903,
0.2825152277946472,
-0.036458466202020645,
-0.6062275767326355,
0.3783680200576782,
0.020681237801909447,
1.0765584707260132,
-0.4167640209197998,
0.6408347487449646,
0.6147332191467285,
-0.9552972316741943,
-0.5045608878135681,
0.05275203660130501,
0.20346187055110931,
-0.35799935460090637,
0.5251343846321106,
-0.1792452186346054,
-0.12447382509708405,
-0.02613690122961998,
-0.3030688464641571,
-0.43355870246887207,
1.170290470123291,
0.2231340855360031,
-0.107938252389431,
-0.2589368224143982,
-0.06586674600839615,
0.47838929295539856,
0.0904371440410614,
0.4239642024040222,
-0.1478605717420578,
0.4466877579689026,
0.33321133255958557,
-0.6091325879096985,
-0.12783685326576233,
-0.5633395314216614,
-0.09800258278846741,
0.06233225762844086,
-0.6361454725265503,
0.7545115351676941,
-0.09546070545911789,
-0.11166737973690033,
0.08192236721515656,
0.8227545022964478,
0.0849803015589714,
0.3146647810935974,
0.30213338136672974,
0.578194797039032,
0.6292875409126282,
-0.042257413268089294,
1.3770880699157715,
0.11627314239740372,
0.030501283705234528,
1.0285907983779907,
0.00042679053149186075,
0.9885947704315186,
0.6911494135856628,
0.14654168486595154,
0.31795206665992737,
0.6279547214508057,
0.04172544181346893,
0.3361985981464386,
-0.08292951434850693,
-0.3141160011291504,
-0.44123098254203796,
-0.19382344186306,
-0.30486130714416504,
0.29264751076698303,
0.18818549811840057,
-0.06110348552465439,
-0.4027058482170105,
0.2946756184101105,
-0.5515017509460449,
0.1378926783800125,
-0.16372355818748474,
0.804905891418457,
-0.09183245152235031,
-0.3242782652378082,
0.2946092188358307,
0.04327785223722458,
0.24848490953445435,
-0.6704436540603638,
-0.30953696370124817,
-0.013821370899677277,
-0.11931797862052917,
-0.06885024160146713,
-1.1085790395736694,
-0.11675179749727249,
-0.23271802067756653,
-0.5631000995635986,
-0.13094373047351837,
0.458951473236084,
-0.4643598794937134,
-0.39322957396507263,
-0.022770512849092484,
0.767907440662384,
-0.25927451252937317,
-0.23412495851516724,
-0.7044745683670044,
-0.1045331284403801,
-0.26542922854423523,
-0.29583150148391724,
0.5944063067436218,
0.6869198083877563,
-0.20019108057022095,
0.950236976146698,
0.5012004375457764,
-0.4615933299064636,
0.33543094992637634,
0.007265395484864712,
0.8908448219299316,
-0.3914256989955902,
-0.4946485459804535,
-0.0764060690999031,
0.5180628299713135,
0.008224423974752426,
-0.4900681972503662,
0.8088974952697754,
0.7427240014076233,
0.6949483156204224,
-0.12406976521015167,
0.6025081276893616,
-0.049081992357969284,
0.1107158362865448,
-0.5964194536209106,
0.7955443263053894,
-1.3167409896850586,
-0.2273177057504654,
-0.39110350608825684,
-0.9281541109085083,
-0.19951093196868896,
0.2522922456264496,
-0.0263962522149086,
-0.18482625484466553,
0.7304255366325378,
0.8296494483947754,
-0.3147801458835602,
-0.06102108955383301,
0.30710548162460327,
-0.21801505982875824,
0.27972567081451416,
0.3964109718799591,
0.8299225568771362,
-0.5253086686134338,
0.9119560122489929,
-0.07242956012487411,
0.002258996246382594,
-0.08428843319416046,
-0.4503692090511322,
-0.7551761269569397,
-1.2050806283950806,
-0.26593244075775146,
-0.46713995933532715,
0.07112231105566025,
0.37570419907569885,
0.4696862995624542,
-0.48081478476524353,
0.31282442808151245,
0.39820602536201477,
0.16068385541439056,
-0.101765938103199,
-0.24549932777881622,
0.5915305614471436,
0.016175076365470886,
-0.6974018812179565,
0.17031769454479218,
0.4972675144672394,
0.17955981194972992,
-0.36808836460113525,
-0.010716816410422325,
-0.7141713500022888,
0.095661960542202,
0.5215836763381958,
0.4884656071662903,
-0.3586494028568268,
-0.09817665815353394,
0.18871408700942993,
-0.5151339173316956,
0.39054232835769653,
0.8074977993965149,
-0.49473974108695984,
0.8184900283813477,
1.0707966089248657,
0.9425391554832458,
0.7360456585884094,
0.17369037866592407,
0.42600777745246887,
-0.5086023211479187,
0.06258616596460342,
0.2689023017883301,
0.3071698844432831,
0.373770147562027,
-0.2565069794654846,
0.3554004728794098,
0.2071722149848938,
-0.15748994052410126,
-0.5658062696456909,
0.14797848463058472,
-1.494208812713623,
-0.5218656063079834,
1.0584369897842407,
-0.0403120331466198,
-0.49458184838294983,
-0.23118479549884796,
-0.5948843955993652,
0.21366474032402039,
-0.16443277895450592,
0.43815377354621887,
0.6214479804039001,
-0.0003338002134114504,
-1.048646330833435,
-0.8119149208068848,
0.32046517729759216,
0.27403295040130615,
-0.8426228761672974,
-0.1274232417345047,
0.7783560752868652,
0.0016754246316850185,
0.2686325013637543,
0.8560613393783569,
-0.2798420190811157,
0.6054309606552124,
0.24071502685546875,
-0.09587831795215607,
-0.32148459553718567,
-0.6469319462776184,
-0.12111364305019379,
0.6803910732269287,
-0.10653369873762131,
-0.16335776448249817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12715v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12715v2
|
Ensemble Learning for Heterogeneous Large Language Models with Deep Parallel Collaboration
| 2024-04-19T08:52:22 | 2024-05-30T16:59:56 |
Yichong Huang, Xiaocheng Feng, Baohang Li, Yang Xiang, Hui Wang, Bing Qin, Ting Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) exhibit complementary strengths in various
tasks, motivating the research of LLM ensembling. However, existing work
focuses on training an extra reward model or fusion model to select or combine
all candidate answers, posing a great challenge to the generalization on unseen
data distributions. Besides, prior methods use textual responses as
communication media, ignoring the valuable information in the internal
representations. In this work, we propose a training-free ensemble framework
DeePEn, fusing the informative probability distributions yielded by different
LLMs at each decoding step. Unfortunately, the vocabulary discrepancy between
heterogeneous LLMs directly makes averaging the distributions unfeasible due to
the token misalignment. To address this challenge, DeePEn maps the probability
distribution of each model from its own probability space to a universal
relative space based on the relative representation theory, and performs
aggregation. Next, we devise a search-based inverse transformation to transform
the aggregated result back to the probability space of one of the ensembling
LLMs (main model), in order to determine the next token. We conduct extensive
experiments on ensembles of different number of LLMs, ensembles of LLMs with
different architectures, and ensembles between the LLM and the specialist
model. Experimental results show that (i) DeePEn achieves consistent
improvements across six benchmarks covering subject examination, reasoning, and
knowledge, (ii) a well-performing specialist model can benefit from a less
effective LLM through distribution fusion, and (iii) DeePEn has complementary
strengths with other ensemble methods such as voting.
|
[
-0.2946961522102356,
-0.394812673330307,
0.5171042680740356,
-0.005141725298017263,
-0.17476268112659454,
0.26729288697242737,
-0.6398031711578369,
-0.4291112422943115,
0.3466537594795227,
0.5494349002838135,
-0.47583886981010437,
-0.7323713302612305,
-0.6214590668678284,
-0.05122341215610504,
-0.2283783257007599,
0.6868048906326294,
-0.02518550120294094,
0.15042200684547424,
-0.3215616047382355,
-0.3532096743583679,
-0.2989813983440399,
-0.35120195150375366,
-0.38719743490219116,
-0.46816468238830566,
0.3723978102207184,
0.46199291944503784,
0.29872503876686096,
0.490487277507782,
0.6259692311286926,
0.37869057059288025,
0.08399979025125504,
0.23275606334209442,
-0.5853278040885925,
0.20438708364963531,
-0.22882580757141113,
-0.5683274269104004,
-0.2756401300430298,
-0.05651942268013954,
0.7726210355758667,
1.0800387859344482,
-0.2465038001537323,
-0.03435009345412254,
0.37162911891937256,
0.3900776505470276,
-0.7202697396278381,
0.026813549920916557,
-0.875706672668457,
0.06145337596535683,
-0.25571173429489136,
0.12171067297458649,
-0.2823041081428528,
-0.16420845687389374,
0.06147246062755585,
-0.38617971539497375,
0.28745537996292114,
-0.04019750654697418,
0.3972338140010834,
0.24599741399288177,
-0.1972111165523529,
0.04908260330557823,
-0.6721175312995911,
0.9335508346557617,
-0.5903632640838623,
0.3129678964614868,
0.21866777539253235,
0.26962903141975403,
0.14353278279304504,
-0.4804133176803589,
-0.5339176654815674,
0.10456262528896332,
0.15898708999156952,
0.29447078704833984,
0.10058277100324631,
0.05202121287584305,
-0.3852400481700897,
0.5719634890556335,
-0.6118940711021423,
0.7137637734413147,
-0.1324465423822403,
-0.1944493055343628,
0.6892214417457581,
0.2970828711986542,
-0.0708836019039154,
0.339260071516037,
-0.39186105132102966,
-0.6256352663040161,
-0.686662495136261,
-0.15994279086589813,
0.40727072954177856,
0.2706318497657776,
-0.3656400442123413,
0.49999094009399414,
-0.07586799561977386,
0.4261702597141266,
0.11202363669872284,
0.2164587825536728,
0.6201019287109375,
-0.17432759702205658,
-0.4345935583114624,
0.14008359611034393,
0.8487300872802734,
-0.1311488002538681,
-0.06937363743782043,
-0.2533285319805145,
-0.3543216586112976,
-0.014086964540183544,
-0.22974006831645966,
-0.5440669655799866,
-0.20407870411872864,
0.3650497794151306,
-0.3612944781780243,
-0.45325568318367004,
0.1487571746110916,
-0.6056554317474365,
-0.38933250308036804,
-0.3943937420845032,
0.21559178829193115,
-0.34647998213768005,
-0.2877924144268036,
0.10796722024679184,
0.024784965440630913,
0.14627020061016083,
0.2972710132598877,
-0.7947511672973633,
0.3401140868663788,
0.8580366969108582,
0.5902562141418457,
-0.40442851185798645,
-0.6040248274803162,
-0.6245415210723877,
0.2828441858291626,
-0.40445676445961,
0.697434663772583,
-0.8032102584838867,
-0.3299534022808075,
0.15566423535346985,
-0.05953775346279144,
-0.181634321808815,
-0.6096205115318298,
0.3498643636703491,
-0.449881911277771,
0.34546464681625366,
0.013303936459124088,
-0.9204091429710388,
-0.0007770931115373969,
0.39268869161605835,
-0.6059480309486389,
0.5347139835357666,
-0.2091049700975418,
-0.5743555426597595,
0.29092514514923096,
-0.32759416103363037,
-0.2672794461250305,
0.14613449573516846,
-0.5586932301521301,
-0.24449686706066132,
0.11867474764585495,
0.375010222196579,
0.6472623348236084,
-0.3466353416442871,
0.19278228282928467,
-0.6425937414169312,
-0.48334333300590515,
0.030083701014518738,
-0.5727701783180237,
0.5997123718261719,
0.04609929025173187,
-0.0414297915995121,
0.24088025093078613,
-0.5008365511894226,
-0.197835311293602,
-0.03619292378425598,
-0.3279672861099243,
-0.3165549635887146,
-0.09435267746448517,
-0.04790320619940758,
-0.1810462772846222,
0.2638007402420044,
-0.4113301932811737,
0.2683001458644867,
-0.7592324614524841,
-0.1593914031982422,
0.9520402550697327,
-0.06815578788518906,
0.843673050403595,
-0.28291070461273193,
0.3036707043647766,
0.1869669407606125,
-0.1867639422416687,
-0.007113839499652386,
-0.325602650642395,
-0.45051681995391846,
-0.3891887962818146,
0.2877940535545349,
0.6771301031112671,
-0.7155085206031799,
0.7155150771141052,
-0.5943699479103088,
-0.32124823331832886,
-0.6421924233436584,
0.3337641954421997,
0.2506980299949646,
0.39504265785217285,
0.17622649669647217,
-0.2977209985256195,
-0.3143809139728546,
-0.7732406854629517,
-0.10308920592069626,
-0.08711682260036469,
-0.22715319693088531,
0.20656248927116394,
0.26034292578697205,
-0.4076921343803406,
0.5899365544319153,
-0.4343462884426117,
-0.49415677785873413,
-0.2281372994184494,
0.20399391651153564,
0.448290079832077,
0.5123299360275269,
0.2469812035560608,
-0.7478557825088501,
-0.25826287269592285,
0.2753255367279053,
-0.7694964408874512,
0.18996229767799377,
0.19549645483493805,
0.022400399670004845,
0.09193084388971329,
0.45196855068206787,
-0.41628497838974,
-0.02685641124844551,
0.6413018107414246,
0.18899814784526825,
0.3277014195919037,
-0.33151063323020935,
0.08123664557933807,
-1.2803291082382202,
-0.0299434382468462,
-0.12755009531974792,
0.1220104992389679,
-0.3072810471057892,
0.18313606083393097,
-0.0668468251824379,
-0.15878251194953918,
-0.34235522150993347,
0.5188040137290955,
-0.4525265097618103,
-0.06821183860301971,
-0.1371646374464035,
-0.00044830897240899503,
-0.39527496695518494,
0.4804377257823944,
0.20154991745948792,
0.4602338969707489,
0.7876750230789185,
-0.515576958656311,
0.4927338659763336,
0.16296008229255676,
-0.40059688687324524,
0.2842983603477478,
-0.40947410464286804,
0.16060113906860352,
-0.2641419768333435,
0.3304426670074463,
-1.0595861673355103,
-0.6660639047622681,
0.08984929323196411,
-0.29766935110092163,
0.45707452297210693,
-0.052118267863988876,
-0.45936453342437744,
-0.19563093781471252,
-0.3416644334793091,
0.5613123178482056,
0.5400175452232361,
-0.6863760352134705,
0.6838380098342896,
0.35628440976142883,
-0.10001885145902634,
-0.7144138216972351,
-0.8082928657531738,
0.04085386544466019,
-0.31831005215644836,
-0.8399448394775391,
0.45167964696884155,
0.17265553772449493,
-0.3795442581176758,
0.01257280632853508,
0.07331686466932297,
-0.13048726320266724,
0.05009797587990761,
0.06359714269638062,
0.2537303566932678,
-0.356607049703598,
0.7291243672370911,
0.07454434782266617,
0.016336023807525635,
-0.19382329285144806,
-0.40351852774620056,
0.6991593241691589,
-0.15333032608032227,
-0.7665380835533142,
0.06097782775759697,
0.4520708918571472,
0.27485400438308716,
-0.4860564172267914,
0.907421886920929,
0.6511480212211609,
-0.3801155090332031,
-0.14933666586875916,
-0.7290870547294617,
-0.43043994903564453,
-0.4807756841182709,
0.4540007710456848,
-0.2900109589099884,
-1.1328105926513672,
0.680927038192749,
-0.12246828526258469,
0.12578967213630676,
0.4530278742313385,
0.5342199206352234,
-0.07248735427856445,
0.7933624982833862,
0.6165949106216431,
-0.5758150815963745,
0.18373845517635345,
-0.24896128475666046,
-0.022542033344507217,
-0.5771808624267578,
-0.23647437989711761,
-0.34492233395576477,
-0.42282435297966003,
-0.568518877029419,
-0.5090286731719971,
0.5173197984695435,
-0.005701932590454817,
-0.2712564468383789,
-0.003047314705327153,
-0.32046064734458923,
0.584190845489502,
0.3231414258480072,
0.1555347740650177,
0.20850524306297302,
0.40255314111709595,
-0.07705653458833694,
0.2060120701789856,
-0.7245109677314758,
-0.08770428597927094,
1.0796376466751099,
0.2963188588619232,
0.8803449869155884,
0.22758039832115173,
1.2672348022460938,
-0.07783607393503189,
0.25385624170303345,
-0.4541003108024597,
0.48746949434280396,
-0.4218253195285797,
-0.17511865496635437,
-0.5878182053565979,
-0.619063138961792,
-1.0099416971206665,
0.40423575043678284,
-0.2487550675868988,
-0.8500186800956726,
0.4852025508880615,
0.09875297546386719,
-0.15623584389686584,
0.3844802975654602,
-0.5578970313072205,
0.6226609945297241,
-0.046111516654491425,
-0.4703201651573181,
-0.4339437186717987,
-0.7113869190216064,
0.6517745852470398,
-0.1777767688035965,
0.23155872523784637,
0.07217780500650406,
-0.08821438997983932,
0.516040563583374,
-0.0872519314289093,
0.9096308350563049,
0.12822207808494568,
-0.2448282539844513,
0.13957495987415314,
0.15938152372837067,
0.7658666968345642,
0.07764928787946701,
-0.24122153222560883,
0.10248588025569916,
-0.5536589026451111,
-0.36176732182502747,
-0.3935399651527405,
0.9646269083023071,
-0.8250192999839783,
-0.6440383195877075,
-0.05838845297694206,
-0.6027584075927734,
-0.47842466831207275,
-0.02496992237865925,
0.45373040437698364,
0.3478740155696869,
-0.17895890772342682,
0.3391816318035126,
0.8522553443908691,
-0.1237044408917427,
0.394287109375,
0.16199614107608795,
0.012362314388155937,
-0.37376925349235535,
0.9598239660263062,
-0.1666938066482544,
0.21125943958759308,
0.657058835029602,
0.13156384229660034,
-0.4331165850162506,
-0.40191853046417236,
-0.18298348784446716,
0.14496368169784546,
-0.780929446220398,
0.003925837576389313,
-0.6061099171638489,
-0.08609279990196228,
-0.7218140959739685,
-0.0988001674413681,
-0.29596152901649475,
-0.13325650990009308,
-0.3785437047481537,
-0.03663033992052078,
0.11402367800474167,
0.3378794491291046,
-0.20811860263347626,
0.12663443386554718,
-0.7645390033721924,
-0.09374624490737915,
0.4633289575576782,
0.3967805802822113,
0.15076330304145813,
-0.359637051820755,
-0.12210830301046371,
0.09677709639072418,
-0.11621569097042084,
-0.5902784466743469,
0.17237846553325653,
0.19986291229724884,
0.6281247138977051,
0.31594839692115784,
-0.10622091591358185,
0.5148167610168457,
-0.2795396149158478,
0.5879231691360474,
0.4062928259372711,
-0.6008501648902893,
0.25641417503356934,
-0.4132368266582489,
0.270087331533432,
0.5345171093940735,
0.21263818442821503,
-0.4123322069644928,
-0.36015647649765015,
-0.5756375789642334,
-0.8944512009620667,
0.56097412109375,
0.05702386051416397,
0.19290538132190704,
0.04282943904399872,
-0.1370115429162979,
0.09763623774051666,
0.07699547708034515,
-0.4983709752559662,
-0.053188808262348175,
0.11156739294528961,
-0.44109442830085754,
-0.4847748577594757,
0.17579971253871918,
-0.20565903186798096,
-0.26020920276641846,
0.5667136907577515,
-0.22217577695846558,
0.24592657387256622,
0.0893300399184227,
-0.06251279264688492,
0.023769795894622803,
0.331306129693985,
0.21187452971935272,
0.21267762780189514,
-0.09440246969461441,
0.26660051941871643,
0.4318300485610962,
-0.034453004598617554,
0.10641364753246307,
0.3227226138114929,
0.4758897125720978,
-0.22175432741641998,
0.7575600147247314,
0.71891850233078,
0.1602310687303543,
-0.6970014572143555,
0.5671198964118958,
0.22830574214458466,
-0.36939653754234314,
-0.18910038471221924,
0.10446422547101974,
0.2995077073574066,
0.3392307460308075,
0.44260066747665405,
0.10164445638656616,
0.2076033651828766,
-0.5474563837051392,
0.21374614536762238,
0.43589499592781067,
-0.3309430778026581,
-0.04624708369374275,
0.3238314092159271,
0.1629662662744522,
-0.09517447650432587,
0.6099002361297607,
-0.13047830760478973,
-0.34191834926605225,
0.6600118279457092,
0.27010565996170044,
0.9709749221801758,
-0.30313417315483093,
0.05689151957631111,
0.0037645648699253798,
0.07139892876148224,
-0.2966268062591553,
-0.06236729770898819,
-0.18941502273082733,
-1.0349678993225098,
-0.619211733341217,
-0.4126195013523102,
-0.3240014910697937,
0.2519891560077667,
-0.3528197705745697,
0.10469924658536911,
-0.07094532251358032,
0.3803330361843109,
-0.20949280261993408,
-0.20752406120300293,
-0.8178955316543579,
0.025044212117791176,
0.2503002882003784,
0.7182400822639465,
-0.8547783493995667,
0.7399645447731018,
0.7912075519561768,
-0.18680983781814575,
-0.8019556999206543,
0.2496241182088852,
-0.1333555281162262,
-0.8455024361610413,
0.4616060256958008,
0.08321729302406311,
0.04199661314487457,
-0.04413483664393425,
-0.7205514311790466,
-0.7566661238670349,
0.9298601150512695,
0.4485144317150116,
-0.9305717945098877,
0.12306796759366989,
0.1452203094959259,
0.4712539613246918,
-0.5581211447715759,
0.1354559063911438,
0.22950385510921478,
0.14543400704860687,
0.16372984647750854,
-0.7894609570503235,
-0.1391795426607132,
-0.14385782182216644,
-0.0791853815317154,
0.26720768213272095,
-0.4663861393928528,
0.9175517559051514,
0.09467240422964096,
-0.10679974406957626,
0.04527752473950386,
0.5999295711517334,
0.45979776978492737,
0.1731608361005783,
0.5471833348274231,
0.5494415163993835,
0.8998482823371887,
0.17950156331062317,
1.0394574403762817,
-0.09057339280843735,
0.3482869267463684,
1.2715339660644531,
-0.6596617698669434,
0.8473466634750366,
0.47731292247772217,
0.016816506162285805,
0.35200369358062744,
0.42144516110420227,
0.00655520660802722,
0.6545523405075073,
0.18811850249767303,
-0.5457490682601929,
-0.6372739672660828,
0.1311153918504715,
-0.47201260924339294,
0.3976382613182068,
0.33687713742256165,
-0.34261053800582886,
-0.4484551250934601,
0.12928900122642517,
-0.6560842394828796,
0.2905948758125305,
-0.24998486042022705,
0.7854399085044861,
0.14865364134311676,
-0.5733872652053833,
0.4698805809020996,
-0.021918704733252525,
0.7698982954025269,
-0.3458201587200165,
0.04335934668779373,
-0.22347427904605865,
0.5174672603607178,
-0.050025515258312225,
-0.8806697130203247,
0.08659986406564713,
-0.3932579457759857,
-0.16410954296588898,
0.048666972666978836,
0.8759315013885498,
-0.7280175685882568,
-0.6178377866744995,
0.3106667399406433,
0.6173213124275208,
0.16591818630695343,
0.0390816293656826,
-0.3577219247817993,
0.010321816429495811,
-0.13731227815151215,
-0.06878917664289474,
0.49728715419769287,
0.4754367470741272,
-0.07385317981243134,
0.6244555711746216,
0.5361799597740173,
-0.058495666831731796,
-0.16327844560146332,
0.2573409676551819,
0.8434503078460693,
-0.21432091295719147,
-0.6449460983276367,
-0.8403377532958984,
0.30289754271507263,
-0.25155070424079895,
-0.1588541567325592,
0.5605376362800598,
0.4770679771900177,
0.9529837965965271,
-0.10845361649990082,
0.6488766670227051,
0.4208422601222992,
0.392939031124115,
-0.5272842645645142,
0.5203635096549988,
-0.5356827974319458,
0.5367483496665955,
-0.142083540558815,
-1.0150595903396606,
-0.2254544496536255,
0.34150850772857666,
-0.33336132764816284,
-0.17627295851707458,
0.2897064983844757,
0.6790689826011658,
-0.4443226456642151,
0.09638164937496185,
0.27246901392936707,
0.022014012560248375,
0.21072392165660858,
0.7806002497673035,
0.7263813018798828,
-0.16761194169521332,
0.426861435174942,
-0.1293802708387375,
-0.1470717191696167,
-0.08266330510377884,
-0.5152269005775452,
-0.7999454140663147,
-0.4878702461719513,
-0.21898607909679413,
0.029578495770692825,
0.12972716987133026,
1.0808626413345337,
0.6200155019760132,
-0.7345200777053833,
-0.42882487177848816,
-0.3694777190685272,
0.14516323804855347,
-0.16617301106452942,
-0.17542283236980438,
0.41773200035095215,
-0.4045979976654053,
-0.5876654386520386,
0.46413013339042664,
0.10699016600847244,
0.034604694694280624,
-0.17956368625164032,
-0.260339617729187,
0.006872264202684164,
-0.19857141375541687,
0.3633348047733307,
0.02787007950246334,
-0.6082305312156677,
-0.23459935188293457,
-0.10481079667806625,
-0.025912290439009666,
-0.030178086832165718,
0.4259132444858551,
-0.8563485741615295,
0.15772148966789246,
0.5376459956169128,
1.0197831392288208,
0.5541337728500366,
-0.3113149404525757,
0.640428364276886,
-1.122092366218567,
0.30719488859176636,
0.5024330615997314,
0.46199479699134827,
0.24751879274845123,
-0.3226512670516968,
0.4569694995880127,
0.22574983537197113,
-0.3289543688297272,
-0.8621934056282043,
0.1196603998541832,
-0.7963240742683411,
-0.48688220977783203,
1.103945016860962,
0.047336600720882416,
-0.12397874146699905,
0.1953526735305786,
0.1474345475435257,
0.18700337409973145,
-0.2910762429237366,
0.5810043215751648,
0.6572414040565491,
0.1704779416322708,
-0.24743054807186127,
0.1807142049074173,
0.023031340911984444,
0.6367994546890259,
-0.6131247878074646,
-0.01717406138777733,
0.3348890542984009,
0.19545835256576538,
0.1940435916185379,
0.4076753854751587,
0.04583827033638954,
0.18257412314414978,
-0.10622620582580566,
0.08693556487560272,
0.07351183891296387,
-0.12012982368469238,
-0.6293450593948364,
0.4049363434314728,
-0.24024416506290436,
-0.277747243642807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13099v1
|
Mathify: Evaluating Large Language Models on Mathematical Problem Solving Tasks
| 2024-04-19T08:45:42 | 2024-04-19T08:45:42 |
Avinash Anand, Mohit Gupta, Kritarth Prasad, Navya Singla, Sanjana Sanjeev, Jatin Kumar, Adarsh Raj Shivam, Rajiv Ratn Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid progress in the field of natural language processing (NLP) systems
and the expansion of large language models (LLMs) have opened up numerous
opportunities in the field of education and instructional methods. These
advancements offer the potential for tailored learning experiences and
immediate feedback, all delivered through accessible and cost-effective
services. One notable application area for this technological advancement is in
the realm of solving mathematical problems. Mathematical problem-solving not
only requires the ability to decipher complex problem statements but also the
skill to perform precise arithmetic calculations at each step of the
problem-solving process. However, the evaluation of the arithmetic capabilities
of large language models remains an area that has received relatively little
attention. In response, we introduce an extensive mathematics dataset called
"MathQuest" sourced from the 11th and 12th standard Mathematics NCERT
textbooks. This dataset encompasses mathematical challenges of varying
complexity and covers a wide range of mathematical concepts. Utilizing this
dataset, we conduct fine-tuning experiments with three prominent LLMs: LLaMA-2,
WizardMath, and MAmmoTH. These fine-tuned models serve as benchmarks for
evaluating their performance on our dataset. Our experiments reveal that among
the three models, MAmmoTH-13B emerges as the most proficient, achieving the
highest level of competence in solving the presented mathematical problems.
Consequently, MAmmoTH-13B establishes itself as a robust and dependable
benchmark for addressing NCERT mathematics problems.
|
[
-0.40188711881637573,
-0.7189061641693115,
0.38222599029541016,
0.4978303909301758,
-0.02971184439957142,
0.11140308529138565,
-0.41952595114707947,
-0.40931886434555054,
-0.009179479442536831,
0.3208087980747223,
-0.6786625981330872,
-0.3935229480266571,
-0.8267439007759094,
0.4527050852775574,
-0.21845735609531403,
0.7261558771133423,
-0.04066940397024155,
0.26214614510536194,
-0.6217694878578186,
-0.02487454004585743,
-0.7210635542869568,
-0.5414999127388,
-0.49485042691230774,
-0.5929446816444397,
0.2711670398712158,
0.1308729201555252,
0.9726479053497314,
0.5055766701698303,
0.9032460451126099,
0.36856797337532043,
-0.2703052759170532,
0.32716578245162964,
-0.6798839569091797,
0.18492576479911804,
-0.15577660501003265,
-0.572454035282135,
-0.35654211044311523,
-0.13091468811035156,
0.587263286113739,
1.173365831375122,
-0.3264143168926239,
0.3371352255344391,
-0.1661592423915863,
0.671483039855957,
-0.5481729507446289,
0.43688541650772095,
-0.7469784021377563,
-0.04748048633337021,
-0.2428501695394516,
0.2797701954841614,
-0.23440663516521454,
-0.5617287755012512,
0.14359697699546814,
-1.0888265371322632,
-0.03544798493385315,
-0.09511961787939072,
0.402031809091568,
0.466176301240921,
-0.31272247433662415,
-0.6257413029670715,
-0.48251715302467346,
1.06440007686615,
-0.6391133069992065,
0.4260174334049225,
0.6882578134536743,
0.32497331500053406,
-0.31843802332878113,
-0.25966235995292664,
-0.3083610236644745,
-0.19209888577461243,
0.23704363405704498,
-0.07812881469726562,
-0.42286187410354614,
-0.3097948729991913,
0.5378111004829407,
0.562499463558197,
-0.6036222577095032,
0.2225390374660492,
-0.4716876745223999,
-0.29474973678588867,
0.6563759446144104,
0.5920349359512329,
0.3283001780509949,
-0.0864391103386879,
0.23204097151756287,
-0.21009638905525208,
-0.7468923926353455,
-0.07371292263269424,
0.25583547353744507,
0.3861558139324188,
-0.022923577576875687,
0.9513994455337524,
-0.1664927750825882,
0.8921919465065002,
-0.03434055298566818,
-0.20837613940238953,
0.16619285941123962,
0.023251499980688095,
-0.2300674468278885,
-0.0851963460445404,
0.4553629159927368,
0.0912008211016655,
0.3612242043018341,
0.04741106182336807,
-0.4727528393268585,
0.33198410272598267,
0.07626297324895859,
-0.8616014719009399,
-0.18255586922168732,
-0.037808857858181,
-0.1332874447107315,
-0.16129282116889954,
-0.2782840430736542,
-0.39416638016700745,
-0.6472106575965881,
-0.7739500403404236,
0.6249073147773743,
-0.2680383324623108,
-0.1872864067554474,
0.5079565644264221,
0.24275563657283783,
-0.16294574737548828,
0.5207580924034119,
-0.8400679230690002,
0.4545639455318451,
1.1814624071121216,
0.6800610423088074,
-0.16206423938274384,
-0.014342532493174076,
-0.5505275726318359,
-0.3220318853855133,
-0.6307141184806824,
0.7549177408218384,
-0.6948450207710266,
-0.40240478515625,
0.09018298238515854,
-0.3592270314693451,
-0.07591713219881058,
-1.0894182920455933,
0.732256293296814,
-0.6102800369262695,
0.06530202925205231,
-0.2938636243343353,
-0.6864698529243469,
-0.30829957127571106,
0.5354209542274475,
-0.8520688414573669,
1.0817855596542358,
0.19808003306388855,
-0.3892712891101837,
-0.06523033231496811,
-0.5013227462768555,
-0.06229260936379433,
0.04549357667565346,
0.10029170662164688,
-0.353241890668869,
0.5487805008888245,
0.31751611828804016,
0.17267920076847076,
-0.8251069784164429,
0.3121705651283264,
-0.36784827709198,
-0.26922664046287537,
0.28959232568740845,
-0.3623185157775879,
0.8037087917327881,
0.07568971812725067,
-0.005926392041146755,
-0.22033536434173584,
-0.7653820514678955,
0.055393561720848083,
0.2785000503063202,
-0.24752135574817657,
-0.3902999758720398,
-0.27184757590293884,
-0.2925119400024414,
-0.008692936971783638,
0.4437013864517212,
-0.3083478808403015,
0.27920037508010864,
-0.49167704582214355,
0.127272829413414,
0.7393574118614197,
-0.17904578149318695,
0.24104632437229156,
-0.35765206813812256,
0.7737725377082825,
-0.37370362877845764,
-0.03680667653679848,
-0.12856972217559814,
-0.5958057641983032,
-0.6870479583740234,
-0.06532133370637894,
0.4919091761112213,
0.5438351631164551,
-0.6075399518013,
-0.10586012154817581,
-0.3400440812110901,
-0.7654678225517273,
-0.23409688472747803,
0.31486693024635315,
0.391735315322876,
0.3086525499820709,
0.2085932493209839,
-0.0964222326874733,
-0.31594905257225037,
-0.7859968543052673,
-0.48528850078582764,
-0.0786173865199089,
-0.17203590273857117,
0.39266788959503174,
0.4107963442802429,
-0.15429338812828064,
0.5903974175453186,
-0.6879961490631104,
-0.3491648733615875,
0.07684832811355591,
0.10533850640058517,
0.7165117263793945,
0.25323328375816345,
0.41098302602767944,
-0.5642591118812561,
-0.37122613191604614,
0.011470324359834194,
-0.7655383348464966,
-0.5730631947517395,
0.2563515305519104,
-0.15908513963222504,
-0.15477389097213745,
0.1652422398328781,
-0.568692684173584,
0.41455599665641785,
0.8083561062812805,
-0.2760353088378906,
0.6377251744270325,
0.006587131880223751,
-0.047406237572431564,
-0.4667625427246094,
-0.02730579674243927,
0.013887036591768265,
0.1267377883195877,
-0.4920862913131714,
0.04881850630044937,
0.0635911151766777,
-0.3262249231338501,
-0.15480589866638184,
0.49828624725341797,
-0.3642060458660126,
-0.11117520928382874,
-0.09470483660697937,
-0.006077079568058252,
-0.10730628669261932,
0.31470805406570435,
-0.16997402906417847,
0.8496079444885254,
0.44428741931915283,
-0.5437136888504028,
0.43597158789634705,
0.37597352266311646,
-0.4881165027618408,
0.5343215465545654,
-0.846247136592865,
0.2283983677625656,
0.09794781357049942,
-0.08637671917676926,
-0.7598015666007996,
-0.2151525914669037,
-0.05885428190231323,
-0.41641244292259216,
0.011863410472869873,
-0.13976840674877167,
-0.6903836131095886,
-0.288490355014801,
0.029689909890294075,
0.7401918768882751,
0.11549555510282516,
-0.338662326335907,
0.9129167795181274,
0.46826863288879395,
-0.3544709384441376,
-0.5306376218795776,
-0.33011600375175476,
0.07558226585388184,
-0.04963406175374985,
-0.6904314160346985,
0.10636799782514572,
-0.3011401295661926,
-0.544945478439331,
-0.20558860898017883,
-0.3915892541408539,
-0.16366912424564362,
0.12616795301437378,
0.39144784212112427,
0.5032073855400085,
-0.20772558450698853,
0.0753033310174942,
-0.05908612534403801,
-0.4226483106613159,
0.48883071541786194,
-0.18356916308403015,
0.5268496870994568,
-0.1369187980890274,
-0.5604775547981262,
-0.20395176112651825,
0.092275470495224,
0.6697819828987122,
-0.38127854466438293,
0.5074769258499146,
0.12433452904224396,
-0.7743368148803711,
-0.009593237191438675,
-0.5868306756019592,
-0.010126789100468159,
-0.44990742206573486,
0.25957387685775757,
-0.45350703597068787,
-0.7729188799858093,
0.5435503125190735,
-0.1396702378988266,
0.25628146529197693,
0.5779538154602051,
0.6809992790222168,
0.41899389028549194,
1.1482250690460205,
0.36966845393180847,
0.09817894548177719,
0.19811929762363434,
-0.3008055090904236,
0.039340659976005554,
-0.6222366690635681,
-0.41000720858573914,
-0.8006336688995361,
-0.20250003039836884,
-0.2414393126964569,
-0.5484588742256165,
0.5144429206848145,
0.11358322203159332,
-0.38402342796325684,
0.4867617189884186,
-0.34948983788490295,
0.6325095295906067,
0.3292648196220398,
-0.11213165521621704,
0.4352050721645355,
0.20697808265686035,
-0.2911367416381836,
-0.34181585907936096,
-0.44187942147254944,
-0.27215349674224854,
1.2854373455047607,
0.04324987903237343,
0.8077360987663269,
0.5877076983451843,
0.25012555718421936,
0.12858229875564575,
0.4571867287158966,
-0.8498245477676392,
0.4953383505344391,
-0.27128520607948303,
-0.6798481345176697,
-0.21290193498134613,
-0.6810475587844849,
-1.035435438156128,
0.3234620690345764,
-0.38310176134109497,
-0.4076041281223297,
-0.12324123084545135,
-0.11460430175065994,
-0.22907303273677826,
0.05205293372273445,
-0.5223401784896851,
0.5740940570831299,
-0.14936013519763947,
-0.2752155661582947,
-0.4803633987903595,
-0.08148013800382614,
0.35640788078308105,
-0.5168540477752686,
0.4138413369655609,
-0.3388150930404663,
-0.05433107540011406,
0.6404206156730652,
-0.4651084244251251,
0.6497097611427307,
0.06342162191867828,
-0.5214524269104004,
0.17534257471561432,
0.6993038654327393,
0.4306739866733551,
0.17531707882881165,
-0.4040718078613281,
0.2952054738998413,
-0.025930197909474373,
-0.22488680481910706,
-0.817919909954071,
0.7714444994926453,
-0.9031740427017212,
-0.6432603597640991,
-0.423733115196228,
-0.6720103621482849,
-0.38321396708488464,
0.18515010178089142,
-0.2671712636947632,
0.8346396684646606,
0.0630679652094841,
0.2583252489566803,
0.7764787673950195,
-0.22595539689064026,
0.22758440673351288,
0.5037232637405396,
-0.5855171084403992,
-0.7943856120109558,
0.7728700637817383,
0.2854132354259491,
0.21144869923591614,
0.3726419508457184,
0.2777874171733856,
-0.5619402527809143,
-0.43511760234832764,
-0.5318362712860107,
0.4294044077396393,
-0.7613344192504883,
-0.5618273019790649,
-0.38929659128189087,
-0.14855118095874786,
-0.1201261356472969,
0.006267706397920847,
-0.3279992640018463,
-0.6734942197799683,
-0.3185822069644928,
0.20955020189285278,
0.32912638783454895,
0.7842987775802612,
-0.135817289352417,
0.2158370167016983,
-0.7351601123809814,
0.47616446018218994,
0.5300745368003845,
0.3606058955192566,
0.12388844788074493,
-0.6901643872261047,
-0.17210420966148376,
0.07270827889442444,
-0.2925150692462921,
-0.5896664261817932,
0.30699124932289124,
0.20787647366523743,
0.485932856798172,
0.22542043030261993,
-0.08290494233369827,
0.8672102689743042,
-0.42364823818206787,
0.4676240086555481,
0.28156495094299316,
-1.087831974029541,
0.3053954243659973,
-0.43104287981987,
0.45328786969184875,
0.33599528670310974,
0.27763426303863525,
-0.5071648955345154,
0.04616417735815048,
-0.40137746930122375,
-0.4830780625343323,
0.4755067825317383,
0.39352479577064514,
0.2301599085330963,
0.07745462656021118,
0.35063716769218445,
0.1396786868572235,
0.23508864641189575,
-0.39412716031074524,
-0.12902241945266724,
0.15899376571178436,
-0.16640061140060425,
-0.13686062395572662,
-0.16570216417312622,
-0.14100389182567596,
-0.1831049919128418,
0.521685779094696,
0.015062973834574223,
0.044460587203502655,
-0.25146958231925964,
-0.28125783801078796,
-0.23333528637886047,
-0.031346600502729416,
0.7431877851486206,
1.1457408666610718,
0.02977946028113365,
0.037746280431747437,
0.40457624197006226,
-0.8475358486175537,
0.00865261908620596,
0.24856409430503845,
0.0702737495303154,
0.01189376786351204,
0.426071435213089,
0.45318669080734253,
0.33374786376953125,
-0.9154164791107178,
0.41060006618499756,
-0.08610355108976364,
-0.18837669491767883,
-0.3704513907432556,
0.09334366023540497,
0.010682560503482819,
0.008214707486331463,
0.6287531852722168,
0.06060712784528732,
0.13605305552482605,
-0.06199181079864502,
-0.18439273536205292,
0.3455708920955658,
-0.23626935482025146,
-0.34746524691581726,
0.503539502620697,
0.025197025388479233,
-0.5195754170417786,
0.8513429760932922,
-0.0016129176365211606,
-0.6876237988471985,
0.789454996585846,
0.7210088968276978,
0.492941290140152,
-0.18524156510829926,
-0.025903737172484398,
0.5510814189910889,
0.3569314181804657,
-0.07556548714637756,
0.20400512218475342,
0.16774772107601166,
-0.5710221529006958,
-0.8861261010169983,
-0.6901779174804688,
-0.5694670081138611,
-0.018949264660477638,
-0.7560482025146484,
0.33203163743019104,
-0.5261391997337341,
-0.23430277407169342,
0.16804687678813934,
0.33593782782554626,
-0.768979012966156,
0.2167862206697464,
0.24899893999099731,
0.9287592768669128,
-0.7146303653717041,
0.1119830310344696,
0.8479132056236267,
0.14887607097625732,
-0.8337202668190002,
-0.6473575830459595,
0.3605476915836334,
-1.0189085006713867,
0.7527958154678345,
0.18789751827716827,
-0.10012766718864441,
0.0347445011138916,
-0.4889054298400879,
-0.992340624332428,
0.7395533323287964,
0.6502694487571716,
-0.619052529335022,
0.3408600986003876,
0.3843027651309967,
0.41798704862594604,
-0.11976290494203568,
0.44235554337501526,
0.3366182744503021,
0.4661683738231659,
0.2228192687034607,
-1.3077924251556396,
-0.27461978793144226,
-0.407323956489563,
0.052019838243722916,
0.5317841172218323,
-0.3561069667339325,
0.7953502535820007,
-0.10894525051116943,
-0.028328530490398407,
0.19158601760864258,
0.6323566436767578,
0.7648531198501587,
0.458714097738266,
0.6170573830604553,
0.9519710540771484,
0.8451655507087708,
-0.26739513874053955,
0.7183235883712769,
-0.15219156444072723,
0.4132840037345886,
0.7617674469947815,
-0.09165367484092712,
0.825228750705719,
0.14526867866516113,
-0.5005529522895813,
0.34594035148620605,
0.6303955912590027,
0.02403700351715088,
0.2094917744398117,
0.6330305337905884,
-0.31217995285987854,
-0.6429907083511353,
-0.23722076416015625,
-0.5070868134498596,
0.43987131118774414,
0.6281219720840454,
0.17696185410022736,
-0.42305421829223633,
-0.1456071436405182,
0.05690518021583557,
0.24086390435695648,
-0.7233893871307373,
0.5609839558601379,
0.1122056171298027,
-0.5926879644393921,
0.65961754322052,
-0.022705499082803726,
0.2500123977661133,
-0.5558830499649048,
-0.22706906497478485,
-0.27763044834136963,
0.2987099587917328,
-0.17164629697799683,
-0.6893094182014465,
0.1808125525712967,
0.03566068410873413,
-0.2432337999343872,
0.047627028077840805,
0.34025242924690247,
-0.08923238515853882,
-0.9322154521942139,
-0.11657572537660599,
0.48704665899276733,
0.18306727707386017,
-0.21449849009513855,
-0.7026107907295227,
0.5215646624565125,
-0.15501034259796143,
0.16107676923274994,
0.2287130206823349,
0.6407702565193176,
-0.19014449417591095,
0.9151548147201538,
1.1005592346191406,
-0.10081090778112411,
0.13713470101356506,
0.18722696602344513,
0.9094499945640564,
-0.4579463303089142,
-0.2339220494031906,
-0.7016439437866211,
0.30832070112228394,
0.20752593874931335,
-0.48314011096954346,
0.7828157544136047,
0.858695387840271,
0.705702543258667,
-0.004973432049155235,
0.28754523396492004,
0.2079886496067047,
0.42432114481925964,
-0.44484925270080566,
0.23669646680355072,
-0.34567949175834656,
0.4445987939834595,
-0.32427406311035156,
-1.3498051166534424,
-0.7061938643455505,
0.6058098077774048,
-0.5183698534965515,
-0.06034596636891365,
0.5371116995811462,
0.6166998744010925,
-0.08601147681474686,
0.27003538608551025,
0.24178631603717804,
-0.01927242800593376,
0.13996882736682892,
0.6381694078445435,
1.0844773054122925,
-0.3960351049900055,
0.5855891704559326,
-0.19060605764389038,
-0.22695223987102509,
-0.11060500144958496,
-0.8803672194480896,
-0.9566658735275269,
-0.2710464894771576,
-0.2986208200454712,
-0.41309067606925964,
-0.2951031029224396,
0.9794072508811951,
0.4297734498977661,
-0.7713813781738281,
-0.4236026108264923,
0.12724938988685608,
0.048122674226760864,
-0.1872953325510025,
-0.11472005397081375,
0.389258474111557,
-0.19552375376224518,
-0.7917746901512146,
0.27203500270843506,
0.23999279737472534,
-0.0058477409183979034,
-0.27943509817123413,
0.11079313606023788,
0.3458280861377716,
0.08943589776754379,
0.5814281702041626,
0.09444870054721832,
-0.6962385773658752,
0.14219146966934204,
0.4589024782180786,
0.06813237816095352,
-0.15963877737522125,
0.9334627389907837,
-0.781212329864502,
0.515666127204895,
0.28703540563583374,
1.0396082401275635,
0.44959840178489685,
-0.044794678688049316,
0.4518946409225464,
-0.022837454453110695,
-0.08969376236200333,
0.1500830054283142,
0.2743763327598572,
0.4195753037929535,
-0.14664889872074127,
0.684889554977417,
0.08569839596748352,
-0.5758388042449951,
-1.012890338897705,
-0.04506776109337807,
-0.8307729363441467,
0.05333682894706726,
0.9509118795394897,
0.01648421213030815,
-0.14565931260585785,
0.033595964312553406,
-0.12483740597963333,
-0.2543564736843109,
-0.20695574581623077,
0.8499986529350281,
0.9440897703170776,
0.08720264583826065,
0.05828477814793587,
-0.7584494352340698,
0.07193069905042648,
0.6411533951759338,
-0.6289442181587219,
0.1453239470720291,
0.6356549859046936,
0.08749909698963165,
0.30319494009017944,
0.009139223024249077,
-0.15360522270202637,
0.2517983913421631,
-0.15810519456863403,
-0.23701202869415283,
-0.16627398133277893,
-0.12942148745059967,
-0.3788663446903229,
0.19489814341068268,
0.019809748977422714,
0.37040722370147705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12698v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12698v1
|
Neural Semantic Parsing with Extremely Rich Symbolic Meaning Representations
| 2024-04-19T08:06:01 | 2024-04-19T08:06:01 |
Xiao Zhang, Gosse Bouma, Johan Bos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current open-domain neural semantics parsers show impressive performance.
However, closer inspection of the symbolic meaning representations they produce
reveals significant weaknesses: sometimes they tend to merely copy character
sequences from the source text to form symbolic concepts, defaulting to the
most frequent word sense based in the training distribution. By leveraging the
hierarchical structure of a lexical ontology, we introduce a novel
compositional symbolic representation for concepts based on their position in
the taxonomical hierarchy. This representation provides richer semantic
information and enhances interpretability. We introduce a neural "taxonomical"
semantic parser to utilize this new representation system of predicates, and
compare it with a standard neural semantic parser trained on the traditional
meaning representation format, employing a novel challenge set and evaluation
metric for evaluation. Our experimental findings demonstrate that the
taxonomical model, trained on much richer and complex meaning representations,
is slightly subordinate in performance to the traditional model using the
standard metrics for evaluation, but outperforms it when dealing with
out-of-vocabulary concepts. This finding is encouraging for research in
computational semantics that aims to combine data-driven distributional
meanings with knowledge-based symbolic representations.
|
[
-0.08514661341905594,
-0.20183466374874115,
0.49624350666999817,
0.2718745470046997,
-0.4406988024711609,
0.11062745749950409,
-0.2274673730134964,
-0.5039619207382202,
0.5936236381530762,
0.1769508719444275,
-0.4356478154659271,
-0.4432530105113983,
-0.8255987763404846,
0.07177311927080154,
-0.20118598639965057,
0.79874187707901,
0.23571306467056274,
0.25124698877334595,
-0.23566707968711853,
-0.28579390048980713,
-0.585882842540741,
-0.6461663246154785,
-0.3674556016921997,
-0.5064207911491394,
0.6884522438049316,
-0.33728986978530884,
0.9169923663139343,
1.0176995992660522,
0.7666654586791992,
0.2807592749595642,
-0.2471751868724823,
-0.08079321682453156,
-0.10353000462055206,
0.2369978129863739,
-0.46003270149230957,
-0.649034857749939,
-0.30328482389450073,
-0.14030444622039795,
0.7048822641372681,
1.0879478454589844,
-0.016712363809347153,
-0.13039253652095795,
-0.26328685879707336,
0.19501271843910217,
-0.7064017057418823,
0.589043378829956,
-0.8178105354309082,
0.17564234137535095,
-0.2562844157218933,
-0.3899689316749573,
-0.37988153100013733,
-0.023129234090447426,
0.24667222797870636,
-0.8029240965843201,
-0.3236987292766571,
-0.03512275218963623,
0.7452519536018372,
0.473191499710083,
-0.21910887956619263,
-0.150748148560524,
-0.29228371381759644,
0.6768101453781128,
-0.4494791030883789,
0.49218130111694336,
0.04951164871454239,
0.46966126561164856,
0.10686925798654556,
-0.8632145524024963,
-0.5014047026634216,
-0.3927319049835205,
-0.07214540243148804,
0.1951466053724289,
-0.3686206042766571,
-0.06513527035713196,
-0.1013682559132576,
0.20338834822177887,
-0.3995996117591858,
-0.11549848318099976,
0.2113908976316452,
-0.08526405692100525,
0.38887450098991394,
0.2713155746459961,
0.4439312815666199,
-0.39453357458114624,
-0.5539591908454895,
-0.4617457389831543,
-0.48853379487991333,
-0.3121159076690674,
0.03592003509402275,
0.5403614044189453,
0.16522575914859772,
0.5997685790061951,
-0.04554958641529083,
0.5629011392593384,
-0.4286852180957794,
0.2940625548362732,
0.3201020658016205,
-0.10502834618091583,
-0.17521068453788757,
0.26878926157951355,
0.4708895683288574,
0.13234038650989532,
0.24162866175174713,
-0.45055127143859863,
-0.27174729108810425,
0.4911051392555237,
0.29180771112442017,
-0.5478824377059937,
-0.320200651884079,
-0.10556437075138092,
-0.4787735939025879,
-0.23911887407302856,
0.18319131433963776,
-0.23588037490844727,
-0.4233505129814148,
-0.5301434397697449,
0.3284105062484741,
-0.6152496337890625,
-0.26007306575775146,
0.43570512533187866,
-0.5804834365844727,
0.07457728683948517,
0.22960630059242249,
-1.0245494842529297,
0.4535387456417084,
0.7658655047416687,
0.7832882404327393,
-0.05712185800075531,
-0.25459471344947815,
-0.18637493252754211,
0.3930806517601013,
-0.3820350468158722,
0.8408225178718567,
-0.7452023029327393,
0.026674699038267136,
-0.43067216873168945,
-0.29180973768234253,
-0.169554203748703,
-0.7954843044281006,
0.26440495252609253,
-0.7591070532798767,
-0.5050534605979919,
-0.27201998233795166,
-0.6184335947036743,
-0.0475698858499527,
0.31025439500808716,
-0.6553674936294556,
0.6604383587837219,
0.2912091910839081,
-0.679678201675415,
0.2782289981842041,
-0.5742471218109131,
-0.2586948275566101,
0.44769492745399475,
-0.4053855538368225,
0.41934823989868164,
0.22906848788261414,
-0.21439267694950104,
0.4019525349140167,
-0.367744117975235,
0.23932895064353943,
-0.20576095581054688,
0.026143373921513557,
0.27490782737731934,
-0.1199035495519638,
0.7912263870239258,
0.16494649648666382,
-0.28949177265167236,
0.21341051161289215,
-0.6501126289367676,
0.08765460550785065,
0.43099886178970337,
0.07522059977054596,
-0.8741274476051331,
0.05061321333050728,
-0.0956023558974266,
0.2593032717704773,
0.22870773077011108,
-0.5437606573104858,
0.004513926804065704,
-0.7181586027145386,
0.5928374528884888,
0.717424750328064,
-0.34940049052238464,
0.5249448418617249,
-0.20803038775920868,
0.18643540143966675,
0.31202229857444763,
-0.11604589223861694,
0.022420793771743774,
-0.4352649748325348,
-0.5884016156196594,
-0.1274186223745346,
0.44492170214653015,
0.3689229488372803,
-0.5672351717948914,
0.7359042167663574,
-0.6047777533531189,
-0.29139208793640137,
-0.30968043208122253,
-0.15771126747131348,
0.26210129261016846,
0.34575164318084717,
0.39410683512687683,
-0.40195661783218384,
-0.3886619210243225,
-0.772075355052948,
-0.19491523504257202,
-0.22873364388942719,
0.06504863500595093,
0.004539718385785818,
0.6612717509269714,
-0.1692819893360138,
0.870285153388977,
-0.6787563562393188,
-0.462146520614624,
-0.1310247927904129,
0.016453465446829796,
-0.09573055803775787,
0.36039218306541443,
0.3045210540294647,
-0.7419915199279785,
0.09193365275859833,
0.19960778951644897,
-0.8964877128601074,
0.10940920561552048,
-0.07458628714084625,
-0.38920024037361145,
-0.2025386095046997,
0.37813639640808105,
-0.7245970964431763,
0.18782640993595123,
0.15176483988761902,
-0.5643528699874878,
0.330726683139801,
-0.014882474206387997,
-0.376577764749527,
-0.9433122873306274,
-0.028851017355918884,
-0.3362439274787903,
-0.042097315192222595,
-0.200060173869133,
0.5332606434822083,
0.10802431404590607,
0.1463828980922699,
-0.47138530015945435,
0.5453142523765564,
-0.12876848876476288,
-0.06643615663051605,
-0.023367781192064285,
0.13284236192703247,
0.14538748562335968,
0.38821491599082947,
0.4024285078048706,
0.1138743981719017,
0.42844438552856445,
-0.3484543561935425,
0.7167882323265076,
0.4753638505935669,
-0.15720310807228088,
0.43305298686027527,
-0.8004019260406494,
-0.4421467185020447,
-0.20731019973754883,
0.2882814109325409,
-0.7588760256767273,
-0.18583878874778748,
0.20026901364326477,
-0.5087952017784119,
0.19651485979557037,
0.17433792352676392,
-0.7410025596618652,
0.06628173589706421,
-0.18588262796401978,
0.5912790298461914,
0.41309854388237,
-0.5281959176063538,
0.532061755657196,
0.2801043391227722,
0.008199495263397694,
-0.2557666599750519,
-1.0131442546844482,
0.21122674643993378,
-0.07070252299308777,
-0.7388808131217957,
0.7068997025489807,
0.49322840571403503,
-0.2876083552837372,
0.2812228798866272,
-0.20220182836055756,
-0.045768193900585175,
0.13681155443191528,
-0.03191361203789711,
0.17157918214797974,
-0.49960026144981384,
0.5626869201660156,
0.044669270515441895,
-0.25774887204170227,
0.401324599981308,
-0.6279268264770508,
0.6445421576499939,
-0.07979004830121994,
-0.34099864959716797,
-0.2908138632774353,
0.44664621353149414,
0.37461596727371216,
-0.41503867506980896,
0.8385042548179626,
0.03157718479633331,
-0.5950584411621094,
-0.31756138801574707,
0.1551045924425125,
-0.3195735812187195,
-0.36845701932907104,
0.36388686299324036,
-0.4070234000682831,
-0.6432931423187256,
0.5307902097702026,
-0.06490214914083481,
-0.2493790239095688,
0.6968270540237427,
0.2858221232891083,
-0.07680392265319824,
1.0049629211425781,
0.12155832350254059,
0.2698005139827728,
0.03763497620820999,
-0.36963000893592834,
0.12603825330734253,
-0.616205632686615,
-0.5501859784126282,
-0.5713359713554382,
-0.2774007320404053,
-0.3729686439037323,
-0.4249001145362854,
0.10173550248146057,
-0.0013228869065642357,
-0.42999207973480225,
0.27619239687919617,
-0.44082725048065186,
0.3776538074016571,
0.4345643222332001,
0.05791814252734184,
0.27363577485084534,
0.02665267325937748,
-0.3005073666572571,
0.04092485457658768,
-0.6138823628425598,
-0.5627345442771912,
0.6745975613594055,
0.3393712639808655,
0.7664089798927307,
0.1851479411125183,
0.5298715233802795,
0.04092549532651901,
0.05713939294219017,
-1.119494915008545,
0.5285738706588745,
-0.5087984800338745,
-0.3542524576187134,
-0.04294608533382416,
-0.5363311767578125,
-0.851786196231842,
0.47220131754875183,
-0.10587897151708603,
-0.5872982740402222,
0.16900600492954254,
-0.08717761188745499,
-0.26612886786460876,
0.2931865155696869,
-0.5081744194030762,
1.03171706199646,
-0.15996727347373962,
0.2006387710571289,
0.028064081445336342,
-0.9069802761077881,
0.16363295912742615,
0.07741676270961761,
-0.2501562237739563,
-0.1359935998916626,
-0.26784831285476685,
0.6119458079338074,
-0.5599712133407593,
0.7788262367248535,
-0.06957388669252396,
-0.11854788661003113,
0.01961440220475197,
0.09045560657978058,
0.10005732625722885,
-0.164735347032547,
0.05767752602696419,
0.3733513057231903,
0.1303100436925888,
-0.40386736392974854,
-1.0260560512542725,
0.5605752468109131,
-0.8481968641281128,
-0.3416352868080139,
-0.5702288150787354,
-0.6982948780059814,
-0.3777942359447479,
0.15153323113918304,
0.25812721252441406,
0.522800624370575,
-0.01797764003276825,
0.22288642823696136,
0.5292232632637024,
-0.043331801891326904,
0.10526643693447113,
-0.3063780665397644,
-0.1398496925830841,
-0.21459178626537323,
1.0073202848434448,
0.027268651872873306,
0.348321795463562,
0.7583316564559937,
0.32325127720832825,
-0.6337451934814453,
-0.3672983646392822,
-0.4747715890407562,
0.023968445137143135,
-0.9847704172134399,
-0.27991777658462524,
-0.7853102087974548,
-0.23875692486763,
-0.38651350140571594,
0.020356889814138412,
-0.18189206719398499,
-0.8428612351417542,
-0.16195321083068848,
0.11833580583333969,
0.21680761873722076,
0.6160270571708679,
0.22689589858055115,
0.4799734950065613,
-0.8359406590461731,
0.32135728001594543,
0.255876362323761,
0.41222962737083435,
0.25809550285339355,
-0.30253562331199646,
0.05438460409641266,
0.09095662832260132,
-0.32739686965942383,
-0.7580085396766663,
0.3628765642642975,
0.32794123888015747,
0.5387816429138184,
0.4004043638706207,
-0.10039560496807098,
0.688897967338562,
-0.44068169593811035,
0.6738505959510803,
0.32514137029647827,
-0.9492026567459106,
0.5382949113845825,
-0.2543417513370514,
0.33376967906951904,
0.38691461086273193,
0.48549243807792664,
-0.4947315454483032,
-0.256539523601532,
-0.5718045830726624,
-0.7335514426231384,
0.6530089974403381,
0.2863158881664276,
0.5023983716964722,
-0.4258362352848053,
0.17340083420276642,
0.06120683625340462,
-0.02759692259132862,
-0.5558525323867798,
-0.2834758460521698,
-0.6138586401939392,
-0.43572935461997986,
0.003900044597685337,
0.02100181020796299,
-0.10449876636266708,
-0.40252166986465454,
0.36093172430992126,
-0.13754573464393616,
0.37179839611053467,
-0.056333187967538834,
-0.2153870314359665,
0.296056866645813,
0.11284548044204712,
0.09533079713582993,
0.39549165964126587,
0.014081310480833054,
0.7511299252510071,
-0.16836363077163696,
-0.33426836133003235,
0.09787587076425552,
0.22799842059612274,
0.10182905942201614,
0.03621242940425873,
0.5995057225227356,
0.7204331159591675,
0.3380405902862549,
-0.730118989944458,
0.564676821231842,
0.08671407401561737,
-0.046230074018239975,
0.017934631556272507,
-0.11668112874031067,
0.5113458633422852,
0.07651244103908539,
0.09179627895355225,
0.30183330178260803,
0.22713401913642883,
-0.6063305139541626,
0.13914690911769867,
0.34101855754852295,
-0.3289687931537628,
-0.37039050459861755,
0.3795965611934662,
-0.1442282795906067,
0.22193118929862976,
0.5645706653594971,
-0.2766631841659546,
-0.5301840305328369,
0.6312937140464783,
0.7763674855232239,
0.6799165606498718,
-0.1268240511417389,
0.24317269027233124,
-0.1123143881559372,
0.034726351499557495,
0.08767189830541611,
0.4486250877380371,
-0.1843455731868744,
-0.9563996195793152,
-0.34797701239585876,
-1.0292563438415527,
-0.09964622557163239,
-0.2723538875579834,
-0.6101679801940918,
-0.09259911626577377,
-0.5677341222763062,
0.04273797571659088,
0.4551892578601837,
-0.5710767507553101,
-0.3211331069469452,
0.32223325967788696,
0.17060916125774384,
0.9444475173950195,
-0.6093757748603821,
0.6163569092750549,
1.0643267631530762,
-0.5522940158843994,
-0.9861143231391907,
-0.1861020028591156,
-0.262311726808548,
-0.7715199589729309,
1.2947331666946411,
0.13981764018535614,
-0.0877479612827301,
-0.034393321722745895,
-0.16994546353816986,
-0.7860626578330994,
0.6867088675498962,
0.6989474892616272,
-0.21827031672000885,
-0.23362140357494354,
0.5605895519256592,
0.7356567978858948,
-0.4479100704193115,
0.13054054975509644,
0.6007871627807617,
0.38814571499824524,
0.46339839696884155,
-0.5040362477302551,
0.27818387746810913,
-0.45453080534935,
0.3062383830547333,
0.30104830861091614,
-0.12782782316207886,
0.8446337580680847,
0.3123377859592438,
-0.3259817063808441,
0.08712058514356613,
0.6529009938240051,
0.22716499865055084,
0.051522284746170044,
0.30297350883483887,
0.84581059217453,
0.5908078551292419,
-0.20304763317108154,
1.2031257152557373,
-0.08812505006790161,
0.0867355689406395,
1.132027268409729,
-0.2131655365228653,
0.8545883297920227,
0.4747340679168701,
-0.04894653335213661,
0.581159234046936,
0.6413571238517761,
0.21713374555110931,
0.6106268167495728,
0.5964970588684082,
-0.34078332781791687,
-0.46576714515686035,
-0.5339527726173401,
-0.32041892409324646,
0.775506854057312,
0.39297664165496826,
-0.51823890209198,
-0.7146039009094238,
-0.028408247977495193,
-0.3444860875606537,
0.21053709089756012,
-0.36212247610092163,
0.8210931420326233,
0.2711118161678314,
-0.39253169298171997,
0.7171247601509094,
-0.03635239228606224,
0.43705111742019653,
-0.7004417777061462,
-0.24833877384662628,
0.2559228539466858,
0.18553198873996735,
-0.27118170261383057,
-0.699613630771637,
0.6525151133537292,
-0.31697535514831543,
-0.045966535806655884,
-0.3087252974510193,
0.6681069135665894,
-0.08778675645589828,
-0.2256397306919098,
0.6212925910949707,
0.4734719693660736,
0.1257631927728653,
-0.4073306620121002,
-0.48080897331237793,
0.005130788777023554,
-0.6047362685203552,
-0.02279014140367508,
0.18313448131084442,
0.6734535694122314,
-0.34500250220298767,
0.3173620104789734,
0.42127639055252075,
0.2319718599319458,
0.23922297358512878,
0.46829792857170105,
1.0380922555923462,
-0.8837252855300903,
-0.6950252056121826,
-0.8769609332084656,
0.19352222979068756,
0.15251822769641876,
-0.4404129683971405,
0.3756827116012573,
0.2011111080646515,
1.047061800956726,
-0.16571779549121857,
0.5842536091804504,
-0.04594101384282112,
-0.21024490892887115,
-0.42073243856430054,
0.7393800020217896,
-0.574200451374054,
0.01345757581293583,
-0.24363838136196136,
-1.0140128135681152,
-0.7390326857566833,
0.6776020526885986,
-0.1405218541622162,
-0.060639675706624985,
0.9110218286514282,
0.3762626051902771,
-0.13332368433475494,
0.4936303198337555,
0.42692363262176514,
0.11623977869749069,
-0.09606340527534485,
0.6140664219856262,
1.3835512399673462,
-0.11153235286474228,
0.13171562552452087,
-0.1902468502521515,
-0.1823664903640747,
0.08713752031326294,
-0.721785843372345,
-0.5788864493370056,
-0.6524933576583862,
-0.014674106612801552,
-0.19107450544834137,
0.06717468798160553,
1.061026930809021,
0.7057726979255676,
-0.594399094581604,
-0.03948798030614853,
-0.3177341818809509,
-0.17748163640499115,
-0.259067565202713,
-0.20469892024993896,
0.365701824426651,
-0.7176827788352966,
-0.30571436882019043,
0.17432671785354614,
0.3123873472213745,
-0.055804964154958725,
-0.11474908143281937,
-0.010626406408846378,
-0.04379644617438316,
0.09724821895360947,
0.9486231803894043,
-0.23219464719295502,
-0.5827037692070007,
-0.2767931818962097,
0.06404130905866623,
-0.1518530547618866,
0.1270700991153717,
0.8234338760375977,
-0.7377669811248779,
0.15548303723335266,
0.6694532632827759,
1.1074979305267334,
0.006373537704348564,
-0.23354102671146393,
0.19337986409664154,
-0.6211043000221252,
-0.14721344411373138,
0.6446402072906494,
0.4756939709186554,
0.24291998147964478,
-0.2970166504383087,
0.2665002942085266,
0.4724564850330353,
0.24248848855495453,
-0.48443281650543213,
0.42458608746528625,
-1.2872228622436523,
-0.548711895942688,
0.9375370144844055,
-0.2875889241695404,
-0.39533355832099915,
0.0011547448812052608,
0.019653448835015297,
0.1990841180086136,
-0.2441217601299286,
0.44406744837760925,
0.626772940158844,
-0.1704174429178238,
0.21677441895008087,
-0.03095931187272072,
0.17261113226413727,
0.6717512011528015,
-0.8948286175727844,
0.10049337148666382,
0.489755243062973,
0.04470347613096237,
0.5104458928108215,
0.21454469859600067,
-0.49794629216194153,
0.343344122171402,
0.09530746191740036,
0.04677893593907356,
-0.016418006271123886,
-0.4320167303085327,
-0.46949854493141174,
0.3480929136276245,
0.0025769437197595835,
-0.04891905188560486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12670v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12670v1
|
Towards Human-centered Proactive Conversational Agents
| 2024-04-19T07:14:31 | 2024-04-19T07:14:31 |
Yang Deng, Lizi Liao, Zhonghua Zheng, Grace Hui Yang, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Recent research on proactive conversational agents (PCAs) mainly focuses on
improving the system's capabilities in anticipating and planning action
sequences to accomplish tasks and achieve goals before users articulate their
requests. This perspectives paper highlights the importance of moving towards
building human-centered PCAs that emphasize human needs and expectations, and
that considers ethical and social implications of these agents, rather than
solely focusing on technological capabilities. The distinction between a
proactive and a reactive system lies in the proactive system's
initiative-taking nature. Without thoughtful design, proactive systems risk
being perceived as intrusive by human users. We address the issue by
establishing a new taxonomy concerning three key dimensions of human-centered
PCAs, namely Intelligence, Adaptivity, and Civility. We discuss potential
research opportunities and challenges based on this new taxonomy upon the five
stages of PCA system construction. This perspectives paper lays a foundation
for the emerging area of conversational information retrieval research and
paves the way towards advancing human-centered proactive conversational
systems.
|
[
-0.5317696928977966,
-0.7194226980209351,
0.6415232419967651,
0.3940892219543457,
-0.026934044435620308,
0.4058884382247925,
-0.07592899352312088,
-0.6719781160354614,
0.30209535360336304,
0.298215389251709,
-0.37107983231544495,
0.15347276628017426,
-0.1694442480802536,
-0.18185606598854065,
0.12497652322053909,
0.6476230621337891,
0.5214788317680359,
-0.11862020194530487,
-0.06401277333498001,
0.05466947332024574,
-0.775816023349762,
-0.7284683585166931,
-0.6383674144744873,
-0.4750517010688782,
0.48022663593292236,
0.516301155090332,
1.119857907295227,
0.19156095385551453,
0.6413678526878357,
0.31911924481391907,
0.12978670001029968,
0.011477124877274036,
-0.13931968808174133,
0.1701802909374237,
-0.17897021770477295,
-0.46890661120414734,
-0.8401628732681274,
0.21102800965309143,
0.2543974220752716,
0.6198697686195374,
-0.29838407039642334,
0.10175842046737671,
0.023569636046886444,
0.6261099576950073,
-0.49532249569892883,
0.36426398158073425,
-0.232066810131073,
0.005913314875215292,
-0.074878990650177,
-0.3271346688270569,
-0.31724807620048523,
-0.43308383226394653,
0.41176626086235046,
-0.7436961531639099,
-0.04578324779868126,
-0.3569463789463043,
0.4067409038543701,
-0.13209711015224457,
-0.36304137110710144,
-0.13719035685062408,
-1.0847994089126587,
0.5559531450271606,
-0.3999902009963989,
0.2309216856956482,
0.3324325382709503,
0.3689609467983246,
-0.4675694406032562,
-0.673477828502655,
-0.6097716093063354,
-0.07251887768507004,
0.1480831652879715,
-0.03232155740261078,
-0.4906068444252014,
0.08498712629079819,
-0.1401115506887436,
0.03702162951231003,
-0.23814962804317474,
-0.0027268726844340563,
-0.30265331268310547,
-0.15035687386989594,
0.5728147625923157,
0.08559205383062363,
0.277717262506485,
0.14556154608726501,
-0.1054016575217247,
0.01644221879541874,
-0.39935770630836487,
0.4316765367984772,
0.32248008251190186,
0.5392577052116394,
0.15122543275356293,
0.18794891238212585,
-0.22294344007968903,
0.3280057907104492,
0.18068504333496094,
-0.18342572450637817,
0.20950521528720856,
-0.20762766897678375,
-0.16930550336837769,
-0.02005786821246147,
0.4490405321121216,
0.16231921315193176,
0.5133282542228699,
-0.15442314743995667,
0.2077113687992096,
0.18656517565250397,
0.8677095174789429,
-0.6908763647079468,
-0.17678840458393097,
0.24661363661289215,
-0.71593177318573,
-0.36696717143058777,
0.3742179870605469,
-0.44970470666885376,
-0.35402435064315796,
-0.7186969518661499,
0.1325664073228836,
-0.124191515147686,
-0.5049393177032471,
0.055917732417583466,
0.31627753376960754,
0.41993653774261475,
0.38061779737472534,
-0.6024051904678345,
0.6021270155906677,
0.748581051826477,
0.38600340485572815,
0.20341812074184418,
-0.0090414984151721,
-0.32433706521987915,
0.03798731788992882,
-0.31099221110343933,
0.7985426187515259,
-0.814892053604126,
-0.5952482223510742,
-0.129254549741745,
0.04713951051235199,
0.12775824964046478,
-0.6644881963729858,
0.6501549482345581,
-0.5275015830993652,
0.3088439106941223,
-0.6092128157615662,
0.04243836551904678,
-0.345174103975296,
0.3602546453475952,
-0.1267462819814682,
0.392757385969162,
0.06033950299024582,
-0.3034842312335968,
0.12776058912277222,
-0.6970348358154297,
-0.48698124289512634,
0.45808035135269165,
-0.23308898508548737,
-0.10259323567152023,
0.11105131357908249,
-0.24765416979789734,
0.2992914915084839,
-0.24395489692687988,
0.39725762605667114,
-0.1921497881412506,
-0.22267061471939087,
0.5178282856941223,
-0.09061400592327118,
0.8033193349838257,
0.34840789437294006,
-0.4520023465156555,
0.1292194128036499,
-0.589033305644989,
0.1761588752269745,
-0.19546698033809662,
-0.39878860116004944,
-0.01851709745824337,
0.6228886842727661,
0.047861482948064804,
0.36220523715019226,
0.35789746046066284,
-0.46834316849708557,
-0.08548837900161743,
-0.11652258038520813,
0.35563918948173523,
0.882658839225769,
-0.11588926613330841,
0.5275924801826477,
-0.4325069487094879,
0.6074342131614685,
-0.03537646681070328,
0.8146076202392578,
0.07624279707670212,
-0.8184554576873779,
-0.3513261377811432,
-0.22504638135433197,
-0.547590970993042,
0.7119137644767761,
-0.390060693025589,
0.6355642676353455,
-0.05434923619031906,
-0.6174774765968323,
-0.181245818734169,
0.0011400821385905147,
0.40467384457588196,
0.3653429448604584,
0.06784538924694061,
-0.9881172776222229,
-0.4851400852203369,
-0.7314196825027466,
-0.11281485855579376,
-0.8253994584083557,
0.015142817050218582,
0.36009079217910767,
0.052645307034254074,
-0.2806943655014038,
1.0024991035461426,
-0.26870089769363403,
-0.6316462755203247,
-0.2763057351112366,
0.012223154306411743,
0.13004037737846375,
0.3859141170978546,
0.3964807689189911,
-1.0837923288345337,
-0.539479672908783,
0.209286168217659,
-0.6266549229621887,
0.029825624078512192,
0.190122589468956,
0.06605342030525208,
-0.1702047884464264,
0.26687729358673096,
-0.8172110319137573,
0.4974389970302582,
-0.1298750638961792,
-0.6174744963645935,
0.36501577496528625,
-0.11009620875120163,
-0.0017508049495518208,
-0.8270348310470581,
0.2675589919090271,
-0.18033024668693542,
-0.1325737088918686,
-1.181935429573059,
-0.1953653246164322,
-0.43102362751960754,
-0.15601873397827148,
-0.3342776596546173,
0.2759411036968231,
-0.23454974591732025,
-0.3650452494621277,
-0.4372890293598175,
0.19560854136943817,
-0.10975565016269684,
0.44904187321662903,
-0.14415380358695984,
0.6427527070045471,
0.16097848117351532,
-0.8368159532546997,
0.2584797143936157,
0.425326943397522,
0.0270883496850729,
1.0269479751586914,
-0.6078943610191345,
0.18596972525119781,
-0.20484739542007446,
0.37964507937431335,
-0.369314044713974,
-0.08144103735685349,
0.46291249990463257,
-0.752949595451355,
-0.12000113725662231,
0.47520506381988525,
-0.31282690167427063,
-0.37485355138778687,
-0.1721707135438919,
0.27666500210762024,
0.34934693574905396,
0.0906120240688324,
0.7387829422950745,
0.7517637610435486,
-0.41956987977027893,
-0.3701813519001007,
-0.27188754081726074,
0.34880200028419495,
-0.007244565058499575,
-0.4628908932209015,
0.5642871260643005,
-0.043072350323200226,
-0.7027254104614258,
-0.2417634278535843,
0.26320716738700867,
0.045835599303245544,
0.39825886487960815,
0.24535439908504486,
0.0966741293668747,
0.05133422464132309,
0.050489429384469986,
-0.7913098931312561,
-0.1302480846643448,
0.2452680468559265,
-0.2663787305355072,
0.5336340665817261,
-0.5653631687164307,
-0.15729372203350067,
-0.924432098865509,
0.47139203548431396,
0.5217362642288208,
-0.45623019337654114,
0.38338714838027954,
0.7383943200111389,
-0.34508174657821655,
0.5963855981826782,
-0.5714066624641418,
-0.34593677520751953,
-0.4000058174133301,
0.18078742921352386,
-0.13185957074165344,
-0.7471616268157959,
0.7738109230995178,
0.1703687310218811,
0.06477684527635574,
0.10630887746810913,
0.5745450854301453,
-0.31527361273765564,
1.264378547668457,
0.9907498359680176,
-0.015892978757619858,
0.8352632522583008,
0.11072063446044922,
0.5851637125015259,
-0.6656151413917542,
-0.5451453924179077,
-0.7178007364273071,
-0.3920254707336426,
-0.7183519601821899,
-0.2116524577140808,
0.24979688227176666,
-0.3322671949863434,
-0.48100966215133667,
0.08433546870946884,
-0.5549913644790649,
0.051418840885162354,
0.5271828770637512,
0.17589077353477478,
0.21528179943561554,
-0.21047133207321167,
0.4808620810508728,
0.05405966565012932,
-0.23095832765102386,
-0.8375771641731262,
0.6638360023498535,
0.5347775816917419,
0.28092026710510254,
0.5810710191726685,
0.06924735009670258,
0.46929365396499634,
0.43786343932151794,
-0.723764181137085,
0.7136109471321106,
0.08071020245552063,
-0.7914100885391235,
-0.25903382897377014,
-0.018867669627070427,
-1.076249599456787,
0.09114420413970947,
0.08140335977077484,
-0.9991647601127625,
0.8316482305526733,
-0.024972977116703987,
-0.5435944199562073,
0.10621397197246552,
-0.6645271182060242,
0.6274571418762207,
-0.18384741246700287,
-0.4275895655155182,
-0.4191180467605591,
-0.8731884956359863,
-0.040520623326301575,
0.35244065523147583,
0.19655688107013702,
-0.2938888967037201,
0.07683974504470825,
0.3973185420036316,
-0.13542771339416504,
1.0929014682769775,
-0.6938512921333313,
-0.012406911700963974,
0.6080547571182251,
0.07631759345531464,
0.4002947211265564,
-0.1875305026769638,
0.18506500124931335,
-0.5246841311454773,
-0.08293374627828598,
-0.6800180077552795,
-0.4168418347835541,
0.16194620728492737,
-0.9670583605766296,
-0.7339372634887695,
-0.3169727921485901,
-0.36454570293426514,
-0.43285608291625977,
0.3161635398864746,
-0.31578826904296875,
0.1685110181570053,
-0.6716108918190002,
0.4000449478626251,
0.885304868221283,
-0.13096851110458374,
0.3845250606536865,
0.622370183467865,
-0.016061587259173393,
-0.10066830366849899,
0.8530739545822144,
-0.0069313268177211285,
0.18035966157913208,
0.4467880427837372,
0.03750031441450119,
-0.03779711574316025,
-0.3663717806339264,
0.2928912341594696,
-0.08009705692529678,
-0.3656214475631714,
-0.03972221538424492,
-0.602735698223114,
0.0018834054935723543,
-0.7520692348480225,
-0.1278991997241974,
-0.27481937408447266,
-0.18204952776432037,
-0.8863092660903931,
0.06857813149690628,
-0.060864951461553574,
0.500883162021637,
0.040695738047361374,
0.5747965574264526,
-0.5484999418258667,
0.20424191653728485,
0.71402907371521,
0.1567007154226303,
-0.00997388456016779,
-0.3525724709033966,
-0.011130232363939285,
-0.10494032502174377,
-0.9959369897842407,
-0.6240439414978027,
0.4279807209968567,
0.15694347023963928,
0.8365816473960876,
0.7710155248641968,
-0.024418577551841736,
0.4028748571872711,
-0.0514729805290699,
0.5965622663497925,
0.1344400942325592,
-0.5741046667098999,
0.6691321134567261,
-0.49203726649284363,
0.1946285516023636,
0.7078664302825928,
0.17483492195606232,
-0.6392064690589905,
0.1291758269071579,
-0.7445986866950989,
-0.5318573713302612,
0.6044872403144836,
0.11840268969535828,
0.33946552872657776,
-0.1071707233786583,
0.25015661120414734,
-0.23141860961914062,
0.15850147604942322,
-0.45356515049934387,
0.29056647419929504,
-0.4489326775074005,
-0.02844717726111412,
-0.10902433842420578,
-0.21533501148223877,
-0.08372233062982559,
0.052614446729421616,
0.5516294836997986,
-0.4905775487422943,
0.500353217124939,
0.3690864145755768,
0.15710194408893585,
0.04668821394443512,
0.6864880919456482,
0.503345251083374,
0.7822064161300659,
-0.3544461727142334,
0.11843790113925934,
-0.29286351799964905,
-0.5965849757194519,
0.34763601422309875,
-0.07344014942646027,
0.1339915543794632,
-0.6509189009666443,
-0.0659051463007927,
0.33999359607696533,
0.030553266406059265,
-0.7160733342170715,
0.6687083840370178,
-0.21011567115783691,
-0.024515947327017784,
-0.5150793790817261,
0.07098743319511414,
-0.09294503182172775,
0.3645085096359253,
0.5626436471939087,
0.23803430795669556,
0.14568577706813812,
-1.0279643535614014,
-0.03183862566947937,
0.35834792256355286,
-0.8217639327049255,
-0.8251001834869385,
0.38687315583229065,
0.5423219799995422,
-0.75811368227005,
0.5621781945228577,
-0.2849273383617401,
-0.30242082476615906,
0.4608002007007599,
0.31833401322364807,
1.1096407175064087,
-0.540861964225769,
0.4279576539993286,
-0.26419344544410706,
0.39249637722969055,
0.15491224825382233,
0.5939081907272339,
-0.22301872074604034,
-0.9240745902061462,
0.03546714037656784,
-0.12675660848617554,
-0.3903287351131439,
-0.30823391675949097,
-0.6707370281219482,
-0.09428862482309341,
-0.6566635966300964,
-0.7574408054351807,
-0.052442848682403564,
0.27338317036628723,
-0.6084694862365723,
-0.01289328932762146,
-0.047388702630996704,
0.7961791753768921,
-0.4966316521167755,
0.6369350552558899,
0.8743947744369507,
-0.2783054709434509,
-0.3675890564918518,
-0.2718944549560547,
0.01442724373191595,
-0.448420912027359,
0.5746411085128784,
0.01690106838941574,
-0.1855664700269699,
-0.12877772748470306,
-0.3528880178928375,
-0.5079917311668396,
1.3421496152877808,
0.264366090297699,
-0.10018026828765869,
-0.16940294206142426,
0.07467290014028549,
0.923615574836731,
-0.563887894153595,
0.047129951417446136,
0.8096416592597961,
0.45936328172683716,
-0.17170998454093933,
-0.9475443363189697,
-0.12988467514514923,
-0.5309954285621643,
0.2198641151189804,
-0.25954052805900574,
-0.9552618861198425,
0.6855111718177795,
-0.25833383202552795,
-0.18954379856586456,
0.03189610317349434,
0.6890503168106079,
0.1876731961965561,
0.4146040678024292,
0.45006877183914185,
0.23930972814559937,
0.5943301320075989,
0.008529996499419212,
0.7881622314453125,
0.010810788720846176,
-0.4019124209880829,
0.7722019553184509,
-0.5248810052871704,
0.6320021748542786,
0.5153153538703918,
-0.4306231141090393,
0.6282630562782288,
0.5700159668922424,
0.4404064416885376,
0.2294335961341858,
-0.11032399535179138,
-0.6584812998771667,
-0.295160710811615,
-0.7020204663276672,
-0.09311836957931519,
0.8737869262695312,
0.6555677652359009,
-0.06568223983049393,
0.17090412974357605,
0.02865423820912838,
0.01935863494873047,
0.38497498631477356,
-0.14243397116661072,
1.059958577156067,
-0.0580231212079525,
-0.8728205561637878,
-0.1328665018081665,
-0.09054719656705856,
0.34608104825019836,
-0.24249428510665894,
0.19710738956928253,
-0.05538661405444145,
0.3167720139026642,
-0.15510326623916626,
-0.5547227263450623,
0.26728975772857666,
-0.33500006794929504,
-0.31859585642814636,
-0.3919106721878052,
0.8699207901954651,
0.27157068252563477,
-0.0752839595079422,
0.23620331287384033,
0.5300692915916443,
0.17830948531627655,
-0.1889430284500122,
-0.7356933355331421,
-0.09859457612037659,
-0.15306466817855835,
-0.12128322571516037,
0.29284411668777466,
0.2590577304363251,
-0.2869766056537628,
0.8723147511482239,
0.5450392365455627,
0.0809490755200386,
-0.2475176304578781,
0.13157682120800018,
0.8156939744949341,
-0.48968982696533203,
-0.5501298904418945,
-0.3233955502510071,
0.29035818576812744,
0.09730575233697891,
-0.13508738577365875,
0.25722500681877136,
0.23836272954940796,
0.5313153862953186,
0.2871359586715698,
0.7239604592323303,
-0.28830966353416443,
0.4617568850517273,
0.29392364621162415,
0.21966153383255005,
0.11681761592626572,
0.24670347571372986,
-0.233414888381958,
-0.7952054142951965,
-0.23612946271896362,
0.460997998714447,
-0.15961824357509613,
0.1871790736913681,
0.02619657665491104,
0.7260668873786926,
0.24258355796337128,
0.2780507802963257,
0.04611175134778023,
0.009875291027128696,
0.9709034562110901,
0.34902891516685486,
0.8682985305786133,
-0.11984573304653168,
0.3685404658317566,
-0.07408512383699417,
-0.5047476887702942,
-0.4670320153236389,
-0.4853527247905731,
-0.4004721939563751,
-0.6065771579742432,
-0.0331617146730423,
-0.015233955346047878,
-0.061592135578393936,
0.8348703384399414,
0.8598693609237671,
-0.6184099316596985,
-0.38858315348625183,
-0.32885533571243286,
0.1296357959508896,
-0.36895468831062317,
-0.31963592767715454,
-0.07045915722846985,
-0.5324797034263611,
-0.43106064200401306,
0.1773688644170761,
0.5379834771156311,
0.12465567886829376,
-0.5170096158981323,
-0.09240224212408066,
-0.3375265896320343,
0.1375952512025833,
0.9117844104766846,
0.8276001214981079,
-0.530243992805481,
-0.4418731927871704,
0.23467956483364105,
0.013971639797091484,
-0.03272075951099396,
0.9423299431800842,
-0.9835939407348633,
0.519590437412262,
0.429293155670166,
0.5254884362220764,
-0.09435787796974182,
0.08707421272993088,
0.6877829432487488,
-0.4461679458618164,
0.08343388885259628,
0.5466030240058899,
-0.2611449658870697,
0.28656089305877686,
-0.4580110013484955,
0.35994312167167664,
0.3056711256504059,
-0.7379612326622009,
-0.6602639555931091,
0.27291324734687805,
-0.9918256998062134,
-0.21193824708461761,
0.7334805130958557,
-0.019115852192044258,
0.04114400967955589,
-0.6120216846466064,
-0.3828709125518799,
0.10396009683609009,
-0.29945626854896545,
0.9786707758903503,
0.33486196398735046,
-0.6607996821403503,
-0.18288962543010712,
-0.5257439017295837,
0.5129896998405457,
0.2131236344575882,
-1.1393240690231323,
0.19635950028896332,
0.26661086082458496,
-0.15901724994182587,
0.5310351252555847,
1.1430213451385498,
-0.3364587724208832,
0.49729016423225403,
-0.39148396253585815,
0.31549373269081116,
0.35395729541778564,
-0.5727360844612122,
0.22369126975536346,
0.25725603103637695,
0.33366474509239197,
-0.006944708991795778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12659v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12659v1
|
SOS-1K: A Fine-grained Suicide Risk Classification Dataset for Chinese Social Media Analysis
| 2024-04-19T06:58:51 | 2024-04-19T06:58:51 |
Hongzhi Qi, Hanfei Liu, Jianqiang Li, Qing Zhao, Wei Zhai, Dan Luo, Tian Yu He, Shuo Liu, Bing Xiang Yang, Guanghui Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the social media, users frequently express personal emotions, a subset of
which may indicate potential suicidal tendencies. The implicit and varied forms
of expression in internet language complicate accurate and rapid identification
of suicidal intent on social media, thus creating challenges for timely
intervention efforts. The development of deep learning models for suicide risk
detection is a promising solution, but there is a notable lack of relevant
datasets, especially in the Chinese context. To address this gap, this study
presents a Chinese social media dataset designed for fine-grained suicide risk
classification, focusing on indicators such as expressions of suicide intent,
methods of suicide, and urgency of timing. Seven pre-trained models were
evaluated in two tasks: high and low suicide risk, and fine-grained suicide
risk classification on a level of 0 to 10. In our experiments, deep learning
models show good performance in distinguishing between high and low suicide
risk, with the best model achieving an F1 score of 88.39%. However, the results
for fine-grained suicide risk classification were still unsatisfactory, with an
weighted F1 score of 50.89%. To address the issues of data imbalance and
limited dataset size, we investigated both traditional and advanced, large
language model based data augmentation techniques, demonstrating that data
augmentation can enhance model performance by up to 4.65% points in F1-score.
Notably, the Chinese MentalBERT model, which was pre-trained on psychological
domain data, shows superior performance in both tasks. This study provides
valuable insights for automatic identification of suicidal individuals,
facilitating timely psychological intervention on social media platforms. The
source code and data are publicly available.
|
[
-0.0008170964429154992,
-0.7882957458496094,
0.35521015524864197,
0.6026929020881653,
-0.17837558686733246,
-0.2677418291568756,
-0.2311364710330963,
-0.12375495582818985,
-0.067720927298069,
0.12065714597702026,
-0.8878873586654663,
-0.6577014327049255,
-0.6273338198661804,
-0.21448878943920135,
-0.1533757597208023,
1.0899605751037598,
0.17861407995224,
0.26358702778816223,
0.2908249497413635,
0.11932586133480072,
0.1454445719718933,
-0.2623750567436218,
-1.3181428909301758,
0.14585401117801666,
0.7645002007484436,
0.22251060605049133,
0.611973226070404,
0.1893436461687088,
0.6950608491897583,
0.23350782692432404,
0.028606422245502472,
-0.09197042137384415,
-0.7124462723731995,
-0.47807636857032776,
0.12261376529932022,
-0.02987109310925007,
-0.6537131071090698,
0.20794899761676788,
0.3057255744934082,
0.36986809968948364,
0.024254972115159035,
0.5708077549934387,
0.32502517104148865,
0.6428977251052856,
-0.7252904772758484,
-0.14352469146251678,
-0.21605612337589264,
0.4798790216445923,
-0.32168084383010864,
0.01458065491169691,
-0.24158373475074768,
-0.7828046679496765,
0.11234689503908157,
-0.48019546270370483,
-0.013892272487282753,
-0.6078696846961975,
0.7015712261199951,
0.4282722771167755,
-0.1718069463968277,
-0.19219344854354858,
-0.6345858573913574,
0.7055001854896545,
-0.8962734937667847,
-0.04917154461145401,
0.43017005920410156,
0.5030490159988403,
0.06842145323753357,
-0.3637717366218567,
-0.3327237665653229,
0.08855582028627396,
-0.057638172060251236,
0.1315634399652481,
0.1383829116821289,
0.27622610330581665,
0.18200494349002838,
0.34050530195236206,
-0.7337361574172974,
0.2976464629173279,
-0.4846014082431793,
-0.28465163707733154,
1.1485238075256348,
0.37904980778694153,
0.3375645577907562,
-0.5421796441078186,
-0.3845682740211487,
0.1318037509918213,
-0.2920198440551758,
0.4640278220176697,
0.4708535075187683,
0.5008403062820435,
-0.30052512884140015,
0.18803396821022034,
-0.33761265873908997,
0.3663903772830963,
0.04363835230469704,
-0.24928386509418488,
0.1966407597064972,
-0.09168926626443863,
-0.3218010663986206,
0.24107761681079865,
1.2148902416229248,
0.5419569611549377,
0.21917575597763062,
0.34696289896965027,
0.030643871054053307,
-0.04934239387512207,
0.1416347622871399,
-0.9294915795326233,
-0.20328201353549957,
0.4025946259498596,
-0.8389398455619812,
-0.39231443405151367,
0.07066866010427475,
-0.3453565537929535,
-0.5448287129402161,
-0.12866097688674927,
0.40201535820961,
-0.6140234470367432,
-0.22599303722381592,
0.1599883735179901,
0.07620828598737717,
-0.053060904145240784,
0.43985432386398315,
-0.3198656141757965,
-0.11063363403081894,
0.48868462443351746,
0.9057359099388123,
-0.1364290565252304,
-0.2287500500679016,
-0.2857554852962494,
-0.21834637224674225,
-0.35584238171577454,
0.6085318922996521,
-0.2265217900276184,
0.18393200635910034,
0.13156290352344513,
0.21990254521369934,
0.29326993227005005,
-0.12043846398591995,
0.9023372530937195,
-0.18017488718032837,
-0.05072535201907158,
-0.36075493693351746,
-0.4595721364021301,
-0.16184715926647186,
0.31498822569847107,
-0.5743882656097412,
0.8744528889656067,
0.08251314610242844,
-0.756544828414917,
0.32100921869277954,
-0.41766077280044556,
-0.4715939462184906,
0.25250643491744995,
-0.08272251486778259,
-0.43792012333869934,
-0.05550045520067215,
-0.0821700468659401,
1.3196029663085938,
-0.08272340148687363,
0.2937949001789093,
-0.7081039547920227,
-0.3476426899433136,
0.13172674179077148,
-0.5736627578735352,
0.8651626110076904,
0.5166729688644409,
0.28194645047187805,
-0.056749533861875534,
-0.8276331424713135,
0.10903353244066238,
0.21925538778305054,
-0.44059446454048157,
-0.533427894115448,
-0.0779426097869873,
0.34531038999557495,
0.5749914646148682,
0.40470007061958313,
-0.7395249009132385,
-0.003854050999507308,
-0.16177067160606384,
0.2859494686126709,
0.7285885214805603,
0.03842340409755707,
0.25365638732910156,
-0.07141504436731339,
0.24617822468280792,
-0.08160501718521118,
0.6917441487312317,
-0.00007279891724465415,
-0.08066391199827194,
-0.1869913935661316,
-0.4179588556289673,
-0.08700713515281677,
0.5841311812400818,
-0.3492129445075989,
0.6963489651679993,
-0.17309175431728363,
-0.9677572250366211,
-0.3682606518268585,
-0.02716437727212906,
0.2822240889072418,
0.31494569778442383,
0.32991573214530945,
0.2290889173746109,
-0.6524869799613953,
-0.8062827587127686,
-0.31165266036987305,
0.13412414491176605,
-0.3728412091732025,
0.21533653140068054,
-0.15849386155605316,
-0.2628180682659149,
0.6776580214500427,
-0.6735365986824036,
-0.577667772769928,
-0.39532244205474854,
0.21412578225135803,
0.2040005475282669,
0.3158882260322571,
0.2597039043903351,
-0.8196042776107788,
-0.7985014915466309,
0.00876491330564022,
-1.1650556325912476,
0.004674216266721487,
-0.44822368025779724,
0.041087087243795395,
-0.2256453037261963,
0.37013354897499084,
-0.37732991576194763,
0.6601165533065796,
0.2003152072429657,
0.0067388201132416725,
0.4736637473106384,
0.10767892003059387,
0.15159998834133148,
-1.0471727848052979,
-0.033487528562545776,
0.37640082836151123,
0.10216620564460754,
-1.0164451599121094,
-0.2921796441078186,
0.11044631153345108,
-0.13070467114448547,
-0.7260118126869202,
0.45863956212997437,
0.1130182296037674,
0.18752893805503845,
-0.2228127419948578,
0.052116699516773224,
-0.3320385813713074,
0.43406036496162415,
-0.16624051332473755,
0.28496506810188293,
0.6052090525627136,
-0.6204767227172852,
0.012921762652695179,
0.2580682933330536,
-0.25598177313804626,
0.33548223972320557,
-0.40023964643478394,
-0.21589010953903198,
-0.36870378255844116,
0.3023092746734619,
-1.0357763767242432,
-0.552649974822998,
0.15566164255142212,
-0.38169464468955994,
0.07161887735128403,
0.1298624873161316,
-0.20453579723834991,
-0.3421831727027893,
-0.6368016004562378,
0.26452529430389404,
0.03260805085301399,
0.018098048865795135,
0.48734354972839355,
0.2933511435985565,
-0.4604990780353546,
-0.49154403805732727,
-0.7135927677154541,
-0.2499290555715561,
-0.2338605523109436,
-0.5554777979850769,
0.16616509854793549,
0.14308348298072815,
0.3444739878177643,
-0.2061242014169693,
-0.07480408996343613,
-0.03706726059317589,
0.14477020502090454,
0.42980194091796875,
0.2762913107872009,
-0.028897855430841446,
0.3589061200618744,
0.29986557364463806,
-0.25711482763290405,
-0.1124490275979042,
0.30993375182151794,
0.6428436040878296,
0.11933115869760513,
-0.1315884292125702,
-0.8707292675971985,
0.22854377329349518,
0.30159568786621094,
0.1244126632809639,
0.654805600643158,
0.6980226635932922,
-0.7283298969268799,
-0.05451465770602226,
-0.2837170362472534,
0.148732990026474,
-0.47577640414237976,
0.49135497212409973,
-0.09188488125801086,
-0.7946838736534119,
0.5680497884750366,
-0.21647509932518005,
-0.0053076716139912605,
0.4237805902957916,
0.357702374458313,
-0.304109126329422,
1.0185911655426025,
0.4763830304145813,
-0.4972824156284332,
0.5685010552406311,
-0.35386157035827637,
0.26441606879234314,
-0.4020295739173889,
0.1457185596227646,
-0.039552897214889526,
-0.4272240102291107,
-0.42765355110168457,
-0.028232723474502563,
0.5151649117469788,
0.3130917251110077,
-0.7267723083496094,
0.3501080572605133,
-0.5811999440193176,
0.3997422456741333,
0.03763076663017273,
0.5649473071098328,
0.06109619140625,
-0.1288517415523529,
0.6334104537963867,
-0.01988823339343071,
-0.45463085174560547,
-0.6099793314933777,
0.9376083612442017,
0.549068808555603,
0.9095103740692139,
-0.22710660099983215,
0.5732371211051941,
0.47264739871025085,
0.45264098048210144,
-0.5518708229064941,
0.5670292377471924,
-0.8263254761695862,
-0.44898781180381775,
-0.7162789106369019,
-0.33756157755851746,
-0.5319778323173523,
-0.5777389407157898,
-0.12081391364336014,
-0.8277150392532349,
0.08336086571216583,
-0.01848548837006092,
-1.1500478982925415,
-0.13284172117710114,
-0.5360919237136841,
1.0566918849945068,
-0.4878719449043274,
0.022340748459100723,
-0.15342313051223755,
-0.6754080653190613,
0.5208582282066345,
-0.3579438328742981,
0.04549393057823181,
-0.44206783175468445,
0.4107134938240051,
0.7229505181312561,
-0.4180855453014374,
0.7751166224479675,
-0.36310359835624695,
-0.048671066761016846,
0.24721486866474152,
-0.06940891593694687,
0.7062572240829468,
0.04824089631438255,
-0.22856354713439941,
0.2349860817193985,
0.042211808264255524,
-0.32974180579185486,
-0.5423300862312317,
0.5715003609657288,
-0.7629827857017517,
0.003806732129305601,
0.1016426831483841,
-0.3864714503288269,
0.15784825384616852,
0.21209821105003357,
0.6190292239189148,
0.0868895873427391,
-0.38534459471702576,
0.07158464193344116,
0.4556795656681061,
-0.5967810153961182,
0.3395997881889343,
0.31953656673431396,
-0.1596900224685669,
-0.29348570108413696,
1.1263459920883179,
0.6247097253799438,
0.20941133797168732,
0.12547890841960907,
0.2814170718193054,
0.043363362550735474,
-0.16160500049591064,
-0.1686142385005951,
-0.06987464427947998,
-0.7475825548171997,
-0.3996669352054596,
-0.765933096408844,
-0.8031198382377625,
-0.47130656242370605,
-0.29424548149108887,
-0.536143958568573,
-0.1260361522436142,
-0.25403493642807007,
-0.29434970021247864,
0.30720651149749756,
0.4870966374874115,
-0.10614662617444992,
0.6623779535293579,
-0.9477946758270264,
0.44992712140083313,
0.160906583070755,
0.3899718225002289,
0.04821103438735008,
-0.21446837484836578,
-0.3693934679031372,
0.030031409114599228,
-0.25498148798942566,
-0.8809515237808228,
0.1313646137714386,
0.3015194833278656,
0.20165273547172546,
1.3005913496017456,
0.37447911500930786,
0.8672813773155212,
-0.32160940766334534,
0.6482081413269043,
0.18317492306232452,
-0.5873889923095703,
0.7270531058311462,
-0.5098700523376465,
0.012255189009010792,
0.8821654319763184,
1.0037274360656738,
-0.8931076526641846,
-0.10503172129392624,
-0.37590938806533813,
-0.5093539953231812,
1.042346477508545,
0.09914172440767288,
0.2214755117893219,
0.1323508471250534,
0.49312102794647217,
0.2285395860671997,
-0.060587771236896515,
-0.7218531370162964,
-0.3950883150100708,
-0.2465588003396988,
-0.6811748743057251,
0.01779341511428356,
-0.18547643721103668,
0.23784895241260529,
-0.2355058342218399,
0.6135549545288086,
-0.13376188278198242,
0.12730978429317474,
0.08806327730417252,
0.2552243769168854,
-0.3604559302330017,
-0.1733233481645584,
0.1319255232810974,
-0.06195734441280365,
-0.2145271748304367,
-0.17254090309143066,
0.22425509989261627,
-0.4284687042236328,
0.24849741160869598,
0.40554291009902954,
-0.39326003193855286,
-0.39174798130989075,
0.30008095502853394,
0.6250097751617432,
-0.2151806801557541,
-0.7477051019668579,
0.7297633290290833,
-0.11499592661857605,
-0.051945872604846954,
-0.37597912549972534,
0.08342582732439041,
-0.045163724571466446,
0.3530156910419464,
0.4976706802845001,
0.0158902145922184,
0.5286701321601868,
-0.35107123851776123,
0.08965479582548141,
0.4069952070713043,
-0.4818972051143646,
-0.42893558740615845,
0.17243844270706177,
-0.1633116602897644,
-0.41240203380584717,
0.1820039004087448,
-0.539678156375885,
-0.5229352116584778,
0.33673980832099915,
-0.09951911866664886,
1.098765254020691,
-0.617326557636261,
0.6034687161445618,
0.5036609768867493,
0.289838969707489,
-0.24894863367080688,
0.5692205429077148,
0.09170903265476227,
-0.6252229809761047,
-0.29872891306877136,
-0.8615351915359497,
0.15136396884918213,
0.6431446671485901,
-0.5507355332374573,
0.5627500414848328,
-0.8289037942886353,
-0.028417149558663368,
0.17996935546398163,
-0.004805988632142544,
-0.5533552765846252,
0.6166982054710388,
0.5834667086601257,
0.8666980266571045,
-1.236587405204773,
0.445438951253891,
0.5066218376159668,
-0.38134124875068665,
-0.9801540374755859,
0.27416861057281494,
0.0957069918513298,
-0.2605317234992981,
0.4698655605316162,
0.7514115571975708,
0.2824411690235138,
-0.04455186426639557,
-0.8770114183425903,
-0.9441250562667847,
0.9100982546806335,
0.336277037858963,
-0.2950316369533539,
-0.041771043092012405,
0.6273300051689148,
0.6470182538032532,
-0.18262125551700592,
0.10523363202810287,
0.45316633582115173,
0.2461354285478592,
-0.10534358769655228,
-0.46436604857444763,
0.1803123652935028,
-0.1582830399274826,
-0.08630923181772232,
0.05489344522356987,
-0.9690950512886047,
0.8267739415168762,
0.26346734166145325,
-0.6878576874732971,
-0.2007986158132553,
0.5420315861701965,
0.18272770941257477,
0.7582104802131653,
0.44863635301589966,
0.6334838271141052,
0.5386543273925781,
0.1499628722667694,
0.5044837594032288,
0.01028971467167139,
0.4824424982070923,
0.9235914945602417,
-0.12342635542154312,
0.7718654870986938,
-0.09853024035692215,
-0.4193491041660309,
0.14728763699531555,
0.9742059707641602,
0.11900150775909424,
0.6247632503509521,
-0.11272496730089188,
-0.1151779294013977,
-0.5779156684875488,
-0.13105937838554382,
0.03899972885847092,
0.3649117350578308,
0.568657636642456,
-0.32688307762145996,
-0.43540966510772705,
0.531799852848053,
-0.13824668526649475,
-0.22451604902744293,
-0.43419140577316284,
0.807854413986206,
0.029408955946564674,
-0.21606168150901794,
0.37309035658836365,
-0.17496703565120697,
0.5683732628822327,
-0.6712759733200073,
0.20478123426437378,
-0.19070930778980255,
0.26617667078971863,
-0.47846686840057373,
-0.8394509553909302,
0.5019626021385193,
0.0038578736130148172,
-0.1278224140405655,
0.06516215950250626,
1.0639561414718628,
-0.25909361243247986,
-0.8423164486885071,
0.15945488214492798,
0.15358944237232208,
0.365822434425354,
-0.5577203035354614,
-0.9191164970397949,
-0.1491529643535614,
-0.14082717895507812,
-0.4916524589061737,
0.27340859174728394,
0.7380114793777466,
-0.18233133852481842,
0.7384892702102661,
0.6144056916236877,
-0.036439698189496994,
-0.01383461244404316,
-0.1434015929698944,
1.0189934968948364,
-0.5876168608665466,
-0.4427183270454407,
-0.8819486498832703,
0.5909115076065063,
-0.1784151792526245,
-0.3464336693286896,
0.7740751504898071,
0.5157263278961182,
0.7874385118484497,
-0.01774311251938343,
1.0058116912841797,
-0.2731844186782837,
0.6833314299583435,
-0.20675766468048096,
0.9261565208435059,
-0.6323920488357544,
-0.1008715033531189,
-0.48540693521499634,
-0.40284502506256104,
-0.334515243768692,
0.41846129298210144,
-0.552095353603363,
-0.13005542755126953,
0.1194257065653801,
0.8237130641937256,
-0.032301485538482666,
-0.08069521933794022,
0.21003009378910065,
0.16434617340564728,
0.06347297132015228,
0.4819013774394989,
0.7535247206687927,
-0.797740638256073,
0.3228721618652344,
-0.30632075667381287,
-0.3051126003265381,
-0.3057765066623688,
-0.5307332277297974,
-0.9182104468345642,
-0.4747750759124756,
-0.15624122321605682,
-0.022240355610847473,
-0.24004730582237244,
1.0880167484283447,
0.4827481210231781,
-0.7340656518936157,
0.2375604212284088,
-0.10848459601402283,
-0.31861889362335205,
-0.1860305517911911,
-0.2265142947435379,
0.6236308217048645,
-0.28912538290023804,
-0.355818510055542,
0.043452028185129166,
0.4822925925254822,
-0.07170271873474121,
-0.365812748670578,
-0.26812636852264404,
-0.2674526572227478,
0.09034848213195801,
0.5640720129013062,
0.07871444523334503,
-0.598781406879425,
-0.1472955048084259,
0.049771469086408615,
-0.48959025740623474,
-0.2594272792339325,
0.4851429760456085,
-0.34614044427871704,
0.04724644124507904,
0.597745954990387,
0.7060425877571106,
0.008275666274130344,
0.19268815219402313,
0.00846987497061491,
-0.883525550365448,
-0.08848073333501816,
0.06109962239861488,
0.06600828468799591,
0.22828972339630127,
-1.0028409957885742,
0.36600372195243835,
-0.1257767230272293,
-0.5493061542510986,
-0.7503319382667542,
-0.08070816844701767,
-0.8385151028633118,
-0.4642501771450043,
0.9401153922080994,
-0.3582024574279785,
-0.08027276396751404,
0.06544023752212524,
-0.4617854654788971,
0.6001800894737244,
-0.3271975517272949,
0.883514404296875,
0.5428835153579712,
0.04407302662730217,
-0.05488472431898117,
-0.4979536235332489,
0.9054046273231506,
0.056688468903303146,
-0.7583587765693665,
0.4545849859714508,
0.14859279990196228,
-0.13370834290981293,
0.2748624384403229,
0.7806339263916016,
0.3769803047180176,
0.46506479382514954,
-0.44714632630348206,
0.15622784197330475,
0.1775384396314621,
-0.3586321771144867,
-0.35779303312301636,
0.18812309205532074,
-0.6545395255088806,
0.011947120539844036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12652v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12652v1
|
Pre-trained Vision-Language Models Learn Discoverable Visual Concepts
| 2024-04-19T06:41:32 | 2024-04-19T06:41:32 |
Yuan Zang, Tian Yun, Hao Tan, Trung Bui, Chen Sun
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Do vision-language models (VLMs) pre-trained to caption an image of a
"durian" learn visual concepts such as "brown" (color) and "spiky" (texture) at
the same time? We aim to answer this question as visual concepts learned "for
free" would enable wide applications such as neuro-symbolic reasoning or
human-interpretable object classification. We assume that the visual concepts,
if captured by pre-trained VLMs, can be extracted by their vision-language
interface with text-based concept prompts. We observe that recent works
prompting VLMs with concepts often differ in their strategies to define and
evaluate the visual concepts, leading to conflicting conclusions. We propose a
new concept definition strategy based on two observations: First, certain
concept prompts include shortcuts that recognize correct concepts for wrong
reasons; Second, multimodal information (e.g. visual discriminativeness, and
textual knowledge) should be leveraged when selecting the concepts. Our
proposed concept discovery and learning (CDL) framework is thus designed to
identify a diverse list of generic visual concepts (e.g. "spiky" as opposed to
"spiky durian"), which are ranked and selected based on visual and language
mutual information. We carefully design quantitative and human evaluations of
the discovered concepts on six diverse visual recognition datasets, which
confirm that pre-trained VLMs do learn visual concepts that provide accurate
and thorough descriptions for the recognized objects. All code and models are
publicly released.
|
[
-0.3898312747478485,
-0.722740650177002,
0.6540343165397644,
0.15889783203601837,
-0.5592951774597168,
0.22050310671329498,
-0.24079947173595428,
-0.5694022178649902,
0.2175341248512268,
0.48798123002052307,
-0.43962323665618896,
-0.4890129864215851,
-0.580119252204895,
0.09606514126062393,
-0.35170337557792664,
0.8907914757728577,
-0.11278915405273438,
-0.03502610698342323,
-0.4236758053302765,
-0.16540688276290894,
-0.640478253364563,
-0.31052908301353455,
-0.2636924386024475,
0.0690242201089859,
0.6861903667449951,
0.3108125329017639,
0.509518027305603,
0.6555845141410828,
0.7387599945068359,
0.3454724848270416,
-0.09415556490421295,
0.30264830589294434,
-0.14233872294425964,
-0.30588555335998535,
-0.3303646743297577,
-0.5224056243896484,
-0.10790172219276428,
0.15941110253334045,
0.21706783771514893,
0.6653411984443665,
-0.14897005259990692,
0.1308101862668991,
-0.10699280351400375,
0.7474504113197327,
-0.6692494750022888,
0.3020855188369751,
-0.6543542146682739,
0.3643586039543152,
-0.06424907594919205,
-0.39642417430877686,
-0.33143875002861023,
-0.21008367836475372,
0.4941446781158447,
-0.9498748779296875,
0.21857750415802002,
0.02390684001147747,
1.1803536415100098,
0.29657238721847534,
-0.13593395054340363,
-0.29679590463638306,
-0.4491107761859894,
0.6508021354675293,
0.07170403748750687,
0.4123903810977936,
0.24301877617835999,
0.5372222661972046,
0.28518542647361755,
-0.7378965616226196,
-0.7545007467269897,
-0.41363975405693054,
-0.23848013579845428,
0.12249342352151871,
0.061227425932884216,
-0.1265333890914917,
0.31424543261528015,
0.2102094143629074,
-0.5687248110771179,
-0.04329197481274605,
-0.6069174408912659,
-0.18894974887371063,
0.7638410329818726,
0.0849585309624672,
0.214941143989563,
-0.0002359453501412645,
-0.734741747379303,
-0.0905165821313858,
-0.617318868637085,
-0.12151572108268738,
-0.2056858092546463,
0.19431541860103607,
-0.4028267562389374,
0.6511591076850891,
-0.27746132016181946,
0.5345299243927002,
-0.03440443426370621,
-0.12073018401861191,
0.762722909450531,
-0.4322703778743744,
-0.32213717699050903,
-0.1818164885044098,
0.6204640865325928,
0.3189436197280884,
0.42051127552986145,
0.04396123066544533,
-0.2786015570163727,
0.25288647413253784,
0.352661669254303,
-0.4359937906265259,
-0.48088473081588745,
-0.11084404587745667,
-0.4694742262363434,
-0.4350999891757965,
0.1129191666841507,
-0.4756716191768646,
-0.569857120513916,
-0.47729435563087463,
0.7670086622238159,
-0.26911044120788574,
-0.42974206805229187,
0.17243154346942902,
-0.4809841513633728,
0.296701580286026,
0.7673460841178894,
-0.6139334440231323,
0.08838339895009995,
0.2096782773733139,
0.6170241832733154,
-0.40458858013153076,
-0.30563369393348694,
-0.15415029227733612,
0.012463009916245937,
-0.619964063167572,
0.8370273113250732,
-0.49988409876823425,
-0.41440749168395996,
-0.19350065290927887,
0.07978721708059311,
0.046187132596969604,
-0.5113312005996704,
0.032446470111608505,
-0.36584553122520447,
0.09534239768981934,
-0.5388010740280151,
-0.30275166034698486,
-0.1254201978445053,
0.10460393130779266,
-0.7342948913574219,
0.47302281856536865,
-0.037427131086587906,
-0.9924018383026123,
0.734580397605896,
-0.6751080751419067,
-0.3313923478126526,
0.4725407660007477,
-0.7303038239479065,
-0.3425791263580322,
0.1990518867969513,
-0.14090630412101746,
0.45750120282173157,
-0.14508642256259918,
0.06251771748065948,
-0.12915751338005066,
-0.2665817141532898,
0.3584810495376587,
-0.24897083640098572,
0.6004643440246582,
0.4970409572124481,
-0.1563154011964798,
0.3103978633880615,
-0.7875269055366516,
-0.04036832973361015,
0.5371320247650146,
-0.19165538251399994,
-0.3696083724498749,
0.03867378830909729,
-0.13890251517295837,
-0.036318983882665634,
0.26860255002975464,
-0.39498171210289,
-0.05412584915757179,
-0.1194673478603363,
0.21453358232975006,
0.7711849212646484,
-0.321862131357193,
0.42820510268211365,
-0.020938172936439514,
0.21222656965255737,
0.4985768496990204,
0.2691367566585541,
-0.25100454688072205,
-0.21658724546432495,
-1.0692720413208008,
-0.4247903525829315,
-0.0706079974770546,
0.5144328474998474,
-1.1695507764816284,
0.20314274728298187,
-0.04828379675745964,
-0.4108525514602661,
-0.17992854118347168,
0.12307251989841461,
0.6046723127365112,
0.4420526325702667,
0.3567593991756439,
-0.5337088704109192,
-0.4885306656360626,
-0.8087755441665649,
-0.008381559513509274,
-0.10813362896442413,
0.2222944051027298,
0.2894093990325928,
0.5973442792892456,
-0.1756955087184906,
0.9575352668762207,
-0.7576231360435486,
-0.26479050517082214,
-0.22279515862464905,
0.26449528336524963,
-0.13504844903945923,
0.24310532212257385,
0.3630957007408142,
-1.2013378143310547,
-0.38874900341033936,
0.19156192243099213,
-0.9520565271377563,
0.21114930510520935,
0.1285022646188736,
0.09859618544578552,
0.24136802554130554,
0.5360996127128601,
-0.6072952747344971,
0.5650444626808167,
0.027055686339735985,
-0.2013518065214157,
0.5899376273155212,
-0.3884694278240204,
-0.2620440125465393,
-0.6867702007293701,
-0.14424316585063934,
0.165868878364563,
0.0684719979763031,
-0.3779061436653137,
0.20365747809410095,
0.19620802998542786,
-0.01271980069577694,
-0.7140278816223145,
0.717080295085907,
-0.5067538619041443,
-0.1699855774641037,
-0.170746311545372,
0.08693021535873413,
-0.026351843029260635,
0.4027593731880188,
0.7663486003875732,
0.6107779145240784,
0.7072027921676636,
-0.817814826965332,
0.2992098033428192,
0.11242055147886276,
-0.48216062784194946,
0.6350530385971069,
-0.46897777915000916,
0.01875883899629116,
-0.42727169394493103,
-0.09480281174182892,
-0.7713955640792847,
0.11319297552108765,
0.40746673941612244,
-0.34649837017059326,
0.09776246547698975,
0.1456669420003891,
-0.23670963943004608,
-0.5547592639923096,
0.07265806198120117,
0.25921207666397095,
0.31900864839553833,
-0.4592418968677521,
0.5777619481086731,
0.3993222415447235,
0.1598624736070633,
-0.7493353486061096,
-0.5414223670959473,
-0.16153857111930847,
-0.25454291701316833,
-0.1061747819185257,
0.0803225040435791,
-0.20136485993862152,
-0.12043645977973938,
0.0672248899936676,
-0.1875392347574234,
-0.29118192195892334,
0.2372126579284668,
0.382510781288147,
0.364850252866745,
-0.0885242223739624,
0.44779863953590393,
-0.4677949547767639,
-0.1453714668750763,
-0.11812862753868103,
-0.42744454741477966,
0.31453272700309753,
-0.33624985814094543,
-0.25035062432289124,
-0.22310994565486908,
-0.039788879454135895,
0.25395655632019043,
-0.7338612675666809,
0.289619117975235,
0.8161718249320984,
-0.19688135385513306,
-0.1491173952817917,
-0.4545018672943115,
-0.013476944528520107,
-0.463735431432724,
0.5026346445083618,
-0.5719923377037048,
-0.6453292965888977,
-0.07582132518291473,
0.026681238785386086,
-0.18797291815280914,
0.20997242629528046,
0.3800607919692993,
-0.41212499141693115,
0.6622828245162964,
1.1127606630325317,
0.4604809880256653,
0.5058755278587341,
-0.4340088665485382,
0.10350475460290909,
-0.2724404036998749,
-0.5661565661430359,
-0.2405257225036621,
-0.011830054223537445,
-0.5375245213508606,
-0.5848979949951172,
0.08662959188222885,
-0.04201224446296692,
-0.10426130890846252,
0.16125482320785522,
-0.4266865849494934,
0.6480885148048401,
0.5558117032051086,
0.2682015001773834,
0.15187972784042358,
0.23553314805030823,
-0.40844541788101196,
0.16478368639945984,
-0.38010483980178833,
-0.31923410296440125,
1.0222673416137695,
0.317547082901001,
0.733528196811676,
-0.27774372696876526,
0.7115961909294128,
0.265330970287323,
0.27227097749710083,
-0.6846133470535278,
0.7102349996566772,
-0.31078049540519714,
-0.375,
-0.13448019325733185,
-0.4362702965736389,
-0.6609129309654236,
0.21874338388442993,
-0.4916140139102936,
-0.5257490873336792,
0.16432473063468933,
0.3040316104888916,
-0.3549661338329315,
0.07204824686050415,
-0.7944416999816895,
0.9611835479736328,
-0.7300217151641846,
-0.14503316581249237,
-0.37396788597106934,
-0.7460374236106873,
0.2184712439775467,
-0.20780706405639648,
0.20074908435344696,
-0.0773429274559021,
0.04604899138212204,
0.5642679333686829,
-0.1351301670074463,
0.8185033202171326,
-0.1309162825345993,
-0.11552216857671738,
0.338520884513855,
-0.10436059534549713,
-0.1052614226937294,
-0.14050915837287903,
0.6742138862609863,
0.2838118076324463,
0.034140873700380325,
-0.3065190017223358,
-0.7085562348365784,
0.05379297211766243,
-0.7337104082107544,
-0.6068719029426575,
-0.4854047894477844,
-0.3348357379436493,
0.10033869743347168,
0.21002289652824402,
0.1737057864665985,
0.11216360330581665,
-0.33545589447021484,
0.0888645350933075,
0.7919995188713074,
-0.4502912759780884,
0.21186916530132294,
0.77841717004776,
-0.492035835981369,
-0.1704997420310974,
1.2959697246551514,
-0.005056043621152639,
0.2906997799873352,
0.6316104531288147,
0.14995326101779938,
-0.20495113730430603,
-0.5504957437515259,
-0.12565980851650238,
0.09619910269975662,
-0.7835879325866699,
0.04862140864133835,
-0.4820197820663452,
-0.34914618730545044,
0.16037645936012268,
-0.04032847285270691,
-0.18099325895309448,
-0.20270301401615143,
-0.2089899182319641,
-0.21345436573028564,
0.16111546754837036,
0.6425127983093262,
-0.04626580700278282,
0.2002803087234497,
-0.5480535626411438,
0.5993540287017822,
0.581466794013977,
0.19911538064479828,
-0.2949349284172058,
-0.18198983371257782,
-0.29573124647140503,
0.17311540246009827,
-0.15557004511356354,
-0.5811295509338379,
0.4298841953277588,
0.10118791460990906,
0.6913872957229614,
0.59261554479599,
-0.3476424813270569,
0.5293422341346741,
-0.5038752555847168,
0.5197260975837708,
0.6770480275154114,
-0.66932213306427,
0.7182130813598633,
0.1640826016664505,
0.042817771434783936,
0.2065565288066864,
0.4958789646625519,
-0.3111748993396759,
-0.07444387674331665,
-0.5312578082084656,
-0.41693249344825745,
0.41495367884635925,
0.005528013221919537,
0.22141265869140625,
-0.2627180516719818,
-0.0700618326663971,
0.17431341111660004,
0.5673172473907471,
-0.7143187522888184,
-0.22937345504760742,
-0.5396877527236938,
-0.23268897831439972,
-0.1774722933769226,
-0.2091781497001648,
-0.25893834233283997,
-0.2779099941253662,
-0.08189010620117188,
-0.263897180557251,
0.14152880012989044,
0.1318129152059555,
-0.44822633266448975,
0.07930822670459747,
0.07751650363206863,
0.48083552718162537,
0.7555530667304993,
-0.17731444537639618,
0.343423992395401,
-0.03386488929390907,
-0.6151215434074402,
0.0921330526471138,
-0.09760456532239914,
-0.2939719259738922,
0.06116428226232529,
0.2055663764476776,
1.005002498626709,
0.026480508968234062,
-1.0015228986740112,
0.6696061491966248,
-0.24501661956310272,
-0.31383076310157776,
-0.36732450127601624,
0.19536171853542328,
-0.049682535231113434,
0.30441519618034363,
0.27241793274879456,
0.2475949078798294,
-0.18102943897247314,
-0.5707074403762817,
0.2978338599205017,
0.5902751088142395,
-0.3503512442111969,
-0.32431676983833313,
0.4087460935115814,
0.2575134038925171,
-0.03234794735908508,
0.3983936905860901,
-0.22791077196598053,
-0.4278181195259094,
0.7573391795158386,
0.3069094121456146,
0.6064548492431641,
0.06080776825547218,
0.7629368901252747,
0.15987379848957062,
0.1746411770582199,
-0.02413722686469555,
0.5737051367759705,
-0.22380369901657104,
-1.2332948446273804,
0.02076132781803608,
-0.6732590198516846,
-0.03049914538860321,
0.01702224463224411,
-0.4746612310409546,
0.4648672044277191,
-0.7961763143539429,
-0.03597288578748703,
0.16776278614997864,
-0.056259579956531525,
-1.0505013465881348,
0.6201106905937195,
0.4956255853176117,
0.8506372570991516,
-0.8732938766479492,
0.8413577079772949,
0.7337724566459656,
-1.0383141040802002,
-0.71637362241745,
-0.24900268018245697,
-0.08062607049942017,
-1.0095736980438232,
1.4033416509628296,
0.20193368196487427,
-0.12290172278881073,
-0.10368025302886963,
-0.8071253299713135,
-0.8907426595687866,
1.0758169889450073,
0.11906684935092926,
-0.520208477973938,
-0.13875150680541992,
-0.04146241024136543,
0.39187511801719666,
-0.5562357902526855,
0.24565498530864716,
0.2137717455625534,
0.29717379808425903,
0.3753295838832855,
-1.0628001689910889,
-0.29635268449783325,
-0.23104479908943176,
0.0018870256608352065,
-0.16565218567848206,
-0.3681561350822449,
0.919813871383667,
-0.7281972169876099,
-0.556056022644043,
0.02623767964541912,
0.7135269641876221,
0.29630017280578613,
0.5368479490280151,
0.5154423713684082,
0.6484143137931824,
0.7749150395393372,
0.010899334214627743,
0.7515013813972473,
0.11203426867723465,
0.1805132031440735,
0.9737491011619568,
-0.3392880856990814,
0.8469913005828857,
0.4567581117153168,
-0.098821721971035,
0.4063076674938202,
0.486297607421875,
-0.17166128754615784,
0.85043865442276,
0.2463928759098053,
0.07023802399635315,
-0.26453015208244324,
-0.24615326523780823,
-0.4086008667945862,
0.4832315146923065,
0.5783487558364868,
-0.389541357755661,
-0.1286105364561081,
0.19305703043937683,
-0.43934622406959534,
0.06303012371063232,
-0.41309118270874023,
0.8952809572219849,
0.27954670786857605,
-0.24616681039333344,
0.7195720672607422,
-0.2985881268978119,
0.5502151250839233,
-0.5679003000259399,
-0.14751820266246796,
-0.13644197583198547,
0.029885297641158104,
-0.136221244931221,
-0.7894059419631958,
-0.09447801113128662,
-0.20747913420200348,
-0.04427967965602875,
-0.09842780977487564,
0.6430793404579163,
-0.49933749437332153,
-0.47921696305274963,
0.2087140828371048,
0.791170060634613,
0.1484963446855545,
0.07484687119722366,
-0.7179034948348999,
0.03769787773489952,
-0.13711488246917725,
0.30980080366134644,
0.06500962376594543,
0.5693151950836182,
-0.2109941691160202,
0.8638724684715271,
0.43952739238739014,
0.24236339330673218,
0.07021136581897736,
0.19615593552589417,
0.8188303112983704,
-0.6755461096763611,
-0.43043220043182373,
-0.5684237480163574,
0.4724011719226837,
-0.15669482946395874,
-0.02673264592885971,
0.5354261994361877,
0.25190049409866333,
1.3808549642562866,
-0.3745289444923401,
0.859807014465332,
0.06966406852006912,
0.37214651703834534,
-0.7907832264900208,
0.5533062219619751,
-0.743663489818573,
0.11105182021856308,
-0.4766332805156708,
-0.7900761961936951,
-0.16537804901599884,
0.9235470294952393,
-0.3451533019542694,
-0.1141003966331482,
0.9743245244026184,
0.6398715972900391,
0.09052905440330505,
-0.07907626032829285,
0.383181095123291,
0.1674557477235794,
-0.04476885497570038,
0.4531383216381073,
1.110949993133545,
0.14208409190177917,
0.3783820867538452,
-0.20816035568714142,
-0.053908754140138626,
-0.1451537311077118,
-0.8557860851287842,
-0.8122416138648987,
-0.8137468099594116,
-0.33791008591651917,
0.09209074825048447,
0.36828991770744324,
0.8574456572532654,
0.6539981365203857,
-0.41642650961875916,
-0.2148963212966919,
-0.19008946418762207,
0.19353297352790833,
-0.20157577097415924,
-0.1014518067240715,
0.31417542695999146,
-0.31328505277633667,
-0.15587285161018372,
0.13347387313842773,
0.43643587827682495,
0.26235151290893555,
-0.1708851158618927,
-0.2944069802761078,
0.16303792595863342,
-0.09409580379724503,
0.7566449642181396,
0.34620386362075806,
-0.8795364499092102,
-0.2493702471256256,
-0.06278395652770996,
-0.15899957716464996,
0.11506088823080063,
0.8052414059638977,
-0.9883721470832825,
0.5569273829460144,
0.28037700057029724,
0.4982137084007263,
0.19425922632217407,
-0.1736416220664978,
0.30105534195899963,
-0.5969303250312805,
0.47557908296585083,
0.0038479494396597147,
0.4479931890964508,
0.33007726073265076,
0.02394622005522251,
0.3512190878391266,
0.5456022024154663,
0.2732406556606293,
-0.5864197015762329,
0.5885645151138306,
-0.9092890620231628,
-0.55134117603302,
0.9006035327911377,
-0.09914451837539673,
-0.33390191197395325,
0.1207975372672081,
-0.4561520218849182,
-0.014501919038593769,
0.04274490848183632,
0.638195812702179,
0.24122099578380585,
0.34748002886772156,
-0.4997958540916443,
-0.3442555069923401,
0.6660208702087402,
0.22599224746227264,
-0.7558460235595703,
-0.11210467666387558,
0.4955380856990814,
0.2888103127479553,
0.3925819396972656,
0.6892072558403015,
-0.12131928652524948,
0.4302155375480652,
-0.16997095942497253,
0.10981029272079468,
-0.22717691957950592,
-0.8616432547569275,
-0.011519374325871468,
-0.03120528720319271,
0.1874570995569229,
-0.4295624792575836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12642v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12642v1
|
Cooperative Sentiment Agents for Multimodal Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-04-19T05:48:09 | 2024-04-19T05:48:09 |
Shanmin Wang, Hui Shuai, Qingshan Liu, Fei Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In this paper, we propose a new Multimodal Representation Learning (MRL)
method for Multimodal Sentiment Analysis (MSA), which facilitates the adaptive
interaction between modalities through Cooperative Sentiment Agents, named
Co-SA. Co-SA comprises two critical components: the Sentiment Agents
Establishment (SAE) phase and the Sentiment Agents Cooperation (SAC) phase.
During the SAE phase, each sentiment agent deals with an unimodal signal and
highlights explicit dynamic sentiment variations within the modality via the
Modality-Sentiment Disentanglement (MSD) and Deep Phase Space Reconstruction
(DPSR) modules. Subsequently, in the SAC phase, Co-SA meticulously designs
task-specific interaction mechanisms for sentiment agents so that coordinating
multimodal signals to learn the joint representation. Specifically, Co-SA
equips an independent policy model for each sentiment agent that captures
significant properties within the modality. These policies are optimized
mutually through the unified reward adaptive to downstream tasks. Benefitting
from the rewarding mechanism, Co-SA transcends the limitation of pre-defined
fusion modes and adaptively captures unimodal properties for MRL in the
multimodal interaction setting. To demonstrate the effectiveness of Co-SA, we
apply it to address Multimodal Sentiment Analysis (MSA) and Multimodal Emotion
Recognition (MER) tasks. Our comprehensive experimental results demonstrate
that Co-SA excels at discovering diverse cross-modal features, encompassing
both common and complementary aspects. The code can be available at
https://github.com/smwanghhh/Co-SA.
|
[
-0.6292421817779541,
-0.47984904050827026,
0.22738978266716003,
0.5326624512672424,
-0.48445409536361694,
0.5854030251502991,
-0.2862483263015747,
-0.21324124932289124,
0.67825847864151,
-0.03771581873297691,
-0.8779448866844177,
-0.40190616250038147,
-0.5198414921760559,
0.06594526767730713,
0.538029134273529,
0.8547734618186951,
-0.009859618730843067,
0.24329954385757446,
-0.4869016110897064,
-0.5302992463111877,
-0.4626702070236206,
-0.6361615657806396,
-0.47568365931510925,
-0.19215825200080872,
0.6532772779464722,
0.3232371509075165,
0.5243995785713196,
-0.5043156743049622,
0.44856932759284973,
0.3803026080131531,
0.2080363929271698,
0.4980495572090149,
-0.3084917664527893,
0.2742445766925812,
-0.19488480687141418,
-0.27912411093711853,
-0.6545845866203308,
0.18778753280639648,
0.14725394546985626,
0.38229334354400635,
0.011237758211791515,
-0.03443515673279762,
0.03448735922574997,
0.6172348856925964,
-0.7206942439079285,
0.5152556896209717,
-0.3732500672340393,
0.2359294295310974,
0.21044759452342987,
-0.3482992649078369,
-0.651382327079773,
0.0214067529886961,
0.05752206966280937,
-0.5524298548698425,
-0.10319150984287262,
0.11643201112747192,
0.6347960829734802,
0.250370055437088,
-0.6150313019752502,
-0.5595712661743164,
-0.3876273036003113,
1.0904589891433716,
-0.1943836808204651,
0.4497067630290985,
0.043622493743896484,
0.3492666780948639,
-0.028687680140137672,
-0.36437660455703735,
-0.7210416197776794,
-0.3752759099006653,
-0.26555106043815613,
0.7085497379302979,
-0.18175101280212402,
0.12294171750545502,
-0.3294791877269745,
0.2719830870628357,
-0.40867704153060913,
-0.17039208114147186,
0.055920206010341644,
-0.6012144088745117,
0.7525194883346558,
0.22918522357940674,
0.18346785008907318,
-0.4244179427623749,
-0.9229644536972046,
-0.41236814856529236,
-0.0062408447265625,
0.44928157329559326,
0.04182566702365875,
0.2716456949710846,
-0.5681666731834412,
0.33884745836257935,
0.061150744557380676,
0.2297387570142746,
0.2568148970603943,
-0.029306216165423393,
0.5760182738304138,
-0.4240143597126007,
-0.29885539412498474,
-0.13513655960559845,
1.0364335775375366,
0.33333083987236023,
-0.24914051592350006,
-0.0003624631790444255,
-0.25863945484161377,
0.4006434679031372,
0.1323198825120926,
-0.08071200549602509,
-0.12537990510463715,
0.06825166195631027,
-0.48583105206489563,
-0.21665160357952118,
0.007730587385594845,
-1.2225638628005981,
-0.5059722661972046,
-0.33935248851776123,
0.7302048206329346,
-0.16407456994056702,
-0.5112782120704651,
-0.12677250802516937,
-0.2654794752597809,
0.051586613059043884,
0.2980547249317169,
-0.5496370792388916,
0.2350432127714157,
0.40633752942085266,
0.7404218912124634,
-0.04512184113264084,
-0.3981705904006958,
-0.4748447835445404,
-0.1007113978266716,
-0.1789649873971939,
0.4549436569213867,
-0.7782613039016724,
-0.28913289308547974,
-0.2589457929134369,
-0.07026082277297974,
-0.33591198921203613,
-0.2699950039386749,
0.3297171890735626,
-0.7361056804656982,
0.338754266500473,
-0.3446100354194641,
-0.0581127405166626,
-0.43060803413391113,
0.5130798816680908,
-0.9355143904685974,
0.6202903389930725,
0.2445196807384491,
-0.4466622471809387,
0.1616995483636856,
-0.8934375047683716,
-0.27043548226356506,
-0.3815544843673706,
-0.19224704802036285,
-0.5875003933906555,
0.1025543287396431,
0.2890915274620056,
0.7078842520713806,
0.09019427001476288,
0.09102971106767654,
-0.5568063259124756,
-0.13989277184009552,
0.35566282272338867,
-0.46348094940185547,
0.4661772549152374,
0.48302942514419556,
-0.1471623033285141,
0.5590231418609619,
-0.7420024871826172,
-0.2797197997570038,
-0.05120105668902397,
-0.009791885502636433,
-0.43636786937713623,
-0.230527862906456,
0.06162817031145096,
0.4831247925758362,
0.3977334201335907,
-0.3714373707771301,
0.04249222204089165,
0.17405229806900024,
0.10987588763237,
0.8717962503433228,
0.09529447555541992,
0.7457451820373535,
-0.07455024123191833,
0.6904053092002869,
0.5196713805198669,
0.38592666387557983,
-0.10247838497161865,
-0.016968734562397003,
-0.7058774828910828,
-0.8784346580505371,
-0.0945727676153183,
0.08542464673519135,
-1.1225265264511108,
0.4755420386791229,
-0.017915936186909676,
-0.3193403482437134,
-0.532939076423645,
0.050701435655355453,
0.31421035528182983,
0.03500529006123543,
0.4962979257106781,
-0.7260082960128784,
-0.7845891118049622,
-0.5853860378265381,
-0.09825464338064194,
0.057208698242902756,
0.44781792163848877,
0.3020698130130768,
0.3595174551010132,
-0.3133256435394287,
0.9145506024360657,
-0.1846887469291687,
-0.5228725671768188,
-0.2761595845222473,
0.6383464932441711,
-0.2597014307975769,
0.19976259768009186,
0.542778730392456,
-0.9886151552200317,
-0.5824081301689148,
-0.17486155033111572,
-1.0025179386138916,
0.24824991822242737,
-0.2217196673154831,
-0.015028286725282669,
0.47294291853904724,
0.24000096321105957,
-0.36821746826171875,
0.00491911917924881,
1.0490723848342896,
-0.5191317200660706,
0.2763117849826813,
-0.14982908964157104,
0.2910240888595581,
-1.338614821434021,
-0.281077116727829,
0.203603595495224,
-0.4096320569515228,
-0.2814994156360626,
-0.03662155196070671,
-0.2901533842086792,
-0.18300017714500427,
-0.22267530858516693,
0.04499339312314987,
-0.6860091686248779,
-0.22277773916721344,
-0.24532848596572876,
0.026730643585324287,
0.05862387642264366,
1.0023177862167358,
0.12918893992900848,
0.6628875732421875,
0.5634627342224121,
-0.3252967298030853,
0.5306133031845093,
0.11543770134449005,
0.23727698624134064,
0.7677778005599976,
-0.2600882351398468,
0.315764844417572,
-0.1379276067018509,
0.46966347098350525,
-1.1176892518997192,
-0.16568200290203094,
0.6363570690155029,
-0.4830268621444702,
0.10310431569814682,
0.21707697212696075,
0.0025721390265971422,
-0.014139918610453606,
-0.5384591817855835,
0.24744351208209991,
0.23925542831420898,
-0.6372455358505249,
1.2472376823425293,
0.39524757862091064,
-0.013326198793947697,
-0.764915943145752,
-0.4319186806678772,
-0.056560080498456955,
0.0645366981625557,
-0.6968852877616882,
0.06368441879749298,
-0.0021648923866450787,
-0.09595877677202225,
0.11886663734912872,
0.10282698273658752,
0.07051672041416168,
-0.049473412334918976,
0.5192999839782715,
0.42132577300071716,
0.07316375523805618,
0.205729141831398,
0.2131592184305191,
-0.2612168788909912,
-0.008165620267391205,
0.4417780041694641,
0.9304606318473816,
-0.49455171823501587,
-0.29376867413520813,
-0.554201066493988,
0.3696476221084595,
0.8243771195411682,
-0.6340388059616089,
0.7194123864173889,
1.052755355834961,
0.010762952268123627,
-0.020489545539021492,
-0.20125041902065277,
-0.052393555641174316,
-0.49242985248565674,
0.3903762996196747,
-0.5473357439041138,
-0.9827194809913635,
0.4822700023651123,
-0.17640386521816254,
-0.39586126804351807,
0.26202863454818726,
0.7541893124580383,
-0.19996419548988342,
0.9596983194351196,
0.7915667295455933,
-0.3445592522621155,
0.49302855134010315,
-0.21302074193954468,
0.07700300216674805,
-0.7489968538284302,
-0.4712986648082733,
-0.03151596337556839,
-0.38971343636512756,
-0.4319552481174469,
-0.6060209274291992,
0.6737918853759766,
-0.1220916137099266,
-0.0103999562561512,
-0.01819358579814434,
-0.18006570637226105,
0.08207159489393234,
0.2971736490726471,
0.3777850270271301,
0.19494600594043732,
0.17397625744342804,
0.02161031775176525,
0.09068331867456436,
-0.4728628993034363,
-0.1524004340171814,
0.592643678188324,
0.363900363445282,
0.9654200077056885,
-0.0010616221698001027,
0.8568698763847351,
0.5959482192993164,
0.08265077322721481,
-0.7646166086196899,
0.6719803810119629,
-0.09638600796461105,
-0.1222425326704979,
-0.08181621879339218,
-0.37331604957580566,
-0.6181160807609558,
0.4131177067756653,
-0.49011653661727905,
-0.11207102239131927,
0.5625500679016113,
0.10413389652967453,
-0.23771622776985168,
-0.032959334552288055,
-0.7760341763496399,
0.6717802286148071,
-0.08300059288740158,
-0.5095670223236084,
-0.7829656004905701,
-0.8288913369178772,
0.12213269621133804,
0.2781788408756256,
0.22759543359279633,
0.044131066650152206,
-0.10870590060949326,
0.6021727919578552,
0.13542887568473816,
1.2466460466384888,
-0.5530749559402466,
-0.03536895662546158,
0.37850260734558105,
0.04350947588682175,
0.5627940893173218,
0.018284203484654427,
0.07974793016910553,
0.1393342912197113,
-0.18427546322345734,
-0.34757280349731445,
-0.5947319865226746,
0.6196865439414978,
-1.0299510955810547,
-0.1143094077706337,
-0.6726195812225342,
-0.8721086978912354,
-0.3167237937450409,
-0.11783099919557571,
-0.17729894816875458,
0.3220251500606537,
-0.2924707531929016,
0.091120146214962,
0.3095720410346985,
-0.1285260021686554,
0.6333925724029541,
0.3691893517971039,
0.009764537215232849,
-0.8167915344238281,
1.1454834938049316,
-0.20399323105812073,
0.2242758721113205,
0.32541635632514954,
0.1136784479022026,
-0.3029248118400574,
-0.02506876178085804,
-0.1612277776002884,
0.03466968983411789,
-0.6915502548217773,
-0.10780652612447739,
-0.5564922094345093,
0.19160906970500946,
-0.41282251477241516,
-0.2333361953496933,
-0.33898404240608215,
-0.07328837364912033,
-0.2384057343006134,
0.18614549934864044,
0.3086003065109253,
0.48407331109046936,
-0.39283907413482666,
0.05655777081847191,
-0.8912725448608398,
0.4182686507701874,
0.39500266313552856,
0.2651347219944,
-0.012101305648684502,
0.05599386617541313,
-0.15509606897830963,
0.19418394565582275,
-0.25985845923423767,
-0.6870615482330322,
0.3894045650959015,
0.21870315074920654,
0.38460633158683777,
0.19145746529102325,
0.138207346200943,
0.607939600944519,
0.15476694703102112,
0.9574002027511597,
0.641796350479126,
-1.0633149147033691,
0.031902167946100235,
-0.12611247599124908,
-0.09556231647729874,
0.4581981599330902,
0.663860023021698,
-0.6138652563095093,
-0.06435539573431015,
-0.18321429193019867,
-0.4590408205986023,
0.6072284579277039,
-0.14710107445716858,
0.22915923595428467,
0.16263051331043243,
-0.020758965983986855,
0.2970448434352875,
0.21354760229587555,
-0.7724282741546631,
-0.13994669914245605,
-0.4985261559486389,
-0.7951529026031494,
-0.25643864274024963,
-0.2833542823791504,
-0.30890515446662903,
-0.07013386487960815,
0.5502259731292725,
-0.48518767952919006,
0.5900835990905762,
0.29066845774650574,
-0.36825984716415405,
-0.35521551966667175,
0.48470303416252136,
0.5796785354614258,
0.22184635698795319,
-0.07820867747068405,
0.2494652271270752,
-0.055982477962970734,
-0.23437316715717316,
0.1585286408662796,
0.02109553851187229,
0.3348507881164551,
-0.10961232334375381,
0.24079926311969757,
0.9401636123657227,
0.04646730050444603,
-0.4648822546005249,
0.752938449382782,
-0.2007649689912796,
-0.07833283394575119,
-0.29024606943130493,
-0.22103504836559296,
0.028639283031225204,
0.7966747879981995,
0.2095550000667572,
0.597011148929596,
-0.033739715814590454,
-0.9641614556312561,
0.2773354947566986,
0.6071377396583557,
-0.7282874584197998,
-0.7324144840240479,
0.20262280106544495,
0.35646045207977295,
0.06165139004588127,
0.14982116222381592,
-0.4799317419528961,
-0.6919153332710266,
0.2831023335456848,
0.3958211839199066,
0.9012418985366821,
-0.15818317234516144,
0.5890010595321655,
0.03807807341217995,
-0.012325889430940151,
0.2077801376581192,
0.5393319129943848,
-0.1277657300233841,
-0.8510912656784058,
-0.21976757049560547,
-0.3711184561252594,
-0.4953118860721588,
-0.4389820098876953,
-0.7618345618247986,
0.04638168588280678,
-0.41114819049835205,
0.015625616535544395,
-0.2159890979528427,
-0.09441936016082764,
-0.4594949781894684,
0.3779313266277313,
0.28139299154281616,
0.4069842994213104,
-1.0404741764068604,
0.5501492619514465,
0.7803764343261719,
-0.7362992167472839,
-0.6195699572563171,
-0.03897424042224884,
0.06396134197711945,
-0.7463363409042358,
0.4471818804740906,
-0.002736900234594941,
-0.5199393630027771,
-0.21022509038448334,
-0.5657796263694763,
-0.4084647595882416,
1.355383038520813,
0.15884427726268768,
-0.5292738080024719,
0.29300427436828613,
0.1424681842327118,
0.7179526686668396,
-0.5979797840118408,
0.13526548445224762,
-0.049244072288274765,
0.2613113224506378,
0.20549364387989044,
-0.6444572806358337,
0.13839931786060333,
-0.16214679181575775,
-0.38529786467552185,
0.004839188884943724,
-1.222442865371704,
0.8952478766441345,
-0.05978121981024742,
0.04399530962109566,
-0.10687969624996185,
1.0118281841278076,
0.24169902503490448,
0.9418665170669556,
0.8690747022628784,
0.43582603335380554,
0.6035782098770142,
-0.025960464030504227,
0.6647903919219971,
-0.11437847465276718,
0.6419429779052734,
0.919948399066925,
-0.4581955671310425,
0.8176790475845337,
0.7072521448135376,
-0.0033785502891987562,
0.9007575511932373,
0.2790588140487671,
0.02958589978516102,
0.8282838463783264,
-0.43128642439842224,
-0.6246228218078613,
-0.5284630656242371,
-0.2169094830751419,
-0.13123515248298645,
0.7420839667320251,
0.124266617000103,
-0.3169730603694916,
-0.15909814834594727,
0.5702782273292542,
-0.25524675846099854,
0.2125156670808792,
-0.45106983184814453,
0.8731449246406555,
0.08484236150979996,
-0.5018583536148071,
0.181228905916214,
-0.27735111117362976,
1.0220831632614136,
-0.7102532386779785,
-0.034774333238601685,
-0.020235056057572365,
0.3311094641685486,
-0.3164241909980774,
-0.541436493396759,
0.3094748258590698,
-0.4307754337787628,
-0.21057644486427307,
-0.008276981301605701,
1.0139414072036743,
-0.6368686556816101,
-0.1359848976135254,
0.5464186668395996,
0.4085385501384735,
-0.36386990547180176,
0.006592098157852888,
-0.7550448775291443,
0.3846946954727173,
-0.209623321890831,
-0.24295884370803833,
0.44204720854759216,
0.15082989633083344,
-0.04486129805445671,
0.5370450615882874,
0.5307440161705017,
-0.3912516236305237,
0.008014076389372349,
0.12065722048282623,
1.0646051168441772,
-0.683685302734375,
-0.498205304145813,
-0.6448974013328552,
0.43122148513793945,
-0.0616384856402874,
0.15668046474456787,
0.8130242228507996,
0.2403927445411682,
0.6951345801353455,
-0.3774377405643463,
0.8439357876777649,
-0.2750086188316345,
0.08917173743247986,
-0.4564110338687897,
0.5500560998916626,
-0.8136923313140869,
-0.23641334474086761,
-0.24871723353862762,
-0.48777368664741516,
-0.20913131535053253,
0.49725523591041565,
-0.18791884183883667,
0.030371805652976036,
0.6579213738441467,
0.9998067021369934,
0.05526578426361084,
0.24699613451957703,
0.2857941687107086,
0.047317471355199814,
0.23392294347286224,
0.5612999796867371,
1.0782408714294434,
-0.3729499280452728,
0.3858966529369354,
-0.5120090842247009,
-0.23120296001434326,
-0.0738803818821907,
-0.6310315728187561,
-0.9441232085227966,
-0.7779915928840637,
-0.12944220006465912,
-0.37538090348243713,
-0.015256025828421116,
1.6071313619613647,
0.5519503951072693,
-0.7219684720039368,
-0.10016719996929169,
0.20861825346946716,
-0.05599803850054741,
-0.6003564596176147,
-0.2685612738132477,
0.2543308436870575,
-0.5532612204551697,
-0.6504074931144714,
0.5113694071769714,
0.4620562493801117,
-0.33467403054237366,
-0.4953453540802002,
-0.5961116552352905,
-0.2912958562374115,
0.14266850054264069,
0.9221416115760803,
-0.06935290992259979,
-0.38099992275238037,
-0.3515649139881134,
-0.03751622885465622,
-0.18113599717617035,
0.2022840678691864,
0.8598232269287109,
-0.5986320376396179,
0.7427934408187866,
0.6331009268760681,
0.42030566930770874,
0.13434948027133942,
-0.12699727714061737,
0.33119046688079834,
-1.0177936553955078,
0.30573198199272156,
0.054495152086019516,
0.4292692244052887,
0.18603013455867767,
-0.2763499617576599,
0.17938651144504547,
0.5532358884811401,
-0.30189189314842224,
-0.5116368532180786,
0.24702036380767822,
-1.7828357219696045,
-0.07609472423791885,
0.8592669367790222,
-0.15377765893936157,
-0.36053693294525146,
-0.05409548431634903,
-0.5070744752883911,
0.4974358081817627,
-0.6968162655830383,
0.790894627571106,
0.4546104669570923,
-0.19867800176143646,
-0.48985379934310913,
0.47924795746803284,
0.24205195903778076,
0.5221365094184875,
-0.7233983278274536,
-0.15921837091445923,
0.5578749179840088,
0.1006995290517807,
0.4559243321418762,
0.7072804570198059,
-0.15382976830005646,
0.37580326199531555,
0.039739448577165604,
0.32258060574531555,
-0.44953107833862305,
-0.3745730519294739,
-0.6642618179321289,
0.539156436920166,
-0.10430006682872772,
-0.43774712085723877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12628v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12628v1
|
Efficient infusion of self-supervised representations in Automatic Speech Recognition
| 2024-04-19T05:01:12 | 2024-04-19T05:01:12 |
Darshan Prabhu, Sai Ganesh Mirishkar, Pankaj Wasnik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Self-supervised learned (SSL) models such as Wav2vec and HuBERT yield
state-of-the-art results on speech-related tasks. Given the effectiveness of
such models, it is advantageous to use them in conventional ASR systems. While
some approaches suggest incorporating these models as a trainable encoder or a
learnable frontend, training such systems is extremely slow and requires a lot
of computation cycles. In this work, we propose two simple approaches that use
(1) framewise addition and (2) cross-attention mechanisms to efficiently
incorporate the representations from the SSL model(s) into the ASR
architecture, resulting in models that are comparable in size with standard
encoder-decoder conformer systems while also avoiding the usage of SSL models
during training. Our approach results in faster training and yields significant
performance gains on the Librispeech and Tedlium datasets compared to
baselines. We further provide detailed analysis and ablation studies that
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach.
|
[
-0.27973735332489014,
-0.17344491183757782,
0.3353155255317688,
0.08333218097686768,
-0.18650007247924805,
-0.041034799069166183,
-0.23121081292629242,
-0.5396402478218079,
0.05871843546628952,
0.4572843015193939,
-0.25858840346336365,
-0.11760378628969193,
-0.47522202134132385,
-0.024576466530561447,
-0.6508497595787048,
0.673327624797821,
-0.04318171367049217,
0.18825574219226837,
-0.10504820197820663,
-0.21181443333625793,
0.0035712462849915028,
-0.565475344657898,
-0.646771252155304,
-0.44810113310813904,
0.1830197423696518,
-0.004582215566188097,
0.146897092461586,
0.7575573325157166,
0.4354877471923828,
0.3197353780269623,
0.0759228840470314,
0.04323851317167282,
-0.13962756097316742,
0.049820274114608765,
-0.17995361983776093,
-0.07957406342029572,
-0.28670257329940796,
-0.09486670047044754,
0.6862578988075256,
0.44432902336120605,
-0.2528354823589325,
0.41586998105049133,
0.32155340909957886,
0.663919985294342,
-0.8105960488319397,
0.22377178072929382,
-0.5087770819664001,
0.06095940247178078,
-0.23844531178474426,
-0.17802056670188904,
-0.4507145583629608,
0.05272862687706947,
0.27400094270706177,
-0.4803827106952667,
0.15003275871276855,
-0.3022702634334564,
0.3989655375480652,
0.41949647665023804,
-0.019110260531306267,
-0.4866311848163605,
-0.8112844824790955,
0.6270869374275208,
-0.5145812630653381,
1.0684319734573364,
0.3739500045776367,
0.3121088147163391,
0.29322749376296997,
-0.638878345489502,
-0.1975586712360382,
-0.07236023247241974,
-0.07855113595724106,
0.35808202624320984,
-0.2925267219543457,
-0.04865777865052223,
0.21783287823200226,
0.1940334588289261,
-0.7006918787956238,
0.0990305170416832,
-0.43006232380867004,
-0.3653307855129242,
0.6302627921104431,
-0.013403365388512611,
-0.1653076857328415,
0.08536644279956818,
-0.3164990246295929,
-0.12798872590065002,
-0.4933297038078308,
0.1951272040605545,
0.11079894006252289,
0.46853628754615784,
-0.25002264976501465,
0.4079534411430359,
-0.11530737578868866,
0.696381151676178,
0.5899078249931335,
0.022899189963936806,
0.23681390285491943,
-0.39579588174819946,
-0.18956637382507324,
0.35223475098609924,
0.6447463631629944,
-0.2348424196243286,
0.2897518575191498,
-0.24145400524139404,
-0.20615601539611816,
0.2783192992210388,
0.37352827191352844,
-0.8784412741661072,
-0.3937760889530182,
0.41387227177619934,
-0.4594650864601135,
0.02381725423038006,
-0.06599485129117966,
-0.12611453235149384,
0.19218945503234863,
-0.4133184850215912,
0.5259205102920532,
-0.5696801543235779,
-0.019168805330991745,
-0.12974277138710022,
-0.14851894974708557,
0.1727161407470703,
0.26060932874679565,
-0.901720404624939,
0.3989410400390625,
0.36042675375938416,
0.6848139762878418,
-0.24035456776618958,
0.045608039945364,
-0.9646486639976501,
0.49563631415367126,
-0.3349919021129608,
0.5912364721298218,
-0.48230117559432983,
-0.3879854083061218,
-0.13679322600364685,
-0.15446791052818298,
-0.0020257383584976196,
-0.5311885476112366,
0.13200168311595917,
-0.5313737392425537,
-0.14154255390167236,
0.049165692180395126,
-0.7455176115036011,
-0.10359103232622147,
-0.3697822391986847,
-0.4863267242908478,
0.9361777305603027,
-0.08963004499673843,
-0.656642496585846,
-0.0010148489382117987,
-0.6568382382392883,
-0.6518791317939758,
-0.04567822068929672,
-0.30349037051200867,
-0.5213485360145569,
0.12653349339962006,
0.5805106163024902,
0.7891279458999634,
-0.057395514100790024,
-0.050237175077199936,
-0.15857355296611786,
-0.25184527039527893,
0.4290204644203186,
-0.33368802070617676,
0.7963858842849731,
0.3720066547393799,
-0.3297441601753235,
0.058687422424554825,
-0.8946900963783264,
-0.03281747177243233,
-0.09278267621994019,
-0.4507567882537842,
-0.41549286246299744,
-0.2360038012266159,
0.05203074589371681,
-0.05248930677771568,
0.12169338017702103,
-0.6275988817214966,
-0.35700610280036926,
-0.5955039858818054,
0.40137845277786255,
0.5677897930145264,
-0.26459723711013794,
0.6647476553916931,
-0.006022817455232143,
0.0005071365158073604,
0.04929238557815552,
-0.04112418740987778,
-0.18726973235607147,
-0.08011885732412338,
-0.7867236137390137,
-0.4952283799648285,
0.4387357234954834,
0.3981708586215973,
-0.7106332778930664,
0.42283204197883606,
-0.14887188374996185,
-0.4626902639865875,
-0.9397692084312439,
0.28486236929893494,
0.7455595135688782,
0.48397761583328247,
0.6254700422286987,
-0.4492655396461487,
-0.410693496465683,
-0.6765217781066895,
-0.12435422837734222,
-0.08726304769515991,
-0.29544973373413086,
0.18899181485176086,
0.2711171805858612,
-0.001400401582941413,
0.7846658825874329,
-0.07704205811023712,
-0.4009861946105957,
-0.08714376389980316,
0.017470667138695717,
-0.07375868409872055,
0.6394996047019958,
0.31101009249687195,
-0.4572352468967438,
-0.6119003295898438,
-0.02988530322909355,
-0.7142810821533203,
0.06676977872848511,
-0.0895286276936531,
0.1800067275762558,
0.2316664606332779,
0.6330114603042603,
-0.16417069733142853,
0.5864776372909546,
0.5046349167823792,
0.0984499529004097,
0.0724668949842453,
-0.2842104434967041,
-0.023806223645806313,
-0.5460122227668762,
-0.054578330367803574,
0.06034759059548378,
-0.49528270959854126,
-1.0215325355529785,
-0.1627013385295868,
0.44081446528434753,
-0.25973865389823914,
-0.4141073226928711,
0.33176273107528687,
-0.7234129309654236,
-0.34843960404396057,
-0.25860896706581116,
0.08117484301328659,
-0.1758933961391449,
0.5074690580368042,
0.4662294387817383,
0.8248100876808167,
0.7552645802497864,
-0.7651246190071106,
0.08639182895421982,
0.2390836477279663,
0.0909779891371727,
0.33318468928337097,
-0.6687861680984497,
0.2820269763469696,
-0.17895030975341797,
0.31343355774879456,
-0.7834702134132385,
-0.10140428692102432,
0.18137431144714355,
-0.5613242387771606,
0.5663226246833801,
-0.14349107444286346,
-0.047884441912174225,
-0.32202672958374023,
-0.18414521217346191,
0.45399031043052673,
0.6571789383888245,
-0.996093213558197,
0.9575493931770325,
0.5386322736740112,
0.19903112947940826,
-0.24989475309848785,
-1.0851157903671265,
-0.3370973765850067,
-0.17144551873207092,
-0.3475586473941803,
0.5944729447364807,
0.09318786859512329,
0.15482909977436066,
0.015717314556241035,
-0.14036765694618225,
0.1393580287694931,
-0.0748661607503891,
0.3602420389652252,
-0.12977300584316254,
-0.15938229858875275,
0.18283164501190186,
-0.11581144481897354,
-0.39472824335098267,
-0.1661272495985031,
-0.46079161763191223,
0.2626272737979889,
0.018465934321284294,
-0.5927326083183289,
-1.0483510494232178,
0.5083538889884949,
0.28069165349006653,
-0.7184635996818542,
0.1492285430431366,
0.6243899464607239,
-0.3504622280597687,
-0.3922063410282135,
-0.7373601794242859,
-0.37223562598228455,
-0.4964742958545685,
0.13814522325992584,
-0.3575296998023987,
-0.8910481333732605,
0.3507968485355377,
0.19822092354297638,
-0.006808621343225241,
0.23405252397060394,
0.6753559708595276,
-0.1987745761871338,
0.7196595072746277,
0.3588745892047882,
-0.07980207353830338,
0.7636059522628784,
-0.31246820092201233,
-0.08921702206134796,
-1.167736291885376,
-0.05243833735585213,
-0.2856834828853607,
0.18792589008808136,
-0.4336852729320526,
-0.9051396250724792,
0.36210495233535767,
-0.3554992377758026,
-0.17719173431396484,
0.5704195499420166,
-0.6451258659362793,
0.011950119398534298,
0.5926526188850403,
0.21860994398593903,
0.12793691456317902,
0.22951404750347137,
0.06933101266622543,
0.1456340104341507,
-0.8945456743240356,
-0.11570538580417633,
1.2440893650054932,
0.5433989763259888,
0.9321097731590271,
-0.1305837482213974,
1.0679017305374146,
0.09112262725830078,
0.06517760455608368,
-0.5100880861282349,
0.4185296893119812,
-0.5617237687110901,
-0.40731486678123474,
-0.4559512138366699,
-0.272567480802536,
-0.702576220035553,
0.22785422205924988,
-0.0731843113899231,
-0.5880743861198425,
0.46178245544433594,
0.42930206656455994,
-0.8851454854011536,
0.014173156581819057,
-0.4775586724281311,
0.3924674093723297,
-0.2529028356075287,
-0.46289557218551636,
-0.4181464612483978,
-0.6532101035118103,
-0.13884158432483673,
-0.07389301061630249,
0.13260343670845032,
0.06185849383473396,
0.09114982932806015,
0.8881220817565918,
-0.29016607999801636,
0.7504655718803406,
-0.31911396980285645,
-0.08393026888370514,
0.5834891200065613,
-0.250224769115448,
0.5497846007347107,
-0.1194007396697998,
-0.09661674499511719,
0.2729407250881195,
-0.18362073600292206,
-0.11236277967691422,
-0.6084516644477844,
0.5138107538223267,
-0.7521033883094788,
-0.3930296003818512,
-0.3165644705295563,
-0.2789711356163025,
-0.30333608388900757,
-0.31137603521347046,
0.003773303935304284,
0.8355216383934021,
-0.08220379799604416,
0.15323565900325775,
0.7142658829689026,
0.13206490874290466,
0.5353333353996277,
0.6330777406692505,
0.02185276336967945,
-0.44017893075942993,
0.9290494322776794,
0.5870456099510193,
0.3843655288219452,
0.28226980566978455,
0.005622756201773882,
-0.32304075360298157,
-0.5958549380302429,
-0.43056127429008484,
0.24454857409000397,
-0.5485648512840271,
-0.2075488567352295,
-0.9011924862861633,
-0.5697301626205444,
-0.7055782675743103,
-0.14110645651817322,
-0.7714074850082397,
-0.45089787244796753,
-0.5954697728157043,
0.17664362490177155,
0.41097503900527954,
0.31707432866096497,
-0.37861138582229614,
0.4627833664417267,
-0.6976171731948853,
0.5982357263565063,
0.6078233122825623,
0.25234612822532654,
0.18017062544822693,
-0.8213462829589844,
-0.5254091024398804,
-0.10448972135782242,
0.019959142431616783,
-0.6269577741622925,
0.28674954175949097,
0.42577624320983887,
0.5662996768951416,
0.3308255970478058,
0.007431644480675459,
1.0781248807907104,
-0.7168650031089783,
0.42143893241882324,
0.20191600918769836,
-0.9902652502059937,
0.6530948877334595,
0.10317544639110565,
0.28648892045021057,
0.43318724632263184,
0.2894410490989685,
-0.012946860864758492,
-0.4443656802177429,
-0.48022231459617615,
-0.5636901259422302,
0.7304285764694214,
0.2697960138320923,
-0.019808873534202576,
0.25862938165664673,
0.2023540586233139,
-0.05926448851823807,
-0.2330024242401123,
-0.2993907630443573,
-0.08437804132699966,
-0.42402753233909607,
-0.3823266923427582,
-0.10849268734455109,
-0.19197286665439606,
0.05828895792365074,
-0.21638934314250946,
0.8142061829566956,
-0.19023434817790985,
0.29970958828926086,
0.5533076524734497,
-0.33185264468193054,
0.022187620401382446,
0.03795647621154785,
-0.04049227014183998,
0.04189843684434891,
-0.10474817454814911,
0.22538721561431885,
0.29983073472976685,
-0.14732719957828522,
0.06507156044244766,
0.28812381625175476,
-0.08805149793624878,
-0.07981381565332413,
0.24749235808849335,
0.8049586415290833,
0.3249616324901581,
-0.43253883719444275,
0.4426630437374115,
0.08462536334991455,
0.03511748090386391,
-0.4983263909816742,
0.18535937368869781,
0.2966012954711914,
0.7097373604774475,
0.28408971428871155,
-0.05628582835197449,
0.5795387625694275,
-0.41196107864379883,
0.4569031298160553,
0.4979574382305145,
-0.5831528306007385,
-0.23954449594020844,
0.6869891881942749,
0.2883439064025879,
-0.24197623133659363,
0.44847068190574646,
0.13210414350032806,
-0.36325129866600037,
0.18773673474788666,
0.6531362533569336,
0.9238466620445251,
-0.6735889315605164,
-0.08138509839773178,
0.46477773785591125,
-0.024329377338290215,
-0.01757889799773693,
0.06447020918130875,
-0.498562753200531,
-0.5831851959228516,
-0.26876363158226013,
-0.6167861819267273,
-0.21284142136573792,
-0.2752133011817932,
-0.770086407661438,
0.06038375571370125,
-0.3118031919002533,
-0.3091372847557068,
0.3053285777568817,
-0.31884509325027466,
-0.7341440916061401,
0.24709191918373108,
0.5154218077659607,
0.6061074137687683,
-0.7965129017829895,
1.1653889417648315,
0.2795635759830475,
-0.215598002076149,
-0.809209942817688,
-0.07237958163022995,
-0.11644621193408966,
-0.767881453037262,
0.6299445033073425,
0.17980417609214783,
-0.4434044659137726,
0.11669451743364334,
-0.06544546037912369,
-1.0704267024993896,
0.9770293235778809,
0.09747772663831711,
-0.8758386373519897,
0.036682385951280594,
0.07884220778942108,
0.5068226456642151,
-0.5316988229751587,
0.0555315800011158,
0.4689943194389343,
0.06090649589896202,
-0.0037196960765868425,
-0.9450966715812683,
0.033137861639261246,
-0.06444338709115982,
0.24832527339458466,
-0.1914213001728058,
-0.6250744462013245,
0.6342269778251648,
-0.07037904113531113,
-0.44015243649482727,
-0.16399617493152618,
1.1089732646942139,
0.18178270757198334,
0.19566641747951508,
0.5927711129188538,
0.4375312626361847,
0.5451216101646423,
0.11596379429101944,
0.8437278866767883,
-0.33161014318466187,
0.17377223074436188,
1.235637903213501,
-0.18925614655017853,
0.9623585343360901,
0.5815547704696655,
-0.21474601328372955,
0.18444864451885223,
0.2161715030670166,
-0.12397782504558563,
0.7865785360336304,
0.11601979285478592,
-0.016631824895739555,
-0.526877760887146,
-0.020519567653536797,
-0.2945432662963867,
0.6761846542358398,
0.351142942905426,
-0.2556743025779724,
-0.17085205018520355,
0.35143712162971497,
-0.45938631892204285,
0.06933515518903732,
-0.4151088297367096,
1.0856250524520874,
0.2784760594367981,
-0.24206559360027313,
0.5853391885757446,
-0.19758541882038116,
0.7292620539665222,
-0.5737210512161255,
0.01691676676273346,
0.15156926214694977,
0.19105328619480133,
-0.20104087889194489,
-0.48722028732299805,
0.4245484471321106,
0.23204289376735687,
-0.03963613137602806,
-0.29700013995170593,
0.8562595248222351,
-0.8203150629997253,
-0.6289190053939819,
0.5571293234825134,
0.36181527376174927,
0.19153790175914764,
0.03911422938108444,
-0.48242244124412537,
0.17371903359889984,
-0.04639492556452751,
-0.10019894689321518,
0.2575385570526123,
0.08125526458024979,
-0.06908554583787918,
0.681529700756073,
0.6390599012374878,
0.01746271178126335,
0.14951495826244354,
0.01639518141746521,
0.9801260828971863,
-0.296976774930954,
-0.6033769845962524,
-0.7036946415901184,
0.577849805355072,
0.06316297501325607,
0.23460210859775543,
0.7125346064567566,
0.5532939434051514,
0.7833577394485474,
-0.03951707109808922,
0.7898978590965271,
0.32200929522514343,
0.8287245631217957,
-0.5914155840873718,
0.6518420577049255,
-0.5886821150779724,
0.12480375915765762,
-0.09708213806152344,
-0.2943989336490631,
-0.21871428191661835,
0.9021760821342468,
-0.1276889592409134,
-0.15072809159755707,
0.15603424608707428,
0.7110201120376587,
-0.10107755661010742,
0.020915836095809937,
0.27438226342201233,
-0.0009442823356948793,
0.23835314810276031,
0.4289093315601349,
0.6952212452888489,
-0.5397284626960754,
0.3501126170158386,
-0.5176462531089783,
-0.10199498385190964,
-0.32622581720352173,
-0.45049816370010376,
-1.021588921546936,
-0.5834693908691406,
-0.5843730568885803,
-0.18457941710948944,
0.39166775345802307,
1.0113461017608643,
0.8570536971092224,
-1.065780758857727,
-0.3630520701408386,
0.2770090401172638,
-0.2619198262691498,
-0.2059708684682846,
-0.05532148480415344,
0.5906668305397034,
-0.3412021994590759,
-0.5646284818649292,
0.6837615966796875,
0.3588098883628845,
0.19834384322166443,
-0.2173534780740738,
-0.15739662945270538,
0.06390967220067978,
0.20749442279338837,
0.5604251027107239,
0.16817639768123627,
-0.7809611558914185,
-0.4121433198451996,
-0.2085573375225067,
0.09835994988679886,
0.19651983678340912,
0.7509956955909729,
-0.9725159406661987,
0.5806576609611511,
0.3502800166606903,
0.8139740228652954,
1.0125789642333984,
0.1046026274561882,
0.40267840027809143,
-0.505012035369873,
0.15716679394245148,
0.2320690155029297,
0.187043234705925,
0.5174968242645264,
-0.24864362180233002,
0.38679155707359314,
-0.1336299628019333,
-0.31041401624679565,
-0.6827646493911743,
0.10619641840457916,
-0.8971543312072754,
-0.0721200555562973,
0.8974089026451111,
-0.25102001428604126,
-0.27854618430137634,
-0.046843271702528,
0.10524194687604904,
0.5153719186782837,
-0.5594424605369568,
0.4154566824436188,
0.09526444971561432,
-0.4376114010810852,
-0.03932869806885719,
-0.2619745433330536,
0.4449562430381775,
0.25029024481773376,
-0.42931345105171204,
0.4108807444572449,
0.3159053921699524,
0.4564710557460785,
0.254404753446579,
0.8333703279495239,
-0.21458496153354645,
0.2681918144226074,
0.020972460508346558,
-0.013693265616893768,
-0.28399625420570374,
-0.5164645910263062,
-0.6188157796859741,
0.1793135404586792,
-0.3111833930015564,
-0.3474680781364441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12618v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12618v1
|
CORI: CJKV Benchmark with Romanization Integration -- A step towards Cross-lingual Transfer Beyond Textual Scripts
| 2024-04-19T04:02:50 | 2024-04-19T04:02:50 |
Hoang H. Nguyen, Chenwei Zhang, Ye Liu, Natalie Parde, Eugene Rohrbaugh, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Naively assuming English as a source language may hinder cross-lingual
transfer for many languages by failing to consider the importance of language
contact. Some languages are more well-connected than others, and target
languages can benefit from transferring from closely related languages; for
many languages, the set of closely related languages does not include English.
In this work, we study the impact of source language for cross-lingual
transfer, demonstrating the importance of selecting source languages that have
high contact with the target language. We also construct a novel benchmark
dataset for close contact Chinese-Japanese-Korean-Vietnamese (CJKV) languages
to further encourage in-depth studies of language contact. To comprehensively
capture contact between these languages, we propose to integrate Romanized
transcription beyond textual scripts via Contrastive Learning objectives,
leading to enhanced cross-lingual representations and effective zero-shot
cross-lingual transfer.
|
[
-0.3238494396209717,
-0.130687415599823,
0.12132216989994049,
0.2747592031955719,
-0.004592397715896368,
0.17292943596839905,
-0.5090852379798889,
-0.7131926417350769,
0.23727385699748993,
0.39837580919265747,
-0.3879970610141754,
-0.5539997220039368,
-0.14143162965774536,
0.09363941103219986,
-0.16303473711013794,
0.7400872707366943,
-0.5340559482574463,
0.12794308364391327,
0.0057381936348974705,
-0.2379606068134308,
-0.2543027102947235,
-0.44939449429512024,
-0.3463287353515625,
-0.018411433324217796,
0.6679831147193909,
0.7401167750358582,
0.3285983204841614,
0.4701264500617981,
0.8985719084739685,
0.14370563626289368,
0.34890612959861755,
-0.14185455441474915,
-0.45601046085357666,
-0.057211875915527344,
-0.26121219992637634,
-0.7491466403007507,
-0.21655263006687164,
0.0537852980196476,
0.8177820444107056,
0.9478299021720886,
0.25023701786994934,
0.19998301565647125,
-0.12638184428215027,
0.48213261365890503,
-0.9554163813591003,
0.15787161886692047,
-0.17152999341487885,
0.34396177530288696,
-0.5422444343566895,
-0.2883511781692505,
-0.5213549137115479,
-0.2289266288280487,
0.20636829733848572,
-0.8818122148513794,
-0.009087193757295609,
-0.07256297767162323,
0.9746217727661133,
0.28355294466018677,
-0.40308690071105957,
-0.2608623802661896,
-0.792350709438324,
0.8080946803092957,
-0.2774493396282196,
0.7682202458381653,
0.17523515224456787,
0.27095550298690796,
0.24362066388130188,
-0.569555401802063,
-0.23382723331451416,
-0.6273011565208435,
-0.21973779797554016,
0.4228370785713196,
0.18043212592601776,
0.006649081129580736,
0.33590641617774963,
0.10081107914447784,
-0.6893004179000854,
-0.005952876526862383,
-0.3415561020374298,
-0.2537041902542114,
0.5363451242446899,
-0.08701908588409424,
0.9206104278564453,
-0.07698242366313934,
-0.5979601144790649,
-0.3001149594783783,
-0.898691713809967,
0.16639384627342224,
0.3379913568496704,
0.407765656709671,
-0.3525339365005493,
0.48892632126808167,
-0.20876279473304749,
0.5905964970588684,
0.03160380944609642,
-0.1268552839756012,
0.1052708774805069,
-0.826562762260437,
0.024260245263576508,
0.43804335594177246,
0.8943555951118469,
0.47908827662467957,
0.4776211678981781,
-0.4285884499549866,
0.3818835914134979,
-0.02094884030520916,
-0.15582622587680817,
-0.8158459663391113,
-0.21664811670780182,
-0.2562215030193329,
-0.2618744373321533,
0.2793399691581726,
0.24337436258792877,
-0.6455550789833069,
0.25512033700942993,
-0.23377476632595062,
0.2209983915090561,
-0.4705429673194885,
-0.4740617275238037,
-0.21880201995372772,
-0.3554496169090271,
0.4930133521556854,
0.3191995918750763,
-0.9174408316612244,
0.45688140392303467,
0.48817476630210876,
0.6325631141662598,
-0.5340175628662109,
-0.5023149251937866,
-0.7736177444458008,
0.6959629654884338,
-0.5359976887702942,
0.6858184933662415,
-0.4543377459049225,
-0.3706890940666199,
0.06079588085412979,
0.16243131458759308,
-0.19577740132808685,
-0.5672295093536377,
0.4143194258213043,
-0.3547385632991791,
0.2079785317182541,
-0.361354798078537,
-0.23007909953594208,
-0.2615903317928314,
0.21305471658706665,
-0.7320566773414612,
0.9558311700820923,
0.21939700841903687,
-0.6855885982513428,
0.5833326578140259,
-0.2576006352901459,
-0.5334097146987915,
0.3773711323738098,
-0.18579669296741486,
-0.11737711727619171,
-0.4345038831233978,
-0.034253332763910294,
0.272577702999115,
-0.13688822090625763,
0.15055117011070251,
-0.43462640047073364,
-0.6868183016777039,
-0.06288037449121475,
-0.25768163800239563,
0.7712200880050659,
0.15751056373119354,
-0.3595392405986786,
-0.355307400226593,
-0.8733217716217041,
-0.010530470870435238,
-0.3867606818675995,
-0.3273687958717346,
-0.9612257480621338,
-0.5592732429504395,
0.32503458857536316,
0.21826595067977905,
0.5178874731063843,
-0.5334463715553284,
0.19886797666549683,
-0.18091753125190735,
-0.25303947925567627,
-0.02968648076057434,
-0.15179693698883057,
0.7242246866226196,
0.014745102263987064,
0.5972678065299988,
0.1516321748495102,
-0.2046121060848236,
-0.22835960984230042,
-0.14833460748195648,
-0.7523720860481262,
-0.30733394622802734,
0.5921626091003418,
0.8738104104995728,
-1.1106023788452148,
0.07688415050506592,
-0.3069536089897156,
-0.42186203598976135,
-0.7117183804512024,
0.29703590273857117,
0.7103688716888428,
0.510177731513977,
0.376171350479126,
-0.5020079612731934,
-0.8371245265007019,
-0.79881352186203,
-0.21057920157909393,
-0.2686946988105774,
0.07174118608236313,
0.2336895912885666,
0.21728220582008362,
0.0758642628788948,
0.659009575843811,
-0.001961382804438472,
-0.2398243397474289,
-0.19449615478515625,
0.00246756081469357,
-0.007457592990249395,
0.5289547443389893,
0.44790226221084595,
-0.8744685053825378,
-1.1566176414489746,
0.6943539977073669,
-0.8880335688591003,
-0.3185538947582245,
-0.17858490347862244,
-0.2416267693042755,
0.2060076743364334,
1.0309191942214966,
-0.12714874744415283,
0.20742255449295044,
0.9394600987434387,
-0.12252496927976608,
0.31848689913749695,
-0.21362678706645966,
0.4992217719554901,
-1.0196466445922852,
0.5808217525482178,
0.14951878786087036,
-0.16006344556808472,
-0.6644405722618103,
-0.10629168152809143,
0.33610615134239197,
0.11105840653181076,
-0.8069740533828735,
0.6149823665618896,
-0.6114100217819214,
-0.3376058042049408,
0.1902317851781845,
0.3227523863315582,
-0.03289719298481941,
0.5027191042900085,
0.3716128170490265,
0.9238539338111877,
0.11537308990955353,
-0.4469394087791443,
0.32411813735961914,
0.14607121050357819,
-0.224357008934021,
0.8287007212638855,
-0.5571417212486267,
-0.1371951550245285,
0.3238927721977234,
0.025683527812361717,
-0.9038199186325073,
0.05152455344796181,
0.5807913541793823,
-0.44258442521095276,
0.6080807447433472,
-0.5228773355484009,
-0.008751795627176762,
0.28805628418922424,
-0.36386048793792725,
0.8086507320404053,
0.2623648941516876,
-0.4152645468711853,
0.10157841444015503,
0.17597122490406036,
-0.21896477043628693,
-0.7865034341812134,
-0.9556758999824524,
0.33043578267097473,
-0.22091862559318542,
-0.5207262635231018,
0.4660745859146118,
0.06815996021032333,
-0.29138070344924927,
0.15977509319782257,
0.26228660345077515,
-0.078032486140728,
-0.12000722438097,
-0.08894340693950653,
0.6195520162582397,
-0.4861255884170532,
-0.43282634019851685,
0.077657051384449,
-0.2652184069156647,
-0.12875579297542572,
-0.046049442142248154,
0.21526359021663666,
0.44762736558914185,
-0.47486358880996704,
-0.4993652403354645,
0.41290900111198425,
0.3954865336418152,
-0.2639845907688141,
0.43464070558547974,
0.6520581841468811,
-0.10162543505430222,
0.05651877447962761,
-0.2972448468208313,
0.45455625653266907,
-0.3726809322834015,
0.375853031873703,
-0.7937870025634766,
-0.7199317216873169,
0.4883154034614563,
-0.06057362258434296,
-0.40269121527671814,
0.46764516830444336,
0.5375440716743469,
-0.003687298856675625,
0.7265167832374573,
0.5920669436454773,
-0.24713630974292755,
0.8161031603813171,
-0.005095808766782284,
-0.14223763346672058,
-0.9973791837692261,
-0.24108484387397766,
-0.6723625659942627,
0.14292682707309723,
-1.2390153408050537,
-0.5984082818031311,
0.10643889009952545,
0.1444493979215622,
0.027632564306259155,
0.85098797082901,
-0.12475425004959106,
0.30875617265701294,
0.44251781702041626,
-0.19706669449806213,
0.49279677867889404,
-0.19042952358722687,
-0.30771470069885254,
-0.41499170660972595,
-0.8120120167732239,
-0.15135245025157928,
0.8902273774147034,
0.25954753160476685,
0.9390504956245422,
0.019014872610569,
0.9955703020095825,
0.11361078917980194,
0.3891802728176117,
-0.6683588624000549,
0.34658578038215637,
-0.40791943669319153,
-0.14862479269504547,
-0.27304914593696594,
-0.37664902210235596,
-0.8889550566673279,
0.19597400724887848,
0.035096462815999985,
-0.5366609692573547,
0.5224036574363708,
-0.32326316833496094,
0.009191637858748436,
-0.08081836253404617,
-0.7848632335662842,
0.9496123194694519,
-0.023724067956209183,
-0.6924372911453247,
-0.02543318085372448,
-0.5739235281944275,
0.4244484305381775,
0.1005924791097641,
0.14056777954101562,
0.0863698348402977,
-0.2883506119251251,
0.6823996305465698,
-0.18732981383800507,
0.6416152119636536,
0.029302412644028664,
-0.34974947571754456,
0.16998198628425598,
0.06875964254140854,
0.2279343605041504,
-0.16928881406784058,
0.10307731479406357,
0.3972693681716919,
0.23052117228507996,
-0.28830572962760925,
-0.3989073932170868,
0.6439900398254395,
-0.8551795482635498,
-0.31219354271888733,
-0.27180182933807373,
-0.4260886013507843,
-0.0572967492043972,
0.23225831985473633,
0.22818563878536224,
0.06999580562114716,
-0.6437883377075195,
0.047845106571912766,
0.552007257938385,
-0.15841054916381836,
0.41579893231391907,
0.6027621030807495,
-0.21525566279888153,
-0.660922110080719,
1.1909348964691162,
0.34028035402297974,
0.463649719953537,
0.6740418076515198,
-0.31539419293403625,
-0.1641240119934082,
-0.3828073740005493,
-0.84238201379776,
0.3451831042766571,
-0.6079767346382141,
0.12908640503883362,
-0.2784140706062317,
-0.23142856359481812,
-0.44450843334198,
-0.25565335154533386,
-0.34486669301986694,
-0.16977129876613617,
-0.09145920723676682,
0.3991089165210724,
-0.1601589173078537,
0.4198690950870514,
-0.22299697995185852,
-0.21478304266929626,
-1.167688250541687,
0.562319815158844,
0.11514782905578613,
0.36058562994003296,
-0.33206844329833984,
-0.4814099371433258,
-0.7604569792747498,
-0.12940704822540283,
0.22228381037712097,
-0.6502119302749634,
0.2792838513851166,
0.08652378618717194,
0.7560437321662903,
0.16421957314014435,
-0.004450130742043257,
0.8425250053405762,
-0.603895902633667,
0.5426918864250183,
0.28920748829841614,
-0.964663028717041,
0.24082542955875397,
-0.41395601630210876,
0.28311535716056824,
0.748677134513855,
0.571815550327301,
-1.214714765548706,
-0.4750843644142151,
-0.3968101143836975,
-0.6430287957191467,
0.7068808078765869,
-0.11562993377447128,
-0.39251893758773804,
0.20197716355323792,
0.058174002915620804,
0.07755310088396072,
-0.15546861290931702,
-0.4943852126598358,
0.03928569331765175,
0.09698892384767532,
-0.23993027210235596,
-0.2039821296930313,
0.13682138919830322,
0.07391250878572464,
-0.1828901618719101,
0.2942966818809509,
-0.27448785305023193,
-0.24887795746326447,
0.5140326023101807,
-0.49948176741600037,
-0.44713613390922546,
0.06396143138408661,
0.45009881258010864,
0.164698526263237,
-0.03253808990120888,
0.01965840719640255,
0.32778415083885193,
-0.725849449634552,
0.10342460870742798,
0.19215674698352814,
-0.42880699038505554,
0.16036637127399445,
0.6117769479751587,
0.5716756582260132,
0.6125006079673767,
-0.4833155870437622,
0.29712292551994324,
0.0725678950548172,
-0.03680712357163429,
-0.2002740502357483,
0.12925061583518982,
0.1116553395986557,
0.18633311986923218,
0.25760895013809204,
-0.1940789818763733,
0.338326632976532,
-0.7188782691955566,
0.30825793743133545,
0.454578161239624,
-0.5598448514938354,
-0.37637171149253845,
0.42933037877082825,
0.424215167760849,
-0.17698578536510468,
0.36006298661231995,
0.11780451983213425,
-0.6158564686775208,
0.7621278762817383,
0.4093027412891388,
0.6968953013420105,
-0.5861435532569885,
0.006506878416985273,
0.7091827392578125,
0.13308468461036682,
0.034048840403556824,
0.0035411908756941557,
-0.3531181514263153,
-0.5298678874969482,
-0.7903687357902527,
-0.1947653442621231,
-1.092321753501892,
-0.4489307403564453,
-1.0362248420715332,
0.7099559903144836,
-0.026255786418914795,
0.4469149708747864,
-0.2519608438014984,
0.2527037262916565,
-0.5531445741653442,
0.23736844956874847,
0.7451345920562744,
0.9632242321968079,
-0.8739565014839172,
1.1661880016326904,
0.49915075302124023,
-0.5484364628791809,
-0.6652703285217285,
0.1734500676393509,
-0.3925303518772125,
-0.6990313529968262,
0.9608210325241089,
0.15935048460960388,
-0.16552042961120605,
-0.10074389725923538,
-0.273542582988739,
-0.9687533378601074,
0.9813534617424011,
0.4224567413330078,
-0.756995677947998,
-0.0671616643667221,
0.4787955582141876,
0.8143425583839417,
-0.3399823009967804,
0.4125876724720001,
0.7038273215293884,
0.5053424835205078,
0.2374972105026245,
-1.2384601831436157,
0.16773155331611633,
-0.2449186146259308,
-0.006427896209061146,
0.2755184471607208,
-1.050845980644226,
0.613379716873169,
-0.058643944561481476,
-0.2897343039512634,
-0.04005031660199165,
0.6647959351539612,
0.05047309026122093,
0.37589773535728455,
0.13756443560123444,
0.41717728972435,
0.2932809591293335,
-0.03050813265144825,
0.6455859541893005,
-0.3391619026660919,
0.14230132102966309,
1.0118147134780884,
-0.5233407616615295,
1.1489953994750977,
0.694210410118103,
-0.26914116740226746,
0.6223701238632202,
0.4265379011631012,
-0.12585024535655975,
0.5537555813789368,
0.08105414360761642,
-0.2780025899410248,
0.05874982848763466,
-0.40276962518692017,
-0.4433861970901489,
0.5824640393257141,
0.360622376203537,
-0.04074978083372116,
-0.17178627848625183,
-0.126466304063797,
0.0034229492302984,
0.042617764323949814,
-0.20617254078388214,
0.8491564989089966,
0.02936347760260105,
-1.073932409286499,
0.5228995084762573,
-0.39084386825561523,
0.9089272618293762,
-0.6956642866134644,
-0.34426751732826233,
-0.2617700397968292,
0.11367891728878021,
-0.35477539896965027,
-0.7592592239379883,
0.3436438739299774,
-0.09240324050188065,
0.09777052700519562,
-0.2726024091243744,
0.6890075206756592,
-1.2297066450119019,
-0.1715870499610901,
0.7204013466835022,
0.5842021107673645,
0.24950610101222992,
0.5131595134735107,
-0.40743520855903625,
0.13744708895683289,
-0.01452564261853695,
-0.1304023563861847,
0.5956891775131226,
0.5189545154571533,
-0.22748041152954102,
0.1923418492078781,
0.6669662594795227,
0.35336336493492126,
-0.10864120721817017,
0.09365304559469223,
0.5886164307594299,
-0.8830930590629578,
-0.3497890830039978,
-0.5910621285438538,
0.35230785608291626,
0.030871644616127014,
-0.0781828835606575,
1.033859133720398,
0.691574215888977,
1.3868030309677124,
0.0764632597565651,
0.9612165093421936,
-0.05451485887169838,
0.34927335381507874,
-0.5630069375038147,
0.7653781771659851,
-0.5048545598983765,
-0.12039454281330109,
-0.4808342754840851,
-0.8220221400260925,
-0.2863280475139618,
0.3538477420806885,
-0.3369026780128479,
-0.15478061139583588,
0.7735489010810852,
0.6336519718170166,
0.006268736906349659,
-0.45496636629104614,
0.7692314386367798,
-0.22696784138679504,
0.06968070566654205,
1.049621820449829,
0.8602817058563232,
-0.7113151550292969,
0.8579378724098206,
-0.30226483941078186,
-0.018107417970895767,
-0.2864719033241272,
-0.7734536528587341,
-0.7536313533782959,
-0.44252559542655945,
-0.3296620547771454,
-0.37815555930137634,
0.08591888844966888,
0.7116138935089111,
0.4900076389312744,
-0.93073570728302,
-0.6218345165252686,
0.24752704799175262,
0.0958026722073555,
-0.09611024707555771,
-0.23481932282447815,
0.32756754755973816,
-0.36951959133148193,
-1.2770909070968628,
0.3551441431045532,
0.47212255001068115,
0.08232155442237854,
-0.5616040825843811,
-0.3023322522640228,
-0.2713136672973633,
-0.41259223222732544,
0.3136986494064331,
0.6586459875106812,
-0.3214883506298065,
-0.12763138115406036,
0.19163422286510468,
-0.6637006402015686,
0.3428632915019989,
1.0517898797988892,
-0.7164545655250549,
0.43440157175064087,
0.5346770882606506,
0.6238763928413391,
0.6795520186424255,
-0.3115600347518921,
0.8978269100189209,
-0.49543890357017517,
0.5165576934814453,
-0.07294926047325134,
0.14859163761138916,
0.5388903021812439,
-0.4574030339717865,
0.47012749314308167,
0.38291242718696594,
-0.2099105417728424,
-0.6476718187332153,
-0.0439017228782177,
-1.0334045886993408,
0.09191732108592987,
1.2154991626739502,
-0.6222256422042847,
-0.4446919858455658,
-0.4432726800441742,
-0.24259701371192932,
0.5979081988334656,
-0.1902574747800827,
0.20863860845565796,
0.8856157064437866,
0.008026559837162495,
-0.2937535047531128,
-0.3512396216392517,
0.6574515104293823,
0.41707515716552734,
-0.8628846406936646,
-0.12922076880931854,
0.2643096148967743,
0.31703609228134155,
0.3245466947555542,
0.6416834592819214,
-0.04059174284338951,
0.7767757773399353,
0.36301302909851074,
0.2879163920879364,
0.3579651117324829,
-0.2198326587677002,
-0.31191352009773254,
-0.015539177693426609,
0.09824784100055695,
-0.19229288399219513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12608v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12608v1
|
Auto-Formula: Recommend Formulas in Spreadsheets using Contrastive Learning for Table Representations
| 2024-04-19T03:28:18 | 2024-04-19T03:28:18 |
Sibei Chen, Yeye He, Weiwei Cui, Ju Fan, Song Ge, Haidong Zhang, Dongmei Zhang, Surajit Chaudhuri
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Spreadsheets are widely recognized as the most popular end-user programming
tools, which blend the power of formula-based computation, with an intuitive
table-based interface. Today, spreadsheets are used by billions of users to
manipulate tables, most of whom are neither database experts nor professional
programmers.
Despite the success of spreadsheets, authoring complex formulas remains
challenging, as non-technical users need to look up and understand non-trivial
formula syntax. To address this pain point, we leverage the observation that
there is often an abundance of similar-looking spreadsheets in the same
organization, which not only have similar data, but also share similar
computation logic encoded as formulas. We develop an Auto-Formula system that
can accurately predict formulas that users want to author in a target
spreadsheet cell, by learning and adapting formulas that already exist in
similar spreadsheets, using contrastive-learning techniques inspired by
"similar-face recognition" from compute vision.
Extensive evaluations on over 2K test formulas extracted from real enterprise
spreadsheets show the effectiveness of Auto-Formula over alternatives. Our
benchmark data is available at https://github.com/microsoft/Auto-Formula to
facilitate future research.
|
[
-0.14265526831150055,
-0.4653010666370392,
0.41124552488327026,
0.30755701661109924,
0.0011903248960152268,
0.16788747906684875,
0.02582496590912342,
-0.48597830533981323,
0.25253555178642273,
0.32307901978492737,
-0.5836359262466431,
-0.45594003796577454,
-0.3373624384403229,
0.10725659877061844,
-0.47725820541381836,
1.0343087911605835,
-0.2944585680961609,
0.2938494384288788,
-0.6528065204620361,
-0.1854063868522644,
-0.20370718836784363,
-0.14864084124565125,
-0.13851380348205566,
-0.2274641990661621,
0.43676912784576416,
0.7761892080307007,
0.5976161360740662,
0.6052902936935425,
0.6305824518203735,
0.30505606532096863,
0.3394656181335449,
-0.10817851126194,
-0.4394686222076416,
0.32752057909965515,
0.026073377579450607,
-0.37329843640327454,
-0.31099963188171387,
0.05255700275301933,
0.36296436190605164,
0.6905353665351868,
-0.29668164253234863,
0.12643089890480042,
0.154725581407547,
1.0089373588562012,
-0.6923770904541016,
0.5651976466178894,
-0.6518336534500122,
0.33085477352142334,
-0.3486839830875397,
0.00675538694486022,
-0.24207688868045807,
-0.6868743300437927,
0.19657212495803833,
-0.8662588000297546,
0.18605226278305054,
0.09896476566791534,
0.4473475217819214,
0.16436199843883514,
-0.10890229046344757,
-0.5241760611534119,
-0.7020189166069031,
0.33141061663627625,
-0.20399080216884613,
0.4340265393257141,
0.3245411217212677,
0.7018163204193115,
-0.15591973066329956,
-0.6992458701133728,
-0.6209350228309631,
-0.7231918573379517,
-0.2444576919078827,
0.44608402252197266,
-0.19426541030406952,
-0.3391234576702118,
0.4584433138370514,
0.14114706218242645,
-0.748396635055542,
-0.06653458625078201,
-0.4139602780342102,
-0.029307221993803978,
0.2715674936771393,
0.3198612332344055,
0.2824680507183075,
0.4487619698047638,
-0.29612451791763306,
-0.21659068763256073,
-0.7538754940032959,
-0.1652054786682129,
0.23196403682231903,
0.07119260728359222,
-0.11363989859819412,
0.46457937359809875,
-0.4642255902290344,
0.45369699597358704,
0.22167274355888367,
0.5816475749015808,
0.3533816635608673,
-0.11331193149089813,
-0.36375540494918823,
0.14430996775627136,
0.5490239858627319,
0.3304540514945984,
0.4950960874557495,
-0.25701454281806946,
0.017960378900170326,
0.06172063201665878,
0.22664809226989746,
-0.7723175883293152,
-0.7316404581069946,
-0.28885090351104736,
-0.11172324419021606,
-0.38743728399276733,
0.09435686469078064,
-0.807742714881897,
-0.5025004744529724,
-0.44904467463493347,
0.45996156334877014,
-0.2843037247657776,
0.27289414405822754,
-0.5063315629959106,
0.13788317143917084,
0.11204841732978821,
0.5704551935195923,
-0.7649804949760437,
0.5965368151664734,
0.19630178809165955,
0.5654839873313904,
-0.07132252305746078,
-0.5704131722450256,
-0.9739431142807007,
0.2346275895833969,
-0.333670437335968,
1.1476304531097412,
-0.704220175743103,
-0.4775160849094391,
-0.046393703669309616,
-0.39432260394096375,
0.030865691602230072,
-0.8126603960990906,
0.15166649222373962,
-0.29120340943336487,
0.21675007045269012,
-0.5162401795387268,
-0.4907148778438568,
0.199807807803154,
-0.03585314005613327,
-0.8584718704223633,
0.7635232210159302,
0.4596906900405884,
-0.41781166195869446,
0.5149350166320801,
-0.969049334526062,
-0.462406188249588,
0.3215447664260864,
-0.375465989112854,
-0.7962083220481873,
0.06018061935901642,
0.019620534032583237,
0.24103929102420807,
-0.15878264605998993,
-0.30857568979263306,
-0.355392724275589,
-0.05548376962542534,
0.21330952644348145,
0.09826217591762543,
0.3965936005115509,
0.2816389501094818,
-0.273764044046402,
0.3792426586151123,
-0.5101682543754578,
-0.17110314965248108,
0.17217426002025604,
0.20916776359081268,
-0.19378060102462769,
-0.1352653205394745,
0.08816548436880112,
0.17704781889915466,
0.3248083293437958,
-0.24980232119560242,
-0.04562823101878166,
-0.1506204605102539,
0.11853191256523132,
0.48287031054496765,
-0.3919704854488373,
0.4987066090106964,
-0.34085917472839355,
0.6616412997245789,
0.23610392212867737,
0.08349844813346863,
-0.03630261495709419,
-0.21169327199459076,
-0.42710167169570923,
0.09613185375928879,
0.12383907288312912,
0.5270485877990723,
-0.39136528968811035,
0.21059994399547577,
0.1895977258682251,
-0.5979353785514832,
-0.09301575273275375,
0.5600691437721252,
0.5976656675338745,
1.0921927690505981,
0.6400943994522095,
-0.17465436458587646,
-0.4345351457595825,
-1.0611997842788696,
-0.47471147775650024,
0.008059819228947163,
0.15607032179832458,
0.589530885219574,
0.5551720261573792,
-0.24949926137924194,
1.0138059854507446,
-1.0226079225540161,
-0.571621835231781,
-0.12584708631038666,
0.267339825630188,
-0.07820046693086624,
0.3624090850353241,
0.693209171295166,
-0.8852874040603638,
-1.3701914548873901,
-0.0072506628930568695,
-0.6043412089347839,
-0.3390251398086548,
-0.008790521882474422,
-0.2479214072227478,
0.17173346877098083,
0.6625083088874817,
-0.1699618697166443,
0.5023585557937622,
0.15883371233940125,
-0.24993276596069336,
0.8037751317024231,
-0.3633616864681244,
-0.12601208686828613,
-0.911922812461853,
0.40175682306289673,
0.259992778301239,
-0.22422672808170319,
-0.4135434329509735,
-0.16432994604110718,
0.39992228150367737,
-0.06520703434944153,
-0.18959985673427582,
0.43007200956344604,
-0.38964343070983887,
-0.1957346647977829,
0.06097947806119919,
-0.14273710548877716,
-0.1933586150407791,
0.21140171587467194,
-0.11397624760866165,
1.1113990545272827,
0.3252360224723816,
-0.3708922266960144,
0.36488762497901917,
0.46786779165267944,
-0.4436508119106293,
0.9842014908790588,
-0.5359774827957153,
-0.026843024417757988,
0.101504847407341,
0.31518226861953735,
-0.7569071650505066,
-0.2878449261188507,
0.08592966198921204,
-0.2648339569568634,
0.29355326294898987,
0.15054723620414734,
-0.16926071047782898,
-0.31356489658355713,
-0.28766149282455444,
0.27536696195602417,
0.45329010486602783,
-0.5198383331298828,
0.7190831303596497,
0.4685186743736267,
-0.2463715523481369,
-0.6587016582489014,
-0.5129290819168091,
0.17216581106185913,
-0.11006569862365723,
-0.27983829379081726,
0.6638763546943665,
-0.3065008819103241,
-0.2493332177400589,
0.19911757111549377,
-0.2604380249977112,
-0.2477002590894699,
0.04583339765667915,
0.4359000027179718,
0.31782782077789307,
0.09843196719884872,
0.05046072229743004,
0.022552596405148506,
-0.22923488914966583,
0.1013721376657486,
-0.17628008127212524,
0.26623085141181946,
-0.4361282289028168,
-0.15204940736293793,
-0.1870323270559311,
0.5496054291725159,
0.48012596368789673,
-0.2336529940366745,
0.5092253088951111,
0.5929480791091919,
-0.45132216811180115,
-0.38524070382118225,
-0.5116115808486938,
0.006269411183893681,
-0.4763471782207489,
0.40252912044525146,
-0.41135504841804504,
-0.1657683402299881,
0.8333365321159363,
0.05274267494678497,
-0.030198393389582634,
0.7589617967605591,
0.7277501225471497,
-0.43882885575294495,
0.6868675947189331,
0.572167694568634,
0.024339957162737846,
0.7477124929428101,
-0.11407867074012756,
-0.24190063774585724,
-0.6286333203315735,
-0.639837384223938,
-0.6108509302139282,
-0.2409321367740631,
-0.4197867214679718,
0.04217834770679474,
0.37959957122802734,
-0.3053814172744751,
-0.2359100729227066,
0.6668896675109863,
-0.4220725893974304,
0.8535317778587341,
0.6946427822113037,
0.2484993189573288,
0.02603762596845627,
0.10743346065282822,
-0.3889226019382477,
-0.03667739778757095,
-0.25971344113349915,
-0.0404883548617363,
0.9655382037162781,
-0.17135974764823914,
0.8957768678665161,
-0.053680337965488434,
0.9902588129043579,
0.43176499009132385,
0.8170793056488037,
-0.5876583456993103,
0.3575212061405182,
-0.5778742432594299,
-0.01893129013478756,
-0.13509415090084076,
-0.6644426584243774,
-0.9687087535858154,
-0.36241525411605835,
-0.30505311489105225,
-0.4768986701965332,
0.07011593878269196,
0.5002129077911377,
-0.2679669260978699,
-0.18917247653007507,
-0.9949425458908081,
1.147675633430481,
-0.21300481259822845,
-0.5843332409858704,
-0.11883584409952164,
-0.45018479228019714,
-0.12457519769668579,
-0.1434435397386551,
0.12587970495224,
0.16248773038387299,
0.13124215602874756,
0.8481533527374268,
-0.7038963437080383,
0.4756036400794983,
-0.10432519018650055,
-0.0008838364155963063,
0.10456490516662598,
0.4617277681827545,
0.3762885630130768,
-0.20727361738681793,
0.017676403746008873,
-0.3418556749820709,
-0.12441097944974899,
-0.26667919754981995,
-0.7592377066612244,
1.0574748516082764,
-0.41956570744514465,
-0.3591023087501526,
-0.3487466275691986,
-0.5032315850257874,
-0.1690339744091034,
0.3557100296020508,
0.15356339514255524,
0.3674662709236145,
-0.3835527300834656,
0.15085218846797943,
0.22263364493846893,
0.17658673226833344,
0.22048979997634888,
0.35970428586006165,
0.055888429284095764,
-0.6750075221061707,
0.9170885682106018,
0.2892775237560272,
0.025914529338479042,
0.4886249899864197,
0.46931955218315125,
-0.579649806022644,
-0.30147814750671387,
-0.5082029104232788,
-0.1184815764427185,
-0.729629397392273,
-0.3390796184539795,
-0.32011595368385315,
0.027325164526700974,
-0.27131929993629456,
-0.45268863439559937,
-0.060654085129499435,
-0.4311465919017792,
-0.26538151502609253,
0.1864473819732666,
0.34679222106933594,
0.7164751887321472,
-0.08061634004116058,
-0.020473003387451172,
-0.4205686151981354,
0.40647852420806885,
0.7284445762634277,
0.7833422422409058,
-0.3089970648288727,
-0.20556414127349854,
-0.3859436810016632,
-0.25515711307525635,
-0.38074564933776855,
-1.0773472785949707,
0.5932626128196716,
0.3396485447883606,
0.566940188407898,
0.18257541954517365,
-0.08975386619567871,
0.6953174471855164,
-0.701912522315979,
0.02805318310856819,
0.3084394335746765,
-0.9769032001495361,
0.39440107345581055,
-0.17950312793254852,
0.1748058944940567,
1.0685325860977173,
0.4106890559196472,
-0.2608470320701599,
-0.07528050243854523,
-0.4639773368835449,
-0.6914078593254089,
0.4324190616607666,
0.3493872284889221,
-0.05424930155277252,
0.2536050081253052,
0.38354721665382385,
0.46331536769866943,
0.241549551486969,
-0.6947564482688904,
-0.28697362542152405,
-0.5110503435134888,
-0.7230295538902283,
-0.07581191509962082,
0.10985149443149567,
0.09292838722467422,
-0.12710735201835632,
0.2952919006347656,
-0.21558693051338196,
0.2207513451576233,
0.14862197637557983,
-0.3909308910369873,
-0.35670217871665955,
0.071497842669487,
0.6296597719192505,
0.5912463665008545,
-0.6028976440429688,
0.056190453469753265,
0.15374912321567535,
-0.7451953291893005,
-0.31843793392181396,
0.467820942401886,
-0.08972296863794327,
-0.08955572545528412,
-0.15540260076522827,
0.1712038516998291,
0.22795316576957703,
-0.5112047791481018,
0.3369508385658264,
-0.022303253412246704,
-0.261251300573349,
-0.47224631905555725,
0.23888349533081055,
0.12986169755458832,
-0.02544168196618557,
0.34856143593788147,
0.09429237246513367,
0.3098675608634949,
-0.7256668210029602,
0.4302312433719635,
0.5901042819023132,
-0.48247262835502625,
-0.06892038136720657,
0.819871187210083,
0.30972906947135925,
-0.5052575469017029,
0.48638486862182617,
-0.22137562930583954,
-0.73872309923172,
0.8351269364356995,
0.539587676525116,
1.0633846521377563,
-0.34153735637664795,
0.1371973305940628,
0.28117430210113525,
-0.20058497786521912,
0.06579511612653732,
0.20007945597171783,
-0.21351489424705505,
-0.3245767056941986,
0.12440847605466843,
-0.38097840547561646,
-0.9471126198768616,
-0.11797911673784256,
-0.6031256914138794,
0.2648778557777405,
-0.48570725321769714,
0.1075894683599472,
0.5546457171440125,
0.17507663369178772,
-0.9931343197822571,
0.20617377758026123,
0.14500008523464203,
0.6752936840057373,
-0.8580317497253418,
0.5800468921661377,
0.6974781155586243,
-0.472522109746933,
-0.3653159737586975,
0.023227375000715256,
-0.11591212451457977,
-0.5861266851425171,
0.8838189244270325,
0.2508471608161926,
-0.25479254126548767,
-0.11394284665584564,
-0.5828874707221985,
-0.45758357644081116,
1.1291390657424927,
0.3336135149002075,
-0.6578681468963623,
0.03493630513548851,
0.06866639107465744,
0.49882468581199646,
-0.7380078434944153,
0.5558866858482361,
0.41555410623550415,
0.2428491711616516,
0.13470137119293213,
-0.8501684069633484,
0.1866372972726822,
-0.4552019536495209,
-0.3902067542076111,
0.09573687613010406,
-0.3233053386211395,
0.7507550120353699,
-0.38041773438453674,
0.11483757197856903,
-0.17577986419200897,
0.52198326587677,
0.039985813200473785,
0.7737143039703369,
0.40561529994010925,
0.24814611673355103,
0.6325103044509888,
0.10918521136045456,
0.7295789122581482,
-0.2981652021408081,
0.22784975171089172,
1.4356603622436523,
-0.568264365196228,
0.7991885542869568,
0.10363968461751938,
-0.34046459197998047,
0.9864858388900757,
0.19827450811862946,
-0.45857885479927063,
0.4052126705646515,
0.17474351823329926,
0.0966266393661499,
-0.13061857223510742,
0.13659413158893585,
-0.29452604055404663,
0.20505446195602417,
0.4870685935020447,
-0.3732549250125885,
-0.42188945412635803,
-0.5397457480430603,
-0.3228543698787689,
0.511589765548706,
-0.21287326514720917,
0.8288024663925171,
-0.015140987001359463,
-0.37961816787719727,
0.1734020859003067,
-0.536335289478302,
0.08281660079956055,
-0.40652889013290405,
-0.18804717063903809,
-0.24981655180454254,
0.010680566541850567,
-0.35395023226737976,
-0.9701856970787048,
0.2551552355289459,
0.05000397935509682,
-0.15779542922973633,
-0.17136839032173157,
0.4596704840660095,
-0.5802672505378723,
-0.36117857694625854,
0.03409272059798241,
0.5593085885047913,
-0.06945502012968063,
-0.1344979703426361,
-0.8467708230018616,
-0.5407178401947021,
-0.1294367015361786,
0.08428233861923218,
0.37940722703933716,
0.17053768038749695,
0.03634263947606087,
0.8213813304901123,
0.6135908961296082,
-0.2057916522026062,
-0.3514706790447235,
0.17275264859199524,
0.9330062866210938,
-0.7473567724227905,
-0.7131542563438416,
-0.905926525592804,
0.16171643137931824,
-0.25809550285339355,
-0.10680374503135681,
0.5662187337875366,
1.0030478239059448,
0.6907750368118286,
-0.21997104585170746,
0.5145497918128967,
0.32138746976852417,
0.29667919874191284,
-0.38975417613983154,
0.8427571654319763,
-0.5009517073631287,
0.0816475972533226,
-0.613119900226593,
-1.097885012626648,
-0.6239532828330994,
0.6990382671356201,
-0.5114901065826416,
0.22604519128799438,
0.6349835991859436,
0.5849608182907104,
-0.19424007833003998,
-0.11597619950771332,
0.1273791790008545,
0.30585455894470215,
0.15754792094230652,
0.5727623701095581,
0.50459885597229,
-0.08530067652463913,
0.8043033480644226,
-0.3562002182006836,
-0.35794907808303833,
-0.5718564987182617,
-1.0051411390304565,
-0.6750309467315674,
-0.5825008749961853,
-0.6416077017784119,
-0.3351325988769531,
-0.07257110625505447,
1.0815907716751099,
0.49968722462654114,
-0.977618932723999,
-0.25177234411239624,
-0.5241301655769348,
0.05101949721574783,
-0.16164372861385345,
-0.2154277116060257,
0.6167333722114563,
-0.22565333545207977,
-0.5450350046157837,
0.025150535628199577,
0.3030971586704254,
0.4019183814525604,
-0.007148002739995718,
0.030911555513739586,
0.3505200147628784,
0.08309005200862885,
0.4158210754394531,
0.7019948363304138,
-0.20123565196990967,
0.2559422254562378,
0.1537988930940628,
-0.33657875657081604,
0.2863309681415558,
0.8005405068397522,
-1.0325772762298584,
0.5524142980575562,
0.45393431186676025,
0.23167656362056732,
0.5650246143341064,
0.10325854271650314,
0.5251529812812805,
-0.09216532111167908,
-0.3549492359161377,
0.2882481813430786,
0.46556356549263,
0.2508062720298767,
-0.35195568203926086,
0.3782983422279358,
0.13059009611606598,
-0.39596685767173767,
-0.6872341632843018,
0.31600427627563477,
-1.2645039558410645,
0.0540696457028389,
0.7186019420623779,
-0.03785844147205353,
-0.3436119854450226,
0.031236687675118446,
-0.2531314194202423,
0.2161967009305954,
-0.7888410687446594,
1.3112086057662964,
0.21716032922267914,
-0.32060301303863525,
0.045817598700523376,
-0.18771274387836456,
0.8082056045532227,
0.5776656270027161,
-1.0979925394058228,
0.26230573654174805,
0.3848300576210022,
0.39432936906814575,
0.15516993403434753,
0.22576244175434113,
-0.021803174167871475,
0.6234384775161743,
0.04248684272170067,
-0.30737921595573425,
-0.45051872730255127,
-0.24177725613117218,
0.018952688202261925,
0.025714432820677757,
-0.22089432179927826,
0.10978075861930847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12596v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12596v1
|
Parameter Efficient Diverse Paraphrase Generation Using Sequence-Level Knowledge Distillation
| 2024-04-19T02:59:09 | 2024-04-19T02:59:09 |
Lasal Jayawardena, Prasan Yapa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Over the past year, the field of Natural Language Generation (NLG) has
experienced an exponential surge, largely due to the introduction of Large
Language Models (LLMs). These models have exhibited the most effective
performance in a range of domains within the Natural Language Processing and
Generation domains. However, their application in domain-specific tasks, such
as paraphrasing, presents significant challenges. The extensive number of
parameters makes them difficult to operate on commercial hardware, and they
require substantial time for inference, leading to high costs in a production
setting. In this study, we tackle these obstacles by employing LLMs to develop
three distinct models for the paraphrasing field, applying a method referred to
as sequence-level knowledge distillation. These distilled models are capable of
maintaining the quality of paraphrases generated by the LLM. They demonstrate
faster inference times and the ability to generate diverse paraphrases of
comparable quality. A notable characteristic of these models is their ability
to exhibit syntactic diversity while also preserving lexical diversity,
features previously uncommon due to existing data quality issues in datasets
and not typically observed in neural-based approaches. Human evaluation of our
models shows that there is only a 4% drop in performance compared to the LLM
teacher model used in the distillation process, despite being 1000 times
smaller. This research provides a significant contribution to the NLG field,
offering a more efficient and cost-effective solution for paraphrasing tasks.
|
[
-0.257209837436676,
-0.6665205359458923,
0.5906550884246826,
0.3969420790672302,
-0.5895066261291504,
0.06592801958322525,
-0.09432850033044815,
-0.1160580962896347,
-0.255302369594574,
0.6842231750488281,
-0.2993646264076233,
-0.6200770735740662,
-0.7978704571723938,
0.4720698595046997,
-0.6292884945869446,
0.995899498462677,
0.1710844486951828,
-0.06950192898511887,
-0.18121910095214844,
-0.1524214744567871,
-0.2658555805683136,
-0.46492522954940796,
-0.39899638295173645,
-0.2555844783782959,
0.291037380695343,
0.21216893196105957,
0.5586151480674744,
0.5518275499343872,
0.2917516231536865,
0.3136400580406189,
-0.5453519821166992,
0.29491037130355835,
-0.4675399959087372,
0.6430500745773315,
-0.3033350110054016,
-0.3135283589363098,
-0.08261046558618546,
-0.2811242938041687,
0.6367886662483215,
0.8730071187019348,
-0.3628156781196594,
0.09772834181785583,
0.46508991718292236,
0.5783214569091797,
-0.5752416253089905,
-0.04211200773715973,
-1.1255306005477905,
0.02965940348803997,
-0.18535679578781128,
-0.030034147202968597,
-0.23263290524482727,
-0.6409459114074707,
0.3743126392364502,
-0.47197937965393066,
0.4501025080680847,
-0.08127543330192566,
0.5394009351730347,
0.20911017060279846,
-0.2627323567867279,
-0.4216524660587311,
-0.6141090393066406,
1.0512109994888306,
-1.2894155979156494,
-0.05147900432348251,
0.1016920804977417,
0.32001200318336487,
-0.10116353631019592,
-1.1552255153656006,
-0.5648404955863953,
-0.20184075832366943,
0.12088067829608917,
-0.14094293117523193,
-0.20466062426567078,
-0.0668855533003807,
0.3271043002605438,
0.4817676246166229,
-0.36638081073760986,
-0.06143861636519432,
-0.3039584457874298,
0.08453855663537979,
0.3000198304653168,
0.41956764459609985,
-0.027192065492272377,
-0.37825891375541687,
-0.33132341504096985,
0.0970490425825119,
-0.48440754413604736,
-0.3125804364681244,
0.3815724849700928,
0.25341716408729553,
0.4052528440952301,
0.37792545557022095,
-0.5898118615150452,
0.8461897969245911,
-0.05144529789686203,
-0.4686310589313507,
0.07276256382465363,
-0.557724118232727,
-0.13833566009998322,
-0.2176516056060791,
0.7871174812316895,
0.3866071403026581,
0.19159233570098877,
-0.2048720121383667,
-0.15999911725521088,
-0.31449806690216064,
0.12194820493459702,
-0.75800621509552,
-0.27175813913345337,
-0.1735508143901825,
-0.37871289253234863,
-0.4109232723712921,
-0.14489322900772095,
-1.2413874864578247,
-0.4708695709705353,
-0.35662025213241577,
0.22506454586982727,
-0.5277238488197327,
-0.046413667500019073,
0.08879079669713974,
-0.48597389459609985,
-0.01416016835719347,
0.14747557044029236,
-0.822001576423645,
0.2810794711112976,
0.4050399959087372,
0.9539733529090881,
-0.37750741839408875,
-0.3695681691169739,
-0.3281613290309906,
0.3224608600139618,
-0.019551770761609077,
0.4539576470851898,
-0.5060718655586243,
-0.48601245880126953,
-0.17719057202339172,
-0.5734633803367615,
-0.0044165486469864845,
-0.9879406690597534,
0.5951120257377625,
-0.4115689992904663,
0.06814760714769363,
-0.26670703291893005,
-0.6489138603210449,
-0.13950864970684052,
0.0785120502114296,
-0.6650347113609314,
0.9400875568389893,
0.00903299730271101,
-0.7868713140487671,
0.3018372058868408,
-0.16162551939487457,
-0.5687285661697388,
0.24643217027187347,
-0.23067596554756165,
-0.38635683059692383,
0.30516770482063293,
0.3727884888648987,
0.5258029699325562,
-0.7961824536323547,
0.6352431774139404,
-0.2026158720254898,
-0.06403522193431854,
0.08622194081544876,
-0.6539416909217834,
0.677157461643219,
0.5055002570152283,
-0.43207332491874695,
-0.2552611231803894,
-0.8868057727813721,
-0.08692562580108643,
0.041773319244384766,
-0.4378642737865448,
-0.4313305914402008,
-0.015550813637673855,
-0.16274294257164001,
0.28191840648651123,
0.24634216725826263,
-0.26829224824905396,
-0.18436643481254578,
-0.13445241749286652,
0.6027663350105286,
0.44510605931282043,
0.41249561309814453,
0.3751735985279083,
-0.3357618749141693,
0.6939190030097961,
0.09831137955188751,
0.032890211790800095,
-0.04484320059418678,
-0.5151413083076477,
-0.3411717712879181,
-0.2678424119949341,
0.16686859726905823,
0.3161326050758362,
-0.8707525730133057,
0.3678451180458069,
-0.21807245910167694,
-0.6133201718330383,
-0.32967105507850647,
0.4775635600090027,
0.3478389084339142,
0.8964247107505798,
0.55515056848526,
0.2441163957118988,
-0.351402223110199,
-0.8173660635948181,
-0.5626806616783142,
0.08351318538188934,
-0.15315872430801392,
0.06785641610622406,
0.20134267210960388,
0.3142741024494171,
0.8515108823776245,
-0.5785989165306091,
0.12034867703914642,
-0.6873816847801208,
0.27948781847953796,
0.34701260924339294,
0.1561650037765503,
0.7142900824546814,
-0.7350776195526123,
-0.5929067730903625,
-0.2772987484931946,
-0.7779223918914795,
-0.3624364137649536,
-0.19568423926830292,
-0.31356075406074524,
-0.09975028783082962,
0.354949951171875,
-0.6000117659568787,
0.14771686494350433,
0.4708680212497711,
-0.0193293746560812,
0.4443938434123993,
-0.17995092272758484,
0.12123596668243408,
-1.3721373081207275,
0.10337258130311966,
0.03467538207769394,
-0.05559658259153366,
-0.6250341534614563,
0.10946136713027954,
-0.1752900779247284,
-0.04387178644537926,
-0.5772996544837952,
0.2497800886631012,
-0.5089765787124634,
0.2617379128932953,
-0.3804728388786316,
0.09784702956676483,
0.3834158778190613,
0.3566725254058838,
-0.08416171371936798,
0.4539671242237091,
0.54572993516922,
-0.745177149772644,
0.415042906999588,
0.23903171718120575,
-0.45822542905807495,
0.3531971871852875,
-0.6811121702194214,
-0.14800935983657837,
0.019795723259449005,
0.1863909512758255,
-0.8494530320167542,
-0.08505922555923462,
0.006883874069899321,
0.04392150416970253,
0.050552379339933395,
-0.01412121206521988,
-0.5287818312644958,
-0.2776327133178711,
-0.15551796555519104,
0.26564455032348633,
0.8391138315200806,
-0.5813761353492737,
0.4070989191532135,
0.12149015069007874,
-0.5478764772415161,
-0.4252478778362274,
-0.6668186187744141,
0.33963605761528015,
-0.8241268992424011,
-0.48324277997016907,
0.4480075240135193,
0.16116531193256378,
-0.31940191984176636,
-0.27677351236343384,
-0.2847921848297119,
-0.16836422681808472,
0.09249138832092285,
-0.25606241822242737,
0.0650852844119072,
-0.1270577758550644,
-0.16421905159950256,
0.37176620960235596,
0.3017784059047699,
0.047314129769802094,
-0.40982580184936523,
0.4412862956523895,
0.20753753185272217,
-0.06349130719900131,
-0.28080278635025024,
0.5369139313697815,
0.6480914354324341,
-0.22555530071258545,
0.9055585861206055,
0.25659099221229553,
-0.3052271008491516,
-0.499660849571228,
-0.48870334029197693,
-0.12160229682922363,
-0.4864692687988281,
0.4387606680393219,
-0.24159468710422516,
-0.6313403248786926,
0.5169481039047241,
-0.14006420969963074,
0.19738925993442535,
0.43443533778190613,
0.515770435333252,
0.20762713253498077,
0.5399573445320129,
-0.028918052092194557,
0.17061889171600342,
0.2792745530605316,
-0.024971242994070053,
0.042384058237075806,
-0.5322547554969788,
-0.21048039197921753,
-0.4777606129646301,
-0.5704315304756165,
-0.2966201901435852,
-0.45828452706336975,
0.32395097613334656,
0.425773024559021,
0.15318620204925537,
0.2945494055747986,
-0.3489227890968323,
0.4722241759300232,
0.9442045092582703,
0.09609375894069672,
0.5497453808784485,
0.13107796013355255,
-0.20961439609527588,
-0.06780771911144257,
-0.7674829959869385,
-0.7385905385017395,
1.2338759899139404,
0.027932241559028625,
0.7294493913650513,
0.08619409799575806,
1.1525219678878784,
0.07619763910770416,
-0.22907276451587677,
-0.2482181340456009,
0.7882532477378845,
-0.508140504360199,
-0.5022009611129761,
-0.35844460129737854,
-0.5451818704605103,
-0.706779956817627,
0.382931113243103,
-0.007750220131129026,
-0.4553951323032379,
0.07345857471227646,
0.1999976933002472,
-0.5516749024391174,
0.5067204833030701,
-0.4179956018924713,
0.8208353519439697,
-0.06369811296463013,
-0.34173452854156494,
-0.1175852119922638,
-0.8287451863288879,
0.48460856080055237,
-0.37521180510520935,
-0.05328263342380524,
-0.2543398439884186,
0.08980374783277512,
0.7595817446708679,
-0.5792906880378723,
0.7114101648330688,
-0.3861105740070343,
-0.07005354017019272,
0.7011516094207764,
0.039623454213142395,
0.4727371037006378,
0.14378753304481506,
-0.4021698236465454,
0.13435091078281403,
-0.11685530841350555,
-0.28368842601776123,
-0.5112636685371399,
0.792456865310669,
-0.3957107365131378,
-0.7869277000427246,
-0.02300720289349556,
-0.725764274597168,
-0.3317252993583679,
0.040051545947790146,
0.5334601402282715,
0.34638890624046326,
-0.02539679780602455,
0.469171941280365,
0.6743500232696533,
-0.38160619139671326,
0.6408692598342896,
0.12013188004493713,
0.038502246141433716,
-0.5334492921829224,
0.9017587304115295,
0.02966056577861309,
0.6362436413764954,
0.3646785318851471,
0.3682393431663513,
-0.3275914192199707,
-1.0578296184539795,
-0.16704018414020538,
0.04412386193871498,
-0.7861945629119873,
-0.34377041459083557,
-0.8556739687919617,
-0.12501516938209534,
-0.5261997580528259,
0.08786806464195251,
-0.1051579937338829,
-0.696708619594574,
-0.49797019362449646,
-0.06725425273180008,
0.49155595898628235,
0.49568960070610046,
0.180308535695076,
0.4698047339916229,
-1.087180495262146,
0.6681883931159973,
0.4359882175922394,
-0.1883087456226349,
0.10626838356256485,
-0.8299294114112854,
-0.07193435728549957,
0.06212655082345009,
-0.7236917018890381,
-1.0062936544418335,
0.6408482789993286,
0.5659928917884827,
0.7646347880363464,
0.15733890235424042,
0.32462480664253235,
0.7259935736656189,
-0.5774679183959961,
0.9285525679588318,
0.126556858420372,
-0.9618819952011108,
0.42980074882507324,
-0.3044776916503906,
0.39917516708374023,
0.6753517985343933,
0.3769420087337494,
-0.21333272755146027,
-0.9003249406814575,
-0.47286221385002136,
-1.3186556100845337,
0.5189790725708008,
0.39479535818099976,
0.2617160975933075,
-0.32417023181915283,
0.4775990843772888,
0.6264569163322449,
0.3993181884288788,
-0.6502289175987244,
-0.22308573126792908,
-0.1887960582971573,
-0.5418476462364197,
0.01676701195538044,
-0.1970217376947403,
-0.03836287930607796,
-0.1283688098192215,
0.3934696912765503,
0.14507904648780823,
-0.33607742190361023,
-0.013299262151122093,
-0.27615898847579956,
0.38613542914390564,
0.3836240768432617,
0.44980064034461975,
0.7388527989387512,
0.12227458506822586,
0.26161712408065796,
0.4567774832248688,
-0.267103374004364,
0.2274906188249588,
0.15908372402191162,
-0.1638302356004715,
0.40992721915245056,
0.26684460043907166,
0.7883132100105286,
0.19167830049991608,
-0.6188107132911682,
0.24059878289699554,
0.1946294605731964,
-0.4664342701435089,
0.16038778424263,
0.17254145443439484,
0.38139772415161133,
0.5004898309707642,
0.5161854028701782,
-0.09316254407167435,
0.47900569438934326,
-0.09645354002714157,
0.2664700448513031,
0.17299900949001312,
0.4239841401576996,
-0.05177496746182442,
0.8746803998947144,
0.2526165843009949,
-0.03221353515982628,
0.6845751404762268,
-0.03873234614729881,
-0.18441157042980194,
0.6055324077606201,
0.592883825302124,
0.9925696849822998,
-0.14552438259124756,
0.22903206944465637,
0.31939586997032166,
-0.13291826844215393,
-0.4582923948764801,
0.07202108949422836,
-0.09420689195394516,
-0.31305211782455444,
-0.23277603089809418,
-1.0936156511306763,
-0.3086871802806854,
0.22362525761127472,
-0.7784005999565125,
0.10721508413553238,
-0.3719751536846161,
-0.22713987529277802,
-0.024641552940011024,
-0.5434682965278625,
-0.4360947608947754,
0.13204500079154968,
0.25486353039741516,
0.6489984393119812,
-0.7091400623321533,
0.8036425113677979,
0.4217444658279419,
-0.2823978364467621,
-0.6276890635490417,
0.2807720899581909,
-0.3934960663318634,
-0.5264540314674377,
0.7587061524391174,
-0.027495859190821648,
0.11602810025215149,
0.2150425761938095,
-0.10107041895389557,
-0.6209447383880615,
1.3237372636795044,
0.6592481136322021,
-0.782808780670166,
-0.5193215012550354,
0.4711848199367523,
0.5838225483894348,
-0.20294047892093658,
-0.17105430364608765,
0.6873762011528015,
0.1681155115365982,
0.36667296290397644,
-0.7393689155578613,
0.09651992470026016,
0.08528293669223785,
0.4107794165611267,
0.000019305887690279633,
-0.277823805809021,
0.9658384323120117,
0.0015745945274829865,
0.0709785744547844,
0.15767653286457062,
0.7885981798171997,
0.6162250638008118,
0.11670008301734924,
0.3818371891975403,
0.5522043704986572,
0.6504550576210022,
0.16015352308750153,
0.7960984706878662,
-0.36169862747192383,
0.07958763837814331,
1.3630993366241455,
-0.3044068217277527,
0.6820694804191589,
0.6722897291183472,
-0.1969020962715149,
0.28389978408813477,
0.3320161998271942,
0.00020450296869967133,
0.7743714451789856,
0.3194749355316162,
-0.6582692265510559,
-0.25919899344444275,
0.1500658243894577,
-0.23324419558048248,
0.12610651552677155,
0.10249227285385132,
-0.7690984010696411,
-0.5261930227279663,
0.021729443222284317,
-0.21448282897472382,
0.3148075342178345,
-0.19034215807914734,
0.8702800869941711,
0.3052276372909546,
-0.943514347076416,
0.7025532126426697,
-0.04015257582068443,
0.6566198468208313,
-0.614664614200592,
0.02297818660736084,
-0.513397216796875,
0.10692852735519409,
0.008701886981725693,
-0.6301686763763428,
0.36539629101753235,
0.30096444487571716,
-0.08413144201040268,
-0.4210810661315918,
0.36649090051651,
-0.6549848318099976,
-0.418605774641037,
0.16436199843883514,
0.4994284510612488,
0.08837435394525528,
-0.19785451889038086,
-0.5524510741233826,
-0.3194144368171692,
0.18815770745277405,
-0.3701828122138977,
0.30307599902153015,
0.7135323882102966,
0.13645848631858826,
0.42995473742485046,
0.2882762849330902,
0.09889279305934906,
0.6152703166007996,
0.17120788991451263,
0.7874136567115784,
-0.6800328493118286,
-0.3541913330554962,
-1.3430331945419312,
0.49495452642440796,
-0.19304156303405762,
-0.3462296426296234,
0.9145925641059875,
0.36699602007865906,
0.4476240277290344,
-0.301923006772995,
0.9807481169700623,
0.03400315344333649,
0.46143588423728943,
-0.4994979500770569,
0.523088276386261,
-0.3321021497249603,
0.4119701683521271,
-0.41364315152168274,
-1.1104263067245483,
-0.16745148599147797,
0.3479813039302826,
-0.08600930124521255,
0.01710788905620575,
0.6965028047561646,
0.5444344282150269,
0.030225148424506187,
0.0356023907661438,
0.41068461537361145,
-0.10659737139940262,
0.4965890645980835,
0.5721877217292786,
0.838986873626709,
-0.2059916853904724,
0.9308251142501831,
-0.36506593227386475,
-0.003726482391357422,
0.010006292723119259,
-0.9717847108840942,
-0.8762213587760925,
-0.310231477022171,
-0.417803555727005,
-0.08205112814903259,
0.03198913112282753,
0.6563551425933838,
0.1979249268770218,
-0.6347450017929077,
-0.16247418522834778,
-0.600387454032898,
-0.14216849207878113,
-0.1743062436580658,
-0.1928471177816391,
-0.030022991821169853,
-0.5162153840065002,
-0.9839486479759216,
0.37870919704437256,
0.025023318827152252,
0.03318524360656738,
-0.04029940813779831,
0.04587265104055405,
-0.3484579622745514,
0.13709352910518646,
0.4001499116420746,
-0.011051769368350506,
-0.8505849838256836,
0.1374674141407013,
-0.04396796599030495,
-0.13726527988910675,
-0.09846782684326172,
0.5575587749481201,
-0.4979511797428131,
0.10388956218957901,
0.6283150315284729,
0.7344005107879639,
0.3255797326564789,
0.1564922034740448,
0.8642174601554871,
-0.9415707588195801,
-0.05138440430164337,
0.46242862939834595,
0.3527644872665405,
0.3400411307811737,
0.007932840846478939,
0.12620602548122406,
0.3408852517604828,
-0.5199785828590393,
-0.7531531453132629,
0.1507231593132019,
-0.6060429811477661,
-0.4968487024307251,
1.4167547225952148,
-0.480151891708374,
0.10206206887960434,
0.004294743295758963,
-0.13963815569877625,
0.48577991127967834,
-0.18191567063331604,
0.7716325521469116,
0.6869039535522461,
0.010144487954676151,
0.18868142366409302,
-0.2525472342967987,
0.4348486661911011,
0.5253855586051941,
-0.7332139611244202,
0.2825740575790405,
0.5771604776382446,
0.4274784326553345,
-0.17314091324806213,
0.11238358169794083,
-0.123715840280056,
-0.05391587316989899,
0.1033862829208374,
-0.011666237376630306,
-0.0644305869936943,
-0.1698046177625656,
-0.2953103184700012,
0.5707216262817383,
0.28791338205337524,
-0.2374899834394455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12580v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12580v1
|
iTBLS: A Dataset of Interactive Conversations Over Tabular Information
| 2024-04-19T02:11:41 | 2024-04-19T02:11:41 |
Anirudh Sundar, Christopher Richardson, William Gay, Larry Heck
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces Interactive Tables (iTBLS), a dataset of interactive
conversations situated in tables from scientific articles. This dataset is
designed to facilitate human-AI collaborative problem-solving through
AI-powered multi-task tabular capabilities. In contrast to prior work that
models interactions as factoid QA or procedure synthesis, iTBLS broadens the
scope of interactions to include mathematical reasoning, natural language
manipulation, and expansion of existing tables from natural language
conversation by delineating interactions into one of three tasks:
interpretation, modification, or generation. Additionally, the paper presents a
suite of baseline approaches to iTBLS, utilizing zero-shot prompting and
parameter-efficient fine-tuning for different computing situations. We also
introduce a novel multi-step approach and show how it can be leveraged in
conjunction with parameter-efficient fine-tuning to achieve the
state-of-the-art on iTBLS; outperforming standard parameter-efficient
fine-tuning by up to 15% on interpretation, 18% on modification, and 38% on
generation.
|
[
-0.5389600396156311,
-1.0653036832809448,
0.4872574210166931,
0.3017105162143707,
-0.08598150312900543,
0.3343743681907654,
-0.28066325187683105,
-0.4068198502063751,
0.33758750557899475,
0.3419570326805115,
-0.4982837736606598,
-0.5810545682907104,
-0.09799341857433319,
-0.051507897675037384,
-0.3368295431137085,
1.2083238363265991,
-0.031045550480484962,
0.0333709791302681,
-0.4779219627380371,
0.07369565218687057,
-0.45294156670570374,
0.059676360338926315,
-0.49083182215690613,
-0.22643166780471802,
0.6991832256317139,
0.9149582982063293,
1.0444457530975342,
0.7854761481285095,
0.7643250226974487,
0.3866407573223114,
0.2904316186904907,
0.3845529854297638,
-0.5407404899597168,
0.3119286596775055,
-0.14665533602237701,
-0.32584348320961,
-0.5565515756607056,
-0.3954891264438629,
0.3993655741214752,
0.9229329228401184,
-0.17189614474773407,
0.2843417525291443,
0.12329772859811783,
0.7490138411521912,
-0.27130332589149475,
0.7414105534553528,
-0.7089843153953552,
0.03488514572381973,
-0.329376757144928,
-0.3625466227531433,
-0.5797387957572937,
-0.2215748280286789,
0.03898874670267105,
-0.7908914685249329,
-0.07719411700963974,
0.4466509222984314,
0.5632038116455078,
0.37190207839012146,
-0.3477429747581482,
-0.29474300146102905,
-0.8195601105690002,
0.6457513570785522,
-0.6575822830200195,
0.41829973459243774,
0.44082558155059814,
0.12521900236606598,
-0.4247736930847168,
-0.8194785118103027,
-0.8140846490859985,
-0.5917168855667114,
-0.4156017005443573,
-0.07107797265052795,
-0.45408937335014343,
0.38621076941490173,
0.40843698382377625,
0.06630813330411911,
-0.5036660432815552,
-0.022151486948132515,
-0.5599770545959473,
0.2790933847427368,
0.7337959408760071,
0.7422835826873779,
0.17642895877361298,
-0.05819149687886238,
0.22766798734664917,
0.12658116221427917,
-0.4558049440383911,
0.1424819976091385,
-0.01311239879578352,
0.4520457684993744,
-0.07858288288116455,
0.7591357231140137,
-0.32127299904823303,
1.1506590843200684,
-0.030780091881752014,
0.19169673323631287,
-0.09715655446052551,
-0.7651081085205078,
-0.0384737104177475,
-0.21585039794445038,
0.7817041873931885,
0.3356405198574066,
-0.051550816744565964,
-0.2332381308078766,
0.5397693514823914,
-0.18069368600845337,
0.5274232625961304,
-0.564448893070221,
-0.44797492027282715,
0.37333759665489197,
-0.08407686650753021,
-0.15812069177627563,
-0.11893361061811447,
-0.7987309694290161,
-0.31921762228012085,
-0.7058008313179016,
0.3890012204647064,
-0.46354940533638,
0.1088656634092331,
-0.2202509492635727,
0.0526956282556057,
-0.3142871856689453,
0.4589023292064667,
-0.7995579242706299,
0.48454099893569946,
0.5002374053001404,
0.651482880115509,
-0.3831506073474884,
-0.3480076789855957,
-0.570054829120636,
0.5776404738426208,
-0.39854705333709717,
0.9797167778015137,
-0.6047290563583374,
-0.37216776609420776,
-0.22476397454738617,
-0.5489005446434021,
0.031102389097213745,
-0.23555001616477966,
0.3093874156475067,
-0.373306542634964,
0.14383535087108612,
-0.44980257749557495,
-0.5181088447570801,
-0.06706427782773972,
0.3919789791107178,
-0.729771077632904,
0.7893218994140625,
-0.1654101014137268,
-0.7786567807197571,
0.44514161348342896,
-1.2610970735549927,
-0.4823360741138458,
0.2166975438594818,
-0.3538823425769806,
-0.34027478098869324,
-0.2627442479133606,
0.10218627750873566,
0.3350795805454254,
-0.24179700016975403,
0.44070184230804443,
-0.4667043685913086,
-0.11333274841308594,
0.15854525566101074,
-0.011673285625874996,
0.6455088257789612,
0.26239141821861267,
-0.21841783821582794,
0.6686541438102722,
-0.6995348334312439,
0.3978591561317444,
-0.23785598576068878,
-0.2324589490890503,
0.03950110077857971,
0.17393329739570618,
-0.21494995057582855,
-0.09125572443008423,
0.1650017946958542,
-0.4449041783809662,
0.500633180141449,
-0.02065783180296421,
0.41757938265800476,
0.1938582807779312,
0.11709969490766525,
0.42405688762664795,
-0.5363306999206543,
0.022322142496705055,
-0.1414434313774109,
0.39908042550086975,
-0.1955420970916748,
-0.5765356421470642,
-0.8533243536949158,
-0.416051983833313,
0.3038129210472107,
0.516685962677002,
-1.0782312154769897,
0.5105693340301514,
-0.21171678602695465,
-0.7113599181175232,
-0.5597777366638184,
0.11296141147613525,
0.19431117177009583,
0.6837134957313538,
0.6006476879119873,
0.0499153807759285,
-0.4737173318862915,
-0.937654972076416,
-0.1700226217508316,
-0.3820807635784149,
-0.04998013377189636,
0.2030199021100998,
0.3472684323787689,
0.10237540304660797,
1.194515585899353,
-0.2622047960758209,
-0.4543428421020508,
-0.25154009461402893,
0.6571645736694336,
0.08593577891588211,
0.5881556868553162,
0.20674169063568115,
-0.6409761309623718,
-1.0005654096603394,
0.10582558065652847,
-0.8932104110717773,
-0.10368664562702179,
-0.2659513056278229,
-0.06281880289316177,
0.07986079156398773,
0.3924465775489807,
-0.6792079210281372,
0.7253478765487671,
0.01505471020936966,
-0.31620684266090393,
0.19383174180984497,
-0.2963397204875946,
0.42886078357696533,
-0.7384399771690369,
0.13258996605873108,
-0.04476368799805641,
0.05631599202752113,
-1.0056649446487427,
-0.10534423589706421,
-0.19363565742969513,
-0.022270942106842995,
-0.12672880291938782,
0.41076043248176575,
-0.5762847661972046,
-0.2010992020368576,
0.061782535165548325,
0.20163975656032562,
0.05883724242448807,
0.6688036322593689,
-0.048187777400016785,
0.6135836243629456,
0.2948777377605438,
-0.44645974040031433,
0.4229181706905365,
0.8121885657310486,
-0.18444021046161652,
0.7234979271888733,
-0.5191150307655334,
0.21377596259117126,
-0.00677023408934474,
0.10086599737405777,
-0.9082596302032471,
-0.24571558833122253,
0.18479323387145996,
-0.3195044994354248,
0.26305893063545227,
0.34830087423324585,
-0.7018505930900574,
-0.4574640095233917,
-0.5511595010757446,
0.11886828392744064,
-0.16119949519634247,
-0.25117579102516174,
0.755974292755127,
0.4992673099040985,
-0.6889142394065857,
-0.4472762644290924,
-0.40679872035980225,
0.6030075550079346,
0.043038323521614075,
-0.7790831327438354,
0.6338563561439514,
-0.460191011428833,
-0.690977156162262,
0.2549474537372589,
0.258040189743042,
-0.23017410933971405,
-0.16418078541755676,
0.28494542837142944,
0.27095022797584534,
0.269492506980896,
0.030115138739347458,
0.2989960014820099,
0.005749924574047327,
-0.23435808718204498,
0.3304935395717621,
0.39196130633354187,
-0.362856388092041,
-0.6481471061706543,
-0.7266111969947815,
0.5917463302612305,
0.43792396783828735,
-0.08261284232139587,
0.6121939420700073,
0.45187681913375854,
-0.25566351413726807,
0.2214786261320114,
-0.5180469155311584,
-0.19034884870052338,
-0.5314301252365112,
0.2272075116634369,
-0.36499419808387756,
-0.6255180239677429,
0.588134765625,
0.27555373311042786,
0.7258204817771912,
0.11326433718204498,
0.651608943939209,
-0.5798569917678833,
1.1945558786392212,
0.5500704646110535,
0.1276056319475174,
0.5655981302261353,
-0.1204877719283104,
0.23551753163337708,
-0.40535253286361694,
-0.5401438474655151,
-0.7434669137001038,
-0.49455904960632324,
-0.42999884486198425,
-0.15881270170211792,
0.8899010419845581,
-0.2330198734998703,
-0.4124089479446411,
0.4063046872615814,
-0.43272531032562256,
0.48555469512939453,
0.8238012194633484,
0.22263599932193756,
0.6982060670852661,
-0.09131663292646408,
0.355904221534729,
-0.39720964431762695,
-0.859997034072876,
-0.33798375725746155,
0.8097184300422668,
-0.03562283515930176,
0.740540087223053,
0.06996151804924011,
0.49678224325180054,
0.6615656614303589,
0.4459846317768097,
-0.6197606325149536,
0.6513059735298157,
0.15564146637916565,
-0.6750130653381348,
-0.6759604215621948,
-0.49205389618873596,
-1.0330827236175537,
-0.03598162159323692,
-0.5893262028694153,
-1.2766902446746826,
-0.23089385032653809,
0.34906789660453796,
-0.39032500982284546,
0.2364644706249237,
-0.8579847812652588,
0.8181689977645874,
-0.3642604649066925,
-0.848975419998169,
-0.5268349647521973,
-0.7275144457817078,
0.12889160215854645,
0.22714148461818695,
0.2780366837978363,
0.22699740529060364,
0.30568796396255493,
0.6896584033966064,
-0.32673147320747375,
0.780298113822937,
-0.07214585691690445,
0.20695315301418304,
0.40803059935569763,
0.4264426827430725,
0.3492984175682068,
0.1138971671462059,
-0.3587992489337921,
0.14459611475467682,
0.3088127672672272,
-0.3184799551963806,
-0.5778846740722656,
0.5166125893592834,
-0.30519935488700867,
-0.6927403211593628,
-0.165908083319664,
-1.2497509717941284,
-0.5461211204528809,
0.24668115377426147,
-0.12304121255874634,
0.4556787312030792,
0.03073241002857685,
0.44878897070884705,
0.14615139365196228,
-0.06493266671895981,
0.4973338544368744,
0.6056398749351501,
0.01641380414366722,
-0.2832755148410797,
0.9817005395889282,
0.2760843336582184,
0.004992903675884008,
0.33461815118789673,
-0.08931618183851242,
-0.08163390308618546,
-0.7687459588050842,
-0.5863302946090698,
-0.05785281956195831,
-0.3824000954627991,
-0.4859929382801056,
-0.5586492419242859,
0.01154704112559557,
-0.1276674121618271,
-0.2327519804239273,
-0.05176066234707832,
-0.40813493728637695,
-0.4065796434879303,
-0.1224968433380127,
0.5864041447639465,
0.9500748515129089,
-0.28881436586380005,
0.38565364480018616,
-1.0752917528152466,
0.4817568063735962,
0.22187864780426025,
0.4577100872993469,
-0.14996999502182007,
-0.28488636016845703,
-0.27735355496406555,
0.04559565335512161,
-0.4539937674999237,
-1.0259068012237549,
0.35197627544403076,
0.28048914670944214,
0.7185350060462952,
0.16149656474590302,
0.1214551329612732,
0.9353983998298645,
-0.5265905261039734,
0.793240487575531,
0.057801973074674606,
-1.028676986694336,
0.24181072413921356,
-0.4565422534942627,
0.1626194715499878,
0.9217848777770996,
0.40816840529441833,
-0.18275833129882812,
-0.43764838576316833,
-0.5689237117767334,
-0.7549898624420166,
0.8464325070381165,
0.30906304717063904,
-0.189433291554451,
0.37158966064453125,
0.1987515687942505,
0.26120540499687195,
0.5545198917388916,
-0.49216723442077637,
-0.23769629001617432,
0.09596113115549088,
-0.5438175797462463,
0.4734205901622772,
0.03564576059579849,
-0.4216807782649994,
-0.6304864287376404,
0.6458105444908142,
-0.3361224830150604,
0.23377323150634766,
-0.31206610798835754,
-0.015740416944026947,
-0.4785134494304657,
0.24500514566898346,
0.3556261360645294,
0.8806282877922058,
-0.10536786168813705,
-0.013810909353196621,
0.2765944004058838,
-0.1481032818555832,
-0.43988847732543945,
0.33292752504348755,
-0.06773306429386139,
-0.18292023241519928,
0.2774587869644165,
0.8587300777435303,
0.14356371760368347,
-0.5592218041419983,
0.024099357426166534,
-0.208114892244339,
-0.15460103750228882,
0.16211894154548645,
0.16504055261611938,
0.16856373846530914,
0.45490723848342896,
0.4719734489917755,
-0.24446886777877808,
0.383912593126297,
-0.7365948557853699,
0.4967316687107086,
0.742997407913208,
-0.19915908575057983,
-0.21371740102767944,
0.5451956391334534,
0.28360700607299805,
-0.7637074589729309,
0.4903624951839447,
-0.3726804852485657,
-0.11122538149356842,
0.4556257128715515,
0.2504216134548187,
0.1766161173582077,
0.08673437684774399,
0.5641875267028809,
0.25404706597328186,
0.1567324548959732,
0.3572315275669098,
0.6026269197463989,
-0.3996354043483734,
-0.4685216546058655,
-0.3499974310398102,
-0.11195392161607742,
-1.1425261497497559,
0.18279200792312622,
-0.7188825607299805,
0.29972130060195923,
-0.2837972939014435,
-0.11552649736404419,
0.4581918716430664,
0.10279752314090729,
-0.6171368956565857,
-0.20587389171123505,
-0.16741105914115906,
0.6949244737625122,
-0.44579946994781494,
0.5700273513793945,
0.582736611366272,
-0.40089622139930725,
-0.65838623046875,
-0.39390692114830017,
-0.17038758099079132,
-0.5277178883552551,
0.3910633325576782,
-0.21837489306926727,
0.33703848719596863,
0.30619025230407715,
-0.9038583040237427,
-0.8358560800552368,
0.9386852979660034,
0.39380374550819397,
-0.45965686440467834,
-0.06781190633773804,
0.40332216024398804,
0.805006206035614,
-0.033922772854566574,
0.631934642791748,
0.7860686182975769,
0.8187316656112671,
-0.008091548457741737,
-1.3406684398651123,
-0.10180165618658066,
-0.4410971999168396,
-0.574956476688385,
0.1516934633255005,
-0.4921617805957794,
0.6492568254470825,
-0.37940362095832825,
0.022763116285204887,
-0.06843063235282898,
0.721255898475647,
0.3282451033592224,
0.5240644812583923,
0.4526459574699402,
0.22772692143917084,
0.6950675249099731,
-0.1584893763065338,
0.38318321108818054,
-0.32417920231819153,
-0.0082527045160532,
1.246020793914795,
-0.5725266337394714,
0.6275264620780945,
0.5958854556083679,
-0.3265249729156494,
0.5299261808395386,
0.3177822530269623,
-0.09968601912260056,
0.3489920198917389,
0.15327271819114685,
-0.19152545928955078,
0.016358692198991776,
-0.38234931230545044,
-0.03836144134402275,
0.3363293409347534,
0.8913630843162537,
0.2881135940551758,
-0.5350533127784729,
0.10456275194883347,
-0.10237382352352142,
0.14293666183948517,
-0.20181825757026672,
1.1217759847640991,
-0.2229297012090683,
-0.7352541089057922,
0.2042810469865799,
-0.3738158643245697,
0.19824734330177307,
-0.49732038378715515,
-0.5442067980766296,
0.05193997547030449,
-0.2911948263645172,
-0.3709940016269684,
-1.260380744934082,
0.3933071494102478,
0.14940288662910461,
0.1232546865940094,
-0.2508307695388794,
0.5273715853691101,
-0.5979037880897522,
-0.14090222120285034,
-0.15348966419696808,
0.7317125797271729,
0.006143790669739246,
0.17266492545604706,
-0.8167101740837097,
0.2745485007762909,
0.11289887130260468,
-0.3401406407356262,
0.22942183911800385,
0.2627037465572357,
-0.2724297344684601,
0.9240198135375977,
0.49149003624916077,
-0.02840672992169857,
-0.03587229177355766,
-0.06241987645626068,
1.0849634408950806,
-0.6371175050735474,
-0.5721213221549988,
-0.48544466495513916,
0.7571550011634827,
-0.3902495503425598,
0.04792512208223343,
0.4905230402946472,
0.369585782289505,
0.54566890001297,
0.1522180587053299,
0.7619789838790894,
-0.39310017228126526,
0.5119305849075317,
-0.29410600662231445,
0.5965062379837036,
-0.2666911780834198,
0.22004453837871552,
-0.2855018377304077,
-0.6786283850669861,
-0.4947039484977722,
0.5833103060722351,
-0.29573407769203186,
-0.15062588453292847,
0.6555330753326416,
0.5766791105270386,
0.1398743838071823,
0.4370952248573303,
0.152953639626503,
0.31239885091781616,
0.5969264507293701,
0.05401461571455002,
0.6988285779953003,
-0.038254592567682266,
0.6524750590324402,
-0.4914049506187439,
-0.16893155872821808,
-0.0876735970377922,
-1.0101056098937988,
-0.7815914154052734,
-0.8002264499664307,
-0.28843986988067627,
-0.08333679288625717,
-0.05778967961668968,
1.1211200952529907,
0.49410098791122437,
-0.9745722413063049,
-0.3258715271949768,
-0.23980847001075745,
0.0028144230600446463,
-0.03497198596596718,
-0.273592084646225,
0.2526889741420746,
-0.36311718821525574,
-0.6743107438087463,
0.5559141039848328,
0.22463738918304443,
-0.19988223910331726,
-0.23689520359039307,
0.39342424273490906,
-0.24047793447971344,
-0.03606054559350014,
0.43471622467041016,
0.5410724878311157,
-0.2813555896282196,
-0.21912704408168793,
0.18905869126319885,
-0.0025733995717018843,
0.225993812084198,
0.7342966198921204,
-0.6724737882614136,
0.5489419102668762,
0.48949459195137024,
0.7228522300720215,
0.8513437509536743,
0.09935969859361649,
0.510719895362854,
-0.8651989698410034,
0.002047718968242407,
0.40585529804229736,
0.18661700189113617,
0.3630342483520508,
-0.3304467499256134,
0.42903932929039,
-0.20215316116809845,
-0.6032688021659851,
-1.0307812690734863,
0.039295393973588943,
-1.238736629486084,
-0.123781718313694,
0.8709826469421387,
0.14822642505168915,
-0.03800394758582115,
-0.5163074731826782,
-0.6053525805473328,
0.41274362802505493,
-0.73518306016922,
1.2503819465637207,
0.38480639457702637,
-0.9242079257965088,
0.020318062976002693,
-0.4764255881309509,
0.6443116664886475,
0.4956514537334442,
-1.6021955013275146,
0.17175167798995972,
0.6628183722496033,
-0.38845294713974,
0.5656705498695374,
0.678206205368042,
0.20384714007377625,
0.04112190008163452,
-0.07777699083089828,
0.05779062584042549,
-0.3615376055240631,
-0.6224086284637451,
0.19438263773918152,
0.2053154557943344,
-0.03649512305855751,
0.049529220908880234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12560v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12560v1
|
Dubo-SQL: Diverse Retrieval-Augmented Generation and Fine Tuning for Text-to-SQL
| 2024-04-19T00:48:30 | 2024-04-19T00:48:30 |
Dayton G. Thorpe, Andrew J. Duberstein, Ian A. Kinsey
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DB
|
The current state-of-the-art (SOTA) for automated text-to-SQL still falls
well short of expert human performance as measured by execution accuracy (EX)
on the BIRD-SQL benchmark. The most accurate methods are also slow and
expensive. To advance the SOTA for text-to-SQL while reducing cost and
improving speed, we explore the combination of low-cost fine tuning, novel
methods for diverse retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) and new input and
output formats that help large language models (LLMs) achieve higher EX. We
introduce two new methods, Dubo-SQL v1 and v2. Dubo-SQL v1 sets a new record
for EX on the holdout test set of BIRD-SQL. Dubo-SQL v2 achieves even higher
performance on the BIRD-SQL dev set. Dubo-SQL v1 relies on LLMs from OpenAI,
but uses the low-cost GPT-3.5 Turbo while exceeding the performance of the
next-best model using OpenAI, which instead uses the more expensive GPT-4.
Dubo-SQL v1 exceeds the performance of the next-best model using GPT-3.5 by
over 20%. Dubo-SQL v2 uses GPT-4 Turbo and RAG in place of fine tuning to push
EX higher.
|
[
-0.35695046186447144,
-0.9135144948959351,
0.22662070393562317,
0.15495184063911438,
-0.23885416984558105,
0.16132967174053192,
-0.220149964094162,
-0.6584340929985046,
0.0994490385055542,
0.8658201694488525,
-0.4342932403087616,
-0.1142016127705574,
-0.381197452545166,
0.4428587257862091,
-0.1264224648475647,
1.1862215995788574,
0.33635351061820984,
-0.03720889240503311,
0.038232576102018356,
-0.10701879858970642,
-0.6242794990539551,
-0.44042715430259705,
-0.6112009286880493,
-0.016830889508128166,
0.3400821089744568,
0.7541242837905884,
0.8131044507026672,
0.5730352401733398,
0.5720239877700806,
0.21369542181491852,
-0.0693671852350235,
0.6135911345481873,
-0.6484251022338867,
0.3488028347492218,
-0.3416861891746521,
-0.6478845477104187,
-0.7838282585144043,
-0.43249407410621643,
0.6588397026062012,
0.25946521759033203,
-0.16180960834026337,
0.05586520582437515,
-0.3530225455760956,
1.1543997526168823,
-0.7281959652900696,
-0.05702584981918335,
-1.0599842071533203,
-0.10931973904371262,
-0.5695047974586487,
-0.2024720311164856,
-0.5165417194366455,
-0.4062620997428894,
-0.2986990213394165,
-0.6349065899848938,
0.06848710775375366,
0.4196908473968506,
0.8855199217796326,
0.35642802715301514,
-0.5191324949264526,
-0.25104743242263794,
-0.6971207857131958,
0.8694825172424316,
-0.8037587404251099,
0.3772905468940735,
0.22295251488685608,
0.4434882402420044,
-0.37808093428611755,
-0.643415093421936,
-0.6608213782310486,
-0.23038923740386963,
0.12464916706085205,
0.10677585005760193,
0.18610815703868866,
0.024372678250074387,
0.29675087332725525,
0.5607975721359253,
-0.4360935091972351,
0.19599047303199768,
-0.3748907744884491,
0.16657444834709167,
0.9484525322914124,
0.1922852098941803,
0.032775916159152985,
-0.060095079243183136,
-0.13046689331531525,
-0.0005655248533003032,
-0.7591977119445801,
-0.17523087561130524,
0.23161083459854126,
0.6098013520240784,
0.2758626341819763,
0.7420942783355713,
-0.3977382779121399,
0.8486266136169434,
-0.07125245034694672,
0.1625855714082718,
0.014398223720490932,
-0.6483960151672363,
-0.16955265402793884,
-0.15602782368659973,
0.8502762317657471,
0.311186820268631,
0.4292078912258148,
-0.013749625533819199,
-0.37207478284835815,
-0.26805636286735535,
0.15242759883403778,
-0.8164278864860535,
0.00855846144258976,
0.13518238067626953,
-0.26166677474975586,
-0.44022950530052185,
-0.0995466411113739,
-0.9026957154273987,
-0.41888973116874695,
-0.30207300186157227,
0.472263902425766,
-0.31732383370399475,
-0.2442813366651535,
-0.2791481614112854,
-0.21011324226856232,
0.24426138401031494,
0.42648938298225403,
-1.0123037099838257,
0.6849777698516846,
0.6476106643676758,
0.7051575779914856,
-0.6090639233589172,
-0.056088853627443314,
-1.0203713178634644,
-0.018352070823311806,
-0.6059523224830627,
0.7864987850189209,
-0.6632757782936096,
-0.32481828331947327,
-0.2810848355293274,
-0.2382064014673233,
0.33960041403770447,
-0.8765760064125061,
0.261439710855484,
-0.636921763420105,
0.0699402317404747,
-0.19207964837551117,
-0.554796040058136,
-0.050967585295438766,
0.06588304042816162,
-0.6436168551445007,
1.4187296628952026,
0.24197706580162048,
-0.4253532588481903,
0.22916221618652344,
-0.5608136057853699,
-0.538101315498352,
0.03291473537683487,
-0.23404549062252045,
-0.4307954013347626,
0.3257679045200348,
0.16399617493152618,
0.2721961438655853,
-0.8597793579101562,
0.00881117768585682,
0.0717732161283493,
-0.5985092520713806,
-0.0705786943435669,
-0.04754268005490303,
0.5013898015022278,
0.3910371959209442,
-0.12309515476226807,
0.05773257091641426,
-0.9591095447540283,
0.20963478088378906,
0.22815802693367004,
-0.39434462785720825,
-0.24464812874794006,
-0.040697477757930756,
0.07208434492349625,
-0.09149632602930069,
0.2739172577857971,
-0.363355427980423,
0.3217402696609497,
-0.6824369430541992,
0.2557648718357086,
0.45558902621269226,
-0.07828009873628616,
0.4290863275527954,
-0.2640236020088196,
0.38409921526908875,
-0.02881719544529915,
0.22025662660598755,
-0.17869846522808075,
-0.6396332383155823,
-0.5790776014328003,
-0.23445641994476318,
0.4883222281932831,
0.7274214625358582,
-0.7227504253387451,
0.07684066891670227,
-0.025203600525856018,
-0.6141907572746277,
-0.4942030906677246,
0.03569331020116806,
0.3404090404510498,
0.2639724314212799,
0.3930808901786804,
-0.3046201765537262,
-0.6560971736907959,
-0.736369788646698,
-0.5726950764656067,
0.07409218698740005,
0.16766037046909332,
0.5487078428268433,
0.3522494435310364,
-0.015148290432989597,
0.8980957269668579,
-0.5547229647636414,
-0.3673458397388458,
-0.08024471253156662,
0.02856726013123989,
0.3901286721229553,
0.46477240324020386,
0.3543464243412018,
-0.7888517379760742,
-0.7534315586090088,
0.4366746246814728,
-0.29201170802116394,
0.08694935590028763,
0.10882751643657684,
0.05561402067542076,
0.6824923157691956,
0.29864078760147095,
-0.29994043707847595,
0.25407400727272034,
0.4054619073867798,
-0.16482840478420258,
0.6477400064468384,
-0.335802286863327,
0.35923564434051514,
-1.0304862260818481,
-0.07734228670597076,
-0.3438591957092285,
-0.38126248121261597,
-0.6310875415802002,
0.17452943325042725,
0.14081554114818573,
-0.12135599553585052,
-0.3505200445652008,
0.49557262659072876,
-0.5050768256187439,
-0.22555255889892578,
-0.2501823902130127,
0.1419743448495865,
-0.03070424124598503,
0.23188261687755585,
-0.16816040873527527,
1.2359509468078613,
0.43544644117355347,
-0.704699695110321,
0.29192668199539185,
0.16349729895591736,
-0.05498999357223511,
0.18043577671051025,
-0.7933219075202942,
0.30458375811576843,
-0.01734999567270279,
0.021376412361860275,
-0.7950417995452881,
-0.15519508719444275,
-0.10887862741947174,
-0.5258814096450806,
0.5639306902885437,
-0.2039583921432495,
-0.4845463037490845,
0.05506246164441109,
-0.40097513794898987,
0.33422282338142395,
0.7610905766487122,
-0.40983983874320984,
0.4148562550544739,
0.3972862958908081,
-0.19354747235774994,
-0.7548241019248962,
-0.6144111156463623,
0.18616683781147003,
0.08568692207336426,
-0.4408425986766815,
0.5066047310829163,
0.22516608238220215,
-0.15725462138652802,
-0.32841628789901733,
-0.06678478419780731,
-0.2394142895936966,
-0.15418076515197754,
-0.14389482140541077,
0.24954989552497864,
-0.3317713141441345,
0.17068956792354584,
0.23877550661563873,
-0.016132181510329247,
-0.484701931476593,
-0.16500847041606903,
0.38351792097091675,
-0.1851801872253418,
0.2296849638223648,
-0.1899191439151764,
0.528354823589325,
0.3594226539134979,
-0.5289848446846008,
0.7142492532730103,
0.23980370163917542,
-0.24517755210399628,
-0.2743874192237854,
-0.6643300652503967,
-0.18047159910202026,
-0.4593961536884308,
0.4557969272136688,
-0.6542046666145325,
-0.7058916091918945,
0.2943961024284363,
-0.3581360876560211,
0.3113958537578583,
0.5608485341072083,
0.4827100932598114,
-0.0976189374923706,
0.8100704550743103,
0.6029492616653442,
0.36833655834198,
0.4534936845302582,
-0.1666862666606903,
0.0067405691370368,
-0.7229364514350891,
-0.11388568580150604,
-0.832873523235321,
-0.04784548655152321,
-0.879525899887085,
-0.5541611909866333,
0.15553893148899078,
0.3453907370567322,
-0.2594546377658844,
0.3978300392627716,
-0.7185407876968384,
0.6453303694725037,
0.47347816824913025,
-0.06133115664124489,
0.7202354669570923,
0.09876323491334915,
0.1804453432559967,
-0.10479775816202164,
-0.5928158760070801,
-0.3205014169216156,
1.2760640382766724,
-0.03457498550415039,
0.7771154046058655,
0.21661263704299927,
0.7467750310897827,
0.3548092246055603,
0.17066948115825653,
-0.6873857378959656,
0.5154094099998474,
-0.6733384132385254,
-0.6977025866508484,
-0.49086183309555054,
-0.5583326816558838,
-0.8257387280464172,
0.15145716071128845,
-0.3618675172328949,
-0.39391642808914185,
0.035679277032613754,
0.23768973350524902,
-0.12132032215595245,
0.09502114355564117,
-0.7158747315406799,
0.6671022772789001,
-0.061700332909822464,
-0.4308229982852936,
-0.19523736834526062,
-0.4993521571159363,
0.36536768078804016,
-0.27286288142204285,
0.07683716714382172,
-0.12431683391332626,
-0.5442095398902893,
0.5496007800102234,
-0.5955696105957031,
0.304821252822876,
-0.06062113866209984,
-0.0015863406006246805,
0.284798800945282,
0.05659838765859604,
0.8689600229263306,
-0.04880744218826294,
-0.6429659128189087,
0.2214166820049286,
0.15938934683799744,
-0.2474127560853958,
-0.6529760956764221,
0.6729369759559631,
-0.5903768539428711,
-0.4575175344944,
-0.37795501947402954,
-0.617232084274292,
-0.13730207085609436,
0.2721443176269531,
0.3632854223251343,
0.3076310157775879,
-0.04881337285041809,
0.31883004307746887,
0.6179837584495544,
-0.3264143168926239,
0.13183560967445374,
0.5176473259925842,
-0.2949472665786743,
-0.5642438530921936,
0.8972505927085876,
0.3414141535758972,
0.37400954961776733,
0.6445673704147339,
0.28932657837867737,
-0.4494982659816742,
-0.6270574331283569,
-0.5257155895233154,
0.3007540702819824,
-0.31409016251564026,
-0.4216965436935425,
-0.49323907494544983,
-0.09152831882238388,
-0.4240587055683136,
0.1549447476863861,
-0.6946617960929871,
-0.7968538999557495,
-0.0699765756726265,
0.40277254581451416,
0.7169316411018372,
0.7820828557014465,
0.08849883079528809,
0.199815034866333,
-0.7140947580337524,
0.42903396487236023,
0.1043320894241333,
0.38536736369132996,
-0.1664058268070221,
-0.5884968042373657,
-0.07063818722963333,
-0.1365634799003601,
-0.40434160828590393,
-0.9016590714454651,
0.19994322955608368,
0.610069990158081,
0.11698809266090393,
-0.1762581169605255,
0.33477479219436646,
0.689307451248169,
-0.7373889088630676,
0.684962272644043,
0.10285332798957825,
-0.7471400499343872,
0.9536246061325073,
-0.37326568365097046,
-0.09148696064949036,
0.6268537640571594,
0.2469763308763504,
-0.14240005612373352,
-0.314779132604599,
-0.39770379662513733,
-0.7151832580566406,
0.9234845042228699,
0.3651655316352844,
-0.05310668423771858,
0.09252820909023285,
0.55033940076828,
0.45664581656455994,
0.12559650838375092,
-0.44573989510536194,
-0.24635350704193115,
-0.07700715959072113,
-0.17618942260742188,
-0.04836517572402954,
-0.15997745096683502,
0.2237524390220642,
-0.2421470284461975,
0.6639457941055298,
-0.2587741017341614,
-0.016593223437666893,
0.15564469993114471,
0.13954678177833557,
0.00016194864292629063,
0.3084133565425873,
0.5162937045097351,
0.4337449073791504,
-0.3513067662715912,
-0.2684038281440735,
0.4581871032714844,
-0.4208734929561615,
-0.0622234083712101,
-0.10572811961174011,
-0.34864503145217896,
0.1277998983860016,
-0.16385972499847412,
0.711399495601654,
-0.09417659044265747,
-0.7105605602264404,
0.23964278399944305,
-0.05087815225124359,
-0.023467889055609703,
-0.14063793420791626,
0.3925493657588959,
0.05452362447977066,
-0.003180210944265127,
0.2787052392959595,
0.21252253651618958,
0.42174720764160156,
-0.8638242483139038,
0.08297600597143173,
0.4130028486251831,
-0.12429974228143692,
0.05186828225851059,
0.6924993395805359,
0.2963796555995941,
-0.655916154384613,
0.6070857644081116,
-0.1822901964187622,
-0.1518724262714386,
0.639363169670105,
0.6466124057769775,
0.6265966892242432,
-0.2607385814189911,
-0.2244720458984375,
0.5647047162055969,
0.2648313641548157,
-0.2730141580104828,
0.779310941696167,
-0.1405738890171051,
-0.4190180003643036,
-0.5455078482627869,
-0.6249204874038696,
-0.6455503702163696,
-0.161356121301651,
-0.563962996006012,
0.45377039909362793,
-0.3703031539916992,
-0.25723886489868164,
-0.006195469293743372,
0.3673299252986908,
-0.317111611366272,
0.21590951085090637,
-0.36694806814193726,
0.9756107926368713,
-0.4287009537220001,
0.8906691074371338,
0.7038644552230835,
-0.43463006615638733,
-0.5920792818069458,
-0.06981149315834045,
-0.3511485755443573,
-0.49283626675605774,
0.6166765093803406,
-0.11465809494256973,
-0.06486906111240387,
0.22284500300884247,
-0.26035284996032715,
-0.7793416976928711,
0.9288912415504456,
0.35608893632888794,
-0.7581419348716736,
-0.038737569004297256,
0.11925001442432404,
0.3944905698299408,
-0.21218223869800568,
0.5633717179298401,
0.832079291343689,
0.35570627450942993,
0.05747946351766586,
-1.1214014291763306,
-0.05211017280817032,
-0.028393467888236046,
0.3507890999317169,
0.44175803661346436,
-0.8218922019004822,
0.7985010743141174,
-0.4624783396720886,
-0.13936986029148102,
0.16896770894527435,
0.7234300971031189,
0.574608564376831,
0.2892143726348877,
0.40136846899986267,
0.22209696471691132,
0.755974292755127,
-0.2499811053276062,
1.1036819219589233,
0.0513518825173378,
0.09177440404891968,
1.2331373691558838,
-0.2874722480773926,
1.2885932922363281,
0.3460303544998169,
-0.37696877121925354,
0.25234439969062805,
0.41877642273902893,
0.1759428232908249,
0.32186368107795715,
0.2338624894618988,
0.05562387779355049,
-0.11232427507638931,
-0.14633040130138397,
-0.42707890272140503,
0.4266429543495178,
0.3452596366405487,
0.10293003171682358,
0.08862292766571045,
-0.22314149141311646,
-0.14008936285972595,
0.24358533322811127,
-0.20247530937194824,
0.9194943308830261,
0.0828104168176651,
-0.8118195533752441,
0.9323148131370544,
-0.03326723352074623,
0.8217000365257263,
-0.6550796627998352,
-0.1906193047761917,
-0.5284698605537415,
0.19604842364788055,
-0.3599543571472168,
-0.6592059135437012,
0.5034283995628357,
0.24620532989501953,
-0.23022527992725372,
0.11095558851957321,
0.6575548648834229,
-0.2810486853122711,
-0.36055099964141846,
0.06597332656383514,
0.22595688700675964,
0.44086337089538574,
-0.3009048104286194,
-0.5733085870742798,
0.2580306828022003,
0.022380193695425987,
-0.20293021202087402,
0.2157427966594696,
0.541789174079895,
-0.12871739268302917,
0.48410823941230774,
0.5513086915016174,
0.3032257556915283,
0.23508842289447784,
0.1455426812171936,
0.5957107543945312,
-0.8000643849372864,
-0.28789594769477844,
-0.6862414479255676,
0.2745532989501953,
-0.28179699182510376,
-0.3493930995464325,
0.5127221941947937,
0.8350003957748413,
0.7050245404243469,
-0.18941721320152283,
0.45948874950408936,
-0.13647638261318207,
0.6727709770202637,
-0.5171366333961487,
0.6259948015213013,
-1.1208748817443848,
0.1821046769618988,
-0.2285485863685608,
-1.1285979747772217,
-0.2413201779127121,
0.22656910121440887,
0.14294980466365814,
0.030466962605714798,
0.638018786907196,
1.0336477756500244,
0.28342801332473755,
0.07805217802524567,
0.4439908564090729,
0.32152259349823,
0.3371574878692627,
0.4565294682979584,
0.7561665773391724,
-1.0023082494735718,
0.7229986190795898,
-0.007922532968223095,
-0.3973892629146576,
-0.3325346112251282,
-0.7481873035430908,
-0.5970799922943115,
-0.5002456903457642,
-0.3075835406780243,
-0.1287367343902588,
0.2968827486038208,
0.7360721230506897,
0.797354519367218,
-1.0313464403152466,
-0.36792421340942383,
-0.16854435205459595,
0.06115845590829849,
-0.41709104180336,
-0.19994841516017914,
0.1782391369342804,
-0.7226730585098267,
-0.9975383877754211,
0.5189419388771057,
0.47304338216781616,
-0.10990802943706512,
0.09410683810710907,
-0.13698996603488922,
-0.22205357253551483,
0.24615485966205597,
0.7452514171600342,
0.3716910183429718,
-0.7129902243614197,
0.23222923278808594,
0.05742138624191284,
-0.13300998508930206,
0.23434443771839142,
0.515400767326355,
-0.8377952575683594,
0.4246613085269928,
0.7688692212104797,
0.7479619979858398,
0.752539873123169,
0.07084695249795914,
0.6657295823097229,
-0.7372643947601318,
-0.005206166300922632,
0.3886246979236603,
-0.0986841544508934,
0.17567771673202515,
-0.5214371681213379,
0.842479944229126,
0.15379171073436737,
-0.7033000588417053,
-0.9997888803482056,
0.1877417266368866,
-0.9526960253715515,
-0.19881956279277802,
0.9359624981880188,
0.39732006192207336,
-0.19922293722629547,
-0.11163634061813354,
-0.45543721318244934,
0.25353574752807617,
-0.39536264538764954,
0.5393193364143372,
0.2478540539741516,
-0.21591229736804962,
-0.07886677235364914,
-0.6218401789665222,
0.7680225372314453,
0.6595763564109802,
-0.9387919306755066,
0.2020001858472824,
0.26896733045578003,
0.1792031228542328,
-0.05643918737769127,
0.7652876377105713,
-0.31799495220184326,
0.3512544333934784,
0.1653045117855072,
0.05726530775427818,
-0.2658464014530182,
-0.3709259331226349,
-0.04354060813784599,
-0.0655166283249855,
0.1318991631269455,
-0.13949719071388245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12545v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12545v2
|
Latent Concept-based Explanation of NLP Models
| 2024-04-18T23:50:50 | 2024-06-17T20:24:49 |
Xuemin Yu, Fahim Dalvi, Nadir Durrani, Marzia Nouri, Hassan Sajjad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Interpreting and understanding the predictions made by deep learning models
poses a formidable challenge due to their inherently opaque nature. Many
previous efforts aimed at explaining these predictions rely on input features,
specifically, the words within NLP models. However, such explanations are often
less informative due to the discrete nature of these words and their lack of
contextual verbosity. To address this limitation, we introduce the Latent
Concept Attribution method (LACOAT), which generates explanations for
predictions based on latent concepts. Our foundational intuition is that a word
can exhibit multiple facets, contingent upon the context in which it is used.
Therefore, given a word in context, the latent space derived from our training
process reflects a specific facet of that word. LACOAT functions by mapping the
representations of salient input words into the training latent space, allowing
it to provide latent context-based explanations of the prediction.
|
[
-0.16789589822292328,
-0.7350230813026428,
0.6011145710945129,
0.14553770422935486,
-0.4881041646003723,
0.27344661951065063,
0.1435679942369461,
-0.3229309022426605,
0.28592705726623535,
0.536421000957489,
-0.8931055068969727,
-0.2667926847934723,
-0.3965637683868408,
-0.43308889865875244,
-0.27066347002983093,
1.1623319387435913,
-0.0094531811773777,
-0.23927421867847443,
-0.3452993929386139,
0.17009863257408142,
-0.6601895689964294,
-0.42790836095809937,
-0.5109869241714478,
-0.6879830360412598,
0.6251252889633179,
0.17238202691078186,
0.7314736247062683,
0.40955933928489685,
0.5577816367149353,
0.15794676542282104,
-0.2671874165534973,
0.0331169068813324,
-0.4253745675086975,
0.0029029313009232283,
-0.18880651891231537,
-0.7698244452476501,
-0.478098064661026,
0.28005123138427734,
0.5794761180877686,
1.316222071647644,
0.018935495987534523,
-0.03016611933708191,
0.09857276827096939,
0.6595216989517212,
-0.7083452343940735,
0.2151348888874054,
-1.0067121982574463,
0.4751889407634735,
0.020170122385025024,
-0.3242843449115753,
-0.3739505410194397,
0.0928429588675499,
0.4249519109725952,
-0.8074575066566467,
0.39413386583328247,
-0.04531874880194664,
0.801471471786499,
0.5922942161560059,
0.051064278930425644,
-0.15730009973049164,
-0.6013091206550598,
0.8926213979721069,
-0.7292304635047913,
0.18769530951976776,
0.6294865012168884,
0.15270322561264038,
0.024927979335188866,
-0.660960853099823,
-0.7084380984306335,
-0.027463817968964577,
-0.2637709379196167,
0.35727372765541077,
0.06503094732761383,
-0.09902037680149078,
0.053200095891952515,
0.3306253254413605,
-0.5169601440429688,
0.13575319945812225,
-0.3695460259914398,
-0.18739725649356842,
0.7451086044311523,
-0.042987558990716934,
0.02623661980032921,
-0.07674183696508408,
-0.5753505229949951,
0.3752773702144623,
-0.8219166994094849,
0.1647285372018814,
0.1304626315832138,
0.49632900953292847,
-0.40140825510025024,
0.6033639311790466,
0.20611965656280518,
0.6342158317565918,
0.08493584394454956,
0.09287916868925095,
0.337004691362381,
-0.01659448817372322,
-0.2734562158584595,
0.35969147086143494,
0.5441100001335144,
0.3222369849681854,
-0.07018451392650604,
-0.2142287790775299,
-0.18614062666893005,
0.24319565296173096,
0.3415510356426239,
-0.5317542552947998,
-0.29007232189178467,
0.4692917764186859,
-0.4983539879322052,
-0.7384011149406433,
-0.26605987548828125,
-0.5935460925102234,
-0.4161106050014496,
-0.2058383822441101,
0.23668038845062256,
-0.24576513469219208,
-0.26407569646835327,
-0.040571797639131546,
0.018792102113366127,
-0.021579548716545105,
0.4787178933620453,
-0.9964712262153625,
0.2807287871837616,
0.7188993692398071,
1.0542315244674683,
-0.4326844811439514,
-0.07357317954301834,
-0.5824787616729736,
0.12169268727302551,
-0.6636790633201599,
0.745225191116333,
-0.5703994631767273,
-0.22641652822494507,
-0.08650030195713043,
-0.24358750879764557,
-0.06752142310142517,
-0.4502392113208771,
0.26128923892974854,
-0.7129551768302917,
0.2573421895503998,
-0.21133741736412048,
-0.7333257794380188,
-0.41867053508758545,
-0.04348386451601982,
-0.6562387943267822,
0.7601320147514343,
0.012454280629754066,
-0.7094824910163879,
0.42087870836257935,
-1.1727051734924316,
-0.26943108439445496,
0.22571441531181335,
-0.22125284373760223,
-0.2917460501194,
0.49069225788116455,
0.24687333405017853,
0.8331246376037598,
-0.041009023785591125,
0.45964860916137695,
-0.3582737147808075,
-0.15888747572898865,
0.6239755749702454,
-0.436517596244812,
0.8121431469917297,
0.25472280383110046,
-0.15703235566616058,
-0.08034411817789078,
-0.5806658864021301,
-0.10116444528102875,
0.06820418685674667,
-0.1000858023762703,
-0.2924209237098694,
0.3260830342769623,
-0.09295565634965897,
-0.07345514744520187,
0.11616572737693787,
-0.3606702983379364,
-0.07170111685991287,
-0.7807838916778564,
0.59797203540802,
0.7137168049812317,
-0.021584080532193184,
0.6219843029975891,
-0.11342446506023407,
0.598799467086792,
0.14077726006507874,
-0.1799650341272354,
-0.3322901725769043,
-0.7283447980880737,
-0.401175320148468,
-0.13261838257312775,
0.16460786759853363,
0.39284849166870117,
-0.7280135750770569,
0.23024459183216095,
-0.06817626953125,
-0.2641700804233551,
-0.3196633458137512,
0.032126087695360184,
0.23342852294445038,
0.7921598553657532,
0.3866140842437744,
-0.3855242133140564,
-0.37243881821632385,
-0.8377669453620911,
0.027778513729572296,
-0.43086928129196167,
0.02509383112192154,
0.25304096937179565,
0.741273045539856,
-0.036744292825460434,
1.3011786937713623,
-0.557828426361084,
-0.09471242129802704,
-0.003727405332028866,
0.406806081533432,
0.3421740233898163,
0.501757025718689,
0.5698590278625488,
-1.100229024887085,
-0.03974967077374458,
-0.149712935090065,
-0.8983878493309021,
-0.12377092987298965,
-0.2553339898586273,
0.11126721650362015,
-0.1631256490945816,
0.5683766007423401,
-0.3405713737010956,
0.4555355906486511,
0.6151288151741028,
-0.2714245319366455,
0.8268542289733887,
0.12486211955547333,
-0.5907083749771118,
-0.8606388568878174,
-0.0808950737118721,
-0.268667608499527,
0.009105369448661804,
-0.5962871313095093,
0.2126474231481552,
-0.22485293447971344,
-0.33603620529174805,
-0.530068576335907,
0.7057570815086365,
-0.17051872611045837,
-0.25060510635375977,
-0.134721577167511,
0.2568556070327759,
0.376172810792923,
0.3583173155784607,
0.35211968421936035,
0.7525944113731384,
0.42907044291496277,
-0.620790958404541,
0.40171048045158386,
0.2470424473285675,
-0.16429774463176727,
0.3602573871612549,
-0.8613066673278809,
-0.07217267155647278,
-0.07385791093111038,
0.28396013379096985,
-1.1569995880126953,
-0.05466122925281525,
0.14629104733467102,
-0.658750593662262,
0.2546162009239197,
-0.15773575007915497,
-0.12649786472320557,
-0.2966938316822052,
-0.19944964349269867,
0.39373183250427246,
0.13632835447788239,
-0.5342483520507812,
0.605821967124939,
0.19600901007652283,
-0.22040116786956787,
-0.954008162021637,
-1.0462580919265747,
-0.03094063699245453,
-0.4035259187221527,
-0.4047008156776428,
0.7243149280548096,
-0.16539940237998962,
-0.38241109251976013,
0.12042198330163956,
-0.17356301844120026,
-0.4022507667541504,
0.5481122732162476,
0.44117823243141174,
0.40710604190826416,
-0.5977150797843933,
0.4552607536315918,
0.1658160388469696,
-0.2013217955827713,
0.2934107482433319,
-0.413369745016098,
0.3241881728172302,
-0.28592589497566223,
-0.3054390549659729,
-0.38696974515914917,
0.2839801013469696,
0.21077944338321686,
-0.2546440064907074,
0.8385984301567078,
0.7364814281463623,
-0.5237822532653809,
-0.38515734672546387,
-0.15803170204162598,
-0.3541812002658844,
-0.42374417185783386,
0.4382370114326477,
-0.5264719128608704,
-0.7580112814903259,
0.8350936770439148,
-0.08706441521644592,
0.002525062533095479,
0.698371171951294,
0.6283564567565918,
-0.5041036009788513,
0.4148959219455719,
0.83570396900177,
0.06067603826522827,
0.22856317460536957,
-0.5643674731254578,
0.3198322057723999,
-0.9208040237426758,
-0.3322533667087555,
-0.29257309436798096,
-0.19825288653373718,
-0.20978499948978424,
-0.6680061221122742,
-0.14620912075042725,
0.45392584800720215,
0.0032895703334361315,
-0.004758063703775406,
-0.478270947933197,
0.3771055042743683,
0.3182350993156433,
-0.013407480902969837,
0.2002408355474472,
0.17945779860019684,
-0.38808518648147583,
-0.33670663833618164,
-0.8214696049690247,
-0.6526320576667786,
1.0340745449066162,
0.6152416467666626,
0.630964457988739,
0.06400447338819504,
0.579033613204956,
0.4546479284763336,
0.3589461147785187,
-1.0692291259765625,
0.24280624091625214,
-0.2400606870651245,
-0.7929362058639526,
-0.3042689859867096,
-0.13564835488796234,
-0.802234411239624,
0.20301924645900726,
-0.44967901706695557,
-1.0729326009750366,
0.362447589635849,
0.21978887915611267,
-0.6945483088493347,
0.24779433012008667,
-0.5290673971176147,
0.7064487934112549,
-0.2492942363023758,
-0.44150596857070923,
-0.1461908370256424,
-0.5212059617042542,
0.48135271668434143,
-0.5200074911117554,
0.3614244759082794,
-0.22757409512996674,
-0.2709652781486511,
0.9565679430961609,
-0.6055972576141357,
1.1445393562316895,
-0.29228225350379944,
-0.3415210247039795,
0.27939271926879883,
0.0643952488899231,
0.07006168365478516,
0.21359416842460632,
-0.16242225468158722,
0.23454083502292633,
-0.3750452399253845,
-0.22143550217151642,
-0.8134346008300781,
0.36547380685806274,
-0.783760666847229,
-0.24966366589069366,
-0.14760705828666687,
-0.6765629649162292,
-0.16411353647708893,
-0.07012498378753662,
0.33002397418022156,
0.41417914628982544,
-0.05582190677523613,
0.1437968909740448,
0.7797238230705261,
-0.36804330348968506,
0.4244076907634735,
0.2951197624206543,
-0.3701752722263336,
0.1938275545835495,
0.8783189654350281,
-0.026370681822299957,
0.07482985407114029,
0.6393474340438843,
0.3954788148403168,
-0.43864870071411133,
-0.7375221252441406,
-0.21711020171642303,
0.15468281507492065,
-0.710538387298584,
0.03583743795752525,
-0.4883056879043579,
-0.2406981736421585,
0.01780010387301445,
-0.5931864380836487,
-0.4998629689216614,
-0.6636830568313599,
-0.6220598220825195,
-0.07281088083982468,
0.18268081545829773,
0.6575612425804138,
-0.06347192078828812,
0.8579854369163513,
-0.47054192423820496,
0.4272189140319824,
0.3682607412338257,
0.27658018469810486,
0.06453102827072144,
-0.8367841839790344,
-0.2442513108253479,
0.05082375556230545,
-0.2116316556930542,
-0.9015935659408569,
0.38497865200042725,
0.5072463750839233,
0.6285725235939026,
0.603452742099762,
-0.20388241112232208,
0.5083529949188232,
-0.5318251848220825,
1.0863038301467896,
0.3729325234889984,
-1.0260118246078491,
0.9628477096557617,
-0.281462699174881,
0.029726434499025345,
0.0638497993350029,
0.5362727046012878,
-0.29908517003059387,
-0.24233920872211456,
-0.8592377305030823,
-1.0024666786193848,
0.5711622834205627,
0.2505193054676056,
0.25880154967308044,
0.3983844816684723,
0.6526721715927124,
0.35294416546821594,
0.3853922486305237,
-0.8497718572616577,
-0.3219543993473053,
-0.4686930179595947,
-0.13286322355270386,
-0.30853766202926636,
-0.37683284282684326,
-0.18392294645309448,
0.05093028023838997,
0.6431187391281128,
-0.35454830527305603,
0.5645982623100281,
-0.056612398475408554,
-0.25940749049186707,
-0.04334665834903717,
-0.10906731337308884,
0.7191795110702515,
0.8415713906288147,
-0.31772470474243164,
0.19115561246871948,
-0.031720586121082306,
-0.44866490364074707,
-0.1276036500930786,
0.14495523273944855,
-0.15882642567157745,
0.4121289849281311,
1.0521461963653564,
0.923779308795929,
-0.04278300702571869,
-0.3552882969379425,
0.5142561793327332,
0.15589921176433563,
-0.2417585849761963,
-0.33951622247695923,
-0.0651957169175148,
0.28788527846336365,
0.3543887138366699,
0.7098647952079773,
0.17980562150478363,
0.12958884239196777,
-0.5089553594589233,
0.30772924423217773,
0.3690398037433624,
-0.5623139142990112,
-0.37139347195625305,
0.8515368700027466,
-0.08407050371170044,
-0.09901805967092514,
0.34009629487991333,
0.052944544702768326,
-0.7123636603355408,
0.7038192749023438,
0.3797476887702942,
0.7420888543128967,
-0.047244686633348465,
0.47379472851753235,
0.11370483785867691,
0.1864059865474701,
0.2933366298675537,
0.12456449866294861,
-0.0800376832485199,
-1.2850574254989624,
-0.8035580515861511,
-0.9435198903083801,
-0.31849536299705505,
0.4926101267337799,
-0.5691849589347839,
-0.2638678550720215,
-0.6215049028396606,
-0.13938294351100922,
0.7246752977371216,
0.01421421393752098,
-0.5361959338188171,
0.4959653615951538,
0.473567932844162,
0.561540424823761,
-1.240647554397583,
0.570020318031311,
0.7290591597557068,
-0.5110639333724976,
-0.765977144241333,
-0.05993644520640373,
0.18885394930839539,
-1.184914469718933,
1.2279173135757446,
0.028348149731755257,
-0.11914848536252975,
-0.3376940190792084,
-0.7967846393585205,
-0.7667052745819092,
0.7037716507911682,
0.4073009788990021,
-0.407711923122406,
-0.020376170054078102,
0.05727370083332062,
0.4577313959598541,
-0.8735148310661316,
0.0055787344463169575,
0.1378265917301178,
0.26886600255966187,
0.14707884192466736,
-0.5873890519142151,
-0.039394132792949677,
-0.18167567253112793,
0.19772928953170776,
-0.5194138288497925,
-0.004194194450974464,
1.007798433303833,
-0.4076054096221924,
0.10205139219760895,
-0.24974238872528076,
0.8678334951400757,
0.28967079520225525,
0.34873029589653015,
0.432323694229126,
0.21999023854732513,
0.9054545164108276,
-0.17336805164813995,
0.9476442337036133,
0.029941417276859283,
0.49266183376312256,
1.4952280521392822,
-0.017803989350795746,
0.9361850023269653,
0.5792824029922485,
-0.28852200508117676,
0.7589337229728699,
1.0320110321044922,
-0.07591439038515091,
0.8294426798820496,
0.2722078561782837,
-0.09934373944997787,
0.025519132614135742,
-0.3226608633995056,
-0.3491089344024658,
0.6568788290023804,
0.9020731449127197,
-0.5272003412246704,
0.05207676813006401,
0.04188099503517151,
-0.19845232367515564,
-0.017185255885124207,
-0.45998772978782654,
0.5923774242401123,
0.33919668197631836,
-0.21153989434242249,
0.6750736832618713,
-0.20425009727478027,
0.5194970369338989,
-0.4093545079231262,
-0.11325611174106598,
-0.07281534373760223,
0.11693654954433441,
-0.4398927092552185,
-0.7917903065681458,
0.578624963760376,
-0.3003014922142029,
-0.39558982849121094,
-0.2843044698238373,
0.6779119372367859,
-0.3326076567173004,
-0.5984057188034058,
0.21519841253757477,
0.7971331477165222,
0.44245004653930664,
-0.2156841903924942,
-1.1278024911880493,
-0.061016492545604706,
-0.11360765248537064,
-0.18014410138130188,
-0.26092344522476196,
0.5734843611717224,
0.0014928841264918447,
0.6700596213340759,
0.5722519755363464,
0.31932979822158813,
-0.1646111160516739,
0.051431793719530106,
0.7070037722587585,
-0.23141373693943024,
-0.603258490562439,
-0.9050857424736023,
0.6982142329216003,
0.13237974047660828,
-0.13489213585853577,
0.23249970376491547,
0.39074867963790894,
0.6270431280136108,
-0.1852329820394516,
0.9264093637466431,
0.13487620651721954,
0.3845963776111603,
-0.8259175419807434,
0.828671932220459,
-0.8750982284545898,
0.4599246680736542,
-0.3788771629333496,
-0.9380742311477661,
-0.31117478013038635,
1.1473089456558228,
-0.29291272163391113,
-0.045435719192028046,
0.9431338906288147,
0.3716735541820526,
-0.13017259538173676,
0.1495974361896515,
0.33036959171295166,
0.29356011748313904,
-0.005349749233573675,
0.2916654050350189,
0.7628265023231506,
-0.18594714999198914,
-0.07166159152984619,
-0.23015505075454712,
-0.1478954702615738,
-0.39450329542160034,
-1.156137466430664,
-0.8373806476593018,
-0.6738398671150208,
-0.5131216049194336,
-0.01991741545498371,
0.002512340433895588,
0.35208067297935486,
0.9560868144035339,
-0.8910799622535706,
-0.13239814341068268,
-0.045960262417793274,
0.235572949051857,
-0.2462451308965683,
-0.26512783765792847,
0.6045077443122864,
-0.3566601872444153,
-0.21507585048675537,
0.4107232391834259,
0.1970059722661972,
0.05602952837944031,
-0.4448990821838379,
0.05194774270057678,
-0.2616207003593445,
-0.13764767348766327,
0.7945961356163025,
-0.09058506786823273,
-1.0438390970230103,
-0.08470332622528076,
-0.3040187358856201,
0.33456557989120483,
0.08323590457439423,
0.7464517951011658,
-0.9225430488586426,
0.45646044611930847,
0.1104540079832077,
0.7255101203918457,
0.6454790830612183,
-0.23028093576431274,
0.8515462279319763,
-0.9359534978866577,
0.27005839347839355,
0.3998521566390991,
0.21477483212947845,
0.4670851528644562,
-0.5028781294822693,
0.7419592142105103,
0.4019220769405365,
0.048117317259311676,
-0.7448813915252686,
0.32523173093795776,
-0.918121337890625,
-0.5834441781044006,
0.5597787499427795,
-0.5904072523117065,
-0.17650437355041504,
-0.1564156860113144,
0.3306051790714264,
0.3255029320716858,
-0.3489571809768677,
0.584598958492279,
0.7157701849937439,
-0.04356493800878525,
-0.22857673466205597,
-0.8933128118515015,
0.568078875541687,
0.5676251649856567,
-0.6386426091194153,
0.15057943761348724,
0.23002272844314575,
-0.09507615864276886,
0.6297633647918701,
0.5532585382461548,
0.11644477397203445,
0.12577594816684723,
0.05169049650430679,
-0.13449272513389587,
0.07269196957349777,
-0.3435578942298889,
-0.37877169251441956,
0.09556469321250916,
-0.004038835875689983,
-0.042245715856552124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12535v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12535v1
|
HalluciBot: Is There No Such Thing as a Bad Question?
| 2024-04-18T22:56:57 | 2024-04-18T22:56:57 |
William Watson, Nicole Cho
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Hallucination continues to be one of the most critical challenges in the
institutional adoption journey of Large Language Models (LLMs). In this
context, an overwhelming number of studies have focused on analyzing the
post-generation phase - refining outputs via feedback, analyzing logit output
values, or deriving clues via the outputs' artifacts. We propose HalluciBot, a
model that predicts the probability of hallucination $\textbf{before
generation}$, for any query imposed to an LLM. In essence, HalluciBot does not
invoke any generation during inference. To derive empirical evidence for
HalluciBot, we employ a Multi-Agent Monte Carlo Simulation using a Query
Perturbator to craft $n$ variations per query at train time. The construction
of our Query Perturbator is motivated by our introduction of a new definition
of hallucination - $\textit{truthful hallucination}$. Our training methodology
generated 2,219,022 estimates for a training corpus of 369,837 queries,
spanning 13 diverse datasets and 3 question-answering scenarios. HalluciBot
predicts both binary and multi-class probabilities of hallucination, enabling a
means to judge the query's quality with regards to its propensity to
hallucinate. Therefore, HalluciBot paves the way to revise or cancel a query
before generation and the ensuing computational waste. Moreover, it provides a
lucid means to measure user accountability for hallucinatory queries.
|
[
-0.5862148404121399,
-0.9459097385406494,
0.6723767518997192,
0.06780704110860825,
-0.24289478361606598,
-0.22509796917438507,
-0.16817426681518555,
-0.45036083459854126,
0.5085951089859009,
0.8661516308784485,
-0.5395074486732483,
-0.46868404746055603,
-0.4354267120361328,
-0.1041552871465683,
-0.6246251463890076,
0.8756853938102722,
0.4101904630661011,
0.13244785368442535,
-0.2454468160867691,
0.25611498951911926,
-0.5611633062362671,
-0.6731203198432922,
-0.34744295477867126,
-0.26313358545303345,
0.6204106211662292,
0.20272977650165558,
0.6977032423019409,
0.13521982729434967,
0.3325278162956238,
0.21258075535297394,
0.21995984017848969,
-0.052257902920246124,
-0.7285190224647522,
0.34616193175315857,
-0.12312290817499161,
-0.5651124119758606,
-0.14437459409236908,
-0.006281570997089148,
0.21111232042312622,
0.8112351894378662,
-0.2892787754535675,
-0.1206079050898552,
-0.12909835577011108,
0.454159140586853,
-0.535332977771759,
-0.15556512773036957,
-1.1693987846374512,
-0.06383726000785828,
0.046885255724191666,
-0.5728055834770203,
-0.603782594203949,
-0.6585311889648438,
-0.05488196015357971,
-0.11009237915277481,
0.4372956156730652,
0.14262352883815765,
0.6748875975608826,
0.4718724489212036,
-0.19789864122867584,
-0.600004255771637,
-0.6019733548164368,
0.3410322666168213,
-0.4244581460952759,
0.510798454284668,
0.6896644830703735,
0.42404866218566895,
-0.4390333592891693,
-0.536469578742981,
-0.6773341298103333,
-0.45383381843566895,
-0.03568177670240402,
-0.16654416918754578,
0.3154902756214142,
-0.03675215691328049,
0.046923015266656876,
0.21770088374614716,
-0.7703191637992859,
-0.16992701590061188,
-0.38556715846061707,
-0.21389903128147125,
0.6156907081604004,
0.08335798233747482,
0.25275829434394836,
-0.4160884618759155,
-0.10386229306459427,
0.04725338891148567,
-0.5691813230514526,
-0.42566436529159546,
0.3510870039463043,
0.2483506202697754,
0.35970428586006165,
0.6446489691734314,
-0.061787672340869904,
0.3286898136138916,
0.03691951557993889,
0.3910728693008423,
0.1376297026872635,
0.07264638692140579,
-0.0652909129858017,
0.492236465215683,
0.77061527967453,
0.07392928004264832,
0.19520124793052673,
-0.5878971219062805,
-0.30530068278312683,
0.1499551385641098,
0.6905688047409058,
-0.8884140849113464,
-0.5133355259895325,
0.5756981372833252,
0.0784478634595871,
-0.345975786447525,
0.23117689788341522,
-0.7701866030693054,
-0.7820086479187012,
-0.04365941509604454,
0.46138593554496765,
-0.543358564376831,
-0.20495209097862244,
0.17462484538555145,
0.25268393754959106,
0.3531183898448944,
0.3000420331954956,
-0.7391018867492676,
0.14946162700653076,
0.7507462501525879,
0.5580275654792786,
-0.30786794424057007,
-0.5619437098503113,
-0.558320164680481,
-0.09090199321508408,
-0.5196331143379211,
0.9311895370483398,
-0.4936746060848236,
-0.43878450989723206,
-0.09529312700033188,
0.13642717897891998,
0.020153161138296127,
-0.5953333377838135,
0.3144613206386566,
-0.6322664618492126,
0.0014632922830060124,
-0.3825445771217346,
-0.5731934309005737,
-0.2221173197031021,
0.19793063402175903,
-0.6352465152740479,
0.46088510751724243,
0.020220646634697914,
-0.5165250301361084,
0.5530524253845215,
-0.3661825656890869,
-0.3265608549118042,
0.412696897983551,
-0.43971166014671326,
-0.30962541699409485,
0.2776224911212921,
-0.029560863971710205,
0.3374100625514984,
-0.1786661148071289,
0.5636833906173706,
-0.3052838146686554,
-0.6046324968338013,
0.4702751636505127,
-0.1861172467470169,
0.7795449495315552,
-0.02901286818087101,
-0.4768825173377991,
0.018427006900310516,
-0.5784229636192322,
-0.07330077141523361,
0.03384571149945259,
0.21102577447891235,
-0.06430935114622116,
0.06843475997447968,
-0.17767712473869324,
0.15193632245063782,
-0.13242822885513306,
-0.30234891176223755,
0.2370052933692932,
-0.48234206438064575,
0.07347407191991806,
0.7438596487045288,
0.2356913536787033,
0.23400072753429413,
-0.3379170298576355,
0.5741093158721924,
-0.3386111557483673,
-0.010029032826423645,
0.2150276005268097,
-0.4338497817516327,
-0.5711487531661987,
-0.1292400360107422,
0.1755448579788208,
0.2458208203315735,
-0.611312985420227,
0.4128754138946533,
-0.09383701533079147,
-0.6253128051757812,
-0.6490491628646851,
-0.11961913853883743,
-0.0729939416050911,
0.06988587230443954,
0.33069825172424316,
-0.0551297590136528,
-0.4642808139324188,
-0.4818476438522339,
0.030551711097359657,
-0.46786677837371826,
0.0059814853593707085,
0.3055681884288788,
0.6704296469688416,
-0.2985588312149048,
0.537558376789093,
-0.417861670255661,
-0.26438531279563904,
-0.4156852066516876,
0.36029917001724243,
0.08325948566198349,
0.3915310204029083,
0.26505786180496216,
-0.5393078923225403,
0.03698371723294258,
-0.23895969986915588,
-0.9449034929275513,
-0.12491252273321152,
-0.23896512389183044,
-0.4003281891345978,
0.32491692900657654,
0.4376263916492462,
-0.9218984246253967,
0.40815916657447815,
0.3898999094963074,
-0.330966591835022,
0.7699377536773682,
0.10292258113622665,
0.36009982228279114,
-0.5461758971214294,
-0.17003586888313293,
-0.720977783203125,
0.19089850783348083,
-0.6311693787574768,
0.19574888050556183,
-0.1015581265091896,
-0.01369992271065712,
-0.45450684428215027,
0.44947829842567444,
-0.14817628264427185,
-0.008810527622699738,
-0.25021207332611084,
0.08179685473442078,
-0.19031861424446106,
0.4016704559326172,
-0.06356626749038696,
0.6545276641845703,
0.43980664014816284,
-0.7345798015594482,
0.17311760783195496,
0.41349560022354126,
-0.3843477666378021,
0.23971357941627502,
-0.6090760827064514,
0.35230782628059387,
-0.20939643681049347,
0.10261759161949158,
-1.2288845777511597,
-0.4461975693702698,
0.3249626159667969,
-0.8186407089233398,
0.01412844005972147,
0.14015918970108032,
-0.5052193999290466,
-0.2411714494228363,
-0.20311224460601807,
0.3693068325519562,
0.3142836093902588,
-0.5366581678390503,
0.5512703657150269,
0.387635201215744,
0.1441500037908554,
-0.4114852547645569,
-0.5558180809020996,
0.054021600633859634,
-0.0345422700047493,
-0.6733372807502747,
0.044240161776542664,
-0.18693888187408447,
-0.12303312867879868,
-0.259753942489624,
-0.0403604581952095,
0.1553279161453247,
0.21526744961738586,
0.4830494821071625,
0.26432526111602783,
-0.020231708884239197,
0.30182385444641113,
0.036649081856012344,
0.03954378888010979,
0.3971690237522125,
0.06260578334331512,
1.2453464269638062,
0.028566405177116394,
-0.5589757561683655,
-0.38896721601486206,
-0.04136332497000694,
0.4549295902252197,
-0.07693134993314743,
0.5646655559539795,
0.46142157912254333,
-0.5484479665756226,
-0.24094301462173462,
-0.7366510629653931,
-0.7540647387504578,
-0.40837761759757996,
0.3176456391811371,
-0.584808886051178,
-0.46860471367836,
0.5379562377929688,
0.41086244583129883,
-0.005883696489036083,
0.21124467253684998,
0.5948944687843323,
-0.005611236207187176,
0.9747607707977295,
0.16507583856582642,
0.40300247073173523,
0.017360087484121323,
-0.22867467999458313,
0.3586556017398834,
-0.5012755990028381,
-0.46845361590385437,
-0.5881844758987427,
-0.1575608104467392,
-0.7996251583099365,
-0.31383055448532104,
0.022076882421970367,
0.05111562833189964,
-0.04938695952296257,
0.3124918043613434,
-0.46671876311302185,
0.4380562901496887,
0.3671925663948059,
0.06000268831849098,
0.13179433345794678,
-0.0977860763669014,
0.17115569114685059,
0.0004979603108949959,
-0.3185289204120636,
-0.49051669239997864,
1.038067102432251,
-0.11041862517595291,
0.7776782512664795,
0.0838601216673851,
1.0670325756072998,
0.16741731762886047,
0.4034629762172699,
-0.7405945658683777,
0.7546408772468567,
0.36630940437316895,
-0.8990461826324463,
-0.6715470552444458,
-0.5380406379699707,
-1.0707052946090698,
0.5571137070655823,
-0.20501959323883057,
-0.9621607661247253,
0.18840324878692627,
-0.038878776133060455,
-0.2518596053123474,
0.25602349638938904,
-0.397209495306015,
0.8979139924049377,
-0.3392487168312073,
-0.5387964248657227,
-0.01890934444963932,
-0.5017409324645996,
0.6450477838516235,
-0.22992102801799774,
0.07262828946113586,
-0.2693607211112976,
0.3477696478366852,
0.48853713274002075,
-0.2675951421260834,
0.37857726216316223,
-0.07304457575082779,
0.01775725558400154,
0.41920047998428345,
0.6858811378479004,
0.47231316566467285,
0.3089776039123535,
-0.34421980381011963,
0.10943924635648727,
0.09934032708406448,
-0.18338581919670105,
-0.7174263596534729,
0.6408453583717346,
-0.6781317591667175,
-0.8639471530914307,
-0.51381516456604,
-0.5714413523674011,
-0.16700278222560883,
-0.012384767644107342,
0.37014055252075195,
0.14565110206604004,
-0.24302805960178375,
0.2336736023426056,
0.5338724851608276,
-0.49430909752845764,
0.007871560752391815,
0.18364034593105316,
-0.7650074362754822,
-0.114164337515831,
1.1489759683609009,
0.047905001789331436,
0.13840556144714355,
0.04497051611542702,
0.1728329062461853,
-0.42620521783828735,
-0.5864238739013672,
-0.18109583854675293,
0.6234661936759949,
-0.6133875250816345,
-0.09712294489145279,
-1.134817123413086,
-0.3682304918766022,
-0.6612293720245361,
-0.213699072599411,
-0.25785502791404724,
-0.1633812040090561,
-0.3668869435787201,
-0.21138893067836761,
0.008125276304781437,
0.5335680842399597,
-0.010463771410286427,
0.1581529974937439,
-0.33740806579589844,
0.42329370975494385,
0.3939673602581024,
0.03827410563826561,
-0.084586501121521,
-0.6492692828178406,
0.2617708146572113,
-0.008410591632127762,
-0.5045589208602905,
-0.9498230814933777,
0.5348135232925415,
-0.14822731912136078,
0.5767838954925537,
0.41923171281814575,
0.29520538449287415,
0.5249764919281006,
-0.25775089859962463,
0.827709972858429,
0.08893381059169769,
-0.6592686772346497,
0.422813355922699,
-0.061384253203868866,
0.12648142874240875,
0.8135214447975159,
0.5220089554786682,
-0.40415653586387634,
-0.9261990189552307,
-0.7064039707183838,
-0.8133284449577332,
0.5375400185585022,
0.2110500931739807,
0.33125317096710205,
-0.4275542199611664,
0.27886220812797546,
0.42159023880958557,
0.5037209391593933,
-0.6884340047836304,
-0.060099899768829346,
-0.455206036567688,
0.23502357304096222,
0.018868708983063698,
-0.25735682249069214,
0.23170678317546844,
-0.39907804131507874,
0.7044981122016907,
0.2763005793094635,
0.35757383704185486,
-0.05781305208802223,
-0.43570876121520996,
-0.2348414808511734,
0.20177042484283447,
0.41301724314689636,
0.9754666686058044,
-0.6870326995849609,
0.3446282744407654,
0.04019676893949509,
-0.38830721378326416,
0.1429460048675537,
-0.03990432992577553,
-0.207852303981781,
0.14509449899196625,
0.11542259156703949,
0.5369126796722412,
-0.12822183966636658,
-0.8033495545387268,
0.4353795647621155,
-0.07684563100337982,
-0.4880121350288391,
-0.4073781371116638,
0.2238997519016266,
-0.07454629242420197,
0.1822957992553711,
0.3286399841308594,
-0.41917842626571655,
0.4269881546497345,
-0.7322011590003967,
0.6235052943229675,
0.5009946227073669,
-0.6117541790008545,
-0.3037203550338745,
0.9570537805557251,
-0.1741637885570526,
-0.4960257112979889,
0.7842438220977783,
-0.5287520289421082,
-0.5949211120605469,
0.48183998465538025,
0.4455692172050476,
0.8656966686248779,
-0.48715806007385254,
0.5461007952690125,
0.3614172041416168,
0.4678618907928467,
-0.0752611756324768,
0.3485325574874878,
0.3097270727157593,
-0.6278389692306519,
-0.10043845325708389,
-0.9614923596382141,
-0.22311195731163025,
0.5762845277786255,
-0.3483806252479553,
0.4652308225631714,
-0.3323964476585388,
-0.11614246666431427,
-0.04338693246245384,
0.027366284281015396,
-0.41386500000953674,
0.12675312161445618,
-0.04992518573999405,
0.38655567169189453,
-0.5442644357681274,
0.5438276529312134,
0.22086167335510254,
-0.6584141850471497,
-0.3214624226093292,
0.18193213641643524,
-0.16113904118537903,
-0.77431720495224,
0.49052730202674866,
0.4753063917160034,
-0.1053968071937561,
-0.02446327731013298,
-0.5954399704933167,
-0.5442230701446533,
0.6932916045188904,
0.3897079825401306,
-0.5193650722503662,
-0.16440556943416595,
0.37602052092552185,
0.3401051163673401,
-0.22057542204856873,
0.21850132942199707,
0.7833951711654663,
0.38757506012916565,
0.5306481122970581,
-0.19079789519309998,
0.25734376907348633,
0.15483999252319336,
-0.2769854962825775,
0.32738807797431946,
-0.08865837007761002,
0.8858414888381958,
-0.45938438177108765,
-0.2732628583908081,
0.2325567603111267,
0.6699056625366211,
0.3707221448421478,
0.2945738732814789,
0.5235421657562256,
0.2681718170642853,
0.8470578193664551,
-0.17679105699062347,
1.0524625778198242,
-0.41222840547561646,
0.14245516061782837,
1.2970126867294312,
-0.347553551197052,
0.6719928979873657,
0.6314228177070618,
0.18226760625839233,
0.20335634052753448,
0.6036040186882019,
-0.024286437779664993,
0.5202223062515259,
0.7013884782791138,
0.00949373934417963,
-0.365437775850296,
-0.0010888469405472279,
-0.515629768371582,
0.39716222882270813,
0.33957046270370483,
-0.16495057940483093,
0.045690711587667465,
0.05421794578433037,
-0.11406394839286804,
-0.11691548675298691,
0.137178435921669,
0.6663041114807129,
0.03148853778839111,
-0.8181385397911072,
0.8172276020050049,
-0.4634692370891571,
0.2501499056816101,
-0.325607568025589,
-0.05790524184703827,
-0.4715215563774109,
-0.11612914502620697,
-0.24001410603523254,
-0.4817429780960083,
0.1746222972869873,
-0.40527600049972534,
0.3290626108646393,
0.33134225010871887,
0.279485821723938,
-0.3655627965927124,
-0.5058326125144958,
0.2782911956310272,
0.5356742143630981,
0.7662915587425232,
-0.411176860332489,
-0.3561006486415863,
0.19626198709011078,
-0.039350252598524094,
-0.32548555731773376,
0.11635490506887436,
0.6568516492843628,
0.176864355802536,
0.6225119233131409,
0.5190890431404114,
0.19316187500953674,
0.15844601392745972,
0.3877263367176056,
0.7046005129814148,
-0.6957080364227295,
-0.20385678112506866,
-0.7768297791481018,
0.3507942259311676,
0.15155765414237976,
-0.17666885256767273,
0.5838651061058044,
0.3703863024711609,
0.7545057535171509,
0.14617103338241577,
0.6394420266151428,
0.07199271768331528,
0.23507621884346008,
-0.3934899568557739,
0.8511697053909302,
-0.8133240938186646,
0.54734206199646,
-0.4236857295036316,
-1.2662436962127686,
-0.30864182114601135,
0.8158150911331177,
-0.485506147146225,
0.04899117350578308,
0.8388380408287048,
1.1219494342803955,
0.16114631295204163,
0.3593142628669739,
0.6258065104484558,
0.3132549524307251,
0.4323783218860626,
0.2600005269050598,
1.1681711673736572,
-0.27835455536842346,
0.6372960805892944,
-0.21391288936138153,
0.03342988342046738,
-0.6109156608581543,
-0.2993951737880707,
-1.0096321105957031,
-0.580316424369812,
-0.05031360313296318,
-0.6534709930419922,
0.14193607866764069,
1.005934476852417,
0.2891731262207031,
-0.8345215916633606,
-0.467828631401062,
-0.22056230902671814,
0.2681460976600647,
-0.013351354748010635,
-0.24845917522907257,
0.28393203020095825,
-0.7014240026473999,
-0.4318000078201294,
-0.03544441983103752,
0.02354568988084793,
0.047356218099594116,
-0.5160061717033386,
-0.16360679268836975,
-0.33440926671028137,
0.33929234743118286,
0.6064401865005493,
-0.13669933378696442,
-0.7569922804832458,
-0.24163171648979187,
0.1536562144756317,
-0.12301255762577057,
0.13297253847122192,
0.6658633351325989,
-0.5400617718696594,
0.4046127200126648,
0.34702643752098083,
0.6368668079376221,
0.7071238160133362,
-0.10041642934083939,
0.27192896604537964,
-0.21152672171592712,
-0.02116338722407818,
0.5456063747406006,
0.09510676562786102,
0.217489555478096,
-0.4212327301502228,
0.5459532141685486,
0.025080347433686256,
-0.5849003791809082,
-1.2066309452056885,
0.21077145636081696,
-0.6945858001708984,
-0.5464306473731995,
1.160534381866455,
0.5177606344223022,
-0.3686927855014801,
-0.11448412388563156,
-0.20073190331459045,
0.15831203758716583,
-0.41413864493370056,
1.3854479789733887,
0.6173341870307922,
-0.10631178319454193,
-0.16776911914348602,
-0.7502703666687012,
0.45603683590888977,
0.3044840395450592,
-0.8702623844146729,
0.3220406174659729,
0.5140596032142639,
-0.14881734549999237,
0.278991162776947,
0.6571269035339355,
-0.03475714102387428,
0.31954509019851685,
0.0466129295527935,
0.26995527744293213,
0.2682653069496155,
-0.6461559534072876,
0.1356167197227478,
0.4730159044265747,
0.09230560809373856,
-0.0006997009040787816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12526v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12526v1
|
Adaptive Memory Replay for Continual Learning
| 2024-04-18T22:01:56 | 2024-04-18T22:01:56 |
James Seale Smith, Lazar Valkov, Shaunak Halbe, Vyshnavi Gutta, Rogerio Feris, Zsolt Kira, Leonid Karlinsky
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Foundation Models (FMs) have become the hallmark of modern AI, however, these
models are trained on massive data, leading to financially expensive training.
Updating FMs as new data becomes available is important, however, can lead to
`catastrophic forgetting', where models underperform on tasks related to data
sub-populations observed too long ago. This continual learning (CL) phenomenon
has been extensively studied, but primarily in a setting where only a small
amount of past data can be stored. We advocate for the paradigm where memory is
abundant, allowing us to keep all previous data, but computational resources
are limited. In this setting, traditional replay-based CL approaches are
outperformed by a simple baseline which replays past data selected uniformly at
random, indicating that this setting necessitates a new approach. We address
this by introducing a framework of adaptive memory replay for continual
learning, where sampling of past data is phrased as a multi-armed bandit
problem. We utilize Bolzmann sampling to derive a method which dynamically
selects past data for training conditioned on the current task, assuming full
data access and emphasizing training efficiency. Through extensive evaluations
on both vision and language pre-training tasks, we demonstrate the
effectiveness of our approach, which maintains high performance while reducing
forgetting by up to 10% at no training efficiency cost.
|
[
-0.11060258001089096,
-0.7099034190177917,
0.3471532166004181,
0.2333846390247345,
-0.1822606921195984,
0.1642083078622818,
-0.18845635652542114,
-0.15316668152809143,
0.16019608080387115,
0.6240840554237366,
-0.4334900677204132,
-0.0771825909614563,
-0.4424442946910858,
-0.32893145084381104,
-0.4749969244003296,
1.019569754600525,
-0.237396240234375,
0.16504357755184174,
-0.5039576888084412,
-0.449930876493454,
-0.8139116168022156,
-0.5251657962799072,
-1.1497670412063599,
-0.5243654847145081,
0.4055006206035614,
0.30606022477149963,
0.2641361355781555,
0.29776203632354736,
0.24246765673160553,
0.18759198486804962,
0.14243479073047638,
0.09893637150526047,
-0.9247676730155945,
0.10933416336774826,
-0.301658570766449,
-0.3739219307899475,
-0.20273199677467346,
-0.07780638337135315,
1.000098466873169,
0.699561595916748,
-0.4828276038169861,
-0.06816328316926956,
0.07160937786102295,
0.9300283789634705,
-0.8100168108940125,
-0.041283316910266876,
-0.8999404311180115,
0.0167002622038126,
0.11537839472293854,
-0.28731271624565125,
-0.4917075037956238,
-0.42108821868896484,
0.43700504302978516,
-0.4500854015350342,
0.14747686684131622,
-0.16109386086463928,
0.5579565763473511,
0.3241175711154938,
0.12180037796497345,
-0.3869960308074951,
-0.9745501279830933,
0.7057898044586182,
-0.2458002120256424,
0.16290153563022614,
0.3585042953491211,
0.4381842017173767,
-0.06270446628332138,
-0.6732548475265503,
-0.3700466454029083,
-0.3648240566253662,
0.3656492233276367,
0.45852160453796387,
-0.16506719589233398,
-0.28923630714416504,
0.198997363448143,
0.20035161077976227,
-0.4061034321784973,
-0.19628234207630157,
-0.4602736234664917,
-0.06812617182731628,
0.5410419702529907,
0.23279057443141937,
-0.15183129906654358,
0.5899277925491333,
-0.6215793490409851,
-0.18495160341262817,
-0.8612474203109741,
0.01862487569451332,
-0.12577998638153076,
-0.04042661935091019,
0.0838448703289032,
-0.02994430996477604,
-0.1599130481481552,
0.7887864708900452,
-0.006396282929927111,
-0.06533164530992508,
0.19477510452270508,
-0.13100504875183105,
-0.2483506202697754,
-0.1488739252090454,
0.19422000646591187,
-0.011833800002932549,
0.35947445034980774,
-0.3815711736679077,
-0.3227737247943878,
0.012114820070564747,
0.7498565316200256,
-0.4738386869430542,
-0.5260061025619507,
0.04149143397808075,
-0.1949860006570816,
0.08151698857545853,
-0.019586162641644478,
-0.7181527018547058,
-0.11658114194869995,
-0.20297999680042267,
0.7053818702697754,
-0.6827061772346497,
-0.08066471666097641,
0.26279085874557495,
-0.289853572845459,
0.06951525062322617,
0.49757373332977295,
-0.6619105339050293,
0.22085852921009064,
0.20919328927993774,
0.7673707008361816,
-0.16628694534301758,
-0.5268977880477905,
-0.720751166343689,
0.3322318494319916,
-0.5089937448501587,
0.7242870926856995,
-0.44521138072013855,
-0.4931848645210266,
-0.07069502025842667,
-0.2848193645477295,
-0.2521030604839325,
-0.7666494250297546,
-0.2256464809179306,
-0.5465876460075378,
-0.027037249878048897,
-0.28002023696899414,
-0.4605766236782074,
-0.2551894783973694,
0.29808542132377625,
-0.4853315055370331,
0.9667735695838928,
0.4052574932575226,
-0.2770082354545593,
0.5275951623916626,
-0.4568578004837036,
-0.3425423502922058,
-0.01180875115096569,
-0.04462258517742157,
-0.6292007565498352,
0.23893466591835022,
-0.021625941619277,
0.40445658564567566,
0.07343842089176178,
0.422855406999588,
-0.5055624842643738,
-0.6660993099212646,
0.18583574891090393,
-0.5861070156097412,
0.4215633273124695,
-0.07536730915307999,
-0.31422683596611023,
-0.02989666722714901,
-0.6462545990943909,
-0.29476282000541687,
0.044575996696949005,
-0.45253223180770874,
-0.3410261869430542,
0.2867487072944641,
-0.3592051565647125,
0.18493910133838654,
0.18474066257476807,
-0.3414367437362671,
0.06886442750692368,
-0.12670870125293732,
0.26422128081321716,
0.9006457924842834,
0.12571971118450165,
0.3412482440471649,
-1.0317935943603516,
0.3125608563423157,
0.13489797711372375,
-0.006654335185885429,
-0.6034283638000488,
-0.01906953752040863,
-0.7825195789337158,
-0.32545343041419983,
0.15239118039608002,
0.5989383459091187,
-0.8441144227981567,
0.17210057377815247,
-0.4494648277759552,
-0.3639797270298004,
-0.03084326535463333,
0.3554942011833191,
0.3178180754184723,
0.3408554196357727,
0.5474755167961121,
-0.6785892844200134,
-0.5264343619346619,
-0.4596448540687561,
0.18428120017051697,
-0.08420797437429428,
-0.08449018001556396,
0.5755623579025269,
0.6756023168563843,
-0.16027705371379852,
1.1149412393569946,
-0.18329937756061554,
-0.3166552782058716,
-0.11080238223075867,
0.23544983565807343,
-0.05193464457988739,
0.7981359958648682,
0.8731463551521301,
-0.6798980236053467,
-0.12062399089336395,
-0.35138633847236633,
-0.8702083826065063,
0.37106451392173767,
-0.7658191323280334,
-0.10456578433513641,
0.43109992146492004,
0.33291149139404297,
-0.44801831245422363,
0.484646737575531,
0.3975279629230499,
-0.0035849679261446,
0.3887692391872406,
-0.341934472322464,
-0.14830413460731506,
-0.5865442752838135,
0.3118102550506592,
-0.46934670209884644,
-0.07371780276298523,
-0.06235869601368904,
-0.06605888903141022,
0.019223829731345177,
-0.05309293791651726,
-0.32810407876968384,
0.7089657783508301,
-0.43448883295059204,
-0.1652040332555771,
-0.3787458539009094,
-0.024717014282941818,
-0.20552024245262146,
0.6715920567512512,
0.17088308930397034,
0.5414813160896301,
0.6705768704414368,
-0.8376890420913696,
0.5145677924156189,
0.04731271415948868,
-0.24342584609985352,
0.8096722960472107,
-0.25071051716804504,
0.1221935972571373,
-0.5037130117416382,
0.655249834060669,
-0.9205281138420105,
0.005544556304812431,
0.014707452617585659,
-0.4767293930053711,
0.5956946611404419,
0.1207389384508133,
-0.1344597488641739,
-0.4475725293159485,
-0.13739345967769623,
0.08709723502397537,
0.6905879974365234,
-0.6516033411026001,
0.8779019713401794,
0.313688188791275,
-0.08570879697799683,
-0.6030636429786682,
-0.47686269879341125,
-0.006051317322999239,
-0.11139053851366043,
-0.204461008310318,
0.22335751354694366,
-0.23545630276203156,
0.09974215179681778,
0.11040110886096954,
-0.5089291334152222,
-0.24440735578536987,
0.281341552734375,
0.09633942693471909,
0.2933036983013153,
-0.2951512038707733,
0.2211456000804901,
-0.17017202079296112,
-0.13644208014011383,
0.03876650333404541,
-0.8211692571640015,
0.6157657504081726,
0.1050824299454689,
-0.1540067344903946,
-0.22418177127838135,
0.2580863833427429,
0.4923528730869293,
-0.10339703410863876,
0.7572453022003174,
0.5180712342262268,
-0.7002429962158203,
-0.2136342078447342,
-0.7273975014686584,
0.002400750759989023,
-0.37163543701171875,
0.33104854822158813,
-0.057224296033382416,
-0.7730816602706909,
0.48530831933021545,
-0.09389523416757584,
0.3522745370864868,
0.2390146702528,
0.46201291680336,
-0.5510354042053223,
0.29028594493865967,
0.5909894704818726,
-0.5295081734657288,
0.6235978603363037,
-0.40813085436820984,
-0.3843224346637726,
-0.49599534273147583,
-0.37595057487487793,
-0.19903546571731567,
-0.4168582260608673,
0.32625988125801086,
-0.19753320515155792,
0.16387991607189178,
0.41034114360809326,
-0.33159351348876953,
0.18223655223846436,
-0.017240604385733604,
0.4508853852748871,
0.54188472032547,
0.463308721780777,
-0.05913759395480156,
0.04698198288679123,
0.04332812502980232,
0.2251339554786682,
-0.981104850769043,
0.009168317541480064,
1.2934147119522095,
-0.046022821217775345,
0.6931836605072021,
-0.15145401656627655,
0.7361293435096741,
0.32519781589508057,
0.851783037185669,
-0.2598752975463867,
0.33087924122810364,
-0.05840484797954559,
-0.5387592911720276,
-0.29289814829826355,
-0.5179253816604614,
-0.9447714686393738,
-0.0640450194478035,
-0.30171138048171997,
-0.6389394998550415,
0.11805922538042068,
0.8330671787261963,
-0.6081092357635498,
0.5029658079147339,
-0.20937836170196533,
0.744659960269928,
-0.2652670443058014,
-0.5257889032363892,
-0.7189304232597351,
-0.6174636483192444,
0.3076188564300537,
-0.37489500641822815,
-0.1701028198003769,
0.18477636575698853,
0.21207432448863983,
0.5616275668144226,
0.057558730244636536,
0.9257465600967407,
-0.45707041025161743,
0.39577528834342957,
0.5451909303665161,
-0.14718039333820343,
0.5163237452507019,
0.07042113691568375,
0.1624951809644699,
0.0004559366498142481,
-0.16194623708724976,
-0.8760355710983276,
-0.48592454195022583,
0.5377935767173767,
-0.3361269235610962,
-0.2528232932090759,
-0.5519031286239624,
-0.43928635120391846,
-0.2982217073440552,
-0.01534552127122879,
0.08437161147594452,
0.5238233804702759,
-0.38352370262145996,
0.6301515102386475,
1.0104645490646362,
-0.2886252999305725,
0.49181002378463745,
0.503032922744751,
0.001046719728037715,
-0.5031450986862183,
1.1118972301483154,
0.21949242055416107,
0.3073561489582062,
0.3320619463920593,
0.014608255587518215,
-0.010259750299155712,
-0.7637340426445007,
-0.4588358700275421,
0.022752176970243454,
-0.4415847361087799,
-0.35312703251838684,
-0.729824423789978,
-0.16845372319221497,
0.056255023926496506,
-0.552721381187439,
-0.3527572751045227,
-0.13432006537914276,
-0.13579216599464417,
0.1247096136212349,
0.2749624252319336,
0.25706005096435547,
-0.2613508701324463,
0.49689698219299316,
-0.8194189667701721,
0.3922726511955261,
0.34095674753189087,
0.3784691095352173,
0.25569164752960205,
-0.4676613211631775,
-0.4262065589427948,
0.18052327632904053,
-0.3974840044975281,
-0.47288280725479126,
0.23264597356319427,
0.33239614963531494,
0.7511675953865051,
0.2415127158164978,
-0.11009655147790909,
0.7893844246864319,
-0.3704906105995178,
0.6409021615982056,
0.04079718515276909,
-0.5769058465957642,
0.37928807735443115,
-0.22878694534301758,
0.5690830945968628,
0.8291590213775635,
0.47415393590927124,
-0.3383917808532715,
-0.19871440529823303,
-0.7645942568778992,
-0.866966724395752,
0.5754372477531433,
-0.1607855260372162,
0.34743472933769226,
-0.05839195102453232,
0.555087149143219,
0.0031891283579170704,
0.259269654750824,
-0.4008420705795288,
0.07448750734329224,
-0.35953256487846375,
-0.15721799433231354,
-0.21587978303432465,
-0.16303463280200958,
-0.07562393695116043,
-0.07443428039550781,
0.6643095016479492,
-0.04280411824584007,
0.39396655559539795,
-0.04733501002192497,
-0.3176155388355255,
0.18244826793670654,
-0.14510196447372437,
0.6632078886032104,
0.8478344082832336,
-0.32168444991111755,
-0.43011683225631714,
0.4966561198234558,
-0.6533671021461487,
0.02231418341398239,
0.013603013940155506,
-0.3559871017932892,
-0.06120782718062401,
0.13811145722866058,
0.6320651769638062,
0.6006077527999878,
-0.9806422591209412,
0.3267284035682678,
0.2572866380214691,
-0.20852021872997284,
-1.006285548210144,
0.3621194362640381,
0.04487202689051628,
0.2812575101852417,
0.642119824886322,
0.646994411945343,
-0.3508254587650299,
-0.6137452125549316,
0.7032780051231384,
0.41880732774734497,
-0.3972121477127075,
0.04613477364182472,
0.49855080246925354,
-0.03992806002497673,
0.008500760421156883,
0.9629820585250854,
0.02081516943871975,
-0.43639811873435974,
0.6438632607460022,
0.5680442452430725,
0.6423258781433105,
-0.38544365763664246,
-0.11670398712158203,
0.5704683065414429,
0.07724771648645401,
-0.758736789226532,
0.2510492503643036,
-0.2648322582244873,
-0.7403756976127625,
-0.15090247988700867,
-0.6349406242370605,
-0.43955564498901367,
0.18150384724140167,
-0.8488011956214905,
-0.10388704389333725,
-0.9523078799247742,
0.03951222822070122,
-0.6130000948905945,
-0.20595459640026093,
-0.5877960920333862,
0.555730402469635,
-0.07624389976263046,
1.0892235040664673,
-0.5932163000106812,
1.073190689086914,
0.27086666226387024,
-0.2762821316719055,
-0.14384175837039948,
-0.16524958610534668,
-0.033736396580934525,
-0.7553744316101074,
0.1822449117898941,
0.13966397941112518,
-0.1933901607990265,
0.16735859215259552,
-0.6408023834228516,
-0.9659246802330017,
1.2577829360961914,
0.20269471406936646,
-0.3005456328392029,
-0.16239242255687714,
-0.7270063161849976,
0.3808712661266327,
-0.44329017400741577,
-0.20960968732833862,
0.7174328565597534,
0.1765247881412506,
0.42342570424079895,
-0.39437761902809143,
-0.4360146224498749,
-0.21469824016094208,
-0.20011006295681,
0.19927603006362915,
-0.6125321984291077,
0.7036877870559692,
-0.2720209062099457,
-0.0720629096031189,
0.4062276780605316,
0.7859941720962524,
0.47107475996017456,
0.45673421025276184,
0.310243159532547,
0.5596985816955566,
0.6870342493057251,
-0.17169055342674255,
0.9440218210220337,
-0.15310968458652496,
0.2427653968334198,
1.2977807521820068,
-0.3170664608478546,
1.0262463092803955,
0.1776835024356842,
-0.16738758981227875,
0.3531549572944641,
0.4955556094646454,
-0.24176979064941406,
0.6558403372764587,
0.1834365278482437,
-0.22419479489326477,
-0.27768489718437195,
0.4052203595638275,
-0.23314116895198822,
0.4484883248806,
0.5617715716362,
-0.24537335336208344,
-0.13802985846996307,
0.2525012493133545,
-0.06250074505805969,
0.06527374684810638,
-0.49300363659858704,
0.6231545209884644,
-0.05280930921435356,
-0.7749980092048645,
0.6379196047782898,
-0.33082616329193115,
0.6213921308517456,
-1.0156493186950684,
-0.07991498708724976,
-0.4580318033695221,
0.45569828152656555,
0.27723532915115356,
-0.21499872207641602,
0.6708036065101624,
-0.2859269678592682,
-0.2888767123222351,
-0.31283247470855713,
0.24968379735946655,
-0.4604186415672302,
-0.37732625007629395,
0.19881100952625275,
0.17545373737812042,
0.027814995497465134,
0.038202282041311264,
-0.5114735960960388,
-0.07530951499938965,
-0.12516270577907562,
-0.03547746688127518,
0.5272993445396423,
0.06858468055725098,
-0.08718416839838028,
0.9263255000114441,
0.6380062103271484,
0.04564373567700386,
0.038195155560970306,
-0.4895119071006775,
0.7813976407051086,
-0.787380576133728,
-0.5807094573974609,
-0.6717185378074646,
0.3807920217514038,
-0.04843553155660629,
-0.4465630054473877,
0.24697110056877136,
0.5732630491256714,
1.181167483329773,
-0.056660838425159454,
0.7605916857719421,
0.1431596726179123,
0.43658021092414856,
-0.8857706189155579,
0.6697402000427246,
-0.6005764603614807,
-0.01266951858997345,
-0.210506409406662,
-0.7083173394203186,
-0.2222670614719391,
0.8870999813079834,
0.014419798739254475,
0.14918842911720276,
0.6389542818069458,
0.36105871200561523,
-0.10952519625425339,
0.09689130634069443,
0.3276750445365906,
0.20189078152179718,
-0.1621815264225006,
1.2563769817352295,
0.6762809753417969,
-0.13037236034870148,
0.45643073320388794,
0.05909091979265213,
-0.3471956253051758,
-0.15817739069461823,
-0.7031369805335999,
-0.6183340549468994,
-0.43728238344192505,
-0.19113795459270477,
-0.34357133507728577,
0.43723782896995544,
0.7424419522285461,
0.6034867763519287,
-0.87127286195755,
-0.2654600143432617,
0.10600514709949493,
-0.17931662499904633,
-0.7640448808670044,
-0.08846751600503922,
0.2824687063694,
-0.3995307683944702,
-0.434068500995636,
0.4457719027996063,
0.5410506129264832,
0.17143194377422333,
-0.3167717456817627,
-0.1393701434135437,
-0.11927629262208939,
0.05309285596013069,
0.429002970457077,
0.7438351511955261,
-0.3889772295951843,
-0.43236762285232544,
-0.11296316236257553,
0.033739123493433,
0.2108239382505417,
0.9006697535514832,
-1.3848098516464233,
0.49263858795166016,
0.08330277353525162,
1.2078722715377808,
0.8987507820129395,
-0.08518548309803009,
0.7121068835258484,
-0.40151962637901306,
0.19809167087078094,
0.31898173689842224,
0.4518457353115082,
0.3104361891746521,
-0.11397290229797363,
0.4016015827655792,
0.5883091688156128,
-0.32789891958236694,
-0.6126114726066589,
0.11086226254701614,
-0.8495261073112488,
-0.4335973858833313,
0.5363970994949341,
-0.5417546033859253,
-0.004875367972999811,
-0.30210575461387634,
0.13571186363697052,
-0.06853104382753372,
-0.11503633111715317,
1.087096095085144,
0.7245265245437622,
0.0038699067663401365,
-0.3080461919307709,
-0.5666735768318176,
0.3372417986392975,
0.4105827212333679,
-0.5570672154426575,
-0.042293086647987366,
0.7939725518226624,
0.42194288969039917,
-0.017231548205018044,
1.0974650382995605,
-0.07363901287317276,
0.7930185198783875,
0.29969361424446106,
-0.32613956928253174,
0.021308379247784615,
-0.9199259877204895,
-0.49678900837898254,
0.31758037209510803,
-0.3485909700393677,
-0.14064918458461761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12500v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12500v1
|
UIClip: A Data-driven Model for Assessing User Interface Design
| 2024-04-18T20:43:08 | 2024-04-18T20:43:08 |
Jason Wu, Yi-Hao Peng, Amanda Li, Amanda Swearngin, Jeffrey P. Bigham, Jeffrey Nichols
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
User interface (UI) design is a difficult yet important task for ensuring the
usability, accessibility, and aesthetic qualities of applications. In our
paper, we develop a machine-learned model, UIClip, for assessing the design
quality and visual relevance of a UI given its screenshot and natural language
description. To train UIClip, we used a combination of automated crawling,
synthetic augmentation, and human ratings to construct a large-scale dataset of
UIs, collated by description and ranked by design quality. Through training on
the dataset, UIClip implicitly learns properties of good and bad designs by i)
assigning a numerical score that represents a UI design's relevance and quality
and ii) providing design suggestions. In an evaluation that compared the
outputs of UIClip and other baselines to UIs rated by 12 human designers, we
found that UIClip achieved the highest agreement with ground-truth rankings.
Finally, we present three example applications that demonstrate how UIClip can
facilitate downstream applications that rely on instantaneous assessment of UI
design quality: i) UI code generation, ii) UI design tips generation, and iii)
quality-aware UI example search.
|
[
-0.581636905670166,
-0.5035191774368286,
0.4108445346355438,
0.05921312794089317,
-0.34314534068107605,
0.29404833912849426,
0.3345029354095459,
-0.31405743956565857,
0.14772285521030426,
0.40398210287094116,
-0.3666061758995056,
-0.5703530311584473,
-0.08083734661340714,
-0.12526577711105347,
-0.3074602782726288,
0.5787524580955505,
-0.2560230791568756,
-0.4917451739311218,
-0.5274715423583984,
-0.14126846194267273,
-0.7706637382507324,
-0.3368144631385803,
-0.06385099142789841,
0.08742064237594604,
0.24824286997318268,
0.6871228814125061,
0.7765482068061829,
0.4261847734451294,
0.5610505938529968,
0.15722867846488953,
0.32658037543296814,
0.08901023864746094,
-0.570110023021698,
-0.17304454743862152,
-0.08360028266906738,
-0.1621047407388687,
-0.2204275131225586,
0.508147656917572,
0.07558930665254593,
0.6357619762420654,
0.2520172595977783,
0.5650674700737,
0.19606640934944153,
0.8717551231384277,
-0.6890398263931274,
0.04937027767300606,
-0.2832130789756775,
-0.0467790924012661,
-0.08618344366550446,
-0.08203216642141342,
-0.5412033200263977,
-0.5273288488388062,
0.04129720851778984,
-0.5907084941864014,
0.031310051679611206,
0.3280412554740906,
0.9387733340263367,
0.15347498655319214,
-0.3619910776615143,
-0.061088986694812775,
-0.18271321058273315,
0.7082237601280212,
-0.6198109984397888,
0.40385058522224426,
0.18902741372585297,
0.45237457752227783,
-0.22459395229816437,
-0.5110160112380981,
-0.39624273777008057,
-0.48100635409355164,
-0.006209454033523798,
0.07283756881952286,
0.1754526048898697,
-0.0373406782746315,
0.25801587104797363,
0.2397029995918274,
-0.5998902916908264,
0.18092676997184753,
-0.4473031759262085,
-0.45156118273735046,
0.7362357974052429,
0.18741877377033234,
0.7636277675628662,
-0.14179643988609314,
-0.6677751541137695,
-0.2706237733364105,
-0.6686801910400391,
0.5396390557289124,
0.3880980610847473,
0.021944278851151466,
-0.1946748048067093,
0.4853823184967041,
-0.27942126989364624,
0.8839850425720215,
-0.014827021397650242,
-0.23274444043636322,
0.3607499301433563,
-0.4289110600948334,
0.2012205868959427,
-0.4384080767631531,
0.7446632385253906,
0.870306670665741,
0.0868312194943428,
-0.020773084834218025,
-0.1913403868675232,
0.05811925604939461,
0.5198961496353149,
-0.7620506882667542,
-0.6028900146484375,
0.1268058866262436,
-0.7669874429702759,
-0.30525442957878113,
0.4465399384498596,
-0.6672208905220032,
-0.11845608800649643,
-0.6964437961578369,
0.37779179215431213,
-0.04249517247080803,
-0.31595009565353394,
-0.3270234763622284,
-0.647724986076355,
-0.08449840545654297,
0.3985671401023865,
-0.5474546551704407,
0.1318521946668625,
0.5090576410293579,
0.7060966491699219,
-0.7848491668701172,
-0.3627679944038391,
-0.41451549530029297,
-0.2261955291032791,
-0.594621479511261,
0.8139938116073608,
-0.46130913496017456,
-0.6366556882858276,
-0.3090394139289856,
-0.3244416117668152,
0.12832796573638916,
-0.5033458471298218,
0.39518630504608154,
-0.3072347939014435,
-0.032802764326334,
-0.027609597891569138,
-0.3530678153038025,
-0.2860848605632782,
-0.04443708434700966,
-0.751771867275238,
0.7424161434173584,
0.5994570851325989,
-0.8389365077018738,
0.6272372603416443,
-0.8578926920890808,
-0.4803767204284668,
0.2395508736371994,
-0.03482184559106827,
-0.5967414975166321,
0.48999935388565063,
0.055462226271629333,
0.36547136306762695,
0.17652946710586548,
0.19915805757045746,
-0.6818790435791016,
-0.5735798478126526,
0.3158632516860962,
-0.25662723183631897,
0.8858351707458496,
0.4197489619255066,
-0.10547171533107758,
0.12519791722297668,
-0.7190760970115662,
0.5172551274299622,
-0.30278870463371277,
-0.35737693309783936,
-0.507310152053833,
-0.18607792258262634,
0.3435000777244568,
0.21120670437812805,
0.013200237415730953,
-0.6230697631835938,
0.3325946629047394,
0.12025001645088196,
0.5198489427566528,
0.5346661806106567,
0.025736374780535698,
0.3766990005970001,
-0.1890162229537964,
0.25397974252700806,
-0.34543997049331665,
0.5733978152275085,
-0.15147587656974792,
-0.4665085971355438,
-0.3994954228401184,
-0.3605640232563019,
0.5397425293922424,
0.23070336878299713,
-0.8007928133010864,
0.2967870831489563,
-0.29109638929367065,
-0.4473879337310791,
-0.3686598241329193,
0.2739289700984955,
0.46928390860557556,
0.6174831390380859,
0.10692524164915085,
-0.9764739871025085,
0.016141068190336227,
-0.9223220348358154,
-0.13671904802322388,
-0.46217018365859985,
-0.3158856928348541,
0.44099530577659607,
0.5388441681861877,
-0.3284134566783905,
1.268307089805603,
-0.4681611955165863,
-0.22430965304374695,
-0.14666077494621277,
0.8594005703926086,
0.030374981462955475,
0.24444468319416046,
0.7106247544288635,
-0.9961946606636047,
-0.5647855997085571,
-0.05413400009274483,
-0.6471191048622131,
-0.3818974196910858,
-0.13773086667060852,
-0.1531219631433487,
-0.2020202875137329,
-0.0402652882039547,
-0.2686000466346741,
0.9045356512069702,
0.14504823088645935,
-0.22514331340789795,
0.8757621049880981,
-0.22097386419773102,
0.4318189024925232,
-0.5413492918014526,
0.49598076939582825,
0.049379706382751465,
-0.012136504054069519,
-0.4709368050098419,
0.22897706925868988,
0.3074478507041931,
-0.5982011556625366,
-0.7159614562988281,
0.8555835485458374,
-0.5000882744789124,
-0.29103878140449524,
-0.5594386458396912,
-0.18186724185943604,
0.43066027760505676,
0.6380029916763306,
-0.16137385368347168,
1.0427273511886597,
-0.10519856959581375,
-0.6346118450164795,
0.10229578614234924,
0.2501044273376465,
-0.6094347834587097,
0.9687982797622681,
-0.6173520684242249,
0.09519895166158676,
0.1476820409297943,
0.004603674169629812,
-1.2225295305252075,
-0.41556692123413086,
-0.12075577676296234,
-0.48123815655708313,
0.012042948976159096,
-0.1618434190750122,
-0.49010321497917175,
-0.8505765795707703,
-0.5393406748771667,
0.24596601724624634,
0.3496828079223633,
-0.8271564245223999,
0.3817024230957031,
0.5931282043457031,
-0.18828971683979034,
-0.05150140821933746,
-0.15221135318279266,
0.12542973458766937,
-0.23170770704746246,
-0.5627632141113281,
0.4118112027645111,
-0.3273317217826843,
-0.20315265655517578,
-0.2184651643037796,
-0.0500379242002964,
-0.49847590923309326,
0.650343120098114,
0.7219528555870056,
0.33443835377693176,
0.3386669158935547,
0.005296006333082914,
0.05113738402724266,
-0.1780339479446411,
-0.02504923567175865,
0.3150632679462433,
-0.06546340137720108,
-0.05067156255245209,
-0.5940835475921631,
-0.8885568380355835,
0.3850868344306946,
0.8170548677444458,
0.000050168397137895226,
-0.4119536280632019,
0.37146687507629395,
0.006165777798742056,
0.04925597831606865,
-0.48026132583618164,
0.14305280148983002,
-0.4277079701423645,
-0.04851686581969261,
-0.6695499420166016,
-0.45865094661712646,
0.2565912902355194,
-0.4901619553565979,
0.3558499217033386,
0.3335413634777069,
0.025264160707592964,
-0.5610212683677673,
1.462768793106079,
0.8413279056549072,
-0.4364771544933319,
0.6372233033180237,
-0.28860291838645935,
-0.05212150141596794,
-0.7891322374343872,
0.06748048216104507,
-0.4116686284542084,
-0.44127246737480164,
-0.3989890515804291,
0.1987537294626236,
0.5391219854354858,
0.15814997255802155,
-0.3909524977207184,
0.5536020398139954,
-0.6851765513420105,
0.29791247844696045,
0.9726845026016235,
0.37127313017845154,
0.16984979808330536,
0.09740792959928513,
-0.3518355190753937,
-0.11307888478040695,
-0.31867069005966187,
-0.4913262128829956,
0.9003106951713562,
0.4786299765110016,
1.121977686882019,
-0.2301633507013321,
0.4790157377719879,
0.9089668989181519,
0.49025508761405945,
-0.5083747506141663,
0.35341599583625793,
-0.13052469491958618,
-0.25834882259368896,
-0.12886139750480652,
-0.3220093548297882,
-0.4602847695350647,
-0.17505891621112823,
0.006194845773279667,
-0.5042480230331421,
0.3116985559463501,
0.2879413366317749,
-0.3571195900440216,
-0.15978820621967316,
-1.032841682434082,
0.8796092867851257,
-0.8973615169525146,
-0.5548163652420044,
-0.11756428331136703,
-0.7171630263328552,
0.39591681957244873,
0.181942418217659,
0.16230714321136475,
-0.2316298633813858,
0.3403932750225067,
0.746783435344696,
-0.47606897354125977,
0.8021754026412964,
-0.21002881228923798,
0.22603215277194977,
0.5054663419723511,
0.24862076342105865,
0.015398849733173847,
-0.06894811242818832,
-0.07228756695985794,
0.21446004509925842,
0.039571914821863174,
-0.2379712164402008,
-0.9258117079734802,
0.5948458909988403,
-0.6645798087120056,
-0.3382430970668793,
0.011502642184495926,
-0.1991795003414154,
0.07959721237421036,
0.2936655580997467,
0.1712930053472519,
0.6842384934425354,
-0.2775736153125763,
-0.03341073915362358,
0.1361362338066101,
-0.11594939231872559,
0.2150605022907257,
0.264057993888855,
-0.3085286617279053,
-0.5320183634757996,
1.218738079071045,
-0.043062981218099594,
0.20653463900089264,
0.24065369367599487,
0.07505533844232559,
-0.29274630546569824,
-0.33124449849128723,
-0.7549185156822205,
-0.18734130263328552,
-0.3525013029575348,
-0.17725926637649536,
0.024217259138822556,
-0.14714866876602173,
0.04496948421001434,
-0.12611708045005798,
-0.27817344665527344,
-0.4153898358345032,
-0.3974185883998871,
0.08992554247379303,
0.09756416827440262,
0.6555275321006775,
-0.0976686030626297,
0.3028257191181183,
-0.4025864601135254,
0.7107958793640137,
0.5608369708061218,
0.6942014098167419,
-0.22945503890514374,
-0.32742857933044434,
-0.08967673033475876,
0.19561702013015747,
-0.7217745780944824,
-0.3702348470687866,
0.5085856318473816,
0.09983441978693008,
0.7857320308685303,
0.7066452503204346,
0.4170474708080292,
0.4918184280395508,
-0.3807847499847412,
0.7884292602539062,
0.5862941145896912,
-0.7231854796409607,
0.8420838713645935,
-0.06540904194116592,
0.379304438829422,
1.0989866256713867,
0.35729995369911194,
-0.249810591340065,
-0.09788843989372253,
-0.522801399230957,
-0.5739213228225708,
0.03299977630376816,
-0.10918594151735306,
0.0957135334610939,
0.17266543209552765,
0.45238661766052246,
0.4579933285713196,
0.2122851461172104,
-0.3912208676338196,
0.027821434661746025,
-0.567629873752594,
-0.19883090257644653,
0.36891621351242065,
-0.20022960007190704,
-0.14720387756824493,
-0.2829674482345581,
0.10874062031507492,
-0.43813231587409973,
0.43118900060653687,
-0.22800491750240326,
-0.4616032540798187,
0.32203829288482666,
0.059016138315200806,
0.4343562424182892,
1.0399867296218872,
-0.17492955923080444,
0.1955486685037613,
-0.3365403115749359,
-0.3775572180747986,
0.2130965143442154,
-0.1601722538471222,
-0.3544895052909851,
0.06241646781563759,
0.09164705127477646,
0.8318719267845154,
0.37251609563827515,
-0.6953831911087036,
0.8098845481872559,
-0.25685322284698486,
-0.1570195108652115,
-0.021361328661441803,
0.3073830306529999,
-0.594972550868988,
-0.29722121357917786,
0.533111572265625,
-0.08509431779384613,
0.4893854856491089,
-0.6313362121582031,
0.53006511926651,
0.5023166537284851,
-0.572377622127533,
-0.38570547103881836,
0.8755667805671692,
0.6926447153091431,
-0.5177432298660278,
0.979543149471283,
0.13235482573509216,
-0.5832717418670654,
0.5688222050666809,
0.046252697706222534,
0.6804551482200623,
0.009873154573142529,
0.3601630926132202,
0.32930395007133484,
-0.24810844659805298,
0.07353325188159943,
0.13216863572597504,
-0.5020889639854431,
-0.1337675154209137,
-0.1390829235315323,
-0.25873276591300964,
-0.7984464168548584,
-0.26149192452430725,
-0.7765913009643555,
0.25200894474983215,
-0.3203411102294922,
-0.5603646039962769,
-0.3486253321170807,
0.09873831272125244,
-0.6760170459747314,
0.19682197272777557,
-0.07415076345205307,
1.0222368240356445,
-0.8646562695503235,
0.2856638729572296,
0.29967543482780457,
-0.6428307890892029,
-0.27064049243927,
-0.08585797995328903,
-0.03783024102449417,
-0.5253714323043823,
0.9778680801391602,
0.5443161129951477,
0.05776863545179367,
-0.19066350162029266,
-0.8613640069961548,
-0.6381345391273499,
0.8545712232589722,
0.1302681416273117,
-0.28643155097961426,
0.1835724264383316,
0.0491613894701004,
0.40461573004722595,
-0.1791238635778427,
0.6438938975334167,
0.23588010668754578,
0.23129983246326447,
-0.20963047444820404,
-0.9808915257453918,
-0.34868323802948,
-0.5996030569076538,
0.2613629400730133,
-0.027916930615901947,
-0.4584496319293976,
0.42690858244895935,
-0.4269593358039856,
-0.45112451910972595,
0.4273821711540222,
0.694433867931366,
0.17205524444580078,
0.5715706944465637,
0.45374050736427307,
0.4494939148426056,
0.5477460026741028,
-0.007378521841019392,
0.8366632461547852,
-0.24353410303592682,
0.07955089956521988,
0.9780813455581665,
-0.20095518231391907,
1.0743447542190552,
0.3992585837841034,
-0.025529222562909126,
0.5161349773406982,
0.7339726686477661,
0.04084712639451027,
0.8476083874702454,
0.3560611605644226,
0.14202187955379486,
-0.10142788290977478,
-0.17341828346252441,
-0.2733188271522522,
0.2789948284626007,
0.37121206521987915,
-0.21946291625499725,
-0.11505846679210663,
0.4899512529373169,
-0.37723562121391296,
0.2026343047618866,
-0.13506153225898743,
0.8075003027915955,
-0.0823209211230278,
-0.6207197308540344,
0.5819289684295654,
-0.42204028367996216,
0.45659035444259644,
-0.04536527395248413,
-0.5268101096153259,
-0.29307878017425537,
-0.1035780981183052,
-0.11192510277032852,
-1.1186105012893677,
-0.17528055608272552,
-0.14146238565444946,
-0.16051600873470306,
-0.35166579484939575,
0.6244693994522095,
0.3481471538543701,
-0.4990799129009247,
0.0014812329318374395,
0.24210789799690247,
0.26736196875572205,
0.021296095103025436,
-0.6266829967498779,
0.3406813144683838,
-0.28444862365722656,
0.03760327771306038,
0.37387847900390625,
0.04715508967638016,
-0.17298439145088196,
1.109262466430664,
0.5316163897514343,
-0.26325345039367676,
-0.18946473300457,
0.01418472733348608,
0.8865160346031189,
-0.46809589862823486,
-0.4007287621498108,
-0.3998021185398102,
0.6353150010108948,
-0.5419495701789856,
-0.3494583070278168,
0.5084340572357178,
0.6707592010498047,
0.8397060632705688,
-0.11048458516597748,
1.1149675846099854,
0.08615262061357498,
0.7755311131477356,
-0.2212332785129547,
0.7395492792129517,
-0.290995329618454,
0.002432943321764469,
-0.3286310136318207,
-0.5594870448112488,
-0.31710085272789,
0.6512513160705566,
-0.3524044454097748,
-0.18100905418395996,
0.15132030844688416,
0.36998245120048523,
-0.35446926951408386,
-0.2953207790851593,
0.25706449151039124,
-0.278643935918808,
0.40864062309265137,
0.4387165307998657,
0.9298301935195923,
-0.3202401101589203,
0.431696355342865,
-0.3898169696331024,
-0.6029809713363647,
-0.5129501223564148,
-0.8932157754898071,
-0.8906504511833191,
-0.7021629214286804,
-0.4285483956336975,
0.06342215090990067,
-0.04775978624820709,
0.41336458921432495,
0.9484977722167969,
-0.5251826643943787,
-0.30832022428512573,
0.13014134764671326,
0.2592161297798157,
-0.39938703179359436,
-0.2938247323036194,
0.3374055325984955,
-0.04533743858337402,
-0.14491231739521027,
0.163142591714859,
0.21461263298988342,
0.11391587555408478,
-0.1963522583246231,
0.06794311106204987,
0.47421395778656006,
-0.4482077658176422,
0.6830682754516602,
0.8017393350601196,
-0.682966411113739,
-0.4546186625957489,
-0.0553571879863739,
-0.1782623678445816,
0.16100303828716278,
0.7097553610801697,
-0.9639275074005127,
0.7948262095451355,
0.56596839427948,
0.5431719422340393,
0.05260990560054779,
0.6292567849159241,
0.6916098594665527,
-0.44132041931152344,
-0.39233845472335815,
-0.3378725051879883,
0.20388025045394897,
0.32143399119377136,
-0.13122935593128204,
0.48996293544769287,
-0.03858693316578865,
-0.46155476570129395,
-0.6849029660224915,
0.2364577353000641,
-0.9755399823188782,
-0.21404269337654114,
0.7573596835136414,
-0.227379709482193,
-0.34502050280570984,
-0.4112059473991394,
-0.6917762756347656,
-0.35540053248405457,
-0.3582887053489685,
1.0647268295288086,
0.14915689826011658,
-0.34877797961235046,
-0.17276662588119507,
-0.5083078145980835,
0.17882099747657776,
-0.35180899500846863,
-0.9122607111930847,
0.04037655517458916,
0.6056371927261353,
0.3320121169090271,
0.340711772441864,
0.31348708271980286,
0.043598707765340805,
0.7125951051712036,
-0.3274975121021271,
0.19721664488315582,
-0.30238354206085205,
-0.5413785576820374,
0.2666946053504944,
0.31412625312805176,
0.3067716956138611,
-0.39784231781959534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12494v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12494v1
|
BIRD: A Trustworthy Bayesian Inference Framework for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-18T20:17:23 | 2024-04-18T20:17:23 |
Yu Feng, Ben Zhou, Weidong Lin, Dan Roth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models primarily rely on inductive reasoning for decision
making. This results in unreliable decisions when applied to real-world tasks
that often present incomplete contexts and conditions. Thus, accurate
probability estimation and appropriate interpretations are required to enhance
decision-making reliability. In this paper, we propose a Bayesian inference
framework called BIRD for large language models. BIRD provides controllable and
interpretable probability estimation for model decisions, based on abductive
factors, LLM entailment, as well as learnable deductive Bayesian modeling.
Experiments show that BIRD produces probability estimations that align with
human judgments over 65% of the time using open-sourced Llama models,
outperforming the state-of-the-art GPT-4 by 35%. We also show that BIRD can be
directly used for trustworthy decision making on many real-world applications.
|
[
0.03326669707894325,
-0.9350929260253906,
0.8334601521492004,
0.3884908854961395,
0.02804846316576004,
-0.20819157361984253,
-0.18015924096107483,
-0.4789208173751831,
-0.2790006995201111,
0.4886155128479004,
-0.3148096203804016,
-0.44044381380081177,
-0.6131585240364075,
-0.09275242686271667,
-0.3908354938030243,
0.3300117552280426,
0.5523024797439575,
-0.18303599953651428,
0.07533570379018784,
0.2507908344268799,
-0.06354574114084244,
-0.3073962926864624,
-0.8735546469688416,
-0.6619459390640259,
0.37438106536865234,
0.1854308694601059,
1.1292213201522827,
0.5192891359329224,
0.5961483716964722,
0.18048499524593353,
0.04130902141332626,
0.00468407990410924,
-0.009587165899574757,
0.21200034022331238,
-0.7089771628379822,
-0.5794845223426819,
-0.44623199105262756,
-0.07032008469104767,
0.46546316146850586,
0.8239490985870361,
-0.38173431158065796,
-0.1481553465127945,
-0.1843796968460083,
0.510016918182373,
-0.8669431805610657,
0.6444308161735535,
-0.9688038229942322,
0.20914322137832642,
-0.08653894066810608,
0.07690572738647461,
-0.6112415194511414,
-0.28156137466430664,
0.1584133356809616,
-0.5416262149810791,
-0.17513035237789154,
-0.04294116795063019,
0.26992830634117126,
0.1459789127111435,
-0.4895686209201813,
-0.10603142529726028,
-0.6343092322349548,
0.8767659664154053,
-1.0994503498077393,
0.506885290145874,
0.9078549146652222,
0.6182767152786255,
-0.8108125329017639,
-0.4869583547115326,
-0.8203068375587463,
-0.3315945863723755,
0.22145269811153412,
0.33863386511802673,
-0.042280372232198715,
0.2217913269996643,
0.08722401410341263,
0.0431196391582489,
-0.5017610192298889,
0.23109310865402222,
0.12919116020202637,
-0.018875669687986374,
0.7632791996002197,
-0.3260578215122223,
0.11715653538703918,
-0.025409836322069168,
-0.023750275373458862,
-0.1274147480726242,
-0.7214217782020569,
0.04434414207935333,
0.4766564965248108,
0.5025942921638489,
-0.02444470301270485,
0.6029653549194336,
-0.27463504672050476,
0.968839704990387,
-0.03779395669698715,
-0.32239967584609985,
-0.2213139533996582,
0.2774290442466736,
-0.6081449389457703,
0.04059005156159401,
0.7037936449050903,
0.2949415445327759,
0.5108822584152222,
-0.18874236941337585,
-0.024925043806433678,
0.1657247096300125,
0.09896307438611984,
-0.5452437996864319,
-0.21530292928218842,
0.5436467528343201,
-0.39660021662712097,
-0.5955415964126587,
0.40071654319763184,
-0.45264261960983276,
-0.4630174934864044,
0.038751713931560516,
0.27179282903671265,
-0.5761119723320007,
-0.6487079858779907,
0.44682279229164124,
-0.10149406641721725,
0.33812037110328674,
0.45677459239959717,
-0.8242692947387695,
-0.1181255355477333,
1.0672639608383179,
0.7007652521133423,
0.10809877514839172,
-0.38659775257110596,
-0.8124246597290039,
0.4955599308013916,
-0.8441503047943115,
0.6130192875862122,
-1.1417737007141113,
-0.30959439277648926,
0.036873187869787216,
0.2063935101032257,
-0.017428221181035042,
-0.153522327542305,
0.6175963282585144,
-0.46955037117004395,
-0.13516858220100403,
-0.0493454672396183,
-0.5907014608383179,
-0.7446425557136536,
0.2601960599422455,
-0.6283782124519348,
0.48452672362327576,
0.04323376715183258,
-0.8690347671508789,
0.5754887461662292,
-0.36048758029937744,
-0.39956092834472656,
0.010953114368021488,
-0.22717107832431793,
-0.20945817232131958,
0.038465917110443115,
0.3150234520435333,
0.7785334587097168,
-0.36627721786499023,
0.49094903469085693,
-1.0679242610931396,
-0.34326839447021484,
0.5160505175590515,
-0.5944821238517761,
0.9416801333427429,
0.4530200660228729,
-0.3564845025539398,
0.014693429693579674,
-0.7558431029319763,
-0.2673652172088623,
-0.12730832397937775,
-0.2824423909187317,
-0.36814889311790466,
0.3339656889438629,
-0.17535944283008575,
-0.05116095766425133,
-0.13831545412540436,
-0.540061891078949,
0.14055447280406952,
-0.48239630460739136,
0.6591904759407043,
0.5488576292991638,
0.08903390914201736,
0.31390181183815,
-0.4240241050720215,
0.5248728394508362,
0.07090803980827332,
0.16689759492874146,
0.1633056253194809,
-0.6384987831115723,
-0.19977246224880219,
-0.3308546245098114,
0.007486952468752861,
0.4456240236759186,
-0.5785056948661804,
0.4237753450870514,
-0.0972415953874588,
-0.5058303475379944,
-0.2732287049293518,
-0.1030193641781807,
0.2640947103500366,
0.3630771338939667,
-0.021708574146032333,
0.11577735096216202,
-0.26200446486473083,
-0.8203567862510681,
-0.2718713879585266,
-0.6149988174438477,
0.013804111629724503,
-0.1054098904132843,
0.3833022117614746,
-0.389788955450058,
0.7864652276039124,
0.09824145585298538,
0.16382762789726257,
-0.31441640853881836,
0.14588621258735657,
0.47899308800697327,
0.6436223983764648,
0.4747867286205292,
-0.6543733477592468,
-0.14752347767353058,
0.2710925340652466,
-0.6757725477218628,
0.08241130411624908,
-0.3866463303565979,
-0.35142600536346436,
0.30325043201446533,
0.12304378300905228,
-0.8484117388725281,
0.5696799159049988,
0.5835196375846863,
-0.32685163617134094,
0.4719509482383728,
-0.2264968901872635,
0.06964263319969177,
-0.8895989060401917,
0.052150677889585495,
0.24752755463123322,
-0.4204595685005188,
-0.21451790630817413,
0.37704887986183167,
-0.012151891365647316,
0.21910588443279266,
-0.16423314809799194,
0.5449706315994263,
-0.19692683219909668,
-0.2716316878795624,
-0.25606849789619446,
0.007132594007998705,
-0.02152101695537567,
-0.04968273639678955,
0.44946303963661194,
0.5928841829299927,
0.6074064373970032,
-0.3686354160308838,
0.21748758852481842,
0.3015516698360443,
-0.7244955897331238,
0.5381907820701599,
-0.6463602781295776,
-0.23786106705665588,
-0.08091320097446442,
0.4669892489910126,
-0.8706024885177612,
-0.31291621923446655,
0.3376043438911438,
-0.4131789803504944,
0.2225155085325241,
-0.3239668607711792,
-0.4387854039669037,
-0.3020087778568268,
-0.024474378675222397,
-0.14581730961799622,
0.2654268145561218,
-0.6341091394424438,
0.45984482765197754,
0.3324708938598633,
-0.1427588164806366,
-0.8385207653045654,
-1.0198055505752563,
0.13818179070949554,
-0.049756839871406555,
-0.4275757968425751,
-0.12291790544986725,
0.08370431512594223,
-0.6476118564605713,
-0.1353939026594162,
-0.18926404416561127,
-0.23189979791641235,
0.24786730110645294,
0.49159935116767883,
-0.010040170513093472,
-0.1436178833246231,
0.18800877034664154,
0.15566889941692352,
0.016756027936935425,
0.12639713287353516,
-0.2983448803424835,
0.13570375740528107,
-0.173736572265625,
-0.7737675309181213,
-0.36708080768585205,
0.19771669805049896,
0.9786176681518555,
-0.24653565883636475,
0.6556286811828613,
0.4930247664451599,
-0.36912769079208374,
-0.43253928422927856,
-0.6399319767951965,
-0.253620445728302,
-0.36426451802253723,
0.20804953575134277,
-0.7105443477630615,
-0.6670238375663757,
0.3904778063297272,
0.1624930053949356,
0.1535727083683014,
0.3565915822982788,
0.29267340898513794,
-0.019584905356168747,
0.9816146492958069,
0.4166125953197479,
-0.23644432425498962,
0.09525974839925766,
0.029839854687452316,
0.08396764099597931,
-0.5670047998428345,
0.0580301471054554,
-0.3655671775341034,
0.13147978484630585,
-0.49702197313308716,
-0.4604203402996063,
-0.06840047985315323,
0.2325296700000763,
-0.6328008770942688,
0.07774413377046585,
-0.29684025049209595,
0.2512737810611725,
0.7368971109390259,
0.16200049221515656,
0.4635336995124817,
-0.1557352989912033,
0.004003392532467842,
0.3601755201816559,
-0.4419901669025421,
-0.6058740019798279,
1.0358378887176514,
0.26046937704086304,
0.9982891082763672,
0.41403689980506897,
0.33849090337753296,
0.29356175661087036,
0.3179022967815399,
-0.5894280672073364,
0.24969226121902466,
-0.022761764004826546,
-0.8666284084320068,
-0.46866393089294434,
-0.40123358368873596,
-0.7241648435592651,
0.4572206735610962,
-0.306448757648468,
-0.987613320350647,
0.08418020606040955,
-0.04392271488904953,
-0.28491485118865967,
0.4534901976585388,
-0.3313460350036621,
0.7711253762245178,
-0.1943608969449997,
-0.36251160502433777,
-0.39748796820640564,
-0.5087277293205261,
0.8076514601707458,
-0.37601444125175476,
0.21350882947444916,
-0.4121723771095276,
-0.04098249971866608,
0.4179413914680481,
-0.48586171865463257,
0.9803462028503418,
-0.1974688023328781,
-0.16361573338508606,
0.39330971240997314,
0.5430826544761658,
0.7863506078720093,
0.29882603883743286,
-0.8501814603805542,
0.20461420714855194,
0.5749406814575195,
-0.1518886685371399,
-0.7721986770629883,
0.6565253734588623,
-0.6742250323295593,
-0.6928952932357788,
-0.5905251502990723,
-0.47827231884002686,
-0.29983457922935486,
0.047833044081926346,
-0.10435910522937775,
0.27113407850265503,
0.03166605159640312,
0.42029398679733276,
0.02704988792538643,
-0.4585079550743103,
0.4906432330608368,
0.7039679288864136,
-0.43762466311454773,
-0.1619623303413391,
0.4423269033432007,
-0.11508742719888687,
0.10507450997829437,
0.6462841033935547,
0.459897518157959,
-0.46285709738731384,
-0.6964784264564514,
-0.2124679982662201,
0.1913892924785614,
-0.5909491777420044,
0.008047114126384258,
-0.47783663868904114,
-0.1889221966266632,
-0.39091843366622925,
-0.2173626869916916,
-0.26156729459762573,
-0.4462309777736664,
0.08908072113990784,
-0.33369871973991394,
0.4262494742870331,
0.6019227504730225,
-0.18974749743938446,
0.5327916145324707,
-0.6551686525344849,
0.030209848657250404,
0.36794957518577576,
0.28264445066452026,
0.10567350685596466,
-0.5444077253341675,
0.1964493989944458,
0.26034244894981384,
-0.022947240620851517,
-0.8663530349731445,
0.380037397146225,
0.4425834119319916,
0.7672781944274902,
0.653871476650238,
0.3082413673400879,
0.5500996708869934,
0.019577326253056526,
0.5957485437393188,
0.10469057410955429,
-0.8232704401016235,
0.7532026171684265,
-0.6224381923675537,
0.2971097528934479,
0.3511691391468048,
0.2661125361919403,
-0.26136866211891174,
-0.555260419845581,
-0.3556111454963684,
-0.3688342869281769,
0.4065898060798645,
0.10720488429069519,
-0.22783489525318146,
-0.2530125379562378,
0.38121089339256287,
0.508500874042511,
0.24533772468566895,
-0.6739611625671387,
0.3825831711292267,
-0.19223034381866455,
-0.1759243905544281,
-0.3409130573272705,
-0.21360492706298828,
0.17404505610466003,
-0.31270110607147217,
0.9549728035926819,
-0.2684955596923828,
-0.10195150226354599,
0.034289177507162094,
-0.07609599828720093,
-0.23276160657405853,
0.20342665910720825,
0.37836986780166626,
1.133562684059143,
-0.6432546377182007,
0.38608643412590027,
-0.17573998868465424,
-0.22424744069576263,
0.06591390073299408,
0.0432017557322979,
-0.1446610689163208,
-0.28130578994750977,
0.6141096949577332,
0.3294636309146881,
0.2071172297000885,
-0.6901094317436218,
0.6235581636428833,
0.02163887768983841,
-0.05226820707321167,
-0.5927839875221252,
0.1612003594636917,
0.20394103229045868,
0.6451829075813293,
0.11943957209587097,
-0.2122645080089569,
0.12220869213342667,
-0.615734338760376,
0.24221572279930115,
0.6324241757392883,
-0.2898716628551483,
-0.27263692021369934,
0.7482637763023376,
0.09195912629365921,
0.10146939009428024,
0.5217158794403076,
-0.15194439888000488,
-0.38338086009025574,
0.5064886808395386,
0.7666740417480469,
0.8488783836364746,
-0.27903833985328674,
0.555280327796936,
0.35971301794052124,
0.4752049744129181,
-0.4292199909687042,
0.3638688623905182,
-0.08492293208837509,
-0.9143489003181458,
-0.6709806323051453,
-1.0394277572631836,
-0.7549965977668762,
0.2988350987434387,
-0.4027659595012665,
-0.20879757404327393,
-0.5585441589355469,
-0.29882338643074036,
-0.0009322441183030605,
0.05607070401310921,
-0.4917415976524353,
0.23241014778614044,
0.06958131492137909,
1.0903382301330566,
-0.7444779872894287,
1.1911015510559082,
0.6276281476020813,
-0.5829244256019592,
-0.7977136969566345,
-0.029214831069111824,
0.09846704453229904,
-0.8050910234451294,
0.8836820125579834,
0.11210712045431137,
-0.3020471930503845,
-0.13770291209220886,
-0.4813109040260315,
-0.8848299384117126,
0.8351578116416931,
0.5552009344100952,
-0.7887960076332092,
0.36126935482025146,
-0.10917587578296661,
0.08183895796537399,
-0.34846556186676025,
0.4781980812549591,
0.600926399230957,
0.7764533162117004,
0.3191056251525879,
-0.7743133306503296,
0.18610893189907074,
-0.06532132625579834,
0.11173838376998901,
-0.26162225008010864,
-0.5148568153381348,
0.7561870813369751,
-0.35282546281814575,
-0.0737488716840744,
0.06945273280143738,
0.6415664553642273,
0.4939059019088745,
0.13421356678009033,
0.5497206449508667,
0.4283512830734253,
0.9160428643226624,
0.1497560441493988,
1.06928551197052,
-0.38443219661712646,
0.013913547620177269,
1.3683949708938599,
-0.3039732277393341,
1.235486626625061,
0.2586156129837036,
-0.49512597918510437,
0.38153889775276184,
0.9049903154373169,
0.18331895768642426,
0.38265249133110046,
0.02792329154908657,
-0.26054033637046814,
-0.7320777177810669,
0.3448939323425293,
-0.2927553057670593,
0.9380016326904297,
0.44611385464668274,
-0.34941861033439636,
-0.032467763870954514,
-0.27833518385887146,
0.045181505382061005,
-0.15425631403923035,
-0.12666969001293182,
0.38655927777290344,
0.2740979492664337,
-0.746110737323761,
0.17184214293956757,
-0.11097176373004913,
0.4866124391555786,
-0.5891198515892029,
-0.12461623549461365,
-0.12861254811286926,
0.4017806053161621,
-0.32288575172424316,
-0.9004309177398682,
0.28983503580093384,
-0.2674233913421631,
-0.07848058640956879,
0.3804711401462555,
0.5682653784751892,
-0.3907955586910248,
-0.9173762798309326,
0.14376680552959442,
0.48770737648010254,
0.29658427834510803,
-0.5709205865859985,
-0.5501267313957214,
0.13934937119483948,
-0.2933598756790161,
-0.3812977969646454,
0.0738578587770462,
0.44844257831573486,
-0.03733677789568901,
1.1244078874588013,
0.7521777153015137,
0.5649054050445557,
-0.2377820461988449,
0.057751744985580444,
0.0517696850001812,
-0.5799478888511658,
-0.5550383925437927,
-0.8748685717582703,
0.12783415615558624,
-0.0939001739025116,
0.19873404502868652,
0.7619243860244751,
0.20356661081314087,
0.5063938498497009,
-0.06880383938550949,
1.3029367923736572,
0.22250144183635712,
0.438117116689682,
-0.4573792815208435,
1.0009615421295166,
-0.46236512064933777,
0.21050608158111572,
-0.2559378743171692,
-1.0652319192886353,
-0.47409456968307495,
1.211838722229004,
-0.46657794713974,
-0.1315467357635498,
0.4055599868297577,
0.7500874996185303,
-0.18045656383037567,
0.23620222508907318,
0.6243555545806885,
0.20638182759284973,
0.6352704167366028,
0.7486101984977722,
0.8909472823143005,
0.001067086006514728,
0.2221090942621231,
-0.26193588972091675,
-0.42127275466918945,
-0.4003309905529022,
-1.3352824449539185,
-0.9811473488807678,
-0.45635929703712463,
-0.38183408975601196,
-0.06344763189554214,
0.19861872494220734,
1.048668622970581,
0.7655453681945801,
-0.8467322587966919,
-0.26006901264190674,
-0.20600804686546326,
0.30931538343429565,
-0.49538353085517883,
-0.19392625987529755,
0.4610261023044586,
-0.24465098977088928,
-0.5219168066978455,
0.5152407288551331,
0.3856719136238098,
0.027434172108769417,
-0.2540997862815857,
-0.18579041957855225,
-0.21780048310756683,
0.2762950360774994,
0.752178966999054,
0.38801538944244385,
-1.168373942375183,
-0.702223002910614,
-0.6165655851364136,
-0.005928236059844494,
-0.44067302346229553,
0.2403368353843689,
-0.4803074598312378,
0.6687636375427246,
0.30686086416244507,
0.7298550605773926,
0.4176178276538849,
-0.0016190506285056472,
1.0386441946029663,
-0.008820119313895702,
0.22693638503551483,
-0.1255340278148651,
0.5680431127548218,
0.401618629693985,
-0.08323954045772552,
0.8514402508735657,
0.09030231088399887,
-0.5249925851821899,
-0.6887012124061584,
0.3130118250846863,
-1.0862752199172974,
-0.46040675044059753,
1.330754041671753,
-0.3702794313430786,
-0.39543741941452026,
0.023745955899357796,
0.09856341779232025,
0.2954818904399872,
-0.4108540713787079,
0.7519629001617432,
0.6604999899864197,
0.0003829426714219153,
-0.31899261474609375,
-0.7059237360954285,
0.2651883363723755,
-0.01085716299712658,
-0.6139153838157654,
0.18127146363258362,
0.559080958366394,
0.2505587041378021,
-0.34651023149490356,
0.3582097887992859,
0.1166461631655693,
0.05706700310111046,
0.25943395495414734,
-0.1759832501411438,
-0.29191046953201294,
-0.28726157546043396,
0.0810156837105751,
0.09963595867156982,
0.4314444959163666,
-0.078733891248703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12493v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12493v1
|
EnriCo: Enriched Representation and Globally Constrained Inference for Entity and Relation Extraction
| 2024-04-18T20:15:48 | 2024-04-18T20:15:48 |
Urchade Zaratiana, Nadi Tomeh, Yann Dauxais, Pierre Holat, Thierry Charnois
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Joint entity and relation extraction plays a pivotal role in various
applications, notably in the construction of knowledge graphs. Despite recent
progress, existing approaches often fall short in two key aspects: richness of
representation and coherence in output structure. These models often rely on
handcrafted heuristics for computing entity and relation representations,
potentially leading to loss of crucial information. Furthermore, they disregard
task and/or dataset-specific constraints, resulting in output structures that
lack coherence. In our work, we introduce EnriCo, which mitigates these
shortcomings. Firstly, to foster rich and expressive representation, our model
leverage attention mechanisms that allow both entities and relations to
dynamically determine the pertinent information required for accurate
extraction. Secondly, we introduce a series of decoding algorithms designed to
infer the highest scoring solutions while adhering to task and dataset-specific
constraints, thus promoting structured and coherent outputs. Our model
demonstrates competitive performance compared to baselines when evaluated on
Joint IE datasets.
|
[
-0.5436645746231079,
-0.575217068195343,
0.7193708419799805,
0.03970537334680557,
-0.14187951385974884,
0.0332009494304657,
-0.20196661353111267,
-1.0024545192718506,
0.5458757877349854,
0.4563087522983551,
-0.488974392414093,
-0.23313182592391968,
-0.5429840683937073,
0.1688944697380066,
-0.10699598491191864,
0.8524404764175415,
0.20618675649166107,
0.20504769682884216,
-0.6022633910179138,
0.02331678569316864,
-0.32540398836135864,
-0.11359542608261108,
-0.41453927755355835,
-0.3658064007759094,
0.5096355080604553,
0.4269258975982666,
0.6837465167045593,
0.5132865309715271,
0.2868180274963379,
0.22921930253505707,
-0.08828961104154587,
0.5796318054199219,
-0.8133196830749512,
0.5597266554832458,
-0.5017221570014954,
-0.28454723954200745,
-0.4511655569076538,
-0.4161788821220398,
0.6897974014282227,
1.0354540348052979,
0.17359663546085358,
0.08033019304275513,
0.2143002599477768,
0.2639467716217041,
-0.9923595190048218,
0.6581737399101257,
-0.5681877136230469,
-0.05468106269836426,
-0.22495214641094208,
-0.123259536921978,
-0.7332053184509277,
-0.1949578821659088,
0.04637930542230606,
-0.8883178234100342,
-0.1478528082370758,
-0.00910149049013853,
1.4184653759002686,
0.18326273560523987,
-0.7176715731620789,
-0.26606112718582153,
-1.0614749193191528,
0.6947349309921265,
-0.1767168492078781,
0.8859766125679016,
0.06543277204036713,
0.27516114711761475,
-0.4005245268344879,
-0.7055698037147522,
-0.13372702896595,
0.008515496738255024,
-0.15664200484752655,
0.3322325646877289,
-0.07746763527393341,
0.1585569679737091,
0.2269473522901535,
0.6069790124893188,
0.0674910917878151,
-0.1750364750623703,
-0.31617459654808044,
-0.22886697947978973,
0.7156862616539001,
0.13298125565052032,
0.24120858311653137,
-0.36330264806747437,
-0.479329913854599,
0.03245357424020767,
-0.8291536569595337,
-0.2575293481349945,
0.3671073019504547,
0.153153195977211,
0.1945829838514328,
0.5315423607826233,
-0.32387226819992065,
0.6560425758361816,
-0.00017243299225810915,
-0.10274837911128998,
-0.37322765588760376,
-0.18994033336639404,
-0.1166461929678917,
-0.12322431057691574,
0.8806298971176147,
-0.08153459429740906,
0.24451951682567596,
-0.7577933669090271,
0.030736450105905533,
-0.2133043259382248,
0.05275355279445648,
-0.6166229248046875,
-0.3651667535305023,
-0.016871951520442963,
-0.047025009989738464,
0.15378499031066895,
0.41671979427337646,
-1.0912108421325684,
-0.03486054390668869,
-0.23140324652194977,
0.29311203956604004,
-0.3324987590312958,
-0.3590686023235321,
-0.10935471951961517,
-0.20597437024116516,
-0.08108484745025635,
0.21379771828651428,
-0.8887329697608948,
0.6614686846733093,
0.5158484578132629,
0.4338517189025879,
-0.07167152315378189,
0.25899234414100647,
-0.7617504000663757,
0.9052920937538147,
-0.2554810643196106,
0.6886944770812988,
-0.7452443242073059,
-0.1868279129266739,
-0.4758012294769287,
-0.19530458748340607,
-0.12375223636627197,
-0.47360676527023315,
0.4831230938434601,
-0.8368895053863525,
0.029681777581572533,
-0.5241130590438843,
-0.8353143334388733,
-0.23821388185024261,
-0.12771300971508026,
-1.0803734064102173,
0.8072748184204102,
0.2650923430919647,
-0.8886688947677612,
0.34331822395324707,
-0.3147939145565033,
-0.33875536918640137,
0.16374512016773224,
-0.4175824820995331,
-0.233315572142601,
0.31296202540397644,
0.331754207611084,
0.4160529375076294,
-0.6578412055969238,
0.6133228540420532,
-0.8012886047363281,
-0.1474975049495697,
-0.13407817482948303,
-0.012577373534440994,
1.0417577028274536,
0.29830241203308105,
-0.19909615814685822,
-0.22361785173416138,
-0.8082658052444458,
0.16227994859218597,
0.09199907630681992,
-0.20148447155952454,
-0.5635877847671509,
0.22456584870815277,
-0.36771759390830994,
-0.15656134486198425,
0.09347519278526306,
-0.4125500023365021,
0.15941785275936127,
-0.5255051851272583,
0.09473173320293427,
0.3986254632472992,
0.3586929738521576,
0.48839059472084045,
0.20958930253982544,
0.49403420090675354,
0.03457460179924965,
-0.1509678065776825,
0.10950712859630585,
-0.43711307644844055,
-0.6689513325691223,
-0.36376798152923584,
0.6224400401115417,
0.5067228078842163,
-0.9076413512229919,
0.4068543612957001,
-0.7192345261573792,
-0.326576292514801,
-0.31737738847732544,
0.12939982116222382,
0.3781958520412445,
0.390188068151474,
0.17871148884296417,
-0.3993816375732422,
-0.5532535910606384,
-1.093765139579773,
-0.20133981108665466,
-0.0618368461728096,
0.13447371125221252,
0.4086998403072357,
0.4006454348564148,
0.19955341517925262,
0.8687892556190491,
-0.8408000469207764,
-0.19269169867038727,
-0.3992694020271301,
-0.24019648134708405,
0.2198936939239502,
0.6152483224868774,
0.3487265110015869,
-0.960571825504303,
-0.4118557572364807,
0.21037474274635315,
-0.9089941382408142,
0.2798788249492645,
-0.0663241520524025,
-0.39259636402130127,
-0.3382183313369751,
0.1388719081878662,
-0.7361419796943665,
0.3131844997406006,
0.19260936975479126,
-0.25209400057792664,
0.22421930730342865,
0.18911045789718628,
0.04692840948700905,
-1.2637128829956055,
0.07904036343097687,
-0.2265072762966156,
-0.6053696870803833,
-0.38601768016815186,
0.5337381958961487,
-0.09795450419187546,
-0.1260780543088913,
-0.039526596665382385,
0.3975958824157715,
-0.953131914138794,
-0.5787157416343689,
0.4626668691635132,
0.013601834885776043,
0.608645498752594,
0.5317594408988953,
0.04566613957285881,
0.6097726821899414,
0.4128960967063904,
-0.5160088539123535,
0.4419066905975342,
0.3466404378414154,
-0.2300138771533966,
0.47855257987976074,
-0.5855168700218201,
0.0969466120004654,
0.01816244050860405,
0.011334404349327087,
-0.5538939237594604,
-0.876961350440979,
0.5219061374664307,
-0.2873043119907379,
0.7661851644515991,
-0.14779998362064362,
-0.5527747869491577,
0.06186984106898308,
-0.011928183026611805,
0.28738662600517273,
0.14537237584590912,
-0.5066792964935303,
0.7516494989395142,
0.7234606742858887,
0.06349299103021622,
-0.43932849168777466,
-0.5031101703643799,
0.00917772576212883,
-0.12511563301086426,
-0.6589335203170776,
0.5936121940612793,
0.228391632437706,
-0.3250257670879364,
0.5782809257507324,
-0.242018461227417,
-0.6958810687065125,
0.26632043719291687,
0.04468890279531479,
0.09508313983678818,
-0.17276795208454132,
0.1786092072725296,
0.4280514717102051,
-0.01967781037092209,
0.18037866055965424,
-0.1418050080537796,
0.22038643062114716,
0.22009854018688202,
-0.2761179506778717,
-0.46538177132606506,
0.7512083649635315,
0.40276259183883667,
-0.2513834834098816,
0.8132380843162537,
0.45623350143432617,
-0.7357155084609985,
-0.12902383506298065,
-0.2364439070224762,
-0.2165808081626892,
-0.37794703245162964,
0.44534429907798767,
-0.8823643922805786,
-0.5892578959465027,
0.7509515285491943,
-0.1521560102701187,
-0.2910042703151703,
0.5479135513305664,
0.19668635725975037,
0.21964797377586365,
1.0242488384246826,
0.6305478811264038,
0.14761634171009064,
0.23145043849945068,
-0.4328872263431549,
0.37675023078918457,
-0.9860872626304626,
-0.554846465587616,
-0.6043972373008728,
0.037736762315034866,
-0.4392772316932678,
-0.042703937739133835,
0.5066091418266296,
0.6059877276420593,
0.31364503502845764,
0.3934653401374817,
-0.3570321500301361,
0.5958379507064819,
0.48665425181388855,
0.3101760745048523,
0.39857974648475647,
0.021220242604613304,
-0.2225150763988495,
-0.26630672812461853,
-0.8112232089042664,
-0.14822497963905334,
0.7282983064651489,
0.014616540633141994,
0.690567135810852,
0.26123201847076416,
1.1323891878128052,
-0.10050307959318161,
0.20609821379184723,
-0.8117730617523193,
0.45769014954566956,
0.11083947867155075,
-0.9330153465270996,
-0.1879243403673172,
-0.7379025816917419,
-0.7345576286315918,
0.10046994686126709,
-0.27339866757392883,
-1.1574087142944336,
0.695085883140564,
0.20802532136440277,
-0.2687230408191681,
0.2918935716152191,
-0.7806313037872314,
0.9212309122085571,
0.21111460030078888,
-1.1426899433135986,
-0.1202620267868042,
-0.44768211245536804,
0.5199156403541565,
0.3570620119571686,
-0.0760037824511528,
-0.135985866189003,
0.025979047641158104,
0.39118292927742004,
-0.1927543431520462,
0.5274872183799744,
-0.11759568005800247,
0.07109114527702332,
0.2399073988199234,
0.2130270153284073,
0.577004075050354,
0.6101670861244202,
-0.38148534297943115,
-0.11868599057197571,
-0.08830926567316055,
-0.37778791785240173,
-0.7431156635284424,
0.707432746887207,
-0.5047118663787842,
-0.7624074220657349,
-0.22508898377418518,
-0.6331875324249268,
-0.3375246524810791,
0.4366559088230133,
0.45287755131721497,
0.7133424878120422,
-0.2860642075538635,
0.13761064410209656,
0.6836578249931335,
0.027616076171398163,
0.01621200144290924,
-0.22861896455287933,
0.006754620466381311,
-0.7376179099082947,
0.9510533213615417,
0.25649455189704895,
0.22573715448379517,
0.5277137756347656,
-0.3006505072116852,
-0.3592257499694824,
-0.29638171195983887,
-0.601737380027771,
0.2205725461244583,
-0.8311316967010498,
-0.5547017455101013,
-0.6110238432884216,
-0.07608510553836823,
-0.49510401487350464,
0.11908719688653946,
-0.3481070101261139,
-0.7231547236442566,
-0.5632089376449585,
0.042121827602386475,
-0.12233920395374298,
0.9525647163391113,
-0.03818286955356598,
-0.33364176750183105,
-0.7209933996200562,
0.2601875066757202,
0.34964802861213684,
0.19505955278873444,
0.09138836711645126,
0.282527357339859,
-0.4272187650203705,
-0.1592094600200653,
-0.4284861087799072,
-1.528644323348999,
0.2551664710044861,
0.5773859620094299,
0.5233644247055054,
0.57564777135849,
0.36690178513526917,
1.1892400979995728,
-0.11264064162969589,
0.39943304657936096,
-0.08378923684358597,
-1.0167908668518066,
0.5727477073669434,
-0.3035163879394531,
-0.1571134626865387,
0.5216484665870667,
0.5526882410049438,
0.1888500601053238,
-0.6501118540763855,
-0.787773609161377,
-0.8943403959274292,
0.7676023244857788,
0.24656252562999725,
-0.10507111251354218,
-0.033813610672950745,
0.6625971794128418,
0.06055700033903122,
0.13842344284057617,
-0.9129853844642639,
0.03064548969268799,
0.20161479711532593,
-0.25349920988082886,
0.42167219519615173,
-0.5003048181533813,
-0.08187701553106308,
-0.37638258934020996,
0.7676632404327393,
-0.04487878456711769,
0.4891428053379059,
0.5258582830429077,
-0.26065072417259216,
-0.08085879683494568,
0.23944143950939178,
0.04652480036020279,
0.7992694973945618,
0.002505857264623046,
0.19231471419334412,
0.10780908167362213,
-0.008843917399644852,
-0.04197338595986366,
0.36262646317481995,
-0.3824467957019806,
0.16082066297531128,
0.6712219715118408,
0.7082034945487976,
0.5597395300865173,
-0.24532632529735565,
0.23043233156204224,
0.1143573448061943,
0.21393053233623505,
-0.1816202849149704,
0.3763900101184845,
0.3368797302246094,
0.32700473070144653,
0.13773348927497864,
-0.005406045354902744,
0.7472482919692993,
-0.42881035804748535,
0.1551314890384674,
0.5011093020439148,
-0.3989103138446808,
-0.5326501131057739,
0.9729315042495728,
0.09760721027851105,
0.11493872106075287,
0.4761179983615875,
-0.6352100968360901,
-0.4196953773498535,
0.5940158367156982,
0.570247232913971,
0.7790225744247437,
-0.06464873254299164,
0.08298809826374054,
0.5723274350166321,
-0.06968827545642853,
0.1975933313369751,
0.2979234457015991,
-0.5969962477684021,
-0.7360767126083374,
-0.533341646194458,
-0.4702741503715515,
-0.3750843405723572,
-0.19226320087909698,
-1.3047924041748047,
0.19066686928272247,
-0.1517680436372757,
-0.18626198172569275,
0.20396065711975098,
0.2495889812707901,
-0.6056880354881287,
-0.036892008036375046,
-0.2715144157409668,
0.5376709699630737,
-0.6686995625495911,
1.0419594049453735,
0.7541556358337402,
-0.4554714858531952,
-1.0161548852920532,
-0.05377629026770592,
-0.21452465653419495,
-0.24536137282848358,
0.7977524399757385,
0.22647613286972046,
0.06489042192697525,
0.2581893801689148,
-0.18948045372962952,
-0.9448297619819641,
0.9152820110321045,
1.2162079811096191,
-0.49562689661979675,
-0.3514951467514038,
-0.08453254401683807,
0.22621780633926392,
-0.44516801834106445,
0.07747715711593628,
0.3170837461948395,
0.44774356484413147,
0.10039301216602325,
-0.5623833537101746,
0.024814190343022346,
-0.15009911358356476,
-0.0223060455173254,
0.5158007144927979,
-0.5296770334243774,
0.6110401749610901,
-0.22449713945388794,
-0.7034687399864197,
-0.008130506612360477,
0.8770204186439514,
-0.058101970702409744,
0.29224318265914917,
0.42419901490211487,
0.7996950149536133,
0.7447187900543213,
-0.3622569143772125,
1.0408916473388672,
-0.33290234208106995,
0.5950381755828857,
1.2238844633102417,
-0.3245548903942108,
0.5506728887557983,
0.5089564323425293,
-0.06446859240531921,
0.568259596824646,
0.531431257724762,
0.16221871972084045,
0.5608311295509338,
-0.2913128137588501,
-0.36375391483306885,
-0.6328186988830566,
-0.5568737983703613,
-0.1807733029127121,
0.5819591283798218,
0.4176643490791321,
-0.22752802073955536,
-0.28254151344299316,
-0.3106927275657654,
0.1168464720249176,
0.13864922523498535,
-0.0302976593375206,
0.9258686900138855,
0.11876462399959564,
-0.9601148962974548,
0.33910736441612244,
-0.3709944784641266,
-0.26774024963378906,
-0.3018472194671631,
-0.37928617000579834,
-0.05803489685058594,
0.13567465543746948,
-0.22726988792419434,
-0.39751094579696655,
0.6666375398635864,
-0.2759478986263275,
-0.3172145187854767,
-0.027959447354078293,
0.9146844744682312,
-0.5738204717636108,
-0.4131249189376831,
0.652241051197052,
0.43529340624809265,
-0.03766917437314987,
0.3119578957557678,
-0.29744574427604675,
0.19758258759975433,
0.17928481101989746,
-0.4259783923625946,
-0.12388467788696289,
0.6743367314338684,
0.06106163188815117,
0.41763266921043396,
0.24047724902629852,
0.35307297110557556,
-0.16371716558933258,
-0.30668824911117554,
1.1541857719421387,
-0.4505121111869812,
-0.4519021213054657,
-0.7636843323707581,
0.5532029867172241,
-0.4635658860206604,
-0.07358761876821518,
0.5893958210945129,
0.5912854075431824,
0.7545334696769714,
0.083828866481781,
0.20917223393917084,
-0.26306602358818054,
0.1365751028060913,
-0.7089939713478088,
0.3488488495349884,
-0.6527608036994934,
0.31303107738494873,
-0.2014191746711731,
-1.0326367616653442,
-0.3307238221168518,
0.4413256347179413,
-0.08775851875543594,
-0.10525964945554733,
0.5090832114219666,
0.5082453489303589,
-0.2908557653427124,
-0.03270472213625908,
0.2583653926849365,
0.20220737159252167,
0.394325315952301,
0.9405992031097412,
0.4699387550354004,
-0.4817142188549042,
0.5571299195289612,
-0.4447292387485504,
0.11067403107881546,
-0.060155000537633896,
-0.7062315344810486,
-0.7547565698623657,
-0.6506472229957581,
-0.2424711436033249,
-0.22442737221717834,
0.2940944731235504,
0.6707786321640015,
0.9799738526344299,
-0.6621442437171936,
-0.040612537413835526,
-0.19969387352466583,
0.5595834255218506,
-0.1806536465883255,
-0.27692821621894836,
0.26225265860557556,
-0.2851676940917969,
-1.0347672700881958,
0.3450891375541687,
0.43054628372192383,
-0.16273681819438934,
-0.2155996859073639,
-0.0726180374622345,
-0.16840004920959473,
-0.25502240657806396,
0.26360851526260376,
0.16544613242149353,
-0.47222164273262024,
-0.4443078339099884,
-0.1375247985124588,
0.17395666241645813,
0.19263115525245667,
0.4761839807033539,
-0.7795296311378479,
0.6762092113494873,
0.6331446766853333,
0.6780171394348145,
0.670295774936676,
-0.19942152500152588,
0.9142628312110901,
-0.8385271430015564,
0.2601233124732971,
0.45964813232421875,
0.4689393937587738,
0.32805192470550537,
-0.7670950293540955,
0.6561466455459595,
0.29626208543777466,
-0.4079481065273285,
-1.012718677520752,
0.6297945380210876,
-0.835878849029541,
-0.077574722468853,
0.6171267628669739,
-0.6099916696548462,
-0.4238876700401306,
-0.11162128299474716,
0.35465067625045776,
0.47715142369270325,
-0.41934528946876526,
0.5965859293937683,
0.7360984086990356,
-0.348440021276474,
-0.033274780958890915,
-0.4534083604812622,
0.34919142723083496,
0.23795923590660095,
-1.0155752897262573,
-0.13105511665344238,
0.7362411618232727,
0.10627710819244385,
0.43237704038619995,
0.29703962802886963,
-0.13186512887477875,
0.34085917472839355,
0.07142415642738342,
-0.06163143366575241,
-0.1061263158917427,
-0.7437395453453064,
0.07015137374401093,
0.53836590051651,
0.1524193435907364,
0.05288050323724747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12491v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12491v1
|
GraphER: A Structure-aware Text-to-Graph Model for Entity and Relation Extraction
| 2024-04-18T20:09:37 | 2024-04-18T20:09:37 |
Urchade Zaratiana, Nadi Tomeh, Niama El Khbir, Pierre Holat, Thierry Charnois
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Information extraction (IE) is an important task in Natural Language
Processing (NLP), involving the extraction of named entities and their
relationships from unstructured text. In this paper, we propose a novel
approach to this task by formulating it as graph structure learning (GSL). By
formulating IE as GSL, we enhance the model's ability to dynamically refine and
optimize the graph structure during the extraction process. This formulation
allows for better interaction and structure-informed decisions for entity and
relation prediction, in contrast to previous models that have separate or
untied predictions for these tasks. When compared against state-of-the-art
baselines on joint entity and relation extraction benchmarks, our model,
GraphER, achieves competitive results.
|
[
-0.12100483477115631,
-0.9491391777992249,
0.5092923641204834,
-0.11559488624334335,
-0.16777636110782623,
0.1742870956659317,
0.057549454271793365,
-1.004377007484436,
0.1361173391342163,
0.421487420797348,
-0.32319697737693787,
-0.4947420656681061,
-0.890552818775177,
0.11009873449802399,
-0.39971286058425903,
1.269729733467102,
-0.05342348292469978,
-0.24570609629154205,
-0.18961277604103088,
0.08424826711416245,
-0.1879805028438568,
-0.2688330411911011,
-0.838592529296875,
-0.4558221399784088,
0.6243693232536316,
-0.08448322862386703,
0.5037285685539246,
0.8831870555877686,
0.4041813910007477,
0.29074546694755554,
-0.21826867759227753,
0.09678259491920471,
-0.5058994889259338,
0.30730223655700684,
-0.30395928025245667,
-0.34713709354400635,
-0.5710418820381165,
-0.08837002515792847,
0.7265133857727051,
1.0229135751724243,
-0.042228974401950836,
0.2767222225666046,
0.05061941593885422,
0.6648858189582825,
-0.5125197172164917,
0.7653332948684692,
-0.8252784013748169,
0.017190998420119286,
-0.0919131338596344,
-0.07552425563335419,
-0.69842129945755,
-0.17725668847560883,
0.31226950883865356,
-0.7689006328582764,
0.19937780499458313,
0.15539728105068207,
1.3402185440063477,
0.06613123416900635,
-0.5759444832801819,
-0.44967418909072876,
-0.7100245952606201,
0.09527119994163513,
-0.22097359597682953,
0.8208751678466797,
-0.010148615576326847,
0.2873867154121399,
-0.16553108394145966,
-1.3680919408798218,
-0.1984921246767044,
0.14089025557041168,
-0.33360838890075684,
0.13021542131900787,
-0.14160507917404175,
0.03761876001954079,
0.11188364028930664,
0.29845479130744934,
-0.28917214274406433,
-0.15727300941944122,
-0.5413904786109924,
0.14694170653820038,
0.4233812689781189,
-0.2658975124359131,
0.731116771697998,
-0.4166441559791565,
-0.6021740436553955,
0.23285429179668427,
-0.6565120220184326,
0.15701165795326233,
0.13351371884346008,
0.6267244815826416,
0.19036619365215302,
0.6174586415290833,
0.1151466816663742,
0.3923981189727783,
0.2589000463485718,
-0.11311743408441544,
0.16296838223934174,
0.09555914998054504,
-0.43811163306236267,
0.29591700434684753,
0.7746624946594238,
0.07714878022670746,
0.36461472511291504,
-0.8304003477096558,
-0.16757862269878387,
0.08058613538742065,
0.13540340960025787,
-0.9871863126754761,
-0.7343642115592957,
0.04332254081964493,
-0.48553338646888733,
-0.2886185348033905,
0.17434893548488617,
-0.7802067995071411,
-0.04859640449285507,
-0.1495055854320526,
-0.0077511887066066265,
-0.45303574204444885,
-0.2951173186302185,
-0.2325473129749298,
-0.40987706184387207,
-0.2215748131275177,
0.33160316944122314,
-0.9064716696739197,
0.5662099719047546,
0.47035151720046997,
0.7138668894767761,
-0.3247576355934143,
-0.0035541108809411526,
-0.7647011280059814,
0.7354405522346497,
-0.06916292756795883,
0.8374966382980347,
-0.7091418504714966,
-0.5103548765182495,
-0.4227895438671112,
0.05828366056084633,
-0.20243766903877258,
-0.19180342555046082,
0.39971548318862915,
-0.8492446541786194,
0.33317601680755615,
0.01193172112107277,
-0.7298266887664795,
-0.18450894951820374,
0.19497671723365784,
-1.1212588548660278,
1.0509693622589111,
0.38082632422447205,
-1.0278798341751099,
0.43055596947669983,
-0.6916884779930115,
-0.4724675118923187,
0.5760064721107483,
-0.4657168984413147,
-0.4685477614402771,
-0.17118823528289795,
0.3132559657096863,
0.2220342457294464,
-0.12326459586620331,
0.3015470802783966,
-0.23146505653858185,
-0.030161652714014053,
-0.38408634066581726,
0.14633077383041382,
0.8055475950241089,
0.09126988798379898,
0.0964742973446846,
0.10806707292795181,
-0.8830245733261108,
0.10111045837402344,
0.4564448595046997,
-0.6204803586006165,
-0.5060721635818481,
0.30700576305389404,
-0.16849146783351898,
0.20133841037750244,
0.10222848504781723,
-0.4960196018218994,
0.17529065907001495,
-0.8524159789085388,
0.47795847058296204,
0.6237186789512634,
0.370311975479126,
0.7222933769226074,
0.32355353236198425,
0.38898226618766785,
-0.31590965390205383,
-0.2538544237613678,
-0.003633716609328985,
-0.3463524878025055,
-0.37205514311790466,
-0.3225572109222412,
0.5538228750228882,
0.6141700744628906,
-0.6511350274085999,
0.24429918825626373,
-0.5810858607292175,
-0.44006291031837463,
-0.14726956188678741,
0.09287604689598083,
0.4284078776836395,
0.887309730052948,
0.4233377277851105,
-0.15337136387825012,
-0.6890429258346558,
-0.4082593321800232,
-0.5429984331130981,
-0.30586671829223633,
-0.007666727993637323,
0.25876227021217346,
0.29031598567962646,
-0.20962046086788177,
1.1214181184768677,
-0.8233447074890137,
-0.25066637992858887,
-0.4714421033859253,
0.1208893209695816,
-0.07094574719667435,
0.12425415217876434,
0.4183956980705261,
-1.1365305185317993,
-0.7880388498306274,
0.20866018533706665,
-0.9393499493598938,
0.17516399919986725,
0.29961952567100525,
-0.16741813719272614,
-0.15688879787921906,
0.6002126336097717,
-0.8314992785453796,
0.4458087682723999,
0.21178796887397766,
-0.17413923144340515,
0.4039298892021179,
0.07715559005737305,
-0.4854711890220642,
-1.2479132413864136,
0.14679455757141113,
0.232949897646904,
-0.5398187041282654,
-0.515181839466095,
0.28206300735473633,
0.02343820594251156,
-0.33891716599464417,
-0.1695326715707779,
0.6273947358131409,
-0.9068157076835632,
-0.20405703783035278,
0.041637271642684937,
0.5575044751167297,
0.30398625135421753,
0.4033074975013733,
-0.047090623527765274,
0.7096408605575562,
0.3890276849269867,
-0.46564221382141113,
0.10692883282899857,
0.5363373160362244,
-0.04862013831734657,
0.1746169626712799,
-0.7231725454330444,
0.2777101695537567,
-0.3883262276649475,
0.13792195916175842,
-0.6825912594795227,
-0.10101127624511719,
0.256304532289505,
-0.5107319355010986,
0.5821846723556519,
-0.45076462626457214,
-0.1873372197151184,
-0.2271362841129303,
0.03654402494430542,
-0.06929242610931396,
0.004112566821277142,
-0.6046286821365356,
1.019736647605896,
0.8396933078765869,
-0.47900688648223877,
-0.5928173661231995,
-0.29178234934806824,
0.08217594772577286,
-0.09100658446550369,
-0.4901513457298279,
0.6150398850440979,
0.1946980059146881,
-0.2129240334033966,
0.4370080232620239,
-0.4545432925224304,
-0.3758281469345093,
0.2500746548175812,
0.36081287264823914,
0.5241711735725403,
-0.14525102078914642,
0.445502370595932,
-0.1400575190782547,
-0.22899821400642395,
0.171441912651062,
-0.25060907006263733,
0.44221049547195435,
0.07932780683040619,
0.13378161191940308,
-0.1406160145998001,
0.3750043511390686,
0.09041944891214371,
-0.626173198223114,
0.500515878200531,
0.3029896318912506,
-0.7062290906906128,
-0.19548936188220978,
0.12020067125558853,
0.041800446808338165,
-0.4502132833003998,
0.6429497003555298,
-0.763698160648346,
-0.8099363446235657,
0.3071499764919281,
-0.5597322583198547,
0.02352917194366455,
0.7260187864303589,
-0.012411793693900108,
0.022822218015789986,
1.2451660633087158,
1.1111056804656982,
-0.21593402326107025,
0.5514901280403137,
-0.11826431006193161,
0.6350358724594116,
-0.8425541520118713,
-0.43231937289237976,
-0.6091129183769226,
0.08325760066509247,
-0.4530867636203766,
0.20628264546394348,
0.02183203399181366,
0.5700793266296387,
-0.05565397068858147,
0.5730314254760742,
-0.654639482498169,
0.4970857799053192,
0.11454671621322632,
-0.025871308520436287,
0.4011971056461334,
0.18414026498794556,
-0.19608983397483826,
0.056748539209365845,
-0.32963326573371887,
-0.6770879030227661,
0.7805687785148621,
0.15342243015766144,
0.423143208026886,
0.05805998295545578,
0.7539308071136475,
0.0830092504620552,
0.5086784958839417,
-0.759912371635437,
0.445344477891922,
-0.13467517495155334,
-0.47940999269485474,
-0.4290267527103424,
-0.6055037975311279,
-1.0881134271621704,
0.1726735383272171,
-0.3126372992992401,
-1.453466534614563,
0.046585116535425186,
-0.0485880970954895,
0.09432537108659744,
0.32761839032173157,
-0.7207645177841187,
0.7398948669433594,
0.08464066684246063,
-0.1285240352153778,
0.4542468190193176,
-0.6617656946182251,
0.10210351645946503,
0.0006358135142363608,
0.26299136877059937,
-0.15038657188415527,
0.19187967479228973,
0.5926123857498169,
-0.09987866878509521,
0.443525493144989,
-0.13134953379631042,
0.051909081637859344,
0.16468490660190582,
0.14359571039676666,
0.9611152410507202,
0.1457771211862564,
-0.23769663274288177,
-0.1699359118938446,
-0.13973748683929443,
0.02543080784380436,
-0.6974585056304932,
0.3862511217594147,
-0.637275755405426,
-0.3768090605735779,
-0.11576636135578156,
-0.3960387706756592,
-0.1014752984046936,
0.7085757851600647,
0.2736007273197174,
0.4596114456653595,
-0.3603532612323761,
-0.08230164647102356,
0.31477195024490356,
0.29542243480682373,
0.361177921295166,
0.18420274555683136,
-0.5184236764907837,
-0.38128748536109924,
0.723743736743927,
0.14210310578346252,
-0.03698742762207985,
0.6108338832855225,
-0.07677991688251495,
-0.3907168507575989,
-0.47393468022346497,
-0.31294041872024536,
0.20165616273880005,
-0.9008281230926514,
-0.10263387113809586,
-1.095306158065796,
-0.5296449661254883,
-0.439032644033432,
0.06730006635189056,
-0.2522156238555908,
-0.40901002287864685,
-0.2472754418849945,
-0.5040857195854187,
-0.11055536568164825,
0.7477397918701172,
0.6294587850570679,
0.12203957885503769,
-0.7297528982162476,
0.30298128724098206,
0.24099650979042053,
0.24280619621276855,
-0.22163787484169006,
0.08701206743717194,
-0.05087047442793846,
-0.2744936943054199,
-0.2614051401615143,
-1.0814062356948853,
0.4284358620643616,
0.38887959718704224,
0.4899807870388031,
0.398909330368042,
-0.06696684658527374,
0.7201902270317078,
-0.7512208819389343,
0.3941960334777832,
0.2684290111064911,
-0.7962899804115295,
0.6776924133300781,
-0.1114850863814354,
-0.34374526143074036,
0.4511762261390686,
0.3761157989501953,
-0.3302229642868042,
-0.21765658259391785,
-0.7465848922729492,
-1.0016216039657593,
0.4334625005722046,
0.18298426270484924,
-0.25019022822380066,
-0.11098381876945496,
0.6726763248443604,
-0.06930612772703171,
0.21588298678398132,
-1.1396479606628418,
-0.28638479113578796,
0.063383549451828,
-0.2361992597579956,
0.09809789061546326,
-0.27986785769462585,
-0.0049611483700573444,
-0.11620598286390305,
0.6422303318977356,
-0.13620924949645996,
0.223081573843956,
0.19719870388507843,
-0.45936140418052673,
-0.30846211314201355,
0.19944752752780914,
-0.29017192125320435,
0.7757396101951599,
-0.30990150570869446,
0.3731144070625305,
0.12915122509002686,
-0.3095073103904724,
-0.1893283873796463,
0.5999528765678406,
-0.33206865191459656,
-0.0230410136282444,
0.39004331827163696,
0.7777954936027527,
0.21610939502716064,
-0.31395453214645386,
0.3815704584121704,
-0.039244700223207474,
-0.044738441705703735,
-0.015208881348371506,
0.03335298225283623,
0.2501786947250366,
0.33075106143951416,
0.2643119692802429,
0.05319656804203987,
0.3474034070968628,
-0.49431225657463074,
0.5077715516090393,
0.4213961660861969,
-0.7452535033226013,
-0.45770150423049927,
1.0290812253952026,
0.06235996633768082,
-0.5984420776367188,
0.6210592985153198,
-0.3270769715309143,
-0.5953119397163391,
0.458570271730423,
1.0046281814575195,
0.638984739780426,
-0.15563248097896576,
0.2191871851682663,
0.33539706468582153,
-0.016880545765161514,
0.26307132840156555,
-0.025947168469429016,
0.038369495421648026,
-0.795570433139801,
-0.3544448912143707,
-0.49830010533332825,
-0.10513325035572052,
-0.08039610087871552,
-0.7301254868507385,
0.3329620063304901,
-0.3515133261680603,
-0.10855546593666077,
0.585601270198822,
0.3247695565223694,
-0.4113825559616089,
0.34561917185783386,
-0.09531398117542267,
0.7843625545501709,
-0.5701752305030823,
1.0135021209716797,
0.8461693525314331,
-0.6137245297431946,
-1.1533750295639038,
-0.21219350397586823,
-0.14963001012802124,
-0.5802486538887024,
0.7627710103988647,
0.45528897643089294,
-0.17398665845394135,
0.3813553750514984,
-0.2506221532821655,
-0.8388024568557739,
1.2755255699157715,
0.6155163645744324,
-0.3736381232738495,
-0.7614217400550842,
-0.2409323751926422,
0.3174925744533539,
-0.6327601075172424,
0.1553676575422287,
0.29514697194099426,
0.20076867938041687,
0.03234528377652168,
-0.4237656593322754,
0.1893085539340973,
-0.5829989314079285,
-0.06643771380186081,
0.708999514579773,
-0.25258639454841614,
1.009971261024475,
-0.12653790414333344,
-0.9219932556152344,
-0.3064371943473816,
0.670985758304596,
0.07434488087892532,
0.17830918729305267,
0.6111226081848145,
0.44453856348991394,
1.1788402795791626,
0.11503943800926208,
0.9775566458702087,
-0.39666417241096497,
0.5668012499809265,
1.5466667413711548,
-0.4490787088871002,
0.7843471169471741,
0.23713506758213043,
-0.11353172361850739,
0.893711507320404,
0.5863438844680786,
-0.0194815956056118,
0.516726016998291,
-0.17897938191890717,
-0.031222740188241005,
-0.024019936099648476,
-0.08105461299419403,
-0.1931465119123459,
0.3906438648700714,
0.2528965473175049,
-0.6028040647506714,
-0.4964970350265503,
-0.5213322043418884,
0.2187090367078781,
0.10392247140407562,
-0.1596561223268509,
0.9048927426338196,
0.06943338364362717,
-0.37055331468582153,
-0.16998906433582306,
-0.04293601214885712,
-0.10363452881574631,
-0.5145493149757385,
-0.1316995769739151,
0.31050899624824524,
0.006109509617090225,
-0.16337403655052185,
-0.5095218420028687,
0.29185816645622253,
-0.13791503012180328,
-0.5428205728530884,
-0.014647187665104866,
1.2879204750061035,
-0.4876013398170471,
-0.3563801646232605,
0.739335834980011,
0.51517653465271,
0.04430345445871353,
-0.246159628033638,
-0.7081375122070312,
-0.3903047740459442,
0.02723369002342224,
-0.3292886018753052,
0.15507985651493073,
0.5112414956092834,
-0.04575362801551819,
0.6105824708938599,
0.6889055967330933,
0.30508172512054443,
-0.1445726752281189,
-0.0541725791990757,
1.0661510229110718,
-0.5390942096710205,
-0.6542226076126099,
-0.962181031703949,
0.4273292124271393,
-0.5546990036964417,
-0.07966586202383041,
0.6785914897918701,
0.8325830698013306,
0.592313826084137,
0.32244932651519775,
0.7679076790809631,
0.06711059808731079,
0.47123637795448303,
-0.40087419748306274,
0.5696234107017517,
-0.2789406180381775,
0.1272014081478119,
-0.44407930970191956,
-1.132644772529602,
-0.19309143722057343,
0.411783903837204,
-0.2545783519744873,
-0.23407594859600067,
0.9151008129119873,
0.3156701624393463,
-0.07283341884613037,
0.20449747145175934,
-0.09042425453662872,
0.02783340774476528,
0.6500925421714783,
0.4034020006656647,
0.3151485025882721,
-0.4740959107875824,
0.7829879522323608,
0.12418976426124573,
0.017153332009911537,
0.2921563386917114,
-0.834205687046051,
-0.9075614213943481,
-0.5063785910606384,
-0.2261441946029663,
-0.22543150186538696,
0.054138001054525375,
0.6902285814285278,
0.6768166422843933,
-0.4903623163700104,
0.1295851171016693,
-0.3537793457508087,
0.3519429862499237,
0.009490160271525383,
-0.2690959572792053,
0.6558026075363159,
-0.36781564354896545,
-0.7480942010879517,
0.5187878608703613,
0.6212872266769409,
0.09606918692588806,
0.3796467185020447,
0.021332992240786552,
-0.4471406638622284,
-0.1238282099366188,
0.626131534576416,
0.2832157015800476,
-0.3555867373943329,
-0.44720977544784546,
-0.3012109398841858,
-0.2206287980079651,
0.5082641243934631,
0.489695280790329,
-0.6172415018081665,
0.5696147680282593,
0.33824965357780457,
0.568861186504364,
0.8473543524742126,
0.3316846787929535,
0.660820722579956,
-0.9274891018867493,
-0.05892125517129898,
-0.1398475617170334,
0.4329002797603607,
0.2527669668197632,
-0.6949647068977356,
0.7779658436775208,
0.2499680370092392,
-0.29397350549697876,
-0.7633090019226074,
0.43824827671051025,
-0.776782214641571,
-0.3347212076187134,
0.8364022374153137,
-0.3955492675304413,
-0.3827877640724182,
-0.10517726838588715,
-0.10669684410095215,
0.732386589050293,
-0.36069992184638977,
0.5472413301467896,
0.45648494362831116,
0.002759302034974098,
-0.2566084861755371,
-0.35238999128341675,
0.5052921175956726,
-0.39425382018089294,
-1.0410889387130737,
-0.1031845211982727,
0.18487784266471863,
0.41136351227760315,
0.3576901853084564,
0.7117652297019958,
-0.14539273083209991,
-0.24399296939373016,
-0.032734986394643784,
0.16818904876708984,
-0.17362180352210999,
-0.48650845885276794,
0.3352229595184326,
0.6205623149871826,
-0.09043620526790619,
0.02490123175084591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12489v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12489v2
|
Grammatical Error Correction for Code-Switched Sentences by Learners of English
| 2024-04-18T20:05:30 | 2024-05-06T22:27:36 |
Kelvin Wey Han Chan, Christopher Bryant, Li Nguyen, Andrew Caines, Zheng Yuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Code-switching (CSW) is a common phenomenon among multilingual speakers where
multiple languages are used in a single discourse or utterance. Mixed language
utterances may still contain grammatical errors however, yet most existing
Grammar Error Correction (GEC) systems have been trained on monolingual data
and not developed with CSW in mind. In this work, we conduct the first
exploration into the use of GEC systems on CSW text. Through this exploration,
we propose a novel method of generating synthetic CSW GEC datasets by
translating different spans of text within existing GEC corpora. We then
investigate different methods of selecting these spans based on CSW ratio,
switch-point factor and linguistic constraints, and identify how they affect
the performance of GEC systems on CSW text. Our best model achieves an average
increase of 1.57 $F_{0.5}$ across 3 CSW test sets (English-Chinese,
English-Korean and English-Japanese) without affecting the model's performance
on a monolingual dataset. We furthermore discovered that models trained on one
CSW language generalise relatively well to other typologically similar CSW
languages.
|
[
-0.09118150919675827,
-0.732231080532074,
0.3075040876865387,
0.542834997177124,
0.16512364149093628,
0.23828738927841187,
-0.3157689571380615,
-0.4682631492614746,
0.009695809334516525,
0.12561707198619843,
-0.5994356870651245,
-0.5630326867103577,
-0.28732216358184814,
0.54612797498703,
-0.5693579316139221,
0.8853028416633606,
-0.29742297530174255,
0.3358605206012726,
-0.12418591976165771,
-0.02024409919977188,
-0.4642549157142639,
-0.8514679074287415,
-0.4121914207935333,
-0.0602731890976429,
0.4378426969051361,
0.577392041683197,
0.8718635439872742,
0.34489205479621887,
0.1893712729215622,
0.28571921586990356,
-0.06695067882537842,
0.49688348174095154,
-0.460990309715271,
-0.4970231354236603,
-0.2189851850271225,
-0.5392751693725586,
-0.35671645402908325,
-0.18956780433654785,
0.5755290389060974,
0.8602845072746277,
-0.0626242384314537,
-0.13621938228607178,
0.1821073442697525,
0.524173378944397,
-0.6515170335769653,
0.1935637891292572,
-0.5858519077301025,
0.3721024990081787,
-0.31440070271492004,
-0.018396183848381042,
-0.9182653427124023,
-0.2969803512096405,
-0.112212173640728,
-0.5790620446205139,
0.47017306089401245,
-0.26921164989471436,
0.9840308427810669,
-0.1204414963722229,
-0.3830772638320923,
-0.21634221076965332,
-0.798466145992279,
0.7721736431121826,
-0.8039551377296448,
0.3385469913482666,
0.2483978271484375,
-0.1576455533504486,
0.04973743110895157,
-0.5037811398506165,
-0.4625234007835388,
-0.16085344552993774,
-0.3799953758716583,
0.3085997402667999,
-0.26595520973205566,
0.13517054915428162,
0.21468713879585266,
0.15894627571105957,
-0.42478570342063904,
-0.07265624403953552,
-0.35611504316329956,
-0.174764022231102,
0.5676414370536804,
0.14589525759220123,
0.5946714282035828,
-0.22208330035209656,
-0.05799688398838043,
-0.03241213783621788,
-0.5202271342277527,
0.10610770434141159,
0.45687443017959595,
0.5647150874137878,
-0.22260946035385132,
0.44071558117866516,
-0.0515548437833786,
0.7434875965118408,
0.08951342105865479,
-0.012757944874465466,
0.30842557549476624,
-0.49213868379592896,
-0.20742544531822205,
-0.12452878057956696,
0.45680126547813416,
0.29392144083976746,
0.5055259466171265,
-0.1666463166475296,
0.016179703176021576,
0.5166329741477966,
0.2261727899312973,
-0.21972694993019104,
-0.207983136177063,
-0.2257731705904007,
-0.39495307207107544,
-0.5000914931297302,
0.39612483978271484,
-0.6504579186439514,
0.11726078391075134,
-0.3055136501789093,
-0.031108852475881577,
-0.32915258407592773,
-0.13991162180900574,
0.29626327753067017,
0.15797284245491028,
-0.07055927813053131,
0.11875490099191666,
-0.761570930480957,
0.39554765820503235,
0.17643682658672333,
0.7040683627128601,
-0.26548534631729126,
-0.6722972989082336,
-0.3999696969985962,
-0.1329038292169571,
-0.5336998701095581,
0.5855388641357422,
-0.4293059706687927,
-0.6261412501335144,
0.47061172127723694,
0.2849108576774597,
-0.4626600444316864,
-0.2908080220222473,
0.3201482594013214,
-0.4786367416381836,
0.32806599140167236,
-0.1931270956993103,
-0.3038274943828583,
0.19179902970790863,
0.049627918750047684,
-0.7366602420806885,
1.23023521900177,
0.0007019962067715824,
-0.7798780202865601,
0.29739388823509216,
-0.39694783091545105,
-0.9136311411857605,
-0.23750987648963928,
-0.018609043210744858,
-0.39093366265296936,
-0.06503929197788239,
0.29067477583885193,
0.15867716073989868,
0.2737911641597748,
0.13385482132434845,
0.03835749626159668,
-0.364886999130249,
0.36447834968566895,
-0.372981995344162,
0.7491233348846436,
0.13946300745010376,
-0.3657239079475403,
-0.08357566595077515,
-0.8783696889877319,
0.4291292130947113,
-0.01175693329423666,
-0.5772776007652283,
-0.38623136281967163,
0.44207414984703064,
0.1318831741809845,
0.26871544122695923,
-0.01299544982612133,
-0.4219803512096405,
0.16946247220039368,
-0.0700964629650116,
0.15683844685554504,
0.5668429136276245,
-0.1015283614397049,
0.35743144154548645,
-0.1822039783000946,
0.7675785422325134,
-0.05521722882986069,
0.08881047368049622,
0.021725120022892952,
-0.2865809202194214,
-0.9940744638442993,
0.17592348158359528,
0.3339739143848419,
1.0346440076828003,
-0.9162759780883789,
0.19715535640716553,
0.12670445442199707,
-0.12624885141849518,
-0.2979736030101776,
0.016688013449311256,
0.6675981283187866,
0.035548098385334015,
0.45429667830467224,
0.1697743684053421,
-0.7712878584861755,
-0.5764887928962708,
-0.4791069030761719,
-0.4390789568424225,
0.26596173644065857,
0.21566660702228546,
0.12488256394863129,
-0.22261685132980347,
0.8440523743629456,
-0.701705276966095,
0.1833696812391281,
-0.3669101595878601,
0.12819266319274902,
0.14847232401371002,
0.2838330864906311,
0.40957462787628174,
-0.5453920364379883,
-0.6465146541595459,
0.26212361454963684,
-0.5571632981300354,
-0.596022367477417,
-0.6274054050445557,
-0.2292577475309372,
0.5099055767059326,
0.9669776558876038,
-0.0684165209531784,
0.4692704975605011,
0.9343342781066895,
-0.5312749743461609,
0.8359165787696838,
-0.3127996027469635,
0.30857717990875244,
-0.9453758597373962,
-0.13566702604293823,
0.056650709360837936,
-0.3385184705257416,
-0.61855548620224,
0.18965701758861542,
0.5787413120269775,
0.0907476618885994,
-0.43014413118362427,
-0.022002670913934708,
-0.6883378624916077,
0.23237113654613495,
-0.0079510398209095,
-0.042373377829790115,
-0.19078044593334198,
0.5476159453392029,
-0.08163526654243469,
0.696541428565979,
0.22873547673225403,
-0.6196719408035278,
-0.015092674642801285,
0.26996031403541565,
0.02521357126533985,
0.36918845772743225,
-0.27932682633399963,
0.2725503444671631,
-0.0785415843129158,
-0.09746987372636795,
-0.9182271957397461,
0.014533933252096176,
0.013142650946974754,
-0.2980841398239136,
0.24187421798706055,
-0.19130665063858032,
-0.3207227289676666,
-0.3928564190864563,
0.1879606693983078,
0.3502621054649353,
0.13990618288516998,
-0.7714243531227112,
0.24069678783416748,
0.1358647644519806,
-0.10769150406122208,
-0.5412169694900513,
-1.001490831375122,
0.1348506212234497,
0.3501289486885071,
-0.705274760723114,
0.3401915729045868,
-0.0012508523650467396,
-0.25457367300987244,
0.01042464841157198,
-0.08467938005924225,
-0.01644747704267502,
-0.17730394005775452,
0.04075992852449417,
0.6616308093070984,
-0.23815733194351196,
0.17711478471755981,
0.21983157098293304,
0.0008223431650549173,
-0.040949247777462006,
-0.24993297457695007,
0.32962554693222046,
-0.45906296372413635,
-0.4173460304737091,
0.23502744734287262,
0.4690825641155243,
0.2552568018436432,
-0.1783733069896698,
0.4765828251838684,
-0.023948373273015022,
-0.3817366063594818,
-0.5757120847702026,
-0.2423008531332016,
0.39451679587364197,
-0.426787793636322,
0.511825680732727,
-0.40677782893180847,
-0.6526774168014526,
0.5264531970024109,
0.20572395622730255,
0.05943581461906433,
0.3911433517932892,
0.37602707743644714,
0.021942196413874626,
0.8588391542434692,
0.7877466082572937,
-0.08318167179822922,
0.5992532968521118,
0.1406964212656021,
0.2694702744483948,
0.018090955913066864,
-0.007666971534490585,
-0.6547285914421082,
-0.1953001767396927,
-0.7663466930389404,
-0.5436724424362183,
0.33290430903434753,
0.061800844967365265,
0.1433911919593811,
0.5556726455688477,
-0.16205686330795288,
0.7583022713661194,
0.13812673091888428,
0.24890820682048798,
0.6033793091773987,
0.15446485579013824,
-0.4395361840724945,
-0.30978235602378845,
-0.8025233745574951,
-0.28160127997398376,
0.7689738273620605,
0.022613525390625,
1.0279756784439087,
-0.0042448751628398895,
0.45543235540390015,
0.28976985812187195,
0.05893191322684288,
-0.5628233551979065,
0.5815611481666565,
-0.6478248834609985,
-0.3334744870662689,
-0.2525111138820648,
-0.5343915224075317,
-0.7924157381057739,
0.32743167877197266,
-0.21470661461353302,
-0.18097515404224396,
0.2675347626209259,
0.25714370608329773,
-0.10063941031694412,
0.47188040614128113,
-1.008995532989502,
0.8045667409896851,
-0.21266162395477295,
-0.24180474877357483,
-0.13447381556034088,
-0.6366734504699707,
0.09770576655864716,
0.07617903500795364,
0.36825472116470337,
0.3341970443725586,
0.18187656998634338,
0.2907802164554596,
-0.5490748286247253,
0.9138175845146179,
0.05460971221327782,
-0.18706314265727997,
0.2805059254169464,
0.2806957960128784,
0.6276853084564209,
-0.1106693297624588,
0.0063398065976798534,
0.2570643424987793,
-0.1277063637971878,
-0.370701402425766,
-0.28218886256217957,
0.41156595945358276,
-0.7217347621917725,
-0.20506562292575836,
-0.6208120584487915,
-0.5198361277580261,
-0.4762594699859619,
0.17898818850517273,
0.36097273230552673,
0.17776775360107422,
-0.5881486535072327,
-0.2653215527534485,
0.3628564774990082,
-0.23739168047904968,
0.4758910536766052,
0.7158187627792358,
-0.35070714354515076,
-0.08786137402057648,
0.6032717823982239,
0.15005281567573547,
0.6740337610244751,
0.3349370062351227,
-0.09366638958454132,
0.2966707944869995,
-0.3313888907432556,
-0.5904905796051025,
0.11678770184516907,
-0.7403771281242371,
-0.08982723951339722,
-0.5772261023521423,
-0.22181513905525208,
-0.264845609664917,
-0.5634259581565857,
-0.328277051448822,
-0.2480343133211136,
-0.36972543597221375,
-0.36619991064071655,
0.14060518145561218,
0.564793050289154,
-0.07140319049358368,
0.10942994058132172,
-0.7054014205932617,
0.16383221745491028,
0.068827785551548,
0.41829749941825867,
-0.4096669852733612,
-0.352385550737381,
-0.4045032262802124,
0.13319550454616547,
0.052147913724184036,
-1.0651304721832275,
0.32089000940322876,
0.17385832965373993,
0.32786285877227783,
0.033582158386707306,
-0.29559969902038574,
0.9211592674255371,
-0.6581655144691467,
0.8640651106834412,
0.2469346672296524,
-1.2541276216506958,
0.38659533858299255,
-0.36326128244400024,
0.49584293365478516,
0.608299970626831,
-0.0025167823769152164,
-1.262927532196045,
-0.5704678297042847,
-0.45147281885147095,
-0.7336625456809998,
0.7288734912872314,
0.10143773257732391,
0.11858182400465012,
-0.2949901819229126,
0.1764020025730133,
0.018443861976265907,
-0.19276577234268188,
-1.0503312349319458,
-0.27207261323928833,
-0.13171972334384918,
-0.2180415540933609,
0.15370117127895355,
-0.08346311748027802,
0.2028939425945282,
-0.20231278240680695,
0.8985380530357361,
-0.40230220556259155,
-0.0026768436655402184,
0.3291585445404053,
-0.45862847566604614,
-0.41628921031951904,
0.4733404517173767,
0.47491100430488586,
0.7533815503120422,
0.2886849045753479,
0.1387755274772644,
0.5111918449401855,
-0.4894333779811859,
0.07820456475019455,
-0.07359295338392258,
-0.4668751657009125,
0.5516096949577332,
0.24220287799835205,
0.6027228236198425,
0.5770442485809326,
-0.4753633737564087,
0.24127556383609772,
0.12408623844385147,
-0.15693561732769012,
-0.2194053679704666,
-0.20333361625671387,
0.04546363279223442,
-0.2650738060474396,
0.05952782183885574,
0.49551814794540405,
-0.17321543395519257,
-0.4697254002094269,
0.23413899540901184,
0.15313118696212769,
-0.06697297096252441,
-0.13300709426403046,
0.401329904794693,
0.33716779947280884,
-0.042333029210567474,
0.4738348722457886,
-0.32273465394973755,
-0.5643077492713928,
0.6962980031967163,
0.9147017002105713,
0.7634966373443604,
-0.3386697769165039,
0.5980380773544312,
0.5242713689804077,
0.6102911233901978,
-0.2767714262008667,
0.21131539344787598,
0.43888217210769653,
-0.9883224964141846,
-0.4887138903141022,
-0.06646430492401123,
-0.3508215546607971,
-0.28711187839508057,
-0.7866476774215698,
0.6555052399635315,
-0.3587762117385864,
0.09506911039352417,
-0.26829051971435547,
-0.4769112765789032,
-0.5139374136924744,
0.16401110589504242,
0.3504718244075775,
0.8485704064369202,
-1.0977575778961182,
0.740852952003479,
0.777409017086029,
-0.18442237377166748,
-1.0099303722381592,
0.06056613102555275,
0.07674802094697952,
-0.7167779207229614,
0.18817055225372314,
-0.42439526319503784,
-0.402052640914917,
-0.29343676567077637,
-0.5246014595031738,
-0.6703388690948486,
0.5862462520599365,
0.2458040565252304,
-0.7691121101379395,
-0.25683489441871643,
0.4332013428211212,
0.6604806780815125,
-0.17176604270935059,
-0.004956417717039585,
0.7062253952026367,
0.28717899322509766,
-0.355207234621048,
-0.9793837070465088,
-0.15748819708824158,
-0.5633621215820312,
0.1785450279712677,
0.24597494304180145,
-0.5947282314300537,
0.9979029297828674,
-0.2385813593864441,
-0.42167991399765015,
0.00396012794226408,
0.508951723575592,
0.014006383717060089,
0.03987274318933487,
0.6295391917228699,
0.2829962372779846,
0.8618662357330322,
-0.14441466331481934,
1.0406993627548218,
-0.07941199839115143,
0.7177735567092896,
1.1137064695358276,
-0.277556449174881,
0.6955755949020386,
0.45169636607170105,
-0.5224480628967285,
0.8518036603927612,
0.45793789625167847,
-0.10988590866327286,
0.29153260588645935,
0.18915382027626038,
-0.22363732755184174,
-0.14135855436325073,
0.47512301802635193,
-0.3435494005680084,
0.1426900178194046,
0.07610905915498734,
-0.3993152678012848,
-0.15220068395137787,
0.01835303194820881,
0.5014867186546326,
0.4596536159515381,
-0.362592488527298,
0.4552667737007141,
-0.23134972155094147,
-0.8137599229812622,
0.5226969122886658,
0.4519946575164795,
0.9108486175537109,
-0.7167293429374695,
-0.009349854663014412,
-0.5412789583206177,
0.3136092722415924,
-0.5407964587211609,
-0.38840219378471375,
0.20194366574287415,
0.4488080143928528,
-0.4924044907093048,
-0.3273225724697113,
0.7852527499198914,
-0.8289711475372314,
-0.8727443814277649,
0.39300158619880676,
0.37669453024864197,
-0.20728573203086853,
0.23829776048660278,
-0.35804450511932373,
-0.04300975427031517,
0.3500336706638336,
0.2690091133117676,
-0.011969901621341705,
0.13770952820777893,
-0.21924032270908356,
0.1645793914794922,
0.5618681311607361,
0.12574511766433716,
0.5197363495826721,
0.3444554805755615,
0.5279753804206848,
-0.6580666899681091,
-1.0235315561294556,
-0.6252407431602478,
0.6074628233909607,
-0.05212823301553726,
-0.4435325264930725,
0.8200357556343079,
0.6401399970054626,
1.3685888051986694,
-0.5096675157546997,
1.2451050281524658,
-0.25614386796951294,
0.3103411793708801,
-0.7564374804496765,
0.386475145816803,
-0.20559796690940857,
0.1101323738694191,
-0.6933643817901611,
-0.5149369239807129,
-0.33413320779800415,
0.619831919670105,
-0.2196761816740036,
-0.1469745934009552,
1.1710247993469238,
1.016476035118103,
0.025776926428079605,
0.367538720369339,
0.32653769850730896,
0.1577007919549942,
0.12175242602825165,
0.7148618698120117,
0.7178345322608948,
-0.5851653814315796,
0.7676491737365723,
-0.11915192008018494,
-0.2463729828596115,
-0.15085139870643616,
-0.6873436570167542,
-0.6390526294708252,
-0.37023577094078064,
-0.5161221623420715,
-0.7512854933738708,
0.31030356884002686,
0.8649080991744995,
0.5115571022033691,
-1.0963757038116455,
-0.4673526883125305,
-0.34849584102630615,
0.1015019416809082,
-0.7039980888366699,
-0.2699620723724365,
0.05741865187883377,
-0.5795012712478638,
-0.8531926274299622,
0.45778483152389526,
0.011297034099698067,
-0.058891333639621735,
0.00761841144412756,
-0.19351284205913544,
-0.37163323163986206,
0.1563284695148468,
0.5877891778945923,
0.4728042781352997,
-0.4461544156074524,
-0.45530959963798523,
0.42499542236328125,
-0.5368543863296509,
0.058743566274642944,
1.3569416999816895,
-0.3805263936519623,
0.4608283042907715,
0.45142680406570435,
0.6670523881912231,
0.43166083097457886,
-0.16910673677921295,
0.6539040207862854,
-1.1565568447113037,
0.13284623622894287,
-0.01932380348443985,
0.46982160210609436,
0.099765345454216,
-0.5011118650436401,
0.591705858707428,
0.5113200545310974,
-0.22285017371177673,
-0.48005133867263794,
0.16172459721565247,
-0.8963955640792847,
-0.3278518319129944,
1.406950831413269,
-0.07140690088272095,
0.06744131445884705,
-0.08561370521783829,
-0.507499635219574,
0.1649698168039322,
0.02003682777285576,
0.5949442386627197,
1.1777615547180176,
0.10034190863370895,
0.13898400962352753,
-0.292881041765213,
0.3891180157661438,
0.767642617225647,
-1.0688540935516357,
0.0703715831041336,
0.7593912482261658,
0.3753771483898163,
0.10073912888765335,
0.41172778606414795,
-0.4030243754386902,
0.6344379186630249,
0.08093427121639252,
0.2968779504299164,
0.12250763177871704,
-0.30990463495254517,
-0.33356204628944397,
0.0277935229241848,
-0.3101416528224945,
-0.3212873041629791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14432v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14432v1
|
Monitoring Critical Infrastructure Facilities During Disasters Using Large Language Models
| 2024-04-18T19:41:05 | 2024-04-18T19:41:05 |
Abdul Wahab Ziaullah, Ferda Ofli, Muhammad Imran
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Critical Infrastructure Facilities (CIFs), such as healthcare and
transportation facilities, are vital for the functioning of a community,
especially during large-scale emergencies. In this paper, we explore a
potential application of Large Language Models (LLMs) to monitor the status of
CIFs affected by natural disasters through information disseminated in social
media networks. To this end, we analyze social media data from two disaster
events in two different countries to identify reported impacts to CIFs as well
as their impact severity and operational status. We employ state-of-the-art
open-source LLMs to perform computational tasks including retrieval,
classification, and inference, all in a zero-shot setting. Through extensive
experimentation, we report the results of these tasks using standard evaluation
metrics and reveal insights into the strengths and weaknesses of LLMs. We note
that although LLMs perform well in classification tasks, they encounter
challenges with inference tasks, especially when the context/prompt is complex
and lengthy. Additionally, we outline various potential directions for future
exploration that can be beneficial during the initial adoption phase of LLMs
for disaster response tasks.
|
[
-0.28672847151756287,
-0.9679890275001526,
0.9599252343177795,
0.365402489900589,
-0.17835354804992676,
0.26049157977104187,
-0.4718591868877411,
-0.3970252573490143,
0.2676388919353485,
0.45910635590553284,
-0.22792084515094757,
-0.5789059996604919,
-0.6032119393348694,
0.20012682676315308,
-0.7721949815750122,
0.7283247709274292,
-0.17885005474090576,
-0.0051630293019115925,
0.2690655291080475,
0.09996695071458817,
-0.2206374853849411,
-0.4949238896369934,
-0.7888491749763489,
-0.056463103741407394,
0.6597626805305481,
0.6382724642753601,
0.6845122575759888,
0.06826893985271454,
0.9044795036315918,
0.28226953744888306,
-0.11780614405870438,
-0.030288496986031532,
-0.605091392993927,
-0.06600651890039444,
-0.29235532879829407,
0.027738574892282486,
-0.04719286412000656,
-0.5436422228813171,
0.9564741849899292,
0.7171257138252258,
-0.18176765739917755,
0.28527581691741943,
0.22023195028305054,
0.3139251172542572,
-0.7884894013404846,
0.3010149896144867,
-0.4460994601249695,
-0.0382242277264595,
-0.1593482494354248,
-0.3113600015640259,
-0.19818228483200073,
-0.2511669993400574,
0.31996381282806396,
0.029417382553219795,
0.0891481339931488,
-0.14930300414562225,
0.5063053369522095,
0.20963816344738007,
-0.6122738718986511,
-0.2889000177383423,
-0.9017040133476257,
0.6848121285438538,
-0.6336736679077148,
0.338114857673645,
0.3391108512878418,
0.41093671321868896,
-0.48141831159591675,
-0.6132357716560364,
-0.5255398154258728,
-0.027319014072418213,
0.13546626269817352,
-0.13635900616645813,
-0.11280976980924606,
0.10581967979669571,
0.2864503264427185,
0.24621978402137756,
-0.3803170621395111,
0.23355446755886078,
-0.3094221353530884,
-0.06720437109470367,
0.5043507814407349,
0.35853472352027893,
0.4133148193359375,
-0.6216333508491516,
-0.3051411509513855,
0.1917230784893036,
-0.7091936469078064,
-0.17105373740196228,
-0.015855416655540466,
0.4379918575286865,
-0.6505273580551147,
0.5441077947616577,
-0.17696721851825714,
0.36614805459976196,
-0.7761720418930054,
-0.12096012383699417,
0.1191098541021347,
-0.10374540090560913,
-0.6271036863327026,
-0.08386637270450592,
0.8426098227500916,
0.3540235459804535,
0.4209290146827698,
-0.3052751123905182,
-0.19274191558361053,
-0.17727290093898773,
0.18617194890975952,
-0.5599439144134521,
-0.09905398637056351,
0.17338313162326813,
-0.43679022789001465,
-0.28904467821121216,
-0.12147887796163559,
-0.5701203942298889,
-0.7699881792068481,
-0.2329854816198349,
0.16035757958889008,
-0.0707986131310463,
-0.6544135808944702,
0.17951178550720215,
0.1483362913131714,
0.029712378978729248,
0.34462970495224,
-0.38486456871032715,
0.04726722091436386,
0.5368668437004089,
1.3321830034255981,
0.22264467179775238,
0.12073409557342529,
-0.7282968163490295,
0.08704418689012527,
-0.2702925205230713,
0.888704776763916,
-0.08542756736278534,
-0.30133911967277527,
0.5258113145828247,
0.23397615551948547,
0.09232203662395477,
-0.35166406631469727,
0.901996910572052,
-0.5680479407310486,
-0.6106864809989929,
-0.2712719440460205,
-0.04521312564611435,
-0.05926460772752762,
0.3509301245212555,
-0.6662715673446655,
0.8323118090629578,
0.1686789095401764,
-1.0568451881408691,
-0.08758586645126343,
-0.562498152256012,
-0.6198413372039795,
0.05396626144647598,
-0.09443576633930206,
-0.35854899883270264,
0.36161163449287415,
-0.05526192486286163,
0.7054818868637085,
-0.5911772847175598,
0.4899599552154541,
-0.9358617067337036,
-0.34839409589767456,
0.24838244915008545,
-0.39998024702072144,
0.7374607920646667,
0.15976431965827942,
-0.28962773084640503,
-0.027119312435388565,
-0.5463603138923645,
-0.1714697927236557,
0.12162125110626221,
-0.5515565276145935,
-0.3567608892917633,
0.5970715880393982,
0.5699217319488525,
0.07797762006521225,
-0.015512503683567047,
-0.3719935119152069,
0.001968960976228118,
-0.18433937430381775,
0.5279326438903809,
0.6654875874519348,
0.2239549160003662,
0.25410351157188416,
-0.08203721046447754,
0.2505256235599518,
0.0013754094252362847,
0.2788882255554199,
0.05431261286139488,
-0.2171746790409088,
-0.6874799132347107,
-0.17265793681144714,
-0.036123909056186676,
0.5971220135688782,
-0.9176920056343079,
0.038758356124162674,
-0.4600917100906372,
-0.2578738331794739,
-0.06880166381597519,
-0.08143673092126846,
-0.2535282373428345,
0.5298115611076355,
0.18144547939300537,
0.19776803255081177,
-0.7408823370933533,
-0.8879586458206177,
0.10439065098762512,
-0.48004230856895447,
-0.2932997941970825,
0.25750309228897095,
0.35449492931365967,
-0.38345661759376526,
0.5828181505203247,
-0.38767537474632263,
-0.11504539102315903,
-0.34656378626823425,
-0.009154516272246838,
0.32381361722946167,
-0.10107067972421646,
0.6021299362182617,
-0.7193177342414856,
-0.25386834144592285,
-0.030527329072356224,
-0.9552420377731323,
-0.19972918927669525,
-0.14068986475467682,
0.2545797526836395,
0.08852875232696533,
0.397943377494812,
-0.31740784645080566,
0.22913837432861328,
0.7015573978424072,
-0.11993084847927094,
0.4884723126888275,
0.043671365827322006,
0.238090381026268,
-1.1314365863800049,
0.14524579048156738,
0.17288650572299957,
-0.299547404050827,
-0.7529891729354858,
-0.00764811085537076,
0.0949024111032486,
-0.16963380575180054,
-0.7170741558074951,
0.42212167382240295,
-0.5900006294250488,
-0.2610971927642822,
-0.27054357528686523,
-0.041499629616737366,
-0.45921385288238525,
-0.08419612050056458,
0.13960233330726624,
0.2779092788696289,
0.7332930564880371,
-0.43042314052581787,
0.14454582333564758,
0.022634878754615784,
-0.7072662711143494,
0.1975279301404953,
-0.5358939170837402,
-0.015372070483863354,
-0.16319714486598969,
0.2771158218383789,
-1.0270529985427856,
-0.5419013500213623,
0.207212895154953,
-0.11907859891653061,
-0.047280218452215195,
-0.25948479771614075,
-0.9038758873939514,
-0.6692506074905396,
-0.2595103085041046,
-0.16641923785209656,
0.12234502285718918,
-0.37404993176460266,
0.7068684101104736,
0.6480189561843872,
-0.10630250722169876,
-0.1953384429216385,
-0.8459059596061707,
0.5267542004585266,
-0.3617885410785675,
-0.5901671051979065,
-0.4320259392261505,
0.03384729102253914,
-0.5176140069961548,
-0.22502650320529938,
0.041986528784036636,
-0.3073597252368927,
0.694040834903717,
0.6090269684791565,
0.36079153418540955,
-0.16941173374652863,
0.1476782262325287,
-0.1276586353778839,
0.26786619424819946,
0.3927718698978424,
-0.021470993757247925,
0.547648549079895,
-0.1838705837726593,
-0.3470698297023773,
-0.34967637062072754,
0.6107804775238037,
0.7711533308029175,
-0.11139658838510513,
1.057254433631897,
0.29589030146598816,
-0.8333724737167358,
0.09080839157104492,
-0.7575231194496155,
-0.1787942796945572,
-0.4524506628513336,
0.3066854476928711,
0.03581846132874489,
-1.0035560131072998,
0.6866326928138733,
-0.34692084789276123,
0.1609671711921692,
0.1821972280740738,
0.5463139414787292,
-0.264705628156662,
0.759760320186615,
0.6625097393989563,
-0.4632934331893921,
0.5055535435676575,
-0.2529408633708954,
0.43776118755340576,
-0.6927575469017029,
-0.03315204754471779,
-0.7090799808502197,
-0.08990779519081116,
-0.44852977991104126,
-0.41387051343917847,
0.6608347296714783,
0.042246319353580475,
-0.31778860092163086,
-0.0025664314161986113,
0.05775323137640953,
0.23453064262866974,
-0.15631413459777832,
0.27223044633865356,
0.4291606545448303,
0.3466840386390686,
0.26527372002601624,
0.27594834566116333,
-0.6417805552482605,
-0.6908982396125793,
0.7880522012710571,
0.6362755298614502,
0.7378793954849243,
0.13313935697078705,
0.6357595324516296,
0.28427502512931824,
0.9335951209068298,
-0.6724005341529846,
0.2932129502296448,
-0.1562335044145584,
-0.6711114048957825,
-0.3993777930736542,
-0.5517435669898987,
-0.4928690493106842,
-0.24025772511959076,
-0.2903401255607605,
-0.7542656064033508,
0.1465570479631424,
0.09491889923810959,
-0.45217472314834595,
0.5296965837478638,
-0.6531267762184143,
0.38868463039398193,
-0.2510688602924347,
0.03881523758172989,
-0.3795742690563202,
-0.33446770906448364,
0.3142651915550232,
-0.2767244577407837,
0.7009328007698059,
-0.09571792930364609,
0.18281561136245728,
0.16285261511802673,
-0.09085997194051743,
1.0883382558822632,
0.029262211173772812,
-0.16253040730953217,
0.6788680553436279,
0.010903112590312958,
0.623568058013916,
0.3595297932624817,
-0.3746635913848877,
0.4756273031234741,
-0.25725728273391724,
-0.3028852939605713,
-0.17218220233917236,
1.132775068283081,
-0.7849346399307251,
-0.32001790404319763,
-0.25705650448799133,
-0.4113832712173462,
-0.18953484296798706,
0.27451515197753906,
-0.03121769428253174,
0.5613675117492676,
-0.2574734389781952,
0.26779258251190186,
0.6232491731643677,
-0.31785863637924194,
0.7885118126869202,
0.8936736583709717,
0.10224601626396179,
-0.24451062083244324,
0.5634875297546387,
0.48808231949806213,
0.26004236936569214,
0.2915972173213959,
0.08551580458879471,
-0.1209343671798706,
-0.6988852620124817,
-0.2922970652580261,
0.36493754386901855,
-0.5813822150230408,
-0.49563536047935486,
-1.0282971858978271,
-0.4168107807636261,
-0.1810259073972702,
-0.266559898853302,
-0.07218793034553528,
0.06078232824802399,
-0.3793078064918518,
-0.2455698698759079,
0.18635690212249756,
0.759353756904602,
-0.18077673017978668,
0.24016524851322174,
-0.8932018280029297,
0.16007162630558014,
-0.22513039410114288,
0.7153661847114563,
0.228155255317688,
-0.11417186260223389,
-0.4100666642189026,
-0.009068761020898819,
-0.06341922283172607,
-1.0132269859313965,
0.17965570092201233,
0.13907621800899506,
0.19416965544223785,
0.5199518799781799,
0.21133607625961304,
0.4119022488594055,
-0.6674911975860596,
0.5128538608551025,
0.2579624354839325,
-0.5811076760292053,
0.4536232352256775,
-0.7132856845855713,
0.25983965396881104,
0.4657052755355835,
0.5321483612060547,
-0.7348611950874329,
-0.563518762588501,
-0.22595909237861633,
-0.6973191499710083,
0.3259638547897339,
0.05624817684292793,
0.32230231165885925,
-0.620097815990448,
0.1594570130109787,
-0.7290850281715393,
-0.02376331016421318,
-0.40969035029411316,
-0.08009353280067444,
0.2547515034675598,
0.07537911832332611,
-0.06813328713178635,
-0.48707011342048645,
-0.15476234257221222,
0.16622093319892883,
0.3138834536075592,
-0.16210488975048065,
-0.0915876179933548,
0.362041711807251,
0.02300143614411354,
-0.3931841552257538,
0.3186258375644684,
0.4410858750343323,
0.5544101595878601,
-0.0741758719086647,
0.2950887382030487,
0.6414135098457336,
-0.45460498332977295,
-0.08631010353565216,
-0.08138775080442429,
-0.11909287422895432,
0.17895683646202087,
0.5955764055252075,
0.2942766845226288,
0.5191990733146667,
-0.928047239780426,
0.35569825768470764,
-0.13892042636871338,
0.06300029903650284,
-0.6343375444412231,
-0.2203088253736496,
0.44479408860206604,
0.5908008217811584,
0.6007398962974548,
-0.364439457654953,
0.5314781665802002,
-0.6373862028121948,
-0.10384644567966461,
0.4249936640262604,
-0.39652881026268005,
-0.28560036420822144,
0.28437232971191406,
0.10478485375642776,
-0.38748496770858765,
0.7088867425918579,
0.16067446768283844,
-0.42285263538360596,
0.6084835529327393,
0.2963397204875946,
0.945477306842804,
-0.49521124362945557,
0.1753017157316208,
0.38107314705848694,
0.6967124342918396,
-0.2538685202598572,
0.6420554518699646,
0.29275625944137573,
-0.5818914175033569,
-0.6110441088676453,
-0.9081922769546509,
-0.16981609165668488,
0.6291345357894897,
-0.41911306977272034,
0.5755892395973206,
-0.7470560073852539,
-0.45792776346206665,
-0.2027088850736618,
-0.28899359703063965,
-0.8065773844718933,
0.14341548085212708,
0.5271148085594177,
1.159199833869934,
-1.1397761106491089,
0.3778248131275177,
0.8832451105117798,
-0.137782022356987,
-1.03870689868927,
0.008792351931333542,
0.004643280990421772,
-0.3853774964809418,
0.30037936568260193,
0.11181945353746414,
0.11434077471494675,
-0.1465844362974167,
-0.5332878232002258,
-1.009847640991211,
0.799910306930542,
0.4715503752231598,
-0.976646900177002,
-0.13696490228176117,
0.4799096882343292,
0.7800140380859375,
0.005829156842082739,
0.33374354243278503,
0.4239802956581116,
0.483751505613327,
-0.2524503767490387,
-1.0476231575012207,
0.07562283426523209,
0.0659681186079979,
-0.04594888165593147,
0.42656487226486206,
-0.812075138092041,
0.2865874171257019,
-0.2262403517961502,
-0.43179619312286377,
-0.2522686719894409,
0.6968579292297363,
0.017611678689718246,
0.506779134273529,
0.7438260316848755,
0.29936400055885315,
0.3849796950817108,
-0.025785669684410095,
1.158450961112976,
-0.21970206499099731,
0.5124898552894592,
1.0292279720306396,
-0.18354974687099457,
0.9409552216529846,
0.3894020915031433,
0.11172233521938324,
0.34948503971099854,
0.6243656277656555,
0.27663716673851013,
0.37819811701774597,
0.30700939893722534,
-0.5631831884384155,
-0.2707577049732208,
-0.49161410331726074,
-0.16102559864521027,
0.21215875446796417,
0.5848553776741028,
-0.5909343361854553,
-0.6359341740608215,
0.17101390659809113,
0.043255291879177094,
-0.2807602286338806,
-0.3541649580001831,
0.4205061197280884,
0.5124782919883728,
-0.18189340829849243,
0.5126256942749023,
-0.10562332719564438,
0.08421608060598373,
-0.23717568814754486,
-0.04985229671001434,
-0.05517898499965668,
0.11204136162996292,
-0.45162665843963623,
-0.9332899451255798,
0.7764306664466858,
0.18939439952373505,
-0.24120843410491943,
0.13276837766170502,
0.5577698349952698,
-0.01678367331624031,
-0.602553129196167,
0.7050867080688477,
0.12290194630622864,
0.06914899498224258,
-0.37630271911621094,
-0.2564932405948639,
0.6690783500671387,
-0.36189010739326477,
-0.23705816268920898,
0.23003828525543213,
0.5486151576042175,
-0.39719533920288086,
0.7725121974945068,
0.5120552778244019,
0.19761985540390015,
-0.21850153803825378,
0.5350361466407776,
1.1984788179397583,
-0.31369414925575256,
-0.15316791832447052,
-0.974132239818573,
0.4399486184120178,
-0.08644955605268478,
-0.005689714103937149,
0.46130257844924927,
0.39628350734710693,
0.33831074833869934,
-0.008720438927412033,
1.0435444116592407,
-0.04276210814714432,
0.472206711769104,
-0.07203393429517746,
0.6060413122177124,
-0.4666787385940552,
0.44054320454597473,
-0.43100517988204956,
-0.875341534614563,
-0.4325668215751648,
0.2649552822113037,
-0.5431435108184814,
-0.7371314764022827,
0.3753783404827118,
0.6235958933830261,
-0.28030070662498474,
-0.0980900228023529,
0.15930554270744324,
0.4503096342086792,
0.6123205423355103,
0.407333105802536,
0.9654315114021301,
-0.11310796439647675,
0.4966897666454315,
0.04818887263536453,
-0.5352625250816345,
-0.39057785272598267,
-0.9603506922721863,
-1.1248279809951782,
-0.38789474964141846,
-0.17263197898864746,
-0.3870619535446167,
0.11705164611339569,
0.7243542671203613,
0.33658215403556824,
-0.8891387581825256,
-0.12296204268932343,
0.12383976578712463,
0.20530572533607483,
0.38323161005973816,
-0.24453242123126984,
0.3070809841156006,
0.03903348371386528,
-0.25354957580566406,
0.3615264892578125,
0.6210209131240845,
-0.11966486275196075,
-0.6186988949775696,
0.4026819169521332,
-0.28122609853744507,
0.18160073459148407,
0.7930425405502319,
0.2141590416431427,
-0.48650622367858887,
-0.7182824611663818,
0.20912131667137146,
-0.2807134687900543,
-0.4440508484840393,
0.6782670021057129,
-0.3450332283973694,
0.046631477773189545,
0.6152015924453735,
0.8340774774551392,
0.17534703016281128,
-0.37452027201652527,
0.33103418350219727,
-0.363923579454422,
-0.1196981891989708,
0.11497975140810013,
0.5647273659706116,
0.7413426637649536,
-0.5337079763412476,
0.6312358379364014,
-0.0033133928664028645,
-0.6332352757453918,
-1.048945426940918,
0.00903315283358097,
-0.603327751159668,
0.06670462340116501,
1.3597627878189087,
-0.1044100821018219,
-0.17923589050769806,
-0.28049132227897644,
0.0935119092464447,
0.34724754095077515,
-0.10726474225521088,
1.258280873298645,
0.7610304355621338,
0.40848293900489807,
-0.2243991494178772,
-0.9258813261985779,
0.06709840148687363,
-0.09401226788759232,
-0.7451521158218384,
-0.17966145277023315,
0.4780178964138031,
0.6805009841918945,
0.19266852736473083,
0.8539510369300842,
0.04583530128002167,
0.18999768793582916,
-0.7117353081703186,
-0.1771722435951233,
0.531701385974884,
-0.4673251509666443,
-0.20401506125926971,
0.2151046097278595,
-0.08251422643661499,
0.2933366894721985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12464v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12464v4
|
NormAd: A Benchmark for Measuring the Cultural Adaptability of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-18T18:48:50 | 2024-06-06T16:02:39 |
Abhinav Rao, Akhila Yerukola, Vishwa Shah, Katharina Reinecke, Maarten Sap
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) into various global cultures
fundamentally presents a cultural challenge: LLMs must navigate interactions,
respect social norms, and avoid transgressing cultural boundaries. However, it
is still unclear if LLMs can adapt their outputs to diverse cultural norms. Our
study focuses on this aspect. We introduce NormAd, a novel dataset, which
includes 2.6k stories that represent social and cultural norms from 75
countries, to assess the ability of LLMs to adapt to different granular levels
of socio-cultural contexts such as the country of origin, its associated
cultural values, and prevalent social norms. Our study reveals that LLMs
struggle with cultural reasoning across all contextual granularities, showing
stronger adaptability to English-centric cultures over those from the Global
South. Even with explicit social norms, the top-performing model,
Mistral-7b-Instruct, achieves only 81.8\% accuracy, lagging behind the 95.6\%
achieved by humans. Evaluation on NormAd further reveals that LLMs struggle to
adapt to stories involving gift-giving across cultures. Due to inherent
agreement or sycophancy biases, LLMs find it considerably easier to assess the
social acceptability of stories that adhere to cultural norms than those that
deviate from them. Our benchmark measures the cultural adaptability (or lack
thereof) of LLMs, emphasizing the potential to make these technologies more
equitable and useful for global audiences. We release the NormAd dataset and
its associated code on GitHub.
|
[
-0.3460141122341156,
-0.33925679326057434,
0.22942858934402466,
0.4490104913711548,
-0.34339892864227295,
-0.04408624395728111,
-0.6416720151901245,
-0.647992730140686,
-0.012624763883650303,
0.22273020446300507,
-0.22826185822486877,
-0.6903157830238342,
-0.67563396692276,
0.19787466526031494,
-0.07056117802858353,
0.9193076491355896,
-0.16717225313186646,
0.013122913427650928,
-0.21876589953899384,
-0.5334529280662537,
-0.1893233060836792,
-0.6016554832458496,
-0.18705980479717255,
0.07859961688518524,
0.09050313383340836,
0.46746551990509033,
0.6040073037147522,
0.45942944288253784,
0.4437863528728485,
0.12190359085798264,
-0.21523605287075043,
0.14479535818099976,
-0.6322654485702515,
0.21573980152606964,
-0.3146733343601227,
-0.09063563495874405,
-0.5807196497917175,
0.08096912503242493,
0.7685396671295166,
0.5321174263954163,
0.016510125249624252,
0.775080144405365,
0.43587711453437805,
0.5589416027069092,
-0.6334381699562073,
0.2573661506175995,
-0.5168969035148621,
-0.0067762341350317,
-0.19750191271305084,
0.25112324953079224,
-0.2705031931400299,
-0.6243112683296204,
-0.061284326016902924,
-0.4214349687099457,
-0.16359113156795502,
-0.2569694519042969,
0.5687873363494873,
0.16970579326152802,
-0.6846665740013123,
-0.3116455674171448,
-0.856819212436676,
0.6013058423995972,
-0.6033118367195129,
0.4863641858100891,
0.22383739054203033,
0.1621602326631546,
-0.12347561120986938,
-0.472751647233963,
-0.28645509481430054,
-0.19052457809448242,
0.292594850063324,
-0.05750357732176781,
-0.147376149892807,
-0.4448385238647461,
0.23907214403152466,
0.3379823565483093,
-0.503738284111023,
0.14629246294498444,
-0.32550913095474243,
-0.00127135100774467,
0.7502753138542175,
0.19915251433849335,
0.17611677944660187,
-0.21977028250694275,
-0.3420069217681885,
0.15960358083248138,
-0.5193287134170532,
0.42760929465293884,
0.05485717952251434,
0.2120158076286316,
-0.5613070130348206,
0.24281397461891174,
-0.20686110854148865,
0.6180281043052673,
0.033534593880176544,
-0.11199578642845154,
0.2096925973892212,
-0.3486837148666382,
0.01428048126399517,
-0.027926595881581306,
0.6204409003257751,
0.7715485095977783,
0.6911782622337341,
0.1354265660047531,
-0.06330264359712601,
-0.13497798144817352,
0.017345432192087173,
-0.8090073466300964,
0.2527642250061035,
-0.05289362370967865,
-0.5918704867362976,
-0.19319216907024384,
-0.07230588048696518,
-0.5020731091499329,
-0.5904521346092224,
0.028359530493617058,
0.05061709135770798,
-0.33569836616516113,
-0.28407517075538635,
0.1722356379032135,
0.09669645875692368,
0.4944377839565277,
0.26670628786087036,
-0.843864917755127,
0.19653932750225067,
0.7845481038093567,
1.1545225381851196,
-0.22218365967273712,
-0.1921205371618271,
-0.22875435650348663,
0.08275696635246277,
-0.5344552397727966,
0.5440230965614319,
-0.516677975654602,
-0.493789404630661,
-0.021231992170214653,
0.15530548989772797,
0.10631176084280014,
-0.5031177401542664,
0.9549098610877991,
-0.5383933782577515,
-0.31369274854660034,
-0.45045891404151917,
-0.455947607755661,
-0.16354334354400635,
0.43619653582572937,
-0.6150606274604797,
0.7752646207809448,
0.27620968222618103,
-0.5279722213745117,
0.6306029558181763,
-0.30646923184394836,
-0.3745534121990204,
0.15911051630973816,
0.026091784238815308,
0.007310045417398214,
0.2619245946407318,
0.15347068011760712,
0.6193767786026001,
-0.5693538188934326,
0.5210654735565186,
-0.7057874798774719,
-0.4607400596141815,
0.2176724672317505,
-0.5375068187713623,
0.972503125667572,
0.42918023467063904,
-0.11718381196260452,
-0.07378530502319336,
-0.9767072796821594,
-0.09257768839597702,
0.10887543857097626,
-0.40889599919319153,
-0.5244446992874146,
-0.2018158882856369,
0.43132051825523376,
0.41876348853111267,
0.20192751288414001,
-0.39353275299072266,
0.2200024574995041,
-0.025329887866973877,
0.5540677309036255,
0.9755359888076782,
-0.23970730602741241,
0.4195248782634735,
-0.5428776741027832,
0.6551684141159058,
-0.14516153931617737,
0.09673476219177246,
0.1139727309346199,
-0.10659770667552948,
-0.31811317801475525,
-0.37931907176971436,
0.21627193689346313,
0.3750676214694977,
-0.2612874507904053,
0.38188308477401733,
-0.4162115752696991,
-0.7507960200309753,
-0.4594523012638092,
0.31921011209487915,
0.1560104936361313,
0.11628356575965881,
-0.27690160274505615,
-0.47187158465385437,
-0.5015690326690674,
-0.7741694450378418,
-0.40075886249542236,
-0.31166166067123413,
-0.16234296560287476,
0.21509107947349548,
0.4536076784133911,
-0.06918413192033768,
0.7208896279335022,
0.0034343930892646313,
-0.2493089735507965,
-0.034145887941122055,
-0.3011372983455658,
0.4646073877811432,
0.24310335516929626,
0.4499828815460205,
-0.6073461771011353,
-0.6382308602333069,
0.09339866787195206,
-0.9875847697257996,
-0.27586477994918823,
-0.039034679532051086,
0.2623509466648102,
0.3620099127292633,
0.5626954436302185,
0.004913725424557924,
0.07513399422168732,
1.0085891485214233,
-0.5633764863014221,
0.723138689994812,
-0.23266014456748962,
0.310139924287796,
-1.1364991664886475,
0.03220263123512268,
0.14787675440311432,
-0.22938555479049683,
-0.33785951137542725,
-0.07831475138664246,
0.2574005126953125,
0.061814066022634506,
-0.41382431983947754,
0.7826691269874573,
-0.3682577610015869,
-0.28686001896858215,
0.17047809064388275,
0.009686226956546307,
-0.09885010123252869,
0.006043657660484314,
-0.008456101641058922,
0.8874134421348572,
0.4316176176071167,
-0.6493170261383057,
0.33764657378196716,
0.14601711928844452,
-0.8804229497909546,
1.070878505706787,
-0.6305002570152283,
-0.015508350916206837,
0.02233690209686756,
0.567766547203064,
-0.7058221697807312,
-0.129924014210701,
-0.031778160482645035,
-0.15083397924900055,
-0.3433212637901306,
-0.16728311777114868,
-0.32606640458106995,
-0.011426172219216824,
-0.23019438982009888,
0.6389246582984924,
0.6439770460128784,
-0.5878766775131226,
0.5876093506813049,
0.2844443917274475,
-0.34534013271331787,
-0.2891102433204651,
-0.25448933243751526,
0.3646244406700134,
-0.41113394498825073,
-1.1197642087936401,
0.2646055817604065,
-0.37985074520111084,
-0.7080784440040588,
-0.18896859884262085,
-0.150549054145813,
0.17975063621997833,
0.28082892298698425,
0.10909385979175568,
-0.05742747709155083,
-0.4709911048412323,
-0.10450763255357742,
-0.25221383571624756,
-0.0720059797167778,
0.1735585778951645,
-0.27765101194381714,
0.42136287689208984,
-0.5349918603897095,
-0.3269708752632141,
-0.2529495656490326,
0.1086115762591362,
1.0031602382659912,
0.019129034131765366,
0.7034427523612976,
0.7560812830924988,
-0.3052642345428467,
-0.1986331194639206,
-0.5772916674613953,
0.22404204308986664,
-0.4416764974594116,
0.3270879089832306,
-0.6091273427009583,
-0.7687572240829468,
0.7413355708122253,
-0.05764462426304817,
0.15088243782520294,
0.24395392835140228,
0.5908471345901489,
0.022150907665491104,
0.6336915493011475,
0.6865718364715576,
-0.017672628164291382,
0.25359952449798584,
0.09592083841562271,
-0.08413010090589523,
-0.9929748177528381,
0.030879180878400803,
-0.45125752687454224,
-0.3544023633003235,
-0.8241062164306641,
-0.5428918600082397,
0.571312665939331,
0.0943048968911171,
-0.32070454955101013,
-0.11825188994407654,
-0.1267596334218979,
0.5053544640541077,
0.31622540950775146,
-0.22900700569152832,
0.7117821574211121,
-0.3009643852710724,
0.08102668821811676,
-0.13059495389461517,
-0.5850206613540649,
-0.9581109285354614,
1.162529468536377,
0.30388689041137695,
0.9415160417556763,
0.3212479054927826,
0.43782901763916016,
0.5234699845314026,
0.37763604521751404,
-0.6108490824699402,
0.43017348647117615,
-0.49274030327796936,
-0.3075813055038452,
-0.1307530403137207,
0.01041323784738779,
-0.43917447328567505,
0.21056881546974182,
-0.02280256524682045,
-0.7873733043670654,
0.4088943600654602,
-0.08855060487985611,
-0.14679613709449768,
0.24667422473430634,
-0.5512261390686035,
0.703529417514801,
-0.2613760828971863,
-0.37486332654953003,
-0.021278584375977516,
-0.38644808530807495,
0.512151837348938,
-0.4630703032016754,
0.7990702390670776,
-0.37346771359443665,
0.11398467421531677,
0.8089780807495117,
0.09577976167201996,
0.8836583495140076,
0.125565767288208,
-0.3795083463191986,
-0.1331472545862198,
0.3978407084941864,
0.4262179732322693,
0.3202521502971649,
-0.4196336567401886,
0.5143818259239197,
0.42328330874443054,
-0.488332062959671,
-0.2912037670612335,
0.7720102071762085,
-0.8006211519241333,
-0.7339527010917664,
-0.6009174585342407,
-0.9378533959388733,
-0.3357410728931427,
-0.14678917825222015,
-0.021757949143648148,
0.20353975892066956,
-0.8487762212753296,
0.41022104024887085,
0.4367472231388092,
-0.2410666048526764,
0.36862078309059143,
0.5696879625320435,
-0.2064209282398224,
-0.15916936099529266,
0.4095093309879303,
0.23521588742733002,
0.589156985282898,
-0.19632792472839355,
0.2328987419605255,
-0.09115427732467651,
-0.38149896264076233,
-0.589657723903656,
0.032376062124967575,
-0.8503232002258301,
0.30569276213645935,
-0.37730738520622253,
-0.22462598979473114,
-0.4689669609069824,
-0.6751688718795776,
-0.18540561199188232,
-0.17427033185958862,
-0.05551797151565552,
-0.06912567466497421,
0.38461822271347046,
0.6526188850402832,
-0.3690735995769501,
-0.16813533008098602,
-0.778812825679779,
0.12919816374778748,
0.12888318300247192,
0.38905197381973267,
-0.08562842756509781,
-0.9335543513298035,
-0.06026624143123627,
-0.04520600289106369,
0.09519090503454208,
-0.3791746199131012,
0.18187640607357025,
0.29526636004447937,
0.36632537841796875,
0.504276692867279,
0.38374924659729004,
0.6231389045715332,
-0.5197291374206543,
0.8464033007621765,
-0.11892512440681458,
-0.9944605827331543,
0.09981779754161835,
-0.38544604182243347,
0.4935789406299591,
0.2906755208969116,
0.42563554644584656,
-1.1700992584228516,
-0.35848620533943176,
-0.4956815838813782,
-0.6443086266517639,
0.5929445624351501,
-0.29835712909698486,
0.46011051535606384,
0.15148106217384338,
0.25734612345695496,
0.4152098000049591,
-0.17411698400974274,
-0.7177487015724182,
-0.008352503180503845,
0.02400031127035618,
-0.12586472928524017,
-0.5025151968002319,
-0.4371919333934784,
-0.07826145738363266,
-0.21343500912189484,
0.5286287665367126,
-0.0680016577243805,
-0.27167290449142456,
0.04291710630059242,
-0.3499701917171478,
0.05109259486198425,
0.47653529047966003,
0.5083974003791809,
0.9378496408462524,
-0.3104983866214752,
0.17079490423202515,
0.3989776372909546,
-0.5636537075042725,
0.26515719294548035,
-0.10847003757953644,
-0.20999537408351898,
-0.18595640361309052,
0.4569907486438751,
0.5030927062034607,
0.026728874072432518,
-0.688940703868866,
0.19180305302143097,
-0.24507230520248413,
-0.02506425976753235,
-0.4185410737991333,
0.04157805070281029,
0.26715707778930664,
0.4427375793457031,
0.2308407872915268,
-0.23365597426891327,
-0.24596963822841644,
-0.5461974143981934,
0.24562902748584747,
0.5420765280723572,
-0.595782458782196,
-0.3170965909957886,
0.5628962516784668,
0.2782996594905853,
-0.5227927565574646,
0.3039049506187439,
-0.20713618397712708,
-0.11779636144638062,
0.6198585033416748,
0.8451856970787048,
0.7086560726165771,
-0.2385053187608719,
0.45265743136405945,
0.22894799709320068,
0.5251193642616272,
0.046252328902482986,
0.10998354107141495,
0.10462171584367752,
-1.1109023094177246,
-0.12948839366436005,
-0.8440070748329163,
-0.28862836956977844,
-0.053403180092573166,
-0.8443616628646851,
0.4135916233062744,
-0.5125616788864136,
0.012637370266020298,
-0.04811091721057892,
-0.20704178512096405,
-0.7088406085968018,
-0.18436919152736664,
0.11834737658500671,
1.1818186044692993,
-1.1678184270858765,
0.6702681183815002,
0.605592668056488,
-0.027462171390652657,
-0.37684494256973267,
0.2241305559873581,
0.30250200629234314,
-0.8722153902053833,
0.5834103226661682,
-0.0935448631644249,
-0.06745249032974243,
0.043798260390758514,
-0.18727774918079376,
-0.7569379210472107,
0.9758263826370239,
0.38676315546035767,
-0.6082601547241211,
0.37560370564460754,
-0.04021792858839035,
0.5775867104530334,
-0.5666975378990173,
0.12250258773565292,
0.726305365562439,
0.5591431260108948,
0.21322320401668549,
-1.1657346487045288,
0.20810042321681976,
-0.23458461463451385,
0.26086732745170593,
-0.21812915802001953,
-0.8012449741363525,
0.4893890917301178,
-0.36034977436065674,
-0.050494518131017685,
-0.02733427658677101,
0.48301687836647034,
0.3762200176715851,
0.35059720277786255,
0.5358087420463562,
0.1371559202671051,
0.7776564359664917,
-0.022167542949318886,
0.8057793378829956,
-0.29500114917755127,
0.17347590625286102,
0.7743569612503052,
-0.6947739720344543,
0.699338972568512,
0.2917231619358063,
-0.12455032765865326,
0.5034315586090088,
0.6816219687461853,
0.018017549067735672,
0.27402961254119873,
0.2170163244009018,
-0.3349928855895996,
-0.27198708057403564,
-0.5043590068817139,
-0.5053349137306213,
0.6553351879119873,
0.3608328104019165,
-0.20987096428871155,
-0.2165500372648239,
0.16983862221240997,
0.21658900380134583,
0.27041956782341003,
-0.355735719203949,
0.6927677392959595,
0.17429818212985992,
-0.4817236363887787,
0.9672960638999939,
0.03140905871987343,
0.8589999079704285,
-0.4450145661830902,
0.24508419632911682,
-0.3588200509548187,
0.16248002648353577,
-0.17409077286720276,
-0.6627814173698425,
0.34849223494529724,
0.1683022677898407,
-0.32581937313079834,
-0.2891351580619812,
0.3732117712497711,
-0.23190900683403015,
-0.7476004958152771,
0.20995424687862396,
0.5810635089874268,
0.10329289734363556,
0.2996912896633148,
-0.42386487126350403,
0.5035577416419983,
-0.038100335747003555,
-0.09225690364837646,
0.5220745801925659,
0.6109122633934021,
-0.5113446712493896,
0.6930081844329834,
0.4752953350543976,
0.21049293875694275,
-0.34639665484428406,
-0.01818719133734703,
0.39665156602859497,
-0.7315530180931091,
-0.5781334042549133,
-0.8885484337806702,
0.39175423979759216,
0.0795120969414711,
-0.5013958215713501,
0.8437520861625671,
0.4127982556819916,
0.9999200701713562,
0.014412392862141132,
0.8772785663604736,
-0.1421816051006317,
-0.04377613589167595,
-0.49589574337005615,
0.7682900428771973,
-0.39882731437683105,
0.4838580787181854,
-0.3033773601055145,
-0.9453491568565369,
-0.16849108040332794,
0.5528141260147095,
-0.3390650153160095,
0.08850423246622086,
0.7173938155174255,
0.5501378178596497,
-0.11288642138242722,
0.19523261487483978,
0.3020692765712738,
0.5164573788642883,
0.3521270453929901,
0.41687166690826416,
0.8670563697814941,
-0.10065130144357681,
0.3880666494369507,
0.07570691406726837,
-0.39724066853523254,
-0.09274137020111084,
-1.198979139328003,
-0.5984641313552856,
-0.815986692905426,
-0.3000394105911255,
-0.605319619178772,
0.2613388001918793,
1.1949701309204102,
0.5467000603675842,
-0.6714113354682922,
-0.5249999165534973,
0.6224709153175354,
0.28165891766548157,
-0.47522637248039246,
-0.2026778608560562,
0.30821460485458374,
-0.1305411458015442,
-0.8106633424758911,
0.138950914144516,
0.3344375491142273,
-0.17647762596607208,
-0.30517953634262085,
-0.06684257090091705,
0.17649966478347778,
0.053869761526584625,
0.6861346960067749,
0.004799190443009138,
-0.7517221570014954,
-0.546843945980072,
0.07028743624687195,
-0.07833041995763779,
-0.05465485155582428,
0.7127714157104492,
-0.4855177700519562,
0.2741675078868866,
0.2079562097787857,
0.38713908195495605,
0.24394746124744415,
-0.18226198852062225,
0.7776729464530945,
-0.6483463644981384,
0.12940074503421783,
0.15572963654994965,
0.18695732951164246,
0.2730018198490143,
-0.19621634483337402,
0.4379936754703522,
0.04858040064573288,
-0.5964756608009338,
-0.7962467074394226,
0.2914397418498993,
-0.9294962286949158,
-0.2233094871044159,
1.638511300086975,
-0.1288357526063919,
-0.016337379813194275,
-0.4165394604206085,
-0.013181669637560844,
-0.24224445223808289,
-0.2592322528362274,
0.9869554042816162,
1.102699637413025,
0.3307202458381653,
-0.03876492753624916,
-0.7400051951408386,
0.47378718852996826,
0.12174610048532486,
-0.5279074907302856,
0.41013434529304504,
0.6352174282073975,
0.6826645731925964,
-0.2223617285490036,
0.7706589102745056,
-0.17556503415107727,
0.2662477195262909,
-0.3845316469669342,
-0.003955308347940445,
-0.011455086059868336,
0.08678831905126572,
-0.6910111904144287,
0.08578243851661682,
0.3968124985694885,
0.2510087788105011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12457v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12457v2
|
RAGCache: Efficient Knowledge Caching for Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-04-18T18:32:30 | 2024-04-25T06:47:57 |
Chao Jin, Zili Zhang, Xuanlin Jiang, Fangyue Liu, Xin Liu, Xuanzhe Liu, Xin Jin
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has shown significant improvements in
various natural language processing tasks by integrating the strengths of large
language models (LLMs) and external knowledge databases. However, RAG
introduces long sequence generation and leads to high computation and memory
costs. We propose RAGCache, a novel multilevel dynamic caching system tailored
for RAG. Our analysis benchmarks current RAG systems, pinpointing the
performance bottleneck (i.e., long sequence due to knowledge injection) and
optimization opportunities (i.e., caching knowledge's intermediate states).
Based on these insights, we design RAGCache, which organizes the intermediate
states of retrieved knowledge in a knowledge tree and caches them in the GPU
and host memory hierarchy. RAGCache proposes a replacement policy that is aware
of LLM inference characteristics and RAG retrieval patterns. It also
dynamically overlaps the retrieval and inference steps to minimize the
end-to-end latency. We implement RAGCache and evaluate it on vLLM, a
state-of-the-art LLM inference system and Faiss, a state-of-the-art vector
database. The experimental results show that RAGCache reduces the time to first
token (TTFT) by up to 4x and improves the throughput by up to 2.1x compared to
vLLM integrated with Faiss.
|
[
-0.5327199697494507,
-0.7583028674125671,
0.36484330892562866,
0.1815524399280548,
-0.13465087115764618,
0.6489709615707397,
-0.08329040557146072,
-0.7343082427978516,
0.4737500548362732,
0.46444350481033325,
-0.2787012755870819,
-0.2589372992515564,
-0.23903469741344452,
-0.1778436303138733,
-0.4375540316104889,
0.9231826066970825,
0.09244298934936523,
-0.3906678557395935,
-0.340375691652298,
0.05117776617407799,
-0.4611383080482483,
0.02540508843958378,
-1.0626944303512573,
-0.35913392901420593,
0.7107065320014954,
0.3412490785121918,
0.6211976408958435,
0.5437946915626526,
0.1585044264793396,
0.24579033255577087,
-0.23689350485801697,
0.6635498404502869,
-0.660402774810791,
0.630743145942688,
-0.3259485065937042,
-0.37728166580200195,
-0.47904786467552185,
-0.3741148114204407,
0.39284011721611023,
0.1405889391899109,
-0.4290047287940979,
0.10536196082830429,
-0.06027790158987045,
0.7306207418441772,
-1.1920514106750488,
0.11929398030042648,
-0.8592544794082642,
-0.10441508889198303,
-0.543989360332489,
-0.48287612199783325,
-0.5750930905342102,
-0.3801971673965454,
0.0012305123964324594,
-0.7552996277809143,
0.42659032344818115,
0.05054900050163269,
0.6047844290733337,
0.5573095679283142,
-0.19776307046413422,
-0.34920060634613037,
-0.6197146773338318,
0.6734132766723633,
-0.5780075788497925,
0.2370055913925171,
0.38735759258270264,
0.556693434715271,
-0.47478583455085754,
-0.8945973515510559,
-0.7634316086769104,
-0.07193756848573685,
0.12238524854183197,
0.18698948621749878,
0.26377546787261963,
-0.11495033651590347,
-0.012919912114739418,
0.6498927474021912,
-0.2502240240573883,
0.03592991456389427,
0.10402928292751312,
-0.05547454208135605,
0.23576492071151733,
0.2033398449420929,
0.2628803551197052,
-0.27360621094703674,
-0.4245114326477051,
-0.23812326788902283,
-0.7713931798934937,
0.008709829300642014,
0.35815346240997314,
0.46258601546287537,
0.22739365696907043,
0.2587658166885376,
-0.3352736532688141,
0.7182531356811523,
-0.06190022453665733,
-0.3759235739707947,
0.17665985226631165,
-0.22664868831634521,
-0.0666583701968193,
0.1216638907790184,
0.32403096556663513,
-0.04766833409667015,
-0.09747352451086044,
-0.2568325102329254,
-0.18492178618907928,
-0.06282339245080948,
0.5386948585510254,
-0.7907313108444214,
-0.07782413810491562,
-0.013370881788432598,
0.19860559701919556,
-0.3985220193862915,
0.046235278248786926,
-1.0448806285858154,
-0.8405401110649109,
0.025376442819833755,
0.37575215101242065,
-0.26061591506004333,
-0.22411994636058807,
0.05332659184932709,
-0.13557665050029755,
0.11421018093824387,
0.3512001633644104,
-0.6328244209289551,
0.49072265625,
0.7330136895179749,
0.787752091884613,
-0.4227595329284668,
0.20077911019325256,
-0.6389483213424683,
0.5625917911529541,
-0.20407941937446594,
0.980427622795105,
-0.6377020478248596,
-0.48713013529777527,
-0.0671207532286644,
-0.04486989602446556,
0.16383878886699677,
-0.5196334719657898,
0.5663350820541382,
-1.0768622159957886,
-0.04289599880576134,
-0.5401778221130371,
-0.33832040429115295,
-0.1094190925359726,
0.05005335807800293,
-0.9217856526374817,
1.4047704935073853,
-0.19068171083927155,
-1.0020374059677124,
0.35963737964630127,
-0.42939698696136475,
-0.6782124638557434,
0.2248719334602356,
-0.14535042643547058,
-0.2854980528354645,
-0.06546152383089066,
0.18456974625587463,
0.11442573368549347,
-0.7002469897270203,
0.2923327088356018,
-0.0752812922000885,
-0.4847031235694885,
-0.22755372524261475,
-0.2952912747859955,
0.5595762133598328,
0.4042166471481323,
-0.39440858364105225,
-0.3424735367298126,
-0.8098953366279602,
0.07343887537717819,
0.11859367042779922,
-0.585037887096405,
-0.5263749957084656,
0.18301482498645782,
-0.24101071059703827,
-0.024994216859340668,
0.4923388957977295,
-0.5471300482749939,
0.32311925292015076,
-0.44591712951660156,
0.008863217197358608,
0.7652716636657715,
0.17221210896968842,
0.4521358907222748,
-0.27336597442626953,
0.47388872504234314,
0.0488513708114624,
-0.1302928477525711,
-0.2596668601036072,
-0.37383705377578735,
-0.8992689251899719,
-0.26944878697395325,
0.20425760746002197,
0.45811372995376587,
-1.0781300067901611,
0.055501773953437805,
-0.1497156322002411,
-0.4282728135585785,
-0.5639556646347046,
-0.0730542466044426,
0.5120559930801392,
0.6504273414611816,
0.5514649152755737,
-0.26806214451789856,
-0.22985471785068512,
-0.665776252746582,
-0.3176747262477875,
0.09836047887802124,
0.33170565962791443,
0.42805397510528564,
0.07565151154994965,
-0.2815941274166107,
0.880925178527832,
-0.43841034173965454,
-0.10527028143405914,
0.11345911026000977,
0.28098011016845703,
0.22929441928863525,
0.20461803674697876,
0.28470513224601746,
-0.547731876373291,
-0.48251503705978394,
0.08640412241220474,
-0.2959384322166443,
-0.3249221742153168,
0.07353845238685608,
-0.24373087286949158,
0.5779063701629639,
0.3843469023704529,
-0.6361671090126038,
0.5826751589775085,
0.5620954632759094,
-0.08859393000602722,
0.5354146361351013,
-0.4874532222747803,
0.2075638622045517,
-1.0088924169540405,
0.2679002285003662,
-0.5842618346214294,
-0.3262757658958435,
-0.2470831274986267,
0.24564602971076965,
0.03525983542203903,
0.12997107207775116,
-0.04891185462474823,
0.8818485736846924,
-0.6286089420318604,
-0.15531189739704132,
-0.5898549556732178,
0.18045327067375183,
0.2558494508266449,
0.26240450143814087,
-0.4216383397579193,
1.0846055746078491,
0.31500664353370667,
-0.8776484131813049,
0.1998675912618637,
-0.039811521768569946,
-0.21972313523292542,
0.3659343719482422,
-0.3084512948989868,
0.28914597630500793,
-0.1175476536154747,
0.5809372663497925,
-0.9131412506103516,
-0.140746608376503,
-0.11467470228672028,
-0.25303223729133606,
0.6073635816574097,
-0.09625635296106339,
-0.5933213233947754,
-0.37468451261520386,
-0.21914418041706085,
0.4238806366920471,
0.2729673981666565,
-0.8660577535629272,
0.7206354737281799,
0.656997561454773,
-0.06272904574871063,
-1.1417254209518433,
-0.44099944829940796,
0.2253190577030182,
0.09076499193906784,
-0.467862606048584,
0.7598528265953064,
0.1145252212882042,
0.13867653906345367,
0.12370781600475311,
-0.37223389744758606,
0.11263474822044373,
-0.1353665143251419,
0.17130573093891144,
-0.13406679034233093,
-0.016004236415028572,
0.33984285593032837,
0.27411675453186035,
-0.23047347366809845,
-0.3915700912475586,
-0.2527138292789459,
0.7874507904052734,
-0.04907447099685669,
-0.28712359070777893,
-0.13540196418762207,
0.07165982574224472,
0.46073395013809204,
-0.3473024070262909,
0.818113386631012,
0.7270922660827637,
-0.2901652753353119,
-0.563749372959137,
-0.7920182347297668,
-0.06369204819202423,
-0.4954672157764435,
-0.027961594983935356,
-0.34385186433792114,
-0.6693202257156372,
0.5481808185577393,
-0.18151326477527618,
0.26080378890037537,
0.40480026602745056,
0.705077052116394,
0.09097710996866226,
0.6356640458106995,
0.4322338402271271,
0.06780267506837845,
0.3492892384529114,
-0.42169106006622314,
0.36098942160606384,
-0.7222946882247925,
-0.19698597490787506,
-0.5351598858833313,
-0.26681849360466003,
-0.6151412725448608,
-0.9400416612625122,
0.3214956521987915,
0.05981763079762459,
-0.3652222454547882,
0.04128609970211983,
-0.3119458258152008,
0.46662959456443787,
0.49847137928009033,
0.05188262462615967,
0.5510135293006897,
-0.027979115024209023,
-0.5343218445777893,
0.1359120011329651,
-0.7321720719337463,
-0.2095012068748474,
0.7454804182052612,
-0.09816543757915497,
0.9697948694229126,
0.11459026485681534,
0.6867251396179199,
0.21120001375675201,
0.21722708642482758,
-0.5077351927757263,
0.5626981854438782,
-0.3348137438297272,
-0.6310944557189941,
-0.1619095504283905,
-0.5030097365379333,
-1.0454378128051758,
0.19877271354198456,
-0.25679996609687805,
-0.37484222650527954,
0.0364612340927124,
0.286418616771698,
-0.2205802947282791,
0.6025837063789368,
-0.5188791751861572,
0.3173951208591461,
-0.04939381405711174,
-0.8000727891921997,
-0.5784123539924622,
-0.4541819989681244,
0.4859943091869354,
-0.14621524512767792,
0.16485710442066193,
0.1283905953168869,
-0.0040460932068526745,
0.5423987507820129,
-0.5003023743629456,
0.556209921836853,
-0.5082516074180603,
-0.0944768637418747,
0.34292072057724,
0.30235597491264343,
0.7766343355178833,
0.1832084208726883,
-0.07661786675453186,
-0.3833259046077728,
-0.07155327498912811,
-0.26224973797798157,
-0.5512650012969971,
1.1486916542053223,
-0.5216378569602966,
-0.6855533719062805,
-0.5342963337898254,
-0.5948523283004761,
-0.41398128867149353,
0.3124188780784607,
-0.1599603146314621,
0.31389036774635315,
-0.016904225572943687,
0.18921621143817902,
0.828781008720398,
-0.7487765550613403,
0.2535707652568817,
0.5112547874450684,
-0.359110563993454,
-0.08430981636047363,
0.9749492406845093,
0.008470763452351093,
0.20805934071540833,
0.4029824137687683,
0.2689584791660309,
-0.1481749713420868,
-0.1828034222126007,
-0.37078624963760376,
0.25802090764045715,
-0.515868604183197,
-0.536823034286499,
-0.9481370449066162,
-0.20739389955997467,
-0.25633978843688965,
0.03645701706409454,
-0.6424007415771484,
-0.4425979554653168,
-0.19524404406547546,
0.05933520942926407,
0.743149995803833,
0.7091516256332397,
-0.07450433820486069,
0.24494975805282593,
-0.47842520475387573,
0.7160300612449646,
0.25033870339393616,
0.5713982582092285,
0.4713185131549835,
-0.30031195282936096,
-0.25482282042503357,
-0.1418171226978302,
-0.40261852741241455,
-0.5769062042236328,
0.31086161732673645,
0.16193591058254242,
0.5484145879745483,
0.2191292643547058,
0.060006894171237946,
1.0420690774917603,
-0.5706267356872559,
0.506449282169342,
-0.15626105666160583,
-0.4835623502731323,
0.1763783097267151,
-0.15264266729354858,
0.43834421038627625,
0.6453855633735657,
0.09512053430080414,
-0.5298339128494263,
-0.5128903388977051,
-0.5172683000564575,
-1.2034932374954224,
0.33608993887901306,
-0.21886558830738068,
-0.02699553221464157,
-0.21802780032157898,
0.4476780891418457,
0.21568132936954498,
0.09569501876831055,
-0.04125014320015907,
-0.20446400344371796,
0.13184069097042084,
0.06966497749090195,
0.12594850361347198,
-0.22879113256931305,
0.1436930149793625,
-0.081838458776474,
0.8807493448257446,
-0.008169847540557384,
0.19852131605148315,
-0.00857856310904026,
-0.024802880361676216,
-0.21992793679237366,
0.06190657988190651,
0.21038854122161865,
0.600389838218689,
-0.16051730513572693,
0.2928474545478821,
0.21785445511341095,
-0.5783714652061462,
-0.06320112198591232,
0.11321263760328293,
-0.1164303719997406,
-0.08820592612028122,
-0.10233868658542633,
0.3944992125034332,
0.476235955953598,
-0.6096723675727844,
0.1739329993724823,
-0.21692171692848206,
0.41937917470932007,
-0.23330789804458618,
0.27382078766822815,
0.4489305317401886,
0.23728466033935547,
0.45019474625587463,
-0.1333760768175125,
0.016819102689623833,
-0.4496636390686035,
0.3332710266113281,
0.4791876971721649,
0.08635072410106659,
0.0805547758936882,
0.608371913433075,
0.06641139090061188,
0.022501010447740555,
0.4661404490470886,
-0.11151466518640518,
-0.22190776467323303,
0.2112533450126648,
0.4488861560821533,
0.5253454446792603,
-0.38993462920188904,
0.19231660664081573,
0.4211576282978058,
0.0663570985198021,
-0.030102821066975594,
0.36729562282562256,
-0.26226043701171875,
-0.5688680410385132,
-0.6404827237129211,
-1.149385929107666,
-0.45248693227767944,
-0.09904298931360245,
-0.553562581539154,
0.14227384328842163,
-0.3133092522621155,
-0.2824867367744446,
-0.25458216667175293,
0.27705270051956177,
-0.7427939772605896,
0.00835101492702961,
-0.26162615418434143,
1.0897667407989502,
-0.3246120512485504,
0.9652383923530579,
0.328879177570343,
-0.21842120587825775,
-0.46624433994293213,
-0.15951859951019287,
-0.0375029556453228,
-1.0031239986419678,
0.5240108370780945,
-0.12019585818052292,
-0.6228588223457336,
0.03768349811434746,
-0.23506151139736176,
-0.9989045858383179,
1.2173168659210205,
0.23284123837947845,
-0.3687082827091217,
-0.1972748041152954,
-0.17117612063884735,
0.587422788143158,
-0.11270232498645782,
0.03061266988515854,
0.5528987646102905,
0.5640730857849121,
0.466266393661499,
-0.6799173951148987,
-0.08444222807884216,
-0.13196347653865814,
0.10173989087343216,
0.4293445348739624,
-0.47575679421424866,
0.8026044964790344,
-0.21195350587368011,
-0.4985724091529846,
0.12011521309614182,
0.6131762862205505,
0.6172578930854797,
0.07635349035263062,
0.47549158334732056,
1.0699996948242188,
0.8737119436264038,
0.09438379853963852,
1.2249326705932617,
-0.40231719613075256,
0.03984450921416283,
1.329575777053833,
-0.17723912000656128,
0.8081357479095459,
0.4836311638355255,
0.15657085180282593,
0.8101547360420227,
0.21378667652606964,
0.5886208415031433,
0.5345041751861572,
0.38123446702957153,
-0.612910270690918,
0.06040246784687042,
-0.2542378604412079,
-0.3313937485218048,
0.10773816704750061,
0.500262439250946,
-0.05077122524380684,
-0.48403826355934143,
-0.24740977585315704,
0.18642765283584595,
-0.16984044015407562,
-0.07758673280477524,
0.8291404843330383,
0.03388340771198273,
-0.842887282371521,
0.5702608823776245,
0.04101910814642906,
0.49831902980804443,
-0.4657716155052185,
-0.21450050175189972,
-0.314251184463501,
0.2441628873348236,
-0.18590684235095978,
-0.6131418943405151,
0.12034544348716736,
0.08474535495042801,
-0.049979906529188156,
-0.2194163054227829,
0.8826557397842407,
-0.39793214201927185,
-0.0580834224820137,
0.4039751887321472,
0.4369414448738098,
0.0026996529195457697,
0.1378331035375595,
-0.5110427141189575,
0.04242024943232536,
-0.40769150853157043,
-0.4852703809738159,
0.3906959891319275,
0.5346997976303101,
-0.16583701968193054,
0.6321458220481873,
0.8583086133003235,
0.2998533844947815,
0.43373215198516846,
0.2630058228969574,
0.9894824624061584,
-0.5747286677360535,
-0.6203478574752808,
-0.31908369064331055,
0.28219664096832275,
-0.051136717200279236,
0.0604000948369503,
0.46788156032562256,
0.4377707540988922,
0.5305784344673157,
0.2812296152114868,
0.5463860630989075,
-0.1742660403251648,
0.762569010257721,
-0.43729129433631897,
0.760384738445282,
-0.7895897030830383,
0.19224101305007935,
-0.15878207981586456,
-0.9003823399543762,
-0.10814668983221054,
0.4263320565223694,
-0.024616412818431854,
0.0503963828086853,
0.657559871673584,
0.9857476949691772,
-0.007018897216767073,
0.08599365502595901,
0.07300016283988953,
0.32385164499282837,
0.6491187810897827,
0.3851357698440552,
0.5063027739524841,
-0.19889689981937408,
0.3138224184513092,
-0.10407532006502151,
-0.33461710810661316,
-0.1921549141407013,
-0.9993450045585632,
-0.4136303663253784,
-0.6480879187583923,
0.2692262530326843,
-0.2879100441932678,
0.1867724359035492,
0.3500120937824249,
0.3729773461818695,
-0.574610710144043,
-0.15648657083511353,
-0.09155423194169998,
0.11538849025964737,
-0.0009760937537066638,
-0.30377501249313354,
0.30039212107658386,
-0.7608844041824341,
-0.4444787800312042,
0.5120820999145508,
0.4286932647228241,
-0.2940152883529663,
-0.5196489691734314,
0.07589785009622574,
-0.5260719060897827,
0.1964120864868164,
0.6057909727096558,
0.4160333275794983,
-0.6136165857315063,
-0.23643381893634796,
-0.07542118430137634,
-0.22792868316173553,
0.0020145948510617018,
0.919446587562561,
-1.1486599445343018,
0.7820781469345093,
0.6975456476211548,
1.1946429014205933,
1.052506685256958,
-0.165782168507576,
0.3499666452407837,
-0.6503745317459106,
0.09061295539140701,
0.2504842281341553,
0.2562875747680664,
0.22236020863056183,
-0.27701616287231445,
0.32881486415863037,
0.09453500807285309,
-0.6610075235366821,
-0.7457177042961121,
0.14122198522090912,
-1.0402801036834717,
-0.27316197752952576,
0.8592690229415894,
0.20082388818264008,
-0.2632358968257904,
-0.15171408653259277,
-0.1683146208524704,
0.47659099102020264,
-0.44299793243408203,
0.9803829193115234,
0.48677965998649597,
0.0018613695865496993,
0.06024762988090515,
-0.8481479287147522,
0.7096439003944397,
0.409282386302948,
-0.8091356158256531,
0.18928618729114532,
0.38390371203422546,
0.03615553304553032,
0.2621323764324188,
0.6418120861053467,
-0.3346407413482666,
0.17594818770885468,
-0.21660016477108002,
0.13998010754585266,
0.04712870717048645,
-0.605529248714447,
0.25760307908058167,
0.15118253231048584,
-0.0871269553899765,
0.3763546645641327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12452v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12452v1
|
Characterizing LLM Abstention Behavior in Science QA with Context Perturbations
| 2024-04-18T18:26:43 | 2024-04-18T18:26:43 |
Bingbing Wen, Bill Howe, Lucy Lu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The correct model response in the face of uncertainty is to abstain from
answering a question so as not to mislead the user. In this work, we study the
ability of LLMs to abstain from answering context-dependent science questions
when provided insufficient or incorrect context. We probe model sensitivity in
several settings: removing gold context, replacing gold context with irrelevant
context, and providing additional context beyond what is given. In experiments
on four QA datasets with four LLMs, we show that performance varies greatly
across models, across the type of context provided, and also by question type;
in particular, many LLMs seem unable to abstain from answering boolean
questions using standard QA prompts. Our analysis also highlights the
unexpected impact of abstention performance on QA task accuracy.
Counter-intuitively, in some settings, replacing gold context with irrelevant
context or adding irrelevant context to gold context can improve abstention
performance in a way that results in improvements in task performance. Our
results imply that changes are needed in QA dataset design and evaluation to
more effectively assess the correctness and downstream impacts of model
abstention.
|
[
-0.22318843007087708,
-0.9946374893188477,
0.8690648078918457,
0.011170285753905773,
-0.2194654494524002,
-0.15679439902305603,
0.18130850791931152,
-0.37802690267562866,
-0.1272675096988678,
0.5216308832168579,
-0.7732715010643005,
-0.2637629210948944,
-0.5032805800437927,
0.6631627678871155,
-0.382418155670166,
0.9011901617050171,
-0.2976929545402527,
-0.09520412981510162,
-0.7915669679641724,
-0.12069343030452728,
-0.8269186615943909,
-0.5052743554115295,
-0.23026511073112488,
-0.5346280932426453,
0.5951324105262756,
0.2582493722438812,
0.5002636313438416,
0.5579758286476135,
0.5542820692062378,
0.23484808206558228,
-0.26541584730148315,
-0.0243348628282547,
-0.4459856450557709,
0.1733417958021164,
-0.4364263713359833,
-1.0389668941497803,
-0.43543103337287903,
0.02746536396443844,
0.4532974064350128,
0.5649767518043518,
0.165818452835083,
0.3680505156517029,
0.14716210961341858,
0.4606276750564575,
-0.9360830783843994,
0.10519884526729584,
-0.8236239552497864,
-0.05784769728779793,
0.19924317300319672,
-0.5337915420532227,
-0.3068382740020752,
0.12037774920463562,
0.19364739954471588,
-0.7105028629302979,
0.17521345615386963,
-0.2106371521949768,
0.7934232354164124,
0.7651835083961487,
-0.6866167783737183,
-0.2646428644657135,
-0.8762394785881042,
0.5352699756622314,
-0.6838650107383728,
0.06591769307851791,
0.501047670841217,
-0.13011014461517334,
-0.046558868139982224,
-0.6235285997390747,
-0.3202192187309265,
0.004727064166218042,
-0.15376147627830505,
0.15566441416740417,
-0.20836478471755981,
0.10045278072357178,
0.39719077944755554,
0.05246717855334282,
-0.2958787977695465,
-0.08180753141641617,
-0.4281447231769562,
-0.1487811952829361,
0.3769676685333252,
0.433226615190506,
-0.03349219635128975,
-0.16020633280277252,
-0.3912242650985718,
0.026166953146457672,
-1.0697407722473145,
0.39371949434280396,
0.07503782212734222,
0.40020033717155457,
0.05426405742764473,
0.8248943090438843,
-0.24768126010894775,
0.5716414451599121,
0.1955713927745819,
0.006060375366359949,
-0.10971728712320328,
-0.28020843863487244,
-0.34266188740730286,
-0.11291269212961197,
0.1748398244380951,
0.2265993356704712,
-0.1401694118976593,
0.05932006612420082,
-0.4161244034767151,
0.07835673540830612,
0.46994930505752563,
-0.7479208111763,
-0.014971157535910606,
0.593308687210083,
-0.058634206652641296,
-0.05296117812395096,
-0.05762539431452751,
-0.0992092490196228,
-0.3646382987499237,
-0.3018784523010254,
0.7006585001945496,
-0.06280490756034851,
0.030856607481837273,
-0.04668499529361725,
0.05467430502176285,
0.11463529616594315,
0.2948247790336609,
-0.5041759014129639,
0.2771954834461212,
0.4754262864589691,
0.7268801927566528,
-0.11555034667253494,
-0.08106337487697601,
-0.35543352365493774,
0.1198538988828659,
-0.4043843150138855,
0.7466517090797424,
-0.33436915278434753,
-0.7185598015785217,
-0.4514780342578888,
0.2137605845928192,
-0.303346186876297,
-0.7510973811149597,
0.3884775936603546,
-0.7897111177444458,
-0.14218783378601074,
-0.7680126428604126,
-0.4666231870651245,
-0.5833494067192078,
0.29725557565689087,
-0.5630594491958618,
0.4353737533092499,
0.11994778364896774,
-0.7084749341011047,
0.36160358786582947,
-0.5818769335746765,
-0.2640259265899658,
-0.008350679650902748,
-0.0961235910654068,
-0.08456223458051682,
0.3273128867149353,
0.1266328990459442,
0.1593315750360489,
0.1720743179321289,
0.03706337884068489,
-0.24004001915454865,
-0.6533181071281433,
0.6077594757080078,
-0.43596017360687256,
0.5774667263031006,
0.10322285443544388,
-0.07929263263940811,
0.1866704821586609,
-0.48708808422088623,
0.05160246416926384,
-0.10069472342729568,
-0.2888440191745758,
-0.49867504835128784,
0.184653639793396,
-0.26537612080574036,
0.41603243350982666,
-0.0006526846555061638,
-0.4124467670917511,
0.01787777990102768,
-0.40870752930641174,
0.38242295384407043,
0.7942106127738953,
0.2643137574195862,
0.051555074751377106,
-0.6887085437774658,
0.6418147087097168,
-0.009011000394821167,
-0.04288247227668762,
0.18424977362155914,
-0.3082301914691925,
-0.4357122778892517,
-0.23647885024547577,
0.11494314670562744,
0.8786170482635498,
-0.5925717353820801,
0.23195038735866547,
-0.06201751530170441,
-0.18964000046253204,
-0.386358380317688,
0.18728946149349213,
0.5375623106956482,
1.1037722826004028,
0.4601709246635437,
-0.2431311458349228,
-0.40853866934776306,
-0.8320391774177551,
-0.2298019379377365,
-0.35933345556259155,
-0.3049784004688263,
0.44335827231407166,
0.878180980682373,
-0.0714932531118393,
1.2699096202850342,
-0.4284581243991852,
-0.023565135896205902,
0.12180273979902267,
-0.11818873137235641,
0.13737784326076508,
0.2979345917701721,
0.23684458434581757,
-1.0236262083053589,
0.05597954988479614,
-0.40882542729377747,
-0.717469334602356,
-0.2551313638687134,
-0.016599152237176895,
0.17804937064647675,
0.3406029939651489,
0.284525603055954,
-0.7016745209693909,
0.7621431350708008,
0.4713984727859497,
-0.41002511978149414,
1.022913932800293,
0.10407979041337967,
0.18563570082187653,
-0.6369268298149109,
0.4924910068511963,
-0.19033439457416534,
-0.09791244566440582,
-0.693469226360321,
0.04940818250179291,
0.20425204932689667,
0.3385315537452698,
-0.9090933799743652,
0.6102121472358704,
-0.12645825743675232,
-0.26433053612709045,
-0.4045569598674774,
0.14020724594593048,
0.27189046144485474,
0.190810889005661,
0.2547855079174042,
0.9805124402046204,
0.16557367146015167,
-1.0243878364562988,
0.09197674691677094,
0.501173734664917,
-0.18134275078773499,
0.35514065623283386,
-0.9756982326507568,
-0.002476705936715007,
-0.09452971816062927,
0.37395283579826355,
-1.111464023590088,
-0.3270331621170044,
0.3907743990421295,
-0.3097931146621704,
0.11290000379085541,
-0.15886469185352325,
-0.25743386149406433,
-0.1957055628299713,
-0.20881883800029755,
0.4252822995185852,
0.19352950155735016,
-0.2175436019897461,
0.39141222834587097,
-0.3432900905609131,
-0.33233657479286194,
-0.702701985836029,
-0.9006478786468506,
-0.1373990774154663,
-0.38255417346954346,
-0.4826781153678894,
0.36277079582214355,
-0.3412849009037018,
-0.5260071158409119,
0.1350301057100296,
-0.6496003270149231,
0.25312313437461853,
0.559314489364624,
0.47760236263275146,
0.4415251314640045,
0.06071443855762482,
0.3018443286418915,
0.0736817866563797,
0.17169463634490967,
0.4525059163570404,
0.3009403944015503,
0.32115352153778076,
-0.08674000948667526,
-0.6798373460769653,
-0.6160841584205627,
0.034507349133491516,
0.2971874475479126,
-0.043085940182209015,
0.6786022186279297,
0.11516324430704117,
-0.167363241314888,
0.20717167854309082,
-0.27355191111564636,
-0.704420804977417,
-0.4974055290222168,
0.32443302869796753,
-0.5911036729812622,
-0.9581068754196167,
0.9577047228813171,
0.2795012295246124,
0.2780611515045166,
0.3198283910751343,
0.337717205286026,
-0.2585048973560333,
0.9898721575737,
0.44743797183036804,
0.2919756770133972,
0.14424610137939453,
-0.07579072564840317,
0.14267617464065552,
-1.0749036073684692,
0.004448256455361843,
-0.5519266724586487,
-0.10718458145856857,
-0.5251270532608032,
-0.1598566621541977,
0.5859349370002747,
0.21182973682880402,
-0.14919407665729523,
-0.2018808275461197,
-0.38855770230293274,
0.3306953012943268,
0.06766904890537262,
0.287814199924469,
0.43423017859458923,
-0.22413545846939087,
0.2741987109184265,
0.17834272980690002,
-0.6731160283088684,
-0.7844034433364868,
1.0447499752044678,
0.26611942052841187,
0.719092845916748,
0.1524534970521927,
0.31444740295410156,
0.08307036757469177,
0.4756501317024231,
-0.7191054821014404,
0.35217776894569397,
0.1959610879421234,
-0.8239007592201233,
-0.43969088792800903,
-0.4296751618385315,
-0.7404024600982666,
0.46195849776268005,
-0.11330504715442657,
-0.7374043464660645,
0.21264788508415222,
0.29038897156715393,
-0.7461352944374084,
0.19242246448993683,
-0.4715258777141571,
0.4768667221069336,
-0.12605462968349457,
-0.5108060836791992,
0.18964582681655884,
-0.6874514818191528,
0.5234286189079285,
-0.24567662179470062,
0.2569180130958557,
-0.2250889092683792,
-0.27075690031051636,
0.5079017281532288,
-0.10518693178892136,
1.0366742610931396,
0.026302842423319817,
-0.36804550886154175,
0.4605785310268402,
0.5110645294189453,
0.6368184685707092,
0.3340650796890259,
-0.19492340087890625,
-0.055241383612155914,
0.41975095868110657,
-0.4623093605041504,
-0.5555934906005859,
0.3665887415409088,
-0.623259425163269,
-1.0992158651351929,
-0.2624509632587433,
-0.9544165134429932,
-0.3647107779979706,
-0.004037559498101473,
0.44461721181869507,
0.13589833676815033,
0.16307207942008972,
0.09443134814500809,
0.8377705812454224,
-0.1571253091096878,
0.3395993411540985,
0.6783966422080994,
0.04608249291777611,
0.09258149564266205,
0.45548897981643677,
0.28718674182891846,
0.527169406414032,
0.0608530193567276,
0.041519422084093094,
-0.5981876850128174,
-0.6346553564071655,
-0.18495075404644012,
0.16256651282310486,
-0.8238855004310608,
-0.11070245504379272,
-0.43333888053894043,
-0.18412385880947113,
-0.49224504828453064,
-0.20881111919879913,
-0.04119294881820679,
-0.36835283041000366,
-0.7726744413375854,
-0.3995610773563385,
0.23870937526226044,
0.6089804172515869,
0.16021335124969482,
0.09784366935491562,
-0.6236818432807922,
-0.04630886763334274,
0.2631555497646332,
0.0012902235612273216,
-0.1844763308763504,
-0.8805277347564697,
0.1721981316804886,
0.15393327176570892,
-0.42961055040359497,
-0.7861822843551636,
0.4629916846752167,
0.05804521217942238,
0.6158998012542725,
0.42880120873451233,
0.42083975672721863,
0.5550224781036377,
0.027550064027309418,
0.8535855412483215,
-0.3255973160266876,
-0.9770817756652832,
0.572291910648346,
-0.4465627372264862,
0.48992398381233215,
0.39004236459732056,
0.3961171805858612,
-0.38154515624046326,
-0.46058517694473267,
-0.1688288450241089,
-0.9568020701408386,
0.5256655216217041,
0.12127940356731415,
0.18997937440872192,
0.22487445175647736,
0.8601388335227966,
0.25740450620651245,
0.3754882216453552,
-0.7898319959640503,
-0.13453784584999084,
-0.16498106718063354,
0.34779447317123413,
-0.18972457945346832,
-0.35568103194236755,
-0.6178011894226074,
-0.06141804903745651,
0.5080855488777161,
-0.34623992443084717,
0.07295864075422287,
0.5373461246490479,
-0.2555139660835266,
-0.32216280698776245,
0.4375033974647522,
0.9461202025413513,
1.1251963376998901,
-0.4758293330669403,
0.10531850159168243,
0.4120346009731293,
-0.31340840458869934,
0.2125953733921051,
-0.2805279493331909,
-0.56742262840271,
-0.5662230849266052,
0.5947155952453613,
0.47215771675109863,
-0.22646678984165192,
-0.6245439648628235,
0.072394460439682,
0.06524159759283066,
-0.34654101729393005,
0.049221087247133255,
0.2696269452571869,
-0.10021007061004639,
0.04654891788959503,
0.6875572204589844,
-0.08812177926301956,
0.2490565925836563,
-0.3778846263885498,
0.2060304433107376,
0.5546082258224487,
-0.3199174702167511,
-0.2895881235599518,
0.6614503860473633,
-0.054951008409261703,
-0.0036807877477258444,
0.5412828326225281,
0.0846191868185997,
-0.3727235794067383,
1.074657678604126,
0.7055485248565674,
0.4941766858100891,
-0.2164798378944397,
0.15430842339992523,
0.16972537338733673,
0.36247989535331726,
0.3469356298446655,
0.49201133847236633,
0.05329939350485802,
-0.7982622981071472,
-0.5944703221321106,
-0.266867995262146,
-0.5888662338256836,
0.278549462556839,
-0.8735552430152893,
-0.24216336011886597,
-0.4649854600429535,
-0.4097902178764343,
-0.4045230746269226,
0.11782502382993698,
-0.4702792167663574,
0.4513864517211914,
-0.3151088356971741,
0.8660515546798706,
-0.9662374258041382,
0.24914678931236267,
0.9280749559402466,
-0.215314581990242,
-0.6646990776062012,
0.01399565301835537,
0.39115768671035767,
-0.21649517118930817,
0.5241010785102844,
0.1600373089313507,
-0.2796218693256378,
-0.2131909430027008,
-0.684188961982727,
-1.2226499319076538,
1.2133623361587524,
0.22520241141319275,
-0.2723871171474457,
0.33196085691452026,
-0.015147014521062374,
0.5902248620986938,
-0.19226357340812683,
0.17340292036533356,
0.4897385239601135,
0.5599291324615479,
-0.006348570808768272,
-0.9107301831245422,
0.4483885169029236,
0.06447293609380722,
-0.0599578395485878,
-0.35522958636283875,
-0.7441712021827698,
1.0190461874008179,
-0.36057546734809875,
-0.316830575466156,
0.12991471588611603,
0.4598039388656616,
0.8066684603691101,
0.5252726078033447,
0.47755900025367737,
0.04505104944109917,
0.5374088883399963,
-0.15572421252727509,
0.9050755500793457,
-0.14721138775348663,
0.047398537397384644,
0.8990702629089355,
-0.622868001461029,
0.6694309711456299,
0.8509783148765564,
-0.19670745730400085,
0.319948673248291,
0.9024726152420044,
0.20085109770298004,
0.4524976313114166,
0.2678905725479126,
-0.3971996605396271,
-0.2352132350206375,
-0.22676366567611694,
-0.28693559765815735,
0.5256854891777039,
0.6485099196434021,
0.04147419333457947,
-0.052148930728435516,
0.07046639174222946,
-0.10892735421657562,
-0.08416371047496796,
-0.3990277945995331,
0.32700246572494507,
0.0479111485183239,
-0.7514012455940247,
0.6875022053718567,
0.012950712814927101,
0.5249583125114441,
-0.550370454788208,
0.12628746032714844,
-0.3954196870326996,
-0.14839813113212585,
-0.47732317447662354,
-0.619198739528656,
0.429447203874588,
-0.18181224167346954,
-0.40323325991630554,
0.11909106373786926,
0.6190721988677979,
-0.083077073097229,
-0.12562645971775055,
0.11527322232723236,
0.5664060711860657,
0.25031328201293945,
-0.03298501670360565,
-0.4408484995365143,
0.03964852914214134,
-0.15375863015651703,
-0.6076099276542664,
0.41213804483413696,
-0.027553174644708633,
-0.33934903144836426,
1.1396417617797852,
0.6581152081489563,
0.06119836866855621,
-0.12004970759153366,
-0.390944242477417,
0.8228970766067505,
-0.327920526266098,
-0.32981181144714355,
-0.6199237108230591,
0.4649139642715454,
0.4336649179458618,
-0.22601914405822754,
0.8512289524078369,
0.2399442195892334,
0.7242518067359924,
0.036462828516960144,
0.778099775314331,
0.060040079057216644,
0.39552733302116394,
-0.6809384822845459,
0.5969455242156982,
-0.6499731540679932,
0.7533538937568665,
-0.1918652057647705,
-0.5822690725326538,
-0.22799794375896454,
0.31093090772628784,
-0.535544216632843,
0.3297540545463562,
0.5113328695297241,
0.8740071654319763,
0.18167635798454285,
-0.16267818212509155,
0.3474523425102234,
0.20614729821681976,
0.3135363459587097,
0.4919208586215973,
0.8245313167572021,
-0.16946595907211304,
0.2939470410346985,
-0.3734888434410095,
0.02634136565029621,
-0.3811693787574768,
-0.8847460746765137,
-0.6124386787414551,
-0.4076978862285614,
-0.3200705945491791,
-0.37343332171440125,
0.21598561108112335,
0.5593886375427246,
0.593867838382721,
-0.871862530708313,
0.006144489627331495,
0.1623721420764923,
0.48805180191993713,
-0.3763047158718109,
-0.25626856088638306,
0.45544198155403137,
-0.12723089754581451,
-0.4582207202911377,
0.710919976234436,
0.014042841270565987,
0.27952539920806885,
-0.07382062077522278,
0.11097820848226547,
-0.21024364233016968,
0.5184693336486816,
0.4928815960884094,
0.561404287815094,
-0.8411282300949097,
-0.46728622913360596,
0.07477078586816788,
-0.15815460681915283,
-0.10500987619161606,
0.478412002325058,
-0.7848274111747742,
0.09435618668794632,
0.3600515127182007,
0.3204357326030731,
0.1815076470375061,
0.7091113328933716,
0.3801908493041992,
-1.0093799829483032,
-0.11441276967525482,
0.3049083352088928,
-0.06069796532392502,
0.14709384739398956,
-0.7278738021850586,
0.5603615641593933,
0.2836359441280365,
-0.6350148320198059,
-1.0786323547363281,
0.23058968782424927,
-0.6776042580604553,
-0.6779494285583496,
1.1123442649841309,
-0.18134070932865143,
-0.2907129228115082,
-0.3290964663028717,
-0.04596679285168648,
0.0398971289396286,
-0.19475017488002777,
0.8734158873558044,
0.9723597168922424,
-0.7901178598403931,
-0.28137773275375366,
-0.6411623954772949,
0.36674463748931885,
0.8022760152816772,
-0.6012054681777954,
0.10182062536478043,
0.7048800587654114,
0.6717385053634644,
0.05163639411330223,
0.5281974673271179,
-0.001881212810985744,
0.5128502249717712,
-0.20343878865242004,
0.057166531682014465,
-0.41223686933517456,
-0.288591593503952,
-0.5885622501373291,
0.31030166149139404,
0.07789073884487152,
-0.004182650242000818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12447v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12447v2
|
AmbigDocs: Reasoning across Documents on Different Entities under the Same Name
| 2024-04-18T18:12:01 | 2024-05-26T14:00:07 |
Yoonsang Lee, Xi Ye, Eunsol Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Different entities with the same name can be difficult to distinguish.
Handling confusing entity mentions is a crucial skill for language models
(LMs). For example, given the question "Where was Michael Jordan educated?" and
a set of documents discussing different people named Michael Jordan, can LMs
distinguish entity mentions to generate a cohesive answer to the question? To
test this ability, we introduce a new benchmark, AmbigDocs. By leveraging
Wikipedia's disambiguation pages, we identify a set of documents, belonging to
different entities who share an ambiguous name. From these documents, we
generate questions containing an ambiguous name and their corresponding sets of
answers. Our analysis reveals that current state-of-the-art models often yield
ambiguous answers or incorrectly merge information belonging to different
entities. We establish an ontology categorizing four types of incomplete
answers and automatic evaluation metrics to identify such categories. We lay
the foundation for future work on reasoning across multiple documents with
ambiguous entities.
|
[
-0.773963451385498,
-0.9633195400238037,
0.8559463024139404,
0.051137302070856094,
0.04280620068311691,
0.44147536158561707,
-0.14925801753997803,
-0.6112827658653259,
0.1690986305475235,
0.24460506439208984,
-0.7779433727264404,
-0.3515867590904236,
-0.7607949376106262,
0.22361917793750763,
-0.6037746071815491,
0.6662192344665527,
-0.3258970379829407,
0.0031413414981216192,
-0.3101464807987213,
-0.3602416217327118,
-0.17243577539920807,
-0.013035598210990429,
-0.6880441308021545,
-0.3146170675754547,
0.6480599045753479,
0.4134541153907776,
0.8569788932800293,
0.5298521518707275,
0.5081079006195068,
0.3586859703063965,
-0.0480363667011261,
0.4733875095844269,
-0.10179512947797775,
0.09478309005498886,
-0.6080608367919922,
-0.25091552734375,
-0.12387067824602127,
0.18267935514450073,
0.40973198413848877,
1.001762866973877,
-0.11748646199703217,
0.13857106864452362,
-0.2671275734901428,
0.20937348902225494,
-0.8844466805458069,
-0.18614065647125244,
-0.7696482539176941,
0.02242758497595787,
-0.1593337059020996,
-0.19473187625408173,
-0.16315539181232452,
-0.2807964086532593,
0.07901234179735184,
-0.6214743256568909,
0.4205248951911926,
0.06460511684417725,
1.145966649055481,
0.2187214344739914,
-0.5707538723945618,
-0.7302851676940918,
-0.6889108419418335,
0.4219191074371338,
-0.30240389704704285,
0.6254239082336426,
0.18372495472431183,
0.3572910726070404,
-0.19634976983070374,
-0.6471760869026184,
-0.7713004350662231,
0.0033815873321145773,
-0.07428375631570816,
0.13499470055103302,
-0.17105716466903687,
-0.17331819236278534,
0.2590623199939728,
0.17219245433807373,
-0.4528842866420746,
0.03941844403743744,
-0.509194552898407,
-0.04292033985257149,
0.5680698156356812,
-0.09572678059339523,
0.25312453508377075,
-0.33406707644462585,
-0.5814082026481628,
0.16331656277179718,
-0.6167857050895691,
0.07308687269687653,
0.6310450434684753,
-0.19313715398311615,
0.2701675593852997,
0.6585444211959839,
-0.2561852037906647,
0.6206848621368408,
0.07969055324792862,
-0.07684940844774246,
0.2660607695579529,
-0.28828591108322144,
-0.010302378796041012,
0.22695037722587585,
0.5965732336044312,
0.20364804565906525,
0.24953818321228027,
-0.669136643409729,
0.05430684611201286,
-0.3163582384586334,
0.6133439540863037,
-0.3767225444316864,
-0.1635306477546692,
0.3528030216693878,
-0.18300269544124603,
-0.004839794710278511,
0.1334732174873352,
-0.5669301152229309,
-0.5159900784492493,
-0.11489970237016678,
0.3495657742023468,
-0.23050087690353394,
-0.22432835400104523,
-0.18551002442836761,
-0.2937402129173279,
-0.03419596329331398,
0.6549790501594543,
-0.9087444543838501,
0.27196478843688965,
0.762319803237915,
0.5707123279571533,
-0.12218840420246124,
-0.697181224822998,
-0.37768813967704773,
0.4044407308101654,
-0.3667704463005066,
1.008100152015686,
-0.6319296360015869,
-0.4882938861846924,
-0.02714635245501995,
0.061226293444633484,
0.12141039222478867,
-0.5523733496665955,
0.48621633648872375,
-0.5551130771636963,
0.1603030413389206,
-0.5120807886123657,
-0.7496902942657471,
-0.13930977880954742,
0.5375508666038513,
-0.4939756393432617,
0.9520630836486816,
0.20464006066322327,
-0.8195128440856934,
0.4857870936393738,
-0.28055280447006226,
-0.10682988911867142,
0.1438966691493988,
-0.5306241512298584,
-0.10660379379987717,
-0.10129433125257492,
-0.07256566733121872,
0.19590026140213013,
-0.5722413063049316,
0.34677696228027344,
-0.5284255146980286,
-0.1642398238182068,
0.48811301589012146,
-0.1405680626630783,
0.7243430614471436,
0.1774977147579193,
-0.09252108633518219,
-0.12857824563980103,
-0.7963878512382507,
0.1987455189228058,
-0.15679626166820526,
-0.5547629594802856,
-0.4702432155609131,
-0.03261275589466095,
-0.42955344915390015,
0.11371790617704391,
0.18688559532165527,
-0.4953022599220276,
0.2660497725009918,
-0.058800581842660904,
0.16656531393527985,
0.3949058949947357,
0.23072604835033417,
0.4189789593219757,
-0.24156659841537476,
0.40164443850517273,
0.2521675229072571,
-0.12233337759971619,
-0.10730204731225967,
-0.7103154063224792,
-0.7682012915611267,
0.13272608816623688,
0.3888099491596222,
0.470934122800827,
-0.6991146802902222,
0.09837277233600616,
-0.3519710898399353,
-0.7226894497871399,
-0.7408916354179382,
0.29410120844841003,
0.3135593831539154,
0.6231966614723206,
0.6004341840744019,
-0.23110657930374146,
-0.31500616669654846,
-0.9534343481063843,
-0.6807533502578735,
-0.43833619356155396,
-0.29623931646347046,
0.4746568500995636,
0.680432915687561,
-0.11832309514284134,
0.6855964064598083,
-0.5815051198005676,
0.12227298319339752,
0.4585588574409485,
0.3893447816371918,
-0.10202469676733017,
0.24619317054748535,
0.2725815176963806,
-1.1163828372955322,
-0.3151898980140686,
-0.13645675778388977,
-0.7253676652908325,
-0.14587534964084625,
-0.2655108571052551,
-0.4032117426395416,
-0.21957211196422577,
0.7281051278114319,
-0.9211341142654419,
0.1621684581041336,
0.08490807563066483,
-0.2790428698062897,
0.4004329442977905,
-0.3039129674434662,
0.4780152142047882,
-0.8777809143066406,
-0.006230951752513647,
-0.09425465017557144,
0.018003106117248535,
-0.3345031142234802,
-0.05557572469115257,
0.2655712962150574,
0.0862639993429184,
-0.3135461211204529,
0.6957603693008423,
-0.7257903218269348,
-0.07193548232316971,
0.09902261197566986,
0.7617251873016357,
0.05322835221886635,
0.24519361555576324,
-0.15642064809799194,
0.3833760619163513,
0.4447827935218811,
-0.5237118005752563,
0.927770733833313,
0.3056965172290802,
-0.2347528338432312,
0.8831115365028381,
-0.23758907616138458,
0.051977355033159256,
-0.1310558319091797,
0.0933808907866478,
-0.9543902277946472,
-0.3088192045688629,
0.3699895143508911,
-0.4235018491744995,
0.22978147864341736,
-0.27730363607406616,
-0.6320828795433044,
-0.6100864410400391,
0.09090717881917953,
0.09155533462762833,
0.019248632714152336,
-0.4931167960166931,
0.5291366577148438,
0.4791031777858734,
-0.16229109466075897,
-0.7797154188156128,
-0.5447096228599548,
0.04931449145078659,
-0.14841285347938538,
-0.6537812352180481,
0.5097301006317139,
-0.18564936518669128,
-0.38745027780532837,
0.6525062918663025,
-0.4295942783355713,
-0.3578261435031891,
0.28718867897987366,
0.3412390947341919,
0.061203572899103165,
-0.2814425230026245,
0.6587735414505005,
0.12509866058826447,
-0.013466288335621357,
0.10360895842313766,
-0.0705774649977684,
0.07129710167646408,
0.005862059071660042,
-0.6976634860038757,
0.5047760009765625,
0.5353456139564514,
0.31255030632019043,
-0.35214656591415405,
0.6912480592727661,
0.3776828646659851,
-0.6265659332275391,
-0.253084272146225,
-0.7378478646278381,
0.19846706092357635,
-0.42805516719818115,
0.1850476861000061,
-0.5674586892127991,
-0.5981495976448059,
0.7661722302436829,
-0.1943664252758026,
0.0022708787582814693,
0.42230352759361267,
0.6866952776908875,
-0.04555146023631096,
0.6001651287078857,
0.1422523856163025,
0.4356244206428528,
0.04459000378847122,
0.13957799971103668,
0.465283066034317,
-0.5504593253135681,
-0.5200062990188599,
-0.5773820281028748,
-0.27362295985221863,
-0.7171247005462646,
-0.612872302532196,
0.024551287293434143,
0.44102543592453003,
-0.032165009528398514,
0.27021676301956177,
-0.4114919602870941,
0.7532168030738831,
0.6299747824668884,
-0.12735217809677124,
0.3729550242424011,
-0.409205824136734,
-0.08111913502216339,
0.38060230016708374,
-0.18445533514022827,
-0.6865723133087158,
0.9281728267669678,
0.03269657865166664,
0.5689890384674072,
0.388552725315094,
0.703650176525116,
0.23612569272518158,
0.3539292812347412,
-0.5397152304649353,
0.3966044783592224,
0.06864242255687714,
-1.0980099439620972,
-0.26477810740470886,
-0.38058820366859436,
-0.9835074543952942,
0.47717222571372986,
-0.31538915634155273,
-0.9208452701568604,
0.08823952078819275,
-0.17281801998615265,
-0.3165592849254608,
0.2568891942501068,
-0.8104644417762756,
1.1241016387939453,
-0.2436205893754959,
-0.3462054133415222,
0.08899185806512833,
-0.6212791800498962,
0.20807810127735138,
-0.26054733991622925,
0.2073885202407837,
-0.46660229563713074,
-0.26940611004829407,
0.37893640995025635,
-0.25358593463897705,
0.03297543525695801,
0.028161827474832535,
-0.0062567973509430885,
0.4915667772293091,
-0.00653128931298852,
0.11054850369691849,
0.2752171456813812,
-0.12708169221878052,
0.0683382898569107,
0.14443287253379822,
-0.2826586365699768,
-0.7465435266494751,
1.0932400226593018,
-0.6456080675125122,
-0.8764647245407104,
-0.13740287721157074,
-0.43998095393180847,
-0.4551349878311157,
0.46952295303344727,
0.2824147045612335,
0.08013831079006195,
-0.22776281833648682,
0.0047257812693715096,
0.6805736422538757,
0.0786951333284378,
0.16062304377555847,
0.9419794678688049,
-0.029755782335996628,
0.056979697197675705,
0.5315093398094177,
0.5539436340332031,
-0.1487942337989807,
0.34036076068878174,
-0.17792394757270813,
-0.25522661209106445,
-0.40272578597068787,
-0.6418361663818359,
0.17846353352069855,
-1.1224048137664795,
-0.15729300677776337,
-0.813064694404602,
-0.24519476294517517,
-0.37578582763671875,
-0.16508300602436066,
-0.34462541341781616,
-0.2082870602607727,
-0.22642670571804047,
-0.06128566712141037,
-0.16722989082336426,
0.6864239573478699,
0.12359762191772461,
-0.048740413039922714,
-0.8465397953987122,
0.48180800676345825,
0.3906971514225006,
0.4241940677165985,
-0.147295743227005,
-0.13266243040561676,
-0.015379375778138638,
0.03187865391373634,
-0.4607909917831421,
-1.5228718519210815,
-0.2516419291496277,
0.023931846022605896,
0.9227977991104126,
0.27194744348526,
0.15934979915618896,
0.6039651036262512,
-0.630835771560669,
0.44654980301856995,
0.15388840436935425,
-0.7091000080108643,
0.5894396305084229,
-0.09384738653898239,
0.28377971053123474,
0.5537213087081909,
0.8258497714996338,
-0.6728523373603821,
-0.732525646686554,
-0.858156144618988,
-0.9537093043327332,
0.6490569710731506,
0.21879959106445312,
-0.13402459025382996,
-0.11575711518526077,
0.4340808093547821,
0.1321277916431427,
0.42328813672065735,
-0.6204939484596252,
-0.4692278504371643,
0.1513693779706955,
-0.08203918486833572,
0.0704856812953949,
-0.12439169734716415,
-0.4758203327655792,
0.1261516660451889,
0.8067910075187683,
0.10631927102804184,
-0.10524220764636993,
0.16127541661262512,
-0.18878360092639923,
-0.2516328692436218,
0.5158187747001648,
0.3302173316478729,
0.7467504739761353,
-0.021826336160302162,
0.6022633910179138,
0.27248087525367737,
-0.04960573464632034,
0.08090528100728989,
0.34139880537986755,
0.018567297607660294,
0.2238745093345642,
0.27993613481521606,
0.5952717065811157,
0.3399118483066559,
-0.6307371854782104,
0.5027454495429993,
-0.13794225454330444,
-0.08522926270961761,
-0.4821323752403259,
0.3061167895793915,
0.49316731095314026,
0.41971737146377563,
0.3532388210296631,
0.21048717200756073,
0.11406359076499939,
-0.6266752481460571,
0.10756127536296844,
0.22241425514221191,
-0.18015459179878235,
0.0038081735838204622,
0.624838650226593,
0.23508194088935852,
-0.4941938519477844,
0.595163106918335,
-0.41338834166526794,
-0.3874830901622772,
0.652164876461029,
0.06696043908596039,
0.48268359899520874,
-0.14786137640476227,
0.09979956597089767,
0.2270728200674057,
0.3654480576515198,
0.09539243578910828,
0.04626015946269035,
-0.32510727643966675,
-0.7110680341720581,
0.22967372834682465,
-0.46248701214790344,
-0.5966836810112,
-0.10776485502719879,
-0.5980024337768555,
0.4660285413265228,
-0.2354964017868042,
-0.2544504702091217,
0.695438027381897,
0.000779976136982441,
-0.7597089409828186,
0.29261717200279236,
0.34976235032081604,
0.9253584146499634,
-0.8929805159568787,
0.741289496421814,
1.0657798051834106,
-0.6725636720657349,
-0.8602526783943176,
0.10220968723297119,
0.11059091240167618,
-0.5508265495300293,
0.5823692679405212,
0.08711837232112885,
-0.0994415357708931,
-0.11286287754774094,
-0.25492966175079346,
-0.8268120288848877,
1.0120474100112915,
0.40498095750808716,
-0.31092503666877747,
-0.28177598118782043,
0.04535912722349167,
0.6001413464546204,
-0.29503899812698364,
0.5362104773521423,
0.4389740526676178,
0.49311479926109314,
0.28567105531692505,
-0.9310428500175476,
-0.12167264521121979,
-0.2594664990901947,
-0.39845967292785645,
0.25891807675361633,
-0.50825035572052,
0.897209644317627,
-0.3450511693954468,
-0.28922581672668457,
-0.051729265600442886,
0.47955578565597534,
0.2047479897737503,
0.6154108643531799,
0.49243465065956116,
0.6549866199493408,
1.268513798713684,
-0.35152146220207214,
0.7926086783409119,
-0.09177393466234207,
0.6116080284118652,
1.3830502033233643,
-0.162875235080719,
0.7660166025161743,
0.6735956072807312,
-0.31949079036712646,
0.6166256070137024,
0.8169510364532471,
-0.3465685248374939,
0.38734474778175354,
0.4357914924621582,
-0.3070482909679413,
-0.44111955165863037,
-0.03808942437171936,
-0.440777063369751,
0.4547381103038788,
0.2600363790988922,
-0.2944197356700897,
-0.4964790642261505,
-0.23951496183872223,
0.09658247977495193,
-0.04092184081673622,
-0.09810706973075867,
0.536553680896759,
-0.014918851666152477,
-1.141948938369751,
0.18981537222862244,
0.17941980063915253,
0.07309553027153015,
-0.5411367416381836,
0.148130863904953,
-0.11122207343578339,
0.15592506527900696,
-0.3060399889945984,
-1.2155126333236694,
0.2664134204387665,
0.024755073711276054,
-0.4897465705871582,
-0.18301692605018616,
0.5865468382835388,
-0.608603835105896,
-0.3002307713031769,
0.45186635851860046,
0.6940922737121582,
0.37926992774009705,
0.06522498279809952,
-0.7478690147399902,
-0.25722888112068176,
-0.15922527015209198,
-0.22231285274028778,
0.006752866320312023,
0.9379894137382507,
-0.014627527445554733,
0.8585938215255737,
0.32056286931037903,
-0.04165927320718765,
0.5047003626823425,
-0.13895472884178162,
0.6504446864128113,
-0.3941448926925659,
-0.4212431311607361,
-0.6711471080780029,
0.2610199749469757,
-0.31830117106437683,
-0.4741511344909668,
0.9036760330200195,
0.5915998816490173,
1.168640375137329,
0.010916410014033318,
0.5272597074508667,
-0.18040378391742706,
0.7376413345336914,
-0.3754791021347046,
0.5655186772346497,
-0.9425008296966553,
0.5156218409538269,
-0.1390407234430313,
-0.8205845952033997,
0.07709712535142899,
0.4347324073314667,
-0.27760666608810425,
0.08915464580059052,
0.8531543016433716,
0.4895203411579132,
-0.3053785562515259,
0.10512924939393997,
0.2401367574930191,
0.16669771075248718,
0.16154064238071442,
0.42404332756996155,
0.9408944845199585,
-0.4704654812812805,
0.8589255213737488,
-0.15731148421764374,
0.2423761785030365,
-0.19900520145893097,
-0.699758768081665,
-0.6120783686637878,
-0.5680856704711914,
-0.6864216923713684,
-0.32753637433052063,
0.1348925083875656,
0.5414789915084839,
0.5035492777824402,
-0.7205844521522522,
0.14390051364898682,
0.04047146812081337,
0.5692969560623169,
0.17924261093139648,
-0.15389853715896606,
0.14719726145267487,
-0.11282958835363388,
-0.8734320998191833,
0.24868187308311462,
0.349683552980423,
0.01772097684442997,
-0.20390932261943817,
-0.1057133674621582,
-0.5229564905166626,
0.1344195008277893,
-0.20114709436893463,
0.24794460833072662,
-0.9561114311218262,
-0.41580235958099365,
-0.12010237574577332,
-0.412494421005249,
-0.026294434443116188,
0.7961797118186951,
-0.561025857925415,
0.8131173849105835,
0.5055978298187256,
0.5329669713973999,
0.2937058210372925,
0.23201750218868256,
0.1242278441786766,
-0.7690605521202087,
-0.17267361283302307,
0.12307292222976685,
0.49283117055892944,
0.41223254799842834,
-0.23460566997528076,
0.5012786388397217,
0.34922534227371216,
-0.45799633860588074,
-0.7803280353546143,
0.21955589950084686,
-0.8891712427139282,
-0.5504180192947388,
1.007788062095642,
-0.5634881258010864,
0.07333812117576599,
-0.14184531569480896,
0.09925559908151627,
0.3920777142047882,
-0.15252290666103363,
0.7879847288131714,
1.1581138372421265,
-0.1463974267244339,
-0.030394291505217552,
-0.5438488125801086,
0.09936527162790298,
0.25467243790626526,
-0.9042876958847046,
-0.13822036981582642,
0.3901813328266144,
0.4115954637527466,
0.5594407916069031,
0.7202497720718384,
0.11127942055463791,
0.3308666944503784,
0.3417503833770752,
-0.20665782690048218,
0.08506511896848679,
-0.22187946736812592,
0.32420292496681213,
0.3584243357181549,
0.07553057372570038,
-0.05309402197599411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12444v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12444v1
|
mOthello: When Do Cross-Lingual Representation Alignment and Cross-Lingual Transfer Emerge in Multilingual Models?
| 2024-04-18T18:03:08 | 2024-04-18T18:03:08 |
Tianze Hua, Tian Yun, Ellie Pavlick
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Many pretrained multilingual models exhibit cross-lingual transfer ability,
which is often attributed to a learned language-neutral representation during
pretraining. However, it remains unclear what factors contribute to the
learning of a language-neutral representation, and whether the learned
language-neutral representation suffices to facilitate cross-lingual transfer.
We propose a synthetic task, Multilingual Othello (mOthello), as a testbed to
delve into these two questions. We find that: (1) models trained with naive
multilingual pretraining fail to learn a language-neutral representation across
all input languages; (2) the introduction of "anchor tokens" (i.e., lexical
items that are identical across languages) helps cross-lingual representation
alignment; and (3) the learning of a language-neutral representation alone is
not sufficient to facilitate cross-lingual transfer. Based on our findings, we
propose a novel approach - multilingual pretraining with unified output space -
that both induces the learning of language-neutral representation and
facilitates cross-lingual transfer.
|
[
-0.365023672580719,
-0.08998876810073853,
0.2872227430343628,
0.24150602519512177,
-0.1825506091117859,
0.05965332314372063,
-0.25331956148147583,
-0.7839038968086243,
0.46167391538619995,
0.07645555585622787,
-0.7674703598022461,
-0.014924231916666031,
-0.46223002672195435,
0.23279155790805817,
-0.1920279860496521,
1.0920196771621704,
-0.1300601065158844,
0.316814661026001,
0.03565637394785881,
-0.35691216588020325,
-0.6280945539474487,
-0.39421185851097107,
-0.39345547556877136,
-0.2817888557910919,
0.8527132868766785,
0.4534861147403717,
0.3740237355232239,
0.5776664018630981,
0.05345044285058975,
0.35452359914779663,
0.6277464032173157,
-0.07659472525119781,
-0.47414788603782654,
-0.07588592171669006,
-0.49682703614234924,
-0.7085229158401489,
-0.3642631769180298,
-0.051356200128793716,
0.6953905820846558,
1.1231331825256348,
0.18720825016498566,
0.013955829665064812,
0.18600259721279144,
0.22531290352344513,
-0.7768388986587524,
0.1351732611656189,
-0.6867762804031372,
0.2591446042060852,
-0.3401445150375366,
-0.027813095599412918,
-0.41619136929512024,
-0.09282207489013672,
-0.058586396276950836,
-1.0241649150848389,
-0.06370951235294342,
-0.058277472853660583,
0.5944699048995972,
-0.11657102406024933,
-0.693872332572937,
-0.12868738174438477,
-0.5820629596710205,
0.7929977178573608,
-0.5032377243041992,
0.5904768705368042,
-0.07571454346179962,
0.3103521466255188,
0.38927873969078064,
-0.5401782393455505,
-0.473883718252182,
-0.13239158689975739,
-0.14982466399669647,
0.24841472506523132,
0.06918562948703766,
-0.0968155786395073,
0.07338834553956985,
0.03829045966267586,
-0.6186187863349915,
0.23735474050045013,
-0.7276567816734314,
-0.3789682984352112,
0.4572871923446655,
-0.19764859974384308,
0.6478675603866577,
0.04609313979744911,
-0.6474825739860535,
-0.04031909257173538,
-0.6573925018310547,
-0.03799859434366226,
0.41387924551963806,
0.5843887329101562,
-0.19419299066066742,
0.4702923893928528,
0.24770736694335938,
0.5097317695617676,
0.056001655757427216,
0.19974978268146515,
0.13912619650363922,
-0.2589593827724457,
0.1572512984275818,
0.4839573800563812,
0.8283696174621582,
0.20468135178089142,
0.6782765984535217,
-0.5104745030403137,
0.028540510684251785,
0.3687376081943512,
0.34127017855644226,
-0.5768756866455078,
-0.012832165695726871,
-0.2659793496131897,
-0.07953277975320816,
-0.17900806665420532,
0.34806451201438904,
-0.7996577620506287,
-0.026925701647996902,
-0.46567562222480774,
0.602182924747467,
-0.24806465208530426,
-0.5346651673316956,
-0.053526461124420166,
-0.06629621237516403,
0.03139596804976463,
0.07345747202634811,
-1.1688802242279053,
0.2669544816017151,
0.4221187233924866,
0.5112031102180481,
-0.6403830051422119,
-0.9243922829627991,
-0.5307607650756836,
0.36667370796203613,
-0.6572629809379578,
0.519105851650238,
-0.37430766224861145,
-0.0997215062379837,
0.3534052073955536,
0.36515694856643677,
-0.4954650104045868,
-0.2134186029434204,
-0.07968639582395554,
-0.4111371636390686,
0.39903563261032104,
-0.38157498836517334,
-0.27201706171035767,
-0.37215951085090637,
0.07262244075536728,
-0.8663341999053955,
0.6083840727806091,
0.02074768953025341,
-0.6178127527236938,
0.2338576465845108,
-0.4375552237033844,
-0.6241014003753662,
-0.3727538287639618,
-0.316879540681839,
0.2247384488582611,
0.3426034450531006,
0.043456483632326126,
0.15420104563236237,
-0.1256864070892334,
0.14898885786533356,
-0.4497112035751343,
-0.4042632281780243,
0.33296820521354675,
-0.3747555613517761,
1.0302989482879639,
-0.04663785174489021,
-0.6198431849479675,
-0.025871621444821358,
-0.6413201689720154,
-0.024613408371806145,
-0.03135262802243233,
-0.020952044054865837,
-0.3019987940788269,
-0.46996843814849854,
0.16227512061595917,
0.30948108434677124,
0.45208096504211426,
-0.6516163349151611,
0.2888113856315613,
-0.40900883078575134,
0.15006886422634125,
0.7786648869514465,
-0.37594833970069885,
0.8473288416862488,
-0.258284330368042,
0.8091168999671936,
0.19812420010566711,
-0.06306599825620651,
-0.22694168984889984,
-0.396685391664505,
-0.9172077178955078,
0.11247217655181885,
0.47422853112220764,
0.6168198585510254,
-0.9153585433959961,
-0.09346385300159454,
-0.34719452261924744,
-0.24135755002498627,
-0.6155012249946594,
0.1785486340522766,
0.5956776738166809,
0.32024601101875305,
0.3303588032722473,
-0.20137637853622437,
-0.7128261923789978,
-0.8707844614982605,
-0.4261658489704132,
-0.08396092057228088,
0.4318119287490845,
-0.3939453959465027,
0.28094425797462463,
-0.322883278131485,
0.6529357433319092,
-0.12549081444740295,
-0.3364383280277252,
-0.33309221267700195,
0.47568565607070923,
0.106293685734272,
0.928602933883667,
0.9081125259399414,
-0.6755782961845398,
-0.5557501316070557,
0.5625706315040588,
-0.6691570281982422,
-0.217173233628273,
-0.14399585127830505,
-0.2834351062774658,
0.2680411636829376,
0.7112880349159241,
-0.45868754386901855,
0.11561226844787598,
0.8919369578361511,
0.011270449496805668,
0.511265754699707,
-0.2706039547920227,
0.24691621959209442,
-1.2170069217681885,
0.35491541028022766,
-0.5325388312339783,
-0.172296404838562,
-0.7101603150367737,
-0.02801627479493618,
0.17791065573692322,
-0.21626444160938263,
-0.6274426579475403,
0.8813357353210449,
-0.6453582644462585,
-0.28796014189720154,
-0.16737587749958038,
0.06730718165636063,
0.13447162508964539,
0.891628623008728,
0.05478128045797348,
0.6574061512947083,
0.6492962837219238,
-0.3837031424045563,
-0.02679525502026081,
-0.14743296802043915,
0.0059415362775325775,
0.5723679065704346,
-0.49675965309143066,
0.263468474149704,
0.04081592708826065,
-0.21107591688632965,
-1.2624582052230835,
-0.12908989191055298,
0.30696913599967957,
-0.37990638613700867,
0.6052454113960266,
-0.1629566103219986,
-0.09740518778562546,
0.021991781890392303,
-0.07737048715353012,
1.0689815282821655,
0.16558516025543213,
-0.5681381225585938,
0.47338151931762695,
0.3550499975681305,
-0.08569846302270889,
-0.635466992855072,
-1.046898603439331,
-0.23971760272979736,
-0.22676797211170197,
-0.24784690141677856,
0.48419684171676636,
0.05753682926297188,
0.19177807867527008,
0.12231656908988953,
-0.20711031556129456,
-0.2106015682220459,
-0.1563519388437271,
-0.1252032220363617,
0.37858226895332336,
-0.43903422355651855,
-0.0803103968501091,
0.17223535478115082,
-0.2974339723587036,
0.0636756643652916,
-0.6176938414573669,
0.30631357431411743,
0.10098186135292053,
-0.6777438521385193,
-0.2774663269519806,
0.5778356194496155,
0.785542905330658,
-0.4241001307964325,
0.4585627019405365,
0.8506967425346375,
-0.43642133474349976,
-0.10879071801900864,
-0.3704512417316437,
-0.0959763154387474,
-0.4509275257587433,
0.4129822254180908,
-0.4469340741634369,
-0.5799061059951782,
0.7415443658828735,
0.007830086164176464,
0.22894641757011414,
0.5542972087860107,
0.1817220002412796,
0.006052443757653236,
1.1509311199188232,
0.8142030835151672,
-0.013992729596793652,
0.4880022406578064,
-0.23864874243736267,
0.14913754165172577,
-0.6515227556228638,
-0.3262028396129608,
-0.6760461926460266,
-0.4371347725391388,
-0.7131341695785522,
-0.425566166639328,
0.18868960440158844,
0.16036257147789001,
-0.19998514652252197,
0.5728214979171753,
-0.05306905880570412,
0.230679452419281,
0.4261670708656311,
-0.29062068462371826,
0.2550888955593109,
0.1302117258310318,
-0.6522823572158813,
-0.3999001085758209,
-0.9768121838569641,
-0.06858501583337784,
0.9002100825309753,
-0.1588241010904312,
0.756912350654602,
0.13665737211704254,
0.7118905782699585,
-0.10552295297384262,
0.47327470779418945,
-0.4912486672401428,
0.2997085452079773,
-0.37161484360694885,
-0.7084294557571411,
-0.05628903582692146,
-0.4690990746021271,
-1.1682627201080322,
0.4959964156150818,
-0.10157288610935211,
-0.8913843035697937,
0.6269240379333496,
0.07099809497594833,
-0.030485257506370544,
0.325992226600647,
-0.7359198331832886,
1.3143333196640015,
-0.5939504504203796,
-0.42626792192459106,
-0.013844717293977737,
-0.5816773772239685,
0.3999040126800537,
-0.215947687625885,
0.5209147930145264,
0.185031458735466,
-0.17731767892837524,
0.732686460018158,
-0.13136906921863556,
0.8552828431129456,
0.041535936295986176,
-0.3333681523799896,
-0.06183810904622078,
0.45436331629753113,
0.1406293511390686,
0.02099384181201458,
0.05049210041761398,
0.22914129495620728,
0.09510768204927444,
-0.3118441104888916,
-0.8835026025772095,
0.5968163013458252,
-0.891512930393219,
-0.4315301775932312,
-0.44414639472961426,
-0.5739285349845886,
-0.493590772151947,
0.4960414171218872,
0.5844188332557678,
0.5184575915336609,
-0.34498587250709534,
0.01577862538397312,
0.18660615384578705,
0.024608710780739784,
0.4226449131965637,
0.3474171757698059,
-0.5864174962043762,
-0.582459032535553,
1.0737594366073608,
0.23225662112236023,
0.41627785563468933,
0.5622719526290894,
0.0003506122448015958,
-0.5313193202018738,
-0.056929875165224075,
-0.6641326546669006,
0.37743112444877625,
-0.686403751373291,
-0.013303915038704872,
-0.3925454318523407,
-0.11326418817043304,
-0.501794159412384,
-0.3532140552997589,
-0.6259784698486328,
-0.5846073031425476,
-0.3978932201862335,
-0.04947725310921669,
-0.27149513363838196,
0.7114478349685669,
-0.45089656114578247,
0.009180684573948383,
-0.9234313368797302,
0.3896177113056183,
0.5040184259414673,
-0.0037504618521779776,
0.14193770289421082,
-0.4278427064418793,
-0.42425447702407837,
0.40907368063926697,
-0.033431921154260635,
-1.042070984840393,
0.17659129202365875,
0.3515896797180176,
0.8213520646095276,
0.7477579712867737,
0.02063036896288395,
1.0054490566253662,
-0.658250629901886,
0.4410666525363922,
0.7077047824859619,
-1.0427156686782837,
0.19429929554462433,
-0.3931027948856354,
0.4685758352279663,
0.7501809000968933,
0.6641215085983276,
-0.5783075094223022,
-0.27930358052253723,
-0.4346362352371216,
-0.5239867568016052,
0.9084155559539795,
-0.07058735191822052,
0.24660584330558777,
0.06058212369680405,
-0.1498444527387619,
0.3552972078323364,
0.3944874405860901,
-1.0851653814315796,
0.1003393679857254,
-0.4406047761440277,
-0.10307203978300095,
-0.38488397002220154,
0.08510066568851471,
-0.045266177505254745,
-0.2925378680229187,
0.3068884015083313,
-0.25234928727149963,
0.19586455821990967,
0.008035263046622276,
-0.43616965413093567,
-0.2889861464500427,
0.01587791182100773,
0.4126984179019928,
0.6647101640701294,
0.24553795158863068,
0.4092625677585602,
0.03239315748214722,
-0.22907911241054535,
0.44014114141464233,
-0.07554410398006439,
0.08503741025924683,
0.29515519738197327,
0.7862337827682495,
0.9490002393722534,
0.9164648652076721,
-0.4284352958202362,
0.3744325339794159,
0.2736890912055969,
-0.1314508020877838,
-0.060424551367759705,
-0.03140288218855858,
0.080165334045887,
-0.002931352239102125,
0.1975891888141632,
0.17176245152950287,
-0.05283256620168686,
-1.029535174369812,
0.08557283878326416,
0.25653594732284546,
-0.3591882884502411,
-0.6728407144546509,
0.7646915316581726,
0.04130200296640396,
-0.11520593613386154,
0.5950717926025391,
-0.006084787659347057,
-0.7736045718193054,
0.5490613579750061,
0.793342113494873,
0.8793473839759827,
-0.585004985332489,
0.26201868057250977,
0.46214836835861206,
0.37078264355659485,
0.03925744816660881,
0.13157792389392853,
-0.2244981825351715,
-0.8764384984970093,
-0.3553755283355713,
-0.39296475052833557,
0.01521366648375988,
-0.26433855295181274,
-0.9325831532478333,
0.20455001294612885,
0.026923250406980515,
-0.026765450835227966,
-0.3379441797733307,
-0.19259223341941833,
-0.7130899429321289,
-0.04575403779745102,
0.18677547574043274,
0.6332098245620728,
-0.9945783019065857,
0.8603269457817078,
0.8041514754295349,
-0.30338364839553833,
-0.903984785079956,
-0.0395190604031086,
-0.1196485236287117,
-0.7684038877487183,
0.7743907570838928,
0.41969266533851624,
-0.11663222312927246,
0.13972266018390656,
0.05691128224134445,
-0.8195746541023254,
0.6892858743667603,
0.8838948011398315,
-0.5448430776596069,
-0.25461140275001526,
0.565780520439148,
0.4535374045372009,
-0.4995329678058624,
0.05049969628453255,
0.015275530517101288,
0.6874641180038452,
-0.007617862429469824,
-1.018370270729065,
0.03206703066825867,
-0.3795788288116455,
0.11679624766111374,
-0.06001921743154526,
-0.3046673834323883,
1.1124192476272583,
-0.05428404361009598,
-0.38587281107902527,
0.11852003633975983,
0.5363188982009888,
0.15652360022068024,
0.013157786801457405,
0.45251327753067017,
0.5108203291893005,
0.46748048067092896,
-0.04203313961625099,
0.8616538643836975,
-0.2865867018699646,
0.15488021075725555,
1.0148074626922607,
-0.3716683089733124,
0.7493377923965454,
0.7402035593986511,
0.0714862272143364,
0.5484708547592163,
0.4269115924835205,
0.37378445267677307,
0.6555640697479248,
0.007467030547559261,
0.12497013062238693,
-0.26589736342430115,
-0.05579614266753197,
-0.6337427496910095,
0.534546971321106,
0.055549293756484985,
0.11995460093021393,
-0.4902069568634033,
0.45022815465927124,
-0.14136019349098206,
-0.06812427192926407,
-0.2987605035305023,
0.6540704369544983,
0.21884463727474213,
-1.1224889755249023,
0.7695764303207397,
-0.27377066016197205,
0.5301159620285034,
-0.8849284648895264,
-0.021768713369965553,
-0.29260900616645813,
0.2331598550081253,
-0.09957273304462433,
-0.30229467153549194,
0.45302727818489075,
-0.2568771541118622,
0.01415978092700243,
-0.5284957885742188,
0.45083922147750854,
-0.8930941224098206,
-0.6231255531311035,
0.7765379548072815,
0.6711220145225525,
-0.012186367064714432,
0.16039063036441803,
-0.5077522993087769,
0.1527700275182724,
0.050934236496686935,
0.16890746355056763,
0.3992897570133209,
0.8251415491104126,
-0.17971399426460266,
0.07687639445066452,
0.7310333847999573,
0.294242262840271,
0.4964415431022644,
0.08614012598991394,
0.6031622886657715,
-0.2721104919910431,
-0.7703726887702942,
-0.5519851446151733,
0.6508337259292603,
0.2318972945213318,
-0.38034775853157043,
0.7543747425079346,
0.37696030735969543,
1.2546597719192505,
-0.40000757575035095,
0.5214422941207886,
0.02196035161614418,
-0.04956705868244171,
-0.7430732846260071,
0.7974295616149902,
-1.0837767124176025,
-0.2809675335884094,
-0.30195194482803345,
-1.0626927614212036,
-0.03348977118730545,
0.7671000361442566,
-0.0355236791074276,
0.13339008390903473,
0.9007428884506226,
0.7425262331962585,
-0.4359048306941986,
-0.2176642119884491,
0.39800670742988586,
0.10251584649085999,
-0.11830033361911774,
0.7729132175445557,
0.9946374297142029,
-0.48062318563461304,
0.53145831823349,
-0.20971769094467163,
0.043935056775808334,
-0.11429736018180847,
-0.9032260775566101,
-0.8586010932922363,
-0.8427144885063171,
-0.1784840226173401,
0.03535262122750282,
0.11179427057504654,
0.641031801700592,
0.8918324708938599,
-0.9707388281822205,
-0.7592560648918152,
-0.2646942436695099,
0.05584994703531265,
-0.303571879863739,
-0.15851999819278717,
0.09331724047660828,
-0.7315146327018738,
-0.9561002850532532,
0.38788551092147827,
0.1161295622587204,
0.09667109698057175,
-0.48844388127326965,
-0.13600562512874603,
-0.3864590525627136,
-0.28382715582847595,
0.22193698585033417,
0.5572832822799683,
-0.39005666971206665,
-0.023881496861577034,
0.11161715537309647,
-0.15720604360103607,
-0.005266936030238867,
1.082525372505188,
-0.5348042845726013,
0.4645135700702667,
0.5258511304855347,
0.7921898365020752,
0.46137121319770813,
-0.44095945358276367,
1.0636999607086182,
-0.8220707178115845,
0.6395424008369446,
0.11934548616409302,
0.5324962139129639,
0.19032195210456848,
-0.06380929797887802,
0.1515575647354126,
0.38536375761032104,
0.07638198137283325,
-0.7891765236854553,
0.11583276093006134,
-0.8064725995063782,
-0.433881014585495,
0.861678421497345,
-0.1535371094942093,
-0.2513033151626587,
0.08080220967531204,
-0.04928691312670708,
0.5534347295761108,
0.18339216709136963,
0.6025625467300415,
0.6612748503684998,
0.382777601480484,
-0.15033265948295593,
-0.4793030321598053,
0.2784101068973541,
0.5100014805793762,
-0.7093919515609741,
-0.2927655577659607,
0.2255840003490448,
0.1714772880077362,
0.5461058616638184,
0.5202404260635376,
-0.20992511510849,
0.4461888074874878,
-0.14643706381320953,
0.025244103744626045,
-0.014437797479331493,
-0.8204188346862793,
-0.2835344970226288,
0.0793454721570015,
-0.1694263070821762,
-0.4378645122051239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12390v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12390v4
|
BLINK: Multimodal Large Language Models Can See but Not Perceive
| 2024-04-18T17:59:54 | 2024-07-03T08:44:45 |
Xingyu Fu, Yushi Hu, Bangzheng Li, Yu Feng, Haoyu Wang, Xudong Lin, Dan Roth, Noah A. Smith, Wei-Chiu Ma, Ranjay Krishna
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We introduce Blink, a new benchmark for multimodal language models (LLMs)
that focuses on core visual perception abilities not found in other
evaluations. Most of the Blink tasks can be solved by humans "within a blink"
(e.g., relative depth estimation, visual correspondence, forensics detection,
and multi-view reasoning). However, we find these perception-demanding tasks
cast significant challenges for current multimodal LLMs because they resist
mediation through natural language. Blink reformats 14 classic computer vision
tasks into 3,807 multiple-choice questions, paired with single or multiple
images and visual prompting. While humans get 95.70% accuracy on average, Blink
is surprisingly challenging for existing multimodal LLMs: even the
best-performing GPT-4V and Gemini achieve accuracies of 51.26% and 45.72%, only
13.17% and 7.63% higher than random guessing, indicating that such perception
abilities have not "emerged" yet in recent multimodal LLMs. Our analysis also
highlights that specialist CV models could solve these problems much better,
suggesting potential pathways for future improvements. We believe Blink will
stimulate the community to help multimodal LLMs catch up with human-level
visual perception.
|
[
-0.25310686230659485,
-0.6301828026771545,
0.8348528146743774,
0.605626106262207,
-0.07744305580854416,
0.28747454285621643,
-0.19691184163093567,
-0.7839146852493286,
0.1191311627626419,
0.49614599347114563,
-0.5331444144248962,
-0.34507450461387634,
-0.5392765402793884,
0.1956266462802887,
-0.526648223400116,
0.28313755989074707,
0.15730057656764984,
0.08753085136413574,
-0.34394216537475586,
-0.21829326450824738,
-0.4589524567127228,
-0.2750700116157532,
-0.5000141263008118,
0.05317468196153641,
0.5969924926757812,
0.1900084763765335,
0.4734436869621277,
0.04241495579481125,
0.4699784815311432,
0.36119338870048523,
-0.1618371307849884,
0.29887011647224426,
-0.2562083303928375,
0.00481714541092515,
0.07884441316127777,
-0.6696690320968628,
-0.45142504572868347,
0.054394375532865524,
0.8667637705802917,
0.8848438858985901,
0.036292750388383865,
0.1369883120059967,
-0.019000696018338203,
0.8348690867424011,
-0.8778188228607178,
0.22015689313411713,
-0.6950010657310486,
-0.05411728471517563,
-0.3384680449962616,
-0.06840790808200836,
-0.7717108130455017,
-0.04738881438970566,
0.12925653159618378,
-0.5534146428108215,
0.17523393034934998,
0.46153515577316284,
0.5094394087791443,
0.29842305183410645,
-0.7593802213668823,
0.16139161586761475,
-0.5309151411056519,
0.8037611246109009,
-0.39915937185287476,
0.7255101799964905,
-0.009208849631249905,
0.18669801950454712,
-0.18172882497310638,
-0.5133194923400879,
-0.9216944575309753,
-0.4797764718532562,
0.3221709132194519,
0.2728029191493988,
-0.3245602250099182,
0.09933585673570633,
0.4606098234653473,
0.13625524938106537,
-0.6911488771438599,
-0.21109196543693542,
-0.16528868675231934,
-0.3049485385417938,
0.1463080495595932,
0.23891685903072357,
0.2619127035140991,
-0.18871690332889557,
-0.7787531614303589,
-0.174747034907341,
-0.7015582919120789,
0.18278583884239197,
0.1729261726140976,
-0.045071791857481,
-0.07964513450860977,
0.532843828201294,
-0.37420979142189026,
0.8030380010604858,
-0.0544084869325161,
-0.077424556016922,
0.508759617805481,
-0.28464311361312866,
-0.22473837435245514,
-0.5814803838729858,
0.6762591004371643,
0.5031334757804871,
0.1241622045636177,
-0.054659150540828705,
-0.13674215972423553,
0.40498530864715576,
0.28665459156036377,
-0.1566554605960846,
-0.2740369737148285,
0.2114635407924652,
-0.4369375705718994,
-0.20880469679832458,
-0.09933437407016754,
-0.9477387070655823,
-0.6969370245933533,
-0.09741272032260895,
0.6386110782623291,
-0.2544516324996948,
-0.5114994645118713,
0.1896601915359497,
-0.2958521544933319,
0.20268456637859344,
0.7736684679985046,
-0.6700382232666016,
0.034362662583589554,
0.5749012231826782,
0.7940013408660889,
-0.3026775121688843,
-0.6902236938476562,
-0.49421805143356323,
-0.012631374411284924,
-0.4728371500968933,
0.9550843238830566,
-0.6505441665649414,
-0.14464262127876282,
-0.0318208709359169,
0.003082655370235443,
-0.11182501912117004,
-0.7079888582229614,
0.013249027542769909,
-0.3895006477832794,
-0.19797401130199432,
-0.39022523164749146,
-0.22412936389446259,
-0.3116941452026367,
0.5382252335548401,
-0.8587534427642822,
0.8346534967422485,
0.017757941037416458,
-0.6100988388061523,
0.7450303435325623,
-0.35605937242507935,
-0.38955000042915344,
0.1859290897846222,
-0.21045264601707458,
0.09202833473682404,
0.3563542068004608,
0.2446911484003067,
0.37840279936790466,
-0.20080097019672394,
0.010169426910579205,
-0.48944705724716187,
-0.19577932357788086,
0.48624423146247864,
-0.6903136372566223,
0.6309075355529785,
-0.20264318585395813,
-0.32738155126571655,
0.4330276548862457,
-0.8611764311790466,
0.1636844128370285,
-0.12527799606323242,
-0.5405263304710388,
-0.0688854530453682,
0.1923631876707077,
0.42152413725852966,
0.3566995859146118,
0.25724899768829346,
-0.524678111076355,
0.21788597106933594,
-0.24342447519302368,
0.5074009895324707,
0.9325851798057556,
-0.3846699893474579,
0.36867082118988037,
-0.09177059680223465,
0.4562302529811859,
0.38730356097221375,
0.5514468550682068,
-0.4086802303791046,
-0.7840555906295776,
-1.1273386478424072,
-0.3330775201320648,
-0.13108566403388977,
0.5201695561408997,
-1.1626745462417603,
-0.21422609686851501,
-0.16290098428726196,
-0.31995776295661926,
-0.6073641180992126,
0.30803215503692627,
0.6159632205963135,
0.3551972806453705,
0.4389200508594513,
-0.42844101786613464,
-0.3040812909603119,
-0.9589269161224365,
-0.37149888277053833,
-0.32777535915374756,
0.20956839621067047,
0.18377166986465454,
0.5625995397567749,
-0.36696869134902954,
0.6268766522407532,
-0.29573777318000793,
-0.28690236806869507,
-0.3990842401981354,
0.27028948068618774,
-0.02644110471010208,
0.04373006522655487,
0.19622768461704254,
-1.0691921710968018,
-0.38403183221817017,
-0.23038053512573242,
-0.7277663946151733,
0.23625528812408447,
-0.11547113209962845,
0.37667158246040344,
0.3955220580101013,
0.38946324586868286,
-0.4452555179595947,
0.38308632373809814,
0.8710141777992249,
-0.3706936240196228,
0.7146577835083008,
-0.21900421380996704,
0.3983652591705322,
-0.702102780342102,
-0.08061850816011429,
0.09432633966207504,
-0.36531195044517517,
-0.6212634444236755,
0.13145048916339874,
0.46023064851760864,
0.06051285192370415,
-0.7184147834777832,
0.8689520359039307,
-0.7864099144935608,
-0.2320055216550827,
-0.14903369545936584,
0.1444062441587448,
-0.000841282366309315,
0.5875179767608643,
0.045534923672676086,
0.7189517021179199,
0.8936888575553894,
-0.4710657596588135,
0.5694524049758911,
0.04900680109858513,
-0.8094175457954407,
0.8768635392189026,
-0.29747486114501953,
0.023096879944205284,
-0.0040535470470786095,
0.2460995763540268,
-1.1231818199157715,
-0.332561194896698,
0.04321521893143654,
-0.3797297179698944,
0.2391252964735031,
0.11289367079734802,
-0.5985845327377319,
-0.5036699771881104,
-0.3595970571041107,
0.6486515998840332,
0.4035364091396332,
-0.7091886401176453,
0.811295211315155,
0.20399783551692963,
0.32089170813560486,
-0.644010603427887,
-0.5818334221839905,
0.4786232113838196,
0.03806736320257187,
-0.725085437297821,
-0.15499283373355865,
-0.20727072656154633,
-0.2302655428647995,
-0.2880972623825073,
0.04758196324110031,
-0.010521123185753822,
0.04810522124171257,
0.4195343852043152,
0.33348703384399414,
-0.006251013372093439,
0.11432234197854996,
-0.49581223726272583,
-0.2597455382347107,
-0.16703782975673676,
0.03951609507203102,
0.34641748666763306,
-0.3145364224910736,
-0.8356990814208984,
-0.44928818941116333,
0.29636046290397644,
0.6852217316627502,
-0.2392169088125229,
0.35638749599456787,
0.6272191405296326,
-0.13782711327075958,
-0.2544468641281128,
-1.0608094930648804,
-0.04180644452571869,
-0.5074066519737244,
0.5749175548553467,
-0.3691050112247467,
-0.9684903025627136,
0.3291918635368347,
-0.14640045166015625,
-0.24466519057750702,
0.11391880363225937,
0.5561041831970215,
-0.16937881708145142,
1.2818244695663452,
0.9342350363731384,
-0.0232678409665823,
0.46235430240631104,
0.1770598441362381,
0.07188309729099274,
-1.13956618309021,
-0.32957157492637634,
-0.07682646811008453,
-0.4218209683895111,
-0.28143417835235596,
-0.6557190418243408,
0.7008875608444214,
-0.0010712729999795556,
0.27659714221954346,
0.2285068780183792,
-0.29216232895851135,
0.3446768522262573,
0.7052328586578369,
0.2037997543811798,
0.5161486268043518,
-0.32409265637397766,
-0.07683811336755753,
-0.023381492123007774,
-0.4986515939235687,
-0.2967531979084015,
1.0738301277160645,
0.078681081533432,
0.8503563404083252,
0.0970514789223671,
0.3634933531284332,
0.03633614256978035,
0.41215720772743225,
-0.6376498341560364,
0.9133551120758057,
-0.0126741211861372,
-0.788034200668335,
-0.12445124983787537,
-0.3532410264015198,
-0.6811457276344299,
0.5174458026885986,
-0.37707868218421936,
-0.8325141072273254,
0.15239517390727997,
0.412387490272522,
-0.04070651903748512,
0.39512336254119873,
-0.822576642036438,
0.930597186088562,
-0.18760523200035095,
-0.37231624126434326,
-0.244717076420784,
-0.6035172939300537,
0.5277701616287231,
0.039748452603816986,
0.40956249833106995,
-0.25813567638397217,
-0.10148239135742188,
0.4652891755104065,
-0.010512745939195156,
1.1446244716644287,
-0.06746160238981247,
0.033711645752191544,
0.13360264897346497,
0.17759157717227936,
0.33188390731811523,
-0.1719064712524414,
0.34398460388183594,
0.22250868380069733,
0.0627371147274971,
-0.33653801679611206,
-0.546886682510376,
0.46149569749832153,
-0.2311144918203354,
-0.5494259595870972,
-0.5306819081306458,
-0.47418448328971863,
-0.4827427566051483,
0.21866469085216522,
0.2680589556694031,
0.6069083213806152,
-0.1970621943473816,
0.09191793203353882,
0.5664749145507812,
-0.32137253880500793,
0.4721606969833374,
0.6951891779899597,
-0.4235577881336212,
-0.3254437744617462,
1.136062741279602,
-0.20869360864162445,
0.4974525570869446,
0.5450582504272461,
-0.06889856606721878,
-0.3323330581188202,
-0.5651060938835144,
-0.49606120586395264,
0.16152313351631165,
-0.9593762755393982,
0.02553574927151203,
-0.5900610685348511,
0.1974119246006012,
-0.3199473023414612,
-0.02705276384949684,
-0.42046627402305603,
-0.16768059134483337,
-0.16485579311847687,
0.18123391270637512,
0.01901175267994404,
0.8938353657722473,
0.0293800737708807,
-0.06420660763978958,
-0.777868390083313,
0.4837997853755951,
0.5259592533111572,
0.4640550911426544,
0.0757393091917038,
-0.281374990940094,
-0.03863309696316719,
-0.2954770624637604,
-0.3485232889652252,
-0.7010360360145569,
0.268814355134964,
0.0834975391626358,
0.38698118925094604,
0.4616921544075012,
-0.18635450303554535,
0.8764954805374146,
-0.8490103483200073,
0.9247922897338867,
0.6740515232086182,
-0.9257155656814575,
0.34741079807281494,
-0.10382488369941711,
0.5056424736976624,
0.3722999691963196,
0.008642567321658134,
-0.6561556458473206,
-0.7382491827011108,
-0.3357883393764496,
-0.7973598837852478,
0.3458684980869293,
-0.07407334446907043,
0.1402844339609146,
-0.3200744390487671,
0.008188578300178051,
-0.07883387804031372,
0.41508281230926514,
-0.9642640352249146,
-0.11512146890163422,
0.03548483923077583,
-0.09911314398050308,
-0.38027656078338623,
-0.4020887613296509,
-0.057651568204164505,
-0.10274003446102142,
0.06904856860637665,
-0.23228976130485535,
0.31627997756004333,
0.09915193170309067,
-0.2976232171058655,
-0.17009130120277405,
0.3794805407524109,
0.7864789366722107,
0.7610305547714233,
0.051342740654945374,
0.41130486130714417,
0.20224668085575104,
-0.5450747609138489,
-0.028350654989480972,
-0.4452071189880371,
0.031310033053159714,
-0.2292260080575943,
0.8317899703979492,
0.673151969909668,
0.7717252373695374,
-0.973477303981781,
0.8486617803573608,
0.07055883854627609,
-0.19580820202827454,
-0.26287320256233215,
0.0938071608543396,
0.03442932292819023,
0.6604090332984924,
0.46241962909698486,
0.3455480635166168,
0.12287475168704987,
-0.7062133550643921,
-0.006961317732930183,
0.7969667911529541,
-0.5379713773727417,
-0.5783592462539673,
0.8656046390533447,
0.2141474038362503,
-0.1259339153766632,
0.4397638738155365,
-0.09181756526231766,
-0.6454511880874634,
0.35826167464256287,
0.4298557639122009,
0.8706313967704773,
0.03227906674146652,
0.15807995200157166,
0.23423652350902557,
0.41473668813705444,
-0.5144984126091003,
0.4324887990951538,
0.06590496748685837,
-0.8612686395645142,
-0.33001428842544556,
-0.628610372543335,
-0.6559259295463562,
-0.2189931422472,
-0.6029140949249268,
0.08317393064498901,
-0.385447233915329,
-0.19519823789596558,
-0.01986418105661869,
-0.45158180594444275,
-0.7101565599441528,
0.13383780419826508,
0.1354427933692932,
0.992168128490448,
-0.6507292985916138,
0.7458001375198364,
0.5721567273139954,
-0.3779986798763275,
-0.453459769487381,
-0.08295471221208572,
0.3518413007259369,
-0.9493048787117004,
0.8463495969772339,
0.4145071804523468,
-0.299585223197937,
-0.06329561769962311,
-0.7207860946655273,
-0.577735424041748,
0.8439101576805115,
0.24980349838733673,
-0.5615137815475464,
-0.08840769529342651,
-0.1848868727684021,
0.3899363577365875,
-0.08559095114469528,
0.3006967306137085,
0.17462937533855438,
0.6668828725814819,
0.13956066966056824,
-1.160919189453125,
-0.11917169392108917,
-0.13981647789478302,
-0.09685331583023071,
0.19155575335025787,
-0.9135755896568298,
1.0726054906845093,
-0.47246238589286804,
-0.3275652825832367,
0.07768271118402481,
0.4806995987892151,
0.1082758903503418,
0.40474963188171387,
0.7254020571708679,
0.5940369963645935,
0.5714064836502075,
-0.15437431633472443,
1.105621099472046,
-0.040068820118904114,
0.18126365542411804,
0.9115117788314819,
-0.7089951038360596,
1.3633829355239868,
0.7061467170715332,
-0.32979249954223633,
0.35164201259613037,
0.22079439461231232,
0.006573466584086418,
0.38558229804039,
-0.1735420972108841,
-0.46387073397636414,
-0.8346168994903564,
0.30510464310646057,
-0.14033550024032593,
0.42503246665000916,
0.07331269234418869,
0.07217767089605331,
0.05964743718504906,
0.3514860272407532,
-0.563698947429657,
0.011143242940306664,
-0.18499867618083954,
0.7153016328811646,
0.0704461932182312,
-0.5497899651527405,
0.2887992858886719,
-0.3893934488296509,
0.9135699272155762,
-0.3937879502773285,
-0.14963401854038239,
-0.002458242466673255,
0.3296090364456177,
-0.08936280012130737,
-0.7928749322891235,
-0.02217574045062065,
-0.19283346831798553,
-0.32111626863479614,
-0.2950649857521057,
0.4901047646999359,
-0.19511455297470093,
-0.6660473942756653,
0.5652456283569336,
0.4831515848636627,
0.17935600876808167,
-0.44297194480895996,
-0.5687674283981323,
0.34589439630508423,
-0.08326172828674316,
-0.3398980498313904,
0.40170612931251526,
0.3361172378063202,
0.06718381494283676,
1.2464784383773804,
0.6034510135650635,
0.0781574547290802,
0.41748201847076416,
0.00993289053440094,
0.808693528175354,
-0.9121809005737305,
-0.23855236172676086,
-0.7715089917182922,
0.6742573976516724,
0.0838828757405281,
-0.2969440817832947,
0.8758566975593567,
0.41500324010849,
0.8108310699462891,
-0.19479170441627502,
0.5516464114189148,
0.1388830691576004,
0.6117537021636963,
-0.7751907110214233,
0.5697233080863953,
-1.0725544691085815,
0.054515574127435684,
-0.39947712421417236,
-0.7838200330734253,
-0.40113723278045654,
0.5519238114356995,
-0.1870066523551941,
0.058765944093465805,
0.9146627187728882,
0.7742236256599426,
0.0711342841386795,
-0.1945882886648178,
0.8253384232521057,
0.3321206271648407,
0.26818057894706726,
0.8214403986930847,
1.2113709449768066,
-0.18521586060523987,
0.6145363450050354,
0.058322448283433914,
-0.3759672939777374,
-0.30946290493011475,
-0.9026665091514587,
-1.0611804723739624,
-0.8138887286186218,
-0.24757954478263855,
-0.06188012659549713,
-0.2907770574092865,
0.5341789126396179,
0.7827104330062866,
-0.5566440224647522,
-0.021137574687600136,
0.00970421638339758,
0.12320426106452942,
-0.36800116300582886,
-0.20890316367149353,
-0.0371905080974102,
-0.33418044447898865,
-0.5943513512611389,
0.7188501954078674,
0.7945762872695923,
-0.1452694982290268,
-0.6439313888549805,
0.11931125819683075,
-0.15264563262462616,
-0.1752873808145523,
0.8099321126937866,
0.22232715785503387,
-1.3083611726760864,
-0.5448375940322876,
0.14554345607757568,
-0.07784071564674377,
0.25291168689727783,
0.6898318529129028,
-0.878432035446167,
0.8954161405563354,
0.27661773562431335,
0.22420533001422882,
0.3382680416107178,
-0.3044240474700928,
0.2434089630842209,
-0.5147233605384827,
0.3033791184425354,
0.12311150133609772,
0.45617929100990295,
0.31989821791648865,
0.10867094248533249,
0.18556950986385345,
0.39857274293899536,
-0.38830074667930603,
-0.906607985496521,
0.4916045665740967,
-1.3683418035507202,
-0.15390531718730927,
1.1253424882888794,
0.0633726641535759,
-0.3948880732059479,
-0.21302953362464905,
-0.19030891358852386,
-0.31376883387565613,
-0.11643622815608978,
0.6479032635688782,
0.7791043519973755,
-0.13339237868785858,
-0.534471333026886,
-0.9056047201156616,
0.39197078347206116,
0.35668057203292847,
-0.6753218173980713,
0.1067642867565155,
0.5653424263000488,
0.39342164993286133,
0.3092302083969116,
0.9231135249137878,
0.13341763615608215,
0.4397757649421692,
0.13323985040187836,
0.134689062833786,
0.01321982592344284,
-0.6647868156433105,
-0.37386780977249146,
0.26441365480422974,
0.09989100694656372,
-0.00008909640746423975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12387v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12387v1
|
Reka Core, Flash, and Edge: A Series of Powerful Multimodal Language Models
| 2024-04-18T17:59:48 | 2024-04-18T17:59:48 |
Reka Team, Aitor Ormazabal, Che Zheng, Cyprien de Masson d'Autume, Dani Yogatama, Deyu Fu, Donovan Ong, Eric Chen, Eugenie Lamprecht, Hai Pham, Isaac Ong, Kaloyan Aleksiev, Lei Li, Matthew Henderson, Max Bain, Mikel Artetxe, Nishant Relan, Piotr Padlewski, Qi Liu, Ren Chen, Samuel Phua, Yazheng Yang, Yi Tay, Yuqi Wang, Zhongkai Zhu, Zhihui Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
We introduce Reka Core, Flash, and Edge, a series of powerful multimodal
language models trained from scratch by Reka. Reka models are able to process
and reason with text, images, video, and audio inputs. This technical report
discusses details of training some of these models and provides comprehensive
evaluation results. We show that Reka Edge and Reka Flash are not only
state-of-the-art but also outperform many much larger models, delivering
outsized values for their respective compute class. Meanwhile, our most capable
and largest model, Reka Core, approaches the best frontier models on both
automatic evaluations and blind human evaluations. On image question answering
benchmarks (e.g. MMMU, VQAv2), Core performs competitively to GPT4-V.
Meanwhile, on multimodal chat, Core ranks as the second most preferred model
under a blind third-party human evaluation setup, outperforming other models
such as Claude 3 Opus. On text benchmarks, Core not only performs competitively
to other frontier models on a set of well-established benchmarks (e.g. MMLU,
GSM8K) but also outperforms GPT4-0613 on human evaluation. On video question
answering (Perception-Test), Core outperforms Gemini Ultra. Models are shipped
in production at http://chat.reka.ai . A showcase of non cherry picked
qualitative examples can also be found at http://showcase.reka.ai .
|
[
-0.29502981901168823,
-0.9996852874755859,
0.5001919269561768,
0.011038356460630894,
-0.04556940123438835,
0.470427930355072,
-0.34957367181777954,
-0.6214080452919006,
0.005784031003713608,
0.4438987076282501,
-0.6967999339103699,
-0.29440054297447205,
-0.4515661299228668,
-0.041784968227148056,
-0.5636290907859802,
0.6194204092025757,
0.16438491642475128,
0.15712572634220123,
-0.1906418800354004,
-0.28832799196243286,
-0.5468848347663879,
-0.26296356320381165,
-0.5566866397857666,
-0.45779237151145935,
0.37189966440200806,
0.7594018578529358,
1.03639554977417,
0.38134387135505676,
0.3533925712108612,
0.3998786509037018,
0.24256522953510284,
-0.1720602810382843,
-0.0905313491821289,
0.3189087510108948,
-0.043391574174165726,
-0.5213199853897095,
-0.6273486614227295,
-0.045024484395980835,
0.4711799621582031,
0.357782244682312,
0.13098645210266113,
0.21354909241199493,
-0.3820987939834595,
0.7172485589981079,
-0.6363802552223206,
-0.02695171907544136,
-0.4904405176639557,
-0.022980524227023125,
-0.10624682158231735,
0.10697130858898163,
-0.6110777258872986,
0.000615552649833262,
0.24615596234798431,
-0.7352248430252075,
0.06271733343601227,
0.1743706464767456,
0.8976126313209534,
0.10309645533561707,
-0.5905157327651978,
0.009846734814345837,
-0.7048518657684326,
1.024142861366272,
-0.5177581906318665,
0.80351322889328,
0.4313164949417114,
0.7551830410957336,
0.010071746073663235,
-0.8489884734153748,
-0.5438662171363831,
-0.23017218708992004,
0.34001415967941284,
0.13913492858409882,
-0.4135628342628479,
-0.056849099695682526,
-0.01825328916311264,
0.4118199050426483,
-0.5500373244285583,
0.11246320605278015,
-0.25426211953163147,
-0.11483217775821686,
0.569185197353363,
0.321074515581131,
0.3931851387023926,
-0.1662406325340271,
-0.06465820223093033,
-0.22856326401233673,
-0.7327902913093567,
0.13135048747062683,
0.20163652300834656,
-0.03428474813699722,
-0.13016359508037567,
0.4203909933567047,
-0.5803585648536682,
0.8395046591758728,
0.0067143794149160385,
-0.4481582045555115,
0.3733167052268982,
-0.35611748695373535,
-0.3063582181930542,
-0.4374344050884247,
0.7667729258537292,
0.433668315410614,
0.26324746012687683,
-0.08953467756509781,
-0.34692856669425964,
-0.15236958861351013,
0.39996588230133057,
-0.4829697012901306,
-0.25036928057670593,
0.19728796184062958,
-0.7278025150299072,
-0.3255787193775177,
-0.743637204170227,
-0.8287597894668579,
-0.25198090076446533,
-0.3551595211029053,
0.4411934018135071,
-0.4718824625015259,
-0.6913010478019714,
-0.13370376825332642,
0.12939469516277313,
0.2624084949493408,
0.43328720331192017,
-1.0091297626495361,
0.34131476283073425,
0.5628308057785034,
0.6962568759918213,
0.11589358001947403,
-0.40956735610961914,
-0.09758057445287704,
-0.29587361216545105,
-0.17148007452487946,
1.070450782775879,
-0.8905001282691956,
-0.1389194130897522,
0.1737356334924698,
-0.02422690950334072,
0.26507049798965454,
-0.4127548038959503,
0.6650747060775757,
-0.47333264350891113,
0.06244591623544693,
-0.10864982008934021,
-0.28720155358314514,
-0.38207438588142395,
0.4826471507549286,
-0.7854464650154114,
0.7851331830024719,
0.035160474479198456,
-0.6407521963119507,
0.4029410183429718,
-0.5672239661216736,
-0.4990313649177551,
-0.00317753036506474,
-0.202167347073555,
-0.29225635528564453,
0.1835263967514038,
0.42652469873428345,
0.44594043493270874,
-0.6260039806365967,
0.21171920001506805,
-0.3126741647720337,
-0.11700611561536789,
0.4205900728702545,
-0.22210323810577393,
0.36928513646125793,
0.32302913069725037,
-0.3855082392692566,
0.6794106364250183,
-0.8598213791847229,
0.24206966161727905,
0.23989416658878326,
-0.37318217754364014,
0.07387109845876694,
-0.12734046578407288,
0.5492191314697266,
0.29464879631996155,
-0.1277938038110733,
-0.596020519733429,
-0.12210287153720856,
-0.061811190098524094,
0.8064400553703308,
0.5344811081886292,
-0.49889156222343445,
0.44703951478004456,
-0.17715804278850555,
0.5725448131561279,
-0.05357436090707779,
0.36378517746925354,
-0.4525994658470154,
-0.7340646386146545,
-0.914857029914856,
-0.14367258548736572,
0.2895095944404602,
0.5553042888641357,
-1.0104870796203613,
0.027268527075648308,
-0.4146018922328949,
-0.8243545889854431,
-0.648306131362915,
-0.051063958555459976,
0.47704017162323,
0.5406538844108582,
0.09838198870420456,
-0.14323239028453827,
-0.4453730881214142,
-1.465654969215393,
-0.32819437980651855,
-0.12468324601650238,
0.13311685621738434,
0.2796068787574768,
0.5179139375686646,
-0.01918339729309082,
1.0499050617218018,
-0.1926392912864685,
0.0986538901925087,
-0.6715493202209473,
0.30636629462242126,
-0.04886656254529953,
0.3628356158733368,
0.2708798348903656,
-1.0611647367477417,
-0.4286379814147949,
-0.1525418609380722,
-0.6519029140472412,
0.1562487632036209,
-0.09079092741012573,
0.16622871160507202,
0.34235721826553345,
0.23503322899341583,
-0.4427005648612976,
0.2794070243835449,
0.6676509976387024,
-0.25314685702323914,
0.6689856052398682,
-0.014551146887242794,
0.46621832251548767,
-1.2111561298370361,
0.18601274490356445,
0.018334010615944862,
-0.6252656579017639,
-0.8082125186920166,
0.013089546002447605,
0.09334864467382431,
-0.5275777578353882,
-0.6900738477706909,
0.4983723759651184,
-0.5801019668579102,
-0.46615883708000183,
-0.5512236952781677,
0.17114494740962982,
-0.0051689790561795235,
0.6316067576408386,
0.3324270248413086,
0.6646117568016052,
0.9698062539100647,
-0.4205227494239807,
0.7590581774711609,
0.0652126595377922,
-0.7681979537010193,
0.5886302590370178,
-0.7758409976959229,
0.2309853434562683,
0.0802680030465126,
0.29008010029792786,
-0.9927762746810913,
-0.21093130111694336,
0.07712824642658234,
-0.6041386127471924,
0.3060062825679779,
-0.23917777836322784,
-0.6198225617408752,
-0.11409343779087067,
-0.055625755339860916,
0.3550006151199341,
0.5008877515792847,
-0.2699497640132904,
0.9576733112335205,
0.6031423211097717,
-0.029921172186732292,
-0.8560870885848999,
-0.7841567993164062,
0.2928977310657501,
-0.13855406641960144,
-1.0791223049163818,
0.09832637012004852,
0.1496427059173584,
-0.09358226507902145,
0.06622365862131119,
0.1354081779718399,
-0.3703499734401703,
0.24170440435409546,
0.605318546295166,
0.01695229858160019,
-0.16960841417312622,
0.2795867621898651,
-0.15264897048473358,
-0.35487470030784607,
-0.10937422513961792,
0.04464580863714218,
0.47364988923072815,
-0.6860508918762207,
-0.3255108594894409,
-0.5221899151802063,
0.47410324215888977,
0.63278728723526,
-0.281642884016037,
0.5729166269302368,
0.756698727607727,
-0.529366135597229,
0.20829768478870392,
-0.809566855430603,
-0.2727499008178711,
-0.44229856133461,
0.5694785118103027,
-0.7150655388832092,
-1.0393404960632324,
0.6525947451591492,
0.04172374680638313,
0.38567018508911133,
0.378170371055603,
0.6949483156204224,
0.049097105860710144,
0.9899047613143921,
0.8202428221702576,
0.2432895302772522,
0.654859185218811,
-0.03305654600262642,
0.16630157828330994,
-0.6822004914283752,
-0.24837692081928253,
-0.20448437333106995,
-0.46781888604164124,
-0.22449243068695068,
-0.14309062063694,
0.0994030088186264,
-0.1790742576122284,
-0.005537124350667,
0.3871554732322693,
-0.17710725963115692,
0.508672297000885,
0.5617384910583496,
-0.06383942812681198,
0.3265458345413208,
0.011652443557977676,
0.06262341141700745,
-0.16485178470611572,
-0.7847059369087219,
-0.5708677768707275,
1.374476671218872,
0.727272629737854,
0.957830548286438,
0.101181760430336,
0.1708889603614807,
0.2535746693611145,
0.491971880197525,
-0.712604820728302,
0.6094815731048584,
0.08653249591588974,
-1.0528777837753296,
-0.10927439481019974,
-0.297659307718277,
-0.7051618695259094,
0.33806684613227844,
-0.6066766381263733,
-0.37051039934158325,
-0.04947159066796303,
0.0929722934961319,
-0.45312950015068054,
0.37585216760635376,
-0.8791950345039368,
1.0227123498916626,
-0.3056165874004364,
-0.30429592728614807,
-0.6468695998191833,
-0.6464084982872009,
0.551484227180481,
0.09429287165403366,
0.2163848876953125,
-0.24105431139469147,
-0.0681256353855133,
0.9170238971710205,
0.1773233264684677,
0.9353030920028687,
0.06898640841245651,
0.21576543152332306,
0.3624385595321655,
0.176308274269104,
0.005360071547329426,
0.1033143475651741,
0.3741089701652527,
0.036013536155223846,
-0.15314112603664398,
-0.3366909623146057,
-0.6872456669807434,
0.7619372010231018,
-0.8960781097412109,
-0.5914407968521118,
-0.1880485713481903,
-0.5142056941986084,
-0.26796987652778625,
0.3249419629573822,
0.186821848154068,
0.740617036819458,
-0.27714312076568604,
0.2678859233856201,
0.534957230091095,
-0.24770087003707886,
0.4399448335170746,
0.5626770257949829,
-0.4822066128253937,
-0.583433210849762,
0.7563539147377014,
-0.13192503154277802,
0.44724544882774353,
0.3862110674381256,
0.04979664832353592,
-0.33680054545402527,
-0.42111432552337646,
-0.8112349510192871,
0.09953891485929489,
-1.173609733581543,
-0.11660424619913101,
-0.9464287161827087,
0.07615363597869873,
-0.5732178688049316,
-0.08885496854782104,
-0.9281826019287109,
-0.6539474129676819,
0.280122309923172,
-0.08531477302312851,
0.2219267040491104,
0.9125629663467407,
0.04943663254380226,
0.47356176376342773,
-0.8687642216682434,
0.05772939696907997,
0.35539010167121887,
0.3013860285282135,
-0.0721280574798584,
-0.45677122473716736,
-0.4158115088939667,
-0.1869707703590393,
-0.3957589268684387,
-0.9694958329200745,
0.12645521759986877,
0.18503041565418243,
0.6810786724090576,
0.23830440640449524,
-0.375942200422287,
0.3271692395210266,
-0.39183923602104187,
0.7175470590591431,
0.2966134250164032,
-1.0333067178726196,
0.5623462200164795,
-0.2777762711048126,
0.4179527163505554,
0.6951092481613159,
0.19952210783958435,
-0.7628829479217529,
-0.14080555737018585,
-0.6885418891906738,
-0.5865918397903442,
0.5793088674545288,
0.17393141984939575,
0.013641138561069965,
0.3552551865577698,
0.22577735781669617,
0.14814415574073792,
0.20699431002140045,
-0.8767480850219727,
-0.2215472161769867,
-0.54873126745224,
-0.032811157405376434,
0.12726958096027374,
-0.4019046127796173,
-0.01922767050564289,
0.10076214373111725,
0.5716365575790405,
-0.1977941244840622,
0.30583393573760986,
0.05503086745738983,
-0.43308743834495544,
-0.036755215376615524,
0.4862450957298279,
0.8995705842971802,
0.9910708069801331,
-0.03466068208217621,
0.2666551172733307,
0.16087695956230164,
-0.42644253373146057,
0.07425075024366379,
-0.4848763942718506,
0.1579904556274414,
-0.07670550793409348,
0.587811291217804,
0.8441279530525208,
0.5751773118972778,
-0.9656755328178406,
0.38528570532798767,
-0.368472158908844,
-0.12094517052173615,
-0.475776344537735,
-0.38398873805999756,
0.17881019413471222,
0.2939627468585968,
0.17081817984580994,
-0.04533565789461136,
0.14320099353790283,
-0.8066710233688354,
0.27438884973526,
0.19448839128017426,
-0.3170720338821411,
-0.6715739965438843,
0.37152424454689026,
0.6307209134101868,
-0.2513154149055481,
0.9203634262084961,
0.04070092737674713,
-0.7718798518180847,
0.26222652196884155,
0.5496589541435242,
0.9981706738471985,
-0.21995940804481506,
0.2212790697813034,
0.4656088650226593,
0.5004992485046387,
0.07104596495628357,
0.366376131772995,
0.0135262506082654,
-0.7286036014556885,
-0.5097029209136963,
-0.1996738314628601,
-0.6470692157745361,
-0.03477500379085541,
-0.3969222903251648,
0.20461420714855194,
-0.6431803703308105,
-0.414840430021286,
-0.04546360671520233,
0.005011065863072872,
-0.5295235514640808,
0.29165026545524597,
0.24412204325199127,
1.039446234703064,
-1.2297769784927368,
1.0612242221832275,
0.9832785725593567,
-0.48067209124565125,
-0.4587797224521637,
-0.5772949457168579,
0.08513256162405014,
-0.7630625367164612,
0.833345353603363,
0.2472783327102661,
-0.11537666618824005,
-0.2685229778289795,
-0.44111692905426025,
-0.9404433369636536,
1.1304570436477661,
0.21191249787807465,
-0.3672623038291931,
0.20558308064937592,
-0.03805679827928543,
0.3312472701072693,
-0.7467849254608154,
0.6975311636924744,
0.5467604398727417,
0.345380038022995,
0.0971604436635971,
-1.0366865396499634,
-0.02952476590871811,
-0.4265890121459961,
-0.21970626711845398,
-0.019857868552207947,
-0.7609402537345886,
0.8766814470291138,
-0.19867193698883057,
-0.40254467725753784,
-0.2287907898426056,
0.9758750796318054,
0.19141033291816711,
0.16981402039527893,
0.7999128103256226,
0.6618369817733765,
0.3444477319717407,
-0.11856555938720703,
0.9800475239753723,
-0.2640141248703003,
0.05380566790699959,
0.9861143827438354,
-0.020736100152134895,
0.9880136847496033,
0.3095458149909973,
0.10984371602535248,
0.5623944997787476,
0.7419934868812561,
0.1856149584054947,
0.4417000412940979,
-0.09840838611125946,
0.03664899617433548,
-0.7949109673500061,
-0.05766117572784424,
-0.16865341365337372,
0.4090637266635895,
0.2508212625980377,
-0.05095582827925682,
-0.2713296413421631,
0.2062855064868927,
0.09602618217468262,
-0.07769187539815903,
-0.1841888129711151,
0.4057497978210449,
0.11009170860052109,
-0.567201554775238,
0.3517967462539673,
0.2566429376602173,
0.7796987891197205,
-0.48639267683029175,
0.1642482727766037,
-0.17861692607402802,
0.3175252377986908,
-0.1965155303478241,
-0.9567638039588928,
0.44870561361312866,
0.045438360422849655,
-0.13218273222446442,
-0.24926890432834625,
1.0381619930267334,
-0.15186817944049835,
-0.49173370003700256,
0.06948170810937881,
0.427299827337265,
0.3606514632701874,
-0.12564890086650848,
-1.0347380638122559,
0.268035352230072,
-0.17063899338245392,
-0.4471115469932556,
0.30900025367736816,
0.034102052450180054,
-0.15113632380962372,
1.3593018054962158,
0.49090802669525146,
-0.5189217329025269,
0.2651435434818268,
0.14428658783435822,
0.8144047260284424,
-0.7923123240470886,
-0.40686362981796265,
-0.5925384759902954,
0.5560647249221802,
0.003211383009329438,
-0.5182802081108093,
0.7007584571838379,
0.51344895362854,
0.5102014541625977,
-0.08118906617164612,
0.6454395055770874,
-0.10374622792005539,
0.34525641798973083,
-0.444964200258255,
0.7453956604003906,
-0.7153971791267395,
-0.33579182624816895,
0.059834498912096024,
-0.9673739671707153,
-0.12421528995037079,
0.38575685024261475,
-0.19858184456825256,
0.2693556249141693,
0.7396337985992432,
0.5234286785125732,
-0.04606227949261665,
0.29027512669563293,
0.5911985635757446,
-0.10297852754592896,
0.6000844240188599,
0.8837102651596069,
1.014747977256775,
-0.5397235155105591,
0.6833154559135437,
-0.3302598297595978,
-0.44773077964782715,
-0.16877233982086182,
-0.7736120223999023,
-1.0506395101547241,
-0.8195121884346008,
-0.38564005494117737,
-0.07886115461587906,
-0.22530850768089294,
0.5807082653045654,
1.0802801847457886,
-0.591105043888092,
-0.2678966820240021,
0.3749687671661377,
0.09960655122995377,
-0.16137245297431946,
-0.10592813044786453,
0.1123872697353363,
-0.2517281472682953,
-0.7116360068321228,
0.6993083953857422,
0.28951653838157654,
-0.04059116169810295,
-0.7062786221504211,
0.016673658043146133,
-0.29863134026527405,
-0.18546171486377716,
0.42737385630607605,
0.3060222566127777,
-0.9491444230079651,
-0.20949096977710724,
0.21838167309761047,
0.03689275309443474,
0.01060018502175808,
1.0850093364715576,
-0.9001386761665344,
0.34196963906288147,
0.7020139098167419,
0.6367076635360718,
0.39499711990356445,
-0.31822746992111206,
0.7941158413887024,
-0.3609016537666321,
0.12507939338684082,
0.09984862804412842,
0.4254608750343323,
0.6344165205955505,
0.08870919048786163,
0.3841926157474518,
0.15658579766750336,
-0.6269691586494446,
-0.8026712536811829,
0.5670017600059509,
-0.9262781143188477,
-0.20939667522907257,
0.9622994065284729,
-0.2591208219528198,
-0.5052241683006287,
-0.2681405544281006,
0.12605886161327362,
0.05603452026844025,
-0.31242257356643677,
0.4002465605735779,
0.9519913196563721,
0.012677580118179321,
-0.7620921730995178,
-0.675856351852417,
0.327053040266037,
0.7795496582984924,
-0.8012298941612244,
0.15443895757198334,
0.4053259491920471,
0.5938873887062073,
0.35299572348594666,
0.68196040391922,
-0.13997729122638702,
0.4671875834465027,
0.2208613157272339,
0.3406536877155304,
-0.43724438548088074,
-0.6025682687759399,
-0.3731241822242737,
0.046225499361753464,
0.13768930733203888,
-0.10349699854850769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12365v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12365v1
|
When LLMs are Unfit Use FastFit: Fast and Effective Text Classification with Many Classes
| 2024-04-18T17:48:05 | 2024-04-18T17:48:05 |
Asaf Yehudai, Elron Bendel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
We present FastFit, a method, and a Python package design to provide fast and
accurate few-shot classification, especially for scenarios with many
semantically similar classes. FastFit utilizes a novel approach integrating
batch contrastive learning and token-level similarity score. Compared to
existing few-shot learning packages, such as SetFit, Transformers, or few-shot
prompting of large language models via API calls, FastFit significantly
improves multiclass classification performance in speed and accuracy across
FewMany, our newly curated English benchmark, and Multilingual datasets.
FastFit demonstrates a 3-20x improvement in training speed, completing training
in just a few seconds. The FastFit package is now available on GitHub and PyPi,
presenting a user-friendly solution for NLP practitioners.
|
[
-0.0810096263885498,
-0.568182647228241,
0.3573964238166809,
0.21423257887363434,
-0.2688872516155243,
0.15498512983322144,
-0.07387413084506989,
-0.396083801984787,
-0.042675990611314774,
0.0668245404958725,
-0.5713682770729065,
-0.36463478207588196,
-0.7948458790779114,
0.2941105365753174,
-0.5148529410362244,
1.0987979173660278,
-0.11845552921295166,
-0.015837179496884346,
0.15170566737651825,
-0.36527907848358154,
-0.37516283988952637,
-0.3120685815811157,
-0.9274988174438477,
-0.5843111872673035,
0.8646114468574524,
0.5465019941329956,
0.7122141718864441,
0.5866237878799438,
0.8956953883171082,
0.2821681499481201,
0.0324588418006897,
0.09722906351089478,
-0.5682625770568848,
0.16326174139976501,
-0.12495812028646469,
-0.6330993175506592,
-0.09543382376432419,
0.07826010137796402,
0.6669262647628784,
0.32019686698913574,
-0.022681990638375282,
0.12900952994823456,
0.14580345153808594,
0.6226608157157898,
-0.8050203323364258,
0.04248800501227379,
-0.74136883020401,
0.22184260189533234,
-0.6506186723709106,
-0.3825884461402893,
-0.46999168395996094,
-0.21442098915576935,
0.2293165624141693,
-0.5413135290145874,
0.30441945791244507,
0.21821314096450806,
0.8153347969055176,
0.5957154631614685,
-0.42666095495224,
-0.061012737452983856,
-0.22443357110023499,
0.8383374810218811,
-0.6486513018608093,
0.447783887386322,
0.2798018157482147,
0.4377700388431549,
-0.33811837434768677,
-0.9253300428390503,
-0.4944019019603729,
0.18081161379814148,
-0.1299843043088913,
-0.01026115845888853,
0.12296201288700104,
0.1353043019771576,
0.2495320737361908,
0.2733694612979889,
-0.7978016138076782,
0.43510371446609497,
-0.02153775468468666,
-0.48138427734375,
0.49544236063957214,
0.3975849747657776,
0.24642811715602875,
-0.14014585316181183,
-0.534171462059021,
0.012448550201952457,
-0.6603416800498962,
-0.17601412534713745,
0.4004504084587097,
0.4862203896045685,
-0.020685769617557526,
0.4729321300983429,
-0.17780204117298126,
0.7360472679138184,
-0.22719325125217438,
-0.7329317927360535,
0.30432599782943726,
-0.1940051019191742,
-0.2506974935531616,
0.01323368214070797,
0.7402085065841675,
0.160370334982872,
0.14529870450496674,
0.15970006585121155,
-0.2960386574268341,
0.01800195872783661,
-0.02875182405114174,
-1.0971417427062988,
-0.23634135723114014,
0.21511447429656982,
-0.5167536735534668,
-0.3532794713973999,
-0.1478646993637085,
-0.5772241950035095,
-0.6475703716278076,
-0.13499853014945984,
0.43892744183540344,
-0.4392068684101105,
-0.019523860886693,
-0.014487487263977528,
-0.23695412278175354,
0.30597949028015137,
0.5430303812026978,
-0.9660372138023376,
0.10675687342882156,
0.5917523503303528,
1.0899516344070435,
-0.6811818480491638,
-0.6545969843864441,
-0.8340863585472107,
-0.1282387226819992,
-0.20576061308383942,
1.1947077512741089,
-0.22271345555782318,
0.0015480250585824251,
0.08999603241682053,
-0.02613700181245804,
-0.08786591142416,
-0.4723805785179138,
0.4671529531478882,
-0.3269316256046295,
0.08864254504442215,
0.15948106348514557,
-0.6339583396911621,
-0.13369646668434143,
0.5244598984718323,
-0.43640509247779846,
1.1071484088897705,
0.19350813329219818,
-1.1951607465744019,
0.5409699082374573,
-0.37329402565956116,
-0.3781341016292572,
0.22026023268699646,
0.023410271853208542,
-0.5411731004714966,
-0.18994058668613434,
-0.10351569950580597,
1.105555772781372,
0.12245922535657883,
-0.026324784383177757,
-0.42044878005981445,
-0.6024926900863647,
0.10833956301212311,
-0.3995222747325897,
0.616685688495636,
0.19880647957324982,
0.018726976588368416,
0.04754040017724037,
-0.9828798770904541,
0.07048120349645615,
0.17665676772594452,
-0.7204194664955139,
-0.38547757267951965,
-0.09751288592815399,
0.3831581175327301,
0.2163124680519104,
-0.11895871162414551,
-0.27041950821876526,
0.4397054612636566,
-0.43960174918174744,
0.26189523935317993,
0.7763437032699585,
-0.07381163537502289,
0.4563544690608978,
-0.4091540575027466,
0.4093098044395447,
-0.05280261114239693,
-0.06823352724313736,
-0.45168283581733704,
-0.5482333302497864,
-0.8167232871055603,
-0.6100878119468689,
0.20290829241275787,
0.7756953835487366,
-0.9551641345024109,
0.15233023464679718,
-0.2528548538684845,
-0.5562872290611267,
-0.4206155240535736,
0.47609609365463257,
0.31748318672180176,
0.38024070858955383,
0.43562114238739014,
-0.0647541731595993,
-0.2923497259616852,
-0.6527934074401855,
-0.49280861020088196,
-0.22482019662857056,
-0.019469108432531357,
-0.06604211777448654,
0.7240176200866699,
-0.5208193063735962,
0.6884124279022217,
-0.6042078733444214,
-0.48709961771965027,
-0.3182751536369324,
0.2925414443016052,
0.045872822403907776,
0.30360642075538635,
0.46706071496009827,
-0.552483856678009,
-0.5544796586036682,
-0.024896834045648575,
-0.510317325592041,
-0.011683788150548935,
-0.2917449176311493,
-0.023428598418831825,
0.19363436102867126,
0.25542888045310974,
-0.3037535548210144,
0.30562788248062134,
0.3471333682537079,
-0.29905980825424194,
0.20582374930381775,
0.19829779863357544,
0.05101153999567032,
-0.958329975605011,
-0.04076030105352402,
-0.000024713934180908836,
-0.6391550898551941,
-0.5990285873413086,
0.165940061211586,
0.2749364972114563,
-0.028865303844213486,
-1.2038702964782715,
0.8027541041374207,
0.10304902493953705,
0.17176997661590576,
-0.3360515832901001,
0.10769517719745636,
-0.049856752157211304,
0.2636690139770508,
0.07929699122905731,
0.7818634510040283,
0.35134294629096985,
-0.6007548570632935,
0.32916733622550964,
0.401263028383255,
-0.31220442056655884,
0.5336032509803772,
-0.21185854077339172,
0.22567318379878998,
-0.21279358863830566,
0.4176204800605774,
-0.8132514357566833,
-0.4850853979587555,
0.15720555186271667,
-0.28619617223739624,
0.4941679537296295,
-0.22981180250644684,
-0.5515087842941284,
-0.19606737792491913,
-0.6294418573379517,
0.27340584993362427,
0.19293998181819916,
-0.7802978157997131,
0.29170840978622437,
-0.07608883082866669,
0.04887949675321579,
-0.8240774869918823,
-0.8702078461647034,
-0.2599625885486603,
-0.2917064428329468,
-0.3291965126991272,
0.25173047184944153,
-0.12491320073604584,
-0.18572881817817688,
-0.16951321065425873,
-0.1743832379579544,
-0.5488112568855286,
0.38014665246009827,
0.09626482427120209,
0.125185027718544,
-0.1370062381029129,
0.420085072517395,
-0.05330949276685715,
-0.39294081926345825,
-0.6297241449356079,
-0.020771725103259087,
0.3414364457130432,
-0.12248030304908752,
-0.05292850732803345,
-0.596851110458374,
0.32144731283187866,
0.4650387763977051,
-0.020018216222524643,
0.6561810970306396,
0.9946523904800415,
-0.2969820499420166,
-0.5160217881202698,
-0.5001606941223145,
-0.20309098064899445,
-0.47816744446754456,
0.3800206184387207,
-0.3503261208534241,
-1.0032223463058472,
0.31791314482688904,
-0.11940004676580429,
0.3705418109893799,
0.40346014499664307,
0.4900602400302887,
-0.23838850855827332,
0.5384524464607239,
0.8160741329193115,
-0.1653435379266739,
0.6208595633506775,
-0.1933421790599823,
0.041199952363967896,
-0.25603291392326355,
-0.16938580572605133,
-0.6731945276260376,
-0.3915881812572479,
-0.5563141107559204,
-0.22147193551063538,
0.03389701619744301,
0.21474801003932953,
-0.2610887885093689,
0.37635552883148193,
-0.5476337671279907,
0.9032045006752014,
0.31389719247817993,
0.12560957670211792,
0.23556506633758545,
-0.11310185492038727,
0.16791023313999176,
-0.20316067337989807,
-0.740546703338623,
-0.4303215444087982,
0.9819769263267517,
0.41809314489364624,
0.930065393447876,
-0.06321939826011658,
1.227871298789978,
0.15594571828842163,
0.5530052185058594,
-1.4154927730560303,
0.23600083589553833,
-0.3327404260635376,
-0.6763198971748352,
-0.16556169092655182,
-0.3650425672531128,
-0.8581029176712036,
0.3267374634742737,
-0.5342265367507935,
-0.3999071717262268,
-0.08666936308145523,
0.027120251208543777,
-0.591852068901062,
0.28691521286964417,
-0.8665603399276733,
0.9556043744087219,
-0.1084364727139473,
-0.30531495809555054,
0.029097149148583412,
-0.7674752473831177,
0.6450817584991455,
-0.44960954785346985,
0.0031830351799726486,
-0.58314049243927,
-0.31817707419395447,
0.8951173424720764,
-0.36170217394828796,
0.7617959976196289,
0.025962935760617256,
0.17546048760414124,
0.2477778047323227,
-0.026568397879600525,
0.34757766127586365,
-0.014993088319897652,
-0.19558236002922058,
0.32407456636428833,
0.20595981180667877,
-0.5462945103645325,
-0.5081270933151245,
0.5459517240524292,
-0.6200335621833801,
-0.18047557771205902,
-0.7152585983276367,
-0.3481341600418091,
0.06185878440737724,
0.2533378303050995,
0.3965447247028351,
0.26190492510795593,
0.04303165525197983,
-0.008582029491662979,
0.6765161156654358,
-0.23637506365776062,
0.8060492873191833,
0.4178444445133209,
-0.02660072036087513,
-0.26122167706489563,
0.8927342891693115,
0.11908495426177979,
0.22700457274913788,
0.5116217136383057,
0.2795616686344147,
-0.23787176609039307,
-0.7033953070640564,
-0.2774292826652527,
0.14457924664020538,
-1.0007044076919556,
-0.8017348051071167,
-0.5354297161102295,
-0.15553097426891327,
-0.2691299617290497,
-0.2998459041118622,
-0.4406496286392212,
-0.45589715242385864,
-0.41218292713165283,
0.02193109318614006,
0.41468730568885803,
0.5953515768051147,
0.3127492368221283,
0.7867436408996582,
-0.9729370474815369,
0.4956294596195221,
0.3313491642475128,
0.35774970054626465,
-0.44595086574554443,
-0.6389686465263367,
-0.14502863585948944,
-0.7794824838638306,
-0.5617557168006897,
-0.6559828519821167,
0.40553519129753113,
0.5959097146987915,
0.5420340299606323,
0.5437858700752258,
0.13312141597270966,
0.8052157759666443,
-0.8395012617111206,
0.7282745838165283,
0.40834277868270874,
-0.8002334833145142,
0.6923631429672241,
0.11533692479133606,
0.29892560839653015,
0.9625352025032043,
0.7361242175102234,
-0.5706913471221924,
-0.3547917604446411,
-0.31292852759361267,
-0.7039773464202881,
0.6688607931137085,
-0.025371750816702843,
-0.021809929981827736,
-0.06263919919729233,
0.4891922175884247,
0.4364890158176422,
-0.20081394910812378,
-0.9024890065193176,
-0.36352211236953735,
-0.1103067472577095,
-0.4938267171382904,
-0.17508962750434875,
-0.12938840687274933,
0.07936742156744003,
-0.22713792324066162,
0.6749971508979797,
-0.5661293268203735,
0.15979218482971191,
0.07695149630308151,
-0.3179590702056885,
0.21383939683437347,
0.3863897919654846,
0.5040906071662903,
0.3588419258594513,
-0.15978597104549408,
0.42423367500305176,
0.3316033184528351,
-0.47023066878318787,
0.5099493265151978,
0.005262456834316254,
0.0789811983704567,
0.0445670485496521,
0.778581976890564,
0.48078277707099915,
0.37972041964530945,
-0.44711267948150635,
0.819911777973175,
-0.23866941034793854,
0.09455357491970062,
0.14335492253303528,
0.15247084200382233,
-0.21838340163230896,
0.27189505100250244,
0.037446241825819016,
0.2799477279186249,
0.20247617363929749,
-0.4828769564628601,
0.38813039660453796,
0.22370561957359314,
-0.14716625213623047,
-0.0030958352144807577,
0.5015497803688049,
0.4119083881378174,
-0.34434330463409424,
0.573269784450531,
-0.2934623658657074,
-0.4994807243347168,
0.17899246513843536,
0.4650161564350128,
0.9562052488327026,
-0.29297366738319397,
0.202413871884346,
0.21738910675048828,
0.2747461795806885,
-0.6089798808097839,
-0.034548722207546234,
0.13006189465522766,
-0.8532782793045044,
-0.5408682823181152,
-0.9004261493682861,
-0.4765661358833313,
0.07073332369327545,
-0.13954859972000122,
0.7314923405647278,
-0.6886683106422424,
-0.06671827286481857,
0.10774847120046616,
0.21108277142047882,
-0.7913258075714111,
0.031061066314578056,
0.2808438539505005,
0.9871273040771484,
-1.134969711303711,
1.1612154245376587,
0.7029886245727539,
-0.36449486017227173,
-0.6318722367286682,
0.18249820172786713,
0.41958242654800415,
-0.6577226519584656,
0.7595809698104858,
0.5459455847740173,
-0.05909999832510948,
0.06197859346866608,
-0.6022637486457825,
-0.564401388168335,
1.0219882726669312,
0.3077065944671631,
-0.5772466659545898,
0.1257457584142685,
-0.11319686472415924,
0.2680058479309082,
0.019009878858923912,
0.2586129307746887,
0.7212104201316833,
0.4353545010089874,
-0.07635435461997986,
-0.8212548494338989,
-0.19389016926288605,
0.21746401488780975,
-0.2148933857679367,
0.19688555598258972,
-0.6537514925003052,
0.5256275534629822,
-0.20926541090011597,
-0.16820117831230164,
-0.06710471957921982,
0.5235875844955444,
0.210881769657135,
0.6147046089172363,
0.44544321298599243,
0.5012962222099304,
0.9727790355682373,
-0.13907000422477722,
1.0707274675369263,
0.22268953919410706,
0.43033644556999207,
0.9530358910560608,
-0.19548307359218597,
1.0897244215011597,
0.41825664043426514,
-0.28887563943862915,
0.13366897404193878,
0.9502043724060059,
0.05793590843677521,
0.5271201729774475,
0.16191984713077545,
-0.45436838269233704,
-0.35720404982566833,
0.0930088609457016,
-0.02085697278380394,
0.44888076186180115,
0.19324158132076263,
0.10713721811771393,
-0.27311551570892334,
0.2891491651535034,
0.12475185096263885,
-0.0724606066942215,
-0.33265987038612366,
0.7012224793434143,
0.3792305290699005,
-0.2711135745048523,
0.6898232698440552,
0.04890856146812439,
1.285548210144043,
-0.6325060129165649,
-0.03546818345785141,
-0.38592901825904846,
0.44035401940345764,
-0.6491976380348206,
-0.8198226094245911,
0.34659069776535034,
-0.01732192002236843,
-0.022698642686009407,
-0.29499292373657227,
0.9858549237251282,
-0.36953455209732056,
-0.365207701921463,
0.14552900195121765,
0.44116607308387756,
0.4255845844745636,
0.050281181931495667,
-0.9123820066452026,
0.07671574503183365,
-0.19052956998348236,
-0.2938198745250702,
0.40639352798461914,
0.29271286725997925,
0.0451253205537796,
0.838886022567749,
0.4825381934642792,
-0.06839868426322937,
0.35068076848983765,
-0.07240772247314453,
0.5678574442863464,
-0.6675054430961609,
-0.1226377859711647,
-1.0139256715774536,
0.43065619468688965,
0.1456993818283081,
-0.5269753932952881,
0.5484952330589294,
0.5777578353881836,
0.8943134546279907,
-0.09648802131414413,
0.4905721843242645,
0.1102556362748146,
0.5039108991622925,
-0.6232763528823853,
0.7977333068847656,
-0.6332358121871948,
0.003325953148305416,
-0.18331721425056458,
-0.992204487323761,
-1.0128611326217651,
0.7230441570281982,
0.1864439845085144,
-0.4805186092853546,
1.1946665048599243,
0.6217791438102722,
-0.06973325461149216,
-0.30120179057121277,
0.5917725563049316,
-0.1528690606355667,
0.4051653742790222,
0.4894564151763916,
1.0309995412826538,
-0.5401798486709595,
0.5977694988250732,
-0.4150178134441376,
-0.1350477933883667,
-0.2568571865558624,
-0.99732506275177,
-1.2015267610549927,
-0.26593321561813354,
-0.6334208846092224,
-0.12696480751037598,
-0.04663283750414848,
1.2194654941558838,
0.7668930292129517,
-0.8230302929878235,
0.1859130859375,
0.2399875968694687,
0.4336998760700226,
-0.07165359705686569,
-0.301144003868103,
0.36447814106941223,
-0.8996374607086182,
-0.7961193919181824,
0.4734020233154297,
0.3138989508152008,
0.21789558231830597,
0.12734290957450867,
-0.1484796553850174,
-0.1844678521156311,
-0.1299491673707962,
0.8161098957061768,
0.1840936243534088,
-0.4872928559780121,
-0.3080221116542816,
-0.27020764350891113,
-0.23111049830913544,
0.10966771841049194,
0.8963825702667236,
-0.7873886823654175,
0.1875736266374588,
0.7441235184669495,
1.0085194110870361,
0.4179486036300659,
-0.3372187614440918,
-0.1532144397497177,
-0.9351167678833008,
0.49240046739578247,
0.3561207950115204,
0.48486781120300293,
0.3568928837776184,
-0.32326656579971313,
0.7310785055160522,
0.4720984399318695,
-0.6703318953514099,
-0.8631550073623657,
0.13931354880332947,
-1.0453054904937744,
-0.20323987305164337,
1.1879888772964478,
-0.44305482506752014,
-0.11249130219221115,
-0.20285415649414062,
-0.3057778775691986,
0.094680555164814,
-0.3608553111553192,
0.45037931203842163,
0.7399248480796814,
-0.30354827642440796,
-0.15755397081375122,
-0.7938548922538757,
0.625659167766571,
0.1921217441558838,
-1.133415937423706,
-0.043705955147743225,
0.19403232634067535,
0.4817650020122528,
0.055878542363643646,
0.6840813159942627,
-0.02375216968357563,
0.12112727761268616,
-0.13199010491371155,
-0.032631076872348785,
0.1795545220375061,
-0.43911927938461304,
-0.5581462979316711,
0.1656302660703659,
0.2035665661096573,
-0.1782734990119934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12342v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12342v1
|
Large Language Models in Targeted Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-04-18T17:16:16 | 2024-04-18T17:16:16 |
Nicolay Rusnachenko, Anton Golubev, Natalia Loukachevitch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper we investigate the use of decoder-based generative transformers
for extracting sentiment towards the named entities in Russian news articles.
We study sentiment analysis capabilities of instruction-tuned large language
models (LLMs). We consider the dataset of RuSentNE-2023 in our study. The first
group of experiments was aimed at the evaluation of zero-shot capabilities of
LLMs with closed and open transparencies. The second covers the fine-tuning of
Flan-T5 using the "chain-of-thought" (CoT) three-hop reasoning framework
(THoR). We found that the results of the zero-shot approaches are similar to
the results achieved by baseline fine-tuned encoder-based transformers
(BERT-base). Reasoning capabilities of the fine-tuned Flan-T5 models with THoR
achieve at least 5% increment with the base-size model compared to the results
of the zero-shot experiment. The best results of sentiment analysis on
RuSentNE-2023 were achieved by fine-tuned Flan-T5-xl, which surpassed the
results of previous state-of-the-art transformer-based classifiers. Our CoT
application framework is publicly available:
https://github.com/nicolay-r/Reasoning-for-Sentiment-Analysis-Framework
|
[
-0.2524276375770569,
-0.6232195496559143,
0.6040617227554321,
0.33957475423812866,
-0.39100414514541626,
0.126229926943779,
-0.4018201529979706,
-0.2622898817062378,
0.01794297806918621,
0.38892555236816406,
-0.43028008937835693,
-0.8029111623764038,
-0.6242526769638062,
0.2738463580608368,
-0.5554589629173279,
1.196837306022644,
-0.024912800639867783,
0.2746240794658661,
0.061761531978845596,
0.04883885383605957,
-0.19648435711860657,
-0.3188982605934143,
-0.4451683461666107,
-0.07627513259649277,
0.7607163190841675,
0.26052746176719666,
0.5903557538986206,
0.1449785679578781,
0.587327241897583,
0.22327406704425812,
-0.24593627452850342,
-0.15384402871131897,
-0.3771364092826843,
0.1414199024438858,
-0.2846132218837738,
-0.6082274317741394,
-0.6180894374847412,
-0.23123778402805328,
0.6566974520683289,
0.35003915429115295,
0.15679208934307098,
0.17937356233596802,
-0.039280638098716736,
0.5000039339065552,
-0.6012755632400513,
0.0900348573923111,
-0.6767067313194275,
0.22369760274887085,
0.008810735307633877,
-0.04338759928941727,
-0.7723334431648254,
-0.17203031480312347,
-0.01198060717433691,
-0.13478727638721466,
0.31652554869651794,
-0.02862105518579483,
0.9459520578384399,
0.03289171680808067,
-0.29923897981643677,
-0.188216432929039,
-0.7968139052391052,
1.2386008501052856,
-0.7770364284515381,
0.3870806396007538,
-0.10574298352003098,
0.09650645405054092,
-0.007799763232469559,
-0.4494190514087677,
-0.46798351407051086,
0.0007733979728072882,
0.02594032511115074,
0.2620188295841217,
-0.36629071831703186,
0.050096578896045685,
0.34165364503860474,
0.5273904204368591,
-0.427254855632782,
-0.03737747669219971,
-0.20896992087364197,
-0.07750942558050156,
0.5545986294746399,
0.05022468790411949,
-0.13863646984100342,
-0.4008881151676178,
-0.2591400444507599,
-0.013501380570232868,
-0.5228689908981323,
-0.254788875579834,
0.5404183864593506,
0.36134541034698486,
-0.10029995441436768,
0.8249486088752747,
-0.37232455611228943,
0.7303522825241089,
0.2958124577999115,
-0.1604514867067337,
0.3049711287021637,
0.030928490683436394,
-0.5020045042037964,
-0.027730807662010193,
0.9550042152404785,
0.22218245267868042,
0.41261938214302063,
-0.1525377482175827,
-0.5264493227005005,
0.14600065350532532,
0.4713701605796814,
-0.7669969797134399,
0.1273663192987442,
0.2911195456981659,
-0.5929286479949951,
-0.7151113748550415,
0.0789995789527893,
-1.1826543807983398,
-0.36966750025749207,
-0.20380085706710815,
0.4065985679626465,
-0.3163079619407654,
-0.40913939476013184,
0.27194470167160034,
0.022142380475997925,
0.8262202739715576,
0.26180300116539,
-0.6987782716751099,
-0.05513957515358925,
0.9536745548248291,
0.7739996314048767,
-0.25524288415908813,
0.002553755883127451,
-0.5551149249076843,
-0.22814062237739563,
-0.3393186926841736,
0.8511712551116943,
-0.6148090362548828,
-0.2470952719449997,
0.3346368372440338,
-0.0306791290640831,
-0.029991300776600838,
-0.41811585426330566,
0.7391125559806824,
-0.7278621792793274,
0.2803010940551758,
-0.09363585710525513,
-0.48705044388771057,
0.0028858461882919073,
0.5387530326843262,
-0.5853785276412964,
0.700649082660675,
0.3725675940513611,
-0.8812292218208313,
0.26448363065719604,
-0.5790383815765381,
-0.6281513571739197,
-0.23518873751163483,
0.17061282694339752,
-0.4862683117389679,
0.46495914459228516,
0.2882431447505951,
0.7712069153785706,
-0.28002649545669556,
0.2624024450778961,
-0.3093494474887848,
-0.19277989864349365,
0.447807639837265,
-0.4577556252479553,
0.36847367882728577,
0.356767475605011,
-0.42149001359939575,
0.37486255168914795,
-0.6118571162223816,
-0.06306936591863632,
-0.16279742121696472,
-0.3425735831260681,
-0.008440571837127209,
-0.09782212972640991,
0.19326111674308777,
0.22010360658168793,
0.049633752554655075,
-0.7598044276237488,
0.22614258527755737,
-0.6053110361099243,
0.18883399665355682,
0.6135015487670898,
0.012862144969403744,
0.4802631735801697,
0.05423089116811752,
0.808440089225769,
0.38882023096084595,
0.19064629077911377,
-0.13768133521080017,
-0.1731170266866684,
-1.1731964349746704,
-0.1434730440378189,
0.4021543562412262,
0.2432134449481964,
-0.8851407766342163,
0.381782591342926,
-0.5865210890769958,
-0.23940256237983704,
-0.6787782311439514,
-0.14588092267513275,
0.06933331489562988,
0.197251558303833,
0.2939510643482208,
0.1640682816505432,
-0.5593425035476685,
-0.9287729263305664,
-0.5563517808914185,
0.1602609008550644,
0.058223482221364975,
-0.1169816106557846,
0.49518731236457825,
-0.10539401322603226,
0.7709285020828247,
-0.43686291575431824,
-0.19247476756572723,
-0.6486406922340393,
0.16760236024856567,
0.3479642868041992,
0.1269591897726059,
0.23960049450397491,
-0.849683403968811,
-0.6163294315338135,
0.2267298400402069,
-0.6675716042518616,
0.14227533340454102,
-0.1713176965713501,
0.008874018676578999,
0.7026661038398743,
0.28137853741645813,
-1.065853238105774,
0.2800324559211731,
0.4702291488647461,
-0.3105967938899994,
0.4867943823337555,
0.43098577857017517,
0.030880659818649292,
-1.3971506357192993,
0.038008276373147964,
0.2467372715473175,
-0.3968941569328308,
-0.6720245480537415,
-0.05142178386449814,
-0.07460203021764755,
-0.08138752728700638,
-0.5999240279197693,
0.4038866460323334,
-0.33032459020614624,
-0.13759726285934448,
-0.3084944486618042,
0.02135366201400757,
-0.021336810663342476,
0.2860727310180664,
0.22032339870929718,
0.5187546610832214,
0.651980996131897,
-0.1734100580215454,
0.4764566421508789,
0.014719340018928051,
-0.5451894998550415,
0.6471275687217712,
-0.6433774828910828,
-0.02065022476017475,
-0.2721617817878723,
0.08408601582050323,
-0.6051093935966492,
-0.2781367301940918,
0.2942429184913635,
-0.6556811332702637,
0.4636351466178894,
-0.1347540318965912,
-0.5843608975410461,
-0.24775856733322144,
-0.3334072232246399,
0.13582457602024078,
0.633338987827301,
-0.4343094229698181,
0.8777471780776978,
-0.08236266672611237,
0.09312756359577179,
-0.7639536261558533,
-0.5234465003013611,
0.12250736355781555,
-0.5737903118133545,
-0.3387468755245209,
0.03974287211894989,
0.16790834069252014,
-0.3326033055782318,
0.05450721085071564,
0.029701340943574905,
0.3445883095264435,
-0.27936649322509766,
0.043754156678915024,
0.28415489196777344,
-0.42620137333869934,
0.17132613062858582,
-0.18828526139259338,
-0.019336814060807228,
0.17415019869804382,
-0.3312378227710724,
0.6954154372215271,
-0.5580193400382996,
-0.02193761058151722,
-0.33258187770843506,
0.2103583663702011,
0.8277592658996582,
-0.2718574106693268,
0.9642819762229919,
0.8606314063072205,
-0.12597134709358215,
-0.426961213350296,
-0.6892242431640625,
0.022194871678948402,
-0.4241383373737335,
0.45002296566963196,
-0.36392903327941895,
-0.8589785695075989,
0.37786227464675903,
-0.009916002862155437,
-0.22050856053829193,
0.6501381397247314,
0.7497994899749756,
-0.15647728741168976,
1.17946457862854,
0.3854399621486664,
-0.3756157159805298,
0.2647322416305542,
-0.43347519636154175,
0.5162400007247925,
-0.9137948155403137,
-0.25165918469429016,
-0.336199551820755,
-0.37293219566345215,
-0.6622996926307678,
-0.21687886118888855,
0.3103541433811188,
-0.20072774589061737,
-0.15314951539039612,
0.06715764105319977,
-0.20561163127422333,
0.32222896814346313,
0.22790494561195374,
-0.1426582634449005,
0.059892211109399796,
0.22329214215278625,
0.1521250456571579,
0.18295754492282867,
-0.45437976717948914,
-0.3928895592689514,
0.9374484419822693,
0.573750376701355,
1.0052680969238281,
-0.11138007789850235,
0.5855609178543091,
0.2847979664802551,
0.4098740220069885,
-1.4714372158050537,
0.5828995108604431,
-0.2055618315935135,
-0.4412097930908203,
0.0012825458543375134,
-0.3816211223602295,
-0.7641134262084961,
0.22712482511997223,
-0.1411600559949875,
-0.5297083258628845,
0.06017995998263359,
-0.11123254150152206,
-0.10342148691415787,
0.5292317867279053,
-0.35315001010894775,
0.7794204950332642,
-0.05131038650870323,
-0.38117191195487976,
-0.27952808141708374,
-0.3777045011520386,
0.30781760811805725,
0.16524063050746918,
0.04511236771941185,
0.019642937928438187,
0.1798912137746811,
0.4112309217453003,
0.10090915858745575,
0.8500867486000061,
-0.2385769486427307,
-0.47956106066703796,
0.29291394352912903,
-0.05874444544315338,
0.4285949766635895,
-0.17498517036437988,
-0.33323171734809875,
0.17278848588466644,
-0.1108717992901802,
-0.18059970438480377,
-0.6344218254089355,
0.899027407169342,
-0.7300296425819397,
-0.6493629813194275,
-0.5812196731567383,
-0.5435083508491516,
-0.3228731155395508,
0.20403043925762177,
0.2806680500507355,
0.4842779040336609,
-0.09110764414072037,
0.708797812461853,
0.6469950079917908,
-0.2464471459388733,
0.38853034377098083,
0.34183239936828613,
-0.3337576389312744,
-0.46538034081459045,
0.7492628693580627,
-0.20273590087890625,
0.2489127367734909,
0.7514894604682922,
0.2459283173084259,
-0.14383140206336975,
-0.3505231440067291,
-0.3233502209186554,
0.35947278141975403,
-0.8358491659164429,
-0.6750230193138123,
-0.5668606162071228,
-0.14401179552078247,
-0.3614436388015747,
-0.05141841992735863,
-0.4683983027935028,
-0.14665155112743378,
-0.4027869701385498,
-0.16691063344478607,
0.14147384464740753,
0.6840957403182983,
0.4225429892539978,
0.430237352848053,
-0.7809392213821411,
0.2937156856060028,
-0.05720536783337593,
0.53091961145401,
-0.0540853813290596,
-0.49731579422950745,
-0.3517693877220154,
0.1259920299053192,
-0.4287381172180176,
-0.9109779596328735,
0.6139376759529114,
-0.07018348574638367,
0.22297102212905884,
0.3956500291824341,
-0.0009404922602698207,
0.224701926112175,
-0.19400806725025177,
0.9001960754394531,
0.05239558219909668,
-1.0187891721725464,
0.6108595728874207,
-0.7384446263313293,
0.41615527868270874,
0.17300844192504883,
0.3071211278438568,
-0.2814464271068573,
-0.29102781414985657,
-0.48357972502708435,
-0.5117156505584717,
0.8358566164970398,
0.042781732976436615,
0.35336288809776306,
-0.2650282382965088,
0.429497629404068,
-0.016742460429668427,
0.21805529296398163,
-0.9017983078956604,
0.07487436383962631,
-0.25224995613098145,
-0.5973781943321228,
-0.021579496562480927,
-0.48322468996047974,
0.09197612851858139,
-0.12179048359394073,
0.8172537088394165,
-0.2947372794151306,
0.2907279431819916,
0.057951007038354874,
-0.16233238577842712,
-0.24598044157028198,
0.6654826402664185,
0.5216609239578247,
0.3801841735839844,
-0.030941704288125038,
0.08044560998678207,
0.1836477518081665,
-0.3155674338340759,
-0.04190912842750549,
-0.29174309968948364,
-0.22331954538822174,
0.07777061313390732,
0.43165159225463867,
1.0702846050262451,
0.13806667923927307,
-0.4471641182899475,
0.7768892049789429,
0.0032818668987601995,
-0.3342704772949219,
-0.5263742804527283,
-0.08393877744674683,
0.013271006755530834,
0.3650517761707306,
0.12014301866292953,
0.030880209058523178,
0.09598785638809204,
-0.5398740172386169,
-0.23056916892528534,
0.6912572979927063,
-0.5449933409690857,
-0.7060138583183289,
0.2057795524597168,
0.07234195619821548,
-0.1711806356906891,
0.6500987410545349,
-0.05171874538064003,
-0.5907421112060547,
0.40071243047714233,
0.6510559320449829,
1.2675427198410034,
-0.22800084948539734,
0.5131670236587524,
0.3418794572353363,
0.20834900438785553,
-0.17788466811180115,
0.32778263092041016,
0.18936361372470856,
-0.8189701437950134,
-0.5979059934616089,
-1.1259750127792358,
-0.024596406146883965,
0.46522951126098633,
-0.9250460267066956,
0.6070598363876343,
-0.17998753488063812,
-0.18618813157081604,
-0.053397875279188156,
-0.21417473256587982,
-0.6492735147476196,
0.32610073685646057,
0.3088695704936981,
0.8265954852104187,
-0.7291762828826904,
0.6765097975730896,
0.7993718385696411,
-0.14707058668136597,
-0.6715308427810669,
0.3495822846889496,
-0.37529540061950684,
-0.4663710296154022,
0.6916306018829346,
0.3385767638683319,
-0.25402215123176575,
0.03924582898616791,
-0.5800477266311646,
-0.7069231271743774,
0.8915115594863892,
0.29496124386787415,
-0.45167800784111023,
0.03100677952170372,
0.41505035758018494,
0.8200008869171143,
-0.49223262071609497,
0.06850488483905792,
0.7429611086845398,
0.532821774482727,
0.1775117963552475,
-0.6825560331344604,
-0.22050675749778748,
-0.14702662825584412,
-0.025869550183415413,
0.40552300214767456,
-0.6404688358306885,
0.5548826456069946,
-0.0715806782245636,
-0.04257557913661003,
0.004318490158766508,
0.7386441826820374,
-0.17061525583267212,
0.037078168243169785,
0.4590499699115753,
0.6615903973579407,
0.058395761996507645,
-0.046253371983766556,
1.2012909650802612,
-0.19613872468471527,
0.6269612312316895,
0.6979401111602783,
-0.24336156249046326,
1.0559555292129517,
0.579814612865448,
-0.21065306663513184,
0.8174999952316284,
0.14715778827667236,
-0.24413423240184784,
0.5102636814117432,
0.13843053579330444,
-0.46995651721954346,
-0.3137165307998657,
-0.08779104799032211,
0.1537853479385376,
0.8377994298934937,
0.5026582479476929,
-0.6136671304702759,
-0.15009573101997375,
0.24393312633037567,
0.07641401141881943,
-0.10436488687992096,
-0.5007301568984985,
0.9819895625114441,
0.2582993507385254,
-0.8044333457946777,
0.44955670833587646,
0.17819230258464813,
0.689585268497467,
-0.42210662364959717,
0.1105756163597107,
-0.10454552620649338,
0.5060176253318787,
-0.31409621238708496,
-0.8184874057769775,
0.4233170747756958,
0.25843140482902527,
-0.20398461818695068,
-0.1597754955291748,
0.9160583019256592,
-0.4176825284957886,
-0.9101332426071167,
0.18771834671497345,
0.22210639715194702,
-0.06656861305236816,
-0.11107497662305832,
-0.30823349952697754,
0.3083122670650482,
0.08245906233787537,
-0.6378681063652039,
0.2106352597475052,
0.3581787943840027,
0.12354031205177307,
0.44879350066185,
0.24660499393939972,
0.2701971232891083,
-0.21689558029174805,
0.352914959192276,
0.8165574073791504,
-0.6170711517333984,
-0.2137618362903595,
-0.9999417662620544,
0.5466576218605042,
-0.03619655966758728,
0.0046521322801709175,
0.7384681701660156,
0.4889606535434723,
0.5583834648132324,
-0.5671650767326355,
0.8841480612754822,
-0.007827569730579853,
0.4956972301006317,
-0.6601631045341492,
0.5316593050956726,
-0.5169371962547302,
0.1343327760696411,
-0.19812428951263428,
-1.1433228254318237,
-0.46650099754333496,
0.5486432909965515,
-0.5275628566741943,
0.20492029190063477,
0.691155731678009,
0.7599806189537048,
-0.23192787170410156,
0.016862157732248306,
0.3933439552783966,
0.42647892236709595,
0.4084286093711853,
0.30576440691947937,
1.0382084846496582,
-0.42772176861763,
0.5139133930206299,
-0.16816236078739166,
0.09726572781801224,
-0.11573337763547897,
-0.946017861366272,
-1.1074703931808472,
-0.31156688928604126,
-0.34569698572158813,
-0.358116090297699,
-0.050019510090351105,
0.7360140085220337,
0.3521682918071747,
-0.9760597348213196,
0.02721882238984108,
-0.2056226283311844,
-0.035223495215177536,
0.11542028933763504,
-0.36910393834114075,
0.427251398563385,
-0.6225589513778687,
-0.8710055947303772,
0.10558035969734192,
0.19837099313735962,
-0.29393038153648376,
-0.45123961567878723,
0.17441824078559875,
0.033986885100603104,
0.014034971594810486,
0.9427917003631592,
-0.26610738039016724,
-0.9313257932662964,
-0.5273290276527405,
0.27103927731513977,
0.17122043669223785,
0.027627723291516304,
0.841325581073761,
-0.7504047155380249,
0.258382648229599,
0.5246925950050354,
0.3960956931114197,
0.30896490812301636,
0.18520958721637726,
0.5310187339782715,
-0.9129254221916199,
-0.02638404630124569,
0.38143450021743774,
0.3518853485584259,
0.6538721919059753,
-0.42095863819122314,
0.0358029343187809,
0.0005692965351045132,
-0.43306565284729004,
-0.6656195521354675,
0.22649936378002167,
-0.945375919342041,
-0.09756947308778763,
1.717551589012146,
-0.061086446046829224,
-0.1455591917037964,
0.29276710748672485,
-0.15128293633460999,
0.23353458940982819,
-0.26850202679634094,
0.6987663507461548,
0.7804626226425171,
0.08429579436779022,
-0.5133016109466553,
-0.42724743485450745,
0.4070263206958771,
0.37665945291519165,
-0.7863665819168091,
0.07034097611904144,
0.46285468339920044,
0.34866684675216675,
0.15748287737369537,
0.11330942809581757,
-0.3051626980304718,
-0.06400959938764572,
-0.16144736111164093,
0.05284231901168823,
0.20736058056354523,
-0.4506048560142517,
-0.5274812579154968,
0.22595596313476562,
0.06448136270046234,
-0.04935247823596001
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12318v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12318v1
|
Reuse Your Rewards: Reward Model Transfer for Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual Alignment
| 2024-04-18T16:52:36 | 2024-04-18T16:52:36 |
Zhaofeng Wu, Ananth Balashankar, Yoon Kim, Jacob Eisenstein, Ahmad Beirami
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aligning language models (LMs) based on human-annotated preference data is a
crucial step in obtaining practical and performant LM-based systems. However,
multilingual human preference data are difficult to obtain at scale, making it
challenging to extend this framework to diverse languages. In this work, we
evaluate a simple approach for zero-shot cross-lingual alignment, where a
reward model is trained on preference data in one source language and directly
applied to other target languages. On summarization and open-ended dialog
generation, we show that this method is consistently successful under
comprehensive evaluation settings, including human evaluation: cross-lingually
aligned models are preferred by humans over unaligned models on up to >70% of
evaluation instances. We moreover find that a different-language reward model
sometimes yields better aligned models than a same-language reward model. We
also identify best practices when there is no language-specific data for even
supervised finetuning, another component in alignment.
|
[
-0.11135417222976685,
-0.1493564248085022,
0.35083961486816406,
-0.060548122972249985,
-0.15130367875099182,
-0.0690709576010704,
-0.4017890393733978,
-0.4460107088088989,
0.35604438185691833,
0.5194519758224487,
-0.485647588968277,
-0.31580933928489685,
-0.32171934843063354,
-0.008286097086966038,
-0.046579357236623764,
1.1546472311019897,
-0.30606579780578613,
0.17602595686912537,
-0.3102308213710785,
-0.4742351174354553,
-0.5639011859893799,
-0.655474066734314,
-0.4201962351799011,
-0.7084102034568787,
0.8516521453857422,
0.7525312900543213,
0.6386582851409912,
0.5776762366294861,
0.277582049369812,
0.1831555962562561,
0.2823689579963684,
-0.03773671016097069,
-0.6567596197128296,
0.038482315838336945,
-0.4220869243144989,
-0.37976428866386414,
-0.4806557893753052,
0.06563527882099152,
0.3903841972351074,
0.8459917902946472,
-0.1588432490825653,
0.2159976214170456,
0.00241735833697021,
0.6189649105072021,
-0.8131657242774963,
-0.053064655512571335,
-0.41052162647247314,
0.08894526213407516,
-0.04101220890879631,
-0.23140840232372284,
-0.5016862750053406,
-0.4961180090904236,
0.3135595917701721,
-0.7928317189216614,
-0.27429288625717163,
-0.17576222121715546,
0.9016855955123901,
0.031633224338293076,
-0.46761462092399597,
-0.15852999687194824,
-0.5319529175758362,
1.1840629577636719,
-0.7005966901779175,
0.3274431526660919,
0.17310009896755219,
0.3703061044216156,
0.315149188041687,
-0.1687115728855133,
-0.33342283964157104,
-0.22514134645462036,
-0.14518113434314728,
0.050800684839487076,
-0.15365569293498993,
-0.34246060252189636,
-0.1921939253807068,
0.2647135555744171,
-0.567898154258728,
0.2591584622859955,
-0.15179912745952606,
-0.1449500024318695,
0.825931966304779,
0.22074738144874573,
0.34523898363113403,
-0.16986088454723358,
-0.5325076580047607,
-0.2658182680606842,
-0.885181188583374,
0.3573130965232849,
0.4112192690372467,
0.8679330945014954,
-0.21138131618499756,
0.8059143424034119,
-0.3690505623817444,
0.9548571109771729,
0.3332228362560272,
-0.14509864151477814,
0.38780882954597473,
-0.5626809597015381,
-0.14168380200862885,
0.2619878649711609,
0.7177205681800842,
0.7385112643241882,
0.5200507640838623,
-0.45359715819358826,
-0.25552788376808167,
-0.07764394581317902,
0.26900091767311096,
-0.6222028136253357,
0.16020002961158752,
0.13439525663852692,
-0.30850303173065186,
-0.49514392018318176,
-0.25264978408813477,
-0.3794366717338562,
-0.2291281819343567,
-0.5791140198707581,
0.5046361684799194,
-0.23310762643814087,
-0.3449755012989044,
0.4437124729156494,
-0.02273866906762123,
0.4986901581287384,
0.3445885479450226,
-1.332488775253296,
0.023638302460312843,
0.748439371585846,
0.7579874992370605,
-0.3591422140598297,
-0.52139812707901,
-0.6796290874481201,
0.23142504692077637,
-0.34689784049987793,
0.7235957384109497,
-0.48625317215919495,
-0.2990158796310425,
0.12741348147392273,
0.19149675965309143,
-0.14079038798809052,
-0.46524307131767273,
0.5451695919036865,
-0.3061088025569916,
0.599611222743988,
-0.42657989263534546,
-0.7007591724395752,
0.03694341704249382,
0.3932686448097229,
-0.5827882289886475,
0.6665396094322205,
0.3158112168312073,
-0.5560933351516724,
0.43760257959365845,
-0.7261818647384644,
-0.40816983580589294,
0.11219033598899841,
-0.030353425070643425,
-0.14061212539672852,
0.11889347434043884,
0.17462210357189178,
0.33303654193878174,
-0.08605924248695374,
0.4313632845878601,
-0.3224433660507202,
-0.39235636591911316,
0.14195206761360168,
-0.22127804160118103,
0.8027667999267578,
0.19349144399166107,
-0.23545719683170319,
0.2737768590450287,
-0.424992173910141,
-0.0009481023880653083,
0.12671636044979095,
-0.2566754221916199,
-0.6404696702957153,
-0.3862658739089966,
0.13180886209011078,
0.24990160763263702,
0.48607543110847473,
-0.7705814838409424,
0.5396478772163391,
-0.34926989674568176,
0.06472469121217728,
0.7670997977256775,
-0.3967811167240143,
0.8329307436943054,
-0.5592188239097595,
0.6782858967781067,
-0.09431874006986618,
0.007359344512224197,
-0.13411086797714233,
-0.04490762576460838,
-0.5716431140899658,
-0.054808907210826874,
0.5305266380310059,
0.6633226275444031,
-0.7416699528694153,
0.27478301525115967,
-0.4557487964630127,
-0.40231361985206604,
-0.877022922039032,
0.037609610706567764,
0.42453691363334656,
0.6126738786697388,
0.1972152590751648,
-0.3975992202758789,
-0.29327356815338135,
-1.1014145612716675,
-0.31565287709236145,
-0.00992079358547926,
-0.06378212571144104,
0.3844814598560333,
0.07706260681152344,
0.10342094302177429,
0.985203206539154,
-0.3214470148086548,
-0.03392822667956352,
-0.37488317489624023,
0.24832484126091003,
0.05727476626634598,
0.5776989459991455,
0.8108696341514587,
-0.5519579648971558,
-0.674569308757782,
0.2689460217952728,
-0.7621855139732361,
-0.2939658463001251,
-0.18409931659698486,
-0.288827121257782,
0.4723442792892456,
-0.09718687832355499,
-0.2700555622577667,
0.06656647473573685,
0.6224061250686646,
-0.3640839457511902,
0.4111957252025604,
0.06927140802145004,
0.4988735318183899,
-1.1129703521728516,
0.3955286741256714,
-0.0339539498090744,
-0.42730650305747986,
-0.7570438385009766,
-0.1411355584859848,
0.09839952737092972,
-0.08372215926647186,
-0.7114418148994446,
0.8992610573768616,
-0.3100675642490387,
-0.07146251201629639,
-0.37847229838371277,
0.192661315202713,
0.03435233607888222,
0.6475861668586731,
0.5356894731521606,
0.44754499197006226,
0.4273548424243927,
-0.34787529706954956,
0.3419152498245239,
0.25079214572906494,
-0.4027111232280731,
1.015089988708496,
-0.6141773462295532,
-0.0019582966342568398,
-0.15217651426792145,
-0.12009212374687195,
-0.9150450229644775,
-0.10116048902273178,
0.33655840158462524,
-0.44309714436531067,
0.4384303092956543,
-0.15642723441123962,
0.09643863886594772,
0.32106971740722656,
-0.45871031284332275,
0.6869513988494873,
0.2639125883579254,
-0.7634150981903076,
0.18015342950820923,
0.4455091059207916,
-0.2722534239292145,
-0.9420316815376282,
-0.6415562629699707,
-0.010054984129965305,
-0.3760583698749542,
-0.47948935627937317,
0.35136574506759644,
-0.04407580569386482,
-0.0336083248257637,
0.19123822450637817,
-0.014674634672701359,
0.2788029611110687,
0.11366631090641022,
0.1328941434621811,
0.4305421710014343,
-0.20735016465187073,
0.017107883468270302,
-0.19328990578651428,
-0.34076735377311707,
-0.42959290742874146,
-0.23712007701396942,
0.4883730709552765,
-0.01595015823841095,
-0.48806536197662354,
-0.3285229802131653,
0.605360746383667,
0.5571030378341675,
-0.1599358469247818,
0.5534221529960632,
0.3467489778995514,
-0.29042160511016846,
0.23174265027046204,
-0.3919532597064972,
-0.022104676812887192,
-0.33970561623573303,
0.14680549502372742,
-0.36059486865997314,
-1.076850414276123,
0.2768919765949249,
0.21379980444908142,
0.4361867904663086,
0.38176578283309937,
0.6621567606925964,
0.04168938845396042,
0.9344418048858643,
0.8747459053993225,
-0.3970225751399994,
0.6530683040618896,
0.19046472012996674,
0.22007900476455688,
-0.6915113925933838,
-0.15040764212608337,
-0.44006672501564026,
-0.4771632254123688,
-0.36305078864097595,
-0.07158024609088898,
0.08477837592363358,
0.16020619869232178,
-0.2698723375797272,
0.4586118757724762,
-0.326777845621109,
0.4618091881275177,
0.5339102745056152,
-0.22319386899471283,
0.3617557883262634,
0.20157571136951447,
0.019660145044326782,
-0.1296655386686325,
-0.7726033329963684,
-0.5884810090065002,
1.1645426750183105,
0.1560574322938919,
0.8469553589820862,
0.2330830842256546,
0.9725494980812073,
0.1382034868001938,
0.5114887952804565,
-0.8403193950653076,
0.1248815581202507,
-0.19777843356132507,
-0.39085930585861206,
-0.6367517113685608,
-0.416925311088562,
-0.9738336205482483,
0.3692922592163086,
-0.08610484004020691,
-0.9690007567405701,
0.27256453037261963,
0.12294378876686096,
-0.6250938773155212,
0.21087567508220673,
-0.7279824018478394,
1.3190586566925049,
-0.6085358262062073,
-0.5001294016838074,
0.13549357652664185,
-0.5817835330963135,
0.5623757839202881,
0.02604551427066326,
0.06179697811603546,
-0.10290297865867615,
0.15420180559158325,
0.7107442617416382,
-0.43113481998443604,
0.7406928539276123,
-0.08135735243558884,
-0.3062272369861603,
-0.04240129142999649,
0.18725328147411346,
0.20855912566184998,
-0.22283807396888733,
-0.1316709667444229,
0.14511428773403168,
0.14947010576725006,
-0.4735025465488434,
-0.7181088328361511,
0.8397279381752014,
-0.7906006574630737,
-0.5416958332061768,
-0.4118240475654602,
-0.7654019594192505,
-0.2372102588415146,
0.15061336755752563,
0.059880245476961136,
0.18551552295684814,
-0.3089215159416199,
0.01638871617615223,
0.09733286499977112,
-0.20512740314006805,
0.279327929019928,
0.7204868793487549,
-0.3530323803424835,
-0.32043513655662537,
1.106558084487915,
-0.005701927002519369,
0.5555846691131592,
0.4661596715450287,
0.12701186537742615,
-0.42969173192977905,
0.08308498561382294,
-0.917487621307373,
0.1961613893508911,
-0.4466085433959961,
-0.1929505318403244,
-0.3509342670440674,
0.09585142880678177,
-0.5028402209281921,
-0.643519937992096,
-0.613618791103363,
-0.8400499820709229,
-0.03272741660475731,
-0.0756894201040268,
0.2642801105976105,
0.5931335687637329,
-0.3481566905975342,
0.26195549964904785,
-0.9344055652618408,
0.13601024448871613,
0.17399083077907562,
0.496504008769989,
-0.06839791685342789,
-0.5486336350440979,
-0.44372549653053284,
0.3582581877708435,
-0.013707511126995087,
-0.8179283738136292,
0.5560511350631714,
-0.23723864555358887,
0.697775661945343,
0.2533836364746094,
-0.012378048151731491,
0.6510114073753357,
-0.3293859362602234,
0.8605578541755676,
0.48658713698387146,
-1.0134278535842896,
0.20195594429969788,
-0.2192758172750473,
0.4393070340156555,
0.7594389915466309,
0.5493378639221191,
-1.0839059352874756,
0.0673692524433136,
-0.4242573082447052,
-0.8058310151100159,
0.9568019509315491,
-0.23691369593143463,
-0.059196796268224716,
0.19072319567203522,
0.256682425737381,
0.3708451986312866,
0.19974040985107422,
-0.9714123606681824,
-0.10623051226139069,
-0.3862932622432709,
-0.31238070130348206,
-0.3273954689502716,
-0.09028221666812897,
-0.35806989669799805,
-0.08232931792736053,
0.6937605738639832,
-0.27602559328079224,
-0.08421837538480759,
-0.060499224811792374,
-0.2453317493200302,
-0.4590713679790497,
0.5603752136230469,
0.6881304979324341,
0.48715826869010925,
-0.2896093726158142,
0.031616535037755966,
-0.018673287704586983,
0.24272406101226807,
0.43861860036849976,
-0.19803094863891602,
-0.3017137944698334,
-0.13517288863658905,
0.12982329726219177,
0.9532303810119629,
0.4876386523246765,
-0.7035017609596252,
0.5778684020042419,
-0.07495159655809402,
-0.16145816445350647,
0.08260972052812576,
-0.2884560823440552,
0.3284069895744324,
0.12552538514137268,
-0.2004242092370987,
-0.3800245523452759,
-0.03740638494491577,
-0.7210658192634583,
0.16136695444583893,
0.6747730374336243,
-0.48823457956314087,
-0.23980744183063507,
0.4255664646625519,
0.1767703890800476,
-0.23324815928936005,
0.6018967628479004,
-0.11963575333356857,
-0.44777369499206543,
0.25306060910224915,
0.630489706993103,
0.9264769554138184,
-0.255801260471344,
0.44450247287750244,
0.3763158917427063,
0.14823377132415771,
-0.07456879317760468,
0.1465480476617813,
-0.22853200137615204,
-1.0064070224761963,
-0.47071006894111633,
-0.5454315543174744,
-0.5933558940887451,
-0.21196560561656952,
-0.8504312038421631,
0.34273603558540344,
0.21974892914295197,
0.10924961417913437,
0.0073017883114516735,
-0.21030253171920776,
-0.5251997709274292,
-0.10094838589429855,
0.3980691134929657,
0.585556149482727,
-1.2034350633621216,
0.8202078938484192,
0.6517480611801147,
-0.5683767795562744,
-0.9247903823852539,
-0.5028430223464966,
0.1197882667183876,
-0.872665286064148,
0.6556636691093445,
-0.09973558783531189,
-0.10657352209091187,
-0.42019057273864746,
-0.29537445306777954,
-0.8838380575180054,
1.0838079452514648,
0.4338549077510834,
-0.5527154803276062,
0.038657817989587784,
0.38660749793052673,
0.4702865779399872,
-0.7656683325767517,
0.33166781067848206,
0.5315921902656555,
0.40202611684799194,
0.2786250710487366,
-1.1456323862075806,
-0.08095578849315643,
-0.21346673369407654,
-0.20094603300094604,
0.26070788502693176,
-0.6706173419952393,
0.8449205756187439,
-0.1487031877040863,
-0.2548488676548004,
0.048140570521354675,
0.24504008889198303,
0.35048267245292664,
0.1346072107553482,
0.5435476303100586,
0.6881936192512512,
0.5847866535186768,
0.09056589007377625,
1.0641090869903564,
-0.37701964378356934,
0.46738865971565247,
1.2626286745071411,
-0.7564648985862732,
0.855722963809967,
0.7472760081291199,
0.253076434135437,
0.3631114661693573,
0.6750902533531189,
0.239543616771698,
0.6149753928184509,
0.07029349356889725,
-0.011201574467122555,
-0.44531431794166565,
-0.5492449998855591,
-0.32726794481277466,
0.5126991868019104,
-0.18425653874874115,
-0.10830150544643402,
-0.45687684416770935,
-0.17757155001163483,
-0.02806362323462963,
-0.06351116299629211,
-0.28875109553337097,
0.824090838432312,
-0.14019767940044403,
-1.051956057548523,
0.6890419125556946,
0.06671592593193054,
0.7870384454727173,
-0.6631942391395569,
0.02481897920370102,
-0.38862061500549316,
0.052152518182992935,
-0.26502954959869385,
-0.8335340023040771,
0.2961024045944214,
0.1541774868965149,
-0.22637493908405304,
-0.5772002339363098,
0.5745497345924377,
-1.0274962186813354,
-0.41332706809043884,
0.16871443390846252,
0.6995790004730225,
0.23153936862945557,
0.22848334908485413,
-0.4923401474952698,
-0.1999918669462204,
0.26569312810897827,
-0.30324816703796387,
0.7313841581344604,
0.10336373001337051,
-0.3090360462665558,
0.40815672278404236,
0.6176306009292603,
0.03750133141875267,
-0.08172423392534256,
0.33101433515548706,
0.5631778240203857,
-0.7641072869300842,
-0.33833229541778564,
-0.8375675678253174,
0.6638052463531494,
0.0022952924482524395,
-0.2638329267501831,
0.7420170307159424,
0.6600894331932068,
1.2168874740600586,
-0.15488415956497192,
0.8807093501091003,
0.1402626484632492,
0.47478610277175903,
-0.3574155569076538,
0.5575162172317505,
-0.9199844002723694,
-0.019720841199159622,
-0.27398785948753357,
-0.7115784883499146,
-0.3316866457462311,
0.5865895748138428,
-0.26261159777641296,
-0.17251256108283997,
0.3895224630832672,
0.6539709568023682,
-0.12253902107477188,
-0.05580626428127289,
0.48526960611343384,
-0.5055636167526245,
0.18015585839748383,
1.0175817012786865,
0.8719878196716309,
-0.14086610078811646,
0.2422511726617813,
-0.46420764923095703,
-0.2775771915912628,
-0.16148999333381653,
-1.0780397653579712,
-0.483784556388855,
-0.43825244903564453,
-0.3846611976623535,
-0.011384179815649986,
-0.08497200906276703,
1.1141046285629272,
0.6342507004737854,
-0.9027506113052368,
-0.736962080001831,
0.5299227833747864,
0.3026653230190277,
-0.32278144359588623,
-0.21181322634220123,
0.20412354171276093,
-0.3740823566913605,
-0.9337339997291565,
0.32590019702911377,
0.47407427430152893,
-0.010860959067940712,
-0.2630763053894043,
-0.37956786155700684,
-0.22992143034934998,
-0.021186478435993195,
0.5504458546638489,
0.5977088212966919,
-0.6917877793312073,
-0.58598792552948,
0.2799774408340454,
-0.30468469858169556,
0.06586597114801407,
1.0107519626617432,
-0.586502194404602,
0.5242090225219727,
0.5269882082939148,
0.8712428212165833,
0.3732873499393463,
0.21408498287200928,
1.0407276153564453,
-0.6565552949905396,
0.04687239229679108,
0.053789086639881134,
0.6274470686912537,
0.4821638762950897,
-0.2376008927822113,
0.5515559911727905,
-0.03176804631948471,
-0.4668826758861542,
-0.9206420183181763,
0.25447362661361694,
-1.1752632856369019,
-0.24587862193584442,
1.0804922580718994,
-0.2188161313533783,
-0.11689817160367966,
0.20801863074302673,
-0.16810815036296844,
0.29681652784347534,
-0.30546286702156067,
0.6781954765319824,
0.8554752469062805,
-0.22024863958358765,
-0.1799294501543045,
-0.12834089994430542,
0.2956749498844147,
0.9409884214401245,
-0.6709210872650146,
0.3138008713722229,
0.49419891834259033,
0.41366273164749146,
0.22631360590457916,
0.7257323265075684,
-0.2082744687795639,
0.3242989778518677,
-0.35405826568603516,
0.5832545161247253,
-0.09438972175121307,
-0.1977887600660324,
-0.9048182964324951,
0.18078359961509705,
0.2724727988243103,
-0.31869834661483765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12299v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12299v1
|
Simultaneous Interpretation Corpus Construction by Large Language Models in Distant Language Pair
| 2024-04-18T16:24:12 | 2024-04-18T16:24:12 |
Yusuke Sakai, Mana Makinae, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In Simultaneous Machine Translation (SiMT) systems, training with a
simultaneous interpretation (SI) corpus is an effective method for achieving
high-quality yet low-latency systems. However, it is very challenging to curate
such a corpus due to limitations in the abilities of annotators, and hence,
existing SI corpora are limited. Therefore, we propose a method to convert
existing speech translation corpora into interpretation-style data, maintaining
the original word order and preserving the entire source content using Large
Language Models (LLM-SI-Corpus). We demonstrate that fine-tuning SiMT models in
text-to-text and speech-to-text settings with the LLM-SI-Corpus reduces
latencies while maintaining the same level of quality as the models trained
with offline datasets. The LLM-SI-Corpus is available at
\url{https://github.com/yusuke1997/LLM-SI-Corpus}.
|
[
-0.1296210139989853,
-0.5348142385482788,
0.6843956708908081,
0.1992921084165573,
-0.6367183923721313,
0.04718373715877533,
-0.5384312272071838,
-0.6683223843574524,
0.33753207325935364,
0.7978635430335999,
-0.5486371517181396,
-0.5224952101707458,
-0.5300318598747253,
0.16591542959213257,
-0.4419533610343933,
1.0808664560317993,
-0.1095980554819107,
0.558122456073761,
-0.20285257697105408,
-0.24574053287506104,
-0.3794918954372406,
-0.34885039925575256,
-0.4942750036716461,
-0.09939498454332352,
0.42729878425598145,
0.24461887776851654,
1.109127163887024,
0.7712505459785461,
0.4941088557243347,
0.21029596030712128,
-0.06282605975866318,
0.2271462380886078,
-0.5066965818405151,
0.31014785170555115,
-0.16140952706336975,
-0.4252587556838989,
-0.44959548115730286,
-0.13435815274715424,
1.1577786207199097,
1.0496928691864014,
0.18194501101970673,
0.11008697748184204,
0.061968713998794556,
0.24295549094676971,
-0.23233970999717712,
0.24069055914878845,
-0.6251794099807739,
-0.24802765250205994,
-0.3249446451663971,
-0.40178316831588745,
-0.6945661306381226,
-0.19291970133781433,
0.058718595653772354,
-0.46915963292121887,
-0.02609136700630188,
0.19838561117649078,
0.7516798973083496,
0.6183016300201416,
-0.44744330644607544,
0.005891496781259775,
-1.0118523836135864,
0.9215416312217712,
-0.7176668643951416,
0.6641002297401428,
0.2111348807811737,
0.12741373479366302,
-0.09871264547109604,
-0.5675845146179199,
-0.25384238362312317,
-0.29658469557762146,
-0.014465543441474438,
0.37165510654449463,
0.11198730766773224,
0.019493674859404564,
0.1468658298254013,
0.29801374673843384,
-0.5392810106277466,
0.18195097148418427,
-0.5818763375282288,
-0.21665871143341064,
0.6730157732963562,
0.07436756044626236,
0.18514780700206757,
-0.03749512881040573,
-0.5449165105819702,
0.0767788290977478,
-0.8600490689277649,
-0.48308688402175903,
0.2922254204750061,
0.27321794629096985,
-0.17513275146484375,
0.6536744832992554,
-0.1442812979221344,
0.5623138546943665,
-0.24125464260578156,
-0.1155686229467392,
0.3458331823348999,
-0.4247511327266693,
-0.17890284955501556,
0.18486085534095764,
0.7984514832496643,
0.14711113274097443,
0.007494864519685507,
-0.3954082429409027,
-0.27701693773269653,
0.06695616245269775,
0.09266286343336105,
-0.6520484089851379,
0.14129719138145447,
0.11702565103769302,
-0.5137093663215637,
-0.2881941497325897,
0.10592643171548843,
-0.6841012239456177,
-0.1325290948152542,
-0.6952782273292542,
0.226895272731781,
-0.4421744644641876,
-0.304371178150177,
-0.04930398613214493,
0.24477776885032654,
0.0035304161719977856,
0.3311386704444885,
-0.7119925022125244,
0.5416251420974731,
0.5937237739562988,
0.9896283745765686,
-0.4157734215259552,
-0.4514307379722595,
-1.0939884185791016,
0.2773611545562744,
-0.3191368579864502,
0.638441801071167,
-0.50227952003479,
-0.27323606610298157,
-0.20455294847488403,
-0.04232045263051987,
-0.1667831391096115,
-0.44332537055015564,
0.6699878573417664,
-0.5529237985610962,
0.054722726345062256,
0.15985272824764252,
-0.6458205580711365,
0.09244920313358307,
-0.24589477479457855,
-0.7004970908164978,
0.9871096014976501,
0.0063573820516467094,
-0.8165059089660645,
0.08891082555055618,
-0.6564557552337646,
-0.3675186336040497,
0.15808211266994476,
-0.15475942194461823,
-0.16953904926776886,
0.20424100756645203,
0.1832846701145172,
0.5201095938682556,
-0.344849169254303,
0.4251750111579895,
-0.5135916471481323,
-0.5597059726715088,
0.1908896565437317,
-0.5627659559249878,
0.6487715244293213,
0.48193299770355225,
-0.07271009683609009,
0.1952245533466339,
-0.6904575228691101,
-0.17418909072875977,
0.06082385033369064,
-0.18829646706581116,
-0.45296430587768555,
0.14748352766036987,
0.23307134211063385,
0.2856076955795288,
0.45398131012916565,
-0.5316756963729858,
0.018171628937125206,
-0.5446664094924927,
0.2912525534629822,
0.5315498113632202,
-0.2054423689842224,
0.4459562599658966,
-0.22285844385623932,
0.5300012826919556,
-0.04978882148861885,
-0.0017501787515357137,
-0.057507336139678955,
-0.41961973905563354,
-0.6647512912750244,
-0.3383207321166992,
0.3983522653579712,
0.6965001225471497,
-0.6826662421226501,
0.250318318605423,
-0.8048363327980042,
-0.3283778131008148,
-0.8274562358856201,
0.1759396493434906,
0.08901765942573547,
0.02950725331902504,
0.3584364056587219,
-0.22967027127742767,
-0.40076813101768494,
-0.6921238899230957,
-0.06613031774759293,
0.0059191077016294,
-0.06630709767341614,
0.04894263297319412,
0.2258252501487732,
-0.14690537750720978,
0.8452078104019165,
-0.3892247676849365,
0.13849088549613953,
-0.16560539603233337,
0.1627076119184494,
0.012362506240606308,
0.4080221652984619,
0.4085591435432434,
-1.0802768468856812,
-0.28419291973114014,
0.10204629600048065,
-0.776197075843811,
-0.38483425974845886,
-0.2891729176044464,
-0.2766241431236267,
0.09188994020223618,
0.9569187164306641,
-0.3416571319103241,
0.23915933072566986,
0.8758238554000854,
-0.1620049625635147,
0.5908762812614441,
-0.1851605772972107,
0.05079910159111023,
-1.5382366180419922,
0.09664620459079742,
-0.23601937294006348,
-0.5835740566253662,
-0.6666364669799805,
0.1276656985282898,
-0.06456708908081055,
-0.11060117930173874,
-0.6123416423797607,
0.6138243675231934,
-0.5712141394615173,
-0.3842395544052124,
-0.35665732622146606,
0.3484635353088379,
-0.0794873982667923,
0.18539837002754211,
0.35738232731819153,
0.6335614919662476,
0.41361865401268005,
-0.28525134921073914,
0.3721722364425659,
0.322905033826828,
-0.19655747711658478,
0.5344364643096924,
-0.3964880108833313,
0.13941940665245056,
-0.01281753834336996,
0.37158578634262085,
-0.7712050080299377,
-0.36635667085647583,
0.18955186009407043,
-0.2942811846733093,
0.37995022535324097,
-0.17908330261707306,
-0.7205482125282288,
0.017940232530236244,
-0.2193896621465683,
0.5559080839157104,
0.37024787068367004,
-0.664742648601532,
0.17001114785671234,
0.13875021040439606,
-0.5393850803375244,
-0.32166025042533875,
-0.861286997795105,
0.18627436459064484,
-0.2314550131559372,
-0.7887994647026062,
0.5052185654640198,
-0.28060513734817505,
-0.4058873653411865,
0.1370425820350647,
0.07090309262275696,
-0.0943954661488533,
-0.028009433299303055,
0.31649303436279297,
0.6826066970825195,
-0.43310096859931946,
0.2658754587173462,
0.3982892632484436,
-0.07880913466215134,
-0.1045689508318901,
-0.3959115147590637,
0.6069347858428955,
0.06274964660406113,
-0.4846477210521698,
-0.4941879212856293,
0.5840880274772644,
0.8420091867446899,
-0.23930996656417847,
1.0192561149597168,
0.633956789970398,
-0.2241288125514984,
0.043048083782196045,
-0.5622730851173401,
-0.09924203902482986,
-0.36071598529815674,
0.23304258286952972,
-0.6925708651542664,
-0.9562883377075195,
0.41165563464164734,
-0.36609941720962524,
0.07114490121603012,
0.5345165133476257,
0.6302413940429688,
0.23839202523231506,
0.9611900448799133,
0.47974693775177,
-0.1599547117948532,
0.7012315988540649,
0.22512026131153107,
-0.10882951319217682,
-0.821435809135437,
0.19410467147827148,
-0.20000849664211273,
0.12901604175567627,
-0.6906799674034119,
-0.41389861702919006,
0.3212601840496063,
0.15501894056797028,
0.07996217906475067,
0.28125032782554626,
-0.22776824235916138,
0.4390702247619629,
0.5285846590995789,
0.2830657660961151,
0.6570039987564087,
0.1975111961364746,
-0.06000173091888428,
-0.030181938782334328,
-0.46979498863220215,
-0.6010157465934753,
1.0600323677062988,
0.3428603410720825,
0.4754813015460968,
-0.031003277748823166,
1.002678394317627,
-0.13829971849918365,
0.10281422734260559,
-0.6224125027656555,
0.4408041834831238,
-0.4246528148651123,
-0.5327627658843994,
-0.21094806492328644,
-0.7224864363670349,
-0.7142429947853088,
0.3634696900844574,
-0.20741653442382812,
-0.745336651802063,
-0.20597895979881287,
-0.17863012850284576,
-0.3544520437717438,
0.3274368643760681,
-0.6815080642700195,
0.8709250688552856,
-0.16323089599609375,
-0.4558316171169281,
-0.3708118796348572,
-0.7492069005966187,
0.3688475489616394,
-0.47198501229286194,
0.32295939326286316,
-0.14838729798793793,
-0.09685825556516647,
0.62469083070755,
-0.43127045035362244,
0.691199779510498,
0.14874963462352753,
-0.11335200816392899,
0.19876328110694885,
0.06743007153272629,
0.5552611351013184,
0.14984947443008423,
-0.4256174564361572,
0.3683360815048218,
0.2588704526424408,
-0.44790610671043396,
-0.4194280207157135,
0.7833858132362366,
-0.7531988620758057,
-0.2564021050930023,
-0.2569447159767151,
-0.8788115382194519,
-0.10547401756048203,
0.26012009382247925,
0.29395073652267456,
0.4988710284233093,
-0.20769526064395905,
0.06515733152627945,
0.357229083776474,
-0.18798640370368958,
0.0686446875333786,
0.2467634081840515,
-0.21566739678382874,
-0.31756025552749634,
0.8116431832313538,
0.09283553063869476,
0.8390654921531677,
0.3905634880065918,
0.040827780961990356,
-0.2716735601425171,
-0.7881496548652649,
-0.5331010818481445,
0.4304393231868744,
-0.5098152756690979,
0.0890231803059578,
-0.4737420082092285,
-0.3549145758152008,
-0.5629711747169495,
0.0057873474434018135,
-0.3841663599014282,
-0.453531414270401,
-0.3189166188240051,
0.3042197525501251,
0.2946391701698303,
0.827082097530365,
-0.0530095100402832,
0.5075739026069641,
-1.0919829607009888,
0.3447486162185669,
-0.16559019684791565,
0.2781279385089874,
-0.5413822531700134,
-0.6909787654876709,
-0.28580641746520996,
0.21155409514904022,
0.1414107084274292,
-0.8417351841926575,
0.5796399116516113,
-0.03666185587644577,
0.25583064556121826,
0.20799320936203003,
0.05724204704165459,
0.7607707977294922,
-0.5624616742134094,
0.5907357931137085,
0.09277723729610443,
-0.8754827380180359,
0.49380841851234436,
-0.6091327667236328,
0.39406877756118774,
0.5834113359451294,
0.22667644917964935,
-0.6807987093925476,
-0.5626246929168701,
-0.48525840044021606,
-0.8750213980674744,
1.0282983779907227,
0.36874839663505554,
-0.04816262423992157,
0.26639389991760254,
0.27670910954475403,
0.3107887804508209,
0.0441468320786953,
-0.7573257088661194,
-0.087697833776474,
0.12844863533973694,
-0.40382418036460876,
-0.07564093917608261,
-0.2206743210554123,
0.0577271468937397,
-0.0700734481215477,
0.8178670406341553,
-0.15339477360248566,
0.31985360383987427,
-0.07452716678380966,
-0.2597787380218506,
-0.2710588276386261,
0.4318408668041229,
0.3815138638019562,
0.42101672291755676,
-0.29377281665802,
0.1300659328699112,
0.46578681468963623,
-0.4333750903606415,
-0.19206495583057404,
0.2886813282966614,
-0.245228573679924,
0.12375206500291824,
0.36073407530784607,
0.9506587386131287,
0.5334147214889526,
-0.5401423573493958,
0.46738722920417786,
0.09451615810394287,
0.15935814380645752,
-0.43113669753074646,
-0.29157009720802307,
0.2184695452451706,
0.28907570242881775,
0.0006038843421265483,
0.16694387793540955,
0.0013314095558598638,
-0.4531247615814209,
0.16913986206054688,
0.16473343968391418,
-0.10863912105560303,
-0.24013012647628784,
0.7870755195617676,
-0.013457456603646278,
0.01754577085375786,
0.5176761746406555,
-0.33491405844688416,
-0.307475209236145,
0.2769499123096466,
0.5890889167785645,
0.831651508808136,
-0.237528458237648,
0.05995014309883118,
0.15635307133197784,
0.06030762195587158,
-0.4607081413269043,
0.10579504072666168,
-0.005383704788982868,
-0.6149800419807434,
-0.7899125814437866,
-0.9473251700401306,
-0.6372725367546082,
0.15499313175678253,
-0.7860744595527649,
0.6592240929603577,
-0.02773413248360157,
0.2645057737827301,
0.1667954921722412,
-0.19785930216312408,
-0.4073522090911865,
0.06672345101833344,
0.43626126646995544,
0.44440576434135437,
-0.8183879256248474,
1.2650736570358276,
0.6577306985855103,
-0.4591611623764038,
-0.6668192744255066,
0.21127046644687653,
0.033695101737976074,
-0.6088485717773438,
0.6243064999580383,
0.05514108017086983,
-0.29968830943107605,
0.12820498645305634,
-0.49637553095817566,
-1.0946635007858276,
1.0672234296798706,
0.7719147801399231,
-0.8470290899276733,
-0.08686868101358414,
0.3924233615398407,
0.5189675092697144,
-0.295580118894577,
0.21947067975997925,
0.5256119966506958,
0.3059851825237274,
0.14606624841690063,
-1.206771731376648,
0.025207923725247383,
-0.03423082455992699,
-0.18687684834003448,
0.30702126026153564,
-0.620844304561615,
0.6094686985015869,
0.11996296048164368,
-0.3101601004600525,
0.4188201129436493,
0.7552257180213928,
0.10886190831661224,
0.3053635358810425,
0.6972300410270691,
0.18187060952186584,
0.6220678091049194,
0.08824338763952255,
0.8441488742828369,
-0.3810998499393463,
0.3361487090587616,
1.4721940755844116,
-0.3037027418613434,
1.1863124370574951,
0.5656205415725708,
-0.09253783524036407,
0.15164195001125336,
0.6522220969200134,
-0.023089533671736717,
0.233651265501976,
-0.07916946709156036,
-0.456501305103302,
-0.5102338790893555,
-0.24261827766895294,
-0.2639000713825226,
0.4834956228733063,
0.3835146427154541,
-0.4000312089920044,
-0.07905161380767822,
0.14365965127944946,
0.10501204431056976,
0.030534040182828903,
-0.1121600791811943,
0.417183518409729,
0.29050660133361816,
-0.5659424066543579,
0.4255944788455963,
-0.1537962108850479,
0.7101832628250122,
-0.4937345087528229,
0.2089742124080658,
0.08910918235778809,
0.13695792853832245,
-0.3030882477760315,
-0.5448589324951172,
0.5621356964111328,
0.06145218014717102,
0.005402491427958012,
-0.3067050576210022,
0.4514799118041992,
-0.7961386442184448,
-0.6927387714385986,
0.5983631610870361,
0.6621325016021729,
0.6847309470176697,
-0.07939372211694717,
-0.42692795395851135,
0.22904030978679657,
-0.03977936506271362,
-0.22897657752037048,
0.32769903540611267,
0.38081738352775574,
-0.2862561345100403,
0.3313482403755188,
0.6529148817062378,
0.4417721629142761,
0.21551360189914703,
0.2870638966560364,
0.7181820273399353,
-0.6587701439857483,
-0.3495867848396301,
-0.8429769277572632,
0.0911218672990799,
-0.04547005891799927,
-0.06420495361089706,
0.5124216079711914,
0.6719851493835449,
0.8787299990653992,
0.060458164662122726,
0.7337093353271484,
0.03813102841377258,
0.494467556476593,
-0.72945237159729,
0.5235169529914856,
-0.7408914566040039,
0.3760223090648651,
-0.42433395981788635,
-1.146914005279541,
-0.5999355316162109,
0.32530343532562256,
-0.5358951091766357,
-0.2479945868253708,
0.9204232096672058,
0.8126423358917236,
-0.37103271484375,
0.22622913122177124,
0.5664071440696716,
0.2999359667301178,
-0.06776043772697449,
0.45065173506736755,
0.8167397379875183,
-0.3932395279407501,
0.8024678230285645,
-0.3209533393383026,
-0.19118700921535492,
-0.10197198390960693,
-0.640282154083252,
-0.7031236290931702,
-0.5967115163803101,
-0.42710021138191223,
-0.28210821747779846,
0.05485949665307999,
1.1598714590072632,
0.637355387210846,
-0.7575146555900574,
-0.29505613446235657,
-0.035398632287979126,
-0.27609390020370483,
-0.17770203948020935,
-0.17043150961399078,
0.438357949256897,
-0.362449586391449,
-1.1536322832107544,
0.7550769448280334,
0.1812380850315094,
0.021029485389590263,
-0.20956513285636902,
-0.2436433881521225,
-0.11959308385848999,
-0.08001862466335297,
0.6117466688156128,
-0.09385321289300919,
-0.7183699607849121,
-0.2807158827781677,
-0.07669146358966827,
-0.017065929248929024,
0.13890664279460907,
0.5075010657310486,
-0.40862032771110535,
0.46558088064193726,
0.450411856174469,
0.5701413154602051,
0.8144617080688477,
-0.02796209789812565,
0.5339527130126953,
-0.7084774374961853,
0.37388375401496887,
0.06724849343299866,
0.555367648601532,
0.3862081468105316,
-0.36818552017211914,
0.6479783058166504,
0.25758233666419983,
-0.5340884923934937,
-0.800499677658081,
0.3434211015701294,
-1.3229568004608154,
-0.15499302744865417,
1.497658610343933,
-0.21609926223754883,
-0.16894441843032837,
-0.055303897708654404,
-0.405962735414505,
0.6991032361984253,
-0.2698071002960205,
0.3008226752281189,
0.683638870716095,
0.0027493382804095745,
0.08375414460897446,
-0.9215860962867737,
0.057928070425987244,
0.5911502838134766,
-0.8665347099304199,
0.12185502052307129,
0.5288028120994568,
0.2690110504627228,
0.23431862890720367,
0.3559845983982086,
-0.21364106237888336,
0.08878930658102036,
0.112809918820858,
-0.09013239294290543,
0.10888667404651642,
-0.1992245614528656,
-0.5953888297080994,
-0.051846835762262344,
0.23303942382335663,
-0.2619796097278595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12291v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12291v2
|
Augmenting emotion features in irony detection with Large language modeling
| 2024-04-18T16:11:17 | 2024-04-20T01:52:29 |
Yucheng Lin, Yuhan Xia, Yunfei Long
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study introduces a novel method for irony detection, applying Large
Language Models (LLMs) with prompt-based learning to facilitate emotion-centric
text augmentation. Traditional irony detection techniques typically fall short
due to their reliance on static linguistic features and predefined knowledge
bases, often overlooking the nuanced emotional dimensions integral to irony. In
contrast, our methodology augments the detection process by integrating subtle
emotional cues, augmented through LLMs, into three benchmark pre-trained NLP
models - BERT, T5, and GPT-2 - which are widely recognized as foundational in
irony detection. We assessed our method using the SemEval-2018 Task 3 dataset
and observed substantial enhancements in irony detection capabilities.
|
[
-0.3887432813644409,
-0.5975674390792847,
0.7368486523628235,
0.3236038088798523,
-0.4700314700603485,
-0.14959873259067535,
-0.26481688022613525,
-0.7639052867889404,
0.33104372024536133,
0.3588336706161499,
-0.6382719874382019,
-0.4620116055011749,
-0.5752920508384705,
0.3876042366027832,
-0.09178094565868378,
0.7895110845565796,
0.10286934673786163,
-0.019489185884594917,
-0.03839930519461632,
-0.1708623766899109,
-0.039848800748586655,
-0.45660606026649475,
-0.7952857613563538,
-0.16922299563884735,
0.8106235265731812,
0.5964846611022949,
0.42829659581184387,
0.14120759069919586,
0.3634055256843567,
0.24252763390541077,
-0.019459206610918045,
-0.05907807499170303,
-0.25595030188560486,
0.2683848738670349,
0.09212788194417953,
-0.4732838273048401,
-0.5541579127311707,
0.06316079199314117,
0.40692219138145447,
0.32268109917640686,
0.22195102274417877,
-0.01412090752273798,
-0.21781650185585022,
0.6539364457130432,
-0.8046509623527527,
-0.09202642738819122,
-0.4479813277721405,
0.2937064468860626,
-0.1802210807800293,
-0.34289470314979553,
-0.4349753260612488,
-0.5368843078613281,
0.1895449310541153,
-0.08074638992547989,
-0.08329755812883377,
0.03525605797767639,
0.3386240005493164,
0.3892444670200348,
-0.518372118473053,
-0.2913803458213806,
-0.4069628119468689,
0.7929835319519043,
-0.9856933355331421,
0.053468286991119385,
-0.043258100748062134,
0.16232897341251373,
0.32702815532684326,
-0.5685668587684631,
-0.7150663733482361,
-0.29573652148246765,
0.10249777883291245,
0.1796349287033081,
-0.2874302864074707,
0.19887666404247284,
0.44719186425209045,
0.3989001214504242,
-0.4355538487434387,
0.3009883761405945,
0.23787060379981995,
0.18584182858467102,
0.667993426322937,
0.03298962861299515,
0.3803170919418335,
-0.30874601006507874,
-0.5653756856918335,
0.06043460592627525,
-0.48158058524131775,
0.0726635679602623,
0.8287498354911804,
0.03671112656593323,
-0.029731623828411102,
0.4575928747653961,
-0.06226580590009689,
0.32015201449394226,
-0.2494383007287979,
0.2836483120918274,
0.48043394088745117,
0.3983440399169922,
-0.0963565856218338,
0.1317790150642395,
0.6227092742919922,
0.32998794317245483,
0.4535163938999176,
0.2522853910923004,
-0.5434054732322693,
0.010037211701273918,
-0.09515128284692764,
-0.6498063206672668,
-0.18568842113018036,
0.4000481069087982,
-0.3252023160457611,
-0.5289524793624878,
-0.2638677656650543,
-0.6053535342216492,
-0.7014209032058716,
-0.11535921692848206,
0.4553911089897156,
-0.592034101486206,
-0.289283812046051,
0.059203241020441055,
-0.43612241744995117,
0.2791696786880493,
0.5228093862533569,
-0.6073561906814575,
-0.0932084396481514,
0.7005288004875183,
0.5763923525810242,
0.11126919835805893,
-0.08366499841213226,
-0.43474966287612915,
-0.22610105574131012,
-0.13822874426841736,
0.9604337811470032,
-0.8170145153999329,
-0.1612829715013504,
0.0935429036617279,
-0.10609249025583267,
0.1662016361951828,
-0.3807136118412018,
0.9953488707542419,
-0.3280949890613556,
0.16046643257141113,
-0.3027055561542511,
-0.6097177863121033,
-0.40617936849594116,
0.32485905289649963,
-0.9527988433837891,
1.4163506031036377,
0.23413290083408356,
-1.0754324197769165,
-0.0660964846611023,
-0.8001108169555664,
-0.6123937964439392,
0.09427343308925629,
0.22730767726898193,
-0.3227543532848358,
0.36949411034584045,
0.35792845487594604,
0.6477060914039612,
-0.2314462959766388,
0.03994224965572357,
-0.7635048627853394,
-0.533169150352478,
0.5326660871505737,
-0.536427915096283,
0.7625836730003357,
0.09010466188192368,
-0.5050753355026245,
-0.03373463451862335,
-0.5080477595329285,
-0.2825978696346283,
0.07035360485315323,
0.01320712361484766,
-0.46809467673301697,
-0.17118680477142334,
0.1231178566813469,
0.45024755597114563,
0.5908960700035095,
-0.47544071078300476,
0.04487959295511246,
-0.48431921005249023,
0.09601002931594849,
0.9759283065795898,
-0.04739144816994667,
0.05721328780055046,
-0.09919589012861252,
0.7008819580078125,
0.022628944367170334,
0.2499704360961914,
-0.213934987783432,
-0.3012179732322693,
-0.8463723659515381,
-0.48673954606056213,
0.10716164112091064,
0.812468945980072,
-0.6584445834159851,
0.6855731010437012,
-0.02735973335802555,
-0.16601553559303284,
-0.702362596988678,
-0.06144746392965317,
0.08199995756149292,
0.49271148443222046,
0.2556835412979126,
-0.00025827824720181525,
-0.6276179552078247,
-0.8182376623153687,
-0.6653081774711609,
-0.021594272926449776,
0.015276611782610416,
0.5315158367156982,
0.39060014486312866,
0.07438378781080246,
0.49144554138183594,
-0.329374760389328,
-0.04289103299379349,
-0.3575204014778137,
0.6841538548469543,
0.10481850802898407,
0.10507404804229736,
0.5459057688713074,
-0.7951876521110535,
-0.6725786924362183,
-0.09187816828489304,
-0.6852964758872986,
-0.5764673352241516,
0.19652578234672546,
0.3126372694969177,
0.47248539328575134,
0.5297943949699402,
-0.475132018327713,
0.39699339866638184,
0.3483436405658722,
-0.0982368066906929,
0.775898814201355,
0.19173969328403473,
0.5904533267021179,
-1.0152294635772705,
0.13242875039577484,
-0.04054604098200798,
-0.2746090292930603,
-0.5750044584274292,
-0.15421687066555023,
0.08530787378549576,
0.02117709070444107,
-0.5850968956947327,
0.6592587232589722,
-0.5504258275032043,
-0.15329064428806305,
-0.3756366968154907,
0.334026038646698,
0.03991809859871864,
0.3227333724498749,
-0.14890049397945404,
0.49316856265068054,
0.4235801100730896,
-0.08642401546239853,
0.5146419405937195,
-0.24199435114860535,
-0.26699715852737427,
1.0027012825012207,
-0.516676664352417,
0.0646982342004776,
-0.16600187122821808,
0.3494100868701935,
-1.3292909860610962,
-0.3996679484844208,
0.1636563092470169,
-0.5341527462005615,
0.2192007154226303,
-0.06178579851984978,
-0.5860912799835205,
-0.544402539730072,
-0.825797975063324,
0.36612600088119507,
0.640388011932373,
-0.5582137107849121,
0.9621186852455139,
-0.2038346230983734,
-0.6304143071174622,
-0.8958067893981934,
-0.5477575659751892,
0.20643623173236847,
-0.4206359386444092,
-0.8226531744003296,
0.044509585946798325,
-0.041537899523973465,
-0.11616917699575424,
0.038290634751319885,
0.19048182666301727,
0.23951543867588043,
0.29442182183265686,
0.07785072177648544,
0.23529593646526337,
-0.08129723370075226,
0.4015345573425293,
0.06742029637098312,
0.04671899974346161,
0.11508826911449432,
-0.05479951947927475,
0.4816107153892517,
-0.03211282938718796,
-0.39000964164733887,
-0.6629078388214111,
0.5645762085914612,
0.5960934162139893,
-0.264710932970047,
0.56928551197052,
1.1370110511779785,
-0.3499860465526581,
-0.42434707283973694,
-0.7698734402656555,
-0.3588038384914398,
-0.456144779920578,
0.36795300245285034,
-0.16724036633968353,
-1.1688947677612305,
0.7705846428871155,
-0.4351976215839386,
-0.33362123370170593,
0.47786903381347656,
0.27523571252822876,
-0.35618826746940613,
1.299317717552185,
0.8034679293632507,
-0.1278795301914215,
0.7345312833786011,
0.12484867870807648,
0.4041999280452728,
-1.218244194984436,
0.15498842298984528,
-0.5493199825286865,
-0.6197888851165771,
-0.4427509009838104,
-0.47060033679008484,
0.3281187117099762,
-0.1448422223329544,
-0.19978149235248566,
-0.4176259934902191,
-0.2020789086818695,
0.3993717133998871,
0.2190726399421692,
0.29462069272994995,
-0.060531534254550934,
-0.2042936384677887,
0.0667499378323555,
-0.14116056263446808,
-0.3199000358581543,
-0.3432648479938507,
0.9645848870277405,
0.26929768919944763,
0.7379404306411743,
0.17862477898597717,
0.7749641537666321,
0.4979988932609558,
0.538263201713562,
-0.8257091641426086,
0.5686216950416565,
-0.5006557703018188,
-0.27577993273735046,
-0.1481582373380661,
-0.4643174707889557,
-0.4290955364704132,
-0.2653730809688568,
-0.07860749214887619,
-0.9498386383056641,
0.11460896581411362,
0.2437778115272522,
-0.2966391146183014,
0.2658449113368988,
-0.7323378324508667,
0.7796069383621216,
-0.30430376529693604,
-0.10558893531560898,
-0.06864197552204132,
-0.9227499961853027,
0.5961430668830872,
0.06825115531682968,
0.14556340873241425,
-0.3529142737388611,
-0.19718949496746063,
0.4537191092967987,
-0.2047564536333084,
1.069828748703003,
-0.33370280265808105,
-0.18561720848083496,
0.16380244493484497,
-0.07996249943971634,
1.0391818284988403,
-0.25038349628448486,
-0.3493817150592804,
-0.2091001272201538,
-0.8649618029594421,
-0.3036231994628906,
-0.712023913860321,
0.7895148396492004,
-0.5618346333503723,
-0.543889582157135,
-0.3208945691585541,
-0.7419670820236206,
-0.11197222024202347,
-0.1522897630929947,
0.106361024081707,
0.12887856364250183,
-0.15437684953212738,
0.07691104710102081,
1.032658338546753,
-0.3417653739452362,
0.5184139609336853,
0.3009946644306183,
0.10955701768398285,
-0.48363518714904785,
0.6107293367385864,
-0.03298059478402138,
0.2744990289211273,
0.43443068861961365,
0.25559839606285095,
-0.5884331464767456,
-0.18671441078186035,
0.13649028539657593,
0.2677483558654785,
-1.0914474725723267,
-0.0567648708820343,
-1.0845121145248413,
-0.038927845656871796,
-0.7002439498901367,
-0.4977007508277893,
-0.1445876955986023,
-0.5726136565208435,
-0.5061656832695007,
-0.08707331866025925,
0.7235987186431885,
0.5337453484535217,
-0.25146958231925964,
0.5667679905891418,
-0.7356916069984436,
0.15548290312290192,
0.3444828689098358,
0.23458759486675262,
0.04182327166199684,
-0.8748698830604553,
-0.01571838930249214,
-0.39419472217559814,
0.03363832086324692,
-0.9915454387664795,
0.46231499314308167,
0.2547370195388794,
0.3426707684993744,
0.5882517099380493,
0.297294557094574,
0.3268764615058899,
-0.2539527416229248,
0.9480943083763123,
0.09749297052621841,
-1.1377109289169312,
0.605104923248291,
-0.31557711958885193,
0.24601319432258606,
0.2971843183040619,
0.5192428827285767,
-0.5767312049865723,
-0.2826569974422455,
-0.726276159286499,
-1.1071901321411133,
0.6014416217803955,
-0.15487810969352722,
0.25671806931495667,
0.011083527468144894,
0.307171493768692,
-0.0055898320861160755,
0.27685314416885376,
-0.8555084466934204,
-0.005899566691368818,
0.20764636993408203,
-0.7848948240280151,
-0.006802583113312721,
-0.600578784942627,
-0.003903753124177456,
0.08149263262748718,
0.8690158128738403,
-0.1717560738325119,
0.3022781312465668,
0.17945842444896698,
-0.2526252269744873,
-0.005813343916088343,
0.43791690468788147,
0.5091179609298706,
-0.07848889380693436,
-0.3731594979763031,
0.3243628144264221,
0.18032421171665192,
-0.1639057844877243,
-0.02811255492269993,
0.47947973012924194,
0.24504926800727844,
0.006768933031708002,
0.4551404118537903,
0.9180412292480469,
0.34404367208480835,
-0.5854355692863464,
0.7203917503356934,
0.22338542342185974,
0.055385980755090714,
-0.3324708938598633,
-0.08336197584867477,
0.17769630253314972,
0.6904286742210388,
0.44385313987731934,
-0.006390684749931097,
0.6918081045150757,
-0.3631928861141205,
0.1962454617023468,
0.5109712481498718,
-0.5395861864089966,
-0.37382444739341736,
0.21561850607395172,
0.3520098626613617,
-0.06706719100475311,
0.31929925084114075,
-0.3229702115058899,
-1.1639982461929321,
0.7000585198402405,
0.4560462534427643,
1.3395569324493408,
-0.7344716787338257,
0.17395219206809998,
0.11375115811824799,
0.5673137307167053,
-0.0041569871827960014,
0.8739479184150696,
-0.016801754012703896,
-0.5000226497650146,
-0.4792860448360443,
-0.4096747636795044,
-0.4290013313293457,
-0.044536858797073364,
-0.4141078591346741,
0.5230103731155396,
-0.264112263917923,
-0.005296050570905209,
-0.13954894244670868,
-0.11824841052293777,
-0.5407939553260803,
0.2526208162307739,
0.5053287148475647,
0.9057363271713257,
-1.1731582880020142,
0.44738006591796875,
0.7884480357170105,
0.001588103943504393,
-0.7132435441017151,
0.20307886600494385,
0.09951461851596832,
-0.6999368667602539,
0.5009909272193909,
0.6446585059165955,
-0.3770357072353363,
0.245714008808136,
-0.9205505847930908,
-0.334919810295105,
0.8304585814476013,
0.4681892693042755,
-0.33515286445617676,
0.43985575437545776,
-0.1168891191482544,
0.5104958415031433,
-0.5586104393005371,
0.5763686299324036,
0.4067050814628601,
0.605118989944458,
0.2529357075691223,
-0.3025120496749878,
0.08522124588489532,
-0.30812448263168335,
-0.20485465228557587,
0.3860531151294708,
-0.562203586101532,
1.0074543952941895,
-0.22624056041240692,
-0.08549493551254272,
-0.12112902104854584,
0.5863972902297974,
0.19898095726966858,
0.4001070261001587,
0.7229047417640686,
1.0114067792892456,
0.8281837701797485,
-0.006572296842932701,
0.9438627362251282,
-0.08605846017599106,
0.3902842402458191,
1.0360276699066162,
-0.6521326303482056,
0.8437404632568359,
0.4996165633201599,
0.10072660446166992,
0.6542303562164307,
0.8319131135940552,
0.25031372904777527,
0.11319982260465622,
-0.017427900806069374,
-0.8274378180503845,
-0.4941706359386444,
-0.3678916394710541,
-0.2589974105358124,
0.1912965029478073,
0.5727874040603638,
-0.5215526819229126,
-0.05834845080971718,
0.12750481069087982,
0.2651593089103699,
-0.275373637676239,
-0.3656846880912781,
0.5365817546844482,
0.179757758975029,
-0.20274633169174194,
0.1934896558523178,
-0.31078192591667175,
0.7678236961364746,
-0.3614431321620941,
-0.10573598742485046,
-0.24633009731769562,
-0.13620221614837646,
-0.13840918242931366,
-0.9334855079650879,
-0.1906106173992157,
0.21181733906269073,
0.018627354875206947,
0.20480826497077942,
0.9422504305839539,
-0.5493341088294983,
-0.45366302132606506,
0.3832913339138031,
0.17717918753623962,
0.1980101764202118,
-0.31332799792289734,
-0.7239220142364502,
0.07447339594364166,
-0.14855538308620453,
-0.5504612922668457,
-0.12367944419384003,
1.1827306747436523,
0.08966874331235886,
0.4806116819381714,
0.5140370726585388,
-0.133073091506958,
-0.21850784122943878,
0.3921392261981964,
0.7997218370437622,
-0.7799786925315857,
-0.6226206421852112,
-0.980131208896637,
0.8380245566368103,
-0.42526933550834656,
-0.11777792125940323,
0.4718305468559265,
0.0695958212018013,
0.2492409497499466,
-0.23515430092811584,
1.0519359111785889,
-0.03033698908984661,
0.4200972616672516,
-0.4757487177848816,
0.2982846200466156,
-0.8098039031028748,
0.24229192733764648,
-0.50848788022995,
-0.8672214150428772,
-0.4676051735877991,
0.42566433548927307,
-0.48484718799591064,
0.33462172746658325,
0.6973433494567871,
0.5492837429046631,
0.040205638855695724,
0.1759009063243866,
0.4122423529624939,
0.5009470582008362,
0.017791587859392166,
0.6383678913116455,
1.0995241403579712,
-0.27820640802383423,
0.10371522605419159,
-0.10453445464372635,
-0.561492383480072,
-0.9117847084999084,
-1.2190637588500977,
-0.8050077557563782,
-0.22315026819705963,
-0.31847167015075684,
-0.05012942850589752,
-0.04576344043016434,
0.9554178714752197,
0.08572801202535629,
-0.534862756729126,
0.3206579387187958,
0.32125601172447205,
0.3084738254547119,
-0.10055175423622131,
-0.29128244519233704,
0.3501165807247162,
-0.47074708342552185,
-0.683972954750061,
0.06499385833740234,
0.6915891170501709,
0.023891765624284744,
-0.08665314316749573,
0.09873043745756149,
-0.42464005947113037,
0.5031129121780396,
0.7326538562774658,
0.003055304754525423,
-0.47442173957824707,
-0.6440276503562927,
0.09863623231649399,
-0.02920358255505562,
-0.09286227077245712,
0.6714359521865845,
-0.41086429357528687,
0.390302836894989,
0.6027623414993286,
0.5889787077903748,
-0.014010929502546787,
0.041823092848062515,
0.26358097791671753,
-1.0434201955795288,
0.26368409395217896,
0.5095618963241577,
0.45110172033309937,
0.7170480489730835,
-0.7793804407119751,
0.3698541224002838,
0.3807756006717682,
-0.6846351027488708,
-0.9016538262367249,
0.32431939244270325,
-1.1673760414123535,
-0.07676411420106888,
0.8845388889312744,
-0.3495820164680481,
-0.37581172585487366,
0.055705226957798004,
-0.13667897880077362,
0.3911324143409729,
-0.4174836575984955,
0.8029559254646301,
0.6601731181144714,
-0.30447104573249817,
-0.488584041595459,
-0.42885518074035645,
0.4339856207370758,
0.6530013084411621,
-0.9591268301010132,
0.18749146163463593,
0.5738838911056519,
0.01187123078852892,
-0.09805653989315033,
0.4008115530014038,
-0.08535906672477722,
0.4910535216331482,
-0.30927902460098267,
0.6570151448249817,
0.36201873421669006,
-0.3484058976173401,
-0.5913342833518982,
0.08194610476493835,
0.052616044878959656,
0.19707776606082916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12289v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12289v1
|
Resilience through Scene Context in Visual Referring Expression Generation
| 2024-04-18T16:10:38 | 2024-04-18T16:10:38 |
Simeon Junker, Sina Zarrieß
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Scene context is well known to facilitate humans' perception of visible
objects. In this paper, we investigate the role of context in Referring
Expression Generation (REG) for objects in images, where existing research has
often focused on distractor contexts that exert pressure on the generator. We
take a new perspective on scene context in REG and hypothesize that contextual
information can be conceived of as a resource that makes REG models more
resilient and facilitates the generation of object descriptions, and object
types in particular. We train and test Transformer-based REG models with target
representations that have been artificially obscured with noise to varying
degrees. We evaluate how properties of the models' visual context affect their
processing and performance. Our results show that even simple scene contexts
make models surprisingly resilient to perturbations, to the extent that they
can identify referent types even when visual information about the target is
completely missing.
|
[
-0.08640868961811066,
-0.33147090673446655,
0.4745282232761383,
0.037281282246112823,
-0.2721822261810303,
-0.4090020954608917,
0.08445479720830917,
-0.6077675819396973,
-0.36860203742980957,
0.37093234062194824,
-0.5262707471847534,
0.23106123507022858,
-0.2819226384162903,
0.5057958960533142,
-0.4070955514907837,
0.7652370929718018,
0.1275242120027542,
-0.057443298399448395,
-0.5640092492103577,
-0.27994564175605774,
-0.93967205286026,
-0.633397102355957,
-0.502258837223053,
0.10845545679330826,
0.5517728924751282,
0.057482123374938965,
0.5289466381072998,
0.6499859690666199,
1.015802025794983,
0.3529585599899292,
0.2761487662792206,
-0.19345299899578094,
-0.6358170509338379,
0.621356189250946,
-0.3732554018497467,
-0.4158068299293518,
0.06097393482923508,
-0.327037513256073,
0.698016345500946,
0.21554674208164215,
-0.0162506066262722,
0.2350742220878601,
0.14708589017391205,
0.45592203736305237,
-0.7492363452911377,
0.23617132008075714,
-0.8652632832527161,
0.12966062128543854,
-0.06879835575819016,
-0.29646527767181396,
-0.5132192969322205,
0.21883545815944672,
0.1453993022441864,
-0.5429869890213013,
0.634877622127533,
0.16031180322170258,
1.0364223718643188,
0.5375964045524597,
-0.18097862601280212,
0.3131367564201355,
-0.9598926305770874,
0.5940625071525574,
-0.1281307190656662,
0.3386390209197998,
-0.010689778253436089,
0.729091465473175,
-0.2186807543039322,
-1.0896246433258057,
-0.38577884435653687,
-0.14456406235694885,
-0.3444533348083496,
0.13251711428165436,
-0.3444500267505646,
-0.21983785927295685,
0.5439690947532654,
0.05342366546392441,
0.10390959680080414,
-0.48666390776634216,
-0.39710894227027893,
-0.17528767883777618,
0.1309743970632553,
0.43199294805526733,
0.3139684200286865,
-0.2925944924354553,
-0.6383591294288635,
-0.21144700050354004,
-0.8486389517784119,
0.12071257829666138,
-0.28166019916534424,
0.15192796289920807,
0.2604658305644989,
0.373163640499115,
-0.012265394441783428,
1.1064387559890747,
0.12918972969055176,
-0.13490940630435944,
-0.12724804878234863,
-0.5154682397842407,
-0.21394191682338715,
-0.2513260841369629,
0.45213639736175537,
0.69237220287323,
0.328332781791687,
-0.051069892942905426,
-0.2462838888168335,
0.08574073016643524,
0.7959973216056824,
-0.8986124992370605,
-0.16668421030044556,
-0.5073882341384888,
-0.537405252456665,
-0.23253771662712097,
0.24375250935554504,
-0.541692316532135,
-0.3066762089729309,
0.043646492063999176,
0.262502521276474,
-0.4342133104801178,
-0.12825244665145874,
-0.17623253166675568,
-0.3024091124534607,
0.15750452876091003,
0.3757613003253937,
-0.44869357347488403,
0.008265210315585136,
0.1766020953655243,
0.5100874900817871,
0.24790866672992706,
-0.3353908956050873,
-0.5433269739151001,
0.4260326027870178,
-0.2762097716331482,
1.0409780740737915,
-0.8328710198402405,
-0.4996855854988098,
-0.03347040340304375,
0.4201197922229767,
-0.06209398806095123,
-0.6528106927871704,
0.2947402596473694,
-0.34129586815834045,
-0.07202563434839249,
-0.36127549409866333,
-0.09377972036600113,
-0.13095158338546753,
0.10602778196334839,
-0.9102620482444763,
0.7176147699356079,
0.39033204317092896,
-0.8009711503982544,
0.5141774415969849,
-0.3641207218170166,
-0.30088546872138977,
-0.023116691038012505,
-0.3717919886112213,
-0.5119538903236389,
0.5565668344497681,
0.03310953825712204,
0.24104611575603485,
-0.19461633265018463,
0.046869631856679916,
-0.13551557064056396,
-0.13368551433086395,
0.6845060586929321,
-0.355760395526886,
-0.1411849707365036,
0.009546531364321709,
-0.08377767354249954,
0.16142065823078156,
-0.568385660648346,
-0.32559266686439514,
0.22426004707813263,
-0.07116371393203735,
-0.28696051239967346,
0.22291381657123566,
0.009566301479935646,
0.6263692378997803,
-0.0345313586294651,
-0.41391244530677795,
-0.30977192521095276,
0.20621997117996216,
0.42497172951698303,
0.5713822245597839,
0.4115811586380005,
0.08833874017000198,
-0.3955771028995514,
0.4749593734741211,
0.352906197309494,
-0.03146691247820854,
-0.525806188583374,
-0.45756033062934875,
-0.6290343403816223,
-0.09862899035215378,
-0.060301247984170914,
0.23627647757530212,
-0.7776780724525452,
0.00960666686296463,
-0.3022221028804779,
-0.13244859874248505,
-0.22567453980445862,
-0.355116605758667,
0.6290692687034607,
1.3018838167190552,
0.32914310693740845,
-0.18257386982440948,
-0.7460168600082397,
-1.290451169013977,
-0.12569935619831085,
-0.060501452535390854,
-0.2614598572254181,
0.5894554257392883,
0.28118622303009033,
-0.0316431000828743,
1.2594276666641235,
-0.5689400434494019,
-0.2785247266292572,
-0.1755571961402893,
-0.2341422289609909,
-0.2656990885734558,
0.5109778046607971,
0.6990271806716919,
-1.0786761045455933,
-0.14190401136875153,
-0.1972290426492691,
-0.6843317747116089,
-0.04025651514530182,
-0.25613218545913696,
-0.12768562138080597,
-0.11088036745786667,
0.6451565027236938,
-0.23092223703861237,
0.7262565493583679,
0.13023969531059265,
-0.49285638332366943,
0.4440467357635498,
0.06161777302622795,
0.1276177614927292,
-1.2675426006317139,
0.30463919043540955,
0.1863822191953659,
-0.42827457189559937,
-0.7461386322975159,
-0.03244118392467499,
-0.10933443903923035,
-0.48882317543029785,
-0.6757494211196899,
0.4565719664096832,
-0.3739938735961914,
-0.20289669930934906,
-0.23337048292160034,
-0.08434321731328964,
0.08814200013875961,
0.1447693109512329,
0.5007296800613403,
1.0267339944839478,
0.48072877526283264,
-0.470051109790802,
-0.08527006953954697,
0.46745559573173523,
-0.29695793986320496,
0.7214869260787964,
-0.7420604228973389,
-0.12605436146259308,
-0.3139392137527466,
0.34426286816596985,
-1.0380477905273438,
-0.5801695585250854,
0.11961479485034943,
-0.13144426047801971,
0.3188970983028412,
-0.10209686309099197,
-0.17866703867912292,
-0.19070714712142944,
0.1324537694454193,
0.7160520553588867,
0.5335437059402466,
-0.4275484085083008,
0.594943642616272,
0.18564245104789734,
0.13330549001693726,
-0.43901515007019043,
-0.5981870293617249,
0.12012425065040588,
-0.4753577411174774,
-0.5648897290229797,
0.28155064582824707,
-0.02452540025115013,
-0.2568790018558502,
0.10517916083335876,
-0.37093061208724976,
-0.23697152733802795,
0.1209806427359581,
0.7104055881500244,
0.3529016077518463,
-0.0987091138958931,
0.0926705151796341,
-0.658031702041626,
-0.03014364279806614,
0.11703196913003922,
0.47262027859687805,
0.2776804268360138,
-0.15397170186042786,
-0.27379027009010315,
-0.3502752482891083,
0.34520959854125977,
0.4961796700954437,
0.02314959093928337,
0.524622917175293,
0.2623664140701294,
-0.4853973388671875,
0.1434306502342224,
-0.3895239531993866,
-0.301030695438385,
-0.5054882168769836,
0.6829555034637451,
-0.6110388040542603,
-0.8077818751335144,
0.7042664885520935,
0.02543526515364647,
-0.1970803141593933,
0.4214331805706024,
0.17423881590366364,
0.12759876251220703,
0.6715538501739502,
0.6464225649833679,
0.23309701681137085,
0.8362685441970825,
0.15316911041736603,
0.10145248472690582,
-1.1849911212921143,
-0.2870045006275177,
-0.28846409916877747,
-0.36780744791030884,
-0.25388026237487793,
-0.60772305727005,
0.34093475341796875,
0.12638723850250244,
-0.13997483253479004,
0.4981294274330139,
-0.71649569272995,
0.4317653477191925,
0.3131762146949768,
0.35327792167663574,
0.03027384541928768,
-0.016942622140049934,
0.3694175183773041,
-0.11583849042654037,
-0.8052815794944763,
-0.5335896015167236,
0.664630651473999,
0.38408705592155457,
0.7417648434638977,
-0.19477583467960358,
0.4452528953552246,
-0.014169709756970406,
0.5750024318695068,
-0.5574374794960022,
0.6952527165412903,
0.06230713427066803,
-0.5214570760726929,
-0.14161372184753418,
-0.1429658979177475,
-0.9896371364593506,
0.11582239717245102,
-0.2525429129600525,
-0.6837576031684875,
0.6284694075584412,
0.15476416051387787,
-0.5123388171195984,
0.03597850352525711,
-0.4370200037956238,
0.8234338760375977,
0.36154696345329285,
-0.500056803226471,
0.04946248233318329,
-0.6981843113899231,
0.15010423958301544,
-0.0921940803527832,
-0.03997081145644188,
0.18943557143211365,
-0.05949206277728081,
0.5009174346923828,
-0.29022344946861267,
1.0054432153701782,
-0.008380110375583172,
0.05000554025173187,
0.60137540102005,
0.37371158599853516,
0.44283267855644226,
0.10875672847032547,
0.16742661595344543,
0.027216080576181412,
-0.40482595562934875,
-0.0106353173032403,
-0.6886436939239502,
0.32572129368782043,
-0.2740625739097595,
-0.8346286416053772,
-0.037974365055561066,
-0.745066225528717,
0.019797703251242638,
0.019153034314513206,
0.5128046870231628,
0.6967942118644714,
-0.17217187583446503,
0.5255447030067444,
0.5100493431091309,
-0.1160721406340599,
0.6667584180831909,
0.3968786895275116,
0.10892396420240402,
-0.3148903250694275,
0.8164642453193665,
-0.017484642565250397,
0.40632766485214233,
0.2850089967250824,
-0.08206207305192947,
0.07229983061552048,
-0.14385412633419037,
-0.015164483338594437,
-0.13982127606868744,
-0.8936859369277954,
-0.731106698513031,
-0.12539483606815338,
-0.2639044523239136,
0.052049774676561356,
-0.3540344536304474,
-0.22126172482967377,
-0.4169526994228363,
-0.31999948620796204,
-0.23462919890880585,
0.19271545112133026,
0.7014732360839844,
0.1018163412809372,
0.04624764621257782,
-0.7906285524368286,
0.3481804430484772,
0.7249544262886047,
0.2399090677499771,
-0.1549275815486908,
-0.36378130316734314,
-0.20861239731311798,
-0.20795822143554688,
-0.056951720267534256,
-0.6192196607589722,
0.23619775474071503,
0.2662559151649475,
0.3518550992012024,
0.3822942078113556,
0.06912273913621902,
0.8036206960678101,
-0.9294859170913696,
0.8871080279350281,
0.22549135982990265,
-0.5082504749298096,
0.5834457874298096,
-0.3377077877521515,
0.2209470421075821,
0.3685823380947113,
-0.2114037573337555,
-0.24821700155735016,
-0.5012916326522827,
-0.6910251379013062,
-0.6400918364524841,
0.5601974725723267,
0.21957999467849731,
0.27375340461730957,
-0.4291202127933502,
0.4028134346008301,
-0.09100130945444107,
0.08075564354658127,
-0.8642581701278687,
-0.0022746562026441097,
-0.589531421661377,
0.13358174264431,
0.1700764000415802,
-0.566227376461029,
-0.5040116310119629,
0.04736759886145592,
-0.2059788703918457,
-0.06303392350673676,
0.5770876407623291,
0.6125227212905884,
-0.04540052264928818,
-0.2739585340023041,
-0.07273740321397781,
0.8000196218490601,
0.5482408404350281,
-0.1653875857591629,
0.07336042076349258,
0.029762160032987595,
-0.3673350214958191,
0.1542436182498932,
-0.3210074007511139,
-0.0003880274307448417,
0.14164407551288605,
0.692340612411499,
1.0090680122375488,
0.5719344019889832,
-0.5975425839424133,
0.29986971616744995,
-0.21625784039497375,
0.045037735253572464,
-0.21896082162857056,
0.31825366616249084,
-0.17797571420669556,
0.19273518025875092,
0.5341705083847046,
0.47840654850006104,
0.08875565230846405,
-0.6016789674758911,
0.4312001168727875,
0.37788936495780945,
-0.5005929470062256,
-0.40591147541999817,
0.8166686296463013,
0.13889029622077942,
-0.3779364824295044,
0.5008375644683838,
0.39672958850860596,
-0.3711640536785126,
0.8316881060600281,
1.020941138267517,
1.0652118921279907,
-0.2838391065597534,
-0.1771944910287857,
0.5081188082695007,
0.052488941699266434,
-0.08359059691429138,
-0.051228176802396774,
0.04848873242735863,
-0.9483688473701477,
0.02448257803916931,
-0.3417307138442993,
-0.12493319809436798,
-0.1196998879313469,
-0.888487696647644,
-0.09577945619821548,
-0.3776823580265045,
-0.4025268852710724,
-0.3386165201663971,
-0.8770465850830078,
-0.6496957540512085,
0.4584232568740845,
0.02145916409790516,
0.9727872014045715,
-0.8047046661376953,
0.5642665028572083,
0.92880779504776,
-0.5040856003761292,
-0.7303649187088013,
0.36610856652259827,
-0.5353320837020874,
-0.59616619348526,
1.2744054794311523,
0.42140188813209534,
-0.14207571744918823,
-0.026749059557914734,
-0.4007141590118408,
-0.9528183937072754,
1.078135371208191,
0.4663419723510742,
-0.39910927414894104,
0.09599374979734421,
-0.08354919403791428,
0.6483356952667236,
-0.7174829244613647,
-0.07525889575481415,
0.1996336728334427,
0.41651713848114014,
0.2785189151763916,
-0.5969243049621582,
0.48760735988616943,
-0.19623102247714996,
0.3950735628604889,
-0.015818707644939423,
-0.7549077272415161,
0.8114102482795715,
-0.10307569801807404,
-0.5453213453292847,
0.13499952852725983,
0.591605007648468,
0.21743914484977722,
-0.10222666710615158,
0.5607733726501465,
0.33845335245132446,
0.08071490377187729,
-0.19779732823371887,
1.2587095499038696,
-0.4043920636177063,
-0.012390484102070332,
1.2410281896591187,
-0.20463405549526215,
0.8322159647941589,
0.6877481341362,
0.09698942303657532,
0.7496932744979858,
0.32322731614112854,
-0.1310819834470749,
0.8068267107009888,
0.09121948480606079,
-0.37587612867355347,
-0.4335823655128479,
-0.42429471015930176,
-0.3246682584285736,
0.44513389468193054,
0.2015901356935501,
-0.41702666878700256,
-0.4248484671115875,
0.06907513737678528,
-0.5149585604667664,
0.08878180384635925,
-0.270221471786499,
0.7878358364105225,
0.04414426535367966,
-0.4879794716835022,
0.3973715007305145,
-0.4943515956401825,
-0.10034958273172379,
-0.41901275515556335,
-0.431437611579895,
-0.2830207049846649,
0.02972656674683094,
-0.07840428501367569,
-0.7504764199256897,
0.5803502202033997,
-0.23942390084266663,
-0.5876107811927795,
-0.14526726305484772,
1.0127416849136353,
-0.1670294553041458,
-0.45202943682670593,
-0.0892040804028511,
-0.02715642750263214,
-0.10034285485744476,
0.07355139404535294,
-0.39852237701416016,
-0.01400713063776493,
-0.05832674354314804,
-0.4012082815170288,
0.583053469657898,
0.7170335054397583,
-0.291649729013443,
0.849755585193634,
0.21543821692466736,
-0.25823357701301575,
-0.06549398601055145,
-0.14731472730636597,
1.0826358795166016,
-0.6721978187561035,
-0.039585571736097336,
-0.8176395297050476,
0.868084192276001,
-0.023491481319069862,
-0.21566618978977203,
0.73396897315979,
0.32784175872802734,
0.5112519860267639,
-0.5643014311790466,
0.5239098072052002,
-0.15334199368953705,
0.18521082401275635,
-0.23905102908611298,
0.4059589207172394,
-0.1852196305990219,
0.11627435684204102,
-0.271696537733078,
-0.9341132640838623,
-0.4193253517150879,
0.7416731715202332,
-0.06894344091415405,
-0.13775596022605896,
0.6367936730384827,
0.6976902484893799,
-0.05387679114937782,
-0.6068533658981323,
0.4990677535533905,
-0.09317759424448013,
0.2030366063117981,
0.47181859612464905,
0.8425211906433105,
-0.38861849904060364,
0.5963974595069885,
-0.11878957599401474,
0.07634704560041428,
-0.10600969195365906,
-1.0746667385101318,
-0.8251979351043701,
-0.7058857083320618,
-0.363260954618454,
-0.3534930944442749,
-0.1069018766283989,
0.13792282342910767,
0.5968435406684875,
-0.5132120251655579,
-0.026405122131109238,
-0.37665894627571106,
-0.03981370851397514,
-0.14086125791072845,
-0.27894848585128784,
0.15029768645763397,
-0.5672969818115234,
-0.5360977649688721,
0.44467124342918396,
0.3951297998428345,
0.2714596688747406,
-0.051914066076278687,
0.2168990522623062,
0.1722813844680786,
0.042617179453372955,
0.41390079259872437,
0.2821516990661621,
-0.5853062272071838,
-0.8254448771476746,
-0.2620678246021271,
-0.003873099572956562,
0.23715834319591522,
0.9076434373855591,
-1.1751986742019653,
0.4864959716796875,
0.33212172985076904,
0.4110856056213379,
-0.10993959754705429,
0.5126727223396301,
0.9789535403251648,
-1.0207111835479736,
0.483675479888916,
0.05206923931837082,
0.7287342548370361,
0.4198848009109497,
-0.4741396903991699,
0.8097025752067566,
0.3014466166496277,
-0.443491667509079,
-0.9489157795906067,
0.6464648246765137,
-0.625317394733429,
-0.2892874479293823,
0.9315440058708191,
-0.334821492433548,
-0.40421125292778015,
0.24511906504631042,
-0.47723111510276794,
0.1319081038236618,
-0.21124328672885895,
0.9041333794593811,
0.6965107321739197,
-0.13377346098423004,
-0.400471031665802,
-0.1917697787284851,
0.682471513748169,
0.20937024056911469,
-0.5021656155586243,
0.3073120713233948,
0.8063631057739258,
0.2930864989757538,
0.5175235271453857,
0.2591014504432678,
0.04345159977674484,
0.4238705635070801,
0.20719294250011444,
-0.07104147225618362,
-0.3392486870288849,
-0.37916019558906555,
-0.280880331993103,
0.282547265291214,
0.0162021666765213,
-0.3741859793663025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12283v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12283v1
|
Enhancing Embedding Performance through Large Language Model-based Text Enrichment and Rewriting
| 2024-04-18T15:58:56 | 2024-04-18T15:58:56 |
Nicholas Harris, Anand Butani, Syed Hashmy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Embedding models are crucial for various natural language processing tasks
but can be limited by factors such as limited vocabulary, lack of context, and
grammatical errors. This paper proposes a novel approach to improve embedding
performance by leveraging large language models (LLMs) to enrich and rewrite
input text before the embedding process. By utilizing ChatGPT 3.5 to provide
additional context, correct inaccuracies, and incorporate metadata, the
proposed method aims to enhance the utility and accuracy of embedding models.
The effectiveness of this approach is evaluated on three datasets:
Banking77Classification, TwitterSemEval 2015, and Amazon Counter-factual
Classification. Results demonstrate significant improvements over the baseline
model on the TwitterSemEval 2015 dataset, with the best-performing prompt
achieving a score of 85.34 compared to the previous best of 81.52 on the
Massive Text Embedding Benchmark (MTEB) Leaderboard. However, performance on
the other two datasets was less impressive, highlighting the importance of
considering domain-specific characteristics. The findings suggest that
LLM-based text enrichment has shown promising results to improve embedding
performance, particularly in certain domains. Hence, numerous limitations in
the process of embedding can be avoided.
|
[
-0.15575216710567474,
-1.2079839706420898,
0.6892727017402649,
0.16685444116592407,
-0.44889605045318604,
0.4378663897514343,
-0.4036107659339905,
-0.2998718321323395,
0.19880816340446472,
0.7431621551513672,
-0.30155596137046814,
-0.7764341831207275,
-0.8021215200424194,
-0.13351400196552277,
-0.2825157940387726,
0.8044860363006592,
-0.2551068663597107,
-0.17221330106258392,
-0.2409517914056778,
0.11633683741092682,
-0.6264261603355408,
-0.4754096269607544,
-0.5590527057647705,
-0.2604336142539978,
0.4141426086425781,
0.396600604057312,
0.7663131356239319,
0.7758487462997437,
0.41356199979782104,
0.24019910395145416,
-0.13684815168380737,
0.46522483229637146,
-0.552642285823822,
0.3263190984725952,
-0.11479517817497253,
-0.22251971065998077,
-0.41306135058403015,
-0.14600147306919098,
0.8352789282798767,
0.4666284918785095,
-0.2612046003341675,
-0.15384049713611603,
0.335743248462677,
0.18867667019367218,
-0.44120827317237854,
0.4137738049030304,
-0.6224210262298584,
-0.13509675860404968,
0.07501892000436783,
-0.4451020359992981,
-0.5569201111793518,
-0.5018296241760254,
0.3776108920574188,
-0.5020479559898376,
0.20285335183143616,
0.2102580964565277,
0.660960853099823,
0.29044967889785767,
-0.35787737369537354,
-0.3257792592048645,
-0.5310644507408142,
0.7553256750106812,
-0.9753564596176147,
0.47432592511177063,
0.3961470425128937,
0.0969773530960083,
-0.23133188486099243,
-0.770686686038971,
-0.3449620306491852,
-0.190432608127594,
-0.06327590346336365,
-0.18468409776687622,
0.021857865154743195,
-0.0004608913150150329,
0.22472381591796875,
0.2998807728290558,
-0.35136762261390686,
0.20840878784656525,
-0.010286706499755383,
-0.18671898543834686,
0.48976993560791016,
0.0671701729297638,
0.25352728366851807,
-0.12832768261432648,
-0.18033839762210846,
-0.2132626324892044,
-0.8907719850540161,
-0.2555294930934906,
0.35417500138282776,
0.545787513256073,
0.12363386154174805,
0.7377369999885559,
-0.1086258739233017,
0.3694462478160858,
-0.3331393003463745,
-0.05305037274956703,
0.3043379783630371,
-0.21305964887142181,
-0.20949283242225647,
0.09776192903518677,
0.4734352231025696,
0.31773316860198975,
0.1742834895849228,
-0.18171411752700806,
-0.3564499020576477,
-0.3136686384677887,
0.28058743476867676,
-1.002190351486206,
-0.000552416720893234,
0.22522033751010895,
-0.4336325228214264,
-0.41727349162101746,
-0.04412985220551491,
-0.5596444606781006,
-0.47996068000793457,
-0.30891838669776917,
0.46495187282562256,
-0.7300925850868225,
-0.04324212297797203,
0.1440146118402481,
0.027751246467232704,
0.2665307819843292,
0.44619086384773254,
-0.7641453146934509,
0.10950764268636703,
1.1580729484558105,
0.9576750993728638,
0.08955063670873642,
-0.1921679526567459,
-0.5577314496040344,
0.3449501097202301,
-0.013177641667425632,
0.8475249409675598,
-0.9639891386032104,
-0.3965199887752533,
0.4287737011909485,
-0.11631282418966293,
-0.010309056378901005,
-0.4081818461418152,
0.7675057649612427,
-0.6896413564682007,
0.09087948501110077,
-0.06714066863059998,
-1.1068496704101562,
-0.16842254996299744,
0.3192654550075531,
-0.7853412628173828,
1.1249315738677979,
-0.03527979180216789,
-0.627461314201355,
0.3857114315032959,
-0.6972149610519409,
-0.4171588718891144,
0.020040342584252357,
0.10670466721057892,
-0.43336111307144165,
0.13547322154045105,
0.6350029706954956,
0.7690227627754211,
-0.20634254813194275,
0.4401158094406128,
-0.17350147664546967,
-0.5286993384361267,
0.22048786282539368,
-0.5975421071052551,
0.14039818942546844,
-0.03152449056506157,
-0.033965833485126495,
-0.03914690017700195,
-0.5171142220497131,
-0.021480189636349678,
0.05718464031815529,
-0.4354700744152069,
-0.2430419921875,
0.18041858077049255,
0.1381174772977829,
-0.0897025540471077,
0.3304680287837982,
-0.6474606990814209,
0.36397838592529297,
-0.5061837434768677,
0.5497661828994751,
0.819093644618988,
0.15326794981956482,
0.33177122473716736,
-0.3680102527141571,
0.4556213617324829,
-0.12048587203025818,
-0.20245742797851562,
-0.3207418918609619,
-0.5594115257263184,
-0.5234324932098389,
-0.347430020570755,
0.6754856705665588,
0.5187416076660156,
-0.6443541646003723,
0.4092004597187042,
-0.570672333240509,
-0.4604889750480652,
-0.7682629823684692,
0.21090780198574066,
0.09290811419487,
0.2279919683933258,
0.46994614601135254,
-0.07317373156547546,
-0.5905309915542603,
-0.857805609703064,
-0.4480441212654114,
0.21126972138881683,
-0.035190753638744354,
0.3978537619113922,
0.387151300907135,
-0.4529726207256317,
0.8427485823631287,
-0.7794908285140991,
-0.046518564224243164,
-0.3864648640155792,
0.07548380643129349,
0.27822718024253845,
0.5512785315513611,
0.009272794239223003,
-0.5472442507743835,
-0.5366036891937256,
-0.08114320784807205,
-0.4495651423931122,
-0.15732842683792114,
-0.052433960139751434,
-0.09293144196271896,
0.12527000904083252,
0.6890239715576172,
-0.3551589250564575,
0.4100516438484192,
0.5603629350662231,
-0.23705556988716125,
0.23541036248207092,
-0.3161267638206482,
0.04741905629634857,
-1.3398218154907227,
-0.2031765729188919,
-0.08908657729625702,
-0.4937710165977478,
-0.4985852539539337,
-0.043348945677280426,
0.06387437134981155,
-0.08621346950531006,
-0.3008159101009369,
0.43374335765838623,
-0.3663087487220764,
0.14408883452415466,
-0.40818825364112854,
0.5077000260353088,
0.03881888836622238,
0.2831230163574219,
-0.11095549911260605,
0.6529189944267273,
0.3856866657733917,
-0.34830188751220703,
0.2624606192111969,
0.3391129672527313,
-0.5489938259124756,
0.1175529733300209,
-0.7881051301956177,
0.0945698618888855,
-0.030701732262969017,
0.5033034682273865,
-0.9998424649238586,
-0.0771942287683487,
0.26547667384147644,
-0.30875515937805176,
0.4420540928840637,
-0.2264081984758377,
-0.84312504529953,
0.20935356616973877,
-0.3833405375480652,
0.29052531719207764,
0.4491131603717804,
-0.6238824129104614,
0.7357334494590759,
0.12652447819709778,
-0.3852965533733368,
-0.5384235382080078,
-0.5890761017799377,
0.3496626615524292,
-0.2465459555387497,
-0.6834444999694824,
0.765392541885376,
0.23043839633464813,
0.11143272370100021,
0.11862502247095108,
0.21777145564556122,
0.18892450630664825,
0.07954833656549454,
0.048721566796302795,
0.16231903433799744,
-0.21204525232315063,
0.3757389485836029,
0.13040360808372498,
-0.1604379564523697,
-0.14863966405391693,
-0.21198999881744385,
0.7319608330726624,
0.22312703728675842,
-0.40859460830688477,
-0.46526509523391724,
0.527204155921936,
0.2601633071899414,
-0.37180712819099426,
1.2408218383789062,
0.6271347999572754,
-0.392280250787735,
-0.3667842745780945,
-0.6879342198371887,
-0.1547030210494995,
-0.48134467005729675,
0.3476982116699219,
-0.2348131537437439,
-1.3222401142120361,
0.429928183555603,
-0.19909755885601044,
0.1996942162513733,
0.21696846187114716,
0.5485374927520752,
0.046769674867391586,
0.8463305234909058,
0.6996297240257263,
-0.1075211688876152,
0.7269641757011414,
-0.10290628671646118,
0.5811416506767273,
-0.9535130858421326,
-0.09954924136400223,
-0.3681536018848419,
-0.24801810085773468,
-1.0051007270812988,
-0.8003165125846863,
-0.1442641317844391,
-0.1666182428598404,
-0.10407879948616028,
0.23001055419445038,
-0.11698310822248459,
0.4318556785583496,
0.3838008940219879,
0.2635956108570099,
0.2768403887748718,
0.12587596476078033,
-0.1778331696987152,
-0.054347649216651917,
-0.5822341442108154,
-0.9636154770851135,
1.293167233467102,
0.6829748749732971,
0.7987487316131592,
0.27503296732902527,
0.7582756280899048,
0.35565385222435,
0.43628308176994324,
-0.663345992565155,
0.32583674788475037,
-0.09945864230394363,
-0.3022625148296356,
-0.3045699894428253,
-0.3781285583972931,
-0.7877599000930786,
0.37775900959968567,
-0.3127616345882416,
-0.7282299995422363,
-0.1436489075422287,
0.06310942769050598,
-0.25813546776771545,
0.3362904191017151,
-0.8087183833122253,
0.6865007877349854,
0.09912687540054321,
-0.5127530097961426,
-0.20333920419216156,
-0.12306961417198181,
0.0725908875465393,
-0.16992615163326263,
0.15304921567440033,
-0.02197669818997383,
-0.32685157656669617,
0.5850571990013123,
-0.3834688365459442,
0.9728825688362122,
-0.1524743288755417,
-0.3913900554180145,
0.24179290235042572,
-0.11922713369131088,
1.020254135131836,
0.16307216882705688,
-0.15364746749401093,
-0.15251487493515015,
-0.2748243808746338,
-0.48593342304229736,
-0.7906166911125183,
0.8681891560554504,
-0.5908427834510803,
-0.7403523325920105,
-0.05983907729387283,
-0.4658013880252838,
-0.4290739893913269,
-0.0202613715082407,
-0.1391376405954361,
0.4836982488632202,
-0.3853086829185486,
0.6923655271530151,
0.7676928639411926,
-0.4841764271259308,
0.3125709593296051,
0.25317463278770447,
-0.2646476924419403,
-0.39670440554618835,
0.7703770399093628,
0.0570528469979763,
0.1909434199333191,
0.5870665907859802,
0.17957572638988495,
-0.5556676387786865,
-0.6312676072120667,
-0.1127156987786293,
0.27741724252700806,
-0.7806570529937744,
-0.16889730095863342,
-0.9864166975021362,
-0.14384885132312775,
-0.7076475024223328,
-0.186695396900177,
-0.2527705430984497,
-0.26849180459976196,
-0.19664616882801056,
-0.27892500162124634,
0.42415091395378113,
0.6209515333175659,
0.1440313458442688,
0.6612449288368225,
-0.8497070670127869,
-0.03668619692325592,
-0.009388730861246586,
0.6151114702224731,
0.1859636753797531,
-0.7820451259613037,
-0.47856730222702026,
0.027431953698396683,
-0.1874161660671234,
-0.7280305027961731,
0.43852075934410095,
0.10961092263460159,
0.604793131351471,
0.2790996730327606,
-0.2821764349937439,
0.6020385026931763,
-0.6643775701522827,
0.571401834487915,
-0.5009263157844543,
-0.9591031670570374,
0.5257750749588013,
-0.4437031149864197,
0.1368187814950943,
0.3771178722381592,
0.1892113834619522,
-0.6852484345436096,
-0.31836292147636414,
-0.7234676480293274,
-1.0713586807250977,
0.464854896068573,
0.37038540840148926,
0.3516975939273834,
0.07312619686126709,
0.3832903206348419,
0.018296290189027786,
0.14868371188640594,
-0.5912098288536072,
0.05760709568858147,
0.03201381489634514,
-0.17632272839546204,
-0.3633958399295807,
-0.6231995820999146,
0.2629404067993164,
0.05466250702738762,
0.802025556564331,
0.061917759478092194,
0.2785217761993408,
0.03233794495463371,
-0.3420829176902771,
0.2660819888114929,
0.3107435405254364,
0.5456997156143188,
0.4790061414241791,
-0.33351263403892517,
-0.03224392980337143,
0.32702115178108215,
-0.34386971592903137,
-0.06597187370061874,
0.021463662385940552,
0.08059442788362503,
-0.04336957260966301,
0.5872220396995544,
0.6041968464851379,
0.44621825218200684,
-0.6884245276451111,
0.4339889585971832,
-0.16870549321174622,
0.03811129182577133,
-0.11246459186077118,
-0.003941184375435114,
0.2957327365875244,
0.27077820897102356,
0.2114560604095459,
-0.4275484085083008,
-0.09458886831998825,
-0.4305209815502167,
0.2607816159725189,
0.20555315911769867,
-0.07495485246181488,
0.04088224843144417,
0.2150324136018753,
0.143479123711586,
-0.3238828778266907,
0.6799491047859192,
0.13549499213695526,
-0.6024196743965149,
0.35770732164382935,
0.8039970397949219,
0.9710848927497864,
-0.22777827084064484,
0.0902022048830986,
0.36071595549583435,
0.45480942726135254,
-0.016865907236933708,
0.15827453136444092,
0.12153543531894684,
-0.9263864755630493,
-0.7687965035438538,
-0.6381490230560303,
-0.5990294814109802,
-0.06039094924926758,
-0.34537655115127563,
0.3451762795448303,
-0.41269367933273315,
0.06031973659992218,
-0.22986756265163422,
0.09086373448371887,
-0.7881917357444763,
0.14815852046012878,
0.05188199132680893,
0.8509597778320312,
-0.7677243947982788,
0.7461196780204773,
0.6266522407531738,
-0.12724916636943817,
-0.6020097732543945,
0.1174573302268982,
-0.26630735397338867,
-0.7158780097961426,
0.3043448030948639,
0.2878269553184509,
0.10267799347639084,
0.05851258710026741,
-0.4884752333164215,
-0.9929388165473938,
1.1556828022003174,
0.1463647335767746,
-0.5257129669189453,
0.21843412518501282,
0.21139484643936157,
0.5800362229347229,
-0.6868631839752197,
0.2552925646305084,
0.5506495833396912,
0.4361664354801178,
0.06283191591501236,
-0.5074025988578796,
0.3000570833683014,
-0.05005379766225815,
0.21890072524547577,
0.16000941395759583,
-0.3905431926250458,
0.5559614300727844,
0.13260741531848907,
-0.2029028981924057,
-0.1401500105857849,
0.7269464135169983,
0.21337969601154327,
-0.044205863028764725,
0.29150843620300293,
0.6785835027694702,
0.8655723929405212,
-0.0443396158516407,
1.1259886026382446,
-0.29285889863967896,
0.35181960463523865,
1.2215713262557983,
-0.27939584851264954,
1.1903358697891235,
0.4142720401287079,
0.061076365411281586,
0.5017380714416504,
0.5930114388465881,
-0.008425414562225342,
0.4323427677154541,
0.3173508942127228,
-0.38539403676986694,
-0.2716934084892273,
-0.24837923049926758,
-0.3403860330581665,
0.5588372349739075,
0.4551639258861542,
-0.6623439192771912,
-0.25846126675605774,
-0.07440504431724548,
0.21110227704048157,
0.02138020657002926,
0.12959358096122742,
0.6677910685539246,
-0.02722424641251564,
-0.5060735940933228,
0.15725021064281464,
0.3711196184158325,
0.749094545841217,
-0.37749144434928894,
-0.23636960983276367,
-0.25062471628189087,
0.1304427981376648,
-0.07807419449090958,
-0.7447748184204102,
0.3407660722732544,
0.1790515035390854,
-0.08336415141820908,
-0.5633755922317505,
0.7663689255714417,
-0.3603556156158447,
-0.4593118727207184,
0.19097501039505005,
0.540758490562439,
0.03668604791164398,
-0.23935526609420776,
-0.4440780580043793,
0.1286400705575943,
0.11600837856531143,
-0.3902631103992462,
0.20828786492347717,
0.681384801864624,
0.18494568765163422,
0.732545793056488,
0.9526694416999817,
-0.05096714571118355,
-0.1622799038887024,
0.1855471134185791,
1.0081359148025513,
-0.8347328901290894,
-0.49263569712638855,
-1.1642063856124878,
0.3916670083999634,
-0.21585506200790405,
-0.11949317902326584,
0.6734187006950378,
0.6823421716690063,
0.7183564305305481,
0.11511873453855515,
0.8093351125717163,
0.16195471584796906,
0.5556218028068542,
-0.6621885895729065,
0.545492947101593,
-0.3465181291103363,
0.5135923027992249,
-0.4430837631225586,
-1.256103277206421,
-0.36753952503204346,
0.5097243785858154,
-0.5260891914367676,
0.09295690804719925,
0.5635757446289062,
1.0873247385025024,
0.026852568611502647,
0.08846935629844666,
0.4413355886936188,
0.14003828167915344,
0.7255086302757263,
0.3619830906391144,
0.9455003142356873,
-0.4848701059818268,
0.5071654319763184,
-0.005186287686228752,
-0.059780094772577286,
-0.40301066637039185,
-1.1695215702056885,
-0.913081169128418,
-0.30709996819496155,
-0.318065345287323,
-0.2183009833097458,
-0.04307558387517929,
0.9893152117729187,
0.3113138675689697,
-0.6272382736206055,
0.11079925298690796,
0.19027721881866455,
0.15771517157554626,
0.1454162746667862,
-0.2106768935918808,
0.49397194385528564,
-0.39425399899482727,
-0.8042798042297363,
0.48770657181739807,
0.1687629371881485,
0.041114691644907,
-0.19216547906398773,
0.08729548007249832,
-0.32634368538856506,
0.15193840861320496,
0.7691338658332825,
-0.3093879818916321,
-0.62311190366745,
-0.5196689367294312,
-0.08694508671760559,
-0.06767455488443375,
0.00827693659812212,
0.747392475605011,
-0.6021450161933899,
0.20644336938858032,
0.5213985443115234,
1.0764672756195068,
0.33758965134620667,
0.20947131514549255,
0.6847512722015381,
-0.8339893221855164,
-0.22444716095924377,
0.24747850000858307,
0.5421264171600342,
0.6188390851020813,
-0.36759838461875916,
0.41476112604141235,
-0.02262985147535801,
-0.6678380966186523,
-0.6822414398193359,
-0.06229156628251076,
-0.7238932251930237,
-0.1679251343011856,
1.2188313007354736,
-0.20959170162677765,
-0.1141161322593689,
-0.03282225877046585,
-0.3882620334625244,
0.2974366247653961,
-0.5864363312721252,
0.6274974346160889,
1.0273107290267944,
0.21994104981422424,
-0.19921140372753143,
-0.7118188738822937,
0.2529110312461853,
0.45772412419319153,
-0.6135144233703613,
0.273415744304657,
0.3649124503135681,
0.22034341096878052,
-0.15986031293869019,
0.2872399389743805,
-0.07231002300977707,
-0.1173219308257103,
-0.036848679184913635,
-0.11618297547101974,
-0.09976531565189362,
-0.0037187684793025255,
-0.22460530698299408,
0.1693718135356903,
0.07402872294187546,
-0.03672533854842186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12274v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12274v1
|
Advancing the Robustness of Large Language Models through Self-Denoised Smoothing
| 2024-04-18T15:47:00 | 2024-04-18T15:47:00 |
Jiabao Ji, Bairu Hou, Zhen Zhang, Guanhua Zhang, Wenqi Fan, Qing Li, Yang Zhang, Gaowen Liu, Sijia Liu, Shiyu Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Although large language models (LLMs) have achieved significant success,
their vulnerability to adversarial perturbations, including recent jailbreak
attacks, has raised considerable concerns. However, the increasing size of
these models and their limited access make improving their robustness a
challenging task. Among various defense strategies, randomized smoothing has
shown great potential for LLMs, as it does not require full access to the
model's parameters or fine-tuning via adversarial training. However, randomized
smoothing involves adding noise to the input before model prediction, and the
final model's robustness largely depends on the model's performance on these
noise corrupted data. Its effectiveness is often limited by the model's
sub-optimal performance on noisy data. To address this issue, we propose to
leverage the multitasking nature of LLMs to first denoise the noisy inputs and
then to make predictions based on these denoised versions. We call this
procedure self-denoised smoothing. Unlike previous denoised smoothing
techniques in computer vision, which require training a separate model to
enhance the robustness of LLMs, our method offers significantly better
efficiency and flexibility. Our experimental results indicate that our method
surpasses existing methods in both empirical and certified robustness in
defending against adversarial attacks for both downstream tasks and human
alignments (i.e., jailbreak attacks). Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/UCSB-NLP-Chang/SelfDenoise
|
[
-0.4737444519996643,
-0.7996025085449219,
0.43863776326179504,
0.1709231734275818,
-0.3142295479774475,
0.057547397911548615,
-0.45282047986984253,
-0.2985246479511261,
0.31412360072135925,
0.7625517249107361,
-0.480146199464798,
-0.48633280396461487,
-0.938978910446167,
-0.05430978536605835,
-0.5355413556098938,
0.6922109127044678,
0.3181811273097992,
-0.03918709605932236,
0.19390836358070374,
0.18234269320964813,
-0.36805132031440735,
-0.5127285718917847,
-0.7176783680915833,
-0.11994950473308563,
0.35293638706207275,
0.17155295610427856,
0.8040802478790283,
0.6713083386421204,
0.48601046204566956,
0.3651968240737915,
-0.004977423697710037,
0.08025959134101868,
-0.4891279339790344,
0.6272681951522827,
0.24088390171527863,
-0.18372774124145508,
-0.5586917400360107,
-0.23169071972370148,
0.598163366317749,
0.3750092685222626,
-0.20132951438426971,
-0.14471621811389923,
0.17162658274173737,
0.7965782284736633,
-0.5934851765632629,
0.14844729006290436,
-0.7548375725746155,
-0.20559664070606232,
-0.3225502669811249,
0.10107021778821945,
-0.0865415558218956,
0.09030423313379288,
-0.17195071280002594,
-0.32676491141319275,
0.21434448659420013,
-0.3125181794166565,
0.5857961177825928,
0.586495041847229,
-0.0025694493670016527,
0.2549688518047333,
-0.5944030284881592,
0.7309419512748718,
-1.1046292781829834,
0.514220118522644,
0.5939707159996033,
0.13435325026512146,
-0.6629799604415894,
-0.5267066359519958,
-0.30797135829925537,
-0.3190888464450836,
0.26325616240501404,
0.05799901857972145,
-0.1916140764951706,
0.1936357468366623,
0.33757340908050537,
0.21552346646785736,
-0.43379127979278564,
0.4674692451953888,
-0.29229995608329773,
-0.3472161293029785,
0.6499948501586914,
-0.10440360754728317,
0.2791854441165924,
0.1716853529214859,
-0.020823877304792404,
-0.08731313049793243,
-0.4502091705799103,
-0.11225827783346176,
0.4523026645183563,
0.637112021446228,
-0.16603390872478485,
0.27316299080848694,
-0.36551326513290405,
0.6330848932266235,
0.06552697718143463,
-0.3546651005744934,
0.08263085037469864,
-0.2031404972076416,
-0.175514355301857,
-0.1759587973356247,
0.8497243523597717,
0.35717952251434326,
0.2145186811685562,
-0.189749076962471,
-0.18508335947990417,
-0.019310778006911278,
0.340955525636673,
-0.8721747994422913,
-0.4998403787612915,
0.36950328946113586,
-0.28261181712150574,
-0.374794602394104,
-0.32237160205841064,
-0.9991981387138367,
-0.552035391330719,
-0.03452805429697037,
0.169692263007164,
-0.10087976604700089,
-0.216592475771904,
0.2451459765434265,
0.18953101336956024,
-0.2889249622821808,
0.3638662099838257,
-1.224266529083252,
0.2911805808544159,
0.46699976921081543,
0.7892888784408569,
-0.23108656704425812,
-0.25351953506469727,
-0.5018225312232971,
0.015281513333320618,
-0.41873496770858765,
0.5747058987617493,
-0.3726658225059509,
-0.3633356988430023,
-0.22734422981739044,
-0.2847743034362793,
0.007295436691492796,
-0.4344750940799713,
0.46175965666770935,
-0.39578330516815186,
-0.22036869823932648,
0.03252127766609192,
-0.25721973180770874,
-0.06961879134178162,
0.23442696034908295,
-0.691650927066803,
1.0974866151809692,
-0.10010598599910736,
-0.6418383121490479,
0.3315429389476776,
-0.34353479743003845,
-0.48480290174484253,
-0.15266986191272736,
-0.009555837139487267,
-0.6348828077316284,
0.11692187190055847,
0.7067713141441345,
0.6120727062225342,
-0.006482782308012247,
0.3966817557811737,
-0.7278879284858704,
-0.15352272987365723,
0.052905116230249405,
-0.6751165986061096,
0.49625322222709656,
0.36368927359580994,
-0.2763015627861023,
0.1768372654914856,
-0.704936683177948,
-0.06763940304517746,
0.11977033317089081,
-0.4170245826244354,
-0.25560426712036133,
-0.03270100802183151,
-0.20498180389404297,
0.19032587110996246,
0.28799280524253845,
-0.525058388710022,
0.27967000007629395,
-0.5944851636886597,
0.5444453954696655,
0.7937497496604919,
-0.12427879124879837,
0.40809494256973267,
-0.21838489174842834,
0.4684857726097107,
-0.001493734773248434,
0.22333362698554993,
-0.3362789452075958,
-0.6219512224197388,
-0.5460335612297058,
-0.6572665572166443,
0.3729299008846283,
0.3525710701942444,
-0.3276880979537964,
0.33865559101104736,
-0.1213853508234024,
-0.44118255376815796,
-0.4895557761192322,
0.6678662300109863,
0.27585455775260925,
0.25855979323387146,
0.46088483929634094,
-0.5323391556739807,
-0.506898820400238,
-0.6725488305091858,
-0.34219926595687866,
0.028551220893859863,
0.010180995799601078,
-0.14217032492160797,
0.11257825791835785,
-0.253329873085022,
0.46796080470085144,
-0.261032372713089,
-0.4471314251422882,
-0.2222946286201477,
0.01747645065188408,
0.11966942995786667,
0.5761950612068176,
0.41947025060653687,
-0.3867129385471344,
-0.3729584217071533,
-0.27843621373176575,
-0.4995833933353424,
-0.2708752155303955,
-0.17644190788269043,
0.06019006669521332,
0.05902423337101936,
0.8489757180213928,
-0.41080713272094727,
0.49609217047691345,
0.8004425764083862,
0.0340927392244339,
0.37661269307136536,
-0.4716586172580719,
-0.02388608455657959,
-0.9296156167984009,
-0.2552165985107422,
0.03839236497879028,
-0.413699746131897,
-0.8998867869377136,
0.08740001171827316,
-0.1568167507648468,
0.03778121620416641,
-0.08088132739067078,
0.4645571708679199,
-0.5745813846588135,
0.013004718348383904,
-0.49995264410972595,
0.17865200340747833,
0.026517244055867195,
0.2745242416858673,
-0.1688481867313385,
0.766530454158783,
0.9023197889328003,
-0.44553589820861816,
0.023770688101649284,
-0.11811381578445435,
-0.302889883518219,
0.07783006131649017,
-0.4542434811592102,
0.09124790132045746,
-0.17982633411884308,
0.10174290090799332,
-0.9248496890068054,
-0.10003317892551422,
0.08057735115289688,
-0.2858441472053528,
0.794620156288147,
-0.3412024974822998,
-0.3656904697418213,
-0.38409844040870667,
-0.40184494853019714,
0.2218685746192932,
0.44961977005004883,
-0.5516818165779114,
0.6071335673332214,
0.6999547481536865,
-0.2917560040950775,
-0.6725249886512756,
-0.7282525300979614,
0.4398212432861328,
-0.21699097752571106,
-0.5320600271224976,
0.10506879538297653,
-0.10413407534360886,
-0.20811375975608826,
-0.4959077537059784,
-0.2985785901546478,
-0.17527692019939423,
0.47160038352012634,
0.3503604829311371,
0.2268362194299698,
0.020297588780522346,
-0.1823877990245819,
0.06112084537744522,
-0.2007758766412735,
0.037097930908203125,
-0.39059069752693176,
0.5411635637283325,
0.045546989887952805,
-0.28952929377555847,
-0.5007432699203491,
0.15302293002605438,
0.6221945881843567,
-0.0680907815694809,
0.47085538506507874,
0.7385143637657166,
-0.2888902723789215,
-0.2100130319595337,
-0.8273460268974304,
-0.4204150140285492,
-0.5291239619255066,
0.4279084801673889,
-0.3343980610370636,
-1.1615272760391235,
0.5480021834373474,
0.022750889882445335,
0.22827233374118805,
0.21583302319049835,
0.6981716156005859,
0.047254592180252075,
1.0597976446151733,
0.684140145778656,
-0.3751470446586609,
0.5705413222312927,
-0.05104957893490791,
0.36826831102371216,
-0.7913468480110168,
0.04314187541604042,
-0.43761271238327026,
-0.1480284184217453,
-0.6409862637519836,
-0.4547974169254303,
0.13270148634910583,
-0.013192407786846161,
0.07013142853975296,
0.30499473214149475,
-0.44652894139289856,
0.38359564542770386,
0.674405574798584,
0.1482485681772232,
0.28270140290260315,
0.17362330853939056,
-0.17174477875232697,
-0.07197874039411545,
-0.6196928024291992,
-0.24792644381523132,
1.1746708154678345,
0.5115692615509033,
1.1795263290405273,
-0.09161752462387085,
0.8191844820976257,
0.1796821653842926,
0.050858382135629654,
-0.5179840922355652,
0.5186633467674255,
-0.4935236871242523,
-0.5269773602485657,
-0.49631038308143616,
-0.45296552777290344,
-0.9676632285118103,
0.44794192910194397,
-0.3485164940357208,
-0.9557077884674072,
0.26030948758125305,
0.36326029896736145,
-0.5412811636924744,
0.44418367743492126,
-0.5861515402793884,
0.7465871572494507,
-0.24994589388370514,
-0.28750428557395935,
-0.22418849170207977,
-0.6052039861679077,
0.47787079215049744,
-0.4724561870098114,
0.5471886396408081,
-0.4170930087566376,
0.2649797201156616,
0.6929669380187988,
-0.23522722721099854,
1.0588855743408203,
-0.1517365574836731,
-0.13636215031147003,
-0.04110502451658249,
0.31093570590019226,
0.35754334926605225,
0.04953495040535927,
0.009630678221583366,
0.39060544967651367,
0.043080706149339676,
-0.36880987882614136,
-0.46653756499290466,
1.0048747062683105,
-0.6413509249687195,
-0.8805572986602783,
-0.232954204082489,
-0.7509343028068542,
-0.1848459094762802,
0.4732191264629364,
-0.08576726168394089,
0.42855361104011536,
0.06938523799180984,
-0.01075487770140171,
0.5734771490097046,
-0.039610378444194794,
0.6015426516532898,
0.36149609088897705,
-0.43434250354766846,
-0.3015097379684448,
0.8558617234230042,
0.21855898201465607,
0.3501075208187103,
0.11316941678524017,
0.3416101634502411,
-0.31158560514450073,
-0.9395278096199036,
-0.2720901668071747,
0.07032351940870285,
-0.5779236555099487,
-0.24251770973205566,
-0.6870143413543701,
-0.17709635198116302,
-0.7565337419509888,
-0.08988973498344421,
-0.6065810322761536,
-0.5648300647735596,
-0.16580715775489807,
0.009129234589636326,
0.32550865411758423,
0.5639915466308594,
-0.34764596819877625,
0.38483870029449463,
-0.5785619616508484,
0.6170731782913208,
0.34698814153671265,
0.353931725025177,
-0.17264388501644135,
-0.7222659587860107,
-0.24693654477596283,
0.12149851769208908,
-0.13344581425189972,
-0.5172861218452454,
0.6462461352348328,
0.1999291479587555,
0.5228905081748962,
0.47633835673332214,
0.12236345559358597,
0.8678820729255676,
-0.33518368005752563,
0.4915674924850464,
0.13114643096923828,
-0.608888566493988,
0.37378019094467163,
-0.34120798110961914,
0.47592753171920776,
0.7140318751335144,
-0.19294489920139313,
-0.05302521586418152,
-0.9083727598190308,
-0.4434875249862671,
-0.8565155267715454,
0.43120330572128296,
0.07996179163455963,
0.16791123151779175,
0.11142674833536148,
0.36339616775512695,
-0.14355993270874023,
0.1203538179397583,
-0.6149072647094727,
-0.1951933652162552,
-0.4195569157600403,
-0.06384463608264923,
-0.19060750305652618,
-0.3690204620361328,
-0.0998288244009018,
-0.2138962298631668,
0.672120988368988,
-0.04584306478500366,
-0.034779325127601624,
0.16780932247638702,
0.07125512510538101,
-0.017886601388454437,
0.29726096987724304,
0.5638248920440674,
0.2453058362007141,
-0.17367435991764069,
0.33001619577407837,
0.25833913683891296,
-0.8276836276054382,
0.009441995993256569,
0.2078450620174408,
-0.33889251947402954,
-0.2917836010456085,
0.03814281150698662,
0.5872218012809753,
0.17555412650108337,
-0.5701909065246582,
0.39472198486328125,
-0.2539514899253845,
-0.05418210104107857,
-0.0939619243144989,
0.07924134284257889,
-0.1119314581155777,
0.23657816648483276,
0.022612106055021286,
0.21148382127285004,
0.23859840631484985,
-0.2208000123500824,
0.2533951699733734,
0.6728625297546387,
-0.23386625945568085,
-0.13034628331661224,
0.7637708783149719,
-0.1862606257200241,
-0.1152416542172432,
0.44845694303512573,
-0.01922747865319252,
-0.4157467782497406,
0.4128808379173279,
0.5704249143600464,
0.9434945583343506,
-0.41129761934280396,
-0.11527080088853836,
0.3336634635925293,
0.6379215717315674,
-0.41482865810394287,
0.17063233256340027,
0.07743410766124725,
-0.6942897439002991,
-0.5320770144462585,
-0.6974635124206543,
-0.18602707982063293,
0.26774850487709045,
-0.4607512056827545,
0.04266255721449852,
-0.6634947657585144,
-0.4690416157245636,
-0.16152694821357727,
-0.18289944529533386,
-0.2563205659389496,
0.281934529542923,
0.23792433738708496,
0.6898006200790405,
-0.5360718965530396,
1.1371068954467773,
0.18915429711341858,
0.03842730075120926,
-0.6458795666694641,
-0.018658380955457687,
0.11489169299602509,
-0.8720545172691345,
0.2718852162361145,
0.2643643617630005,
-0.3391314744949341,
-0.03401278704404831,
-0.3863891661167145,
-1.0119671821594238,
0.6590901613235474,
0.49527397751808167,
-0.7601820826530457,
0.12810415029525757,
-0.0533883199095726,
0.4253126382827759,
-0.17598536610603333,
0.07039047032594681,
0.6775388121604919,
0.4547061026096344,
0.017777329310774803,
-0.8882991075515747,
0.07275355607271194,
-0.13260594010353088,
-0.0012842249125242233,
0.3218602240085602,
-0.45818182826042175,
0.5509608387947083,
-0.4985634386539459,
-0.13272260129451752,
0.10707303881645203,
0.6945638060569763,
0.04350457340478897,
-0.07055054605007172,
0.5337181091308594,
0.7870924472808838,
0.6083171963691711,
-0.04944968223571777,
0.8815182447433472,
-0.603687047958374,
0.09028653800487518,
1.329267144203186,
-0.08992920070886612,
0.7681174278259277,
0.40120089054107666,
-0.0564899779856205,
0.1642528772354126,
0.390848845243454,
-0.2848188281059265,
0.4720660150051117,
0.15633390843868256,
-0.11424687504768372,
-0.44861236214637756,
0.20357361435890198,
-0.1694970577955246,
0.40648406744003296,
0.3459553122520447,
-0.05513625219464302,
-0.3826564848423004,
0.07642918080091476,
0.2097565084695816,
0.10291005671024323,
-0.33095940947532654,
0.6749152541160583,
0.18265007436275482,
-0.565609872341156,
0.5501914024353027,
0.11710083484649658,
0.7860534191131592,
-0.6334825158119202,
0.1749793440103531,
-0.19388741254806519,
0.12179683893918991,
-0.15729087591171265,
-0.612858772277832,
0.16124553978443146,
-0.11296014487743378,
0.01665562018752098,
-0.16955871880054474,
0.7663936018943787,
-0.4503965377807617,
-0.5068783760070801,
0.46915769577026367,
0.317405104637146,
0.18664774298667908,
-0.10830278694629669,
-0.7156657576560974,
0.25908327102661133,
-0.17059822380542755,
-0.18071144819259644,
0.7563133239746094,
0.002181018004193902,
0.12173308432102203,
1.0578131675720215,
0.8799427151679993,
0.3044273555278778,
0.44790077209472656,
0.4742436408996582,
1.0141804218292236,
-0.26697981357574463,
-0.3432382345199585,
-1.0062824487686157,
0.20391054451465607,
0.1017613559961319,
-0.1237361878156662,
0.9691037535667419,
0.3667832314968109,
0.631843626499176,
0.2038383185863495,
0.6296972036361694,
0.2494211047887802,
0.36207661032676697,
-0.5195695757865906,
0.7071882486343384,
-0.38212132453918457,
0.4526633024215698,
-0.21840894222259521,
-0.5218654870986938,
-0.6693922877311707,
0.6869637966156006,
-0.24159343540668488,
0.24001860618591309,
0.2999054193496704,
1.1427390575408936,
0.03560824319720268,
-0.31693828105926514,
0.7079880833625793,
0.5039442777633667,
0.28622499108314514,
0.13203273713588715,
0.46392619609832764,
-0.2783452868461609,
0.41347694396972656,
-0.5819899439811707,
-0.2563527226448059,
0.07249574363231659,
-0.8689730763435364,
-1.1391363143920898,
-0.2554267942905426,
-0.3497011363506317,
-0.38509541749954224,
0.2012968510389328,
0.6666560173034668,
0.86467045545578,
-0.8997405767440796,
-0.28835737705230713,
-0.08495454490184784,
0.026923611760139465,
-0.30085378885269165,
-0.16050276160240173,
0.1431070864200592,
-0.5501578450202942,
-0.6205063462257385,
0.7915441393852234,
0.44900941848754883,
0.1711452454328537,
-0.49780741333961487,
0.15269169211387634,
-0.08449605107307434,
0.16742920875549316,
0.3436691164970398,
0.3861350417137146,
-0.741498589515686,
-0.08909732848405838,
-0.20518502593040466,
0.008625182323157787,
0.19471335411071777,
0.5870928168296814,
-0.5815626382827759,
0.8350749611854553,
0.18438789248466492,
0.5388938784599304,
0.6101821064949036,
0.022455791011452675,
0.46416571736335754,
-0.5252911448478699,
0.22507555782794952,
-0.08269090205430984,
0.5317939519882202,
0.37447530031204224,
-0.4110129773616791,
0.15898744761943817,
-0.07312481850385666,
-0.7731825709342957,
-0.7762941718101501,
0.2309267520904541,
-1.0487490892410278,
-0.3128543496131897,
0.9572115540504456,
-0.20572859048843384,
-0.15251898765563965,
-0.38075557351112366,
-0.11804751306772232,
0.12141578644514084,
-0.5765254497528076,
1.1075422763824463,
0.4536566138267517,
0.16481412947177887,
-0.3340311050415039,
-0.6717027425765991,
0.5496265888214111,
0.30260810256004333,
-0.5978370308876038,
0.3659653961658478,
0.3499685525894165,
0.3337804675102234,
0.007506747730076313,
0.700676441192627,
-0.23885522782802582,
-0.017898717895150185,
-0.04940173402428627,
-0.07367181032896042,
-0.2190079241991043,
-0.5149912238121033,
-0.6374759078025818,
0.15648405253887177,
0.2788786292076111,
0.05463866516947746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12273v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12273v1
|
FedEval-LLM: Federated Evaluation of Large Language Models on Downstream Tasks with Collective Wisdom
| 2024-04-18T15:46:26 | 2024-04-18T15:46:26 |
Yuanqin He, Yan Kang, Lixin Fan, Qiang Yang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Federated Learning (FL) has emerged as a promising solution for collaborative
training of large language models (LLMs). However, the integration of LLMs into
FL introduces new challenges, particularly concerning the evaluation of LLMs.
Traditional evaluation methods that rely on labeled test sets and
similarity-based metrics cover only a subset of the acceptable answers, thereby
failing to accurately reflect the performance of LLMs on generative tasks.
Meanwhile, although automatic evaluation methods that leverage advanced LLMs
present potential, they face critical risks of data leakage due to the need to
transmit data to external servers and suboptimal performance on downstream
tasks due to the lack of domain knowledge. To address these issues, we propose
a Federated Evaluation framework of Large Language Models, named FedEval-LLM,
that provides reliable performance measurements of LLMs on downstream tasks
without the reliance on labeled test sets and external tools, thus ensuring
strong privacy-preserving capability. FedEval-LLM leverages a consortium of
personalized LLMs from participants as referees to provide domain knowledge and
collective evaluation capability, thus aligning to the respective downstream
tasks and mitigating uncertainties and biases associated with a single referee.
Experimental results demonstrate a significant improvement in the evaluation
capability of personalized evaluation models on downstream tasks. When applied
to FL, these evaluation models exhibit strong agreement with human preference
and RougeL-score on meticulously curated test sets. FedEval-LLM effectively
overcomes the limitations of traditional metrics and the reliance on external
services, making it a promising framework for the evaluation of LLMs within
collaborative training scenarios.
|
[
-0.3644340932369232,
-0.528530478477478,
0.4244709014892578,
0.4414714276790619,
0.02388898842036724,
0.35988280177116394,
-0.6514431238174438,
-0.4030766189098358,
0.012872365303337574,
0.4014962613582611,
-0.7667163014411926,
-0.5778061747550964,
-0.5273565649986267,
0.2196291834115982,
-0.4961060583591461,
1.0734328031539917,
-0.024193890392780304,
0.29390570521354675,
-0.786005437374115,
-0.2874509394168854,
-0.2586738169193268,
-0.41881564259529114,
-0.3039499521255493,
-0.6086183190345764,
0.41447070240974426,
0.2755579352378845,
0.512938916683197,
0.39722564816474915,
0.8167382478713989,
0.43397584557533264,
0.14787180721759796,
-0.016879189759492874,
-0.8033860325813293,
0.32054391503334045,
-0.48405081033706665,
-0.3858632743358612,
-0.43517783284187317,
0.3080935776233673,
0.7364687919616699,
0.8319247961044312,
-0.26862525939941406,
0.3816019892692566,
0.03323144465684891,
0.762079656124115,
-0.6088055372238159,
0.4237651824951172,
-0.526858925819397,
0.2375483363866806,
-0.09249423444271088,
-0.09979686886072159,
-0.532289981842041,
-0.4879732131958008,
0.37097176909446716,
-0.4401831328868866,
0.08035605400800705,
0.08455346524715424,
0.38767674565315247,
0.21791908144950867,
-0.04308389499783516,
-0.2029474526643753,
-0.7011509537696838,
0.8751305341720581,
-0.32776013016700745,
0.4592553377151489,
0.20483453571796417,
0.3989194333553314,
-0.09240198880434036,
-0.7389240264892578,
-0.2747223675251007,
-0.2837318480014801,
-0.0931469276547432,
0.13031308352947235,
-0.1940300315618515,
0.12835334241390228,
-0.24549268186092377,
0.7430364489555359,
-0.4641093909740448,
0.31707248091697693,
-0.02312876284122467,
-0.23356495797634125,
0.9591884613037109,
0.26254600286483765,
0.037899911403656006,
0.3373725414276123,
-0.6690196394920349,
0.01990116760134697,
-0.6511458158493042,
-0.22867795825004578,
0.2532735764980316,
0.5221276879310608,
-0.09026741236448288,
0.22577232122421265,
-0.4818632900714874,
0.5331672430038452,
0.3102021813392639,
-0.19458238780498505,
0.3783217966556549,
-0.3091214895248413,
-0.3759666979312897,
-0.29879170656204224,
0.9877519607543945,
0.07532238215208054,
0.0591762512922287,
-0.7238700985908508,
-0.5858373045921326,
-0.24130336940288544,
0.03279934450984001,
-0.7575770020484924,
-0.02543213963508606,
0.20581743121147156,
-0.37942421436309814,
-0.567304253578186,
0.05652086064219475,
-0.7194475531578064,
-0.4545290768146515,
-0.48043951392173767,
0.4720391631126404,
-0.1325681358575821,
-0.28455352783203125,
-0.1615058034658432,
0.16692288219928741,
0.045071862637996674,
0.4878191649913788,
-1.04096519947052,
0.6207194924354553,
1.1522365808486938,
0.8986747860908508,
-0.5119395852088928,
-0.5324397683143616,
-1.109330654144287,
-0.3132638931274414,
0.11058007925748825,
0.6575394868850708,
-0.45910194516181946,
-0.2271582931280136,
0.21767458319664001,
-0.05628950893878937,
-0.22057734429836273,
-0.46691110730171204,
0.16630937159061432,
-0.813599169254303,
0.3324965238571167,
-0.21791431307792664,
-0.823877215385437,
0.01782250590622425,
0.4358345866203308,
-0.5069543123245239,
0.4614841639995575,
0.234131321310997,
-0.6041991710662842,
0.2850227952003479,
-0.5402592420578003,
-0.3207564651966095,
0.4419623613357544,
-0.2723971903324127,
-0.30808380246162415,
-0.10736037790775299,
0.061663590371608734,
0.7122668623924255,
-0.625419020652771,
0.5974541306495667,
-0.48079296946525574,
-0.5847102403640747,
-0.013741680420935154,
-0.3122815489768982,
0.8315207362174988,
0.05010514333844185,
-0.39770573377609253,
0.4870331287384033,
-0.3842344284057617,
0.07151830196380615,
-0.11820882558822632,
-0.49839866161346436,
-0.3406137526035309,
-0.24194782972335815,
-0.04330339655280113,
0.08062177151441574,
0.3868875205516815,
-0.4801059663295746,
-0.00674709677696228,
-0.5238629579544067,
0.16441936790943146,
1.0169581174850464,
-0.19926080107688904,
0.5889278650283813,
-0.40107542276382446,
0.6550762057304382,
-0.2294117957353592,
0.27024513483047485,
0.23234222829341888,
-0.252127468585968,
-0.729289174079895,
-0.20926231145858765,
0.1430070996284485,
0.35809195041656494,
-0.6993451714515686,
0.5140296816825867,
-0.7212658524513245,
-0.7113456130027771,
-0.3250942826271057,
0.45230215787887573,
0.5762988924980164,
0.38453030586242676,
0.13451163470745087,
-0.4207160472869873,
-0.22331015765666962,
-0.6368257403373718,
-0.11270169168710709,
-0.1911212056875229,
-0.06251651793718338,
0.2493514120578766,
0.5830894112586975,
-0.2992020845413208,
0.9599182605743408,
-0.18807366490364075,
-0.5766702890396118,
-0.2247142493724823,
0.12774091958999634,
0.02830513007938862,
0.25632405281066895,
0.3266647756099701,
-0.4862350821495056,
-0.42575404047966003,
0.19851966202259064,
-0.5600807070732117,
-0.19972841441631317,
0.1591975837945938,
-0.009698440320789814,
0.17221657931804657,
-0.09169913083314896,
-0.23356296122074127,
-0.1951562911272049,
0.8675078749656677,
-0.33125120401382446,
0.7527447938919067,
-0.013204035349190235,
0.04915450140833855,
-0.8745144605636597,
0.02607668563723564,
-0.1384993940591812,
-0.3227238655090332,
-0.38784173130989075,
0.28303593397140503,
-0.1814219057559967,
0.12539374828338623,
-0.37182188034057617,
0.5807850360870361,
-0.4401039481163025,
-0.4891588091850281,
-0.03659100458025932,
0.38735079765319824,
-0.11883526295423508,
0.4106927812099457,
0.04623309522867203,
0.9345452785491943,
0.526153028011322,
-0.19876204431056976,
0.785061240196228,
0.39738234877586365,
-0.3266006112098694,
0.7270006537437439,
-0.3397853970527649,
0.268136203289032,
0.342155784368515,
0.22368361055850983,
-0.5202815532684326,
-0.29633811116218567,
-0.08124169707298279,
-0.08963300287723541,
0.18647633492946625,
0.02409118041396141,
-0.462326318025589,
-0.19308443367481232,
-0.2668772339820862,
-0.013490889221429825,
0.2989464998245239,
-0.855473518371582,
0.31756988167762756,
0.4294658601284027,
0.023293713107705116,
-0.7338293194770813,
-0.6613438129425049,
-0.11947976052761078,
-0.0751744732260704,
-0.9489187002182007,
0.17193154990673065,
-0.000767261313740164,
-0.34564900398254395,
-0.19814467430114746,
-0.036127764731645584,
-0.23736774921417236,
0.19161714613437653,
0.4504905641078949,
0.16758114099502563,
-0.3479141592979431,
0.35440319776535034,
-0.043116066604852676,
0.03194776177406311,
0.23799459636211395,
-0.31172439455986023,
0.4747759997844696,
-0.8424139022827148,
-0.4491753578186035,
-0.2744104564189911,
0.13875751197338104,
0.4769250154495239,
-0.4089009761810303,
0.8583677411079407,
0.6507394313812256,
-0.14874331653118134,
-0.3352343738079071,
-0.7917221188545227,
-0.3395298421382904,
-0.4934130609035492,
0.16148437559604645,
-0.006342419423162937,
-1.4710627794265747,
0.5151411890983582,
-0.319012314081192,
0.07195649296045303,
0.17222097516059875,
0.7522176504135132,
0.015368427149951458,
0.3312264084815979,
0.7063109278678894,
-0.3367966413497925,
0.3349432647228241,
-0.2431652694940567,
-0.04494081437587738,
-0.574138343334198,
-0.2211853265762329,
-0.2703418731689453,
-0.13660404086112976,
-0.3922225534915924,
-0.4222687780857086,
0.2475489377975464,
-0.27797457575798035,
-0.22187593579292297,
0.07759997248649597,
-0.2075493484735489,
0.5989479422569275,
0.30329376459121704,
0.04125824570655823,
0.6435458064079285,
0.06863215565681458,
-0.2627868056297302,
0.20374542474746704,
-0.5662689805030823,
-0.36659860610961914,
1.0258064270019531,
0.4627596437931061,
0.6571753621101379,
0.0984979122877121,
1.0509696006774902,
0.28502950072288513,
0.9699251651763916,
-0.7771898508071899,
0.5896593928337097,
-0.21368306875228882,
-0.42077526450157166,
-0.2771497368812561,
-0.5740001797676086,
-0.5798278450965881,
0.4223894476890564,
-0.21822766959667206,
-0.6515046954154968,
-0.021643338724970818,
-0.04571632668375969,
-0.42029690742492676,
0.20023836195468903,
-0.5630253553390503,
0.7402034997940063,
-0.23340600728988647,
-0.6632246971130371,
-0.3211747705936432,
-0.5461872816085815,
0.746653139591217,
-0.2884814441204071,
0.1342589557170868,
-0.02461043745279312,
0.12946394085884094,
0.847096860408783,
-0.6886650323867798,
0.8515244722366333,
-0.14388234913349152,
-0.0077337888069450855,
0.018203407526016235,
-0.09495420753955841,
0.4157129228115082,
0.061628568917512894,
-0.27720579504966736,
0.3613290786743164,
-0.09323011338710785,
-0.05299847573041916,
-0.5468345284461975,
1.1214444637298584,
-0.8176087141036987,
-0.6533333659172058,
-0.4426352381706238,
-0.5920199155807495,
-0.49009811878204346,
0.2006109207868576,
-0.1294955462217331,
0.27821287512779236,
-0.37903493642807007,
0.3086093068122864,
0.425264835357666,
0.026618901640176773,
0.355761855840683,
0.6767800450325012,
-0.33030396699905396,
-0.5018224120140076,
0.6594124436378479,
-0.2974463105201721,
0.4408152997493744,
0.4157699942588806,
0.4075477123260498,
-0.3334873914718628,
-0.5436714291572571,
-0.10759162902832031,
0.15209151804447174,
-0.6994587182998657,
-0.4322761595249176,
-0.27799323201179504,
-0.11083327233791351,
-0.16102954745292664,
-0.17402943968772888,
-0.5742205381393433,
-0.17294448614120483,
-0.22361576557159424,
-0.16647711396217346,
0.4032558500766754,
0.600559413433075,
-0.01972690410912037,
0.21047748625278473,
-0.8365106582641602,
-0.3506130278110504,
0.28867238759994507,
0.6117225289344788,
0.15146078169345856,
-0.25230416655540466,
-0.28643685579299927,
0.048488032072782516,
-0.1942249983549118,
-0.38793814182281494,
0.23412880301475525,
0.26616594195365906,
0.5101459622383118,
0.42897817492485046,
0.1425800919532776,
0.7170121073722839,
-0.46633559465408325,
0.5266266465187073,
0.21409152448177338,
-1.001029372215271,
0.2647689878940582,
-0.34840714931488037,
0.07680720090866089,
0.9446706771850586,
0.30228912830352783,
-0.36725908517837524,
-0.5423874258995056,
-0.31456664204597473,
-0.4741743206977844,
0.6752648949623108,
0.1644582748413086,
0.004450200125575066,
0.18903352320194244,
0.14603884518146515,
0.24678067862987518,
0.3049871027469635,
-0.6069273948669434,
-0.10986034572124481,
0.14208219945430756,
0.011586034670472145,
0.025516211986541748,
0.12146329134702682,
-0.37930721044540405,
-0.29384827613830566,
0.5754184722900391,
-0.1554945856332779,
0.09032729268074036,
0.07451920956373215,
-0.21301554143428802,
-0.2840326726436615,
0.2757226526737213,
0.3841674029827118,
0.6395218968391418,
-0.1467309445142746,
-0.09471206367015839,
0.13841745257377625,
-0.4959026575088501,
0.25855883955955505,
0.2729775309562683,
-0.04045995697379112,
-0.2299073040485382,
0.7573130130767822,
0.6505628824234009,
0.41557836532592773,
-0.6521629095077515,
0.824372410774231,
-0.15847446024417877,
-0.14306731522083282,
-0.44517508149147034,
0.13360637426376343,
0.12339334189891815,
0.3348112106323242,
0.336270272731781,
0.13145896792411804,
-0.08796639740467072,
-0.3921264410018921,
0.48035264015197754,
0.5536469221115112,
-0.35910624265670776,
-0.3787166178226471,
0.3279642164707184,
0.5902619957923889,
-0.15305288136005402,
0.6108195781707764,
-0.06185416877269745,
-0.5787893533706665,
0.21124263107776642,
0.2281126081943512,
1.0175418853759766,
-0.5192477107048035,
0.33384034037590027,
0.0632096529006958,
0.16034390032291412,
-0.17701785266399384,
-0.05839420482516289,
-0.31553447246551514,
-0.704615592956543,
-0.4344808757305145,
-0.8932629227638245,
-0.5501611232757568,
0.0872735008597374,
-0.664064347743988,
0.024748772382736206,
-0.5408573746681213,
0.03187337890267372,
-0.35841068625450134,
0.3487299084663391,
-0.7170854806900024,
0.04401296004652977,
0.011123531498014927,
0.9291223883628845,
-0.8775975108146667,
0.857076108455658,
0.42746543884277344,
-0.40867358446121216,
-0.7107282280921936,
-0.03093382716178894,
0.08660217374563217,
-0.6515471935272217,
0.9147513508796692,
0.23228059709072113,
-0.18900258839130402,
-0.14343127608299255,
-0.23298949003219604,
-0.7237641215324402,
1.4960404634475708,
0.3961377441883087,
-0.7745497226715088,
0.17422647774219513,
0.33752530813217163,
0.8244554996490479,
-0.6316214203834534,
0.2580748200416565,
0.5901833176612854,
0.4109230637550354,
0.223746657371521,
-1.1884855031967163,
0.1649729311466217,
0.08903604000806808,
-0.12722048163414001,
-0.07148043066263199,
-0.8820220232009888,
0.5935181975364685,
-0.20564720034599304,
-0.24048705399036407,
-0.027188509702682495,
0.7171597480773926,
0.18090282380580902,
0.30418848991394043,
0.5894610285758972,
0.2754165828227997,
0.8893755674362183,
-0.11067564785480499,
1.105833649635315,
-0.11990997195243835,
0.6865358948707581,
1.3133563995361328,
-0.6535531878471375,
1.0054030418395996,
0.5510819554328918,
-0.2886328399181366,
0.2309345006942749,
0.3189958930015564,
-0.021560098975896835,
0.5638362169265747,
0.27454254031181335,
-0.5097591876983643,
-0.2589642405509949,
-0.010345966555178165,
-0.053518109023571014,
0.5767711997032166,
0.21865031123161316,
-0.500045657157898,
-0.44550397992134094,
-0.0553046315908432,
-0.1452292948961258,
0.3141680359840393,
-0.20434385538101196,
0.7049400210380554,
0.13513104617595673,
-0.6235578656196594,
0.6058031916618347,
-0.12010768055915833,
0.8106982111930847,
-0.5197972059249878,
0.3411625027656555,
-0.40449121594429016,
0.30560624599456787,
-0.3200884759426117,
-0.5655810236930847,
0.5450909733772278,
0.12321867793798447,
0.008107655681669712,
-0.552696168422699,
0.6689029335975647,
-0.4873664379119873,
-0.33530232310295105,
0.5553805232048035,
0.6378067135810852,
-0.04981199651956558,
0.010928504168987274,
-0.5339834690093994,
0.20768901705741882,
-0.2189060002565384,
-0.21699704229831696,
0.5705050230026245,
-0.021936506032943726,
0.07769700884819031,
0.9157018661499023,
0.5674275755882263,
0.07375554740428925,
-0.19866272807121277,
0.2551105320453644,
0.9518057703971863,
-0.07459798455238342,
-0.29399967193603516,
-0.8020411729812622,
0.1244976595044136,
-0.05805029347538948,
-0.049479253590106964,
0.7799683213233948,
0.49791157245635986,
0.8852561116218567,
-0.2457008957862854,
0.6288632750511169,
0.17108584940433502,
0.29350194334983826,
-0.35609397292137146,
1.2802557945251465,
-0.2914239168167114,
0.43235844373703003,
-0.24588140845298767,
-0.8182154297828674,
-0.29001685976982117,
0.4649578928947449,
-0.6362277269363403,
-0.12815739214420319,
0.6584808826446533,
0.5222408771514893,
-0.07548221945762634,
0.3474524915218353,
0.378243625164032,
0.18778137862682343,
0.44257307052612305,
0.6543166041374207,
0.686497688293457,
-0.211417555809021,
0.3924870193004608,
-0.582345187664032,
-0.296781063079834,
-0.18601226806640625,
-0.8564706444740295,
-1.0367506742477417,
-0.6799639463424683,
-0.5005025863647461,
0.1717349737882614,
0.19938866794109344,
0.9775440692901611,
0.7632167339324951,
-0.8430879712104797,
-0.37885209918022156,
-0.24967360496520996,
0.2303992658853531,
-0.20452269911766052,
-0.3011256456375122,
0.17455053329467773,
-0.3157464265823364,
-0.6294059753417969,
0.5046570897102356,
0.32878828048706055,
-0.2621905505657196,
-0.7793090343475342,
-0.21960866451263428,
-0.12933185696601868,
-0.3820711672306061,
0.5646840929985046,
-0.15591534972190857,
-0.8479751944541931,
-0.41011929512023926,
-0.16634123027324677,
-0.031857844442129135,
-0.18564659357070923,
0.5655014514923096,
-0.8784906268119812,
0.36935675144195557,
0.5292230248451233,
0.9131282567977905,
0.13722823560237885,
0.05210817605257034,
0.8234207034111023,
-0.8727606534957886,
0.06849056482315063,
0.3689154386520386,
0.28766849637031555,
0.5200508236885071,
-0.4563617706298828,
0.5467203855514526,
0.22762832045555115,
-0.6949900388717651,
-0.7755278944969177,
-0.10152750462293625,
-0.7426267266273499,
0.30261218547821045,
1.0132393836975098,
-0.8031399250030518,
-0.10205399990081787,
0.14760179817676544,
0.43004828691482544,
-0.050946567207574844,
-0.3352847099304199,
0.69630366563797,
0.9012836813926697,
0.0017867033602669835,
-0.03557872399687767,
-0.2621743977069855,
0.4194031059741974,
0.21737487614154816,
-0.9097902178764343,
0.2624584138393402,
0.5660467147827148,
0.46670833230018616,
0.21611717343330383,
0.4686077833175659,
0.027406202629208565,
0.1817675083875656,
-0.33773910999298096,
-0.21562838554382324,
-0.3190702795982361,
-0.1537451595067978,
-0.5913671255111694,
0.23266489803791046,
-0.10886912047863007,
-0.025407997891306877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12253v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12253v1
|
Toward Self-Improvement of LLMs via Imagination, Searching, and Criticizing
| 2024-04-18T15:21:34 | 2024-04-18T15:21:34 |
Ye Tian, Baolin Peng, Linfeng Song, Lifeng Jin, Dian Yu, Haitao Mi, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite the impressive capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) on
various tasks, they still struggle with scenarios that involves complex
reasoning and planning. Recent work proposed advanced prompting techniques and
the necessity of fine-tuning with high-quality data to augment LLMs' reasoning
abilities. However, these approaches are inherently constrained by data
availability and quality. In light of this, self-correction and self-learning
emerge as viable solutions, employing strategies that allow LLMs to refine
their outputs and learn from self-assessed rewards. Yet, the efficacy of LLMs
in self-refining its response, particularly in complex reasoning and planning
task, remains dubious. In this paper, we introduce AlphaLLM for the
self-improvements of LLMs, which integrates Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) with
LLMs to establish a self-improving loop, thereby enhancing the capabilities of
LLMs without additional annotations. Drawing inspiration from the success of
AlphaGo, AlphaLLM addresses the unique challenges of combining MCTS with LLM
for self-improvement, including data scarcity, the vastness search spaces of
language tasks, and the subjective nature of feedback in language tasks.
AlphaLLM is comprised of prompt synthesis component, an efficient MCTS approach
tailored for language tasks, and a trio of critic models for precise feedback.
Our experimental results in mathematical reasoning tasks demonstrate that
AlphaLLM significantly enhances the performance of LLMs without additional
annotations, showing the potential for self-improvement in LLMs.
|
[
-0.3448501229286194,
-0.9477954506874084,
0.7760491967201233,
0.14510758221149445,
0.1241893544793129,
0.3896803557872772,
-0.38891875743865967,
-0.22021374106407166,
0.30083200335502625,
0.2928566634654999,
-0.7906875014305115,
-0.3710378110408783,
-0.3012787997722626,
0.16063351929187775,
-0.025347497314214706,
0.871688723564148,
-0.21144600212574005,
0.014162757433950901,
-0.1559138000011444,
0.1468413770198822,
-0.4867319166660309,
-0.3537043333053589,
-0.6997010111808777,
-0.3413219451904297,
0.7834185361862183,
0.6482203006744385,
0.44208863377571106,
0.5819260478019714,
0.40130457282066345,
0.35484579205513,
0.36997857689857483,
0.6047002673149109,
-0.452127605676651,
0.48735079169273376,
-0.42063409090042114,
-0.41483283042907715,
-0.6763597130775452,
0.049479998648166656,
0.475420206785202,
0.17216026782989502,
-0.13593602180480957,
0.004910450894385576,
0.20785680413246155,
0.7762728333473206,
-0.4993247389793396,
0.3768211305141449,
-0.6795427799224854,
0.029767675325274467,
-0.029889386147260666,
-0.4835994839668274,
-0.12948188185691833,
-0.3120366632938385,
-0.23819725215435028,
-0.5878969430923462,
0.15506085753440857,
0.21738584339618683,
0.34061893820762634,
0.3233408033847809,
0.12289442867040634,
-0.5389470458030701,
-0.6911452412605286,
0.7036033272743225,
-0.7598971128463745,
0.1611347496509552,
0.2452586442232132,
0.19476348161697388,
-0.27515220642089844,
-0.2896677553653717,
-0.336449533700943,
-0.3199109733104706,
0.054110750555992126,
0.32770290970802307,
0.057523444294929504,
0.1265757530927658,
0.2413872331380844,
0.2860885560512543,
-0.3281554579734802,
0.09876726567745209,
-0.09792871028184891,
-0.22135627269744873,
0.7987972497940063,
0.171635240316391,
0.06496661901473999,
-0.20334279537200928,
0.07143082469701767,
-0.1428341120481491,
-0.8462213277816772,
-0.12769125401973724,
0.2659590244293213,
0.2352275550365448,
0.5054363012313843,
0.5698618292808533,
-0.348530113697052,
0.4128008186817169,
-0.039260316640138626,
-0.32597073912620544,
-0.014355672523379326,
-0.06225883588194847,
-0.1754736453294754,
-0.14233173429965973,
0.6464875340461731,
0.05428123474121094,
0.1917380541563034,
-0.22287186980247498,
-0.5514883995056152,
0.032358985394239426,
0.19012583792209625,
-0.5625455975532532,
-0.4482262432575226,
0.28913047909736633,
-0.08304179459810257,
-0.059596799314022064,
-0.3256077468395233,
-0.3994157910346985,
-0.2281682938337326,
-0.4428243637084961,
0.5789918899536133,
-0.4514404833316803,
-0.15402160584926605,
0.12923090159893036,
0.3463057577610016,
-0.29746755957603455,
0.8112294673919678,
-0.7413225769996643,
0.12975959479808807,
0.5758136510848999,
0.68121737241745,
-0.12714636325836182,
-0.3408953547477722,
-0.4113607704639435,
0.04211963340640068,
-0.6221559643745422,
0.9581072330474854,
-0.47564423084259033,
-0.31507793068885803,
-0.3541683554649353,
-0.36281704902648926,
-0.08851025998592377,
-0.6175518035888672,
0.5599924921989441,
-0.23017163574695587,
0.09268683940172195,
-0.21478348970413208,
-0.5680548548698425,
-0.22216394543647766,
0.6502975821495056,
-0.29876643419265747,
1.0322200059890747,
-0.029865730553865433,
-0.4564659893512726,
-0.07988454401493073,
-0.9197197556495667,
-0.13784554600715637,
0.1382244974374771,
-0.373738557100296,
-0.3690614402294159,
0.41528987884521484,
0.5266479253768921,
0.4011135995388031,
-0.12352074682712555,
0.11800026893615723,
-0.3682631850242615,
-0.27486321330070496,
0.4044426381587982,
-0.3365176320075989,
0.1641700565814972,
0.3109605312347412,
-0.39681896567344666,
0.23531097173690796,
-0.514988362789154,
0.44305673241615295,
0.20018181204795837,
-0.24231064319610596,
-0.06908046454191208,
0.16772150993347168,
-0.5688311457633972,
0.24358586966991425,
0.19673940539360046,
-0.43782973289489746,
0.5757011771202087,
-0.4711180329322815,
0.2412964403629303,
0.9575121402740479,
0.004366938956081867,
0.24128344655036926,
-0.5161364078521729,
0.7100823521614075,
-0.06147714704275131,
0.17546182870864868,
-0.45969414710998535,
-0.20337125658988953,
-0.9584214091300964,
-0.09024687111377716,
0.35404592752456665,
0.36265358328819275,
-0.7509655356407166,
0.06096614524722099,
0.04363808408379555,
-0.3070422410964966,
-0.8475517630577087,
0.4688803255558014,
0.3921250104904175,
0.3525543212890625,
0.5080968737602234,
-0.1677785962820053,
-0.6301068663597107,
-0.652204155921936,
-0.3052848279476166,
-0.2266082763671875,
0.12018544226884842,
0.2868870198726654,
0.19978028535842896,
-0.24610193073749542,
0.9056912064552307,
-0.3118933439254761,
-0.49527591466903687,
-0.1591041386127472,
0.024980556219816208,
0.13893866539001465,
0.4741221070289612,
-0.034128520637750626,
-0.11014828085899353,
-0.3255431354045868,
-0.17512932419776917,
-0.739811360836029,
-0.1978098750114441,
-0.0825565829873085,
-0.00504760118201375,
0.07498333603143692,
0.5128194093704224,
-0.29160913825035095,
0.19403712451457977,
0.37931114435195923,
-0.0700644701719284,
0.6043851971626282,
-0.461141437292099,
0.11022107303142548,
-0.5359316468238831,
-0.3675995469093323,
-0.07689185440540314,
-0.20704953372478485,
-0.3287988305091858,
0.1822509467601776,
0.03143209218978882,
0.1959301084280014,
-0.19490624964237213,
0.7192754745483398,
-0.6759968400001526,
0.04180146008729935,
-0.5038028955459595,
0.2710800766944885,
-0.21812014281749725,
0.5693106651306152,
-0.11405868083238602,
0.7749300003051758,
0.7062020897865295,
-0.5635571479797363,
0.1214928925037384,
-0.17998158931732178,
-0.1122615709900856,
0.21350234746932983,
-0.4312964379787445,
0.202663391828537,
-0.30746564269065857,
-0.007606129162013531,
-0.9309381246566772,
-0.05039159953594208,
0.38991695642471313,
-0.3709203600883484,
0.26098963618278503,
-0.02402566559612751,
-0.4863116145133972,
-0.38103538751602173,
-0.3135535418987274,
0.14106695353984833,
0.5311460494995117,
-0.6406917572021484,
0.761324942111969,
0.08393501490354538,
-0.13130420446395874,
-0.5558404326438904,
-0.38621440529823303,
0.18784737586975098,
0.03527360409498215,
-0.41658294200897217,
-0.050023384392261505,
-0.34929656982421875,
-0.3273167312145233,
-0.12494657933712006,
-0.25881466269493103,
0.46964019536972046,
0.15951481461524963,
0.2319003939628601,
-0.02745322696864605,
-0.02629082091152668,
0.40360888838768005,
0.0638166144490242,
-0.14220258593559265,
0.33425280451774597,
-0.3778533339500427,
0.3298826813697815,
-0.28869524598121643,
-0.4562664031982422,
-0.07908628135919571,
-0.03991705924272537,
0.03582657501101494,
-0.18764400482177734,
-0.020618434995412827,
0.24514055252075195,
-0.13103456795215607,
-0.5852183103561401,
-0.8761844038963318,
-0.4268079102039337,
-0.5144029259681702,
0.1912182867527008,
-0.7107059955596924,
-1.1360642910003662,
0.1820366084575653,
-0.2929801940917969,
0.3120168447494507,
0.551559329032898,
0.48589709401130676,
-0.4000159204006195,
1.2391729354858398,
0.35359907150268555,
0.27573513984680176,
0.26517951488494873,
-0.4969727098941803,
0.08387241512537003,
-1.1269237995147705,
-0.2517934739589691,
-0.3280550241470337,
-0.23111307621002197,
-0.42363449931144714,
-0.6097851395606995,
0.21557413041591644,
0.12784703075885773,
0.06844539940357208,
-0.09221352636814117,
-0.6248999834060669,
0.69205242395401,
0.4103141129016876,
0.19455526769161224,
0.4852026104927063,
-0.05169251933693886,
-0.4270295798778534,
-0.3502334952354431,
-1.0414516925811768,
-0.4725962281227112,
0.9885645508766174,
0.41757604479789734,
1.1591459512710571,
-0.10741349309682846,
0.9879882335662842,
0.12818801403045654,
0.7891819477081299,
-0.7384844422340393,
0.6540732979774475,
0.2689739763736725,
-0.4074801504611969,
-0.40077823400497437,
-0.6756927371025085,
-0.9377377033233643,
0.2545134425163269,
-0.14411409199237823,
-0.5756096839904785,
-0.10963819175958633,
0.461290568113327,
-0.29532837867736816,
0.2743369936943054,
-0.5458572506904602,
0.6418595910072327,
-0.7511293292045593,
-0.5770611763000488,
-0.3375442922115326,
-0.10264725238084793,
0.4296835660934448,
-0.18833446502685547,
0.48941266536712646,
-0.4787517189979553,
-0.03825035318732262,
0.5022382140159607,
-0.38292717933654785,
0.7321617603302002,
-0.0030095006804913282,
-0.2420262098312378,
0.385600745677948,
0.688302218914032,
0.5572711229324341,
0.3683418333530426,
-0.002324870554730296,
-0.15881697833538055,
-0.3297954499721527,
-0.2669650614261627,
-0.9408847689628601,
0.9362764954566956,
-0.6835864782333374,
-1.1446915864944458,
-0.4226807951927185,
-0.7409794926643372,
-0.3323393166065216,
0.04171634092926979,
-0.17858897149562836,
0.23792651295661926,
-0.04520327225327492,
-0.20381030440330505,
0.613025963306427,
0.025809641927480698,
0.6301689147949219,
0.45827987790107727,
-0.6698169708251953,
-0.4789116382598877,
0.8857849836349487,
0.2557588219642639,
0.1200714260339737,
0.11226797848939896,
0.284548282623291,
-0.5739164352416992,
-0.5956740975379944,
-0.31923046708106995,
0.42567673325538635,
-0.8219119906425476,
-0.3941228985786438,
-0.7390893697738647,
-0.23068572580814362,
-0.3152560889720917,
-0.04749390482902527,
-0.4473217725753784,
-0.592456579208374,
-0.0854325070977211,
-0.031010033562779427,
0.31178170442581177,
0.951797604560852,
-0.314347505569458,
0.14814284443855286,
-0.36278361082077026,
0.03023247793316841,
0.5475091934204102,
0.4310084879398346,
0.2865150570869446,
-0.47813260555267334,
-0.40051597356796265,
0.1529267579317093,
-0.4398459196090698,
-0.486310750246048,
0.5512953400611877,
0.09799986332654953,
0.4667051434516907,
0.1421501338481903,
-0.1366540789604187,
0.9885029196739197,
-0.4765641689300537,
0.3533385992050171,
0.1889946609735489,
-1.0218946933746338,
0.8083838820457458,
-0.08333797752857208,
0.5548207759857178,
0.4431648850440979,
0.15054509043693542,
-0.2423291951417923,
-0.7819783687591553,
-0.7729368805885315,
-0.4881461262702942,
0.5834662318229675,
0.3545985221862793,
-0.09216802567243576,
-0.10652809590101242,
0.623833179473877,
-0.2129540592432022,
0.044200457632541656,
-0.6873979568481445,
-0.023790784180164337,
-0.29092973470687866,
-0.0068401857279241085,
-0.22395022213459015,
-0.12128888815641403,
-0.10376239567995071,
-0.3576054275035858,
0.9862192273139954,
-0.5714324712753296,
0.03519764170050621,
0.5644532442092896,
-0.11530660092830658,
-0.33578169345855713,
0.2873173952102661,
0.3717682361602783,
0.7278383374214172,
0.002465844852849841,
0.4983215928077698,
0.42624208331108093,
0.10546253621578217,
0.26550066471099854,
-0.21261385083198547,
-0.06147848814725876,
0.036821603775024414,
0.10413700342178345,
0.5333297252655029,
0.31731289625167847,
-0.7082477807998657,
0.048459116369485855,
-0.16724893450737,
-0.04301012307405472,
-0.2451167106628418,
0.5215988755226135,
0.19442501664161682,
0.3165662884712219,
0.5361490845680237,
-0.05249742045998573,
0.2094927877187729,
-0.6851550936698914,
0.17916619777679443,
0.5304017066955566,
-0.3342377841472626,
-0.06899020075798035,
0.6493803858757019,
-0.0715646892786026,
-0.5294283628463745,
0.3741636574268341,
-0.2741943597793579,
-0.4172128140926361,
0.5070108771324158,
0.5112622380256653,
0.8520969152450562,
-0.5216296911239624,
0.21688425540924072,
0.497542142868042,
0.4101191461086273,
-0.2981536090373993,
0.3331402838230133,
-0.10091054439544678,
-0.6242078542709351,
-0.683273434638977,
-0.4940073788166046,
-0.5134497284889221,
-0.11551439762115479,
-0.10678873211145401,
0.1849571019411087,
-0.6934422850608826,
-0.1049136146903038,
-0.19777807593345642,
0.27498766779899597,
-0.43827056884765625,
0.3753306567668915,
-0.1946180909872055,
0.6960110664367676,
-0.2671937644481659,
0.9550893306732178,
0.6045740246772766,
-0.24892060458660126,
-0.8379577994346619,
-0.13587087392807007,
-0.285739928483963,
-0.8354896306991577,
0.48846057057380676,
0.1915556639432907,
-0.16370557248592377,
0.12854833900928497,
-0.5062294006347656,
-1.015014410018921,
0.8847066760063171,
0.3184806704521179,
-0.9840383529663086,
0.0031201825477182865,
-0.07720065861940384,
0.734732985496521,
-0.6318438053131104,
0.5047741532325745,
0.268974244594574,
0.5149184465408325,
0.19955365359783173,
-0.7139362692832947,
-0.026856854557991028,
-0.053535040467977524,
0.1804114729166031,
0.274264931678772,
-0.6448328495025635,
0.6506681442260742,
-0.4822777211666107,
-0.16391785442829132,
-0.17557452619075775,
0.7159194350242615,
0.5015572905540466,
0.11632188409566879,
0.4056946337223053,
0.5301297903060913,
0.6231431365013123,
-0.1648998111486435,
0.8663691878318787,
-0.34003886580467224,
0.5193825960159302,
1.443244218826294,
-0.08900132775306702,
0.6359907388687134,
0.2672516107559204,
0.1127903088927269,
0.4609619677066803,
0.6808987259864807,
0.09565111994743347,
0.1556159406900406,
0.4733569920063019,
-0.1896054595708847,
-0.5732280611991882,
0.17946936190128326,
-0.11440788954496384,
0.1917290985584259,
0.5716795921325684,
-0.16188481450080872,
-0.4404917359352112,
-0.053201161324977875,
0.027810528874397278,
0.22048938274383545,
-0.5706164240837097,
0.7391287088394165,
0.14834317564964294,
-0.8037474751472473,
0.5837300419807434,
0.07827452570199966,
0.5571786165237427,
-0.40188661217689514,
-0.13104771077632904,
-0.3691345155239105,
0.24938815832138062,
-0.33544430136680603,
-0.6744961738586426,
0.28788134455680847,
-0.17279289662837982,
0.13362209498882294,
-0.3707616627216339,
0.7295250296592712,
-0.5527883768081665,
-0.6834397912025452,
0.3760526478290558,
0.8597723245620728,
0.1779739111661911,
-0.03582056984305382,
-1.1144890785217285,
0.18471185863018036,
-0.07786786556243896,
-0.3356301188468933,
0.21757152676582336,
0.5957556962966919,
0.040860407054424286,
0.99447101354599,
0.7107841372489929,
0.3321622312068939,
-0.07869315892457962,
-0.03048098459839821,
0.8270837664604187,
-0.8579804301261902,
-0.26916101574897766,
-0.8972964286804199,
0.21966029703617096,
0.04983997344970703,
-0.13387490808963776,
1.039586067199707,
0.7129706144332886,
0.8706289529800415,
0.09121578931808472,
0.7734570503234863,
0.23005008697509766,
0.6440674662590027,
-0.6325133442878723,
0.27565866708755493,
-0.5250763893127441,
0.6174818277359009,
-0.10736430436372757,
-1.0349795818328857,
-0.29638123512268066,
0.7479209899902344,
-0.19741998612880707,
0.11496192216873169,
0.7582516670227051,
0.8951870799064636,
0.013091527856886387,
-0.200527161359787,
0.5404340624809265,
0.45958828926086426,
0.330980122089386,
0.5304965376853943,
0.9498267769813538,
-0.32457900047302246,
0.4205504059791565,
-0.32486215233802795,
-0.20536364614963531,
-0.03000120259821415,
-0.7008692622184753,
-1.0301419496536255,
-0.3001643121242523,
-0.5679835677146912,
-0.44446736574172974,
0.34802091121673584,
1.1667637825012207,
0.6515536904335022,
-0.639746904373169,
-0.5368004441261292,
-0.1899433434009552,
0.3828878700733185,
-0.16391584277153015,
-0.20165202021598816,
0.11690276861190796,
-0.9609384536743164,
-0.6257569193840027,
0.6934210658073425,
0.6435924768447876,
0.028926260769367218,
-0.7079532146453857,
-0.4073622226715088,
0.015018097124993801,
0.32635489106178284,
0.5196626782417297,
0.316772997379303,
-0.9436396956443787,
-0.25386378169059753,
0.16529028117656708,
-0.00925176776945591,
0.3824809789657593,
0.8559218049049377,
-1.0368022918701172,
0.7444136738777161,
0.17902174592018127,
0.4750557243824005,
0.6038865447044373,
-0.11974899470806122,
0.4129619002342224,
-0.5355416536331177,
-0.2980526089668274,
0.44990476965904236,
0.46119675040245056,
0.2631300687789917,
-0.31143897771835327,
0.8522980213165283,
0.06293392926454544,
-0.6589744091033936,
-0.6232729554176331,
0.20921872556209564,
-0.6454949378967285,
-0.4211432635784149,
1.0470249652862549,
-0.048884905874729156,
-0.404812216758728,
0.05576597899198532,
-0.5184923410415649,
-0.08411724865436554,
-0.4517645537853241,
1.2975050210952759,
0.6556521058082581,
-0.5019614696502686,
-0.6044993996620178,
-0.229154571890831,
0.5792138576507568,
0.6466729640960693,
-0.9641498923301697,
0.13122175633907318,
0.5021335482597351,
0.2795616388320923,
0.20355860888957977,
0.7470473647117615,
-0.18623335659503937,
0.1532912403345108,
-0.44021785259246826,
0.26063597202301025,
-0.1127217710018158,
-0.60665363073349,
-0.4290724992752075,
0.17677079141139984,
0.4347206950187683,
0.3988928496837616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12242v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12242v1
|
CMNEE: A Large-Scale Document-Level Event Extraction Dataset based on Open-Source Chinese Military News
| 2024-04-18T15:02:35 | 2024-04-18T15:02:35 |
Mengna Zhu, Zijie Xu, Kaisheng Zeng, Kaiming Xiao, Mao Wang, Wenjun Ke, Hongbin Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extracting structured event knowledge, including event triggers and
corresponding arguments, from military texts is fundamental to many
applications, such as intelligence analysis and decision assistance. However,
event extraction in the military field faces the data scarcity problem, which
impedes the research of event extraction models in this domain. To alleviate
this problem, we propose CMNEE, a large-scale, document-level open-source
Chinese Military News Event Extraction dataset. It contains 17,000 documents
and 29,223 events, which are all manually annotated based on a pre-defined
schema for the military domain including 8 event types and 11 argument role
types. We designed a two-stage, multi-turns annotation strategy to ensure the
quality of CMNEE and reproduced several state-of-the-art event extraction
models with a systematic evaluation. The experimental results on CMNEE fall
shorter than those on other domain datasets obviously, which demonstrates that
event extraction for military domain poses unique challenges and requires
further research efforts. Our code and data can be obtained from
https://github.com/Mzzzhu/CMNEE.
|
[
-0.4158300459384918,
-0.7786168456077576,
0.6991082429885864,
0.028342055156826973,
-0.5127335786819458,
-0.1905578374862671,
-0.3218806982040405,
-0.22783823311328888,
-0.005973590072244406,
0.24535712599754333,
-0.7071748375892639,
-0.684978187084198,
-0.8234150409698486,
-0.2186281830072403,
-0.3087116479873657,
0.9565039277076721,
-0.1189308762550354,
-0.18735367059707642,
0.3322112262248993,
-0.16389551758766174,
0.09702541679143906,
-0.7546294331550598,
-0.7855132222175598,
0.14177821576595306,
0.6498556733131409,
0.495451420545578,
0.3526412546634674,
0.5594950318336487,
0.7518211007118225,
0.1629270762205124,
0.16410769522190094,
0.43831437826156616,
-0.22876855731010437,
0.0259343720972538,
-0.0788750872015953,
-0.10116642713546753,
-0.5601601004600525,
0.4263562858104706,
0.6219627857208252,
0.17996545135974884,
0.016915053129196167,
0.3314190208911896,
-0.15409812331199646,
0.2624598443508148,
-0.49775052070617676,
0.1201203316450119,
-0.6285737752914429,
0.02323928289115429,
-0.7082433700561523,
-0.2917749285697937,
-0.2684611976146698,
-0.09603891521692276,
0.18380598723888397,
-0.8197862505912781,
0.24546702206134796,
-0.3007434010505676,
0.9953742623329163,
-0.1474074423313141,
-0.3530229926109314,
0.04364002123475075,
-0.2591104507446289,
0.7901931405067444,
-0.7526293396949768,
0.22199863195419312,
0.3892698585987091,
0.4670821726322174,
-0.05250333249568939,
-0.6345533132553101,
-0.42317530512809753,
0.04913756623864174,
0.18909704685211182,
0.3220163583755493,
0.05728454887866974,
-0.18961326777935028,
0.4258042573928833,
0.1556698977947235,
-0.6248838901519775,
0.24863049387931824,
-0.41406816244125366,
0.08383038640022278,
0.8605297207832336,
0.1666746437549591,
0.43231794238090515,
-0.4837598204612732,
-0.5186322331428528,
0.11972743272781372,
-0.6517944931983948,
0.1381976157426834,
0.12686225771903992,
0.10513891279697418,
-0.46388673782348633,
0.7060182690620422,
-0.432267963886261,
0.33485522866249084,
0.06704989075660706,
-0.2241731435060501,
0.05159634351730347,
-0.3012031018733978,
-0.4234209656715393,
0.01620841585099697,
1.1429749727249146,
0.38571032881736755,
0.10992198437452316,
-0.17447267472743988,
-0.041501495987176895,
-0.17249131202697754,
0.058703817427158356,
-1.098402738571167,
-0.21037140488624573,
0.4147017300128937,
-0.9208984971046448,
-0.709717333316803,
0.36728599667549133,
-1.037092924118042,
-0.5345362424850464,
-0.3208950161933899,
0.02057407982647419,
-0.3969168961048126,
-0.4902995228767395,
-0.3095947504043579,
-0.7319300770759583,
0.3183133006095886,
0.344939649105072,
-0.6606529951095581,
-0.5165098309516907,
0.9327799677848816,
0.9031922221183777,
-0.57977694272995,
-0.23673351109027863,
-1.015157699584961,
0.018954114988446236,
-0.2781687378883362,
0.8010132312774658,
-0.5505894422531128,
-0.37387776374816895,
-0.08191483467817307,
0.3467613458633423,
0.002520742127671838,
-0.3521803021430969,
0.8249086737632751,
-0.47594138979911804,
0.0433858297765255,
-0.10993363708257675,
-0.24016517400741577,
0.11895386129617691,
0.34146788716316223,
-0.608802855014801,
0.6596003770828247,
0.22145090997219086,
-0.5632850527763367,
0.49067118763923645,
-0.6609442830085754,
-0.4527532756328583,
0.12978537380695343,
-0.48433640599250793,
-0.3439350426197052,
0.10261661559343338,
0.35100868344306946,
0.5295541882514954,
-0.6079786419868469,
0.4227217733860016,
-0.46834370493888855,
0.09513191133737564,
0.09855276346206665,
-0.4850224256515503,
1.106835961341858,
0.1723732054233551,
-0.484646737575531,
0.005442972760647535,
-1.0247890949249268,
-0.11428950726985931,
0.13249827921390533,
-0.5278319716453552,
-0.26703283190727234,
0.08323685824871063,
0.029824955388903618,
0.5425299406051636,
0.1381738781929016,
-0.8384408950805664,
0.489172101020813,
-0.39163997769355774,
0.23670457303524017,
0.6455926299095154,
0.42641985416412354,
0.4957692325115204,
-0.0718209370970726,
0.33824393153190613,
0.38054728507995605,
0.536687970161438,
-0.23053514957427979,
-0.4331772029399872,
-0.26125675439834595,
-0.4081760048866272,
0.16745033860206604,
0.3291354775428772,
-0.8318988084793091,
0.4769081473350525,
0.08233430981636047,
-0.7353243827819824,
-0.2556607723236084,
-0.008976105600595474,
0.05196614935994148,
0.4913928806781769,
0.2137915939092636,
0.036126505583524704,
-0.8883615732192993,
-0.606560230255127,
-0.0020120784174650908,
-0.1524057239294052,
0.006616278551518917,
-0.1682911366224289,
0.060738760977983475,
-0.1340285688638687,
0.7723216414451599,
-0.47717365622520447,
-0.24605093896389008,
-0.09893231838941574,
0.5705333352088928,
-0.021724555641412735,
0.1903011053800583,
0.5008677244186401,
-0.93165123462677,
-0.05987175554037094,
0.48180869221687317,
-1.099807620048523,
-0.143523171544075,
-0.5932630300521851,
-0.4637583792209625,
0.33606043457984924,
0.41247352957725525,
-0.7334080338478088,
0.7261449098587036,
0.45130541920661926,
-0.2571183741092682,
0.9628129005432129,
0.4910840690135956,
0.30224135518074036,
-1.1157771348953247,
0.3017961382865906,
-0.09508121758699417,
0.2528930902481079,
-0.43228980898857117,
0.22829516232013702,
0.2921455204486847,
-0.4138895273208618,
-0.43707743287086487,
0.6826053261756897,
-0.3553747832775116,
0.000018820932382368483,
-0.4893786311149597,
0.5872904658317566,
0.18464313447475433,
0.42535513639450073,
0.32167941331863403,
0.4532650113105774,
0.33941641449928284,
-0.41044560074806213,
0.5227328538894653,
0.42105305194854736,
-0.3065694272518158,
0.4425283968448639,
-0.24935026466846466,
-0.35708266496658325,
0.21535448729991913,
0.20248563587665558,
-0.41523757576942444,
-0.16145335137844086,
0.3969745934009552,
-0.4578978717327118,
-0.035721562802791595,
-0.35043153166770935,
-0.2779819071292877,
-0.16529805958271027,
-0.39975112676620483,
0.11952776461839676,
0.20259122550487518,
-0.6338376998901367,
0.5900009870529175,
0.5533449649810791,
-0.29884791374206543,
-0.47330668568611145,
-0.5114050507545471,
0.16842445731163025,
-0.007622046861797571,
-0.3022303879261017,
0.014685851521790028,
-0.05533621087670326,
-0.19723452627658844,
-0.13203763961791992,
-0.3206122815608978,
-0.29364103078842163,
0.11721449345350266,
0.5819934010505676,
0.8947519063949585,
-0.7225276827812195,
-0.006206413730978966,
-0.11874859780073166,
-0.1264754980802536,
0.2099534273147583,
-0.2790455222129822,
0.3346481919288635,
0.41073358058929443,
-0.5293978452682495,
-0.507615864276886,
0.6638631820678711,
0.7220549583435059,
-0.5707715153694153,
0.5317205786705017,
0.926092267036438,
-0.3857838213443756,
-0.1787610799074173,
-0.4059670865535736,
0.12124527990818024,
-0.39599406719207764,
0.3010707199573517,
-0.23757538199424744,
-0.3300347626209259,
0.0660337507724762,
-0.23506397008895874,
0.7065776586532593,
0.9574894905090332,
0.3789246082305908,
0.03913377970457077,
1.0141390562057495,
0.20802041888237,
-0.2957700490951538,
0.3577914237976074,
-0.2012639343738556,
-0.1051010936498642,
-0.9093756675720215,
-0.19473622739315033,
-0.5753926038742065,
-0.16590453684329987,
0.013112414628267288,
-0.42647919058799744,
0.2341313660144806,
0.03408496826887131,
-0.2756461799144745,
0.1929040253162384,
-0.3123233914375305,
0.01686464436352253,
0.3746967315673828,
0.028605995699763298,
0.15381935238838196,
-0.0599057637155056,
0.17392735183238983,
-0.007986892946064472,
-0.5240916609764099,
-0.26432886719703674,
0.762985110282898,
0.07505535334348679,
0.40760117769241333,
-0.0030362389516085386,
0.7874088287353516,
0.033331796526908875,
0.317787766456604,
-1.0074844360351562,
0.30436059832572937,
-0.46846532821655273,
-0.5425885915756226,
-0.4993780553340912,
-0.5548082590103149,
-0.7287558317184448,
-0.08452308177947998,
-0.20982183516025543,
-0.5436825752258301,
0.48849520087242126,
-0.6278342604637146,
-0.35507848858833313,
0.48715484142303467,
-0.41578978300094604,
0.6683984398841858,
-0.2536506950855255,
0.23027241230010986,
-0.06681367009878159,
-0.35522428154945374,
0.6422491669654846,
-0.5171296000480652,
0.2809111773967743,
-0.30115118622779846,
-0.11010978370904922,
0.8324413299560547,
-0.40440699458122253,
0.5546600222587585,
-0.24443505704402924,
-0.17248041927814484,
0.29153934121131897,
0.06285607814788818,
0.6826188564300537,
0.1368597447872162,
-0.5399541258811951,
0.3433755338191986,
0.08342648297548294,
-0.14935782551765442,
-0.3823011815547943,
0.5461717247962952,
-0.6845347881317139,
-0.6121829748153687,
-0.1772119402885437,
-0.2568148076534271,
0.015253812074661255,
0.37261489033699036,
0.3668687343597412,
0.9665619134902954,
-0.4119129180908203,
0.3502627909183502,
0.3746888041496277,
-0.33516767621040344,
0.6936439275741577,
0.5058349967002869,
-0.12788325548171997,
-0.3860611319541931,
0.9986221194267273,
0.38878512382507324,
0.1353493630886078,
0.20280444622039795,
0.07933886349201202,
0.19089771807193756,
-0.34962746500968933,
-0.8659505248069763,
-0.14382147789001465,
-0.693596363067627,
-0.4272509813308716,
-0.8852362036705017,
-0.806996762752533,
-0.27784475684165955,
-0.3519464135169983,
-0.1524202972650528,
-0.7535340785980225,
-0.48830273747444153,
0.04193717613816261,
0.07819072902202606,
0.36439573764801025,
0.0027079719584435225,
0.22116518020629883,
-1.1352753639221191,
0.9881337285041809,
-0.15226328372955322,
0.09320872277021408,
-0.013884629122912884,
-0.4235430657863617,
-0.3383029103279114,
-0.0908854529261589,
-0.49045857787132263,
-0.6245558261871338,
0.3323526084423065,
0.19900184869766235,
0.7852787971496582,
0.827491283416748,
0.33916181325912476,
0.7065814733505249,
-0.31085851788520813,
1.1231285333633423,
0.3704540729522705,
-0.5862851738929749,
0.8430569767951965,
-0.4228973686695099,
0.4378178119659424,
0.23222972452640533,
0.37528496980667114,
-0.33016201853752136,
-0.427822083234787,
-0.933299720287323,
-0.45907947421073914,
0.9229212999343872,
-0.24254663288593292,
-0.41661229729652405,
-0.283766508102417,
0.006371989846229553,
0.19267989695072174,
-0.29260656237602234,
-0.10759688913822174,
-0.1208178773522377,
-0.08241453766822815,
-0.13881294429302216,
0.05674003064632416,
-0.2288408875465393,
-0.2219245731830597,
0.14563313126564026,
0.6655333042144775,
-0.029238218441605568,
-0.03865952044725418,
0.32190775871276855,
-0.2683091461658478,
-0.15440507233142853,
0.07808034121990204,
0.5446836948394775,
0.728732705116272,
-0.08069223165512085,
-0.03757335990667343,
0.16350986063480377,
-0.7094357013702393,
-0.157300665974617,
0.3738839626312256,
0.003131127217784524,
0.24499596655368805,
0.5114622712135315,
0.3028585910797119,
0.32257696986198425,
-0.7404829859733582,
0.8503865003585815,
-0.24260377883911133,
-0.5590367317199707,
-0.19400621950626373,
-0.056370723992586136,
-0.0708715170621872,
0.5421584844589233,
0.6540994048118591,
0.023223450407385826,
0.10370993614196777,
-0.520060658454895,
0.6327928900718689,
0.37186360359191895,
-0.23072348535060883,
-0.10015922784805298,
0.5997639894485474,
0.26881635189056396,
-0.19174359738826752,
0.3844701647758484,
0.008218929171562195,
-0.3054094910621643,
0.8174575567245483,
0.1854296773672104,
0.7624496221542358,
-0.05755339562892914,
0.4254256784915924,
0.6450843214988708,
0.242476686835289,
0.06325268745422363,
0.08991596102714539,
-0.06764212995767593,
-0.06667038798332214,
-0.32537463307380676,
-0.7146773934364319,
-0.27433523535728455,
0.29670265316963196,
-0.4905617833137512,
0.7286052107810974,
-0.5513609051704407,
0.055016472935676575,
0.4173620939254761,
0.26629677414894104,
-0.5697821974754333,
0.032283078879117966,
0.5499017238616943,
1.282563328742981,
-0.2093120515346527,
0.958632230758667,
0.061421118676662445,
-0.44245752692222595,
-0.6884143948554993,
0.04531927779316902,
0.3094366788864136,
-0.6278822422027588,
0.6955095529556274,
0.024150395765900612,
0.4005184769630432,
-0.2803846597671509,
-0.2005407214164734,
-0.6094502806663513,
1.0619014501571655,
-0.029424019157886505,
-0.7546701431274414,
-0.11497174948453903,
0.059696514159440994,
-0.1114656925201416,
-0.5107477307319641,
-0.0013012961717322469,
0.47490113973617554,
0.6774668097496033,
-0.1123594418168068,
-0.5453549027442932,
0.14788761734962463,
-0.13225968182086945,
-0.6084417104721069,
0.313507080078125,
-0.7405765652656555,
0.7433990836143494,
0.049764782190322876,
-0.41777876019477844,
0.06805678457021713,
0.492601603269577,
0.35826805233955383,
0.6724092364311218,
0.22070744633674622,
0.2614400386810303,
0.67216956615448,
0.12444920092821121,
0.6782727241516113,
0.1935792714357376,
0.0014741069171577692,
1.0095007419586182,
-0.24184025824069977,
0.8773125410079956,
0.03181597590446472,
0.2411634474992752,
0.25277799367904663,
0.4399218261241913,
-0.2243475317955017,
0.32344862818717957,
-0.34192076325416565,
-0.40226101875305176,
-0.13229042291641235,
0.06298839300870895,
-0.3692786395549774,
0.5535739064216614,
0.3942283093929291,
-0.6289557814598083,
-0.6322425007820129,
0.07399667054414749,
0.04156351834535599,
-0.49111461639404297,
-0.3477265536785126,
0.9189745187759399,
0.1245734915137291,
-0.553324818611145,
0.5552858710289001,
0.1377032846212387,
0.41820454597473145,
-0.6126216650009155,
-0.21253767609596252,
-0.08021511882543564,
-0.2377336323261261,
-0.24216404557228088,
-0.8256431818008423,
0.2725737988948822,
0.24881331622600555,
-0.3797445297241211,
0.18802884221076965,
0.8839421272277832,
-0.25279760360717773,
-0.4351635277271271,
0.05589490383863449,
0.5949531197547913,
0.1329837292432785,
-0.44538554549217224,
-0.5457766056060791,
0.3496446907520294,
-0.039867646992206573,
-0.4099977910518646,
0.600411593914032,
1.056838035583496,
-0.0965408980846405,
0.01987520232796669,
0.9882316589355469,
0.3169986605644226,
-0.04117486998438835,
0.0844007208943367,
0.9279555678367615,
-0.7540429830551147,
-0.09105567634105682,
-1.0216598510742188,
0.6683021783828735,
-0.6760981678962708,
-0.6705578565597534,
0.5350145697593689,
0.7032182812690735,
0.17032243311405182,
0.06727828830480576,
1.1846063137054443,
-0.25614824891090393,
0.28961294889450073,
-0.3464156985282898,
0.9836005568504333,
-0.39463159441947937,
-0.11677191406488419,
0.0824938714504242,
-0.46704334020614624,
-0.12571924924850464,
-0.14158684015274048,
-0.036045949906110764,
-0.8460657596588135,
0.7206820249557495,
0.7438100576400757,
-0.318511426448822,
0.3885349631309509,
0.5461385250091553,
-0.07849230617284775,
0.4807875454425812,
0.34255051612854004,
0.8752611875534058,
-0.4972999095916748,
0.8565796613693237,
-0.04977824166417122,
-0.4658326804637909,
-0.34396106004714966,
-0.8049871921539307,
-0.9694705605506897,
-0.9137584567070007,
-0.18206608295440674,
0.07051607966423035,
-0.03015371412038803,
0.9154201745986938,
0.8637616634368896,
-0.6479511260986328,
0.24063341319561005,
0.4231719970703125,
0.04233214631676674,
-0.07673665881156921,
-0.2254640907049179,
0.5686119794845581,
-0.7558943033218384,
-0.3247273564338684,
0.638617753982544,
0.28635573387145996,
-0.3927222490310669,
0.3004252016544342,
0.09489143639802933,
-0.3343421518802643,
0.029251590371131897,
0.9108774662017822,
0.53276526927948,
-0.6626675724983215,
-0.32309845089912415,
-0.19296108186244965,
-0.2995617389678955,
-0.12302889674901962,
0.84930819272995,
-0.46432796120643616,
0.043754227459430695,
0.3233340084552765,
1.0894488096237183,
0.20344576239585876,
-0.0725765973329544,
0.5720373392105103,
-0.9407814145088196,
0.22809384763240814,
-0.25289836525917053,
0.3588346242904663,
-0.19156630337238312,
-0.6180710196495056,
0.6891083121299744,
0.30675631761550903,
-0.615341067314148,
-0.8360787034034729,
-0.1383076310157776,
-1.195443034172058,
-0.42864367365837097,
1.3886348009109497,
-0.24101509153842926,
-0.2431120127439499,
-0.22611679136753082,
-0.5881777405738831,
0.5944814682006836,
-0.05909376218914986,
0.6183504462242126,
0.9797757267951965,
0.13111257553100586,
-0.42873629927635193,
-0.8545238375663757,
0.5844153165817261,
-0.249428391456604,
-1.1277730464935303,
0.5377018451690674,
0.5119664669036865,
-0.12682506442070007,
-0.13020184636116028,
0.2679000794887543,
-0.3066481351852417,
0.8178428411483765,
0.07053141295909882,
-0.041659776121377945,
-0.14535263180732727,
-0.37810036540031433,
-0.04501853510737419,
0.43596506118774414,
-0.2158135324716568,
-0.3017616868019104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12241v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12241v2
|
Introducing v0.5 of the AI Safety Benchmark from MLCommons
| 2024-04-18T15:01:00 | 2024-05-13T20:46:10 |
Bertie Vidgen, Adarsh Agrawal, Ahmed M. Ahmed, Victor Akinwande, Namir Al-Nuaimi, Najla Alfaraj, Elie Alhajjar, Lora Aroyo, Trupti Bavalatti, Max Bartolo, Borhane Blili-Hamelin, Kurt Bollacker, Rishi Bomassani, Marisa Ferrara Boston, Siméon Campos, Kal Chakra, Canyu Chen, Cody Coleman, Zacharie Delpierre Coudert, Leon Derczynski, Debojyoti Dutta, Ian Eisenberg, James Ezick, Heather Frase, Brian Fuller, Ram Gandikota, Agasthya Gangavarapu, Ananya Gangavarapu, James Gealy, Rajat Ghosh, James Goel, Usman Gohar, Sujata Goswami, Scott A. Hale, Wiebke Hutiri, Joseph Marvin Imperial, Surgan Jandial, Nick Judd, Felix Juefei-Xu, Foutse Khomh, Bhavya Kailkhura, Hannah Rose Kirk, Kevin Klyman, Chris Knotz, Michael Kuchnik, Shachi H. Kumar, Srijan Kumar, Chris Lengerich, Bo Li, Zeyi Liao, Eileen Peters Long, Victor Lu, Sarah Luger, Yifan Mai, Priyanka Mary Mammen, Kelvin Manyeki, Sean McGregor, Virendra Mehta, Shafee Mohammed, Emanuel Moss, Lama Nachman, Dinesh Jinenhally Naganna, Amin Nikanjam, Besmira Nushi, Luis Oala, Iftach Orr, Alicia Parrish, Cigdem Patlak, William Pietri, Forough Poursabzi-Sangdeh, Eleonora Presani, Fabrizio Puletti, Paul Röttger, Saurav Sahay, Tim Santos, Nino Scherrer, Alice Schoenauer Sebag, Patrick Schramowski, Abolfazl Shahbazi, Vin Sharma, Xudong Shen, Vamsi Sistla, Leonard Tang, Davide Testuggine, Vithursan Thangarasa, Elizabeth Anne Watkins, Rebecca Weiss, Chris Welty, Tyler Wilbers, Adina Williams, Carole-Jean Wu, Poonam Yadav, Xianjun Yang, Yi Zeng, Wenhui Zhang, Fedor Zhdanov, Jiacheng Zhu, Percy Liang, Peter Mattson, Joaquin Vanschoren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper introduces v0.5 of the AI Safety Benchmark, which has been created
by the MLCommons AI Safety Working Group. The AI Safety Benchmark has been
designed to assess the safety risks of AI systems that use chat-tuned language
models. We introduce a principled approach to specifying and constructing the
benchmark, which for v0.5 covers only a single use case (an adult chatting to a
general-purpose assistant in English), and a limited set of personas (i.e.,
typical users, malicious users, and vulnerable users). We created a new
taxonomy of 13 hazard categories, of which 7 have tests in the v0.5 benchmark.
We plan to release version 1.0 of the AI Safety Benchmark by the end of 2024.
The v1.0 benchmark will provide meaningful insights into the safety of AI
systems. However, the v0.5 benchmark should not be used to assess the safety of
AI systems. We have sought to fully document the limitations, flaws, and
challenges of v0.5. This release of v0.5 of the AI Safety Benchmark includes
(1) a principled approach to specifying and constructing the benchmark, which
comprises use cases, types of systems under test (SUTs), language and context,
personas, tests, and test items; (2) a taxonomy of 13 hazard categories with
definitions and subcategories; (3) tests for seven of the hazard categories,
each comprising a unique set of test items, i.e., prompts. There are 43,090
test items in total, which we created with templates; (4) a grading system for
AI systems against the benchmark; (5) an openly available platform, and
downloadable tool, called ModelBench that can be used to evaluate the safety of
AI systems on the benchmark; (6) an example evaluation report which benchmarks
the performance of over a dozen openly available chat-tuned language models;
(7) a test specification for the benchmark.
|
[
-0.43065449595451355,
-0.44239190220832825,
-0.013778315857052803,
0.1832226812839508,
0.041813548654317856,
-0.3304368555545807,
0.08636949956417084,
-0.8427280783653259,
-0.47308966517448425,
0.4344262480735779,
-0.42468947172164917,
-0.4219943881034851,
-0.400760680437088,
0.023929312825202942,
-0.5946841835975647,
1.060996413230896,
-0.0617944709956646,
-0.2555427849292755,
-0.4728274941444397,
-0.32230138778686523,
-0.5828465819358826,
-0.7730390429496765,
-0.8003852367401123,
0.04616454616189003,
0.6727222800254822,
0.2914588153362274,
0.5200977921485901,
0.732601523399353,
0.9384766817092896,
0.3172995150089264,
0.01375330425798893,
-0.20915360748767853,
-0.15068258345127106,
0.1822984665632248,
0.14459717273712158,
-0.4630597233772278,
-0.6626386046409607,
0.23795023560523987,
0.26615145802497864,
0.5068065524101257,
-0.06304324418306351,
0.17264792323112488,
-0.1246882751584053,
0.5093103647232056,
-0.8242069482803345,
0.2536151111125946,
-0.45537927746772766,
0.1531796157360077,
-0.10917355120182037,
-0.02637043036520481,
-0.5102543830871582,
-0.2151627093553543,
0.06884481012821198,
-0.3175097107887268,
-0.12193722277879715,
0.1514139324426651,
0.8248397707939148,
0.6144061088562012,
-0.5143543481826782,
0.11801797151565552,
-0.5993086099624634,
0.5309388637542725,
-0.5274534225463867,
0.23261147737503052,
0.3968361020088196,
0.8478691577911377,
-0.12350356578826904,
-0.9056714177131653,
-0.5434565544128418,
-0.4695669710636139,
0.1580478847026825,
-0.15310047566890717,
-0.15501660108566284,
0.09971652179956436,
0.32870185375213623,
0.18250826001167297,
-0.5955818295478821,
0.24565835297107697,
-0.4354361891746521,
-0.18949702382087708,
1.145422101020813,
0.444252073764801,
0.35103869438171387,
0.27609503269195557,
-0.5720358490943909,
-0.5402022004127502,
-0.877352774143219,
-0.06907116621732712,
0.19055868685245514,
0.12286166101694107,
-0.2892959415912628,
0.2959819436073303,
-0.19921685755252838,
0.1826295703649521,
-0.45066168904304504,
-0.10439764708280563,
0.5983332991600037,
-0.37808313965797424,
-0.17340677976608276,
-0.06895190477371216,
1.0308542251586914,
0.7814527750015259,
0.4047471582889557,
-0.012894445098936558,
-0.06100185960531235,
0.12686975300312042,
0.48049864172935486,
-0.49789339303970337,
-0.41596290469169617,
0.15446574985980988,
-0.3290575444698334,
-0.5609104633331299,
-0.34721073508262634,
-0.4624495804309845,
-0.5838419198989868,
0.18891163170337677,
0.3792404532432556,
-0.3030080497264862,
-0.11461691558361053,
-0.13077470660209656,
0.124533511698246,
0.3231668770313263,
0.23774591088294983,
-0.7591874599456787,
0.30696430802345276,
0.7033889889717102,
0.34674516320228577,
-0.20006917417049408,
-0.5053368806838989,
-0.3397155702114105,
-0.0010371371172368526,
-0.46870890259742737,
0.7454663515090942,
-0.17502088844776154,
-0.5633978247642517,
-0.09498412162065506,
-0.008151509799063206,
0.09333188086748123,
-0.5715065002441406,
0.590548574924469,
-0.17499719560146332,
0.20784498751163483,
0.0537232980132103,
-0.5379491448402405,
-0.1555052101612091,
0.3056481182575226,
-0.43609243631362915,
1.0542246103286743,
-0.20368079841136932,
-0.5224705934524536,
0.5449438095092773,
-0.7502102851867676,
-0.495828777551651,
-0.05975509062409401,
-0.21960864961147308,
-0.44532033801078796,
-0.44707000255584717,
-0.11189592629671097,
0.14943917095661163,
-0.36593031883239746,
0.004761743359267712,
-0.4613049328327179,
-0.3084767758846283,
0.04586101323366165,
-0.7075661420822144,
0.7860513925552368,
0.28252118825912476,
-0.40762004256248474,
0.3567480742931366,
-0.5777552723884583,
0.29881131649017334,
-0.12880392372608185,
-0.3438222110271454,
-0.07013113796710968,
0.3890571594238281,
0.08777936547994614,
0.1533983051776886,
0.411367803812027,
-0.16757746040821075,
-0.21804706752300262,
-0.06851842999458313,
0.08052067458629608,
0.7750371694564819,
-0.14466607570648193,
-0.008790605701506138,
-0.4702034592628479,
0.2970050573348999,
0.1513853222131729,
0.5657682418823242,
-0.2450850009918213,
-0.5116767883300781,
-0.7800753712654114,
-0.14670909941196442,
0.48437973856925964,
0.8026318550109863,
-0.15610331296920776,
0.9676541686058044,
0.0029327967204153538,
-0.8068991303443909,
-0.4029930830001831,
-0.25445660948753357,
0.5865091681480408,
0.33082056045532227,
0.36448946595191956,
-0.33547937870025635,
-0.39116862416267395,
-0.8120258450508118,
-0.2549864947795868,
-0.5816337466239929,
-0.17786279320716858,
0.30097413063049316,
0.336702436208725,
-0.27083808183670044,
0.5242685079574585,
-0.1754707545042038,
-0.021053314208984375,
-0.13693831861019135,
0.17213578522205353,
-0.2571250796318054,
0.8238629698753357,
0.5350192785263062,
-0.7273316979408264,
-0.5191922187805176,
-0.05311080068349838,
-0.9067299365997314,
0.11975449323654175,
0.07653893530368805,
0.09802474826574326,
0.2414862960577011,
0.7971207499504089,
-0.4254911243915558,
0.5787951946258545,
0.29320672154426575,
-0.27521345019340515,
0.3451470732688904,
-0.21849431097507477,
-0.15309686958789825,
-1.1089891195297241,
0.26527220010757446,
0.08590517938137054,
-0.1369781792163849,
-0.577237606048584,
0.38956156373023987,
0.011778865940868855,
-0.09086909145116806,
-0.7521392107009888,
0.6599685549736023,
-0.06551550328731537,
0.08435866981744766,
-0.08791782706975937,
-0.010340297594666481,
-0.46861475706100464,
0.3246678113937378,
-0.4004244804382324,
0.7976142764091492,
0.6115537285804749,
-0.7086421847343445,
0.2579578161239624,
0.041321221739053726,
-0.13700760900974274,
0.641949474811554,
-0.9613374471664429,
0.27651530504226685,
0.02679913491010666,
0.17661713063716888,
-0.6624844670295715,
-0.016667991876602173,
0.44294384121894836,
-0.5076170563697815,
0.09435302019119263,
0.24400068819522858,
-0.1872839331626892,
-0.2971649467945099,
-0.2980601191520691,
0.15201102197170258,
0.7716958522796631,
-0.129293754696846,
0.30006471276283264,
0.8057323694229126,
-0.04757609963417053,
-0.6199288964271545,
-0.45300015807151794,
0.158130943775177,
-0.541610598564148,
-0.6120765209197998,
0.11525823920965195,
-0.5653164386749268,
-0.3944445550441742,
-0.12697044014930725,
-0.15236954391002655,
-0.08077479153871536,
0.7079458236694336,
0.35834476351737976,
0.13550199568271637,
-0.15860876441001892,
-0.05307301878929138,
-0.21991178393363953,
-0.5598744750022888,
0.23841245472431183,
0.4268289804458618,
0.15381217002868652,
-0.32392096519470215,
-0.3435114026069641,
-0.6131535172462463,
0.31092190742492676,
0.6298438310623169,
-0.17639987170696259,
0.7207220196723938,
0.4125945270061493,
-0.46301859617233276,
0.07813712954521179,
-0.17164567112922668,
-0.14079923927783966,
-0.49648454785346985,
0.27946987748146057,
-0.32615265250205994,
-0.6395416855812073,
0.3700363039970398,
-0.0236686859279871,
0.5092675089836121,
0.6167917251586914,
0.3467240035533905,
-0.28734514117240906,
1.2154467105865479,
0.7221883535385132,
-0.483173668384552,
0.30076533555984497,
0.21242594718933105,
0.2680931091308594,
-0.5321542024612427,
-0.21452070772647858,
-0.975222647190094,
-0.2407524734735489,
-0.878119170665741,
-0.14154361188411713,
0.7456439137458801,
-0.2161969691514969,
-0.48442015051841736,
0.34322503209114075,
-0.30542615056037903,
0.402815580368042,
0.7679799795150757,
-0.26164671778678894,
0.03517623245716095,
-0.3690805733203888,
0.04785047098994255,
0.08354717493057251,
-0.4279398024082184,
-0.6376805901527405,
1.1522037982940674,
0.616563618183136,
0.6832330822944641,
0.12940417230129242,
0.5490031242370605,
0.5439071655273438,
0.29777997732162476,
-0.40072596073150635,
0.8896136283874512,
-0.04859873652458191,
-0.9888509511947632,
-0.3691096305847168,
-0.274941623210907,
-0.9667262434959412,
0.025475822389125824,
-0.24051813781261444,
-0.9758433103561401,
-0.06442399322986603,
0.19697748124599457,
-0.3474918603897095,
-0.08626330643892288,
-0.7562662363052368,
1.2212185859680176,
-0.220673605799675,
-0.02298114076256752,
-0.4086950123310089,
-0.9242365956306458,
0.16524738073349,
0.1518135368824005,
-0.0766901969909668,
-0.596489429473877,
-0.034049082547426224,
0.4887610673904419,
-0.4457027018070221,
0.8537030220031738,
0.04016055166721344,
0.1909785121679306,
0.21439199149608612,
-0.13337944447994232,
0.47169020771980286,
-0.15150228142738342,
-0.13231481611728668,
0.29156509041786194,
0.2938767969608307,
-0.300527423620224,
-0.09024162590503693,
0.48567184805870056,
-0.8817175030708313,
-0.5808760523796082,
-0.6285480856895447,
-0.4565190076828003,
-0.28054484724998474,
0.3379862606525421,
-0.04733883589506149,
0.2608918249607086,
-0.3092820644378662,
0.43016350269317627,
0.5672379732131958,
-0.3249092102050781,
0.4781723916530609,
0.45601820945739746,
0.1611025333404541,
-0.05073096975684166,
0.8932814598083496,
-0.24530671536922455,
0.041736993938684464,
0.270031601190567,
-0.09374625235795975,
-0.20522020757198334,
-0.6165149807929993,
-0.3197360932826996,
-0.29533421993255615,
-0.7142947316169739,
-0.05787690356373787,
-0.4290602207183838,
-0.616788387298584,
-0.5020973086357117,
0.026772867888212204,
-0.4047846496105194,
-0.027530957013368607,
0.04961758106946945,
0.1125105693936348,
0.21085497736930847,
0.6014024019241333,
-0.1765328198671341,
-0.10028570145368576,
-0.7351133227348328,
-0.00467370729893446,
0.3221154510974884,
0.3971978724002838,
-0.3416888415813446,
-0.00048088812036439776,
-0.14339667558670044,
-0.08628292381763458,
-0.3284664750099182,
-0.3061660826206207,
0.029551098123192787,
-0.04816881939768791,
0.9114464521408081,
0.3228280544281006,
0.43672680854797363,
0.28723564743995667,
-0.5744174122810364,
0.8438124060630798,
0.09240328520536423,
-0.596887469291687,
0.3109203577041626,
-0.40436044335365295,
-0.0008153872331604362,
0.8170479536056519,
0.4080503284931183,
-0.7008379101753235,
-0.23611339926719666,
-0.615746259689331,
-0.9586197733879089,
0.4714434742927551,
0.3659571707248688,
0.16886180639266968,
-0.1632150411605835,
-0.0517803356051445,
-0.07020464539527893,
0.1913641095161438,
-0.43445339798927307,
-0.5418295860290527,
0.1016942709684372,
-0.3329673409461975,
-0.22100108861923218,
-0.11961521953344345,
-0.3087976574897766,
-0.10915357619524002,
0.6505594849586487,
-0.08082651346921921,
0.35560351610183716,
-0.20352232456207275,
0.19217205047607422,
0.05651063099503517,
0.004661920014768839,
0.5948396921157837,
0.2973552942276001,
-0.24269209802150726,
0.15133467316627502,
0.30264726281166077,
-0.45917603373527527,
0.03054022789001465,
0.35626351833343506,
-0.1540592908859253,
-0.37224262952804565,
0.23064228892326355,
0.6675704121589661,
0.01182670146226883,
-0.8839733004570007,
0.2130891978740692,
-0.363406240940094,
-0.0771259069442749,
-0.4942246973514557,
0.7050560116767883,
-0.04144194349646568,
0.18852762877941132,
0.10426143556833267,
0.18455640971660614,
0.08452605456113815,
-0.5290673971176147,
0.37730032205581665,
0.28299981355667114,
-0.36600959300994873,
-0.08940796554088593,
0.8305608034133911,
0.6575754284858704,
-0.6059156656265259,
0.4564865231513977,
-0.17002113163471222,
0.03871645778417587,
0.8031473755836487,
0.17507800459861755,
0.9765769243240356,
-0.1900012046098709,
0.026373356580734253,
0.36941641569137573,
0.5335795879364014,
0.005210603587329388,
0.2809709310531616,
0.1883302479982376,
-0.5380249619483948,
0.3204112648963928,
-0.20572344958782196,
-0.7020239233970642,
0.17911824584007263,
-0.26747843623161316,
0.22002467513084412,
-0.6887997984886169,
-0.06538303196430206,
0.15106570720672607,
-0.04210745915770531,
-0.33663466572761536,
0.4807480573654175,
0.2897377610206604,
1.0264109373092651,
-0.39456629753112793,
0.5375738739967346,
0.6104949712753296,
-0.3248385787010193,
-0.6872876286506653,
0.2913517951965332,
0.19339154660701752,
-0.5613102912902832,
-0.016429858282208443,
0.054499901831150055,
0.16629905998706818,
-0.2820797860622406,
-0.5516152381896973,
-0.8656176328659058,
0.9658375382423401,
0.1960059255361557,
-0.2767092287540436,
0.20870205760002136,
0.30630210041999817,
0.6989538669586182,
-0.252104252576828,
0.20710355043411255,
0.3709375560283661,
0.37983238697052,
-0.1760387122631073,
-1.1751770973205566,
0.08005209267139435,
-0.5668521523475647,
-0.024920087307691574,
0.02191670797765255,
-0.7234858870506287,
0.80780029296875,
0.008906565606594086,
-0.12698815762996674,
0.30107930302619934,
0.6150564551353455,
0.27032652497291565,
0.48087722063064575,
0.5341349244117737,
0.40621253848075867,
0.6903055310249329,
-0.17234748601913452,
1.115607500076294,
-0.513806164264679,
0.04071839153766632,
1.154631495475769,
-0.44776076078414917,
1.068739652633667,
0.1655654013156891,
-0.3411429524421692,
0.38454771041870117,
0.7746752500534058,
0.16119039058685303,
0.44076964259147644,
0.15810999274253845,
-0.36582839488983154,
-0.21980290114879608,
-0.19399940967559814,
-0.6850605607032776,
0.3026514947414398,
0.17066848278045654,
-0.3093684911727905,
-0.001967811491340399,
-0.3822700083255768,
0.2830495536327362,
-0.28627410531044006,
0.11144846677780151,
0.7652154564857483,
-0.03767795488238335,
-0.7217785716056824,
0.5975672006607056,
0.06639967858791351,
0.2606508135795593,
-0.3593486547470093,
0.14239731431007385,
-0.42211830615997314,
0.5322926044464111,
0.2688126564025879,
-0.7256451845169067,
0.2487047016620636,
0.06026916950941086,
0.22404268383979797,
-0.03469892963767052,
0.6147612929344177,
-0.0025043345522135496,
-0.455188512802124,
0.027563005685806274,
0.09615129977464676,
0.33012184500694275,
0.32289087772369385,
-0.7532405257225037,
0.13916298747062683,
-0.3053317070007324,
-0.17285890877246857,
0.3670842945575714,
0.1412111222743988,
-0.3596392571926117,
0.909189760684967,
0.32792678475379944,
-0.5179187655448914,
0.004847899544984102,
-0.1508089303970337,
0.6866727471351624,
-0.6590418219566345,
-0.5304321646690369,
-0.5084671974182129,
0.684642493724823,
-0.095881886780262,
-0.733452558517456,
0.6546582579612732,
0.29435136914253235,
0.9362539052963257,
0.19113320112228394,
0.9411787390708923,
-0.3586259186267853,
0.3048344552516937,
-0.10683367401361465,
0.9567998647689819,
-0.6492656469345093,
0.26441001892089844,
-0.3579929769039154,
-0.41288501024246216,
-0.31309840083122253,
0.42705848813056946,
-0.13399919867515564,
0.362318217754364,
0.6855393052101135,
0.694474458694458,
0.37326762080192566,
-0.07652551680803299,
0.40933969616889954,
0.153632253408432,
0.5045371055603027,
0.390519380569458,
0.596656084060669,
-0.6932249665260315,
0.6731871366500854,
-0.36004456877708435,
-0.07364322990179062,
-0.37187856435775757,
-0.8435084819793701,
-1.028567910194397,
-0.5831453204154968,
-0.4895588159561157,
-0.16960427165031433,
0.49943724274635315,
0.792746901512146,
0.8735600709915161,
-0.7584020495414734,
-0.2201170176267624,
-0.11992041766643524,
0.028451746329665184,
-0.4020708501338959,
-0.11461565643548965,
-0.021666264161467552,
-0.2081824541091919,
-0.47296231985092163,
0.5063184499740601,
0.20544859766960144,
0.03474735468626022,
-0.3471561074256897,
-0.1998831033706665,
-0.06278065592050552,
0.12502261996269226,
0.2616088092327118,
0.5614262819290161,
-0.401530385017395,
-0.8032345771789551,
-0.20738139748573303,
-0.3441460132598877,
-0.11174917966127396,
0.1865454912185669,
-0.35931071639060974,
0.20367074012756348,
0.5039023160934448,
0.5659952759742737,
0.1426135003566742,
-0.2965276837348938,
0.6824738383293152,
-0.512000322341919,
0.27849116921424866,
0.13779667019844055,
0.2912532091140747,
0.14893288910388947,
-0.27101150155067444,
0.7202845215797424,
0.13708102703094482,
-0.4549831449985504,
-0.9859494566917419,
0.16296030580997467,
-0.7133705615997314,
0.005189176183193922,
0.7720857858657837,
-0.2521955072879791,
-0.18231719732284546,
-0.2608804404735565,
-0.008469083346426487,
0.11358604580163956,
-0.09779246896505356,
1.1009255647659302,
0.3831593692302704,
-0.06655373424291611,
-0.13216373324394226,
-0.4349251389503479,
0.682583212852478,
0.4072815179824829,
-1.2261072397232056,
0.10609503835439682,
0.3899633586406708,
0.20447449386119843,
0.11957851052284241,
0.5990294218063354,
-0.11883316189050674,
0.6541959643363953,
0.3662995398044586,
0.3202296197414398,
0.2076932042837143,
-0.5432393550872803,
0.03395490348339081,
0.09927888214588165,
0.09584702551364899,
-0.4799479842185974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12224v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12224v2
|
Length Generalization of Causal Transformers without Position Encoding
| 2024-04-18T14:38:32 | 2024-05-28T01:38:59 |
Jie Wang, Tao Ji, Yuanbin Wu, Hang Yan, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang, Xiaoling Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generalizing to longer sentences is important for recent Transformer-based
language models. Besides algorithms manipulating explicit position features,
the success of Transformers without position encodings (NoPE) provides a new
way to overcome the challenge. In this paper, we study the length
generalization property of NoPE. We find that although NoPE can extend to
longer sequences than the commonly used explicit position encodings, it still
has a limited context length. We identify a connection between the failure of
NoPE's generalization and the distraction of attention distributions. We
propose a parameter-efficient tuning for searching attention heads' best
temperature hyper-parameters, which substantially expands NoPE's context size.
Experiments on long sequence language modeling, the synthetic passkey retrieval
task and real-world long context tasks show that NoPE can achieve competitive
performances with state-of-the-art length generalization algorithms. The source
code is publicly accessible
|
[
-0.4688601493835449,
-0.6009838581085205,
0.8422585725784302,
0.2822433412075043,
-0.39134329557418823,
-0.45365211367607117,
-0.5221452116966248,
-0.3789290189743042,
0.19257554411888123,
0.4656275510787964,
-0.5439306497573853,
-0.3159390985965729,
-0.6288055777549744,
0.18182414770126343,
-0.46907156705856323,
1.1095967292785645,
0.2754562199115753,
-0.6252606511116028,
-0.15583646297454834,
-0.16261908411979675,
-0.2578471601009369,
-0.24671199917793274,
-0.2841329872608185,
-0.033579710870981216,
0.9552088379859924,
0.3836958408355713,
0.8173816800117493,
1.1081507205963135,
0.6882686018943787,
0.23565945029258728,
-0.0778704583644867,
0.05412337929010391,
-0.570504903793335,
0.2840285003185272,
-0.10802645236253738,
-0.21778574585914612,
-0.07529838383197784,
-0.13625115156173706,
0.7717207074165344,
0.7221353650093079,
0.14750772714614868,
0.19878923892974854,
-0.280821293592453,
0.7116779088973999,
-0.9206116795539856,
0.1436607539653778,
-0.47388482093811035,
0.0025465022772550583,
-0.17055116593837738,
-0.577873706817627,
-0.6500241160392761,
-0.08938341587781906,
0.26280778646469116,
-0.48092183470726013,
0.5980947017669678,
-0.044531695544719696,
0.850403368473053,
0.6494347453117371,
-0.7417128682136536,
0.16005821526050568,
-1.2306321859359741,
1.1635175943374634,
-0.5750856995582581,
0.7510716915130615,
0.2352108657360077,
0.20399592816829681,
-0.03514031320810318,
-0.409728080034256,
-0.47294172644615173,
-0.23658253252506256,
-0.32045263051986694,
0.04614514485001564,
-0.15953956544399261,
0.2020207792520523,
0.48673802614212036,
0.06324353069067001,
-0.4973154664039612,
-0.006231979001313448,
-0.5695261359214783,
0.12590236961841583,
0.5754925608634949,
0.15782436728477478,
-0.008059976622462273,
-0.2123817503452301,
-0.29040104150772095,
-0.16654159128665924,
-0.490212619304657,
-0.022009707987308502,
0.32259252667427063,
-0.007315167225897312,
-0.23235362768173218,
0.3512730300426483,
-0.3320383131504059,
0.8566949367523193,
0.2458350509405136,
0.15143853425979614,
-0.11591062694787979,
-0.0589359775185585,
-0.3651069402694702,
-0.12369553744792938,
0.6893092393875122,
0.20802323520183563,
-0.06729187816381454,
-0.8263766169548035,
0.24941527843475342,
-0.1304997205734253,
0.4502377510070801,
-0.696814239025116,
-0.02893456444144249,
0.120974101126194,
-0.045192789286375046,
0.040761545300483704,
0.11483859270811081,
-0.7601051926612854,
0.15032482147216797,
-0.4717394709587097,
0.11526039242744446,
-0.34281352162361145,
0.07305077463388443,
0.27646327018737793,
-0.5325773358345032,
0.7216801643371582,
-0.3012986481189728,
-1.0986050367355347,
0.07111527770757675,
0.512493371963501,
0.660065233707428,
-0.15914662182331085,
-0.3047156035900116,
-0.3128489553928375,
0.44403141736984253,
-0.3853961229324341,
0.5863524675369263,
-0.6942704916000366,
-0.4610264003276825,
-0.2714022994041443,
0.005153934005647898,
-0.1036238819360733,
-0.20307958126068115,
0.7450159192085266,
-0.9445738792419434,
0.2586573660373688,
-0.14694258570671082,
-0.41989627480506897,
-0.07808738946914673,
-0.33424460887908936,
-0.5540115833282471,
0.7245866060256958,
-0.013733849860727787,
-0.6922388672828674,
0.3674136698246002,
-0.9639031887054443,
-0.8056984543800354,
-0.11767566949129105,
-0.01501866988837719,
-0.4473956823348999,
0.410964697599411,
0.2633698582649231,
0.33961543440818787,
-0.21093645691871643,
0.39952021837234497,
-0.3619753420352936,
-0.6675770878791809,
0.1423024982213974,
-0.6177997589111328,
0.580545961856842,
0.006993482820689678,
-0.7435218095779419,
0.12465505301952362,
-0.6432926654815674,
-0.060189422219991684,
0.15232770144939423,
-0.11575568467378616,
-0.304146409034729,
0.08240890502929688,
0.0022605513222515583,
0.21104580163955688,
0.2923036217689514,
-0.6208340525627136,
0.16235440969467163,
-0.398868203163147,
0.4741227924823761,
0.5637990832328796,
0.021565157920122147,
0.7441050410270691,
0.09323538094758987,
0.35334381461143494,
-0.13749971985816956,
0.42818397283554077,
0.00009668693382991478,
-0.33697080612182617,
-1.01224684715271,
-0.16154234111309052,
0.20764371752738953,
0.41117075085639954,
-0.8156048655509949,
0.7692108750343323,
-0.5376308560371399,
-0.49913957715034485,
-0.066951684653759,
-0.11898841708898544,
0.29066821932792664,
0.6300443410873413,
0.6434091329574585,
0.1422738879919052,
-0.6387879848480225,
-1.1061753034591675,
-0.2708851993083954,
0.10958457738161087,
-0.49062463641166687,
0.2742680311203003,
0.19193482398986816,
-0.3833540678024292,
1.2119596004486084,
-0.8356420397758484,
-0.12860257923603058,
-0.17093926668167114,
-0.08743195235729218,
0.5122674703598022,
0.2583256959915161,
0.4500396251678467,
-0.7533301115036011,
-0.19067741930484772,
-0.1201695129275322,
-0.9647797346115112,
0.1963271051645279,
0.049585629254579544,
-0.04652101919054985,
0.19908715784549713,
0.5289286971092224,
-0.8947665095329285,
0.40002956986427307,
0.45193302631378174,
-0.1503782868385315,
0.32971569895744324,
-0.3261696696281433,
-0.19915573298931122,
-0.6000133156776428,
0.443737655878067,
0.21255525946617126,
-0.12604033946990967,
-0.8618305325508118,
0.19060055911540985,
0.2849102020263672,
-0.2698737382888794,
-0.6033531427383423,
0.5837408304214478,
-0.37280789017677307,
0.3870336413383484,
-0.40142741799354553,
0.11936908215284348,
-0.1292610764503479,
0.856598973274231,
0.21704448759555817,
0.41224953532218933,
0.6413226127624512,
-1.012877106666565,
0.20644031465053558,
0.1392151415348053,
0.06344334036111832,
0.4942804276943207,
-0.7177703976631165,
0.34937095642089844,
-0.47739896178245544,
0.3656122088432312,
-0.675056517124176,
-0.33040326833724976,
0.07971560955047607,
-0.31916460394859314,
0.28100675344467163,
-0.056979838758707047,
-0.23758123815059662,
-0.5088715553283691,
-0.13337425887584686,
0.47960492968559265,
0.6381915211677551,
-0.3160211741924286,
0.11480148881673813,
-0.06351078301668167,
0.17025847733020782,
-0.8288789987564087,
-0.5573070645332336,
0.005436714272946119,
-0.549638032913208,
-0.47435203194618225,
0.3817886412143707,
-0.13998770713806152,
0.26689937710762024,
-0.13989987969398499,
-0.4814881384372711,
-0.15411819517612457,
-0.16064167022705078,
0.0709647610783577,
-0.057839952409267426,
-0.2666809558868408,
0.11004028469324112,
0.2501421272754669,
-0.4014917314052582,
-0.044431254267692566,
-0.36771780252456665,
0.3378795385360718,
0.22818432748317719,
-0.018497338518500328,
-0.49294808506965637,
0.45347052812576294,
0.6257666349411011,
0.031135670840740204,
0.9361676573753357,
0.668228805065155,
-0.14211131632328033,
-0.21984124183654785,
-0.6206774711608887,
-0.4772302806377411,
-0.5637916326522827,
0.14078745245933533,
-0.14576898515224457,
-1.3467254638671875,
0.3248174786567688,
0.24221067130565643,
-0.11424297839403152,
0.5589382648468018,
0.01436737272888422,
0.09257092326879501,
0.966896653175354,
1.0006195306777954,
-0.3116934895515442,
0.4273940324783325,
-0.191265270113945,
0.6235042214393616,
-0.8183454871177673,
-0.1269991397857666,
-0.37239405512809753,
-0.48516473174095154,
-0.5861227512359619,
-0.2037408947944641,
0.5150810480117798,
-0.16154694557189941,
-0.31270933151245117,
0.7532021403312683,
-0.5124218463897705,
0.7813581228256226,
0.57015061378479,
0.15549607574939728,
-0.14225725829601288,
-0.15274208784103394,
0.2869472801685333,
-0.16097939014434814,
-0.5904326438903809,
0.13696324825286865,
0.9061457514762878,
0.1958463490009308,
0.5407178997993469,
0.056857749819755554,
0.5414968132972717,
0.2520936131477356,
-0.17293855547904968,
-0.6801996231079102,
0.5050239562988281,
-0.09242921322584152,
-0.6008883118629456,
-0.9648749232292175,
-0.7544122338294983,
-1.2179791927337646,
0.05983434244990349,
0.43404361605644226,
-0.6563658118247986,
0.35225799679756165,
-0.04081599786877632,
-0.36106929183006287,
0.17910943925380707,
-0.5301777124404907,
0.8333021402359009,
-0.011717263609170914,
-0.2535664737224579,
0.0958205834031105,
-0.7798109650611877,
0.2566866874694824,
0.04676169902086258,
-0.15788748860359192,
0.05574240908026695,
-0.08229606598615646,
0.7159774303436279,
-0.1816287636756897,
0.6250384449958801,
-0.1074075773358345,
-0.0027692886069417,
0.05773228406906128,
-0.13434192538261414,
0.46470391750335693,
0.14956475794315338,
0.11912155896425247,
0.33826008439064026,
-0.2955811023712158,
-0.694752037525177,
-0.8470454812049866,
0.8460638523101807,
-0.530518114566803,
-0.8683116436004639,
-0.08247409015893936,
-0.5052725076675415,
-0.39439982175827026,
0.5453516840934753,
0.5724809169769287,
0.31349310278892517,
0.08639802783727646,
0.5836761593818665,
0.7704471945762634,
-0.19336029887199402,
0.773065984249115,
0.4765992760658264,
0.44853121042251587,
-0.20729166269302368,
0.8974088430404663,
-0.10385581851005554,
0.019606303423643112,
0.7619982361793518,
0.22198744118213654,
-0.6503498554229736,
-0.0807732567191124,
-0.35210710763931274,
0.3862345814704895,
-0.5454853773117065,
-0.18051889538764954,
-0.7565956711769104,
-0.2805587947368622,
-0.597953736782074,
-0.16403330862522125,
-0.21293960511684418,
-0.2575470507144928,
-0.24983784556388855,
-0.2835995852947235,
0.46955206990242004,
0.5203467011451721,
-0.1783081293106079,
0.4109334349632263,
-0.5916663408279419,
0.5742287635803223,
0.4591418504714966,
0.6922034025192261,
0.015594657510519028,
-0.5250111818313599,
-0.3803706467151642,
-0.16843846440315247,
-0.4607817530632019,
-0.6379672884941101,
0.41127970814704895,
0.1798011064529419,
0.4354952573776245,
0.612095832824707,
0.21198011934757233,
0.7585508823394775,
-0.712475597858429,
0.6312016248703003,
0.14922724664211273,
-1.0152407884597778,
0.3278314471244812,
-0.5914137363433838,
0.7043116092681885,
0.2137676477432251,
0.38141167163848877,
-0.6316412091255188,
-0.3576941192150116,
-0.5921180844306946,
-1.099692702293396,
0.8457636833190918,
0.5741565227508545,
0.5032525062561035,
-0.23842832446098328,
0.4444500505924225,
-0.08265026658773422,
0.09897448122501373,
-0.43512192368507385,
-0.7117279171943665,
-0.15602801740169525,
0.16147053241729736,
-0.360766738653183,
-0.30214351415634155,
0.09584512561559677,
-0.3239540755748749,
0.44358372688293457,
-0.0349334217607975,
0.5973816514015198,
0.30957669019699097,
-0.09492640942335129,
-0.08164343982934952,
0.43445324897766113,
0.886229932308197,
0.6144788861274719,
-0.31173816323280334,
0.19785358011722565,
0.23908601701259613,
-0.11690715700387955,
0.23266509175300598,
-0.050708405673503876,
-0.10829060524702072,
0.2026781588792801,
0.22713540494441986,
0.8684059381484985,
0.5139961242675781,
-0.3365171253681183,
0.42048710584640503,
0.09267276525497437,
0.09402251988649368,
-0.2620457112789154,
0.137607142329216,
-0.05898325890302658,
-0.12022897601127625,
0.4183560311794281,
-0.14160646498203278,
0.4498370885848999,
-0.062026817351579666,
0.45020195841789246,
0.2447170913219452,
-0.7320528626441956,
-0.41613247990608215,
0.8619499206542969,
-0.05556183680891991,
-0.07391390949487686,
0.5739478468894958,
0.07053155452013016,
0.06505486369132996,
0.7259933352470398,
0.5018081068992615,
1.0603389739990234,
-0.39760348200798035,
0.2654738426208496,
0.15347011387348175,
0.3538183867931366,
-0.010426141321659088,
-0.19089768826961517,
-0.43654826283454895,
-0.2986794412136078,
-0.5702105760574341,
-0.48102959990501404,
-0.2822524905204773,
0.33874189853668213,
-0.7835306525230408,
0.23437227308750153,
-0.3732682466506958,
-0.2634112238883972,
-0.11330088973045349,
-0.6066312193870544,
-0.7761453986167908,
0.27235502004623413,
-0.01688338816165924,
0.6042508482933044,
-0.5423345565795898,
0.7140575647354126,
0.2000230997800827,
-0.06946499645709991,
-0.43025752902030945,
0.11907079070806503,
-0.48200827836990356,
-0.34153568744659424,
0.5636225938796997,
0.305806428194046,
-0.17147400975227356,
-0.06294669955968857,
-0.6026538610458374,
-1.0833849906921387,
0.8465183973312378,
0.6658538579940796,
-0.408006489276886,
-0.371490478515625,
0.4575190544128418,
0.8969895839691162,
0.3699038028717041,
0.21879161894321442,
0.543669581413269,
0.44300180673599243,
0.012699409388005733,
-0.6737188100814819,
-0.009476232342422009,
0.002808628836646676,
0.191497802734375,
0.45263737440109253,
-0.8176770210266113,
0.41552498936653137,
-0.05473756045103073,
-0.33211156725883484,
-0.00011194225226063281,
0.7252377867698669,
-0.264845073223114,
0.17639696598052979,
-0.0362619049847126,
0.5915724635124207,
0.07173094153404236,
0.06365631520748138,
1.1918085813522339,
-0.432297021150589,
0.6970201730728149,
0.9281383156776428,
-0.13881559669971466,
0.547061026096344,
0.38149407505989075,
0.07990840822458267,
0.5398632287979126,
0.1118662878870964,
0.1691042184829712,
0.5936804413795471,
0.05772969126701355,
-0.021117353811860085,
-0.35982778668403625,
0.13863874971866608,
-0.3109435439109802,
0.33465033769607544,
0.21853798627853394,
-0.43641287088394165,
-0.35132864117622375,
-0.13796508312225342,
0.09853540360927582,
-0.18330919742584229,
0.017309993505477905,
0.550235390663147,
0.29469627141952515,
-0.5841733813285828,
0.9114430546760559,
0.1718411147594452,
0.596457302570343,
-0.5037381052970886,
0.25215813517570496,
-0.325563907623291,
-0.022210078313946724,
-0.07799983769655228,
-0.4152602255344391,
0.4327663779258728,
-0.2007591426372528,
-0.43332400918006897,
-0.15345139801502228,
0.3873092532157898,
-0.13314807415008545,
-0.3997758626937866,
0.34822332859039307,
0.005708768032491207,
-0.18273454904556274,
-0.24469177424907684,
-0.09014519304037094,
-0.29790812730789185,
-0.3698785901069641,
-0.2668069005012512,
0.17127534747123718,
0.3201316297054291,
-0.009903219528496265,
0.6371933221817017,
0.5730750560760498,
-0.4053572118282318,
0.18024763464927673,
-0.25785693526268005,
0.48165348172187805,
-1.1773293018341064,
-0.4846685230731964,
-1.060788869857788,
0.1499083936214447,
0.09885212033987045,
-0.1598847210407257,
0.8564420938491821,
0.4458293914794922,
0.7785724401473999,
-0.5591452717781067,
0.6335204839706421,
0.1496075540781021,
0.16941070556640625,
-0.2985902726650238,
0.5121068954467773,
-0.5076681971549988,
-0.21745970845222473,
-0.31970757246017456,
-1.186073899269104,
-0.7502509355545044,
0.09683454781770706,
-0.6489642262458801,
0.07723540812730789,
0.7917580008506775,
0.43008527159690857,
-0.35328853130340576,
-0.13253572583198547,
0.7402074933052063,
-0.09057631343603134,
0.24414323270320892,
0.7527449131011963,
0.49833837151527405,
-0.39312744140625,
0.6558473110198975,
-0.24356384575366974,
-0.03238961473107338,
-0.246953085064888,
-0.6988548636436462,
-0.9369271993637085,
-0.5742484331130981,
-0.12791091203689575,
0.17634478211402893,
-0.07407473772764206,
0.16947835683822632,
0.8909662365913391,
-0.6890308856964111,
0.061561260372400284,
-0.17281058430671692,
0.1795344203710556,
-0.26634594798088074,
-0.33231374621391296,
0.4961451292037964,
-0.329760879278183,
-0.5349506735801697,
0.6038804054260254,
0.6879874467849731,
-0.25485897064208984,
-0.14649927616119385,
0.13946762681007385,
0.1982816457748413,
0.3336852192878723,
0.6967566013336182,
0.6442024111747742,
-0.7447623014450073,
-0.5900064706802368,
0.43366295099258423,
0.09992121905088425,
0.17214420437812805,
0.8136529922485352,
-0.5865617394447327,
0.09132764488458633,
0.46230465173721313,
0.5160565376281738,
0.353455126285553,
-0.09500773251056671,
0.45653143525123596,
-1.1381689310073853,
0.3077460527420044,
0.019152970984578133,
0.1857435256242752,
0.09527485072612762,
-0.5486891865730286,
0.25005224347114563,
0.1979621946811676,
-0.5333607196807861,
-0.45708632469177246,
0.4683561325073242,
-1.140228509902954,
-0.1102227121591568,
1.2427259683609009,
0.07950766384601593,
-0.31515687704086304,
0.017721286043524742,
0.09026310592889786,
0.3845657706260681,
-0.5408124327659607,
1.116448163986206,
0.32121285796165466,
-0.2647402584552765,
-0.2328784316778183,
-0.14516247808933258,
0.486003577709198,
0.41713279485702515,
-0.44634202122688293,
-0.028464706614613533,
0.2572617828845978,
0.29122722148895264,
0.45677903294563293,
0.16248248517513275,
0.02940121479332447,
0.30422264337539673,
-0.2909056544303894,
-0.1910797655582428,
0.05888732895255089,
-0.5859028100967407,
-0.3920857310295105,
0.3014594614505768,
-0.2176734060049057,
-0.12098799645900726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12195v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12195v1
|
OpenBezoar: Small, Cost-Effective and Open Models Trained on Mixes of Instruction Data
| 2024-04-18T13:57:18 | 2024-04-18T13:57:18 |
Chandeepa Dissanayake, Lahiru Lowe, Sachith Gunasekara, Yasiru Ratnayake
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Instruction fine-tuning pretrained LLMs for diverse downstream tasks has
demonstrated remarkable success and has captured the interest of both academics
and practitioners. To ensure such fine-tuned LLMs align with human preferences,
techniques such as RLHF and DPO have emerged. At the same time, there is
increasing interest in smaller parameter counts for models. In this work, using
OpenLLaMA 3Bv2 as a base model, we describe the recipe used to fine-tune the
OpenBezoar family of models. In this recipe: We first generate synthetic
instruction fine-tuning data using an open and commercially non-restrictive
instruction fine-tuned variant of the Falcon-40B model under three schemes
based on: LaMini-LM, WizardLM/Evol-Instruct (with databricks-dolly-15k as a
seed dataset) and Orca (with the Flan Collection as a seed dataset), then
filter these generations using GPT-4 as a human proxy. We then perform
cost-effective QLoRA-based supervised fine-tuning sequentially with each
scheme. The resulting checkpoint is further fine-tuned with a subset of the
HH-RLHF dataset to minimize distribution shift prior to using the DPO loss to
obtain the final checkpoint. Evaluation is done with the LM Eval Harness
tasks/metrics as well as on MT-Bench using the "LLM-as-a-judge" framework with
Claude 2.1, with the finding that the final checkpoint,
"OpenBezoar-HH-RLHF-DPO", demonstrates superior performance over many models at
the 3B parameter scale, even outperforming the top model in one of the
categories on the Huggingface Open LLM Leaderboard. We release
"OpenBezoar-SFT", "OpenBezoar-HH-RLHF-SFT", "OpenBezoar-HH-RLHF-DPO"
checkpoints, alongside our generated datasets on HuggingFace at
https://huggingface.co/collections/SurgeGlobal/open-bezoar-6620a24923e12127e9e2b9cc
and our codebase at
https://bitbucket.org/paladinanalytics/workspace/projects/OP.
|
[
-0.5834327340126038,
-0.6565495729446411,
0.328154593706131,
0.06677800416946411,
-0.18344524502754211,
-0.11198493838310242,
-0.19047857820987701,
-0.5523229241371155,
-0.040942493826150894,
0.9069207310676575,
-0.7731150388717651,
-0.7608645558357239,
-0.28598183393478394,
-0.30396950244903564,
0.11790226399898529,
0.9327678084373474,
-0.34654107689857483,
0.10151846706867218,
0.193807914853096,
-0.12416147440671921,
-0.3619428873062134,
-0.01110840030014515,
-0.6595152020454407,
-0.516232430934906,
0.6028569936752319,
0.6076723337173462,
0.584496796131134,
0.7825238704681396,
0.41242408752441406,
0.13633902370929718,
-0.2093355655670166,
0.5161547064781189,
-0.7264685034751892,
-0.16077132523059845,
-0.27393221855163574,
-0.4052087962627411,
-0.7568696141242981,
0.02775731310248375,
0.48181289434432983,
0.7242075800895691,
-0.49921342730522156,
0.33293774724006653,
-0.023607801645994186,
0.9199241399765015,
-0.8871092200279236,
0.1651465743780136,
-0.3172667920589447,
0.13446079194545746,
-0.4339736998081207,
-0.04013960063457489,
-0.47419804334640503,
-0.7091275453567505,
-0.34601840376853943,
-0.43331193923950195,
0.21418440341949463,
0.27681413292884827,
0.7083889842033386,
0.2606610953807831,
-0.250784307718277,
-0.30068790912628174,
-0.7333762049674988,
0.5992725491523743,
-0.8101269602775574,
0.3864128887653351,
0.1467248946428299,
0.539212167263031,
-0.5253986120223999,
-0.5799596309661865,
-0.2389683574438095,
0.08325310796499252,
0.167938232421875,
0.3666072189807892,
-0.08453913033008575,
0.2535024583339691,
0.10796722769737244,
0.5426517724990845,
-0.4573252499103546,
0.5185706615447998,
-0.6211684346199036,
-0.06788064539432526,
0.4977744221687317,
0.4742545783519745,
-0.15577973425388336,
0.16949498653411865,
-0.521083414554596,
-0.16661091148853302,
-0.9328677654266357,
0.39539819955825806,
0.48036232590675354,
0.44012346863746643,
-0.29809311032295227,
0.46400222182273865,
-0.5093547105789185,
1.0395420789718628,
0.2862822115421295,
-0.20525583624839783,
-0.008001971058547497,
-0.31427815556526184,
-0.29127368330955505,
-0.0358683206140995,
0.6689824461936951,
0.3490477502346039,
0.18108658492565155,
0.19934962689876556,
-0.28556349873542786,
-0.34681236743927,
0.37505632638931274,
-1.400328278541565,
-0.22566170990467072,
0.013786791823804379,
-0.5461069941520691,
-0.25720977783203125,
0.38559067249298096,
-0.9073647856712341,
-0.2193249613046646,
-0.2738339602947235,
0.2747719883918762,
-0.3782411515712738,
0.13322699069976807,
0.3171737492084503,
0.270486444234848,
0.188497856259346,
0.530738115310669,
-0.9680567979812622,
0.4757729172706604,
0.67061448097229,
0.8408663272857666,
0.09962587058544159,
-0.2288861870765686,
-0.7343369722366333,
0.08439674228429794,
-0.6640355587005615,
0.6800969243049622,
-0.5576829314231873,
-0.4083716869354248,
-0.10258408635854721,
0.1799960881471634,
-0.10880821198225021,
-0.8362975120544434,
0.25987496972084045,
-0.6457889080047607,
-0.03833187371492386,
-0.2944851815700531,
-0.5066345930099487,
-0.48475632071495056,
-0.18113231658935547,
-0.5357182025909424,
0.933165431022644,
0.3582935631275177,
-0.1972283273935318,
0.36272114515304565,
-0.6654390096664429,
-0.09880029410123825,
-0.1413489133119583,
-0.019681360572576523,
-0.36750203371047974,
0.16760799288749695,
0.19742250442504883,
0.3486140966415405,
-0.5412933230400085,
-0.22238795459270477,
-0.41373956203460693,
-0.6423540115356445,
-0.09240812808275223,
0.09639886766672134,
0.7764707803726196,
0.20492926239967346,
-0.19684846699237823,
0.24992769956588745,
-0.7216494679450989,
0.22827701270580292,
0.06002914905548096,
-0.3426276445388794,
-0.10041622072458267,
-0.24944978952407837,
-0.2551996111869812,
0.017902392894029617,
0.060636989772319794,
-0.5787694454193115,
0.32134079933166504,
-0.44070276618003845,
0.2838752865791321,
0.8191652894020081,
0.18201769888401031,
0.3755771815776825,
-0.39947575330734253,
0.6982796788215637,
0.08102264255285263,
0.40116748213768005,
-0.15699636936187744,
-0.5708999037742615,
-0.51419597864151,
-0.64815753698349,
0.13794702291488647,
0.3357631266117096,
-0.1774100959300995,
0.31299954652786255,
0.08911552280187607,
-0.7306746244430542,
-0.5762519240379333,
0.40420547127723694,
0.6004374623298645,
0.5998271107673645,
0.4608508348464966,
-0.420920193195343,
-0.14133472740650177,
-0.812057614326477,
0.18186427652835846,
0.09918534755706787,
0.030402300879359245,
0.3864935040473938,
0.4601142704486847,
-0.2328980714082718,
0.8080574870109558,
-0.7763330936431885,
-0.427129864692688,
-0.011998758651316166,
0.19250375032424927,
0.382098525762558,
0.3971309959888458,
0.8554823398590088,
-0.24643585085868835,
-0.43254828453063965,
0.11432681232690811,
-0.41131481528282166,
-0.19133038818836212,
0.22421017289161682,
-0.5414668321609497,
0.12988132238388062,
0.42941200733184814,
-0.5972895622253418,
0.482338011264801,
0.374230295419693,
-0.1960454136133194,
0.31907862424850464,
-0.20884358882904053,
0.08895003795623779,
-0.796327531337738,
-0.022960929200053215,
-0.3110398054122925,
-0.10714614391326904,
-0.33889245986938477,
0.23829896748065948,
0.1761319935321808,
0.09008310735225677,
-0.5389955043792725,
0.7180043458938599,
-0.4994112253189087,
-0.18360745906829834,
-0.39572614431381226,
0.08637558668851852,
-0.03208134323358536,
0.5303028225898743,
-0.24263650178909302,
0.7389777302742004,
0.23479986190795898,
-0.4966837763786316,
0.42163997888565063,
0.40749025344848633,
-0.34302279353141785,
0.4787304699420929,
-0.60381680727005,
0.2142234742641449,
-0.05876423045992851,
0.27395591139793396,
-0.5889936089515686,
-0.48719358444213867,
0.6353001594543457,
-0.06666047126054764,
0.5167694091796875,
-0.32939082384109497,
-0.3304162919521332,
-0.4227283000946045,
-0.3889816403388977,
0.2234373390674591,
0.7172789573669434,
-0.7795440554618835,
0.31106477975845337,
0.07918377220630646,
-0.002267213771119714,
-0.31757667660713196,
-0.43265658617019653,
-0.45127004384994507,
-0.02120337076485157,
-0.5462158918380737,
0.5436245203018188,
-0.09986969083547592,
-0.0734243392944336,
-0.010081381537020206,
-0.41364410519599915,
-0.052709486335515976,
-0.10374879091978073,
0.5457236170768738,
0.3147042691707611,
-0.3761514723300934,
-0.23124410212039948,
0.24128687381744385,
-0.08517781645059586,
-0.09035046398639679,
-0.25892946124076843,
0.5477248430252075,
-0.3120329678058624,
-0.40778160095214844,
-0.25106334686279297,
-0.051842957735061646,
0.25744494795799255,
-0.21885541081428528,
0.8435156345367432,
0.7167806029319763,
-0.43457797169685364,
-0.5763088464736938,
-0.24620892107486725,
-0.28865450620651245,
-0.48103564977645874,
-0.018744369968771935,
-0.22924384474754333,
-0.8190449476242065,
0.4768339991569519,
-0.06204930320382118,
0.15336312353610992,
0.07451268285512924,
0.7431102395057678,
0.018368098884820938,
0.6318082809448242,
0.4322710931301117,
0.1170717403292656,
0.4430416524410248,
-0.1713462471961975,
-0.10179286450147629,
-0.8649885654449463,
-0.32153770327568054,
-0.2985900342464447,
-0.43972522020339966,
-0.5821722745895386,
-0.6008023619651794,
0.4220903515815735,
0.4976867735385895,
-0.5648157000541687,
0.20108024775981903,
-0.3077744245529175,
0.513765811920166,
0.7145773768424988,
0.4573849141597748,
0.12359849363565445,
-0.16747406125068665,
-0.07073231041431427,
0.1707863062620163,
-0.5388990640640259,
-0.5493132472038269,
1.1528387069702148,
0.24942179024219513,
0.8728207349777222,
0.005300180055201054,
0.9482334852218628,
0.1205369308590889,
0.37382495403289795,
-0.6212878227233887,
0.6472957134246826,
-0.19398802518844604,
-0.5911192893981934,
-0.04398542270064354,
-0.3790450394153595,
-0.8102977275848389,
0.06424262374639511,
0.08218571543693542,
-0.7810593843460083,
0.22510434687137604,
0.3083738088607788,
-0.6886833310127258,
0.30713582038879395,
-0.46680065989494324,
0.9923322796821594,
-0.16465984284877777,
-0.5887677073478699,
-0.2912365198135376,
-0.6689487099647522,
0.5364837050437927,
-0.1942424476146698,
-0.13753849267959595,
-0.39540740847587585,
-0.21104609966278076,
0.48686566948890686,
-0.8535067439079285,
0.7467319369316101,
-0.48005107045173645,
-0.09223958104848862,
0.4321615993976593,
-0.05018100515007973,
0.5061514973640442,
-0.012009120546281338,
-0.17322894930839539,
0.30092620849609375,
-0.13281187415122986,
-0.5010415315628052,
-0.4380331337451935,
0.5788692831993103,
-0.7592946887016296,
-0.3066183030605316,
-0.14060725271701813,
-0.3721190094947815,
-0.31813621520996094,
0.24327689409255981,
0.28988924622535706,
0.5286060571670532,
-0.10008079558610916,
0.32211458683013916,
0.5964301228523254,
-0.2577436566352844,
0.21100212633609772,
0.7711736559867859,
-0.44029027223587036,
-0.4993835389614105,
0.7651392817497253,
0.017977802082896233,
0.33368319272994995,
0.3957962691783905,
0.20350371301174164,
0.08594382554292679,
-0.7152780890464783,
-0.7107860445976257,
0.2750591039657593,
-0.6178713440895081,
-0.35562387108802795,
-0.14299368858337402,
-0.2470107078552246,
-0.16091255843639374,
-0.21557463705539703,
-0.5929574966430664,
-0.0807172954082489,
-0.37730228900909424,
-0.009487946517765522,
0.4389946758747101,
0.721096396446228,
-0.20433540642261505,
0.610015869140625,
-0.7494633793830872,
0.3928709030151367,
0.16182196140289307,
0.4324960708618164,
-0.17118145525455475,
-0.5792548060417175,
-0.39684638381004333,
0.32435816526412964,
-0.4174640476703644,
-0.8456870317459106,
0.24329577386379242,
0.27938535809516907,
0.485041081905365,
0.5013660192489624,
0.15672972798347473,
0.7652798295021057,
-0.3628496527671814,
0.4449118673801422,
-0.06454470008611679,
-0.6362245678901672,
0.7396373152732849,
-0.6337721347808838,
0.08320124447345734,
0.635237455368042,
0.37647363543510437,
0.21453160047531128,
-0.15096284449100494,
-0.14536228775978088,
-0.6820575594902039,
1.0589015483856201,
0.012731526046991348,
-0.15516167879104614,
0.17126969993114471,
0.6549955010414124,
0.4498199224472046,
0.3207133710384369,
-0.29731592535972595,
-0.1440732181072235,
-0.13950003683567047,
-0.29787927865982056,
0.05887056887149811,
-0.1444244235754013,
-0.22357921302318573,
-0.11353950202465057,
0.7046336531639099,
-0.16792908310890198,
0.10909905284643173,
-0.19533956050872803,
0.15154287219047546,
-0.39607614278793335,
0.05676010623574257,
0.6329807043075562,
0.5947385430335999,
-0.6826900839805603,
-0.38134652376174927,
-0.009653693065047264,
-0.6002663969993591,
0.016832295805215836,
0.18271803855895996,
-0.383371502161026,
-0.414430171251297,
0.2179485410451889,
0.9604538679122925,
0.5499618053436279,
-0.7074466347694397,
0.2976750433444977,
0.27668577432632446,
-0.09773627668619156,
-0.0009317534859292209,
0.6037892699241638,
0.029483791440725327,
0.6202508211135864,
0.004712049849331379,
0.09269673377275467,
0.028556540608406067,
-0.4753410220146179,
-0.012680977582931519,
0.20332206785678864,
-0.26086708903312683,
-0.3404256999492645,
0.6405423879623413,
0.10616966336965561,
-0.03851126506924629,
0.5738374590873718,
-0.25615566968917847,
-0.12253323197364807,
0.6518211364746094,
0.40859878063201904,
0.7487715482711792,
-0.29009464383125305,
0.21549499034881592,
0.45242178440093994,
0.48487430810928345,
-0.15889059007167816,
0.3550112247467041,
-0.05266794189810753,
-0.6222518682479858,
0.08106148988008499,
-0.9398066401481628,
-0.7847071290016174,
-0.09572824090719223,
-1.1230796575546265,
0.41141477227211,
-0.7571501135826111,
-0.17239828407764435,
-0.12603624165058136,
0.032477330416440964,
-0.7331140637397766,
0.23076030611991882,
0.01384885236620903,
0.9075900316238403,
-0.48884159326553345,
0.7029994130134583,
0.7799765467643738,
-0.5101196765899658,
-0.690454363822937,
0.034322965890169144,
0.07938074320554733,
-0.9941515922546387,
0.4637781083583832,
0.2554633319377899,
-0.1880754828453064,
0.07236488908529282,
-0.37063369154930115,
-0.6184415817260742,
1.3202601671218872,
0.35787710547447205,
-0.8025071024894714,
-0.06055055558681488,
-0.05355807766318321,
0.4286051094532013,
-0.43010905385017395,
0.22552353143692017,
0.6036792993545532,
0.4602991044521332,
0.15193450450897217,
-0.7530499696731567,
0.1611204594373703,
0.026879312470555305,
0.021302131935954094,
0.42608940601348877,
-1.1646496057510376,
1.0113247632980347,
-0.5278347730636597,
0.061118755489587784,
0.23315711319446564,
0.4913358986377716,
0.45850059390068054,
0.5669578313827515,
0.29312393069267273,
0.4960884153842926,
0.7045337557792664,
-0.10941538959741592,
0.8343594074249268,
-0.25443413853645325,
0.16653044521808624,
1.2950342893600464,
-0.4708903133869171,
0.8707178831100464,
0.147977814078331,
-0.2714681625366211,
0.5649926662445068,
0.906378984451294,
-0.1129741445183754,
0.6554251313209534,
0.1535050868988037,
-0.00743784848600626,
-0.22318057715892792,
0.12881554663181305,
-0.3630129396915436,
0.5620999932289124,
0.21013306081295013,
-0.2136589139699936,
-0.30748915672302246,
0.07977711409330368,
0.08907439559698105,
-0.07231073081493378,
-0.6009740233421326,
0.6065974235534668,
0.18182118237018585,
-0.6047145128250122,
0.6756280064582825,
0.15154680609703064,
0.2631711959838867,
-0.6823689937591553,
0.14115354418754578,
-0.4276275038719177,
0.47401177883148193,
-0.2041572630405426,
-0.4958963394165039,
0.26690948009490967,
-0.03357776254415512,
-0.16983674466609955,
-0.2059294730424881,
0.5084018111228943,
-0.21399027109146118,
-0.2875765860080719,
0.4252030849456787,
0.3687416911125183,
0.060999974608421326,
0.01363928709179163,
-0.4274101257324219,
0.2480444312095642,
-0.11119270324707031,
-0.5542915463447571,
0.34028878808021545,
0.18403629958629608,
0.041668638586997986,
0.5215277075767517,
0.40950217843055725,
0.21145100891590118,
0.09389807283878326,
0.04613998904824257,
0.9014513492584229,
-0.799237072467804,
-0.27439504861831665,
-0.5609800815582275,
0.23552776873111725,
0.2509319484233856,
-0.4358886480331421,
0.5879141688346863,
0.5178441405296326,
0.9519256353378296,
-0.16591376066207886,
0.3784920573234558,
0.17121025919914246,
0.5968142747879028,
-0.945100724697113,
0.510227382183075,
-0.7404915690422058,
0.13236618041992188,
0.010926996357738972,
-1.0382903814315796,
0.24988344311714172,
0.48957520723342896,
-0.1636359989643097,
0.3809921145439148,
0.34963634610176086,
1.0068763494491577,
-0.16359516978263855,
0.24601894617080688,
0.14524832367897034,
0.27477625012397766,
0.09943265467882156,
0.7616738080978394,
0.6857626438140869,
-0.3012348711490631,
0.31273651123046875,
-0.47820034623146057,
-0.47048452496528625,
-0.6214901208877563,
-0.6838106513023376,
-1.0520212650299072,
-0.02729656547307968,
-0.24441294372081757,
-0.09865798056125641,
0.21849168837070465,
0.9656200408935547,
0.8564563989639282,
-0.8511210083961487,
-0.3052789568901062,
-0.20417487621307373,
-0.08349567651748657,
-0.34346887469291687,
-0.19119380414485931,
-0.05325565114617348,
-0.24599245190620422,
-0.6989573836326599,
0.7434127330780029,
0.35782310366630554,
0.14794476330280304,
-0.1411539614200592,
-0.18485955893993378,
0.2986288070678711,
0.2392197698354721,
0.4438056945800781,
0.3126104474067688,
-0.6858304142951965,
-0.26100656390190125,
-0.014569958671927452,
-0.10930416733026505,
-0.045181725174188614,
0.5739975571632385,
-0.5303599834442139,
0.3608075976371765,
0.3148431181907654,
0.39739149808883667,
0.842171311378479,
0.1854686290025711,
0.4620789587497711,
-0.5668883323669434,
0.09368981420993805,
0.06089872866868973,
0.29724299907684326,
0.0131965521723032,
-0.05712159723043442,
0.8035704493522644,
0.07785510271787643,
-0.5420492887496948,
-0.9454948306083679,
0.2514302432537079,
-1.1427325010299683,
-0.15459111332893372,
0.8718112707138062,
-0.21469908952713013,
-0.14961214363574982,
0.37805309891700745,
-0.2519746720790863,
0.13596981763839722,
-0.3587668836116791,
0.6068227887153625,
0.4708382487297058,
-0.3330695629119873,
-0.10342434048652649,
-0.6735709309577942,
0.2611936032772064,
0.07400336116552353,
-1.0234991312026978,
-0.051347967237234116,
0.7315493226051331,
0.26250123977661133,
-0.18760450184345245,
0.518436074256897,
-0.04966328293085098,
0.41370677947998047,
0.03932823985815048,
0.04803319647908211,
-0.6565187573432922,
-0.5122309923171997,
-0.028080368414521217,
0.23256628215312958,
-0.12023752182722092,
-0.35038742423057556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12177v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12177v2
|
EuSQuAD: Automatically Translated and Aligned SQuAD2.0 for Basque
| 2024-04-18T13:31:57 | 2024-06-04T15:43:54 |
Aitor García-Pablos, Naiara Perez, Montse Cuadros, Jaione Bengoetxea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The widespread availability of Question Answering (QA) datasets in English
has greatly facilitated the advancement of the Natural Language Processing
(NLP) field. However, the scarcity of such resources for minority languages,
such as Basque, poses a substantial challenge for these communities. In this
context, the translation and alignment of existing QA datasets plays a crucial
role in narrowing this technological gap. This work presents EuSQuAD, the first
initiative dedicated to automatically translating and aligning SQuAD2.0 into
Basque, resulting in more than 142k QA examples. We demonstrate EuSQuAD's value
through extensive qualitative analysis and QA experiments supported with
EuSQuAD as training data. These experiments are evaluated with a new
human-annotated dataset.
|
[
-0.31023526191711426,
-0.38205069303512573,
0.2758120000362396,
0.41565918922424316,
-0.1867809146642685,
0.47715693712234497,
0.05091492459177971,
-0.389882892370224,
0.2996431291103363,
0.19130268692970276,
-0.680055558681488,
-0.324165016412735,
-0.2849980294704437,
0.4080587327480316,
-0.5013617873191833,
0.8772157430648804,
-0.20629343390464783,
0.26907235383987427,
-0.05506162717938423,
-0.4074130654335022,
-0.6069789528846741,
-0.4843282401561737,
-0.7051102519035339,
-0.16941863298416138,
0.10134950280189514,
0.5988854765892029,
0.8082505464553833,
0.37352436780929565,
0.21538524329662323,
0.3166333734989166,
0.16811633110046387,
0.1582486629486084,
-0.5685945749282837,
0.2177397906780243,
-0.32772159576416016,
-0.5681948065757751,
0.0025506396777927876,
-0.24865685403347015,
0.4144020676612854,
0.31839093565940857,
-0.3922138512134552,
0.3221459686756134,
0.047797586768865585,
0.751244843006134,
-0.2257319986820221,
0.13284894824028015,
-0.4643103778362274,
-0.021177344024181366,
-0.08912939578294754,
-0.06583049893379211,
-0.023456158116459846,
-0.3142074644565582,
0.1678897589445114,
-0.8794282674789429,
0.3471564054489136,
-0.2061421275138855,
0.7720034122467041,
0.5547104477882385,
-0.2946242690086365,
-0.0881560668349266,
-0.5584251880645752,
0.6929075717926025,
-0.275727242231369,
0.1917937695980072,
0.10061582177877426,
0.46391332149505615,
-0.4402327835559845,
-0.3961610198020935,
-0.6789803504943848,
0.8886378407478333,
0.2719632089138031,
0.2409881055355072,
-0.5004209280014038,
-0.32640305161476135,
-0.2693018317222595,
0.09445973485708237,
-0.7984632849693298,
0.2636744976043701,
-0.7030338048934937,
-0.07431534677743912,
0.9262402057647705,
0.07886801660060883,
0.5005497932434082,
0.0029705651104450226,
-0.4888003170490265,
0.004164663143455982,
-0.5078374743461609,
0.2098638415336609,
0.17441591620445251,
0.06255044043064117,
-0.1878540813922882,
0.6566752791404724,
-0.6786531209945679,
0.32810690999031067,
0.19833897054195404,
0.5016227960586548,
0.3637631833553314,
-0.06513366848230362,
-0.11279528588056564,
0.25975289940834045,
0.9633588790893555,
0.579971432685852,
0.4301052689552307,
-0.2955716848373413,
0.03845534473657608,
0.07977552711963654,
0.15668271481990814,
-0.3087029457092285,
-0.08183308690786362,
0.6453400254249573,
0.10659318417310715,
-0.29334551095962524,
0.03064221888780594,
-0.5494809746742249,
-0.16442914307117462,
-0.04582466930150986,
0.3460325002670288,
-0.2013149857521057,
-0.09828811883926392,
0.4345640540122986,
-0.3126741647720337,
0.6365732550621033,
0.31929194927215576,
-0.9072170853614807,
0.22158856689929962,
0.6182045936584473,
0.6054955720901489,
-0.5250219702720642,
-0.18803486227989197,
-0.20621027052402496,
0.09249144047498703,
-0.3910955786705017,
1.0210745334625244,
-0.023264136165380478,
-0.1593812108039856,
0.0641501322388649,
0.28220006823539734,
0.09029767662286758,
-0.37640735507011414,
0.5596870183944702,
-0.5817917585372925,
0.39377206563949585,
-0.13426466286182404,
-0.3777743875980377,
-0.004424636717885733,
0.02160300686955452,
-0.6062855124473572,
1.6034666299819946,
0.563288688659668,
-0.460873544216156,
0.09466879069805145,
-0.4890700578689575,
-0.22341403365135193,
0.32482507824897766,
-0.23093275725841522,
-0.03248582407832146,
-0.11690136790275574,
0.3720034062862396,
0.31855911016464233,
-0.4538159966468811,
0.42449915409088135,
0.016113972291350365,
0.1155427098274231,
0.37406373023986816,
-0.20202191174030304,
1.2935208082199097,
0.3424028754234314,
-0.2921103239059448,
-0.22790035605430603,
-0.258043497800827,
0.3267856538295746,
-0.011546008288860321,
-0.10434705764055252,
-0.16057375073432922,
0.03740822151303291,
0.11212416738271713,
0.5547970533370972,
0.3977350890636444,
-0.7712593674659729,
-0.036989931017160416,
-0.3183988928794861,
0.3931800425052643,
0.538923978805542,
-0.1412913203239441,
0.5596343874931335,
-0.20487993955612183,
0.7989588379859924,
-0.440610408782959,
0.3137437403202057,
0.30203989148139954,
-0.8377569913864136,
-0.4451618194580078,
-0.27228933572769165,
0.38536912202835083,
1.0020238161087036,
-0.9765215516090393,
0.5917602777481079,
-0.12527699768543243,
-0.414845734834671,
-0.9188553690910339,
0.2678777575492859,
0.3607499301433563,
0.27084892988204956,
0.4917040169239044,
0.025140345096588135,
-0.578390896320343,
-1.1109510660171509,
-0.01221702340990305,
-0.3512254059314728,
-0.42177754640579224,
-0.3744020164012909,
0.26315930485725403,
0.0017377522308379412,
1.0467184782028198,
-0.3538578152656555,
-0.2528689205646515,
-0.26677951216697693,
-0.010480164550244808,
-0.09273567795753479,
0.6284216046333313,
0.32830706238746643,
-0.7864025831222534,
-0.5389456748962402,
0.04892214015126228,
-0.7285069823265076,
-0.5180561542510986,
0.09313783794641495,
-0.6280166506767273,
0.028362616896629333,
0.5335737466812134,
-0.6483264565467834,
0.17062537372112274,
0.8449896574020386,
-0.6636967062950134,
0.027695370838046074,
0.013855010271072388,
0.2947971820831299,
-1.3920161724090576,
-0.2667399048805237,
-0.06545406579971313,
-0.4129014015197754,
-0.5266759395599365,
0.2300070822238922,
0.1596963256597519,
-0.13762091100215912,
-0.6115158200263977,
0.6334653496742249,
-0.2353435456752777,
-0.04502555727958679,
0.23842856287956238,
0.32389748096466064,
0.20731410384178162,
0.2778390049934387,
0.10247264057397842,
0.8544406294822693,
0.17997696995735168,
-0.3639507293701172,
0.6508852243423462,
0.7484391927719116,
-0.144636869430542,
0.9582862854003906,
-0.7638609409332275,
-0.020389676094055176,
-0.006353562697768211,
0.11678990721702576,
-0.9518438577651978,
-0.20699861645698547,
0.08114923536777496,
-0.542697548866272,
-0.0025782238226383924,
-0.037229735404253006,
-0.4459418058395386,
-0.32963114976882935,
-0.1497623175382614,
0.6592745780944824,
0.4871211647987366,
-0.48929423093795776,
0.24804919958114624,
0.9459017515182495,
-0.562657356262207,
-0.27866291999816895,
-0.5841151475906372,
0.04629836231470108,
-0.11766884475946426,
-0.7035605311393738,
0.307907372713089,
-0.09700227528810501,
-0.10732682794332504,
-0.27995598316192627,
0.01549407746642828,
-0.49476316571235657,
0.15964262187480927,
0.16085930168628693,
0.23109643161296844,
-0.15723197162151337,
0.2564346492290497,
0.23707064986228943,
-0.149820938706398,
-0.007251816336065531,
-0.16517004370689392,
0.5345209240913391,
-0.21209734678268433,
-0.13839781284332275,
-0.7283313870429993,
0.5994557738304138,
0.4494262635707855,
-0.47668883204460144,
0.4682765603065491,
0.37107133865356445,
-0.3659825325012207,
-0.21555408835411072,
-0.48184600472450256,
0.3559889793395996,
-0.44718289375305176,
0.4757940471172333,
-0.20234529674053192,
-0.7508784532546997,
0.5899549722671509,
0.1069643571972847,
0.10598849505186081,
0.836557924747467,
0.3998132348060608,
-0.7341969609260559,
1.1940275430679321,
0.5864987969398499,
-0.1389240026473999,
0.18415001034736633,
-0.2638234794139862,
-0.1767171174287796,
-0.731856107711792,
-0.5728369951248169,
-0.9180681705474854,
-0.4937436878681183,
-0.4846525490283966,
-0.7048007249832153,
0.42782145738601685,
0.2005688101053238,
-0.002761300653219223,
0.3476392924785614,
-0.6453187465667725,
0.7132311463356018,
0.21130679547786713,
0.0114462124183774,
0.2648972272872925,
-0.12664934992790222,
0.38546374440193176,
-0.05965442582964897,
-1.132379412651062,
-0.6206066012382507,
1.0704656839370728,
0.2794669270515442,
0.49444982409477234,
0.2467992603778839,
0.7174266576766968,
0.3716033101081848,
0.13434328138828278,
-0.6792134642601013,
0.30191659927368164,
0.02845587208867073,
-0.702157199382782,
-0.794857382774353,
-0.1493491679430008,
-1.1757488250732422,
0.051072873175144196,
-0.349730908870697,
-0.4615476727485657,
0.3740384876728058,
-0.0500696524977684,
-0.46228963136672974,
-0.0741409957408905,
-0.7937642931938171,
0.9611210227012634,
-0.4584430754184723,
-0.05042807385325432,
-0.07796749472618103,
-0.5468721985816956,
0.014771144837141037,
-0.22494558990001678,
0.16935358941555023,
-0.2823432981967926,
-0.2527521848678589,
0.8280591368675232,
-0.3067862093448639,
0.44555675983428955,
0.07647375017404556,
-0.4534126818180084,
0.23715150356292725,
-0.09376482665538788,
0.2755142152309418,
0.2087864875793457,
-0.18279393017292023,
0.049508627504110336,
0.5990097522735596,
-0.9608818292617798,
-0.45922985672950745,
0.49212244153022766,
-0.7608786821365356,
-0.20035703480243683,
-0.45822200179100037,
-0.7348245978355408,
-0.35142144560813904,
-0.011290404014289379,
0.17079269886016846,
0.24711623787879944,
-0.6606617569923401,
0.13696007430553436,
0.9261583089828491,
-0.15050996840000153,
0.2089533805847168,
0.7586396932601929,
-0.19211481511592865,
-0.2890360951423645,
0.6011339426040649,
-0.025774654000997543,
0.3455730080604553,
0.2287984937429428,
-0.2276945561170578,
-0.6019535660743713,
-0.23908233642578125,
-1.0228900909423828,
-0.09056387841701508,
-0.38033419847488403,
-0.34620803594589233,
-0.36067458987236023,
0.07895182818174362,
-0.22246113419532776,
-0.3371109664440155,
-0.406765878200531,
-0.9453150629997253,
-0.14114752411842346,
-0.08028171211481094,
0.3853539824485779,
0.7068660855293274,
0.16866058111190796,
0.11687006056308746,
-0.6928689479827881,
0.7122946977615356,
0.3391696512699127,
0.15466944873332977,
-0.814818799495697,
-0.2952691614627838,
-0.3015446960926056,
0.10471334308385849,
-0.061668407171964645,
-1.2426700592041016,
0.2488514482975006,
0.14089113473892212,
0.4162318706512451,
0.09556106477975845,
0.36105605959892273,
0.4236243665218353,
-0.38902294635772705,
0.6803508996963501,
0.04473026841878891,
-0.673629105091095,
0.489443302154541,
-0.4004669487476349,
0.4298044741153717,
0.8051837086677551,
0.49941572546958923,
-0.48538827896118164,
-0.694297730922699,
-0.898034393787384,
-0.6353219747543335,
0.4895996153354645,
0.2999604642391205,
0.031117137521505356,
-0.2175271362066269,
0.3483448922634125,
0.011598934419453144,
0.09864512085914612,
-0.049116577953100204,
-0.13447155058383942,
0.1419036090373993,
-0.7550738453865051,
-0.040166955441236496,
0.14233627915382385,
-0.21310390532016754,
-0.25977805256843567,
0.9090449213981628,
-0.15684174001216888,
-0.015361495316028595,
0.37637436389923096,
-0.2650470435619354,
-0.08377396315336227,
0.28394782543182373,
0.11201722919940948,
0.5444836616516113,
0.08729629963636398,
-0.34032729268074036,
0.4104209542274475,
-0.3138231039047241,
0.40272775292396545,
0.0805908814072609,
-0.47792673110961914,
0.20593155920505524,
-0.18817615509033203,
0.10037491470575333,
0.17160232365131378,
-0.8805363774299622,
0.6485609412193298,
-0.1179695874452591,
-0.12526638805866241,
-0.298220157623291,
-0.043596651405096054,
-0.009793886914849281,
0.514235258102417,
0.6243214011192322,
-0.23591342568397522,
0.07189606130123138,
-0.5164235234260559,
0.230757936835289,
0.626790463924408,
-0.479631632566452,
-0.22542250156402588,
0.49476417899131775,
0.5926443338394165,
-0.342674195766449,
0.28790637850761414,
-0.406850665807724,
-0.6783085465431213,
0.7213258743286133,
0.43110132217407227,
0.7812047600746155,
-0.4893524646759033,
0.8205753564834595,
0.187846377491951,
0.5042536854743958,
-0.3164251744747162,
0.8625332117080688,
0.15434259176254272,
-0.6722792983055115,
-0.39652860164642334,
-0.5192932486534119,
-0.3064784109592438,
-0.16997960209846497,
-0.9898324012756348,
0.2101779282093048,
-0.018858911469578743,
-0.07242625206708908,
-0.31420138478279114,
-0.003123497124761343,
-0.7053311467170715,
0.14704522490501404,
-0.16623727977275848,
0.8895761966705322,
-1.092612862586975,
0.5858638882637024,
0.7411690354347229,
-0.1927710324525833,
-0.6359063982963562,
-0.45849061012268066,
-0.11626328527927399,
-0.7551329135894775,
0.34340500831604004,
-0.28644734621047974,
-0.011185535229742527,
0.44355612993240356,
-0.3983114957809448,
-0.6094294190406799,
1.0376900434494019,
0.4960176348686218,
-0.32950571179389954,
0.1341140866279602,
0.3637336790561676,
0.6697014570236206,
-0.3111042380332947,
-0.05898383632302284,
0.7548239231109619,
0.2741910517215729,
-0.46639320254325867,
-1.0084787607192993,
-0.1238437369465828,
-0.47105854749679565,
-0.2905556559562683,
0.5103346109390259,
-0.6754275560379028,
0.37589898705482483,
-0.09963366389274597,
-0.4334639310836792,
0.2725009024143219,
0.6968713402748108,
-0.05058645084500313,
0.02104960009455681,
0.1515275090932846,
0.6683990359306335,
0.8306289315223694,
-0.25043874979019165,
0.7017243504524231,
-0.17210736870765686,
0.1909579038619995,
1.0322571992874146,
-0.18780601024627686,
1.103990912437439,
0.7075229287147522,
-0.37818145751953125,
0.42429468035697937,
0.5298900008201599,
0.16638609766960144,
0.19244809448719025,
-0.010971718467772007,
-0.3504756689071655,
-0.2650357484817505,
-0.15635256469249725,
-0.35735782980918884,
0.4220389127731323,
0.2054951786994934,
0.08118225634098053,
-0.26714712381362915,
-0.2528209686279297,
-0.2649399936199188,
0.41196587681770325,
-0.22479866445064545,
0.8871492147445679,
-0.3633635342121124,
-0.6594756245613098,
0.5420734286308289,
0.02100992016494274,
0.3800875246524811,
-0.4333084523677826,
-0.07220354676246643,
-0.4064469337463379,
-0.3944869041442871,
-0.3480595648288727,
-1.0792713165283203,
0.13280804455280304,
0.2867650091648102,
-0.11375302076339722,
-0.29323747754096985,
0.0956401526927948,
-0.7756055593490601,
-0.5252841711044312,
-0.02716512233018875,
0.7400085926055908,
0.26507696509361267,
-0.0864715501666069,
-0.7743931412696838,
-0.31569987535476685,
0.07509110122919083,
0.295376718044281,
0.2892604172229767,
0.9209359288215637,
-0.30638009309768677,
0.6891257762908936,
0.532520055770874,
0.07435985654592514,
0.4084247648715973,
-0.3102461099624634,
0.6500755548477173,
-0.3930777907371521,
-0.6418762803077698,
-0.369271457195282,
0.6244500279426575,
-0.08287157863378525,
-0.6478770971298218,
0.5479432940483093,
0.8584134578704834,
0.944561779499054,
0.005058846436440945,
0.7783188223838806,
-0.19478441774845123,
0.5788959264755249,
-0.5603071451187134,
0.6248368620872498,
-0.04695427790284157,
0.13209182024002075,
0.12310001254081726,
-0.673224925994873,
-0.009170720353722572,
0.499497652053833,
0.23473165929317474,
-0.7548433542251587,
0.5240577459335327,
0.8104742169380188,
0.05305580049753189,
-0.004040876403450966,
0.10846678167581558,
-0.05662131309509277,
0.02449897490441799,
0.6493570804595947,
0.7824743986129761,
-0.8755386471748352,
0.7286510467529297,
-0.29931640625,
-0.19048631191253662,
0.18194212019443512,
-0.5967060923576355,
-0.6941241025924683,
-0.7595570683479309,
-0.26978304982185364,
-0.30764201283454895,
0.15008220076560974,
1.0029042959213257,
0.265574187040329,
-1.0477681159973145,
-0.3146722614765167,
0.07090850919485092,
0.0813000351190567,
-0.1390952616930008,
-0.21803602576255798,
0.17507576942443848,
-0.31931760907173157,
-0.7679083943367004,
0.3302087187767029,
0.1854686588048935,
0.10378044843673706,
-0.3020799160003662,
-0.33382704854011536,
-0.359719842672348,
-0.0767560750246048,
0.4243592619895935,
0.8967030644416809,
-0.4533737599849701,
-0.0396101251244545,
0.13852156698703766,
-0.19760362803936005,
0.05113540217280388,
0.4372982382774353,
-0.9863690137863159,
0.43779051303863525,
0.5557287931442261,
0.9714965224266052,
0.15716010332107544,
0.24639993906021118,
1.1426647901535034,
-0.6367849707603455,
0.128742054104805,
0.19508463144302368,
0.07859779894351959,
0.273898184299469,
-0.23624001443386078,
0.736229419708252,
-0.14415238797664642,
-0.47067394852638245,
-0.7023714780807495,
0.08086448907852173,
-0.7599159479141235,
0.12362035363912582,
1.053002119064331,
0.05690622702240944,
-0.07632775604724884,
-0.7319961786270142,
-0.4596973955631256,
0.5303390622138977,
-0.4716467559337616,
0.9354677200317383,
0.6434326767921448,
-0.04943762347102165,
0.18877354264259338,
-0.8944887518882751,
0.8180629014968872,
0.6368082761764526,
-1.1423230171203613,
-0.10044114291667938,
0.5296382308006287,
0.08804335445165634,
-0.061435844749212265,
0.6045427322387695,
-0.19759586453437805,
0.7363834977149963,
-0.5111449360847473,
0.2811349332332611,
0.4275904595851898,
-0.07229305058717728,
-0.5148926377296448,
-0.1772819310426712,
-0.11931727826595306,
-0.2579811215400696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12174v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12174v1
|
Claim Check-Worthiness Detection: How Well do LLMs Grasp Annotation Guidelines?
| 2024-04-18T13:31:05 | 2024-04-18T13:31:05 |
Laura Majer, Jan Šnajder
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The increasing threat of disinformation calls for automating parts of the
fact-checking pipeline. Identifying text segments requiring fact-checking is
known as claim detection (CD) and claim check-worthiness detection (CW), the
latter incorporating complex domain-specific criteria of worthiness and often
framed as a ranking task. Zero- and few-shot LLM prompting is an attractive
option for both tasks, as it bypasses the need for labeled datasets and allows
verbalized claim and worthiness criteria to be directly used for prompting. We
evaluate the LLMs' predictive and calibration accuracy on five CD/CW datasets
from diverse domains, each utilizing a different worthiness criterion. We
investigate two key aspects: (1) how best to distill factuality and worthiness
criteria into a prompt and (2) what amount of context to provide for each
claim. To this end, we experiment with varying the level of prompt verbosity
and the amount of contextual information provided to the model. Our results
show that optimal prompt verbosity is domain-dependent, adding context does not
improve performance, and confidence scores can be directly used to produce
reliable check-worthiness rankings.
|
[
-0.30352678894996643,
-0.6193593740463257,
1.0116899013519287,
0.13100621104240417,
-0.30568164587020874,
-0.04791318625211716,
-0.02011023834347725,
-0.6530874371528625,
0.12249898910522461,
0.2458992898464203,
-0.5558992624282837,
-0.5003262758255005,
-0.8270330429077148,
0.38661444187164307,
-0.11343292891979218,
1.1918216943740845,
0.016415612772107124,
-0.3198181390762329,
-0.672488808631897,
-0.04680114984512329,
-0.5598790645599365,
-0.42925548553466797,
-0.35568588972091675,
-0.42879486083984375,
0.7235244512557983,
0.575421154499054,
0.5760805606842041,
0.3852408230304718,
0.320496141910553,
0.18850426375865936,
-0.13498251140117645,
0.49459972977638245,
-0.2516691982746124,
0.22082599997520447,
-0.11340392380952835,
-0.6785255074501038,
-0.6359119415283203,
0.3983367085456848,
0.0076009053736925125,
0.4453824758529663,
0.17790725827217102,
0.558688223361969,
0.0333683155477047,
0.6463999152183533,
-0.710458517074585,
0.37378159165382385,
-0.739449679851532,
-0.08357249945402145,
-0.2506991922855377,
-0.5719370245933533,
-0.5081383585929871,
-0.4797736704349518,
0.32325029373168945,
-0.4760587811470032,
0.1314673125743866,
0.10690467059612274,
1.0008434057235718,
0.6240701675415039,
-0.4931238293647766,
-0.558648407459259,
-0.2142265886068344,
0.645990788936615,
-0.5123558044433594,
-0.031233936548233032,
0.8093605041503906,
0.10966514050960541,
0.1562875509262085,
-0.3098856806755066,
-0.6619018316268921,
-0.38345855474472046,
-0.2825527489185333,
0.2398841828107834,
-0.48593035340309143,
0.08486460149288177,
0.6438027620315552,
0.3321684002876282,
-0.3190922737121582,
0.23473037779331207,
-0.20587114989757538,
-0.6097769737243652,
0.6883862018585205,
-0.15287631750106812,
-0.045743219554424286,
-0.4713228940963745,
-0.592847466468811,
0.17112331092357635,
-0.9516909122467041,
0.17776334285736084,
0.41926610469818115,
0.2363920658826828,
-0.03993745148181915,
0.7107973098754883,
-0.44669461250305176,
0.6082258224487305,
0.30687668919563293,
-0.3645170032978058,
0.08951281756162643,
-0.448486864566803,
-0.32289591431617737,
0.3345831036567688,
0.35341984033584595,
0.5981929898262024,
0.30861884355545044,
-0.005473432131111622,
-0.5476129651069641,
-0.037142056971788406,
0.1556873917579651,
-0.7091910243034363,
-0.21482765674591064,
0.4653014838695526,
-0.35864561796188354,
-0.5814383625984192,
-0.010423730127513409,
-0.26000359654426575,
-0.701695442199707,
-0.7293330430984497,
0.6408957242965698,
-0.36502569913864136,
0.022875934839248657,
-0.12691393494606018,
-0.18021169304847717,
0.1964280605316162,
0.7138565182685852,
-0.4834563434123993,
-0.2900015413761139,
0.3747248947620392,
0.9044094085693359,
-0.3505650460720062,
0.014566551893949509,
-0.951600193977356,
-0.23280403017997742,
-0.33628323674201965,
1.2124559879302979,
-0.08066930621862411,
-0.16513125598430634,
0.24123457074165344,
0.0030271781142801046,
0.13895663619041443,
-0.5884360671043396,
0.7791770696640015,
-0.7927701473236084,
0.14875291287899017,
-0.7834346890449524,
-0.644976794719696,
-0.17332330346107483,
0.6850572228431702,
-0.8667759895324707,
0.900058925151825,
0.08888380229473114,
-0.6502848863601685,
0.9479309916496277,
-0.3696628212928772,
-0.3768763244152069,
0.3145948648452759,
-0.013719247654080391,
-0.35167840123176575,
0.12911061942577362,
0.12688283622264862,
0.7394719123840332,
-0.10021911561489105,
0.27306821942329407,
-0.003443092107772827,
-0.20267143845558167,
0.5102794170379639,
-0.7117590308189392,
0.6087652444839478,
0.22836172580718994,
-0.41921088099479675,
-0.11753559112548828,
-0.8635846972465515,
-0.056602343916893005,
-0.2325328290462494,
-0.5644204020500183,
-0.20698821544647217,
-0.14520344138145447,
-0.26582232117652893,
0.22853487730026245,
0.2444073110818863,
-0.5941815972328186,
0.07295239716768265,
0.006563945207744837,
-0.0045689730904996395,
0.6910548210144043,
0.004838966298848391,
0.02617686428129673,
-0.785506546497345,
0.37027743458747864,
0.14695784449577332,
-0.11148698627948761,
-0.3984469473361969,
-0.41320309042930603,
-0.8422887325286865,
-0.4287845492362976,
0.5603552460670471,
0.6813904047012329,
-0.7716003060340881,
0.5577667355537415,
-0.24356764554977417,
-0.3033227026462555,
-0.4340733587741852,
0.014907238073647022,
0.20318058133125305,
0.8105641603469849,
0.5013733506202698,
-0.03124247118830681,
-0.2672020196914673,
-0.6747674942016602,
-0.2481103390455246,
-0.40943288803100586,
-0.034569546580314636,
0.09587026387453079,
0.4158632755279541,
0.10713625699281693,
1.2348910570144653,
-0.4066729247570038,
-0.4215284585952759,
-0.06392727792263031,
0.2604319155216217,
0.10694075375795364,
-0.04716121777892113,
0.5245180726051331,
-0.8130173087120056,
-0.34558701515197754,
-0.512096643447876,
-0.7540119886398315,
-0.4906351566314697,
-0.2793000340461731,
0.3608933091163635,
0.5033136010169983,
0.21223993599414825,
-0.4495457410812378,
0.5715662240982056,
0.32160887122154236,
-0.27186161279678345,
0.7949891090393066,
-0.09031824767589569,
0.45379209518432617,
-0.5908642411231995,
0.04758421704173088,
0.09215519577264786,
-0.5832188725471497,
-0.5097669959068298,
-0.39457783102989197,
0.1536792814731598,
0.42707762122154236,
-0.5474958419799805,
0.3329935371875763,
-0.46575185656547546,
0.11719503253698349,
-0.5282846093177795,
0.36845141649246216,
0.20987655222415924,
0.19227483868598938,
-0.18476463854312897,
0.9259609580039978,
0.33064278960227966,
-0.9473949074745178,
0.34691524505615234,
0.05581704154610634,
-0.43223270773887634,
1.2419328689575195,
-0.6069971323013306,
-0.17802655696868896,
-0.06858304142951965,
0.27777066826820374,
-1.1766862869262695,
-0.14974012970924377,
0.04859759286046028,
-0.5537636876106262,
0.2906331419944763,
-0.24833746254444122,
-0.6110953688621521,
-0.08111608773469925,
-0.5688781142234802,
0.10833144932985306,
0.38045263290405273,
-0.7400004863739014,
0.2814613878726959,
0.25935932993888855,
-0.14949317276477814,
-0.7346324324607849,
-0.6826031804084778,
0.39472565054893494,
-0.27292877435684204,
-0.40121030807495117,
0.5140031576156616,
-0.002687229309231043,
-0.3560917377471924,
-0.1881352812051773,
-0.21305161714553833,
0.09694132953882217,
0.17186228930950165,
0.4494999349117279,
0.5133722424507141,
0.13072501122951508,
0.149443581700325,
0.015160237438976765,
-0.4761754870414734,
0.39994654059410095,
-0.18445679545402527,
0.012814831919968128,
0.11166630685329437,
-0.4455913007259369,
-0.4949151873588562,
-0.03366772457957268,
0.4130186438560486,
-0.05340903624892235,
0.5270805954933167,
0.36973336338996887,
-0.397382527589798,
-0.13604243099689484,
-0.9440869688987732,
-0.055635202676057816,
-0.4390794336795807,
-0.3064207136631012,
-0.20166286826133728,
-0.8130382895469666,
0.32358551025390625,
-0.27796298265457153,
0.2002551257610321,
0.6421937942504883,
0.5454438924789429,
-0.26400336623191833,
0.5082169771194458,
0.5861599445343018,
-0.010354094207286835,
0.2131931185722351,
-0.06252529472112656,
0.11927729845046997,
-0.3936343193054199,
-0.23663750290870667,
-0.434450626373291,
-0.010265219025313854,
-0.3281179666519165,
-0.4413202106952667,
0.47803300619125366,
-0.062470436096191406,
0.3057578504085541,
0.20622511208057404,
-0.4485199749469757,
0.530763566493988,
0.32044756412506104,
0.09208906441926956,
0.774920642375946,
0.12811632454395294,
-0.04264417290687561,
-0.08756240457296371,
-0.36223408579826355,
-0.8490181565284729,
0.9564976096153259,
0.351926326751709,
0.6295441389083862,
0.11607891321182251,
0.5841686725616455,
0.8359824419021606,
0.4403862953186035,
-1.0979299545288086,
0.3889339864253998,
0.25203144550323486,
-0.5025946497917175,
-0.09321286529302597,
-0.1518079787492752,
-0.582126259803772,
0.0672563761472702,
-0.3377499580383301,
-0.45016613602638245,
0.21585911512374878,
0.43206480145454407,
-0.5643190741539001,
0.15103253722190857,
-0.3751700818538666,
0.3070618212223053,
-0.2215624302625656,
-0.11311087012290955,
-0.1545524299144745,
-0.5975317358970642,
0.36820515990257263,
-0.14760135114192963,
0.13949809968471527,
-0.4229644238948822,
-0.07082062214612961,
0.5429365634918213,
-0.3900129795074463,
1.0541579723358154,
-0.28119900822639465,
-0.4411875307559967,
0.5095236897468567,
0.04880982264876366,
0.6455410718917847,
0.10336016118526459,
-0.17047102749347687,
0.20029543340206146,
0.20514599978923798,
-0.13057152926921844,
-0.3605839014053345,
0.29220321774482727,
-0.26955708861351013,
-0.5602045655250549,
-0.8101179003715515,
-0.25038161873817444,
-0.11620378494262695,
0.21958662569522858,
0.40476739406585693,
0.3655533492565155,
-0.21610327064990997,
-0.14386403560638428,
1.04647696018219,
-0.08965351432561874,
0.3986946642398834,
0.6879187226295471,
0.225343257188797,
-0.2783852517604828,
0.8779172301292419,
0.3188718557357788,
0.3870398998260498,
0.33277133107185364,
0.031084511429071426,
-0.5412752032279968,
-0.45621824264526367,
-0.5953466296195984,
0.07808968424797058,
-0.8715158104896545,
-0.6827403903007507,
-0.5346938967704773,
-0.14495110511779785,
-0.07894432544708252,
-0.06527351588010788,
-0.05608724430203438,
-0.6039655804634094,
-0.288278728723526,
-0.4038476049900055,
0.5987762808799744,
0.6795479655265808,
-0.1384776383638382,
-0.007812479976564646,
-0.6227214932441711,
0.16170090436935425,
0.31246909499168396,
0.09946542978286743,
-0.3825151324272156,
-0.6105617880821228,
-0.15766115486621857,
-0.004090792499482632,
-0.20769567787647247,
-0.713594913482666,
-0.10327021777629852,
-0.02532900869846344,
0.4838370978832245,
0.28404501080513,
0.4888083040714264,
0.4198459982872009,
-0.36649948358535767,
0.984625518321991,
0.036470308899879456,
-0.8530837297439575,
0.5945447683334351,
0.11465980112552643,
-0.09638916701078415,
0.8698549270629883,
0.575053870677948,
-0.43182870745658875,
-0.28303447365760803,
-0.4711079001426697,
-0.6052488088607788,
0.4678729176521301,
0.05853976681828499,
0.05504768341779709,
-0.023103270679712296,
0.4095235764980316,
0.190802663564682,
0.23188497126102448,
-0.6898767948150635,
-0.45859917998313904,
-0.08204615116119385,
-0.06085661053657532,
0.31003430485725403,
-0.6099188327789307,
-0.4727436304092407,
0.18096674978733063,
0.5026063919067383,
-0.4987335801124573,
0.1166745200753212,
0.631953239440918,
-0.4219038486480713,
-0.18736593425273895,
0.45510736107826233,
0.5161842107772827,
0.8646360635757446,
-0.10218869149684906,
0.34484007954597473,
0.3249911963939667,
-0.45415133237838745,
0.3520684540271759,
0.1779729425907135,
-0.3346756100654602,
0.2760138511657715,
0.5056428909301758,
0.47464337944984436,
-0.057889338582754135,
-0.5265200138092041,
0.9116080403327942,
0.03490623086690903,
-0.3948073387145996,
-0.2359236180782318,
0.09589666873216629,
-0.2674447298049927,
0.12326505035161972,
0.47867152094841003,
-0.08825543522834778,
0.15930357575416565,
-0.2783685326576233,
0.18805846571922302,
0.45114660263061523,
-0.3490819036960602,
-0.1724398136138916,
0.5953434109687805,
0.1601293534040451,
0.141587495803833,
0.20514725148677826,
-0.3252972960472107,
-0.5606797933578491,
0.6231894493103027,
0.19616086781024933,
0.647907018661499,
0.23395942151546478,
0.3604821562767029,
0.35766878724098206,
0.4398857355117798,
-0.04453667253255844,
0.14950531721115112,
-0.3101697862148285,
-0.6419715285301208,
-0.5015290379524231,
-0.38802289962768555,
-0.7344136834144592,
-0.019970400258898735,
-0.569678008556366,
0.4135175943374634,
-0.2603355646133423,
-0.3618081212043762,
0.1369127780199051,
0.19101445376873016,
-0.6670522689819336,
0.44383057951927185,
0.26094648241996765,
1.056990385055542,
-0.6206929683685303,
0.5881054997444153,
0.3489558696746826,
-0.5895196795463562,
-0.6171431541442871,
0.15615113079547882,
0.5874099731445312,
-0.8413423895835876,
0.7891314029693604,
0.4798343777656555,
-0.36111077666282654,
-0.1997883915901184,
-0.6592905521392822,
-0.6778711080551147,
1.5030542612075806,
0.3635493218898773,
-0.4737837314605713,
0.22354525327682495,
-0.023714832961559296,
0.13100814819335938,
-0.1360607147216797,
0.31477445363998413,
0.5446638464927673,
0.5990038514137268,
0.19787272810935974,
-0.8705129027366638,
0.38392359018325806,
0.28151118755340576,
-0.34878239035606384,
-0.21309953927993774,
-0.6498371362686157,
0.48353058099746704,
-0.44244086742401123,
-0.4644962251186371,
-0.19707763195037842,
0.7118932008743286,
0.45777761936187744,
0.6706030368804932,
0.9484192728996277,
0.3579729497432709,
1.1772254705429077,
-0.225833460688591,
0.9440615177154541,
-0.25586485862731934,
0.24075402319431305,
0.7837128639221191,
-0.2791215479373932,
0.5865449905395508,
0.302011638879776,
-0.21620264649391174,
0.4764648973941803,
0.7853996753692627,
-0.10874573886394501,
0.3425206243991852,
0.0717720091342926,
-0.4656659960746765,
-0.22100664675235748,
-0.40295785665512085,
-0.1810501664876938,
0.20034801959991455,
0.409320205450058,
-0.22938314080238342,
-0.13893213868141174,
-0.22295360267162323,
0.4435163140296936,
-0.18429681658744812,
-0.0667848065495491,
0.7189951539039612,
0.14615146815776825,
-1.118851900100708,
0.4881711006164551,
-0.1367536187171936,
0.7914828062057495,
-0.4971157908439636,
-0.10676795989274979,
-0.13091765344142914,
-0.3000313937664032,
-0.6687472462654114,
-0.8648290038108826,
0.2107488363981247,
0.3286723494529724,
-0.45010143518447876,
-0.2584482431411743,
0.9227055311203003,
-0.4291228950023651,
0.015928667038679123,
0.04584364593029022,
0.6412209868431091,
0.19128355383872986,
-0.2466202974319458,
-0.547773003578186,
-0.12184888869524002,
-0.13600370287895203,
-0.19572016596794128,
0.22445864975452423,
0.5502137541770935,
0.10117895156145096,
0.5512472987174988,
0.7626438140869141,
0.0493585504591465,
-0.29101085662841797,
0.07870559394359589,
0.9374898672103882,
-0.41249507665634155,
-0.12884527444839478,
-1.037807822227478,
0.5898466110229492,
-0.2408474087715149,
-0.1584332138299942,
0.9010605216026306,
0.4090902805328369,
0.6540252566337585,
0.2876462936401367,
0.8785010576248169,
-0.16771669685840607,
0.30093151330947876,
-0.8488624691963196,
0.7394310832023621,
-0.4262215793132782,
0.37641170620918274,
-0.2005142718553543,
-0.5857430100440979,
-0.4042433798313141,
0.46152323484420776,
-0.17780478298664093,
-0.12275709956884384,
0.7584100961685181,
0.8133785128593445,
0.210890993475914,
-0.04114850237965584,
0.38926610350608826,
-0.11681855469942093,
0.48683351278305054,
0.2883065640926361,
0.8998717665672302,
-0.23850609362125397,
0.4866761267185211,
-0.10419125109910965,
-0.49034661054611206,
-0.3570597171783447,
-1.512852430343628,
-0.8010156154632568,
-0.2965298295021057,
-0.7372704148292542,
-0.6287034153938293,
-0.2733007073402405,
0.8348235487937927,
0.6564844250679016,
-0.7301527261734009,
0.38072019815444946,
0.38366565108299255,
0.33558833599090576,
-0.02381928823888302,
-0.21006469428539276,
0.25954312086105347,
-0.6879624724388123,
-0.4227462112903595,
0.3260030746459961,
0.3519595265388489,
0.0851641595363617,
-0.19062688946723938,
0.12654636800289154,
-0.06103095784783363,
0.2636733949184418,
0.709913969039917,
0.19695022702217102,
-0.7517336010932922,
-0.41631174087524414,
-0.046082474291324615,
-0.31778058409690857,
0.02808748558163643,
0.7807970643043518,
-0.8142377138137817,
0.5361806750297546,
0.21683813631534576,
0.6881639957427979,
0.15819700062274933,
0.22119426727294922,
0.2476591020822525,
-0.8120598793029785,
-0.30465707182884216,
-0.015222032554447651,
0.3188275992870331,
0.41519036889076233,
-0.7612353563308716,
0.5483008027076721,
0.3407336175441742,
-0.7774357795715332,
-0.716422975063324,
0.09646006673574448,
-1.0150548219680786,
-0.023408928886055946,
1.099508285522461,
-0.27621135115623474,
-0.03879327327013016,
-0.3269211947917938,
-0.32258281111717224,
-0.007794355042278767,
-0.30689018964767456,
0.7576711773872375,
1.0132458209991455,
-0.22974668443202972,
0.1846107393503189,
-0.5894274115562439,
0.7541509866714478,
0.3426450788974762,
-0.805180013179779,
0.3169555366039276,
0.7488791346549988,
0.4461498260498047,
0.3820924460887909,
0.7652778625488281,
0.015162439085543156,
0.4246777594089508,
-0.40603551268577576,
-0.3231912851333618,
-0.24673809111118317,
-0.3246242105960846,
-0.44076037406921387,
-0.02301742322742939,
0.24065753817558289,
-0.1910884976387024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12171v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12171v1
|
Stance Detection on Social Media with Fine-Tuned Large Language Models
| 2024-04-18T13:25:29 | 2024-04-18T13:25:29 |
İlker Gül, Rémi Lebret, Karl Aberer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Stance detection, a key task in natural language processing, determines an
author's viewpoint based on textual analysis. This study evaluates the
evolution of stance detection methods, transitioning from early machine
learning approaches to the groundbreaking BERT model, and eventually to modern
Large Language Models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT, LLaMa-2, and Mistral-7B. While
ChatGPT's closed-source nature and associated costs present challenges, the
open-source models like LLaMa-2 and Mistral-7B offers an encouraging
alternative. Initially, our research focused on fine-tuning ChatGPT, LLaMa-2,
and Mistral-7B using several publicly available datasets. Subsequently, to
provide a comprehensive comparison, we assess the performance of these models
in zero-shot and few-shot learning scenarios. The results underscore the
exceptional ability of LLMs in accurately detecting stance, with all tested
models surpassing existing benchmarks. Notably, LLaMa-2 and Mistral-7B
demonstrate remarkable efficiency and potential for stance detection, despite
their smaller sizes compared to ChatGPT. This study emphasizes the potential of
LLMs in stance detection and calls for more extensive research in this field.
|
[
-0.3883190155029297,
-0.9423165321350098,
0.7644265294075012,
0.17146757245063782,
-0.5270379781723022,
-0.04438372701406479,
-0.349090576171875,
-0.48220670223236084,
0.24799011647701263,
0.3063077926635742,
-0.5239911079406738,
-0.8494375944137573,
-1.0234909057617188,
-0.020493507385253906,
-0.4583743214607239,
1.0302144289016724,
-0.04125604405999184,
0.12397042661905289,
0.2107984572649002,
-0.34678658843040466,
-0.19519855082035065,
-0.3299182057380676,
-0.7273176312446594,
-0.3684690296649933,
0.5076144933700562,
0.2159264236688614,
0.8856931924819946,
0.40975815057754517,
0.44478732347488403,
0.16914235055446625,
-0.4119548797607422,
-0.10256405174732208,
-0.5211255550384521,
0.23598712682724,
-0.0002683096390683204,
-0.4017568528652191,
-0.46567302942276,
-0.0869472473859787,
0.7813013792037964,
0.3242928683757782,
0.000843578192871064,
0.0878743901848793,
-0.06976203620433807,
0.6646673083305359,
-0.3472346365451813,
-0.019308773800730705,
-0.7897077202796936,
-0.04767443612217903,
-0.399490624666214,
0.1663873791694641,
-0.3793134391307831,
-0.3539387285709381,
-0.1725991815328598,
-0.21203678846359253,
0.11072591692209244,
-0.2780422270298004,
0.9419710636138916,
0.1493701934814453,
-0.26609131693840027,
-0.22158890962600708,
-0.5324802398681641,
0.8121394515037537,
-0.908761203289032,
0.6370821595191956,
0.35253390669822693,
0.2040187418460846,
-0.43347686529159546,
-0.3985203504562378,
-0.7165091633796692,
-0.2806454300880432,
0.39626047015190125,
-0.015761440619826317,
-0.5335703492164612,
0.07532089948654175,
0.020636143162846565,
0.16747881472110748,
-0.4835108518600464,
0.5270124673843384,
-0.03941941261291504,
0.027546396479010582,
0.4390697479248047,
-0.15255706012248993,
0.14954032003879547,
-0.46985694766044617,
-0.3886806070804596,
-0.009325500577688217,
-0.7255389094352722,
0.1524583101272583,
0.4883853793144226,
0.3687378466129303,
-0.1506766825914383,
0.7489769458770752,
-0.20903678238391876,
0.5140917897224426,
0.3793947696685791,
-0.06814863532781601,
-0.11115282028913498,
0.0998893678188324,
-0.22937005758285522,
-0.002625758294016123,
0.9034846425056458,
0.41316917538642883,
0.1853381097316742,
0.17673249542713165,
-0.3383777439594269,
0.04675609618425369,
-0.031223392114043236,
-0.6246683597564697,
-0.19514942169189453,
0.28215131163597107,
-0.7278539538383484,
-0.4272990822792053,
-0.07590831816196442,
-0.36087876558303833,
-1.0676852464675903,
-0.5342498421669006,
0.16675890982151031,
-0.5079855918884277,
-0.5039160847663879,
0.1524984985589981,
-0.03420248255133629,
0.9146263003349304,
0.6673579216003418,
-0.6485224962234497,
-0.03456635773181915,
1.2002934217453003,
1.1926299333572388,
-0.3456164598464966,
0.11460021138191223,
-0.33198535442352295,
-0.23205454647541046,
-0.508123517036438,
0.968000590801239,
-0.5923174023628235,
-0.3339994549751282,
0.2368408888578415,
-0.16372330486774445,
0.32041218876838684,
-0.3732619881629944,
0.62208092212677,
-0.5394201278686523,
-0.13989397883415222,
-0.3895361125469208,
-0.7088144421577454,
-0.1204158142209053,
0.8042088747024536,
-0.7440037727355957,
1.080963134765625,
-0.21889802813529968,
-0.8161739706993103,
0.5402722358703613,
-0.5829733610153198,
-0.3585699498653412,
-0.09232668578624725,
-0.21414940059185028,
-0.4739581346511841,
0.09578677266836166,
0.17386028170585632,
0.8341590762138367,
-0.026496753096580505,
0.19974173605442047,
-0.8251379728317261,
-0.20074588060379028,
0.1627430021762848,
-0.3969130516052246,
0.9856835007667542,
0.01737125590443611,
-0.3046361207962036,
0.20869965851306915,
-0.44865208864212036,
-0.3733319938182831,
0.2054741233587265,
-0.3930183947086334,
-0.28683406114578247,
0.34584560990333557,
-0.13808901607990265,
0.10255204141139984,
0.2817941904067993,
-0.5121116638183594,
0.2706179916858673,
-0.2272510826587677,
0.3143974542617798,
0.8724086284637451,
0.079098179936409,
0.22601552307605743,
-0.027730315923690796,
0.3579467236995697,
-0.13410189747810364,
0.19896286725997925,
0.07731163501739502,
-0.5659688711166382,
-0.8564351201057434,
-0.3038080930709839,
0.06623932719230652,
0.2365073263645172,
-0.39396414160728455,
0.42343613505363464,
-0.24841229617595673,
-0.6321623921394348,
-0.5657910704612732,
0.3779659569263458,
0.014345669187605381,
-0.01612051948904991,
0.15821044147014618,
-0.22813181579113007,
-0.38491079211235046,
-0.742594301700592,
-0.5436549186706543,
-0.5811211466789246,
0.22901472449302673,
-0.016452323645353317,
0.3161243796348572,
-0.12148908525705338,
1.0030272006988525,
-0.15212416648864746,
-0.141245499253273,
-0.4182649254798889,
0.30276522040367126,
0.2847328186035156,
-0.05442678555846214,
0.8086509704589844,
-0.7193486094474792,
-0.5780314207077026,
0.13427267968654633,
-0.6186659932136536,
-0.10773714631795883,
-0.06716295331716537,
-0.09987320005893707,
0.39994966983795166,
0.5635121464729309,
-0.8686792254447937,
0.37420591711997986,
0.693242609500885,
-0.1284136027097702,
0.46232926845550537,
0.34239986538887024,
0.016836119815707207,
-1.154194951057434,
-0.1693955361843109,
0.47247040271759033,
-0.5582663416862488,
-0.7429577708244324,
-0.08923465758562088,
-0.032898589968681335,
0.12072387337684631,
-0.6363359093666077,
0.4585738182067871,
-0.2816859185695648,
-0.08295507729053497,
-0.4077749252319336,
0.10654517263174057,
-0.27287089824676514,
0.17833881080150604,
0.20223161578178406,
0.3913913071155548,
0.4305906593799591,
-0.3971746563911438,
0.11013571172952652,
0.039427224546670914,
-0.30599474906921387,
0.5981773138046265,
-0.6489918828010559,
0.3151385486125946,
-0.3296011686325073,
0.517967164516449,
-1.271525502204895,
-0.33193767070770264,
0.37362614274024963,
-0.5581859350204468,
0.3188166320323944,
-0.6054660081863403,
-0.7417762875556946,
-0.1652728170156479,
-0.7830641269683838,
-0.11761756986379623,
0.27672913670539856,
-0.6863428354263306,
0.40941330790519714,
0.39929306507110596,
-0.2740991711616516,
-0.7303712964057922,
-0.24822747707366943,
0.22146636247634888,
-0.27350327372550964,
-0.43702998757362366,
-0.016976594924926758,
0.2366630733013153,
-0.581368625164032,
-0.29502391815185547,
-0.06258874386548996,
0.04869123920798302,
0.00095524633070454,
0.2709653079509735,
0.12198077887296677,
-0.25497445464134216,
0.13249127566814423,
0.09176290780305862,
0.1693154275417328,
-0.07183286547660828,
-0.15537244081497192,
0.717327892780304,
-0.3185277581214905,
-0.5239759087562561,
-0.649031937122345,
-0.000317647703923285,
0.8108616471290588,
-0.10331310331821442,
0.7030827403068542,
0.9077609777450562,
-0.3419397175312042,
-0.15406231582164764,
-0.579860270023346,
0.056943465024232864,
-0.45986300706863403,
0.27065154910087585,
0.15551818907260895,
-0.9194629192352295,
0.3748503029346466,
-0.05924244970083237,
0.3742730915546417,
0.31368908286094666,
0.9609504342079163,
-0.36949679255485535,
0.9158185124397278,
0.6719125509262085,
-0.5412455797195435,
0.906305730342865,
-0.06458258628845215,
0.26969242095947266,
-0.3805382251739502,
0.16125817596912384,
-0.48629313707351685,
-0.4371618926525116,
-0.6568567752838135,
-0.514784574508667,
0.25522157549858093,
0.056574638932943344,
-0.28565993905067444,
0.4252593219280243,
-0.21786944568157196,
0.40231797099113464,
0.09823636710643768,
0.11577282100915909,
0.332578182220459,
-0.0011199751170352101,
0.25425857305526733,
-0.004818734247237444,
-0.12129602581262589,
-0.8104639053344727,
1.0520155429840088,
0.7148831486701965,
0.6762117147445679,
0.3415207862854004,
0.7167571783065796,
0.6192319989204407,
0.5008054971694946,
-1.3290067911148071,
0.7403196096420288,
-0.21958543360233307,
-0.49904584884643555,
-0.20439870655536652,
0.14095883071422577,
-0.8703403472900391,
0.37088271975517273,
-0.2441200464963913,
-0.6153175830841064,
-0.0003325479628983885,
0.24435168504714966,
-0.006267033517360687,
0.5432837009429932,
-0.5016815066337585,
0.5962609052658081,
-0.20242658257484436,
-0.3039984405040741,
-0.2151329219341278,
-0.5083758234977722,
0.31985312700271606,
0.036487650126218796,
0.005671613849699497,
-0.43611493706703186,
0.008339625783264637,
0.6402351260185242,
-0.07237698137760162,
1.3679471015930176,
-0.56195467710495,
-0.5522080063819885,
0.38996419310569763,
0.10949601233005524,
0.5333502888679504,
0.03567870333790779,
-0.2759246230125427,
0.2527194619178772,
-0.28231099247932434,
-0.21127866208553314,
-0.17563533782958984,
0.6598724126815796,
-0.770102322101593,
-0.5101017951965332,
-0.22595706582069397,
-0.153707817196846,
-0.2620052099227905,
0.25238147377967834,
0.10658618062734604,
-0.09887046366930008,
-0.6449659466743469,
0.511603593826294,
0.6388136744499207,
-0.09933938831090927,
0.5119543671607971,
0.4587108790874481,
-0.2089313417673111,
-0.11965746432542801,
0.5219398736953735,
-0.06345221400260925,
0.09608197957277298,
0.28599151968955994,
0.27868402004241943,
-0.4842226505279541,
-0.7223665714263916,
-0.21804854273796082,
0.3251248300075531,
-0.7150510549545288,
-0.2799460291862488,
-0.4829268455505371,
0.05615135654807091,
-0.42307883501052856,
-0.23740988969802856,
-0.5045822262763977,
-0.34256401658058167,
-0.19308285415172577,
-0.22797395288944244,
0.511493444442749,
0.7395610809326172,
0.1180470734834671,
0.5204931497573853,
-0.5099468231201172,
0.38740769028663635,
0.024109233170747757,
0.26475000381469727,
-0.2132580280303955,
-0.43764087557792664,
0.22549700736999512,
-0.01325428020209074,
-0.5953173041343689,
-0.9426450729370117,
0.1418546587228775,
0.0878436267375946,
0.3670974671840668,
0.7968530058860779,
-0.050771571695804596,
0.40330976247787476,
-0.3330846130847931,
0.8595632314682007,
0.3080539405345917,
-0.7835360765457153,
0.5857439637184143,
-0.8491448760032654,
-0.0413166843354702,
0.4287741780281067,
0.4684669077396393,
-0.4560273587703705,
-0.4323853850364685,
-0.4030957818031311,
-0.5646494030952454,
0.5677822232246399,
0.13969556987285614,
0.314287930727005,
-0.006304492708295584,
0.36162495613098145,
0.21360599994659424,
0.0965539813041687,
-1.009252667427063,
0.24365879595279694,
-0.13215015828609467,
-0.2635226845741272,
0.08978331834077835,
0.026392199099063873,
0.02075769752264023,
-0.2986404001712799,
0.5349122285842896,
-0.2296460121870041,
0.12484657019376755,
-0.1125512421131134,
-0.2771916091442108,
-0.08983825892210007,
0.39952266216278076,
0.38278403878211975,
0.2912640869617462,
-0.10754546523094177,
-0.08986011892557144,
0.19434070587158203,
-0.4021152853965759,
0.007133553270250559,
-0.09520884603261948,
-0.3049885630607605,
0.2871118485927582,
0.24277156591415405,
0.9048489332199097,
0.13665957748889923,
-0.3569600582122803,
0.7670553922653198,
0.2875513434410095,
-0.20512865483760834,
-0.3545711636543274,
-0.05849095433950424,
0.18031364679336548,
0.3930019438266754,
-0.01992787979543209,
-0.17477767169475555,
-0.07008213549852371,
-0.6024799346923828,
-0.05143138766288757,
0.7700849771499634,
-0.5452207922935486,
-0.4723877012729645,
0.3760446310043335,
-0.07335805892944336,
-0.24092784523963928,
0.13040202856063843,
0.030462387949228287,
-0.47854653000831604,
0.4201025366783142,
0.4354032278060913,
0.8884745836257935,
-0.07273104041814804,
0.5202880501747131,
0.08719031512737274,
0.25389182567596436,
-0.2725822925567627,
0.1476176530122757,
-0.059408653527498245,
-0.873843789100647,
-0.22836817800998688,
-0.5654823780059814,
-0.6376159191131592,
0.29141953587532043,
-0.5754942297935486,
0.7193217277526855,
-0.7613052129745483,
-0.4797970652580261,
0.24528421461582184,
0.021558241918683052,
-0.5328114032745361,
-0.24808523058891296,
0.5004472732543945,
0.7585477232933044,
-0.8141074776649475,
0.8018236756324768,
1.0738252401351929,
-0.0665651336312294,
-0.34190070629119873,
0.5452383160591125,
0.536041796207428,
-0.8952093124389648,
0.25928446650505066,
0.17084546387195587,
-0.5171110033988953,
-0.12771330773830414,
-1.0513708591461182,
-0.2976519465446472,
1.0068590641021729,
0.596111536026001,
-0.3981969356536865,
0.21246908605098724,
0.06704443693161011,
0.676184356212616,
0.07652919739484787,
-0.1228749081492424,
0.5854420065879822,
0.4591864347457886,
-0.055796246975660324,
-0.6660051345825195,
-0.3156765401363373,
0.2009720653295517,
-0.09332548826932907,
0.3527505695819855,
-0.9128179550170898,
0.7437937259674072,
0.08845414966344833,
-0.12862569093704224,
-0.055021658539772034,
0.7096312046051025,
0.5089017152786255,
0.1726420670747757,
0.5970398783683777,
0.44334155321121216,
0.6465654969215393,
0.05487890914082527,
0.8286901712417603,
-0.03415142744779587,
0.4671436846256256,
0.5860145092010498,
-0.5055356621742249,
1.3701305389404297,
0.5248422622680664,
-0.11758791655302048,
0.5704910159111023,
0.7386062741279602,
0.03227242827415466,
0.1502319723367691,
-0.09938724339008331,
-0.32008811831474304,
-0.46980032324790955,
-0.07888837903738022,
-0.031980276107788086,
0.6409998536109924,
0.527365505695343,
-0.26890361309051514,
-0.44883665442466736,
-0.3210815191268921,
0.48166516423225403,
-0.03581864759325981,
-0.4652182161808014,
0.7949740886688232,
0.2762300670146942,
-0.5169802308082581,
0.4279966354370117,
0.08872745931148529,
0.8350251317024231,
-0.5905534625053406,
0.0975990816950798,
-0.20095257461071014,
0.19935601949691772,
-0.19371265172958374,
-1.1804332733154297,
-0.06785751134157181,
0.47755590081214905,
0.14240868389606476,
-0.16955532133579254,
1.263465404510498,
-0.033324502408504486,
-0.3242339789867401,
0.44171056151390076,
0.4909960925579071,
0.1058305948972702,
-0.09432743489742279,
-0.7632145285606384,
0.22800080478191376,
-0.1888148933649063,
-0.4753638207912445,
0.4260677695274353,
0.524738073348999,
-0.22537128627300262,
0.4547722637653351,
0.7059194445610046,
-0.12101995944976807,
0.024725468829274178,
0.16405285894870758,
0.9450671672821045,
-0.4522305727005005,
-0.30556023120880127,
-1.0108996629714966,
0.21586255729198456,
-0.12035854160785675,
-0.14961974322795868,
0.6590026021003723,
0.2759399712085724,
0.6413280367851257,
0.16562269628047943,
0.8417973518371582,
-0.1038774847984314,
0.32772600650787354,
-0.517668604850769,
0.8561794757843018,
-0.5011548399925232,
0.05102422460913658,
-0.4238511621952057,
-0.8244005441665649,
-0.4508090615272522,
0.69755619764328,
-0.3608039617538452,
-0.21760478615760803,
0.16778366267681122,
0.6742867231369019,
-0.2584715187549591,
-0.016136618331074715,
0.05554713308811188,
0.24133987724781036,
0.6017623543739319,
0.0840844139456749,
0.8833014369010925,
-0.04912719503045082,
0.4863012731075287,
0.11381974071264267,
-0.13092395663261414,
-0.457376092672348,
-1.0699862241744995,
-1.0938791036605835,
-0.39825552701950073,
-0.2375001162290573,
-0.31829774379730225,
-0.017559871077537537,
1.037152886390686,
0.5869247317314148,
-0.8662024140357971,
-0.10750827193260193,
-0.028636319562792778,
0.036851875483989716,
-0.024399887770414352,
-0.18427710235118866,
0.2951991856098175,
-0.3526604473590851,
-0.6705619692802429,
0.34113121032714844,
0.2309558093547821,
0.07101388275623322,
-0.2243739515542984,
-0.2045120745897293,
-0.2696625590324402,
0.2023671269416809,
1.0272105932235718,
0.5230013728141785,
-1.0450117588043213,
-0.4428449273109436,
0.10104889422655106,
-0.08319509774446487,
0.2779500484466553,
0.6418579816818237,
-0.28788575530052185,
0.1931825578212738,
0.5761950612068176,
0.6995039582252502,
0.34692877531051636,
0.27506333589553833,
0.3489954173564911,
-0.890052855014801,
0.09127236157655716,
0.1661420464515686,
0.4550711512565613,
0.42939358949661255,
-0.08427619934082031,
0.3227229416370392,
0.1131429672241211,
-0.347401887178421,
-0.8326314091682434,
0.18601976335048676,
-1.246501088142395,
-0.14387792348861694,
1.5071487426757812,
0.10112839937210083,
-0.036680445075035095,
-0.1460108458995819,
-0.4431954026222229,
0.3228975534439087,
-0.5808188915252686,
0.6923280358314514,
0.9846585988998413,
-0.2875712215900421,
-0.21605584025382996,
-0.689474880695343,
0.36334604024887085,
0.3453353941440582,
-0.5544470548629761,
0.2358218878507614,
0.5593565106391907,
0.3097835183143616,
-0.04673875495791435,
0.7402200102806091,
-0.14470356702804565,
0.06744373589754105,
-0.4760884940624237,
-0.03824043646454811,
0.364836186170578,
-0.1671450138092041,
-0.4622121751308441,
0.029571613296866417,
0.4265907406806946,
-0.18569999933242798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12152v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12152v1
|
FecTek: Enhancing Term Weight in Lexicon-Based Retrieval with Feature Context and Term-level Knowledge
| 2024-04-18T12:58:36 | 2024-04-18T12:58:36 |
Zunran Wang, Zhonghua Li, Wei Shen, Qi Ye, Liqiang Nie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Lexicon-based retrieval has gained siginificant popularity in text retrieval
due to its efficient and robust performance. To further enhance performance of
lexicon-based retrieval, researchers have been diligently incorporating
state-of-the-art methodologies like Neural retrieval and text-level contrastive
learning approaches. Nonetheless, despite the promising outcomes, current
lexicon-based retrieval methods have received limited attention in exploring
the potential benefits of feature context representations and term-level
knowledge guidance. In this paper, we introduce an innovative method by
introducing FEature Context and TErm-level Knowledge modules(FecTek). To
effectively enrich the feature context representations of term weight, the
Feature Context Module (FCM) is introduced, which leverages the power of BERT's
representation to determine dynamic weights for each element in the embedding.
Additionally, we develop a term-level knowledge guidance module (TKGM) for
effectively utilizing term-level knowledge to intelligently guide the modeling
process of term weight. Evaluation of the proposed method on MS Marco benchmark
demonstrates its superiority over the previous state-of-the-art approaches.
|
[
-0.5084251761436462,
-0.6915407180786133,
0.5295829176902771,
0.020406728610396385,
-0.381536602973938,
0.3257695436477661,
-0.08361628651618958,
-0.53657066822052,
0.4786671996116638,
0.5961276292800903,
-0.2833823561668396,
-0.4773903787136078,
-0.30770397186279297,
-0.05146627873182297,
-0.5636441111564636,
0.977715015411377,
0.10278218984603882,
0.045550454407930374,
-0.4169727563858032,
-0.12172700464725494,
-0.4857202470302582,
-0.4984999895095825,
-0.23922041058540344,
-0.5885319113731384,
0.600803792476654,
0.438219279050827,
0.5054203867912292,
0.6071376204490662,
0.45171117782592773,
0.21234029531478882,
-0.5284232497215271,
-0.048298176378011703,
-0.2523796260356903,
0.1268227994441986,
-0.23549562692642212,
-0.43201684951782227,
-0.3746032118797302,
-0.2514057755470276,
0.6743208765983582,
0.8265307545661926,
-0.12793168425559998,
-0.3141111433506012,
0.0957922413945198,
0.552848219871521,
-0.5503965020179749,
-0.0014573965454474092,
-0.804986834526062,
0.16618242859840393,
0.04963770881295204,
-0.30069243907928467,
-0.25801998376846313,
-0.16274398565292358,
0.6170762777328491,
-0.8409833312034607,
0.26173025369644165,
0.19694173336029053,
0.9865814447402954,
0.03358917683362961,
-0.3641281723976135,
-0.42711174488067627,
-0.4705062210559845,
0.8445865511894226,
-0.608292281627655,
0.5106062889099121,
0.31725528836250305,
0.2702837586402893,
-0.043888792395591736,
-0.616062343120575,
-0.13886304199695587,
-0.5503880381584167,
-0.2158404290676117,
-0.13720034062862396,
0.27075284719467163,
0.1841646134853363,
0.19547076523303986,
0.5962782502174377,
-0.06757605820894241,
-0.3139374852180481,
-0.09810299426317215,
-0.35657578706741333,
0.4359220564365387,
-0.12486511468887329,
0.11021564900875092,
-0.38989922404289246,
-0.9071531295776367,
-0.1414884477853775,
-0.4955267906188965,
-0.1942572444677353,
0.2448536455631256,
0.5031957030296326,
0.2015286237001419,
0.348538875579834,
-0.451482355594635,
0.3845745623111725,
-0.01870150677859783,
0.13247789442539215,
0.49475839734077454,
-0.3467561900615692,
0.15014994144439697,
0.17613011598587036,
0.20470423996448517,
-0.02650620974600315,
-0.17651283740997314,
-0.5066721439361572,
-0.39283356070518494,
-0.4359099566936493,
0.5064190626144409,
-0.722171425819397,
-0.17663541436195374,
-0.08275424689054489,
-0.4592643678188324,
-0.46773669123649597,
0.39216184616088867,
-1.1115869283676147,
-0.545649528503418,
-0.1370028257369995,
1.1560208797454834,
-0.7431080937385559,
-0.4978417456150055,
-0.011644618585705757,
-0.37902572751045227,
0.3302387297153473,
0.4545830190181732,
-0.9472079277038574,
0.3280637562274933,
0.799111545085907,
0.8139785528182983,
-0.0876583531498909,
0.22728079557418823,
-0.4181036949157715,
-0.0019847736693918705,
-0.20929192006587982,
0.6451173424720764,
-0.6696246862411499,
-0.19085614383220673,
0.13639697432518005,
-0.19083818793296814,
0.3779561221599579,
-0.51478111743927,
0.2054455280303955,
-0.45997264981269836,
0.14304284751415253,
-0.557571530342102,
-0.5644398927688599,
-0.25501537322998047,
0.2688100337982178,
-0.6244975328445435,
1.5354396104812622,
0.2385418564081192,
-0.8036273121833801,
0.6350516080856323,
-0.5452373623847961,
-0.6082114577293396,
0.27721264958381653,
-0.2249658852815628,
-0.22332346439361572,
0.28631800413131714,
0.16598846018314362,
0.5492634773254395,
0.1487514078617096,
-0.04963849484920502,
-0.25716516375541687,
-0.29888519644737244,
0.024907756596803665,
0.3194761574268341,
0.24458208680152893,
0.2463187426328659,
-0.18229803442955017,
-0.0363217368721962,
-0.4491628408432007,
-0.21136970818042755,
-0.11752587556838989,
-0.320709764957428,
-0.937645673751831,
0.16641861200332642,
-0.25381574034690857,
0.11261920630931854,
0.6343393921852112,
-0.635090708732605,
-0.01542309857904911,
-0.5484963655471802,
0.3310061991214752,
0.447454571723938,
-0.16623929142951965,
0.6069439649581909,
-0.1845691055059433,
0.25576144456863403,
-0.03415524959564209,
-0.12770965695381165,
-0.09796075522899628,
-0.1936490833759308,
-0.6673837304115295,
-0.05187801271677017,
0.6129181981086731,
0.36704596877098083,
-1.2135666608810425,
0.5225675702095032,
-0.19645553827285767,
-0.3243098258972168,
-0.2424914389848709,
0.18109318614006042,
0.20380549132823944,
0.6817317008972168,
0.5690815448760986,
-0.17437274754047394,
-0.373761385679245,
-0.8187697529792786,
-0.1412203162908554,
-0.07644350081682205,
-0.3249248266220093,
0.39660340547561646,
0.5329328179359436,
0.2734644114971161,
0.9517747759819031,
-0.6549205780029297,
-0.2592681348323822,
-0.46215832233428955,
0.3817089796066284,
0.17008456587791443,
0.5387471914291382,
0.5423227548599243,
-0.9489976763725281,
0.03884909301996231,
0.13668781518936157,
-0.21505571901798248,
-0.4076375365257263,
0.03547348454594612,
-0.43231528997421265,
0.20094561576843262,
0.49649158120155334,
-0.09018992632627487,
0.19438618421554565,
0.11648347228765488,
-0.811132550239563,
0.3434009253978729,
-0.341531902551651,
0.19008852541446686,
-1.1901227235794067,
0.3969939053058624,
-0.019581131637096405,
-0.39813828468322754,
-0.5643247365951538,
0.24688324332237244,
0.23767785727977753,
0.138453871011734,
-0.28906309604644775,
0.5841841101646423,
-0.08892664313316345,
-0.2417808622121811,
-0.2566794753074646,
0.356391966342926,
-0.022906705737113953,
0.442232608795166,
0.04000905528664589,
0.6388986110687256,
0.0937974750995636,
-0.6878971457481384,
0.1358044594526291,
0.16383427381515503,
-0.24360860884189606,
0.5811849236488342,
-0.27820664644241333,
-0.27637094259262085,
-0.012829970568418503,
-0.3517043888568878,
-1.063922643661499,
0.13019555807113647,
-0.05427801236510277,
-0.5458804368972778,
0.36923277378082275,
0.23136292397975922,
-0.5426610112190247,
-0.24549730122089386,
-0.7108410000801086,
-0.007848713546991348,
0.31080198287963867,
-0.5108888745307922,
0.7285228967666626,
0.2991870045661926,
-0.08097578585147858,
-0.8591461181640625,
-0.7261419296264648,
-0.19502310454845428,
-0.2513139843940735,
-0.17975759506225586,
0.8026683330535889,
0.09220518916845322,
0.1598365604877472,
0.029156425967812538,
-0.8453430533409119,
0.05522788316011429,
0.3369137644767761,
-0.2242523729801178,
0.030469948425889015,
0.05406789481639862,
0.555870771408081,
0.10916823148727417,
-0.009433935396373272,
-0.05324013531208038,
-0.23271948099136353,
0.6202882528305054,
0.07834272086620331,
0.486990749835968,
0.2026003897190094,
0.298360139131546,
0.15625382959842682,
-0.06335776299238205,
0.6316291689872742,
0.7566585540771484,
-0.6104184985160828,
-0.3066185414791107,
-0.6146863698959351,
-0.41369208693504333,
-0.4440286457538605,
0.4117404818534851,
-0.27709466218948364,
-1.2613834142684937,
0.7796170711517334,
-0.2384606897830963,
-0.08779724687337875,
0.47025397419929504,
0.2891367971897125,
-0.19271746277809143,
0.8684492707252502,
1.0140105485916138,
-0.04860522225499153,
0.932966411113739,
-0.19080917537212372,
-0.16784153878688812,
-0.9262484908103943,
-0.5311249494552612,
-0.6286397576332092,
-0.4702520966529846,
-0.4923573434352875,
-0.21886251866817474,
0.30775755643844604,
0.2946532964706421,
-0.17582572996616364,
0.6333094239234924,
-0.37401729822158813,
0.05908613279461861,
0.44380271434783936,
0.5924801826477051,
0.2706359624862671,
0.1453368216753006,
-0.8910472989082336,
0.07525087893009186,
-0.7162013649940491,
-0.16019542515277863,
0.9322012662887573,
0.3737427890300751,
0.6040229201316833,
-0.06526945531368256,
0.5987149477005005,
0.6181351542472839,
0.1763160228729248,
-0.9663379788398743,
0.6999416947364807,
-0.364956259727478,
-0.6187533736228943,
-0.2347785085439682,
-0.7683748006820679,
-0.5687444806098938,
0.3611338138580322,
-0.6081586480140686,
-0.8077495098114014,
0.159131720662117,
0.09657314419746399,
-0.4171721339225769,
0.1296994835138321,
-0.4118651747703552,
0.7108191847801208,
-0.17965228855609894,
-0.27502360939979553,
-0.5175432562828064,
-0.49945762753486633,
-0.13700687885284424,
-0.013572102412581444,
-0.04148387163877487,
-0.20761920511722565,
-0.7156656980514526,
0.7806551456451416,
-0.6066753268241882,
0.33928176760673523,
-0.3522418737411499,
-0.33408471941947937,
-0.07939145714044571,
-0.08591402322053909,
0.1891663819551468,
0.16842804849147797,
-0.224273219704628,
0.10426726192235947,
0.0058471993543207645,
-0.21576330065727234,
-0.5981210470199585,
0.5936452746391296,
-0.4745359718799591,
-0.5013368129730225,
-0.15995825827121735,
-0.5621917843818665,
-0.18806907534599304,
0.3966809809207916,
-0.1563529372215271,
0.4180980920791626,
-0.02861158922314644,
0.5079108476638794,
0.9892160296440125,
-0.5471937656402588,
0.32169321179389954,
0.3668062388896942,
-0.27575188875198364,
-0.7945943474769592,
0.9370744824409485,
0.09689655154943466,
0.16605404019355774,
1.0914173126220703,
0.49539685249328613,
-0.1761019080877304,
-0.4321684241294861,
0.040464259684085846,
0.08376987278461456,
-0.4014027416706085,
-0.5891407132148743,
-0.6246554851531982,
-0.05702763795852661,
-0.04953080788254738,
-0.20984259247779846,
-0.12236707657575607,
-0.7511950731277466,
-0.002804721239954233,
0.03175851330161095,
0.585984468460083,
0.3981049656867981,
0.04524704068899155,
0.5948785543441772,
-0.38373294472694397,
0.2121456414461136,
0.37367919087409973,
0.6076174378395081,
0.006641819141805172,
-0.1898541897535324,
-0.6082289814949036,
-0.21965479850769043,
-0.3185347318649292,
-0.7572892904281616,
0.27326148748397827,
0.12577421963214874,
0.555722177028656,
0.37436071038246155,
0.14250193536281586,
0.3084937632083893,
-0.21048183739185333,
0.7136978507041931,
-0.1343708336353302,
-1.1278184652328491,
0.8377141356468201,
-0.2945798635482788,
0.4233866333961487,
0.5723026990890503,
0.2642378807067871,
-0.4766750633716583,
-0.5150201320648193,
-0.5245940089225769,
-1.095549464225769,
0.8967686295509338,
0.31452396512031555,
0.238377183675766,
0.25890153646469116,
0.6391335725784302,
0.20662447810173035,
0.6418687105178833,
-0.4132980406284332,
0.09913217276334763,
-0.22615456581115723,
-0.47703200578689575,
0.4663998484611511,
-0.2402442842721939,
0.2205868810415268,
-0.3774806261062622,
0.6930419206619263,
-0.36930760741233826,
0.618608832359314,
0.40300798416137695,
-0.236099511384964,
0.01687755435705185,
0.16848021745681763,
0.4867412745952606,
0.46128830313682556,
-0.5801330804824829,
0.07608646899461746,
0.6007691621780396,
-0.6395437717437744,
-0.2925790846347809,
0.46679413318634033,
-0.12758709490299225,
0.05756437033414841,
0.28139427304267883,
0.4648136794567108,
0.7927367687225342,
-0.4536716639995575,
0.28938597440719604,
0.24273262917995453,
-0.3212137520313263,
-0.10316252708435059,
0.12486974149942398,
-0.11534012109041214,
0.3300510048866272,
0.8164077997207642,
-0.526631772518158,
0.3202238082885742,
-0.4151952564716339,
0.608884871006012,
0.5318450927734375,
-0.32384708523750305,
-0.05839241296052933,
0.537261426448822,
0.3689134418964386,
0.3295702338218689,
0.2518887221813202,
0.17149198055267334,
-0.7412571310997009,
0.6551240086555481,
0.15354323387145996,
0.6304349303245544,
-0.3772953450679779,
0.18856024742126465,
0.32504940032958984,
0.3155296742916107,
-0.12121827155351639,
0.738855242729187,
-0.5347291231155396,
-0.7621597647666931,
-0.27908626198768616,
-0.8470394015312195,
-0.34399762749671936,
0.11556702852249146,
-0.4842672049999237,
0.43507444858551025,
-0.6330513954162598,
-0.23517045378684998,
-0.1586938053369522,
0.6467571258544922,
-0.37825557589530945,
0.018854942172765732,
0.3277992904186249,
1.3110551834106445,
-0.3709053695201874,
0.8089070320129395,
1.0669459104537964,
-0.4021174907684326,
-0.4951035678386688,
-0.0560842826962471,
-0.26252201199531555,
-0.5792357325553894,
0.4122155010700226,
0.38983702659606934,
0.06824195384979248,
-0.03882380202412605,
-0.4187847077846527,
-0.8782364726066589,
1.3915921449661255,
0.14663700759410858,
-0.29096898436546326,
-0.20114153623580933,
0.27640965580940247,
0.5534203052520752,
-0.5521857738494873,
0.1796058863401413,
0.286180317401886,
0.423780232667923,
0.25167086720466614,
-0.7476323843002319,
0.30907005071640015,
0.0845879390835762,
0.48945438861846924,
0.6230044364929199,
-0.4837416112422943,
0.5861099362373352,
0.19158825278282166,
0.0011162023292854428,
0.30810728669166565,
0.8801779747009277,
-0.18954825401306152,
0.11869777739048004,
0.7688417434692383,
0.7223929762840271,
0.48604750633239746,
-0.25158193707466125,
0.5800313353538513,
-0.46580269932746887,
0.6437464356422424,
0.5443752408027649,
0.11115574836730957,
0.9899152517318726,
0.4557099938392639,
0.2076566219329834,
0.7618305087089539,
0.3842204511165619,
0.009021248668432236,
0.7731142640113831,
0.14060033857822418,
-0.297611802816391,
-0.5410885810852051,
-0.19781535863876343,
-0.20854710042476654,
0.41482657194137573,
0.7684872150421143,
-0.6483259797096252,
-0.4981331527233124,
0.13015374541282654,
0.06560801714658737,
-0.11041159182786942,
-0.6985563635826111,
0.8269601464271545,
0.11357724666595459,
-0.14678964018821716,
0.3487836420536041,
-0.18989747762680054,
1.083033800125122,
-0.8028085827827454,
-0.28247982263565063,
-0.22325274348258972,
0.11418121308088303,
-0.18734081089496613,
-0.743672251701355,
0.3223811388015747,
-0.22348766028881073,
0.0167442224919796,
-0.3537653088569641,
1.0191326141357422,
-0.7315296530723572,
-0.2904622554779053,
0.3728671967983246,
0.40990492701530457,
-0.23272116482257843,
-0.06380613148212433,
-0.7287911176681519,
-0.21718072891235352,
-0.36972111463546753,
-0.19224344193935394,
0.0949016883969307,
0.4780448079109192,
0.15372957289218903,
0.6565733551979065,
0.21337445080280304,
0.013370849192142487,
-0.5040313601493835,
-0.16319520771503448,
0.9662252068519592,
-0.8317973613739014,
-0.5689166784286499,
-0.5597620606422424,
0.41917747259140015,
-0.2504032552242279,
-0.11863178759813309,
0.3853612542152405,
0.30416786670684814,
1.018308401107788,
0.10193963348865509,
0.32232794165611267,
-0.4026859998703003,
0.40484118461608887,
-0.5469674468040466,
1.0758084058761597,
-0.9221851229667664,
0.17182131111621857,
-0.6054881811141968,
-0.8760983943939209,
-0.2988632321357727,
0.6870055794715881,
-0.08150112628936768,
0.12977571785449982,
0.7081928849220276,
0.6829702258110046,
0.13759854435920715,
0.06605850905179977,
0.2694922685623169,
0.1651996523141861,
-0.06743153929710388,
0.5744903087615967,
0.4953096807003021,
-0.30094197392463684,
0.6616089940071106,
-0.37370535731315613,
-0.25182002782821655,
-0.4683707356452942,
-1.025252103805542,
-0.8389872312545776,
-0.7109205722808838,
-0.21135453879833221,
0.03261655196547508,
0.12574602663516998,
1.036110758781433,
0.7082192897796631,
-0.7750012874603271,
-0.13376200199127197,
0.040221232920885086,
0.3430284261703491,
-0.4177058935165405,
-0.3194381892681122,
0.13127323985099792,
-0.6221569180488586,
-0.3401031196117401,
0.08870099484920502,
0.01921979710459709,
-0.22664418816566467,
-0.32965657114982605,
0.1013777107000351,
-0.5055446028709412,
-0.032029736787080765,
0.86042320728302,
-0.08994816243648529,
-0.42283114790916443,
-0.7131924629211426,
-0.021022005006670952,
0.021130718290805817,
0.024851853027939796,
0.9283680319786072,
-1.3080592155456543,
0.31501829624176025,
0.9468724727630615,
0.7822909951210022,
0.10724993795156479,
-0.10633223503828049,
0.8863533139228821,
-1.0065113306045532,
-0.1325841099023819,
0.200120210647583,
0.3030547499656677,
0.2551760673522949,
-0.5562870502471924,
0.6468756198883057,
0.38898512721061707,
-0.13630884885787964,
-0.5126427412033081,
-0.09680057317018509,
-0.9879846572875977,
-0.4051834046840668,
0.8220432996749878,
0.07626205682754517,
-0.05464202165603638,
0.14789648354053497,
-0.0756978690624237,
0.3870278596878052,
-0.7443036437034607,
0.8971553444862366,
0.9522051811218262,
-0.00653324369341135,
-0.2488127201795578,
-0.6522442698478699,
0.5730348825454712,
0.5477811694145203,
-0.6877579689025879,
-0.08551015704870224,
0.2680283784866333,
0.2547239363193512,
0.2868720293045044,
-0.10773083567619324,
-0.22662745416164398,
0.08600406348705292,
-0.3501582741737366,
0.23619599640369415,
-0.06360829621553421,
-0.29339534044265747,
-0.31463590264320374,
0.17190353572368622,
-0.14996100962162018,
0.07360165566205978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12150v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12150v1
|
Aligning language models with human preferences
| 2024-04-18T12:55:18 | 2024-04-18T12:55:18 |
Tomasz Korbak
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) trained on vast quantities of text data can acquire
sophisticated skills such as generating summaries, answering questions or
generating code. However, they also manifest behaviors that violate human
preferences, e.g., they can generate offensive content, falsehoods or
perpetuate social biases. In this thesis, I explore several approaches to
aligning LMs with human preferences. First, I argue that aligning LMs can be
seen as Bayesian inference: conditioning a prior (base, pretrained LM) on
evidence about human preferences (Chapter 2). Conditioning on human preferences
can be implemented in numerous ways. In Chapter 3, I investigate the relation
between two approaches to finetuning pretrained LMs using feedback given by a
scoring function: reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) and
distribution matching. I show that RLHF can be seen as a special case of
distribution matching but distributional matching is strictly more general. In
chapter 4, I show how to extend the distribution matching to conditional
language models. Finally, in chapter 5 I explore a different root: conditioning
an LM on human preferences already during pretraining. I show that involving
human feedback from the very start tends to be more effective than using it
only during supervised finetuning. Overall, these results highlight the room
for alignment techniques different from and complementary to RLHF.
|
[
-0.3227289915084839,
-0.6108890771865845,
0.5421098470687866,
-0.013592351227998734,
0.11523177474737167,
-0.19652920961380005,
-0.5884140729904175,
-0.10749660432338715,
-0.04865404590964317,
0.8539242744445801,
-0.5246188044548035,
-0.31979432702064514,
-0.27114227414131165,
-0.31639954447746277,
-0.03187568858265877,
1.0439019203186035,
0.02547454833984375,
0.17824110388755798,
-0.12938950955867767,
-0.34433040022850037,
-0.4200074076652527,
-0.8754583597183228,
-0.7005488872528076,
-0.6545416712760925,
0.6523543000221252,
0.4135994613170624,
1.1535022258758545,
0.6454288363456726,
0.44680118560791016,
0.2955568730831146,
0.3003937005996704,
-0.07628417015075684,
-0.4820460379123688,
0.1786501407623291,
-0.5197680592536926,
-0.4285863935947418,
-0.16442987322807312,
0.08443886041641235,
0.5196131467819214,
0.9428194761276245,
-0.3836148679256439,
-0.10773705691099167,
0.1343408077955246,
0.8898399472236633,
-0.7683011293411255,
-0.08868110179901123,
-0.3200743496417999,
-0.036698125302791595,
-0.01453219261020422,
-0.12864531576633453,
-0.5071127414703369,
-0.560096025466919,
0.4193646013736725,
-0.4933292269706726,
0.21569180488586426,
0.11512909084558487,
0.980991780757904,
0.46375200152397156,
-0.5180461406707764,
-0.21321465075016022,
-0.7372352480888367,
1.063225269317627,
-0.8147521018981934,
0.45308104157447815,
0.7035707831382751,
0.29838958382606506,
-0.24014931917190552,
-0.12024449557065964,
-0.5617062449455261,
-0.25321027636528015,
-0.30590614676475525,
-0.009695738554000854,
0.1887447088956833,
0.32323288917541504,
0.2761687934398651,
0.18179823458194733,
-0.49227139353752136,
0.4036942720413208,
-0.15446752309799194,
-0.0757642537355423,
0.8007262349128723,
0.055294256657361984,
0.2543160319328308,
0.020233074203133583,
-0.20097333192825317,
-0.4974335730075836,
-0.6702507734298706,
0.0886533185839653,
0.8385673761367798,
0.4990108609199524,
0.06852150708436966,
0.6450577974319458,
-0.24923045933246613,
0.8793429136276245,
0.2424631416797638,
-0.16949020326137543,
0.16107311844825745,
-0.10024071484804153,
-0.11359377205371857,
0.10201983898878098,
0.75384122133255,
0.6209814548492432,
0.729101836681366,
0.13192281126976013,
-0.3336482346057892,
0.456810861825943,
0.3194194436073303,
-0.3371933698654175,
-0.20453408360481262,
0.07764436304569244,
-0.5253915786743164,
-0.2977105975151062,
-0.000733605062123388,
-0.5562117695808411,
-0.5437984466552734,
-0.6752877831459045,
0.6792805194854736,
-0.17624278366565704,
-0.29883819818496704,
0.3515295684337616,
-0.05330986529588699,
0.3448120355606079,
0.15135857462882996,
-1.534027338027954,
0.5738716125488281,
0.7227529883384705,
0.415429949760437,
-0.10285290330648422,
-0.22411547601222992,
-0.40677574276924133,
0.22468334436416626,
-0.34020158648490906,
0.58885657787323,
-0.4507080018520355,
-0.08666325360536575,
0.30942803621292114,
-0.06965858489274979,
0.08604590594768524,
-0.5931907892227173,
0.6438900828361511,
-0.4454970955848694,
0.5144416689872742,
-0.3737221956253052,
-0.7587780952453613,
-0.07144749164581299,
-0.009373790584504604,
-0.6356184482574463,
0.8287245631217957,
0.16674445569515228,
-0.7965898513793945,
0.28410226106643677,
-0.46275612711906433,
-0.3739299178123474,
-0.36269575357437134,
-0.04795456677675247,
-0.2642815411090851,
-0.06778602302074432,
0.06486263126134872,
0.41098111867904663,
0.10922520607709885,
0.33579322695732117,
-0.6367471218109131,
-0.19522757828235626,
0.402320921421051,
-0.25473088026046753,
0.5563293695449829,
0.5266624093055725,
-0.19623245298862457,
0.3404696583747864,
-0.39520230889320374,
-0.06583024561405182,
-0.05870041996240616,
-0.24156975746154785,
-0.48161160945892334,
0.44869187474250793,
-0.08884449303150177,
-0.0963170975446701,
0.16832992434501648,
-0.17452803254127502,
0.2147686630487442,
-0.5617448091506958,
0.37062811851501465,
0.7852076888084412,
-0.2698037624359131,
0.9256884455680847,
-0.6342894434928894,
0.3783714771270752,
-0.12365368008613586,
0.18838949501514435,
0.19330744445323944,
-0.0030858314130455256,
-0.6430352926254272,
0.09044887870550156,
0.30479446053504944,
0.643902063369751,
-0.3810901939868927,
0.4792419373989105,
-0.06302429735660553,
-0.16240862011909485,
-0.7756052017211914,
0.12553703784942627,
0.4332779049873352,
0.39694711565971375,
0.23863716423511505,
-0.3798764944076538,
-0.6573017239570618,
-1.03534996509552,
-0.27580755949020386,
-0.2179565727710724,
-0.00616894755512476,
0.17452692985534668,
-0.08858221024274826,
-0.08788750320672989,
1.0036531686782837,
-0.5524436831474304,
0.10321827232837677,
-0.244872584939003,
-0.08832927793264389,
0.22828488051891327,
0.6452087163925171,
0.6372166275978088,
-0.6721875071525574,
-0.530955970287323,
0.08491725474596024,
-0.3411419987678528,
-0.40261492133140564,
0.14638899266719818,
-0.17759545147418976,
0.3490138053894043,
0.3135257065296173,
-0.35362961888313293,
0.2843838632106781,
0.6765439510345459,
-0.23107266426086426,
0.47226572036743164,
-0.2560831904411316,
0.21828527748584747,
-0.978375256061554,
-0.2666950225830078,
0.24887330830097198,
-0.44387656450271606,
-0.7411770224571228,
-0.048567626625299454,
-0.22233620285987854,
0.15654750168323517,
-0.22631430625915527,
0.8098955750465393,
-0.3674609661102295,
-0.013151012361049652,
-0.4349142909049988,
0.26620495319366455,
-0.13891589641571045,
0.4026787281036377,
0.44877660274505615,
0.40554794669151306,
0.3199909031391144,
-0.6053695678710938,
0.24896880984306335,
0.11854804307222366,
-0.2130616158246994,
0.6116502285003662,
-0.5467664003372192,
0.008392504416406155,
-0.3052600920200348,
0.12126406282186508,
-0.875709056854248,
-0.2032056748867035,
0.4401837885379791,
-0.4564576745033264,
0.17741966247558594,
-0.24230393767356873,
-0.16447874903678894,
0.02902069501578808,
-0.2711522877216339,
0.25606727600097656,
0.6789467334747314,
-0.5274799466133118,
0.2877919375896454,
0.4904532730579376,
-0.20822535455226898,
-0.8289811611175537,
-0.3716335892677307,
-0.4854535758495331,
-0.48821887373924255,
-0.31323549151420593,
0.33631375432014465,
-0.2632044553756714,
-0.5446690320968628,
-0.056322116404771805,
0.03992434963583946,
-0.09157026559114456,
0.1345241516828537,
0.23050552606582642,
0.38182583451271057,
-0.23304344713687897,
0.06311315298080444,
-0.10642117261886597,
-0.1616538166999817,
-0.3153025209903717,
-0.3623441159725189,
0.47010576725006104,
0.017175326123833656,
-0.3801363706588745,
-0.2833194136619568,
0.4149378836154938,
0.10811101645231247,
0.11178544908761978,
0.7507929801940918,
0.4291498363018036,
-0.32658204436302185,
0.026331309229135513,
-0.8197731375694275,
-0.40762174129486084,
-0.4447377324104309,
0.18828976154327393,
-0.1857266128063202,
-0.9088788628578186,
0.07027383148670197,
0.2771744430065155,
0.04701743647456169,
0.21717767417430878,
0.7576667070388794,
-0.2903014123439789,
1.3275134563446045,
0.7876004576683044,
-0.31458187103271484,
0.8493033647537231,
0.22440263628959656,
0.22019943594932556,
-0.5617133975028992,
0.20572136342525482,
-0.6989931464195251,
-0.3562026619911194,
-0.7102000117301941,
-0.0017350357957184315,
-0.26538556814193726,
0.44734987616539,
-0.5290138125419617,
0.37204527854919434,
-0.3164057433605194,
0.6166383624076843,
0.6857044696807861,
0.10132502019405365,
-0.03170336037874222,
-0.16441258788108826,
-0.17039941251277924,
0.023862596601247787,
-0.7578064799308777,
-0.8613961935043335,
0.983366072177887,
0.40086957812309265,
0.9546627998352051,
0.2746190130710602,
0.6804550886154175,
0.05806603655219078,
0.515813946723938,
-0.6402656435966492,
0.21106207370758057,
-0.15042118728160858,
-0.7413991689682007,
-0.5345998406410217,
-0.34970903396606445,
-1.0125893354415894,
0.19455525279045105,
-0.42190036177635193,
-0.8895350694656372,
0.09438438713550568,
0.5924060344696045,
-0.3683573007583618,
-0.02429749071598053,
-1.1268519163131714,
0.9960876703262329,
-0.39829137921333313,
-0.3821706473827362,
-0.2433614432811737,
-0.9278905987739563,
0.30460721254348755,
0.27184560894966125,
0.3378300666809082,
-0.29750165343284607,
0.2049112170934677,
0.5795321464538574,
-0.24472010135650635,
0.8725954294204712,
-0.21783384680747986,
-0.11722313612699509,
-0.13069140911102295,
-0.11981888860464096,
0.14983659982681274,
-0.0969853550195694,
-0.1695704311132431,
-0.41076794266700745,
0.5985352396965027,
-0.5165504813194275,
-0.7262604832649231,
0.5349395275115967,
-0.9291723966598511,
-0.7570905685424805,
-0.30437031388282776,
-0.5758591294288635,
-0.3272366523742676,
0.19502854347229004,
0.13050693273544312,
0.1332974135875702,
-0.26607611775398254,
-0.14180687069892883,
0.7772860527038574,
-0.18431301414966583,
0.21560272574424744,
0.5587866902351379,
-0.5359621047973633,
-0.4261555075645447,
0.7582530975341797,
-0.24263975024223328,
0.512415885925293,
0.5605697631835938,
0.3262593150138855,
-0.550605297088623,
-0.21332862973213196,
-0.04157305508852005,
0.3255234658718109,
-0.6550227999687195,
0.0008354769088327885,
-0.2727268934249878,
-0.04725337773561478,
-0.6037573218345642,
-0.24075904488563538,
-0.1390993595123291,
-0.33886951208114624,
-0.29629555344581604,
-0.021455207839608192,
0.10073961317539215,
0.7009209394454956,
-0.21486565470695496,
0.6912320256233215,
-0.6674718856811523,
0.1548169106245041,
0.31714412569999695,
0.4157368838787079,
-0.05401184409856796,
-0.5090120434761047,
-0.12196599692106247,
0.24207745492458344,
-0.2394944578409195,
-0.9005162119865417,
0.24464328587055206,
-0.02552732080221176,
0.7304363250732422,
0.6061004400253296,
0.13538257777690887,
0.5318597555160522,
-0.4309959411621094,
0.49868738651275635,
0.2212660163640976,
-0.890256941318512,
0.4579833447933197,
-0.2811732590198517,
-0.13877838850021362,
0.6830538511276245,
0.7256947755813599,
-0.8121299743652344,
-0.08283045887947083,
-0.6113361120223999,
-0.3484736680984497,
0.4778842628002167,
-0.11322838813066483,
0.27920711040496826,
-0.03792756423354149,
0.556381344795227,
0.10536987334489822,
0.16370324790477753,
-0.8114850521087646,
-0.12990741431713104,
-0.23395739495754242,
-0.7521528601646423,
-0.45231032371520996,
-0.11928147077560425,
-0.27298298478126526,
-0.20957164466381073,
0.6828631162643433,
-0.1841334104537964,
-0.11978776752948761,
-0.13454346358776093,
-0.30819958448410034,
-0.0130606135353446,
0.38677823543548584,
0.717562735080719,
0.7020682692527771,
-0.29159069061279297,
0.22164969146251678,
-0.056632257997989655,
0.15100742876529694,
0.4203266203403473,
-0.09239989519119263,
-0.1190844252705574,
-0.3388592600822449,
0.13586705923080444,
0.91817706823349,
0.2092849463224411,
-0.5015090107917786,
0.47887641191482544,
-0.04637832194566727,
-0.07056639343500137,
0.05188477784395218,
0.30879122018814087,
0.24654324352741241,
0.23121576011180878,
-0.13821835815906525,
-0.20948731899261475,
-0.15365386009216309,
-0.7552306056022644,
0.06454815715551376,
0.7046793699264526,
-0.5667393803596497,
-0.2922300696372986,
0.4331668019294739,
-0.04321407526731491,
-0.519389808177948,
0.43074434995651245,
0.06330982595682144,
-0.5871883630752563,
0.12759065628051758,
0.5582152009010315,
0.5870925188064575,
-0.5061250329017639,
0.2007560282945633,
0.25242099165916443,
0.025551414117217064,
-0.3834696114063263,
0.13120125234127045,
-0.22018533945083618,
-1.2648593187332153,
-0.47121286392211914,
-0.6962242722511292,
-0.4909745156764984,
-0.16129323840141296,
-0.7967320680618286,
0.39070218801498413,
-0.21738536655902863,
-0.3008904755115509,
0.09622542560100555,
0.027368953451514244,
-0.6267902255058289,
0.17735931277275085,
0.1669108122587204,
0.45777469873428345,
-1.099390983581543,
1.0203447341918945,
0.6893870234489441,
-0.5811327695846558,
-0.9115344285964966,
-0.13817988336086273,
0.0030056904070079327,
-0.8117164373397827,
0.49756941199302673,
-0.20847176015377045,
0.13478387892246246,
0.12091382592916489,
-0.48593688011169434,
-0.7264070510864258,
0.4642668664455414,
0.5298103094100952,
-0.5609882473945618,
0.04139517992734909,
-0.06934525072574615,
0.46786317229270935,
-0.3756050169467926,
0.2829870581626892,
0.9067889451980591,
0.4176243543624878,
-0.15194879472255707,
-0.776533305644989,
-0.12241145968437195,
0.01948145590722561,
0.014155245386064053,
0.45139506459236145,
-0.39569956064224243,
0.41146090626716614,
-0.23030535876750946,
-0.08721818774938583,
0.13278056681156158,
0.5101044178009033,
0.28714779019355774,
-0.053903717547655106,
0.6732645630836487,
0.7261717915534973,
0.636328935623169,
-0.058957990258932114,
0.8186965584754944,
-0.15298953652381897,
0.3827015161514282,
1.0435073375701904,
-0.4304913580417633,
0.949439287185669,
0.5795773267745972,
-0.3569158911705017,
0.43925848603248596,
0.974015474319458,
0.2850343585014343,
0.6795727014541626,
0.38196882605552673,
-0.08408541977405548,
-0.19455589354038239,
-0.11565163731575012,
-0.2676528990268707,
0.04277431219816208,
0.23518691956996918,
-0.06326507031917572,
0.009045489132404327,
-0.11378400027751923,
-0.08958325535058975,
0.36541861295700073,
-0.04233646020293236,
1.016510009765625,
0.046079427003860474,
-1.121989369392395,
0.3556993305683136,
-0.013656655326485634,
0.6085821986198425,
-0.5507875680923462,
0.1711139678955078,
-0.289987176656723,
0.23757843673229218,
-0.29019713401794434,
-0.8426445126533508,
0.3620426654815674,
-0.3315275013446808,
-0.4910282492637634,
-0.3014086186885834,
0.62143874168396,
-0.7624881267547607,
-0.09465061128139496,
0.15558400750160217,
0.2184186577796936,
0.011515609920024872,
0.3007485568523407,
-0.5806952118873596,
-0.02245386317372322,
-0.02401243895292282,
-0.07789134979248047,
0.5723776817321777,
0.25151973962783813,
-0.07999604195356369,
0.5427474975585938,
0.6620386242866516,
0.3032718598842621,
-0.06420321762561798,
0.505690336227417,
0.32741615176200867,
-0.6654704213142395,
-0.37705719470977783,
-0.9588314890861511,
0.24279563128948212,
0.11309849470853806,
-0.13790389895439148,
0.4245186746120453,
0.16848652064800262,
0.9154865741729736,
-0.030758202075958252,
0.7190228700637817,
0.3008069694042206,
0.5560266375541687,
-0.6400696039199829,
0.38044846057891846,
-0.29151999950408936,
0.21570242941379547,
-0.37558501958847046,
-1.092332124710083,
-0.22220538556575775,
0.8870551586151123,
-0.4873369634151459,
0.04646408185362816,
0.5430779457092285,
0.8824219703674316,
0.008481788448989391,
-0.20570026338100433,
0.2235589474439621,
-0.26586484909057617,
0.16326844692230225,
0.461777001619339,
1.0928924083709717,
-0.03932616859674454,
0.10045482963323593,
-0.30991166830062866,
-0.353868693113327,
-0.16487714648246765,
-1.0127068758010864,
-0.66420978307724,
-0.6269957423210144,
-0.28224754333496094,
-0.3169857859611511,
0.08908232301473618,
1.2204233407974243,
0.8217933773994446,
-0.9007444381713867,
-0.6711524128913879,
0.1372070610523224,
0.40500861406326294,
-0.21311552822589874,
-0.22486050426959991,
0.17094139754772186,
-0.5420337319374084,
-0.6808149218559265,
0.020587515085935593,
0.11392781883478165,
0.24024896323680878,
-0.2800877094268799,
-0.42301738262176514,
-0.20860789716243744,
0.13743644952774048,
0.4575868248939514,
0.37441587448120117,
-0.8930228352546692,
-0.6711633801460266,
-0.18535690009593964,
-0.2668543756008148,
0.06243264302611351,
0.8369929790496826,
-0.6007177233695984,
0.18452557921409607,
0.6500247120857239,
0.6822339296340942,
0.29475826025009155,
0.21924541890621185,
0.9582923054695129,
-0.5953642725944519,
0.08549830317497253,
0.06315148621797562,
0.43619969487190247,
0.46021702885627747,
-0.10522229224443436,
0.34208551049232483,
-0.061275895684957504,
-0.8585272431373596,
-0.8504628539085388,
0.45946696400642395,
-0.8525458574295044,
-0.19690151512622833,
0.9528458118438721,
0.10982393473386765,
-0.08553998917341232,
0.029872829094529152,
-0.290154367685318,
0.39447879791259766,
-0.13095325231552124,
0.6514683365821838,
0.9519909620285034,
-0.04125997796654701,
-0.18363651633262634,
-0.5611026287078857,
0.7888081073760986,
0.7372962236404419,
-0.6226961016654968,
0.06636620312929153,
0.42658016085624695,
0.4752635955810547,
-0.07955598831176758,
0.7387388348579407,
0.2773389518260956,
0.10203076899051666,
-0.5021910667419434,
0.19776342809200287,
0.6330446004867554,
0.00908038578927517,
-0.4674883782863617,
-0.22348986566066742,
0.4953455924987793,
-0.125421941280365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12145v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12145v1
|
From Form(s) to Meaning: Probing the Semantic Depths of Language Models Using Multisense Consistency
| 2024-04-18T12:48:17 | 2024-04-18T12:48:17 |
Xenia Ohmer, Elia Bruni, Dieuwke Hupkes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The staggering pace with which the capabilities of large language models
(LLMs) are increasing, as measured by a range of commonly used natural language
understanding (NLU) benchmarks, raises many questions regarding what
"understanding" means for a language model and how it compares to human
understanding. This is especially true since many LLMs are exclusively trained
on text, casting doubt on whether their stellar benchmark performances are
reflective of a true understanding of the problems represented by these
benchmarks, or whether LLMs simply excel at uttering textual forms that
correlate with what someone who understands the problem would say. In this
philosophically inspired work, we aim to create some separation between form
and meaning, with a series of tests that leverage the idea that world
understanding should be consistent across presentational modes - inspired by
Fregean senses - of the same meaning. Specifically, we focus on consistency
across languages as well as paraphrases. Taking GPT-3.5 as our object of study,
we evaluate multisense consistency across five different languages and various
tasks. We start the evaluation in a controlled setting, asking the model for
simple facts, and then proceed with an evaluation on four popular NLU
benchmarks. We find that the model's multisense consistency is lacking and run
several follow-up analyses to verify that this lack of consistency is due to a
sense-dependent task understanding. We conclude that, in this aspect, the
understanding of LLMs is still quite far from being consistent and human-like,
and deliberate on how this impacts their utility in the context of learning
about human language and understanding.
|
[
-0.2067209780216217,
-0.6928216814994812,
0.8550011515617371,
0.3324252963066101,
-0.2680864930152893,
-0.06914324313402176,
-0.30089953541755676,
-0.4053213596343994,
-0.107974573969841,
0.327770471572876,
-0.5147202610969543,
-0.23339039087295532,
-1.1390150785446167,
0.19800952076911926,
-0.4221997559070587,
0.8969415426254272,
-0.2266584038734436,
-0.016713516786694527,
-0.3841424286365509,
-0.3018558621406555,
-0.24419941008090973,
-0.2111930251121521,
-0.5150023102760315,
-0.30268600583076477,
0.72755366563797,
0.03643018379807472,
0.8256845474243164,
0.6345124840736389,
0.3871109187602997,
0.2581932544708252,
-0.23035947978496552,
-0.01642058789730072,
-0.6023596525192261,
0.41939225792884827,
-0.09471365809440613,
-0.5669885873794556,
-0.01970158889889717,
0.240348219871521,
0.9647229313850403,
1.0907775163650513,
-0.06528158485889435,
-0.06207408383488655,
0.3147381544113159,
0.5141300559043884,
-0.6708155870437622,
0.26066771149635315,
-0.7679430842399597,
-0.22971178591251373,
-0.12990862131118774,
0.1770271211862564,
-0.4146375060081482,
-0.020633021369576454,
0.05082711577415466,
-0.47708332538604736,
0.330672949552536,
-0.16645987331867218,
1.1126047372817993,
0.1732153445482254,
-0.5407025814056396,
-0.23912738263607025,
-0.438732385635376,
0.8274358510971069,
-0.7044458985328674,
0.9390160441398621,
0.424318790435791,
0.2817259132862091,
-0.09101078659296036,
-0.5900307297706604,
-0.7522464394569397,
-0.5007057785987854,
-0.14502525329589844,
0.11519572138786316,
-0.15687063336372375,
-0.12848421931266785,
0.2788994014263153,
0.4079945981502533,
-0.743179440498352,
-0.1627449095249176,
-0.3420477509498596,
-0.1468995064496994,
0.5130013823509216,
-0.04301948845386505,
0.39599108695983887,
-0.34599199891090393,
-0.5011882185935974,
-0.13624688982963562,
-0.7718823552131653,
0.08882589638233185,
0.13771750032901764,
0.22644536197185516,
-0.09065533429384232,
0.6276915073394775,
-0.06298929452896118,
0.7076507210731506,
-0.3831208348274231,
-0.1571611911058426,
-0.09468034654855728,
-0.4016134440898895,
-0.43597349524497986,
-0.24970519542694092,
0.6622638702392578,
0.047487176954746246,
0.05995266139507294,
-0.483582466840744,
-0.19687826931476593,
0.39396846294403076,
0.2387213110923767,
-0.5162891745567322,
-0.0341343879699707,
-0.07190714031457901,
-0.4862546920776367,
0.051136378198862076,
0.07220199704170227,
-0.20696620643138885,
-0.39222681522369385,
-0.7995470762252808,
0.47731128334999084,
-0.6930699944496155,
-0.4781586825847626,
0.382744163274765,
-0.05757385864853859,
0.4640304148197174,
0.4330461919307709,
-0.909252405166626,
0.4529840350151062,
0.9847423434257507,
0.8174580335617065,
-0.17414338886737823,
-0.6456171870231628,
-0.25227829813957214,
0.16413867473602295,
-0.3473121225833893,
0.7834898233413696,
-0.3837778866291046,
-0.14692483842372894,
-0.30707108974456787,
0.058727048337459564,
-0.32439881563186646,
-0.3680773377418518,
0.4069790840148926,
-0.3078714907169342,
0.2580820620059967,
-0.4121357500553131,
-0.7438939213752747,
-0.34478849172592163,
0.38346049189567566,
-0.6157107353210449,
1.0813329219818115,
-0.04601013660430908,
-0.31471607089042664,
0.46421992778778076,
-0.49124959111213684,
-0.22699898481369019,
0.024296432733535767,
-0.35517430305480957,
0.006234258413314819,
0.6007584929466248,
-0.18718521296977997,
0.4826432764530182,
-0.3322572112083435,
0.45065614581108093,
-0.29002684354782104,
-0.043924979865550995,
0.09122637659311295,
-0.743259072303772,
0.7810665369033813,
0.10765642672777176,
-0.37735503911972046,
0.028226569294929504,
-0.6789306998252869,
-0.0858161523938179,
0.2580614387989044,
-0.06528928130865097,
-0.3601231575012207,
0.09766603261232376,
-0.11176124215126038,
0.395492821931839,
0.14922752976417542,
-0.6422775983810425,
-0.1252877414226532,
-0.4471612274646759,
0.5327187180519104,
0.8038106560707092,
-0.31222328543663025,
0.31820955872535706,
-0.3307790756225586,
0.44527873396873474,
-0.11977307498455048,
0.12219554930925369,
-0.17077051103115082,
-0.5243378281593323,
-0.7329399585723877,
-0.015830770134925842,
0.005185767542570829,
0.14334942400455475,
-0.08379989862442017,
0.2406245470046997,
-0.4264208972454071,
-0.558890163898468,
-0.6631502509117126,
0.39569908380508423,
0.18701712787151337,
0.47131526470184326,
0.32287997007369995,
-0.17960317432880402,
-0.2929248809814453,
-0.9403917193412781,
-0.6221613883972168,
-0.15461397171020508,
-0.07869673520326614,
0.00851327646523714,
0.5878512859344482,
-0.17070049047470093,
0.8200077414512634,
-0.3910236954689026,
0.1510276198387146,
-0.2665291726589203,
-0.04705554246902466,
0.011182025074958801,
0.2080363929271698,
0.25806596875190735,
-0.8839901089668274,
-0.2428167164325714,
-0.1992655098438263,
-0.8077849745750427,
0.15203793346881866,
-0.017879651859402657,
-0.30742019414901733,
-0.17259825766086578,
0.529606819152832,
-0.7059325575828552,
0.43160519003868103,
0.6974067091941833,
-0.4227125644683838,
0.40672507882118225,
-0.08628396689891815,
0.10538921505212784,
-1.0336848497390747,
0.02248230017721653,
0.05014537274837494,
0.05897228419780731,
-0.5726495385169983,
0.10719090700149536,
0.22617857158184052,
-0.005509964656084776,
-0.5055990219116211,
0.7533243894577026,
-0.5470441579818726,
-0.015151494182646275,
-0.1199662908911705,
0.46910804510116577,
0.5849384069442749,
0.05328606069087982,
-0.1556670069694519,
0.6309798359870911,
0.4926239848136902,
-0.5878177881240845,
0.25229349732398987,
0.21225254237651825,
-0.3224273920059204,
0.7723921537399292,
-0.7441152334213257,
0.08947434276342392,
-0.44209620356559753,
0.05802411213517189,
-1.3591440916061401,
-0.18489429354667664,
0.16004063189029694,
-0.4025959372520447,
0.13918723165988922,
0.04687228053808212,
-0.5929428935050964,
0.17920111119747162,
-0.1598028987646103,
0.36243948340415955,
0.25237351655960083,
-0.3797664940357208,
0.9847999811172485,
0.25934138894081116,
-0.06687574088573456,
-0.35125863552093506,
-0.6878499388694763,
0.27709829807281494,
-0.24692076444625854,
-1.0077831745147705,
0.3034254312515259,
-0.0620572529733181,
-0.5183718204498291,
-0.17285066843032837,
-0.3564716875553131,
-0.04955240711569786,
0.38109713792800903,
0.21361011266708374,
0.027906406670808792,
-0.3913499116897583,
0.37934553623199463,
0.07900386303663254,
0.042146604508161545,
0.11619741469621658,
0.004448575899004936,
0.4280467629432678,
-0.31734445691108704,
-0.6137099862098694,
-0.3319588303565979,
0.4440677762031555,
0.5371301770210266,
-0.2880195677280426,
0.8515039086341858,
0.422308087348938,
-0.5505189299583435,
0.08475084602832794,
-0.5269626975059509,
-0.20310921967029572,
-0.4045591652393341,
0.2018219381570816,
-0.9203452467918396,
-0.8290604948997498,
0.6624889373779297,
-0.0071850791573524475,
0.1338861733675003,
0.7433016896247864,
0.2579757273197174,
-0.19002056121826172,
0.9212779402732849,
0.6338794827461243,
0.3431331217288971,
0.1771020144224167,
-0.03948873654007912,
0.27253004908561707,
-0.8903366327285767,
-0.40707194805145264,
-0.5931949615478516,
-0.1747143715620041,
-0.3650309443473816,
-0.27098482847213745,
0.286345511674881,
0.5074655413627625,
-0.1346360296010971,
0.29635921120643616,
-0.1617640107870102,
0.454986035823822,
0.34627407789230347,
0.029286032542586327,
0.3827452063560486,
-0.2614125907421112,
0.05549795925617218,
-0.14364054799079895,
-0.5686227679252625,
-0.8582306504249573,
0.8659468293190002,
0.3337870240211487,
0.7115026712417603,
0.4548363983631134,
0.5334785580635071,
-0.11232555657625198,
0.3329494297504425,
-0.7965700626373291,
0.5054943561553955,
-0.10999540239572525,
-0.42738303542137146,
-0.2294096201658249,
-0.20807601511478424,
-1.30267333984375,
0.5762470364570618,
0.018812691792845726,
-0.5840749740600586,
-0.18261687457561493,
-0.12635211646556854,
-0.02935555763542652,
0.20813529193401337,
-0.6727936267852783,
1.1724765300750732,
-0.2731863558292389,
-0.1775180548429489,
-0.17012746632099152,
-0.8671967387199402,
0.5020285248756409,
0.1931026577949524,
0.13141366839408875,
-0.41313737630844116,
-0.1697683334350586,
0.7538557648658752,
-0.08363562077283859,
0.8284911513328552,
0.07684792578220367,
-0.5053858757019043,
0.01609082706272602,
0.13836562633514404,
0.08925020694732666,
0.06296936422586441,
-0.02482002228498459,
0.06438985466957092,
0.18093667924404144,
-0.7270112037658691,
-0.9646994471549988,
0.5399763584136963,
-0.636766791343689,
-0.5188177227973938,
-0.19730909168720245,
-0.531635582447052,
-0.286252498626709,
0.3160860240459442,
0.019946692511439323,
0.5068240761756897,
-0.2820647358894348,
0.21180762350559235,
0.9056960940361023,
-0.04014238342642784,
0.19126485288143158,
0.3882199227809906,
-0.12955424189567566,
-0.09935291856527328,
0.5151697993278503,
-0.056782230734825134,
0.6572341918945312,
0.4787633419036865,
0.3606584072113037,
-0.8360130190849304,
-0.21732297539710999,
-0.5322617292404175,
0.4188251197338104,
-0.9194259643554688,
-0.03609703481197357,
-0.6294493675231934,
-0.10084563493728638,
-0.6503395438194275,
0.09247326105833054,
-0.2721538245677948,
-0.011683885008096695,
-0.16621921956539154,
-0.10999692976474762,
0.27416306734085083,
0.9356247186660767,
0.03833913058042526,
0.27921780943870544,
-0.8594406247138977,
0.4021759331226349,
0.14655354619026184,
0.393999844789505,
-0.034444961696863174,
-0.6394055485725403,
0.019869418814778328,
0.20678438246250153,
-0.20633909106254578,
-0.9608259201049805,
-0.09030475467443466,
0.42103564739227295,
0.8251296877861023,
0.433713436126709,
-0.38060200214385986,
0.6440927982330322,
-0.5187806487083435,
0.798826277256012,
0.1473160833120346,
-1.282238245010376,
0.6925966143608093,
-0.19962120056152344,
0.2790505886077881,
0.5819026827812195,
0.5033829212188721,
-1.1635798215866089,
-0.5742590427398682,
-0.9135646224021912,
-0.5096988081932068,
0.3474431037902832,
-0.07543434947729111,
0.3316354751586914,
-0.15138739347457886,
0.4651084244251251,
0.37828296422958374,
0.1066833958029747,
-0.7601512670516968,
-0.06896005570888519,
-0.14216949045658112,
-0.45006057620048523,
-0.4305262863636017,
-0.20656053721904755,
-0.14343896508216858,
-0.01589304208755493,
0.2831428349018097,
-0.12043581902980804,
0.22976042330265045,
-0.037751611322164536,
-0.43484699726104736,
0.21389372646808624,
0.32773542404174805,
0.8550052046775818,
0.9027118682861328,
0.1550884246826172,
0.7026399970054626,
-0.0743977427482605,
-0.4556281566619873,
0.2101953774690628,
0.05941787734627724,
0.08417133241891861,
0.008579394780099392,
0.5249508023262024,
0.8187956213951111,
0.3570224940776825,
-0.5795382857322693,
0.570279598236084,
0.004703975282609463,
-0.2367391437292099,
0.18493805825710297,
-0.035437390208244324,
0.3377830982208252,
-0.054772451519966125,
0.09696106612682343,
0.1414562463760376,
-0.03751995414495468,
-0.586646556854248,
0.27107056975364685,
0.4146864712238312,
-0.3806551694869995,
-0.4392900764942169,
0.5479608178138733,
-0.3398285210132599,
-0.13338732719421387,
0.5417173504829407,
-0.23895670473575592,
-0.47657865285873413,
0.27394962310791016,
0.4304206669330597,
0.7544834613800049,
-0.26325270533561707,
0.10016895085573196,
-0.018092438578605652,
0.420785516500473,
-0.3185213506221771,
0.39785194396972656,
0.005877354647964239,
-1.071028709411621,
-0.782148003578186,
-0.7044232487678528,
-0.2847641408443451,
0.12402696907520294,
-0.7260628938674927,
0.1419122815132141,
-0.25399672985076904,
0.25807976722717285,
0.11331477761268616,
-0.07547663897275925,
-0.6611394882202148,
0.265394002199173,
0.10240650177001953,
0.8654682040214539,
-1.2850605249404907,
0.6062774062156677,
0.45380082726478577,
-0.5220685005187988,
-1.0221292972564697,
-0.0711202397942543,
0.0613197423517704,
-0.9353983998298645,
0.7220672965049744,
0.3273606598377228,
-0.261310875415802,
-0.008488782681524754,
-0.37195083498954773,
-0.9459569454193115,
0.8253560662269592,
0.6089285016059875,
-0.30511629581451416,
0.03543521836400032,
0.0829654112458229,
0.4101463854312897,
0.000575859856326133,
0.1935030072927475,
0.6225700378417969,
0.5420577526092529,
-0.10113736242055893,
-0.8861587047576904,
0.1549796462059021,
-0.13596539199352264,
0.024615779519081116,
0.3818102478981018,
-0.36205825209617615,
0.75260990858078,
0.04047907888889313,
-0.33227187395095825,
-0.05111696571111679,
0.71685791015625,
0.4181557297706604,
0.17829933762550354,
0.3956734240055084,
0.815730094909668,
0.7571910619735718,
-0.18666312098503113,
0.9629494547843933,
-0.09533891826868057,
0.36710694432258606,
0.9997264742851257,
-0.1629137098789215,
0.961458683013916,
0.6815803647041321,
-0.33917921781539917,
0.4439951479434967,
0.6547340750694275,
0.31247344613075256,
0.3284955322742462,
0.42361995577812195,
-0.41046079993247986,
-0.2285744547843933,
-0.06988538801670074,
-0.16217784583568573,
0.7056505084037781,
0.2729412913322449,
-0.2462541162967682,
-0.5596896409988403,
0.17538104951381683,
-0.041443902999162674,
0.3423195779323578,
-0.12309899181127548,
0.7030225396156311,
0.21432723104953766,
-0.5874231457710266,
0.6260512471199036,
-0.06537827104330063,
0.49843156337738037,
-0.6926151514053345,
-0.01743479259312153,
-0.12448658794164658,
-0.03781938925385475,
0.037131231278181076,
-0.9356391429901123,
0.46353989839553833,
-0.27144962549209595,
-0.23525385558605194,
-0.5387702584266663,
0.6960856914520264,
-0.5356955528259277,
-0.3778212070465088,
0.3694951832294464,
0.9293079972267151,
0.4551120400428772,
-0.1741894781589508,
-0.8238103985786438,
0.3887783885002136,
-0.18363124132156372,
-0.05300496518611908,
0.24219569563865662,
0.6676785349845886,
0.1631348729133606,
0.3966713845729828,
0.4713745415210724,
0.0490889847278595,
0.25043952465057373,
0.36560845375061035,
0.4279937446117401,
-0.6730318665504456,
-0.22296081483364105,
-1.1222270727157593,
0.4622621238231659,
0.09204354137182236,
-0.668535590171814,
0.7685623168945312,
0.6035366654396057,
0.9586917161941528,
0.23791112005710602,
0.4887748658657074,
0.09062948077917099,
0.42224714159965515,
-0.6285532116889954,
0.5894185900688171,
-0.6814490556716919,
-0.015154808759689331,
-0.11853267252445221,
-0.8901306390762329,
-0.43592122197151184,
0.8386635780334473,
-0.4024878442287445,
-0.039120864123106,
0.7509811520576477,
0.6281142830848694,
-0.22556553781032562,
0.21730266511440277,
0.48442962765693665,
0.0905739963054657,
0.47306743264198303,
0.473468542098999,
1.162191390991211,
-0.5678970217704773,
0.22032120823860168,
0.07879657298326492,
-0.14407964050769806,
0.22908830642700195,
-0.8087424635887146,
-0.47585493326187134,
-0.7244099378585815,
-0.07205662131309509,
-0.39447060227394104,
-0.17378069460391998,
0.6458489298820496,
0.493821918964386,
-0.4459272623062134,
-0.33729690313339233,
-0.41468310356140137,
-0.05601576343178749,
-0.2507563829421997,
-0.199188232421875,
0.4321827292442322,
-0.666185736656189,
-0.6158640384674072,
0.5830528140068054,
0.4685194790363312,
0.0960230752825737,
-0.3882550597190857,
-0.15076696872711182,
-0.21126973628997803,
-0.07340015470981598,
0.766325831413269,
-0.12463207542896271,
-1.2105308771133423,
-0.4539918601512909,
0.20984186232089996,
-0.2864028215408325,
0.08801563829183578,
0.599147379398346,
-0.48732098937034607,
0.2892419099807739,
0.4093443751335144,
0.9310097694396973,
0.37016353011131287,
-0.2594326138496399,
0.5867545008659363,
-0.4273521602153778,
-0.21303816139698029,
0.2396877557039261,
0.443570613861084,
0.4400809705257416,
0.030111409723758698,
0.41531920433044434,
0.295987606048584,
-0.3051120936870575,
-0.751954197883606,
0.5056877732276917,
-0.953929603099823,
-0.3619624078273773,
0.9969040751457214,
-0.1911322921514511,
-0.22625897824764252,
-0.034515101462602615,
0.0219728946685791,
0.23822391033172607,
0.0821484699845314,
0.6270051598548889,
0.9531306028366089,
-0.24425658583641052,
-0.22434751689434052,
-0.7777693867683411,
0.5786658525466919,
0.7484487891197205,
-0.6938821077346802,
0.18564918637275696,
0.3479481637477875,
0.5004633069038391,
0.1510688215494156,
0.5062234401702881,
-0.10417228192090988,
0.051107630133628845,
-0.04535169526934624,
-0.20598353445529938,
0.4578217566013336,
-0.29377856850624084,
-0.4073795974254608,
0.0680035650730133,
0.22931301593780518,
-0.03897266834974289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12132v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12132v1
|
Enhancing Suicide Risk Assessment: A Speech-Based Automated Approach in Emergency Medicine
| 2024-04-18T12:33:57 | 2024-04-18T12:33:57 |
Shahin Amiriparian, Maurice Gerczuk, Justina Lutz, Wolfgang Strube, Irina Papazova, Alkomiet Hasan, Alexander Kathan, Björn W. Schuller
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS, I.2
|
The delayed access to specialized psychiatric assessments and care for
patients at risk of suicidal tendencies in emergency departments creates a
notable gap in timely intervention, hindering the provision of adequate mental
health support during critical situations. To address this, we present a
non-invasive, speech-based approach for automatic suicide risk assessment. For
our study, we have collected a novel dataset of speech recordings from $20$
patients from which we extract three sets of features, including wav2vec,
interpretable speech and acoustic features, and deep learning-based spectral
representations. We proceed by conducting a binary classification to assess
suicide risk in a leave-one-subject-out fashion. Our most effective speech
model achieves a balanced accuracy of $66.2\,\%$. Moreover, we show that
integrating our speech model with a series of patients' metadata, such as the
history of suicide attempts or access to firearms, improves the overall result.
The metadata integration yields a balanced accuracy of $94.4\,\%$, marking an
absolute improvement of $28.2\,\%$, demonstrating the efficacy of our proposed
approaches for automatic suicide risk assessment in emergency medicine.
|
[
-0.057409778237342834,
-0.5410320162773132,
0.852998673915863,
0.2006523311138153,
0.20280852913856506,
0.04947074502706528,
-0.13353858888149261,
-0.27403023838996887,
0.275250107049942,
0.12071112543344498,
-0.5126697421073914,
-0.5997180342674255,
-0.8400347232818604,
-0.017705297097563744,
-0.29458341002464294,
0.648757815361023,
0.24976681172847748,
0.38189569115638733,
0.22987976670265198,
-0.053645964711904526,
-0.43383803963661194,
-0.2200702726840973,
-1.1790677309036255,
0.19606339931488037,
0.8093341588973999,
0.3431958854198456,
0.7830966114997864,
0.29838356375694275,
0.5510257482528687,
0.17546910047531128,
0.014590430073440075,
-0.20215469598770142,
-0.085356704890728,
-0.15113797783851624,
0.19501107931137085,
-0.03746762126684189,
-0.7801759243011475,
0.01811450906097889,
0.48176467418670654,
0.5344438552856445,
-0.53092360496521,
0.47411125898361206,
-0.19889171421527863,
0.6376962661743164,
-0.6992833018302917,
-0.14143772423267365,
-0.2867966890335083,
0.3408779203891754,
-0.048235081136226654,
0.04502781480550766,
-0.42279568314552307,
-0.4840947389602661,
0.36773574352264404,
-0.32608458399772644,
-0.06754349917173386,
-0.44661158323287964,
0.2721004784107208,
0.6726012229919434,
-0.3498769700527191,
-0.2325594127178192,
-0.9052555561065674,
0.33099183440208435,
-0.7319788932800293,
0.48910659551620483,
0.5178107023239136,
0.5009867548942566,
0.03091820888221264,
-0.38716748356819153,
-0.30132439732551575,
-0.17346957325935364,
0.019639713689684868,
0.2942271828651428,
-0.322512149810791,
0.5581567287445068,
0.23056672513484955,
0.31629660725593567,
-0.5850520730018616,
0.3034094572067261,
-0.24554891884326935,
-0.4451019763946533,
1.013553261756897,
0.33258962631225586,
0.5973126888275146,
-0.45563581585884094,
-0.18458063900470734,
-0.017004922032356262,
-0.05064002424478531,
-0.007870404981076717,
0.24274976551532745,
0.2846565246582031,
0.07152946293354034,
0.6400398015975952,
-0.06327299773693085,
0.406646192073822,
0.040867529809474945,
-0.22021815180778503,
0.4815698564052582,
0.12442974001169205,
-0.3442273736000061,
0.5236983895301819,
1.0235449075698853,
0.7536658048629761,
-0.1465495526790619,
-0.011476157233119011,
0.17468854784965515,
-0.2032657414674759,
0.6026023626327515,
-0.2874778211116791,
-0.53221595287323,
0.6580958366394043,
-0.6424076557159424,
-0.2880820631980896,
-0.45589354634284973,
-0.9103153944015503,
-0.6445176601409912,
-0.055985596030950546,
0.8070961833000183,
-0.6935369968414307,
-0.3410593271255493,
-0.04635310918092728,
-0.1046246662735939,
0.05318935215473175,
0.24474254250526428,
-0.330405056476593,
0.3647470474243164,
0.2827829122543335,
1.241895079612732,
-0.17713920772075653,
0.2294144332408905,
-0.5880860686302185,
0.034666452556848526,
-0.36559930443763733,
0.8565391302108765,
-0.315708726644516,
-0.4081496298313141,
-0.15954726934432983,
-0.02991425059735775,
0.017040599137544632,
-0.3378068804740906,
1.1528432369232178,
0.12180998921394348,
0.1611773669719696,
-0.09171123802661896,
-0.6260703206062317,
-0.559168815612793,
-0.20588070154190063,
-0.5884414911270142,
0.8930913209915161,
0.26413360238075256,
-0.5916048288345337,
0.42642301321029663,
-0.9370714426040649,
-0.3183022439479828,
0.2970195412635803,
-0.0671856701374054,
-0.5624454617500305,
0.19567494094371796,
0.2964523732662201,
0.600744366645813,
0.09895913302898407,
0.19467507302761078,
-0.4505111873149872,
0.08665495365858078,
0.20173713564872742,
-0.5501077175140381,
0.785844087600708,
0.13800539076328278,
-0.15694794058799744,
-0.054670266807079315,
-0.9000629186630249,
0.43512797355651855,
-0.07760683447122574,
-0.3258611857891083,
-0.3790208101272583,
0.2366320937871933,
0.25681471824645996,
0.3314892649650574,
0.07858911156654358,
-0.5584760308265686,
-0.2481188029050827,
-0.5457704067230225,
-0.07456810772418976,
0.4618281424045563,
0.4118111729621887,
0.3153843283653259,
-0.4043337404727936,
0.4572618901729584,
-0.328518271446228,
0.5970482230186462,
0.11250025779008865,
-0.7091010212898254,
-0.28899526596069336,
-0.8700518012046814,
0.18091964721679688,
1.2588374614715576,
0.0036600851453840733,
0.7720069289207458,
0.17095664143562317,
-0.8876495957374573,
-0.7168684601783752,
-0.41026368737220764,
0.07815265655517578,
0.6897476315498352,
0.6831759810447693,
-0.39185211062431335,
-0.8199144005775452,
-0.9683564305305481,
-0.3129667639732361,
-0.32739895582199097,
-0.3387463390827179,
0.2913101017475128,
-0.13494174182415009,
-0.31880080699920654,
0.7792904376983643,
-0.5523368716239929,
-0.5747874975204468,
-0.18627168238162994,
0.279928982257843,
0.2000439167022705,
0.35682523250579834,
0.24416695535182953,
-0.4399561583995819,
-0.530451774597168,
-0.2951224446296692,
-0.8583202362060547,
-0.38147932291030884,
-0.28562504053115845,
0.1058521494269371,
-0.11814989894628525,
-0.11700963228940964,
-0.3946459889411926,
0.57047438621521,
0.24413375556468964,
0.06961067020893097,
0.1364372819662094,
-0.2833681106567383,
0.10553550720214844,
-0.9892029762268066,
0.0017954317154362798,
-0.0901237353682518,
-0.1623731255531311,
-1.0876795053482056,
-0.5963937044143677,
-0.08823134750127792,
-0.40379077196121216,
-0.3261188864707947,
0.1401975303888321,
-0.2389248162508011,
0.16679970920085907,
-0.3861415684223175,
0.011421564035117626,
-0.44992348551750183,
0.10332602262496948,
0.09242429584264755,
0.4350064992904663,
0.6062170267105103,
-0.26523253321647644,
0.08170820772647858,
0.29928311705589294,
-0.14428094029426575,
0.6309398412704468,
-0.42477816343307495,
0.13268925249576569,
-0.1526731252670288,
0.2833154499530792,
-0.9256777167320251,
-0.3698592782020569,
0.2988296151161194,
-0.4023738205432892,
0.3047982454299927,
-0.13823075592517853,
0.014293519780039787,
-0.10652795433998108,
-0.1591099202632904,
-0.004839225672185421,
0.6066344976425171,
0.4843834638595581,
0.6434938907623291,
0.8183680772781372,
-0.8116231560707092,
-0.4242696464061737,
-0.357342392206192,
0.5097962021827698,
-0.4359327554702759,
-0.09530974924564362,
-0.04352140426635742,
0.030413394793868065,
-0.3152015805244446,
-0.3563767075538635,
0.11874677240848541,
-0.3115033805370331,
0.2962121367454529,
0.7300043702125549,
0.3645271360874176,
-0.004039035644382238,
0.4841949939727783,
0.4697466194629669,
-0.16479572653770447,
0.31761977076530457,
-0.3396650552749634,
0.29262837767601013,
0.07519743591547012,
-0.2167874574661255,
-1.068913459777832,
0.9811108112335205,
0.5667484998703003,
0.14404913783073425,
0.6197040677070618,
0.5308713912963867,
-0.860084593296051,
0.22336773574352264,
-0.6583608388900757,
-0.006913876160979271,
-0.3308164179325104,
0.34500691294670105,
0.46391531825065613,
-0.32061055302619934,
0.3060140609741211,
-0.12235943228006363,
0.033468253910541534,
0.5970107913017273,
0.6932661533355713,
-0.5273876190185547,
0.9641794562339783,
0.41480594873428345,
-0.09357410669326782,
0.16936078667640686,
0.042006995528936386,
0.2975682318210602,
-0.5842795968055725,
-0.26501208543777466,
-0.16752710938453674,
-0.3337242007255554,
-0.3457379937171936,
-0.43891802430152893,
0.8841546773910522,
-0.09541798382997513,
-0.25192156434059143,
0.31091660261154175,
-0.6168736219406128,
0.0923091247677803,
0.24765156209468842,
0.2433275729417801,
0.09274612367153168,
-0.14763490855693817,
0.20570515096187592,
-0.26117363572120667,
-0.4188017249107361,
-0.4184612035751343,
1.2358547449111938,
0.6091585755348206,
0.5013871192932129,
0.06310443580150604,
0.9110888838768005,
0.6210625767707825,
0.3254208564758301,
-0.8151130080223083,
0.24373997747898102,
-0.10437171161174774,
-0.5301555395126343,
-0.6215746998786926,
-0.3147250711917877,
-0.28385648131370544,
-0.2997913062572479,
-0.3047730624675751,
-0.7507575750350952,
0.5021595358848572,
0.017123766243457794,
-1.1383296251296997,
0.0034625756088644266,
-0.7971309423446655,
0.39623913168907166,
-0.5786808729171753,
0.2769753932952881,
-0.19376493990421295,
-0.8020530343055725,
0.07510385662317276,
-0.3916959762573242,
0.30394116044044495,
-0.4250039756298065,
-0.27290135622024536,
1.0394165515899658,
-0.3167150020599365,
0.8057523965835571,
-0.31831562519073486,
-0.16698507964611053,
0.11277181655168533,
0.08390899747610092,
0.39306727051734924,
0.2311745285987854,
-0.16364924609661102,
0.43494531512260437,
-0.030027391389012337,
-0.025102607905864716,
-0.6435746550559998,
0.18924126029014587,
-0.6635544896125793,
-0.2503758668899536,
-0.30839109420776367,
-0.539181649684906,
-0.5266134738922119,
0.20329530537128448,
0.25682616233825684,
0.5077847838401794,
-0.3423556685447693,
-0.23787522315979004,
0.5402740240097046,
-0.42631277441978455,
0.4427655339241028,
0.508573055267334,
0.15592819452285767,
-0.9677615165710449,
0.8050889372825623,
0.506858229637146,
0.18347564339637756,
0.3474210798740387,
0.47369807958602905,
-0.6058247089385986,
-0.5277055501937866,
-0.320613831281662,
-0.023239102214574814,
-0.6208410263061523,
-0.2914697229862213,
-1.3150221109390259,
-0.401763916015625,
-0.5178402662277222,
0.013211390934884548,
-0.21183353662490845,
-0.6192318797111511,
-0.24598462879657745,
-0.4745173156261444,
0.6291778683662415,
0.45417532324790955,
-0.5174785852432251,
0.1430474817752838,
-0.9780460596084595,
0.15448737144470215,
0.36915770173072815,
-0.04731107875704765,
-0.10593050718307495,
-0.3125976324081421,
-0.062408193945884705,
-0.17167618870735168,
-0.2909127473831177,
-1.4974371194839478,
0.4209659993648529,
0.6473506093025208,
0.41799208521842957,
0.7126596570014954,
0.44451475143432617,
0.7187392711639404,
-0.7544888257980347,
0.8293003439903259,
0.4475470781326294,
-0.9549747705459595,
0.770773708820343,
-0.44421443343162537,
-0.22468823194503784,
0.9229905605316162,
0.8166580200195312,
-0.8162481784820557,
-0.46299052238464355,
-0.8151451945304871,
-0.7943761348724365,
0.42564475536346436,
0.3220507502555847,
-0.1026531234383583,
-0.09935855120420456,
0.18679402768611908,
-0.20716124773025513,
0.08968806266784668,
-0.33699125051498413,
-0.41407960653305054,
-0.26477161049842834,
-0.5612908601760864,
-0.13625425100326538,
-0.17574246227741241,
-0.43344825506210327,
-0.3717910349369049,
0.5337458252906799,
-0.0884365662932396,
0.6034273505210876,
0.5526336431503296,
0.11313005536794662,
-0.2239086925983429,
0.3635616600513458,
0.4983070194721222,
0.2527352273464203,
-0.34748679399490356,
0.025545280426740646,
0.7924422025680542,
-0.7099683880805969,
0.4660637080669403,
0.19037975370883942,
0.03128351643681526,
0.2621366083621979,
0.31718918681144714,
0.5494887828826904,
-0.06241866201162338,
-0.9587152600288391,
0.6344749927520752,
-0.00760066881775856,
-0.16320189833641052,
-0.5902405381202698,
0.06862983852624893,
-0.1391327679157257,
0.23775745928287506,
0.2758120596408844,
0.11363112181425095,
0.7636163830757141,
-0.06720268726348877,
0.5871687531471252,
0.20332099497318268,
-0.7757930755615234,
-0.22106288373470306,
0.27224767208099365,
0.02094355970621109,
-0.7629907131195068,
0.3258211314678192,
0.0021227209363132715,
-0.3117021918296814,
0.0892702043056488,
0.26637497544288635,
1.398054838180542,
-0.6645898222923279,
0.6471583247184753,
0.4436030387878418,
0.4697544276714325,
0.1967441290616989,
0.5608023405075073,
0.09398823976516724,
-0.031010622158646584,
-0.25549784302711487,
-0.5776397585868835,
-0.44317030906677246,
0.11828403919935226,
-0.8764404058456421,
0.16912062466144562,
-0.8836829662322998,
-0.284816712141037,
-0.09504754096269608,
-0.1506912112236023,
-0.06666350364685059,
0.5230119824409485,
0.6661584377288818,
0.9581736922264099,
-0.9112246036529541,
0.1636071652173996,
0.5339974164962769,
-0.11398714780807495,
-0.9304251670837402,
0.30864304304122925,
0.30041688680648804,
-0.4387548565864563,
0.2597442865371704,
0.26260310411453247,
0.07109694927930832,
-0.229377880692482,
-0.10330567508935928,
-1.1250853538513184,
0.7557913661003113,
0.57767254114151,
-0.6101179122924805,
-0.23231898248195648,
0.2782934606075287,
0.6100801229476929,
-0.14669449627399445,
0.49587056040763855,
0.4113786816596985,
0.45259812474250793,
-0.2168869823217392,
-1.0592724084854126,
-0.049931600689888,
-0.0015361253172159195,
-0.2694857716560364,
0.3975903391838074,
-0.2549579441547394,
0.48513564467430115,
-0.2645353674888611,
-0.5167848467826843,
-0.3243633210659027,
0.6279293894767761,
-0.4616488516330719,
0.6093947887420654,
0.5920063257217407,
0.8401455283164978,
1.375572681427002,
0.20186875760555267,
0.6975038647651672,
0.2551616430282593,
0.4452095627784729,
1.2526211738586426,
-0.40075820684432983,
1.059867024421692,
0.03368176147341728,
-0.2040468156337738,
0.35859960317611694,
0.581053614616394,
0.07642767578363419,
0.5248119831085205,
-0.09187501668930054,
-0.7653168439865112,
-0.45257800817489624,
-0.13766488432884216,
-0.18012335896492004,
0.29217538237571716,
0.5397721529006958,
-0.6974021792411804,
-0.41844362020492554,
0.5190814137458801,
-0.10428569465875626,
-0.30644479393959045,
-0.13733477890491486,
1.188490629196167,
0.178273543715477,
-0.0951576977968216,
0.3847055435180664,
-0.2080441117286682,
0.01485193520784378,
-0.3989739716053009,
0.03775288537144661,
0.4025285243988037,
-0.03026498109102249,
-0.38781434297561646,
-0.6759163737297058,
0.7175199389457703,
0.25307193398475647,
-0.11628811061382294,
0.037679221481084824,
0.6180432438850403,
-0.15520448982715607,
-0.8292194604873657,
0.2138826549053192,
0.2855101525783539,
0.13485804200172424,
-0.1687404215335846,
-0.9311750531196594,
-0.4249984323978424,
-0.34320515394210815,
0.19099321961402893,
0.06877657026052475,
-0.004911013413220644,
0.20191605389118195,
0.5018520355224609,
0.6306543946266174,
0.3721409738063812,
0.07250871509313583,
-0.20593221485614777,
0.48894959688186646,
-0.5312396287918091,
-0.4428185522556305,
-0.8003977537155151,
0.4720759093761444,
-0.11169973760843277,
-0.4359996020793915,
0.4476313292980194,
0.3594706654548645,
0.12806621193885803,
0.14466774463653564,
0.8272644877433777,
-0.25437822937965393,
0.9111663699150085,
-0.4648015797138214,
1.12129545211792,
-0.5130663514137268,
-0.24477049708366394,
-0.45720434188842773,
-0.34769606590270996,
-0.46700698137283325,
0.5413109064102173,
-0.3120461106300354,
-0.3246240019798279,
0.5538572669029236,
0.6631212830543518,
0.3370295464992523,
0.08533492684364319,
0.3472776710987091,
0.2935371696949005,
0.3139849305152893,
0.5522102117538452,
0.8881340622901917,
-0.5070161819458008,
0.046274784952402115,
-0.2951866686344147,
-0.6628801226615906,
0.034288518130779266,
-0.6736065149307251,
-0.6045251488685608,
-0.5234957337379456,
-0.4820660352706909,
-0.09844856709241867,
0.04130561649799347,
1.2047812938690186,
0.552734375,
-0.5320878028869629,
0.1361992210149765,
0.1884593963623047,
-0.22127139568328857,
-0.4968264698982239,
-0.14672790467739105,
0.3587547242641449,
0.006238364148885012,
-0.2401367425918579,
0.7418472170829773,
0.6248630285263062,
0.055441614240407944,
-0.11502793431282043,
0.36706140637397766,
-0.09371869266033173,
0.33764520287513733,
0.3477397561073303,
0.1932980865240097,
-0.5987451076507568,
-0.17838861048221588,
-0.17912723124027252,
0.012030779384076595,
0.0870019793510437,
0.5381677746772766,
-0.7313699722290039,
0.2826082706451416,
0.20582355558872223,
0.6791269779205322,
-0.439680814743042,
-0.05039734020829201,
0.39465829730033875,
-0.4528036117553711,
-0.15506519377231598,
0.6624438166618347,
0.057622943073511124,
0.2574464678764343,
-1.0771291255950928,
-0.05547986179590225,
0.08455602079629898,
-0.39283090829849243,
-0.9822469353675842,
0.023679642006754875,
-0.9720411896705627,
0.29756394028663635,
0.6956101655960083,
-0.2438451200723648,
-0.024352287873625755,
-0.4214955270290375,
-0.37719064950942993,
0.2843419909477234,
-0.6280768513679504,
0.7556763291358948,
0.22585277259349823,
-0.3696821331977844,
-0.14576688408851624,
-0.672420859336853,
0.7261620759963989,
0.18238811194896698,
-0.7996012568473816,
0.07122176140546799,
0.271836519241333,
0.21585972607135773,
0.4375284016132355,
0.546297013759613,
-0.043175216764211655,
0.5797532200813293,
-0.5079925656318665,
-0.08577489107847214,
0.16210168600082397,
-0.5462499260902405,
-0.6879504919052124,
0.35903289914131165,
-0.3120429515838623,
-0.15040813386440277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12104v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12104v1
|
Ethical-Lens: Curbing Malicious Usages of Open-Source Text-to-Image Models
| 2024-04-18T11:38:25 | 2024-04-18T11:38:25 |
Yuzhu Cai, Sheng Yin, Yuxi Wei, Chenxin Xu, Weibo Mao, Felix Juefei-Xu, Siheng Chen, Yanfeng Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The burgeoning landscape of text-to-image models, exemplified by innovations
such as Midjourney and DALLE 3, has revolutionized content creation across
diverse sectors. However, these advancements bring forth critical ethical
concerns, particularly with the misuse of open-source models to generate
content that violates societal norms. Addressing this, we introduce
Ethical-Lens, a framework designed to facilitate the value-aligned usage of
text-to-image tools without necessitating internal model revision. Ethical-Lens
ensures value alignment in text-to-image models across toxicity and bias
dimensions by refining user commands and rectifying model outputs. Systematic
evaluation metrics, combining GPT4-V, HEIM, and FairFace scores, assess
alignment capability. Our experiments reveal that Ethical-Lens enhances
alignment capabilities to levels comparable with or superior to commercial
models like DALLE 3, ensuring user-generated content adheres to ethical
standards while maintaining image quality. This study indicates the potential
of Ethical-Lens to ensure the sustainable development of open-source
text-to-image tools and their beneficial integration into society. Our code is
available at https://github.com/yuzhu-cai/Ethical-Lens.
|
[
0.001086659380234778,
-0.39234018325805664,
0.6138741374015808,
-0.07263191789388657,
-0.4115622639656067,
-0.3060205578804016,
-0.018020810559391975,
-0.6936048269271851,
-0.2882630228996277,
0.8454751372337341,
-0.4304969310760498,
-0.6161092519760132,
-0.4551984965801239,
0.038022689521312714,
-0.39000362157821655,
1.1435965299606323,
0.15058016777038574,
0.43691664934158325,
-0.20564702153205872,
-0.5955236554145813,
-0.2518334984779358,
0.1967855840921402,
-0.5640179514884949,
0.21076494455337524,
0.7316354513168335,
0.30656352639198303,
1.038024663925171,
0.99998939037323,
0.9221315383911133,
0.16669230163097382,
0.23415793478488922,
0.11109448224306107,
-0.7940941452980042,
-0.005462064407765865,
-0.7433961033821106,
-0.13736170530319214,
-0.6633397936820984,
0.4302476644515991,
0.3611987233161926,
0.0184312853962183,
-0.11752720922231674,
0.641015350818634,
-0.02751799114048481,
0.5875030755996704,
-0.8894882202148438,
-0.572176456451416,
-0.583252489566803,
-0.02823350951075554,
-0.4184909760951996,
-0.502135694026947,
-0.5329075455665588,
-0.6018181443214417,
-0.13556523621082306,
-1.2579233646392822,
-0.3934367299079895,
0.11284945160150528,
0.9507701992988586,
0.41300320625305176,
-0.23510661721229553,
-0.32349294424057007,
-0.49291688203811646,
0.9080312848091125,
-0.525689423084259,
0.35175997018814087,
0.20691120624542236,
0.31453847885131836,
0.341372549533844,
-0.5564327239990234,
-0.6098155975341797,
0.4620019495487213,
0.268850177526474,
0.364300936460495,
-0.2399778813123703,
-0.07091379165649414,
-0.014188813045620918,
0.2727962136268616,
-0.31388527154922485,
0.15220846235752106,
-0.5396237373352051,
0.09917879849672318,
0.626630425453186,
0.005498416256159544,
0.63373863697052,
-0.18110425770282745,
-0.473878413438797,
0.061811935156583786,
-0.9634842276573181,
-0.022804832085967064,
0.9349269866943359,
-0.13896730542182922,
0.16000327467918396,
0.8488578796386719,
0.23328334093093872,
0.28743311762809753,
0.3943469226360321,
-0.14697718620300293,
0.21593046188354492,
-0.40750032663345337,
-0.2771167755126953,
0.1476854830980301,
0.6525484919548035,
1.2978092432022095,
0.40255245566368103,
-0.01222771592438221,
-0.09241437166929245,
0.04744444414973259,
0.6631494164466858,
-0.9020305275917053,
0.19464804232120514,
0.03201128542423248,
-0.7108823657035828,
-1.0411577224731445,
-0.003939345013350248,
-0.843728244304657,
-0.484065979719162,
-0.24480466544628143,
0.5985192656517029,
-0.2588963508605957,
-0.2946752905845642,
0.10600254684686661,
-0.1371859312057495,
0.2430996298789978,
0.4974590837955475,
-0.4976624548435211,
0.015224074013531208,
0.548224925994873,
0.825289785861969,
-0.026089617982506752,
-0.04129040986299515,
-0.6266580820083618,
0.6685448884963989,
-0.476761132478714,
0.3959113359451294,
-0.6778015494346619,
-0.39616796374320984,
0.07399314641952515,
0.1484602391719818,
0.5364019870758057,
-0.26869437098503113,
0.6708510518074036,
-0.6841992139816284,
0.1827574521303177,
-0.3938216269016266,
-0.3101607859134674,
0.04239671677350998,
0.2736978828907013,
-0.6458402276039124,
0.8950802683830261,
-0.07325191050767899,
-0.8597133755683899,
0.5725299715995789,
-0.8733780384063721,
-0.08738253265619278,
0.27169832587242126,
-0.2765376567840576,
-0.5455744862556458,
-0.05158958584070206,
0.06612817198038101,
0.18442854285240173,
-0.31998810172080994,
0.2785957455635071,
-0.5935022234916687,
-0.2953561246395111,
-0.00026062666438519955,
-0.5182361006736755,
1.1709842681884766,
0.3024696111679077,
-0.19745895266532898,
0.1085994616150856,
-0.6285344958305359,
0.057789191603660583,
0.20193441212177277,
0.20466579496860504,
-0.8285966515541077,
0.006907890550792217,
0.38510921597480774,
0.013393337838351727,
-0.0705854669213295,
-0.7095301747322083,
-0.08399581909179688,
-0.022414611652493477,
0.5343253016471863,
1.1397465467453003,
-0.11928356438875198,
0.9768735766410828,
-0.4166802763938904,
0.2598351240158081,
-0.018215186893939972,
0.6874536871910095,
-0.2295578569173813,
-0.38593122363090515,
-0.24110321700572968,
-0.22573882341384888,
-0.06276977062225342,
0.5594555139541626,
-0.49005216360092163,
0.04926270246505737,
-0.29523077607154846,
-0.4668680727481842,
-0.8957313299179077,
0.043092578649520874,
0.23164482414722443,
0.8360146284103394,
0.3928760290145874,
-0.4113070070743561,
-0.025187259539961815,
-1.0044454336166382,
-0.4487260580062866,
-0.0433446504175663,
-0.06258422881364822,
0.434631884098053,
0.32017838954925537,
-0.24624371528625488,
1.003336787223816,
-0.252262145280838,
-0.462726891040802,
0.5767478346824646,
-0.05990562587976456,
-0.3345218896865845,
0.6439613103866577,
0.6868425607681274,
-1.0794812440872192,
-0.20589902997016907,
-0.021069137379527092,
-0.9872782230377197,
-0.31036967039108276,
0.11057063937187195,
-0.5609562397003174,
0.14969132840633392,
0.33917754888534546,
-0.37775903940200806,
0.5928879976272583,
0.41671591997146606,
-0.24983716011047363,
0.4885649085044861,
0.054870981723070145,
0.5991092324256897,
-1.1734800338745117,
0.31732288002967834,
0.21515831351280212,
-0.3757763206958771,
-0.27448955178260803,
0.355966180562973,
0.2281118929386139,
-0.19217486679553986,
-0.6784847974777222,
0.6493485569953918,
-0.1725369691848755,
0.02278781123459339,
0.15072160959243774,
-0.043860167264938354,
0.36174914240837097,
-0.25171157717704773,
0.10480447113513947,
0.846459150314331,
0.29502034187316895,
-0.017576932907104492,
0.10235834121704102,
0.3582456409931183,
-0.10607703775167465,
1.415761947631836,
-0.49578219652175903,
0.10347730666399002,
-0.04600018262863159,
0.01820652186870575,
-0.1829133778810501,
-0.2055501788854599,
0.6222724318504333,
-0.3375133275985718,
-0.0980038046836853,
-0.09386158734560013,
-0.47712329030036926,
0.15336187183856964,
-0.6387699246406555,
0.9639702439308167,
0.5826691389083862,
-0.615529477596283,
0.3745509386062622,
0.39522042870521545,
-0.02870328724384308,
-0.7610469460487366,
-0.8078749775886536,
0.1937255710363388,
-0.4129734933376312,
-1.0382132530212402,
0.6162965893745422,
-0.04624272510409355,
-0.27505287528038025,
0.5416802167892456,
0.1288779228925705,
-0.1069948822259903,
-0.35014209151268005,
0.051870811730623245,
0.4600107669830322,
-0.19632560014724731,
-0.052238527685403824,
0.06557995080947876,
-0.13385848701000214,
-0.0846848338842392,
-0.5821303725242615,
-0.2529061436653137,
-0.22008563578128815,
-0.47073644399642944,
-0.29777243733406067,
0.4701692461967468,
0.6509805917739868,
-0.5420663356781006,
0.2734344005584717,
0.5433652997016907,
-0.5118065476417542,
0.16869769990444183,
-0.6348060965538025,
-0.01222294569015503,
-0.5017756819725037,
0.1638108640909195,
0.37194812297821045,
-0.6627199649810791,
0.14071708917617798,
0.02959156036376953,
0.25057488679885864,
0.2354813814163208,
0.4077823758125305,
-0.4029206335544586,
0.7930424213409424,
0.6783412098884583,
0.4296806752681732,
0.3662171959877014,
-0.044720787554979324,
0.3713437020778656,
-0.8320983648300171,
-0.2324509471654892,
-0.027378860861063004,
-0.21069923043251038,
-0.41744816303253174,
-0.46266108751296997,
0.44215071201324463,
-0.10362815856933594,
-0.3920323848724365,
0.00027964910259470344,
-0.7937827110290527,
0.9315378069877625,
0.4042885899543762,
0.2844521403312683,
0.7603443264961243,
0.040948472917079926,
0.25569623708724976,
-0.09829219430685043,
-0.3161681294441223,
-0.864734411239624,
1.0401424169540405,
0.4037207067012787,
0.9666276574134827,
-0.07155031710863113,
0.587171196937561,
0.3121200501918793,
0.39304184913635254,
-0.6220842599868774,
0.5566477179527283,
-0.4008108079433441,
-0.7718517780303955,
-0.15435640513896942,
-0.13145573437213898,
-0.40875348448753357,
-0.08297339081764221,
0.06541308015584946,
-0.605880081653595,
0.4607900083065033,
0.27407366037368774,
-0.35830795764923096,
0.37750717997550964,
-0.49808987975120544,
0.8244069218635559,
-0.38539958000183105,
-1.1348158121109009,
-0.4248121678829193,
-0.7029436826705933,
0.20507121086120605,
-0.15567070245742798,
0.40769821405410767,
-0.04565788805484772,
-0.1790236532688141,
0.36002522706985474,
-0.3219018280506134,
0.8447155356407166,
-0.06492763012647629,
-0.027334976941347122,
0.21151375770568848,
0.08194869756698608,
-0.053478606045246124,
0.3649692237377167,
0.06157965585589409,
0.39924976229667664,
0.16349513828754425,
-0.1898396760225296,
-0.31233227252960205,
0.6251067519187927,
-0.4700073301792145,
-0.49650838971138,
-0.47365280985832214,
-0.6403611302375793,
0.15623055398464203,
0.621873676776886,
0.6063183546066284,
0.43855980038642883,
-0.30586668848991394,
0.1640217900276184,
0.7591667175292969,
-0.3165590167045593,
0.2730695307254791,
0.3415513038635254,
-0.2553907334804535,
-0.5351637601852417,
0.8527594208717346,
0.08772378414869308,
0.5722834467887878,
-0.1757119745016098,
0.16943369805812836,
-0.12958361208438873,
-0.28141921758651733,
-0.9513461589813232,
-0.025886476039886475,
-0.8079351782798767,
-0.48115646839141846,
-0.20297780632972717,
-0.2279086709022522,
-0.16475322842597961,
-0.9478566646575928,
-0.4338917136192322,
-0.1548273116350174,
-0.3379116356372833,
0.08786268532276154,
0.3979472517967224,
0.4287116825580597,
-0.14752297103405,
0.07987243682146072,
-0.6877461075782776,
0.1331985592842102,
-0.05587418004870415,
0.6295502185821533,
-0.2493569552898407,
0.05686786770820618,
0.1152932420372963,
0.24158833920955658,
-0.666408896446228,
-0.787390947341919,
0.016928821802139282,
0.11850979924201965,
0.12236104905605316,
0.6405370235443115,
0.04025515541434288,
0.6588747501373291,
-0.8626370429992676,
0.6393066048622131,
0.5950735211372375,
-1.125045657157898,
0.4193892478942871,
-0.689452588558197,
0.030279790982604027,
0.5918219685554504,
0.3202531933784485,
-0.5155361890792847,
-0.6389114856719971,
-0.4526832699775696,
-0.5278123021125793,
0.4879339635372162,
0.4058068096637726,
0.2565324902534485,
0.12972332537174225,
0.3199325501918793,
0.1042051762342453,
0.26187801361083984,
-0.9585281014442444,
0.41164708137512207,
-0.6722748875617981,
-0.6084280014038086,
0.5088921189308167,
0.02250821702182293,
-0.39005810022354126,
-0.05406078323721886,
0.6491631269454956,
-0.06462763994932175,
-0.08451296389102936,
0.35754579305648804,
-0.1387285739183426,
-0.5203595161437988,
0.22986413538455963,
0.023050496354699135,
0.4639466106891632,
-0.09763628244400024,
-0.12880702316761017,
-0.4216924011707306,
-0.6617945432662964,
0.17483597993850708,
-0.09709589928388596,
-0.6101386547088623,
-0.4628676176071167,
-0.13714727759361267,
0.1306583136320114,
0.07675504684448242,
-0.47360944747924805,
0.9362521767616272,
0.24446937441825867,
-0.19489288330078125,
-0.17913532257080078,
-0.1781712770462036,
-0.06849109381437302,
0.19859309494495392,
-0.00547429546713829,
0.4986948072910309,
0.6058093905448914,
-0.43760445713996887,
0.09002798795700073,
0.4865005612373352,
-0.3928076922893524,
-0.17668843269348145,
0.9070202112197876,
0.5615050792694092,
-0.23357129096984863,
0.5602831244468689,
-0.14129123091697693,
-0.15520192682743073,
0.49936941266059875,
0.5289987921714783,
0.6800612807273865,
-0.1802189201116562,
0.4260452687740326,
0.03829776868224144,
0.648996114730835,
-0.25783607363700867,
0.09720202535390854,
0.24615108966827393,
-0.7766276001930237,
-0.14656537771224976,
-0.3153885304927826,
-0.2144206166267395,
-0.11808351427316666,
-0.7062885761260986,
0.5075024962425232,
-0.42999109625816345,
-0.1846238523721695,
0.0873059406876564,
-0.5437763333320618,
-0.40964367985725403,
0.16353237628936768,
-0.17412059009075165,
0.8385177850723267,
-0.6515013575553894,
0.6879451870918274,
0.5108426213264465,
-0.6982999444007874,
-0.5179072022438049,
-0.2076253443956375,
0.444746732711792,
-0.7495937943458557,
0.4204033315181732,
0.415730744600296,
-0.5179797410964966,
0.17282727360725403,
-0.8049605488777161,
-0.40805965662002563,
1.3007512092590332,
0.5009440183639526,
-0.3359014689922333,
-0.2833731174468994,
0.16289743781089783,
0.1828683614730835,
-0.3879108428955078,
-0.1139434203505516,
-0.09209871292114258,
0.5871968269348145,
0.21060407161712646,
-0.43401578068733215,
0.11680211126804352,
-0.41027069091796875,
0.013270187191665173,
0.43963196873664856,
-0.4453710913658142,
0.3392784297466278,
-0.4362102746963501,
-0.2318163365125656,
0.1376815140247345,
-0.10525499284267426,
-0.0013403150951489806,
0.8391897082328796,
0.3678463399410248,
0.8275301456451416,
0.5443927049636841,
0.015887584537267685,
0.7270790934562683,
-0.09312918037176132,
0.1979929655790329,
0.7442377209663391,
-0.45493394136428833,
0.5417928099632263,
0.6444461941719055,
0.5754185318946838,
0.014457511715590954,
0.3560047149658203,
-0.6705226898193359,
0.712702214717865,
-0.3710155189037323,
-0.1034030094742775,
-0.11225384473800659,
-0.40845561027526855,
-0.25524982810020447,
0.328499436378479,
0.12864995002746582,
-0.45596879720687866,
-0.1649053990840912,
0.05909859389066696,
-0.004313885699957609,
0.192414328455925,
-0.45837315917015076,
0.5114600658416748,
0.1683400273323059,
-0.28061509132385254,
-0.16809014976024628,
-0.05495534837245941,
0.6140021681785583,
-0.2990528345108032,
-0.11314168572425842,
0.4936794638633728,
0.150380477309227,
-0.5034337043762207,
-0.9541100263595581,
0.6662557125091553,
0.21169397234916687,
-0.16414980590343475,
-0.4175748825073242,
0.8940812945365906,
-0.4035624861717224,
-0.5823147296905518,
0.2847554683685303,
0.09052228927612305,
-0.2937161922454834,
0.1926421970129013,
-0.5620600581169128,
0.12299895286560059,
-0.2986737787723541,
0.03268706053495407,
0.17460955679416656,
0.2374807894229889,
-0.1266380101442337,
0.20665672421455383,
0.7348291277885437,
-0.13135215640068054,
-0.22439877688884735,
-0.17679913341999054,
0.5412216186523438,
-0.11085838079452515,
-0.40814247727394104,
-0.9909504055976868,
0.7191373109817505,
-0.4509375989437103,
-0.37923455238342285,
0.4840404987335205,
0.5529466271400452,
1.1038157939910889,
0.07811220735311508,
0.7033500671386719,
0.03333435580134392,
-0.12189783155918121,
-0.5611111521720886,
1.2174102067947388,
-1.0254286527633667,
0.026127653196454048,
-0.547649085521698,
-0.8097680807113647,
-0.3194616734981537,
0.6593186259269714,
-0.26201242208480835,
-0.13495829701423645,
0.45891106128692627,
0.8977742195129395,
-0.2878151834011078,
0.39796337485313416,
0.2317400723695755,
-0.11912751197814941,
0.21733734011650085,
0.06385751813650131,
0.6880236864089966,
-0.23535342514514923,
0.5510162115097046,
-0.1789083331823349,
-0.5491479635238647,
0.038296859711408615,
-1.5412685871124268,
-0.5307104587554932,
-0.6378207802772522,
-0.24162626266479492,
-0.374207079410553,
0.46252524852752686,
0.6052103638648987,
0.859253466129303,
-0.059379931539297104,
-0.052487146109342575,
-0.17345309257507324,
-0.2517348825931549,
-0.051232606172561646,
-0.14516553282737732,
-0.03553266450762749,
-0.0052763004787266254,
-0.559583306312561,
-0.2976256310939789,
0.7759203314781189,
-0.10398127883672714,
-0.20865635573863983,
-0.06480048596858978,
0.060109104961156845,
0.4143524467945099,
0.5883356332778931,
-0.010890163481235504,
-0.7241654992103577,
-0.26816606521606445,
0.3578682243824005,
-0.14585237205028534,
0.2420019954442978,
0.6223477125167847,
-0.052522554993629456,
0.5676489472389221,
0.04621804505586624,
0.7494457960128784,
-0.032405171543359756,
-0.07252853363752365,
0.8114550709724426,
-0.3249335289001465,
-0.10796508193016052,
0.41751614212989807,
0.27416542172431946,
0.47360584139823914,
-0.7252040505409241,
0.5874159336090088,
0.12798821926116943,
-0.7693425416946411,
-1.001265048980713,
0.43927669525146484,
-1.0448890924453735,
-0.10500310361385345,
1.027008056640625,
0.027631975710392,
-0.21234215795993805,
0.3946051597595215,
-0.3115836977958679,
0.11043840646743774,
-0.4433296322822571,
0.5891307592391968,
0.6275174021720886,
0.5564799308776855,
-0.1977226287126541,
-0.6807796359062195,
0.1813422590494156,
0.13654489815235138,
-0.9073848724365234,
-0.17698298394680023,
0.7097285389900208,
0.48391804099082947,
0.1787521243095398,
0.5482776165008545,
-0.9691054821014404,
0.5745641589164734,
-0.3746257424354553,
0.1498328596353531,
-0.17667974531650543,
-0.19028827548027039,
0.0006545332726091146,
-0.16644762456417084,
-0.20925962924957275,
-0.09981437027454376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12096v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12096v2
|
LongEmbed: Extending Embedding Models for Long Context Retrieval
| 2024-04-18T11:29:23 | 2024-04-25T02:26:15 |
Dawei Zhu, Liang Wang, Nan Yang, Yifan Song, Wenhao Wu, Furu Wei, Sujian Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Embedding models play a pivot role in modern NLP applications such as IR and
RAG. While the context limit of LLMs has been pushed beyond 1 million tokens,
embedding models are still confined to a narrow context window not exceeding 8k
tokens, refrained from application scenarios requiring long inputs such as
legal contracts. This paper explores context window extension of existing
embedding models, pushing the limit to 32k without requiring additional
training. First, we examine the performance of current embedding models for
long context retrieval on our newly constructed LongEmbed benchmark. LongEmbed
comprises two synthetic tasks and four carefully chosen real-world tasks,
featuring documents of varying length and dispersed target information.
Benchmarking results underscore huge room for improvement in these models.
Based on this, comprehensive experiments show that training-free context window
extension strategies like position interpolation can effectively extend the
context window of existing embedding models by several folds, regardless of
their original context being 512 or beyond 4k. Furthermore, for models
employing absolute position encoding (APE), we show the possibility of further
fine-tuning to harvest notable performance gains while strictly preserving
original behavior for short inputs. For models using rotary position embedding
(RoPE), significant enhancements are observed when employing RoPE-specific
methods, such as NTK and SelfExtend, indicating RoPE's superiority over APE for
context window extension. To facilitate future research, we release E5-Base-4k
and E5-RoPE-Base, along with the LongEmbed benchmark.
|
[
-0.5850153565406799,
-0.6776336431503296,
0.6268520355224609,
0.2443813979625702,
-0.4621434807777405,
-0.23231536149978638,
-0.41407251358032227,
-0.8624969124794006,
0.13968804478645325,
0.5893340706825256,
-0.22999723255634308,
-0.7071261405944824,
-0.6311832070350647,
-0.07642918825149536,
-0.49826112389564514,
0.8084760308265686,
-0.15742066502571106,
-0.3682096004486084,
-0.4351404309272766,
-0.45087555050849915,
-0.6793546080589294,
-0.6860023736953735,
-0.08973944187164307,
-0.1415712684392929,
0.3910336196422577,
0.2896365821361542,
0.3461827039718628,
0.5745728611946106,
0.3463086485862732,
0.15394656360149384,
-0.04347303509712219,
0.03957910090684891,
-0.5003485083580017,
0.37220340967178345,
-0.2633437514305115,
-0.3098140060901642,
-0.6663103699684143,
0.08593582361936569,
0.6891594529151917,
0.5516256093978882,
0.090837761759758,
0.026491204276680946,
0.23244518041610718,
0.5555390119552612,
-0.8576427102088928,
0.1097392663359642,
-0.3862288296222687,
-0.02203254960477352,
-0.09969150274991989,
-0.19339513778686523,
-0.5560221076011658,
0.1277609020471573,
0.34105589985847473,
-0.3277420103549957,
0.04774792119860649,
0.10298547148704529,
0.5517241954803467,
0.27857494354248047,
-0.8770634531974792,
-0.2860058546066284,
-0.46663472056388855,
0.827038586139679,
-0.6884819269180298,
0.5896547436714172,
0.5181301832199097,
0.2734122574329376,
-0.15300185978412628,
-0.8256978988647461,
-0.10455669462680817,
-0.39446237683296204,
0.02694208174943924,
-0.00808699894696474,
-0.0022168343421071768,
0.20218545198440552,
0.40267619490623474,
0.005480336491018534,
-0.22289884090423584,
0.13930319249629974,
-0.2911311686038971,
0.2110443115234375,
0.5513691902160645,
-0.07843328267335892,
-0.026082808151841164,
-0.04120522737503052,
-0.7848212122917175,
-0.09291296452283859,
-0.8889856338500977,
0.02774936892092228,
0.159678652882576,
0.05625085532665253,
-0.019290447235107422,
0.5840356945991516,
-0.05092819035053253,
0.928888738155365,
-0.30158138275146484,
0.1561218649148941,
0.05800257995724678,
-0.06387340277433395,
-0.1510123312473297,
0.0689450353384018,
0.14924101531505585,
0.6040140390396118,
-0.1435430943965912,
-0.11166593432426453,
-0.34345370531082153,
-0.2826376259326935,
0.35193949937820435,
-0.767163097858429,
0.3406566381454468,
-0.05244787409901619,
-0.3363136053085327,
0.16975851356983185,
0.18980933725833893,
-0.5359187126159668,
-0.13744913041591644,
-0.34391868114471436,
0.29348239302635193,
-0.6418889760971069,
-0.024060463532805443,
0.36430585384368896,
-0.10040591657161713,
0.6655286550521851,
0.40921828150749207,
-0.5180153846740723,
0.32966065406799316,
1.1137043237686157,
0.8000839948654175,
-0.473162442445755,
-0.2793058753013611,
-0.4499596357345581,
0.33241981267929077,
-0.15114185214042664,
0.38313180208206177,
-0.6643726229667664,
-0.3873653709888458,
0.22807343304157257,
0.27915316820144653,
0.1354367733001709,
-0.4126558303833008,
0.5424238443374634,
-0.695372462272644,
0.15625615417957306,
-0.035145170986652374,
-0.9846506714820862,
-0.3852100074291229,
0.38707950711250305,
-0.6833044290542603,
1.027211308479309,
0.1579044908285141,
-0.3274105191230774,
0.3056676983833313,
-0.9467822909355164,
-0.22672796249389648,
-0.13185827434062958,
0.027132874354720116,
-0.301826149225235,
0.2954123318195343,
0.1408444046974182,
0.6493291854858398,
-0.31058016419410706,
0.24636848270893097,
-0.4989634156227112,
-0.629470705986023,
0.05151309072971344,
-0.43370571732521057,
0.36346691846847534,
0.052177947014570236,
-0.19601163268089294,
-0.08972907066345215,
-0.35439449548721313,
-0.12717300653457642,
-0.1367485225200653,
-0.3533346354961395,
-0.7131891846656799,
-0.01301934290677309,
0.045483868569135666,
0.14328323304653168,
0.22901536524295807,
-0.6759234666824341,
0.47410982847213745,
-0.161342591047287,
0.5423024296760559,
0.5030922293663025,
-0.14794982969760895,
0.5347604155540466,
-0.1700121909379959,
0.6028067469596863,
-0.18269215524196625,
-0.19214944541454315,
-0.42532408237457275,
-0.2829378843307495,
-0.3760375380516052,
-0.3340967297554016,
0.435657799243927,
0.1831783503293991,
-0.3863270878791809,
0.47750598192214966,
-0.7432254552841187,
-0.012036692351102829,
-0.2785781919956207,
-0.163067027926445,
0.178071990609169,
0.2887159287929535,
0.588553249835968,
-0.3815392255783081,
-0.5112059712409973,
-0.925436794757843,
-0.24996913969516754,
0.36364641785621643,
-0.19190241396427155,
0.37815821170806885,
0.6595795750617981,
-0.2765892744064331,
1.2694976329803467,
-0.5251783132553101,
-0.42452529072761536,
0.01689242012798786,
-0.19938376545906067,
0.37107816338539124,
0.5600686073303223,
0.6099348664283752,
-0.7598364353179932,
-0.4821871519088745,
-0.2876441478729248,
-0.6795991063117981,
0.24289551377296448,
-0.0813591331243515,
0.008399536833167076,
0.1815798282623291,
0.8433572053909302,
-0.5866193771362305,
0.6350029706954956,
0.6305460929870605,
-0.32118964195251465,
0.2507106065750122,
-0.3357376456260681,
-0.1931159347295761,
-1.1099638938903809,
-0.07309540361166,
-0.020624736323952675,
-0.85992032289505,
-0.36983978748321533,
0.41207748651504517,
0.4764471650123596,
-0.28857696056365967,
-0.5271656513214111,
0.7314359545707703,
-0.7837595343589783,
-0.35488495230674744,
-0.557274580001831,
0.3790656626224518,
0.11750543117523193,
0.3911788761615753,
0.008957008831202984,
0.6512768864631653,
0.3022950291633606,
-0.417303204536438,
0.156023308634758,
0.034332726150751114,
-0.5563253164291382,
0.30628031492233276,
-0.6361417770385742,
0.3097948133945465,
-0.18188752233982086,
0.7657656669616699,
-0.737348735332489,
-0.04099329933524132,
-0.18066290020942688,
-0.2308105230331421,
0.5743194222450256,
-0.5964342951774597,
-0.2139335572719574,
-0.27108556032180786,
-0.5981631278991699,
0.6540231108665466,
0.4407513439655304,
-0.795361340045929,
0.4742129147052765,
0.22582270205020905,
0.0769413411617279,
-0.827346920967102,
-0.4998021423816681,
0.3444216251373291,
-0.4078831076622009,
-0.5408464074134827,
0.9991287589073181,
0.14601877331733704,
0.16100867092609406,
0.09347421675920486,
-0.24571357667446136,
0.108538419008255,
0.05259661376476288,
0.3021298050880432,
0.020062876865267754,
-0.21629278361797333,
0.25979986786842346,
0.10942482948303223,
-0.04998428001999855,
-0.0833517387509346,
-0.37804901599884033,
0.5439658761024475,
-0.2139407992362976,
-0.5116007924079895,
0.013856022618710995,
0.47977760434150696,
0.5372706055641174,
-0.2110104262828827,
0.7934800982475281,
0.44720175862312317,
-0.4692070782184601,
-0.1579880267381668,
-0.5610856413841248,
-0.19841629266738892,
-0.47472578287124634,
0.6647942066192627,
-0.59123295545578,
-1.0686956644058228,
0.32899904251098633,
-0.4015842378139496,
-0.00579046830534935,
0.17863687872886658,
0.13121388852596283,
-0.26465803384780884,
0.79261714220047,
0.998282790184021,
-0.16443948447704315,
0.6498336791992188,
-0.5003188848495483,
0.006694514770060778,
-1.3666175603866577,
0.07648490369319916,
-0.017162827774882317,
-0.4408039152622223,
-0.6085593700408936,
-0.8433055281639099,
0.3998640775680542,
0.37117820978164673,
0.015497628599405289,
0.557214617729187,
-0.30886250734329224,
0.4927418828010559,
0.37030676007270813,
0.21199531853199005,
-0.05575980618596077,
-0.1306689977645874,
-0.04481063783168793,
0.07615530490875244,
-0.5048844814300537,
-0.39544954895973206,
1.1343653202056885,
0.6009312868118286,
0.6276243329048157,
0.1854345053434372,
0.647581934928894,
0.45404645800590515,
0.24291221797466278,
-0.8700817227363586,
0.4909834563732147,
-0.054915640503168106,
-0.6128504276275635,
-0.3953409790992737,
0.27302712202072144,
-0.9902213215827942,
0.33314958214759827,
-0.006526169832795858,
-0.5769882202148438,
0.25016510486602783,
-0.06569328904151917,
-0.17315992712974548,
0.24679674208164215,
-0.4553939700126648,
0.615345299243927,
-0.12158800661563873,
-0.6191428303718567,
-0.3787429928779602,
-0.6294271349906921,
0.0139678455889225,
0.009798034094274044,
-0.06918034702539444,
-0.36309871077537537,
-0.4648307263851166,
0.715277373790741,
-0.34134116768836975,
0.8097284436225891,
-0.4737416207790375,
-0.1621266007423401,
0.3089310824871063,
-0.1492820829153061,
0.7704540491104126,
0.09983810782432556,
-0.23352614045143127,
0.14765198528766632,
-0.03956208750605583,
-0.4826667904853821,
-0.6098964214324951,
0.9211704730987549,
-0.48754581809043884,
-0.8452848196029663,
-0.2685306668281555,
-0.44289642572402954,
-0.20490634441375732,
0.12123570591211319,
-0.0019518183544278145,
0.4177035987377167,
-0.09517581015825272,
1.0353683233261108,
0.38435742259025574,
-0.2323211431503296,
0.5853753089904785,
0.3905986249446869,
-0.19902253150939941,
-0.1168561652302742,
0.4298538565635681,
0.025159701704978943,
-0.041520100086927414,
0.40305671095848083,
-0.0574919693171978,
-0.4070098400115967,
-0.5254712700843811,
-0.1974640190601349,
0.060316864401102066,
-0.796448290348053,
-0.22931577265262604,
-0.5377650260925293,
-0.09200717508792877,
-0.3785981237888336,
-0.3180690407752991,
-0.5058040618896484,
-0.5459062457084656,
-0.08716201037168503,
-0.30511727929115295,
0.3650239109992981,
0.46820738911628723,
0.019359759986400604,
0.34110671281814575,
-0.864143967628479,
0.016436107456684113,
0.16415001451969147,
0.5452089905738831,
0.026924198493361473,
-0.53790283203125,
-0.5458307266235352,
-0.05036846175789833,
-0.25013741850852966,
-0.867339015007019,
0.5944159030914307,
0.2565147578716278,
0.49156439304351807,
0.2384643852710724,
0.18210449814796448,
0.6972112655639648,
-0.7742229700088501,
0.6748957633972168,
0.0205728467553854,
-0.7890686988830566,
0.3123888075351715,
-0.3696456551551819,
0.3099762499332428,
0.3867878019809723,
0.5360434651374817,
-0.47976142168045044,
0.2227937877178192,
-0.17996056377887726,
-1.1131178140640259,
0.44855785369873047,
0.06940259039402008,
0.38872841000556946,
-0.07448417693376541,
0.5991691946983337,
0.1864985227584839,
-0.14762985706329346,
-0.6015923023223877,
0.054363932460546494,
-0.13186194002628326,
-0.015025768429040909,
-0.17224302887916565,
-0.451973021030426,
-0.07703424990177155,
-0.3343473970890045,
0.322969913482666,
-0.3513622581958771,
0.6692525148391724,
0.31644028425216675,
-0.4838210344314575,
0.3096200227737427,
0.1715037226676941,
0.7362562417984009,
0.8315954208374023,
-0.3992307782173157,
0.01710103079676628,
0.4819697141647339,
-0.08572446554899216,
0.15237660706043243,
0.08754212409257889,
0.14702236652374268,
0.02369100973010063,
0.4041207432746887,
0.9409076571464539,
0.35231930017471313,
-0.3986809253692627,
0.662629246711731,
0.1000119000673294,
0.047089919447898865,
-0.6602999567985535,
-0.08465925604104996,
0.16258712112903595,
0.2421383261680603,
0.5330922603607178,
-0.3877076506614685,
0.19351975619792938,
-0.46666938066482544,
0.39561644196510315,
0.5895682573318481,
-0.5771512389183044,
-0.24270516633987427,
0.5268495678901672,
0.20750746130943298,
-0.3445814847946167,
0.5352032780647278,
0.2606884837150574,
-0.41348621249198914,
0.5676648616790771,
0.7734692096710205,
0.7150572538375854,
0.020220503211021423,
-0.36486005783081055,
0.29622626304626465,
0.015305500477552414,
0.009594655595719814,
-0.1162242516875267,
-0.3786008358001709,
-0.522973358631134,
-0.5645878314971924,
-0.4352712035179138,
-0.37061193585395813,
-0.07609055191278458,
-0.9139123558998108,
0.49652740359306335,
-0.11565845459699631,
-0.43276098370552063,
-0.47527366876602173,
-0.022957436740398407,
-0.7337779402732849,
0.007325697690248489,
0.27024850249290466,
1.2323532104492188,
-0.24536874890327454,
1.3241301774978638,
0.6364290714263916,
0.08995267003774643,
-0.09552114456892014,
0.0348191037774086,
-0.34470459818840027,
-0.7205069661140442,
0.552797257900238,
0.6378317475318909,
-0.12310098856687546,
-0.15937218070030212,
-0.7000882029533386,
-0.9941397905349731,
1.4387677907943726,
0.09834812581539154,
-0.714462161064148,
-0.4171021282672882,
0.13616110384464264,
0.47582024335861206,
-0.640221118927002,
0.07098139822483063,
0.28627169132232666,
0.2015666663646698,
-0.3210657238960266,
-0.7012885212898254,
0.20081812143325806,
0.0032515532802790403,
0.1938467025756836,
0.19231216609477997,
-0.4917605221271515,
0.49748727679252625,
0.10447850078344345,
0.07857123017311096,
0.16479609906673431,
0.8078340888023376,
0.22299818694591522,
0.2575312852859497,
0.5933188199996948,
0.4133600890636444,
0.3257980942726135,
0.045697715133428574,
1.2506885528564453,
-0.7234169840812683,
0.5273019075393677,
1.3421169519424438,
-0.2902124226093292,
1.0834786891937256,
0.6152461171150208,
0.13831399381160736,
0.5380507111549377,
0.47133752703666687,
0.2484346479177475,
0.6247764229774475,
0.10245328396558762,
-0.24661582708358765,
-0.12839476764202118,
0.051973115652799606,
-0.5386107563972473,
0.48517748713493347,
0.7368268966674805,
-0.5270994901657104,
-0.1250021606683731,
0.37604638934135437,
-0.1401822417974472,
-0.19769808650016785,
0.01757325418293476,
0.48621952533721924,
0.4754942059516907,
-0.7423207759857178,
0.6388891935348511,
0.38018926978111267,
0.9688113927841187,
-0.5058648586273193,
-0.10766155272722244,
-0.19958773255348206,
0.12908758223056793,
0.24165283143520355,
-0.7722041606903076,
0.25885093212127686,
-0.2541672885417938,
0.054396286606788635,
-0.4798557460308075,
0.8446277379989624,
-0.3787163496017456,
0.01925298012793064,
0.6997982263565063,
0.23236683011054993,
0.03211083263158798,
-0.0434248112142086,
-0.47774365544319153,
-0.09965857863426208,
-0.17068304121494293,
-0.49590760469436646,
0.5212885141372681,
0.22907377779483795,
-0.29455816745758057,
0.6315100789070129,
0.5010623931884766,
-0.3293934464454651,
0.1637117713689804,
-0.34894073009490967,
0.8683257699012756,
-0.9982161521911621,
-0.35029780864715576,
-0.8178663849830627,
0.29959604144096375,
-0.11099867522716522,
0.007729846518486738,
0.5989463329315186,
0.5154795050621033,
0.834510087966919,
-0.1350889503955841,
0.42719566822052,
0.10664399713277817,
0.31637805700302124,
-0.5408940315246582,
0.44572001695632935,
-0.7175865173339844,
0.20611032843589783,
-0.008993237279355526,
-1.2189059257507324,
-0.23323577642440796,
0.38840195536613464,
-0.44810089468955994,
-0.03150233253836632,
0.5011615753173828,
0.445896714925766,
-0.37412911653518677,
-0.24570219218730927,
0.5371416211128235,
0.060754600912332535,
0.5141685605049133,
0.5516418814659119,
0.8878707885742188,
-0.4432012438774109,
0.19031931459903717,
-0.21526053547859192,
0.012854594737291336,
-0.5534464120864868,
-1.2078837156295776,
-0.5629600286483765,
-0.5380564332008362,
-0.011102795600891113,
-0.07324593514204025,
0.15067486464977264,
1.0919909477233887,
1.02700936794281,
-0.3992222249507904,
-0.19845443964004517,
0.29472607374191284,
-0.06751278787851334,
0.050372589379549026,
-0.2010607123374939,
0.44992950558662415,
-0.15400457382202148,
-0.8178532123565674,
0.8487669229507446,
0.26904696226119995,
0.07994445413351059,
-0.0720057412981987,
-0.16898180544376373,
-0.3027493953704834,
0.04551074281334877,
1.040337085723877,
0.232744038105011,
-0.6108596920967102,
-0.5933379530906677,
0.0833631083369255,
0.05651865154504776,
0.1321459412574768,
0.7442318797111511,
-0.9779738783836365,
0.2646425664424896,
0.4521884322166443,
0.6493832468986511,
1.0364552736282349,
0.1551550328731537,
0.7421074509620667,
-1.0700197219848633,
0.3782597780227661,
0.28620365262031555,
0.5388655662536621,
0.1838439255952835,
-0.16881202161312103,
0.717014491558075,
-0.24331209063529968,
-0.43052569031715393,
-0.8960185050964355,
0.1739509403705597,
-0.8187251091003418,
-0.4982872009277344,
1.0573513507843018,
-0.45763352513313293,
-0.22930532693862915,
0.08596409112215042,
0.029661690816283226,
0.20839592814445496,
-0.1767771989107132,
0.5428590774536133,
0.6827262043952942,
-0.25826674699783325,
-0.0036830147728323936,
-0.7148921489715576,
0.35553500056266785,
0.6542940735816956,
-0.3255545496940613,
-0.08537687361240387,
0.421665757894516,
0.25105637311935425,
0.005528603680431843,
0.3219377100467682,
-0.16714370250701904,
0.10862187296152115,
-0.5325078368186951,
-0.07725702971220016,
-0.22330500185489655,
-0.5166304111480713,
-0.4781007170677185,
0.3521832823753357,
0.06257478892803192,
-0.25259092450141907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12077v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12077v1
|
TIMIT Speaker Profiling: A Comparison of Multi-task learning and Single-task learning Approaches
| 2024-04-18T10:59:54 | 2024-04-18T10:59:54 |
Rong Wang, Kun Sun
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
This study employs deep learning techniques to explore four speaker profiling
tasks on the TIMIT dataset, namely gender classification, accent
classification, age estimation, and speaker identification, highlighting the
potential and challenges of multi-task learning versus single-task models. The
motivation for this research is twofold: firstly, to empirically assess the
advantages and drawbacks of multi-task learning over single-task models in the
context of speaker profiling; secondly, to emphasize the undiminished
significance of skillful feature engineering for speaker recognition tasks. The
findings reveal challenges in accent classification, and multi-task learning is
found advantageous for tasks of similar complexity. Non-sequential features are
favored for speaker recognition, but sequential ones can serve as starting
points for complex models. The study underscores the necessity of meticulous
experimentation and parameter tuning for deep learning models.
|
[
-0.5575763583183289,
-0.6510360836982727,
0.26112377643585205,
-0.05193230137228966,
0.10931741446256638,
0.23385398089885712,
-0.3857721984386444,
-0.4515491724014282,
-0.19536848366260529,
0.5347204208374023,
-0.8636404871940613,
-0.2883414030075073,
-0.5238655805587769,
0.08458970487117767,
-0.1360749751329422,
0.6886318325996399,
0.6051905751228333,
0.053040724247694016,
0.2834005355834961,
-0.24013078212738037,
-1.123392105102539,
-0.3850027322769165,
-1.1470359563827515,
-0.17997847497463226,
0.4410113990306854,
0.9509789943695068,
0.17232999205589294,
0.19709832966327667,
0.3537476062774658,
0.34825825691223145,
0.1729828119277954,
0.23861047625541687,
-0.19141702353954315,
0.2650071680545807,
0.05806827172636986,
-0.13394927978515625,
-0.12325885891914368,
0.4406992793083191,
0.652357816696167,
0.8979683518409729,
0.13937366008758545,
0.3076220750808716,
0.19201286137104034,
0.5393563508987427,
-0.2435111403465271,
0.16436763107776642,
-0.5973982214927673,
0.2024882733821869,
-0.42364487051963806,
-0.3647628128528595,
-0.489544540643692,
-0.017002757638692856,
0.406040221452713,
-0.2612319886684418,
0.7716108560562134,
0.21999229490756989,
0.5870113372802734,
0.13486164808273315,
-0.6841397881507874,
-0.06320935487747192,
-0.9405679106712341,
1.072609782218933,
-0.4073416292667389,
0.5852750539779663,
0.3721027970314026,
0.5690714716911316,
0.21274368464946747,
-0.39749276638031006,
-0.36993470788002014,
-0.47430551052093506,
-0.12024728208780289,
-0.2435956597328186,
0.23453688621520996,
0.1222270280122757,
0.36406829953193665,
0.34870606660842896,
-0.47871214151382446,
0.19350549578666687,
-0.4321782886981964,
-0.07935056835412979,
0.44422778487205505,
-0.2544475495815277,
0.18648262321949005,
-0.1798545867204666,
-0.5044184327125549,
-0.4498312175273895,
-0.2271915078163147,
0.09479077160358429,
0.5876258611679077,
1.1923507452011108,
-0.03947899118065834,
0.1333145797252655,
-0.025223037227988243,
0.09370119869709015,
0.07277069240808487,
-0.10589636862277985,
0.4218166470527649,
-0.2174510359764099,
-0.17487600445747375,
0.07115276902914047,
0.8320122957229614,
-0.13962462544441223,
0.3210712969303131,
-0.2572368383407593,
0.08675120770931244,
-0.5491016507148743,
0.36397629976272583,
-0.6666131019592285,
-0.13272391259670258,
0.4193302392959595,
-0.41045328974723816,
-0.02899819053709507,
0.2405300736427307,
-0.9522597193717957,
-0.47009655833244324,
-0.3851298689842224,
0.3854353725910187,
-0.6365266442298889,
-0.5907450914382935,
-0.1367369145154953,
-0.38974425196647644,
0.06063225492835045,
0.31402087211608887,
-0.8482189178466797,
0.5216979384422302,
0.5275422930717468,
0.6997768878936768,
-0.14948208630084991,
-0.4565710425376892,
-0.650985836982727,
-0.28228479623794556,
-0.22385118901729584,
0.48024946451187134,
-0.4523170590400696,
-0.38884860277175903,
-0.14795029163360596,
-0.07355756312608719,
-0.29835978150367737,
-0.530314028263092,
0.5939534902572632,
-0.08929576724767685,
0.12969884276390076,
-0.595967710018158,
-0.20096097886562347,
-0.38621652126312256,
-0.002202895237132907,
-0.9318416118621826,
1.4260141849517822,
0.1274169236421585,
-0.7983171939849854,
0.705780029296875,
-0.9029966592788696,
-0.3986077308654785,
0.16270774602890015,
-0.3632977604866028,
-0.4975154995918274,
0.16633881628513336,
0.2228553295135498,
0.8291673064231873,
-0.24165129661560059,
0.1981436312198639,
-0.1625535786151886,
-0.25455307960510254,
0.043002694845199585,
-0.3883880078792572,
0.7553765177726746,
0.39593935012817383,
-0.530062735080719,
-0.00617633294314146,
-0.8527036905288696,
-0.32261210680007935,
0.24014779925346375,
-0.07215911149978638,
-0.14943727850914001,
0.09258364886045456,
0.32902252674102783,
0.034153781831264496,
-0.09969905763864517,
-0.8123021125793457,
-0.04118775203824043,
-0.17964497208595276,
0.28011077642440796,
0.5514470338821411,
-0.11850382387638092,
0.0813259556889534,
-0.4370003044605255,
0.3078143000602722,
0.12052664160728455,
0.03593989834189415,
-0.2906990647315979,
-0.4209531843662262,
-0.4155960977077484,
-0.4173874258995056,
0.4342108368873596,
0.7057247161865234,
-0.41075456142425537,
0.06230535730719566,
-0.107185959815979,
-0.4647732079029083,
-0.4533533751964569,
0.2055947184562683,
0.568662166595459,
0.289589524269104,
0.19580784440040588,
-0.369113028049469,
-0.5033132433891296,
-1.0114861726760864,
-0.28490060567855835,
-0.031024077907204628,
0.08940371125936508,
0.5435776710510254,
0.5041573643684387,
0.39929428696632385,
0.7106271386146545,
-0.09997174888849258,
-0.34451794624328613,
-0.3466886281967163,
0.6479171514511108,
-0.06185454502701759,
0.7033452987670898,
0.958544909954071,
-1.083753228187561,
-0.5066186189651489,
0.21304333209991455,
-0.4823547899723053,
0.17115944623947144,
-0.021524960175156593,
0.4454443156719208,
-0.26483139395713806,
0.2397194504737854,
-0.5640238523483276,
0.2627469599246979,
0.005739310290664434,
-0.1417800486087799,
0.41923218965530396,
0.016893217340111732,
0.7479117512702942,
-0.9372105598449707,
0.11979424953460693,
0.39546042680740356,
-0.14602723717689514,
-1.0768650770187378,
-0.026442909613251686,
-0.05542697757482529,
-0.37751710414886475,
-0.5330317616462708,
0.506679356098175,
-0.4795211851596832,
-0.05920378863811493,
-0.25779300928115845,
-0.2089812457561493,
-0.09685423970222473,
0.7656456828117371,
-0.12998470664024353,
1.0688014030456543,
0.5063331723213196,
-0.45411914587020874,
0.21894167363643646,
0.21221306920051575,
-0.3336373567581177,
0.5424525141716003,
-0.24512721598148346,
0.751756489276886,
-0.049198199063539505,
-0.224061980843544,
-1.6455706357955933,
-0.05365529656410217,
0.030957914888858795,
-0.5810185670852661,
0.8051614761352539,
-0.20769456028938293,
-0.5347240567207336,
-0.2791667580604553,
-0.38647177815437317,
0.5864576697349548,
0.10038699209690094,
-0.4475533068180084,
0.7356119751930237,
0.2793731391429901,
-0.5545113682746887,
-0.7613958716392517,
-0.5133805274963379,
0.022180672734975815,
-0.5736044049263,
-0.2290722131729126,
0.4564315676689148,
0.07342908531427383,
-0.29328295588493347,
-0.540288507938385,
-0.18952086567878723,
-0.28569114208221436,
0.14494724571704865,
0.37763670086860657,
-0.2604505717754364,
-0.29396891593933105,
0.4182959496974945,
-0.2862558364868164,
-0.08500547707080841,
-0.3447330594062805,
0.036013759672641754,
0.5386388897895813,
0.010510064661502838,
-0.2927662134170532,
-0.8251888751983643,
0.8124238848686218,
0.4683689773082733,
-0.48814356327056885,
0.5527970194816589,
1.0204898118972778,
-0.30379655957221985,
-0.26897716522216797,
-1.157472848892212,
-0.3408661186695099,
-0.45950427651405334,
0.44989776611328125,
-0.6851413249969482,
-0.9406781792640686,
0.5249562859535217,
-0.22642770409584045,
0.051420122385025024,
0.551590621471405,
0.1452799290418625,
-0.1176159456372261,
0.730583667755127,
1.0676865577697754,
-0.2453821301460266,
0.6812620759010315,
-0.13104254007339478,
0.05812002345919609,
-0.3678341805934906,
-0.1910017877817154,
-1.1456849575042725,
-0.3513405919075012,
-0.5939250588417053,
-0.0690406784415245,
0.08238602429628372,
-0.35446569323539734,
-0.4152916967868805,
0.4933629035949707,
-0.6694343686103821,
0.21777160465717316,
0.978431761264801,
0.3092774748802185,
-0.03177507221698761,
-0.126207634806633,
-0.08018022030591965,
-0.046989791095256805,
-0.28437790274620056,
-0.35711756348609924,
1.1331126689910889,
0.46257707476615906,
0.3898945450782776,
-0.03001914545893669,
0.3995263874530792,
0.6141107082366943,
-0.2478356957435608,
-0.5881929397583008,
0.4503280520439148,
-0.42352280020713806,
-0.7520991563796997,
-0.7604037523269653,
-0.43849658966064453,
-0.7854092121124268,
0.09433992952108383,
-0.03708736598491669,
-1.0674089193344116,
0.5158983469009399,
0.04433319345116615,
-0.41850489377975464,
0.529576301574707,
-1.0026333332061768,
0.9368742108345032,
-0.31728026270866394,
-0.045690957456827164,
-0.20545035600662231,
-0.6638041138648987,
0.07144083082675934,
-0.20913130044937134,
0.22201745212078094,
-0.4223109483718872,
0.4105638265609741,
0.945121705532074,
0.26706501841545105,
1.042974591255188,
-0.5664187669754028,
0.31585943698883057,
0.06883744895458221,
-0.01506807841360569,
0.19084449112415314,
-0.011328325606882572,
-0.35877034068107605,
0.14594359695911407,
0.19877111911773682,
-0.41835933923721313,
-0.26835155487060547,
0.46438243985176086,
-1.0393999814987183,
-0.7114366888999939,
-0.16425761580467224,
-0.7603906989097595,
-0.4970581531524658,
0.14625871181488037,
-0.036796167492866516,
0.6162590384483337,
-0.2891607880592346,
0.31788280606269836,
0.7299968004226685,
-0.24135351181030273,
0.5948931574821472,
0.12113132327795029,
0.2839171886444092,
-0.3365178406238556,
0.7540673613548279,
0.2974361479282379,
0.11619456857442856,
0.7004895806312561,
0.1757771372795105,
-0.10589045286178589,
-0.6933017373085022,
-0.03563905879855156,
0.19700802862644196,
-0.5989527106285095,
0.2728738486766815,
-0.5561478734016418,
-0.12184760719537735,
-0.6681830286979675,
0.5368676781654358,
-0.5234276056289673,
-0.30691125988960266,
-0.009964403696358204,
-0.13823866844177246,
0.21066536009311676,
0.6526665687561035,
0.32916417717933655,
0.7377582788467407,
-0.31968405842781067,
0.2882976830005646,
0.5166643261909485,
0.19312138855457306,
-0.18569540977478027,
-0.35501086711883545,
-0.28620433807373047,
-0.28804516792297363,
-0.6601316332817078,
-1.0934038162231445,
0.13625562191009521,
0.4988200068473816,
0.8645448088645935,
0.45803406834602356,
-0.04036938399076462,
0.557270884513855,
-0.40970689058303833,
0.7525815963745117,
-0.039682984352111816,
-0.8562215566635132,
0.7164422273635864,
-0.4038480818271637,
0.0910506621003151,
0.8706677556037903,
0.44596704840660095,
-0.33781927824020386,
0.0025491563137620687,
-0.513154149055481,
-0.5042678713798523,
0.9936223030090332,
0.15136517584323883,
0.1698809713125229,
0.1611061841249466,
0.37373805046081543,
0.694703221321106,
0.5949980020523071,
-0.42884284257888794,
-0.4060739278793335,
-0.31247925758361816,
0.1053520068526268,
-0.3961292505264282,
-0.39035850763320923,
-0.16140690445899963,
-0.41787490248680115,
0.4889190196990967,
-0.20350733399391174,
0.5834041237831116,
-0.05514119938015938,
0.05321519076824188,
-0.11062658578157425,
0.6009309887886047,
0.6559342741966248,
0.563563346862793,
-0.6089216470718384,
0.1665695160627365,
0.37234044075012207,
-0.23140117526054382,
-0.036323606967926025,
0.3056770861148834,
0.6089630126953125,
0.1528647392988205,
0.37024471163749695,
1.0978695154190063,
0.07380349189043045,
-0.3698063790798187,
0.6280080080032349,
0.0025655117351561785,
-0.5727909803390503,
-0.3663909435272217,
-0.1359076201915741,
-0.2593652009963989,
0.5541168451309204,
0.8287014365196228,
0.06127960607409477,
0.18157434463500977,
-0.6770790219306946,
0.21856725215911865,
0.5371869802474976,
-0.5029280185699463,
-0.36797839403152466,
0.6190534830093384,
0.07331608980894089,
-0.5943240523338318,
0.7519718408584595,
0.04893505573272705,
-0.26417458057403564,
0.7024755477905273,
0.15232396125793457,
1.1410644054412842,
-0.7651913166046143,
0.06587480008602142,
0.2050335705280304,
0.27919963002204895,
0.09551291912794113,
0.34386250376701355,
-0.44930437207221985,
-0.7317529916763306,
-0.4056440591812134,
-0.24046754837036133,
-0.5648415684700012,
0.4536120593547821,
-0.5675432085990906,
0.28274911642074585,
-0.31133362650871277,
-0.6050487160682678,
0.5094280242919922,
0.38623136281967163,
-1.1067522764205933,
0.1866636574268341,
0.28153854608535767,
0.7756009697914124,
-1.1474500894546509,
0.9643615484237671,
0.6662102341651917,
-0.21493719518184662,
-0.697299063205719,
-0.1109357550740242,
0.25471097230911255,
-0.4045366644859314,
0.886885941028595,
0.4567900598049164,
-0.007312388624995947,
-0.16468660533428192,
-0.2270357459783554,
-0.41122967004776,
0.9499204754829407,
0.5132839679718018,
-0.42825326323509216,
-0.1931915134191513,
0.27348119020462036,
0.002717813942581415,
-0.2818441390991211,
0.5532627701759338,
0.40968677401542664,
0.5570067763328552,
-0.020528268069028854,
-1.5188696384429932,
-0.15203283727169037,
-0.3868297338485718,
-0.10890781879425049,
0.22814951837062836,
-0.8310229778289795,
1.1178646087646484,
0.045833755284547806,
-0.24788439273834229,
-0.10239272564649582,
0.5278130173683167,
-0.14572928845882416,
0.31214943528175354,
0.849340558052063,
0.254059374332428,
0.6962061524391174,
-0.268197625875473,
0.5733634233474731,
-0.17978675663471222,
0.3237941861152649,
1.0678865909576416,
-0.1752077043056488,
0.5532054901123047,
0.4723414480686188,
-0.46517378091812134,
-0.05514150485396385,
0.7494974732398987,
-0.10776162147521973,
0.4844018518924713,
-0.15587039291858673,
-0.13986529409885406,
-0.3984702527523041,
-0.04882074519991875,
-0.16607210040092468,
0.5437527894973755,
0.2039351761341095,
-0.03420696035027504,
-0.1341353803873062,
0.6219271421432495,
-0.16369906067848206,
-0.16923275589942932,
0.06379086524248123,
0.596649169921875,
0.09502206742763519,
-0.35293644666671753,
0.02492973767220974,
-0.21200419962406158,
0.5711875557899475,
-0.4315725564956665,
-0.14657391607761383,
0.11731022596359253,
0.06335931271314621,
-0.02611629292368889,
-0.386322557926178,
0.0066504632122814655,
-0.38704714179039,
-0.2449667602777481,
-0.4688849449157715,
0.6458239555358887,
-0.17028440535068512,
-0.27283424139022827,
0.38044309616088867,
0.7970868945121765,
0.17303837835788727,
-0.3302414119243622,
-0.7782756090164185,
-0.24385401606559753,
-0.1815681904554367,
-0.3832619786262512,
0.287046879529953,
0.49885034561157227,
0.13846077024936676,
0.7070371508598328,
0.3276911675930023,
-0.0052249436266720295,
0.049880631268024445,
0.2715930938720703,
0.3734675645828247,
-0.7832314968109131,
-0.49084386229515076,
-0.878170371055603,
0.3830198049545288,
-0.04558679834008217,
-0.45946967601776123,
0.7412106394767761,
0.6074263453483582,
0.8160894513130188,
-0.05119460076093674,
0.7136000990867615,
0.12088458240032196,
1.1012860536575317,
-0.20143140852451324,
0.3151586353778839,
-0.6208770275115967,
0.31290143728256226,
-0.4358419179916382,
-0.5319872498512268,
-0.10346733033657074,
0.10213208198547363,
-0.240045964717865,
0.5976491570472717,
0.7714452147483826,
0.7358489632606506,
-0.3040635883808136,
0.25835520029067993,
0.4756244421005249,
-0.23363539576530457,
0.31808149814605713,
0.28658604621887207,
0.8036802411079407,
-0.2824471592903137,
0.30771201848983765,
-0.6132850050926208,
-0.01624518446624279,
-0.23844723403453827,
-0.6900224089622498,
-1.21205735206604,
-1.0344234704971313,
-0.44500720500946045,
0.2678944170475006,
0.2070367932319641,
1.0891320705413818,
1.2228050231933594,
-1.0480751991271973,
-0.5222896933555603,
0.523974597454071,
-0.16590476036071777,
-0.8735098838806152,
-0.2055220901966095,
0.49247294664382935,
-0.4647272527217865,
-0.9264993667602539,
0.7670310139656067,
0.09126155078411102,
-0.19825398921966553,
-0.027601052075624466,
0.24179106950759888,
-0.20828355848789215,
-0.10712413489818573,
0.23932518064975739,
0.35057851672172546,
-0.7831128239631653,
-0.6616872549057007,
-0.20098473131656647,
0.0817747563123703,
0.46492481231689453,
1.0394635200500488,
-0.5447850823402405,
0.34887757897377014,
0.37205183506011963,
0.6645526885986328,
0.7558680772781372,
-0.062065646052360535,
0.33391818404197693,
-1.2408065795898438,
0.2407715618610382,
0.056834109127521515,
0.3742295801639557,
0.2702476382255554,
-0.35564544796943665,
0.3130350410938263,
0.10325012356042862,
-0.6548548936843872,
-1.0576783418655396,
0.054610725492239,
-1.4753446578979492,
-0.35920318961143494,
0.6723780035972595,
0.017712010070681572,
0.34725943207740784,
-0.4293312132358551,
-0.280530720949173,
0.47723448276519775,
-0.43590542674064636,
0.4749434292316437,
0.6885592341423035,
-0.20508360862731934,
-0.7621676325798035,
-1.3497378826141357,
0.6003864407539368,
0.41707587242126465,
-0.3344869315624237,
-0.12561744451522827,
-0.16361866891384125,
0.4101024568080902,
0.2910642623901367,
0.6046009063720703,
0.27453431487083435,
0.20411190390586853,
-0.08276889473199844,
0.22623153030872345,
-0.4676506519317627,
-0.705899178981781,
-0.03274807706475258,
0.816213071346283,
0.26405099034309387,
-0.6833316087722778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12065v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12065v1
|
RAGAR, Your Falsehood RADAR: RAG-Augmented Reasoning for Political Fact-Checking using Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-04-18T10:25:42 | 2024-04-18T10:25:42 |
M. Abdul Khaliq, P. Chang, M. Ma, B. Pflugfelder, F. Miletić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.ET, cs.MA
|
The escalating challenge of misinformation, particularly in the context of
political discourse, necessitates advanced solutions for fact-checking. We
introduce innovative approaches to enhance the reliability and efficiency of
multimodal fact-checking through the integration of Large Language Models
(LLMs) with Retrieval-augmented Generation (RAG)- based advanced reasoning
techniques. This work proposes two novel methodologies, Chain of RAG (CoRAG)
and Tree of RAG (ToRAG). The approaches are designed to handle multimodal
claims by reasoning the next questions that need to be answered based on
previous evidence. Our approaches improve the accuracy of veracity predictions
and the generation of explanations over the traditional fact-checking approach
of sub-question generation with chain of thought veracity prediction. By
employing multimodal LLMs adept at analyzing both text and images, this
research advances the capability of automated systems in identifying and
countering misinformation.
|
[
-0.5520756244659424,
-1.0336053371429443,
0.6760087013244629,
-0.07161290943622589,
-0.23528818786144257,
0.7800489664077759,
-0.037876904010772705,
-0.2507120668888092,
0.2743256092071533,
0.6773114800453186,
-0.2780666649341583,
-0.47102177143096924,
-0.7984890937805176,
-0.09519145637750626,
-0.2569296956062317,
0.9062134623527527,
0.10309512913227081,
-0.04810767620801926,
-0.17182981967926025,
-0.38632988929748535,
-0.30891257524490356,
-0.46961188316345215,
-0.14532126486301422,
-0.3850823938846588,
0.5319651961326599,
0.5269221663475037,
0.8373094201087952,
0.49727576971054077,
0.5578047037124634,
0.36431944370269775,
0.06968976557254791,
0.9683710336685181,
0.01992001198232174,
0.2887077033519745,
-0.3921072781085968,
-0.4954414665699005,
-0.4501344561576843,
0.3554351329803467,
0.472363144159317,
-0.013621581718325615,
-0.08624076843261719,
0.38460245728492737,
-0.4328911602497101,
0.5032851099967957,
-1.0481536388397217,
0.07608114182949066,
-0.9456836581230164,
-0.3493308126926422,
-0.3277364671230316,
-0.4896894097328186,
-0.5995774865150452,
-0.4815932512283325,
-0.3622128367424011,
-0.293690949678421,
0.09830879420042038,
0.31219515204429626,
0.9878699779510498,
0.3443134129047394,
-0.6978354454040527,
-0.6329185366630554,
-0.9225384593009949,
0.7341411709785461,
-0.3658464252948761,
0.4200364351272583,
0.5827924013137817,
0.4952733516693115,
-0.2243453860282898,
-0.5503628849983215,
-0.8010323643684387,
-0.2535375952720642,
-0.2875361740589142,
0.20850539207458496,
-0.11084063351154327,
-0.24992233514785767,
0.16614125669002533,
0.09879347681999207,
-0.5137919187545776,
-0.43818631768226624,
-0.09433110058307648,
-0.33057186007499695,
0.4400354027748108,
-0.15454024076461792,
0.06453864276409149,
-0.5394585728645325,
-0.6152681708335876,
-0.09785232692956924,
-0.5470931529998779,
-0.39300188422203064,
0.340465784072876,
0.1501561552286148,
-0.16602855920791626,
0.7297884821891785,
0.06464017182588577,
0.5850439667701721,
0.2545255422592163,
-0.6402304172515869,
0.165109783411026,
-0.5214062929153442,
-0.141023650765419,
-0.11082655191421509,
0.5728483200073242,
0.27067092061042786,
-0.21874529123306274,
0.09024956077337265,
-0.16447317600250244,
0.3940553665161133,
0.0769660696387291,
-0.22546397149562836,
0.18686053156852722,
0.19429577887058258,
-0.4199703335762024,
-0.383433073759079,
0.029184948652982712,
-1.1116670370101929,
-0.7934134602546692,
-0.14777031540870667,
0.4658788740634918,
-0.3552378714084625,
-0.45263659954071045,
-0.14930059015750885,
-0.289267361164093,
0.05839082971215248,
0.6064335107803345,
-0.011277560144662857,
-0.13608022034168243,
0.7182546257972717,
0.7502266764640808,
0.19413255155086517,
0.0950198620557785,
-0.6486878395080566,
0.25139081478118896,
-0.6655475497245789,
1.1476627588272095,
-0.7818633317947388,
0.025699753314256668,
-0.10683821141719818,
-0.10822532325983047,
-0.029561007395386696,
-0.45256519317626953,
0.786051332950592,
-0.8627437353134155,
0.385356068611145,
-0.19358158111572266,
-0.24122565984725952,
-0.4608897864818573,
0.7295913100242615,
-0.6242600679397583,
0.9417394399642944,
-0.2239248901605606,
-1.0128611326217651,
0.20032285153865814,
-0.6260279417037964,
-0.32169610261917114,
-0.07192575931549072,
-0.32268208265304565,
-0.5565215349197388,
-0.20386607944965363,
0.27915188670158386,
0.32823291420936584,
-0.5415292978286743,
0.5659403800964355,
-0.19971492886543274,
0.1416671723127365,
0.4312065541744232,
-0.5635982751846313,
0.7129537463188171,
0.444611519575119,
-0.43941906094551086,
0.19336432218551636,
-0.8508236408233643,
-0.05387840420007706,
-0.16003452241420746,
-0.2982485294342041,
-0.37417274713516235,
0.06926105171442032,
-0.1909136176109314,
0.11244487017393112,
0.26041266322135925,
-0.5417681932449341,
-0.0037082757335156202,
0.07758381962776184,
-0.23950089514255524,
0.7776187062263489,
-0.0021839907858520746,
0.31627336144447327,
-0.5740598440170288,
0.41892218589782715,
0.1738734245300293,
0.09700396656990051,
-0.2345009744167328,
-0.4850535988807678,
-0.6410280466079712,
-0.3894694447517395,
0.396355003118515,
0.8484300971031189,
-1.3845396041870117,
0.05510174483060837,
0.006164879538118839,
-0.6418453454971313,
-0.2431231439113617,
-0.18764223158359528,
0.4327686131000519,
0.4677605628967285,
0.35889992117881775,
0.31197047233581543,
-0.899465799331665,
-0.7563859820365906,
-0.5751425623893738,
-0.48731550574302673,
0.38839733600616455,
0.1281052827835083,
0.8129965662956238,
-0.3071884214878082,
0.8401403427124023,
-0.28579622507095337,
-0.07753688842058182,
-0.1405898928642273,
0.5124027132987976,
0.15609388053417206,
0.154934361577034,
0.4046388566493988,
-1.154127836227417,
-0.41843098402023315,
0.17355811595916748,
-0.5500431656837463,
-0.005932087078690529,
-0.3226432502269745,
0.12064731866121292,
0.6424452066421509,
0.2113477885723114,
-0.8419435024261475,
0.4051160514354706,
0.7900511026382446,
-0.5881142616271973,
0.6404691338539124,
-0.1364041417837143,
0.8571301698684692,
-0.919641375541687,
-0.07015381008386612,
-0.048865579068660736,
-0.5650866031646729,
-0.5007021427154541,
0.08960297703742981,
0.01871516741812229,
0.37045589089393616,
-0.09539926052093506,
0.44116446375846863,
-0.40715304017066956,
0.019292771816253662,
-0.46593695878982544,
-0.07472864538431168,
-0.032146286219358444,
0.13291683793067932,
-0.3608075976371765,
0.8402185440063477,
0.3912506401538849,
-0.40106114745140076,
0.5774568915367126,
0.007004613056778908,
-0.31009048223495483,
0.665703296661377,
-0.20560987293720245,
0.02616289258003235,
-0.36530375480651855,
0.43475496768951416,
-1.0596176385879517,
-0.4909721910953522,
0.4593208134174347,
-0.7545332312583923,
0.2555760145187378,
-0.32479313015937805,
-0.6764441132545471,
-0.16266213357448578,
-0.1545684039592743,
0.06160246953368187,
0.38850584626197815,
-0.6875369548797607,
1.2485018968582153,
0.6272128820419312,
0.18554964661598206,
-1.0253705978393555,
-0.4323207437992096,
0.16407135128974915,
-0.1463501751422882,
-0.4635108411312103,
0.13576753437519073,
0.16929084062576294,
-0.7920060157775879,
0.15077458322048187,
-0.23973308503627777,
-0.26688694953918457,
-0.28987616300582886,
0.2635730504989624,
0.32529082894325256,
-0.19689306616783142,
0.3099854290485382,
-0.18763916194438934,
-0.07893402874469757,
-0.1831083446741104,
0.13726137578487396,
0.3315829336643219,
-0.29974666237831116,
-0.4032246470451355,
-0.18181931972503662,
0.2709462642669678,
0.9212481379508972,
-0.4092436730861664,
0.7747155427932739,
0.7667860984802246,
-0.22443075478076935,
-0.0423671156167984,
-1.0844199657440186,
0.051119763404130936,
-0.4427954852581024,
0.0891370177268982,
-0.20897965133190155,
-0.602495014667511,
0.2406986802816391,
-0.4574603736400604,
0.1289864033460617,
0.46472692489624023,
0.6649901866912842,
-0.13121463358402252,
0.9480356574058533,
0.39453932642936707,
0.27642372250556946,
0.01346413604915142,
-0.0882703885436058,
0.10204962641000748,
-0.30239591002464294,
-0.3786229193210602,
-0.6216447949409485,
0.042385000735521317,
-0.6070164442062378,
-1.123594880104065,
0.6736096739768982,
-0.30037862062454224,
-0.2290010154247284,
-0.1590043604373932,
-0.28011900186538696,
0.5012577772140503,
0.31710386276245117,
-0.05730580911040306,
0.4418424665927887,
0.12182789295911789,
0.15340638160705566,
0.17985913157463074,
-0.6587892174720764,
-0.5147987604141235,
0.8191594481468201,
0.39368799328804016,
0.8774399757385254,
0.2578143775463104,
0.1468353420495987,
0.5724096894264221,
0.5170868635177612,
-0.48026254773139954,
0.556678056716919,
-0.21504388749599457,
-1.0723081827163696,
-0.05150015279650688,
-0.5337444543838501,
-0.5087661743164062,
0.5195478796958923,
-0.6511666774749756,
-0.11670248210430145,
0.12562255561351776,
0.3043428361415863,
-0.053323183208703995,
0.7558806538581848,
-0.4087941646575928,
0.13698215782642365,
-0.365636944770813,
-0.18476471304893494,
-0.61250239610672,
-0.5761520266532898,
0.6592716574668884,
0.04482417181134224,
0.8743612170219421,
-0.1783212572336197,
-0.19063185155391693,
0.504891037940979,
-0.02157353237271309,
0.8430968523025513,
-0.2642824649810791,
0.03031764179468155,
0.41533374786376953,
0.12548722326755524,
0.6261513829231262,
-0.05735327675938606,
0.15306898951530457,
0.029577964916825294,
-0.10732926428318024,
-0.062477562576532364,
-0.5289223790168762,
0.5620755553245544,
-0.49921345710754395,
-0.7071922421455383,
-0.8602349758148193,
-0.7639363408088684,
-0.13873761892318726,
0.027247007936239243,
0.031983066350221634,
0.515632688999176,
0.033287838101387024,
0.41525542736053467,
0.7982218861579895,
-0.2870374321937561,
0.0676991418004036,
0.5583046078681946,
-0.38890689611434937,
-0.5620514154434204,
0.7560362219810486,
0.31422853469848633,
0.09783397614955902,
0.4816339612007141,
0.40011894702911377,
-0.44759535789489746,
-0.19975587725639343,
-0.3526116907596588,
0.3261752128601074,
-0.8174729943275452,
-0.5135065913200378,
-0.661106288433075,
-0.09823744744062424,
-0.25635161995887756,
0.27397313714027405,
-0.6139113903045654,
-0.49146461486816406,
0.33028480410575867,
0.2579917013645172,
0.6109201312065125,
0.8895278573036194,
-0.5050317645072937,
0.18801657855510712,
-0.6627358794212341,
0.9035477042198181,
0.2285289317369461,
0.41006898880004883,
-0.4818446636199951,
-0.588354766368866,
-0.12121281027793884,
0.22340308129787445,
-0.3440819978713989,
-1.15811288356781,
0.07611826807260513,
-0.08006491512060165,
0.4355730712413788,
0.06902283430099487,
0.055224813520908356,
0.517504096031189,
-0.4781090021133423,
0.5530773401260376,
0.17792373895645142,
-0.6764059662818909,
0.37616679072380066,
-0.2908259332180023,
-0.11323154717683792,
-0.10403794795274734,
0.5321298837661743,
-0.13027921319007874,
-0.5021294355392456,
-0.6267516613006592,
-0.45792150497436523,
0.3448188304901123,
0.03500405326485634,
-0.2850399315357208,
-0.057083386927843094,
0.06801464408636093,
0.10926693677902222,
0.020427273586392403,
-0.4585535526275635,
-0.49776872992515564,
-0.2589499056339264,
-0.0995030403137207,
0.006297433283179998,
-0.4496605396270752,
-0.5790668725967407,
0.023551160469651222,
0.8696237802505493,
-0.339089959859848,
-0.05255041643977165,
0.24919097125530243,
0.20161744952201843,
-0.21612083911895752,
0.6293661594390869,
0.8568018078804016,
0.823775589466095,
-0.18268845975399017,
0.5380847454071045,
0.21089182794094086,
-0.36032846570014954,
0.3513769805431366,
-0.3205527067184448,
-0.11324184387922287,
0.5096079707145691,
0.33332744240760803,
0.38658198714256287,
-0.24293486773967743,
-0.4090062975883484,
0.5221018195152283,
0.08899424970149994,
-0.167694091796875,
-0.44546860456466675,
-0.2705118656158447,
0.09491011500358582,
0.48726174235343933,
0.5346674919128418,
0.6058252453804016,
-0.05825268104672432,
-0.7582896947860718,
0.24063023924827576,
0.7093486189842224,
0.1640615314245224,
-0.059812646359205246,
0.34158003330230713,
-0.06298191100358963,
-0.11841742694377899,
-0.08290522545576096,
-0.19291602075099945,
-0.7286878228187561,
0.5689577460289001,
0.37033316493034363,
0.4938710331916809,
-0.44067853689193726,
0.697482705116272,
0.46405887603759766,
0.7736284732818604,
-0.10910170525312424,
0.2489122748374939,
0.31064561009407043,
-0.7112556099891663,
-0.8468669056892395,
-0.3060823678970337,
-0.5238921642303467,
0.24912531673908234,
-0.19399558007717133,
0.06837401539087296,
-0.59794020652771,
-0.4082303047180176,
0.03760936111211777,
-0.006620181258767843,
-0.2199709266424179,
0.3385666608810425,
0.028809141367673874,
0.7663392424583435,
-0.8248991370201111,
0.49646008014678955,
0.623938262462616,
-0.11993660777807236,
-0.5185419321060181,
0.06339536607265472,
0.4204705059528351,
-0.7054598331451416,
0.8584884405136108,
-0.32964831590652466,
-0.7169466018676758,
-0.5513068437576294,
-0.785088062286377,
-1.013696312904358,
0.7816411852836609,
0.43945857882499695,
-0.39635246992111206,
0.19028735160827637,
-0.12000948190689087,
0.13108806312084198,
-0.30146968364715576,
0.2894241213798523,
0.46525895595550537,
0.8606579303741455,
0.38482430577278137,
-0.8991237878799438,
-0.036263685673475266,
0.08017197251319885,
-0.3155207931995392,
0.2484121471643448,
-0.5927156209945679,
0.9666993021965027,
-0.22218334674835205,
-0.4137977361679077,
-0.11759065091609955,
0.4785814583301544,
0.26274311542510986,
0.4582182466983795,
0.8663903474807739,
0.449444055557251,
0.804945707321167,
-0.14354804158210754,
1.0180130004882812,
-0.252300500869751,
0.16470520198345184,
1.2075048685073853,
-0.05877560377120972,
0.6525123715400696,
0.5196737051010132,
0.10902777314186096,
0.8950881361961365,
0.08295947313308716,
0.086912140250206,
0.2002081573009491,
-0.33143576979637146,
-0.24648387730121613,
-0.5299332737922668,
-0.3265511095523834,
-0.21663692593574524,
0.774212658405304,
0.6775442361831665,
0.02250397764146328,
-0.4226335287094116,
0.10531964898109436,
0.07292058318853378,
0.5207198858261108,
-0.09544491767883301,
0.5365740060806274,
-0.3525124490261078,
-0.6025148034095764,
0.7125387787818909,
0.15506526827812195,
0.5945886373519897,
-0.533745288848877,
-0.4657660126686096,
0.16654588282108307,
0.1466684341430664,
-0.3520837128162384,
-0.9804573655128479,
0.49904173612594604,
0.22387884557247162,
-0.2997719645500183,
-0.17442625761032104,
1.0197278261184692,
-0.46058428287506104,
-0.3769243359565735,
0.01083497516810894,
0.8320498466491699,
-0.06521186232566833,
0.04626040533185005,
-0.7481154203414917,
0.33190497756004333,
-0.09784223139286041,
-0.15676748752593994,
-0.1207813024520874,
0.45318248867988586,
-0.20623265206813812,
0.9365517497062683,
0.76284259557724,
0.25207456946372986,
-0.07296349853277206,
-0.1276024729013443,
0.8454678654670715,
-0.3895919919013977,
-0.2403518110513687,
-0.7548730373382568,
0.3957872688770294,
-0.2469479739665985,
0.22841514647006989,
0.9122672080993652,
0.452170729637146,
0.3978186547756195,
-0.0417848601937294,
0.820188045501709,
-0.2625475823879242,
1.2730704545974731,
-0.5211895704269409,
0.7489730715751648,
-0.4906124472618103,
0.15809567272663116,
-0.0711013600230217,
-0.41608554124832153,
-0.2612542510032654,
0.5495187640190125,
-0.3427235782146454,
-0.06573456525802612,
0.7559813857078552,
1.1830260753631592,
-0.20686286687850952,
-0.03704630956053734,
0.3285810351371765,
0.5791849493980408,
0.1614592969417572,
0.1508951187133789,
1.1799352169036865,
-0.2888852655887604,
0.7413308620452881,
-0.1292271465063095,
-0.3481609523296356,
-0.06812440603971481,
-0.9761353731155396,
-0.9070785045623779,
-0.7230167984962463,
-0.38597533106803894,
-0.6279013156890869,
0.10252556204795837,
0.7690304517745972,
0.7052131295204163,
-0.5686205625534058,
-0.08795018494129181,
0.27034875750541687,
0.6302003860473633,
0.16506941616535187,
-0.271854430437088,
0.3801886737346649,
-0.19399437308311462,
-0.3749467730522156,
0.2780209481716156,
0.3857029974460602,
-0.1585572361946106,
-0.2622695863246918,
-0.06279094517230988,
-0.7982279658317566,
0.5484182834625244,
0.6331188678741455,
0.1256391406059265,
-1.0839924812316895,
-0.4996385872364044,
-0.28480064868927,
-0.05612020567059517,
0.03161165863275528,
0.8660125136375427,
-0.7788212299346924,
0.4753554165363312,
0.5914595723152161,
0.5810394883155823,
0.11687548458576202,
0.2063426524400711,
0.15582695603370667,
-0.6831610202789307,
0.18945194780826569,
0.24304378032684326,
0.17637597024440765,
0.41829240322113037,
-0.2278132438659668,
0.3808847963809967,
0.2785845696926117,
-0.4926128089427948,
-0.9361200332641602,
0.5393770337104797,
-0.6863439083099365,
-0.556556224822998,
1.0594762563705444,
0.023625532165169716,
-0.34341752529144287,
-0.3742105960845947,
-0.34205442667007446,
0.2713768482208252,
-0.070528045296669,
0.7227470874786377,
0.6155418157577515,
-0.023207079619169235,
-0.32872939109802246,
-0.5711356401443481,
0.6093043684959412,
0.18031825125217438,
-0.8975494503974915,
0.09400860220193863,
0.645766019821167,
0.21778272092342377,
0.6658692359924316,
0.6146076917648315,
-0.16754627227783203,
0.506888747215271,
0.26524248719215393,
-0.24019435048103333,
-0.03470223769545555,
-0.676887571811676,
0.19166795909404755,
0.35048389434814453,
-0.25995010137557983,
-0.2071089744567871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12059v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12059v1
|
Constituents Correspond to Word Sequence Patterns among Sentences with Equivalent Predicate-Argument Structures: Unsupervised Constituency Parsing by Span Matching
| 2024-04-18T10:17:04 | 2024-04-18T10:17:04 |
Junjie Chen, Xiangheng He, Danushka Bollegala, Yusuke Miyao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Unsupervised constituency parsing is about identifying word sequences that
form a syntactic unit (i.e., constituents) in a target sentence. Linguists
identify the constituent by evaluating a set of Predicate-Argument Structure
(PAS) equivalent sentences where we find the constituent corresponds to
frequent word sequences. However, such information is unavailable to previous
parsing methods which identify the constituent by observing sentences with
diverse PAS. In this study, we empirically verify that \textbf{constituents
correspond to word sequence patterns in the PAS-equivalent sentence set}. We
propose a frequency-based method \emph{span-overlap}, applying the word
sequence pattern to computational unsupervised parsing for the first time.
Parsing experiments show that the span-overlap parser outperforms
state-of-the-art parsers in eight out of ten languages. Further discrimination
analysis confirms that the span-overlap method can non-trivially separate
constituents from non-constituents. This result highlights the utility of the
word sequence pattern. Additionally, we discover a multilingual phenomenon:
\textbf{participant-denoting constituents are more frequent than event-denoting
constituents}. The phenomenon indicates a behavioral difference between the two
constituent types, laying the foundation for future labeled unsupervised
parsing.
|
[
-0.2694143056869507,
-0.6991477012634277,
0.5369482636451721,
0.3765563666820526,
-0.4984287619590759,
0.12355252355337143,
0.0496332123875618,
-0.37358346581459045,
0.43404513597488403,
0.367514044046402,
-0.6133082509040833,
-0.26596593856811523,
-0.2308512181043625,
0.21695125102996826,
-0.5390033721923828,
0.3184933364391327,
0.153911754488945,
0.1634891927242279,
-0.08811894804239273,
-0.05426205322146416,
-0.2475862056016922,
-0.7349981069564819,
-0.011775434948503971,
-0.2809427082538605,
0.35102707147598267,
0.19943183660507202,
0.16465601325035095,
0.9072808623313904,
0.2127877175807953,
0.48170700669288635,
-0.17152610421180725,
0.1715899109840393,
-0.05349322408437729,
0.08487384766340256,
-0.1504468321800232,
-0.4523734450340271,
-0.05184419825673103,
-0.23699288070201874,
0.6358253955841064,
1.1765587329864502,
0.047718409448862076,
-0.2729639708995819,
0.2593846023082733,
0.7508626580238342,
-0.6741629242897034,
0.23578181862831116,
-0.7342146635055542,
-0.024102404713630676,
-0.9720219969749451,
-0.3693915903568268,
-0.5026308298110962,
-0.17650526762008667,
-0.26623237133026123,
-0.38036099076271057,
0.3485310673713684,
-0.032007135450839996,
0.8881102204322815,
-0.06470166891813278,
-0.2570383846759796,
0.05623357370495796,
-0.14182138442993164,
0.29099392890930176,
-0.3725324273109436,
0.5397037863731384,
0.11866771429777145,
-0.10767299681901932,
-0.5561022758483887,
-0.7212828397750854,
-0.463936448097229,
0.2526606619358063,
-0.32139766216278076,
0.023599328473210335,
-0.24787279963493347,
0.3280610144138336,
0.03561849147081375,
0.6786185503005981,
-0.8073624968528748,
0.01172204501926899,
-0.1218758299946785,
-0.3069874048233032,
0.2502063810825348,
-0.022978007793426514,
0.3125721216201782,
-0.5080039501190186,
-0.3287096917629242,
0.10531988739967346,
-0.5921391248703003,
0.43666598200798035,
0.45786261558532715,
0.55750972032547,
0.07979866862297058,
0.8231070041656494,
-0.3648286759853363,
0.9755316376686096,
0.27652648091316223,
0.5256913900375366,
0.15977247059345245,
-0.24054424464702606,
-0.36260777711868286,
0.46204259991645813,
0.5832407474517822,
-0.10614903271198273,
0.46500441431999207,
-0.14034387469291687,
0.20406688749790192,
0.2368597388267517,
0.03823694959282875,
-0.44166556000709534,
-0.33681827783584595,
-0.13245874643325806,
-0.7067301869392395,
-0.07082419097423553,
0.6278819441795349,
-1.0690820217132568,
-0.13246196508407593,
-0.3678244352340698,
0.14464016258716583,
-0.21634627878665924,
-0.1819804459810257,
0.2447727620601654,
-0.15121908485889435,
0.10472634434700012,
-0.3077538013458252,
-0.9728273153305054,
0.4921029508113861,
1.0532516241073608,
0.7992146015167236,
-0.308962345123291,
-0.5409416556358337,
-0.7940504550933838,
-0.10309460014104843,
-0.34615933895111084,
1.097301959991455,
-0.9512681365013123,
-0.37194231152534485,
0.12654519081115723,
0.31205740571022034,
-0.3911692500114441,
-0.753113329410553,
0.3507072925567627,
-0.508199155330658,
0.20345069468021393,
-0.8003112077713013,
-0.9539360404014587,
-0.10511836409568787,
-0.1332540363073349,
-0.5905049443244934,
1.0083234310150146,
0.3694048225879669,
-0.5702418684959412,
0.6562703847885132,
-0.563990592956543,
-0.4811762571334839,
0.13409367203712463,
-0.2894597351551056,
-0.0630393773317337,
0.554811418056488,
0.11026404052972794,
0.11202085763216019,
0.11847985535860062,
0.1869216412305832,
-0.20800694823265076,
-0.22742146253585815,
0.2863565683364868,
-0.2250075340270996,
0.8021435141563416,
-0.06478191167116165,
-0.17023764550685883,
0.5510551929473877,
-0.8452954888343811,
0.028212575241923332,
-0.24777944386005402,
-0.26999175548553467,
-0.6271306276321411,
0.2107854038476944,
0.004013724159449339,
0.06780821084976196,
-0.16302286088466644,
-0.670493483543396,
0.30956944823265076,
-0.6519584655761719,
0.48286172747612,
0.7275715470314026,
0.26535946130752563,
0.16117940843105316,
-0.16583475470542908,
0.31939563155174255,
0.2706874907016754,
-0.20717041194438934,
-0.5836752653121948,
-0.39167049527168274,
-0.6620996594429016,
-0.4930620491504669,
0.37101802229881287,
0.3510305881500244,
-0.09495870023965836,
0.7625395059585571,
-0.14856679737567902,
-0.04965514317154884,
-0.36102449893951416,
-0.19020874798297882,
0.2052898406982422,
0.45288023352622986,
0.4135856330394745,
-0.4851490557193756,
-1.030439853668213,
-0.7421649694442749,
-0.537060558795929,
-0.3576698303222656,
0.27211761474609375,
-0.21701422333717346,
0.1815948188304901,
0.2851148247718811,
1.0706225633621216,
-0.536970853805542,
0.0014420624356716871,
-0.2601197063922882,
0.26418811082839966,
0.05357116460800171,
0.3483765125274658,
0.3175065219402313,
-0.42294976115226746,
-0.42537418007850647,
-0.0541321225464344,
-0.40747639536857605,
-0.5658648014068604,
0.047226015478372574,
-0.3386263847351074,
0.07797696441411972,
0.7791143655776978,
-0.4627319276332855,
0.4559232294559479,
0.2523159682750702,
-0.6416199803352356,
0.35131019353866577,
0.2420394867658615,
0.10404641181230545,
-1.165614128112793,
-0.11949057877063751,
-0.30139169096946716,
-0.38916048407554626,
-0.49054384231567383,
0.05951264500617981,
-0.005089156329631805,
0.03605080395936966,
-0.3251210153102875,
0.18738608062267303,
-0.4882642924785614,
-0.422326922416687,
-0.16434749960899353,
-0.37039807438850403,
0.1643155962228775,
0.28244003653526306,
0.06120859086513519,
0.8603509664535522,
0.5127816200256348,
-0.4852004647254944,
0.2966052293777466,
0.12000787258148193,
-0.7711809277534485,
0.6283599734306335,
-0.4345531165599823,
-0.2829996347427368,
-0.06510284543037415,
-0.08135753870010376,
-1.1157991886138916,
-0.0775931105017662,
0.13875634968280792,
-0.12154094874858856,
0.08595439046621323,
-0.08688349276781082,
-0.3252972364425659,
-0.16521786153316498,
-0.12488842010498047,
0.5786144137382507,
0.012403846718370914,
-0.6577420234680176,
0.18229499459266663,
0.17999275028705597,
-0.09548655897378922,
-0.3144606649875641,
-0.622165322303772,
-0.07289010286331177,
-0.3190266788005829,
-0.42169663310050964,
0.6301069855690002,
0.4219883382320404,
-0.34570685029029846,
0.14344637095928192,
-0.08826946467161179,
-0.08653684705495834,
0.038524653762578964,
0.16063354909420013,
0.03196364641189575,
-0.5582730770111084,
0.1161988154053688,
-0.05206725746393204,
-0.10303226113319397,
-0.0369388610124588,
-0.33772775530815125,
1.03852379322052,
-0.053013235330581665,
-0.6655365228652954,
-0.4461360573768616,
0.8881665468215942,
0.5057334899902344,
-0.49818313121795654,
0.3067600131034851,
0.06101655587553978,
-0.3669688403606415,
0.21359582245349884,
-0.5393823385238647,
-0.17146287858486176,
-0.4683084785938263,
0.48818331956863403,
-0.572704553604126,
-0.8787380456924438,
0.7033090591430664,
-0.08982693403959274,
-0.3313125669956207,
0.5527982115745544,
0.36973023414611816,
0.023203454911708832,
0.43676161766052246,
0.23369050025939941,
-0.17969830334186554,
0.4059217572212219,
0.323826402425766,
0.033555932343006134,
-0.7951405644416809,
-0.3333103358745575,
-0.7318106293678284,
-0.3525160551071167,
-0.4663708508014679,
-0.422081857919693,
0.011775153689086437,
0.31407174468040466,
-0.30931738018989563,
0.3446952998638153,
-0.2644582688808441,
0.5906608700752258,
0.3695361614227295,
-0.2926582098007202,
0.39061620831489563,
0.3021966218948364,
-0.24298518896102905,
-0.3803977370262146,
-0.3602268397808075,
-0.06030699610710144,
0.39748895168304443,
-0.18317930400371552,
0.2873353362083435,
0.2114051729440689,
0.5842498540878296,
0.37540456652641296,
-0.16644425690174103,
-0.956214189529419,
0.5815262794494629,
-0.3880090117454529,
-0.24607262015342712,
-0.04597347602248192,
-0.2923021614551544,
-1.3462300300598145,
0.5659792423248291,
0.11166829615831375,
-1.0988847017288208,
0.7748485207557678,
-0.24587905406951904,
0.02544127032160759,
0.33781933784484863,
-0.36339664459228516,
1.0011861324310303,
-0.14143578708171844,
0.0028272089548408985,
0.22585082054138184,
-0.45961642265319824,
0.29644665122032166,
0.03890956938266754,
-0.21571533381938934,
-0.1542833298444748,
0.2405850738286972,
0.53718101978302,
-0.704350471496582,
0.6728395819664001,
0.016052452847361565,
0.19422869384288788,
0.3117128014564514,
0.12129174172878265,
0.21371234953403473,
-0.42459356784820557,
-0.08029022812843323,
0.06339558959007263,
-0.07139017432928085,
-0.35956719517707825,
-0.4046342074871063,
0.46830877661705017,
-0.4061656892299652,
-0.3830728530883789,
-0.5508275628089905,
-0.21880459785461426,
-0.2171887308359146,
0.23514080047607422,
0.4814453125,
0.45949587225914,
-0.5389571785926819,
0.26370203495025635,
0.1990479975938797,
0.20738889276981354,
0.9259217977523804,
0.6432213187217712,
-0.18679243326187134,
-0.13936759531497955,
0.7163569927215576,
-0.07493188977241516,
-0.11739225685596466,
0.8513180017471313,
0.31451183557510376,
-0.6203785538673401,
-0.13022029399871826,
-0.5833615660667419,
0.022393668070435524,
-0.27133360505104065,
-0.16940703988075256,
-0.7223374247550964,
-0.14070764183998108,
-0.31143224239349365,
-0.04337481036782265,
-0.2715016305446625,
-0.3455463647842407,
-0.20293979346752167,
-0.13464058935642242,
0.18127791583538055,
0.5523814558982849,
-0.11824599653482437,
0.40624427795410156,
-0.7435586452484131,
0.11527609080076218,
0.4382658898830414,
0.22560173273086548,
-0.17579899728298187,
-0.27103957533836365,
0.31320998072624207,
-0.18955357372760773,
-0.16452395915985107,
-1.625169277191162,
0.1310214102268219,
0.44695043563842773,
0.6500728726387024,
0.7553091049194336,
-0.08118081837892532,
1.1650164127349854,
-0.5872325897216797,
0.8749635815620422,
0.1518525332212448,
-1.6288853883743286,
0.46149012446403503,
-0.27853065729141235,
0.07150226831436157,
0.8042017221450806,
-0.025489676743745804,
-0.8056918978691101,
0.00001627944402571302,
-0.29789847135543823,
-0.8648504018783569,
0.6426500678062439,
0.07094405591487885,
-0.18569274246692657,
-0.45771870017051697,
0.34745287895202637,
0.13537248969078064,
0.2773926556110382,
-0.6144678592681885,
-0.1355856955051422,
-0.4013327360153198,
-0.12349704653024673,
0.14420382678508759,
-0.24928508698940277,
0.1689465045928955,
-0.23489226400852203,
0.22419802844524384,
-0.008365104906260967,
0.17405717074871063,
0.12878699600696564,
-0.24686163663864136,
-0.14402137696743011,
0.5699918866157532,
0.6489868760108948,
0.612166702747345,
0.030972177162766457,
0.4841190576553345,
-0.3376874327659607,
-0.2649184763431549,
0.30127227306365967,
0.27430838346481323,
-0.1382492482662201,
0.3338111937046051,
0.5662439465522766,
0.6408038139343262,
0.26305902004241943,
-0.39108291268348694,
0.566135823726654,
0.35158172249794006,
-0.10039669275283813,
0.07314537465572357,
-0.18870531022548676,
-0.04310521110892296,
0.11285337805747986,
0.21912945806980133,
-0.10043776035308838,
0.3533281087875366,
-0.9150341749191284,
0.5527207255363464,
0.4049393832683563,
-0.44804447889328003,
-0.4083404541015625,
0.32349663972854614,
0.11428433656692505,
-0.29301729798316956,
0.6760236024856567,
-0.28201043605804443,
-0.7267636060714722,
0.6099386811256409,
0.6895158886909485,
0.7841444611549377,
-0.5550169944763184,
0.30103951692581177,
0.09208135306835175,
0.12012277543544769,
-0.08428289741277695,
0.635185182094574,
-0.06169213354587555,
-0.6583298444747925,
-0.6115373373031616,
-0.793335497379303,
0.1878538727760315,
0.2941466271877289,
-1.1155121326446533,
0.03554357588291168,
0.045654308050870895,
0.21488457918167114,
0.17851833999156952,
-0.27260246872901917,
-0.13849887251853943,
-0.16567061841487885,
-0.08207713812589645,
0.7984709739685059,
-1.2651705741882324,
0.6981051564216614,
0.788955807685852,
-0.13154344260692596,
-0.7352114915847778,
0.3410018980503082,
0.24016831815242767,
-0.8041717410087585,
0.4131077527999878,
0.27041560411453247,
0.0644606500864029,
-0.206806018948555,
0.2897384464740753,
-0.5583235621452332,
0.3328232765197754,
0.381725549697876,
-0.61431485414505,
0.22644369304180145,
0.5055743455886841,
0.3380374312400818,
-0.3380816876888275,
-0.1270710676908493,
0.5076034069061279,
0.5919110178947449,
0.0148259736597538,
-0.6163055300712585,
0.16545361280441284,
-0.2661168575286865,
-0.06383583694696426,
0.7499358057975769,
-0.4507346749305725,
1.0183415412902832,
0.3317948579788208,
-0.16581536829471588,
0.3128338158130646,
0.781609833240509,
0.2607724070549011,
0.29228344559669495,
0.6989858150482178,
0.6876696348190308,
0.9265417456626892,
-0.3947320580482483,
0.42535436153411865,
-0.3228963315486908,
0.15677256882190704,
1.1611814498901367,
-0.3788042962551117,
0.7906399369239807,
0.5146684646606445,
-0.5152137875556946,
0.7960913181304932,
0.8496033549308777,
-0.019446950405836105,
0.5657147765159607,
0.5190845131874084,
-0.2759791314601898,
-0.3812882602214813,
-0.18377937376499176,
-0.6883482933044434,
0.932976245880127,
0.31085798144340515,
-0.33021873235702515,
-0.405545175075531,
-0.3819807469844818,
-0.02239752747118473,
0.353884220123291,
-0.21012470126152039,
0.8839936852455139,
-0.1425459086894989,
-0.7984488606452942,
0.12781767547130585,
0.1091480553150177,
0.23092949390411377,
-0.7308753728866577,
-0.0047193546779453754,
-0.26299285888671875,
0.039626967161893845,
-0.23510150611400604,
-0.6136554479598999,
0.6551423072814941,
-0.08791988343000412,
-0.3634873330593109,
0.02583029679954052,
0.3453538417816162,
-0.5157365798950195,
-0.41113147139549255,
0.17428627610206604,
0.7562676072120667,
0.18032680451869965,
-0.4993010461330414,
-0.4038287401199341,
0.05624490976333618,
-0.1279086321592331,
-0.06021951884031296,
0.3126724660396576,
0.5700479745864868,
-0.2815219461917877,
-0.24992969632148743,
0.4985673129558563,
0.26429009437561035,
0.2618583142757416,
0.4128359854221344,
0.8544889092445374,
-0.6527829170227051,
-0.7657231688499451,
-1.072709083557129,
0.37670251727104187,
-0.1104331985116005,
-0.3583833873271942,
0.5249611735343933,
1.026018500328064,
0.7954363226890564,
-0.011818003840744495,
0.3599744439125061,
0.05762629210948944,
0.24601899087429047,
-0.6333858966827393,
0.22099919617176056,
-0.6076369285583496,
0.04255933314561844,
-0.345581591129303,
-1.129669427871704,
-0.16452081501483917,
0.7796360850334167,
0.03390460088849068,
-0.026020359247922897,
0.9613703489303589,
0.6595709323883057,
-0.3930741250514984,
0.32670336961746216,
0.15201926231384277,
0.0522921159863472,
0.16726374626159668,
0.3581297695636749,
0.8594051003456116,
0.00905124843120575,
0.2180909663438797,
-0.03574245050549507,
0.01613272726535797,
-0.18423865735530853,
-0.825110912322998,
-0.73243248462677,
-0.8599154353141785,
-0.10431881994009018,
-0.2751237452030182,
0.19662293791770935,
0.8840776085853577,
0.7607516050338745,
-0.917392373085022,
-0.2785421907901764,
-0.6709856390953064,
-0.09293514490127563,
-0.4658675789833069,
-0.32677364349365234,
0.6706523299217224,
-0.35874199867248535,
-0.5711966156959534,
0.7642611861228943,
0.5214818120002747,
-0.08545106649398804,
0.022944534197449684,
0.4383201003074646,
-0.2959948778152466,
0.1165122240781784,
0.6114734411239624,
0.4349111020565033,
-0.9143519401550293,
-0.23835457861423492,
0.07338959723711014,
0.2134591042995453,
0.37020862102508545,
1.4597556591033936,
-0.6641031503677368,
0.4546108543872833,
0.7017412781715393,
0.6211881637573242,
0.23276720941066742,
0.5131044983863831,
0.30527234077453613,
-1.1569007635116577,
0.3144875168800354,
-0.13772861659526825,
0.619041383266449,
0.1840466558933258,
-0.1808762103319168,
0.3332180380821228,
0.6406466960906982,
-0.15689605474472046,
-0.7101555466651917,
0.7213456630706787,
-1.2629631757736206,
-0.4440288245677948,
0.8639233708381653,
-0.1275327056646347,
0.02931167185306549,
-0.4098440110683441,
-0.15724624693393707,
0.19186706840991974,
-0.25667136907577515,
0.7848781943321228,
0.7989784479141235,
-0.2901264727115631,
-0.36695387959480286,
0.34931424260139465,
0.4117932915687561,
0.6726492047309875,
-0.9148202538490295,
0.18663325905799866,
0.3664097785949707,
-0.03103742003440857,
0.04886505752801895,
0.5879654884338379,
-0.37662458419799805,
0.08429981023073196,
-0.16143272817134857,
-0.32196271419525146,
-0.04728975519537926,
-0.2248271256685257,
-0.2459632009267807,
0.5111707448959351,
-0.265442430973053,
-0.5578058958053589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12050v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12050v1
|
emrQA-msquad: A Medical Dataset Structured with the SQuAD V2.0 Framework, Enriched with emrQA Medical Information
| 2024-04-18T10:06:00 | 2024-04-18T10:06:00 |
Jimenez Eladio, Hao Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine Reading Comprehension (MRC) holds a pivotal role in shaping Medical
Question Answering Systems (QAS) and transforming the landscape of accessing
and applying medical information. However, the inherent challenges in the
medical field, such as complex terminology and question ambiguity, necessitate
innovative solutions. One key solution involves integrating specialized medical
datasets and creating dedicated datasets. This strategic approach enhances the
accuracy of QAS, contributing to advancements in clinical decision-making and
medical research. To address the intricacies of medical terminology, a
specialized dataset was integrated, exemplified by a novel Span extraction
dataset derived from emrQA but restructured into 163,695 questions and 4,136
manually obtained answers, this new dataset was called emrQA-msquad dataset.
Additionally, for ambiguous questions, a dedicated medical dataset for the Span
extraction task was introduced, reinforcing the system's robustness. The
fine-tuning of models such as BERT, RoBERTa, and Tiny RoBERTa for medical
contexts significantly improved response accuracy within the F1-score range of
0.75 to 1.00 from 10.1% to 37.4%, 18.7% to 44.7% and 16.0% to 46.8%,
respectively. Finally, emrQA-msquad dataset is publicy available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/Eladio/emrqa-msquad.
|
[
-0.3703204095363617,
-0.8860912919044495,
0.4403354823589325,
0.1245511993765831,
-0.0984816700220108,
0.33272823691368103,
0.304008424282074,
-0.4095829427242279,
0.31670209765434265,
0.4424423277378082,
-0.8391857743263245,
-0.2721574604511261,
-0.476220965385437,
0.3333953022956848,
-0.0795719102025032,
1.0319204330444336,
-0.08750166743993759,
0.2700585126876831,
-0.32776176929473877,
-0.4349938929080963,
-0.4393481910228729,
-0.5783982276916504,
-0.5713145136833191,
-0.053629662841558456,
0.7506833672523499,
0.7209786772727966,
0.7954838871955872,
0.7599794864654541,
0.611274003982544,
0.11527269333600998,
0.05833983048796654,
0.4858991205692291,
-0.2766544222831726,
0.43751323223114014,
0.04035642743110657,
-0.4460667073726654,
-0.4367233216762543,
-0.22008132934570312,
0.42739877104759216,
0.3751283288002014,
-0.41049930453300476,
0.2811237573623657,
-0.1483067274093628,
0.9289023876190186,
-0.5994381308555603,
-0.09147299081087112,
-0.3747733533382416,
0.220991849899292,
-0.042241860181093216,
-0.27224817872047424,
-0.18520553410053253,
-0.053996603935956955,
0.18859471380710602,
-0.5932756662368774,
0.025096571072936058,
0.0351853147149086,
0.95565265417099,
0.6578026413917542,
-0.48681938648223877,
-0.2383926808834076,
-0.3059186339378357,
0.5702606439590454,
-0.3008197546005249,
0.38087067008018494,
0.4626668393611908,
0.5175732374191284,
0.09891011565923691,
-0.6316726207733154,
-0.388566255569458,
0.3413068950176239,
0.12275388091802597,
0.4252309203147888,
-0.156671404838562,
-0.05179021507501602,
0.10645157098770142,
0.11705043166875839,
-0.7642835378646851,
0.005914562847465277,
-0.6994555592536926,
0.023101143538951874,
0.6951423287391663,
0.4852532148361206,
0.13713136315345764,
-0.12785543501377106,
-0.32003551721572876,
0.1211957111954689,
-0.8036885261535645,
0.1142282485961914,
-0.20992201566696167,
0.15092019736766815,
-0.04125167056918144,
0.8919029831886292,
-0.6307997107505798,
0.7170666456222534,
0.028972657397389412,
0.12750805914402008,
0.46598121523857117,
-0.26692014932632446,
-0.38730350136756897,
-0.21383947134017944,
0.7254701256752014,
0.3625153601169586,
0.34140777587890625,
-0.09021171927452087,
-0.055697422474622726,
-0.3741389513015747,
0.3982588052749634,
-0.6655107736587524,
-0.26321402192115784,
0.7193881869316101,
-0.4055871069431305,
-0.33600690960884094,
0.011130569502711296,
-0.6666556000709534,
-0.32926279306411743,
-0.26904383301734924,
0.2771090865135193,
-0.42625555396080017,
0.031603213399648666,
0.17451049387454987,
-0.09394164383411407,
0.3255399763584137,
0.27560490369796753,
-0.5694628953933716,
0.06118977814912796,
0.46156635880470276,
0.7929229736328125,
-0.2513059973716736,
0.2254304140806198,
-0.3906805217266083,
0.03978694975376129,
-0.13433735072612762,
0.9687547087669373,
-0.5773758888244629,
-0.290408730506897,
-0.0700148418545723,
0.090687096118927,
-0.40250852704048157,
-0.6155153512954712,
0.4536159336566925,
-0.6034650206565857,
0.22679905593395233,
-0.11029627174139023,
-0.35321173071861267,
-0.12472919374704361,
0.40435415506362915,
-0.6313279271125793,
1.1024984121322632,
0.34528905153274536,
-0.6193323731422424,
0.20199090242385864,
-0.6465290784835815,
-0.4323933720588684,
-0.042688000947237015,
-0.2495003193616867,
-0.4665054976940155,
-0.23402896523475647,
0.695501983165741,
0.37592440843582153,
-0.4536559283733368,
-0.02212519571185112,
-0.15939027070999146,
0.016323432326316833,
0.564253032207489,
-0.05909612774848938,
0.7636775970458984,
0.6276916861534119,
0.17338049411773682,
-0.10716384649276733,
-0.5893033742904663,
0.6787583827972412,
-0.08980568498373032,
-0.3058803677558899,
-0.05689314752817154,
-0.10122089833021164,
-0.05731937289237976,
0.6095127463340759,
0.024171197786927223,
-0.38686931133270264,
-0.04083268716931343,
-0.13796989619731903,
0.5320662260055542,
0.38655486702919006,
0.22036467492580414,
0.1613878309726715,
-0.6621274948120117,
1.095192313194275,
0.10403230786323547,
0.25685226917266846,
-0.16540926694869995,
-0.6619182825088501,
-0.38141122460365295,
-0.7115236520767212,
0.46447381377220154,
0.8993954658508301,
-0.8922590017318726,
0.41661182045936584,
-0.07063233852386475,
-0.45151451230049133,
-1.0295027494430542,
-0.23868852853775024,
0.5509114861488342,
0.7079962491989136,
0.611072301864624,
0.08712762594223022,
-0.47183099389076233,
-1.0090285539627075,
-0.3573395013809204,
-0.0925329178571701,
-0.3740977644920349,
0.41719868779182434,
0.43680980801582336,
-0.1492823362350464,
0.8532961010932922,
-0.7340587377548218,
-0.24047914147377014,
-0.0976170226931572,
-0.1864968240261078,
0.043956875801086426,
0.6033014059066772,
0.24361826479434967,
-0.9305320382118225,
-0.27911993861198425,
-0.2735837996006012,
-0.7459525465965271,
-0.24472570419311523,
-0.08218254148960114,
-0.2917988896369934,
-0.008579879999160767,
0.4231530725955963,
-0.37520983815193176,
0.2975699305534363,
0.5529345870018005,
-0.5297930240631104,
0.5506488680839539,
0.03187704086303711,
0.5438739657402039,
-1.2832560539245605,
0.012012168765068054,
-0.07056032866239548,
-0.12776394188404083,
-0.47062334418296814,
0.40153029561042786,
0.29888850450515747,
0.22847187519073486,
-0.355292409658432,
0.22237391769886017,
-0.1965927630662918,
0.18899384140968323,
0.2042299062013626,
0.17341822385787964,
0.21810168027877808,
0.1865728199481964,
-0.23647767305374146,
0.8473807573318481,
0.30791014432907104,
-0.41192543506622314,
0.3232437074184418,
0.6673555970191956,
-0.037988726049661636,
0.8616960048675537,
-1.002105712890625,
0.1986054629087448,
-0.1578110307455063,
0.023654790595173836,
-0.8844999670982361,
-0.35139626264572144,
0.3189450204372406,
-0.6554994583129883,
0.20499640703201294,
-0.03137996420264244,
-0.49393463134765625,
-0.35703080892562866,
-0.06370184570550919,
0.5834585428237915,
0.25859829783439636,
-0.21163995563983917,
0.42876508831977844,
0.74237459897995,
-0.4615858197212219,
-0.7268574237823486,
-0.8508111238479614,
-0.046650003641843796,
0.004668062087148428,
-0.8006790280342102,
0.13062363862991333,
-0.19494470953941345,
-0.05164489895105362,
-0.21487537026405334,
-0.099933922290802,
-0.5281228423118591,
-0.20084427297115326,
0.3030513525009155,
0.4354562759399414,
-0.32420435547828674,
0.6014712452888489,
0.5209167003631592,
0.04024449363350868,
-0.0629567950963974,
0.251703143119812,
0.38258224725723267,
0.03425828740000725,
-0.21536415815353394,
-0.3309020698070526,
0.5742585062980652,
0.5972793698310852,
-0.6080524325370789,
0.8160218596458435,
0.21835975348949432,
-0.541534960269928,
0.10751048475503922,
-0.35980960726737976,
-0.1795290857553482,
-0.3898696005344391,
0.5226941704750061,
-0.8414775729179382,
-1.0274889469146729,
0.5739102959632874,
0.38394632935523987,
0.12926901876926422,
0.7357352375984192,
0.4895284175872803,
-0.587166428565979,
1.3091356754302979,
0.09428577870130539,
0.2568635642528534,
0.10621706396341324,
0.11469927430152893,
-0.46387848258018494,
-0.9146506786346436,
-0.6936858296394348,
-0.664706826210022,
-0.33271804451942444,
-0.27355384826660156,
-0.47846075892448425,
0.5846249461174011,
-0.18788227438926697,
-0.356464147567749,
-0.15554532408714294,
-0.5996196866035461,
0.36300572752952576,
0.22112485766410828,
0.6609889268875122,
0.3056959807872772,
0.0010095433099195361,
-0.02800416387617588,
-0.13215333223342896,
-0.7969746589660645,
-0.36540335416793823,
1.3026883602142334,
0.39444035291671753,
0.6460676789283752,
0.08787555247545242,
0.4582314193248749,
0.39446038007736206,
0.17514394223690033,
-0.8836207389831543,
0.13419649004936218,
0.011282975785434246,
-0.8404434323310852,
-0.20504820346832275,
-0.5498027205467224,
-0.9039338827133179,
0.2989979386329651,
-0.538804829120636,
-0.2899211049079895,
0.13090798258781433,
-0.09479983150959015,
-0.7791690826416016,
-0.05864573270082474,
-0.690693736076355,
0.7024142742156982,
0.02667311020195484,
-0.03892207145690918,
-0.06602275371551514,
-1.0067081451416016,
0.3163721561431885,
-0.3197439908981323,
0.12121425569057465,
-0.15643161535263062,
-0.3475738763809204,
0.8025790452957153,
-0.5029088854789734,
0.3222655951976776,
0.03574812784790993,
-0.023817304521799088,
0.17407244443893433,
-0.19244074821472168,
0.19023706018924713,
0.20220108330249786,
-0.20537854731082916,
-0.1149727925658226,
0.7474886178970337,
-0.755739688873291,
-0.4653271734714508,
0.26209717988967896,
-0.6442333459854126,
-0.22645030915737152,
-0.5382120609283447,
-0.9420440196990967,
-0.5568951368331909,
-0.03238396346569061,
0.0707044005393982,
0.4467369318008423,
-0.16617165505886078,
0.3214714825153351,
0.8692783117294312,
-0.32088345289230347,
-0.20281881093978882,
0.6807807683944702,
0.04832807183265686,
-0.46237537264823914,
0.21351154148578644,
0.12116917967796326,
0.3479686975479126,
0.369998574256897,
-0.23762457072734833,
-0.42929738759994507,
-0.37950077652931213,
-0.7393849492073059,
0.19184324145317078,
-0.5101955533027649,
-0.5009437203407288,
-0.8123219609260559,
-0.4502982497215271,
-0.25328385829925537,
0.11555839329957962,
-0.02152143605053425,
-0.6304808259010315,
-0.27762070298194885,
-0.16441547870635986,
0.5442958474159241,
0.59400874376297,
0.2780141830444336,
0.3503977656364441,
-1.120599627494812,
0.5577983260154724,
0.01748480461537838,
0.06949922442436218,
-0.7158533930778503,
-0.8004418611526489,
-0.26837316155433655,
0.2873564660549164,
-0.11520283669233322,
-1.078020453453064,
0.24102452397346497,
0.30646592378616333,
0.35910892486572266,
0.4421411156654358,
0.16894188523292542,
0.7866854667663574,
-0.48732343316078186,
0.4088810980319977,
-0.01302550919353962,
-0.4794337749481201,
0.3599313497543335,
-0.33138713240623474,
0.43275395035743713,
0.7429607510566711,
0.38787946105003357,
-0.5945673584938049,
-0.3825399875640869,
-0.536304235458374,
-0.5324870944023132,
0.5069382190704346,
0.17499564588069916,
-0.28341299295425415,
0.08542647212743759,
0.6635686755180359,
-0.0023037639912217855,
0.2079433798789978,
0.12360486388206482,
-0.3351985514163971,
0.164300337433815,
-0.6990674734115601,
0.013932673260569572,
-0.07396124303340912,
-0.3677351474761963,
-0.3642955422401428,
0.49876680970191956,
-0.10840316861867905,
0.36866962909698486,
0.51870197057724,
-0.21726278960704803,
-0.0553898811340332,
0.21653154492378235,
0.4618043601512909,
0.6374515295028687,
-0.20488272607326508,
0.00941065140068531,
0.23863479495048523,
-0.6974965929985046,
-0.04069337621331215,
0.14302393794059753,
-0.037363201379776,
-0.19137737154960632,
0.12153434753417969,
-0.0053344592452049255,
-0.267409086227417,
-1.0854374170303345,
0.24725745618343353,
-0.08002282679080963,
-0.3188508152961731,
-0.043055735528469086,
0.08565844595432281,
-0.13777942955493927,
0.4336918294429779,
0.5110735893249512,
0.24566958844661713,
0.2983701229095459,
-0.1929546296596527,
0.714724063873291,
0.20809173583984375,
-0.6758974194526672,
-0.00009198073530569673,
0.5760768055915833,
-0.050890639424324036,
0.04601452127099037,
0.7124379873275757,
0.15019722282886505,
-0.4483907222747803,
0.870319128036499,
0.42152711749076843,
0.396005779504776,
-0.40523579716682434,
0.46918800473213196,
0.4374559819698334,
0.45049983263015747,
0.0856093093752861,
0.9853195548057556,
0.3306327164173126,
-0.6351720094680786,
-0.2716993987560272,
-0.3430419862270355,
-0.31045717000961304,
-0.3112223446369171,
-1.0536004304885864,
-0.042764633893966675,
-0.40665850043296814,
-0.11382902413606644,
-0.0441012941300869,
-0.003046320052817464,
-0.6416906118392944,
0.6528431177139282,
-0.2608672082424164,
1.0102379322052002,
-0.5782089233398438,
0.705677330493927,
0.7405250668525696,
-0.5816992521286011,
-0.7003424167633057,
-0.2481945902109146,
0.023010598495602608,
-1.0528730154037476,
0.1444881558418274,
-0.026289843022823334,
0.0351935513317585,
0.03999350219964981,
-0.5541139841079712,
-0.627575159072876,
1.1455589532852173,
-0.00371647160500288,
-0.49981755018234253,
-0.02395949885249138,
0.12796339392662048,
0.5076461434364319,
-0.5948788523674011,
0.3063816726207733,
0.8455042243003845,
0.3825284540653229,
0.09441017359495163,
-0.7779564261436462,
0.319982647895813,
-0.3320215046405792,
-0.4620770812034607,
0.16864876449108124,
-0.633490800857544,
0.6719558238983154,
-0.6094138622283936,
-0.1298230141401291,
0.3931199014186859,
0.3629721999168396,
0.5168017745018005,
0.45470717549324036,
0.23189611732959747,
0.5171941518783569,
1.0252553224563599,
-0.38520485162734985,
0.8729236125946045,
-0.06479743868112564,
0.03202316537499428,
1.015380859375,
0.00821415800601244,
1.0694724321365356,
0.5267391204833984,
-0.43297508358955383,
0.47832152247428894,
0.9538336992263794,
0.002490860875695944,
0.43322497606277466,
0.11346501857042313,
-0.24566879868507385,
-0.330878347158432,
0.09821182489395142,
-0.5534148812294006,
0.2937582731246948,
0.6422313451766968,
-0.631033182144165,
0.16404129564762115,
-0.03199807181954384,
-0.025489436462521553,
-0.05205364525318146,
-0.19615092873573303,
0.7370678782463074,
-0.009554491378366947,
-0.49525296688079834,
0.5318369269371033,
-0.08030296862125397,
0.2365850955247879,
-0.4379718601703644,
0.04569659382104874,
-0.1972905993461609,
-0.08717704564332962,
-0.4424404799938202,
-0.9382907152175903,
0.2359325885772705,
-0.05089166760444641,
-0.4193025231361389,
0.22010520100593567,
0.41588354110717773,
-0.535006582736969,
-0.4444615840911865,
-0.3935847878456116,
1.0928479433059692,
0.20007942616939545,
-0.32179757952690125,
-1.0541661977767944,
-0.24954333901405334,
0.026934973895549774,
0.1045968309044838,
0.12731875479221344,
0.5346730351448059,
0.15618818998336792,
0.8339160680770874,
0.4851209223270416,
-0.05806092172861099,
0.1258169412612915,
-0.15953095257282257,
0.9115428924560547,
-0.658250629901886,
-0.4349237382411957,
-0.4644474387168884,
0.5567343235015869,
-0.09518353641033173,
-0.507001519203186,
0.47413671016693115,
0.6938340663909912,
0.2845057249069214,
-0.16557270288467407,
0.727682888507843,
-0.1494375318288803,
0.9085296392440796,
-0.5219035148620605,
1.019362449645996,
-0.6946211457252502,
0.06990478187799454,
0.06637328863143921,
-0.34260720014572144,
-0.5424277782440186,
0.42992815375328064,
-0.005370088387280703,
0.101188063621521,
0.725364089012146,
0.971616268157959,
0.18539929389953613,
0.1515279859304428,
0.21124432981014252,
0.055220648646354675,
0.06937380135059357,
0.5622405409812927,
0.8087965250015259,
-0.6752378344535828,
0.6924324631690979,
0.24878333508968353,
-0.3293991982936859,
-0.10071820765733719,
-0.23326051235198975,
-0.8513128161430359,
-0.596000611782074,
-0.3426424562931061,
-0.6147468090057373,
0.42316409945487976,
0.9116133451461792,
0.6555829048156738,
-0.9949769377708435,
0.2584001123905182,
0.3761788010597229,
-0.005640064366161823,
-0.3866368532180786,
-0.2771371006965637,
0.44930708408355713,
-0.35415393114089966,
-0.5580010414123535,
0.3111036419868469,
0.08222316205501556,
-0.05753462016582489,
0.22353334724903107,
-0.16287977993488312,
-0.307846337556839,
0.23992478847503662,
0.5728607177734375,
0.43824318051338196,
-0.3424396514892578,
-0.11005653440952301,
0.49984806776046753,
-0.3687792420387268,
0.2895735800266266,
0.5377277135848999,
-0.8104642629623413,
0.6452109217643738,
0.43788301944732666,
0.8285053372383118,
0.19105514883995056,
0.28133463859558105,
0.6390072107315063,
-0.6329423785209656,
-0.23953530192375183,
0.3346155285835266,
0.14167755842208862,
0.03095402754843235,
-0.20265506207942963,
0.626141369342804,
-0.010186079889535904,
-0.6374422311782837,
-0.7130159139633179,
0.24843719601631165,
-1.0374404191970825,
-0.26334109902381897,
1.0810121297836304,
-0.03543493524193764,
-0.040539927780628204,
-0.6287248730659485,
-0.5092281699180603,
0.32038620114326477,
-0.46432843804359436,
0.7561578154563904,
0.49621260166168213,
-0.275736004114151,
-0.34400004148483276,
-0.768138587474823,
0.5932791829109192,
0.6545103788375854,
-1.098464846611023,
-0.3111562728881836,
0.5831462740898132,
0.2767278254032135,
-0.31826716661453247,
0.4502387046813965,
-0.40389418601989746,
0.5148684978485107,
-0.2370814085006714,
-0.15971559286117554,
-0.13747574388980865,
-0.2929149568080902,
-0.3443204462528229,
0.1516047716140747,
-0.329475462436676,
-0.6172435879707336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12045v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12045v1
|
RAM: Towards an Ever-Improving Memory System by Learning from Communications
| 2024-04-18T09:58:51 | 2024-04-18T09:58:51 |
Jiaqi Li, Xiaobo Wang, Zihao Wang, Zilong Zheng
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We introduce RAM, an innovative RAG-based framework with an ever-improving
memory. Inspired by humans' pedagogical process, RAM utilizes recursively
reasoning-based retrieval and experience reflections to continually update the
memory and learn from users' communicative feedback, namely communicative
learning. Extensive experiments with both simulated and real users demonstrate
significant improvements over traditional RAG and self-knowledge methods,
particularly excelling in handling false premise and multi-hop questions.
Furthermore, RAM exhibits promising adaptability to various feedback and
retrieval method chain types, showcasing its potential for advancing AI
capabilities in dynamic knowledge acquisition and lifelong learning.
|
[
-0.21170029044151306,
-0.9214310646057129,
0.3266426920890808,
0.18341967463493347,
0.1396883726119995,
0.6422531604766846,
-0.20991623401641846,
-0.543583869934082,
0.3935558795928955,
0.2849966585636139,
-0.26916104555130005,
-0.05391240492463112,
-0.5549893975257874,
-0.4465739130973816,
-0.28019222617149353,
1.1059794425964355,
0.26439568400382996,
-0.021503539755940437,
0.06071160361170769,
-0.3809240460395813,
-0.9471922516822815,
-0.42224040627479553,
-1.2891429662704468,
-0.5618957877159119,
0.5877155065536499,
0.6741307377815247,
0.2601887881755829,
0.5675212740898132,
0.6024067997932434,
0.23035027086734772,
0.14897148311138153,
0.3286440372467041,
-0.7181638479232788,
0.5243685841560364,
-0.3668878376483917,
-0.6421968936920166,
-0.4977155327796936,
-0.022822434082627296,
0.6795908808708191,
0.46836018562316895,
-0.7184323668479919,
0.3470657467842102,
-0.08836905658245087,
0.9315255284309387,
-0.7528045773506165,
-0.073520727455616,
-0.8973391652107239,
-0.09227646887302399,
0.00724039738997817,
-0.490699827671051,
-0.6554505228996277,
-0.13732191920280457,
0.04953093081712723,
-0.5855669975280762,
-0.04701950028538704,
0.15388518571853638,
0.7732822299003601,
0.33915388584136963,
0.13745053112506866,
-0.648025631904602,
-0.9571828842163086,
0.9489985704421997,
-0.05080883949995041,
0.704539954662323,
0.4292738735675812,
0.7489048838615417,
-0.1583818644285202,
-0.683560848236084,
-0.2568166255950928,
-0.25765934586524963,
0.3195468485355377,
0.44288626313209534,
0.20820672810077667,
-0.189958855509758,
0.04889436811208725,
0.19825133681297302,
-0.10151875019073486,
-0.3500618040561676,
-0.5611408948898315,
0.1141509860754013,
0.36127591133117676,
0.2145419418811798,
0.37405794858932495,
0.058294691145420074,
-0.5653753876686096,
-0.20328661799430847,
-0.6709554195404053,
-0.15196865797042847,
-0.12335096299648285,
-0.2517491281032562,
-0.017112435773015022,
-0.1368475705385208,
0.1387961059808731,
0.8064944744110107,
0.07570682466030121,
-0.2634807527065277,
0.12271789461374283,
0.238807812333107,
-0.15182757377624512,
-0.10012788325548172,
0.23509670794010162,
0.0828005000948906,
0.1366838961839676,
-0.27656054496765137,
-0.22648045420646667,
-0.022198805585503578,
0.6255608797073364,
-0.3142320215702057,
-0.5517076253890991,
-0.26392337679862976,
-0.7429117560386658,
-0.054141007363796234,
0.04666634649038315,
-0.7868044972419739,
-0.355771541595459,
-0.12400057911872864,
0.7479756474494934,
-0.718864917755127,
-0.4719288945198059,
0.4218728542327881,
-0.30362728238105774,
0.3001547157764435,
0.7792342305183411,
-0.8388219475746155,
0.6091004014015198,
0.6295551061630249,
0.5880117416381836,
-0.37461036443710327,
-0.2926178574562073,
-0.49876758456230164,
0.646828293800354,
-0.20485009253025055,
1.0780400037765503,
-0.4687836170196533,
-0.4686143696308136,
-0.5935253500938416,
-0.4740481674671173,
-0.06754639744758606,
-0.9654741287231445,
0.20753689110279083,
-0.7257381677627563,
0.07364584505558014,
0.12391713261604309,
-0.5020597577095032,
-0.21121971309185028,
0.31075382232666016,
-0.5249423980712891,
0.9547245502471924,
0.11164052039384842,
-0.44427290558815,
0.017003344371914864,
-0.8562077283859253,
-0.2739727199077606,
0.08683475852012634,
-0.2785714864730835,
-0.20470179617404938,
0.0656132847070694,
-0.3401795029640198,
0.1624804139137268,
-0.3535509705543518,
0.2520590126514435,
-0.046301018446683884,
-0.5359117388725281,
0.33515456318855286,
-0.4963565766811371,
0.5600870847702026,
0.47577738761901855,
-0.2328605055809021,
-0.20651254057884216,
-0.9125880002975464,
0.0503355972468853,
-0.045227039605379105,
-0.8448275923728943,
-0.20341621339321136,
0.12736876308918,
-0.39875587821006775,
-0.1693686693906784,
0.15178538858890533,
-0.5555599927902222,
-0.02639324590563774,
-0.028789738193154335,
0.20328231155872345,
0.8335705995559692,
-0.033264849334955215,
0.4474829435348511,
-0.8067713379859924,
0.4114930033683777,
0.13177914917469025,
0.1924699991941452,
-0.8150570392608643,
-0.3535003960132599,
-0.9403733611106873,
-0.1995105743408203,
-0.033303555101156235,
0.6261014342308044,
-0.5008238554000854,
-0.22622941434383392,
-0.1525275558233261,
-0.29926323890686035,
-0.4342499375343323,
0.24021312594413757,
0.5130748748779297,
0.6229523420333862,
0.4858662188053131,
-0.4844422936439514,
-0.7456724643707275,
-0.4461144208908081,
-0.2764715552330017,
-0.7197573184967041,
0.07088294625282288,
0.6739919185638428,
-0.019622817635536194,
-0.24908743798732758,
0.5938813090324402,
-0.6382239460945129,
-0.13405857980251312,
-0.32451581954956055,
0.36924976110458374,
0.10831674933433533,
0.5158066749572754,
0.0773165300488472,
-0.7061290740966797,
-0.5091456174850464,
-0.12564237415790558,
-0.7172484397888184,
0.05396851897239685,
-0.40781402587890625,
-0.1563922017812729,
0.41480255126953125,
0.6072865128517151,
-0.6639753580093384,
0.4355292320251465,
0.14200064539909363,
-0.06678847968578339,
0.7215371131896973,
-0.45972180366516113,
0.1131116971373558,
-0.9679420590400696,
0.010974972508847713,
-0.34113651514053345,
-0.1635255515575409,
-0.21491561830043793,
0.0016278760740533471,
0.06276091188192368,
0.04295438900589943,
-0.09008940309286118,
0.8858850598335266,
-0.595596969127655,
-0.11640142649412155,
-0.5198516845703125,
0.1121671125292778,
-0.06374918669462204,
0.4159170985221863,
-0.18182256817817688,
0.731136679649353,
0.4695904850959778,
-0.8030359745025635,
0.5425478219985962,
0.19379618763923645,
-0.29380905628204346,
0.7722676992416382,
-0.3881879150867462,
0.1640450805425644,
-0.3179101347923279,
0.38133856654167175,
-0.9908026456832886,
-0.030385827645659447,
0.13264022767543793,
-0.9482806324958801,
0.4528822600841522,
0.08915617316961288,
-0.27448171377182007,
-0.2737431526184082,
0.03863273188471794,
0.2504608929157257,
0.6978979110717773,
-0.6346176862716675,
0.6786329746246338,
0.6072705388069153,
0.19648176431655884,
-0.7051571607589722,
-0.3711579144001007,
0.21063438057899475,
-0.05766889825463295,
-0.23161037266254425,
0.06464265286922455,
-0.25089460611343384,
-0.2824244201183319,
0.04980221018195152,
-0.319637656211853,
-0.3576868772506714,
0.14448872208595276,
0.12143121659755707,
0.41786596179008484,
-0.21562612056732178,
0.6446844339370728,
-0.34958213567733765,
-0.16045048832893372,
0.15066857635974884,
-0.48572850227355957,
0.47711846232414246,
-0.14818868041038513,
-0.3150935173034668,
-0.25222885608673096,
0.3084363043308258,
0.15606988966464996,
-0.10133951157331467,
0.35053354501724243,
0.4159884750843048,
-0.019014274701476097,
-0.59925776720047,
-0.842617928981781,
-0.46764346957206726,
-0.5091672539710999,
0.44642266631126404,
-0.4658930003643036,
-1.108513355255127,
0.3743498921394348,
-0.48613783717155457,
-0.00600639171898365,
-0.005679515656083822,
0.214768648147583,
-0.671683669090271,
0.6546775698661804,
0.8893794417381287,
0.0521400161087513,
0.49588486552238464,
-0.2941397726535797,
0.007174888625741005,
-0.9290084838867188,
-0.36908280849456787,
-0.2845953404903412,
-0.4407254457473755,
-0.2864452004432678,
-0.5510544180870056,
0.16641990840435028,
0.25397205352783203,
-0.6206027269363403,
0.20115317404270172,
-0.5170634388923645,
0.3452729284763336,
0.5618703365325928,
0.16782593727111816,
0.27125611901283264,
-0.03688214719295502,
-0.11664123833179474,
0.12045653164386749,
-0.7832895517349243,
-0.1424170881509781,
0.9562392234802246,
0.38445019721984863,
1.333641529083252,
0.13124608993530273,
0.7422543168067932,
0.4243713915348053,
0.7483239769935608,
-0.5656925439834595,
0.672709584236145,
0.14956578612327576,
-0.673997700214386,
-0.081364206969738,
-0.6353511810302734,
-1.0025066137313843,
-0.2010001838207245,
-0.005526241846382618,
-0.8424068689346313,
-0.27271074056625366,
0.1940804421901703,
-0.37493351101875305,
0.5252301096916199,
-0.585178792476654,
0.24470795691013336,
-0.4027676284313202,
-0.3890497088432312,
-0.8362104892730713,
-0.6895723938941956,
0.06164851784706116,
-0.06673866510391235,
-0.024192502722144127,
-0.015843801200389862,
-0.23015953600406647,
0.7292062640190125,
0.3363143801689148,
0.8274766802787781,
-0.18488597869873047,
0.27455368638038635,
0.5642461776733398,
0.28767314553260803,
0.036020196974277496,
0.1435166746377945,
-0.15786713361740112,
-0.23690453171730042,
-0.19969439506530762,
-0.3385755717754364,
-1.0025453567504883,
0.6242538094520569,
-0.9020592570304871,
-0.8197115659713745,
-0.24681401252746582,
-0.784428596496582,
-0.2743958830833435,
0.08023867756128311,
-0.4561915397644043,
0.358024537563324,
-0.19099555909633636,
0.16368328034877777,
1.136614203453064,
-0.5758270025253296,
0.19130976498126984,
0.9624856114387512,
-0.49023035168647766,
-0.5600064992904663,
1.1279363632202148,
-0.013473371043801308,
0.18166060745716095,
0.5212952494621277,
0.1574949324131012,
-0.13642342388629913,
-0.19393621385097504,
-0.441008597612381,
0.42765188217163086,
-0.7867700457572937,
-0.30964431166648865,
-0.9406093955039978,
-0.5319539904594421,
-0.026480410248041153,
-0.18037283420562744,
-0.3137812614440918,
-0.5780880451202393,
-0.12600524723529816,
-0.04510359838604927,
0.3128965198993683,
1.1374473571777344,
-0.49753057956695557,
0.5203781723976135,
-0.8611682057380676,
0.4259457290172577,
0.2829412817955017,
0.7029690146446228,
0.33420467376708984,
-0.6130719780921936,
-0.5454469323158264,
-0.16281147301197052,
-0.8129540085792542,
-0.7088540196418762,
0.14525315165519714,
0.3140224516391754,
0.8308692574501038,
0.22353990375995636,
-0.41539597511291504,
0.825868546962738,
-0.49649178981781006,
0.3097971975803375,
0.31416454911231995,
-0.6565397381782532,
0.6080731749534607,
-0.2674054205417633,
0.20924165844917297,
0.4296753406524658,
0.19097326695919037,
-0.6694372892379761,
-0.25770512223243713,
-0.9733743667602539,
-0.5664178729057312,
0.3999600410461426,
-0.49119818210601807,
0.3479495346546173,
-0.17948774993419647,
0.8444684743881226,
0.07153963297605515,
0.1489902287721634,
-0.0648958757519722,
-0.21039943397045135,
-0.018045421689748764,
-0.14555001258850098,
0.20313803851604462,
-0.2840765714645386,
0.21161334216594696,
-0.435649573802948,
0.6204226016998291,
0.02969592995941639,
0.6552892923355103,
-0.03584414720535278,
0.06594756990671158,
0.023436859250068665,
-0.01622621901333332,
0.40227457880973816,
0.8787211179733276,
-0.20694836974143982,
0.17002101242542267,
0.34256643056869507,
-0.6922041773796082,
0.3985092341899872,
-0.4731975495815277,
-0.08374794572591782,
-0.11630450934171677,
-0.26423946022987366,
0.5985909700393677,
0.5020278096199036,
-0.6599740982055664,
0.03470730409026146,
-0.2453475445508957,
0.11947350949048996,
-0.6593061089515686,
0.6159764528274536,
0.33962497115135193,
0.13248534500598907,
0.6811739206314087,
0.42814162373542786,
0.004623062442988157,
-0.5228637456893921,
0.8894684910774231,
0.3409743309020996,
-0.460114985704422,
-0.20564404129981995,
0.5716820359230042,
0.20356100797653198,
-0.7020809650421143,
0.4643934965133667,
-0.02667340636253357,
-0.2701224982738495,
0.384390264749527,
0.8809263110160828,
0.5669861435890198,
-0.5646506547927856,
0.4553094506263733,
0.5550098419189453,
-0.0047087823040783405,
-0.373546302318573,
0.561023473739624,
-0.5702590942382812,
-0.8053275942802429,
-0.5064814686775208,
-0.5034099221229553,
-0.6607717275619507,
-0.07344771921634674,
-0.6442198753356934,
0.2553962171077728,
-0.8629058599472046,
-0.1408883035182953,
-0.3233897089958191,
0.14968512952327728,
-0.172743558883667,
0.3744277358055115,
-0.05215523764491081,
1.2857744693756104,
-0.2724032402038574,
1.190497636795044,
1.0414623022079468,
-0.2505646049976349,
-0.7795897126197815,
-0.08902005851268768,
-0.2483447790145874,
-0.9526772499084473,
1.1328535079956055,
0.1309099644422531,
-0.4058140516281128,
0.1883823722600937,
-0.700753390789032,
-1.0751702785491943,
1.0063393115997314,
0.31604626774787903,
-0.03191607445478439,
0.1548355519771576,
-0.39667555689811707,
0.45523783564567566,
-0.37453263998031616,
0.5258524417877197,
0.22785846889019012,
0.14284291863441467,
0.3582119941711426,
-0.6328620314598083,
-0.4396722912788391,
-0.38418564200401306,
-0.14184434711933136,
0.27758899331092834,
-0.9308250546455383,
0.7341822385787964,
-0.4427536427974701,
-0.339926153421402,
-0.003055400447919965,
1.0784084796905518,
0.5088445544242859,
0.40906575322151184,
0.2656855583190918,
0.9466555714607239,
0.9384507536888123,
0.28317171335220337,
0.7233346104621887,
-0.25831159949302673,
-0.06939772516489029,
1.684052586555481,
-0.17503418028354645,
0.9006896615028381,
0.39468085765838623,
0.09699370712041855,
0.9553865790367126,
0.1588251292705536,
0.2252221256494522,
0.2735285460948944,
0.4015119671821594,
-0.47269517183303833,
-0.16262495517730713,
0.018127785995602608,
0.08321032673120499,
0.4589405655860901,
0.8445962071418762,
0.05965343117713928,
-0.3653046190738678,
0.03169180825352669,
-0.023250119760632515,
0.28262779116630554,
-0.2489539235830307,
0.8381245732307434,
0.30314821004867554,
-0.8089154362678528,
0.6172488331794739,
-0.19217157363891602,
0.8600145578384399,
-0.46219077706336975,
-0.46906787157058716,
-0.16298794746398926,
0.5920404195785522,
0.01975422166287899,
-0.8236526250839233,
0.5807241797447205,
-0.19611456990242004,
-0.2288234978914261,
-0.2998453974723816,
1.2068957090377808,
-0.17831139266490936,
-0.0024702991358935833,
0.522011935710907,
0.6440080404281616,
0.3797767162322998,
0.4712783694267273,
-0.9509390592575073,
0.3549310266971588,
-0.2530270516872406,
-0.046802129596471786,
0.31491243839263916,
0.3932148814201355,
0.06959053874015808,
1.2945976257324219,
0.5514586567878723,
0.40961581468582153,
0.20331327617168427,
-0.3035036623477936,
0.7279092669487,
-0.7736876606941223,
-0.3408820331096649,
-0.4656211733818054,
0.2213086485862732,
-0.29204005002975464,
-0.05555075779557228,
0.8143438100814819,
0.48766037821769714,
0.9699638485908508,
0.24942898750305176,
0.8655722737312317,
-0.05330564081668854,
1.0837301015853882,
0.01948203518986702,
0.9427119493484497,
-0.31457749009132385,
0.3031223714351654,
0.14673514664173126,
-0.5460131168365479,
-0.0918404683470726,
0.8712462186813354,
0.05248093605041504,
0.04581254720687866,
0.5655480623245239,
0.6943719387054443,
-0.2632891535758972,
0.26424551010131836,
0.47674599289894104,
0.3225993514060974,
0.19091930985450745,
0.7062150835990906,
1.0103771686553955,
-0.2733733057975769,
0.44763290882110596,
0.17493285238742828,
-0.5233093500137329,
0.03504979982972145,
-0.6185648441314697,
-0.7227086424827576,
-0.7359129786491394,
-0.03657088801264763,
-0.422422856092453,
0.6529646515846252,
0.7086846828460693,
0.6810489296913147,
-0.4512387812137604,
-0.7888931632041931,
-0.009042153134942055,
0.274673730134964,
-0.14151662588119507,
-0.21763074398040771,
0.009895927272737026,
-0.8750401139259338,
-0.21937763690948486,
0.4003421664237976,
0.6677952408790588,
-0.2050376534461975,
-0.4424431025981903,
-0.29685646295547485,
-0.33122825622558594,
0.23900429904460907,
0.596123993396759,
0.65193110704422,
-0.06719343364238739,
-0.2649098336696625,
0.14654721319675446,
-0.2715657353401184,
0.2917313575744629,
0.7163922786712646,
-1.2161091566085815,
0.3981839120388031,
0.46241989731788635,
1.1453588008880615,
0.5222063064575195,
-0.22176103293895721,
0.5851147174835205,
-0.24283403158187866,
0.01590002328157425,
0.11646068841218948,
-0.14391978085041046,
0.37861135601997375,
-0.20845209062099457,
0.4862586557865143,
0.2620377242565155,
-0.8394613862037659,
-0.5975534319877625,
0.2778800427913666,
-0.7922728657722473,
-0.19925037026405334,
0.9085775017738342,
-0.38187354803085327,
-0.6214550137519836,
-0.4125443994998932,
-0.18204213678836823,
0.24746918678283691,
-0.39531388878822327,
1.354443073272705,
0.3712591826915741,
-0.25369203090667725,
-0.38689520955085754,
-0.8772441744804382,
0.5082434415817261,
0.6901025176048279,
-0.8788194060325623,
-0.12962055206298828,
0.43299785256385803,
0.43858644366264343,
0.23937737941741943,
1.2507774829864502,
-0.34799128770828247,
0.6077598333358765,
-0.13438551127910614,
0.07023703306913376,
0.16325926780700684,
-0.825851559638977,
0.12771888077259064,
0.08129339665174484,
0.03615555167198181,
-0.12315545976161957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12042v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12042v1
|
Exploring Boundaries and Intensities in Offensive and Hate Speech: Unveiling the Complex Spectrum of Social Media Discourse
| 2024-04-18T09:52:50 | 2024-04-18T09:52:50 |
Abinew Ali Ayele, Esubalew Alemneh Jalew, Adem Chanie Ali, Seid Muhie Yimam, Chris Biemann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The prevalence of digital media and evolving sociopolitical dynamics have
significantly amplified the dissemination of hateful content. Existing studies
mainly focus on classifying texts into binary categories, often overlooking the
continuous spectrum of offensiveness and hatefulness inherent in the text. In
this research, we present an extensive benchmark dataset for Amharic,
comprising 8,258 tweets annotated for three distinct tasks: category
classification, identification of hate targets, and rating offensiveness and
hatefulness intensities. Our study highlights that a considerable majority of
tweets belong to the less offensive and less hate intensity levels,
underscoring the need for early interventions by stakeholders. The prevalence
of ethnic and political hatred targets, with significant overlaps in our
dataset, emphasizes the complex relationships within Ethiopia's sociopolitical
landscape. We build classification and regression models and investigate the
efficacy of models in handling these tasks. Our results reveal that hate and
offensive speech can not be addressed by a simplistic binary classification,
instead manifesting as variables across a continuous range of values. The
Afro-XLMR-large model exhibits the best performances achieving F1-scores of
75.30%, 70.59%, and 29.42% for the category, target, and regression tasks,
respectively. The 80.22% correlation coefficient of the Afro-XLMR-large model
indicates strong alignments.
|
[
-0.6993969082832336,
-1.016481876373291,
-0.047491107136011124,
0.3212685286998749,
-0.15147648751735687,
0.4885125458240509,
-0.4927314221858978,
-0.8090628981590271,
0.3529219925403595,
0.21236984431743622,
-0.3850841224193573,
-0.529900312423706,
-1.1664085388183594,
-0.16764293611049652,
-0.7107881903648376,
1.268891453742981,
0.18662121891975403,
-0.24886026978492737,
0.7116339206695557,
-0.6048353314399719,
-0.0663641020655632,
-0.5893089175224304,
-0.7161383628845215,
0.08001594990491867,
0.8233138918876648,
0.15640124678611755,
0.7620717883110046,
0.2642446458339691,
0.3325805068016052,
0.17614851891994476,
-0.36835798621177673,
0.034890368580818176,
-0.4665663540363312,
0.29682955145835876,
-0.1767415851354599,
0.12056402117013931,
-0.1517539918422699,
0.07947620749473572,
0.4230732023715973,
0.4887244999408722,
-0.20888221263885498,
0.41046589612960815,
0.2692011892795563,
0.26032131910324097,
-0.784159779548645,
-0.20541083812713623,
-0.7169493436813354,
-0.17445112764835358,
-0.4149693250656128,
0.23637640476226807,
-0.05132758244872093,
-0.4152393341064453,
-0.22207731008529663,
-0.4584881365299225,
-0.1680033653974533,
-0.04959578439593315,
0.6582055687904358,
-0.07808434963226318,
-0.7582932710647583,
-0.6347519755363464,
-0.8007178902626038,
0.8830319046974182,
-0.49408838152885437,
0.154085174202919,
0.2552143931388855,
0.21859364211559296,
0.26538410782814026,
-0.33497685194015503,
-0.5856481194496155,
0.12266901880502701,
0.2564370334148407,
0.010136823169887066,
-0.5820688009262085,
-0.14323857426643372,
0.31805068254470825,
0.06254605948925018,
0.08091908693313599,
0.3213135302066803,
-0.4132159650325775,
-0.12757791578769684,
0.8433821797370911,
0.40388572216033936,
0.34477195143699646,
-0.28627800941467285,
-0.17906399071216583,
0.23104003071784973,
-0.3820051848888397,
0.1890358179807663,
0.7717665433883667,
0.4894239008426666,
-0.46119484305381775,
0.6238319873809814,
0.036083709448575974,
0.5358303189277649,
-0.19332492351531982,
0.061451446264982224,
0.1415444016456604,
-0.07297401130199432,
0.04942712187767029,
0.018365252763032913,
0.8542312383651733,
0.5758112072944641,
0.37364110350608826,
0.1827126294374466,
-0.2835187315940857,
0.3010375201702118,
0.846276581287384,
-0.6883888244628906,
0.2265758514404297,
0.013738646171987057,
-0.4587673544883728,
-0.480228453874588,
-0.4091152250766754,
-0.9033698439598083,
-0.703249990940094,
-0.21154990792274475,
0.31089237332344055,
-0.468243271112442,
-0.20697259902954102,
-0.5728612542152405,
0.06934478878974915,
0.11210169643163681,
0.48866626620292664,
-0.9642298221588135,
0.7444761395454407,
0.5992811322212219,
0.9740694761276245,
-0.21954385936260223,
0.18277354538440704,
-0.11033462733030319,
-0.23848915100097656,
-0.40221598744392395,
0.2292807400226593,
-0.7164964079856873,
-0.20430977642536163,
0.37060293555259705,
-0.3471263349056244,
0.08392799645662308,
-0.5926195383071899,
1.138802170753479,
-0.7462475299835205,
-0.5024687051773071,
-0.14604364335536957,
-0.2526762783527374,
-0.5068341493606567,
0.18845883011817932,
-0.41270866990089417,
0.9171083569526672,
0.3445071876049042,
-0.7960816621780396,
0.31060439348220825,
-0.6462710499763489,
-0.7028056383132935,
-0.11484385281801224,
-0.16371291875839233,
-0.5611088871955872,
0.10611240565776825,
0.024646248668432236,
0.32388949394226074,
-0.38233691453933716,
0.22879156470298767,
-0.5145183801651001,
-0.2069876790046692,
0.11742150783538818,
-0.17373539507389069,
1.039288878440857,
0.44546937942504883,
-0.72439044713974,
0.1531979739665985,
-0.5713361501693726,
-0.48723703622817993,
0.16893763840198517,
-0.18389080464839935,
-0.5013220906257629,
0.11151362210512161,
0.5112683176994324,
0.24643611907958984,
-0.21484658122062683,
-0.9504525661468506,
-0.31214454770088196,
-0.040165238082408905,
0.46923166513442993,
0.784722089767456,
-0.08373091369867325,
0.0936746597290039,
-0.5343875288963318,
0.4042443335056305,
0.3419778347015381,
0.19860415160655975,
0.5053626298904419,
-0.542637050151825,
-0.4185025691986084,
-0.010762689635157585,
-0.07119020074605942,
0.436864972114563,
-0.1836649477481842,
0.16421346366405487,
0.02828158438205719,
-0.7273887991905212,
-0.5447069406509399,
-0.2838316857814789,
0.15988664329051971,
0.45854631066322327,
0.5476939678192139,
-0.06540356576442719,
-0.8150846362113953,
-1.1142162084579468,
-0.3443623185157776,
-0.3197821080684662,
0.2560894191265106,
0.5478483438491821,
0.6193590760231018,
-0.06918908655643463,
0.47542548179626465,
-0.11240781843662262,
-0.22799892723560333,
-0.04453713446855545,
0.49044594168663025,
0.046349745243787766,
0.2089807242155075,
0.7189153432846069,
-1.1970365047454834,
-0.8665193915367126,
-0.006932780612260103,
-0.44568151235580444,
-0.38747870922088623,
0.44530150294303894,
0.1131155788898468,
0.028050845488905907,
0.020969342440366745,
0.058176979422569275,
0.5899731516838074,
0.5333031415939331,
-0.1282663494348526,
0.6514464020729065,
0.7671123147010803,
0.7019267678260803,
-0.8073391914367676,
-0.10328816622495651,
0.22336655855178833,
0.006231826264411211,
-0.9225139617919922,
-0.2819650173187256,
-0.09469146281480789,
-0.0737278014421463,
-0.50113445520401,
0.30007514357566833,
0.059775955975055695,
0.25973621010780334,
-0.008382641710340977,
-0.19059062004089355,
-0.4313623607158661,
0.31001368165016174,
-0.1481347233057022,
0.4295293092727661,
0.32596349716186523,
-0.5812581181526184,
0.24012869596481323,
0.36683568358421326,
-0.6929647326469421,
0.5508885383605957,
-0.3393227159976959,
-0.24614907801151276,
-0.14927615225315094,
-0.09775736182928085,
-0.938576340675354,
-0.3086038827896118,
0.4353490471839905,
-0.39207279682159424,
0.15418148040771484,
-0.0687769427895546,
-0.2921108305454254,
-0.3076736629009247,
-0.324913889169693,
0.7691407203674316,
0.35589680075645447,
-0.263094037771225,
0.627263605594635,
1.034156322479248,
-0.3651353120803833,
-0.8586617112159729,
-0.6188156604766846,
0.21832029521465302,
-0.621946394443512,
-0.4711366891860962,
0.41580435633659363,
0.08604976534843445,
-0.7016113996505737,
-0.19082176685333252,
0.07107533514499664,
-0.009715893305838108,
0.19309067726135254,
0.586133599281311,
-0.235323965549469,
0.04745646193623543,
-0.15777038037776947,
0.12740512192249298,
0.6342145800590515,
0.23123949766159058,
0.08122555911540985,
0.4490145742893219,
0.1810469925403595,
0.14924190938472748,
0.12036518007516861,
0.590453028678894,
0.3917635977268219,
-0.0174458809196949,
1.017225980758667,
0.5114076733589172,
-0.7509925961494446,
-0.19963303208351135,
-0.6838134527206421,
0.22018447518348694,
-0.31358373165130615,
0.34023019671440125,
-0.13947749137878418,
-0.8417372703552246,
0.9192311763763428,
0.24216784536838531,
0.22972586750984192,
0.3486335873603821,
0.8324161767959595,
-0.03519125282764435,
0.7492073178291321,
0.32752591371536255,
-0.13832056522369385,
0.42718225717544556,
-0.02649601735174656,
0.17334525287151337,
-0.8771703243255615,
-0.3450157642364502,
-0.6908442974090576,
-0.2539355456829071,
-0.5382575988769531,
-0.10634131729602814,
0.4665691554546356,
-0.2375563532114029,
-0.5023182034492493,
0.35017096996307373,
-0.3685838580131531,
0.05267015099525452,
0.07818830013275146,
-0.0009986956138163805,
-0.1554880142211914,
0.10951907932758331,
0.004835197702050209,
-0.35090747475624084,
-0.2726076543331146,
-0.43691927194595337,
0.855792760848999,
0.5117195248603821,
0.6923214197158813,
0.4495070278644562,
0.3456324636936188,
0.7703116536140442,
0.9264163970947266,
-0.802597165107727,
0.2529655694961548,
-0.3517267405986786,
-1.0923423767089844,
-0.20429179072380066,
-0.3357921540737152,
-0.7531325817108154,
0.351529061794281,
-0.35259488224983215,
-1.0597487688064575,
0.27096325159072876,
-0.21647514402866364,
-0.26329702138900757,
0.8100833892822266,
-0.2636023461818695,
0.5097097754478455,
0.0387592688202858,
-0.4398597478866577,
-0.12388253211975098,
-0.6818323731422424,
0.4763791859149933,
-0.5162448287010193,
0.9115817546844482,
-0.42210566997528076,
-0.3426322042942047,
1.0660943984985352,
-0.13606992363929749,
0.8234196305274963,
-0.1436212956905365,
-0.13699056208133698,
0.4753984808921814,
-0.010149907320737839,
0.09343694150447845,
-0.5472420454025269,
-0.6021413207054138,
0.3977045714855194,
-0.526802122592926,
-0.28683310747146606,
-0.15835826098918915,
0.5057775974273682,
-0.8635818958282471,
-0.31833750009536743,
-0.05746571347117424,
-0.5024425387382507,
-0.07668932527303696,
0.20788361132144928,
0.38342633843421936,
0.613381028175354,
-0.5746006965637207,
0.12332803755998611,
0.46777188777923584,
-0.27916499972343445,
0.2974061667919159,
0.22105470299720764,
-0.08049347251653671,
-0.36831173300743103,
0.6429637670516968,
0.6863781809806824,
0.20254401862621307,
0.08207844197750092,
-0.06159859895706177,
-0.3035433888435364,
-0.7100367546081543,
-0.38089051842689514,
-0.08197928220033646,
-0.6673731803894043,
-0.34952718019485474,
-1.0104808807373047,
-0.41415056586265564,
-0.4591602683067322,
-0.2452256977558136,
-0.12646527588367462,
-0.20223017036914825,
0.03176690265536308,
0.14784221351146698,
0.09242574870586395,
1.1025347709655762,
-0.3957185447216034,
0.6204478144645691,
-0.27889829874038696,
0.3193061649799347,
-0.15094242990016937,
0.29795917868614197,
0.17261864244937897,
-1.0537813901901245,
-0.37161049246788025,
0.10401985049247742,
-0.5213921070098877,
-1.2369600534439087,
0.3108491897583008,
-0.03200409561395645,
0.1724781095981598,
0.23114489018917084,
0.33759501576423645,
0.42750084400177,
-0.5546433329582214,
0.5638213157653809,
0.18932600319385529,
-0.8223550319671631,
0.37734344601631165,
-0.6374295353889465,
-0.17138701677322388,
0.32262054085731506,
1.0054713487625122,
-0.6116456985473633,
-0.8296277523040771,
-0.7336910367012024,
-0.8539987206459045,
0.7541404366493225,
0.4559641480445862,
0.29610249400138855,
-0.14973795413970947,
-0.008837522007524967,
0.007683216128498316,
0.23817801475524902,
-0.7408930659294128,
-0.7337817549705505,
-0.20173250138759613,
-0.2402743250131607,
-0.03304624184966087,
-0.5186656713485718,
-0.29117241501808167,
-0.19165334105491638,
0.6487839221954346,
0.37011030316352844,
-0.016758963465690613,
-0.16102907061576843,
-0.02724359929561615,
-0.3940270245075226,
0.28487399220466614,
0.40661337971687317,
0.4643564224243164,
-0.3083641529083252,
0.08356070518493652,
0.0663820207118988,
-0.6232329607009888,
0.43105238676071167,
0.056461628526449203,
-0.18048270046710968,
-0.029589258134365082,
0.2887560725212097,
0.5925591588020325,
0.01707823947072029,
-0.23982883989810944,
0.5494115352630615,
0.12061505019664764,
-0.403043657541275,
-0.39616653323173523,
-0.146817147731781,
0.040130842477083206,
0.10689996182918549,
0.5076878070831299,
0.06966759264469147,
0.32992085814476013,
-0.5068392753601074,
0.17447134852409363,
0.3517795205116272,
-0.5531907677650452,
-0.25879907608032227,
0.8370183110237122,
0.10098455101251602,
-0.40419501066207886,
0.33270224928855896,
0.030792023986577988,
-0.6758624911308289,
0.692849338054657,
0.47627514600753784,
0.5069881677627563,
-0.4148855209350586,
0.3369053602218628,
0.7351584434509277,
0.6459555625915527,
0.8276053667068481,
-0.0053335558623075485,
-0.07497107982635498,
-1.0127846002578735,
0.05146291106939316,
-0.91242915391922,
-0.2267664670944214,
0.3162463903427124,
-0.7593023777008057,
0.1985223889350891,
-0.7648990750312805,
-0.5458883047103882,
0.9226428270339966,
0.16693054139614105,
-0.3502119481563568,
0.4625036120414734,
0.5781856179237366,
0.7635058760643005,
-1.0269180536270142,
0.282597154378891,
0.644761860370636,
-0.25557687878608704,
-0.5630751252174377,
-0.1925734430551529,
0.4338591992855072,
-0.7328206300735474,
0.5542836785316467,
0.27286630868911743,
-0.08071094006299973,
-0.1131114661693573,
-0.6823622584342957,
-0.3862322270870209,
0.23202314972877502,
-0.03468440845608711,
-0.3747696280479431,
0.39218711853027344,
0.27982407808303833,
0.494628369808197,
-0.6049426198005676,
0.2756270468235016,
0.5847340822219849,
0.38696619868278503,
0.014886006712913513,
-0.6891876459121704,
0.18562164902687073,
-0.3338659703731537,
-0.21691086888313293,
0.6187117099761963,
-0.7751432061195374,
0.8264194130897522,
-0.025409860536456108,
-0.3720567524433136,
-0.25053274631500244,
0.43463531136512756,
-0.250897079706192,
0.2814403474330902,
0.709553062915802,
0.416622519493103,
0.3194805085659027,
-0.09048489481210709,
0.6873488426208496,
0.17487019300460815,
-0.06823122501373291,
0.8917246460914612,
-0.0766829326748848,
0.5011398792266846,
0.09956487268209457,
-0.29312393069267273,
0.5366389155387878,
0.7538281679153442,
0.09162140637636185,
0.18813283741474152,
0.529972493648529,
-0.6263880133628845,
0.06015005707740784,
-0.8344171047210693,
-0.0982719138264656,
0.32306522130966187,
0.9033812284469604,
-0.16542445123195648,
-0.3866812288761139,
0.18933337926864624,
0.2470318078994751,
0.3831828236579895,
-0.5574688911437988,
0.7046820521354675,
0.16764944791793823,
-0.3358365297317505,
0.4836099147796631,
0.28673747181892395,
0.783554196357727,
-0.5047341585159302,
0.17753754556179047,
0.12266610562801361,
-0.2200503945350647,
-0.4207986295223236,
-0.9678215384483337,
0.7317245602607727,
0.37711772322654724,
-0.10768920183181763,
0.1401710957288742,
0.6304762959480286,
-0.3499963581562042,
-0.02615695632994175,
0.7615931630134583,
0.06895742565393448,
0.025054356083273888,
-0.04584907367825508,
-0.7899275422096252,
0.42619097232818604,
0.04912491887807846,
-0.11666940152645111,
0.16823038458824158,
0.37121978402137756,
-0.2260671705007553,
0.5151262879371643,
0.21986989676952362,
0.21484850347042084,
0.16604754328727722,
0.16902141273021698,
0.910966694355011,
-0.5625496506690979,
-0.18913576006889343,
-0.9122656583786011,
0.35417458415031433,
-0.16271135210990906,
-0.48122403025627136,
0.722012460231781,
0.6664201021194458,
0.8005218505859375,
0.36047765612602234,
0.8001611828804016,
-0.4888703525066376,
0.8717185258865356,
0.10488897562026978,
0.5711339712142944,
-0.6118495464324951,
-0.06366331875324249,
-0.426903635263443,
-0.6881975531578064,
-0.28935033082962036,
0.360594242811203,
-0.43794840574264526,
-0.07130417227745056,
0.12273288518190384,
0.595861554145813,
-0.1513344943523407,
0.3770671784877777,
0.23707500100135803,
0.46482038497924805,
0.280695378780365,
0.14030645787715912,
1.2123322486877441,
-0.4121360778808594,
0.35000085830688477,
-0.4791589081287384,
-0.41728702187538147,
-0.11179504543542862,
-0.47449034452438354,
-0.7028908729553223,
-0.6053247451782227,
-0.08629103749990463,
-0.6287417411804199,
0.14491775631904602,
0.8855549693107605,
0.5157464146614075,
-0.8825565576553345,
-0.5251158475875854,
0.646060049533844,
0.14629927277565002,
-0.06176547706127167,
-0.22570018470287323,
0.08083657175302505,
-0.13999110460281372,
-0.7391688823699951,
-0.32113873958587646,
0.15660153329372406,
0.020137663930654526,
0.1517476737499237,
0.20334915816783905,
-0.6180210709571838,
0.36866047978401184,
0.8349512219429016,
0.22613747417926788,
-0.507082998752594,
-0.26338499784469604,
-0.3633876442909241,
-0.20083434879779816,
0.011331320740282536,
0.5650601387023926,
-0.15271210670471191,
0.12965941429138184,
-0.006798268761485815,
0.6762763261795044,
0.38064271211624146,
0.28959378600120544,
0.2029709815979004,
-0.6132352352142334,
0.12298126518726349,
0.5656629204750061,
0.13516761362552643,
0.3351696729660034,
-0.15320606529712677,
0.5322278738021851,
0.01376295369118452,
-0.44284501671791077,
-0.8602045774459839,
0.2166597992181778,
-0.8480725884437561,
-0.1738690584897995,
1.044975757598877,
0.0662647932767868,
-0.14781905710697174,
-0.422603577375412,
-0.06191437691450119,
0.5549671053886414,
-0.600275456905365,
0.9170664548873901,
0.8889802694320679,
0.1637439727783203,
0.1420947164297104,
-0.6145199537277222,
0.5321595072746277,
0.4476800560951233,
-0.6032382845878601,
0.23261038959026337,
0.40891724824905396,
0.07868330925703049,
0.26541247963905334,
0.5835514068603516,
-0.22012671828269958,
-0.0793643444776535,
0.20602908730506897,
-0.22917315363883972,
0.5200346112251282,
-0.2923128306865692,
-0.16698771715164185,
0.3038165867328644,
-0.30410629510879517,
0.07928761839866638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12041v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12041v2
|
Can We Catch the Elephant? A Survey of the Evolvement of Hallucination Evaluation on Natural Language Generation
| 2024-04-18T09:52:18 | 2024-06-15T22:57:20 |
Siya Qi, Yulan He, Zheng Yuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Hallucination in Natural Language Generation (NLG) is like the elephant in
the room, obvious but often overlooked until recent achievements significantly
improved the fluency and grammaticality of generated text. As the capabilities
of text generation models have improved, researchers have begun to pay more
attention to the phenomenon of hallucination. Despite significant progress in
this field in recent years, the evaluation system for hallucination is complex
and diverse, lacking clear organization. We are the first to comprehensively
survey how various evaluation methods have evolved with the development of text
generation models from three dimensions, including hallucinated fact
granularity, evaluator design principles, and assessment facets. This survey
aims to help researchers identify current limitations in hallucination
evaluation and highlight future research directions.
|
[
-0.7408986687660217,
-1.1230883598327637,
0.5505917072296143,
0.40690770745277405,
-0.3934721350669861,
-0.07710150629281998,
-0.14919790625572205,
-0.8648694753646851,
0.3997993469238281,
0.4768398702144623,
-0.39961621165275574,
-0.27803894877433777,
-0.6421239376068115,
0.6471747159957886,
-0.48015329241752625,
0.907629132270813,
0.19466951489448547,
-0.20635466277599335,
-0.18083034455776215,
0.011225547641515732,
-0.809833824634552,
-0.5185959339141846,
-0.48717743158340454,
-0.23932182788848877,
0.2042945921421051,
0.1566542387008667,
0.4664085805416107,
0.3366243243217468,
0.4881592094898224,
0.2571222186088562,
-0.04184606671333313,
0.41033947467803955,
-0.3752295672893524,
0.015259268693625927,
0.27482518553733826,
0.0714983120560646,
-0.26071691513061523,
0.06992818415164948,
0.4470006823539734,
1.0315775871276855,
-0.27136874198913574,
-0.22658586502075195,
0.3355189859867096,
0.8089296817779541,
-0.6150644421577454,
-0.0953020378947258,
-0.9356202483177185,
0.27273404598236084,
-0.08072536438703537,
-0.3737562894821167,
-0.3819456696510315,
-0.7837135791778564,
0.4566640853881836,
-0.47436657547950745,
0.45423755049705505,
0.0681544616818428,
0.7624883055686951,
0.299799382686615,
-0.26155731081962585,
-1.0333688259124756,
-0.7560982704162598,
0.8885223865509033,
-0.46960654854774475,
0.29392772912979126,
0.47010570764541626,
0.24289609491825104,
-0.03983696177601814,
-0.6992666125297546,
-0.5851263999938965,
-0.6093385815620422,
0.07669784873723984,
-0.08170313388109207,
-0.09481921792030334,
-0.2807939648628235,
-0.06957186758518219,
0.4746910333633423,
-0.7563465237617493,
-0.0998840406537056,
-0.2407834827899933,
-0.18539835512638092,
0.8453617691993713,
-0.09523702412843704,
0.44982555508613586,
-0.4512200653553009,
-0.3594250977039337,
-0.11078323423862457,
-0.3438941538333893,
-0.4497937858104706,
0.3899715840816498,
0.340411514043808,
0.4036109447479248,
0.4672424793243408,
0.06955099105834961,
0.4757116436958313,
-0.14635489881038666,
0.29706135392189026,
0.22875097393989563,
-0.2837529480457306,
-0.041022203862667084,
0.38621658086776733,
0.6603750586509705,
0.4348309636116028,
-0.022302165627479553,
-0.36501798033714294,
-0.40198948979377747,
0.1719488650560379,
0.7415269017219543,
-0.5742092728614807,
-0.12152305245399475,
0.20139464735984802,
-0.645670473575592,
-0.4440457224845886,
0.1356302797794342,
-1.1768525838851929,
-0.6115105152130127,
0.0821143090724945,
0.4409235417842865,
-0.6570124626159668,
-0.4796740412712097,
0.4257219433784485,
-0.17061369121074677,
0.45331427454948425,
-0.048782262951135635,
-0.9785661101341248,
0.5647954344749451,
0.8138163089752197,
0.928374707698822,
-0.3049541413784027,
-0.5317972302436829,
-0.22562113404273987,
-0.3413170874118805,
-0.39192309975624084,
1.0025441646575928,
-0.3600405156612396,
-0.6420602798461914,
0.25910627841949463,
-0.4295438826084137,
-0.08486872911453247,
-0.8512639999389648,
0.7620368003845215,
-0.21128056943416595,
0.4236304759979248,
-0.277870774269104,
-0.4748193621635437,
-0.3630923628807068,
0.09595680981874466,
-0.5680511593818665,
0.9776684045791626,
-0.04077877476811409,
-0.8196559548377991,
0.7999529242515564,
-0.7134502530097961,
-0.41396400332450867,
0.2936641275882721,
-0.25215089321136475,
-0.6268327236175537,
0.41496726870536804,
0.24810190498828888,
0.23804894089698792,
-0.16367404162883759,
0.39028164744377136,
-0.01562172919511795,
-0.5147168636322021,
0.26844584941864014,
-0.34526437520980835,
0.7465474009513855,
0.34040671586990356,
-0.502035915851593,
-0.1972077637910843,
-0.9851371645927429,
-0.15038445591926575,
0.2586615979671478,
-0.230424702167511,
-0.40342605113983154,
0.24082700908184052,
0.08825735002756119,
-0.07724705338478088,
0.03198998048901558,
-0.21488995850086212,
0.19440020620822906,
-0.3320896625518799,
0.14359445869922638,
0.47256168723106384,
0.4880353808403015,
0.21789874136447906,
-0.4682464897632599,
0.4757269620895386,
-0.5188524127006531,
-0.15527647733688354,
0.2957848012447357,
-0.6144241094589233,
-0.7143413424491882,
0.18028762936592102,
0.034776970744132996,
0.289050430059433,
-0.5714954733848572,
0.7274240851402283,
-0.17747241258621216,
-0.5656538605690002,
-0.43678969144821167,
-0.02774033695459366,
0.1912524402141571,
0.16024205088615417,
0.25319692492485046,
-0.3190542161464691,
-0.6735731959342957,
-0.7266174554824829,
-0.375649094581604,
-0.392822265625,
-0.04702528566122055,
0.19311314821243286,
0.5798805952072144,
-0.32868871092796326,
0.766926109790802,
-0.35220831632614136,
-0.27146244049072266,
-0.5014073252677917,
0.7794446349143982,
-0.13246959447860718,
0.32211408019065857,
0.7002423405647278,
-0.4406887888908386,
0.028659721836447716,
-0.022384600713849068,
-0.9944729804992676,
-0.36073756217956543,
-0.3618602454662323,
0.0031428055372089148,
0.21571868658065796,
0.3689376413822174,
-0.7835153341293335,
0.279258668422699,
0.5222780704498291,
-0.2803431451320648,
0.6769994497299194,
-0.06079741194844246,
0.04897031933069229,
-0.5347771644592285,
0.012568768113851547,
-0.34786173701286316,
0.35790884494781494,
-0.703696072101593,
0.0050244564190506935,
-0.22525499761104584,
-0.035417646169662476,
-0.1384105384349823,
0.33837786316871643,
-0.5381661057472229,
-0.009200619533658028,
-0.2969384789466858,
0.5860995650291443,
-0.1799326241016388,
0.1796230673789978,
0.08020637184381485,
0.475376695394516,
0.48502790927886963,
-0.9702353477478027,
0.03845158591866493,
0.392581969499588,
-0.6372328996658325,
0.4733456075191498,
-0.4136124551296234,
0.3896326720714569,
-0.239458829164505,
0.041362643241882324,
-0.7796222567558289,
-0.39994922280311584,
0.15272098779678345,
-0.4601345360279083,
0.19928359985351562,
0.6093000769615173,
-0.2034704089164734,
-0.4043404757976532,
-0.565514326095581,
0.23561213910579681,
0.381414532661438,
-0.6510120630264282,
0.29882481694221497,
0.3105505406856537,
-0.008067594841122627,
-0.4089839458465576,
-0.6382546424865723,
0.3762567937374115,
-0.4506853520870209,
-0.6938061118125916,
-0.0316644087433815,
-0.07289321720600128,
-0.5865717530250549,
-0.3416326940059662,
-0.2422644942998886,
0.1508379578590393,
0.1611354947090149,
-0.07072911411523819,
-0.14523065090179443,
-0.12410483509302139,
0.2959081530570984,
-0.11623416095972061,
0.07997529208660126,
0.3417239785194397,
-0.08564332127571106,
0.6652387976646423,
-0.008042899891734123,
-0.23624370992183685,
-0.19207142293453217,
0.41039910912513733,
0.15438227355480194,
0.025765161961317062,
0.40621674060821533,
0.43800556659698486,
-0.6163344383239746,
-0.4939907491207123,
-0.5790879726409912,
-0.3466196358203888,
-0.40582898259162903,
0.4885147511959076,
-0.1786893606185913,
-0.661659300327301,
0.3244520127773285,
-0.01415231078863144,
0.09178367257118225,
0.5617071986198425,
0.33014798164367676,
0.3233352601528168,
1.0310804843902588,
0.68388831615448,
0.35308799147605896,
-0.006302483379840851,
-0.04094431921839714,
0.5067731738090515,
-0.5341599583625793,
-0.32055872678756714,
-0.7233464121818542,
-0.1703193336725235,
-0.7235737442970276,
0.024777838960289955,
0.08123037964105606,
0.3138793110847473,
0.3326065242290497,
0.20898622274398804,
-0.9171114563941956,
0.1756054311990738,
0.09254775196313858,
-0.1765688955783844,
0.29446840286254883,
-0.049280960112810135,
0.026311036199331284,
-0.33845314383506775,
-0.3950628340244293,
-0.9712187647819519,
0.7594547271728516,
0.4167385697364807,
0.33038249611854553,
0.04785820096731186,
0.9513248801231384,
0.4780988395214081,
0.32219159603118896,
-0.7870408892631531,
0.7702032327651978,
0.15511776506900787,
-0.44595545530319214,
-0.46173202991485596,
-0.3680000305175781,
-1.271370530128479,
0.38994595408439636,
-0.08124653249979019,
-0.994295597076416,
0.1689656376838684,
-0.21750673651695251,
-0.21736839413642883,
0.13878053426742554,
-0.6240613460540771,
0.7791014313697815,
-0.3558520972728729,
0.09718251973390579,
0.062329549342393875,
-0.26667535305023193,
0.7221415042877197,
-0.4298087954521179,
0.2840172350406647,
-0.02351273037493229,
0.07516754418611526,
0.9456421732902527,
-0.4416993260383606,
0.43856364488601685,
-0.22527958452701569,
-0.456964910030365,
0.6889687180519104,
0.2988309860229492,
0.28027406334877014,
0.04899103567004204,
-0.25286439061164856,
0.11324532330036163,
-0.47901034355163574,
-0.09182818233966827,
-0.487926185131073,
0.6045741438865662,
-0.5888286828994751,
-0.42755869030952454,
-0.5428902506828308,
-0.30666521191596985,
-0.2730577290058136,
0.04773717373609543,
0.5558270215988159,
0.00029125239234417677,
-0.5172727108001709,
0.0876244455575943,
0.3501500189304352,
-0.435639888048172,
0.7311055064201355,
0.056082140654325485,
-0.7042334675788879,
-0.3823218047618866,
1.2501959800720215,
0.02233431302011013,
-0.11154778301715851,
0.08289439231157303,
0.37780576944351196,
-0.3438546657562256,
-0.7641939520835876,
-0.2083231508731842,
0.28078174591064453,
-0.5544803738594055,
0.031944580376148224,
-0.913540244102478,
-0.2647755742073059,
-0.4315086007118225,
-0.22659830749034882,
-0.2686851918697357,
-0.34097522497177124,
-0.2640710771083832,
-0.27070897817611694,
0.15740689635276794,
1.2852436304092407,
-0.17040593922138214,
0.3260875642299652,
-0.5631617307662964,
0.33077168464660645,
0.5892080068588257,
0.38778284192085266,
-0.006823054980486631,
-0.26764485239982605,
0.039872318506240845,
-0.21194058656692505,
-0.5085012316703796,
-1.026505947113037,
0.5021209716796875,
0.10281720012426376,
0.4310431182384491,
0.6078848838806152,
-0.08288224041461945,
0.5915151238441467,
-0.24732814729213715,
1.234294056892395,
0.15374398231506348,
-0.9778913855552673,
0.5238323211669922,
-0.14078037440776825,
0.14058230817317963,
0.5273644328117371,
0.05014899745583534,
-0.3648044168949127,
-0.562263011932373,
-0.4940127730369568,
-0.8066802024841309,
0.48116791248321533,
0.5391385555267334,
0.16308006644248962,
-0.17068585753440857,
0.04809664562344551,
0.6208118200302124,
0.19063499569892883,
-0.8913190364837646,
0.10834153741598129,
-0.29812830686569214,
0.38739582896232605,
0.10229550302028656,
-0.18535906076431274,
0.25678324699401855,
-0.06230442598462105,
0.5099315047264099,
0.12119036167860031,
0.2497873604297638,
0.10949113219976425,
-0.12361996620893478,
-0.2078307569026947,
0.2526678740978241,
0.6969444751739502,
0.8078659772872925,
-0.4356655478477478,
0.15083202719688416,
0.33948051929473877,
-0.7475827932357788,
-0.07586301118135452,
0.04144185408949852,
-0.27627986669540405,
0.3732057511806488,
0.5141425132751465,
0.7144254446029663,
-0.05927930399775505,
-0.730962336063385,
0.4056421220302582,
-0.319889634847641,
-0.6587298512458801,
-0.26300978660583496,
-0.03087739460170269,
-0.3393518328666687,
-0.19537127017974854,
0.6091761589050293,
-0.07513033598661423,
0.3544881045818329,
-0.4984070360660553,
0.30607014894485474,
0.40233805775642395,
-0.4010733366012573,
-0.14741310477256775,
0.7514008283615112,
0.038292303681373596,
-0.5686548352241516,
0.5602445602416992,
-0.5590338706970215,
-0.3177531361579895,
0.4108116924762726,
0.5873798131942749,
1.4298750162124634,
-0.20781579613685608,
0.3911144733428955,
0.3769811987876892,
0.6149905323982239,
-0.005430270917713642,
0.460393488407135,
-0.08857525140047073,
-0.5450820326805115,
-0.19733448326587677,
-0.9625400304794312,
-0.20533683896064758,
0.5761657953262329,
-0.43554002046585083,
0.3866426646709442,
-0.1430826336145401,
-0.17597442865371704,
-0.08506869524717331,
-0.006829314865171909,
-0.4889088273048401,
0.033188626170158386,
0.18159309029579163,
0.6108785271644592,
-0.7223788499832153,
0.20606687664985657,
0.6294402480125427,
-0.3641045093536377,
-0.21669992804527283,
0.3883739411830902,
-0.06471245735883713,
-0.4385310113430023,
0.2686893045902252,
0.5539350509643555,
-0.20395216345787048,
-0.3317629396915436,
-0.7548153400421143,
-0.39011675119400024,
0.6126713752746582,
-0.22425499558448792,
-0.15306848287582397,
-0.052300143986940384,
0.3098464906215668,
0.7395740747451782,
-0.3552124500274658,
0.046661023050546646,
1.0109230279922485,
0.5900949835777283,
-0.17906637489795685,
-0.6490559577941895,
-0.06470326334238052,
-0.27879825234413147,
0.27990439534187317,
0.05703260004520416,
-0.36978664994239807,
0.5745450854301453,
-0.15148797631263733,
-0.5326939821243286,
0.27100369334220886,
0.6482163071632385,
0.42039382457733154,
0.48953136801719666,
0.6265480518341064,
0.5539811849594116,
0.7725352644920349,
-0.20049598813056946,
1.0707838535308838,
-0.11976026743650436,
0.19815409183502197,
0.7071747779846191,
-0.3637368381023407,
0.6170269846916199,
0.5591614246368408,
-0.10063411295413971,
0.2961432933807373,
0.6076241135597229,
0.1108136847615242,
0.45869648456573486,
0.6150239109992981,
-0.26940813660621643,
0.025577766820788383,
-0.23918038606643677,
-0.4501534700393677,
0.6521599888801575,
0.41248127818107605,
-0.12589611113071442,
-0.20941641926765442,
0.13447238504886627,
-0.1770462989807129,
0.23103827238082886,
0.2034510225057602,
0.877855122089386,
-0.06442651897668839,
-0.7501139044761658,
0.7256479859352112,
-0.21612860262393951,
0.6019588112831116,
-0.3532352149486542,
-0.3885563313961029,
-0.4286856949329376,
-0.29775846004486084,
-0.16790352761745453,
-0.475505530834198,
0.4048711061477661,
0.14190362393856049,
0.37410968542099,
-0.2807142734527588,
0.6442476511001587,
-0.09248704463243484,
-0.2588445246219635,
0.31465211510658264,
0.6429051756858826,
0.6276437044143677,
-0.05766403675079346,
-0.22143974900245667,
0.42329561710357666,
-0.16388434171676636,
-0.23196543753147125,
-0.16465437412261963,
0.7527778744697571,
0.17192751169204712,
0.40781688690185547,
0.35651057958602905,
0.17260144650936127,
0.33368372917175293,
0.2476789653301239,
0.4416877329349518,
-0.7658223509788513,
-0.22409528493881226,
-0.8096436262130737,
0.28835102915763855,
-0.1511664241552353,
-0.5852401256561279,
0.8645844459533691,
0.7249018549919128,
0.8314709663391113,
-0.09507384151220322,
0.9571648240089417,
-0.19204840064048767,
0.48470619320869446,
-0.3869578242301941,
0.7423207759857178,
-0.5525344014167786,
0.4067588448524475,
-0.6558018326759338,
-1.4970694780349731,
-0.40787458419799805,
0.7521513104438782,
-0.04207377880811691,
0.1475229412317276,
0.9894329309463501,
0.5937143564224243,
0.18447797000408173,
0.5224297046661377,
0.3815499246120453,
0.1707446277141571,
0.25220727920532227,
0.22916506230831146,
1.3727351427078247,
-0.31384220719337463,
0.6390158534049988,
-0.29674601554870605,
-0.19731751084327698,
-0.3640177845954895,
-0.8576068878173828,
-0.7574490904808044,
-0.6455293297767639,
-0.3836246430873871,
-0.18501007556915283,
-0.09273634850978851,
0.6658678650856018,
0.21402882039546967,
-0.7240804433822632,
-0.36733579635620117,
-0.5228862762451172,
0.059701304882764816,
-0.42582225799560547,
-0.3079879581928253,
0.3981509804725647,
-0.5189133882522583,
-0.7051191329956055,
0.3304212689399719,
0.3488686680793762,
0.06549675762653351,
-0.4822189211845398,
-0.1749451756477356,
-0.09561758488416672,
0.1688673198223114,
0.8000591397285461,
0.21511594951152802,
-0.8366677165031433,
-0.5175347328186035,
0.06389174610376358,
-0.14083650708198547,
-0.034978315234184265,
0.8192383050918579,
-0.5163275003433228,
0.7146898508071899,
0.5031111836433411,
0.6580142378807068,
0.09022972732782364,
-0.11779330670833588,
0.3104712963104248,
-0.6382740139961243,
-0.1435299962759018,
0.3985501527786255,
0.22464218735694885,
0.38303372263908386,
-0.09096415340900421,
0.6310051679611206,
0.14861531555652618,
-0.8402265310287476,
-1.0511231422424316,
-0.067304328083992,
-0.8616542816162109,
-0.15523439645767212,
0.9550110101699829,
0.5852155089378357,
0.08420078456401825,
-0.2870337665081024,
-0.45407459139823914,
0.31999027729034424,
-0.21379432082176208,
1.5258629322052002,
0.9213525056838989,
-0.5030468702316284,
-0.004521047696471214,
-0.7639420032501221,
0.678002119064331,
0.4435962438583374,
-1.1797877550125122,
-0.004554972052574158,
0.5784376263618469,
-0.4672457277774811,
0.5812331438064575,
0.36497387290000916,
-0.06409604102373123,
0.1629904955625534,
0.3157723546028137,
0.21420709788799286,
0.6485735177993774,
-0.27221548557281494,
-0.5181302428245544,
0.19479799270629883,
0.24511441588401794,
-0.16763272881507874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12038v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12038v3
|
Uncovering Safety Risks of Large Language Models through Concept Activation Vector
| 2024-04-18T09:46:25 | 2024-07-02T14:17:57 |
Zhihao Xu, Ruixuan Huang, Changyu Chen, Shuai Wang, Xiting Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite careful safety alignment, current large language models (LLMs) remain
vulnerable to various attacks. To further unveil the safety risks of LLMs, we
introduce a Safety Concept Activation Vector (SCAV) framework, which
effectively guides the attacks by accurately interpreting LLMs' safety
mechanisms. We then develop an SCAV-guided attack method that can generate both
attack prompts and embedding-level attacks with automatically selected
perturbation hyperparameters. Both automatic and human evaluations demonstrate
that our attack method significantly improves the attack success rate and
response quality while requiring less training data. Additionally, we find that
our generated attack prompts may be transferable to GPT-4, and the
embedding-level attacks may also be transferred to other white-box LLMs whose
parameters are known. Our experiments further uncover the safety risks present
in current LLMs. For example, we find that six out of seven open-source LLMs
that we attack consistently provide relevant answers to more than 85\%
malicious instructions. Finally, we provide insights into the safety mechanism
of LLMs.
|
[
-0.017348652705550194,
-0.9269821047782898,
0.5830011963844299,
-0.14157716929912567,
-0.37042129039764404,
0.12164515256881714,
-0.06026046350598335,
-0.27115315198898315,
-0.07143481820821762,
0.6166917681694031,
-0.20044514536857605,
-0.6506505608558655,
-0.7843604683876038,
-0.23495930433273315,
-0.5191130638122559,
0.7773370146751404,
0.15716803073883057,
-0.12145695835351944,
-0.29100170731544495,
0.2483086735010147,
-0.2856755554676056,
-0.7418960332870483,
-0.5725919604301453,
0.14773154258728027,
0.6380795240402222,
0.41090312600135803,
0.5017894506454468,
0.6336755752563477,
0.677871584892273,
0.3414384424686432,
-0.14187681674957275,
-0.3566898703575134,
-0.5470371842384338,
0.4116038978099823,
-0.1142338216304779,
-0.5196190476417542,
-0.4807589054107666,
-0.3157501816749573,
0.5405995845794678,
0.41682684421539307,
-0.18712957203388214,
0.10419261455535889,
0.10159557312726974,
0.4880749583244324,
-0.7293685078620911,
0.12211396545171738,
-0.9033114910125732,
-0.0036781439557671547,
-0.4160137176513672,
-0.2981240749359131,
-0.6063873171806335,
-0.19514867663383484,
0.1069352999329567,
-0.3603736162185669,
-0.16951453685760498,
-0.057222310453653336,
0.6496109366416931,
0.2864520251750946,
-0.48484933376312256,
-0.2039189338684082,
-0.5430710911750793,
0.7922179102897644,
-0.5270779132843018,
0.1458280086517334,
0.1575976461172104,
0.30730512738227844,
-0.6023573279380798,
-0.4383285641670227,
-0.4204278886318207,
-0.24877561628818512,
0.17374584078788757,
-0.26173892617225647,
-0.5150927901268005,
0.2835805416107178,
0.46395188570022583,
0.007049983832985163,
-0.570793628692627,
0.22833015024662018,
-0.4398688077926636,
-0.2869085669517517,
0.6242061257362366,
0.1479451209306717,
0.5661085247993469,
-0.13875369727611542,
-0.6194412708282471,
-0.1909351646900177,
-1.1042977571487427,
-0.09014540910720825,
0.6021563410758972,
0.18332189321517944,
-0.1585332453250885,
0.7108439207077026,
-0.035527393221855164,
0.5790141820907593,
-0.07050482928752899,
-0.13845302164554596,
0.3900890052318573,
-0.19523517787456512,
-0.24789509177207947,
0.27068451046943665,
0.9399049282073975,
0.2577151954174042,
0.16004414856433868,
-0.061691563576459885,
-0.15565404295921326,
0.09260742366313934,
0.47182905673980713,
-0.7842978239059448,
0.1441042423248291,
0.35989025235176086,
-0.06840451806783676,
-0.684492826461792,
-0.009123507887125015,
-0.7567540407180786,
-0.4306904375553131,
0.16133931279182434,
0.3361087739467621,
-0.4831535220146179,
-0.4616169035434723,
0.28088176250457764,
0.10329937189817429,
0.5588154792785645,
0.11285454779863358,
-0.8244709968566895,
-0.027893755584955215,
0.8967217206954956,
0.5824772119522095,
-0.314884215593338,
-0.07882127165794373,
-0.8275351524353027,
0.5569474101066589,
-0.5233233571052551,
0.7108754515647888,
-0.44884955883026123,
-0.4554807245731354,
0.22044360637664795,
-0.18667417764663696,
0.29049065709114075,
-0.09760230034589767,
0.3769972026348114,
-0.6528806090354919,
-0.3372017741203308,
-0.24430027604103088,
-0.45291823148727417,
-0.07999896258115768,
0.3879120647907257,
-0.575289249420166,
0.936967134475708,
-0.312348335981369,
-1.0912606716156006,
0.05220065265893936,
-0.7049767971038818,
-0.47109439969062805,
0.11197873950004578,
-0.43041670322418213,
-0.29542723298072815,
0.27150633931159973,
-0.07528865337371826,
0.7801588177680969,
-0.23109042644500732,
0.019480930641293526,
-0.38782188296318054,
-0.102781742811203,
0.3398146629333496,
-0.3729059398174286,
0.8176902532577515,
0.2284492403268814,
-0.18945781886577606,
0.40910494327545166,
-0.7310554385185242,
-0.06179574131965637,
0.39990442991256714,
-0.3103557825088501,
-0.6397967338562012,
-0.10337027162313461,
-0.47952577471733093,
0.3583425283432007,
0.26282694935798645,
-0.5839074850082397,
0.12822020053863525,
-0.407961905002594,
0.45693981647491455,
0.6833915710449219,
0.42778459191322327,
0.41217637062072754,
0.21093621850013733,
0.7665441632270813,
0.03675863519310951,
0.2236495465040207,
-0.22530913352966309,
-0.43032997846603394,
-0.5578336715698242,
-0.2569074034690857,
0.25779497623443604,
0.5885567665100098,
-0.8940479159355164,
0.5719782114028931,
-0.2981993556022644,
-0.6164115071296692,
-0.3170342743396759,
0.020222991704940796,
0.47859111428260803,
0.27595749497413635,
-0.01675027422606945,
-0.18741923570632935,
-0.23816989362239838,
-0.8765149116516113,
-0.19958390295505524,
-0.4024730920791626,
-0.09292621910572052,
-0.14466480910778046,
0.44409576058387756,
-0.27245524525642395,
0.7294037342071533,
-0.5213785171508789,
0.17892463505268097,
-0.20752260088920593,
0.04293908551335335,
-0.1925165206193924,
0.5926235914230347,
0.5352360010147095,
-0.6585670113563538,
-0.29088088870048523,
-0.09269833564758301,
-0.7348671555519104,
0.06593004614114761,
-0.027500811964273453,
-0.152753084897995,
0.14134766161441803,
0.9673202037811279,
-0.8084818124771118,
0.35837218165397644,
0.5602143406867981,
-0.13972657918930054,
0.37117451429367065,
-0.0623389333486557,
-0.21190090477466583,
-1.2583867311477661,
-0.21028901636600494,
0.06157935410737991,
-0.017339861020445824,
-0.9435540437698364,
0.2879998981952667,
0.12529581785202026,
-0.1264883577823639,
-0.9588751792907715,
0.22082412242889404,
-0.26428157091140747,
-0.16249553859233856,
-0.03122630901634693,
-0.003573367837816477,
-0.20762722194194794,
0.2818896770477295,
-0.3190043568611145,
0.5926167964935303,
0.8465091586112976,
-0.45574983954429626,
0.17333650588989258,
0.07144597917795181,
-0.4646655321121216,
0.3885177969932556,
-0.7817569375038147,
0.49197912216186523,
-0.06497685611248016,
0.08718273788690567,
-1.1418975591659546,
-0.20259569585323334,
0.4954851269721985,
-0.5373735427856445,
0.5679690837860107,
-0.4109857678413391,
-0.6262158751487732,
0.047392431646585464,
-0.3613974452018738,
0.2746540904045105,
0.42224687337875366,
-0.29144832491874695,
0.7456747889518738,
0.6398004293441772,
-0.5129117965698242,
-0.8758300542831421,
-0.543145477771759,
0.25147274136543274,
-0.48756033182144165,
-0.5693895816802979,
-0.05999506637454033,
-0.03688166290521622,
-0.29424646496772766,
-0.1571810096502304,
-0.00841868668794632,
0.26357007026672363,
0.5840572714805603,
0.4297449290752411,
0.27769720554351807,
-0.04752669110894203,
0.030672769993543625,
0.08068907260894775,
-0.36368313431739807,
0.41844189167022705,
-0.17457488179206848,
0.7170509696006775,
-0.1842433214187622,
-0.590137779712677,
-0.3561370074748993,
0.43800726532936096,
0.777704119682312,
-0.5031649470329285,
0.6496739387512207,
0.4091184139251709,
-0.47028106451034546,
-0.0015124506317079067,
-0.28830453753471375,
-0.1605386734008789,
-0.56734299659729,
0.7416869401931763,
-0.39709848165512085,
-0.908656656742096,
0.21826201677322388,
-0.08742073178291321,
0.2350102663040161,
0.3586844801902771,
0.6434147357940674,
-0.08180499076843262,
1.1541218757629395,
0.6517270803451538,
-0.02881796471774578,
0.4905833601951599,
-0.10952534526586533,
0.17990334331989288,
-0.6198490858078003,
-0.31696653366088867,
-0.5208075046539307,
0.1468517929315567,
-0.6016007661819458,
-0.49991723895072937,
0.374132364988327,
0.05943306162953377,
-0.32061827182769775,
0.3175687789916992,
-0.2865666449069977,
0.4465900957584381,
0.2977137565612793,
-0.27808770537376404,
0.15122847259044647,
0.24852360785007477,
-0.44113025069236755,
0.1408764272928238,
-0.582133412361145,
-0.5717993378639221,
1.2808810472488403,
0.7913200259208679,
0.99817955493927,
0.19323882460594177,
0.8715730309486389,
0.15123498439788818,
0.21616514027118683,
-0.7456257343292236,
0.728947103023529,
0.17245781421661377,
-0.6329633593559265,
-0.43007007241249084,
-0.27716150879859924,
-0.8640695214271545,
0.20438456535339355,
-0.48383650183677673,
-0.6645880937576294,
0.021078264340758324,
0.15032929182052612,
-0.3248825967311859,
0.2474888116121292,
-0.6229543685913086,
0.6078321933746338,
-0.4933273494243622,
-0.26050567626953125,
-0.18141904473304749,
-0.5906350612640381,
0.4345735013484955,
-0.40022721886634827,
0.224125474691391,
-0.12546983361244202,
-0.0949038565158844,
0.6513273119926453,
-0.04461021348834038,
1.1013072729110718,
-0.11390984058380127,
-0.5145096182823181,
0.11379920691251755,
0.20171846449375153,
0.7338808178901672,
-0.03126771003007889,
0.06565643846988678,
0.40181198716163635,
-0.2978845238685608,
-0.39348116517066956,
-0.5794044137001038,
0.7939208149909973,
-0.5722786784172058,
-0.9828107953071594,
-0.6117555499076843,
-0.4604513645172119,
-0.12571172416210175,
0.2726530432701111,
0.04792279750108719,
0.11125054210424423,
-0.14673377573490143,
0.3838920295238495,
0.9467267990112305,
-0.45057597756385803,
0.3238639533519745,
0.5404149293899536,
-0.01000532228499651,
-0.38594475388526917,
0.8379655480384827,
-0.1055200919508934,
0.6893703937530518,
0.25387927889823914,
0.11757135391235352,
-0.14894260466098785,
-1.0059970617294312,
-0.29897502064704895,
0.13368277251720428,
-0.9601527452468872,
-0.2863655686378479,
-0.7782527804374695,
-0.22124925255775452,
-0.23729199171066284,
-0.05368531122803688,
-0.38833439350128174,
-0.18293645977973938,
-0.030117643997073174,
-0.528566837310791,
0.388025164604187,
0.7107959985733032,
0.18205460906028748,
0.3545095920562744,
-0.8088440299034119,
-0.0408235564827919,
0.453747421503067,
0.10590062290430069,
-0.19397427141666412,
-0.23442953824996948,
-0.17320264875888824,
-0.1805209219455719,
-0.19292519986629486,
-0.8989589214324951,
0.14577525854110718,
-0.24588418006896973,
0.6574418544769287,
0.6360569000244141,
0.18984930217266083,
0.21107767522335052,
-0.8233247995376587,
0.7893608808517456,
0.420634388923645,
-0.8381233215332031,
0.4503248631954193,
-0.414630264043808,
-0.08569870889186859,
0.34782370924949646,
0.41367125511169434,
-0.3294234275817871,
-0.4288536310195923,
-0.6825384497642517,
-0.9735498428344727,
0.3345583379268646,
0.10092740505933762,
0.3559606075286865,
-0.22260168194770813,
0.43139025568962097,
-0.12108687311410904,
0.1464323103427887,
-0.5443152189254761,
-0.3590403199195862,
-0.04401937127113342,
-0.146091490983963,
0.10210858285427094,
-0.5326948165893555,
-0.38981014490127563,
0.04471378028392792,
0.5473290681838989,
-0.1515180617570877,
0.29704317450523376,
-0.16422809660434723,
-0.12752652168273926,
-0.3304912745952606,
0.4443192481994629,
0.6910760998725891,
0.3578755259513855,
-0.0011093250941485167,
0.2907988727092743,
0.2918810546398163,
-0.49525919556617737,
0.34069088101387024,
0.018381919711828232,
-0.13390672206878662,
-0.2874043881893158,
0.4089975655078888,
0.7352087497711182,
0.29633527994155884,
-0.5911174416542053,
0.6393383145332336,
-0.22215020656585693,
-0.1400933563709259,
-0.3695290684700012,
0.3287988305091858,
0.3146272897720337,
0.1720622479915619,
0.33439743518829346,
-0.12937892973423004,
-0.13026466965675354,
-0.36260348558425903,
0.27185818552970886,
0.7288553714752197,
-0.45221009850502014,
-0.3298632800579071,
0.5036491751670837,
0.30711203813552856,
-0.29202693700790405,
-0.004741339012980461,
0.013573464006185532,
-0.6190310120582581,
0.5682878494262695,
0.5512402057647705,
0.960706353187561,
-0.5075965523719788,
0.11512959003448486,
0.027141382917761803,
0.6565441489219666,
0.05229582637548447,
0.3317975699901581,
0.45975857973098755,
-0.6800468564033508,
-0.4985576570034027,
-0.48402005434036255,
-0.42265376448631287,
0.4438225030899048,
-0.676408588886261,
0.30658432841300964,
-0.6010987758636475,
0.0012490034569054842,
-0.00628671096637845,
-0.27277040481567383,
-0.4675348103046417,
0.0038319334853440523,
0.2758650779724121,
0.9267718195915222,
-0.9248923063278198,
0.9668625593185425,
0.7305017709732056,
-0.33733445405960083,
-0.6426336169242859,
0.22041863203048706,
0.1199001669883728,
-0.7384715676307678,
0.7157384753227234,
0.03470546007156372,
-0.2713717818260193,
0.044955380260944366,
-0.6373846530914307,
-1.166661262512207,
1.0082744359970093,
0.6890725493431091,
-0.7923063039779663,
-0.015791863203048706,
0.396884948015213,
0.33715733885765076,
-0.37898194789886475,
-0.28846001625061035,
0.5540159344673157,
0.3418614864349365,
0.050499655306339264,
-0.42063742876052856,
0.30034151673316956,
0.008804935961961746,
0.005356512498110533,
0.21423280239105225,
-0.30131596326828003,
0.6811608076095581,
-0.19945530593395233,
-0.22332143783569336,
-0.28484418988227844,
0.7594851851463318,
0.43456366658210754,
-0.06016077101230621,
0.7130513191223145,
0.5040700435638428,
0.5962674617767334,
0.08788929134607315,
1.0858607292175293,
-0.37579619884490967,
-0.0042425235733389854,
0.8341923952102661,
-0.3427489399909973,
0.9811800122261047,
0.6134718060493469,
0.0747375413775444,
0.23839697241783142,
0.4738803803920746,
0.11588958650827408,
0.6335844397544861,
0.4400855600833893,
-0.24770373106002808,
-0.2742369771003723,
0.1925552785396576,
-0.3523400127887726,
0.47133734822273254,
0.8500382900238037,
-0.26579827070236206,
-0.12411841005086899,
0.16228261590003967,
0.34013548493385315,
-0.2565363049507141,
-0.17515641450881958,
0.7675703763961792,
0.18805374205112457,
-0.2769015431404114,
0.5780806541442871,
-0.08565212786197662,
0.4487398862838745,
-0.7116570472717285,
-0.07953488081693649,
0.11266019195318222,
0.02774243801832199,
0.027032703161239624,
-0.6387667655944824,
-0.11922138929367065,
0.006977386306971312,
0.17938920855522156,
0.2048034369945526,
0.7763120532035828,
-0.5476976633071899,
-0.4015750288963318,
0.3097713589668274,
0.257958322763443,
0.014847184531390667,
0.09934227913618088,
-0.6437662243843079,
0.4069262444972992,
-0.11539110541343689,
-0.2974551320075989,
0.6520534157752991,
0.4429977834224701,
-0.2769283354282379,
0.6838984489440918,
0.7888941764831543,
0.19611045718193054,
0.041133709251880646,
-0.2730160653591156,
1.074342966079712,
-0.5719195604324341,
-0.5735909342765808,
-0.9379224181175232,
0.5986986756324768,
-0.1737859547138214,
0.044390998780727386,
0.7065883278846741,
0.2028358280658722,
0.6735735535621643,
-0.02974562905728817,
1.1274514198303223,
0.3276185691356659,
0.21442195773124695,
-0.7187319397926331,
0.9809066653251648,
-0.2850349545478821,
0.6415842175483704,
-0.450499027967453,
-0.740607738494873,
-0.49661916494369507,
0.38308271765708923,
-0.3503139615058899,
-0.3799840807914734,
0.6678183078765869,
0.8499072790145874,
0.14179794490337372,
-0.2663441002368927,
0.41978487372398376,
0.329604834318161,
0.7673331499099731,
0.32065123319625854,
0.8874611854553223,
-0.19442233443260193,
0.7899314165115356,
-0.06884665042161942,
-0.3022319972515106,
-0.39531752467155457,
-1.366213321685791,
-1.2320282459259033,
-0.4228178858757019,
-0.5178700089454651,
-0.49089181423187256,
0.22129106521606445,
0.9779388904571533,
0.42238759994506836,
-0.7970319986343384,
0.11579015105962753,
0.15533144772052765,
-0.017360134050250053,
0.1037895530462265,
-0.11797002702951431,
0.652856707572937,
-0.233265221118927,
-0.4090037941932678,
0.6001971364021301,
0.34532228112220764,
0.1925542801618576,
-0.46622782945632935,
-0.08113673329353333,
-0.04694908484816551,
0.27176201343536377,
0.4721080958843231,
0.27944761514663696,
-0.7040727138519287,
-0.6823462247848511,
-0.17828448116779327,
-0.2523455321788788,
-0.16308604180812836,
0.7027450203895569,
-0.19131797552108765,
0.3308769762516022,
0.42423179745674133,
0.9947478175163269,
0.12770164012908936,
-0.23935146629810333,
0.7342722415924072,
-0.8856362700462341,
0.2405548095703125,
0.07469409704208374,
0.49391108751296997,
0.35777294635772705,
-0.550807535648346,
0.28091442584991455,
-0.009721118956804276,
-0.24771709740161896,
-1.0520367622375488,
0.44777122139930725,
-0.9281384944915771,
-0.12375994026660919,
1.559989333152771,
-0.26621323823928833,
-0.5102474093437195,
-0.2820837199687958,
-0.09531781822443008,
0.1780477613210678,
-0.453166127204895,
0.6526936888694763,
0.5795205235481262,
0.2553490698337555,
0.08142521977424622,
-0.8077639937400818,
0.7965837717056274,
0.16997459530830383,
-0.87069171667099,
0.24968208372592926,
0.27600711584091187,
0.5664632320404053,
0.3009588122367859,
0.14741680026054382,
-0.4338884949684143,
0.3095836937427521,
-0.20352283120155334,
0.2590465247631073,
-0.2634812891483307,
-0.37185320258140564,
-0.6423852443695068,
0.2824375629425049,
0.15631994605064392,
-0.41769641637802124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12022v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12022v1
|
Parallel Decoding via Hidden Transfer for Lossless Large Language Model Acceleration
| 2024-04-18T09:17:06 | 2024-04-18T09:17:06 |
Pengfei Wu, Jiahao Liu, Zhuocheng Gong, Qifan Wang, Jinpeng Li, Jingang Wang, Xunliang Cai, Dongyan Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have recently shown remarkable performance
across a wide range of tasks. However, the substantial number of parameters in
LLMs contributes to significant latency during model inference. This is
particularly evident when utilizing autoregressive decoding methods, which
generate one token in a single forward process, thereby not fully capitalizing
on the parallel computing capabilities of GPUs. In this paper, we propose a
novel parallel decoding approach, namely \textit{hidden transfer}, which
decodes multiple successive tokens simultaneously in a single forward pass. The
idea is to transfer the intermediate hidden states of the previous context to
the \textit{pseudo} hidden states of the future tokens to be generated, and
then the pseudo hidden states will pass the following transformer layers
thereby assimilating more semantic information and achieving superior
predictive accuracy of the future tokens.
Besides, we use the novel tree attention mechanism to simultaneously generate
and verify multiple candidates of output sequences, which ensure the lossless
generation and further improves the generation efficiency of our method.
Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. We conduct a lot of
analytic experiments to prove our motivation. In terms of acceleration metrics,
we outperform all the single-model acceleration techniques, including Medusa
and Self-Speculative decoding.
|
[
-0.11709659546613693,
-0.5512185096740723,
0.5504215359687805,
0.33594560623168945,
-0.4276586174964905,
0.3991047441959381,
-0.13936950266361237,
-0.3511497378349304,
0.13962355256080627,
0.2913379669189453,
-0.7188519239425659,
-0.532707929611206,
-0.8314363956451416,
0.010445264168083668,
-0.6523077487945557,
0.6251968145370483,
-0.22665327787399292,
-0.15297932922840118,
0.0006856478867121041,
-0.11371687054634094,
-0.3209191858768463,
-0.5868822336196899,
-0.5828070044517517,
-0.10804959386587143,
0.26139190793037415,
0.23994703590869904,
0.28221383690834045,
0.8288543820381165,
0.35483014583587646,
0.321710467338562,
0.037796780467033386,
0.03358493372797966,
-0.4842219054698944,
0.03154706582427025,
-0.12495236843824387,
-0.5532612204551697,
-0.5013604760169983,
-0.39214736223220825,
1.0202178955078125,
0.5033197402954102,
0.0276812557131052,
0.2582663893699646,
0.13724543154239655,
0.41690805554389954,
-0.703005313873291,
0.46542254090309143,
-0.7065148949623108,
-0.034269291907548904,
-0.3280697762966156,
-0.15833422541618347,
-0.5717165470123291,
-0.26694145798683167,
-0.34934762120246887,
-0.4583272635936737,
0.37336117029190063,
0.014527080580592155,
0.460128515958786,
0.2402917593717575,
-0.26960518956184387,
0.030413053929805756,
-0.7392569184303284,
0.6275541186332703,
-0.6392356157302856,
0.35163846611976624,
0.05653132125735283,
0.3304051458835602,
0.007803718093782663,
-0.9161731600761414,
-0.6051563024520874,
-0.0006073657423257828,
-0.18678681552410126,
0.01560848206281662,
-0.3590192198753357,
-0.017624318599700928,
0.19339115917682648,
0.48031356930732727,
-0.5044584274291992,
0.28704193234443665,
-0.028225628659129143,
-0.36160358786582947,
0.30561110377311707,
0.35773417353630066,
0.030245527625083923,
0.09807773679494858,
-0.33533158898353577,
-0.3958585262298584,
-0.6441096663475037,
0.06944400817155838,
0.11890043318271637,
0.33669784665107727,
-0.29788100719451904,
0.2665475308895111,
-0.3578486740589142,
0.39553678035736084,
-0.040319643914699554,
0.036203593015670776,
0.2697538733482361,
-0.6184318661689758,
-0.08446408808231354,
0.09110142290592194,
0.8699105381965637,
-0.03164464980363846,
-0.04747558757662773,
-0.16952037811279297,
-0.16012060642242432,
0.38437914848327637,
-0.18929097056388855,
-1.0543763637542725,
-0.1923438161611557,
0.09449349343776703,
-0.5483616590499878,
-0.18601423501968384,
-0.17516812682151794,
-0.8582640886306763,
-0.026013175025582314,
0.06397959589958191,
0.2286267727613449,
-0.08533916622400284,
-0.25914445519447327,
0.3813110589981079,
0.15211506187915802,
0.06254102289676666,
0.1473870873451233,
-0.9601452350616455,
0.570728600025177,
0.5249778628349304,
0.7748895287513733,
-0.3862348794937134,
-0.2944018840789795,
-0.9154534935951233,
0.36235979199409485,
-0.32805439829826355,
0.6807682514190674,
-0.5943108797073364,
-0.16683074831962585,
-0.08574061095714569,
0.04783666878938675,
-0.24666428565979004,
-0.14851048588752747,
0.5840551257133484,
-0.45752212405204773,
-0.11124186962842941,
-0.0805375874042511,
-0.3691757321357727,
-0.10710907727479935,
-0.05194041505455971,
-0.5498369932174683,
0.7329745888710022,
-0.2748616635799408,
-0.7107492685317993,
-0.12750044465065002,
-0.8525710701942444,
-0.5078970789909363,
-0.0796906128525734,
-0.14743831753730774,
-0.3571731746196747,
0.36263972520828247,
0.714309811592102,
0.4134252071380615,
-0.27227985858917236,
0.2459949254989624,
-0.2315579354763031,
-0.4169485867023468,
0.0061571672558784485,
-0.8951207399368286,
0.5407960414886475,
0.11652395874261856,
-0.5606771111488342,
0.280459463596344,
-0.7598078846931458,
-0.09965227544307709,
0.24488374590873718,
-0.20600615441799164,
-0.07211967557668686,
-0.08922000229358673,
-0.28442105650901794,
0.09063474088907242,
0.2800566256046295,
-0.7207963466644287,
0.18459801375865936,
-0.29588261246681213,
0.2941005527973175,
0.8221258521080017,
-0.15221627056598663,
0.3566729426383972,
0.16679076850414276,
0.49685636162757874,
0.2284613996744156,
0.036144107580184937,
-0.6671265959739685,
-0.2933143377304077,
-0.8951911926269531,
-0.2913084328174591,
0.363410085439682,
0.2988628149032593,
-0.6646379828453064,
0.2817709743976593,
-0.44460368156433105,
-0.15074704587459564,
-0.6967035531997681,
-0.22194893658161163,
0.40091678500175476,
0.4814397692680359,
0.32682034373283386,
-0.1472429782152176,
-0.23890016973018646,
-0.7740312814712524,
-0.3104177713394165,
-0.0939558818936348,
0.17631997168064117,
0.17004233598709106,
0.1753741353750229,
-0.031010594218969345,
0.31363731622695923,
-0.5308921337127686,
-0.09637933224439621,
-0.12357506155967712,
0.3426288664340973,
0.3513414263725281,
0.6946443915367126,
0.3626471757888794,
-0.41729089617729187,
-0.3757884204387665,
0.18960285186767578,
-0.5951851010322571,
-0.014575988985598087,
-0.23959705233573914,
-0.15463384985923767,
0.2207266092300415,
0.6232929825782776,
-0.7363206744194031,
0.4776824414730072,
0.8512476086616516,
-0.277305543422699,
0.3169545531272888,
-0.3306565284729004,
0.12271428108215332,
-0.766338586807251,
0.22955097258090973,
-0.6283349394798279,
-0.4556181728839874,
-0.31280139088630676,
0.1893540322780609,
0.3044396936893463,
-0.07363607734441757,
-0.35669341683387756,
0.6159428954124451,
-0.8074024319648743,
-0.21183176338672638,
-0.6302541494369507,
-0.0872856006026268,
-0.06481791287660599,
0.5501986145973206,
-0.23354773223400116,
0.8496894836425781,
1.028441309928894,
-0.37468960881233215,
0.38056427240371704,
0.030593708157539368,
-0.10018036514520645,
-0.026878107339143753,
-0.40204399824142456,
0.4138839840888977,
-0.22583408653736115,
0.3332444429397583,
-0.8782144784927368,
0.23669962584972382,
0.31183940172195435,
-0.44487878680229187,
0.4344671666622162,
0.002794451080262661,
-0.7473987340927124,
-0.6331382393836975,
-0.025676505640149117,
0.5319904088973999,
0.5746870636940002,
-0.6620371341705322,
0.6873102784156799,
0.12915481626987457,
-0.20942988991737366,
-0.6761242151260376,
-0.732963502407074,
0.3319612741470337,
-0.0019447726663202047,
-0.3835364580154419,
0.31339526176452637,
-0.14875541627407074,
0.2944745719432831,
0.29361146688461304,
-0.2476993054151535,
0.27694860100746155,
0.10766571015119553,
0.24788638949394226,
0.2126496434211731,
-0.48635876178741455,
-0.07969298958778381,
0.3340113162994385,
-0.28212782740592957,
0.1271735578775406,
-0.6901347041130066,
0.6591616272926331,
-0.36838340759277344,
-0.49729737639427185,
-0.8181028962135315,
0.5641912817955017,
0.7385972142219543,
-0.5727475881576538,
0.8122139573097229,
0.7007858753204346,
-0.3224009871482849,
-0.18095353245735168,
-0.2559124827384949,
-0.2623341679573059,
-0.4865732491016388,
0.4244629144668579,
-0.6898182034492493,
-0.9503157138824463,
0.7643128633499146,
-0.18903511762619019,
-0.078084796667099,
0.4720897674560547,
0.6383777260780334,
0.4333464801311493,
1.2762680053710938,
0.8665406703948975,
-0.22590820491313934,
0.3376181125640869,
-0.2734058201313019,
0.18944954872131348,
-0.4802827835083008,
-0.2314031571149826,
-0.5182276368141174,
-0.22979524731636047,
-0.4229154586791992,
-0.6482219696044922,
0.009715077467262745,
0.2595289647579193,
-0.028902564197778702,
0.303524911403656,
-0.23142509162425995,
0.47657743096351624,
0.4664148986339569,
-0.14126023650169373,
0.4974115490913391,
0.26025334000587463,
-0.5048249363899231,
0.16083282232284546,
-0.8470603227615356,
-0.10559827089309692,
0.9286626577377319,
0.53639155626297,
0.7557452917098999,
-0.07080861926078796,
0.646452784538269,
0.1337626874446869,
0.469700425863266,
-0.5644657611846924,
0.6376632452011108,
-0.44199591875076294,
-0.09322302043437958,
-0.18299604952335358,
-0.48284417390823364,
-0.7272976040840149,
0.3422427475452423,
-0.11459871381521225,
-0.7312911748886108,
0.11071307957172394,
0.16975216567516327,
-0.3067917227745056,
0.4875911474227905,
-0.5008925795555115,
0.8163476586341858,
-0.14260300993919373,
-0.47518783807754517,
-0.38969820737838745,
-0.5747855305671692,
0.33062124252319336,
-0.3153245747089386,
0.026757031679153442,
-0.05876836180686951,
0.03674082085490227,
0.6041054129600525,
-0.1644953340291977,
0.73082435131073,
-0.24893704056739807,
-0.027354134246706963,
0.023307088762521744,
0.18577322363853455,
1.0694271326065063,
-0.0529450997710228,
-0.03422394022345543,
0.23108334839344025,
-0.2872597873210907,
-0.46255576610565186,
-0.5660256147384644,
0.896988570690155,
-0.46636173129081726,
-0.7493903040885925,
-0.23126009106636047,
-0.788587749004364,
-0.1902695596218109,
0.5609987378120422,
-0.06583279371261597,
0.27914583683013916,
0.10894715785980225,
-0.04958656057715416,
0.35263150930404663,
-0.1329648345708847,
0.7950281500816345,
0.5216489434242249,
-0.27010378241539,
-0.16520898044109344,
0.8250967264175415,
-0.29761967062950134,
0.171711266040802,
0.5317346453666687,
0.2072700709104538,
-0.5847275853157043,
-1.0371472835540771,
-0.6107311844825745,
0.49561381340026855,
-0.5928182005882263,
-0.29087352752685547,
-0.8351183533668518,
-0.23914793133735657,
-0.5574657917022705,
0.24966315925121307,
-0.691676914691925,
-0.21483688056468964,
-0.31565961241722107,
-0.18982774019241333,
0.15357619524002075,
0.6896071434020996,
-0.14364264905452728,
0.4890894293785095,
-1.1303765773773193,
0.4997217655181885,
0.18227191269397736,
0.35620182752609253,
0.19347669184207916,
-0.4221569895744324,
-0.17359115183353424,
-0.1531001627445221,
0.1290128529071808,
-0.6187587976455688,
0.5212286114692688,
0.050644271075725555,
0.6393496990203857,
0.3600601553916931,
0.2574361562728882,
0.8655731081962585,
-0.6072143912315369,
0.42083582282066345,
0.2119748443365097,
-1.1441736221313477,
0.26432082056999207,
-0.22057119011878967,
0.3997151851654053,
0.289265900850296,
0.11908043920993805,
-0.19571831822395325,
-0.48065701127052307,
-0.43439313769340515,
-0.7733081579208374,
0.9854559302330017,
0.24558231234550476,
0.1953110247850418,
0.16750790178775787,
0.14532379806041718,
0.22685030102729797,
0.08971467614173889,
-0.6018499135971069,
-0.3769688904285431,
-0.06413984298706055,
-0.1044682189822197,
-0.13916562497615814,
-0.21019820868968964,
0.07613568753004074,
-0.029792435467243195,
0.24875454604625702,
-0.24136707186698914,
0.3675006628036499,
0.06752818077802658,
0.062179990112781525,
-0.22195899486541748,
0.14527636766433716,
0.5167636275291443,
0.4260483980178833,
-0.12262941151857376,
0.46894320845603943,
0.015495838597416878,
-0.26986435055732727,
0.09431159496307373,
0.3106248378753662,
0.1270277053117752,
0.06704269349575043,
0.14226652681827545,
1.2349539995193481,
-0.05909942463040352,
-0.317498117685318,
0.6563664674758911,
-0.32433611154556274,
0.018072912469506264,
0.07130786776542664,
-0.28826645016670227,
0.23241323232650757,
0.4149000346660614,
0.47734376788139343,
0.3036705255508423,
0.022674275562167168,
-0.17720098793506622,
0.3233598470687866,
0.382293701171875,
-0.009777827188372612,
-0.4642281234264374,
0.9164196252822876,
0.19817112386226654,
0.030492769554257393,
0.6124815344810486,
-0.17441999912261963,
-0.414437860250473,
0.43129053711891174,
0.9207114577293396,
1.051578164100647,
-0.22891035676002502,
-0.02063005603849888,
0.35486575961112976,
0.23619277775287628,
-0.2157774567604065,
0.11470287293195724,
-0.4033467769622803,
-0.3398262858390808,
-0.8641932010650635,
-0.9285802841186523,
0.10092578828334808,
0.14529302716255188,
-0.581536054611206,
-0.08976531773805618,
-0.11466389894485474,
0.19226589798927307,
-0.2679114043712616,
-0.45777252316474915,
-0.6312711238861084,
-0.07899095118045807,
0.48620280623435974,
0.8614705204963684,
-0.9393948316574097,
1.1711755990982056,
0.2622825801372528,
0.24068382382392883,
-0.785325825214386,
0.3110927641391754,
-0.4495515525341034,
-0.9926367998123169,
0.7123249173164368,
0.31141671538352966,
-0.5018796920776367,
0.2566775381565094,
-0.14349423348903656,
-1.0996102094650269,
0.7863242626190186,
0.6491870284080505,
-0.8972253799438477,
-0.2420087307691574,
0.13339027762413025,
0.34743714332580566,
-0.4536520838737488,
0.08482417464256287,
0.4247569739818573,
0.3575786352157593,
0.16189241409301758,
-0.870274543762207,
0.3699198067188263,
-0.12587670981884003,
0.13052144646644592,
0.14876344799995422,
-0.40559229254722595,
0.9387422204017639,
-0.30178576707839966,
-0.712713897228241,
0.23045195639133453,
0.9304304718971252,
0.1992475986480713,
0.11530118435621262,
0.23825517296791077,
0.511673092842102,
0.603895902633667,
0.24582841992378235,
1.165516972541809,
-0.5530437231063843,
0.44205552339553833,
1.0338274240493774,
-0.006016917992383242,
0.8919163346290588,
0.43148186802864075,
-0.06572232395410538,
0.2837679088115692,
0.2552768886089325,
0.2660715579986572,
0.7171204090118408,
0.12170413136482239,
-0.3175569772720337,
-0.3560244143009186,
-0.09718240052461624,
-0.43854591250419617,
0.4699671268463135,
0.30246540904045105,
-0.41432058811187744,
-0.45645374059677124,
0.2119257003068924,
-0.10102137178182602,
0.013127529062330723,
-0.5834814310073853,
0.3714207410812378,
0.021367928013205528,
-0.638437032699585,
0.8146824836730957,
0.21018004417419434,
0.6714977622032166,
-0.5093085169792175,
-0.10582909733057022,
-0.4358520209789276,
0.4321240782737732,
-0.016096197068691254,
-0.5884424448013306,
0.3665621280670166,
-0.13232651352882385,
-0.14573653042316437,
-0.4994686245918274,
0.6309225559234619,
-0.40495848655700684,
-0.6254110932350159,
0.541095495223999,
0.510639488697052,
0.25896167755126953,
-0.21797756850719452,
-0.48394617438316345,
0.37422609329223633,
0.08860550075769424,
-0.07123618572950363,
0.22837984561920166,
0.33477798104286194,
-0.08809246122837067,
0.5509948134422302,
0.7885986566543579,
0.3227875530719757,
0.5862270593643188,
0.15485863387584686,
0.9733841419219971,
-0.6898927688598633,
-0.7624117136001587,
-0.9127873778343201,
0.21774226427078247,
0.2516860365867615,
0.18076536059379578,
0.9234426021575928,
0.47912082076072693,
0.6754879951477051,
-0.08135293424129486,
0.5304765701293945,
0.4042814373970032,
0.3494219183921814,
-0.5998187065124512,
0.7365628480911255,
-0.3517187833786011,
0.3283020257949829,
-0.04210766404867172,
-0.7068569660186768,
-0.29434290528297424,
0.040774669498205185,
0.05260821431875229,
-0.26194092631340027,
0.7880917191505432,
0.6896535754203796,
-0.12032153457403183,
-0.0763106420636177,
0.39070162177085876,
0.43391773104667664,
0.27685752511024475,
0.8685978651046753,
0.7570729851722717,
-0.5591989755630493,
0.6527325510978699,
-0.1905575543642044,
-0.17579221725463867,
0.02597498521208763,
-0.8504380583763123,
-0.6739134192466736,
-0.3033337891101837,
-0.3070686459541321,
-0.12346037477254868,
0.23553958535194397,
0.2701708972454071,
0.7688491344451904,
-0.854515552520752,
-0.23806902766227722,
-0.5293281674385071,
-0.06707308441400528,
-0.20250137150287628,
-0.18258050084114075,
0.6786438226699829,
-0.23423171043395996,
-1.0160127878189087,
0.7374662756919861,
0.42678701877593994,
0.02344195544719696,
-0.19399020075798035,
-0.0005029851454310119,
0.004089829511940479,
-0.20327629148960114,
0.4833064377307892,
0.2334357053041458,
-0.6669564843177795,
-0.08421023935079575,
-0.07671988755464554,
0.006033540703356266,
0.13627459108829498,
1.0940240621566772,
-1.0913265943527222,
0.32506489753723145,
0.575593113899231,
0.9392761588096619,
1.0176737308502197,
-0.027840981259942055,
0.40365561842918396,
-0.621841311454773,
0.25898560881614685,
0.2708878517150879,
0.21074770390987396,
0.23919595777988434,
-0.37577250599861145,
-0.1638539731502533,
0.4519423246383667,
-0.18094094097614288,
-0.8904280662536621,
0.14664530754089355,
-0.9121811389923096,
-0.38471856713294983,
0.8246963620185852,
-0.35225725173950195,
-0.48215335607528687,
0.1594306081533432,
0.2362438440322876,
0.4213588237762451,
-0.4430612623691559,
0.31316983699798584,
0.20463287830352783,
-0.3533822298049927,
-0.46821051836013794,
-0.2859274744987488,
0.19399215281009674,
0.6154516339302063,
-0.6730263233184814,
0.5440328121185303,
0.30202117562294006,
0.21868419647216797,
0.10157156735658646,
0.5388097763061523,
-0.37619930505752563,
0.03195216506719589,
0.32906949520111084,
-0.09825598448514938,
-0.40092840790748596,
-0.5200912952423096,
-0.6841633319854736,
0.43139803409576416,
-0.15257057547569275,
-0.757363498210907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12014v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12014v1
|
Enhance Robustness of Language Models Against Variation Attack through Graph Integration
| 2024-04-18T09:04:39 | 2024-04-18T09:04:39 |
Zi Xiong, Lizhi Qing, Yangyang Kang, Jiawei Liu, Hongsong Li, Changlong Sun, Xiaozhong Liu, Wei Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
The widespread use of pre-trained language models (PLMs) in natural language
processing (NLP) has greatly improved performance outcomes. However, these
models' vulnerability to adversarial attacks (e.g., camouflaged hints from drug
dealers), particularly in the Chinese language with its rich character
diversity/variation and complex structures, hatches vital apprehension. In this
study, we propose a novel method, CHinese vAriatioN Graph Enhancement (CHANGE),
to increase the robustness of PLMs against character variation attacks in
Chinese content. CHANGE presents a novel approach for incorporating a Chinese
character variation graph into the PLMs. Through designing different
supplementary tasks utilizing the graph structure, CHANGE essentially enhances
PLMs' interpretation of adversarially manipulated text. Experiments conducted
in a multitude of NLP tasks show that CHANGE outperforms current language
models in combating against adversarial attacks and serves as a valuable
contribution to robust language model research. These findings contribute to
the groundwork on robust language models and highlight the substantial
potential of graph-guided pre-training strategies for real-world applications.
|
[
-0.13450559973716736,
-0.8578990697860718,
-0.03542904183268547,
0.08956065028905869,
-0.36300623416900635,
0.2966444492340088,
-0.17126232385635376,
-0.45346546173095703,
0.11636126786470413,
0.7658882737159729,
-0.4890500605106354,
-0.5428987741470337,
-0.7337778806686401,
0.17864279448986053,
-0.10241793841123581,
0.7774763107299805,
-0.13999976217746735,
0.1035015806555748,
0.4216710329055786,
-0.24467070400714874,
-0.2994900345802307,
-0.6388888955116272,
-0.615062952041626,
-0.33282506465911865,
0.5426304936408997,
-0.3301883041858673,
1.195965051651001,
0.6179668307304382,
0.6559165716171265,
0.3210536539554596,
-0.3767678439617157,
0.4276038706302643,
-0.5337256789207458,
0.07526186853647232,
-0.15265287458896637,
-0.7826955318450928,
-0.49761831760406494,
-0.09866199642419815,
0.6319042444229126,
0.766227662563324,
0.12123698741197586,
-0.5896030068397522,
0.26439955830574036,
0.4468972384929657,
-0.4730220139026642,
0.09719213843345642,
-0.8548364639282227,
-0.008128339424729347,
-0.587658166885376,
0.0021224378142505884,
-0.520395815372467,
-0.025794584304094315,
-0.163888618350029,
-0.6354792714118958,
0.30096450448036194,
-0.2919977307319641,
1.203485131263733,
0.14739087224006653,
-0.18910224735736847,
-0.029977960512042046,
-0.45377036929130554,
0.48079630732536316,
-1.0915141105651855,
0.25768324732780457,
0.17637959122657776,
0.1448926031589508,
-0.647998034954071,
-0.8837423324584961,
-0.3971261978149414,
-0.4371601641178131,
-0.18603461980819702,
-0.045825667679309845,
-0.09274328500032425,
0.3162119686603546,
0.21971888840198517,
0.4940433204174042,
-0.4075970947742462,
0.29719921946525574,
0.2629033625125885,
-0.35006052255630493,
0.5061991810798645,
0.20789438486099243,
1.0130890607833862,
-0.052370112389326096,
-0.03568023070693016,
-0.4182162582874298,
-0.7302356362342834,
0.3573051393032074,
0.6542149782180786,
0.7476286292076111,
-0.15196838974952698,
0.3007669448852539,
0.04469158872961998,
0.934212863445282,
-0.029631590470671654,
0.043693795800209045,
0.14003819227218628,
-0.43697014451026917,
-0.26802757382392883,
-0.48246249556541443,
0.7553015351295471,
-0.0014979828847572207,
-0.22759167850017548,
-0.12649010121822357,
-0.33302077651023865,
0.0609155036509037,
0.12810473144054413,
-0.8048082590103149,
-0.7251219153404236,
0.034116484224796295,
-0.358265221118927,
-0.3232496678829193,
0.19187462329864502,
-0.7273241877555847,
-0.7879823446273804,
0.21104012429714203,
0.005348090082406998,
-0.8318421244621277,
-0.31577014923095703,
0.147263303399086,
-0.2245234251022339,
-0.014736589044332504,
0.40927258133888245,
-0.8169669508934021,
0.1480369120836258,
0.5511396527290344,
0.7919589281082153,
-0.3738086521625519,
-0.4341181218624115,
-0.6110188961029053,
0.13751329481601715,
-0.41794854402542114,
0.5140130519866943,
-0.6145234704017639,
-0.6027011871337891,
0.024262364953756332,
-0.0033832804765552282,
-0.2048729956150055,
-0.535071074962616,
0.5982260704040527,
-0.62483811378479,
0.12751230597496033,
-0.18568076193332672,
-0.2706371545791626,
-0.1396254003047943,
0.4784920811653137,
-1.0414237976074219,
0.7823454737663269,
0.29367807507514954,
-1.1876977682113647,
0.11480221897363663,
-0.7380051016807556,
-0.7397923469543457,
0.18561626970767975,
0.01564919948577881,
-0.6365998387336731,
-0.13892632722854614,
0.5070074200630188,
-0.0835089236497879,
0.18935123085975647,
-0.21870289742946625,
-0.5075418949127197,
-0.1713099628686905,
0.5418484210968018,
-0.621691882610321,
1.2183175086975098,
0.19607003033161163,
-0.13423079252243042,
0.2683422267436981,
-0.49409517645835876,
-0.04959513247013092,
0.35819610953330994,
-0.3943672478199005,
-0.4916137456893921,
0.014088496565818787,
-0.12222795933485031,
-0.07073953747749329,
0.4687941074371338,
-0.2643336355686188,
0.2586604654788971,
-0.83655846118927,
0.40028324723243713,
0.6130881905555725,
-0.020520050078630447,
0.27385661005973816,
-0.3409751355648041,
0.6366164684295654,
0.061135776340961456,
0.36295562982559204,
-0.3411131501197815,
-0.4907383322715759,
-0.5646222829818726,
-0.32505178451538086,
0.562143087387085,
0.5292203426361084,
-1.0715579986572266,
0.35902172327041626,
0.04645026475191116,
-0.3550091087818146,
-0.48688602447509766,
0.2713768780231476,
0.09237654507160187,
0.34546008706092834,
0.3224310278892517,
-0.45986294746398926,
-0.4304482340812683,
-0.3394289016723633,
-0.7183495759963989,
-0.26973384618759155,
-0.22298216819763184,
0.18204039335250854,
0.1156437024474144,
-0.47849240899086,
0.7117149233818054,
-0.5820609927177429,
-0.026113200932741165,
-0.5189067721366882,
0.25370168685913086,
0.09536324441432953,
0.4860474467277527,
0.7662451267242432,
-0.9853197932243347,
-0.807888925075531,
0.04250258579850197,
-0.18601757287979126,
-0.30233046412467957,
-0.33384260535240173,
-0.21622543036937714,
-0.17647790908813477,
0.3201374113559723,
-0.39770665764808655,
0.43011850118637085,
0.5120787620544434,
-0.08423388749361038,
0.4660508632659912,
-0.2423066347837448,
0.00983479619026184,
-0.9796174168586731,
-0.24657468497753143,
-0.319627583026886,
-0.23423762619495392,
-0.949682354927063,
0.5258050560951233,
0.06319420784711838,
-0.07011046260595322,
-0.3315999507904053,
0.30059075355529785,
-0.3810846507549286,
0.2725946605205536,
-0.31265854835510254,
0.09257946908473969,
0.24670276045799255,
0.34627246856689453,
-0.2859606146812439,
0.590795636177063,
0.6134339570999146,
-0.4478210210800171,
0.24219073355197906,
0.07365582138299942,
-0.11021262407302856,
0.2235976904630661,
-0.4735046923160553,
0.34237560629844666,
-0.08822587132453918,
0.2607860863208771,
-1.042759895324707,
-0.12200520932674408,
0.5621057152748108,
-0.3956337869167328,
0.769584059715271,
-0.049028921872377396,
-0.3332499861717224,
-0.2084713727235794,
-0.5273503661155701,
0.018144549801945686,
0.16116534173488617,
-0.48580852150917053,
0.6576271653175354,
0.1578504592180252,
-0.1258985847234726,
-0.5834301710128784,
-0.8076299428939819,
0.4213525056838989,
-0.14287573099136353,
-0.6518139839172363,
0.5465742349624634,
-0.3081153631210327,
-0.06931553781032562,
-0.10374562442302704,
0.05149534344673157,
-0.3184504806995392,
0.5411437749862671,
-0.15423552691936493,
0.3622278869152069,
-0.25835633277893066,
-0.3253842294216156,
0.024891158565878868,
0.06265176087617874,
-0.2990066409111023,
-0.3073013126850128,
0.7282646298408508,
0.12522901594638824,
-0.48896104097366333,
-0.48570966720581055,
0.3071035146713257,
0.4202675223350525,
-0.4456620514392853,
0.720736563205719,
0.5967249274253845,
-0.27104851603507996,
-0.24006099998950958,
0.0917201042175293,
-0.05669056624174118,
-0.5373161435127258,
0.7989941239356995,
-0.3311072587966919,
-0.7669700384140015,
0.6521052718162537,
-0.02600184455513954,
0.10873865336179733,
0.39197275042533875,
0.3183794617652893,
0.11391300708055496,
1.2504738569259644,
0.7398717403411865,
-0.2088097780942917,
1.0159868001937866,
0.11148421466350555,
0.22296389937400818,
-0.6581798791885376,
0.20494818687438965,
-0.5042749643325806,
-0.05674993619322777,
-0.6352751851081848,
-0.4187963604927063,
0.05675140395760536,
0.23365403711795807,
-0.02470662072300911,
0.31184688210487366,
-0.38091298937797546,
0.3860171139240265,
0.1850137561559677,
0.33981961011886597,
0.0683043971657753,
-0.08791917562484741,
-0.024172309786081314,
-0.30452483892440796,
-0.6419557332992554,
-0.31647151708602905,
0.9970349669456482,
0.2890484631061554,
0.8593640327453613,
0.22353512048721313,
0.46891993284225464,
0.28912413120269775,
0.42026203870773315,
-0.30746233463287354,
0.36744368076324463,
-0.7396564483642578,
-0.09953734278678894,
-0.43940988183021545,
-0.5644146800041199,
-1.0000898838043213,
0.4176577627658844,
-0.08373595029115677,
-0.6958931088447571,
0.04467102885246277,
0.18171052634716034,
-0.06978613883256912,
0.6016554832458496,
-0.5293625593185425,
0.7733097672462463,
-0.4173212945461273,
0.0945046991109848,
0.22441521286964417,
-0.45259925723075867,
0.2625182569026947,
-0.15134213864803314,
0.14849013090133667,
0.3049567639827728,
0.10648283362388611,
0.3295833468437195,
-0.5506827235221863,
1.1193217039108276,
-0.021318256855010986,
-0.23754669725894928,
0.14490891993045807,
0.2785751223564148,
0.9737200736999512,
-0.03269416466355324,
-0.15745623409748077,
0.2790232002735138,
-0.4851040840148926,
-0.5192124247550964,
-0.7024291753768921,
0.334710955619812,
-0.7360010743141174,
-0.8174425363540649,
0.031029367819428444,
-0.8979358077049255,
-0.025703992694616318,
0.4601879417896271,
0.5370030999183655,
0.16219335794448853,
-0.3393627405166626,
0.03996230289340019,
0.5634065270423889,
-0.36299824714660645,
0.38868048787117004,
0.38039547204971313,
-0.15785691142082214,
-0.3966444730758667,
0.7806888222694397,
0.16261182725429535,
0.6696983575820923,
0.6803000569343567,
0.2768949568271637,
-0.1599261611700058,
-0.9462717771530151,
-0.33143723011016846,
-0.10326297581195831,
-0.7302400469779968,
0.05796953663229942,
-0.468004435300827,
-0.30531737208366394,
-0.7548747658729553,
-0.12696577608585358,
-0.24942760169506073,
-0.1174360141158104,
-0.38664931058883667,
0.11121398210525513,
0.021327879279851913,
0.4362450838088989,
0.13394610583782196,
0.6328930258750916,
-0.6282496452331543,
0.35258907079696655,
0.32596540451049805,
0.21250943839550018,
-0.35055625438690186,
-0.7081049680709839,
-0.2690768837928772,
0.41170769929885864,
-0.3104870021343231,
-1.2440766096115112,
0.5446925163269043,
0.17789863049983978,
0.721807599067688,
0.549993097782135,
0.23015707731246948,
0.39343583583831787,
-0.1383861005306244,
0.9424758553504944,
0.1785876601934433,
-1.086051344871521,
0.4320457875728607,
-0.35635295510292053,
0.38709527254104614,
0.27828294038772583,
-0.1861332356929779,
-0.5235717296600342,
-0.7961192727088928,
-0.4747289717197418,
-0.651496410369873,
0.772578775882721,
0.3923335671424866,
0.2458256334066391,
0.4723213016986847,
0.2966390550136566,
-0.012752167880535126,
0.13088397681713104,
-1.1426289081573486,
-0.3934500515460968,
-0.7132295370101929,
-0.1811915785074234,
0.10562796145677567,
-0.039471495896577835,
-0.20306448638439178,
0.01718882843852043,
0.4224959909915924,
-0.1711520254611969,
-0.22263464331626892,
0.054116230458021164,
-0.14682148396968842,
0.13610564172267914,
0.2369249314069748,
0.49426746368408203,
0.28240999579429626,
-0.02589063160121441,
0.366106778383255,
0.2974899709224701,
-0.7221277356147766,
-0.21613328158855438,
0.2863616943359375,
-0.5174602270126343,
0.12745383381843567,
0.5368229150772095,
0.9668956995010376,
-0.16021613776683807,
-0.4343486726284027,
0.30621421337127686,
-0.1324327439069748,
0.24907922744750977,
0.5105926990509033,
0.28321027755737305,
-0.17755034565925598,
-0.04467446357011795,
-0.00510393874719739,
0.21068798005580902,
-0.10137738287448883,
-0.329842209815979,
0.16568976640701294,
0.3974062204360962,
-0.4678562879562378,
-0.34232455492019653,
0.5664718151092529,
-0.04227910935878754,
-0.696850061416626,
0.21370458602905273,
-0.23662970960140228,
-0.9074283242225647,
0.7089064717292786,
0.8731778264045715,
0.786016047000885,
-0.8053460717201233,
0.3387686014175415,
-0.13063311576843262,
0.7593101263046265,
0.11792349070310593,
-0.021681426092982292,
0.2700614631175995,
-0.9231571555137634,
-0.1451537013053894,
-0.09959159791469574,
-0.47248414158821106,
0.3474944829940796,
-0.37861064076423645,
0.41583120822906494,
-0.7212938666343689,
-0.136748805642128,
-0.30647072196006775,
-0.20865170657634735,
-0.08467980474233627,
0.296797513961792,
0.1414722204208374,
0.4690307378768921,
-0.6299987435340881,
0.9035792946815491,
0.7466962337493896,
-0.4155421257019043,
-0.6929590106010437,
0.40787169337272644,
-0.3222968876361847,
-0.5638841390609741,
0.2945719063282013,
0.04249192774295807,
-0.024097394198179245,
-0.36268866062164307,
-0.6954448819160461,
-0.6545877456665039,
0.49525243043899536,
0.7298418283462524,
-0.2121446132659912,
0.20600123703479767,
0.49507105350494385,
0.5640175938606262,
-0.33892834186553955,
0.03739393875002861,
0.4290313720703125,
0.33573922514915466,
-0.021475695073604584,
-0.38666772842407227,
0.08862435072660446,
-0.33822211623191833,
0.15361234545707703,
0.1856113225221634,
-0.5704929828643799,
1.465448021888733,
0.005592512432485819,
-0.4261917471885681,
-0.106674425303936,
0.7400256991386414,
0.05544544756412506,
0.0031115785241127014,
0.7646641731262207,
0.09377920627593994,
1.1399577856063843,
0.057484906166791916,
0.9889441728591919,
-0.4824681580066681,
0.19265815615653992,
1.2651996612548828,
-0.264504998922348,
0.4717760384082794,
0.13010866940021515,
-0.2032133936882019,
0.6932951211929321,
0.6816580295562744,
-0.13678692281246185,
0.4914299547672272,
0.20779302716255188,
-0.14736253023147583,
-0.22095483541488647,
0.036991432309150696,
-0.5426011681556702,
0.1349637806415558,
0.5264984369277954,
-0.18326027691364288,
-0.2042849212884903,
-0.15628570318222046,
0.3689565360546112,
0.2875731885433197,
-0.14026379585266113,
0.4257667362689972,
-0.03154350072145462,
-0.39102867245674133,
0.5089979767799377,
0.3744168281555176,
0.6540142893791199,
-1.0002540349960327,
0.1311464011669159,
-0.24879588186740875,
0.0842563733458519,
-0.1375044733285904,
-0.461399644613266,
0.12764465808868408,
-0.15179789066314697,
-0.022832561284303665,
0.04986531287431717,
0.7312892079353333,
-0.4582137167453766,
-0.4078899025917053,
0.3288181722164154,
-0.0940336138010025,
-0.36800792813301086,
-0.12291602790355682,
-0.9334876537322998,
0.030593911185860634,
0.32879385352134705,
-0.031007902696728706,
0.40721768140792847,
0.3614065945148468,
-0.014260782860219479,
0.4994577169418335,
0.7213239669799805,
0.37434709072113037,
0.0711202472448349,
0.23755311965942383,
0.9582195281982422,
-0.27285236120224,
-0.9834600687026978,
-0.9531790018081665,
0.33295050263404846,
-0.3913689851760864,
-0.18081629276275635,
0.8673704862594604,
0.23031564056873322,
0.710562527179718,
0.23597785830497742,
1.0501371622085571,
0.23683324456214905,
0.24486631155014038,
-0.519435703754425,
0.8906968832015991,
-0.33463743329048157,
0.579245388507843,
-0.5122436285018921,
-0.41346028447151184,
-0.5487050414085388,
0.28465330600738525,
-0.19187086820602417,
-0.0737634003162384,
0.6294000744819641,
0.8320804238319397,
0.13982830941677094,
-0.06975845992565155,
0.3327939510345459,
0.44331055879592896,
0.8336358666419983,
0.48393651843070984,
0.6616891026496887,
-0.3905356824398041,
0.7020488977432251,
-0.07718225568532944,
-0.2621317207813263,
-0.07776935398578644,
-0.788006603717804,
-1.0200008153915405,
-0.1780671626329422,
-0.37997061014175415,
-0.5463062524795532,
0.0037202525418251753,
0.4003430902957916,
0.3414771854877472,
-0.928442120552063,
-0.012371310032904148,
-0.19306208193302155,
0.45851603150367737,
-0.3685034513473511,
-0.2085135281085968,
0.6081376075744629,
-0.5401930212974548,
-0.7906053066253662,
0.5406762361526489,
0.3604353368282318,
0.4194115102291107,
-0.2497977614402771,
-0.05439010262489319,
-0.03476788103580475,
0.37016287446022034,
0.08619967848062515,
0.31109216809272766,
-0.6319229006767273,
-0.28507000207901,
-0.04364883527159691,
-0.3503824770450592,
0.36741775274276733,
1.0520708560943604,
-0.15733438730239868,
0.8475928902626038,
0.5889459252357483,
0.8310658931732178,
0.12584999203681946,
-0.05036608874797821,
0.7541326284408569,
-0.8008289933204651,
0.39457714557647705,
0.08049637824296951,
0.5196273922920227,
0.6741082668304443,
-0.6057644486427307,
0.1549600064754486,
0.5537940263748169,
0.03294108435511589,
-0.9735942482948303,
0.6536404490470886,
-0.7664940357208252,
-0.6242956519126892,
0.9094895124435425,
-0.7193742990493774,
-0.17747318744659424,
-0.473583847284317,
-0.4733767807483673,
0.4345201849937439,
-0.029645761474967003,
0.8041642308235168,
0.6574942469596863,
0.12242231518030167,
0.052072763442993164,
-0.006782836280763149,
0.6127749681472778,
0.5422658324241638,
-0.9024481177330017,
0.22850894927978516,
0.1422007530927658,
0.013552502728998661,
0.09420009702444077,
0.3419029414653778,
-0.20774248242378235,
0.06112457066774368,
0.19521567225456238,
-0.16901351511478424,
-0.10566001385450363,
0.07813861966133118,
-0.38408827781677246,
0.4088385999202728,
0.10995575040578842,
-0.19189511239528656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12013v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12013v1
|
Sequential Compositional Generalization in Multimodal Models
| 2024-04-18T09:04:15 | 2024-04-18T09:04:15 |
Semih Yagcioglu, Osman Batur İnce, Aykut Erdem, Erkut Erdem, Desmond Elliott, Deniz Yuret
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rise of large-scale multimodal models has paved the pathway for
groundbreaking advances in generative modeling and reasoning, unlocking
transformative applications in a variety of complex tasks. However, a pressing
question that remains is their genuine capability for stronger forms of
generalization, which has been largely underexplored in the multimodal setting.
Our study aims to address this by examining sequential compositional
generalization using \textsc{CompAct} (\underline{Comp}ositional
\underline{Act}ivities)\footnote{Project Page:
\url{http://cyberiada.github.io/CompAct}}, a carefully constructed,
perceptually grounded dataset set within a rich backdrop of egocentric kitchen
activity videos. Each instance in our dataset is represented with a combination
of raw video footage, naturally occurring sound, and crowd-sourced step-by-step
descriptions. More importantly, our setup ensures that the individual concepts
are consistently distributed across training and evaluation sets, while their
compositions are novel in the evaluation set. We conduct a comprehensive
assessment of several unimodal and multimodal models. Our findings reveal that
bi-modal and tri-modal models exhibit a clear edge over their text-only
counterparts. This highlights the importance of multimodality while charting a
trajectory for future research in this domain.
|
[
-0.08670222759246826,
-0.6043789386749268,
0.8656817078590393,
0.3733474612236023,
-0.12822556495666504,
0.11300712078809738,
-0.31681883335113525,
-0.19437119364738464,
-0.13228358328342438,
0.1116519346833229,
-0.4583851993083954,
-0.5097686052322388,
-0.4906202554702759,
-0.016362817957997322,
-0.5382324457168579,
0.7119762897491455,
-0.21331049501895905,
0.09573051333427429,
-0.4395294785499573,
-0.44091999530792236,
-0.8348388671875,
-0.20805573463439941,
-0.08350000530481339,
-0.24014851450920105,
0.45546233654022217,
0.3594631254673004,
0.5699945092201233,
0.328426331281662,
0.28693342208862305,
0.4305467903614044,
0.2818654775619507,
0.1813810169696808,
-0.4289187788963318,
0.1977900117635727,
-0.23935575783252716,
-0.43212398886680603,
-0.08550512045621872,
0.029338330030441284,
0.7529497742652893,
0.8553093075752258,
-0.005012777168303728,
0.14048559963703156,
-0.05888812988996506,
0.4286392331123352,
-0.790920078754425,
0.25681403279304504,
-0.30328014492988586,
0.057865116745233536,
-0.1066727489233017,
-0.15639829635620117,
-0.5124925971031189,
0.0058217355981469154,
0.11543484777212143,
-0.868148148059845,
0.1448746621608734,
-0.014319868758320808,
0.2581050992012024,
0.201913520693779,
-0.8924020528793335,
-0.2192811667919159,
-1.2737631797790527,
0.6624531149864197,
-0.2800225615501404,
0.4559679329395294,
0.11564946919679642,
0.28605034947395325,
0.2296523004770279,
-1.135855793952942,
-0.7407615780830383,
-0.06009988114237785,
0.04338185116648674,
0.3317616283893585,
-0.06089133024215698,
0.06334389746189117,
0.1414378583431244,
0.4922427535057068,
-0.6663221120834351,
-0.03998715803027153,
-0.30855846405029297,
0.1514051854610443,
0.47118374705314636,
0.45729586482048035,
0.40407276153564453,
0.052767492830753326,
-0.6978357434272766,
-0.31276196241378784,
-0.31263428926467896,
0.09616146236658096,
0.14623703062534332,
-0.022158393636345863,
-0.43002820014953613,
0.7339631915092468,
-0.17337891459465027,
0.6277784109115601,
0.13500376045703888,
-0.014018068090081215,
0.29852187633514404,
-0.9975906610488892,
-0.19303344190120697,
-0.3207879066467285,
0.8838406801223755,
0.36365750432014465,
0.19663238525390625,
-0.08290460705757141,
-0.14602859318256378,
0.40656521916389465,
0.5630041360855103,
-0.6453250050544739,
-0.31985634565353394,
0.24238674342632294,
-0.48508885502815247,
-0.14268530905246735,
0.20831140875816345,
-0.37495243549346924,
-0.33081087470054626,
-0.7664743661880493,
0.523565411567688,
-0.2724479138851166,
-0.20807047188282013,
0.3367852568626404,
-0.05989266559481621,
0.10133872181177139,
0.1989823430776596,
-1.1363682746887207,
0.3331955671310425,
0.552551805973053,
0.773466169834137,
-0.10528798401355743,
-0.2546064853668213,
0.005273384042084217,
0.30710482597351074,
-0.41469934582710266,
0.7549623847007751,
-0.8757086396217346,
-0.5199304223060608,
-0.0018650260753929615,
-0.04660213366150856,
-0.4713456928730011,
-0.4589977264404297,
0.4869843125343323,
-0.41278254985809326,
0.21339088678359985,
-0.14089497923851013,
-0.34102240204811096,
-0.13312137126922607,
0.06440036743879318,
-0.5196180939674377,
0.7127300500869751,
-0.1373860239982605,
-0.540097177028656,
0.5580075979232788,
-0.479928582906723,
-0.6292260885238647,
-0.21184779703617096,
-0.5126890540122986,
-0.2635633051395416,
0.5111303329467773,
0.11402732878923416,
0.4452953338623047,
-0.16682492196559906,
0.2781773805618286,
-0.39845940470695496,
-0.3626956343650818,
0.406256765127182,
-0.46955591440200806,
0.08292745798826218,
0.27264171838760376,
-0.2861587107181549,
0.3874850869178772,
-0.6693521738052368,
-0.019558019936084747,
0.08896689862012863,
-0.23551476001739502,
-0.4224829077720642,
-0.008458542637526989,
0.0003214108874090016,
0.1575002670288086,
0.11727641522884369,
-0.21834887564182281,
0.14162133634090424,
0.08307292312383652,
0.2820339798927307,
0.9032042622566223,
-0.06444696336984634,
0.7560440301895142,
-0.5513882637023926,
0.4500177502632141,
0.14167842268943787,
0.23544304072856903,
-0.5819827318191528,
-0.5315819978713989,
-0.3758019506931305,
-0.42841407656669617,
0.2259020209312439,
0.378655344247818,
-0.7149373888969421,
0.13125215470790863,
-0.30847007036209106,
-0.25430530309677124,
0.032472722232341766,
-0.0379069484770298,
0.3914389908313751,
0.20292030274868011,
0.2811661660671234,
-0.5806161165237427,
-0.45957306027412415,
-0.7875446081161499,
0.07428993284702301,
0.1306198686361313,
-0.06383272260427475,
0.21702568233013153,
0.342879980802536,
-0.42802438139915466,
0.8654689192771912,
-0.6136651635169983,
-0.21405234932899475,
-0.053716499358415604,
0.3922804594039917,
0.06932990998029709,
0.4200839102268219,
0.518017590045929,
-1.2663065195083618,
-0.5956969261169434,
-0.10468439012765884,
-0.9129059314727783,
0.07078278064727783,
-0.5141289234161377,
0.031204475089907646,
-0.32630014419555664,
0.30896931886672974,
-0.6329935789108276,
0.2864757180213928,
0.512210488319397,
-0.21347405016422272,
0.578972578048706,
-0.2803969979286194,
0.24681295454502106,
-1.0459301471710205,
-0.006011869292706251,
-0.025152988731861115,
0.01762222684919834,
-0.6926339864730835,
0.07351310551166534,
-0.15685541927814484,
-0.0333343967795372,
-0.18490630388259888,
0.44517016410827637,
-0.6144880652427673,
-0.253046452999115,
-0.1775948405265808,
-0.06110096350312233,
-0.010922121815383434,
0.5156372785568237,
0.053629904985427856,
0.7419077157974243,
0.5480632185935974,
-0.5674752593040466,
0.17144879698753357,
0.10041899234056473,
-0.3954612612724304,
0.5269565582275391,
-0.697986364364624,
-0.05438967049121857,
-0.202895388007164,
0.4715062975883484,
-1.3850396871566772,
-0.4075946807861328,
0.22313381731510162,
-0.16241799294948578,
0.21834039688110352,
0.10147721320390701,
-0.6643334031105042,
-0.16246604919433594,
-0.15003624558448792,
0.8298218250274658,
0.24692313373088837,
-0.17731504142284393,
1.0106087923049927,
0.1387869119644165,
-0.056833818554878235,
-0.33398330211639404,
-0.5480281710624695,
-0.2877524793148041,
-0.0657513365149498,
-0.717237114906311,
0.3598008453845978,
-0.5994299650192261,
-0.30820202827453613,
-0.25275760889053345,
-0.3732229471206665,
-0.09373126924037933,
0.002719549462199211,
0.45928794145584106,
0.03079804964363575,
-0.11131434142589569,
0.17141656577587128,
0.06018143892288208,
0.21556702256202698,
-0.1459486335515976,
-0.2281167209148407,
0.5688713192939758,
-0.15757152438163757,
-0.37181881070137024,
-0.4276238977909088,
0.48732084035873413,
0.7038478851318359,
-0.21060292422771454,
0.5325716733932495,
0.7927602529525757,
-0.22901342809200287,
-0.018473181873559952,
-0.3565431535243988,
-0.19979706406593323,
-0.469454288482666,
-0.03995799645781517,
-0.452573299407959,
-0.5397477746009827,
0.5989640355110168,
-0.10494975745677948,
-0.040199194103479385,
0.09603652358055115,
0.48347270488739014,
-0.1349390745162964,
0.9268702864646912,
0.31143632531166077,
0.5414813756942749,
0.7671610713005066,
-0.5615580081939697,
-0.012975492514669895,
-0.8587374687194824,
-0.4798201322555542,
-0.0317293219268322,
-0.45329713821411133,
-0.5618987679481506,
-0.6443399786949158,
0.55972820520401,
-0.3440275490283966,
0.13531088829040527,
0.14957718551158905,
-0.1237187534570694,
0.47228744626045227,
0.4289473295211792,
0.27472367882728577,
0.24416393041610718,
-0.1544615477323532,
-0.42139601707458496,
0.10900814086198807,
-0.5389740467071533,
-0.3165029287338257,
1.3241835832595825,
0.1212371289730072,
0.6557404398918152,
0.3892577290534973,
0.6747244596481323,
0.5515187978744507,
0.16475443542003632,
-0.7051000595092773,
0.5759897232055664,
-0.26189717650413513,
-0.5729760527610779,
-0.10453478246927261,
-0.3892711102962494,
-1.123240351676941,
0.6513710021972656,
-0.401412695646286,
-0.30571240186691284,
0.4119552969932556,
0.13828256726264954,
-0.6106249690055847,
-0.10456980764865875,
-1.0344651937484741,
0.938274621963501,
-0.292885959148407,
-0.6449090242385864,
-0.23112666606903076,
-0.7952845096588135,
0.5170672535896301,
-0.1405097246170044,
0.4688911437988281,
0.15499988198280334,
0.012741451151669025,
0.2900010645389557,
-0.1702316850423813,
0.9964815974235535,
0.09723416715860367,
-0.12550516426563263,
0.2902688980102539,
-0.04528709501028061,
0.1935340166091919,
0.12055707722902298,
0.6251344680786133,
-0.023751752451062202,
-0.12883368134498596,
-0.2704044580459595,
-0.734599769115448,
0.5404899716377258,
-0.582551896572113,
-0.28884655237197876,
-0.3042733371257782,
-0.39804190397262573,
-0.25155773758888245,
0.4012810289859772,
0.1169380322098732,
0.950303316116333,
-0.18572315573692322,
0.40855881571769714,
0.989351749420166,
0.14472420513629913,
0.39133310317993164,
0.3933248817920685,
-0.10753952711820602,
-0.43339911103248596,
0.7959917187690735,
0.061174821108579636,
0.41234540939331055,
0.6433831453323364,
0.31974756717681885,
-0.2986142635345459,
-0.4424666166305542,
-0.23451268672943115,
0.0986756682395935,
-0.720210075378418,
0.13744233548641205,
-0.6704365611076355,
0.2850048243999481,
-0.42484480142593384,
-0.1904972940683365,
-0.35023343563079834,
-0.5946633815765381,
-0.4817357063293457,
-0.15991000831127167,
-0.5495402812957764,
0.9257553815841675,
-0.09822787344455719,
0.26597148180007935,
-0.5470152497291565,
0.7440378069877625,
0.7099616527557373,
0.12706957757472992,
0.05645815283060074,
-0.35543057322502136,
-0.2626020610332489,
-0.11223903298377991,
-0.4600543975830078,
-0.6235957741737366,
-0.1409643590450287,
0.17163147032260895,
0.6458311676979065,
0.590135395526886,
-0.0724286362528801,
0.5620877742767334,
-0.4114154279232025,
0.8701344728469849,
0.430902361869812,
-0.6144493222236633,
0.19428248703479767,
-0.622790515422821,
0.6826131343841553,
0.483844518661499,
0.47152015566825867,
-0.3837915062904358,
-0.03660191223025322,
-0.5229173302650452,
-0.9665233492851257,
0.37430429458618164,
0.18654590845108032,
0.3012060225009918,
-0.15623103082180023,
-0.1968391388654709,
0.2826310396194458,
0.3580387234687805,
-0.7679005265235901,
-0.17611739039421082,
-0.40187081694602966,
-0.3047318160533905,
-0.0584142841398716,
-0.3529491126537323,
-0.2648000419139862,
0.03152162581682205,
0.23603728413581848,
-0.1722048968076706,
0.305876225233078,
-0.000803051982074976,
-0.09937316179275513,
0.23356664180755615,
0.3245662748813629,
1.1765921115875244,
0.6746841669082642,
-0.02993815392255783,
0.25261327624320984,
-0.26932665705680847,
-0.3192613124847412,
0.27668750286102295,
0.04630609229207039,
0.00022837509459350258,
-0.26385483145713806,
0.543258786201477,
0.8207526803016663,
0.6917397975921631,
-0.532447099685669,
0.7207735776901245,
-0.2065112441778183,
0.09592626243829727,
-0.5918519496917725,
-0.026337141171097755,
-0.2592688798904419,
0.42277464270591736,
0.3328150510787964,
0.40529534220695496,
0.4610578119754791,
-0.9905425310134888,
0.056208472698926926,
0.21110418438911438,
0.07622022926807404,
-0.7107197046279907,
0.6993268728256226,
0.14922963082790375,
0.25816062092781067,
0.32509469985961914,
0.10725514590740204,
-0.1570168435573578,
0.2870960831642151,
0.38956260681152344,
0.9443835020065308,
-0.06047159060835838,
0.19829924404621124,
0.2192520648241043,
0.07855294644832611,
-0.2970748245716095,
0.2678718864917755,
-0.7240175604820251,
-0.7515231966972351,
-0.1677267849445343,
-0.25026264786720276,
-0.21055126190185547,
-0.39048221707344055,
-0.5223414301872253,
-0.015228730626404285,
-0.5621162056922913,
-0.3762862980365753,
-0.09178837388753891,
-0.6118387579917908,
-0.5987735986709595,
0.30085036158561707,
0.4062553942203522,
0.3052893579006195,
-1.0186717510223389,
0.3859170079231262,
0.7635042071342468,
-0.47548434138298035,
-0.553816556930542,
0.17626126110553741,
0.040829990059137344,
-0.5354408621788025,
0.6741259098052979,
0.23168228566646576,
-0.20837323367595673,
-0.4395850598812103,
-0.4879286289215088,
-0.744086742401123,
1.282657504081726,
0.04666164517402649,
-0.4283917546272278,
-0.43995940685272217,
0.14696761965751648,
0.6017392873764038,
-0.46133852005004883,
0.3610876202583313,
0.2443036288022995,
0.45709699392318726,
0.4148676097393036,
-0.8913683891296387,
-0.1788448691368103,
-0.22095882892608643,
0.2961123287677765,
-0.10607351362705231,
-0.8651401400566101,
0.9021956324577332,
-0.34595105051994324,
-0.553675651550293,
0.13101957738399506,
0.5634479522705078,
0.08429411053657532,
0.6019132733345032,
0.3784359097480774,
0.7014248967170715,
0.4493716061115265,
-0.09277869015932083,
1.1522294282913208,
0.08192364126443863,
0.04508619010448456,
1.579405426979065,
-0.32362401485443115,
0.43243634700775146,
0.4224236309528351,
0.07225191593170166,
0.6756148934364319,
0.289815753698349,
0.17483380436897278,
0.8145444989204407,
0.0071084750816226006,
-0.37606778740882874,
-0.40739455819129944,
-0.10267860442399979,
-0.18682409822940826,
0.8153848648071289,
0.3088289797306061,
-0.47107693552970886,
0.10683178156614304,
0.28607162833213806,
-0.2453276365995407,
0.32231026887893677,
-0.22440007328987122,
0.8766842484474182,
0.005263121798634529,
-0.6473855376243591,
0.3359905183315277,
-0.14677609503269196,
0.36674150824546814,
-0.8013085126876831,
-0.007154891267418861,
-0.1696547567844391,
0.11854667961597443,
-0.05770319327712059,
-0.7209225296974182,
0.04113660752773285,
-0.5333651900291443,
-0.33927562832832336,
-0.5013816952705383,
0.3759883642196655,
-0.405638724565506,
-0.17297373712062836,
0.05195414647459984,
0.1014922484755516,
-0.3050512969493866,
0.08259841054677963,
-0.2418443113565445,
0.38669636845588684,
-0.3088763356208801,
0.09293466061353683,
-0.022212421521544456,
0.42237588763237,
-0.1336500197649002,
0.5958967804908752,
0.4726810157299042,
-0.4158823788166046,
0.30442702770233154,
0.1942145973443985,
0.9045564532279968,
-0.2762533724308014,
-0.4713825285434723,
-0.46599462628364563,
0.9350228905677795,
0.0890238806605339,
-0.1742262840270996,
0.7141255736351013,
0.6284624338150024,
1.1168105602264404,
-0.4792111814022064,
0.6864822506904602,
-0.13201242685317993,
-0.021970856934785843,
-0.8494501113891602,
0.07778703421354294,
-0.6046355962753296,
0.12905125319957733,
-0.36473172903060913,
-0.7708075046539307,
-0.21836838126182556,
0.32532432675361633,
-0.3507995903491974,
0.3367645740509033,
0.8335961699485779,
0.384439617395401,
-0.2869088649749756,
0.06840716302394867,
0.4917125701904297,
0.10859165340662003,
0.05501517653465271,
0.36785057187080383,
1.0727678537368774,
-0.44084829092025757,
0.20993568003177643,
-0.14794281125068665,
-0.1715012639760971,
-0.13094332814216614,
-0.5328375101089478,
-0.8374283909797668,
-0.8124393820762634,
-0.17744536697864532,
0.21916134655475616,
-0.29872891306877136,
0.8405075669288635,
0.9703671336174011,
-0.6195715665817261,
-0.2279132604598999,
0.1057882085442543,
-0.08328351378440857,
-0.3254426419734955,
-0.1772184669971466,
-0.17430470883846283,
-0.10998138040304184,
-0.6478394865989685,
0.7073981761932373,
0.15294605493545532,
0.22536739706993103,
-0.17414826154708862,
0.1229555532336235,
-0.3124051094055176,
0.37030068039894104,
0.8757721185684204,
0.18680548667907715,
-0.570201575756073,
-0.20153948664665222,
-0.10693728923797607,
0.1620396375656128,
-0.005307433661073446,
1.2635040283203125,
-0.5457202196121216,
0.9070432782173157,
0.5712783932685852,
0.34387823939323425,
0.563865065574646,
0.2304924726486206,
0.546252965927124,
-0.9891641736030579,
0.040210701525211334,
-0.026868125423789024,
0.5926142930984497,
0.3189689517021179,
-0.06917442381381989,
0.47081977128982544,
0.5262324213981628,
-0.43897905945777893,
-0.592362105846405,
0.5571454763412476,
-1.2100695371627808,
-0.2653317153453827,
1.0627329349517822,
0.09463091194629669,
0.12101719528436661,
0.144664466381073,
-0.0969712883234024,
0.06241372227668762,
-0.36206144094467163,
0.6867889165878296,
0.5807194113731384,
-0.07450473308563232,
-0.09111744165420532,
-0.1792697161436081,
-0.05822689086198807,
0.25678136944770813,
-0.672765851020813,
-0.12313777953386307,
0.9796313047409058,
0.30999836325645447,
0.3902043402194977,
0.6942691206932068,
-0.07174596190452576,
0.33139851689338684,
-0.043372634798288345,
-0.3094411790370941,
-0.04710107296705246,
-0.9327470064163208,
-0.304934024810791,
0.3183723986148834,
-0.24663980305194855,
-0.3147376775741577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12010v1
|
ParaFusion: A Large-Scale LLM-Driven English Paraphrase Dataset Infused with High-Quality Lexical and Syntactic Diversity
| 2024-04-18T09:02:45 | 2024-04-18T09:02:45 |
Lasal Jayawardena, Prasan Yapa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Paraphrase generation is a pivotal task in natural language processing (NLP).
Existing datasets in the domain lack syntactic and lexical diversity, resulting
in paraphrases that closely resemble the source sentences. Moreover, these
datasets often contain hate speech and noise, and may unintentionally include
non-English language sentences. This research introduces ParaFusion, a
large-scale, high-quality English paraphrase dataset developed using Large
Language Models (LLM) to address these challenges. ParaFusion augments existing
datasets with high-quality data, significantly enhancing both lexical and
syntactic diversity while maintaining close semantic similarity. It also
mitigates the presence of hate speech and reduces noise, ensuring a cleaner and
more focused English dataset. Results show that ParaFusion offers at least a
25% improvement in both syntactic and lexical diversity, measured across
several metrics for each data source. The paper also aims to set a gold
standard for paraphrase evaluation as it contains one of the most comprehensive
evaluation strategies to date. The results underscore the potential of
ParaFusion as a valuable resource for improving NLP applications.
|
[
-0.12928299605846405,
-0.43408745527267456,
0.2888972759246826,
0.4458804428577423,
-0.3281129002571106,
0.1511557698249817,
-0.14887987077236176,
-0.2567143738269806,
0.162322998046875,
0.8026037812232971,
-0.14508122205734253,
-0.6307229995727539,
-0.5190824270248413,
0.5232521295547485,
-0.9153903126716614,
1.2032502889633179,
0.03276007995009422,
-0.00450592115521431,
-0.4225984513759613,
-0.456195205450058,
-0.12258213758468628,
-0.3241024911403656,
-0.5367898344993591,
0.06243538111448288,
0.5852079391479492,
0.25965914130210876,
1.0796985626220703,
0.6484193205833435,
0.6116151213645935,
0.21359093487262726,
-0.029623795300722122,
0.3031805753707886,
-0.5716766715049744,
0.44754430651664734,
-0.46217361092567444,
-0.19592559337615967,
-0.0698317289352417,
-0.5418246388435364,
0.7249402403831482,
0.6399176716804504,
-0.2786687910556793,
-0.06509856134653091,
0.5234565734863281,
0.479532927274704,
-0.7647153735160828,
-0.09723939746618271,
-0.8541428446769714,
0.04213083162903786,
-0.41452717781066895,
-0.22335389256477356,
-0.16031350195407867,
-0.4592708945274353,
0.07513073086738586,
-0.4776889681816101,
0.2890022099018097,
0.10045688599348068,
0.5377774238586426,
0.090455561876297,
-0.2769683599472046,
-0.2629109025001526,
-0.5943665504455566,
0.9098162651062012,
-0.723224401473999,
0.3441060483455658,
0.06057910993695259,
0.07943791151046753,
-0.0194389708340168,
-0.9059300422668457,
-0.5737759470939636,
-0.08017947524785995,
0.14498381316661835,
-0.12362486869096756,
-0.1256239116191864,
-0.10502185672521591,
-0.29889583587646484,
0.42912641167640686,
-0.8422304391860962,
-0.035579171031713486,
-0.22202639281749725,
-0.34232908487319946,
0.4665508568286896,
0.31591546535491943,
0.3409568965435028,
-0.17330625653266907,
-0.24891631305217743,
0.0737779513001442,
-0.5812867283821106,
-0.44083479046821594,
0.1295255422592163,
0.26481905579566956,
0.14415737986564636,
0.36214208602905273,
-0.3821019232273102,
0.7048039436340332,
-0.5679513216018677,
-0.412718802690506,
0.25907641649246216,
-0.5915829539299011,
-0.15777330100536346,
-0.13123881816864014,
0.866429328918457,
0.7001159191131592,
0.205734521150589,
-0.49166515469551086,
-0.17796194553375244,
-0.023600943386554718,
-0.01968165673315525,
-0.7553892731666565,
0.04574502632021904,
0.1623067557811737,
-0.323161780834198,
-0.36240318417549133,
-0.13163045048713684,
-1.2882726192474365,
-0.5889678597450256,
-0.07134668529033661,
0.1507183313369751,
-0.5235854387283325,
0.08509016782045364,
0.23652280867099762,
-0.4390563368797302,
0.21712765097618103,
0.1165056973695755,
-0.6683400869369507,
0.36193332076072693,
0.7246631979942322,
0.8196364045143127,
-0.6621924042701721,
-0.8124525547027588,
-0.3975273668766022,
0.45711594820022583,
-0.11035330593585968,
0.8578548431396484,
-0.7660953998565674,
-0.16589827835559845,
0.16006924211978912,
-0.19814227521419525,
0.23375649750232697,
-1.0052099227905273,
0.7946736812591553,
-0.2974620759487152,
0.11112739890813828,
-0.1266515851020813,
-0.4345875680446625,
0.1736900955438614,
-0.006674072239547968,
-0.4247935712337494,
0.9790573120117188,
0.09491880983114243,
-0.7176175713539124,
0.35529202222824097,
-0.18715588748455048,
-0.6737027168273926,
0.30324578285217285,
-0.1614844650030136,
-0.27297526597976685,
0.1960042119026184,
0.43944916129112244,
0.39857617020606995,
-0.9297078847885132,
0.33321353793144226,
-0.43238189816474915,
-0.1395905315876007,
0.1962229311466217,
-0.4900912046432495,
0.4847007691860199,
0.38641297817230225,
-0.21655595302581787,
-0.2826143801212311,
-0.7864610552787781,
-0.21301984786987305,
0.14505824446678162,
-0.014751465991139412,
-0.382418692111969,
-0.17922461032867432,
0.25250715017318726,
0.39434894919395447,
0.36197561025619507,
-0.5356082916259766,
-0.5722842812538147,
-0.41053280234336853,
0.4258553981781006,
0.48824939131736755,
0.5010678768157959,
0.31864601373672485,
-0.5368037819862366,
0.6098014712333679,
-0.038935694843530655,
0.21158760786056519,
0.16868941485881805,
-0.32100149989128113,
-0.3663395345211029,
-0.19984787702560425,
-0.005551631096750498,
0.4754359722137451,
-0.6821509599685669,
0.48255330324172974,
-0.138978511095047,
-0.6348435282707214,
-0.5807213187217712,
0.6274768710136414,
0.21088799834251404,
0.8311094641685486,
0.6122257709503174,
0.21036462485790253,
-0.571017861366272,
-1.0705742835998535,
-0.384321004152298,
0.11619727313518524,
-0.17809584736824036,
0.04560009762644768,
0.18786948919296265,
-0.006187945604324341,
0.7929681539535522,
-0.3451441526412964,
-0.10953544080257416,
-0.5017332434654236,
0.014962933026254177,
-0.023711156100034714,
0.18627583980560303,
0.475999653339386,
-0.7080062031745911,
-0.48597756028175354,
-0.13963346183300018,
-0.969867467880249,
-0.34169435501098633,
-0.21783296763896942,
-0.5538999438285828,
-0.22654391825199127,
0.3574514091014862,
-0.4439469277858734,
-0.06406326591968536,
0.6098095178604126,
-0.22678501904010773,
0.2734949588775635,
-0.033568739891052246,
0.32548442482948303,
-1.3714179992675781,
-0.020735928788781166,
-0.13042788207530975,
-0.03734336793422699,
-0.3157523572444916,
0.20914208889007568,
-0.01793006807565689,
-0.37848079204559326,
-0.7592400312423706,
0.31604087352752686,
-0.14750774204730988,
0.06835480779409409,
-0.3011271059513092,
0.19445283710956573,
0.22525951266288757,
0.1233249306678772,
-0.1287582814693451,
0.886637270450592,
0.7707480192184448,
-0.5011298060417175,
0.5070456266403198,
0.44419464468955994,
-0.28946954011917114,
0.6950739622116089,
-0.6082644462585449,
-0.14200608432292938,
-0.23408541083335876,
0.2659461498260498,
-0.7534486055374146,
-0.2315896600484848,
-0.31676313281059265,
-0.06715837121009827,
-0.32536762952804565,
0.4197934865951538,
-0.6587480306625366,
-0.10157066583633423,
-0.40749433636665344,
0.2251477688550949,
0.6961997151374817,
-0.5434051752090454,
0.18069340288639069,
0.4835936725139618,
-0.4178277850151062,
-0.4870627820491791,
-0.707807183265686,
0.5759414434432983,
-0.47359147667884827,
-0.576573371887207,
0.42232102155685425,
-0.032016903162002563,
-0.2740194797515869,
-0.24809306859970093,
-0.05537266656756401,
-0.18549199402332306,
0.01434839703142643,
-0.153428852558136,
0.0408458411693573,
0.04321572557091713,
-0.09202660620212555,
0.28262925148010254,
0.3152182400226593,
0.0198543518781662,
-0.39984244108200073,
0.5768065452575684,
0.28228750824928284,
-0.09970163553953171,
-0.44831138849258423,
0.6498613357543945,
0.7435721158981323,
-0.2865919768810272,
0.8262046575546265,
0.42509961128234863,
-0.26381927728652954,
-0.4396498501300812,
-0.3298632800579071,
0.012436170130968094,
-0.44896844029426575,
0.40118858218193054,
-0.08534403145313263,
-0.7541130185127258,
0.35398319363594055,
0.3712778687477112,
0.301045298576355,
0.5104702711105347,
0.5863891243934631,
-0.1356077939271927,
0.6411349177360535,
-0.05552901327610016,
0.06130175665020943,
0.19425258040428162,
0.24229681491851807,
0.01310353446751833,
-0.3109422028064728,
-0.1208178699016571,
-0.5648210644721985,
-0.3979620933532715,
-0.3755941092967987,
-0.5771734714508057,
0.3097027838230133,
-0.052567411214113235,
0.1725461483001709,
0.3332243859767914,
-0.3472462594509125,
0.5291013717651367,
0.38794761896133423,
0.11563727259635925,
0.33682844042778015,
0.20465081930160522,
0.1546274721622467,
-0.2568158805370331,
-0.45116811990737915,
-0.38344359397888184,
1.3094152212142944,
0.03229040279984474,
0.6951434016227722,
0.03506489843130112,
1.1151456832885742,
0.3330371677875519,
-0.2147779017686844,
-0.16941915452480316,
0.8705443143844604,
-0.34284549951553345,
-0.3128432631492615,
-0.1885080635547638,
-0.443393737077713,
-1.0612765550613403,
0.07480674982070923,
-0.1526235044002533,
-0.29323652386665344,
-0.046450767666101456,
0.044341593980789185,
-0.2985650300979614,
0.04947328567504883,
-0.47574830055236816,
0.7418561577796936,
0.05819249153137207,
-0.49949315190315247,
-0.200748011469841,
-0.5322484970092773,
0.1515561044216156,
-0.39830613136291504,
0.10264259576797485,
-0.08406803011894226,
-0.2727574110031128,
0.9851515293121338,
-0.4748966097831726,
0.31586554646492004,
-0.13766799867153168,
-0.12855765223503113,
0.42647016048431396,
0.13301688432693481,
0.6037705540657043,
0.090833380818367,
-0.31211036443710327,
0.1278609037399292,
-0.003937131725251675,
-0.5491952896118164,
-0.7593689560890198,
0.9575842618942261,
-0.486349493265152,
-0.47225823998451233,
0.007375236600637436,
-0.8497146964073181,
-0.48249855637550354,
-0.057420551776885986,
0.3804512321949005,
0.3611518144607544,
-0.07788930833339691,
0.6325322985649109,
0.5994618535041809,
-0.291683167219162,
0.4081941545009613,
0.1186704933643341,
0.05149657651782036,
-0.702210009098053,
1.0525922775268555,
-0.005380250047892332,
0.5250294208526611,
0.5290951132774353,
0.16338086128234863,
-0.20131850242614746,
-0.9667074680328369,
-0.026348590850830078,
0.22561705112457275,
-0.7235360145568848,
-0.3175390660762787,
-0.9792364835739136,
0.009423131123185158,
-0.7368801236152649,
-0.37929806113243103,
-0.13583405315876007,
-0.42703700065612793,
-0.08255553245544434,
-0.03488677367568016,
0.43654850125312805,
0.2967962324619293,
0.20476259291172028,
0.2402448058128357,
-0.8656251430511475,
0.548142671585083,
0.23825298249721527,
-0.09361812472343445,
-0.24417170882225037,
-0.7332382798194885,
-0.21081161499023438,
-0.2552715241909027,
-0.269598126411438,
-0.9052527546882629,
0.6450604200363159,
0.4191008508205414,
0.44138726592063904,
0.10443472862243652,
0.13348643481731415,
0.6868719458580017,
-0.538545548915863,
0.9652169346809387,
0.018769269809126854,
-0.6495245695114136,
0.45710888504981995,
-0.29469752311706543,
0.27421483397483826,
0.9473000764846802,
0.2994129955768585,
-0.5490506887435913,
-1.143569827079773,
-0.6883431077003479,
-1.101853370666504,
0.22575294971466064,
0.33866992592811584,
0.12970170378684998,
-0.27121269702911377,
0.0670667514204979,
0.43855780363082886,
0.32075807452201843,
-0.6967600584030151,
-0.24528926610946655,
0.014291560277342796,
-0.6491769552230835,
-0.19125400483608246,
-0.03255113586783409,
-0.1842261552810669,
-0.09578030556440353,
0.3983069062232971,
0.18576638400554657,
0.08490569144487381,
-0.023341797292232513,
-0.4113074839115143,
0.30343058705329895,
0.2419956773519516,
0.29686790704727173,
0.6813471913337708,
-0.014981438405811787,
0.2687188386917114,
0.44301339983940125,
-0.32186827063560486,
0.10627031326293945,
0.1510741263628006,
-0.06588171422481537,
0.28287848830223083,
0.4467523694038391,
0.5420911908149719,
0.19840164482593536,
-0.9509968757629395,
0.40781646966934204,
0.22408445179462433,
-0.207912877202034,
0.06045660004019737,
0.02991761453449726,
0.17154379189014435,
0.042917974293231964,
0.3791082501411438,
-0.13357990980148315,
0.4921448528766632,
-0.20101983845233917,
0.5378355979919434,
0.34623637795448303,
0.4139031767845154,
0.005323559045791626,
0.6525809168815613,
0.3432310223579407,
-0.23905602097511292,
0.3923770487308502,
-0.043553393334150314,
0.010105734691023827,
0.4179741442203522,
0.7137846350669861,
0.9832838773727417,
-0.08625147491693497,
0.27762889862060547,
0.14827494323253632,
0.13200294971466064,
-0.036233752965927124,
0.0344126932322979,
-0.053936611860990524,
-0.5317978858947754,
-0.1998775154352188,
-1.1357831954956055,
-0.4304361045360565,
0.3557737469673157,
-0.5789363980293274,
0.324949711561203,
-0.4780300259590149,
0.41198021173477173,
-0.04905316233634949,
-0.6154223084449768,
-0.48915907740592957,
0.2695949375629425,
0.1839590072631836,
0.7444141507148743,
-0.9779376983642578,
0.7088980674743652,
0.3757787048816681,
-0.22194159030914307,
-0.4254243075847626,
0.44064509868621826,
-0.3842880427837372,
-0.9319562911987305,
0.4263018071651459,
0.025268491357564926,
0.0640624463558197,
0.043481726199388504,
-0.09716871380805969,
-0.8276874423027039,
1.0229463577270508,
0.7077670097351074,
-0.36065149307250977,
-0.32777172327041626,
0.5831530690193176,
0.6538859605789185,
-0.2744271755218506,
0.025801459327340126,
0.7688769102096558,
0.1697612851858139,
0.1547013521194458,
-0.5636404156684875,
0.07477225363254547,
0.08256805688142776,
0.2454029768705368,
0.21898557245731354,
-0.37619832158088684,
0.5987070798873901,
0.43186068534851074,
0.14956852793693542,
-0.1775808334350586,
0.8983412981033325,
0.29228660464286804,
0.08736349642276764,
0.42732393741607666,
0.4970830976963043,
0.5836113691329956,
0.34238502383232117,
0.916310727596283,
-0.4626992642879486,
0.10689843446016312,
1.1363327503204346,
-0.5352385640144348,
0.8168591856956482,
0.6993725299835205,
-0.2211623340845108,
0.2879611551761627,
0.272487610578537,
0.0729532316327095,
0.5796113014221191,
-0.04958810284733772,
-0.6950989961624146,
-0.1686067134141922,
-0.2684325575828552,
-0.10422936826944351,
0.3814425766468048,
0.2042139321565628,
-0.6476918458938599,
-0.7341903448104858,
0.37638962268829346,
-0.04149584099650383,
0.26803338527679443,
-0.2653955817222595,
0.7805801033973694,
-0.1568724662065506,
-0.9258182644844055,
0.8091803193092346,
-0.1559259593486786,
0.6725068092346191,
-0.5995712280273438,
0.09513849020004272,
-0.5450400710105896,
-0.023242224007844925,
-0.28536200523376465,
-0.8890591859817505,
0.633679986000061,
0.20079606771469116,
0.09285788983106613,
-0.5307555198669434,
0.31850433349609375,
-0.608572244644165,
-0.42399081587791443,
0.3820534348487854,
0.23490053415298462,
0.2991263270378113,
-0.0963553786277771,
-0.8400921821594238,
0.02896975539624691,
0.24385948479175568,
-0.09296649694442749,
0.6270833015441895,
0.5193366408348083,
0.13602374494075775,
0.3853004574775696,
0.49864837527275085,
0.3665250539779663,
0.03585025668144226,
0.07939105480909348,
0.6073004007339478,
-0.5940918922424316,
-0.42177948355674744,
-1.1811763048171997,
0.29151225090026855,
-0.26631638407707214,
-0.4749942123889923,
0.8655285835266113,
0.7514382600784302,
0.6261112689971924,
-0.04556720331311226,
0.8554360270500183,
0.017914986237883568,
0.5740944743156433,
-0.3941005766391754,
0.38663479685783386,
-0.4212002754211426,
-0.03611423075199127,
-0.34378403425216675,
-0.990212619304657,
-0.3744153380393982,
0.36307501792907715,
0.137926384806633,
-0.32873743772506714,
0.9182405471801758,
1.1453262567520142,
0.01161645632237196,
-0.03773198649287224,
0.5813207030296326,
0.0038888086564838886,
0.2998848855495453,
0.5596941709518433,
0.6330021619796753,
-0.33225956559181213,
1.055253028869629,
-0.2100977897644043,
-0.22482939064502716,
0.08366833627223969,
-0.707700252532959,
-0.608126163482666,
-0.5507051944732666,
-0.4434491991996765,
-0.6378902196884155,
0.055413395166397095,
0.8863746523857117,
0.10608881711959839,
-0.8256435394287109,
-0.378082811832428,
-0.6080329418182373,
-0.08714623749256134,
-0.20680393278598785,
-0.2662471532821655,
-0.0047601680271327496,
-0.69637531042099,
-1.0220593214035034,
0.5898504257202148,
0.47751808166503906,
-0.1664533019065857,
-0.1327294260263443,
0.06336574256420135,
-0.2836572229862213,
0.28739550709724426,
0.3686111867427826,
0.11957661062479019,
-0.3890164792537689,
0.03509675711393356,
-0.20434972643852234,
-0.24072004854679108,
0.1210816502571106,
0.6311144232749939,
-0.4509788751602173,
0.018871475011110306,
0.44788163900375366,
1.1536346673965454,
0.11110085994005203,
-0.20557916164398193,
0.8047158718109131,
-0.8052113652229309,
0.24486275017261505,
0.5396054983139038,
0.424993097782135,
0.4326058626174927,
-0.26613667607307434,
0.1761382520198822,
0.5128123164176941,
-0.6404845118522644,
-0.9871260523796082,
0.1153227910399437,
-0.7015419006347656,
-0.19436344504356384,
1.5377671718597412,
-0.04278178513050079,
-0.2284315973520279,
-0.10056807100772858,
-0.1463719606399536,
0.18137076497077942,
-0.4030221104621887,
0.47370395064353943,
0.746910035610199,
0.015450961887836456,
-0.049298156052827835,
-0.26796022057533264,
0.6015758514404297,
0.8899760842323303,
-1.1495925188064575,
0.4393405616283417,
0.5036726593971252,
0.26161646842956543,
-0.09089931100606918,
0.17381033301353455,
-0.20176468789577484,
0.21002399921417236,
-0.1105763390660286,
0.04923151805996895,
0.20347853004932404,
-0.2633253037929535,
-0.4474925100803375,
0.6070798635482788,
0.14908935129642487,
-0.2062179148197174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12006v1
|
Variational Multi-Modal Hypergraph Attention Network for Multi-Modal Relation Extraction
| 2024-04-18T08:56:47 | 2024-04-18T08:56:47 |
Qian Li, Cheng Ji, Shu Guo, Yong Zhao, Qianren Mao, Shangguang Wang, Yuntao Wei, Jianxin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-modal relation extraction (MMRE) is a challenging task that aims to
identify relations between entities in text leveraging image information.
Existing methods are limited by their neglect of the multiple entity pairs in
one sentence sharing very similar contextual information (ie, the same text and
image), resulting in increased difficulty in the MMRE task. To address this
limitation, we propose the Variational Multi-Modal Hypergraph Attention Network
(VM-HAN) for multi-modal relation extraction. Specifically, we first construct
a multi-modal hypergraph for each sentence with the corresponding image, to
establish different high-order intra-/inter-modal correlations for different
entity pairs in each sentence. We further design the Variational Hypergraph
Attention Networks (V-HAN) to obtain representational diversity among different
entity pairs using Gaussian distribution and learn a better hypergraph
structure via variational attention. VM-HAN achieves state-of-the-art
performance on the multi-modal relation extraction task, outperforming existing
methods in terms of accuracy and efficiency.
|
[
-0.5755694508552551,
-0.883479118347168,
0.4959150552749634,
0.2698196470737457,
-0.4584723711013794,
-0.1936710625886917,
-0.23455537855625153,
-0.5725976824760437,
0.37301167845726013,
0.41733595728874207,
-0.8850155472755432,
-0.17236743867397308,
-0.502608597278595,
0.1804903894662857,
0.3741072714328766,
1.0497500896453857,
0.1101330891251564,
-0.12715241312980652,
-0.297308087348938,
-0.4122830629348755,
-0.41043370962142944,
-0.38508301973342896,
-0.007349760737270117,
-0.014052985236048698,
0.8753662109375,
0.21904721856117249,
0.8829109072685242,
0.6204328536987305,
0.9301289916038513,
0.29316991567611694,
-0.08262759447097778,
0.6775810122489929,
-0.5195606350898743,
0.2042078822851181,
-0.15634240210056305,
-0.039037637412548065,
-0.42665261030197144,
-0.1824527084827423,
0.7032976150512695,
0.5410305261611938,
0.1266779750585556,
0.14650946855545044,
-0.24626217782497406,
0.5986108779907227,
-0.8031948208808899,
0.4781748354434967,
-0.4113665521144867,
-0.03571971133351326,
-0.2625882625579834,
-0.35657867789268494,
-0.2437623143196106,
0.11909845471382141,
0.15612760186195374,
-0.7366232872009277,
0.1432209014892578,
0.2502872347831726,
1.4247045516967773,
0.09047359228134155,
-0.6524065732955933,
0.03341098129749298,
-0.7063995599746704,
0.561903715133667,
-0.30824014544487,
0.6410332322120667,
0.37168923020362854,
0.273872971534729,
0.20720337331295013,
-0.6836763024330139,
-0.4287763237953186,
-0.4631190001964569,
-0.4120994806289673,
0.41847047209739685,
-0.023177942261099815,
0.06320635229349136,
0.26945337653160095,
0.6721535325050354,
-0.46667173504829407,
-0.30343300104141235,
-0.08113741129636765,
-0.06639983505010605,
0.16010351479053497,
0.4638825058937073,
0.20775948464870453,
-0.6605470776557922,
-0.8093382120132446,
0.030471578240394592,
-0.32552123069763184,
-0.156389981508255,
0.14392481744289398,
0.24938447773456573,
-0.1021118238568306,
0.7292331457138062,
-0.18298086524009705,
0.6834167838096619,
-0.030862292274832726,
-0.2542433440685272,
0.6170706152915955,
-0.5372760891914368,
-0.5121512413024902,
-0.7291457653045654,
1.147433876991272,
0.2900961935520172,
-0.10629704594612122,
-0.16174650192260742,
-0.10803066939115524,
-0.24481156468391418,
0.0762629359960556,
-0.8436006903648376,
0.10563020408153534,
-0.28905123472213745,
-0.7193679809570312,
-0.19562160968780518,
0.2284260243177414,
-0.9957932829856873,
-0.07441410422325134,
-0.3782796263694763,
0.27859610319137573,
-0.47226834297180176,
-0.31608477234840393,
-0.06270424276590347,
-0.1342708319425583,
0.07562714070081711,
0.16711165010929108,
-0.8034462928771973,
0.2587722837924957,
0.36724597215652466,
0.7999258041381836,
-0.09956958889961243,
-0.47004106640815735,
-0.4900720715522766,
0.5423172116279602,
0.20176337659358978,
0.45246782898902893,
-0.702712893486023,
-0.2831384539604187,
-0.22950692474842072,
0.13343843817710876,
-0.39594027400016785,
-0.42759326100349426,
0.558980405330658,
-0.8104617595672607,
0.46304163336753845,
-0.15959234535694122,
-0.35952574014663696,
-0.17808897793293,
0.44715404510498047,
-1.1481295824050903,
0.8665323257446289,
0.3153431713581085,
-1.1552029848098755,
-0.13459640741348267,
-0.6078672409057617,
-0.4787942171096802,
0.05998224392533302,
-0.5132496953010559,
-0.6485692858695984,
-0.007535262499004602,
0.5356494784355164,
0.5678346753120422,
-0.85636305809021,
-0.12118792533874512,
-0.39145368337631226,
0.07280785590410233,
0.3479122519493103,
-0.6181967258453369,
0.7481390237808228,
0.1383337676525116,
-0.18995502591133118,
-0.007972410880029202,
-0.8552528619766235,
-0.24614311754703522,
0.16327370703220367,
-0.4670749604701996,
-0.5578011870384216,
-0.3358032703399658,
0.4652787446975708,
0.5072662830352783,
0.24827350676059723,
-0.37277477979660034,
-0.11328740417957306,
-0.2842138111591339,
0.08792098611593246,
0.573997437953949,
0.4266527593135834,
0.297114759683609,
-0.3528288006782532,
0.6571463942527771,
0.3378806710243225,
0.09792131930589676,
-0.49207425117492676,
-0.431768536567688,
-0.6089164614677429,
-0.6677653789520264,
0.11761823296546936,
0.33380600810050964,
-0.7381162047386169,
0.4276197552680969,
-0.3575849235057831,
-0.047440625727176666,
-0.2949784994125366,
0.13508012890815735,
0.5156434774398804,
0.742791473865509,
0.34419316053390503,
-0.35174113512039185,
-0.24713309109210968,
-0.9574365615844727,
0.10526761412620544,
-0.07740528881549835,
0.17768549919128418,
1.0000276565551758,
0.18575313687324524,
-0.46532416343688965,
0.8266316056251526,
-0.6812673807144165,
-0.530285656452179,
0.021056432276964188,
0.16050969064235687,
0.058679476380348206,
0.24487826228141785,
0.560972273349762,
-1.1960768699645996,
-0.5287455320358276,
0.3637096583843231,
-0.8411200046539307,
0.3228510618209839,
-0.17238964140415192,
-0.3109835982322693,
-0.13877518475055695,
0.4588927924633026,
-0.7482271194458008,
0.033414583653211594,
0.37865740060806274,
0.019833266735076904,
0.5275318622589111,
-0.012091313488781452,
0.13936418294906616,
-1.4281920194625854,
0.14673364162445068,
0.31249555945396423,
-0.48008015751838684,
-0.2587636709213257,
0.15767082571983337,
0.14780203998088837,
-0.0750289186835289,
-0.2084352970123291,
0.18098850548267365,
-0.8585183620452881,
0.14152003824710846,
0.10011322796344757,
0.054730694741010666,
0.15058062970638275,
0.825431227684021,
-0.18212758004665375,
0.513699471950531,
0.5722313523292542,
-0.3308890759944916,
0.499398410320282,
0.13147486746311188,
0.13445515930652618,
0.6652578711509705,
-0.4834456443786621,
0.19455479085445404,
-0.28560951352119446,
-0.06515511125326157,
-1.0399961471557617,
-0.2651020288467407,
0.5585436224937439,
-0.18969275057315826,
0.42856544256210327,
-0.0947485938668251,
-0.22695031762123108,
-0.295432984828949,
-0.25113630294799805,
0.6056200265884399,
-0.19636932015419006,
-0.2309110313653946,
0.8256889581680298,
0.26790881156921387,
0.025465644896030426,
-0.8823151588439941,
-0.5397592186927795,
0.06189126893877983,
-0.10937154293060303,
-0.7107868790626526,
0.4900311231613159,
-0.10166862607002258,
0.028062008321285248,
0.5218341946601868,
-0.04135311394929886,
-0.45708340406417847,
-0.23118045926094055,
0.35885414481163025,
0.4186936020851135,
-0.5924106240272522,
0.36475813388824463,
-0.07473648339509964,
-0.24090750515460968,
-0.11112779378890991,
0.22042426466941833,
0.44865891337394714,
-0.25520238280296326,
-0.3087816536426544,
-0.6397150754928589,
0.7033345699310303,
0.9747446775436401,
-0.6610150337219238,
0.6000488996505737,
0.8105061650276184,
-0.407857209444046,
0.2882882356643677,
-0.5320138335227966,
-0.02127167582511902,
-0.43000978231430054,
0.631909191608429,
-0.839149534702301,
-0.9431408047676086,
0.36904376745224,
-0.21388816833496094,
-0.4906359314918518,
0.45015856623649597,
0.7880757451057434,
0.044987183064222336,
0.72470623254776,
0.8647461533546448,
-0.3598802387714386,
0.7661529183387756,
-0.1976250559091568,
-0.030433325096964836,
-0.9705133438110352,
-0.25026214122772217,
-0.0589517243206501,
-0.03499310463666916,
-0.47953352332115173,
-0.5027251243591309,
0.396939754486084,
-0.1869761198759079,
0.06482592225074768,
0.25786516070365906,
-0.2343578040599823,
0.5934805870056152,
0.3635982871055603,
0.5097463726997375,
0.3622397780418396,
0.05098273977637291,
0.0719723179936409,
-0.330412358045578,
-0.290828675031662,
-0.17083634436130524,
0.9564777612686157,
0.23513421416282654,
0.6968187689781189,
0.15363246202468872,
0.5725317597389221,
-0.04403049871325493,
0.16870401799678802,
-0.9782634377479553,
0.2794061601161957,
0.11383432149887085,
-0.5210124850273132,
-0.4555177092552185,
-0.7766242623329163,
-1.0803914070129395,
0.6304106712341309,
-0.1453331559896469,
-0.6247799396514893,
0.3627934455871582,
-0.2995506823062897,
-0.13246619701385498,
-0.024948464706540108,
-0.5902199149131775,
0.8467620611190796,
0.10999448597431183,
-0.30252474546432495,
-0.03926139324903488,
-1.164423942565918,
0.49609896540641785,
0.18010391294956207,
0.18986141681671143,
-0.23444612324237823,
-0.10828913748264313,
0.3184618353843689,
-0.24019107222557068,
0.6852896213531494,
0.2340967059135437,
0.2251480221748352,
0.014263572171330452,
0.022160029038786888,
0.3241162896156311,
0.4567289352416992,
0.013831586576998234,
-0.3138088583946228,
-0.5982538461685181,
-0.11680860817432404,
-0.583760678768158,
0.5153123140335083,
-0.8754914999008179,
-0.32051482796669006,
-0.17338906228542328,
-0.9163945913314819,
-0.2142326682806015,
0.3746187388896942,
0.14415226876735687,
0.5481786131858826,
-0.5379049181938171,
0.22654031217098236,
0.5531259775161743,
0.48708897829055786,
0.7083930373191833,
0.031016042456030846,
-0.07277283817529678,
-0.8401055932044983,
0.991463840007782,
-0.05859080329537392,
0.24582107365131378,
0.87630695104599,
0.13868571817874908,
-0.08156659454107285,
0.19381415843963623,
-0.5843945741653442,
0.427606463432312,
-0.46767815947532654,
-0.338167667388916,
-0.9568709135055542,
-0.1671983301639557,
-0.24665389955043793,
0.28235918283462524,
-0.28844448924064636,
-0.25696122646331787,
-0.568994402885437,
0.31317034363746643,
0.11125396192073822,
0.3521518111228943,
-0.0919695645570755,
0.17884200811386108,
-0.8602625131607056,
0.8243526220321655,
0.7296117544174194,
-0.04211890324950218,
-0.07449116557836533,
-0.2063576728105545,
-0.14455722272396088,
-0.24604862928390503,
-0.3745168149471283,
-1.2523808479309082,
0.24041172862052917,
0.2728390395641327,
0.5375446081161499,
0.6513264775276184,
-0.21650002896785736,
0.4899146556854248,
-0.42622247338294983,
0.23760248720645905,
0.7052894234657288,
-0.7876845002174377,
0.2116651087999344,
-0.535515546798706,
0.07309702038764954,
0.3325433135032654,
0.3895496726036072,
-0.6316148638725281,
-0.09579440206289291,
-0.5058981776237488,
-0.8825398087501526,
0.6921911239624023,
0.3925422132015228,
0.23817090690135956,
0.09837266802787781,
0.2293201982975006,
-0.15546347200870514,
0.35761210322380066,
-1.034897804260254,
-0.588901698589325,
-0.09992734342813492,
-0.20406915247440338,
0.1598007082939148,
-0.2917754054069519,
-0.48106497526168823,
-0.2265312522649765,
0.25032758712768555,
-0.1783682405948639,
0.4322349727153778,
0.28573960065841675,
-0.3456065058708191,
-0.2978261709213257,
0.1606844663619995,
0.5339890122413635,
0.7403135299682617,
-0.2825767993927002,
0.41791200637817383,
-0.1046319454908371,
-0.4119146466255188,
0.1563725620508194,
0.4777299463748932,
0.14011460542678833,
0.11222401261329651,
0.16939641535282135,
0.9138644337654114,
-0.018504075706005096,
-0.2803856432437897,
0.9910227656364441,
-0.09965193271636963,
0.1072637215256691,
0.25172945857048035,
-0.35899972915649414,
0.40463221073150635,
0.38052648305892944,
0.1922881156206131,
0.21301443874835968,
0.28732427954673767,
-0.4452359080314636,
0.3196931779384613,
0.20333361625671387,
-0.5994539856910706,
-0.19671325385570526,
0.4966989755630493,
-0.0456317774951458,
-0.4678066074848175,
0.38620027899742126,
-0.2807536721229553,
-0.38953447341918945,
0.6460269093513489,
0.7973076105117798,
0.8679362535476685,
-0.21773995459079742,
0.38133782148361206,
0.11177296936511993,
0.460316002368927,
0.44436004757881165,
0.1881699413061142,
-0.03864971920847893,
-0.6649127006530762,
-0.45524728298187256,
-0.10067471861839294,
-0.4297323524951935,
0.1981433480978012,
-0.7893641591072083,
0.30362755060195923,
-0.3696417808532715,
-0.17154528200626373,
0.12882643938064575,
-0.43380671739578247,
-0.7425974011421204,
0.36979058384895325,
0.04364657774567604,
-0.0475599430501461,
-0.7352381944656372,
0.5975556373596191,
0.8562374114990234,
-0.9151149988174438,
-0.7145280241966248,
0.19212299585342407,
-0.20672756433486938,
-0.5610328912734985,
0.5260494351387024,
0.3289709687232971,
-0.3666954040527344,
-0.07237384468317032,
-0.26324382424354553,
-0.8389677405357361,
1.0281087160110474,
0.5558682680130005,
-0.5675503611564636,
0.041956577450037,
-0.09213048219680786,
0.30015769600868225,
-0.5750786662101746,
0.26353326439857483,
-0.0182077344506979,
0.22943370044231415,
-0.10393822193145752,
-0.7892749309539795,
0.3455892503261566,
-0.28327304124832153,
0.2168191522359848,
0.2643803656101227,
-1.0081417560577393,
1.0806708335876465,
-0.02664509043097496,
-0.18532879650592804,
-0.34996098279953003,
0.8064171671867371,
0.15520064532756805,
0.2747977077960968,
0.6239609718322754,
0.5769683718681335,
0.7467126250267029,
0.4032256305217743,
0.7790029644966125,
-0.16162365674972534,
0.6480861902236938,
1.2985961437225342,
-0.15661847591400146,
0.5585107207298279,
0.6545678377151489,
0.020123377442359924,
0.62477046251297,
0.43683210015296936,
0.026467077434062958,
0.6058852672576904,
-0.10757825523614883,
-0.26511669158935547,
-0.4232402741909027,
-0.18692898750305176,
-0.567964494228363,
0.2562333047389984,
0.2875984013080597,
-0.6450607776641846,
-0.3099736273288727,
0.08979490399360657,
0.003647647798061371,
-0.14464110136032104,
0.034720275551080704,
0.6437720656394958,
0.005793423857539892,
0.015877407044172287,
0.32675647735595703,
-0.02715221606194973,
0.39005783200263977,
-0.3081209063529968,
0.11146679520606995,
0.08857189863920212,
-0.11237338930368423,
0.023202858865261078,
-0.3517816662788391,
-0.07362528145313263,
-0.61018306016922,
-0.7446743249893188,
0.31984734535217285,
0.8924386501312256,
-0.46720099449157715,
-0.4069225788116455,
0.420370876789093,
1.0000133514404297,
-0.21411842107772827,
-0.1407071053981781,
-0.7247764468193054,
-0.18163137137889862,
-0.2014056146144867,
-0.6689085364341736,
0.1647261679172516,
0.9513076543807983,
0.14928565919399261,
0.309293270111084,
0.6313751935958862,
-0.30480197072029114,
0.1922920197248459,
0.3525153398513794,
1.3774235248565674,
-0.5508981347084045,
-0.5312890410423279,
-1.0080899000167847,
0.4022742509841919,
-0.456534206867218,
-0.6279835104942322,
0.4225181043148041,
0.5610698461532593,
0.49651461839675903,
-0.09125083684921265,
0.6552318930625916,
-0.08583130687475204,
0.16792111098766327,
-0.2751244306564331,
0.3544626235961914,
-0.7361130714416504,
-0.13498999178409576,
-0.49092164635658264,
-1.0478949546813965,
-0.4875912666320801,
0.4324485957622528,
0.05401301011443138,
0.019523324444890022,
1.1539937257766724,
0.9320670366287231,
-0.542740523815155,
-0.1732206642627716,
0.40177929401397705,
-0.18267257511615753,
0.2447575032711029,
0.6346336603164673,
0.9790997505187988,
-0.41967159509658813,
0.8039480447769165,
-0.3346081078052521,
-0.24789418280124664,
-0.3242979645729065,
-0.7608481049537659,
-0.8287492990493774,
-0.6619864702224731,
-0.23118099570274353,
-0.2647310793399811,
-0.1483141928911209,
0.9723406434059143,
0.7005524635314941,
-0.2575346529483795,
-0.09174060076475143,
-0.04098185524344444,
0.2712470293045044,
-0.19264769554138184,
-0.3047630190849304,
0.6739322543144226,
-0.43452492356300354,
-0.7539499998092651,
0.31007176637649536,
0.6908591985702515,
0.0640234723687172,
-0.10470902174711227,
0.030628768727183342,
-0.4205865263938904,
-0.04664427787065506,
0.5721129775047302,
0.02395285665988922,
-0.47151437401771545,
-0.15832364559173584,
0.06780609488487244,
-0.641180694103241,
0.4772651791572571,
0.9556818604469299,
-0.13040746748447418,
0.6489686369895935,
0.6229786276817322,
0.8719571232795715,
0.7947608232498169,
-0.11376907676458359,
0.3225248157978058,
-0.7530688643455505,
0.27916768193244934,
0.35911497473716736,
0.45404794812202454,
0.20458918809890747,
-0.4610997140407562,
0.33260205388069153,
0.7066981196403503,
-0.554384171962738,
-0.5942361950874329,
0.5388770699501038,
-1.4863642454147339,
-0.0895518958568573,
1.225101113319397,
-0.2101868838071823,
-0.27963027358055115,
-0.2069864422082901,
-0.6069440245628357,
0.2931482791900635,
-0.46153515577316284,
0.47265759110450745,
0.4958311915397644,
-0.1909930258989334,
-0.3346766531467438,
-0.36618512868881226,
0.1403370350599289,
0.5093359351158142,
-0.8426602482795715,
-0.0023125724401324987,
0.607751727104187,
0.08640635013580322,
0.38077792525291443,
0.8180660605430603,
-0.0727941170334816,
0.2807230055332184,
-0.07794895023107529,
-0.03415939211845398,
-0.12333718687295914,
-0.3858962059020996,
-0.14815236628055573,
0.671604573726654,
-0.18943452835083008,
-0.5961419343948364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11999v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11999v4
|
Token-level Direct Preference Optimization
| 2024-04-18T08:49:38 | 2024-06-27T15:27:41 |
Yongcheng Zeng, Guoqing Liu, Weiyu Ma, Ning Yang, Haifeng Zhang, Jun Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fine-tuning pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) is essential to align
them with human values and intentions. This process often utilizes methods like
pairwise comparisons and KL divergence against a reference LLM, focusing on the
evaluation of full answers generated by the models. However, the generation of
these responses occurs in a token level, following a sequential,
auto-regressive fashion. In this paper, we introduce Token-level Direct
Preference Optimization (TDPO), a novel approach to align LLMs with human
preferences by optimizing policy at the token level. Unlike previous methods,
which face challenges in divergence efficiency, TDPO incorporates forward KL
divergence constraints for each token, improving alignment and diversity.
Utilizing the Bradley-Terry model for a token-based reward system, TDPO
enhances the regulation of KL divergence, while preserving simplicity without
the need for explicit reward modeling. Experimental results across various text
tasks demonstrate TDPO's superior performance in balancing alignment with
generation diversity. Notably, fine-tuning with TDPO strikes a better balance
than DPO in the controlled sentiment generation and single-turn dialogue
datasets, and significantly improves the quality of generated responses
compared to both DPO and PPO-based RLHF methods. Our code is open-sourced at
https://github.com/Vance0124/Token-level-Direct-Preference-Optimization.
|
[
-0.28555336594581604,
-0.3349049389362335,
0.3814149498939514,
0.31199997663497925,
-0.46014538407325745,
0.5225069522857666,
-0.3053906261920929,
-0.07685040682554245,
-0.014652435667812824,
0.34668275713920593,
-0.7438458204269409,
-0.74957674741745,
-0.42748504877090454,
0.15666808187961578,
0.226165309548378,
0.7844887971878052,
0.011528008617460728,
-0.07902482897043228,
0.035845838487148285,
0.13546831905841827,
-0.5869496464729309,
-0.44132286310195923,
-0.9990191459655762,
-0.3625911772251129,
0.8119859099388123,
0.5667216777801514,
0.5685024857521057,
0.861653745174408,
0.26857030391693115,
0.21548552811145782,
-0.3371531665325165,
0.5267810821533203,
-0.5991108417510986,
0.09588020294904709,
-0.23172912001609802,
-0.3943287134170532,
-0.4352037310600281,
-0.12469684332609177,
0.3671340346336365,
0.46225664019584656,
0.011219006963074207,
-0.02537349984049797,
0.004196851048618555,
0.7538061738014221,
-0.7269645929336548,
-0.12856696546077728,
-0.7137279510498047,
0.3146218955516815,
-0.027020560577511787,
-0.31551477313041687,
-0.3689050078392029,
-0.6869709491729736,
0.2537405490875244,
-0.46384644508361816,
-0.07015592604875565,
0.11159243434667587,
0.7121919393539429,
0.252262145280838,
-0.566962480545044,
-0.12415757030248642,
-0.5633902549743652,
0.9761796593666077,
-0.722515881061554,
0.286545068025589,
0.07659825682640076,
-0.1592072695493698,
-0.061963848769664764,
-0.22719858586788177,
-0.5339226722717285,
-0.17064258456230164,
-0.013793110847473145,
0.04989779368042946,
0.0558774396777153,
0.37816524505615234,
-0.1386757493019104,
0.30614256858825684,
-0.28297197818756104,
0.5042901635169983,
0.1089138463139534,
-0.14836768805980682,
0.43838536739349365,
0.29249465465545654,
0.16405342519283295,
-0.3312983512878418,
-0.43330326676368713,
-0.09242040663957596,
-0.4951696991920471,
0.42381101846694946,
0.5570862889289856,
0.6271527409553528,
-0.002237769542261958,
0.5856635570526123,
-0.19929005205631256,
0.5611509680747986,
0.40119633078575134,
-0.2113918662071228,
0.25784632563591003,
-0.5924001336097717,
-0.016452381387352943,
0.13372370600700378,
0.6437469124794006,
0.4187566936016083,
0.29603293538093567,
-0.08890054374933243,
-0.31659671664237976,
-0.017347317188978195,
0.1232210174202919,
-0.7181318402290344,
0.3628373444080353,
0.4062383472919464,
-0.41738197207450867,
-1.017047643661499,
-0.12696018815040588,
-0.6592959761619568,
-0.21824119985103607,
-0.5890808701515198,
0.1281929463148117,
-0.05928831920027733,
-0.4521791636943817,
0.40543973445892334,
-0.0003734540077857673,
0.1646583080291748,
0.03686155006289482,
-1.1155041456222534,
0.13866209983825684,
0.9186578989028931,
0.7592280507087708,
-0.5787928700447083,
-0.07571979612112045,
-0.6066839694976807,
0.2530704736709595,
-0.419971764087677,
0.4413345158100128,
-0.6633599996566772,
-0.6843605041503906,
0.21109037101268768,
-0.47680041193962097,
0.23206670582294464,
-0.4853003919124603,
0.8328149914741516,
-0.47915926575660706,
0.27183234691619873,
-0.4410018026828766,
-0.3379818797111511,
0.4549962282180786,
0.4288925528526306,
-0.1655890792608261,
1.0150549411773682,
-0.07197433710098267,
-0.7286341786384583,
0.6738508343696594,
-0.8085353970527649,
-0.400156706571579,
-0.23599115014076233,
-0.09098168462514877,
-0.27351850271224976,
0.14361970126628876,
0.31593015789985657,
0.2054261416196823,
-0.1097988560795784,
0.5483957529067993,
-0.3032904863357544,
-0.1887935996055603,
-0.09864655137062073,
-0.10362756252288818,
0.5460088849067688,
0.26103007793426514,
-0.33521947264671326,
0.5942485928535461,
-0.5788799524307251,
0.09904836118221283,
-0.004918861202895641,
-0.5222162008285522,
-0.43159228563308716,
0.0953432247042656,
-0.41849228739738464,
0.21256709098815918,
0.44303184747695923,
-0.6137478947639465,
0.53020179271698,
-0.6485305428504944,
0.4934040307998657,
1.312374472618103,
-0.20029550790786743,
0.746064305305481,
-0.019888686016201973,
0.4363740384578705,
0.3658619523048401,
0.4986377954483032,
0.14936211705207825,
-0.02076316438615322,
-0.6737270951271057,
-0.3597794473171234,
0.2692078948020935,
0.3417733311653137,
-0.32060304284095764,
0.9360832571983337,
-0.2010670304298401,
-0.21951663494110107,
-0.5161693096160889,
0.0037262041587382555,
0.2931385636329651,
0.8000725507736206,
0.17636382579803467,
-0.19919447600841522,
-0.33949920535087585,
-1.022269606590271,
-0.22994154691696167,
-0.3023715615272522,
0.09739313274621964,
0.6006597876548767,
-0.19829612970352173,
-0.3019506633281708,
1.1708228588104248,
-0.6814494132995605,
-0.017950311303138733,
-0.17471280694007874,
0.04124577343463898,
0.20964713394641876,
0.40337082743644714,
0.39794909954071045,
-0.5926898121833801,
-0.5193147659301758,
0.043437860906124115,
-0.15918275713920593,
-0.44258683919906616,
0.11532571911811829,
-0.483531653881073,
0.3484821915626526,
0.09922167658805847,
-0.588406503200531,
-0.0466005764901638,
0.3033042848110199,
-0.4137892723083496,
0.28657299280166626,
-0.0745936781167984,
0.0035936017520725727,
-1.0924116373062134,
0.1024966910481453,
-0.22605909407138824,
-0.24819301068782806,
-0.37691909074783325,
-0.23668226599693298,
0.015247806906700134,
-0.2055375874042511,
-0.2585281729698181,
0.6658872961997986,
-0.15216350555419922,
0.07366924732923508,
-0.18555831909179688,
-0.03902276232838631,
0.12321901321411133,
0.5095890760421753,
0.08288703113794327,
0.7015751004219055,
0.409972608089447,
-0.44199231266975403,
0.05522354319691658,
0.33615848422050476,
0.06956372410058975,
0.3029852509498596,
-0.6257117390632629,
0.4035471975803375,
-0.25163760781288147,
0.06908708065748215,
-1.0031933784484863,
0.15700581669807434,
0.19239845871925354,
-0.22389303147792816,
0.3395766615867615,
0.05061865597963333,
-0.3558138608932495,
-0.4286179840564728,
-0.6866046190261841,
0.6250262260437012,
0.4736112952232361,
-0.653417706489563,
0.3708456754684448,
0.08058612793684006,
-0.125907763838768,
-1.0987931489944458,
-0.19035591185092926,
-0.024001173675060272,
-0.14005976915359497,
-0.32219576835632324,
0.4632894694805145,
-0.16842207312583923,
-0.10418175905942917,
-0.25661784410476685,
-0.319755494594574,
0.4171443283557892,
-0.06803850084543228,
-0.1095879003405571,
0.2988359332084656,
0.07288088649511337,
0.19889947772026062,
0.33596017956733704,
-0.09801660478115082,
-0.2699277997016907,
-0.587911069393158,
1.0247771739959717,
0.06915416568517685,
-0.09318137913942337,
-0.4942774772644043,
0.2322641760110855,
0.38233208656311035,
-0.2779843509197235,
0.28421467542648315,
0.4187271296977997,
0.18770267069339752,
-0.28583791851997375,
-0.48787474632263184,
-0.10313840955495834,
-0.5624145269393921,
0.3727191388607025,
-0.425582617521286,
-0.8767196536064148,
0.18625785410404205,
-0.05439618229866028,
0.13739456236362457,
0.22222793102264404,
0.6821286082267761,
0.3160635232925415,
1.2438336610794067,
0.5573107004165649,
-0.5289603471755981,
0.6950708031654358,
0.03799445182085037,
0.2161286473274231,
-0.4234853684902191,
-0.24706342816352844,
-0.5570434331893921,
-0.5451512932777405,
-0.5558682680130005,
-0.12287391722202301,
0.03287690877914429,
0.12068218737840652,
-0.6503359079360962,
0.044994257390499115,
-0.7750709652900696,
0.5443623661994934,
0.6857867240905762,
0.04184858873486519,
0.3931165635585785,
-0.04299622401595116,
-0.45595815777778625,
-0.02836425229907036,
-0.5801234245300293,
-0.43106809258461,
1.0539851188659668,
0.4023156762123108,
0.7473313808441162,
-0.14573903381824493,
0.9753907322883606,
0.4545879364013672,
0.07762390375137329,
-0.738730251789093,
0.5073947906494141,
-0.22445079684257507,
-0.21704530715942383,
-0.31376007199287415,
-0.5141478180885315,
-0.8524137139320374,
0.03845027834177017,
-0.05220523476600647,
-0.48618510365486145,
0.332414835691452,
0.23942700028419495,
-0.32872098684310913,
0.12899555265903473,
-0.7025777101516724,
0.7259870171546936,
-0.42754748463630676,
-0.2342924177646637,
-0.23836679756641388,
-0.5951913595199585,
0.2579748034477234,
0.008697091601788998,
-0.2611604630947113,
-0.31256401538848877,
-0.45014867186546326,
0.26089391112327576,
-0.27695024013519287,
0.6635501980781555,
-0.35222193598747253,
-0.35640043020248413,
-0.09563187509775162,
-0.004764912184327841,
0.5939748883247375,
0.1910407394170761,
-0.2688148021697998,
0.0031102385837584734,
-0.1846124529838562,
-0.45655396580696106,
-0.3898793160915375,
0.8561015725135803,
-1.14811110496521,
-0.7994673252105713,
-0.042917847633361816,
-0.5018826127052307,
-0.41447705030441284,
0.38375863432884216,
0.06121326610445976,
0.18534377217292786,
-0.08307215571403503,
-0.19937936961650848,
0.4135703146457672,
-0.44018080830574036,
0.4450509548187256,
0.3719635605812073,
-0.2202560156583786,
-0.661819577217102,
0.6800309419631958,
-0.39383554458618164,
0.43650200963020325,
0.7313047647476196,
0.5619840025901794,
-0.5323046445846558,
-0.5927849411964417,
-0.2608662247657776,
0.13785050809383392,
-0.40556418895721436,
-0.30410146713256836,
-0.45485222339630127,
0.0763828456401825,
-0.45033660531044006,
-0.28123605251312256,
-0.28344571590423584,
-0.3510773181915283,
-0.4171489477157593,
-0.13038396835327148,
-0.027314988896250725,
0.4155879616737366,
0.04153529554605484,
0.11496811360120773,
-0.4909227192401886,
0.24700817465782166,
0.3719770610332489,
0.5733853578567505,
-0.015292777679860592,
-0.20323367416858673,
0.14048293232917786,
0.03797396272420883,
-0.38148969411849976,
-0.334362655878067,
0.1843605786561966,
-0.08649535477161407,
0.30305740237236023,
0.5724890828132629,
0.22395776212215424,
0.6707541942596436,
-0.4738592207431793,
0.6551925539970398,
0.3531572222709656,
-1.0868560075759888,
0.6552409529685974,
-0.48926156759262085,
0.3542056977748871,
0.683817982673645,
0.2502553164958954,
-0.4779118001461029,
-0.25851011276245117,
-0.26182499527931213,
-0.8008260726928711,
0.7351192831993103,
-0.013089211657643318,
0.47435954213142395,
-0.23419083654880524,
0.5071535706520081,
0.22116751968860626,
0.41597163677215576,
-0.641061007976532,
-0.16186673939228058,
-0.12775938212871552,
-0.4466269016265869,
0.12331267446279526,
-0.4309366047382355,
-0.2850087881088257,
-0.25461846590042114,
0.47283124923706055,
-0.18164286017417908,
0.02204613946378231,
0.23239284753799438,
0.36390769481658936,
-0.31612101197242737,
0.20089420676231384,
0.8447304368019104,
0.46936702728271484,
-0.2506868541240692,
-0.033723004162311554,
-0.08510942757129669,
-0.19230999052524567,
0.3352021276950836,
-0.101841039955616,
-0.23269535601139069,
-0.1495746672153473,
-0.058117303997278214,
0.7967059016227722,
-0.22660887241363525,
-0.5962306261062622,
0.5401287078857422,
-0.15057092905044556,
-0.18499955534934998,
0.026792462915182114,
0.16428063809871674,
0.018350519239902496,
0.30542752146720886,
0.3399384915828705,
0.08494109660387039,
-0.17505599558353424,
-0.35332050919532776,
-0.12992160022258759,
0.691664457321167,
-0.22625789046287537,
-0.1753135770559311,
0.6338183283805847,
0.6723821759223938,
-0.6486104726791382,
0.3110863268375397,
0.01345809455960989,
-0.4230642020702362,
0.4198220372200012,
0.4425964951515198,
0.9916473031044006,
0.014768632128834724,
0.29941803216934204,
0.22981978952884674,
-0.042624279856681824,
0.1290317177772522,
0.20767904818058014,
-0.3436736762523651,
-0.9677747488021851,
-0.3816027343273163,
-0.655138373374939,
-0.3591080605983734,
-0.034978237003088,
-0.4077891707420349,
0.5647324323654175,
-0.619559109210968,
-0.299251526594162,
-0.05419871211051941,
0.12263467162847519,
-0.6353260278701782,
-0.005427110008895397,
0.17265471816062927,
0.8571913838386536,
-0.36207714676856995,
0.6656177639961243,
0.3158554136753082,
-0.2007749229669571,
-0.6786231994628906,
0.18584240972995758,
-0.3445650637149811,
-1.1035915613174438,
0.9489432573318481,
-0.009673546068370342,
-0.2097984403371811,
0.2822750508785248,
-0.31891417503356934,
-0.6679335236549377,
0.9884048700332642,
0.466204971075058,
-0.7507643103599548,
-0.24357378482818604,
0.5358371138572693,
0.44925230741500854,
-0.44093024730682373,
0.09280003607273102,
0.44832244515419006,
0.439818412065506,
-0.02656898833811283,
-0.8611544966697693,
0.0337219312787056,
0.15583747625350952,
0.29148101806640625,
0.4506315588951111,
-0.9456801414489746,
0.40643563866615295,
-0.11308114975690842,
-0.010626322589814663,
-0.058599889278411865,
0.37770146131515503,
0.3536224961280823,
-0.0048952954821288586,
0.9000078439712524,
0.5941751599311829,
0.589061975479126,
0.012959469109773636,
0.7506407499313354,
-0.5823336243629456,
0.2731410562992096,
0.7114395499229431,
-0.44665732979774475,
0.5843783020973206,
0.7814324498176575,
-0.06264659762382507,
0.4496929943561554,
0.898989200592041,
0.18806535005569458,
0.6750531792640686,
0.4532944858074188,
-0.45221981406211853,
-0.20747166872024536,
-0.4542178809642792,
-0.17194907367229462,
0.34078970551490784,
-0.24253930151462555,
-0.37158387899398804,
-0.051548250019550323,
-0.18272356688976288,
-0.11359941214323044,
0.08518830686807632,
-0.41455334424972534,
0.9510796070098877,
-0.16463670134544373,
-0.8444116115570068,
0.5810376405715942,
-0.016478857025504112,
0.9432689547538757,
-0.5840153098106384,
0.36704233288764954,
-0.5397852659225464,
0.2688737213611603,
-0.09325788170099258,
-0.5094168186187744,
-0.005637775640934706,
-0.0031019283924251795,
-0.25634774565696716,
-0.44790229201316833,
0.6538732051849365,
-0.550694465637207,
-0.2974528670310974,
0.32391566038131714,
0.29317739605903625,
-0.4641175866127014,
0.22285820543766022,
-0.6718770265579224,
0.038664307445287704,
0.14376913011074066,
-0.36934149265289307,
0.21885141730308533,
0.4388720989227295,
0.09964627027511597,
0.6096020340919495,
0.5693041682243347,
0.263714998960495,
-0.2527824640274048,
0.3640427589416504,
0.8957996368408203,
-0.6491860747337341,
-0.5305975675582886,
-1.1692293882369995,
0.41018998622894287,
-0.2215530127286911,
-0.4865509867668152,
0.27962726354599,
0.6875582933425903,
0.7727007865905762,
-0.0721084326505661,
0.713073194026947,
0.19782544672489166,
0.3969537615776062,
-0.2979905903339386,
0.2779581546783447,
-0.6064098477363586,
0.1873515397310257,
-0.29424962401390076,
-0.8855071067810059,
-0.22404387593269348,
0.09650122374296188,
-0.3208586275577545,
-0.06478816270828247,
0.3653797209262848,
0.7713971138000488,
-0.015436545014381409,
-0.33655864000320435,
0.25664907693862915,
-0.20056958496570587,
0.37539970874786377,
0.4750850796699524,
0.7454303503036499,
0.22889630496501923,
0.6876446008682251,
-0.04715633764863014,
-0.01691981591284275,
0.004474830813705921,
-0.9661178588867188,
-0.9392250180244446,
-0.15910334885120392,
-0.11658082157373428,
-0.09478509426116943,
0.04349400848150253,
1.2947185039520264,
0.7374163269996643,
-0.6543433666229248,
-0.25130289793014526,
-0.35424888134002686,
0.200491800904274,
0.22622396051883698,
-0.2755141854286194,
0.26005876064300537,
-0.8100919723510742,
-1.0553371906280518,
0.01590852439403534,
0.5006224513053894,
0.12370103597640991,
-0.2593671977519989,
-0.2145281434059143,
0.012042317539453506,
0.12447818368673325,
0.6592967510223389,
-0.05875116214156151,
-0.8647208213806152,
-0.49324163794517517,
0.260403573513031,
-0.3295638859272003,
0.23466630280017853,
1.0365936756134033,
-0.5062991976737976,
0.4454667270183563,
0.6164622902870178,
0.8421486020088196,
0.3400479853153229,
0.38420653343200684,
0.9450723528862,
-0.984181821346283,
0.15312567353248596,
0.4512300193309784,
0.06758779287338257,
0.11801869422197342,
-0.5711193084716797,
0.2600347697734833,
0.09998930990695953,
-0.5566965937614441,
-0.9071330428123474,
0.4344303011894226,
-1.123319387435913,
-0.20566533505916595,
1.188245177268982,
0.22803109884262085,
0.14869791269302368,
0.21794812381267548,
-0.5622761845588684,
0.23436808586120605,
-0.7193720936775208,
1.0264500379562378,
0.6559998989105225,
-0.055666349828243256,
-0.05817323550581932,
0.18111445009708405,
0.7971972227096558,
0.8083745837211609,
-0.6444606781005859,
0.18547797203063965,
0.18545624613761902,
0.15723291039466858,
-0.231650710105896,
0.8235592842102051,
-0.0004347671056166291,
-0.2635197043418884,
-0.5795390605926514,
0.13174331188201904,
-0.21272005140781403,
0.042571697384119034,
-0.19314153492450714,
0.04607783257961273,
0.39548027515411377,
-0.40835821628570557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11978v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11978v1
|
EVIT: Event-Oriented Instruction Tuning for Event Reasoning
| 2024-04-18T08:14:53 | 2024-04-18T08:14:53 |
Zhengwei Tao, Xiancai Chen, Zhi Jin, Xiaoying Bai, Haiyan Zhao, Yiwei Lou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Events refer to specific occurrences, incidents, or happenings that take
place under a particular background. Event reasoning aims to infer events
according to certain relations and predict future events. The cutting-edge
techniques for event reasoning play a crucial role in various natural language
processing applications. Large language models (LLMs) have made significant
advancements in event reasoning owing to their wealth of knowledge and
reasoning capabilities. However, smaller instruction-tuned models currently in
use do not consistently demonstrate exceptional proficiency in managing these
tasks. This discrepancy arises from the absence of explicit modeling of events
and the interconnections of them within their instruction data. Consequently,
these models face challenges in comprehending event structures and semantics
while struggling to bridge the gap between their interpretations and human
understanding of events. Additionally, their limitations in grasping event
relations lead to constrained event reasoning abilities to effectively deduce
and incorporate pertinent event knowledge. In this paper, we propose
Event-Oriented Instruction Tuning (EvIT) to train our LLM. Specifically, we
first propose a novel structure named event quadruple which contains the
structure and semantics of events and is complete in the event representation.
We then design event-relation learning based on the structures. We encapsulate
the learning into the instruction-tuning formulation to better stimulate the
event reasoning capacity of our model. We design a heuristic unsupervised
method to mine event quadruple from a large-scale corpus. At last, we finetune
a Llama model on our Event-Oriented Instruction Tuning. We conduct extensive
experiments on event reasoning tasks on several datasets. Automatic and human
evaluations demonstrate EvIT achieves competitive performances on event
reasoning.
|
[
-0.11467002332210541,
-0.8962273597717285,
0.6556389927864075,
-0.12041422724723816,
-0.1601080596446991,
0.15931543707847595,
-0.21910631656646729,
-0.48040369153022766,
-0.16850456595420837,
0.22893846035003662,
-0.7019798755645752,
-0.7004726529121399,
-0.20382337272167206,
0.01887928508222103,
-0.1779041439294815,
0.7223273515701294,
-0.19875699281692505,
-0.24978582561016083,
-0.21840311586856842,
-0.0020267979707568884,
-0.44062960147857666,
-0.6351363658905029,
-0.9133926630020142,
-0.39685752987861633,
0.07114710658788681,
0.7895458936691284,
0.048547036945819855,
0.819131076335907,
0.3429418206214905,
0.271849125623703,
-0.010122832842171192,
0.38597625494003296,
-0.474470317363739,
0.12579737603664398,
-0.22585420310497284,
-0.6915140748023987,
-0.35297346115112305,
-0.11943792551755905,
0.6463663578033447,
0.4478539526462555,
-0.2653736472129822,
0.1772492378950119,
-0.07131525874137878,
0.33657053112983704,
-0.6137882471084595,
0.1867489516735077,
-0.8389774560928345,
-0.011702006682753563,
-0.24548393487930298,
-0.5718804001808167,
-0.5866034030914307,
-0.016225386410951614,
-0.28569331765174866,
-0.7060648798942566,
0.5288037657737732,
0.35274043679237366,
0.9832319617271423,
0.3114722669124603,
-0.3476233184337616,
-0.028439253568649292,
-0.7109226584434509,
0.7393656373023987,
-0.45039162039756775,
0.5430114269256592,
0.5176476240158081,
0.047679219394922256,
-0.444665789604187,
-0.5769754648208618,
-0.4663785994052887,
-0.03741990402340889,
0.17326997220516205,
0.030319182202219963,
0.27756333351135254,
0.35273343324661255,
0.3514096140861511,
0.18211975693702698,
-0.533085286617279,
0.40305033326148987,
-0.010852452367544174,
0.14532962441444397,
0.6212553381919861,
0.5193731784820557,
0.22236745059490204,
0.07877126336097717,
-0.38805896043777466,
-0.0033485714811831713,
-0.8530359268188477,
-0.04805123805999756,
0.5368253588676453,
-0.033857088536024094,
0.06425412744283676,
0.4577649235725403,
-0.17372722923755646,
0.5554136037826538,
0.4081314504146576,
0.14656725525856018,
0.0120851444080472,
-0.35911327600479126,
-0.39141467213630676,
0.29796871542930603,
0.36670535802841187,
0.30540263652801514,
0.23674088716506958,
-0.1162615567445755,
0.07395320385694504,
0.052991244941949844,
0.17681947350502014,
-0.9027838706970215,
-0.13037854433059692,
0.20080287754535675,
-0.20638369023799896,
-0.25930267572402954,
-0.1834968626499176,
-0.7993090152740479,
-0.0533149391412735,
-0.49432334303855896,
0.4676283001899719,
-0.8125754594802856,
-0.03149121627211571,
0.22375507652759552,
0.023821556940674782,
0.5638071298599243,
0.37769007682800293,
-1.072157859802246,
0.06140225753188133,
0.9597234129905701,
0.3979146182537079,
0.0017095108050853014,
-0.399193674325943,
-0.7274279594421387,
0.4701226055622101,
-0.01909819059073925,
0.8533350229263306,
-1.1775312423706055,
-0.20507307350635529,
0.0014719374012202024,
-0.06879997253417969,
-0.3202469050884247,
-0.2996571660041809,
0.7764366865158081,
-0.6508170366287231,
-0.029381878674030304,
0.16798067092895508,
-1.1285145282745361,
-0.244193434715271,
0.11054855585098267,
-0.34384647011756897,
1.0216182470321655,
-0.09836297482252121,
-0.573944091796875,
0.48639169335365295,
-0.5284696221351624,
-0.6968018412590027,
0.2591591775417328,
-0.46298038959503174,
-0.6182069778442383,
0.1663576364517212,
0.3623526096343994,
0.28760406374931335,
-0.09973682463169098,
0.06841918081045151,
-0.14940756559371948,
-0.3612886965274811,
-0.2648327946662903,
-0.1767757534980774,
0.3263797163963318,
-0.09575625509023666,
-0.4286205768585205,
0.06455403566360474,
-1.0456037521362305,
0.03557152301073074,
0.01715334691107273,
-0.28280308842658997,
-0.4894731640815735,
0.36281058192253113,
-0.2633083760738373,
-0.1854514628648758,
0.19255486130714417,
-0.4469790458679199,
0.41874805092811584,
-0.5624955296516418,
0.4259220063686371,
0.8012352585792542,
0.14629842340946198,
0.6361371874809265,
-0.03482861816883087,
0.5170051455497742,
0.14991319179534912,
0.33870959281921387,
-0.5183098316192627,
-0.4765385389328003,
-0.7565817832946777,
0.03555477038025856,
-0.07464627176523209,
0.5974065661430359,
-0.7381463050842285,
0.4952632188796997,
0.06529251486063004,
0.007627776358276606,
-0.3976215720176697,
0.0034516446758061647,
0.20543219149112701,
0.5045493245124817,
0.1679994761943817,
0.3124791383743286,
-0.846260666847229,
-0.6575233936309814,
-0.26238200068473816,
-0.21049363911151886,
0.16650830209255219,
0.006515107583254576,
0.4595909118652344,
0.01411702111363411,
0.5630719065666199,
-0.2652863562107086,
-0.11005200445652008,
-0.2919405698776245,
0.4009157121181488,
0.06050393730401993,
0.2589516341686249,
0.3245195150375366,
-0.5967455506324768,
-0.28786614537239075,
0.2270035743713379,
-0.5132644176483154,
-0.019762078300118446,
-0.24242135882377625,
-0.4100053906440735,
0.32686224579811096,
0.5587581992149353,
-0.21967092156410217,
0.6205437183380127,
0.09631337225437164,
-0.6775583624839783,
0.3289809823036194,
-0.14671540260314941,
0.21097040176391602,
-0.9343950748443604,
-0.5554482340812683,
-0.20498685538768768,
-0.24588727951049805,
-0.4055637717247009,
0.12086141854524612,
0.10806842148303986,
0.27477651834487915,
-0.15173578262329102,
0.41173356771469116,
-0.4817543923854828,
0.18943773210048676,
-0.4672282934188843,
-0.05107700824737549,
0.16617989540100098,
0.4699775278568268,
0.2304001897573471,
0.6885136961936951,
0.3760770261287689,
-0.7143802046775818,
0.3546905517578125,
0.3493986427783966,
-0.40222635865211487,
0.7292191386222839,
-0.24274669587612152,
0.31715166568756104,
-0.1026952937245369,
-0.15719667077064514,
-0.5273135900497437,
-0.11693369597196579,
-0.16783352196216583,
-0.3510298430919647,
0.6050690412521362,
-0.22773584723472595,
-0.4890033006668091,
-0.18248069286346436,
-0.22689680755138397,
0.19787925481796265,
0.35866498947143555,
-0.7831135392189026,
0.9619196057319641,
0.13983799517154694,
0.09561000019311905,
-0.4313408434391022,
-0.22573591768741608,
-0.07036083936691284,
-0.28023776412010193,
-0.732602596282959,
0.33906829357147217,
-0.04435824602842331,
-0.1469009667634964,
0.101026751101017,
-0.18518878519535065,
-0.040433961898088455,
-0.0071039930917322636,
0.22525805234909058,
0.23028722405433655,
-0.5017731189727783,
0.44177067279815674,
0.14135301113128662,
-0.04220714420080185,
-0.10427732020616531,
-0.29347339272499084,
0.27159520983695984,
-0.22489000856876373,
-0.5880271196365356,
-0.6519006490707397,
0.5712296366691589,
0.37496936321258545,
-0.1669933944940567,
0.848982572555542,
0.6497836112976074,
-0.3985144793987274,
-0.43148767948150635,
-0.7694735527038574,
-0.4729490876197815,
-0.44261425733566284,
0.7293921709060669,
-0.5514324903488159,
-0.8997333645820618,
0.4034211337566376,
-0.22277142107486725,
0.2467503547668457,
0.3187658190727234,
0.6867777705192566,
-0.1137022152543068,
1.1410167217254639,
0.7617775797843933,
0.1510007679462433,
0.7547727227210999,
-0.04256220534443855,
0.12784339487552643,
-1.0338695049285889,
-0.24101634323596954,
-0.4291267395019531,
-0.36720070242881775,
-0.2308380901813507,
-0.3100309669971466,
0.33174780011177063,
0.17180971801280975,
-0.6831474900245667,
0.10426323860883713,
-0.45813700556755066,
0.8368710875511169,
0.605399489402771,
-0.12819550931453705,
0.4133327007293701,
-0.0060633206740021706,
0.03192191570997238,
-0.0030905904714018106,
-0.8841855525970459,
-0.49019771814346313,
0.8570379018783569,
0.11874638497829437,
0.6828780174255371,
-0.1903236210346222,
0.7375755906105042,
-0.0928330048918724,
0.0195001233369112,
-0.482118159532547,
0.3973924517631531,
0.14963950216770172,
-0.4027830958366394,
-0.48775631189346313,
-0.3625805079936981,
-0.818378210067749,
0.002081336220726371,
0.02201780118048191,
-0.9493697881698608,
0.30370837450027466,
-0.045509275048971176,
-0.263365238904953,
0.4745450019836426,
-0.9599466323852539,
0.7121062278747559,
-0.32147735357284546,
-0.5666486024856567,
-0.40523332357406616,
-0.3459128141403198,
0.10748715698719025,
0.2632504999637604,
0.21941012144088745,
-0.212750643491745,
0.08604928106069565,
0.5972838401794434,
-0.3601813018321991,
0.9204143285751343,
0.31716713309288025,
0.18610318005084991,
0.3273526430130005,
0.18313045799732208,
0.9934152364730835,
0.3769534230232239,
-0.24024458229541779,
-0.06419386714696884,
0.11154482513666153,
-0.20260503888130188,
-0.5671272277832031,
0.6532254219055176,
-0.9591176509857178,
-0.7606974244117737,
-0.13332952558994293,
-0.3140415847301483,
-0.19548851251602173,
-0.2725773751735687,
0.3213441073894501,
0.5072522759437561,
-0.2477104514837265,
-0.17365282773971558,
0.8774767518043518,
-0.07984469085931778,
0.39306896924972534,
0.7326855659484863,
0.13335730135440826,
-0.10188836604356766,
0.7418427467346191,
-0.2963247299194336,
0.1324976682662964,
0.8289079070091248,
0.0707450807094574,
-0.08927126973867416,
-0.4186089336872101,
-0.6343027353286743,
0.21770022809505463,
-0.725574791431427,
-0.33184149861335754,
-0.5449678897857666,
-0.1621667742729187,
-0.16166222095489502,
-0.42488694190979004,
-0.421362042427063,
-0.36818644404411316,
-0.5644762516021729,
-0.38049182295799255,
0.6692597270011902,
0.4309849143028259,
0.10711485892534256,
0.17270906269550323,
-0.729522705078125,
0.11323851346969604,
0.2055177390575409,
0.4586745798587799,
-0.04842265695333481,
-0.7164603471755981,
-0.2873893082141876,
-0.37839606404304504,
-0.4451349973678589,
-0.8629212379455566,
0.22234834730625153,
0.6600823402404785,
0.5513901710510254,
0.4209926426410675,
0.05257238447666168,
0.6514921188354492,
-0.857169508934021,
0.38721615076065063,
-0.04121056944131851,
-0.8713768124580383,
1.047232985496521,
-0.13523374497890472,
0.11875857412815094,
0.44799739122390747,
0.09322770684957504,
-0.3130479156970978,
-0.4241626262664795,
-0.8259220123291016,
-0.974887490272522,
1.0555367469787598,
0.20293280482292175,
-0.09900356829166412,
-0.1704230010509491,
0.6849942207336426,
0.1444229632616043,
0.09551158547401428,
-0.23824608325958252,
-0.0930885449051857,
-0.021205099299550056,
-0.44004350900650024,
0.36249688267707825,
-0.4276580512523651,
0.023922160267829895,
-0.4704097807407379,
0.8333421349525452,
-0.07258511334657669,
0.1516725867986679,
0.01220269687473774,
-0.002287496579810977,
-0.41872572898864746,
0.3752897381782532,
0.4488752484321594,
0.7044405341148376,
-0.22236330807209015,
0.062497686594724655,
0.4701436161994934,
-0.5419875383377075,
0.054053232073783875,
0.1047762781381607,
-0.0011690707178786397,
-0.25993767380714417,
0.4099664092063904,
1.0709140300750732,
0.3644101023674011,
-0.5624250769615173,
0.2937590181827545,
-0.14918352663516998,
-0.0525214821100235,
-0.4109944999217987,
0.20430490374565125,
0.12572188675403595,
0.49362486600875854,
0.20994842052459717,
-0.5556071400642395,
0.03281772881746292,
-0.6344980001449585,
0.23757632076740265,
0.16096721589565277,
-0.10447118431329727,
-0.5332580804824829,
0.8269407153129578,
0.5720542073249817,
-0.43196097016334534,
0.9468445777893066,
-0.2958420217037201,
-0.5255371332168579,
0.9058303833007812,
0.6758561730384827,
0.939750611782074,
-0.39924532175064087,
-0.018981123343110085,
0.5985814929008484,
0.6233404278755188,
0.3491145372390747,
0.3890165388584137,
0.055617805570364,
-0.8486016988754272,
-0.8822329044342041,
-0.9847134351730347,
-0.4458659887313843,
0.3001323640346527,
-0.4676420986652374,
0.5100283026695251,
-0.10266095399856567,
0.21691668033599854,
-0.05946514755487442,
-0.16103769838809967,
-0.8462494611740112,
-0.22485150396823883,
0.3355564773082733,
0.8596233129501343,
-0.7704588770866394,
0.6897855401039124,
1.0696840286254883,
-0.415367990732193,
-0.7661457061767578,
-0.25212910771369934,
-0.13721880316734314,
-0.6632618308067322,
0.6280848383903503,
-0.06888244301080704,
0.14624136686325073,
0.18137937784194946,
-0.2819874882698059,
-0.7473078370094299,
0.7915674448013306,
0.23146165907382965,
-1.1617228984832764,
-0.21072569489479065,
0.041876692324876785,
0.3771200180053711,
-0.4196145534515381,
0.34645673632621765,
0.7972367405891418,
0.4615359306335449,
0.34685641527175903,
-0.6524477005004883,
-0.13604746758937836,
-0.006310864817351103,
-0.2215213179588318,
0.6200742125511169,
-0.6059151291847229,
0.47038912773132324,
-0.3180830478668213,
-0.15555334091186523,
-0.2399044930934906,
0.8517404794692993,
0.12044109404087067,
0.6110174059867859,
0.21750245988368988,
0.6949200630187988,
0.8027549386024475,
-0.15074245631694794,
1.0057789087295532,
-0.18620188534259796,
0.22925348579883575,
1.2286217212677002,
-0.495621919631958,
0.6546530723571777,
0.18518099188804626,
-0.04932430759072304,
0.38909539580345154,
0.5933067798614502,
0.19974641501903534,
0.35068461298942566,
-0.12666769325733185,
-0.5475084185600281,
-0.8385114073753357,
0.26546841859817505,
-0.21082575619220734,
0.5013812780380249,
0.7568848729133606,
-0.15543736517429352,
-0.3985770046710968,
0.23033474385738373,
-0.1364881694316864,
-0.01971558853983879,
-0.5511308312416077,
0.874179482460022,
0.1643630713224411,
-0.3962658643722534,
0.26398026943206787,
-0.011697412468492985,
0.19057680666446686,
-0.4320242702960968,
-0.48264002799987793,
-0.030292712152004242,
0.3676683306694031,
-0.03603480011224747,
-0.6408923864364624,
0.41469839215278625,
-0.12354151159524918,
-0.3401537835597992,
0.12362351268529892,
0.5716914534568787,
-0.44047293066978455,
-0.48055270314216614,
0.080903060734272,
0.24799402058124542,
0.006885502487421036,
0.04996322840452194,
-0.40084078907966614,
0.15250220894813538,
0.012071196921169758,
-0.4961753189563751,
0.42154812812805176,
0.989779531955719,
-0.26042622327804565,
0.40778499841690063,
0.3044013977050781,
-0.10007999837398529,
0.14875125885009766,
0.3464488685131073,
0.6459407210350037,
-0.7081236243247986,
-0.5928861498832703,
-0.9079665541648865,
0.1662900745868683,
-0.11133534461259842,
-0.2619261145591736,
0.38024255633354187,
0.6388923525810242,
0.7772552967071533,
0.24375875294208527,
0.6700349450111389,
0.18835406005382538,
0.39134353399276733,
-0.6111053824424744,
0.1583651900291443,
-0.27999210357666016,
0.22826634347438812,
0.34992489218711853,
-0.6025843024253845,
-0.057339299470186234,
0.5473319292068481,
-0.394456148147583,
-0.11462357640266418,
0.7291549444198608,
0.5418063402175903,
-0.006716094445437193,
0.43505406379699707,
0.4398358464241028,
0.3498854339122772,
0.3691149950027466,
0.8686125874519348,
1.0269384384155273,
-0.12892191112041473,
0.406782329082489,
0.014714008197188377,
-0.38573652505874634,
-0.594171404838562,
-0.8828567266464233,
-1.113634705543518,
-0.724209725856781,
-0.5708275437355042,
0.18391457200050354,
0.5386268496513367,
0.9989646077156067,
0.48360079526901245,
-0.6336053013801575,
0.12201355397701263,
-0.28350648283958435,
0.35507747530937195,
-0.23188245296478271,
-0.2634679079055786,
0.6518580317497253,
-0.6402801275253296,
-0.8253576755523682,
0.4836474657058716,
0.47397008538246155,
-0.40199485421180725,
0.3113742172718048,
0.32638177275657654,
-0.3026339113712311,
0.28429433703422546,
0.7717477083206177,
0.35180380940437317,
-0.4323103725910187,
-0.7610023021697998,
-0.23364609479904175,
0.17975203692913055,
0.1486535221338272,
0.6927229762077332,
-0.6925023198127747,
0.33334848284721375,
0.39353373646736145,
0.6935193538665771,
0.6591699123382568,
-0.2502489387989044,
0.6035008430480957,
-0.9121121168136597,
0.08585339039564133,
0.32676923274993896,
0.412540465593338,
0.05979156121611595,
-0.8064836859703064,
0.5153235197067261,
0.14836308360099792,
-0.7909671068191528,
-0.7120376229286194,
0.4645715355873108,
-0.8016327619552612,
-0.06020507961511612,
1.163133978843689,
0.25300952792167664,
-0.382379949092865,
-0.21094633638858795,
-0.11652909219264984,
0.4088193476200104,
-0.20261423289775848,
0.8495387434959412,
0.7028889060020447,
-0.5253086090087891,
-0.2733408510684967,
-0.7389046549797058,
0.4250032305717468,
0.18569105863571167,
-0.7755043506622314,
0.06636080145835876,
0.3140847384929657,
0.23612020909786224,
-0.2867857813835144,
0.27235302329063416,
0.09088849276304245,
0.4473307728767395,
-0.10384256392717361,
0.46010884642601013,
-0.3489026129245758,
-0.37222644686698914,
0.022383201867341995,
0.1035897508263588,
-0.01170686911791563,
-0.39794793725013733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11972v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11972v2
|
Aligning Language Models to Explicitly Handle Ambiguity
| 2024-04-18T07:59:53 | 2024-06-17T03:04:32 |
Hyuhng Joon Kim, Youna Kim, Cheonbok Park, Junyeob Kim, Choonghyun Park, Kang Min Yoo, Sang-goo Lee, Taeuk Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In interactions between users and language model agents, user utterances
frequently exhibit ellipsis (omission of words or phrases) or imprecision (lack
of exactness) to prioritize efficiency. This can lead to varying
interpretations of the same input based on different assumptions or background
knowledge. It is thus crucial for agents to adeptly handle the inherent
ambiguity in queries to ensure reliability. However, even state-of-the-art
large language models (LLMs) still face challenges in such scenarios, primarily
due to the following hurdles: (1) LLMs are not explicitly trained to deal with
ambiguous utterances; (2) the degree of ambiguity perceived by the LLMs may
vary depending on the possessed knowledge. To address these issues, we propose
Alignment with Perceived Ambiguity (APA), a novel pipeline that aligns LLMs to
manage ambiguous queries by leveraging their own assessment of ambiguity (i.e.,
perceived ambiguity). Experimental results on question-answering datasets
demonstrate that APA empowers LLMs to explicitly detect and manage ambiguous
queries while retaining the ability to answer clear questions. Furthermore, our
finding proves that APA excels beyond training with gold-standard labels,
especially in out-of-distribution scenarios.
|
[
-0.18441547453403473,
-0.6419039368629456,
0.8805770874023438,
0.2360229790210724,
-0.11262181401252747,
0.1039469987154007,
-0.0987505167722702,
-0.7034367918968201,
-0.012619304470717907,
0.45864132046699524,
-0.4831903576850891,
-0.23151211440563202,
-0.5829722285270691,
0.24763517081737518,
-0.24353575706481934,
0.6687113642692566,
-0.20540475845336914,
-0.18908748030662537,
-0.3283464014530182,
-0.3454470634460449,
-0.5650377869606018,
-0.48210182785987854,
-0.4207061529159546,
-0.42423152923583984,
0.49985072016716003,
0.24291063845157623,
1.2507269382476807,
0.5095634460449219,
0.4659694731235504,
0.3280593454837799,
-0.04235819727182388,
0.5908036828041077,
-0.1809404492378235,
0.39787760376930237,
-0.43805956840515137,
-0.4768059253692627,
-0.29808127880096436,
-0.3527560830116272,
0.6095577478408813,
0.9442629814147949,
-0.40605098009109497,
0.03864177688956261,
-0.006565979681909084,
0.4526013135910034,
-0.9773925542831421,
-0.14456115663051605,
-1.0067445039749146,
-0.17557868361473083,
-0.08241008967161179,
-0.06008344516158104,
-0.3048321008682251,
-0.04751839488744736,
0.3253181576728821,
-0.8623915314674377,
-0.25143760442733765,
0.054449670016765594,
1.1371248960494995,
0.5494165420532227,
-0.5347587466239929,
-0.4186641275882721,
-0.8851186037063599,
0.4197680354118347,
-0.6785250306129456,
0.45888882875442505,
0.268310546875,
0.3327145576477051,
-0.47480085492134094,
-0.5519563555717468,
-0.824748694896698,
0.25426408648490906,
-0.12149731069803238,
-0.03376707807183266,
-0.0920487567782402,
0.18788444995880127,
0.1199200227856636,
-0.05059821903705597,
-0.5657466053962708,
0.4068199396133423,
-0.17271679639816284,
0.0015212873695418239,
0.4355180263519287,
0.21536937355995178,
0.32810625433921814,
-0.006304373033344746,
-0.34460848569869995,
0.23516808450222015,
-0.7372589707374573,
0.09002406895160675,
0.43152129650115967,
0.4589252471923828,
0.2062975913286209,
0.857806384563446,
-0.1463581770658493,
1.051611304283142,
0.05186968296766281,
0.32553914189338684,
0.2124640941619873,
0.03736649453639984,
-0.36143162846565247,
-0.09195412695407867,
0.6951735615730286,
0.1263512670993805,
0.21559984982013702,
-0.06611399352550507,
-0.3127465844154358,
-0.2040826827287674,
0.3945061266422272,
-0.23394818603992462,
0.13605117797851562,
0.44248726963996887,
0.08961112052202225,
0.11484108865261078,
0.07151798903942108,
-0.6733722686767578,
-0.6136746406555176,
-0.34132906794548035,
0.5801678895950317,
-0.1264016032218933,
-0.19719131290912628,
0.29122474789619446,
0.13917692005634308,
0.20185644924640656,
0.4271475672721863,
-0.8832342028617859,
0.2951872944831848,
0.7589755654335022,
0.44407790899276733,
0.09038793295621872,
-0.4537581503391266,
-0.42941293120384216,
0.5102143287658691,
-0.22372403740882874,
0.565785825252533,
-0.8636473417282104,
-0.13228628039360046,
0.27301740646362305,
-0.1777326464653015,
-0.31734275817871094,
-0.4955875873565674,
0.6476600170135498,
-0.7149805426597595,
0.2641618847846985,
-0.2926766574382782,
-0.7717562317848206,
0.03342171758413315,
0.2756665050983429,
-0.49001345038414,
1.0228320360183716,
0.047228310257196426,
-0.5355717539787292,
0.278115838766098,
-0.3728030025959015,
-0.01798870787024498,
0.12875232100486755,
-0.29631027579307556,
-0.412441223859787,
0.11175532639026642,
0.4378855526447296,
-0.06993981450796127,
-0.12876571714878082,
0.22177305817604065,
-0.2527960538864136,
-0.29002687335014343,
0.3893173038959503,
-0.18652652204036713,
0.4052327275276184,
0.2735420763492584,
0.022487333044409752,
-0.19144362211227417,
-0.4042518436908722,
0.2165297120809555,
-0.08027356117963791,
-0.14796124398708344,
-0.5904166102409363,
0.07954584807157516,
-0.26662594079971313,
0.4076898694038391,
0.6348769664764404,
-0.2785413861274719,
0.2056426852941513,
-0.5826181173324585,
0.2635124921798706,
0.6712671518325806,
-0.28105685114860535,
0.5684664249420166,
-0.29991888999938965,
0.6463896036148071,
-0.07916201651096344,
0.1779259741306305,
-0.01738305389881134,
-0.47970980405807495,
-0.5973278880119324,
0.02944137342274189,
0.12794384360313416,
0.5814253687858582,
-0.4311240315437317,
0.69785475730896,
-0.3635839521884918,
-0.18355907499790192,
-0.797691822052002,
0.2723810374736786,
0.22231139242649078,
0.6325227618217468,
0.29643628001213074,
0.02765350230038166,
-0.7047471404075623,
-0.7529823780059814,
-0.5322479605674744,
-0.444012850522995,
-0.03160868585109711,
0.39262160658836365,
0.22611835598945618,
-0.17828534543514252,
1.3385493755340576,
-0.3666574954986572,
-0.22282080352306366,
0.02811061218380928,
0.22618231177330017,
0.03851154446601868,
0.3211555480957031,
0.141199991106987,
-1.1476391553878784,
-0.46478888392448425,
0.17116984724998474,
-0.5713416337966919,
-0.5870987772941589,
-0.1115296483039856,
-0.1784759908914566,
0.2512519955635071,
0.35519859194755554,
-0.8819780945777893,
0.2698364853858948,
0.5496793389320374,
-0.20400762557983398,
0.27793025970458984,
-0.15025436878204346,
0.06793910264968872,
-0.9220531582832336,
0.019922884181141853,
-0.15458275377750397,
-0.3330225348472595,
-0.46199163794517517,
-0.02031284011900425,
0.21512489020824432,
-0.07718337327241898,
-0.30495283007621765,
0.8216555118560791,
-0.5177728533744812,
-0.18570782244205475,
-0.2170345038175583,
0.44855669140815735,
0.32224178314208984,
0.14627335965633392,
0.14238278567790985,
0.6520678400993347,
0.390320360660553,
-0.4662603735923767,
-0.062038734555244446,
0.30659690499305725,
-0.08315502852201462,
0.7027485370635986,
-0.5563841462135315,
0.1958026885986328,
-0.23921440541744232,
0.1656634658575058,
-1.0139882564544678,
-0.1113879606127739,
0.29822051525115967,
-0.39825475215911865,
0.23996791243553162,
-0.2647305428981781,
-0.3785330653190613,
-0.4679720401763916,
0.2123659998178482,
0.5279132723808289,
0.24228225648403168,
-0.45822933316230774,
0.8549348711967468,
0.2654849886894226,
-0.0803593173623085,
-1.2246047258377075,
-0.41811123490333557,
0.03777307644486427,
-0.2760668992996216,
-0.5778120160102844,
0.3704544007778168,
0.20585188269615173,
-0.09894102066755295,
0.18496838212013245,
-0.28640201687812805,
-0.2145565003156662,
-0.04354667291045189,
0.2452777475118637,
0.2504435181617737,
-0.029365086928009987,
0.43906059861183167,
-0.13558706641197205,
0.29224562644958496,
-0.1463497132062912,
-0.2507564127445221,
0.48195889592170715,
-0.07493114471435547,
-0.7503505945205688,
-0.3402913808822632,
0.21349312365055084,
0.5383214354515076,
-0.41607654094696045,
0.7886345386505127,
0.33484092354774475,
-0.43304961919784546,
0.04895465821027756,
-0.7384054064750671,
-0.08249761909246445,
-0.5272014141082764,
0.3652102053165436,
-0.5267992615699768,
-0.6982071399688721,
1.0320546627044678,
0.03399483859539032,
0.08166074007749557,
0.20851916074752808,
0.22596924006938934,
-0.38410845398902893,
1.2807629108428955,
0.5783897638320923,
0.15794865787029266,
0.4754581153392792,
0.40252870321273804,
0.40162792801856995,
-0.9014900326728821,
-0.21698260307312012,
-0.6912194490432739,
-0.1904638111591339,
-0.38403618335723877,
-0.23105010390281677,
0.25797250866889954,
0.2219509333372116,
-0.3310011923313141,
0.09341263025999069,
-0.3797803521156311,
0.5344341993331909,
0.05589783936738968,
-0.11949539184570312,
0.35114586353302,
-0.1659667193889618,
0.07997928559780121,
-0.0367654450237751,
-0.46709108352661133,
-0.6995527744293213,
1.0114647150039673,
0.2772708833217621,
0.7691935896873474,
0.3034304678440094,
0.5591908097267151,
0.059828802943229675,
0.0026485249400138855,
-0.5160533785820007,
0.16640247404575348,
0.18185952305793762,
-0.742490828037262,
-0.47586750984191895,
-0.3934359848499298,
-1.2096859216690063,
0.6272886395454407,
-0.19998565316200256,
-0.9516055583953857,
0.3009642958641052,
0.19894804060459137,
-0.4105040729045868,
0.14597085118293762,
-0.7759789824485779,
0.9286437630653381,
-0.2590705156326294,
-0.18774206936359406,
0.285118043422699,
-0.786696195602417,
0.1516341269016266,
-0.10132313519716263,
0.27335381507873535,
-0.24449768662452698,
-0.4065133333206177,
0.2644219398498535,
-0.5817355513572693,
0.7774344086647034,
-0.031035369262099266,
-0.2715110778808594,
0.2515629827976227,
0.07380650192499161,
0.9286201596260071,
-0.1827222853899002,
-0.17236630618572235,
-0.17834943532943726,
0.039795659482479095,
-0.44694676995277405,
-0.8985968232154846,
0.4241298735141754,
-0.7700614333152771,
-0.7772231101989746,
-0.41712576150894165,
-0.7005688548088074,
-0.4379798471927643,
0.1994393914937973,
0.18240198493003845,
-0.02700931578874588,
-0.1463737189769745,
-0.41569480299949646,
0.4712761342525482,
-0.012039540335536003,
0.15575450658798218,
0.8604166507720947,
-0.2578856647014618,
0.026716476306319237,
0.4273879826068878,
0.10500282794237137,
0.3743099272251129,
0.43166691064834595,
-0.011597045697271824,
-0.6167106032371521,
-0.5290570855140686,
-0.35546261072158813,
0.25483545660972595,
-0.6958165168762207,
-0.1476314514875412,
-0.6890870928764343,
-0.21458323299884796,
-0.48887205123901367,
-0.1406468003988266,
-0.3370894193649292,
-0.2241745889186859,
-0.3429129123687744,
-0.10989338159561157,
0.18079885840415955,
0.5828869938850403,
0.11201953142881393,
0.5803620219230652,
-0.5921136140823364,
0.005952467210590839,
0.28941819071769714,
0.20146428048610687,
-0.22066062688827515,
-0.7307062149047852,
-0.05547202005982399,
0.2072727233171463,
-0.29166707396507263,
-0.9951551556587219,
0.34967878460884094,
0.28102293610572815,
0.6711429357528687,
0.1959734410047531,
0.18959039449691772,
0.8829893469810486,
-0.44917479157447815,
0.5388808846473694,
-0.09107989072799683,
-1.0170304775238037,
0.48867398500442505,
-0.26586437225341797,
0.2879466116428375,
0.6016730666160583,
0.34184789657592773,
-0.8655063509941101,
-0.6972905397415161,
-0.43589919805526733,
-1.026064395904541,
0.5820055603981018,
0.22527308762073517,
0.20480555295944214,
-0.049082767218351364,
0.475957989692688,
-0.04563453048467636,
0.29173702001571655,
-0.7728968262672424,
-0.12760242819786072,
0.12123961001634598,
-0.44578105211257935,
0.32153624296188354,
-0.11713972687721252,
-0.19785591959953308,
0.060455042868852615,
0.4281538128852844,
-0.13686592876911163,
-0.13804253935813904,
0.12965109944343567,
-0.40536659955978394,
-0.3361879885196686,
0.3917827904224396,
0.48455217480659485,
1.171465516090393,
-0.2863856554031372,
0.2477644979953766,
0.05087299272418022,
-0.12756262719631195,
0.09521324932575226,
0.29898780584335327,
0.039468467235565186,
-0.20418797433376312,
0.12918028235435486,
0.4991579055786133,
0.0175454281270504,
-0.8630140423774719,
0.49381133913993835,
0.009863605722784996,
0.3713976740837097,
-0.1886051446199417,
-0.22950007021427155,
0.008281120099127293,
0.06885775923728943,
0.4575653076171875,
0.060837626457214355,
0.01837211847305298,
-0.309883713722229,
0.1326998919248581,
0.5641921758651733,
-0.3647797405719757,
-0.1572122722864151,
0.5366381406784058,
0.2881212532520294,
-0.260149210691452,
0.643813967704773,
-0.03377270698547363,
-0.5351531505584717,
0.6886602640151978,
0.4836762845516205,
0.5601232647895813,
-0.4539961814880371,
0.07160032540559769,
-0.12509827315807343,
0.5388752222061157,
0.0007556172204203904,
0.29226595163345337,
0.16912385821342468,
-1.0722737312316895,
-0.29389768838882446,
-0.3937086760997772,
-0.5290451049804688,
-0.00789732113480568,
-0.6964928507804871,
0.3367736339569092,
-0.1584828495979309,
-0.19252172112464905,
0.08260773122310638,
-0.186052143573761,
-0.6370581984519958,
0.07771266251802444,
0.21128474175930023,
0.6693917512893677,
-1.0464552640914917,
0.7281409502029419,
0.8620023131370544,
-0.4706302285194397,
-0.8626444339752197,
-0.182633176445961,
0.004999528639018536,
-0.8824276924133301,
0.2006971687078476,
0.04739338532090187,
-0.13854128122329712,
-0.2755943834781647,
-0.27339762449264526,
-0.9384116530418396,
0.8294111490249634,
0.6549310684204102,
-0.597171425819397,
-0.05718366056680679,
0.40355536341667175,
0.6999173164367676,
-0.5250453352928162,
0.3135361075401306,
0.48150280117988586,
0.534116268157959,
0.2187570482492447,
-1.1574492454528809,
-0.03345278277993202,
-0.03161540627479553,
-0.02955317497253418,
0.44633033871650696,
-0.41779688000679016,
0.8006746172904968,
-0.16386431455612183,
-0.2669861614704132,
0.09727256745100021,
0.5789746046066284,
0.25354424118995667,
0.3851952850818634,
0.45981836318969727,
0.7302805781364441,
1.2047951221466064,
-0.1025337353348732,
0.8318004608154297,
0.023015672340989113,
0.2665502727031708,
1.618452548980713,
-0.7323194742202759,
0.9032076001167297,
0.6512399911880493,
-0.16651181876659393,
0.4075367748737335,
0.9584229588508606,
0.35261180996894836,
0.29331091046333313,
-0.03178505226969719,
-0.22891290485858917,
-0.41388270258903503,
-0.11834987998008728,
-0.4631257951259613,
0.4243415594100952,
0.7400298714637756,
-0.29776298999786377,
-0.3068089187145233,
-0.1831102967262268,
-0.14519384503364563,
0.552350640296936,
-0.16112542152404785,
0.7058678269386292,
-0.04031291604042053,
-0.7706713080406189,
0.46344882249832153,
-0.051313042640686035,
0.49773845076560974,
-0.5781232118606567,
0.18053507804870605,
-0.10602681338787079,
-0.10888192057609558,
-0.33575496077537537,
-1.0533620119094849,
0.3493531346321106,
-0.32842379808425903,
-0.1525983214378357,
0.040218327194452286,
0.44060683250427246,
-0.6683982610702515,
-0.28842973709106445,
0.2376146912574768,
0.5538868308067322,
0.14131495356559753,
-0.14878615736961365,
-0.8264000415802002,
0.03854287788271904,
-0.2045356035232544,
0.0625675618648529,
0.08388006687164307,
0.7531318068504333,
-0.22378788888454437,
0.79832923412323,
0.1764429807662964,
0.14651140570640564,
0.3754254877567291,
0.11002551019191742,
0.6416014432907104,
-0.30863717198371887,
-0.4174503982067108,
-0.7975134253501892,
0.26936787366867065,
-0.08166700601577759,
-0.302125483751297,
0.4352504014968872,
0.39988771080970764,
0.6099000573158264,
0.34692618250846863,
0.583476722240448,
0.08058729022741318,
0.3899456858634949,
-0.33337822556495667,
0.32986971735954285,
-0.6721444129943848,
0.587967038154602,
-0.18153336644172668,
-0.9606465101242065,
-0.2410198599100113,
0.415314644575119,
-0.5791580080986023,
0.14893393218517303,
0.3290588855743408,
0.7582559585571289,
-0.0645582377910614,
-0.1397986263036728,
0.2013174444437027,
0.01558986958116293,
0.4166274070739746,
0.6626997590065002,
1.0498615503311157,
-0.24771267175674438,
0.6941936612129211,
0.015117209404706955,
0.09582845121622086,
-0.2574641704559326,
-0.8712648749351501,
-0.48578956723213196,
-0.6094334125518799,
-0.275104820728302,
-0.06486231833696365,
0.24069304764270782,
0.951542854309082,
0.6720829606056213,
-0.5479781031608582,
-0.14653469622135162,
-0.10409102588891983,
0.6106897592544556,
-0.22608554363250732,
-0.21736903488636017,
0.2901438772678375,
-0.5748858451843262,
-1.0407326221466064,
0.0936632752418518,
0.20738859474658966,
0.3138299584388733,
-0.11307325214147568,
-0.075538270175457,
-0.4043653905391693,
0.3470795452594757,
0.10339031368494034,
0.6648223400115967,
-0.8615807294845581,
-0.3984513580799103,
-0.12670789659023285,
-0.3810896873474121,
0.13741859793663025,
0.5232430100440979,
-0.7052672505378723,
0.6686254143714905,
0.347129225730896,
0.7349947690963745,
0.1925450712442398,
0.38636475801467896,
0.9390735626220703,
-1.056705117225647,
0.1740265041589737,
0.3847463130950928,
0.22297315299510956,
0.44957831501960754,
-0.7047700881958008,
0.4002573788166046,
-0.34444114565849304,
-0.6126625537872314,
-1.0384008884429932,
0.4234021008014679,
-0.8204935789108276,
-0.24071960151195526,
0.9243273735046387,
-0.14875167608261108,
-0.12280966341495514,
-0.35417836904525757,
-0.06418262422084808,
0.11706430464982986,
-0.3348056972026825,
0.8520506024360657,
0.8731714487075806,
-0.09477339684963226,
-0.14741213619709015,
-0.3952447772026062,
0.532658576965332,
0.8629266023635864,
-0.6279431581497192,
0.2532380521297455,
0.3991534113883972,
0.128607377409935,
0.11455149948596954,
0.4793281555175781,
0.0060806586407125,
0.18991516530513763,
-0.5435290336608887,
0.12507495284080505,
0.13471560180187225,
-0.21611636877059937,
-0.40246349573135376,
0.024381767958402634,
0.30250898003578186,
-0.30113789439201355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11968v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11968v1
|
P-NAL: an Effective and Interpretable Entity Alignment Method
| 2024-04-18T07:55:02 | 2024-04-18T07:55:02 |
Chuanhao Xu, Jingwei Cheng, Fu Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.4
|
Entity alignment (EA) aims to find equivalent entities between two Knowledge
Graphs. Existing embedding-based EA methods usually encode entities as
embeddings, triples as embeddings' constraint and learn to align the
embeddings. The structural and side information are usually utilized via
embedding propagation, aggregation or interaction. However, the details of the
underlying logical inference steps among the alignment process are usually
omitted, resulting in inadequate inference process. In this paper, we introduce
P-NAL, an entity alignment method that captures two types of logical inference
paths with Non-Axiomatic Logic (NAL). Type 1 is the bridge-like inference path
between to-be-aligned entity pairs, consisting of two relation/attribute
triples and a similarity sentence between the other two entities. Type 2 links
the entity pair by their embeddings. P-NAL iteratively aligns entities and
relations by integrating the conclusions of the inference paths. Moreover, our
method is logically interpretable and extensible due to the expressiveness of
NAL. Our proposed method is suitable for various EA settings. Experimental
results show that our method outperforms state-of-the-art methods in terms of
Hits@1, achieving 0.98+ on all three datasets of DBP15K with both supervised
and unsupervised settings. To our knowledge, we present the first in-depth
analysis of entity alignment's basic principles from a unified logical
perspective.
|
[
-0.28379562497138977,
-0.8970558047294617,
0.5419436097145081,
0.12616519629955292,
-0.1354164034128189,
0.016856839880347252,
0.06247617304325104,
-0.30326318740844727,
0.46647733449935913,
0.3813250660896301,
-0.562217652797699,
-0.5668219327926636,
-0.08740295469760895,
-0.09518789499998093,
-0.17311233282089233,
0.9334214925765991,
-0.17844676971435547,
-0.05055784806609154,
-0.20439615845680237,
-0.1480073779821396,
-0.40214449167251587,
0.1073959544301033,
-0.38303136825561523,
-0.2840098440647125,
0.2867593467235565,
0.2861310541629791,
0.8495030999183655,
0.8068957924842834,
0.4005051255226135,
0.1478203386068344,
0.1246415376663208,
0.3896534740924835,
-0.2726304531097412,
-0.09488862752914429,
-0.547773540019989,
-0.3116668462753296,
-0.7897641062736511,
-0.23611539602279663,
0.6928110122680664,
0.951227068901062,
-0.3041831851005554,
0.14257875084877014,
0.2076689600944519,
0.5993571281433105,
-0.7885160446166992,
0.19919739663600922,
-0.5888420343399048,
0.08781050145626068,
-0.3671877086162567,
-0.022466713562607765,
-0.5770633220672607,
-0.34260302782058716,
0.3137454688549042,
-1.033478856086731,
-0.21621987223625183,
0.47170671820640564,
1.2029571533203125,
0.39101457595825195,
-0.7637029886245728,
-0.3055257201194763,
-0.2425299733877182,
0.87105792760849,
-0.6102578639984131,
0.5000492930412292,
-0.07288466393947601,
0.43669840693473816,
-0.05163747817277908,
-0.5353005528450012,
-0.7046645879745483,
0.39005792140960693,
-0.274514764547348,
0.03113933838903904,
0.013959772884845734,
0.2231329381465912,
0.0028732051141560078,
0.33624547719955444,
-0.5507097244262695,
0.018613260239362717,
0.01120482012629509,
-0.179266557097435,
0.639232337474823,
0.06704246252775192,
0.5125644207000732,
0.10393428802490234,
-0.991288959980011,
0.1875525265932083,
-0.9103445410728455,
-0.3760562241077423,
0.2996475398540497,
0.2678501307964325,
0.05836224555969238,
0.660294771194458,
0.08310038596391678,
0.7406613230705261,
0.36386796832084656,
-0.26077133417129517,
0.43301036953926086,
-0.3833006024360657,
-0.22296151518821716,
0.43889331817626953,
0.6432091593742371,
0.6037516593933105,
0.20982325077056885,
-0.3895927965641022,
-0.2268063873052597,
-0.011963140219449997,
0.21023403108119965,
-0.4868602454662323,
-0.37750309705734253,
0.05675918236374855,
-0.5223373770713806,
-0.1379864364862442,
0.24841929972171783,
-0.9875974655151367,
-0.3953601121902466,
-0.42714452743530273,
0.4889630377292633,
-0.5004180669784546,
-0.5660925507545471,
0.11549396067857742,
0.16105784475803375,
0.8268957734107971,
0.3287687599658966,
-0.5429153442382812,
0.5364807844161987,
0.7638843655586243,
0.7807894349098206,
-0.15520702302455902,
-0.25023695826530457,
-0.4114600419998169,
0.5111175775527954,
-0.5276378989219666,
0.6123562455177307,
-0.26866284012794495,
0.23821187019348145,
-0.031428512185811996,
-0.2008313685655594,
-0.2586401700973511,
-0.2958020269870758,
0.7156241536140442,
-0.8236497640609741,
-0.035896625369787216,
-0.26632750034332275,
-1.1056230068206787,
-0.45392748713493347,
-0.0032145807053893805,
-0.5939576029777527,
0.7440120577812195,
-0.11039065569639206,
-0.8588515520095825,
0.5900776982307434,
-0.7228062748908997,
-0.2891550064086914,
-0.11626623570919037,
-0.21010544896125793,
-0.48298928141593933,
-0.1915484368801117,
0.36425215005874634,
0.0031089764088392258,
-0.4468103051185608,
0.4265521764755249,
-0.5320809483528137,
-0.08399759978055954,
0.003368185833096504,
-0.15069761872291565,
1.0234670639038086,
0.19060645997524261,
-0.5594813823699951,
-0.07709339261054993,
-0.5156312584877014,
0.22998006641864777,
0.2069665789604187,
-0.0010199384996667504,
-0.3008379340171814,
0.01126090344041586,
-0.143678218126297,
0.3499818742275238,
0.4479847848415375,
-0.5297756195068359,
0.42759227752685547,
-0.5739667415618896,
0.09747600555419922,
0.5403835773468018,
0.33535337448120117,
0.9113985896110535,
-0.12525855004787445,
0.29527631402015686,
0.12067330628633499,
0.006351313088089228,
0.3531336486339569,
-0.4844672977924347,
-0.456443190574646,
-0.18826539814472198,
0.5635197162628174,
0.7682477235794067,
-0.8839766383171082,
0.5323382616043091,
-0.434148371219635,
-0.3884222209453583,
-0.6870667338371277,
0.26831722259521484,
0.602552592754364,
0.940379798412323,
0.5212132930755615,
-0.11547645926475525,
-0.5112403035163879,
-1.1228044033050537,
-0.3948230743408203,
-0.19463926553726196,
0.12270258367061615,
0.1312265247106552,
0.36352232098579407,
0.28307104110717773,
0.8834909796714783,
-0.4837600290775299,
-0.30014652013778687,
0.040509339421987534,
0.00845839362591505,
-0.00036477894173003733,
0.5357657670974731,
0.47032400965690613,
-0.687739908695221,
-0.46014824509620667,
-0.23170389235019684,
-0.9931700825691223,
-0.31595495343208313,
-0.25607314705848694,
-0.5792391300201416,
0.09902041405439377,
0.2533980906009674,
-0.5175695419311523,
0.4278002679347992,
0.003636628156527877,
-0.5725091695785522,
-0.0024869642220437527,
0.11970207095146179,
-0.06793860346078873,
-0.6965808272361755,
-0.0806942731142044,
0.05844598636031151,
-0.12453228235244751,
-0.6613473892211914,
-0.018408330157399178,
0.2068687230348587,
0.025740642100572586,
-0.1984688937664032,
0.3560926914215088,
-0.8887445330619812,
-0.33484888076782227,
0.026357263326644897,
0.4073040783405304,
0.25969192385673523,
0.34285908937454224,
0.3478127717971802,
0.39599743485450745,
0.7129740118980408,
-0.4919221103191376,
0.15716883540153503,
0.655250608921051,
-0.23456189036369324,
1.003761887550354,
-0.3061349093914032,
0.3308413028717041,
-0.14859431982040405,
0.3359174430370331,
-0.6721063852310181,
0.23087194561958313,
0.591211199760437,
-0.23084747791290283,
0.5222533941268921,
-0.21104544401168823,
-0.38766947388648987,
0.08176431804895401,
-0.08183582872152328,
0.4187186658382416,
0.056159086525440216,
-0.677780270576477,
0.9732475280761719,
0.36456573009490967,
0.13141532242298126,
-0.710784375667572,
-0.7328792810440063,
0.12813861668109894,
-0.4422903060913086,
-0.8553602695465088,
0.6159221529960632,
0.41825631260871887,
-0.38232100009918213,
0.36874252557754517,
-0.3560323715209961,
-0.15080411732196808,
0.05734376981854439,
0.18790654838085175,
0.4984370470046997,
-0.6770671010017395,
0.06015901640057564,
0.0740538015961647,
-0.1685483753681183,
-0.004732893779873848,
-0.5503879189491272,
0.10575249046087265,
-0.2676031291484833,
-0.5522673726081848,
-0.7628397345542908,
0.32498699426651,
0.3022207021713257,
-0.464472234249115,
0.9348269104957581,
0.20703484117984772,
-0.7002738118171692,
-0.1408756524324417,
-0.3993287980556488,
0.026491915807127953,
-0.3704158067703247,
-0.04259166866540909,
-0.5482096672058105,
-0.03160660341382027,
0.1891547292470932,
-0.2472427487373352,
0.3662279546260834,
0.40633922815322876,
0.11607299745082855,
-0.04232923313975334,
0.8241029381752014,
0.28020021319389343,
0.09346047788858414,
0.007939527742564678,
-0.05622024089097977,
0.616840660572052,
-0.8787117004394531,
-0.45481663942337036,
-0.1989496946334839,
-0.5515049695968628,
-0.3049792945384979,
-0.23114904761314392,
0.06490510702133179,
0.5445540547370911,
-0.6022689342498779,
0.3927389681339264,
-0.41544654965400696,
0.28631359338760376,
0.3087918758392334,
0.11923347413539886,
0.2708759605884552,
-0.19047681987285614,
-0.02394358441233635,
-0.26261046528816223,
-0.4894842505455017,
-0.5633240342140198,
1.1401549577713013,
0.2305205762386322,
0.605888843536377,
0.6647754311561584,
0.9125452041625977,
-0.05815941095352173,
0.34335264563560486,
-0.6277902126312256,
0.33805203437805176,
0.31158047914505005,
-0.7436123490333557,
-0.30582502484321594,
-0.3219194710254669,
-0.5544468760490417,
0.14626121520996094,
-0.38209033012390137,
-0.9183568954467773,
0.4929148554801941,
0.1560792475938797,
-0.371437132358551,
0.50860196352005,
-0.8846275806427002,
1.0770810842514038,
-0.5954927802085876,
-0.42201727628707886,
0.21466489136219025,
-0.8018171191215515,
0.26023751497268677,
0.11211677640676498,
0.07094895094633102,
0.2038128674030304,
-0.6273930072784424,
0.5121290683746338,
-0.5509195923805237,
0.3937327563762665,
-0.5686243772506714,
-0.13580387830734253,
0.46493515372276306,
0.18520890176296234,
0.6555357575416565,
0.0790020301938057,
-0.016253415495157242,
0.0013580115046352148,
-0.07833414524793625,
-0.5794200897216797,
-1.0530425310134888,
0.5956205725669861,
-0.445345014333725,
-0.5045178532600403,
-0.39296382665634155,
-0.5195863842964172,
-0.39869651198387146,
0.24350856244564056,
-0.06285735219717026,
0.2317361682653427,
0.1425844132900238,
0.12966232001781464,
0.682170569896698,
-0.15401838719844818,
0.09849844872951508,
0.5933283567428589,
-0.4281015694141388,
-0.2712444067001343,
0.9883760809898376,
0.07909689843654633,
0.25260818004608154,
0.6787815690040588,
-0.24132294952869415,
-0.760140061378479,
-0.43184179067611694,
-0.6171340346336365,
0.1872519999742508,
-0.6061634421348572,
-0.2602692246437073,
-0.6493313908576965,
0.08157982677221298,
-0.3397957384586334,
-0.3095282316207886,
-0.4847621023654938,
-0.25343644618988037,
-0.06722317636013031,
-0.1393451690673828,
0.07028532773256302,
0.31550297141075134,
-0.08021224290132523,
-0.18241462111473083,
-0.32654690742492676,
0.2949593961238861,
-0.07999467104673386,
0.19099469482898712,
-0.0452740378677845,
-0.18925563991069794,
0.39580920338630676,
-0.07434672862291336,
-0.2443263977766037,
-1.5550507307052612,
0.04048754274845123,
0.49502989649772644,
0.44342899322509766,
0.7869074940681458,
0.24803996086120605,
0.7348304390907288,
-0.20100940763950348,
0.2995448708534241,
0.10793229937553406,
-1.0269463062286377,
0.5376957058906555,
0.03228612616658211,
-0.506500244140625,
0.6270509362220764,
0.2945616841316223,
-0.09078224003314972,
0.24226956069469452,
-0.7163687944412231,
-0.9142720699310303,
0.3360864222049713,
0.20930933952331543,
-0.5799076557159424,
0.025472616776823997,
0.32797771692276,
-0.22883710265159607,
0.13592320680618286,
-0.6412275433540344,
-0.6527367830276489,
-0.28283169865608215,
-0.4411427974700928,
0.3478262424468994,
0.10279089212417603,
0.01019957009702921,
-0.0316777303814888,
1.0388810634613037,
-0.11680049449205399,
0.07682955265045166,
0.18578623235225677,
-0.41173073649406433,
0.01361971814185381,
0.21879860758781433,
-0.08603380620479584,
0.8727063536643982,
-0.14480428397655487,
0.15639907121658325,
0.24016880989074707,
0.10976861417293549,
0.1549348086118698,
0.16848132014274597,
-0.35676315426826477,
-0.04400220140814781,
0.20820198953151703,
0.4748574495315552,
0.38080283999443054,
-0.30856987833976746,
0.8461500406265259,
0.27637779712677,
-0.11710979044437408,
-0.24116632342338562,
-0.3957536816596985,
0.4770910441875458,
0.3048710525035858,
-0.01439624186605215,
-0.21512547135353088,
0.23436369001865387,
-0.3481444716453552,
0.3664078712463379,
0.4671694040298462,
-0.4356413185596466,
0.06537696719169617,
0.7095010280609131,
0.1215759739279747,
0.005925252567976713,
0.8449198603630066,
-0.5767841935157776,
-0.3221099376678467,
0.46591225266456604,
0.6344830393791199,
0.46030759811401367,
-0.032547686249017715,
0.29265713691711426,
0.294823557138443,
0.3955400884151459,
0.20336763560771942,
0.2872641086578369,
0.14212356507778168,
-0.833803653717041,
-0.5069622993469238,
-0.5815957188606262,
-0.08967278897762299,
-0.054311249405145645,
-1.0337775945663452,
0.23301352560520172,
-0.2832985520362854,
0.3292529582977295,
0.27395594120025635,
0.12215019762516022,
-0.7248615622520447,
0.08359943330287933,
-0.07555114477872849,
0.9669328331947327,
-1.0858192443847656,
0.7479279041290283,
1.0280684232711792,
-0.6859881281852722,
-1.2087918519973755,
0.05632263049483299,
0.639476478099823,
-0.7412053346633911,
0.50486159324646,
-0.12894649803638458,
0.176295205950737,
0.10737528651952744,
-0.1509838104248047,
-0.8734650611877441,
1.4716594219207764,
0.46971625089645386,
-0.6516009569168091,
-0.3278263211250305,
0.004661255981773138,
0.227369487285614,
-0.43545886874198914,
-0.06606719642877579,
0.5955947637557983,
0.6698320508003235,
-0.17646627128124237,
-0.7380951642990112,
0.36806970834732056,
-0.13024577498435974,
-0.10060115903615952,
0.7059163451194763,
-0.4370611906051636,
0.5775129199028015,
-0.012240511365234852,
-0.470528244972229,
-0.019653722643852234,
0.8510634303092957,
0.1434161514043808,
0.38896822929382324,
0.746377170085907,
1.031808853149414,
1.0802254676818848,
-0.13072875142097473,
0.6554158926010132,
-0.4110846221446991,
0.49042612314224243,
1.300223469734192,
-0.492715984582901,
0.4318089485168457,
0.5856090784072876,
-0.14174626767635345,
0.49203944206237793,
0.45534759759902954,
-0.0185843538492918,
0.5863068103790283,
0.12733322381973267,
-0.23800408840179443,
-0.36849257349967957,
-0.16292200982570648,
-0.2546371519565582,
0.3239750564098358,
0.34414294362068176,
-0.4242333471775055,
-0.458692342042923,
-0.47770336270332336,
-0.022211425006389618,
0.13824959099292755,
-0.26352229714393616,
0.8317280411720276,
0.08954717218875885,
-0.6852627396583557,
0.07627221196889877,
-0.17578192055225372,
0.3261703848838806,
-0.02473398856818676,
-0.36680254340171814,
0.15276247262954712,
0.04711490869522095,
-0.4209079444408417,
-0.8679820895195007,
0.4298812747001648,
-0.19007521867752075,
-0.10711674392223358,
-0.1387425810098648,
0.8333247303962708,
-0.3962990343570709,
-0.10593614727258682,
0.29846999049186707,
0.6508931517601013,
0.1948121190071106,
-0.011416745372116566,
-0.9111329317092896,
-0.5081075429916382,
0.0011040521785616875,
-0.08923327177762985,
0.21353565156459808,
0.7585951685905457,
-0.16318577527999878,
0.4047994613647461,
0.3478793501853943,
0.09884703904390335,
-0.026495730504393578,
-0.13771238923072815,
0.3996961712837219,
-0.36099523305892944,
-0.3235582411289215,
-0.6746346950531006,
0.392131507396698,
-0.22336871922016144,
-0.2672083377838135,
0.4617246389389038,
0.6998690962791443,
0.6694162487983704,
0.391371488571167,
0.46231523156166077,
-0.2227623015642166,
0.3918614983558655,
-0.7294574975967407,
0.44726359844207764,
-0.3807847499847412,
0.2703615427017212,
-0.34664255380630493,
-1.0794938802719116,
-0.09535403549671173,
0.7145211696624756,
-0.5815209746360779,
-0.11954901367425919,
0.8763067722320557,
0.8578531742095947,
-0.15029318630695343,
0.22032009065151215,
-0.1807565540075302,
0.11550917476415634,
-0.01951518841087818,
0.8625597953796387,
0.5782089233398438,
-0.38521331548690796,
0.5944083333015442,
-0.3609313368797302,
-0.21774183213710785,
0.15993474423885345,
-0.9539604187011719,
-0.4404417872428894,
-0.45821651816368103,
-0.595665454864502,
-0.5675298571586609,
0.07126413285732269,
0.768692672252655,
0.26225608587265015,
-0.6739540696144104,
0.3911767303943634,
-0.276593953371048,
0.23251177370548248,
-0.46900272369384766,
-0.3015691936016083,
0.7138919830322266,
-0.02867879346013069,
-0.4240214228630066,
0.2492036074399948,
0.4042481780052185,
-0.35332006216049194,
0.032179780304431915,
-0.23659583926200867,
-0.6517524719238281,
-0.14034058153629303,
-0.0730561912059784,
0.37961822748184204,
-0.830531656742096,
-0.29235321283340454,
-0.1388758420944214,
0.08643995225429535,
0.22918462753295898,
0.4599032998085022,
-0.2889993488788605,
0.3450397849082947,
0.31674492359161377,
0.9863069653511047,
0.12551595270633698,
0.34970030188560486,
0.5339987277984619,
-0.6319586038589478,
-0.2969038486480713,
0.2528696060180664,
0.5813888907432556,
0.3180178105831146,
-0.20428401231765747,
0.5532163977622986,
0.04308756813406944,
-0.44907036423683167,
-0.6691443920135498,
0.3274118900299072,
-0.8184705972671509,
0.008103636093437672,
0.9222641587257385,
-0.5055347681045532,
-0.2219686061143875,
-0.173197939991951,
-0.03437959775328636,
0.5476614236831665,
-0.27113068103790283,
0.39018478989601135,
0.5118553042411804,
-0.25675708055496216,
-0.032374877482652664,
-0.38625115156173706,
0.27027687430381775,
0.4912125766277313,
-0.8215545415878296,
-0.34730264544487,
0.4794454574584961,
0.33252188563346863,
0.3240021765232086,
0.3974127173423767,
-0.3063317537307739,
0.22563648223876953,
0.146966353058815,
0.07077275216579437,
0.11768987029790878,
-0.23550306260585785,
-0.08273985236883163,
0.20289434492588043,
0.05616694688796997,
-0.2577502727508545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11932v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11932v2
|
CrossIn: An Efficient Instruction Tuning Approach for Cross-Lingual Knowledge Alignment
| 2024-04-18T06:20:50 | 2024-06-12T09:35:48 |
Geyu Lin, Bin Wang, Zhengyuan Liu, Nancy F. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multilingual proficiency presents a significant challenge for large language
models (LLMs). English-centric models are usually suboptimal in other
languages, particularly those that are linguistically distant from English.
This performance discrepancy mainly stems from the imbalanced distribution of
training data across languages during pre-training and instruction tuning
stages. To address this problem, we propose a novel approach called CrossIn,
which utilizes a mixed composition of cross-lingual instruction tuning data.
Our method leverages the compressed representation shared by various languages
to efficiently enhance the model's task-solving capabilities and multilingual
proficiency within a single process. In addition, we introduce a multi-task and
multi-faceted benchmark to evaluate the effectiveness of CrossIn. Experimental
results demonstrate that our method substantially improves performance across
tasks and languages, and we provide extensive insights into the impact of
cross-lingual data volume and the integration of translation data on enhancing
multilingual consistency and accuracy.
|
[
-0.14027716219425201,
-0.4947068691253662,
0.11835748702287674,
0.16552114486694336,
-0.0037355313543230295,
0.3663231432437897,
-0.605217456817627,
-0.4614579379558563,
0.23124583065509796,
0.13862234354019165,
-0.5897147059440613,
-0.6175178289413452,
-0.5949447751045227,
-0.0446305088698864,
-0.013921044766902924,
0.6660983562469482,
-0.2058735191822052,
0.535609781742096,
-0.4109068214893341,
-0.2976740598678589,
-0.5962488651275635,
-0.17070099711418152,
-0.5367547273635864,
-0.45776164531707764,
0.6578934192657471,
0.752203643321991,
0.5880749821662903,
0.8638825416564941,
0.2154136747121811,
0.29922348260879517,
0.5170732736587524,
0.560729444026947,
-0.5088387727737427,
-0.1421320140361786,
-0.2740788757801056,
-0.6513470411300659,
-0.5303332209587097,
-0.056981056928634644,
0.7362450957298279,
0.8787282109260559,
-0.04838091507554054,
-0.07077395915985107,
0.2648054361343384,
0.41606152057647705,
-0.771012544631958,
0.0026032307650893927,
-0.4578211009502411,
-0.01059828232973814,
-0.4668028652667999,
-0.3088679909706116,
-0.3998900055885315,
0.052615635097026825,
-0.169348806142807,
-0.936648964881897,
0.17032243311405182,
0.1692676544189453,
0.7232736945152283,
0.12889748811721802,
-0.33612754940986633,
-0.12182702124118805,
-0.4361625015735626,
1.1593888998031616,
-0.7254005670547485,
0.8517314195632935,
0.25215834379196167,
0.1258823424577713,
0.22084935009479523,
-0.1800733357667923,
-0.22344368696212769,
0.17333458364009857,
-0.20922526717185974,
0.24070988595485687,
0.15108871459960938,
-0.20896132290363312,
-0.02277754433453083,
0.25930097699165344,
-0.7219314575195312,
0.4400257468223572,
-0.23727156221866608,
-0.2523390054702759,
0.7506850361824036,
0.08443064987659454,
0.5985205173492432,
0.2930688261985779,
-0.2617014944553375,
-0.20439717173576355,
-0.8035316467285156,
0.09087902307510376,
0.5668929219245911,
0.5459704399108887,
-0.2563493251800537,
0.5457229614257812,
-0.11113446205854416,
0.7505490183830261,
0.2250077873468399,
-0.2853041887283325,
0.272002249956131,
-0.4853518009185791,
0.10182718932628632,
0.32222309708595276,
0.5709787011146545,
0.4498918354511261,
0.36294105648994446,
-0.2716456949710846,
-0.14937536418437958,
-0.25563064217567444,
0.23528335988521576,
-0.5765160918235779,
-0.052500393241643906,
0.03491836041212082,
-0.1501443088054657,
0.2170775979757309,
-0.14889800548553467,
-0.6788673400878906,
-0.006718742195516825,
-0.528859555721283,
0.27189555764198303,
-0.48245397210121155,
-0.12335214018821716,
-0.03373134136199951,
0.39417797327041626,
0.18598118424415588,
0.10522281378507614,
-1.0686525106430054,
0.057160165160894394,
0.8902726173400879,
0.6256877183914185,
-0.4420740604400635,
-0.780122697353363,
-0.7042427062988281,
0.3459450900554657,
-0.4003148376941681,
0.4984961152076721,
-0.8536364436149597,
-0.06495869904756546,
0.10078569501638412,
0.30983394384384155,
-0.5320175290107727,
-0.5403338074684143,
0.016607724130153656,
-0.4410172700881958,
0.2371980994939804,
-0.2554131746292114,
-0.7791958451271057,
-0.1919805407524109,
0.24008658528327942,
-0.6818389892578125,
1.214200496673584,
0.04161984845995903,
-0.7944785952568054,
0.36169835925102234,
-0.2635762691497803,
-0.6981614232063293,
-0.1059333011507988,
-0.1588497906923294,
-0.2712062895298004,
0.04833130165934563,
0.45730146765708923,
0.3935522139072418,
-0.4228307008743286,
0.12553736567497253,
-0.032030414789915085,
-0.4606006145477295,
-0.189059317111969,
-0.12906934320926666,
0.6019863486289978,
-0.07256878912448883,
-0.3210129141807556,
0.08312474936246872,
-0.6410083174705505,
0.2609028220176697,
-0.12175678461790085,
-0.12985779345035553,
-0.7435444593429565,
-0.34644225239753723,
-0.10024136304855347,
0.09316357225179672,
0.6429692506790161,
-0.6071875095367432,
0.06649580597877502,
-0.24774731695652008,
-0.05625717714428902,
0.5446202754974365,
-0.472481906414032,
0.5373499989509583,
-0.32256874442100525,
0.5947167873382568,
0.3223685920238495,
0.16731785237789154,
-0.10722196847200394,
-0.3533163368701935,
-0.7657231688499451,
-0.10413095355033875,
0.5249265432357788,
1.0483359098434448,
-0.8748630285263062,
0.19731292128562927,
-0.518229067325592,
-0.43339595198631287,
-0.8511574864387512,
0.5758072733879089,
0.719365656375885,
0.3057720959186554,
0.4404093027114868,
-0.17485736310482025,
-0.4227861166000366,
-1.0453144311904907,
-0.5542087554931641,
0.22807347774505615,
0.11012940853834152,
0.22378692030906677,
0.18869374692440033,
-0.16704784333705902,
0.27676090598106384,
-0.06611137837171555,
0.02217436209321022,
-0.27609720826148987,
0.2681223154067993,
-0.09233399480581284,
0.7704710960388184,
0.23610401153564453,
-0.587981104850769,
-0.956069827079773,
0.6113079190254211,
-0.6400477886199951,
-0.22702747583389282,
-0.047715768218040466,
-0.5523918867111206,
0.35971638560295105,
0.48241153359413147,
-0.14193855226039886,
0.1210111752152443,
0.831838846206665,
-0.07284187525510788,
0.1635843962430954,
-0.2540857791900635,
0.598321795463562,
-1.162379264831543,
-0.08059383928775787,
-0.0009313265909440815,
-0.22921597957611084,
-0.5693115592002869,
-0.11495499312877655,
0.4462820589542389,
0.040661439299583435,
-0.4513865113258362,
0.393414705991745,
-0.6085274815559387,
0.0910324677824974,
-0.1120629832148552,
0.24658116698265076,
-0.013920221477746964,
0.533545970916748,
0.14665821194648743,
0.9760806560516357,
0.6273494362831116,
-0.26744693517684937,
0.3321559429168701,
0.033938899636268616,
-0.2677496373653412,
0.8371480107307434,
-0.554479718208313,
0.09414957463741302,
-0.0666905865073204,
-0.3053978383541107,
-0.5535212755203247,
-0.05848310887813568,
0.017796920612454414,
-0.0603916309773922,
0.8596594333648682,
-0.1431170552968979,
-0.2892801761627197,
0.27971091866493225,
-0.09084276854991913,
0.8455237150192261,
0.1191241666674614,
-0.5321629643440247,
0.8578128218650818,
0.32830262184143066,
-0.19234085083007812,
-0.7890637516975403,
-0.6090430617332458,
-0.1705915778875351,
-0.024166420102119446,
-0.7784593105316162,
0.5475243330001831,
0.01201644167304039,
-0.06746236234903336,
-0.01579575426876545,
-0.18640786409378052,
0.0653965026140213,
-0.326241135597229,
-0.12101157754659653,
0.2265845388174057,
-0.3260810673236847,
-0.06846099346876144,
0.37171128392219543,
-0.10890469700098038,
-0.25788381695747375,
-0.41664567589759827,
0.2216908484697342,
0.22486639022827148,
-0.5660199522972107,
-0.1701606810092926,
0.7900132536888123,
0.4279137849807739,
-0.40685707330703735,
0.7689305543899536,
0.48773109912872314,
-0.2710174024105072,
-0.5173555612564087,
-0.5756749510765076,
0.018706059083342552,
-0.3996216058731079,
0.4588741362094879,
-0.40847694873809814,
-0.7560420036315918,
0.5070499181747437,
-0.048863623291254044,
0.29588761925697327,
0.05541590228676796,
0.3500416576862335,
0.05138628929853439,
1.0579850673675537,
0.844799280166626,
-0.18164831399917603,
0.4074588418006897,
0.009019868448376656,
0.29677921533584595,
-0.5878892540931702,
-0.35558512806892395,
-0.3019498288631439,
-0.5092464089393616,
-0.5428908467292786,
-0.6359965801239014,
0.39431291818618774,
0.014661450870335102,
0.05027239769697189,
0.46523284912109375,
-0.1325691044330597,
0.574158251285553,
0.5974065065383911,
0.12251678109169006,
0.1737610250711441,
0.09996646642684937,
-0.2607773542404175,
-0.3783547878265381,
-1.1443413496017456,
-0.10165204107761383,
1.0543787479400635,
0.06301340460777283,
0.8092617988586426,
-0.1101144477725029,
0.7067113518714905,
-0.046818431466817856,
0.19848984479904175,
-0.34240901470184326,
0.2452114075422287,
-0.5659412741661072,
-0.40047764778137207,
-0.3558105230331421,
-0.5934098362922668,
-0.8287100791931152,
0.1999749392271042,
-0.09426780045032501,
-0.5308422446250916,
0.10462333261966705,
0.05069107189774513,
-0.1451185941696167,
0.3282698392868042,
-0.8445827960968018,
1.2276495695114136,
-0.7338851690292358,
-0.757656991481781,
-0.36315086483955383,
-0.5164244174957275,
0.23474961519241333,
-0.14675335586071014,
0.3110099732875824,
0.04818086326122284,
-0.21550770103931427,
0.6957659721374512,
-0.222665473818779,
0.8541504144668579,
-0.055787041783332825,
-0.4262978136539459,
-0.17721489071846008,
-0.0814991369843483,
0.5715137720108032,
-0.175050750374794,
0.026548754423856735,
0.3668471574783325,
-0.02568548545241356,
-0.8145812153816223,
-0.9263246059417725,
0.9477999806404114,
-0.8291693925857544,
-0.45114633440971375,
0.02529226429760456,
-1.0795984268188477,
-0.5568304657936096,
0.10272162407636642,
0.33888038992881775,
0.2891623079776764,
-0.07100197672843933,
-0.026429101824760437,
0.7971500754356384,
-0.3090710937976837,
0.16520793735980988,
0.6063795685768127,
-0.015558559447526932,
-0.4886206090450287,
1.1177983283996582,
0.30494123697280884,
0.3997112512588501,
0.7463163733482361,
-0.132661834359169,
-0.14708763360977173,
-0.2003353238105774,
-0.6378639340400696,
0.4167284667491913,
-0.7281666398048401,
-0.13385780155658722,
-0.3965090215206146,
0.012565241195261478,
-0.44513338804244995,
-0.14170800149440765,
-0.7354592680931091,
-0.12984926998615265,
0.1200597956776619,
0.21597003936767578,
0.042180515825748444,
0.4736505448818207,
-0.033068135380744934,
0.10476064682006836,
-0.9261902570724487,
0.10131534188985825,
0.18897801637649536,
0.49466684460639954,
-0.12556517124176025,
-0.45833757519721985,
-0.9246228337287903,
0.31603169441223145,
0.07545376569032669,
-0.6191575527191162,
0.20895610749721527,
0.35182932019233704,
0.7879201173782349,
0.02185269258916378,
-0.19274257123470306,
0.9234513640403748,
-0.5537003874778748,
0.46973857283592224,
0.07947015017271042,
-1.0379234552383423,
0.38994306325912476,
0.036633722484111786,
0.4287434220314026,
0.5656761527061462,
0.7226525545120239,
-0.5865567922592163,
-0.3738519549369812,
-0.168587788939476,
-0.8349323272705078,
0.7487037181854248,
-0.16399136185646057,
-0.20105934143066406,
0.3831096291542053,
0.028440400958061218,
0.3981190323829651,
0.021903173997998238,
-0.45796748995780945,
-0.3181312382221222,
-0.26526036858558655,
-0.5362640023231506,
-0.3505586087703705,
0.004419785924255848,
-0.31667575240135193,
-0.3890405595302582,
1.02839994430542,
-0.36849308013916016,
-0.22134694457054138,
-0.10871297866106033,
-0.4270385205745697,
-0.32027432322502136,
0.188980832695961,
0.5333658456802368,
0.8304606080055237,
0.33130088448524475,
0.14918820559978485,
0.336645245552063,
-0.3636777102947235,
0.09405054897069931,
0.17560769617557526,
-0.17787466943264008,
-0.14118868112564087,
0.6481640338897705,
0.8676722645759583,
0.5871803760528564,
-0.5337815880775452,
0.3728249967098236,
-0.00037203895044513047,
-0.03268318995833397,
0.1881621927022934,
-0.06002941355109215,
0.13122951984405518,
0.28443649411201477,
-0.010840660892426968,
-0.24170151352882385,
-0.27719661593437195,
-0.4088577330112457,
0.12352647632360458,
0.36936154961586,
-0.16510239243507385,
-0.28387755155563354,
0.4541117250919342,
0.16200001537799835,
-0.12160944938659668,
0.5409424304962158,
0.11331551522016525,
-0.47994863986968994,
0.312629371881485,
0.5624421834945679,
0.7636685371398926,
-0.4272209405899048,
0.14223706722259521,
0.37708449363708496,
0.47997739911079407,
0.09912329167127609,
0.36209213733673096,
-0.08076249808073044,
-0.7935803532600403,
-0.7640380859375,
-0.3862685561180115,
-0.2800736129283905,
-0.10466216504573822,
-0.6443233489990234,
0.1400822103023529,
-0.042854953557252884,
0.2478560358285904,
-0.14060242474079132,
0.0579054057598114,
-0.6039577722549438,
0.17106901109218597,
0.25802943110466003,
0.815150797367096,
-1.1212944984436035,
0.9789413213729858,
0.8920394778251648,
-0.11786627769470215,
-1.0627518892288208,
-0.07680568844079971,
-0.12797388434410095,
-0.8428694605827332,
0.5295472145080566,
-0.01049598678946495,
-0.1301850974559784,
-0.23653332889080048,
-0.2432073950767517,
-0.7500008344650269,
0.914047122001648,
0.5301876664161682,
-0.9760936498641968,
0.14379192888736725,
0.6190466284751892,
0.40571486949920654,
-0.6326785683631897,
0.21901699900627136,
0.6218486428260803,
0.6219773292541504,
-0.13858534395694733,
-1.0110208988189697,
-0.05645616725087166,
-0.510956883430481,
-0.019284287467598915,
0.28534188866615295,
-0.7297537326812744,
0.6747498512268066,
0.23616370558738708,
-0.133025661110878,
-0.39676839113235474,
0.6951900720596313,
0.08456219732761383,
0.3177728056907654,
0.5468171834945679,
0.7382319569587708,
0.7887237668037415,
-0.0450151152908802,
0.823031485080719,
-0.8222320079803467,
-0.012438207864761353,
1.071056604385376,
-0.369424432516098,
0.5490365028381348,
0.659872829914093,
0.16786833107471466,
0.38597050309181213,
0.5448356866836548,
0.22451579570770264,
0.4057798683643341,
-0.17878296971321106,
-0.169117733836174,
-0.6139273047447205,
-0.19787470996379852,
-0.2923169732093811,
0.42720094323158264,
0.11888958513736725,
-0.036117542535066605,
-0.2278406023979187,
0.1279163658618927,
-0.14956572651863098,
0.27373746037483215,
-0.34948521852493286,
0.5693017244338989,
-0.11471331864595413,
-0.9248747229576111,
0.7638664841651917,
-0.04323595017194748,
0.686344563961029,
-0.6344548463821411,
-0.11908897012472153,
-0.3692187964916229,
0.17863017320632935,
-0.29620882868766785,
-0.49991777539253235,
0.2334229201078415,
-0.04486601799726486,
-0.2883913815021515,
-0.33062368631362915,
0.3180592358112335,
-1.2173279523849487,
-0.6508938670158386,
0.5496271848678589,
0.6201872229576111,
-0.015805592760443687,
0.40056413412094116,
-0.6561225056648254,
0.19914674758911133,
0.16621939837932587,
0.11314889788627625,
0.46148571372032166,
0.6896932125091553,
-0.21479389071464539,
0.4897111654281616,
0.291319340467453,
0.1726071983575821,
0.3725317418575287,
0.25948774814605713,
0.6346108913421631,
-0.3551574647426605,
-0.3519720733165741,
-0.44601988792419434,
0.5929698944091797,
-0.015842074528336525,
-0.3080122470855713,
0.978210985660553,
0.879461407661438,
1.3556188344955444,
0.02456315979361534,
0.6726699471473694,
0.10813156515359879,
0.5786019563674927,
-0.6951176524162292,
0.47627466917037964,
-1.0038400888442993,
0.2330598533153534,
0.024180350825190544,
-0.8560499548912048,
-0.14342354238033295,
0.290558397769928,
-0.3899711072444916,
0.1113922968506813,
0.7348021268844604,
1.0748707056045532,
-0.5226581692695618,
0.024213716387748718,
0.4504232406616211,
-0.200866237282753,
-0.185410276055336,
0.8000165224075317,
0.599336564540863,
-0.5690280199050903,
0.4138997793197632,
-0.6429616212844849,
-0.190464049577713,
0.0425519160926342,
-0.6056258678436279,
-0.9966638088226318,
-0.41063475608825684,
-0.4001157581806183,
0.01900508813560009,
0.390606164932251,
0.7173317670822144,
0.8754560947418213,
-1.083984136581421,
-0.5331346988677979,
0.23129460215568542,
0.17207548022270203,
-0.5548250675201416,
-0.12055464833974838,
0.167174831032753,
-0.5901310443878174,
-1.0433207750320435,
0.68915855884552,
0.185530886054039,
-0.20180784165859222,
-0.25213494896888733,
-0.33965981006622314,
-0.4267536401748657,
0.022806966677308083,
0.18886245787143707,
0.15677325427532196,
-0.446094274520874,
-0.17403298616409302,
0.2692137062549591,
-0.24742740392684937,
0.031050322577357292,
1.0237091779708862,
-0.21339035034179688,
0.49526000022888184,
0.5113065838813782,
1.0146549940109253,
0.43698325753211975,
-0.06804925203323364,
0.8625957369804382,
-1.039976716041565,
0.17627471685409546,
-0.013639507815241814,
0.2867316007614136,
0.5347580313682556,
-0.5219716429710388,
0.3099748194217682,
0.11026221513748169,
-0.4786050617694855,
-0.513481855392456,
0.036392536014318466,
-0.6408987641334534,
-0.1748228818178177,
0.690660834312439,
-0.3299487829208374,
-0.35543689131736755,
0.1352521926164627,
0.1436319202184677,
0.4794520139694214,
-0.11033741384744644,
0.5161837935447693,
0.7890895009040833,
0.0518474355340004,
-0.38028910756111145,
-0.43013817071914673,
0.21811982989311218,
0.9304859042167664,
-0.7111620306968689,
0.14499253034591675,
0.3095451891422272,
0.1624782681465149,
0.1780318021774292,
0.010995768941938877,
-0.039735231548547745,
0.24969804286956787,
0.004001752007752657,
0.16517700254917145,
-0.018132878467440605,
-0.5815960764884949,
-0.1932753175497055,
-0.0259342473000288,
-0.3181653618812561,
-0.16667646169662476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11916v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11916v1
|
SKIP: Skill-Localized Prompt Tuning for Inference Speed Boost-Up
| 2024-04-18T05:43:50 | 2024-04-18T05:43:50 |
Nakyeong Yang, Junseok Kim, Jiwon Moon, Yunah Jang, Kyomin Jung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Prompt-tuning methods have shown comparable performance as
parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods in various natural language
understanding tasks. However, existing prompt tuning methods still utilize the
entire model architecture; thus, they fail to accelerate inference speed in the
application. In this paper, we propose a novel approach called SKIll-localized
Prompt tuning (SKIP), which is extremely efficient in inference time. Our
method significantly enhances inference efficiency by investigating and
utilizing a skill-localized subnetwork in a language model. Surprisingly, our
method improves the inference speed up to 160% while pruning 52% of the
parameters. Furthermore, we demonstrate that our method is applicable across
various transformer-based architectures, thereby confirming its practicality
and scalability.
|
[
-0.5343800187110901,
-0.934999942779541,
0.4723156690597534,
0.5378236174583435,
-0.3051382601261139,
0.05346037074923515,
-0.29053062200546265,
-0.2258874624967575,
-0.015556169673800468,
0.3111378252506256,
-0.7037014365196228,
-0.279885470867157,
-0.3218378722667694,
0.32671865820884705,
0.07857808470726013,
0.6192705631256104,
0.39074262976646423,
-0.1321878284215927,
0.06987462937831879,
0.19718964397907257,
-0.6731632947921753,
-0.014370594173669815,
-1.3927887678146362,
-0.2272285372018814,
0.6290701031684875,
0.7406044602394104,
0.6582667827606201,
0.9667912721633911,
0.15419608354568481,
0.3173764646053314,
-0.49734336137771606,
0.4011520445346832,
-0.13545970618724823,
0.14491334557533264,
-0.1967790573835373,
-0.5676887035369873,
-0.608669102191925,
-0.18864169716835022,
0.5393450856208801,
0.787961483001709,
0.19435933232307434,
-0.025510767474770546,
-0.17730684578418732,
0.5327609181404114,
-0.6448392868041992,
0.056518178433179855,
-0.8409298658370972,
0.07477745413780212,
-0.25815704464912415,
-0.3796933889389038,
-0.7012979388237,
-0.3124600648880005,
0.1663569211959839,
-0.8198814392089844,
0.8258989453315735,
0.10673949867486954,
0.8405490517616272,
0.5381454825401306,
-0.34731826186180115,
0.31760329008102417,
-0.32899999618530273,
0.7050007581710815,
-0.7777663469314575,
0.4680028557777405,
0.4998718202114105,
0.3673190474510193,
-0.023202909156680107,
-0.6841108798980713,
-0.3168404996395111,
-0.20232638716697693,
-0.2433559149503708,
0.059257734566926956,
-0.16570250689983368,
0.241472989320755,
0.46165990829467773,
0.17561227083206177,
-0.4204809367656708,
0.31832730770111084,
0.050209980458021164,
-0.323453426361084,
0.5038177371025085,
0.10553009063005447,
0.18388207256793976,
-0.17402158677577972,
-0.09785501658916473,
0.07222957909107208,
-0.670015275478363,
0.3333548605442047,
0.4265363812446594,
0.7180322408676147,
0.1047094389796257,
-0.03063023090362549,
-0.35661330819129944,
1.0886690616607666,
0.477988600730896,
-0.08848518133163452,
0.32788151502609253,
-0.6675243377685547,
-0.1856878250837326,
0.08780317008495331,
0.39589929580688477,
0.08580291271209717,
0.3364400863647461,
-0.19395887851715088,
0.14828266203403473,
-0.24677729606628418,
0.19991590082645416,
-0.631862223148346,
-0.27905407547950745,
-0.05686379596590996,
-0.34164777398109436,
-0.08556932210922241,
-0.19594436883926392,
-0.8032992482185364,
-0.3042222559452057,
-0.24585214257240295,
0.08507152646780014,
-0.576187014579773,
-0.2109953612089157,
-0.00578761100769043,
-0.18843594193458557,
0.3577830493450165,
0.23645885288715363,
-0.9578224420547485,
-0.05500383302569389,
0.596542477607727,
0.8903459310531616,
-0.18533112108707428,
-0.301851361989975,
-1.0522823333740234,
-0.4507670998573303,
-0.31647881865501404,
0.9960576295852661,
-0.7095155119895935,
-0.3195125162601471,
-0.25872233510017395,
0.2442774474620819,
-0.3698006272315979,
-0.5704141855239868,
1.0089722871780396,
-0.5469439625740051,
-0.06623846292495728,
-0.3858296871185303,
-0.31077149510383606,
-0.06034896895289421,
-0.13293305039405823,
-0.618858814239502,
1.288394808769226,
0.022658921778202057,
-0.5941793918609619,
0.6345170736312866,
-0.5582260489463806,
-0.9040431380271912,
0.046221647411584854,
0.30191242694854736,
-0.31528687477111816,
0.18430781364440918,
0.9582295417785645,
0.42128512263298035,
-0.1855437159538269,
0.360116183757782,
-0.016922220587730408,
-0.6278117299079895,
-0.4131966829299927,
-0.632502555847168,
0.663079559803009,
0.23640204966068268,
-0.429623544216156,
0.04411587864160538,
-0.9094483256340027,
-0.1610247641801834,
-0.217606320977211,
-0.2145320028066635,
-0.4048890471458435,
0.007263818755745888,
-0.4317828416824341,
-0.08995494991540909,
0.20260873436927795,
-0.4211285412311554,
0.222516268491745,
-0.7234269380569458,
0.20236018300056458,
0.6539197564125061,
0.07604259997606277,
0.9365249276161194,
0.03223881870508194,
0.7735912799835205,
0.06057220324873924,
0.1298530548810959,
-0.6701268553733826,
-0.6455959677696228,
-0.8877919912338257,
-0.5929490327835083,
0.4969785213470459,
0.6651036739349365,
-0.9354350566864014,
0.647208034992218,
-0.11068680137395859,
-0.5955779552459717,
-0.8144069910049438,
-0.1494254320859909,
0.3713535964488983,
1.1110092401504517,
0.6047869920730591,
0.3793352544307709,
-0.38574013113975525,
-0.9555804133415222,
-0.9230412244796753,
0.1489233672618866,
-0.35634052753448486,
0.427547425031662,
0.08292681723833084,
0.3054400086402893,
1.2569468021392822,
-0.29348015785217285,
0.1103672981262207,
-0.36230960488319397,
0.3517981767654419,
0.772068440914154,
0.5036768913269043,
0.49884966015815735,
-0.7169157266616821,
-0.7079864144325256,
0.09356239438056946,
-0.20807060599327087,
-0.6254302263259888,
-0.4377214014530182,
-0.2271455079317093,
0.05032964423298836,
0.4719797372817993,
-0.4310492277145386,
0.2923843562602997,
0.1788536161184311,
-0.8300688862800598,
0.38793638348579407,
-0.3276786506175995,
0.3429205119609833,
-0.781374990940094,
-0.10312056541442871,
0.03610657900571823,
-0.2631601393222809,
-0.5870882868766785,
-0.16090676188468933,
0.35555946826934814,
0.07402694970369339,
-0.29831570386886597,
0.8198904395103455,
-0.6445804238319397,
0.24145857989788055,
-0.161697119474411,
-0.02925693988800049,
0.0417511872947216,
0.39319080114364624,
0.175901859998703,
1.232080101966858,
0.8402643203735352,
-0.9117250442504883,
-0.15546372532844543,
0.1314535290002823,
-0.27340060472488403,
0.4525618553161621,
-0.704788327217102,
0.10643809288740158,
-0.1872369796037674,
-0.060053255409002304,
-0.803718090057373,
0.036277078092098236,
-0.009564866311848164,
-0.32371848821640015,
0.26954254508018494,
-0.3713865578174591,
-0.23979833722114563,
-0.2950037717819214,
-0.035178154706954956,
0.06928038597106934,
0.6617769002914429,
-0.9219922423362732,
0.8865630626678467,
-0.24812935292720795,
-0.17626117169857025,
-0.6099511981010437,
-0.47689297795295715,
-0.14535517990589142,
-0.2408391535282135,
-0.6829298734664917,
0.5403146743774414,
0.04665551334619522,
-0.009869717992842197,
-0.4315943121910095,
-0.27101123332977295,
-0.034811001271009445,
0.20596610009670258,
-0.17347994446754456,
-0.11429054290056229,
-0.3893798887729645,
0.08713926374912262,
0.6273826360702515,
-0.3654337525367737,
-0.3566124439239502,
-0.15043509006500244,
0.27759850025177,
0.011574683710932732,
-0.18112312257289886,
-0.5107154846191406,
0.18507763743400574,
0.3742038309574127,
-0.43022799491882324,
0.839365541934967,
0.5954286456108093,
0.05376967042684555,
-0.4046996831893921,
-0.5437475442886353,
-0.4555254578590393,
-0.5551624894142151,
0.3246094584465027,
-0.5573678612709045,
-0.8311119675636292,
0.5445541739463806,
-0.31230106949806213,
0.02291613630950451,
0.2431247979402542,
0.1850418597459793,
0.06137917563319206,
1.027039885520935,
0.6799323558807373,
0.00012877886183559895,
0.7419860363006592,
0.1887436956167221,
0.42099401354789734,
-0.6128283739089966,
0.00031189335277304053,
-0.9236932396888733,
-0.3763198256492615,
-0.3666395843029022,
-0.5983921885490417,
0.35707539319992065,
0.2909819185733795,
-0.446426123380661,
0.3744080662727356,
-0.33242112398147583,
0.7242626547813416,
0.6999487280845642,
0.1393778771162033,
0.4941480755805969,
0.08723368495702744,
-0.24585865437984467,
-0.30210620164871216,
-1.0881658792495728,
-0.1386764645576477,
0.5032231211662292,
0.26145997643470764,
0.3936837613582611,
-0.31518828868865967,
0.16132162511348724,
0.19467535614967346,
0.099690280854702,
-0.5170188546180725,
0.453397661447525,
-0.13666976988315582,
-0.37534162402153015,
-0.41552305221557617,
-0.57334965467453,
-0.86870276927948,
0.2513457238674164,
0.08654619008302689,
-0.7042120099067688,
0.37072503566741943,
0.4696660339832306,
-0.416833758354187,
0.3708493411540985,
-1.034839153289795,
0.9061262607574463,
0.09330320358276367,
-0.1618974655866623,
0.00844204518944025,
-0.5266384482383728,
0.04856252297759056,
0.021126359701156616,
0.025904575362801552,
-0.2185797095298767,
-0.06827284395694733,
0.5225574374198914,
-0.3516438603401184,
0.791390597820282,
-0.40331634879112244,
-0.06359036266803741,
0.08984468132257462,
0.12422827631235123,
0.7777723670005798,
0.2908657491207123,
-0.45086342096328735,
0.08815116435289383,
-0.5663145184516907,
-0.5403029322624207,
-0.8118267059326172,
0.4916066527366638,
-0.23536455631256104,
-0.39621758460998535,
0.04716697335243225,
-0.5552379488945007,
-0.49674591422080994,
0.16374053061008453,
0.5424734354019165,
0.5170087218284607,
0.14728185534477234,
0.05694352835416794,
0.8300163745880127,
-0.3826024532318115,
0.7111385464668274,
0.8602999448776245,
0.2817234992980957,
-0.10448278486728668,
0.7252607345581055,
-0.027021894231438637,
0.05959755927324295,
0.6903427243232727,
0.18380236625671387,
-0.3677840828895569,
-0.4542904198169708,
-0.3917834758758545,
0.20310497283935547,
-0.3861078917980194,
-0.3396865129470825,
-0.6155163645744324,
0.16230225563049316,
-0.41319799423217773,
-0.5077771544456482,
-0.5095943808555603,
-0.1343114674091339,
-0.33162301778793335,
-0.1991773098707199,
0.6931666135787964,
0.16692163050174713,
0.07504883408546448,
0.7659299969673157,
-0.8271992206573486,
0.30803871154785156,
0.10962383449077606,
0.3975692093372345,
0.04500069469213486,
-0.8205827474594116,
-0.09877275675535202,
-0.28957322239875793,
0.11776891350746155,
-0.905265212059021,
0.36239635944366455,
0.42733079195022583,
0.7172874212265015,
0.5162346959114075,
0.20169925689697266,
0.8371760845184326,
-0.5185378193855286,
0.8022196888923645,
-0.23852722346782684,
-1.134124994277954,
0.7886715531349182,
-0.4557328224182129,
0.8424081206321716,
0.7130401134490967,
0.3513834774494171,
-0.3765067458152771,
-0.4175141453742981,
-0.4746650159358978,
-1.0360301733016968,
0.7040256261825562,
0.05660128593444824,
0.17355570197105408,
-0.35481032729148865,
0.528559684753418,
0.2777293622493744,
-0.08923746645450592,
-0.1973089873790741,
-0.4588387906551361,
0.2356356382369995,
0.03255822882056236,
-0.19290320575237274,
-0.13896410167217255,
0.5058213472366333,
-0.6689653396606445,
0.8706397414207458,
-0.5470871329307556,
0.25209882855415344,
0.35248902440071106,
-0.10552852600812912,
0.0721040815114975,
0.17417916655540466,
0.263701468706131,
0.6512460708618164,
0.0763872042298317,
-0.0217277929186821,
0.6314976811408997,
-0.45646119117736816,
-0.10286877304315567,
0.08436901867389679,
-0.5486703515052795,
0.3361060917377472,
0.4660648703575134,
1.0702253580093384,
0.5283876061439514,
-0.38035720586776733,
0.169088676571846,
-0.24008505046367645,
-0.0919777899980545,
0.28747859597206116,
0.19947415590286255,
0.05205174908041954,
0.34677502512931824,
0.4313223361968994,
0.3014522194862366,
-0.004656614735722542,
0.1049603670835495,
0.18283532559871674,
0.19265373051166534,
-0.3302038908004761,
-0.20125696063041687,
0.5973785519599915,
0.3452049791812897,
-0.5558825135231018,
0.7690895795822144,
-0.2669012248516083,
-0.27292585372924805,
0.7707178592681885,
0.565494954586029,
0.9276872277259827,
-0.21318568289279938,
0.44573119282722473,
0.6351299285888672,
0.38460874557495117,
-0.03925415873527527,
0.3525642156600952,
-0.4551311135292053,
-0.6622172594070435,
-0.9185919165611267,
-0.6973914504051208,
-0.18683387339115143,
-0.17470459640026093,
-0.6106645464897156,
0.12145274132490158,
-0.005133898463100195,
-0.08432126045227051,
-0.16250750422477722,
-0.16219961643218994,
-0.6842844486236572,
0.12259817868471146,
-0.09955012053251266,
1.6366885900497437,
-0.8130486607551575,
0.7681909203529358,
0.5992166996002197,
0.07676893472671509,
-1.0357030630111694,
0.05001958832144737,
-0.404283344745636,
-0.4429014325141907,
0.4844391345977783,
0.03668962046504021,
-0.1273292452096939,
0.30761513113975525,
-0.3411239981651306,
-0.7137553691864014,
1.0410120487213135,
0.6488237380981445,
-0.6164533495903015,
-0.07182050496339798,
-0.3578301966190338,
0.4271145164966583,
-0.2219274342060089,
0.6908183097839355,
1.1550222635269165,
0.717880368232727,
-0.07381942868232727,
-0.975721538066864,
0.014210877940058708,
-0.1963524967432022,
0.08771738409996033,
0.278602659702301,
-0.4440183937549591,
0.658385694026947,
-0.10180976986885071,
-0.031237727031111717,
0.13871318101882935,
0.8592482805252075,
0.07010097801685333,
0.2201811671257019,
0.6233843564987183,
0.3583724796772003,
1.0669653415679932,
-0.28316420316696167,
0.9702678322792053,
-0.42887961864471436,
0.3199337124824524,
1.090687870979309,
0.05428263545036316,
0.5034628510475159,
0.45367535948753357,
0.012730973772704601,
0.3424128293991089,
0.6683215498924255,
0.16402554512023926,
0.548934280872345,
-0.23337650299072266,
-0.37162014842033386,
-0.7018254399299622,
-0.16193699836730957,
-0.269961416721344,
0.39749598503112793,
0.0740208849310875,
-0.4283793568611145,
-0.4565775394439697,
-0.03133998066186905,
0.11650987714529037,
0.020121848210692406,
-0.5318013429641724,
0.5560208559036255,
-0.21436449885368347,
-1.087545394897461,
0.4403209984302521,
-0.009871143847703934,
0.766498863697052,
-0.7486927509307861,
-0.0707673653960228,
-0.7476938962936401,
-0.013759310357272625,
0.12650418281555176,
-0.4093170762062073,
0.21419766545295715,
-0.018138187006115913,
-0.3138720691204071,
-0.6886473298072815,
0.7471620440483093,
-0.10360194742679596,
-0.32744500041007996,
0.23871904611587524,
0.7425178289413452,
-0.016756806522607803,
-0.2772589325904846,
-0.5255814790725708,
-0.506740927696228,
0.03609013557434082,
-0.537954568862915,
0.11534056812524796,
0.5825791358947754,
-0.0007807817892171443,
0.610163688659668,
0.7320510745048523,
0.10846253484487534,
0.08078933507204056,
0.24207542836666107,
0.6059452295303345,
-0.6910960674285889,
-0.8159374594688416,
-0.8885323405265808,
0.7412716746330261,
-0.22314190864562988,
-0.8023980259895325,
0.907541811466217,
0.25493499636650085,
0.6634901165962219,
-0.1637727916240692,
0.4795457720756531,
-0.09882449358701706,
0.4738527536392212,
-0.615588903427124,
0.6431993246078491,
-0.41382357478141785,
0.18763048946857452,
-0.07031282782554626,
-0.778888463973999,
-0.2537924647331238,
0.534822940826416,
-0.523435115814209,
0.04692431539297104,
0.7295194864273071,
1.0228915214538574,
-0.22778505086898804,
0.09874438494443893,
0.3895949423313141,
0.2943815588951111,
-0.048043519258499146,
0.22237057983875275,
0.42125755548477173,
-0.1511976718902588,
0.16596712172031403,
-0.35791274905204773,
-0.3380911350250244,
0.07119961082935333,
-1.275705337524414,
-1.081836462020874,
-0.2260565608739853,
-0.19072887301445007,
0.0007285900646820664,
-0.0392155684530735,
0.6572473645210266,
0.9101466536521912,
-0.7456327676773071,
0.34836646914482117,
-0.415271520614624,
0.40991079807281494,
-0.6975371241569519,
-0.2932615578174591,
0.2969156503677368,
-0.7082237005233765,
-0.8062017560005188,
1.0214978456497192,
0.24493707716464996,
-0.46924176812171936,
0.24954509735107422,
0.07009368389844894,
-0.21156679093837738,
0.10551099479198456,
0.3725450336933136,
0.2755580544471741,
-0.4665803611278534,
-0.021648170426487923,
0.3704557716846466,
0.39018985629081726,
0.15052936971187592,
1.117071509361267,
-1.2196582555770874,
0.4620058536529541,
0.6366655826568604,
0.723152220249176,
0.39437001943588257,
0.22052596509456635,
0.9054637551307678,
-1.117834448814392,
0.3299591541290283,
0.25025999546051025,
0.3901362717151642,
0.07832071185112,
-0.6651889681816101,
0.3395930528640747,
0.28778478503227234,
-0.425098180770874,
-0.5896012783050537,
0.25772765278816223,
-0.645343005657196,
-0.1949596107006073,
0.7828797698020935,
-0.16121424734592438,
-0.20131011307239532,
-0.32038968801498413,
-0.3643418848514557,
0.3538340926170349,
-0.5655400156974792,
0.4438857138156891,
0.19922243058681488,
-0.21266701817512512,
-0.3043869733810425,
-0.4858463704586029,
0.6247851252555847,
0.8439006805419922,
-0.801782488822937,
-0.038268595933914185,
0.08381269872188568,
0.14817161858081818,
-0.046060580760240555,
0.701445460319519,
0.4097866714000702,
0.45605209469795227,
0.09621952474117279,
-0.3162093162536621,
-0.2820969223976135,
-0.5957435369491577,
-0.5882377028465271,
0.12729382514953613,
-0.1844833940267563,
0.062359582632780075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11912v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11912v2
|
TriForce: Lossless Acceleration of Long Sequence Generation with Hierarchical Speculative Decoding
| 2024-04-18T05:25:54 | 2024-04-23T03:38:13 |
Hanshi Sun, Zhuoming Chen, Xinyu Yang, Yuandong Tian, Beidi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
With large language models (LLMs) widely deployed in long content generation
recently, there has emerged an increasing demand for efficient long-sequence
inference support. However, key-value (KV) cache, which is stored to avoid
re-computation, has emerged as a critical bottleneck by growing linearly in
size with the sequence length. Due to the auto-regressive nature of LLMs, the
entire KV cache will be loaded for every generated token, resulting in low
utilization of computational cores and high latency. While various compression
methods for KV cache have been proposed to alleviate this issue, they suffer
from degradation in generation quality. We introduce TriForce, a hierarchical
speculative decoding system that is scalable to long sequence generation. This
approach leverages the original model weights and dynamic sparse KV cache via
retrieval as a draft model, which serves as an intermediate layer in the
hierarchy and is further speculated by a smaller model to reduce its drafting
latency. TriForce not only facilitates impressive speedups for Llama2-7B-128K,
achieving up to 2.31$\times$ on an A100 GPU but also showcases scalability in
handling even longer contexts. For the offloading setting on two RTX 4090 GPUs,
TriForce achieves 0.108s/token$\unicode{x2014}$only half as slow as the
auto-regressive baseline on an A100, which attains 7.78$\times$ on our
optimized offloading system. Additionally, TriForce performs 4.86$\times$ than
DeepSpeed-Zero-Inference on a single RTX 4090 GPU. TriForce's robustness is
highlighted by its consistently outstanding performance across various
temperatures. The code is available at
https://github.com/Infini-AI-Lab/TriForce.
|
[
-0.12018569558858871,
-0.47691810131073,
0.3452717959880829,
0.5686975121498108,
-0.43537211418151855,
0.5968278646469116,
-0.17521148920059204,
-0.4793740510940552,
0.03690512850880623,
0.2757441997528076,
-0.5557737350463867,
-0.5680178999900818,
-0.3612302541732788,
-0.05808543041348457,
-0.5452097654342651,
0.5741701722145081,
-0.06567569822072983,
-0.3482320010662079,
-0.22101925313472748,
0.049423400312662125,
-0.21270319819450378,
-0.484881192445755,
-0.6267785429954529,
-0.24345052242279053,
0.008234799839556217,
0.6908326148986816,
0.9291406273841858,
0.9563048481941223,
0.2469712644815445,
0.33187657594680786,
-0.0990087017416954,
0.33006909489631653,
-0.9062337279319763,
0.42590150237083435,
0.3197847604751587,
-0.3348507881164551,
-0.6034711003303528,
-0.46575552225112915,
0.9260575175285339,
0.2535267770290375,
-0.23518329858779907,
0.21284526586532593,
-0.053034741431474686,
0.7000652551651001,
-0.9453272819519043,
0.1331774741411209,
-0.33876490592956543,
0.09914160519838333,
-0.6396265029907227,
-0.4762228727340698,
-0.34226855635643005,
-0.41583719849586487,
-0.27417367696762085,
-0.930724024772644,
0.486956387758255,
0.38662582635879517,
0.6850986480712891,
0.6241430640220642,
0.029173363000154495,
0.21193759143352509,
-0.9114536643028259,
0.7123025059700012,
-0.7077930569648743,
0.3563726246356964,
0.08316858112812042,
0.3640677034854889,
-0.39654475450515747,
-0.9811461567878723,
-0.609796941280365,
0.07585016638040543,
0.4083780348300934,
0.1108008548617363,
-0.2731861472129822,
0.31334635615348816,
0.3431675434112549,
0.6074420809745789,
-0.5333677530288696,
0.3159146308898926,
0.05279975384473801,
0.0004595893551595509,
0.6348791718482971,
0.5015602111816406,
0.15518151223659515,
-0.26647430658340454,
-0.24958640336990356,
-0.30951908230781555,
-0.8152685165405273,
0.21816247701644897,
0.2679956257343292,
0.1910976767539978,
-0.3614213168621063,
0.2463144063949585,
-0.4185691177845001,
0.4726720452308655,
0.2633705735206604,
0.03739147633314133,
0.24952082335948944,
-0.321251779794693,
-0.2962968051433563,
0.15811505913734436,
0.8582732081413269,
0.38387274742126465,
0.024411791935563087,
-0.4380859136581421,
0.00771586736664176,
-0.08791476488113403,
0.1192619726061821,
-1.2528696060180664,
0.14663226902484894,
0.47931039333343506,
-0.4355703592300415,
-0.4437869191169739,
-0.1686113029718399,
-1.051456332206726,
-0.2905113101005554,
0.2371150106191635,
-0.22222588956356049,
-0.18698392808437347,
-0.1855468600988388,
0.5554465055465698,
-0.2153836488723755,
0.2241903692483902,
0.12658393383026123,
-0.9421863555908203,
0.46907839179039,
0.777102530002594,
0.9723449349403381,
-0.3304109275341034,
-0.15178976953029633,
-0.7105885148048401,
0.14922869205474854,
-0.5036733150482178,
0.6053787469863892,
-0.43885183334350586,
-0.5405470132827759,
0.037031758576631546,
-0.2759116291999817,
0.49918124079704285,
-0.4928097426891327,
0.6681378483772278,
-0.824596643447876,
-0.33313873410224915,
-0.2982631325721741,
-0.3701689839363098,
0.04388514161109924,
0.0066369702108204365,
-0.8181065320968628,
1.3052947521209717,
0.10552894324064255,
-0.5213301777839661,
0.43513399362564087,
-0.39415058493614197,
-0.5714783668518066,
0.24522995948791504,
-0.23243287205696106,
-0.5089621543884277,
0.09639840573072433,
0.21143393218517303,
0.3786890506744385,
-0.8981627821922302,
0.3138355016708374,
-0.7201979160308838,
-0.7109056711196899,
-0.3390640616416931,
-0.5586867332458496,
0.4682009518146515,
0.06369737535715103,
-0.6119964122772217,
-0.019076455384492874,
-0.8262496590614319,
0.18123435974121094,
0.12267640978097916,
-0.20579907298088074,
0.01530255377292633,
-0.05117569491267204,
-0.26662546396255493,
0.29231908917427063,
-0.0298170018941164,
-0.7307224273681641,
0.25634780526161194,
-0.3036060035228729,
0.26467058062553406,
0.5473602414131165,
0.11030469834804535,
0.3898373544216156,
-0.175705686211586,
0.6756085157394409,
-0.07342571765184402,
0.19764459133148193,
0.30660104751586914,
-0.2646769881248474,
-0.7263051271438599,
-0.07427351176738739,
0.13030128180980682,
0.25749388337135315,
-1.0988876819610596,
-0.0921623557806015,
-0.5483174324035645,
-0.259570837020874,
-0.5957520008087158,
0.2600551247596741,
0.3817310929298401,
0.40362703800201416,
0.45274555683135986,
0.1877879947423935,
-0.4913702607154846,
-0.7409893870353699,
-0.12410096079111099,
-0.3430691659450531,
0.16577929258346558,
0.2650187909603119,
0.0814051702618599,
0.0354001484811306,
0.6495625972747803,
-0.36018693447113037,
0.308374285697937,
-0.08275335282087326,
0.5503596067428589,
0.2672308385372162,
0.29055941104888916,
0.5097025632858276,
-0.5970097184181213,
-0.32938340306282043,
-0.1052749752998352,
-0.6285125017166138,
-0.21272049844264984,
-0.16293352842330933,
-0.36806419491767883,
0.2947847843170166,
0.6589029431343079,
-0.815117597579956,
0.48630818724632263,
0.5976482629776001,
-0.12742197513580322,
0.42605775594711304,
-0.24662049114704132,
0.09472029656171799,
-1.216905117034912,
0.1744372397661209,
-0.41172435879707336,
-0.2893906533718109,
-0.5696854591369629,
-0.05645717680454254,
0.2631225883960724,
0.1216125562787056,
-0.5708655118942261,
0.33680182695388794,
-0.37405678629875183,
-0.12759244441986084,
-0.44222739338874817,
-0.20518846809864044,
0.02909129671752453,
0.43682539463043213,
0.1697218269109726,
1.101109266281128,
0.40177613496780396,
-0.754482626914978,
0.43047404289245605,
-0.01722896471619606,
-0.108019158244133,
-0.04589007794857025,
-0.7012195587158203,
0.0925489217042923,
-0.11661501973867416,
0.3960854113101959,
-0.7143256664276123,
0.01596805453300476,
0.2259330004453659,
-0.3115635812282562,
0.36996933817863464,
-0.025744406506419182,
-0.801148533821106,
-0.6381866335868835,
-0.342509001493454,
0.8841575980186462,
0.5011456608772278,
-0.7409999370574951,
0.49401047825813293,
0.05542884021997452,
0.026180753484368324,
-0.9697525501251221,
-0.6480060815811157,
0.2588764727115631,
0.007587473839521408,
-0.6324414610862732,
0.7705536484718323,
-0.17547892034053802,
-0.10560382902622223,
0.050768930464982986,
-0.1626962572336197,
0.0881367176771164,
-0.037814561277627945,
0.5839536786079407,
0.3689739406108856,
-0.4051126539707184,
0.2779218852519989,
0.15230786800384521,
-0.2264999896287918,
0.1360732614994049,
-0.6077804565429688,
0.5389960408210754,
-0.4071640372276306,
-0.016771849244832993,
-0.22064514458179474,
0.37965428829193115,
1.0228058099746704,
0.0654188022017479,
0.5168682336807251,
0.581827700138092,
-0.33647406101226807,
-0.5592137575149536,
-0.3786298334598541,
0.34001627564430237,
-0.5435316562652588,
0.20408079028129578,
-0.19072724878787994,
-0.9425355792045593,
0.386737585067749,
-0.12789388000965118,
0.17374558746814728,
0.7255632877349854,
0.6567662358283997,
0.1313444972038269,
0.7483974695205688,
0.5240088105201721,
-0.36783021688461304,
0.2948487401008606,
-0.5466839671134949,
0.10473570972681046,
-0.4963260591030121,
-0.2770041227340698,
-0.4322240650653839,
-0.40743502974510193,
-0.5191618800163269,
-0.7909648418426514,
0.24304614961147308,
0.012969735078513622,
-0.30098119378089905,
0.03524366393685341,
-0.10095708072185516,
0.5638050436973572,
0.34141820669174194,
-0.11613418161869049,
0.25636088848114014,
-0.08497919142246246,
-0.19041281938552856,
0.3617370128631592,
-0.9976751208305359,
0.041816551238298416,
0.8830769062042236,
0.26113489270210266,
1.0255558490753174,
0.08000411093235016,
0.6579038500785828,
0.4400743246078491,
0.08554759621620178,
-0.615173876285553,
0.4448974132537842,
-0.2460954338312149,
-0.5867558717727661,
-0.279003381729126,
-0.4731767475605011,
-0.435526579618454,
-0.1550581008195877,
-0.29976433515548706,
-0.33542400598526,
0.34240373969078064,
0.18135003745555878,
-1.0453063249588013,
0.6715988516807556,
-0.3069727420806885,
0.496347039937973,
-0.265127032995224,
-0.8465360999107361,
-0.25269147753715515,
-0.5824978947639465,
0.5506017804145813,
-0.1372276395559311,
-0.39587631821632385,
0.09235688298940659,
-0.06265839189291,
0.5434907674789429,
-0.6751725673675537,
0.6529251933097839,
0.029594354331493378,
0.040850333869457245,
0.40255749225616455,
0.11422337591648102,
0.5892738103866577,
0.3634437024593353,
-0.19144730269908905,
0.024304421618580818,
-0.2280532866716385,
-0.5011190176010132,
-0.71646648645401,
0.7376093864440918,
-0.9076756238937378,
-0.5200802087783813,
-0.3954264521598816,
-0.8942189812660217,
-0.2880813777446747,
0.34403273463249207,
0.49036648869514465,
0.45815348625183105,
-0.06354209780693054,
0.3045218586921692,
0.6937888264656067,
-0.20521362125873566,
0.9749121069908142,
0.333185613155365,
0.0688125491142273,
-0.348396360874176,
0.7316399216651917,
-0.2306632250547409,
0.4813667833805084,
0.49853965640068054,
-0.07441406697034836,
-0.448110967874527,
-0.6431378722190857,
-0.674862265586853,
0.12354699522256851,
-0.37035468220710754,
-0.6671091914176941,
-0.4773850440979004,
-0.4350717067718506,
-0.17046476900577545,
-0.12497951090335846,
-0.823852002620697,
-0.5578815340995789,
-0.4446699321269989,
0.0205767173320055,
0.41222140192985535,
0.739493191242218,
-0.08456231653690338,
0.5653731226921082,
-0.7796949148178101,
0.7180835604667664,
0.10006348043680191,
0.6001244783401489,
0.2076016664505005,
-0.4875708222389221,
-0.2352234125137329,
-0.07483728229999542,
-0.3247367739677429,
-0.24106691777706146,
0.3500085175037384,
0.1241900771856308,
0.17224039137363434,
0.6144624352455139,
0.3713023066520691,
1.2812120914459229,
-0.3050006926059723,
0.7364586591720581,
0.07013309746980667,
-0.8979796767234802,
-0.06780293583869934,
-0.03431304916739464,
0.4813742935657501,
0.5308293700218201,
0.3458409011363983,
-0.4307297170162201,
-0.27758800983428955,
-0.6884933114051819,
-0.6801848411560059,
0.7635974884033203,
0.27852773666381836,
-0.22925712168216705,
0.0006537064909934998,
0.5242983102798462,
0.0723762959241867,
0.056223608553409576,
-0.09127407521009445,
-0.33997005224227905,
-0.262543261051178,
0.07924819737672806,
-0.11208423227071762,
-0.3875085413455963,
0.22313115000724792,
-0.015122098848223686,
0.6124811172485352,
-0.05494171380996704,
0.20793476700782776,
0.1915206015110016,
0.06365714222192764,
-0.5977544188499451,
0.14540210366249084,
0.6406859755516052,
0.24727033078670502,
-0.5956397652626038,
-0.04815466329455376,
0.1185634508728981,
-0.4988862872123718,
0.10823746025562286,
0.35453861951828003,
-0.15294469892978668,
0.04624932259321213,
0.25263744592666626,
0.8628789186477661,
0.340665727853775,
-0.2781595289707184,
0.4441777467727661,
-0.44488948583602905,
-0.21615369617938995,
0.01405328232795,
-0.17329931259155273,
-0.011223084293305874,
0.35841065645217896,
0.26192840933799744,
0.1260823756456375,
0.07155896723270416,
-0.15151451528072357,
0.20705373585224152,
0.267434686422348,
0.0433809757232666,
-0.18508945405483246,
0.7632229328155518,
0.2901904881000519,
0.0580938421189785,
0.9379112720489502,
-0.20446346700191498,
-0.41571691632270813,
0.48348698019981384,
0.7506030201911926,
1.2375602722167969,
0.039620015770196915,
0.05606973543763161,
0.3612123131752014,
0.13262605667114258,
-0.24587619304656982,
0.41823679208755493,
-0.42940253019332886,
-0.4825606644153595,
-0.498057097196579,
-0.8002783060073853,
-0.3734758496284485,
0.07460145652294159,
-0.5736851692199707,
0.09144594520330429,
-0.670282244682312,
-0.1806495189666748,
-0.3261871635913849,
0.07675452530384064,
-0.6515786051750183,
-0.022751618176698685,
0.5610017776489258,
1.3007053136825562,
-0.5873193740844727,
0.8856225609779358,
-0.025746669620275497,
-0.027670320123434067,
-0.6572222709655762,
0.11259875446557999,
0.00786646082997322,
-0.882084846496582,
0.6786453127861023,
-0.1827705055475235,
-0.5729584693908691,
-0.1103091686964035,
-0.36390236020088196,
-1.113555669784546,
1.2894266843795776,
0.4082183539867401,
-0.657768726348877,
-0.5483111143112183,
0.5324324369430542,
0.45954766869544983,
-0.31443560123443604,
0.20907919108867645,
0.6153043508529663,
0.2269265204668045,
0.4592420756816864,
-0.5119302272796631,
0.1915435791015625,
-0.42109379172325134,
0.14124269783496857,
0.3299486041069031,
-0.8327678442001343,
0.7153165936470032,
-0.2930947542190552,
-0.4251837730407715,
0.3661685883998871,
1.0429996252059937,
0.30410629510879517,
0.10682965815067291,
0.24305360019207,
0.776328980922699,
0.9218551516532898,
0.04197434335947037,
1.2784043550491333,
-0.809391975402832,
0.1494932919740677,
1.0185290575027466,
-0.08254693448543549,
0.7592982649803162,
0.42484065890312195,
0.21510814130306244,
0.5298323631286621,
0.6536251306533813,
0.35363832116127014,
0.2843721807003021,
0.14028629660606384,
-0.352031409740448,
-0.5375407934188843,
-0.2935454249382019,
-0.5721049904823303,
0.21455928683280945,
0.36212393641471863,
-0.17125722765922546,
-0.43068012595176697,
-0.5114508271217346,
-0.03837350755929947,
-0.5401504635810852,
-0.457205593585968,
0.15965567529201508,
0.209281787276268,
-0.6412981748580933,
0.9967625737190247,
-0.09731455892324448,
0.39857539534568787,
-0.5582136511802673,
-0.12144336849451065,
-0.2767554521560669,
0.16847136616706848,
-0.21400666236877441,
-0.8476754426956177,
0.05151509866118431,
0.03144146502017975,
-0.324503093957901,
-0.3611689507961273,
0.6663146018981934,
-0.24884071946144104,
-0.37851935625076294,
0.2814428210258484,
0.2485777586698532,
-0.23348112404346466,
0.02914423495531082,
-0.4086079001426697,
0.3385184407234192,
-0.42247316241264343,
0.010516817681491375,
-0.14739714562892914,
0.5131229162216187,
-0.09252893179655075,
0.7230579257011414,
0.6628664135932922,
0.1997249871492386,
0.25986552238464355,
0.1691339910030365,
1.0759952068328857,
-0.7760294079780579,
-0.555875301361084,
-0.8485283255577087,
0.2873553931713104,
-0.053644780069589615,
-0.40181684494018555,
0.5642272233963013,
0.6179190278053284,
0.6009813547134399,
0.1828085333108902,
0.6366968750953674,
0.11017131805419922,
-0.008474806323647499,
-0.5604486465454102,
0.6172611713409424,
-0.5590740442276001,
0.14550301432609558,
-0.24686524271965027,
-0.6075328588485718,
-0.4279269874095917,
-0.329180508852005,
-0.08263488858938217,
-0.09124619513750076,
0.7118642330169678,
0.6870852112770081,
-0.07777959853410721,
0.22062690556049347,
0.2664385437965393,
0.31008607149124146,
0.39387139678001404,
0.8898795247077942,
0.6543974280357361,
-0.5513355135917664,
0.7494480609893799,
-0.4362059235572815,
-0.1722123771905899,
-0.21922844648361206,
-0.9432752728462219,
-0.7164694666862488,
-0.20652428269386292,
0.1141473725438118,
-0.5743729472160339,
0.1741240918636322,
0.9326692819595337,
0.855660080909729,
-0.597568690776825,
-0.3821719288825989,
-0.3220699429512024,
-0.060488972812891006,
-0.03227192535996437,
-0.1632125973701477,
0.32669544219970703,
-0.374138742685318,
-0.47277969121932983,
0.436734139919281,
0.5175082683563232,
0.04689887911081314,
-0.06336675584316254,
-0.403067022562027,
0.051015615463256836,
-0.16412028670310974,
0.5340669751167297,
0.7875288724899292,
-0.6161056756973267,
0.045629240572452545,
0.09189791232347488,
-0.06533316522836685,
0.14680378139019012,
0.9675692915916443,
-0.9254195094108582,
0.5182978510856628,
0.696031391620636,
1.1341291666030884,
0.7624354958534241,
0.2777857482433319,
0.8646823167800903,
-0.4920419752597809,
0.00760468328371644,
0.42408978939056396,
0.1961735188961029,
0.04935511201620102,
-0.6539942622184753,
0.0915842354297638,
0.3679630160331726,
-0.4661058187484741,
-0.6052330136299133,
-0.12896513938903809,
-1.0510307550430298,
0.014865829609334469,
1.1795992851257324,
0.2557973563671112,
-0.5999842882156372,
0.27492547035217285,
0.28686589002609253,
0.6332319974899292,
-0.6127564311027527,
0.6561798453330994,
0.552798867225647,
-0.14950327575206757,
-0.10582530498504639,
-0.47574153542518616,
0.8795667290687561,
0.5172939300537109,
-0.5803710222244263,
0.4288429915904999,
0.23101675510406494,
-0.1457497775554657,
-0.02602359652519226,
0.4255169630050659,
-0.21962079405784607,
0.6954354643821716,
0.16788342595100403,
0.12746335566043854,
-0.314404159784317,
-0.6978666186332703,
-0.41779178380966187,
0.172787606716156,
-0.08395840227603912,
-0.23304322361946106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11891v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11891v1
|
Large Language Models Can Plan Your Travels Rigorously with Formal Verification Tools
| 2024-04-18T04:36:37 | 2024-04-18T04:36:37 |
Yilun Hao, Yongchao Chen, Yang Zhang, Chuchu Fan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
The recent advancements of Large Language Models (LLMs), with their abundant
world knowledge and capabilities of tool-using and reasoning, fostered many LLM
planning algorithms. However, LLMs have not shown to be able to accurately
solve complex combinatorial optimization problems. In Xie et al. (2024), the
authors proposed TravelPlanner, a U.S. domestic travel planning benchmark, and
showed that LLMs themselves cannot make travel plans that satisfy user
requirements with a best success rate of 0.6%. In this work, we propose a
framework that enables LLMs to formally formulate and solve the travel planning
problem as a satisfiability modulo theory (SMT) problem and use SMT solvers
interactively and automatically solve the combinatorial search problem. The SMT
solvers guarantee the satisfiable of input constraints and the LLMs can enable
a language-based interaction with our framework. When the input constraints
cannot be satisfiable, our LLM-based framework will interactively offer
suggestions to users to modify their travel requirements via automatic
reasoning using the SMT solvers. We evaluate our framework with TravelPlanner
and achieve a success rate of 97%. We also create a separate dataset that
contain international travel benchmarks and use both dataset to evaluate the
effectiveness of our interactive planning framework when the initial user
queries cannot be satisfied. Our framework could generate valid plans with an
average success rate of 78.6% for our dataset and 85.0% for TravelPlanner
according to diverse humans preferences.
|
[
-0.2600246071815491,
-0.5964616537094116,
1.051367163658142,
0.5972654819488525,
0.03183532506227493,
0.02785518951714039,
-0.5003321170806885,
-0.11093003302812576,
0.08047954738140106,
0.416465163230896,
-0.9305157661437988,
-0.06277785450220108,
-0.11453554034233093,
0.21966949105262756,
-0.2185608595609665,
0.2691655158996582,
-0.5704144239425659,
-0.04012028127908707,
-0.3851734399795532,
0.18456070125102997,
-0.09033236652612686,
-0.7279472351074219,
-0.3411167860031128,
-0.3731127381324768,
0.27922528982162476,
0.42701032757759094,
0.6206837892532349,
0.24299335479736328,
0.6945619583129883,
0.25615960359573364,
-0.22042295336723328,
0.6024681329727173,
-0.42079320549964905,
0.010743541643023491,
-0.2968139052391052,
-0.26124945282936096,
-0.16155870258808136,
-0.4971798360347748,
0.7470030784606934,
0.7741845846176147,
-0.43205174803733826,
-0.07067250460386276,
-0.5031657218933105,
0.4034481942653656,
-0.3360111713409424,
0.18575716018676758,
-0.7368393540382385,
0.004890644457191229,
-0.023923933506011963,
-0.43163666129112244,
-0.2648892104625702,
-0.3806819021701813,
-0.039900731295347214,
-0.5125062465667725,
-0.14541806280612946,
0.2280796468257904,
0.6697916984558105,
0.16972798109054565,
-0.6759389042854309,
-0.3412654995918274,
-1.2789984941482544,
0.7101116180419922,
-0.6851394176483154,
0.426828533411026,
0.42000317573547363,
0.48761725425720215,
-0.7201992869377136,
-0.5367900729179382,
-0.6959459781646729,
-0.38839614391326904,
-0.07138732075691223,
-0.19473174214363098,
0.1635221391916275,
0.037051569670438766,
0.5285452008247375,
0.341903954744339,
-0.9045577645301819,
-0.1724691540002823,
-0.21907047927379608,
-0.05489415302872658,
0.7909576296806335,
0.3329911530017853,
0.36742469668388367,
0.07118748128414154,
-0.32659274339675903,
0.39385199546813965,
-0.7594224810600281,
0.19948287308216095,
0.09972897171974182,
0.1319049596786499,
-0.08159255981445312,
0.7147233486175537,
-0.46064090728759766,
0.4830818176269531,
-0.09961731731891632,
-0.3058203458786011,
-0.13787421584129333,
-0.5315336585044861,
-0.17765873670578003,
-0.3871856927871704,
0.514620304107666,
0.21656164526939392,
0.3841736316680908,
-0.35414019227027893,
-0.47304052114486694,
-0.1871163696050644,
-0.02859150804579258,
-1.0931298732757568,
-0.03933136910200119,
0.37730953097343445,
-0.16337256133556366,
0.09306264668703079,
0.04160674288868904,
-0.23800888657569885,
-0.07301875948905945,
-0.5074272751808167,
0.37479227781295776,
-0.3612476587295532,
-0.2177770882844925,
0.45066437125205994,
0.2685728371143341,
0.2665821611881256,
0.3121052384376526,
-0.6842124462127686,
0.3492008149623871,
0.6098167300224304,
0.648886501789093,
-0.22084099054336548,
-0.35366204380989075,
-0.4208310544490814,
0.24416175484657288,
-0.17010056972503662,
0.8169795274734497,
-0.41683316230773926,
-0.6373779773712158,
0.1872788667678833,
-0.007199963089078665,
-0.19212892651557922,
-0.18888723850250244,
0.6879690289497375,
-0.39598548412323,
0.008432435803115368,
-0.5698897838592529,
-0.522537350654602,
-0.16492019593715668,
0.6116067171096802,
-0.5269251465797424,
0.631249189376831,
0.0766083300113678,
-0.38099634647369385,
0.175099179148674,
-0.6209936738014221,
-0.695735514163971,
0.2398158609867096,
-0.24781128764152527,
-0.3368951678276062,
-0.06842630356550217,
0.25547125935554504,
0.25663062930107117,
-0.3522384464740753,
0.6988617181777954,
-0.19338831305503845,
-0.6996141076087952,
0.37785038352012634,
-0.12312737852334976,
0.930582582950592,
0.09112785011529922,
-0.2962121069431305,
0.18715624511241913,
-0.6014156341552734,
0.11918578296899796,
0.12584872543811798,
-0.6867461800575256,
0.10586248338222504,
0.2807489037513733,
0.12030119448900223,
0.20851553976535797,
0.38144218921661377,
-0.4880688488483429,
0.6118830442428589,
-0.38015711307525635,
0.5492878556251526,
0.7353471517562866,
0.02648095414042473,
0.39642053842544556,
-0.4246220290660858,
0.7153117656707764,
-0.3221367597579956,
0.1610640287399292,
-0.2085874229669571,
-0.12283309549093246,
-0.7470011115074158,
0.09359516203403473,
0.04473799467086792,
0.5936898589134216,
-0.6055060029029846,
0.6364734172821045,
-0.48140236735343933,
-0.3157477080821991,
0.3341178894042969,
-0.08989571779966354,
0.16618245840072632,
0.07555286586284637,
0.1706956923007965,
0.32202276587486267,
-0.5548985600471497,
-0.5285842418670654,
-0.15589648485183716,
-0.14041446149349213,
0.13932707905769348,
0.29290884733200073,
0.6327049732208252,
-0.39930441975593567,
0.7664681673049927,
-0.4200006425380707,
-0.1462070345878601,
-0.3853325843811035,
0.009552075527608395,
0.028705226257443428,
0.37325000762939453,
0.3523012101650238,
-1.0412606000900269,
-0.4232761859893799,
-0.03171028569340706,
-0.4339815676212311,
-0.04587080329656601,
-0.38258135318756104,
-0.1186298280954361,
-0.016182150691747665,
0.4531618058681488,
-0.4693063497543335,
0.34551236033439636,
0.4088379740715027,
-0.5064122676849365,
0.6654792428016663,
-0.26067084074020386,
0.08604314923286438,
-0.7888923287391663,
0.12254492193460464,
-0.24824687838554382,
-0.4576195478439331,
-0.33176136016845703,
0.2673400640487671,
0.0058158463798463345,
-0.20173297822475433,
-0.15160450339317322,
0.5898550152778625,
-0.19088353216648102,
-0.04653562232851982,
-0.14964620769023895,
-0.19462165236473083,
-0.006390302907675505,
0.5172332525253296,
-0.013257909566164017,
0.9686774611473083,
0.41839006543159485,
-0.4357111155986786,
0.22956424951553345,
0.41663047671318054,
-0.21578601002693176,
0.674394965171814,
-0.5735728144645691,
-0.10418866574764252,
-0.09358448535203934,
0.6037313938140869,
-0.7349555492401123,
-0.47812849283218384,
-0.15235066413879395,
0.10919594764709473,
-0.0069705406203866005,
-0.09365884214639664,
-0.5901758670806885,
-0.5295928716659546,
0.012228915467858315,
0.37768349051475525,
0.32085782289505005,
-0.6044194102287292,
1.201453685760498,
0.17748653888702393,
-0.1523381769657135,
-0.05438348278403282,
-0.5372339487075806,
0.20164309442043304,
0.02054310403764248,
-0.9033705592155457,
0.49120643734931946,
-0.6680999994277954,
-0.15598878264427185,
-0.1729666292667389,
-0.2315489798784256,
-0.15793536603450775,
-0.0772855281829834,
0.3942735195159912,
0.18695777654647827,
0.129062220454216,
-0.2531462013721466,
-0.17163851857185364,
-0.18696941435337067,
0.12726834416389465,
-0.3731212913990021,
0.5086567997932434,
-0.3303503394126892,
-0.5809082984924316,
-0.48050016164779663,
0.45239168405532837,
0.6315370798110962,
-0.4403040111064911,
0.312248557806015,
0.40280503034591675,
-0.3369850516319275,
-0.21807561814785004,
-0.6739320158958435,
0.03608673810958862,
-0.4826712906360626,
0.03593757003545761,
-0.9060958623886108,
-0.9301667809486389,
0.5105159878730774,
-0.272926926612854,
0.28819775581359863,
0.0013286680914461613,
0.573535144329071,
0.16562600433826447,
1.2416385412216187,
0.800058901309967,
0.46301576495170593,
0.1797192245721817,
-0.17949305474758148,
0.36488503217697144,
-0.6452943682670593,
-0.3149265944957733,
-0.5205084681510925,
-0.2313348948955536,
-0.621955156326294,
-0.4999014139175415,
0.48138850927352905,
-0.08087128400802612,
-0.2004411816596985,
0.3315107524394989,
-0.14615541696548462,
0.733563244342804,
0.43425726890563965,
-0.24834829568862915,
0.5364159941673279,
-0.11481940746307373,
-0.3955695629119873,
-0.022966887801885605,
-0.5645877718925476,
-0.3708828091621399,
0.7438568472862244,
-0.05508965626358986,
0.8817122578620911,
0.2123376578092575,
0.5989896059036255,
-0.04968171566724777,
0.0048753549344837666,
-0.7517217397689819,
0.8836361765861511,
0.10111600905656815,
-0.6126624345779419,
-0.30460938811302185,
-0.7275049090385437,
-0.640924334526062,
0.007487885653972626,
-0.04473276436328888,
-0.8612076044082642,
0.35302719473838806,
-0.04094593971967697,
-0.2881580889225006,
0.20936642587184906,
-0.43908917903900146,
0.44649943709373474,
-0.6098990440368652,
-0.39087092876434326,
0.030541107058525085,
-0.4042086899280548,
0.4943930506706238,
-0.2603984475135803,
0.33519893884658813,
-0.3749033510684967,
0.14470131695270538,
0.4137689471244812,
-0.44535309076309204,
0.4070405662059784,
0.02359187975525856,
0.1286195069551468,
-0.09379156678915024,
0.6022224426269531,
0.7705174684524536,
0.039073020219802856,
-0.3612793982028961,
-0.0634949803352356,
0.24770012497901917,
-0.317177414894104,
-0.4781116843223572,
0.8505483865737915,
-0.44990167021751404,
-0.2804797291755676,
-0.43051254749298096,
-0.7496054172515869,
-0.27612125873565674,
0.5257031917572021,
-0.0116372499614954,
0.2744723856449127,
-0.22663703560829163,
-0.04258972033858299,
0.23497702181339264,
0.011436467990279198,
0.4259116053581238,
0.6452803015708923,
-0.5947715044021606,
-0.3345111310482025,
0.964239239692688,
0.21859890222549438,
0.08423865586519241,
0.4002227187156677,
0.4366718530654907,
-0.28094255924224854,
-0.7510202527046204,
-0.23476748168468475,
0.24529221653938293,
-0.5864071249961853,
0.017445476725697517,
-0.45437946915626526,
-0.29362472891807556,
-0.13847507536411285,
-0.5220382809638977,
-0.2405884712934494,
-0.5916422605514526,
0.4620911478996277,
0.053700853139162064,
-0.18792276084423065,
0.585688054561615,
-0.07882445305585861,
0.31809473037719727,
-0.3782518804073334,
0.3611564040184021,
0.24115325510501862,
0.3611886501312256,
-0.40158161520957947,
-0.18824811279773712,
-0.19351446628570557,
-0.04221584275364876,
-0.09347107261419296,
-0.2647850513458252,
0.2662868797779083,
-0.16585639119148254,
0.6981354355812073,
0.49193522334098816,
0.24576810002326965,
0.9971027970314026,
-0.44275546073913574,
0.7165956497192383,
-0.18329158425331116,
-0.8412138223648071,
0.43234026432037354,
-0.43395742774009705,
0.28662389516830444,
0.7496407628059387,
0.349336713552475,
-0.2632550597190857,
-0.17362187802791595,
-0.7203781604766846,
-0.7429435849189758,
0.44359520077705383,
0.5701383948326111,
-0.3101842403411865,
0.32442763447761536,
0.25183331966400146,
-0.11748795211315155,
0.30992820858955383,
-0.9619011282920837,
0.013321874663233757,
0.2536841332912445,
0.16733402013778687,
-0.021536191925406456,
-0.4566414952278137,
-0.17678210139274597,
-0.25969213247299194,
0.8232582211494446,
-0.008106541819870472,
0.10641788691282272,
0.1617375761270523,
0.07576705515384674,
-0.46211516857147217,
0.1901208907365799,
0.9008849263191223,
1.2794339656829834,
-0.5780102014541626,
0.20491798222064972,
-0.09749479591846466,
-0.17869232594966888,
0.19930028915405273,
0.40066537261009216,
-0.7273946404457092,
-0.13659752905368805,
0.15255820751190186,
0.36944589018821716,
0.12826229631900787,
-0.9659062027931213,
0.5294094681739807,
-0.3990097641944885,
-0.27545174956321716,
-0.5979956388473511,
0.07775881141424179,
0.14977772533893585,
0.05327146127820015,
0.19155253469944,
-0.12872928380966187,
0.012893594801425934,
-0.24197648465633392,
0.1196909099817276,
0.629505455493927,
-0.1268349587917328,
-0.1976878046989441,
0.7193470597267151,
0.47036680579185486,
-0.7625790238380432,
0.25808510184288025,
-0.5671720504760742,
-0.7304317355155945,
0.31562963128089905,
0.6173197031021118,
0.7099116444587708,
-0.16427333652973175,
0.012535365298390388,
0.4742375910282135,
0.6057576537132263,
-0.2885272800922394,
0.6570534706115723,
-0.15905317664146423,
-0.4933304786682129,
-0.6940482258796692,
-0.7218920588493347,
-0.5608008503913879,
0.044478610157966614,
-0.18198148906230927,
0.3464846909046173,
-0.308404803276062,
0.1807970553636551,
-0.36229050159454346,
0.18556411564350128,
-0.6875267624855042,
-0.10182679444551468,
0.031971316784620285,
0.8788727521896362,
-0.5589238405227661,
0.2463524490594864,
0.7213422060012817,
-0.3405842185020447,
-1.0553860664367676,
0.18760736286640167,
0.03149918094277382,
-0.6466969847679138,
0.3391439914703369,
0.32282692193984985,
-0.3133534789085388,
-0.1033075600862503,
-0.4180738031864166,
-0.8268824219703674,
1.0205268859863281,
0.19972290098667145,
-0.880291223526001,
-0.3910505473613739,
0.30557283759117126,
-0.06361569464206696,
-0.34392955899238586,
0.06532185524702072,
0.48913779854774475,
0.7035489678382874,
0.5512127876281738,
-1.0067511796951294,
0.20290419459342957,
0.12763038277626038,
0.07610829174518585,
0.23950593173503876,
-0.4149864912033081,
0.6592758297920227,
-0.315337598323822,
-0.1540692001581192,
0.2884858548641205,
0.2805934548377991,
0.2546526789665222,
0.2843479812145233,
0.6567795276641846,
0.4825008809566498,
0.8831116557121277,
-0.04557114094495773,
1.030045509338379,
-0.19902902841567993,
0.3153027594089508,
1.0208410024642944,
-0.6572043895721436,
0.7986301779747009,
0.5483769178390503,
-0.2799209952354431,
0.4824574291706085,
0.33100318908691406,
0.05811305344104767,
0.40032321214675903,
0.3719239830970764,
-0.3394539952278137,
-0.713657796382904,
0.015943963080644608,
-0.14884710311889648,
0.33797919750213623,
0.28060218691825867,
0.14503724873065948,
-0.5259848237037659,
0.15524525940418243,
0.02808280475437641,
0.08194713294506073,
-0.11072742938995361,
0.4299951493740082,
0.06437129527330399,
-0.6678074598312378,
0.380418986082077,
0.21109096705913544,
0.28371354937553406,
-0.79433673620224,
0.04556066542863846,
-0.17686651647090912,
0.15950867533683777,
-0.20056694746017456,
-0.5337056517601013,
0.2390153855085373,
-0.30101481080055237,
0.06412024050951004,
-0.32347995042800903,
0.6519622206687927,
-0.3297737240791321,
-0.9812173843383789,
-0.15842284262180328,
0.4835326671600342,
-0.0016988174756988883,
-0.22281748056411743,
-0.38579052686691284,
0.21456684172153473,
0.07408315688371658,
-0.2681433856487274,
0.06443578749895096,
0.4435279071331024,
-0.00823850929737091,
1.0034351348876953,
1.0430870056152344,
0.2533411383628845,
-0.10591674596071243,
-0.10337715595960617,
0.8367145657539368,
-0.7450270652770996,
-0.9198601245880127,
-0.7011023163795471,
0.5580987930297852,
-0.19323042035102844,
0.13867618143558502,
0.5001881122589111,
0.7752934694290161,
0.6537631154060364,
0.12893694639205933,
0.7583918571472168,
0.022610776126384735,
0.38380327820777893,
-0.5324743986129761,
0.07497387379407883,
-0.43224355578422546,
0.6687654256820679,
0.304237425327301,
-0.8536461591720581,
-0.3646334409713745,
0.9640180468559265,
-0.53229159116745,
-0.142343670129776,
0.6696475148200989,
0.9243592619895935,
-0.3211870491504669,
-0.1612408608198166,
0.20616823434829712,
-0.016659390181303024,
0.9033229947090149,
0.7463163733482361,
0.9147740602493286,
-0.027169244363904,
0.7646400928497314,
-0.45479270815849304,
-0.18809747695922852,
-0.5880324244499207,
-1.093066692352295,
-1.0034679174423218,
-0.4191596210002899,
-0.22786597907543182,
-0.35470104217529297,
0.08513849973678589,
1.1475030183792114,
0.8549551963806152,
-0.338688462972641,
-0.40337613224983215,
-0.5477516055107117,
0.2986908257007599,
-0.1802777796983719,
-0.2649173438549042,
0.23104184865951538,
-0.1886870563030243,
-0.4082103371620178,
0.6245079636573792,
0.4355631172657013,
0.1633748710155487,
-0.6466944217681885,
-0.15462875366210938,
-0.048084620386362076,
0.3914542496204376,
0.45389676094055176,
0.35904160141944885,
-0.6824908256530762,
0.008829353377223015,
0.07142872363328934,
-0.12983517348766327,
-0.20785294473171234,
1.2076185941696167,
-0.40633460879325867,
0.33833539485931396,
0.3043425679206848,
0.49970197677612305,
0.729623019695282,
0.05549303814768791,
0.6198408007621765,
-0.42245933413505554,
0.00518030533567071,
0.4204432964324951,
0.5831419825553894,
0.12592878937721252,
-0.34574949741363525,
0.5885387659072876,
-0.04254531115293503,
-1.0182411670684814,
-0.8754369616508484,
0.6032987833023071,
-1.498862385749817,
-0.08321607112884521,
1.5538958311080933,
0.1455153226852417,
-0.18529227375984192,
-0.16301950812339783,
-0.3771510720252991,
-0.5180016756057739,
-0.20834296941757202,
0.7217490673065186,
0.4965548813343048,
-0.4609815776348114,
0.302691787481308,
-0.3459271788597107,
0.3913603127002716,
0.054937493056058884,
-0.8894214034080505,
0.24479341506958008,
0.6242386698722839,
0.37884435057640076,
0.21564553678035736,
0.9751983284950256,
0.24994707107543945,
0.056758612394332886,
-0.3021300733089447,
-0.1662282794713974,
-0.45932736992836,
-0.3747074604034424,
0.18069329857826233,
0.08075303584337234,
0.2512667179107666,
0.28229430317878723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11870v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11870v1
|
Enhancing Length Extrapolation in Sequential Models with Pointer-Augmented Neural Memory
| 2024-04-18T03:03:46 | 2024-04-18T03:03:46 |
Hung Le, Dung Nguyen, Kien Do, Svetha Venkatesh, Truyen Tran
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We propose Pointer-Augmented Neural Memory (PANM) to help neural networks
understand and apply symbol processing to new, longer sequences of data. PANM
integrates an external neural memory that uses novel physical addresses and
pointer manipulation techniques to mimic human and computer symbol processing
abilities. PANM facilitates pointer assignment, dereference, and arithmetic by
explicitly using physical pointers to access memory content. Remarkably, it can
learn to perform these operations through end-to-end training on sequence data,
powering various sequential models. Our experiments demonstrate PANM's
exceptional length extrapolating capabilities and improved performance in tasks
that require symbol processing, such as algorithmic reasoning and Dyck language
recognition. PANM helps Transformer achieve up to 100% generalization accuracy
in compositional learning tasks and significantly better results in
mathematical reasoning, question answering and machine translation tasks.
|
[
-0.34839585423469543,
-0.6682985424995422,
0.4481404423713684,
0.5001340508460999,
-0.2640955448150635,
-0.008024073205888271,
-0.21250228583812714,
-0.617113471031189,
0.48273390531539917,
0.23536251485347748,
0.03131748363375664,
-0.06772908568382263,
-0.645673930644989,
0.04490385577082634,
-0.4481876492500305,
0.3676273226737976,
0.14843274652957916,
0.22099949419498444,
0.034427352249622345,
-0.08467023819684982,
-0.6944193840026855,
-0.8081565499305725,
-0.5119156837463379,
-0.3335523009300232,
0.8310646414756775,
0.322637140750885,
0.7191681861877441,
0.8901025056838989,
0.7105339169502258,
0.3459829092025757,
0.04280126094818115,
0.2159782201051712,
0.12364395707845688,
0.0045106676407158375,
0.13245555758476257,
-0.7855525016784668,
-0.9018574953079224,
-0.23864558339118958,
0.8891202807426453,
0.8834482431411743,
0.20276176929473877,
0.022272253409028053,
-0.3139026165008545,
0.8702996969223022,
-0.5809469223022461,
0.33383217453956604,
-0.5147210955619812,
0.2789120674133301,
0.040992483496665955,
-0.33847686648368835,
-0.5849133133888245,
-0.504228413105011,
0.3386073410511017,
-0.5833739042282104,
0.1740347146987915,
-0.15112966299057007,
0.3554847538471222,
0.13255111873149872,
-0.12407758831977844,
-0.02395831234753132,
-0.6832659840583801,
0.5551602840423584,
-0.5430588722229004,
0.34239262342453003,
0.25898152589797974,
0.5851858258247375,
-0.019066408276557922,
-0.9620122313499451,
-0.4995255768299103,
-0.10990596562623978,
0.04262729361653328,
-0.00994188617914915,
0.22437945008277893,
0.1828760802745819,
0.5373579263687134,
0.17267963290214539,
-0.20945242047309875,
-0.3042069971561432,
-0.5369840860366821,
0.05412467569112778,
0.492029070854187,
0.15823879837989807,
0.48065513372421265,
0.16780100762844086,
-0.34038832783699036,
-0.33543890714645386,
-0.8267338275909424,
0.034257449209690094,
0.3364623486995697,
0.2750793397426605,
0.37199681997299194,
0.5125324726104736,
0.1795314997434616,
0.8122547268867493,
0.2049679458141327,
0.5280322432518005,
0.08460620045661926,
0.09083019942045212,
-0.2736676335334778,
0.3937317430973053,
0.22687266767024994,
0.19381791353225708,
0.2455122023820877,
-0.046529728919267654,
0.07615658640861511,
-0.1716190129518509,
0.2369266301393509,
-0.918800413608551,
-0.6534113883972168,
-0.2226162850856781,
-0.351418673992157,
0.3820205628871918,
0.24544060230255127,
-0.5612514019012451,
-0.3281964659690857,
-0.687976598739624,
0.5467929840087891,
-0.6385785341262817,
0.06357214599847794,
0.2925584614276886,
-0.4483407437801361,
0.12099645286798477,
0.372397243976593,
-0.944398820400238,
0.2614021599292755,
0.7127941846847534,
0.9066221714019775,
0.1415320783853531,
-0.5125845074653625,
-0.4763718545436859,
0.34901729226112366,
-0.44432348012924194,
0.3988591432571411,
-0.7705316543579102,
-0.325023889541626,
-0.4116251766681671,
-0.24823173880577087,
-0.05764319747686386,
-0.66799396276474,
0.243941992521286,
-0.7743718028068542,
-0.08198589831590652,
-0.6424883008003235,
-0.46288755536079407,
-0.4790228307247162,
0.0023108243476599455,
-0.8718018531799316,
0.7980737686157227,
-0.09153316169977188,
-0.554908812046051,
0.25320786237716675,
-0.8193040490150452,
-0.45432791113853455,
-0.14798304438591003,
-0.019460689276456833,
-0.09507941454648972,
0.5388806462287903,
0.2178320288658142,
0.4573330283164978,
-0.13142512738704681,
0.0869554951786995,
-0.23013406991958618,
-0.6028683185577393,
0.6127433776855469,
-0.2804904580116272,
0.4596744179725647,
-0.12276226282119751,
-0.048152510076761246,
0.31826430559158325,
-0.6657722592353821,
-0.049979034811258316,
-0.1795300394296646,
-0.24695564806461334,
-0.40569350123405457,
-0.07557100057601929,
-0.11816869676113129,
0.4632551372051239,
0.39345619082450867,
-0.4277132451534271,
0.26128241419792175,
-0.5738174319267273,
0.3625366687774658,
0.7616221308708191,
-0.44046398997306824,
0.5213009715080261,
-0.3492140769958496,
0.16876041889190674,
0.33430248498916626,
0.09713117778301239,
-0.596107006072998,
-0.5143231749534607,
-1.1897679567337036,
-0.21125023066997528,
0.21556827425956726,
0.3642409145832062,
-0.7837847471237183,
0.4794144928455353,
-0.3876723349094391,
-0.13060609996318817,
-0.020704304799437523,
-0.10901006311178207,
0.19758157432079315,
0.8482778072357178,
0.6759973168373108,
-0.4523770213127136,
-0.8180301189422607,
-0.8578800559043884,
-0.1995186060667038,
-0.19789522886276245,
-0.08523447811603546,
0.16112461686134338,
0.16805554926395416,
0.04222491383552551,
1.0008153915405273,
-0.3856155574321747,
-0.026489954441785812,
-0.06052812933921814,
0.2645149827003479,
0.4334937036037445,
0.39128854870796204,
0.1959170550107956,
-0.7627012133598328,
-0.7924944162368774,
-0.3313353359699249,
-0.527224600315094,
0.08783628791570663,
-0.2572718560695648,
-0.002330485498532653,
-0.15359434485435486,
0.0751594826579094,
-0.5727732181549072,
0.4315217435359955,
-0.038412582129240036,
-0.39264777302742004,
0.6202831268310547,
-0.5444837212562561,
-0.1145404502749443,
-0.8773040771484375,
0.13219685852527618,
-0.03614957630634308,
-0.25179657340049744,
-0.6760525107383728,
-0.16609139740467072,
0.29795220494270325,
0.06632907688617706,
-0.5684102773666382,
0.5622227191925049,
-0.7364675998687744,
-0.5445466637611389,
-0.7801783680915833,
-0.294021338224411,
0.045860424637794495,
0.36735641956329346,
0.4943402409553528,
0.7954177260398865,
0.7181532979011536,
-0.4828000068664551,
0.44073206186294556,
0.22883795201778412,
-0.16740255057811737,
0.3402981162071228,
-0.7782129049301147,
0.14017783105373383,
-0.13834524154663086,
0.1752362996339798,
-0.6991617679595947,
0.1452077180147171,
0.025362219661474228,
-0.42098918557167053,
0.5373069047927856,
0.1664183884859085,
-0.629041850566864,
-0.2729804813861847,
-0.3567163050174713,
0.67020183801651,
0.5900653600692749,
-0.7685332894325256,
0.7196500301361084,
0.1537259817123413,
-0.12257785350084305,
-0.6367520689964294,
-0.744285523891449,
0.21652834117412567,
-0.1633928418159485,
-0.517084538936615,
0.4039318859577179,
-0.0317801758646965,
0.04686186835169792,
-0.33365398645401,
0.07593338191509247,
-0.2770509123802185,
-0.12062611430883408,
0.14230147004127502,
0.39162498712539673,
-0.17087838053703308,
-0.01520596630871296,
0.0349196121096611,
-0.2939155101776123,
0.22674979269504547,
-0.19370219111442566,
0.7248319983482361,
-0.414177805185318,
-0.26376157999038696,
-0.40811166167259216,
0.33166542649269104,
0.5401429533958435,
0.11850614845752716,
0.4430122673511505,
0.7186269760131836,
-0.5038477778434753,
-0.20388959348201752,
-0.34881407022476196,
-0.5536187887191772,
-0.5360450148582458,
0.48892587423324585,
-0.44825565814971924,
-0.5417997241020203,
0.6902406811714172,
-0.036740031093358994,
-0.23046332597732544,
0.2918819487094879,
0.4913426339626312,
0.0423671156167984,
0.931699275970459,
0.5447520017623901,
-0.09582532942295074,
0.47192928194999695,
-0.37553203105926514,
0.07276590168476105,
-1.2072558403015137,
-0.24345281720161438,
0.08244813978672028,
-1.0526750087738037,
0.09026479721069336,
-0.8078463077545166,
0.3608711361885071,
0.33303168416023254,
-0.2546062171459198,
0.6399914622306824,
-0.5604280829429626,
0.6497802734375,
0.7250428795814514,
0.3430745005607605,
0.15711283683776855,
0.01780284196138382,
-0.3742845952510834,
-0.18965652585029602,
-0.6201885342597961,
-0.026814527809619904,
1.0557763576507568,
0.4029933214187622,
0.644792377948761,
-0.1788565069437027,
0.14510725438594818,
0.14968006312847137,
0.34645187854766846,
-0.79036545753479,
0.6918684840202332,
-0.1910731941461563,
-0.29994484782218933,
-0.09500166028738022,
-0.21398936212062836,
-0.5280871391296387,
0.09241598099470139,
0.3523138463497162,
-0.7320494651794434,
0.4741649031639099,
0.35845640301704407,
-0.47142231464385986,
0.5880059003829956,
-0.46124422550201416,
0.204977348446846,
-0.49733710289001465,
-0.3067638874053955,
-0.33931171894073486,
-0.8946589231491089,
0.3657204210758209,
0.08842302858829498,
-0.6970263123512268,
-0.015653859823942184,
-0.284192830324173,
0.7995970845222473,
-0.5377570390701294,
1.038561463356018,
-0.14873412251472473,
0.23746314644813538,
0.28272518515586853,
0.024368826299905777,
0.36976420879364014,
0.12137444317340851,
-0.049571894109249115,
0.3386511206626892,
-0.1959463357925415,
-0.2774823307991028,
-0.8104901909828186,
0.7657277584075928,
-0.7717325687408447,
-0.4923023581504822,
-0.5137936472892761,
-1.107803463935852,
-0.33588042855262756,
-0.09019053727388382,
-0.10201286524534225,
0.26346734166145325,
0.11769139766693115,
0.1214187741279602,
0.6790592074394226,
-0.22523078322410583,
0.9051728248596191,
0.37683847546577454,
-0.11968347430229187,
-0.7105787992477417,
0.7977047562599182,
0.07208896428346634,
-0.12011287361383438,
0.7568468451499939,
0.29262298345565796,
-0.6691914200782776,
-0.2862645089626312,
-0.44915005564689636,
0.06090191751718521,
-0.6680107712745667,
-0.24431081116199493,
-0.7562992572784424,
-0.42640021443367004,
-0.04649694263935089,
-0.07763303071260452,
-0.4342709183692932,
-0.9685884118080139,
-0.23716424405574799,
-0.08367758244276047,
0.4246429204940796,
0.21026486158370972,
-0.3711194097995758,
0.6128325462341309,
-0.9141256809234619,
0.30577409267425537,
0.5359995365142822,
0.18134962022304535,
0.17045432329177856,
-0.5259437561035156,
-0.3605790436267853,
0.009536459110677242,
-0.23148925602436066,
-0.7893114686012268,
0.5549466013908386,
0.4039868712425232,
0.22947309911251068,
0.5251331329345703,
-0.38871467113494873,
0.8828551769256592,
-0.7476311922073364,
0.5121861696243286,
0.6013882160186768,
-0.9493516683578491,
0.2954723834991455,
-0.1136794239282608,
0.41735345125198364,
0.19677110016345978,
0.43675824999809265,
-0.6032518148422241,
0.5204826593399048,
-0.25596508383750916,
-0.7142661809921265,
0.38531264662742615,
-0.16246050596237183,
0.24074025452136993,
-0.16122287511825562,
0.5591845512390137,
0.1695321947336197,
0.27202948927879333,
-0.15249842405319214,
-0.4768965542316437,
-0.23459947109222412,
0.03415391966700554,
-0.03235328942537308,
-0.45094943046569824,
-0.012374715879559517,
-0.7855046987533569,
0.36191847920417786,
-0.3389805257320404,
0.862139880657196,
0.1746419221162796,
-0.26889699697494507,
0.17177990078926086,
-0.045983172953128815,
0.7150465250015259,
1.0446738004684448,
-0.1280430257320404,
0.38359808921813965,
0.14320673048496246,
-0.6030839085578918,
0.13025599718093872,
0.3980969786643982,
-0.05241474509239197,
0.23495647311210632,
-0.1326727569103241,
0.7729085683822632,
0.13090744614601135,
-0.43874800205230713,
0.3735188841819763,
-0.09369505196809769,
0.16896745562553406,
-0.4185570776462555,
0.13175170123577118,
0.10879867523908615,
0.2770255506038666,
0.5427771210670471,
0.07413599640130997,
0.15837611258029938,
-0.35671401023864746,
0.46636468172073364,
0.2747773826122284,
-0.4338672161102295,
-0.7968970537185669,
0.679034411907196,
-0.00946679338812828,
-0.1877603828907013,
0.7340022325515747,
0.46395155787467957,
-0.6023998856544495,
0.8415324687957764,
0.8604332208633423,
0.9611290693283081,
-0.39728686213493347,
0.06671169400215149,
0.28140971064567566,
0.01610313169658184,
-0.11010799556970596,
0.6316143274307251,
-0.3385929763317108,
-0.7039617300033569,
-0.7588489651679993,
-0.49736422300338745,
-0.35255521535873413,
-0.18877877295017242,
-0.4546118378639221,
0.26167526841163635,
-0.9322003126144409,
-0.24256493151187897,
-0.2475714087486267,
-0.1331249326467514,
-0.5346903800964355,
0.036752812564373016,
0.20557889342308044,
1.2927478551864624,
-0.5768471956253052,
1.1973010301589966,
0.6955683827400208,
-0.1956264078617096,
-0.539385974407196,
-0.6206613779067993,
-0.35938194394111633,
-0.7438053488731384,
1.1703699827194214,
0.3955788314342499,
0.18819056451320648,
-0.07495788484811783,
-0.009465484879910946,
-0.6689698696136475,
1.031021237373352,
0.5830379128456116,
-0.6736048460006714,
-0.20947840809822083,
0.7272295355796814,
0.5100162625312805,
-0.23534587025642395,
0.7437629699707031,
0.3941631317138672,
0.44519510865211487,
0.15087063610553741,
-0.742400050163269,
-0.05458526685833931,
-0.3819737434387207,
0.20133699476718903,
0.29753097891807556,
-0.6680699586868286,
1.0505226850509644,
-0.21002329885959625,
0.15298178791999817,
0.17816218733787537,
0.8874192833900452,
0.28451651334762573,
0.15456198155879974,
0.2260873019695282,
0.8392389416694641,
0.5768522620201111,
0.0026892111636698246,
0.7603551745414734,
-0.5673500299453735,
-0.11979164183139801,
1.4361971616744995,
-0.28515973687171936,
0.832872211933136,
0.7376007437705994,
0.08833327144384384,
0.5000281929969788,
0.42446449398994446,
0.05232969671487808,
0.31365829706192017,
0.19173094630241394,
-0.5189517736434937,
-0.13319571316242218,
0.11676870286464691,
-0.6140150427818298,
0.30591216683387756,
0.6011664867401123,
-0.9288533926010132,
-0.1049557477235794,
0.07361314445734024,
-0.31337544322013855,
-0.20337766408920288,
-0.46551433205604553,
0.37624114751815796,
0.3955812156200409,
-0.31214940547943115,
0.2524539828300476,
0.13882872462272644,
0.5408982634544373,
-0.5303902626037598,
-0.37133291363716125,
-0.04918653145432472,
0.45518195629119873,
0.07940150797367096,
-0.3859619200229645,
0.5667881965637207,
-0.4980236291885376,
-0.38932004570961,
-0.3314092457294464,
0.9206016659736633,
-0.3863948583602905,
-0.6165950298309326,
-0.009126213379204273,
0.4100185036659241,
0.001620636903680861,
-0.43174758553504944,
-0.711708664894104,
-0.18936249613761902,
-0.6387438774108887,
-0.049142178148031235,
0.41520461440086365,
0.01141150202602148,
0.07663489878177643,
0.6356288194656372,
0.707698404788971,
0.1913900375366211,
0.6799944043159485,
-0.18278896808624268,
0.942520797252655,
-0.8237721920013428,
-0.6056134700775146,
-0.9939928650856018,
0.23773518204689026,
-0.1472739279270172,
0.0021490948274731636,
0.9320289492607117,
0.7925741672515869,
0.612109899520874,
-0.36363375186920166,
0.46854203939437866,
0.014175706543028355,
0.19884301722049713,
-0.21850991249084473,
0.6416915059089661,
0.05105539411306381,
0.1384488195180893,
0.05397498235106468,
-1.0403995513916016,
-0.5803285241127014,
0.649386465549469,
-0.5690027475357056,
-0.04948514699935913,
0.5812994241714478,
0.49851059913635254,
-0.3175589442253113,
0.15297502279281616,
0.5000016689300537,
0.046444252133369446,
0.20568639039993286,
1.0416251420974731,
1.0234720706939697,
-0.5872758030891418,
0.10952837020158768,
-0.4487544298171997,
0.10421410948038101,
0.0038969600573182106,
-0.8441354632377625,
-1.038367748260498,
-0.48906299471855164,
-0.2343270480632782,
-0.10381735116243362,
0.008181433193385601,
0.6956686973571777,
1.0720698833465576,
-0.6879407167434692,
-0.29793667793273926,
-0.27840545773506165,
-0.06535238027572632,
-0.2765069901943207,
-0.22004342079162598,
0.6774907112121582,
-0.25646841526031494,
-0.8651505708694458,
0.5588318705558777,
0.5253965258598328,
-0.07746915519237518,
-0.30967244505882263,
-0.2057548314332962,
-0.24353404343128204,
-0.009610339067876339,
0.7436705231666565,
0.6333884000778198,
-0.3593682646751404,
-0.1559261530637741,
0.20378267765045166,
0.31000378727912903,
0.506781816482544,
1.2784912586212158,
-1.0510051250457764,
0.6441803574562073,
0.9989400506019592,
0.9469912052154541,
0.3175865709781647,
0.08712691068649292,
0.7372109889984131,
-0.7018937468528748,
0.2608977258205414,
0.3828544318675995,
0.5242043733596802,
0.22608882188796997,
-0.4401407837867737,
0.12536633014678955,
0.22433266043663025,
-0.3421020209789276,
-0.3253072500228882,
0.1208067387342453,
-0.9446766972541809,
-0.14745350182056427,
0.6665024757385254,
-0.34895700216293335,
-0.3866012990474701,
0.20014634728431702,
-0.0403907373547554,
0.4013521671295166,
-0.21090857684612274,
0.9415096640586853,
0.44688329100608826,
-0.5142551064491272,
-0.43055272102355957,
-0.18989425897598267,
0.3546503186225891,
0.6089929342269897,
-0.6235437989234924,
-0.23639462888240814,
0.5257624983787537,
0.07481558620929718,
0.24150654673576355,
0.18056610226631165,
-0.2634323537349701,
0.662034273147583,
-0.3457096219062805,
-0.12468388676643372,
-0.5668107867240906,
-0.9316627979278564,
-0.4035073220729828,
0.33288341760635376,
-0.0889069065451622,
-0.3183864951133728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11845v1
|
Challenging Negative Gender Stereotypes: A Study on the Effectiveness of Automated Counter-Stereotypes
| 2024-04-18T01:48:28 | 2024-04-18T01:48:28 |
Isar Nejadgholi, Kathleen C. Fraser, Anna Kerkhof, Svetlana Kiritchenko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Gender stereotypes are pervasive beliefs about individuals based on their
gender that play a significant role in shaping societal attitudes, behaviours,
and even opportunities. Recognizing the negative implications of gender
stereotypes, particularly in online communications, this study investigates
eleven strategies to automatically counter-act and challenge these views. We
present AI-generated gender-based counter-stereotypes to (self-identified) male
and female study participants and ask them to assess their offensiveness,
plausibility, and potential effectiveness. The strategies of counter-facts and
broadening universals (i.e., stating that anyone can have a trait regardless of
group membership) emerged as the most robust approaches, while humour,
perspective-taking, counter-examples, and empathy for the speaker were
perceived as less effective. Also, the differences in ratings were more
pronounced for stereotypes about the different targets than between the genders
of the raters. Alarmingly, many AI-generated counter-stereotypes were perceived
as offensive and/or implausible. Our analysis and the collected dataset offer
foundational insight into counter-stereotype generation, guiding future efforts
to develop strategies that effectively challenge gender stereotypes in online
interactions.
|
[
-0.8034643530845642,
-0.8324320912361145,
0.15616801381111145,
0.27562186121940613,
-0.022298015654087067,
0.20290744304656982,
0.2594670355319977,
-0.4565388262271881,
0.2559937834739685,
0.2691245377063751,
-0.7075839042663574,
-0.273922324180603,
-0.5337179899215698,
0.6180673241615295,
-0.6029726266860962,
0.6532958745956421,
0.24949294328689575,
0.255704402923584,
-0.3648887276649475,
-0.309918612241745,
-0.8462830781936646,
-0.889970600605011,
-0.37154272198677063,
-0.06817594170570374,
0.2719041407108307,
0.5385314226150513,
0.6313101649284363,
0.21935485303401947,
0.42509299516677856,
0.30539196729660034,
0.08401300013065338,
0.19102706015110016,
-0.8956440687179565,
0.16205649077892303,
-0.1898537129163742,
-0.5955376029014587,
-0.3828898072242737,
0.4123349189758301,
-0.00017327874957118183,
0.5011695027351379,
0.0028777113184332848,
0.4921080470085144,
0.030238961800932884,
0.43706950545310974,
-0.556784451007843,
0.06682217866182327,
-0.5682902932167053,
0.3153553307056427,
-0.18417128920555115,
-0.11141357570886612,
-0.24899865686893463,
-0.38224828243255615,
0.027029840275645256,
-0.542937695980072,
0.3869917392730713,
0.13231252133846283,
0.7054693698883057,
-0.022960305213928223,
-0.6740747094154358,
-0.5366748571395874,
-0.9600844979286194,
0.7469105124473572,
-0.5844398736953735,
0.14006397128105164,
0.5473047494888306,
0.30888834595680237,
0.14702144265174866,
0.11353456228971481,
-0.47554633021354675,
0.005688615143299103,
-0.22520235180854797,
0.10407498478889465,
-0.5906432271003723,
-0.10051919519901276,
0.32445889711380005,
-0.13374006748199463,
-0.5602677464485168,
-0.01584087498486042,
-0.39749354124069214,
0.05581532046198845,
0.7425125241279602,
0.019333651289343834,
0.6475401520729065,
-0.20891587436199188,
0.09761280566453934,
0.2018243670463562,
-0.6530699729919434,
-0.21990644931793213,
0.9229602217674255,
0.25437474250793457,
-0.013141949661076069,
0.48287996649742126,
-0.11828860640525818,
-0.03133755549788475,
0.4972061216831207,
0.13414934277534485,
0.3754022717475891,
0.07059479504823685,
0.10204126685857773,
0.3514317274093628,
0.42912834882736206,
0.5849981307983398,
0.7963849902153015,
0.0486648865044117,
0.022328604012727737,
0.47256824374198914,
0.5430209040641785,
-0.47945454716682434,
0.161252960562706,
0.04123089462518692,
-0.5288467407226562,
-0.5324758887290955,
-0.10707230120897293,
-0.8594098687171936,
-0.5671513080596924,
-0.013258406892418861,
0.5943397283554077,
-0.10821829736232758,
-0.2696487605571747,
-0.31178680062294006,
-0.5920707583427429,
0.2866555452346802,
0.2129123955965042,
-0.7902281880378723,
0.3512323498725891,
0.3643624484539032,
0.6491243839263916,
0.3539259731769562,
0.2823878228664398,
-0.1430538147687912,
0.01441512256860733,
-0.5384864211082458,
0.41508564352989197,
-0.630653977394104,
-0.4516490697860718,
-0.12446960806846619,
-0.10623078048229218,
0.011207249946892262,
-0.45234349370002747,
0.19564251601696014,
0.036384452134370804,
0.4994415044784546,
-0.3605499267578125,
-0.43854308128356934,
0.054354164749383926,
0.6099699139595032,
-0.4452356696128845,
0.6441833972930908,
-0.1510017365217209,
-0.7166599035263062,
0.26953738927841187,
-0.8650309443473816,
-0.45380961894989014,
-0.2372075915336609,
-0.3795115351676941,
-0.33561551570892334,
0.1771862953901291,
0.47138428688049316,
0.008333205245435238,
-0.22230209410190582,
-0.04637075215578079,
-0.4742063283920288,
-0.34390249848365784,
0.21170242130756378,
-0.3501093089580536,
0.9296582341194153,
0.2032514065504074,
-0.6916183233261108,
0.056192416697740555,
-0.2545866072177887,
-0.5199506878852844,
0.39021652936935425,
0.464152455329895,
-0.6978972554206848,
-0.10270728170871735,
-0.4889240562915802,
0.23383300006389618,
-0.2857278287410736,
-0.6608102917671204,
0.00815709587186575,
-0.259933203458786,
0.3370356857776642,
0.7743880748748779,
-0.2525923550128937,
0.11083020269870758,
-0.5027262568473816,
0.8000643253326416,
-0.34083014726638794,
0.4940466582775116,
0.2252398431301117,
-0.7707876563072205,
-0.5097507238388062,
-0.12416540831327438,
-0.10113532096147537,
0.8892009258270264,
-0.7670038938522339,
0.5054923892021179,
0.0006555848522111773,
-0.6216274499893188,
-0.5943388342857361,
0.2774563431739807,
0.5518828630447388,
0.5944741368293762,
0.5337967872619629,
-0.43052437901496887,
-0.775753915309906,
-0.9593536853790283,
-0.7642760872840881,
-0.6184824109077454,
-0.0019105111714452505,
0.3533746600151062,
0.5949224829673767,
-0.09508022665977478,
1.1179770231246948,
-0.45887595415115356,
-0.3118382692337036,
-0.4371815621852875,
0.8915832042694092,
-0.13065318763256073,
0.37124061584472656,
0.7244614362716675,
-0.9756903052330017,
-0.23864687979221344,
-0.86623615026474,
-1.0791479349136353,
-0.407562792301178,
-0.12854379415512085,
0.03540287911891937,
0.21698513627052307,
0.6367178559303284,
-0.581397533416748,
0.6366440653800964,
0.37089455127716064,
-0.5198646187782288,
0.5888422727584839,
0.15073367953300476,
0.5911383032798767,
-0.5403236150741577,
-0.26772454380989075,
0.4571916162967682,
-0.1281091719865799,
-0.9029818773269653,
0.10970409214496613,
-0.49483752250671387,
0.00955009926110506,
-0.530428946018219,
0.5454904437065125,
-0.2846684157848358,
0.05849717557430267,
0.10409277677536011,
-0.3528849482536316,
-0.06624121963977814,
-0.012600529938936234,
-0.021722357720136642,
0.6942298412322998,
0.07459407299757004,
-0.4260844588279724,
0.2882944345474243,
0.515592098236084,
-0.12104393541812897,
0.9452335834503174,
-0.670801043510437,
0.4115987718105316,
-0.6944893002510071,
0.5492974519729614,
-1.4429824352264404,
0.18714867532253265,
0.45418626070022583,
-0.6801526546478271,
-0.12997768819332123,
-0.06046540290117264,
-0.20868417620658875,
-0.5069754123687744,
-0.3494958281517029,
0.6509798169136047,
0.5845806002616882,
-0.2371806502342224,
0.6065416932106018,
0.3639777898788452,
-0.1627858281135559,
-0.46600764989852905,
-0.7229530215263367,
0.5037069916725159,
-0.6805942058563232,
-0.24023769795894623,
-0.10448604077100754,
-0.1362607628107071,
-0.7430071830749512,
-0.5002539157867432,
0.15447428822517395,
-0.09625430405139923,
0.10746417939662933,
0.1460035890340805,
0.11071670800447464,
0.1298598051071167,
0.03915991261601448,
-0.21502657234668732,
0.10974431782960892,
0.1455533504486084,
0.0594390444457531,
0.6511003971099854,
-0.11487629264593124,
-0.33312496542930603,
-0.29646629095077515,
0.3374422788619995,
0.4430307149887085,
0.2705662250518799,
0.7668880224227905,
0.8493433594703674,
-0.2295890599489212,
0.23435169458389282,
-0.6100792288780212,
-0.502099871635437,
-0.47589805722236633,
0.10273977369070053,
-0.22363825142383575,
-0.4533226191997528,
0.33725184202194214,
0.10747961699962616,
0.08404132723808289,
0.3465944230556488,
0.042412374168634415,
-0.6716920137405396,
1.3903144598007202,
0.6131104826927185,
-0.01259689498692751,
0.14457418024539948,
-0.00557344825938344,
0.2396559864282608,
-0.28093191981315613,
0.04761314392089844,
-0.6823949813842773,
-0.4533225893974304,
-0.6704410314559937,
-0.18164202570915222,
0.3840813636779785,
-0.2006576508283615,
-0.505403459072113,
0.40942105650901794,
-0.42960527539253235,
-0.06519709527492523,
0.4675951302051544,
0.03371383249759674,
0.18748922646045685,
-0.2731721103191376,
0.14221306145191193,
-0.4425150454044342,
-0.6309899091720581,
-0.4898073971271515,
0.9202979207038879,
0.3315572142601013,
0.677878737449646,
0.42953750491142273,
0.3999801576137543,
1.1325197219848633,
0.4751187562942505,
-0.5092875361442566,
0.7831652164459229,
-0.33007797598838806,
-1.2063692808151245,
-0.23075458407402039,
-0.5868232250213623,
-0.5514875650405884,
-0.10807785391807556,
-0.42675620317459106,
-0.8075913190841675,
0.3804623484611511,
0.5936902165412903,
0.2512891888618469,
0.45521748065948486,
-0.6236494779586792,
0.7289984226226807,
-0.39052221179008484,
-0.0871753841638565,
-0.21793466806411743,
-0.7493590712547302,
0.4555269181728363,
-0.03556022047996521,
0.6664489507675171,
-0.12673859298229218,
0.2896759808063507,
0.3898012042045593,
-0.06811497360467911,
1.3078635931015015,
-0.18911980092525482,
-0.2669302225112915,
0.17253820598125458,
0.2281571328639984,
0.185556560754776,
-0.5060425400733948,
-0.014248497784137726,
0.7153265476226807,
-0.2859845459461212,
-0.42862844467163086,
-0.3332770764827728,
-0.06822191178798676,
-0.9210512638092041,
-0.6736177206039429,
-0.14234736561775208,
-0.35972079634666443,
-0.23689767718315125,
-0.016019616276025772,
0.30107057094573975,
0.5774628520011902,
-0.6626566052436829,
-0.2247866839170456,
0.6651673913002014,
-0.8053673505783081,
-0.1988348513841629,
0.15224455296993256,
-0.3171120882034302,
-0.28942570090293884,
1.15659499168396,
0.20588764548301697,
0.5812745690345764,
0.41046470403671265,
0.37694379687309265,
-0.34867772459983826,
0.1356310397386551,
-0.4804932773113251,
-0.02080216258764267,
-0.6640394330024719,
0.19683358073234558,
-0.6865115761756897,
0.01995749957859516,
-1.1094651222229004,
-0.18950124084949493,
-0.32129809260368347,
-0.5450150966644287,
-0.022745000198483467,
0.05203825980424881,
0.22047226130962372,
0.6267904043197632,
-0.17707806825637817,
0.3937852084636688,
-0.47297024726867676,
0.7289147973060608,
0.6415871381759644,
-0.24118535220623016,
-0.21913018822669983,
-0.3134520947933197,
0.5795800685882568,
0.06310621649026871,
-0.08080696314573288,
-0.9868744015693665,
0.503247082233429,
-0.0017261509783565998,
0.5082182288169861,
0.6171444654464722,
0.4506550133228302,
0.5176169276237488,
-0.09551281481981277,
0.6053389310836792,
0.3408087193965912,
-1.0588515996932983,
0.47469523549079895,
-0.41925787925720215,
0.07242483645677567,
0.29637181758880615,
0.7569622993469238,
-0.7101988196372986,
-0.7878547310829163,
-0.640419065952301,
-0.7774852514266968,
0.10969357937574387,
0.6629334688186646,
0.2914888560771942,
-0.11969858407974243,
0.14007937908172607,
0.27260446548461914,
0.7207160592079163,
-0.5587812662124634,
-0.644199550151825,
-0.8791168928146362,
-0.30705350637435913,
0.10442356765270233,
-0.12438131123781204,
-0.3884337842464447,
-0.34444326162338257,
0.5351800918579102,
-0.09909866005182266,
0.31589969992637634,
0.13337719440460205,
-0.24956734478473663,
0.15418413281440735,
0.5709009766578674,
0.5561221241950989,
0.627082884311676,
-0.5587382912635803,
0.15482230484485626,
0.31961172819137573,
-0.2916581332683563,
0.35522913932800293,
-0.16073602437973022,
-0.6063400506973267,
0.11178098618984222,
0.2193095088005066,
0.4301188290119171,
-0.2753835618495941,
-0.5091159343719482,
0.24166817963123322,
-0.38654404878616333,
-0.2672092318534851,
-0.3160005807876587,
-0.16828306019306183,
-0.10143055766820908,
-0.13607120513916016,
0.3994475305080414,
0.04411793500185013,
0.1349114179611206,
-1.0319114923477173,
-0.11210954189300537,
0.6222138404846191,
-0.6070734262466431,
-0.08798286318778992,
0.6230697631835938,
0.6163979172706604,
-0.33729949593544006,
0.5208693146705627,
-0.30875834822654724,
-0.6818442344665527,
0.9696516394615173,
0.6834168434143066,
0.8408224582672119,
-0.08812397718429565,
0.5862206220626831,
0.40623000264167786,
0.7073951363563538,
0.188240185379982,
-0.15118050575256348,
0.29707396030426025,
-1.0903009176254272,
0.3448121249675751,
-0.16062228381633759,
-0.5644002556800842,
-0.03857335075736046,
-0.346577912569046,
0.27515289187431335,
-0.4457017779350281,
-0.4829201400279999,
-0.10516203194856644,
-0.36981266736984253,
-0.6542527079582214,
0.1859840452671051,
0.4586782157421112,
0.8432725667953491,
-1.0641204118728638,
0.07416092604398727,
0.7028396725654602,
-0.5669477581977844,
-0.27399900555610657,
0.32664942741394043,
0.9628672003746033,
-0.7648618817329407,
0.762248158454895,
0.3481782078742981,
-0.6082331538200378,
-0.05090930685400963,
-0.6118549704551697,
-0.4303615093231201,
0.4566558003425598,
0.26174765825271606,
-0.544589638710022,
-0.12721972167491913,
0.47011449933052063,
0.44515812397003174,
-0.49522140622138977,
0.8562955260276794,
0.4790850877761841,
0.6716526746749878,
-0.06494598835706711,
-1.1556962728500366,
0.039849188178777695,
-0.41470372676849365,
-0.24067126214504242,
-0.28180360794067383,
-0.5444687604904175,
0.7270215749740601,
-0.11243877559900284,
-0.10559681802988052,
0.1511399894952774,
0.28791260719299316,
0.0700790211558342,
0.2602100968360901,
1.0481407642364502,
0.3309482932090759,
0.42975062131881714,
0.16864289343357086,
0.5715224146842957,
0.011348539032042027,
-0.03480584919452667,
0.6680865287780762,
-0.2972392141819,
0.1407083421945572,
0.11116976290941238,
0.21174034476280212,
0.4572337865829468,
0.016443876549601555,
-0.10764352232217789,
0.009422148577868938,
0.38583701848983765,
-0.07927923649549484,
-0.3734429180622101,
-0.5349481701850891,
-0.3669361472129822,
0.8746949434280396,
0.4658418893814087,
-0.03567535802721977,
-0.2835216224193573,
0.011118616908788681,
0.12340310961008072,
0.3985444903373718,
-0.3197658956050873,
0.6495385766029358,
0.024502454325556755,
-0.23375727236270905,
0.3384620249271393,
-0.19050706923007965,
1.0642950534820557,
-0.4415720999240875,
-0.27477502822875977,
-0.30559682846069336,
0.10135186463594437,
-0.11932681500911713,
-0.2682700455188751,
0.19773347675800323,
0.22961775958538055,
-0.07057228684425354,
-0.3782522678375244,
0.9545924663543701,
-0.20770509541034698,
-0.726274847984314,
0.20637360215187073,
0.7112517356872559,
0.22353197634220123,
0.022373635321855545,
-0.6896367073059082,
-0.22474059462547302,
-0.15442295372486115,
0.36064907908439636,
0.27192074060440063,
0.01663580723106861,
-0.2321377843618393,
1.0496673583984375,
0.39809685945510864,
0.16613513231277466,
-0.25106263160705566,
0.24808655679225922,
0.34136712551116943,
-0.7185226082801819,
-0.61040860414505,
-0.7847521901130676,
0.06785597652196884,
-0.2905558943748474,
-0.40952107310295105,
0.9259608387947083,
0.16553674638271332,
0.7927054762840271,
0.14117152988910675,
0.8895019888877869,
-0.11019718647003174,
0.5523756146430969,
0.12294276803731918,
0.7815014719963074,
-0.4991321563720703,
0.25170642137527466,
-0.8749228715896606,
-0.5705134868621826,
-0.09372600167989731,
0.5074706673622131,
-0.43425706028938293,
0.1496506631374359,
-0.029511943459510803,
0.7223948836326599,
0.20191124081611633,
0.17563270032405853,
0.03141789138317108,
0.43596503138542175,
0.7413904070854187,
0.058070216327905655,
1.163060188293457,
-0.11189906299114227,
0.8445252180099487,
-0.0677490159869194,
-0.2223861813545227,
-0.10863916575908661,
-0.8168820142745972,
-1.1168427467346191,
0.04699212685227394,
-0.4289332628250122,
-0.43853384256362915,
0.42618703842163086,
1.135132908821106,
0.5326622724533081,
-0.5860469341278076,
-0.4392242431640625,
-0.09216182678937912,
0.23698391020298004,
-0.3111560344696045,
-0.27348262071609497,
-0.25744131207466125,
0.06201743334531784,
-0.5513113141059875,
0.04815545678138733,
-0.11733423918485641,
-0.15821999311447144,
-0.4252315163612366,
0.08508256077766418,
-0.27814286947250366,
0.49490347504615784,
0.7090087532997131,
0.4844461679458618,
-0.4151571989059448,
-0.4528863728046417,
-0.07552262395620346,
-0.13999006152153015,
-0.0480797216296196,
0.6570090651512146,
-0.7249866127967834,
0.39380282163619995,
0.5224144458770752,
0.11110157519578934,
-0.2163679003715515,
0.5657233595848083,
1.069661259651184,
-0.6824836134910583,
0.052243467420339584,
0.20296229422092438,
-0.01438625156879425,
0.43942946195602417,
-0.5047604441642761,
0.4441359341144562,
0.7265669107437134,
-0.06312073022127151,
-0.6700791716575623,
0.3405779004096985,
-0.31363630294799805,
-0.6413873434066772,
0.8819044232368469,
0.1627131551504135,
0.271067351102829,
-0.5886980891227722,
-0.16446267068386078,
0.42005065083503723,
-0.4887538552284241,
1.3912817239761353,
0.5510170459747314,
-0.41902318596839905,
-0.08429517596960068,
-0.613969087600708,
0.3919178545475006,
0.4802186191082001,
-0.8572604656219482,
-0.16581547260284424,
0.355666846036911,
0.2044277936220169,
0.26109716296195984,
0.5730669498443604,
0.10690271109342575,
-0.07296762615442276,
-0.025961728766560555,
0.12449323385953903,
0.0830049216747284,
-0.30587610602378845,
-0.009444927796721458,
-0.012760266661643982,
-0.47395145893096924,
-0.12508319318294525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11826v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11826v1
|
AdvisorQA: Towards Helpful and Harmless Advice-seeking Question Answering with Collective Intelligence
| 2024-04-18T01:15:41 | 2024-04-18T01:15:41 |
Minbeom Kim, Hwanhee Lee, Joonsuk Park, Hwaran Lee, Kyomin Jung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As the integration of large language models into daily life is on the rise,
there is a clear gap in benchmarks for advising on subjective and personal
dilemmas. To address this, we introduce AdvisorQA, the first benchmark
developed to assess LLMs' capability in offering advice for deeply personalized
concerns, utilizing the LifeProTips subreddit forum. This forum features a
dynamic interaction where users post advice-seeking questions, receiving an
average of 8.9 advice per query, with 164.2 upvotes from hundreds of users,
embodying a collective intelligence framework. Therefore, we've completed a
benchmark encompassing daily life questions, diverse corresponding responses,
and majority vote ranking to train our helpfulness metric. Baseline experiments
validate the efficacy of AdvisorQA through our helpfulness metric, GPT-4, and
human evaluation, analyzing phenomena beyond the trade-off between helpfulness
and harmlessness. AdvisorQA marks a significant leap in enhancing QA systems
for providing personalized, empathetic advice, showcasing LLMs' improved
understanding of human subjectivity.
|
[
-0.36712485551834106,
-0.7687061429023743,
0.6372959613800049,
0.29228612780570984,
-0.23049837350845337,
0.2488548755645752,
0.192371666431427,
-0.273043692111969,
0.26937854290008545,
0.1700378656387329,
-0.9950594902038574,
-0.7438328862190247,
-0.44842690229415894,
0.028400657698512077,
-0.09410952776670456,
0.90080326795578,
0.5092899799346924,
0.26566946506500244,
-0.34305518865585327,
-0.14842243492603302,
-0.673018753528595,
-0.4624510407447815,
-0.9314343929290771,
0.10991435497999191,
0.8123767971992493,
0.7045198082923889,
0.7482953667640686,
0.05296013504266739,
0.549592137336731,
0.18823227286338806,
-0.08890827745199203,
0.33882105350494385,
-0.47994670271873474,
0.10780036449432373,
-0.003126756753772497,
-0.3728315532207489,
-0.96808260679245,
0.22914692759513855,
-0.18699540197849274,
0.6683938503265381,
-0.42212021350860596,
0.4006655216217041,
-0.11328988522291183,
0.5045292973518372,
-0.6789284944534302,
-0.262249618768692,
-0.5742848515510559,
-0.019577493891119957,
-0.10072177648544312,
0.03910692036151886,
-0.10081078112125397,
-0.8778014183044434,
0.254073828458786,
-0.8101465106010437,
-0.14959530532360077,
-0.07125085592269897,
0.2801071107387543,
0.4927254319190979,
-0.28259751200675964,
-0.3267492651939392,
-0.49828535318374634,
0.7575028538703918,
-0.590269148349762,
0.1391117423772812,
0.3799439072608948,
0.630439043045044,
-0.12244747579097748,
-0.6369532346725464,
-0.11163981258869171,
-0.21023529767990112,
0.3309682011604309,
0.23700611293315887,
-0.7238591313362122,
-0.1439201980829239,
-0.0685473084449768,
0.11353752762079239,
-0.21886353194713593,
-0.22121813893318176,
-0.1903005689382553,
-0.36459046602249146,
0.864914059638977,
0.1706545352935791,
0.26373741030693054,
-0.035111427307128906,
-0.44604402780532837,
0.1862504780292511,
-0.7728242874145508,
0.33006709814071655,
0.29858461022377014,
-0.22208242118358612,
0.17725248634815216,
0.39519086480140686,
-0.33687230944633484,
0.23484379053115845,
0.12035154551267624,
0.09430744498968124,
-0.052042074501514435,
-0.4663494825363159,
0.15904594957828522,
-0.004979290533810854,
0.5163106918334961,
0.8722292184829712,
0.5504637956619263,
-0.44160377979278564,
-0.08556142449378967,
0.022517237812280655,
0.6689404249191284,
-0.47439005970954895,
-0.25673991441726685,
0.21499478816986084,
-0.29075267910957336,
-0.16448770463466644,
-0.12766258418560028,
-0.7974886298179626,
-0.7200720906257629,
-0.06457294523715973,
0.38465556502342224,
-0.33623239398002625,
-0.24716664850711823,
0.10468775033950806,
0.056051675230264664,
0.32110142707824707,
0.3861894905567169,
-0.32725459337234497,
0.4329829216003418,
0.8281567692756653,
0.5404057502746582,
-0.416467547416687,
0.09487226605415344,
-0.7882529497146606,
-0.030656876042485237,
-0.3511463403701782,
1.2712172269821167,
-0.5330346822738647,
-0.6417315006256104,
-0.0625293105840683,
-0.3660562038421631,
0.4266733229160309,
-0.8569333553314209,
1.004828929901123,
-0.4003295600414276,
-0.2749697268009186,
-0.7927352786064148,
-0.3527444899082184,
-0.17884185910224915,
0.4228678047657013,
-0.0367954857647419,
1.1154375076293945,
0.09999983012676239,
-0.4985737204551697,
0.5366453528404236,
-0.7699216604232788,
-0.013196013867855072,
0.36183038353919983,
-0.11649167537689209,
-0.03666280582547188,
-0.21555155515670776,
0.2622860074043274,
0.5932305455207825,
-0.3446207046508789,
0.1330207884311676,
-0.49091094732284546,
-0.19467192888259888,
0.4194307029247284,
-0.37724724411964417,
0.6067017316818237,
0.16724523901939392,
-0.2156379669904709,
0.16554522514343262,
-0.6607699990272522,
0.21815946698188782,
-0.21928684413433075,
-0.05508001521229744,
-0.7075532674789429,
-0.1940690129995346,
-0.456266313791275,
0.10892988741397858,
0.32156476378440857,
-0.5716933608055115,
0.2000267654657364,
-0.4207819998264313,
0.4158899784088135,
0.7542137503623962,
0.5589184761047363,
0.18390390276908875,
-0.5585934519767761,
0.8126732707023621,
0.008275873027741909,
0.5032064318656921,
0.4572030305862427,
-0.7908234596252441,
-0.5069210529327393,
0.010754036717116833,
-0.11913497000932693,
0.630634069442749,
-0.5597880482673645,
0.2913955748081207,
-0.0051394314505159855,
-0.7384465336799622,
-0.4947911500930786,
0.4766154885292053,
0.5119529366493225,
0.4519249498844147,
0.524817943572998,
-0.5202446579933167,
-0.2621290981769562,
-1.1568841934204102,
-0.5687718391418457,
-0.15717294812202454,
0.034318793565034866,
0.24670736491680145,
0.11508990079164505,
-0.19505615532398224,
0.9493497014045715,
-0.4638851583003998,
-0.3244819939136505,
0.011332271620631218,
0.05753004923462868,
0.03657723218202591,
0.16044016182422638,
0.4943879544734955,
-0.6843180656433105,
-0.32684263586997986,
-0.3726091980934143,
-0.52410888671875,
-0.23057039082050323,
0.22726599872112274,
-0.5002877116203308,
-0.4496668875217438,
0.4406983554363251,
-0.5655792951583862,
0.3545442819595337,
0.11253970116376877,
-0.4861356317996979,
0.40377676486968994,
-0.12227856367826462,
-0.11456660181283951,
-1.0321184396743774,
-0.14687283337116241,
-0.06028999760746956,
-0.2295076847076416,
-0.7373220920562744,
-0.07120687514543533,
-0.24384284019470215,
0.3200443983078003,
-0.43372678756713867,
0.7307206988334656,
-0.22653651237487793,
-0.02600211091339588,
0.009431174956262112,
0.536113977432251,
-0.369438499212265,
0.4129331111907959,
-0.7425453066825867,
1.2638341188430786,
0.3239198625087738,
-0.7921376824378967,
0.41145020723342896,
0.6065855026245117,
-0.026029318571090698,
1.009838342666626,
-0.7111629247665405,
0.4852325916290283,
0.07578575611114502,
-0.0035412891302257776,
-0.8919878005981445,
-0.10698172450065613,
0.5405555963516235,
-0.5374569296836853,
-0.2239723652601242,
0.25672292709350586,
-0.13869015872478485,
-0.268044650554657,
-0.5674623847007751,
0.5339735746383667,
0.3805994391441345,
-0.31928205490112305,
0.9325124621391296,
0.5761828422546387,
-0.37482696771621704,
-0.857418417930603,
-0.4834056496620178,
0.08752976357936859,
-0.31976988911628723,
-0.4502115547657013,
0.1587643325328827,
-0.4903600215911865,
-0.6876073479652405,
0.0402214415371418,
-0.2448325753211975,
-0.199815571308136,
0.3175821304321289,
0.5283506512641907,
0.16511261463165283,
0.027605395764112473,
0.15367011725902557,
-0.012238777242600918,
-0.3197081983089447,
0.6857469081878662,
-0.007939922623336315,
0.3502937853336334,
-0.34242281317710876,
-0.5705530643463135,
-0.18291406333446503,
0.14530307054519653,
0.3613132834434509,
-0.22744804620742798,
0.3716600835323334,
0.4574988782405853,
-0.31824934482574463,
-0.0898255705833435,
-0.8332246541976929,
-0.057210009545087814,
-0.5065786838531494,
0.15912510454654694,
-0.1931481659412384,
-0.6543252468109131,
0.6305031180381775,
-0.0017846445553004742,
0.2513742446899414,
0.343886137008667,
0.5591789484024048,
0.04364558309316635,
0.9441480040550232,
0.3828696310520172,
-0.1652299463748932,
0.0036710118874907494,
-0.20321671664714813,
0.2811400592327118,
-0.7385499477386475,
-0.3804807662963867,
-0.3051106035709381,
-0.23800204694271088,
-0.15253454446792603,
-0.2900523543357849,
0.6113720536231995,
-0.09255296736955643,
-0.2735061049461365,
0.08186212182044983,
-0.744854748249054,
0.39237940311431885,
0.6658649444580078,
0.3304411470890045,
0.5521371960639954,
-0.5502297878265381,
-0.12938840687274933,
-0.1292640119791031,
-0.4372558891773224,
-0.6221432089805603,
1.0347840785980225,
0.2425425946712494,
0.5544202327728271,
0.3350866138935089,
0.6145520210266113,
0.4814613461494446,
0.7043068408966064,
-0.9939945936203003,
0.9286737442016602,
-0.003545396262779832,
-0.6891282796859741,
-0.016359813511371613,
-0.30524659156799316,
-0.6144258379936218,
-0.33434537053108215,
-0.14088024199008942,
-0.7581237554550171,
0.19061493873596191,
0.10502410680055618,
-0.9060288071632385,
0.03195025399327278,
-0.6768490672111511,
0.5850863456726074,
-0.27419334650039673,
-0.4506768584251404,
-0.2401464730501175,
-0.5346114039421082,
0.42307668924331665,
-0.05344342440366745,
0.23491039872169495,
-0.48283809423446655,
-0.5776497721672058,
0.7160478830337524,
-0.033541999757289886,
0.6841099858283997,
-0.47282353043556213,
-0.12541836500167847,
0.31019121408462524,
0.2692878246307373,
0.14550164341926575,
0.42239490151405334,
-0.18196536600589752,
-0.23654504120349884,
0.25135332345962524,
-0.42630240321159363,
-0.5597169399261475,
0.5818544030189514,
-0.7534863948822021,
-0.8927191495895386,
-0.2223442643880844,
-0.4005366563796997,
-0.6950042843818665,
0.05889464542269707,
0.0890367403626442,
0.44293999671936035,
-0.4421212375164032,
0.19321796298027039,
0.6675286293029785,
-0.18132001161575317,
0.14363287389278412,
0.4593490660190582,
-0.23791973292827606,
-0.34461158514022827,
0.6520330309867859,
0.022128785029053688,
0.05888158082962036,
0.04258670657873154,
0.14705698192119598,
-0.5256810188293457,
-0.5611165761947632,
-0.2947319746017456,
0.04624524340033531,
-1.0271917581558228,
-0.5697329044342041,
-0.7090858221054077,
-0.08307349681854248,
-0.22909857332706451,
0.026699790731072426,
-0.38556140661239624,
-0.28746646642684937,
-0.18362407386302948,
-0.2647765278816223,
0.5477349758148193,
0.8824114203453064,
0.022131456062197685,
-0.0916997492313385,
-0.9887763261795044,
0.17595180869102478,
0.7612348794937134,
0.18312853574752808,
-0.04632990434765816,
-0.25169041752815247,
0.18013933300971985,
-0.0661686584353447,
-0.48293086886405945,
-0.9162155389785767,
-0.07240135967731476,
0.2392721027135849,
0.8860357999801636,
0.767982542514801,
0.7725620269775391,
0.4377996325492859,
0.09035951644182205,
0.8848980665206909,
-0.30999451875686646,
-0.6599204540252686,
0.30003610253334045,
-0.4445418417453766,
0.24538347125053406,
1.0924898386001587,
0.5667380094528198,
-0.34448596835136414,
-0.5322998762130737,
-0.3908899426460266,
-0.5891554355621338,
0.20105154812335968,
0.11911740899085999,
0.4572224020957947,
0.059067316353321075,
1.0028886795043945,
0.07129642367362976,
0.21272049844264984,
-0.5827420353889465,
-0.41257232427597046,
0.07145275175571442,
-0.11650259792804718,
0.4903200566768646,
-0.33247390389442444,
-0.41908058524131775,
-0.33201563358306885,
0.5717397332191467,
-0.15942862629890442,
0.40596795082092285,
0.3425254821777344,
0.3919386565685272,
-0.13497498631477356,
0.355927437543869,
0.4852004647254944,
0.9980819821357727,
-0.1463334709405899,
0.01222468912601471,
0.7483915686607361,
-0.5135999321937561,
0.20582585036754608,
0.0591103658080101,
0.08162061870098114,
-0.4353004992008209,
0.22257377207279205,
0.12706540524959564,
0.40331998467445374,
-0.6795713901519775,
0.7318791151046753,
-0.5308951735496521,
-0.38335341215133667,
-0.5723922848701477,
0.6545610427856445,
0.2514048218727112,
0.15716323256492615,
0.7385153770446777,
0.0805182158946991,
0.38648730516433716,
-0.5242534279823303,
0.15183289349079132,
0.7406230568885803,
-0.5926625728607178,
-0.3325973153114319,
0.6799328923225403,
0.3822985589504242,
-0.6100205779075623,
0.18844851851463318,
-0.3067016303539276,
-0.6369720697402954,
0.5056067109107971,
-0.16520246863365173,
0.8539937138557434,
-0.0908658355474472,
0.42324045300483704,
0.28780582547187805,
-0.01843402348458767,
0.30030566453933716,
0.3632528483867645,
-0.14450083673000336,
-0.5986485481262207,
-0.10230810195207596,
-0.4390805959701538,
-0.9290123581886292,
-0.066892109811306,
-0.783171534538269,
0.14244699478149414,
-0.6365229487419128,
-0.3193866014480591,
0.05490519478917122,
0.3125568628311157,
-0.5285441875457764,
0.22653821110725403,
-0.2884846031665802,
1.248419165611267,
-0.2620074152946472,
0.5891487002372742,
0.9721457362174988,
-0.2901620864868164,
-1.1125456094741821,
0.29758626222610474,
0.14858710765838623,
-0.8115990161895752,
0.3289993405342102,
0.20829813182353973,
-0.6828650236129761,
-0.04136142134666443,
-0.6893333196640015,
-0.46447670459747314,
1.1331385374069214,
0.33794960379600525,
-0.2406124770641327,
-0.12814071774482727,
0.01091932412236929,
0.6372772455215454,
-0.37166452407836914,
0.406574010848999,
0.6328869462013245,
0.6502912640571594,
-0.013871164992451668,
-0.4573371112346649,
0.1225995123386383,
-0.48756274580955505,
-0.40764549374580383,
-0.20060046017169952,
-0.8256393671035767,
0.5444610714912415,
-0.16728585958480835,
-0.2651066184043884,
0.35495725274086,
0.5382739305496216,
0.18666593730449677,
0.6346325874328613,
0.7336743474006653,
0.16948436200618744,
0.6958325505256653,
0.00419055437669158,
1.0547819137573242,
-0.6016288995742798,
-0.19850632548332214,
0.9116060137748718,
-0.023405805230140686,
0.7689475417137146,
0.35728058218955994,
-0.1702614426612854,
0.4126874804496765,
0.7282146215438843,
0.15993104875087738,
0.4428231418132782,
0.01348137203603983,
-0.41808363795280457,
-0.4436464309692383,
-0.3561742603778839,
-0.4494045078754425,
0.3705717921257019,
0.18391700088977814,
0.14531175792217255,
-0.17507217824459076,
-0.12553156912326813,
-0.04577159881591797,
0.3184189796447754,
-0.2405991554260254,
0.8898167610168457,
0.3128734529018402,
-0.8905147910118103,
0.1895676702260971,
-0.2188185155391693,
0.7328615784645081,
-0.553218424320221,
0.004005642142146826,
-0.6288111209869385,
0.20157791674137115,
-0.15530763566493988,
-0.7789211273193359,
0.3334427773952484,
0.016853269189596176,
0.19867528975009918,
-0.026073995977640152,
0.8269750475883484,
0.11799968779087067,
-0.26497113704681396,
0.6859067678451538,
1.0094740390777588,
0.046050041913986206,
-0.04941080883145332,
-0.789100706577301,
-0.5879647135734558,
-0.29237040877342224,
-0.21806666254997253,
0.05966172739863396,
0.5745202302932739,
0.2760283648967743,
1.184637427330017,
0.5367779731750488,
0.05334942787885666,
-0.03872578591108322,
-0.18563495576381683,
1.2820440530776978,
-0.5190383791923523,
-0.2549755871295929,
-0.6142722964286804,
0.31170862913131714,
0.0037491749972105026,
-0.8276515007019043,
0.9032829999923706,
0.24912573397159576,
0.4990622401237488,
0.2302648425102234,
0.2950153648853302,
0.21766993403434753,
0.8871984481811523,
-0.30454710125923157,
0.6903161406517029,
-0.7569608688354492,
0.6482443809509277,
-0.09544304758310318,
-0.987437903881073,
-0.15862910449504852,
0.2827298641204834,
-0.5684645771980286,
0.18797430396080017,
0.33089831471443176,
1.023833990097046,
0.12781231105327606,
0.1729915589094162,
0.24420610070228577,
0.1727517992258072,
0.3291689455509186,
0.5234327912330627,
1.1341849565505981,
-0.03408844396471977,
0.9216615557670593,
-0.32401350140571594,
0.0005673334817402065,
-0.03753837198019028,
-0.6302655339241028,
-1.0038203001022339,
-0.18756695091724396,
-0.1341271549463272,
-0.1216866746544838,
0.2976504862308502,
1.293764352798462,
0.7480183839797974,
-0.8115241527557373,
0.1974390745162964,
-0.18167610466480255,
-0.11891769617795944,
-0.10085415840148926,
-0.22645410895347595,
-0.061668142676353455,
-0.08911195397377014,
-0.4790310859680176,
0.42105937004089355,
0.17786350846290588,
-0.2116585373878479,
-0.6878526210784912,
-0.11612425744533539,
-0.08832333236932755,
0.2933889627456665,
0.11221394687891006,
0.1161460280418396,
-0.7413870096206665,
-0.5560076832771301,
0.3883349895477295,
-0.29286617040634155,
0.17555256187915802,
0.6095860600471497,
-0.6669601798057556,
0.18241627514362335,
-0.07469780743122101,
0.9346739649772644,
-0.10664748400449753,
0.3578561842441559,
0.7262348532676697,
-0.7125294208526611,
-0.2184702754020691,
0.38628602027893066,
-0.18262223899364471,
0.3030557334423065,
-0.8581373691558838,
0.7828493118286133,
-0.19684097170829773,
-0.7050831913948059,
-0.5202857851982117,
0.05523622781038284,
-1.0983332395553589,
0.07642059028148651,
1.0176385641098022,
-0.42097413539886475,
0.03499375283718109,
-0.4726330637931824,
-0.5712860226631165,
0.019888069480657578,
-0.8679173588752747,
0.9428070187568665,
0.633584201335907,
-0.4278467893600464,
-0.36773523688316345,
-0.6841864585876465,
0.7409321069717407,
0.722663402557373,
-1.1303396224975586,
-0.08672429621219635,
0.3173467218875885,
0.13648191094398499,
0.323180615901947,
0.6907418966293335,
0.15976043045520782,
0.6069237589836121,
-0.26077765226364136,
-0.43546998500823975,
-0.14622995257377625,
-0.18591323494911194,
-0.13704130053520203,
0.26314181089401245,
0.40576526522636414,
-0.0639374852180481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02318v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02318v1
|
NL2FOL: Translating Natural Language to First-Order Logic for Logical Fallacy Detection
| 2024-04-18T00:20:48 | 2024-04-18T00:20:48 |
Abhinav Lalwani, Lovish Chopra, Christopher Hahn, Caroline Trippel, Zhijing Jin, Mrinmaya Sachan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.LO
|
Logical fallacies are common errors in reasoning that undermine the logic of
an argument. Automatically detecting logical fallacies has important
applications in tracking misinformation and validating claims. In this paper,
we design a process to reliably detect logical fallacies by translating natural
language to First-order Logic (FOL) step-by-step using Large Language Models
(LLMs). We then utilize Satisfiability Modulo Theory (SMT) solvers to reason
about the validity of the formula and classify inputs as either a fallacy or
valid statement. Our model also provides a novel means of utilizing LLMs to
interpret the output of the SMT solver, offering insights into the
counter-examples that illustrate why a given sentence is considered a logical
fallacy. Our approach is robust, interpretable and does not require training
data or fine-tuning. We evaluate our model on a mixed dataset of fallacies and
valid sentences. The results demonstrate improved performance compared to
end-to-end LLMs, with our classifier achieving an F1-score of 71\% on the Logic
dataset. The approach is able to generalize effectively, achieving an F1-score
of 73% on the challenge set, LogicClimate, outperforming state-of-the-art
models by 21% despite its much smaller size.
|
[
-0.028682878240942955,
-0.8035218119621277,
0.5778731107711792,
0.29499199986457825,
-0.33119720220565796,
-0.10033101588487625,
-0.017847323790192604,
-0.36144158244132996,
-0.39092615246772766,
0.7500332593917847,
-0.4572642147541046,
-0.3847871720790863,
-0.796629011631012,
0.3159937262535095,
-0.5161157846450806,
1.0211830139160156,
-0.09671737253665924,
-0.026860691606998444,
-0.24001555144786835,
-0.04710590839385986,
-0.2890597879886627,
-0.4325379431247711,
-0.5146300792694092,
-0.5605506896972656,
-0.14121654629707336,
0.3077392280101776,
0.6591468453407288,
0.15880176424980164,
0.5321589708328247,
0.2963651120662689,
-0.10586783289909363,
0.6309279203414917,
-0.5409628748893738,
-0.22021199762821198,
-0.13261184096336365,
-0.7689601182937622,
-0.15705348551273346,
0.16688013076782227,
0.19923920929431915,
0.20450173318386078,
-0.49779802560806274,
0.03945167735219002,
-0.3382812440395355,
0.7883297204971313,
-0.3088929355144501,
0.3428853452205658,
-0.8794305920600891,
0.2783343195915222,
0.08415543287992477,
-0.17886948585510254,
-0.914684534072876,
-0.6043062210083008,
-0.007580254226922989,
-0.424285888671875,
0.14915651082992554,
0.18924276530742645,
0.6380835771560669,
0.6871659755706787,
-0.3735033869743347,
-0.4942142069339752,
-0.6025482416152954,
1.032698392868042,
-1.1430449485778809,
0.5841125249862671,
0.05472407117486,
0.37266862392425537,
-0.4829331934452057,
-0.5859521627426147,
-0.7264583110809326,
-0.5030733942985535,
-0.3368222415447235,
0.021433653309941292,
-0.25349560379981995,
-0.0971963033080101,
0.44002553820610046,
0.2626700699329376,
-0.562228798866272,
-0.24231897294521332,
-0.09918785095214844,
-0.2703987658023834,
0.6472593545913696,
-0.0026464788243174553,
0.2286902666091919,
-0.1937142312526703,
-0.6113845705986023,
0.26535260677337646,
-0.5758043527603149,
-0.07415639609098434,
-0.05184243246912956,
0.33782559633255005,
0.0764128714799881,
0.47817134857177734,
0.012240600772202015,
0.7075330018997192,
0.1547045111656189,
-0.6524770855903625,
0.19585630297660828,
-0.5269185900688171,
-0.45102325081825256,
0.017982201650738716,
0.4995443820953369,
0.3885456919670105,
0.44419318437576294,
-0.0915231928229332,
-0.5354514718055725,
0.3891332447528839,
0.10126815736293793,
-0.7051814794540405,
-0.08854450285434723,
0.01486273854970932,
-0.32726117968559265,
-0.6021711826324463,
-0.00949277263134718,
-0.4045942723751068,
-0.5053233504295349,
-0.5442389249801636,
0.25827276706695557,
-0.5095227956771851,
-0.20750868320465088,
0.4415345788002014,
0.026012880727648735,
0.10083840787410736,
0.5773674249649048,
-0.45024898648262024,
0.48297610878944397,
0.7927358746528625,
0.6555713415145874,
-0.3244147002696991,
-0.021055972203612328,
-0.7041988968849182,
-0.02343744970858097,
-0.3962738513946533,
0.8672589063644409,
-0.2577117383480072,
-0.015547629445791245,
-0.12350066751241684,
-0.03157939016819,
-0.15283207595348358,
-0.7881796956062317,
1.0142793655395508,
-0.4595019817352295,
0.4434688985347748,
0.22536398470401764,
-0.5624094009399414,
-0.1749982237815857,
0.48068514466285706,
-0.48097777366638184,
1.0737130641937256,
0.138713076710701,
-0.8296570777893066,
0.3138231337070465,
-0.7158993482589722,
-0.7929904460906982,
-0.054858285933732986,
-0.2348543405532837,
-0.24685321748256683,
0.29098039865493774,
0.15701942145824432,
0.17791149020195007,
-0.52113276720047,
0.4678625762462616,
-0.01249423623085022,
-0.10594063252210617,
0.38377541303634644,
-0.5923091769218445,
0.9283000230789185,
0.04382491484284401,
-0.35877978801727295,
-0.19304926693439484,
-0.6479824781417847,
-0.0008499867399223149,
0.16283008456230164,
-0.6261762380599976,
-0.20370444655418396,
0.35179612040519714,
-0.017651153728365898,
0.5250385999679565,
0.11589149385690689,
-0.6307396292686462,
-0.05904967710375786,
-0.7692333459854126,
0.4596433639526367,
0.6746820211410522,
-0.1927863210439682,
-0.02590622939169407,
-0.24066637456417084,
0.26730334758758545,
0.3623245358467102,
0.18619881570339203,
0.19485649466514587,
-0.6179406046867371,
-0.6599296927452087,
-0.13493221998214722,
0.061210859566926956,
1.047705054283142,
-0.9187842607498169,
0.3968096673488617,
-0.3211573362350464,
-0.05987900123000145,
-0.19798903167247772,
0.41884106397628784,
0.2142023891210556,
1.0403790473937988,
0.4493364691734314,
0.3306768238544464,
-0.35264867544174194,
-0.8812527656555176,
-0.1558353155851364,
-0.509035050868988,
-0.24555344879627228,
-0.07182235270738602,
0.680255651473999,
-0.4486686885356903,
1.1080213785171509,
-0.4999520778656006,
-0.3968144357204437,
-0.2830653786659241,
0.241214781999588,
0.5497542023658752,
0.16200606524944305,
0.5743536949157715,
-1.1245238780975342,
-0.21328642964363098,
0.0556933768093586,
-0.7384689450263977,
-0.3310371935367584,
-0.014661041088402271,
0.06769902259111404,
0.7133871912956238,
0.2754509747028351,
-0.6521437168121338,
0.5797328352928162,
0.27662819623947144,
-0.3314918577671051,
0.6106774806976318,
0.06769298762083054,
0.005788824986666441,
-1.0575919151306152,
-0.14944951236248016,
0.20958462357521057,
-0.550866425037384,
-0.5962023138999939,
-0.02182033285498619,
-0.19100171327590942,
0.3195634186267853,
-0.43047070503234863,
0.2873561978340149,
0.13126607239246368,
0.20382431149482727,
-0.30669012665748596,
0.2656838297843933,
0.15689405798912048,
0.07951068878173828,
0.05695636197924614,
0.6083281636238098,
-0.21436023712158203,
-0.4470311105251312,
0.5038286447525024,
0.28318196535110474,
-0.25645142793655396,
0.7861801981925964,
-0.5459470748901367,
-0.08630126714706421,
-0.09957469999790192,
0.34576475620269775,
-1.0125919580459595,
-0.039853375405073166,
0.17881371080875397,
-0.5652289390563965,
0.03552709147334099,
-0.14397700130939484,
-0.8712485432624817,
-0.40145906805992126,
-0.10008937120437622,
-0.11619925498962402,
0.21242676675319672,
-0.6852875351905823,
0.7165438532829285,
0.3322317898273468,
0.05724279209971428,
-0.5561450719833374,
-1.1274572610855103,
-0.09790798276662827,
-0.03948628529906273,
-0.9165657758712769,
0.103022500872612,
-0.2598782479763031,
-0.2974676191806793,
-0.1494728922843933,
-0.37840649485588074,
-0.2816118597984314,
0.10149718075990677,
-0.13557110726833344,
0.3173251152038574,
-0.3873347342014313,
0.03510764241218567,
-0.028666313737630844,
-0.11574302613735199,
0.2721777856349945,
-0.4458552300930023,
0.17686860263347626,
-0.36598071455955505,
-0.13920770585536957,
-0.38652992248535156,
0.3188330829143524,
0.8150319457054138,
0.11663495749235153,
0.5167136788368225,
0.2159232348203659,
-0.7411270141601562,
-0.5326367616653442,
-0.5532534122467041,
-0.14465662837028503,
-0.45394548773765564,
0.15653856098651886,
-0.21285000443458557,
-0.5106491446495056,
0.03664398193359375,
0.008282898925244808,
0.41120707988739014,
0.3223332464694977,
0.4225704073905945,
-0.07246730476617813,
1.1866114139556885,
0.5022541880607605,
0.05612355098128319,
0.04940096288919449,
-0.037391576915979385,
0.6202054023742676,
-0.1257031112909317,
-0.09681221097707748,
-0.1815594732761383,
0.17614412307739258,
-0.271664559841156,
-0.628291130065918,
0.09088766574859619,
0.04107644408941269,
0.10030942410230637,
0.1440453678369522,
-0.3272041976451874,
0.638990044593811,
0.1306622326374054,
-0.011188918724656105,
0.5367580056190491,
0.2529420256614685,
-0.1415405422449112,
-0.36114436388015747,
-0.4573993980884552,
-0.6430466175079346,
0.6501272916793823,
0.5109279751777649,
0.5644857287406921,
0.5508207678794861,
0.4722799062728882,
0.6714704036712646,
0.6908619403839111,
-1.1332091093063354,
0.7040293216705322,
-0.6409164667129517,
-0.6592239737510681,
-0.01791544072329998,
-0.7498199939727783,
-0.21401919424533844,
0.2614921033382416,
-0.1626380831003189,
-0.45107999444007874,
-0.1970285177230835,
0.21394787728786469,
-0.04683525860309601,
0.11788246780633926,
-0.6880688071250916,
0.8074668645858765,
-0.41112667322158813,
-0.1736859828233719,
-0.06442071497440338,
-0.4530441462993622,
0.7469220161437988,
-0.2027687132358551,
0.39235931634902954,
-0.15990568697452545,
0.20251749455928802,
0.5579919815063477,
-0.6857796311378479,
0.7114386558532715,
-0.2102118730545044,
-0.2706611454486847,
0.20815029740333557,
0.15946747362613678,
0.5427667498588562,
-0.01603865623474121,
-0.33630886673927307,
-0.09837903082370758,
0.15102380514144897,
-0.23563537001609802,
-0.7574833631515503,
0.3269208073616028,
-0.37070921063423157,
-0.40133076906204224,
-0.5525633692741394,
-0.42479032278060913,
-0.24289964139461517,
0.3182722330093384,
0.07972671836614609,
0.20392420887947083,
-0.009473265148699284,
0.11385900527238846,
0.7237679362297058,
0.21120847761631012,
-0.0035772928968071938,
0.6700115203857422,
-0.3130839765071869,
-0.43615493178367615,
0.7955824732780457,
-0.015059527941048145,
0.33170101046562195,
0.39550745487213135,
0.3656702935695648,
-0.6603769659996033,
-0.7167566418647766,
-0.47347313165664673,
0.25689932703971863,
-1.095363736152649,
-0.3434920608997345,
-0.17554587125778198,
-0.2547496259212494,
-0.5123019218444824,
0.05278845131397247,
-0.23765407502651215,
-0.44290485978126526,
0.03103766404092312,
-0.16350041329860687,
0.06680522859096527,
0.40957924723625183,
0.1358339637517929,
0.2943967282772064,
-0.6342446208000183,
0.6607591509819031,
0.30892476439476013,
0.10697846859693527,
-0.5178838968276978,
-0.8610261082649231,
0.3258930444717407,
0.10058863461017609,
-0.19828473031520844,
-0.8639512658119202,
0.36990243196487427,
0.10069653391838074,
0.6324840784072876,
0.5667059421539307,
0.13480506837368011,
0.4821278750896454,
-0.5231810212135315,
0.320427805185318,
0.3455147445201874,
-1.0485939979553223,
0.8205925822257996,
0.009114667773246765,
-0.08930518478155136,
0.7138262987136841,
0.19228993356227875,
-0.39468976855278015,
-0.1886787861585617,
-0.3828582465648651,
-0.6276533603668213,
0.7677860856056213,
0.3020835816860199,
-0.367657870054245,
-0.010628880001604557,
0.3210604786872864,
-0.05407583341002464,
0.3813396990299225,
-1.1577794551849365,
-0.165579155087471,
-0.07513004541397095,
-0.5425068736076355,
0.16569675505161285,
-0.09594615548849106,
-0.27554500102996826,
-0.1608424186706543,
0.9052034020423889,
-0.5236364006996155,
-0.00006980357284191996,
0.11685175448656082,
-0.4423118531703949,
-0.04754633083939552,
0.26631370186805725,
0.7026853561401367,
0.7275176644325256,
-0.2585778832435608,
0.18202151358127594,
0.20105095207691193,
-0.3276108503341675,
0.27846553921699524,
0.4122734069824219,
-0.6235424876213074,
0.2237412929534912,
0.28373393416404724,
0.46418553590774536,
0.10221070796251297,
-0.8565742373466492,
0.7736501693725586,
-0.12212531268596649,
-0.1322544515132904,
-0.46745765209198,
-0.1509934514760971,
-0.07090772688388824,
0.012348141521215439,
0.4126310348510742,
0.2302577644586563,
0.07329192012548447,
-0.5262319445610046,
0.4547487497329712,
0.20654480159282684,
-0.05317101627588272,
-0.0467667318880558,
0.47024232149124146,
0.3065161406993866,
-0.30158498883247375,
0.5273177027702332,
-0.3068884611129761,
-0.8017860054969788,
0.4905797243118286,
0.7659117579460144,
0.5433976054191589,
-0.2108384072780609,
0.5152204632759094,
0.10916401445865631,
0.8636837005615234,
-0.21962912380695343,
0.24074093997478485,
0.14339077472686768,
-0.9033554196357727,
-0.5112261176109314,
-0.8820331692695618,
-0.46032166481018066,
0.223929762840271,
-0.2600470781326294,
0.40619733929634094,
-0.7378175258636475,
0.14304886758327484,
0.17658524215221405,
-0.07969874888658524,
-0.24211423099040985,
0.3218788802623749,
0.5814988017082214,
1.15503990650177,
-1.1354800462722778,
0.616584300994873,
0.7276204824447632,
-0.3428906202316284,
-0.3814888000488281,
0.1890980452299118,
0.3258036971092224,
-0.592498779296875,
0.6825243234634399,
0.6474870443344116,
-0.6731255650520325,
-0.3198695778846741,
-0.6585602164268494,
-0.45645871758461,
0.8161429762840271,
0.5468811392784119,
-0.32663393020629883,
-0.04001094400882721,
0.4870977997779846,
0.5353211760520935,
-0.73006671667099,
0.09162827581167221,
0.8148812055587769,
0.4428754448890686,
0.2616119384765625,
-0.6261823773384094,
0.26435068249702454,
-0.06404469162225723,
-0.16395121812820435,
0.16634663939476013,
-0.3695622980594635,
0.4937613010406494,
-0.221770241856575,
-0.2942218780517578,
-0.2065650075674057,
0.5823989510536194,
0.658552348613739,
0.8103904724121094,
0.9520887732505798,
0.6332058310508728,
0.8782024383544922,
-0.21201112866401672,
0.6444950103759766,
-0.03349774330854416,
0.45073187351226807,
1.0982022285461426,
-0.5292608141899109,
1.0470771789550781,
0.6259116530418396,
-0.21250277757644653,
0.6641923189163208,
0.3499780297279358,
0.05117030814290047,
0.2876358926296234,
0.27122926712036133,
-0.164854496717453,
-0.5819128751754761,
-0.01702301949262619,
0.018279943615198135,
0.12724578380584717,
0.6988237500190735,
-0.26111671328544617,
-0.2859112322330475,
-0.17544041574001312,
0.05434183403849602,
0.31535986065864563,
-0.05987866222858429,
0.3692949712276459,
0.19299836456775665,
-0.615628719329834,
0.6124671697616577,
0.08830620348453522,
0.6368328332901001,
-0.4337604343891144,
-0.15263019502162933,
-0.2640155255794525,
0.4891423285007477,
-0.3780381679534912,
-0.5987726449966431,
0.3708665668964386,
0.1417687088251114,
-0.36692291498184204,
-0.1645408570766449,
0.6257411241531372,
-0.12648403644561768,
-0.8908562660217285,
0.4280262589454651,
0.19236962497234344,
0.03303149342536926,
0.15167236328125,
-1.0040874481201172,
-0.18093249201774597,
0.24713027477264404,
-0.08035299181938171,
-0.3118421137332916,
0.31725484132766724,
0.0011863855179399252,
0.6867131590843201,
0.821547269821167,
-0.17367789149284363,
0.10472322255373001,
-0.005860161501914263,
0.6778411865234375,
-0.4398329257965088,
-0.5461955070495605,
-0.6516444683074951,
0.3861771821975708,
-0.4193868637084961,
0.001688666525296867,
0.2481364905834198,
0.5475881695747375,
0.6487696766853333,
0.03284746780991554,
0.905210018157959,
-0.06284794211387634,
0.7608715295791626,
-0.6615721583366394,
0.3349471092224121,
-0.5989691615104675,
0.4925098717212677,
0.10473772883415222,
-0.5943509936332703,
-0.4708713889122009,
0.9164793491363525,
-0.4794846773147583,
-0.3783281743526459,
0.7511348724365234,
0.7913349866867065,
-0.3804513216018677,
0.27534133195877075,
0.25246357917785645,
0.583210289478302,
0.4577350914478302,
0.6490671634674072,
0.8086819648742676,
-0.588249146938324,
0.7859780192375183,
-0.10565473884344101,
-0.2759721577167511,
-0.392136812210083,
-0.9313343167304993,
-0.8657539486885071,
0.046005118638277054,
-0.5442908406257629,
-0.6047776341438293,
-0.15862739086151123,
0.964641809463501,
0.5592983365058899,
-1.0806341171264648,
0.02625957503914833,
-0.34719404578208923,
0.3810977637767792,
0.06505440920591354,
-0.362554669380188,
-0.20323191583156586,
-0.18842291831970215,
-0.5298091173171997,
0.7212836742401123,
0.3405374586582184,
-0.06737729161977768,
-0.16934087872505188,
-0.09047359228134155,
-0.35383644700050354,
0.5128828883171082,
0.8864271640777588,
0.09170816093683243,
-1.1270612478256226,
-0.364326149225235,
-0.11363281309604645,
-0.1214006245136261,
0.1529046595096588,
0.5588440299034119,
-0.6475059390068054,
0.16360877454280853,
0.6755669713020325,
0.6338788866996765,
0.12472984939813614,
0.0903601348400116,
0.36685648560523987,
-0.6089104413986206,
0.012738046236336231,
0.3477771580219269,
0.3625909090042114,
0.43636757135391235,
-0.15308837592601776,
0.6227906942367554,
0.6194735765457153,
-0.2718670964241028,
-1.1694505214691162,
0.5546097755432129,
-0.949322521686554,
-0.08857893198728561,
0.8862950801849365,
-0.213354229927063,
-0.23824293911457062,
-0.06747110933065414,
-0.11282528936862946,
-0.15638090670108795,
-0.21508949995040894,
0.7767355442047119,
0.8407317996025085,
-0.15210996568202972,
-0.0020912436302751303,
-0.8300818800926208,
0.4139048755168915,
0.5458719730377197,
-1.053875207901001,
0.1306995153427124,
0.8330203890800476,
0.6232333183288574,
0.4868265986442566,
0.39185991883277893,
-0.09246902912855148,
0.47938060760498047,
-0.4156830906867981,
-0.5276428461074829,
0.12246695160865784,
-0.2263982594013214,
-0.1410892754793167,
0.17201590538024902,
-0.2394123375415802,
0.013223765417933464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11809v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11809v1
|
Sharing Parameter by Conjugation for Knowledge Graph Embeddings in Complex Space
| 2024-04-18T00:05:02 | 2024-04-18T00:05:02 |
Xincan Feng, Zhi Qu, Yuchang Cheng, Taro Watanabe, Nobuhiro Yugami
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
A Knowledge Graph (KG) is the directed graphical representation of entities
and relations in the real world. KG can be applied in diverse Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks where knowledge is required. The need to scale up and
complete KG automatically yields Knowledge Graph Embedding (KGE), a shallow
machine learning model that is suffering from memory and training time
consumption issues. To mitigate the computational load, we propose a
parameter-sharing method, i.e., using conjugate parameters for complex numbers
employed in KGE models. Our method improves memory efficiency by 2x in relation
embedding while achieving comparable performance to the state-of-the-art
non-conjugate models, with faster, or at least comparable, training time. We
demonstrated the generalizability of our method on two best-performing KGE
models $5^{\bigstar}\mathrm{E}$ and $\mathrm{ComplEx}$ on five benchmark
datasets.
|
[
-0.9032289385795593,
-0.6705018281936646,
0.461692750453949,
0.2587902843952179,
-0.566464900970459,
-0.15173761546611786,
-0.1166866347193718,
-0.4156416952610016,
0.23572473227977753,
0.33631834387779236,
-0.12774959206581116,
-0.6625640988349915,
-0.9083526134490967,
-0.30964958667755127,
0.14973856508731842,
0.5934420824050903,
-0.18258577585220337,
0.1623888909816742,
-0.5523857474327087,
-0.43291184306144714,
-0.47279560565948486,
-0.37274715304374695,
-0.8422887921333313,
-0.43661659955978394,
0.8946738243103027,
0.3912946283817291,
1.1387546062469482,
0.49962642788887024,
0.20106759667396545,
0.18103131651878357,
0.08778723329305649,
0.5838810205459595,
-0.4460562467575073,
0.4526316821575165,
-0.15275487303733826,
-0.19341030716896057,
-0.45443934202194214,
0.15711253881454468,
0.6036596298217773,
1.2811740636825562,
-0.09264565259218216,
-0.03375409543514252,
0.1860877275466919,
0.7580211758613586,
-0.8912585377693176,
0.6529804468154907,
-0.17805948853492737,
0.1618964821100235,
0.20609283447265625,
0.07610026746988297,
-0.3902629315853119,
-0.6966699957847595,
0.3457055389881134,
-0.9709393978118896,
-0.050179556012153625,
0.22920531034469604,
0.6817111372947693,
0.26764824986457825,
-0.7200366258621216,
-0.3527854382991791,
-0.6281241774559021,
0.5424485206604004,
-0.7458496689796448,
0.7820133566856384,
0.256199449300766,
0.5899356603622437,
-0.29037854075431824,
-0.789158821105957,
-0.6836229562759399,
-0.3473496735095978,
-0.5120409727096558,
-0.05044855549931526,
0.030467357486486435,
0.46303513646125793,
0.35173967480659485,
0.03172336518764496,
-0.5118517875671387,
-0.17626942694187164,
-0.31898629665374756,
-0.22139328718185425,
0.6546393632888794,
-0.04241352528333664,
0.1395619958639145,
-0.06555117666721344,
-0.29114922881126404,
-0.2847531735897064,
-0.5154408812522888,
-0.04387296363711357,
0.380735844373703,
0.13264048099517822,
0.06851626187562943,
0.4794364273548126,
-0.3726627826690674,
0.9514794945716858,
-0.03543110936880112,
0.24207480251789093,
0.22620557248592377,
0.08845791965723038,
-0.2737129032611847,
-0.05928619205951691,
0.7918869853019714,
0.48573005199432373,
0.561870813369751,
-0.66153883934021,
0.35792040824890137,
-0.04644174128770828,
0.09395108371973038,
-1.0962671041488647,
-0.4370556175708771,
-0.12883824110031128,
-0.08857949823141098,
0.24065576493740082,
-0.05840364098548889,
-0.7150944471359253,
-0.36784231662750244,
-0.4327930212020874,
0.6048198938369751,
-0.6024628281593323,
-0.1537443846464157,
0.3677912652492523,
-0.4029619097709656,
-0.09909704327583313,
0.1925538331270218,
-0.7706825137138367,
0.48975443840026855,
0.4568284749984741,
0.4766762852668762,
0.1343003362417221,
-0.09532564878463745,
-0.4632147252559662,
0.5433849692344666,
-0.17952056229114532,
0.219800665974617,
-0.8231737017631531,
-0.39823630452156067,
-0.24041010439395905,
-0.24070033431053162,
-0.07116352766752243,
-0.8146347403526306,
0.5080382227897644,
-0.8314185738563538,
-0.13572421669960022,
-0.3876302242279053,
-1.124780535697937,
-0.6174710392951965,
0.3572927415370941,
-0.8352245688438416,
0.8019056916236877,
0.18782106041908264,
-0.4685894250869751,
0.33374354243278503,
-0.4375830590724945,
-0.20782005786895752,
-0.0063209147192537785,
-0.20458339154720306,
-0.6347119212150574,
-0.3448333144187927,
0.33452948927879333,
0.9463772773742676,
-0.31812113523483276,
0.3728768527507782,
-0.7492703199386597,
-0.2981085479259491,
-0.05867854878306389,
-0.15086016058921814,
0.3585324287414551,
0.1526499092578888,
0.08203569799661636,
-0.4075656533241272,
-0.48823457956314087,
0.19515708088874817,
-0.03026898391544819,
-0.30096304416656494,
-0.7984496355056763,
-0.1702640801668167,
-0.4271836578845978,
0.13193267583847046,
0.2694353759288788,
-0.4908584952354431,
0.5596424341201782,
-0.3747365176677704,
0.027507266029715538,
0.19621732831001282,
0.38470444083213806,
0.718452513217926,
-0.0674246996641159,
0.41246527433395386,
0.42693910002708435,
0.17583052814006805,
0.3745751976966858,
-0.6969943642616272,
-0.6044824123382568,
-0.10574298352003098,
0.525066077709198,
0.07861890643835068,
-0.6655538082122803,
0.007282213773578405,
-0.12076546996831894,
-0.843427836894989,
-0.4331793487071991,
0.058814942836761475,
0.6617252826690674,
0.36291009187698364,
0.6052851676940918,
0.16509051620960236,
-0.20961417257785797,
-1.153480052947998,
-0.5939902067184448,
0.37205785512924194,
-0.0999947339296341,
0.661916971206665,
0.21266579627990723,
-0.025978120043873787,
0.7541018128395081,
-0.9305416345596313,
0.01206541620194912,
-0.00436298456043005,
0.275928258895874,
0.22960233688354492,
0.7353008389472961,
0.7418578863143921,
-1.0525459051132202,
-0.9434625506401062,
-0.130391463637352,
-0.8721116185188293,
0.17943261563777924,
0.18592847883701324,
-0.5061163306236267,
-0.23979230225086212,
0.41694921255111694,
-0.6747228503227234,
0.23460660874843597,
0.6502090096473694,
-0.4532008469104767,
0.04784237593412399,
-0.33532774448394775,
0.12558908760547638,
-1.176930546760559,
-0.22733460366725922,
0.04978470876812935,
-0.3737405240535736,
-0.4278390407562256,
0.12256921827793121,
0.1252148449420929,
-0.17512156069278717,
-0.3039620816707611,
0.6586463451385498,
-0.5803425908088684,
0.13303594291210175,
0.22077105939388275,
0.41017282009124756,
0.26049843430519104,
0.8871909976005554,
-0.5016495585441589,
0.34333404898643494,
0.631195604801178,
-0.9185894727706909,
0.4182245135307312,
0.0035977233201265335,
0.03246435895562172,
0.4121074378490448,
-0.45956364274024963,
0.25209641456604004,
-0.2511177361011505,
0.22486789524555206,
-0.8059359788894653,
-0.06264343112707138,
0.6018582582473755,
-0.3829970955848694,
0.6366620659828186,
-0.3814476430416107,
-0.6794637441635132,
0.011546306312084198,
-0.14230790734291077,
0.7001069188117981,
0.3940056562423706,
-0.40520069003105164,
0.8583773970603943,
0.3731210231781006,
0.28499704599380493,
-0.3828752636909485,
-0.2062080055475235,
-0.32774069905281067,
-0.11155564337968826,
-0.8060898780822754,
0.5812256932258606,
0.1727984994649887,
0.22247938811779022,
0.3989502787590027,
-0.06355885416269302,
-0.1081630140542984,
-0.03504684567451477,
0.29394766688346863,
-0.15481294691562653,
0.03412475436925888,
0.21675726771354675,
0.5907859206199646,
-0.46711599826812744,
-0.02330666035413742,
-0.4380815923213959,
0.5923718214035034,
0.25815126299858093,
-0.3856101334095001,
-0.3380858898162842,
0.658504843711853,
0.6210136413574219,
-0.09402160346508026,
1.1821194887161255,
0.5412720441818237,
-0.5881627202033997,
-0.36589449644088745,
-0.23746758699417114,
-0.09728994220495224,
-0.5031419992446899,
0.3537421226501465,
-0.32288113236427307,
-1.0141607522964478,
0.5354984402656555,
-0.6836618185043335,
-0.18499855697155,
0.3211229741573334,
0.05462915077805519,
-0.20862741768360138,
1.0491899251937866,
0.5065210461616516,
-0.02913050539791584,
0.15820303559303284,
-0.616020917892456,
0.5240601301193237,
-0.8590606451034546,
-0.5790650844573975,
-0.2194540947675705,
-0.843737006187439,
-0.6347101330757141,
-0.5202921628952026,
0.7220665216445923,
0.6897439360618591,
-0.5643220543861389,
0.17709068953990936,
-0.3444644808769226,
0.47998765110969543,
0.5521343350410461,
0.20799671113491058,
0.05926473066210747,
-0.1302417665719986,
-0.36366164684295654,
-0.27141469717025757,
-0.9254868030548096,
-0.15045571327209473,
0.871778130531311,
-0.20106931030750275,
0.6727333664894104,
0.19528187811374664,
0.45987367630004883,
0.2707056701183319,
0.15313827991485596,
-0.6483752727508545,
0.6903865337371826,
-0.4295143783092499,
-0.3812367618083954,
-0.35348185896873474,
-0.6047340035438538,
-0.9051740765571594,
0.4546334445476532,
-0.15774816274642944,
-0.6611453294754028,
0.2608335316181183,
0.4024076461791992,
-0.11173412203788757,
0.4223082959651947,
-0.7791442275047302,
0.8120779395103455,
0.4750378727912903,
-0.13394084572792053,
-0.5244886875152588,
-0.529036819934845,
0.19733764231204987,
0.2866894602775574,
-0.24973221123218536,
-0.16439837217330933,
0.0746302530169487,
0.8289458155632019,
-0.3873465061187744,
0.711107075214386,
-0.8031262159347534,
0.359256386756897,
0.2663203477859497,
0.30333563685417175,
0.9919024705886841,
0.20499955117702484,
-0.24456056952476501,
0.0548439584672451,
-0.20353513956069946,
-0.5130548477172852,
-1.3186469078063965,
0.7318171262741089,
-0.8996204137802124,
-0.45543453097343445,
-0.03441057354211807,
-0.6355768442153931,
-0.7029266357421875,
0.029188700020313263,
-0.07977301627397537,
0.5133842825889587,
0.31329283118247986,
0.5112242698669434,
0.6780832409858704,
-0.18916697800159454,
0.14474745094776154,
0.2553371489048004,
-0.14045432209968567,
-0.4565700888633728,
0.7284095883369446,
0.8387489914894104,
0.4741663932800293,
0.27902790904045105,
0.311582088470459,
-0.26047948002815247,
-0.24400874972343445,
-0.3347165286540985,
0.29385116696357727,
-0.7263938188552856,
-0.28386127948760986,
-0.9695239663124084,
-0.28913670778274536,
-0.04953199252486229,
-0.4188457429409027,
-0.4216652512550354,
-0.6416611671447754,
0.049048759043216705,
-0.18403898179531097,
0.7003606557846069,
0.3686043918132782,
0.23494555056095123,
0.5812209248542786,
-0.7851372361183167,
0.490541011095047,
0.5364446640014648,
0.5807799100875854,
0.3562733829021454,
-0.019025443121790886,
-0.4104110300540924,
0.19837437570095062,
-0.25634780526161194,
-0.9946275353431702,
0.04107052832841873,
0.15790274739265442,
0.7292911410331726,
0.2076476663351059,
0.2924300730228424,
0.7876107096672058,
-0.12025561928749084,
0.6074129939079285,
0.02470344863831997,
-0.8108194470405579,
0.13408531248569489,
-0.2953983545303345,
-0.10060825943946838,
0.31865400075912476,
0.7523308396339417,
-0.673759937286377,
-0.4188797175884247,
-0.6344628930091858,
-0.9664809107780457,
0.4533769488334656,
0.223031684756279,
0.19417230784893036,
0.2118835747241974,
0.9617725014686584,
-0.1113928034901619,
0.355473130941391,
-0.25994765758514404,
-0.5709862112998962,
0.025261200964450836,
-0.22609806060791016,
0.31886959075927734,
-0.40064895153045654,
0.03064829483628273,
-0.5189154148101807,
0.6258469223976135,
-0.141886904835701,
0.2924146056175232,
0.025796493515372276,
0.0535552091896534,
0.22661210596561432,
-0.12620624899864197,
0.11433105170726776,
0.3784542977809906,
-0.10062205046415329,
0.340517520904541,
0.3833990693092346,
-0.22217653691768646,
0.10345198959112167,
0.08073403686285019,
-0.13875649869441986,
0.07332652807235718,
0.11891552060842514,
0.6550989747047424,
0.31122857332229614,
-0.02289462834596634,
0.448381245136261,
0.1756020486354828,
-0.22037051618099213,
0.03165700286626816,
0.3606950640678406,
0.5414288640022278,
0.508319616317749,
-0.11434974521398544,
0.21382278203964233,
0.18629617989063263,
-0.07045800238847733,
0.18589824438095093,
0.4026356637477875,
-0.38762640953063965,
-0.1802712380886078,
0.7448781728744507,
-0.007036306895315647,
-0.11151057481765747,
0.6924764513969421,
-0.5889378190040588,
-0.36898910999298096,
0.5927758812904358,
0.6014132499694824,
0.6357563138008118,
-0.047801319509744644,
0.1973811835050583,
0.5011743307113647,
-0.11526667326688766,
0.16948576271533966,
0.4207477867603302,
-0.10789581388235092,
-0.800570547580719,
-0.24501138925552368,
-0.5573131442070007,
-0.4426182210445404,
-0.360973984003067,
-0.6820869445800781,
0.13744814693927765,
-0.57118159532547,
-0.11072156578302383,
-0.07492191344499588,
0.11829495429992676,
-0.7646214962005615,
0.2521117329597473,
0.03862510621547699,
0.7649845480918884,
-0.6348548531532288,
0.9364516735076904,
0.5799278616905212,
-0.4481341540813446,
-1.2753819227218628,
-0.20246636867523193,
-0.5816003680229187,
-0.5645220875740051,
0.5375449061393738,
-0.030494781211018562,
-0.353534072637558,
0.11518826335668564,
-0.7068010568618774,
-0.9181148409843445,
1.283718466758728,
0.7013574838638306,
-0.57840496301651,
0.19284650683403015,
0.42582976818084717,
0.33877110481262207,
-0.2161974310874939,
-0.235187828540802,
0.06867533177137375,
0.730938196182251,
0.20538514852523804,
-0.3300616443157196,
0.426188588142395,
-0.12204568088054657,
0.07036805152893066,
0.5478364825248718,
-0.953289806842804,
0.7142210602760315,
0.13704824447631836,
-0.06640639901161194,
-0.46244481205940247,
0.7499030828475952,
0.3204173743724823,
0.33058884739875793,
0.5404245257377625,
0.7777814865112305,
1.0000253915786743,
0.043958231806755066,
0.9044914841651917,
-0.45475712418556213,
0.594996452331543,
1.0405564308166504,
0.026345882564783096,
0.5101025700569153,
0.4863717555999756,
-0.13406525552272797,
0.2737267315387726,
0.30921342968940735,
0.09655303508043289,
0.5348190069198608,
0.3035237193107605,
-0.1897394359111786,
-0.3935181498527527,
-0.008031205274164677,
-0.3862372934818268,
-0.1802244931459427,
0.40822163224220276,
-0.37651920318603516,
-0.4102785289287567,
0.0357506088912487,
0.6774097681045532,
-0.01366238109767437,
-0.19312778115272522,
0.5426949858665466,
0.30483004450798035,
-0.7067908644676208,
0.5258368253707886,
-0.01506870985031128,
0.3526454567909241,
-0.7998341917991638,
-0.3194507360458374,
-0.2673628032207489,
0.20549410581588745,
-0.17396382987499237,
-0.8084900975227356,
0.4588589072227478,
-0.5086249113082886,
-0.3629986643791199,
-0.02481399103999138,
0.4247795641422272,
-0.6837809085845947,
-0.508760392665863,
0.7980892658233643,
0.21713760495185852,
-0.14566496014595032,
-0.20704837143421173,
-0.38959941267967224,
-0.4334906339645386,
-0.20434404909610748,
-0.30661171674728394,
0.31817278265953064,
0.6120884418487549,
-0.15299366414546967,
0.7951428294181824,
0.5787157416343689,
-0.2924439311027527,
0.46611279249191284,
0.11283614486455917,
1.2088872194290161,
-0.43238961696624756,
-0.24372898042201996,
-0.975715696811676,
0.48827260732650757,
-0.046296991407871246,
-0.2919941246509552,
0.752901017665863,
0.6742299795150757,
0.7523824572563171,
0.009293061681091785,
0.5018694996833801,
0.06954516470432281,
0.025490105152130127,
-0.5465484261512756,
0.9086559414863586,
-0.5534913539886475,
-0.055780649185180664,
-0.23296330869197845,
-0.8857187628746033,
-0.6827161908149719,
0.23357829451560974,
-0.21745674312114716,
0.06338794529438019,
0.4441315531730652,
0.8625936508178711,
-0.37048566341400146,
-0.1639336794614792,
0.40160611271858215,
0.12340512871742249,
0.5566124320030212,
0.6264470219612122,
0.46501028537750244,
-0.49331286549568176,
0.37762030959129333,
-0.3305661976337433,
0.08684191107749939,
-0.1709730327129364,
-0.6490626931190491,
-0.6745091080665588,
-0.5941930413246155,
-0.3844929337501526,
-0.3278229534626007,
0.12086142599582672,
1.0377827882766724,
0.8718492984771729,
-0.39009252190589905,
0.23859450221061707,
-0.008862503804266453,
0.22221490740776062,
-0.27827274799346924,
-0.14252173900604248,
0.6327254772186279,
-0.21897539496421814,
-0.7123475074768066,
-0.021663324907422066,
0.1437130868434906,
-0.09304559975862503,
-0.3595394194126129,
-0.3304475247859955,
-0.1451510190963745,
0.0974130928516388,
0.42310795187950134,
-0.11800292879343033,
-0.3194449245929718,
-0.3780103921890259,
-0.32889267802238464,
0.005460729822516441,
-0.04866491258144379,
0.53641277551651,
-0.6926312446594238,
0.6148356199264526,
0.7434967756271362,
0.6660884022712708,
0.9479798078536987,
-0.1474875509738922,
0.6997278928756714,
-0.9495217800140381,
0.24016202986240387,
0.21140559017658234,
0.4416911005973816,
0.14921097457408905,
-0.47300875186920166,
0.3465517461299896,
0.22621393203735352,
-0.4692147374153137,
-0.2287445068359375,
0.30136004090309143,
-1.0712252855300903,
-0.16026219725608826,
0.8842709064483643,
-0.4012554883956909,
-0.09257233142852783,
0.011860820464789867,
-0.0469624288380146,
0.7976593971252441,
-0.5137576460838318,
0.4891546666622162,
0.48881784081459045,
-0.20180968940258026,
0.11622200161218643,
-0.6514793038368225,
0.5184871554374695,
0.17189551889896393,
-0.444644033908844,
-0.2901761829853058,
0.14813223481178284,
0.23507453501224518,
-0.024114297702908516,
0.25767648220062256,
0.11927464604377747,
-0.1576748639345169,
0.027376387268304825,
0.03033749759197235,
-0.3956414759159088,
-0.33036237955093384,
0.39300212264060974,
0.5227974653244019,
-0.13145741820335388,
-0.48542171716690063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11793v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11793v1
|
Enhancing Argument Summarization: Prioritizing Exhaustiveness in Key Point Generation and Introducing an Automatic Coverage Evaluation Metric
| 2024-04-17T23:00:29 | 2024-04-17T23:00:29 |
Mohammad Khosravani, Chenyang Huang, Amine Trabelsi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The proliferation of social media platforms has given rise to the amount of
online debates and arguments. Consequently, the need for automatic
summarization methods for such debates is imperative, however this area of
summarization is rather understudied. The Key Point Analysis (KPA) task
formulates argument summarization as representing the summary of a large
collection of arguments in the form of concise sentences in bullet-style
format, called key points. A sub-task of KPA, called Key Point Generation
(KPG), focuses on generating these key points given the arguments. This paper
introduces a novel extractive approach for key point generation, that
outperforms previous state-of-the-art methods for the task. Our method utilizes
an extractive clustering based approach that offers concise, high quality
generated key points with higher coverage of reference summaries, and less
redundant outputs. In addition, we show that the existing evaluation metrics
for summarization such as ROUGE are incapable of differentiating between
generated key points of different qualities. To this end, we propose a new
evaluation metric for assessing the generated key points by their coverage. Our
code can be accessed online.
|
[
-0.43591180443763733,
-0.652161180973053,
0.5927324891090393,
0.1510828733444214,
-0.6792981028556824,
0.3409208655357361,
0.05020716413855553,
-0.10180583596229553,
0.504040002822876,
0.17672838270664215,
-0.10611197352409363,
-0.6661280989646912,
-0.772215723991394,
0.02194124273955822,
-0.2415010631084442,
0.9645224809646606,
0.13536211848258972,
-0.38574838638305664,
-0.013175981119275093,
-0.26854172348976135,
-0.29562172293663025,
-0.2754632234573364,
-0.5212274789810181,
-0.06441184878349304,
0.5355862975120544,
0.5964592695236206,
0.4599214196205139,
0.5908863544464111,
0.6773977875709534,
0.30501827597618103,
-0.2719554603099823,
0.291913777589798,
-0.33575546741485596,
0.16686196625232697,
0.04164743050932884,
-0.06697704643011093,
-0.6198452115058899,
-0.3259543180465698,
0.7609149813652039,
0.4273262023925781,
0.2603450417518616,
0.2879730761051178,
-0.08062209188938141,
0.8541843295097351,
-0.9195718765258789,
-0.0011989925988018513,
-0.9530072808265686,
-0.05832924693822861,
0.031061358749866486,
-0.4273169934749603,
-0.08749422430992126,
-0.5575494766235352,
0.10683898627758026,
-0.523581862449646,
0.18703597784042358,
-0.6056237816810608,
1.066711187362671,
0.08893901109695435,
-0.3242270052433014,
-0.4886981248855591,
-0.6194367408752441,
0.2218663990497589,
-0.9171720147132874,
-0.20397497713565826,
-0.10187985748052597,
0.5418269038200378,
0.13455374538898468,
-0.6920815706253052,
-0.4035802185535431,
0.16610704362392426,
-0.1188582330942154,
0.36031532287597656,
-0.3323386311531067,
0.004009613301604986,
0.05361980199813843,
0.20657242834568024,
-0.24742621183395386,
-0.26951366662979126,
-0.5907177329063416,
-0.21103687584400177,
1.065177321434021,
0.17991545796394348,
-0.05003261938691139,
-0.4801419675350189,
0.1565108597278595,
-0.12377152591943741,
-0.5070986151695251,
0.2837839722633362,
0.576064944267273,
0.13430826365947723,
0.03225943446159363,
0.3733745813369751,
-0.4073559045791626,
0.2582527697086334,
0.3251088559627533,
-0.2101283222436905,
0.15477058291435242,
-0.4071043133735657,
-0.13293763995170593,
0.07792074978351593,
0.9131655693054199,
0.8362658023834229,
-0.03996865078806877,
0.10499114543199539,
0.34740495681762695,
-0.038243651390075684,
0.3301262855529785,
-0.9726325273513794,
-0.36060312390327454,
0.46566274762153625,
-0.7664559483528137,
-0.6488494277000427,
0.2626359462738037,
-1.0411028861999512,
-0.35671523213386536,
0.17436634004116058,
0.10514344274997711,
-0.10297274589538574,
-0.3402591943740845,
-0.18516118824481964,
-0.44828811287879944,
0.16947965323925018,
0.23334252834320068,
-0.47978881001472473,
0.13718341290950775,
0.7624638676643372,
1.043549656867981,
-0.3174992501735687,
0.17308591306209564,
-0.4083003103733063,
0.20477908849716187,
-0.7050281167030334,
1.2370730638504028,
-0.5871888399124146,
-0.7229397296905518,
0.11138979345560074,
0.09736089408397675,
0.16465502977371216,
-0.6333439946174622,
0.5628002285957336,
-0.4161381125450134,
-0.021999264135956764,
-0.5038192868232727,
-0.6654126048088074,
-0.19841952621936798,
0.27071550488471985,
-0.49272340536117554,
0.7312912940979004,
-0.09984204173088074,
-0.43895474076271057,
0.6886594295501709,
-0.9746322631835938,
-0.594158947467804,
0.289226233959198,
-0.24419115483760834,
-0.7876228094100952,
0.048269812017679214,
0.4926387667655945,
0.5816842913627625,
0.1863129734992981,
0.0758710503578186,
-0.22170694172382355,
-0.20846395194530487,
0.0719965398311615,
0.2196863293647766,
0.5837410092353821,
0.17390792071819305,
-0.4611447751522064,
0.4967632293701172,
-0.7686626315116882,
0.24953337013721466,
0.130344957113266,
-0.14820952713489532,
-0.26327046751976013,
0.2545735239982605,
-0.2865111827850342,
0.12906359136104584,
0.025157593190670013,
-0.35517945885658264,
-0.037594616413116455,
-0.5190897583961487,
0.4400359094142914,
0.593070924282074,
0.7450479865074158,
0.510615885257721,
-0.17353549599647522,
0.5616288185119629,
-0.14620628952980042,
0.015572096221148968,
-0.5304672122001648,
-0.49675673246383667,
-0.5551530718803406,
-0.3401564657688141,
0.16402140259742737,
0.41122984886169434,
-0.3059804439544678,
0.4243699312210083,
-0.45962974429130554,
-1.0276178121566772,
-0.3943951427936554,
0.08736805617809296,
0.2633306682109833,
0.08108679950237274,
0.21957816183567047,
-0.07736659795045853,
-0.397961288690567,
-0.7793008089065552,
-0.5750328898429871,
-0.1623615324497223,
-0.03385029733181,
0.355560302734375,
0.36200442910194397,
0.0961851105093956,
0.8937317728996277,
-0.7702843546867371,
-0.2355843335390091,
-0.5997716784477234,
0.18116402626037598,
0.019205553457140923,
0.22051699459552765,
0.5153850317001343,
-0.5876097679138184,
-0.9886432886123657,
-0.017643539234995842,
-0.4520179331302643,
-0.2819943130016327,
-0.41775432229042053,
-0.20785735547542572,
-0.21074476838111877,
0.6782900094985962,
-0.5806072354316711,
0.3550570607185364,
-0.12778212130069733,
-0.2685348391532898,
0.4353959262371063,
0.11385061591863632,
0.30607661604881287,
-1.234554648399353,
0.3014582395553589,
-0.13703584671020508,
-0.17728041112422943,
-0.5129002928733826,
0.23991580307483673,
-0.06024498492479324,
-0.2527809143066406,
-0.22608956694602966,
0.4029856026172638,
-0.23980812728405,
0.0687151774764061,
-0.71047043800354,
0.3279031813144684,
0.12107671797275543,
0.310126930475235,
0.027316581457853317,
0.20342829823493958,
0.21077007055282593,
-0.46738436818122864,
0.20751453936100006,
0.10256385058164597,
-0.09226235747337341,
0.5118230581283569,
-0.9735457301139832,
0.07750300318002701,
-0.040831059217453,
0.3724585771560669,
-1.1006330251693726,
-0.25337398052215576,
0.37554144859313965,
-0.6243261694908142,
-0.034483592957258224,
-0.23783022165298462,
-0.03836023434996605,
-0.028528349474072456,
-0.5844140648841858,
0.13794636726379395,
0.46488550305366516,
-0.1642989069223404,
0.4425942599773407,
0.7531690001487732,
-0.6092011332511902,
-0.2784801125526428,
0.1663805991411209,
0.020017556846141815,
-0.6106494665145874,
-0.36249083280563354,
0.552104651927948,
0.22229108214378357,
-0.42250576615333557,
0.12122976779937744,
-0.05567203089594841,
0.06588371843099594,
-0.024466240778565407,
0.3571602404117584,
-0.1503184735774994,
-0.08567669242620468,
0.03190603107213974,
0.3661291301250458,
-0.19335313141345978,
0.25731098651885986,
0.17173638939857483,
0.3037680387496948,
-0.04187995195388794,
-0.1955367922782898,
-0.3082466721534729,
0.7890218496322632,
0.5035202503204346,
-0.20891577005386353,
0.08918065577745438,
0.4062789976596832,
-0.3398871421813965,
-0.18302808701992035,
-0.3749816119670868,
-0.02937367558479309,
-0.4428069293498993,
0.46068304777145386,
-0.14366380870342255,
-0.5716547966003418,
0.5693279504776001,
-0.2529270052909851,
0.7424547076225281,
0.8909856677055359,
0.6451867818832397,
-0.08947621285915375,
1.0363987684249878,
0.4349622130393982,
-0.20216035842895508,
0.4274303615093231,
-0.26967915892601013,
0.28670400381088257,
-0.44986847043037415,
0.028770947828888893,
-0.511030375957489,
-0.3877984285354614,
-0.35614466667175293,
-0.3834690749645233,
0.4267924726009369,
0.18821501731872559,
0.07934100925922394,
0.2692231237888336,
-0.6728566884994507,
0.6268483996391296,
0.2540803551673889,
-0.1400373876094818,
0.2775667607784271,
0.07859063148498535,
0.21755880117416382,
0.08051414787769318,
-0.41706588864326477,
-0.6962302923202515,
1.26675283908844,
0.4052357077598572,
-0.0007709080236963928,
-0.03420335054397583,
0.7912410497665405,
0.5045925974845886,
0.4339171051979065,
-0.8880520462989807,
0.5778799057006836,
0.1266733855009079,
-0.3404545187950134,
-0.45206767320632935,
-0.3451022803783417,
-0.9784080386161804,
0.5873863697052002,
-0.15181557834148407,
-0.6871301531791687,
0.14413222670555115,
0.23811590671539307,
-0.7154656648635864,
0.08741296827793121,
-0.5804235935211182,
0.8906750082969666,
0.11318375915288925,
0.054903045296669006,
-0.4973514676094055,
-0.49446791410446167,
0.33741506934165955,
0.22400586307048798,
-0.00006793175271013752,
-0.1340586245059967,
0.19264376163482666,
0.8556214570999146,
-0.7052173018455505,
0.4064975678920746,
-0.42339301109313965,
0.021529091522097588,
0.6509238481521606,
-0.2306899130344391,
0.35147249698638916,
0.1459682583808899,
0.32223233580589294,
-0.10907990485429764,
0.16773821413516998,
-0.3809589445590973,
-0.7168673276901245,
0.4322068393230438,
-0.2916957139968872,
-0.44085821509361267,
-0.11812650412321091,
-0.4195232689380646,
-0.1427583247423172,
0.09820499271154404,
0.292749285697937,
0.30883440375328064,
-0.32888850569725037,
0.16646960377693176,
0.16454274952411652,
-0.1757253259420395,
0.5527490973472595,
0.23983533680438995,
0.09788980334997177,
-0.8558788299560547,
1.2156579494476318,
0.1830245405435562,
0.16098234057426453,
0.06457997858524323,
0.5557174682617188,
-0.34461256861686707,
-0.6433273553848267,
-0.4039706885814667,
0.024717550724744797,
-0.8103236556053162,
-0.2016509771347046,
-0.8716745376586914,
-0.27014005184173584,
-0.5384889841079712,
-0.5814363956451416,
-0.2102227509021759,
-0.7204254865646362,
0.26687827706336975,
-0.19539110362529755,
0.050787750631570816,
0.5438166856765747,
-0.048320792615413666,
0.6127819418907166,
-0.8864127397537231,
0.302163302898407,
0.1918133646249771,
-0.07024381309747696,
0.05183717608451843,
-0.16396977007389069,
-0.19340495765209198,
-0.32163766026496887,
-0.8832435011863708,
-1.2209454774856567,
0.29320117831230164,
0.3083339333534241,
0.48504403233528137,
0.8083475828170776,
0.0848139226436615,
0.8765606880187988,
-0.38088861107826233,
0.8469756245613098,
0.039900682866573334,
-0.7782474160194397,
0.5930118560791016,
-0.23130114376544952,
0.41273510456085205,
0.7829674482345581,
0.3607241213321686,
-0.31632891297340393,
-0.6324480175971985,
-1.0828802585601807,
-1.0397084951400757,
0.0826435387134552,
0.17046716809272766,
0.0040710195899009705,
-0.05527523159980774,
0.212408646941185,
-0.0019387546926736832,
0.22271232306957245,
-0.5056923627853394,
0.036724112927913666,
-0.23183725774288177,
-0.09348484873771667,
0.11711758375167847,
-0.3450365960597992,
-0.2813468277454376,
-0.23144574463367462,
0.683035671710968,
-0.13318821787834167,
-0.018707934767007828,
0.2237606793642044,
-0.058219507336616516,
0.059217799454927444,
0.3293274939060211,
0.6716035008430481,
0.6476780772209167,
-0.08588306605815887,
-0.08243950456380844,
0.010366583243012428,
-0.6067309975624084,
0.019367411732673645,
0.09118502587080002,
-0.5560259819030762,
0.6064922213554382,
0.4395655393600464,
0.4211955964565277,
-0.020047619938850403,
-0.5269890427589417,
0.496364951133728,
0.07954645901918411,
-0.3595530688762665,
-0.2450942099094391,
-0.16797634959220886,
0.04376004636287689,
0.23961682617664337,
0.37391728162765503,
-0.18060916662216187,
0.3122457265853882,
-0.39498424530029297,
0.2351376712322235,
0.5370984077453613,
-0.40464410185813904,
-0.09653148055076599,
0.2425657957792282,
0.3959178924560547,
-0.1848486363887787,
-0.11183663457632065,
-0.4640131890773773,
-0.6489976644515991,
0.7036234736442566,
0.12105035036802292,
0.9937506914138794,
-0.06166840344667435,
0.4906201660633087,
0.784841001033783,
0.31452763080596924,
0.5732163190841675,
0.400895893573761,
-0.23953045904636383,
-0.323384165763855,
-0.35251912474632263,
-0.28460416197776794,
-0.3139666020870209,
0.2482437938451767,
-0.4016127288341522,
0.04582953080534935,
-0.41088905930519104,
0.0023687672801315784,
0.14900536835193634,
0.24789492785930634,
-0.015468960627913475,
0.05472003296017647,
-0.41400671005249023,
0.68121337890625,
-0.8981286883354187,
0.04712658002972603,
0.497658371925354,
-0.10344605147838593,
-0.6595635414123535,
0.2592564821243286,
-0.12047626823186874,
-0.170405313372612,
0.15518547594547272,
0.1623382568359375,
0.12151829153299332,
-0.28566673398017883,
-0.05350014939904213,
-0.5366655588150024,
0.9667302966117859,
0.17295733094215393,
-0.22444447875022888,
0.09656548500061035,
0.26586347818374634,
0.40199875831604004,
-0.3889347314834595,
0.16798800230026245,
0.5591154098510742,
0.39220234751701355,
0.13151872158050537,
-0.4425593316555023,
0.2018555849790573,
-0.452745646238327,
-0.3933277428150177,
0.22263863682746887,
-0.33889040350914,
0.2486519068479538,
-0.24854765832424164,
-0.49543076753616333,
-0.21094606816768646,
0.6484851837158203,
0.22918595373630524,
0.5410276651382446,
0.6324428915977478,
0.37630003690719604,
0.6171188950538635,
0.041709356009960175,
0.8028120398521423,
-0.33064189553260803,
0.12091075628995895,
1.1793544292449951,
-0.05804885923862457,
0.8907131552696228,
0.37054556608200073,
-0.04718508571386337,
0.2596237361431122,
0.6533859372138977,
-0.057301878929138184,
0.4933922588825226,
0.2521848976612091,
-0.14091342687606812,
-0.23437683284282684,
0.06388489902019501,
-0.3904474675655365,
0.3916645348072052,
0.3732009530067444,
-0.500072181224823,
-0.5469228029251099,
-0.46962252259254456,
0.07947978377342224,
0.18352365493774414,
-0.4120912253856659,
1.1093049049377441,
0.05959530919790268,
-0.716666042804718,
0.2264033704996109,
0.058826323598623276,
0.16109918057918549,
-0.6475925445556641,
-0.19983592629432678,
0.023628681898117065,
0.006257038097828627,
-0.3063971996307373,
-0.5267021059989929,
0.6224444508552551,
0.2400323450565338,
0.07557592540979385,
0.08155197650194168,
0.9704006910324097,
-0.1861145943403244,
-0.6131845712661743,
-0.04695318639278412,
0.4802052676677704,
0.2103358954191208,
-0.3898710310459137,
-0.6275867223739624,
-0.1461280733346939,
-0.3752146363258362,
-0.1864584982395172,
0.13070008158683777,
0.15511195361614227,
-0.062024157494306564,
0.21098056435585022,
0.7985057234764099,
0.25619208812713623,
0.06460171192884445,
0.10515832155942917,
0.7911964058876038,
-0.3327125608921051,
-0.7115570902824402,
-1.1231281757354736,
0.82168048620224,
-0.7888814806938171,
-0.5142476558685303,
0.8508109450340271,
0.678334653377533,
0.39868974685668945,
0.01024707593023777,
0.928881049156189,
-0.16753704845905304,
0.559714138507843,
-0.07301165908575058,
0.8547677993774414,
-0.3808118999004364,
-0.19332359731197357,
-0.8323084115982056,
-0.8457819819450378,
-0.20629087090492249,
0.5821864604949951,
-0.21321631968021393,
-0.4057579040527344,
0.5368947386741638,
0.6133340001106262,
0.10865738242864609,
-0.15821433067321777,
0.15167663991451263,
-0.16966082155704498,
0.6027823686599731,
0.34936508536338806,
0.6157931089401245,
-0.427792489528656,
0.7405349612236023,
-0.314775675535202,
-0.3581525683403015,
-0.26632562279701233,
-1.1138639450073242,
-0.9033319354057312,
-0.7073895931243896,
-0.5140284895896912,
-0.2740057706832886,
-0.08367566019296646,
0.6718000173568726,
0.6395388245582581,
-0.8946738839149475,
-0.07026496529579163,
-0.1498507857322693,
0.35263127088546753,
-0.5199419856071472,
-0.27915722131729126,
0.6951250433921814,
-0.3656381368637085,
-0.4488259553909302,
0.4517250061035156,
0.36513715982437134,
-0.3622685670852661,
-0.1648898422718048,
-0.008550804108381271,
0.08192768692970276,
0.2558365762233734,
0.6603373289108276,
0.4930615723133087,
-0.5055718421936035,
-0.1758045107126236,
-0.10437388718128204,
0.26610448956489563,
0.06196625158190727,
1.054213285446167,
-0.34443917870521545,
0.42579659819602966,
0.6615608334541321,
0.877774178981781,
0.25863200426101685,
0.3600209653377533,
0.7175372838973999,
-0.445253849029541,
-0.15779642760753632,
0.17062170803546906,
0.26797613501548767,
0.02116975747048855,
-0.23326894640922546,
0.34898048639297485,
0.13784343004226685,
-0.37676262855529785,
-0.896010160446167,
0.1771751195192337,
-0.9693818688392639,
-0.16370780766010284,
1.1476470232009888,
-0.3122704327106476,
0.07523751258850098,
-0.03140377998352051,
-0.38753169775009155,
0.21462251245975494,
-0.3646239936351776,
1.226186752319336,
0.6456975936889648,
0.096941277384758,
-0.14560672640800476,
-0.30827397108078003,
0.6971651911735535,
0.2947639226913452,
-1.182379961013794,
0.047020889818668365,
0.4355073869228363,
0.19713056087493896,
0.47670531272888184,
0.8727908134460449,
-0.30689918994903564,
0.4721246063709259,
-0.01870448887348175,
-0.38800302147865295,
0.06152019277215004,
-0.3449256122112274,
-0.10965116322040558,
0.8019046187400818,
-0.20860065519809723,
-0.35154205560684204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11782v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11782v1
|
REQUAL-LM: Reliability and Equity through Aggregation in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-17T22:12:41 | 2024-04-17T22:12:41 |
Sana Ebrahimi, Nima Shahbazi, Abolfazl Asudeh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
The extensive scope of large language models (LLMs) across various domains
underscores the critical importance of responsibility in their application,
beyond natural language processing. In particular, the randomized nature of
LLMs, coupled with inherent biases and historical stereotypes in data, raises
critical concerns regarding reliability and equity. Addressing these challenges
are necessary before using LLMs for applications with societal impact. Towards
addressing this gap, we introduce REQUAL-LM, a novel method for finding
reliable and equitable LLM outputs through aggregation. Specifically, we
develop a Monte Carlo method based on repeated sampling to find a reliable
output close to the mean of the underlying distribution of possible outputs. We
formally define the terms such as reliability and bias, and design an
equity-aware aggregation to minimize harmful bias while finding a highly
reliable output. REQUAL-LM does not require specialized hardware, does not
impose a significant computing load, and uses LLMs as a blackbox. This design
choice enables seamless scalability alongside the rapid advancement of LLM
technologies. Our system does not require retraining the LLMs, which makes it
deployment ready and easy to adapt. Our comprehensive experiments using various
tasks and datasets demonstrate that REQUAL- LM effectively mitigates bias and
selects a more equitable response, specifically the outputs that properly
represents minority groups.
|
[
-0.11105701327323914,
-0.7689314484596252,
0.49035030603408813,
0.18776936829090118,
0.040404580533504486,
0.40921497344970703,
-0.21458007395267487,
-0.2706313729286194,
0.4475012421607971,
0.3775121867656708,
-0.06671921163797379,
-0.4160859286785126,
-0.8761940002441406,
-0.1950644701719284,
-0.644237220287323,
0.7460097670555115,
-0.08824865520000458,
0.13790176808834076,
-0.4002203047275543,
-0.22204962372779846,
-0.16501356661319733,
-0.4367574453353882,
-0.9569984674453735,
-0.41737255454063416,
0.7204323410987854,
0.42955267429351807,
0.7593696117401123,
0.5665122866630554,
0.5177966356277466,
0.32748857140541077,
0.027222562581300735,
0.02361718937754631,
-0.7711337208747864,
0.2153479903936386,
-0.1054597869515419,
-0.4396631717681885,
-0.7969619631767273,
0.04217859357595444,
1.0146812200546265,
0.9127119183540344,
-0.5389071106910706,
0.3559081554412842,
0.34572646021842957,
0.7993482947349548,
-0.883298933506012,
0.0481741689145565,
-0.519280731678009,
0.10102783888578415,
-0.17920614778995514,
0.0939100906252861,
-0.2543541193008423,
-0.5699635148048401,
-0.3939022123813629,
-0.49895983934402466,
0.1517656296491623,
0.3031080961227417,
0.4420100450515747,
0.21470625698566437,
-0.4602077901363373,
-0.07209441810846329,
-0.5201170444488525,
1.3039040565490723,
-0.6280969977378845,
0.6790295839309692,
0.3382483720779419,
0.12662214040756226,
-0.42438942193984985,
-0.7911044359207153,
-0.3515333831310272,
-0.21334584057331085,
0.12280155718326569,
0.23218344151973724,
0.14033764600753784,
-0.1251152902841568,
-0.13825061917304993,
0.4996075928211212,
-0.38119837641716003,
0.46590450406074524,
-0.380530446767807,
-0.39626285433769226,
0.7062311172485352,
0.26284128427505493,
0.2530459463596344,
0.23604921996593475,
-0.13154932856559753,
0.3192959725856781,
-0.7885617017745972,
-0.15727078914642334,
0.3971478044986725,
0.2885496914386749,
-0.21881480515003204,
0.5750559568405151,
-0.03820513188838959,
0.7692943811416626,
-0.31077030301094055,
-0.2558835446834564,
0.26213619112968445,
-0.22474727034568787,
-0.13043229281902313,
0.05110928788781166,
0.7292976379394531,
0.29519957304000854,
0.5133391618728638,
-0.0410250686109066,
-0.3514176309108734,
-0.18195398151874542,
0.14255371689796448,
-0.39605507254600525,
0.17546965181827545,
0.3903951048851013,
-0.5305047631263733,
-0.3264703154563904,
-0.240433007478714,
-0.7335442304611206,
-0.3406006097793579,
-0.2907885015010834,
0.16915646195411682,
0.02335803583264351,
-0.24618017673492432,
-0.06992193311452866,
0.09595423936843872,
-0.05391109734773636,
0.4095539152622223,
-0.6037909984588623,
0.27854257822036743,
0.7383654117584229,
0.9497473835945129,
-0.34689491987228394,
-0.4211534261703491,
-0.8342624306678772,
0.2320045530796051,
-0.2415376603603363,
0.4573507308959961,
-0.48762309551239014,
-0.2488277405500412,
0.16836149990558624,
-0.20359663665294647,
0.36854133009910583,
-0.5467331409454346,
0.6795861124992371,
-0.49522918462753296,
-0.08784307539463043,
0.005959159228950739,
-0.6238133311271667,
0.2563793361186981,
0.22703467309474945,
-0.8012183904647827,
0.6492171883583069,
0.0034198700450360775,
-0.8647997379302979,
0.5790788531303406,
-0.16646315157413483,
-0.2897056043148041,
-0.11609476059675217,
-0.3814539909362793,
-0.5227344036102295,
0.26561394333839417,
0.07977860420942307,
0.29411664605140686,
-0.46021196246147156,
0.4834325909614563,
-0.6658965945243835,
-0.48092469573020935,
0.2781141996383667,
-0.6149817109107971,
0.6922508478164673,
0.33868032693862915,
0.16061991453170776,
-0.15911658108234406,
-0.5506830215454102,
0.04525183141231537,
0.17772066593170166,
-0.4778457283973694,
-0.3183620572090149,
0.24665576219558716,
-0.08992667496204376,
-0.11185269057750702,
0.531599760055542,
-0.5382001399993896,
-0.24996647238731384,
-0.15858571231365204,
0.15247410535812378,
1.144986629486084,
-0.3492732644081116,
0.6357378959655762,
-0.3940078020095825,
0.5054233074188232,
-0.03145642206072807,
0.03241579234600067,
0.09734396636486053,
-0.39012113213539124,
-0.5446946024894714,
-0.5585304498672485,
0.45909765362739563,
0.5556285977363586,
-0.5163378119468689,
0.3157080411911011,
-0.37447062134742737,
-0.26800307631492615,
-0.4651888310909271,
0.30128976702690125,
0.34580478072166443,
0.3080664575099945,
-0.1236983984708786,
-0.6094290614128113,
-0.36019614338874817,
-1.0730533599853516,
-0.717120885848999,
-0.1780899167060852,
-0.06856132298707962,
0.1797139197587967,
0.21147744357585907,
-0.15221895277500153,
1.149730920791626,
-0.49974310398101807,
-0.18426212668418884,
-0.3358985483646393,
0.07747802883386612,
0.4120984375476837,
0.2803989052772522,
0.17231407761573792,
-0.468482106924057,
-0.16103483736515045,
-0.17983607947826385,
-0.8492875695228577,
-0.5284889340400696,
0.17658363282680511,
-0.03448142483830452,
0.18272770941257477,
0.4570618271827698,
-0.12985673546791077,
0.22224344313144684,
0.8283149003982544,
0.04885522276163101,
0.3273021876811981,
-0.14242330193519592,
0.182827427983284,
-1.0859465599060059,
-0.09020987153053284,
0.2486572265625,
-0.4257875978946686,
-0.3154647946357727,
-0.03385845944285393,
-0.20180435478687286,
0.045834846794605255,
-0.498863160610199,
0.7919938564300537,
-0.4571048319339752,
-0.43193188309669495,
-0.27623075246810913,
0.4097517728805542,
-0.19191384315490723,
0.20922809839248657,
-0.24917711317539215,
0.7091410756111145,
0.40762418508529663,
-0.5074391961097717,
0.3285645842552185,
-0.32472673058509827,
-0.3510614037513733,
0.6979014873504639,
-0.7243656516075134,
-0.09898081421852112,
-0.29023945331573486,
0.3473404049873352,
-0.7757630944252014,
-0.1914408951997757,
0.13263507187366486,
-0.5056442618370056,
0.30250269174575806,
-0.020634615793824196,
-0.3317684829235077,
-0.12167282402515411,
-0.20480754971504211,
0.8852643370628357,
0.3918120861053467,
-0.35439491271972656,
0.6585099697113037,
0.9543738961219788,
-0.4329974353313446,
-0.8696776628494263,
-0.8491957783699036,
0.034663401544094086,
-0.17258866131305695,
-0.6980804204940796,
-0.09326817840337753,
0.3016393780708313,
-0.6289325952529907,
-0.07246177643537521,
-0.1513788253068924,
-0.20592184364795685,
0.1246623620390892,
0.143236443400383,
-0.06476894021034241,
0.24191175401210785,
0.06052130460739136,
0.1752997785806656,
-0.13708972930908203,
0.07226819545030594,
-0.08004522323608398,
0.3674663007259369,
0.19697025418281555,
-0.6676145195960999,
-0.03545602038502693,
0.603501558303833,
0.5070104002952576,
0.04862058535218239,
0.7770220637321472,
0.49509212374687195,
-0.4022049009799957,
-0.22005480527877808,
-0.5421330332756042,
-0.1794613152742386,
-0.43682563304901123,
0.5962713956832886,
0.012002002447843552,
-1.3434743881225586,
0.7335430383682251,
0.036283984780311584,
0.563796877861023,
0.07211209088563919,
0.7358493804931641,
0.01790335401892662,
0.6420555114746094,
0.5070045590400696,
-0.4478878676891327,
0.4529682993888855,
0.2607837915420532,
0.4724891483783722,
-0.6050316095352173,
-0.0676843449473381,
-0.5277717709541321,
-0.41192057728767395,
-0.5865475535392761,
-0.5144148468971252,
0.5589383244514465,
-0.14358645677566528,
-0.5093981623649597,
-0.4354926347732544,
-0.16098393499851227,
0.4097050428390503,
0.5721809267997742,
0.07902448624372482,
0.5488975644111633,
0.2785721719264984,
0.14627961814403534,
-0.18211863934993744,
-0.8321468830108643,
-0.6037735342979431,
1.174435019493103,
0.6118738651275635,
1.251397967338562,
0.2692950963973999,
1.011506199836731,
0.6604360342025757,
0.778082549571991,
-0.6832274794578552,
0.5483344197273254,
-0.2033797949552536,
-0.5120990872383118,
-0.4656371474266052,
-0.8800973296165466,
-0.9714629650115967,
0.2506021559238434,
0.0034848826471716166,
-0.6675095558166504,
0.1778719276189804,
0.4932554066181183,
-0.15934190154075623,
0.3927082419395447,
-0.5258179306983948,
0.3539386987686157,
-0.25724926590919495,
-0.7296043634414673,
-0.31142187118530273,
-0.3873057961463928,
0.6824322938919067,
-0.44666266441345215,
0.7312067151069641,
-0.14998354017734528,
-0.21241073310375214,
0.8749988675117493,
-0.39823853969573975,
0.8969139456748962,
0.12312041968107224,
-0.3984604477882385,
0.274284690618515,
0.11990364640951157,
0.5365869402885437,
0.1928025633096695,
-0.19952642917633057,
0.4946877956390381,
-0.6587809324264526,
-0.6649515628814697,
-0.45408299565315247,
0.9907178282737732,
-0.7816668748855591,
-0.6357890367507935,
-0.6261573433876038,
-0.6675782203674316,
-0.058094412088394165,
0.09215140342712402,
-0.07454167306423187,
0.13097409904003143,
-0.4110664129257202,
0.056382227689027786,
0.48536425828933716,
-0.41382500529289246,
0.314054012298584,
0.3720167875289917,
-0.4775215685367584,
-0.525648832321167,
0.8487587571144104,
0.30221888422966003,
0.5505067110061646,
0.15032325685024261,
-0.09812824428081512,
-0.2453887015581131,
-0.2653926610946655,
-0.11513780802488327,
0.10808034986257553,
-0.496250182390213,
-0.1973894089460373,
-0.679384171962738,
-0.25160661339759827,
-0.2837946116924286,
-0.2842905819416046,
-0.6417479515075684,
-0.39585357904434204,
0.1012975424528122,
-0.20480944216251373,
0.11807811260223389,
0.4906077980995178,
-0.4514646828174591,
0.10883175581693649,
-0.7921721339225769,
0.35887080430984497,
0.5087296962738037,
0.41334769129753113,
0.048386286944150925,
-0.6478675603866577,
-0.5040596127510071,
0.24928493797779083,
-0.1881750524044037,
-0.6329346895217896,
0.38322851061820984,
0.062968909740448,
0.7687051296234131,
-0.008420674130320549,
-0.10385165363550186,
0.28710415959358215,
-0.48767250776290894,
0.722795844078064,
0.3458901643753052,
-0.9536975622177124,
0.08881932497024536,
-0.2640626132488251,
0.022869881242513657,
0.33961790800094604,
-0.01642576977610588,
-0.45369651913642883,
-0.7895196676254272,
-0.3507606089115143,
-1.2537755966186523,
0.265202134847641,
0.27207738161087036,
-0.05668173357844353,
-0.038020748645067215,
0.16855347156524658,
-0.11595667153596878,
0.28412601351737976,
-0.6931614875793457,
-0.3037262558937073,
-0.047815609723329544,
-0.1401161253452301,
-0.10847432911396027,
-0.3821403384208679,
-0.16870813071727753,
0.0942002683877945,
0.5147477388381958,
0.09172563999891281,
0.05484747886657715,
0.12326446920633316,
-0.19880631566047668,
0.09027981013059616,
0.44845879077911377,
0.389098584651947,
0.725484311580658,
-0.1885758936405182,
0.2739289402961731,
0.329868882894516,
-0.45937076210975647,
0.46036747097969055,
-0.28295013308525085,
0.02240159921348095,
0.007964378222823143,
0.2542402148246765,
0.2384810745716095,
0.13341160118579865,
-0.6030479073524475,
0.15044797956943512,
-0.06325546652078629,
-0.04627043753862381,
-0.4936564564704895,
-0.2114362269639969,
0.15595293045043945,
0.03749022260308266,
0.4335416853427887,
-0.49171170592308044,
0.17597255110740662,
-0.5217910408973694,
0.4235973358154297,
0.38538962602615356,
-0.09198401123285294,
0.30466076731681824,
0.6724174618721008,
0.401937872171402,
-0.2992885708808899,
0.7563811540603638,
-0.07518481463193893,
-0.17035897076129913,
0.8105823993682861,
0.4566816985607147,
0.8093350529670715,
-0.35555651783943176,
0.15409056842327118,
0.21377989649772644,
0.6313348412513733,
-0.29288405179977417,
0.21795359253883362,
0.5002962350845337,
-1.0291178226470947,
-0.7219276428222656,
-0.6561084985733032,
-0.4555738866329193,
-0.3302229344844818,
-0.706020176410675,
-0.07272070646286011,
-0.2558116912841797,
-0.3655165433883667,
-0.6257059574127197,
-0.2205745428800583,
-0.48795533180236816,
0.2760280966758728,
0.02998921647667885,
0.7321497797966003,
-1.1447747945785522,
0.4413154423236847,
0.4729135036468506,
-0.00848583597689867,
-0.6525450348854065,
-0.07051247358322144,
0.1305500864982605,
-1.0036314725875854,
0.630468487739563,
-0.19883275032043457,
-0.21891887485980988,
-0.19443349540233612,
-0.6335111856460571,
-0.9049375057220459,
1.069441795349121,
0.6371862292289734,
-1.0260885953903198,
0.523644745349884,
0.15707676112651825,
0.14027169346809387,
-0.4403230845928192,
0.26916012167930603,
0.5396391749382019,
0.5004463195800781,
-0.027033863589167595,
-0.8986912369728088,
-0.023983391001820564,
0.0223302710801363,
0.10717083513736725,
0.3033756911754608,
-0.8164352178573608,
0.7619454264640808,
-0.2843645513057709,
0.028306683525443077,
-0.23194408416748047,
1.0268259048461914,
1.0387678146362305,
0.6503921747207642,
0.5316956043243408,
0.865858793258667,
0.8914650082588196,
-0.006747105624526739,
1.0808018445968628,
-0.3982906937599182,
0.4579427242279053,
1.0957317352294922,
-0.5056829452514648,
0.47057396173477173,
0.6422757506370544,
-0.23046493530273438,
0.06524165719747543,
0.4796352684497833,
0.45611321926116943,
0.1381073147058487,
0.7041882872581482,
-0.5093178749084473,
-0.3700047433376312,
-0.32547035813331604,
-0.32911673188209534,
0.05605662986636162,
0.27312925457954407,
-0.4039381146430969,
-0.21804270148277283,
-0.5031940937042236,
0.16699160635471344,
0.1609886735677719,
-0.6520973443984985,
0.1845695823431015,
0.6925977468490601,
-0.30758219957351685,
0.07422582060098648,
0.05800766870379448,
0.7752631306648254,
-0.30334559082984924,
0.06468409299850464,
-0.6546687483787537,
0.049567073583602905,
-0.3193976581096649,
-0.7606483101844788,
0.3584255278110504,
0.009109018370509148,
-0.4021442234516144,
-0.09073252230882645,
0.5990543365478516,
-0.5158799886703491,
-0.9990186095237732,
0.25393158197402954,
0.8990715146064758,
0.23724842071533203,
0.35355764627456665,
-0.47598475217819214,
0.36383241415023804,
-0.10930788516998291,
-0.1922597885131836,
0.49734559655189514,
0.39863520860671997,
-0.20646630227565765,
1.0446114540100098,
0.42050158977508545,
0.2913188934326172,
0.1631631702184677,
0.250192254781723,
0.5793163180351257,
-0.5480152368545532,
-0.23036490380764008,
-0.8023563623428345,
0.42774441838264465,
-0.29444506764411926,
0.08469006419181824,
0.715761125087738,
0.6257930994033813,
0.6768710017204285,
0.26069003343582153,
1.0170793533325195,
0.08366083353757858,
0.3860248029232025,
-0.3767361640930176,
0.6746017336845398,
-0.7162119150161743,
0.5125739574432373,
-0.25803184509277344,
-0.995923638343811,
-0.3662221431732178,
0.6695612668991089,
-0.1111406609416008,
0.49011752009391785,
0.3987436294555664,
0.9489685297012329,
-0.10329587757587433,
-0.47450655698776245,
0.3954753875732422,
0.19048631191253662,
0.44371673464775085,
0.5741439461708069,
0.5973301529884338,
-0.0856882631778717,
0.23882488906383514,
0.32269081473350525,
-0.4704393446445465,
-0.07723155617713928,
-1.043714165687561,
-0.41943469643592834,
-0.06153549998998642,
-0.3880842924118042,
-0.43680647015571594,
0.2990337908267975,
0.8326238393783569,
0.45170506834983826,
-0.545296311378479,
-0.5684605836868286,
0.15641841292381287,
0.7624571323394775,
0.034252844750881195,
-0.22122853994369507,
0.06278586387634277,
-0.4091668128967285,
-0.8649763464927673,
-0.09331456571817398,
0.40747663378715515,
-0.4177056550979614,
-0.46248316764831543,
-0.3255949914455414,
0.1807771474123001,
0.11905037611722946,
0.4984520971775055,
0.2808915972709656,
-0.46763771772384644,
-0.19366267323493958,
-0.32978126406669617,
-0.13085120916366577,
-0.30845117568969727,
0.8883180618286133,
-0.5684890747070312,
0.08682610839605331,
0.5647793412208557,
0.6836642622947693,
-0.11070467531681061,
-0.09141521900892258,
1.0844491720199585,
-0.6592651605606079,
0.0655767098069191,
0.19848395884037018,
0.7063016295433044,
0.338101327419281,
-0.16443343460559845,
0.5549863576889038,
0.14330630004405975,
-0.9444661140441895,
-0.9415479302406311,
0.5866689682006836,
-0.8812726736068726,
0.010481170378625393,
1.2776240110397339,
-0.263310968875885,
-0.24617932736873627,
-0.36018502712249756,
0.17317740619182587,
0.2733934223651886,
-0.7607571482658386,
0.9171726107597351,
0.5914310216903687,
0.2789424955844879,
-0.4633987545967102,
-0.33001747727394104,
-0.14770916104316711,
0.5087934136390686,
-0.5220818519592285,
0.0640581026673317,
0.6707432866096497,
0.24253815412521362,
-0.011182921938598156,
0.8974846005439758,
-0.24999281764030457,
-0.014736298471689224,
-0.2553907334804535,
0.27139753103256226,
0.15980227291584015,
-0.049775250256061554,
-0.22606514394283295,
0.37863871455192566,
0.20103493332862854,
-0.09560335427522659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11757v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11757v1
|
Language Models Still Struggle to Zero-shot Reason about Time Series
| 2024-04-17T21:27:33 | 2024-04-17T21:27:33 |
Mike A. Merrill, Mingtian Tan, Vinayak Gupta, Tom Hartvigsen, Tim Althoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Time series are critical for decision-making in fields like finance and
healthcare. Their importance has driven a recent influx of works passing time
series into language models, leading to non-trivial forecasting on some
datasets. But it remains unknown whether non-trivial forecasting implies that
language models can reason about time series. To address this gap, we generate
a first-of-its-kind evaluation framework for time series reasoning, including
formal tasks and a corresponding dataset of multi-scale time series paired with
text captions across ten domains. Using these data, we probe whether language
models achieve three forms of reasoning: (1) Etiological Reasoning - given an
input time series, can the language model identify the scenario that most
likely created it? (2) Question Answering - can a language model answer factual
questions about time series? (3) Context-Aided Forecasting - does highly
relevant textual context improve a language model's time series forecasts?
We find that otherwise highly-capable language models demonstrate
surprisingly limited time series reasoning: they score marginally above random
on etiological and question answering tasks (up to 30 percentage points worse
than humans) and show modest success in using context to improve forecasting.
These weakness showcase that time series reasoning is an impactful, yet deeply
underdeveloped direction for language model research. We also make our datasets
and code public at to support further research in this direction at
https://github.com/behavioral-data/TSandLanguage
|
[
-0.08930595219135284,
-0.5474263429641724,
0.9521114826202393,
0.1848786473274231,
-0.24294421076774597,
-0.009848376736044884,
-0.13639412820339203,
-0.43729111552238464,
-0.2116296887397766,
0.31408771872520447,
-0.6955844163894653,
-0.29744043946266174,
-0.40995290875434875,
0.08879324793815613,
-0.5473183393478394,
0.9129709005355835,
-0.027321480214595795,
0.10478364676237106,
-0.003418204141780734,
-0.32264795899391174,
-0.36083585023880005,
-0.4925927519798279,
-0.4251268208026886,
-0.5002759695053101,
0.33513134717941284,
0.30232954025268555,
0.6600498557090759,
0.6801360845565796,
0.26976504921913147,
0.14423595368862152,
0.23619787395000458,
0.2265734225511551,
-0.1394152194261551,
0.2749321162700653,
0.015667632222175598,
-0.27981770038604736,
-0.12168671935796738,
-0.034057874232530594,
0.3940199315547943,
1.0635563135147095,
-0.17943784594535828,
0.3414866626262665,
-0.35431987047195435,
0.4007904827594757,
-0.38114842772483826,
0.1962771713733673,
-0.3060307502746582,
-0.1735692024230957,
-0.20494544506072998,
-0.5054883360862732,
-0.5589329600334167,
-0.037950366735458374,
0.3205359876155853,
-0.2190190702676773,
0.19734379649162292,
0.3947503864765167,
0.9013914465904236,
0.28928807377815247,
-0.456998735666275,
0.17889870703220367,
-1.133267879486084,
1.0817586183547974,
-0.9210325479507446,
0.30907079577445984,
0.37220650911331177,
0.4294325113296509,
0.305396169424057,
-0.39262935519218445,
-0.4226028323173523,
-0.03702353313565254,
0.0402839258313179,
-0.23282727599143982,
-0.36091679334640503,
-0.33959293365478516,
0.4606765806674957,
0.1471848487854004,
-0.7172747254371643,
-0.07688988000154495,
-0.29467910528182983,
0.01938755251467228,
0.35255396366119385,
0.284518837928772,
0.4558069109916687,
-0.30437061190605164,
-0.06929515302181244,
0.17714861035346985,
-0.4787541627883911,
0.036292169243097305,
0.022295933216810226,
0.39961156249046326,
-0.2462693750858307,
0.5274983644485474,
-0.10233896970748901,
0.790338933467865,
-0.3744838833808899,
0.010357829742133617,
-0.1940860152244568,
-0.015734059736132622,
-0.5610692501068115,
0.0570509135723114,
0.4310619831085205,
0.4906478822231293,
0.3393031358718872,
-0.45852839946746826,
0.0446370393037796,
0.26507627964019775,
0.04432479664683342,
-0.718673586845398,
-0.04198192059993744,
0.6112829446792603,
-0.18021924793720245,
-0.3018037676811218,
-0.29146963357925415,
-0.5806668400764465,
-0.34187692403793335,
-0.5433182120323181,
0.19351482391357422,
-0.382981538772583,
-0.2889234721660614,
0.505776047706604,
-0.36907026171684265,
0.2657666504383087,
0.4169365167617798,
-0.8328128457069397,
0.2827548384666443,
0.7399255037307739,
0.7487724423408508,
0.11399616301059723,
-0.2716746926307678,
-0.31006094813346863,
-0.005372624844312668,
-0.5563137531280518,
0.9816457629203796,
-0.5112234950065613,
-0.2767893671989441,
-0.2848241329193115,
-0.004181509371846914,
-0.15328249335289001,
-0.3024730384349823,
0.18564389646053314,
-0.3057127594947815,
0.3530672490596771,
-0.263454407453537,
-0.39302587509155273,
-0.18034957349300385,
0.29530373215675354,
-0.5243129730224609,
0.7141652703285217,
-0.0026281101163476706,
-0.5183107256889343,
0.5589177012443542,
-0.5334957242012024,
-0.4750637710094452,
-0.21804089844226837,
-0.13077831268310547,
-0.2148292511701584,
-0.21146295964717865,
0.5356869101524353,
0.5045803189277649,
-0.8296099305152893,
0.8044191002845764,
-0.7398353219032288,
-0.13523364067077637,
0.32880136370658875,
-0.7877780795097351,
0.790603518486023,
0.2575247883796692,
-0.4621049761772156,
-0.02872231788933277,
-0.6057506799697876,
0.1497126668691635,
0.36288589239120483,
0.43546393513679504,
-0.35440826416015625,
0.27425456047058105,
-0.02026427537202835,
0.09280905872583389,
-0.21249711513519287,
-0.494220107793808,
0.21598783135414124,
-0.47726544737815857,
0.9312874674797058,
0.5506445169448853,
0.13366036117076874,
0.3335469961166382,
-0.5391994118690491,
0.6288016438484192,
-0.00607214355841279,
0.282211035490036,
-0.5447416305541992,
-0.5015281438827515,
-0.7503800392150879,
0.14853009581565857,
-0.13761335611343384,
0.5596071481704712,
-0.5586835741996765,
-0.35616734623908997,
-0.46064430475234985,
-0.7206114530563354,
-0.22177249193191528,
-0.33127641677856445,
0.18646781146526337,
0.6085052490234375,
0.43074893951416016,
0.3407208323478699,
-0.4607734978199005,
-0.6610708832740784,
-0.38522911071777344,
-0.13692212104797363,
0.20829439163208008,
0.30565303564071655,
0.4913470447063446,
0.06486250460147858,
0.8894955515861511,
-0.4369134306907654,
0.506534993648529,
-0.42253240942955017,
0.30840975046157837,
0.37826672196388245,
0.01794556714594364,
0.8269844651222229,
-0.5115489363670349,
0.08461727946996689,
-0.04251846298575401,
-0.7974158525466919,
-0.13082930445671082,
-0.25266435742378235,
0.17549096047878265,
0.17232520878314972,
0.19359159469604492,
-0.4106704890727997,
0.3979748487472534,
0.4371548891067505,
-0.5232455134391785,
0.7041318416595459,
0.10019499063491821,
0.09778687357902527,
-0.7563705444335938,
0.32458674907684326,
0.1858978569507599,
-0.2994343340396881,
-0.6652777791023254,
-0.20667150616645813,
-0.26042667031288147,
-0.5914996862411499,
-0.1302536129951477,
1.0773594379425049,
-0.19215528666973114,
0.003317042253911495,
-0.0673770159482956,
-0.09702407568693161,
0.41176193952560425,
0.4886053204536438,
0.0941334143280983,
0.45200419425964355,
0.5759885907173157,
-0.5642086863517761,
0.260785311460495,
-0.19619640707969666,
-0.7335925102233887,
0.18616577982902527,
-0.744211733341217,
-0.08204732835292816,
-0.22756268084049225,
0.010345983318984509,
-0.7317427396774292,
-0.3279896378517151,
0.17922186851501465,
-0.3516745865345001,
0.2488282024860382,
-0.04165530204772949,
-0.18415458500385284,
-0.39325499534606934,
0.10890979319810867,
0.3984178304672241,
0.24596741795539856,
-0.6222293376922607,
0.20478476583957672,
0.14538316428661346,
-0.0916748195886612,
-0.691550612449646,
-0.8426545858383179,
-0.08946719765663147,
-0.2756315767765045,
-0.5085276365280151,
-0.07814356684684753,
-0.18504400551319122,
-0.8118343949317932,
0.11941373348236084,
-0.5132722854614258,
-0.15105541050434113,
0.35594648122787476,
0.07067375630140305,
0.5008355379104614,
-0.36634361743927,
0.2713797390460968,
-0.14352528750896454,
-0.15474574267864227,
0.009692898020148277,
-0.5006116628646851,
0.3091576099395752,
-0.3994044363498688,
-0.6295107007026672,
-0.07148416340351105,
0.3049585521221161,
0.7789275050163269,
-0.12912876904010773,
0.6277345418930054,
0.16064846515655518,
-0.48152828216552734,
-0.49230653047561646,
-0.4729258716106415,
-0.05912641063332558,
-0.3229275047779083,
-0.06330764293670654,
-0.05746937543153763,
-0.9465236067771912,
0.2759314775466919,
0.2557024657726288,
0.0925559550523758,
0.47168368101119995,
0.4505811929702759,
0.16573365032672882,
1.136230230331421,
0.12712028622627258,
-0.11334484070539474,
0.010730846785008907,
-0.2844771146774292,
0.5795748233795166,
-0.256131649017334,
-0.08054626733064651,
-0.4779391586780548,
0.04780669882893562,
-0.3033885657787323,
-0.19331778585910797,
0.37138229608535767,
-0.07239987701177597,
-0.3444874882698059,
0.1227552518248558,
-0.43029913306236267,
0.369665265083313,
0.20882491767406464,
-0.18294748663902283,
0.22515138983726501,
-0.16541634500026703,
0.018329564481973648,
0.17254862189292908,
-0.5687113404273987,
-0.7648219466209412,
0.9527571797370911,
0.3515879213809967,
0.6560855507850647,
-0.07068554311990738,
0.15617556869983673,
0.5466879606246948,
0.4189886152744293,
-0.882795512676239,
0.3515491485595703,
-0.06925532966852188,
-0.7191147208213806,
-0.4986831545829773,
-0.2518734335899353,
-0.7029245495796204,
0.03957723453640938,
0.20742489397525787,
-0.6447068452835083,
0.3453158140182495,
0.05174250155687332,
-0.6175404787063599,
0.4097646474838257,
-0.6658757328987122,
1.2283931970596313,
-0.37800338864326477,
-0.3301185369491577,
-0.06905640661716461,
-0.47294488549232483,
0.3634805977344513,
0.1625359207391739,
0.568288266658783,
-0.5548601150512695,
0.37954190373420715,
0.5561043620109558,
-0.7137734889984131,
0.7468575835227966,
-0.040284961462020874,
0.04404623806476593,
0.3333873748779297,
0.27901431918144226,
-0.08501401543617249,
0.12043844908475876,
-0.3756725490093231,
0.3359375,
0.5260017514228821,
-0.5573456883430481,
-0.7650073766708374,
0.5575268864631653,
-0.5989782214164734,
-0.6260734796524048,
-0.6932041049003601,
-0.30973976850509644,
-0.3351629376411438,
0.16811147332191467,
0.09143882244825363,
0.9460320472717285,
-0.16814060509204865,
0.07013020664453506,
0.31719285249710083,
0.031193628907203674,
0.6196936964988708,
0.6464350819587708,
-0.5028102993965149,
-0.18375009298324585,
0.8757869005203247,
-0.09313744306564331,
0.25795993208885193,
0.5173689723014832,
0.49265193939208984,
-0.20933248102664948,
-0.3049367666244507,
-0.6908975839614868,
0.2174854427576065,
-0.7493659257888794,
0.04553045704960823,
-0.29450613260269165,
-0.11840493232011795,
-0.4080583155155182,
-0.03764187544584274,
-0.134014293551445,
-0.6894906759262085,
-0.14747217297554016,
-0.12237796187400818,
0.4397813677787781,
0.6033714413642883,
0.19949284195899963,
0.03159121423959732,
-0.7918242812156677,
0.2760380506515503,
0.2904687821865082,
0.44325563311576843,
0.16130885481834412,
-0.32219716906547546,
-0.16672493517398834,
-0.16465958952903748,
-0.12775573134422302,
-0.8883405327796936,
0.6944117546081543,
0.057262904942035675,
0.33118289709091187,
0.49985912442207336,
0.03099037893116474,
0.7281458377838135,
-0.638954222202301,
0.9399552345275879,
-0.13740326464176178,
-0.988292932510376,
0.5600624680519104,
-0.5529691576957703,
0.3219064176082611,
-0.04144136235117912,
0.31059226393699646,
-0.8322079181671143,
-0.29841485619544983,
-0.6204012632369995,
-0.5252009630203247,
0.8289530277252197,
0.01704014092683792,
-0.198616623878479,
-0.30891677737236023,
0.25540730357170105,
0.1618550568819046,
0.29222121834754944,
-0.5786318778991699,
-0.3455883860588074,
-0.5901103019714355,
0.1688985824584961,
-0.42181500792503357,
-0.06219770386815071,
-0.040888331830501556,
-0.139551043510437,
0.531211793422699,
-0.18341422080993652,
0.15876275300979614,
0.23380964994430542,
0.25139057636260986,
-0.4335864186286926,
0.6692264676094055,
0.6780624985694885,
0.8142759799957275,
-0.2339726984500885,
0.017394205555319786,
-0.1811518669128418,
0.2139221578836441,
0.1433180868625641,
0.3489263653755188,
-0.1847791075706482,
0.09986280649900436,
0.5443252325057983,
1.207997441291809,
0.3292117714881897,
-0.8070636987686157,
0.40288954973220825,
-0.05023626238107681,
0.06138260290026665,
-0.3970261216163635,
-0.1655346006155014,
-0.12156633287668228,
0.1114279255270958,
0.37681305408477783,
0.31150221824645996,
0.05478518828749657,
-0.5049217343330383,
-0.12629334628582,
0.21201030910015106,
-0.15960146486759186,
-0.49634599685668945,
0.9498289823532104,
-0.08306065201759338,
-0.06528040766716003,
0.42533978819847107,
-0.05879665166139603,
-0.38886314630508423,
0.8531646728515625,
0.36193251609802246,
0.8730974197387695,
-0.13691721856594086,
0.4101220369338989,
0.35210296511650085,
0.3324195146560669,
-0.3306035101413727,
0.3784434497356415,
-0.09113677591085434,
-0.7818590998649597,
-0.8360016345977783,
-0.6689002513885498,
-0.6571393609046936,
0.4308600425720215,
-0.5005272626876831,
0.3609166443347931,
-0.537676990032196,
-0.22080591320991516,
0.31959158182144165,
-0.32331204414367676,
-0.5348538756370544,
0.41695964336395264,
0.32293903827667236,
0.7694134712219238,
-0.9824463129043579,
0.6079597473144531,
0.4871744215488434,
-0.4601752758026123,
-0.7172803282737732,
-0.06554430723190308,
0.08499324321746826,
-0.869192361831665,
0.6080198287963867,
0.3846191465854645,
-0.10030661523342133,
-0.20836414396762848,
-0.6849111914634705,
-0.8209906816482544,
0.7160384058952332,
0.3995092213153839,
-0.5012267827987671,
-0.13156257569789886,
0.06602742522954941,
0.5743701457977295,
-0.24730843305587769,
0.3424410820007324,
0.4433005750179291,
0.5854388475418091,
0.001357099274173379,
-0.8564049601554871,
-0.1197393462061882,
-0.4930214285850525,
-0.2732376754283905,
0.39019590616226196,
-0.5041400790214539,
0.6340431571006775,
-0.5877479910850525,
-0.30496951937675476,
0.1828652322292328,
0.36424458026885986,
0.16247370839118958,
0.8859202861785889,
0.3036766052246094,
0.5465193390846252,
0.5020115971565247,
-0.26715925335884094,
1.4995747804641724,
-0.3079034984111786,
0.270810604095459,
1.079344391822815,
-0.5385649800300598,
0.6190903186798096,
0.29910019040107727,
-0.2587461471557617,
0.671580970287323,
0.7280956506729126,
-0.0005584770115092397,
0.24076691269874573,
-0.13661062717437744,
-0.11706334352493286,
-0.8104360103607178,
-0.2343471348285675,
-0.11321192234754562,
0.29860273003578186,
0.45483312010765076,
-0.033347614109516144,
-0.3849466145038605,
0.018459107726812363,
0.17568781971931458,
-0.024413812905550003,
-0.003182735526934266,
0.1750689297914505,
0.24533969163894653,
-0.8657696843147278,
0.43428030610084534,
0.010978964157402515,
-0.11975660175085068,
-0.5955669283866882,
0.031153609976172447,
-0.004560097586363554,
-0.006798058748245239,
-0.03258635103702545,
-0.7106248140335083,
0.549351692199707,
0.14623910188674927,
-0.32141467928886414,
-0.44254493713378906,
0.4377588927745819,
-0.10707423090934753,
-0.4871763586997986,
0.1073588877916336,
0.7548606991767883,
0.0821453109383583,
0.09430243074893951,
-0.39608457684516907,
-0.23245243728160858,
-0.15508705377578735,
-0.2775226831436157,
-0.0765557810664177,
0.4427049458026886,
-0.1331602782011032,
0.8911623954772949,
0.5636107325553894,
0.20496074855327606,
-0.21830689907073975,
0.49726971983909607,
0.3407818078994751,
-0.7765393257141113,
-0.31889432668685913,
-1.0815459489822388,
0.3527003824710846,
0.24350513517856598,
-0.06880981475114822,
0.6427615880966187,
0.3066871464252472,
0.5302011370658875,
-0.08724737912416458,
0.9901267290115356,
0.13968244194984436,
0.8198491334915161,
-0.4367414116859436,
0.3355936110019684,
-0.8623209595680237,
0.45742860436439514,
0.006933378055691719,
-0.4188331365585327,
-0.519938588142395,
0.13230885565280914,
-0.9682896733283997,
0.006360162980854511,
0.7263268232345581,
0.2347460687160492,
0.057971369475126266,
0.41419708728790283,
0.28518402576446533,
0.30569541454315186,
0.3638925850391388,
0.3522462248802185,
0.9363282918930054,
-0.17189092934131622,
0.5757937431335449,
-0.4026763141155243,
-0.03975648805499077,
-0.1431664228439331,
-1.277849793434143,
-0.8092250227928162,
-0.3876839280128479,
-0.2572951912879944,
-0.2180020660161972,
0.044805608689785004,
0.8882275819778442,
0.4689454734325409,
-0.9252010583877563,
-0.16673003137111664,
-0.1600845903158188,
0.11136063188314438,
-0.38153716921806335,
-0.2688247561454773,
0.341199666261673,
-0.2606373727321625,
-0.5265806317329407,
0.548666775226593,
0.5894842743873596,
-0.017386702820658684,
-0.3730124831199646,
0.15886414051055908,
0.20425403118133545,
0.12937314808368683,
0.507278561592102,
0.6142482161521912,
-0.9385975003242493,
-0.22161266207695007,
0.3154383897781372,
0.18901146948337555,
-0.05634204298257828,
0.9189266562461853,
-0.6577537655830383,
0.6566881537437439,
0.3271273076534271,
0.4268434941768646,
0.1856199949979782,
-0.17914359271526337,
0.5291990041732788,
-0.5739529132843018,
-0.04862464219331741,
0.32458680868148804,
0.6749370694160461,
0.4414427876472473,
-0.07776105403900146,
0.3942388892173767,
0.5451695919036865,
-0.7234790921211243,
-0.8841207027435303,
0.11605367064476013,
-0.8268397450447083,
-0.438057005405426,
1.1055508852005005,
0.15318486094474792,
-0.2579438388347626,
-0.2091997265815735,
0.04834185168147087,
0.1421298086643219,
-0.313647598028183,
0.6915546655654907,
1.0409598350524902,
-0.19944819808006287,
-0.12472769618034363,
-0.7688417434692383,
0.3334800899028778,
0.537580132484436,
-0.6070421934127808,
0.3023340106010437,
0.48937907814979553,
0.216253861784935,
0.07138513773679733,
0.5295498967170715,
0.07812327146530151,
0.30712607502937317,
-0.30945754051208496,
-0.41162440180778503,
-0.05627662315964699,
-0.5436652302742004,
-0.32332369685173035,
-0.08376338332891464,
0.1926337480545044,
0.24042724072933197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11752v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11752v1
|
Mapping Violence: Developing an Extensive Framework to Build a Bangla Sectarian Expression Dataset from Social Media Interactions
| 2024-04-17T21:09:13 | 2024-04-17T21:09:13 |
Nazia Tasnim, Sujan Sen Gupta, Md. Istiak Hossain Shihab, Fatiha Islam Juee, Arunima Tahsin, Pritom Ghum, Kanij Fatema, Marshia Haque, Wasema Farzana, Prionti Nasir, Ashique KhudaBukhsh, Farig Sadeque, Asif Sushmit
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Communal violence in online forums has become extremely prevalent in South
Asia, where many communities of different cultures coexist and share resources.
These societies exhibit a phenomenon characterized by strong bonds within their
own groups and animosity towards others, leading to conflicts that frequently
escalate into violent confrontations. To address this issue, we have developed
the first comprehensive framework for the automatic detection of communal
violence markers in online Bangla content accompanying the largest collection
(13K raw sentences) of social media interactions that fall under the definition
of four major violence class and their 16 coarse expressions. Our workflow
introduces a 7-step expert annotation process incorporating insights from
social scientists, linguists, and psychologists. By presenting data statistics
and benchmarking performance using this dataset, we have determined that, aside
from the category of Non-communal violence, Religio-communal violence is
particularly pervasive in Bangla text. Moreover, we have substantiated the
effectiveness of fine-tuning language models in identifying violent comments by
conducting preliminary benchmarking on the state-of-the-art Bangla deep
learning model.
|
[
-0.329154908657074,
-0.9382383823394775,
0.10148727893829346,
0.5651400089263916,
-0.3597520589828491,
0.39339324831962585,
-0.2904684841632843,
-0.5288691520690918,
0.3425918221473694,
0.3690863251686096,
-0.2967289984226227,
-0.5954076647758484,
-0.9489564299583435,
0.22135542333126068,
-0.5165242552757263,
0.7424330115318298,
-0.057743195444345474,
0.05715017393231392,
0.31744030117988586,
-0.21395951509475708,
-0.012744499370455742,
-0.47802770137786865,
-0.45829764008522034,
0.007208528928458691,
0.5784521698951721,
-0.14392590522766113,
0.42076390981674194,
0.7770772576332092,
1.071710467338562,
0.4179896414279938,
-0.13918375968933105,
0.31220248341560364,
-0.8183119297027588,
0.3047708570957184,
-0.29339587688446045,
0.026235071942210197,
-0.10884640365839005,
-0.4552621841430664,
0.3502296209335327,
0.49358415603637695,
-0.05129909887909889,
0.3148679733276367,
-0.055045753717422485,
0.5435929298400879,
-0.6950730681419373,
0.19991090893745422,
-0.4842354953289032,
0.19166989624500275,
-0.4935765564441681,
-0.23903796076774597,
-0.3033609986305237,
-0.9664821028709412,
-0.24644218385219574,
-0.4565088748931885,
-0.040722742676734924,
-0.21380627155303955,
0.8617751002311707,
0.45034635066986084,
-0.5298945903778076,
-0.43430593609809875,
-0.5434024930000305,
0.4693003296852112,
-0.5443465709686279,
0.04678291827440262,
0.726033091545105,
0.37370356917381287,
-0.25288209319114685,
-0.3887084126472473,
-0.3755417764186859,
0.34042176604270935,
-0.029765186831355095,
-0.0923943743109703,
-0.0382441021502018,
0.027786018326878548,
0.16791056096553802,
0.377404123544693,
-0.35583189129829407,
-0.04503169283270836,
-0.5938916206359863,
-0.0883261039853096,
0.996891975402832,
0.4936186969280243,
0.30390840768814087,
0.027697386220097542,
-0.2041759192943573,
0.2359933853149414,
-0.6468819379806519,
0.0515669621527195,
0.5633745193481445,
0.4744059145450592,
-0.3861581087112427,
0.3893331289291382,
-0.06035640835762024,
0.888390839099884,
0.0518527515232563,
-0.4141256809234619,
0.07654599845409393,
-0.6094503998756409,
0.07032962888479233,
-0.07200199365615845,
1.0890402793884277,
0.8915613889694214,
0.4541635811328888,
0.12971140444278717,
0.17029885947704315,
0.35177546739578247,
0.17815037071704865,
-1.066453456878662,
-0.4147840738296509,
-0.16640335321426392,
-0.5351694226264954,
-0.5680588483810425,
-0.1746356040239334,
-1.1888478994369507,
-1.234921932220459,
-0.1080707535147667,
-0.2078053504228592,
-0.21268154680728912,
-0.6790688633918762,
-0.11398280411958694,
0.04230162873864174,
0.3336436450481415,
0.249155193567276,
-0.7656101584434509,
0.17985767126083374,
0.5265336036682129,
0.9940243363380432,
-0.019276456907391548,
-0.026032475754618645,
-0.13179709017276764,
0.23521219193935394,
-0.5895677804946899,
0.8619195818901062,
-1.1096187829971313,
-0.2702062726020813,
0.5832666158676147,
-0.21922080218791962,
0.06936995685100555,
-0.7646974325180054,
0.6251034736633301,
-0.43317410349845886,
-0.505002498626709,
-0.33335795998573303,
-0.5746243596076965,
-0.2627134323120117,
0.128570556640625,
-0.44664689898490906,
0.9747522473335266,
0.056519363075494766,
-0.5578469038009644,
0.3200465142726898,
-0.5838800072669983,
-0.4722277820110321,
0.16994383931159973,
-0.2404126226902008,
-0.48575559258461,
-0.025191234424710274,
-0.033738769590854645,
0.4516489505767822,
-0.41935622692108154,
0.44376423954963684,
-0.7289630174636841,
-0.44594764709472656,
0.34042900800704956,
0.06419693678617477,
0.7890240550041199,
0.2518971860408783,
-0.22321954369544983,
0.3450486660003662,
-0.5478846430778503,
-0.3541898727416992,
0.1619025319814682,
-0.04788130894303322,
-0.16647650301456451,
0.1996282935142517,
0.16617543995380402,
0.3194926083087921,
0.10583152621984482,
-0.5895890593528748,
0.2893023192882538,
-0.008641855791211128,
0.12238306552171707,
0.7470974922180176,
0.30502745509147644,
-0.152058944106102,
-0.4021252393722534,
0.3943534195423126,
0.14749161899089813,
0.16711075603961945,
0.05009972304105759,
-0.5087370276451111,
-0.4334712624549866,
-0.3762000799179077,
-0.06126820296049118,
0.3347223699092865,
-0.2757343649864197,
0.5848124027252197,
-0.07934805005788803,
-0.6585549116134644,
-0.7545056343078613,
0.2784827947616577,
0.2205432504415512,
0.18505971133708954,
0.36887574195861816,
-0.3323764204978943,
-1.032145380973816,
-0.7636012434959412,
-0.19623331725597382,
-0.3050554692745209,
0.2932116985321045,
0.0005179658182896674,
0.1801811158657074,
-0.3114863932132721,
0.9866188168525696,
-0.40150368213653564,
-0.45424866676330566,
-0.03878477215766907,
0.7827171087265015,
-0.4213096797466278,
0.03606009855866432,
0.5057851672172546,
-1.0615127086639404,
-0.9310455918312073,
0.1954188495874405,
-1.1505749225616455,
-0.8385557532310486,
-0.008034156635403633,
-0.06783654540777206,
-0.22245948016643524,
0.5754280686378479,
0.2495923787355423,
0.8122396469116211,
0.42777955532073975,
-0.1576237827539444,
0.43494975566864014,
0.5647720098495483,
0.5858838558197021,
-1.0159187316894531,
-0.19103793799877167,
0.17449048161506653,
-0.15635399520397186,
-0.6340961456298828,
0.2849850058555603,
-0.5198678374290466,
-0.13984766602516174,
-0.36700543761253357,
0.12039206176996231,
0.065379299223423,
0.19978651404380798,
-0.5326615571975708,
0.05775966867804527,
-0.5548231601715088,
0.4773748219013214,
0.18116384744644165,
0.5736390948295593,
0.4863945245742798,
-0.19476725161075592,
0.5075967907905579,
0.24025709927082062,
-0.2066829949617386,
0.33264970779418945,
-0.33969569206237793,
-0.0650281012058258,
0.1027466356754303,
0.17384839057922363,
-0.6697642803192139,
-0.6475533246994019,
0.43193212151527405,
-0.2428625077009201,
-0.2536507844924927,
-0.3821612596511841,
-0.5901305079460144,
0.008791082538664341,
-0.30674731731414795,
0.7395840883255005,
0.2584493160247803,
-0.1474888026714325,
0.6333119869232178,
0.8950110077857971,
-0.1688765585422516,
-0.34482941031455994,
-0.4156103730201721,
0.25529149174690247,
-0.3896348476409912,
-0.6088553667068481,
-0.18526512384414673,
-0.057474009692668915,
-0.42023998498916626,
-0.24859359860420227,
0.4791050851345062,
-0.673725426197052,
0.04344184324145317,
0.7974806427955627,
-0.19824236631393433,
0.11549609899520874,
-0.09490154683589935,
0.1512969583272934,
0.21565406024456024,
0.26648977398872375,
0.6192099452018738,
0.7882848381996155,
-0.21857577562332153,
-0.24240180850028992,
-0.5439156889915466,
0.6919572353363037,
0.37412360310554504,
-0.2010469287633896,
0.679741382598877,
0.6519086956977844,
-0.4238933324813843,
0.44602882862091064,
-0.3856775760650635,
0.16356465220451355,
-0.4858247637748718,
0.264743447303772,
-0.11112446337938309,
-0.9140029549598694,
0.7577228546142578,
-0.6306504011154175,
-0.2643029987812042,
0.23160973191261292,
1.0114885568618774,
0.21619074046611786,
0.7504199147224426,
0.6655989289283752,
-0.056788112968206406,
0.2747710943222046,
0.26199424266815186,
0.563823401927948,
-0.5090311169624329,
-0.2821718156337738,
-0.4773915708065033,
-0.2373405545949936,
-0.9515044689178467,
-0.5469946265220642,
0.281437486410141,
0.21759715676307678,
-0.2671234607696533,
0.32671400904655457,
-0.5525025725364685,
0.5361847281455994,
-0.138042151927948,
-0.08736027777194977,
0.21678267419338226,
-0.13669176399707794,
0.22717903554439545,
-0.37780022621154785,
-0.30459994077682495,
-0.5580152273178101,
0.8759275674819946,
0.15862075984477997,
0.8042107224464417,
0.48081180453300476,
0.8490376472473145,
0.5015661716461182,
0.6591430902481079,
-0.6346456408500671,
0.7640026211738586,
0.06724956631660461,
-0.6037353873252869,
0.01872452162206173,
-0.36000847816467285,
-0.9166285395622253,
0.01926730014383793,
-0.1894039362668991,
-0.8480827808380127,
0.37110304832458496,
-0.17547452449798584,
-0.4803710877895355,
0.4601197838783264,
-0.3816085755825043,
0.48680731654167175,
0.16403447091579437,
-0.6106058955192566,
-0.12762735784053802,
-0.8216798901557922,
0.429894357919693,
-0.42766982316970825,
0.4349891245365143,
-0.2801089584827423,
0.18306131660938263,
0.5509037971496582,
-0.274190753698349,
1.1898232698440552,
-0.031125426292419434,
-0.027901461347937584,
0.4784014821052551,
-0.0030836963560432196,
-0.08534827828407288,
-0.4366791546344757,
-0.024019530043005943,
0.3198205828666687,
-0.28332096338272095,
-0.516537606716156,
-0.4122726023197174,
0.5315341949462891,
-0.6452929973602295,
-0.05479097738862038,
-0.44539305567741394,
-0.499925822019577,
0.1357167661190033,
0.011869776993989944,
-0.0278606154024601,
0.31032899022102356,
-0.1702142208814621,
0.2844296097755432,
0.5893296003341675,
0.027328452095389366,
0.44104433059692383,
0.3018108904361725,
-0.7613514065742493,
-0.4821471869945526,
1.2480300664901733,
0.06623122096061707,
-0.15941829979419708,
0.00783102959394455,
0.21123509109020233,
-0.05988038703799248,
-0.49739399552345276,
-0.3359690308570862,
-0.2105899304151535,
-0.6442086100578308,
-0.4411494731903076,
-0.48520317673683167,
-0.07252299785614014,
-0.4972737729549408,
-0.5007650256156921,
-0.21157677471637726,
0.1735939085483551,
0.23921385407447815,
0.06360122561454773,
0.31708845496177673,
1.2052149772644043,
-0.32607871294021606,
0.5806245803833008,
-0.6030988097190857,
0.2680431306362152,
0.09131474792957306,
0.33118149638175964,
-0.21524204313755035,
-0.39079561829566956,
-0.3106909692287445,
-0.10428042709827423,
-0.36669453978538513,
-1.4196902513504028,
0.25439342856407166,
0.19124704599380493,
-0.24181576073169708,
0.7220745086669922,
0.37449774146080017,
1.06574285030365,
-0.34173083305358887,
0.6685985922813416,
0.021488051861524582,
-0.48969486355781555,
0.5708235502243042,
-0.6816690564155579,
0.014793585985898972,
0.6716240048408508,
0.8388463258743286,
-0.48296403884887695,
-0.6470043063163757,
-0.21099360287189484,
-0.9904599189758301,
0.07519470155239105,
0.05437316372990608,
0.022620994597673416,
-0.2720625400543213,
0.18678098917007446,
0.042961716651916504,
0.2332969754934311,
-0.8472943305969238,
-0.3096650242805481,
-0.17060843110084534,
-0.3379838764667511,
0.600642740726471,
-0.2206219881772995,
-0.47229766845703125,
-0.48100191354751587,
0.4952128529548645,
-0.01058724895119667,
0.13752101361751556,
-0.016485456377267838,
-0.24336612224578857,
-0.48333999514579773,
-0.12036581337451935,
0.5102887153625488,
0.8310660123825073,
-0.24514950811862946,
-0.07423137128353119,
-0.2521737515926361,
-0.418704628944397,
0.2631760835647583,
0.17279154062271118,
-0.2058744579553604,
-0.13079477846622467,
0.46410879492759705,
0.5531915426254272,
0.20874415338039398,
-0.6803808212280273,
0.6286417841911316,
-0.015948712825775146,
-0.0096522755920887,
-0.33674776554107666,
-0.11201860755681992,
-0.053267788141965866,
0.3521462082862854,
0.5646865963935852,
-0.15990078449249268,
0.3469688892364502,
-0.4137571454048157,
0.42369163036346436,
-0.00386418541893363,
-0.2963050603866577,
-0.11538294702768326,
0.18614105880260468,
0.2594670355319977,
-0.5568462014198303,
0.0664932057261467,
-0.509490430355072,
-0.8490766882896423,
0.2043541967868805,
0.30898067355155945,
0.6895813345909119,
-0.4262632131576538,
0.3130783140659332,
0.6385764479637146,
0.35095158219337463,
0.5446636080741882,
0.21840351819992065,
-0.0799809917807579,
-0.4713398218154907,
-0.5878617763519287,
-0.9417943954467773,
-0.40780767798423767,
0.00641114404425025,
-0.9100610017776489,
0.1870543509721756,
-0.7445013523101807,
-0.19251656532287598,
0.021750397980213165,
0.31672805547714233,
-0.11183500289916992,
0.11708948016166687,
0.24262821674346924,
0.3949532210826874,
-1.2986122369766235,
0.5952790975570679,
0.5455463528633118,
-0.5729420781135559,
-0.5293331742286682,
0.04892868548631668,
0.17490124702453613,
-0.6005184650421143,
0.6823136806488037,
0.4318792223930359,
-0.25833460688591003,
-0.3398655652999878,
-0.7928100824356079,
-0.36607757210731506,
0.4099518060684204,
0.1262359768152237,
-0.37012240290641785,
0.3968627452850342,
0.4902534782886505,
0.9072457551956177,
-0.45591235160827637,
0.2611815333366394,
0.3223589360713959,
0.4927718937397003,
0.043403107672929764,
-0.591955304145813,
0.1467406451702118,
-0.4603942036628723,
-0.28733500838279724,
0.61191326379776,
-0.8929396867752075,
0.47572895884513855,
0.4161839187145233,
-0.09365295618772507,
0.045939210802316666,
0.7199069261550903,
0.0036477213725447655,
0.48328447341918945,
0.21395623683929443,
0.5199854373931885,
0.47479966282844543,
-0.322955459356308,
0.6086175441741943,
-0.4447987675666809,
0.2504690885543823,
1.3080981969833374,
-0.37803250551223755,
0.8056225776672363,
0.21452447772026062,
-0.3064306378364563,
0.836136519908905,
0.8503987193107605,
-0.17277540266513824,
0.44881510734558105,
0.509067177772522,
-0.7419622540473938,
-0.4466931223869324,
-0.9040623903274536,
-0.4614057242870331,
0.5993613600730896,
0.4664411246776581,
-0.27983808517456055,
-0.41250720620155334,
-0.2191200703382492,
-0.044076867401599884,
0.5910037755966187,
-0.333980917930603,
1.0530080795288086,
-0.23928877711296082,
-0.08077710121870041,
0.3262673318386078,
-0.06503114849328995,
0.5608083605766296,
-0.6492472290992737,
-0.2522328197956085,
-0.10792127251625061,
-0.16612713038921356,
-0.3209950923919678,
-0.672712504863739,
0.7071688175201416,
0.1561068743467331,
-0.14734801650047302,
0.0655101090669632,
0.7735239863395691,
-0.6499897241592407,
-0.5020858645439148,
0.5013136267662048,
0.10234933346509933,
0.4250429570674896,
0.15807797014713287,
-0.6140187382698059,
0.6727277636528015,
-0.11431856453418732,
0.2936461567878723,
0.5194269418716431,
0.4577852785587311,
-0.15685243904590607,
0.51055508852005,
0.5160654187202454,
0.08509434014558792,
0.36122360825538635,
0.016727393493056297,
1.096168875694275,
-0.34776514768600464,
0.008683662861585617,
-0.9035077095031738,
0.24909938871860504,
-0.6771493554115295,
-0.4317815899848938,
0.6285827159881592,
0.6164544820785522,
0.743452787399292,
0.4167516827583313,
0.6950792074203491,
-0.2712847888469696,
0.3305456042289734,
0.13822205364704132,
0.556879460811615,
-0.20266282558441162,
-0.29981866478919983,
-0.46958160400390625,
-0.496783584356308,
-0.325668066740036,
0.8744404911994934,
-0.3915574550628662,
-0.2903510332107544,
0.329816073179245,
0.924044668674469,
0.16006098687648773,
0.33270764350891113,
0.2694597542285919,
0.3445415794849396,
0.25934523344039917,
0.3313785195350647,
0.7549927830696106,
-0.49046826362609863,
0.33166253566741943,
-0.4810791611671448,
-0.42500242590904236,
-0.1686265766620636,
-0.9300044178962708,
-1.1141492128372192,
-0.6759483814239502,
-0.49656760692596436,
-0.2812780737876892,
0.21801261603832245,
1.233651041984558,
0.5144922137260437,
-0.8154952526092529,
-0.5651556849479675,
0.2600438892841339,
-0.03882819414138794,
-0.006798384245485067,
-0.2317354530096054,
0.1421498954296112,
-0.06761471927165985,
-0.5432295203208923,
0.2501756250858307,
0.5280684232711792,
-0.26698893308639526,
-0.23924684524536133,
0.04874414578080177,
-0.8124493956565857,
0.0895918682217598,
0.7214857935905457,
0.3630334436893463,
-0.4543483257293701,
-0.0891314148902893,
-0.5371423363685608,
-0.017967339605093002,
-0.008501535281538963,
0.8414632081985474,
-0.23267070949077606,
0.7368412613868713,
0.2520739734172821,
1.0508263111114502,
0.14369706809520721,
0.15279680490493774,
0.3606983721256256,
-0.724891185760498,
0.23373186588287354,
0.2733902633190155,
0.07123657315969467,
0.5985625386238098,
-0.09547924995422363,
0.7064409255981445,
0.4241827428340912,
-0.755882978439331,
-1.1496137380599976,
0.4723614454269409,
-0.726190984249115,
0.07214802503585815,
1.0170162916183472,
-0.4959999620914459,
-0.19843558967113495,
-0.6061200499534607,
-0.3717779815196991,
0.6117637157440186,
-0.4822569489479065,
1.1525850296020508,
0.7986019849777222,
-0.053425006568431854,
0.05392315983772278,
-0.16689805686473846,
0.5003817677497864,
0.3074529469013214,
-0.794919490814209,
0.32024091482162476,
0.5210061073303223,
-0.2804219424724579,
0.34275445342063904,
0.47969016432762146,
0.050702858716249466,
0.26336947083473206,
-0.10313720256090164,
-0.03035219945013523,
0.06261249631643295,
-0.15910927951335907,
-0.14940021932125092,
0.6093065142631531,
-0.31450894474983215,
0.24538664519786835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11730v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11730v2
|
Missed Connections: Lateral Thinking Puzzles for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-17T20:31:05 | 2024-04-21T15:38:19 |
Graham Todd, Tim Merino, Sam Earle, Julian Togelius
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The Connections puzzle published each day by the New York Times tasks players
with dividing a bank of sixteen words into four groups of four words that each
relate to a common theme. Solving the puzzle requires both common linguistic
knowledge (i.e. definitions and typical usage) as well as, in many cases,
lateral or abstract thinking. This is because the four categories ascend in
complexity, with the most challenging category often requiring thinking about
words in uncommon ways or as parts of larger phrases. We investigate the
capacity for automated AI systems to play Connections and explore the game's
potential as an automated benchmark for abstract reasoning and a way to measure
the semantic information encoded by data-driven linguistic systems. In
particular, we study both a sentence-embedding baseline and modern large
language models (LLMs). We report their accuracy on the task, measure the
impacts of chain-of-thought prompting, and discuss their failure modes.
Overall, we find that the Connections task is challenging yet feasible, and a
strong test-bed for future work.
|
[
-0.6053673624992371,
-0.9674902558326721,
0.8689764738082886,
0.1379997730255127,
-0.04774118587374687,
0.05675308033823967,
0.0749339684844017,
-0.6696710586547852,
0.2516384720802307,
0.4871579110622406,
-0.9030361771583557,
-0.3228907883167267,
-0.4376012682914734,
0.3851470649242401,
-0.4853133261203766,
0.6759953498840332,
-0.15444853901863098,
-0.365704745054245,
-0.34710440039634705,
-0.35230618715286255,
-0.7669089436531067,
-0.1946333646774292,
-0.6827552318572998,
-0.6103968024253845,
0.6240875720977783,
0.2678268849849701,
0.7275564074516296,
0.8362341523170471,
0.662359356880188,
0.319333553314209,
-0.12483745068311691,
-0.041400060057640076,
-0.41935408115386963,
0.06007831543684006,
-0.496537983417511,
-0.7123104333877563,
-0.23168563842773438,
-0.013472703285515308,
0.6138907074928284,
1.1807407140731812,
0.16796351969242096,
0.20492145419120789,
-0.3247773349285126,
1.2630281448364258,
-0.3455022871494293,
0.23743674159049988,
-0.7038089632987976,
0.23622509837150574,
-0.1304447203874588,
-0.11504407972097397,
-0.14097963273525238,
-0.39162009954452515,
0.35203930735588074,
-0.43091249465942383,
0.011207856237888336,
0.07269773632287979,
0.7174165844917297,
0.29554080963134766,
-0.6613956689834595,
-0.4870636463165283,
-0.6628852486610413,
0.47021937370300293,
-0.4764089584350586,
0.23852023482322693,
0.55866539478302,
0.23909692466259003,
-0.314200222492218,
-0.2684572637081146,
-0.6246783137321472,
-0.25286996364593506,
0.1650148332118988,
0.04631863161921501,
-0.24233528971672058,
0.18889975547790527,
0.4277489483356476,
0.2130204439163208,
-0.4405791163444519,
0.01889984868466854,
-0.45192402601242065,
0.04877956584095955,
0.8910126686096191,
0.5039902925491333,
0.373977392911911,
0.16106969118118286,
0.056182861328125,
0.12616918981075287,
-0.9802058935165405,
0.14891009032726288,
0.590873658657074,
0.007696229964494705,
-0.18263466656208038,
0.7414541244506836,
-0.2729034721851349,
0.9048458337783813,
0.12200617045164108,
0.2576039731502533,
0.06354542821645737,
-0.4789482355117798,
0.07813805341720581,
-0.17333674430847168,
0.594938337802887,
0.23899322748184204,
0.34653958678245544,
-0.14882022142410278,
-0.14342190325260162,
0.20111513137817383,
0.10940999537706375,
-0.09448422491550446,
-0.5310885906219482,
0.22721798717975616,
-0.3006628155708313,
0.1478915512561798,
-0.497640997171402,
-0.34960976243019104,
-0.335348904132843,
-0.44478365778923035,
0.4165857136249542,
-0.5814879536628723,
-0.16283194720745087,
0.0714474767446518,
-0.2690727710723877,
0.21306921541690826,
0.3251458704471588,
-0.992466390132904,
0.2325991541147232,
0.5471290349960327,
0.7814573049545288,
-0.0540999174118042,
-0.39629635214805603,
-0.3256874978542328,
0.06707786023616791,
-0.4632856249809265,
0.8622795939445496,
-0.5071991682052612,
-0.17047572135925293,
-0.01492848340421915,
-0.09394629299640656,
-0.06492707878351212,
-0.28520601987838745,
0.23917624354362488,
-0.6680383682250977,
0.016203945502638817,
-0.5381827354431152,
-0.9551486372947693,
-0.27055662870407104,
0.6270036697387695,
-0.7679403424263,
0.4696294963359833,
-0.2935466170310974,
-0.7826657891273499,
-0.1312631070613861,
-0.6162881851196289,
-0.46047741174697876,
0.014247250743210316,
-0.5238618850708008,
0.27702099084854126,
0.11596719175577164,
0.015533588826656342,
0.17566236853599548,
-0.4018886089324951,
-0.007384315133094788,
-0.26806893944740295,
-0.3686066269874573,
0.22845043241977692,
-0.06853259354829788,
0.9740523099899292,
-0.19025546312332153,
-0.27546608448028564,
0.025085391476750374,
-0.6333136558532715,
-0.26736941933631897,
0.16956879198551178,
-0.3537931740283966,
-0.343801885843277,
0.08947174996137619,
-0.4370902180671692,
0.243771493434906,
0.09921965003013611,
-0.3845072090625763,
0.0684494823217392,
-0.4770122170448303,
0.690302312374115,
0.7685521841049194,
-0.15325087308883667,
0.37218451499938965,
-0.25863635540008545,
0.5444899797439575,
0.25534653663635254,
-0.25638145208358765,
-0.4515630900859833,
-0.6212819218635559,
-0.9536731243133545,
0.34864237904548645,
0.19784191250801086,
0.7538079619407654,
-1.009007453918457,
0.6867212653160095,
-0.05102349445223808,
-0.5697565078735352,
-0.2487841546535492,
0.004300110973417759,
0.25333312153816223,
0.44971784949302673,
0.2250368297100067,
-0.13726794719696045,
-0.25005102157592773,
-1.0293054580688477,
-0.5406800508499146,
-0.41327691078186035,
0.11082712560892105,
0.4772155284881592,
0.8276028037071228,
-0.345285564661026,
0.9418363571166992,
-0.510748565196991,
-0.21568968892097473,
-0.1106361597776413,
0.11008381098508835,
0.2677442133426666,
0.27827921509742737,
0.14153508841991425,
-0.4418187737464905,
-0.13557712733745575,
-0.11789720505475998,
-0.9327966570854187,
0.19533267617225647,
-0.25591349601745605,
0.142770454287529,
-0.015289880335330963,
0.771941602230072,
-0.8321875333786011,
0.2227371633052826,
0.6430163979530334,
-0.5512516498565674,
0.6068191528320312,
-0.4706112742424011,
-0.2005542367696762,
-0.7584728598594666,
0.12459089607000351,
0.048311345279216766,
0.22914017736911774,
-0.4264061152935028,
-0.05459770932793617,
-0.02028527855873108,
-0.1308380663394928,
-0.15168683230876923,
0.3861373960971832,
-0.8368723392486572,
-0.17686696350574493,
-0.14643220603466034,
0.5133111476898193,
-0.18815430998802185,
0.4499896764755249,
-0.2771197259426117,
0.5077083110809326,
0.6837249398231506,
-0.6133888363838196,
0.7004469633102417,
0.34087133407592773,
-0.311961829662323,
0.36926761269569397,
-0.6987320780754089,
0.35655876994132996,
-0.40198570489883423,
0.40209507942199707,
-1.0878832340240479,
-0.1916762739419937,
-0.09688634425401688,
-0.29955753684043884,
-0.13816623389720917,
0.231915682554245,
-0.3389122188091278,
-0.41218945384025574,
0.038855183869600296,
0.8993579149246216,
0.24085456132888794,
-0.3033066391944885,
0.4690955579280853,
0.7523565292358398,
-0.18541672825813293,
-0.4754717946052551,
-0.8996422290802002,
0.36709243059158325,
-0.17713598906993866,
-0.7767937183380127,
0.2037215679883957,
0.06587208807468414,
-0.33624544739723206,
0.09058771282434464,
0.12230043858289719,
0.06702707707881927,
0.13604424893856049,
0.08054060488939285,
-0.008054009638726711,
-0.19867119193077087,
0.27399906516075134,
-0.017076848074793816,
-0.006872076075524092,
0.47802814841270447,
-0.24641774594783783,
0.336100697517395,
-0.3265359103679657,
-0.5736834406852722,
-0.31299248337745667,
0.5008241534233093,
0.5837953686714172,
-0.1368870884180069,
0.3958122730255127,
0.08458233624696732,
-0.4028032422065735,
-0.09313089400529861,
-0.6528953313827515,
-0.21384640038013458,
-0.43881669640541077,
0.3365271985530853,
-0.4361989200115204,
-1.1927624940872192,
0.8449795246124268,
-0.005629223771393299,
0.08321473747491837,
0.32535287737846375,
0.10517924278974533,
-0.09112732857465744,
0.9271833300590515,
0.7138676643371582,
-0.1794796884059906,
0.1678045392036438,
-0.010784880258142948,
0.5833722949028015,
-0.5659099817276001,
-0.13873495161533356,
-0.3536494970321655,
-0.5772008895874023,
-0.8008776903152466,
-0.34099966287612915,
0.319904088973999,
0.08888085186481476,
-0.287735253572464,
0.36642348766326904,
-0.13953660428524017,
0.7591445446014404,
0.6883947849273682,
0.00831073708832264,
0.45404762029647827,
-0.19363826513290405,
-0.3246292471885681,
0.03632090985774994,
-0.6487995982170105,
-0.21006043255329132,
0.9200617074966431,
0.37609633803367615,
0.4727230668067932,
0.14195354282855988,
0.5223423838615417,
0.25508251786231995,
-0.15246771275997162,
-0.8556506633758545,
0.8388193249702454,
0.22953744232654572,
-0.7230652570724487,
-0.3290039300918579,
-0.45793044567108154,
-1.0864574909210205,
-0.1074812114238739,
-0.29301315546035767,
-0.8696861863136292,
-0.01908600702881813,
-0.010643765330314636,
-0.4144810140132904,
0.2294934093952179,
-0.5272889137268066,
0.6415231227874756,
-0.002538887318223715,
-0.18662956357002258,
-0.6284103393554688,
-0.7999048233032227,
0.5982807874679565,
-0.038344427943229675,
0.10426295548677444,
-0.09780304878950119,
0.05876115337014198,
0.7549571990966797,
-0.12070433795452118,
0.677615761756897,
0.2919340431690216,
-0.06324764341115952,
0.41553744673728943,
0.07760480791330338,
0.43472209572792053,
-0.18759723007678986,
0.2705491781234741,
0.39705079793930054,
-0.1660703420639038,
-0.44583144783973694,
-0.4537610709667206,
0.6441766023635864,
-0.6076646447181702,
-0.8605520129203796,
-0.4721781015396118,
-0.8653033971786499,
-0.3640482425689697,
0.345445454120636,
0.03416666388511658,
0.27198728919029236,
-0.22365471720695496,
0.034328609704971313,
0.5283835530281067,
-0.39709559082984924,
0.5202078223228455,
0.2221413403749466,
-0.06429167836904526,
-0.33988991379737854,
0.6058404445648193,
0.16609229147434235,
0.10671299695968628,
0.193076953291893,
-0.09020260721445084,
-0.387918621301651,
-0.5652580261230469,
-0.4412212073802948,
0.64324951171875,
-0.6566502451896667,
0.08002017438411713,
-0.7646979689598083,
-0.23597626388072968,
-0.13404536247253418,
0.041433025151491165,
-0.23978902399539948,
-0.3805532455444336,
0.04750897362828255,
-0.15898479521274567,
0.27531901001930237,
1.0496420860290527,
-0.08388501405715942,
0.009892907924950123,
-1.10068941116333,
0.04236690327525139,
0.3722074031829834,
0.4496179521083832,
0.1545325070619583,
-0.04382883384823799,
-0.4963066577911377,
0.025691956281661987,
-0.35896843671798706,
-1.023916482925415,
0.07044228911399841,
-0.17629097402095795,
0.382238507270813,
0.4503246545791626,
-0.10194913297891617,
0.4798424243927002,
-0.7651435732841492,
0.8483604192733765,
0.3915034234523773,
-1.0247104167938232,
0.5673985481262207,
-0.7080836892127991,
0.5418838262557983,
0.38115864992141724,
0.4661846458911896,
-0.5528327822685242,
-0.4011564254760742,
-0.5776963829994202,
-0.5825798511505127,
0.5803447365760803,
0.33713141083717346,
-0.1430519074201584,
-0.3756076395511627,
0.18895882368087769,
-0.19136588275432587,
0.06872463971376419,
-0.45770418643951416,
-0.3121904134750366,
0.5674244165420532,
-0.069603830575943,
-0.1548946350812912,
-0.016527442261576653,
-0.06679825484752655,
-0.3108311593532562,
0.26198333501815796,
-0.12340524792671204,
0.33420369029045105,
0.09052835404872894,
0.10439582914113998,
-0.1383761465549469,
-0.14967355132102966,
0.6250815987586975,
0.9550054669380188,
0.10681286454200745,
0.18706288933753967,
0.10597892105579376,
-0.33916139602661133,
0.2911781668663025,
-0.037605173885822296,
-0.1445089876651764,
0.10461948066949844,
0.5290131568908691,
0.721805989742279,
0.04920756444334984,
-0.905671238899231,
0.14121884107589722,
0.023488890379667282,
-0.22015781700611115,
-0.49725109338760376,
0.09541887789964676,
0.6040061712265015,
0.4626476466655731,
0.2953341007232666,
0.25239798426628113,
0.07529649138450623,
-0.8783822059631348,
0.09423523396253586,
0.5302464365959167,
-0.31844082474708557,
-0.47016945481300354,
0.42646825313568115,
0.3957194983959198,
-0.664840817451477,
0.862501323223114,
-0.03521532937884331,
-0.5211057662963867,
0.7865937352180481,
0.36534783244132996,
0.856645941734314,
0.04492945224046707,
0.025329014286398888,
0.25277814269065857,
0.47125333547592163,
-0.28428399562835693,
0.10696978867053986,
0.029677558690309525,
-0.8679032921791077,
-0.6495380401611328,
0.04084264487028122,
-0.3746925890445709,
0.15372934937477112,
-0.27382975816726685,
0.12930703163146973,
-0.48299312591552734,
-0.36515411734580994,
-0.1056443378329277,
0.01212254073470831,
-0.7317470908164978,
-0.13656435906887054,
0.2573658227920532,
1.1038861274719238,
-1.0699536800384521,
0.561627209186554,
0.830552875995636,
-0.4037727415561676,
-0.7060178518295288,
0.0236979853361845,
0.11124702543020248,
-0.3860970437526703,
0.7589232921600342,
0.25394997000694275,
-0.10307057946920395,
0.08457532525062561,
-0.1700410544872284,
-1.1519780158996582,
0.8982266783714294,
0.22974476218223572,
-0.5474848747253418,
-0.37261247634887695,
0.29302287101745605,
0.5599140524864197,
-0.3344559669494629,
0.30636391043663025,
0.7585536241531372,
0.3486431837081909,
-0.010237923823297024,
-0.9633923172950745,
0.08165682852268219,
-0.24100248515605927,
-0.2438015341758728,
0.34234100580215454,
-0.6386789679527283,
0.9441764950752258,
-0.2436709702014923,
-0.23090507090091705,
-0.15348637104034424,
0.7684558629989624,
0.3201596438884735,
0.41437503695487976,
0.5397075414657593,
0.7064148783683777,
0.7923317551612854,
0.08961965888738632,
0.6120738983154297,
-0.15136772394180298,
0.033993255347013474,
0.9945515990257263,
-0.3175024688243866,
0.764968752861023,
0.6167782545089722,
-0.22921721637248993,
0.50833660364151,
0.5476271510124207,
0.19125109910964966,
0.3015015125274658,
0.5164921283721924,
-0.08563625812530518,
-0.13768218457698822,
-0.021234292536973953,
-0.3523925244808197,
0.449617862701416,
0.6265420913696289,
-0.09378784894943237,
-0.36740195751190186,
-0.21210230886936188,
-0.4126303493976593,
0.14164574444293976,
-0.2344397008419037,
0.6890488862991333,
0.3190498352050781,
-1.1021931171417236,
0.577105700969696,
-0.1736309677362442,
0.43827390670776367,
-0.30512815713882446,
-0.13465574383735657,
-0.5060212016105652,
0.4006167948246002,
0.03782690316438675,
-0.9691396355628967,
0.5102948546409607,
-0.15492363274097443,
-0.08218292891979218,
0.06427948921918869,
0.4984126091003418,
-0.48217737674713135,
-0.345322847366333,
0.40932002663612366,
0.779735267162323,
0.22807009518146515,
0.04110027849674225,
-0.8803406357765198,
0.13890446722507477,
0.08021793514490128,
-0.08420541882514954,
0.2905108332633972,
0.8359009623527527,
-0.10869922488927841,
0.991356372833252,
0.416400283575058,
0.17081691324710846,
0.08105358481407166,
-0.20718517899513245,
0.7906590104103088,
-1.1396782398223877,
-0.753495454788208,
-0.9208989143371582,
0.2769300043582916,
-0.18007315695285797,
-0.45860397815704346,
0.8078401684761047,
0.34474053978919983,
0.8329691290855408,
-0.0527927465736866,
0.5922679305076599,
0.25264278054237366,
0.21661856770515442,
-0.45508018136024475,
0.6038328409194946,
-0.30959391593933105,
0.3144143521785736,
-0.27169927954673767,
-0.9062094688415527,
-0.21551862359046936,
0.4720004200935364,
-0.4236451983451843,
-0.2868638336658478,
1.049271821975708,
0.6428630352020264,
-0.1175159141421318,
0.4911375939846039,
0.1907866895198822,
0.18832848966121674,
0.24348430335521698,
1.079793095588684,
0.922238826751709,
-0.4191560447216034,
0.3130582571029663,
0.14798958599567413,
-0.20763510465621948,
-0.11938615888357162,
-0.8702676296234131,
-1.3132226467132568,
-0.7608587145805359,
-0.45114001631736755,
-0.29885348677635193,
0.023778604343533516,
0.8405120968818665,
0.21540549397468567,
-0.5370711088180542,
-0.5509041547775269,
-0.6734201908111572,
0.2050321400165558,
-0.11166772991418839,
-0.18167203664779663,
0.30862995982170105,
-0.3334718942642212,
-0.3856373131275177,
0.5042290687561035,
0.3396732211112976,
-0.17380696535110474,
-0.4575100839138031,
0.1594822108745575,
-0.7055884599685669,
0.17407137155532837,
0.5545971989631653,
0.2959171533584595,
-0.704208254814148,
-0.2821885943412781,
-0.033890824764966965,
0.014716897159814835,
-0.24284669756889343,
0.8435065746307373,
-0.7648504972457886,
0.2956587076187134,
0.8614519834518433,
1.1109496355056763,
0.396526575088501,
-0.20463503897190094,
0.839451253414154,
-0.19365544617176056,
0.1719074547290802,
0.44710856676101685,
0.4275485873222351,
0.2945353388786316,
-0.07182272523641586,
0.4674304723739624,
0.40280044078826904,
-0.5344769358634949,
-0.628549337387085,
0.6172300577163696,
-0.5533062815666199,
-0.32521557807922363,
0.8926889300346375,
-0.21580259501934052,
-0.41873595118522644,
-0.44528728723526,
0.1778974086046219,
0.035432975739240646,
-0.060625478625297546,
0.9592716693878174,
1.0108096599578857,
-0.31531479954719543,
-0.18632368743419647,
-0.4155125617980957,
0.5065735578536987,
0.5717436075210571,
-0.5208321213722229,
-0.02548651583492756,
0.7917858958244324,
-0.15365272760391235,
0.49020832777023315,
0.7013716697692871,
0.1950007528066635,
0.037939321249723434,
0.1709005981683731,
-0.37879762053489685,
0.19990865886211395,
-0.30165642499923706,
-0.17703168094158173,
0.030949031934142113,
-0.19471688568592072,
-0.03373013809323311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11726v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11726v1
|
Investigating Gender Bias in Turkish Language Models
| 2024-04-17T20:24:41 | 2024-04-17T20:24:41 |
Orhun Caglidil, Malte Ostendorff, Georg Rehm
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models are trained mostly on Web data, which often contains social
stereotypes and biases that the models can inherit. This has potentially
negative consequences, as models can amplify these biases in downstream tasks
or applications. However, prior research has primarily focused on the English
language, especially in the context of gender bias. In particular,
grammatically gender-neutral languages such as Turkish are underexplored
despite representing different linguistic properties to language models with
possibly different effects on biases. In this paper, we fill this research gap
and investigate the significance of gender bias in Turkish language models. We
build upon existing bias evaluation frameworks and extend them to the Turkish
language by translating existing English tests and creating new ones designed
to measure gender bias in the context of T\"urkiye. Specifically, we also
evaluate Turkish language models for their embedded ethnic bias toward Kurdish
people. Based on the experimental results, we attribute possible biases to
different model characteristics such as the model size, their multilingualism,
and the training corpora. We make the Turkish gender bias dataset publicly
available.
|
[
-0.4750252664089203,
-0.6520810723304749,
0.2832473814487457,
0.1841873973608017,
-0.0009144630748778582,
-0.2376508116722107,
-0.26065295934677124,
-0.4283387362957001,
-0.18073442578315735,
0.5304573178291321,
-0.5404570698738098,
-0.48104578256607056,
-0.687189519405365,
0.2414361536502838,
-0.35541483759880066,
0.9589025378227234,
-0.11215012520551682,
0.536216139793396,
-0.08218206465244293,
-0.3164283037185669,
-0.5296233892440796,
-0.4289417266845703,
-0.2887299656867981,
-0.34926265478134155,
0.29604843258857727,
0.23469901084899902,
0.33552032709121704,
0.21813447773456573,
0.1002340093255043,
0.15420056879520416,
-0.22372876107692719,
-0.2647276818752289,
-0.27639663219451904,
0.10544972121715546,
-0.18994933366775513,
-0.3803744614124298,
-0.2191721796989441,
0.31440913677215576,
0.7854828238487244,
0.8941874504089355,
-0.006921700201928616,
0.8097007870674133,
0.25851890444755554,
0.7452974319458008,
-1.0837115049362183,
0.1746242344379425,
-0.4234558045864105,
0.13250719010829926,
-0.24901297688484192,
0.19485945999622345,
-0.13041146099567413,
-0.4085693359375,
0.3194822669029236,
-0.16464915871620178,
0.6242386102676392,
-0.02764310874044895,
0.533984363079071,
-0.19487039744853973,
-0.9775344133377075,
-0.053136326372623444,
-0.7692151069641113,
0.9021768569946289,
-0.8406320810317993,
0.8017136454582214,
0.6896473169326782,
0.3485508859157562,
-0.2691916823387146,
-0.16381409764289856,
-0.4611753821372986,
-0.5568006634712219,
-0.21426789462566376,
-0.1930800825357437,
-0.1700364649295807,
-0.17848168313503265,
0.17266373336315155,
0.20989356935024261,
-0.3655679225921631,
-0.13874877989292145,
-0.44693174958229065,
0.18204917013645172,
0.6426585912704468,
-0.00021413384820334613,
0.3289314806461334,
-0.12224467098712921,
0.30753302574157715,
0.10997658222913742,
-0.7466937303543091,
0.0993187204003334,
1.1449378728866577,
0.4825839698314667,
-0.06866307556629181,
0.882629930973053,
-0.35356587171554565,
0.4719788730144501,
0.13559289276599884,
-0.044082723557949066,
0.1508525162935257,
-0.18336398899555206,
-0.03975233435630798,
0.26559510827064514,
0.5073879361152649,
0.16198612749576569,
0.31662416458129883,
-0.0751519650220871,
0.07855015248060226,
0.07739951461553574,
0.3272218108177185,
-0.481935977935791,
0.11720099300146103,
0.14401426911354065,
-0.662269651889801,
-0.59710294008255,
-0.07669062167406082,
-0.8326475024223328,
-0.6429603099822998,
0.16156233847141266,
0.08669193089008331,
0.02676531672477722,
-0.6936566829681396,
0.14014221727848053,
-0.23195014894008636,
0.08415936678647995,
0.16130125522613525,
-1.1239795684814453,
0.4005204439163208,
0.7410231232643127,
0.29303815960884094,
0.18002760410308838,
-0.3471648693084717,
-0.35059940814971924,
0.026040907949209213,
-0.4457787275314331,
0.5242415070533752,
-0.7133573293685913,
-0.26166173815727234,
0.270717591047287,
0.19741953909397125,
-0.1027606651186943,
-0.39197418093681335,
0.6412639617919922,
-0.03940805792808533,
0.6753689050674438,
-0.40965577960014343,
-0.5084943771362305,
-0.28976520895957947,
0.16915282607078552,
-0.7094222903251648,
0.9903040528297424,
-0.13849614560604095,
-1.2893327474594116,
0.6147721409797668,
-0.4837513267993927,
-0.35270625352859497,
-0.30895137786865234,
-0.34682726860046387,
-0.48465222120285034,
0.4173942506313324,
0.24028953909873962,
0.27690643072128296,
-0.35342076420783997,
0.3548111617565155,
-0.5448437333106995,
-0.34072166681289673,
0.26352933049201965,
-0.2877829372882843,
0.9575768113136292,
-0.05906800553202629,
-0.6565821170806885,
-0.13814061880111694,
-0.6142623424530029,
-0.5231839418411255,
0.176609605550766,
-0.3947118818759918,
-0.7267993688583374,
0.10772295296192169,
0.14644688367843628,
0.05477346479892731,
-0.08187136054039001,
-0.7615156173706055,
0.10723192244768143,
-0.18551082909107208,
-0.05486498400568962,
0.7027852535247803,
-0.2993148863315582,
0.652748167514801,
-0.1260809451341629,
0.6938401460647583,
-0.16201388835906982,
0.03754333406686783,
0.3693277835845947,
-0.5950338840484619,
-0.8678135275840759,
-0.10927999764680862,
0.4276965260505676,
0.25985947251319885,
0.07751471549272537,
0.1636946052312851,
0.05090121552348137,
-0.28334563970565796,
-0.7818163633346558,
0.10050329566001892,
0.16755065321922302,
0.39623337984085083,
-0.08408965170383453,
-0.08866070955991745,
-0.6456642746925354,
-1.2232657670974731,
-0.6537724733352661,
-0.3691174387931824,
-0.13776810467243195,
0.3003980219364166,
0.6524688601493835,
-0.10158353298902512,
0.7635027170181274,
-0.046838853508234024,
-0.35618340969085693,
-0.5772600173950195,
0.21220757067203522,
0.06409469246864319,
0.5151067972183228,
0.5238515734672546,
-0.465668648481369,
-0.19516925513744354,
-0.030167823657393456,
-0.5140959024429321,
-0.3889467716217041,
0.3181025981903076,
-0.10244748741388321,
0.49949026107788086,
0.3326023817062378,
-0.5632707476615906,
0.6102696061134338,
0.8327642679214478,
-0.8935099840164185,
0.8512973189353943,
0.22125713527202606,
0.31607332825660706,
-0.9461153149604797,
0.23664289712905884,
0.16081231832504272,
-0.11401917040348053,
-0.6413472294807434,
0.13906125724315643,
-0.14716143906116486,
0.07765424996614456,
-0.46931391954421997,
0.7247583270072937,
-0.5391161441802979,
-0.22139756381511688,
-0.12961940467357635,
-0.4486228823661804,
0.00036776013439521194,
0.18059176206588745,
0.18492773175239563,
0.5665440559387207,
0.16927912831306458,
-0.2912105619907379,
-0.020680615678429604,
0.024839509278535843,
-0.5173211693763733,
0.2982015013694763,
-0.4801796078681946,
0.10157313942909241,
-0.2857559621334076,
0.10325264185667038,
-0.8562366366386414,
0.07489312440156937,
0.4325166642665863,
-0.4209043085575104,
0.18346211314201355,
-0.6523793339729309,
-0.23605220019817352,
-0.18178372085094452,
-0.2830166518688202,
0.43688076734542847,
0.3086683452129364,
-0.18096336722373962,
0.6243008375167847,
0.4578266441822052,
-0.1133178249001503,
-0.9149327278137207,
-0.6237347722053528,
-0.24523986876010895,
-0.4877766966819763,
-0.48475581407546997,
-0.27656838297843933,
0.3225529193878174,
-0.7125516533851624,
0.015805352479219437,
-0.08002845197916031,
-0.14218121767044067,
0.22827854752540588,
0.2437744140625,
0.058333542197942734,
-0.41609296202659607,
0.14526835083961487,
0.28000688552856445,
0.3510974645614624,
0.1323031485080719,
-0.45614349842071533,
0.6584888696670532,
-0.30357056856155396,
-0.3532913625240326,
-0.2830538749694824,
0.4470480978488922,
0.4637953042984009,
-0.2604851722717285,
1.0695319175720215,
0.6975067853927612,
-0.5129884481430054,
0.22011788189411163,
-0.9216439127922058,
-0.23176319897174835,
-0.3885473608970642,
0.5963689684867859,
-0.3144717812538147,
-0.977108359336853,
0.4721662402153015,
0.34085652232170105,
0.07323969900608063,
0.4278832674026489,
0.5817322731018066,
-0.2969827651977539,
1.1138089895248413,
0.7978483438491821,
-0.2169327586889267,
0.26085537672042847,
-0.003392347600311041,
-0.04008321836590767,
-0.6905009150505066,
-0.1293020397424698,
-0.8684192895889282,
-0.036357130855321884,
-0.8768705129623413,
-0.03568935766816139,
-0.12603497505187988,
-0.13839690387248993,
-0.2712756395339966,
-0.06958475708961487,
0.11058277636766434,
0.3971673846244812,
0.5440871715545654,
-0.1444600373506546,
0.2019362598657608,
0.3297305405139923,
-0.10751917958259583,
-0.23009128868579865,
-0.6231091618537903,
-0.7989673018455505,
1.3719278573989868,
0.5194171071052551,
0.6246100664138794,
0.1328263133764267,
0.39598631858825684,
0.6035730242729187,
0.03877096623182297,
-0.22205708920955658,
0.2581883370876312,
-0.20912471413612366,
-1.1336464881896973,
-0.34711822867393494,
-0.3260350227355957,
-1.0659281015396118,
0.4145064353942871,
-0.4493323564529419,
-0.9230387806892395,
0.3127083480358124,
0.23360668122768402,
0.2084117978811264,
0.38273757696151733,
-0.6162689924240112,
1.0091692209243774,
0.052710819989442825,
-0.4045493006706238,
-0.2708568871021271,
-0.14577361941337585,
0.5636762380599976,
0.07326504588127136,
0.1972082108259201,
-0.2996583580970764,
0.3840193748474121,
0.8545731902122498,
-0.26048916578292847,
0.6561142206192017,
-0.028927400708198547,
-0.2534477412700653,
-0.15574806928634644,
0.24781006574630737,
0.1729704886674881,
0.026962600648403168,
-0.0335470549762249,
0.5136207342147827,
-0.004201496951282024,
-0.7555806040763855,
-0.33316683769226074,
0.526254415512085,
-0.89368736743927,
-0.7074575424194336,
-0.5031515955924988,
-0.3694518506526947,
-0.08167894184589386,
0.145035520195961,
-0.03293682262301445,
0.3696611225605011,
-0.5764598846435547,
-0.1820671707391739,
0.37678831815719604,
-0.5510517358779907,
0.019699880853295326,
0.6786178946495056,
-0.310189813375473,
0.07240898907184601,
0.4097653925418854,
-0.09430902451276779,
0.08086930215358734,
0.09038161486387253,
0.4240168333053589,
-0.22979731857776642,
-0.19773836433887482,
-0.5133340358734131,
0.33574312925338745,
-0.4518255591392517,
0.46543607115745544,
-0.7567193508148193,
0.09205126017332077,
-0.8903599381446838,
0.17983053624629974,
-0.6923652291297913,
-0.6359148025512695,
0.014889596030116081,
-0.18993334472179413,
0.020107751712203026,
1.0019012689590454,
0.18577814102172852,
0.06246507167816162,
-0.42398399114608765,
0.19940003752708435,
0.5064277052879333,
0.1508917212486267,
0.10781551152467728,
-0.5174457430839539,
-0.07437276095151901,
-0.017166171222925186,
0.016470305621623993,
-1.045832872390747,
0.3843770921230316,
-0.09801123291254044,
0.5729764103889465,
0.3346507251262665,
-0.22251726686954498,
0.18167521059513092,
-0.5691804885864258,
0.7167205214500427,
-0.2238951176404953,
-0.8526294827461243,
0.518439531326294,
-0.592046856880188,
0.3890318274497986,
0.5325806140899658,
0.3747628927230835,
-0.7446051239967346,
-0.7113965153694153,
-0.5019600987434387,
-0.5384418964385986,
0.7672058343887329,
0.5100163817405701,
0.20618309080600739,
0.20753616094589233,
0.26559963822364807,
0.45920899510383606,
0.4196716248989105,
-0.7124795317649841,
-0.4363637864589691,
-0.07748839259147644,
-0.08305809646844864,
-0.04852135106921196,
-0.746368944644928,
0.06945114582777023,
-0.31858816742897034,
0.8305960297584534,
0.1983388513326645,
0.37725916504859924,
-0.27508556842803955,
-0.3626559376716614,
-0.2931140959262848,
0.6605944037437439,
0.6528672575950623,
0.749214768409729,
-0.49584877490997314,
0.2015215903520584,
0.3345782458782196,
-0.8124221563339233,
0.37756264209747314,
0.18620739877223969,
-0.4103069305419922,
0.11646061390638351,
0.45219674706459045,
0.7927168011665344,
-0.3240450322628021,
-0.49800312519073486,
0.45951876044273376,
-0.5035654306411743,
0.04023264721035957,
-0.5829327702522278,
-0.34406307339668274,
0.10388101637363434,
0.38078275322914124,
0.5204601883888245,
-0.3090824782848358,
0.2882162630558014,
-0.5651939511299133,
-0.0861181914806366,
0.3529747426509857,
-0.39972177147865295,
-0.35759568214416504,
0.5259690880775452,
0.24543853104114532,
-0.056202176958322525,
0.6648467183113098,
0.10176843404769897,
-0.6763748526573181,
0.6399641036987305,
0.4330657124519348,
1.0073546171188354,
-0.4217640459537506,
0.37924087047576904,
0.30597203969955444,
0.7987228035926819,
0.2030380517244339,
0.21163076162338257,
0.08763410151004791,
-0.7740228176116943,
-0.26967284083366394,
-0.5801506638526917,
-0.021688133478164673,
0.5056046843528748,
-0.5720496773719788,
0.5073195099830627,
-0.2300424575805664,
-0.23378047347068787,
-0.26464948058128357,
0.051168497651815414,
-0.6483187675476074,
0.002456211717799306,
0.5518300533294678,
0.7649503946304321,
-1.2889045476913452,
0.582047700881958,
1.078018069267273,
-0.21622946858406067,
-0.28965991735458374,
0.09184781461954117,
0.11917229741811752,
-0.5358729362487793,
0.9843129515647888,
0.3240746855735779,
0.04172908514738083,
-0.455165833234787,
-0.10742751508951187,
-0.6576788425445557,
0.5771048069000244,
0.649298369884491,
-0.281410276889801,
0.0792149007320404,
0.5935044884681702,
0.41913095116615295,
-0.37246301770210266,
0.5087346434593201,
0.6601393222808838,
0.35737136006355286,
-0.7713525891304016,
-0.9743706583976746,
0.06092270463705063,
-0.40119755268096924,
-0.056720342487096786,
-0.04788859933614731,
-0.2916836142539978,
0.7555444836616516,
0.19850046932697296,
0.10015896707773209,
-0.20280547440052032,
0.6587666273117065,
0.30808117985725403,
0.23507706820964813,
0.6094779968261719,
0.46836477518081665,
0.4524909555912018,
0.2075575441122055,
0.9563135504722595,
0.05208497866988182,
0.14384374022483826,
1.129158616065979,
-0.12401563674211502,
0.4202866852283478,
0.527817964553833,
-0.25635474920272827,
0.5452902913093567,
0.5387778282165527,
0.27676326036453247,
0.3844808340072632,
0.1732044368982315,
-0.4010644853115082,
-0.17076437175273895,
-0.4817892909049988,
-0.4388613998889923,
0.5209417343139648,
0.05379636958241463,
-0.5533233880996704,
-0.1377238929271698,
-0.07500098645687103,
0.35437315702438354,
-0.13706648349761963,
-0.18726330995559692,
0.34529462456703186,
-0.06619580835103989,
-0.41097015142440796,
0.21877387166023254,
0.19665250182151794,
0.43315601348876953,
-0.487689346075058,
-0.07969503104686737,
-0.5233802199363708,
0.16720329225063324,
-0.09081652760505676,
-0.278616338968277,
0.07035847008228302,
0.20662455260753632,
-0.17813263833522797,
0.14092595875263214,
0.9146785140037537,
-0.6189441084861755,
-0.8226941823959351,
0.1449856162071228,
0.6227608919143677,
0.07211615890264511,
-0.20366819202899933,
-0.5262759923934937,
-0.04812682792544365,
0.030203543603420258,
-0.24399606883525848,
0.3512440621852875,
0.08275643736124039,
-0.4011865258216858,
0.7549384236335754,
0.3576652705669403,
0.2978425621986389,
0.41946378350257874,
0.24502986669540405,
0.3242071270942688,
-0.5320510268211365,
-0.38503172993659973,
-0.9301436543464661,
0.24514491856098175,
0.09070388227701187,
-0.26291748881340027,
1.1063474416732788,
0.49904724955558777,
0.9564384818077087,
-0.17551547288894653,
0.9975051283836365,
0.160251185297966,
0.3547940254211426,
-0.2556892931461334,
1.1750479936599731,
-0.6518876552581787,
-0.002097729593515396,
-0.6623414158821106,
-1.0571109056472778,
-0.016910793259739876,
0.6965339183807373,
-0.3560093641281128,
0.026236793026328087,
0.44206807017326355,
0.4822881817817688,
-0.2359398752450943,
0.13026481866836548,
0.126893550157547,
0.2018660604953766,
0.03673723340034485,
0.01475472841411829,
1.1636587381362915,
-0.42548230290412903,
0.22251379489898682,
-0.342723548412323,
0.02600390650331974,
-0.17047302424907684,
-0.8226568102836609,
-1.4087140560150146,
-0.46697863936424255,
-0.3515354096889496,
-0.29867517948150635,
0.5397869944572449,
1.0055150985717773,
0.5235833525657654,
-1.013875126838684,
-0.6363961100578308,
0.05654200538992882,
0.24359722435474396,
-0.015723902732133865,
-0.17342065274715424,
0.34980499744415283,
-0.003619465744122863,
-0.7009351253509521,
0.06358768045902252,
-0.32430943846702576,
0.05140798166394234,
-0.4648992419242859,
-0.12126008421182632,
-0.38657549023628235,
-0.04396443068981171,
0.28836700320243835,
0.1012769564986229,
-0.5923693776130676,
-0.1778755635023117,
-0.13869033753871918,
0.05984925106167793,
-0.3074880540370941,
0.8766826391220093,
-0.5509241223335266,
0.3896217942237854,
0.6373963952064514,
0.32575199007987976,
0.5021289587020874,
-0.3513015806674957,
1.224880576133728,
-0.6534686088562012,
0.37929579615592957,
-0.11205560714006424,
0.591995120048523,
0.5002018809318542,
-0.2386511266231537,
0.3953816890716553,
0.25712597370147705,
-0.2392628788948059,
-0.9111876487731934,
0.12512540817260742,
-0.22986125946044922,
-0.38255441188812256,
1.4511994123458862,
-0.06803851574659348,
-0.10324494540691376,
-0.28161120414733887,
-0.19856268167495728,
0.5229443311691284,
-0.4617351293563843,
1.0317329168319702,
0.8868623971939087,
0.2968786358833313,
-0.24825419485569,
-0.9000145792961121,
0.46851274371147156,
0.704370379447937,
-0.38037383556365967,
0.09960605949163437,
0.3934670686721802,
0.4985383450984955,
-0.27899450063705444,
0.503633975982666,
-0.11481110006570816,
0.28658849000930786,
-0.1587490439414978,
0.3581226170063019,
0.04869817569851875,
-0.059337832033634186,
-0.6680313944816589,
-0.15845459699630737,
0.17774555087089539,
-0.06911180168390274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11717v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11717v1
|
How often are errors in natural language reasoning due to paraphrastic variability?
| 2024-04-17T20:11:32 | 2024-04-17T20:11:32 |
Neha Srikanth, Marine Carpuat, Rachel Rudinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models have been shown to behave inconsistently in response to
meaning-preserving paraphrastic inputs. At the same time, researchers evaluate
the knowledge and reasoning abilities of these models with test evaluations
that do not disaggregate the effect of paraphrastic variability on performance.
We propose a metric for evaluating the paraphrastic consistency of natural
language reasoning models based on the probability of a model achieving the
same correctness on two paraphrases of the same problem. We mathematically
connect this metric to the proportion of a model's variance in correctness
attributable to paraphrasing. To estimate paraphrastic consistency, we collect
ParaNLU, a dataset of 7,782 human-written and validated paraphrased reasoning
problems constructed on top of existing benchmark datasets for defeasible and
abductive natural language inference. Using ParaNLU, we measure the
paraphrastic consistency of several model classes and show that consistency
dramatically increases with pretraining but not finetuning. All models tested
exhibited room for improvement in paraphrastic consistency.
|
[
0.09395057708024979,
-0.763462483882904,
0.675559937953949,
0.5244302153587341,
-0.18448765575885773,
-0.3246629536151886,
-0.32623091340065,
-0.11247684061527252,
-0.13701379299163818,
0.5139176249504089,
-0.16355985403060913,
-0.31063947081565857,
-0.6402977705001831,
0.33483296632766724,
-0.5172511339187622,
0.7987926602363586,
-0.10500112175941467,
0.02486957050859928,
-0.5189421772956848,
-0.545744776725769,
-0.3669947385787964,
-0.36213696002960205,
-0.22440579533576965,
-0.13851703703403473,
0.5348007082939148,
0.2591126561164856,
1.1215789318084717,
0.6019247770309448,
0.7930151224136353,
0.32254758477211,
0.005047202575951815,
0.2930946350097656,
0.016045698896050453,
0.13102249801158905,
-0.614832878112793,
-0.4658777713775635,
-0.218632772564888,
-0.06789685785770416,
0.7902482151985168,
0.793597400188446,
-0.4931870400905609,
-0.036081671714782715,
0.2994953989982605,
0.19067314267158508,
-0.544390857219696,
0.146652489900589,
-0.6309522390365601,
-0.35807254910469055,
-0.1025223433971405,
0.11878588050603867,
-0.14820556342601776,
-0.8905021548271179,
0.29214218258857727,
-0.6000419855117798,
0.12755775451660156,
0.006046888418495655,
1.0052977800369263,
0.3884066939353943,
0.09583400189876556,
-0.2684779167175293,
-0.5230125784873962,
0.9641671776771545,
-1.1622674465179443,
0.31101852655410767,
0.6295440196990967,
0.2740144729614258,
0.013615182600915432,
-0.679891049861908,
-0.6465108394622803,
-0.4661657214164734,
-0.04565385356545448,
-0.3113313615322113,
-0.20661036670207977,
-0.2073814868927002,
-0.00984653178602457,
0.15470606088638306,
-0.6684073805809021,
-0.21302126348018646,
0.0507880263030529,
-0.29484835267066956,
0.5405260324478149,
0.1686573028564453,
0.32401949167251587,
-0.2633880376815796,
-0.1514732837677002,
-0.06815505027770996,
-0.09762150049209595,
-0.1133563295006752,
0.3609083890914917,
0.19133935868740082,
0.2952215075492859,
0.47503629326820374,
-0.2275804877281189,
0.68868488073349,
-0.2580301761627197,
-0.05226390063762665,
0.20499660074710846,
-0.6016016006469727,
-0.3150080442428589,
-0.47432634234428406,
0.8605361580848694,
0.42324313521385193,
0.3172178268432617,
-0.47657349705696106,
-0.18552187085151672,
0.1389797180891037,
0.2951182723045349,
-0.2501557767391205,
-0.5171723365783691,
-0.21416176855564117,
-0.11606745421886444,
-0.02875140681862831,
0.21263276040554047,
-0.6785070300102234,
-0.460114061832428,
-0.5395501255989075,
0.7584312558174133,
-0.876724898815155,
-0.20642784237861633,
0.4236743450164795,
-0.29167699813842773,
-0.04982322081923485,
0.14875701069831848,
-0.5708264708518982,
0.46495023369789124,
0.7598681449890137,
0.7823632955551147,
-0.2969839572906494,
-0.9732655882835388,
-0.27726277709007263,
-0.15271247923374176,
-0.3841096758842468,
0.7704633474349976,
-0.5445378422737122,
-0.010039734654128551,
-0.11376272141933441,
-0.05255063623189926,
-0.45773690938949585,
-0.7720952033996582,
1.0119613409042358,
0.04480532929301262,
0.004493377637118101,
-0.534399151802063,
-1.051692247390747,
-0.07305041700601578,
0.2511601150035858,
-0.417762815952301,
0.8960154056549072,
0.03763741999864578,
-0.8094735741615295,
0.23864993453025818,
-0.2562483847141266,
-0.04205220937728882,
0.10629896074533463,
-0.049009017646312714,
-0.5372241139411926,
0.3109878599643707,
-0.10500667244195938,
0.1345992237329483,
-0.2802061140537262,
0.661392092704773,
-0.3418673276901245,
-0.39328235387802124,
0.40289828181266785,
-0.751497745513916,
0.5827761292457581,
-0.03949211910367012,
-0.2592218816280365,
-0.16527245938777924,
-0.8827577829360962,
0.18773581087589264,
-0.04203077033162117,
-0.13745230436325073,
-0.43267831206321716,
0.1292037069797516,
-0.13888241350650787,
0.0804111436009407,
0.3218023478984833,
-0.5905742645263672,
-0.3235202133655548,
-0.2731306552886963,
0.3749291002750397,
0.5252004265785217,
0.09714120626449585,
0.2185031920671463,
-0.757764458656311,
0.1664694994688034,
-0.07303040474653244,
0.05439988151192665,
0.22103963792324066,
-0.5186285972595215,
-0.6977049708366394,
0.1763412058353424,
0.2463540881872177,
0.33699139952659607,
-0.2317200005054474,
0.48536065220832825,
-0.3805055022239685,
-0.8063316941261292,
-0.3551878035068512,
0.3133973181247711,
0.4751875102519989,
0.6313089728355408,
0.5861245393753052,
-0.04821489378809929,
-0.5031936168670654,
-0.9285329580307007,
-0.8744933605194092,
-0.17289043962955475,
-0.10150958597660065,
-0.013790752738714218,
0.4763129651546478,
-0.033057522028684616,
0.7785230875015259,
-0.03831828385591507,
0.21889552474021912,
-0.26865771412849426,
0.5667552351951599,
-0.11283757537603378,
0.6088882684707642,
0.3917034864425659,
-0.41894611716270447,
-0.39530718326568604,
-0.13672992587089539,
-0.7919529676437378,
-0.2725476920604706,
-0.0634736716747284,
-0.3396485149860382,
0.07151935994625092,
0.14423055946826935,
-0.7538340091705322,
0.27475470304489136,
0.33066707849502563,
-0.28639131784439087,
0.7715690732002258,
-0.4996899664402008,
0.1685008704662323,
-0.601908802986145,
0.0331195667386055,
0.12425047159194946,
0.021545037627220154,
-0.42190828919410706,
-0.01738033816218376,
0.2293146401643753,
0.38980624079704285,
-0.07197526097297668,
0.40747788548469543,
0.0009060802403837442,
0.12958933413028717,
-0.225462406873703,
0.2389713078737259,
0.35897621512413025,
0.21534918248653412,
-0.04213863983750343,
0.5423521399497986,
0.45203644037246704,
-0.7188614010810852,
0.44626903533935547,
0.12298522889614105,
-0.4537564516067505,
0.8976467847824097,
-0.729611873626709,
0.13497181236743927,
-0.011768038384616375,
0.0880400687456131,
-0.8339649438858032,
-0.3482118248939514,
0.02463589981198311,
-0.29566606879234314,
-0.31586095690727234,
0.36356303095817566,
-0.583185613155365,
-0.20909187197685242,
-0.016621600836515427,
0.11809934675693512,
0.353578120470047,
-0.3608251214027405,
0.436066210269928,
-0.1453300565481186,
-0.004023164976388216,
-0.4135112166404724,
-0.6764695048332214,
0.037228427827358246,
-0.30273038148880005,
-0.6263604760169983,
0.0824718102812767,
-0.07377026230096817,
-0.43023860454559326,
-0.08893843740224838,
-0.4332544803619385,
-0.4960084855556488,
0.026475930586457253,
0.03864667937159538,
0.05556739121675491,
-0.3101930022239685,
0.34082433581352234,
-0.3686666190624237,
0.2440091371536255,
0.2758153975009918,
-0.43578940629959106,
0.3441877067089081,
-0.31132081151008606,
-0.5006241798400879,
-0.7205380201339722,
0.04829135537147522,
0.5653741359710693,
-0.11773953586816788,
0.6281238198280334,
0.3150618076324463,
-0.43407976627349854,
0.16626636683940887,
-0.5783557295799255,
0.11895676702260971,
-0.3921787142753601,
0.25654977560043335,
-0.25322723388671875,
-0.1489204466342926,
0.5101360082626343,
0.46860471367836,
0.19148273766040802,
0.6831101179122925,
0.14003108441829681,
-0.25083014369010925,
0.729612410068512,
0.22235406935214996,
0.5526561141014099,
0.021795185282826424,
0.0985918715596199,
-0.005042837932705879,
-0.28287065029144287,
-0.272232323884964,
-0.5728582143783569,
-0.25948503613471985,
-0.2563683092594147,
-0.5257686972618103,
-0.24299649894237518,
0.2226436883211136,
-0.41953709721565247,
0.5242477655410767,
-0.167603999376297,
0.6760241985321045,
0.7048451900482178,
0.14837391674518585,
0.2772884666919708,
-0.2860581576824188,
-0.18018896877765656,
-0.37933406233787537,
-0.519038736820221,
-0.794889509677887,
0.896679699420929,
0.021922703832387924,
0.6016079187393188,
0.08559820801019669,
0.5767108201980591,
0.033630043268203735,
0.03171822056174278,
-0.24835415184497833,
0.5311260223388672,
-0.04800794646143913,
-0.41241127252578735,
-0.4757222831249237,
-0.5306159853935242,
-0.6339344382286072,
-0.027022726833820343,
0.14634579420089722,
-0.7138707041740417,
0.015702929347753525,
0.15605725347995758,
-0.34770044684410095,
0.4430999755859375,
-0.5195455551147461,
1.1008230447769165,
-0.11702096462249756,
-0.2666980028152466,
0.07941437512636185,
-0.8163164854049683,
0.14682762324810028,
-0.13563239574432373,
0.002911166287958622,
-0.28594598174095154,
0.21064631640911102,
0.7881625294685364,
-0.4939959645271301,
0.469891756772995,
-0.03342510759830475,
0.21949626505374908,
0.4453696608543396,
0.22324271500110626,
0.3902382254600525,
-0.02783174254000187,
-0.2989082634449005,
0.14206312596797943,
0.2798021733760834,
-0.6651220917701721,
-0.8479045033454895,
0.3920266926288605,
-0.6117784380912781,
-0.5418897867202759,
-0.3012729287147522,
-0.8113623857498169,
-0.40708380937576294,
-0.042626433074474335,
0.540719211101532,
0.22467733919620514,
-0.2720365822315216,
0.41966602206230164,
0.6652045845985413,
0.041661083698272705,
0.3445678949356079,
0.15581339597702026,
0.03869561851024628,
-0.08503749966621399,
0.9772648215293884,
0.16964076459407806,
0.5665407776832581,
0.20828711986541748,
0.6351944804191589,
-0.3437182903289795,
-0.48885732889175415,
-0.17789313197135925,
0.1974760740995407,
-0.7273382544517517,
-0.26800817251205444,
-0.6230378746986389,
-0.23134392499923706,
-0.3369256854057312,
-0.02810066007077694,
-0.4237610399723053,
-0.3599996864795685,
-0.1929788887500763,
0.06844257563352585,
0.26021334528923035,
0.5582754611968994,
-0.08460891991853714,
0.26269492506980896,
-0.7575216889381409,
0.22308902442455292,
0.38840535283088684,
0.2616932690143585,
-0.1401464343070984,
-1.0033313035964966,
0.08829936385154724,
0.3236754238605499,
-0.2872051000595093,
-0.8345673084259033,
0.1796669363975525,
0.4525689482688904,
0.6916341185569763,
0.24828146398067474,
-0.06854000687599182,
0.5115434527397156,
-0.3443903923034668,
0.8065213561058044,
0.24901270866394043,
-1.2156202793121338,
0.5955338478088379,
-0.2559434771537781,
0.49490833282470703,
0.7029253244400024,
0.29618632793426514,
-0.5409340858459473,
-0.9758625626564026,
-0.9764491319656372,
-0.41944077610969543,
0.34242570400238037,
0.29256194829940796,
0.3034009635448456,
-0.3283859193325043,
0.1937522441148758,
0.22516849637031555,
0.0172893013805151,
-0.5287946462631226,
0.13580486178398132,
-0.5151200294494629,
-0.5052611231803894,
-0.1085423156619072,
-0.17803941667079926,
-0.1951403021812439,
-0.38447046279907227,
0.4013077914714813,
0.09000129252672195,
-0.11731048673391342,
0.003551407251507044,
-0.2902364134788513,
0.21840104460716248,
0.2617846131324768,
0.7044535279273987,
1.204784870147705,
-0.16838900744915009,
0.3870719373226166,
0.29092878103256226,
-0.4333193004131317,
0.12903887033462524,
0.07099137455224991,
-0.007051961962133646,
0.5164651274681091,
0.3807501494884491,
0.6304144859313965,
0.5366082787513733,
-0.7738566398620605,
0.5206180214881897,
-0.06059107184410095,
-0.38043567538261414,
0.01627240516245365,
0.0941629558801651,
0.3147277534008026,
0.045096296817064285,
0.14622430503368378,
0.3225869834423065,
-0.08795396983623505,
-0.35054317116737366,
0.39087170362472534,
0.013355628587305546,
-0.15514223277568817,
-0.3291811943054199,
0.6550697088241577,
-0.24467064440250397,
-0.4785458743572235,
0.5730805993080139,
-0.1728079468011856,
-0.37126943469047546,
0.6427110433578491,
0.4664159417152405,
0.6334959864616394,
-0.4079018235206604,
0.38384634256362915,
0.34627246856689453,
0.28907081484794617,
-0.6558108329772949,
0.2392878383398056,
0.3167060613632202,
-0.6927887797355652,
0.007236313074827194,
-0.7679172158241272,
-0.5969153642654419,
-0.0201688501983881,
-0.6891749501228333,
0.3032141327857971,
-0.42762911319732666,
-0.0065513006411492825,
0.2761238217353821,
-0.3386676013469696,
-0.4600091278553009,
0.35039836168289185,
-0.07150766253471375,
0.6437196135520935,
-0.8840749263763428,
0.8273753523826599,
0.6104285717010498,
-0.484228253364563,
-0.9533818364143372,
0.22702275216579437,
-0.2212952822446823,
-0.5434750914573669,
0.45017150044441223,
0.08130393922328949,
0.04215485230088234,
-0.26675963401794434,
-0.2924259305000305,
-0.9404988288879395,
0.7560142874717712,
0.5352678298950195,
-0.5179951190948486,
-0.07800786197185516,
0.2695898115634918,
0.704426646232605,
-0.20422568917274475,
0.1385938823223114,
0.9460549354553223,
0.4501785635948181,
0.03787875920534134,
-1.1602747440338135,
-0.2091880589723587,
0.10888662189245224,
0.12271928042173386,
-0.05448239669203758,
-0.20643562078475952,
0.9250239133834839,
-0.08770899474620819,
0.020729217678308487,
0.252433717250824,
0.6509876251220703,
0.3530329763889313,
0.3787907361984253,
0.33742451667785645,
0.7500331401824951,
1.1041933298110962,
-0.29347991943359375,
0.9395264387130737,
0.004127762746065855,
0.48693111538887024,
1.4063537120819092,
-0.07376088201999664,
0.8979088068008423,
0.35526159405708313,
-0.31662681698799133,
0.3629409968852997,
0.27334484457969666,
0.02777848206460476,
0.4641784429550171,
0.22619716823101044,
-0.18281403183937073,
-0.33714529871940613,
0.05875780060887337,
-0.03593573346734047,
0.4356482923030853,
0.05319735035300255,
-0.3456677794456482,
-0.417528361082077,
0.060691796243190765,
0.02506573498249054,
0.6377735137939453,
-0.06760340183973312,
0.4268726706504822,
-0.07219977676868439,
-0.948286771774292,
0.9591233134269714,
-0.055845536291599274,
0.4361143112182617,
-0.307006299495697,
0.15716233849525452,
-0.5604252815246582,
0.19435255229473114,
-0.12512244284152985,
-0.8695628046989441,
0.825840175151825,
-0.014668288640677929,
-0.11571214348077774,
0.062234874814748764,
0.2747730314731598,
-0.41077956557273865,
-0.5612303614616394,
0.07108049094676971,
0.48906397819519043,
0.2375388741493225,
0.017804855480790138,
-0.6549618244171143,
-0.008670348674058914,
-0.03891340270638466,
0.10677873343229294,
0.21479029953479767,
0.6701828837394714,
0.12486441433429718,
0.6514418125152588,
0.11314530670642853,
-0.13148197531700134,
0.4878828823566437,
0.21588224172592163,
0.21122156083583832,
-0.4778357446193695,
-0.17847542464733124,
-1.0799329280853271,
0.3302633762359619,
-0.2824440002441406,
-0.7487403750419617,
1.0193731784820557,
0.40566638112068176,
0.5110440254211426,
0.1293051391839981,
0.5194178223609924,
0.1591324806213379,
0.6375035047531128,
-0.2197786569595337,
0.3333980143070221,
-0.2597346305847168,
0.12174917757511139,
-0.31555065512657166,
-0.9615893959999084,
-0.25147131085395813,
0.7995460033416748,
-0.3505735993385315,
-0.22825446724891663,
0.9536052346229553,
0.5416768789291382,
-0.28863009810447693,
0.2837510406970978,
0.44957196712493896,
-0.02023978903889656,
-0.08970038592815399,
0.4981823265552521,
0.8234947323799133,
-0.4921533763408661,
0.6403204798698425,
-0.21515734493732452,
0.027423901483416557,
0.0031101712957024574,
-0.729249119758606,
-0.42011430859565735,
-0.3381159007549286,
-0.6701505780220032,
-0.4269997179508209,
0.33038070797920227,
0.6785215139389038,
0.18007178604602814,
-0.7901481986045837,
-0.203410342335701,
-0.9086595773696899,
0.17571724951267242,
-0.5517257452011108,
-0.2379467636346817,
0.2434130758047104,
-0.7560392618179321,
-0.6759374737739563,
0.08110838383436203,
0.20246785879135132,
-0.11826413869857788,
-0.06499555706977844,
-0.10446713864803314,
-0.33585071563720703,
0.5491319298744202,
-0.10196728259325027,
0.30685192346572876,
-1.0165839195251465,
-0.4638988673686981,
0.057352710515260696,
-0.48826995491981506,
0.16407735645771027,
0.25877246260643005,
-0.2079601138830185,
0.34027016162872314,
0.521827220916748,
0.751484215259552,
-0.039138440042734146,
0.14330805838108063,
0.5387207269668579,
-0.7046236395835876,
-0.17127783596515656,
0.5008978843688965,
0.42459771037101746,
0.46602317690849304,
0.19674654304981232,
0.29015588760375977,
0.39759209752082825,
-0.8165786266326904,
-0.8337354063987732,
0.046897657215595245,
-0.5805553197860718,
-0.19143444299697876,
1.1940126419067383,
-0.6897696256637573,
0.040229227393865585,
-0.11918618530035019,
0.19418589770793915,
0.21424560248851776,
0.12981638312339783,
0.6585531234741211,
1.2766814231872559,
-0.15057171881198883,
-0.06116070598363876,
-0.7018849849700928,
0.5355764031410217,
0.8041886687278748,
-0.6270466446876526,
0.3364354968070984,
0.34705665707588196,
0.6357715129852295,
0.2514493763446808,
0.1937960535287857,
0.04950924217700958,
0.4301322400569916,
0.2345893383026123,
-0.32221606373786926,
0.48807159066200256,
-0.1775602251291275,
-0.18066513538360596,
-0.03764210268855095,
0.1867021918296814,
-0.061388056725263596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13087v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13087v1
|
Demystifying Legalese: An Automated Approach for Summarizing and Analyzing Overlaps in Privacy Policies and Terms of Service
| 2024-04-17T19:53:59 | 2024-04-17T19:53:59 |
Shikha Soneji, Mitchell Hoesing, Sujay Koujalgi, Jonathan Dodge
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The complexities of legalese in terms and policy documents can bind
individuals to contracts they do not fully comprehend, potentially leading to
uninformed data sharing. Our work seeks to alleviate this issue by developing
language models that provide automated, accessible summaries and scores for
such documents, aiming to enhance user understanding and facilitate informed
decisions. We compared transformer-based and conventional models during
training on our dataset, and RoBERTa performed better overall with a remarkable
0.74 F1-score. Leveraging our best-performing model, RoBERTa, we highlighted
redundancies and potential guideline violations by identifying overlaps in
GDPR-required documents, underscoring the necessity for stricter GDPR
compliance.
|
[
-0.6954570412635803,
-0.68510502576828,
0.602227509021759,
0.010239813476800919,
-0.3243032991886139,
0.04440068453550339,
0.267069935798645,
-0.6519845724105835,
0.03535623475909233,
0.7981109619140625,
-0.46958476305007935,
-0.684992253780365,
-0.8178104162216187,
0.05701414495706558,
-0.6670903563499451,
1.3379234075546265,
0.009383922442793846,
-0.2148238718509674,
-0.28238946199417114,
-0.03707689419388771,
-0.37385454773902893,
-0.2544395625591278,
-0.1931895613670349,
-0.4157847762107849,
0.26894786953926086,
0.17086391150951385,
0.90899658203125,
0.6569744944572449,
0.7774825692176819,
0.3764013350009918,
-0.3311253488063812,
0.05716969072818756,
-0.3540976643562317,
0.08086758106946945,
-0.23634985089302063,
-0.3283253312110901,
-0.5087569355964661,
-0.003804419655352831,
0.44574233889579773,
0.6763889789581299,
-0.33244287967681885,
0.05380074307322502,
-0.13312174379825592,
0.47223174571990967,
-0.39002373814582825,
0.1163228452205658,
-0.3211594223976135,
0.11252366751432419,
0.17829753458499908,
-0.08332405239343643,
-0.09498009085655212,
-0.47917455434799194,
0.3064080774784088,
-0.6307334899902344,
0.14043284952640533,
-0.035184551030397415,
1.2889761924743652,
0.511025071144104,
-0.5450247526168823,
-0.2123582512140274,
-0.6722906231880188,
0.604171633720398,
-0.5630480647087097,
0.27911797165870667,
0.5322955250740051,
0.399742066860199,
0.07049224525690079,
-0.7657308578491211,
-0.5312945246696472,
-0.047799549996852875,
-0.3942889869213104,
0.06922796368598938,
-0.686506986618042,
0.19593454897403717,
0.3914106488227844,
0.4993693232536316,
-0.6200077533721924,
0.26356539130210876,
-0.8424226641654968,
-0.005410282872617245,
0.9798939228057861,
0.44263312220573425,
0.3999866247177124,
-0.11565514653921127,
0.03879650682210922,
0.09353182464838028,
-0.31536462903022766,
0.11799263209104538,
0.8567703366279602,
0.04673903435468674,
-0.4075676500797272,
0.5293814539909363,
-0.15472321212291718,
0.7897099256515503,
0.16006091237068176,
-0.0039045263547450304,
0.26655760407447815,
-0.1874329149723053,
-0.4210489094257355,
0.023234963417053223,
0.8585793375968933,
0.4604485332965851,
0.2612403333187103,
-0.21816955506801605,
-0.06191939115524292,
-0.3474278151988983,
0.46004411578178406,
-0.6471723914146423,
-0.1140902191400528,
0.7201533913612366,
-0.5007595419883728,
-0.30998608469963074,
0.4835108816623688,
-0.716503918170929,
-0.4732075333595276,
-0.8182362914085388,
-0.0033803891856223345,
-0.2500266432762146,
-0.12919555604457855,
0.22313420474529266,
-0.4541090130805969,
0.15482519567012787,
0.309975266456604,
-0.8074110746383667,
0.5844242572784424,
0.9399556517601013,
0.6766961216926575,
0.004289398435503244,
-0.27363768219947815,
-0.04725653678178787,
0.143970787525177,
-0.11250808835029602,
0.4796716272830963,
-0.6296231150627136,
-0.7478124499320984,
-0.025576671585440636,
0.14866755902767181,
-0.016360068693757057,
-0.35616904497146606,
0.45091959834098816,
-0.5679864287376404,
0.6583051681518555,
0.005499694030731916,
-0.6980020403862,
-0.47972992062568665,
0.27868637442588806,
-1.0088815689086914,
0.6922546029090881,
0.27457550168037415,
-0.8987507224082947,
0.45915281772613525,
-0.8856161236763,
-0.573920726776123,
0.049121055752038956,
-0.19415952265262604,
-0.6620314717292786,
0.10422901809215546,
-0.059211503714323044,
0.21041196584701538,
-0.2442934811115265,
0.5983572006225586,
-0.15550412237644196,
-0.20073528587818146,
0.29686322808265686,
-0.22946509718894958,
1.0771044492721558,
0.3370550572872162,
-0.2723636031150818,
0.44657784700393677,
-0.812494158744812,
-0.16328924894332886,
-0.13797760009765625,
-0.2497061789035797,
-0.500393271446228,
-0.4625515043735504,
0.22068212926387787,
0.11080422252416611,
0.45835748314857483,
-0.0995062068104744,
-0.0002579960273578763,
-0.3098965585231781,
0.4604635536670685,
0.6097092032432556,
0.02568775974214077,
0.5498520731925964,
-0.531346321105957,
0.8146305680274963,
-0.02095644176006317,
0.43493789434432983,
-0.2911398112773895,
-0.5418552756309509,
-0.2745707929134369,
-0.20353035628795624,
0.41512230038642883,
0.6193060874938965,
0.07578533887863159,
0.7316955924034119,
-0.5443838238716125,
-0.46677708625793457,
-0.8511402010917664,
0.020663689821958542,
0.40917307138442993,
0.3160460293292999,
0.1348884552717209,
-0.14905349910259247,
-0.6352723240852356,
-0.9318146109580994,
-0.35807135701179504,
-0.008649506606161594,
-0.14954788982868195,
0.35747063159942627,
0.6642035245895386,
-0.38728487491607666,
1.2448536157608032,
-0.4338228702545166,
-0.24626842141151428,
-0.25922322273254395,
0.27139344811439514,
0.14556916058063507,
0.4276230037212372,
0.32086944580078125,
-1.336377501487732,
-0.4850459694862366,
0.1374940723180771,
-0.932658314704895,
-0.025705968961119652,
-0.02286779321730137,
0.3391883671283722,
0.13402660191059113,
0.36046352982521057,
-0.40833985805511475,
0.4484933316707611,
0.4411882758140564,
-0.6048998832702637,
0.47374221682548523,
-0.6827180981636047,
0.5026509761810303,
-1.0517951250076294,
0.09564430266618729,
0.022372763603925705,
-0.3946835696697235,
-0.9053166508674622,
0.13931804895401,
-0.12212394922971725,
-0.31163641810417175,
-0.423398494720459,
0.39272400736808777,
-0.2727680504322052,
-0.13631436228752136,
-0.016022000461816788,
0.08164123445749283,
0.1985042840242386,
0.05266569182276726,
-0.2617703378200531,
1.029189109802246,
0.4940401613712311,
-0.5108789801597595,
0.14501188695430756,
0.47252434492111206,
-0.11340745538473129,
0.5911093950271606,
-0.793624997138977,
-0.20054085552692413,
-0.320881724357605,
-0.07698559015989304,
-0.6856904029846191,
-0.5116885304450989,
0.03017650730907917,
-0.2256031185388565,
0.10086552053689957,
-0.32419130206108093,
-0.45012161135673523,
-0.21677540242671967,
-0.26553651690483093,
0.2723182737827301,
0.5897632837295532,
-0.26227179169654846,
1.1373296976089478,
1.038649320602417,
-0.12401818484067917,
-0.3233119249343872,
-0.7480534315109253,
0.30973830819129944,
-0.7969077229499817,
-0.6638131141662598,
0.48609426617622375,
0.23174358904361725,
-0.7032980918884277,
0.20749549567699432,
0.18001258373260498,
-0.5214005708694458,
0.06546760350465775,
0.6140391826629639,
0.06097373366355896,
0.19615712761878967,
-0.21091726422309875,
-0.053712960332632065,
-0.18639834225177765,
0.24867548048496246,
-0.08794988691806793,
0.4842560887336731,
-0.24623484909534454,
-0.34579211473464966,
-0.770482063293457,
0.45447006821632385,
0.7905217409133911,
-0.25135913491249084,
0.42543551325798035,
0.234749436378479,
-0.18802586197853088,
0.3093871772289276,
-0.3820689618587494,
0.08900011330842972,
-0.43538734316825867,
-0.09404890239238739,
-0.4765779972076416,
-0.8844271898269653,
0.9022101759910583,
0.14109046757221222,
0.1060500219464302,
0.3341687321662903,
0.12185525894165039,
-0.05449717491865158,
0.7984663844108582,
1.0888967514038086,
-0.2314879298210144,
0.5279185771942139,
-0.17123568058013916,
0.38719442486763,
-0.5118878483772278,
-0.47298797965049744,
-0.543538510799408,
0.11844388395547867,
-1.128163456916809,
-0.11729767918586731,
0.32066237926483154,
-0.12904246151447296,
-0.012031016871333122,
0.5640512108802795,
-0.208046093583107,
0.6958231329917908,
0.4980466961860657,
0.08728642761707306,
0.4190046489238739,
0.045801397413015366,
0.23505619168281555,
0.0953097715973854,
-0.390097051858902,
-0.7063814997673035,
1.185755968093872,
0.39922863245010376,
0.8142998218536377,
0.25551894307136536,
0.7907412648200989,
0.5719761252403259,
-0.28324082493782043,
-0.39370352029800415,
0.5166646838188171,
-0.35868433117866516,
-0.4616086483001709,
-0.5334191918373108,
-0.4383092224597931,
-1.1714835166931152,
0.2719360589981079,
0.048653122037649155,
-0.8169488310813904,
-0.04860522970557213,
0.027335114777088165,
-0.26968204975128174,
-0.03089955821633339,
-0.37560197710990906,
0.9634054899215698,
-0.09978882223367691,
-0.40921834111213684,
-0.426134318113327,
-0.6953177452087402,
0.53163081407547,
-0.1548042744398117,
0.47427263855934143,
-0.021055633202195168,
0.21764343976974487,
0.6855994462966919,
-0.4653064012527466,
0.7550420761108398,
0.07395967096090317,
-0.3294692039489746,
0.10798203945159912,
-0.0766778215765953,
0.23372341692447662,
-0.20333634316921234,
0.19239206612110138,
0.2524186968803406,
0.19872653484344482,
-0.1821780651807785,
-0.5829156041145325,
0.4652653634548187,
-0.5475330352783203,
-0.5659565329551697,
-0.30784791707992554,
-0.7610930800437927,
0.026775497943162918,
0.4681006371974945,
-0.07473507523536682,
0.1616171896457672,
-0.29854539036750793,
-0.06257622689008713,
1.0127108097076416,
-0.06409703195095062,
-0.0027475785464048386,
0.6720768213272095,
-0.20836018025875092,
-0.2074112594127655,
0.5660455822944641,
0.12102659046649933,
-0.048649862408638,
0.212770015001297,
0.17450065910816193,
-0.6196919679641724,
-0.29769444465637207,
-0.052470862865448,
0.2667669355869293,
-0.8492167592048645,
0.2788599729537964,
-0.9151997566223145,
-0.14372597634792328,
-0.5362188816070557,
-0.14037610590457916,
0.3045235276222229,
-0.5997108817100525,
-0.3318922817707062,
-0.17628060281276703,
0.35763832926750183,
0.9521892666816711,
-0.030135788023471832,
0.5141318440437317,
-0.7655296325683594,
0.4262676537036896,
-0.1425633728504181,
0.396904319524765,
-0.476847380399704,
-0.5247007608413696,
0.09642072021961212,
-0.1970328837633133,
-0.07563724368810654,
-0.7048923969268799,
0.10710842907428741,
-0.1653679758310318,
0.5898401737213135,
0.58665931224823,
-0.12852568924427032,
0.8572250604629517,
-0.4247477650642395,
0.7304068207740784,
0.20362283289432526,
-0.937609851360321,
0.5562225580215454,
-0.37279456853866577,
0.1800948679447174,
0.6206080317497253,
0.5514201521873474,
-0.4287244975566864,
-0.7657623887062073,
-0.943330705165863,
-0.9892064332962036,
0.3222580552101135,
0.0008080262341536582,
0.19025132060050964,
0.406878799200058,
0.0012699622893705964,
0.03829692676663399,
0.41704457998275757,
-0.37868615984916687,
0.008205808699131012,
0.20181681215763092,
-0.46951672434806824,
0.1464894860982895,
-0.13325558602809906,
-0.45903363823890686,
-0.0016039160545915365,
0.564005434513092,
0.2029600590467453,
-0.33186373114585876,
-0.18383577466011047,
-0.07694146782159805,
0.11872510612010956,
0.4348158836364746,
0.5824393033981323,
0.9747079610824585,
0.0396614708006382,
-0.0020725287031382322,
0.04582788795232773,
-0.37616899609565735,
-0.077748142182827,
0.40116918087005615,
-0.5072623491287231,
0.2567010819911957,
0.3154274821281433,
0.5167767405509949,
0.32519280910491943,
-0.8735204339027405,
0.480692982673645,
-0.27970343828201294,
-0.340197890996933,
-0.4222806692123413,
0.241508349776268,
-0.20325851440429688,
0.13989005982875824,
-0.05947244539856911,
-0.29769811034202576,
0.516517162322998,
-0.3617296814918518,
0.5406883955001831,
0.41069117188453674,
-0.26614052057266235,
-0.015259981155395508,
0.7424842715263367,
-0.07057544589042664,
-0.2702897787094116,
0.3306851089000702,
0.07417813688516617,
-0.32258984446525574,
0.6131448149681091,
0.1213141456246376,
0.7672253251075745,
-0.12230980396270752,
0.17964129149913788,
0.023029109463095665,
0.24147458374500275,
-0.17060543596744537,
0.5178390145301819,
-0.09236208349466324,
-0.18211303651332855,
-0.12339671701192856,
-0.347647488117218,
-0.38004177808761597,
-0.002095626899972558,
-1.0395251512527466,
0.26184478402137756,
-0.39915961027145386,
-0.24200119078159332,
0.2807501256465912,
-0.13354173302650452,
-0.6834937334060669,
0.12271647900342941,
-0.48475366830825806,
0.9642270803451538,
-1.052911400794983,
0.41346511244773865,
0.4627392292022705,
-0.9762322902679443,
-0.6675570011138916,
-0.015647396445274353,
0.21714623272418976,
-0.45755383372306824,
0.5073754787445068,
0.0704023689031601,
-0.11684325337409973,
-0.23918476700782776,
-0.048471011221408844,
-0.46995630860328674,
1.0590718984603882,
0.025678815320134163,
-0.7209774851799011,
-0.212174654006958,
0.5995258688926697,
0.6466706991195679,
-0.24831926822662354,
0.12694403529167175,
0.9343158602714539,
0.6922738552093506,
-0.16427753865718842,
-0.9963418245315552,
0.045613616704940796,
0.011681435629725456,
-0.13929878175258636,
0.19780991971492767,
-0.176441952586174,
0.6688047647476196,
-0.10663547366857529,
-0.3029431998729706,
0.02734653651714325,
0.23290248215198517,
-0.14782775938510895,
0.5060112476348877,
0.2834668457508087,
0.726115882396698,
1.1171787977218628,
-0.16161340475082397,
1.1239683628082275,
-0.5649727582931519,
0.2517213225364685,
1.3204383850097656,
-0.20007839798927307,
0.38160181045532227,
0.46640655398368835,
-0.23368069529533386,
0.40661072731018066,
0.5152092576026917,
-0.3805311620235443,
0.35260412096977234,
0.11530380696058273,
-0.1435798555612564,
0.06954333931207657,
-0.26069122552871704,
-0.14173389971256256,
0.44549623131752014,
0.0034890060778707266,
-0.4558296501636505,
-0.551511824131012,
-0.009983578696846962,
0.06573904305696487,
0.49163293838500977,
-0.21120071411132812,
1.2551790475845337,
-0.15629512071609497,
-0.7037458419799805,
0.23332172632217407,
0.012615010142326355,
0.2932705283164978,
-0.49660739302635193,
0.007632111199200153,
-0.15912741422653198,
-0.075065478682518,
-0.39092400670051575,
-1.165715217590332,
0.6177680492401123,
0.3866090178489685,
-0.33887630701065063,
-0.31918901205062866,
0.30440640449523926,
-0.5351368188858032,
-0.3770769238471985,
0.15290741622447968,
0.26510506868362427,
0.4845075011253357,
0.2582750916481018,
-1.020559549331665,
0.19597753882408142,
-0.165387362241745,
0.063741534948349,
0.18698611855506897,
0.49888214468955994,
-0.2495926320552826,
0.7269458174705505,
0.7091658711433411,
0.01957707852125168,
0.017399858683347702,
0.5301204919815063,
0.7842516899108887,
-0.5271635055541992,
-1.1625726222991943,
-0.8880981802940369,
0.7807431817054749,
-0.4382637143135071,
-0.2188624143600464,
0.821052610874176,
0.8589258193969727,
0.808483898639679,
0.1513858288526535,
1.018656611442566,
-0.026608381420373917,
0.3708679676055908,
-0.6305715441703796,
0.8342062830924988,
-0.4693942368030548,
0.46326592564582825,
0.07851255685091019,
-0.3549725115299225,
-0.4439707398414612,
0.5247688293457031,
-0.5063608884811401,
-0.05196766555309296,
0.26682737469673157,
0.8548508286476135,
-0.29380229115486145,
0.04770568013191223,
0.3052467405796051,
-0.17704829573631287,
0.6371744871139526,
0.11353646963834763,
0.5806373357772827,
-0.413864403963089,
0.436145156621933,
0.01685386523604393,
-0.04325476288795471,
-0.3042082190513611,
-0.80989009141922,
-0.8770846128463745,
-0.6737470626831055,
-0.27235084772109985,
-0.3186536431312561,
0.23600712418556213,
0.52414470911026,
0.7508970499038696,
-0.7021325826644897,
-0.2475331872701645,
-0.3858938217163086,
0.29880842566490173,
-0.12238308042287827,
-0.2638300657272339,
0.1020960807800293,
-0.39342689514160156,
-0.7961409091949463,
0.0017126258462667465,
0.2598108649253845,
0.49001190066337585,
-0.4354509711265564,
-0.11238773912191391,
0.08417288213968277,
0.08711813390254974,
0.12581206858158112,
0.15694454312324524,
-0.9248888492584229,
0.22277578711509705,
-0.5046424269676208,
-0.10177742689847946,
-0.07134969532489777,
0.9992326498031616,
-0.2584497034549713,
0.36099931597709656,
0.3870227336883545,
0.6191478967666626,
0.3373493552207947,
0.5164292454719543,
0.5776304006576538,
-0.23959191143512726,
0.04896632209420204,
0.068971648812294,
0.4102053642272949,
0.27738672494888306,
-0.5174452066421509,
0.3962026834487915,
-0.48523059487342834,
-0.3531658947467804,
-0.8370456099510193,
0.5174760818481445,
-0.8640568852424622,
-0.6035643219947815,
0.9036492705345154,
-0.2422843724489212,
-0.36403030157089233,
-0.4306836724281311,
-0.0005527951871044934,
-0.07212354242801666,
-0.30517297983169556,
1.2442495822906494,
0.46825551986694336,
0.18154625594615936,
-0.07720070332288742,
-0.6167646646499634,
0.5651208758354187,
-0.13062237203121185,
-1.091317892074585,
0.3383628726005554,
0.6290464401245117,
0.5479156374931335,
0.2144974172115326,
0.4316108822822571,
-0.25558313727378845,
0.27733537554740906,
-0.07953425496816635,
-0.3473604917526245,
-0.39232343435287476,
-0.526838481426239,
-0.8966968059539795,
0.24919112026691437,
-0.20077690482139587,
0.017414845526218414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11691v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11691v1
|
Improvement in Semantic Address Matching using Natural Language Processing
| 2024-04-17T18:42:36 | 2024-04-17T18:42:36 |
Vansh Gupta, Mohit Gupta, Jai Garg, Nitesh Garg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Address matching is an important task for many businesses especially delivery
and take out companies which help them to take out a certain address from their
data warehouse. Existing solution uses similarity of strings, and edit distance
algorithms to find out the similar addresses from the address database, but
these algorithms could not work effectively with redundant, unstructured, or
incomplete address data. This paper discuss semantic Address matching
technique, by which we can find out a particular address from a list of
possible addresses. We have also reviewed existing practices and their
shortcoming. Semantic address matching is an essentially NLP task in the field
of deep learning. Through this technique We have the ability to triumph the
drawbacks of existing methods like redundant or abbreviated data problems. The
solution uses the OCR on invoices to extract the address and create the data
pool of addresses. Then this data is fed to the algorithm BM-25 for scoring the
best matching entries. Then to observe the best result, this will pass through
BERT for giving the best possible result from the similar queries. Our
investigation exhibits that our methodology enormously improves both accuracy
and review of cutting-edge technology existing techniques.
|
[
-0.4421567916870117,
-0.5865873694419861,
0.398580402135849,
-0.15682943165302277,
-0.13663142919540405,
-0.022687571123242378,
0.013626685366034508,
-1.3057177066802979,
0.08814821392297745,
0.9042664170265198,
-0.5831552147865295,
-0.49514979124069214,
-0.29424068331718445,
0.23770081996917725,
-0.14389775693416595,
0.6297356486320496,
0.16341613233089447,
-0.07824549078941345,
-0.20711176097393036,
-0.4101984202861786,
-0.8140832185745239,
-0.3016091585159302,
-0.4720427691936493,
-0.25583329796791077,
-0.1054660826921463,
0.484063059091568,
0.6315997838973999,
0.5961462259292603,
0.8518515825271606,
0.43039748072624207,
-0.11218846589326859,
0.6215723156929016,
-0.08701563626527786,
0.21654443442821503,
-0.4731642007827759,
-0.12938860058784485,
-0.18691731989383698,
-0.4455980360507965,
0.6912937164306641,
0.8896728157997131,
0.009681555442512035,
0.04140781611204147,
-0.17315888404846191,
1.1085387468338013,
-0.5904750823974609,
-0.13840068876743317,
-0.8813464641571045,
0.11264011263847351,
-0.35583990812301636,
-0.2266480177640915,
-0.2101585865020752,
-0.6484218239784241,
0.33695054054260254,
-0.19893652200698853,
0.4409814774990082,
0.34978049993515015,
0.9753676056861877,
0.05485573410987854,
-0.16560663282871246,
-0.7669246196746826,
-0.9426897168159485,
0.35829728841781616,
-0.691109836101532,
0.23393772542476654,
0.22268909215927124,
0.5439139604568481,
-0.6443849802017212,
-0.47807738184928894,
-0.5385515689849854,
-0.014534984715282917,
-0.12382087111473083,
-0.059943798929452896,
-0.12266141921281815,
0.04145273193717003,
0.47491204738616943,
0.6223238110542297,
-0.4209330081939697,
0.22878634929656982,
-0.37984132766723633,
-0.08750541508197784,
0.32025718688964844,
0.27063417434692383,
0.2875060737133026,
0.10753923654556274,
-0.5462620258331299,
-0.06029822304844856,
-0.38137540221214294,
0.004508940037339926,
0.573769748210907,
0.269838809967041,
0.47933822870254517,
0.629611074924469,
-0.6864229440689087,
0.9046368598937988,
-0.02797849103808403,
0.18792276084423065,
0.36146414279937744,
-0.2595307528972626,
-0.3517988324165344,
0.5848315358161926,
0.4851270914077759,
0.30046534538269043,
0.20683355629444122,
-0.24780574440956116,
-0.15016812086105347,
0.09007584303617477,
0.34638577699661255,
-0.4112425148487091,
-0.08813955634832382,
0.19055332243442535,
-0.4919995963573456,
0.074610136449337,
0.22083592414855957,
-0.7765032649040222,
-0.356844961643219,
-0.27310505509376526,
0.03126591816544533,
-0.5713375806808472,
0.2576965391635895,
0.23493432998657227,
-0.0746883749961853,
0.5370601415634155,
0.5676515102386475,
-1.022599458694458,
0.545008659362793,
1.1019315719604492,
0.53273606300354,
0.1424475908279419,
-0.04321585223078728,
-0.5795209407806396,
0.22238291800022125,
-0.09284978359937668,
1.0009846687316895,
-0.5715665221214294,
0.0708967000246048,
0.06526961177587509,
-0.43898820877075195,
0.15976175665855408,
-1.116978406906128,
0.588114321231842,
-0.7606115937232971,
0.013489756733179092,
0.0612160861492157,
-0.982103705406189,
-0.04604372754693031,
0.4559493660926819,
-0.7948537468910217,
0.9885326027870178,
0.10301818698644638,
-0.787837564945221,
0.296312153339386,
-0.789120078086853,
-0.42986825108528137,
0.38201454281806946,
0.45272770524024963,
-0.446140319108963,
0.27000799775123596,
0.33728522062301636,
0.115858294069767,
-0.20126283168792725,
-0.1839531809091568,
-0.2629604637622833,
-0.31381282210350037,
-0.018779907375574112,
0.0058172764256596565,
0.7287279963493347,
0.3773317039012909,
-0.15122035145759583,
-0.19450291991233826,
-1.0202569961547852,
0.0852431058883667,
0.07590209692716599,
-0.09869690984487534,
-0.5776987671852112,
-0.15788865089416504,
-0.13732610642910004,
0.24013938009738922,
0.5250124931335449,
-0.7778947353363037,
0.042405325919389725,
-0.8751453757286072,
0.03489595279097557,
0.45648378133773804,
-0.07604768127202988,
0.5691261291503906,
-0.4330731928348541,
0.1203019991517067,
-0.00296717113815248,
0.04256966710090637,
-0.09205327928066254,
-0.6514477729797363,
-0.5529350638389587,
-0.07252690941095352,
0.4152872562408447,
0.8220993876457214,
-0.3870118260383606,
0.43513044714927673,
-0.4353772699832916,
-0.6030440926551819,
-1.0024404525756836,
0.1810799390077591,
0.1835123896598816,
0.7096433639526367,
0.25673067569732666,
-0.6068857908248901,
-0.6324231624603271,
-0.7987241148948669,
-0.5166957974433899,
0.17473556101322174,
-0.16409964859485626,
0.34318000078201294,
0.06880444288253784,
-0.3695676922798157,
1.0537031888961792,
-0.6481209397315979,
-0.5860158801078796,
0.06902588158845901,
-0.19422532618045807,
0.47228342294692993,
0.4372660219669342,
0.3588583171367645,
-0.8024140000343323,
-0.5355507731437683,
0.15109804272651672,
-0.45550107955932617,
-0.023921914398670197,
0.21901963651180267,
-0.2291831523180008,
0.5525105595588684,
0.04196581989526749,
-0.6080105304718018,
0.43227723240852356,
0.10477260500192642,
-0.30434128642082214,
0.1660398691892624,
-0.7113564610481262,
0.10530702024698257,
-0.942150890827179,
-0.0773056149482727,
-0.05529835820198059,
-0.3420560956001282,
-0.6490235328674316,
-0.06481175869703293,
0.008414098992943764,
-0.31733283400535583,
-0.3993723690509796,
0.3257558345794678,
-0.4191787540912628,
-0.5581074953079224,
-0.2876482903957367,
0.28630200028419495,
-0.01596386544406414,
0.27172499895095825,
0.1070016399025917,
0.28287118673324585,
0.22135956585407257,
-0.44727104902267456,
0.8195705413818359,
0.4476362466812134,
-0.6602330207824707,
0.9706412553787231,
-0.06708284467458725,
0.4065450131893158,
-0.2817287743091583,
0.09804990142583847,
-1.257656216621399,
0.30490347743034363,
0.39938950538635254,
-0.39626792073249817,
0.10506846755743027,
-0.01085748616605997,
-1.0056238174438477,
-0.35076403617858887,
-0.11541967839002609,
0.15580876171588898,
0.505805253982544,
-0.879529595375061,
0.4036831855773926,
0.13016021251678467,
-0.1472783386707306,
-0.3850075304508209,
-0.5116337537765503,
0.19270780682563782,
-0.11145384609699249,
-0.6783323884010315,
0.47934234142303467,
0.18090039491653442,
-0.16005080938339233,
0.16609802842140198,
-0.06800369918346405,
-0.3990963101387024,
0.05449792370200157,
-0.16429391503334045,
0.2539949417114258,
-0.16658416390419006,
-0.01301587000489235,
-0.27750954031944275,
-0.2997059226036072,
0.010164628736674786,
-0.5022444725036621,
0.16226714849472046,
0.119004987180233,
-0.20235559344291687,
-0.5924938917160034,
0.619637668132782,
0.3989350497722626,
-0.43971312046051025,
0.6701432466506958,
0.25599339604377747,
-0.6538135409355164,
-0.02170625329017639,
-0.8346636891365051,
0.12363272905349731,
-0.47137150168418884,
0.05824054405093193,
-0.24151669442653656,
-0.4381151497364044,
0.46756166219711304,
-0.3301006555557251,
-0.12549534440040588,
0.3009122610092163,
0.17677372694015503,
-0.2122049629688263,
0.37808096408843994,
0.6525988578796387,
-0.24274173378944397,
0.4171658158302307,
0.08938752859830856,
0.6474447250366211,
-0.5434372425079346,
-0.4216320216655731,
-0.8952375054359436,
-0.24579842388629913,
-0.7347586750984192,
-0.18525296449661255,
-0.07703208178281784,
-0.319987028837204,
0.2789849638938904,
0.6052825450897217,
-0.7288542985916138,
0.41281434893608093,
0.7650949954986572,
0.03748169541358948,
0.2610853910446167,
-0.004539909772574902,
-0.17188552021980286,
0.0005812578019686043,
-0.40543437004089355,
-0.21668559312820435,
0.43034976720809937,
0.17094223201274872,
0.478864461183548,
0.13476456701755524,
0.6971103549003601,
0.3278583288192749,
-0.19603517651557922,
-0.4753284752368927,
0.5392224192619324,
-0.24015946686267853,
-0.2533409595489502,
-0.46642082929611206,
-0.47836947441101074,
-1.1670645475387573,
0.003041921416297555,
-0.3031468391418457,
-0.7190378308296204,
0.10038024187088013,
0.05804591253399849,
-0.02149946056306362,
0.44169101119041443,
-0.5361469984054565,
0.7792516946792603,
-0.1149863451719284,
-0.1070157140493393,
0.07868710160255432,
-0.8665292859077454,
-0.13108223676681519,
0.04678843170404434,
0.08286703377962112,
-0.05759972706437111,
0.4259364902973175,
0.47206762433052063,
-0.8086397647857666,
0.31026846170425415,
-0.20015783607959747,
-0.17916832864284515,
0.16003791987895966,
-0.22193047404289246,
0.7485529184341431,
-0.3886745274066925,
-0.30141884088516235,
0.17745637893676758,
-0.2130896896123886,
-0.4382570683956146,
-0.7055326104164124,
0.6570278406143188,
-0.1716940701007843,
-0.014105670154094696,
-0.23962828516960144,
-0.7238386869430542,
-0.18633443117141724,
0.26816633343696594,
0.08611666411161423,
0.2978557050228119,
-0.011961828917264938,
-0.07549596577882767,
0.6743360161781311,
0.10544247925281525,
0.445850133895874,
0.44468775391578674,
0.5343517661094666,
-0.27629587054252625,
0.5547090172767639,
0.035539720207452774,
0.004836612846702337,
0.9394020438194275,
0.1407993882894516,
-0.7545920610427856,
-0.3977603018283844,
-0.3068215548992157,
0.027760658413171768,
-0.7620822787284851,
-0.44812604784965515,
-0.4756794571876526,
-0.061752788722515106,
-0.39691853523254395,
-0.2676542103290558,
-0.37308940291404724,
-0.12059248983860016,
0.02705470100045204,
0.3878815472126007,
0.3931802809238434,
0.6930909752845764,
0.3058498501777649,
-0.13246120512485504,
-0.9491119980812073,
0.3891996145248413,
0.17330345511436462,
0.6005724668502808,
-0.029869411140680313,
0.04059490188956261,
-0.18477840721607208,
0.08208392560482025,
-0.16087567806243896,
-0.7474114298820496,
0.29698634147644043,
0.05964187905192375,
0.4810561537742615,
0.20251420140266418,
0.3924418091773987,
0.9385179281234741,
-0.739010214805603,
0.22481611371040344,
-0.13710524141788483,
-0.8886634707450867,
0.685124397277832,
0.14556090533733368,
0.39605090022087097,
0.7583764791488647,
0.12733225524425507,
-0.3225509524345398,
-0.2565729022026062,
-0.7436193227767944,
-0.9630759954452515,
0.5710075497627258,
0.351632297039032,
-0.12740349769592285,
0.016123276203870773,
0.5081839561462402,
0.044539857655763626,
0.1271728277206421,
0.0034876989666372538,
-0.3643938899040222,
0.41747209429740906,
-0.2826234698295593,
0.0803319588303566,
-0.2574760913848877,
0.5244107246398926,
0.06838628649711609,
0.43067166209220886,
0.25070491433143616,
0.5102697610855103,
0.1020640879869461,
0.1026986837387085,
0.013016819022595882,
0.32577967643737793,
0.4879581928253174,
0.5880466103553772,
-0.43150386214256287,
-0.12981678545475006,
0.44510290026664734,
-0.43177688121795654,
-0.11098429560661316,
0.234147310256958,
0.0009787514572963119,
0.5289151668548584,
0.05734513700008392,
0.6254321932792664,
-0.14120762050151825,
-0.7311616539955139,
0.5413976907730103,
0.06982742249965668,
0.004431682173162699,
-0.5414965152740479,
-0.09380165487527847,
-0.22165079414844513,
0.2255491316318512,
0.19374075531959534,
0.24618373811244965,
0.5131532549858093,
-0.5894046425819397,
0.21787409484386444,
0.6329839825630188,
-0.46317964792251587,
0.42857035994529724,
0.34667325019836426,
0.015296919271349907,
-0.9261336922645569,
1.0944730043411255,
-0.054706379771232605,
-0.4788562059402466,
0.7134415507316589,
0.724415123462677,
0.8512377738952637,
-0.20015521347522736,
-0.24390582740306854,
0.022624840959906578,
0.15043000876903534,
0.012625948525965214,
0.2029021829366684,
-0.31935355067253113,
-0.6343111991882324,
-0.3620074391365051,
-0.22793714702129364,
-0.7693599462509155,
-0.17135614156723022,
-0.7134801745414734,
0.4589412808418274,
-0.33520373702049255,
0.42087024450302124,
0.051723845303058624,
0.21760068833827972,
-0.7773715853691101,
0.3259095847606659,
0.22896622121334076,
1.0773082971572876,
-0.6695060729980469,
0.8169782757759094,
0.7994829416275024,
0.2599034011363983,
-0.40375208854675293,
-0.1925722062587738,
-0.40249723196029663,
-0.43469369411468506,
0.838373064994812,
0.24848605692386627,
-0.20124126970767975,
-0.28192129731178284,
0.05952274054288864,
-0.5015276074409485,
0.7264732122421265,
0.2204151600599289,
-0.5104402303695679,
0.18694783747196198,
0.42510896921157837,
0.6751846671104431,
-0.27894827723503113,
0.11404943466186523,
0.5351386666297913,
0.23526902496814728,
0.4322679340839386,
-0.815218985080719,
0.06225430965423584,
-0.15450967848300934,
0.20019233226776123,
0.7157644629478455,
-0.1121615469455719,
0.3043667674064636,
-0.06273381412029266,
0.23250128328800201,
0.2175045609474182,
0.6674847602844238,
0.06575477123260498,
0.5570273399353027,
0.4009181261062622,
0.8410004377365112,
0.8787296414375305,
0.10651891678571701,
0.7471708655357361,
0.0223260335624218,
0.5633686184883118,
1.1066585779190063,
-0.7883826494216919,
0.9436066150665283,
0.49285954236984253,
-0.1467263400554657,
0.3215121328830719,
0.19268426299095154,
-0.23757727444171906,
0.7088766694068909,
0.627846896648407,
-0.1080608144402504,
0.2362849861383438,
-0.09050227701663971,
-0.13744157552719116,
0.4834253191947937,
0.18670429289340973,
-0.19567908346652985,
-0.514966607093811,
0.01762467436492443,
-0.22280986607074738,
0.35975706577301025,
-0.18746335804462433,
1.1565263271331787,
-0.32949066162109375,
-0.43498122692108154,
0.39137402176856995,
0.050874993205070496,
0.4556397497653961,
-0.4957422912120819,
-0.45316216349601746,
-0.0931454747915268,
0.3529789447784424,
0.05239527300000191,
-0.667426586151123,
0.6351581811904907,
-0.0967002660036087,
-0.3034350574016571,
-0.31666094064712524,
0.896251380443573,
-0.3643757998943329,
-0.22060370445251465,
0.19122391939163208,
-0.1815119832754135,
0.26128968596458435,
-0.18336836993694305,
-0.6206676959991455,
-0.2275761365890503,
-0.33817028999328613,
0.45883727073669434,
0.36169418692588806,
0.9251418709754944,
0.17120005190372467,
0.4698197841644287,
0.6053208708763123,
0.06120995059609413,
-0.036648884415626526,
-0.24174930155277252,
0.5436079502105713,
-0.7243790030479431,
-0.7068299055099487,
-0.8833021521568298,
0.12294147908687592,
-0.38592642545700073,
-0.15085448324680328,
0.5595389008522034,
0.8098839521408081,
1.1116154193878174,
-0.3566683828830719,
0.24729031324386597,
0.2447551041841507,
0.7354196906089783,
-0.7008082866668701,
0.34368595480918884,
-0.1080932766199112,
0.5381422638893127,
-0.6716527938842773,
-1.233437418937683,
-0.539787769317627,
0.6178012490272522,
-0.2669696509838104,
-0.23696507513523102,
0.6198904514312744,
0.6141401529312134,
0.03125831484794617,
-0.01315264217555523,
0.2657654285430908,
-0.29458314180374146,
-0.025757960975170135,
0.9372746348381042,
0.6812396049499512,
-0.747839093208313,
0.42616987228393555,
-0.5346003770828247,
0.023919833824038506,
-0.640264630317688,
-0.9889423847198486,
-0.6324129104614258,
-0.45922014117240906,
-0.5134738683700562,
-0.41266700625419617,
0.10336731374263763,
0.906945526599884,
0.42998865246772766,
-0.7730424404144287,
-0.03319289907813072,
-0.06252944469451904,
0.26430606842041016,
-0.5597167611122131,
-0.14811794459819794,
0.5611583590507507,
-0.3291011154651642,
-0.8139963746070862,
0.03921106457710266,
0.6109927892684937,
0.07029569149017334,
0.37960538268089294,
0.3008493483066559,
-0.3770325183868408,
-0.10611028969287872,
0.45292583107948303,
0.2781865894794464,
-0.48376670479774475,
-0.31945812702178955,
-0.12452727556228638,
-0.22717225551605225,
0.2670622766017914,
0.6307142376899719,
-0.7662058472633362,
0.5346588492393494,
0.742658793926239,
1.0525890588760376,
0.10564161092042923,
0.28350257873535156,
0.2353629767894745,
-0.6937798261642456,
0.08777877688407898,
0.3186681866645813,
0.358055055141449,
0.48448270559310913,
-0.7538423538208008,
0.471606969833374,
-0.030102277174592018,
-0.4193788766860962,
-0.4927286207675934,
0.24785877764225006,
-1.206249713897705,
-0.08536811918020248,
0.6430127024650574,
-0.044920917600393295,
-0.39817699790000916,
-0.4769997298717499,
-0.4947647154331207,
0.040955621749162674,
-0.1611267328262329,
0.6957704424858093,
0.48902586102485657,
-0.11361381411552429,
-0.06735431402921677,
-0.42495349049568176,
0.21102885901927948,
0.3281063437461853,
-0.8191770315170288,
-0.2317117154598236,
0.245074063539505,
0.14737191796302795,
0.26378870010375977,
0.5004234313964844,
-0.054572902619838715,
0.2754520773887634,
-0.2609284222126007,
-0.0027122017927467823,
-0.09577865153551102,
-0.005497353617101908,
-0.24925608932971954,
0.25532591342926025,
0.06695190817117691,
-0.8003922700881958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11682v1
|
How Well Can You Articulate that Idea? Insights from Automated Formative Assessment
| 2024-04-17T18:27:59 | 2024-04-17T18:27:59 |
Mahsa Sheikhi Karizaki, Dana Gnesdilow, Sadhana Puntambekar, Rebecca J. Passonneau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automated methods are becoming increasingly integrated into studies of
formative feedback on students' science explanation writing. Most of this work,
however, addresses students' responses to short answer questions. We
investigate automated feedback on students' science explanation essays, where
students must articulate multiple ideas. Feedback is based on a rubric that
identifies the main ideas students are prompted to include in explanatory
essays about the physics of energy and mass, given their experiments with a
simulated roller coaster. We have found that students generally improve on
revised versions of their essays. Here, however, we focus on two factors that
affect the accuracy of the automated feedback. First, we find that the main
ideas in the rubric differ with respect to how much freedom they afford in
explanations of the idea, thus explanation of a natural law is relatively
constrained. Students have more freedom in how they explain complex relations
they observe in their roller coasters, such as transfer of different forms of
energy. Second, by tracing the automated decision process, we can diagnose when
a student's statement lacks sufficient clarity for the automated tool to
associate it more strongly with one of the main ideas above all others. This in
turn provides an opportunity for teachers and peers to help students reflect on
how to state their ideas more clearly.
|
[
-0.40268728137016296,
-0.7198260426521301,
0.9053489565849304,
0.3023315668106079,
-0.2779754102230072,
0.42847245931625366,
-0.2853381335735321,
-0.4299933612346649,
0.37206098437309265,
0.03630661219358444,
-0.24439574778079987,
-0.12235275655984879,
-0.4120381474494934,
0.35384660959243774,
-0.4831511080265045,
1.0437917709350586,
-0.706300675868988,
0.029870731756091118,
-0.5607231855392456,
0.0844094455242157,
-0.4695192575454712,
-0.011008613742887974,
-0.40812501311302185,
-0.22207021713256836,
0.6027802228927612,
0.5159990191459656,
0.5396292209625244,
0.9755404591560364,
0.7512822151184082,
0.3951256573200226,
0.02445877343416214,
-0.2206231951713562,
0.09857820719480515,
-0.04784822463989258,
-0.09212551265954971,
-0.5341872572898865,
-0.3592066764831543,
0.33292314410209656,
0.6638270020484924,
1.1009951829910278,
-0.10337928682565689,
0.21133360266685486,
0.16087625920772552,
0.5047619342803955,
-0.6876168251037598,
0.20375558733940125,
-0.30493995547294617,
0.17719420790672302,
0.19401493668556213,
-0.09808621555566788,
-0.3741808831691742,
-0.41996732354164124,
0.1131836399435997,
-0.9175933003425598,
0.23117445409297943,
0.1561269462108612,
0.8862867951393127,
0.3334779739379883,
-0.4066888391971588,
-0.5340355634689331,
-0.8615103960037231,
0.5411983728408813,
-0.3095976412296295,
-0.1921984702348709,
0.09729573130607605,
0.4166238605976105,
-0.17500118911266327,
-0.7098482251167297,
-0.8814021944999695,
-0.25113171339035034,
-0.3296205997467041,
0.41193658113479614,
0.17500269412994385,
0.21826565265655518,
0.5017632842063904,
0.24765190482139587,
-0.4802522659301758,
0.049176059663295746,
-0.6133557558059692,
-0.26261234283447266,
0.8508888483047485,
0.18442592024803162,
0.04462776705622673,
-0.2449236810207367,
-0.08023849129676819,
-0.3567376434803009,
0.053546782582998276,
0.5742753744125366,
0.5799285173416138,
0.20051530003547668,
0.10579828172922134,
0.7561536431312561,
-0.04930851608514786,
0.3459714651107788,
0.2945350110530853,
0.04292086884379387,
0.2418774962425232,
-0.4094148278236389,
0.05360560864210129,
0.03784879669547081,
0.6900537610054016,
0.4495701789855957,
-0.11518707126379013,
-0.14171402156352997,
-0.23375637829303741,
0.2146752029657364,
0.09197258949279785,
-0.81805819272995,
-0.25734809041023254,
0.34544968605041504,
-0.3761467933654785,
0.06151454895734787,
0.456096351146698,
-0.7016869783401489,
-0.35792869329452515,
-0.6439411044120789,
0.7161144614219666,
-0.026220545172691345,
0.07944341748952866,
0.07315801084041595,
-0.5379917025566101,
-0.248859703540802,
0.6254029870033264,
-0.6948206424713135,
0.40004968643188477,
0.559038519859314,
0.607596755027771,
-0.09665713459253311,
-0.2866643965244293,
-0.32259657979011536,
0.046848803758621216,
-0.30395758152008057,
1.2981442213058472,
-0.6358028650283813,
-0.49420663714408875,
-0.43575021624565125,
0.28868016600608826,
-0.23651765286922455,
-0.32949376106262207,
0.23234659433364868,
-0.21740840375423431,
0.7587447762489319,
-0.248639315366745,
-0.6806658506393433,
-0.2596348226070404,
-0.25484105944633484,
-0.5478251576423645,
0.49545249342918396,
-0.34539300203323364,
-0.6477994918823242,
0.7104220986366272,
-1.0454577207565308,
-0.5055923461914062,
-0.0544191375374794,
-0.26128509640693665,
-0.21547558903694153,
0.31852665543556213,
-0.07376822084188461,
-0.00333848362788558,
0.21072152256965637,
0.1634121686220169,
-0.13789643347263336,
-0.30006709694862366,
0.5462389588356018,
-0.20416970551013947,
0.4779540002346039,
0.24605624377727509,
-0.4752845764160156,
0.06457435339689255,
-0.7562165260314941,
0.34042659401893616,
-0.18640722334384918,
-0.16530853509902954,
-0.17380376160144806,
-0.0825442224740982,
-0.18090549111366272,
-0.04512988403439522,
0.20068393647670746,
-0.5944533944129944,
0.40990695357322693,
-0.3535551428794861,
0.1256590485572815,
0.6191027760505676,
0.28068476915359497,
0.5763715505599976,
-0.45766481757164,
0.6734846830368042,
-0.12349452078342438,
0.04250995069742203,
-0.22107400000095367,
-0.2611164450645447,
-0.5657948851585388,
-0.04733223095536232,
0.15400095283985138,
0.30828726291656494,
-0.29258501529693604,
0.14846056699752808,
0.047440242022275925,
-0.5446915030479431,
-0.5923686623573303,
0.1808778941631317,
0.24902212619781494,
0.36939746141433716,
0.2471492886543274,
-0.3267208933830261,
-0.4845825731754303,
-0.7793632745742798,
-0.6178926229476929,
-0.41715139150619507,
-0.33067214488983154,
0.16235671937465668,
0.9605320692062378,
0.3185775578022003,
1.278045892715454,
-0.5583075284957886,
0.13054713606834412,
0.1502305269241333,
0.7658572196960449,
0.02889944426715374,
0.5900346040725708,
0.319476455450058,
-0.6240965723991394,
-0.5147795081138611,
-0.25112423300743103,
-0.5309876799583435,
-0.19234298169612885,
-0.48740193247795105,
-0.011539312079548836,
0.035733021795749664,
0.034998923540115356,
-0.33022478222846985,
0.49951037764549255,
-0.18992696702480316,
-0.5571145415306091,
0.607849657535553,
-0.3527810275554657,
0.1921091228723526,
-0.5386219024658203,
0.10263244062662125,
-0.15437056124210358,
0.2596115171909332,
-0.16567328572273254,
-0.3198365867137909,
-0.0398990735411644,
0.21175841987133026,
-0.24771983921527863,
0.32567793130874634,
-0.3174506723880768,
0.14560332894325256,
-0.6222572922706604,
0.26223456859588623,
0.44774410128593445,
0.06889185309410095,
-0.11096484959125519,
0.5403158068656921,
0.13771997392177582,
-0.607774555683136,
0.3734839856624603,
-0.12833856046199799,
-0.11159326136112213,
0.542540967464447,
-0.6962741613388062,
0.32733920216560364,
-0.4500994384288788,
0.6214691400527954,
-1.1106510162353516,
-0.6469681859016418,
-0.19058270752429962,
-0.4533039927482605,
-0.030626289546489716,
0.21900416910648346,
-0.23722386360168457,
-0.6590566635131836,
-0.37128692865371704,
-0.1356392502784729,
0.21748974919319153,
-0.32631897926330566,
0.7680506706237793,
0.04922875389456749,
-0.05359811335802078,
-0.46143579483032227,
-0.46515458822250366,
0.0625254213809967,
-0.4821569323539734,
-0.46983617544174194,
0.33669018745422363,
-0.5353481769561768,
-0.8830372095108032,
0.20547239482402802,
-0.09674078971147537,
-0.3168181777000427,
0.34834858775138855,
0.45716339349746704,
0.06705594807863235,
-0.05390343815088272,
0.6308401823043823,
0.12069197744131088,
-0.06556575000286102,
0.6431565880775452,
0.08189374953508377,
-0.07098870724439621,
-0.28818634152412415,
-0.1984807401895523,
-0.713309109210968,
0.31966733932495117,
0.6912927627563477,
0.39860799908638,
0.6148223876953125,
0.5994240045547485,
-0.1863383799791336,
-0.09415973722934723,
-0.17479127645492554,
-0.4670484960079193,
-0.4087146818637848,
0.07124748080968857,
-0.2543306052684784,
-0.3522757291793823,
0.7059564590454102,
0.1791471689939499,
0.48994383215904236,
0.7472096681594849,
0.2041642963886261,
-0.39367660880088806,
1.325649619102478,
0.7668172717094421,
0.6810067892074585,
0.2780165374279022,
-0.25612038373947144,
0.19563356041908264,
-0.6309249401092529,
-0.5126088857650757,
-0.9541098475456238,
-0.360223650932312,
-0.4105072617530823,
-0.03525171056389809,
0.11475200206041336,
0.05757558345794678,
-0.003600555472075939,
0.07771793007850647,
-0.6357556581497192,
0.5203388929367065,
0.417553573846817,
-0.10235466063022614,
0.3549133837223053,
-0.2432350218296051,
-0.12550178170204163,
-0.1125049963593483,
-0.20013809204101562,
-0.8695805072784424,
0.7431948184967041,
0.2980547547340393,
0.7776587605476379,
0.04277218133211136,
0.4310075044631958,
0.09740916639566422,
0.6122371554374695,
-1.0085164308547974,
0.36043593287467957,
0.18957483768463135,
-0.6841931343078613,
-0.26445472240448,
-0.2878066897392273,
-0.6973162293434143,
0.16742290556430817,
-0.40460026264190674,
-0.44448986649513245,
-0.17886494100093842,
0.11431112885475159,
-0.7512169480323792,
0.1109243854880333,
-0.9156879782676697,
0.609241783618927,
-0.43112513422966003,
-0.5564490556716919,
-0.24587227404117584,
-0.6129307746887207,
-0.07089082896709442,
-0.24806028604507446,
0.5044854879379272,
0.10671296715736389,
0.017477789893746376,
1.4706535339355469,
-0.6310429573059082,
0.6595485210418701,
-0.41215717792510986,
0.016932273283600807,
0.7676344513893127,
-0.11600037664175034,
0.1342450976371765,
0.021365713328123093,
0.07672607153654099,
-0.4237060546875,
0.13306179642677307,
-0.34379130601882935,
-1.1240891218185425,
0.2729492783546448,
-0.7416399121284485,
-0.9311977028846741,
-0.10234006494283676,
-0.6147785186767578,
0.1756732016801834,
-0.07675018906593323,
0.2937188744544983,
0.2885756194591522,
0.21239601075649261,
0.099409319460392,
0.1723896563053131,
0.19374093413352966,
0.7101201415061951,
0.6940181851387024,
-0.33564844727516174,
-0.20752543210983276,
0.6114992499351501,
0.5636852979660034,
0.1668570637702942,
-0.11422654241323471,
0.6118860840797424,
-0.36977797746658325,
-0.31849199533462524,
-0.6574009656906128,
0.1627550721168518,
-0.8887572288513184,
0.24029091000556946,
-0.8509172201156616,
0.3311898410320282,
-0.4414409399032593,
-0.40557771921157837,
-0.16177746653556824,
-0.9937832355499268,
-0.2913329303264618,
-0.3468681275844574,
0.23965096473693848,
1.1438541412353516,
-0.38201937079429626,
0.2817361652851105,
-0.22326155006885529,
-0.1111408919095993,
0.44633913040161133,
0.10941094160079956,
0.1638839989900589,
-0.6982348561286926,
-0.24058113992214203,
0.1153094619512558,
-0.5573597550392151,
-0.6332312226295471,
0.09873440861701965,
0.06953945010900497,
0.39450621604919434,
0.6489130258560181,
-0.003090294310823083,
0.8325834274291992,
-0.21407461166381836,
1.0137112140655518,
0.15000703930854797,
-0.9043180346488953,
0.789563775062561,
0.15336574614048004,
0.12838946282863617,
0.5970559120178223,
0.3354100286960602,
-0.17348051071166992,
-0.6474484801292419,
-0.7994926571846008,
-0.5077673196792603,
-0.04927416890859604,
-0.05509526655077934,
0.05440976098179817,
0.1517433226108551,
0.5752415657043457,
0.53053879737854,
0.2852129638195038,
-0.6798139214515686,
0.016033664345741272,
-0.36889761686325073,
-0.27828240394592285,
0.2476276457309723,
0.3239270746707916,
-0.29906365275382996,
-0.41464611887931824,
0.3347153663635254,
-0.36618801951408386,
0.2514272928237915,
0.377639502286911,
0.2053728550672531,
-0.594063401222229,
0.44794172048568726,
0.7869410514831543,
1.0160715579986572,
-0.0786643847823143,
0.4310537874698639,
0.3012382984161377,
-0.6767730712890625,
0.16796980798244476,
0.019796933978796005,
-0.0889199748635292,
0.2801300883293152,
0.6073794960975647,
0.4843742251396179,
-0.49927058815956116,
-0.47439754009246826,
0.27472540736198425,
-0.40065228939056396,
-0.2968639135360718,
-0.2699355185031891,
0.36596405506134033,
-0.4449167549610138,
-0.14869533479213715,
0.6577341556549072,
0.3142916262149811,
0.13423305749893188,
-0.5983868837356567,
0.020789310336112976,
0.4436117112636566,
-0.3842931091785431,
-0.6876173615455627,
0.7272683382034302,
0.04690726846456528,
-0.26068776845932007,
0.10855215787887573,
0.033886488527059555,
-0.626430332660675,
1.1737375259399414,
0.3700487017631531,
0.6478836536407471,
0.2123488187789917,
0.32039815187454224,
0.4673434793949127,
0.16633304953575134,
0.18967431783676147,
0.2059711217880249,
-0.19723936915397644,
-0.1966697722673416,
-0.6837550401687622,
-0.3466445505619049,
-0.7968473434448242,
-0.135487362742424,
-0.7096368670463562,
0.24465559422969818,
-0.5410453677177429,
-0.19806919991970062,
0.23241546750068665,
0.44546762108802795,
-0.5049883127212524,
0.2125493586063385,
-0.2672922909259796,
0.7013771533966064,
-1.2342172861099243,
0.04606245085597038,
1.1222702264785767,
-0.5756838917732239,
-1.2113243341445923,
-0.1995546817779541,
0.04049185290932655,
-0.3636590838432312,
0.8466245532035828,
0.18691648542881012,
-0.17776155471801758,
-0.3822462856769562,
-0.893097996711731,
-0.8360742330551147,
0.639100968837738,
-0.2021738886833191,
-0.28417494893074036,
0.032023508101701736,
-0.11458338797092438,
0.9018660187721252,
-0.5386396050453186,
0.7145159840583801,
0.19717895984649658,
0.9376370906829834,
0.13975362479686737,
-1.1096196174621582,
0.04594104364514351,
-0.16188845038414001,
-0.48291534185409546,
-0.13863156735897064,
-0.5414856672286987,
0.7717143297195435,
-0.8695746660232544,
-0.3654189109802246,
-0.10082205384969711,
0.7963745594024658,
-0.19256071746349335,
0.9596571326255798,
0.6585437655448914,
0.21706953644752502,
1.070915937423706,
-0.0544075183570385,
0.8471856117248535,
-0.032348256558179855,
0.24133607745170593,
0.7363132834434509,
-0.07391642779111862,
0.6014690399169922,
0.8030261993408203,
-0.13200271129608154,
0.8634603023529053,
0.7140083312988281,
0.07511288672685623,
0.3868771195411682,
0.4046432375907898,
-0.05334123596549034,
-0.191582590341568,
-0.3048980236053467,
-0.2471819818019867,
0.49917539954185486,
0.4548925459384918,
-0.14394158124923706,
0.0933929830789566,
0.5143453478813171,
0.0754210352897644,
0.2595859169960022,
-0.2814125120639801,
0.7194010019302368,
-0.14141303300857544,
-0.9481112957000732,
0.18893779814243317,
-0.3630290627479553,
0.2774699926376343,
0.04399258643388748,
-0.20273403823375702,
-0.14755170047283173,
0.04182006046175957,
-0.5256656408309937,
-0.9758724570274353,
0.27343860268592834,
0.006226733326911926,
-0.29427751898765564,
-0.26643815636634827,
0.2045803964138031,
-0.20884951949119568,
-0.2793719172477722,
-0.44167980551719666,
0.3770054280757904,
0.45307406783103943,
0.5095473527908325,
-0.3557955026626587,
0.014922632835805416,
-0.17407338321208954,
-0.2147226333618164,
-0.21655160188674927,
0.49091431498527527,
0.08289686590433121,
0.40889349579811096,
0.3681696653366089,
0.016746262088418007,
-0.15843378007411957,
-0.1294167935848236,
0.7138219475746155,
-0.6317654848098755,
-0.4983750879764557,
-0.5679701566696167,
0.6614737510681152,
-0.14867278933525085,
-0.37022408843040466,
0.7698853015899658,
0.5186192989349365,
0.5981619954109192,
0.15206126868724823,
0.8531951308250427,
0.005289227236062288,
0.6494480967521667,
-0.4308602809906006,
0.5051543712615967,
-0.49060702323913574,
0.15708251297473907,
-0.12888100743293762,
-0.8691758513450623,
-0.3243124485015869,
0.8525473475456238,
-0.4922000765800476,
0.22442527115345,
1.2930245399475098,
0.13040295243263245,
0.3299158215522766,
0.3759250342845917,
-0.23375040292739868,
0.4315391182899475,
0.6090577840805054,
0.2158578485250473,
1.020615577697754,
-0.21851672232151031,
0.4643484652042389,
-0.4976050555706024,
-0.37792572379112244,
-0.19345365464687347,
-0.8334606885910034,
-0.7759250402450562,
-0.5284635424613953,
-0.8874838352203369,
-0.47216254472732544,
-0.354833722114563,
0.7870878577232361,
0.41173914074897766,
-0.5940521359443665,
-0.041322045028209686,
-0.053726840764284134,
0.18752525746822357,
-0.11152658611536026,
-0.33214646577835083,
0.5248684287071228,
-0.17374911904335022,
-0.644646406173706,
0.11897621303796768,
0.10198694467544556,
0.3286718726158142,
-0.22969530522823334,
0.3233465850353241,
0.3726136088371277,
0.2875434160232544,
0.23724602162837982,
0.23550836741924286,
-0.5267057418823242,
-0.788214385509491,
0.21153652667999268,
-0.18978963792324066,
-0.07390471547842026,
0.6768085956573486,
-0.8144908547401428,
0.6574574112892151,
0.38302525877952576,
0.18150411546230316,
0.18826143443584442,
0.18382218480110168,
0.2562745213508606,
-0.2662960886955261,
0.0062126643024384975,
0.3719552755355835,
0.2871469557285309,
0.17999286949634552,
-0.327816903591156,
0.28412488102912903,
0.4600328505039215,
-0.6536057591438293,
-0.7751924991607666,
-0.26647549867630005,
-0.9113835692405701,
-0.42254921793937683,
0.7315015196800232,
-0.028938381001353264,
-0.5821431279182434,
-0.21675793826580048,
-0.3212263286113739,
0.04890093952417374,
-0.3671986758708954,
1.219905138015747,
0.9376909732818604,
-0.6390735507011414,
0.24080400168895721,
-0.5141803622245789,
0.33526208996772766,
0.589033842086792,
-0.8345998525619507,
-0.15797187387943268,
0.5252915620803833,
0.020604122430086136,
0.6731955409049988,
0.14908434450626373,
0.2557276487350464,
0.4252379238605499,
0.09901069104671478,
-0.07474153488874435,
-0.004176000598818064,
-0.4968836307525635,
-0.16318416595458984,
0.37594926357269287,
-0.003990453667938709,
-0.10086818784475327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11672v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11672v1
|
MemLLM: Finetuning LLMs to Use An Explicit Read-Write Memory
| 2024-04-17T18:13:16 | 2024-04-17T18:13:16 |
Ali Modarressi, Abdullatif Köksal, Ayyoob Imani, Mohsen Fayyaz, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While current large language models (LLMs) demonstrate some capabilities in
knowledge-intensive tasks, they are limited by relying on their parameters as
an implicit storage mechanism. As a result, they struggle with infrequent
knowledge and temporal degradation. In addition, the uninterpretable nature of
parametric memorization makes it challenging to understand and prevent
hallucination. Parametric memory pools and model editing are only partial
solutions. Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) $\unicode{x2013}$ though
non-parametric $\unicode{x2013}$ has its own limitations: it lacks structure,
complicates interpretability and makes it hard to effectively manage stored
knowledge. In this paper, we introduce MemLLM, a novel method of enhancing LLMs
by integrating a structured and explicit read-and-write memory module. MemLLM
tackles the aforementioned challenges by enabling dynamic interaction with the
memory and improving the LLM's capabilities in using stored knowledge. Our
experiments indicate that MemLLM enhances the LLM's performance and
interpretability, in language modeling in general and knowledge-intensive tasks
in particular. We see MemLLM as an important step towards making LLMs more
grounded and factual through memory augmentation.
|
[
-0.10165144503116608,
-0.9927969574928284,
0.578026294708252,
0.014644700102508068,
-0.29578351974487305,
0.2251812219619751,
-0.16322651505470276,
-0.35830017924308777,
-0.2729761600494385,
0.5580040812492371,
-0.4215549826622009,
-0.4867062270641327,
-0.222853422164917,
-0.13464412093162537,
-0.33220258355140686,
0.9981446862220764,
-0.20651544630527496,
0.015435528010129929,
-0.5870527625083923,
-0.2399059236049652,
-0.4586274325847626,
-0.8300893306732178,
-0.44828692078590393,
-0.3609085977077484,
0.5731517672538757,
0.256608247756958,
0.6829460859298706,
0.6515233516693115,
0.4077063798904419,
0.265186607837677,
-0.16246621310710907,
0.6766902804374695,
-0.6239913702011108,
0.40629976987838745,
-0.12286850810050964,
-0.5434989333152771,
-0.7803218960762024,
-0.18873310089111328,
0.7761929035186768,
0.5574979186058044,
-0.18685726821422577,
0.18692323565483093,
0.21817149221897125,
0.5570766925811768,
-0.6845309138298035,
-0.020691504701972008,
-0.7783684134483337,
-0.02039703167974949,
-0.28210651874542236,
-0.5929903984069824,
-0.4835909903049469,
0.05040014535188675,
-0.04507611691951752,
-0.39081045985221863,
0.0939953550696373,
0.2491745501756668,
0.504594624042511,
0.35185152292251587,
-0.11681747436523438,
-0.35750705003738403,
-0.9700232148170471,
0.8725570440292358,
-0.8497462272644043,
0.5412782430648804,
0.29401150345802307,
0.3083401918411255,
-0.13795870542526245,
-0.6171000599861145,
-0.6500411629676819,
-0.4390797019004822,
-0.12585334479808807,
-0.1045476496219635,
0.14503061771392822,
0.021206671372056007,
0.2988249957561493,
0.29466527700424194,
-0.49997809529304504,
-0.09720682352781296,
-0.45055389404296875,
-0.21807435154914856,
0.3561230003833771,
0.5904721617698669,
0.4461100399494171,
0.11312762647867203,
-0.5420356392860413,
0.2767910659313202,
-0.8394027948379517,
-0.16452084481716156,
0.27070802450180054,
0.15962013602256775,
0.13864485919475555,
0.6921634078025818,
-0.054982736706733704,
0.8525330424308777,
-0.3107001483440399,
-0.20048834383487701,
-0.008212530985474586,
-0.13627395033836365,
-0.27171340584754944,
-0.08488244563341141,
0.3298722505569458,
0.2048708200454712,
0.07530011236667633,
-0.1337108612060547,
-0.5406227707862854,
-0.3859899640083313,
0.322609007358551,
-0.7714644074440002,
-0.2982479929924011,
0.1634792685508728,
-0.48217013478279114,
-0.15266133844852448,
-0.10354867577552795,
-0.4809504449367523,
-0.4065554141998291,
-0.6657629609107971,
0.6349694132804871,
-0.49965062737464905,
-0.20517736673355103,
0.20488354563713074,
0.011202078312635422,
0.21955351531505585,
0.7043970227241516,
-0.9354137182235718,
0.3767971694469452,
0.7149975895881653,
0.7134771943092346,
-0.28084415197372437,
-0.3953503966331482,
-0.3749532997608185,
0.6878194808959961,
-0.11056745052337646,
0.7051439881324768,
-0.6092695593833923,
-0.13120681047439575,
-0.13319650292396545,
-0.34078335762023926,
-0.051947031170129776,
-0.7497673630714417,
0.2436317801475525,
-0.5819130539894104,
0.1646757572889328,
0.09650060534477234,
-0.7871944904327393,
-0.03864995017647743,
0.37251120805740356,
-0.5146222710609436,
0.9590789675712585,
0.1506640762090683,
-0.48318514227867126,
0.03454095870256424,
-0.5340891480445862,
-0.3133224546909332,
-0.02411968819797039,
-0.06473025679588318,
-0.3215300738811493,
0.2844875752925873,
-0.13359704613685608,
0.5919606685638428,
-0.2642677426338196,
0.48791077733039856,
-0.1757044941186905,
-0.29904940724372864,
0.41086289286613464,
-0.7826966047286987,
0.3001929223537445,
0.43110769987106323,
0.054525066167116165,
0.2176501452922821,
-0.8320856690406799,
-0.13044412434101105,
-0.04572990536689758,
-0.6871725916862488,
-0.4507232904434204,
0.011130849830806255,
-0.13442708551883698,
0.1356605887413025,
0.7093197703361511,
-0.2788124680519104,
0.1399703174829483,
-0.10118337720632553,
0.26070356369018555,
0.7056081891059875,
-0.1582602560520172,
0.6170824766159058,
-0.4880754053592682,
0.2584262788295746,
0.11135558784008026,
0.39420247077941895,
-0.3047722578048706,
-0.04326559603214264,
-0.8950905203819275,
-0.21762098371982574,
0.041287727653980255,
0.4528197646141052,
-0.6822133660316467,
0.05437988415360451,
0.057797469198703766,
-0.39040690660476685,
-0.5869854092597961,
0.41693314909935,
0.46498891711235046,
0.8571156859397888,
0.7033590078353882,
0.3372184932231903,
-0.46909430623054504,
-0.7739782929420471,
-0.2504386901855469,
-0.08583635091781616,
-0.0698438361287117,
0.5738282203674316,
-0.04735708236694336,
-0.31254488229751587,
0.5855024456977844,
-0.5502716898918152,
-0.3077263832092285,
-0.2482093870639801,
-0.017992053180933,
0.16160108149051666,
0.6673362255096436,
0.17701077461242676,
-0.581047773361206,
-0.27836892008781433,
-0.115357406437397,
-0.8067713975906372,
-0.33058279752731323,
-0.3584323525428772,
-0.20816898345947266,
0.49910980463027954,
0.8064078688621521,
-0.6231482028961182,
0.040001802146434784,
0.3768336772918701,
-0.6049808859825134,
0.6364372968673706,
-0.6724331974983215,
-0.15138481557369232,
-0.6468055844306946,
0.014567937701940536,
-0.6870291233062744,
-0.42519012093544006,
-0.7587598562240601,
0.1263086497783661,
0.3795715868473053,
0.09671807289123535,
-0.5340020656585693,
0.8032535314559937,
-0.7382440567016602,
0.014234562404453754,
-0.39135226607322693,
0.006719726603478193,
0.21281515061855316,
0.32151925563812256,
-0.2961839437484741,
0.832730770111084,
0.34273046255111694,
-0.7455383539199829,
0.10284554213285446,
0.15835238993167877,
-0.10800562053918839,
0.3337668478488922,
-0.3413144052028656,
0.16264592111110687,
-0.14622947573661804,
-0.14356102049350739,
-0.7628860473632812,
0.07534077763557434,
0.12401483207941055,
-0.1371728777885437,
0.747127115726471,
0.4131346344947815,
-0.4535188674926758,
-0.07809976488351822,
-0.18150560557842255,
0.3927685618400574,
0.5291554927825928,
-0.5946112275123596,
0.9176883697509766,
0.29184016585350037,
-0.014811721630394459,
-0.4932120144367218,
-0.482496440410614,
0.06689722836017609,
-0.26251041889190674,
-0.3853153586387634,
0.10417221486568451,
-0.21991150081157684,
-0.3485523760318756,
0.048267912119627,
-0.18712104856967926,
-0.05579688400030136,
0.10319644957780838,
-0.07439914345741272,
0.4667908847332001,
-0.3285083472728729,
0.4435303509235382,
0.17198462784290314,
-0.1373869925737381,
-0.166177898645401,
-0.19876456260681152,
0.8073874115943909,
-0.10582609474658966,
-0.28074824810028076,
-0.19096961617469788,
0.23942644894123077,
0.5625625252723694,
-0.36569175124168396,
0.8034741282463074,
0.49226754903793335,
-0.237180694937706,
-0.4331909120082855,
-0.6722606420516968,
-0.22761063277721405,
-0.5427595376968384,
0.374938428401947,
-0.543743371963501,
-1.1002904176712036,
0.38723352551460266,
-0.24946175515651703,
0.007307733409106731,
0.2667815089225769,
0.6132622957229614,
-0.35947445034980774,
0.8266269564628601,
0.3488127291202545,
0.18288186192512512,
0.37549886107444763,
0.010962685570120811,
0.028140654787421227,
-1.030827283859253,
-0.40487322211265564,
-0.1414855718612671,
-0.480095773935318,
-0.07721319049596786,
-0.8874052166938782,
0.03956448286771774,
0.39879587292671204,
-0.25448572635650635,
-0.10539024323225021,
-0.3660675287246704,
0.45636317133903503,
0.43169134855270386,
0.16259974241256714,
0.5828682780265808,
-0.25064557790756226,
-0.3757953345775604,
-0.1072954311966896,
-0.5364946722984314,
-0.7939618229866028,
0.9819501638412476,
0.30209314823150635,
1.1699644327163696,
0.04445928707718849,
0.5586938858032227,
0.20819474756717682,
0.3323979377746582,
-0.383081316947937,
0.6787331700325012,
-0.22157151997089386,
-0.4592442512512207,
-0.39064550399780273,
-0.26016128063201904,
-0.7211121320724487,
0.17054785788059235,
-0.28547337651252747,
-0.3166656494140625,
-0.028797563165426254,
0.4444114565849304,
-0.1299515962600708,
0.4976827800273895,
-0.5025761723518372,
0.5259135961532593,
-0.4640868008136749,
-0.5125070810317993,
-0.31667786836624146,
-0.485482394695282,
0.29543206095695496,
-0.18284954130649567,
-0.02404394932091236,
-0.30226650834083557,
-0.5043492913246155,
0.27986496686935425,
-0.5342562198638916,
0.7362169623374939,
-0.32371786236763,
-0.19581001996994019,
0.23968832194805145,
0.2729884684085846,
0.5697023868560791,
-0.044076599180698395,
-0.1255684345960617,
-0.06461584568023682,
-0.018529849126935005,
-0.31532764434814453,
-0.8843346834182739,
0.7220964431762695,
-0.6460210084915161,
-0.9243981242179871,
-0.03042738512158394,
-1.2450248003005981,
-0.19996333122253418,
0.23648948967456818,
-0.33467698097229004,
0.5287916660308838,
-0.19376008212566376,
0.17415817081928253,
0.762978196144104,
-0.3173462152481079,
0.2705267667770386,
0.8327309489250183,
-0.3476705253124237,
-0.1636572778224945,
1.127608299255371,
0.12130247056484222,
0.3646908402442932,
0.6243114471435547,
0.2655359208583832,
-0.42489585280418396,
-0.9079793095588684,
-0.2354886680841446,
0.21366533637046814,
-0.6057464480400085,
-0.16553044319152832,
-0.8384431004524231,
-0.28054431080818176,
0.005545065272599459,
-0.07980100810527802,
-0.14118917286396027,
-0.7053045034408569,
-0.5409122705459595,
-0.048854269087314606,
0.39242783188819885,
0.6264437437057495,
-0.01812262088060379,
0.24475911259651184,
-0.8406726717948914,
0.2868299186229706,
0.15811336040496826,
0.4207862615585327,
0.10439345240592957,
-0.4901496469974518,
-0.1983642876148224,
-0.1463850885629654,
-0.1348656415939331,
-0.4851570129394531,
0.3584855794906616,
0.2614077627658844,
0.6542376279830933,
0.40830838680267334,
0.05702659487724304,
0.7871867418289185,
-0.8165597319602966,
0.36359524726867676,
-0.25231000781059265,
-0.9057821035385132,
0.32448434829711914,
-0.43691956996917725,
0.14210249483585358,
0.34492555260658264,
0.007267901208251715,
-0.36821863055229187,
-0.8101578950881958,
-0.5504757761955261,
-0.7564590573310852,
0.4340987205505371,
-0.07600194215774536,
0.5028938055038452,
0.13754802942276,
0.7395952343940735,
0.12237334996461868,
0.3690839111804962,
-0.43024739623069763,
-0.20744293928146362,
0.12209711223840714,
-0.3390689790248871,
-0.14390307664871216,
-0.7823068499565125,
0.14999641478061676,
-0.46387454867362976,
0.5268286466598511,
0.1182447299361229,
0.14901146292686462,
0.1733013242483139,
-0.3815973103046417,
-0.0004847227537538856,
0.15823350846767426,
0.8277865648269653,
0.6962035894393921,
-0.3250395357608795,
0.6087318658828735,
0.3814820945262909,
-0.5394543409347534,
0.18275664746761322,
-0.1529102474451065,
-0.4639052450656891,
-0.0907476618885994,
0.2520556151866913,
0.7995135188102722,
0.25214216113090515,
-0.8736686706542969,
-0.046278052031993866,
0.07516950368881226,
-0.15342122316360474,
-0.1757678985595703,
0.42933061718940735,
0.2612172067165375,
0.5330933332443237,
0.22281160950660706,
0.06119914725422859,
0.19123797118663788,
-0.38826417922973633,
0.48800984025001526,
0.6181263327598572,
-0.35400575399398804,
-0.20293894410133362,
0.847338080406189,
0.017776817083358765,
-0.26790809631347656,
0.3812497556209564,
0.039180006831884384,
-0.26288124918937683,
0.1915799081325531,
0.9929330945014954,
0.6322591304779053,
-0.5279226899147034,
-0.07130901515483856,
0.17343081533908844,
0.2609652280807495,
0.11257235705852509,
0.46363866329193115,
-0.09538234770298004,
-0.7730393409729004,
-0.18323786556720734,
-0.854719877243042,
-0.4278514087200165,
0.20932482182979584,
-0.46701934933662415,
0.3159690797328949,
-0.5833021998405457,
0.33058837056159973,
-0.3769616484642029,
-0.03110753931105137,
-0.24698607623577118,
0.18793992698192596,
0.07248710840940475,
0.9238004684448242,
-0.47436898946762085,
1.0658906698226929,
0.5871365070343018,
-0.10285227000713348,
-0.7348951101303101,
-0.14022725820541382,
-0.14044633507728577,
-0.9472072720527649,
0.4240640699863434,
-0.010415245778858662,
0.12114093452692032,
0.27257949113845825,
-0.4111945927143097,
-0.6779159307479858,
1.331703543663025,
0.36900022625923157,
-0.5428488850593567,
0.051612142473459244,
0.1662195920944214,
0.6018062829971313,
-0.45175281167030334,
-0.10468937456607819,
0.5829828977584839,
0.5064797401428223,
0.2370862364768982,
-0.42398199439048767,
0.24346396327018738,
-0.27522414922714233,
-0.14422094821929932,
0.34671440720558167,
-0.4575672447681427,
1.1695988178253174,
-0.3249070346355438,
-0.07358536869287491,
0.0895247831940651,
0.5562946200370789,
0.48332685232162476,
0.33757030963897705,
0.23563259840011597,
0.46501457691192627,
1.1526210308074951,
0.19997268915176392,
1.1291491985321045,
-0.13809099793434143,
0.1089877039194107,
1.4428695440292358,
-0.2134501338005066,
1.101959466934204,
0.5526782870292664,
-0.01219191960990429,
0.21384695172309875,
0.23478877544403076,
-0.10200441628694534,
0.49043139815330505,
0.2162679135799408,
-0.61713045835495,
-0.25253725051879883,
-0.03914135321974754,
-0.09335500746965408,
0.21275006234645844,
0.46322545409202576,
-0.39780306816101074,
-0.33568742871284485,
0.13161888718605042,
0.12358406186103821,
0.1531754434108734,
-0.38891541957855225,
0.8788591623306274,
0.15178531408309937,
-0.30786195397377014,
0.7177764177322388,
-0.1234559714794159,
0.45859140157699585,
-0.3953845202922821,
-0.15953423082828522,
-0.08831322193145752,
0.500158429145813,
-0.12556041777133942,
-0.7248845100402832,
0.6990861296653748,
-0.06167063117027283,
-0.36101245880126953,
-0.34584203362464905,
1.2311644554138184,
-0.869415819644928,
-0.411393404006958,
0.33230265974998474,
0.8696643114089966,
0.19945773482322693,
-0.045983634889125824,
-0.6524012684822083,
0.015256708487868309,
0.009362404234707355,
-0.19417326152324677,
0.40479370951652527,
0.6144399642944336,
-0.10235186666250229,
0.7859410643577576,
0.8029785752296448,
0.16759075224399567,
0.22686231136322021,
0.15417730808258057,
0.9495592713356018,
-0.6695891618728638,
-0.019421668723225594,
-1.2820924520492554,
0.5353459715843201,
0.18099407851696014,
0.1696469783782959,
0.8795500993728638,
0.7368124723434448,
0.4318612515926361,
-0.2371465116739273,
0.5835737586021423,
0.2271633893251419,
0.5779919624328613,
-0.7477409839630127,
1.0704916715621948,
-0.6317564845085144,
0.37604451179504395,
0.013601395301520824,
-0.872200071811676,
-0.5482638478279114,
0.4266662001609802,
-0.20684362947940826,
-0.26253047585487366,
0.5169605612754822,
0.7969310283660889,
0.011280311271548271,
-0.2617896497249603,
0.7779538035392761,
0.5428407192230225,
0.382494181394577,
0.440731406211853,
1.1845440864562988,
-0.028526881709694862,
0.5133703351020813,
-0.01874181069433689,
-0.09137636423110962,
-0.1349407583475113,
-0.7959015965461731,
-1.105380892753601,
-0.537315309047699,
0.03898375481367111,
-0.17468564212322235,
0.10452678054571152,
0.633672833442688,
0.23078587651252747,
-0.7335318922996521,
-0.19540448486804962,
-0.18965864181518555,
0.22541680932044983,
0.25144100189208984,
-0.16313572227954865,
0.25970616936683655,
-0.8365525603294373,
-0.7152727842330933,
0.21961326897144318,
0.66713547706604,
0.3990214169025421,
-0.37340259552001953,
-0.35402414202690125,
-0.26621943712234497,
0.24741950631141663,
0.6505118608474731,
0.04567880555987358,
-0.5773635506629944,
-0.011300013400614262,
0.14134137332439423,
-0.14598993957042694,
0.04919563606381416,
0.6736903786659241,
-0.7417320013046265,
0.48750656843185425,
0.5571233034133911,
0.6256659626960754,
0.3768805265426636,
0.0222280565649271,
0.8310352563858032,
-0.6187446117401123,
0.20867983996868134,
0.23369143903255463,
0.4441642761230469,
0.2913556396961212,
-0.464973121881485,
0.3159455955028534,
-0.10033039003610611,
-0.6060880422592163,
-0.8601869344711304,
-0.08162963390350342,
-0.695154070854187,
-0.34212222695350647,
1.0730282068252563,
-0.027296723797917366,
-0.2652064263820648,
-0.36638057231903076,
-0.48292630910873413,
0.2909446358680725,
-0.10413366556167603,
0.685262143611908,
0.5644336938858032,
-0.08563215285539627,
-0.42355120182037354,
-0.8519657254219055,
0.7491031885147095,
0.42153647541999817,
-0.8835325241088867,
0.22973006963729858,
0.5372877717018127,
0.09746316820383072,
-0.0330500490963459,
0.652902364730835,
-0.22240300476551056,
0.10598687827587128,
-0.3038741648197174,
-0.03615585342049599,
-0.428809255361557,
-0.512811541557312,
-0.257260262966156,
0.0022992659360170364,
0.26289188861846924,
0.05893418565392494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11588v1
|
Related Work and Citation Text Generation: A Survey
| 2024-04-17T17:37:30 | 2024-04-17T17:37:30 |
Xiangci Li, Jessica Ouyang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To convince readers of the novelty of their research paper, authors must
perform a literature review and compose a coherent story that connects and
relates prior works to the current work. This challenging nature of literature
review writing makes automatic related work generation (RWG) academically and
computationally interesting, and also makes it an excellent test bed for
examining the capability of SOTA natural language processing (NLP) models.
Since the initial proposal of the RWG task, its popularity has waxed and waned,
following the capabilities of mainstream NLP approaches. In this work, we
survey the zoo of RWG historical works, summarizing the key approaches and task
definitions and discussing the ongoing challenges of RWG.
|
[
-0.7152174115180969,
-0.5916911959648132,
0.4677973687648773,
-0.04763505235314369,
-0.17518247663974762,
-0.1840985268354416,
0.28393852710723877,
-1.0577270984649658,
0.141306072473526,
0.8751029968261719,
-1.1505717039108276,
-0.27933844923973083,
-0.07269402593374252,
0.7565492987632751,
-0.4004681408405304,
1.442629337310791,
-0.20289315283298492,
-0.27496713399887085,
-0.40387022495269775,
-0.43195173144340515,
-0.5159684419631958,
-0.595874011516571,
-0.1711137443780899,
-0.5476695895195007,
0.7390142679214478,
0.2275940179824829,
0.5619475245475769,
0.3682691752910614,
0.7108705639839172,
0.17463022470474243,
0.09264300018548965,
0.24005743861198425,
-0.4819486141204834,
0.6228222250938416,
-0.48361265659332275,
-0.43343809247016907,
-0.16576094925403595,
-0.025160910561680794,
0.4410598576068878,
0.6970057487487793,
0.21503621339797974,
0.3016827404499054,
0.10597632080316544,
0.8125693798065186,
-0.2946937382221222,
0.053577497601509094,
-0.5807296633720398,
0.21450692415237427,
-0.3951902389526367,
-0.39992421865463257,
-0.3598288595676422,
-0.3929250240325928,
0.13125190138816833,
-0.4900881052017212,
0.7526704668998718,
0.04582122340798378,
0.8967280983924866,
-0.05300610139966011,
-0.169284388422966,
-0.7582337260246277,
-0.8464191555976868,
0.8677293658256531,
-0.5014402270317078,
-0.17230536043643951,
0.19950908422470093,
-0.04280179366469383,
-0.42332714796066284,
-1.1417040824890137,
-0.6057683825492859,
-0.21965350210666656,
-0.19271545112133026,
0.13823822140693665,
-0.05260247364640236,
-0.42266032099723816,
0.26814860105514526,
0.41725635528564453,
-0.4973297119140625,
-0.3223297894001007,
-0.285673588514328,
-0.0164179727435112,
0.6952685117721558,
0.3477742373943329,
0.21968691051006317,
-0.37086737155914307,
-0.34658902883529663,
-0.1384652704000473,
-0.9452121257781982,
-0.13216692209243774,
0.4922085404396057,
0.02246301993727684,
0.46498429775238037,
0.6430880427360535,
-0.24553944170475006,
0.8036530613899231,
-0.38387641310691833,
-0.051154304295778275,
0.10369747877120972,
-0.5823526978492737,
0.07484015077352524,
-0.12127131223678589,
0.7437201142311096,
0.44622889161109924,
0.18595612049102783,
0.0205147173255682,
0.011482922360301018,
-0.22635097801685333,
0.39738062024116516,
-0.49695467948913574,
0.06295333057641983,
-0.0332849845290184,
-0.7587383389472961,
-0.38125985860824585,
0.08825332671403885,
-0.4321807622909546,
-0.08405301719903946,
-0.16449742019176483,
0.03739384561777115,
-0.18107400834560394,
-0.3068215250968933,
-0.2979944944381714,
-0.2870897352695465,
-0.08808956295251846,
0.2525111138820648,
-0.6303581595420837,
-0.2122843712568283,
0.7070358395576477,
0.6105837821960449,
-0.20996065437793732,
-0.5377610921859741,
-0.12065346539020538,
0.3141357898712158,
-0.20049507915973663,
1.1052980422973633,
-0.41719937324523926,
-0.5543426275253296,
0.345785915851593,
0.13628704845905304,
-0.027166040614247322,
-0.46046125888824463,
0.5714784860610962,
-0.6471284627914429,
0.23284518718719482,
-0.3095206320285797,
-0.14722062647342682,
-0.253557413816452,
0.31524553894996643,
-0.8095167279243469,
1.3045679330825806,
0.1434495896100998,
-1.277644395828247,
0.5299175381660461,
-0.4599241316318512,
-0.5307785868644714,
-0.02442927658557892,
-0.3240704834461212,
-0.6569530367851257,
0.14730487763881683,
-0.20202267169952393,
0.5139983892440796,
-0.5145894289016724,
0.23618552088737488,
-0.17642541229724884,
-0.25358590483665466,
0.09430793672800064,
0.37148571014404297,
0.679076075553894,
0.42336925864219666,
-0.3111322224140167,
0.2192838042974472,
-0.8552916646003723,
-0.04447105526924133,
0.21495001018047333,
-0.21837618947029114,
-0.46773770451545715,
0.03860791400074959,
0.11170806735754013,
0.16090895235538483,
0.07078991830348969,
-0.3653148412704468,
0.24470838904380798,
-0.1289702206850052,
0.4182101786136627,
0.06144490838050842,
0.42794564366340637,
0.024380045011639595,
-0.6905277967453003,
0.6163924336433411,
-0.4435625970363617,
-0.16969311237335205,
-0.37326672673225403,
-0.6631376147270203,
-0.3113367259502411,
0.35428640246391296,
0.27741536498069763,
0.22969433665275574,
-1.043066382408142,
0.17950621247291565,
-0.21992412209510803,
-0.6845332980155945,
0.03589129447937012,
0.032210346311330795,
0.2380487471818924,
0.5851544141769409,
0.26974907517433167,
-0.18294958770275116,
-0.6238216757774353,
-0.6446793079376221,
-0.38199031352996826,
-0.4850831925868988,
0.04371679946780205,
0.33040091395378113,
0.5770379900932312,
-0.24119685590267181,
1.1995726823806763,
-0.5882161259651184,
-0.5575082302093506,
-0.3903237283229828,
0.6791052222251892,
0.12011232227087021,
0.5330061912536621,
0.7231751680374146,
-0.6212095618247986,
-0.5296812653541565,
0.05746595934033394,
-1.005921483039856,
-0.21605704724788666,
-0.2788487374782562,
-0.07126713544130325,
0.26721087098121643,
1.0315728187561035,
-0.21599212288856506,
0.32946619391441345,
0.31481507420539856,
0.10288170725107193,
0.7807866930961609,
-0.026903340592980385,
0.01992860436439514,
-0.9189803600311279,
0.56633061170578,
-0.3010980486869812,
-0.12934577465057373,
-0.37702104449272156,
0.29412442445755005,
-0.31704196333885193,
-0.28151121735572815,
-0.05773714929819107,
0.11579418182373047,
-0.6631659269332886,
0.037800151854753494,
-0.5716379284858704,
0.13603487610816956,
-0.12299137562513351,
0.21563732624053955,
0.4276407063007355,
0.4257062077522278,
0.12102477252483368,
-0.5886852145195007,
0.24200038611888885,
0.32119378447532654,
-0.1010536178946495,
0.37490609288215637,
-0.39491263031959534,
0.24563734233379364,
-0.10694181174039841,
0.5654093027114868,
-0.6325950622558594,
-0.01250917837023735,
-0.01809118315577507,
-0.26197537779808044,
0.1287277638912201,
0.11745896190404892,
-0.5615980625152588,
-0.4228472411632538,
-0.4597541391849518,
0.20208251476287842,
0.1755421906709671,
-0.27256858348846436,
0.42970648407936096,
0.14195328950881958,
-0.6064526438713074,
-0.5359228253364563,
-0.6765478849411011,
0.1461801379919052,
-0.05378635227680206,
-0.696266770362854,
0.508590579032898,
0.28063809871673584,
-0.21289807558059692,
0.20466816425323486,
0.006933483760803938,
0.1559303253889084,
-0.1504281610250473,
0.027810953557491302,
0.149147629737854,
-0.31304752826690674,
0.05182793363928795,
-0.15095500648021698,
-0.0850367397069931,
0.2625443935394287,
0.08432069420814514,
0.4878663420677185,
0.2600367069244385,
-0.16947126388549805,
0.14113052189350128,
0.7809539437294006,
0.05660427361726761,
-0.01702561415731907,
0.499492883682251,
0.8471126556396484,
0.011466620489954948,
-0.19483958184719086,
-0.37383097410202026,
-0.12068524956703186,
-0.34949925541877747,
0.39466962218284607,
-0.4319067895412445,
-0.7114017605781555,
0.4972269535064697,
-0.21721909940242767,
0.5624122619628906,
0.8194001913070679,
0.4175831973552704,
-0.1457950472831726,
0.44311949610710144,
0.8908166289329529,
0.2969802916049957,
0.5902314186096191,
-0.16870057582855225,
0.35395708680152893,
-0.6873605251312256,
-0.2716258466243744,
-0.9822394847869873,
-0.024985965341329575,
-0.6756024956703186,
-0.17925342917442322,
0.1642208844423294,
0.1478205919265747,
0.3757939040660858,
0.5059892535209656,
-0.6777204871177673,
-0.10394471883773804,
0.609874427318573,
-0.11300188302993774,
0.5678227543830872,
-0.00001798648554540705,
-0.2624521851539612,
-0.17047978937625885,
-0.5314149260520935,
-0.7462583184242249,
0.997377872467041,
0.15513962507247925,
0.7167280316352844,
-0.18612748384475708,
0.9938111305236816,
0.36226168274879456,
0.5856029391288757,
-0.5065584778785706,
0.6388913989067078,
0.2978481352329254,
-0.7598735690116882,
-0.5028370022773743,
-0.057565659284591675,
-1.1382169723510742,
0.15453572571277618,
-0.2751844525337219,
-0.45132285356521606,
0.20428940653800964,
0.09141161292791367,
-0.10517612099647522,
-0.013350172899663448,
-0.19768932461738586,
0.5242236852645874,
0.4434090554714203,
-0.5481565594673157,
-0.29019027948379517,
-0.8229487538337708,
0.4879130423069,
-0.08070915937423706,
0.13901807367801666,
0.02046719752252102,
0.24643920361995697,
0.8694073557853699,
-0.547650933265686,
0.544760525226593,
-0.03812389448285103,
-0.26429593563079834,
0.8444679379463196,
0.07628486305475235,
0.7413516044616699,
0.07654330879449844,
-0.2508011758327484,
-0.22865760326385498,
0.08515391498804092,
-0.10430949926376343,
-0.1817702353000641,
0.7011519074440002,
-0.23638688027858734,
-0.6682273745536804,
-0.6387547850608826,
-0.6832224726676941,
-0.42084625363349915,
0.3266768455505371,
0.4350254535675049,
0.28947779536247253,
-0.44101062417030334,
0.3412081301212311,
0.1994788497686386,
0.05900005251169205,
0.6732414960861206,
0.13738295435905457,
-0.3584693372249603,
-0.17229855060577393,
0.6990348696708679,
0.07616380602121353,
0.01270082127302885,
0.2422429919242859,
-0.03830301761627197,
-0.21080273389816284,
-0.8451895713806152,
-0.5213075280189514,
0.1500679850578308,
-0.6846044063568115,
-0.20237191021442413,
-0.9241585731506348,
-0.16227006912231445,
-0.4757746756076813,
-0.12308421730995178,
0.14574041962623596,
-0.1967840939760208,
-0.3293575048446655,
0.10949508845806122,
0.3796171247959137,
1.2275950908660889,
-0.16935046017169952,
-0.08453354984521866,
-0.7865282297134399,
0.4745686650276184,
0.3352271318435669,
0.0028948045801371336,
0.13544045388698578,
0.09378682076931,
-0.41314461827278137,
-0.42023617029190063,
-0.4451746642589569,
-0.8156744241714478,
0.24022002518177032,
0.05731785297393799,
0.656767725944519,
0.05414585769176483,
0.40655890107154846,
0.4824521541595459,
-0.39589089155197144,
1.0581024885177612,
0.22924543917179108,
-0.4080054461956024,
0.4717820882797241,
-0.5421685576438904,
0.2030114382505417,
0.7964614033699036,
0.3681822419166565,
-0.2791264057159424,
-0.5778507590293884,
-0.7416040897369385,
-1.0125820636749268,
0.7722889184951782,
0.2897922992706299,
0.042327363044023514,
0.10989651083946228,
0.06557802110910416,
0.3712169826030731,
0.2574455738067627,
-1.1555192470550537,
-0.22684071958065033,
-0.20726867020130157,
0.05139758065342903,
0.1488763839006424,
-0.3929216265678406,
-0.12856733798980713,
0.18951186537742615,
0.7757750749588013,
-0.3392096757888794,
0.154471755027771,
0.6413081884384155,
-0.04608602821826935,
-0.16776227951049805,
0.2537139654159546,
0.5957544445991516,
0.677456259727478,
-0.22237341105937958,
-0.0929340124130249,
0.030800072476267815,
-0.7191603779792786,
-0.1721286028623581,
0.09256285429000854,
-0.4489700496196747,
0.3776431679725647,
0.7206482291221619,
0.3054969012737274,
-0.0033058649860322475,
-0.4760392904281616,
0.1904338300228119,
0.08144273608922958,
-0.6148245930671692,
-0.29090094566345215,
0.15468089282512665,
0.17844536900520325,
-0.2198319137096405,
0.7920608520507812,
0.25777992606163025,
0.22063970565795898,
-0.9909628033638,
0.12075425684452057,
0.3624017834663391,
-0.5206404328346252,
0.03658418729901314,
0.3339208662509918,
0.3335525691509247,
-0.16925407946109772,
0.035261500626802444,
-0.14999361336231232,
-0.33081698417663574,
0.5532832741737366,
0.7536807060241699,
0.8107482194900513,
0.3381885290145874,
0.07183831185102463,
0.42057573795318604,
0.20994475483894348,
0.08924781531095505,
0.3089212477207184,
-0.3328121602535248,
-0.3842118978500366,
-0.2918822169303894,
-0.5382797122001648,
-0.46251171827316284,
0.20325152575969696,
-0.8954017758369446,
0.2259955108165741,
-0.20624931156635284,
-0.2013198733329773,
0.09017202258110046,
0.10765828937292099,
-0.38031405210494995,
0.2634405195713043,
-0.38018888235092163,
0.6136905550956726,
-0.7657317519187927,
0.7195076942443848,
1.0159943103790283,
-0.4362950026988983,
-0.5528009533882141,
0.4064106047153473,
-0.3713843822479248,
-0.4271591007709503,
0.6181830167770386,
0.0020475564524531364,
-0.4020496606826782,
0.10803627967834473,
-0.41420382261276245,
-0.5583113431930542,
0.9827518463134766,
-0.13319626450538635,
-0.3093818724155426,
-0.13790979981422424,
-0.13031259179115295,
0.6897011399269104,
-0.4759286046028137,
-0.013065775856375694,
0.4468907415866852,
0.46090421080589294,
0.005150249693542719,
-0.7424554824829102,
0.21364575624465942,
-0.3746728003025055,
0.03297082334756851,
-0.04830397292971611,
-0.5265529155731201,
0.7156296968460083,
-0.08788783848285675,
-0.2980864346027374,
0.3114723265171051,
0.8547974824905396,
0.5609188079833984,
0.5170367956161499,
0.5155084729194641,
0.08092140406370163,
0.22803834080696106,
0.05730276182293892,
0.8367581367492676,
-0.020667677745223045,
0.22320909798145294,
1.215131402015686,
-0.647341251373291,
0.7886474132537842,
0.6907650232315063,
-0.24557030200958252,
0.8624430298805237,
0.4168402850627899,
-0.24669724702835083,
0.39385557174682617,
0.34854769706726074,
-0.11382830888032913,
-0.020986242219805717,
-0.4614410400390625,
-0.8733372092247009,
0.24122707545757294,
-0.06665942072868347,
-0.6032500267028809,
-0.41248029470443726,
0.17529667913913727,
-0.0463724248111248,
0.6571409702301025,
-0.17354054749011993,
0.9915620684623718,
0.05160517618060112,
-1.181679129600525,
0.24973341822624207,
-0.06297052651643753,
0.6349732875823975,
-0.5109177827835083,
-0.29562848806381226,
0.050888288766145706,
-0.07923636585474014,
-0.38808733224868774,
-0.7870877385139465,
0.7731973528862,
0.12168377637863159,
-0.40825802087783813,
-0.43225669860839844,
0.9509186148643494,
-0.00014092959463596344,
-0.28094735741615295,
0.18450435996055603,
0.6011252999305725,
0.07656210660934448,
0.23263506591320038,
-0.561835765838623,
0.007187796290963888,
0.2969425618648529,
-0.4902978241443634,
0.29520848393440247,
0.5116330981254578,
-0.1829596757888794,
0.46198293566703796,
0.6935893893241882,
-0.008335008285939693,
-0.05869293212890625,
0.04853414371609688,
0.7469597458839417,
-1.0394691228866577,
-0.7447589635848999,
-0.4351974427700043,
0.07832127809524536,
-0.15354159474372864,
-0.4808174967765808,
0.8017696738243103,
0.542955756187439,
0.7420006990432739,
-0.435172975063324,
0.9914358258247375,
-0.47743380069732666,
0.8835319876670837,
-0.4054466784000397,
0.6598071455955505,
-0.4541504383087158,
-0.0765647292137146,
-0.6422624588012695,
-0.7391640543937683,
-0.20235751569271088,
0.5042230486869812,
-0.06386465579271317,
-0.029815159738063812,
1.1825246810913086,
0.4284159541130066,
0.35075411200523376,
0.27619481086730957,
0.2222786694765091,
-0.361042857170105,
0.10320389270782471,
-0.007155082654207945,
1.011521339416504,
-0.4323772192001343,
0.8693378567695618,
-0.1754610240459442,
0.22328780591487885,
-0.44296395778656006,
-1.2556028366088867,
-0.877997636795044,
-0.6932525634765625,
-0.49175459146499634,
-0.539465069770813,
-0.20818831026554108,
0.37837982177734375,
0.4429578185081482,
-0.9087672233581543,
-0.12295260280370712,
-0.5050236582756042,
0.14716893434524536,
-0.4534214437007904,
-0.29588058590888977,
0.298534095287323,
-0.3454514145851135,
-0.6156244874000549,
0.029312757775187492,
0.10125157982110977,
-0.010048513300716877,
-0.47174954414367676,
0.17991459369659424,
-0.5590015649795532,
-0.10047070682048798,
0.41420403122901917,
0.5887176990509033,
-0.4681229889392853,
-0.043727807700634,
-0.17504671216011047,
-0.4232376515865326,
-0.2045067399740219,
1.4008742570877075,
-0.78133225440979,
0.16060975193977356,
0.8006430864334106,
0.18028943240642548,
0.74476158618927,
0.01222149096429348,
0.824897289276123,
-0.5209197998046875,
0.04329976066946983,
0.5363183617591858,
0.26903778314590454,
0.2467205971479416,
-0.3448297083377838,
0.8021314740180969,
0.3985722064971924,
-0.5902521014213562,
-1.0456241369247437,
0.31258222460746765,
-0.8011430501937866,
-0.3981936275959015,
0.7016366124153137,
-0.3538408875465393,
-0.26123568415641785,
-0.7615087628364563,
-0.45780572295188904,
0.22440382838249207,
0.051351528614759445,
0.7293745279312134,
0.7079690098762512,
-0.5758119821548462,
0.15730394423007965,
-0.3506254255771637,
0.8125093579292297,
0.44406846165657043,
-0.8916545510292053,
0.048332177102565765,
0.3622322082519531,
0.13703568279743195,
0.5878188610076904,
0.812442421913147,
-0.12430423498153687,
0.32958370447158813,
0.364996999502182,
0.3779699206352234,
-0.20021578669548035,
-0.0901448056101799,
0.1499546766281128,
0.7143871784210205,
0.29770874977111816,
0.10879009962081909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11584v1
|
The Landscape of Emerging AI Agent Architectures for Reasoning, Planning, and Tool Calling: A Survey
| 2024-04-17T17:32:41 | 2024-04-17T17:32:41 |
Tula Masterman, Sandi Besen, Mason Sawtell, Alex Chao
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This survey paper examines the recent advancements in AI agent
implementations, with a focus on their ability to achieve complex goals that
require enhanced reasoning, planning, and tool execution capabilities. The
primary objectives of this work are to a) communicate the current capabilities
and limitations of existing AI agent implementations, b) share insights gained
from our observations of these systems in action, and c) suggest important
considerations for future developments in AI agent design. We achieve this by
providing overviews of single-agent and multi-agent architectures, identifying
key patterns and divergences in design choices, and evaluating their overall
impact on accomplishing a provided goal. Our contribution outlines key themes
when selecting an agentic architecture, the impact of leadership on agent
systems, agent communication styles, and key phases for planning, execution,
and reflection that enable robust AI agent systems.
|
[
-0.6595593690872192,
-0.5550907850265503,
0.6674110293388367,
0.150071918964386,
0.2552451491355896,
0.5176788568496704,
0.2197580635547638,
-0.6586035490036011,
0.25790512561798096,
0.3833326995372772,
-0.5217275619506836,
-0.40392744541168213,
-0.4462810158729553,
-0.07210932672023773,
-0.061448320746421814,
0.46184593439102173,
0.10162265598773956,
0.04876567795872688,
-0.38696905970573425,
-0.11587996035814285,
-0.8461353778839111,
-0.22867938876152039,
-0.7215393781661987,
-0.47240445017814636,
0.19663681089878082,
0.23351258039474487,
1.0933966636657715,
0.5581584572792053,
0.33022961020469666,
0.4111715257167816,
0.09531215578317642,
0.4451691210269928,
0.19330023229122162,
0.3947749137878418,
0.044950224459171295,
-0.3598572611808777,
-1.1517565250396729,
0.3857632577419281,
0.5797760486602783,
0.4604249894618988,
0.06182248890399933,
0.017030658200383186,
-0.2893890142440796,
0.11256325989961624,
-0.6372578740119934,
0.5137084722518921,
-0.25435471534729004,
0.05164562538266182,
-0.02443312108516693,
-0.1192263662815094,
-0.4811434745788574,
-0.11628566682338715,
0.4833783209323883,
-0.37166598439216614,
-0.36359283328056335,
-0.09386011958122253,
0.3294888436794281,
0.3290681838989258,
-0.5300226211547852,
-0.5096216201782227,
-0.9292349815368652,
0.7039263844490051,
-0.28049567341804504,
0.19894802570343018,
0.0868188887834549,
0.7695797681808472,
-0.13972464203834534,
-0.7471249103546143,
0.010290003381669521,
-0.1629934012889862,
0.005002445541322231,
0.16942429542541504,
-0.4197649657726288,
0.21969734132289886,
-0.10247164964675903,
-0.02343524992465973,
-0.34356486797332764,
0.13358251750469208,
-0.04419414699077606,
-0.021773118525743484,
0.8228302597999573,
0.5701341032981873,
0.30758655071258545,
0.3898873031139374,
-0.20400750637054443,
-0.13005544245243073,
-0.4659867584705353,
0.2386685460805893,
0.2892429232597351,
0.28674638271331787,
-0.076764777302742,
0.2961525022983551,
-0.25038060545921326,
0.49123725295066833,
-0.2780745029449463,
0.07472246140241623,
0.12662997841835022,
-0.31480780243873596,
0.014206326566636562,
-0.03999723866581917,
0.21025952696800232,
0.18578726053237915,
-0.06674110144376755,
-0.33181852102279663,
-0.3052753806114197,
-0.2831833064556122,
0.6499244570732117,
-0.4088048040866852,
0.009330318309366703,
0.4770842492580414,
-0.5956206321716309,
-0.22575931251049042,
0.18452098965644836,
-0.5909451246261597,
-0.7880845665931702,
-0.3167186975479126,
0.14595302939414978,
-0.07589911669492722,
-0.5725400447845459,
-0.1760261207818985,
-0.6238024830818176,
0.9535982608795166,
0.7129971385002136,
-0.16566836833953857,
0.34698671102523804,
0.7552279233932495,
0.6795403957366943,
-0.10002876073122025,
-0.5160540342330933,
-0.43698573112487793,
0.06958907097578049,
-0.5622207522392273,
1.0099201202392578,
-0.7173411250114441,
-0.559237003326416,
0.20667847990989685,
-0.26098066568374634,
0.016432330012321472,
-0.5364764928817749,
0.3555912375450134,
-0.5327346920967102,
-0.2751181721687317,
-0.04250245913863182,
-0.034050147980451584,
-0.2968387007713318,
0.5213740468025208,
-0.6952428221702576,
0.447282612323761,
0.012741385027766228,
-0.1452428251504898,
0.435280978679657,
-1.1229591369628906,
-0.5643274784088135,
0.33815857768058777,
-0.5169907808303833,
-0.21907773613929749,
-0.02889220602810383,
0.06702005863189697,
0.40346652269363403,
-0.3286157548427582,
-0.19868816435337067,
-0.0974058210849762,
-0.2716321051120758,
-0.018082818016409874,
-0.2425231784582138,
0.8698316216468811,
0.4290649890899658,
-0.4911130368709564,
0.5687443017959595,
-0.4412291646003723,
0.4067888557910919,
0.1190592423081398,
-0.06427886337041855,
0.09834947437047958,
0.44219592213630676,
-0.2225114107131958,
0.09837982803583145,
0.45345818996429443,
-0.11633602529764175,
0.4283653199672699,
0.0470694936811924,
0.19771979749202728,
0.8510370850563049,
-0.08898036926984787,
0.7494693398475647,
-0.5090703964233398,
0.8633173108100891,
-0.15882350504398346,
0.5763658881187439,
-0.07283780723810196,
-0.5893183946609497,
-0.3599604368209839,
-0.3183140754699707,
-0.35603222250938416,
0.5067806243896484,
-0.4406762421131134,
0.3272116780281067,
-0.07430746406316757,
-0.8266946077346802,
-0.32312577962875366,
-0.3120988607406616,
0.12983520328998566,
-0.2514326274394989,
0.09221219271421432,
-0.1814953088760376,
-0.2998432517051697,
-0.8189071416854858,
-0.17707359790802002,
-0.4704270660877228,
0.24585120379924774,
0.4989628791809082,
0.3039901852607727,
-0.21012942492961884,
0.8910366892814636,
-0.30842989683151245,
0.08473626524209976,
-0.6038312315940857,
-0.054659970104694366,
-0.05256006866693497,
0.29745572805404663,
0.7645663022994995,
-0.9819753170013428,
-0.2826291620731354,
0.0706925243139267,
-0.6723042726516724,
0.29196539521217346,
-0.21757586300373077,
-0.007180771324783564,
-0.2896094024181366,
0.28286293148994446,
-0.9248539209365845,
0.6704511046409607,
-0.028228437528014183,
-0.37661853432655334,
0.5500072240829468,
-0.005556243006139994,
0.06352516263723373,
-0.8149721622467041,
0.03941017761826515,
-0.43029549717903137,
0.10329999029636383,
-0.945465087890625,
0.2668997049331665,
-0.48568156361579895,
0.0675789937376976,
-0.3985213339328766,
0.7423442006111145,
-0.8486654162406921,
-0.4219987988471985,
-0.5083680748939514,
-0.14388038218021393,
-0.20456768572330475,
0.10953999310731888,
-0.08946052193641663,
0.7905566692352295,
0.7226027250289917,
-0.6416217684745789,
0.48544034361839294,
0.4822111129760742,
-0.050050992518663406,
0.44369322061538696,
-0.698964536190033,
0.3054369390010834,
-0.15155312418937683,
0.4281003177165985,
-0.6178249716758728,
-0.14547528326511383,
0.46591776609420776,
-0.5221612453460693,
0.05695270374417305,
0.1469849944114685,
-0.03129252791404724,
-0.21098202466964722,
-0.33113396167755127,
0.5281557440757751,
0.254236102104187,
-0.24958176910877228,
1.2804259061813354,
0.5515057444572449,
0.06206316500902176,
-0.7188989520072937,
-0.35178878903388977,
0.23036694526672363,
-0.025270726531744003,
-0.4724719226360321,
-0.08870738744735718,
0.053395096212625504,
-0.8242230415344238,
-0.02293466404080391,
0.07507820427417755,
0.06938524544239044,
0.29394322633743286,
0.4573104977607727,
0.044636886566877365,
-0.10670554637908936,
-0.1882287859916687,
-0.09754466265439987,
-0.10916459560394287,
0.22584876418113708,
-0.06825433671474457,
0.6238212585449219,
-0.3145451843738556,
-0.3841691315174103,
-0.28442901372909546,
0.7437896728515625,
0.8956378698348999,
-0.7866416573524475,
0.6409475207328796,
0.3950927257537842,
-0.33684220910072327,
-0.4521477222442627,
-0.17147569358348846,
-0.05832699313759804,
-0.4333784282207489,
0.29055193066596985,
-0.6892940998077393,
-0.2153514325618744,
0.684120774269104,
-0.35987383127212524,
0.8030204176902771,
0.4224247336387634,
0.6614229083061218,
0.016403429210186005,
1.2780802249908447,
0.5362831950187683,
-0.07030871510505676,
0.5570928454399109,
-0.5104133486747742,
0.22861917316913605,
-0.5958077311515808,
-0.3116990923881531,
-0.5768636465072632,
-0.24019412696361542,
-0.7078741788864136,
-0.3169613480567932,
0.437048077583313,
-0.5911052823066711,
-0.18659824132919312,
0.14551220834255219,
-0.5945047736167908,
0.1446252018213272,
0.761151909828186,
-0.36096933484077454,
0.06101851910352707,
-0.5529999136924744,
0.35295021533966064,
0.7673088908195496,
-0.5982142686843872,
-0.7732910513877869,
0.8655238747596741,
0.3608939051628113,
0.5446775555610657,
0.29417884349823,
0.38437435030937195,
0.674543023109436,
0.07610698789358139,
-0.6729902625083923,
0.5301404595375061,
0.4608846604824066,
-0.9330799579620361,
-0.5945264101028442,
0.27599963545799255,
-0.9913994669914246,
0.36721324920654297,
0.04737616330385208,
-0.5145934224128723,
0.36057108640670776,
-0.21714124083518982,
-0.28735846281051636,
0.17549797892570496,
-0.6287559866905212,
0.6785743236541748,
-0.30285266041755676,
0.19444411993026733,
-0.4370131194591522,
-0.8899009227752686,
-0.17866265773773193,
0.6398398280143738,
-0.15436185896396637,
-0.19359365105628967,
-0.20489540696144104,
0.24446910619735718,
-0.18707126379013062,
0.7471259236335754,
-0.41659268736839294,
0.10689742118120193,
0.7445678114891052,
-0.42034339904785156,
0.7165005207061768,
-0.21740968525409698,
-0.3222154378890991,
-0.1512882262468338,
0.07744155824184418,
-0.6086697578430176,
-0.46857553720474243,
0.13218466937541962,
-1.1087604761123657,
-0.7944674491882324,
-0.557127833366394,
-0.48766863346099854,
-0.289221853017807,
0.2686348855495453,
-0.019641319289803505,
0.5098280310630798,
-0.6271557807922363,
-0.07116973400115967,
0.13124220073223114,
0.15683016180992126,
0.6686510443687439,
0.05243350937962532,
0.16604432463645935,
-0.16647346317768097,
0.6355262398719788,
0.18718013167381287,
0.20668724179267883,
0.060891181230545044,
-0.30278152227401733,
-0.24521248042583466,
-0.8964463472366333,
-0.5950022339820862,
-0.27386802434921265,
-0.6722813844680786,
-0.06581419706344604,
-0.46722009778022766,
-0.41112643480300903,
-0.7071434855461121,
-0.35012683272361755,
-0.5431049466133118,
-0.10512249916791916,
-0.10875625908374786,
0.08289886265993118,
-0.05803592503070831,
1.334283709526062,
0.15207013487815857,
0.43396055698394775,
-0.265256404876709,
-0.24568365514278412,
0.17830519378185272,
0.07939789444208145,
0.21726323664188385,
0.20941804349422455,
-0.3246876299381256,
-0.09250521659851074,
-0.392335444688797,
-0.8537606000900269,
0.041999805718660355,
-0.027428269386291504,
1.2763047218322754,
0.6110832691192627,
0.15114475786685944,
0.24784748256206512,
-0.1910751610994339,
0.7628176808357239,
-0.504248857498169,
-0.3274911046028137,
0.6225718855857849,
-0.2504095733165741,
0.4158796966075897,
0.45740455389022827,
0.11689573526382446,
-0.19102442264556885,
-0.27415135502815247,
-0.7318804860115051,
-0.4559057652950287,
0.6152622103691101,
0.10848052054643631,
0.03479388356208801,
0.34346815943717957,
0.24745076894760132,
0.05314517021179199,
0.32173165678977966,
0.08040322363376617,
-0.42836707830429077,
-0.005764744244515896,
0.29635605216026306,
-0.09797476977109909,
0.24870523810386658,
-0.38853874802589417,
-0.05445798113942146,
0.4164077937602997,
-0.3504805266857147,
0.6623951196670532,
-0.12705489993095398,
0.2562865614891052,
0.2357836365699768,
0.30493393540382385,
0.5371027588844299,
0.8588517904281616,
-0.01184729766100645,
0.09868061542510986,
0.15728750824928284,
-0.49054738879203796,
0.16002506017684937,
0.19276581704616547,
-0.16917763650417328,
-0.19210216403007507,
0.5128540396690369,
0.607894778251648,
-0.6243581771850586,
-0.5345977544784546,
0.34862199425697327,
-0.027763841673731804,
-0.03791480511426926,
-0.554154634475708,
0.23097774386405945,
-0.1883319467306137,
0.8816469311714172,
0.4709799289703369,
0.2490614801645279,
0.30250999331474304,
-0.9466322064399719,
0.03682040050625801,
0.854259192943573,
-0.27602940797805786,
-0.42000725865364075,
0.4274803102016449,
0.330545574426651,
-0.671809196472168,
0.5923288464546204,
-0.3308725655078888,
-0.37529250979423523,
0.8979852795600891,
0.18215203285217285,
1.367079496383667,
-0.1726360023021698,
0.37351542711257935,
-0.3423492908477783,
0.42999497056007385,
0.38761985301971436,
0.45416688919067383,
-0.2904752790927887,
-0.7806680798530579,
0.1514216810464859,
-0.2735673189163208,
-0.7441563010215759,
-0.31110283732414246,
-0.3150365650653839,
-0.011134577915072441,
-0.5037041902542114,
-0.4287421703338623,
0.02655709907412529,
0.3299221098423004,
-0.7011880874633789,
0.06210068613290787,
-0.040896233171224594,
0.9113496541976929,
-0.34377172589302063,
0.5466508269309998,
1.3818678855895996,
-0.32005244493484497,
-0.6679335236549377,
0.04366650804877281,
0.3125284016132355,
-0.8716703653335571,
-0.05791561305522919,
-0.07115180790424347,
-0.6080324053764343,
-0.08992522954940796,
-0.4230833947658539,
-0.6996480226516724,
1.498041033744812,
-0.01617239974439144,
0.41215336322784424,
-0.44385361671447754,
0.1950855702161789,
0.46468299627304077,
-0.7981458902359009,
0.5915589332580566,
0.598599374294281,
0.6638289093971252,
0.02082821913063526,
-0.7362362742424011,
-0.20202985405921936,
-0.4925774931907654,
-0.32413268089294434,
0.13920822739601135,
-1.0625863075256348,
0.678505539894104,
-0.18288898468017578,
-0.27631404995918274,
0.244727224111557,
0.6395631432533264,
0.18892499804496765,
0.6353490948677063,
0.6024104952812195,
-0.02112475596368313,
0.4649854898452759,
-0.024648386985063553,
0.8153349757194519,
-0.2914353013038635,
-0.4659084379673004,
0.8303560018539429,
-0.08160079270601273,
0.4874630570411682,
0.18502289056777954,
-0.04502653330564499,
0.37994062900543213,
0.6373264789581299,
0.08398015797138214,
0.2462248057126999,
-0.1516420543193817,
-0.3760083019733429,
-0.2998795807361603,
-0.5676807761192322,
-0.18518054485321045,
1.0528136491775513,
0.1938903033733368,
0.014958357438445091,
-0.20332038402557373,
-0.05127809941768646,
-0.20467934012413025,
-0.2800109088420868,
-0.2959974706172943,
0.7675068974494934,
-0.22806131839752197,
-0.6775857210159302,
-0.21705171465873718,
-0.25601422786712646,
0.11171805113554001,
-0.38516637682914734,
-0.3904363512992859,
0.005642673932015896,
0.2740999460220337,
-0.06247778981924057,
-0.8235016465187073,
0.14587754011154175,
-0.4087337851524353,
0.022612253203988075,
-0.438478946685791,
0.7696491479873657,
0.19635961949825287,
0.1917615383863449,
0.28255495429039,
1.161102294921875,
0.18631868064403534,
-0.09986967593431473,
-0.7189618349075317,
0.19977466762065887,
-0.46296563744544983,
-0.2844782769680023,
-0.0005101839196868241,
0.2683461606502533,
-0.2784465551376343,
0.9002084136009216,
0.16291864216327667,
0.07621286809444427,
0.024217087775468826,
-0.16705241799354553,
0.8347840309143066,
-0.607475996017456,
-0.5779163837432861,
-0.2835279107093811,
0.5695285201072693,
-0.23445619642734528,
-0.5257310271263123,
0.5686326026916504,
0.5283182263374329,
0.5274648666381836,
0.27847424149513245,
0.7828317284584045,
-0.2920815348625183,
0.07921519130468369,
0.04158126935362816,
0.7198165059089661,
-0.5989440679550171,
0.12137141823768616,
-0.10115981847047806,
-0.6727955937385559,
-0.05994488298892975,
0.17324267327785492,
-0.2356298267841339,
0.37486061453819275,
0.09974531084299088,
0.5213608145713806,
0.4006984531879425,
0.19878660142421722,
0.2630070447921753,
-0.08230963349342346,
0.7821575999259949,
0.12571261823177338,
1.3352327346801758,
-0.13308840990066528,
0.37433111667633057,
0.10360248386859894,
-0.25305861234664917,
-0.24838928878307343,
-0.14572373032569885,
-0.6615283489227295,
-0.7211176156997681,
-0.09302407503128052,
0.07552605122327805,
0.1827906221151352,
0.8401033282279968,
0.7879424095153809,
-0.5485730171203613,
-0.3771785497665405,
-0.0005833522300235927,
0.4363936483860016,
-0.5723270177841187,
-0.13680708408355713,
0.14995156228542328,
-0.2692663073539734,
-0.7092071771621704,
0.49074587225914,
0.4360731542110443,
-0.040186379104852676,
-0.5111232399940491,
-0.38336214423179626,
-0.30889439582824707,
0.3217093348503113,
0.5970263481140137,
0.49747180938720703,
-0.6977884769439697,
-0.4041443169116974,
0.2259172946214676,
-0.11321793496608734,
0.14513535797595978,
0.8230010867118835,
-0.4579445719718933,
0.3906865119934082,
0.3768494129180908,
0.676367461681366,
0.06028760224580765,
-0.015036892145872116,
0.7085685133934021,
-0.2343122959136963,
-0.012699821032583714,
0.5198583006858826,
-0.06649206578731537,
-0.2006198763847351,
-0.34601128101348877,
0.548646092414856,
-0.18258588016033173,
-0.6269878149032593,
-0.6650641560554504,
0.3406814634799957,
-0.9085043668746948,
-0.4099988043308258,
0.606564462184906,
0.045410800725221634,
0.04806026071310043,
-0.47257304191589355,
-0.38747504353523254,
0.16719891130924225,
-0.44511905312538147,
0.3728547692298889,
0.6308320760726929,
-0.9699738621711731,
-0.3287787139415741,
-0.39418500661849976,
0.5494658350944519,
0.1319519728422165,
-0.9893274903297424,
-0.059022072702646255,
0.6575909852981567,
-0.42826342582702637,
0.26089000701904297,
0.6266992092132568,
0.04793277010321617,
0.593365490436554,
0.6219335198402405,
-0.008208218030631542,
0.07934414595365524,
-0.8220809698104858,
-0.0015727714635431767,
0.46420207619667053,
0.5576418042182922,
-0.4378301501274109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11553v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11553v2
|
Quantifying Multilingual Performance of Large Language Models Across Languages
| 2024-04-17T16:53:16 | 2024-06-16T08:24:32 |
Zihao Li, Yucheng Shi, Zirui Liu, Fan Yang, Ali Payani, Ninghao Liu, Mengnan Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The development of Large Language Models (LLMs) relies on extensive text
corpora, which are often unevenly distributed across languages. This imbalance
results in LLMs performing significantly better on high-resource languages like
English, German, and French, while their capabilities in low-resource languages
remain inadequate. Currently, there is a lack of quantitative methods to
evaluate the performance of LLMs in these low-resource languages. To address
this gap, we propose the Language Ranker, an intrinsic metric designed to
benchmark and rank languages based on LLM performance using internal
representations. By comparing the LLM's internal representation of various
languages against a baseline derived from English, we can assess the model's
multilingual capabilities in a robust and language-agnostic manner. Our
analysis reveals that high-resource languages exhibit higher similarity scores
with English, demonstrating superior performance, while low-resource languages
show lower similarity scores, underscoring the effectiveness of our metric in
assessing language-specific capabilities. Besides, the experiments show that
there is a strong correlation between the LLM's performance in different
languages and the proportion of those languages in its pre-training corpus.
These insights underscore the efficacy of the Language Ranker as a tool for
evaluating LLM performance across different languages, particularly those with
limited resources.
|
[
-0.38233107328414917,
-0.35266342759132385,
0.5055909156799316,
0.3989669680595398,
-0.11804211884737015,
0.5236143469810486,
-0.7074925899505615,
-0.5077425837516785,
0.1486394703388214,
0.08052036911249161,
0.062454525381326675,
-0.3433187007904053,
-0.8183454871177673,
0.35049498081207275,
-0.08091896027326584,
0.7023178339004517,
-0.08482865989208221,
0.4501466453075409,
-0.4613836705684662,
-0.4853774607181549,
-0.3899592459201813,
-0.8364691734313965,
-0.5120259523391724,
-0.5203632712364197,
0.672924280166626,
0.08514198660850525,
0.5631967782974243,
0.4255971908569336,
0.741058349609375,
0.3944328725337982,
-0.22357936203479767,
-0.006139247212558985,
-0.6071611642837524,
0.05975882336497307,
-0.19084767997264862,
-0.43177512288093567,
-0.45860767364501953,
-0.16712957620620728,
1.2669403553009033,
0.7483636140823364,
0.1812838912010193,
0.3331918716430664,
0.2668914496898651,
0.34437263011932373,
-0.6419209837913513,
0.24958686530590057,
-0.5497158765792847,
-0.15665015578269958,
-0.34671199321746826,
-0.17295020818710327,
-0.3421476483345032,
-0.279318630695343,
-0.23538647592067719,
-0.29634419083595276,
-0.07554440200328827,
0.053041696548461914,
0.664688766002655,
0.11619111150503159,
-0.3591157793998718,
-0.05543066933751106,
-0.6530455350875854,
1.0016835927963257,
-0.7354039549827576,
0.6471104025840759,
0.16715791821479797,
0.14156898856163025,
0.3291020691394806,
-0.23798321187496185,
-0.35351336002349854,
-0.5652890205383301,
-0.28730863332748413,
0.004861883353441954,
-0.059476274996995926,
-0.2288532853126526,
0.1884101778268814,
0.5750290751457214,
-0.7066882252693176,
0.5530549883842468,
-0.2489517331123352,
-0.20530638098716736,
0.5224725008010864,
0.0503864586353302,
0.3409692347049713,
0.10598492622375488,
-0.04789098724722862,
-0.19881264865398407,
-0.6685777902603149,
0.20738692581653595,
0.428488165140152,
0.41897451877593994,
-0.1585986465215683,
0.6368269324302673,
0.137594535946846,
0.48428475856781006,
-0.34658074378967285,
-0.4714832901954651,
0.36505749821662903,
-0.2811739146709442,
0.12327029556035995,
0.020943494513630867,
0.9091770648956299,
0.21938548982143402,
0.20520614087581635,
-0.2503034770488739,
-0.42072629928588867,
0.0478239431977272,
-0.058930691331624985,
-0.9511155486106873,
0.026755813509225845,
-0.123985156416893,
-0.3878746032714844,
0.07670250535011292,
-0.15549474954605103,
-0.5032340288162231,
-0.2666458487510681,
-0.0962020605802536,
0.3522495925426483,
-0.3125634789466858,
-0.4344726800918579,
-0.3372194468975067,
0.1401270627975464,
0.10052480548620224,
0.054786600172519684,
-0.7675661444664001,
0.25735893845558167,
0.6848693490028381,
1.0144397020339966,
-0.49663975834846497,
-0.4901454448699951,
-0.5292569994926453,
0.14554834365844727,
-0.4439902603626251,
0.6985359787940979,
-0.7176694273948669,
-0.3382619321346283,
0.1474010944366455,
0.050147250294685364,
-0.0867546796798706,
-0.7254765033721924,
0.3769751191139221,
-0.5061805844306946,
-0.031994953751564026,
-0.18598894774913788,
-0.6019726395606995,
0.07269854098558426,
0.4165707230567932,
-0.8157527446746826,
1.2319486141204834,
0.043969497084617615,
-0.5302737355232239,
0.41544854640960693,
-0.3459322154521942,
-0.3462265133857727,
0.2053518295288086,
-0.26077190041542053,
-0.20178374648094177,
0.2710365653038025,
0.0386238768696785,
0.3902212977409363,
-0.511240541934967,
0.12055141478776932,
-0.24597911536693573,
-0.5970395803451538,
0.31019023060798645,
-0.5078968405723572,
0.2990676462650299,
0.0007443959475494921,
-0.06182276830077171,
0.1276126354932785,
-0.7123996615409851,
0.17951901257038116,
0.2241915911436081,
-0.5737174153327942,
-0.4907649755477905,
-0.16689862310886383,
0.2573573589324951,
0.24154053628444672,
0.6136057376861572,
-0.5695991516113281,
0.058556921780109406,
-0.3647104799747467,
0.3022719621658325,
0.665409505367279,
-0.35224711894989014,
0.4734000265598297,
-0.24156345427036285,
0.6843338012695312,
-0.15566480159759521,
-0.1489882618188858,
-0.15702909231185913,
-0.37771978974342346,
-0.7314621210098267,
-0.40832531452178955,
0.4181302785873413,
0.5630797147750854,
-0.2645902633666992,
0.24067945778369904,
-0.6773571372032166,
-0.4764145314693451,
-0.8028125166893005,
0.3953046500682831,
0.6132172346115112,
-0.1715414971113205,
0.3115362823009491,
-0.37776893377304077,
-0.06397037208080292,
-1.1187931299209595,
-0.23945552110671997,
-0.33406248688697815,
-0.048175662755966187,
0.14268597960472107,
0.3381945788860321,
0.009659427218139172,
0.38293275237083435,
-0.17538979649543762,
-0.1045432984828949,
-0.44109678268432617,
0.0466349720954895,
0.21164166927337646,
0.3444960117340088,
0.6291921138763428,
-0.5807172060012817,
-0.6269333362579346,
0.3658633828163147,
-0.7173171043395996,
-0.18007908761501312,
0.25468090176582336,
0.01637343131005764,
0.4554292559623718,
0.4549550712108612,
-0.16183046996593475,
-0.0767403319478035,
0.9578424692153931,
-0.044784847646951675,
0.5311574339866638,
-0.43226557970046997,
0.32512640953063965,
-0.7939729690551758,
0.25749725103378296,
-0.033504024147987366,
-0.05161774531006813,
-0.3181067407131195,
0.25129565596580505,
0.28314903378486633,
-0.08145907521247864,
-0.4262617230415344,
0.8790861368179321,
-0.4326479732990265,
-0.23667187988758087,
-0.030825907364487648,
0.17211180925369263,
-0.12241797149181366,
0.34456080198287964,
0.052144743502140045,
1.0206162929534912,
0.46893227100372314,
-0.36496874690055847,
0.09764610230922699,
-0.1043279618024826,
-0.5393782258033752,
0.5849320888519287,
-0.6752178072929382,
-0.11376385390758514,
-0.11022119224071503,
-0.20060065388679504,
-0.9031767249107361,
0.006910074967890978,
-0.41591012477874756,
-0.18976041674613953,
0.4933384954929352,
-0.2987827658653259,
-0.7300935983657837,
-0.24571843445301056,
-0.14236781001091003,
0.6250817775726318,
0.2892313301563263,
-0.34494084119796753,
0.5337182283401489,
0.4338206648826599,
-0.42959585785865784,
-0.5123889446258545,
-0.6228324770927429,
0.04856422170996666,
-0.30029845237731934,
-0.5898376703262329,
0.32569512724876404,
-0.25323325395584106,
-0.4552883803844452,
-0.12425481528043747,
0.01870277337729931,
-0.09643711149692535,
0.11075440794229507,
0.058918025344610214,
0.20469880104064941,
-0.370451956987381,
0.25800833106040955,
-0.27871397137641907,
-0.14033564925193787,
0.0006904983893036842,
-0.09730858355760574,
0.6917385458946228,
-0.35349950194358826,
-0.6070725321769714,
-0.05611128732562065,
0.3420412838459015,
0.6718277335166931,
-0.6391228437423706,
0.9881622791290283,
0.5574067831039429,
-0.21918721497058868,
-0.04401916265487671,
-0.7049857378005981,
0.0716579258441925,
-0.42908719182014465,
0.4826904833316803,
-0.5371982455253601,
-0.9219185709953308,
0.8012382984161377,
0.00308164581656456,
0.02036432735621929,
0.40399956703186035,
0.6877567768096924,
0.20654402673244476,
1.0938783884048462,
0.7977617979049683,
-0.35371530055999756,
0.44645142555236816,
-0.16638793051242828,
0.3752710819244385,
-0.6524599194526672,
-0.26432004570961,
-0.4760395288467407,
-0.27038058638572693,
-0.8652068376541138,
-0.5050964951515198,
0.5995375514030457,
0.290910929441452,
-0.2539905905723572,
0.2499581277370453,
-0.20422086119651794,
0.5213708877563477,
0.4319043755531311,
-0.46489039063453674,
0.519309401512146,
0.05785708874464035,
-0.32467010617256165,
-0.23045270144939423,
-0.5992270112037659,
-0.8322494626045227,
0.8819299340248108,
0.4060468375682831,
0.6189135909080505,
0.34832659363746643,
0.6425527334213257,
-0.01142452098429203,
0.37177592515945435,
-0.7448678612709045,
0.38037556409835815,
-0.35775336623191833,
-0.3989238739013672,
-0.31529828906059265,
-0.6381572484970093,
-0.7460596561431885,
0.6821847558021545,
-0.05323368310928345,
-0.5769771337509155,
-0.2504332363605499,
-0.13042040169239044,
-0.06831413507461548,
0.3423222005367279,
-0.6454322338104248,
1.039992332458496,
-0.6047930121421814,
-0.4897085428237915,
-0.4275818169116974,
-0.036668647080659866,
0.07960474491119385,
-0.3829895257949829,
0.45927688479423523,
-0.2866363525390625,
-0.22688977420330048,
0.7045336365699768,
-0.05228831246495247,
0.43287065625190735,
0.15510722994804382,
-0.37930700182914734,
-0.18205055594444275,
0.1341506838798523,
0.2441561371088028,
0.11742648482322693,
-0.4295476973056793,
0.4729025959968567,
0.006692464463412762,
-0.5766391158103943,
-0.3874971568584442,
1.060184359550476,
-0.8490462303161621,
-0.3766685426235199,
-0.36517253518104553,
-0.43488529324531555,
-0.322797954082489,
0.19384846091270447,
0.2127038687467575,
0.3429418206214905,
-0.46988463401794434,
0.12398698180913925,
0.29061365127563477,
-0.46690863370895386,
0.5806998610496521,
0.8389652967453003,
-0.2921953797340393,
-0.18626639246940613,
1.0744216442108154,
0.32723402976989746,
0.3624988794326782,
0.6866182088851929,
0.10698975622653961,
-0.316775918006897,
-0.5425522327423096,
-0.5072193741798401,
0.3976312279701233,
-0.71739661693573,
-0.058573804795742035,
-0.5682466626167297,
-0.18139220774173737,
-0.05992940068244934,
-0.17200513184070587,
-0.453605592250824,
-0.2155674695968628,
0.23409372568130493,
0.021210048347711563,
0.11298105120658875,
0.8786193132400513,
0.13197994232177734,
0.16135962307453156,
-0.715298056602478,
0.01531242486089468,
0.20520570874214172,
0.6263258457183838,
0.10336723923683167,
-0.5727165341377258,
-0.6095550060272217,
-0.1252852827310562,
-0.2092352956533432,
-0.40632376074790955,
0.3782196640968323,
0.26868224143981934,
0.8972181081771851,
0.15049341320991516,
-0.2603377103805542,
0.6286106705665588,
-0.5981032252311707,
0.8168296217918396,
0.08395931869745255,
-0.9146980047225952,
0.21048809587955475,
-0.1890503466129303,
0.40002068877220154,
0.44818422198295593,
0.43654555082321167,
-0.5720197558403015,
-0.8358282446861267,
-0.17387156188488007,
-0.9647542834281921,
0.6702961921691895,
0.06434935331344604,
0.16938923299312592,
-0.07852642238140106,
-0.1527506560087204,
0.028787951916456223,
0.16946019232273102,
-0.9827452898025513,
-0.3289428651332855,
0.1107022613286972,
-0.015562033280730247,
-0.5780564546585083,
-0.23642978072166443,
0.06536313891410828,
-0.1385354995727539,
0.605059802532196,
-0.18690693378448486,
0.1150859147310257,
-0.34537479281425476,
-0.5092375874519348,
-0.12887193262577057,
0.43600550293922424,
0.2847100794315338,
0.9654518961906433,
-0.13550052046775818,
0.34258896112442017,
0.4357491731643677,
-0.3139383792877197,
0.25879886746406555,
0.13084229826927185,
0.13849331438541412,
-0.06414229422807693,
0.8367924094200134,
0.5962826013565063,
0.4431341886520386,
-0.9486539363861084,
0.4688853621482849,
-0.004472658038139343,
0.34418803453445435,
-0.2359253615140915,
-0.16888076066970825,
0.30469462275505066,
0.13787232339382172,
0.3135990798473358,
-0.24819260835647583,
-0.20951661467552185,
-0.5483149886131287,
-0.03201646730303764,
0.3905147314071655,
-0.318968802690506,
-0.31980234384536743,
0.398331880569458,
0.0668262168765068,
-0.17502939701080322,
0.4298516809940338,
-0.28173667192459106,
-0.619939923286438,
0.5708329677581787,
0.48270711302757263,
0.44324612617492676,
-0.3429408669471741,
0.00818354357033968,
0.47783511877059937,
0.48339712619781494,
-0.13402405381202698,
0.146650493144989,
0.24542135000228882,
-0.6067916750907898,
-0.7030404806137085,
-0.9234587550163269,
-0.2926689088344574,
0.2973482310771942,
-0.5940847396850586,
0.1276499629020691,
-0.1648750752210617,
-0.09012220054864883,
0.10171487927436829,
0.19731073081493378,
-0.8974913954734802,
-0.20377691090106964,
0.37740638852119446,
0.7670978307723999,
-0.774585485458374,
0.8028498291969299,
0.9241112470626831,
-0.4809883236885071,
-0.4922657608985901,
-0.03274126723408699,
-0.10055097192525864,
-0.8615570664405823,
0.8910341262817383,
0.2510623633861542,
-0.27409520745277405,
-0.23201677203178406,
0.17730480432510376,
-0.943390429019928,
0.8267787098884583,
0.6814241409301758,
-0.6529784202575684,
0.2800777852535248,
0.45084401965141296,
0.7591977119445801,
-0.28065890073776245,
0.6727657914161682,
0.33440274000167847,
0.5855394601821899,
-0.37778595089912415,
-1.379502773284912,
-0.1826154589653015,
-0.34039539098739624,
0.20852312445640564,
0.3776344954967499,
-0.8062839508056641,
0.8347538113594055,
0.05182614177465439,
-0.1868760585784912,
0.029481561854481697,
0.39708584547042847,
0.18145689368247986,
-0.041754428297281265,
0.29301783442497253,
0.4626820385456085,
0.7615640163421631,
-0.06773702800273895,
1.066417932510376,
-0.7746350169181824,
0.24526019394397736,
0.8703579306602478,
-0.4866017997264862,
1.1551631689071655,
0.2676320970058441,
-0.2741336226463318,
0.3402631878852844,
0.31855008006095886,
0.12804871797561646,
0.24247264862060547,
0.3031843602657318,
-0.3616132140159607,
-0.4580947160720825,
-0.3617554306983948,
-0.388236939907074,
0.5122568011283875,
0.14495518803596497,
-0.2548356354236603,
-0.18148428201675415,
0.07375368475914001,
-0.06955112516880035,
0.29578542709350586,
-0.41623246669769287,
0.8304242491722107,
0.051512230187654495,
-0.6018767356872559,
0.8373525142669678,
0.16174453496932983,
0.9185606837272644,
-0.6489658355712891,
0.0924161821603775,
-0.3703348934650421,
0.2776029706001282,
0.10825268179178238,
-0.9316630363464355,
0.060826197266578674,
0.22722738981246948,
-0.3074406385421753,
-0.4148441553115845,
0.18135417997837067,
-0.6278364062309265,
-0.7865028977394104,
0.9146854877471924,
0.753471851348877,
0.2606619894504547,
0.026671377941966057,
-0.4437551200389862,
0.3826237916946411,
-0.4647817313671112,
-0.02168952114880085,
0.6605121493339539,
0.49506086111068726,
-0.18940390646457672,
0.8319715857505798,
0.40553560853004456,
0.283279150724411,
-0.027609530836343765,
0.3581893742084503,
0.6081722378730774,
-0.448588103055954,
-0.37822097539901733,
-0.9169785380363464,
0.17266952991485596,
-0.061452288180589676,
-0.3533141314983368,
0.9566907286643982,
0.9415155053138733,
1.2017275094985962,
0.03554195538163185,
0.6934970617294312,
0.19231180846691132,
0.4025805592536926,
-0.3098323941230774,
0.7451766133308411,
-0.8049317598342896,
0.32475554943084717,
-0.21572013199329376,
-1.2628597021102905,
-0.02942768670618534,
0.5989144444465637,
-0.3099178373813629,
0.04481261596083641,
0.6742146611213684,
0.7733401656150818,
-0.1595488339662552,
-0.5004109740257263,
0.5551125407218933,
0.19493193924427032,
0.15230633318424225,
0.419929176568985,
0.9338509440422058,
-0.06331208348274231,
0.6054604053497314,
-0.1983245611190796,
-0.20595994591712952,
-0.07217256724834442,
-0.8511571288108826,
-0.9224203824996948,
-0.47305142879486084,
-0.05788545310497284,
-0.026629121974110603,
-0.09945844858884811,
0.9118705987930298,
0.7751927971839905,
-0.9141274690628052,
-0.7331575751304626,
0.5484495162963867,
0.17010700702667236,
-0.24451084434986115,
-0.1929970234632492,
0.22303804755210876,
-0.41879239678382874,
-0.8762437105178833,
0.5328790545463562,
0.2771759629249573,
-0.18708497285842896,
-0.5660346746444702,
-0.29474562406539917,
-0.013715872541069984,
-0.14492596685886383,
0.8205413818359375,
-0.0583532452583313,
-0.7928502559661865,
0.028889141976833344,
0.005863555707037449,
-0.3106641173362732,
-0.01610708050429821,
0.868134081363678,
-0.5271291136741638,
0.2945922613143921,
0.4529081881046295,
0.46475932002067566,
0.32035940885543823,
-0.3451179265975952,
0.6151716709136963,
-0.9016641974449158,
0.2969711422920227,
0.23159685730934143,
0.5711351633071899,
0.6239930391311646,
-0.11023475974798203,
0.43614909052848816,
-0.13446179032325745,
-0.5059228539466858,
-0.8758363723754883,
-0.0005096702952869236,
-0.6092561483383179,
-0.29753559827804565,
1.1038758754730225,
-0.2689720392227173,
0.16358111798763275,
0.09016654640436172,
0.18218249082565308,
0.01876513473689556,
-0.5241755843162537,
0.4899779260158539,
0.9418534636497498,
0.2394508570432663,
-0.18737120926380157,
-0.7871518731117249,
0.2770634889602661,
0.3288576304912567,
-0.5261858105659485,
0.0833095982670784,
0.2698347866535187,
0.2389487326145172,
0.4661824703216553,
0.5673938989639282,
-0.16924534738063812,
-0.1979532241821289,
-0.26887616515159607,
0.13387265801429749,
0.11435584723949432,
-0.2705795466899872,
-0.4047967791557312,
0.2048526257276535,
0.5029529333114624,
0.30995264649391174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11539v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11539v1
|
Evaluating Span Extraction in Generative Paradigm: A Reflection on Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-04-17T16:33:22 | 2024-04-17T16:33:22 |
Soyoung Yang, Won Ik Cho
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the era of rapid evolution of generative language models within the realm
of natural language processing, there is an imperative call to revisit and
reformulate evaluation methodologies, especially in the domain of aspect-based
sentiment analysis (ABSA). This paper addresses the emerging challenges
introduced by the generative paradigm, which has moderately blurred traditional
boundaries between understanding and generation tasks. Building upon prevailing
practices in the field, we analyze the advantages and shortcomings associated
with the prevalent ABSA evaluation paradigms. Through an in-depth examination,
supplemented by illustrative examples, we highlight the intricacies involved in
aligning generative outputs with other evaluative metrics, specifically those
derived from other tasks, including question answering. While we steer clear of
advocating for a singular and definitive metric, our contribution lies in
paving the path for a comprehensive guideline tailored for ABSA evaluations in
this generative paradigm. In this position paper, we aim to provide
practitioners with profound reflections, offering insights and directions that
can aid in navigating this evolving landscape, ensuring evaluations that are
both accurate and reflective of generative capabilities.
|
[
-0.6039546132087708,
-0.6834684014320374,
0.5085266828536987,
0.6616742014884949,
-0.44667863845825195,
0.2174633890390396,
-0.06421605497598648,
-0.750755250453949,
0.3831538259983063,
0.2444911003112793,
-0.5681341886520386,
-0.24958756566047668,
-0.4919727146625519,
0.26148897409439087,
-0.3837103545665741,
1.1989367008209229,
-0.16006506979465485,
-0.13134674727916718,
-0.5329289436340332,
-0.1789247840642929,
-0.6347071528434753,
-0.2786828577518463,
-0.5839064717292786,
-0.26093313097953796,
0.23054032027721405,
0.06848026067018509,
0.4489814043045044,
0.40260010957717896,
0.449891060590744,
0.2671317756175995,
-0.21650122106075287,
0.02349860966205597,
-0.12971383333206177,
0.38690394163131714,
-0.02979864738881588,
-0.3958534598350525,
-0.6132535934448242,
0.08024290204048157,
0.7349557876586914,
1.1563423871994019,
0.08415361493825912,
0.0709829181432724,
0.2849062383174896,
1.18413507938385,
-0.6157311797142029,
0.245357483625412,
-0.4343671500682831,
0.29824918508529663,
-0.32485488057136536,
-0.027597937732934952,
-0.12205524742603302,
-0.5806049108505249,
0.3100321888923645,
-0.360105961561203,
0.24706973135471344,
-0.08448068052530289,
0.9672425985336304,
0.055415548384189606,
-0.06485798209905624,
-0.2733611762523651,
-0.8064128160476685,
0.8160295486450195,
-0.5642950534820557,
0.2455844134092331,
0.007726483978331089,
0.20587822794914246,
0.3593532145023346,
-0.48980793356895447,
-0.5095718502998352,
-0.03373328968882561,
0.17506720125675201,
0.47893524169921875,
-0.5015746355056763,
0.03238341584801674,
-0.06593291461467743,
1.036744236946106,
-0.1471092253923416,
0.16589191555976868,
-0.4875621199607849,
0.15002146363258362,
0.7357317805290222,
0.08319091796875,
0.09199891984462738,
-0.6109743714332581,
-0.4807289242744446,
0.07746621966362,
-0.8399941325187683,
0.07886505872011185,
0.6654123663902283,
0.30046969652175903,
-0.06470096111297607,
0.5168870687484741,
-0.3731246888637543,
0.5441461205482483,
0.10387090593576431,
0.5923095941543579,
0.3996710777282715,
-0.3938940167427063,
-0.16588054597377777,
-0.3753180503845215,
0.8728192448616028,
0.4451279044151306,
-0.013022269122302532,
-0.3394912779331207,
-0.3751794099807739,
0.09248261153697968,
0.8045839071273804,
-0.4889703392982483,
-0.0017841761000454426,
0.27597278356552124,
-0.6405768990516663,
-0.38510915637016296,
0.4031759202480316,
-1.5184398889541626,
-0.3686598539352417,
-0.19895261526107788,
0.08653116971254349,
-0.3832217752933502,
-0.34891194105148315,
-0.15073753893375397,
-0.20251311361789703,
0.6927072405815125,
0.29013940691947937,
-0.8868119120597839,
0.1930978000164032,
0.990658164024353,
0.9553931355476379,
-0.17600440979003906,
0.07012475281953812,
-0.17069099843502045,
-0.515095591545105,
-0.5001657605171204,
0.8496094942092896,
-0.5777471661567688,
-0.6929267048835754,
0.15584291517734528,
-0.39055535197257996,
-0.20113897323608398,
-0.7685517072677612,
0.5380707383155823,
-0.5610624551773071,
0.26309484243392944,
-0.3054804503917694,
-0.4006403684616089,
-0.11371178925037384,
0.24776184558868408,
-0.7403668761253357,
1.1658935546875,
0.3536245822906494,
-0.6061720848083496,
0.552183210849762,
-0.8642581105232239,
-0.5596792697906494,
0.16320881247520447,
-0.1568068265914917,
-0.5531262755393982,
0.5106226205825806,
0.3464582860469818,
0.29968780279159546,
-0.3628297448158264,
-0.0787944570183754,
-0.264560341835022,
0.10448203235864639,
0.22046327590942383,
-0.434375137090683,
0.6050916910171509,
0.25472062826156616,
-0.43058907985687256,
0.22564052045345306,
-0.4588285982608795,
0.12382220476865768,
-0.12322895973920822,
-0.1926141381263733,
-0.48028630018234253,
0.09278556704521179,
0.03446020185947418,
0.0818641185760498,
0.3207421898841858,
-0.6825727224349976,
0.016816874966025352,
-0.8640334606170654,
0.04577761888504028,
0.8029025197029114,
0.22090499103069305,
0.41771596670150757,
-0.08853144198656082,
1.0243263244628906,
-0.23551054298877716,
0.3300369679927826,
-0.06477946788072586,
-0.18975403904914856,
-0.8100188970565796,
-0.12638795375823975,
0.2115173190832138,
0.2096257507801056,
-0.7312665581703186,
0.7423547506332397,
-0.40031254291534424,
-0.6717758178710938,
-0.9624426960945129,
0.2342907041311264,
0.5455958843231201,
0.3671279847621918,
0.44583526253700256,
-0.9579302072525024,
-0.6960594654083252,
-0.8980761766433716,
-0.1852903515100479,
-0.45498132705688477,
0.04627097025513649,
-0.01614931784570217,
0.3215404152870178,
0.21176877617835999,
1.3401696681976318,
-0.570210337638855,
-0.1711694896221161,
-0.7718968987464905,
0.39086270332336426,
0.018536198884248734,
0.3272693455219269,
0.41221553087234497,
-0.8052510619163513,
-0.29554399847984314,
0.02297966182231903,
-0.8581193685531616,
-0.3829527795314789,
-0.3259294927120209,
0.025198854506015778,
-0.06401219218969345,
0.21947339177131653,
-0.4677559435367584,
0.318019837141037,
0.3607428967952728,
-0.21669717133045197,
0.8194558024406433,
0.3841666281223297,
-0.01681467518210411,
-1.0133451223373413,
0.16658936440944672,
0.32825228571891785,
0.11348023265600204,
-0.5437418222427368,
0.23403607308864594,
-0.2983623147010803,
0.33354946970939636,
-0.10607997328042984,
0.3146634101867676,
-0.5986080765724182,
-0.297006756067276,
-0.3678362965583801,
0.19509154558181763,
0.21704427897930145,
0.14987631142139435,
-0.03403298556804657,
0.6674105525016785,
0.3627725839614868,
-0.3534543514251709,
0.3245294690132141,
0.22523680329322815,
-0.4418967068195343,
0.9559783935546875,
-0.6109150052070618,
0.23160222172737122,
-0.24249880015850067,
0.1318923830986023,
-0.8067066073417664,
0.16213218867778778,
0.35473155975341797,
-0.3723588287830353,
0.32139676809310913,
0.061252571642398834,
-0.2061356008052826,
-0.3121638298034668,
-0.7783829569816589,
0.2920736074447632,
0.3637113869190216,
-0.3262609839439392,
0.4998234808444977,
0.2020070105791092,
-0.37947481870651245,
-0.6323827505111694,
-0.14702817797660828,
0.11248317360877991,
-0.5466609001159668,
-0.3010207414627075,
0.37623170018196106,
0.2661761939525604,
-0.6783272624015808,
-0.023649150505661964,
-0.4127998650074005,
0.13641878962516785,
0.21720929443836212,
0.31723982095718384,
0.3472353219985962,
-0.21189291775226593,
-0.12639908492565155,
0.31983712315559387,
-0.047731101512908936,
0.27804136276245117,
0.1654583215713501,
0.5220698714256287,
-0.4515300393104553,
-0.3873012363910675,
-0.21098589897155762,
0.47582438588142395,
0.32269471883773804,
-0.4765849709510803,
0.4591926038265228,
0.3413332998752594,
-0.14433380961418152,
-0.30816906690597534,
-0.3881588578224182,
0.05285736173391342,
-0.361954927444458,
0.6060972809791565,
-0.21594202518463135,
-0.5811448693275452,
0.41253232955932617,
-0.17725853621959686,
0.1915365755558014,
0.8717280626296997,
0.30307263135910034,
-0.26251932978630066,
0.5377106070518494,
0.8577845692634583,
-0.2691100239753723,
0.5291213989257812,
-0.29042866826057434,
0.31847068667411804,
-1.4534467458724976,
-0.3921903371810913,
-0.5814014077186584,
-0.040701694786548615,
-0.19443048536777496,
-0.1617627590894699,
0.4833758771419525,
0.33613651990890503,
0.32696762681007385,
0.2650812268257141,
-0.30198219418525696,
0.011153357103466988,
0.09726087749004364,
-0.11692258715629578,
0.2675321102142334,
-0.3477148115634918,
0.29077422618865967,
-0.08122444152832031,
-0.36995944380760193,
-0.6983512043952942,
0.9073108434677124,
0.5776853561401367,
0.4289196729660034,
0.07558559626340866,
0.6550286412239075,
0.3869434595108032,
0.799487829208374,
-1.131301760673523,
0.5332856774330139,
-0.09158293157815933,
-0.3865606188774109,
-0.1383361518383026,
-0.24315817654132843,
-0.8600717186927795,
0.682751476764679,
-0.026184024289250374,
-0.768794059753418,
0.20627225935459137,
-0.09699937701225281,
-0.38115519285202026,
0.275311678647995,
-0.43080928921699524,
0.895226240158081,
-0.08237035572528839,
-0.1114056259393692,
-0.07597225904464722,
-0.6562991738319397,
0.3174300491809845,
0.03442227095365524,
0.15855874121189117,
0.02041887491941452,
0.1673109531402588,
0.7866466045379639,
-0.5289439558982849,
1.1323198080062866,
-0.35665592551231384,
-0.2568133473396301,
0.4347495436668396,
-0.16658179461956024,
-0.10472667962312698,
-0.3227585554122925,
0.00685567781329155,
0.128693088889122,
-0.13686901330947876,
-0.060974881052970886,
-0.624869704246521,
0.2030266970396042,
-0.561919093132019,
-0.5107788443565369,
-0.36366409063339233,
-0.21827425062656403,
-0.5990424752235413,
-0.11390722543001175,
0.16288317739963531,
0.2762296199798584,
-0.6383622884750366,
0.06073029339313507,
0.4191947281360626,
-0.05972913280129433,
0.592877209186554,
-0.022703135386109352,
-0.20440669357776642,
-0.42053842544555664,
0.8025784492492676,
-0.10993952304124832,
0.3274827301502228,
0.42088964581489563,
-0.031517162919044495,
-0.552537739276886,
-0.6591395139694214,
-0.6632713675498962,
0.069918192923069,
-0.6876174211502075,
-0.29926857352256775,
-0.3695910573005676,
-0.10847786068916321,
-0.22802017629146576,
-0.12038130313158035,
-0.5156417489051819,
-0.3788849413394928,
-0.2512921094894409,
-0.4042307734489441,
0.0018725642003118992,
0.775325357913971,
0.10411052405834198,
0.30846619606018066,
-0.5825074911117554,
-0.013500649482011795,
0.14119012653827667,
0.15085934102535248,
0.28336867690086365,
-0.23175832629203796,
-0.22156260907649994,
-0.2825072109699249,
-0.7035542726516724,
-1.1483500003814697,
0.25776582956314087,
0.1222534105181694,
0.4468463063240051,
0.6268669962882996,
-0.11156468093395233,
0.6766397953033447,
-0.17935188114643097,
0.9844273924827576,
0.3210774064064026,
-1.1931570768356323,
0.5492560267448425,
-0.046158235520124435,
-0.05379375442862511,
0.7625086903572083,
0.1308113932609558,
-0.8399735689163208,
-0.5416200160980225,
-0.4441739618778229,
-1.3278467655181885,
0.34134531021118164,
0.12307633459568024,
0.45415356755256653,
-0.07708340883255005,
0.31735825538635254,
0.428052693605423,
0.4591745436191559,
-0.7462643384933472,
-0.13885945081710815,
-0.471343994140625,
-0.23253965377807617,
0.321251779794693,
-0.1395118683576584,
-0.09932783991098404,
-0.15354640781879425,
0.5142288208007812,
-0.19447369873523712,
0.40098464488983154,
0.09301278740167618,
0.038984473794698715,
0.00827051606029272,
0.6616906523704529,
0.03865499049425125,
0.7095915079116821,
0.15154284238815308,
0.017065687105059624,
0.020181721076369286,
-0.2541765868663788,
-0.26099029183387756,
0.3678092360496521,
-0.23003451526165009,
-0.058230914175510406,
0.7367138862609863,
0.810187041759491,
-0.12350261211395264,
-0.5379394888877869,
0.6104010939598083,
0.4577685594558716,
0.13087141513824463,
-0.3532234728336334,
-0.1432429403066635,
-0.3178005814552307,
0.05140585079789162,
0.6523406505584717,
0.03900162875652313,
0.2515444755554199,
-0.528904914855957,
0.08660175651311874,
0.7416206002235413,
-0.7189420461654663,
-0.7072799801826477,
0.500817060470581,
0.12396468967199326,
0.1959603875875473,
0.5319265127182007,
-0.19424736499786377,
-0.703226625919342,
0.690487802028656,
0.3444088399410248,
1.527220606803894,
-0.22046315670013428,
0.5607244968414307,
-0.07291938364505768,
0.40582603216171265,
0.3106171488761902,
0.29289183020591736,
-0.23924939334392548,
-0.8211933970451355,
-0.5652878284454346,
-1.0758910179138184,
-0.37643468379974365,
-0.04942082241177559,
-1.0781404972076416,
-0.35155564546585083,
-0.39247119426727295,
0.017271991819143295,
0.18938110768795013,
-0.06251499801874161,
-0.329176664352417,
0.29513269662857056,
-0.058437779545784,
0.6907138228416443,
-1.1762117147445679,
0.40845420956611633,
0.914878785610199,
-0.8164655566215515,
-0.4815376400947571,
0.42985638976097107,
-0.1021718680858612,
-0.5077559947967529,
0.48816853761672974,
0.2704937160015106,
-0.4030192196369171,
-0.4987143278121948,
-0.1783401072025299,
-0.28917157649993896,
0.8385633826255798,
-0.1586165577173233,
-0.07309321314096451,
0.0042461371049284935,
0.15215079486370087,
0.9461796879768372,
-0.3823896050453186,
-0.036418523639440536,
0.6779698133468628,
0.3465527892112732,
-0.20892775058746338,
-0.8206555247306824,
0.1272558718919754,
-0.43756040930747986,
0.375222772359848,
0.20881789922714233,
-0.6383135318756104,
0.52629154920578,
0.11867955327033997,
-0.3503175973892212,
0.3595595955848694,
1.190466284751892,
-0.07809769362211227,
0.33379819989204407,
0.7254791855812073,
0.4196285009384155,
0.2613488435745239,
-0.3137924373149872,
1.1463831663131714,
0.06067736819386482,
0.3352164924144745,
0.693178117275238,
-0.24650537967681885,
0.8014265298843384,
0.7579366564750671,
-0.6947823762893677,
0.754805862903595,
0.6057963967323303,
0.09665089100599289,
0.4577702581882477,
0.057392530143260956,
-0.6486159563064575,
0.08197731524705887,
-0.123640276491642,
-0.24711988866329193,
0.7857866287231445,
0.3634234666824341,
-0.3887583017349243,
-0.19819508492946625,
-0.27942463755607605,
0.18151292204856873,
0.38127920031547546,
-0.33346667885780334,
0.890540361404419,
0.10142535716295242,
-0.8358495235443115,
-0.08967938274145126,
0.24269609153270721,
0.6814976334571838,
-0.6122227311134338,
-0.05286611244082451,
-0.4249180257320404,
-0.2125241756439209,
-0.39623650908470154,
-0.8299852609634399,
0.9198170900344849,
0.28167882561683655,
-0.09045831114053726,
-0.37436628341674805,
0.39333879947662354,
-0.12591861188411713,
-0.21231204271316528,
0.16429823637008667,
0.7739783525466919,
-0.06167666241526604,
-0.12716302275657654,
-0.5760121941566467,
0.04285011067986488,
0.029205627739429474,
-0.2915097773075104,
0.12279444932937622,
0.13543306291103363,
-0.0481593981385231,
0.23000134527683258,
0.3575288951396942,
0.21994298696517944,
-0.15166863799095154,
0.1602468341588974,
0.8958257436752319,
-0.5609728693962097,
-0.5085771679878235,
-0.9700848460197449,
0.48553380370140076,
-0.2581142783164978,
-0.5153809189796448,
0.8937016725540161,
0.7296332716941833,
0.7704422473907471,
0.0023667027708142996,
1.080625295639038,
-0.6968802213668823,
0.22834502160549164,
-0.5767560005187988,
0.47926294803619385,
-0.4495600163936615,
0.4303072988986969,
-0.5921586751937866,
-1.1329772472381592,
-0.16262079775333405,
0.4843446612358093,
-0.5583788752555847,
0.35040950775146484,
0.5686296224594116,
0.30165135860443115,
0.24078471958637238,
0.3340342938899994,
-0.13861998915672302,
-0.02139369212090969,
0.3270828127861023,
0.25543904304504395,
1.111390471458435,
-0.15901054441928864,
0.12724223732948303,
-0.3399202227592468,
-0.4381263256072998,
0.155411496758461,
-0.7323060035705566,
-0.30325743556022644,
-0.6784607768058777,
-0.38092634081840515,
-0.1731446087360382,
-0.15624549984931946,
0.6922087669372559,
0.3599330484867096,
-0.6286203265190125,
-0.22946177423000336,
-0.09662599116563797,
0.1293352246284485,
-0.8954081535339355,
-0.4081936776638031,
0.6041142344474792,
-0.49914827942848206,
-0.9398542642593384,
0.48299047350883484,
0.43368932604789734,
-0.23541946709156036,
-0.5984699130058289,
0.24378904700279236,
0.18713624775409698,
-0.040954262018203735,
0.7350508570671082,
0.5521100759506226,
-0.5825497508049011,
-0.4854448437690735,
-0.2989683449268341,
0.28157272934913635,
0.3291609585285187,
0.8045899868011475,
-0.608747661113739,
0.6861398816108704,
0.18970835208892822,
0.7277589440345764,
0.29014039039611816,
0.55373215675354,
0.6384644508361816,
-1.1479823589324951,
-0.4353885352611542,
0.31959107518196106,
0.21389399468898773,
0.6761044263839722,
-0.059157129377126694,
0.5594156384468079,
0.2532764673233032,
-0.00584318395704031,
-0.71153724193573,
0.43929505348205566,
-1.0379774570465088,
-0.13177616894245148,
0.9721535444259644,
-0.3073909282684326,
0.0913194939494133,
-0.15107804536819458,
0.005025870632380247,
0.15309986472129822,
-0.0776810571551323,
0.9613152146339417,
0.5466139912605286,
-0.5593662261962891,
0.03678063675761223,
-0.3743613064289093,
0.42694297432899475,
0.7171697616577148,
-1.2994985580444336,
0.2697180211544037,
0.746690571308136,
0.11885286867618561,
0.25250115990638733,
0.6914680004119873,
-0.573710560798645,
0.0756504163146019,
-0.09610553085803986,
0.21582618355751038,
0.2976692020893097,
-0.3056015968322754,
-0.6856894493103027,
0.5381327271461487,
0.30390095710754395,
-0.37879660725593567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11538v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11538v1
|
GenFighter: A Generative and Evolutive Textual Attack Removal
| 2024-04-17T16:32:13 | 2024-04-17T16:32:13 |
Md Athikul Islam, Edoardo Serra, Sushil Jajodia
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Adversarial attacks pose significant challenges to deep neural networks
(DNNs) such as Transformer models in natural language processing (NLP). This
paper introduces a novel defense strategy, called GenFighter, which enhances
adversarial robustness by learning and reasoning on the training classification
distribution. GenFighter identifies potentially malicious instances deviating
from the distribution, transforms them into semantically equivalent instances
aligned with the training data, and employs ensemble techniques for a unified
and robust response. By conducting extensive experiments, we show that
GenFighter outperforms state-of-the-art defenses in accuracy under attack and
attack success rate metrics. Additionally, it requires a high number of queries
per attack, making the attack more challenging in real scenarios. The ablation
study shows that our approach integrates transfer learning, a
generative/evolutive procedure, and an ensemble method, providing an effective
defense against NLP adversarial attacks.
|
[
-0.5116205811500549,
-1.1004630327224731,
-0.04119475185871124,
-0.1549108326435089,
0.01311405561864376,
0.8277606964111328,
-0.16259680688381195,
-0.24068893492221832,
0.05700933560729027,
0.5306827425956726,
-0.46076157689094543,
-0.3198795020580292,
-0.7511965036392212,
0.0028296855743974447,
-0.853762686252594,
1.202185034751892,
0.2090999186038971,
-0.3550160825252533,
-0.07331136614084244,
0.06532049924135208,
-0.21925288438796997,
-0.6522642970085144,
-0.9992789626121521,
-0.20517145097255707,
0.48736605048179626,
-0.10547412931919098,
0.8985861539840698,
0.4102136194705963,
0.7146021723747253,
0.4548453092575073,
-0.25189387798309326,
-0.20561359822750092,
-0.3865969777107239,
0.4831234812736511,
-0.14919881522655487,
-0.47725996375083923,
-0.16035877168178558,
-0.3227425813674927,
0.4695030450820923,
0.39939478039741516,
-0.15483053028583527,
-0.40012937784194946,
-0.10827617347240448,
0.7330322861671448,
-0.56879061460495,
-0.4695741534233093,
-1.0231425762176514,
0.3704065680503845,
-0.3122161626815796,
-0.1888822466135025,
-0.6118638515472412,
-0.09623637795448303,
0.051111798733472824,
-0.6359190344810486,
0.5721596479415894,
-0.2921278178691864,
0.7989189624786377,
0.3434733748435974,
-0.3181327283382416,
-0.1790398210287094,
-0.6418803334236145,
0.2834165692329407,
-0.21657954156398773,
-0.13575014472007751,
0.15157102048397064,
0.4203092157840729,
-0.2565731108188629,
-0.8192012310028076,
-0.3016280233860016,
0.1429625153541565,
0.000700784963555634,
0.4045683741569519,
-0.8613981604576111,
0.325874000787735,
0.10438219457864761,
0.276943176984787,
-0.8473145365715027,
0.41704753041267395,
-0.311151385307312,
-0.19416609406471252,
0.6130741834640503,
-0.09619096666574478,
0.6200430989265442,
-0.037921421229839325,
-0.809022068977356,
-0.39481350779533386,
-0.3224562108516693,
-0.016838371753692627,
0.7378562092781067,
-0.0745527520775795,
0.07434596121311188,
0.3960551917552948,
-0.13138426840305328,
0.5098832845687866,
0.12957292795181274,
0.1590287685394287,
-0.147274911403656,
0.05661662667989731,
-0.5448241233825684,
0.19389350712299347,
0.9820759892463684,
0.06652246415615082,
0.0690394937992096,
-0.5694659948348999,
-0.15581248700618744,
0.17391283810138702,
0.8991642594337463,
-0.6775349974632263,
-0.419493168592453,
0.078165203332901,
-0.31788870692253113,
-1.094473123550415,
0.002181860152631998,
-1.2782725095748901,
-0.4563784599304199,
0.31217384338378906,
0.22791273891925812,
-0.6479837894439697,
-0.18567857146263123,
-0.061453595757484436,
-0.4907824397087097,
0.24846309423446655,
0.10815559327602386,
-1.1440556049346924,
0.1454615443944931,
0.6910055875778198,
0.5027657747268677,
0.2565370202064514,
-0.06356506794691086,
-0.6208893656730652,
0.020512841641902924,
-0.4035015404224396,
0.8142874240875244,
-0.3202073872089386,
-0.6614577174186707,
-0.09844081103801727,
-0.29246166348457336,
-0.49117758870124817,
-0.47737324237823486,
0.7101126909255981,
-0.8537628650665283,
0.12389339506626129,
0.32012516260147095,
-0.5263940095901489,
-0.32967403531074524,
0.3745015859603882,
-0.7910412549972534,
0.7790616750717163,
0.14527538418769836,
-0.6252076029777527,
0.2872649133205414,
-0.393741637468338,
-0.8416302800178528,
0.4291326701641083,
-0.00061175343580544,
-0.5956885814666748,
0.08107013255357742,
0.4343905746936798,
0.41056233644485474,
-0.11077464371919632,
0.1702762246131897,
-0.36614206433296204,
0.111501045525074,
0.10551704466342926,
-0.8206729292869568,
1.0175882577896118,
0.6836757659912109,
-0.3485584855079651,
0.14416272938251495,
-0.8699697852134705,
0.0631028562784195,
0.40919920802116394,
-0.2541653513908386,
-0.40132367610931396,
-0.09205666929483414,
-0.32808032631874084,
-0.22787022590637207,
-0.20506000518798828,
-0.4467739760875702,
0.3452995717525482,
-0.726466178894043,
0.5165762305259705,
0.5207550525665283,
0.09798025339841843,
0.7360745668411255,
-0.1818455010652542,
0.8854999542236328,
-0.5213394165039062,
0.27869105339050293,
-0.14462007582187653,
-0.3800773322582245,
-0.5876085758209229,
-0.4849710464477539,
0.04056508094072342,
0.6699643731117249,
-1.3779866695404053,
0.6539990901947021,
-0.09738191217184067,
-0.5715242624282837,
-0.4212794601917267,
0.32816699147224426,
0.427887499332428,
0.412366658449173,
0.3183782696723938,
0.020208869129419327,
-0.705317497253418,
-0.5663504004478455,
-0.4057832956314087,
-0.5070735216140747,
-0.049885787069797516,
-0.48824867606163025,
0.30013948678970337,
-0.1015659049153328,
0.5899056792259216,
-0.22819150984287262,
-0.12443651258945465,
-0.4945945739746094,
0.21395686268806458,
-0.4288237988948822,
0.31431347131729126,
0.9444190263748169,
-0.9204245209693909,
-0.2625124454498291,
0.14782673120498657,
-1.0770797729492188,
0.12154771387577057,
-0.496147483587265,
-0.14840903878211975,
-0.17910140752792358,
0.6356953978538513,
-0.6255626082420349,
0.44367945194244385,
0.23798571527004242,
-0.3123437464237213,
0.09083575755357742,
-0.04533902183175087,
-0.025731267407536507,
-1.015261173248291,
-0.04834434762597084,
-0.04031992703676224,
-0.15051411092281342,
-1.0573827028274536,
0.7718440294265747,
-0.18865013122558594,
-0.23067085444927216,
-0.35061880946159363,
0.3431185185909271,
0.2370162159204483,
0.33386293053627014,
-0.1608378142118454,
-0.16492106020450592,
0.4068278968334198,
0.1493111550807953,
-0.261076420545578,
0.5771303772926331,
0.3516659438610077,
-0.29004818201065063,
0.7303887605667114,
0.48765185475349426,
-0.018410226330161095,
0.9188159704208374,
-0.5821354389190674,
0.20279404520988464,
-0.3404448330402374,
0.34729015827178955,
-1.0175179243087769,
0.08591251820325851,
0.3321496844291687,
-0.7772407531738281,
0.6387746334075928,
-0.350460946559906,
-0.35914263129234314,
-0.4805208444595337,
-0.16590836644172668,
-0.030004743486642838,
0.3704424202442169,
-0.8503509759902954,
0.7633653283119202,
-0.03597193956375122,
-0.1376129388809204,
-0.6281738877296448,
-0.6272642612457275,
0.6504723429679871,
-0.574052095413208,
-0.5144380927085876,
0.4886571764945984,
0.2216312140226364,
-0.29684126377105713,
-0.11984261870384216,
0.27475979924201965,
-0.09622199833393097,
0.8774551153182983,
-0.09955769032239914,
0.28219130635261536,
0.019008545204997063,
0.04165159910917282,
-0.20654073357582092,
0.00946007203310728,
0.3653648793697357,
-0.1119786873459816,
0.38725054264068604,
0.07510016858577728,
-0.30495768785476685,
-0.03190959244966507,
0.19972464442253113,
0.6175110340118408,
-0.20899121463298798,
0.7443972229957581,
1.048775315284729,
-0.1187620460987091,
-0.3555561602115631,
-0.3157658874988556,
-0.016297856345772743,
-0.5044789910316467,
0.5374154448509216,
-0.36371105909347534,
-0.552545428276062,
0.39987385272979736,
0.12895677983760834,
0.18956083059310913,
0.7834151983261108,
0.21166059374809265,
-0.08798588812351227,
0.8978874683380127,
0.09394987672567368,
-0.3089990019798279,
0.29476356506347656,
-0.47039735317230225,
0.05114668607711792,
-0.6590691208839417,
-0.49609997868537903,
-0.796746015548706,
-0.22184596955776215,
-0.3537459075450897,
0.19374097883701324,
-0.03522744029760361,
0.24414752423763275,
-0.28755471110343933,
0.6030964255332947,
-0.6321918964385986,
0.24377700686454773,
0.37723255157470703,
0.12263930588960648,
-0.1062341257929802,
0.15645459294319153,
-0.10155778378248215,
0.2247970998287201,
-0.7359831929206848,
-0.12436755001544952,
1.1236811876296997,
0.46036773920059204,
0.6894916892051697,
0.38872191309928894,
0.7621934413909912,
0.33884379267692566,
0.2768254578113556,
-0.6581493020057678,
0.4789186716079712,
-0.4881553649902344,
-0.5132603049278259,
-0.11095380783081055,
-0.665444016456604,
-0.9453607201576233,
0.5544989109039307,
-0.341274619102478,
-0.46028852462768555,
-0.08933161944150925,
-0.30918172001838684,
-0.39634576439857483,
0.8460663557052612,
-0.6726014614105225,
0.6758370995521545,
-0.43702176213264465,
-0.07640160620212555,
-0.002094442956149578,
-0.6479076743125916,
0.3840523362159729,
-0.1393839716911316,
0.05997729301452637,
0.24581490457057953,
0.30942100286483765,
0.63798987865448,
-0.2895888090133667,
0.7677100300788879,
-0.28545787930488586,
-0.018526071682572365,
0.3302980661392212,
0.15992949903011322,
0.5746542811393738,
-0.1376304030418396,
0.08525865525007248,
-0.23178738355636597,
-0.37721967697143555,
-0.28647878766059875,
-0.677077054977417,
0.36378976702690125,
-0.6176194548606873,
-0.5437108278274536,
-0.2812099754810333,
-0.1394527554512024,
0.011865992099046707,
0.15065422654151917,
0.4707784950733185,
0.484253466129303,
-0.6934557557106018,
0.4069317579269409,
0.9751937389373779,
-0.538711428642273,
0.6796627640724182,
0.24025538563728333,
0.025987906381487846,
-0.7962971329689026,
0.8635072112083435,
-0.46882006525993347,
0.5811915993690491,
0.718690812587738,
0.02494710497558117,
-0.4375545084476471,
-0.6112605333328247,
-0.8126204609870911,
-0.593213677406311,
-0.8322111368179321,
-0.49396687746047974,
-0.7891441583633423,
-0.4482439458370209,
-0.43073660135269165,
-0.3403950035572052,
-0.22918860614299774,
-0.23125575482845306,
-0.2215731292963028,
-0.16864770650863647,
0.5125895738601685,
0.5078410506248474,
0.42051824927330017,
0.546045184135437,
-0.6042444705963135,
0.416914165019989,
0.6252953410148621,
-0.08888280391693115,
-0.05299680680036545,
-0.6125836968421936,
0.09920449554920197,
-0.09632771462202072,
-0.6150500774383545,
-0.6023553609848022,
0.6449512839317322,
0.34591972827911377,
0.6131203770637512,
0.5560493469238281,
0.26638442277908325,
0.3738114535808563,
-0.1783905178308487,
0.49947401881217957,
0.4890117049217224,
-0.5256456136703491,
0.45054423809051514,
-0.2489432692527771,
0.22093361616134644,
0.7556727528572083,
-0.07775712013244629,
0.025572657585144043,
-0.4263957738876343,
-0.9667521119117737,
-0.636462926864624,
0.21903517842292786,
0.347938597202301,
0.1056731790304184,
-0.007881462574005127,
0.24127915501594543,
-0.33173301815986633,
0.09365789592266083,
-0.3769493103027344,
-0.30036085844039917,
-0.46388986706733704,
-0.4228713810443878,
0.043906908482313156,
0.18286000192165375,
-0.23237881064414978,
-0.14191877841949463,
0.5337145328521729,
-0.061599552631378174,
0.1961863785982132,
0.14991749823093414,
-0.1292383074760437,
0.07583336532115936,
0.5471851825714111,
0.4778750538825989,
-0.2503713071346283,
-0.06662778556346893,
0.3460083603858948,
0.12608079612255096,
-0.6315730810165405,
0.4872879385948181,
0.48473235964775085,
-0.30902665853500366,
-0.18708175420761108,
0.6163523197174072,
0.7048109769821167,
0.34146183729171753,
-0.4073885381221771,
0.586138129234314,
-0.1637130081653595,
-0.5595307350158691,
-0.10220608115196228,
0.009403758682310581,
-0.29350563883781433,
0.04665239155292511,
0.45205920934677124,
0.760281503200531,
0.16033154726028442,
-0.34825798869132996,
0.34811797738075256,
0.753990888595581,
-0.509881854057312,
-0.14335116744041443,
0.8590964078903198,
0.24133995175361633,
-0.11484929174184799,
0.3962491452693939,
-0.17649133503437042,
-1.0552270412445068,
1.067068099975586,
0.43077027797698975,
1.1830790042877197,
-0.2796704173088074,
0.5131571888923645,
0.023345662280917168,
0.7446234822273254,
0.058333855122327805,
-0.4059262275695801,
0.09506157785654068,
-0.6774580478668213,
-0.19262348115444183,
-0.5276046991348267,
-0.13112102448940277,
0.21566547453403473,
-0.8260165452957153,
-0.11445089429616928,
-0.9102586507797241,
-0.07088490575551987,
0.367719441652298,
-0.1475708782672882,
-0.6643754243850708,
0.22719025611877441,
0.14731964468955994,
0.6445534229278564,
-0.5057049989700317,
0.5928285717964172,
0.6580400466918945,
-0.34034526348114014,
-0.48499348759651184,
-0.22340552508831024,
0.32764333486557007,
-0.8717499375343323,
0.6227588653564453,
-0.009752409532666206,
0.1167314201593399,
-0.06357061862945557,
-0.07330813258886337,
-0.40962836146354675,
0.5521593689918518,
0.32188040018081665,
-0.425798237323761,
0.10797207057476044,
-0.06918029487133026,
0.5966044068336487,
-0.03584698960185051,
0.1404852569103241,
0.4765927195549011,
0.3116310238838196,
0.13652195036411285,
-0.41500914096832275,
-0.08222293108701706,
-0.32209035754203796,
-0.09553810209035873,
0.30364373326301575,
-0.5310403108596802,
0.47337642312049866,
0.039195649325847626,
-0.268157035112381,
0.3067150115966797,
0.5390752553939819,
-0.2176249772310257,
0.3125525116920471,
0.4734993577003479,
1.1328771114349365,
0.5409866571426392,
-0.2268417775630951,
1.2115241289138794,
0.13761022686958313,
0.08712417632341385,
0.6158730983734131,
-0.1513088047504425,
0.5672425031661987,
0.10084830969572067,
-0.3661659061908722,
0.43892982602119446,
0.23120810091495514,
-0.2767002582550049,
0.6298536062240601,
0.22056196630001068,
-0.6250749826431274,
0.028165284544229507,
0.26604291796684265,
-0.30762580037117004,
0.5698336958885193,
0.19972540438175201,
-0.433805912733078,
-0.21215511858463287,
0.4545305073261261,
0.3396844267845154,
0.4351385235786438,
-0.2371598780155182,
1.2975698709487915,
-0.2726009786128998,
-0.6106425523757935,
0.6845812201499939,
-0.0049532996490597725,
0.6305822730064392,
-0.8242025375366211,
0.26352331042289734,
-0.13100992143154144,
0.3355865478515625,
-0.2447965294122696,
-0.5502893924713135,
0.23424766957759857,
-0.005619898438453674,
-0.09776567667722702,
-0.19824589788913727,
0.8385511636734009,
-0.29794785380363464,
-0.4580349624156952,
0.24641679227352142,
0.024861395359039307,
-0.42107656598091125,
-0.0010938197374343872,
-0.8122147917747498,
-0.006683402229100466,
0.17348121106624603,
-0.06636954843997955,
0.6316888332366943,
0.27388399839401245,
0.48142820596694946,
0.7360606789588928,
0.7187410593032837,
0.2083270400762558,
0.008037760853767395,
0.3319394290447235,
0.8201830983161926,
-0.08911004662513733,
-0.4825304448604584,
-0.9903601408004761,
0.04809129983186722,
-0.40036389231681824,
-0.2209031581878662,
0.753446638584137,
0.3830200731754303,
0.5538812279701233,
0.20811043679714203,
1.1026705503463745,
-0.01339484192430973,
0.3045123219490051,
-0.6358579993247986,
0.7260226011276245,
-0.07491570711135864,
0.5504652261734009,
-0.3447120785713196,
-0.5987482666969299,
-0.4240815341472626,
0.4686417877674103,
0.007427018601447344,
-0.12348993867635727,
0.4579313099384308,
0.43208077549934387,
0.24891319870948792,
0.3395163416862488,
0.2532075047492981,
-0.22304044663906097,
0.7944282293319702,
0.5755897164344788,
0.9333696365356445,
-0.7368695139884949,
0.870365560054779,
-0.3309895694255829,
-0.168453186750412,
-0.013763027265667915,
-0.6110908389091492,
-1.115801215171814,
-0.08260243386030197,
-0.2127145677804947,
-0.4435993731021881,
0.3639987111091614,
0.5125505924224854,
0.5482368469238281,
-0.5904346704483032,
0.41268810629844666,
-0.26921483874320984,
0.06893584132194519,
-0.3316735625267029,
-0.29274362325668335,
0.24466799199581146,
-0.5070370435714722,
-0.23042979836463928,
0.835128903388977,
0.05621962994337082,
0.1925545632839203,
-0.3886321187019348,
0.027532747015357018,
-0.042617835104465485,
-0.17942674458026886,
0.41926226019859314,
0.5871182680130005,
-0.56990647315979,
-0.1907110959291458,
-0.1933693140745163,
-0.1516820639371872,
-0.3169751763343811,
0.6773316264152527,
-0.7366119623184204,
0.8102687001228333,
0.27233612537384033,
1.2454159259796143,
0.03965971618890762,
0.1240089014172554,
0.6252362132072449,
-1.0554286241531372,
0.32032960653305054,
0.2004411220550537,
0.2049648016691208,
0.37410882115364075,
-0.7672745585441589,
0.47260206937789917,
0.39001864194869995,
-0.3481219410896301,
-0.6444984674453735,
0.10228477418422699,
-0.5614672899246216,
-0.5156069397926331,
0.9102523326873779,
-0.08501161634922028,
0.07989552617073059,
-0.21350573003292084,
-0.006216743029654026,
-0.008533697575330734,
-0.23569682240486145,
0.6227682828903198,
0.3531000018119812,
0.5893619060516357,
-0.04296700283885002,
-0.49149811267852783,
0.5050355195999146,
0.3556191623210907,
-1.0799142122268677,
-0.02878469042479992,
0.0014557952526956797,
0.034384213387966156,
0.157246932387352,
0.06706930696964264,
-0.1216004341840744,
0.1879860758781433,
0.2812184691429138,
-0.07647711783647537,
-0.11178378015756607,
-0.4050825536251068,
-0.4904574751853943,
0.5556013584136963,
-0.37459197640419006,
-0.19837962090969086
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.