id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16764v1
|
Dataset of Quotation Attribution in German News Articles
| 2024-04-25T17:19:13 | 2024-04-25T17:19:13 |
Fynn Petersen-Frey, Chris Biemann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extracting who says what to whom is a crucial part in analyzing human
communication in today's abundance of data such as online news articles. Yet,
the lack of annotated data for this task in German news articles severely
limits the quality and usability of possible systems. To remedy this, we
present a new, freely available, creative-commons-licensed dataset for
quotation attribution in German news articles based on WIKINEWS. The dataset
provides curated, high-quality annotations across 1000 documents (250,000
tokens) in a fine-grained annotation schema enabling various downstream uses
for the dataset. The annotations not only specify who said what but also how,
in which context, to whom and define the type of quotation. We specify our
annotation schema, describe the creation of the dataset and provide a
quantitative analysis. Further, we describe suitable evaluation metrics, apply
two existing systems for quotation attribution, discuss their results to
evaluate the utility of our dataset and outline use cases of our dataset in
downstream tasks.
|
[
-0.43167009949684143,
-0.22734911739826202,
0.5289778113365173,
0.320217490196228,
-0.545394778251648,
-0.23261334002017975,
-0.13764691352844238,
-0.51608806848526,
0.4230329096317291,
0.4658149480819702,
-0.685061514377594,
-0.4503777325153351,
-0.7430199384689331,
0.2413574457168579,
-0.5017721056938171,
1.210734486579895,
0.015146728605031967,
0.01843549683690071,
-0.4976268410682678,
-0.3796529173851013,
-0.07246222347021103,
-0.4428391456604004,
-0.35971784591674805,
-0.35192450881004333,
0.988812267780304,
0.5729458928108215,
0.4452625513076782,
0.35989615321159363,
0.41255030035972595,
0.22464248538017273,
0.0009595709852874279,
-0.05718620866537094,
-0.3553188741207123,
0.2431679368019104,
-0.3242172300815582,
-0.23650187253952026,
0.013177663087844849,
0.26036766171455383,
0.6455170512199402,
0.5532318949699402,
0.015118135139346123,
0.5982242822647095,
-0.029217049479484558,
0.3910583555698395,
-0.6869296431541443,
0.2250787317752838,
-0.644424557685852,
0.12754285335540771,
-0.34916678071022034,
-0.18418656289577484,
-0.19472946226596832,
-0.8284575343132019,
0.1465476006269455,
-0.5875390768051147,
0.09810370206832886,
-0.1037408635020256,
0.7329923510551453,
0.15792414546012878,
-0.647849977016449,
-0.22928625345230103,
-0.23350615799427032,
0.5746808648109436,
-0.7875156402587891,
0.22875037789344788,
0.5721172094345093,
0.2226465344429016,
0.035289980471134186,
-0.670430600643158,
-0.4064469337463379,
-0.07449210435152054,
-0.4906574785709381,
0.1740671694278717,
-0.2851347029209137,
-0.42763713002204895,
0.08472968637943268,
0.01994313672184944,
-0.15595072507858276,
0.10071305185556412,
-0.5143250226974487,
-0.4132274091243744,
0.6948239803314209,
-0.16973651945590973,
-0.459529310464859,
-0.5838955044746399,
-0.348204106092453,
0.04519405588507652,
-0.4772961437702179,
-0.1991126984357834,
0.6273133754730225,
0.310568243265152,
0.0861273780465126,
0.7495087385177612,
-0.5563796162605286,
0.6072272062301636,
-0.041820164769887924,
0.1926707774400711,
0.5407078266143799,
-0.0230388380587101,
0.25133681297302246,
0.27619853615760803,
0.9602094888687134,
0.689001739025116,
0.48389679193496704,
-0.33827269077301025,
-0.15926294028759003,
-0.3158782422542572,
0.22766843438148499,
-0.7157079577445984,
-0.3565114438533783,
-0.03985537216067314,
-0.5022822618484497,
-0.7532357573509216,
0.6162292957305908,
-0.7340214252471924,
-0.7028841376304626,
-0.13739848136901855,
0.1468401700258255,
0.027688151225447655,
-0.25692665576934814,
-0.23371277749538422,
-0.5486471652984619,
0.009128240868449211,
0.12375206500291824,
-0.6313974261283875,
0.0072913626208901405,
0.35776105523109436,
0.6829618215560913,
-0.2790288031101227,
-0.270634263753891,
-0.6905407309532166,
0.3065497577190399,
-0.4905894100666046,
1.0916177034378052,
-0.408997118473053,
-0.12360556423664093,
0.0699893906712532,
0.055667705833911896,
0.29907193779945374,
-0.5009986758232117,
0.9929609298706055,
-0.2781423032283783,
0.4972842335700989,
-0.5887325406074524,
-0.6936798691749573,
-0.06815692037343979,
-0.12572573125362396,
-0.9396181702613831,
0.9296628832817078,
0.20567138493061066,
-0.9992185831069946,
0.6763994693756104,
-0.9742662906646729,
-0.6844282150268555,
0.27294349670410156,
-0.2764914631843567,
-0.3555041253566742,
0.4271148443222046,
0.17390736937522888,
0.7168576121330261,
-0.19551679491996765,
0.22375063598155975,
-0.3363993465900421,
-0.03614934906363487,
0.6354905962944031,
-0.23471230268478394,
0.9638701677322388,
0.3598399758338928,
-0.016432547941803932,
-0.15118171274662018,
-0.8050243854522705,
0.045352790504693985,
0.15549860894680023,
-0.3836725056171417,
-0.4823321998119354,
0.1378181427717209,
0.38832738995552063,
0.30039143562316895,
0.18521255254745483,
-0.7132543325424194,
-0.06800192594528198,
0.09771566092967987,
0.39942285418510437,
0.7041799426078796,
0.3304053246974945,
0.21443063020706177,
-0.043154630810022354,
0.2773883640766144,
-0.08120812475681305,
0.2093273252248764,
0.08729525655508041,
-0.33404242992401123,
-0.32842400670051575,
-0.17586082220077515,
0.3583841323852539,
0.4845114052295685,
-0.46723923087120056,
0.708264946937561,
-0.3805010914802551,
-0.47050461173057556,
-0.37561479210853577,
0.0420558825135231,
0.11880335211753845,
0.564262330532074,
0.0482250452041626,
-0.10748288035392761,
-0.5856794118881226,
-1.2213510274887085,
-0.5645999312400818,
-0.346275269985199,
-0.38969290256500244,
0.15154244005680084,
0.4109492897987366,
0.26338791847229004,
1.3137092590332031,
-0.7152902483940125,
-0.2143637239933014,
-0.01550364587455988,
0.4416239857673645,
-0.06560461223125458,
0.20485897362232208,
0.5423455238342285,
-0.7575973868370056,
-0.22496841847896576,
-0.05575314909219742,
-0.8259539008140564,
-0.5511583089828491,
-0.013475202023983002,
-0.1886754184961319,
0.01211081724613905,
0.473537415266037,
-0.6178605556488037,
0.1853887140750885,
0.434312105178833,
-0.3503737151622772,
0.827852189540863,
0.20612846314907074,
0.13839037716388702,
-1.2608156204223633,
0.3044719099998474,
0.18230441212654114,
-0.34004300832748413,
-0.23771178722381592,
-0.31021830439567566,
0.10894472151994705,
0.11132898926734924,
-0.5420806407928467,
0.5729976892471313,
-0.2528957724571228,
-0.029189180582761765,
-0.043230388313531876,
0.18815408647060394,
0.06662698835134506,
0.1492442637681961,
-0.10104874521493912,
0.6389554142951965,
0.16002504527568817,
-0.22721095383167267,
0.8354849815368652,
0.6265369653701782,
-0.7543368935585022,
0.9295385479927063,
-0.42039912939071655,
-0.0021692789159715176,
-0.08312924206256866,
0.4612226188182831,
-0.6551002264022827,
-0.3951476216316223,
0.32291239500045776,
-0.539344310760498,
-0.3676254451274872,
-0.14159409701824188,
-0.9618409276008606,
-0.3825785219669342,
-0.21558760106563568,
-0.15961560606956482,
0.07826665788888931,
-0.22363005578517914,
0.32236623764038086,
0.49375396966934204,
-0.41442328691482544,
-0.3579102158546448,
-0.8944195508956909,
0.3901548981666565,
-0.5066373348236084,
-0.29512110352516174,
0.1493268758058548,
0.3750329613685608,
-0.3270852267742157,
0.17999641597270966,
-0.12293929606676102,
-0.350374311208725,
0.07744841277599335,
0.11307674646377563,
0.24267524480819702,
0.01650197245180607,
0.4557151198387146,
0.1719333827495575,
-0.19788430631160736,
0.2541658282279968,
-0.09473162889480591,
0.07931449264287949,
0.1835443079471588,
-0.24671295285224915,
-0.5328861474990845,
0.7671055197715759,
0.2867543399333954,
-0.2532684803009033,
0.8360468149185181,
0.6734535694122314,
-0.27066662907600403,
0.1546902358531952,
-0.6180607080459595,
-0.3848264217376709,
-0.4061013162136078,
0.6496168971061707,
-0.07236742228269577,
-0.5764704942703247,
0.6780036091804504,
-0.08345042914152145,
0.05416207015514374,
0.7606392502784729,
0.3848545551300049,
-0.46520429849624634,
0.6019152402877808,
0.3889583945274353,
-0.42579448223114014,
0.5548802018165588,
0.14178407192230225,
-0.023708399385213852,
-0.24640819430351257,
-0.2153489738702774,
-0.7209727168083191,
-0.26437562704086304,
-0.4725731611251831,
0.2249259203672409,
0.12815965712070465,
-0.05502377077937126,
-0.16808971762657166,
0.35413962602615356,
-0.38543081283569336,
0.508607029914856,
0.6250767111778259,
-0.023653535172343254,
0.43023642897605896,
0.3978146016597748,
0.26442697644233704,
0.029344020411372185,
-0.4017573297023773,
-0.5586689710617065,
0.8778141736984253,
-0.06012377142906189,
0.764471709728241,
-0.13328413665294647,
0.5480448007583618,
0.8347389698028564,
0.2188534438610077,
-0.6844316124916077,
0.46760067343711853,
0.07028988003730774,
-0.9877474308013916,
-0.31276392936706543,
-0.451995849609375,
-0.9830080270767212,
-0.057492174208164215,
-0.17460530996322632,
-0.9908617734909058,
0.14132413268089294,
-0.12843254208564758,
-0.16726821660995483,
0.14836366474628448,
-0.908582329750061,
0.782100260257721,
0.07975789159536362,
0.1530458629131317,
-0.17828837037086487,
-0.7459363341331482,
0.010498709976673126,
-0.372975617647171,
-0.06249060481786728,
-0.3887794315814972,
-0.24156098067760468,
1.336233377456665,
-0.3051230013370514,
0.7408680319786072,
-0.3689267039299011,
-0.40369805693626404,
0.26142236590385437,
-0.4347662031650543,
0.7356483340263367,
-0.15200531482696533,
-0.31935203075408936,
0.2446461170911789,
0.1113683208823204,
-0.27361637353897095,
-0.35779306292533875,
0.5211721062660217,
-0.4524122476577759,
-0.2520270347595215,
-0.2407469004392624,
-0.39423462748527527,
-0.29887744784355164,
0.28713634610176086,
0.5561007261276245,
0.3145069181919098,
-0.20040708780288696,
0.37362614274024963,
-0.014018254354596138,
0.21709808707237244,
0.264309823513031,
0.3625336289405823,
-0.00923517532646656,
-0.4529275596141815,
0.9284141659736633,
0.40834149718284607,
-0.049691591411828995,
-0.11439324915409088,
0.08268111199140549,
-0.44033706188201904,
-0.07272353768348694,
-0.44083330035209656,
0.11418217420578003,
-0.9941853284835815,
-0.39608824253082275,
-0.284685343503952,
-0.15190979838371277,
-0.24179215729236603,
-0.08135288208723068,
-0.22366151213645935,
-0.7795393466949463,
-0.291739821434021,
-0.40839672088623047,
0.5710126161575317,
0.6848543286323547,
0.1429697722196579,
0.5477103590965271,
-0.7216766476631165,
0.11089582741260529,
0.10996384173631668,
0.46928030252456665,
-0.24076305329799652,
-0.14707981050014496,
-0.6457823514938354,
0.058991044759750366,
-0.5545507669448853,
-1.1011276245117188,
-0.01853824220597744,
0.2206757515668869,
0.6800580024719238,
0.4019647538661957,
0.4215241074562073,
0.37141159176826477,
-0.2992675304412842,
0.6447437405586243,
0.34604158997535706,
-0.6621334552764893,
0.48615211248397827,
-0.4569317102432251,
0.056754227727651596,
0.6518464684486389,
0.28493204712867737,
-0.8419144749641418,
-0.4995790719985962,
-0.5672301650047302,
-0.7726631164550781,
0.8658416271209717,
0.23039358854293823,
0.3052852749824524,
0.07704956829547882,
0.3495197296142578,
0.551144540309906,
0.29084518551826477,
-0.5938402414321899,
-0.4413529932498932,
-0.18015725910663605,
-0.29981809854507446,
-0.03797163814306259,
-0.17058390378952026,
-0.4429914057254791,
-0.3107173442840576,
0.6935132741928101,
-0.11673199385404587,
0.36422765254974365,
-0.10566066205501556,
-0.18782265484333038,
-0.23134972155094147,
0.2277306467294693,
0.12387637048959732,
0.9117121696472168,
0.0005236733704805374,
-0.06127472221851349,
0.1463424265384674,
-0.3250105082988739,
0.07474017888307571,
0.5769509673118591,
-0.25718846917152405,
0.3273226022720337,
0.4577445089817047,
0.7823454141616821,
-0.016531795263290405,
-0.4049895703792572,
0.6777505874633789,
0.19070424139499664,
-0.42216187715530396,
-0.42320919036865234,
-0.17809703946113586,
0.1528104692697525,
0.44207629561424255,
1.0462206602096558,
-0.007670976687222719,
0.25234535336494446,
-0.08398937433958054,
0.3610513508319855,
0.26402777433395386,
-0.35498708486557007,
-0.2524787485599518,
0.33108118176460266,
0.21277201175689697,
-0.1016208678483963,
0.5328121781349182,
0.2039482593536377,
-0.3598521947860718,
0.09130155295133591,
0.1284247487783432,
0.9113926291465759,
0.02200966887176037,
0.5918959379196167,
0.1002320870757103,
-0.02640632912516594,
0.08762332051992416,
0.0264144167304039,
-0.16839836537837982,
-0.5374888181686401,
-0.6444507241249084,
-0.3511958122253418,
-0.28444403409957886,
0.11452409625053406,
-0.95710688829422,
0.22283990681171417,
0.046440962702035904,
-0.4442169964313507,
0.2440340220928192,
-0.026897232979536057,
-0.42106494307518005,
0.13589808344841003,
0.2646430432796478,
0.8548657298088074,
-1.095676064491272,
0.7287869453430176,
0.5848150849342346,
-0.4176008701324463,
-0.2815021574497223,
0.34667596220970154,
-0.10561808943748474,
-0.5604797601699829,
0.43024981021881104,
0.07086869329214096,
0.26718074083328247,
0.11302775144577026,
-0.8428668975830078,
-0.6966915130615234,
0.8729183673858643,
0.8869575262069702,
-0.0999830961227417,
0.013400264084339142,
0.24112732708454132,
0.1988072544336319,
-0.12683358788490295,
-0.049625057727098465,
0.4727754592895508,
0.7237846255302429,
-0.008617140352725983,
-0.8041236400604248,
0.0942583903670311,
-0.16435815393924713,
-0.39501285552978516,
0.07455417513847351,
-0.5113953948020935,
0.2429235577583313,
0.05092957615852356,
-0.0007293588132597506,
-0.11160359531641006,
0.7281039953231812,
-0.1429777443408966,
0.08296805620193481,
0.5751891732215881,
0.24071860313415527,
0.8111158609390259,
-0.02333296649158001,
0.9711061716079712,
0.1822340488433838,
0.42410704493522644,
1.1342225074768066,
-0.019834356382489204,
0.8119228482246399,
0.7391643524169922,
-0.3184197247028351,
0.5090928673744202,
0.5552259087562561,
-0.17693547904491425,
0.713771402835846,
0.16736586391925812,
-0.3440520465373993,
-0.13240398466587067,
-0.3121931850910187,
-0.07857806235551834,
0.4280802011489868,
0.06984318792819977,
-0.47059166431427,
-0.45341381430625916,
0.02665777876973152,
0.13938643038272858,
-0.2716559171676636,
-0.0535787008702755,
1.0037063360214233,
0.01941172033548355,
-0.5951250195503235,
0.23182447254657745,
-0.2070535123348236,
0.39347729086875916,
-0.6158724427223206,
0.2593593895435333,
-0.17913763225078583,
-0.023310737684369087,
-0.3953137993812561,
-1.0940178632736206,
0.3282249867916107,
0.16956999897956848,
-0.25447505712509155,
-0.026647023856639862,
0.6695561408996582,
-0.258617103099823,
-0.6930396556854248,
0.04443870484828949,
0.5727332830429077,
0.3786882758140564,
-0.35051894187927246,
-0.6161333322525024,
-0.22734230756759644,
-0.06883951276540756,
-0.6195051074028015,
0.09213121980428696,
0.6361938118934631,
-0.28104138374328613,
0.6223935484886169,
0.5115596055984497,
0.25657182931900024,
0.022587109357118607,
0.16360104084014893,
0.9764621257781982,
-0.535110592842102,
-0.405805379152298,
-0.7314144372940063,
0.44442591071128845,
-0.7562978863716125,
-0.35070595145225525,
0.9218204021453857,
0.65107661485672,
0.6455493569374084,
-0.09432241320610046,
1.2076388597488403,
-0.2035829871892929,
0.628492534160614,
-0.08754687011241913,
0.8803646564483643,
-0.533633828163147,
-0.3602927625179291,
-0.4829042851924896,
-0.9485575556755066,
-0.2795865833759308,
0.8306041359901428,
-0.3432304859161377,
0.003659285372123122,
0.4618850350379944,
0.3142642080783844,
-0.07813937962055206,
0.248930886387825,
0.12784434854984283,
0.03186935558915138,
0.25784099102020264,
-0.17075344920158386,
0.6909043788909912,
-0.15157964825630188,
0.8385794162750244,
-0.19168822467327118,
0.03853955119848251,
-0.4068542420864105,
-1.0904793739318848,
-0.5012063980102539,
-0.9516865611076355,
-0.36626654863357544,
-0.12379896640777588,
-0.006069102790206671,
0.9305856823921204,
0.6888994574546814,
-0.8257023692131042,
0.026353051885962486,
0.07010091841220856,
-0.17498090863227844,
-0.23444829881191254,
-0.2338724434375763,
0.5507599115371704,
-0.2510673403739929,
-0.43700093030929565,
-0.13877665996551514,
-0.19322341680526733,
-0.012528002262115479,
-0.16849404573440552,
-0.12162361294031143,
-0.13552221655845642,
-0.02599761076271534,
0.4325433671474457,
0.11559785902500153,
-0.6304047107696533,
-0.3135775625705719,
-0.4792514443397522,
-0.10256963223218918,
0.06589855253696442,
0.7633111476898193,
-0.6267730593681335,
0.22833220660686493,
0.2959444224834442,
0.4695476293563843,
0.45013514161109924,
0.21299056708812714,
0.494279682636261,
-0.9842106103897095,
0.22109629213809967,
0.07017157226800919,
0.292878657579422,
0.5196256041526794,
-0.35550373792648315,
0.36475658416748047,
0.3259829580783844,
-0.31824275851249695,
-0.5289819240570068,
-0.14460061490535736,
-0.86882483959198,
-0.16573643684387207,
1.2986210584640503,
-0.18685738742351532,
-0.07467807084321976,
-0.25163015723228455,
-0.4374012351036072,
0.340889573097229,
-0.8407765030860901,
0.6766949892044067,
1.169966459274292,
0.19826532900333405,
-0.13102677464485168,
-0.5963024497032166,
0.3661082088947296,
0.1934560388326645,
-0.8192389011383057,
0.5005323886871338,
0.7840330004692078,
0.23625268042087555,
-0.08182241022586823,
0.43519729375839233,
0.015548165887594223,
0.02592146210372448,
-0.07826210558414459,
0.08088038861751556,
-0.13191749155521393,
0.04269922897219658,
0.19579057395458221,
0.048568401485681534,
-0.16619031131267548,
-0.4378904104232788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16743v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16743v2
|
Automatic Speech Recognition System-Independent Word Error Rate Estimation
| 2024-04-25T16:57:05 | 2024-04-26T11:11:02 |
Chanho Park, Mingjie Chen, Thomas Hain
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Word error rate (WER) is a metric used to evaluate the quality of
transcriptions produced by Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems. In many
applications, it is of interest to estimate WER given a pair of a speech
utterance and a transcript. Previous work on WER estimation focused on building
models that are trained with a specific ASR system in mind (referred to as ASR
system-dependent). These are also domain-dependent and inflexible in real-world
applications. In this paper, a hypothesis generation method for ASR
System-Independent WER estimation (SIWE) is proposed. In contrast to prior
work, the WER estimators are trained using data that simulates ASR system
output. Hypotheses are generated using phonetically similar or linguistically
more likely alternative words. In WER estimation experiments, the proposed
method reaches a similar performance to ASR system-dependent WER estimators on
in-domain data and achieves state-of-the-art performance on out-of-domain data.
On the out-of-domain data, the SIWE model outperformed the baseline estimators
in root mean square error and Pearson correlation coefficient by relative
17.58% and 18.21%, respectively, on Switchboard and CALLHOME. The performance
was further improved when the WER of the training set was close to the WER of
the evaluation dataset.
|
[
-0.33610084652900696,
-0.38762935996055603,
0.1289079487323761,
0.002769814571365714,
-0.13835559785366058,
-0.15266624093055725,
-0.13810944557189941,
-0.4156404435634613,
0.03964623063802719,
0.1499917209148407,
-0.3134883642196655,
-0.18910348415374756,
-0.7201030850410461,
0.19043143093585968,
-0.3067386746406555,
0.2003718465566635,
0.234320268034935,
0.5616008043289185,
0.017033420503139496,
-0.1444275975227356,
-0.558601438999176,
-0.3792315721511841,
-0.3534483313560486,
-0.4332010746002197,
0.11770094186067581,
0.4590006172657013,
0.4013725817203522,
0.318599134683609,
0.5208306908607483,
0.3427366614341736,
0.14132216572761536,
-0.021211499348282814,
0.031138572841882706,
-0.08018103241920471,
0.0017257902072742581,
-0.486324280500412,
-0.34076160192489624,
0.10049394518136978,
0.6194171905517578,
0.6647534370422363,
-0.3196503221988678,
0.24508517980575562,
0.26383230090141296,
0.4723326861858368,
-0.5990311503410339,
0.058954786509275436,
-0.906101405620575,
0.020517343655228615,
-0.1747116893529892,
-0.3961760699748993,
-0.27286770939826965,
-0.4334111511707306,
0.462382435798645,
-0.5036791563034058,
0.5247734189033508,
0.03298022225499153,
0.6832844614982605,
0.31732597947120667,
0.0131332753226161,
-0.3652888536453247,
-0.6075348854064941,
0.8179478049278259,
-1.0856094360351562,
0.7786884903907776,
0.5627303719520569,
0.2115401178598404,
-0.501795768737793,
-0.3652070164680481,
-0.7720603942871094,
-0.23969683051109314,
0.057408418506383896,
0.26441487669944763,
-0.46544721722602844,
-0.2910750210285187,
0.2732308506965637,
0.06955479830503464,
-0.30127185583114624,
-0.10226975381374359,
-0.5184604525566101,
-0.5129114985466003,
0.803067147731781,
-0.12628629803657532,
0.4070596694946289,
-0.023566201329231262,
-0.2599252760410309,
-0.08776392042636871,
-0.4818529486656189,
0.2101343721151352,
0.2929624617099762,
0.6649877429008484,
0.17000038921833038,
0.7013285756111145,
-0.12984523177146912,
0.3357290029525757,
0.246541365981102,
-0.7511855959892273,
0.4536077380180359,
0.03255221247673035,
-0.12077333778142929,
0.4762091636657715,
0.9950113892555237,
0.38363349437713623,
0.03367339074611664,
-0.3677706718444824,
-0.48998239636421204,
0.8381643891334534,
0.09432840347290039,
-0.7287108898162842,
0.07954103499650955,
-0.02182546816766262,
-0.13612884283065796,
0.03429742157459259,
0.09731205552816391,
-0.5638697147369385,
-0.14321672916412354,
-0.11927372962236404,
0.9908343553543091,
-0.7560254335403442,
-0.30097097158432007,
-0.16803568601608276,
-0.3801882266998291,
-0.0905676782131195,
-0.10908696800470352,
-0.40676984190940857,
0.5557408332824707,
0.04170992597937584,
0.5546174049377441,
-0.47196412086486816,
-0.44010576605796814,
-0.800031840801239,
-0.006125551648437977,
-0.37250450253486633,
0.7117875814437866,
-0.0504562146961689,
-0.8356208205223083,
-0.31856632232666016,
-0.15963895618915558,
-0.1894674003124237,
-0.47208064794540405,
0.69340980052948,
-0.6471215486526489,
0.16572070121765137,
-0.00962074100971222,
-1.0157221555709839,
-0.11960316449403763,
-0.2883037328720093,
-0.3867012858390808,
0.8688868880271912,
-0.17385448515415192,
-1.105798602104187,
0.7875416874885559,
-0.781400740146637,
-0.5436208248138428,
0.14411991834640503,
-0.1386621594429016,
-0.44552481174468994,
0.05982774868607521,
0.12255506217479706,
0.311694860458374,
-0.38977622985839844,
0.19234754145145416,
-0.10649462044239044,
-0.6890618801116943,
0.34477531909942627,
-0.5491688251495361,
0.6139243841171265,
0.13358965516090393,
-0.7874424457550049,
-0.04606284946203232,
-1.046863079071045,
0.3113690912723541,
-0.014993179589509964,
-0.41552188992500305,
-0.6044912934303284,
0.1974714994430542,
-0.19385120272636414,
-0.14944587647914886,
0.10973864048719406,
-1.0003865957260132,
-0.33712220191955566,
-0.33258023858070374,
0.06405381113290787,
0.4259205758571625,
-0.020405245944857597,
0.34693244099617004,
-0.07157354056835175,
0.5631059408187866,
-0.13087429106235504,
-0.17536944150924683,
0.24160592257976532,
-0.5297611951828003,
-0.5373120307922363,
-0.302958607673645,
0.40531396865844727,
0.5762906670570374,
-0.32372865080833435,
0.623874843120575,
-0.2634342610836029,
-0.5516732335090637,
-0.5239973664283752,
-0.15806375443935394,
0.6205564141273499,
0.7093772888183594,
0.33956000208854675,
-0.36467811465263367,
-0.646091878414154,
-0.39754509925842285,
-0.3946826159954071,
-0.37232640385627747,
-0.07400636374950409,
-0.016689730808138847,
0.21572375297546387,
-0.27492108941078186,
1.2238094806671143,
-0.5270905494689941,
-0.35567665100097656,
-0.23091188073158264,
0.19511757791042328,
-0.0048026228323578835,
0.3386229872703552,
-0.1477610468864441,
-0.5554016828536987,
-0.558459997177124,
-0.315573513507843,
-0.47955238819122314,
-0.20277263224124908,
0.42191627621650696,
0.1538131684064865,
0.28292346000671387,
0.3364827334880829,
-0.04473669081926346,
0.9611735343933105,
0.6275016665458679,
-0.33196577429771423,
0.568372368812561,
-0.5510960817337036,
0.17009824514389038,
-0.8786652088165283,
-0.03106457181274891,
0.32473716139793396,
0.18881964683532715,
-0.5502873063087463,
-0.22911874949932098,
0.08082655072212219,
0.15302209556102753,
-0.0792454183101654,
0.3941285014152527,
-0.5454158186912537,
-0.35704562067985535,
-0.3196866512298584,
0.1212277039885521,
-0.07839193940162659,
0.2860525846481323,
0.13312512636184692,
1.165339469909668,
0.632408618927002,
-0.8593804836273193,
-0.1312866359949112,
0.40271350741386414,
-0.4893190562725067,
0.3430190682411194,
-0.6409849524497986,
0.24005842208862305,
0.1297740787267685,
0.07148420065641403,
-0.9841726422309875,
-0.176788330078125,
-0.20402337610721588,
-0.685540497303009,
0.2833298146724701,
-0.04060263931751251,
-0.0401001051068306,
-0.537371039390564,
0.04505480080842972,
-0.08204574882984161,
0.6218571066856384,
-0.561285674571991,
0.33103489875793457,
0.905276358127594,
-0.09936714172363281,
-0.44083085656166077,
-0.6189323663711548,
-0.2214784324169159,
-0.31103068590164185,
-0.5364472270011902,
0.2556498646736145,
-0.06186828017234802,
-0.27390697598457336,
-0.1880108267068863,
-0.19332675635814667,
-0.2624131143093109,
-0.2673211693763733,
0.5581527352333069,
0.3743503987789154,
-0.3813376724720001,
-0.11406639218330383,
-0.14740398526191711,
-0.17627649009227753,
0.018216131255030632,
-0.15719495713710785,
0.439927339553833,
0.000549626478459686,
-0.6221107244491577,
-0.7495704889297485,
0.3871826231479645,
0.43501585721969604,
-0.12042348831892014,
0.2956780195236206,
0.4226011037826538,
-0.4954734146595001,
-0.1264335811138153,
-0.7270460724830627,
-0.09553912281990051,
-0.45270344614982605,
0.2110716849565506,
-0.5589237809181213,
-0.2843390107154846,
0.3355269730091095,
0.10082877427339554,
-0.12193957716226578,
0.5548872947692871,
0.04690314456820488,
0.07011209428310394,
1.1211814880371094,
0.9159901142120361,
-0.14203709363937378,
0.29831114411354065,
-0.25235745310783386,
0.05440226569771767,
-0.7885105013847351,
0.026375586166977882,
-0.44554367661476135,
0.0459696501493454,
-0.466695636510849,
-0.24432584643363953,
0.6281506419181824,
0.3081457018852234,
-0.06490597873926163,
0.4335835874080658,
-0.3314156234264374,
-0.13437014818191528,
0.947537362575531,
0.1189112663269043,
0.3656192123889923,
0.2132870852947235,
-0.32845330238342285,
-0.24108704924583435,
-0.6866681575775146,
-0.32426372170448303,
1.060050368309021,
0.1677694022655487,
0.8180186748504639,
-0.03269929066300392,
0.7756087779998779,
0.33641317486763,
0.36962759494781494,
-0.8367179036140442,
0.35688516497612,
-0.2266443818807602,
-0.35882240533828735,
-0.7900550365447998,
-0.36753517389297485,
-0.6661059260368347,
0.12195013463497162,
0.011576631106436253,
-0.8065991997718811,
0.24568761885166168,
0.4455792307853699,
-0.3697309195995331,
0.19963058829307556,
-0.6808014512062073,
0.21181128919124603,
0.039275217801332474,
0.11571986228227615,
-0.060032639652490616,
-0.43611982464790344,
0.04494462534785271,
-0.24156345427036285,
0.18947608768939972,
-0.09973660111427307,
0.23376521468162537,
1.0751450061798096,
-0.7808051109313965,
0.5852831602096558,
-0.5193586945533752,
-0.11455292999744415,
0.7286571264266968,
-0.27324822545051575,
0.5773215889930725,
-0.43749547004699707,
-0.7225422263145447,
0.3174828290939331,
-0.0670209527015686,
0.14518967270851135,
-0.23100414872169495,
0.2572475075721741,
-0.8271018862724304,
-0.33735376596450806,
-0.3813110291957855,
-0.36595162749290466,
-0.6871150732040405,
0.10174640268087387,
0.9816703796386719,
0.8158218264579773,
-0.3885418176651001,
-0.17587175965309143,
0.23859797418117523,
-0.046389661729335785,
0.4037317633628845,
0.6834184527397156,
-0.046293530613183975,
-0.4759405255317688,
1.0061726570129395,
0.36575570702552795,
0.3084716200828552,
0.07896504551172256,
0.5812283158302307,
-0.549470067024231,
-0.4228489100933075,
-0.5564457774162292,
-0.11274904012680054,
-0.49426892399787903,
-0.29001104831695557,
-0.6718453168869019,
-0.4652014970779419,
-0.3688085973262787,
0.005353493615984917,
-0.3387519419193268,
-0.17208555340766907,
0.08174263685941696,
0.2683088779449463,
0.615833580493927,
0.6125678420066833,
-0.2942773699760437,
0.5246888399124146,
-0.809598982334137,
0.3214046061038971,
0.2450273483991623,
0.21670255064964294,
-0.16100051999092102,
-0.9960489869117737,
-0.004821949638426304,
0.22290368378162384,
0.045871902257204056,
-0.7573630809783936,
0.5437970161437988,
0.4871324896812439,
0.7467545866966248,
0.12811706960201263,
0.17807571589946747,
0.8718081116676331,
-0.8235689997673035,
0.5188720226287842,
0.6832171678543091,
-0.969013512134552,
0.6221704483032227,
-0.09879133105278015,
0.24631474912166595,
0.4792466461658478,
0.0797487124800682,
-0.294254332780838,
-0.3473949432373047,
-0.6556965708732605,
-0.7206697463989258,
0.5922532677650452,
-0.02393147349357605,
-0.2154332548379898,
0.0056777531281113625,
0.11327510327100754,
0.27938568592071533,
0.08440756052732468,
-0.14163555204868317,
-0.3367972671985626,
-0.03487542271614075,
-0.021489832550287247,
-0.0789615660905838,
-0.09723321348428726,
0.19430460035800934,
-0.18103797733783722,
1.2002328634262085,
-0.33966830372810364,
0.3821375072002411,
0.35580313205718994,
-0.22425523400306702,
-0.6092718243598938,
0.35724976658821106,
0.23178382217884064,
0.7754302620887756,
-0.2915914058685303,
-0.008208063431084156,
0.4475601315498352,
-0.9240010380744934,
0.3184335231781006,
0.04047822207212448,
-0.4302094280719757,
0.35595956444740295,
-0.03804495930671692,
0.7017723917961121,
-0.13556262850761414,
-0.6377100944519043,
0.6791053414344788,
-0.30645331740379333,
-0.04742591828107834,
-0.42196834087371826,
0.14161308109760284,
0.0001383669296046719,
0.1538214236497879,
0.6523498296737671,
0.40763282775878906,
0.25790396332740784,
-0.30832692980766296,
0.4685378670692444,
0.5873579978942871,
-0.5879888534545898,
-0.3736453950405121,
0.6615971326828003,
-0.014417626895010471,
-0.4416608214378357,
0.005810796748846769,
-0.30590561032295227,
-0.6791887283325195,
0.32813560962677,
1.1093978881835938,
0.8542414903640747,
-0.5744569897651672,
0.07525456696748734,
0.4634682536125183,
-0.09969529509544373,
-0.26048851013183594,
0.5924460887908936,
0.2704635560512543,
-1.175621747970581,
-0.1893748790025711,
-0.8983734846115112,
-0.40266796946525574,
0.22708486020565033,
-0.9604637622833252,
0.22434605658054352,
-0.10575457662343979,
-0.5440863966941833,
0.0338837169110775,
0.0997316911816597,
-0.6623789668083191,
0.6999759674072266,
0.018834881484508514,
0.803113579750061,
-0.5446818470954895,
0.8225030899047852,
0.4232042729854584,
-0.18178710341453552,
-1.2240372896194458,
0.47642242908477783,
-0.06999479234218597,
-0.7876326441764832,
0.7682359218597412,
-0.14516803622245789,
-0.8734679222106934,
-0.058837465941905975,
-0.1623178869485855,
-1.2086318731307983,
1.019036889076233,
0.19548316299915314,
-0.7288958430290222,
0.2205956131219864,
0.01866176351904869,
0.22846072912216187,
-0.29131534695625305,
-0.15446661412715912,
0.6119750738143921,
0.13989174365997314,
0.08176203817129135,
-1.0441683530807495,
-0.10086219012737274,
-0.19329692423343658,
0.024065133184194565,
0.02468852512538433,
-0.41039714217185974,
0.379058301448822,
-0.5988200902938843,
-0.17734000086784363,
0.12595516443252563,
1.0089714527130127,
0.43417519330978394,
0.30983179807662964,
0.9850965738296509,
0.15582223236560822,
0.9030773639678955,
0.2533847391605377,
0.6531732678413391,
-0.32758599519729614,
0.066872738301754,
1.294981598854065,
-0.3098430335521698,
1.199363350868225,
0.5574356913566589,
-0.4837181270122528,
0.10119128972291946,
0.19362732768058777,
0.2276034951210022,
0.6382850408554077,
0.27540379762649536,
-0.29602083563804626,
0.22255221009254456,
0.0820685401558876,
-0.3575601279735565,
0.7321687936782837,
0.44525405764579773,
-0.021726908162236214,
0.13378992676734924,
-0.023733491078019142,
-0.06577737629413605,
-0.15079601109027863,
-0.16889941692352295,
0.7335203289985657,
-0.04209885373711586,
-0.6001420617103577,
0.47494038939476013,
-0.08761640638113022,
1.0688598155975342,
-0.5993455648422241,
0.08895136415958405,
-0.04334419220685959,
0.45240485668182373,
-0.03850205987691879,
-0.07556916773319244,
0.023091141134500504,
0.3960992395877838,
-0.3045351803302765,
0.4004831910133362,
0.8560952544212341,
-0.38301047682762146,
-0.9016121029853821,
0.3356148302555084,
0.5542899370193481,
0.32770439982414246,
0.18665677309036255,
-0.296697199344635,
0.05172725021839142,
0.03519021347165108,
-0.12268129736185074,
0.1523200422525406,
0.2939606010913849,
-0.04825752601027489,
0.38373732566833496,
0.5320466756820679,
0.37908291816711426,
0.2719886898994446,
0.14837367832660675,
0.3706616759300232,
-0.3272761404514313,
-0.6842166185379028,
-0.46840962767601013,
0.4164789021015167,
-0.05900200456380844,
-0.46409717202186584,
0.758874237537384,
0.5230234861373901,
0.4005594253540039,
0.23544389009475708,
1.251541256904602,
-0.1411757618188858,
1.103722333908081,
-0.1843421310186386,
0.8591136932373047,
-0.40868890285491943,
0.18198755383491516,
-0.6160120368003845,
-0.6882697939872742,
0.04772650822997093,
0.7477220296859741,
-0.13759028911590576,
-0.3520261347293854,
0.47951796650886536,
0.7433232069015503,
-0.12144479900598526,
0.40571799874305725,
0.6154617667198181,
0.11092667281627655,
0.009107263758778572,
-0.3784751892089844,
0.638379693031311,
-0.8138636350631714,
0.3079213798046112,
-0.40050581097602844,
-0.5353880524635315,
0.03617317974567413,
-0.6984074711799622,
-0.3075083792209625,
-0.6082031726837158,
-0.3541601896286011,
-0.46811342239379883,
0.03718871623277664,
1.001499056816101,
0.5301627516746521,
-1.0849591493606567,
-0.479667603969574,
-0.037899088114500046,
-0.4776841104030609,
-0.2194637656211853,
-0.16123931109905243,
0.646894097328186,
-0.2640128433704376,
-0.46292123198509216,
0.7991960644721985,
-0.032714489847421646,
0.019388239830732346,
-0.05488063022494316,
-0.27257758378982544,
0.08795870095491409,
0.3516313135623932,
0.29284268617630005,
0.23451855778694153,
-0.6827167272567749,
-0.6064623594284058,
0.13706514239311218,
-0.08390310406684875,
0.035096097737550735,
0.3888697028160095,
-0.5918700098991394,
0.33633050322532654,
0.18450357019901276,
0.34879621863365173,
0.3363514840602875,
-0.11212291568517685,
0.8137867450714111,
-0.596469521522522,
0.06412656605243683,
-0.12862226366996765,
0.6607072353363037,
0.4770674407482147,
-0.30382341146469116,
0.3654190003871918,
0.21532811224460602,
-0.40104272961616516,
-0.7920448780059814,
-0.16909222304821014,
-0.6209108233451843,
0.26388296484947205,
1.1024608612060547,
-0.33578184247016907,
-0.18345943093299866,
-0.028426600620150566,
-0.14137212932109833,
0.5826857089996338,
-0.5275672078132629,
0.7048574686050415,
0.22686877846717834,
-0.4264400601387024,
0.5722202658653259,
-0.2583191394805908,
0.4905640780925751,
-0.012024754658341408,
-0.5983872413635254,
-0.12687861919403076,
0.3843945860862732,
0.7987338304519653,
0.5489493012428284,
0.9340827465057373,
0.0739143118262291,
0.19061578810214996,
0.40609636902809143,
0.43476343154907227,
0.4634833335876465,
-0.0614585243165493,
0.013854709453880787,
0.10937444120645523,
-0.0451139360666275,
-0.6124234795570374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16710v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16710v2
|
LayerSkip: Enabling Early Exit Inference and Self-Speculative Decoding
| 2024-04-25T16:20:23 | 2024-04-29T15:02:36 |
Mostafa Elhoushi, Akshat Shrivastava, Diana Liskovich, Basil Hosmer, Bram Wasti, Liangzhen Lai, Anas Mahmoud, Bilge Acun, Saurabh Agarwal, Ahmed Roman, Ahmed A Aly, Beidi Chen, Carole-Jean Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We present LayerSkip, an end-to-end solution to speed-up inference of large
language models (LLMs). First, during training we apply layer dropout, with low
dropout rates for earlier layers and higher dropout rates for later layers, and
an early exit loss where all transformer layers share the same exit. Second,
during inference, we show that this training recipe increases the accuracy of
early exit at earlier layers, without adding any auxiliary layers or modules to
the model. Third, we present a novel self-speculative decoding solution where
we exit at early layers and verify and correct with remaining layers of the
model. Our proposed self-speculative decoding approach has less memory
footprint than other speculative decoding approaches and benefits from shared
compute and activations of the draft and verification stages. We run
experiments on different Llama model sizes on different types of training:
pretraining from scratch, continual pretraining, finetuning on specific data
domain, and finetuning on specific task. We implement our inference solution
and show speedups of up to 2.16x on summarization for CNN/DM documents, 1.82x
on coding, and 2.0x on TOPv2 semantic parsing task.
|
[
-0.1630491465330124,
-0.6220119595527649,
0.7731353640556335,
0.4053857922554016,
-0.16660667955875397,
0.2604476511478424,
-0.31127431988716125,
-0.46660077571868896,
0.16598623991012573,
0.7122370004653931,
-0.5932623744010925,
-0.3614918291568756,
-0.7372873425483704,
-0.2706863582134247,
-0.6185619235038757,
0.6084583401679993,
-0.09920261800289154,
-0.19538241624832153,
-0.3387830853462219,
0.6611660122871399,
0.08552221953868866,
-0.4472331404685974,
-0.9257829189300537,
-0.5200614929199219,
0.4887756407260895,
0.7232153415679932,
0.4354628920555115,
0.8472191691398621,
0.10025402158498764,
0.2855890989303589,
-0.20174868404865265,
0.2306746542453766,
-0.522812008857727,
0.0675235390663147,
0.11972338706254959,
-0.49956828355789185,
-0.2801777720451355,
0.015545460395514965,
0.3419354557991028,
0.554569661617279,
-0.4047730267047882,
0.1441430002450943,
-0.15212289988994598,
0.6821917295455933,
-0.8717934489250183,
-0.032016150653362274,
-0.5186550617218018,
0.5223487615585327,
-0.14125195145606995,
-0.4109368324279785,
-0.7458513975143433,
0.3299826681613922,
0.050034455955028534,
-0.7066044807434082,
0.21950511634349823,
-0.059129782021045685,
0.704131543636322,
0.3725595474243164,
-0.3752632439136505,
-0.08961005508899689,
-0.7212380170822144,
0.674267053604126,
-1.026292085647583,
0.6113083362579346,
0.48362377285957336,
0.26010894775390625,
-0.19872194528579712,
-0.9492757320404053,
-0.784152090549469,
-0.28550106287002563,
0.17015483975410461,
0.19478198885917664,
0.06301531940698624,
0.011375078931450844,
0.24928730726242065,
0.2992815673351288,
-0.26205700635910034,
0.45774808526039124,
-0.0737016350030899,
-0.24628949165344238,
0.43682801723480225,
0.09433285892009735,
0.08660390973091125,
-0.25861141085624695,
-0.46790775656700134,
-0.09369413554668427,
-0.5863694548606873,
-0.002252289094030857,
0.4676656424999237,
-0.04970251023769379,
-0.3737281560897827,
0.3433970510959625,
-0.5779706239700317,
0.39462339878082275,
0.18521730601787567,
-0.08912543952465057,
0.1052141860127449,
0.09002965688705444,
-0.2980043590068817,
0.16960497200489044,
0.8370494842529297,
0.31176021695137024,
0.024241356179118156,
-0.5416152477264404,
-0.0928175076842308,
-0.12726034224033356,
0.034976109862327576,
-0.8061299920082092,
-0.39925700426101685,
0.541461169719696,
-0.48230668902397156,
-0.46386709809303284,
-0.5313262939453125,
-0.5902767181396484,
-0.21265889704227448,
-0.19785186648368835,
0.17578625679016113,
-0.3817066252231598,
-0.39180147647857666,
0.45654645562171936,
-0.21581541001796722,
0.4820191562175751,
0.2597882151603699,
-1.0931607484817505,
0.552456259727478,
0.6651590466499329,
0.7429753541946411,
-0.24234730005264282,
-0.47128868103027344,
-0.386034220457077,
0.3682650327682495,
-0.5021327137947083,
0.9139221906661987,
-0.3453539311885834,
-0.11923421174287796,
-0.37548092007637024,
-0.1807643175125122,
0.11550378054380417,
-0.2879905700683594,
0.8425993323326111,
-0.8340197801589966,
0.14644955098628998,
-0.13704073429107666,
-0.6688282489776611,
0.04658697545528412,
0.19875980913639069,
-0.4723275899887085,
1.0849511623382568,
-0.22945638000965118,
-0.6917386651039124,
0.2406921684741974,
-0.35612034797668457,
-0.40527328848838806,
-0.2284487932920456,
-0.049408383667469025,
-0.16957461833953857,
0.3143828213214874,
0.4486231803894043,
0.7659624814987183,
-0.5265747904777527,
0.03633605316281319,
-0.3235979676246643,
-0.20371411740779877,
-0.051283448934555054,
-0.20791953802108765,
0.6526407599449158,
0.3695005178451538,
-0.3938770294189453,
-0.20621202886104584,
-0.9374616742134094,
0.29924023151397705,
0.40948742628097534,
-0.2691211700439453,
-0.2675071060657501,
0.12841075658798218,
-0.01825990341603756,
0.36141490936279297,
0.2781360447406769,
-0.6551327705383301,
0.1401340812444687,
-0.12384460121393204,
0.5619744658470154,
0.8828042149543762,
-0.11653859913349152,
0.33959901332855225,
0.16021902859210968,
0.49289336800575256,
0.5060740113258362,
0.16412639617919922,
-0.2599007189273834,
-0.44398170709609985,
-1.078665018081665,
-0.1018407866358757,
0.346996933221817,
0.5620334148406982,
-0.8959604501724243,
0.6061331629753113,
-0.18007299304008484,
-0.6262163519859314,
-0.2565891146659851,
0.07006623595952988,
0.5099178552627563,
0.7044677138328552,
0.25804781913757324,
-0.2318171113729477,
-0.4342365264892578,
-1.0122984647750854,
-0.23694883286952972,
-0.09738121181726456,
-0.08219543844461441,
0.06410804390907288,
0.3086511790752411,
-0.10825077444314957,
0.6584343314170837,
-0.5717700719833374,
0.07370821386575699,
-0.21918828785419464,
-0.07734327018260956,
0.3414655923843384,
0.518337070941925,
0.14070451259613037,
-0.43759244680404663,
-0.38136759400367737,
0.08025380969047546,
-0.8088046312332153,
0.0009619712946005166,
-0.33279502391815186,
-0.43547195196151733,
-0.020718568935990334,
0.572959840297699,
-0.993168830871582,
-0.11372914165258408,
0.5758094191551208,
-0.3949209749698639,
0.4907310903072357,
-0.268194317817688,
0.0946299284696579,
-1.0656059980392456,
-0.18046610057353973,
-0.13038921356201172,
-0.2324325442314148,
-0.7004959583282471,
0.018214594572782516,
0.35389602184295654,
-0.07628042250871658,
-0.4643135964870453,
0.37419360876083374,
-0.6440511345863342,
-0.17004339396953583,
-0.06557484716176987,
0.08189892023801804,
0.18919731676578522,
0.48771005868911743,
0.2475108951330185,
0.6745345592498779,
0.6407393217086792,
-0.5885076522827148,
0.11549795418977737,
-0.05591489002108574,
-0.30057981610298157,
-0.25197750329971313,
-0.656610369682312,
0.6680859327316284,
-0.06436385959386826,
0.3562847077846527,
-0.8006323575973511,
-0.1973537653684616,
0.1706984043121338,
-0.28625765442848206,
0.4568418860435486,
-0.13490663468837738,
-0.5243254899978638,
-0.4461957812309265,
-0.314185231924057,
0.28287479281425476,
0.4698698818683624,
-0.7329269051551819,
0.6848205924034119,
0.258927583694458,
0.2732617259025574,
-1.031090259552002,
-0.9773262143135071,
0.4482564628124237,
-0.027374504134058952,
-0.7167820930480957,
0.31577268242836,
-0.07247143238782883,
0.20915518701076508,
0.018657831475138664,
0.006339686922729015,
-0.1502455621957779,
0.13035450875759125,
0.01496074628084898,
-0.13074928522109985,
-0.3543902635574341,
-0.3426785469055176,
0.4023600220680237,
-0.4412393867969513,
0.24915774166584015,
-0.6672503352165222,
0.7186970710754395,
-0.06912738084793091,
-0.3113326132297516,
-0.396794855594635,
0.3243090510368347,
0.32388606667518616,
-0.1352311223745346,
0.8769292831420898,
0.5446951985359192,
-0.3224569857120514,
-0.5542948246002197,
-0.8465844392776489,
0.026901857927441597,
-0.5058221220970154,
0.26981475949287415,
-0.569037914276123,
-0.7647498846054077,
0.8440037369728088,
-0.08030271530151367,
-0.18753178417682648,
0.5444921255111694,
0.6444457769393921,
-0.0786307081580162,
0.6335747241973877,
0.6597657203674316,
-0.02820631116628647,
0.27278390526771545,
-0.472146213054657,
0.3242638409137726,
-0.831720769405365,
-0.3752231001853943,
-0.2371264100074768,
-0.16028635203838348,
-0.21645186841487885,
-0.615978479385376,
-0.025135697796940804,
0.38342976570129395,
0.1735173612833023,
0.1553317755460739,
-0.306904673576355,
1.0504860877990723,
0.4695177972316742,
0.2078414112329483,
0.35080602765083313,
0.04979915916919708,
-0.07601580768823624,
0.019457371905446053,
-0.8898459076881409,
-0.22665934264659882,
1.193572759628296,
0.5367636680603027,
0.7333765625953674,
0.004201267380267382,
0.937866747379303,
0.3845069706439972,
0.10911616683006287,
-0.6884912252426147,
0.5926083326339722,
-0.188179612159729,
-0.38257718086242676,
-0.1852523535490036,
-0.40805062651634216,
-0.4727310240268707,
0.11709161847829819,
0.05157453566789627,
-0.564935028553009,
0.2876092493534088,
0.22125951945781708,
-0.3162347376346588,
0.4818589389324188,
-0.9259755611419678,
0.8625829815864563,
-0.09172677248716354,
-0.3067488968372345,
-0.2542824447154999,
-0.722564160823822,
0.8332720994949341,
-0.005575147457420826,
-0.239187091588974,
-0.18367038667201996,
-0.3007243871688843,
0.7704578638076782,
-0.3544493615627289,
0.8634743094444275,
-0.17344167828559875,
-0.2642061412334442,
0.3623727262020111,
0.14321357011795044,
0.49007120728492737,
-0.021184980869293213,
-0.1888967603445053,
0.4958062171936035,
-0.10552356392145157,
-0.3692874014377594,
-0.6146051287651062,
0.7928606271743774,
-1.0381293296813965,
-0.30172282457351685,
-0.1569739282131195,
-0.444177508354187,
-0.15573668479919434,
0.15306025743484497,
0.2683374583721161,
0.39374276995658875,
0.2614733874797821,
-0.004216855391860008,
0.7617170214653015,
-0.16151033341884613,
0.4971729516983032,
0.5832976698875427,
-0.009064699523150921,
-0.26032745838165283,
0.8407159447669983,
-0.04252292588353157,
0.41028010845184326,
0.5308149456977844,
0.40400996804237366,
-0.387456476688385,
-0.884345531463623,
-0.6174691915512085,
0.16565974056720734,
-0.9956117868423462,
-0.17132450640201569,
-0.9332818388938904,
-0.42206835746765137,
-0.5186808705329895,
-0.034137167036533356,
-0.6880753636360168,
-0.7689993977546692,
-0.054715514183044434,
-0.07503147423267365,
0.033845093101263046,
0.6148234605789185,
-0.12102946639060974,
0.4806468188762665,
-0.6978572607040405,
0.38760697841644287,
0.027947090566158295,
0.2908186912536621,
0.26512816548347473,
-0.8022727370262146,
-0.43764740228652954,
-0.6137195825576782,
-0.08692556619644165,
-0.7655148506164551,
0.27375951409339905,
0.3167358934879303,
0.6311676502227783,
0.5562193989753723,
0.013352415524423122,
0.5925182104110718,
-0.6437057852745056,
0.9104431867599487,
0.19200299680233002,
-1.0289855003356934,
0.49778538942337036,
-0.37495502829551697,
0.27430787682533264,
0.31350773572921753,
0.3967350423336029,
-0.6012511849403381,
-0.2964175045490265,
-0.5048897862434387,
-0.7795218825340271,
0.6470934748649597,
0.03579025715589523,
0.04327787458896637,
-0.22224579751491547,
0.6360017657279968,
0.12687689065933228,
0.041526831686496735,
-0.6290441155433655,
-0.3370667099952698,
-0.10002375394105911,
-0.016502458602190018,
-0.12398207187652588,
-0.6670483946800232,
-0.01396180409938097,
-0.09660346806049347,
0.7016339898109436,
-0.30199894309043884,
0.2824469208717346,
0.28409895300865173,
-0.13849027454853058,
-0.19942361116409302,
0.19283618032932281,
0.4500037729740143,
0.6008800268173218,
-0.05646442994475365,
0.28574299812316895,
0.2628365159034729,
-0.45116284489631653,
0.2645217776298523,
-0.03304266929626465,
-0.21948635578155518,
-0.31510117650032043,
0.6441240310668945,
0.657984733581543,
0.3499447703361511,
-0.4839513599872589,
0.3650258183479309,
-0.34720954298973083,
-0.17240391671657562,
-0.4249444007873535,
0.014403602108359337,
0.259893536567688,
0.3787113428115845,
0.38337647914886475,
-0.07694196701049805,
0.34684890508651733,
-0.18383094668388367,
0.16887931525707245,
0.17690834403038025,
0.2201077789068222,
-0.20714271068572998,
0.8098171949386597,
0.11258967220783234,
-0.07701241970062256,
0.5866862535476685,
-0.191824808716774,
-0.3424587547779083,
0.6593545079231262,
0.7731184959411621,
1.2247682809829712,
-0.20463670790195465,
0.22029539942741394,
0.12524011731147766,
0.4046339690685272,
-0.08015678077936172,
0.07228181511163712,
-0.5063899159431458,
-0.873678982257843,
-0.8819722533226013,
-0.7949793934822083,
-0.5121715664863586,
0.19148994982242584,
-0.6195229291915894,
0.061704572290182114,
-0.69642174243927,
0.25814029574394226,
-0.22095783054828644,
0.05467263236641884,
-0.5433472990989685,
0.28843778371810913,
0.5849211812019348,
1.243533730506897,
-0.7422116994857788,
0.9508633017539978,
0.2265573889017105,
0.04332250356674194,
-0.6504071354866028,
-0.009890138171613216,
-0.06362240761518478,
-0.8882702589035034,
0.8389648199081421,
0.1951705664396286,
-0.40507587790489197,
0.07893713563680649,
-0.596342146396637,
-1.0697741508483887,
1.142395257949829,
0.5854564309120178,
-0.6088487505912781,
-0.3329550623893738,
0.14924821257591248,
0.4170713722705841,
-0.419318288564682,
0.577953577041626,
0.7759742736816406,
0.05762115865945816,
0.17079603672027588,
-0.45021966099739075,
0.10184984654188156,
-0.21781961619853973,
-0.0006929556257091463,
0.07454352080821991,
-0.7151170969009399,
0.8306541442871094,
-0.35467299818992615,
-0.09136361628770828,
-0.012669937685132027,
1.0869885683059692,
-0.009071625769138336,
0.18584783375263214,
0.7140297293663025,
0.8987768888473511,
0.5412186980247498,
0.18273866176605225,
1.278773546218872,
-0.6989395618438721,
0.2720433175563812,
1.1931558847427368,
0.05259114131331444,
1.134508490562439,
0.4808673560619354,
-0.035410523414611816,
0.545281708240509,
0.936996340751648,
0.532149076461792,
0.6203807592391968,
-0.07046268880367279,
-0.2254144698381424,
-0.626423180103302,
0.06851237267255783,
-0.4647667109966278,
0.5329707264900208,
0.39655929803848267,
-0.2125261425971985,
-0.1820695549249649,
-0.40926873683929443,
0.006919517181813717,
-0.29177340865135193,
0.009994509629905224,
0.43247658014297485,
0.2481682449579239,
-0.5426071286201477,
0.4300726056098938,
0.08571062237024307,
0.5272824168205261,
-0.8467179536819458,
0.2086305469274521,
-0.35687580704689026,
0.21963141858577728,
-0.2510296702384949,
-0.7255361080169678,
-0.049415405839681625,
-0.25658538937568665,
-0.23054681718349457,
-0.22283504903316498,
0.9370809197425842,
-0.4523683786392212,
-0.52983558177948,
0.5644347667694092,
0.5241132974624634,
0.2514937222003937,
-0.03787075728178024,
-0.7191839218139648,
0.16378100216388702,
-0.24609987437725067,
-0.7734451293945312,
0.15965153276920319,
0.5838869214057922,
0.34193143248558044,
0.7848400473594666,
0.9188126921653748,
0.17410345375537872,
0.4122854769229889,
0.33924034237861633,
1.1065760850906372,
-0.7466239929199219,
-0.8167515993118286,
-0.8526736497879028,
0.4800584614276886,
-0.22375793755054474,
-0.34825992584228516,
0.8103531002998352,
0.4882577955722809,
0.7209754586219788,
-0.16518716514110565,
0.4090268611907959,
0.10352522879838943,
0.26208260655403137,
-1.0322092771530151,
0.5913903117179871,
-0.4368392825126648,
0.43038564920425415,
-0.06426824629306793,
-0.9029459953308105,
0.05310504510998726,
0.1899913102388382,
-0.13021838665008545,
0.06226377934217453,
0.655780553817749,
0.5152143239974976,
-0.3227311968803406,
-0.03860349953174591,
0.41078004240989685,
0.36305516958236694,
0.5781305432319641,
0.777367353439331,
0.944434642791748,
-0.539947509765625,
0.22090135514736176,
-0.7666803002357483,
-0.23415905237197876,
0.1598464399576187,
-1.1113356351852417,
-1.0314995050430298,
-0.31797340512275696,
-0.20393507182598114,
-0.2705986499786377,
-0.08855585753917694,
0.6039621829986572,
0.9538735747337341,
-0.4927936792373657,
-0.19833585619926453,
0.02551914192736149,
-0.13211794197559357,
-0.07663969695568085,
-0.20714429020881653,
0.26616114377975464,
-0.49907514452934265,
-0.3230048418045044,
0.7476217746734619,
0.26045700907707214,
-0.27094388008117676,
-0.6542038917541504,
-0.22498995065689087,
-0.058569326996803284,
-0.002497485838830471,
0.6694381237030029,
0.26046720147132874,
-0.8754963874816895,
-0.08025061339139938,
-0.1724015772342682,
0.08941507339477539,
-0.025149067863821983,
1.0140812397003174,
-0.7945623397827148,
0.28420063853263855,
0.4085279703140259,
1.0377976894378662,
1.0749586820602417,
-0.2983368933200836,
0.5463523864746094,
-0.7096699476242065,
0.45493677258491516,
-0.022151680663228035,
0.18209971487522125,
0.23546914756298065,
-0.6694841384887695,
0.391028493642807,
0.1973162442445755,
-0.5815367698669434,
-0.7535499930381775,
0.09935295581817627,
-1.0498427152633667,
0.05066130310297012,
0.8424854874610901,
-0.1134377270936966,
-0.693664014339447,
0.1655884087085724,
0.24650579690933228,
0.0366046205163002,
-0.35450637340545654,
0.704535722732544,
0.6896593570709229,
-0.24562816321849823,
-0.5833185911178589,
-0.6509487628936768,
0.4753875732421875,
0.5593376159667969,
-1.084376573562622,
0.26064953207969666,
0.18474994599819183,
0.18073931336402893,
0.254383385181427,
0.8943043947219849,
0.17913930118083954,
0.18635746836662292,
0.39424872398376465,
0.11740311980247498,
-0.25871193408966064,
-0.5954362154006958,
-0.20081542432308197,
0.033915575593709946,
-0.08556074649095535,
-0.004821998067200184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16698v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16698v2
|
Cooperate or Collapse: Emergence of Sustainability Behaviors in a Society of LLM Agents
| 2024-04-25T15:59:16 | 2024-05-31T14:03:10 |
Giorgio Piatti, Zhijing Jin, Max Kleiman-Weiner, Bernhard Schölkopf, Mrinmaya Sachan, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As AI systems pervade human life, ensuring that large language models (LLMs)
make safe decisions is a significant challenge. This paper introduces the
Governance of the Commons Simulation (GovSim), a generative simulation platform
designed to study strategic interactions and cooperative decision-making in
LLMs. Using GovSim, we investigate the dynamics of sustainable resource sharing
in a society of AI agents. This environment allows us to study the influence of
ethical considerations, strategic planning, and negotiation skills on
cooperative outcomes for AI agents. We develop an LLM-based agent architecture
designed for these social dilemmas and test it with a variety of LLMs. We find
that all but the most powerful LLM agents fail to achieve a sustainable
equilibrium in GovSim. Ablations reveal that successful multi-agent
communication between agents is critical for achieving cooperation in these
cases. Furthermore, our analyses show that the failure to achieve sustainable
cooperation in most LLMs stems from their inability to formulate and analyze
hypotheses about the long-term effects of their actions on the equilibrium of
the group. Finally, we show that agents that leverage
``Universalization''-based reasoning, a theory of moral thinking, are able to
achieve significantly greater sustainability. Taken together, GovSim enables us
to study the mechanisms that underlie sustainable self-government with
significant specificity and scale. We open source the full suite of our
research results, including the simulation environment, agent prompts, and a
comprehensive web interface.
|
[
-0.4961860775947571,
-0.5225225687026978,
0.6910701990127563,
-0.055191587656736374,
0.020871423184871674,
0.20807567238807678,
-0.07889004051685333,
-0.3521023690700531,
0.26748126745224,
0.7568028569221497,
-0.4959940016269684,
-0.309301495552063,
-0.342075914144516,
0.03134894371032715,
0.10205485671758652,
0.8841228485107422,
0.42619794607162476,
0.13281786441802979,
-0.7098146677017212,
-0.3928772211074829,
-0.3935307562351227,
-0.16281063854694366,
-1.0681707859039307,
-0.47554048895835876,
0.42468294501304626,
0.41621771454811096,
1.0777602195739746,
0.4947342872619629,
0.31836962699890137,
0.5776384472846985,
-0.2556212544441223,
0.0102985929697752,
-0.7863712310791016,
0.2114461362361908,
-0.5331734418869019,
-0.26885196566581726,
-0.1965254843235016,
0.3982207477092743,
0.6871911287307739,
0.32261568307876587,
-0.3571086525917053,
0.1833878457546234,
0.1363256871700287,
0.16190160810947418,
-0.4055473208427429,
0.3989632725715637,
-0.5544565320014954,
-0.13628843426704407,
0.3021286427974701,
-0.10831750929355621,
-0.11037657409906387,
-0.24994799494743347,
-0.23681053519248962,
-0.4709244668483734,
-0.4159209132194519,
0.3552948236465454,
0.5521608591079712,
0.527476966381073,
-0.1338421106338501,
-0.2903720438480377,
-0.6846586465835571,
0.9573472738265991,
-0.43461698293685913,
-0.06378047168254852,
0.2684410512447357,
0.1418563574552536,
-0.47367629408836365,
-0.5578466057777405,
-0.8049504160881042,
-0.3524326682090759,
-0.10959303379058838,
0.46917256712913513,
-0.09640571475028992,
0.288470983505249,
-0.020844990387558937,
-0.011740535497665405,
-0.31304505467414856,
0.1867949366569519,
-0.4509318768978119,
-0.13691630959510803,
0.6766883134841919,
0.40070176124572754,
0.5810388326644897,
-0.48141470551490784,
-0.7023389339447021,
-0.21057195961475372,
-0.41767406463623047,
0.016677379608154297,
0.3997078835964203,
0.20200154185295105,
-0.32600510120391846,
0.3715165853500366,
0.3975639343261719,
-0.11679421365261078,
-0.42780789732933044,
-0.1137770414352417,
-0.23550860583782196,
-0.2890477180480957,
-0.26162415742874146,
-0.10609583556652069,
0.7335747480392456,
0.5003659725189209,
0.07322680950164795,
-0.18089371919631958,
-0.2741377353668213,
0.21692483127117157,
0.24305787682533264,
-0.3777664005756378,
0.1158665269613266,
0.388516366481781,
-0.6527857184410095,
-0.24203543365001678,
0.158971905708313,
-0.6587060689926147,
-0.3549095094203949,
-0.4949847161769867,
0.15639349818229675,
-0.039267342537641525,
-0.5818004608154297,
0.0592641644179821,
-0.2943054735660553,
0.5883264541625977,
0.25076162815093994,
-0.5189710259437561,
0.5872294902801514,
0.8228312730789185,
0.7912807464599609,
-0.1705598533153534,
-0.7085018754005432,
-0.2951541244983673,
0.3907490670681,
-0.2331119328737259,
0.5047333836555481,
-0.2716485857963562,
-0.8277814984321594,
-0.29323771595954895,
-0.05129668861627579,
0.16225895285606384,
-0.45632368326187134,
0.4233083724975586,
-0.2326527088880539,
-0.23494982719421387,
-0.5574231147766113,
-0.3572520613670349,
0.15380363166332245,
0.5933330059051514,
-0.777951717376709,
0.5049456357955933,
-0.3662102520465851,
-0.517480194568634,
0.21636863052845,
-1.0941710472106934,
0.09417600929737091,
0.4065839350223541,
-0.43606680631637573,
-0.28614622354507446,
-0.10984109342098236,
-0.6872587203979492,
0.30874988436698914,
-0.3733007311820984,
0.5134628415107727,
-0.6069331765174866,
-0.27184754610061646,
0.07700804620981216,
-0.5026475787162781,
1.018005132675171,
0.5315423607826233,
-0.030362898483872414,
0.2781379520893097,
-0.11112155765295029,
-0.03138665482401848,
0.18744464218616486,
-0.1838664710521698,
-0.21389222145080566,
0.1998865157365799,
0.027565008029341698,
0.07022855430841446,
0.2573949098587036,
-0.3483360707759857,
0.21285493671894073,
0.23683449625968933,
0.6313547492027283,
1.1877851486206055,
0.021736735478043556,
0.6133756637573242,
-0.7664917707443237,
0.2988872826099396,
-0.35058581829071045,
0.5330612659454346,
0.24881033599376678,
-0.24924728274345398,
-0.6458172798156738,
-0.21036377549171448,
-0.22355663776397705,
0.3533581793308258,
-0.5153046250343323,
0.3702329695224762,
-0.2711796164512634,
-0.36993104219436646,
-0.12821374833583832,
-0.24805614352226257,
0.24359369277954102,
-0.038361478596925735,
0.12047426402568817,
-0.30997398495674133,
-0.18965266644954681,
-0.6976768970489502,
0.07877126336097717,
-0.5358421206474304,
0.296115517616272,
0.49490317702293396,
0.8765987157821655,
-0.48920154571533203,
1.0155127048492432,
0.12555792927742004,
-0.041973792016506195,
-0.40275365114212036,
0.015233161859214306,
-0.07535140216350555,
0.7062383890151978,
0.40318432450294495,
-1.0052006244659424,
0.1112104207277298,
-0.16792447865009308,
-0.7854534983634949,
0.4408079981803894,
-0.4220200479030609,
-0.18963655829429626,
0.12698304653167725,
0.4718690812587738,
-0.924445629119873,
0.1344718486070633,
0.4566163122653961,
-0.4939737319946289,
0.8142417073249817,
-0.4874580502510071,
0.11489777266979218,
-0.980449378490448,
0.1742420196533203,
-0.33196431398391724,
-0.051454126834869385,
-0.3947421908378601,
0.3778668940067291,
-0.6632506847381592,
-0.39364954829216003,
-0.37123173475265503,
0.6751371026039124,
-0.5071908235549927,
-0.4216809868812561,
-0.09087155014276505,
0.18146912753582,
-0.2639825940132141,
0.19627924263477325,
-0.17520157992839813,
0.8152735829353333,
0.6383274793624878,
-0.666290819644928,
0.31940048933029175,
0.393873929977417,
-0.04647902026772499,
0.5141211152076721,
-0.6093596816062927,
-0.08555648475885391,
-0.39153143763542175,
0.3075461983680725,
-0.653780996799469,
-0.36596614122390747,
0.20109090209007263,
-0.24273796379566193,
-0.019562790170311928,
0.1580357849597931,
-0.525000274181366,
-0.2746357023715973,
-0.36539921164512634,
0.2181306779384613,
0.4113808572292328,
-0.442333459854126,
1.0447018146514893,
0.7121806740760803,
-0.10246990621089935,
-0.36775368452072144,
-0.9798876643180847,
0.40440377593040466,
-0.3417675197124481,
-0.7464923858642578,
0.03267315775156021,
-0.4365248680114746,
-0.8033297657966614,
0.23739950358867645,
-0.1411762535572052,
0.2813090682029724,
0.3991500735282898,
0.39490318298339844,
0.11975040286779404,
0.24789443612098694,
-0.04041203111410141,
-0.11685041338205338,
-0.2233341485261917,
0.2683451175689697,
-0.22652515769004822,
0.5267412662506104,
-0.6008996367454529,
-0.38568049669265747,
-0.36577826738357544,
0.3892982602119446,
1.0633031129837036,
-0.19148096442222595,
0.9202876091003418,
0.05889570713043213,
-0.23570068180561066,
-0.25970524549484253,
-0.4630107879638672,
-0.03451262786984444,
-0.5441769957542419,
-0.06789986789226532,
-0.020280146971344948,
-0.8870598673820496,
0.7462519407272339,
-0.4465544819831848,
0.33344975113868713,
0.10221542418003082,
0.2510066032409668,
-0.19157281517982483,
0.3303089141845703,
0.7610275149345398,
-0.12929289042949677,
0.16428765654563904,
-0.5759871602058411,
0.01049551460891962,
-0.39064955711364746,
-0.5083495378494263,
-0.4264383912086487,
-0.20792894065380096,
-0.8206976652145386,
-0.5136247873306274,
0.41967281699180603,
-0.0016030113911256194,
-0.5821101069450378,
-0.010948100127279758,
-0.3416881561279297,
0.9612957835197449,
0.5105926394462585,
-0.1408502161502838,
0.23839299380779266,
-0.18864066898822784,
-0.09188303351402283,
0.387238472700119,
-0.753117024898529,
-0.900891900062561,
0.20586638152599335,
0.10358826816082001,
0.8367246389389038,
0.31138578057289124,
1.140557885169983,
0.7501276731491089,
0.39291220903396606,
-0.5265144109725952,
0.984858512878418,
0.13548938930034637,
-0.21985435485839844,
-0.5656488537788391,
-0.6532939672470093,
-1.0070298910140991,
0.21128185093402863,
-0.25816407799720764,
-0.4946984648704529,
0.09276298433542252,
-0.2917923331260681,
-0.1939653903245926,
0.48401570320129395,
-0.39209383726119995,
0.7258142232894897,
-0.3501752018928528,
-0.6046083569526672,
-0.7709509134292603,
-0.5472049713134766,
0.19512104988098145,
0.45674991607666016,
0.46367940306663513,
-0.19496609270572662,
-0.09410528838634491,
0.26628366112709045,
-0.2924842834472656,
0.925468921661377,
0.03706971928477287,
-0.020189393311738968,
0.6322389841079712,
0.1393829882144928,
0.4313841760158539,
0.2186976969242096,
-0.29043054580688477,
0.16284772753715515,
-0.08921682834625244,
-0.5420194864273071,
-0.37080785632133484,
0.9133886098861694,
-1.1442975997924805,
-0.8367921710014343,
-0.6195060610771179,
-0.3028140366077423,
0.32428669929504395,
0.22111375629901886,
-0.17918512225151062,
0.0544142909348011,
-0.6758075952529907,
0.16653522849082947,
0.45441770553588867,
-0.1472690999507904,
0.7160310745239258,
0.3359506130218506,
0.02507677674293518,
-0.6273636817932129,
0.5528185963630676,
0.1282883882522583,
0.3796917796134949,
-0.3420042097568512,
0.3473021388053894,
-0.2972680330276489,
-0.27954375743865967,
0.06977743655443192,
0.061972618103027344,
-0.6985808610916138,
-0.29052191972732544,
-0.2627953290939331,
-0.37415745854377747,
-0.0894203782081604,
-0.5119786262512207,
-0.1271156519651413,
0.12116654217243195,
-0.12323744595050812,
-0.3511006832122803,
-0.03178422152996063,
0.9288789629936218,
-0.7169617414474487,
-0.20587563514709473,
-0.5090686678886414,
-0.005148324184119701,
0.24316084384918213,
0.33519062399864197,
0.14227049052715302,
0.29907211661338806,
0.053073443472385406,
0.00472648162394762,
-0.23483982682228088,
-0.6014600992202759,
0.15765470266342163,
-0.12518134713172913,
0.900895893573761,
0.3920382857322693,
0.2463359385728836,
0.38937488198280334,
-0.17629757523536682,
0.9142419099807739,
0.4631497859954834,
-0.927720844745636,
0.1720503866672516,
-0.5754677653312683,
0.0019791454542428255,
0.4445379376411438,
0.1454664170742035,
-0.5475224256515503,
-0.4161337912082672,
-0.702820897102356,
-0.6951700448989868,
0.519985020160675,
0.4681622385978699,
0.36490747332572937,
-0.24580791592597961,
0.2916001081466675,
-0.07795504480600357,
0.025824028998613358,
-0.7660409212112427,
-0.3257450461387634,
-0.09884492307901382,
0.3017957806587219,
-0.0976429134607315,
-0.28442999720573425,
-0.36269792914390564,
0.04640917107462883,
0.470151424407959,
-0.08497290313243866,
0.016694912686944008,
0.1764761209487915,
0.4584959149360657,
-0.12751229107379913,
0.3940253257751465,
0.38073259592056274,
0.5104421973228455,
0.31525060534477234,
0.27257052063941956,
0.2068287432193756,
-0.1125335544347763,
0.38659828901290894,
-0.21317574381828308,
-0.17198729515075684,
-0.5899908542633057,
0.03931703045964241,
0.5297738909721375,
0.13502852618694305,
-0.5294461250305176,
0.10154607146978378,
-0.2683632969856262,
-0.4009851813316345,
-0.49868935346603394,
0.13308009505271912,
0.31545019149780273,
0.6101133227348328,
0.25280117988586426,
0.34351927042007446,
-0.06594004482030869,
-1.0049691200256348,
0.2929748296737671,
0.7280930280685425,
0.3098733425140381,
0.11419232189655304,
0.5356629490852356,
0.5453593730926514,
-0.3952789604663849,
0.6684938669204712,
-0.46106529235839844,
-0.3927249312400818,
0.992872416973114,
0.29151007533073425,
0.8749054670333862,
0.03120613656938076,
0.5627273321151733,
0.18446514010429382,
0.4229739308357239,
-0.3193550705909729,
0.11561565101146698,
-0.275686115026474,
-0.9226900935173035,
-0.3784541189670563,
-0.6460791230201721,
-0.8085991144180298,
-0.05434316396713257,
-0.4294969141483307,
0.01580112613737583,
-0.6922615766525269,
-0.25272807478904724,
-0.6663435101509094,
0.44125548005104065,
-0.2963103652000427,
-0.2537253499031067,
0.03243562579154968,
0.7278372049331665,
-0.5841510891914368,
0.3882034718990326,
0.6038411855697632,
-0.5551329851150513,
-0.6619950532913208,
0.1855321228504181,
0.05534736067056656,
-0.4760080873966217,
0.34954899549484253,
0.23535943031311035,
-0.47078269720077515,
0.050244200974702835,
-1.221724271774292,
-0.9186784625053406,
1.6221271753311157,
0.6427943110466003,
-0.3284684121608734,
0.23596441745758057,
0.10719379037618637,
0.4780905246734619,
-0.10753776133060455,
0.04564299061894417,
0.3453603982925415,
0.9412417411804199,
0.21893887221813202,
-0.6948873400688171,
0.04257426783442497,
-0.11506594717502594,
-0.011244605295360088,
0.03529256209731102,
-1.3633625507354736,
0.6362704038619995,
-0.5086525678634644,
-0.5580145120620728,
0.5197104215621948,
0.7701518535614014,
0.5657604932785034,
0.40509724617004395,
0.5898467898368835,
0.6048820614814758,
0.8840049505233765,
0.11519978195428848,
0.9987828135490417,
-0.4072932302951813,
0.6306211352348328,
0.5882174372673035,
-0.33286595344543457,
0.42731279134750366,
0.3387259244918823,
0.21405592560768127,
0.31948918104171753,
0.22884809970855713,
-0.2456435263156891,
0.26535624265670776,
0.5512887239456177,
-0.4835812449455261,
-0.6382333040237427,
-0.5924118161201477,
0.10681827366352081,
0.5391870737075806,
0.22221460938453674,
0.31523752212524414,
-0.31459617614746094,
-0.15305063128471375,
-0.10185947269201279,
0.33745038509368896,
-0.5253346562385559,
0.6631599068641663,
0.3082903325557709,
-0.5479043126106262,
0.04019320756196976,
-0.24516868591308594,
0.641240656375885,
-0.5026572942733765,
-0.10564104467630386,
-0.3291628360748291,
0.00831409078091383,
-0.14329572021961212,
-0.840015709400177,
0.5429638028144836,
-0.25133442878723145,
0.09070698171854019,
-0.7145041227340698,
0.6938909888267517,
-0.35230928659439087,
0.05126107484102249,
0.7148111462593079,
0.6333498954772949,
0.2943987250328064,
0.7121652364730835,
-0.9312877655029297,
0.31661278009414673,
-0.3510638475418091,
0.04218948632478714,
0.3363303542137146,
0.39154404401779175,
0.1386190801858902,
1.0481035709381104,
0.6730629205703735,
0.008947155438363552,
-0.5325196385383606,
-0.22147604823112488,
1.031794786453247,
-0.42075127363204956,
-0.5146191716194153,
-0.796296238899231,
0.3882172107696533,
-0.3230677545070648,
0.01468397956341505,
0.5925126075744629,
0.2866279184818268,
0.7942584156990051,
0.04350065812468529,
0.8056632280349731,
-0.3367388844490051,
-0.5083314180374146,
-0.44267892837524414,
1.2214264869689941,
-0.5760697722434998,
0.19309113919734955,
0.10176559537649155,
-0.7582808136940002,
-0.016958968713879585,
0.4577806890010834,
-0.03156861290335655,
0.17284703254699707,
0.1089857667684555,
0.6572899222373962,
0.08186741173267365,
-0.054613031446933746,
0.7007888555526733,
0.15867450833320618,
0.3805316388607025,
0.16399382054805756,
0.8706732988357544,
0.3329327404499054,
0.5567954778671265,
0.20047438144683838,
-0.03665778785943985,
0.30682215094566345,
-0.7881654500961304,
-0.8496670722961426,
-0.4415745735168457,
0.030168000608682632,
-0.27409443259239197,
0.3783007264137268,
1.1249451637268066,
0.5859225988388062,
-0.4532290995121002,
-0.44839897751808167,
-0.5195133090019226,
0.5601369142532349,
0.14109545946121216,
-0.2262009084224701,
0.04878140613436699,
-0.2262551486492157,
-0.5270426869392395,
0.26617395877838135,
0.4556658864021301,
0.0718993991613388,
-0.7357078790664673,
-0.7938467264175415,
0.00308823911473155,
0.29306671023368835,
0.23396876454353333,
0.4983527660369873,
-0.6959811449050903,
-0.24081191420555115,
-0.37112414836883545,
-0.17982217669487,
-0.2848420739173889,
0.6406542062759399,
-0.4885250926017761,
0.16431842744350433,
0.31473711133003235,
0.5486315488815308,
-0.06399024277925491,
0.018995940685272217,
0.39483189582824707,
-0.22910091280937195,
-0.024334464222192764,
0.3938679099082947,
0.3378184139728546,
0.16733914613723755,
-0.29498523473739624,
0.5677585005760193,
0.22711388766765594,
-0.9804208874702454,
-0.5144914388656616,
0.3673097491264343,
-0.7734255194664001,
-0.30846232175827026,
1.0198813676834106,
-0.2806633710861206,
-0.337275892496109,
-0.018131021410226822,
-0.14204324781894684,
0.01863916590809822,
-0.7565317153930664,
0.7705965042114258,
0.6135678887367249,
-0.07478129118680954,
-0.35861435532569885,
-0.018755454570055008,
0.3793265223503113,
0.15697932243347168,
-0.879664421081543,
0.16278555989265442,
0.6444174647331238,
0.228311687707901,
0.5655704736709595,
0.8136890530586243,
0.2417101114988327,
0.07033411413431168,
0.35325002670288086,
0.02833137847483158,
-0.17565059661865234,
-0.44678550958633423,
-0.1016196459531784,
0.058532584458589554,
0.05406530946493149,
0.18385758996009827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16692v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16692v1
|
Influence of Solution Efficiency and Valence of Instruction on Additive and Subtractive Solution Strategies in Humans and GPT-4
| 2024-04-25T15:53:00 | 2024-04-25T15:53:00 |
Lydia Uhler, Verena Jordan, Jürgen Buder, Markus Huff, Frank Papenmeier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We explored the addition bias, a cognitive tendency to prefer adding elements
over removing them to alter an initial state or structure, by conducting four
preregistered experiments examining the problem-solving behavior of both humans
and OpenAl's GPT-4 large language model. The experiments involved 588
participants from the U.S. and 680 iterations of the GPT-4 model. The
problem-solving task was either to create symmetry within a grid (Experiments 1
and 3) or to edit a summary (Experiments 2 and 4). As hypothesized, we found
that overall, the addition bias was present. Solution efficiency (Experiments 1
and 2) and valence of the instruction (Experiments 3 and 4) played important
roles. Human participants were less likely to use additive strategies when
subtraction was relatively more efficient than when addition and subtraction
were equally efficient. GPT-4 exhibited the opposite behavior, with a strong
addition bias when subtraction was more efficient. In terms of instruction
valence, GPT-4 was more likely to add words when asked to "improve" compared to
"edit", whereas humans did not show this effect. When we looked at the addition
bias under different conditions, we found more biased responses for GPT-4
compared to humans. Our findings highlight the importance of considering
comparable and sometimes superior subtractive alternatives, as well as
reevaluating one's own and particularly the language models' problem-solving
behavior.
|
[
-0.5859200358390808,
-0.8346514105796814,
0.6449238657951355,
-0.0032092733308672905,
0.10544701665639877,
-0.02557218447327614,
-0.19955281913280487,
-0.3402692377567291,
-0.16429387032985687,
-0.19633746147155762,
-0.40238621830940247,
-0.1840997338294983,
-0.5374389290809631,
0.18184660375118256,
0.12000609934329987,
1.1161457300186157,
-0.07344170659780502,
0.3540043234825134,
-0.31124091148376465,
0.10245960205793381,
-0.7373428344726562,
-0.9819275736808777,
-0.45372840762138367,
-0.8350952863693237,
0.4362157881259918,
0.44355061650276184,
0.7041141390800476,
0.5750024914741516,
0.5349084734916687,
0.4112050533294678,
-0.1319618672132492,
-0.5386370420455933,
-0.3178859353065491,
-0.2022334784269333,
-0.4987839460372925,
-0.7714642882347107,
-0.5716796517372131,
0.4963403642177582,
0.3104715943336487,
0.7280729413032532,
-0.2699066400527954,
-0.10343620181083679,
0.14262433350086212,
0.8345154523849487,
-0.5629348158836365,
0.2373659759759903,
-0.16425694525241852,
0.043382998555898666,
-0.033057812601327896,
-0.04695431888103485,
-0.11102962493896484,
-0.4736563563346863,
0.5813571810722351,
-0.8660351037979126,
0.5420454144477844,
-0.5464634895324707,
0.5555219650268555,
0.21623462438583374,
-0.11743313074111938,
-0.6862626671791077,
-0.6866029500961304,
0.7982532978057861,
-0.3629092574119568,
0.44582128524780273,
0.43964752554893494,
-0.3745984733104706,
-0.23347966372966766,
-0.4532132148742676,
-0.45212191343307495,
-0.052573785185813904,
-0.05521553382277489,
0.4353307783603668,
-0.17494873702526093,
0.27081218361854553,
0.546810507774353,
0.10727977752685547,
-0.3460003435611725,
-0.07834492623806,
-0.7763606905937195,
-0.3821585178375244,
0.2946457862854004,
0.011334307491779327,
0.4404847323894501,
0.11597796529531479,
-0.215070903301239,
0.05409582704305649,
-0.4543837606906891,
0.21306559443473816,
0.4194047152996063,
0.14274078607559204,
0.15027104318141937,
0.6701314449310303,
0.11773034185171127,
0.36850202083587646,
0.13625741004943848,
0.061915427446365356,
0.28970563411712646,
-0.6290261149406433,
0.0029056414496153593,
0.1625833958387375,
0.20037534832954407,
0.2560487985610962,
0.37078121304512024,
-0.052396710962057114,
-0.2397032082080841,
0.8521738648414612,
0.27265456318855286,
-0.7878918647766113,
-0.5652891397476196,
-0.34017589688301086,
-0.15397673845291138,
0.02273000217974186,
-0.2506448030471802,
-0.5346059799194336,
-0.15395449101924896,
-0.5319294929504395,
0.7357466220855713,
-0.4809035658836365,
0.017674177885055542,
0.2034282684326172,
-0.4371103048324585,
0.26138177514076233,
0.36458155512809753,
-0.9524930715560913,
0.7237463593482971,
0.6559350490570068,
0.7793891429901123,
-0.23475179076194763,
-0.41037625074386597,
-0.43812480568885803,
-0.15834730863571167,
-0.5365903973579407,
0.8183477520942688,
-0.5001459121704102,
-0.6018625497817993,
-0.5241369605064392,
-0.2066112905740738,
-0.16903765499591827,
-0.6414054036140442,
0.7648060321807861,
-0.34686195850372314,
0.6380646824836731,
-0.9209768772125244,
-0.5611485242843628,
-0.29137808084487915,
-0.13224466145038605,
-0.585006594657898,
0.7671560049057007,
0.30816879868507385,
-0.713158369064331,
0.2863478660583496,
-0.9802194833755493,
-0.5132114291191101,
-0.1179952397942543,
-0.2642888128757477,
-0.2758551239967346,
0.26210761070251465,
0.14566418528556824,
-0.2301924228668213,
-0.20170925557613373,
-0.21489231288433075,
-0.030013557523489,
-0.7900808453559875,
0.3475003242492676,
-0.37441959977149963,
0.7010541558265686,
-0.11600053310394287,
-0.658775269985199,
0.013134239241480827,
-0.24306553602218628,
-0.15488284826278687,
0.036463454365730286,
-0.69412761926651,
-0.711094856262207,
-0.03358802944421768,
-0.6993981003761292,
0.40164053440093994,
0.024845948442816734,
-0.7189080715179443,
0.18478308618068695,
-0.31704604625701904,
0.2019217163324356,
1.1097089052200317,
0.18412314355373383,
0.5837183594703674,
-0.3315102756023407,
0.45958295464515686,
0.11212610453367233,
-0.06630387902259827,
0.0648263618350029,
-0.7438012957572937,
-0.8632550239562988,
-0.0629982128739357,
0.01328403502702713,
0.6747461557388306,
-0.6822360157966614,
-0.3146829605102539,
-0.11481189727783203,
-0.07490570843219757,
-0.3057263195514679,
0.2547839283943176,
0.8175904154777527,
0.7761439085006714,
0.41910824179649353,
-0.36118802428245544,
-0.34314438700675964,
-0.950463056564331,
-0.39556685090065,
-0.02102443389594555,
0.015395318157970905,
0.15759772062301636,
0.562184751033783,
-0.03226134926080704,
0.8684006929397583,
-0.774408757686615,
0.011767474934458733,
-0.0018785930005833507,
0.33641576766967773,
0.1466081738471985,
0.4985668957233429,
0.42412441968917847,
-0.6007875800132751,
-0.4591861963272095,
-0.22253389656543732,
-0.5749902725219727,
-0.3585934340953827,
0.2193681001663208,
-0.34939050674438477,
0.4543541669845581,
0.12031286209821701,
-0.5645820498466492,
0.5884917378425598,
0.19765381515026093,
-0.4289957284927368,
0.6695218682289124,
-0.3389813303947449,
0.1387508064508438,
-0.617424726486206,
-0.42261257767677307,
0.30928701162338257,
0.3557797074317932,
-0.7977598309516907,
-0.177459716796875,
-0.01290583610534668,
0.06396079808473587,
-0.131974995136261,
0.022199589759111404,
-0.6334702372550964,
-0.30723074078559875,
-0.08214378356933594,
0.24127939343452454,
0.05686596408486366,
0.7008834481239319,
0.048297218978405,
1.386834740638733,
0.15453670918941498,
-0.8102602958679199,
0.2158249169588089,
0.016386233270168304,
0.03325015679001808,
0.5399815440177917,
-0.9031714200973511,
0.25283941626548767,
-0.15712501108646393,
-0.0708935335278511,
-0.9631591439247131,
0.044530343264341354,
0.18247927725315094,
-0.3201614320278168,
0.07031504809856415,
0.20302574336528778,
0.0807512179017067,
-0.24552784860134125,
-0.6089972257614136,
0.40306299924850464,
0.6237502694129944,
-0.25978022813796997,
0.3843616247177124,
0.06366419047117233,
-0.38986942172050476,
-0.45632660388946533,
-0.791289746761322,
-0.2961021065711975,
-0.15514954924583435,
-0.4168330729007721,
0.5382800698280334,
-0.2562151551246643,
-0.41816720366477966,
0.19508793950080872,
-0.4426000118255615,
0.06291629374027252,
0.028062989935278893,
-0.13026604056358337,
0.3382468521595001,
0.05169377848505974,
0.19339686632156372,
-0.1286173164844513,
-0.3144903779029846,
0.3591983914375305,
-0.005494845565408468,
0.37866881489753723,
-0.36972880363464355,
-0.36155810952186584,
-0.5849286913871765,
0.44550207257270813,
0.46919551491737366,
-0.20977257192134857,
0.4549456238746643,
0.48130133748054504,
-0.13032640516757965,
0.3562263250350952,
-0.44898539781570435,
-0.5030698776245117,
-0.47254082560539246,
0.49423012137413025,
-0.5367710590362549,
-0.6613128185272217,
0.5576689839363098,
0.3017518222332001,
0.04797964170575142,
0.19702431559562683,
0.543752908706665,
0.022397777065634727,
1.0908803939819336,
0.3687015771865845,
0.2697617709636688,
0.6482868790626526,
-0.22098691761493683,
-0.010011722333729267,
-1.1205772161483765,
0.033494915813207626,
-0.4793851971626282,
-0.41127708554267883,
-0.6912844777107239,
-0.4167070984840393,
0.49983787536621094,
0.08781591057777405,
-0.5949599146842957,
-0.0018474241951480508,
-0.6834332346916199,
0.3977971374988556,
0.8079530596733093,
0.3327530324459076,
0.27560535073280334,
-0.1098177582025528,
-0.07442470639944077,
-0.41636085510253906,
-0.774408757686615,
0.015158694237470627,
1.184725046157837,
0.23291915655136108,
0.7791368365287781,
0.5175277590751648,
0.784444272518158,
0.18587477505207062,
0.5216090679168701,
-0.8270246982574463,
0.4038642346858978,
0.04578952491283417,
-0.5721240639686584,
-0.17225217819213867,
-0.5555180311203003,
-0.9538760185241699,
0.32786881923675537,
-0.06644845753908157,
-0.5625161528587341,
0.3420644700527191,
0.23568293452262878,
-0.20604361593723297,
-0.08411017805337906,
-1.2744890451431274,
0.6848953366279602,
-0.29886746406555176,
-0.7919354438781738,
-0.1696300059556961,
-0.35252845287323,
0.3239874243736267,
0.01229636836796999,
0.2997274398803711,
0.4229181408882141,
-0.2457038164138794,
0.9639968872070312,
-0.3930557072162628,
0.6683931350708008,
-0.37731269001960754,
-0.27081742882728577,
0.5031896233558655,
0.009012245573103428,
0.6724519729614258,
-0.38614776730537415,
0.09568021446466446,
-0.16040092706680298,
-0.3439163267612457,
-0.42854127287864685,
-0.910391628742218,
0.6830582618713379,
-1.1447014808654785,
-0.8668252825737,
-0.6824435591697693,
-0.4529806971549988,
-0.019832491874694824,
0.02114107832312584,
0.25850772857666016,
0.5679807662963867,
0.12249494343996048,
0.039727576076984406,
0.8831928372383118,
-0.07210814952850342,
0.6403692364692688,
0.3901844918727875,
0.01988912746310234,
-0.3245644271373749,
0.9117614030838013,
0.5866605043411255,
0.6020353436470032,
0.050291769206523895,
0.5545193552970886,
-0.2883676290512085,
-0.36101579666137695,
-0.19499114155769348,
0.27868393063545227,
-0.7201998829841614,
0.17517685890197754,
-0.43818774819374084,
0.05437780171632767,
-0.2370193600654602,
-0.21752813458442688,
-0.28644058108329773,
-0.38730180263519287,
-0.2201945185661316,
-0.25052839517593384,
0.2311457246541977,
0.7111957669258118,
-0.08539653569459915,
0.12331253290176392,
-0.6317301988601685,
0.30643659830093384,
0.7902272939682007,
0.3743091821670532,
0.03223339468240738,
-0.347968727350235,
-0.1907995492219925,
0.16232994198799133,
-0.4106241464614868,
-1.3006820678710938,
-0.061276260763406754,
-0.0020308676175773144,
0.7494907975196838,
0.002176260109990835,
-0.18938998878002167,
0.8329413533210754,
-0.23195387423038483,
0.8245592713356018,
0.05270512402057648,
-1.1857503652572632,
0.07677463442087173,
-0.47786033153533936,
0.42505863308906555,
0.12879706919193268,
0.299080491065979,
-0.28909650444984436,
0.03520935773849487,
-0.45929303765296936,
-0.5359858870506287,
0.8715645670890808,
0.29488739371299744,
-0.02300395257771015,
0.021659929305315018,
0.5383507013320923,
-0.1867416948080063,
0.1273842751979828,
-0.7981282472610474,
-0.32130342721939087,
-0.34571191668510437,
0.28206127882003784,
0.046660710126161575,
-0.25867170095443726,
-0.12407390028238297,
-0.47844594717025757,
0.6147938370704651,
0.20597925782203674,
0.4609281122684479,
0.5055962204933167,
-0.09677489846944809,
-0.12972256541252136,
0.7109971046447754,
0.9313778877258301,
0.758923351764679,
-0.15883702039718628,
0.06376795470714569,
0.321901798248291,
-0.9005721211433411,
0.4217916429042816,
-0.09473510086536407,
-0.15865562856197357,
-0.36475393176078796,
0.39859533309936523,
0.5102126002311707,
-0.006652283947914839,
-0.21078552305698395,
0.2669960558414459,
-0.09791280329227448,
-0.4639052748680115,
-0.0072407168336212635,
0.2987781763076782,
0.10079259425401688,
0.16502340137958527,
0.32611778378486633,
0.2306990772485733,
0.2996799051761627,
-0.6587730646133423,
-0.001642583403736353,
0.35040342807769775,
-0.38552892208099365,
-0.4777401387691498,
0.28286585211753845,
0.25039979815483093,
-0.4246656894683838,
0.6174702644348145,
-0.4173652231693268,
-0.918508768081665,
0.41374126076698303,
0.8881776332855225,
0.7483028173446655,
-0.477067768573761,
0.11439452320337296,
0.28128573298454285,
0.44253745675086975,
0.18835632503032684,
0.44520753622055054,
-0.002918945625424385,
-0.9106200337409973,
-0.6887928247451782,
-0.12380792200565338,
-0.15542837977409363,
0.021085720509290695,
-0.8780214190483093,
-0.2307223379611969,
-0.31639355421066284,
-0.4007454514503479,
-0.05720239877700806,
0.08978748321533203,
-0.5943127274513245,
0.08210308104753494,
-0.17450185120105743,
0.3821389675140381,
-1.0311675071716309,
0.34729883074760437,
1.1727468967437744,
-0.42635253071784973,
-0.9592169523239136,
-0.12259671837091446,
0.18459828197956085,
-0.28981754183769226,
0.6734716296195984,
-0.15050457417964935,
-0.4325956404209137,
-0.0329890139400959,
-0.3017118275165558,
-0.9120843410491943,
0.8917433619499207,
0.23106098175048828,
-0.10819356888532639,
-0.12066969275474548,
-0.3549089729785919,
0.60264652967453,
-0.07583120465278625,
0.24561895430088043,
0.8518502116203308,
0.48455819487571716,
-0.012837951071560383,
-0.948074996471405,
0.15597298741340637,
-0.38654017448425293,
0.19344662129878998,
0.41162633895874023,
-0.4773133397102356,
1.5098539590835571,
-0.3951767385005951,
-0.1629544198513031,
-0.5899236798286438,
0.31723710894584656,
0.11806726455688477,
0.16276174783706665,
0.2570652961730957,
0.6643895506858826,
0.40564700961112976,
-0.06706985831260681,
0.9355019330978394,
0.1299637109041214,
0.1875716596841812,
0.9903517961502075,
-0.10237526148557663,
0.3534548282623291,
0.5280675292015076,
-0.431839257478714,
0.7473175525665283,
0.35917922854423523,
0.5536873936653137,
0.5472094416618347,
0.21880842745304108,
-0.39774006605148315,
0.009311338886618614,
0.20340746641159058,
-0.5525494813919067,
0.44850024580955505,
0.5611780881881714,
-0.0731828361749649,
-0.2151687741279602,
-0.07550815492868423,
0.38396650552749634,
0.21334697306156158,
-0.40723976492881775,
0.8848966360092163,
-0.270418643951416,
-1.0090713500976562,
0.6824986338615417,
0.04825673624873161,
0.5437557697296143,
-0.37980931997299194,
-0.27085256576538086,
-0.23318065702915192,
0.3409179747104645,
-0.37189510464668274,
-0.7001721858978271,
0.16383159160614014,
-0.05746375769376755,
-0.39522355794906616,
0.15673886239528656,
0.48305413126945496,
-0.23983962833881378,
-0.1811734288930893,
0.1376819610595703,
0.6620710492134094,
0.005044444464147091,
0.12123025208711624,
-0.5857687592506409,
-0.022657303139567375,
0.3074580729007721,
-0.47729772329330444,
0.44457030296325684,
0.29343855381011963,
-0.4062763750553131,
0.5290942192077637,
0.8495936393737793,
0.031426966190338135,
0.1431788057088852,
-0.08297794312238693,
1.1479448080062866,
-0.4964885115623474,
-0.4930988550186157,
-1.0131800174713135,
0.3680570423603058,
0.0006784811266697943,
-0.08774806559085846,
0.8613868355751038,
0.5585569739341736,
0.8436914682388306,
-0.04102782905101776,
0.994558572769165,
0.09673254936933517,
0.43998461961746216,
-0.3449003994464874,
0.08112502843141556,
-0.17553719878196716,
0.4369671642780304,
-0.7421011328697205,
-1.1498725414276123,
0.12759214639663696,
0.8129191398620605,
-0.7472179532051086,
0.5086342692375183,
1.0347483158111572,
0.6104732751846313,
0.03437405824661255,
0.10607270151376724,
-0.17030972242355347,
0.06553847342729568,
0.5585537552833557,
0.7221952676773071,
0.6955456733703613,
-0.07727902382612228,
0.325735479593277,
-0.3553471565246582,
-0.7887938618659973,
0.0707077607512474,
-0.6530264019966125,
-0.7081174850463867,
-0.28579744696617126,
-0.13839584589004517,
-0.34305864572525024,
0.15064582228660583,
1.0301196575164795,
0.16547830402851105,
-0.5508789420127869,
-0.2685110569000244,
-0.4492795169353485,
0.23998869955539703,
-0.37026527523994446,
-0.23392735421657562,
0.5446571707725525,
-0.329733282327652,
-0.6646105051040649,
0.08678276091814041,
0.024172725155949593,
0.26151522994041443,
-0.014930774457752705,
-0.16955505311489105,
-0.27198585867881775,
0.15858647227287292,
0.6171178221702576,
0.2541975677013397,
-0.5686647891998291,
-0.4360383152961731,
0.27225232124328613,
-0.06485821306705475,
0.09675610065460205,
0.9115538001060486,
-0.6695621013641357,
0.7615470886230469,
0.5865818858146667,
0.43825671076774597,
0.4411928951740265,
0.5705381631851196,
0.7361052632331848,
-0.44820940494537354,
0.09966957569122314,
0.1939195841550827,
0.010896353982388973,
0.21002955734729767,
-0.38403382897377014,
0.3918992578983307,
0.5746971964836121,
-0.7692912220954895,
-0.3195013999938965,
0.35319116711616516,
-0.3345929682254791,
-0.22019962966442108,
0.8547046780586243,
-0.09562233090400696,
-0.10169462114572525,
-0.24101488292217255,
-0.4251885414123535,
0.268797904253006,
-0.6129763722419739,
0.6866727471351624,
1.0055365562438965,
-0.9300298690795898,
-0.1325187385082245,
-0.4950155019760132,
0.5929555296897888,
0.5555068254470825,
-0.6551989316940308,
-0.09313330054283142,
0.9005765914916992,
0.31123971939086914,
0.4115074872970581,
0.8271280527114868,
-0.13309140503406525,
0.5957215428352356,
0.2017332911491394,
0.11710399389266968,
-0.17002403736114502,
-0.2617599070072174,
-0.3175947964191437,
-0.09049451351165771,
0.03613538295030594,
-0.2823711037635803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00716v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00716v3
|
Large Language Models in the Clinic: A Comprehensive Benchmark
| 2024-04-25T15:51:06 | 2024-06-26T17:48:18 |
Andrew Liu, Hongjian Zhou, Yining Hua, Omid Rohanian, Anshul Thakur, Lei Clifton, David A. Clifton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The adoption of large language models (LLMs) to assist clinicians has
attracted remarkable attention. Existing works mainly adopt the close-ended
question-answering (QA) task with answer options for evaluation. However, many
clinical decisions involve answering open-ended questions without pre-set
options. To better understand LLMs in the clinic, we construct a benchmark
ClinicBench. We first collect eleven existing datasets covering diverse
clinical language generation, understanding, and reasoning tasks. Furthermore,
we construct six novel datasets and complex clinical tasks that are close to
real-world practice, i.e., referral QA, treatment recommendation,
hospitalization (long document) summarization, patient education, pharmacology
QA and drug interaction for emerging drugs. We conduct an extensive evaluation
of twenty-two LLMs under both zero-shot and few-shot settings. Finally, we
invite medical experts to evaluate the clinical usefulness of LLMs.
|
[
-0.08811110258102417,
-0.7765451669692993,
1.0589380264282227,
-0.012189595960080624,
-0.27495676279067993,
-0.12649427354335785,
-0.47517919540405273,
-0.45003628730773926,
0.013889948837459087,
0.6740865707397461,
-0.3056866228580475,
-0.7606233954429626,
-0.6308527588844299,
0.192579448223114,
-0.42597511410713196,
0.7214392423629761,
-0.21380403637886047,
0.4890706241130829,
-0.25948306918144226,
-0.2340242862701416,
-0.3759603500366211,
-0.3615766763687134,
-0.684870183467865,
-0.4047910273075104,
0.6068887114524841,
0.3069917857646942,
0.6333094239234924,
0.4829455614089966,
0.6801077127456665,
0.2598189115524292,
-0.14729160070419312,
-0.12603437900543213,
-0.45031413435935974,
0.05620325356721878,
-0.16887174546718597,
-0.5554882287979126,
-0.5722473859786987,
-0.26793602108955383,
0.6484618186950684,
1.2141895294189453,
-0.2917007803916931,
0.13830214738845825,
-0.4692628085613251,
0.34983018040657043,
-0.6716938018798828,
-0.15874861180782318,
-0.43957993388175964,
0.13602961599826813,
-0.2609211206436157,
0.2687796950340271,
-0.24630844593048096,
-0.2939845025539398,
0.17904452979564667,
-0.3596312701702118,
0.0383111946284771,
-0.18899711966514587,
0.4450695216655731,
-0.0451403483748436,
-0.5698708295822144,
-0.38804948329925537,
-0.7104965448379517,
0.6713794469833374,
-1.0543004274368286,
0.45476245880126953,
0.2824868857860565,
0.5302931666374207,
-0.47215771675109863,
-0.8842629790306091,
-0.4458754360675812,
-0.29372870922088623,
0.050056882202625275,
0.12620066106319427,
-0.23156897723674774,
0.2912871539592743,
0.4464518427848816,
0.33354830741882324,
-0.673424243927002,
0.371783584356308,
-0.37208250164985657,
0.04872717708349228,
0.4554271399974823,
0.41888269782066345,
0.3062133491039276,
0.18073096871376038,
-0.21448656916618347,
0.12483047693967819,
-0.8417242765426636,
-0.043217651546001434,
-0.4085332751274109,
0.13673190772533417,
-0.07123974710702896,
0.6437886357307434,
-0.4104959964752197,
0.852721631526947,
-0.37307095527648926,
-0.2972317636013031,
0.19660517573356628,
-0.24365836381912231,
-0.5379393100738525,
-0.09924962371587753,
1.0427732467651367,
0.4788114130496979,
0.30244114995002747,
-0.3059235215187073,
-0.06796073913574219,
-0.22792671620845795,
0.2620539367198944,
-0.7131935954093933,
0.11256298422813416,
0.630868673324585,
-0.4996073544025421,
-0.164301797747612,
-0.42646297812461853,
-0.7137129306793213,
-0.43913841247558594,
-0.2635142207145691,
0.17518632113933563,
-0.27650031447410583,
-0.1573573797941208,
0.39289748668670654,
0.050135232508182526,
0.42185091972351074,
0.3845837116241455,
-0.5539831519126892,
0.6985759735107422,
0.585395336151123,
0.7703679203987122,
-0.1630898118019104,
-0.07502447068691254,
-0.6246070861816406,
0.13559085130691528,
-0.6573782563209534,
1.001648187637329,
-0.411901593208313,
-0.53648841381073,
0.43815121054649353,
0.08848624676465988,
-0.043577034026384354,
-0.8835607171058655,
0.6268248558044434,
-0.25092142820358276,
0.08874394744634628,
-0.32219547033309937,
-0.7044314742088318,
0.18737153708934784,
0.3837234675884247,
-0.48807162046432495,
0.6028338074684143,
0.19020672142505646,
-0.41703370213508606,
0.1952650099992752,
-0.37917569279670715,
-0.3909497857093811,
0.26741474866867065,
-0.294139564037323,
-0.2785775661468506,
0.3793283998966217,
0.14340516924858093,
0.4751649796962738,
-0.4982709288597107,
0.3517559766769409,
-0.40833497047424316,
-0.2654609680175781,
0.4660398066043854,
-0.09956395626068115,
0.550091028213501,
0.3819499909877777,
0.07734867930412292,
0.11862719058990479,
-0.759345531463623,
0.0993296355009079,
0.046444669365882874,
-0.04834284260869026,
-0.16632048785686493,
-0.24548503756523132,
0.11488442867994308,
0.35438472032546997,
0.18434424698352814,
-0.6120482087135315,
0.03480393812060356,
-0.26426273584365845,
0.3981791138648987,
0.20618373155593872,
0.14112696051597595,
-0.10463269799947739,
-0.32916566729545593,
0.7756041288375854,
-0.061417222023010254,
0.23823492228984833,
-0.12931321561336517,
-0.2117144763469696,
-0.43733030557632446,
-0.42493993043899536,
0.19966623187065125,
0.42320477962493896,
-0.456730455160141,
-0.01829097419977188,
-0.13427381217479706,
-0.5866328477859497,
-0.365442156791687,
0.1238885447382927,
0.48359957337379456,
0.4866558015346527,
0.24830541014671326,
-0.3336232602596283,
-0.22867721319198608,
-1.0450928211212158,
-0.18021979928016663,
0.123525470495224,
-0.0886426493525505,
0.31784042716026306,
0.43527835607528687,
-0.19943831861019135,
0.7298282384872437,
-0.5755297541618347,
-0.21443170309066772,
-0.41597941517829895,
-0.09459839016199112,
0.4340990483760834,
0.02973790466785431,
0.4760119318962097,
-0.3378693461418152,
-0.410236120223999,
-0.00507014337927103,
-0.8642488121986389,
-0.25276634097099304,
0.01473492942750454,
-0.031323470175266266,
-0.34623268246650696,
0.6787950396537781,
-0.7607288360595703,
0.17858487367630005,
0.5865291953086853,
-0.01096559502184391,
0.4226749837398529,
-0.4581405520439148,
0.11134480684995651,
-1.075319766998291,
0.2848461866378784,
0.009723464958369732,
-0.48248350620269775,
-0.8424460887908936,
-0.04453151673078537,
0.11160916090011597,
-0.19820305705070496,
-0.6048137545585632,
0.6478621959686279,
-0.24047738313674927,
-0.16138604283332825,
-0.2193802446126938,
0.3771258592605591,
-0.1811237782239914,
-0.048691704869270325,
0.17084072530269623,
0.5982900261878967,
0.522729218006134,
-0.33005306124687195,
0.5100547075271606,
0.34984713792800903,
-0.5511482357978821,
0.5634292364120483,
-0.9743812084197998,
-0.0000010390886018285528,
-0.002091794740408659,
0.3317786455154419,
-0.8835645318031311,
-0.24923457205295563,
-0.11353845149278641,
0.010101182386279106,
0.23672159016132355,
0.04347514733672142,
-0.6356707811355591,
-0.5102567672729492,
-0.02524372562766075,
0.42309361696243286,
0.46529263257980347,
-0.06232736259698868,
0.09812945127487183,
0.3152342736721039,
-0.5042712688446045,
-0.39795005321502686,
-0.3801726698875427,
0.2738531231880188,
-0.014702619053423405,
-0.15719006955623627,
0.027617983520030975,
-0.16360722482204437,
-0.4836888909339905,
-0.1618662029504776,
0.2253798097372055,
-0.23692487180233002,
-0.023294391110539436,
0.03848296403884888,
0.06423521041870117,
-0.33974769711494446,
0.4532772898674011,
0.08333007246255875,
0.018359055742621422,
0.153284952044487,
0.16427011787891388,
0.5524259209632874,
-0.00246939598582685,
-0.5887051224708557,
-0.2989461421966553,
0.49757689237594604,
0.6140183210372925,
-0.3593531847000122,
0.6245983839035034,
0.3460175693035126,
-0.5563002824783325,
-0.10723531991243362,
-0.6632158756256104,
-0.05282413586974144,
-0.3262038230895996,
0.6183128356933594,
-0.25843915343284607,
-0.7843020558357239,
0.4766675531864166,
-0.3256289064884186,
0.1784035712480545,
0.1838289499282837,
1.0175594091415405,
0.0015685803955420852,
0.8822989463806152,
0.3023512065410614,
0.20300845801830292,
0.03498725965619087,
0.06434933841228485,
0.29399144649505615,
-0.7502079010009766,
-0.11887137591838837,
-0.45219939947128296,
0.07236939668655396,
-0.4402000904083252,
-0.6388401389122009,
0.5601871013641357,
0.24752110242843628,
-0.1313902586698532,
0.013492951169610023,
-0.07046477496623993,
0.2795245945453644,
0.1819702833890915,
0.07756025344133377,
0.3955976068973541,
-0.3543540835380554,
-0.15892274677753448,
0.14351437985897064,
-0.5333185791969299,
-0.537723183631897,
1.4897164106369019,
0.49810484051704407,
0.6012433171272278,
0.054238419979810715,
0.6326709389686584,
-0.06145397946238518,
0.5986986756324768,
-0.7332673668861389,
0.5211070775985718,
-0.312541127204895,
-0.5434654355049133,
-0.153770312666893,
-0.20405513048171997,
-0.9403101801872253,
0.2911258637905121,
-0.20151138305664062,
-0.7431812286376953,
-0.18476502597332,
-0.13802294433116913,
-0.6410490274429321,
0.058509908616542816,
-0.5562700629234314,
1.0169583559036255,
-0.2723318338394165,
-0.32601338624954224,
-0.1474831998348236,
-0.49813133478164673,
0.42142003774642944,
-0.22821329534053802,
0.4367464482784271,
-0.2093735784292221,
-0.20045384764671326,
0.48306751251220703,
-0.408701628446579,
0.6242756843566895,
0.0065179429948329926,
-0.22153960168361664,
0.026361782103776932,
-0.08036459982395172,
0.23874670267105103,
0.1722317337989807,
-0.05388117581605911,
0.04240655526518822,
0.4436992406845093,
-0.4423356056213379,
-0.5554177165031433,
0.7281416654586792,
-0.6151785850524902,
-0.4417251944541931,
-0.40080374479293823,
-0.5288931131362915,
-0.7582586407661438,
0.28078320622444153,
0.01676785945892334,
0.7126356959342957,
-0.6402609944343567,
0.11634561419487,
0.6384303569793701,
-0.5920048952102661,
0.007429791614413261,
0.8665661215782166,
-0.33018532395362854,
-0.3554033637046814,
0.24298986792564392,
-0.1715855449438095,
0.5267525911331177,
0.3542191982269287,
0.17877961695194244,
-0.390751451253891,
-1.0231105089187622,
-0.36816227436065674,
0.5875816345214844,
-0.6626616716384888,
0.00036339598591439426,
-0.6724357604980469,
-0.2371535301208496,
-0.4638587534427643,
-0.0838722437620163,
-0.23443788290023804,
0.055081866681575775,
0.05823361128568649,
-0.06598993390798569,
0.209012970328331,
0.7736446857452393,
0.30861952900886536,
0.27949637174606323,
-1.0218108892440796,
0.40910232067108154,
0.1681639403104782,
0.6130231618881226,
-0.12830689549446106,
-0.23449301719665527,
-0.270388126373291,
-0.06682183593511581,
-0.012177147902548313,
-0.841005265712738,
0.28380295634269714,
0.0758824571967125,
0.7164242267608643,
0.5053525567054749,
-0.11253474652767181,
0.554072380065918,
-0.8560651540756226,
0.704822838306427,
0.3781719207763672,
-0.585525631904602,
0.43557849526405334,
-0.4812086820602417,
0.600162148475647,
0.5510855317115784,
0.4268680810928345,
-0.8295301198959351,
-0.43151387572288513,
-0.3329271972179413,
-0.6122753620147705,
0.45999211072921753,
0.015435653738677502,
0.13700847327709198,
-0.20313243567943573,
0.37710046768188477,
0.12121127545833588,
0.3670473098754883,
-0.363190621137619,
-0.005421251989901066,
0.37600451707839966,
-0.42652514576911926,
-0.35004305839538574,
-0.2592739462852478,
-0.5123674869537354,
0.04581388831138611,
0.2801331579685211,
-0.23026162385940552,
0.1290580928325653,
0.3338204622268677,
-0.12135148793458939,
-0.3285238742828369,
0.730532169342041,
0.6385871767997742,
1.034777283668518,
-0.3700341284275055,
-0.038132715970277786,
0.37728968262672424,
-0.3976547122001648,
-0.09199199080467224,
0.2646520435810089,
0.12804119288921356,
0.06575961410999298,
0.634607195854187,
0.6315878033638,
0.3026604652404785,
-1.362346887588501,
0.5379605293273926,
-0.19794529676437378,
-0.3156909942626953,
-0.3599090874195099,
-0.1113983616232872,
0.1743803322315216,
0.2817297875881195,
-0.05334039032459259,
-0.5710442066192627,
0.22159047424793243,
-0.5828865170478821,
0.1917486935853958,
0.6198710799217224,
-0.7143680453300476,
-0.1551186740398407,
0.43356919288635254,
-0.025399211794137955,
-0.08971823751926422,
0.5066379308700562,
0.3327367305755615,
-0.12872080504894257,
0.448557585477829,
0.6288192272186279,
0.5953900814056396,
0.040449097752571106,
0.26809191703796387,
0.28178420662879944,
-0.041555825620889664,
-0.09878376126289368,
0.2743603587150574,
0.2966780364513397,
-0.5637733340263367,
-0.5119127631187439,
-0.6007879972457886,
-0.7851659059524536,
0.4707508385181427,
-0.7041960954666138,
0.2951882779598236,
-0.4566252827644348,
-0.1243356466293335,
0.11040797829627991,
0.02377292700111866,
-0.7347263097763062,
0.39595070481300354,
0.24901247024536133,
1.0994545221328735,
-0.6476572751998901,
0.8403778076171875,
0.9526737332344055,
-0.25595369935035706,
-0.4723653793334961,
-0.23728398978710175,
-0.11367367953062057,
-0.8681175112724304,
0.2641782760620117,
-0.06257779151201248,
0.2329694926738739,
-0.22903813421726227,
-0.4747796356678009,
-0.6425411701202393,
1.0797264575958252,
0.188163623213768,
-0.8063618540763855,
0.008891472592949867,
0.42979738116264343,
0.9587249159812927,
-0.4682028293609619,
0.548001766204834,
0.726057231426239,
0.08721480518579483,
0.09298863261938095,
-1.1867945194244385,
0.037431638687849045,
-0.08253452181816101,
-0.17422527074813843,
0.2653748393058777,
-0.5201079249382019,
0.7190791964530945,
-0.3561047315597534,
0.11344798654317856,
0.4048383831977844,
0.03853064775466919,
0.3496367633342743,
0.3241797685623169,
0.4077085554599762,
0.5325749516487122,
0.579740047454834,
-0.06589393317699432,
1.2055678367614746,
-0.2568332850933075,
0.22801686823368073,
1.006869912147522,
-0.8819869160652161,
1.103675127029419,
0.37857675552368164,
-0.47337254881858826,
0.2611640989780426,
0.4267299473285675,
0.08505932241678238,
0.24650272727012634,
0.3669087290763855,
-0.35531166195869446,
-0.47823742032051086,
-0.3641469478607178,
-0.45595598220825195,
0.37136560678482056,
0.4528951942920685,
-0.42461928725242615,
-0.41090714931488037,
0.19497591257095337,
0.02863992564380169,
0.10673501342535019,
-0.20327046513557434,
0.9599894285202026,
0.47351109981536865,
-0.6237232089042664,
0.5497453212738037,
-0.184015154838562,
-0.03295314311981201,
-0.9299508333206177,
-0.03173944354057312,
-0.17012155055999756,
0.3965795040130615,
-0.10198719799518585,
-0.7836182713508606,
-0.10089164972305298,
0.06825011968612671,
0.059903234243392944,
0.0023800665512681007,
0.5756906270980835,
-0.5079724788665771,
-0.529691219329834,
0.21418023109436035,
0.7526988983154297,
0.27725180983543396,
0.09604459255933762,
-0.5717588067054749,
0.09331265836954117,
-0.3615127503871918,
-0.15024471282958984,
0.590395450592041,
0.44907018542289734,
-0.14511017501354218,
0.6803264617919922,
0.579127311706543,
0.5802399516105652,
-0.20612497627735138,
0.4089652895927429,
0.8719075918197632,
-0.80860435962677,
-0.1853272169828415,
-0.5205538272857666,
0.11072232574224472,
-0.20086069405078888,
-0.4338764250278473,
0.46812278032302856,
0.45826593041419983,
0.38191747665405273,
0.016657963395118713,
0.7152592539787292,
0.3370872437953949,
0.8946669697761536,
-0.5664659142494202,
0.42638111114501953,
-0.6281328201293945,
0.09266559779644012,
-0.15322096645832062,
-0.6959394216537476,
-0.5734606981277466,
0.22045210003852844,
-0.5397235751152039,
-0.034176651388406754,
0.776017427444458,
0.5158133506774902,
0.19584155082702637,
-0.01127414871007204,
0.6560893058776855,
0.4210246205329895,
0.6245396733283997,
0.8624776601791382,
0.8054546117782593,
-0.336845338344574,
0.262199342250824,
-0.19736388325691223,
-0.3116905093193054,
-0.13455910980701447,
-0.7728111743927002,
-0.9635836482048035,
-0.0386035181581974,
-0.1874193400144577,
-0.18193848431110382,
0.18906345963478088,
1.1880756616592407,
0.5360011458396912,
-1.0131007432937622,
-0.38842588663101196,
0.14215309917926788,
-0.23074981570243835,
-0.2866971790790558,
-0.1227637231349945,
0.4646729826927185,
-0.2744910717010498,
-0.6561533212661743,
0.3202628195285797,
0.4142371416091919,
-0.07540107518434525,
-0.26479920744895935,
0.14723040163516998,
-0.13261078298091888,
-0.049413051456213,
0.6775836944580078,
0.221803218126297,
-0.6381679773330688,
0.14082038402557373,
0.11912224441766739,
-0.23586051166057587,
0.03665676712989807,
0.9501391053199768,
-0.673950731754303,
0.6312930583953857,
0.25591665506362915,
0.573342502117157,
0.3865232765674591,
-0.1728726327419281,
0.9124622344970703,
-0.11155550181865692,
-0.02320788986980915,
0.3747919201850891,
0.45273804664611816,
0.23096923530101776,
0.17519353330135345,
0.23418830335140228,
-0.10272641479969025,
-0.4909253716468811,
-0.9023222923278809,
0.0618320070207119,
-1.001926064491272,
-0.3209536671638489,
1.2651644945144653,
-0.32523995637893677,
-0.08287588506937027,
-0.40110498666763306,
-0.267214298248291,
-0.03823300823569298,
-0.17118242383003235,
0.5495966672897339,
0.710642397403717,
-0.21255826950073242,
-0.29700765013694763,
-1.019447922706604,
0.48687997460365295,
0.2560356557369232,
-1.1350911855697632,
0.012538129463791847,
0.581235945224762,
0.3873503506183624,
-0.1580885499715805,
1.0250279903411865,
-0.36293789744377136,
0.3355615735054016,
-0.30095887184143066,
-0.05465032532811165,
0.17418727278709412,
0.10528085380792618,
-0.38951990008354187,
0.08470424264669418,
0.47664543986320496,
0.1343899965286255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17607v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17607v1
|
Utilizing Large Language Models to Identify Reddit Users Considering Vaping Cessation for Digital Interventions
| 2024-04-25T15:45:58 | 2024-04-25T15:45:58 |
Sai Krishna Revanth Vuruma, Dezhi Wu, Saborny Sen Gupta, Lucas Aust, Valerie Lookingbill, Caleb Henry, Yang Ren, Erin Kasson, Li-Shiun Chen, Patricia Cavazos-Rehg, Dian Hu, Ming Huang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
The widespread adoption of social media platforms globally not only enhances
users' connectivity and communication but also emerges as a vital channel for
the dissemination of health-related information, thereby establishing social
media data as an invaluable organic data resource for public health research.
The surge in popularity of vaping or e-cigarette use in the United States and
other countries has caused an outbreak of e-cigarette and vaping use-associated
lung injury (EVALI), leading to hospitalizations and fatalities in 2019,
highlighting the urgency to comprehend vaping behaviors and develop effective
strategies for cession. In this study, we extracted a sample dataset from one
vaping sub-community on Reddit to analyze users' quit vaping intentions.
Leveraging large language models including both the latest GPT-4 and
traditional BERT-based language models for sentence-level quit-vaping intention
prediction tasks, this study compares the outcomes of these models against
human annotations. Notably, when compared to human evaluators, GPT-4 model
demonstrates superior consistency in adhering to annotation guidelines and
processes, showcasing advanced capabilities to detect nuanced user quit-vaping
intentions that human evaluators might overlook. These preliminary findings
emphasize the potential of GPT-4 in enhancing the accuracy and reliability of
social media data analysis, especially in identifying subtle users' intentions
that may elude human detection.
|
[
-0.1725340038537979,
-1.0108273029327393,
1.1284488439559937,
-0.038537830114364624,
-0.2090890109539032,
-0.14164376258850098,
-0.43520957231521606,
-0.44063833355903625,
0.3767070770263672,
0.41141727566719055,
-0.376507967710495,
-0.6957370638847351,
-0.671430230140686,
-0.14569565653800964,
-0.5553520917892456,
0.9861804246902466,
-0.23595786094665527,
-0.18495206534862518,
-0.04496314749121666,
0.34355705976486206,
-0.484106183052063,
-0.6650266647338867,
-0.9631218910217285,
-0.11600130796432495,
0.9798874855041504,
0.21847021579742432,
0.22761018574237823,
-0.3830502927303314,
0.19498208165168762,
0.2394304722547531,
-0.018922870978713036,
-0.04029781371355057,
-0.5796401500701904,
-0.18329305946826935,
-0.08338578790426254,
-0.15967650711536407,
-0.17278419435024261,
0.016328636556863785,
0.19257886707782745,
0.14681020379066467,
-0.38216638565063477,
0.2500525414943695,
0.001366455340757966,
0.5532341003417969,
-0.4503205120563507,
-0.0972294881939888,
-0.4418909251689911,
-0.25854483246803284,
-0.10389827191829681,
-0.2952432334423065,
-0.25173649191856384,
-0.5235445499420166,
-0.22662244737148285,
-0.5955986380577087,
0.28573736548423767,
-0.5564414262771606,
0.9249749183654785,
0.062143635004758835,
-0.5163076519966125,
-0.21398098766803741,
-0.9655427932739258,
0.4533798396587372,
-0.7521167993545532,
0.6289885640144348,
0.6609442234039307,
0.32538551092147827,
-0.16275736689567566,
-0.6295027732849121,
-0.6865625977516174,
0.25013303756713867,
-0.10454811900854111,
0.003323811572045088,
-0.3992553651332855,
0.10489358752965927,
0.023330872878432274,
-0.0025993953458964825,
-0.41953521966934204,
-0.007595238741487265,
-0.6801978945732117,
0.07997879385948181,
0.6661007404327393,
-0.12168857455253601,
0.5308440327644348,
-0.23998741805553436,
-0.13327214121818542,
0.4246535301208496,
-0.5204670429229736,
0.07041309028863907,
0.41536664962768555,
-0.07674653828144073,
-0.1935279369354248,
0.5038819909095764,
-0.06780052930116653,
0.41458672285079956,
0.024424010887742043,
0.09869856387376785,
0.1324526071548462,
-0.6908218860626221,
-0.3259166181087494,
-0.12698841094970703,
0.9863441586494446,
0.6126827597618103,
0.35341116786003113,
0.29211071133613586,
-0.09194830060005188,
0.09161123633384705,
0.36152517795562744,
-0.8722321391105652,
-0.38184550404548645,
0.5222755670547485,
-0.7668372988700867,
-0.28250694274902344,
0.07693356275558472,
-0.5040773749351501,
-0.3391743004322052,
-0.3612990975379944,
0.29086920619010925,
-0.25874587893486023,
-0.4128964841365814,
0.29515764117240906,
-0.39039769768714905,
-0.1967206746339798,
0.37910762429237366,
-0.8964983820915222,
0.5181673169136047,
0.7532359957695007,
0.8931492567062378,
0.12487677484750748,
0.10822543501853943,
-0.3536713421344757,
-0.1111886277794838,
-0.1427811086177826,
0.5316388010978699,
-0.5801003575325012,
-0.31546175479888916,
0.12451457977294922,
0.1517293006181717,
0.016107609495520592,
-0.29457053542137146,
0.7493942379951477,
-0.4106510877609253,
0.06732499599456787,
-0.5051079392433167,
-0.37978318333625793,
-0.4013698101043701,
0.5307605266571045,
-0.620451807975769,
0.7242952585220337,
-0.15687139332294464,
-0.5588743090629578,
0.475197970867157,
-0.5908277630805969,
-0.3157060146331787,
0.2035452276468277,
-0.31643983721733093,
-0.5190490484237671,
0.31020787358283997,
0.3265452980995178,
0.7239966988563538,
-0.12567220628261566,
0.42808932065963745,
-0.327846497297287,
-0.3386101722717285,
0.26442715525627136,
-0.6687338948249817,
0.8271748423576355,
-0.06256838887929916,
-0.272026002407074,
0.2559153437614441,
-0.2375750094652176,
-0.17928583920001984,
0.1440436840057373,
-0.21622101962566376,
-0.7351886034011841,
0.20199698209762573,
0.5062673091888428,
0.4665614664554596,
0.18615292012691498,
-0.7180811762809753,
0.032781608402729034,
-0.07812440395355225,
0.8825240731239319,
0.652949333190918,
0.7212839722633362,
-0.43284058570861816,
-0.2541813254356384,
0.6341775059700012,
-0.3558715283870697,
0.489444762468338,
0.07627297192811966,
-0.917323112487793,
-0.009602605365216732,
-0.24712787568569183,
0.19625231623649597,
0.00510116433724761,
-0.4284294843673706,
0.49611204862594604,
-0.3390548527240753,
-0.642865777015686,
-0.24227149784564972,
0.17556408047676086,
0.19373241066932678,
0.29667672514915466,
0.193931445479393,
-0.03769097477197647,
-0.4430933892726898,
-0.8595426678657532,
-0.21347466111183167,
-0.4278191924095154,
-0.17699794471263885,
0.34901171922683716,
0.4416433870792389,
-0.4447856843471527,
0.5710440278053284,
-0.33578652143478394,
-0.28070196509361267,
-0.2356833815574646,
0.2627451419830322,
-0.08884324133396149,
-0.2630642056465149,
0.3859916925430298,
-1.1157596111297607,
-0.7339828014373779,
0.3941281735897064,
-0.45378509163856506,
-0.17296788096427917,
-0.3802337646484375,
0.03904978558421135,
-0.0518014170229435,
0.20798228681087494,
-0.5088821649551392,
0.5735027194023132,
0.8744860887527466,
-0.32041800022125244,
0.5351327061653137,
-0.1046219915151596,
0.6160757541656494,
-0.692912757396698,
0.24270343780517578,
0.39845505356788635,
-0.10380098223686218,
-0.77442866563797,
-0.6554610729217529,
0.1779913604259491,
0.015388719737529755,
-0.5338462591171265,
0.6788964867591858,
-0.11547671258449554,
0.243338480591774,
-0.11638789623975754,
-0.11646395176649094,
0.2138344645500183,
0.030369848012924194,
0.1802762746810913,
0.496935099363327,
-0.0763339251279831,
-0.27362632751464844,
-0.27417540550231934,
0.09820188581943512,
-0.29182347655296326,
0.38549503684043884,
-0.6936619281768799,
-0.1669337898492813,
0.016128692775964737,
0.4026602804660797,
-1.0394001007080078,
-0.48239415884017944,
0.4335397481918335,
-0.6201746463775635,
-0.12880021333694458,
-0.025125084444880486,
-0.3227032721042633,
-0.45307791233062744,
-0.3476077914237976,
0.5354483723640442,
0.3682028353214264,
-0.23532292246818542,
0.37651199102401733,
0.5450563430786133,
-0.22035275399684906,
-0.15749026834964752,
-0.6106922030448914,
0.2564554512500763,
-0.33675724267959595,
-0.36439216136932373,
0.28145694732666016,
0.13752293586730957,
-0.11755313724279404,
0.11729427427053452,
0.11855858564376831,
-0.1440284103155136,
-0.020253624767065048,
0.20988309383392334,
0.048633139580488205,
0.4981067478656769,
0.4120289385318756,
-0.03794050216674805,
0.04533594846725464,
0.36945515871047974,
0.0060959383845329285,
0.5554929375648499,
0.11011938750743866,
-0.2730378210544586,
-0.945892333984375,
0.37296581268310547,
0.4430386424064636,
-0.14946448802947998,
0.6190858483314514,
0.48273587226867676,
-0.6457078456878662,
0.1491107940673828,
-0.7185194492340088,
-0.10140608251094818,
-0.45455455780029297,
0.1828809529542923,
0.03319087624549866,
-0.5968379974365234,
0.23042970895767212,
0.12078948318958282,
0.039191119372844696,
0.06861678510904312,
0.7560520768165588,
-0.18846569955348969,
0.7709830403327942,
0.3630889654159546,
-0.010881330817937851,
0.6177877187728882,
-0.08093859255313873,
0.5332628488540649,
-0.572949230670929,
-0.24417702853679657,
-0.2056584656238556,
-0.269030898809433,
-0.2701396048069,
-0.38991594314575195,
0.37321755290031433,
-0.29036521911621094,
-0.15062305331230164,
0.2758038341999054,
-0.6396036148071289,
0.33544647693634033,
0.2676934599876404,
0.4065772294998169,
0.22745224833488464,
0.01256248913705349,
0.4302613437175751,
-0.2753600478172302,
-0.26313143968582153,
-0.4773700535297394,
1.0713797807693481,
0.32728537917137146,
0.4074957072734833,
0.03375411778688431,
0.8557610511779785,
0.43587926030158997,
0.40617817640304565,
-0.6956233382225037,
0.18492740392684937,
-0.07921886444091797,
-0.7008563280105591,
-0.2697203755378723,
-0.39398735761642456,
-1.0919171571731567,
-0.056531138718128204,
-0.15269233286380768,
-0.7984331846237183,
0.1871500313282013,
0.19274237751960754,
-0.33063337206840515,
0.3067839741706848,
-0.9013442993164062,
0.9374655485153198,
-0.7450359463691711,
-0.16496513783931732,
-0.0873892530798912,
-0.24941770732402802,
0.5267466902732849,
-0.49393805861473083,
0.509570837020874,
-0.15230466425418854,
0.03205985203385353,
0.8546624183654785,
-0.195182666182518,
0.9744644165039062,
-0.19329266250133514,
0.07650275528430939,
0.39932993054389954,
-0.3677721917629242,
0.5349302291870117,
0.006152339745312929,
0.055870696902275085,
0.6033531427383423,
-0.05358639732003212,
-0.18194708228111267,
-0.498353511095047,
0.6997376680374146,
-0.5403825044631958,
-0.24880078434944153,
-0.03928712382912636,
0.1275239735841751,
0.0729103535413742,
0.2643057405948639,
0.21602049469947815,
-0.0919051393866539,
-0.4944055378437042,
0.15228193998336792,
0.520751953125,
-0.31622135639190674,
0.13614243268966675,
0.03295745328068733,
-0.21682117879390717,
-0.3559923768043518,
0.7385157942771912,
0.20818252861499786,
0.14602042734622955,
0.1955738663673401,
0.5915407538414001,
-0.3065302073955536,
-0.5140406489372253,
0.05535659193992615,
0.49387723207473755,
-0.4553101062774658,
0.11059695482254028,
-0.6003609299659729,
-0.0932060182094574,
-0.28511911630630493,
-0.2907155156135559,
-0.15330930054187775,
0.06945513933897018,
-0.037240169942379,
-0.3806655704975128,
0.37821677327156067,
0.945682942867279,
0.21099621057510376,
0.17898866534233093,
-0.850073516368866,
0.3234740197658539,
0.36283302307128906,
0.07994618266820908,
-0.024704471230506897,
0.010635817423462868,
-0.17150016129016876,
-0.05843197554349899,
-0.20688363909721375,
-1.0409141778945923,
0.385242223739624,
0.009493640623986721,
0.43495821952819824,
0.6561101078987122,
0.0021569847594946623,
0.567795991897583,
-0.44576752185821533,
0.901552140712738,
0.514200747013092,
-0.6386259198188782,
0.5235384702682495,
-0.9158071875572205,
0.18810191750526428,
0.7023887038230896,
0.6088701486587524,
-1.207598090171814,
-0.14229848980903625,
-0.7088897824287415,
-0.8944262266159058,
0.04000859707593918,
0.4221969544887543,
0.1392790824174881,
-0.2648986577987671,
0.1905626654624939,
0.16981326043605804,
0.3362024128437042,
-0.6599884033203125,
0.0023921914398670197,
-0.16769163310527802,
-0.3957030475139618,
0.07428093254566193,
-0.34536224603652954,
-0.16611993312835693,
-0.3195747435092926,
0.6635260581970215,
0.21659891307353973,
0.27960848808288574,
-0.11303005367517471,
0.3835417628288269,
-0.24230599403381348,
0.31738659739494324,
0.4949958920478821,
0.792184591293335,
-0.14899910986423492,
-0.15187616646289825,
-0.30984804034233093,
-0.4771749675273895,
0.24563707411289215,
-0.06051652878522873,
-0.5480363965034485,
0.03834934160113335,
0.09306701272726059,
0.41448912024497986,
0.28646957874298096,
-0.7576121687889099,
0.7307307124137878,
-0.3768920600414276,
-0.4226395785808563,
-0.5280714631080627,
-0.158827006816864,
0.5323635935783386,
-0.19503946602344513,
-0.007149999029934406,
-0.26818740367889404,
0.31728795170783997,
-0.3679830729961395,
0.21605049073696136,
0.46106117963790894,
-0.3895253539085388,
-0.6136632561683655,
0.766323983669281,
0.320404589176178,
-0.4418815076351166,
0.19648465514183044,
0.08276224136352539,
-0.4141305088996887,
0.5164801478385925,
0.10716215521097183,
0.9733800292015076,
-0.21257948875427246,
0.4630923867225647,
0.618721604347229,
0.35406389832496643,
-0.19705617427825928,
0.12948301434516907,
0.15318083763122559,
-0.4961695969104767,
-0.17278367280960083,
-0.28907305002212524,
-0.0618443489074707,
0.571106493473053,
-0.5410083532333374,
0.6821315884590149,
-0.4215349853038788,
-0.2964956760406494,
0.3041630685329437,
-0.15022356808185577,
-0.8749420046806335,
0.19859004020690918,
0.22381766140460968,
0.32578709721565247,
-1.325173020362854,
0.7454395890235901,
0.7411395311355591,
-0.48507919907569885,
-0.5814679265022278,
0.43160250782966614,
0.4951494336128235,
-0.19010157883167267,
0.3048075735569,
0.46210649609565735,
0.04959626868367195,
-0.3975403308868408,
-0.4094892144203186,
-0.5020524859428406,
0.9365309476852417,
0.0628662183880806,
-0.8363547921180725,
-0.009627402760088444,
-0.18425525724887848,
0.5665636658668518,
-0.19583354890346527,
0.15331882238388062,
0.660728931427002,
0.6167658567428589,
-0.2084673047065735,
-0.8260863423347473,
0.09098285436630249,
-0.1575121432542801,
0.0630546361207962,
0.4823914170265198,
-0.5765485167503357,
0.5743637681007385,
0.23179271817207336,
-0.3794975280761719,
-0.4571284353733063,
0.046435579657554626,
0.20795683562755585,
0.3784008026123047,
0.573631227016449,
0.49878090620040894,
0.7951573729515076,
0.31469786167144775,
0.8436058759689331,
-0.005614382214844227,
0.40754634141921997,
0.9760894179344177,
-0.08641795814037323,
1.0496962070465088,
0.4404572546482086,
-0.09760168939828873,
0.44037437438964844,
0.698284924030304,
0.3507131338119507,
0.45983004570007324,
-0.20369777083396912,
-0.5677123665809631,
-0.29220640659332275,
0.15383771061897278,
-0.10981310904026031,
0.23991353809833527,
0.8479688763618469,
-0.6292624473571777,
-0.07162722945213318,
0.04125887155532837,
0.17426535487174988,
0.1372567117214203,
-0.08230697363615036,
0.6584805846214294,
-0.045814186334609985,
-0.5501782298088074,
0.562329888343811,
-0.18262311816215515,
0.46317461133003235,
-0.4900833070278168,
-0.2564104497432709,
0.2873600423336029,
-0.07489963620901108,
-0.3993920385837555,
-0.6282192468643188,
0.37165212631225586,
0.09087631106376648,
0.0037479368038475513,
-0.2266484946012497,
0.8703168034553528,
-0.47316598892211914,
-0.8088738918304443,
0.4004824757575989,
0.22802552580833435,
0.29055193066596985,
-0.20609909296035767,
-0.771511435508728,
0.16555094718933105,
0.061444565653800964,
-0.43125849962234497,
0.2051866054534912,
0.2738514542579651,
-0.18794676661491394,
0.28658628463745117,
0.7323741316795349,
0.40572696924209595,
-0.26020631194114685,
-0.03612662851810455,
0.7918024063110352,
-0.68283611536026,
-0.27180930972099304,
-0.7426639199256897,
0.6033132076263428,
-0.17159058153629303,
-0.3680458068847656,
0.7348855137825012,
0.22133603692054749,
0.9476563930511475,
0.23808851838111877,
1.3281434774398804,
-0.2198771983385086,
0.4761941730976105,
-0.43479013442993164,
0.7707105278968811,
-0.5887113809585571,
0.2430383414030075,
-0.0052318209782242775,
-0.6588553786277771,
-0.20179367065429688,
0.4345633089542389,
-0.6338363885879517,
0.25549736618995667,
0.49554336071014404,
0.4843284487724304,
-0.14938873052597046,
-0.29458916187286377,
0.3045746684074402,
0.033746615052223206,
0.7582675218582153,
0.24921084940433502,
0.2982179820537567,
-0.33521392941474915,
0.33037012815475464,
-0.16453510522842407,
-0.15297359228134155,
-0.5044770240783691,
-0.6280763745307922,
-1.0333598852157593,
-0.5076247453689575,
-0.15704530477523804,
-0.21000754833221436,
0.17220935225486755,
0.9265891313552856,
0.388149231672287,
-0.47492489218711853,
0.14197058975696564,
-0.2678651213645935,
-0.11032979935407639,
-0.2751927971839905,
-0.21550877392292023,
0.27647024393081665,
0.03571949899196625,
-0.551078200340271,
0.0834873840212822,
0.20960760116577148,
-0.388520210981369,
-0.41558510065078735,
-0.04876700043678284,
-0.49621012806892395,
0.05171569064259529,
0.5722732543945312,
0.5240656733512878,
-1.0348756313323975,
-0.35599926114082336,
-0.1518678367137909,
-0.11886938661336899,
0.0969090685248375,
0.8188546299934387,
-0.4936056435108185,
0.7917845845222473,
0.6753258109092712,
0.5549190044403076,
0.587751567363739,
0.4536450207233429,
0.4780158996582031,
-0.6300340890884399,
-0.3524593114852905,
0.33143794536590576,
0.28630170226097107,
0.389428973197937,
-0.6215387582778931,
0.33349698781967163,
-0.04693574830889702,
-0.7825638651847839,
-0.40590980648994446,
-0.024043714627623558,
-0.7858898639678955,
-0.43249404430389404,
1.5562968254089355,
-0.05092620849609375,
-0.34126517176628113,
-0.523925244808197,
-0.4082131087779999,
0.01615081913769245,
-0.6801175475120544,
0.8610358238220215,
0.8841624855995178,
-0.10258820652961731,
-0.23160657286643982,
-1.2401752471923828,
0.4300597310066223,
-0.11936309188604355,
-0.9846076965332031,
0.3577309250831604,
0.6265745162963867,
0.3540067970752716,
-0.07275132834911346,
1.189670443534851,
0.09698313474655151,
0.39455923438072205,
-0.38403382897377014,
0.30549323558807373,
-0.06256188452243805,
-0.3238653838634491,
-0.4130215048789978,
-0.08153695613145828,
-0.10208731889724731,
-0.05547276511788368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16914v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16914v1
|
Prediction Is All MoE Needs: Expert Load Distribution Goes from Fluctuating to Stabilizing
| 2024-04-25T15:39:59 | 2024-04-25T15:39:59 |
Peizhuang Cong, Aomufei Yuan, Shimao Chen, Yuxuan Tian, Bowen Ye, Tong Yang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
MoE facilitates the development of large models by making the computational
complexity of the model no longer scale linearly with increasing parameters.
The learning sparse gating network selects a set of experts for each token to
be processed; however, this may lead to differences in the number of tokens
processed by each expert over several successive iterations, i.e., the expert
load fluctuations, which reduces computational parallelization and resource
utilization. To this end, we traced and analyzed loads of each expert in the
training iterations for several large language models in this work, and defined
the transient state with "obvious load fluctuation" and the stable state with
"temporal locality". Moreover, given the characteristics of these two states
and the computational overhead, we deployed three classical prediction
algorithms that achieve accurate expert load prediction results. For the GPT3
350M model, the average error rates for predicting the expert load proportion
over the next 1,000 and 2,000 steps are approximately 1.3% and 1.8%,
respectively. This work can provide valuable guidance for expert placement or
resource allocation for MoE model training. Based on this work, we will propose
an expert placement scheme for transient and stable states in our coming work.
|
[
-0.5561807751655579,
-0.7807344198226929,
0.4837273359298706,
0.4140629768371582,
0.22300027310848236,
-0.05497932434082031,
-0.09821856021881104,
-0.6053503751754761,
0.1031077578663826,
0.14485622942447662,
-0.4033277928829193,
0.16570979356765747,
-0.6456452012062073,
-0.0034671304747462273,
-0.14574885368347168,
0.8099692463874817,
-0.07838446646928787,
0.0926370620727539,
-0.031248467043042183,
0.3760853409767151,
-0.9483701586723328,
0.09951546788215637,
-0.7929125428199768,
-0.29087868332862854,
0.110858254134655,
0.2620786726474762,
0.8220757246017456,
0.7222838997840881,
0.43889203667640686,
0.3415866196155548,
0.06613191962242126,
-0.07283509522676468,
-0.581879734992981,
0.19824829697608948,
-0.005262710619717836,
-0.34255415201187134,
-0.6347308158874512,
0.023480545729398727,
0.5656577944755554,
0.4392510950565338,
-0.6341761350631714,
-0.1738324612379074,
0.05603386461734772,
0.06122379004955292,
-0.5057640671730042,
0.4123772382736206,
-0.9966986775398254,
0.012147864326834679,
-0.2608164846897125,
-0.3101203739643097,
-0.6280767917633057,
-0.019499143585562706,
0.5010770559310913,
-0.6322414875030518,
0.4335821270942688,
0.2822548747062683,
0.8434887528419495,
0.28441089391708374,
-0.47723931074142456,
0.10659082978963852,
-0.6523445248603821,
1.002376914024353,
-0.48591193556785583,
0.08831154555082321,
0.7377816438674927,
0.3678532540798187,
-0.24681545794010162,
-0.419396311044693,
-0.2809765934944153,
-0.11103565245866776,
0.1525547355413437,
0.09754814207553864,
0.11039131879806519,
0.2070436030626297,
0.02917891927063465,
0.21992558240890503,
-0.33196866512298584,
0.08663307875394821,
-0.39395204186439514,
-0.0620780810713768,
0.5741168260574341,
0.3300642669200897,
0.3395017981529236,
0.1530032455921173,
-0.6827042102813721,
0.46160078048706055,
-0.46184635162353516,
-0.27894067764282227,
0.2916077673435211,
0.22275136411190033,
0.08434049785137177,
0.004466287326067686,
-0.2126808911561966,
0.4898316562175751,
0.3867250680923462,
-0.07556039839982986,
0.20090247690677643,
0.033069707453250885,
-0.15939271450042725,
0.014069527387619019,
1.035369634628296,
0.3577701449394226,
0.553351640701294,
-0.13705846667289734,
-0.3611471652984619,
-0.6841439604759216,
0.5573786497116089,
-0.5829070210456848,
-0.48722636699676514,
-0.2319832593202591,
-0.09971371293067932,
-0.28548702597618103,
0.09503545612096786,
-0.8417989611625671,
-0.3902972936630249,
-0.12090927362442017,
0.43564045429229736,
-0.4720956087112427,
-0.6695572137832642,
-0.02370806410908699,
0.490426242351532,
-0.29575982689857483,
0.2771827280521393,
-1.3926489353179932,
0.2425086796283722,
0.34351372718811035,
0.9279786944389343,
-0.00037251508911140263,
-0.2804151177406311,
-0.2808266580104828,
0.3120180666446686,
-0.27329862117767334,
0.6778485178947449,
-0.5464204549789429,
-0.3450925052165985,
0.017429649829864502,
-0.04091361165046692,
-0.47483307123184204,
-0.013796541839838028,
0.33084821701049805,
-0.7759965658187866,
-0.2621222138404846,
-0.3360321819782257,
-0.35239753127098083,
-0.4405277967453003,
-0.17926719784736633,
-0.7807341814041138,
1.2186243534088135,
0.07595998793840408,
-0.8328837752342224,
0.47659167647361755,
-0.44046831130981445,
-0.3806297779083252,
0.18338750302791595,
-0.03888608515262604,
-0.3425773084163666,
0.09813956916332245,
0.287246435880661,
0.8627563714981079,
-0.0863206684589386,
0.2857908010482788,
-0.4946444630622864,
-0.3801989257335663,
0.13513189554214478,
-0.42499423027038574,
0.3563137948513031,
0.34495753049850464,
-0.4249187707901001,
-0.1464845836162567,
-0.27781322598457336,
-0.011211329139769077,
-0.048023074865341187,
-0.3438664376735687,
0.03552298620343208,
0.48162657022476196,
-0.0297684408724308,
-0.031941190361976624,
0.1780392974615097,
-0.25054433941841125,
0.48696449398994446,
-0.33255431056022644,
0.5410589575767517,
1.1907336711883545,
-0.024652104824781418,
0.43684592843055725,
-0.06366421282291412,
0.6591947674751282,
-0.11141888797283173,
0.14692576229572296,
-0.04006582498550415,
-0.7410191893577576,
-0.617920458316803,
-0.07349094748497009,
0.3155835270881653,
0.6812331080436707,
-0.7795436978340149,
0.01792697235941887,
-0.444071888923645,
-0.30285245180130005,
-0.568560779094696,
0.1783309280872345,
0.33303552865982056,
0.4855923056602478,
0.5534980297088623,
0.2887691557407379,
-0.3688686788082123,
-0.8875430822372437,
0.09452734142541885,
-0.11120820045471191,
0.30172958970069885,
-0.14074182510375977,
0.27574142813682556,
0.003993586637079716,
1.0300651788711548,
-0.5520535707473755,
-0.25955861806869507,
-0.09318989515304565,
0.4873531758785248,
0.08907967805862427,
0.6166539788246155,
0.8846285343170166,
-0.6275222897529602,
-0.8560302257537842,
0.1895122528076172,
-0.5636361837387085,
0.1046876311302185,
-0.11410658061504364,
-0.19091585278511047,
0.28412920236587524,
0.29279959201812744,
-0.5621770024299622,
0.24953259527683258,
0.4727083742618561,
0.05798361450433731,
0.5970823168754578,
-0.09112682193517685,
-0.05167362466454506,
-1.163191318511963,
-0.15419167280197144,
0.23475277423858643,
-0.353744775056839,
-0.39939823746681213,
0.032312195748090744,
-0.10649996250867844,
0.04132778197526932,
-0.015905389562249184,
0.3731306493282318,
-0.7739592790603638,
0.25974801182746887,
-0.08386050164699554,
-0.19909174740314484,
-0.6279978156089783,
0.519757866859436,
-0.17934119701385498,
1.2302305698394775,
1.112285852432251,
-0.4929538369178772,
0.4004063606262207,
-0.03982405737042427,
-0.6167738437652588,
0.09101612120866776,
-0.7210605144500732,
0.1288314163684845,
0.37921378016471863,
-0.025011802092194557,
-0.9142332077026367,
-0.2492920160293579,
0.010988494381308556,
-0.5232513546943665,
0.6765342354774475,
-0.3748358190059662,
-0.5662611126899719,
-0.34349778294563293,
0.13109058141708374,
0.31351420283317566,
0.4365254044532776,
-0.0789843276143074,
0.6847425103187561,
0.6310612559318542,
-0.5577557682991028,
-0.8809710144996643,
-0.7367002964019775,
-0.10134874284267426,
0.17094849050045013,
-0.526519238948822,
0.002335380995646119,
0.01042537484318018,
0.043665941804647446,
0.18173833191394806,
-0.11476936936378479,
-0.1317971646785736,
0.4234365224838257,
0.3401239812374115,
0.14088074862957,
-0.2630758583545685,
0.2896045446395874,
-0.06084884703159332,
-0.4041455388069153,
0.10803409665822983,
-0.26900890469551086,
0.38436275720596313,
-0.39783549308776855,
-0.22965125739574432,
-0.5781850218772888,
0.20986506342887878,
0.45548954606056213,
-0.004029837902635336,
0.9481105208396912,
0.7191331386566162,
-0.2946416139602661,
-0.15466158092021942,
-0.7642866969108582,
0.2349192202091217,
-0.5268566608428955,
0.539503276348114,
-0.40470758080482483,
-0.3058537244796753,
0.5007081031799316,
0.11396482586860657,
0.12361063063144684,
0.6815922856330872,
0.6090288162231445,
-0.1738099455833435,
1.4978678226470947,
0.8387526869773865,
-0.48709142208099365,
0.6078811287879944,
-0.34897223114967346,
0.09147284924983978,
-0.45839226245880127,
-0.09336040914058685,
-0.0718865916132927,
-0.4472375810146332,
-0.35833433270454407,
-0.25415652990341187,
0.290601909160614,
0.14205124974250793,
-0.07895692437887192,
0.01304456777870655,
-0.371416300535202,
0.5819393992424011,
0.35743528604507446,
0.04008496180176735,
-0.3228960931301117,
0.24777626991271973,
-0.4248916506767273,
0.16590553522109985,
-0.5474179983139038,
-0.3748241066932678,
1.1228644847869873,
0.2667267322540283,
0.7122790217399597,
-0.05326148867607117,
0.09991633892059326,
0.3579105734825134,
0.4023270308971405,
-0.815497636795044,
0.5488460063934326,
0.15633681416511536,
-0.7207817435264587,
-0.32487425208091736,
-0.4452509582042694,
-0.7544944286346436,
-0.09272981435060501,
-0.3330160081386566,
-0.7166708707809448,
0.0010561802191659808,
0.2428644448518753,
-0.484035462141037,
0.5407666563987732,
-0.7789949178695679,
0.48655077815055847,
0.011322452686727047,
-0.16228023171424866,
-0.41706588864326477,
-0.4927305281162262,
0.1592644900083542,
-0.1798166036605835,
-0.060946352779865265,
-0.20324485003948212,
-0.018071318045258522,
0.5925070643424988,
-0.49853724241256714,
0.7789556384086609,
-0.35503602027893066,
0.03955778852105141,
0.36278077960014343,
0.3049890100955963,
0.6351284384727478,
0.08205724507570267,
-0.5824781656265259,
-0.02851524017751217,
-0.24432675540447235,
-0.6224595904350281,
-0.3947177231311798,
0.7422706484794617,
-1.010636329650879,
-0.5998433828353882,
-0.292919784784317,
-0.5770363211631775,
-0.3782189190387726,
0.28479528427124023,
0.4771951735019684,
0.5115320682525635,
0.1837540566921234,
0.2618400454521179,
0.8791716694831848,
0.45746591687202454,
0.5921287536621094,
0.35935696959495544,
-0.12487740069627762,
-0.42174795269966125,
0.9808815121650696,
0.542029082775116,
0.1578764021396637,
0.20417095720767975,
-0.09601069241762161,
-0.117416612803936,
-0.729175329208374,
-0.34044238924980164,
0.013244309462606907,
-0.4904979169368744,
-0.31742149591445923,
-0.6219121217727661,
0.026390837505459785,
-0.2305757701396942,
-0.37526431679725647,
-0.2619457244873047,
-0.18496207892894745,
-0.32649457454681396,
-0.33558446168899536,
0.5124439001083374,
0.9316020607948303,
0.10877785831689835,
0.7517797350883484,
-0.5522243976593018,
-0.11638446897268295,
0.4347384572029114,
0.661198079586029,
0.2819126844406128,
-0.33628398180007935,
-0.7329363226890564,
0.05340411514043808,
-0.6578291654586792,
-0.7882195115089417,
0.23577268421649933,
0.4242929220199585,
0.8602591156959534,
0.9738878011703491,
0.04437229782342911,
0.7893529534339905,
-0.654689371585846,
0.7019339799880981,
0.24466946721076965,
-0.7546459436416626,
0.4940485656261444,
-0.7810685038566589,
-0.21929006278514862,
0.3726213276386261,
0.5700426697731018,
0.038842782378196716,
-0.30051282048225403,
-0.5443524718284607,
-0.8053341507911682,
0.82069331407547,
-0.025137074291706085,
0.18607304990291595,
-0.12803131341934204,
0.352643221616745,
0.30472496151924133,
0.014358376152813435,
-0.4586280286312103,
-0.07466860860586166,
0.005495070479810238,
-0.24747760593891144,
-0.03843941539525986,
-0.4145381450653076,
0.07419760525226593,
-0.11419925838708878,
0.7979365587234497,
-0.1588742434978485,
0.6524686813354492,
-0.2909007966518402,
-0.010875867679715157,
-0.5741612911224365,
-0.15728338062763214,
0.5491267442703247,
0.9491374492645264,
-0.3351063132286072,
-0.20147591829299927,
0.3919706344604492,
-0.721068799495697,
-0.07703327387571335,
-0.08935366570949554,
-0.07352709770202637,
0.026228012517094612,
0.2631184458732605,
0.950438916683197,
0.4799823462963104,
-0.005211099050939083,
0.39568349719047546,
0.26620543003082275,
-0.18950359523296356,
-0.47527188062667847,
0.23808526992797852,
-0.05606662482023239,
0.14191003143787384,
0.6209032535552979,
0.4454106092453003,
-0.04949910193681717,
-0.12338966876268387,
0.06509040296077728,
0.15488563477993011,
-0.3232420086860657,
-0.725538432598114,
0.8961071372032166,
0.5597113370895386,
0.20140229165554047,
0.9665177464485168,
-0.16935031116008759,
-0.537240743637085,
0.6275129318237305,
0.3334060311317444,
0.9319429993629456,
-0.6759856939315796,
0.03986566513776779,
0.32109397649765015,
0.2444121390581131,
-0.7059064507484436,
0.2957533299922943,
0.22415301203727722,
-0.5925422310829163,
-0.5718509554862976,
-0.5146389007568359,
-0.17671337723731995,
-0.18935121595859528,
-0.8607916831970215,
0.34248650074005127,
-0.4993574023246765,
-0.7132930159568787,
-0.311286985874176,
0.31343796849250793,
-0.7332780957221985,
0.07863860577344894,
0.17282137274742126,
0.8529359698295593,
-0.9151387810707092,
0.8585662245750427,
0.8102329969406128,
-0.42083898186683655,
-0.9345707297325134,
0.1798660159111023,
0.06504890322685242,
-1.0131560564041138,
0.806175708770752,
0.19488409161567688,
-0.15115122497081757,
0.4201783835887909,
-0.6124290823936462,
-1.031245231628418,
1.2646336555480957,
0.41244566440582275,
-0.4171014428138733,
-0.17333590984344482,
-0.38056814670562744,
0.3283676505088806,
-0.09725753962993622,
0.5203333497047424,
-0.11378280818462372,
0.366763710975647,
0.03741628676652908,
-1.095198392868042,
-0.015701711177825928,
-0.3288218080997467,
0.09761602431535721,
0.4182160198688507,
-0.6824123859405518,
1.1000144481658936,
-0.3540114760398865,
-0.37110084295272827,
0.19849051535129547,
0.9749799370765686,
-0.15581321716308594,
-0.012815352529287338,
0.4979515075683594,
0.6258779168128967,
0.7453057765960693,
-0.2546498775482178,
1.1281473636627197,
-0.5854917168617249,
0.7116267085075378,
0.6616693139076233,
0.08288303017616272,
1.0617198944091797,
0.07744751870632172,
-0.43165600299835205,
0.4889190196990967,
1.0418107509613037,
-0.2690792679786682,
0.6076213717460632,
-0.19015537202358246,
-0.1765701174736023,
-0.4620109498500824,
0.1342533677816391,
-0.6786831617355347,
-0.10462358593940735,
0.5487188696861267,
-0.11143253743648529,
-0.0375223383307457,
0.07590696215629578,
0.04675186052918434,
-0.7179659605026245,
-0.5201332569122314,
0.4338318109512329,
0.019737185910344124,
-0.4612075686454773,
0.6504104733467102,
-0.2506311535835266,
0.43202072381973267,
-0.4749942719936371,
0.18439620733261108,
-0.045158930122852325,
0.17726163566112518,
-0.3120806813240051,
-0.9446946978569031,
-0.20127002894878387,
-0.32287994027137756,
-0.592571496963501,
-0.42738181352615356,
0.457084983587265,
-0.24783296883106232,
-0.5098440051078796,
0.1897096335887909,
0.12661947309970856,
0.2607437074184418,
0.09636691957712173,
-0.6326576471328735,
-0.43129655718803406,
-0.23691853880882263,
-0.6185161471366882,
0.4859979450702667,
0.69873046875,
-0.050679877400398254,
1.193828821182251,
0.35626858472824097,
0.3452551066875458,
0.46065205335617065,
-0.3687613308429718,
0.7875705361366272,
-0.13108646869659424,
-0.7449037432670593,
-0.5285706520080566,
0.4812346398830414,
0.24171769618988037,
-0.2700664699077606,
0.495369553565979,
-0.061648834496736526,
0.6354954838752747,
-0.19983327388763428,
0.7547560930252075,
-0.10602187365293503,
0.12890899181365967,
-0.7094545364379883,
0.8673522472381592,
-0.5025634169578552,
0.1735074520111084,
-0.12743908166885376,
-0.746958315372467,
0.16598045825958252,
0.5395277738571167,
-0.5052425861358643,
0.3054024279117584,
0.5284197926521301,
0.580729067325592,
-0.09572739154100418,
0.05532330274581909,
0.13600294291973114,
0.48696669936180115,
0.021325625479221344,
0.44309261441230774,
0.5635841488838196,
-0.24269722402095795,
0.6665147542953491,
-0.23516419529914856,
0.012860453687608242,
-0.7539897561073303,
-0.7665901780128479,
-0.6510058641433716,
-0.5297337770462036,
-0.2602548599243164,
0.17314106225967407,
-0.10380903631448746,
0.8701415657997131,
0.9416102766990662,
-0.88677978515625,
-0.05473785847425461,
-0.0919715091586113,
-0.15443730354309082,
-0.5535547137260437,
-0.3214060068130493,
0.34426066279411316,
-0.6931183934211731,
-0.6996845602989197,
0.33819693326950073,
-0.05323386937379837,
-0.038708776235580444,
-0.24768172204494476,
-0.02734404057264328,
-0.38275429606437683,
-0.07633274048566818,
0.33616140484809875,
0.1688423901796341,
-0.7511579394340515,
-0.26611870527267456,
-0.22112353146076202,
-0.23979789018630981,
-0.17618156969547272,
0.47884654998779297,
-0.596707284450531,
0.7621302008628845,
0.6176591515541077,
0.6626612544059753,
-0.06645118445158005,
0.09933269768953323,
0.9091669321060181,
-0.7398938536643982,
-0.0977289155125618,
-0.049739986658096313,
0.6171130537986755,
-0.20144811272621155,
-0.6809711456298828,
0.648022472858429,
0.5050751566886902,
-0.97588050365448,
-0.7879440188407898,
-0.1500251144170761,
-0.9307834506034851,
0.07183794677257538,
0.9457854628562927,
-0.3967098295688629,
0.11476746946573257,
-0.2937464416027069,
-0.055446065962314606,
0.17099088430404663,
-0.814435601234436,
0.8655951619148254,
1.016370177268982,
-0.1093544214963913,
-0.18776465952396393,
-1.268264889717102,
0.32769712805747986,
0.4727720022201538,
-0.08721821755170822,
-0.16081851720809937,
0.22858266532421112,
0.4294368624687195,
0.2610549032688141,
0.4089784622192383,
0.3833548128604889,
0.061314500868320465,
0.032445188611745834,
0.1796484887599945,
-0.4153638780117035,
-0.45918452739715576,
-0.028287174180150032,
0.15464352071285248,
-0.17867445945739746,
-0.3104025721549988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00715v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00715v4
|
Adapting Open-Source Large Language Models for Cost-Effective, Expert-Level Clinical Note Generation with On-Policy Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-04-25T15:34:53 | 2024-06-10T01:09:03 |
Hanyin Wang, Chufan Gao, Bolun Liu, Qiping Xu, Guleid Hussein, Mohamad El Labban, Kingsley Iheasirim, Hariprasad Korsapati, Chuck Outcalt, Jimeng Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Proprietary Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-4 and Gemini have
demonstrated promising capabilities in clinical text summarization tasks.
However, due to patient data privacy concerns and computational costs, many
healthcare providers prefer using small, locally-hosted models over external
generic LLMs. This study presents a comprehensive domain- and task-specific
adaptation process for the open-source LLaMA-2 13 billion parameter model,
enabling it to generate high-quality clinical notes from outpatient
patient-doctor dialogues. Our process incorporates continued pre-training,
supervised fine-tuning, and reinforcement learning from both AI and human
feedback. We introduced a new approach, DistillDirect, for performing on-policy
reinforcement learning with Gemini 1.0 Pro as the teacher model. Our resulting
model, LLaMA-Clinic, can generate clinical notes comparable in quality to those
authored by physicians. In a blinded physician reader study, the majority
(90.4%) of individual evaluations rated the notes generated by LLaMA-Clinic as
"acceptable" or higher across all three criteria: real-world readiness,
completeness, and accuracy. In the more challenging "Assessment and Plan"
section, LLaMA-Clinic scored higher (4.2/5) in real-world readiness than
physician-authored notes (4.1/5). Our cost analysis for inference shows that
our LLaMA-Clinic model achieves a 3.75-fold cost reduction compared to an
external generic LLM service. Additionally, we highlight key considerations for
future clinical note-generation tasks, emphasizing the importance of
pre-defining a best-practice note format, rather than relying on LLMs to
determine this for clinical practice. We have made our newly created synthetic
clinic dialogue-note dataset and the physician feedback dataset publicly
available to foster future research.
|
[
0.04715678468346596,
-0.5458536744117737,
0.9093533754348755,
0.33833250403404236,
-0.2824036478996277,
-0.1819380819797516,
-0.3820716142654419,
-0.35231438279151917,
0.07510638982057571,
0.7513795495033264,
-0.3968740999698639,
-0.7566567063331604,
-0.5983728170394897,
0.11792700737714767,
0.023229030892252922,
1.580816626548767,
-0.19796891510486603,
0.05203765258193016,
-0.2436334192752838,
0.006549246143549681,
-0.16056866943836212,
-0.3463935852050781,
-0.6457228064537048,
-0.1188216507434845,
0.5047029256820679,
0.5084362626075745,
0.3878187835216522,
0.49268391728401184,
0.6139044165611267,
0.27265462279319763,
-0.03876730427145958,
0.306532621383667,
-0.4111160337924957,
0.0223406869918108,
-0.21740932762622833,
-0.3117387294769287,
-0.9256744980812073,
-0.042560964822769165,
0.40627139806747437,
0.5101492404937744,
-0.5728178024291992,
0.06848447024822235,
-0.16917003691196442,
0.44132906198501587,
-0.30364248156547546,
0.1989079713821411,
-0.6961643099784851,
0.01140583399683237,
0.029699165374040604,
-0.2803477346897125,
-0.4313427209854126,
-0.589216947555542,
0.39667898416519165,
-0.8549438714981079,
0.22732089459896088,
-0.2482466697692871,
0.5144796371459961,
0.17756034433841705,
-0.3247474133968353,
-0.7049633264541626,
-0.5551515817642212,
0.6486579775810242,
-0.8761320114135742,
-0.20662476122379303,
0.47373074293136597,
0.3609699606895447,
-0.39869776368141174,
-0.9020600318908691,
-0.31622403860092163,
-0.5895495414733887,
0.06333084404468536,
0.44619473814964294,
0.02258899062871933,
0.30594757199287415,
0.21066364645957947,
0.31047701835632324,
-0.2231341451406479,
0.2404719442129135,
-0.5118231773376465,
0.062178537249565125,
0.7890796661376953,
0.3686177730560303,
-0.07525679469108582,
0.013868010602891445,
-0.1642039567232132,
0.011496302671730518,
-0.8434768915176392,
-0.13154734671115875,
0.024657830595970154,
0.17057600617408752,
-0.20940589904785156,
0.29330211877822876,
-0.029881523922085762,
0.336640864610672,
0.218300461769104,
-0.6314131021499634,
0.07095634192228317,
-0.18473997712135315,
-0.0916576236486435,
0.3574795126914978,
0.8315958976745605,
0.40031057596206665,
0.13764025270938873,
0.03045102395117283,
-0.16957376897335052,
-0.1599818766117096,
0.5860903263092041,
-0.8061672449111938,
-0.47194910049438477,
0.29833459854125977,
-0.4972924292087555,
-0.5448309183120728,
-0.44837531447410583,
-0.5814267992973328,
-0.47848501801490784,
-0.15089017152786255,
0.2726522386074066,
-0.3170207738876343,
-0.09581619501113892,
0.1361875832080841,
0.2333025336265564,
-0.24105985462665558,
0.8501758575439453,
-0.8941600918769836,
0.6861457824707031,
0.3858049511909485,
0.7892837524414062,
-0.13660719990730286,
-0.22321461141109467,
-0.7931487560272217,
0.2092519998550415,
-0.37970370054244995,
0.7637118697166443,
-0.17432481050491333,
-0.6812984347343445,
0.07381542772054672,
-0.12378852814435959,
-0.1394203156232834,
-0.7551215291023254,
0.4075118899345398,
-0.0030273678712546825,
0.3316788375377655,
0.029052259400486946,
-0.4607032537460327,
0.29851165413856506,
0.17465855181217194,
-0.45745354890823364,
0.7107611894607544,
0.5350868105888367,
-0.4858127236366272,
0.292172372341156,
-0.7964494824409485,
-0.5533236265182495,
0.044215597212314606,
-0.17888793349266052,
-0.6886246800422668,
0.2500591278076172,
0.3756517767906189,
0.42854365706443787,
-0.39105603098869324,
0.3754315972328186,
-0.10738228261470795,
-0.13357362151145935,
0.46108874678611755,
-0.21973589062690735,
0.47700566053390503,
0.25987136363983154,
-0.0736762285232544,
0.2491452395915985,
-0.9346684217453003,
-0.3350841701030731,
0.1678946167230606,
-0.6043393015861511,
-0.17992174625396729,
0.07908184826374054,
-0.005781067535281181,
0.21916289627552032,
-0.04196929931640625,
-0.5572219491004944,
0.3371637761592865,
-0.3591732382774353,
0.6878061890602112,
0.599050760269165,
0.3664969205856323,
0.17377500236034393,
-0.4547732472419739,
0.6101481914520264,
0.07320057600736618,
0.5094941854476929,
-0.3391351103782654,
-0.44444069266319275,
-0.44741666316986084,
-0.4831688702106476,
0.0979723110795021,
0.47081100940704346,
-0.4601362347602844,
0.04821035638451576,
-0.20749755203723907,
-0.49958980083465576,
-0.8103046417236328,
0.10776183754205704,
0.6900132298469543,
0.8773235082626343,
0.45884209871292114,
-0.4371931254863739,
-0.22529152035713196,
-0.5217122435569763,
-0.02199239656329155,
-0.3481406569480896,
-0.03178642690181732,
0.47794830799102783,
0.47571635246276855,
-0.09161210805177689,
0.6243040561676025,
-0.6834138035774231,
-0.5949000716209412,
-0.4008335471153259,
0.06033286452293396,
0.2642633020877838,
0.2761838436126709,
0.32795795798301697,
-0.3610275089740753,
-0.47393736243247986,
0.03293418139219284,
-0.3478868305683136,
-0.20282365381717682,
-0.4523663818836212,
0.20443783700466156,
0.30493319034576416,
0.46358156204223633,
-0.5885093212127686,
0.4032325744628906,
0.5785622000694275,
-0.06299102306365967,
0.48576149344444275,
-0.9200095534324646,
-0.0804295539855957,
-1.2733824253082275,
0.14550456404685974,
0.12016396969556808,
-0.29736050963401794,
-0.5389171838760376,
-0.22299322485923767,
-0.07420474290847778,
0.022270848974585533,
-0.3857182264328003,
0.38810354471206665,
-0.15092496573925018,
0.07237617671489716,
-0.2372087687253952,
0.19287805259227753,
-0.038535039871931076,
0.413519024848938,
0.24602268636226654,
0.450849324464798,
0.009787306189537048,
-0.49124279618263245,
0.11289524286985397,
0.5886294841766357,
-0.4741118252277374,
0.6233870387077332,
-0.7052375674247742,
0.07401564717292786,
0.19233769178390503,
0.5424761772155762,
-0.6131912469863892,
-0.24206361174583435,
0.1799420267343521,
-0.29548779129981995,
0.21804925799369812,
-0.1476893424987793,
-0.29033899307250977,
-0.12044627219438553,
-0.14087200164794922,
0.008770689368247986,
0.6799910664558411,
-0.27093300223350525,
0.3378886580467224,
0.42498978972435,
-0.7221105098724365,
-0.2530982196331024,
-0.456745982170105,
0.1993575543165207,
0.030084237456321716,
-0.08064538240432739,
0.5311681628227234,
0.09958408027887344,
-0.18124644458293915,
0.016370421275496483,
0.0512542724609375,
0.040682461112737656,
0.09036004543304443,
0.2995195984840393,
0.397490531206131,
-0.2339220494031906,
0.08167362213134766,
0.46021273732185364,
-0.09902407228946686,
0.2437826246023178,
-0.23534627258777618,
0.18090344965457916,
0.19913756847381592,
-0.3072640299797058,
-0.47878751158714294,
0.2530865967273712,
0.5062566995620728,
-0.199700266122818,
0.4273075461387634,
0.3252100944519043,
-0.1974308043718338,
-0.35938090085983276,
-0.37966588139533997,
-0.15923719108104706,
-0.45199206471443176,
0.5506317019462585,
-0.037794485688209534,
-0.7075927257537842,
0.22410590946674347,
-0.3042515218257904,
0.4079606533050537,
0.3217278718948364,
0.8818211555480957,
-0.16118112206459045,
0.8235691785812378,
0.29851439595222473,
0.027541235089302063,
0.16885733604431152,
0.00027292469167150557,
0.09245522320270538,
-0.7833107709884644,
-0.3621276021003723,
-0.3441006541252136,
0.05011352524161339,
-0.6950767636299133,
-0.4892389476299286,
0.7935345768928528,
-0.14171458780765533,
-0.23660139739513397,
0.0035350462421774864,
-0.5612762570381165,
0.18209074437618256,
0.5305115580558777,
0.3364013433456421,
0.39114701747894287,
-0.03326357528567314,
0.009780085645616055,
0.06858893483877182,
-0.4960006773471832,
-0.323365718126297,
1.4776793718338013,
0.4319870173931122,
0.7386511564254761,
0.09861520677804947,
0.7162851691246033,
0.26562708616256714,
0.7130700349807739,
-0.4002282917499542,
0.44974285364151,
-0.3155008852481842,
-0.17754225432872772,
-0.23943297564983368,
-0.4079434871673584,
-0.8706581592559814,
0.13756605982780457,
-0.2978909909725189,
-0.6296306252479553,
-0.29958638548851013,
0.48334652185440063,
-0.5324506163597107,
-0.038417503237724304,
-0.3616187870502472,
0.7638930678367615,
-0.3209792375564575,
-0.2767190933227539,
-0.38314738869667053,
-0.6570264101028442,
0.318266361951828,
-0.22112365067005157,
0.11530955135822296,
-0.06730225682258606,
-0.13699062168598175,
0.39011895656585693,
-0.6689019799232483,
0.9578688144683838,
-0.3010694682598114,
-0.3849741518497467,
0.31894785165786743,
0.012387650087475777,
0.6376524567604065,
0.22375944256782532,
0.2162676453590393,
-0.11397463828325272,
0.037423595786094666,
-0.15726375579833984,
-0.5275479555130005,
0.6916994452476501,
-0.8889511823654175,
-0.5480219721794128,
-0.3385837972164154,
-0.6364215612411499,
-0.39181163907051086,
-0.14048393070697784,
0.08810949325561523,
0.5183572173118591,
-0.3754773736000061,
-0.4107377529144287,
0.6454887986183167,
-0.7107012271881104,
0.01505074929445982,
0.8316982388496399,
-0.21474790573120117,
-0.8245863318443298,
0.9909650683403015,
-0.10666786134243011,
0.37278124690055847,
0.33656027913093567,
0.465333491563797,
-0.3563791811466217,
-0.8059322834014893,
-0.4635268449783325,
0.4363192915916443,
-0.6019663214683533,
0.15029174089431763,
-0.6637557148933411,
-0.20404137670993805,
-0.5570551753044128,
-0.23582418262958527,
-0.17281578481197357,
-0.4876454472541809,
-0.4007003605365753,
-0.12062337249517441,
0.6672915816307068,
0.7016457319259644,
0.1077003926038742,
0.5079209208488464,
-0.8450716137886047,
0.19260014593601227,
0.022976739332079887,
0.11083804816007614,
-0.1509837508201599,
-0.7222438454627991,
-0.2477259635925293,
-0.3146093487739563,
-0.5782343149185181,
-0.6483649015426636,
0.40706774592399597,
0.38070571422576904,
0.4096886217594147,
0.558211088180542,
0.0380496121942997,
0.6574438214302063,
-0.7633464336395264,
0.629065990447998,
0.3777901530265808,
-0.7481602430343628,
0.7017152905464172,
-0.49864083528518677,
0.17941296100616455,
0.5668898224830627,
0.2735937237739563,
-0.5730077624320984,
-0.48384132981300354,
-0.611433207988739,
-0.7555004358291626,
0.7784450054168701,
-0.04876253008842468,
0.08585447818040848,
-0.04266779497265816,
0.5485096573829651,
0.30701586604118347,
0.2510809898376465,
-0.3821534812450409,
0.14870311319828033,
-0.10628087818622589,
-0.6516643166542053,
-0.43693122267723083,
-0.06340514868497849,
-0.33656710386276245,
-0.07789858430624008,
0.31520912051200867,
-0.30460548400878906,
0.18585634231567383,
0.3638935685157776,
-0.12448129802942276,
-0.004700126126408577,
0.23840926587581635,
0.9698247313499451,
0.6039162874221802,
-0.1702282428741455,
-0.21802663803100586,
0.1894790083169937,
-0.8127962350845337,
0.004281166475266218,
0.23827402293682098,
-0.10290531814098358,
0.05397959053516388,
0.4401284456253052,
0.9637788534164429,
0.38610461354255676,
-0.9790035486221313,
0.6522127985954285,
0.05031656101346016,
-0.5452370047569275,
-0.5242002010345459,
0.16555818915367126,
0.039181437343358994,
0.09492430090904236,
-0.1971624493598938,
-0.28000253438949585,
0.1494670957326889,
-0.3970034122467041,
0.04245474189519882,
-0.0005240488681010902,
-0.49196070432662964,
-0.4740508794784546,
0.7855719923973083,
0.31085214018821716,
-0.11086651682853699,
0.650883674621582,
0.14585797488689423,
-0.10533509403467178,
0.5868703722953796,
0.8356499671936035,
0.608772337436676,
-0.2987334728240967,
0.6197507381439209,
0.2710826098918915,
0.07481250166893005,
-0.23169507086277008,
0.3667701780796051,
-0.10985346883535385,
-0.15455621480941772,
-0.5314775705337524,
-0.3112146258354187,
-0.8439580798149109,
0.14381146430969238,
-0.7320882678031921,
0.20112818479537964,
-0.8264524340629578,
-0.13184580206871033,
-0.051211509853601456,
0.0021175143774598837,
-0.3547946512699127,
0.16723978519439697,
-0.00527782691642642,
0.9309003353118896,
-0.5519115328788757,
0.9082475304603577,
0.663024365901947,
-0.4557608664035797,
-0.697641134262085,
-0.18512564897537231,
0.1235671192407608,
-0.9123294949531555,
0.28816941380500793,
-0.06582096219062805,
0.26039570569992065,
-0.19842126965522766,
-0.1477627009153366,
-0.5609264373779297,
1.142699122428894,
0.34310975670814514,
-0.6940330862998962,
-0.15420566499233246,
0.3045327365398407,
0.8699242472648621,
-0.42769959568977356,
0.48311230540275574,
0.4898003339767456,
-0.0543314628303051,
-0.02390151657164097,
-1.103521704673767,
0.25093820691108704,
0.06222814694046974,
-0.14990414679050446,
0.27924108505249023,
-0.6174203157424927,
0.8642992377281189,
-0.6015427112579346,
0.2574481964111328,
0.1675560027360916,
0.28523239493370056,
0.4342063069343567,
0.5116873979568481,
0.22701646387577057,
0.4378504455089569,
0.8348652720451355,
0.2515692412853241,
1.0853674411773682,
-0.24005359411239624,
-0.010893220081925392,
1.2801415920257568,
-0.7832353711128235,
0.8648361563682556,
0.4309292137622833,
-0.25425979495048523,
0.6148827075958252,
0.3865984082221985,
-0.026857079938054085,
0.6380216479301453,
0.47329699993133545,
-0.37979280948638916,
0.04137110710144043,
-0.14743001759052277,
-0.15695974230766296,
0.16125516593456268,
0.5111255645751953,
-0.7125424742698669,
-0.02530638687312603,
-0.07159501314163208,
0.2545522153377533,
0.11955545097589493,
-0.3845736086368561,
1.1568580865859985,
0.3590161204338074,
-0.9995477795600891,
0.35396188497543335,
-0.02688838168978691,
0.021365273743867874,
-0.8169518709182739,
-0.11889299005270004,
-0.2438889443874359,
0.6114282011985779,
-0.143398717045784,
-0.4635199010372162,
-0.09550069272518158,
0.3250918686389923,
-0.028001155704259872,
-0.2748706042766571,
0.40150004625320435,
-0.5336743593215942,
-0.4627719521522522,
-0.032788023352622986,
0.24365177750587463,
0.27522656321525574,
0.1737242043018341,
-0.6827956438064575,
-0.10663191229104996,
-0.13141968846321106,
-0.3331949710845947,
0.8096089959144592,
0.331632524728775,
-0.19131562113761902,
0.522075355052948,
0.6521196961402893,
0.6184464693069458,
-0.20928777754306793,
0.24841099977493286,
0.8640905618667603,
-0.46953535079956055,
-0.5185169577598572,
-0.5895673632621765,
0.3743232488632202,
-0.10819680988788605,
-0.7201733589172363,
0.27998101711273193,
0.334960013628006,
0.5988060235977173,
-0.052982863038778305,
0.9268710017204285,
0.36853018403053284,
0.7514504790306091,
-0.6670215725898743,
0.6849501729011536,
-0.473184734582901,
0.12753799557685852,
-0.3640184700489044,
-0.47615209221839905,
-0.19895564019680023,
0.4567480981349945,
-0.29448768496513367,
-0.24703752994537354,
0.6759635806083679,
0.6346935629844666,
0.1808691918849945,
-0.09175340831279755,
0.09865961223840714,
0.20642514526844025,
0.5394887924194336,
1.0092157125473022,
0.7372279167175293,
-0.1856919676065445,
0.6331635117530823,
-0.1610867828130722,
-0.3656182885169983,
-0.2569948136806488,
-0.8323789238929749,
-0.8445100784301758,
-0.35216736793518066,
-0.5253964066505432,
-0.4809936583042145,
0.09358781576156616,
1.1609746217727661,
0.35217058658599854,
-0.6627817153930664,
-0.11157944798469543,
-0.11396677792072296,
-0.43991410732269287,
-0.3609190285205841,
-0.05385502055287361,
0.7260375022888184,
-0.3290276527404785,
-0.46001455187797546,
0.3001292645931244,
0.4405684471130371,
-0.05875808745622635,
-0.1789156049489975,
-0.2830687463283539,
0.3034136891365051,
0.040650881826877594,
0.45050475001335144,
0.30701494216918945,
-0.6504508256912231,
0.14207354187965393,
-0.1310291290283203,
-0.3277966380119324,
0.17952150106430054,
1.0703833103179932,
-0.5445218086242676,
0.33909767866134644,
-0.01578056812286377,
0.5792795419692993,
0.6015833616256714,
-0.13330954313278198,
0.49572455883026123,
-0.2418254166841507,
-0.07376169413328171,
0.41486430168151855,
0.15571743249893188,
0.13873761892318726,
-0.2595260739326477,
0.23239469528198242,
0.05282367393374443,
-0.6512874364852905,
-0.807356059551239,
0.07302922010421753,
-0.9642125368118286,
-0.1731778085231781,
1.0853136777877808,
-0.54398512840271,
-0.2352905124425888,
-0.16954445838928223,
-0.5435400009155273,
0.04790320619940758,
-0.4175008535385132,
1.1187604665756226,
0.12941890954971313,
-0.24453531205654144,
-0.14473563432693481,
-0.62773597240448,
0.6874233484268188,
0.19165204465389252,
-1.0338183641433716,
0.05258825421333313,
0.561290442943573,
0.4625195562839508,
-0.2151169329881668,
1.0874465703964233,
-0.3514304757118225,
0.5104283094406128,
-0.11889507621526718,
0.15180642902851105,
-0.21104876697063446,
-0.2431461066007614,
-0.32435163855552673,
-0.01426992192864418,
0.371450811624527,
-0.08849122375249863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16659v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16659v1
|
ProbGate at EHRSQL 2024: Enhancing SQL Query Generation Accuracy through Probabilistic Threshold Filtering and Error Handling
| 2024-04-25T14:55:07 | 2024-04-25T14:55:07 |
Sangryul Kim, Donghee Han, Sehyun Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, deep learning-based language models have significantly enhanced
text-to-SQL tasks, with promising applications in retrieving patient records
within the medical domain. One notable challenge in such applications is
discerning unanswerable queries. Through fine-tuning model, we demonstrate the
feasibility of converting medical record inquiries into SQL queries.
Additionally, we introduce an entropy-based method to identify and filter out
unanswerable results. We further enhance result quality by filtering
low-confidence SQL through log probability-based distribution, while
grammatical and schema errors are mitigated by executing queries on the actual
database. We experimentally verified that our method can filter unanswerable
questions, which can be widely utilized even when the parameters of the model
are not accessible, and that it can be effectively utilized in practice.
|
[
-0.11029992997646332,
-0.9414986371994019,
0.8216844797134399,
-0.31337952613830566,
-0.37947091460227966,
-0.20334401726722717,
0.14405903220176697,
-0.4143974483013153,
0.020400574430823326,
0.9410173296928406,
-0.8419278264045715,
-0.7851728200912476,
-0.2751331329345703,
-0.11321637034416199,
-0.3732946217060089,
0.8601742386817932,
0.29951557517051697,
0.24288927018642426,
-0.32578834891319275,
-0.0440748892724514,
-0.42526763677597046,
-0.5458974838256836,
-0.6629248857498169,
-0.41164371371269226,
-0.016548022627830505,
0.2508794963359833,
0.6053148508071899,
0.5224270820617676,
0.7848367691040039,
0.12149366736412048,
-0.030044453218579292,
0.4607027769088745,
-0.2028750330209732,
0.5952032208442688,
-0.10342128574848175,
-0.6139191389083862,
-0.5568837523460388,
-0.7812899947166443,
0.5816848278045654,
0.632662296295166,
-0.6955119371414185,
-0.06018576771020889,
-0.012711390852928162,
1.0736690759658813,
-0.4662451148033142,
-0.1081729605793953,
-1.051736831665039,
0.2748529613018036,
-0.47617045044898987,
-0.35984906554222107,
-0.3745330572128296,
-0.36143648624420166,
-0.281088262796402,
-0.19810475409030914,
0.4405626952648163,
0.2371269017457962,
0.7258254289627075,
0.5567587018013,
-0.34046539664268494,
-0.32643193006515503,
-0.535816490650177,
0.6111613512039185,
-0.9251335263252258,
0.5012204051017761,
0.8411818742752075,
0.27134403586387634,
-0.41292789578437805,
-0.7923218011856079,
-0.3299263119697571,
0.03621872887015343,
-0.030293338000774384,
-0.08847755938768387,
-0.0724462941288948,
0.278798907995224,
-0.11223545670509338,
0.22809968888759613,
-0.7650159001350403,
0.2679828107357025,
-0.0938120111823082,
-0.061870165169239044,
0.6967546343803406,
0.605616569519043,
0.290861040353775,
-0.1251583844423294,
0.3099225163459778,
0.22256971895694733,
-0.5388007760047913,
-0.11974677443504333,
-0.12127422541379929,
0.2830563485622406,
0.3569274842739105,
0.7041531801223755,
-0.4494341313838959,
1.0231610536575317,
0.09947700053453445,
0.2989065647125244,
0.14224186539649963,
-0.22721944749355316,
-0.40220555663108826,
-0.005600066389888525,
0.6610455513000488,
0.19185245037078857,
-0.13046586513519287,
-0.09873152524232864,
-0.352260559797287,
-0.2736647129058838,
0.4403563439846039,
-0.7654942870140076,
-0.5270852446556091,
0.7834795713424683,
-0.5238512754440308,
-0.23109860718250275,
-0.03462224453687668,
-0.820178747177124,
-0.5574079155921936,
0.0064606512896716595,
0.1489044427871704,
-0.5543789863586426,
-0.1388152539730072,
0.2516575753688812,
0.23181983828544617,
-0.14146238565444946,
0.21564649045467377,
-0.8050878047943115,
0.42825090885162354,
0.6196557879447937,
0.3396606743335724,
-0.22074195742607117,
0.2293452024459839,
-0.5717753767967224,
-0.027628308162093163,
-0.5343117713928223,
0.5480312705039978,
-0.35004132986068726,
-0.14713111519813538,
-0.007590156514197588,
0.01281838770955801,
0.0019641011022031307,
-0.7403120994567871,
0.5434817671775818,
-0.9871858358383179,
0.040072739124298096,
0.09563537687063217,
-0.7585452198982239,
0.14637614786624908,
0.17284521460533142,
-0.4479714334011078,
0.7560132741928101,
0.06716622412204742,
-0.5704953074455261,
0.3732544779777527,
-0.4243496358394623,
-0.47674182057380676,
0.5237026810646057,
-0.3537164330482483,
-0.7144656777381897,
0.2808709740638733,
0.26954007148742676,
0.4970220923423767,
-0.529711127281189,
0.39411455392837524,
0.03944344073534012,
-0.06686922162771225,
0.07920048385858536,
-0.23151130974292755,
0.753175675868988,
0.49380090832710266,
-0.24065469205379486,
-0.0522657111287117,
-1.0302547216415405,
0.8293261528015137,
0.1249971091747284,
-0.35917460918426514,
-0.2476610243320465,
0.29871904850006104,
-0.2618477940559387,
-0.06123407930135727,
-0.05269409343600273,
-0.3300355076789856,
-0.43909913301467896,
-0.6463503837585449,
0.29031431674957275,
0.1792774796485901,
0.5158382058143616,
0.29927727580070496,
-0.11997848749160767,
0.45076674222946167,
0.31716349720954895,
0.20614686608314514,
0.1358499377965927,
-0.557551383972168,
-0.3278665840625763,
0.0423031747341156,
0.3134377598762512,
0.7980301380157471,
-0.8799237012863159,
0.6296250224113464,
0.24345551431179047,
-0.6437253952026367,
-0.6545742750167847,
0.006184252444654703,
0.4043117165565491,
0.7264552712440491,
0.557609498500824,
-0.49494561553001404,
-0.5632023215293884,
-0.45565342903137207,
-0.5626278519630432,
-0.3966222107410431,
-0.2054080218076706,
0.4599103331565857,
0.10877466201782227,
-0.18805038928985596,
0.5666672587394714,
-0.704053521156311,
-0.5372105240821838,
0.058502066880464554,
-0.04728066176176071,
0.4805818796157837,
0.6970219016075134,
0.030092978850007057,
-0.8711802959442139,
-0.2047855257987976,
-0.01324252039194107,
-0.9729878306388855,
0.14596806466579437,
0.039274126291275024,
-0.07340949773788452,
0.27202746272087097,
0.5669183731079102,
-0.7562258839607239,
0.4171311557292938,
0.08259796351194382,
-0.3990405201911926,
0.3527984917163849,
-0.5710804462432861,
0.3212445378303528,
-0.8061848282814026,
-0.2601383626461029,
0.0478314608335495,
0.030262857675552368,
-0.6713330745697021,
0.040775276720523834,
0.19325153529644012,
-0.15824800729751587,
-0.2927877902984619,
0.06937897205352783,
-0.5397858619689941,
0.3908427357673645,
0.05625859647989273,
-0.1990528255701065,
0.03804773837327957,
-0.07160444557666779,
0.0017838414059951901,
0.24901913106441498,
0.679339587688446,
-0.9007051587104797,
0.3744969367980957,
0.4565815329551697,
-0.5657090544700623,
0.7283857464790344,
-0.6463805437088013,
0.05881842225790024,
-0.42489513754844666,
-0.12478431314229965,
-0.8082391619682312,
-0.5450986623764038,
0.08514397591352463,
-0.7552093863487244,
0.36070123314857483,
-0.29876458644866943,
-0.3234312832355499,
-0.4701942801475525,
0.15132589638233185,
0.11698757857084274,
0.6254279613494873,
-0.12793214619159698,
0.3581559956073761,
0.5735139846801758,
-0.1551438868045807,
-0.5547232031822205,
-0.9218676686286926,
0.014120185747742653,
-0.00938398577272892,
-0.3525594472885132,
0.4087907075881958,
0.12258471548557281,
-0.36266735196113586,
0.15859323740005493,
0.12488174438476562,
-0.5479468107223511,
0.03269531950354576,
0.11297737807035446,
0.23903153836727142,
-0.3167596161365509,
0.5111701488494873,
0.30028611421585083,
0.2598697543144226,
0.3887365162372589,
-0.4214646816253662,
0.4145127236843109,
0.2382695972919464,
-0.6773676872253418,
-0.5989858508110046,
0.40588581562042236,
0.37766459584236145,
-0.5203701257705688,
0.8790106773376465,
0.3612285852432251,
-0.8919194936752319,
-0.2134675532579422,
-0.4773123264312744,
-0.6834793090820312,
-0.40474340319633484,
0.736090362071991,
-0.2234240174293518,
-0.8579703569412231,
0.35406333208084106,
0.0985943153500557,
-0.02876376174390316,
0.6005803942680359,
0.5896404385566711,
-0.3692905604839325,
1.1087052822113037,
0.28525564074516296,
0.4870670437812805,
0.07349410653114319,
0.3208221197128296,
0.22963689267635345,
-0.46651196479797363,
-0.6112673282623291,
-0.6956793069839478,
0.2596352994441986,
-0.6790682077407837,
-0.3473454415798187,
0.613061785697937,
0.029920300468802452,
-0.27457335591316223,
-0.010381939820945263,
-0.8048530220985413,
0.49236053228378296,
0.597834050655365,
0.5351253747940063,
0.1914966106414795,
0.16340835392475128,
-0.07460680603981018,
-0.2724527418613434,
-0.6685230731964111,
-0.16543900966644287,
0.9679566025733948,
0.16562841832637787,
0.9064706563949585,
0.09522451460361481,
0.7967572212219238,
0.23769500851631165,
-0.15724049508571625,
-0.3199312686920166,
0.44679731130599976,
-0.16814005374908447,
-0.9843251705169678,
-0.7786613702774048,
-0.6248881816864014,
-0.9159896969795227,
0.15949811041355133,
-0.5416685342788696,
-0.7498613595962524,
0.3064955770969391,
0.29247790575027466,
-0.5896762013435364,
0.5787100791931152,
-0.5552522540092468,
0.8355026245117188,
-0.21954521536827087,
-0.3844689428806305,
0.01127617433667183,
-0.8392380475997925,
0.16285841166973114,
-0.36409875750541687,
0.07794615626335144,
-0.18246082961559296,
0.13485769927501678,
0.5246267318725586,
-0.4739716649055481,
0.5800656676292419,
-0.35562920570373535,
0.1934732347726822,
0.550477147102356,
0.262040376663208,
0.5833958387374878,
0.15138182044029236,
-0.5257617831230164,
-0.03883681818842888,
0.22160901129245758,
-0.21683548390865326,
-0.4046396017074585,
0.46927276253700256,
-0.32292577624320984,
-0.5772866010665894,
-0.23933786153793335,
-0.398672878742218,
-0.3874953091144562,
0.3614938259124756,
0.3793962299823761,
0.38038647174835205,
-0.10603344440460205,
0.27815353870391846,
0.8076377511024475,
-0.3417451083660126,
-0.032521802932024,
0.6538086533546448,
0.2132713347673416,
-0.08914805203676224,
0.7048545479774475,
0.33071187138557434,
-0.1713956892490387,
0.5109383463859558,
0.019031550735235214,
-0.5975443720817566,
-1.0332856178283691,
-0.5042428374290466,
0.11071859300136566,
-0.6413945555686951,
-0.49546951055526733,
-0.8065785765647888,
-0.4111306965351105,
-0.54166179895401,
0.3144368827342987,
-0.15743498504161835,
-0.25247424840927124,
-0.6875073909759521,
0.03554503247141838,
0.33671191334724426,
0.5421507954597473,
0.0822286382317543,
0.1508079320192337,
-1.010952353477478,
0.06366179138422012,
0.232244610786438,
0.48894333839416504,
-0.1819116175174713,
-0.7333836555480957,
-0.06679384410381317,
-0.15070663392543793,
-0.2643047273159027,
-0.955775260925293,
0.6631292104721069,
0.4260985851287842,
0.4047977030277252,
0.07768043875694275,
0.5452911257743835,
0.4562118649482727,
-0.8249930739402771,
0.6785266399383545,
0.21002992987632751,
-0.6207233667373657,
1.1009622812271118,
-0.16249977052211761,
-0.012162378989160061,
0.8408313393592834,
0.389117032289505,
-0.016356326639652252,
-0.3016164302825928,
-0.674047589302063,
-1.111940622329712,
0.4279949367046356,
-0.008794602006673813,
0.060415156185626984,
-0.2309940904378891,
0.8274648189544678,
-0.2638229727745056,
0.2992820143699646,
-0.09748821705579758,
-0.24666383862495422,
0.18174991011619568,
-0.35770857334136963,
0.00125125830527395,
-0.4712205231189728,
-0.03277457877993584,
-0.24939092993736267,
0.6450855731964111,
0.023348283022642136,
0.22263562679290771,
0.22898896038532257,
0.14481210708618164,
-0.4419063627719879,
0.4409380555152893,
0.22913870215415955,
0.7005353569984436,
-0.46833670139312744,
0.14171549677848816,
0.3121999502182007,
-0.596409797668457,
-0.012922300025820732,
0.1684478223323822,
-0.17237961292266846,
0.19256262481212616,
-0.07277576625347137,
0.5732139348983765,
-0.5124064683914185,
-0.7147395610809326,
0.20979386568069458,
-0.15301524102687836,
-0.22709205746650696,
-0.3091886341571808,
0.18946845829486847,
-0.040065642446279526,
0.07052498310804367,
0.4741506278514862,
-0.044106096029281616,
0.4562203288078308,
-0.23818719387054443,
0.6409507393836975,
0.5400524735450745,
-0.8332743048667908,
0.0987342819571495,
1.1900091171264648,
-0.14265872538089752,
-0.5774127244949341,
0.9371215105056763,
0.03858857601881027,
-0.04390815272927284,
0.5660809278488159,
0.5604920387268066,
0.29579201340675354,
-0.5783546566963196,
0.1408495008945465,
0.4065145254135132,
0.32316794991493225,
-0.14313483238220215,
0.6785784363746643,
0.26447024941444397,
-0.6154658794403076,
-0.2177274525165558,
-0.4399908483028412,
-0.5549649000167847,
-0.06976238638162613,
-0.8760573863983154,
0.011526879854500294,
-0.2647697925567627,
-0.4162673056125641,
0.13216422498226166,
-0.15448598563671112,
-0.5697887539863586,
0.7972143292427063,
-0.47612911462783813,
0.5866388082504272,
-0.6337499022483826,
0.7520795464515686,
0.8119588494300842,
-0.20798923075199127,
-0.6525362133979797,
-0.05716942623257637,
-0.06201934441924095,
-0.9338825941085815,
0.5310529470443726,
-0.3964214026927948,
0.29471561312675476,
0.1774609386920929,
-0.41461312770843506,
-0.31799110770225525,
0.8334690928459167,
0.28617608547210693,
-0.6203924417495728,
-0.028870834037661552,
0.3124617040157318,
0.6798726320266724,
-0.021672828122973442,
0.113279789686203,
0.6840965747833252,
0.05910161882638931,
-0.06913094222545624,
-0.628717839717865,
0.13862502574920654,
-0.02484726905822754,
-0.1915634572505951,
0.3574444651603699,
-0.05643168091773987,
0.7651128768920898,
-0.44853922724723816,
-0.00024327574647031724,
-0.048214372247457504,
0.57313472032547,
0.4419442415237427,
0.6192865371704102,
0.27250975370407104,
0.5417429804801941,
1.1447752714157104,
-0.20496448874473572,
1.1728222370147705,
-0.21566924452781677,
0.15288712084293365,
1.1274198293685913,
-0.3990095555782318,
0.9314299821853638,
0.5011157393455505,
-0.36571744084358215,
0.26463931798934937,
0.7186986804008484,
0.31679293513298035,
0.7315119504928589,
0.3336939513683319,
-0.4401437044143677,
-0.36902037262916565,
-0.23568858206272125,
-0.46342670917510986,
0.0821736678481102,
0.633476197719574,
-0.4772194027900696,
0.03463112935423851,
-0.15698251128196716,
-0.2620278298854828,
0.20228970050811768,
-0.30517345666885376,
1.0176233053207397,
0.3004416525363922,
-0.7295750975608826,
0.5560398697853088,
0.05520286038517952,
0.20413705706596375,
-0.35002627968788147,
0.006382447201758623,
-0.24834367632865906,
0.4137999415397644,
-0.41338014602661133,
-1.0355699062347412,
0.4097141623497009,
-0.16386930644512177,
-0.13641975820064545,
0.33000296354293823,
1.1210966110229492,
-0.37319132685661316,
-0.304491251707077,
-0.24642549455165863,
0.7964468002319336,
0.42921245098114014,
-0.2804688513278961,
-0.9573414921760559,
-0.27845498919487,
0.07343371212482452,
-0.060419000685214996,
0.3445984721183777,
0.9178853631019592,
-0.030981384217739105,
0.7147135734558105,
0.4081037938594818,
0.4331829249858856,
-0.10517553240060806,
0.12298046797513962,
0.5466587543487549,
-0.3442843556404114,
-0.5385188460350037,
-0.8759523630142212,
0.40762102603912354,
-0.06329116225242615,
-0.04393591359257698,
0.46483853459358215,
0.338392972946167,
0.39649924635887146,
-0.15472669899463654,
0.4441790282726288,
0.0785449966788292,
0.8346185684204102,
-0.6298405528068542,
0.9754000306129456,
-0.6822811961174011,
0.3788347840309143,
-0.082719586789608,
-0.4012443423271179,
-0.7454261779785156,
0.38587915897369385,
-0.049857791513204575,
0.10955800116062164,
0.5419659614562988,
0.8907097578048706,
0.45483821630477905,
-0.07484177500009537,
0.5367867350578308,
-0.03570934757590294,
0.13096846640110016,
0.5513671636581421,
0.43509116768836975,
-0.6177275776863098,
0.35935911536216736,
-0.019015247002243996,
-0.016749750822782516,
-0.17085380852222443,
-0.636501133441925,
-0.5951933264732361,
-0.563125491142273,
-0.4681139290332794,
-0.7330477237701416,
0.47663742303848267,
0.6432007551193237,
0.8124480247497559,
-1.228312611579895,
0.12900398671627045,
-0.4314759373664856,
0.2228139191865921,
-0.2711106538772583,
-0.15722712874412537,
0.6157093048095703,
-0.429505318403244,
-0.2347852885723114,
0.19888368248939514,
0.16084645688533783,
0.13473013043403625,
0.1345229297876358,
0.051760487258434296,
0.054114293307065964,
0.043144941329956055,
0.3339097499847412,
0.22954316437244415,
-0.2074371576309204,
0.22316858172416687,
0.09477786719799042,
-0.12075945734977722,
0.07728084921836853,
0.45974600315093994,
-0.5061979293823242,
0.3982546329498291,
0.45293429493904114,
0.9145122170448303,
0.3707636892795563,
0.11268511414527893,
0.22245368361473083,
-0.8504458665847778,
-0.2456299066543579,
0.7525510787963867,
0.11211992800235748,
0.26004400849342346,
-0.900972306728363,
0.5370902419090271,
0.08599396049976349,
-0.7867299318313599,
-1.0139586925506592,
0.12266754359006882,
-0.45195284485816956,
-0.23150840401649475,
0.8355501294136047,
0.13072453439235687,
-0.15021958947181702,
-0.48972031474113464,
0.19164727628231049,
0.19523635506629944,
-0.0738714411854744,
0.6848961710929871,
0.3114723861217499,
-0.4676145315170288,
-0.5082541108131409,
-0.9549856185913086,
0.8204929828643799,
0.8579477071762085,
-1.0584379434585571,
-0.0963490903377533,
0.36419910192489624,
0.26487284898757935,
-0.34338366985321045,
0.944635272026062,
-0.5564579367637634,
0.33143600821495056,
-0.2405630648136139,
-0.0423269122838974,
0.27248287200927734,
-0.08312731981277466,
-0.28996768593788147,
0.41725707054138184,
0.3883252739906311,
-0.27872246503829956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16653v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16653v1
|
Análise de ambiguidade linguística em modelos de linguagem de grande escala (LLMs)
| 2024-04-25T14:45:07 | 2024-04-25T14:45:07 |
Lavínia de Carvalho Moraes, Irene Cristina Silvério, Rafael Alexandre Sousa Marques, Bianca de Castro Anaia, Dandara Freitas de Paula, Maria Carolina Schincariol de Faria, Iury Cleveston, Alana de Santana Correia, Raquel Meister Ko Freitag
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Linguistic ambiguity continues to represent a significant challenge for
natural language processing (NLP) systems, notwithstanding the advancements in
architectures such as Transformers and BERT. Inspired by the recent success of
instructional models like ChatGPT and Gemini (In 2023, the artificial
intelligence was called Bard.), this study aims to analyze and discuss
linguistic ambiguity within these models, focusing on three types prevalent in
Brazilian Portuguese: semantic, syntactic, and lexical ambiguity. We create a
corpus comprising 120 sentences, both ambiguous and unambiguous, for
classification, explanation, and disambiguation. The models capability to
generate ambiguous sentences was also explored by soliciting sets of sentences
for each type of ambiguity. The results underwent qualitative analysis, drawing
on recognized linguistic references, and quantitative assessment based on the
accuracy of the responses obtained. It was evidenced that even the most
sophisticated models, such as ChatGPT and Gemini, exhibit errors and
deficiencies in their responses, with explanations often providing
inconsistent. Furthermore, the accuracy peaked at 49.58 percent, indicating the
need for descriptive studies for supervised learning.
|
[
-0.09535673260688782,
-1.3153842687606812,
0.3363384008407593,
0.7142106890678406,
-0.2206319123506546,
0.242780864238739,
-0.2857004404067993,
-0.7222888469696045,
0.014896824955940247,
0.21482840180397034,
-0.480508029460907,
-0.2525276243686676,
-1.0461816787719727,
0.3308381736278534,
-0.6913036704063416,
0.7402127981185913,
-0.22255051136016846,
0.02920130454003811,
0.1160726323723793,
0.060526445508003235,
-0.4999964237213135,
-0.29347464442253113,
-0.6839044094085693,
-0.13386136293411255,
0.6584799885749817,
-0.01594981551170349,
1.1829307079315186,
0.30441874265670776,
0.3671552538871765,
0.4238065779209137,
-0.3472069799900055,
0.32358840107917786,
-0.21782591938972473,
0.21984745562076569,
-0.23828817903995514,
-0.6167945265769958,
-0.20602118968963623,
-0.17812702059745789,
0.6193789839744568,
0.8924039006233215,
-0.13171496987342834,
-0.07426891475915909,
0.04591633006930351,
0.6213480830192566,
-0.3779342770576477,
0.22178666293621063,
-0.8419263958930969,
0.009567822329699993,
-0.3913547396659851,
0.005501416977494955,
-0.0347125269472599,
-0.2925582230091095,
0.07622072100639343,
-0.5712948441505432,
-0.12404020875692368,
0.001957943895831704,
1.168683409690857,
0.6380696892738342,
-0.5817673802375793,
-0.7545115947723389,
-0.7291706800460815,
0.510732889175415,
-0.5999873280525208,
0.2794801592826843,
0.11636414378881454,
0.18236567080020905,
-0.5357082486152649,
-0.273067831993103,
-0.5826414823532104,
-0.10844992101192474,
-0.06566163897514343,
0.015132894739508629,
-0.5871381759643555,
0.16687333583831787,
0.08846665918827057,
-0.07337863743305206,
-0.7311997413635254,
0.4672805070877075,
-0.6391271352767944,
-0.04223163425922394,
0.46427589654922485,
0.049594391137361526,
0.2738756239414215,
-0.4305575489997864,
-0.35145342350006104,
0.4892500936985016,
-0.6964945793151855,
0.23504701256752014,
0.8654895424842834,
0.28693273663520813,
-0.11785478889942169,
0.907602846622467,
0.04639990255236626,
1.1638554334640503,
-0.3391040563583374,
0.13596074283123016,
-0.016380377113819122,
0.12771645188331604,
-0.27131006121635437,
-0.2266874462366104,
0.6995997428894043,
-0.0706060528755188,
0.3449117839336395,
-0.19915138185024261,
-0.19595001637935638,
0.34832239151000977,
0.30318647623062134,
0.07731904834508896,
0.23855237662792206,
0.6478612422943115,
0.02765565738081932,
-0.31112122535705566,
-0.21761451661586761,
-0.5799441337585449,
-0.34843018651008606,
-0.37195637822151184,
0.4358768165111542,
-0.57880038022995,
0.04484771564602852,
0.321207195520401,
0.01256248913705349,
0.15307439863681793,
0.4040503203868866,
-0.7478553056716919,
0.06318921595811844,
0.5712310075759888,
0.282919704914093,
-0.09636480361223221,
-0.33842378854751587,
0.1296061873435974,
0.2040853500366211,
-0.1879890412092209,
0.7388899922370911,
-0.6970326900482178,
-0.5414764881134033,
0.046571891754865646,
-0.054438259452581406,
-0.23098275065422058,
-0.32494843006134033,
0.7246788144111633,
-0.4399133026599884,
0.42881885170936584,
0.11577125638723373,
-0.5521489381790161,
-0.41669028997421265,
0.3724918067455292,
-0.39870959520339966,
1.2944072484970093,
0.21929624676704407,
-0.6790084838867188,
-0.05302318558096886,
-0.49801114201545715,
-0.09810717403888702,
0.230474591255188,
-0.5451740622520447,
-0.23593752086162567,
0.022122438997030258,
0.1479601114988327,
0.318002313375473,
-0.2951871156692505,
0.710205078125,
0.06255453079938889,
-0.5275712609291077,
0.5995842814445496,
-0.5427395105361938,
0.9644595980644226,
0.21445167064666748,
-0.24441298842430115,
-0.16474057734012604,
-0.6787052750587463,
-0.049471165984869,
0.18188782036304474,
-0.42067277431488037,
-0.08229079097509384,
0.032125186175107956,
-0.05635267123579979,
-0.015879236161708832,
0.4832577109336853,
-0.3084344267845154,
0.18773417174816132,
-0.5171424746513367,
0.3759588301181793,
0.5094188451766968,
-0.3329664468765259,
0.15079712867736816,
-0.32843780517578125,
0.8897897601127625,
0.20505739748477936,
0.17093525826931,
0.2186090052127838,
-0.8714677691459656,
-0.7847130298614502,
0.03356600180268288,
0.5870778560638428,
0.9352320432662964,
-0.7068047523498535,
0.46326014399528503,
-0.2947290241718292,
-0.45657750964164734,
-0.8193973302841187,
-0.017321547493338585,
0.31419306993484497,
0.23110875487327576,
0.26614144444465637,
0.0913483276963234,
-0.43427255749702454,
-0.9360297322273254,
-0.5965632200241089,
-0.2746995687484741,
-0.09454851597547531,
0.15978601574897766,
0.4521998465061188,
-0.39982983469963074,
0.9701635241508484,
0.07504285126924515,
0.10531754046678543,
-0.13138127326965332,
0.36669498682022095,
0.22690732777118683,
0.23930369317531586,
0.6546879410743713,
-0.9260746240615845,
-0.2023249715566635,
0.007548792753368616,
-0.5699546337127686,
-0.3095206320285797,
0.0043235523626208305,
0.18340305984020233,
0.39391523599624634,
0.11527596414089203,
-0.3416423797607422,
0.4775240421295166,
0.8138332962989807,
-0.08055869489908218,
0.3616446256637573,
-0.267605721950531,
0.09197155386209488,
-0.7019249796867371,
-0.07845854014158249,
-0.15851172804832458,
0.12479798495769501,
-0.4547589421272278,
0.00289399572648108,
-0.025119591504335403,
0.06675782799720764,
-0.4566193222999573,
0.550832211971283,
-0.3978014290332794,
0.001964390277862549,
-0.13779444992542267,
0.7635051012039185,
-0.15735945105552673,
0.4807007312774658,
-0.039281513541936874,
0.23735520243644714,
0.4676492512226105,
-0.5325350761413574,
0.5874645113945007,
0.024450555443763733,
-0.19606159627437592,
0.40921521186828613,
-0.6519356966018677,
-0.17678435146808624,
-0.39497655630111694,
0.029620224609971046,
-1.1178430318832397,
-0.22382712364196777,
0.6309505105018616,
-0.5407829880714417,
0.3648952543735504,
-0.23285751044750214,
-0.3035566210746765,
-0.6358315944671631,
0.3285469710826874,
0.31587064266204834,
0.15514585375785828,
-0.1878109723329544,
0.4861452579498291,
0.19609445333480835,
-0.21605585515499115,
-1.1812983751296997,
-0.7825270295143127,
0.02076324261724949,
-0.3770603537559509,
-0.8483908176422119,
0.2053121030330658,
0.20336024463176727,
-0.3857569694519043,
0.15588724613189697,
0.09494422376155853,
-0.10325023531913757,
0.31736308336257935,
0.2698659598827362,
0.3721536695957184,
-0.1350817233324051,
0.2806023061275482,
0.2012147307395935,
0.11696341633796692,
-0.1525324136018753,
-0.05307941883802414,
0.3308582901954651,
-0.31846103072166443,
-0.5021772980690002,
-0.08462785929441452,
0.27642330527305603,
0.06681597977876663,
0.007644891273230314,
0.6026074886322021,
0.561698317527771,
-0.33293578028678894,
-0.10251468420028687,
-0.4733176827430725,
0.39356034994125366,
-0.43825235962867737,
0.18450911343097687,
-0.4751763641834259,
-0.9774457812309265,
0.8948784470558167,
0.18501655757427216,
-0.11147619038820267,
0.43931615352630615,
0.5866825580596924,
-0.24424204230308533,
0.6166105270385742,
0.22684845328330994,
0.35370826721191406,
0.34586653113365173,
0.02577885426580906,
0.3620132803916931,
-0.45749908685684204,
-0.37696656584739685,
-0.73594069480896,
-0.31901460886001587,
-1.0617821216583252,
-0.42693471908569336,
0.3962124288082123,
-0.028574280440807343,
-0.05847226455807686,
0.3751527965068817,
-0.5426745414733887,
0.4247693419456482,
0.40993818640708923,
-0.029926348477602005,
0.2363632172346115,
-0.23876895010471344,
-0.06438160687685013,
0.08888114988803864,
-0.6827645301818848,
-0.8079648017883301,
0.9536283016204834,
0.34260767698287964,
0.7527996301651001,
0.4662944972515106,
0.5246449112892151,
0.29580917954444885,
-0.16497613489627838,
-0.7473636269569397,
0.33674994111061096,
-0.09206294268369675,
-0.8990673422813416,
-0.3707747757434845,
-0.2269136607646942,
-1.627957820892334,
0.6568596959114075,
-0.48151910305023193,
-0.8439895510673523,
0.22370417416095734,
0.02866874821484089,
-0.3855481445789337,
0.1503198891878128,
-0.7764202952384949,
0.9014787077903748,
-0.4279567301273346,
-0.2875853180885315,
0.2471340298652649,
-1.015726923942566,
0.4669885039329529,
-0.12281327694654465,
0.6403566598892212,
-0.2548489272594452,
-0.3289315402507782,
0.32617366313934326,
0.07080695778131485,
0.8179914355278015,
0.28712573647499084,
-0.49942752718925476,
0.5194646716117859,
0.17989185452461243,
0.3744527995586395,
-0.23373909294605255,
-0.19102805852890015,
0.25913041830062866,
0.3791631758213043,
-0.7283799052238464,
-0.6261954307556152,
0.26686301827430725,
-0.8557252883911133,
-0.7127821445465088,
-0.5101675391197205,
-0.5424019694328308,
-0.17116597294807434,
-0.13290023803710938,
0.19485130906105042,
0.21277040243148804,
-0.4080735743045807,
-0.34674736857414246,
0.37691667675971985,
-0.48842963576316833,
0.23833732306957245,
0.7483376264572144,
-0.2447030246257782,
0.3529368042945862,
0.6666454672813416,
0.16693487763404846,
0.1840307116508484,
0.4081597626209259,
-0.08798526227474213,
-0.21349214017391205,
-0.8200589418411255,
-0.3889099061489105,
0.2531711161136627,
-0.5751346945762634,
0.06336258351802826,
-0.5342549681663513,
-0.1931455135345459,
-0.554979145526886,
-0.1340985894203186,
-0.05631198361515999,
-0.5682919025421143,
-0.35999366641044617,
0.08949850499629974,
0.1464391052722931,
0.9970679879188538,
-0.07858578860759735,
0.7992147207260132,
-0.6932668685913086,
0.12140494585037231,
-0.1828165203332901,
-0.0776052474975586,
-0.5678960084915161,
-0.6399660110473633,
0.005132857710123062,
0.28468599915504456,
-0.341671884059906,
-1.499314308166504,
0.4238364100456238,
-0.09042307734489441,
0.7735776305198669,
0.32234200835227966,
-0.2643980383872986,
0.34802061319351196,
-0.24125006794929504,
0.8018203377723694,
-0.2120429277420044,
-0.8673965930938721,
0.5090592503547668,
-0.7137331962585449,
0.09760238230228424,
0.014941778965294361,
0.4477081298828125,
-0.7461044788360596,
-0.8829188942909241,
-0.9205294251441956,
-0.9384668469429016,
0.5775665640830994,
0.3509736657142639,
-0.031477976590394974,
-0.18559831380844116,
0.566508948802948,
-0.019963985309004784,
0.24987106025218964,
-1.0314356088638306,
-0.31083568930625916,
0.246810644865036,
-0.11486262828111649,
0.07014564424753189,
-0.1969776600599289,
-0.07711566984653473,
0.17102311551570892,
0.6203124523162842,
0.17308828234672546,
0.2688748836517334,
-0.08744582533836365,
-0.20819950103759766,
0.035119131207466125,
0.7018750309944153,
0.6405160427093506,
0.5750941038131714,
-0.009664486162364483,
0.2687813639640808,
0.14961408078670502,
0.013537958264350891,
-0.042224664241075516,
0.30980876088142395,
-0.061112288385629654,
0.14539450407028198,
0.18609508872032166,
0.6773970723152161,
0.3854873478412628,
-0.7655506730079651,
0.409236878156662,
0.25003165006637573,
0.13783878087997437,
-0.4598882496356964,
-0.00378706818446517,
0.08937157690525055,
0.30000028014183044,
0.06677976995706558,
0.14782413840293884,
0.2636895775794983,
-0.502368688583374,
-0.3571942150592804,
0.42975595593452454,
-0.19535821676254272,
0.045179519802331924,
0.5769898891448975,
0.24262072145938873,
-0.22812636196613312,
0.5912233591079712,
-0.289889931678772,
-0.5899186134338379,
0.7598569393157959,
0.2231607735157013,
0.3871636390686035,
-0.306520015001297,
0.3119119703769684,
0.011020313948392868,
0.7540611028671265,
0.21266621351242065,
0.36397770047187805,
0.2993433475494385,
-0.9141547083854675,
-0.24731118977069855,
-0.5384321212768555,
-0.47219184041023254,
-0.2864069640636444,
-0.5504247546195984,
0.5380776524543762,
0.17657290399074554,
-0.21161389350891113,
0.009968731552362442,
-0.20889820158481598,
-0.44135546684265137,
0.21254141628742218,
0.2563492953777313,
0.5807710886001587,
-0.9488431215286255,
0.7959228157997131,
0.577712893486023,
-0.42435523867607117,
-0.5880448818206787,
-0.5173177719116211,
0.18118473887443542,
-1.1655932664871216,
0.5338805913925171,
-0.28623589873313904,
-0.13608288764953613,
-0.2028474658727646,
-0.4718706011772156,
-0.6163526177406311,
0.646898627281189,
0.50600665807724,
-0.45287811756134033,
-0.29246819019317627,
0.4258456230163574,
0.8817957639694214,
-0.2527344226837158,
0.598956823348999,
0.7463163733482361,
0.778314471244812,
0.3130112886428833,
-1.0787485837936401,
-0.3101532757282257,
-0.07767343521118164,
0.13224491477012634,
0.287922739982605,
-0.512236475944519,
0.6833400130271912,
-0.3088088929653168,
-0.2713296413421631,
0.2342544049024582,
0.5882940292358398,
-0.06212196871638298,
0.031013289466500282,
0.16676117479801178,
0.3050288259983063,
0.9963279366493225,
-0.6126034259796143,
0.9798559546470642,
-0.0412280298769474,
0.12015929073095322,
1.205095887184143,
0.1972886174917221,
0.8406153917312622,
0.5626172423362732,
-0.5501996278762817,
0.6301168203353882,
1.2476258277893066,
-0.061820633709430695,
-0.30821532011032104,
0.5353351831436157,
-0.278563529253006,
-0.08112075179815292,
0.16516336798667908,
-0.40540215373039246,
0.6385722160339355,
0.9954036474227905,
-0.2708078920841217,
-0.23481932282447815,
-0.09166660159826279,
0.20859955251216888,
0.23199717700481415,
-0.05714913085103035,
0.2158321887254715,
-0.24539005756378174,
-0.7931261658668518,
0.5515496730804443,
0.2807767689228058,
0.6815623044967651,
-0.636006236076355,
0.3653993010520935,
-0.02382422797381878,
-0.20978285372257233,
-0.2896795868873596,
-0.9073883295059204,
0.4378434121608734,
-0.1708776205778122,
0.3489008843898773,
-0.19646510481834412,
0.23640984296798706,
-0.6668121814727783,
-0.5937398672103882,
0.2525087893009186,
0.7982067465782166,
0.8233276009559631,
0.17727121710777283,
-1.129143476486206,
0.17005044221878052,
0.08999019861221313,
0.033564407378435135,
-0.15515977144241333,
0.6889136433601379,
-0.06070604920387268,
0.7217016816139221,
-0.14284460246562958,
0.028987092897295952,
0.6599462628364563,
-0.13539202511310577,
0.49743303656578064,
-0.4866873621940613,
-0.07291151583194733,
-0.6307605504989624,
0.3866477906703949,
0.3958548307418823,
-0.4137662351131439,
0.5366396903991699,
0.3994944095611572,
0.6879146099090576,
0.05896596238017082,
0.6439814567565918,
-0.3332764506340027,
0.5899102091789246,
-0.43872004747390747,
-0.024485521018505096,
-0.6479476690292358,
0.6454095244407654,
-0.11382835358381271,
-0.6887800693511963,
-0.3329753279685974,
0.517829954624176,
-0.5116773247718811,
0.20684263110160828,
0.647836446762085,
0.7743892073631287,
0.1524178832769394,
0.24979442358016968,
0.3778611719608307,
0.5341403484344482,
-0.045708008110523224,
0.6242535710334778,
1.0964734554290771,
-0.4813898801803589,
0.5983093976974487,
-0.0205196812748909,
-0.1318512260913849,
-0.2431388795375824,
-0.8978070020675659,
-0.5878800749778748,
-0.6366124749183655,
-0.34825170040130615,
-0.34183764457702637,
0.3502938151359558,
0.721950352191925,
0.018757427111268044,
-0.5813204646110535,
-0.4340642988681793,
0.03238973021507263,
0.6621555089950562,
0.0397234670817852,
-0.21433287858963013,
0.14694026112556458,
-0.5933007597923279,
-1.3041037321090698,
0.2055463045835495,
0.08743488788604736,
0.4395573139190674,
-0.3015873432159424,
0.25653401017189026,
-0.2701924443244934,
0.2253616750240326,
0.281986802816391,
0.34750667214393616,
-1.2220577001571655,
-0.24307051301002502,
-0.07022104412317276,
-0.10387056320905685,
-0.1008395105600357,
0.4334218502044678,
-0.5958012938499451,
0.510692834854126,
0.28598538041114807,
0.31320324540138245,
0.2933349311351776,
-0.0847102627158165,
0.5449517369270325,
-0.5835413932800293,
0.3474457263946533,
0.21981577575206757,
0.3761063814163208,
0.2968776524066925,
-0.27228525280952454,
0.6611878871917725,
0.15682728588581085,
-0.41971349716186523,
-0.5426966547966003,
0.3918328583240509,
-1.2759253978729248,
-0.4882216155529022,
1.2074532508850098,
-0.06712522357702255,
-0.1500348150730133,
-0.3349962532520294,
-0.34932640194892883,
0.28532466292381287,
-0.1371675729751587,
0.7320263981819153,
1.048195719718933,
-0.4062560200691223,
0.08473210036754608,
-0.5685212016105652,
0.28990235924720764,
0.4580134451389313,
-0.4400831460952759,
-0.22779029607772827,
0.5184098482131958,
0.04716676473617554,
0.06902734190225601,
0.1435278207063675,
-0.23684978485107422,
-0.028275126591324806,
-0.017414607107639313,
-0.03213764354586601,
0.41417455673217773,
0.05095992609858513,
-0.35456913709640503,
0.07667314261198044,
0.002207642886787653,
0.002265069168061018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16645v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16645v1
|
Tele-FLM Technical Report
| 2024-04-25T14:34:47 | 2024-04-25T14:34:47 |
Xiang Li, Yiqun Yao, Xin Jiang, Xuezhi Fang, Chao Wang, Xinzhang Liu, Zihan Wang, Yu Zhao, Xin Wang, Yuyao Huang, Shuangyong Song, Yongxiang Li, Zheng Zhang, Bo Zhao, Aixin Sun, Yequan Wang, Zhongjiang He, Zhongyuan Wang, Xuelong Li, Tiejun Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have showcased profound capabilities in language
understanding and generation, facilitating a wide array of applications.
However, there is a notable paucity of detailed, open-sourced methodologies on
efficiently scaling LLMs beyond 50 billion parameters with minimum
trial-and-error cost and computational resources. In this report, we introduce
Tele-FLM (aka FLM-2), a 52B open-sourced multilingual large language model that
features a stable, efficient pre-training paradigm and enhanced factual
judgment capabilities. Tele-FLM demonstrates superior multilingual language
modeling abilities, measured by BPB on textual corpus. Besides, in both English
and Chinese foundation model evaluation, it is comparable to strong
open-sourced models that involve larger pre-training FLOPs, such as Llama2-70B
and DeepSeek-67B. In addition to the model weights, we share the core designs,
engineering practices, and training details, which we expect to benefit both
the academic and industrial communities.
|
[
-0.2442285418510437,
-0.5804150104522705,
0.3110669255256653,
0.4334922432899475,
-0.04032769799232483,
-0.0648806020617485,
-0.7140159606933594,
-0.6957957148551941,
-0.20851801335811615,
0.5391157865524292,
-0.1412472277879715,
-0.37348097562789917,
-0.5065232515335083,
0.0747447982430458,
-0.3454646170139313,
0.5954456329345703,
0.0544792041182518,
0.31715866923332214,
0.24877311289310455,
0.06285123527050018,
-0.10951349884271622,
-0.45612606406211853,
-0.6115828156471252,
-0.24642795324325562,
0.4979870915412903,
0.5896736979484558,
0.9935356378555298,
0.5353321433067322,
0.599388599395752,
0.2392912060022354,
0.0199798084795475,
-0.003680999856442213,
-0.6228132247924805,
-0.35419929027557373,
-0.09290751814842224,
-0.6912394762039185,
-0.812774658203125,
0.1390017420053482,
0.8398222923278809,
0.7524215579032898,
-0.2574942409992218,
0.3217483460903168,
-0.17440806329250336,
0.624724805355072,
-0.3908367156982422,
0.2760574519634247,
-0.869653046131134,
-0.07829588651657104,
-0.5782517194747925,
0.1671065390110016,
-0.772332489490509,
-0.37561145424842834,
0.2742047905921936,
-0.4500783085823059,
0.07559550553560257,
0.0620519258081913,
0.8136287331581116,
-0.04707343131303787,
-0.576141357421875,
0.07191365957260132,
-0.9345417618751526,
0.8296148777008057,
-0.9625474810600281,
0.865411639213562,
0.4349621832370758,
0.4600164592266083,
0.0714002251625061,
-0.7141942381858826,
-0.3465990722179413,
-0.4509527385234833,
0.2928629219532013,
-0.02841489017009735,
0.1204042062163353,
0.15223535895347595,
0.05186716467142105,
0.46150344610214233,
-0.6008215546607971,
0.3118000328540802,
-0.5297937393188477,
-0.18858161568641663,
0.5452827215194702,
-0.12045569717884064,
0.16692551970481873,
0.06525145471096039,
-0.39578860998153687,
0.19361160695552826,
-0.7979103326797485,
-0.35957807302474976,
0.17793424427509308,
0.40553992986679077,
-0.2376057505607605,
0.6415926814079285,
-0.0906357690691948,
0.5710739493370056,
-0.39363598823547363,
-0.22424718737602234,
0.2938010096549988,
-0.45510154962539673,
-0.25239893794059753,
0.010034599341452122,
0.8460312485694885,
0.16935859620571136,
0.5139687061309814,
-0.18944646418094635,
-0.3518773913383484,
-0.27422353625297546,
0.11030010133981705,
-0.9834672212600708,
0.12146959453821182,
0.24300256371498108,
-0.5881929397583008,
-0.16276130080223083,
0.12177921831607819,
-0.7824265360832214,
-0.3148987293243408,
-0.30580341815948486,
0.23542442917823792,
-0.5423789620399475,
-0.8065757155418396,
0.359362930059433,
0.2688564658164978,
0.34436190128326416,
0.4182616174221039,
-0.549433708190918,
0.17779766023159027,
0.6934077739715576,
1.0007455348968506,
0.07501748949289322,
-0.2953275740146637,
-0.5724874138832092,
-0.01894238404929638,
-0.5093387365341187,
0.46055543422698975,
-0.45858508348464966,
-0.2698444724082947,
0.39204391837120056,
-0.11460695415735245,
0.08180718123912811,
-0.5662168264389038,
0.6810222864151001,
-0.8545384407043457,
0.27596285939216614,
-0.1619555503129959,
-0.3727635443210602,
-0.3876776695251465,
0.03256143629550934,
-0.8626981377601624,
0.906050443649292,
0.10399902611970901,
-0.7008200287818909,
0.2100861370563507,
-0.5498985052108765,
-0.3244549334049225,
0.19539061188697815,
0.15106713771820068,
-0.17103739082813263,
0.21640603244304657,
-0.21319404244422913,
0.3392168879508972,
-0.8098754286766052,
0.46169209480285645,
-0.4062689244747162,
-0.3221077620983124,
0.07268460839986801,
-0.45345377922058105,
0.657657265663147,
0.5120542049407959,
-0.35569319128990173,
0.20755982398986816,
-0.7235644459724426,
-0.04324762150645256,
0.2843337953090668,
-0.47816169261932373,
-0.037319526076316833,
-0.05799955502152443,
0.3039339780807495,
0.3679933547973633,
0.4126394987106323,
-0.650087833404541,
-0.29592365026474,
-0.653960645198822,
0.3355253040790558,
0.3366824686527252,
-0.6864503622055054,
0.44466379284858704,
-0.23649531602859497,
0.5186209082603455,
-0.15591645240783691,
0.04604259133338928,
-0.240377739071846,
-0.23844948410987854,
-0.8246824145317078,
-0.29049941897392273,
0.3904874622821808,
0.6786547303199768,
-0.44844695925712585,
0.21819762885570526,
-0.5021156072616577,
-0.5559979677200317,
-0.32862499356269836,
0.20069946348667145,
0.17186987400054932,
0.10450707376003265,
0.20083874464035034,
-0.03299369290471077,
-0.38131073117256165,
-0.7862884998321533,
-0.19042055308818817,
-0.13894428312778473,
-0.0926731675863266,
0.05876082926988602,
0.05582932382822037,
-0.1642032414674759,
0.88407963514328,
-0.2394111454486847,
-0.3346812129020691,
-0.3572702407836914,
0.021443812176585197,
0.11391805857419968,
0.06252261251211166,
0.6661614775657654,
-0.5726771354675293,
-0.3692232370376587,
0.21031151711940765,
-0.7403026819229126,
-0.1695888191461563,
0.12551546096801758,
0.07084006071090698,
0.35319623351097107,
0.4615241289138794,
-0.7185558676719666,
0.062290895730257034,
0.5394376516342163,
-0.09635325521230698,
0.6604821085929871,
-0.14687612652778625,
0.05283348262310028,
-1.0451751947402954,
0.14387162029743195,
0.2101760357618332,
-0.4647417962551117,
-0.5615949034690857,
0.14587748050689697,
0.2400352507829666,
-0.3855721950531006,
-0.6222608685493469,
0.44345909357070923,
-0.5508174896240234,
-0.10409271717071533,
-0.32125183939933777,
0.32916009426116943,
-0.22709912061691284,
0.18945413827896118,
0.2932525873184204,
0.7103220224380493,
0.4609358012676239,
-0.4014262855052948,
0.5156360268592834,
-0.19594186544418335,
-0.5475085377693176,
0.2625657618045807,
-0.7613145112991333,
0.2608846426010132,
0.0030903073493391275,
0.27113160490989685,
-0.7320389151573181,
-0.2443796843290329,
-0.16746054589748383,
-0.11928727477788925,
0.4711962640285492,
0.07521453499794006,
-0.7375605702400208,
-0.47176042199134827,
-0.4920766055583954,
0.5118654370307922,
0.2965252995491028,
-0.473408579826355,
0.6922532320022583,
0.33079418540000916,
-0.252492755651474,
-0.3588569760322571,
-0.769676148891449,
0.13491103053092957,
-0.19162596762180328,
-0.9864274263381958,
0.1307627260684967,
0.027578575536608696,
-0.33097246289253235,
-0.30210840702056885,
0.07223397493362427,
-0.16801363229751587,
-0.06375029683113098,
-0.024238144978880882,
0.2765457332134247,
-0.792637825012207,
0.22429369390010834,
-0.3105134963989258,
0.01934250071644783,
0.29364654421806335,
-0.49382707476615906,
0.5145078301429749,
-0.4310413599014282,
-0.13726799190044403,
-0.27481281757354736,
0.12438230216503143,
0.6870577931404114,
-0.665645182132721,
0.8757781982421875,
0.5813608765602112,
-0.6187412738800049,
-0.3316642940044403,
-0.719748854637146,
0.04435115307569504,
-0.5131343007087708,
0.7656633853912354,
-0.41177594661712646,
-0.9280999302864075,
0.24602831900119781,
-0.390421986579895,
0.4071580469608307,
0.3335205614566803,
0.6293240189552307,
0.28885552287101746,
0.4405170679092407,
0.620171308517456,
-0.07868459820747375,
0.45446738600730896,
0.08564446121454239,
0.12796007096767426,
-0.18505220115184784,
-0.17036527395248413,
-0.6276822686195374,
0.04181121662259102,
-0.2680470943450928,
-0.8551611304283142,
0.36478835344314575,
0.10321655869483948,
-0.33583298325538635,
0.22688564658164978,
0.09619556367397308,
0.35656872391700745,
0.3619045615196228,
0.034179698675870895,
0.40193989872932434,
0.11509304493665695,
-0.09611004590988159,
0.15930740535259247,
-0.6220471262931824,
-0.8419048190116882,
1.2547191381454468,
0.8625596761703491,
0.6507241129875183,
0.2848392426967621,
0.28639402985572815,
0.08360430598258972,
0.4116775691509247,
-0.799456000328064,
0.6072020530700684,
-0.42211854457855225,
-0.9454768896102905,
-0.45677849650382996,
-0.475078821182251,
-0.5730224847793579,
0.2045443207025528,
-0.0826975405216217,
-0.568707287311554,
-0.2720119059085846,
0.03998811915516853,
-0.18369844555854797,
0.5459360480308533,
-0.7616714835166931,
0.7181426286697388,
-0.4029253125190735,
-0.2700974643230438,
-0.7814541459083557,
-0.6414772868156433,
0.7687088251113892,
-0.6332399845123291,
0.564775824546814,
-0.17036740481853485,
-0.15158462524414062,
0.6621132493019104,
-0.47969067096710205,
0.6454663872718811,
-0.07168354839086533,
-0.6731300950050354,
0.5094723105430603,
0.20523656904697418,
0.34049496054649353,
0.04957044869661331,
-0.555244505405426,
0.5175409913063049,
-0.20285679399967194,
-0.22970326244831085,
-0.277305543422699,
0.7267419695854187,
-0.8379738330841064,
-0.42139822244644165,
-0.20254378020763397,
-0.5343184471130371,
-0.4492034316062927,
0.4047779440879822,
0.0643412172794342,
0.6077584028244019,
-0.3955291211605072,
0.31619247794151306,
0.6117208003997803,
-0.5487954020500183,
0.4018552005290985,
0.729571521282196,
-0.6750545501708984,
-0.5617241859436035,
0.9049544334411621,
0.1427745819091797,
0.6190271377563477,
0.6805582642555237,
0.11726251244544983,
-0.3192841708660126,
-0.4200114607810974,
-0.27302682399749756,
0.6342300772666931,
-0.6376563310623169,
-0.12590062618255615,
-0.4034362733364105,
-0.24428777396678925,
-0.256119966506958,
0.3225351870059967,
-0.7762618660926819,
-0.4884619414806366,
-0.13548173010349274,
-0.2773922085762024,
0.1930389702320099,
0.9061588048934937,
-0.11242508888244629,
0.45109277963638306,
-0.8864451050758362,
0.3101903200149536,
-0.011213393881917,
0.6261110901832581,
-0.04362209886312485,
-0.6082021594047546,
-0.44795435667037964,
0.3068968951702118,
-0.2603012025356293,
-0.563187837600708,
-0.016281111165881157,
0.4041188657283783,
0.2189112901687622,
0.4556724429130554,
-0.04323788359761238,
0.15387344360351562,
-0.6533774137496948,
0.7925110459327698,
0.28786227107048035,
-0.9964911937713623,
0.41693636775016785,
-0.5129430890083313,
0.2723529040813446,
0.19740259647369385,
0.4694516360759735,
-0.3539222776889801,
-0.12146163731813431,
-0.15139895677566528,
-0.5776479244232178,
0.9409445524215698,
-0.1729063242673874,
0.30883294343948364,
0.150148406624794,
0.19625715911388397,
0.3253885507583618,
0.1049632877111435,
-0.71665358543396,
-0.1513582170009613,
-0.2495793104171753,
-0.22127500176429749,
-0.0988132432103157,
-0.6011497974395752,
0.17765943706035614,
-0.03655082359910011,
0.7880522608757019,
-0.08182122558355331,
0.10868939012289047,
-0.104889415204525,
-0.24013662338256836,
-0.2572278380393982,
0.332412451505661,
0.6838374733924866,
0.7849802374839783,
-0.22015050053596497,
0.2468705177307129,
0.31515398621559143,
-0.47438010573387146,
-0.011824928224086761,
0.28124645352363586,
0.12736526131629944,
-0.050511181354522705,
0.5219652652740479,
0.6990721821784973,
0.24722062051296234,
-0.7536713480949402,
0.5325265526771545,
0.08316268026828766,
-0.3579019606113434,
-0.12225954979658127,
-0.18038028478622437,
0.27243149280548096,
0.14250552654266357,
0.35066622495651245,
-0.22246301174163818,
-0.2839736342430115,
-0.3534586429595947,
0.3609744906425476,
0.32105162739753723,
-0.25073766708374023,
-0.5769516825675964,
0.855512797832489,
0.5786952376365662,
-0.17884129285812378,
0.6769230365753174,
0.1121458113193512,
-0.44642436504364014,
0.24199609458446503,
0.46896424889564514,
0.7288348078727722,
-0.4415298402309418,
0.32321521639823914,
0.25596359372138977,
0.6817129254341125,
-0.24222460389137268,
0.3514609634876251,
0.3597477376461029,
-0.651702344417572,
-0.5210434794425964,
-0.7282318472862244,
-0.18699726462364197,
0.3462618291378021,
-0.2956087589263916,
0.6877027153968811,
-0.5561066269874573,
-0.384147047996521,
-0.22126713395118713,
0.05933260917663574,
-0.6736587882041931,
0.32528921961784363,
0.49659082293510437,
1.4200587272644043,
-0.46628040075302124,
1.0415713787078857,
0.6362223029136658,
-0.23648342490196228,
-1.0748374462127686,
-0.04711592197418213,
0.005084226839244366,
-0.6539260149002075,
0.6752417683601379,
0.3136894106864929,
-0.29063963890075684,
0.023272234946489334,
-0.3534623682498932,
-0.905780017375946,
0.9378277659416199,
0.867475688457489,
-0.762800395488739,
-0.12889352440834045,
0.6484726667404175,
0.35613813996315,
-0.1014660969376564,
0.6342751383781433,
0.3010246455669403,
0.48459452390670776,
-0.07911492884159088,
-1.581055760383606,
-0.049417439848184586,
0.030210236087441444,
0.028871677815914154,
0.11667048186063766,
-1.083676815032959,
0.5587444305419922,
-0.43563905358314514,
-0.20988650619983673,
-0.039450593292713165,
1.1102972030639648,
-0.04019824415445328,
0.07928340137004852,
0.5844395160675049,
0.27701953053474426,
0.757926344871521,
0.0251799114048481,
0.8304063081741333,
-0.46500810980796814,
0.24890749156475067,
1.046621322631836,
-0.6428235173225403,
0.9060118794441223,
0.04398055747151375,
-0.34420251846313477,
0.33786556124687195,
0.5122358798980713,
0.3590432405471802,
0.1890173703432083,
0.21201461553573608,
-0.21209107339382172,
-0.33512258529663086,
-0.3465743064880371,
-0.4452594220638275,
0.5655601024627686,
0.20922216773033142,
-0.1928132027387619,
-0.2665737271308899,
-0.08005346357822418,
0.1741468608379364,
0.0037758806720376015,
-0.17484159767627716,
0.35787442326545715,
0.5538685917854309,
-0.3530389368534088,
0.7440264225006104,
0.37288135290145874,
0.696051299571991,
-0.9399613738059998,
0.3470178544521332,
-0.08745882660150528,
0.3171127140522003,
-0.17231738567352295,
-0.5438957810401917,
0.27388328313827515,
0.08015074580907822,
-0.0963703840970993,
-0.15844805538654327,
0.545107364654541,
-0.575051486492157,
-0.5832617878913879,
0.4975513219833374,
0.5256152749061584,
0.043264832347631454,
-0.15984022617340088,
-0.45391565561294556,
0.2914659082889557,
-0.20032040774822235,
-0.4052123725414276,
0.15452876687049866,
0.6450980305671692,
-0.020591218024492264,
0.7522860765457153,
0.36206841468811035,
0.17660097777843475,
0.273080050945282,
0.27028515934944153,
0.4734443724155426,
-0.6739712953567505,
-0.21286195516586304,
-0.6707886457443237,
0.3449115455150604,
0.21618542075157166,
-0.10110718011856079,
0.629008412361145,
0.86479651927948,
0.758694052696228,
-0.10336681455373764,
0.7897730469703674,
0.23902945220470428,
0.38575318455696106,
-0.5205122232437134,
0.6526416540145874,
-0.5389155149459839,
0.30615299940109253,
-0.14585381746292114,
-1.0051350593566895,
-0.25508177280426025,
0.3131296932697296,
-0.2534928619861603,
0.2827675938606262,
0.7270485758781433,
0.7417283058166504,
-0.0818263366818428,
0.4356690049171448,
0.28251802921295166,
0.4041255712509155,
0.4862241744995117,
0.6215046644210815,
0.6874040961265564,
-0.2825320065021515,
0.685713529586792,
-0.06906077265739441,
-0.44691944122314453,
-0.05858232453465462,
-0.9019752144813538,
-1.0272386074066162,
-0.2854156792163849,
-0.32492440938949585,
-0.13420389592647552,
-0.2973112463951111,
1.073256492614746,
0.9514790177345276,
-0.7892131805419922,
-0.5913838744163513,
0.13403865694999695,
-0.14805959165096283,
0.0628919005393982,
-0.2214777022600174,
0.10912097990512848,
-0.3729785978794098,
-0.7091094851493835,
0.6386772394180298,
0.20817352831363678,
-0.1017303466796875,
-0.46960246562957764,
-0.11240959912538528,
-0.22555288672447205,
0.23794633150100708,
0.7062099575996399,
-0.08492594957351685,
-0.742440402507782,
-0.07410518079996109,
0.12786315381526947,
-0.15717847645282745,
-0.10239089280366898,
0.7178516387939453,
-0.4303821325302124,
0.24756570160388947,
0.3144749104976654,
0.5954393148422241,
0.3182956576347351,
-0.15980099141597748,
1.0873583555221558,
-0.48106011748313904,
0.18863385915756226,
-0.038976483047008514,
0.375203013420105,
0.47737056016921997,
-0.16822199523448944,
0.5557813048362732,
0.15503939986228943,
-0.44931671023368835,
-0.8249703049659729,
0.12318167090415955,
-0.9001938104629517,
-0.2104443460702896,
1.4376460313796997,
-0.11651322990655899,
0.15052543580532074,
0.17611531913280487,
-0.22675105929374695,
0.2858348488807678,
-0.2652595043182373,
0.2868778705596924,
0.787662148475647,
0.5485811829566956,
-0.10204799473285675,
-0.7611337900161743,
0.2490183711051941,
0.37785887718200684,
-0.8499428033828735,
0.27446040511131287,
0.45770004391670227,
0.2726273536682129,
0.04557108134031296,
0.49707892537117004,
-0.20582042634487152,
0.06994450837373734,
-0.2655135691165924,
-0.08302122354507446,
-0.16917499899864197,
-0.4966457486152649,
-0.1803034543991089,
0.301298052072525,
0.4195149838924408,
0.024117061868309975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16627v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16627v1
|
Incorporating Lexical and Syntactic Knowledge for Unsupervised Cross-Lingual Transfer
| 2024-04-25T14:10:52 | 2024-04-25T14:10:52 |
Jianyu Zheng, Fengfei Fan, Jianquan Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Unsupervised cross-lingual transfer involves transferring knowledge between
languages without explicit supervision. Although numerous studies have been
conducted to improve performance in such tasks by focusing on cross-lingual
knowledge, particularly lexical and syntactic knowledge, current approaches are
limited as they only incorporate syntactic or lexical information. Since each
type of information offers unique advantages and no previous attempts have
combined both, we attempt to explore the potential of this approach. In this
paper, we present a novel framework called "Lexicon-Syntax Enhanced
Multilingual BERT" that combines both lexical and syntactic knowledge.
Specifically, we use Multilingual BERT (mBERT) as the base model and employ two
techniques to enhance its learning capabilities. The code-switching technique
is used to implicitly teach the model lexical alignment information, while a
syntactic-based graph attention network is designed to help the model encode
syntactic structure. To integrate both types of knowledge, we input
code-switched sequences into both the syntactic module and the mBERT base model
simultaneously. Our extensive experimental results demonstrate this framework
can consistently outperform all baselines of zero-shot cross-lingual transfer,
with the gains of 1.0~3.7 points on text classification, named entity
recognition (ner), and semantic parsing tasks. Keywords:cross-lingual transfer,
lexicon, syntax, code-switching, graph attention network
|
[
-0.4069804847240448,
-0.5761885643005371,
0.38181203603744507,
0.35674941539764404,
-0.17963764071464539,
0.46432971954345703,
-0.33798128366470337,
-0.6419122815132141,
0.23436425626277924,
0.32317283749580383,
-0.17107364535331726,
-0.30367401242256165,
-0.46311038732528687,
-0.14387018978595734,
-0.44361215829849243,
1.0095441341400146,
-0.11205949634313583,
0.18739533424377441,
-0.04930296540260315,
-0.0048490180633962154,
-0.3142341077327728,
-0.6501230597496033,
-0.29478779435157776,
-0.20878484845161438,
0.509860098361969,
0.183739572763443,
0.5373151302337646,
0.02533118985593319,
0.32403916120529175,
0.1636282205581665,
-0.04828689619898796,
0.18353179097175598,
-0.22382822632789612,
-0.41505664587020874,
-0.5076099634170532,
-0.2985086441040039,
-0.21170029044151306,
-0.6932038068771362,
0.7230340242385864,
0.9631542563438416,
0.058835018426179886,
-0.11567162722349167,
0.18251529335975647,
0.5504385828971863,
-0.5078697800636292,
0.38712751865386963,
-0.6630816459655762,
0.15511447191238403,
-0.12634846568107605,
-0.15650039911270142,
-0.4458741843700409,
-0.06661830097436905,
0.217911034822464,
-0.665394127368927,
-0.10772188752889633,
-0.237578883767128,
0.7842699885368347,
-0.13248397409915924,
-0.47509530186653137,
-0.037915922701358795,
-0.5002691745758057,
0.49733585119247437,
-0.49545446038246155,
0.7759479880332947,
0.03949543088674545,
0.17761845886707306,
0.32977762818336487,
-0.6217984557151794,
-0.38285982608795166,
0.0721336379647255,
-0.19797760248184204,
0.1769399642944336,
-0.19306418299674988,
-0.0834508091211319,
-0.17607265710830688,
-0.007220120169222355,
-0.47527027130126953,
-0.13974811136722565,
-0.4571436047554016,
-0.3102494180202484,
0.1874246597290039,
-0.44745323061943054,
0.45831167697906494,
-0.17905686795711517,
-0.922744870185852,
-0.17090341448783875,
-0.4302574396133423,
0.15322642028331757,
0.09205609560012817,
0.5986882448196411,
-0.08204589039087296,
0.28167909383773804,
0.056574296206235886,
0.6245256066322327,
0.02244945801794529,
0.17216816544532776,
0.3356252610683441,
-0.6357733607292175,
-0.11772418767213821,
0.24852892756462097,
0.5077019333839417,
0.2882518470287323,
0.52928626537323,
-0.6371265649795532,
-0.08382490277290344,
-0.01767980493605137,
0.12442810088396072,
-0.5088845491409302,
-0.2408139705657959,
-0.3409058749675751,
-0.32185471057891846,
-0.005015549715608358,
-0.010174749419093132,
-0.8246061205863953,
-0.029838770627975464,
-0.19604361057281494,
0.4641215205192566,
-0.6856045126914978,
-0.4183093309402466,
0.06743407994508743,
-0.25507667660713196,
0.23554712533950806,
0.2768486738204956,
-1.0112100839614868,
0.31130731105804443,
0.26667436957359314,
0.7297153472900391,
-0.32334598898887634,
-0.49438297748565674,
-0.26472246646881104,
0.5943413376808167,
-0.2983030378818512,
0.8064030408859253,
-0.4021244943141937,
-0.041176121681928635,
0.15821851789951324,
0.11338773369789124,
-0.3955008089542389,
-0.16694001853466034,
-0.11301632225513458,
-0.6599293947219849,
0.029994681477546692,
-0.1911991387605667,
-0.40890854597091675,
-0.4645744860172272,
0.1288817822933197,
-0.6228776574134827,
1.1085115671157837,
0.23713870346546173,
-0.7476778626441956,
0.27872195839881897,
-0.5996229648590088,
-0.9591933488845825,
-0.019236277788877487,
-0.05541025102138519,
0.17832660675048828,
-0.15172027051448822,
0.48477989435195923,
0.3814910352230072,
0.02423175424337387,
0.21768149733543396,
-0.18497368693351746,
-0.1640668511390686,
0.27875345945358276,
-0.11912377178668976,
0.9155930280685425,
-0.09795791655778885,
-0.2718304991722107,
-0.09275969117879868,
-0.648934543132782,
0.2563529312610626,
-0.026378879323601723,
-0.36873650550842285,
-0.4801884889602661,
-0.6686573624610901,
0.33785420656204224,
0.4352490305900574,
0.432282954454422,
-0.45870286226272583,
0.050887059420347214,
-0.26262351870536804,
0.21527312695980072,
0.5406101942062378,
-0.17456313967704773,
0.8221023082733154,
-0.20984314382076263,
0.37745359539985657,
0.051754020154476166,
-0.09232710301876068,
0.06707234680652618,
-0.3844102919101715,
-0.625231921672821,
0.05438106879591942,
0.6563526391983032,
0.8130795359611511,
-1.2791807651519775,
0.31145352125167847,
-0.2352854609489441,
-0.009880268014967442,
-0.4519624412059784,
0.3782363533973694,
0.4918558597564697,
0.3999904692173004,
0.5398238897323608,
-0.4618822932243347,
-0.4744774401187897,
-0.6892451047897339,
-0.20642413198947906,
-0.27857735753059387,
0.30108150839805603,
0.21302804350852966,
0.0814104676246643,
-0.1021026074886322,
0.7199998497962952,
-0.13742169737815857,
-0.43037182092666626,
-0.701017439365387,
0.14327184855937958,
-0.11781058460474014,
0.43524569272994995,
0.7222403287887573,
-0.6062660813331604,
-0.7112990021705627,
0.4454590380191803,
-0.6311467885971069,
-0.16839154064655304,
-0.3038807511329651,
-0.5132588744163513,
0.4574132561683655,
0.5624121427536011,
-0.4647729992866516,
0.13933983445167542,
0.6117846965789795,
-0.22932685911655426,
0.3988124430179596,
-0.13897670805454254,
0.07723037153482437,
-0.9707716703414917,
0.15416266024112701,
-0.32149991393089294,
-0.372978150844574,
-0.5796026587486267,
0.013700521551072598,
0.3752327859401703,
0.00601371331140399,
-0.7809692621231079,
0.7276830673217773,
-0.5885255932807922,
-0.3814534544944763,
0.039591234177351,
0.288806676864624,
0.18506482243537903,
0.9066972136497498,
0.21097415685653687,
0.5794719457626343,
0.6780800223350525,
-0.32761967182159424,
0.3426874876022339,
0.3064504563808441,
-0.3385552167892456,
0.36460310220718384,
-0.20983323454856873,
0.08330518007278442,
0.18669989705085754,
-0.09124267101287842,
-0.9466535449028015,
0.337633341550827,
0.1199941486120224,
-0.5853199362754822,
0.5202843546867371,
-0.19941012561321259,
-0.64673912525177,
0.1674458384513855,
-0.05122034624218941,
0.335069864988327,
0.3324654996395111,
-0.6369467973709106,
0.5986659526824951,
0.2458144873380661,
-0.3684820532798767,
-0.6122236847877502,
-1.078275442123413,
0.14571869373321533,
0.16591285169124603,
-0.6274861693382263,
0.4300791919231415,
0.2030254751443863,
0.10143844038248062,
0.3823640048503876,
-0.08205872029066086,
-0.25069981813430786,
-0.2560400366783142,
-0.376387357711792,
0.4302910566329956,
-0.23533855378627777,
0.33918729424476624,
0.29921460151672363,
0.04937652125954628,
0.05905820056796074,
-0.5754922032356262,
0.35782259702682495,
-0.06202482804656029,
-0.2659829258918762,
0.055729206651449203,
0.605400562286377,
0.40989741683006287,
-0.3719955384731293,
0.5154833197593689,
0.8539639115333557,
-0.271014541387558,
-0.32565581798553467,
-0.22664035856723785,
0.0022577454801648855,
-0.3335958421230316,
0.5366082787513733,
-0.35458138585090637,
-0.7884008288383484,
0.5724866390228271,
-0.11927011609077454,
0.010814422741532326,
0.10147713124752045,
0.5536405444145203,
-0.00016528744890820235,
0.7019345164299011,
0.896406352519989,
0.028314366936683655,
0.7314671874046326,
-0.010646285489201546,
0.21973149478435516,
-0.7341959476470947,
-0.13978885114192963,
0.03339293226599693,
-0.18655897676944733,
-0.2887970507144928,
-0.6729300022125244,
0.1327151358127594,
0.13004714250564575,
-0.07586760818958282,
0.48345115780830383,
-0.12708157300949097,
0.3080218732357025,
0.4829956591129303,
0.09960618615150452,
0.30914390087127686,
0.203778937458992,
-0.7495922446250916,
0.08284813910722733,
-0.9646971225738525,
0.07302986830472946,
1.100633978843689,
0.054898571223020554,
0.9895106554031372,
0.3865499198436737,
0.5145174264907837,
0.26117950677871704,
-0.06517957895994186,
-0.5820888876914978,
0.6502569913864136,
-0.41605377197265625,
-0.5490357875823975,
-0.2152010053396225,
-0.4451192021369934,
-0.6989530920982361,
0.4957371950149536,
-0.1632644236087799,
-0.8001139163970947,
0.31379178166389465,
-0.14086681604385376,
-0.2433987855911255,
0.4626951217651367,
-0.9965001344680786,
0.9767032265663147,
-0.6444918513298035,
-0.46125614643096924,
-0.04633859917521477,
-0.8650501370429993,
0.08272744715213776,
-0.20906059443950653,
0.22011403739452362,
0.041103631258010864,
0.0027700134087353945,
0.5433099269866943,
0.00683393981307745,
1.0579774379730225,
-0.04673798754811287,
-0.1474842131137848,
0.0909191370010376,
0.1705162078142166,
0.1686113327741623,
-0.011247205547988415,
0.3676089644432068,
0.4016744792461395,
0.05530783534049988,
-0.1051177978515625,
-0.7474915981292725,
0.5339280962944031,
-0.6723459959030151,
-0.20814555883407593,
-0.2392931580543518,
-0.9903829097747803,
-0.51126629114151,
0.5650575160980225,
-0.06117614731192589,
0.28299590945243835,
-0.19540739059448242,
0.027743827551603317,
0.60453861951828,
-0.20903584361076355,
0.39006876945495605,
0.4918120205402374,
-0.5481521487236023,
-0.3140386641025543,
0.9111248850822449,
0.10215872526168823,
0.6031773090362549,
0.9134327173233032,
-0.05268484354019165,
-0.49736231565475464,
-0.1294294148683548,
-0.7118825912475586,
0.231603741645813,
-1.0189672708511353,
-0.2049098014831543,
-0.6880881190299988,
-0.3232710063457489,
-0.7971823215484619,
-0.4070890545845032,
-0.35403046011924744,
-0.6079781651496887,
-0.07007613033056259,
0.0036707345861941576,
0.3028225600719452,
0.3075787425041199,
-0.3266400396823883,
0.08494743704795837,
-0.9995467066764832,
0.26002198457717896,
0.18066304922103882,
0.3533249497413635,
0.06855657696723938,
-0.40271198749542236,
-0.4783225357532501,
-0.08421077579259872,
0.038477297872304916,
-0.9706727862358093,
0.44427311420440674,
0.27351614832878113,
0.7560632228851318,
0.1863570362329483,
0.046489425003528595,
0.6601129174232483,
-0.4052939713001251,
0.2563699781894684,
0.39990437030792236,
-1.1783100366592407,
0.21956366300582886,
-0.09393458813428879,
0.4505745470523834,
0.45980584621429443,
0.2760458290576935,
-0.6312727332115173,
-0.46637019515037537,
-0.5326096415519714,
-0.8084173798561096,
0.8079347014427185,
0.10936617851257324,
-0.21284040808677673,
0.1626267284154892,
-0.18552756309509277,
0.0015476775588467717,
0.2155342996120453,
-0.8739016652107239,
0.04141220077872276,
-0.2097635120153427,
-0.0666745975613594,
0.058724284172058105,
0.15789738297462463,
-0.0928075909614563,
-0.38066810369491577,
0.4724043905735016,
-0.3452819287776947,
0.31853705644607544,
0.15379680693149567,
-0.6589623689651489,
0.12430307269096375,
0.3370611369609833,
0.1955021768808365,
0.6427991986274719,
-0.1329636424779892,
0.32064226269721985,
0.300777792930603,
-0.2115740180015564,
-0.14700359106063843,
0.45775410532951355,
-0.015175138600170612,
0.23218034207820892,
0.40061214566230774,
0.6377204656600952,
0.766264021396637,
-0.527389645576477,
0.3810790181159973,
0.2083100974559784,
-0.18365558981895447,
0.04125332459807396,
-0.3901476562023163,
0.36897599697113037,
0.34041571617126465,
-0.010367456823587418,
0.0019498701440170407,
0.10361099243164062,
-0.5959771275520325,
0.4457508623600006,
0.3108660578727722,
-0.19477413594722748,
-0.2527560889720917,
0.3393910527229309,
0.3152877688407898,
0.2478591650724411,
0.32144975662231445,
-0.18479564785957336,
-0.7712458372116089,
0.5512340068817139,
0.9003400206565857,
0.5140547752380371,
-0.13484877347946167,
0.27361607551574707,
0.09917227923870087,
0.3995918035507202,
0.2560874819755554,
0.2781810462474823,
-0.4994383156299591,
-1.0252712965011597,
-0.38634854555130005,
-0.4495771527290344,
-0.39056193828582764,
-0.42815282940864563,
-0.7483242154121399,
0.17679376900196075,
-0.31438204646110535,
0.1499575674533844,
0.008934739045798779,
-0.2537432014942169,
-0.6915102005004883,
-0.10512914508581161,
0.28358909487724304,
0.8079481720924377,
-0.79749596118927,
1.1332097053527832,
1.099966049194336,
-0.45018264651298523,
-0.8399754762649536,
-0.028784167021512985,
-0.2508213222026825,
-1.2132713794708252,
0.7377152442932129,
-0.07873376458883286,
-0.20179815590381622,
0.016105996444821358,
0.12102402001619339,
-0.933091938495636,
0.8053593039512634,
0.5173071622848511,
-0.527454137802124,
-0.23877260088920593,
0.18736307322978973,
0.4970364570617676,
-0.23495231568813324,
0.1311551183462143,
0.5019552707672119,
0.39434555172920227,
0.34737783670425415,
-1.1819133758544922,
0.02429177425801754,
-0.24948909878730774,
0.11177501082420349,
0.38538888096809387,
-0.5026851892471313,
0.7812928557395935,
-0.43882665038108826,
-0.2808593213558197,
-0.29318204522132874,
0.49298039078712463,
-0.22320915758609772,
-0.02771885134279728,
0.4302240312099457,
0.48418939113616943,
0.49186813831329346,
0.14424803853034973,
0.7239676117897034,
-0.6268736124038696,
0.38779014348983765,
0.9889207482337952,
-0.526303231716156,
0.790768027305603,
0.6163035035133362,
-0.12719431519508362,
0.633916974067688,
0.391400009393692,
0.04093364626169205,
0.82730633020401,
-0.20176604390144348,
-0.08050204068422318,
-0.35501328110694885,
-0.18044911324977875,
-0.4809814691543579,
0.441651314496994,
0.31792718172073364,
-0.28931987285614014,
-0.6556117534637451,
0.1861409842967987,
0.014337990432977676,
-0.18243303894996643,
-0.207830548286438,
0.8980956077575684,
0.06991466879844666,
-0.4767562747001648,
0.5519877672195435,
-0.13288342952728271,
0.6755288243293762,
-0.7886494398117065,
-0.15001998841762543,
-0.11870071291923523,
0.3272242844104767,
-0.07530846446752548,
-1.0223807096481323,
0.379468709230423,
-0.1884927600622177,
0.002475650981068611,
-0.5606445074081421,
1.0953892469406128,
-0.9121150970458984,
-0.5807372331619263,
0.9189227223396301,
0.8549555540084839,
0.10004591196775436,
0.14005813002586365,
-0.7003570199012756,
-0.2370501160621643,
0.050631921738386154,
0.24848337471485138,
0.5835565328598022,
0.8049415946006775,
-0.04982634261250496,
0.30444100499153137,
0.6752434372901917,
0.3137590289115906,
0.1554715782403946,
0.405737042427063,
0.9444451928138733,
-0.6517435312271118,
-0.7814810872077942,
-0.3996984362602234,
0.21114403009414673,
0.03675040230154991,
-0.2085341215133667,
0.7273002862930298,
0.3316779136657715,
1.2001136541366577,
-0.03808549791574478,
0.9104195237159729,
-0.1718158721923828,
0.36054328083992004,
-0.632899820804596,
0.7892294526100159,
-0.6550279855728149,
0.005735388491302729,
-0.41410571336746216,
-0.7269342541694641,
-0.2809760570526123,
0.6401375532150269,
-0.06679058820009232,
0.07016176730394363,
0.8833436369895935,
0.5255927443504333,
-0.05719441547989845,
-0.2865777611732483,
0.44426393508911133,
-0.08201330155134201,
-0.012760738842189312,
1.155258297920227,
0.6942082643508911,
-0.06897636502981186,
0.8292681574821472,
-0.3417137861251831,
-0.3247186541557312,
-0.16444027423858643,
-0.7868577241897583,
-1.026977777481079,
-0.5122436881065369,
-0.11051268875598907,
-0.20679037272930145,
0.5369806885719299,
0.5913775563240051,
0.6620548963546753,
-0.6527472138404846,
-0.31093430519104004,
0.12356825917959213,
0.20194005966186523,
-0.4720580577850342,
-0.24694134294986725,
0.4393429458141327,
-0.6414430737495422,
-0.529639482498169,
0.2559611201286316,
0.29163843393325806,
-0.009030095301568508,
-0.23407480120658875,
0.18238146603107452,
-0.640591561794281,
-0.07897297292947769,
0.7359663844108582,
0.2448955923318863,
-0.43840181827545166,
-0.13268549740314484,
0.1886100322008133,
-0.11195480078458786,
0.0015709868166595697,
0.9069835543632507,
-0.8370386362075806,
0.46839529275894165,
0.5225327014923096,
1.1072978973388672,
0.3794987201690674,
-0.24325791001319885,
0.5593217611312866,
-0.9891432523727417,
0.18030640482902527,
0.12767668068408966,
0.5152697563171387,
0.4136825203895569,
-0.3752630949020386,
0.30250978469848633,
0.32629916071891785,
-0.1791212260723114,
-0.47527191042900085,
0.07122930884361267,
-1.106507658958435,
-0.5170190930366516,
1.3426607847213745,
-0.2498151808977127,
-0.04076689854264259,
-0.21762730181217194,
-0.007302480284124613,
0.3456926643848419,
-0.4777166545391083,
0.5467895269393921,
0.8498393893241882,
-0.2444838285446167,
-0.4719662368297577,
-0.3785180449485779,
0.140789195895195,
0.6965704560279846,
-0.9013033509254456,
0.03723810240626335,
0.20789434015750885,
0.26853179931640625,
0.27440595626831055,
0.48552149534225464,
-0.2620076537132263,
0.5367118716239929,
0.05097626894712448,
0.4619327485561371,
-0.0627136379480362,
-0.5652220249176025,
-0.1823205053806305,
-0.03287138044834137,
-0.2779901623725891,
-0.32317057251930237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16621v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16621v1
|
Hippocrates: An Open-Source Framework for Advancing Large Language Models in Healthcare
| 2024-04-25T14:06:37 | 2024-04-25T14:06:37 |
Emre Can Acikgoz, Osman Batur İnce, Rayene Bench, Arda Anıl Boz, İlker Kesen, Aykut Erdem, Erkut Erdem
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) into healthcare promises to
transform medical diagnostics, research, and patient care. Yet, the progression
of medical LLMs faces obstacles such as complex training requirements, rigorous
evaluation demands, and the dominance of proprietary models that restrict
academic exploration. Transparent, comprehensive access to LLM resources is
essential for advancing the field, fostering reproducibility, and encouraging
innovation in healthcare AI. We present Hippocrates, an open-source LLM
framework specifically developed for the medical domain. In stark contrast to
previous efforts, it offers unrestricted access to its training datasets,
codebase, checkpoints, and evaluation protocols. This open approach is designed
to stimulate collaborative research, allowing the community to build upon,
refine, and rigorously evaluate medical LLMs within a transparent ecosystem.
Also, we introduce Hippo, a family of 7B models tailored for the medical
domain, fine-tuned from Mistral and LLaMA2 through continual pre-training,
instruction tuning, and reinforcement learning from human and AI feedback. Our
models outperform existing open medical LLMs models by a large-margin, even
surpassing models with 70B parameters. Through Hippocrates, we aspire to unlock
the full potential of LLMs not just to advance medical knowledge and patient
care but also to democratize the benefits of AI research in healthcare, making
them available across the globe.
|
[
0.03979640081524849,
-0.48899850249290466,
0.9518781900405884,
0.10343065112829208,
-0.18567802011966705,
-0.16885872185230255,
-0.4092749059200287,
-0.5788490176200867,
0.1834574192762375,
0.6820476651191711,
-0.28184443712234497,
-0.5919427871704102,
-0.8094874620437622,
0.005061272531747818,
0.04141337797045708,
0.8405200242996216,
-0.08765560388565063,
0.5170082449913025,
-0.1807384043931961,
-0.22221197187900543,
0.09374846518039703,
-0.34510159492492676,
-0.25385212898254395,
-0.7789582014083862,
0.5472354888916016,
0.25276997685432434,
0.8056948781013489,
0.8442378044128418,
0.5203767418861389,
0.2623894214630127,
0.17244422435760498,
0.14120584726333618,
-0.3208274841308594,
0.43426692485809326,
-0.47620290517807007,
-0.2703667879104614,
-0.33857154846191406,
-0.06865086406469345,
0.5843507051467896,
0.9724925756454468,
-0.24599546194076538,
0.06920500099658966,
-0.07950949668884277,
0.7114683985710144,
-0.6366394758224487,
0.3102262318134308,
-0.30136895179748535,
0.20161670446395874,
-0.10804276913404465,
-0.3122141659259796,
-0.1830502450466156,
-0.6011733412742615,
0.28262317180633545,
-0.8124407529830933,
-0.09970888495445251,
-0.11752939969301224,
0.6108660697937012,
0.1707235425710678,
-0.04969387501478195,
-0.14005151391029358,
-0.8036972284317017,
0.6627984046936035,
-0.5499705076217651,
0.4580821096897125,
0.21610569953918457,
0.3558823764324188,
-0.40954259037971497,
-0.9982821345329285,
-0.30072927474975586,
-0.33591920137405396,
0.36424320936203003,
-0.055222682654857635,
-0.21490928530693054,
0.19643378257751465,
-0.1449524611234665,
0.8283515572547913,
-0.37217751145362854,
0.3648490905761719,
-0.2988009452819824,
-0.10060293227434158,
0.23678924143314362,
0.1814926117658615,
0.30240723490715027,
0.13271349668502808,
-0.20660820603370667,
0.4477783143520355,
-0.790107011795044,
-0.18178901076316833,
-0.3392297923564911,
0.04787809029221535,
-0.2105722576379776,
0.6723745465278625,
-0.19602084159851074,
0.4073035418987274,
-0.14897997677326202,
-0.506250262260437,
0.29835203289985657,
-0.16141536831855774,
-0.522952675819397,
-0.09988205134868622,
1.0996710062026978,
-0.04676095396280289,
-0.16130109131336212,
-0.3313041925430298,
-0.0015220360364764929,
0.18907293677330017,
0.30373185873031616,
-0.8208091855049133,
-0.1670348346233368,
0.651607871055603,
-0.7087476253509521,
-0.48218435049057007,
-0.4390473961830139,
-0.5020010471343994,
-0.8396158218383789,
-0.28306815028190613,
0.2576580047607422,
-0.6394655108451843,
-0.1827441304922104,
0.4707757532596588,
0.007399681024253368,
0.13872778415679932,
0.4446410536766052,
-0.7862986922264099,
0.558646559715271,
1.047744870185852,
0.8026804327964783,
0.062411148101091385,
-0.2092653065919876,
-0.5472413897514343,
0.24061086773872375,
-0.5243960022926331,
0.557482123374939,
-0.6000604033470154,
-0.4526579678058624,
0.19511985778808594,
0.021986084058880806,
0.1608135849237442,
-0.7891501188278198,
0.5527541637420654,
-0.21903471648693085,
0.05785383656620979,
-0.1851302981376648,
-0.6246302127838135,
0.17893126606941223,
0.20889827609062195,
-0.5142948031425476,
0.5956987142562866,
0.1953791230916977,
-0.6716235280036926,
0.15857988595962524,
-0.9620422124862671,
-0.1558828502893448,
0.5172677040100098,
-0.668912947177887,
-0.43687209486961365,
0.27251991629600525,
0.08631423860788345,
0.3204699456691742,
-0.7734231948852539,
0.3241930305957794,
-0.4809475839138031,
-0.13591477274894714,
0.03009844943881035,
0.07585263252258301,
0.9053781032562256,
0.26019152998924255,
-0.4049542248249054,
0.5188512206077576,
-0.6427915692329407,
-0.044629015028476715,
0.3728925883769989,
-0.2751334309577942,
-0.5713461637496948,
0.11223627626895905,
-0.2040252387523651,
-0.03094545193016529,
0.2796435058116913,
-0.5630353689193726,
0.23547065258026123,
-0.5445836186408997,
0.6942800879478455,
0.6064456105232239,
0.08448804169893265,
0.4087490737438202,
-0.652586817741394,
0.5448852181434631,
-0.10252279788255692,
0.41125574707984924,
-0.28428345918655396,
-0.713062047958374,
-0.12307490408420563,
-0.6411039233207703,
0.13343104720115662,
0.5148716568946838,
-0.4250718355178833,
0.5451877117156982,
-0.23170135915279388,
-0.7306022047996521,
-0.9758212566375732,
0.14602361619472504,
0.1879238486289978,
0.6903243064880371,
0.07532627880573273,
-0.4639459252357483,
-0.20471704006195068,
-0.7596315741539001,
0.03602997213602066,
-0.2640528380870819,
-0.34627431631088257,
0.356330543756485,
0.44243323802948,
-0.5282628536224365,
0.39221683144569397,
-0.23609419167041779,
-0.23338918387889862,
-0.15600931644439697,
-0.2964373826980591,
0.06323505192995071,
0.41489821672439575,
0.3102113902568817,
-0.3534111976623535,
0.021814174950122833,
0.36419007182121277,
-0.9145975112915039,
-0.11301717162132263,
0.34307247400283813,
-0.37444546818733215,
-0.3072160482406616,
0.12415318936109543,
-0.6317520141601562,
0.053361497819423676,
0.7195937037467957,
-0.21986091136932373,
0.7027891278266907,
-0.39264237880706787,
0.01862400583922863,
-1.187051773071289,
0.2721870541572571,
-0.05746167153120041,
-0.28496280312538147,
-0.4301649332046509,
0.2188732773065567,
0.008249616250395775,
-0.2934032380580902,
-0.09712209552526474,
0.5367496609687805,
-0.33232381939888,
-0.0756441205739975,
-0.20267917215824127,
0.030136020854115486,
0.09324758499860764,
-0.22245213389396667,
0.1475113183259964,
0.3428817093372345,
0.8947286605834961,
-0.3896469473838806,
0.45438432693481445,
0.4516068696975708,
-0.6058722734451294,
0.6149476170539856,
-0.7721114754676819,
-0.10597406327724457,
0.11482466757297516,
0.226277157664299,
-0.2590634822845459,
-0.26439332962036133,
0.5239773392677307,
-0.2059151828289032,
0.008968060836195946,
-0.03074577823281288,
-0.48476913571357727,
-0.21143867075443268,
-0.19931656122207642,
0.1982465237379074,
0.5937609076499939,
-0.514026403427124,
0.4945454001426697,
0.7254540324211121,
-0.32838743925094604,
-0.6227275729179382,
-0.3344828486442566,
0.008868669159710407,
0.20572452247142792,
-0.6688374280929565,
0.4620612561702728,
-0.04714146628975868,
-0.534816324710846,
0.07164564728736877,
-0.013514484278857708,
-0.12505267560482025,
-0.04227643832564354,
0.38546839356422424,
0.24748337268829346,
-0.42644932866096497,
0.22827613353729248,
0.08387172222137451,
0.03669203072786331,
0.2538895606994629,
-0.7919011116027832,
0.3933272659778595,
-0.0760367140173912,
-0.4781202971935272,
-0.61583411693573,
0.4038117527961731,
0.9208512902259827,
-0.48505738377571106,
0.4789549708366394,
0.22817185521125793,
-0.6346687078475952,
-0.21984803676605225,
-0.40934857726097107,
-0.05888017639517784,
-0.4070560932159424,
0.4894310235977173,
0.1326509267091751,
-0.9627812504768372,
0.33716458082199097,
-0.41038137674331665,
0.40477097034454346,
0.22455811500549316,
0.951546311378479,
0.1607617437839508,
0.5020536780357361,
0.8180429935455322,
-0.0373990498483181,
0.1691294014453888,
0.10424047708511353,
-0.05137006193399429,
-0.7415928244590759,
-0.6738715767860413,
-0.6713325381278992,
-0.018931031227111816,
-0.6556621789932251,
-0.6782479286193848,
0.5528438091278076,
-0.20992718636989594,
-0.1813710629940033,
-0.39711272716522217,
-0.556244969367981,
0.21441809833049774,
0.4837048053741455,
0.38052821159362793,
0.5444438457489014,
-0.13121385872364044,
-0.388864666223526,
0.11166341602802277,
-0.5562820434570312,
-0.5635948777198792,
1.1307998895645142,
0.7610455751419067,
1.0032854080200195,
-0.07183460146188736,
0.7783517837524414,
0.006614518351852894,
0.44629621505737305,
-1.0256885290145874,
0.2734847366809845,
-0.1434912532567978,
-0.5192693471908569,
-0.24674640595912933,
-0.4011281132698059,
-1.1184253692626953,
0.1492954045534134,
-0.26769813895225525,
-0.4743988513946533,
0.08565083146095276,
0.23338265717029572,
-0.3897056579589844,
0.5404499173164368,
-0.32389411330223083,
1.0092705488204956,
-0.3269381821155548,
-0.38644418120384216,
-0.3418221175670624,
-0.6995015740394592,
0.41915029287338257,
-0.054364901036024094,
0.29936861991882324,
-0.23252920806407928,
-0.5104514360427856,
0.4756241738796234,
-0.6214640736579895,
0.7909596562385559,
0.0767967626452446,
-0.17929679155349731,
-0.023969164118170738,
0.15548136830329895,
0.12400784343481064,
0.24983087182044983,
0.0046702055260539055,
0.5122841596603394,
0.0033732601441442966,
-0.5553351044654846,
-0.17678795754909515,
0.9462152123451233,
-0.9044249653816223,
-0.3094605803489685,
-0.5558372139930725,
-0.5565969944000244,
-0.5097711682319641,
0.3346009850502014,
0.1618744432926178,
0.28907808661460876,
-0.4504188895225525,
-0.038849249482154846,
0.9605954885482788,
-0.5753119587898254,
-0.20121490955352783,
0.7194000482559204,
-0.3080058693885803,
-0.46415814757347107,
0.43438494205474854,
-0.35729753971099854,
0.17380523681640625,
0.3539355993270874,
0.6276737451553345,
-0.14624188840389252,
-0.8701839447021484,
-0.388563334941864,
0.5726344585418701,
-0.5181893110275269,
0.06006878614425659,
-0.38041257858276367,
-0.19912490248680115,
-0.47256579995155334,
-0.11676540970802307,
-0.33738160133361816,
-0.17481587827205658,
-0.260614812374115,
0.13962770998477936,
0.3323599696159363,
1.051861047744751,
-0.08496769517660141,
0.04114127531647682,
-0.8779036998748779,
0.49072515964508057,
0.06496834754943848,
0.834297776222229,
-0.30372491478919983,
-0.3034980297088623,
-0.09874322265386581,
-0.42011234164237976,
-0.42248886823654175,
-0.9938127398490906,
0.30426836013793945,
0.06842651963233948,
0.6188015341758728,
0.5776548385620117,
-0.15703196823596954,
0.30647173523902893,
-0.9118700623512268,
0.5997334122657776,
0.4971901774406433,
-0.7242114543914795,
0.617148756980896,
-0.3408604860305786,
0.2952726483345032,
0.4200839102268219,
0.608677089214325,
-0.6378477215766907,
-0.4354969561100006,
-0.4745490550994873,
-0.6117866635322571,
0.21934784948825836,
-0.1130482405424118,
-0.11951253563165665,
0.017373744398355484,
0.478262722492218,
0.38408163189888,
0.23756913840770721,
-0.3058614730834961,
-0.09928431361913681,
-0.014350134879350662,
-0.24423210322856903,
0.013983620330691338,
0.032992783933877945,
-0.460061639547348,
-0.18933285772800446,
0.6345905065536499,
-0.02621017023921013,
0.08949852734804153,
0.39579150080680847,
0.28164198994636536,
-0.465021550655365,
0.4292316436767578,
0.17092503607273102,
0.766412079334259,
-0.021848315373063087,
-0.033789776265621185,
-0.5147778987884521,
-0.6491426229476929,
0.0009295549825765193,
0.38830509781837463,
-0.20819297432899475,
0.19814854860305786,
0.18710006773471832,
0.4466528296470642,
0.108037069439888,
-0.9941083788871765,
0.5027514696121216,
0.03326385095715523,
-0.16027189791202545,
-0.35015425086021423,
-0.06530473381280899,
0.1853741556406021,
0.3381767272949219,
-0.006627328228205442,
-0.007137579843401909,
0.08598294109106064,
-0.5512698292732239,
0.27633562684059143,
0.35458657145500183,
-0.4652886986732483,
-0.3130432069301605,
0.7963504195213318,
0.2734508514404297,
-0.2712635397911072,
0.3793221414089203,
0.293053537607193,
0.05178550258278847,
0.1971016526222229,
0.5076429843902588,
0.7401837110519409,
-0.4852367341518402,
0.13512961566448212,
0.15593686699867249,
0.3189401626586914,
-0.3284386098384857,
0.4188312590122223,
0.20806650817394257,
-0.3945784866809845,
-0.6736471056938171,
-0.6667696833610535,
-0.8089661598205566,
0.5660143494606018,
-0.4964793622493744,
0.30111777782440186,
-0.7733673453330994,
-0.15051774680614471,
0.242562934756279,
-0.19252632558345795,
-0.3865855634212494,
-0.11874528229236603,
0.19218717515468597,
1.110617756843567,
-0.5725546479225159,
0.9191374182701111,
0.734168529510498,
-0.27162525057792664,
-0.4276239573955536,
-0.15806947648525238,
0.05312453210353851,
-1.0326471328735352,
0.09937335550785065,
-0.16647528111934662,
0.08717287331819534,
-0.4295060336589813,
-0.6743648052215576,
-0.44477638602256775,
0.9250809550285339,
0.6791816353797913,
-0.7041103839874268,
-0.3878977596759796,
-0.020825780928134918,
0.49384915828704834,
-0.48990073800086975,
-0.17191490530967712,
0.47939592599868774,
0.09851942211389542,
-0.09438340365886688,
-1.2110563516616821,
0.0992451012134552,
-0.181857168674469,
-0.18715162575244904,
0.17737515270709991,
-0.3905074894428253,
0.5492470860481262,
-0.5684520602226257,
0.29448628425598145,
0.38759660720825195,
0.25009870529174805,
0.4342121481895447,
0.35336077213287354,
0.14571484923362732,
0.5865130424499512,
0.9771111011505127,
0.0019058790057897568,
1.3072973489761353,
-0.3716754913330078,
0.030200699344277382,
0.9136301279067993,
-0.4595348536968231,
0.7974401712417603,
0.38590744137763977,
-0.045484911650419235,
0.5791256427764893,
0.4027111530303955,
0.21731743216514587,
0.3117678165435791,
0.21773923933506012,
-0.66126948595047,
-0.22445376217365265,
-0.3195556700229645,
-0.5671421885490417,
0.16439278423786163,
0.5671373605728149,
-0.805290937423706,
0.005335045512765646,
-0.23914889991283417,
0.05919753015041351,
0.2527969479560852,
-0.5593118667602539,
0.6972892880439758,
0.41290315985679626,
-0.37477579712867737,
0.4271085262298584,
-0.07357403635978699,
0.3084290027618408,
-1.1022027730941772,
-0.06673520058393478,
0.1136351004242897,
0.21907928586006165,
-0.2738635838031769,
-0.45262610912323,
0.11889626085758209,
-0.11283864825963974,
-0.10200677812099457,
-0.049447812139987946,
0.5721855163574219,
-0.21683034300804138,
-0.39251649379730225,
0.2897292375564575,
0.5174051523208618,
0.06101159378886223,
0.09417859464883804,
-0.6986071467399597,
0.13372363150119781,
-0.4131292998790741,
0.13369010388851166,
0.42614126205444336,
0.6655820608139038,
0.18016214668750763,
0.682391881942749,
0.6214311122894287,
0.7064968347549438,
-0.20699399709701538,
0.012864266522228718,
0.8381549715995789,
-0.5852943062782288,
-0.5802232027053833,
-0.7205771207809448,
0.1402381807565689,
0.171194389462471,
-0.2335296869277954,
0.2703436315059662,
0.6340576410293579,
0.5968652367591858,
-0.024472864344716072,
1.181613802909851,
0.21545258164405823,
0.6599798202514648,
-0.22077326476573944,
0.8320366144180298,
-0.4962550401687622,
0.23252180218696594,
-0.05604066699743271,
-0.3154032528400421,
-0.313259482383728,
0.4967435300350189,
-0.19177739322185516,
-0.20834626257419586,
0.6204875707626343,
0.32899966835975647,
0.061654821038246155,
-0.14154009521007538,
0.44584715366363525,
0.46149545907974243,
0.268991082906723,
0.7444475293159485,
0.6821585297584534,
0.03954328969120979,
0.41684985160827637,
-0.34199726581573486,
-0.7014023661613464,
-0.09333257377147675,
-0.672158420085907,
-0.6244153380393982,
-0.1814894825220108,
-0.34491968154907227,
-0.6003981828689575,
0.3111023008823395,
1.286811351776123,
0.7154779434204102,
-0.7678375840187073,
-0.30095309019088745,
0.09365232288837433,
-0.04113989323377609,
-0.41111624240875244,
-0.05767412111163139,
0.23925460875034332,
-0.24274031817913055,
-0.5428392887115479,
0.5627292990684509,
0.7244792580604553,
-0.12807141244411469,
-0.5196447968482971,
-0.28765425086021423,
0.35804522037506104,
0.061457980424165726,
0.5040201544761658,
0.6678816676139832,
-0.7883530855178833,
0.2187170535326004,
0.015897704288363457,
-0.3255608081817627,
0.3237648010253906,
1.001227855682373,
-0.6614733934402466,
0.6567431688308716,
0.2661089301109314,
0.92324298620224,
0.034242089837789536,
-0.3977665603160858,
0.6826104521751404,
0.08057383447885513,
0.14807406067848206,
0.749739944934845,
0.6298644542694092,
0.3656148314476013,
-0.10529609769582748,
0.23673564195632935,
0.28216877579689026,
-0.6845051646232605,
-0.6872876882553101,
0.34527814388275146,
-0.9959416389465332,
-0.3575153648853302,
1.0527656078338623,
-0.16822758316993713,
-0.286567360162735,
-0.3360154926776886,
0.0319707915186882,
0.06665100902318954,
-0.2663375735282898,
0.9488202929496765,
0.13942770659923553,
-0.3307397961616516,
0.21438126266002655,
-0.7549580931663513,
0.4560897946357727,
0.2651916444301605,
-0.9999417662620544,
0.03873441368341446,
0.7361850142478943,
0.6062294244766235,
0.021926913410425186,
1.1026241779327393,
-0.826457142829895,
0.4577260911464691,
-0.30016955733299255,
0.18946804106235504,
-0.02520039677619934,
-0.10350172966718674,
-0.5460099577903748,
0.3056814968585968,
0.5035394430160522,
-0.18051563203334808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16587v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16587v1
|
Understanding Privacy Risks of Embeddings Induced by Large Language Models
| 2024-04-25T13:10:48 | 2024-04-25T13:10:48 |
Zhihao Zhu, Ninglu Shao, Defu Lian, Chenwang Wu, Zheng Liu, Yi Yang, Enhong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) show early signs of artificial general
intelligence but struggle with hallucinations. One promising solution to
mitigate these hallucinations is to store external knowledge as embeddings,
aiding LLMs in retrieval-augmented generation. However, such a solution risks
compromising privacy, as recent studies experimentally showed that the original
text can be partially reconstructed from text embeddings by pre-trained
language models. The significant advantage of LLMs over traditional pre-trained
models may exacerbate these concerns. To this end, we investigate the
effectiveness of reconstructing original knowledge and predicting entity
attributes from these embeddings when LLMs are employed. Empirical findings
indicate that LLMs significantly improve the accuracy of two evaluated tasks
over those from pre-trained models, regardless of whether the texts are
in-distribution or out-of-distribution. This underscores a heightened potential
for LLMs to jeopardize user privacy, highlighting the negative consequences of
their widespread use. We further discuss preliminary strategies to mitigate
this risk.
|
[
-0.20859093964099884,
-0.5385628938674927,
0.7968735694885254,
-0.23171915113925934,
-0.02691873535513878,
-0.03198157250881195,
-0.38947707414627075,
-0.7264450788497925,
0.09119254350662231,
0.8546645641326904,
-0.2426947057247162,
-0.603900671005249,
-0.7972633242607117,
-0.22403787076473236,
-0.5551176071166992,
0.8887860774993896,
0.13041912019252777,
-0.07968039810657501,
-0.432498037815094,
0.16342294216156006,
-0.13219822943210602,
-0.9223307967185974,
-0.32734185457229614,
-0.09085775166749954,
0.5562402606010437,
-0.0008634307887405157,
0.8356867432594299,
0.6079375743865967,
0.3100317120552063,
0.33924195170402527,
-0.0706692561507225,
0.04369102045893669,
-0.7818045020103455,
0.29295092821121216,
-0.1921316683292389,
-0.5156955718994141,
-0.17423425614833832,
0.08795245736837387,
0.67055743932724,
0.742584228515625,
-0.27246424555778503,
0.01582867093384266,
0.29385727643966675,
0.3942757248878479,
-0.8912827968597412,
0.11570142954587936,
-0.7063301205635071,
0.21556639671325684,
0.026632504537701607,
-0.32408687472343445,
-0.6166892647743225,
-0.53387051820755,
0.4990523159503937,
-0.33084601163864136,
0.08875478059053421,
0.1577078253030777,
0.7047492265701294,
0.3275468051433563,
-0.34269091486930847,
-0.32414937019348145,
-0.884580671787262,
0.6867706775665283,
-0.48830437660217285,
0.6184671521186829,
0.6969441175460815,
0.043454479426145554,
-0.31350305676460266,
-0.6430698037147522,
-0.23880860209465027,
-0.37405312061309814,
-0.390109658241272,
-0.3478817343711853,
-0.1876201629638672,
0.1386059671640396,
0.39818164706230164,
0.3686280846595764,
-0.2244504690170288,
0.5365103483200073,
-0.21778534352779388,
-0.408930242061615,
0.7622807621955872,
0.05927054211497307,
0.21268899738788605,
-0.05156327411532402,
-0.09656166285276413,
-0.08975952863693237,
-1.0208615064620972,
-0.1315678507089615,
0.7815420031547546,
0.03072976879775524,
0.19950275123119354,
0.7512193322181702,
0.14827826619148254,
0.23635053634643555,
-0.09640329331159592,
-0.044743821024894714,
0.26076605916023254,
-0.008395507000386715,
-0.17906427383422852,
0.11455168575048447,
0.6814784407615662,
0.0718969777226448,
0.5903392434120178,
-0.5380190014839172,
-0.06122932583093643,
-0.385188490152359,
0.4059741795063019,
-0.641792356967926,
-0.182287335395813,
0.1769547015428543,
-0.4536694288253784,
-0.20368294417858124,
0.15245220065116882,
-0.6562293171882629,
-0.6821062564849854,
-0.2817355692386627,
0.41341933608055115,
-0.30949148535728455,
-0.043606895953416824,
0.11449597030878067,
0.18650513887405396,
0.007771969772875309,
0.27481406927108765,
-0.8776608109474182,
0.27368471026420593,
0.8403992652893066,
0.5549089908599854,
-0.005595999304205179,
-0.24374762177467346,
-0.36645621061325073,
0.49390098452568054,
-0.17407870292663574,
0.26771214604377747,
-0.38472965359687805,
-0.566401481628418,
0.29765573143959045,
0.14940786361694336,
0.19348706305027008,
-0.48148784041404724,
0.15891286730766296,
-0.6349313259124756,
0.23651166260242462,
-0.22158634662628174,
-0.7670885324478149,
-0.10894615203142166,
0.1866324543952942,
-0.6767272353172302,
0.4630034267902374,
-0.21319226920604706,
-0.9201735854148865,
0.046810079365968704,
-0.2940773367881775,
-0.40425679087638855,
-0.22146078944206238,
-0.2341499775648117,
-0.5025684833526611,
0.41685914993286133,
0.1436714380979538,
0.781057596206665,
0.002573645208030939,
-0.004127579741179943,
-0.34752705693244934,
-0.2521345317363739,
0.6199763417243958,
-0.4267443120479584,
0.633514940738678,
0.15428268909454346,
-0.2605239748954773,
-0.1618570238351822,
-0.4641580283641815,
-0.09648173302412033,
0.0614304281771183,
-0.1118588075041771,
-0.7659154534339905,
-0.014956812374293804,
-0.6382764577865601,
-0.12333478033542633,
0.4886031448841095,
-0.5175944566726685,
-0.13458161056041718,
-0.5917923450469971,
0.3260589838027954,
1.049107551574707,
0.16915041208267212,
0.7707478404045105,
-0.14715345203876495,
0.46123364567756653,
0.06801889091730118,
0.21354562044143677,
-0.12106411159038544,
-0.4571492373943329,
-0.24630600214004517,
-0.20540690422058105,
0.30498364567756653,
0.45468100905418396,
-0.3173224925994873,
0.4638194143772125,
-0.35986626148223877,
-0.38078752160072327,
-0.4779159426689148,
0.2268623560667038,
0.4123159646987915,
-0.07391215115785599,
-0.08204352855682373,
-0.08652662485837936,
-0.28159865736961365,
-1.0148842334747314,
-0.404438853263855,
-0.023746227845549583,
-0.05966916307806969,
0.5764264464378357,
0.4546658396720886,
-0.4768996834754944,
0.6190121173858643,
-0.6526688933372498,
-0.28371724486351013,
0.11185892671346664,
-0.23076194524765015,
-0.3256697654724121,
0.6318758130073547,
0.308599054813385,
-0.7131803631782532,
-0.08591493219137192,
-0.15126004815101624,
-0.8765357136726379,
0.23344239592552185,
-0.09393591433763504,
-0.14882977306842804,
0.17424263060092926,
0.3247373104095459,
-0.9126230478286743,
0.6688756942749023,
0.6143245100975037,
-0.08767842501401901,
0.28252974152565,
-0.5402227640151978,
-0.07240016758441925,
-1.0830239057540894,
-0.2474803924560547,
-0.2173875868320465,
-0.3174363970756531,
-0.47681042551994324,
0.16434872150421143,
-0.06769885867834091,
-0.179121196269989,
-0.4342634677886963,
0.3376166820526123,
-0.7894556522369385,
-0.31453970074653625,
-0.09364435821771622,
0.13054578006267548,
-0.012267081998288631,
0.09106442332267761,
-0.10085092484951019,
0.6847831606864929,
0.5075132846832275,
-0.6035377979278564,
0.03519407659769058,
0.26248300075531006,
-0.5718593597412109,
-0.031115347519516945,
-0.41180306673049927,
0.532376766204834,
-0.30466020107269287,
-0.009065208956599236,
-0.6598371267318726,
-0.24003002047538757,
0.2606586217880249,
-0.4433225989341736,
0.6317903995513916,
0.19996294379234314,
-0.749526858329773,
-0.10291676968336105,
-0.6010031700134277,
0.25646063685417175,
0.5444425940513611,
-0.6954111456871033,
0.8236427903175354,
0.9061498045921326,
-0.14539046585559845,
-0.7310264110565186,
-0.8795279264450073,
0.10085057467222214,
-0.2658542990684509,
-0.4602578282356262,
0.4038360118865967,
0.1604670286178589,
-0.2891607880592346,
0.39346617460250854,
0.19908951222896576,
0.15126483142375946,
0.42833513021469116,
0.6774390339851379,
0.034435708075761795,
0.07803837209939957,
0.2508801817893982,
0.05077603459358215,
-0.09876226633787155,
0.3979558050632477,
-0.2075396478176117,
0.571914792060852,
0.1213865578174591,
-0.5116289854049683,
-0.34360384941101074,
0.44300577044487,
0.133123978972435,
-0.19566379487514496,
1.3221358060836792,
0.2072114646434784,
-0.732174277305603,
-0.3249579071998596,
-0.7209734916687012,
-0.33509814739227295,
-0.5207535624504089,
0.43897774815559387,
-0.03710947185754776,
-1.0559672117233276,
0.49507954716682434,
-0.05703161656856537,
-0.02797294408082962,
0.0784357413649559,
0.5379008054733276,
-0.19282269477844238,
1.0134531259536743,
0.9044119715690613,
-0.24680840969085693,
0.5015677213668823,
-0.217693492770195,
0.5339730381965637,
-0.7542785406112671,
-0.634019136428833,
-0.4463016390800476,
-0.18804246187210083,
-1.0286545753479004,
-0.25593289732933044,
0.04434868320822716,
-0.1418628841638565,
-0.11456624418497086,
0.20392772555351257,
-0.2654072046279907,
0.6358224749565125,
0.6889840960502625,
0.3560957908630371,
0.3593388795852661,
0.23640090227127075,
0.3633342683315277,
-0.06323672086000443,
-0.2975749373435974,
-0.7479269504547119,
1.3867894411087036,
0.6676987409591675,
1.2546236515045166,
0.16741536557674408,
1.1315737962722778,
0.1495451033115387,
0.3784080147743225,
-0.5631576776504517,
0.540759801864624,
-0.19313792884349823,
-0.6469232439994812,
-0.3261406719684601,
-0.6145508289337158,
-0.9782789349555969,
0.080314040184021,
-0.35961097478866577,
-1.217095136642456,
0.25844883918762207,
0.23348559439182281,
-0.36564481258392334,
0.459427148103714,
-0.7061405181884766,
0.42494454979896545,
-0.32146891951560974,
-0.519661545753479,
-0.23626600205898285,
-0.46326032280921936,
0.4652366042137146,
-0.3323952257633209,
0.17793557047843933,
0.1446101814508438,
-0.06773818284273148,
0.7086571455001831,
-0.04807821288704872,
0.9896062612533569,
-0.1639600247144699,
-0.3423629105091095,
0.035512007772922516,
0.0849648043513298,
0.769587516784668,
0.06915108114480972,
-0.044250864535570145,
0.24802125990390778,
-0.050868481397628784,
-0.11624810844659805,
-0.6214137673377991,
1.11321222782135,
-0.9109513163566589,
-1.1431779861450195,
-0.26861897110939026,
-0.6233553886413574,
-0.22666138410568237,
0.03624022379517555,
0.26078757643699646,
0.05900309234857559,
-0.20961233973503113,
0.38681331276893616,
0.9779382944107056,
-0.727601170539856,
0.06492038816213608,
0.2697179913520813,
-0.3858785331249237,
-0.2291439026594162,
0.6488945484161377,
0.32269030809402466,
0.18276487290859222,
0.237269327044487,
0.1433958262205124,
-0.5027522444725037,
-0.6223616600036621,
0.2039007693529129,
0.42010846734046936,
-0.8762430548667908,
-0.0864555835723877,
-0.8874924778938293,
-0.24512025713920593,
-0.48860692977905273,
0.060123197734355927,
-0.24430982768535614,
-0.2304626852273941,
-0.5995434522628784,
-0.5221394896507263,
0.26487964391708374,
0.9516198635101318,
-0.07741864025592804,
0.2351789027452469,
-0.8693172335624695,
0.004530572798103094,
0.21018530428409576,
0.35504063963890076,
0.11555106937885284,
-0.43594303727149963,
-0.22462429106235504,
0.07922982424497604,
-0.0353054516017437,
-0.8746694922447205,
0.39788416028022766,
0.026992615312337875,
0.7029170393943787,
0.4144552946090698,
-0.00920218974351883,
0.48529958724975586,
-0.579306423664093,
0.7316370606422424,
-0.17015323042869568,
-0.8089002370834351,
0.3259108364582062,
-0.013403840363025665,
-0.30804014205932617,
0.45370668172836304,
0.6288514733314514,
-0.014255348592996597,
-0.44124287366867065,
-0.7189949154853821,
-0.7721298933029175,
0.3633464574813843,
0.02171957679092884,
0.7016738653182983,
0.03381297364830971,
0.5908238291740417,
0.1945691704750061,
0.4754103720188141,
-0.7165141105651855,
-0.18213066458702087,
0.0805206373333931,
-0.2166779488325119,
-0.2417478710412979,
-0.6510103940963745,
-0.15940280258655548,
-0.10084157437086105,
0.5341477394104004,
0.4053560197353363,
0.3802953064441681,
-0.1754104346036911,
-0.28466105461120605,
0.13816054165363312,
0.14188003540039062,
0.4409085512161255,
0.49185654520988464,
-0.08146154135465622,
0.4248822033405304,
0.15257041156291962,
-0.373874694108963,
0.1892733871936798,
0.14500059187412262,
-0.15823887288570404,
-0.21155409514904022,
0.277926504611969,
0.5342017412185669,
0.29849591851234436,
-0.5486774444580078,
0.5922306776046753,
0.03647210821509361,
-0.03349526226520538,
-0.7325157523155212,
-0.01341949962079525,
0.24284836649894714,
0.24453841149806976,
0.09897620975971222,
-0.25047746300697327,
0.11459372192621231,
-0.6480957269668579,
0.17553916573524475,
0.6076011061668396,
-0.0458243303000927,
-0.3965775966644287,
0.5898320078849792,
-0.15016937255859375,
-0.4406394064426422,
0.5411595702171326,
0.0894894152879715,
-0.4989002048969269,
0.2197396159172058,
0.5273430943489075,
0.904902458190918,
-0.4692521393299103,
0.09341217577457428,
-0.019263094291090965,
0.43368953466415405,
-0.12070921063423157,
0.04097718372941017,
0.16312532126903534,
-0.8881138563156128,
-0.1775495558977127,
-0.4435569643974304,
-0.3645187318325043,
0.12725907564163208,
-0.7283176779747009,
-0.13939397037029266,
-0.6751521825790405,
-0.32275643944740295,
-0.3721722662448883,
-0.234682098031044,
-0.8897435665130615,
-0.1299855262041092,
0.3542621433734894,
0.6112164855003357,
-0.6681795716285706,
0.7656787633895874,
0.3216400742530823,
-0.24761636555194855,
-0.7462218403816223,
0.15355005860328674,
-0.16568057239055634,
-0.8319881558418274,
0.5818429589271545,
0.2802594304084778,
-0.18160124123096466,
-0.012094815261662006,
-0.5593667030334473,
-0.8566399216651917,
0.9907955527305603,
0.6977225542068481,
-0.8645056486129761,
-0.17331565916538239,
0.4297123849391937,
0.5491663813591003,
-0.2610381543636322,
-0.16888725757598877,
0.4999144375324249,
0.24124163389205933,
-0.3717665374279022,
-0.5566688776016235,
0.3070186376571655,
0.18660397827625275,
0.08176471292972565,
0.19245342910289764,
-0.15148179233074188,
0.8012495636940002,
-0.3411346971988678,
-0.39320108294487,
0.004242150112986565,
0.5374380946159363,
0.05023690685629845,
0.09879405051469803,
0.3484804332256317,
0.5590117573738098,
1.0813233852386475,
0.12062687426805496,
1.3466500043869019,
-0.3430827260017395,
0.1978253573179245,
1.1548699140548706,
-0.4147622883319855,
0.8847664594650269,
0.5652487874031067,
0.0969945639371872,
0.3701588809490204,
0.3853967785835266,
0.04411274567246437,
0.7925794124603271,
0.39532625675201416,
-0.2578996419906616,
-0.03193247690796852,
-0.20553189516067505,
-0.5487158298492432,
0.31980636715888977,
0.37128645181655884,
-0.8460286259651184,
0.09477086365222931,
0.22329269349575043,
0.09366476535797119,
0.16666921973228455,
-0.13135415315628052,
0.8951135873794556,
0.39964985847473145,
-0.37573397159576416,
0.006857843603938818,
-0.16020071506500244,
0.5738084316253662,
-0.42390182614326477,
0.09473937004804611,
0.031593259423971176,
0.34121063351631165,
-0.1949731409549713,
-0.8113811612129211,
0.3649970293045044,
-0.08773981034755707,
0.008590529672801495,
-0.20840372145175934,
0.7408073544502258,
-0.45047351717948914,
-0.3275832235813141,
0.6398233771324158,
0.4998799264431,
0.18050387501716614,
-0.26434093713760376,
-0.3833004832267761,
0.03704970329999924,
-0.033261723816394806,
-0.5330899953842163,
0.6384241580963135,
0.5237500071525574,
0.09071864932775497,
0.6994093656539917,
0.6864940524101257,
0.2584385275840759,
0.13512900471687317,
0.053585752844810486,
0.991527795791626,
-0.579931378364563,
-0.392683207988739,
-1.1106547117233276,
0.28890541195869446,
-0.11593855172395706,
0.06573338061571121,
0.9057905077934265,
0.37823620438575745,
0.9560157060623169,
-0.09736663848161697,
0.6736449599266052,
0.47848570346832275,
0.4048684537410736,
-0.7392361164093018,
1.039960265159607,
-0.4147774279117584,
0.6599318981170654,
-0.11681987345218658,
-0.9072832465171814,
-0.2776432931423187,
0.6059424877166748,
-0.6974784731864929,
-0.0031602666713297367,
0.560907781124115,
0.962133526802063,
0.2120371013879776,
0.01728474348783493,
0.44852447509765625,
0.23945775628089905,
0.3701610267162323,
0.4060172438621521,
1.1322851181030273,
-0.08845110237598419,
0.35568881034851074,
-0.4863540530204773,
0.025830261409282684,
0.026956778019666672,
-0.8838488459587097,
-1.1118379831314087,
-0.3637601137161255,
-0.14194735884666443,
-0.3595946133136749,
0.05840439721941948,
0.7907284498214722,
0.46759355068206787,
-0.7561765313148499,
0.11590038239955902,
0.30380669236183167,
0.09140849113464355,
0.43541258573532104,
-0.1672343909740448,
0.35966604948043823,
0.11589664965867996,
-0.5862221717834473,
0.12354718148708344,
0.07143138349056244,
0.4325222373008728,
-0.615308940410614,
-0.07062015682458878,
0.07173439860343933,
0.002014866331592202,
0.4441007673740387,
0.011044846847653389,
-0.750008225440979,
-0.76781165599823,
-0.07917211204767227,
-0.13771866261959076,
-0.249424010515213,
0.626672089099884,
-0.593279242515564,
0.11035244911909103,
0.34441259503364563,
1.0023033618927002,
0.4023585915565491,
0.12224823236465454,
0.7626546621322632,
-0.7564810514450073,
0.22473613917827606,
0.2752256393432617,
0.5925104022026062,
0.4854546785354614,
-0.8896521329879761,
0.3259139060974121,
-0.23391082882881165,
-0.5808440446853638,
-1.10391104221344,
0.17919348180294037,
-0.42098501324653625,
-0.24121828377246857,
1.0822317600250244,
-0.5439844727516174,
-0.29896923899650574,
0.05204761400818825,
-0.01779838278889656,
0.17733503878116608,
-0.21147237718105316,
1.011107087135315,
0.5625469088554382,
0.33203351497650146,
-0.1703972965478897,
-0.48513802886009216,
0.5548482537269592,
0.11242730170488358,
-0.7309789657592773,
0.185362309217453,
0.3201480805873871,
0.33830615878105164,
0.1985674500465393,
0.35744738578796387,
-0.25128117203712463,
-0.16460412740707397,
-0.16866393387317657,
-0.17420022189617157,
-0.32208651304244995,
-0.45508715510368347,
-0.40332847833633423,
0.2325945645570755,
0.15854096412658691,
-0.31501707434654236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16574v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16574v1
|
Exploring Internal Numeracy in Language Models: A Case Study on ALBERT
| 2024-04-25T12:36:19 | 2024-04-25T12:36:19 |
Ulme Wennberg, Gustav Eje Henter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
It has been found that Transformer-based language models have the ability to
perform basic quantitative reasoning. In this paper, we propose a method for
studying how these models internally represent numerical data, and use our
proposal to analyze the ALBERT family of language models. Specifically, we
extract the learned embeddings these models use to represent tokens that
correspond to numbers and ordinals, and subject these embeddings to Principal
Component Analysis (PCA). PCA results reveal that ALBERT models of different
sizes, trained and initialized separately, consistently learn to use the axes
of greatest variation to represent the approximate ordering of various
numerical concepts. Numerals and their textual counterparts are represented in
separate clusters, but increase along the same direction in 2D space. Our
findings illustrate that language models, trained purely to model text, can
intuit basic mathematical concepts, opening avenues for NLP applications that
intersect with quantitative reasoning.
|
[
-0.3198075294494629,
-0.3736538589000702,
0.6922436356544495,
0.42237868905067444,
-0.040718674659729004,
0.025322167202830315,
-0.09572979807853699,
-0.05861564725637436,
-0.30579137802124023,
0.5746957063674927,
-0.039726436138153076,
-0.5346123576164246,
-0.45994246006011963,
0.21856434643268585,
-0.22605036199092865,
0.7077603340148926,
0.015505603514611721,
0.3955349028110504,
-0.3643597960472107,
-0.18318933248519897,
-0.4699428081512451,
-0.6773302555084229,
-0.5158029198646545,
-0.3877338469028473,
0.23630981147289276,
0.3416122496128082,
0.8007166981697083,
0.4757225215435028,
0.8700966238975525,
0.40702515840530396,
-0.01558500062674284,
-0.08874976634979248,
-0.24919921159744263,
0.19364389777183533,
0.03820309787988663,
-0.874450147151947,
-0.06194804981350899,
-0.26617157459259033,
0.8965115547180176,
1.1146736145019531,
0.029541993513703346,
-0.005259966477751732,
-0.163267582654953,
0.6402590274810791,
-0.4557901918888092,
0.6967818140983582,
-0.5614010095596313,
-0.006014332640916109,
0.18065977096557617,
-0.08415742963552475,
-0.6205797791481018,
-0.5402818918228149,
0.1866578310728073,
-0.3568302094936371,
0.14411340653896332,
-0.06768815964460373,
0.5257341265678406,
0.34662359952926636,
-0.5762514472007751,
-0.47551867365837097,
-0.7751235365867615,
0.9139317870140076,
-0.8554063439369202,
0.34455230832099915,
0.6320733428001404,
0.10600586235523224,
0.09734705835580826,
-0.3424929976463318,
-0.3769916892051697,
-0.4389984607696533,
-0.3323996365070343,
-0.18941010534763336,
-0.2842244803905487,
-0.1484818160533905,
0.37784329056739807,
0.3641481399536133,
-0.6333509087562561,
0.04754585400223732,
-0.47660115361213684,
0.47402718663215637,
0.6956266164779663,
0.16284272074699402,
0.44914674758911133,
-0.05852304399013519,
0.07101911306381226,
-0.4423709213733673,
-0.7367397546768188,
0.11498276889324188,
0.16719366610050201,
0.37987056374549866,
-0.2450496405363083,
0.8680986762046814,
0.13134051859378815,
0.413944274187088,
-0.07719473540782928,
0.08569041639566422,
0.23858579993247986,
-0.035708729177713394,
-0.32454192638397217,
0.1441444605588913,
0.7615319490432739,
-0.2839403450489044,
0.5515111088752747,
-0.2199472337961197,
-0.17640379071235657,
0.1754136085510254,
0.35663869976997375,
-0.829954206943512,
-0.34431350231170654,
0.14215369522571564,
-0.4054160714149475,
-0.4104457497596741,
0.23571841418743134,
-0.3724709153175354,
-0.14035707712173462,
-0.6452056765556335,
0.21894489228725433,
-0.6554965972900391,
-0.3023427724838257,
0.16421765089035034,
-0.13198545575141907,
0.28189221024513245,
0.04682977870106697,
-1.1326104402542114,
0.4447254538536072,
1.1883723735809326,
0.5786967277526855,
0.2912200391292572,
0.01848386973142624,
0.07125840336084366,
-0.02932671830058098,
-0.7049295902252197,
0.78089839220047,
-0.7905295491218567,
-0.4579971432685852,
-0.08934717625379562,
-0.2986530363559723,
0.1059809997677803,
-0.5823507905006409,
0.18033431470394135,
-0.6862891912460327,
0.3346482217311859,
-0.15442833304405212,
-0.6386197805404663,
-0.32948485016822815,
0.06439071148633957,
-0.7741064429283142,
0.840132474899292,
-0.03328162804245949,
-0.6375251412391663,
0.19934003055095673,
-0.6263608932495117,
0.0013032149290665984,
0.08711456507444382,
-0.44451838731765747,
-0.45673394203186035,
0.6806776523590088,
0.10067465156316757,
0.25342807173728943,
-0.4114491045475006,
0.35523682832717896,
-0.5649599432945251,
-0.3116302788257599,
0.5028567910194397,
-0.5199346542358398,
1.084426999092102,
-0.09624632447957993,
0.03169426694512367,
-0.1404077112674713,
-0.7744854688644409,
0.06192867457866669,
0.08802343904972076,
0.024257056415081024,
-0.8987146019935608,
-0.16498684883117676,
-0.5146593451499939,
-0.010918991640210152,
0.1672830581665039,
-0.3310771882534027,
0.5096824765205383,
-0.5929357409477234,
0.2569713890552521,
0.44295787811279297,
0.022765938192605972,
0.9897857308387756,
-0.04969468712806702,
0.48887407779693604,
-0.1664048731327057,
-0.2786875367164612,
-0.44144243001937866,
-0.7693111896514893,
-0.7369651198387146,
-0.10257210582494736,
0.3581053614616394,
0.4768030345439911,
-0.5612277984619141,
0.2846960127353668,
-0.5224981904029846,
-0.3899504244327545,
-0.6311506628990173,
-0.04836453124880791,
0.17135196924209595,
0.19545011222362518,
0.06982306391000748,
-0.02165839448571205,
-0.17733439803123474,
-0.9277800917625427,
0.025303512811660767,
-0.4195393919944763,
-0.4536260664463043,
-0.001148114213719964,
0.6905837655067444,
0.10244783014059067,
1.0231447219848633,
-0.37445107102394104,
0.09001604467630386,
0.10458429902791977,
0.681966245174408,
0.41949015855789185,
0.3467486500740051,
0.544182538986206,
-0.7991576790809631,
-0.5603470206260681,
0.2112036943435669,
-1.1906296014785767,
-0.2287794053554535,
-0.07550850510597229,
-0.04288520663976669,
-0.04462885484099388,
0.3271205723285675,
-0.44124892354011536,
0.685725748538971,
0.34634843468666077,
-0.42793935537338257,
0.18365368247032166,
-0.4134065508842468,
-0.18659499287605286,
-0.7086623311042786,
-0.07779625058174133,
0.244125634431839,
0.09099876135587692,
-0.8080565333366394,
-0.00540207652375102,
0.1443602591753006,
-0.14644844830036163,
-0.05650915950536728,
0.3818649649620056,
-0.5254327654838562,
-0.25420793890953064,
-0.366012841463089,
-0.21062323451042175,
0.1349027007818222,
0.33555400371551514,
0.41021350026130676,
0.6628048419952393,
0.26710742712020874,
-0.35219505429267883,
-0.06716753542423248,
0.2905679941177368,
-0.41138750314712524,
0.5148239135742188,
-0.9447048902511597,
0.034371666610240936,
-0.6841171979904175,
-0.14674311876296997,
-1.043212652206421,
0.22509294748306274,
0.10832168906927109,
-0.46315866708755493,
0.3564319610595703,
-0.34306585788726807,
-0.6240741610527039,
-0.027388354763388634,
-0.010451399721205235,
0.5728831887245178,
0.39245545864105225,
-0.25173723697662354,
0.8661019206047058,
0.45606592297554016,
-0.47035545110702515,
-0.29951784014701843,
-0.5611404776573181,
-0.24770201742649078,
-0.39124491810798645,
-0.6426782608032227,
0.3558122217655182,
-0.025713887065649033,
-0.9839890003204346,
0.07791450619697571,
0.3304813802242279,
-0.46464595198631287,
-0.0715838074684143,
0.32943278551101685,
0.3505829870700836,
-0.5795586109161377,
0.4182004928588867,
-0.01570015586912632,
-0.2310371994972229,
0.44109001755714417,
0.27072638273239136,
0.43235132098197937,
-0.5446445941925049,
-0.2525854706764221,
-0.3176804482936859,
0.42440250515937805,
0.4583168625831604,
-0.18020573258399963,
0.8637687563896179,
0.15300939977169037,
-0.45351341366767883,
-0.1929183006286621,
-0.21531137824058533,
-0.38367193937301636,
-0.47325199842453003,
0.22274884581565857,
-0.5485605001449585,
-0.6163463592529297,
0.5105802416801453,
0.19738590717315674,
0.13203231990337372,
0.4949429929256439,
0.6517196297645569,
-0.09120359271764755,
1.3166176080703735,
0.7144519686698914,
0.16919147968292236,
0.3499693274497986,
-0.6147186160087585,
0.3022947609424591,
-0.65623939037323,
-0.2715380787849426,
-0.7648305296897888,
-0.08839881420135498,
-0.5269337892532349,
-0.43506067991256714,
0.3938174545764923,
0.19333292543888092,
-0.8138388991355896,
0.2935691475868225,
-0.3510717749595642,
0.663282036781311,
0.4760039746761322,
-0.30522242188453674,
0.3847370147705078,
-0.007579594850540161,
-0.0031658452935516834,
-0.3805081844329834,
-0.6491618752479553,
-0.6637409925460815,
1.010812520980835,
0.5907565951347351,
0.6459895372390747,
0.21250790357589722,
0.3735433518886566,
-0.21596422791481018,
0.9386031031608582,
-0.6921996474266052,
0.18476629257202148,
-0.21847973763942719,
-0.6377630233764648,
-0.36607086658477783,
-0.7922167181968689,
-0.7858403921127319,
0.6103724241256714,
-0.0747932568192482,
-0.543770432472229,
0.6197219491004944,
-0.2995028793811798,
-0.3905792236328125,
0.16006101667881012,
-0.6838008165359497,
0.7403351664543152,
-0.5104646682739258,
0.06008215621113777,
-0.13906186819076538,
-0.3659195005893707,
0.6713595390319824,
-0.2110508382320404,
0.3932890295982361,
-0.1955234408378601,
-0.008605068549513817,
0.41684114933013916,
-0.4364781975746155,
1.0335228443145752,
0.23564690351486206,
-0.4534078538417816,
0.21665075421333313,
0.3586099445819855,
0.043485261499881744,
0.2422073632478714,
-0.269349068403244,
0.4231865108013153,
0.09659155458211899,
-0.16830499470233917,
-1.0034233331680298,
0.48427122831344604,
-0.9253228902816772,
-0.10301576554775238,
-0.6386094093322754,
-0.5564053058624268,
-0.1259065419435501,
-0.05780789256095886,
-0.09815391898155212,
0.5594251751899719,
-0.045583173632621765,
0.5016496181488037,
0.6672664880752563,
-0.1803530603647232,
0.43482860922813416,
0.6607285737991333,
-0.2965693771839142,
-0.6354209184646606,
0.7179210186004639,
0.11614937335252762,
0.08410076797008514,
0.8518399596214294,
0.30162373185157776,
-0.2942221462726593,
-0.03311530128121376,
-0.1286909133195877,
0.6200742721557617,
-0.758112370967865,
-0.23717285692691803,
-0.32302865386009216,
-0.13783369958400726,
-0.2875353991985321,
-0.06317590177059174,
-0.27911242842674255,
-0.5771608948707581,
-0.3993226885795593,
-0.014922767877578735,
0.1941879838705063,
1.1170933246612549,
-0.03740018233656883,
0.5879639387130737,
-0.7679360508918762,
0.2745721936225891,
0.4658683240413666,
0.2421366572380066,
0.19495591521263123,
-0.5774080157279968,
-0.10916263610124588,
0.17097662389278412,
-0.23357784748077393,
-0.9113686680793762,
0.7756877541542053,
0.009522021748125553,
0.3994869291782379,
0.7014535665512085,
-0.12231076508760452,
0.49273234605789185,
-0.5836098790168762,
0.37367624044418335,
-0.02990543283522129,
-1.045261263847351,
0.0940336138010025,
-0.11133813858032227,
0.40781107544898987,
0.5209066271781921,
0.6888760924339294,
-0.3570996820926666,
-0.12404125183820724,
-0.5916393399238586,
-0.5589513778686523,
0.3970123529434204,
0.31162092089653015,
0.18896038830280304,
-0.1719052493572235,
0.2937820553779602,
0.07292616367340088,
0.32586047053337097,
-0.6960030794143677,
-0.2972981929779053,
-0.12052106857299805,
-0.4323889911174774,
0.08747819066047668,
-0.2815488278865814,
0.0782870426774025,
-0.23368243873119354,
0.48656976222991943,
-0.1570589393377304,
0.42732948064804077,
-0.39374446868896484,
0.06847753375768661,
0.01423106249421835,
-0.038138486444950104,
0.4299711287021637,
0.9656028747558594,
-0.2839290499687195,
0.1519971787929535,
-0.04903500899672508,
-0.03870074823498726,
0.07157818228006363,
-0.08784084767103195,
-0.1603046953678131,
0.13002020120620728,
0.5619915127754211,
0.6617717146873474,
0.7082408666610718,
-0.5228056311607361,
0.39346495270729065,
-0.26005837321281433,
-0.03063354641199112,
-0.6245551705360413,
-0.39810246229171753,
-0.03149953484535217,
0.1286703199148178,
0.383940726518631,
-0.24806587398052216,
0.0761885792016983,
-0.6458673477172852,
0.2370198518037796,
0.5494725108146667,
-0.2582947909832001,
-0.6015350818634033,
0.38262414932250977,
-0.17152848839759827,
-0.41436463594436646,
0.8755443096160889,
0.0682610273361206,
-0.45221996307373047,
0.7878046035766602,
0.4634474515914917,
0.8290038108825684,
-0.2789958119392395,
0.44951826333999634,
0.2840060889720917,
0.46628791093826294,
-0.12595109641551971,
0.2849786877632141,
0.03986029326915741,
-1.056265115737915,
-0.7416281700134277,
-0.3460599482059479,
-0.5663569569587708,
-0.0395941361784935,
-0.7158430814743042,
0.26930537819862366,
-0.34397628903388977,
-0.1599174290895462,
0.3514769971370697,
-0.2970152795314789,
-0.7399492263793945,
0.036287520080804825,
0.4625691771507263,
0.5691221952438354,
-1.0151883363723755,
0.6095466613769531,
0.4760058522224426,
-0.7408949136734009,
-0.595259428024292,
-0.46363627910614014,
-0.39093172550201416,
-0.9457935094833374,
1.1634858846664429,
0.10001304745674133,
0.20017707347869873,
-0.19254793226718903,
-0.7109749913215637,
-1.0591353178024292,
0.677876353263855,
0.2683910131454468,
-0.353272408246994,
-0.3039252758026123,
0.5933926701545715,
0.7507805228233337,
-0.5244055986404419,
0.6641901135444641,
0.353488028049469,
0.44120869040489197,
0.07318156212568283,
-0.5547294616699219,
-0.3986692428588867,
-0.3607610762119293,
0.2767273783683777,
0.2947007417678833,
-0.3364059627056122,
1.0232099294662476,
-0.0014322634087875485,
-0.12699483335018158,
-0.05186845734715462,
0.8559950590133667,
0.3626875877380371,
0.22927545011043549,
0.2311292439699173,
0.7720283269882202,
0.572523832321167,
-0.026111062616109848,
1.0352587699890137,
-0.5097883343696594,
0.4320625960826874,
0.9870456457138062,
-0.17542904615402222,
1.001003623008728,
0.3327428996562958,
-0.32639238238334656,
0.7813828587532043,
0.14110268652439117,
0.033079855144023895,
0.5653795599937439,
0.2931670844554901,
-0.29805558919906616,
-0.24210554361343384,
0.24421392381191254,
-0.2836318910121918,
0.45479363203048706,
0.7331532835960388,
-0.5554583072662354,
-0.21817496418952942,
-0.07877662777900696,
-0.032562822103500366,
0.005677016917616129,
-0.38140812516212463,
0.9583426117897034,
0.5289583802223206,
-0.34902331233024597,
0.3838656544685364,
0.03902888298034668,
0.17493605613708496,
-0.5064517855644226,
-0.39956745505332947,
-0.10831581056118011,
0.23466087877750397,
0.1607002317905426,
-0.7797160148620605,
0.4262003004550934,
-0.1916033923625946,
-0.09319061785936356,
-0.4466847777366638,
0.2481735348701477,
-0.5235609412193298,
-1.016893982887268,
-0.16837596893310547,
0.37842458486557007,
0.19692841172218323,
-0.20979836583137512,
-0.46886417269706726,
0.021911602467298508,
-0.25423669815063477,
0.05803902447223663,
0.09387661516666412,
1.060287594795227,
-0.1150190532207489,
0.6857307553291321,
0.5276991128921509,
0.0011790902353823185,
0.02428392879664898,
0.14405813813209534,
0.6210862398147583,
-0.6558688282966614,
-0.39674586057662964,
-0.906507670879364,
0.48416486382484436,
-0.006399000994861126,
-0.2656525671482086,
0.833057165145874,
0.48085564374923706,
0.6951338052749634,
-0.1683264821767807,
0.6732441782951355,
0.4271775484085083,
0.31733545660972595,
-0.23408852517604828,
0.37509098649024963,
-0.07139676809310913,
0.2891484498977661,
-0.013312614522874355,
-1.0025564432144165,
-0.6915852427482605,
1.135259747505188,
-0.8002111911773682,
-0.17866764962673187,
0.5279428958892822,
0.4589092433452606,
0.03286929056048393,
0.4011472761631012,
0.27158793807029724,
0.09191714227199554,
0.3271273076534271,
0.31072998046875,
0.8975441455841064,
-0.3716879189014435,
0.11215153336524963,
-0.5711846947669983,
-0.14387758076190948,
-0.02345576137304306,
-0.790282666683197,
-1.0504192113876343,
-0.41848528385162354,
-0.21882356703281403,
-0.05737249180674553,
-0.36849096417427063,
0.8248143792152405,
0.3533816337585449,
-0.9207165241241455,
-0.48955950140953064,
-0.13542810082435608,
0.08120369166135788,
0.10437650233507156,
-0.27202996611595154,
0.38616514205932617,
-0.18658015131950378,
-0.7286298871040344,
0.35576772689819336,
0.2524489164352417,
0.29521048069000244,
-0.6600051522254944,
0.3398491442203522,
0.3237606883049011,
0.27212175726890564,
0.6263764500617981,
0.20481115579605103,
-0.4510944187641144,
-0.0023681086022406816,
0.0938650593161583,
0.03468410298228264,
0.1368333101272583,
1.08579683303833,
-0.9595561027526855,
0.31123360991477966,
0.746674656867981,
0.5760827660560608,
0.3636048436164856,
0.18885095417499542,
0.9396579265594482,
-0.48458588123321533,
0.05120887607336044,
0.4708063304424286,
0.419249564409256,
0.3952348232269287,
0.04718119278550148,
0.4772164225578308,
-0.16367582976818085,
-0.48432230949401855,
-0.9617853164672852,
-0.0074384273029863834,
-0.53850257396698,
-0.3484576642513275,
0.9919028878211975,
0.04748496785759926,
-0.3576081693172455,
0.02300085686147213,
0.03112945333123207,
-0.15772080421447754,
-0.3263344168663025,
0.9723199605941772,
0.6489720344543457,
0.07625603675842285,
-0.2842812240123749,
-0.4557344913482666,
0.2823999524116516,
0.1659843474626541,
-0.6720786690711975,
-0.1035250797867775,
0.09162069857120514,
0.07301228493452072,
0.5120970606803894,
0.4085349440574646,
-0.21982698142528534,
-0.17902150750160217,
0.005027445964515209,
0.13540713489055634,
0.2541673481464386,
-0.38128241896629333,
-0.6887447834014893,
0.3453177511692047,
-0.14066825807094574,
0.2681643068790436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16563v1
|
Evaluating Large Language Models on Time Series Feature Understanding: A Comprehensive Taxonomy and Benchmark
| 2024-04-25T12:24:37 | 2024-04-25T12:24:37 |
Elizabeth Fons, Rachneet Kaur, Soham Palande, Zhen Zeng, Svitlana Vyetrenko, Tucker Balch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) offer the potential for automatic time series
analysis and reporting, which is a critical task across many domains, spanning
healthcare, finance, climate, energy, and many more. In this paper, we propose
a framework for rigorously evaluating the capabilities of LLMs on time series
understanding, encompassing both univariate and multivariate forms. We
introduce a comprehensive taxonomy of time series features, a critical
framework that delineates various characteristics inherent in time series data.
Leveraging this taxonomy, we have systematically designed and synthesized a
diverse dataset of time series, embodying the different outlined features. This
dataset acts as a solid foundation for assessing the proficiency of LLMs in
comprehending time series. Our experiments shed light on the strengths and
limitations of state-of-the-art LLMs in time series understanding, revealing
which features these models readily comprehend effectively and where they
falter. In addition, we uncover the sensitivity of LLMs to factors including
the formatting of the data, the position of points queried within a series and
the overall time series length.
|
[
-0.22461169958114624,
-0.5527297258377075,
0.7104616761207581,
0.28588926792144775,
-0.22753791511058807,
0.45594266057014465,
-0.42952463030815125,
-0.38323312997817993,
-0.011211804114282131,
0.5281543731689453,
-0.4223121404647827,
-0.5987980365753174,
-0.6833208799362183,
0.07324790209531784,
-0.6895400881767273,
0.8548631072044373,
-0.19502197206020355,
-0.036680854856967926,
-0.06352926790714264,
-0.22895115613937378,
-0.10037427395582199,
-0.5501855611801147,
-0.1734195202589035,
-0.5456730127334595,
0.4240387976169586,
-0.03978710621595383,
0.6938195824623108,
0.6284949779510498,
0.6564769148826599,
0.2819570004940033,
-0.10400635749101639,
0.1030644029378891,
-0.5057638883590698,
0.168653205037117,
0.0826575756072998,
-0.21169568598270416,
-0.47271788120269775,
-0.12404364347457886,
0.9157000780105591,
1.1985899209976196,
-0.12514404952526093,
0.6331023573875427,
0.2259887307882309,
0.29538992047309875,
-0.42720627784729004,
0.5161716341972351,
-0.5283951163291931,
-0.005660234019160271,
-0.25405654311180115,
-0.2858659327030182,
-0.23746447265148163,
-0.04376178979873657,
0.296321839094162,
-0.34348607063293457,
0.31157028675079346,
0.17584334313869476,
0.6463377475738525,
0.3457537591457367,
-0.6296148300170898,
0.10476146638393402,
-0.9126116633415222,
0.9596849679946899,
-0.7546360492706299,
0.3166983127593994,
0.000778784800786525,
0.6238921880722046,
0.06705804914236069,
-0.6329527497291565,
-0.39836329221725464,
-0.08396422863006592,
-0.025650324299931526,
-0.1212453544139862,
-0.18727664649486542,
-0.17273937165737152,
0.375773161649704,
0.7069117426872253,
-0.6193243861198425,
0.30132928490638733,
0.02800692990422249,
-0.08751126378774643,
0.5020560622215271,
0.5381669998168945,
-0.09630211442708969,
-0.286930650472641,
-0.3398517072200775,
-0.0550980344414711,
-0.40066251158714294,
-0.028281649574637413,
0.2844344973564148,
0.5676303505897522,
-0.328107088804245,
0.5070532560348511,
-0.08048193901777267,
0.45528408885002136,
-0.644754946231842,
-0.28678950667381287,
0.22932344675064087,
-0.3469627797603607,
-0.5409349799156189,
-0.2524147927761078,
0.5821278095245361,
0.2702728509902954,
0.22798335552215576,
-0.3011806011199951,
-0.2530776560306549,
-0.14880283176898956,
-0.058143120259046555,
-0.8844678997993469,
0.03903338685631752,
0.19541890919208527,
-0.601114809513092,
-0.1819027066230774,
-0.06518673151731491,
-0.7884128093719482,
-0.5706689953804016,
-0.7003278732299805,
0.12447567284107208,
-0.10973896086215973,
-0.2918919026851654,
0.16416139900684357,
-0.07506189495325089,
0.4057551324367523,
0.2664083242416382,
-0.8444408774375916,
0.33280855417251587,
1.0093538761138916,
0.9206799268722534,
-0.11715999990701675,
-0.25731781125068665,
-0.4098607897758484,
0.08894969522953033,
-0.17416425049304962,
0.7267252206802368,
-0.6380923390388489,
-0.5362529754638672,
-0.06728409230709076,
0.013422776013612747,
0.00960824079811573,
-0.5139928460121155,
0.03486189991235733,
-0.5462256669998169,
-0.20871540904045105,
-0.3017546832561493,
-0.5165857672691345,
-0.3680410385131836,
0.2654080390930176,
-0.624862015247345,
0.7927117347717285,
0.19138216972351074,
-0.611057460308075,
0.5331183671951294,
-0.63700270652771,
-0.3059230446815491,
-0.20295284688472748,
-0.1045067310333252,
-0.3026888072490692,
0.016496455296874046,
0.3081654906272888,
0.7106679081916809,
-0.6463121771812439,
0.5806422829627991,
-0.7126856446266174,
0.09866061806678772,
0.4862889051437378,
-0.798554539680481,
0.44709834456443787,
0.2569868564605713,
-0.08143119513988495,
0.2950425446033478,
-0.8927947878837585,
-0.12101999670267105,
0.10094388574361801,
0.091776043176651,
-0.20956189930438995,
0.2538660168647766,
0.4865269958972931,
-0.2801244258880615,
0.19390565156936646,
-0.2414456158876419,
0.28283873200416565,
-0.10512588173151016,
0.8476159572601318,
0.7431732416152954,
0.08028987795114517,
0.03506694361567497,
-0.20513832569122314,
0.7066904902458191,
-0.06987651437520981,
0.3508981466293335,
-0.5248238444328308,
-0.0550386905670166,
-0.4955364763736725,
-0.3876509964466095,
0.12829884886741638,
0.5806329846382141,
-0.3930980861186981,
0.35706135630607605,
-0.5185904502868652,
-0.48424357175827026,
-0.09037764370441437,
0.34166038036346436,
0.20818839967250824,
0.3746754229068756,
0.2676108181476593,
-0.32083413004875183,
-0.3632761538028717,
-0.7688888907432556,
-0.13587090373039246,
-0.1423926204442978,
-0.20951208472251892,
0.2366090565919876,
0.533107340335846,
-0.15855520963668823,
0.7688707113265991,
-0.600432813167572,
0.2965845763683319,
-0.3077293634414673,
0.30816078186035156,
0.3076343536376953,
-0.12075243890285492,
0.6388007998466492,
-0.5930858850479126,
0.0016584754921495914,
-0.005066735669970512,
-0.740395188331604,
-0.0018633230356499553,
-0.14782409369945526,
0.3498762845993042,
-0.0634690523147583,
0.48412758111953735,
-0.1860436201095581,
0.3916783630847931,
0.5658795833587646,
-0.3684076964855194,
0.4786098301410675,
-0.043625589460134506,
0.04911548271775246,
-1.0472463369369507,
0.48438119888305664,
0.29288971424102783,
-0.24144650995731354,
-0.4746871292591095,
-0.15050631761550903,
-0.050359684973955154,
-0.17688065767288208,
-0.242608442902565,
0.674976110458374,
-0.3605377674102783,
-0.5255048871040344,
0.010123328305780888,
-0.1576327383518219,
0.19708870351314545,
0.1326015144586563,
-0.12859763205051422,
0.5716670751571655,
0.3876158595085144,
-0.4973643124103546,
0.495012104511261,
0.05877982825040817,
-0.8674298524856567,
0.23707957565784454,
-0.6600057482719421,
-0.06481610983610153,
-0.13593189418315887,
-0.045900627970695496,
-0.9660321474075317,
-0.2690597176551819,
-0.3399128317832947,
-0.16633319854736328,
0.44410398602485657,
-0.08431032299995422,
-0.7523773908615112,
-0.28049686551094055,
-0.1492355912923813,
0.2784949541091919,
0.1397983878850937,
-0.5550172328948975,
0.6284922957420349,
0.3445526361465454,
-0.1991661638021469,
-0.6393061280250549,
-0.47240927815437317,
0.12742817401885986,
-0.6236089468002319,
-0.42124730348587036,
0.1980474442243576,
-0.060709282755851746,
-0.8009851574897766,
-0.22148796916007996,
-0.14088524878025055,
0.06843167543411255,
0.6252298355102539,
0.06079326942563057,
0.3950842022895813,
-0.4237164556980133,
0.20930279791355133,
-0.4017432928085327,
-0.12565071880817413,
0.060298290103673935,
-0.07766511291265488,
0.5733130574226379,
-0.2527765929698944,
-0.516024112701416,
-0.20958290994167328,
0.16461136937141418,
0.8895952105522156,
-0.32231414318084717,
0.541893482208252,
0.5701003670692444,
-0.27936413884162903,
-0.2876678705215454,
-0.3877502679824829,
-0.00967924203723669,
-0.42719754576683044,
0.5313277840614319,
-0.17613916099071503,
-0.9949120283126831,
0.8547728061676025,
-0.03382626175880432,
0.2021201252937317,
0.42911049723625183,
0.6308721899986267,
0.21042315661907196,
0.7312432527542114,
0.7383410334587097,
-0.3894687294960022,
0.26034584641456604,
-0.2715228497982025,
0.38734206557273865,
-0.8603697419166565,
-0.4416689872741699,
-0.5651715993881226,
-0.1998482048511505,
-0.4767935276031494,
-0.2991401255130768,
0.39904800057411194,
-0.14399805665016174,
-0.4792863726615906,
-0.02368190512061119,
-0.03235375136137009,
0.29029813408851624,
-0.051225461065769196,
-0.14891959726810455,
0.3747115731239319,
-0.10795880109071732,
0.23156824707984924,
0.05338580906391144,
-0.21794894337654114,
-0.7212113738059998,
1.3069074153900146,
0.7483598589897156,
1.1157084703445435,
0.27992549538612366,
0.09794807434082031,
0.5112944841384888,
0.3688669800758362,
-1.075473427772522,
0.3207348585128784,
-0.43473756313323975,
-0.2131621390581131,
-0.3754831552505493,
-0.4028264880180359,
-0.813949465751648,
0.09331347048282623,
-0.0554988719522953,
-0.544722855091095,
0.058602847158908844,
-0.05126763880252838,
-0.5755046010017395,
0.5343148112297058,
-0.6009756326675415,
0.8997824192047119,
-0.6117605566978455,
-0.10588214546442032,
-0.19238585233688354,
-0.28217577934265137,
0.2663130462169647,
-0.14669504761695862,
0.2362501174211502,
-0.49062541127204895,
-0.24279607832431793,
0.5736974477767944,
-0.2955178916454315,
0.9903311729431152,
0.08971738815307617,
-0.1359572410583496,
-0.049073006957769394,
0.05497908592224121,
-0.17696693539619446,
0.25043201446533203,
-0.25983643531799316,
0.4070166349411011,
0.2507072389125824,
-0.47334182262420654,
-0.5939109325408936,
0.5876786708831787,
-0.7702769637107849,
-0.5338639616966248,
-0.506351113319397,
-0.6324058771133423,
-0.4163932502269745,
0.02862510085105896,
-0.25878849625587463,
0.6775315403938293,
-0.5413406491279602,
0.17676445841789246,
0.5169280767440796,
-0.1853448450565338,
0.5928809642791748,
0.610348641872406,
-0.5984739065170288,
-0.19770990312099457,
0.6443239450454712,
0.13597726821899414,
0.3451952040195465,
0.5422964096069336,
0.31888216733932495,
-0.5205361843109131,
-0.7924915552139282,
-0.2840732932090759,
0.23583237826824188,
-0.8971073627471924,
0.05674804002046585,
-0.31409555673599243,
-0.20458802580833435,
-0.42630141973495483,
0.20516884326934814,
-0.04799945279955864,
-0.25488778948783875,
-0.46972569823265076,
-0.09863635897636414,
0.6239238381385803,
1.0276601314544678,
0.4587629735469818,
0.3442195653915405,
-0.9309282302856445,
0.18851929903030396,
0.3381962180137634,
0.5270499587059021,
0.24774114787578583,
-0.6125768423080444,
-0.08291865885257721,
-0.5127276182174683,
-0.32648253440856934,
-0.44095003604888916,
0.6556482911109924,
0.25768327713012695,
0.737478494644165,
0.6833131909370422,
-0.19853346049785614,
0.699529230594635,
-0.4653901755809784,
0.907737672328949,
-0.03650684282183647,
-1.1851799488067627,
0.3363363742828369,
-0.4229183495044708,
0.27365007996559143,
0.16557662189006805,
0.34303003549575806,
-0.740234375,
-0.03035680390894413,
-0.46851497888565063,
-0.864906907081604,
0.2905598282814026,
-0.14985987544059753,
0.09474644064903259,
0.22663608193397522,
0.42126813530921936,
0.2710365951061249,
0.515002429485321,
-0.347660094499588,
-0.20083889365196228,
-0.22901077568531036,
-0.1284179985523224,
-0.705704927444458,
-0.1528334617614746,
-0.25984835624694824,
-0.006099080666899681,
0.16923359036445618,
-0.3047546148300171,
-0.15207985043525696,
-0.05252226069569588,
-0.009279315359890461,
0.11979888379573822,
0.4799535870552063,
0.43640315532684326,
1.1033176183700562,
-0.3199467062950134,
0.08639787137508392,
0.11522258818149567,
-0.19662074744701385,
-0.18700383603572845,
0.24867306649684906,
0.22795051336288452,
-0.0656590685248375,
0.8000602126121521,
0.9184340238571167,
0.23367741703987122,
-0.6527076363563538,
0.12087052315473557,
0.006096031051129103,
0.2379186600446701,
-0.35854411125183105,
-0.02748647704720497,
-0.008665010333061218,
0.3613755702972412,
0.37769120931625366,
-0.1726415455341339,
0.16660551726818085,
-0.7148826718330383,
0.015548212453722954,
0.3652026951313019,
-0.009682922624051571,
-0.47956714034080505,
0.4374203681945801,
0.08662619441747665,
0.15153144299983978,
0.5008972883224487,
0.16462935507297516,
-0.5201314687728882,
0.931847333908081,
0.1784716099500656,
0.8374940752983093,
-0.1355285942554474,
-0.0810631811618805,
0.17949560284614563,
0.4173085689544678,
-0.08594289422035217,
0.3056457042694092,
0.022634530439972878,
-0.6154230237007141,
-0.7280693650245667,
-0.8755304217338562,
-0.7333552837371826,
0.6096658110618591,
-0.8152089715003967,
0.27005863189697266,
-0.6644514799118042,
-0.2621842920780182,
0.4569860100746155,
-0.027507394552230835,
-0.7909082770347595,
-0.03799181431531906,
0.35233116149902344,
1.0481162071228027,
-1.044174075126648,
0.6520043015480042,
0.4901653528213501,
-0.017740609124302864,
-0.5355254411697388,
0.05272505432367325,
0.37408748269081116,
-1.1332684755325317,
0.5758965015411377,
0.2322605699300766,
-0.0831088274717331,
-0.3484713137149811,
-0.3176080882549286,
-0.8822506666183472,
1.1413198709487915,
0.29497355222702026,
-0.642930269241333,
0.13720032572746277,
0.2479054480791092,
0.5599451065063477,
-0.4658109247684479,
0.42663100361824036,
0.8901262879371643,
0.5468831658363342,
-0.07229796797037125,
-1.1265908479690552,
-0.1523042470216751,
-0.17388401925563812,
0.2657107710838318,
0.4088808596134186,
-0.7987222075462341,
0.7208347320556641,
-0.25846433639526367,
-0.06495508551597595,
0.08668863028287888,
0.7156186699867249,
-0.24853189289569855,
0.5509285926818848,
0.5264660120010376,
0.32678791880607605,
0.9384400844573975,
-0.11694904416799545,
1.0743167400360107,
-0.29388850927352905,
0.6074320673942566,
0.9288596510887146,
-0.5388273596763611,
0.8566592931747437,
0.2986075282096863,
-0.5177907943725586,
0.2967182993888855,
0.8058174252510071,
-0.30465710163116455,
0.1483585685491562,
0.4604099690914154,
-0.18150706589221954,
-0.5659515857696533,
-0.14777785539627075,
-0.23076412081718445,
0.5950652956962585,
0.6138162016868591,
-0.37405359745025635,
-0.3624981939792633,
0.06139063462615013,
0.03981031849980354,
0.07339788228273392,
-0.43699535727500916,
0.49916285276412964,
0.3021326959133148,
-0.3363567590713501,
0.3366539180278778,
-0.19663433730602264,
0.466287761926651,
-0.8191824555397034,
0.16158582270145416,
-0.022268669679760933,
0.1306755095720291,
-0.1744837611913681,
-1.122772455215454,
0.47411850094795227,
0.22108598053455353,
-0.3435329794883728,
-0.18030577898025513,
0.1344783902168274,
-0.018712656572461128,
-0.6684897541999817,
0.3588317036628723,
0.3731426000595093,
0.08398725837469101,
0.1338571012020111,
-0.5836617946624756,
0.33296850323677063,
-0.20145900547504425,
-0.28191983699798584,
0.21743445098400116,
0.4164121747016907,
-0.0040110996924340725,
0.8421475887298584,
0.5394168496131897,
0.09078020602464676,
-0.3225231468677521,
0.6317850351333618,
0.5107896327972412,
-0.881310760974884,
-0.3468305766582489,
-0.9310027956962585,
0.23790405690670013,
0.14966940879821777,
-0.1801692694425583,
0.6894297003746033,
0.533979058265686,
0.5859586596488953,
0.19664211571216583,
0.9668272733688354,
0.2805405855178833,
0.5864348411560059,
-0.7961316108703613,
0.5952033996582031,
-0.6474965810775757,
0.6905297040939331,
0.14516915380954742,
-0.8288249373435974,
-0.38810837268829346,
0.04606268182396889,
-0.6147488951683044,
0.09512286633253098,
0.4258388876914978,
0.42721426486968994,
-0.07683547586202621,
0.18930953741073608,
0.3192274868488312,
0.4469241499900818,
0.5141333341598511,
0.27076640725135803,
0.9279550313949585,
0.14268948137760162,
0.4395197927951813,
-0.1644342690706253,
-0.261822372674942,
-0.17127208411693573,
-1.3231772184371948,
-1.0095635652542114,
-0.44474759697914124,
-0.22239860892295837,
-0.3325369656085968,
-0.3749142289161682,
0.9119635820388794,
0.4975284934043884,
-0.9040735363960266,
-0.4561425447463989,
0.5761324763298035,
-0.08263520896434784,
-0.0629647746682167,
-0.2227468192577362,
0.623199999332428,
-0.2252040058374405,
-0.6046032905578613,
0.3799906075000763,
0.44959184527397156,
-0.008023054338991642,
-0.7541632056236267,
0.19521775841712952,
0.4957693815231323,
-0.026275962591171265,
0.755160927772522,
0.2270631641149521,
-0.6789405345916748,
-0.2412520945072174,
0.245650053024292,
0.23080933094024658,
-0.003098491346463561,
1.139528751373291,
-0.44047003984451294,
0.4441892206668854,
0.4354700446128845,
0.6270363926887512,
0.3082778751850128,
-0.28781381249427795,
0.3450729548931122,
-0.36572301387786865,
-0.03739133104681969,
0.16608861088752747,
0.7227551937103271,
0.5321706533432007,
-0.25956544280052185,
0.19113489985466003,
0.25245141983032227,
-0.5882794260978699,
-0.8227431774139404,
0.1373562216758728,
-1.2808821201324463,
-0.3207225799560547,
1.037259578704834,
-0.14872756600379944,
-0.20709222555160522,
-0.23087015748023987,
0.26620495319366455,
0.02565840817987919,
-0.28459927439689636,
0.7224544286727905,
0.8134679198265076,
-0.2161032110452652,
0.0526430681347847,
-0.8364999294281006,
0.05052516236901283,
0.19441498816013336,
-0.7266842722892761,
0.4441755414009094,
0.3082696199417114,
0.5053591728210449,
0.047068264335393906,
0.030860988423228264,
-0.15577369928359985,
-0.14152731001377106,
-0.4329581558704376,
-0.16305044293403625,
-0.03661307319998741,
-0.3373083472251892,
-0.6749569177627563,
0.03358101472258568,
0.3306555151939392,
0.21577870845794678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16905v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16905v1
|
Samsung Research China-Beijing at SemEval-2024 Task 3: A multi-stage framework for Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction in Conversations
| 2024-04-25T11:52:21 | 2024-04-25T11:52:21 |
Shen Zhang, Haojie Zhang, Jing Zhang, Xudong Zhang, Yimeng Zhuang, Jinting Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In human-computer interaction, it is crucial for agents to respond to human
by understanding their emotions. Unraveling the causes of emotions is more
challenging. A new task named Multimodal Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction in
Conversations is responsible for recognizing emotion and identifying causal
expressions. In this study, we propose a multi-stage framework to generate
emotion and extract the emotion causal pairs given the target emotion. In the
first stage, Llama-2-based InstructERC is utilized to extract the emotion
category of each utterance in a conversation. After emotion recognition, a
two-stream attention model is employed to extract the emotion causal pairs
given the target emotion for subtask 2 while MuTEC is employed to extract
causal span for subtask 1. Our approach achieved first place for both of the
two subtasks in the competition.
|
[
-0.35168591141700745,
-0.9192252159118652,
0.38723471760749817,
0.6068935990333557,
-0.29322054982185364,
-0.13254937529563904,
0.1442774534225464,
-0.5889201760292053,
0.40463295578956604,
0.22807882726192474,
-0.9476922750473022,
-0.059380508959293365,
-0.5378093719482422,
0.1015658751130104,
-0.1819511353969574,
0.9704120755195618,
-0.12240380048751831,
0.05997564271092415,
-0.0429438054561615,
-0.03794664144515991,
-0.6596930623054504,
-0.3871932327747345,
-0.9752141833305359,
-0.24077436327934265,
0.6713129281997681,
0.8373706936836243,
-0.014469903893768787,
0.04920274391770363,
0.492969810962677,
0.33771300315856934,
0.16560865938663483,
0.18921498954296112,
-0.5011599659919739,
0.5735662579536438,
0.25918903946876526,
-0.11802251636981964,
-0.6692154407501221,
0.057058583945035934,
0.25044122338294983,
-0.10565511882305145,
-0.22459949553012848,
0.25789281725883484,
0.1914527714252472,
0.5170434713363647,
-0.4963310956954956,
0.48750004172325134,
-0.5118372440338135,
0.08850367367267609,
-0.31674399971961975,
-0.5450636744499207,
-0.2490639090538025,
-0.031770989298820496,
-0.00025718510732986033,
-0.36867547035217285,
0.06401285529136658,
0.10259879380464554,
0.8405628204345703,
0.3466438353061676,
-0.7852247357368469,
-0.3420741558074951,
-0.3976229131221771,
0.6584495306015015,
-0.6422951221466064,
0.21425016224384308,
0.1278911978006363,
-0.0903635025024414,
-0.1871936172246933,
-0.514514684677124,
-0.6652028560638428,
0.09354723244905472,
0.06608763337135315,
0.5169677138328552,
-0.038662731647491455,
0.15813124179840088,
0.1999567598104477,
0.065110944211483,
-0.4601152837276459,
0.20300930738449097,
-0.40981101989746094,
-0.11273203790187836,
0.6591551899909973,
0.36244040727615356,
0.41233107447624207,
-0.6406007409095764,
-0.5020204186439514,
0.16022710502147675,
-0.7499717473983765,
0.17857150733470917,
0.4016115665435791,
0.18041862547397614,
-0.26404711604118347,
0.44272324442863464,
-0.11804039031267166,
0.1192047968506813,
0.15036547183990479,
-0.368643581867218,
0.16404689848423004,
-0.6215239763259888,
-0.1396741271018982,
0.28673022985458374,
0.7180396318435669,
0.3219243288040161,
-0.0639338344335556,
-0.02026922069489956,
0.17785759270191193,
0.22149766981601715,
0.20386575162410736,
-0.8185157775878906,
-0.032777849584817886,
0.6124885678291321,
-0.6595984697341919,
-0.46376264095306396,
-0.15718196332454681,
-1.3457095623016357,
-0.47326964139938354,
-0.24140049517154694,
0.5612952709197998,
0.24226583540439606,
-0.6259654760360718,
-0.2356291264295578,
-0.012303636409342289,
0.36362332105636597,
0.11735747009515762,
-0.8844742774963379,
0.2293572574853897,
0.5132128000259399,
0.5048103332519531,
-0.25641128420829773,
-0.04789436236023903,
-0.45393893122673035,
0.06694710999727249,
-0.15506833791732788,
0.8123319745063782,
-0.32770413160324097,
-0.18081475794315338,
-0.1094139888882637,
0.08146774023771286,
-0.1416054219007492,
-0.3604718744754791,
0.7964179515838623,
-0.38038480281829834,
0.32453715801239014,
-0.29686591029167175,
-0.24035435914993286,
-0.14117518067359924,
0.136541485786438,
-0.646446168422699,
1.090422511100769,
-0.2290399968624115,
-0.9021551012992859,
0.12161023169755936,
-0.7272295951843262,
-0.6792675852775574,
0.06346233189105988,
-0.10918337851762772,
-0.3147095739841461,
-0.19578418135643005,
0.14099831879138947,
0.7813851833343506,
-0.6518821716308594,
0.32723525166511536,
-0.4557100534439087,
-0.09024118632078171,
0.019114291295409203,
-0.2609293460845947,
0.39122122526168823,
0.10472346097230911,
-0.7801466584205627,
0.4489554464817047,
-0.8490080237388611,
-0.350731760263443,
0.23795856535434723,
-0.14628830552101135,
-0.190413698554039,
0.32287558913230896,
-0.09153030067682266,
0.7420939803123474,
0.12096201628446579,
-0.6798392534255981,
-0.35918620228767395,
-0.14145958423614502,
0.3428153991699219,
1.0325433015823364,
0.41213420033454895,
0.3099283277988434,
0.2108624130487442,
0.6583181023597717,
0.26016950607299805,
0.19825401902198792,
-0.4089577794075012,
-0.5736632347106934,
-0.9210739731788635,
-0.13751345872879028,
-0.2251596450805664,
0.6085965633392334,
-0.7765090465545654,
-0.013539887964725494,
0.317678838968277,
-0.30192145705223083,
-0.346205472946167,
0.10682502388954163,
0.5970904231071472,
0.8159732222557068,
0.12249953299760818,
0.04128243401646614,
-0.6928622722625732,
-0.7204369306564331,
0.017135344445705414,
-0.16177675127983093,
0.158949077129364,
0.6435924768447876,
0.2928823232650757,
-0.002591738710179925,
0.4811152517795563,
-0.4764980673789978,
-0.21066462993621826,
-0.27943623065948486,
0.27940282225608826,
-0.1680387258529663,
0.4851109981536865,
0.3001496195793152,
-0.8465532064437866,
-0.2549643814563751,
-0.16250789165496826,
-1.002576470375061,
-0.3219771087169647,
-0.20728176832199097,
-0.3760555386543274,
0.3316960632801056,
0.6368335485458374,
-0.44817447662353516,
0.5600351691246033,
0.5763570070266724,
-0.24403320252895355,
0.5396056175231934,
0.3080489933490753,
0.5466509461402893,
-1.1408133506774902,
-0.05212085694074631,
0.31009989976882935,
0.18563462793827057,
-0.753050684928894,
-0.43483951687812805,
-0.13892431557178497,
-0.08731736987829208,
-0.4310428500175476,
0.3868059813976288,
-0.21390506625175476,
-0.13723501563072205,
-0.11385025084018707,
0.5097351670265198,
-0.02568698860704899,
0.9716324806213379,
-0.12797953188419342,
0.3235087990760803,
0.2288222461938858,
-0.5807411074638367,
0.5064376592636108,
0.3923710882663727,
-0.1534925401210785,
0.6952561140060425,
-0.67646324634552,
0.22329124808311462,
-0.05282987281680107,
0.1885240375995636,
-1.4599816799163818,
-0.4207133948802948,
0.6698017120361328,
-0.39799243211746216,
0.05564968287944794,
0.14149130880832672,
-0.47199946641921997,
-0.44521498680114746,
-0.1180197075009346,
0.4083158075809479,
0.0820745974779129,
-0.4916941523551941,
0.6168420314788818,
0.5890061259269714,
-0.7648259997367859,
-0.19374296069145203,
-0.3684021830558777,
-0.04349282756447792,
-0.5658800601959229,
-0.7355868816375732,
0.1590263843536377,
-0.07041877508163452,
-0.055087585002183914,
-0.3718606233596802,
-0.1532028168439865,
0.015157273039221764,
0.08978326618671417,
0.6528977155685425,
0.35404324531555176,
-0.0027340399101376534,
0.013414238579571247,
0.3387170433998108,
-0.23554974794387817,
0.4123814105987549,
0.36009570956230164,
0.40759575366973877,
0.1989007443189621,
-0.3777247667312622,
-0.646010160446167,
0.7034670114517212,
0.3910399377346039,
-0.23275983333587646,
0.2161843478679657,
0.8634280562400818,
-0.3470122516155243,
0.03839968517422676,
-0.611510694026947,
-0.3452450633049011,
-0.4751463234424591,
0.5393438935279846,
-0.3378666043281555,
-0.7925690412521362,
0.4670793116092682,
-0.3975756764411926,
-0.17721201479434967,
0.45301559567451477,
0.7565871477127075,
-0.06967931240797043,
1.3303788900375366,
0.33681872487068176,
-0.1636035144329071,
0.5472201704978943,
0.28055593371391296,
0.3444008231163025,
-0.8225157260894775,
-0.5816856622695923,
-0.603613555431366,
-0.3222005367279053,
-0.2891658544540405,
0.010968421585857868,
0.5672197937965393,
0.028849225491285324,
-0.19689470529556274,
0.3016556203365326,
-0.14663779735565186,
0.0666440948843956,
0.41819527745246887,
0.19900508224964142,
-0.0545472614467144,
-0.03930813819169998,
0.1087820902466774,
-0.16675055027008057,
-0.5861530303955078,
-0.1478719264268875,
0.6584148406982422,
0.37792614102363586,
0.44923990964889526,
0.16079165041446686,
0.7439261078834534,
0.011126313358545303,
0.010437698103487492,
-0.4656603932380676,
0.672319233417511,
0.18077334761619568,
-0.6658231616020203,
-0.1971401423215866,
-0.3041625916957855,
-0.8818789124488831,
0.29966458678245544,
-0.07272730022668839,
-1.2421395778656006,
0.16463783383369446,
0.01494661532342434,
-0.17683573067188263,
-0.13630329072475433,
-0.7293349504470825,
1.133225679397583,
-0.0870756208896637,
-0.4516255557537079,
-0.5112705230712891,
-0.991097629070282,
0.8577579259872437,
-0.0745791420340538,
0.21386902034282684,
-0.18013660609722137,
0.5281701683998108,
1.0483430624008179,
0.043941907584667206,
0.9477538466453552,
-0.24261905252933502,
-0.24234682321548462,
0.3291628956794739,
0.08544306457042694,
0.6880766153335571,
0.0009486320777796209,
-0.02165224961936474,
-0.12063060700893402,
-0.11923818290233612,
-0.052803877741098404,
-0.44115543365478516,
0.4709152281284332,
-0.32189831137657166,
-0.40916141867637634,
-0.0608845055103302,
-0.3548329472541809,
-0.22585298120975494,
0.0027302687522023916,
-0.07305420935153961,
0.49468207359313965,
-0.078985795378685,
-0.02846687100827694,
0.32355961203575134,
-0.3191319704055786,
0.7427169680595398,
0.3016591966152191,
0.08732745796442032,
-0.49231183528900146,
0.9665767550468445,
-0.43877264857292175,
0.2185075730085373,
0.2241225242614746,
0.26986420154571533,
-0.2899302542209625,
0.08347784727811813,
-0.3003780245780945,
-0.09173250943422318,
-0.6191672086715698,
-0.3619617223739624,
-0.5865921974182129,
-0.021643662825226784,
-0.5499979257583618,
0.22132831811904907,
-0.18683047592639923,
-0.10970398783683777,
-0.47374096512794495,
-0.08241529762744904,
0.20336493849754333,
0.6594541668891907,
-0.23161529004573822,
0.24104344844818115,
-0.8819255232810974,
0.7053980231285095,
0.3479258418083191,
-0.13641692698001862,
0.2901688814163208,
-0.2515431344509125,
-0.1574680656194687,
-0.2127828598022461,
-0.601568877696991,
-0.9761184453964233,
0.6651981472969055,
0.05525480583310127,
0.5308812260627747,
0.7861951589584351,
0.07046718895435333,
1.116693377494812,
-0.31268882751464844,
0.9146665334701538,
0.4367326498031616,
-1.0459318161010742,
0.6493654847145081,
-0.28349441289901733,
-0.17175331711769104,
-0.0019248246680945158,
0.23193733394145966,
-0.6818109750747681,
-0.23155616223812103,
-0.7191312909126282,
-0.997458279132843,
1.1334710121154785,
0.3134978115558624,
-0.2538065016269684,
0.008497202768921852,
0.22693422436714172,
-0.13248439133167267,
0.30238088965415955,
-0.49583518505096436,
-0.3098575174808502,
0.08469506353139877,
-0.33702701330184937,
-0.0023801105562597513,
-0.6181995868682861,
-0.07910086959600449,
0.04414980113506317,
0.5729501843452454,
-0.010831453837454319,
0.5498747229576111,
0.17139412462711334,
-0.007035807240754366,
-0.43211352825164795,
0.17054180800914764,
0.7022477984428406,
0.018833167850971222,
-0.04004539176821709,
-0.013206575997173786,
0.11734834313392639,
-0.17220579087734222,
-0.050764597952365875,
0.194330632686615,
0.30476781725883484,
-0.3525582253932953,
0.3390444815158844,
0.8576854467391968,
0.6436411142349243,
-0.6234510540962219,
0.6068425178527832,
0.03039519116282463,
-0.02491893246769905,
0.01652504689991474,
-0.3275512456893921,
0.08824940025806427,
0.8029748797416687,
0.2712818384170532,
-0.12830489873886108,
0.4914837181568146,
-0.24839578568935394,
0.3924485743045807,
0.20818358659744263,
-0.2668057382106781,
-0.4617185890674591,
0.6907078623771667,
0.5334254503250122,
-0.08967474102973938,
0.345790833234787,
-0.36175259947776794,
-0.8909322619438171,
0.8116356134414673,
0.6266314387321472,
0.9130417108535767,
-0.3652801215648651,
0.2920109033584595,
0.4896869659423828,
-0.18116039037704468,
0.05655822902917862,
0.5561836957931519,
-0.18942908942699432,
-0.7193149328231812,
-0.5202887654304504,
-0.30879366397857666,
-0.4533253014087677,
-0.06928166002035141,
-0.7453587055206299,
0.10672610998153687,
-0.03512486442923546,
0.07719544321298599,
-0.08873593062162399,
0.04271199181675911,
-0.46564310789108276,
0.04671769216656685,
0.37009742856025696,
0.105579674243927,
-0.9425001740455627,
0.6221590638160706,
0.10534357279539108,
-0.4814377725124359,
-1.2271251678466797,
-0.31415417790412903,
0.4540305435657501,
-0.6504931449890137,
1.1184934377670288,
0.21067415177822113,
-0.0821274071931839,
0.018844952806830406,
-0.5912631154060364,
-0.5857871174812317,
1.1542117595672607,
0.029726510867476463,
-0.4113181233406067,
0.2536447048187256,
-0.17641735076904297,
0.2780440151691437,
-0.3317713439464569,
0.25304114818573,
0.3610364496707916,
0.33305731415748596,
0.3220805823802948,
-0.9078706502914429,
0.15412144362926483,
-0.43035194277763367,
-0.3067173361778259,
0.12602238357067108,
-0.8740801811218262,
0.885077953338623,
-0.09616205841302872,
-0.3438921868801117,
-0.03202943876385689,
0.5777843594551086,
0.47536027431488037,
0.6001768708229065,
0.542079508304596,
0.1629825085401535,
0.5191298723220825,
0.09885815531015396,
0.6206463575363159,
-0.3335322439670563,
0.20153552293777466,
1.1156928539276123,
-0.5527615547180176,
0.7387778759002686,
0.5840690732002258,
-0.08721211552619934,
0.5173364281654358,
0.8168420195579529,
0.23947346210479736,
0.4918626546859741,
0.009538593702018261,
-0.17808592319488525,
-0.23848630487918854,
-0.22360360622406006,
-0.05991380661725998,
0.5824806690216064,
0.4152059853076935,
-0.025161676108837128,
-0.030177440494298935,
0.12761104106903076,
0.2859765291213989,
-0.5985212922096252,
-0.13989341259002686,
0.8773403763771057,
0.0919320359826088,
-0.7705948352813721,
0.03830989822745323,
-0.0832299292087555,
0.5410067439079285,
-0.4886201024055481,
-0.16119132936000824,
-0.35399365425109863,
0.18325957655906677,
-0.24442149698734283,
-0.3241083025932312,
-0.04153575003147125,
-0.023515651002526283,
-0.019513651728630066,
-0.07756839692592621,
0.9692577123641968,
-0.6378019452095032,
-0.1814342737197876,
0.36533963680267334,
0.28161200881004333,
0.3233153820037842,
-0.26857686042785645,
-0.6933460235595703,
0.23624490201473236,
-0.04502682760357857,
-0.4097432792186737,
0.34268566966056824,
0.5051138401031494,
0.0505841001868248,
0.4497646391391754,
0.6185061931610107,
-0.2904968559741974,
0.0589892752468586,
0.33296412229537964,
0.7619255781173706,
-0.6838395595550537,
-0.4338848888874054,
-0.7727731466293335,
0.7081831097602844,
-0.18323223292827606,
-0.35608866810798645,
0.6361486315727234,
0.08332926034927368,
0.12983350455760956,
0.06556680053472519,
0.5040892362594604,
-0.31118014454841614,
0.33130112290382385,
-0.3757993280887604,
0.27787625789642334,
-0.7958587408065796,
-0.07289038598537445,
-0.8976824283599854,
-0.5574922561645508,
-0.13272258639335632,
0.380573570728302,
0.1819024533033371,
-0.23940476775169373,
0.8451765179634094,
0.9462476372718811,
0.45469292998313904,
0.49298274517059326,
0.07349689304828644,
0.22414717078208923,
0.5499440431594849,
0.7645571231842041,
0.8392184972763062,
-0.598650336265564,
0.7054531574249268,
-0.11267977952957153,
-0.3822838068008423,
-0.1957903653383255,
-0.8892711400985718,
-0.7076833844184875,
-0.8827651143074036,
-0.3951612114906311,
-0.4744221568107605,
-0.15457771718502045,
0.7503660321235657,
0.515262246131897,
-0.746941328048706,
0.010809045284986496,
-0.06786841154098511,
0.19709526002407074,
-0.24867835640907288,
-0.26404869556427,
0.34978362917900085,
-0.5039759874343872,
-0.6716575622558594,
0.5674493908882141,
0.482583224773407,
-0.15995830297470093,
-0.13125716149806976,
-0.09577761590480804,
-0.21653711795806885,
-0.10579302906990051,
0.8095958232879639,
0.34995707869529724,
-0.6752866506576538,
-0.4577333927154541,
-0.21459361910820007,
-0.019803840667009354,
-0.09659604728221893,
0.9392850995063782,
-0.3252512812614441,
0.23708446323871613,
0.5397008657455444,
0.42895251512527466,
0.5825502872467041,
-0.07960914075374603,
0.4996550679206848,
-0.640501081943512,
0.2622455954551697,
-0.17668871581554413,
0.3037983179092407,
-0.020112240687012672,
-0.42333897948265076,
0.49939537048339844,
0.46151721477508545,
-0.862602710723877,
-0.7926676869392395,
0.36631983518600464,
-1.4390608072280884,
-0.039768386632204056,
1.3445031642913818,
-0.18731874227523804,
-0.012753653340041637,
-0.062237128615379333,
-0.5012770295143127,
0.5886987447738647,
-0.5431770086288452,
0.7962766289710999,
0.6312676668167114,
-0.45832565426826477,
-0.31620731949806213,
-0.43487730622291565,
0.25966936349868774,
0.480657696723938,
-1.1890467405319214,
-0.11747150123119354,
0.44240811467170715,
-0.13198962807655334,
-0.049523621797561646,
0.6502907276153564,
-0.14954371750354767,
-0.0234107356518507,
0.2218826860189438,
0.21758678555488586,
0.2759791314601898,
-0.5103318691253662,
-0.14301849901676178,
0.31293243169784546,
-0.6570636034011841,
-0.4728596806526184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16506v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16506v1
|
Building a Japanese Document-Level Relation Extraction Dataset Assisted by Cross-Lingual Transfer
| 2024-04-25T10:59:02 | 2024-04-25T10:59:02 |
Youmi Ma, An Wang, Naoaki Okazaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Document-level Relation Extraction (DocRE) is the task of extracting all
semantic relationships from a document. While studies have been conducted on
English DocRE, limited attention has been given to DocRE in non-English
languages. This work delves into effectively utilizing existing English
resources to promote DocRE studies in non-English languages, with Japanese as
the representative case. As an initial attempt, we construct a dataset by
transferring an English dataset to Japanese. However, models trained on such a
dataset suffer from low recalls. We investigate the error cases and attribute
the failure to different surface structures and semantics of documents
translated from English and those written by native speakers. We thus switch to
explore if the transferred dataset can assist human annotation on Japanese
documents. In our proposal, annotators edit relation predictions from a model
trained on the transferred dataset. Quantitative analysis shows that relation
recommendations suggested by the model help reduce approximately 50% of the
human edit steps compared with the previous approach. Experiments quantify the
performance of existing DocRE models on our collected dataset, portraying the
challenges of Japanese and cross-lingual DocRE.
|
[
-0.35251718759536743,
-0.3982589542865753,
0.5636538863182068,
-0.019002249464392662,
-0.093815878033638,
-0.23788146674633026,
-0.11647221446037292,
-0.9172818660736084,
-0.00158546247985214,
0.5976992249488831,
-0.38291454315185547,
-0.44661107659339905,
-0.7711362838745117,
0.4184069037437439,
-0.28861528635025024,
0.9314033389091492,
-0.4520573019981384,
-0.03959386795759201,
-0.2701597213745117,
-0.029083745554089546,
-0.5742476582527161,
-0.3015439808368683,
-0.9507005214691162,
-0.47369304299354553,
0.541227400302887,
0.4794417917728424,
0.59731125831604,
0.381773978471756,
0.5559369325637817,
0.1787455528974533,
0.1937774270772934,
0.24665531516075134,
-0.4570622444152832,
0.008202130906283855,
-0.30872514843940735,
-0.7425374984741211,
-0.4137558341026306,
0.06863243132829666,
0.4977027475833893,
0.9582800269126892,
0.2645874619483948,
-0.24811382591724396,
-0.37596797943115234,
0.4738958179950714,
-0.4866084158420563,
0.5515886545181274,
-0.43894413113594055,
0.020729629322886467,
-0.26909440755844116,
-0.11407886445522308,
-0.36707350611686707,
-0.044096432626247406,
0.06125858053565025,
-1.2581777572631836,
0.3560510277748108,
0.08445263653993607,
1.150102972984314,
-0.09791485220193863,
-0.47358980774879456,
-0.20914226770401,
-0.7907758951187134,
0.3234855830669403,
-0.45622313022613525,
0.6120414733886719,
0.8853296637535095,
0.22413113713264465,
-0.12081015110015869,
-0.7422488927841187,
-0.34401118755340576,
-0.0570833683013916,
-0.5258864760398865,
0.27243590354919434,
0.04770740494132042,
-0.19713880121707916,
0.4641818404197693,
0.40126606822013855,
-0.26553240418434143,
0.1569029688835144,
-0.6390630602836609,
-0.22549943625926971,
0.7387691736221313,
0.10535108298063278,
0.7543124556541443,
-0.413650244474411,
-0.09124528616666794,
-0.14551600813865662,
-0.7354544997215271,
-0.13365338742733002,
0.1977798193693161,
0.3221762478351593,
-0.10790614038705826,
0.46366244554519653,
0.024575060233473778,
0.3764115869998932,
0.08271182328462601,
-0.377631276845932,
0.10105016827583313,
-0.5009698271751404,
0.14715363085269928,
0.15283702313899994,
1.0088673830032349,
0.4611794054508209,
0.7071828842163086,
-0.3441624343395233,
-0.22097311913967133,
-0.18447065353393555,
0.07597888261079788,
-0.7175900340080261,
-0.2420598864555359,
-0.22587645053863525,
-0.36310747265815735,
-0.06839082390069962,
0.25195252895355225,
-0.6988371014595032,
-0.37063175439834595,
-0.22236143052577972,
0.1654970794916153,
-0.6850152611732483,
-0.4047837257385254,
-0.060375116765499115,
-0.3620477318763733,
0.050599660724401474,
0.4765163064002991,
-0.8187034130096436,
0.47840210795402527,
0.6074144840240479,
0.6991967558860779,
-0.04519422724843025,
-0.46329569816589355,
-0.3351287245750427,
0.628863513469696,
-0.4620591402053833,
0.7409452199935913,
-0.523216724395752,
-0.9673122763633728,
-0.14019407331943512,
0.4481523931026459,
-0.20268937945365906,
-0.2618161141872406,
0.6557273864746094,
-0.19670352339744568,
0.6225730180740356,
-0.22922833263874054,
-0.5829975008964539,
-0.05876930058002472,
0.03605726361274719,
-1.0015945434570312,
0.9542984962463379,
0.46644681692123413,
-1.045151948928833,
0.280098021030426,
-0.5418148636817932,
-0.8806021213531494,
0.013308442197740078,
-0.11638490110635757,
-0.1535571664571762,
0.008944885805249214,
0.4786544442176819,
0.29203078150749207,
-0.4808540642261505,
0.05116269364953041,
-0.04939529672265053,
-0.26676279306411743,
-0.023449383676052094,
-0.10531678795814514,
0.687601625919342,
0.11125504970550537,
0.060432326048612595,
-0.5040692090988159,
-0.9505968689918518,
-0.642376720905304,
0.24072234332561493,
-0.09705090522766113,
-1.1873174905776978,
-0.35770300030708313,
0.05693678557872772,
0.3802274465560913,
0.15493309497833252,
-0.6798616051673889,
0.3539779484272003,
-0.2915058732032776,
0.12728171050548553,
0.27854466438293457,
0.5644816160202026,
0.7711598873138428,
-0.20938560366630554,
0.6942077279090881,
0.052057068794965744,
0.013698184862732887,
-0.43563565611839294,
-0.50803142786026,
-0.5698742270469666,
-0.03350013121962547,
0.44635382294654846,
0.5548428893089294,
-0.8901644349098206,
0.12937559187412262,
-0.6446135640144348,
-0.3995939791202545,
-0.788536548614502,
0.20703531801700592,
0.42602089047431946,
0.9558119177818298,
0.09666068106889725,
-0.32617419958114624,
-0.4055379629135132,
-0.9616708755493164,
-0.009444165974855423,
-0.3220667839050293,
-0.06287046521902084,
0.22235840559005737,
0.23355485498905182,
-0.03814059495925903,
0.7930461764335632,
-0.38383814692497253,
-0.6080107688903809,
-0.1949659287929535,
0.35105302929878235,
0.06227246671915054,
0.33524951338768005,
0.5619217157363892,
-0.8358032703399658,
-0.695026695728302,
0.4063417613506317,
-0.856301486492157,
-0.14355532824993134,
-0.3219965696334839,
-0.3765221834182739,
0.31755340099334717,
0.5097346901893616,
-0.7324891090393066,
0.4065093994140625,
0.15968936681747437,
-0.16089244186878204,
0.18019749224185944,
-0.4025608003139496,
0.3047780394554138,
-1.473459005355835,
0.43410569429397583,
0.25169530510902405,
-0.302505224943161,
-0.5638836622238159,
-0.2517208158969879,
0.299567312002182,
-0.36207619309425354,
-0.28826773166656494,
0.7707621455192566,
-0.7753555178642273,
-0.11959626525640488,
-0.046860240399837494,
0.20556038618087769,
0.3861663043498993,
0.3309352993965149,
0.40641501545906067,
0.6798593401908875,
0.3272915482521057,
-0.31016063690185547,
0.060306333005428314,
0.7698946595191956,
-0.16240331530570984,
0.9109905362129211,
-0.32892248034477234,
0.2123556137084961,
-0.17392942309379578,
0.13480865955352783,
-0.9512831568717957,
-0.08545342832803726,
0.35059723258018494,
-0.36929216980934143,
0.7835373282432556,
-0.5694305896759033,
-0.4380803108215332,
0.008206541649997234,
-0.09889228641986847,
-0.09715908020734787,
0.2862938344478607,
-0.37238118052482605,
0.6255996227264404,
0.4775262475013733,
-0.5730348825454712,
-0.33055245876312256,
-0.6899148225784302,
0.2338310331106186,
-0.07921169698238373,
-0.5585032105445862,
0.45015865564346313,
0.3971293866634369,
-0.20510059595108032,
0.37396150827407837,
-0.11115529388189316,
-0.27688828110694885,
0.04948022961616516,
0.45484545826911926,
0.5648547410964966,
-0.027920370921492577,
-0.08606068789958954,
0.07145930081605911,
-0.3456859588623047,
0.23190222680568695,
0.1819298267364502,
0.06888856738805771,
0.491570383310318,
0.050912559032440186,
-0.21638622879981995,
0.4223843216896057,
0.6003615260124207,
-0.21657279133796692,
0.5382653474807739,
0.4744502902030945,
-0.5518290400505066,
0.16243422031402588,
-0.32267215847969055,
0.1168873980641365,
-0.35030829906463623,
0.3673945367336273,
-0.9946562647819519,
-0.29931333661079407,
0.5556566119194031,
0.05271834135055542,
0.051034726202487946,
0.7027108669281006,
-0.06857264786958694,
-0.12434188276529312,
0.7015199661254883,
0.7580573558807373,
-0.40011706948280334,
0.40134140849113464,
-0.2910163998603821,
0.16254575550556183,
-0.9063204526901245,
-0.28633174300193787,
-0.6015550494194031,
0.008367247879505157,
-0.6128940582275391,
-0.14623448252677917,
0.09638667851686478,
0.03242233768105507,
0.35195693373680115,
0.6726450324058533,
-0.004562373273074627,
0.3031134009361267,
0.16406738758087158,
-0.11510815471410751,
0.590937614440918,
0.1166769489645958,
0.11606726050376892,
-0.2889672517776489,
-0.6136168241500854,
-0.26417818665504456,
0.9545889496803284,
0.1402634084224701,
0.8000021576881409,
-0.2558560073375702,
0.7702073454856873,
0.07257851958274841,
0.34003767371177673,
-0.7319368124008179,
0.36630088090896606,
-0.3967353403568268,
-0.4284837543964386,
-0.34433332085609436,
-0.6093194484710693,
-1.262311577796936,
-0.06262698769569397,
-0.13334685564041138,
-0.5692983865737915,
0.39073121547698975,
-0.5071660876274109,
0.34894824028015137,
0.1829068809747696,
-0.6042779684066772,
0.7443475127220154,
-0.2836920917034149,
-0.28515708446502686,
0.05954406037926674,
-0.730680525302887,
0.271203875541687,
-0.397350937128067,
0.4729185104370117,
-0.028843393549323082,
0.03661371022462845,
0.9736577272415161,
-0.36986467242240906,
0.6380394101142883,
-0.22816313803195953,
-0.4294080436229706,
-0.0976337343454361,
0.3370012938976288,
0.51069575548172,
-0.088948555290699,
-0.24344921112060547,
0.27168604731559753,
0.19666731357574463,
-0.06172797456383705,
-0.7533131241798401,
0.5868616700172424,
-0.865818977355957,
-0.3903428614139557,
-0.2736932039260864,
-0.7199915051460266,
-0.417613685131073,
0.536339282989502,
0.28204408288002014,
0.26360538601875305,
-0.382868230342865,
-0.22762605547904968,
0.20197823643684387,
0.12035134434700012,
0.17022490501403809,
0.7145355343818665,
-0.288872629404068,
-0.30568593740463257,
0.8653761148452759,
0.37276703119277954,
0.09385315328836441,
0.56791090965271,
0.04027070850133896,
-0.2381546050310135,
-0.17952540516853333,
-0.44598427414894104,
0.4765241742134094,
-0.7878714799880981,
0.10767766833305359,
-0.5939292311668396,
-0.1997724026441574,
-0.39134517312049866,
-0.0615723542869091,
-0.31227415800094604,
-0.6647809743881226,
-0.10335630178451538,
-0.16867496073246002,
0.38069435954093933,
0.701522946357727,
0.024212729185819626,
-0.06827647238969803,
-1.0730457305908203,
0.6020717024803162,
-0.14925417304039001,
0.10586017370223999,
-0.2768193185329437,
-0.5128594040870667,
-0.20371365547180176,
-0.06523730605840683,
0.24255190789699554,
-0.9376221299171448,
0.41853898763656616,
0.2787095308303833,
0.6782618165016174,
0.08637377619743347,
0.015448803082108498,
0.7800620198249817,
-0.28510749340057373,
0.3725091218948364,
0.13512037694454193,
-0.5660352110862732,
0.6851017475128174,
-0.45406374335289,
0.06230950355529785,
0.8314523696899414,
0.9008652567863464,
-0.7954311370849609,
-0.5004382133483887,
-0.8629790544509888,
-0.6261139512062073,
0.8560822010040283,
0.0021127271465957165,
-0.05607633292675018,
0.1722685694694519,
0.5495696067810059,
0.34345728158950806,
-0.1575462967157364,
-0.2570944130420685,
-0.028421631082892418,
0.102826327085495,
-0.25210604071617126,
-0.30500328540802,
0.019567640498280525,
0.11072678864002228,
-0.08196401596069336,
0.6237984895706177,
0.09568221122026443,
-0.22345928847789764,
0.4523003399372101,
-0.374131977558136,
-0.31706520915031433,
0.10903408378362656,
-0.15828461945056915,
0.7763862609863281,
-0.3286855220794678,
-0.0015370850451290607,
-0.06292236596345901,
-0.5726625919342041,
0.13872367143630981,
0.4950698912143707,
-0.5679851174354553,
0.2081870585680008,
0.46083134412765503,
0.7544161677360535,
0.46395331621170044,
-0.19069990515708923,
0.41004514694213867,
-0.2783863842487335,
-0.16915570199489594,
-0.10933160781860352,
-0.21454331278800964,
0.16180121898651123,
-0.3670519292354584,
0.18184879422187805,
-0.29383915662765503,
-0.028789859265089035,
-0.713771402835846,
0.22065764665603638,
0.012705741450190544,
-0.3328881561756134,
-0.33309513330459595,
0.47165238857269287,
0.32102811336517334,
-0.2747238576412201,
0.8468165397644043,
0.13379773497581482,
-0.3767375648021698,
0.48925527930259705,
0.6179935336112976,
0.49148932099342346,
-0.1348336786031723,
0.11645486950874329,
0.6285549402236938,
0.40593910217285156,
-0.15099506080150604,
-0.11781612038612366,
-0.03698651120066643,
-0.7097400426864624,
-0.32226911187171936,
-0.3381050229072571,
-0.5780847668647766,
0.06230243667960167,
-0.8638542294502258,
0.47073298692703247,
-0.2484551966190338,
0.07840436697006226,
0.04894661530852318,
0.2411380410194397,
-0.6535016298294067,
0.24294769763946533,
0.13534437119960785,
0.7941086292266846,
-1.1548017263412476,
1.090650200843811,
0.8125317096710205,
-0.9201022982597351,
-0.842764675617218,
-0.14979030191898346,
-0.3845062851905823,
-0.647036612033844,
0.7227762341499329,
-0.056985918432474136,
0.1113082692027092,
-0.03094918467104435,
0.09489267319440842,
-0.58876633644104,
0.9840941429138184,
0.26794737577438354,
-0.692807137966156,
-0.22387021780014038,
0.292649507522583,
0.5719901323318481,
-0.2633044719696045,
0.21412962675094604,
0.6651630401611328,
0.626398503780365,
-0.03954802826046944,
-0.9133974313735962,
0.36320817470550537,
-0.5575902462005615,
-0.003989190794527531,
0.42869871854782104,
-0.3803912103176117,
0.570687472820282,
0.145131453871727,
-0.38566651940345764,
-0.08421702682971954,
0.3513718545436859,
-0.05795547366142273,
0.21323014795780182,
0.4870108962059021,
0.5195894837379456,
0.7906763553619385,
0.06376773864030838,
1.2904090881347656,
-0.24763737618923187,
-0.15633311867713928,
1.3029693365097046,
-0.5684390068054199,
0.7646383047103882,
0.5940968990325928,
-0.15789076685905457,
0.4543644189834595,
0.5381888747215271,
-0.16152244806289673,
0.42545947432518005,
-0.3601081669330597,
0.1302400678396225,
0.044939007610082626,
-0.2752651572227478,
-0.23324838280677795,
0.3085497319698334,
0.40109822154045105,
-0.34592342376708984,
-0.21916095912456512,
-0.08538679033517838,
0.3704167306423187,
0.006164094433188438,
-0.18303796648979187,
1.0127242803573608,
0.18476107716560364,
-0.8985166549682617,
0.2227359414100647,
-0.1282118558883667,
0.3438662588596344,
-0.8147627711296082,
-0.1587338149547577,
-0.5867294073104858,
-0.11150402575731277,
-0.2947250306606293,
-0.812515139579773,
0.18628863990306854,
0.024130376055836678,
-0.3479040265083313,
-0.111722931265831,
1.160884141921997,
-0.5926357507705688,
-0.6916862726211548,
0.5327613353729248,
0.7020946741104126,
0.32917356491088867,
0.2382797747850418,
-0.41674453020095825,
-0.25004610419273376,
-0.06337420642375946,
-0.07286341488361359,
0.6042761206626892,
0.6103216409683228,
-0.5085668563842773,
0.20762185752391815,
0.811296820640564,
0.4813094735145569,
-0.1980704963207245,
0.3564647138118744,
0.46984297037124634,
-0.5121919512748718,
-0.35971757769584656,
-0.3537808060646057,
0.2862967550754547,
-0.2695738971233368,
-0.19372576475143433,
0.7443374991416931,
0.5674261450767517,
0.9101917147636414,
0.0018936708802357316,
1.1431299448013306,
-0.14087235927581787,
0.3837503492832184,
-0.47105666995048523,
0.8011285066604614,
-0.6030949354171753,
0.030544161796569824,
-0.31420576572418213,
-0.9555039405822754,
-0.17532050609588623,
0.5297860503196716,
-0.35555440187454224,
-0.28701695799827576,
0.8199239373207092,
0.7083846926689148,
-0.3642894923686981,
-0.0862119048833847,
0.3395490050315857,
0.10960940271615982,
0.3114398419857025,
0.8511630296707153,
0.8222706317901611,
-0.7424332499504089,
0.6131296157836914,
-0.6740483641624451,
-0.02439882792532444,
0.20960336923599243,
-0.7798101902008057,
-0.8536269664764404,
-0.6853848695755005,
-0.4002867341041565,
-0.1887214183807373,
0.12726092338562012,
0.3993646502494812,
0.5201653242111206,
-0.46294859051704407,
-0.18824680149555206,
-0.036678165197372437,
-0.12352633476257324,
0.24170924723148346,
-0.23050202429294586,
0.41846996545791626,
-0.18018785119056702,
-0.8551136255264282,
0.5070913434028625,
0.09999264031648636,
0.11776664108037949,
-0.04467567428946495,
-0.18096749484539032,
-0.3195042014122009,
-0.31242433190345764,
0.22102604806423187,
0.4525814354419708,
-0.25506922602653503,
-0.11187003552913666,
-0.20427574217319489,
-0.4187942445278168,
0.20307239890098572,
0.7917891144752502,
-0.4107986092567444,
0.5149831771850586,
0.6145700216293335,
0.615066647529602,
0.9958001971244812,
-0.09340312331914902,
1.0422977209091187,
-0.7902082800865173,
0.2879165709018707,
-0.24841396510601044,
0.6701486706733704,
0.6943804025650024,
-0.5831873416900635,
1.0233193635940552,
0.3215557932853699,
-0.07404835522174835,
-0.5104145407676697,
-0.14576579630374908,
-0.9366796016693115,
-0.23911108076572418,
1.07246994972229,
-0.44227275252342224,
-0.42711755633354187,
-0.22037257254123688,
-0.5043631792068481,
0.4457929730415344,
-0.1875872164964676,
0.5086206793785095,
0.8757987022399902,
0.10972357541322708,
-0.2995571792125702,
-0.4653516411781311,
0.2074887901544571,
0.1777748316526413,
-1.0302573442459106,
0.017229780554771423,
0.4782533347606659,
0.48378682136535645,
0.33600103855133057,
0.801689863204956,
-0.4037427604198456,
0.42867523431777954,
0.12857434153556824,
0.14324872195720673,
-0.37949565052986145,
-0.2155684381723404,
-0.18246492743492126,
0.006438331678509712,
0.2436942756175995,
0.05155772343277931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16478v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16478v1
|
Evaluating Consistency and Reasoning Capabilities of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-25T10:03:14 | 2024-04-25T10:03:14 |
Yash Saxena, Sarthak Chopra, Arunendra Mani Tripathi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are extensively used today across various
sectors, including academia, research, business, and finance, for tasks such as
text generation, summarization, and translation. Despite their widespread
adoption, these models often produce incorrect and misleading information,
exhibiting a tendency to hallucinate. This behavior can be attributed to
several factors, with consistency and reasoning capabilities being significant
contributors. LLMs frequently lack the ability to generate explanations and
engage in coherent reasoning, leading to inaccurate responses. Moreover, they
exhibit inconsistencies in their outputs. This paper aims to evaluate and
compare the consistency and reasoning capabilities of both public and
proprietary LLMs. The experiments utilize the Boolq dataset as the ground
truth, comprising questions, answers, and corresponding explanations. Queries
from the dataset are presented as prompts to the LLMs, and the generated
responses are evaluated against the ground truth answers. Additionally,
explanations are generated to assess the models' reasoning abilities.
Consistency is evaluated by repeatedly presenting the same query to the models
and observing for variations in their responses. For measuring reasoning
capabilities, the generated explanations are compared to the ground truth
explanations using metrics such as BERT, BLEU, and F-1 scores. The findings
reveal that proprietary models generally outperform public models in terms of
both consistency and reasoning capabilities. However, even when presented with
basic general knowledge questions, none of the models achieved a score of 90\%
in both consistency and reasoning. This study underscores the direct
correlation between consistency and reasoning abilities in LLMs and highlights
the inherent reasoning challenges present in current language models.
|
[
-0.08740931749343872,
-0.7387160062789917,
1.0721063613891602,
0.27643057703971863,
0.09758853912353516,
-0.12632615864276886,
-0.5594106912612915,
-0.33051300048828125,
-0.33079269528388977,
0.5952073931694031,
-0.10329283028841019,
-0.6348599791526794,
-0.578203558921814,
0.23076243698596954,
-0.23209059238433838,
0.7208912968635559,
-0.16452549397945404,
-0.004887343849986792,
-0.5869247317314148,
-0.2480248510837555,
-0.6674975156784058,
-0.5104886293411255,
-0.3188680112361908,
-0.445142924785614,
0.19519254565238953,
0.0376744419336319,
1.0677247047424316,
0.4747876226902008,
0.40202146768569946,
0.3204551339149475,
-0.24454250931739807,
0.5169890522956848,
-0.565026044845581,
0.17249779403209686,
-0.5671190619468689,
-0.19013167917728424,
-0.4308120310306549,
-0.25459131598472595,
0.9077467918395996,
0.7504774928092957,
-0.08270625025033951,
0.07060088217258453,
0.11569377034902573,
0.5931150913238525,
-0.5706211924552917,
0.2766343653202057,
-0.9694628715515137,
-0.31076717376708984,
0.061152730137109756,
0.1585521548986435,
-0.5216410160064697,
-0.8205447196960449,
0.09186271578073502,
-0.42142558097839355,
-0.07088719308376312,
0.026156874373555183,
0.9879150390625,
0.21983003616333008,
-0.3729797899723053,
-0.4236840307712555,
-0.7726154327392578,
0.7977020740509033,
-1.1214478015899658,
0.6011962294578552,
0.29962384700775146,
0.15517979860305786,
-0.26458805799484253,
-0.358234167098999,
-0.5364591479301453,
-0.6193060874938965,
-0.07493134588003159,
-0.1105758473277092,
-0.25816136598587036,
-0.24411456286907196,
0.38714662194252014,
0.20474478602409363,
-0.6648349761962891,
0.37291255593299866,
-0.18938809633255005,
-0.37932372093200684,
0.7204491496086121,
0.29419422149658203,
-0.06937157362699509,
-0.11226002126932144,
-0.2918035686016083,
0.04582597687840462,
-0.8171492218971252,
0.05769253894686699,
0.2953508794307709,
0.17673899233341217,
0.08603448420763016,
0.8150070905685425,
-0.22714650630950928,
0.6905981302261353,
-0.0526585578918457,
-0.4939771294593811,
0.05781402066349983,
-0.317914754152298,
-0.4449155032634735,
-0.10420876741409302,
0.779690682888031,
0.22700144350528717,
0.37527796626091003,
-0.24324755370616913,
-0.372744619846344,
-0.05679246410727501,
0.08597154170274734,
-0.32588809728622437,
0.05947576090693474,
0.35703080892562866,
-0.498177170753479,
0.028191929683089256,
0.09922291338443756,
-0.48452436923980713,
-0.6456589698791504,
-0.5575599074363708,
0.681012749671936,
-0.3857751488685608,
-0.31350237131118774,
0.3028342127799988,
0.04297267273068428,
0.28527382016181946,
0.589984118938446,
-0.6324559450149536,
0.28626084327697754,
0.8384873270988464,
0.7204699516296387,
-0.3539454936981201,
-0.17297756671905518,
-0.24936312437057495,
0.19323955476284027,
-0.4744938910007477,
0.6067559123039246,
-0.2803928852081299,
-0.2972352206707001,
0.03406757488846779,
-0.07733217626810074,
-0.1186225563287735,
-0.887728750705719,
0.6273255348205566,
-0.25771939754486084,
-0.09403868764638901,
-0.5566849708557129,
-0.7920798063278198,
-0.18532808125019073,
0.42354616522789,
-0.36106839776039124,
0.7450068593025208,
-0.2253502607345581,
-0.719264566898346,
0.20253288745880127,
-0.2854345440864563,
-0.12306325882673264,
-0.051599252969026566,
-0.3994266092777252,
-0.43726053833961487,
0.13306887447834015,
0.08142530173063278,
0.44469761848449707,
-0.3477995693683624,
0.6418572068214417,
-0.42811766266822815,
-0.5465812683105469,
0.5684205889701843,
-0.517162024974823,
0.7280334234237671,
0.06161477044224739,
-0.38107144832611084,
0.17663781344890594,
-0.6610330939292908,
0.026243187487125397,
0.2862900197505951,
-0.3731805384159088,
-0.11847249418497086,
0.06623461097478867,
-0.44421496987342834,
-0.08427737653255463,
0.5085304975509644,
-0.42841383814811707,
0.16254432499408722,
-0.1411685198545456,
0.3816848397254944,
0.8389151692390442,
-0.06148497387766838,
0.07290312647819519,
-0.47158512473106384,
0.16515202820301056,
-0.03489753603935242,
-0.015500856563448906,
-0.1629321575164795,
-0.6186135411262512,
-0.4553949236869812,
-0.12849058210849762,
0.18751166760921478,
0.41317012906074524,
-0.14509057998657227,
0.44939160346984863,
-0.4751206040382385,
-0.6185860633850098,
-0.3369375765323639,
0.12280820310115814,
0.26334521174430847,
0.5454875230789185,
0.2755340337753296,
0.28210553526878357,
-0.34898754954338074,
-1.0578771829605103,
-0.44394201040267944,
-0.262820303440094,
-0.06712690740823746,
0.3691335916519165,
0.6606772541999817,
-0.24451637268066406,
0.869849681854248,
-0.12987367808818817,
0.2660452127456665,
-0.11406399309635162,
0.05232616141438484,
0.2600615918636322,
0.3906157314777374,
0.1595894694328308,
-0.5056155920028687,
-0.17562812566757202,
0.08570673316717148,
-1.0337892770767212,
-0.1883673518896103,
-0.059153590351343155,
0.13119733333587646,
0.4822487533092499,
0.1622975915670395,
-0.730309009552002,
0.41418805718421936,
0.6490177512168884,
-0.17627404630184174,
0.9742714762687683,
-0.2960449755191803,
0.23046064376831055,
-0.5123456716537476,
0.18448960781097412,
-0.0671316385269165,
-0.22786976397037506,
-0.34193456172943115,
-0.0864134207367897,
0.04938507825136185,
-0.014887205325067043,
-0.10424993187189102,
0.6709122061729431,
-0.501785397529602,
-0.3174850046634674,
-0.14780734479427338,
0.34639325737953186,
0.2575688660144806,
0.09679213166236877,
0.03136055916547775,
0.764410138130188,
0.5577303171157837,
-0.6703376770019531,
0.45773255825042725,
0.20588134229183197,
-0.4182316064834595,
0.35115304589271545,
-0.9529817700386047,
0.24553056061267853,
-0.04795603081583977,
0.17780594527721405,
-1.0251957178115845,
-0.21995452046394348,
0.00022458746389020234,
-0.323750764131546,
0.05217871069908142,
0.02752436324954033,
-0.6767131090164185,
-0.23202474415302277,
-0.05258094146847725,
-0.07828647643327713,
0.5482784509658813,
-0.5316210985183716,
0.6638609766960144,
-0.02612827531993389,
0.03629511222243309,
-0.5573459267616272,
-0.7258560657501221,
-0.10461239516735077,
-0.0322808139026165,
-0.9704329371452332,
-0.019964734092354774,
-0.023445678874850273,
-0.7460760474205017,
0.11356548964977264,
-0.38155388832092285,
0.022844776511192322,
0.07299652695655823,
0.2651458978652954,
0.3012939691543579,
-0.5038564801216125,
0.20563997328281403,
-0.18631359934806824,
0.2941265106201172,
0.12267585098743439,
-0.18053840100765228,
0.30929654836654663,
-0.46140965819358826,
-0.7313962578773499,
-0.5732676386833191,
-0.0515531487762928,
0.7780972719192505,
-0.2692042887210846,
1.169677972793579,
0.22238674759864807,
-0.3301212191581726,
0.019175276160240173,
-0.9226195812225342,
-0.08006732165813446,
-0.3934073746204376,
0.14036445319652557,
-0.4765332043170929,
-0.8376468420028687,
0.7144932150840759,
0.040057867765426636,
0.17662183940410614,
0.40864625573158264,
0.7153400182723999,
0.2231629192829132,
1.0029292106628418,
0.08435150235891342,
0.3039323389530182,
-0.2000809907913208,
0.043465591967105865,
0.3331194221973419,
-0.6051583290100098,
-0.5921788215637207,
-0.5936147570610046,
0.1217927485704422,
-0.4712052047252655,
-0.34636932611465454,
0.2647458612918854,
0.3293064534664154,
-0.462758868932724,
0.11731395125389099,
-0.24872493743896484,
0.4620412290096283,
0.3906303644180298,
-0.13623790442943573,
0.6356643438339233,
-0.1338566392660141,
-0.23388099670410156,
0.0006903040921315551,
-0.48600584268569946,
-1.1630377769470215,
1.1078014373779297,
0.667002260684967,
0.8610089421272278,
0.27258962392807007,
0.5386999249458313,
0.16226617991924286,
0.23957598209381104,
-0.4828217923641205,
0.6405108571052551,
-0.004807801451534033,
-0.5343483686447144,
-0.38359150290489197,
-0.7150271534919739,
-0.6069892644882202,
0.30203136801719666,
-0.41276687383651733,
-0.9078481793403625,
0.06293920427560806,
0.08205272257328033,
-0.10586737096309662,
0.4360305368900299,
-0.6311619281768799,
0.9178980588912964,
-0.3985894024372101,
-0.5921646952629089,
0.048860497772693634,
-0.2481512576341629,
0.6780534982681274,
-0.1933983564376831,
0.08304982632398605,
-0.26999178528785706,
0.1453161984682083,
0.35059723258018494,
-0.1546533852815628,
0.5660769939422607,
0.027627864852547646,
-0.4197089672088623,
0.25556519627571106,
0.21664732694625854,
0.5694355368614197,
0.13491560518741608,
-0.4610106945037842,
0.4508097171783447,
0.03965167701244354,
-0.3885931372642517,
-0.6542989015579224,
0.743340790271759,
-0.7566706538200378,
-1.0268248319625854,
-0.20943304896354675,
-0.6518608331680298,
-0.3652087152004242,
0.03493335843086243,
0.0380869023501873,
0.4079427123069763,
-0.22915375232696533,
0.40651389956474304,
0.8340415954589844,
-0.4284599721431732,
0.06254779547452927,
0.693328320980072,
-0.4563300609588623,
-0.14441685378551483,
0.5836707353591919,
0.1355830878019333,
0.4042743444442749,
0.13206696510314941,
0.3033826947212219,
-0.6046655774116516,
-0.7190045714378357,
-0.36873242259025574,
0.48150745034217834,
-0.7385467886924744,
-0.11213365942239761,
-0.4703488051891327,
-0.2616101801395416,
-0.6364957094192505,
0.057385485619306564,
-0.3807860016822815,
-0.06622294336557388,
-0.023769810795783997,
0.02251710556447506,
-0.058984626084566116,
0.9659906029701233,
-0.050725094974040985,
-0.2548863887786865,
-0.749004065990448,
0.15861381590366364,
0.29560017585754395,
0.2194691151380539,
0.23509098589420319,
-0.6285780072212219,
0.05987395718693733,
0.20551130175590515,
-0.27414438128471375,
-1.0998132228851318,
-0.18076346814632416,
-0.2585892081260681,
0.8496697545051575,
0.4384406507015228,
-0.081558957695961,
0.43960806727409363,
-0.2760905623435974,
0.7833157777786255,
-0.012002067640423775,
-1.2388112545013428,
0.46301501989364624,
-0.4329335391521454,
0.3725338578224182,
0.31196045875549316,
0.43324533104896545,
-0.31078892946243286,
-0.6350602507591248,
-0.5113229751586914,
-0.43766212463378906,
0.32173389196395874,
0.3150618076324463,
-0.146021768450737,
0.04247217997908592,
0.36277130246162415,
0.23140405118465424,
0.20750899612903595,
-0.6605172157287598,
-0.044621340930461884,
-0.13880813121795654,
-0.12911678850650787,
0.10241631418466568,
-0.2821311354637146,
-0.07696215808391571,
-0.0881175845861435,
0.708983302116394,
0.10705707967281342,
-0.1240454837679863,
0.19350078701972961,
0.09625010192394257,
0.028734255582094193,
0.46265602111816406,
0.8959567546844482,
1.2949942350387573,
-0.16910004615783691,
0.2069653570652008,
0.19137156009674072,
-0.016011932864785194,
0.10921923071146011,
-0.015205885283648968,
-0.21395739912986755,
0.09579996764659882,
0.44074422121047974,
0.7335301637649536,
-0.009382318705320358,
-0.9934385418891907,
0.4830963611602783,
0.1109735369682312,
-0.33418935537338257,
-0.2373104989528656,
0.03355007618665695,
0.49421390891075134,
0.33506450057029724,
0.23069047927856445,
-0.03461030125617981,
-0.19793251156806946,
-0.7805646061897278,
-0.12344076484441757,
0.5527359843254089,
0.12695224583148956,
-0.04460751265287399,
0.6203463673591614,
-0.14311638474464417,
-0.18315260112285614,
0.7076079249382019,
-0.22036851942539215,
-0.51085364818573,
0.42253798246383667,
0.6632962226867676,
0.4575246274471283,
0.04401218891143799,
0.21881502866744995,
0.27435871958732605,
0.5397400259971619,
-0.4402838349342346,
0.10700660943984985,
0.2525729537010193,
-0.9145339131355286,
-0.4711949825286865,
-0.642560601234436,
-0.7266829609870911,
0.5754942297935486,
-0.5200003981590271,
0.1150762215256691,
-0.4854499399662018,
-0.11365491151809692,
-0.0805511623620987,
0.010737660340964794,
-0.5099773406982422,
0.07093576341867447,
0.24270452558994293,
0.884985625743866,
-0.7824895977973938,
0.6254448294639587,
0.8070038557052612,
-0.5039811730384827,
-1.0575675964355469,
0.06899736821651459,
0.010299986228346825,
-0.7084125876426697,
0.6925481557846069,
0.08010406792163849,
-0.21956665813922882,
-0.3800424337387085,
-0.5668597221374512,
-0.7835472822189331,
0.9496258497238159,
0.5962614417076111,
-0.8543773889541626,
0.15244844555854797,
0.1305268555879593,
0.628760039806366,
-0.34617432951927185,
0.03702226281166077,
0.5500262379646301,
0.8189898729324341,
0.09412899613380432,
-1.207458257675171,
0.1346256136894226,
0.2402954399585724,
-0.02209925651550293,
-0.0908161923289299,
-0.380000501871109,
0.8293604254722595,
-0.27497705817222595,
-0.16648459434509277,
0.18340210616588593,
0.63535475730896,
0.8726033568382263,
0.46835118532180786,
0.23924319446086884,
0.6804577708244324,
1.1432942152023315,
-0.27748993039131165,
0.9059882164001465,
-0.1100291982293129,
0.313908189535141,
1.135612964630127,
-0.7037674784660339,
0.9283398389816284,
0.1401972621679306,
-0.04624315723776817,
0.5340278148651123,
0.22516663372516632,
-0.30976980924606323,
0.016995778307318687,
0.29681596159935,
-0.09484408795833588,
-0.3666655123233795,
-0.05400685966014862,
-0.34229734539985657,
0.4252708852291107,
-0.030785566195845604,
-0.2671944200992584,
-0.13037517666816711,
-0.13977493345737457,
0.10164514929056168,
0.4980084002017975,
-0.40883582830429077,
0.5335497856140137,
0.040122050791978836,
-0.6871535778045654,
0.845856785774231,
0.08868978917598724,
0.3241826593875885,
-0.4622531235218048,
-0.0053562019020318985,
-0.2743639349937439,
0.3060385286808014,
-0.30996155738830566,
-0.9891955852508545,
0.45662227272987366,
0.2299451380968094,
-0.17175014317035675,
-0.05014901980757713,
0.6769514679908752,
-0.30070480704307556,
-0.24784855544567108,
0.12926128506660461,
0.6445875763893127,
0.4549122750759125,
-0.058990173041820526,
-0.7036524415016174,
0.557079553604126,
-0.10796560347080231,
0.07418914139270782,
0.10191863775253296,
0.5410805344581604,
0.0690782219171524,
0.7741711139678955,
0.3682655990123749,
0.14229023456573486,
0.09661231935024261,
0.06792255491018295,
0.5403175354003906,
-0.4087930917739868,
0.03865218907594681,
-0.9382228851318359,
0.35696184635162354,
-0.07430752366781235,
-0.25026050209999084,
1.1289467811584473,
0.6644518375396729,
0.6284068822860718,
-0.06030108779668808,
0.7011226415634155,
0.28917673230171204,
0.5375897884368896,
-0.7321793437004089,
0.43083781003952026,
-0.4212858974933624,
0.5081135630607605,
0.06734667718410492,
-1.0664968490600586,
0.11744242906570435,
0.6404431462287903,
-0.7328997254371643,
0.11325972527265549,
0.6416759490966797,
0.6711233854293823,
-0.06437217444181442,
0.11138631403446198,
0.4748024344444275,
0.6269044876098633,
0.13983523845672607,
0.4281199276447296,
1.0249320268630981,
-0.11881671845912933,
0.34783920645713806,
0.16447141766548157,
-0.00977011676877737,
-0.09991710633039474,
-0.9518159031867981,
-0.9913325309753418,
-0.22643791139125824,
-0.3369072675704956,
-0.5776971578598022,
0.28184905648231506,
0.647489070892334,
0.45284080505371094,
-0.8908004760742188,
-0.3230835497379303,
-0.18273961544036865,
0.3842616677284241,
0.0006369238835759461,
-0.26381397247314453,
0.28349947929382324,
-0.29640042781829834,
-0.518683671951294,
0.4267517328262329,
0.3572046756744385,
-0.08627010881900787,
-0.610867440700531,
-0.08857280015945435,
-0.09222325682640076,
0.29720401763916016,
0.33531734347343445,
0.1563911885023117,
-1.1797823905944824,
-0.344176709651947,
0.02365618571639061,
-0.21272972226142883,
-0.06107262149453163,
0.5633248090744019,
-0.49636808037757874,
0.13850851356983185,
0.5345317125320435,
0.6679430603981018,
0.19361063838005066,
0.2575571537017822,
0.5849862098693848,
-0.19716675579547882,
-0.2648259699344635,
0.21865412592887878,
0.4042304456233978,
0.6974319219589233,
-0.12701208889484406,
0.3403339087963104,
0.08689737319946289,
-0.8974602222442627,
-0.8295990824699402,
0.26461929082870483,
-0.8160471320152283,
-0.4425361752510071,
1.2560844421386719,
-0.4427833557128906,
-0.013672085478901863,
-0.03938774764537811,
-0.05642110854387283,
0.04234135150909424,
-0.2609497308731079,
0.6191841959953308,
0.9185033440589905,
-0.15432359278202057,
-0.003589540021494031,
-0.5788072347640991,
0.2374146729707718,
0.2926402986049652,
-0.6479576826095581,
0.2219191938638687,
0.5586465001106262,
0.5662001967430115,
0.25142261385917664,
0.516068160533905,
-0.1452210545539856,
0.020637057721614838,
-0.022523531690239906,
-0.3037244975566864,
-0.08843513578176498,
-0.1557534784078598,
-0.41985657811164856,
0.1442200094461441,
0.21831698715686798,
0.2753389775753021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16461v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16461v2
|
Large Language Models Perform on Par with Experts Identifying Mental Health Factors in Adolescent Online Forums
| 2024-04-25T09:42:50 | 2024-04-26T11:36:28 |
Isabelle Lorge, Dan W. Joyce, Andrey Kormilitzin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Mental health in children and adolescents has been steadily deteriorating
over the past few years. The recent advent of Large Language Models (LLMs)
offers much hope for cost and time efficient scaling of monitoring and
intervention, yet despite specifically prevalent issues such as school bullying
and eating disorders, previous studies on have not investigated performance in
this domain or for open information extraction where the set of answers is not
predetermined. We create a new dataset of Reddit posts from adolescents aged
12-19 annotated by expert psychiatrists for the following categories: TRAUMA,
PRECARITY, CONDITION, SYMPTOMS, SUICIDALITY and TREATMENT and compare expert
labels to annotations from two top performing LLMs (GPT3.5 and GPT4). In
addition, we create two synthetic datasets to assess whether LLMs perform
better when annotating data as they generate it. We find GPT4 to be on par with
human inter-annotator agreement and performance on synthetic data to be
substantially higher, however we find the model still occasionally errs on
issues of negation and factuality and higher performance on synthetic data is
driven by greater complexity of real data rather than inherent advantage.
|
[
-0.5249520540237427,
-0.7209340929985046,
1.0742911100387573,
0.11962039023637772,
-0.05717551335692406,
0.22376340627670288,
-0.35442227125167847,
-0.8331952095031738,
0.2674773335456848,
0.320421040058136,
-0.6213245987892151,
-0.4166966378688812,
-1.0329957008361816,
0.28259968757629395,
-0.477944552898407,
0.8621832728385925,
0.04966059699654579,
0.0762053057551384,
-0.27286049723625183,
0.25623220205307007,
-0.08431840687990189,
-0.6446831226348877,
-1.1241403818130493,
-0.34437114000320435,
0.614624559879303,
0.21561802923679352,
0.6038545966148376,
0.5913748741149902,
0.6458701491355896,
0.29808199405670166,
-0.10526537895202637,
0.13740313053131104,
-0.7001163363456726,
0.07829979062080383,
-0.5993456840515137,
-0.03649025782942772,
-0.6093380451202393,
0.038291625678539276,
0.2578703761100769,
0.6841269135475159,
-0.06296242028474808,
0.15042322874069214,
-0.022073933854699135,
0.29356133937835693,
-0.3728327751159668,
0.12123085558414459,
-0.5129629969596863,
0.03892354294657707,
-0.11302648484706879,
-0.011267914436757565,
-0.18531043827533722,
-0.33757147192955017,
-0.013393008150160313,
-0.544380784034729,
0.15607136487960815,
-0.20100244879722595,
0.5442568063735962,
0.29606714844703674,
-0.6716452240943909,
-0.18552745878696442,
-0.9048829674720764,
0.5035880208015442,
-0.9190013408660889,
0.31488755345344543,
0.4993310272693634,
0.0057303812354803085,
-0.28321632742881775,
-0.6378888487815857,
-0.6458361744880676,
0.10733717679977417,
-0.10760766267776489,
-0.052382707595825195,
-0.3975721597671509,
0.15464918315410614,
0.6032325625419617,
0.14822107553482056,
-0.5558249950408936,
0.3382203280925751,
-0.5593184232711792,
-0.16014865040779114,
0.8892995119094849,
0.39157792925834656,
0.42569154500961304,
-0.04059756547212601,
-0.04865604639053345,
0.13714206218719482,
-0.6585450172424316,
-0.06659802049398422,
0.12698504328727722,
0.24051053822040558,
0.05913429707288742,
0.7917895317077637,
-0.15346741676330566,
0.3913094103336334,
0.3793409466743469,
-0.4416893720626831,
0.2348344773054123,
-0.12773719429969788,
0.23070192337036133,
0.1719738394021988,
0.9839174747467041,
0.805661678314209,
0.3238030970096588,
-0.08166655898094177,
-0.47357526421546936,
0.22931793332099915,
0.3535672724246979,
-0.8038570880889893,
-0.3418453335762024,
0.10714500397443771,
-0.44727620482444763,
0.1652422696352005,
-0.02122795581817627,
-0.8350019454956055,
-0.7088064551353455,
-0.562798798084259,
0.2769540548324585,
-0.2089262753725052,
-0.48085588216781616,
-0.03522074222564697,
0.2726074755191803,
-0.30791139602661133,
0.3062041699886322,
-0.7457070350646973,
0.5955138802528381,
0.8748555183410645,
0.8405629992485046,
-0.39471104741096497,
0.17192625999450684,
-0.17141442000865936,
0.03628058731555939,
-0.5015961527824402,
0.9048424959182739,
-0.7497645616531372,
-0.15266253054141998,
-0.06274213641881943,
0.15359696745872498,
-0.13376042246818542,
-0.6698133945465088,
0.6172009110450745,
-0.10939768701791763,
-0.09433884918689728,
-0.32598045468330383,
-0.665258526802063,
0.01769101619720459,
-0.035133082419633865,
-0.48815232515335083,
0.8655244708061218,
0.11809875816106796,
-0.8308770656585693,
0.39989882707595825,
-0.5389938354492188,
-0.2521969676017761,
0.1289009004831314,
-0.17843177914619446,
-0.0250397939234972,
0.29917487502098083,
0.48718732595443726,
0.7343488931655884,
-0.31447210907936096,
0.5479892492294312,
-0.5625830292701721,
-0.3587121367454529,
0.4367581009864807,
-0.2284819781780243,
0.318828284740448,
0.08410968631505966,
-0.22966523468494415,
0.07981609553098679,
-0.7137195467948914,
0.020775409415364265,
0.03091634251177311,
-0.005931790918111801,
-0.43345990777015686,
0.12058304995298386,
0.03564558923244476,
0.49914664030075073,
0.12186580896377563,
-0.7309442162513733,
0.010256105102598667,
-0.2808377742767334,
0.6717021465301514,
0.5510132908821106,
0.4418484568595886,
-0.23151114583015442,
-0.3596872091293335,
0.6898376941680908,
-0.004227872472256422,
0.07801686227321625,
0.1993585228919983,
-0.5391602516174316,
-0.2861480116844177,
-0.4251611530780792,
-0.04975030571222305,
0.3512595295906067,
-0.7245606184005737,
0.28081145882606506,
-0.30689573287963867,
-0.6000755429267883,
-0.504033625125885,
-0.031212296336889267,
0.27835214138031006,
0.31730929017066956,
0.40076860785484314,
-0.3286575973033905,
-0.5413995981216431,
-1.107090711593628,
-0.26067230105400085,
-0.15111002326011658,
-0.06895625591278076,
0.21675889194011688,
0.4050188362598419,
-0.41383352875709534,
0.6722768545150757,
-0.4583750367164612,
-0.09533608704805374,
-0.29706281423568726,
0.38000836968421936,
0.029095835983753204,
0.3282445967197418,
0.4560464024543762,
-0.5118417739868164,
-0.5614669919013977,
-0.06798367202281952,
-0.6460751295089722,
-0.41651657223701477,
0.0555376335978508,
0.16982734203338623,
-0.11530817300081253,
0.4700676202774048,
-0.7097408175468445,
0.10885840654373169,
0.530505359172821,
-0.3321543335914612,
0.3957585394382477,
0.061283983290195465,
0.03831236809492111,
-0.702363908290863,
-0.017570510506629944,
0.4065997302532196,
-0.3387824594974518,
-0.6992669105529785,
-0.227196604013443,
-0.09721268713474274,
-0.05205634981393814,
-0.32571715116500854,
0.2987384796142578,
-0.10912508517503738,
0.1259453445672989,
-0.29625946283340454,
0.2793942093849182,
-0.29476532340049744,
0.1741355061531067,
-0.024750906974077225,
0.845655620098114,
0.42379629611968994,
-0.22580888867378235,
0.31891703605651855,
-0.25963354110717773,
-0.28014063835144043,
0.6251906752586365,
-0.7202205061912537,
0.13636790215969086,
-0.2569844722747803,
0.20748060941696167,
-0.8620843291282654,
-0.6336749792098999,
0.23326918482780457,
-0.43044885993003845,
0.2673727571964264,
0.19886833429336548,
-0.5673675537109375,
-0.44044333696365356,
-0.10910414904356003,
0.3709750771522522,
0.12376337498426437,
-0.15347957611083984,
0.21244683861732483,
0.8791033029556274,
-0.6348274350166321,
-0.2022213637828827,
-0.25344526767730713,
0.22567127645015717,
-0.2801491320133209,
-0.1415134221315384,
0.18924614787101746,
-0.02715395763516426,
-0.5275596976280212,
0.2684178948402405,
-0.11099560558795929,
-0.39283475279808044,
0.0945747122168541,
0.17683197557926178,
0.06350306421518326,
-0.2836047112941742,
0.4338831603527069,
0.05767784267663956,
-0.18305101990699768,
0.4849347770214081,
0.15107840299606323,
0.41878166794776917,
-0.09367043524980545,
-0.14466388523578644,
-0.45788443088531494,
0.4362783432006836,
0.5902886986732483,
-0.015475678257644176,
0.8732757568359375,
0.36646899580955505,
-0.7349058985710144,
-0.015465554781258106,
-0.6176333427429199,
-0.23962591588497162,
-0.3835664987564087,
0.4670388996601105,
-0.22638706862926483,
-0.9154282212257385,
0.3804314136505127,
0.142121821641922,
-0.06407711654901505,
0.6949095129966736,
0.35813108086586,
-0.09853465110063553,
1.5239057540893555,
0.4660870432853699,
0.14562754333019257,
0.07502484321594238,
0.09712245315313339,
0.5417168736457825,
-0.6812477111816406,
-0.21370571851730347,
-0.2887890636920929,
-0.19394665956497192,
-0.6539867520332336,
-0.1713998168706894,
0.41835227608680725,
-0.17140841484069824,
-0.4242793321609497,
0.04259980842471123,
-0.5547239780426025,
0.3653901219367981,
0.11446097493171692,
0.22645938396453857,
0.2846548855304718,
-0.1651739627122879,
0.1298733502626419,
-0.58917236328125,
-0.5526726245880127,
-0.5986593961715698,
1.0842158794403076,
0.43682175874710083,
0.7985567450523376,
0.06715329736471176,
0.3756644129753113,
0.18458931148052216,
0.761791467666626,
-0.5870848894119263,
0.6218770146369934,
-0.21767407655715942,
-0.7016788721084595,
-0.12664060294628143,
-0.6634842753410339,
-0.7620623707771301,
0.20470209419727325,
-0.4788071811199188,
-1.00985586643219,
0.11975730955600739,
-0.05304711312055588,
-0.5509490370750427,
0.3329739272594452,
-0.5083213448524475,
0.5309396386146545,
-0.3239392936229706,
-0.50068598985672,
-0.2028409093618393,
-0.4087819755077362,
0.5160396099090576,
-0.5767262578010559,
0.39212286472320557,
-0.47516247630119324,
-0.13252165913581848,
1.0825062990188599,
-0.2553637623786926,
0.6880301833152771,
-0.057872213423252106,
-0.10963249206542969,
0.09289287775754929,
-0.10196289420127869,
0.0325385145843029,
0.08838146924972534,
0.04774313047528267,
0.0013882284983992577,
0.31165310740470886,
-0.09513628482818604,
-0.5936755537986755,
1.0054020881652832,
-0.9964427947998047,
-0.7654882073402405,
-0.5122583508491516,
-0.26245132088661194,
-0.5192572474479675,
0.28628411889076233,
0.013051535934209824,
0.47670742869377136,
0.19320617616176605,
0.4251917004585266,
0.7051395177841187,
-0.19352088868618011,
0.08723576366901398,
0.39468276500701904,
-0.4570421278476715,
-0.6298645734786987,
0.7386419177055359,
0.38443273305892944,
0.15386462211608887,
-0.024893000721931458,
0.23094868659973145,
-0.268119215965271,
-0.48175397515296936,
-0.08952387422323227,
0.6565132737159729,
-0.6514761447906494,
-0.12940317392349243,
-0.7949880361557007,
-0.43055516481399536,
-0.5673606395721436,
0.019141416996717453,
-0.48942509293556213,
-0.3503604829311371,
-0.06599747389554977,
-0.4706912934780121,
0.24474762380123138,
1.1973507404327393,
-0.19567225873470306,
0.06897224485874176,
-0.7539013028144836,
0.3205886781215668,
0.2172466665506363,
0.45032423734664917,
0.252925843000412,
-0.21899695694446564,
-0.2405949980020523,
0.01894090510904789,
-0.3273126780986786,
-0.8756598830223083,
0.37943312525749207,
0.13113246858119965,
0.5756369233131409,
0.6439930200576782,
0.2723875939846039,
0.8575968146324158,
-0.212065652012825,
0.7015204429626465,
0.11300642043352127,
-0.6496412754058838,
0.3052394390106201,
-0.4081971347332001,
0.1670311689376831,
0.558779239654541,
0.8984591960906982,
-0.6845384836196899,
-0.4985960125923157,
-0.5341062545776367,
-0.9485927224159241,
0.6268321871757507,
-0.007817009463906288,
-0.03840360417962074,
-0.28978240489959717,
0.5541637539863586,
0.11888380348682404,
0.2751684784889221,
-0.7088605761528015,
-0.12612193822860718,
0.03604807332158089,
-0.46153026819229126,
-0.3266979455947876,
-0.5365605354309082,
-0.15712007880210876,
-0.4258735775947571,
0.6364644765853882,
-0.08323471993207932,
0.3552619516849518,
0.2783019542694092,
0.21132874488830566,
-0.5287603735923767,
0.008552046492695808,
0.3864007294178009,
1.0525206327438354,
-0.11668829619884491,
0.3524358868598938,
-0.05906004086136818,
-0.4812583029270172,
0.282343327999115,
0.0564558170735836,
-0.15015874803066254,
-0.28223034739494324,
0.7984906435012817,
0.7323586940765381,
0.3317456543445587,
-0.8885385394096375,
0.4470934569835663,
-0.23818160593509674,
-0.19556193053722382,
-0.3392218351364136,
0.2683672606945038,
0.09943941980600357,
0.3602389693260193,
0.23846566677093506,
-0.2677907347679138,
0.08361080288887024,
-0.6210539937019348,
0.142084002494812,
0.16009782254695892,
-0.35897406935691833,
-0.65653395652771,
0.5690965056419373,
0.046051617711782455,
-0.32507017254829407,
0.46496278047561646,
-0.025029148906469345,
-0.49081510305404663,
0.353079617023468,
0.5005894899368286,
0.574533224105835,
-0.18964789807796478,
0.266267329454422,
0.672636091709137,
0.35988539457321167,
-0.19989530742168427,
0.23358941078186035,
0.43078097701072693,
-0.56105637550354,
-0.4509640336036682,
-0.46264076232910156,
-0.2885347008705139,
0.6813104748725891,
-0.823296308517456,
-0.1175270602107048,
-0.5522692799568176,
-0.6112906336784363,
-0.026680313050746918,
0.15970583260059357,
-0.7021018266677856,
0.483024537563324,
0.2035185992717743,
0.5711179375648499,
-0.9608284831047058,
0.486005574464798,
0.9005432724952698,
-0.14940498769283295,
-0.5700191259384155,
0.18286548554897308,
0.17214849591255188,
-0.1920223981142044,
0.38822445273399353,
0.3076840341091156,
0.05435900762677193,
-0.1486455500125885,
-0.5619524121284485,
-1.1933521032333374,
0.5844395756721497,
0.20263992249965668,
-0.6234157681465149,
0.011245443485677242,
0.19725580513477325,
0.9678365588188171,
-0.4891704022884369,
0.33293935656547546,
0.5464955568313599,
0.5063222646713257,
0.06496927887201309,
-0.8733053803443909,
0.0720316544175148,
-0.22369696199893951,
-0.15875343978405,
0.021053310483694077,
-0.3669227659702301,
0.8299911022186279,
-0.06172360107302666,
-0.433938205242157,
-0.24733632802963257,
0.42401379346847534,
-0.02670276165008545,
0.3252016007900238,
0.38344815373420715,
0.5377624034881592,
0.8106874227523804,
-0.08905135095119476,
0.8747594356536865,
-0.48973140120506287,
0.25688058137893677,
1.177255392074585,
-0.34044215083122253,
1.0187182426452637,
0.15015968680381775,
-0.19219882786273956,
0.07212134450674057,
0.9264217019081116,
0.19452175498008728,
0.47704559564590454,
-0.012421660125255585,
-0.1873260885477066,
-0.5103047490119934,
-0.23468394577503204,
-0.11574316024780273,
0.07048060745000839,
0.7478641867637634,
-0.30313101410865784,
-0.08554380387067795,
0.1136518195271492,
0.3460937440395355,
0.22316716611385345,
-0.39980873465538025,
0.9392607808113098,
0.2693811357021332,
-0.6816496849060059,
0.4984641373157501,
0.07467847317457199,
0.3111249506473541,
-0.27464038133621216,
-0.018965203315019608,
-0.11353515088558197,
0.22458523511886597,
-0.17265284061431885,
-0.9679545164108276,
0.40205901861190796,
0.1679634153842926,
-0.03759317472577095,
-0.19049978256225586,
0.8867712020874023,
-0.4461649954319,
-0.8200606107711792,
0.3595970571041107,
0.5510544776916504,
0.18215566873550415,
0.0018199027981609106,
-0.5357196927070618,
0.15757247805595398,
-0.3169727921485901,
-0.31948843598365784,
0.45335233211517334,
0.5691536068916321,
-0.20049238204956055,
0.7596126794815063,
0.5435129404067993,
0.4820641875267029,
-0.07487082481384277,
-0.19069479405879974,
0.9252795577049255,
-0.6103077530860901,
-0.006214790046215057,
-0.696073055267334,
0.16502498090267181,
-0.28307878971099854,
-0.44696947932243347,
0.7063634395599365,
0.273375540971756,
0.8350886106491089,
0.31261691451072693,
0.6928712725639343,
0.10144459456205368,
0.9747875928878784,
-0.2785710096359253,
0.662429928779602,
-0.5853117108345032,
-0.0027576182037591934,
-0.1709403544664383,
-0.9628058671951294,
-0.37780526280403137,
0.8100438117980957,
-0.6603963375091553,
0.04626155644655228,
0.7100076079368591,
0.7086747288703918,
0.11179947853088379,
0.06080949306488037,
0.19889070093631744,
0.7710664868354797,
0.654654860496521,
0.5373164415359497,
0.7720053195953369,
0.19887594878673553,
-0.2166411578655243,
-0.44925785064697266,
-0.20568051934242249,
-0.004286687355488539,
-0.5220298767089844,
-1.1181831359863281,
-0.45431891083717346,
-0.27964019775390625,
0.099260613322258,
0.17784632742404938,
1.286952257156372,
0.5086619853973389,
-0.651681661605835,
0.08399859070777893,
0.3119102716445923,
-0.1463828980922699,
-0.19509054720401764,
-0.2050645500421524,
0.13824480772018433,
0.036813899874687195,
-0.4945947229862213,
0.2836158871650696,
0.12375571578741074,
-0.20729967951774597,
-0.5567439198493958,
0.291599303483963,
-0.02283712849020958,
0.2555164694786072,
0.6816043257713318,
-0.07481278479099274,
-0.73325115442276,
-0.41623905301094055,
-0.32423707842826843,
-0.22490908205509186,
-0.0002161961019737646,
0.5686107873916626,
-0.5133479833602905,
0.30390942096710205,
0.2448514848947525,
0.5515015721321106,
0.1842588186264038,
0.17999714612960815,
0.4250791370868683,
-0.11698169261217117,
-0.4711196720600128,
0.3465462028980255,
0.267789751291275,
0.5530008673667908,
-0.39621061086654663,
0.41486456990242004,
0.2920531928539276,
-0.5729408264160156,
-0.8565007448196411,
-0.19991475343704224,
-0.44190990924835205,
-0.1541685163974762,
1.0830549001693726,
-0.30539894104003906,
-0.17439278960227966,
-0.20400533080101013,
-0.25712165236473083,
-0.030383283272385597,
-0.5349297523498535,
1.054002285003662,
0.9095572233200073,
-0.24155446887016296,
-0.37773382663726807,
-0.9189926385879517,
0.42680269479751587,
-0.038992010056972504,
-0.727692186832428,
-0.05054626986384392,
0.58470618724823,
0.16206295788288116,
-0.037157800048589706,
0.5050050020217896,
0.011484907940030098,
0.06967251002788544,
-0.15285983681678772,
-0.19608382880687714,
0.023916827514767647,
-0.43197983503341675,
-0.10487962514162064,
0.2567686140537262,
0.07750654220581055,
0.6655834913253784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16442v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16442v1
|
Contextual Categorization Enhancement through LLMs Latent-Space
| 2024-04-25T09:20:51 | 2024-04-25T09:20:51 |
Zineddine Bettouche, Anas Safi, Andreas Fischer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Managing the semantic quality of the categorization in large textual
datasets, such as Wikipedia, presents significant challenges in terms of
complexity and cost. In this paper, we propose leveraging transformer models to
distill semantic information from texts in the Wikipedia dataset and its
associated categories into a latent space. We then explore different approaches
based on these encodings to assess and enhance the semantic identity of the
categories. Our graphical approach is powered by Convex Hull, while we utilize
Hierarchical Navigable Small Worlds (HNSWs) for the hierarchical approach. As a
solution to the information loss caused by the dimensionality reduction, we
modulate the following mathematical solution: an exponential decay function
driven by the Euclidean distances between the high-dimensional encodings of the
textual categories. This function represents a filter built around a contextual
category and retrieves items with a certain Reconsideration Probability (RP).
Retrieving high-RP items serves as a tool for database administrators to
improve data groupings by providing recommendations and identifying outliers
within a contextual framework.
|
[
-0.533435583114624,
-0.781507134437561,
0.5093563199043274,
-0.2149009108543396,
-0.37697315216064453,
-0.04392022639513016,
-0.2788006365299225,
-0.21124692261219025,
0.4545920193195343,
0.4494148790836334,
-0.5785688757896423,
-0.43845081329345703,
-0.5804390907287598,
0.14723250269889832,
-0.4653829038143158,
1.0289641618728638,
0.12895901501178741,
-0.1787494271993637,
-0.5056424140930176,
0.035608138889074326,
-0.22911949455738068,
-0.3678315281867981,
-0.30864545702934265,
-0.14557726681232452,
0.8936930894851685,
0.40684670209884644,
0.9118222594261169,
0.7223928570747375,
0.7187908887863159,
0.2664579749107361,
-0.31154194474220276,
0.33097630739212036,
-0.7187513709068298,
0.1577993780374527,
-0.5791760683059692,
-0.4237060844898224,
-0.4546140730381012,
-0.1099640429019928,
0.5938887000083923,
0.8501319885253906,
-0.1547389030456543,
0.2693781852722168,
0.11141456663608551,
0.30552980303764343,
-0.664715588092804,
0.1904684156179428,
-0.6413542628288269,
0.26499027013778687,
-0.27916908264160156,
-0.5131943821907043,
-0.4032687246799469,
-0.028376324102282524,
0.18982098996639252,
-0.9833858609199524,
0.22258351743221283,
0.1664370894432068,
0.7658270597457886,
0.5681722164154053,
-0.5560031533241272,
-0.2794284224510193,
-0.7543449997901917,
0.7631272077560425,
-0.4295070469379425,
0.5996614098548889,
0.25853225588798523,
0.07583585381507874,
-0.2838965654373169,
-0.9118648767471313,
-0.7761544585227966,
0.10404158383607864,
-0.4012174606323242,
0.10096491128206253,
-0.2805391252040863,
-0.2813616096973419,
0.20042753219604492,
0.4489332139492035,
-0.4675007164478302,
0.23845669627189636,
-0.24674305319786072,
-0.11342652142047882,
0.4647912085056305,
0.3493974208831787,
0.4924803078174591,
-0.743816614151001,
-0.18000255525112152,
-0.14827941358089447,
-0.672572672367096,
-0.20051860809326172,
0.057441942393779755,
0.15677639842033386,
0.18460477888584137,
0.7636609077453613,
-0.1557365357875824,
0.5120624303817749,
0.07084750384092331,
-0.38473427295684814,
0.15074631571769714,
-0.30262377858161926,
-0.1184278279542923,
-0.2664279639720917,
0.3782876133918762,
0.49836161732673645,
-0.16968394815921783,
-0.3717586398124695,
0.0476326048374176,
-0.17393971979618073,
0.5146321058273315,
-0.8032512664794922,
-0.23845604062080383,
-0.00000852654738991987,
-0.5973318815231323,
-0.2671892046928406,
0.13096778094768524,
-0.8937288522720337,
-0.39973366260528564,
-0.3131274878978729,
0.3795281648635864,
-0.10963129997253418,
-0.07815594971179962,
-0.21427252888679504,
-0.20635254681110382,
0.15617436170578003,
0.5667520761489868,
-0.9586880803108215,
0.05157443508505821,
0.6470347046852112,
0.7867302894592285,
-0.6127912402153015,
0.06656040996313095,
-0.22451569139957428,
0.6001513004302979,
-0.28707772493362427,
0.8366515040397644,
-0.40667587518692017,
-0.43974044919013977,
-0.17320570349693298,
0.23729963600635529,
0.22708174586296082,
-0.5631141662597656,
0.5350087285041809,
-0.8017434477806091,
0.256404310464859,
-0.16937831044197083,
-0.5739858150482178,
-0.05743672698736191,
0.21780523657798767,
-0.9250513315200806,
1.2554396390914917,
0.28842538595199585,
-0.9880085587501526,
0.5618730783462524,
-0.4420720040798187,
-0.19787666201591492,
0.3061645030975342,
-0.20867431163787842,
-0.32482749223709106,
0.33151763677597046,
0.3822232484817505,
0.6275236010551453,
-0.20454640686511993,
0.4727930426597595,
-0.2670714259147644,
-0.23725499212741852,
0.1361960470676422,
-0.4794122874736786,
0.4256523847579956,
0.15016283094882965,
-0.20831279456615448,
0.12321892380714417,
-0.8073880672454834,
-0.10766230523586273,
0.03267204388976097,
-0.5215948820114136,
-0.7673861384391785,
0.33168816566467285,
0.06386128067970276,
0.31051522493362427,
0.19619342684745789,
-0.2657129466533661,
0.24112071096897125,
-0.5630751848220825,
0.23382508754730225,
0.6703923940658569,
0.2352200150489807,
0.7413205504417419,
0.04317868873476982,
0.16692160069942474,
0.2424243688583374,
0.1419701725244522,
0.2355540245771408,
-0.52089524269104,
-0.9594434499740601,
-0.15422913432121277,
0.03313174471259117,
0.4992251992225647,
-1.2894643545150757,
0.7502128481864929,
-0.9752039313316345,
-0.5103039741516113,
-0.03180721402168274,
0.1604989469051361,
-0.11627639830112457,
0.6447651982307434,
0.5324047207832336,
-0.32066795229911804,
-0.17043158411979675,
-0.9708864688873291,
0.11982347071170807,
-0.08839821070432663,
-0.5872437953948975,
0.3680461049079895,
0.6270512342453003,
-0.556117832660675,
1.1910713911056519,
-0.5906702280044556,
-0.3878413140773773,
0.13062044978141785,
-0.2147974669933319,
0.1994791179895401,
0.33291390538215637,
0.2227509468793869,
-1.140602469444275,
-0.35118451714515686,
0.04029491916298866,
-0.7751777172088623,
-0.07638464868068695,
0.16702309250831604,
-0.2985881268978119,
-0.1533665508031845,
0.5519529581069946,
-0.48442408442497253,
0.5875897407531738,
0.1810036301612854,
-0.49001750349998474,
0.015154888853430748,
-0.1418149769306183,
0.055298373103141785,
-1.0739576816558838,
-0.05832985043525696,
-0.11851911246776581,
-0.03869790583848953,
-0.5380986928939819,
-0.001807035063393414,
0.029927751049399376,
-0.024920351803302765,
-0.3066064119338989,
0.4654614329338074,
-0.25202280282974243,
-0.026345571503043175,
-0.0866948738694191,
0.6212809085845947,
0.04036494344472885,
0.5078542232513428,
0.12096355855464935,
0.6631957292556763,
0.09654492139816284,
-0.5950065851211548,
0.4114731550216675,
0.4581778943538666,
-0.25209176540374756,
0.857479989528656,
-0.30517444014549255,
-0.17121121287345886,
-0.43209734559059143,
0.42860153317451477,
-1.004553198814392,
-0.29082998633384705,
0.20178481936454773,
-0.13242186605930328,
0.33610159158706665,
0.07729601114988327,
-0.5740948915481567,
-0.32068273425102234,
-0.38858136534690857,
0.23214998841285706,
0.2040577381849289,
-0.869638204574585,
0.6377456784248352,
0.5063796639442444,
-0.2116568386554718,
-0.6398914456367493,
-0.5942785143852234,
0.19960227608680725,
-0.45164382457733154,
-0.6663824915885925,
0.8405687212944031,
-0.08205119520425797,
-0.1557484269142151,
0.24833884835243225,
-0.13360238075256348,
-0.014289760030806065,
0.058043237775564194,
0.16936907172203064,
0.36909162998199463,
-0.10613110661506653,
0.46729734539985657,
0.33456259965896606,
-0.19643817842006683,
-0.0038962808903306723,
-0.5181083083152771,
0.1570882797241211,
0.24016603827476501,
-0.11288102716207504,
-0.19542524218559265,
0.22291377186775208,
0.29627007246017456,
0.13742445409297943,
0.8829770684242249,
0.8892964124679565,
-0.4632052779197693,
-0.3142893612384796,
-0.4092760980129242,
-0.12997712194919586,
-0.45351865887641907,
0.5054088830947876,
-0.3576733469963074,
-1.1021208763122559,
0.31857234239578247,
-0.13909441232681274,
-0.11704160273075104,
0.7645084857940674,
0.7021616101264954,
-0.18050965666770935,
0.6748899817466736,
0.7575653195381165,
0.03624628484249115,
0.5365949869155884,
-0.35102105140686035,
0.31757572293281555,
-0.8455511331558228,
-0.5289705395698547,
-0.4490404427051544,
-0.10737483203411102,
-0.7698292136192322,
-0.7891510128974915,
0.5864809155464172,
0.029482068493962288,
-0.03875979408621788,
0.21756476163864136,
-0.6685999035835266,
0.39120298624038696,
0.2673929035663605,
0.29556119441986084,
0.5228963494300842,
0.44753608107566833,
-0.0008352293516509235,
-0.4612150490283966,
-0.8542720675468445,
-0.7158293724060059,
0.8824752569198608,
0.3872837424278259,
0.8619016408920288,
0.382411390542984,
0.43384066224098206,
0.3544345796108246,
0.5897826552391052,
-0.8583475351333618,
0.4449448883533478,
-0.3412719964981079,
-0.5008588433265686,
-0.6443132758140564,
-0.5597180724143982,
-0.8901634216308594,
0.5344236493110657,
-0.36615484952926636,
-0.7090936303138733,
0.3897726535797119,
-0.2126147300004959,
0.07367958128452301,
0.3722156286239624,
-0.340115487575531,
0.6109893321990967,
0.09262806922197342,
-0.5272818207740784,
-0.23907524347305298,
-0.4828234016895294,
0.10690094530582428,
-0.2667725086212158,
0.342061311006546,
0.04971914365887642,
-0.503150224685669,
0.9612924456596375,
-0.4463585913181305,
0.6710459589958191,
-0.03834574297070503,
-0.5596645474433899,
0.0886169970035553,
-0.022444482892751694,
0.36856967210769653,
0.2026912271976471,
0.2777950167655945,
0.24768425524234772,
-0.017460297793149948,
-0.18798688054084778,
-0.7908183336257935,
0.7536245584487915,
-0.7711808681488037,
-0.5847497582435608,
-0.025441598147153854,
-0.2909368574619293,
-0.3008436858654022,
0.19577442109584808,
0.435088574886322,
0.2693518102169037,
-0.07260563224554062,
0.45130741596221924,
0.8715354800224304,
-0.30988767743110657,
0.2397911250591278,
0.2321341335773468,
0.04972557723522186,
-0.3786199390888214,
0.7903069853782654,
0.22185075283050537,
-0.049363136291503906,
0.7528800368309021,
-0.004610371310263872,
-0.38501954078674316,
-0.3126663863658905,
-0.2872105538845062,
0.1167016252875328,
-1.2255347967147827,
-0.4418843984603882,
-0.6393271088600159,
-0.13880887627601624,
-0.1565154790878296,
-0.10256011039018631,
0.04070688411593437,
-0.5943009853363037,
-0.5037059187889099,
-0.08535066992044449,
0.019174333661794662,
0.7453620433807373,
0.13000230491161346,
0.44887474179267883,
-0.47966837882995605,
0.41003087162971497,
0.4393700659275055,
0.428870290517807,
0.20042668282985687,
-0.701216995716095,
-0.3308238983154297,
-0.3981299102306366,
-0.22643296420574188,
-0.7401598691940308,
0.34739720821380615,
0.07218854874372482,
0.7008641362190247,
0.2964905798435211,
-0.1021415963768959,
0.7293804287910461,
-0.7085914015769958,
0.8630688786506653,
0.15435117483139038,
-0.8232694864273071,
0.6614922881126404,
-0.15244804322719574,
-0.13550342619419098,
0.14439883828163147,
0.536116898059845,
-0.5118280053138733,
-0.3079252541065216,
-0.6263648271560669,
-0.9347758293151855,
0.5610371828079224,
0.37361210584640503,
0.20126965641975403,
-0.04774095118045807,
0.5943463444709778,
-0.10013594478368759,
-0.053766295313835144,
-0.7809510231018066,
-0.3584214448928833,
-0.21343004703521729,
-0.21221894025802612,
-0.2819267809391022,
-0.5733082890510559,
-0.055905960500240326,
-0.35765209794044495,
0.6877174377441406,
-0.15711912512779236,
0.12363231927156448,
0.14666354656219482,
-0.37710028886795044,
0.005757252685725689,
0.4221477508544922,
0.15304677188396454,
0.6350845694541931,
0.0764320120215416,
0.3586335778236389,
0.38813653588294983,
-0.6575084924697876,
0.23582586646080017,
-0.14813114702701569,
-0.14116227626800537,
0.10336071252822876,
0.5221604704856873,
0.5419799089431763,
0.5569443106651306,
-0.2818428575992584,
0.5205991864204407,
-0.10720061510801315,
0.26467373967170715,
-0.08355201780796051,
0.16661015152931213,
0.07151852548122406,
0.2293519377708435,
0.5506060123443604,
-0.4620848000049591,
0.32943156361579895,
-0.17892804741859436,
0.24464063346385956,
0.2695353031158447,
-0.202189102768898,
0.0036788301076740026,
0.5779321193695068,
0.07327963411808014,
0.015305466949939728,
0.6081661581993103,
0.06473685801029205,
-0.21999575197696686,
0.3849121928215027,
0.46234604716300964,
0.40890324115753174,
-0.05900610238313675,
0.16841717064380646,
0.42776912450790405,
0.3924964964389801,
0.17295001447200775,
-0.28172531723976135,
-0.3070177435874939,
-0.7249495983123779,
-0.35880017280578613,
-0.890425980091095,
-0.30954521894454956,
0.04802825301885605,
-0.5703965425491333,
0.1902054250240326,
-0.07647381722927094,
-0.3132067024707794,
0.27492275834083557,
0.09238828718662262,
-0.5274903774261475,
0.36010584235191345,
0.07593565434217453,
0.7978465557098389,
-0.6596532464027405,
0.72889244556427,
0.4382602870464325,
-0.3023235499858856,
-0.4621427655220032,
-0.029784712940454483,
-0.24153326451778412,
-0.3820492625236511,
0.9743728637695312,
-0.12507066130638123,
-0.06658224761486053,
-0.012768096290528774,
-0.5111365914344788,
-1.1036263704299927,
1.3080968856811523,
0.11868022382259369,
-0.4218950867652893,
-0.16063162684440613,
0.13660140335559845,
0.6719527244567871,
-0.29246580600738525,
-0.08399150520563126,
0.4137156009674072,
0.4661352038383484,
0.033599961549043655,
-0.6244743466377258,
0.040802471339702606,
-0.15399852395057678,
0.4889156222343445,
0.0857592299580574,
-0.10375955700874329,
0.7227705121040344,
0.08023908734321594,
-0.44156402349472046,
-0.1628502905368805,
0.6860552430152893,
-0.01738339476287365,
0.15353727340698242,
0.5136386156082153,
0.38416966795921326,
0.866286039352417,
-0.1485215723514557,
0.8356915712356567,
-0.034406572580337524,
0.7186636328697205,
0.8674063086509705,
0.13921746611595154,
0.9274640083312988,
0.7226648926734924,
-0.2566368877887726,
0.7899914979934692,
0.6621754169464111,
-0.05168675631284714,
0.43926072120666504,
0.13212883472442627,
-0.08083885908126831,
-0.104986771941185,
-0.22610588371753693,
-0.10160938650369644,
0.3712523281574249,
0.7707259654998779,
-0.24833478033542633,
-0.2802993655204773,
0.22138607501983643,
-0.06276228278875351,
0.02992832288146019,
-0.3332476019859314,
0.9368467926979065,
-0.0357511006295681,
-0.36498650908470154,
0.3351168930530548,
0.25120896100997925,
0.7858132719993591,
-0.23799607157707214,
0.0022497728932648897,
-0.20937788486480713,
-0.0728209912776947,
-0.5326390266418457,
-0.8340749144554138,
0.4454592764377594,
-0.16127550601959229,
-0.4177252948284149,
-0.17650043964385986,
0.9517279267311096,
-0.39592593908309937,
-0.37229397892951965,
0.2698688209056854,
0.5637774467468262,
0.005943985655903816,
0.23749734461307526,
-0.3597252368927002,
-0.11483149230480194,
-0.3624959886074066,
-0.23261003196239471,
0.06278806924819946,
0.5014153122901917,
-0.3548104465007782,
0.5998621582984924,
0.656883716583252,
-0.07250439375638962,
-0.10688100755214691,
0.02249942161142826,
0.9034415483474731,
-0.6010829210281372,
-0.776923418045044,
-0.7914806604385376,
0.24924854934215546,
-0.29582852125167847,
0.053934745490550995,
0.8528741598129272,
0.4384949803352356,
0.9189966917037964,
-0.17839473485946655,
0.27312320470809937,
-0.14683353900909424,
0.2662898302078247,
-0.6073543429374695,
0.7897008657455444,
-0.8157685399055481,
0.3637063503265381,
-0.2693522572517395,
-1.0141706466674805,
-0.4482066035270691,
0.5592796802520752,
-0.32505863904953003,
-0.13577210903167725,
0.6143278479576111,
0.752374529838562,
-0.33275192975997925,
-0.20602969825267792,
0.40634673833847046,
0.029658528044819832,
0.3109326660633087,
0.3759440779685974,
0.9885311126708984,
-0.3298754096031189,
0.4519360661506653,
-0.2091769576072693,
-0.2926442623138428,
-0.22373045980930328,
-0.7641303539276123,
-0.8780215978622437,
-0.8433486223220825,
-0.2368372082710266,
-0.3304188549518585,
-0.33863961696624756,
0.4073108732700348,
0.8271685838699341,
-0.6385942697525024,
0.0497271902859211,
0.23656955361366272,
0.41806477308273315,
0.23661121726036072,
-0.3240130841732025,
0.6724603176116943,
-0.24497565627098083,
-0.6339224576950073,
0.028775809332728386,
0.6301102638244629,
-0.004274008795619011,
-0.5207738280296326,
0.02234511822462082,
0.12124858051538467,
0.04880698397755623,
0.9656247496604919,
-0.36129286885261536,
-0.8605249524116516,
-0.4094920754432678,
-0.08759500831365585,
-0.29455313086509705,
0.07952702790498734,
0.7799258828163147,
-0.7542418241500854,
0.3696536123752594,
0.4046231210231781,
0.5196858644485474,
0.5998902916908264,
-0.1272035539150238,
-0.004668484441936016,
-0.8246266841888428,
0.12065543234348297,
-0.03563154116272926,
0.27128514647483826,
0.360221266746521,
-0.7305729985237122,
0.6071487069129944,
0.45348140597343445,
-0.20662440359592438,
-0.5766711235046387,
0.04634599760174751,
-0.9078794717788696,
-0.39305567741394043,
0.906807005405426,
0.00046013679821044207,
-0.346043199300766,
-0.07084308564662933,
0.11648296564817429,
0.1518441140651703,
0.07569192349910736,
0.8101938366889954,
0.8132941722869873,
-0.0420641154050827,
0.05920739099383354,
-0.4031769335269928,
0.5677119493484497,
0.09410526603460312,
-1.1148263216018677,
-0.16326385736465454,
0.6976025700569153,
0.3576735258102417,
0.4715011417865753,
0.4308895468711853,
-0.1646384596824646,
-0.026994381099939346,
-0.16034185886383057,
-0.32621118426322937,
0.33527812361717224,
-0.37911567091941833,
-0.3546557128429413,
0.27572405338287354,
-0.33291617035865784,
0.2913593351840973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16418v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16418v1
|
Instruction Matters, a Simple yet Effective Task Selection Approach in Instruction Tuning for Specific Tasks
| 2024-04-25T08:49:47 | 2024-04-25T08:49:47 |
Changho Lee, Janghoon Han, Seonghyeon Ye, Stanley Jungkyu Choi, Honglak Lee, Kyunghoon Bae
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction tuning has shown its ability to not only enhance zero-shot
generalization across various tasks but also its effectiveness in improving the
performance of specific tasks. A crucial aspect in instruction tuning for a
particular task is a strategic selection of related tasks that offer meaningful
supervision, thereby enhancing efficiency and preventing performance
degradation from irrelevant tasks. Our research reveals that leveraging
instruction information \textit{alone} enables the identification of pertinent
tasks for instruction tuning. This approach is notably simpler compared to
traditional methods that necessitate complex measurements of pairwise
transferability between tasks or the creation of data samples for the target
task. Furthermore, by additionally learning the unique instructional template
style of the meta-dataset, we observe an improvement in task selection
accuracy, which contributes to enhanced overall performance. Experimental
results demonstrate that training on a small set of tasks, chosen solely based
on the instructions, leads to substantial performance improvements on
benchmarks like P3, Big-Bench, NIV2, and Big-Bench Hard. Significantly, these
improvements exceed those achieved by prior task selection methods,
highlighting the efficacy of our approach.
|
[
-0.2093515396118164,
-0.6139243245124817,
0.40165677666664124,
0.0345243364572525,
-0.10857691615819931,
-0.3151317536830902,
-0.3351023495197296,
-0.08955471962690353,
0.0031570589635521173,
0.3727686405181885,
-0.5356870889663696,
-0.5151134729385376,
-0.785374104976654,
-0.22609174251556396,
-0.27780407667160034,
1.1500730514526367,
0.04338511452078819,
0.16311293840408325,
-0.28427067399024963,
-0.023036517202854156,
-0.8306765556335449,
0.0814741924405098,
-0.7203025221824646,
-0.28867852687835693,
0.42065420746803284,
0.9609993100166321,
0.1577593982219696,
1.242234706878662,
0.8005010485649109,
0.2778066396713257,
0.2333860844373703,
0.31645113229751587,
-0.48476266860961914,
0.13650831580162048,
-0.3397255837917328,
-0.7189496159553528,
-0.45839688181877136,
0.20449602603912354,
0.35198256373405457,
0.6079486012458801,
-0.0808282420039177,
0.6991574168205261,
0.28246694803237915,
0.8243513703346252,
-1.083747386932373,
0.25204187631607056,
-0.5992820858955383,
0.30538490414619446,
-0.4588838219642639,
-0.50511234998703,
-0.4647058844566345,
-0.15726624429225922,
-0.0991934984922409,
-0.8084943890571594,
0.6520410180091858,
-0.08933567255735397,
0.3027040660381317,
0.3901579976081848,
-0.535944938659668,
-0.2073242962360382,
-0.9332393407821655,
0.8504432439804077,
-0.2181689739227295,
0.23924767971038818,
0.607582688331604,
0.22745686769485474,
0.23202191293239594,
-0.619873046875,
0.07756724208593369,
0.04050228372216225,
-0.023811064660549164,
0.5184937119483948,
0.12110775709152222,
0.39852604269981384,
0.4082038402557373,
0.2779042422771454,
-0.2617184817790985,
-0.04491332545876503,
-0.5522733926773071,
-0.08911877870559692,
0.44804826378822327,
0.21368806064128876,
0.20267024636268616,
0.016376499086618423,
-0.0439041443169117,
-0.24581024050712585,
-0.74962317943573,
0.3709486126899719,
0.3942704498767853,
0.24180932343006134,
0.12223342806100845,
0.3014031946659088,
-0.3438878357410431,
1.0387258529663086,
0.61919105052948,
-0.26409605145454407,
-0.13091419637203217,
-0.45386558771133423,
-0.19240139424800873,
0.19011904299259186,
0.40579715371131897,
0.22140362858772278,
-0.0113239586353302,
-0.42879432439804077,
0.11191615462303162,
-0.10146468877792358,
0.8435932397842407,
-0.7464630007743835,
-0.3825953006744385,
-0.20738916099071503,
-0.3470349609851837,
-0.0490979328751564,
0.29413846135139465,
-0.4929521679878235,
0.06226741522550583,
-0.7516693472862244,
0.48237866163253784,
-0.30031242966651917,
0.16695939004421234,
-0.21013186872005463,
-0.24138909578323364,
0.24239099025726318,
0.2273731678724289,
-1.5106788873672485,
0.13469526171684265,
0.8885562419891357,
0.47852426767349243,
-0.36848029494285583,
-0.17674338817596436,
-0.9162902235984802,
0.3768063187599182,
-0.5836673974990845,
0.7049787640571594,
-0.9254882335662842,
-0.4090898036956787,
-0.17979955673217773,
0.11791177839040756,
-0.4637836217880249,
-0.5677031874656677,
0.5135339498519897,
-0.46719297766685486,
-0.16196900606155396,
-0.4924682676792145,
-0.5013395547866821,
-0.04626075550913811,
-0.0837392583489418,
-0.6653666496276855,
0.9713115096092224,
0.1944693624973297,
-0.4701600968837738,
0.6864842176437378,
-0.6828780174255371,
-0.7733570337295532,
0.0043616038747131824,
-0.07560796290636063,
-0.33593425154685974,
0.4141717255115509,
0.09185700863599777,
0.5667945146560669,
0.04690280556678772,
-0.3376652002334595,
-0.024548953399062157,
-0.8512011766433716,
-0.2729222774505615,
-0.14718866348266602,
0.3197757601737976,
-0.11496029794216156,
-0.7404131889343262,
0.12339535355567932,
-0.5151550769805908,
0.3313301205635071,
-0.2551712095737457,
-0.43293097615242004,
-0.3821406960487366,
0.06525710225105286,
-0.5320580005645752,
-0.15714189410209656,
0.16425158083438873,
-0.3174702227115631,
0.3789326250553131,
-0.15747220814228058,
0.09275762736797333,
0.8176281452178955,
-0.007404018193483353,
0.8566921949386597,
-0.3201407790184021,
0.6057834625244141,
-0.17866936326026917,
0.30225202441215515,
0.045991770923137665,
-0.4447438418865204,
-0.8801621198654175,
-0.0907350480556488,
0.49844372272491455,
0.835414707660675,
-0.645352840423584,
0.26568135619163513,
-0.06779713183641434,
-0.4800163507461548,
-0.6414313912391663,
0.533322274684906,
0.7255381941795349,
0.560174286365509,
0.4125436544418335,
-0.1144949346780777,
-0.4520128667354584,
-0.9226201772689819,
-0.25582000613212585,
0.33698567748069763,
0.03914104774594307,
0.35000354051589966,
0.17039746046066284,
0.21524448692798615,
0.5091922879219055,
-0.6389591097831726,
-0.2178163230419159,
-0.12631335854530334,
0.3197411298751831,
0.11358589679002762,
0.39865127205848694,
0.42618700861930847,
-0.6489598155021667,
-0.9865319728851318,
0.06838855892419815,
-0.5764017105102539,
-0.08960317075252533,
-0.11599235236644745,
-0.35471218824386597,
-0.16150769591331482,
0.49761995673179626,
-0.1465650051832199,
0.4189782738685608,
0.3380952477455139,
-0.10086271166801453,
0.1869550198316574,
-0.40805456042289734,
0.6332017779350281,
-0.7002162337303162,
0.014272862114012241,
-0.06522528827190399,
-0.16577863693237305,
-0.6097114682197571,
-0.012510491535067558,
0.3788461685180664,
0.19228191673755646,
-0.23664122819900513,
0.1501588523387909,
-0.43182820081710815,
0.08174710720777512,
-0.3838922679424286,
-0.15408898890018463,
-0.11455173790454865,
0.6921185255050659,
-0.10093793272972107,
1.0315214395523071,
0.5568346977233887,
-0.7843858599662781,
0.19130177795886993,
0.25961533188819885,
-0.34705108404159546,
0.778815507888794,
-0.6411364078521729,
0.3391818106174469,
-0.06353592872619629,
-0.1883973926305771,
-0.7287811636924744,
-0.05660698935389519,
0.3692660927772522,
-0.017321577295660973,
0.7308851480484009,
-0.3764584958553314,
-0.213493213057518,
-0.025275804102420807,
-0.13631582260131836,
0.03771646320819855,
0.43197980523109436,
-0.2930506765842438,
0.24460181593894958,
0.19258008897304535,
-0.03360042721033096,
-0.7018325328826904,
-0.40688860416412354,
-0.4876571297645569,
-0.08412928879261017,
0.01907036453485489,
0.6983834505081177,
-0.12377001345157623,
0.08024147152900696,
-0.024433951824903488,
-0.7144334316253662,
-0.21367411315441132,
0.27218499779701233,
0.5234089493751526,
0.19244255125522614,
-0.13461019098758698,
0.2023555040359497,
0.5470379590988159,
-0.29542988538742065,
-0.0680801272392273,
-0.2227235585451126,
-0.03339633718132973,
0.2722637951374054,
-0.45139390230178833,
-0.5868787169456482,
0.3875746726989746,
0.306647390127182,
-0.28303712606430054,
0.5983282923698425,
0.8080334067344666,
0.1459813266992569,
-0.5644218325614929,
-0.3646249771118164,
-0.41032394766807556,
-0.49210259318351746,
0.34830376505851746,
-0.18152888119220734,
-0.5202999711036682,
-0.3108261823654175,
-0.11381601542234421,
0.327711284160614,
0.15331542491912842,
0.12028256803750992,
-0.35388749837875366,
1.1666982173919678,
0.7465047240257263,
-0.037415605038404465,
1.0357425212860107,
-0.4029357433319092,
0.029035327956080437,
-0.9829105138778687,
-0.10456101596355438,
-0.45737582445144653,
-0.7053878903388977,
-0.4522447884082794,
-0.33630698919296265,
0.5758676528930664,
0.0049920161254704,
-0.23883870244026184,
0.4311657249927521,
-0.9900883436203003,
0.7642490863800049,
0.9217697381973267,
0.5107570290565491,
0.08046881854534149,
0.0785464346408844,
0.32235804200172424,
-0.2020561844110489,
-0.7036400437355042,
-0.411390483379364,
1.3924206495285034,
-0.36625710129737854,
0.3475135564804077,
-0.23873236775398254,
0.7215812802314758,
0.5166348814964294,
0.05958331376314163,
-0.643103301525116,
0.5287732481956482,
-0.6389524340629578,
-0.6108721494674683,
-0.3760913014411926,
-0.42011716961860657,
-1.1850658655166626,
0.06682571768760681,
-0.3001406490802765,
-0.5154460072517395,
-0.10998983681201935,
0.3879755139350891,
-0.4639950096607208,
0.1663760244846344,
-0.8873034119606018,
0.8963877558708191,
-0.19777341187000275,
-0.4412553012371063,
-0.5626246929168701,
-0.3830978274345398,
-0.015357835218310356,
0.05669550597667694,
-0.2067422866821289,
-0.007371068000793457,
-0.18793289363384247,
1.026163935661316,
0.055914994329214096,
0.7341147065162659,
-0.23504595458507538,
0.2913496792316437,
0.1581224650144577,
-0.09859684109687805,
0.37704429030418396,
-0.07939711213111877,
-0.1370750367641449,
-0.060393791645765305,
-0.10296867042779922,
-0.5433189868927002,
-0.9338788986206055,
0.704587996006012,
-0.779662549495697,
-0.7885184288024902,
0.07134860754013062,
-0.6147128939628601,
-0.449850469827652,
0.21877321600914001,
0.4038279950618744,
0.6015644669532776,
-0.005515631288290024,
0.6128444075584412,
1.158189058303833,
0.4550938010215759,
0.4001486897468567,
0.5410219430923462,
0.6307158470153809,
-0.13376984000205994,
1.0205950736999512,
0.4541285037994385,
0.21074116230010986,
0.8576844930648804,
0.016881218180060387,
0.23180373013019562,
-0.5103482007980347,
-0.49204307794570923,
-0.23709282279014587,
-0.5926870703697205,
-0.25748395919799805,
-0.3843325972557068,
0.019033636897802353,
-0.22606486082077026,
-0.26646003127098083,
-0.3689922094345093,
-0.25236979126930237,
-0.45101720094680786,
-0.16627223789691925,
0.056389834731817245,
0.6817009449005127,
-0.025610169395804405,
0.38695237040519714,
-0.6861737966537476,
0.5440013408660889,
0.8549763560295105,
0.17211712896823883,
-0.26351556181907654,
-0.531588077545166,
-0.4520457983016968,
0.15209491550922394,
-0.6755455732345581,
-0.801109254360199,
-0.26502326130867004,
0.46405553817749023,
0.9290510416030884,
0.4949449598789215,
0.011292783543467522,
0.7649242281913757,
-0.5954135060310364,
0.42229408025741577,
0.07823667675256729,
-0.964651882648468,
0.8765971660614014,
-0.09242203831672668,
0.36934006214141846,
0.8412772417068481,
0.528055727481842,
-0.02759130299091339,
-0.022848691791296005,
-0.5306938290596008,
-0.6935248970985413,
1.1988357305526733,
0.0628167986869812,
0.07083551585674286,
0.23418962955474854,
0.4569810926914215,
0.17323458194732666,
0.33181703090667725,
-0.09940627217292786,
-0.5102021098136902,
-0.08147214353084564,
-0.16586580872535706,
-0.004256513901054859,
0.10984732210636139,
-0.4316910207271576,
-0.41325998306274414,
0.6427738070487976,
-0.24335716664791107,
0.45719584822654724,
-0.09650956839323044,
-0.0881621241569519,
-0.21043778955936432,
0.2796747386455536,
0.5440033078193665,
0.7681394815444946,
-0.043078549206256866,
-0.12081706523895264,
0.4383402466773987,
-0.6532401442527771,
0.17097315192222595,
-0.31403830647468567,
-0.16895639896392822,
-0.18390998244285583,
0.5292991399765015,
1.0741792917251587,
0.694804310798645,
-0.01196393184363842,
0.5013570785522461,
0.134923055768013,
-0.2617950439453125,
0.2788725793361664,
1.0484764575958252,
-0.17624934017658234,
0.20789475739002228,
0.2544018030166626,
0.35030287504196167,
0.34224238991737366,
-0.5201748609542847,
0.05899256467819214,
0.3479589819908142,
-0.4955529272556305,
-0.2689303755760193,
0.36165621876716614,
0.2853124737739563,
-0.406333863735199,
0.5770928263664246,
-0.20653297007083893,
-0.0034371260553598404,
0.8702713251113892,
0.5946379899978638,
0.6455199718475342,
-0.28229883313179016,
0.48892882466316223,
0.527306854724884,
0.18253305554389954,
-0.15727105736732483,
0.07684215903282166,
-0.6481665968894958,
-0.22577956318855286,
-0.42642760276794434,
-0.2926841974258423,
-0.5134821534156799,
-0.043954525142908096,
-1.1822383403778076,
0.0033637394662946463,
-0.5424914956092834,
-0.09599342197179794,
-0.08528159558773041,
0.12846460938453674,
-0.7773050665855408,
0.32702159881591797,
-0.022039610892534256,
0.6928015947341919,
-0.8131566643714905,
0.6295974254608154,
0.8571640849113464,
0.0006230904837138951,
-0.8178964853286743,
0.04311968758702278,
-0.1261381059885025,
-0.6514407992362976,
0.6467314958572388,
-0.029931632801890373,
-0.08909941464662552,
-0.024039316922426224,
-0.29009780287742615,
-0.6664770841598511,
1.3149216175079346,
0.5262963175773621,
-0.6313652992248535,
-0.08690247684717178,
-0.12510450184345245,
0.3125067949295044,
-0.17257149517536163,
0.2776350975036621,
0.6143580079078674,
0.5500251054763794,
0.25687935948371887,
-0.7343552112579346,
-0.13565292954444885,
-0.13439719378948212,
-0.09133447706699371,
0.531006932258606,
-0.7347527146339417,
0.5255746245384216,
-0.047376930713653564,
-0.16494788229465485,
-0.3368998169898987,
0.5664352774620056,
-0.15415780246257782,
0.3809584677219391,
0.30444228649139404,
0.3446901738643646,
0.7838395237922668,
-0.2419479340314865,
0.8542130589485168,
-0.5203008055686951,
0.00455864705145359,
1.0392245054244995,
0.12315532565116882,
0.7127942442893982,
0.21733823418617249,
-0.23158583045005798,
0.30210596323013306,
0.3543732762336731,
-0.028850123286247253,
0.8219614028930664,
-0.1631678193807602,
-0.19015280902385712,
-0.5312197804450989,
0.061208322644233704,
-0.3412339389324188,
0.6938363909721375,
0.2873503267765045,
-0.2226761281490326,
-0.016494397073984146,
-0.1294662356376648,
-0.055599793791770935,
-0.07683636993169785,
-0.6843094825744629,
0.9120960235595703,
-0.19825084507465363,
-1.1234302520751953,
0.25172898173332214,
-0.10010187327861786,
0.4532078504562378,
-0.9179571866989136,
-0.2879774868488312,
-0.025699175894260406,
0.21751640737056732,
-0.3999360501766205,
-0.5175488591194153,
0.3439328968524933,
-0.2768799960613251,
-0.5535725951194763,
-0.5839088559150696,
0.6458800435066223,
-0.3699937164783478,
-0.3702845871448517,
-0.13348928093910217,
0.2821272313594818,
-0.2190074771642685,
0.031932100653648376,
-0.5541328191757202,
-0.24414508044719696,
0.09089816361665726,
-0.02767406962811947,
0.6134063005447388,
0.28333112597465515,
0.15842674672603607,
0.24913281202316284,
0.5106099843978882,
0.20348282158374786,
-0.05719318985939026,
-0.3967244625091553,
0.4674645960330963,
-0.431395560503006,
-0.333545446395874,
-0.5564016103744507,
0.4700225591659546,
-0.2846870720386505,
-0.5730724930763245,
0.9114390015602112,
0.37661200761795044,
0.872256338596344,
-0.25590211153030396,
0.6798525452613831,
0.0024489103816449642,
0.3409561514854431,
-0.545081615447998,
0.38769295811653137,
-0.3909478783607483,
-0.05681630223989487,
-0.09644563496112823,
-0.9124511480331421,
-0.031756673008203506,
0.581852376461029,
-0.6560727953910828,
0.1450030505657196,
0.693296492099762,
0.6822237968444824,
-0.4143054783344269,
-0.07298583537340164,
0.38915860652923584,
-0.4642634093761444,
-0.22025565803050995,
0.5754938125610352,
0.27734655141830444,
-0.39192867279052734,
0.5889373421669006,
-0.4842580258846283,
-0.33622607588768005,
-0.41932299733161926,
-0.7296854257583618,
-0.9228848814964294,
-0.5390092134475708,
-0.559446394443512,
0.24262678623199463,
0.371389776468277,
0.6923366785049438,
1.2746504545211792,
-0.9096973538398743,
-0.2002774327993393,
-0.012328460812568665,
0.11995787173509598,
-0.9802823066711426,
-0.13192249834537506,
0.304533988237381,
-0.669150173664093,
-0.840082585811615,
0.6073338389396667,
0.32971465587615967,
-0.4090980291366577,
0.2612554132938385,
0.1680227369070053,
0.12041514366865158,
0.1250315010547638,
0.4618806838989258,
0.3454325497150421,
-0.3203694820404053,
-0.10435426980257034,
0.05864929035305977,
-0.23768608272075653,
-0.03259439393877983,
1.2107253074645996,
-0.40402403473854065,
0.5843261480331421,
0.480955570936203,
0.686362087726593,
0.592753529548645,
-0.05686679109930992,
0.3866378366947174,
-0.8451727628707886,
-0.10520423948764801,
-0.02346489392220974,
0.10308845341205597,
-0.060695067048072815,
-0.5583750605583191,
0.5867276787757874,
0.1188664510846138,
-0.7015165686607361,
-0.30456653237342834,
0.05243488401174545,
-0.8844677805900574,
-0.137944757938385,
0.9675114750862122,
-0.2569648325443268,
-0.25549283623695374,
-0.012586547061800957,
-0.26805150508880615,
0.4570154547691345,
-0.217432901263237,
1.0206830501556396,
0.607541561126709,
-0.3656182885169983,
0.030340908095240593,
-0.7039991021156311,
0.6531633734703064,
0.5919370651245117,
-0.7741167545318604,
-0.29468831419944763,
0.2312631756067276,
0.26157212257385254,
0.015657616779208183,
0.22039468586444855,
0.3293454945087433,
0.6940683722496033,
-0.1042247861623764,
-0.35912224650382996,
-0.41389647126197815,
-0.6783570051193237,
0.16498377919197083,
0.40788063406944275,
-0.2001301348209381,
-0.7410789132118225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16413v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16413v1
|
Asking and Answering Questions to Extract Event-Argument Structures
| 2024-04-25T08:43:06 | 2024-04-25T08:43:06 |
Md Nayem Uddin, Enfa Rose George, Eduardo Blanco, Steven Corman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a question-answering approach to extract document-level
event-argument structures. We automatically ask and answer questions for each
argument type an event may have. Questions are generated using manually defined
templates and generative transformers. Template-based questions are generated
using predefined role-specific wh-words and event triggers from the context
document. Transformer-based questions are generated using large language models
trained to formulate questions based on a passage and the expected answer.
Additionally, we develop novel data augmentation strategies specialized in
inter-sentential event-argument relations. We use a simple span-swapping
technique, coreference resolution, and large language models to augment the
training instances. Our approach enables transfer learning without any
corpora-specific modifications and yields competitive results with the RAMS
dataset. It outperforms previous work, and it is especially beneficial to
extract arguments that appear in different sentences than the event trigger. We
also present detailed quantitative and qualitative analyses shedding light on
the most common errors made by our best model.
|
[
-0.5049789547920227,
-1.0376726388931274,
0.46091222763061523,
-0.29760080575942993,
-0.2820490300655365,
-0.3264353275299072,
0.006081580184400082,
-0.4275552034378052,
-0.1102813333272934,
0.2804447412490845,
-0.5926376581192017,
-0.14618252217769623,
-0.3865464925765991,
0.13264794647693634,
-0.4676995575428009,
1.103324294090271,
-0.20372681319713593,
-0.11537713557481766,
-0.31880486011505127,
-0.1072273924946785,
-0.20088933408260345,
-0.6627728343009949,
-1.0412940979003906,
-0.042793478816747665,
0.5100145936012268,
0.5082228183746338,
0.1881682127714157,
0.5186615586280823,
0.29756173491477966,
0.1790369153022766,
-0.08609639108181,
0.17401717603206635,
-0.13659919798374176,
0.35757389664649963,
-0.3896823227405548,
-0.34993064403533936,
-0.43837782740592957,
0.03513446822762489,
0.4899302124977112,
0.6314306855201721,
0.03994618356227875,
0.32407867908477783,
-0.2170708328485489,
0.09232048690319061,
-0.5885104537010193,
0.1597186177968979,
-0.8997562527656555,
0.10150139033794403,
-0.17385992407798767,
-0.5588811635971069,
-0.5167369842529297,
-0.390834778547287,
0.05574183911085129,
-0.4105508029460907,
0.5992969274520874,
-0.06108270213007927,
1.0037915706634521,
-0.12626779079437256,
-0.3950679302215576,
-0.529512345790863,
-0.5551000237464905,
0.4576410949230194,
-0.3680051863193512,
0.13728362321853638,
0.35130295157432556,
0.18248127400875092,
0.09769552201032639,
-0.9964643716812134,
-0.6000280380249023,
0.03544602170586586,
-0.1376664936542511,
0.3450845777988434,
-0.29554492235183716,
-0.06850530952215195,
0.32226741313934326,
0.14839531481266022,
-0.8914766311645508,
-0.005874758120626211,
-0.555439829826355,
0.17141097784042358,
0.7427785992622375,
0.24162811040878296,
0.35122862458229065,
-0.3963448703289032,
-0.16496732831001282,
-0.26660487055778503,
-0.610892117023468,
0.10769416391849518,
0.5758126378059387,
0.022523842751979828,
0.1236565038561821,
0.5770968198776245,
0.0008568065240979195,
0.6734967827796936,
0.510659396648407,
0.44774433970451355,
-0.4016719460487366,
-0.49306944012641907,
-0.07472829520702362,
0.0026410254649817944,
0.4493274986743927,
0.44204655289649963,
0.18516524136066437,
-0.36580002307891846,
0.3877883553504944,
-0.26981106400489807,
0.3020089864730835,
-0.8877564668655396,
0.15835928916931152,
0.4657784700393677,
-0.3916283845901489,
-0.3753272294998169,
0.1809588223695755,
-1.1022731065750122,
-0.13579940795898438,
-0.07814840972423553,
0.41904163360595703,
-0.33546701073646545,
-0.19884249567985535,
0.0015400185948237777,
-0.6020088791847229,
0.7612326145172119,
0.41152042150497437,
-0.8841275572776794,
0.17222507297992706,
0.6556326746940613,
0.20114581286907196,
-0.4075852334499359,
-0.0348505973815918,
-1.008373737335205,
0.38979044556617737,
-0.28866803646087646,
1.095302939414978,
-0.6592549681663513,
-0.40995585918426514,
0.06434648483991623,
0.2354872226715088,
-0.22092607617378235,
-0.6815434694290161,
0.6882860660552979,
-0.8216457366943359,
0.7811748385429382,
-0.32779237627983093,
-0.8429393768310547,
0.03385714069008827,
0.425321102142334,
-0.4124886691570282,
1.0458171367645264,
0.013440418988466263,
-0.6745575666427612,
0.28129106760025024,
-0.8112089037895203,
-0.5107132792472839,
0.31058651208877563,
-0.3960137963294983,
-0.034389641135931015,
0.06923098862171173,
0.4785885810852051,
0.4992617964744568,
-0.32415392994880676,
0.15340235829353333,
-0.1934419572353363,
0.24249757826328278,
0.271858811378479,
-0.26553088426589966,
0.6462251543998718,
0.006946027744561434,
-0.19745369255542755,
0.0021845921874046326,
-0.8911826014518738,
-0.148921400308609,
0.08926926553249359,
-0.30925261974334717,
-0.14651863276958466,
0.29292765259742737,
-0.09161783009767532,
0.16308274865150452,
0.28251034021377563,
-0.5672469735145569,
0.31720200181007385,
-0.3327158987522125,
0.15176725387573242,
0.5048642158508301,
0.5694199204444885,
0.5008831024169922,
-0.12066900730133057,
0.8289743065834045,
0.2263260930776596,
0.11096204817295074,
-0.46305209398269653,
-0.41268423199653625,
-0.5472733378410339,
0.2399158775806427,
-0.07533156871795654,
0.5888373851776123,
-0.7147794961929321,
0.2888243794441223,
-0.03277149051427841,
-0.38964271545410156,
-0.2137981653213501,
-0.32941362261772156,
-0.10789982974529266,
1.0158604383468628,
0.49961283802986145,
0.22857721149921417,
-0.8793207406997681,
-0.7545164227485657,
-0.01957011967897415,
-0.6604697108268738,
0.07410784065723419,
0.091269351541996,
0.350053995847702,
0.29373976588249207,
1.0400487184524536,
-0.7095166444778442,
0.2598564624786377,
-0.4680993854999542,
0.43914687633514404,
0.07962647825479507,
0.3362405598163605,
0.45999249815940857,
-0.8898177742958069,
-0.3247164785861969,
0.28645485639572144,
-0.6719140410423279,
-0.2017015665769577,
-0.32241109013557434,
0.038220226764678955,
0.16791653633117676,
0.6890015602111816,
-0.5902753472328186,
0.2804081439971924,
0.047466740012168884,
-0.33139917254447937,
0.7102841138839722,
0.11143328994512558,
0.2021884173154831,
-1.5718551874160767,
0.06064118817448616,
-0.2847495377063751,
-0.0477418452501297,
-0.7323417663574219,
0.20057862997055054,
-0.045355331152677536,
-0.13610972464084625,
-0.4069535434246063,
0.7964176535606384,
-0.054292842745780945,
0.11085692793130875,
-0.3069063127040863,
0.27792611718177795,
0.3265630006790161,
0.28567105531692505,
0.23552186787128448,
0.677010715007782,
0.505961537361145,
-0.6715628504753113,
0.42780208587646484,
0.4649844467639923,
-0.165927454829216,
0.9150402545928955,
-0.6978322267532349,
0.2545696794986725,
-0.60715252161026,
0.17763851583003998,
-0.9716016054153442,
-0.14392021298408508,
0.016865240409970284,
-0.46517321467399597,
0.19344982504844666,
-0.5452108979225159,
-0.2895493507385254,
-0.1698295623064041,
-0.13446764647960663,
0.21337716281414032,
0.3036920130252838,
-0.5840547680854797,
0.7313295602798462,
0.3639340400695801,
-0.459052711725235,
-0.5898396968841553,
-0.46407580375671387,
-0.010895428247749805,
-0.47372883558273315,
-0.7008625864982605,
0.34027910232543945,
-0.24117842316627502,
-0.2885381579399109,
0.1777050644159317,
0.04480259120464325,
-0.25594282150268555,
-0.08355522900819778,
0.04007328674197197,
0.28657031059265137,
-0.6485933661460876,
0.27567386627197266,
0.15058423578739166,
0.05365234613418579,
0.03029509074985981,
-0.23123322427272797,
0.4147162139415741,
-0.14335322380065918,
-0.34682726860046387,
-0.1878603994846344,
1.1714584827423096,
0.413264662027359,
-0.3423832654953003,
0.5280703902244568,
0.6082422137260437,
-0.48470067977905273,
-0.10020414739847183,
-0.6556181907653809,
-0.25743019580841064,
-0.40975919365882874,
0.5444605350494385,
-0.48820197582244873,
-0.738574206829071,
0.6864901781082153,
0.12551362812519073,
0.47629326581954956,
0.7073951959609985,
0.8743840456008911,
-0.4249356985092163,
1.0094823837280273,
0.0035119864623993635,
0.27987372875213623,
0.4413328170776367,
-0.10581129789352417,
0.009538969956338406,
-0.6539289355278015,
-0.16039948165416718,
-0.6535812020301819,
-0.12835213541984558,
0.04441186785697937,
-0.665100634098053,
0.3659696578979492,
0.33442842960357666,
-0.10242072492837906,
0.6844449639320374,
-0.06929776817560196,
0.2707289755344391,
0.06254494935274124,
-0.6237921118736267,
0.21553798019886017,
-0.2351234257221222,
0.13221336901187897,
0.15201589465141296,
-0.7266141772270203,
-0.6400237679481506,
0.6361737847328186,
0.07072712481021881,
0.5221009254455566,
0.02458839677274227,
0.582781970500946,
0.16108891367912292,
0.3374069929122925,
-0.5901370048522949,
0.47702598571777344,
0.18038424849510193,
-0.9169566035270691,
-0.2671303451061249,
-0.30412760376930237,
-1.2088202238082886,
0.401962548494339,
-0.04792962223291397,
-1.0301282405853271,
0.6301484107971191,
-0.1379348188638687,
-0.2597179114818573,
0.39766404032707214,
-0.7489681243896484,
0.9312956929206848,
0.02287728525698185,
0.04506032168865204,
0.00828765332698822,
-0.43399783968925476,
0.02255539782345295,
0.1301032453775406,
-0.02440391108393669,
-0.05067051947116852,
0.20575162768363953,
0.9251232147216797,
-0.09316600859165192,
0.44019100069999695,
0.02942611277103424,
-0.012168909423053265,
0.667209267616272,
-0.005800122395157814,
0.6327983736991882,
0.17480173707008362,
-0.49217191338539124,
-0.4827369451522827,
0.4355263411998749,
-0.06080613657832146,
-0.9142929315567017,
0.20808254182338715,
-0.4952341616153717,
-0.7457426190376282,
0.09907802939414978,
-0.5498670935630798,
-0.346378892660141,
-0.18520894646644592,
0.30637726187705994,
0.9141996502876282,
-0.43657976388931274,
0.3161996304988861,
0.5359311103820801,
-0.05116969347000122,
0.7777565717697144,
0.6848190426826477,
0.23720066249370575,
-0.259315550327301,
0.5944944024085999,
0.030100079253315926,
0.08402353525161743,
0.5819112658500671,
0.31679171323776245,
-0.4444581866264343,
-0.29739320278167725,
-0.8794917464256287,
-0.04964789003133774,
-0.8585494756698608,
-0.30235376954078674,
-1.1418812274932861,
-0.1677670031785965,
-0.5381215810775757,
-0.31602904200553894,
-0.1098923310637474,
-0.767327606678009,
-0.4872778356075287,
-0.6675952672958374,
0.16076365113258362,
0.23645436763763428,
0.052404068410396576,
0.1526869684457779,
-0.9046050906181335,
0.29464495182037354,
0.3791465163230896,
-0.0633520856499672,
-0.09575282782316208,
-0.4393027424812317,
-0.036207981407642365,
-0.398797869682312,
-0.5253767371177673,
-1.4974850416183472,
0.18599660694599152,
0.28258994221687317,
0.727182149887085,
0.40926608443260193,
0.29556336998939514,
0.757110595703125,
-0.5188716053962708,
1.005135178565979,
-0.010067670606076717,
-0.7572972178459167,
0.7944251894950867,
-0.3079066872596741,
-0.024955498054623604,
0.5974399447441101,
0.5557360053062439,
-0.5830469131469727,
-0.38691675662994385,
-1.0401883125305176,
-0.6774601340293884,
0.8581811189651489,
0.08627583086490631,
0.08952608704566956,
-0.4451811909675598,
0.5659263134002686,
0.18416383862495422,
-0.17265601456165314,
-0.5094239115715027,
-0.12379764020442963,
0.05147464573383331,
-0.24548804759979248,
0.3669038414955139,
-0.023328403010964394,
-0.2849699854850769,
-0.2169196903705597,
0.459469199180603,
-0.4025604724884033,
0.03084762580692768,
0.34574517607688904,
-0.19026510417461395,
-0.18690557777881622,
0.4987929165363312,
0.4940204918384552,
0.7720008492469788,
-0.061922021210193634,
0.3902851343154907,
0.6517475247383118,
-0.11037527769804001,
0.06192050129175186,
0.3063487708568573,
-0.06066151708364487,
-0.008779248222708702,
0.3537011742591858,
0.6766372323036194,
-0.20259766280651093,
-0.6736381649971008,
0.4221179187297821,
-0.28333503007888794,
-0.343173086643219,
-0.14564234018325806,
-0.08961446583271027,
0.17725396156311035,
0.3430285155773163,
0.5807319283485413,
-0.5264473557472229,
0.01354131568223238,
-0.797062337398529,
0.5669212341308594,
0.3271813690662384,
-0.5217432975769043,
-0.4139886796474457,
0.5878818035125732,
0.04337466508150101,
-0.18314431607723236,
0.20020264387130737,
0.026549892500042915,
-0.4335511326789856,
0.7971922755241394,
0.6877507567405701,
0.6545668840408325,
-0.1258232742547989,
0.3326852321624756,
0.4178963899612427,
0.3295907974243164,
0.44733136892318726,
0.4994440972805023,
-0.1549134999513626,
-0.7459805011749268,
-0.349647581577301,
-0.5880244374275208,
-0.48454368114471436,
0.4094051122665405,
-0.8740979433059692,
0.31997084617614746,
-0.09419215470552444,
0.05269072577357292,
0.15686000883579254,
-0.03532715141773224,
-0.47986045479774475,
0.09603752195835114,
0.07427496463060379,
0.9328472018241882,
-0.749915361404419,
0.5536329746246338,
1.0209351778030396,
-0.6660910844802856,
-0.5890409350395203,
-0.10463728755712509,
-0.6188912391662598,
-0.3014985918998718,
0.5489569306373596,
-0.2588436007499695,
0.23084178566932678,
-0.02065032534301281,
-0.3487381041049957,
-0.797045886516571,
0.7496618628501892,
0.25205492973327637,
0.1221054270863533,
-0.21330226957798004,
0.23662474751472473,
0.4034528136253357,
-0.36931589245796204,
0.2528483271598816,
0.3407347500324249,
0.48823392391204834,
0.19874373078346252,
-0.36811769008636475,
0.07080362737178802,
-0.15931028127670288,
-0.4451935291290283,
0.11739548295736313,
-0.12006068229675293,
0.5036680102348328,
0.06930381804704666,
-0.32028457522392273,
-0.2047191858291626,
1.0009682178497314,
0.05206736922264099,
0.2663176357746124,
0.47829991579055786,
0.3095927834510803,
0.7860627174377441,
0.06548687070608139,
1.0677852630615234,
-0.20710451900959015,
0.2078365534543991,
1.0823005437850952,
-0.40898966789245605,
0.7955179810523987,
0.49308300018310547,
0.07818963378667831,
0.5756032466888428,
0.6387702822685242,
0.17973218858242035,
0.11836567521095276,
0.03426671028137207,
-0.30987420678138733,
-0.4044531285762787,
0.06909828633069992,
-0.36692383885383606,
0.4129428565502167,
0.504907488822937,
0.046341829001903534,
-0.8283029198646545,
0.016350271180272102,
-0.06033000722527504,
-0.2283078283071518,
0.026636943221092224,
1.0188542604446411,
-0.12287084758281708,
-1.0932000875473022,
-0.023684024810791016,
0.2722949683666229,
0.09730219841003418,
-0.7572139501571655,
0.01796787604689598,
-0.40755411982536316,
-0.10022088140249252,
0.032729946076869965,
-0.7897354960441589,
0.7762945890426636,
0.3249627351760864,
-0.32942500710487366,
-0.09941409528255463,
0.7333107590675354,
-0.513982892036438,
-0.32081887125968933,
-0.10179201513528824,
0.6922333240509033,
0.1012079194188118,
0.1255597472190857,
-0.547042727470398,
-0.2482944279909134,
-0.42272233963012695,
-0.3209433853626251,
0.2752975523471832,
0.4476449489593506,
-0.2697765529155731,
0.09171762317419052,
0.5428757667541504,
-0.022914359346032143,
0.3556778132915497,
-0.03390681743621826,
0.7207111120223999,
-0.37728431820869446,
-0.4168715178966522,
-0.7183377146720886,
0.5362608432769775,
-0.3490469455718994,
-0.4115074872970581,
0.3639622628688812,
0.6410796642303467,
0.41094210743904114,
0.021769480779767036,
0.5903089046478271,
-0.22191160917282104,
0.2949836552143097,
-0.1576395034790039,
0.35907918214797974,
-0.48185184597969055,
-0.20730938017368317,
-0.16638870537281036,
-0.5771854519844055,
0.015119495801627636,
0.4157252609729767,
-0.24274739623069763,
-0.46558380126953125,
0.7939854264259338,
0.7384303212165833,
-0.12077135592699051,
0.4825022220611572,
0.32579824328422546,
-0.16105766594409943,
0.6684389710426331,
0.47331947088241577,
1.1101243495941162,
-0.611553966999054,
0.6704164147377014,
0.21689970791339874,
-0.1606249362230301,
-0.15799580514431,
-0.9983368515968323,
-0.6390359401702881,
-1.1443129777908325,
-0.7691430449485779,
-0.2845091223716736,
-0.010099509730935097,
1.0096055269241333,
0.7872430086135864,
-0.9096447229385376,
-0.18924419581890106,
0.14634308218955994,
0.2770000100135803,
-0.2527313828468323,
-0.2994230389595032,
0.6761589646339417,
-0.6304462552070618,
-0.735930323600769,
0.7245326042175293,
0.1951945573091507,
-0.11739964783191681,
0.23947496712207794,
0.4594723582267761,
-0.4099496901035309,
0.47563615441322327,
0.7749476432800293,
0.4560849964618683,
-0.23756462335586548,
-0.6421046853065491,
-0.013670708984136581,
0.0747818797826767,
0.08580702543258667,
1.0087730884552002,
-0.5008932948112488,
0.17179986834526062,
0.7313532829284668,
1.0174264907836914,
0.7033059597015381,
0.18231722712516785,
0.7155353426933289,
-1.110883116722107,
-0.03759686276316643,
0.26405712962150574,
0.43394309282302856,
0.0648726373910904,
-0.4231138527393341,
0.3606582581996918,
0.19281768798828125,
-0.18694958090782166,
-0.6821312308311462,
0.4123706519603729,
-1.250382661819458,
-0.238970547914505,
1.3282604217529297,
-0.017227744683623314,
-0.0989699438214302,
-0.4959096610546112,
-0.22590571641921997,
0.3333148956298828,
0.15897122025489807,
0.47322431206703186,
0.7719622254371643,
-0.37367233633995056,
-0.2835081219673157,
-0.3569597005844116,
0.5352290868759155,
0.3569280207157135,
-1.1545974016189575,
0.2524058222770691,
0.36785203218460083,
0.24017667770385742,
0.16528277099132538,
0.5467019081115723,
-0.48349428176879883,
0.31465041637420654,
-0.29579290747642517,
-0.07126530259847641,
0.07489123940467834,
-0.12182537466287613,
-0.29757896065711975,
0.9285167455673218,
-0.409374475479126,
-0.14542892575263977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16407v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16407v1
|
U2++ MoE: Scaling 4.7x parameters with minimal impact on RTF
| 2024-04-25T08:34:21 | 2024-04-25T08:34:21 |
Xingchen Song, Di Wu, Binbin Zhang, Dinghao Zhou, Zhendong Peng, Bo Dang, Fuping Pan, Chao Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS, I.2.7
|
Scale has opened new frontiers in natural language processing, but at a high
cost. In response, by learning to only activate a subset of parameters in
training and inference, Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) have been proposed as an
energy efficient path to even larger and more capable language models and this
shift towards a new generation of foundation models is gaining momentum,
particularly within the field of Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR). Recent
works that incorporating MoE into ASR models have complex designs such as
routing frames via supplementary embedding network, improving multilingual
ability for the experts, and utilizing dedicated auxiliary losses for either
expert load balancing or specific language handling. We found that delicate
designs are not necessary, while an embarrassingly simple substitution of MoE
layers for all Feed-Forward Network (FFN) layers is competent for the ASR task.
To be more specific, we benchmark our proposed model on a large scale
inner-source dataset (160k hours), the results show that we can scale our
baseline Conformer (Dense-225M) to its MoE counterparts (MoE-1B) and achieve
Dense-1B level Word Error Rate (WER) while maintaining a Dense-225M level Real
Time Factor (RTF). Furthermore, by applying Unified 2-pass framework with
bidirectional attention decoders (U2++), we achieve the streaming and
non-streaming decoding modes in a single MoE based model, which we call U2++
MoE. We hope that our study can facilitate the research on scaling speech
foundation models without sacrificing deployment efficiency.
|
[
-0.40555423498153687,
-0.6220622062683105,
-0.05912651866674423,
0.5895114541053772,
-0.08889032155275345,
-0.1664455682039261,
-0.4146668314933777,
-0.7240059971809387,
-0.06417514383792877,
0.44429710507392883,
-0.2200244516134262,
0.1273362934589386,
-0.8331431746482849,
0.21096527576446533,
-0.43500927090644836,
0.577073872089386,
0.1769515573978424,
0.17686934769153595,
0.010726521722972393,
-0.3224466145038605,
-0.3321315348148346,
-0.05100668594241142,
-1.056657314300537,
-0.6098835468292236,
0.309186190366745,
0.4272265136241913,
0.5918932557106018,
0.9077882766723633,
0.619722306728363,
0.3326717019081116,
-0.1851717233657837,
-0.15717405080795288,
-0.46331068873405457,
0.062064990401268005,
0.005888535175472498,
-0.28483468294143677,
-0.6851180791854858,
0.1290137618780136,
0.8851072192192078,
0.8244380354881287,
-0.35971537232398987,
0.01821671426296234,
0.036025214940309525,
0.8029634356498718,
-0.4761989712715149,
0.1596280336380005,
-0.657781720161438,
-0.12686552107334137,
-0.16090549528598785,
0.07400542497634888,
-0.47193387150764465,
0.08860498666763306,
0.3300060033798218,
-0.5272291898727417,
0.1790713518857956,
0.005380580201745033,
0.7618624567985535,
0.40380167961120605,
-0.4447436034679413,
-0.14916835725307465,
-0.6890776753425598,
0.9321969151496887,
-0.657708466053009,
0.7302977442741394,
0.3261522650718689,
0.20402275025844574,
0.09158101677894592,
-0.5993813872337341,
-0.34472909569740295,
-0.18354740738868713,
0.16312405467033386,
-0.07290897518396378,
-0.45032769441604614,
0.1139211505651474,
0.04327204078435898,
0.5054044127464294,
-0.42578834295272827,
0.21587549149990082,
-0.40087568759918213,
-0.201711967587471,
0.8490493893623352,
-0.10729538649320602,
-0.004968203604221344,
-0.032690808176994324,
-0.36631616950035095,
-0.18823668360710144,
-0.525750458240509,
0.1730656772851944,
0.09941081702709198,
0.3471432328224182,
-0.023804504424333572,
0.3838912546634674,
-0.5077728033065796,
0.8128771781921387,
0.28936734795570374,
-0.10631086677312851,
0.07959332317113876,
-0.21789611876010895,
-0.2074062079191208,
0.2027006298303604,
0.9703518748283386,
0.0949542224407196,
0.42182835936546326,
-0.30728816986083984,
-0.14838440716266632,
-0.05487436801195145,
0.23206067085266113,
-0.9053844809532166,
-0.46835795044898987,
-0.13461728394031525,
-0.1589500606060028,
-0.10512648522853851,
-0.1576610803604126,
-0.5966721177101135,
-0.08406300097703934,
-0.5040906667709351,
0.6417412161827087,
-0.36228588223457336,
-0.4537090063095093,
0.1857304722070694,
-0.027153750881552696,
0.06216558441519737,
0.3877873718738556,
-0.6558938026428223,
0.39257368445396423,
0.4273855686187744,
0.599657416343689,
0.01571270264685154,
-0.012274486944079399,
-0.5887274146080017,
0.18173567950725555,
-0.0727669969201088,
0.8705146312713623,
-0.7336121201515198,
-0.626874566078186,
-0.4401460886001587,
-0.4379124045372009,
-0.17560382187366486,
-0.5248741507530212,
0.7124890685081482,
-0.552596390247345,
0.0403689481317997,
-0.21920597553253174,
-0.5033245086669922,
-0.3513879179954529,
0.024678794667124748,
-0.6038505434989929,
1.0754811763763428,
-0.003538441611453891,
-0.5584067106246948,
0.34250083565711975,
-0.7455724477767944,
-0.7175172567367554,
0.06325164437294006,
-0.15647506713867188,
-0.14607252180576324,
0.13758587837219238,
0.39557400345802307,
0.4356049597263336,
-0.3905538320541382,
0.20216776430606842,
-0.22579023241996765,
-0.1490849405527115,
0.07376930862665176,
-0.7487553954124451,
0.7547211647033691,
0.19241660833358765,
-0.5126709938049316,
0.041645508259534836,
-1.1108704805374146,
0.061633285135030746,
-0.15517927706241608,
-0.748426079750061,
-0.16744711995124817,
-0.053331661969423294,
0.3206557035446167,
0.1217847689986229,
0.10665518790483475,
-0.5403655767440796,
-0.07911115884780884,
-0.2502647042274475,
0.691798746585846,
0.59373539686203,
-0.32188883423805237,
0.7484155297279358,
-0.03238879144191742,
0.25943833589553833,
-0.03820950165390968,
-0.22538863122463226,
0.07282421737909317,
-0.6605510115623474,
-0.845726728439331,
-0.5925289988517761,
0.4189251661300659,
0.33610260486602783,
-0.540288507938385,
0.4181658625602722,
-0.6179195642471313,
-0.5043426156044006,
-0.8492661714553833,
0.3346926271915436,
0.6053033471107483,
0.7679057121276855,
0.47852998971939087,
-0.14425277709960938,
-0.3693180978298187,
-0.867401659488678,
-0.29416152834892273,
-0.19288085401058197,
-0.2183893769979477,
0.2818582057952881,
0.07223130762577057,
-0.2205982208251953,
1.0748111009597778,
-0.2423309087753296,
-0.4295358657836914,
-0.27609342336654663,
0.32604873180389404,
-0.08163273334503174,
0.6725680828094482,
0.2772899568080902,
-1.0247175693511963,
-0.6063920259475708,
0.022844970226287842,
-0.6205390691757202,
-0.12721692025661469,
0.2733549475669861,
0.005897753406316042,
-0.06223155930638313,
0.38693785667419434,
-0.6354995369911194,
-0.012595434673130512,
0.4926815629005432,
-0.1695539504289627,
0.0370173379778862,
-0.18992866575717926,
-0.13268423080444336,
-0.9445071816444397,
-0.0911654457449913,
0.37920093536376953,
-0.1752443015575409,
-0.7221019864082336,
0.24184682965278625,
0.1858246624469757,
-0.06138569489121437,
-0.13707192242145538,
0.6333669424057007,
-0.5755811333656311,
0.13081496953964233,
-0.17839711904525757,
0.022268595173954964,
0.11456942558288574,
0.41726407408714294,
0.14420978724956512,
0.873219907283783,
0.5717037320137024,
-0.6587510704994202,
0.2913762629032135,
0.018801817670464516,
-0.010054818354547024,
0.6975504159927368,
-0.8403738737106323,
0.1264597773551941,
0.052151039242744446,
0.31110695004463196,
-0.9402945041656494,
-0.2851215898990631,
-0.10456599295139313,
-0.5697763562202454,
0.7670009732246399,
0.06443620473146439,
-0.35975542664527893,
-0.23779615759849548,
-0.2825317978858948,
0.3169211745262146,
0.4142506420612335,
-0.2551916837692261,
0.9368475675582886,
0.46475887298583984,
-0.15796291828155518,
-0.27340370416641235,
-0.8871394395828247,
0.18089161813259125,
-0.1501087099313736,
-0.9199845194816589,
0.2735370099544525,
-0.10759277641773224,
-0.24446657299995422,
0.0393228642642498,
-0.22863374650478363,
-0.21781682968139648,
0.08285028487443924,
0.12861263751983643,
-0.31757432222366333,
-0.7370155453681946,
-0.1731935441493988,
0.15532714128494263,
-0.2953980267047882,
-0.021100692451000214,
-0.18046149611473083,
0.20534856617450714,
-0.24735090136528015,
0.019334260374307632,
-0.7782213091850281,
0.4165743589401245,
0.6781347990036011,
-0.3674708306789398,
0.5864314436912537,
0.8484026789665222,
-0.4399479627609253,
0.11305840313434601,
-0.8827478885650635,
-0.13545028865337372,
-0.48868119716644287,
0.3052785098552704,
-0.4578700363636017,
-0.8447904586791992,
0.3915131390094757,
0.11678249388933182,
0.1553293615579605,
0.5864627957344055,
0.3735818862915039,
-0.05675973743200302,
0.8786104321479797,
0.6060759425163269,
-0.40172427892684937,
0.4401617646217346,
-0.35686424374580383,
0.16331757605075836,
-1.1936582326889038,
0.011584354564547539,
-0.5246070623397827,
-0.46160638332366943,
-0.304027795791626,
-0.38084420561790466,
0.4098978042602539,
0.30397501587867737,
-0.010148449800908566,
0.42925208806991577,
-0.31844037771224976,
0.17935778200626373,
0.6632404327392578,
0.07776056230068207,
0.3411776125431061,
0.014753731898963451,
0.19106435775756836,
0.08998160064220428,
-0.7329531311988831,
-0.2805890738964081,
1.2089134454727173,
0.37116146087646484,
0.75286465883255,
0.13191814720630646,
0.35268712043762207,
0.2031705528497696,
0.4485534131526947,
-0.6896063685417175,
0.5639243721961975,
-0.3057464361190796,
-0.7294042110443115,
-0.6234335899353027,
-0.5946174263954163,
-0.5560576319694519,
0.5025003552436829,
-0.0525948628783226,
-0.46797001361846924,
0.34622928500175476,
0.17402414977550507,
-0.49765944480895996,
0.1444898396730423,
-0.8779962062835693,
0.5039464831352234,
0.19885197281837463,
-0.24562597274780273,
-0.31091466546058655,
-0.6488835215568542,
0.17238225042819977,
0.021565882489085197,
0.26239943504333496,
-0.17048297822475433,
0.0358407199382782,
0.7906217575073242,
-0.12450186908245087,
0.5154638886451721,
-0.162337526679039,
-0.03700340911746025,
0.2822844684123993,
-0.14167124032974243,
0.46167558431625366,
0.2240229845046997,
-0.46053898334503174,
0.3228745758533478,
-0.4234274923801422,
-0.42473798990249634,
-0.2901013195514679,
0.7891786694526672,
-1.033079981803894,
-0.40359729528427124,
-0.01696101762354374,
-0.6898515820503235,
-0.3555052876472473,
0.1124897375702858,
0.38725584745407104,
0.7729235291481018,
0.05499044805765152,
0.7817389369010925,
0.9139862060546875,
0.5045822262763977,
0.4884492754936218,
0.6706039905548096,
0.2676263153553009,
-0.46061331033706665,
0.9234200716018677,
0.44266313314437866,
0.19870701432228088,
0.6424294710159302,
0.23248738050460815,
-0.28134652972221375,
-0.5849076509475708,
-0.7821071743965149,
0.029089579358696938,
-0.41117945313453674,
-0.259700208902359,
-1.0751148462295532,
-0.18756318092346191,
-0.5624904036521912,
-0.12954553961753845,
-0.5600108504295349,
-0.4158271253108978,
-0.6079933047294617,
-0.08257138729095459,
0.4126719832420349,
0.44172579050064087,
-0.09973654896020889,
0.5943436026573181,
-0.7188320159912109,
0.39241522550582886,
0.5212481617927551,
0.2895723283290863,
0.11377561092376709,
-0.7693511843681335,
-0.20771509408950806,
0.21600164473056793,
-0.25670772790908813,
-0.49578404426574707,
0.0921146422624588,
0.7729107141494751,
0.5499810576438904,
0.8176079988479614,
0.1291494071483612,
0.8009825944900513,
-0.6640848517417908,
0.5604031682014465,
0.033117372542619705,
-0.8752158880233765,
0.22313664853572845,
-0.42192602157592773,
0.3001347780227661,
0.5553720593452454,
0.14442168176174164,
-0.14065435528755188,
-0.3669416308403015,
-0.4091719686985016,
-0.7711911201477051,
0.8124575614929199,
0.4526554346084595,
0.2830846905708313,
0.25956258177757263,
0.3690236210823059,
-0.04633782431483269,
0.06656435132026672,
-0.599533200263977,
-0.08328968286514282,
-0.10875832289457321,
-0.290381520986557,
-0.19769611954689026,
-0.4475255310535431,
0.014635570347309113,
-0.4392799437046051,
0.6257278323173523,
0.059608202427625656,
0.23955801129341125,
0.09823423624038696,
-0.31870973110198975,
-0.37556686997413635,
0.1992587298154831,
0.5589011311531067,
0.47158026695251465,
-0.25883379578590393,
0.03565896674990654,
0.054925061762332916,
-0.5987263321876526,
-0.01839342713356018,
0.35173556208610535,
-0.0296991765499115,
-0.08260229974985123,
0.5261719822883606,
0.8486185669898987,
0.7096186280250549,
-0.48094895482063293,
0.2340783029794693,
-0.05757836252450943,
-0.20901226997375488,
-0.06325743347406387,
0.29791003465652466,
0.21347449719905853,
0.22282005846500397,
0.6015444397926331,
0.4250580370426178,
0.3419797420501709,
-0.25439453125,
0.2589981257915497,
0.27533096075057983,
-0.42792201042175293,
-0.6083828806877136,
0.7842268943786621,
0.6186450123786926,
-0.3184894025325775,
0.616796612739563,
-0.04852805286645889,
-0.3215358555316925,
0.3972708284854889,
0.3578020930290222,
0.8196560144424438,
-0.5010941624641418,
-0.06371138244867325,
0.19862191379070282,
0.31279537081718445,
-0.2565613090991974,
0.05863126739859581,
-0.29520609974861145,
-0.7860680818557739,
-0.24812200665473938,
-0.7912224531173706,
-0.2050819844007492,
-0.19030335545539856,
-1.0294700860977173,
0.037849895656108856,
-0.415793240070343,
-0.17539441585540771,
0.1317404955625534,
-0.018424028530716896,
-0.5777485370635986,
0.44592931866645813,
0.05984959751367569,
0.9173457622528076,
-0.6859197616577148,
0.9303366541862488,
0.867638349533081,
-0.1915137767791748,
-0.7309013605117798,
-0.07435240596532822,
-0.014233586378395557,
-0.7133487462997437,
0.560500979423523,
0.25598594546318054,
-0.20974776148796082,
0.32607516646385193,
-0.20926688611507416,
-1.0160750150680542,
0.9567097425460815,
0.325034499168396,
-0.5122025609016418,
-0.28969287872314453,
0.023427393287420273,
0.5482327342033386,
-0.27188074588775635,
0.09709236025810242,
0.40045616030693054,
0.32331737875938416,
0.28929242491722107,
-1.048991084098816,
-0.23595094680786133,
-0.2918635308742523,
0.12667220830917358,
0.1837574988603592,
-0.6998197436332703,
1.0623257160186768,
0.07405778020620346,
0.02941698394715786,
-0.12379875034093857,
1.0345184803009033,
-0.025959385558962822,
0.15852342545986176,
0.5248855352401733,
0.7901355624198914,
0.44566968083381653,
-0.0028896976727992296,
0.9082430005073547,
-0.2977004945278168,
0.1937282830476761,
0.9489189386367798,
-0.1526220142841339,
1.2476694583892822,
0.4081345498561859,
-0.3482723832130432,
0.1959020048379898,
0.4378727972507477,
0.37066182494163513,
0.517750084400177,
-0.2008117288351059,
-0.1770157366991043,
-0.31921473145484924,
-0.07669447362422943,
-0.47504621744155884,
0.43779224157333374,
0.4304620623588562,
0.006257343105971813,
-0.25235143303871155,
0.2994680404663086,
0.10842994600534439,
0.058701690286397934,
-0.41021203994750977,
0.7902657985687256,
0.25857311487197876,
-0.1560651659965515,
0.324780136346817,
0.14411988854408264,
0.8700513243675232,
-0.6006292104721069,
0.2594802975654602,
-0.23040048778057098,
0.36031368374824524,
-0.045421842485666275,
-0.4920669198036194,
0.19453109800815582,
0.0996885672211647,
-0.4662283957004547,
-0.2773192822933197,
0.41662582755088806,
-0.4973675310611725,
-0.8668158054351807,
0.3255062401294708,
0.08501074463129044,
-0.055809106677770615,
-0.42586997151374817,
-0.5870917439460754,
0.06384853273630142,
-0.1445932239294052,
-0.5013442039489746,
0.28165140748023987,
0.6825840473175049,
-0.01944098062813282,
0.8016815185546875,
0.5887284874916077,
0.08077623695135117,
0.4484535753726959,
-0.09917263686656952,
0.8101204633712769,
-0.2887064218521118,
-0.5113155841827393,
-0.5701197385787964,
0.5463393330574036,
0.07915784418582916,
-0.3065369427204132,
0.6851646900177002,
0.36943569779396057,
0.8664830923080444,
0.20455826818943024,
0.32760512828826904,
0.032528918236494064,
0.44749271869659424,
-0.4265204966068268,
0.7720254063606262,
-0.737337589263916,
0.04271528497338295,
-0.3305163085460663,
-0.7852376699447632,
-0.2622338831424713,
0.6592146158218384,
-0.13937534391880035,
0.09843529015779495,
0.22027955949306488,
0.43629375100135803,
-0.10682744532823563,
0.20412075519561768,
0.29217246174812317,
0.2248050719499588,
0.468557208776474,
0.21426081657409668,
0.20766004920005798,
-0.6585053205490112,
0.6170023083686829,
-0.3001885712146759,
-0.24886560440063477,
-0.5270124673843384,
-0.5419890284538269,
-0.6590306758880615,
-0.4044601321220398,
-0.5266246795654297,
0.08653600513935089,
-0.18036754429340363,
0.9071202874183655,
0.9631543159484863,
-0.8287674784660339,
-0.2402081936597824,
-0.09995072335004807,
-0.13431711494922638,
-0.3025393486022949,
-0.20840023458003998,
0.21932408213615417,
-0.19453483819961548,
-0.7169453501701355,
0.49021971225738525,
0.4048347473144531,
-0.20397518575191498,
-0.24736209213733673,
-0.20979437232017517,
-0.17993271350860596,
0.08887434750795364,
0.6780930757522583,
0.07596547156572342,
-0.9068900346755981,
-0.13301610946655273,
-0.060179200023412704,
-0.08648212999105453,
0.130447655916214,
0.5349744558334351,
-0.535757303237915,
0.6537421941757202,
0.4225807785987854,
0.8639882802963257,
0.21963532269001007,
-0.11922333389520645,
0.7662913799285889,
-0.6150466203689575,
0.22182703018188477,
0.2532675266265869,
0.37178802490234375,
0.46792933344841003,
-0.40037617087364197,
0.40713533759117126,
0.22124837338924408,
-0.35612255334854126,
-0.9046708941459656,
-0.0004131401365157217,
-0.9995095729827881,
0.09008979797363281,
1.0517888069152832,
-0.22730369865894318,
0.09701358526945114,
0.1270802915096283,
-0.16029587388038635,
0.10804970562458038,
-0.7580789923667908,
0.5524097084999084,
0.725631833076477,
-0.22846737504005432,
-0.31618526577949524,
-0.5061628222465515,
0.2418661266565323,
0.3924984335899353,
-0.4081602990627289,
-0.10264421254396439,
0.3373410701751709,
0.2813909649848938,
0.2612226903438568,
0.5674555897712708,
0.041720036417245865,
0.030261365696787834,
0.05132295936346054,
-0.14247305691242218,
-0.19281764328479767,
-0.41586053371429443,
-0.4578004777431488,
0.25883379578590393,
-0.012912548147141933,
-0.162303626537323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16405v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16405v1
|
Lost in Recursion: Mining Rich Event Semantics in Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-04-25T08:33:08 | 2024-04-25T08:33:08 |
Florian Plötzky, Niklas Kiehne, Wolf-Tilo Balke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Our world is shaped by events of various complexity. This includes both
small-scale local events like local farmer markets and large complex events
like political and military conflicts. The latter are typically not observed
directly but through the lenses of intermediaries like newspapers or social
media. In other words, we do not witness the unfolding of such events directly
but are confronted with narratives surrounding them. Such narratives capture
different aspects of a complex event and may also differ with respect to the
narrator. Thus, they provide a rich semantics concerning real-world events. In
this paper, we show how narratives concerning complex events can be constructed
and utilized. We provide a formal representation of narratives based on
recursive nodes to represent multiple levels of detail and discuss how
narratives can be bound to event-centric knowledge graphs. Additionally, we
provide an algorithm based on incremental prompting techniques that mines such
narratives from texts to account for different perspectives on complex events.
Finally, we show the effectiveness and future research directions in a proof of
concept.
|
[
-0.2878428101539612,
-0.5981019735336304,
0.8201145529747009,
-0.13932999968528748,
-0.07684145122766495,
0.47174862027168274,
0.0933852270245552,
-0.6131057143211365,
0.30262860655784607,
0.42589420080184937,
-1.0572681427001953,
-0.6718316078186035,
-0.5213215947151184,
0.02730485424399376,
-0.4093382954597473,
1.0272804498672485,
-0.30606672167778015,
-0.5254886746406555,
-0.22131994366645813,
-0.13095177710056305,
-0.2508935034275055,
-0.5449147820472717,
-0.5980666875839233,
-0.5911666750907898,
0.6530473828315735,
0.5698330402374268,
0.5317437648773193,
0.47884416580200195,
0.008701864629983902,
0.19597002863883972,
-0.0843992829322815,
0.4635433256626129,
-0.718902051448822,
0.46367979049682617,
-0.38379937410354614,
-0.30928555130958557,
0.1036224216222763,
0.019994495436549187,
0.37065595388412476,
0.9643285870552063,
-0.06679560989141464,
0.2480393499135971,
-0.050463128834962845,
0.5308602452278137,
-0.44113585352897644,
0.52674800157547,
-0.4176939129829407,
0.38885563611984253,
-0.25391441583633423,
-0.496572881937027,
-0.21259765326976776,
-0.399824857711792,
0.28240931034088135,
-0.6845312714576721,
0.6019754409790039,
-0.058145567774772644,
0.7910993099212646,
-0.15545213222503662,
-0.4989193379878998,
-0.5679233074188232,
-0.852402925491333,
0.7435688972473145,
-0.3712286353111267,
0.10167322307825089,
0.24178043007850647,
0.16833631694316864,
-0.5138841271400452,
-1.170714020729065,
-0.6944217085838318,
0.030678313225507736,
-0.22860978543758392,
-0.03851980343461037,
-0.4821082055568695,
-0.16564646363258362,
0.36281412839889526,
0.25497710704803467,
-0.3370620906352997,
-0.2792556881904602,
0.00053467380348593,
-0.1700158715248108,
0.39932912588119507,
0.7250684499740601,
0.33997470140457153,
-0.433865487575531,
-0.25591930747032166,
0.14120863378047943,
-0.7282546162605286,
0.06296426057815552,
0.6065850257873535,
0.3511841595172882,
-0.09519486129283905,
0.6372597813606262,
-0.542475163936615,
0.6087921261787415,
0.07383161038160324,
-0.3961494565010071,
0.1909581869840622,
-0.431467741727829,
0.19355137646198273,
0.18211838603019714,
0.5166417360305786,
0.5257439017295837,
0.5444537997245789,
-0.21632850170135498,
0.24766963720321655,
-0.10631817579269409,
0.03936288505792618,
-0.6324388384819031,
0.021538127213716507,
0.08270104974508286,
-0.5951626300811768,
-0.4767210781574249,
-0.11276887357234955,
-0.809826135635376,
-0.816951334476471,
-0.17985624074935913,
0.24701876938343048,
-0.30218005180358887,
-0.21209172904491425,
0.14637243747711182,
-0.5135270357131958,
0.2293303906917572,
0.31783977150917053,
-0.6318783760070801,
0.13473501801490784,
0.6962671279907227,
0.864852249622345,
0.277422159910202,
-0.3779863119125366,
-0.5508106350898743,
0.44998106360435486,
0.024598626419901848,
0.6655015349388123,
-0.5772202610969543,
-0.07046978920698166,
0.1998741775751114,
0.1445581465959549,
0.06341195851564407,
-0.3398429751396179,
0.47609904408454895,
-0.6531181335449219,
0.08496665954589844,
0.06160594895482063,
-0.6070128679275513,
-0.5500903725624084,
0.6095390319824219,
-0.5282987356185913,
0.7308598160743713,
0.062089256942272186,
-1.1211010217666626,
0.3192550539970398,
-0.38750746846199036,
-0.810052752494812,
-0.17333798110485077,
-0.2768378257751465,
-0.1941380649805069,
-0.09317882359027863,
0.07316932827234268,
0.4172336757183075,
-0.24036571383476257,
0.31652936339378357,
-0.1090695783495903,
-0.03216322138905525,
0.009287245571613312,
-0.10860148817300797,
0.6349071860313416,
-0.0014347262913361192,
-0.5234947204589844,
0.06556814163923264,
-0.8645209074020386,
-0.26696616411209106,
0.3889564573764801,
-0.07676679641008377,
-0.2821204960346222,
0.3776575028896332,
-0.3193466067314148,
-0.1384785920381546,
0.04527844488620758,
-0.681069016456604,
0.43825483322143555,
-0.6001636981964111,
0.49198344349861145,
0.2755439281463623,
0.576260507106781,
0.381862074136734,
-0.2450558841228485,
0.5850508213043213,
0.25803232192993164,
0.0862065926194191,
-0.5623440146446228,
-0.5852082371711731,
-0.5512979030609131,
0.28537896275520325,
0.08616627007722855,
0.5498722195625305,
-0.8500290513038635,
-0.005929471924901009,
-0.02544625662267208,
-0.5401806831359863,
-0.2029125988483429,
-0.43000078201293945,
-0.17662252485752106,
0.5599051713943481,
-0.08001013845205307,
-0.1763422042131424,
-0.84669429063797,
-0.6234325170516968,
-0.37954914569854736,
-0.19655632972717285,
0.07276357710361481,
0.07776838541030884,
0.33940163254737854,
-0.36088311672210693,
1.0371218919754028,
-0.7425360679626465,
-0.11997708678245544,
-0.4909376800060272,
0.4087764024734497,
0.2438218593597412,
0.2574251890182495,
0.34417349100112915,
-0.72613525390625,
-0.07396949827671051,
0.3955283761024475,
-0.7571922540664673,
0.28294938802719116,
-0.4601607918739319,
0.16017623245716095,
0.10635127872228622,
0.4672401249408722,
-0.5825981497764587,
0.7520104050636292,
0.21782805025577545,
-0.42575380206108093,
0.49518105387687683,
0.049190208315849304,
0.2708558142185211,
-0.7549299597740173,
-0.1672605723142624,
-0.4291805922985077,
-0.6147705316543579,
-0.530487596988678,
-0.05391887202858925,
-0.3910549581050873,
-0.08447495847940445,
-0.1183575987815857,
0.30871930718421936,
-0.284969687461853,
-0.1709975004196167,
-0.08764534443616867,
0.5204713940620422,
0.1034725233912468,
0.2825302183628082,
0.005492009688168764,
-0.010071913711726665,
0.30115216970443726,
-0.49822482466697693,
0.7317596077919006,
0.15947355329990387,
-0.5390162467956543,
0.32830938696861267,
-0.191199392080307,
-0.1708391159772873,
-0.3352900445461273,
0.4256800711154938,
-0.8314493894577026,
-0.21495899558067322,
0.4126984477043152,
-0.6560912132263184,
0.06546232849359512,
-0.36007437109947205,
-0.8506363034248352,
-0.11271394044160843,
-0.2361127734184265,
0.4108138382434845,
-0.05209652706980705,
-0.44814977049827576,
0.8682209253311157,
0.5217335224151611,
-0.27071413397789,
-0.46721771359443665,
-0.4921792447566986,
0.20247218012809753,
-0.0017132029170170426,
-0.6271878480911255,
0.058275431394577026,
0.009975738823413849,
-0.24172966182231903,
0.3898162245750427,
0.07777322828769684,
0.02550611086189747,
-0.10596879571676254,
0.5311844944953918,
-0.18391220271587372,
-0.2176101952791214,
0.18284274637699127,
0.09281084686517715,
-0.5286376476287842,
0.04926466569304466,
-0.5862056016921997,
0.5833805203437805,
-0.07870368659496307,
-0.353890061378479,
-0.440810889005661,
0.6872888207435608,
0.5956439971923828,
-0.02937236614525318,
0.6969570517539978,
0.6287804245948792,
-0.7370958924293518,
0.05077911168336868,
-0.310384064912796,
-0.14237819612026215,
-0.31138551235198975,
0.2731446325778961,
-0.21910464763641357,
-1.0307363271713257,
0.7282705903053284,
-0.516559362411499,
0.060272689908742905,
0.6227925419807434,
0.62450110912323,
0.11121085286140442,
1.0009114742279053,
0.3337961733341217,
0.20923885703086853,
0.25475743412971497,
-0.32434770464897156,
0.41302546858787537,
-0.45643335580825806,
-0.535650372505188,
-0.41919204592704773,
-0.3507099151611328,
-0.5907559990882874,
-0.21660977602005005,
0.08602434396743774,
0.04358085244894028,
-0.5284818410873413,
0.049420300871133804,
-0.20740701258182526,
0.7262136936187744,
0.5796415209770203,
-0.2537285089492798,
0.6971377730369568,
-0.16749563813209534,
0.0010554126929491758,
-0.17798252403736115,
-1.141955018043518,
-0.4023571312427521,
0.3347490429878235,
0.29816657304763794,
0.6907850503921509,
-0.1693112552165985,
0.7248131036758423,
0.31603285670280457,
0.14234355092048645,
-0.7674821019172668,
0.16807617247104645,
0.22626790404319763,
-0.49171164631843567,
-0.22894485294818878,
-0.499780535697937,
-1.406930685043335,
-0.1467626839876175,
-0.38024699687957764,
-0.6515763401985168,
0.5248231291770935,
-0.49158143997192383,
-0.444274365901947,
0.5896462202072144,
-0.4638473391532898,
0.9985904693603516,
0.04589669406414032,
0.1543571501970291,
-0.2286435067653656,
-0.8354820609092712,
0.007696833927184343,
0.44348448514938354,
0.5177197456359863,
-0.025396285578608513,
0.13672073185443878,
0.5569321513175964,
-0.2913619577884674,
1.1561278104782104,
0.01587701216340065,
0.1463315486907959,
0.6971995830535889,
0.44422051310539246,
0.8520380258560181,
0.14514829218387604,
0.16704922914505005,
-0.05411321669816971,
0.19690409302711487,
-0.378968745470047,
-0.3650893568992615,
0.9083443284034729,
-0.7953525185585022,
-0.3327347934246063,
-0.45546457171440125,
-0.6259660124778748,
-0.14405924081802368,
0.21386943757534027,
0.29627951979637146,
0.757551908493042,
-0.08616781234741211,
-0.14049093425273895,
0.5552498698234558,
-0.20009459555149078,
0.2689100205898285,
0.23083561658859253,
-0.19703109562397003,
-0.2690722942352295,
0.7517144083976746,
0.3993876576423645,
-0.010347514413297176,
0.44997522234916687,
0.19563110172748566,
0.04815901070833206,
-0.5415112972259521,
-0.42511337995529175,
0.18071821331977844,
-0.8734846711158752,
-0.6486745476722717,
-0.682745099067688,
-0.10808715969324112,
-0.10370412468910217,
-0.33627527952194214,
-0.10275587439537048,
-0.5968709588050842,
-0.4171566665172577,
-0.7330563068389893,
0.5464561581611633,
1.0984681844711304,
-0.22678117454051971,
-0.06426006555557251,
-0.9819121360778809,
0.3031928241252899,
0.14661136269569397,
0.4139944911003113,
0.48950791358947754,
0.07460933923721313,
-0.282013475894928,
-0.2167935073375702,
-0.16086453199386597,
-1.0344421863555908,
0.2507669925689697,
-0.05256408825516701,
0.4136437177658081,
0.31780797243118286,
0.5217351317405701,
0.6814625859260559,
-0.44335508346557617,
0.660444438457489,
0.030384855344891548,
-0.7574210166931152,
0.700854480266571,
-0.4936010241508484,
0.2724607288837433,
0.36095431447029114,
0.37008917331695557,
-0.7694193720817566,
-0.5671508312225342,
-0.9913635849952698,
-1.251396656036377,
0.8195028901100159,
0.14897800981998444,
0.16592951118946075,
-0.3060193955898285,
0.6932965517044067,
0.32621926069259644,
0.25058990716934204,
-0.6893044114112854,
-0.5537387728691101,
-0.12584418058395386,
-0.25196370482444763,
0.4042549431324005,
-0.3964269161224365,
-0.40885454416275024,
0.14754118025302887,
0.43041226267814636,
0.10957352817058563,
-0.30333608388900757,
0.5536729097366333,
0.053560491651296616,
-0.28775060176849365,
-0.03404267504811287,
0.28283292055130005,
0.6875199675559998,
0.023650463670492172,
0.43320760130882263,
0.21038620173931122,
-0.23251022398471832,
-0.17748670279979706,
0.2580193877220154,
-0.24490737915039062,
0.023367110639810562,
0.8312011361122131,
0.6979872584342957,
0.5350241661071777,
-0.8970212936401367,
0.42534592747688293,
-0.2433680295944214,
0.03112032264471054,
-0.41454875469207764,
-0.29384616017341614,
0.32900354266166687,
0.8251211047172546,
0.4752873480319977,
-0.027141522616147995,
0.283842533826828,
-1.0247735977172852,
0.19686870276927948,
-0.022853035479784012,
-0.5547564625740051,
-0.10937581211328506,
0.37973254919052124,
0.2255123257637024,
-0.22637639939785004,
0.5780373215675354,
-0.5896890163421631,
-0.5641676783561707,
0.5690467357635498,
0.4239922761917114,
0.576366662979126,
0.28114795684814453,
0.34837305545806885,
0.5429825186729431,
0.45547646284103394,
0.396428644657135,
0.04468419775366783,
0.16897456347942352,
-0.6665905117988586,
-0.585311233997345,
-0.5412283539772034,
-0.30652040243148804,
-0.03523587808012962,
-0.5179349184036255,
-0.13480794429779053,
-0.22461475431919098,
0.03973878547549248,
0.0499577559530735,
0.18741807341575623,
-0.6126261949539185,
-0.06791636347770691,
0.24364162981510162,
0.8826329708099365,
-0.5490656495094299,
0.24158579111099243,
0.5399129986763,
-0.3558264970779419,
-0.49393925070762634,
-0.06803560256958008,
-0.11497710645198822,
-0.4456503093242645,
0.4526529908180237,
-0.011397602036595345,
-0.20837564766407013,
0.017428696155548096,
-0.4273480772972107,
-0.7034533023834229,
1.0648666620254517,
0.23516793549060822,
-0.5728787183761597,
0.16293728351593018,
0.1347004473209381,
0.4152967631816864,
-0.7092047333717346,
-0.29406267404556274,
0.5741614103317261,
0.6553887724876404,
0.2928582727909088,
-0.4299617111682892,
0.0732654258608818,
0.29404187202453613,
-0.42587926983833313,
0.3768589198589325,
-0.30526116490364075,
0.6794672608375549,
-0.6805196404457092,
-0.6908793449401855,
0.015912186354398727,
0.8233537077903748,
0.02402496337890625,
1.0982229709625244,
0.44669345021247864,
0.3914211690425873,
0.9570981860160828,
-0.19127656519412994,
1.2078568935394287,
0.04116040840744972,
0.5887081027030945,
1.0624547004699707,
-0.07519510388374329,
0.36262252926826477,
0.11002632230520248,
-0.04234633594751358,
0.970908522605896,
0.8074929714202881,
0.4161349833011627,
0.3560155928134918,
0.24390625953674316,
-0.39986452460289,
-0.45793527364730835,
-0.29979681968688965,
-0.21157023310661316,
0.061652056872844696,
0.372591108083725,
0.07905920594930649,
-0.6536035537719727,
0.056325871497392654,
0.25021666288375854,
0.16931892931461334,
-0.6132015585899353,
0.845847487449646,
0.008397197350859642,
-0.28155258297920227,
-0.08003917336463928,
-0.09177157282829285,
0.06091319024562836,
-0.6449374556541443,
-0.2977678179740906,
-0.11700061708688736,
0.14071770012378693,
-0.3939461410045624,
-1.2173988819122314,
0.5194706916809082,
-0.0691322460770607,
-0.6600225567817688,
0.11036146432161331,
0.8067881464958191,
-0.456177294254303,
-0.308212548494339,
0.45175454020500183,
0.5668577551841736,
-0.07302314043045044,
-0.15173284709453583,
-0.2815939784049988,
0.1181204691529274,
0.11292004585266113,
-0.2759031355381012,
0.2867371141910553,
1.2542883157730103,
-0.15487580001354218,
0.5616365671157837,
0.5229377746582031,
-0.2394811064004898,
-0.16727317869663239,
0.2545434236526489,
0.7870397567749023,
-1.0877540111541748,
-0.342251718044281,
-0.7861901521682739,
0.4019896984100342,
-0.046946920454502106,
-0.0206435676664114,
0.6180453896522522,
0.6196845769882202,
0.8458964824676514,
0.04845544695854187,
0.8397810459136963,
-0.036308642476797104,
0.5842112302780151,
-0.14130935072898865,
0.4176862835884094,
-0.21950849890708923,
-0.05860048532485962,
0.0744948536157608,
-0.32207536697387695,
-0.4649640917778015,
0.35161343216896057,
-0.019177749752998352,
-0.3672932982444763,
0.448464035987854,
0.2510008215904236,
0.22675259411334991,
0.11268851161003113,
0.03822026774287224,
0.378629595041275,
0.2155434638261795,
0.4251680374145508,
1.2302955389022827,
-0.14294955134391785,
0.8342233300209045,
0.01332940999418497,
-0.28987547755241394,
-0.3569253087043762,
-1.025493860244751,
-0.5780866742134094,
-0.9141760468482971,
-0.2514524459838867,
-0.4416176676750183,
-0.09608102589845657,
0.6279124617576599,
0.3267449736595154,
-0.698081910610199,
-0.05323034152388573,
0.06171153858304024,
0.8782369494438171,
-0.1648380607366562,
-0.28165948390960693,
0.3442724943161011,
-0.3137771785259247,
-0.4719569683074951,
0.24653758108615875,
0.42841464281082153,
-0.07463990896940231,
-0.1294070929288864,
0.1726393699645996,
-0.2603621780872345,
0.12156078964471817,
1.027239203453064,
0.28567180037498474,
-0.3236773908138275,
-0.7665413022041321,
-0.41361066699028015,
0.3676137924194336,
-0.14124394953250885,
1.2362514734268188,
-1.1105250120162964,
0.5679742693901062,
0.571259081363678,
0.4500911831855774,
0.8254501819610596,
-0.3449036777019501,
0.47609207034111023,
-0.9956414699554443,
0.08938194811344147,
0.3370307981967926,
0.3154793679714203,
0.4578259289264679,
-0.29080548882484436,
0.6037746667861938,
0.4808099567890167,
-0.4383035898208618,
-0.7087364792823792,
0.6973596811294556,
-1.0512264966964722,
-0.23859937489032745,
0.8953602910041809,
-0.05513298884034157,
0.00908480305224657,
-0.5450621843338013,
-0.36622750759124756,
0.31855881214141846,
-0.153279647231102,
0.6338129639625549,
0.839435875415802,
-0.5412335395812988,
-0.007494253572076559,
-0.4001641571521759,
0.4375767707824707,
-0.6206921935081482,
-0.5293852090835571,
0.4886857867240906,
0.5243275761604309,
0.12067410349845886,
0.4834345579147339,
0.5142503976821899,
-0.09107615798711777,
0.07412221282720566,
0.24114422500133514,
-0.09046770632266998,
-0.1752905547618866,
-0.3091104030609131,
0.10692108422517776,
0.595826268196106,
-0.06724145263433456,
0.11341740190982819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16375v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16375v1
|
List Items One by One: A New Data Source and Learning Paradigm for Multimodal LLMs
| 2024-04-25T07:29:17 | 2024-04-25T07:29:17 |
An Yan, Zhengyuan Yang, Junda Wu, Wanrong Zhu, Jianwei Yang, Linjie Li, Kevin Lin, Jianfeng Wang, Julian McAuley, Jianfeng Gao, Lijuan Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Set-of-Mark (SoM) Prompting unleashes the visual grounding capability of
GPT-4V, by enabling the model to associate visual objects with tags inserted on
the image. These tags, marked with alphanumerics, can be indexed via text
tokens for easy reference. Despite the extraordinary performance from GPT-4V,
we observe that other Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) struggle to
understand these visual tags. To promote the learning of SoM prompting for
open-source models, we propose a new learning paradigm: "list items one by
one," which asks the model to enumerate and describe all visual tags placed on
the image following the alphanumeric orders of tags. By integrating our curated
dataset with other visual instruction tuning datasets, we are able to equip
existing MLLMs with the SoM prompting ability. Furthermore, we evaluate our
finetuned SoM models on five MLLM benchmarks. We find that this new dataset,
even in a relatively small size (10k-30k images with tags), significantly
enhances visual reasoning capabilities and reduces hallucinations for MLLMs.
Perhaps surprisingly, these improvements persist even when the visual tags are
omitted from input images during inference. This suggests the potential of
"list items one by one" as a new paradigm for training MLLMs, which strengthens
the object-text alignment through the use of visual tags in the training stage.
Finally, we conduct analyses by probing trained models to understand the
working mechanism of SoM. Our code and data are available at
\url{https://github.com/zzxslp/SoM-LLaVA}.
|
[
-0.4523591697216034,
-0.8272765278816223,
0.4041353166103363,
-0.04063361883163452,
-0.3766670525074005,
-0.349810391664505,
-0.04907836392521858,
0.044764649122953415,
-0.27644801139831543,
0.8125374913215637,
-0.9629888534545898,
-0.6394325494766235,
-0.5367919206619263,
-0.08712749928236008,
-0.28360188007354736,
1.0937719345092773,
0.06734612584114075,
0.1418239027261734,
-0.2893684506416321,
-0.4646297097206116,
-0.4152112901210785,
-0.40482184290885925,
-0.46200838685035706,
-0.061898697167634964,
0.6710473895072937,
0.4546107053756714,
0.6431999802589417,
0.8376924395561218,
0.7179195880889893,
0.21016421914100647,
0.4058135449886322,
0.45421701669692993,
-0.5597978234291077,
0.12243122607469559,
-0.28379398584365845,
-0.25511592626571655,
-0.563615620136261,
0.22361984848976135,
0.8308337330818176,
0.1893896907567978,
-0.0110908979550004,
0.3583794832229614,
0.15870322287082672,
0.6098522543907166,
-0.44697144627571106,
0.03696570172905922,
-0.6494156718254089,
-0.025797972455620766,
-0.1903747022151947,
-0.42781439423561096,
-0.5380532145500183,
-0.14710621535778046,
0.2255908101797104,
-0.8705013394355774,
-0.13666987419128418,
0.30340373516082764,
0.8847877979278564,
0.6944096088409424,
-0.16344821453094482,
-0.2112753838300705,
-0.31203973293304443,
0.8093467950820923,
-0.5129125714302063,
0.6261594891548157,
0.4324905574321747,
0.08597274869680405,
-0.029237674549221992,
-0.9017246961593628,
-0.6067875027656555,
-0.06442607939243317,
0.2489614635705948,
0.2048572152853012,
-0.040567927062511444,
-0.20364558696746826,
0.331898033618927,
-0.049596939235925674,
-0.7267624735832214,
0.0688735693693161,
-0.2622811198234558,
0.39864104986190796,
0.3609432578086853,
-0.02392479032278061,
0.4014133810997009,
-0.04186013713479042,
-1.0127114057540894,
0.003914858214557171,
-0.9021828770637512,
-0.08059343695640564,
-0.07923443615436554,
0.4035765528678894,
-0.02768978476524353,
0.36540189385414124,
0.1611844301223755,
0.8874881267547607,
-0.1672830730676651,
-0.43302881717681885,
0.026628397405147552,
-0.3739807903766632,
-0.46547970175743103,
-0.16879501938819885,
0.6209564208984375,
0.5896144509315491,
0.4448982775211334,
0.18299098312854767,
-0.11137177050113678,
0.08369432389736176,
0.31323546171188354,
-0.6536266207695007,
-0.22841255366802216,
-0.20720615983009338,
-0.6419161558151245,
-0.13927605748176575,
-0.0042235469445586205,
-0.5465653538703918,
-0.7464489936828613,
-0.3690045177936554,
0.768067479133606,
-0.5226097702980042,
0.011693766340613365,
0.13594216108322144,
-0.06293561309576035,
0.1612299382686615,
0.41874125599861145,
-0.8042696714401245,
0.2049618512392044,
0.3569844365119934,
0.6352828145027161,
-0.21571777760982513,
-0.5860783457756042,
-0.5850327014923096,
0.02438890002667904,
-0.3861008882522583,
1.0393835306167603,
-0.8793838024139404,
-0.08514351397752762,
0.03721443563699722,
-0.09462393075227737,
0.08835478127002716,
-0.38029444217681885,
0.05246824398636818,
-0.38363364338874817,
0.2515638768672943,
-0.5822876691818237,
-0.49426618218421936,
-0.3631305396556854,
0.5522235035896301,
-0.5647980570793152,
1.0610848665237427,
0.061481039971113205,
-0.5758975148200989,
0.7325881719589233,
-0.6071866750717163,
-0.09822368621826172,
0.1890391707420349,
-0.6864354610443115,
-0.2860272228717804,
-0.23593755066394806,
0.20908378064632416,
0.6928170323371887,
-0.4035734236240387,
-0.06432043015956879,
-0.19780796766281128,
-0.22899457812309265,
0.2377602607011795,
-0.4614388048648834,
0.35519564151763916,
0.12990358471870422,
0.010637697763741016,
0.41555243730545044,
-0.8026320934295654,
0.06215791404247284,
0.17148225009441376,
-0.4962300658226013,
-0.19696107506752014,
0.24561455845832825,
-0.11462104320526123,
0.5179689526557922,
0.0996459499001503,
-0.02477029338479042,
0.6971696615219116,
-0.17551898956298828,
0.25861436128616333,
0.9817655682563782,
0.1316288411617279,
0.4508602023124695,
-0.4040182828903198,
0.6023431420326233,
0.026481159031391144,
0.15592575073242188,
-0.7946770191192627,
-0.6101179718971252,
-0.6083963513374329,
-0.5333912968635559,
0.07324621826410294,
0.5481584668159485,
-0.931501567363739,
0.1494375318288803,
-0.11662239581346512,
-0.15270361304283142,
-0.5202842354774475,
0.3350111246109009,
0.3806290626525879,
0.4756159782409668,
0.45873111486434937,
-0.1211041584610939,
-0.5909258127212524,
-0.614313006401062,
-0.002664737170562148,
0.1133749932050705,
0.08065425604581833,
0.2596376836299896,
0.37802445888519287,
-0.10323739796876907,
0.8780267834663391,
-0.17182137072086334,
-0.5343416929244995,
-0.24294622242450714,
-0.037452809512615204,
-0.11725862324237823,
0.41668838262557983,
0.2743847072124481,
-0.58158940076828,
-0.356790691614151,
-0.07458855956792831,
-0.9129547476768494,
0.20742708444595337,
-0.25368255376815796,
-0.13814851641654968,
0.1130237951874733,
0.4878431260585785,
-0.19791343808174133,
0.5262368321418762,
0.27670684456825256,
-0.3713589012622833,
0.1739487200975418,
-0.15731008350849152,
0.008693210780620575,
-1.0458329916000366,
-0.27288877964019775,
0.10449007898569107,
-0.1490609049797058,
-0.6617434024810791,
0.12331732362508774,
0.18399356305599213,
0.061704590916633606,
-0.627442479133606,
0.7027426958084106,
-0.514991283416748,
0.008966667577624321,
-0.23299959301948547,
0.3473753035068512,
0.17680029571056366,
0.6404123306274414,
-0.16673396527767181,
0.7138472199440002,
0.8335959911346436,
-0.6544115543365479,
0.3258063793182373,
0.4645581841468811,
-0.4586089551448822,
0.5655960440635681,
-0.2610648572444916,
0.17394252121448517,
-0.48899906873703003,
0.007625523954629898,
-1.0670424699783325,
0.19353564083576202,
0.5003530979156494,
-0.13218136131763458,
0.397196501493454,
-0.21333347260951996,
-0.5305366516113281,
0.019185340031981468,
-0.3698212504386902,
0.1308489739894867,
0.4574114978313446,
-0.6755291819572449,
0.3444119989871979,
0.17870870232582092,
-0.09281149506568909,
-0.7197097539901733,
-0.4555583596229553,
-0.22154657542705536,
-0.2031726986169815,
-0.48085859417915344,
-0.12061859667301178,
-0.28218820691108704,
-0.09899920970201492,
-0.15085192024707794,
-0.5079764723777771,
0.12514366209506989,
0.11209370195865631,
0.30326637625694275,
0.7043587565422058,
-0.28953808546066284,
0.6513660550117493,
-0.2928818166255951,
-0.09508020430803299,
-0.2679787874221802,
-0.7366450428962708,
0.5041643977165222,
-0.13312417268753052,
-0.4458447992801666,
-0.1711096614599228,
0.25541913509368896,
0.12373638153076172,
-0.5677156448364258,
0.42366158962249756,
0.6031429767608643,
-0.5327414870262146,
-0.2828761041164398,
-0.4940958321094513,
-0.19486552476882935,
-0.46271002292633057,
0.408939003944397,
-0.5424642562866211,
-0.6683319211006165,
0.19595421850681305,
-0.08663063496351242,
0.13301405310630798,
0.10429202020168304,
0.4742046892642975,
-0.17903746664524078,
1.0750296115875244,
0.5833579301834106,
-0.05100027471780777,
0.6847370862960815,
-0.4391649067401886,
0.04797397181391716,
-0.571391761302948,
-0.15404845774173737,
-0.17367812991142273,
-0.44736096262931824,
-0.31946930289268494,
-0.6342716813087463,
0.40345537662506104,
0.3863070011138916,
-0.23303742706775665,
-0.15945766866207123,
-0.790383517742157,
0.6220532655715942,
0.580357015132904,
0.3379039168357849,
0.29565685987472534,
0.2422153651714325,
-0.06160449609160423,
0.06455550342798233,
-0.8628537058830261,
-0.7550753355026245,
1.1828809976577759,
0.41056767106056213,
1.2113990783691406,
-0.13755472004413605,
0.4968317449092865,
0.14683713018894196,
0.31305932998657227,
-0.8815144300460815,
0.6536310315132141,
-0.3577820658683777,
-0.45763835310935974,
-0.3940849304199219,
0.18672111630439758,
-0.9509696364402771,
0.06666480749845505,
-0.3977414071559906,
-0.90082186460495,
0.18523772060871124,
0.19902266561985016,
-0.4098471701145172,
0.19264213740825653,
-0.46559637784957886,
1.098444938659668,
-0.3446956276893616,
-0.5489339232444763,
0.16365663707256317,
-0.6159681081771851,
-0.0029536117799580097,
0.15263578295707703,
0.08788100630044937,
-0.30273088812828064,
-0.2910843789577484,
0.8135450482368469,
-0.11155103892087936,
0.683759331703186,
-0.03944520652294159,
-0.25743532180786133,
0.2829541265964508,
-0.06561510264873505,
0.7204006314277649,
0.03801078349351883,
0.183873251080513,
0.006276777479797602,
-0.13907590508460999,
-0.30169472098350525,
-0.6176584959030151,
0.7274866104125977,
-0.5898647904396057,
-0.5022569298744202,
-0.2582285404205322,
-0.6681818962097168,
0.013822386041283607,
0.31862369179725647,
0.43998944759368896,
0.7638580799102783,
0.18277448415756226,
0.11011093109846115,
1.0296889543533325,
-0.030122103169560432,
0.2947136163711548,
0.49511411786079407,
-0.5050173997879028,
-0.14501583576202393,
1.1143258810043335,
0.39509639143943787,
0.169920414686203,
0.4012826979160309,
0.08820787072181702,
-0.2280958890914917,
-0.5693978071212769,
-0.6112250685691833,
0.029718399047851562,
-1.114492416381836,
-0.13812215626239777,
-0.5444357991218567,
0.08089101314544678,
-0.295600026845932,
-0.11636362969875336,
-0.16324137151241302,
-0.2042885571718216,
-0.3758235573768616,
-0.06937338411808014,
0.3860204517841339,
0.8834197521209717,
0.4594748914241791,
0.16733866930007935,
-0.6825825572013855,
0.4348677098751068,
0.4938279390335083,
0.39294037222862244,
-0.34713372588157654,
-0.5742394328117371,
-0.24754564464092255,
-0.21002857387065887,
-0.28961315751075745,
-1.0628348588943481,
0.18759280443191528,
0.2584618031978607,
0.6173633337020874,
0.8495938777923584,
-0.18862661719322205,
0.7931947112083435,
-0.7549965977668762,
0.7278199791908264,
0.18964055180549622,
-0.6596664786338806,
0.7241384387016296,
-0.3312663733959198,
0.3553776144981384,
0.2615416646003723,
0.6735409498214722,
-0.5400599837303162,
-0.10324390232563019,
-0.43240466713905334,
-0.5006453394889832,
0.8235585689544678,
-0.24131938815116882,
-0.15652865171432495,
-0.19077613949775696,
0.09055311977863312,
0.42941418290138245,
0.29164019227027893,
-0.6851660013198853,
-0.5438930988311768,
-0.47877657413482666,
-0.22827354073524475,
-0.012772217392921448,
-0.28535598516464233,
-0.18736249208450317,
-0.06010645627975464,
0.6587321758270264,
-0.4009268283843994,
0.18283066153526306,
0.16265827417373657,
-0.18006393313407898,
-0.08019091933965683,
0.391002357006073,
0.6965537667274475,
0.9384743571281433,
-0.04334980249404907,
0.3586854636669159,
0.19001059234142303,
-0.13076798617839813,
0.07926306128501892,
-0.027739407494664192,
-0.022458413615822792,
-0.11924981325864792,
0.138114333152771,
1.1358633041381836,
0.1498871147632599,
-0.693520188331604,
0.3724135160446167,
0.1539219319820404,
-0.10505891591310501,
-0.02638809196650982,
0.040810782462358475,
-0.1995965540409088,
0.3611762225627899,
0.2675199806690216,
0.26742735505104065,
0.10437718778848648,
-0.6231483817100525,
0.2765447795391083,
0.5255118012428284,
-0.393146276473999,
-0.12529362738132477,
0.584879994392395,
-0.06648951023817062,
-0.272698312997818,
0.3730463981628418,
-0.3381814956665039,
-0.2952871024608612,
0.20770062506198883,
0.569743275642395,
0.37530532479286194,
-0.27393487095832825,
0.055465828627347946,
0.11385729908943176,
0.5717326402664185,
-0.30252593755722046,
0.6463216543197632,
-0.07263021916151047,
-0.8366166949272156,
-0.19201499223709106,
-0.26830366253852844,
-0.20671547949314117,
0.2566698491573334,
-0.49647870659828186,
0.5369195342063904,
-0.7677214741706848,
0.037139587104320526,
-0.03350640460848808,
-0.3424276113510132,
-0.8967474102973938,
0.3292059302330017,
0.39966753125190735,
0.707010805606842,
-0.7380525469779968,
1.009320855140686,
1.0892024040222168,
-0.6526010036468506,
-0.8001648783683777,
-0.28851404786109924,
0.11314307898283005,
-1.0856484174728394,
0.6572439074516296,
0.18515142798423767,
0.24354809522628784,
0.34056341648101807,
-0.7456043362617493,
-0.915816605091095,
0.903171956539154,
0.056315839290618896,
-0.4276377558708191,
-0.23604847490787506,
-0.16239148378372192,
0.05113789811730385,
-0.5829991102218628,
0.2476062923669815,
0.5344878435134888,
0.6090842485427856,
-0.10117388516664505,
-0.5447044968605042,
0.16446520388126373,
-0.3528137505054474,
-0.023150969296693802,
0.23945406079292297,
-0.4629611074924469,
0.9160858392715454,
-0.12545499205589294,
-0.27804768085479736,
-0.04880853369832039,
0.21881385147571564,
0.4359897971153259,
0.4419880211353302,
0.3610996603965759,
0.4999830722808838,
0.7432559132575989,
-0.07441944628953934,
0.8285744786262512,
-0.011307843029499054,
0.17780916392803192,
1.309933066368103,
-0.31800514459609985,
0.8723081350326538,
0.48423394560813904,
-0.09253812581300735,
0.3198952078819275,
0.44555920362472534,
-0.27009838819503784,
0.4410005211830139,
0.1583164930343628,
-0.17591381072998047,
-0.38573941588401794,
-0.10696256160736084,
-0.43482840061187744,
0.3710850775241852,
0.4284115135669708,
-0.40686866641044617,
-0.20565779507160187,
0.565782368183136,
-0.08538872003555298,
0.006650891620665789,
-0.39089852571487427,
0.9842987656593323,
-0.007230797782540321,
-0.4883289337158203,
0.8324199318885803,
-0.3830011785030365,
0.6183347702026367,
-0.7516759634017944,
-0.27096229791641235,
-0.05223250016570091,
-0.057167671620845795,
-0.26813632249832153,
-0.49612024426460266,
-0.4007115960121155,
-0.12625768780708313,
-0.3395426273345947,
-0.47911790013313293,
0.9957358241081238,
-0.5412702560424805,
-0.5015459060668945,
-0.12843480706214905,
0.5786156058311462,
0.3939632177352905,
-0.11010383069515228,
-0.6402751803398132,
0.12984587252140045,
-0.07615183293819427,
-0.3852653503417969,
0.3870949447154999,
0.42635223269462585,
-0.19674161076545715,
0.9389965534210205,
0.48227447271347046,
-0.05896250903606415,
0.3067522346973419,
0.25734132528305054,
0.9079372882843018,
-0.602326512336731,
-0.419962078332901,
-0.8506240844726562,
0.7688630819320679,
0.19609490036964417,
-0.19143204391002655,
0.8561143279075623,
0.2436397224664688,
0.9108909368515015,
-0.20187799632549286,
0.8369402885437012,
0.24000290036201477,
0.3195546269416809,
-0.672858476638794,
0.6133599877357483,
-0.744652509689331,
0.38211590051651,
-0.131185844540596,
-0.7890393137931824,
-0.19890134036540985,
0.6948336958885193,
-0.11855117231607437,
0.01451969612389803,
0.8921816349029541,
0.8249682784080505,
0.10034634172916412,
-0.1200220063328743,
0.63199782371521,
0.14223554730415344,
-0.05434175208210945,
0.2411273866891861,
0.988657534122467,
-0.5192356705665588,
0.5693231821060181,
0.06906989961862564,
-0.24471928179264069,
-0.13769353926181793,
-0.7022407054901123,
-1.0384987592697144,
-0.6571963429450989,
-0.4563707113265991,
-0.1622288078069687,
0.17245876789093018,
1.2846784591674805,
0.7867990732192993,
-0.5871924757957458,
-0.008123970590531826,
0.09239257872104645,
0.20602527260780334,
-0.4714720845222473,
-0.12655042111873627,
0.14722108840942383,
-0.5212855935096741,
-0.4955126643180847,
0.606738269329071,
0.6474463939666748,
0.02023107185959816,
-0.24921299517154694,
-0.24175716936588287,
-0.5169479846954346,
0.07838312536478043,
0.6296060681343079,
-0.022097887471318245,
-1.0137181282043457,
-0.26728755235671997,
0.11272396147251129,
-0.0029047473799437284,
0.25094175338745117,
0.7930721640586853,
-0.955025851726532,
0.759288489818573,
0.42047491669654846,
0.4842618703842163,
0.2390751987695694,
-0.0415380485355854,
0.04286688566207886,
-0.9874018430709839,
0.07843350619077682,
-0.06750793009996414,
0.4993525445461273,
0.05370347574353218,
-0.16728852689266205,
0.46112310886383057,
0.05370720848441124,
-0.5729928612709045,
-0.7262617945671082,
0.2833970785140991,
-1.0789812803268433,
-0.26375970244407654,
0.9755130410194397,
-0.2590627372264862,
-0.031956255435943604,
-0.005708461161702871,
-0.6193044781684875,
0.24202780425548553,
-0.34818151593208313,
0.4654476046562195,
0.639504611492157,
0.15209202468395233,
-0.6107274293899536,
-0.5122422575950623,
0.4593886435031891,
0.42669013142585754,
-0.8773054480552673,
-0.1300676017999649,
0.4824278950691223,
0.1168283224105835,
0.048602696508169174,
0.7298606634140015,
0.20563076436519623,
0.553020179271698,
-0.0005999752902425826,
0.3203505575656891,
-0.31964412331581116,
-0.5924392342567444,
-0.427127867937088,
0.18634116649627686,
0.18226540088653564,
-0.5101146101951599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16369v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16369v1
|
Don't Say No: Jailbreaking LLM by Suppressing Refusal
| 2024-04-25T07:15:23 | 2024-04-25T07:15:23 |
Yukai Zhou, Wenjie Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Ensuring the safety alignment of Large Language Models (LLMs) is crucial to
generating responses consistent with human values. Despite their ability to
recognize and avoid harmful queries, LLMs are vulnerable to "jailbreaking"
attacks, where carefully crafted prompts elicit them to produce toxic content.
One category of jailbreak attacks is reformulating the task as adversarial
attacks by eliciting the LLM to generate an affirmative response. However, the
typical attack in this category GCG has very limited attack success rate. In
this study, to better study the jailbreak attack, we introduce the DSN (Don't
Say No) attack, which prompts LLMs to not only generate affirmative responses
but also novelly enhance the objective to suppress refusals. In addition,
another challenge lies in jailbreak attacks is the evaluation, as it is
difficult to directly and accurately assess the harmfulness of the attack. The
existing evaluation such as refusal keyword matching has its own limitation as
it reveals numerous false positive and false negative instances. To overcome
this challenge, we propose an ensemble evaluation pipeline incorporating
Natural Language Inference (NLI) contradiction assessment and two external LLM
evaluators. Extensive experiments demonstrate the potency of the DSN and the
effectiveness of ensemble evaluation compared to baseline methods.
|
[
-0.6372289061546326,
-0.9809831380844116,
0.5185945630073547,
-0.06336992979049683,
-0.20420731604099274,
0.26115813851356506,
-0.22632361948490143,
-0.15098388493061066,
0.2595387399196625,
0.6709892749786377,
-0.7199411392211914,
-0.5182134509086609,
-0.7425013184547424,
0.3850786089897156,
-0.532351553440094,
1.322851538658142,
-0.022979650646448135,
-0.0027916356921195984,
0.08925100415945053,
-0.1341170370578766,
-0.53727787733078,
-0.14041653275489807,
-0.6432859897613525,
0.10966873168945312,
0.36299607157707214,
0.230143204331398,
0.5862035155296326,
0.4114418625831604,
0.3918114900588989,
0.34097689390182495,
-0.441762775182724,
0.0015423537697643042,
-0.4250599145889282,
0.3045220375061035,
-0.03643539175391197,
-0.4228087365627289,
-0.2848374843597412,
0.13462601602077484,
0.024929560720920563,
0.2782185971736908,
0.0830220878124237,
0.11924378573894501,
-0.21160447597503662,
0.7579023241996765,
-0.7358925342559814,
-0.23559336364269257,
-1.213905930519104,
-0.07417286932468414,
-0.17767047882080078,
0.19383247196674347,
-0.37110379338264465,
-0.512017548084259,
0.0971413180232048,
-0.11741339415311813,
0.08449509739875793,
-0.06814403831958771,
0.5055052042007446,
0.3230690658092499,
-0.2311399132013321,
-0.39757871627807617,
-0.13647890090942383,
0.6846413612365723,
-0.9929314255714417,
-0.13268566131591797,
0.4502364993095398,
0.1541105955839157,
-0.39117759466171265,
-0.05851564556360245,
-0.8196501731872559,
-0.5942514538764954,
0.17936691641807556,
0.08228554576635361,
-0.16272224485874176,
0.3109140694141388,
0.09741363674402237,
0.22447317838668823,
-0.6435288786888123,
0.14790821075439453,
-0.41578802466392517,
-0.1271505504846573,
0.8198391199111938,
0.2013927549123764,
0.5795322060585022,
-0.2774694561958313,
-0.6578335165977478,
-0.012065194547176361,
-0.6065441966056824,
-0.3473512530326843,
0.6922471523284912,
0.312779039144516,
-0.1456456482410431,
0.691038966178894,
0.020926853641867638,
0.8136598467826843,
0.23503826558589935,
0.16918621957302094,
0.03845827654004097,
-0.2497292459011078,
-0.4766978621482849,
0.38362041115760803,
1.0573405027389526,
0.5657269954681396,
-0.12823693454265594,
-0.6201940774917603,
-0.12793254852294922,
0.48073557019233704,
0.5208967924118042,
-0.6607009768486023,
0.06260377913713455,
0.6840261816978455,
-0.21655826270580292,
-0.8994336128234863,
-0.038643691688776016,
-1.133109450340271,
-0.8331246376037598,
0.19660378992557526,
0.38575315475463867,
-0.5210644006729126,
-0.015498976223170757,
-0.06149228289723396,
-0.27277326583862305,
0.4651806652545929,
0.10155364125967026,
-0.8479043245315552,
0.5614705085754395,
0.7035684585571289,
0.9761892557144165,
-0.04895896837115288,
-0.13854463398456573,
-0.5043126344680786,
-0.1693846881389618,
-0.5417142510414124,
0.4553825259208679,
-0.3024004101753235,
-0.6233299970626831,
-0.5439486503601074,
-0.14982740581035614,
-0.3552544414997101,
-0.5753760933876038,
0.7505056262016296,
-0.6224216222763062,
-0.07849760353565216,
-0.0031352832447737455,
-0.5143892168998718,
-0.21881556510925293,
0.5575981736183167,
-0.6710956692695618,
0.4022130072116852,
-0.23552270233631134,
-0.8440912961959839,
0.15545520186424255,
-0.5970573425292969,
-0.3816136121749878,
-0.04699886962771416,
-0.14072605967521667,
-0.5517137050628662,
0.22960668802261353,
0.25121447443962097,
0.1363157331943512,
-0.1388261318206787,
0.40660154819488525,
-0.7619723677635193,
-0.4234136939048767,
0.3648297190666199,
-0.5674084424972534,
0.9661862850189209,
0.36006107926368713,
-0.6324890851974487,
0.12572407722473145,
-0.5774140357971191,
0.07383086532354355,
0.2413398176431656,
-0.17433808743953705,
-0.35324299335479736,
-0.0414775088429451,
-0.20845700800418854,
0.21352067589759827,
0.06852934509515762,
-0.9161018133163452,
0.297726035118103,
-0.8417483568191528,
0.6139827966690063,
0.9118157029151917,
-0.1769239604473114,
0.401019811630249,
-0.436649352312088,
0.5700790286064148,
-0.22638660669326782,
-0.009234236553311348,
0.059787433594465256,
-0.45008766651153564,
-0.4542222321033478,
0.011210602708160877,
0.2690240144729614,
0.8596665859222412,
-0.7952513098716736,
0.421448290348053,
-0.0576191209256649,
-0.6353049874305725,
-0.7525312900543213,
0.27826282382011414,
0.47636914253234863,
0.5271906852722168,
0.29746145009994507,
-0.16479429602622986,
-0.8204281330108643,
-0.6257477402687073,
-0.45307183265686035,
-0.4672018885612488,
0.1065605878829956,
0.19998878240585327,
0.4381239414215088,
-0.0015441016294062138,
0.708258867263794,
-0.16735199093818665,
-0.17006663978099823,
-0.5114408135414124,
0.03427932783961296,
0.24223527312278748,
0.21452635526657104,
0.7168081402778625,
-0.7221609950065613,
-0.29428040981292725,
-0.23018012940883636,
-0.8142367005348206,
0.024450557306408882,
-0.08122946321964264,
0.36102646589279175,
0.23487919569015503,
0.3540571331977844,
-0.4444112777709961,
0.566594123840332,
0.6444939970970154,
-0.3405567705631256,
0.507896363735199,
0.054230354726314545,
0.15209658443927765,
-0.8325963020324707,
-0.2344905138015747,
-0.03257941082119942,
0.15584707260131836,
-0.6981657147407532,
0.22809475660324097,
0.0807129442691803,
-0.25080105662345886,
-0.5928778052330017,
0.6443079710006714,
-0.025342656299471855,
0.3062337040901184,
-0.33983707427978516,
0.3346690237522125,
-0.10521110147237778,
0.0955728143453598,
-0.2736929953098297,
0.808472216129303,
0.5643026828765869,
-0.44971829652786255,
0.3378523290157318,
0.4309069812297821,
-0.24293465912342072,
0.49415647983551025,
-0.6439551711082458,
0.48990872502326965,
-0.28440600633621216,
0.05864657834172249,
-1.2847942113876343,
-0.04094289615750313,
0.4024563133716583,
-0.6486521363258362,
0.17924723029136658,
-0.3865572512149811,
-0.1385967880487442,
-0.39374634623527527,
-0.7593734264373779,
-0.08886946737766266,
0.20565693080425262,
-0.4701734483242035,
0.1814444363117218,
0.13980969786643982,
-0.0499332956969738,
-0.706404983997345,
-1.0387165546417236,
0.5879877805709839,
-0.563646674156189,
-0.6817626953125,
0.29058557748794556,
-0.3204439580440521,
-0.5024760365486145,
-0.17376317083835602,
-0.3952344059944153,
0.03021068312227726,
0.6572016477584839,
0.21340470016002655,
0.6530845165252686,
-0.02263568714261055,
-0.4517606794834137,
-0.10735923796892166,
-0.05010838806629181,
0.06481820344924927,
-0.23018071055412292,
0.2699374854564667,
-0.26596441864967346,
-0.24141742289066315,
-0.42785418033599854,
0.10055414587259293,
0.7440487146377563,
0.04059187322854996,
0.956558883190155,
0.2180391550064087,
0.02585730515420437,
0.045884598046541214,
-0.40122750401496887,
-0.1257731318473816,
-0.4663102924823761,
0.1330111175775528,
-0.12054233253002167,
-0.958389937877655,
0.21009932458400726,
0.0990888923406601,
0.06077241525053978,
0.06087581068277359,
0.31223103404045105,
-0.00039410291356034577,
0.842678427696228,
0.07390230149030685,
-0.4701021611690521,
0.011762818321585655,
-0.0049408068880438805,
0.4078998565673828,
-0.9128566980361938,
0.012261340394616127,
-0.5468811392784119,
-0.42482680082321167,
-0.7483590841293335,
0.023056410253047943,
0.13103309273719788,
0.20987851917743683,
-0.038831211626529694,
0.6597384214401245,
-0.26665759086608887,
0.4427456557750702,
-0.11799823492765427,
0.04941507428884506,
0.10506471991539001,
-0.22617816925048828,
-0.19673164188861847,
0.04836811125278473,
-0.28191837668418884,
-0.5840920805931091,
1.3501489162445068,
0.13490383327007294,
0.6904476881027222,
0.4387306272983551,
1.1564750671386719,
0.36477744579315186,
0.3630129098892212,
-0.9758248925209045,
0.7807843089103699,
-0.18668411672115326,
-0.5967680215835571,
-0.2835472524166107,
-0.5659776329994202,
-0.9401707053184509,
0.39936646819114685,
0.011183680035173893,
-1.09891939163208,
-0.22080586850643158,
-0.13556581735610962,
-0.5312626361846924,
0.5925559997558594,
-0.8474825024604797,
0.6836816072463989,
-0.4572875201702118,
-0.1905185580253601,
0.1592250019311905,
-0.544060230255127,
0.646752655506134,
-0.14050543308258057,
0.49921372532844543,
-0.14660201966762543,
0.016278551891446114,
0.5791324973106384,
-0.6743810772895813,
0.8047364950180054,
-0.10983743518590927,
0.013240903615951538,
0.4508076608181,
0.3955841362476349,
0.5919871926307678,
0.22017663717269897,
-0.6309800148010254,
0.10051405429840088,
-0.22291480004787445,
-0.20746660232543945,
-0.6458200216293335,
0.9546446204185486,
-0.5769292116165161,
-0.8664988279342651,
-0.18643642961978912,
-0.28049400448799133,
-0.20350104570388794,
0.12464900314807892,
0.18078063428401947,
-0.023021208122372627,
-0.19313310086727142,
-0.14697864651679993,
0.48922884464263916,
-0.3574431538581848,
0.6251857280731201,
0.32718712091445923,
-0.06113434582948685,
-0.660260021686554,
0.8163455128669739,
0.00039050047053024173,
0.28289416432380676,
-0.1631113439798355,
0.25928980112075806,
-0.3658679127693176,
-0.8493644595146179,
-0.7750803828239441,
-0.1812278926372528,
-0.2902427911758423,
-0.2713991105556488,
-0.4173642098903656,
-0.21485675871372223,
-0.5381180047988892,
-0.05838160216808319,
-0.10861827433109283,
-0.36543408036231995,
0.07577169686555862,
-0.37415483593940735,
0.5112252831459045,
0.6412595510482788,
0.11157234758138657,
0.1627979576587677,
-0.7007681727409363,
0.4539523720741272,
0.2004416137933731,
0.23319880664348602,
0.020142322406172752,
-0.4412354528903961,
0.2926834523677826,
-0.0806938111782074,
-0.5576048493385315,
-1.2021019458770752,
0.4060487449169159,
-0.04881569370627403,
0.5755758285522461,
0.08448173850774765,
0.5385516881942749,
0.5220072269439697,
-0.3617732524871826,
0.7494148015975952,
0.2947996258735657,
-1.1939691305160522,
0.8263354897499084,
-0.3401212692260742,
-0.03303098306059837,
0.8464478254318237,
0.11966439336538315,
-0.35427993535995483,
-0.6143057346343994,
-0.825866162776947,
-1.2692468166351318,
0.8385716080665588,
0.3859580159187317,
0.40198054909706116,
-0.3691980242729187,
0.30733126401901245,
-0.05291694775223732,
0.49543148279190063,
-0.7777189612388611,
-0.6475330591201782,
-0.18985570967197418,
-0.015924392268061638,
0.2781151831150055,
-0.05310939997434616,
-0.18791501224040985,
0.11839815974235535,
0.5516638159751892,
0.059104520827531815,
0.06485594063997269,
0.16859595477581024,
-0.13963912427425385,
0.22107523679733276,
0.8699966669082642,
0.5136014223098755,
0.24202832579612732,
-0.22359392046928406,
0.18901239335536957,
0.42849868535995483,
-0.5223129391670227,
0.46181291341781616,
0.023275762796401978,
-0.4701879024505615,
-0.22472719848155975,
0.13909082114696503,
0.8165285587310791,
-0.1289471685886383,
-0.7390756011009216,
0.6116669774055481,
-0.3499062955379486,
-0.39624306559562683,
0.0068308450281620026,
0.1837693452835083,
-0.17033647000789642,
0.03151155263185501,
0.07916571199893951,
0.2970007359981537,
0.04226486757397652,
-0.3572236895561218,
0.344967782497406,
0.5634503364562988,
-0.7055734992027283,
-0.07147708535194397,
0.6691997647285461,
-0.09635830670595169,
-0.24389083683490753,
0.6165161728858948,
-0.5139325261116028,
-0.540970504283905,
0.8536475896835327,
0.5696296095848083,
1.1677743196487427,
-0.12436889857053757,
0.4029179811477661,
0.2262474149465561,
0.5281938910484314,
0.13151545822620392,
0.22000284492969513,
-0.06432397663593292,
-0.7412905693054199,
-0.5088675618171692,
-0.4780532419681549,
-0.32412075996398926,
0.6218472719192505,
-0.7538838386535645,
0.16022589802742004,
-1.0622467994689941,
-0.14753541350364685,
-0.2576144337654114,
-0.1843806505203247,
-0.18890784680843353,
0.20621459186077118,
0.3908426761627197,
0.8780949711799622,
-0.6849048733711243,
0.6551234126091003,
0.4968871474266052,
-0.22725650668144226,
-0.5675700902938843,
0.35979151725769043,
0.5118592977523804,
-0.690421998500824,
0.5445855259895325,
0.3885851800441742,
-0.00795821938663721,
-0.27635806798934937,
-0.6464121341705322,
-0.4415377080440521,
0.7608532309532166,
0.48860394954681396,
-0.6912368535995483,
0.37071359157562256,
-0.19502472877502441,
0.2943897247314453,
0.031569112092256546,
0.32672441005706787,
0.7068498730659485,
0.5999377965927124,
0.21746285259723663,
-0.7604241371154785,
0.19796906411647797,
-0.05907116457819939,
-0.03777281939983368,
0.3062905967235565,
-0.5366069674491882,
0.5396372079849243,
-0.6141347885131836,
-0.08183932304382324,
0.4439675509929657,
0.2658499777317047,
0.5641510486602783,
0.38017675280570984,
0.5753878951072693,
0.7859188318252563,
0.6074264049530029,
-0.09517396241426468,
1.0615686178207397,
-0.12628483772277832,
0.2691985070705414,
1.148112177848816,
-0.5483816862106323,
0.7400705814361572,
0.6397231817245483,
-0.11971870064735413,
0.3266332745552063,
0.4427034556865692,
-0.21280501782894135,
0.6936579346656799,
0.7061829566955566,
-0.4708525836467743,
-0.012793405912816525,
0.18447072803974152,
-0.09980351477861404,
0.4101628065109253,
0.461380273103714,
-0.09855213761329651,
-0.5677969455718994,
0.05648456886410713,
0.37597742676734924,
0.26551756262779236,
-0.43919241428375244,
0.8315518498420715,
0.05047256126999855,
-0.5312613248825073,
0.6783590912818909,
0.2845550775527954,
0.9053046107292175,
-0.4489358067512512,
0.30830544233322144,
-0.16810932755470276,
-0.11017680168151855,
-0.42011404037475586,
-0.6948339343070984,
0.6713380813598633,
0.4088894724845886,
0.1146060898900032,
0.046007923781871796,
0.5580495595932007,
0.12708382308483124,
-0.29045605659484863,
0.7226459383964539,
0.18053923547267914,
0.1112474799156189,
0.13952437043190002,
-0.9737252593040466,
0.16972562670707703,
0.1450231671333313,
-0.16322021186351776,
0.5674706101417542,
-0.035095442086458206,
0.05919727310538292,
0.640627384185791,
0.7079419493675232,
0.18791471421718597,
-0.024803873151540756,
-0.0716160461306572,
0.7566316723823547,
-0.5212465524673462,
-0.15934711694717407,
-1.4222331047058105,
0.33482787013053894,
0.022659244015812874,
-0.04621216282248497,
1.017994999885559,
0.2846109867095947,
0.7815849781036377,
0.29250001907348633,
1.246402382850647,
-0.277282178401947,
0.172101691365242,
-0.6252630352973938,
0.7644109725952148,
-0.30858108401298523,
0.8017432689666748,
-0.6671652793884277,
-0.36869320273399353,
-0.32055187225341797,
0.5046820044517517,
-0.9302338361740112,
-0.054629333317279816,
0.43557941913604736,
0.7169613838195801,
0.37371283769607544,
0.4031427502632141,
0.3872741460800171,
0.3223024010658264,
0.2216133326292038,
0.4967302978038788,
0.9439727067947388,
-0.7369757890701294,
0.827430248260498,
0.03191617876291275,
-0.08609101921319962,
0.163720965385437,
-0.8584949970245361,
-0.9975614547729492,
0.052310649305582047,
-0.29760774970054626,
-0.7794041037559509,
0.2222883105278015,
0.8158968687057495,
0.36376869678497314,
-1.0133010149002075,
-0.11705569922924042,
-0.4851268529891968,
0.39141133427619934,
-0.07711496949195862,
-0.20050503313541412,
0.13649322092533112,
-0.3704226016998291,
-0.4074229598045349,
1.0408674478530884,
0.4082282781600952,
0.08212005347013474,
-0.10454978048801422,
-0.09058555215597153,
-0.09740447252988815,
0.06873036175966263,
0.1068975105881691,
0.22677315771579742,
-0.7127399444580078,
-0.14198285341262817,
0.048212677240371704,
0.07183771580457687,
0.04171781986951828,
0.46343281865119934,
-0.8076230883598328,
0.510854184627533,
0.14964373409748077,
1.037779688835144,
0.12760969996452332,
-0.14879894256591797,
0.4375542998313904,
-0.6136430501937866,
0.11311366409063339,
0.15397535264492035,
0.14434455335140228,
0.3115190863609314,
-0.43134838342666626,
0.22516727447509766,
0.12321927398443222,
-0.31355348229408264,
-0.6692715287208557,
0.37690025568008423,
-0.6055131554603577,
-0.4133567214012146,
0.8890420794487,
-0.24354879558086395,
-0.5192232728004456,
-0.4443873167037964,
-0.22428621351718903,
-0.13931357860565186,
-0.49271726608276367,
0.9739747643470764,
0.6451454162597656,
-0.022903267294168472,
0.07621274143457413,
-0.6363343000411987,
0.2866412103176117,
0.4958716630935669,
-0.598625898361206,
-0.03862428665161133,
0.014691246673464775,
0.5321540832519531,
0.1253553181886673,
0.36282652616500854,
-0.34821441769599915,
0.07222408056259155,
-0.19116725027561188,
-0.4180103838443756,
-0.09875959157943726,
0.005304344464093447,
-0.7169663906097412,
0.2853330075740814,
0.10879479348659515,
-0.4006446897983551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16367v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16367v2
|
Learning Syntax Without Planting Trees: Understanding When and Why Transformers Generalize Hierarchically
| 2024-04-25T07:10:29 | 2024-05-31T23:47:15 |
Kabir Ahuja, Vidhisha Balachandran, Madhur Panwar, Tianxing He, Noah A. Smith, Navin Goyal, Yulia Tsvetkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Transformers trained on natural language data have been shown to learn its
hierarchical structure and generalize to sentences with unseen syntactic
structures without explicitly encoding any structural bias. In this work, we
investigate sources of inductive bias in transformer models and their training
that could cause such generalization behavior to emerge. We extensively
experiment with transformer models trained on multiple synthetic datasets and
with different training objectives and show that while other objectives e.g.
sequence-to-sequence modeling, prefix language modeling, often failed to lead
to hierarchical generalization, models trained with the language modeling
objective consistently learned to generalize hierarchically. We then conduct
pruning experiments to study how transformers trained with the language
modeling objective encode hierarchical structure. When pruned, we find joint
existence of subnetworks within the model with different generalization
behaviors (subnetworks corresponding to hierarchical structure and linear
order). Finally, we take a Bayesian perspective to further uncover
transformers' preference for hierarchical generalization: We establish a
correlation between whether transformers generalize hierarchically on a dataset
and whether the simplest explanation of that dataset is provided by a
hierarchical grammar compared to regular grammars exhibiting linear
generalization.
|
[
-0.1882840245962143,
-0.8396029472351074,
0.4347035884857178,
0.18001939356327057,
0.11395256966352463,
0.059876699000597,
-0.22341956198215485,
-0.06670230627059937,
-0.1307477355003357,
0.3532780408859253,
-0.7377856969833374,
-0.4332568347454071,
-0.6062970161437988,
0.05655963346362114,
-0.706117570400238,
1.2594164609909058,
0.4167163372039795,
-0.0650731697678566,
-0.2083948850631714,
0.06230797991156578,
-0.24688662588596344,
-0.4583343267440796,
-0.23483282327651978,
-0.5276274085044861,
0.31394344568252563,
0.3047961890697479,
1.0757378339767456,
0.750113844871521,
0.4887356162071228,
0.3450254201889038,
-0.07630179077386856,
-0.35915616154670715,
-0.2758539021015167,
0.01941394805908203,
-0.14248700439929962,
-0.7780511379241943,
0.036813683807849884,
-0.17542138695716858,
0.5824978947639465,
1.2103663682937622,
-0.19644035398960114,
0.07613954693078995,
0.05491984635591507,
0.5601598620414734,
-0.2723050117492676,
0.4870862662792206,
-1.024001121520996,
0.2224072515964508,
-0.14552782475948334,
-0.2813064157962799,
-0.5194647312164307,
-0.19315892457962036,
0.22205522656440735,
-0.44914510846138,
0.988679051399231,
-0.1523384302854538,
1.1772857904434204,
0.4942597448825836,
-0.6055535674095154,
-0.060899246484041214,
-1.0319502353668213,
0.6153588891029358,
-0.2650406062602997,
0.49990472197532654,
0.36848700046539307,
0.3276866674423218,
0.06289936602115631,
-0.685264527797699,
-0.28094619512557983,
-0.39484596252441406,
-0.6658623218536377,
0.11502637714147568,
-0.33049285411834717,
0.4430761933326721,
0.5762174725532532,
0.6761593818664551,
-0.5452947020530701,
-0.041069842875003815,
-0.280647873878479,
0.22189714014530182,
0.19409210979938507,
-0.10736501216888428,
0.30814042687416077,
-0.35437995195388794,
-0.1646304577589035,
-0.35147425532341003,
-0.6419209241867065,
0.17086175084114075,
0.5009055137634277,
0.3516831398010254,
-0.03180025517940521,
0.5438218712806702,
0.04790274426341057,
0.40199869871139526,
0.1637170910835266,
0.08777771890163422,
0.14713528752326965,
-0.39702966809272766,
-0.4920394718647003,
-0.3170665502548218,
0.7551365494728088,
-0.013932767324149609,
0.7865093350410461,
-0.581409215927124,
-0.18619035184383392,
0.4690222144126892,
0.6102750301361084,
-0.44688746333122253,
-0.47541558742523193,
-0.017880134284496307,
-0.4564400315284729,
-0.4818289875984192,
0.12665390968322754,
-0.6440938711166382,
0.005190806929022074,
-0.3945282995700836,
0.11271972954273224,
-0.25938495993614197,
-0.2363564521074295,
-0.06774187088012695,
-0.307672917842865,
0.2948269844055176,
-0.16454759240150452,
-1.4477972984313965,
0.6207724809646606,
0.5629100203514099,
0.3744008243083954,
0.14455682039260864,
-0.41486477851867676,
-0.19456610083580017,
0.060880329459905624,
-0.564218282699585,
0.5990462303161621,
-0.6020507216453552,
-0.24431653320789337,
0.11423373222351074,
0.19776934385299683,
-0.3846610188484192,
-0.8454751968383789,
0.47123491764068604,
-0.25537970662117004,
0.15897300839424133,
0.1923135668039322,
-0.12602369487285614,
0.08638501912355423,
-0.10059528052806854,
-0.5228371620178223,
1.0563087463378906,
0.4319517910480499,
-0.9240999817848206,
0.6750189065933228,
-0.47166189551353455,
-0.557329535484314,
-0.18758752942085266,
-0.5377458930015564,
-0.49571850895881653,
0.3741319179534912,
0.34718412160873413,
0.24559876322746277,
-0.09923896193504333,
0.8215287327766418,
0.045248113572597504,
-0.05517164245247841,
-0.09242412447929382,
-0.26818355917930603,
0.8569691181182861,
-0.1332167387008667,
-0.5548992156982422,
0.34354475140571594,
-0.5498175621032715,
-0.4391385316848755,
0.29480329155921936,
-0.05129218101501465,
-0.17881543934345245,
0.35443902015686035,
-0.15420569479465485,
-0.017423115670681,
-0.4231533110141754,
-0.547559380531311,
0.2599940896034241,
-0.5977274179458618,
0.41137152910232544,
0.6067641973495483,
0.11843685060739517,
0.8293356895446777,
-0.1902765929698944,
0.5074478983879089,
0.23203004896640778,
0.2395690232515335,
-0.37029358744621277,
-0.2810043394565582,
-1.0499881505966187,
0.2696593105792999,
0.22298471629619598,
0.4471614360809326,
-0.5866597294807434,
0.3948744833469391,
-0.38137179613113403,
-0.22635237872600555,
-0.516280472278595,
0.03422590345144272,
0.1489322930574417,
0.5466049313545227,
0.548443078994751,
-0.08728794008493423,
-0.6369708180427551,
-1.4130125045776367,
-0.1412023901939392,
-0.21915532648563385,
-0.2722516357898712,
0.13871251046657562,
0.4219101369380951,
-0.5070517063140869,
1.2266286611557007,
-0.3955425024032593,
-0.11960528045892715,
-0.4964686632156372,
0.1039104014635086,
0.20555473864078522,
0.4959183931350708,
0.6278170943260193,
-0.7103894948959351,
-0.23936164379119873,
0.21218113601207733,
-0.5642516016960144,
-0.06651711463928223,
-0.36278900504112244,
0.019948920235037804,
-0.02353942207992077,
0.6288371682167053,
-1.0045892000198364,
0.5610540509223938,
0.2688383162021637,
0.057382479310035706,
0.41915443539619446,
0.18950074911117554,
-0.5281362533569336,
-0.9604361653327942,
-0.039373062551021576,
0.22443842887878418,
-0.06521487236022949,
-0.6713359951972961,
0.08986283838748932,
-0.004080228507518768,
-0.02145514078438282,
0.17000891268253326,
-0.09688971936702728,
-0.25919109582901,
-0.23014049232006073,
0.09144578129053116,
-0.25983381271362305,
-0.10085085779428482,
0.7969785332679749,
0.1562899351119995,
0.6263607740402222,
0.6187638640403748,
-0.5211391448974609,
-0.06730224937200546,
0.3061445653438568,
-0.24131447076797485,
-0.10886513441801071,
-0.7897449135780334,
-0.26379308104515076,
-0.485679566860199,
0.17082935571670532,
-1.0012937784194946,
-0.13067972660064697,
0.27337315678596497,
-0.4946107566356659,
0.38330838084220886,
-0.4399806261062622,
-0.5327785611152649,
-0.20754089951515198,
0.08002427220344543,
0.07776112109422684,
0.593191921710968,
-0.6129792928695679,
0.45626741647720337,
0.16146261990070343,
0.0393802747130394,
-0.4914402663707733,
-0.6333824992179871,
-0.2847430408000946,
-0.32033368945121765,
-0.358107328414917,
0.4995143711566925,
0.17423038184642792,
-0.37937432527542114,
-0.1540440171957016,
-0.4026627540588379,
-0.021139906719326973,
0.2271917760372162,
0.3770645558834076,
0.09838583320379257,
-0.3776240050792694,
0.29331356287002563,
0.157158762216568,
-0.1226821094751358,
0.5558644533157349,
-0.20486806333065033,
0.45261555910110474,
0.027705121785402298,
-0.24130189418792725,
-0.2812838852405548,
0.1197226494550705,
0.4221798777580261,
-0.12375258654356003,
0.5279161930084229,
0.21068395674228668,
-0.2271200716495514,
-0.5875210762023926,
-0.2597602903842926,
-0.4093235731124878,
-0.45801517367362976,
0.2814900875091553,
-0.3757449984550476,
-0.7487030625343323,
0.05821169167757034,
-0.06368890404701233,
0.17437130212783813,
0.5733548998832703,
0.2726297676563263,
-0.004106491804122925,
1.0932077169418335,
0.9398254752159119,
-0.1109362542629242,
0.4956577718257904,
-0.49243468046188354,
0.28204241394996643,
-0.5540700554847717,
-0.22317694127559662,
-0.730696439743042,
-0.10880819708108902,
-0.9530225992202759,
-0.1162792518734932,
0.10111749917268753,
-0.030766241252422333,
-0.2351812720298767,
0.502892792224884,
-0.47460123896598816,
0.48996248841285706,
0.6008398532867432,
-0.15673689544200897,
0.24542444944381714,
0.354647159576416,
-0.30631232261657715,
0.06406572461128235,
-0.8460268378257751,
-0.35444360971450806,
0.7224547266960144,
0.600353479385376,
0.923413097858429,
-0.2504909038543701,
0.39078211784362793,
0.008970942348241806,
0.23401354253292084,
-1.0223455429077148,
0.1419556736946106,
0.0605262890458107,
-0.44862040877342224,
-0.14032429456710815,
-0.4880228042602539,
-1.2760142087936401,
0.29513436555862427,
0.006560905836522579,
-0.5970367193222046,
0.36251500248908997,
0.07810954004526138,
-0.06333258748054504,
0.20590287446975708,
-0.7712029218673706,
0.9805593490600586,
-0.060397397726774216,
0.03304804861545563,
0.09031866490840912,
-1.0232532024383545,
0.2864122688770294,
0.2022189199924469,
0.12917500734329224,
0.2597406804561615,
0.30637940764427185,
0.2809634804725647,
-0.20195862650871277,
1.0113427639007568,
0.0808144360780716,
0.0420398935675621,
0.09968673437833786,
0.17460794746875763,
0.24495020508766174,
-0.03090195171535015,
0.4266216456890106,
-0.00856736022979021,
-0.32613110542297363,
-0.2682313919067383,
-0.6927874088287354,
0.15347200632095337,
-1.0070210695266724,
-0.7945518493652344,
-0.34284377098083496,
-0.5947633385658264,
-0.37976107001304626,
-0.04975557327270508,
0.5297559499740601,
0.343060165643692,
-0.19246706366539001,
0.3249390721321106,
0.5335800647735596,
-0.07608747482299805,
0.44724240899086,
-0.0023570398334413767,
-0.38109874725341797,
-0.01469916570931673,
0.48882409930229187,
-0.015524261631071568,
0.4905853867530823,
0.7720664143562317,
0.26282799243927,
0.0037906556390225887,
-0.5370883941650391,
-0.2779245674610138,
0.2248518317937851,
-0.5568989515304565,
-0.10896418988704681,
-0.9130433797836304,
-0.540155827999115,
-0.3045026957988739,
0.09768733382225037,
-0.022122884169220924,
-0.5294007062911987,
0.017604950815439224,
-0.5497841835021973,
0.04579096660017967,
1.0942556858062744,
0.3045232892036438,
0.7368390560150146,
-0.5019393563270569,
0.4639694094657898,
0.43368229269981384,
0.20859262347221375,
0.10940749943256378,
-0.40528935194015503,
-0.0695481151342392,
-0.019883226603269577,
-0.4433593153953552,
-0.7937160730361938,
0.43594086170196533,
0.23734942078590393,
0.5679913759231567,
0.41254594922065735,
-0.4087408185005188,
0.5473458170890808,
-0.6178110837936401,
0.4304867386817932,
-0.12440475821495056,
-0.8486534357070923,
0.757761538028717,
-0.5990999937057495,
0.3423868417739868,
0.3967823088169098,
0.5393090844154358,
-0.39989030361175537,
-0.6312114596366882,
-1.0096173286437988,
-0.747015118598938,
0.7002178430557251,
0.4382178485393524,
0.2757311463356018,
-0.2834177613258362,
0.17257189750671387,
0.17969252169132233,
0.3663727939128876,
-1.1846826076507568,
-0.2436380535364151,
-0.4715966284275055,
-0.023488016799092293,
-0.12706074118614197,
-0.13961642980575562,
-0.13675522804260254,
-0.43243128061294556,
0.34093666076660156,
-0.14146962761878967,
0.07619278132915497,
0.08639299124479294,
-0.2950305640697479,
-0.2758202850818634,
0.48072412610054016,
0.07147864252328873,
0.7377526760101318,
-0.16896790266036987,
0.36200353503227234,
-0.15172919631004333,
-0.046031076461076736,
-0.12083347886800766,
-0.007058337796479464,
-0.33180999755859375,
0.26798832416534424,
0.5908224582672119,
0.7669968605041504,
0.30193379521369934,
-0.32353442907333374,
0.46246686577796936,
0.030628886073827744,
-0.16318616271018982,
-0.2080104798078537,
0.03832653537392616,
0.21497073769569397,
-0.024215439334511757,
0.4663642942905426,
0.34967243671417236,
0.1480262726545334,
-0.7272379994392395,
0.23294967412948608,
0.55417400598526,
-0.25715529918670654,
-0.5486040115356445,
0.4317883551120758,
-0.09768164902925491,
-0.1904228925704956,
0.8772021532058716,
0.12978097796440125,
-0.563774049282074,
0.780407726764679,
0.71063232421875,
0.8827680945396423,
-0.2839328646659851,
0.35349273681640625,
0.4644063413143158,
0.7140775918960571,
0.1724272072315216,
-0.3462282419204712,
-0.3683963716030121,
-0.7540389895439148,
-0.3526887893676758,
-0.757917582988739,
-0.2165723443031311,
0.14273208379745483,
-0.6894124150276184,
0.12353189289569855,
-0.5131612420082092,
-0.03494943678379059,
0.10745705664157867,
-0.5316930413246155,
-0.5169676542282104,
0.17905132472515106,
-0.07954670488834381,
0.7951580286026001,
-1.106433391571045,
0.9168489575386047,
0.40787315368652344,
-0.4803045094013214,
-0.8538731932640076,
0.3747909367084503,
-0.38610613346099854,
-0.7138632535934448,
0.8119674921035767,
0.34107181429862976,
0.21865864098072052,
0.0015228514093905687,
-0.6147289872169495,
-0.760922372341156,
0.7697021961212158,
0.3835808038711548,
-0.455024391412735,
-0.42119044065475464,
0.3892381489276886,
0.6783013939857483,
-0.40146881341934204,
0.2651825547218323,
0.7988389134407043,
0.12278521806001663,
0.10641670227050781,
-0.7821994423866272,
-0.3372122049331665,
-0.3187338709831238,
0.19622278213500977,
0.5166031718254089,
-0.210642471909523,
0.8758886456489563,
-0.00888381153345108,
-0.5257823467254639,
-0.13728182017803192,
0.4523642361164093,
-0.18819108605384827,
-0.04193924739956856,
0.48244139552116394,
0.6894463896751404,
0.325870156288147,
-0.22729657590389252,
1.2186338901519775,
-0.12013766169548035,
0.3404187262058258,
1.0944602489471436,
0.07212246209383011,
0.41036513447761536,
0.46184054017066956,
-0.2993179261684418,
0.8881034851074219,
0.5849816203117371,
-0.1025085598230362,
0.41394585371017456,
0.23845072090625763,
0.005308801773935556,
-0.1106022521853447,
-0.3039786219596863,
-0.2789207696914673,
0.2126849889755249,
0.4129466116428375,
-0.6058206558227539,
-0.5244410037994385,
-0.3130779564380646,
0.010336721315979958,
0.13513289391994476,
-0.14181731641292572,
0.9272958040237427,
-0.024389537051320076,
-0.8223382830619812,
0.39240562915802,
-0.18324536085128784,
0.4103309214115143,
-0.7602649331092834,
0.03295808658003807,
-0.3106343150138855,
0.0714326724410057,
-0.5040870904922485,
-0.4885939955711365,
0.6687178611755371,
-0.3152666985988617,
-0.297520250082016,
-0.5162128210067749,
0.5309039950370789,
-0.4873352348804474,
-0.5026745200157166,
0.4231920540332794,
0.5066301822662354,
-0.2318393886089325,
-0.06590776890516281,
-0.47755667567253113,
-0.33362990617752075,
-0.07561661303043365,
-0.10916586965322495,
0.2836768627166748,
0.4534379243850708,
-0.1252158135175705,
0.46682053804397583,
0.5542735457420349,
-0.1781337559223175,
0.211210697889328,
0.4431149959564209,
0.9377069473266602,
-0.5710044503211975,
-0.18065737187862396,
-1.017703890800476,
0.508670449256897,
0.12107501178979874,
-0.03553003817796707,
0.8177288770675659,
0.6416705250740051,
1.1194090843200684,
-0.31041601300239563,
0.6681616306304932,
0.08739559352397919,
0.2515740990638733,
-0.320822536945343,
0.2726903557777405,
-0.17300423979759216,
0.06315961480140686,
-0.18990764021873474,
-1.1069507598876953,
-0.3480956256389618,
0.6905001401901245,
-0.430830180644989,
0.10778885334730148,
0.9234582185745239,
0.9498618841171265,
-0.28690749406814575,
-0.023681869730353355,
0.08494951575994492,
0.31594058871269226,
0.15612681210041046,
0.3519248068332672,
1.0599842071533203,
-0.2699020504951477,
0.5355945825576782,
-0.5455411672592163,
-0.09099620580673218,
0.23766815662384033,
-0.4918079972267151,
-1.045762062072754,
-0.5375224351882935,
-0.11349088698625565,
-0.10576067864894867,
-0.10755036771297455,
0.7999610900878906,
0.673367977142334,
-0.8127455115318298,
-0.634344220161438,
-0.8255741000175476,
0.3911672830581665,
-0.07921089231967926,
-0.3640247881412506,
0.11397842317819595,
-0.7965127825737,
-0.6386587023735046,
0.4265359938144684,
0.213642880320549,
0.08212888985872269,
-0.05373005568981171,
0.3584139049053192,
-0.18041589856147766,
-0.17118240892887115,
0.4462459683418274,
0.17375123500823975,
-0.7463474869728088,
-0.1493152529001236,
0.05454903841018677,
0.0016210165340453386,
0.5526860952377319,
1.0489922761917114,
-0.9899324178695679,
0.14714106917381287,
0.4089948236942291,
0.6237413287162781,
0.41279369592666626,
0.1733085662126541,
0.6430349946022034,
-1.1026124954223633,
0.11826324462890625,
0.15670862793922424,
0.2939067482948303,
0.3759993612766266,
-0.2109490931034088,
0.691124677658081,
0.3868359625339508,
-0.492963045835495,
-0.6151015162467957,
0.45332857966423035,
-0.6604316234588623,
-0.23699486255645752,
1.0316895246505737,
0.354300856590271,
-0.15578386187553406,
-0.020016100257635117,
-0.10014878958463669,
0.24685834348201752,
-0.11065781116485596,
0.6840027570724487,
0.4376315474510193,
-0.09614329785108566,
-0.28398773074150085,
-0.5573018193244934,
0.7718005180358887,
0.5133941173553467,
-0.7386959791183472,
0.11881502717733383,
0.32441607117652893,
0.18830710649490356,
0.30120372772216797,
0.25211653113365173,
0.12236892431974411,
0.11468798667192459,
0.038629788905382156,
-0.1189667358994484,
0.38579797744750977,
-0.6681358218193054,
-0.4324204623699188,
0.3072303831577301,
0.2589765787124634,
-0.025656618177890778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16365v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16365v1
|
VISLA Benchmark: Evaluating Embedding Sensitivity to Semantic and Lexical Alterations
| 2024-04-25T07:08:00 | 2024-04-25T07:08:00 |
Sri Harsha Dumpala, Aman Jaiswal, Chandramouli Sastry, Evangelos Milios, Sageev Oore, Hassan Sajjad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite their remarkable successes, state-of-the-art language models face
challenges in grasping certain important semantic details. This paper
introduces the VISLA (Variance and Invariance to Semantic and Lexical
Alterations) benchmark, designed to evaluate the semantic and lexical
understanding of language models. VISLA presents a 3-way semantic
(in)equivalence task with a triplet of sentences associated with an image, to
evaluate both vision-language models (VLMs) and unimodal language models
(ULMs). An evaluation involving 34 VLMs and 20 ULMs reveals surprising
difficulties in distinguishing between lexical and semantic variations. Spatial
semantics encoded by language models also appear to be highly sensitive to
lexical information. Notably, text encoders of VLMs demonstrate greater
sensitivity to semantic and lexical variations than unimodal text encoders. Our
contributions include the unification of image-to-text and text-to-text
retrieval tasks, an off-the-shelf evaluation without fine-tuning, and assessing
LMs' semantic (in)variance in the presence of lexical alterations. The results
highlight strengths and weaknesses across diverse vision and unimodal language
models, contributing to a deeper understanding of their capabilities. % VISLA
enables a rigorous evaluation, shedding light on language models' capabilities
in handling semantic and lexical nuances. Data and code will be made available
at https://github.com/Sri-Harsha/visla_benchmark.
|
[
-0.08043514937162399,
-0.5679966807365417,
0.5628625750541687,
0.07026313245296478,
-0.026106689125299454,
-0.1747536063194275,
-0.1741037517786026,
-0.5709870457649231,
-0.3099173307418823,
0.4221010208129883,
-0.010692778043448925,
-0.45019418001174927,
-0.6617547273635864,
-0.013105365447700024,
-0.5547038912773132,
0.5400149822235107,
-0.30665823817253113,
0.2974354326725006,
-0.427685409784317,
-0.7524641156196594,
-0.45322319865226746,
-0.2097150832414627,
0.1965685337781906,
-0.09743653237819672,
0.28372901678085327,
0.09903677552938461,
0.8967795968055725,
0.3554150462150574,
0.8730678558349609,
0.2748968005180359,
-0.2674998939037323,
0.13587360084056854,
-0.38378211855888367,
0.23890350759029388,
-0.3310478627681732,
-0.4985758364200592,
-0.18516254425048828,
-0.21431772410869598,
0.9839710593223572,
0.9108439683914185,
0.0672312080860138,
0.4714696407318115,
0.16032937169075012,
0.7727685570716858,
-1.331199049949646,
0.12736696004867554,
-1.0059171915054321,
-0.092946358025074,
-0.28047892451286316,
0.18123941123485565,
-0.2725440263748169,
-0.38603323698043823,
0.04289225488901138,
-0.27834856510162354,
-0.04750475287437439,
0.01805102825164795,
1.021497368812561,
0.5043213963508606,
-0.2454301118850708,
-0.09183140099048615,
-0.5642396211624146,
0.6052183508872986,
-0.7036902904510498,
0.6764859557151794,
0.21649721264839172,
0.31817495822906494,
0.0013883685460314155,
-0.592506468296051,
-0.6426096558570862,
-0.299278199672699,
0.3482138216495514,
0.16289973258972168,
-0.3903789818286896,
-0.315614253282547,
0.16694849729537964,
0.3584717810153961,
-0.3815017342567444,
0.009898677468299866,
-0.24885468184947968,
-0.1292080283164978,
0.24314597249031067,
0.3956085741519928,
0.1305101215839386,
-0.06832336634397507,
-0.490047812461853,
-0.2795080840587616,
-0.8076452612876892,
0.06636747717857361,
0.27943670749664307,
0.23092132806777954,
-0.08054725080728531,
0.9481525421142578,
0.0009862016886472702,
0.9308434724807739,
-0.3846912980079651,
0.11484040319919586,
0.4771861135959625,
-0.37586286664009094,
-0.35292425751686096,
-0.24977266788482666,
0.5005107522010803,
0.7089567184448242,
0.2161603718996048,
-0.03561202436685562,
-0.3050335943698883,
0.47261732816696167,
0.16674621403217316,
-0.5348989963531494,
0.32774943113327026,
-0.228574737906456,
-0.3590335547924042,
-0.11280391365289688,
-0.1732671856880188,
-0.6987824440002441,
-0.6464887261390686,
-0.189117431640625,
0.6866998672485352,
-0.43308839201927185,
-0.0654672160744667,
0.45551541447639465,
0.006125729996711016,
0.7154574394226074,
0.23225338757038116,
-0.5082917213439941,
0.4591415822505951,
0.483370304107666,
0.680491030216217,
-0.36257869005203247,
-0.5387415885925293,
-0.37331998348236084,
0.04308874532580376,
-0.38417527079582214,
0.8494906425476074,
-0.7672520279884338,
-0.2406328320503235,
0.20474234223365784,
-0.19995233416557312,
-0.32793331146240234,
-0.7689221501350403,
0.3305659890174866,
-0.4814119338989258,
-0.2294865995645523,
-0.20969730615615845,
-0.6067578196525574,
-0.14847227931022644,
0.20276577770709991,
-0.6087997555732727,
1.0283534526824951,
0.2727431058883667,
-0.8256288170814514,
0.39745277166366577,
-0.5581446290016174,
0.08298511058092117,
-0.026862967759370804,
-0.17108537256717682,
-0.12077610939741135,
0.38343220949172974,
-0.039625126868486404,
0.22129909694194794,
-0.729015588760376,
0.0794064924120903,
-0.511432409286499,
-0.19142068922519684,
0.4633244276046753,
-0.22654245793819427,
0.46734657883644104,
0.17933449149131775,
-0.11685016751289368,
0.03847760334610939,
-0.8547887206077576,
-0.04595867916941643,
0.09199308604001999,
-0.12396454066038132,
-0.4578232765197754,
-0.02680988237261772,
0.3512190580368042,
0.1310110092163086,
0.43063488602638245,
-0.6962912082672119,
-0.18665993213653564,
-0.39928194880485535,
-0.059918638318777084,
0.6254359483718872,
-0.4584227502346039,
0.2935384213924408,
-0.13593265414237976,
0.24782723188400269,
0.3033141791820526,
0.3509622812271118,
0.22121526300907135,
-0.5019898414611816,
-0.7791154384613037,
0.0021369324531406164,
0.3075074851512909,
0.40121763944625854,
-0.6271393895149231,
0.0028572105802595615,
-0.359035849571228,
-0.46008893847465515,
-0.8912546634674072,
0.2773240804672241,
0.5901502370834351,
0.441281795501709,
0.22792719304561615,
-0.46326497197151184,
-0.3074045181274414,
-1.0057796239852905,
-0.5787413120269775,
-0.16754741966724396,
0.0961008071899414,
0.250171959400177,
0.5292671322822571,
-0.4960061013698578,
0.9528867602348328,
-0.2934742271900177,
-0.2599948048591614,
0.10472512245178223,
-0.07257775962352753,
-0.2396196722984314,
0.004757729824632406,
0.39316555857658386,
-0.8238219022750854,
-0.4736916124820709,
0.11397770792245865,
-0.7995246052742004,
-0.04127512127161026,
0.4478703737258911,
0.2036779820919037,
0.22196002304553986,
0.5900814533233643,
-0.19944395124912262,
0.8675486445426941,
0.5724856853485107,
-0.4383549094200134,
0.4034343361854553,
-0.3653044104576111,
-0.07137446105480194,
-0.8327029347419739,
0.05432983487844467,
-0.15272067487239838,
-0.23606900870800018,
-0.5092591643333435,
0.389560341835022,
0.38432398438453674,
0.04166916385293007,
-0.6272103786468506,
0.530457615852356,
-0.37828347086906433,
-0.37357351183891296,
-0.21344126760959625,
0.18788693845272064,
-0.1757526993751526,
0.1503753662109375,
-0.091671884059906,
0.671310544013977,
0.7386367321014404,
-0.4705899953842163,
0.26032236218452454,
0.10898716002702713,
-0.7342365384101868,
0.5682677030563354,
-0.727605402469635,
0.13131998479366302,
-0.24211111664772034,
-0.2869628965854645,
-0.8307841420173645,
0.1007378026843071,
0.05602506175637245,
-0.21756437420845032,
0.09522602707147598,
0.23372916877269745,
-0.600867509841919,
-0.1665099561214447,
-0.5483206510543823,
0.6064449548721313,
0.21633827686309814,
-0.3651083707809448,
0.6421385407447815,
0.5319210290908813,
0.3429262042045593,
-0.43282920122146606,
-0.5949915051460266,
0.2345626950263977,
-0.10112635046243668,
-0.45970815420150757,
0.26875442266464233,
-0.17589402198791504,
-0.5371482968330383,
0.22207021713256836,
-0.012312890030443668,
-0.021086247637867928,
0.001232895883731544,
0.37086668610572815,
0.20773741602897644,
-0.24316629767417908,
0.05378098040819168,
-0.3638184666633606,
-0.0891844853758812,
0.002256156411021948,
-0.09818240255117416,
0.27230194211006165,
-0.6593021750450134,
-0.576152503490448,
-0.0849020853638649,
0.1677224487066269,
0.7527182698249817,
-0.2775966227054596,
0.7612408995628357,
0.575149416923523,
-0.5296118259429932,
0.31588369607925415,
-0.6684969067573547,
0.30746012926101685,
-0.35757917165756226,
0.35944145917892456,
-0.5145577788352966,
-0.7725052833557129,
0.5843110084533691,
-0.04989703744649887,
-0.2505968511104584,
0.4861699342727661,
0.8687081336975098,
0.13250620663166046,
0.6464645266532898,
0.9156944751739502,
0.012956919148564339,
0.2584129273891449,
-0.04456770420074463,
0.0573376789689064,
-1.0429205894470215,
-0.27571049332618713,
-0.4681060016155243,
-0.00941594410687685,
-0.730323076248169,
-0.7416458129882812,
0.2798563539981842,
-0.2816534638404846,
-0.1980540007352829,
0.371084064245224,
-0.13331839442253113,
0.40516892075538635,
0.24889682233333588,
0.07673949003219604,
0.07193651795387268,
-0.12682180106639862,
-0.2960461676120758,
-0.15887784957885742,
-0.3285912573337555,
-0.6051872372627258,
1.2199963331222534,
0.34753555059432983,
1.1459299325942993,
0.3346923589706421,
0.30760258436203003,
0.29436272382736206,
-0.05634044110774994,
-0.4871028959751129,
0.45408549904823303,
-0.15892960131168365,
-0.32373034954071045,
-0.07307149469852448,
-0.009939665906131268,
-0.8162967562675476,
0.4059179127216339,
-0.11681544035673141,
-1.0024299621582031,
0.6484787464141846,
-0.18333762884140015,
-0.19553272426128387,
0.36879613995552063,
-0.7860051393508911,
0.8487438559532166,
-0.014437330886721611,
-0.6285817623138428,
-0.0997183695435524,
-0.6059140563011169,
-0.05278128758072853,
-0.18342188000679016,
0.26091518998146057,
-0.35867878794670105,
-0.5008894801139832,
0.49428513646125793,
-0.19448380172252655,
0.8155460357666016,
0.018661094829440117,
-0.24853703379631042,
0.07620139420032501,
0.2542306184768677,
0.19546723365783691,
-0.1984669715166092,
-0.15951187908649445,
0.11534955352544785,
0.18632318079471588,
-0.46959802508354187,
-0.45954713225364685,
0.6730653643608093,
-0.789336085319519,
-0.2516517639160156,
-0.29068511724472046,
-0.821599543094635,
-0.5124800205230713,
-0.022041575983166695,
0.1809898167848587,
0.6231902241706848,
-0.35061198472976685,
0.19268368184566498,
0.6123759746551514,
-0.3006773591041565,
0.4202935993671417,
0.6525397896766663,
-0.412487268447876,
0.029615625739097595,
0.7827129364013672,
-0.19070306420326233,
0.4836740493774414,
0.4023837745189667,
0.10643624514341354,
-0.35183465480804443,
-0.4347066879272461,
-0.19566920399665833,
-0.009134260006248951,
-1.0113224983215332,
-0.21308256685733795,
-0.5521419644355774,
-0.15085670351982117,
-0.33603036403656006,
0.04187089577317238,
-0.712300717830658,
-0.11818338185548782,
0.012410006485879421,
0.24282868206501007,
0.3610363304615021,
1.1581354141235352,
-0.07964204996824265,
-0.03754618763923645,
-0.4553811252117157,
0.29689404368400574,
0.2675376832485199,
0.48692867159843445,
-0.28379786014556885,
-0.7376103401184082,
-0.1794324368238449,
-0.0019739503040909767,
0.016266826540231705,
-0.8606008291244507,
0.25244033336639404,
0.30456632375717163,
0.43535947799682617,
0.14563460648059845,
-0.2274206280708313,
0.49992093443870544,
-0.48486825823783875,
0.5277173519134521,
0.04643608257174492,
-1.0255385637283325,
0.47186800837516785,
-0.09203001111745834,
0.5104860663414001,
0.7080777883529663,
0.11557416617870331,
-0.30618029832839966,
-0.4476169943809509,
-0.2641318142414093,
-0.7026079893112183,
0.2660520076751709,
0.2965746223926544,
0.09487967938184738,
0.11328507959842682,
0.11359608918428421,
0.18641607463359833,
0.0639304667711258,
-0.7158582210540771,
-0.23147450387477875,
-0.03192482143640518,
-0.08844693005084991,
-0.10631997138261795,
-0.6036030054092407,
0.0837918296456337,
-0.42431962490081787,
0.19493405520915985,
-0.1347905695438385,
0.10857057571411133,
0.08875277638435364,
-0.7606093287467957,
0.21024836599826813,
0.19543617963790894,
0.5440155267715454,
0.8477683663368225,
-0.33045288920402527,
0.2962091863155365,
0.546908974647522,
-0.5409349203109741,
-0.08369696140289307,
-0.08995721489191055,
-0.034211814403533936,
0.02753698267042637,
0.37689751386642456,
0.9637502431869507,
0.6313852071762085,
-0.6815574765205383,
0.7035355567932129,
-0.3185166120529175,
0.04557960852980614,
-0.07526949048042297,
-0.18087296187877655,
0.026720991358160973,
0.17972050607204437,
0.08368615061044693,
0.15779508650302887,
0.3059021830558777,
-0.44480443000793457,
-0.006737323012202978,
0.34676989912986755,
-0.7142528295516968,
-0.2015472650527954,
0.5369511842727661,
-0.2749793529510498,
-0.13190889358520508,
0.10685937106609344,
-0.1603882610797882,
-0.30430883169174194,
0.3744655251502991,
0.5789922475814819,
0.7813665270805359,
-0.15453314781188965,
0.04280618205666542,
0.07616137713193893,
0.36289626359939575,
0.331111341714859,
0.3770974278450012,
0.04494091123342514,
-0.991418182849884,
0.14603421092033386,
-0.6803542971611023,
-0.5217888951301575,
-0.18511323630809784,
-1.0024861097335815,
0.10442378371953964,
-0.11033644527196884,
-0.07617678493261337,
0.18962864577770233,
-0.353589802980423,
-0.9230126142501831,
-0.08954665809869766,
0.3105859160423279,
0.8690652251243591,
-0.836798906326294,
0.8865740299224854,
0.9877522587776184,
-0.3650023639202118,
-0.2913961410522461,
0.04878617823123932,
-0.029218269512057304,
-1.0922791957855225,
0.7134569883346558,
0.11404165625572205,
-0.42022791504859924,
-0.24144357442855835,
-0.43186214566230774,
-0.7797417640686035,
0.8562319874763489,
0.6755919456481934,
-0.4254254400730133,
0.3887968063354492,
0.5425018668174744,
0.7018202543258667,
-0.3211764395236969,
0.34596332907676697,
0.7021918296813965,
0.361960768699646,
-0.11043776571750641,
-0.9780476093292236,
0.013353046029806137,
-0.3633730411529541,
0.6363186240196228,
-0.03384516388177872,
-0.33482375741004944,
0.8323301672935486,
-0.25067591667175293,
-0.1983020305633545,
0.07996425777673721,
0.6779764890670776,
-0.11873628944158554,
0.05028734356164932,
0.5069977641105652,
0.5921885967254639,
0.5838912725448608,
0.09976933151483536,
1.1678671836853027,
-0.311585932970047,
0.31212517619132996,
1.0406564474105835,
-0.7355627417564392,
1.084588646888733,
0.6155609488487244,
-0.3028900623321533,
0.37706249952316284,
0.19851113855838776,
0.2293306142091751,
0.5868250131607056,
0.2772563695907593,
-0.3946721851825714,
-0.13914932310581207,
-0.3654264509677887,
-0.4756302535533905,
0.8719151616096497,
0.3904953598976135,
0.07663221657276154,
-0.6881718635559082,
0.34953832626342773,
-0.18656037747859955,
0.42817455530166626,
-0.1847451776266098,
0.7728173136711121,
-0.010190419852733612,
-0.274842232465744,
0.7486225366592407,
-0.09253022074699402,
0.6883840560913086,
-0.4254271984100342,
0.24268144369125366,
-0.1875077337026596,
0.5852944254875183,
0.05426277965307236,
-0.9359759092330933,
0.34936702251434326,
0.13917480409145355,
-0.16169577836990356,
0.02251282148063183,
0.7638474106788635,
-0.29736149311065674,
-0.6416741609573364,
0.7909626960754395,
0.42292600870132446,
0.1500706672668457,
-0.08396220952272415,
-0.7334288954734802,
0.5437079071998596,
-0.20412632822990417,
0.03469381481409073,
0.4211122393608093,
0.2803940176963806,
-0.06586811691522598,
0.6299569010734558,
0.19628766179084778,
-0.040237411856651306,
0.319568932056427,
0.47085458040237427,
0.8497048020362854,
-0.6578809022903442,
0.15481406450271606,
-0.8365011811256409,
0.061894603073596954,
0.04569300264120102,
-0.4840039312839508,
0.7563411593437195,
0.5826996564865112,
0.8052157163619995,
-0.07993262261152267,
0.3041675388813019,
-0.019037190824747086,
0.18712973594665527,
-0.5101025104522705,
0.6930025815963745,
-0.8163242340087891,
0.019247645512223244,
-0.3655985891819,
-0.7430210709571838,
-0.4177939295768738,
0.38598188757896423,
-0.21510179340839386,
-0.1217404156923294,
0.8665034770965576,
1.0732207298278809,
0.08264654874801636,
-0.1977015882730484,
0.6220788955688477,
0.20773586630821228,
-0.059274181723594666,
0.5537256002426147,
0.9595790505409241,
-0.6787174344062805,
0.26459836959838867,
-0.18152552843093872,
-0.1502411812543869,
-0.10549397021532059,
-0.9365608096122742,
-0.7294136881828308,
-1.007493019104004,
-0.3289565443992615,
-0.3101825714111328,
0.4003484547138214,
0.5413767695426941,
0.2888755798339844,
-0.7973397970199585,
-0.3720913827419281,
0.0315677709877491,
0.08799492567777634,
-0.060208067297935486,
-0.10710196197032928,
0.35385021567344666,
-0.4919043779373169,
-0.5335196852684021,
0.26360902190208435,
0.5829108953475952,
-0.15431003272533417,
-0.1451350450515747,
-0.012069685384631157,
-0.3528089225292206,
0.06450309604406357,
0.6716306805610657,
0.17236268520355225,
-0.9046638607978821,
-0.3187199831008911,
-0.07108429074287415,
-0.3598528206348419,
0.04205918684601784,
0.4165549576282501,
-0.6768057942390442,
0.67184978723526,
0.3166092038154602,
0.59775710105896,
0.49663299322128296,
-0.5921850204467773,
0.44433504343032837,
-0.2840394377708435,
0.33011817932128906,
-0.040606819093227386,
0.6382858157157898,
0.5346437692642212,
0.07670539617538452,
0.5876684784889221,
0.0180827546864748,
-0.21958932280540466,
-0.958035945892334,
-0.0005409784498624504,
-0.8636207580566406,
-0.10887187719345093,
1.2074700593948364,
-0.02945457585155964,
-0.48394766449928284,
0.03955623507499695,
-0.04122765362262726,
0.13361507654190063,
0.1924668401479721,
0.5025076270103455,
0.6130079030990601,
0.46000632643699646,
0.08257779479026794,
-0.7217217087745667,
0.2946849465370178,
0.6315280199050903,
-0.5767538547515869,
0.1445416361093521,
0.2566830813884735,
0.11077097803354263,
-0.02748830057680607,
0.24495601654052734,
-0.46283501386642456,
0.3915651738643646,
0.10701863467693329,
0.2582882344722748,
0.23157274723052979,
-0.24723085761070251,
-0.5657703876495361,
-0.13219954073429108,
0.30437958240509033,
-0.3699137568473816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16341v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16341v1
|
PILA: A Historical-Linguistic Dataset of Proto-Italic and Latin
| 2024-04-25T05:33:47 | 2024-04-25T05:33:47 |
Stephen Bothwell, Brian DuSell, David Chiang, Brian Krostenko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Computational historical linguistics seeks to systematically understand
processes of sound change, including during periods at which little to no
formal recording of language is attested. At the same time, few computational
resources exist which deeply explore phonological and morphological connections
between proto-languages and their descendants. This is particularly true for
the family of Italic languages. To assist historical linguists in the study of
Italic sound change, we introduce the Proto-Italic to Latin (PILA) dataset,
which consists of roughly 3,000 pairs of forms from Proto-Italic and Latin. We
provide a detailed description of how our dataset was created and organized.
Then, we exhibit PILA's value in two ways. First, we present baseline results
for PILA on a pair of traditional computational historical linguistics tasks.
Second, we demonstrate PILA's capability for enhancing other
historical-linguistic datasets through a dataset compatibility study.
|
[
-0.26294392347335815,
-0.3913683295249939,
0.25059667229652405,
0.3065018653869629,
0.04555239528417587,
0.06803125143051147,
-0.320601224899292,
-0.1728796809911728,
0.5839546322822571,
0.19099198281764984,
-0.29491519927978516,
-0.3605659306049347,
-0.3538278043270111,
-0.09154771268367767,
-0.4304759204387665,
0.952764093875885,
0.14941225945949554,
0.06938309967517853,
0.4109452962875366,
-0.013213885016739368,
-0.21937362849712372,
-0.6464012265205383,
-0.4258591830730438,
0.01703452318906784,
0.6707200407981873,
0.4676419496536255,
0.9272856116294861,
0.6984714269638062,
0.46760356426239014,
0.13788241147994995,
-0.2721879184246063,
-0.1263054460287094,
-0.41253137588500977,
0.36101585626602173,
-0.3322758674621582,
-0.50969398021698,
-0.5209738612174988,
-0.13750006258487701,
1.096706748008728,
1.004819393157959,
0.24794811010360718,
0.2969955801963806,
-0.37648436427116394,
0.9093126058578491,
-0.8150677680969238,
0.44921424984931946,
-0.7486155033111572,
0.013425651006400585,
-1.3245093822479248,
-0.6455597281455994,
-0.5271936058998108,
-0.38486728072166443,
-0.24744325876235962,
-0.6436865329742432,
0.3733328580856323,
-0.06496906280517578,
0.777405321598053,
0.11726292222738266,
0.17006205022335052,
-0.27888602018356323,
-1.1386462450027466,
0.27811598777770996,
-0.43873175978660583,
0.5410950779914856,
0.5917105078697205,
0.2988281846046448,
-0.4063078463077545,
-0.7356971502304077,
-0.5608744025230408,
-0.1782844215631485,
0.0378572978079319,
-0.011841666884720325,
-0.5003937482833862,
-0.390500009059906,
0.017475442960858345,
0.5807443261146545,
-0.7725897431373596,
-0.01194513775408268,
-1.218686819076538,
-0.23680417239665985,
0.6840136647224426,
0.05663066357374191,
0.394565612077713,
0.33006981015205383,
0.3229585587978363,
-0.3121819794178009,
-1.294551968574524,
-0.02831490896642208,
0.6478874087333679,
0.8857104778289795,
-0.1461910605430603,
0.5959916710853577,
0.3317300081253052,
1.0225642919540405,
-0.19086439907550812,
-0.3699103593826294,
0.2167941778898239,
-0.2504979968070984,
0.05941358208656311,
0.36184176802635193,
0.778556764125824,
-0.06253036111593246,
0.3995417654514313,
-0.15351563692092896,
0.2222897708415985,
0.22201906144618988,
0.08726736903190613,
-0.31249064207077026,
-0.3070679306983948,
-0.10525987297296524,
-0.13001686334609985,
0.2792074382305145,
0.08009837567806244,
-0.5172222852706909,
-0.38752052187919617,
-0.35277259349823,
0.013157964684069157,
-0.6177406907081604,
-0.5542182326316833,
-0.0894579142332077,
-0.1484755128622055,
0.008013462647795677,
0.11616277694702148,
-1.1259572505950928,
0.27770090103149414,
0.8888092637062073,
0.8868107795715332,
-0.21954691410064697,
-0.4488431215286255,
-0.4223945736885071,
-0.08383999019861221,
-0.5862034559249878,
0.8282567858695984,
-0.7558732628822327,
-0.6248961687088013,
-0.2532326579093933,
-0.1672811359167099,
-0.11916293203830719,
-0.6845492720603943,
0.4477851986885071,
-0.3472055196762085,
-0.10506179183721542,
-0.12586809694766998,
-0.5114116072654724,
-0.1308373510837555,
-0.3985871374607086,
-0.9368074536323547,
0.9985067844390869,
0.2605983018875122,
-0.5583219528198242,
0.4810858368873596,
-0.44866031408309937,
-0.5442559719085693,
0.23999536037445068,
-0.3585767447948456,
-0.30889296531677246,
0.3695210814476013,
-0.341351181268692,
-0.04691491276025772,
-0.5132952928543091,
0.34865236282348633,
-0.33280184864997864,
-0.5113698840141296,
0.03523855283856392,
-0.1329822987318039,
1.0480650663375854,
0.42954087257385254,
-0.282049298286438,
-0.14406123757362366,
-0.6724903583526611,
-0.4486125111579895,
-0.16431351006031036,
0.0052232565358281136,
-0.18703670799732208,
-0.25871792435646057,
0.24961265921592712,
-0.2002810537815094,
0.016695795580744743,
-0.4158756732940674,
0.5229635238647461,
-0.3290511965751648,
0.3355880379676819,
0.30058199167251587,
-0.24764591455459595,
0.5231444239616394,
-0.4328277111053467,
0.3643124997615814,
-0.23021140694618225,
0.11967004835605621,
-0.33582016825675964,
-0.8120651245117188,
-0.5706465840339661,
-0.317855566740036,
0.617003321647644,
0.22058071196079254,
-0.066775381565094,
0.06379202008247375,
-0.18098486959934235,
-0.4404394030570984,
-0.8598313927650452,
-0.12644855678081512,
-0.28476792573928833,
0.4860531687736511,
0.22855453193187714,
-0.08977516740560532,
-0.8701907396316528,
-0.8305968642234802,
0.2230340987443924,
-0.7237120270729065,
0.1552324742078781,
-0.04842406138777733,
0.2559691369533539,
0.054472338408231735,
1.2340871095657349,
0.07574742287397385,
-0.43991926312446594,
0.2869822680950165,
0.288417249917984,
0.4408552050590515,
0.4129032492637634,
0.8094476461410522,
-0.7705750465393066,
-0.5076704025268555,
0.2631050646305084,
-0.4777885973453522,
-0.26600390672683716,
0.016344716772437096,
0.1647339016199112,
0.16322395205497742,
0.29675430059432983,
0.1555415689945221,
0.7423444390296936,
0.6085066795349121,
-0.3424246311187744,
0.42152929306030273,
-0.09564397484064102,
0.17442959547042847,
-0.8466048836708069,
0.6444818377494812,
-0.30035531520843506,
0.13200658559799194,
-0.8989545106887817,
-0.15786293148994446,
0.0366993173956871,
-0.17054682970046997,
-0.5777587294578552,
0.7993097305297852,
-0.47475141286849976,
-0.5841354131698608,
-0.3824905455112457,
-0.06629525125026703,
-0.29160475730895996,
0.15357761085033417,
0.3871265947818756,
1.01589035987854,
0.7746288776397705,
-0.5042532086372375,
0.11429742723703384,
0.016591502353549004,
0.01709514670073986,
0.46856001019477844,
-0.3741381764411926,
0.10410337895154953,
-0.2998999059200287,
0.05723042041063309,
-0.8107185959815979,
0.07049534469842911,
0.33187568187713623,
-0.6459866166114807,
0.2832055687904358,
-0.3309977054595947,
-0.40021657943725586,
0.07696308195590973,
-0.0870802104473114,
0.7147431969642639,
0.030516615137457848,
-0.13993307948112488,
0.5121743679046631,
0.6163106560707092,
-0.7306696772575378,
-0.3156125247478485,
-0.2954765856266022,
0.3834182024002075,
-0.3325337767601013,
-0.6413801312446594,
0.5533881187438965,
-0.3209623694419861,
-0.8256601691246033,
-0.06851503252983093,
0.15204423666000366,
-0.5390453934669495,
-0.0013454521540552378,
0.5311105847358704,
0.4920234978199005,
-0.5417549014091492,
0.2798968553543091,
0.027609283104538918,
-0.13014979660511017,
-0.49226999282836914,
-0.2881098687648773,
0.7949075102806091,
-0.239559605717659,
0.03585653379559517,
-0.5997418165206909,
0.2634306252002716,
0.9201874136924744,
0.048407722264528275,
0.7233792543411255,
0.12030439078807831,
-0.4327438175678253,
0.44914278388023376,
-0.447797030210495,
0.08355800062417984,
-0.29077833890914917,
-0.38264328241348267,
-0.7233335971832275,
-0.5964491963386536,
0.5482291579246521,
0.10993712395429611,
0.24720878899097443,
0.7745883464813232,
0.8795864582061768,
-0.3917398750782013,
0.04513931646943092,
0.3836601972579956,
-0.43276914954185486,
0.5654534101486206,
-0.19279606640338898,
-0.2853611707687378,
-0.5797097086906433,
-0.2386625111103058,
-0.8225218057632446,
-0.1535664051771164,
-0.3976651728153229,
-0.1786787509918213,
0.37593093514442444,
0.01636125147342682,
-0.29497209191322327,
0.5990307927131653,
0.005444319918751717,
0.16605611145496368,
0.46065452694892883,
-0.2047608494758606,
0.39570853114128113,
0.19562309980392456,
0.1908292919397354,
-0.31599533557891846,
-0.46135658025741577,
-0.45973435044288635,
1.192767858505249,
0.10957203060388565,
0.6874597072601318,
0.40394434332847595,
0.4027690589427948,
0.8320260047912598,
0.21935240924358368,
-0.5256414413452148,
-0.08391271531581879,
-0.26447129249572754,
-0.5721859335899353,
-0.15739551186561584,
-0.08458127826452255,
-1.1819103956222534,
-0.09277660399675369,
-0.17350256443023682,
-0.7992342114448547,
0.6134107112884521,
0.42655205726623535,
-0.5010679364204407,
0.09409384429454803,
-0.3093411922454834,
0.4660443663597107,
-0.2544962763786316,
-0.39632490277290344,
0.003178470302373171,
-0.5233436822891235,
-0.030160197988152504,
-0.12614159286022186,
0.22722069919109344,
0.07081947475671768,
0.17055337131023407,
0.6929628849029541,
-0.35261157155036926,
0.7906301021575928,
0.3004808723926544,
-0.23506394028663635,
0.2537058889865875,
0.515525221824646,
0.017301267012953758,
-0.021249443292617798,
-0.4430506229400635,
0.1776772439479828,
0.0460900142788887,
-0.4359596371650696,
-0.3955000042915344,
0.5925860404968262,
-0.7362726330757141,
-0.19606971740722656,
-0.5216643214225769,
-0.7040610313415527,
0.00131161545868963,
0.007044986356049776,
0.5612165927886963,
0.37582311034202576,
-0.2662031948566437,
0.14902348816394806,
0.27278009057044983,
0.10284379124641418,
0.5098274946212769,
0.5400527119636536,
-0.27863800525665283,
-0.2026136964559555,
0.7754360437393188,
0.19874271750450134,
-0.124451644718647,
0.48562192916870117,
0.2063629925251007,
-0.3333493769168854,
-0.4516191780567169,
-0.5257061123847961,
0.41779109835624695,
-0.3352072536945343,
0.08906569331884384,
-0.15165840089321136,
0.012003166601061821,
-0.509591281414032,
-0.004819726105779409,
-0.5345138311386108,
-0.7521268129348755,
-0.3922569453716278,
0.19391807913780212,
0.49694663286209106,
0.8994014859199524,
-0.20929232239723206,
0.5085393786430359,
-0.4127468764781952,
0.1372329294681549,
-0.24438107013702393,
0.11736610531806946,
-0.4188104271888733,
-0.6270381212234497,
0.28391754627227783,
-0.0446048304438591,
0.34424418210983276,
-1.239845633506775,
0.5321192145347595,
0.6943509578704834,
0.5123216509819031,
0.30562150478363037,
-0.15102340281009674,
0.600237250328064,
-0.47319063544273376,
0.5545216798782349,
0.013146498240530491,
-0.9108121395111084,
0.6757597923278809,
-0.23883138597011566,
0.07154522091150284,
0.6593832969665527,
0.6391838788986206,
-0.6978632807731628,
-0.1685352325439453,
-0.6785178780555725,
-0.6568926572799683,
0.4499340355396271,
0.45093128085136414,
-0.559343695640564,
0.26461416482925415,
0.39216259121894836,
0.5749368667602539,
0.07933098077774048,
-0.2913977801799774,
-0.47840631008148193,
-0.21108406782150269,
-0.050508588552474976,
-0.2073116898536682,
0.11934810876846313,
-0.07068415731191635,
-0.33259162306785583,
0.5694934725761414,
-0.10643309354782104,
0.1642175167798996,
-0.17850326001644135,
-0.6141985654830933,
0.17253048717975616,
0.28346920013427734,
1.1162742376327515,
0.9618697762489319,
-0.13846752047538757,
0.24891194701194763,
-0.27044954895973206,
-0.6519579291343689,
-0.053402721881866455,
0.08920839428901672,
-0.3801109492778778,
0.3349415957927704,
0.49696359038352966,
1.2075724601745605,
0.008755700662732124,
-0.3889443278312683,
0.08582974225282669,
0.032837189733982086,
0.23440425097942352,
-0.5909814238548279,
-0.21181662380695343,
0.011202570982277393,
0.09204971790313721,
0.7908101081848145,
-0.04242396727204323,
0.14028458297252655,
-1.0598857402801514,
0.3363523781299591,
-0.10480441153049469,
-0.23721586167812347,
-0.6294313073158264,
0.3125445544719696,
-0.24067680537700653,
-0.5307636857032776,
0.4675615429878235,
0.030190275982022285,
-0.3182087242603302,
0.37037360668182373,
0.5305720567703247,
0.3964821696281433,
-0.38469934463500977,
0.33948707580566406,
0.5568491816520691,
0.1051364615559578,
0.1363922506570816,
0.25823545455932617,
-0.3014470338821411,
-0.5117096304893494,
-0.07731586694717407,
-0.5905270576477051,
-0.5575386881828308,
0.1785789430141449,
-0.6695826053619385,
0.2127348631620407,
-0.5366234183311462,
-0.41926178336143494,
0.39994949102401733,
-0.3501431345939636,
-0.4709077775478363,
-0.12204248458147049,
0.3228236436843872,
0.6728307604789734,
-0.9930235743522644,
0.8391204476356506,
0.5931413173675537,
-0.439100444316864,
-0.17586742341518402,
-0.17776960134506226,
0.36811935901641846,
-0.6863945722579956,
1.3538033962249756,
-0.5313186645507812,
-0.2115229368209839,
-0.16421744227409363,
-0.003616270376369357,
-0.7587725520133972,
0.6123374700546265,
0.8507470488548279,
-0.9096410274505615,
0.18918128311634064,
0.4506852328777313,
0.6792804002761841,
-0.3403918445110321,
0.3518061637878418,
0.9248713254928589,
0.6013955473899841,
0.18329216539859772,
-1.3142459392547607,
-0.5058637857437134,
-0.6060793399810791,
-0.15184776484966278,
0.19814343750476837,
-0.34656184911727905,
1.1511836051940918,
-0.05567024648189545,
-0.5755720734596252,
0.06514772772789001,
0.8071482181549072,
0.24848373234272003,
0.18981178104877472,
0.1466788798570633,
0.19260136783123016,
1.1550018787384033,
-0.43559929728507996,
0.7365301251411438,
-0.41603708267211914,
0.173663929104805,
1.2698304653167725,
-0.46223190426826477,
0.8325040936470032,
0.3667837679386139,
-0.2709561586380005,
0.2563457787036896,
0.8772507309913635,
0.14590920507907867,
0.13259020447731018,
0.26702946424484253,
-0.6274536848068237,
0.11748120188713074,
-0.18034540116786957,
-0.7093223333358765,
0.6554973721504211,
0.6358689665794373,
-0.31010597944259644,
-0.30980032682418823,
0.1603744477033615,
0.3570672273635864,
0.07280677556991577,
-0.3374394178390503,
0.5817931890487671,
-0.3066536486148834,
-0.4419029951095581,
0.645380973815918,
-0.5038707256317139,
0.4207986891269684,
-0.5388385057449341,
-0.07539325952529907,
-0.6004687547683716,
0.004839302506297827,
-0.19464831054210663,
-0.9560925960540771,
0.5066394209861755,
0.09445182234048843,
-0.3939131796360016,
0.0019418433075770736,
0.28327998518943787,
-0.3829951584339142,
-0.5959089398384094,
0.15578044950962067,
0.29228150844573975,
0.4714377820491791,
0.023310428485274315,
-0.21876056492328644,
0.7541177272796631,
-0.19806745648384094,
0.40383777022361755,
0.03337477147579193,
-0.10294509679079056,
-0.5081348419189453,
0.3208145499229431,
0.4746079444885254,
0.749366819858551,
0.38706791400909424,
0.15811121463775635,
0.5410701632499695,
-0.6825428605079651,
-0.43939313292503357,
-0.7861799597740173,
0.1423763483762741,
0.15129511058330536,
-0.4894106984138489,
0.2705443501472473,
0.806958019733429,
0.7488534450531006,
0.023116515949368477,
0.7379177212715149,
-0.15025439858436584,
0.2965114414691925,
-0.4535837769508362,
0.6853242516517639,
-0.21118003129959106,
0.11548992246389389,
-0.2516559362411499,
-0.9058372378349304,
-0.49491724371910095,
0.5658657550811768,
-0.010975119657814503,
-0.3892373740673065,
0.6339386701583862,
0.6890684366226196,
0.10912007838487625,
0.27464956045150757,
0.2267128974199295,
0.08614616096019745,
0.08442215621471405,
0.20780213177204132,
0.6406222581863403,
-0.3595869839191437,
0.28837695717811584,
-0.2834776043891907,
-0.3515166938304901,
-0.1626766175031662,
-0.7237829566001892,
-0.3165673017501831,
-1.2913007736206055,
-0.3118264675140381,
-0.2419883906841278,
0.6147589087486267,
0.7800895571708679,
0.5000886917114258,
-1.1997498273849487,
-0.7702860832214355,
0.24893788993358612,
-0.278701514005661,
-0.28359004855155945,
-0.14508958160877228,
0.5240437984466553,
-0.09521371871232986,
-0.959622323513031,
1.0243793725967407,
0.4495730698108673,
0.04315616562962532,
-0.06785976886749268,
-0.04295732453465462,
-0.13835641741752625,
-0.4335930347442627,
0.36743152141571045,
1.3092999458312988,
-0.5971047878265381,
0.10359885543584824,
-0.021559452638030052,
0.11147468537092209,
0.4497087597846985,
1.400019645690918,
-0.7275311946868896,
0.6073469519615173,
0.7120490074157715,
0.5221988558769226,
0.9355430006980896,
-0.3414075970649719,
1.008336067199707,
-0.6456813216209412,
0.4486936926841736,
0.2162557989358902,
0.6762592196464539,
0.40883228182792664,
-0.1269259750843048,
0.721275269985199,
0.38324660062789917,
0.06667595356702805,
-0.664857029914856,
0.08397531509399414,
-1.1069930791854858,
-0.18623866140842438,
0.9119970798492432,
-0.10629786550998688,
-0.11945033818483353,
-0.3600408434867859,
-0.3363950848579407,
0.25500553846359253,
-0.5017307996749878,
0.6178202033042908,
0.49987056851387024,
-0.14234092831611633,
-0.3300241529941559,
-0.09949137270450592,
0.45421674847602844,
0.006046284455806017,
-0.6082896590232849,
-0.1236613467335701,
0.5079051852226257,
-0.015764925628900528,
0.6483408808708191,
0.6837466359138489,
-0.2494550347328186,
0.5462309718132019,
-0.023248523473739624,
0.03521497920155525,
0.018507933244109154,
-0.9233502149581909,
-0.3516405522823334,
0.4275472164154053,
0.05888768658041954,
0.05279933661222458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02329v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02329v1
|
Digital ASIC Design with Ongoing LLMs: Strategies and Prospects
| 2024-04-25T05:16:57 | 2024-04-25T05:16:57 |
Maoyang Xiang, Emil Goh, T. Hui Teo
|
cs.AR
|
cs.AR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The escalating complexity of modern digital systems has imposed significant
challenges on integrated circuit (IC) design, necessitating tools that can
simplify the IC design flow. The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has
been seen as a promising development, with the potential to automate the
generation of Hardware Description Language (HDL) code, thereby streamlining
digital IC design. However, the practical application of LLMs in this area
faces substantial hurdles. Notably, current LLMs often generate HDL code with
small but critical syntax errors and struggle to accurately convey the
high-level semantics of circuit designs. These issues significantly undermine
the utility of LLMs for IC design, leading to misinterpretations and
inefficiencies.
In response to these challenges, this paper presents targeted strategies to
harness the capabilities of LLMs for digital ASIC design. We outline approaches
that improve the reliability and accuracy of HDL code generation by LLMs. As a
practical demonstration of these strategies, we detail the development of a
simple three-phase Pulse Width Modulation (PWM) generator. This project, part
of the "Efabless AI-Generated Open-Source Chip Design Challenge," successfully
passed the Design Rule Check (DRC) and was fabricated, showcasing the potential
of LLMs to enhance digital ASIC design. This work underscores the feasibility
and benefits of integrating LLMs into the IC design process, offering a novel
approach to overcoming the complexities of modern digital systems.
|
[
-0.6293062567710876,
-0.6597123742103577,
0.9245098829269409,
0.40792766213417053,
-0.620150089263916,
0.3879812955856323,
-0.05374505743384361,
-0.4566025137901306,
-0.04671834036707878,
0.5228267908096313,
-0.5282123684883118,
-0.38291236758232117,
-0.41105934977531433,
0.23833699524402618,
-0.29919561743736267,
0.3564491271972656,
-0.8623325228691101,
-0.08019838482141495,
-0.26643508672714233,
0.4109291136264801,
-0.37722131609916687,
-0.4661825895309448,
-0.5071537494659424,
-0.5093963146209717,
0.018594052642583847,
0.49124887585639954,
0.34583261609077454,
0.44489917159080505,
0.6752773523330688,
0.21099920570850372,
-0.28963592648506165,
0.388459175825119,
0.138996422290802,
0.2846410274505615,
0.516858696937561,
-0.30510857701301575,
-0.7624500393867493,
0.0685277134180069,
0.623035728931427,
0.675377607345581,
-0.13565510511398315,
0.24091120064258575,
0.05836066976189613,
0.7284610271453857,
-0.37753766775131226,
0.24730044603347778,
-0.4831397533416748,
0.11530067771673203,
-0.4569907784461975,
-0.611626386642456,
-0.4509606659412384,
-0.3031778037548065,
-0.36615487933158875,
-0.263187050819397,
-0.3137737512588501,
0.0715896412730217,
0.665218710899353,
0.2187868058681488,
-0.31304219365119934,
-0.5542412996292114,
-1.090376615524292,
0.646273136138916,
-0.9448235630989075,
0.5909850597381592,
0.1528390496969223,
0.12161871045827866,
-0.2878119647502899,
-0.7848725318908691,
-0.4768608510494232,
-0.45623624324798584,
0.1446288824081421,
0.20261789858341217,
0.1791406124830246,
0.27554047107696533,
0.21272504329681396,
0.5479363203048706,
-0.09260173887014389,
0.22165702283382416,
-0.33479464054107666,
-0.008345256559550762,
0.6571034789085388,
0.41135087609291077,
0.11354182660579681,
0.12136915326118469,
-0.5466272234916687,
0.4642011821269989,
-1.3708884716033936,
-0.19230963289737701,
0.7964429259300232,
0.1679285615682602,
-0.15819427371025085,
0.6025646924972534,
0.10794313997030258,
0.6505546569824219,
0.19515497982501984,
-0.19074471294879913,
-0.07101232558488846,
-0.4786817729473114,
-0.06619587540626526,
-0.023886103183031082,
0.4577880799770355,
0.03469367325305939,
-0.07362489402294159,
0.17954596877098083,
-0.7351461052894592,
-0.06008647754788399,
0.48336729407310486,
-0.7615771293640137,
-0.16641263663768768,
0.6206054091453552,
-0.5065192580223083,
-0.2590067684650421,
0.1570660024881363,
-0.5638634562492371,
-0.15164662897586823,
-0.4869679808616638,
0.3313513696193695,
0.03217713162302971,
-0.03583799675107002,
0.2313561886548996,
-0.1186593696475029,
0.1696583330631256,
0.3301782011985779,
-0.7428701519966125,
0.40869736671447754,
0.6568239331245422,
0.6938168406486511,
-0.1957516223192215,
0.14485199749469757,
-0.21889448165893555,
0.502561628818512,
-0.6725347638130188,
0.5245860815048218,
-0.1665050983428955,
-0.5797700881958008,
0.04810316860675812,
-0.44973835349082947,
0.5106953978538513,
-0.8370019793510437,
0.4686959385871887,
-0.8452283143997192,
-0.3010360896587372,
-0.14741770923137665,
-0.2307244837284088,
0.42517873644828796,
0.11209366470575333,
-0.5379893183708191,
0.7323446869850159,
-0.33930227160453796,
-0.59762042760849,
-0.06898728013038635,
-0.759394645690918,
-0.9756228923797607,
0.07020978629589081,
-0.48254191875457764,
-0.5403833985328674,
0.4167378544807434,
-0.19370274245738983,
0.21336032450199127,
-0.4985167682170868,
0.07404866814613342,
-0.2358693927526474,
-0.6539044976234436,
0.3465668559074402,
-0.5068355798721313,
0.6844707727432251,
0.38810276985168457,
-0.5519841313362122,
0.026265105232596397,
-0.673742949962616,
-0.055952172726392746,
0.2139330804347992,
-0.7573636770248413,
0.21324282884597778,
0.4444958567619324,
-0.16495925188064575,
0.2194744497537613,
0.36081963777542114,
-0.7071054577827454,
-0.11558082699775696,
-0.3693269193172455,
0.6417720317840576,
0.9212425947189331,
0.09026335179805756,
0.2253222018480301,
-0.45997557044029236,
0.4645063281059265,
-0.1355123221874237,
0.458282470703125,
-0.06308797746896744,
-0.5692117214202881,
-0.9179531335830688,
-0.11265448480844498,
0.1049363911151886,
0.3433118164539337,
-0.8518702983856201,
0.5106757879257202,
0.08064140379428864,
-0.052555132657289505,
-0.22298799455165863,
0.34530702233314514,
0.027534587308764458,
0.1431652009487152,
0.2262383997440338,
-0.30617576837539673,
-0.5055237412452698,
-0.7338650822639465,
0.21550853550434113,
-0.3516687750816345,
-0.3350023329257965,
0.12223520874977112,
0.2904732823371887,
-0.2307901233434677,
0.5243893265724182,
-0.45404982566833496,
-0.06669081002473831,
-0.2703753709793091,
0.07120591402053833,
0.11742184311151505,
0.27891314029693604,
-0.016751252114772797,
-0.6872814893722534,
-0.386841356754303,
0.07724341750144958,
-0.5445958971977234,
-0.2971746027469635,
-0.030287595465779305,
0.23755915462970734,
0.4135790467262268,
0.6069586277008057,
-0.7253222465515137,
0.34104496240615845,
0.2080957293510437,
-0.08966460078954697,
0.6452827453613281,
-0.23380722105503082,
0.14565002918243408,
-0.5647802948951721,
-0.11315049231052399,
-0.037419747561216354,
0.09635643661022186,
-0.5342374444007874,
0.25835636258125305,
0.018782595172524452,
-0.11586350202560425,
-0.6284434795379639,
0.46726521849632263,
-0.6359454393386841,
-0.10794413089752197,
-0.4233355224132538,
0.0820077657699585,
-0.15217743813991547,
0.160267174243927,
-0.12506885826587677,
0.8015230298042297,
0.26420673727989197,
-0.6970288753509521,
0.4326207637786865,
-0.1452626734972,
-0.12700721621513367,
0.554131805896759,
-0.7539803981781006,
0.2646092176437378,
-0.2797975242137909,
0.09885341674089432,
-0.7406100630760193,
0.044617559760808945,
0.3089931905269623,
-0.17197759449481964,
0.5786609649658203,
0.23464207351207733,
-0.9528220295906067,
-0.6929985880851746,
-0.4008427858352661,
0.431630939245224,
0.5053489208221436,
-0.6929399967193604,
0.8431094884872437,
0.426830917596817,
-0.16609320044517517,
0.030176270753145218,
-0.6570290923118591,
0.13385391235351562,
-0.13078996539115906,
-0.7314350605010986,
0.6469770669937134,
-0.5900236368179321,
-0.7643664479255676,
-0.31254443526268005,
-0.26491525769233704,
0.08749505877494812,
0.3280268609523773,
0.3306666910648346,
0.4703599214553833,
-0.30693989992141724,
0.012730564922094345,
0.007471643388271332,
-0.258449524641037,
0.2338518649339676,
-0.46676895022392273,
0.6835601329803467,
-0.08088163286447525,
-0.6340954899787903,
-0.8204425573348999,
0.5185854434967041,
0.6831897497177124,
-0.13687364757061005,
0.12373141199350357,
0.017465395852923393,
-0.409650981426239,
-0.5132119059562683,
-0.45051106810569763,
-0.008935153484344482,
-0.5879876613616943,
0.13876761496067047,
-0.7094692587852478,
-0.674640953540802,
0.3211666941642761,
-0.23735864460468292,
0.34795621037483215,
0.3096623122692108,
0.6323457956314087,
-0.6027377247810364,
1.0207757949829102,
0.6212524771690369,
0.1344926953315735,
0.2998889684677124,
-0.009966420009732246,
0.41143712401390076,
-0.7587845325469971,
-0.13433250784873962,
-0.25367388129234314,
-0.3117302358150482,
-0.43554580211639404,
-0.4494640529155731,
0.36209896206855774,
-0.04019201919436455,
-0.5974520444869995,
-0.18961256742477417,
-0.2969268560409546,
0.175511434674263,
0.24755623936653137,
0.043135322630405426,
0.5137385129928589,
0.13748040795326233,
-0.02724318951368332,
0.09378906339406967,
-0.47165942192077637,
-0.614702045917511,
0.8261197805404663,
0.7089579701423645,
1.1623218059539795,
0.12876653671264648,
0.6354404091835022,
0.19058412313461304,
0.24393095076084137,
-0.55524742603302,
0.46450361609458923,
-0.17665289342403412,
-0.42921605706214905,
0.10074407607316971,
-0.3143625855445862,
-0.3368481993675232,
-0.4537241756916046,
0.25247880816459656,
-0.414703369140625,
0.01978873275220394,
0.18667952716350555,
-0.41207143664360046,
0.390423059463501,
-0.3100772202014923,
0.14258648455142975,
-0.6750691533088684,
-0.22070620954036713,
-0.2690064311027527,
-0.28245508670806885,
0.28214383125305176,
-0.12920957803726196,
0.14767314493656158,
0.0709087997674942,
-0.361600399017334,
0.37618663907051086,
-0.4916418492794037,
0.8004748225212097,
0.2212466150522232,
-0.46465858817100525,
0.6527611017227173,
-0.037820182740688324,
0.6098979115486145,
0.11903942376375198,
0.028466131538152695,
0.0012808876344934106,
-0.2833425998687744,
-0.3156888782978058,
-0.08382313698530197,
0.9365910887718201,
-0.6501383781433105,
-0.6083230972290039,
-0.07718335837125778,
-0.3181432783603668,
-0.33001163601875305,
0.052718840539455414,
0.14560216665267944,
0.6922965049743652,
0.15754097700119019,
-0.012555068358778954,
0.8056163787841797,
-0.11221247166395187,
0.5076065063476562,
0.2818431556224823,
-0.14826041460037231,
-0.5278444290161133,
1.004697322845459,
-0.02788136899471283,
0.5617355704307556,
0.19162392616271973,
-0.11121978610754013,
-0.06336425989866257,
-0.9784661531448364,
-0.4833744168281555,
0.10510150343179703,
-0.8002912998199463,
-0.2499816119670868,
-0.22820709645748138,
-0.5946768522262573,
-0.1486886739730835,
-0.4851067066192627,
-0.5552051067352295,
-0.11386501789093018,
-0.37857651710510254,
0.14956359565258026,
0.23892372846603394,
1.1633954048156738,
0.18097275495529175,
0.2847476899623871,
-0.5175570845603943,
0.6640747785568237,
0.3303503096103668,
0.8614278435707092,
0.1052781492471695,
-0.422071248292923,
0.023979324847459793,
-0.08436670899391174,
-0.627384603023529,
-0.7297036647796631,
0.0750536322593689,
-0.22477678954601288,
0.819037675857544,
0.11162174493074417,
-0.05919143185019493,
0.5175565481185913,
-0.34604737162590027,
0.5590145587921143,
0.07534664869308472,
-0.7762874960899353,
0.5351614356040955,
-0.2954534590244293,
0.3921447992324829,
0.3112873435020447,
0.22504961490631104,
-0.3328544497489929,
-0.40365538001060486,
-0.47574329376220703,
-0.8932283520698547,
0.3489188849925995,
0.1475878804922104,
0.05610056221485138,
0.0642847940325737,
0.5562897324562073,
-0.06293570250272751,
0.324380099773407,
-0.46775972843170166,
-0.5407789945602417,
0.16141057014465332,
-0.5979996919631958,
0.3872426748275757,
-0.38043516874313354,
-0.20734815299510956,
-0.03378196805715561,
0.8289691209793091,
-0.2418982982635498,
0.4157041013240814,
-0.005500059574842453,
0.08684250712394714,
-0.3056463897228241,
0.10261918604373932,
0.5058130025863647,
0.7234495878219604,
-0.06775276362895966,
0.24971044063568115,
0.09565754979848862,
-0.36130139231681824,
0.223816379904747,
-0.02208111062645912,
-0.4776967465877533,
-0.1581142395734787,
-0.1545872986316681,
0.44452962279319763,
0.0740797221660614,
-0.6611046195030212,
0.2955039143562317,
-0.23183530569076538,
-0.21550767123699188,
-0.667919933795929,
-0.30337098240852356,
0.35582253336906433,
0.28729647397994995,
0.4690256118774414,
-0.1978173404932022,
-0.21957318484783173,
-0.6904541254043579,
0.28548288345336914,
0.7101817727088928,
-0.20173680782318115,
-0.2447638064622879,
0.6846517324447632,
0.4908824563026428,
-0.5145432949066162,
0.566895604133606,
-0.24020232260227203,
-0.37528252601623535,
0.6889750957489014,
0.7074427008628845,
0.7764747142791748,
0.2572115361690521,
-0.15977254509925842,
0.04318534955382347,
0.5322555303573608,
0.03113541193306446,
0.5421901941299438,
-0.10773979127407074,
-0.36878445744514465,
-0.42073380947113037,
-0.8359176516532898,
-0.4926154613494873,
0.03939473628997803,
-0.14342230558395386,
0.776642918586731,
-1.0422664880752563,
-0.031929973512887955,
-0.25901949405670166,
0.18503578007221222,
-0.39133980870246887,
0.08388495445251465,
0.6791069507598877,
0.9668442606925964,
-0.43480420112609863,
0.6444953680038452,
0.6222842335700989,
-0.08169622719287872,
-0.4723204970359802,
0.14062075316905975,
0.2197231948375702,
-0.6169947385787964,
0.6223893761634827,
-0.18253131210803986,
-0.19156590104103088,
0.10078779608011246,
-0.3355002701282501,
-0.758047878742218,
1.1223094463348389,
0.04920053854584694,
-0.3884056508541107,
0.2226223200559616,
0.18529199063777924,
0.3158945143222809,
-0.4760904908180237,
-0.0027673582080751657,
0.7248904705047607,
0.577282190322876,
0.4210719168186188,
-0.7812409400939941,
0.0931413546204567,
-0.2095264047384262,
-0.05357597395777702,
0.4153466820716858,
-0.6918081641197205,
0.7769249081611633,
-0.2944415807723999,
-0.4846704602241516,
0.3093757927417755,
0.6499879956245422,
0.5173521637916565,
0.03327304869890213,
0.22189415991306305,
0.11584892868995667,
0.438773512840271,
-0.07904982566833496,
0.8293835520744324,
-0.48961982131004333,
-0.018455971032381058,
0.776579737663269,
-0.32095229625701904,
0.8348545432090759,
0.672415554523468,
-0.24210971593856812,
0.22371289134025574,
0.5510104894638062,
0.013733956962823868,
0.20757493376731873,
0.362601637840271,
-0.5724665522575378,
-0.22476528584957123,
0.03210515156388283,
-0.1471833884716034,
0.12062172591686249,
0.5256229639053345,
-0.2602180242538452,
0.006704648025333881,
-0.22205528616905212,
-0.1154492124915123,
-0.014030531980097294,
-0.5447980761528015,
0.5153273940086365,
0.38246652483940125,
-0.2817402482032776,
0.383766770362854,
0.1258268654346466,
0.8279334902763367,
-0.2898261249065399,
-0.12744566798210144,
-0.11905357241630554,
0.2446664273738861,
-0.15395088493824005,
-0.8771550059318542,
0.4251232445240021,
-0.23397067189216614,
-0.15074971318244934,
-0.42666491866111755,
0.8391134738922119,
-0.08318512886762619,
-0.7274566888809204,
0.14150340855121613,
0.41287919878959656,
-0.1558796912431717,
0.21066950261592865,
-0.24194695055484772,
0.6764247417449951,
-0.11206959933042526,
0.16545772552490234,
0.3200337290763855,
0.016449660062789917,
0.07516146451234818,
0.811850368976593,
0.4127817749977112,
0.5288485884666443,
0.061483342200517654,
-0.09228071570396423,
0.8146371841430664,
-0.7611352801322937,
-0.23662668466567993,
-0.6981279253959656,
0.4289301931858063,
0.13402590155601501,
-0.031626973301172256,
0.5912244915962219,
0.3675074577331543,
0.7533848285675049,
0.13876153528690338,
0.9392637610435486,
0.11003603786230087,
0.019325152039527893,
-0.6319486498832703,
0.4987306296825409,
-0.452235609292984,
0.6925334930419922,
0.14350977540016174,
-0.6967939138412476,
-0.33648937940597534,
0.25607869029045105,
-0.05605095997452736,
-0.1124434843659401,
0.6663088202476501,
0.502349853515625,
0.14345912635326385,
0.13667765259742737,
0.085729219019413,
0.2439170926809311,
0.5946614742279053,
0.5582119226455688,
1.0823616981506348,
-0.3650314211845398,
0.5388830304145813,
-0.4249107837677002,
-0.24650220572948456,
-0.09512966871261597,
-0.7204589247703552,
-0.6459155678749084,
-0.2709539830684662,
-0.3713352084159851,
0.026325108483433723,
-0.028675265610218048,
0.8210914134979248,
0.39795345067977905,
-0.6077256202697754,
-0.5230817794799805,
-0.20268608629703522,
0.22125768661499023,
0.05588005483150482,
-0.09500345587730408,
-0.14585188031196594,
-0.33412960171699524,
-0.5391691327095032,
0.37171265482902527,
0.6995971202850342,
0.30497288703918457,
-0.5424015522003174,
-0.2986675500869751,
0.1592613309621811,
0.29642969369888306,
0.8244890570640564,
0.14752289652824402,
-0.859967052936554,
-0.25289449095726013,
0.08935561776161194,
-0.2572207748889923,
0.28676486015319824,
0.9438973069190979,
-0.49323371052742004,
0.30276843905448914,
0.4390852749347687,
0.4649331867694855,
0.3768473267555237,
-0.05410967022180557,
0.768451988697052,
-0.3509318232536316,
-0.38451138138771057,
0.25146958231925964,
0.32554176449775696,
0.2790566682815552,
-0.2365674525499344,
-0.036061812192201614,
0.1399059146642685,
-0.49775099754333496,
-0.754115641117096,
0.42930757999420166,
-0.6439844369888306,
-0.34529271721839905,
1.3541350364685059,
0.26244276762008667,
-0.198687344789505,
-0.3435989022254944,
-0.11372670531272888,
-0.020507225766777992,
0.10744574666023254,
0.823387861251831,
0.41605567932128906,
-0.4359058141708374,
0.14615587890148163,
-0.8831354975700378,
0.31995871663093567,
-0.013704794459044933,
-0.8107879161834717,
0.2934718430042267,
0.3336263597011566,
0.10914275795221329,
0.22622190415859222,
0.7447583079338074,
-0.39507609605789185,
0.341604083776474,
0.012716270983219147,
0.08021844178438187,
-0.1652291864156723,
-0.6253083348274231,
-0.40288877487182617,
0.3862113952636719,
0.6638246178627014,
-0.010406476445496082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00711v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00711v2
|
Fake Artificial Intelligence Generated Contents (FAIGC): A Survey of Theories, Detection Methods, and Opportunities
| 2024-04-25T04:44:09 | 2024-05-03T04:47:01 |
Xiaomin Yu, Yezhaohui Wang, Yanfang Chen, Zhen Tao, Dinghao Xi, Shichao Song, Simin Niu, Zhiyu Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
In recent years, generative artificial intelligence models, represented by
Large Language Models (LLMs) and Diffusion Models (DMs), have revolutionized
content production methods. These artificial intelligence-generated content
(AIGC) have become deeply embedded in various aspects of daily life and work.
However, these technologies have also led to the emergence of Fake Artificial
Intelligence Generated Content (FAIGC), posing new challenges in distinguishing
genuine information. It is crucial to recognize that AIGC technology is akin to
a double-edged sword; its potent generative capabilities, while beneficial,
also pose risks for the creation and dissemination of FAIGC. In this survey, We
propose a new taxonomy that provides a more comprehensive breakdown of the
space of FAIGC methods today. Next, we explore the modalities and generative
technologies of FAIGC. We introduce FAIGC detection methods and summarize the
related benchmark from various perspectives. Finally, we discuss outstanding
challenges and promising areas for future research.
|
[
-0.49840250611305237,
-1.2261425256729126,
0.31340330839157104,
-0.03573950380086899,
0.2487340122461319,
0.46730539202690125,
0.15672758221626282,
-0.5242264866828918,
0.15358707308769226,
0.25550293922424316,
-0.8297260403633118,
-0.26101604104042053,
-0.6677056550979614,
0.26275408267974854,
-1.0012890100479126,
0.6551272869110107,
0.014828245155513287,
-0.17397592961788177,
-0.5673251152038574,
0.15912675857543945,
-0.14271800220012665,
-0.4049336910247803,
-0.5705721974372864,
-0.0036184689961373806,
0.07127714157104492,
0.12378998100757599,
0.6231896877288818,
0.6655216217041016,
0.25855404138565063,
0.3727237284183502,
0.2625626027584076,
0.5621159672737122,
-0.2939048707485199,
-0.18431901931762695,
0.23042485117912292,
-0.2485990673303604,
-0.20410248637199402,
0.3961600363254547,
0.5566962957382202,
0.26140859723091125,
-0.1382911205291748,
0.10125020146369934,
-0.28502893447875977,
0.5399395227432251,
-0.704012393951416,
-0.013442907482385635,
-0.47024887800216675,
0.21073834598064423,
-0.5662826299667358,
-0.23345988988876343,
-0.46588191390037537,
-0.1908571422100067,
-0.2100568562746048,
-0.6976950764656067,
0.27082955837249756,
0.0035900671500712633,
0.5945829749107361,
0.27156975865364075,
-0.5787015557289124,
-0.7131364941596985,
-1.0560145378112793,
0.7111597061157227,
-0.5640596151351929,
0.34508299827575684,
0.4527575969696045,
0.3987977206707001,
-0.2701592743396759,
-0.9489945769309998,
-1.1752701997756958,
-0.37107494473457336,
0.03361821547150612,
0.12674549221992493,
-0.3664160668849945,
-0.16875110566616058,
0.030792871490120888,
0.604209840297699,
-0.5304184556007385,
-0.03958788886666298,
-0.22631581127643585,
-0.5492661595344543,
1.0160768032073975,
0.08910693973302841,
0.7518963813781738,
-0.004002394620329142,
-0.39260947704315186,
0.10342053323984146,
-0.7433462142944336,
-0.21959875524044037,
0.9456223845481873,
-0.4506101906299591,
0.026657436043024063,
0.39020851254463196,
-0.31147822737693787,
0.5153768658638,
0.16735132038593292,
-0.2088817059993744,
0.08817733824253082,
-0.547264575958252,
-0.08006816357374191,
-0.13178607821464539,
0.9644827842712402,
-0.3615751564502716,
0.32271459698677063,
0.05338551104068756,
-0.20218102633953094,
0.03364158794283867,
0.5067232251167297,
-0.1979077309370041,
-0.35299819707870483,
0.09763132035732269,
-0.61009281873703,
-0.6119215488433838,
0.42086172103881836,
-0.2737506926059723,
-0.4336254298686981,
-0.034995947033166885,
0.3415525257587433,
-0.5219436883926392,
-0.6205680966377258,
-0.2666628658771515,
-0.10959456115961075,
0.3565102219581604,
0.36972543597221375,
-0.6052799820899963,
0.07710909098386765,
0.8387781381607056,
0.7663926482200623,
-0.26071152091026306,
-0.03255671635270119,
-0.2812195420265198,
0.03984487056732178,
-0.4241243898868561,
1.0614118576049805,
-0.3371083438396454,
-0.5013481974601746,
0.22734862565994263,
-0.24132397770881653,
0.13687895238399506,
-0.5271840691566467,
0.32784247398376465,
-0.697216808795929,
0.25621333718299866,
-0.18995505571365356,
-0.6481137275695801,
-0.22720405459403992,
0.4671823978424072,
-0.8922296166419983,
0.9600481986999512,
0.2277415692806244,
-0.6860553026199341,
0.4149422347545624,
-0.684201717376709,
-0.7814939022064209,
0.45620399713516235,
-0.2696123421192169,
-0.27778154611587524,
-0.18241718411445618,
-0.0946093201637268,
0.2705794870853424,
0.07587707042694092,
0.2645660936832428,
-0.03245100751519203,
-0.4383707344532013,
0.5112307071685791,
-0.9061906933784485,
0.8674612641334534,
0.4942297637462616,
-0.4777817726135254,
0.05362612009048462,
-0.45494896173477173,
-0.2671758830547333,
0.01852422207593918,
-0.06347157806158066,
0.01551042776554823,
0.31847885251045227,
-0.05999527499079704,
0.1791084110736847,
0.15415610373020172,
-0.32027092576026917,
0.17922307550907135,
-0.1513085514307022,
0.4154246151447296,
0.8367541432380676,
0.07087399810552597,
0.14064548909664154,
-0.49613484740257263,
0.6275625228881836,
0.25595128536224365,
0.39547988772392273,
-0.03542132303118706,
-0.6822257041931152,
-0.6119669079780579,
-0.3694523870944977,
0.1946202963590622,
0.5499120354652405,
-1.149687647819519,
0.5495586395263672,
0.017275819554924965,
-0.64813232421875,
-0.5672009587287903,
0.08335022628307343,
0.04189923405647278,
0.3564532995223999,
0.24988225102424622,
0.08913299441337585,
-0.10231827944517136,
-0.8522889018058777,
-0.30275586247444153,
-0.5137523412704468,
0.04356769844889641,
0.3435019254684448,
0.570821225643158,
-0.31806230545043945,
0.793999433517456,
-0.2974972724914551,
-0.34770822525024414,
-0.05073555186390877,
0.5216487050056458,
-0.3418348729610443,
0.3106408417224884,
0.7066803574562073,
-1.2628132104873657,
-0.5238834023475647,
-0.20207563042640686,
-0.9116519093513489,
-0.05189282074570656,
-0.4551267921924591,
0.02478426694869995,
0.34522756934165955,
0.5626959204673767,
-0.4909779131412506,
0.7122130990028381,
0.31386563181877136,
-0.13759270310401917,
0.8311644196510315,
0.24842454493045807,
0.6771085262298584,
-0.7712529301643372,
-0.045432452112436295,
-0.018933190032839775,
-0.16954506933689117,
-0.6914111971855164,
0.19987870752811432,
-0.2238495647907257,
0.2775181233882904,
-0.6681824922561646,
0.7076703310012817,
-0.2712589502334595,
0.20159900188446045,
-0.41543111205101013,
-0.10364317893981934,
-0.19507484138011932,
-0.026117486879229546,
-0.12781211733818054,
0.987282395362854,
0.3483140766620636,
-0.5725906491279602,
0.8399625420570374,
0.1930723637342453,
-0.413239061832428,
0.45018869638442993,
-0.48792481422424316,
0.005972955375909805,
-0.09575391560792923,
0.4536270499229431,
-0.9802793264389038,
-0.5393059253692627,
0.6775476336479187,
-0.66780024766922,
0.0785832330584526,
0.2300262749195099,
-0.9619972109794617,
-0.5073565244674683,
-0.39803454279899597,
0.663958728313446,
0.5976463556289673,
-0.6103957295417786,
0.6545355319976807,
0.3683708608150482,
0.10628224909305573,
-0.5608111619949341,
-0.7918104529380798,
0.10888583213090897,
-0.17211410403251648,
-0.8597021698951721,
0.6177933812141418,
-0.2748678922653198,
-0.5306380391120911,
-0.018393289297819138,
0.06041501462459564,
-0.056797731667757034,
0.30832892656326294,
0.19412031769752502,
-0.12435950338840485,
-0.16366779804229736,
-0.1026393249630928,
0.14707021415233612,
0.24679233133792877,
0.19932998716831207,
-0.21617551147937775,
0.31851863861083984,
0.14704540371894836,
-0.661651074886322,
-0.7471326589584351,
0.4514891803264618,
0.35336217284202576,
-0.013380720280110836,
0.8547111749649048,
1.1624268293380737,
-0.5573122501373291,
-0.43522295355796814,
-0.5885540843009949,
-0.03398975357413292,
-0.5703367590904236,
-0.056190114468336105,
0.11185681074857712,
-0.6451959609985352,
0.5277758836746216,
-0.0841045007109642,
-0.030443526804447174,
0.6214928030967712,
0.7343232035636902,
0.00752136530354619,
1.0228151082992554,
0.6489195227622986,
-0.021717878058552742,
0.5040193796157837,
-0.3609149754047394,
0.4557446241378784,
-0.2392389178276062,
-0.5404317378997803,
-0.1752009093761444,
-0.21242742240428925,
-0.5166524052619934,
-0.2570398449897766,
0.5010026693344116,
-0.061162758618593216,
-0.05185268819332123,
-0.10564012080430984,
-0.4454660713672638,
0.2021380513906479,
0.780570387840271,
-0.07802462577819824,
0.5328288078308105,
-0.07786968350410461,
0.29672062397003174,
0.37066566944122314,
-0.513099193572998,
-0.4527323544025421,
0.8880664110183716,
0.22734954953193665,
0.5162047743797302,
0.18636800348758698,
0.35525137186050415,
1.3095943927764893,
0.6179020404815674,
-0.7401010394096375,
0.43062013387680054,
-0.13765652477741241,
-0.6346884369850159,
0.05385398119688034,
-0.3143119513988495,
-0.4170992374420166,
-0.481458455324173,
-0.2107674777507782,
-0.3595955967903137,
0.000053240284614730626,
0.22015781700611115,
-0.21900565922260284,
0.5092599987983704,
-0.5014047622680664,
0.4809541702270508,
-0.22741450369358063,
-0.27076858282089233,
-0.20292119681835175,
-0.1917862594127655,
0.7062748670578003,
-0.059536006301641464,
0.28066855669021606,
0.11558295041322708,
0.1037643700838089,
0.5834798216819763,
-0.39663219451904297,
0.5831207633018494,
0.02612287551164627,
-0.29824650287628174,
1.0066927671432495,
0.23005002737045288,
0.31021320819854736,
0.22646556794643402,
-0.04960530996322632,
0.39507558941841125,
-0.22304928302764893,
-0.4357224702835083,
-0.25519484281539917,
0.7954163551330566,
-0.7306930422782898,
-0.6524729132652283,
-0.574628472328186,
-0.27211427688598633,
0.034662213176488876,
0.16047073900699615,
0.7004121541976929,
0.03529014438390732,
-0.5031886696815491,
-0.13698247075080872,
0.5719265341758728,
-0.3044682741165161,
0.49034249782562256,
0.06992639601230621,
0.320526123046875,
-0.07472768425941467,
1.117221713066101,
0.013652178458869457,
0.030786029994487762,
-0.008960630744695663,
-0.133499413728714,
-0.2529976963996887,
-0.6042336225509644,
-0.49567440152168274,
0.04804898053407669,
-0.35841724276542664,
-0.4126521050930023,
-0.6131336688995361,
-0.7241563200950623,
-0.8034592270851135,
-0.27787384390830994,
-0.1803678274154663,
-0.017173191532492638,
-0.7932302951812744,
0.006774623412638903,
0.3903304636478424,
0.959463894367218,
-0.14884105324745178,
0.3387974798679352,
-0.5659796595573425,
0.5200724601745605,
0.34093108773231506,
0.19513753056526184,
0.16003161668777466,
-0.24141182005405426,
-0.09698672592639923,
0.5929468870162964,
-0.44421154260635376,
-0.7167957425117493,
0.372005432844162,
0.27407050132751465,
0.6306614875793457,
0.8736103773117065,
0.07841943949460983,
0.30252552032470703,
-0.1986517310142517,
1.225388765335083,
-0.25962692499160767,
-0.8618418574333191,
0.4099343419075012,
-0.602602481842041,
-0.22990921139717102,
0.18142491579055786,
0.8508503437042236,
-0.4651709496974945,
-0.05185435712337494,
-0.6889345645904541,
-0.6018627882003784,
0.3040117919445038,
0.25495707988739014,
0.3139469623565674,
-0.3304939866065979,
0.37096014618873596,
0.25380265712738037,
0.40346017479896545,
-0.7313534617424011,
-0.24876411259174347,
-0.4171545207500458,
-0.24851319193840027,
0.5410160422325134,
-0.04327390715479851,
-0.12240523099899292,
0.1279090940952301,
0.7948790788650513,
-0.1028321161866188,
0.4828031361103058,
0.06093570590019226,
-0.13546836376190186,
-0.11057177931070328,
-0.21874858438968658,
0.6087847352027893,
0.3018435835838318,
0.3588280975818634,
-0.08257678896188736,
-0.39937856793403625,
-0.5461966395378113,
0.04070105031132698,
-0.19277024269104004,
-0.5335029363632202,
-0.27768024802207947,
0.798316240310669,
0.2334100902080536,
-0.46899598836898804,
-0.7982181310653687,
0.6920610070228577,
0.19256921112537384,
-0.4544879198074341,
-0.9917792081832886,
0.4905572235584259,
-0.3365700840950012,
0.033240027725696564,
0.7695494294166565,
0.010638606734573841,
0.3392658233642578,
-0.8709084987640381,
0.31539201736450195,
0.7338767647743225,
-0.2170848399400711,
-0.40092265605926514,
0.61310213804245,
0.17582011222839355,
-0.4032171964645386,
0.9199122190475464,
-0.6199527382850647,
-0.44110381603240967,
0.6874905228614807,
0.36920928955078125,
0.6557255387306213,
-0.11384671181440353,
0.6985107660293579,
-0.11783716827630997,
0.19950807094573975,
-0.164497509598732,
0.09463270008563995,
-0.21649013459682465,
-0.9252311587333679,
-0.08879073709249496,
-0.5073419213294983,
0.017508218064904213,
0.4118419885635376,
-0.3039732575416565,
0.2216329574584961,
-0.5172914266586304,
-0.005792774725705385,
0.08647254854440689,
-0.026038533076643944,
-0.4760006070137024,
0.09448067843914032,
0.3686651587486267,
0.9387044906616211,
-0.9278066158294678,
0.39643779397010803,
0.5187751054763794,
-0.37541523575782776,
-0.4148809313774109,
0.31683549284935,
0.5499282479286194,
-0.6653938293457031,
0.4405633211135864,
-0.08547859638929367,
-0.12433511763811111,
0.015093422494828701,
-0.8594544529914856,
-0.7010636925697327,
1.066482424736023,
-0.10403763502836227,
0.12070086598396301,
-0.17870503664016724,
0.3120453953742981,
0.54366135597229,
-0.39105871319770813,
0.04599982127547264,
0.4482842981815338,
0.6976761221885681,
0.065703384578228,
-0.3067750632762909,
-0.1789093017578125,
-0.4792558550834656,
-0.3399431109428406,
-0.04786308854818344,
-0.8323249220848083,
0.7420485019683838,
0.10682263970375061,
-0.5543641448020935,
0.3223503828048706,
0.8295605182647705,
0.15049314498901367,
0.6845858097076416,
0.3494888246059418,
0.22557590901851654,
0.35297080874443054,
-0.1688300222158432,
0.854186475276947,
0.0022527812980115414,
-0.004239245783537626,
0.31633874773979187,
-0.11675310134887695,
0.3006773591041565,
0.09257735311985016,
-0.06526591628789902,
0.8041970729827881,
0.7477099299430847,
-0.5279397368431091,
0.2782979905605316,
0.14993029832839966,
-0.5868257284164429,
-0.23956868052482605,
-0.4595155119895935,
-0.2981415092945099,
0.6627982258796692,
0.7080337405204773,
-0.2420864701271057,
0.201202392578125,
0.11936239898204803,
-0.03521078824996948,
0.2712825536727905,
-0.267179012298584,
0.7942267060279846,
-0.22680501639842987,
-0.45879507064819336,
0.21072985231876373,
0.20526833832263947,
0.9888033866882324,
-0.4356953501701355,
-0.3514258563518524,
-0.21222633123397827,
-0.3898032605648041,
-0.34019485116004944,
-0.5426558256149292,
0.4501778483390808,
-0.07180050760507584,
0.018293248489499092,
-0.23328283429145813,
0.9824821352958679,
-0.1752341389656067,
-0.4931964576244354,
-0.00469013350084424,
0.6186695098876953,
-0.18155641853809357,
-0.12351754307746887,
-0.5456324219703674,
-0.1281552016735077,
-0.19615650177001953,
-0.19380547106266022,
0.03374016284942627,
0.39169788360595703,
-0.2301265001296997,
0.8307539820671082,
0.7693540453910828,
0.1378527134656906,
0.16251352429389954,
-0.3341137170791626,
0.6106850504875183,
-0.4733903408050537,
-0.5319243669509888,
-0.6145622134208679,
0.3850587010383606,
-0.10094445943832397,
-0.12983328104019165,
0.7988556027412415,
0.3272594213485718,
1.0955312252044678,
-0.13694259524345398,
0.8830010294914246,
-0.2766988277435303,
-0.008447439409792423,
-0.4214167892932892,
1.14053213596344,
-0.6740960478782654,
0.24020850658416748,
-0.28602510690689087,
-0.5234200954437256,
0.10325589776039124,
0.3082219064235687,
0.019692936912178993,
0.34093934297561646,
0.22376038134098053,
0.5209576487541199,
-0.22142556309700012,
0.10031574964523315,
0.1218762919306755,
0.11109607666730881,
0.33190086483955383,
0.09361165016889572,
1.1198211908340454,
-0.4679288864135742,
0.27786827087402344,
-0.157706618309021,
-0.2538554072380066,
-0.33783140778541565,
-0.709321141242981,
-0.6584588289260864,
-0.8625590205192566,
-0.4871523082256317,
-0.30792170763015747,
-0.1266413778066635,
0.426241934299469,
0.8489283323287964,
-0.7623785734176636,
0.21995708346366882,
-0.27177178859710693,
0.26691722869873047,
-0.3543439507484436,
-0.3594275712966919,
0.25241759419441223,
0.3296062648296356,
-0.5345989465713501,
0.4428749978542328,
0.14495590329170227,
0.24599990248680115,
-0.6988186240196228,
0.16915962100028992,
-0.41479334235191345,
0.4334867000579834,
0.5807288885116577,
0.4818185269832611,
-0.7452285885810852,
-0.4344497621059418,
0.21361111104488373,
0.09887217730283737,
-0.3393823504447937,
0.8983128070831299,
-1.0179128646850586,
0.15123432874679565,
0.5437103509902954,
0.6026193499565125,
-0.09393011033535004,
0.27349355816841125,
0.4586799740791321,
-0.970905065536499,
0.03353413566946983,
0.2947579026222229,
-0.034383825957775116,
0.17143169045448303,
-1.0061944723129272,
0.411491721868515,
0.670703649520874,
-0.28823474049568176,
-0.854935884475708,
0.6540117859840393,
-0.6998177170753479,
-0.3750435411930084,
0.8649293184280396,
-0.023286253213882446,
-0.09449979662895203,
-0.07919733226299286,
0.22694095969200134,
0.4588507413864136,
-0.12880143523216248,
1.2623568773269653,
0.6495365500450134,
-0.39485669136047363,
0.123938649892807,
-0.34720781445503235,
0.8260220885276794,
-0.061918918043375015,
-1.1135213375091553,
-0.15216484665870667,
0.7111952304840088,
0.1084066703915596,
0.381717324256897,
0.5533703565597534,
-0.2216290980577469,
0.4406451880931854,
0.12845920026302338,
-0.3345070481300354,
-0.46634146571159363,
-0.554939329624176,
0.051642678678035736,
0.1833295077085495,
-0.3106870949268341,
0.2804938852787018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16308v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16308v1
|
WorldValuesBench: A Large-Scale Benchmark Dataset for Multi-Cultural Value Awareness of Language Models
| 2024-04-25T03:23:28 | 2024-04-25T03:23:28 |
Wenlong Zhao, Debanjan Mondal, Niket Tandon, Danica Dillion, Kurt Gray, Yuling Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The awareness of multi-cultural human values is critical to the ability of
language models (LMs) to generate safe and personalized responses. However,
this awareness of LMs has been insufficiently studied, since the computer
science community lacks access to the large-scale real-world data about
multi-cultural values. In this paper, we present WorldValuesBench, a globally
diverse, large-scale benchmark dataset for the multi-cultural value prediction
task, which requires a model to generate a rating response to a value question
based on demographic contexts. Our dataset is derived from an influential
social science project, World Values Survey (WVS), that has collected answers
to hundreds of value questions (e.g., social, economic, ethical) from 94,728
participants worldwide. We have constructed more than 20 million examples of
the type "(demographic attributes, value question) $\rightarrow$ answer" from
the WVS responses. We perform a case study using our dataset and show that the
task is challenging for strong open and closed-source models. On merely
$11.1\%$, $25.0\%$, $72.2\%$, and $75.0\%$ of the questions, Alpaca-7B,
Vicuna-7B-v1.5, Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct-v0.1, and GPT-3.5 Turbo can respectively
achieve $<0.2$ Wasserstein 1-distance from the human normalized answer
distributions. WorldValuesBench opens up new research avenues in studying
limitations and opportunities in multi-cultural value awareness of LMs.
|
[
-0.6600313186645508,
-0.40518805384635925,
0.059187017381191254,
0.023474249988794327,
0.007872591726481915,
0.039326783269643784,
-0.25380265712738037,
-0.6967200636863708,
-0.01511502917855978,
0.31379878520965576,
-0.5796882510185242,
-0.4536452293395996,
-0.3650682270526886,
-0.20166590809822083,
0.027004310861229897,
0.9546104669570923,
0.1384986788034439,
0.06800148636102676,
-0.15737570822238922,
-0.5533689856529236,
0.02188020572066307,
-0.7620877623558044,
-0.07051128894090652,
-0.08234458416700363,
0.5069425702095032,
0.5796900391578674,
0.5357218980789185,
0.17362920939922333,
0.38248544931411743,
0.13465049862861633,
-0.2988106608390808,
0.018601644784212112,
-0.5814751386642456,
0.39149653911590576,
-0.23392844200134277,
-0.31986403465270996,
-0.3647758662700653,
0.3477410674095154,
0.23114849627017975,
0.8440778851509094,
-0.14812664687633514,
0.8572695851325989,
-0.2549026906490326,
0.6576282382011414,
-0.8108029365539551,
0.3130791485309601,
-0.6584764719009399,
0.10586793720722198,
-0.16322201490402222,
0.17636235058307648,
-0.10779622197151184,
-0.653481125831604,
0.10966481268405914,
-0.2797151803970337,
0.17732682824134827,
0.05034087598323822,
0.6329469084739685,
-0.018726402893662453,
-0.7040452361106873,
0.044269874691963196,
-0.7490782737731934,
0.8767896890640259,
-0.3090519309043884,
0.3498274087905884,
0.41294896602630615,
0.6223343014717102,
-0.17658498883247375,
-0.23928223550319672,
-0.47841930389404297,
-0.03091210126876831,
0.33556124567985535,
0.19332349300384521,
-0.14266610145568848,
-0.3973299264907837,
0.38223063945770264,
0.34864771366119385,
-0.5146145820617676,
-0.03689711540937424,
-0.5542251467704773,
-0.20148178935050964,
0.6430737376213074,
0.20714426040649414,
-0.0033700771164149046,
-0.19246159493923187,
-0.167490154504776,
-0.4539306163787842,
-0.644862949848175,
0.6195735931396484,
0.48075011372566223,
0.40121105313301086,
-0.10776714235544205,
0.39279791712760925,
-0.5893567800521851,
0.6482462286949158,
-0.3784525692462921,
-0.3240283727645874,
0.4765329658985138,
-0.3022403419017792,
0.29540684819221497,
-0.17004595696926117,
0.49523890018463135,
0.6299316883087158,
0.6541526913642883,
0.03893909230828285,
0.14630144834518433,
0.10322791337966919,
0.09661033749580383,
-1.11479914188385,
0.19399769604206085,
0.18837550282478333,
-0.4436820447444916,
-0.2819936275482178,
0.07760196924209595,
-0.8512361645698547,
-0.34028103947639465,
-0.19587862491607666,
-0.17261070013046265,
-0.11720018833875656,
-0.40757420659065247,
-0.16384966671466827,
-0.17874480783939362,
0.13727690279483795,
0.38992738723754883,
-0.8281415104866028,
0.15803775191307068,
0.2994261085987091,
0.548031747341156,
-0.030024196952581406,
-0.19127793610095978,
-0.4661843478679657,
-0.2080184668302536,
-0.2497090846300125,
0.8091127276420593,
-0.619042694568634,
-0.49917787313461304,
-0.2518925070762634,
0.01805710978806019,
0.5023758411407471,
-0.4534653425216675,
0.4518505930900574,
-0.6283613443374634,
-0.021252324804663658,
-0.5523144602775574,
-0.2124742865562439,
-0.08602520078420639,
0.6106377840042114,
-0.8585746884346008,
1.2780718803405762,
0.2513386309146881,
-0.8336939811706543,
0.5603297352790833,
-0.30918067693710327,
-0.08637253940105438,
0.06593606621026993,
-0.19604001939296722,
-0.1402842104434967,
0.18166682124137878,
0.021525051444768906,
0.36846092343330383,
-0.7134420871734619,
0.5074426531791687,
-0.7171526551246643,
-0.42039254307746887,
0.4127982556819916,
-0.7486696243286133,
0.7380327582359314,
0.19670896232128143,
-0.2795102596282959,
-0.006174416281282902,
-1.1761391162872314,
0.3580186665058136,
0.16140133142471313,
-0.2844827473163605,
-0.5407940149307251,
-0.1625141203403473,
0.29069143533706665,
0.7685549855232239,
-0.014949832111597061,
-0.7913990616798401,
0.03683275729417801,
-0.15808230638504028,
0.15182340145111084,
0.9324308037757874,
-0.09984062612056732,
-0.0927908793091774,
-0.19719086587429047,
0.8639683127403259,
-0.02513878047466278,
-0.00927427876740694,
0.13336913287639618,
-0.44792452454566956,
-0.403349369764328,
-0.043633267283439636,
0.08947927504777908,
0.44320833683013916,
-0.34565407037734985,
0.24008731544017792,
-0.4198744297027588,
-0.8724188208580017,
-0.514417290687561,
-0.01521158218383789,
0.24640822410583496,
0.47486934065818787,
0.29912692308425903,
-0.10876208543777466,
-0.4618458151817322,
-1.1336297988891602,
-0.3449476659297943,
-0.32615214586257935,
-0.13321836292743683,
0.3797028064727783,
0.6102222800254822,
0.1789497286081314,
1.012622356414795,
-0.7210014462471008,
0.04923640936613083,
0.039002805948257446,
0.03444785997271538,
0.16188944876194,
0.19029726088047028,
0.19340258836746216,
-0.8644804358482361,
-0.5238749980926514,
-0.15699096024036407,
-0.5083374381065369,
-0.03324263170361519,
0.41182610392570496,
-0.13468611240386963,
0.050699345767498016,
0.3392997086048126,
-0.05147397890686989,
0.26934847235679626,
0.9304683208465576,
-0.1652311086654663,
0.6137779951095581,
-0.08257244527339935,
0.2500236928462982,
-1.4369758367538452,
0.5420413017272949,
0.25814196467399597,
0.1845836341381073,
-0.3758015036582947,
0.02402452938258648,
0.3489682674407959,
-0.1952429562807083,
-0.5837691426277161,
0.781876266002655,
-0.14726509153842926,
0.0027583723422139883,
0.12424660474061966,
0.07887227833271027,
-0.07442009449005127,
0.45016226172447205,
-0.040132660418748856,
0.8675801753997803,
0.1232953742146492,
-0.3344530761241913,
0.6073257327079773,
0.3119161128997803,
-0.5614048838615417,
1.0881943702697754,
-0.4619942605495453,
0.04190271720290184,
-0.3025239408016205,
0.4701076149940491,
-0.7143181562423706,
-0.26610565185546875,
-0.376867413520813,
-0.347194641828537,
-0.3782182037830353,
-0.34335434436798096,
-0.37417328357696533,
-0.37983769178390503,
-0.31017085909843445,
0.5247586965560913,
0.41234290599823,
-0.5628243684768677,
0.22546683251857758,
0.7122086882591248,
-0.41003838181495667,
-0.6510085463523865,
-0.45620736479759216,
-0.01728532835841179,
-0.21315379440784454,
-0.7659461498260498,
0.09421223402023315,
-0.3788111209869385,
-0.456042617559433,
-0.15621352195739746,
-0.09652798622846603,
-0.15771110355854034,
0.15332424640655518,
0.36370906233787537,
0.22582781314849854,
0.04643560200929642,
0.40869760513305664,
-0.18574601411819458,
-0.2648385465145111,
0.014452003873884678,
-0.17709346115589142,
0.3695467710494995,
-0.5378803014755249,
-0.5033910274505615,
0.34829941391944885,
0.31321537494659424,
0.7943061590194702,
-0.6612524390220642,
0.838191568851471,
0.4311603307723999,
-0.4144238531589508,
-0.12701068818569183,
-0.6218634843826294,
0.025713300332427025,
-0.3914017677307129,
0.5024681091308594,
-0.45238277316093445,
-1.1089894771575928,
0.7683277726173401,
0.04275559261441231,
0.055062033236026764,
0.3789792060852051,
0.7241364121437073,
0.17252768576145172,
1.0182483196258545,
0.3915694057941437,
-0.21777735650539398,
0.20269356667995453,
-0.05922599881887436,
0.07124519348144531,
-0.6692647933959961,
-0.35285452008247375,
-0.7338159084320068,
-0.3201350271701813,
-0.7443175315856934,
-0.5389937162399292,
0.7553297877311707,
-0.36407899856567383,
-0.2613770663738251,
-0.04940425232052803,
-0.29568588733673096,
0.5165451169013977,
0.5150682330131531,
-0.1176983043551445,
0.38621848821640015,
0.09608519822359085,
-0.26532697677612305,
-0.34253165125846863,
-0.29469969868659973,
-0.4073058068752289,
1.1721864938735962,
0.0748586431145668,
0.9212915897369385,
0.18645326793193817,
0.32174429297447205,
0.050774045288562775,
0.4233968257904053,
-0.6658246517181396,
0.36241891980171204,
-0.0057119326665997505,
-0.9417171478271484,
-0.3244858682155609,
-0.6513468623161316,
-0.9412365555763245,
0.7317591309547424,
-0.1643766313791275,
-0.6284493803977966,
0.07429990917444229,
0.16819122433662415,
-0.2539217174053192,
0.377050518989563,
-0.302695631980896,
0.9114518761634827,
-0.26808854937553406,
-0.5199218392372131,
-0.20740129053592682,
-0.7033795714378357,
0.3976804316043854,
-0.2182646095752716,
0.778316080570221,
-0.6471912860870361,
0.3624666929244995,
0.4933687448501587,
-0.12805764377117157,
0.7268995642662048,
-0.20722439885139465,
-0.161251500248909,
0.10658864676952362,
0.06901005655527115,
0.29044240713119507,
0.03662411868572235,
-0.44483116269111633,
-0.01673549972474575,
0.23365472257137299,
-0.4530460238456726,
-0.17669206857681274,
0.7863669395446777,
-0.7669074535369873,
-0.35569167137145996,
-0.6108726263046265,
-0.6176604628562927,
-0.5668459534645081,
0.10643923282623291,
-0.032352104783058167,
0.3835722506046295,
-0.8576664924621582,
0.4743562638759613,
0.46264392137527466,
-0.27376842498779297,
0.0533953420817852,
0.7720847725868225,
0.0262589231133461,
-0.210998073220253,
0.828132152557373,
0.2265947163105011,
0.4346810281276703,
0.0006578899337910116,
0.3985510468482971,
-0.20542043447494507,
0.09289667010307312,
-0.6639636158943176,
-0.1578434556722641,
-0.900505006313324,
-0.14076638221740723,
-0.5487602949142456,
-0.09469316899776459,
-0.13246159255504608,
0.054614387452602386,
-0.37490642070770264,
-0.47188061475753784,
0.3310346007347107,
-0.2846224308013916,
0.4999455213546753,
0.45751917362213135,
0.07299535721540451,
-0.39170822501182556,
-0.9931409955024719,
0.2237488478422165,
0.3453719913959503,
0.8069947361946106,
0.09775202721357346,
-0.2373945713043213,
-0.40340137481689453,
0.28697556257247925,
-0.1440986841917038,
-0.6750780344009399,
0.3306734561920166,
0.048427775502204895,
0.6327136754989624,
0.15283113718032837,
0.30371716618537903,
0.7080183625221252,
-0.3301182985305786,
0.6787130832672119,
-0.18884935975074768,
-0.8488751649856567,
0.3713090121746063,
-0.16073109209537506,
0.42271751165390015,
0.8987070918083191,
0.440858393907547,
-1.3441972732543945,
-0.3676277995109558,
-0.5969748497009277,
-0.8727597594261169,
0.7856788039207458,
-0.11579529941082001,
0.19161076843738556,
0.11599104851484299,
0.027195002883672714,
0.2597713768482208,
0.2819439172744751,
-0.6720499396324158,
0.02168034203350544,
-0.16902834177017212,
-0.2134661078453064,
-0.10563461482524872,
0.0414319708943367,
-0.16351063549518585,
-0.14013345539569855,
0.5764315724372864,
-0.5621897578239441,
-0.47563669085502625,
-0.1523800641298294,
-0.1507318913936615,
-0.36906617879867554,
0.7338533997535706,
0.3269239068031311,
0.6854904890060425,
-0.44641587138175964,
0.2347855567932129,
0.41638627648353577,
-0.36378347873687744,
0.47686025500297546,
0.16071677207946777,
0.005926825571805239,
-0.6320750713348389,
0.06582962721586227,
0.5322256088256836,
-0.017044121399521828,
-1.0007115602493286,
0.4944840967655182,
-0.3973708152770996,
0.046821512281894684,
-0.5006937384605408,
-0.2087300568819046,
0.3846960663795471,
-0.13411042094230652,
0.20445942878723145,
0.05349808931350708,
-0.038004159927368164,
-0.6027443408966064,
-0.007289766799658537,
0.45739492774009705,
-0.5969364643096924,
-0.3226676881313324,
0.39970827102661133,
0.15639227628707886,
0.22272562980651855,
0.7861878871917725,
-0.19471000134944916,
-0.5495550632476807,
0.7957272529602051,
0.30928054451942444,
0.4960297644138336,
-0.2776529788970947,
0.08127499371767044,
0.5181846618652344,
0.24396084249019623,
-0.04772696644067764,
0.530934751033783,
0.2681620121002197,
-0.8973667025566101,
-0.11883936822414398,
-0.7425171732902527,
-0.7602775692939758,
-0.11896663159132004,
-0.892036497592926,
0.052770402282476425,
-0.23931635916233063,
-0.07318399846553802,
-0.1592983603477478,
-0.12315862625837326,
-0.8885369300842285,
0.3480079770088196,
0.08611742407083511,
0.7763004302978516,
-1.1696447134017944,
0.7120841145515442,
0.6463786363601685,
-0.41768935322761536,
-0.500523567199707,
-0.09370989352464676,
0.39604341983795166,
-0.7450881600379944,
0.7862008810043335,
0.2918790876865387,
-0.21041162312030792,
-0.3655756115913391,
-0.3210182785987854,
-1.1541508436203003,
0.8548683524131775,
0.23539413511753082,
-0.146188884973526,
0.21230511367321014,
0.23068490624427795,
0.7047017812728882,
-0.18071548640727997,
0.31046515703201294,
0.6366464495658875,
0.5519987344741821,
0.04819865524768829,
-0.849143922328949,
0.0545998215675354,
-0.6720646023750305,
0.11971618235111237,
0.22299237549304962,
-0.96196448802948,
0.8808097839355469,
-0.13026084005832672,
0.19553102552890778,
-0.3941604793071747,
0.3124019503593445,
0.48332393169403076,
-0.1048424020409584,
0.779728353023529,
0.39818891882896423,
0.8138445019721985,
0.004025057889521122,
0.9004954099655151,
-0.5904155373573303,
0.32414358854293823,
0.8545076847076416,
-0.4835103750228882,
0.9543609023094177,
0.22040656208992004,
-0.41092750430107117,
0.4585148096084595,
0.6736577749252319,
-0.09726474434137344,
0.08063308149576187,
0.5318444967269897,
-0.11192993074655533,
-0.40729403495788574,
-0.3731408417224884,
-0.4107745885848999,
0.7298703789710999,
0.30642691254615784,
0.039821792393922806,
-0.17920871078968048,
-0.2355356067419052,
0.06416351348161697,
-0.037695012986660004,
0.1163712739944458,
0.6012684106826782,
-0.0815945714712143,
-0.7176213264465332,
0.5158205032348633,
0.11190814524888992,
0.4800402820110321,
-0.8754554986953735,
-0.00405059615150094,
-0.2086852788925171,
0.3342265486717224,
-0.06489328294992447,
-0.6797776818275452,
0.1185162216424942,
0.17666658759117126,
-0.3391304910182953,
-0.10857123881578445,
0.29153987765312195,
-0.5373123288154602,
-0.8543334007263184,
0.3830086588859558,
0.6013340353965759,
0.03538286313414574,
-0.2603079676628113,
-0.4560212790966034,
-0.040105175226926804,
-0.0672517940402031,
-0.32362884283065796,
0.4994388520717621,
0.2789677083492279,
-0.6018590927124023,
0.7743804454803467,
0.7444124817848206,
0.06500425934791565,
-0.19759654998779297,
0.11780314892530441,
0.7464587092399597,
-0.7864231467247009,
-0.6108942031860352,
-0.5786074995994568,
0.4610377848148346,
-0.14304357767105103,
-0.5513989329338074,
0.684550404548645,
0.7024098634719849,
1.0095270872116089,
0.1459030956029892,
1.101233959197998,
0.056424759328365326,
0.6245521306991577,
-0.05470912903547287,
0.6546431183815002,
-0.7112521529197693,
-0.06722382456064224,
-0.3953883945941925,
-0.8709104061126709,
-0.10124149173498154,
0.41277366876602173,
-0.10116629302501678,
0.1575247049331665,
0.4447135031223297,
0.6881521344184875,
0.014928679913282394,
0.30247464776039124,
0.33202287554740906,
-0.060435280203819275,
0.6532730460166931,
0.5078268647193909,
0.7195709347724915,
0.05906683951616287,
0.7903577089309692,
-0.3690192997455597,
-0.35131171345710754,
-0.13235145807266235,
-0.8431981801986694,
-0.5913673639297485,
-0.44809967279434204,
0.08108168840408325,
-0.46726593375205994,
-0.20166942477226257,
1.3977762460708618,
0.7194182872772217,
-1.0813401937484741,
-0.6116164326667786,
0.6125295758247375,
-0.17471137642860413,
-0.20619642734527588,
-0.13345535099506378,
0.3669639527797699,
0.0504101924598217,
-0.6355793476104736,
0.1484978199005127,
0.11009834706783295,
0.032390568405389786,
-0.589508056640625,
0.2294936180114746,
0.10588958114385605,
-0.03749621659517288,
0.5309014320373535,
0.18439573049545288,
-0.6436431407928467,
-0.38525399565696716,
0.1329387128353119,
-0.20497235655784607,
0.045692719519138336,
0.7520726919174194,
-0.6259313821792603,
0.7300311326980591,
0.4807920455932617,
0.5182216167449951,
0.6273643970489502,
0.0002069779293378815,
0.5620707273483276,
-0.8121694326400757,
0.2776990234851837,
0.27886199951171875,
0.49932122230529785,
0.4236612915992737,
-0.07649171352386475,
0.4174705147743225,
0.1695725917816162,
-0.32851576805114746,
-0.48711326718330383,
0.46546804904937744,
-0.6206368803977966,
-0.20965228974819183,
0.8661580085754395,
-0.1496967375278473,
0.06848856806755066,
-0.15409651398658752,
-0.20395666360855103,
-0.026557549834251404,
-0.5804174542427063,
0.854860782623291,
0.908412516117096,
0.1562443971633911,
0.0036583507899194956,
-0.6626858711242676,
0.1360682249069214,
0.28186509013175964,
-1.0525798797607422,
0.4921388626098633,
0.754377543926239,
0.43070003390312195,
0.16361404955387115,
0.4532575011253357,
-0.26999443769454956,
0.20377017557621002,
-0.051160648465156555,
0.5147536993026733,
-0.02106420323252678,
-0.04790588468313217,
-0.19937598705291748,
0.5102375745773315,
0.30937036871910095,
0.3595152795314789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16294v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16294v1
|
LLM-Based Section Identifiers Excel on Open Source but Stumble in Real World Applications
| 2024-04-25T02:25:35 | 2024-04-25T02:25:35 |
Saranya Krishnamoorthy, Ayush Singh, Shabnam Tafreshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Electronic health records (EHR) even though a boon for healthcare
practitioners, are growing convoluted and longer every day. Sifting around
these lengthy EHRs is taxing and becomes a cumbersome part of physician-patient
interaction. Several approaches have been proposed to help alleviate this
prevalent issue either via summarization or sectioning, however, only a few
approaches have truly been helpful in the past. With the rise of automated
methods, machine learning (ML) has shown promise in solving the task of
identifying relevant sections in EHR. However, most ML methods rely on labeled
data which is difficult to get in healthcare. Large language models (LLMs) on
the other hand, have performed impressive feats in natural language processing
(NLP), that too in a zero-shot manner, i.e. without any labeled data. To that
end, we propose using LLMs to identify relevant section headers. We find that
GPT-4 can effectively solve the task on both zero and few-shot settings as well
as segment dramatically better than state-of-the-art methods. Additionally, we
also annotate a much harder real world dataset and find that GPT-4 struggles to
perform well, alluding to further research and harder benchmarks.
|
[
-0.16835041344165802,
-0.7641593217849731,
0.9872967600822449,
-0.08819655328989029,
-0.6161392331123352,
0.02217714861035347,
0.0843060091137886,
-0.7151619791984558,
0.053218185901641846,
0.4021391272544861,
-0.36670973896980286,
-0.7432351112365723,
-0.5230831503868103,
0.259359210729599,
-0.18685035407543182,
1.273337483406067,
-0.08487733453512192,
-0.08298635482788086,
-0.32718178629875183,
-0.2695280909538269,
-0.21510261297225952,
-0.8927043080329895,
-0.5328254699707031,
-0.6195288896560669,
0.7228516340255737,
0.2357335239648819,
0.35986003279685974,
1.2311292886734009,
1.0341932773590088,
0.22367171943187714,
-0.07364709675312042,
0.22583182156085968,
-0.04633771628141403,
0.11664783954620361,
0.28539273142814636,
-0.33805882930755615,
-0.48205986618995667,
-0.361968457698822,
0.5165536403656006,
0.4989807605743408,
-0.19737020134925842,
0.0750846266746521,
-0.15625432133674622,
0.9741659760475159,
-0.40874648094177246,
0.4335269033908844,
-0.7254078388214111,
0.32000747323036194,
-0.5228546857833862,
-0.41346630454063416,
0.020214220508933067,
-0.4101148247718811,
0.24103374779224396,
-0.3736477494239807,
0.24282145500183105,
-0.05819139629602432,
1.091628909111023,
0.4735824167728424,
-0.31638503074645996,
-0.3737905025482178,
-0.7997820973396301,
0.640041708946228,
-0.7582426071166992,
0.5758390426635742,
0.3777218461036682,
0.2583310306072235,
-0.053166769444942474,
-0.6834926009178162,
-0.16947820782661438,
-0.07377517968416214,
0.06298630684614182,
0.05139404162764549,
-0.19317522644996643,
0.2078654170036316,
0.08579956740140915,
0.5070223212242126,
-0.5892583727836609,
0.3767909109592438,
-0.5540648102760315,
-0.1607789695262909,
0.4817131459712982,
0.3440391719341278,
0.17448623478412628,
-0.12419793009757996,
-0.2895136773586273,
0.37858495116233826,
-0.8906386494636536,
-0.17458763718605042,
-0.08755483478307724,
0.24479416012763977,
-0.3415181040763855,
0.714539647102356,
-0.17964336276054382,
0.8090718984603882,
0.3149881064891815,
-0.4262407124042511,
0.47125479578971863,
-0.08680593967437744,
-0.45542964339256287,
0.046319056302309036,
0.7784566879272461,
0.20164939761161804,
0.09801437705755234,
-0.14099296927452087,
-0.18382757902145386,
-0.21190261840820312,
0.4289741814136505,
-0.7682797908782959,
-0.5031639933586121,
0.7232561707496643,
-0.44759947061538696,
0.0958404690027237,
0.027936600148677826,
-0.3739505410194397,
-0.395262211561203,
-0.5246111750602722,
0.11574564129114151,
-0.507752001285553,
0.27969667315483093,
-0.15877185761928558,
0.026004482060670853,
0.36923396587371826,
0.41808247566223145,
-0.7528886795043945,
0.022467728704214096,
1.222355842590332,
0.9963381290435791,
-0.236403226852417,
0.05883480980992317,
-0.6352208852767944,
-0.030738523229956627,
-0.2740667164325714,
0.9686676859855652,
-0.4616949260234833,
-0.2619914412498474,
-0.0631166622042656,
0.004345702473074198,
-0.016738563776016235,
-0.935222864151001,
0.5394949316978455,
-0.48694658279418945,
0.03064485266804695,
-0.04534845054149628,
-0.7325087785720825,
0.12589240074157715,
0.6121885180473328,
-0.7472296357154846,
0.6019360423088074,
0.0646609291434288,
-0.98698490858078,
0.32689613103866577,
-0.6610077023506165,
-0.37748074531555176,
0.36878514289855957,
-0.4958725571632385,
-1.0679510831832886,
0.3557312488555908,
0.27511000633239746,
0.527746319770813,
-0.17657075822353363,
0.07802504301071167,
-0.1669190675020218,
-0.3055456280708313,
0.2777637541294098,
-0.16875697672367096,
0.36710628867149353,
0.21313804388046265,
0.06710606068372726,
0.29463574290275574,
-0.6058691740036011,
0.01176522672176361,
0.0019192328909412026,
-0.6464883685112,
-0.4617255628108978,
0.06625577062368393,
-0.1780291646718979,
0.05147141218185425,
0.14020276069641113,
-0.4955848753452301,
-0.038375310599803925,
-0.3002508878707886,
0.15045270323753357,
0.5360252261161804,
0.2736741006374359,
0.1606554090976715,
-0.5567964315414429,
0.6294569373130798,
0.24665454030036926,
0.14882910251617432,
-0.27980151772499084,
-0.7408478856086731,
-0.5037523508071899,
-0.6315402388572693,
0.4084744453430176,
0.802158772945404,
-0.7839763760566711,
0.635232150554657,
-0.3144919276237488,
-0.578883945941925,
-0.7641509175300598,
-0.011848877184092999,
0.43216413259506226,
0.7413383722305298,
0.5128393173217773,
-0.3956564664840698,
-0.37524572014808655,
-1.021497368812561,
-0.2676370143890381,
-0.4027461111545563,
-0.41084355115890503,
0.2826898396015167,
0.2333943247795105,
-0.20503810048103333,
0.8728460669517517,
-0.539504885673523,
-0.5531569123268127,
-0.3423316776752472,
-0.11461687088012695,
0.2127469778060913,
0.28079262375831604,
0.0671166181564331,
-0.7094908952713013,
-0.3469000458717346,
0.3389672338962555,
-0.9292027354240417,
-0.27569663524627686,
-0.005779222119599581,
0.11717268079519272,
-0.042625248432159424,
0.1641552895307541,
-0.35003769397735596,
0.2677343487739563,
0.41507622599601746,
-0.014214662835001945,
0.514053225517273,
-0.452962726354599,
-0.0448184609413147,
-0.8685697913169861,
0.04319494962692261,
0.49324831366539,
-0.18421180546283722,
-0.6954711079597473,
0.0677972137928009,
0.3543108403682709,
0.04784982651472092,
-0.6717777252197266,
0.44290828704833984,
-0.4987340569496155,
0.16589350998401642,
-0.1857699453830719,
-0.210968017578125,
-0.09619872272014618,
0.24864327907562256,
0.1917593628168106,
0.3836710751056671,
0.26353976130485535,
-0.6589081287384033,
0.2154829055070877,
0.3126376271247864,
-0.2779897451400757,
0.8141059875488281,
-0.6221837997436523,
0.11861013621091843,
-0.37903666496276855,
0.2903481125831604,
-0.06295362114906311,
-0.5207300782203674,
0.48527440428733826,
-0.08814045786857605,
0.3116591274738312,
-0.4137508273124695,
-0.24192973971366882,
-0.5116808414459229,
-0.47343194484710693,
0.41402503848075867,
0.4741450846195221,
-0.3343965709209442,
0.34637361764907837,
0.6967149972915649,
-0.24399448931217194,
-0.45355573296546936,
-0.8002123832702637,
0.06673398613929749,
-0.5341039299964905,
-0.18131504952907562,
0.5639294385910034,
0.02736511640250683,
-0.22905153036117554,
0.003409693017601967,
-0.30125921964645386,
-0.5782435536384583,
0.007298847660422325,
0.3004167973995209,
0.4225398004055023,
-0.22983527183532715,
0.18060685694217682,
0.02114027552306652,
-0.1743612289428711,
0.07970375567674637,
-0.2521331012248993,
0.12190017849206924,
-0.08735065907239914,
-0.779417872428894,
-0.8469350934028625,
0.4133984446525574,
0.5853853821754456,
-0.3426862359046936,
0.46218910813331604,
0.2882331311702728,
-0.4851839244365692,
-0.054320041090250015,
-0.6350678205490112,
0.19501999020576477,
-0.41207918524742126,
0.5748554468154907,
-0.3021906912326813,
-1.0492430925369263,
0.39105501770973206,
-0.0007418938912451267,
0.2751406729221344,
0.24484539031982422,
0.640276312828064,
-0.185897096991539,
0.47839459776878357,
0.4638541042804718,
-0.12666091322898865,
0.37731966376304626,
0.0847586914896965,
0.37196850776672363,
-1.022422194480896,
-0.5215764045715332,
-0.7072328925132751,
-0.11951863765716553,
-0.7651576399803162,
-0.5964803695678711,
0.8777319192886353,
-0.09665416926145554,
-0.023516684770584106,
0.1662963330745697,
-0.6226472854614258,
0.4524844288825989,
0.3669077455997467,
0.34563708305358887,
0.5226902365684509,
0.015484361909329891,
0.05692519620060921,
-0.05796343833208084,
-0.47328534722328186,
-0.43364179134368896,
0.9674718379974365,
0.6155558824539185,
0.7689517140388489,
0.022094398736953735,
1.0237467288970947,
0.30742108821868896,
0.5284058451652527,
-1.012817144393921,
0.3457946181297302,
-0.31693702936172485,
-0.3671707212924957,
-0.07015752792358398,
-0.5379719734191895,
-1.206985354423523,
0.1860898733139038,
-0.061436790972948074,
-0.5564463138580322,
-0.1027589961886406,
0.3986770212650299,
-0.41616615653038025,
0.4120299518108368,
-0.38104328513145447,
0.7154359221458435,
-0.3440503478050232,
-0.20107722282409668,
0.33512672781944275,
-0.6382527947425842,
0.17866376042366028,
-0.4306511878967285,
0.3152032792568207,
-0.2161102294921875,
-0.10570766031742096,
0.5470952391624451,
-0.6406299471855164,
0.6853734254837036,
-0.0696568638086319,
-0.1824892908334732,
0.3238345682621002,
-0.35877490043640137,
0.3972431719303131,
-0.15662752091884613,
-0.11175639927387238,
0.3684510588645935,
-0.027568425983190536,
-0.3554520606994629,
-0.349106103181839,
0.630966067314148,
-0.42268213629722595,
-0.4921424984931946,
-0.4415214955806732,
-0.18463298678398132,
-0.2724384069442749,
0.031968433409929276,
0.19989638030529022,
0.5808014869689941,
-0.08074215054512024,
0.12922193109989166,
0.5540878772735596,
-0.2848387062549591,
0.2432698905467987,
0.6155717968940735,
0.03258812054991722,
-0.4514871835708618,
0.8613237738609314,
0.24452729523181915,
-0.14710940420627594,
0.5783883333206177,
0.27083292603492737,
-0.3343063294887543,
-0.8661498427391052,
-0.8122275471687317,
0.4464997947216034,
-0.5369437336921692,
-0.34828317165374756,
-0.689443826675415,
-0.4886113703250885,
0.08106876164674759,
-0.04328116402029991,
-0.08664766699075699,
-0.06434692442417145,
-0.3158726692199707,
-0.27168405055999756,
0.19527487456798553,
0.7090672254562378,
0.11014441400766373,
-0.07052174210548401,
-1.352927565574646,
0.3638819754123688,
0.15889409184455872,
0.5823485851287842,
-0.10455375164747238,
-0.2802189886569977,
-0.551384449005127,
-0.34347882866859436,
-0.3595414161682129,
-0.8860253691673279,
0.36450573801994324,
0.05847059562802315,
0.60515958070755,
0.43443432450294495,
0.19561107456684113,
0.7335720062255859,
-0.8595912456512451,
0.7000174522399902,
0.10996758937835693,
-0.593841016292572,
0.40815141797065735,
-0.2376244068145752,
0.4772995114326477,
0.6119557023048401,
0.4379188120365143,
-0.5508477091789246,
-0.4660722017288208,
-0.3113675117492676,
-1.1246553659439087,
0.33662059903144836,
0.0446619912981987,
-0.0291603971272707,
-0.28593334555625916,
0.41805678606033325,
0.2728913426399231,
0.0577583871781826,
-0.5818267464637756,
-0.2959090769290924,
0.2747006118297577,
-0.5381177067756653,
0.4833877980709076,
-0.00949964951723814,
0.06952761858701706,
0.07072015851736069,
0.5655454397201538,
-0.14680634438991547,
0.36036333441734314,
0.4789603650569916,
0.057804230600595474,
-0.13003943860530853,
0.5897756814956665,
0.3594527244567871,
0.582423746585846,
-0.20576068758964539,
0.17183847725391388,
-0.09863824397325516,
-0.4773355722427368,
0.09798324108123779,
0.23147258162498474,
-0.39251944422721863,
0.15502503514289856,
0.4152127206325531,
0.6555995941162109,
-0.1216161698102951,
-0.7064819931983948,
0.4032498598098755,
0.12363733351230621,
-0.18496167659759521,
-0.42991048097610474,
-0.029998725280165672,
-0.001829370390623808,
0.21596422791481018,
0.3560253381729126,
-0.2741679847240448,
0.0370037704706192,
-0.2616960108280182,
0.37024712562561035,
0.4658339321613312,
-0.8393781185150146,
-0.4099747836589813,
0.7206546068191528,
0.3400079905986786,
-0.5731545090675354,
0.5339589715003967,
-0.004539656452834606,
-0.32123810052871704,
0.7497046589851379,
0.47379809617996216,
0.9736751914024353,
-0.03694915771484375,
0.01207500696182251,
0.10499109327793121,
0.15524539351463318,
-0.10384771972894669,
0.2121751308441162,
-0.03790067508816719,
-0.37129512429237366,
-0.6371539235115051,
-0.6422223448753357,
-0.7868404984474182,
0.43315133452415466,
-0.6391345858573914,
0.10641981661319733,
-0.3184824287891388,
-0.24713543057441711,
-0.0055520664900541306,
-0.3360539972782135,
-0.8787978291511536,
0.30893924832344055,
0.5220418572425842,
0.650844156742096,
-0.8456569314002991,
0.9647999405860901,
0.8917107582092285,
-0.21065030992031097,
-0.5921274423599243,
0.2909299433231354,
0.3222523629665375,
-0.49432483315467834,
0.17449459433555603,
0.3807494640350342,
0.26656830310821533,
-0.2975767254829407,
-0.026548441499471664,
-0.4684618413448334,
0.9202455878257751,
0.06646586954593658,
-0.7693942189216614,
-0.22343558073043823,
0.17869463562965393,
0.703344464302063,
-0.18902350962162018,
0.07407864928245544,
0.47391897439956665,
0.48938947916030884,
-0.14994768798351288,
-1.2555326223373413,
-0.04264233633875847,
-0.122835174202919,
-0.20479021966457367,
0.39808937907218933,
-0.490236759185791,
0.6854523420333862,
-0.2257729321718216,
-0.11847054958343506,
-0.03442822024226189,
0.5414469838142395,
0.49134939908981323,
0.9179064035415649,
0.27491334080696106,
0.701751708984375,
0.9119411706924438,
-0.04286644980311394,
1.1049997806549072,
-0.13772793114185333,
0.283132404088974,
1.1056119203567505,
-0.4593731462955475,
0.8735482096672058,
0.398440420627594,
-0.35566994547843933,
0.464792400598526,
0.6245091557502747,
-0.04428379237651825,
0.4481525123119354,
0.36996254324913025,
-0.5586493015289307,
0.008348487317562103,
0.020673982799053192,
-0.37161287665367126,
0.3632507920265198,
0.4359975755214691,
-0.4550449848175049,
-0.2066573202610016,
-0.19015361368656158,
0.20122838020324707,
-0.10702382028102875,
-0.2938205301761627,
1.1018158197402954,
0.260762095451355,
-0.6050202250480652,
0.24083256721496582,
0.1376068890094757,
0.6512024402618408,
-0.6955898404121399,
-0.19606202840805054,
-0.14233627915382385,
0.12980659306049347,
-0.391492635011673,
-0.5640119910240173,
0.5862835049629211,
0.3311738669872284,
-0.06327346712350845,
-0.07852093875408173,
0.705156147480011,
-0.28601184487342834,
-0.5263770818710327,
0.06131778284907341,
0.9055075645446777,
0.4013858139514923,
-0.15578871965408325,
-0.6248675584793091,
0.09302463382482529,
0.06745542585849762,
-0.14002948999404907,
0.5508050918579102,
0.6340571641921997,
-0.13556072115898132,
0.5621498227119446,
0.6184433698654175,
0.34526491165161133,
-0.20308230817317963,
-0.19140927493572235,
0.7945764660835266,
-0.8544127345085144,
-0.49540209770202637,
-1.1194988489151,
0.4747249484062195,
0.01267620362341404,
-0.100896917283535,
0.4024006724357605,
0.8483688235282898,
0.7408871054649353,
-0.0816442221403122,
0.9844435453414917,
0.058095790445804596,
0.7252771258354187,
-0.6475131511688232,
0.5746516585350037,
-0.5138412117958069,
0.5715646743774414,
0.02639116905629635,
-0.6317573189735413,
-0.8675401210784912,
0.24469901621341705,
-0.2626721262931824,
-0.25378167629241943,
0.7225401997566223,
0.4977532923221588,
-0.08155038207769394,
-0.32229989767074585,
0.4346923530101776,
0.10135068744421005,
0.5318761467933655,
0.403250515460968,
0.6236693859100342,
0.01722789742052555,
0.515460193157196,
-0.3476787209510803,
-0.2012544572353363,
-0.26754969358444214,
-0.9570048451423645,
-0.6652026176452637,
-0.20755721628665924,
-0.6488414406776428,
-0.1668703556060791,
0.20416827499866486,
1.1850770711898804,
0.7828965783119202,
-0.8022662401199341,
0.13017208874225616,
0.1465059071779251,
0.10737261921167374,
-0.22696331143379211,
-0.15053904056549072,
0.5698980093002319,
-0.08268261700868607,
-0.530548632144928,
0.5389997363090515,
0.6305602788925171,
-0.06637640297412872,
0.0717288926243782,
0.1387093961238861,
0.28346431255340576,
-0.010054378770291805,
0.5069813132286072,
0.5810881853103638,
-0.9170576930046082,
-0.3239806294441223,
-0.2765789330005646,
-0.16110756993293762,
0.5649194717407227,
0.8869228363037109,
-0.8909739851951599,
0.36501839756965637,
0.36411938071250916,
0.932085394859314,
0.2179844230413437,
0.5420980453491211,
0.15538525581359863,
-0.5911017656326294,
-0.32440122961997986,
0.4145091474056244,
0.2531109154224396,
0.5508856177330017,
-0.3496578633785248,
0.5143465995788574,
0.13625435531139374,
-0.7422571182250977,
-0.5172642469406128,
0.08733410388231277,
-0.9548889994621277,
-0.13080964982509613,
0.9049791097640991,
-0.38920602202415466,
-0.3046545088291168,
-0.61704021692276,
0.021694650873541832,
0.07196034491062164,
-0.43731990456581116,
0.9465473890304565,
0.16268114745616913,
-0.8138575553894043,
0.019968101754784584,
-0.6084722280502319,
0.2767846882343292,
0.012022431008517742,
-1.274678349494934,
-0.1688581258058548,
0.7022871375083923,
0.36948999762535095,
-0.009590198285877705,
1.0371475219726562,
-0.39054590463638306,
0.04314219951629639,
-0.4664023816585541,
-0.0414036400616169,
-0.16668421030044556,
-0.2319798618555069,
-0.5720864534378052,
0.43402743339538574,
0.15791745483875275,
-0.49504825472831726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.17606v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.17606v1
|
SetCSE: Set Operations using Contrastive Learning of Sentence Embeddings
| 2024-04-25T02:05:30 | 2024-04-25T02:05:30 |
Kang Liu
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Taking inspiration from Set Theory, we introduce SetCSE, an innovative
information retrieval framework. SetCSE employs sets to represent complex
semantics and incorporates well-defined operations for structured information
querying under the provided context. Within this framework, we introduce an
inter-set contrastive learning objective to enhance comprehension of sentence
embedding models concerning the given semantics. Furthermore, we present a
suite of operations, including SetCSE intersection, difference, and operation
series, that leverage sentence embeddings of the enhanced model for complex
sentence retrieval tasks. Throughout this paper, we demonstrate that SetCSE
adheres to the conventions of human language expressions regarding compounded
semantics, provides a significant enhancement in the discriminatory capability
of underlying sentence embedding models, and enables numerous information
retrieval tasks involving convoluted and intricate prompts which cannot be
achieved using existing querying methods.
|
[
-0.24909190833568573,
-0.6818075180053711,
0.3097745180130005,
0.395157128572464,
-0.10992171615362167,
0.31830286979675293,
-0.18792657554149628,
-0.24933043122291565,
0.310940682888031,
0.7772794365882874,
-0.5800559520721436,
-0.6858406066894531,
-0.543337881565094,
-0.02792167477309704,
-0.6045548319816589,
0.6012442708015442,
0.048718176782131195,
0.2058234065771103,
0.020470069721341133,
-0.2841552197933197,
-0.324297696352005,
-0.3426446318626404,
-0.32714784145355225,
0.021001409739255905,
0.4072033166885376,
0.5224042534828186,
0.8512163758277893,
0.5212284326553345,
0.9638693928718567,
0.256461501121521,
0.040125373750925064,
0.24933092296123505,
-0.7038699388504028,
0.3059229850769043,
-0.45742297172546387,
-0.569017767906189,
0.6519066095352173,
-0.0828203335404396,
0.49454236030578613,
1.0292006731033325,
0.05957530438899994,
-0.4721064567565918,
-0.054140202701091766,
0.6530264616012573,
-1.042203664779663,
0.006135960109531879,
-0.6769862174987793,
0.3720749020576477,
0.13989512622356415,
-0.29054275155067444,
-0.4140418469905853,
-0.3334228992462158,
0.3242291808128357,
-0.86983722448349,
0.14610789716243744,
0.25586310029029846,
0.6463001370429993,
0.25729721784591675,
-0.5960370302200317,
-0.7281789183616638,
-0.32272961735725403,
0.7423325777053833,
-0.5278851389884949,
0.35990989208221436,
0.20607872307300568,
0.2781895697116852,
-0.14933951199054718,
-1.1624197959899902,
-0.5456351041793823,
-0.40814149379730225,
-0.3849693536758423,
0.17037582397460938,
0.10417197644710541,
0.2160232812166214,
0.47578462958335876,
0.71872878074646,
-0.25328436493873596,
0.08084727823734283,
-0.18704310059547424,
0.17279784381389618,
0.18349406123161316,
0.02758503146469593,
0.46283870935440063,
0.017090478911995888,
-0.5139287114143372,
-0.029416123405098915,
-0.7826306223869324,
0.010827618651092052,
0.12265171110630035,
0.47013330459594727,
0.11709585785865784,
0.674267590045929,
-0.4457141160964966,
0.5728648900985718,
-0.010263727977871895,
0.4702710807323456,
0.1004628986120224,
-0.14805462956428528,
-0.21545417606830597,
0.03513769432902336,
0.42625004053115845,
0.1736387014389038,
0.0392431914806366,
-0.42802903056144714,
-0.26364651322364807,
0.061099760234355927,
0.26621192693710327,
-0.7775698304176331,
-0.24607153236865997,
-0.09368060529232025,
-0.32889923453330994,
-0.4932367205619812,
0.5610167384147644,
-0.44727790355682373,
-0.2464892864227295,
-0.4723066985607147,
0.5091279745101929,
-0.528967559337616,
0.3201570510864258,
0.14298121631145477,
-0.3154210150241852,
0.23224692046642303,
-0.018475761637091637,
-0.680456280708313,
0.7775616645812988,
0.5208318829536438,
0.42589443922042847,
-0.107935331761837,
-0.04197314381599426,
-0.822409987449646,
0.27688732743263245,
-0.34241825342178345,
0.6139163374900818,
-1.2452285289764404,
-0.5196971893310547,
0.3739524185657501,
0.20051825046539307,
0.03178714960813522,
-0.6555200219154358,
0.671109139919281,
-0.7806366086006165,
0.3201579451560974,
-0.5608548521995544,
-0.8011609315872192,
-0.19304993748664856,
0.29707252979278564,
-0.7775766849517822,
0.9462248682975769,
-0.102095827460289,
-0.7598631978034973,
0.17344146966934204,
-0.8807685375213623,
-0.6385663151741028,
0.20425713062286377,
-0.33000269532203674,
-0.096047542989254,
-0.015080706216394901,
0.14736655354499817,
0.23002725839614868,
-0.16717153787612915,
-0.06531381607055664,
-0.2999778985977173,
-0.624797523021698,
0.0082492521032691,
0.08001593500375748,
0.8402730822563171,
0.16873539984226227,
-0.3098556399345398,
0.040578242391347885,
-0.3374828100204468,
0.12165284156799316,
-0.1962408423423767,
-0.16632379591464996,
-0.6888257265090942,
0.1921745240688324,
-0.17613814771175385,
0.21104426681995392,
0.25280728936195374,
-0.5089274048805237,
0.21979935467243195,
-0.428195595741272,
0.38195711374282837,
0.36881446838378906,
0.21133558452129364,
0.23646864295005798,
-0.0300751905888319,
0.2673591077327728,
0.534785807132721,
-0.17628730833530426,
-0.23047156631946564,
0.1741178035736084,
-0.6599393486976624,
-0.04405554383993149,
0.242970809340477,
0.8617312908172607,
-0.9789412021636963,
0.592086911201477,
0.009062913246452808,
-0.18621474504470825,
-0.5733270645141602,
-0.1757785677909851,
0.7051308751106262,
0.3525589406490326,
0.44594040513038635,
0.24863047897815704,
-0.6063730716705322,
-1.3142880201339722,
-0.3583599030971527,
0.44437283277511597,
0.18250901997089386,
0.3557618260383606,
0.44956421852111816,
0.1515507847070694,
0.7013054490089417,
-1.0110533237457275,
0.11629125475883484,
0.29790323972702026,
0.0355033352971077,
-0.0615110844373703,
0.6558451652526855,
0.24440184235572815,
-1.4070584774017334,
-0.3989233076572418,
0.12348725646734238,
-1.0629116296768188,
0.012586279772222042,
0.2605355978012085,
-0.35757261514663696,
-0.36342933773994446,
1.0284843444824219,
-0.2319416105747223,
0.5506852865219116,
0.13411523401737213,
-0.38613632321357727,
0.3243882954120636,
-0.14060568809509277,
0.7124866843223572,
-1.279273509979248,
-0.005219772923737764,
-0.21452157199382782,
-0.27758046984672546,
-0.3989992141723633,
0.5885804891586304,
0.08063240349292755,
-0.32286038994789124,
-0.39893293380737305,
0.08278225362300873,
-0.3794509768486023,
-0.3636305332183838,
0.038314081728458405,
0.6622226238250732,
0.22545954585075378,
0.2206951081752777,
-0.052277591079473495,
0.8236751556396484,
0.5834795236587524,
-0.7234666347503662,
0.3340740501880646,
0.4148196876049042,
-0.3796265125274658,
0.8033674359321594,
-0.6510710716247559,
-0.15295371413230896,
0.014208231121301651,
-0.03417331352829933,
-0.8439680337905884,
0.12945380806922913,
-0.0805547758936882,
-0.11259723454713821,
0.12833061814308167,
0.29761749505996704,
-0.5063679814338684,
-0.21265779435634613,
-0.5345184206962585,
0.3081369400024414,
0.12994790077209473,
-1.011568307876587,
0.17179495096206665,
0.1849517822265625,
0.1090460866689682,
-1.1542551517486572,
-0.5971444845199585,
0.07843219488859177,
-0.06960465759038925,
-0.6032790541648865,
0.6793862581253052,
-0.2347079962491989,
-0.66560959815979,
0.14745847880840302,
0.03339028358459473,
-0.2956993877887726,
0.08917923271656036,
-0.11720641702413559,
0.1264277696609497,
-0.27853500843048096,
0.5730122923851013,
0.3972491919994354,
0.17420172691345215,
-0.4246339201927185,
-0.27285951375961304,
0.4697951376438141,
0.013949288986623287,
-0.3069073259830475,
0.02330899052321911,
0.7968302965164185,
-0.024407342076301575,
-0.30110445618629456,
0.5699171423912048,
0.46887171268463135,
-0.7126414775848389,
-0.08203821629285812,
-0.484235942363739,
-0.44148018956184387,
-0.46594250202178955,
0.5542481541633606,
-0.8872518539428711,
-1.1020416021347046,
0.5715376138687134,
-0.027777500450611115,
0.188648521900177,
0.36737021803855896,
0.08557510375976562,
-0.23460189998149872,
0.7245768308639526,
0.36222967505455017,
0.4035910665988922,
0.4850703179836273,
-0.052121423184871674,
0.34312689304351807,
-0.7712804675102234,
-0.25028765201568604,
-0.6828148365020752,
-0.32534316182136536,
-0.7739664912223816,
-0.08265238255262375,
0.2222384512424469,
0.5931832194328308,
-0.30505022406578064,
0.1606503278017044,
-0.46906721591949463,
0.8844309449195862,
0.52095627784729,
0.6860843896865845,
0.44175633788108826,
0.043205685913562775,
0.030941657721996307,
-0.06086139753460884,
-0.34481602907180786,
-0.4371822774410248,
0.6685611605644226,
-0.42374083399772644,
0.6167171597480774,
0.2505858838558197,
0.5390819311141968,
0.7942736744880676,
-0.2788908779621124,
-0.6407442688941956,
0.6125207543373108,
-0.807665228843689,
-0.17031961679458618,
0.021633367985486984,
-0.3903099000453949,
-1.0381475687026978,
0.3954763114452362,
-0.40467751026153564,
-0.5631940960884094,
0.35214680433273315,
-0.13391627371311188,
0.1413230001926422,
0.21360309422016144,
-0.7141771912574768,
0.7867162227630615,
0.17865319550037384,
-0.3586617410182953,
-0.6419573426246643,
-0.8837687969207764,
0.25937992334365845,
0.24212312698364258,
-0.2332787960767746,
0.18213070929050446,
-0.3251611292362213,
0.6074211597442627,
-0.37259814143180847,
0.610820472240448,
0.0657026469707489,
0.22388909757137299,
0.08620946854352951,
0.2794654667377472,
0.49350833892822266,
0.0800551176071167,
-0.26578232645988464,
-0.3520933985710144,
-0.02087089791893959,
-0.6512168645858765,
-0.8142375349998474,
1.2430309057235718,
-0.501548707485199,
-0.42078423500061035,
-0.0804002583026886,
-0.6515026092529297,
-0.22620239853858948,
0.31522074341773987,
0.21826407313346863,
0.7753371596336365,
-0.4892481863498688,
0.3926111161708832,
0.8709779381752014,
0.04537516459822655,
0.48922818899154663,
0.3908139765262604,
0.010665392503142357,
-0.04748391732573509,
0.707995593547821,
-0.1333770602941513,
0.5465200543403625,
1.0034734010696411,
-0.11969615519046783,
-0.17885932326316833,
-0.3549095094203949,
0.1625930368900299,
0.14673398435115814,
-1.0742106437683105,
-0.12712348997592926,
-0.6449522376060486,
0.017927011474967003,
-0.42052510380744934,
-0.5035673379898071,
0.24642865359783173,
-0.6615742444992065,
-0.2651231288909912,
-0.25582677125930786,
0.1407264769077301,
0.7652890682220459,
0.22452251613140106,
0.4688953161239624,
-0.4039188027381897,
0.3796495795249939,
0.161647766828537,
0.27797913551330566,
-0.6817041635513306,
-0.13944028317928314,
-0.22303007543087006,
-0.008761678822338581,
-0.2984478175640106,
-0.8056750893592834,
-0.10175830870866776,
0.15945439040660858,
0.5109587907791138,
0.32975783944129944,
0.2943626344203949,
0.5645285844802856,
-0.15396259725093842,
0.762613832950592,
-0.023533014580607414,
-1.031499981880188,
0.4320759177207947,
-0.1409379094839096,
0.02634086087346077,
0.7817375063896179,
0.40717676281929016,
-0.6451376676559448,
-0.04572566971182823,
-0.7393342852592468,
-0.6771531105041504,
0.613317608833313,
0.3312772810459137,
-0.18815769255161285,
-0.3964584469795227,
0.5901296138763428,
0.016599813476204872,
0.41510334610939026,
-0.6186508536338806,
-0.035272225737571716,
-0.01036021113395691,
-0.46585696935653687,
0.2865908741950989,
-0.22385843098163605,
-0.15958550572395325,
0.2961847484111786,
0.8162058591842651,
-0.19980908930301666,
0.08101940900087357,
0.18184804916381836,
-0.4037495255470276,
0.30495718121528625,
0.3443647623062134,
0.11051002144813538,
0.46190330386161804,
-0.027491139248013496,
0.17642243206501007,
0.08259125053882599,
-0.11569167673587799,
-0.3776182532310486,
0.2680455446243286,
-0.032942451536655426,
-0.26032325625419617,
0.36255118250846863,
0.6972275376319885,
0.6070225834846497,
-0.9042893648147583,
0.6046733260154724,
0.23840095102787018,
0.10713852196931839,
-0.2259581983089447,
-0.03663582354784012,
-0.11360128968954086,
0.182939812541008,
-0.0971570834517479,
-0.1890646070241928,
0.7606596946716309,
-0.5843778848648071,
0.34857574105262756,
0.47992709279060364,
-0.7089295387268066,
0.25615862011909485,
-0.019346587359905243,
0.21496763825416565,
-0.364595890045166,
0.8263285160064697,
-0.13762207329273224,
-0.40911805629730225,
0.6907268762588501,
0.6762240529060364,
0.5218092203140259,
-0.33640503883361816,
0.05609077587723732,
0.19144779443740845,
0.21811918914318085,
0.011745637282729149,
0.501926064491272,
-0.1941341906785965,
-0.709071159362793,
-0.10286731272935867,
-0.0962376743555069,
-0.3543636202812195,
-0.42339760065078735,
-0.9184091687202454,
0.5152414441108704,
-0.3581961989402771,
0.5688362121582031,
-0.08926007896661758,
-0.023239489644765854,
-0.40098685026168823,
0.42750057578086853,
-0.39374327659606934,
0.925102174282074,
-0.6276205778121948,
0.29408374428749084,
0.582623302936554,
-0.7609187364578247,
-0.4124976396560669,
0.08138266950845718,
-0.5218544006347656,
-0.7572278380393982,
0.7082319855690002,
0.3343175947666168,
-0.26084721088409424,
0.1578584462404251,
-0.7789223790168762,
-0.44528236985206604,
0.8494147062301636,
0.12455540895462036,
-0.5632010698318481,
-0.2493402659893036,
-0.09347795695066452,
0.3678703010082245,
-0.8849751949310303,
0.39174413681030273,
0.5799677968025208,
0.41783225536346436,
0.06841211766004562,
-0.4778776466846466,
0.0838780626654625,
-0.15246795117855072,
0.037301503121852875,
0.40202340483665466,
-0.37864089012145996,
0.6754342317581177,
-0.10327639430761337,
-0.18756203353405,
-0.009340813383460045,
0.5381463170051575,
-0.15637226402759552,
0.12091241776943207,
0.4558894634246826,
0.5849065184593201,
0.7579119801521301,
-0.29360315203666687,
1.1068611145019531,
-0.26318225264549255,
0.29351672530174255,
1.31593656539917,
-0.23115037381649017,
0.9057579040527344,
0.3807544410228729,
-0.013362417928874493,
0.7096960544586182,
0.4057527482509613,
0.23305009305477142,
0.5760571360588074,
0.2945253849029541,
-0.6425506472587585,
-0.3676477372646332,
-0.3057192265987396,
-0.1176893562078476,
0.03635716065764427,
0.7027639746665955,
-0.586056649684906,
-0.20389339327812195,
0.2179144024848938,
-0.08264556527137756,
0.704372227191925,
-0.3557448983192444,
0.9341422319412231,
-0.02365887723863125,
-0.526171088218689,
0.1555502712726593,
-0.20890384912490845,
0.4654656946659088,
-0.7017550468444824,
-0.3477959930896759,
0.05715179070830345,
0.23821043968200684,
-0.45513036847114563,
-0.9801287651062012,
0.31431230902671814,
-0.7023182511329651,
-0.3886371850967407,
0.3940046727657318,
0.5193511843681335,
-0.6586924195289612,
-0.40321940183639526,
0.2789912521839142,
0.19682380557060242,
0.0689251720905304,
-0.016738038510084152,
-0.7183997631072998,
-0.16701821982860565,
0.15970829129219055,
0.0705135315656662,
-0.055581700056791306,
0.5559735298156738,
-0.17704728245735168,
0.5138036608695984,
0.4981989860534668,
-0.40248972177505493,
-0.01351427286863327,
0.2170865386724472,
0.9503119587898254,
-0.9112580418586731,
-0.6904791593551636,
-0.4532534182071686,
0.17067964375019073,
-0.5806805491447449,
-0.06320042163133621,
0.3484671711921692,
0.8454280495643616,
0.6502084732055664,
0.012975923717021942,
0.883960485458374,
-0.1569860279560089,
0.5821244716644287,
-0.6949998140335083,
-0.14020836353302002,
-0.33519691228866577,
0.44225797057151794,
-0.09089689701795578,
-0.9145958423614502,
-0.4140985310077667,
0.5380048751831055,
-0.48182788491249084,
0.02184540033340454,
1.139570713043213,
0.8882872462272644,
-0.25865310430526733,
0.3808731734752655,
0.23496651649475098,
0.2647862434387207,
0.4129791557788849,
0.45030754804611206,
0.5322215557098389,
-0.6139962673187256,
0.4807174801826477,
-0.1644166260957718,
-0.1663682460784912,
-0.15934881567955017,
-0.5680636167526245,
-0.8335239291191101,
-0.594804584980011,
-0.21030962467193604,
-0.4480394423007965,
0.5765012502670288,
1.0706253051757812,
0.4469366669654846,
-0.7053846120834351,
-0.13135282695293427,
-0.22962526977062225,
0.07237204164266586,
-0.18799541890621185,
-0.27613773941993713,
0.6052389740943909,
-0.6938421130180359,
-0.9685174226760864,
0.48000022768974304,
0.184764564037323,
-0.17893864214420319,
-0.014322420582175255,
0.07744427025318146,
-0.6275625228881836,
0.14447246491909027,
0.675284743309021,
0.17658631503582,
-0.42900919914245605,
-0.339790016412735,
-0.12243382632732391,
-0.1539696604013443,
0.10159183293581009,
1.265638828277588,
-0.7937288880348206,
0.3789418935775757,
0.4770573675632477,
0.744575560092926,
0.5826401710510254,
0.05490652844309807,
0.3963589072227478,
-0.9283323884010315,
0.23588751256465912,
0.37609240412712097,
0.5602614283561707,
0.40413230657577515,
-0.554780125617981,
0.6765155792236328,
0.25162509083747864,
-0.2858281135559082,
-0.3703707456588745,
0.6976653933525085,
-1.20015287399292,
-0.38539984822273254,
0.7187642455101013,
-0.27201327681541443,
0.06525053828954697,
-0.16682520508766174,
-0.3733675479888916,
0.0816701203584671,
-0.3404146134853363,
0.49197903275489807,
0.5526083111763,
0.10488582402467728,
0.0561375729739666,
0.1928982436656952,
0.11251243948936462,
0.5084028244018555,
-1.1752127408981323,
-0.06347782164812088,
0.6991089582443237,
0.026434751227498055,
0.08651001006364822,
0.09578153491020203,
-0.39610499143600464,
0.26600223779678345,
-0.03562410920858383,
0.05691256374120712,
-0.015232346951961517,
0.01657741703093052,
-0.01228557713329792,
0.4559997618198395,
-0.3109023869037628,
-0.23825009167194366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16262v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16262v1
|
Interpreting Answers to Yes-No Questions in Dialogues from Multiple Domains
| 2024-04-25T00:13:00 | 2024-04-25T00:13:00 |
Zijie Wang, Farzana Rashid, Eduardo Blanco
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
People often answer yes-no questions without explicitly saying yes, no, or
similar polar keywords. Figuring out the meaning of indirect answers is
challenging, even for large language models. In this paper, we investigate this
problem working with dialogues from multiple domains. We present new benchmarks
in three diverse domains: movie scripts, tennis interviews, and airline
customer service. We present an approach grounded on distant supervision and
blended training to quickly adapt to a new dialogue domain. Experimental
results show that our approach is never detrimental and yields F1 improvements
as high as 11-34%.
|
[
-0.5286862850189209,
-1.0348002910614014,
0.7806907892227173,
0.14648279547691345,
0.0008218772709369659,
0.05110911279916763,
-0.22005094587802887,
-0.516505777835846,
-0.018307585269212723,
0.5076979398727417,
-1.0311903953552246,
-0.023623712360858917,
-0.5554085969924927,
0.29038184881210327,
-0.08207456767559052,
1.2110809087753296,
-0.23544545471668243,
0.36862462759017944,
-0.37269327044487,
-0.6428537368774414,
-0.717426598072052,
-0.6188246011734009,
-0.5423387885093689,
-0.10760798305273056,
0.3035295903682709,
0.6600232124328613,
0.6494188904762268,
-0.03936993330717087,
0.3829425573348999,
0.2846009135246277,
0.19751127064228058,
0.39794161915779114,
-0.3906552791595459,
0.4908577799797058,
-0.2746991217136383,
-0.5473377108573914,
-0.3150324821472168,
0.09012036770582199,
0.4262576699256897,
1.2163851261138916,
0.21683593094348907,
0.2241966873407364,
-0.14896392822265625,
0.35044270753860474,
-0.4300066828727722,
0.20263515412807465,
-0.6138042211532593,
0.09657540917396545,
0.197385773062706,
-0.319435179233551,
-0.3104534447193146,
-0.34608909487724304,
0.5247145295143127,
-0.6669189929962158,
0.3472040593624115,
-0.17292778193950653,
1.028259515762329,
-0.09787965565919876,
-0.8007638454437256,
-0.3258689343929291,
-0.9486603140830994,
0.9882065057754517,
-0.4510248005390167,
0.17026987671852112,
0.3998034596443176,
0.47185757756233215,
0.05807428061962128,
-0.38113725185394287,
-0.5796986818313599,
-0.05731409415602684,
-0.20063559710979462,
0.24804165959358215,
0.12438750267028809,
-0.00958847627043724,
0.14355683326721191,
0.28806406259536743,
-0.16461019217967987,
-0.45106256008148193,
0.018443726003170013,
-0.016346562653779984,
0.4344644248485565,
0.23019549250602722,
0.08251304924488068,
0.2136622667312622,
-0.3041028380393982,
0.1390579789876938,
-0.4210160970687866,
0.04497881233692169,
0.29498860239982605,
0.2661787271499634,
-0.16851918399333954,
0.4368112087249756,
-0.3638594448566437,
0.5858320593833923,
0.37766820192337036,
-0.13875210285186768,
0.09645076096057892,
-0.6873523592948914,
-0.12280751764774323,
-0.2657824158668518,
0.1134045273065567,
0.4328572750091553,
0.19659662246704102,
-0.276154100894928,
0.13885559141635895,
-0.1345282793045044,
0.12453028559684753,
-0.5927941203117371,
0.1969539225101471,
0.39141395688056946,
-0.08592330664396286,
0.03422417864203453,
-0.03863904997706413,
-0.7679584622383118,
-0.20469245314598083,
-0.4097709357738495,
0.5495275855064392,
-0.14357605576515198,
-0.5084563493728638,
0.18602359294891357,
-0.34213685989379883,
0.7886517643928528,
0.7794569730758667,
-0.7414106130599976,
0.6216882467269897,
0.48219552636146545,
0.7147902250289917,
0.12197946012020111,
-0.190763920545578,
-1.1253650188446045,
0.05490283668041229,
-0.22112014889717102,
0.7603923678398132,
-0.5489153861999512,
-0.46356987953186035,
0.2331620454788208,
-0.09422160685062408,
-0.4859856367111206,
-0.7035133838653564,
0.41325801610946655,
-0.5095372796058655,
0.4443835914134979,
-0.19517892599105835,
-0.36228883266448975,
-0.09204138815402985,
0.46462270617485046,
-0.265306293964386,
0.7690466642379761,
0.25312551856040955,
-0.6755333542823792,
0.15399280190467834,
-0.6185458898544312,
-0.6515976786613464,
-0.15130841732025146,
-0.34271207451820374,
-0.2738075852394104,
0.0738421380519867,
0.19852076470851898,
0.36276721954345703,
-0.2571108639240265,
0.6176099181175232,
-0.4602615237236023,
-0.19510310888290405,
0.6563352942466736,
-0.29923778772354126,
0.6584228277206421,
-0.034443244338035583,
-0.5207771062850952,
0.019100386649370193,
-0.498066782951355,
0.13743287324905396,
-0.2594090700149536,
-0.007601103745400906,
-0.2207501083612442,
-0.336971253156662,
-0.19547361135482788,
0.4652249813079834,
-0.09237498044967651,
-0.6043396592140198,
0.2604619860649109,
-0.32248425483703613,
0.24128101766109467,
0.6539859175682068,
0.3797018229961395,
0.4882639944553375,
-0.4279067814350128,
0.7130883932113647,
0.29692983627319336,
0.10238497704267502,
-0.06737068295478821,
-0.8266268372535706,
-1.0896530151367188,
-0.020193830132484436,
-0.2441365122795105,
0.33038580417633057,
-1.1550712585449219,
-0.1764557957649231,
-0.16552259027957916,
-0.05381370708346367,
-0.5435842871665955,
0.1628933697938919,
0.15907511115074158,
0.6000078916549683,
0.3818510174751282,
-0.19659677147865295,
-0.2687470018863678,
-0.8869959115982056,
-0.5069593787193298,
-0.2184881567955017,
0.13386765122413635,
0.791978657245636,
0.5973300933837891,
0.09342597424983978,
0.8784383535385132,
-0.6209653615951538,
-0.279958039522171,
-0.2230520248413086,
0.2496754676103592,
0.3305530846118927,
0.13880756497383118,
0.4737730324268341,
-1.0610692501068115,
-0.8923442363739014,
0.17276747524738312,
-0.8568761348724365,
0.38353031873703003,
-0.5199484825134277,
-0.46276986598968506,
-0.24978436529636383,
0.19803476333618164,
-0.6356338858604431,
0.07779377698898315,
0.2897391617298126,
-0.2529565393924713,
0.5203460454940796,
0.16753770411014557,
0.09057046473026276,
-0.7393614053726196,
0.05427750572562218,
-0.018136896193027496,
-0.29075711965560913,
-1.1455087661743164,
0.090594083070755,
-0.38041388988494873,
0.02003193460404873,
-0.5968635678291321,
0.7011444568634033,
-0.46170976758003235,
0.11537138372659683,
0.10896409302949905,
0.230755016207695,
0.08793889731168747,
0.8334202170372009,
0.24388092756271362,
0.8004563450813293,
0.8214919567108154,
-0.6460499167442322,
0.24424020946025848,
0.7597441673278809,
-0.2838280498981476,
0.8507817387580872,
-0.4272739291191101,
0.5207561254501343,
-0.4650968015193939,
0.33113566040992737,
-1.230866551399231,
-0.4401281476020813,
0.21753838658332825,
-0.34541475772857666,
0.04420850798487663,
-0.19395175576210022,
-0.01815858483314514,
-0.059675708413124084,
-0.3447301983833313,
0.3052549660205841,
0.06846770644187927,
-0.5004760026931763,
0.7243455648422241,
0.07194116711616516,
-0.3535824120044708,
-0.6189239025115967,
-0.42368394136428833,
-0.057945989072322845,
-0.18193404376506805,
-0.6654173731803894,
0.10046666115522385,
-0.32271507382392883,
-0.4562969207763672,
-0.1392299383878708,
-0.5269210934638977,
-0.7671368718147278,
0.24786217510700226,
0.27772092819213867,
0.25532233715057373,
-0.658476710319519,
-0.19555144011974335,
0.18207481503486633,
0.23107954859733582,
0.08734209835529327,
-0.1966831237077713,
0.06495459377765656,
-0.12288821488618851,
-0.043845005333423615,
-0.2012779861688614,
0.863309919834137,
0.5253484845161438,
-0.1785774528980255,
0.8550559282302856,
0.45355096459388733,
-0.07830311357975006,
-0.2361312210559845,
-0.3815697431564331,
-0.17875899374485016,
-0.4768558442592621,
-0.06504172086715698,
-0.6435548663139343,
-1.1794670820236206,
0.4383416771888733,
-0.31027066707611084,
-0.035823993384838104,
0.19324439764022827,
0.6021242737770081,
0.014810420572757721,
0.801186203956604,
0.49026256799697876,
0.3996615409851074,
0.31102341413497925,
-0.2620304524898529,
0.5058693289756775,
-0.6518253087997437,
-0.2696698307991028,
-0.5216862559318542,
0.18645378947257996,
-0.40482279658317566,
-0.46605169773101807,
0.5304664373397827,
0.01747680827975273,
0.031563546508550644,
0.3431490957736969,
0.20361410081386566,
0.3354405164718628,
0.3965107202529907,
-0.0948263555765152,
0.3020571172237396,
-0.24628250300884247,
0.05092228204011917,
0.22730104625225067,
-0.6739993095397949,
-0.2257925122976303,
0.8121381998062134,
0.0825231596827507,
0.4447173774242401,
0.5217524766921997,
0.4312429130077362,
-0.08481384068727493,
0.70537269115448,
-0.5702086687088013,
0.403241902589798,
0.26863861083984375,
-1.2393381595611572,
-0.27498847246170044,
-0.4718332290649414,
-0.5764855146408081,
0.631130576133728,
-0.1201588362455368,
-0.7267724871635437,
0.20674419403076172,
-0.25966089963912964,
-0.6788665652275085,
0.06782827526330948,
-1.0436370372772217,
0.9621751308441162,
-0.1113358587026596,
-0.6070175170898438,
0.2520265281200409,
-0.9962831735610962,
0.518919825553894,
-0.30830714106559753,
0.30963706970214844,
-0.22140367329120636,
0.2649616003036499,
0.4834049642086029,
-0.21677044034004211,
0.8037248849868774,
-0.19650056958198547,
-0.09677597880363464,
0.6305623054504395,
-0.06979775428771973,
0.08733946084976196,
0.34581154584884644,
-0.24631573259830475,
-0.015516720712184906,
0.17899447679519653,
-0.4859500229358673,
-0.8671624660491943,
0.7996817231178284,
-0.9341622591018677,
-0.7321330308914185,
-0.44893863797187805,
-0.43613356351852417,
-0.7689546942710876,
0.17113825678825378,
-0.13322226703166962,
0.5255640149116516,
-0.001530168578028679,
-0.13601046800613403,
0.47932854294776917,
-0.47118309140205383,
0.16574187576770782,
0.7416635751724243,
0.1526774913072586,
-0.25438299775123596,
0.7555469274520874,
-0.09824695438146591,
0.6678347587585449,
0.5040549039840698,
-0.03939484804868698,
-0.5565717220306396,
-0.13046705722808838,
-0.6442404985427856,
0.4131498634815216,
-0.8840198516845703,
-0.1725669801235199,
-0.779228687286377,
-0.09561315178871155,
-0.41799724102020264,
0.03132738173007965,
0.030292101204395294,
-0.4890245199203491,
-0.11623820662498474,
-0.15197567641735077,
0.07276210188865662,
0.5918570756912231,
0.27373170852661133,
0.21883918344974518,
-0.642216145992279,
0.6383352279663086,
0.5146360993385315,
0.3771928548812866,
-0.11630737781524658,
-0.4556390941143036,
-0.306885302066803,
0.10528688877820969,
-0.42674314975738525,
-0.8246423602104187,
0.04746686667203903,
0.5762208700180054,
0.5291379690170288,
0.09057881683111191,
0.27235379815101624,
1.001992106437683,
-0.6254158020019531,
1.067379355430603,
0.016798298805952072,
-1.0005128383636475,
0.37936604022979736,
-0.30405193567276,
0.15473465621471405,
0.8741227388381958,
0.8067895174026489,
-0.5989189743995667,
-0.6141464114189148,
-0.5034184455871582,
-0.5934969186782837,
0.8488973379135132,
0.40072810649871826,
0.8354802131652832,
-0.014586139470338821,
0.42445817589759827,
0.41512054204940796,
0.5410946011543274,
-0.47891873121261597,
-0.7697553634643555,
-0.14396709203720093,
0.32133913040161133,
-0.09580264985561371,
0.08408896625041962,
-0.25618404150009155,
-0.210790753364563,
0.6309225559234619,
-0.30955129861831665,
0.6849221587181091,
0.29502758383750916,
0.061179183423519135,
-0.21905800700187683,
0.4719913899898529,
0.7166821360588074,
0.6081303358078003,
-0.3313004970550537,
0.27209195494651794,
0.048945456743240356,
-0.09830394387245178,
0.3322022557258606,
-0.13117769360542297,
0.244723379611969,
0.25386518239974976,
0.45807480812072754,
0.7548648118972778,
-0.10678179562091827,
-0.5616291761398315,
0.7682093381881714,
-0.2911522686481476,
-0.3464391231536865,
-0.06048184633255005,
0.02933979406952858,
-0.2678768038749695,
-0.19367489218711853,
0.26434326171875,
0.3217666745185852,
0.19742172956466675,
-0.900185227394104,
0.39771613478660583,
0.4447602331638336,
-0.5606264472007751,
-0.36733439564704895,
0.6867205500602722,
0.4694303870201111,
-0.14637768268585205,
0.5674430727958679,
0.02884172834455967,
-0.6174175143241882,
0.457881897687912,
0.3740154504776001,
0.9534754753112793,
-0.02631210908293724,
0.5415428876876831,
0.17757876217365265,
-0.19950541853904724,
0.31592878699302673,
0.10724777728319168,
-0.267769992351532,
-0.9841057062149048,
-0.7332251071929932,
-0.36162254214286804,
-0.9510881900787354,
0.21379517018795013,
-0.926227331161499,
0.09583400189876556,
-0.38217678666114807,
-0.05337293818593025,
0.595577597618103,
-0.30232444405555725,
-0.7363062500953674,
0.18176518380641937,
-0.06165941804647446,
0.500981330871582,
-0.9253563284873962,
0.9547428488731384,
0.778802216053009,
-0.6198464035987854,
-0.6528353095054626,
0.3335488736629486,
-0.1922924965620041,
-0.6462142467498779,
0.8614721894264221,
0.25469574332237244,
-0.39299604296684265,
-0.054904185235500336,
-0.433074027299881,
-0.4794237017631531,
0.5018930435180664,
0.3471410274505615,
-0.027730457484722137,
0.2368846833705902,
0.36861780285835266,
0.5455470681190491,
-0.3484616279602051,
0.5409982204437256,
0.47943878173828125,
0.15969955921173096,
0.024858426302671432,
-1.0202865600585938,
-0.25454020500183105,
-0.2199813574552536,
-0.39060449600219727,
-0.014229238033294678,
-0.8332182765007019,
0.5919478535652161,
-0.11208771169185638,
-0.12446454167366028,
0.36905986070632935,
0.4056077301502228,
-0.2969033122062683,
0.44660353660583496,
0.5071382522583008,
-0.28575125336647034,
0.5407063961029053,
-0.04735901951789856,
1.1353349685668945,
-0.2613399922847748,
0.45608949661254883,
1.3231106996536255,
-0.8201348185539246,
0.6531137228012085,
0.7875366806983948,
-0.020122982561588287,
0.640308678150177,
0.41182446479797363,
0.4624705910682678,
0.522570013999939,
0.092608243227005,
-0.7828294038772583,
-0.5720431208610535,
-0.5270237922668457,
-0.10412397235631943,
0.09114276617765427,
0.010048414580523968,
0.28706952929496765,
-0.4465336501598358,
0.12743918597698212,
-0.1583460122346878,
0.0915273129940033,
0.13056598603725433,
0.7290699481964111,
0.18184895813465118,
-1.046501636505127,
0.6238967180252075,
0.19658157229423523,
0.14354419708251953,
-0.5488682985305786,
-0.5049681663513184,
-0.6321672201156616,
0.1686079055070877,
-0.06103985384106636,
-0.8120365738868713,
0.30885523557662964,
0.2154867798089981,
0.0699925646185875,
-0.5136669278144836,
0.31560587882995605,
-0.5566669702529907,
-0.1573772430419922,
0.21588239073753357,
0.7468349933624268,
0.13555416464805603,
0.14090947806835175,
-0.6389528512954712,
-0.2612028121948242,
0.025029711425304413,
0.17500177025794983,
0.3168984055519104,
0.45152711868286133,
0.05878058820962906,
0.5319526195526123,
0.5064745545387268,
-0.3973500430583954,
0.35005220770835876,
0.1061977669596672,
0.9235893487930298,
-0.3352168798446655,
-0.17325057089328766,
-0.48510345816612244,
0.38390129804611206,
-0.0842917412519455,
-0.5748944878578186,
1.177085041999817,
0.3942846357822418,
1.166258454322815,
-0.264847993850708,
0.8045482039451599,
0.000263875350356102,
0.47828418016433716,
-0.32419896125793457,
-0.18359485268592834,
-0.4353814125061035,
0.21861498057842255,
-0.4755217730998993,
-0.8981173038482666,
-0.5373789072036743,
0.6887716054916382,
-0.6147223711013794,
-0.030595336109399796,
0.932358980178833,
0.5090451240539551,
-0.20601218938827515,
0.3680819272994995,
0.4068547785282135,
0.07577595859766006,
0.41333267092704773,
0.3722243309020996,
1.3797786235809326,
-0.49425238370895386,
0.45137545466423035,
-0.36520007252693176,
0.04159175232052803,
-0.10923582315444946,
-0.48274052143096924,
-0.9142119288444519,
-0.24410034716129303,
-0.7195647954940796,
-0.4736602008342743,
0.10000651329755783,
0.6581758856773376,
0.8361340761184692,
-1.0473982095718384,
-0.3990413248538971,
0.08303127437829971,
0.3422418534755707,
-0.4943736493587494,
-0.25734812021255493,
0.1322503536939621,
-0.35845300555229187,
-0.6177578568458557,
0.4403420090675354,
0.26700642704963684,
-0.10150633752346039,
-0.0728471577167511,
-0.02635461650788784,
-0.43933671712875366,
0.3402612507343292,
0.5884274244308472,
-0.03669389337301254,
-0.5815907716751099,
-0.7635210752487183,
0.3153880834579468,
0.14288273453712463,
0.37237995862960815,
0.9558447003364563,
-0.30641013383865356,
0.41926783323287964,
-0.15922081470489502,
0.9414018988609314,
0.7240858674049377,
0.2508283853530884,
0.5596967339515686,
-0.9251034259796143,
-0.011285031214356422,
0.1768900752067566,
-0.12995833158493042,
0.3902018368244171,
-0.34125837683677673,
0.44216078519821167,
0.37694090604782104,
-0.23392373323440552,
-0.6909985542297363,
0.4031662344932556,
-1.041965365409851,
-0.14264918863773346,
1.2804362773895264,
-0.4957743287086487,
0.06631205230951309,
-0.5795449614524841,
-0.3285236656665802,
-0.17630301415920258,
-0.14522498846054077,
0.1907038688659668,
0.9671856760978699,
-0.5713543891906738,
0.24070823192596436,
-0.8524280190467834,
0.3532860279083252,
0.8229137659072876,
-0.7538549900054932,
-0.002875886857509613,
0.37907469272613525,
0.5141381025314331,
0.10920768976211548,
0.9587503671646118,
0.24541915953159332,
0.13836583495140076,
-0.07238811254501343,
-0.6419844627380371,
0.568331778049469,
-0.5977556705474854,
-0.5119731426239014,
0.1331680417060852,
0.31789281964302063,
-0.1453074961900711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16257v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16257v1
|
Translation of Multifaceted Data without Re-Training of Machine Translation Systems
| 2024-04-25T00:05:19 | 2024-04-25T00:05:19 |
Hyeonseok Moon, Seungyoon Lee, Seongtae Hong, Seungjun Lee, Chanjun Park, Heuiseok Lim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Translating major language resources to build minor language resources
becomes a widely-used approach. Particularly in translating complex data points
composed of multiple components, it is common to translate each component
separately. However, we argue that this practice often overlooks the
interrelation between components within the same data point. To address this
limitation, we propose a novel MT pipeline that considers the intra-data
relation in implementing MT for training data. In our MT pipeline, all the
components in a data point are concatenated to form a single translation
sequence and subsequently reconstructed to the data components after
translation. We introduce a Catalyst Statement (CS) to enhance the intra-data
relation, and Indicator Token (IT) to assist the decomposition of a translated
sequence into its respective data components. Through our approach, we have
achieved a considerable improvement in translation quality itself, along with
its effectiveness as training data. Compared with the conventional approach
that translates each data component separately, our method yields better
training data that enhances the performance of the trained model by 2.690
points for the web page ranking (WPR) task, and 0.845 for the question
generation (QG) task in the XGLUE benchmark.
|
[
-0.3308146595954895,
-0.40585145354270935,
0.4197898507118225,
0.18425625562667847,
-0.42612406611442566,
0.26464253664016724,
-0.32601529359817505,
0.030674025416374207,
0.21979330480098724,
0.43906542658805847,
-0.7394427061080933,
-0.4621865749359131,
-0.555038571357727,
0.2218482941389084,
-0.5713445544242859,
1.1588555574417114,
-0.11126499623060226,
0.29982730746269226,
-0.10162574052810669,
-0.3258261978626251,
-0.434170126914978,
-0.5985089540481567,
-0.5256380438804626,
-0.09072719514369965,
0.7889662384986877,
0.40658095479011536,
0.4135816991329193,
0.7747818231582642,
0.5226667523384094,
0.31356653571128845,
0.4009723663330078,
0.46002495288848877,
-0.4267686605453491,
0.11329341679811478,
-0.13758762180805206,
-0.6595919132232666,
-0.4766424298286438,
0.05364849418401718,
0.9499551653862,
1.1126044988632202,
0.3426930606365204,
0.22015053033828735,
0.3537140488624573,
0.7265807390213013,
-0.3565855026245117,
0.2433956265449524,
-0.6285958290100098,
0.1473502665758133,
-0.4201919138431549,
-0.5676323771476746,
-0.6426620483398438,
-0.25964003801345825,
-0.1743796020746231,
-0.5090522170066833,
0.31175628304481506,
0.07254000008106232,
0.4102602005004883,
0.36968037486076355,
-0.701440691947937,
0.07945872843265533,
-0.6637606024742126,
0.8190452456474304,
-0.4648885130882263,
0.4076504111289978,
-0.044897500425577164,
0.34164300560951233,
-0.25317123532295227,
-0.652797281742096,
-0.774224042892456,
0.2671879231929779,
-0.13290943205356598,
0.20705971121788025,
0.04315393790602684,
-0.20097854733467102,
0.09010344743728638,
0.3723808526992798,
-0.560301661491394,
-0.1092061772942543,
-0.36038777232170105,
-0.12695080041885376,
0.38258448243141174,
0.3805162012577057,
0.11093302816152573,
-0.05655539780855179,
-0.3559606373310089,
-0.4359736442565918,
-0.8244285583496094,
-0.011104902252554893,
0.2863549292087555,
1.0189458131790161,
0.06813293695449829,
0.6942771077156067,
-0.31380513310432434,
0.3067242205142975,
-0.17562124133110046,
-0.11350509524345398,
0.657555878162384,
-0.5251466631889343,
0.06880881637334824,
0.06318952143192291,
0.7917987704277039,
0.3155844807624817,
-0.039471812546253204,
-0.5180222988128662,
-0.004604436457157135,
0.10789995640516281,
0.25090691447257996,
-0.8588951826095581,
-0.057543884962797165,
0.3603622019290924,
-0.17274542152881622,
-0.03774131461977959,
0.21957039833068848,
-0.5554386973381042,
0.05095013231039047,
-0.40051308274269104,
0.12911416590213776,
-0.12383382022380829,
-0.2786823809146881,
-0.15032988786697388,
-0.031973354518413544,
-0.05465200915932655,
0.20520704984664917,
-0.5588900446891785,
0.018147390335798264,
0.7110001444816589,
0.8389862775802612,
-0.35540971159935,
-0.409404456615448,
-0.943437397480011,
0.27210697531700134,
-0.4098806083202362,
0.7311407327651978,
-0.44700369238853455,
-0.17713187634944916,
0.07995059341192245,
0.2593769431114197,
-0.1566668152809143,
-0.487129807472229,
0.5133853554725647,
-0.2853756248950958,
0.2723594009876251,
-0.4195398986339569,
-0.3554167151451111,
-0.11978447437286377,
0.19636204838752747,
-0.4841492176055908,
0.8468520641326904,
0.211968794465065,
-0.6864501237869263,
0.5208725333213806,
-0.5792861580848694,
-0.47938069701194763,
-0.0022382428869605064,
-0.07867946475744247,
-0.28787174820899963,
0.11132442206144333,
0.27878257632255554,
0.3364591896533966,
-0.36814749240875244,
0.1805974841117859,
-0.3733433783054352,
-0.10051701217889786,
0.3196760416030884,
-0.35505548119544983,
0.45029911398887634,
0.08401378244161606,
-0.041892144829034805,
0.24351006746292114,
-0.6653753519058228,
0.14084507524967194,
-0.2353420853614807,
-0.6701052188873291,
-0.1531856656074524,
-0.09319542348384857,
0.007614468224346638,
0.6571002006530762,
0.12026490271091461,
-0.5936657190322876,
0.5716489553451538,
-0.1780768483877182,
0.27183273434638977,
0.6837055087089539,
-0.14546987414360046,
0.5466510653495789,
-0.02912997081875801,
0.419443815946579,
0.37352630496025085,
-0.111664779484272,
-0.14370116591453552,
-0.5218946933746338,
-1.0268930196762085,
-0.05804399028420448,
0.2999327778816223,
0.5640811920166016,
-1.1081044673919678,
0.2131965160369873,
-0.8510234951972961,
-0.30005204677581787,
-0.8164540529251099,
0.18040500581264496,
0.5204912424087524,
0.7610639333724976,
0.7241037487983704,
-0.28341665863990784,
-0.4717138409614563,
-0.6764508485794067,
-0.09497269243001938,
0.04677416756749153,
-0.06461327522993088,
-0.11888203769922256,
0.27212685346603394,
-0.044777028262615204,
0.608275830745697,
-0.4365488886833191,
-0.4467014670372009,
-0.35904571413993835,
0.35730311274528503,
0.2951784133911133,
0.8143975138664246,
0.18268786370754242,
-0.6604909896850586,
-0.7587763667106628,
0.2796226441860199,
-0.7985182404518127,
0.0014030386228114367,
-0.04178089648485184,
-0.34945109486579895,
-0.012312300503253937,
0.4509188234806061,
-0.477172315120697,
0.2144656777381897,
0.43414491415023804,
0.005047567654401064,
0.19171401858329773,
-0.0625891387462616,
0.3671318292617798,
-1.181281566619873,
0.4079562723636627,
-0.15931522846221924,
-0.2575816512107849,
-0.6606876850128174,
0.12200455367565155,
0.0523887500166893,
-0.14196300506591797,
-0.5111230611801147,
0.4555090665817261,
-0.17261479794979095,
-0.07283014059066772,
-0.22647444903850555,
0.08401425182819366,
-0.0558600090444088,
0.6691785454750061,
-0.09486149996519089,
0.8281539082527161,
0.37152111530303955,
-0.5450232625007629,
0.23446789383888245,
0.5692459344863892,
-0.11116176843643188,
0.8414245247840881,
-0.277729868888855,
0.13536259531974792,
-0.2074907124042511,
0.22665593028068542,
-0.8372958898544312,
-0.03061840683221817,
0.4557253420352936,
-0.4568867087364197,
0.3271608352661133,
-0.46060267090797424,
-0.7361786961555481,
-0.17282462120056152,
-0.07936997711658478,
0.3209415674209595,
0.21309730410575867,
-0.3461778461933136,
0.22089135646820068,
0.1461624950170517,
-0.3507561981678009,
-0.604009747505188,
-0.7014447450637817,
0.17212307453155518,
-0.3928314745426178,
-0.6402156949043274,
0.3069205582141876,
-0.11203522980213165,
0.22625137865543365,
0.042468052357435226,
-0.07357358932495117,
-0.1980566382408142,
-0.15923810005187988,
0.04478619992733002,
0.031710512936115265,
-0.2594550848007202,
0.17673607170581818,
0.2004089206457138,
-0.5823146104812622,
-0.05696749687194824,
-0.5054503679275513,
0.4053086042404175,
0.21720805764198303,
-0.336538702249527,
-0.3657649755477905,
0.7050787806510925,
0.6628838777542114,
-0.24092383682727814,
0.8793935179710388,
0.7157178521156311,
-0.11690441519021988,
-0.04743853211402893,
-0.10468828678131104,
-0.18593519926071167,
-0.3863579034805298,
0.2530115246772766,
-0.6656246781349182,
-0.50197434425354,
0.4674610197544098,
-0.2935142517089844,
0.10251511633396149,
0.47691959142684937,
0.3018467128276825,
-0.15151545405387878,
1.3747937679290771,
0.5310457348823547,
-0.20332077145576477,
0.2347388118505478,
-0.29091858863830566,
0.3155708909034729,
-1.0356874465942383,
-0.32226142287254333,
-0.5726222991943359,
-0.44989240169525146,
-0.40451905131340027,
-0.3428261876106262,
0.6242956519126892,
0.14030465483665466,
-0.04420986771583557,
0.5258553624153137,
-0.31140953302383423,
-0.05341699719429016,
0.46864235401153564,
0.04213299974799156,
0.5845208168029785,
0.17485131323337555,
-0.1615927666425705,
-0.384831964969635,
-0.8159409761428833,
-0.27895504236221313,
1.3275294303894043,
0.013987313956022263,
0.345234751701355,
0.19573022425174713,
0.46084079146385193,
0.08822152018547058,
0.4693273603916168,
-0.49309974908828735,
0.3869497776031494,
-0.2458772361278534,
-0.3744657635688782,
-0.1367408186197281,
-0.7165771722793579,
-1.0394933223724365,
0.563920795917511,
-0.3490353524684906,
-0.38102495670318604,
-0.02558579482138157,
0.040350064635276794,
0.05641953647136688,
0.25802081823349,
-0.500703752040863,
1.0158993005752563,
-0.28860804438591003,
-0.3481094241142273,
-0.28869783878326416,
-0.7254233956336975,
0.12507092952728271,
-0.32735106348991394,
0.19599643349647522,
0.0011688130907714367,
0.2206936925649643,
0.46322089433670044,
-0.7589498162269592,
0.47200819849967957,
-0.16390015184879303,
0.00745910732075572,
0.0033276211470365524,
-0.2652502655982971,
0.6212043166160583,
-0.2567633390426636,
-0.07729054987430573,
-0.033959824591875076,
-0.2878415882587433,
-0.49125421047210693,
-0.7573946118354797,
0.5144171714782715,
-0.37318530678749084,
-0.2573685944080353,
-0.24255581200122833,
-0.7451819181442261,
-0.27022191882133484,
0.3314220905303955,
0.17063897848129272,
0.4769042730331421,
0.25211337208747864,
0.35939815640449524,
0.33174270391464233,
0.030176479369401932,
0.22640381753444672,
0.35603034496307373,
-0.04646148532629013,
-0.39875221252441406,
1.140904188156128,
0.04728996753692627,
0.3373182713985443,
0.5342866778373718,
-0.006790902931243181,
-0.48673486709594727,
-0.6180261373519897,
-0.7333877682685852,
0.11609116941690445,
-0.7923179268836975,
-0.29163476824760437,
-0.6973031759262085,
0.09017683565616608,
-0.254353791475296,
0.10454773157835007,
-0.6221697926521301,
-0.3774809241294861,
0.03180745616555214,
0.01837190054357052,
0.11839508265256882,
0.4280579686164856,
0.07099521905183792,
0.34594184160232544,
-1.000803828239441,
0.15751920640468597,
0.0014343727380037308,
0.12660260498523712,
-0.09487468004226685,
-0.40414959192276,
-0.5848093032836914,
0.21446111798286438,
-0.1760520190000534,
-0.4547039270401001,
0.5588566064834595,
0.11019746214151382,
0.5694574117660522,
0.0980290025472641,
0.05262453109025955,
1.1281636953353882,
-0.6636905670166016,
0.39210981130599976,
0.1903262883424759,
-0.8150458931922913,
0.36773955821990967,
-0.27318376302719116,
0.168011873960495,
0.7939248085021973,
0.4143657386302948,
-0.5711811780929565,
-0.5163562297821045,
-0.31218865513801575,
-0.9876860976219177,
0.4910181760787964,
0.19318830966949463,
0.07347369194030762,
-0.019224025309085846,
0.15158885717391968,
0.24593952298164368,
0.6795781850814819,
-0.6278026103973389,
-0.32271555066108704,
-0.07572958618402481,
-0.16389164328575134,
-0.029351981356739998,
0.3685489296913147,
-0.1615646481513977,
-0.27599841356277466,
0.6032986044883728,
-0.46920114755630493,
0.1188969835639,
-0.20387375354766846,
-0.3292989730834961,
-0.061164725571870804,
0.20300060510635376,
0.10656245797872543,
0.5159351229667664,
-0.00961589626967907,
0.15651898086071014,
-0.04203394055366516,
-0.2508945167064667,
0.23619432747364044,
0.08975033462047577,
-0.10810797661542892,
0.009276249445974827,
0.2179848998785019,
0.5214318037033081,
0.2840782105922699,
-0.38791605830192566,
0.5253693461418152,
0.18412227928638458,
0.23795394599437714,
-0.003041386604309082,
-0.23466908931732178,
-0.047811031341552734,
0.2624475657939911,
0.42769765853881836,
0.24281592667102814,
-0.0064236437901854515,
-0.6367452144622803,
0.2529548704624176,
0.2804045081138611,
-0.43112361431121826,
-0.43644434213638306,
0.7151643633842468,
0.33243441581726074,
0.22739043831825256,
0.9882017374038696,
-0.2736169993877411,
-0.4357578456401825,
0.041189227253198624,
0.433707594871521,
0.7037109732627869,
0.028402607887983322,
0.06728443503379822,
0.5088820457458496,
0.22004833817481995,
-0.1152675449848175,
0.28103527426719666,
0.07051023840904236,
-0.5384668111801147,
-0.7586727738380432,
-0.4099399447441101,
-0.22920161485671997,
-0.023233015090227127,
-0.6575251817703247,
0.1919439733028412,
-0.004513883497565985,
0.038278598338365555,
-0.240163654088974,
-0.13748160004615784,
-0.8094434142112732,
0.21334514021873474,
-0.16099180281162262,
0.5578548908233643,
-0.9735844731330872,
1.1155695915222168,
0.2602725028991699,
-0.8947176933288574,
-0.5425750613212585,
-0.15962252020835876,
-0.12761563062667847,
-0.5105398893356323,
0.7982220649719238,
0.18596409261226654,
-0.01850438117980957,
0.11111665517091751,
-0.18413805961608887,
-0.7254688739776611,
0.8556167483329773,
0.5615703463554382,
-0.18121397495269775,
0.1594230681657791,
0.6427258253097534,
0.29608047008514404,
-0.4586521089076996,
-0.12120036035776138,
0.2823944687843323,
0.5462477207183838,
0.034746550023555756,
-0.781731367111206,
0.18826499581336975,
-0.5058904886245728,
-0.2922070622444153,
0.44082945585250854,
-0.4224255681037903,
0.9469879865646362,
0.14897538721561432,
-0.5403555631637573,
0.13081826269626617,
0.5538659691810608,
-0.09737193584442139,
0.06101706996560097,
0.23870304226875305,
0.6691045761108398,
0.6924801468849182,
-0.24791930615901947,
0.9288817644119263,
-0.40106678009033203,
0.2667138874530792,
1.1500476598739624,
-0.036281660199165344,
0.9218311905860901,
0.7411159873008728,
-0.22016897797584534,
0.4457635283470154,
0.353953093290329,
0.1049497202038765,
0.658614456653595,
0.10034321248531342,
-0.2352439910173416,
-0.30701738595962524,
-0.22514674067497253,
-0.5044299364089966,
0.2721198797225952,
0.30803728103637695,
-0.31451520323753357,
-0.4134923219680786,
0.0010377159342169762,
0.001362370909191668,
0.034172967076301575,
-0.072758749127388,
0.5989702343940735,
0.0481206513941288,
-0.7708138227462769,
0.4511449337005615,
-0.04054564982652664,
0.27599090337753296,
-0.7377411127090454,
-0.11243683099746704,
-0.33617547154426575,
0.26980674266815186,
-0.2748459279537201,
-0.7682916522026062,
0.458208292722702,
-0.046707164496183395,
-0.3217644989490509,
-0.5938388109207153,
0.07153044641017914,
-0.6840198636054993,
-0.5078487992286682,
0.014880604110658169,
0.6848681569099426,
0.39168816804885864,
-0.3672044277191162,
-0.49663981795310974,
-0.019153855741024017,
-0.00033571757376194,
0.11185191571712494,
0.37580442428588867,
0.6548546552658081,
-0.051799122244119644,
0.7057663798332214,
1.0137317180633545,
-0.08651985973119736,
0.2408095896244049,
0.05127137154340744,
0.9202086329460144,
-0.513231098651886,
-0.44973424077033997,
-0.5263431072235107,
1.0294448137283325,
-0.11388219892978668,
-0.3723433315753937,
0.8504118323326111,
0.7910516262054443,
0.9991025328636169,
0.09716252982616425,
0.8950850367546082,
0.15660221874713898,
0.4479758143424988,
-0.4612840414047241,
0.3634008467197418,
-0.41787636280059814,
0.09078909456729889,
-0.3009502589702606,
-1.1281723976135254,
-0.4462466239929199,
0.3359922170639038,
-0.036789778620004654,
-0.4121382534503937,
0.8940524458885193,
0.6057178378105164,
-0.2421978861093521,
-0.32822170853614807,
-0.010867273434996605,
-0.09067586064338684,
0.4711718261241913,
0.5676624774932861,
0.5390726923942566,
-0.6768133640289307,
0.8504641056060791,
-0.09633851051330566,
-0.04899583011865616,
-0.05863930284976959,
-0.8010791540145874,
-0.6695046424865723,
-0.7342194318771362,
-0.29396289587020874,
-0.367805153131485,
-0.42195209860801697,
0.711271345615387,
0.6405342817306519,
-0.7860686182975769,
-0.24689747393131256,
-0.10908640176057816,
-0.08709149062633514,
-0.4154556095600128,
-0.13419610261917114,
0.3303333520889282,
-0.59210205078125,
-0.9469153881072998,
0.6782518029212952,
0.4080796539783478,
-0.15608660876750946,
-0.47674646973609924,
-0.1315530687570572,
-0.04535515233874321,
-0.39114516973495483,
0.5936802625656128,
0.24879629909992218,
-0.5155843496322632,
-0.35192373394966125,
-0.05799202248454094,
-0.08211212605237961,
0.4794343113899231,
0.8902992010116577,
-0.7211145162582397,
0.7264928817749023,
0.5056281685829163,
0.9238157868385315,
0.7615044116973877,
-0.019833136349916458,
0.7899775505065918,
-1.0785036087036133,
0.33627817034721375,
-0.037041790783405304,
0.3389531075954437,
0.6196132898330688,
-0.12326691299676895,
0.6474161744117737,
0.3585130274295807,
-0.15975581109523773,
-0.7040960788726807,
0.32061678171157837,
-0.9345308542251587,
0.014883210882544518,
0.6546390652656555,
-0.29277268052101135,
0.03867620229721069,
-0.15124793350696564,
0.02940298244357109,
0.44084370136260986,
-0.3088441789150238,
0.582189679145813,
0.5463742017745972,
-0.02341402694582939,
0.03652992099523544,
-0.6483834385871887,
0.18632301688194275,
0.24131639301776886,
-0.8667992949485779,
-0.0967194139957428,
0.24108242988586426,
0.04531410336494446,
0.2723131775856018,
0.37344974279403687,
-0.25819429755210876,
-0.17950668931007385,
0.10201805830001831,
-0.18466132879257202,
0.07563821226358414,
-0.4427633285522461,
0.06545908749103546,
0.14321383833885193,
-0.17333734035491943,
-0.49921733140945435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16251v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16251v2
|
Investigating the prompt leakage effect and black-box defenses for multi-turn LLM interactions
| 2024-04-24T23:39:58 | 2024-04-26T07:47:49 |
Divyansh Agarwal, Alexander R. Fabbri, Philippe Laban, Ben Risher, Shafiq Joty, Caiming Xiong, Chien-Sheng Wu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Prompt leakage in large language models (LLMs) poses a significant security
and privacy threat, particularly in retrieval-augmented generation (RAG)
systems. However, leakage in multi-turn LLM interactions along with mitigation
strategies has not been studied in a standardized manner. This paper
investigates LLM vulnerabilities against prompt leakage across 4 diverse
domains and 10 closed- and open-source LLMs. Our unique multi-turn threat model
leverages the LLM's sycophancy effect and our analysis dissects task
instruction and knowledge leakage in the LLM response. In a multi-turn setting,
our threat model elevates the average attack success rate (ASR) to 86.2%,
including a 99% leakage with GPT-4 and claude-1.3. We find that some black-box
LLMs like Gemini show variable susceptibility to leakage across domains - they
are more likely to leak contextual knowledge in the news domain compared to the
medical domain. Our experiments measure specific effects of 6 black-box defense
strategies, including a query-rewriter in the RAG scenario. Our proposed
multi-tier combination of defenses still has an ASR of 5.3% for black-box LLMs,
indicating room for enhancement and future direction for LLM security research.
|
[
-0.1440909057855606,
-0.9924962520599365,
0.7931734919548035,
0.055914271622896194,
0.06070689484477043,
0.23177649080753326,
0.11974606662988663,
-0.47719621658325195,
0.0279301255941391,
0.6875654458999634,
-0.765716016292572,
-0.36490002274513245,
-0.7051685452461243,
-0.052989326417446136,
-0.27306246757507324,
0.9958177208900452,
0.15930795669555664,
-0.09337528049945831,
-0.24421972036361694,
-0.04717964306473732,
-0.8023069500923157,
-0.9346527457237244,
-0.48480167984962463,
-0.0523710735142231,
0.6223655343055725,
0.168097123503685,
0.4488402009010315,
-0.21856290102005005,
0.5243849158287048,
0.24854278564453125,
-0.08112815767526627,
0.010319042019546032,
-0.44614118337631226,
0.6417681574821472,
-0.361693799495697,
-0.6115131378173828,
-0.551907479763031,
-0.22364532947540283,
0.43100741505622864,
0.09428095072507858,
-0.17018413543701172,
0.046097323298454285,
0.1288936883211136,
0.6547209024429321,
-0.8376547694206238,
-0.05696883425116539,
-0.9210332632064819,
-0.11454254388809204,
-0.48540198802948,
-0.33245864510536194,
-0.7606105208396912,
-0.08948496729135513,
0.02542382851243019,
-0.5398141741752625,
0.05344000086188316,
0.2158513218164444,
0.3973277807235718,
0.306610107421875,
-0.24986308813095093,
-0.40546390414237976,
-0.49050575494766235,
0.5954083204269409,
-0.47847893834114075,
0.08378216624259949,
0.14062902331352234,
0.4275215268135071,
-0.24854683876037598,
-0.5010297894477844,
-0.5201622247695923,
-0.30233731865882874,
-0.017157966271042824,
0.11904343217611313,
-0.5184434056282043,
-0.10092033445835114,
0.21793247759342194,
0.0642549991607666,
-0.4818230867385864,
0.010096447542309761,
-0.18970125913619995,
-0.24960358440876007,
0.4259501099586487,
0.37511706352233887,
0.4201153814792633,
-0.31318768858909607,
-0.7745475769042969,
-0.07891477644443512,
-0.9312229156494141,
0.07434740662574768,
0.4168627858161926,
0.26920878887176514,
-0.2303103804588318,
0.5979142189025879,
0.20648634433746338,
0.5062947273254395,
0.06278996169567108,
-0.21341446042060852,
-0.03594166040420532,
-0.5993776321411133,
0.019441233947873116,
-0.2694157660007477,
0.9326171875,
0.058806054294109344,
0.014963754452764988,
-0.3149263560771942,
-0.1632850170135498,
-0.21789604425430298,
0.6260403394699097,
-0.6438808441162109,
0.14373493194580078,
0.3157493472099304,
-0.15844237804412842,
-0.3337852656841278,
0.19077523052692413,
-0.8250721096992493,
-0.7594977021217346,
0.15987884998321533,
0.6694516539573669,
-0.4718252718448639,
-0.17258454859256744,
0.048263322561979294,
-0.16628248989582062,
0.23750127851963043,
0.16644605994224548,
-0.3960396349430084,
0.20049820840358734,
0.7568238377571106,
0.8115957975387573,
-0.6460509300231934,
-0.31803712248802185,
-0.5814785361289978,
0.36182036995887756,
0.07858460396528244,
0.7959902882575989,
-0.2976357042789459,
-0.5998180508613586,
0.12724235653877258,
0.03628355264663696,
-0.11808113008737564,
-0.41211754083633423,
0.4742420017719269,
-0.5308113098144531,
-0.0375063419342041,
-0.0967307835817337,
-0.21804362535476685,
0.3116649091243744,
0.4099458158016205,
-0.7080597281455994,
0.5968062281608582,
-0.2739664316177368,
-1.0153247117996216,
-0.10726753622293472,
-0.36916959285736084,
-0.3678666055202484,
0.12473073601722717,
-0.2901421785354614,
-0.4597017467021942,
0.07572972029447556,
0.1678798496723175,
0.46542561054229736,
-0.015515622682869434,
0.09401361644268036,
-0.43318402767181396,
-0.19441896677017212,
0.8222824931144714,
-0.5180543065071106,
0.8181542754173279,
0.004269341938197613,
-0.24793025851249695,
-0.00798043143004179,
-0.513377845287323,
-0.10819649696350098,
0.27333298325538635,
-0.23847490549087524,
-0.41241443157196045,
-0.34006550908088684,
-0.49516886472702026,
0.31146711111068726,
0.29510200023651123,
-0.5430344343185425,
0.44443395733833313,
-0.13478751480579376,
0.20244200527668,
0.7271970510482788,
0.5127517580986023,
0.4183172881603241,
-0.35088619589805603,
0.7290462255477905,
0.2676800489425659,
0.4641691744327545,
-0.5000368356704712,
-0.5889896154403687,
-0.40915754437446594,
-0.2740827798843384,
0.018812738358974457,
0.7714749574661255,
-1.0003352165222168,
-0.23090963065624237,
0.15629592537879944,
-0.2263735681772232,
-0.6532063484191895,
-0.07389732450246811,
0.7367465496063232,
0.18448305130004883,
0.37940800189971924,
0.060432069003582,
0.11765158921480179,
-0.8782325387001038,
-0.45194390416145325,
0.06801304966211319,
0.13722184300422668,
0.44175615906715393,
0.35444003343582153,
-0.20236895978450775,
0.5920961499214172,
-0.6481015086174011,
-0.20324239134788513,
-0.1254686862230301,
-0.015065490268170834,
0.1930745244026184,
0.26105281710624695,
0.34795331954956055,
-0.2850891351699829,
-0.12090344727039337,
-0.36142465472221375,
-0.6552532911300659,
-0.12633521854877472,
-0.12155484408140182,
-0.29564324021339417,
0.4060908854007721,
0.48781371116638184,
-0.9332631826400757,
0.4443869888782501,
0.6176472306251526,
-0.4589099586009979,
0.9070752263069153,
-0.09667839109897614,
-0.1093926653265953,
-1.1969243288040161,
-0.06266921758651733,
-0.10331488400697708,
-0.007999521680176258,
-0.889358401298523,
0.32441192865371704,
0.2908693253993988,
-0.3276628851890564,
-0.8232110738754272,
0.7123404145240784,
-0.6420762538909912,
-0.09896679222583771,
-0.21864239871501923,
0.1492251753807068,
0.13809898495674133,
0.41360899806022644,
-0.33241981267929077,
0.9934556484222412,
0.47582682967185974,
-0.631752073764801,
-0.01982295885682106,
0.08656705915927887,
0.03141593188047409,
0.7608227729797363,
-0.679336667060852,
0.4286983907222748,
0.02559761516749859,
0.2311597615480423,
-0.7196506857872009,
0.08240889012813568,
0.4857885241508484,
-0.5398941040039062,
0.7922032475471497,
-0.12923012673854828,
-0.4364588260650635,
-0.11070426553487778,
-0.5530120134353638,
0.16270872950553894,
0.10253036022186279,
-0.34913963079452515,
0.46351373195648193,
0.32697540521621704,
-0.4585019052028656,
-1.1453202962875366,
-0.6601417064666748,
0.28040367364883423,
-0.13377316296100616,
-0.775941014289856,
0.4237043857574463,
-0.30363917350769043,
-0.2684101462364197,
-0.22812043130397797,
-0.22896665334701538,
0.19031479954719543,
0.22904440760612488,
0.436726838350296,
0.5011012554168701,
0.2818187177181244,
-0.1421087235212326,
0.0001092871607397683,
-0.15522907674312592,
0.38799959421157837,
-0.22656284272670746,
0.6208282113075256,
0.0547514483332634,
-0.7431071996688843,
-0.28707820177078247,
0.6129856109619141,
0.5161454677581787,
-0.21925236284732819,
1.032489538192749,
0.3538839519023895,
-0.11742725223302841,
-0.3989490568637848,
-0.5100558400154114,
-0.45677217841148376,
-0.49096935987472534,
0.23507167398929596,
-0.4532789885997772,
-0.8030034303665161,
0.46530672907829285,
0.18547511100769043,
0.07413239777088165,
0.109458789229393,
0.5945314168930054,
-0.023907743394374847,
0.4544418156147003,
0.6391059160232544,
0.05405981466174126,
0.2812596559524536,
-0.13209283351898193,
0.12792377173900604,
-0.8052632212638855,
-0.514263391494751,
-0.5214085578918457,
0.06496760994195938,
-0.6352944374084473,
-0.44323819875717163,
0.6054592728614807,
0.043378796428442,
-0.05427153408527374,
0.1844300627708435,
-0.31172940135002136,
0.340701162815094,
0.47967085242271423,
0.1764587163925171,
0.5600037574768066,
-0.1452573835849762,
-0.2745968699455261,
0.12936931848526,
-0.5213404893875122,
-0.34750068187713623,
1.1179546117782593,
0.4053823947906494,
1.1162697076797485,
0.37491220235824585,
0.7872983813285828,
0.2621842324733734,
-0.05742820352315903,
-0.3960365355014801,
0.541217565536499,
0.02475319430232048,
-0.6897983551025391,
-0.20387086272239685,
-0.41888174414634705,
-1.0854624509811401,
0.27353718876838684,
-0.23752228915691376,
-0.5137450098991394,
0.10788685828447342,
-0.012158725410699844,
-0.23906216025352478,
0.12092767655849457,
-0.581512987613678,
0.467182993888855,
-0.2518004775047302,
-0.5066636204719543,
-0.07409542053937912,
-0.6205999255180359,
0.6309467554092407,
-0.22819502651691437,
0.21695175766944885,
-0.019010908901691437,
-0.07270897924900055,
0.28738918900489807,
-0.03126228228211403,
1.0585428476333618,
-0.12030389904975891,
-0.21802625060081482,
0.0860808938741684,
0.3498830497264862,
0.6863200664520264,
0.378802090883255,
0.2278849184513092,
0.38559195399284363,
-0.2825073301792145,
-0.34339639544487,
-0.3456457555294037,
0.5758305191993713,
-0.8021175265312195,
-1.0098392963409424,
-0.5936912894248962,
-0.6773194074630737,
-0.2687971293926239,
0.15905824303627014,
0.44207799434661865,
0.28635290265083313,
-0.05218404904007912,
-0.15717923641204834,
1.0242031812667847,
-0.5231823921203613,
0.569840133190155,
0.8123133182525635,
-0.06811552494764328,
-0.43410712480545044,
0.9127376079559326,
-0.016460159793496132,
0.7103383541107178,
0.27486440539360046,
0.06184123456478119,
-0.13733412325382233,
-0.5761602520942688,
-0.36194324493408203,
0.48471036553382874,
-0.49623531103134155,
-0.6128917336463928,
-0.67842698097229,
-0.435484915971756,
-0.3589945435523987,
0.1191752701997757,
-0.08053313195705414,
-0.5429657697677612,
-0.10925369709730148,
-0.09341160207986832,
0.30270376801490784,
0.7869529128074646,
0.3632097840309143,
0.22967667877674103,
-0.7494872808456421,
0.34200790524482727,
0.37900808453559875,
0.02709360234439373,
-0.03790605068206787,
-0.4410409927368164,
0.008009340614080429,
-0.38062092661857605,
-0.7441133260726929,
-1.2790578603744507,
0.26037269830703735,
-0.2748737335205078,
0.793731689453125,
0.15905755758285522,
0.24065150320529938,
0.14487281441688538,
-0.6359023451805115,
0.8206026554107666,
0.3488534390926361,
-0.7340461611747742,
0.363585889339447,
-0.37330362200737,
0.4766920804977417,
0.25309738516807556,
0.2290310561656952,
-0.40423280000686646,
-0.881591796875,
-0.6782512664794922,
-0.8502764105796814,
0.7019017934799194,
0.1564524620771408,
0.006808998063206673,
0.12054656445980072,
0.19388921558856964,
0.26264941692352295,
0.4012835621833801,
-0.8567611575126648,
-0.660999059677124,
-0.16741572320461273,
0.27461692690849304,
0.2472054660320282,
-0.4196961522102356,
-0.23897261917591095,
0.4473361670970917,
0.48291799426078796,
0.15520118176937103,
0.26418831944465637,
0.12646763026714325,
-0.2915908098220825,
0.1603892594575882,
0.7919663786888123,
0.6636446714401245,
0.3813650608062744,
0.044820770621299744,
0.3607829511165619,
0.1315876543521881,
-0.7578300833702087,
0.3628077507019043,
0.2559729814529419,
-0.4474274218082428,
-0.13532701134681702,
0.554292619228363,
0.6030687093734741,
0.12686458230018616,
-0.24522744119167328,
0.6480169892311096,
-0.12237892299890518,
0.10115715116262436,
-0.19397391378879547,
0.09501776844263077,
0.20067018270492554,
0.29981210827827454,
0.5603259205818176,
0.005107128527015448,
-0.004264978691935539,
-0.5844591856002808,
0.20124900341033936,
0.7373805642127991,
-0.15637756884098053,
-0.34292080998420715,
0.36859723925590515,
0.015434698201715946,
-0.23243598639965057,
0.1339464783668518,
-0.13129118084907532,
-0.4437430500984192,
0.3810584843158722,
0.7448371648788452,
0.7461684942245483,
-0.5696932673454285,
0.14269739389419556,
0.009488807991147041,
0.5208892226219177,
0.26524442434310913,
0.2007981538772583,
0.2827477753162384,
-0.47867339849472046,
-0.3658844828605652,
-0.3979508876800537,
-0.6522873044013977,
0.19780392944812775,
-0.6873178482055664,
0.09491405636072159,
-0.38235870003700256,
-0.42684587836265564,
-0.1917695850133896,
-0.11217992752790451,
-0.4839610755443573,
-0.6081995964050293,
0.2594457268714905,
0.8402155041694641,
-0.4604572057723999,
0.5425387024879456,
0.4843728542327881,
-0.32377588748931885,
-0.4499754309654236,
0.27461951971054077,
0.30469608306884766,
-0.9234157204627991,
0.4961160123348236,
0.17353050410747528,
-0.26098063588142395,
-0.4771965742111206,
-0.40375104546546936,
-0.7561971545219421,
1.2686604261398315,
0.5660505890846252,
-0.760012149810791,
-0.14253419637680054,
0.3444327712059021,
0.13953717052936554,
-0.19302630424499512,
0.13760755956172943,
0.6349495649337769,
0.41123828291893005,
-0.17047472298145294,
-0.7675631046295166,
0.21083714067935944,
0.06774168461561203,
-0.16015371680259705,
0.3195287883281708,
-0.8068382740020752,
0.8100898861885071,
-0.4316001236438751,
-0.4513271749019623,
-0.22959774732589722,
0.31619909405708313,
0.9372268319129944,
0.6061473488807678,
0.17203913629055023,
0.6113901138305664,
0.5789665579795837,
0.14627398550510406,
1.1216405630111694,
-0.22660665214061737,
-0.20044557750225067,
0.9295121431350708,
-0.3573179244995117,
0.7761236429214478,
0.440364271402359,
-0.04360591247677803,
0.41465631127357483,
-0.019029395654797554,
0.380116730928421,
0.43690401315689087,
0.3365560472011566,
-0.4213705360889435,
0.26889535784721375,
-0.04767999425530434,
-0.4255916178226471,
-0.10929295420646667,
0.4688701927661896,
0.09375796467065811,
0.016569940373301506,
0.06866800040006638,
0.7200372219085693,
-0.16513283550739288,
-0.35210245847702026,
0.8782545328140259,
0.5156003832817078,
-0.6565940976142883,
0.3738422095775604,
-0.2340119481086731,
0.6777485609054565,
-0.62530517578125,
0.16011185944080353,
-0.37590962648391724,
0.13299678266048431,
-0.20120005309581757,
-0.9545844197273254,
0.14182458817958832,
0.06232355162501335,
-0.35159406065940857,
-0.05243350565433502,
0.9087789058685303,
-0.32351648807525635,
-0.23669905960559845,
0.5483404397964478,
0.7849723100662231,
-0.2537257671356201,
-0.18807639181613922,
-0.699471652507782,
0.21135202050209045,
-0.18365590274333954,
-0.24586303532123566,
0.7174973487854004,
0.5212710499763489,
-0.029902124777436256,
0.8450838327407837,
0.7140632271766663,
0.25100570917129517,
0.42243248224258423,
0.13095588982105255,
0.9843751192092896,
-0.7271509170532227,
-0.2006128430366516,
-0.9701431393623352,
0.4322669208049774,
-0.07754115760326385,
0.017012132331728935,
1.0249749422073364,
0.15783387422561646,
0.385873019695282,
0.03265383839607239,
0.7128030061721802,
0.3933437764644623,
0.4211401343345642,
-0.6542584896087646,
0.6922444105148315,
-0.06612516939640045,
0.6031661629676819,
-0.2585889995098114,
-0.7553707957267761,
0.1567736566066742,
-0.3009473383426666,
-0.009024875238537788,
-0.20032654702663422,
1.0139588117599487,
0.68260258436203,
0.27017951011657715,
-0.251521497964859,
0.31815627217292786,
0.37539660930633545,
0.47400492429733276,
0.6147265434265137,
1.0148863792419434,
0.06340868771076202,
0.9354273080825806,
-0.1375845968723297,
-0.28605079650878906,
0.01606195792555809,
-0.8966302871704102,
-1.0794025659561157,
-0.4045599400997162,
-0.11944800615310669,
-0.5133583545684814,
0.3742331266403198,
0.09735941886901855,
0.47846001386642456,
-0.5646203756332397,
-0.047338370233774185,
0.3693142831325531,
0.16948693990707397,
-0.07292289286851883,
-0.2550504207611084,
0.27168968319892883,
-0.4652181565761566,
-0.21108143031597137,
0.5270992517471313,
0.3418647348880768,
-0.041154757142066956,
-0.582714855670929,
0.14459072053432465,
-0.041945550590753555,
0.16694392263889313,
0.5629876852035522,
0.19947770237922668,
-0.789064884185791,
-0.033287808299064636,
0.3186551332473755,
-0.17652493715286255,
-0.22998476028442383,
0.8940640687942505,
-0.6274043917655945,
0.0979909673333168,
0.2591012418270111,
0.6980252265930176,
0.401508629322052,
0.0749933123588562,
0.5164510011672974,
-1.0151591300964355,
-0.0005667454679496586,
0.22212229669094086,
0.33545345067977905,
0.27964678406715393,
-0.6687053442001343,
0.2501950263977051,
0.17105375230312347,
-0.6890578866004944,
-0.8239738941192627,
0.535182535648346,
-0.9980340003967285,
-0.5778099894523621,
1.2685933113098145,
-0.06529802829027176,
-0.15911497175693512,
-0.1854984015226364,
-0.011845837347209454,
-0.003192383097484708,
-0.7977970838546753,
0.5711800456047058,
0.7463043332099915,
-0.018290456384420395,
-0.29711440205574036,
-1.0095672607421875,
0.44600170850753784,
0.10189829766750336,
-0.9317374229431152,
0.2620793282985687,
0.30841758847236633,
0.22324316203594208,
0.34517383575439453,
0.43300265073776245,
-0.34785330295562744,
0.15038761496543884,
-0.23850135505199432,
-0.03874664753675461,
-0.4227178990840912,
-0.5768553614616394,
-0.5283287763595581,
0.34375840425491333,
-0.017938075587153435,
-0.12820863723754883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16250v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16250v1
|
Semgrex and Ssurgeon, Searching and Manipulating Dependency Graphs
| 2024-04-24T23:39:56 | 2024-04-24T23:39:56 |
John Bauer, Chloe Kiddon, Eric Yeh, Alex Shan, Christopher D. Manning
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Searching dependency graphs and manipulating them can be a time consuming and
challenging task to get right. We document Semgrex, a system for searching
dependency graphs, and introduce Ssurgeon, a system for manipulating the output
of Semgrex. The compact language used by these systems allows for easy command
line or API processing of dependencies. Additionally, integration with publicly
released toolkits in Java and Python allows for searching text relations and
attributes over natural text.
|
[
-0.37816470861434937,
-0.5798618793487549,
0.668816328048706,
0.468924880027771,
-0.08379752188920975,
0.12150198966264725,
0.2519315779209137,
-0.5953722596168518,
0.8018948435783386,
0.8136034607887268,
-0.7215826511383057,
-0.43009358644485474,
-0.7178752422332764,
0.2242426574230194,
-0.138075590133667,
0.6707934737205505,
-0.3451962172985077,
-0.10695955157279968,
0.07281471788883209,
-0.38046351075172424,
-0.32626044750213623,
-0.7127007246017456,
-0.5866810083389282,
-0.7573085427284241,
0.7502595782279968,
0.508906364440918,
0.7493888139724731,
0.3551155924797058,
0.6894906759262085,
0.4744068384170532,
-0.22868849337100983,
0.053515948355197906,
-0.3479888439178467,
0.7900002002716064,
-0.655785858631134,
-0.3818093240261078,
-0.16070570051670074,
-0.11108068376779556,
0.056327059864997864,
0.7727760076522827,
0.19428905844688416,
0.3745018243789673,
-0.09472651034593582,
0.7562583684921265,
-0.8761337399482727,
0.5352703928947449,
-0.08259353786706924,
0.1346154510974884,
-0.4006079137325287,
-0.46334463357925415,
-0.4213901460170746,
-0.6055856347084045,
0.12360133975744247,
-0.566554844379425,
-0.136329784989357,
0.09476333856582642,
0.9633752107620239,
0.33126991987228394,
-0.6552276611328125,
-0.37633606791496277,
-0.6235079169273376,
0.7910157442092896,
-0.40385085344314575,
0.06494799256324768,
0.4224739670753479,
0.5080506205558777,
-0.5095950365066528,
-1.1359260082244873,
0.15054133534431458,
-0.23091094195842743,
-0.5175771713256836,
0.13405057787895203,
-0.29440727829933167,
0.42101067304611206,
0.29903244972229004,
0.454159677028656,
-0.5029240250587463,
0.0025874397251755,
-0.543485701084137,
-0.4608134627342224,
0.5301037430763245,
0.4365402162075043,
0.9512814879417419,
-0.7188075184822083,
-0.06138851121068001,
0.2932315468788147,
-0.5071733593940735,
-0.29727545380592346,
0.3248109519481659,
0.4789750874042511,
0.4482692778110504,
1.1277908086776733,
-0.12357137352228165,
0.6502871513366699,
-0.2496175616979599,
0.4009011387825012,
0.030538534745573997,
0.016774239018559456,
-0.4590877294540405,
0.4633290469646454,
0.5583683848381042,
0.12352361530065536,
-0.031667616218328476,
0.00889798067510128,
0.038596898317337036,
0.39485570788383484,
0.23604361712932587,
-0.8096079230308533,
-0.5360301733016968,
0.3160306513309479,
-0.7491425275802612,
-0.497636616230011,
-0.18532948195934296,
-0.6413242816925049,
-0.5783928036689758,
-0.3186115324497223,
0.49662137031555176,
-0.5394472479820251,
-0.0864216685295105,
-0.3490905165672302,
-0.7353137731552124,
-0.11414084583520889,
0.37408894300460815,
-0.7452702522277832,
0.5002140402793884,
0.33467841148376465,
0.8955103158950806,
-0.09741073846817017,
-0.44889700412750244,
-0.7422819137573242,
0.19866381585597992,
-0.2270357757806778,
0.9998978972434998,
-0.8044143915176392,
-0.3914431631565094,
-0.3532254099845886,
0.4805927574634552,
-0.008968781679868698,
-0.4371104836463928,
0.1159650906920433,
-0.3818546235561371,
0.2170085906982422,
-0.18822292983531952,
-0.457852303981781,
-0.36779093742370605,
-0.010253566317260265,
-1.0053527355194092,
1.355527400970459,
0.7096434831619263,
-1.160867691040039,
-0.008875514380633831,
-0.5339237451553345,
-0.7872896790504456,
0.26384982466697693,
-0.11406819522380829,
0.015562096610665321,
0.04471413046121597,
0.06469715386629105,
0.4817578196525574,
-0.19024558365345,
-0.23193351924419403,
-0.30094605684280396,
-0.7079702019691467,
-0.2969302833080292,
0.37977391481399536,
1.314117193222046,
0.2128920704126358,
-0.44041121006011963,
0.3142531216144562,
-0.8617807626724243,
-0.01485420111566782,
0.24764348566532135,
-0.32622861862182617,
-0.8860312700271606,
0.31445348262786865,
-0.09869299829006195,
-0.036814868450164795,
0.45818960666656494,
-0.2585510015487671,
0.30791395902633667,
-0.6007903814315796,
0.6183399558067322,
0.8799909353256226,
0.20695717632770538,
0.6844735145568848,
0.2364458590745926,
0.49491146206855774,
-0.23434004187583923,
0.17184238135814667,
-0.11012226343154907,
-0.33526182174682617,
-0.49868500232696533,
0.0817783772945404,
0.14469791948795319,
0.7419145107269287,
-0.9355447292327881,
0.14065533876419067,
0.20855888724327087,
-0.7499567866325378,
-0.028652915731072426,
0.034994304180145264,
-0.11510013788938522,
0.0961417630314827,
0.3931524455547333,
-0.1901410073041916,
-0.9422222375869751,
-0.9860517978668213,
-0.44448620080947876,
-0.2529384195804596,
0.10842497646808624,
0.39464035630226135,
0.3209638297557831,
-0.5267316699028015,
0.417470246553421,
-0.9000940918922424,
-0.1421913206577301,
-0.43814367055892944,
0.13658419251441956,
0.39379721879959106,
0.08989791572093964,
0.5949181318283081,
-0.4400801360607147,
-0.5921186208724976,
0.2809428572654724,
-0.8146955966949463,
-0.45247718691825867,
0.3492317795753479,
-0.2395322322845459,
-0.17223653197288513,
0.6549277305603027,
-0.16828130185604095,
0.47235938906669617,
0.6579177379608154,
-0.36015719175338745,
0.7159147262573242,
-0.10781393945217133,
0.36988428235054016,
-1.0622880458831787,
0.2724071443080902,
-0.20024774968624115,
-0.3481818735599518,
-0.7419905662536621,
0.48110565543174744,
0.09090077877044678,
-0.11138943582773209,
-0.41758614778518677,
0.14252425730228424,
-0.5895644426345825,
-0.08936350047588348,
-0.035413697361946106,
0.10325806587934494,
-0.05842609703540802,
0.23835639655590057,
-0.39521166682243347,
1.1359128952026367,
0.3871612250804901,
-0.703555703163147,
0.730191707611084,
0.37140363454818726,
-0.0964222103357315,
0.45937830209732056,
-0.6335086226463318,
-0.019695552065968513,
-0.20155175030231476,
-0.2493962049484253,
-0.6769785284996033,
-0.4495278000831604,
0.4492661952972412,
-0.15460799634456635,
0.017214301973581314,
-0.7528231739997864,
-0.367094486951828,
-0.269528329372406,
-0.11708232760429382,
0.07503929734230042,
0.1600245088338852,
-0.7039899826049805,
0.7347697019577026,
0.6796743273735046,
-0.4727187752723694,
-0.6588637828826904,
-0.724490761756897,
0.19408965110778809,
-0.053176939487457275,
-0.5198142528533936,
0.10676998645067215,
0.41400250792503357,
-0.39747685194015503,
0.08685164898633957,
-0.18910399079322815,
-0.2863052487373352,
0.0610509030520916,
0.6373395919799805,
0.3426840901374817,
-0.004885465372353792,
0.09656835347414017,
0.28175532817840576,
-0.4693654477596283,
-0.12395751476287842,
-0.10728687793016434,
0.7323647737503052,
-0.059231728315353394,
-0.15695053339004517,
0.014356373809278011,
0.4481692910194397,
0.5655205249786377,
-0.029484441503882408,
0.38554346561431885,
0.12506252527236938,
-0.29310011863708496,
-0.06899357587099075,
-0.1251680701971054,
0.030217980965971947,
-0.5670315027236938,
0.17352831363677979,
-0.41830193996429443,
-1.0680948495864868,
0.5554897785186768,
-0.6639952063560486,
-0.3914603590965271,
0.6335185766220093,
0.23970825970172882,
0.12893694639205933,
1.4341624975204468,
0.5709628462791443,
-0.12137236446142197,
0.34049856662750244,
0.0049628280103206635,
0.21272224187850952,
-0.6299481987953186,
-0.04752146452665329,
-0.8145545721054077,
-0.24375222623348236,
-0.6506943702697754,
-0.003445540787652135,
0.22767925262451172,
-0.11916162073612213,
-0.29133373498916626,
1.0051974058151245,
-1.0033020973205566,
0.675066351890564,
0.4586911201477051,
0.11547061055898666,
-0.019984135404229164,
0.2031308263540268,
-0.18592168390750885,
-0.24860186874866486,
-0.44799426198005676,
-0.23313969373703003,
0.5190333127975464,
-0.19024309515953064,
1.088134527206421,
0.09399760514497757,
0.8021881580352783,
0.36977916955947876,
-0.03836996853351593,
-0.8091855645179749,
0.8252512216567993,
-0.4966948628425598,
-0.4418085217475891,
-0.41395285725593567,
-0.6143772602081299,
-1.2513823509216309,
0.03744704648852348,
0.08220139145851135,
-1.0486114025115967,
0.22658047080039978,
0.005682606250047684,
0.060545116662979126,
0.34241917729377747,
-0.8017114996910095,
0.7386720180511475,
-0.1324004977941513,
-0.07295283675193787,
-0.3923454284667969,
-0.4843742847442627,
0.09904319047927856,
0.5726305246353149,
-0.20588406920433044,
-0.36514365673065186,
0.6032248735427856,
0.5081448554992676,
-0.9131760597229004,
0.5584996342658997,
-0.12125072628259659,
0.3243207037448883,
0.05299793928861618,
0.7521494030952454,
0.6101772785186768,
-0.15257114171981812,
-0.13438275456428528,
0.0034612719900906086,
0.4574742615222931,
-0.42208749055862427,
-0.5826531052589417,
0.9247530698776245,
-0.6287066340446472,
-0.3914879560470581,
-0.8287290334701538,
-0.06450188159942627,
0.26355862617492676,
0.8610761761665344,
0.11869321018457413,
0.4796651303768158,
-0.4063592255115509,
-0.3628894090652466,
0.33378174901008606,
-0.34573838114738464,
0.14180752635002136,
0.0791049674153328,
-0.8716490268707275,
-0.34340760111808777,
0.9658865928649902,
0.3792382776737213,
-0.08239445835351944,
0.2998606860637665,
0.083672434091568,
0.021817971020936966,
0.11158688366413116,
-0.34782883524894714,
0.1751391887664795,
-0.8219121694564819,
-0.17018194496631622,
-0.6312986016273499,
-0.5335983633995056,
-0.30772915482521057,
-0.4591660499572754,
-0.19637362658977509,
-1.0623167753219604,
-0.30084437131881714,
-0.05451851710677147,
0.48766517639160156,
1.1539679765701294,
-0.17084555327892303,
0.27640414237976074,
-0.6984602212905884,
0.3116491734981537,
0.6082886457443237,
0.49567434191703796,
-0.38699623942375183,
0.34654176235198975,
-0.2044481784105301,
-0.31232285499572754,
-0.008755597285926342,
-1.4988176822662354,
0.4833255410194397,
-0.12568305432796478,
0.4938880205154419,
0.2153903841972351,
-0.12512335181236267,
0.7303909063339233,
-0.5486927628517151,
0.8767192363739014,
0.17530378699302673,
-1.1315512657165527,
1.1593340635299683,
-0.07757273316383362,
0.16340824961662292,
0.5099499225616455,
0.3140500783920288,
-0.7390746474266052,
-0.35619890689849854,
-0.44860368967056274,
-1.0201342105865479,
0.9396814703941345,
0.3869462013244629,
-0.3832886219024658,
0.16885896027088165,
0.3353756368160248,
-0.10494507849216461,
-0.03231240436434746,
0.06601889431476593,
-0.5369582176208496,
-0.2748246192932129,
0.04802198335528374,
0.04842013865709305,
-0.5307891368865967,
-0.27755624055862427,
-0.28693899512290955,
0.6008877754211426,
0.02551700361073017,
0.1404375284910202,
0.21841974556446075,
-0.4122970700263977,
-0.10546641796827316,
0.35163870453834534,
0.060002878308296204,
0.5229035019874573,
-0.30885615944862366,
0.842946469783783,
0.43283653259277344,
-0.5588901042938232,
0.3472297787666321,
0.25555968284606934,
-0.11761798709630966,
0.29119718074798584,
-0.04608307406306267,
0.5122103095054626,
0.4659286439418793,
-0.4220804274082184,
0.28164398670196533,
-0.09758156538009644,
-0.16368570923805237,
-0.4127310812473297,
0.315267950296402,
0.06730885058641434,
0.23028238117694855,
-0.012842594645917416,
0.28606611490249634,
0.5842006802558899,
-0.3976307213306427,
0.08293161541223526,
-0.11245296150445938,
-0.8051088452339172,
-0.12890440225601196,
0.7241759300231934,
-0.11816629767417908,
-0.49129873514175415,
0.724450409412384,
-0.06514429301023483,
-0.6173577904701233,
0.6633686423301697,
0.4968189001083374,
0.6298356652259827,
-0.49483591318130493,
0.6776431202888489,
0.3142763376235962,
0.5285750031471252,
-0.11220981925725937,
0.5569816827774048,
0.15882863104343414,
-0.5386233925819397,
-0.5542536377906799,
-0.07739847898483276,
-0.6493399739265442,
-0.15147441625595093,
-0.7010607719421387,
0.34055012464523315,
-0.5824823379516602,
-0.263338565826416,
0.37097403407096863,
-0.18947046995162964,
-0.4151405692100525,
0.06305635720491409,
-0.4804091155529022,
0.998557448387146,
-0.7712958455085754,
0.3213532567024231,
1.2227249145507812,
-0.6409793496131897,
-0.9556469917297363,
-0.693763792514801,
0.17257991433143616,
-0.7278653979301453,
0.6493090391159058,
0.2788384258747101,
-0.27832841873168945,
-0.11764536052942276,
-0.6985440850257874,
-0.7880294919013977,
1.0446665287017822,
0.3197496831417084,
-0.06389777362346649,
0.06794316321611404,
-0.008342703804373741,
0.5172980427742004,
0.22929105162620544,
0.4064962565898895,
0.8124687075614929,
0.7816123962402344,
-0.31004729866981506,
-0.490494966506958,
0.3535868227481842,
-0.6271435618400574,
0.07969311624765396,
0.817352294921875,
-0.6813532114028931,
0.6317574381828308,
0.3458584249019623,
-0.4435407221317291,
-0.2526710629463196,
0.2440788745880127,
0.17920322716236115,
0.426408052444458,
0.48167118430137634,
0.4120590090751648,
0.6553839445114136,
-0.2219732701778412,
0.7146444320678711,
-0.33428671956062317,
0.41790369153022766,
0.9464386105537415,
-0.44995930790901184,
0.46052712202072144,
0.68709397315979,
-0.3629547357559204,
0.9153435230255127,
0.7902771234512329,
-0.13995744287967682,
0.15922896564006805,
-0.07469917088747025,
-0.21103273332118988,
-0.2870652377605438,
0.2191878706216812,
-0.22435510158538818,
0.15306396782398224,
0.5564336180686951,
-0.3919641673564911,
-0.5233068466186523,
-0.22736547887325287,
0.05358268693089485,
-0.167275071144104,
-0.2236090451478958,
0.5541338324546814,
0.1729561686515808,
-0.4963826537132263,
0.08611922711133957,
-0.08825494349002838,
0.07141125202178955,
-0.6160116195678711,
-0.2663361728191376,
0.11478515714406967,
0.06984143704175949,
-0.5672241449356079,
-0.9034520983695984,
0.4987086355686188,
-0.43098169565200806,
-0.18620209395885468,
-0.04467504844069481,
1.6387441158294678,
0.14809438586235046,
-0.24975630640983582,
0.7748565673828125,
0.3896788954734802,
0.23211809992790222,
0.004236937500536442,
-0.5671218633651733,
-0.032071929425001144,
0.14588762819766998,
-0.2619037330150604,
0.10241975635290146,
0.10688209533691406,
0.18102939426898956,
0.7824549674987793,
0.4383612871170044,
0.34612223505973816,
-0.011227669194340706,
0.1331312209367752,
1.0646103620529175,
-0.703960120677948,
-0.5146420001983643,
-0.520790696144104,
0.17599983513355255,
-0.4664126932621002,
0.060038160532712936,
1.0989296436309814,
0.5994261503219604,
0.17802099883556366,
-0.017706435173749924,
1.2618976831436157,
-0.43491193652153015,
0.6574625968933105,
-0.21081602573394775,
0.6504823565483093,
-0.5458207726478577,
0.06310736387968063,
-0.441366970539093,
-0.9173605442047119,
-0.506478488445282,
0.6260606050491333,
-0.3057461678981781,
-0.5150611996650696,
0.8572614789009094,
0.8935615420341492,
-0.27121779322624207,
0.26187947392463684,
0.13648755848407745,
0.3295583426952362,
0.16675136983394623,
0.1081027090549469,
0.984785795211792,
-0.32478567957878113,
0.6057705879211426,
-0.39489322900772095,
-0.24624980986118317,
-0.5001646280288696,
-0.39155006408691406,
-0.8529907464981079,
-0.4650302827358246,
-0.00121534732170403,
-0.9558345675468445,
0.27893632650375366,
0.8272328972816467,
0.36371445655822754,
-0.9779289364814758,
-0.16619642078876495,
-0.20682235062122345,
0.4999176859855652,
-0.4585522413253784,
-0.27793392539024353,
0.5011648535728455,
-0.39115193486213684,
-0.4767720103263855,
0.632601797580719,
0.9197707176208496,
-0.13157477974891663,
-0.19912363588809967,
0.17840465903282166,
-0.1134444996714592,
0.04515804722905159,
0.643216073513031,
0.5905681848526001,
-0.02860347181558609,
-0.47972211241722107,
-0.005308430176228285,
-0.31393519043922424,
-0.016140317544341087,
1.1781353950500488,
-0.5453187823295593,
0.6181584596633911,
1.2164829969406128,
0.18783096969127655,
0.8112701177597046,
-0.3374873399734497,
0.6597827076911926,
-0.5974408984184265,
0.15509110689163208,
-0.1927526891231537,
0.4642714858055115,
-0.02929225005209446,
-0.5988926887512207,
0.8365517854690552,
0.1533428132534027,
-0.9901021122932434,
-0.5986818075180054,
0.5705816149711609,
-0.8209457397460938,
-0.6839346885681152,
0.8468700647354126,
0.09624675661325455,
-0.42069312930107117,
-0.6349849104881287,
-0.8120222091674805,
0.23526489734649658,
-0.04203963279724121,
0.624453604221344,
0.4544427990913391,
-0.4398084878921509,
-0.024203067645430565,
-0.365322083234787,
0.3235384523868561,
0.27964165806770325,
-0.6479917168617249,
-0.4207378029823303,
0.3729175925254822,
0.2461465299129486,
0.24652446806430817,
0.7235715985298157,
-0.07879553735256195,
0.026907654479146004,
0.10136827826499939,
0.13726253807544708,
0.20577792823314667,
-0.04025586321949959,
-0.03100568987429142,
0.26030656695365906,
-0.2543323338031769,
0.134511798620224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16248v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16248v1
|
URL: Universal Referential Knowledge Linking via Task-instructed Representation Compression
| 2024-04-24T23:37:15 | 2024-04-24T23:37:15 |
Zhuoqun Li, Hongyu Lin, Tianshu Wang, Boxi Cao, Yaojie Lu, Weixiang Zhou, Hao Wang, Zhenyu Zeng, Le Sun, Xianpei Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Linking a claim to grounded references is a critical ability to fulfill human
demands for authentic and reliable information. Current studies are limited to
specific tasks like information retrieval or semantic matching, where the
claim-reference relationships are unique and fixed, while the referential
knowledge linking (RKL) in real-world can be much more diverse and complex. In
this paper, we propose universal referential knowledge linking (URL), which
aims to resolve diversified referential knowledge linking tasks by one unified
model. To this end, we propose a LLM-driven task-instructed representation
compression, as well as a multi-view learning approach, in order to effectively
adapt the instruction following and semantic understanding abilities of LLMs to
referential knowledge linking. Furthermore, we also construct a new benchmark
to evaluate ability of models on referential knowledge linking tasks across
different scenarios. Experiments demonstrate that universal RKL is challenging
for existing approaches, while the proposed framework can effectively resolve
the task across various scenarios, and therefore outperforms previous
approaches by a large margin.
|
[
-0.039732255041599274,
-0.2193330079317093,
0.610241174697876,
-0.004276953637599945,
-0.3234124183654785,
-0.07583889365196228,
-0.13976645469665527,
-0.6617615222930908,
-0.08954141288995743,
0.529983401298523,
-0.728232741355896,
-0.45709365606307983,
-0.39419615268707275,
0.1263752430677414,
-0.1921425759792328,
0.7517005205154419,
0.1205630674958229,
0.07364235818386078,
-0.6587555408477783,
-0.311713844537735,
-0.5629081726074219,
-0.4107845723628998,
-0.23586778342723846,
-0.54046630859375,
0.5923168063163757,
0.34084922075271606,
0.3722778558731079,
0.7671122550964355,
0.5682389140129089,
0.28633856773376465,
0.1700250804424286,
0.4757409989833832,
-0.3858603537082672,
0.31690582633018494,
-0.5283430814743042,
-0.5308849811553955,
-0.31813788414001465,
-0.006168480962514877,
0.6060153841972351,
0.8577165007591248,
-0.11211474239826202,
0.4687548279762268,
0.40919849276542664,
1.0331928730010986,
-0.7337472438812256,
0.23632097244262695,
-0.8570581078529358,
-0.11750145256519318,
0.2577383518218994,
-0.16593037545681,
-0.5099064111709595,
-0.3047567307949066,
-0.05322322994470596,
-0.8152521252632141,
0.45128297805786133,
0.3263801038265228,
0.6809056401252747,
0.5743798613548279,
-0.564698338508606,
0.04825311154127121,
-0.49058374762535095,
0.4395720362663269,
-0.27454516291618347,
0.6697700023651123,
-0.06649468839168549,
0.3009447753429413,
0.08558282256126404,
-0.6187615990638733,
-0.2546730637550354,
-0.1364540010690689,
-0.047239068895578384,
0.0028320224955677986,
0.013604501262307167,
-0.08531276881694794,
0.2516157627105713,
0.0014602873707190156,
-0.4346761405467987,
-0.2611178755760193,
-0.4051813781261444,
-0.2511250078678131,
0.3873424828052521,
0.15314258635044098,
0.18338103592395782,
-0.3253130316734314,
-0.6075723767280579,
-0.06414558738470078,
-1.130795955657959,
-0.17771799862384796,
0.147675022482872,
0.5130965709686279,
-0.11201005429029465,
0.36914438009262085,
-0.32272204756736755,
1.0097652673721313,
0.13130928575992584,
-0.238937646150589,
-0.0010690230410546064,
-0.2879461348056793,
-0.27946099638938904,
-0.046115443110466,
0.6529093384742737,
0.4030980169773102,
0.31443506479263306,
-0.5669699907302856,
0.3295876383781433,
-0.22712083160877228,
0.6356253623962402,
-0.4812696576118469,
0.03118092380464077,
-0.10232643783092499,
-0.37758299708366394,
-0.014662891626358032,
0.23574844002723694,
-0.5027931928634644,
-0.4799291491508484,
-0.5929648876190186,
0.21833789348602295,
-0.5601734519004822,
-0.0947694256901741,
0.10205509513616562,
0.25432315468788147,
-0.0595339871942997,
0.5072380900382996,
-0.6100005507469177,
0.030981983989477158,
0.5613276362419128,
0.384172260761261,
-0.0319940559566021,
-0.35023364424705505,
-0.29722359776496887,
0.7968924045562744,
0.2397923469543457,
1.03245210647583,
-0.5511254072189331,
-0.2790822982788086,
0.1998586356639862,
-0.14755240082740784,
-0.3112007975578308,
-0.6690685153007507,
0.5049993991851807,
-0.5626150965690613,
-0.07588337361812592,
-0.3585768938064575,
-0.5804305672645569,
-0.3213302791118622,
0.3773965537548065,
-0.7625583410263062,
0.7479909658432007,
-0.13544827699661255,
-0.7273457050323486,
0.23181989789009094,
-0.5725088119506836,
-0.09673352539539337,
0.04838722199201584,
-0.2461293488740921,
0.07494807243347168,
0.040058739483356476,
0.02752414159476757,
0.6436655521392822,
-0.6275572776794434,
0.44174569845199585,
-0.2824920117855072,
-0.12525174021720886,
0.023892883211374283,
-0.24716287851333618,
0.5087639689445496,
0.035953305661678314,
0.009365878067910671,
0.16918182373046875,
-0.7691634893417358,
-0.04394036531448364,
0.12782642245292664,
-0.7026275992393494,
-0.5265933275222778,
-0.2292267233133316,
-0.3492792248725891,
0.16319799423217773,
0.3821339011192322,
-0.358545184135437,
0.5374463200569153,
-0.03693932667374611,
-0.12412489950656891,
0.7147623896598816,
-0.11650487035512924,
0.30061930418014526,
-0.11694997549057007,
0.23979774117469788,
0.15028415620326996,
0.13555821776390076,
-0.12252093106508255,
-0.4552444815635681,
-0.8998626470565796,
0.19092243909835815,
0.30011963844299316,
0.5065175294876099,
-0.5484961867332458,
0.22072525322437286,
-0.7413201332092285,
-0.18012544512748718,
-0.6112920641899109,
0.38104382157325745,
0.8094773292541504,
0.9269155859947205,
0.6603386402130127,
-0.03179459646344185,
-0.5830385088920593,
-0.6796713471412659,
-0.45607930421829224,
-0.44390028715133667,
-0.3799319863319397,
0.4939701557159424,
0.312264084815979,
-0.06753872334957123,
0.723202645778656,
-0.45091572403907776,
-0.5031086802482605,
-0.10443813353776932,
0.09229445457458496,
0.04263688251376152,
0.3144706189632416,
0.22905874252319336,
-0.9642500877380371,
-0.5000165700912476,
-0.1010381430387497,
-0.9079909920692444,
0.033765535801649094,
0.0801115408539772,
-0.09540101140737534,
-0.19600768387317657,
0.46214717626571655,
-0.4144822657108307,
0.2853708267211914,
0.27359938621520996,
-0.5037482976913452,
0.650844931602478,
-0.3309456408023834,
0.2799401879310608,
-1.2316275835037231,
-0.049214232712984085,
0.2708052694797516,
-0.11588913202285767,
-0.24717766046524048,
0.3603493273258209,
0.43341729044914246,
-0.13443472981452942,
-0.4212917685508728,
0.5224842429161072,
-0.6232626438140869,
0.0713324025273323,
0.06933936476707458,
0.1302216649055481,
-0.232315331697464,
0.7285399436950684,
0.017130181193351746,
0.6009193062782288,
0.46157583594322205,
-0.7817696928977966,
0.5809440016746521,
0.2894963026046753,
-0.09080987423658371,
0.7389270067214966,
-0.26944810152053833,
0.14761590957641602,
-0.16822275519371033,
0.1638232171535492,
-1.003170371055603,
-0.26919034123420715,
0.22222404181957245,
-0.30102184414863586,
0.3571796715259552,
-0.25278952717781067,
-0.4258529543876648,
-0.15380370616912842,
0.015940498560667038,
0.5780256390571594,
0.3979068100452423,
-0.7305635213851929,
0.8767173290252686,
-0.014305343851447105,
0.12991254031658173,
-0.6165083050727844,
-0.39381957054138184,
-0.1352653056383133,
-0.18638111650943756,
-0.6269698739051819,
0.6741120219230652,
-0.17091841995716095,
0.04028419777750969,
0.23890529572963715,
-0.521205484867096,
-0.026401158422231674,
-0.29654860496520996,
0.5073378682136536,
0.2717522084712982,
-0.2684594392776489,
0.1565610021352768,
-0.21301011741161346,
-0.25627127289772034,
0.01328354887664318,
-0.39509910345077515,
0.12790240347385406,
0.08115369826555252,
-0.7491377592086792,
-0.4310113787651062,
0.4462827742099762,
0.4244224429130554,
0.1277344673871994,
0.5893902778625488,
0.36558371782302856,
-0.13626302778720856,
0.09105769544839859,
-0.9968074560165405,
0.019847853109240532,
-0.42444226145744324,
0.23925335705280304,
-0.4194435179233551,
-0.8728761672973633,
0.3339698612689972,
-0.679542601108551,
-0.04980418458580971,
0.3828270137310028,
0.25847694277763367,
-0.015215916559100151,
0.465445876121521,
0.9697809815406799,
-0.2891981303691864,
0.0015846490859985352,
-0.09507299959659576,
-0.04740481078624725,
-1.1576815843582153,
-0.768907368183136,
-0.651491105556488,
-0.12896884977817535,
0.05395850911736488,
-0.6101850867271423,
0.293753057718277,
0.3647587299346924,
-0.40519413352012634,
0.48207923769950867,
-0.4917546510696411,
0.4355516731739044,
0.5238949060440063,
0.4496419429779053,
0.6474621295928955,
0.2322530597448349,
-0.6729114651679993,
-0.10917624086141586,
-0.738045334815979,
-0.31800776720046997,
1.1813161373138428,
-0.023398974910378456,
0.8393133878707886,
0.18690632283687592,
0.6700008511543274,
0.37994787096977234,
0.35145050287246704,
-0.5059361457824707,
0.7755290865898132,
-0.011722232215106487,
-0.27181097865104675,
0.00454532029107213,
-0.1896696537733078,
-0.8393228650093079,
0.33211904764175415,
-0.32782602310180664,
-0.8678579330444336,
-0.1275733858346939,
0.2611294388771057,
-0.2182852327823639,
0.46502479910850525,
-0.4742773473262787,
0.6728091239929199,
0.017054524272680283,
-0.47584542632102966,
-0.358585000038147,
-0.7523723840713501,
0.26769688725471497,
0.2746116816997528,
0.22850391268730164,
-0.08855277299880981,
-0.18361277878284454,
0.7609353065490723,
-0.09108580648899078,
1.074509859085083,
-0.03698965534567833,
-0.05674871802330017,
0.11404146999120712,
-0.043370552361011505,
0.3648223876953125,
0.025600383058190346,
-0.03931013494729996,
0.0670713260769844,
-0.36802321672439575,
-0.26305103302001953,
-0.7236565947532654,
0.6416223049163818,
-0.6466797590255737,
-0.6983844041824341,
-0.22375378012657166,
-0.7377418875694275,
-0.6584933400154114,
-0.02657417207956314,
0.03625747561454773,
0.38143160939216614,
-0.09862568229436874,
0.08677717298269272,
0.8528419137001038,
0.15549613535404205,
0.038018159568309784,
0.7459457516670227,
0.23563675582408905,
-0.2783922255039215,
0.6526025533676147,
-0.388525128364563,
0.04384326934814453,
0.7573135495185852,
-0.11817432194948196,
-0.4959927201271057,
-0.2992374002933502,
-0.20865188539028168,
0.39669302105903625,
-0.9039947986602783,
-0.5838814377784729,
-0.4636393189430237,
-0.10529124736785889,
-0.5950556993484497,
-0.09795108437538147,
-0.18641798198223114,
0.01189822144806385,
-0.13685579597949982,
0.08043510466814041,
0.20625971257686615,
0.6053685545921326,
-0.18048354983329773,
-0.0907180979847908,
-1.0169429779052734,
0.6992344260215759,
0.587429940700531,
0.39583492279052734,
0.29252859950065613,
-0.412874698638916,
-0.15373268723487854,
0.01187535934150219,
-0.26129961013793945,
-0.94016033411026,
-0.0878179669380188,
0.17428791522979736,
0.8022662401199341,
0.5399132370948792,
0.26477259397506714,
0.948927640914917,
-0.8254759311676025,
0.6002231240272522,
0.6579848527908325,
-0.3705272078514099,
0.584255576133728,
0.019079308956861496,
0.26820600032806396,
0.492847740650177,
0.724544107913971,
-0.4866516590118408,
-0.24914346635341644,
-0.5986461043357849,
-0.786530077457428,
0.3610517978668213,
-0.14354541897773743,
0.05076390504837036,
0.20494218170642853,
0.6512929797172546,
0.1274227648973465,
-0.08345839381217957,
-0.7202966213226318,
-0.5370337963104248,
0.13615193963050842,
-0.19440889358520508,
0.443178653717041,
-0.5146717429161072,
-0.22800543904304504,
-0.24464742839336395,
0.6140251755714417,
-0.20096845924854279,
0.522345781326294,
0.2393173724412918,
-0.2931320369243622,
-0.05917634814977646,
0.45290759205818176,
0.06435183435678482,
0.7336965799331665,
-0.11604394018650055,
0.06405917555093765,
-0.05736628547310829,
-0.48230263590812683,
0.22190096974372864,
0.1525471955537796,
0.016942359507083893,
-0.17882050573825836,
0.46196016669273376,
0.5333065986633301,
0.6539532542228699,
-0.5492632985115051,
0.2330007404088974,
0.08911344408988953,
-0.22495324909687042,
0.0433158241212368,
0.3325807452201843,
0.3514972925186157,
0.47603777050971985,
0.6101913452148438,
0.07461456209421158,
-0.06785274296998978,
-0.4051640033721924,
0.2773839831352234,
0.3055644631385803,
-0.5362573266029358,
-0.04630715772509575,
0.9567713141441345,
0.4983733892440796,
-0.13662979006767273,
0.6721283197402954,
-0.041421256959438324,
-0.38552019000053406,
0.2426413744688034,
0.62925785779953,
0.7412023544311523,
-0.2411811649799347,
0.0821012482047081,
0.6185988783836365,
-0.15470770001411438,
0.01876155659556389,
0.10640228539705276,
-0.4819437265396118,
-0.7572737336158752,
-0.6561992764472961,
-0.47319117188453674,
-0.4382595717906952,
-0.0011691780528053641,
-0.960695743560791,
-0.12302996963262558,
-0.11703284084796906,
0.3613419532775879,
-0.09144521504640579,
-0.14575915038585663,
-0.8253271579742432,
0.24936626851558685,
0.05649488419294357,
1.035820722579956,
-0.7717702388763428,
1.0173475742340088,
0.9263051748275757,
-0.5652353167533875,
-0.9951829314231873,
0.1161193698644638,
0.31122690439224243,
-1.0814063549041748,
1.1188980340957642,
0.023720158264040947,
-0.26992014050483704,
0.07396216690540314,
-0.5904250144958496,
-0.5850182175636292,
1.256155014038086,
0.5848725438117981,
-0.47511962056159973,
-0.3344942331314087,
0.22879299521446228,
0.0681924894452095,
-0.5273483395576477,
-0.13833998143672943,
0.09981425106525421,
0.21932505071163177,
0.44641637802124023,
-0.9438503384590149,
0.4525185525417328,
-0.19345642626285553,
-0.01901298016309738,
0.022221790626645088,
-0.49401941895484924,
0.2745060622692108,
-0.508158802986145,
0.01610974408686161,
0.09538830071687698,
0.918396532535553,
0.4568091332912445,
-0.061039868742227554,
0.5192190408706665,
0.7217965722084045,
0.6566394567489624,
0.09285111725330353,
0.7206215858459473,
-0.565184473991394,
0.47444143891334534,
1.1662487983703613,
-0.15064667165279388,
0.7817767858505249,
0.5012843012809753,
-0.3874695599079132,
0.5714107751846313,
0.3321191668510437,
-0.03505108505487442,
0.6224557757377625,
-0.036434199661016464,
-0.5028605461120605,
-0.6043140888214111,
-0.4322590231895447,
-0.44978880882263184,
0.09774361550807953,
0.2250925451517105,
-0.19124281406402588,
-0.7354543209075928,
-0.21815918385982513,
-0.22385604679584503,
0.290689617395401,
-0.531928539276123,
0.6714515089988708,
0.006150395609438419,
-0.6344625949859619,
0.5445800423622131,
-0.2372203767299652,
0.8451191186904907,
-0.845485508441925,
-0.3565516173839569,
-0.08805374801158905,
-0.07345829159021378,
-0.07861068844795227,
-0.5844115614891052,
0.19628673791885376,
-0.01158657856285572,
-0.42575690150260925,
-0.309733122587204,
1.07709801197052,
-0.4627598822116852,
-0.27855637669563293,
0.2706332802772522,
0.5455236434936523,
0.1858019232749939,
-0.19590133428573608,
-0.8613958358764648,
-0.21535654366016388,
0.258637934923172,
-0.04029114171862602,
0.7560896277427673,
0.4535391330718994,
0.33555203676223755,
1.0222185850143433,
0.602996826171875,
-0.00908389687538147,
-0.0002858955122064799,
0.1294683814048767,
0.8837458491325378,
-0.9324043989181519,
-0.34564927220344543,
-0.49685850739479065,
0.6366252303123474,
-0.13448628783226013,
0.03998132050037384,
0.5341851115226746,
0.5177700519561768,
0.8791136145591736,
-0.29800429940223694,
0.8252592086791992,
-0.1391979157924652,
0.4345276653766632,
-0.6991154551506042,
0.38990384340286255,
-0.7005534768104553,
0.14631563425064087,
-0.11464828997850418,
-0.7913569211959839,
-0.375102698802948,
0.4239380359649658,
0.17506533861160278,
-0.22649332880973816,
0.8922342658042908,
0.45774292945861816,
-0.40570706129074097,
-0.11176940053701401,
0.4713398516178131,
0.02319548837840557,
-0.18787217140197754,
0.9647589921951294,
0.39058810472488403,
-0.35856395959854126,
0.9760019183158875,
-0.3145179748535156,
0.13728570938110352,
-0.122531957924366,
-1.219024896621704,
-0.8219864368438721,
-0.8499282598495483,
-0.6743317246437073,
-0.4673459231853485,
0.1307547688484192,
0.7886115312576294,
0.7522597908973694,
-0.5395735502243042,
-0.06494393199682236,
0.08114952594041824,
0.2870669364929199,
-0.328994482755661,
-0.12710414826869965,
0.5435763597488403,
-0.35611796379089355,
-0.5369007587432861,
0.2856971025466919,
0.40050145983695984,
-0.24518823623657227,
-0.21726275980472565,
-0.09829122573137283,
-0.18079909682273865,
-0.42485830187797546,
0.40888097882270813,
0.44552814960479736,
-0.9893505573272705,
-0.27989113330841064,
-0.2713622748851776,
0.01998268812894821,
0.028638474643230438,
1.1115152835845947,
-1.0629280805587769,
0.24688784778118134,
0.22498297691345215,
0.8436055779457092,
0.10076365619897842,
0.07453931123018265,
0.3596283793449402,
-0.8503539562225342,
0.14927971363067627,
-0.08915253728628159,
0.4897155165672302,
0.22066397964954376,
-0.47004303336143494,
0.8085048198699951,
0.37176376581192017,
-0.3343605399131775,
-0.2658107578754425,
0.47271737456321716,
-1.2129390239715576,
-0.3138386607170105,
1.2750828266143799,
-0.4266861379146576,
-0.15356780588626862,
-0.21986083686351776,
-0.038738761097192764,
0.4002545177936554,
-0.36992356181144714,
0.8947948217391968,
0.4887953996658325,
-0.37597665190696716,
-0.09244348853826523,
-0.4355211555957794,
0.21030861139297485,
0.06692205369472504,
-0.6248762011528015,
0.18792572617530823,
0.6923059821128845,
0.6133617758750916,
0.3871368169784546,
0.540090799331665,
0.018415478989481926,
0.18320247530937195,
-0.15788167715072632,
0.07086704671382904,
-0.38233688473701477,
-0.3443664014339447,
0.04709654301404953,
0.5174394845962524,
-0.137050062417984,
-0.260822594165802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16226v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16226v2
|
Computational analysis of the language of pain: a systematic review
| 2024-04-24T21:59:40 | 2024-05-10T14:31:53 |
Diogo A. P. Nunes, Joana Ferreira-Gomes, Fani Neto, David Martins de Matos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7; J.3; A.1
|
Objectives: This study aims to systematically review the literature on the
computational processing of the language of pain, or pain narratives, whether
generated by patients or physicians, identifying current trends and challenges.
Methods: Following the PRISMA guidelines, a comprehensive literature search was
conducted to select relevant studies on the computational processing of the
language of pain and answer pre-defined research questions. Data extraction and
synthesis were performed to categorize selected studies according to their
primary purpose and outcome, patient and pain population, textual data,
computational methodology, and outcome targets. Results: Physician-generated
language of pain, specifically from clinical notes, was the most used data.
Tasks included patient diagnosis and triaging, identification of pain mentions,
treatment response prediction, biomedical entity extraction, correlation of
linguistic features with clinical states, and lexico-semantic analysis of pain
narratives. Only one study included previous linguistic knowledge on pain
utterances in their experimental setup. Most studies targeted their outcomes
for physicians, either directly as clinical tools or as indirect knowledge. The
least targeted stage of clinical pain care was self-management, in which
patients are most involved. Affective and sociocultural dimensions were the
least studied domains. Only one study measured how physician performance on
clinical tasks improved with the inclusion of the proposed algorithm.
Discussion: This review found that future research should focus on analyzing
patient-generated language of pain, developing patient-centered resources for
self-management and patient-empowerment, exploring affective and sociocultural
aspects of pain, and measuring improvements in physician performance when aided
by the proposed tools.
|
[
-0.24954625964164734,
-0.493064820766449,
0.6153112649917603,
0.5086419582366943,
-0.18888075649738312,
0.35652095079421997,
-0.22379499673843384,
-0.7819094061851501,
0.7628993988037109,
0.417760968208313,
-0.5412798523902893,
-0.7005005478858948,
-0.5514035224914551,
0.5179397463798523,
-0.1341700553894043,
0.7737902402877808,
-0.018138783052563667,
0.6491700410842896,
0.027164747938513756,
-0.04710615798830986,
-0.4710889160633087,
-0.5369989275932312,
-0.15770962834358215,
-0.2514219582080841,
0.44981855154037476,
0.20021995902061462,
0.39342498779296875,
0.33123037219047546,
0.9139662981033325,
0.349143385887146,
-0.002742947079241276,
-0.23436233401298523,
-0.27645546197891235,
0.0671246349811554,
-0.09343721717596054,
-0.05229803919792175,
-0.15659146010875702,
-0.046937279403209686,
0.27806800603866577,
0.9461910724639893,
-0.39379146695137024,
0.1387748420238495,
-0.05153651908040047,
0.6595988273620605,
-0.5156930685043335,
-0.017298473045229912,
-0.26182764768600464,
0.4002046287059784,
-0.3274395763874054,
-0.27624160051345825,
-0.1450224071741104,
-0.6563028693199158,
0.27102357149124146,
-0.32834240794181824,
-0.07197339087724686,
0.022714246064424515,
0.41958722472190857,
0.3216555118560791,
-0.10149554908275604,
-0.8248337507247925,
-0.7880671620368958,
0.6116569638252258,
-0.5488359332084656,
0.10493918508291245,
0.12231259047985077,
0.2476583868265152,
0.13899579644203186,
-0.47895070910453796,
-0.5006359219551086,
0.013941280543804169,
-0.3398093581199646,
0.15418457984924316,
-0.38811901211738586,
0.26762285828590393,
0.18848146498203278,
0.49723902344703674,
-0.8880207538604736,
-0.1157466247677803,
-0.9820548892021179,
-0.10344591736793518,
0.6925378441810608,
0.561639130115509,
0.7096173167228699,
-0.4357198476791382,
-0.3031177520751953,
0.3077412545681,
-0.6173113584518433,
0.07263348251581192,
0.16390252113342285,
0.1769944280385971,
-0.24314400553703308,
0.5764433741569519,
0.027676591649651527,
0.7557086944580078,
-0.39318394660949707,
-0.19051095843315125,
0.4301958382129669,
-0.20944862067699432,
-0.3358381688594818,
0.2484951615333557,
1.3076057434082031,
0.2776765823364258,
0.028156490996479988,
-0.16098779439926147,
0.11380867660045624,
-0.2900233864784241,
0.767922580242157,
-0.5551198720932007,
-0.13581079244613647,
0.39885058999061584,
-0.7621557116508484,
-0.4443155825138092,
-0.22922459244728088,
-0.9995335936546326,
-0.6332811713218689,
-0.3685656785964966,
-0.3650052547454834,
-0.5372355580329895,
-0.5623822808265686,
0.21589118242263794,
-0.11654886603355408,
0.310392290353775,
-0.039758529514074326,
-0.843312680721283,
0.6846150159835815,
0.578951895236969,
0.8301841020584106,
-0.22207722067832947,
-0.2527932822704315,
0.4113927483558655,
-0.3636045455932617,
-0.5193517804145813,
1.1115522384643555,
-0.4275808334350586,
-0.7411882281303406,
0.24764344096183777,
-0.37793752551078796,
-0.21524138748645782,
-0.6846166849136353,
0.6634413599967957,
-0.14222285151481628,
-0.03341888636350632,
-0.39717379212379456,
-0.2792876064777374,
-0.08078726381063461,
0.16156771779060364,
-0.6277906894683838,
0.6484971642494202,
0.2899644374847412,
-0.5536938905715942,
0.12499403208494186,
-0.6920163631439209,
-0.6463282108306885,
0.25570958852767944,
-0.5453656911849976,
0.004526089411228895,
0.38410109281539917,
0.013072648085653782,
0.14482830464839935,
-0.8062846064567566,
0.3325696289539337,
0.044900741428136826,
-0.18405690789222717,
0.3260529637336731,
0.30007702112197876,
0.6742520332336426,
0.41843631863594055,
-0.27959033846855164,
0.0659090057015419,
-0.562109112739563,
-0.10392118245363235,
0.11903389543294907,
0.055223412811756134,
-0.26314932107925415,
0.07417971640825272,
0.03404412418603897,
0.3782365620136261,
-0.2144489288330078,
-0.6520213484764099,
0.4161635637283325,
-0.7096721529960632,
-0.07239249348640442,
0.37000492215156555,
0.2159290462732315,
0.2615177035331726,
-0.07589652389287949,
0.9490628242492676,
-0.27371737360954285,
0.38029080629348755,
0.0888744443655014,
-0.32140588760375977,
-0.41306397318840027,
0.10701242834329605,
0.2005341649055481,
0.5782727003097534,
-0.7373707890510559,
0.09040408581495285,
-0.08003460615873337,
-0.6632915139198303,
-0.5864354968070984,
-0.1487458199262619,
0.6438655853271484,
0.51749587059021,
0.27013516426086426,
-0.3102514147758484,
-0.5771827697753906,
-0.9547202587127686,
-0.3369368016719818,
-0.2153376340866089,
0.05386185646057129,
0.5221131443977356,
0.26028719544410706,
-0.20161107182502747,
0.6914849281311035,
-0.7011670470237732,
-0.529426097869873,
-0.37645766139030457,
0.4666160047054291,
0.15120325982570648,
0.4802285134792328,
0.6841140389442444,
-0.4712156057357788,
-0.6292506456375122,
0.07703599333763123,
-0.9287154078483582,
-0.474459171295166,
-0.1345759779214859,
0.1965080052614212,
0.2012506127357483,
0.19043892621994019,
-0.2685597538948059,
0.3439043462276459,
0.6868439316749573,
-0.2681621015071869,
0.507701575756073,
0.09974998235702515,
0.5395879745483398,
-0.6495904922485352,
0.4820430278778076,
-0.206041619181633,
0.5422989130020142,
-0.7270824909210205,
-0.21981452405452728,
-0.14273537695407867,
-0.4175940155982971,
-0.40585485100746155,
0.28665047883987427,
-0.5241264700889587,
0.07016956806182861,
-0.3829350173473358,
-0.10009869188070297,
-0.36651673913002014,
0.4369102418422699,
0.1355074942111969,
0.4551558792591095,
0.563130795955658,
-0.32173576951026917,
0.43896475434303284,
0.18484695255756378,
-0.25646519660949707,
0.4678363800048828,
-0.8825526833534241,
0.25009429454803467,
0.13170848786830902,
-0.21368488669395447,
-0.8480255007743835,
-0.14767064154148102,
0.6127637028694153,
-0.7256472706794739,
0.524971067905426,
-0.05628383904695511,
-0.09333522617816925,
-0.4884152114391327,
-0.21799178421497345,
0.6129839420318604,
0.23353061079978943,
0.2831358313560486,
0.5763338804244995,
0.5999625325202942,
-0.7507227063179016,
-0.3113917410373688,
-0.48594146966934204,
0.4336458444595337,
-0.05595853552222252,
-0.49503299593925476,
0.42252814769744873,
-0.2138480544090271,
-0.5579703450202942,
-0.1677066534757614,
0.13716134428977966,
-0.11067982763051987,
-0.18776778876781464,
0.294237345457077,
0.12154081463813782,
0.12973527610301971,
0.29842236638069153,
0.11919762194156647,
-0.22336235642433167,
0.5453214645385742,
0.09830988943576813,
0.5479001402854919,
0.11852411925792694,
-0.30834513902664185,
-0.1771104335784912,
0.7042555809020996,
0.3741837739944458,
-0.165562704205513,
0.43848687410354614,
0.35826990008354187,
-0.3221593201160431,
0.13896699249744415,
-0.5420904755592346,
-0.05387904495000839,
-0.3202817440032959,
-0.11444474756717682,
-0.30084607005119324,
-0.7184751629829407,
0.5131128430366516,
-0.3287491500377655,
-0.26151731610298157,
0.4490003287792206,
0.7200005650520325,
-0.0707743912935257,
0.8217048048973083,
0.4647466838359833,
-0.1837076097726822,
0.14745153486728668,
-0.26547929644584656,
0.46974125504493713,
-0.574848473072052,
-0.2604881227016449,
-0.8606517910957336,
-0.32558852434158325,
-0.6156555414199829,
-0.285612553358078,
0.6390513777732849,
-0.19182802736759186,
0.27025845646858215,
-0.11428321897983551,
-0.6556585431098938,
0.16298449039459229,
0.19178131222724915,
-0.06457770615816116,
-0.20813551545143127,
-0.04414042457938194,
-0.3156772553920746,
-0.32372596859931946,
-0.5276786684989929,
-0.21066555380821228,
1.0262902975082397,
0.1705930531024933,
0.5785926580429077,
-0.016064628958702087,
0.7973394393920898,
0.2811109125614166,
0.1638627052307129,
-0.9296441674232483,
0.2773565948009491,
0.09252092987298965,
-0.4727354943752289,
-0.15056036412715912,
-0.26711466908454895,
-1.1072545051574707,
0.1633533537387848,
-0.050716232508420944,
-0.7142665982246399,
0.21839532256126404,
-0.1369539350271225,
-0.6623978614807129,
-0.05660038813948631,
-0.347763329744339,
0.7061557769775391,
-0.32290297746658325,
-0.22673222422599792,
-0.3019680976867676,
-0.9219605922698975,
0.23519054055213928,
-0.07202145457267761,
0.5958007574081421,
0.14038364589214325,
0.15416987240314484,
0.8953847885131836,
-0.6009760499000549,
0.8388919234275818,
-0.16969390213489532,
-0.1256459504365921,
0.26251158118247986,
0.3283345401287079,
0.14525501430034637,
-0.05398167297244072,
-0.09371133148670197,
0.5206548571586609,
0.2453126311302185,
-0.3444978892803192,
-0.7199968099594116,
0.6066789031028748,
-0.46303218603134155,
-0.3771307170391083,
-0.9321893453598022,
-0.25417324900627136,
-0.46916040778160095,
-0.019147876650094986,
0.30750522017478943,
0.22146202623844147,
-0.40482693910598755,
-0.20774568617343903,
0.26160117983818054,
-0.5673081874847412,
0.12134931236505508,
0.6270173192024231,
-0.012946560978889465,
-0.5619155764579773,
0.7311509251594543,
0.09745915979146957,
-0.2556098401546478,
0.2259308099746704,
0.3195326328277588,
-0.07150143384933472,
-0.9401243925094604,
-0.43977513909339905,
0.5404224395751953,
-0.4422632157802582,
-0.19168426096439362,
-0.5900664329528809,
-0.15255294740200043,
-0.7864128947257996,
-0.16293945908546448,
-0.4187198877334595,
0.11944340914487839,
-0.07442203909158707,
-0.0060395956970751286,
0.20992271602153778,
1.1662817001342773,
-0.21279959380626678,
0.1383797973394394,
-1.120042324066162,
0.23632016777992249,
-0.2789304852485657,
0.49845606088638306,
-0.26649346947669983,
0.15880471467971802,
-0.3595253825187683,
-0.2268785685300827,
-0.061165694147348404,
-1.2590746879577637,
0.936152458190918,
-0.09385108202695847,
0.38580018281936646,
0.1369457244873047,
0.0788869634270668,
0.7022528052330017,
-0.3804290294647217,
1.0878572463989258,
0.4644884765148163,
-0.8566504716873169,
0.6126182079315186,
-0.251132994890213,
0.4347628355026245,
0.5594168901443481,
0.6817297339439392,
-0.8519914746284485,
-0.13251656293869019,
-0.40087956190109253,
-0.8240076899528503,
0.8383421301841736,
0.13988424837589264,
-0.017033038660883904,
-0.2481367588043213,
0.35508355498313904,
0.16616186499595642,
0.0812857449054718,
-0.37523096799850464,
-0.3372678756713867,
0.3881903886795044,
-0.3114028871059418,
0.08730723708868027,
-0.5020630359649658,
-0.20875892043113708,
-0.2478892058134079,
0.23902666568756104,
-0.23254843056201935,
0.5294570922851562,
0.3195570111274719,
-0.07575146108865738,
-0.46827274560928345,
0.2542615234851837,
0.663806676864624,
0.8191040754318237,
0.12003062665462494,
-0.11197976022958755,
0.13756635785102844,
-0.7214395999908447,
-0.44345539808273315,
0.017456497997045517,
-0.042660027742385864,
0.02909422665834427,
0.5129319429397583,
0.5167827010154724,
0.4084206819534302,
-0.8457733988761902,
0.35036879777908325,
-0.216565802693367,
-0.42776602506637573,
-0.5145729780197144,
-0.2984265089035034,
-0.22375044226646423,
0.31761738657951355,
0.18977129459381104,
-0.08914761990308762,
0.7616708874702454,
-0.3064991533756256,
-0.26195594668388367,
0.17967970669269562,
-0.5896955132484436,
-0.47659310698509216,
-0.0013187681324779987,
0.1637483835220337,
-0.23724286258220673,
0.6814156174659729,
0.02535335160791874,
-0.7321327924728394,
0.28875845670700073,
0.06203869357705116,
0.8014567494392395,
-0.3862262964248657,
0.159341499209404,
0.5709448456764221,
0.21857312321662903,
0.4301029443740845,
0.8485963940620422,
-0.042042478919029236,
-0.3273617625236511,
-0.2808331251144409,
-0.6863223910331726,
-0.37238621711730957,
-0.24201230704784393,
-0.6215876340866089,
0.08775749057531357,
-0.17934131622314453,
-0.13805656135082245,
0.03874160721898079,
0.09161493927240372,
-0.4688502848148346,
0.2481153905391693,
0.09829255938529968,
0.6351187229156494,
-0.417021244764328,
0.5458423495292664,
0.6531651020050049,
-0.589108407497406,
-0.861672580242157,
-0.13578329980373383,
0.5222184062004089,
-0.6422818303108215,
0.472538024187088,
-0.35336101055145264,
-0.1585838943719864,
-0.3551819920539856,
-0.5285382270812988,
-0.9726346731185913,
0.9238296747207642,
0.08132176101207733,
-0.3597361147403717,
-0.003462414024397731,
0.488808274269104,
0.9444571733474731,
-0.2375941276550293,
0.1933371126651764,
0.5394564867019653,
0.266609787940979,
0.315138041973114,
-1.1938140392303467,
-0.01059683132916689,
-0.8316606879234314,
-0.1720428764820099,
0.403049498796463,
-0.3511873185634613,
0.5836687088012695,
-0.024432435631752014,
-0.30453476309776306,
-0.00031012538238428533,
0.1596902459859848,
0.08189663290977478,
0.42316848039627075,
0.18847660720348358,
0.2745520770549774,
0.5454959869384766,
0.01524425856769085,
1.2929843664169312,
-0.7686066031455994,
0.2042785882949829,
0.5903511643409729,
-0.43218380212783813,
0.34294918179512024,
0.5933123230934143,
-0.4290306568145752,
0.5546021461486816,
0.6099486351013184,
0.22347383201122284,
0.335625559091568,
0.522282063961029,
-0.07396971434354782,
0.04286470636725426,
-0.26401039958000183,
-0.4218035936355591,
0.657781720161438,
0.3549010157585144,
-0.6490809321403503,
0.07063566893339157,
0.20061840116977692,
0.006819063797593117,
0.09929165244102478,
-0.1319703608751297,
1.149965524673462,
0.14945411682128906,
-0.8795108795166016,
0.5901380181312561,
-0.13933706283569336,
0.3213798999786377,
-0.730803370475769,
-0.1506069153547287,
-0.09162222594022751,
-0.1396862119436264,
-0.3533928692340851,
-0.8126183748245239,
0.822455108165741,
0.16350218653678894,
-0.0550733357667923,
-0.46049195528030396,
0.993826687335968,
-0.05510394275188446,
-0.3539994955062866,
0.38110411167144775,
0.5578047037124634,
0.5653526186943054,
-0.12846475839614868,
-0.7038693428039551,
0.4633637070655823,
-0.06773705035448074,
-0.3071945607662201,
0.40386226773262024,
0.2794465124607086,
0.10611332952976227,
0.4293176233768463,
0.6299854516983032,
0.49579039216041565,
-0.3209449052810669,
0.275791734457016,
0.9983299970626831,
-1.026160478591919,
-0.19763368368148804,
-0.6156623959541321,
0.5596693754196167,
-0.03785794600844383,
-0.47891712188720703,
0.47718092799186707,
0.5046459436416626,
0.4096115827560425,
-0.2567932605743408,
0.7818378806114197,
-0.3707162141799927,
0.8533671498298645,
-0.3977251946926117,
0.6853380799293518,
-0.45322614908218384,
-0.00025233151973225176,
-0.6397663950920105,
-0.16696327924728394,
-0.645439863204956,
0.376741498708725,
-0.5676709413528442,
-0.03903454914689064,
0.8773086667060852,
0.5638734102249146,
0.4427623748779297,
0.23268024623394012,
0.2290201336145401,
0.0722302496433258,
0.030079523101449013,
0.3385266959667206,
0.7253839373588562,
-0.25445351004600525,
0.2375124841928482,
-0.5215915441513062,
-0.05345188453793526,
-0.1429961919784546,
-0.518174946308136,
-0.2809503972530365,
-0.5695454478263855,
-0.1639094352722168,
-0.18705032765865326,
-0.10660754144191742,
1.0729082822799683,
0.4625661373138428,
-0.7949337363243103,
-0.6754840612411499,
0.2188597172498703,
0.03548531234264374,
-0.39546331763267517,
-0.13036338984966278,
0.4418000280857086,
-0.4272924065589905,
-0.3937114477157593,
0.2885627746582031,
0.529134213924408,
-0.3875582814216614,
-0.15081991255283356,
-0.3602273464202881,
-0.025952627882361412,
-0.1675213873386383,
0.5337700843811035,
0.39777854084968567,
-0.6568126082420349,
0.4195197820663452,
0.5237398147583008,
-0.26670312881469727,
-0.023472288623452187,
1.5679967403411865,
-0.45043256878852844,
0.7886787056922913,
0.5481662750244141,
0.23827053606510162,
0.16888205707073212,
-0.21135930716991425,
0.8083991408348083,
-0.2401052862405777,
-0.3151451051235199,
0.6312388777732849,
0.4983941614627838,
-0.01930483616888523,
-0.3906124532222748,
0.3835500180721283,
0.2160966992378235,
-0.2837725281715393,
-0.6197224259376526,
-0.052598532289266586,
-1.0732954740524292,
-0.4217838644981384,
1.1758476495742798,
-0.036389682441949844,
-0.2694332003593445,
-0.3731154203414917,
-0.713610053062439,
0.17165060341358185,
-0.07687433063983917,
0.9650912880897522,
0.6251101493835449,
-0.5408198237419128,
-0.2243340015411377,
-0.41547444462776184,
0.735962986946106,
-0.008115649223327637,
-0.7069156169891357,
-0.00880356039851904,
0.6998511552810669,
-0.17891661822795868,
0.4248599112033844,
0.880971372127533,
-0.3842769265174866,
0.42851176857948303,
-0.05304855853319168,
0.5212298035621643,
0.34786632657051086,
-0.009981345385313034,
-0.589225172996521,
0.47158899903297424,
-0.045283619314432144,
0.5128299593925476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00710v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00710v1
|
Homonym Sense Disambiguation in the Georgian Language
| 2024-04-24T21:48:43 | 2024-04-24T21:48:43 |
Davit Melikidze, Alexander Gamkrelidze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This research proposes a novel approach to the Word Sense Disambiguation
(WSD) task in the Georgian language, based on supervised fine-tuning of a
pre-trained Large Language Model (LLM) on a dataset formed by filtering the
Georgian Common Crawls corpus. The dataset is used to train a classifier for
words with multiple senses. Additionally, we present experimental results of
using LSTM for WSD. Accurately disambiguating homonyms is crucial in natural
language processing. Georgian, an agglutinative language belonging to the
Kartvelian language family, presents unique challenges in this context. The aim
of this paper is to highlight the specific problems concerning homonym
disambiguation in the Georgian language and to present our approach to solving
them. The techniques discussed in the article achieve 95% accuracy for
predicting lexical meanings of homonyms using a hand-classified dataset of over
7500 sentences.
|
[
-0.6499183773994446,
-0.7048730850219727,
0.8293412327766418,
-0.19251397252082825,
-0.7129196524620056,
0.11729221791028976,
-0.3568588197231293,
-0.3510773181915283,
0.4087909460067749,
-0.21506401896476746,
-0.5600003600120544,
-0.685801088809967,
-0.8862937688827515,
0.0872676745057106,
0.14220115542411804,
0.49412456154823303,
-0.2586558163166046,
0.5304276347160339,
0.04568840190768242,
-0.36086609959602356,
-0.2545780539512634,
-0.5955613255500793,
-0.06851232051849365,
-0.38022392988204956,
0.6551154851913452,
0.3970552682876587,
0.42007923126220703,
0.5357436537742615,
0.364128440618515,
0.24732346832752228,
-0.41144242882728577,
0.3084467649459839,
-0.11192187666893005,
-0.011148018762469292,
-0.3408994674682617,
-0.22338762879371643,
-0.24386689066886902,
0.2209615260362625,
0.23894909024238586,
0.8989162445068359,
-0.396391361951828,
0.35146552324295044,
-0.2152659296989441,
0.5799693465232849,
-0.5971250534057617,
0.020006198436021805,
-0.6850695013999939,
-0.0026136280503124,
-0.6224785447120667,
0.1563158631324768,
-0.08824588358402252,
-0.2636657953262329,
-0.3087700605392456,
-0.3260481059551239,
0.07308429479598999,
0.11980181187391281,
1.0243172645568848,
-0.1197894737124443,
-0.3670322299003601,
-0.36575040221214294,
-0.4446108043193817,
0.5703874826431274,
-0.697170615196228,
0.6184025406837463,
0.4988287687301636,
0.2252267748117447,
-0.21850651502609253,
-0.4288964569568634,
-0.8838147521018982,
0.08593835681676865,
0.2442215532064438,
-0.05764495208859444,
-0.0953301340341568,
0.029414229094982147,
0.19370220601558685,
0.6124105453491211,
-0.5281985998153687,
0.02337823621928692,
-0.30197516083717346,
-0.14561018347740173,
0.4305899441242218,
0.1267213374376297,
0.19789697229862213,
-0.10490661859512329,
-0.490972101688385,
0.19715078175067902,
-0.2813418507575989,
-0.0335129015147686,
0.5642755627632141,
0.5979346036911011,
0.33898067474365234,
0.6131650805473328,
-0.4182030260562897,
1.084743857383728,
0.13680820167064667,
-0.15041585266590118,
0.48152396082878113,
-0.2101508378982544,
-0.42009925842285156,
-0.12561531364917755,
0.267705500125885,
0.14274705946445465,
0.4024434983730316,
-0.27961838245391846,
-0.1965261995792389,
0.6163259744644165,
0.05196776241064072,
-0.3267783224582672,
-0.0769222229719162,
-0.10292158275842667,
-0.2403097152709961,
-0.17483706772327423,
0.1072855144739151,
-0.7653127908706665,
-0.30151888728141785,
-0.2554470896720886,
0.5941354632377625,
-0.5074300765991211,
0.05005825310945511,
0.508685290813446,
-0.004062707535922527,
0.14843562245368958,
0.14084845781326294,
-1.0652817487716675,
0.27329200506210327,
0.5880220532417297,
0.9219853281974792,
0.11278517544269562,
-0.26387643814086914,
-0.5458433032035828,
0.09291437268257141,
-0.14331509172916412,
0.5158562660217285,
-0.41764119267463684,
-0.3272550404071808,
-0.38123437762260437,
0.036065295338630676,
0.09288081526756287,
-0.3280554413795471,
0.1576324701309204,
-0.4612896144390106,
0.03657524287700653,
-0.2667316496372223,
-0.6115977764129639,
-0.4166436195373535,
0.2611333727836609,
-0.14330564439296722,
0.6517633199691772,
0.3734448254108429,
-0.6240790486335754,
0.7988912463188171,
-0.10402518510818481,
-0.3670977056026459,
0.5212430357933044,
0.08401945978403091,
0.17710578441619873,
0.3974570035934448,
-0.05031806230545044,
0.4284661114215851,
-0.016787998378276825,
0.38214027881622314,
-0.3093804121017456,
-0.10400390625,
-0.34027552604675293,
0.06356397271156311,
0.5921457409858704,
0.25538790225982666,
-0.1634443998336792,
0.20569749176502228,
-0.7093967199325562,
0.2456933557987213,
-0.05910762771964073,
-0.12005359679460526,
-0.8438503742218018,
-0.1581811159849167,
-0.04801476374268532,
0.28887128829956055,
0.3341919183731079,
-0.7333370447158813,
0.2846154570579529,
-0.27342939376831055,
0.2621244490146637,
0.715337336063385,
-0.2898896336555481,
0.31805798411369324,
0.18072694540023804,
0.639171302318573,
0.16716508567333221,
0.2627657949924469,
0.257720023393631,
-0.6241304874420166,
-0.6412926316261292,
-0.10075413435697556,
0.46653029322624207,
0.35418349504470825,
-0.39278697967529297,
0.4579213857650757,
0.03525282442569733,
-0.6435710787773132,
-0.37936949729919434,
0.16341683268547058,
0.18089386820793152,
0.6686499118804932,
0.2889162003993988,
-0.4610368013381958,
-0.3971574306488037,
-0.8747426867485046,
-0.28918081521987915,
-0.1804225593805313,
0.17199036478996277,
0.27533185482025146,
0.3196168541908264,
-0.6201457381248474,
0.5228321552276611,
-0.6549685597419739,
-0.5709959864616394,
-0.04141603410243988,
0.09647941589355469,
0.20412570238113403,
-0.020441953092813492,
0.30420807003974915,
-0.7375738024711609,
-0.2550344467163086,
-0.00651974743232131,
-0.4515358805656433,
0.09748424589633942,
0.4743273854255676,
-0.0679524838924408,
0.23881007730960846,
0.5007725358009338,
-0.4205702543258667,
0.45576414465904236,
0.5330454707145691,
-0.7093948721885681,
0.5133805274963379,
-0.24392549693584442,
-0.09011203795671463,
-1.1184183359146118,
0.014675835147500038,
0.020829128101468086,
-0.3783106207847595,
-0.5468896627426147,
0.5465002655982971,
-0.0051843514665961266,
0.22841019928455353,
-0.39533543586730957,
0.5425504446029663,
-0.8362382650375366,
0.07171421498060226,
-0.17867784202098846,
0.4873672425746918,
-0.17551296949386597,
0.23252545297145844,
-0.20600390434265137,
0.8712106347084045,
0.6499151587486267,
-0.7055846452713013,
1.0159813165664673,
0.5816666483879089,
-0.6281532645225525,
0.3412897288799286,
-0.25977012515068054,
0.11276030540466309,
-0.27897918224334717,
-0.30019280314445496,
-0.8822991847991943,
-0.26094624400138855,
0.3619803786277771,
-0.44584888219833374,
0.0061131133697927,
-0.10666554421186447,
-0.27495276927948,
-0.4735790491104126,
-0.0042572966776788235,
0.25308263301849365,
0.3794018030166626,
-0.5588389039039612,
0.2975876033306122,
0.6437082886695862,
0.14276985824108124,
-0.39105677604675293,
-0.8442786335945129,
0.11467405408620834,
-0.5192471146583557,
-0.6826171875,
-0.09990710020065308,
0.05071425437927246,
-0.7094920873641968,
-0.24130958318710327,
-0.23806388676166534,
-0.1545698493719101,
0.24971872568130493,
0.1876198798418045,
0.2538039982318878,
0.019901446998119354,
0.501743495464325,
-0.38536953926086426,
-0.0625804215669632,
-0.2173364758491516,
-0.47861188650131226,
0.9477391242980957,
-0.40260112285614014,
-0.18555118143558502,
0.27423879504203796,
0.3036958873271942,
0.11679510772228241,
-0.1955980807542801,
0.9236494302749634,
0.5418947339057922,
-0.3311021029949188,
-0.28100210428237915,
-0.2492905855178833,
0.058138102293014526,
-0.41483134031295776,
0.10711389780044556,
-0.6789961457252502,
-0.7302877306938171,
0.7777099609375,
-0.2899340093135834,
-0.4308835566043854,
0.2070970982313156,
0.2740568518638611,
-0.061460286378860474,
0.7104521989822388,
0.5016260743141174,
-0.3965506851673126,
0.052960027009248734,
0.07015222311019897,
0.5357319712638855,
-0.8655828833580017,
-0.26088058948516846,
-0.46100112795829773,
-0.47603732347488403,
-0.5554471611976624,
-0.3673231601715088,
0.10224758088588715,
0.4314522445201874,
0.20515671372413635,
0.31976425647735596,
-0.03766447305679321,
0.1864364892244339,
0.40193700790405273,
0.14202958345413208,
0.3903980851173401,
0.009526185691356659,
-0.4439120292663574,
0.011949262581765652,
-0.5035847425460815,
-0.7469965219497681,
0.5964328050613403,
-0.03906431421637535,
0.802507758140564,
0.43708017468452454,
0.7902329564094543,
0.08362150192260742,
-0.4648738205432892,
-1.2759172916412354,
0.679421603679657,
-0.24688592553138733,
-0.20119433104991913,
-0.3639214336872101,
-0.24530263245105743,
-0.8113996982574463,
0.1365533024072647,
0.042570218443870544,
-0.995838463306427,
0.2525661587715149,
0.03604201599955559,
-0.2456563413143158,
0.35211843252182007,
-0.48737895488739014,
0.7269479036331177,
-0.053092800080776215,
-0.25669899582862854,
-0.12746068835258484,
-0.5159183144569397,
0.46167925000190735,
-0.08274272829294205,
0.33108803629875183,
-0.33081313967704773,
-0.006327134091407061,
0.37419652938842773,
-0.5369347333908081,
0.18737947940826416,
-0.2667365074157715,
-0.41045403480529785,
-0.11752649396657944,
0.2020542472600937,
0.286471962928772,
0.13236616551876068,
-0.2604743242263794,
0.30445215106010437,
-0.035256560891866684,
-0.3590107858181,
-0.2996020019054413,
0.7579749226570129,
-0.13316915929317474,
-0.7194029688835144,
-0.863749623298645,
-0.5420024991035461,
-0.6489204168319702,
0.328061044216156,
0.3829471170902252,
0.31622982025146484,
-0.27739977836608887,
-0.45027753710746765,
0.5630550384521484,
0.1075759306550026,
0.3327670395374298,
0.21007661521434784,
-0.5238445997238159,
0.18375512957572937,
0.6102874875068665,
-0.017952993512153625,
0.21641167998313904,
-0.3313170373439789,
0.09325236827135086,
-0.2966778874397278,
-0.6734387874603271,
-0.6184273958206177,
0.19232212007045746,
-0.47258540987968445,
-0.12646718323230743,
-0.20765697956085205,
0.0339098796248436,
-0.37046757340431213,
0.07581253349781036,
0.17871825397014618,
-0.13934892416000366,
-0.34701651334762573,
-0.08095143735408783,
0.6537585258483887,
0.6540449261665344,
-0.03929242864251137,
0.42755523324012756,
-0.7858985662460327,
0.6737020611763,
0.2569451332092285,
0.7460656762123108,
-0.3065117597579956,
-0.6170920133590698,
-0.24938583374023438,
0.3499172627925873,
0.2552584409713745,
-0.8922865986824036,
0.6067159175872803,
0.37981748580932617,
0.3992076814174652,
0.4825630784034729,
-0.26176881790161133,
1.1023977994918823,
-0.6067677736282349,
0.7931293845176697,
0.16036492586135864,
-1.2242485284805298,
0.5991560220718384,
-0.4534395635128021,
0.339214563369751,
0.6764785051345825,
0.4215683341026306,
-0.916132390499115,
0.03892037644982338,
-0.4215928912162781,
-0.9424018859863281,
0.47551968693733215,
-0.38652583956718445,
0.19065427780151367,
-0.22276441752910614,
0.4838121831417084,
0.2194238156080246,
0.40421411395072937,
-0.20447300374507904,
-0.16029639542102814,
0.35574597120285034,
-0.21262748539447784,
-0.5166139006614685,
-0.39246466755867004,
0.03988775983452797,
-0.549186110496521,
0.8158283829689026,
-0.15047723054885864,
-0.13033020496368408,
-0.13419489562511444,
-0.5370292067527771,
-0.07782537490129471,
0.34702426195144653,
0.7081950306892395,
1.0036165714263916,
-0.05788741633296013,
0.3370862901210785,
0.09806330502033234,
-0.8114763498306274,
0.38345375657081604,
-0.32578417658805847,
-0.14367298781871796,
0.299296110868454,
-0.17018082737922668,
0.9973949193954468,
-0.29891055822372437,
-0.5378908514976501,
0.33049607276916504,
0.04665951058268547,
-0.1375443935394287,
-0.3192829191684723,
0.0466497503221035,
0.21449483931064606,
0.16614024341106415,
0.3951959013938904,
0.011243212968111038,
0.18375031650066376,
-0.8354156613349915,
0.27858731150627136,
0.6020528674125671,
-0.19612933695316315,
-0.23768538236618042,
0.3823971748352051,
-0.21805241703987122,
-0.20784059166908264,
0.3116419017314911,
-0.46192556619644165,
-0.6694657206535339,
0.16773226857185364,
0.37835943698883057,
0.562272846698761,
-0.4557688534259796,
0.35190773010253906,
0.21176543831825256,
0.12950442731380463,
-0.3327641785144806,
0.7944535613059998,
0.12368080765008926,
-0.9540277719497681,
-0.007068882696330547,
-0.9908086657524109,
0.036802176386117935,
0.1568273901939392,
-0.9562299847602844,
0.3849855065345764,
-0.5554651021957397,
-0.25621065497398376,
0.04654264822602272,
-0.006476544309407473,
-0.228921577334404,
0.3690175414085388,
0.21140322089195251,
0.9118855595588684,
-0.8739587664604187,
0.8737406134605408,
0.9019128680229187,
-0.22082948684692383,
-1.0699598789215088,
0.09341450780630112,
-0.08024392277002335,
-0.7195537686347961,
0.7240033149719238,
-0.19343328475952148,
-0.4500872492790222,
0.3351040482521057,
-0.35360029339790344,
-0.49970853328704834,
0.7185570597648621,
0.1476205289363861,
-1.0859487056732178,
0.06819446384906769,
-0.15290942788124084,
0.5265291333198547,
-0.06798641383647919,
-0.25533393025398254,
0.7184699773788452,
0.7099308967590332,
0.02185787260532379,
-0.8405752182006836,
-0.23630164563655853,
-0.2466876059770584,
0.09811194986104965,
0.6477386355400085,
-0.6161555647850037,
0.9940631985664368,
-0.13582834601402283,
-0.3167257308959961,
-0.0346420556306839,
0.6504347920417786,
0.05184211581945419,
0.31292158365249634,
0.5240074992179871,
0.8313916921615601,
1.049405813217163,
-0.24163006246089935,
0.6607877612113953,
-0.13210918009281158,
0.4537375271320343,
1.0935674905776978,
-0.4437585175037384,
0.5865859985351562,
0.996088445186615,
-0.337413489818573,
0.3663116991519928,
0.8770949840545654,
-0.11097317188978195,
0.4970545172691345,
0.5319516062736511,
-0.7285735011100769,
-0.32271361351013184,
0.0099656255915761,
-0.2624996602535248,
0.9824398159980774,
0.2362588346004486,
-0.06089162081480026,
-0.3705134093761444,
0.4062974750995636,
-0.009987683966755867,
0.37330710887908936,
-0.6013258695602417,
0.7690324783325195,
0.09224812686443329,
-0.17402417957782745,
0.44577065110206604,
0.25923803448677063,
0.8546179533004761,
-0.6336982250213623,
0.24598580598831177,
-0.2994268834590912,
0.2501566410064697,
-0.22289122641086578,
-0.5574097633361816,
0.4073501229286194,
0.0998321995139122,
-0.2619189918041229,
0.03440147265791893,
0.6736104488372803,
-0.6871965527534485,
-0.5444956421852112,
0.4032875597476959,
0.7065415978431702,
0.3586843013763428,
-0.006992099341005087,
-0.06726188957691193,
-0.19136473536491394,
-0.10879877209663391,
0.08124309778213501,
0.30076977610588074,
0.45524823665618896,
-0.31813767552375793,
0.5948794484138489,
0.32463786005973816,
0.8830650448799133,
0.3797295093536377,
0.10897307097911835,
0.5093424320220947,
-0.7927311062812805,
-0.6965829133987427,
-0.8588327765464783,
-0.11805452406406403,
0.3662288784980774,
-0.2972356677055359,
1.090773105621338,
0.4156234562397003,
1.0147675275802612,
-0.2809210419654846,
0.6141124367713928,
-0.19490176439285278,
0.4457799196243286,
-0.4024931788444519,
0.9222410917282104,
-0.5635080337524414,
-0.09308318048715591,
-0.2084238976240158,
-0.8818253874778748,
-0.12342708557844162,
1.0491348505020142,
-0.061030756682157516,
0.04996730759739876,
0.49386101961135864,
0.5413277745246887,
-0.4285018742084503,
-0.07480200380086899,
0.5552821755409241,
0.20352225005626678,
-0.3322651982307434,
0.36383211612701416,
0.6667359471321106,
-0.43920832872390747,
-0.3059855103492737,
-0.07211391627788544,
0.0015613292343914509,
0.006626948714256287,
-0.7658355832099915,
-0.45071378350257874,
-0.9469351172447205,
0.014020050875842571,
-0.16233062744140625,
0.11981841176748276,
0.741229236125946,
0.424776166677475,
-0.8025835156440735,
-0.26409435272216797,
-0.16767987608909607,
-0.20502951741218567,
-0.005842892918735743,
-0.1430337280035019,
-0.035350583493709564,
-0.4177797734737396,
-0.8024389147758484,
0.5590913891792297,
0.1068250834941864,
-0.05782420560717583,
-0.24936455488204956,
0.06279055774211884,
-0.8395575881004333,
-0.06604621559381485,
0.5567705035209656,
-0.04042978957295418,
-0.7368860244750977,
-0.7035440802574158,
-0.16864116489887238,
-0.17139063775539398,
-0.04003732278943062,
0.5341700315475464,
-0.86546790599823,
0.4212646484375,
0.5443110466003418,
0.13782547414302826,
0.4271189272403717,
0.2898890972137451,
0.41602611541748047,
-0.6620633006095886,
0.5314620137214661,
-0.03933031111955643,
0.39233869314193726,
0.26994359493255615,
-0.5363941192626953,
0.49256083369255066,
0.4509257674217224,
-0.039177894592285156,
-0.8428121209144592,
0.3393391966819763,
-0.9743571877479553,
-0.21957270801067352,
1.208565354347229,
-0.20631474256515503,
-0.3137015998363495,
-0.3078610897064209,
0.05253596231341362,
0.4827410578727722,
0.07141430675983429,
0.8506823182106018,
1.1321436166763306,
0.15959803760051727,
-0.09397715330123901,
-0.31000885367393494,
0.5254983901977539,
0.31178009510040283,
-0.5684409141540527,
0.06964448094367981,
0.7581939101219177,
0.4644637703895569,
-0.08681314438581467,
0.21877172589302063,
0.10299710929393768,
-0.028666839003562927,
-0.29517289996147156,
0.3391810655593872,
-0.36964789032936096,
-0.41831377148628235,
-0.8446072936058044,
-0.1416151076555252,
-0.005522405728697777,
-0.5102668404579163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16206v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16206v1
|
Knowledge Graph Completion using Structural and Textual Embeddings
| 2024-04-24T21:04:14 | 2024-04-24T21:04:14 |
Sakher Khalil Alqaaidi, Krzysztof Kochut
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.4
|
Knowledge Graphs (KGs) are widely employed in artificial intelligence
applications, such as question-answering and recommendation systems. However,
KGs are frequently found to be incomplete. While much of the existing
literature focuses on predicting missing nodes for given incomplete KG triples,
there remains an opportunity to complete KGs by exploring relations between
existing nodes, a task known as relation prediction. In this study, we propose
a relations prediction model that harnesses both textual and structural
information within KGs. Our approach integrates walks-based embeddings with
language model embeddings to effectively represent nodes. We demonstrate that
our model achieves competitive results in the relation prediction task when
evaluated on a widely used dataset.
|
[
-0.11824691295623779,
-0.6257025599479675,
1.0760858058929443,
-0.07938782125711441,
-0.13130700588226318,
0.17095032334327698,
0.31934037804603577,
-0.550846517086029,
0.5765424966812134,
0.4882824718952179,
-0.37435808777809143,
-0.5666014552116394,
-0.7004336714744568,
-0.07643939554691315,
-0.04353823512792587,
0.6130586862564087,
-0.2845461070537567,
-0.054443713277578354,
-0.9169405698776245,
0.027390647679567337,
-0.6324247121810913,
-0.15632624924182892,
-0.4309271275997162,
-0.9118987917900085,
0.6126733422279358,
0.10505534708499908,
1.0756816864013672,
0.8679181337356567,
0.027117105200886726,
0.23269318044185638,
-0.15122190117835999,
0.33381879329681396,
-0.3549795150756836,
0.4740857779979706,
0.07068277150392532,
-0.21388129889965057,
-0.4993126690387726,
-0.16801629960536957,
0.5717763900756836,
1.1734172105789185,
0.20874209702014923,
-0.1570865958929062,
0.007232369389384985,
0.6632106304168701,
-0.25963714718818665,
0.7957922220230103,
-0.456339955329895,
0.2604467570781708,
0.04309726133942604,
-0.14361093938350677,
-0.3663328289985657,
-0.4469648599624634,
0.38305142521858215,
-0.7315443754196167,
-0.3382052779197693,
0.3016866445541382,
0.5672535300254822,
-0.00706248776987195,
-0.9176520109176636,
-0.378094881772995,
-0.5648159980773926,
0.09740429371595383,
-0.2689197361469269,
0.7944560050964355,
1.1376709938049316,
0.30796104669570923,
-0.23860689997673035,
-0.6549498438835144,
-0.1381397545337677,
-0.27495330572128296,
-0.686513364315033,
-0.0013782473979517817,
0.03151155635714531,
-0.06711096316576004,
0.03896213322877884,
0.23869164288043976,
-0.2349364012479782,
-0.5115063786506653,
-0.35720953345298767,
0.1038188710808754,
0.3083615303039551,
0.15686392784118652,
0.33420905470848083,
-0.5046505331993103,
-0.1954551786184311,
0.22806400060653687,
-0.534182071685791,
-0.12008646130561829,
0.25710731744766235,
0.3489687442779541,
0.008886298164725304,
0.8101041316986084,
-0.22919826209545135,
0.9900988340377808,
-0.13088051974773407,
-0.05119309946894646,
0.35933494567871094,
-0.30834123492240906,
-0.012038657441735268,
-0.11047841608524323,
0.7965681552886963,
0.41091302037239075,
0.6190623641014099,
-0.7404276132583618,
0.13867640495300293,
-0.16601642966270447,
0.14375385642051697,
-0.48501554131507874,
-0.5394306778907776,
0.18120548129081726,
-0.21075737476348877,
-0.20390024781227112,
-0.15522415935993195,
-0.2954341173171997,
-0.5170888304710388,
-0.18800650537014008,
0.20874348282814026,
-0.7989913821220398,
-0.43556520342826843,
-0.2512495219707489,
-0.5380082726478577,
-0.39089494943618774,
0.19959640502929688,
-0.5312978029251099,
0.28434982895851135,
0.3344888985157013,
0.917202889919281,
0.38056930899620056,
-0.3345733880996704,
-0.36946356296539307,
0.9166927933692932,
-0.28605490922927856,
0.520319938659668,
-0.7962478995323181,
-0.4075559079647064,
0.016323843970894814,
-0.2281937450170517,
-0.0368768610060215,
-0.08803558349609375,
0.3502157926559448,
-0.9123759269714355,
-0.12538810074329376,
-0.26335105299949646,
-0.9760909676551819,
-0.14752212166786194,
0.6848517656326294,
-1.0404410362243652,
1.2023541927337646,
0.22879715263843536,
-1.2020784616470337,
0.03722758591175079,
-0.08133330941200256,
-0.6919845938682556,
0.03381309285759926,
-0.13605713844299316,
-0.4304834008216858,
-0.5214177966117859,
0.1781480461359024,
0.8699733018875122,
-0.13846257328987122,
0.3701123595237732,
-0.653598427772522,
-0.09779965132474899,
-0.06299156695604324,
0.5847322940826416,
0.42278221249580383,
-0.1220129057765007,
0.16439124941825867,
-0.2116461843252182,
-0.8015404939651489,
0.027695974335074425,
0.14399133622646332,
-0.23724190890789032,
-0.805016279220581,
0.3243713676929474,
-0.6161192655563354,
0.2415282130241394,
0.21411143243312836,
-0.5741276144981384,
0.12854677438735962,
-0.4585806131362915,
0.2306162267923355,
0.5196923017501831,
0.28968313336372375,
0.6572492122650146,
-0.2366544008255005,
0.5071142911911011,
-0.10180330276489258,
-0.26440882682800293,
0.05115518346428871,
-0.8854185938835144,
-0.3236500322818756,
0.4094306528568268,
0.3302448093891144,
0.3271631598472595,
-1.0288289785385132,
0.38658878207206726,
-0.685196042060852,
-0.8232942223548889,
-0.0019221367547288537,
0.04323875904083252,
0.4614398181438446,
0.3955146074295044,
0.3158608675003052,
0.1391582190990448,
-0.6002657413482666,
-0.42788589000701904,
-0.32550162076950073,
-0.49935346841812134,
0.053544800728559494,
0.6164805293083191,
0.4478616416454315,
-0.21311470866203308,
1.1591110229492188,
-0.9536446928977966,
-0.517946720123291,
-0.2163119912147522,
-0.25086620450019836,
0.08119476586580276,
0.07796457409858704,
0.4132741391658783,
-0.7850910425186157,
-0.7958031296730042,
0.30907994508743286,
-0.8873475193977356,
0.5746020674705505,
0.5418067574501038,
-0.21966606378555298,
-0.46995314955711365,
0.4387325942516327,
-0.5239582657814026,
0.4680343568325043,
0.5388412475585938,
-0.7094229459762573,
0.28196436166763306,
0.0855153426527977,
-0.10082686692476273,
-1.2638096809387207,
-0.1630149483680725,
-0.08081217855215073,
-0.665907084941864,
-0.5145312547683716,
-0.4413924515247345,
0.10729924589395523,
-0.13134676218032837,
0.18176674842834473,
0.6786265969276428,
-0.42099234461784363,
-0.16321434080600739,
0.37787529826164246,
0.515889585018158,
0.10881925374269485,
0.6002810597419739,
0.14810506999492645,
0.014233233407139778,
0.42603713274002075,
-0.5522528290748596,
0.4358859062194824,
0.6683533787727356,
-0.08338861167430878,
0.19644960761070251,
-0.6264134645462036,
0.07779435813426971,
-0.11294645816087723,
0.2806890308856964,
-0.9465560913085938,
-0.37929147481918335,
0.17274998128414154,
-0.7992777228355408,
0.17586927115917206,
-0.5860621929168701,
-0.36070793867111206,
-0.4574517607688904,
-0.2493310123682022,
0.479392409324646,
0.11735849827528,
-0.2598840892314911,
1.1053394079208374,
0.6190927028656006,
-0.05902046337723732,
-0.5754616856575012,
-0.5201303362846375,
-0.19054456055164337,
0.37632158398628235,
-0.7444044351577759,
0.44599610567092896,
0.26192522048950195,
0.11360371112823486,
0.8078805208206177,
0.1598983108997345,
-0.06346634030342102,
-0.08198431879281998,
0.627291202545166,
-0.01593898795545101,
0.11224927753210068,
0.5020659565925598,
-0.20484621822834015,
0.022387877106666565,
0.10497802495956421,
-0.2592659890651703,
0.5127496123313904,
0.17357666790485382,
-0.31659558415412903,
0.0023421836085617542,
-0.009963969700038433,
0.6418043375015259,
-0.0013686433667317033,
0.9187535047531128,
0.23283885419368744,
-0.6564967632293701,
0.044464174658060074,
-0.32544443011283875,
0.21771861612796783,
-0.3888111710548401,
0.5174199342727661,
-0.5093804597854614,
-0.8462352156639099,
0.4093731641769409,
-0.04821218550205231,
-0.3039906322956085,
0.4021401107311249,
0.00003113807906629518,
-0.01226760447025299,
0.9622917175292969,
0.7019003629684448,
-0.2114131897687912,
0.37737172842025757,
-0.27569591999053955,
0.39807188510894775,
-0.8518543839454651,
-0.7842462062835693,
-0.4481481909751892,
-0.009245045483112335,
-0.5847511887550354,
-0.27951422333717346,
0.46055543422698975,
0.3600828945636749,
-0.29236942529678345,
0.7042965292930603,
-0.010408599860966206,
0.3916400969028473,
0.4457521140575409,
0.17256297171115875,
0.42248964309692383,
0.11745671927928925,
-0.6916684508323669,
0.10327029973268509,
-0.911891520023346,
-0.192414790391922,
1.0594432353973389,
0.29818686842918396,
0.42339959740638733,
0.06741013377904892,
0.7546160817146301,
0.36719292402267456,
0.39700132608413696,
-0.8986311554908752,
0.25693410634994507,
0.14431647956371307,
-0.327200323343277,
-0.3707842528820038,
-0.725915253162384,
-0.9828306436538696,
-0.13229693472385406,
-0.35229820013046265,
-0.7137542366981506,
-0.21367229521274567,
0.02034143917262554,
-0.08476879447698593,
0.48791176080703735,
-0.30563443899154663,
0.7440870404243469,
0.11204097419977188,
-0.12653881311416626,
-0.11008952558040619,
-0.5870877504348755,
0.23494049906730652,
0.10967418551445007,
0.40311291813850403,
-0.10757690668106079,
0.4223986864089966,
1.0456881523132324,
-0.4441819190979004,
0.6998971104621887,
-0.11132442951202393,
0.3260669410228729,
0.2712642550468445,
0.2146393209695816,
0.8801164627075195,
-0.19193986058235168,
-0.36908310651779175,
-0.2605822682380676,
-0.032206106930971146,
-0.228464275598526,
-0.6963819861412048,
0.4372488558292389,
-0.8891560435295105,
-0.20210838317871094,
-0.30931612849235535,
-0.3906994163990021,
-0.7993608117103577,
0.3180930018424988,
-0.24313807487487793,
0.5721673965454102,
-0.29256078600883484,
0.07506253570318222,
0.10966932773590088,
0.10879245400428772,
0.10129843652248383,
0.013721602037549019,
-0.6145164370536804,
-0.835152268409729,
0.7311202883720398,
0.31058189272880554,
0.07975651323795319,
0.3690274655818939,
0.17068876326084137,
-0.533067524433136,
-0.13816429674625397,
-0.2951807975769043,
0.4875834882259369,
-0.7727116346359253,
-0.585294246673584,
-1.0968773365020752,
-0.4532020688056946,
-0.6627278923988342,
-0.01825999841094017,
-0.1393962800502777,
-0.3673354983329773,
0.07707177847623825,
-0.4851735830307007,
0.5028431415557861,
1.5715771913528442,
0.28679075837135315,
0.16407687962055206,
-0.9877201914787292,
0.18506217002868652,
0.4068591892719269,
0.721460223197937,
0.5410406589508057,
0.06533178687095642,
-0.6348820328712463,
-0.0941590815782547,
-0.3474698066711426,
-1.110669493675232,
0.11765586584806442,
0.03746999055147171,
0.494192898273468,
0.2523546516895294,
-0.014135007746517658,
0.6215432286262512,
-0.6476046442985535,
0.4847249388694763,
0.41058510541915894,
-0.6268346905708313,
0.658309817314148,
-0.568951427936554,
-0.19016148149967194,
0.22840695083141327,
0.751236617565155,
-0.6390848159790039,
-0.3626388609409332,
-0.8239802122116089,
-0.6979731917381287,
0.6308506727218628,
0.46314722299575806,
-0.23024044930934906,
-0.22566071152687073,
0.240869402885437,
-0.3506244719028473,
0.2726757526397705,
-0.8392186164855957,
-0.396878182888031,
0.019513169303536415,
-0.3097517490386963,
0.2281946986913681,
-0.4372596740722656,
0.12304297834634781,
-0.3545010983943939,
1.0017739534378052,
0.13907189667224884,
0.2659212648868561,
0.07462665438652039,
0.14089344441890717,
-0.31727179884910583,
-0.1905939280986786,
-0.3467356264591217,
0.7689909338951111,
-0.3915855586528778,
0.1350143402814865,
-0.13406914472579956,
-0.20175951719284058,
0.11804933100938797,
0.18994365632534027,
-0.16892755031585693,
0.17014728486537933,
0.5022894740104675,
0.6384497284889221,
0.25123506784439087,
-0.2422739714384079,
0.6127238273620605,
0.21119572222232819,
-0.01651088148355484,
-0.3639962077140808,
-0.4764576554298401,
0.7779066562652588,
0.25778812170028687,
0.19030247628688812,
0.04496779292821884,
-0.09414444118738174,
-0.6164970397949219,
0.26685672998428345,
0.367125928401947,
-0.7847214937210083,
-0.17980749905109406,
0.5445139408111572,
0.19949860870838165,
-0.28830671310424805,
0.5161279439926147,
-0.3689301013946533,
-1.035143494606018,
0.5629236102104187,
0.4587159752845764,
0.4107755124568939,
-0.16252011060714722,
0.3631189167499542,
0.5548208355903625,
0.16530703008174896,
-0.09342561662197113,
0.07897401601076126,
0.024589747190475464,
-1.014435052871704,
-0.2618768513202667,
-0.9181312322616577,
-0.3883756399154663,
-0.40144822001457214,
-0.34033527970314026,
0.287729948759079,
-0.3429926335811615,
-0.27623048424720764,
-0.1912229061126709,
0.20667606592178345,
-0.7344746589660645,
0.3178282082080841,
-0.039542775601148605,
0.6892244815826416,
-0.9088552594184875,
0.9814662337303162,
0.6999594569206238,
-0.4313775599002838,
-1.1464850902557373,
-0.23919647932052612,
-0.3827367126941681,
-0.5904248356819153,
0.6472747921943665,
0.15943080186843872,
-0.17369702458381653,
-0.09627679735422134,
0.1282181590795517,
-1.2488741874694824,
1.4017301797866821,
0.22749438881874084,
-0.1272943615913391,
-0.21738730370998383,
0.2741374671459198,
0.23404560983181,
-0.47778838872909546,
0.1688176840543747,
0.3499128520488739,
0.5500165820121765,
0.3964320421218872,
-0.6405520439147949,
0.2000700682401657,
-0.32889625430107117,
-0.11314939707517624,
0.4356177747249603,
-0.2522612512111664,
0.7278972864151001,
-0.0060710241086781025,
-0.05737190321087837,
-0.010388319380581379,
0.7236321568489075,
0.17466102540493011,
0.4625382423400879,
0.4468013644218445,
0.8312953114509583,
0.9823119044303894,
0.033742208033800125,
1.0525703430175781,
-0.3683043122291565,
0.29802602529525757,
1.306731939315796,
-0.20977677404880524,
0.9064245820045471,
0.06986458599567413,
-0.5181255340576172,
0.9359109401702881,
0.6852615475654602,
0.16974124312400818,
0.5368516445159912,
-0.22715453803539276,
0.04515524581074715,
-0.2695169746875763,
-0.3661961257457733,
-0.577305257320404,
0.18422865867614746,
0.45241570472717285,
-0.6388857960700989,
-0.030797256156802177,
-0.46279069781303406,
0.07852685451507568,
0.004430610220879316,
-0.261687308549881,
0.71969074010849,
0.05488481745123863,
-0.6996065974235535,
0.02287309616804123,
-0.050190165638923645,
0.11499138176441193,
-0.6662020087242126,
-0.16080398857593536,
0.027666000649333,
-0.17048236727714539,
-0.22080650925636292,
-0.8974725604057312,
0.2850264608860016,
-0.5710265040397644,
-0.41825035214424133,
-0.0746140331029892,
1.0531575679779053,
-0.7719468474388123,
-0.587452232837677,
0.9599188566207886,
0.8563772439956665,
-0.21921631693840027,
-0.0950191393494606,
-0.20290064811706543,
-0.493502140045166,
0.024213241413235664,
-0.15362808108329773,
0.0869627296924591,
0.5713711977005005,
0.04667532071471214,
0.7071271538734436,
0.3555491864681244,
0.004111603368073702,
-0.13970167934894562,
-0.17252099514007568,
1.2340052127838135,
-0.5474463701248169,
-0.5235958099365234,
-0.8123171329498291,
0.3433206081390381,
-0.31250280141830444,
0.17255690693855286,
0.6733841300010681,
0.5261845588684082,
0.5150976181030273,
0.19969207048416138,
0.9358000159263611,
-0.2199687957763672,
0.45040860772132874,
-0.44634294509887695,
0.6103372573852539,
-0.5144234299659729,
0.04918721318244934,
-0.40901800990104675,
-0.8697510957717896,
-0.04827796667814255,
0.22738610208034515,
-0.4144904315471649,
0.14844749867916107,
0.9266365170478821,
0.37430933117866516,
-0.15852564573287964,
0.06076085940003395,
0.33657747507095337,
0.28869563341140747,
-0.07358900457620621,
0.6437435746192932,
0.6668171882629395,
-0.43662574887275696,
0.7787084579467773,
-0.3178282380104065,
0.08955729007720947,
0.16365276277065277,
-0.8449772596359253,
-1.1765868663787842,
-0.7499780654907227,
-0.08739664405584335,
-0.7122789621353149,
0.039610836654901505,
0.6562392115592957,
0.4568954408168793,
-0.3722371757030487,
-0.162189319729805,
-0.022192755714058876,
0.6464349031448364,
0.11708652973175049,
-0.1487642228603363,
0.6745834350585938,
-0.050986938178539276,
-0.2082531452178955,
0.34355461597442627,
0.2480693757534027,
-0.021311933174729347,
-0.04947741702198982,
-0.30229681730270386,
-0.6048774719238281,
-0.2387019246816635,
0.5673830509185791,
-0.16994057595729828,
-0.39915207028388977,
-0.2478751838207245,
-0.17683303356170654,
0.1698562204837799,
-0.04371197521686554,
0.7211154103279114,
-1.032881259918213,
0.43325090408325195,
0.5399987101554871,
0.6628934144973755,
0.7330843806266785,
-0.08292394876480103,
0.9280121922492981,
-1.2327156066894531,
-0.2363581359386444,
0.20753613114356995,
0.6762004494667053,
0.5556744337081909,
-0.4836253225803375,
0.9549749493598938,
0.3417484760284424,
-0.1528237909078598,
-0.25955137610435486,
0.34923237562179565,
-0.6160072684288025,
-0.18446224927902222,
1.225265383720398,
-0.5401533246040344,
-0.27535128593444824,
-0.4591448903083801,
0.19804596900939941,
0.5899059772491455,
-0.28402936458587646,
0.2411535233259201,
0.7975322604179382,
-0.06025442108511925,
0.2864042818546295,
-0.4005204141139984,
0.514310896396637,
0.06741578876972198,
-0.3755064308643341,
-0.0008751061977818608,
0.4420517086982727,
0.1659410446882248,
0.4615848660469055,
0.8421630859375,
0.08880191296339035,
-0.08836666494607925,
-0.03976894170045853,
-0.36805441975593567,
-0.42138490080833435,
-0.35908135771751404,
0.7247576117515564,
0.5037962794303894,
0.20686379075050354,
0.2397836297750473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16198v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16198v1
|
Towards Efficient Patient Recruitment for Clinical Trials: Application of a Prompt-Based Learning Model
| 2024-04-24T20:42:28 | 2024-04-24T20:42:28 |
Mojdeh Rahmanian, Seyed Mostafa Fakhrahmad, Seyedeh Zahra Mousavi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.7
|
Objective: Clinical trials are essential for advancing pharmaceutical
interventions, but they face a bottleneck in selecting eligible participants.
Although leveraging electronic health records (EHR) for recruitment has gained
popularity, the complex nature of unstructured medical texts presents
challenges in efficiently identifying participants. Natural Language Processing
(NLP) techniques have emerged as a solution with a recent focus on transformer
models. In this study, we aimed to evaluate the performance of a prompt-based
large language model for the cohort selection task from unstructured medical
notes collected in the EHR. Methods: To process the medical records, we
selected the most related sentences of the records to the eligibility criteria
needed for the trial. The SNOMED CT concepts related to each eligibility
criterion were collected. Medical records were also annotated with MedCAT based
on the SNOMED CT ontology. Annotated sentences including concepts matched with
the criteria-relevant terms were extracted. A prompt-based large language model
(Generative Pre-trained Transformer (GPT) in this study) was then used with the
extracted sentences as the training set. To assess its effectiveness, we
evaluated the model's performance using the dataset from the 2018 n2c2
challenge, which aimed to classify medical records of 311 patients based on 13
eligibility criteria through NLP techniques. Results: Our proposed model showed
the overall micro and macro F measures of 0.9061 and 0.8060 which were among
the highest scores achieved by the experiments performed with this dataset.
Conclusion: The application of a prompt-based large language model in this
study to classify patients based on eligibility criteria received promising
scores. Besides, we proposed a method of extractive summarization with the aid
of SNOMED CT ontology that can be also applied to other medical texts.
|
[
0.12452852725982666,
-0.6633489727973938,
0.8208311200141907,
0.08302129060029984,
-0.2851834297180176,
-0.16433601081371307,
-0.16898727416992188,
-0.3105207085609436,
-0.05820946767926216,
0.6227994561195374,
-0.546434223651886,
-0.6420349478721619,
-0.5822354555130005,
0.5061836838722229,
-0.3194938004016876,
1.1324864625930786,
0.013514895923435688,
0.2369062453508377,
-0.20766384899616241,
-0.07763340324163437,
-0.8580499291419983,
-0.49339208006858826,
-0.7902328968048096,
-0.29207292199134827,
0.3839219808578491,
0.5108917355537415,
0.22875384986400604,
0.39504292607307434,
0.7624171376228333,
0.2359321564435959,
-0.20855486392974854,
-0.0805627852678299,
-0.3582252264022827,
0.36864566802978516,
0.005673607345670462,
-0.7849095463752747,
-0.0360330231487751,
0.11695586889982224,
0.232217475771904,
0.6194049715995789,
-0.4548114240169525,
0.026602772995829582,
0.032985392957925797,
0.3895151615142822,
-0.07231798022985458,
0.06697936356067657,
-0.49783921241760254,
0.23168285191059113,
-0.08904770761728287,
-0.34967824816703796,
-0.7056481838226318,
-0.4548663794994354,
0.5243449211120605,
-0.6657777428627014,
0.6576189398765564,
0.25774598121643066,
0.712016761302948,
0.06969720125198364,
-0.38429105281829834,
-0.8744074702262878,
-0.2776136100292206,
0.6949121952056885,
-0.46773067116737366,
0.24388177692890167,
0.375209242105484,
0.6863626837730408,
-0.2558606266975403,
-0.8544777035713196,
-0.30853816866874695,
-0.5050799250602722,
-0.19323892891407013,
0.18657970428466797,
0.0800909772515297,
0.20374947786331177,
0.36712709069252014,
0.49681565165519714,
-0.749131977558136,
0.3643374741077423,
-0.45939019322395325,
-0.22122925519943237,
0.5051388144493103,
0.43166670203208923,
0.49392247200012207,
-0.35706523060798645,
-0.44586434960365295,
-0.0653163343667984,
-0.30158761143684387,
0.2178167700767517,
-0.1730685830116272,
0.5966734290122986,
-0.2121315449476242,
0.8137795925140381,
-0.1692742258310318,
0.435942143201828,
0.19545167684555054,
-0.09737203270196915,
0.1862165480852127,
-0.361154705286026,
0.022637663409113884,
0.1914234757423401,
0.8166072964668274,
0.3442588150501251,
0.03667579963803291,
-0.16951797902584076,
-0.22728686034679413,
0.13485105335712433,
0.3700902462005615,
-0.9273335933685303,
-0.026036366820335388,
0.4396574795246124,
-0.8605791926383972,
-0.14849594235420227,
-0.17393934726715088,
-0.9699477553367615,
-0.2956531345844269,
-0.18620054423809052,
0.2652144730091095,
-0.5764272809028625,
0.2244938164949417,
0.1685582846403122,
-0.3173408806324005,
0.12054518610239029,
0.5937827229499817,
-0.6958094239234924,
0.3526339530944824,
0.5574771761894226,
1.0038700103759766,
-0.4056836664676666,
0.2110118269920349,
-0.6609675288200378,
-0.3185654878616333,
0.08984635025262833,
0.5629392266273499,
-0.33862531185150146,
-0.6306719183921814,
0.18181391060352325,
0.2542267143726349,
-0.5275861620903015,
-0.5622614026069641,
0.9048883318901062,
-0.5986790657043457,
0.6797275543212891,
-0.12889356911182404,
-0.7947468757629395,
0.03764237090945244,
0.2939356863498688,
-0.7175877690315247,
0.7564440369606018,
0.3768087923526764,
-0.5189850926399231,
0.41307905316352844,
-0.5480282306671143,
-0.2561301290988922,
0.43733105063438416,
-0.2890337109565735,
-0.6172726154327393,
0.019417351111769676,
0.10654702037572861,
0.4291023015975952,
-0.5505414605140686,
0.4624009132385254,
0.1679898053407669,
-0.2249179631471634,
0.23811884224414825,
0.07288067042827606,
0.7344421744346619,
0.37894782423973083,
-0.14122307300567627,
-0.03569844365119934,
-0.6363701224327087,
-0.28188997507095337,
0.16659903526306152,
-0.6881117820739746,
-0.23444926738739014,
-0.28301918506622314,
0.2695688307285309,
0.47409889101982117,
-0.1603916436433792,
-0.6216443181037903,
0.307032972574234,
-0.5589127540588379,
0.12749777734279633,
0.19636137783527374,
0.2690953314304352,
0.26420584321022034,
-0.2774072289466858,
0.6898565292358398,
-0.24974606931209564,
0.24749411642551422,
-0.28550925850868225,
-0.6612507700920105,
-0.2571539282798767,
-0.26078733801841736,
0.4227093756198883,
0.7344111800193787,
-0.9760482907295227,
0.5968065857887268,
-0.27569299936294556,
-0.32574811577796936,
-0.4161508083343506,
-0.11466121673583984,
0.4438330829143524,
0.9291005730628967,
0.49146464467048645,
-0.20327913761138916,
-0.46290525794029236,
-0.5545064806938171,
-0.08899395912885666,
-0.1051831766963005,
-0.22296716272830963,
0.2942497432231903,
0.6315053701400757,
-0.17018289864063263,
0.7813007235527039,
-0.6121615171432495,
-0.6930386424064636,
-0.7080907821655273,
0.14814314246177673,
0.5595590472221375,
0.3007766902446747,
0.2699732780456543,
-0.8897045254707336,
-0.5042727589607239,
-0.032142966985702515,
-0.8098874092102051,
-0.2612406313419342,
-0.21244727075099945,
0.13575665652751923,
-0.019703039899468422,
0.4443085193634033,
-0.6101296544075012,
0.5321810841560364,
0.3018510639667511,
-0.4762873649597168,
0.16359877586364746,
-0.4002719819545746,
0.36822712421417236,
-1.0288959741592407,
0.2538674771785736,
0.10041782259941101,
-0.0951387882232666,
-0.7051973342895508,
-0.12417799979448318,
0.04546773433685303,
-0.4113595187664032,
-0.4523376226425171,
0.4447210133075714,
-0.2909436821937561,
0.563828706741333,
-0.18951447308063507,
0.003982262220233679,
-0.03726958855986595,
0.17137999832630157,
0.11634141951799393,
0.49757423996925354,
0.2584500014781952,
-0.6924915313720703,
-0.0018116720020771027,
0.8338685035705566,
-0.32316645979881287,
0.6416720747947693,
-0.8041430115699768,
-0.0828920528292656,
-0.2124442607164383,
0.14641331136226654,
-1.0483264923095703,
-0.26860514283180237,
0.09299713373184204,
-0.3942623436450958,
0.31768208742141724,
-0.09953921288251877,
-0.16229499876499176,
-0.564854085445404,
-0.09282109886407852,
0.14938858151435852,
0.5892941355705261,
-0.15866298973560333,
0.5656002163887024,
0.0688876211643219,
-0.4256202280521393,
-0.10306667536497116,
-0.4773803949356079,
0.06403539329767227,
-0.18359680473804474,
-0.26658520102500916,
0.48028793931007385,
0.06325379759073257,
0.14979663491249084,
-0.13700427114963531,
0.23075871169567108,
0.031985919922590256,
-0.16147968173027039,
0.17364585399627686,
0.5091087222099304,
-0.06538134068250656,
0.20867495238780975,
-0.02067764475941658,
-0.20507442951202393,
0.09725922346115112,
0.09488486498594284,
0.5157785415649414,
0.4654422700405121,
-0.20635701715946198,
-0.7307215332984924,
0.5094960927963257,
0.3134383261203766,
0.026106171309947968,
0.7740488052368164,
0.27864328026771545,
-0.2290145605802536,
-0.05323922634124756,
-0.6313232779502869,
-0.411993145942688,
-0.3634212017059326,
0.2483985871076584,
0.04555167630314827,
-1.06325101852417,
0.45096755027770996,
-0.10747411102056503,
0.0003094871935900301,
0.6470680832862854,
0.6384679675102234,
0.008369374088943005,
0.7731137275695801,
0.40430748462677,
0.24409759044647217,
0.4209200143814087,
-0.12333434075117111,
0.043774817138910294,
-0.7113301157951355,
-0.4924333989620209,
-0.8145241141319275,
-0.032857123762369156,
-0.4483722150325775,
-0.4195014238357544,
0.7338888049125671,
-0.31269627809524536,
0.12966226041316986,
0.24880057573318481,
-0.650416910648346,
-0.11641046404838562,
0.35400429368019104,
0.49552881717681885,
0.20553262531757355,
-0.141957625746727,
-0.1139255166053772,
-0.31847715377807617,
-0.5893703103065491,
-0.4640754759311676,
1.2940402030944824,
0.19935071468353271,
0.3419587314128876,
-0.06550880521535873,
0.48869451880455017,
0.4253675937652588,
0.35628005862236023,
-0.752186119556427,
0.4087178707122803,
-0.19607169926166534,
-0.6000716090202332,
-0.3543303906917572,
-0.5432986617088318,
-1.2301993370056152,
0.07698862254619598,
-0.422294944524765,
-0.5325053930282593,
0.12478689104318619,
-0.09090638160705566,
-0.8237905502319336,
-0.11782459169626236,
-0.5106063485145569,
0.7826871275901794,
-0.29951146245002747,
0.12897278368473053,
-0.031598713248968124,
-0.8654870390892029,
0.1137462928891182,
-0.26678767800331116,
0.04948591813445091,
-0.02294146828353405,
-0.010529461316764355,
0.820462167263031,
-0.5867908000946045,
0.5945040583610535,
-0.30941811203956604,
0.258070707321167,
0.36252808570861816,
-0.27675148844718933,
0.5342907309532166,
-0.035623952746391296,
-0.22340799868106842,
0.08043091744184494,
0.08634355664253235,
-0.11860457062721252,
-0.6818965077400208,
0.15965735912322998,
-0.4644770324230194,
-0.44735583662986755,
-0.395182728767395,
-0.33244362473487854,
-0.04142085835337639,
0.23981837928295135,
0.5201230645179749,
0.48786497116088867,
-0.3612809181213379,
0.36435309052467346,
0.6318932175636292,
-0.6231791377067566,
0.13277137279510498,
0.7088177800178528,
-0.1151958778500557,
-0.3676047623157501,
0.30876097083091736,
0.2289746254682541,
0.22481335699558258,
0.5845558047294617,
0.4717519283294678,
-0.5130581259727478,
-0.7642151713371277,
-0.3244182765483856,
0.20201162993907928,
-0.38931775093078613,
-0.04696395993232727,
-1.101261019706726,
-0.12158036977052689,
-0.4993520677089691,
0.022848382592201233,
0.046774644404649734,
-0.04072185978293419,
-0.2520311176776886,
0.07620910555124283,
0.3101465404033661,
0.35579702258110046,
0.4839496314525604,
0.5499322414398193,
-0.8654611110687256,
0.5239430665969849,
0.10396147519350052,
-0.06933251768350601,
-0.3000297546386719,
-0.9112635254859924,
-0.22945143282413483,
-0.40354469418525696,
-0.2594621181488037,
-0.8266518115997314,
0.4316983222961426,
0.11613258719444275,
0.7499628067016602,
0.1608356386423111,
0.24337808787822723,
0.3118078410625458,
-0.4991796016693115,
0.6519899964332581,
0.22351129353046417,
-0.4920688569545746,
0.9403156638145447,
-0.48270082473754883,
0.21246643364429474,
1.1564552783966064,
0.557584822177887,
-0.5343616604804993,
-0.08690815418958664,
-0.5825952887535095,
-0.8523723483085632,
0.8397462964057922,
0.2226599007844925,
-0.17201487720012665,
-0.006000235676765442,
0.575732409954071,
0.21589939296245575,
0.3084099590778351,
-0.4279325008392334,
-0.094992995262146,
0.30722856521606445,
-0.5318346619606018,
-0.16908402740955353,
-0.33395567536354065,
0.07924510538578033,
-0.006531283259391785,
0.38329729437828064,
-0.08442836999893188,
0.2559380531311035,
0.5571585297584534,
0.024051448330283165,
0.01916344463825226,
0.3608061373233795,
0.2789302170276642,
0.31011343002319336,
-0.2431589514017105,
-0.28443530201911926,
0.1446947604417801,
-0.8596604466438293,
0.1506045013666153,
0.2618143856525421,
-0.37286150455474854,
0.23493976891040802,
0.3164859712123871,
0.7227790951728821,
0.28543293476104736,
-0.8590521812438965,
0.8299448490142822,
-0.38103747367858887,
-0.21000652015209198,
-0.16777163743972778,
0.039611250162124634,
-0.34503158926963806,
0.04090305045247078,
0.2560724914073944,
-0.1327485293149948,
0.46696993708610535,
-0.38340485095977783,
0.2965697944164276,
0.18943898379802704,
-0.5282405018806458,
-0.19101206958293915,
0.8210658431053162,
0.06325054913759232,
-0.47600483894348145,
0.8020269870758057,
-0.08058450371026993,
-0.19687579572200775,
0.4838106334209442,
0.6389300227165222,
0.5720576047897339,
-0.43583372235298157,
0.20705239474773407,
0.5373843312263489,
0.14303381741046906,
-0.5062053203582764,
0.25744467973709106,
0.21127963066101074,
-0.3648427426815033,
-0.34597885608673096,
-0.43740710616111755,
-0.47586503624916077,
-0.036721739917993546,
-0.7804244160652161,
0.5692866444587708,
-0.15881340205669403,
-0.33869633078575134,
-0.06649849563837051,
0.02490159310400486,
-0.8675646781921387,
0.3364832103252411,
-0.044344574213027954,
0.9117063879966736,
-0.9301604628562927,
0.44863447546958923,
0.5447160601615906,
-0.3996850252151489,
-0.9387909770011902,
-0.3452756404876709,
0.0876379981637001,
-0.557745635509491,
0.36195480823516846,
0.42113009095191956,
0.6401013731956482,
-0.18009495735168457,
-0.10776738077402115,
-0.45667019486427307,
1.1162649393081665,
0.26295652985572815,
-0.6076171398162842,
-0.3063739240169525,
0.18687772750854492,
0.6775943636894226,
-0.31785017251968384,
0.45222464203834534,
0.508639931678772,
0.18519139289855957,
0.4048641622066498,
-0.968776524066925,
0.13692697882652283,
-0.27836915850639343,
-0.055718887597322464,
0.1237364187836647,
-0.31663835048675537,
0.7951381206512451,
-0.23486800491809845,
-0.3335498869419098,
0.2255486398935318,
0.4108458459377289,
0.42093372344970703,
0.7771422266960144,
0.4841129779815674,
0.4291495382785797,
0.9229896664619446,
-0.12418640404939651,
1.2161710262298584,
-0.06984677165746689,
0.29374048113822937,
0.7636027336120605,
-0.5384923815727234,
0.5796533226966858,
0.3892880380153656,
-0.2890675365924835,
0.5125519633293152,
0.4154551923274994,
0.010585120879113674,
0.5853645205497742,
0.022409215569496155,
-0.16451334953308105,
-0.06412076205015182,
-0.3710823953151703,
-0.22941090166568756,
0.3825435936450958,
0.2988097369670868,
-0.747813880443573,
-0.15613508224487305,
0.3236178755760193,
0.003916276153177023,
0.21082931756973267,
-0.22713834047317505,
0.9495148062705994,
0.2899169921875,
-0.9504501223564148,
0.1193443313241005,
-0.14993132650852203,
0.42569494247436523,
-0.6926557421684265,
-0.12981058657169342,
0.11873912066221237,
0.08259760588407516,
-0.1542125791311264,
-0.5044288635253906,
0.09991389513015747,
0.06151128187775612,
-0.1714181751012802,
-0.11282321810722351,
0.6711380481719971,
-0.2853841483592987,
-0.5830345749855042,
0.07431938499212265,
0.5822853446006775,
0.11486232280731201,
0.034721165895462036,
-0.5870968699455261,
-0.18729867041110992,
-0.050246596336364746,
-0.32168257236480713,
0.23070304095745087,
0.6584379076957703,
-0.160963773727417,
0.4631762206554413,
0.7542850971221924,
0.3257737159729004,
-0.33122751116752625,
0.18775629997253418,
0.7416947484016418,
-0.7434558868408203,
-0.8225076198577881,
-0.8728311657905579,
0.32394590973854065,
-0.12699896097183228,
-0.575387716293335,
0.7442049980163574,
0.7045977115631104,
0.2611715793609619,
-0.19912423193454742,
0.6937349438667297,
0.0040557426400482655,
1.022560954093933,
-0.668552815914154,
0.46296629309654236,
-0.22627532482147217,
0.15232457220554352,
-0.14302998781204224,
-0.4321101903915405,
-0.3710310459136963,
0.26851460337638855,
-0.4241429269313812,
-0.16815881431102753,
0.6651507019996643,
0.662368893623352,
0.3223905563354492,
0.1744523048400879,
0.16798897087574005,
-0.056430693715810776,
0.38286852836608887,
0.7216391563415527,
0.7271217703819275,
-0.6199608445167542,
0.19171513617038727,
0.07570648193359375,
-0.3216089904308319,
-0.5522758364677429,
-0.6358900666236877,
-1.0555968284606934,
-0.4318704605102539,
-0.1749786138534546,
-0.4338099956512451,
-0.03305152431130409,
1.3357783555984497,
0.37721481919288635,
-0.9329258799552917,
-0.011945667676627636,
0.048369795083999634,
-0.3437325060367584,
-0.09607523679733276,
-0.16294384002685547,
0.5240427851676941,
-0.3059138059616089,
-0.4650820195674896,
0.3852754831314087,
0.16371391713619232,
0.03140359744429588,
0.28251340985298157,
-0.0714765414595604,
-0.2256220430135727,
-0.2890278995037079,
0.45841288566589355,
0.09167546033859253,
-0.3026954233646393,
0.1331445723772049,
0.32465681433677673,
-0.40382397174835205,
0.07287028431892395,
1.0724831819534302,
-0.7516875863075256,
0.5302488207817078,
0.38203907012939453,
0.6915536522865295,
0.4358293116092682,
0.1791706532239914,
0.4426913261413574,
-0.2479497343301773,
0.09390348196029663,
0.47258687019348145,
0.27695170044898987,
0.24499720335006714,
-0.6928758025169373,
0.5349765419960022,
0.30980780720710754,
-0.7237646579742432,
-0.6506098508834839,
-0.2963726222515106,
-1.017482876777649,
-0.039027102291584015,
1.1437321901321411,
-0.10318300873041153,
-0.16420529782772064,
-0.6905826926231384,
-0.5415468215942383,
0.45984527468681335,
-0.4340953528881073,
0.8220944404602051,
0.27170297503471375,
-0.2187105417251587,
0.03234584629535675,
-0.9589614272117615,
0.5667138695716858,
0.2968769967556,
-0.7393083572387695,
-0.31781479716300964,
0.33828482031822205,
0.08384022116661072,
0.08114078640937805,
1.0162492990493774,
-0.23089297115802765,
0.3214232921600342,
-0.41988062858581543,
0.2056667059659958,
0.10279639810323715,
-0.10565420240163803,
-0.5475825667381287,
0.3766997754573822,
-0.06955462694168091,
-0.08573905378580093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16192v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16192v1
|
Fusion of Domain-Adapted Vision and Language Models for Medical Visual Question Answering
| 2024-04-24T20:31:15 | 2024-04-24T20:31:15 |
Cuong Nhat Ha, Shima Asaadi, Sanjeev Kumar Karn, Oladimeji Farri, Tobias Heimann, Thomas Runkler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Vision-language models, while effective in general domains and showing strong
performance in diverse multi-modal applications like visual question-answering
(VQA), struggle to maintain the same level of effectiveness in more specialized
domains, e.g., medical. We propose a medical vision-language model that
integrates large vision and language models adapted for the medical domain.
This model goes through three stages of parameter-efficient training using
three separate biomedical and radiology multi-modal visual and text datasets.
The proposed model achieves state-of-the-art performance on the SLAKE 1.0
medical VQA (MedVQA) dataset with an overall accuracy of 87.5% and demonstrates
strong performance on another MedVQA dataset, VQA-RAD, achieving an overall
accuracy of 73.2%.
|
[
-0.3054503798484802,
-0.8314296007156372,
0.9526244401931763,
-0.14711710810661316,
-0.40177851915359497,
-0.07844103127717972,
0.08594883233308792,
-0.7155892252922058,
0.08030641078948975,
0.779191792011261,
-0.5642820596694946,
-0.4989728331565857,
-0.5454221963882446,
-0.10434741526842117,
-0.08974582701921463,
0.6434435844421387,
-0.13077588379383087,
0.7771898508071899,
-0.56627357006073,
-0.541446328163147,
-0.7004987001419067,
-0.40893739461898804,
-0.33702293038368225,
-0.13721083104610443,
0.45389044284820557,
0.1063726618885994,
0.7749007940292358,
0.5068085789680481,
0.8202959299087524,
0.22086051106452942,
0.19258429110050201,
0.290699303150177,
-0.1887441724538803,
0.11455192416906357,
-0.3745785355567932,
-0.29811036586761475,
-0.4996441602706909,
-0.19260646402835846,
0.5607914328575134,
0.7422094941139221,
-0.18050707876682281,
0.12122232466936111,
-0.36143994331359863,
0.5445832014083862,
-0.49877986311912537,
0.053359683603048325,
-0.6004474759101868,
-0.2743126153945923,
0.24561533331871033,
-0.3626139163970947,
-0.4100809395313263,
-0.25570741295814514,
0.520307183265686,
-0.7561168670654297,
-0.025170890614390373,
0.04126420244574547,
0.9502186179161072,
0.46681180596351624,
-0.3895406723022461,
-0.0017053830670192838,
-0.4555636942386627,
0.6436337232589722,
-0.5905015468597412,
0.5814284682273865,
0.4247763454914093,
0.49948203563690186,
0.36687418818473816,
-0.9089242815971375,
-0.4878683090209961,
0.06523291021585464,
0.0958406925201416,
0.2774743437767029,
-0.1442221701145172,
0.21893595159053802,
-0.04927505552768707,
0.021348407492041588,
-0.9798570275306702,
-0.11533182114362717,
-0.7437809109687805,
0.09752121567726135,
0.3936488926410675,
0.4391460716724396,
0.48003464937210083,
-0.08399134129285812,
-0.5727375149726868,
0.10974036902189255,
-0.44564276933670044,
-0.09006466716527939,
-0.6384506225585938,
0.07613322138786316,
0.015582431107759476,
0.7859686017036438,
-0.3890322148799896,
1.2459418773651123,
-0.22030939161777496,
-0.3131144642829895,
0.37970036268234253,
-0.6807158589363098,
-0.5323966145515442,
-0.5476434826850891,
0.5320523977279663,
0.6504433155059814,
0.2596583068370819,
0.0018194952281191945,
-0.08739686012268066,
0.3655659556388855,
0.49088573455810547,
-0.5733826160430908,
-0.2396678477525711,
0.38635385036468506,
-0.4839576780796051,
-0.21288910508155823,
-0.23055127263069153,
-0.5859320759773254,
-0.4888605773448944,
-0.3815723955631256,
0.8741180896759033,
-0.568688690662384,
-0.037102144211530685,
0.650670051574707,
-0.022227860987186432,
0.4530611038208008,
0.5579984784126282,
-0.6428256034851074,
0.23082415759563446,
0.34125757217407227,
0.6361216306686401,
-0.2793009877204895,
-0.37158605456352234,
-0.48540759086608887,
0.07989078015089035,
-0.13105399906635284,
0.7838753461837769,
-0.6740907430648804,
-0.016098789870738983,
-0.06706599146127701,
0.10194879025220871,
-0.5728855133056641,
-0.6992633938789368,
0.14232365787029266,
-0.7026814818382263,
0.30922195315361023,
-0.12878574430942535,
-0.5260466933250427,
-0.34444957971572876,
0.27440690994262695,
-0.5904453992843628,
0.6526209115982056,
0.3810359239578247,
-0.6835271120071411,
0.44665300846099854,
-0.44931355118751526,
-0.2345936894416809,
0.47389963269233704,
-0.5702040195465088,
-0.30568140745162964,
0.031134992837905884,
0.5872759819030762,
0.5013003349304199,
-0.5989500284194946,
0.33684372901916504,
-0.16070035099983215,
-0.19474035501480103,
0.4187942445278168,
-0.169184148311615,
0.6185140013694763,
0.0065682088024914265,
-0.08447537571191788,
0.1122453436255455,
-0.7038617134094238,
0.25221651792526245,
0.18369092047214508,
-0.13295267522335052,
-0.5214281678199768,
-0.004544269759207964,
0.09068029373884201,
0.4097590148448944,
0.2561550438404083,
-0.5544143915176392,
0.2388657033443451,
-0.4064618945121765,
0.22971463203430176,
0.2737535834312439,
0.18700671195983887,
0.22953759133815765,
-0.43072348833084106,
0.7195866703987122,
0.23170755803585052,
0.486020565032959,
0.001517775235697627,
-0.8399527668952942,
-0.728459358215332,
-0.5306891798973083,
0.25533294677734375,
0.8692468404769897,
-1.4236271381378174,
-0.29305845499038696,
-0.2272663563489914,
-0.43990591168403625,
-0.885827362537384,
-0.14739669859409332,
0.465345561504364,
0.6652427315711975,
0.5201749801635742,
-0.3479883670806885,
-0.337481290102005,
-1.0458487272262573,
0.012356219813227654,
-0.34437790513038635,
0.20790837705135345,
0.49734264612197876,
0.586285412311554,
-0.28446993231773376,
0.5796974897384644,
-0.6945602297782898,
-0.05879756435751915,
-0.2624501883983612,
-0.12213387340307236,
0.09630797058343887,
0.23362040519714355,
0.6660907864570618,
-1.1334747076034546,
-0.3115025460720062,
0.1759086698293686,
-0.9708988666534424,
0.07619641721248627,
-0.02826104126870632,
-0.027418913319706917,
0.06267689913511276,
0.28613221645355225,
-0.3697283864021301,
0.539532482624054,
0.7933136224746704,
-0.4759199619293213,
0.5051379203796387,
-0.21480582654476166,
0.5657612085342407,
-1.1830596923828125,
0.08860350400209427,
0.05985746532678604,
-0.2559640407562256,
-1.0824241638183594,
0.4127362072467804,
0.24164751172065735,
-0.19144697487354279,
-0.7663133144378662,
0.7487727999687195,
-0.27094048261642456,
0.1374080926179886,
-0.10870442539453506,
0.07167761027812958,
0.1728043556213379,
0.3565900921821594,
0.17521139979362488,
0.8687562942504883,
0.9762596487998962,
-0.4138360917568207,
0.3434029817581177,
0.3520143926143646,
-0.48272061347961426,
0.8078916668891907,
-0.8488194346427917,
-0.22452114522457123,
-0.34713083505630493,
-0.275400310754776,
-0.9670863151550293,
-0.4295917749404907,
0.21737578511238098,
-0.3935968577861786,
0.024637704715132713,
-0.031632401049137115,
-0.2059239000082016,
-0.42585840821266174,
0.006199789233505726,
0.7954294085502625,
0.48769161105155945,
-0.3737320899963379,
0.8282305002212524,
0.4667479693889618,
-0.40932703018188477,
-0.6445929408073425,
-0.677901029586792,
0.034533414989709854,
0.13407887518405914,
-0.8323006629943848,
0.14700420200824738,
-0.12706151604652405,
-0.0923759788274765,
0.03479410335421562,
0.14614321291446686,
-0.5456966161727905,
-0.2587844133377075,
0.1970246434211731,
0.7894086241722107,
-0.3426130712032318,
0.15882226824760437,
-0.06175597384572029,
0.04739396274089813,
-0.2241496443748474,
-0.18469348549842834,
0.42381829023361206,
-0.10986008495092392,
-0.5876961946487427,
-0.34363853931427,
0.7054670453071594,
1.0171966552734375,
-0.590570867061615,
0.8097417950630188,
0.2533310651779175,
-0.6056406497955322,
0.1657286137342453,
-0.6248152256011963,
0.022603116929531097,
-0.4044305086135864,
0.7026727199554443,
-0.4598388969898224,
-0.8719595670700073,
0.3283979892730713,
0.23657558858394623,
-0.09826681017875671,
0.30294355750083923,
0.7373197674751282,
-0.285555899143219,
1.3259323835372925,
0.6960333585739136,
0.3893541991710663,
0.1908879578113556,
0.016169710084795952,
-0.026249701157212257,
-0.6312003135681152,
-0.5044202208518982,
-0.1265036016702652,
0.08932295441627502,
-0.10849222540855408,
-0.7491425275802612,
0.7432547211647034,
-0.2972714900970459,
0.039644770324230194,
0.06855790317058563,
-0.47213661670684814,
0.21057310700416565,
0.5462598204612732,
0.5575065016746521,
0.2016778588294983,
0.07427152991294861,
-0.16361907124519348,
-0.13816361129283905,
-1.0231887102127075,
-0.10262294113636017,
0.9143496155738831,
0.2634982466697693,
0.9516342282295227,
-0.12085438519716263,
0.33838024735450745,
-0.2793329358100891,
0.024034416303038597,
-0.6149742603302002,
0.5137225389480591,
-0.4646441638469696,
-0.6467239856719971,
-0.13875754177570343,
-0.19131781160831451,
-0.5952264666557312,
0.3800787627696991,
-0.5291350483894348,
-0.48642697930336,
0.33211246132850647,
0.13388779759407043,
-0.41731929779052734,
0.22903911769390106,
-0.7054449319839478,
0.967244565486908,
-0.2039695829153061,
-0.09388656169176102,
-0.11027856171131134,
-0.6880494356155396,
0.3229462504386902,
-0.1744518280029297,
0.20227506756782532,
0.19455298781394958,
-0.15550900995731354,
0.4750969111919403,
-0.11418318003416061,
0.7234980463981628,
-0.09584661573171616,
0.18929150700569153,
0.19041921198368073,
-0.20708143711090088,
0.055824268609285355,
-0.12274283915758133,
0.23235362768173218,
0.17131826281547546,
0.4608716666698456,
-0.48405906558036804,
-0.5753034949302673,
0.3633132576942444,
-0.6678646206855774,
-0.3432590067386627,
-0.40805622935295105,
-0.6925272941589355,
-0.4725555181503296,
0.11965016275644302,
0.2087765783071518,
0.8083975911140442,
-0.018044959753751755,
0.18162180483341217,
0.9088724851608276,
-0.47624170780181885,
-0.07811500132083893,
0.44930583238601685,
-0.40726736187934875,
-0.6523867249488831,
0.7880305647850037,
-0.13419868052005768,
0.6661921143531799,
0.30011653900146484,
-0.07682543247938156,
-0.2206498682498932,
-0.6376593112945557,
-0.7575927376747131,
0.5582734942436218,
-0.9243317246437073,
-0.2408105731010437,
-0.748260498046875,
-0.5370518565177917,
-0.19904206693172455,
-0.22907964885234833,
-0.19967679679393768,
-0.15489442646503448,
-0.1875988095998764,
0.3868381977081299,
0.3712106943130493,
0.5834519267082214,
0.4141201674938202,
0.16952697932720184,
-0.965819239616394,
0.7741672992706299,
0.5206553339958191,
0.48517751693725586,
-0.5151727795600891,
-0.6050124764442444,
-0.24144937098026276,
0.023414848372340202,
0.2991199195384979,
-1.0255775451660156,
0.24732647836208344,
0.30569911003112793,
0.6068605780601501,
-0.045203182846307755,
-0.37236347794532776,
0.6804648637771606,
-0.6542486548423767,
0.8682963848114014,
0.49249738454818726,
-0.4137461185455322,
0.5693012475967407,
-0.16794966161251068,
0.6982271671295166,
0.7467030882835388,
0.33701539039611816,
-0.524324357509613,
-0.47508305311203003,
-0.23519167304039001,
-0.5591760277748108,
0.37854188680648804,
-0.06288448721170425,
-0.18213103711605072,
0.12859229743480682,
0.4566177725791931,
0.06838132441043854,
0.11621567606925964,
-0.5885659456253052,
-0.2245139479637146,
-0.08621295541524887,
-0.4961719810962677,
0.1330183744430542,
-0.13591857254505157,
-0.28845924139022827,
-0.5102109313011169,
0.47955963015556335,
-0.30027610063552856,
0.2947983145713806,
0.23692023754119873,
-0.28365734219551086,
0.19731391966342926,
0.053839657455682755,
0.6635545492172241,
1.035561442375183,
0.11104129254817963,
0.12131296098232269,
0.24438820779323578,
-0.8879711031913757,
-0.017375124618411064,
0.01040065847337246,
-0.22172535955905914,
-0.05006217584013939,
0.2571372389793396,
0.8297178745269775,
-0.028191309422254562,
-1.0310041904449463,
0.8503702878952026,
-0.32713302969932556,
-0.5414345860481262,
0.11748592555522919,
0.06494292616844177,
0.14258165657520294,
0.4540049135684967,
0.3480123281478882,
0.2606043815612793,
0.1394711434841156,
-0.2923166751861572,
0.41986653208732605,
0.3262777328491211,
-0.44811227917671204,
-0.05242033302783966,
0.901289165019989,
-0.10829784721136093,
0.18011876940727234,
0.4269748330116272,
0.44677823781967163,
-0.5182198286056519,
0.41954609751701355,
0.4737766981124878,
0.4982375204563141,
-0.17953002452850342,
0.38835349678993225,
0.381441593170166,
0.22328054904937744,
0.09887704253196716,
1.000291347503662,
0.5383940935134888,
-0.5863064527511597,
-0.7214693427085876,
-0.6451069116592407,
-0.3099241852760315,
0.010829856619238853,
-0.6891579031944275,
0.16774986684322357,
-0.3134290277957916,
-0.24728141725063324,
0.27896207571029663,
-0.4212771952152252,
-0.7849531173706055,
0.8436571359634399,
0.26844456791877747,
0.9299963712692261,
-0.886292576789856,
0.9255761504173279,
1.0518852472305298,
-0.5558910369873047,
-0.5350891947746277,
-0.3440614938735962,
-0.20460869371891022,
-1.20894193649292,
0.48317497968673706,
-0.21732406318187714,
-0.18232810497283936,
-0.0774499699473381,
-0.6413803696632385,
-0.7777681946754456,
1.0613330602645874,
0.2594706118106842,
-0.39450782537460327,
-0.08738622069358826,
0.16233333945274353,
0.4912707805633545,
-0.544643223285675,
-0.15876932442188263,
0.40767306089401245,
0.13370183110237122,
0.19306188821792603,
-1.064950704574585,
-0.07341265678405762,
-0.3659560978412628,
0.08148454129695892,
0.08673928678035736,
-0.3419401943683624,
0.6438581347465515,
-0.3548688590526581,
-0.05656781420111656,
0.23743318021297455,
0.4157542884349823,
0.311265766620636,
0.25087639689445496,
0.4885047972202301,
0.35571226477622986,
0.5864654183387756,
-0.18027080595493317,
1.0917433500289917,
-0.5349555015563965,
0.1612902730703354,
0.8716035485267639,
-0.10885582864284515,
0.9130456447601318,
0.6050019860267639,
0.10994193702936172,
0.23401959240436554,
0.39285996556282043,
0.07168804109096527,
0.705413818359375,
-0.37694236636161804,
-0.5553439259529114,
-0.5136411786079407,
-0.04766460135579109,
-0.42813220620155334,
0.4946713149547577,
0.3888372480869293,
-0.4291344881057739,
0.11556418240070343,
0.3861026465892792,
-0.40933945775032043,
-0.0806141272187233,
-0.2827107310295105,
0.708990752696991,
-0.03139520063996315,
-0.66106778383255,
0.7559202313423157,
-0.20355337858200073,
0.28045910596847534,
-0.5650171041488647,
-0.09896601736545563,
0.023153109475970268,
-0.03161574527621269,
0.03477168455719948,
-0.9592410922050476,
0.04273692145943642,
-0.22251364588737488,
-0.38307616114616394,
0.1775132268667221,
0.7115266919136047,
-0.7311553955078125,
-0.6355302929878235,
0.04327971860766411,
0.7581528425216675,
-0.01425008662045002,
0.14392423629760742,
-0.78305584192276,
0.01733846217393875,
-0.09853760898113251,
0.15486600995063782,
0.1786339282989502,
0.11328018456697464,
-0.0038489666767418385,
0.8146095871925354,
0.3704214096069336,
0.20917461812496185,
0.261027991771698,
0.2708500623703003,
0.9899851679801941,
-0.5283386707305908,
-0.3739933371543884,
-0.4712105691432953,
0.6778212785720825,
-0.05645017325878143,
-0.45362067222595215,
0.28982439637184143,
0.27682971954345703,
0.5501497387886047,
-0.2911759912967682,
0.7309452891349792,
0.0814390555024147,
0.49379780888557434,
-0.704030454158783,
0.6870267391204834,
-1.0530250072479248,
-0.14560578763484955,
-0.2459012269973755,
-0.6173527836799622,
-0.6823870539665222,
0.5814981460571289,
-0.12622304260730743,
0.042281489819288254,
0.9079728722572327,
0.8553122282028198,
-0.10789397358894348,
-0.11670982092618942,
0.7205213308334351,
0.06331771612167358,
0.030396295711398125,
0.7194011807441711,
0.6536149978637695,
-0.5054329633712769,
0.22994689643383026,
-0.07195136696100235,
-0.3785085082054138,
-0.23618200421333313,
-0.34503117203712463,
-0.7671325206756592,
-0.8309864401817322,
-0.421457976102829,
-0.3401359021663666,
0.09811384230852127,
0.5756123661994934,
0.7701573371887207,
-0.6190692186355591,
0.19283536076545715,
0.5287279486656189,
-0.5270525217056274,
-0.2508595287799835,
-0.0991898700594902,
0.4051222503185272,
-0.07975846529006958,
-0.35907888412475586,
0.32792192697525024,
0.650117039680481,
0.015722816810011864,
-0.29791706800460815,
-0.004369704984128475,
-0.30979272723197937,
0.31332072615623474,
0.7539728879928589,
0.22903741896152496,
-0.8778819441795349,
-0.4695475995540619,
0.5004889965057373,
-0.49843424558639526,
0.21061691641807556,
0.5041927099227905,
-0.7072494626045227,
0.9274944067001343,
0.3493761420249939,
0.8991751670837402,
0.4578968584537506,
0.08249416202306747,
0.43925800919532776,
-0.3779968321323395,
-0.07407759130001068,
0.3085290193557739,
0.4131000339984894,
0.3227789103984833,
-0.08881206065416336,
0.26319801807403564,
0.238450825214386,
-0.45842450857162476,
-0.5771010518074036,
0.3018170893192291,
-1.337697148323059,
-0.5308111310005188,
1.158762812614441,
0.087377168238163,
-0.2532016336917877,
-0.23760271072387695,
-0.47578662633895874,
-0.04677009582519531,
0.31422632932662964,
0.28267231583595276,
0.4428200125694275,
-0.19536814093589783,
-0.4875667989253998,
-0.8522318601608276,
0.31699907779693604,
0.455594539642334,
-0.8877221941947937,
-0.25101396441459656,
0.7596487402915955,
0.49329498410224915,
-0.07038668543100357,
0.8725914359092712,
-0.28980737924575806,
0.9071552157402039,
-0.007180632557719946,
0.12967601418495178,
0.10091850161552429,
-0.6091635227203369,
-0.4790423512458801,
0.26385533809661865,
0.09656865894794464,
-0.3044954538345337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05135v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05135v1
|
Lessons from the Use of Natural Language Inference (NLI) in Requirements Engineering Tasks
| 2024-04-24T20:26:48 | 2024-04-24T20:26:48 |
Mohamad Fazelnia, Viktoria Koscinski, Spencer Herzog, Mehdi Mirakhorli
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We investigate the use of Natural Language Inference (NLI) in automating
requirements engineering tasks. In particular, we focus on three tasks:
requirements classification, identification of requirements specification
defects, and detection of conflicts in stakeholders' requirements. While
previous research has demonstrated significant benefit in using NLI as a
universal method for a broad spectrum of natural language processing tasks,
these advantages have not been investigated within the context of software
requirements engineering. Therefore, we design experiments to evaluate the use
of NLI in requirements analysis. We compare the performance of NLI with a
spectrum of approaches, including prompt-based models, conventional transfer
learning, Large Language Models (LLMs)-powered chatbot models, and
probabilistic models. Through experiments conducted under various learning
settings including conventional learning and zero-shot, we demonstrate
conclusively that our NLI method surpasses classical NLP methods as well as
other LLMs-based and chatbot models in the analysis of requirements
specifications. Additionally, we share lessons learned characterizing the
learning settings that make NLI a suitable approach for automating requirements
engineering tasks.
|
[
-0.4384194016456604,
-0.6191325783729553,
0.5274723172187805,
0.45503830909729004,
0.2567809522151947,
-0.11460329592227936,
0.2377966046333313,
-0.8364846110343933,
-0.1035551130771637,
0.6164655685424805,
-0.8450613617897034,
-0.3221064805984497,
-0.13254253566265106,
0.29040008783340454,
-0.39369988441467285,
0.7141498923301697,
-0.4119704067707062,
-0.4131927192211151,
-0.07294429838657379,
0.39957237243652344,
-0.9103096127510071,
-0.2809275686740875,
-0.6105639934539795,
-0.27997347712516785,
0.36017361283302307,
0.3602007031440735,
0.45621904730796814,
0.2610156536102295,
0.3596816658973694,
0.2563571035861969,
-0.00035303583717904985,
0.3056826591491699,
0.12908905744552612,
0.060124896466732025,
0.22531040012836456,
-0.6636703014373779,
-0.08960641920566559,
0.5184618830680847,
0.22667033970355988,
0.845222532749176,
-0.06259633600711823,
0.06704163551330566,
0.27567991614341736,
0.6748250722885132,
-0.8728315234184265,
0.47198179364204407,
-0.5007926225662231,
0.4345329701900482,
0.18346311151981354,
-0.16579194366931915,
-0.6541784405708313,
-0.37101680040359497,
0.45006948709487915,
-0.891720175743103,
0.2567598521709442,
0.27776584029197693,
1.3286975622177124,
0.3931923806667328,
-0.4572526812553406,
-0.7606385350227356,
-0.7661432027816772,
1.1909279823303223,
-0.9184633493423462,
0.2727419137954712,
0.5532765984535217,
0.3778979480266571,
-0.35438844561576843,
-0.3036229908466339,
-0.532829999923706,
-0.4734025299549103,
-0.35902658104896545,
0.11215068399906158,
-0.05909178778529167,
0.42332565784454346,
0.3564084768295288,
0.2749715745449066,
-0.7845393419265747,
0.39617371559143066,
-0.3018238842487335,
-0.25233620405197144,
0.8203434944152832,
-0.019581982865929604,
0.3806929886341095,
-0.7074808478355408,
-0.11643705517053604,
0.1455516666173935,
-0.3432924151420593,
-0.009606507606804371,
0.3602577745914459,
0.49136507511138916,
-0.14507171511650085,
0.3314708471298218,
-0.27980098128318787,
0.8275384306907654,
-0.18574991822242737,
0.05189971625804901,
0.2573680579662323,
-0.41764548420906067,
-0.4999413788318634,
-0.1029011532664299,
0.7127339243888855,
0.19369472563266754,
0.45280036330223083,
-0.47252658009529114,
-0.218851238489151,
0.006137622985988855,
0.501512885093689,
-0.1631733924150467,
0.14955386519432068,
0.41005852818489075,
-0.3369908928871155,
-0.2614067494869232,
-0.1378994584083557,
-0.5009379386901855,
-0.26540592312812805,
-0.70000159740448,
0.34740594029426575,
-0.6203145384788513,
-0.14888150990009308,
0.03507162258028984,
-0.38166335225105286,
0.7733274102210999,
0.15206146240234375,
-0.9223121404647827,
0.22398100793361664,
0.9090781807899475,
0.6373051404953003,
-0.06999978423118591,
-0.2693442702293396,
-0.3414064049720764,
-0.1411694437265396,
-0.3818044066429138,
0.7884944677352905,
-0.18489885330200195,
-0.3840228319168091,
0.0021448528859764338,
-0.3566412031650543,
-0.4237763285636902,
-0.5082122683525085,
0.6543859243392944,
-0.4440804123878479,
0.2644504904747009,
0.045640021562576294,
-0.691724956035614,
-0.33093902468681335,
0.255668044090271,
-0.5948495268821716,
0.8089413642883301,
-0.06713968515396118,
-0.5340134501457214,
0.47228604555130005,
-0.7994215488433838,
-0.4374494254589081,
0.11260891705751419,
-0.005580265540629625,
-0.1745724380016327,
0.1417691707611084,
-0.06082402542233467,
0.4561634659767151,
-0.1931154429912567,
0.28431636095046997,
-0.3694286346435547,
-0.1886848509311676,
0.0063754357397556305,
-0.5101807117462158,
0.9186177849769592,
0.3259788155555725,
-0.4087149202823639,
-0.038318924605846405,
-0.7133498191833496,
0.1499774008989334,
-0.00037063530180603266,
-0.09826603531837463,
-0.14108222723007202,
0.32292237877845764,
-0.04253741353750229,
-0.000006188000952533912,
-0.14710628986358643,
-0.4830043911933899,
-0.26729604601860046,
-0.930959939956665,
0.16341207921504974,
0.27168649435043335,
0.11607468128204346,
0.6635766625404358,
-0.2887323200702667,
0.2172304093837738,
-0.3680765926837921,
0.20545749366283417,
0.17424334585666656,
-0.48883622884750366,
-0.818021833896637,
0.08011394739151001,
0.3120589554309845,
0.9258136749267578,
-0.678469181060791,
0.5715013146400452,
0.2877970039844513,
-0.2570282518863678,
-0.48573875427246094,
0.1677660197019577,
0.1420738697052002,
0.3537609577178955,
0.17889463901519775,
-0.05730948597192764,
-0.896718442440033,
-0.9636849164962769,
-0.2896096408367157,
-0.5960308909416199,
-0.5710417628288269,
0.17758908867835999,
0.3849148750305176,
-0.16390614211559296,
1.2691534757614136,
-0.1355276107788086,
-0.2663756012916565,
-0.6197710037231445,
0.7183836698532104,
0.12430980801582336,
0.32275351881980896,
0.6244093775749207,
-0.9535468816757202,
-0.19711652398109436,
-0.050279129296541214,
-1.116621971130371,
-0.27557113766670227,
-0.5039335489273071,
-0.13137786090373993,
0.36808153986930847,
0.4406168758869171,
-0.5992493033409119,
0.6943511366844177,
0.4609595239162445,
-0.09716010093688965,
0.5484620928764343,
0.008209757506847382,
0.16454443335533142,
-0.8044412732124329,
0.05047211796045303,
0.4522903561592102,
-0.1583818942308426,
-0.8775917887687683,
0.18382273614406586,
-0.06316442787647247,
0.06897036731243134,
-0.3328647315502167,
0.46076250076293945,
-0.38601255416870117,
0.10700281709432602,
-0.5688485503196716,
0.2005389928817749,
0.05612039193511009,
0.35784274339675903,
0.17761728167533875,
0.5949556827545166,
0.3825143575668335,
-0.9449819326400757,
0.14972588419914246,
0.13708174228668213,
-0.26315945386886597,
0.4235247075557709,
-0.7147358655929565,
-0.0982249453663826,
-0.07746674865484238,
-0.14274051785469055,
-0.926237165927887,
-0.24080859124660492,
0.28012892603874207,
-0.4235057830810547,
0.18121857941150665,
0.05319901555776596,
-0.4904830753803253,
-0.40212365984916687,
-0.05565689131617546,
-0.272971510887146,
0.423240602016449,
-0.3569079339504242,
0.8537333011627197,
0.28228238224983215,
0.035187289118766785,
-0.3046208620071411,
-0.6122233867645264,
0.28121548891067505,
-0.16028255224227905,
-0.3156670331954956,
0.2928556799888611,
-0.034533072263002396,
-0.37728777527809143,
-0.11142607033252716,
-0.27712908387184143,
-0.6138117909431458,
0.7225014567375183,
0.7312524318695068,
0.3655927777290344,
-0.20338602364063263,
-0.16362717747688293,
0.005334175657480955,
-0.21678553521633148,
0.3508864641189575,
0.058593738824129105,
-0.16502408683300018,
-0.13395215570926666,
-0.5417315363883972,
-0.8851787447929382,
0.40115121006965637,
0.2976474463939667,
-0.1236085593700409,
0.4680221974849701,
0.2430495172739029,
-0.4095153510570526,
-0.35571733117103577,
-0.6895315051078796,
-0.016826895996928215,
-0.44866421818733215,
0.19900088012218475,
-0.2790539860725403,
-0.6950867772102356,
0.05062534287571907,
0.1482083648443222,
0.7598716616630554,
0.329729825258255,
-0.37139996886253357,
-0.5379456877708435,
0.7792410254478455,
0.8379549980163574,
-0.29903262853622437,
0.3569982945919037,
0.033603109419345856,
0.23515580594539642,
-0.4222409129142761,
0.11606541275978088,
-0.7740346193313599,
-0.16265876591205597,
-0.25581592321395874,
0.024177374318242073,
-0.023498373106122017,
0.04538467526435852,
0.02569613792002201,
0.6268892288208008,
-0.08697400987148285,
0.5112587213516235,
0.48322129249572754,
-0.2505332827568054,
0.10286208242177963,
-0.04247959330677986,
-0.010234183631837368,
-0.04723638668656349,
-0.4728275537490845,
-0.7168500423431396,
0.5549174547195435,
0.35902008414268494,
0.4137585759162903,
-0.07572764903306961,
0.7371561527252197,
0.2946130037307739,
0.4113244414329529,
-0.7651886940002441,
0.509306788444519,
0.19435614347457886,
-0.5625767707824707,
-0.42413973808288574,
-0.49590787291526794,
-0.9123773574829102,
0.147640198469162,
-0.22076570987701416,
-0.5968633890151978,
-0.028741396963596344,
0.2379719465970993,
-0.4659786522388458,
0.15183451771736145,
-1.1241068840026855,
0.9159473180770874,
-0.2241329699754715,
0.29212379455566406,
-0.17759382724761963,
-0.6685652136802673,
0.3789551258087158,
0.019905298948287964,
0.2107703983783722,
-0.21315816044807434,
0.2954902946949005,
0.6089118123054504,
-0.13048891723155975,
1.138228178024292,
-0.1430453360080719,
-0.14785927534103394,
0.3672250211238861,
-0.030002985149621964,
0.27247077226638794,
-0.016674838960170746,
-0.5698378086090088,
-0.05320633947849274,
0.15786932408809662,
-0.3948037326335907,
-0.8089211583137512,
0.24855318665504456,
-0.5321288704872131,
-0.7486371994018555,
-0.2960260808467865,
-0.5297657251358032,
-0.414417564868927,
0.020313747227191925,
-0.06837644428014755,
0.04090835899114609,
-0.3359607458114624,
-0.24494506418704987,
0.5393710732460022,
-0.29553237557411194,
0.7462707161903381,
0.524102509021759,
-0.017158858478069305,
0.19520485401153564,
0.7527372241020203,
-0.04782663285732269,
0.41506481170654297,
0.3386577069759369,
-0.12729257345199585,
0.05601055175065994,
-0.726118266582489,
-0.3424893319606781,
0.2885685861110687,
-0.48429277539253235,
0.026669155806303024,
-0.4515233635902405,
-0.573319137096405,
-0.2974727749824524,
-0.19957473874092102,
-0.16127969324588776,
0.022590981796383858,
-0.43916597962379456,
-0.05868550017476082,
0.010736930184066296,
0.6801019310951233,
0.30337098240852356,
0.12767598032951355,
-0.8246049880981445,
0.456271767616272,
0.3431052267551422,
0.27741432189941406,
-0.1453237384557724,
-0.4634098708629608,
0.12257158011198044,
0.04793829470872879,
-0.30607497692108154,
-0.8833461999893188,
0.40413984656333923,
0.27236998081207275,
0.8642586469650269,
0.07057682424783707,
0.3753674328327179,
0.5987525582313538,
-0.44180306792259216,
0.5554059147834778,
-0.17094385623931885,
-0.8826046586036682,
0.6488617062568665,
0.08941686153411865,
0.24204082787036896,
0.7133173942565918,
0.43020835518836975,
-0.7014508247375488,
-0.7098687291145325,
-0.33664318919181824,
-0.7769748568534851,
0.6211729645729065,
0.38946840167045593,
-0.03262140601873398,
0.0013250275515019894,
0.6805009841918945,
-0.07426765561103821,
0.027362078428268433,
-0.6216413974761963,
-0.13255512714385986,
0.2980227470397949,
-0.38731712102890015,
0.0945969969034195,
-0.1912572979927063,
0.290717214345932,
0.15662595629692078,
0.8205563426017761,
-0.2023274004459381,
0.06009305641055107,
0.3487471640110016,
-0.46629640460014343,
0.296561598777771,
0.4457085430622101,
0.35948440432548523,
0.4933374524116516,
-0.19228358566761017,
-0.15407294034957886,
0.5962573885917664,
-0.07716165482997894,
-0.1276504397392273,
0.13925714790821075,
-0.13822446763515472,
0.3078709542751312,
0.4254676401615143,
0.8852835297584534,
0.27568817138671875,
-0.7075726985931396,
0.38290518522262573,
-0.18892964720726013,
-0.5310119390487671,
-0.28107330203056335,
0.203255757689476,
-0.04642994701862335,
0.06070427596569061,
0.2934753894805908,
0.11324551701545715,
0.47781163454055786,
-0.18576398491859436,
0.2241286337375641,
0.4616120755672455,
-0.7086765766143799,
-0.29086512327194214,
0.3884170949459076,
0.23408810794353485,
-0.369812548160553,
0.5861972570419312,
-0.5248321890830994,
0.026807965710759163,
0.8074765801429749,
0.27906572818756104,
0.9409626126289368,
-0.12999854981899261,
0.5306234955787659,
0.2652282416820526,
0.5449495911598206,
0.026175983250141144,
0.14486552774906158,
-0.06632118672132492,
-0.5051577687263489,
-0.9275750517845154,
-0.7055225968360901,
-0.6610722541809082,
0.08082935959100723,
-0.4757106304168701,
0.24001190066337585,
-0.3375582993030548,
0.19586512446403503,
0.27851569652557373,
-0.3181338310241699,
-0.5494945049285889,
0.14941804111003876,
0.51590895652771,
0.9262223243713379,
-0.963020384311676,
0.33862927556037903,
0.4521734118461609,
-0.27417051792144775,
-0.9594189524650574,
0.0687532052397728,
0.42937225103378296,
-0.29277437925338745,
0.8856207132339478,
0.4092652499675751,
-0.13500002026557922,
-0.27973487973213196,
-0.40766003727912903,
-0.6766680479049683,
0.5706772208213806,
0.2103683352470398,
-0.4622049629688263,
-0.36660611629486084,
0.36674097180366516,
0.445587158203125,
-0.03455977141857147,
0.38443705439567566,
0.5626111626625061,
0.24726521968841553,
-0.034748468548059464,
-1.0710915327072144,
-0.16476494073867798,
-0.20735245943069458,
0.12023270130157471,
0.1626068651676178,
0.02330251783132553,
0.03120374120771885,
0.006400497630238533,
-0.6053516268730164,
0.27411705255508423,
1.0421394109725952,
0.36731573939323425,
0.5173280835151672,
0.8195940852165222,
0.09242630749940872,
0.6672874093055725,
-0.0780305415391922,
0.958842396736145,
-0.11537021398544312,
0.051933757960796356,
1.0556718111038208,
-0.6098493933677673,
0.9431881904602051,
0.5169593691825867,
-0.17493751645088196,
0.5482107996940613,
0.5796064138412476,
0.10264476388692856,
0.05648559704422951,
0.15656760334968567,
-0.1517559140920639,
-0.1059802770614624,
-0.02915245108306408,
0.1550348550081253,
0.2874714434146881,
0.19110004603862762,
-0.010208653286099434,
-0.3461742401123047,
0.1754244863986969,
-0.46262359619140625,
-0.02679627202451229,
0.03513611480593681,
0.8868099451065063,
0.12393994629383087,
-0.768456757068634,
0.31639060378074646,
-0.14902237057685852,
0.6060898303985596,
-0.5318801403045654,
-0.16640837490558624,
-0.003494264092296362,
-0.13335780799388885,
-0.20938630402088165,
-0.6219274401664734,
0.845799446105957,
0.05856894701719284,
-0.16896255314350128,
-0.35320162773132324,
0.5039458274841309,
0.06480873376131058,
-0.39779171347618103,
0.27419641613960266,
0.15308880805969238,
0.12820331752300262,
-0.17982377111911774,
-0.6822497844696045,
-0.427138090133667,
0.0696638748049736,
-0.10747303813695908,
0.17091354727745056,
0.3257041275501251,
0.0941196158528328,
0.740961492061615,
0.29027092456817627,
-0.13542109727859497,
0.10269450396299362,
0.20492295920848846,
0.29638683795928955,
-0.6344724297523499,
-0.3245602548122406,
-0.7171846032142639,
0.5537994503974915,
-0.22372043132781982,
-0.09449873119592667,
0.804393470287323,
0.523949921131134,
0.5780996680259705,
0.01053543109446764,
1.0134801864624023,
-0.057680800557136536,
0.6848391890525818,
-0.6354397535324097,
0.3920517563819885,
-0.38005611300468445,
0.348483145236969,
-0.2284918874502182,
-0.5300452709197998,
-0.6844961047172546,
0.38027429580688477,
-0.42788535356521606,
-0.18990768492221832,
0.7283458113670349,
0.7650455832481384,
0.16826629638671875,
0.44141149520874023,
0.08566044270992279,
-0.28515204787254333,
0.2867804169654846,
0.48048919439315796,
0.91524738073349,
-0.5659614205360413,
0.6079387664794922,
-0.11335255950689316,
-0.1212029829621315,
0.13252472877502441,
-0.6961817741394043,
-0.7710511684417725,
-0.34553736448287964,
-0.530379056930542,
-0.05829981714487076,
0.15233352780342102,
1.0085761547088623,
0.8205861449241638,
-1.1350867748260498,
-0.3609660863876343,
-0.5194171071052551,
0.4909026622772217,
-0.27251625061035156,
-0.2483627200126648,
-0.2888449728488922,
-1.079683780670166,
-0.6637563705444336,
0.6810779571533203,
0.3530038893222809,
0.13288944959640503,
0.11012012511491776,
-0.04862990975379944,
-0.3285869061946869,
0.11010325700044632,
0.3379727303981781,
0.6722028851509094,
-0.9755627512931824,
-0.285255491733551,
0.037240054458379745,
-0.13812722265720367,
0.06207043677568436,
0.6471266150474548,
-0.5489915609359741,
0.0005106399185024202,
0.34439176321029663,
0.8935075998306274,
0.07304929196834564,
-0.3376051187515259,
0.7887638211250305,
-0.8338128924369812,
-0.030389372259378433,
0.051554955542087555,
0.18311136960983276,
0.08873569220304489,
-0.22035151720046997,
0.38309282064437866,
0.03279825299978256,
-0.5645416975021362,
-0.7059800624847412,
0.37508589029312134,
-0.7969613075256348,
-0.34795695543289185,
1.094067096710205,
0.10437840223312378,
-0.266171395778656,
-0.6960101127624512,
-0.2682543098926544,
0.18571294844150543,
0.08989780396223068,
0.6931872963905334,
0.5613475441932678,
-0.12485920637845993,
-0.22477057576179504,
-1.1802655458450317,
0.6125651001930237,
0.616917073726654,
-1.1828700304031372,
-0.0171513669192791,
0.33870649337768555,
0.028464479371905327,
0.2683289051055908,
-0.05837634950876236,
0.15637566149234772,
0.22178198397159576,
-0.24689601361751556,
0.3278215527534485,
0.43885567784309387,
-0.10090559720993042,
-0.26894596219062805,
0.2598875164985657,
0.29173576831817627,
-0.251225084066391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16164v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16164v1
|
Towards a Holistic Evaluation of LLMs on Factual Knowledge Recall
| 2024-04-24T19:40:01 | 2024-04-24T19:40:01 |
Jiaqing Yuan, Lin Pan, Chung-Wei Hang, Jiang Guo, Jiarong Jiang, Bonan Min, Patrick Ng, Zhiguo Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance on a variety
of NLP tasks, and are being rapidly adopted in a wide range of use cases. It is
therefore of vital importance to holistically evaluate the factuality of their
generated outputs, as hallucinations remain a challenging issue.
In this work, we focus on assessing LLMs' ability to recall factual knowledge
learned from pretraining, and the factors that affect this ability. To that
end, we construct FACT-BENCH, a representative benchmark covering 20 domains,
134 property types, 3 answer types, and different knowledge popularity levels.
We benchmark 31 models from 10 model families and provide a holistic assessment
of their strengths and weaknesses. We observe that instruction-tuning hurts
knowledge recall, as pretraining-only models consistently outperform their
instruction-tuned counterparts, and positive effects of model scaling, as
larger models outperform smaller ones for all model families. However, the best
performance from GPT-4 still represents a large gap with the upper-bound. We
additionally study the role of in-context exemplars using counterfactual
demonstrations, which lead to significant degradation of factual knowledge
recall for large models. By further decoupling model known and unknown
knowledge, we find the degradation is attributed to exemplars that contradict a
model's known knowledge, as well as the number of such exemplars. Lastly, we
fine-tune LLaMA-7B in different settings of known and unknown knowledge. In
particular, fine-tuning on a model's known knowledge is beneficial, and
consistently outperforms fine-tuning on unknown and mixed knowledge. We will
make our benchmark publicly available.
|
[
-0.3885112702846527,
-0.6854583024978638,
0.6588869690895081,
-0.11678235232830048,
-0.15218961238861084,
0.08577577769756317,
-0.2741742432117462,
-0.37676170468330383,
-0.09190991520881653,
0.5391162037849426,
-0.25105902552604675,
-0.5872973799705505,
-0.7668865919113159,
0.06096729263663292,
-0.3413391411304474,
1.0926823616027832,
-0.018827209249138832,
-0.20386484265327454,
-0.4083055853843689,
-0.07467623800039291,
-0.5538575649261475,
-0.7596323490142822,
-0.17259320616722107,
-0.378553181886673,
0.33847495913505554,
0.08489760756492615,
0.39850738644599915,
0.5498551726341248,
0.4186229705810547,
0.22857074439525604,
-0.06911788135766983,
0.37625038623809814,
-0.796598494052887,
-0.037206392735242844,
-0.3307652771472931,
-0.542538046836853,
-0.585930585861206,
0.04321519657969475,
0.5739256143569946,
0.6416640877723694,
-0.32335349917411804,
0.370776504278183,
0.10486602783203125,
0.6003545522689819,
-0.8153700828552246,
0.2821374237537384,
-1.1211984157562256,
0.1009751409292221,
0.03485856205224991,
-0.4484074115753174,
-0.47785162925720215,
-0.5163744688034058,
0.31889382004737854,
-0.6509254574775696,
0.37010496854782104,
0.219686821103096,
0.937861979007721,
0.539207935333252,
-0.4148091673851013,
-0.3927907347679138,
-0.6903523206710815,
0.566173255443573,
-0.8111474514007568,
0.3073822259902954,
0.5427026152610779,
0.23900380730628967,
-0.13720667362213135,
-0.7167169451713562,
-0.4173433184623718,
-0.35429829359054565,
-0.11665868759155273,
0.23268431425094604,
-0.03109544888138771,
-0.025028889998793602,
0.6918787956237793,
0.44015881419181824,
-0.4160960614681244,
-0.06807997822761536,
-0.3423815667629242,
-0.4107421636581421,
0.42273327708244324,
0.12035876512527466,
0.0383494608104229,
-0.0469692200422287,
-0.37509846687316895,
0.021656854078173637,
-1.0046015977859497,
-0.26450517773628235,
0.16000911593437195,
0.11180165410041809,
0.08983916789293289,
0.5769495964050293,
-0.18755878508090973,
0.6222128868103027,
0.12083355337381363,
-0.41861075162887573,
0.15136153995990753,
-0.1972070336341858,
-0.25644341111183167,
0.2547089755535126,
0.2297469526529312,
0.37591591477394104,
0.28417178988456726,
-0.2602801024913788,
-0.22393010556697845,
0.05637603998184204,
0.44632673263549805,
-0.6349952220916748,
-0.20728732645511627,
-0.2519029676914215,
-0.20822961628437042,
0.15092532336711884,
-0.07332786172628403,
-0.6940672993659973,
-0.5115939974784851,
-0.5761639475822449,
0.7519720196723938,
-0.44016385078430176,
-0.03110804408788681,
0.2972436547279358,
0.07053469121456146,
0.43227487802505493,
0.39177456498146057,
-0.7872710824012756,
0.26462146639823914,
0.6892616152763367,
0.6530236005783081,
-0.18735048174858093,
-0.32585614919662476,
-0.48914653062820435,
0.23953957855701447,
-0.3661014139652252,
0.6822023987770081,
-0.2915758192539215,
-0.2236778885126114,
-0.13926680386066437,
-0.11981241405010223,
-0.2758157551288605,
-0.875971257686615,
0.23401544988155365,
-0.6911660432815552,
-0.06412135064601898,
-0.852609395980835,
-0.8598248958587646,
-0.49879488348960876,
0.609653890132904,
-0.5748661160469055,
0.8261968493461609,
0.021888241171836853,
-0.7479427456855774,
0.42369556427001953,
-0.09885592013597488,
-0.4995814859867096,
-0.19430780410766602,
-0.12396221607923508,
-0.314921498298645,
0.25667569041252136,
-0.018712323158979416,
0.564050018787384,
-0.290959894657135,
0.5431393980979919,
-0.25294873118400574,
-0.4689149856567383,
-0.009891035966575146,
-0.4673333764076233,
0.30005916953086853,
-0.176066592335701,
-0.5613312721252441,
-0.07523951679468155,
-0.9371757507324219,
-0.2649691104888916,
-0.012950258329510689,
-0.2719838619232178,
-0.32858821749687195,
-0.19202759861946106,
-0.7599690556526184,
0.2494937628507614,
0.215667262673378,
-0.20293477177619934,
-0.018726544454693794,
-0.30668672919273376,
0.0012534810230135918,
0.7485305070877075,
0.2375057339668274,
0.025503801181912422,
-0.46717405319213867,
0.27677884697914124,
0.15300624072551727,
0.011688566766679287,
-0.047106917947530746,
-0.1416078805923462,
-1.0537625551223755,
-0.09515732526779175,
0.16059701144695282,
0.38592877984046936,
-0.628659188747406,
0.4875463843345642,
-0.2107984572649002,
-0.41225486993789673,
-0.2785135507583618,
0.2533239722251892,
0.39119210839271545,
0.7440307140350342,
0.47480642795562744,
-0.3508240580558777,
-0.49034446477890015,
-0.7935227751731873,
-0.24009817838668823,
-0.13565568625926971,
0.1210092082619667,
0.19312582910060883,
0.7533137798309326,
-0.26292288303375244,
0.6524159908294678,
-0.34339866042137146,
-0.2475661337375641,
-0.06027093529701233,
0.19437651336193085,
0.029266534373164177,
0.06314855813980103,
0.3556871712207794,
-0.2701236605644226,
-0.16623274981975555,
-0.03839472308754921,
-0.9736098647117615,
0.15265913307666779,
0.027337603271007538,
-0.06762975454330444,
0.37766826152801514,
0.28886178135871887,
-0.817314863204956,
0.6038870811462402,
0.3026393949985504,
-0.23607097566127777,
0.8099757432937622,
-0.43905892968177795,
0.06908056885004044,
-0.6469537615776062,
0.10207042098045349,
-0.2543008327484131,
0.04608232155442238,
-0.3744657635688782,
-0.18731918931007385,
-0.0018321822863072157,
0.3741316497325897,
-0.2607494592666626,
0.3801715075969696,
-0.48145872354507446,
-0.4594641923904419,
-0.04060651361942291,
0.280569463968277,
0.11775652319192886,
0.5302665829658508,
0.20355656743049622,
0.742322564125061,
0.28337568044662476,
-0.8104580044746399,
0.18975505232810974,
0.09359393268823624,
-0.8235983848571777,
0.27119994163513184,
-0.5278133749961853,
0.2836211919784546,
0.03872055560350418,
0.10962386429309845,
-0.8482645750045776,
-0.19232997298240662,
-0.04482628032565117,
0.00013718684203922749,
0.42624256014823914,
0.11406313627958298,
-0.6015477776527405,
-0.1831692010164261,
-0.07334186136722565,
0.0684884786605835,
0.4997025728225708,
-0.6646842956542969,
0.8878867030143738,
0.26480063796043396,
-0.07055912166833878,
-0.6326694488525391,
-0.12447382509708405,
-0.08779893815517426,
-0.36105990409851074,
-0.2091578096151352,
0.21477225422859192,
0.026674870401620865,
-0.16770969331264496,
-0.18270893394947052,
-0.55082768201828,
0.1988176554441452,
0.1431809663772583,
0.16698791086673737,
0.4148954153060913,
-0.21564626693725586,
0.18604826927185059,
0.056836698204278946,
0.07833994925022125,
0.4458647668361664,
-0.08131388574838638,
0.5082501769065857,
-0.569182276725769,
-0.4493526220321655,
-0.0009352561319246888,
-0.3382624387741089,
0.5146785378456116,
-0.22256499528884888,
0.7868129014968872,
0.5065796971321106,
-0.3588916063308716,
-0.13737203180789948,
-0.9765661954879761,
-0.18894922733306885,
-0.3634887933731079,
0.5491071343421936,
-0.2569567561149597,
-0.9046502113342285,
0.5560455918312073,
-0.25046059489250183,
-0.03371139243245125,
0.46763375401496887,
0.8254706263542175,
0.01099057961255312,
0.5257070064544678,
0.3307778537273407,
0.05246392637491226,
-0.1427025943994522,
-0.4163988530635834,
0.1782923936843872,
-0.8059078454971313,
-0.4451133906841278,
-0.16361433267593384,
-0.036414168775081635,
-0.24980539083480835,
-0.3718705475330353,
0.4063311815261841,
0.014703123830258846,
-0.35078442096710205,
0.07397174090147018,
-0.0510922335088253,
0.4373083710670471,
0.39520078897476196,
0.17472092807292938,
0.5545722842216492,
-0.07341763377189636,
-0.18519842624664307,
0.09753409773111343,
-0.8011189103126526,
-0.7223606705665588,
1.300254464149475,
0.2362007200717926,
0.6404380202293396,
-0.04241347312927246,
0.5036219358444214,
0.09235818684101105,
0.5256484746932983,
-0.6530393958091736,
0.6063083410263062,
0.06384026259183884,
-0.8528727889060974,
-0.2451067715883255,
-0.4003504514694214,
-0.5277183651924133,
0.2721758782863617,
-0.32906779646873474,
-0.44381147623062134,
-0.005518923979252577,
0.4115341007709503,
-0.6401362419128418,
0.46785297989845276,
-0.6557256579399109,
0.6678352952003479,
-0.5006251335144043,
-0.4629064202308655,
-0.30573973059654236,
-0.7221018075942993,
0.7012307643890381,
-0.3460671305656433,
0.09228119254112244,
-0.11741545796394348,
0.3248944878578186,
0.7348605990409851,
0.023024553433060646,
0.9913640022277832,
-0.1477597951889038,
-0.20140446722507477,
0.26184841990470886,
0.15287908911705017,
0.36030375957489014,
-0.08780885487794876,
0.017396679148077965,
0.22336308658123016,
0.29459109902381897,
-0.1211400181055069,
-0.7323508858680725,
0.4743279218673706,
-0.9278271198272705,
-0.8896715641021729,
-0.3228704631328583,
-0.4437686502933502,
-0.6204710006713867,
0.07335244119167328,
0.36375153064727783,
0.4262416660785675,
-0.4265977740287781,
0.33245348930358887,
1.05856192111969,
-0.42840686440467834,
0.03809081390500069,
0.6254040002822876,
-0.2608789801597595,
-0.0819120854139328,
0.9967317581176758,
0.4487302601337433,
0.3158513307571411,
0.3731575608253479,
0.19509704411029816,
-0.4347008466720581,
-0.546536922454834,
-0.005770903080701828,
0.38283637166023254,
-0.9637821316719055,
-0.28406450152397156,
-0.583954930305481,
-0.33956390619277954,
-0.25514453649520874,
0.1848151981830597,
-0.4252895414829254,
-0.18185679614543915,
-0.29116976261138916,
-0.3680240213871002,
0.08207647502422333,
0.9236666560173035,
0.06511063128709793,
0.12202941626310349,
-0.5801159739494324,
0.4459456503391266,
0.5477473139762878,
0.34381726384162903,
0.33542004227638245,
-0.8367705941200256,
-0.3164076805114746,
-0.061495352536439896,
-0.3130989670753479,
-0.5433343052864075,
0.2910807430744171,
0.10192762315273285,
0.736263632774353,
0.45358720421791077,
0.23882365226745605,
0.6957990527153015,
-0.4076368510723114,
0.6279480457305908,
0.016652267426252365,
-0.8491875529289246,
0.37288424372673035,
-0.03438865393400192,
0.15243078768253326,
0.6133939623832703,
0.5030074119567871,
-0.10124167799949646,
-0.12609587609767914,
-0.6484276652336121,
-0.6122471690177917,
0.40854114294052124,
-0.10776632279157639,
-0.09593123942613602,
-0.1347244381904602,
0.5100443959236145,
0.41900137066841125,
0.3675156831741333,
-0.5794892907142639,
-0.10525864362716675,
-0.4727000594139099,
0.043141648173332214,
-0.13676539063453674,
-0.503519594669342,
-0.23540492355823517,
-0.4891303777694702,
0.781947672367096,
0.05641822889447212,
0.03972635418176651,
0.029086915776133537,
-0.4738810062408447,
0.1367478221654892,
0.2948077321052551,
0.6514328122138977,
0.9683670997619629,
-0.4074419140815735,
0.4366248548030853,
0.653245210647583,
-0.37824511528015137,
0.0505204014480114,
-0.10619156062602997,
-0.12573541700839996,
-0.25694212317466736,
0.6723809242248535,
1.057287573814392,
0.3639703392982483,
-0.5815311670303345,
0.35251370072364807,
0.03829295188188553,
-0.1887052357196808,
-0.21627196669578552,
0.29571840167045593,
0.07205699384212494,
0.10509111732244492,
0.149861142039299,
0.12560629844665527,
0.02429269813001156,
-0.6970592737197876,
0.1047833263874054,
0.35503044724464417,
-0.23745015263557434,
-0.5250885486602783,
0.31948915123939514,
-0.06247889623045921,
0.04389254003763199,
0.6471390724182129,
-0.15898911654949188,
-0.6158424615859985,
0.4657978117465973,
0.6112029552459717,
0.48922547698020935,
-0.23979796469211578,
0.024158872663974762,
0.48836860060691833,
0.48336347937583923,
-0.31423220038414,
-0.14203709363937378,
-0.15009848773479462,
-0.899636447429657,
-0.35427746176719666,
-0.6008210778236389,
-0.2897546589374542,
0.3569086790084839,
-0.8271610140800476,
-0.034018177539110184,
-0.6488062739372253,
-0.264470636844635,
-0.5038732290267944,
0.17436754703521729,
-0.9077619910240173,
0.3419835567474365,
0.025088945403695107,
0.7529175281524658,
-0.7560511827468872,
0.7577516436576843,
0.3624221980571747,
-0.15015727281570435,
-0.8883875012397766,
0.06452544778585434,
-0.0848631039261818,
-0.9050874710083008,
0.6933280229568481,
0.1285165250301361,
-0.3245568871498108,
0.1342252492904663,
-0.4019882380962372,
-0.9276489019393921,
1.2488211393356323,
0.5463241934776306,
-0.7190391421318054,
-0.210996612906456,
0.01002766378223896,
0.5852652788162231,
-0.27695000171661377,
0.1955903023481369,
1.0062283277511597,
0.47935086488723755,
0.31154483556747437,
-0.7094020843505859,
0.11358606815338135,
0.028026169165968895,
-0.21400900185108185,
-0.27227240800857544,
-0.5233060121536255,
0.5111193060874939,
-0.3609154224395752,
-0.19815659523010254,
-0.20940780639648438,
0.651017427444458,
0.5471958518028259,
0.2742293179035187,
0.4219866693019867,
0.5590126514434814,
1.049277901649475,
-0.0027268328703939915,
0.9760190844535828,
-0.2745254933834076,
0.2499009668827057,
1.3407824039459229,
-0.5526713132858276,
0.7966296672821045,
0.3535681366920471,
-0.1129429042339325,
0.32882776856422424,
0.417827844619751,
0.07804881036281586,
0.5844057202339172,
0.24662324786186218,
-0.03479559347033501,
-0.4530990421772003,
0.04666772112250328,
-0.5660989284515381,
0.43662527203559875,
0.4287571907043457,
-0.1406877040863037,
-0.1831342726945877,
-0.14706790447235107,
-0.050201114267110825,
-0.10322998464107513,
-0.3008345365524292,
0.7948316931724548,
0.19269631803035736,
-0.7571377158164978,
0.7218916416168213,
-0.31058621406555176,
0.40097755193710327,
-0.6424544453620911,
-0.06153707951307297,
-0.31485694646835327,
0.08314503729343414,
-0.05144558846950531,
-0.4379567503929138,
0.3615919053554535,
-0.12862029671669006,
-0.17750076949596405,
0.09136032313108444,
0.7599269151687622,
-0.3454258441925049,
-0.2594500482082367,
0.3949773907661438,
0.5234260559082031,
0.04726483300328255,
-0.02829507179558277,
-0.31672999262809753,
0.18084077537059784,
-0.0700787901878357,
-0.4614618122577667,
0.4295494854450226,
0.4837111532688141,
0.06322852522134781,
0.6888736486434937,
0.3258388638496399,
0.17741744220256805,
0.29906630516052246,
0.10897119343280792,
0.6757968664169312,
-0.6820713877677917,
0.0025265731383115053,
-0.8826121091842651,
0.22100259363651276,
0.1412900984287262,
-0.23361405730247498,
0.9184283018112183,
0.5592929124832153,
0.9562146067619324,
-0.1939428150653839,
0.7226400375366211,
0.32097283005714417,
0.455344021320343,
-0.8090793490409851,
0.7241917252540588,
-0.3757208585739136,
0.5348652601242065,
-0.20537428557872772,
-0.9224857687950134,
-0.05272523686289787,
0.6841229200363159,
-0.6338973045349121,
0.12812867760658264,
0.699187159538269,
0.719083845615387,
0.07212140411138535,
0.11000239104032516,
0.6612309217453003,
0.5893513560295105,
0.053434986621141434,
0.4606800079345703,
1.2522025108337402,
-0.24511335790157318,
0.27420997619628906,
-0.12751519680023193,
-0.16729646921157837,
-0.20227013528347015,
-1.0056740045547485,
-1.1388529539108276,
-0.45307838916778564,
-0.21841873228549957,
-0.20226718485355377,
0.1626918911933899,
0.7923673987388611,
0.5748081803321838,
-0.7379234433174133,
-0.19252009689807892,
0.26749685406684875,
0.17526310682296753,
-0.07025403529405594,
-0.12772274017333984,
0.5074350833892822,
-0.29685619473457336,
-0.007420526817440987,
0.3099076449871063,
0.35266250371932983,
0.011098615825176239,
-0.21630306541919708,
-0.11231709271669388,
-0.0619523860514164,
0.09704241901636124,
0.9627938270568848,
0.10432615131139755,
-0.8422663807868958,
-0.497758150100708,
0.09104795008897781,
0.1133899986743927,
-0.09579973667860031,
0.7215576767921448,
-0.8416933417320251,
0.27405354380607605,
0.07660557329654694,
0.7212824821472168,
0.7152203917503357,
0.014082028530538082,
0.4103388488292694,
-0.5274214148521423,
-0.2683814764022827,
0.0326930470764637,
0.3984169363975525,
0.3477216958999634,
-0.17772431671619415,
0.38980215787887573,
0.30395957827568054,
-0.47880810499191284,
-0.7444438338279724,
-0.030956095084547997,
-0.7499909996986389,
-0.20700524747371674,
1.062916874885559,
-0.344438374042511,
0.05048977956175804,
-0.18741796910762787,
-0.05504995957016945,
0.4694923758506775,
0.1320679783821106,
1.1837211847305298,
0.964939534664154,
0.020887814462184906,
-0.05727693811058998,
-0.6178847551345825,
0.44671866297721863,
0.3343009054660797,
-0.7695668339729309,
0.232595756649971,
0.536307692527771,
0.43085339665412903,
0.145974799990654,
0.43653008341789246,
-0.025433437898755074,
0.05728667974472046,
-0.19923844933509827,
0.0534612238407135,
-0.11322414875030518,
-0.664421021938324,
-0.11911290138959885,
0.09188389778137207,
0.11215586215257645,
0.3890891373157501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16160v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16160v1
|
Domain-Specific Improvement on Psychotherapy Chatbot Using Assistant
| 2024-04-24T19:30:18 | 2024-04-24T19:30:18 |
Cheng Kang, Daniel Novak, Katerina Urbanova, Yuqing Cheng, Yong Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive generalization
capabilities on specific tasks with human-written instruction data. However,
the limited quantity, diversity, and professional expertise of such instruction
data raise concerns about the performance of LLMs in psychotherapy tasks when
provided with domain-specific instructions. To address this, we firstly propose
Domain-Specific Assistant Instructions based on AlexanderStreet therapy, and
secondly, we use an adaption fine-tuning method and retrieval augmented
generation method to improve pre-trained LLMs. Through quantitative evaluation
of linguistic quality using automatic and human evaluation, we observe that
pre-trained LLMs on Psychotherapy Assistant Instructions outperform
state-of-the-art LLMs response baselines. Our Assistant-Instruction approach
offers a half-annotation method to align pre-trained LLMs with instructions and
provide pre-trained LLMs with more psychotherapy knowledge.
|
[
-0.15260419249534607,
-1.0949219465255737,
0.5673521757125854,
0.040728747844696045,
-0.20992325246334076,
0.34908080101013184,
-0.48623645305633545,
-0.33720478415489197,
0.4088365137577057,
0.5253814458847046,
-0.6049676537513733,
-0.45287296175956726,
-0.9237565994262695,
0.09689322859048843,
-0.020431388169527054,
0.7985961437225342,
0.013713155873119831,
0.3206453323364258,
-0.09041889756917953,
0.22487375140190125,
-0.9654865860939026,
-0.5165196061134338,
-0.8978039026260376,
-0.4128352403640747,
0.36666563153266907,
0.5106650590896606,
0.6884961724281311,
0.30551210045814514,
0.6882186532020569,
0.31317317485809326,
-0.014005604200065136,
0.45756542682647705,
-0.5685349106788635,
0.0039116800762712955,
-0.19715142250061035,
-0.3586733341217041,
-1.1889607906341553,
-0.213176891207695,
0.29483404755592346,
0.8033994436264038,
-0.3250022530555725,
0.019704457372426987,
0.34234756231307983,
0.5033535957336426,
-0.38825687766075134,
0.059999674558639526,
-0.5202836990356445,
0.048089977353811264,
0.027683256193995476,
-0.6551498770713806,
-0.5849522352218628,
-0.41278690099716187,
0.3933602273464203,
-0.6195088624954224,
0.2713029980659485,
0.12150627374649048,
0.5688334703445435,
0.18788324296474457,
-0.42414331436157227,
-0.2605116665363312,
-0.6929160952568054,
0.6334287524223328,
-0.8142499923706055,
0.29936036467552185,
0.7853438854217529,
0.31923606991767883,
-0.5615234971046448,
-0.6712097525596619,
-0.2125989943742752,
-0.2478124350309372,
-0.28369972109794617,
-0.1568305343389511,
-0.3611096441745758,
0.4361720085144043,
0.10932259261608124,
0.1870148777961731,
-0.5603832006454468,
0.14055101573467255,
-0.14366164803504944,
-0.33940401673316956,
0.6896088123321533,
0.4731200337409973,
0.32652896642684937,
0.21218836307525635,
0.02505583129823208,
0.0829281210899353,
-0.5728980898857117,
-0.27151909470558167,
0.11591105908155441,
0.36352914571762085,
-0.048266325145959854,
0.34060344099998474,
-0.0609891340136528,
0.6477528214454651,
0.36603930592536926,
-0.2549420893192291,
0.13869264721870422,
0.0033697846811264753,
-0.21591471135616302,
-0.08847614377737045,
0.6931994557380676,
0.30023592710494995,
0.40558645129203796,
-0.39173945784568787,
0.19714190065860748,
-0.31982967257499695,
0.5578184127807617,
-0.6727178692817688,
-0.48998016119003296,
0.2619912326335907,
-0.2931830585002899,
0.06334085017442703,
-0.6882356405258179,
-0.4983665645122528,
-0.2866493761539459,
-0.4529462158679962,
0.6097522974014282,
-0.8680309057235718,
-0.02520189806818962,
0.23817279934883118,
0.14554129540920258,
-0.10284030437469482,
0.5901002287864685,
-0.9248879551887512,
0.5362637639045715,
0.44692641496658325,
0.6357436776161194,
-0.18776872754096985,
-0.2979384958744049,
-0.34284302592277527,
0.14802150428295135,
-0.32812750339508057,
0.9616547226905823,
-0.6527952551841736,
-0.3205936551094055,
0.09193495661020279,
0.021745309233665466,
-0.0925273522734642,
-0.565130352973938,
0.2821502387523651,
-0.5021165013313293,
0.5259857773780823,
0.24081721901893616,
-0.8608589768409729,
-0.07414345443248749,
0.2477479875087738,
-0.022097067907452583,
0.5091850757598877,
0.34671178460121155,
-0.4943833351135254,
0.024580510333180428,
-1.0543174743652344,
-0.5440014600753784,
0.16525693237781525,
0.1269909143447876,
-0.03755798190832138,
-0.1475706398487091,
0.2769463062286377,
0.41717031598091125,
-0.17424875497817993,
-0.005789879243820906,
-0.09912983328104019,
-0.3804146647453308,
0.26481667160987854,
-0.25369536876678467,
0.5381029844284058,
-0.08980514854192734,
-0.06706824898719788,
0.32564741373062134,
-0.697510302066803,
0.27294203639030457,
0.08718583732843399,
-0.3112657368183136,
-0.14921174943447113,
-0.4003733992576599,
-0.18981915712356567,
-0.21890157461166382,
0.3019999861717224,
-0.2849709093570709,
0.3435123562812805,
-0.46736377477645874,
0.05232056602835655,
0.914672315120697,
0.31329479813575745,
0.2325548529624939,
-0.3210752606391907,
0.8636511564254761,
-0.3795125186443329,
0.07811857014894485,
-0.18809613585472107,
-0.27774181962013245,
-0.7270370125770569,
-0.45281556248664856,
0.3824610412120819,
0.38432279229164124,
-0.6313283443450928,
0.6611119508743286,
-0.17385247349739075,
-0.37816107273101807,
-0.4627709984779358,
0.1520092636346817,
0.5922895073890686,
0.345280259847641,
0.4942176342010498,
-0.7466667890548706,
-0.5815714001655579,
-0.8029014468193054,
-0.26762819290161133,
0.17883065342903137,
-0.16905483603477478,
0.33946117758750916,
0.09627766162157059,
-0.35235241055488586,
0.5841063857078552,
-0.6873515844345093,
-0.53997403383255,
-0.13573811948299408,
0.030805068090558052,
-0.07966305315494537,
0.37487003207206726,
0.2399437129497528,
-0.1444980353116989,
-0.7298429608345032,
-0.1519230753183365,
-0.4540298283100128,
-0.11028101295232773,
0.09374824911355972,
-0.33160150051116943,
0.0364895798265934,
0.25248342752456665,
-0.418241947889328,
0.3704603612422943,
0.21422547101974487,
-0.32114988565444946,
0.41131508350372314,
-0.5414363741874695,
0.3132742941379547,
-1.051360845565796,
-0.30301913619041443,
-0.1860727071762085,
-0.4981822371482849,
-0.8707919120788574,
-0.17758826911449432,
-0.2865715026855469,
-0.02419763244688511,
-0.324521005153656,
0.4344782829284668,
-0.33407965302467346,
0.17044301331043243,
-0.7344679832458496,
0.29051586985588074,
-0.18575207889080048,
0.9502837061882019,
0.2112969160079956,
0.7127445340156555,
0.5877053737640381,
-0.5039730072021484,
0.5250101089477539,
0.40732255578041077,
-0.034834448248147964,
0.6525810956954956,
-0.5086919069290161,
0.8095965385437012,
0.3112538456916809,
0.3228763937950134,
-0.9291533827781677,
-0.32132044434547424,
0.24857816100120544,
-0.34706035256385803,
0.4574737548828125,
-0.0038407861720770597,
-0.46114298701286316,
-0.01006443239748478,
-0.01395415049046278,
0.19381636381149292,
0.6057350039482117,
-0.3234829604625702,
0.45995429158210754,
0.30037733912467957,
-0.3017265200614929,
-0.45414459705352783,
-0.29382678866386414,
0.19901376962661743,
-0.23883230984210968,
-0.5290488004684448,
0.2661452293395996,
-0.0865212008357048,
0.008798814378678799,
-0.2946529686450958,
0.13112908601760864,
-0.14468640089035034,
-0.013799973763525486,
0.02404341846704483,
-0.00854930654168129,
0.01364945713430643,
0.16127270460128784,
0.14504751563072205,
-0.18790382146835327,
0.03834187984466553,
-0.026190651580691338,
0.9482307434082031,
0.038579534739255905,
-0.3776346743106842,
-0.8888060450553894,
0.20921695232391357,
0.026060987263917923,
0.09876549988985062,
0.6296743154525757,
0.5100300312042236,
-0.2324294000864029,
-0.19439347088336945,
-0.30129390954971313,
-0.4142782688140869,
-0.48547184467315674,
0.529079794883728,
-0.3014853298664093,
-0.8010663390159607,
0.19313405454158783,
-0.2810100018978119,
0.019252654165029526,
-0.05638642981648445,
0.6848022937774658,
-0.18610140681266785,
1.1272850036621094,
0.7260632514953613,
0.19153456389904022,
0.6066922545433044,
-0.39231008291244507,
0.30441948771476746,
-1.042400598526001,
0.01726764440536499,
-0.18971560895442963,
-0.350815087556839,
-0.19219911098480225,
-0.22267918288707733,
0.22410817444324493,
-0.07585693150758743,
-0.4561692774295807,
0.4888753890991211,
-0.6960102915763855,
0.36684903502464294,
0.4972744882106781,
0.517646849155426,
0.3306347131729126,
0.00022531196009367704,
0.33568164706230164,
-0.2471882551908493,
-0.7354605197906494,
-0.6879426836967468,
1.326862096786499,
0.42750388383865356,
0.7702377438545227,
0.27536553144454956,
0.6305970549583435,
0.48502281308174133,
0.2969018816947937,
-0.6576951742172241,
0.6056424975395203,
0.08099408447742462,
-0.4302700161933899,
-0.1917940229177475,
-0.20855331420898438,
-1.161758303642273,
0.1288461983203888,
0.08478588610887527,
-1.1674028635025024,
-0.0015443392330780625,
0.41195347905158997,
-0.47976478934288025,
-0.19473598897457123,
-0.8575047850608826,
0.861247718334198,
-0.2780109643936157,
-0.05730156600475311,
-0.642930805683136,
-0.42890602350234985,
0.13518831133842468,
-0.19778954982757568,
0.11960238218307495,
-0.1717509776353836,
0.05448107048869133,
0.7220809459686279,
-0.47740232944488525,
0.9720669984817505,
-0.1988939344882965,
-0.16829219460487366,
-0.04597419872879982,
0.4362456202507019,
0.44220760464668274,
-0.316652774810791,
0.21276165544986725,
-0.26129505038261414,
0.13206827640533447,
-0.592262327671051,
-0.9238088130950928,
0.4618821144104004,
-0.8761904239654541,
-0.9396865367889404,
-0.04431155323982239,
-0.8815032243728638,
-0.76748126745224,
-0.060576096177101135,
0.20906102657318115,
0.32759684324264526,
-0.21472127735614777,
-0.1137387827038765,
0.47251495718955994,
-0.2801799476146698,
-0.1350725293159485,
0.7717374563217163,
-0.22772519290447235,
-0.35359716415405273,
0.7196871638298035,
-0.09128016233444214,
0.39915016293525696,
0.09658479690551758,
0.13293959200382233,
0.027657601982355118,
-0.5911630988121033,
-0.015803327783942223,
0.12457974255084991,
-0.8316279053688049,
-0.28603529930114746,
-0.4958631694316864,
-0.1133732795715332,
-0.6929318904876709,
-0.24245190620422363,
-0.15809893608093262,
-0.4273989498615265,
-0.14444531500339508,
0.004485730081796646,
0.7304283380508423,
0.41422221064567566,
0.1561669111251831,
0.8366534113883972,
-0.709817111492157,
0.2758435308933258,
0.22589443624019623,
0.2736074924468994,
0.16454634070396423,
-1.1835771799087524,
-0.5519146919250488,
0.24458132684230804,
-0.6494813561439514,
-0.6962302923202515,
0.4028056263923645,
0.2854982018470764,
0.29495516419410706,
0.27784642577171326,
0.03302040696144104,
0.9678465127944946,
-0.6250930428504944,
0.6608272194862366,
0.1337224692106247,
-0.8112660050392151,
0.8134785294532776,
-0.21896237134933472,
0.20247207581996918,
0.17745274305343628,
0.27592960000038147,
-0.37111058831214905,
-0.5657150149345398,
-0.7930082678794861,
-0.5386891961097717,
1.1859711408615112,
0.18275868892669678,
0.5683905482292175,
0.1306648999452591,
0.4146382212638855,
0.031246861442923546,
0.04558761790394783,
-0.4112512767314911,
-0.27902600169181824,
0.19146589934825897,
-0.2873307466506958,
0.18638703227043152,
-0.13218723237514496,
-0.506594717502594,
-0.23716972768306732,
0.8852424621582031,
-0.1824047565460205,
0.5115516781806946,
0.03450724110007286,
-0.008884553797543049,
-0.4324153959751129,
0.2235870212316513,
0.4122554063796997,
0.8148678541183472,
-0.29733720421791077,
-0.0715920552611351,
0.5014330744743347,
-0.3924744427204132,
0.1635189801454544,
0.06376952677965164,
0.5312145352363586,
-0.09861409664154053,
0.7440427541732788,
0.8377067446708679,
-0.19111227989196777,
-0.8475140333175659,
0.38364729285240173,
-0.2394053339958191,
-0.0756959542632103,
-0.4051554501056671,
0.569286584854126,
0.04739343374967575,
0.32418233156204224,
0.15464629232883453,
-0.06761486083269119,
0.12682141363620758,
-0.6677267551422119,
0.14446184039115906,
0.26789066195487976,
-0.27094095945358276,
-0.3749135434627533,
0.3478553295135498,
0.1344069242477417,
-1.0434527397155762,
0.26876720786094666,
0.025742167606949806,
-0.36197513341903687,
0.225251704454422,
0.7233527898788452,
0.7475906014442444,
-0.3466588258743286,
0.035208702087402344,
-0.0438585989177227,
-0.16560740768909454,
0.3465275466442108,
0.22470122575759888,
-0.142185777425766,
-0.6852726340293884,
-0.4939650297164917,
-0.11979345232248306,
-0.6746447682380676,
0.029252590611577034,
-0.5898697972297668,
0.20868729054927826,
-0.5938959717750549,
-0.25406429171562195,
0.13554733991622925,
0.10540968179702759,
-0.6625889539718628,
0.06979310512542725,
-0.17478156089782715,
0.6490785479545593,
-0.46392810344696045,
0.9998316168785095,
0.8229766488075256,
-0.3739272952079773,
-0.8617979884147644,
0.07445001602172852,
-0.07786712050437927,
-0.9381210207939148,
0.6978883147239685,
-0.38733071088790894,
-0.14021578431129456,
-0.030539575964212418,
-0.5462272763252258,
-0.6938924789428711,
1.0724014043807983,
0.7136662006378174,
-0.4528411030769348,
-0.06859267503023148,
0.33247196674346924,
1.083832859992981,
-0.45213720202445984,
0.45559147000312805,
0.6776176691055298,
0.07232440263032913,
-0.0669916644692421,
-1.320577621459961,
-0.03024251200258732,
-0.09618310630321503,
0.06445453315973282,
0.026665253564715385,
-0.576668918132782,
0.13471174240112305,
0.05665138363838196,
-0.018976712599396706,
0.17759154736995697,
0.3898128867149353,
0.042467858642339706,
0.0379437617957592,
0.2872897982597351,
0.3116357922554016,
0.7086520195007324,
0.1477067768573761,
1.076567530632019,
-0.5619930624961853,
0.23627716302871704,
1.4838061332702637,
-0.16399411857128143,
0.6366432309150696,
0.3603307604789734,
-0.4715271294116974,
0.4208160638809204,
0.7090846300125122,
0.29905039072036743,
0.4884626567363739,
0.10100042819976807,
-0.15169326961040497,
-0.166435107588768,
-0.2808918058872223,
-0.16097857058048248,
0.3048088252544403,
0.4087219536304474,
-0.5116376876831055,
0.05418098345398903,
0.35176336765289307,
0.05146254226565361,
0.21524760127067566,
-0.05244266614317894,
1.1368399858474731,
0.2050054520368576,
-0.513088583946228,
1.0342875719070435,
-0.02624371089041233,
0.35312479734420776,
-0.5555728673934937,
-0.21126382052898407,
-0.31390881538391113,
0.4375622570514679,
-0.2537550628185272,
-0.6461672782897949,
0.255619615316391,
0.22217132151126862,
0.1303934007883072,
-0.13491758704185486,
0.5262930989265442,
-0.38978931307792664,
-0.2537144720554352,
0.30979374051094055,
0.3932098150253296,
0.5538793206214905,
0.12193552404642105,
-0.6528691053390503,
-0.22662973403930664,
0.09370233863592148,
-0.2754591703414917,
0.5014535784721375,
0.4812310039997101,
0.09330961108207703,
0.7775307297706604,
0.4354034662246704,
0.18787257373332977,
-0.24982653558254242,
0.17542684078216553,
0.8371380567550659,
-0.36842843890190125,
-0.14368125796318054,
-0.6960286498069763,
0.29147398471832275,
-0.0165324117988348,
-0.37700310349464417,
0.5939098000526428,
0.19264937937259674,
0.6268805265426636,
0.10868274420499802,
0.47355881333351135,
0.08577658236026764,
0.8602343201637268,
-0.4338790476322174,
0.2409432977437973,
-0.32755401730537415,
0.528380274772644,
-0.22576084733009338,
-0.9532623291015625,
-0.4466780722141266,
0.6182878017425537,
-0.5524733662605286,
0.12346557527780533,
0.6675853729248047,
0.8544495701789856,
-0.1160600408911705,
-0.07744158804416656,
0.43291565775871277,
0.19432170689105988,
0.40117236971855164,
0.5247831344604492,
0.7842363715171814,
-0.2651859521865845,
0.47156497836112976,
-0.254620224237442,
-0.18009935319423676,
-0.18050505220890045,
-0.3723246157169342,
-0.91745525598526,
-0.3662346601486206,
-0.4453124701976776,
-0.33776986598968506,
0.4041726589202881,
1.3274719715118408,
0.8380404710769653,
-0.6722733378410339,
-0.27789637446403503,
0.10840055346488953,
-0.22518885135650635,
-0.16130948066711426,
-0.19734442234039307,
0.7430925965309143,
-0.570445716381073,
-0.7596657872200012,
0.43189847469329834,
0.08662852644920349,
-0.1075599417090416,
-0.296922504901886,
-0.3203337788581848,
-0.0314098559319973,
0.2601051926612854,
0.5248239040374756,
-0.11899922788143158,
-0.6842712163925171,
-0.5154017210006714,
-0.028497908264398575,
-0.03607003018260002,
0.4649156928062439,
0.7065545916557312,
-0.475923091173172,
0.4642902910709381,
0.13678529858589172,
0.5253756046295166,
0.3600250780582428,
0.09832999110221863,
0.938254177570343,
-0.9582279920578003,
0.1821432113647461,
0.43915677070617676,
0.32550162076950073,
0.34103021025657654,
-0.4913811683654785,
0.5409520864486694,
-0.32208451628685,
-0.7662837505340576,
-0.7863011956214905,
0.05478045716881752,
-0.7213730812072754,
-0.41921722888946533,
1.1214544773101807,
-0.5323582887649536,
-0.17143091559410095,
-0.24796870350837708,
-0.8213995099067688,
0.2757951617240906,
-0.4456392526626587,
1.0787091255187988,
0.6221004724502563,
-0.7960827350616455,
-0.3604607582092285,
-0.19355608522891998,
0.5819769501686096,
0.6263217329978943,
-0.709337592124939,
0.20668436586856842,
0.4730987846851349,
0.2873806655406952,
0.20863917469978333,
1.004711389541626,
0.14067402482032776,
0.38195544481277466,
-0.20379148423671722,
0.30361559987068176,
0.04044885188341141,
-0.03801971301436424,
-0.271291047334671,
-0.05513492971658707,
0.5187429785728455,
-0.24623048305511475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16891v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16891v1
|
Attacks on Third-Party APIs of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-24T19:27:02 | 2024-04-24T19:27:02 |
Wanru Zhao, Vidit Khazanchi, Haodi Xing, Xuanli He, Qiongkai Xu, Nicholas Donald Lane
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Large language model (LLM) services have recently begun offering a plugin
ecosystem to interact with third-party API services. This innovation enhances
the capabilities of LLMs, but it also introduces risks, as these plugins
developed by various third parties cannot be easily trusted. This paper
proposes a new attacking framework to examine security and safety
vulnerabilities within LLM platforms that incorporate third-party services.
Applying our framework specifically to widely used LLMs, we identify real-world
malicious attacks across various domains on third-party APIs that can
imperceptibly modify LLM outputs. The paper discusses the unique challenges
posed by third-party API integration and offers strategic possibilities to
improve the security and safety of LLM ecosystems moving forward. Our code is
released at https://github.com/vk0812/Third-Party-Attacks-on-LLMs.
|
[
-0.2772561013698578,
-0.8198391795158386,
0.7119539976119995,
0.10462906211614609,
-0.0329117476940155,
0.21095818281173706,
0.06634527444839478,
-0.7820073366165161,
0.057423289865255356,
1.0479419231414795,
-0.6330714225769043,
-0.5056859850883484,
-0.5378618836402893,
-0.13283368945121765,
-0.5274035930633545,
0.48957428336143494,
0.14779837429523468,
0.042532771825790405,
-0.08106935024261475,
-0.058199282735586166,
-0.5201475024223328,
-0.9899807572364807,
-0.5372348427772522,
0.15340271592140198,
0.7449864745140076,
0.15973149240016937,
0.544899046421051,
0.09208479523658752,
0.7135201096534729,
0.31982356309890747,
-0.012025149539113045,
-0.35045066475868225,
-0.4828496277332306,
0.29567334055900574,
-0.12953126430511475,
-0.5855429172515869,
-0.7085851430892944,
-0.26522231101989746,
0.3097088634967804,
0.512269914150238,
0.09150706231594086,
0.3687104284763336,
0.11128558218479156,
0.36578068137168884,
-0.767688512802124,
-0.10648470371961594,
-0.8767926096916199,
-0.010480360127985477,
-0.5992636680603027,
-0.10995086282491684,
-0.7066994309425354,
-0.17449918389320374,
-0.023939568549394608,
-0.19401691854000092,
-0.4879806339740753,
0.1035202369093895,
0.49468228220939636,
0.04592795670032501,
-0.15751492977142334,
-0.1757219135761261,
-0.46008187532424927,
0.6704408526420593,
-0.7245513200759888,
0.11224420368671417,
0.21865355968475342,
0.33147165179252625,
-0.7176812887191772,
-0.5967495441436768,
-0.35076940059661865,
0.01195517461746931,
0.06831241399049759,
-0.4194585084915161,
-0.5948693752288818,
-0.15159045159816742,
0.13572178781032562,
0.20243600010871887,
-0.40153440833091736,
0.5719224214553833,
-0.1456083208322525,
-0.27449890971183777,
0.5567494034767151,
0.18508218228816986,
0.7011051774024963,
-0.07979033142328262,
-0.37159183621406555,
0.3357817232608795,
-1.2400672435760498,
-0.06662636995315552,
1.0192855596542358,
0.4720868766307831,
-0.13296112418174744,
0.6937925219535828,
0.2548098862171173,
0.5984784960746765,
-0.1854419857263565,
-0.04054543003439903,
0.08382456749677658,
0.2118670642375946,
-0.12244716286659241,
-0.00420945743098855,
0.8064689636230469,
0.35245752334594727,
0.004122792277485132,
-0.13038161396980286,
-0.4309566020965576,
-0.2553897798061371,
0.0339956171810627,
-0.5616113543510437,
-0.02800273336470127,
0.5695422887802124,
-0.2983270585536957,
-0.5750292539596558,
-0.15333005785942078,
-0.7950240969657898,
-0.7032923698425293,
0.16276973485946655,
0.2544119656085968,
-0.3378552496433258,
-0.44744810461997986,
-0.05416163057088852,
0.20960722863674164,
0.31476613879203796,
0.03442266210913658,
-0.7425037026405334,
0.3508884012699127,
1.33612060546875,
0.895372211933136,
-0.046227388083934784,
-0.21881531178951263,
-0.8699132800102234,
0.36537572741508484,
-0.17729181051254272,
0.6425203084945679,
-0.30983176827430725,
-0.5713333487510681,
0.3595118224620819,
0.13690882921218872,
0.28865429759025574,
-0.3684086799621582,
0.2729690968990326,
-1.2332079410552979,
-0.0762406587600708,
-0.224640354514122,
-0.5849176645278931,
0.01574871875345707,
0.31191661953926086,
-0.8670201897621155,
0.597017765045166,
-0.13410069048404694,
-0.8980532288551331,
-0.12112381309270859,
-0.5139437317848206,
-0.35084834694862366,
0.23929350078105927,
0.02243603579699993,
-0.11822229623794556,
0.09940864890813828,
0.07542329281568527,
0.503362238407135,
-0.029284117743372917,
-0.07202167809009552,
-0.8281337022781372,
-0.21613255143165588,
0.6881136298179626,
-0.4075755178928375,
1.20889151096344,
0.17727045714855194,
0.07994304597377777,
0.23546701669692993,
-0.7956631183624268,
-0.04285941645503044,
0.2388847917318344,
-0.051241111010313034,
-0.401144415140152,
0.011150047183036804,
0.1276417374610901,
0.10660342872142792,
0.5115144848823547,
-0.5039186477661133,
0.18263375759124756,
-0.6641125679016113,
0.7560241222381592,
0.9619143009185791,
0.46250906586647034,
0.4226304292678833,
-0.021775977686047554,
0.7226046919822693,
-0.32889389991760254,
0.6011157631874084,
-0.12320854514837265,
-0.45068639516830444,
-0.25790339708328247,
-0.5286906957626343,
0.38377079367637634,
0.6303136944770813,
-0.6117081046104431,
0.4584132730960846,
-0.1318444162607193,
-0.5433229804039001,
-0.22533023357391357,
0.15248438715934753,
0.11484961956739426,
0.13241349160671234,
0.13580486178398132,
0.01290863286703825,
-0.48349204659461975,
-0.775353193283081,
-0.5012408494949341,
-0.29852667450904846,
-0.3129529058933258,
0.05767762288451195,
0.4936630427837372,
-0.5268304944038391,
0.8261540532112122,
-0.5149273872375488,
-0.09974434226751328,
-0.1120990663766861,
-0.17898577451705933,
0.2499943971633911,
0.6489832997322083,
0.7487971186637878,
-0.4008079171180725,
-0.38508525490760803,
-0.14019885659217834,
-0.4229843020439148,
-0.362180233001709,
0.16659295558929443,
-0.06269516795873642,
0.2265990972518921,
0.6689301133155823,
-0.6687402725219727,
-0.04618488997220993,
0.8428786993026733,
-0.12554879486560822,
0.5077723264694214,
0.09863640367984772,
-0.25386884808540344,
-0.9644482135772705,
-0.13545672595500946,
-0.18278007209300995,
-0.18025870621204376,
-0.8948979377746582,
0.4158836007118225,
0.03896670788526535,
-0.2458660751581192,
-0.9521647691726685,
0.4717062711715698,
-0.10932967066764832,
-0.1900169402360916,
-0.14524556696414948,
0.05068214237689972,
-0.03815551474690437,
0.2241290956735611,
-0.43121033906936646,
0.537588894367218,
0.6378540396690369,
-0.3504260182380676,
0.5577569007873535,
-0.0356251522898674,
-0.38260531425476074,
0.5540562272071838,
-0.5334355235099792,
0.3662866950035095,
0.3547991216182709,
0.38464000821113586,
-0.8042333722114563,
-0.3470967710018158,
0.5476583242416382,
-0.4673977792263031,
0.30022820830345154,
-0.44478973746299744,
-0.9435262084007263,
-0.01862436532974243,
-0.4765223264694214,
0.23827935755252838,
0.27952611446380615,
-0.8116114139556885,
0.8421607613563538,
0.4602522850036621,
-0.3423630893230438,
-0.8409959673881531,
-0.9251352548599243,
0.46407416462898254,
-0.5044150352478027,
-0.687134325504303,
-0.02137758769094944,
-0.06727290898561478,
-0.5440651774406433,
-0.041659433394670486,
0.21585363149642944,
-0.008338497951626778,
0.4735015034675598,
0.20298418402671814,
0.526576578617096,
-0.11877375096082687,
-0.29049667716026306,
-0.2813059687614441,
-0.2472524642944336,
0.45894742012023926,
-0.3391433656215668,
0.6384120583534241,
-0.06408071517944336,
-0.926130473613739,
-0.7240960001945496,
0.4913688898086548,
0.7649869322776794,
-0.27578413486480713,
0.5665022134780884,
0.3365512490272522,
-0.3318844139575958,
-0.12189001590013504,
-0.5965420007705688,
-0.04465007781982422,
-0.5866038799285889,
0.6009555459022522,
-0.3404993414878845,
-0.8987080454826355,
0.7019366025924683,
-0.10225098580121994,
0.17789070308208466,
0.1522652804851532,
0.45370423793792725,
-0.13294494152069092,
1.1360849142074585,
0.6017425060272217,
-0.2779445946216583,
0.3358391225337982,
0.09782838821411133,
0.42538169026374817,
-0.6980443596839905,
-0.12913616001605988,
-0.4122041165828705,
-0.023659497499465942,
-0.7723656296730042,
-0.3641144037246704,
-0.08815649896860123,
-0.12248240411281586,
-0.21039380133152008,
0.29850754141807556,
-0.06432543694972992,
0.5108625292778015,
0.18881221115589142,
-0.3748553395271301,
0.22049091756343842,
-0.18932653963565826,
-0.10395943373441696,
0.0525413379073143,
-0.3995734751224518,
-0.6486225724220276,
1.1104378700256348,
0.9138752818107605,
0.9383863210678101,
0.6656046509742737,
0.6683952212333679,
0.2848391532897949,
0.4259881377220154,
-0.8137637376785278,
0.7317515015602112,
0.09957534074783325,
-0.6685843467712402,
-0.06952670961618423,
-0.1970915049314499,
-0.6490570306777954,
0.35507485270500183,
-0.13784168660640717,
-1.0359160900115967,
0.21052317321300507,
-0.14122600853443146,
-0.4105682671070099,
0.6158235669136047,
-0.7656713724136353,
0.5711621046066284,
-0.5269201993942261,
-0.37348857522010803,
0.20340904593467712,
-0.3582717776298523,
0.46221932768821716,
-0.35661566257476807,
0.5691462755203247,
-0.0841403603553772,
-0.2572864890098572,
0.36445456743240356,
-0.40693676471710205,
1.2249635457992554,
-0.28764936327934265,
-0.6655674576759338,
0.2724555432796478,
0.3621959686279297,
0.7062237858772278,
0.4045805335044861,
0.13132447004318237,
0.3474327027797699,
0.07946929335594177,
-0.45736631751060486,
-0.5767578482627869,
1.1449801921844482,
-0.5874863862991333,
-0.8498961925506592,
-0.5066016316413879,
-0.36145973205566406,
-0.41554516553878784,
0.24207831919193268,
-0.11499679088592529,
0.2746872007846832,
-0.2368970662355423,
0.020735906437039375,
0.8084014058113098,
-0.4659164249897003,
0.5443426370620728,
0.6438360214233398,
-0.5948996543884277,
-0.4763733744621277,
0.8362268805503845,
-0.14248627424240112,
0.5049591660499573,
0.18370138108730316,
-0.12788425385951996,
-0.16618923842906952,
-0.8067373037338257,
-0.09308573603630066,
0.11747702956199646,
-0.9421700239181519,
-0.36199891567230225,
-0.6095138192176819,
-0.044545192271471024,
-0.39536166191101074,
-0.07493394613265991,
-0.382695734500885,
-0.06074792146682739,
-0.23736882209777832,
-0.0899544283747673,
0.32927894592285156,
0.681269645690918,
0.07413008064031601,
0.4891131520271301,
-0.954157829284668,
-0.20348352193832397,
0.4148997366428375,
0.45075303316116333,
-0.04927125200629234,
-0.25210556387901306,
0.0162665992975235,
-0.46139535307884216,
-0.010309848003089428,
-0.901007354259491,
0.15574288368225098,
-0.4479563534259796,
0.3749239444732666,
0.43997013568878174,
-0.09488429874181747,
0.31187519431114197,
-0.8496830463409424,
0.957444429397583,
0.30937060713768005,
-0.9862720966339111,
0.25218939781188965,
-0.35427287220954895,
0.052222516387701035,
0.3486703336238861,
0.26611682772636414,
-0.38890430331230164,
-0.5019932985305786,
-0.6305780410766602,
-1.0089654922485352,
0.5204882025718689,
0.01568504422903061,
0.43556997179985046,
0.11894114315509796,
0.2915472984313965,
-0.03686659783124924,
0.12678126990795135,
-0.8880389332771301,
-0.1762571483850479,
0.1795571744441986,
-0.020112814381718636,
0.19969159364700317,
-0.4173184335231781,
-0.505925178527832,
0.25655457377433777,
0.68648761510849,
0.0513632670044899,
-0.17524223029613495,
-0.2804342806339264,
-0.1958255171775818,
-0.038341373205184937,
0.45025789737701416,
0.39930686354637146,
0.5503425002098083,
-0.10221844166517258,
0.18537120521068573,
0.35163265466690063,
-0.2896483540534973,
-0.05493539571762085,
-0.040313348174095154,
0.1339908093214035,
-0.2709749639034271,
0.7312456965446472,
0.3997860848903656,
0.4184609651565552,
-0.9615828990936279,
0.7104763984680176,
-0.25964802503585815,
-0.030544500797986984,
-0.7459856271743774,
0.0076485853642225266,
0.3684530556201935,
0.48414915800094604,
0.26985248923301697,
0.07626567780971527,
-0.07908874750137329,
-0.3393835425376892,
-0.07290744036436081,
0.6501238346099854,
-0.5074049234390259,
-0.4065690040588379,
0.1458226591348648,
0.1425187736749649,
-0.43263381719589233,
-0.11253245919942856,
0.14033636450767517,
-0.5486755967140198,
0.2750563621520996,
0.5520761609077454,
0.8104341626167297,
-0.2743765711784363,
-0.32951802015304565,
-0.1702897548675537,
0.6229386329650879,
0.1519530713558197,
0.046970266848802567,
0.3703247308731079,
-0.5074667930603027,
-0.5012113451957703,
-0.31548476219177246,
-0.5628377795219421,
0.7376531362533569,
-0.31643834710121155,
0.5764428377151489,
-0.7782469987869263,
-0.209010049700737,
-0.18182094395160675,
-0.314680814743042,
-0.1973569691181183,
-0.3541739583015442,
0.44270968437194824,
0.8550974726676941,
-0.6077041029930115,
0.617310106754303,
0.6250520348548889,
-0.19714456796646118,
-0.4886459410190582,
0.19101034104824066,
0.3367087244987488,
-0.5798463821411133,
0.726341962814331,
-0.055404674261808395,
-0.4230080544948578,
-0.3342127799987793,
-0.5492061376571655,
-0.90262371301651,
0.8500590920448303,
0.4580265283584595,
-0.7431994676589966,
0.16032686829566956,
0.38976603746414185,
0.3382326364517212,
-0.39204275608062744,
-0.1513763964176178,
0.5317270159721375,
0.4630546569824219,
-0.20627284049987793,
-0.4316844642162323,
0.0764685645699501,
0.11208954453468323,
0.08223026990890503,
0.06552769988775253,
-0.5013160109519958,
0.7602892518043518,
0.2375936359167099,
-0.2099846750497818,
0.09002739936113358,
0.6616419553756714,
0.3657792806625366,
-0.06986192613840103,
0.5784247517585754,
0.442440003156662,
0.5837879776954651,
0.22794489562511444,
0.8557352423667908,
-0.3318599462509155,
0.19860190153121948,
1.2469898462295532,
-0.5124116539955139,
1.155540108680725,
0.8066139221191406,
-0.1965247243642807,
0.23100529611110687,
0.5759320855140686,
-0.1412840336561203,
0.3703751564025879,
0.509854793548584,
-0.44759154319763184,
0.04362696036696434,
0.23385478556156158,
-0.45595216751098633,
0.3468403220176697,
0.5249200463294983,
-0.0393739677965641,
-0.0007057785987854004,
0.1676226705312729,
0.38335058093070984,
0.1081826463341713,
-0.13824467360973358,
0.6183290481567383,
0.28962355852127075,
-0.02170717902481556,
0.30098995566368103,
0.12983161211013794,
0.7563530802726746,
-0.5779792666435242,
0.19290192425251007,
0.22575774788856506,
0.08684384077787399,
-0.36222296953201294,
-0.6274518370628357,
0.10523775964975357,
0.2115260660648346,
0.17906369268894196,
0.057433269917964935,
0.6649299263954163,
-0.004856731276959181,
-0.3319198191165924,
0.8576016426086426,
0.3745909631252289,
-0.30708372592926025,
0.0793944001197815,
-0.7322466969490051,
0.5870317220687866,
-0.27974846959114075,
-0.3488105535507202,
0.6351248025894165,
0.5132290720939636,
0.21092139184474945,
0.6347323656082153,
0.8033439517021179,
0.31864455342292786,
-0.09045524895191193,
0.2664850950241089,
0.8872289657592773,
-0.21195729076862335,
-0.5636186003684998,
-1.1732865571975708,
0.2884244918823242,
-0.2442231923341751,
0.2491714060306549,
0.7124263048171997,
0.42214512825012207,
0.7317696213722229,
-0.05207006260752678,
0.818718671798706,
0.07717913389205933,
0.42704224586486816,
-0.5463145971298218,
0.9018434882164001,
-0.308779776096344,
1.077117681503296,
-0.3742170035839081,
-0.820188581943512,
-0.5743116736412048,
-0.1429009884595871,
-0.5317878723144531,
-0.25439584255218506,
0.6523032188415527,
0.7926384806632996,
0.00033125371555797756,
0.068825364112854,
0.09875249862670898,
0.3316025733947754,
0.8886133432388306,
0.2045934498310089,
1.2467057704925537,
-0.11540132761001587,
0.6519132852554321,
-0.13870769739151,
-0.36401015520095825,
-0.3431216776371002,
-1.0415897369384766,
-1.0450373888015747,
-0.2676716446876526,
-0.1335693895816803,
-0.5031467080116272,
-0.08263372629880905,
0.8005899786949158,
0.23552769422531128,
-0.9780834913253784,
-0.1198902353644371,
0.20127418637275696,
0.16021788120269775,
0.05023878812789917,
-0.23909345269203186,
0.22512011229991913,
-0.33431705832481384,
-0.6630752682685852,
0.504082202911377,
0.3781983256340027,
-0.04102327302098274,
-0.723811686038971,
0.20626132190227509,
-0.2463076263666153,
0.1744282990694046,
0.5022125840187073,
0.3578640818595886,
-0.819334089756012,
-0.6406272053718567,
-0.25677695870399475,
-0.06693625450134277,
-0.19678139686584473,
0.8271922469139099,
-0.08841348439455032,
0.01591712236404419,
0.23047909140586853,
1.095680832862854,
-0.1274006962776184,
-0.34666967391967773,
0.46794116497039795,
-0.7311945557594299,
0.3192398250102997,
0.2752404808998108,
0.5230007767677307,
0.45099422335624695,
-0.6002011895179749,
0.09872550517320633,
0.038525357842445374,
-0.4801001250743866,
-1.2204288244247437,
0.5465852618217468,
-0.7633607983589172,
-0.4252127408981323,
1.120322585105896,
-0.3353539705276489,
-0.5526089668273926,
-0.21719036996364594,
-0.04930715262889862,
-0.24930411577224731,
-0.2595996558666229,
0.35322076082229614,
0.8022488951683044,
0.09688170254230499,
0.27740901708602905,
-0.9859141707420349,
0.4393746852874756,
0.10700007528066635,
-0.6104284524917603,
0.22919319570064545,
0.3954066038131714,
0.5653703808784485,
0.25247645378112793,
0.2716185748577118,
-0.5894777774810791,
-0.030862100422382355,
-0.3030994236469269,
-0.062313858419656754,
0.03377629444003105,
-0.08437845855951309,
-0.5967181324958801,
0.435943603515625,
0.32534241676330566,
0.020319411531090736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16130v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16130v1
|
From Local to Global: A Graph RAG Approach to Query-Focused Summarization
| 2024-04-24T18:38:11 | 2024-04-24T18:38:11 |
Darren Edge, Ha Trinh, Newman Cheng, Joshua Bradley, Alex Chao, Apurva Mody, Steven Truitt, Jonathan Larson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, H.3.3; I.2.7
|
The use of retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) to retrieve relevant
information from an external knowledge source enables large language models
(LLMs) to answer questions over private and/or previously unseen document
collections. However, RAG fails on global questions directed at an entire text
corpus, such as "What are the main themes in the dataset?", since this is
inherently a query-focused summarization (QFS) task, rather than an explicit
retrieval task. Prior QFS methods, meanwhile, fail to scale to the quantities
of text indexed by typical RAG systems. To combine the strengths of these
contrasting methods, we propose a Graph RAG approach to question answering over
private text corpora that scales with both the generality of user questions and
the quantity of source text to be indexed. Our approach uses an LLM to build a
graph-based text index in two stages: first to derive an entity knowledge graph
from the source documents, then to pregenerate community summaries for all
groups of closely-related entities. Given a question, each community summary is
used to generate a partial response, before all partial responses are again
summarized in a final response to the user. For a class of global sensemaking
questions over datasets in the 1 million token range, we show that Graph RAG
leads to substantial improvements over a na\"ive RAG baseline for both the
comprehensiveness and diversity of generated answers. An open-source,
Python-based implementation of both global and local Graph RAG approaches is
forthcoming at https://aka.ms/graphrag.
|
[
-0.4921734929084778,
-0.8199053406715393,
0.5972156524658203,
-0.03976522386074066,
-0.06534533202648163,
0.4762903153896332,
-0.15360407531261444,
-0.43906551599502563,
0.5835643410682678,
0.6792958378791809,
-0.22671163082122803,
-0.4987848103046417,
-0.4749446213245392,
0.37909141182899475,
-0.3958492875099182,
1.3494462966918945,
-0.108589306473732,
-0.41182661056518555,
-0.48126792907714844,
-0.34882932901382446,
-0.1304551362991333,
-0.6238149404525757,
-0.8710375428199768,
-0.0648600161075592,
0.8678548336029053,
0.47388750314712524,
0.45099109411239624,
0.4364219903945923,
0.5113581418991089,
0.3448714315891266,
-0.44824209809303284,
0.6131445169448853,
-0.8275881409645081,
0.3156037926673889,
-0.10132025927305222,
-0.6046504378318787,
-0.5059928297996521,
-0.03590431436896324,
0.8047476410865784,
0.8412742018699646,
0.15282733738422394,
0.4037814736366272,
0.041062336415052414,
0.7614392638206482,
-0.5589004755020142,
0.017346277832984924,
-0.7008246183395386,
-0.1828935593366623,
-0.1475203037261963,
-0.19583405554294586,
-0.1729203462600708,
-0.4824516475200653,
-0.03723715618252754,
-0.6772831678390503,
0.47639185190200806,
-0.006550249177962542,
0.7092947959899902,
0.1305438131093979,
-0.815048098564148,
-0.3734550178050995,
-0.5915341973304749,
0.42085257172584534,
-0.3544485569000244,
-0.09035205841064453,
0.42638349533081055,
0.41397786140441895,
-0.08040294051170349,
-1.1059050559997559,
-0.22285978496074677,
0.24061641097068787,
-0.45312705636024475,
0.3927472233772278,
-0.2781125009059906,
-0.08514204621315002,
0.11401250213384628,
0.6226288080215454,
-0.6184370517730713,
-0.3777550160884857,
-0.4663199186325073,
-0.2711939215660095,
0.5589277744293213,
0.4488258361816406,
0.15036794543266296,
-0.3719983398914337,
-0.16789916157722473,
0.20713704824447632,
-0.7130597233772278,
0.1853075623512268,
0.34469953179359436,
0.47252726554870605,
-0.07343985885381699,
0.5917341113090515,
-0.3370911180973053,
0.9091800451278687,
-0.009788588620722294,
-0.10428642481565475,
-0.02032512240111828,
-0.568729043006897,
0.0810207724571228,
-0.2592715620994568,
0.5567164421081543,
0.44991058111190796,
0.2497893124818802,
-0.37122783064842224,
0.02058771252632141,
-0.0718063935637474,
0.09931445121765137,
-0.7799407839775085,
0.17562174797058105,
0.28555893898010254,
-0.20555055141448975,
-0.2733112871646881,
-0.09960413724184036,
-0.6781668066978455,
-0.6620326042175293,
-0.30035990476608276,
0.09080616384744644,
0.06049390882253647,
-0.3074016273021698,
-0.3387443423271179,
-0.34280404448509216,
0.16743698716163635,
0.3036615550518036,
-0.5116902589797974,
0.5642966032028198,
0.7720974683761597,
1.019275188446045,
-0.13457417488098145,
0.06492793560028076,
-0.6769063472747803,
0.2791604697704315,
-0.3808212876319885,
1.0824936628341675,
-0.3879068195819855,
-0.5665011405944824,
-0.1660808026790619,
0.14161942899227142,
-0.18021202087402344,
-0.6021465063095093,
0.2718695104122162,
-0.6444858908653259,
0.38202211260795593,
-0.44180431962013245,
-0.45982614159584045,
-0.005573566071689129,
0.4390217959880829,
-0.4433596134185791,
0.9545405507087708,
0.29149624705314636,
-1.3422595262527466,
-0.06770108640193939,
-0.455048143863678,
-0.4612080454826355,
-0.0987059697508812,
-0.17290468513965607,
-0.07284083962440491,
-0.005226914305239916,
0.2844145596027374,
0.23053042590618134,
-0.27062398195266724,
0.20371583104133606,
-0.1637037992477417,
-0.43588390946388245,
-0.0008104541921056807,
0.027347994968295097,
0.7160847187042236,
0.19694654643535614,
0.14954732358455658,
0.27448225021362305,
-0.5305549502372742,
0.021733008325099945,
0.2196165919303894,
-0.22123369574546814,
-0.5393208265304565,
-0.07976874709129333,
-0.3146708309650421,
-0.20627032220363617,
0.3943946659564972,
-0.40308427810668945,
0.21332907676696777,
-0.612975537776947,
0.3788204789161682,
0.6910581588745117,
0.4249640703201294,
0.706394612789154,
-0.40243247151374817,
0.6780515313148499,
-0.4056231379508972,
-0.1578158438205719,
-0.3952113389968872,
-0.6936423182487488,
-0.44706282019615173,
-0.23563377559185028,
0.2949242889881134,
0.6068799495697021,
-0.6084085702896118,
-0.11367224156856537,
-0.3419591188430786,
-0.49332737922668457,
-0.3430092930793762,
-0.005488418508321047,
0.2608782649040222,
0.8450292348861694,
0.14700625836849213,
-0.20427516102790833,
-0.4730505049228668,
-0.6962082982063293,
-0.3453226089477539,
-0.09410297125577927,
-0.32310840487480164,
0.6642643213272095,
0.2727767527103424,
-0.03085709549486637,
1.298570156097412,
-0.8183870315551758,
-0.33535444736480713,
-0.2780088782310486,
0.15077422559261322,
0.3473494350910187,
-0.12557978928089142,
0.2466011792421341,
-1.0110944509506226,
-0.7009274363517761,
0.18513014912605286,
-0.6820545196533203,
-0.11383054405450821,
0.33891260623931885,
-0.22253088653087616,
0.2102927565574646,
0.575153648853302,
-0.43072032928466797,
0.29671016335487366,
0.4787766635417938,
-0.40111058950424194,
0.3529045879840851,
-0.30187711119651794,
0.08849330246448517,
-1.4003431797027588,
0.4106442630290985,
-0.41007545590400696,
-0.3687816858291626,
-0.49106892943382263,
0.3323540985584259,
-0.12612055242061615,
-0.4298557639122009,
-0.03896012902259827,
0.9655081629753113,
-0.5103544592857361,
-0.46849367022514343,
-0.33675000071525574,
0.7429643869400024,
0.2064908742904663,
0.3877114951610565,
-0.3824850916862488,
0.972352147102356,
0.1946810930967331,
-0.5764366388320923,
0.15987151861190796,
0.19240596890449524,
-0.06147845834493637,
0.34817418456077576,
-0.7894498705863953,
0.3421962559223175,
-0.5744852423667908,
0.4449295997619629,
-1.1921420097351074,
-0.3808284103870392,
0.10881965607404709,
-0.6095137000083923,
0.3814675509929657,
-0.3467002213001251,
-0.30308231711387634,
-0.2653975486755371,
-0.2999611794948578,
0.24820463359355927,
0.2653343677520752,
-0.27840447425842285,
0.7609483599662781,
0.8141728043556213,
-0.468446284532547,
-0.6219363808631897,
-0.322599858045578,
0.17485089600086212,
-0.21084599196910858,
-0.9479721188545227,
0.29548224806785583,
-0.16389736533164978,
-0.5185041427612305,
0.18581809103488922,
-0.2655509114265442,
-0.1618567705154419,
0.1784467250108719,
-0.0898636132478714,
0.026765553280711174,
-0.08431806415319443,
-0.007736009079962969,
-0.010410317219793797,
-0.2725820541381836,
-0.11576798558235168,
-0.17179512977600098,
0.424040824174881,
-0.26465266942977905,
0.15048544108867645,
0.4337579905986786,
0.5391468405723572,
0.26497289538383484,
-0.6716163158416748,
0.4672502279281616,
0.4130335748195648,
-0.10270567238330841,
-0.037199731916189194,
-0.15263012051582336,
-0.061918407678604126,
-0.44621190428733826,
0.21379737555980682,
-0.2607206404209137,
-1.2026417255401611,
0.8851370811462402,
-0.3036087155342102,
0.14366459846496582,
0.44560861587524414,
0.5629913806915283,
-0.17147161066532135,
0.9438940286636353,
0.6519075036048889,
-0.061650656163692474,
0.2612718343734741,
-0.5273155570030212,
0.1859886646270752,
-0.9200727343559265,
0.10418219119310379,
-0.7114563584327698,
-0.29003575444221497,
-0.6857298612594604,
-0.6500301361083984,
0.7591629028320312,
0.20641092956066132,
-0.2097628265619278,
0.0037345627788454294,
-0.6423968076705933,
0.5262259840965271,
0.42882585525512695,
-0.1972607523202896,
0.506984293460846,
0.06703947484493256,
0.03799769654870033,
0.10912708193063736,
-0.6917448043823242,
-0.3314116299152374,
1.0079684257507324,
-0.10549769550561905,
0.4728679358959198,
0.06041315943002701,
0.8868266940116882,
-0.023822274059057236,
0.7900634407997131,
-0.5051262378692627,
0.5058869123458862,
-0.24370959401130676,
-0.6729310154914856,
-0.48091644048690796,
-0.736911416053772,
-1.326902151107788,
0.49850207567214966,
0.10577718168497086,
-0.7674906253814697,
-0.04294005408883095,
0.0003563546924851835,
0.029715580865740776,
0.27470433712005615,
-0.6287652850151062,
0.8938305377960205,
0.17360524833202362,
-0.02428499050438404,
0.08365845680236816,
-0.7333694100379944,
0.3471163511276245,
-0.06359376013278961,
0.6689272522926331,
-0.2322092354297638,
-0.27166035771369934,
0.5980821251869202,
-0.3193129897117615,
0.7217041850090027,
-0.1866770088672638,
-0.04777540639042854,
0.7092159390449524,
0.026206117123365402,
0.5846486687660217,
0.15373052656650543,
0.020817594602704048,
-0.0014419096987694502,
-0.15444497764110565,
-0.29471534490585327,
-0.6972866058349609,
0.5873035788536072,
-0.6297950148582458,
-0.7393100261688232,
-0.20215652883052826,
-0.7928257584571838,
-0.3302150070667267,
0.3603414297103882,
0.2935061454772949,
0.6831470727920532,
-0.0821898877620697,
0.07861166447401047,
0.47210225462913513,
-0.14334413409233093,
0.1219712421298027,
0.4899804890155792,
-0.6031792759895325,
-0.6466609835624695,
0.9293400645256042,
0.3120024800300598,
0.23012325167655945,
0.5583330392837524,
0.441602498292923,
-0.21689856052398682,
-0.2345622330904007,
-0.35419854521751404,
0.3989218771457672,
-0.7345021367073059,
-0.36122897267341614,
-0.6461417078971863,
-0.13495400547981262,
-0.5352501273155212,
-0.1471300721168518,
0.11033502221107483,
-0.5678877234458923,
0.02484598010778427,
-0.05136696249246597,
0.518509566783905,
0.7500556707382202,
-0.019861668348312378,
-0.047250133007764816,
-0.6905043721199036,
0.6411939263343811,
0.27167707681655884,
0.28298938274383545,
-0.19236762821674347,
-0.5225824117660522,
-0.22504015266895294,
-0.0696527436375618,
-0.15821830928325653,
-1.0347545146942139,
0.19818419218063354,
0.09467078745365143,
0.42176979780197144,
-0.04554712399840355,
0.31768935918807983,
0.5356646180152893,
-0.5805505514144897,
0.5093321204185486,
-0.21329659223556519,
-0.47721707820892334,
0.49221938848495483,
-0.7262047529220581,
0.4521079659461975,
0.4613768458366394,
0.47140103578567505,
-0.8728375434875488,
-1.11958909034729,
-0.5089250802993774,
-1.1302460432052612,
0.4134173095226288,
0.10589335858821869,
0.23938684165477753,
-0.16182248294353485,
0.5347011089324951,
-0.25365254282951355,
0.06939927488565445,
-0.20914208889007568,
-0.4693479835987091,
0.024365318939089775,
-0.15371409058570862,
-0.2116284817457199,
-0.071409210562706,
-0.2786293029785156,
-0.08809708058834076,
0.3647746443748474,
-0.6010374426841736,
0.25657498836517334,
0.4961380064487457,
0.16694276034832,
-0.071520134806633,
0.1490831822156906,
0.2810817360877991,
0.8851691484451294,
-0.13212518393993378,
0.02869085967540741,
0.12344586104154587,
-0.3888614773750305,
-0.11933738738298416,
0.1830272078514099,
-0.5949862599372864,
0.06815981864929199,
0.24511118233203888,
0.3739924132823944,
0.2173977941274643,
-0.4021497368812561,
0.3818100094795227,
-0.3224550187587738,
-0.15231135487556458,
-0.10434676706790924,
-0.1247568130493164,
0.5086786150932312,
0.06370492279529572,
0.49711915850639343,
-0.15812461078166962,
0.10200247168540955,
-0.4810802936553955,
0.11829131096601486,
0.34907275438308716,
-0.1403675377368927,
-0.07141714543104172,
0.7774134874343872,
0.004785970319062471,
-0.2617223560810089,
0.42113491892814636,
-0.17051957547664642,
-0.4426461160182953,
0.9192246198654175,
0.529404878616333,
0.7412520051002502,
0.17119666934013367,
0.2936128079891205,
0.47449132800102234,
0.2093978226184845,
0.4153587222099304,
0.3518011271953583,
-0.09974659979343414,
-0.5155168771743774,
-0.6600576639175415,
-0.59087735414505,
-0.6296972036361694,
-0.3085049092769623,
-0.5802749991416931,
-0.09454379975795746,
-0.33817344903945923,
-0.12638892233371735,
-0.036398693919181824,
0.26468485593795776,
-0.2859257459640503,
0.07351836562156677,
-0.1796605885028839,
0.8115827441215515,
-0.3621697425842285,
0.4456425905227661,
0.9185603857040405,
-0.4847506582736969,
-0.8013549447059631,
0.050130877643823624,
-0.27416205406188965,
-0.6292787790298462,
0.32556915283203125,
0.060806963592767715,
-0.03912147134542465,
0.09958194941282272,
-0.5068091154098511,
-1.1774067878723145,
1.1563955545425415,
0.3562813401222229,
-0.06447640061378479,
-0.20297735929489136,
-0.08870543539524078,
0.656190037727356,
-0.06522326171398163,
0.09333290904760361,
0.23558814823627472,
0.3847011923789978,
0.1272721141576767,
-0.7050515413284302,
-0.0403926707804203,
-0.16742520034313202,
-0.1865510642528534,
0.5489715337753296,
-0.7941682934761047,
0.9106560945510864,
-0.32686689496040344,
-0.3852073848247528,
0.035600606352090836,
0.722895085811615,
0.16619426012039185,
0.5525542497634888,
0.38100549578666687,
0.39979419112205505,
1.2472741603851318,
-0.0253443643450737,
1.3910647630691528,
-0.5879994034767151,
0.36265137791633606,
1.2790945768356323,
-0.13384364545345306,
0.6848440170288086,
0.12281498312950134,
-0.154761403799057,
0.4477747976779938,
0.5059590935707092,
0.3520134687423706,
0.3041907846927643,
0.2464236170053482,
-0.30343765020370483,
-0.00799553096294403,
-0.21639776229858398,
-0.40005648136138916,
0.19968043267726898,
0.2028702050447464,
0.09919720143079758,
-0.6067424416542053,
-0.2770656943321228,
0.12769156694412231,
0.4201676547527313,
-0.6283589005470276,
0.9096969366073608,
0.2316739708185196,
-0.7268708348274231,
0.36745429039001465,
0.11339245736598969,
0.33495157957077026,
-0.7110822796821594,
0.11901833862066269,
-0.8139249086380005,
0.06479553878307343,
-0.17535282671451569,
-0.746772825717926,
0.7103012204170227,
0.28894445300102234,
-0.4072321653366089,
-0.17289628088474274,
1.0319973230361938,
-0.2953670918941498,
-0.5680667757987976,
0.21993720531463623,
0.578218936920166,
0.28376489877700806,
-0.055451273918151855,
-0.39532241225242615,
-0.37584376335144043,
-0.21566788852214813,
-0.2799178659915924,
0.5120635032653809,
0.6478680372238159,
-0.3587944209575653,
0.5051150321960449,
0.5495477318763733,
-0.05064930394291878,
-0.05198194459080696,
0.13003456592559814,
0.948112964630127,
-0.37387722730636597,
-0.6701763868331909,
-0.3398544192314148,
0.384030818939209,
-0.2351812869310379,
-0.21323667466640472,
0.9649612307548523,
0.6616979241371155,
0.753761351108551,
0.44517967104911804,
0.6477854251861572,
-0.08562478423118591,
0.9721076488494873,
-0.035929400473833084,
0.6819806098937988,
-0.8032945990562439,
-0.11726771295070648,
-0.28507694602012634,
-0.7905852794647217,
-0.2506420612335205,
0.35095372796058655,
-0.41579824686050415,
-0.1523664891719818,
0.5257032513618469,
0.7350754141807556,
0.2949627935886383,
-0.1515982449054718,
0.17932726442813873,
0.32836028933525085,
0.17995163798332214,
0.21266813576221466,
0.6477383375167847,
-0.16526667773723602,
0.9960064888000488,
0.03149668499827385,
-0.15989868342876434,
0.23145681619644165,
-0.6532957553863525,
-0.6742499470710754,
-0.43947717547416687,
0.03461749851703644,
-0.46275806427001953,
-0.057475779205560684,
0.22841323912143707,
0.1789502501487732,
-0.542888343334198,
-0.23083482682704926,
0.017551178112626076,
0.5979946851730347,
0.035085227340459824,
-0.26616764068603516,
0.5220190286636353,
-0.6147328615188599,
-0.6616953611373901,
0.32364749908447266,
0.3125600814819336,
-0.3548418879508972,
-0.1576179563999176,
0.047154899686574936,
0.0003257528005633503,
0.04192713648080826,
0.5364949107170105,
0.30858558416366577,
-0.26085707545280457,
-0.1207694411277771,
0.20224982500076294,
-0.17504775524139404,
0.118751659989357,
1.0325548648834229,
-0.7591843008995056,
0.38044506311416626,
0.6011130213737488,
0.6544550657272339,
0.8907470703125,
0.20899806916713715,
0.4514128565788269,
-1.0299819707870483,
0.06385859847068787,
0.24148474633693695,
0.13476747274398804,
0.3548109829425812,
-0.2992604672908783,
0.8098762035369873,
0.31928908824920654,
-0.7226330637931824,
-0.7783878445625305,
0.27387744188308716,
-0.6363990306854248,
-0.4318983852863312,
1.0331830978393555,
-0.15305712819099426,
-0.42146530747413635,
-0.2406204491853714,
-0.4287972152233124,
0.15338531136512756,
0.0003021686861757189,
0.41951823234558105,
0.37295448780059814,
0.011593597009778023,
0.20661619305610657,
-0.4851762056350708,
0.3208606243133545,
-0.09489601105451584,
-0.8492910861968994,
0.359414279460907,
0.5184029340744019,
0.3640315532684326,
0.30851083993911743,
1.409989356994629,
-0.10448677837848663,
0.06083095073699951,
-0.027639590203762054,
-0.29875820875167847,
0.035833947360515594,
-0.3249005973339081,
-0.07073675841093063,
0.5240921974182129,
-0.11626601219177246,
0.3275156021118164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16123v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16123v1
|
FairDeDup: Detecting and Mitigating Vision-Language Fairness Disparities in Semantic Dataset Deduplication
| 2024-04-24T18:28:17 | 2024-04-24T18:28:17 |
Eric Slyman, Stefan Lee, Scott Cohen, Kushal Kafle
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.4.10; I.2.7; E.0
|
Recent dataset deduplication techniques have demonstrated that content-aware
dataset pruning can dramatically reduce the cost of training Vision-Language
Pretrained (VLP) models without significant performance losses compared to
training on the original dataset. These results have been based on pruning
commonly used image-caption datasets collected from the web -- datasets that
are known to harbor harmful social biases that may then be codified in trained
models. In this work, we evaluate how deduplication affects the prevalence of
these biases in the resulting trained models and introduce an easy-to-implement
modification to the recent SemDeDup algorithm that can reduce the negative
effects that we observe. When examining CLIP-style models trained on
deduplicated variants of LAION-400M, we find our proposed FairDeDup algorithm
consistently leads to improved fairness metrics over SemDeDup on the FairFace
and FACET datasets while maintaining zero-shot performance on CLIP benchmarks.
|
[
-0.44859030842781067,
-0.5259392261505127,
0.3512200713157654,
0.07060109823942184,
-0.3893339931964874,
-0.3531309962272644,
0.1235714852809906,
-0.40515637397766113,
0.007898608222603798,
0.8420391082763672,
-0.5608083605766296,
-0.39820608496665955,
-0.8130877614021301,
0.00836140476167202,
-0.4500018358230591,
0.7922574877738953,
0.18521107733249664,
0.37145891785621643,
-0.3727794885635376,
-0.43156179785728455,
-0.7301692962646484,
-0.402185320854187,
-0.45677924156188965,
-0.09770286083221436,
0.04184510186314583,
0.5084131956100464,
0.7882598638534546,
0.6857653856277466,
0.7560304403305054,
0.27914732694625854,
-0.047177474945783615,
-0.18996961414813995,
-0.572910726070404,
-0.3462164103984833,
-0.25872159004211426,
-0.5876197814941406,
-0.507681131362915,
0.24618937075138092,
0.6077966094017029,
0.9587135910987854,
-0.27490901947021484,
0.19916094839572906,
0.033081505447626114,
1.012992024421692,
-0.8668409585952759,
0.04414103925228119,
-0.8783173561096191,
0.33006030321121216,
-0.43913739919662476,
-0.23779112100601196,
-0.20434452593326569,
-0.4224783778190613,
-0.11116217821836472,
-0.7328090667724609,
0.5428450703620911,
-0.2210162878036499,
0.7637621760368347,
0.6033732295036316,
-0.23216427862644196,
0.0705409124493599,
-0.21413831412792206,
1.0890299081802368,
-0.6746264696121216,
0.13033434748649597,
0.13055811822414398,
0.4102480113506317,
-0.01831659860908985,
-0.5866724252700806,
-0.8518680930137634,
0.2199813723564148,
0.05870124697685242,
0.163263201713562,
-0.3670819103717804,
0.12567614018917084,
0.5281178951263428,
0.4329337477684021,
-0.46840453147888184,
0.12158510088920593,
-0.5004211664199829,
-0.20954163372516632,
0.5890936851501465,
-0.10104243457317352,
0.3828139305114746,
-0.3451990485191345,
-0.34184136986732483,
-0.2144881933927536,
-1.044022560119629,
-0.14540433883666992,
0.5931687355041504,
0.10857412964105606,
0.12457387149333954,
0.6144726276397705,
-0.6538361310958862,
0.7565191984176636,
-0.07855140417814255,
0.15918371081352234,
0.7050555944442749,
-0.09773701429367065,
-0.33833447098731995,
0.06474865227937698,
0.13539846241474152,
1.18673574924469,
0.6440074443817139,
0.11852864921092987,
-0.28788816928863525,
0.3609955310821533,
-0.05075104534626007,
-0.8001353740692139,
-0.1746768057346344,
-0.1456945687532425,
-0.7514798641204834,
-0.4678574800491333,
0.10125473886728287,
-0.6594007611274719,
-0.49849650263786316,
-0.6475103497505188,
0.5473227500915527,
0.04680466279387474,
-0.3125385642051697,
0.41235655546188354,
-0.3483733832836151,
0.2774342894554138,
0.5550608038902283,
-0.17446443438529968,
0.30629757046699524,
0.6462418437004089,
0.6155877113342285,
-0.3087683320045471,
-0.3448132574558258,
-0.9126126766204834,
0.03965328633785248,
-0.16717685759067535,
0.5556671023368835,
-0.43490540981292725,
0.05766814202070236,
-0.09863942116498947,
0.1383053958415985,
0.11383967846632004,
-0.9534931778907776,
0.4707919955253601,
-0.32928112149238586,
0.2663598954677582,
-0.5087659955024719,
-0.5371994376182556,
-0.25195565819740295,
0.3090398609638214,
-0.95814049243927,
0.505573570728302,
-0.012862088158726692,
-1.1134651899337769,
0.9204050302505493,
-0.4174889922142029,
-0.5404365062713623,
0.10242480039596558,
-0.35990241169929504,
-0.479116290807724,
0.19363418221473694,
0.4479479193687439,
0.4348132312297821,
-0.029735179618000984,
0.4648456871509552,
-0.5101823210716248,
-0.657291054725647,
-0.1162852793931961,
-0.5492497682571411,
1.136136770248413,
0.3087078332901001,
-0.4998348653316498,
-0.15964752435684204,
-0.6638814806938171,
-0.311571329832077,
0.28386473655700684,
0.04807329550385475,
-0.5915793180465698,
0.11542890965938568,
-0.02615462802350521,
0.3061606287956238,
-0.1093759834766388,
-0.5746238827705383,
-0.2057398557662964,
-0.37075719237327576,
0.19113348424434662,
1.0801260471343994,
-0.3167632818222046,
0.5899257659912109,
-0.45403075218200684,
0.2264953851699829,
0.5201765894889832,
0.6146413087844849,
0.19049450755119324,
-0.2825709283351898,
-0.8043965101242065,
-0.4399471580982208,
0.2525976002216339,
0.5966295599937439,
-1.0135325193405151,
0.12235841155052185,
-0.40107402205467224,
0.15050730109214783,
-0.5872002840042114,
0.07838557660579681,
0.2117459625005722,
0.7947651743888855,
0.21819891035556793,
-0.7639806866645813,
-0.28772038221359253,
-1.07040536403656,
-0.2827672064304352,
0.43345722556114197,
0.07593619078397751,
0.3527528941631317,
0.26431941986083984,
-0.23855723440647125,
1.0812115669250488,
-0.5218170881271362,
-0.5189126133918762,
-0.0647677406668663,
-0.23539018630981445,
0.041158851236104965,
0.643612265586853,
0.9476284384727478,
-1.1947078704833984,
-0.2812943756580353,
-0.5931380391120911,
-0.6022642254829407,
-0.5109085440635681,
0.2607693672180176,
0.05488307401537895,
0.3088906407356262,
0.45654934644699097,
-0.38327929377555847,
0.9182810187339783,
0.3674831688404083,
-0.3178475499153137,
0.1861022263765335,
-0.027362022548913956,
0.5225728154182434,
-0.6029092073440552,
-0.013317483477294445,
-0.3793689012527466,
-0.3929681181907654,
-0.2130197435617447,
-0.08770449459552765,
-0.16826605796813965,
-0.14820496737957,
-0.7590251564979553,
0.4539503753185272,
-0.1618226319551468,
-0.31851068139076233,
-0.3116742968559265,
0.2660766839981079,
0.05952475219964981,
0.279293030500412,
0.05548117309808731,
0.5034453868865967,
0.5379986763000488,
-0.6701319217681885,
0.08642618358135223,
0.19506622850894928,
-0.30057811737060547,
0.9420426487922668,
-0.6182301640510559,
-0.18750795722007751,
-0.5878074765205383,
0.07690306752920151,
-0.5961409211158752,
0.04399937391281128,
0.2482324093580246,
-0.34791281819343567,
-0.043216340243816376,
-0.3726913630962372,
-0.29442957043647766,
-0.0940961167216301,
-0.6058508157730103,
0.6665893197059631,
0.40891996026039124,
-0.895251989364624,
0.172091543674469,
0.6918023228645325,
-0.2173760086297989,
-0.8755995631217957,
-0.7592235803604126,
-0.05646475777029991,
-0.36212286353111267,
-0.7656612396240234,
0.589228093624115,
-0.02417812868952751,
-0.48202526569366455,
0.05477634444832802,
-0.15153680741786957,
-0.0037580395583063364,
0.2852790355682373,
0.23195403814315796,
0.1679547280073166,
0.27855756878852844,
0.02788487821817398,
0.1812744140625,
-0.15122820436954498,
-0.2699809968471527,
0.04558863118290901,
0.649728000164032,
-0.08112135529518127,
-0.4797976016998291,
-0.3137742280960083,
0.32779690623283386,
0.14803621172904968,
-0.23810268938541412,
0.41447439789772034,
0.4789830446243286,
-0.4853271245956421,
-0.3210347592830658,
-0.5956647992134094,
-0.21207857131958008,
-0.4545387923717499,
0.23736147582530975,
-0.23018662631511688,
-0.7881588339805603,
0.45036980509757996,
0.11203176528215408,
0.020372161641716957,
0.3553342819213867,
0.13910651206970215,
-0.009250320494174957,
0.8644524216651917,
0.7189768552780151,
0.03108670376241207,
0.697234570980072,
-0.09479179233312607,
0.011584244668483734,
-0.18093755841255188,
0.03622419759631157,
-0.26003673672676086,
-0.37237250804901123,
-0.7872698903083801,
-0.5360209345817566,
-0.08982659131288528,
0.1674100160598755,
0.021363791078329086,
-0.06114455312490463,
-0.5739692449569702,
0.7872355580329895,
0.7208601236343384,
0.19671212136745453,
0.4815610647201538,
0.24174253642559052,
0.43272900581359863,
-0.20506107807159424,
-0.7732114791870117,
-0.31918787956237793,
1.1628347635269165,
0.0790233388543129,
0.7446364760398865,
0.007686797063797712,
0.7965362071990967,
0.7092742919921875,
0.06445058435201645,
-0.565584659576416,
0.555787980556488,
-0.6222766637802124,
-0.4240538775920868,
-0.044966019690036774,
-0.7649626731872559,
-0.6198386549949646,
0.09111662209033966,
-0.016718650236725807,
-0.22789885103702545,
0.5133464336395264,
0.3966318666934967,
0.07171918451786041,
0.1374172419309616,
-0.741301417350769,
0.9485498070716858,
0.0739499032497406,
-0.31990543007850647,
-0.5525861978530884,
-0.5066898465156555,
0.2679494619369507,
0.08577315509319305,
0.3511660397052765,
-0.4047086536884308,
0.36740660667419434,
0.8381086587905884,
-0.5665431022644043,
0.5690470933914185,
-0.7753528356552124,
0.21248865127563477,
0.2898142635822296,
0.044066816568374634,
0.1760087013244629,
-0.008172496221959591,
0.2503243088722229,
0.46654659509658813,
0.11473782360553741,
-0.5427006483078003,
-0.1775330752134323,
0.5931331515312195,
-0.3899851143360138,
-0.4159488379955292,
-0.3695615828037262,
-0.3653216063976288,
0.09378840029239655,
0.19299569725990295,
0.2675829529762268,
0.49372828006744385,
-0.15233871340751648,
0.22034643590450287,
0.6686596274375916,
-0.6307898163795471,
0.35846951603889465,
0.47790971398353577,
-0.03351181000471115,
-0.2954578697681427,
0.7937055230140686,
0.16602446138858795,
0.27502962946891785,
0.05040736123919487,
-0.02637983299791813,
0.055156394839286804,
-0.5231199860572815,
-0.16974766552448273,
-0.1825503706932068,
-0.8766258358955383,
-0.3964901566505432,
-0.3725055456161499,
0.0528256855905056,
-0.46179860830307007,
-0.15502795577049255,
-0.47445493936538696,
-0.8251048922538757,
0.06342597305774689,
-0.09243807941675186,
0.17403580248355865,
0.3602336645126343,
-0.5146797299385071,
0.4205997884273529,
-0.447049081325531,
0.5755651593208313,
0.27704375982284546,
0.6076229214668274,
-0.08384333550930023,
-0.3885855972766876,
0.27424004673957825,
0.1994807869195938,
-0.015090115368366241,
-0.45253685116767883,
0.3153151273727417,
0.1244896948337555,
0.6607530117034912,
0.25287580490112305,
0.19925802946090698,
0.529869019985199,
-0.590516209602356,
0.4308602213859558,
0.3713184893131256,
-1.0245065689086914,
0.5783891081809998,
-0.06320702284574509,
0.14829318225383759,
0.787138819694519,
-0.03471917659044266,
-0.35699933767318726,
-0.3245615065097809,
-0.40895015001296997,
-0.8970935344696045,
0.9034406542778015,
0.28915050625801086,
0.08979611843824387,
-0.10524937510490417,
0.16484332084655762,
0.24619899690151215,
0.37041351199150085,
-0.8222768306732178,
-0.04897062107920647,
-0.5347177982330322,
-0.5496060252189636,
0.237110435962677,
-0.17726172506809235,
-0.3408120572566986,
-0.232695072889328,
0.42576929926872253,
-0.07913587242364883,
-0.030805736780166626,
0.17683488130569458,
-0.7766151428222656,
0.2360832244157791,
0.23735925555229187,
0.365275502204895,
0.6696873307228088,
-0.2607916295528412,
0.06006229296326637,
-0.05926790460944176,
-0.719699501991272,
-0.21831101179122925,
0.44097334146499634,
-0.6480686068534851,
-0.011755009181797504,
-0.07026328146457672,
0.6050146818161011,
-0.16731314361095428,
-0.89250248670578,
1.2132360935211182,
-0.2550818920135498,
-0.10323658585548401,
-0.13360469043254852,
-0.00016823862097226083,
-0.5084851980209351,
0.18373869359493256,
0.19841733574867249,
0.13632436096668243,
0.5500808954238892,
-0.2671639025211334,
0.5388217568397522,
0.4967595636844635,
-0.3887941241264343,
0.09634152799844742,
0.4537758231163025,
0.4902404248714447,
0.0320001095533371,
0.6706302762031555,
-0.1214912161231041,
-0.6358439326286316,
0.8252593278884888,
0.030216984450817108,
0.5530334711074829,
0.17678222060203552,
0.2563357651233673,
0.09704010933637619,
0.37827321887016296,
-0.18270635604858398,
0.22570094466209412,
-0.17655949294567108,
-0.8644733428955078,
-0.35817480087280273,
-0.5319986343383789,
0.04037884250283241,
-0.08211816102266312,
-0.7730630040168762,
0.31634947657585144,
-0.3321252465248108,
-0.13414372503757477,
-0.13952383399009705,
-0.1321067363023758,
-1.1048862934112549,
0.4346558451652527,
0.28239360451698303,
0.708480715751648,
-0.8742243647575378,
0.5385786890983582,
0.19192597270011902,
-0.4614853262901306,
-0.3889283537864685,
-0.1450117528438568,
0.0015548215014860034,
-0.7389844655990601,
0.7645146250724792,
0.5683369636535645,
-0.0839039534330368,
-0.08040156215429306,
-0.5908830165863037,
-0.2963272035121918,
1.0197898149490356,
0.6069194078445435,
-0.8203252553939819,
0.23449380695819855,
0.3850867748260498,
-0.06957154721021652,
-0.07283225655555725,
-0.15024039149284363,
0.5940631628036499,
0.14301273226737976,
-0.13989049196243286,
-0.9989612102508545,
0.014382780529558659,
-0.1281002014875412,
-0.14271456003189087,
0.03742183744907379,
-0.45569363236427307,
0.9521207809448242,
-0.16015729308128357,
-0.27396032214164734,
-0.25298041105270386,
-0.01928260363638401,
0.1755894273519516,
0.6082173585891724,
0.7689745426177979,
0.8745408058166504,
0.67162024974823,
-0.2468644082546234,
0.7535666823387146,
0.16601437330245972,
0.37668484449386597,
1.1656657457351685,
-0.5230549573898315,
0.4183862507343292,
0.751309871673584,
0.09838008135557175,
-0.038462020456790924,
0.3303869366645813,
-0.16142436861991882,
0.8913930058479309,
0.1541237235069275,
-0.04982995241880417,
-0.2703581750392914,
-0.15901212394237518,
-0.40205907821655273,
0.5830530524253845,
-0.14076504111289978,
-0.24242432415485382,
-0.2982518672943115,
0.2589128911495209,
-0.08202070742845535,
0.295911580324173,
-0.6689803600311279,
0.742747962474823,
0.047918468713760376,
-0.37766942381858826,
0.2726621627807617,
-0.05801044777035713,
1.0876275300979614,
-0.04076230525970459,
-0.21219174563884735,
-0.5086109638214111,
0.477283239364624,
-0.20665407180786133,
-0.7693630456924438,
0.4490899443626404,
-0.08703545480966568,
-0.2634168267250061,
-0.24786801636219025,
0.9366452693939209,
-0.2813604772090912,
-0.29787954688072205,
0.33803221583366394,
0.45695415139198303,
-0.061747223138809204,
-0.34258508682250977,
-0.8092594146728516,
0.11490096151828766,
0.031526118516922,
0.015367629006505013,
0.06847041845321655,
0.2202627807855606,
-0.14516694843769073,
0.5276512503623962,
0.28753411769866943,
0.008981123566627502,
0.11393805593252182,
0.5980482697486877,
0.8106915950775146,
-0.6062660217285156,
-0.4290792644023895,
-0.701641857624054,
0.4607445299625397,
-0.4865783154964447,
0.11087925732135773,
0.4573255181312561,
0.6278349161148071,
1.2039597034454346,
-0.21158869564533234,
0.6034787893295288,
-0.2392989546060562,
0.6285339593887329,
-0.5532689690589905,
0.968603253364563,
-0.6930752992630005,
0.3287909924983978,
-0.4890868067741394,
-0.797532320022583,
-0.26193028688430786,
0.7363177537918091,
-0.3205898106098175,
-0.1102384477853775,
0.1282574087381363,
0.8610149621963501,
-0.19292694330215454,
-0.23062369227409363,
0.195287823677063,
-0.21339260041713715,
0.2752127945423126,
0.5484208464622498,
0.7057682275772095,
-0.49527376890182495,
0.4669720530509949,
-0.3519580364227295,
-0.45403191447257996,
-0.13350017368793488,
-0.9619448184967041,
-0.7610554695129395,
-0.21503838896751404,
-0.5004733800888062,
-0.10739023983478546,
0.2392638772726059,
0.32739683985710144,
0.5423009395599365,
-0.7072757482528687,
0.13883209228515625,
-0.2565581202507019,
0.3253978192806244,
0.04495702311396599,
-0.297822505235672,
0.2607179582118988,
-0.043382976204156876,
-0.642279326915741,
-0.28282347321510315,
0.1874435395002365,
0.09813834726810455,
0.14614911377429962,
0.002100714948028326,
0.17070643603801727,
-0.03496070206165314,
0.6352812647819519,
-0.08508597314357758,
-0.4293314516544342,
-0.2728445827960968,
-0.23525451123714447,
-0.008948096074163914,
0.03952307999134064,
0.6341037750244141,
-0.9848142862319946,
0.5179338455200195,
0.5547947883605957,
0.5586732029914856,
0.37550851702690125,
0.03485514968633652,
0.6387348771095276,
-0.8147812485694885,
0.7011275291442871,
0.33382585644721985,
0.3863697350025177,
0.6205478310585022,
-0.031838446855545044,
0.5542130470275879,
0.6551044583320618,
-0.20000320672988892,
-1.0455007553100586,
0.26251915097236633,
-1.0456297397613525,
-0.465617299079895,
0.9234740138053894,
0.11386063694953918,
-0.09326662868261337,
0.20200590789318085,
-0.23559574782848358,
0.1996530294418335,
-0.07011863589286804,
0.9208013415336609,
0.5049051642417908,
0.4355891942977905,
-0.026002220809459686,
-0.5782378315925598,
0.7637619376182556,
0.5349401235580444,
-0.8416227102279663,
0.1983463019132614,
0.9261701703071594,
0.6212524771690369,
-0.3764635920524597,
0.7609519958496094,
-0.42063701152801514,
0.66508549451828,
-0.11790917813777924,
0.08445846289396286,
-0.07473688572645187,
-0.19446782767772675,
-0.3926801383495331,
-0.12934330105781555,
-0.15862059593200684,
-0.37718361616134644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05136v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05136v1
|
Integrating LSTM and BERT for Long-Sequence Data Analysis in Intelligent Tutoring Systems
| 2024-04-24T18:19:44 | 2024-04-24T18:19:44 |
Zhaoxing Li, Jujie Yang, Jindi Wang, Lei Shi, Sebastian Stein
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The field of Knowledge Tracing aims to understand how students learn and
master knowledge over time by analyzing their historical behaviour data. To
achieve this goal, many researchers have proposed Knowledge Tracing models that
use data from Intelligent Tutoring Systems to predict students' subsequent
actions. However, with the development of Intelligent Tutoring Systems,
large-scale datasets containing long-sequence data began to emerge. Recent deep
learning based Knowledge Tracing models face obstacles such as low efficiency,
low accuracy, and low interpretability when dealing with large-scale datasets
containing long-sequence data. To address these issues and promote the
sustainable development of Intelligent Tutoring Systems, we propose a LSTM
BERT-based Knowledge Tracing model for long sequence data processing, namely
LBKT, which uses a BERT-based architecture with a Rasch model-based embeddings
block to deal with different difficulty levels information and an LSTM block to
process the sequential characteristic in students' actions. LBKT achieves the
best performance on most benchmark datasets on the metrics of ACC and AUC.
Additionally, an ablation study is conducted to analyse the impact of each
component of LBKT's overall performance. Moreover, we used t-SNE as the
visualisation tool to demonstrate the model's embedding strategy. The results
indicate that LBKT is faster, more interpretable, and has a lower memory cost
than the traditional deep learning based Knowledge Tracing methods.
|
[
-0.2590906322002411,
-0.8691694736480713,
0.46675142645835876,
0.002261766232550144,
-0.3182181417942047,
0.22984935343265533,
-0.3498894274234772,
-0.6346519589424133,
0.025004876777529716,
0.5489598512649536,
-0.5362599492073059,
-0.49817702174186707,
-0.1938159167766571,
-0.1893172562122345,
-0.4657168388366699,
0.9179171919822693,
0.13581925630569458,
0.1819317638874054,
-0.2903611958026886,
0.07733998447656631,
-0.7379822134971619,
-0.3713747560977936,
-0.6005552411079407,
-0.2634425461292267,
0.6784486770629883,
0.4883859157562256,
0.314794659614563,
0.5384807586669922,
0.22368140518665314,
0.24044638872146606,
-0.1301162987947464,
0.1842656433582306,
-0.3345552980899811,
0.3892732858657837,
-0.2724757194519043,
-0.26936814188957214,
-0.4529328942298889,
-0.5119637846946716,
0.7732686996459961,
0.40479081869125366,
0.155831441283226,
0.057802651077508926,
0.27747347950935364,
0.8894811868667603,
-0.08063536137342453,
0.3151792287826538,
0.004735216032713652,
0.11809078603982925,
-0.03868429362773895,
0.07834068685770035,
-0.43425804376602173,
-0.7088932394981384,
0.6693159341812134,
-0.08415516465902328,
0.12945273518562317,
-0.04679841175675392,
0.24779868125915527,
0.14250482618808746,
-0.3104824721813202,
-0.5396549105644226,
-0.5917665362358093,
0.875147819519043,
-1.026205062866211,
0.3852714002132416,
0.11034603416919708,
0.5064439177513123,
-0.09169909358024597,
-0.5362942814826965,
-0.21105654537677765,
-0.018985258415341377,
-0.0036923044826835394,
0.12105006724596024,
0.33329638838768005,
0.10267595201730728,
0.1678256392478943,
-0.022539881989359856,
-0.48266685009002686,
0.5322290658950806,
-0.5923612713813782,
-0.1548660844564438,
0.6066282987594604,
0.09765864163637161,
-0.2577883005142212,
-0.2918855547904968,
-0.6601930260658264,
0.14450703561306,
-0.4315047562122345,
0.2014385312795639,
0.26634663343429565,
0.7438664436340332,
0.054128579795360565,
0.44255930185317993,
0.0997357964515686,
0.7557717561721802,
-0.21975138783454895,
-0.1612510234117508,
-0.26463863253593445,
-0.032936207950115204,
-0.03605222702026367,
0.5594361424446106,
0.4652223289012909,
0.143423393368721,
0.488350510597229,
-0.04889318719506264,
-0.23532536625862122,
-0.38933390378952026,
0.09913519024848938,
-1.020681381225586,
-0.29012131690979004,
0.09732559323310852,
-0.37162545323371887,
-0.05043814703822136,
-0.1619621366262436,
-0.9433636665344238,
-0.5556222796440125,
-0.523095428943634,
0.47211965918540955,
-0.8719026446342468,
-0.017155470326542854,
-0.020628122612833977,
0.43110471963882446,
0.28288620710372925,
0.4760507047176361,
-0.6049647927284241,
0.11242885887622833,
0.8396469354629517,
0.8656603693962097,
-0.3247765302658081,
0.12942463159561157,
-0.09090011566877365,
0.10881513357162476,
0.008202051743865013,
0.5037150382995605,
-0.2779262065887451,
-0.20995189249515533,
0.23954010009765625,
-0.11245536804199219,
0.03807907924056053,
-0.10161273926496506,
0.2585449516773224,
-0.6946803331375122,
0.0480254627764225,
-0.34351783990859985,
-1.3588221073150635,
-0.6663910746574402,
0.20206159353256226,
-0.482678085565567,
1.0375652313232422,
-0.09217227250337601,
-0.5390454530715942,
0.10042224824428558,
-0.7047169208526611,
-0.47098565101623535,
0.07068759948015213,
-0.06384871900081635,
-0.6937486529350281,
-0.21387115120887756,
0.09093496948480606,
0.9185624718666077,
-0.19969776272773743,
0.6172835230827332,
-0.18555787205696106,
-0.5470970273017883,
0.05225210264325142,
-0.2870958149433136,
0.6580653786659241,
0.16695520281791687,
-0.33968880772590637,
-0.0813746228814125,
-0.7261538505554199,
0.0536007396876812,
-0.05531053617596626,
-0.2942923605442047,
-0.4443166255950928,
0.28878554701805115,
-0.31696945428848267,
0.09165622293949127,
0.3737981617450714,
-0.5593630075454712,
0.47194015979766846,
-0.009185750968754292,
0.32008329033851624,
1.1806577444076538,
-0.1317824274301529,
0.05365696921944618,
-0.18687711656093597,
0.2636876702308655,
0.05247197300195694,
-0.14662986993789673,
-0.4591238498687744,
-0.5683022141456604,
-0.7414928078651428,
-0.1590299755334854,
0.42817720770835876,
0.45865362882614136,
-0.5422458052635193,
0.5987306237220764,
-0.33789777755737305,
-0.3045182228088379,
-0.35982245206832886,
0.13176506757736206,
0.11153624951839447,
0.7781124711036682,
0.3585526645183563,
-0.2620960474014282,
-0.524439811706543,
-0.6128534078598022,
0.028070000931620598,
-0.004600042011588812,
0.19287528097629547,
0.29311731457710266,
0.39638763666152954,
-0.00798052828758955,
1.0981264114379883,
-0.30176565051078796,
-0.24219195544719696,
-0.3481299579143524,
0.12997201085090637,
0.43498846888542175,
0.7160640954971313,
0.5242385268211365,
-0.2756091356277466,
-0.5128141045570374,
-0.1784839630126953,
-0.5911914110183716,
0.16691552102565765,
-0.2873266041278839,
-0.24936255812644958,
0.406491756439209,
0.3585805296897888,
-0.3442595899105072,
0.6947444677352905,
0.044334638863801956,
-0.5030855536460876,
0.5189651846885681,
-0.12183883786201477,
-0.07479490339756012,
-0.9122140407562256,
0.03636256977915764,
-0.10936939716339111,
-0.2448480874300003,
-0.4574199616909027,
-0.25813207030296326,
0.2527700662612915,
-0.10770202428102493,
-0.23782692849636078,
0.42069700360298157,
-0.09299259632825851,
-0.39318543672561646,
0.018050633370876312,
0.03437398746609688,
-0.11620866507291794,
0.6057347059249878,
-0.048217419534921646,
0.40460404753685,
0.45776650309562683,
-0.5192842483520508,
0.5585856437683105,
0.08845416456460953,
-0.5205267071723938,
0.5238332748413086,
-0.4183100759983063,
0.24385966360569,
0.05497877299785614,
0.1659735143184662,
-1.0535718202590942,
0.2830296456813812,
0.029950937256217003,
-0.3309676945209503,
0.34085994958877563,
-0.28131768107414246,
-0.6855350136756897,
-0.5317575931549072,
-0.23084388673305511,
0.37427622079849243,
0.6895222067832947,
-0.6394251585006714,
0.7430785298347473,
-0.537566602230072,
-0.41806840896606445,
-0.6728391647338867,
-0.49257493019104004,
-0.23075564205646515,
-0.23074311017990112,
-0.7522086501121521,
0.011127404868602753,
-0.14452460408210754,
0.3159153163433075,
-0.025060247629880905,
-0.09068814665079117,
0.059891071170568466,
0.022135622799396515,
0.07977040112018585,
0.37861886620521545,
-0.5355976223945618,
0.3530123233795166,
0.07318747043609619,
-0.01495911180973053,
0.23628677427768707,
-0.502345085144043,
0.5191479921340942,
0.08793211728334427,
-0.49884033203125,
-0.5538508892059326,
0.177772656083107,
0.6321492195129395,
-0.06097841262817383,
0.6948336958885193,
0.6753358840942383,
-0.1852535903453827,
-0.53117436170578,
-0.6989732384681702,
-0.19476547837257385,
-0.46751296520233154,
0.46828338503837585,
0.27919802069664,
-0.6478193998336792,
0.7774214148521423,
-0.09775051474571228,
0.4085308611392975,
0.11215171962976456,
0.21229282021522522,
-0.5905121564865112,
0.6407747864723206,
0.6369779109954834,
-0.5155395865440369,
0.6400274634361267,
-0.46510446071624756,
0.21728989481925964,
-0.45940813422203064,
-0.2448020577430725,
-0.18066824972629547,
-0.7990493774414062,
-0.2677844762802124,
-0.2184956818819046,
0.11759694665670395,
-0.03148312494158745,
-0.7048506140708923,
-0.11230415105819702,
-0.4017278552055359,
0.3018934726715088,
0.7247375845909119,
0.3503997325897217,
0.12327243387699127,
0.010738195851445198,
-0.20514991879463196,
-0.012435905635356903,
-0.731299877166748,
-0.04785509034991264,
1.196613073348999,
0.49891549348831177,
0.7784958481788635,
0.009507573209702969,
0.7724437117576599,
0.5127082467079163,
0.2305215746164322,
-0.9665617346763611,
0.7961990833282471,
-0.32935720682144165,
-0.3521300256252289,
-0.4277454912662506,
-0.20571865141391754,
-0.7532715201377869,
-0.1988501399755478,
0.07780636101961136,
-0.6150023341178894,
-0.16679935157299042,
0.1262992024421692,
-0.5573599934577942,
0.7883567810058594,
-0.5303736329078674,
0.49849531054496765,
-0.5968897938728333,
-0.5693450570106506,
-0.30394247174263,
-0.850054144859314,
0.28329595923423767,
-0.18838845193386078,
0.061574555933475494,
0.13245093822479248,
0.5224112272262573,
1.1077282428741455,
-0.418449729681015,
1.1706900596618652,
-0.6106347441673279,
-0.30653318762779236,
0.40564659237861633,
0.12044322490692139,
0.711195707321167,
-0.341469943523407,
-0.1591564565896988,
-0.18159440159797668,
-0.22772791981697083,
-0.36822476983070374,
-0.4215865135192871,
0.6713682413101196,
-0.5275084376335144,
-0.38795673847198486,
-0.33856818079948425,
-0.7249346971511841,
-0.1787012368440628,
0.16881585121154785,
-0.47524628043174744,
0.35576897859573364,
0.2496887594461441,
0.2643119990825653,
0.839539647102356,
-0.39757996797561646,
0.6529790163040161,
0.726553201675415,
-0.3420966565608978,
-0.16752223670482635,
1.035327672958374,
0.44650450348854065,
0.22310897707939148,
0.04259311780333519,
0.27186593413352966,
-0.23080527782440186,
-0.6931995749473572,
-0.2206457108259201,
0.23084713518619537,
-0.6743066310882568,
-0.4814099967479706,
-0.1340741068124771,
-0.441913366317749,
-0.28609853982925415,
-0.3371214270591736,
-0.27730295062065125,
-0.3137292265892029,
-0.2628360092639923,
-0.22655341029167175,
0.8429158329963684,
0.7457035183906555,
-0.05438239127397537,
0.419243186712265,
-0.7871034145355225,
0.16555865108966827,
0.4910643696784973,
0.577329158782959,
0.6026806831359863,
-0.43158668279647827,
-0.680108904838562,
0.02314929850399494,
-0.3121359646320343,
-0.5184729099273682,
0.37803587317466736,
0.15588320791721344,
0.2216975837945938,
0.5977926254272461,
0.10925079882144928,
0.9157528877258301,
-0.3892471492290497,
0.7667454481124878,
-0.050540097057819366,
-0.6313998699188232,
0.5367171168327332,
-0.2445589154958725,
0.1446305811405182,
0.1739509105682373,
0.14249911904335022,
-0.5181291103363037,
-0.16310830414295197,
-0.34222331643104553,
-1.0827302932739258,
0.8368801474571228,
-0.29704129695892334,
-0.2688453495502472,
0.356020450592041,
0.3302910327911377,
0.4037802517414093,
0.00018540635937824845,
-0.37544283270835876,
-0.19948729872703552,
-0.16862013936042786,
-0.4686794877052307,
-0.010949991643428802,
-0.2715417444705963,
0.1086496114730835,
-0.35809043049812317,
0.6227485537528992,
0.08437632769346237,
0.38413530588150024,
0.007244886364787817,
-0.285820335149765,
0.09305372089147568,
0.10415218770503998,
0.4209706783294678,
0.548676073551178,
-0.45518919825553894,
-0.19230002164840698,
0.08987616002559662,
-0.414093017578125,
-0.17503584921360016,
0.36447420716285706,
-0.08706210553646088,
0.06841444969177246,
0.44713881611824036,
0.3920230567455292,
0.3793940544128418,
-0.5694137811660767,
0.35101979970932007,
0.49037519097328186,
0.10369943827390671,
-0.5223876237869263,
-0.06540511548519135,
0.21216382086277008,
0.6530455946922302,
0.5967684984207153,
-0.24886009097099304,
-0.1418399065732956,
-0.11883897334337234,
0.2979848384857178,
0.16601642966270447,
-0.13258858025074005,
-0.2878705561161041,
0.17264845967292786,
0.384661465883255,
-0.1590624898672104,
1.0371615886688232,
0.4136899411678314,
-0.6690660119056702,
1.0422612428665161,
0.4521476924419403,
0.6726951599121094,
-0.3946836292743683,
-0.074176125228405,
0.30232182145118713,
-0.12965647876262665,
0.10834430158138275,
0.44754812121391296,
-0.30783188343048096,
-0.2412577122449875,
-0.5794687271118164,
-0.5345765352249146,
-0.3561362624168396,
0.002608169335871935,
-0.8226822018623352,
0.2864278554916382,
-0.43833640217781067,
0.22222667932510376,
-0.32345759868621826,
0.11703319847583771,
-0.9153578281402588,
0.14730645716190338,
0.3902781903743744,
0.9786980748176575,
-0.6576521992683411,
1.0021321773529053,
0.24712184071540833,
0.09589856117963791,
-0.6170887351036072,
-0.4638458788394928,
-0.12395220249891281,
-1.0008147954940796,
0.8979063034057617,
0.3215271532535553,
0.14312975108623505,
0.011799944564700127,
-0.5256977677345276,
-0.7838952541351318,
1.4378557205200195,
-0.045509498566389084,
-0.8276556134223938,
-0.321285605430603,
0.39035630226135254,
0.37535157799720764,
-0.17599613964557648,
-0.0004922166699543595,
0.5112252235412598,
0.5886266827583313,
0.020937956869602203,
-0.6359521150588989,
-0.045760221779346466,
0.28912150859832764,
-0.262832373380661,
0.312826931476593,
-0.576871395111084,
0.7259302139282227,
-0.2612864077091217,
-0.0016077420441433787,
0.2854636311531067,
0.7939239740371704,
0.05852324515581131,
0.47744888067245483,
0.21587078273296356,
0.5466724038124084,
0.6140448451042175,
-0.05293532460927963,
0.3415444791316986,
-0.2670782804489136,
0.46999290585517883,
1.0501524209976196,
-0.04623594507575035,
0.7654616832733154,
0.47626569867134094,
-0.2800619304180145,
0.5662714838981628,
0.5552738904953003,
-0.15738318860530853,
0.5869836211204529,
0.41777291893959045,
-0.08714035898447037,
-0.09031755477190018,
0.19116008281707764,
-0.4403354823589325,
0.06228577345609665,
0.7030757069587708,
-0.6053175330162048,
-0.33445215225219727,
0.07710982859134674,
-0.13767226040363312,
-0.3602983355522156,
-0.5812554359436035,
0.7108040452003479,
-0.04344318062067032,
-0.3978150188922882,
0.4544405937194824,
-0.43457427620887756,
0.8513105511665344,
-0.8646911978721619,
-0.22338925302028656,
-0.4287092685699463,
0.1908646672964096,
-0.1871909648180008,
-0.8557420372962952,
-0.21020931005477905,
-0.03335675597190857,
0.1079389750957489,
-0.4499334692955017,
0.6237519383430481,
-0.6127010583877563,
-0.4134462773799896,
0.3776822090148926,
0.6108980178833008,
0.14505204558372498,
0.5455454587936401,
-0.5790156126022339,
-0.3093127906322479,
0.15547819435596466,
-0.33592599630355835,
0.32428476214408875,
0.492320716381073,
-0.03596119210124016,
0.9126545786857605,
0.563065230846405,
-0.08342965692281723,
0.16509795188903809,
-0.032329414039850235,
0.7673788070678711,
-0.9927865862846375,
-0.5551295876502991,
-0.9369637966156006,
0.7403029203414917,
0.1558426171541214,
0.15073303878307343,
0.5328086614608765,
0.4218730330467224,
0.4055648744106293,
-0.04764094948768616,
0.6221936345100403,
-0.04432711377739906,
0.830265998840332,
-0.4634384214878082,
0.7868122458457947,
-0.1643838882446289,
0.44985947012901306,
-0.27328354120254517,
-0.6331292986869812,
-0.12779457867145538,
0.4682405889034271,
-0.21824871003627777,
0.03720976412296295,
0.2558186650276184,
0.30233728885650635,
-0.09834258258342743,
0.2136189341545105,
0.08524693548679352,
0.4016764760017395,
0.4845421612262726,
0.6686617732048035,
0.861132025718689,
-0.03410346060991287,
0.25646379590034485,
-0.4377962648868561,
0.1690070778131485,
-0.575764000415802,
-0.9109063744544983,
-0.9488038420677185,
-0.4061424434185028,
-0.07129043340682983,
-0.17757484316825867,
0.26216644048690796,
0.8456236720085144,
0.38815662264823914,
-0.9130069017410278,
-0.19598786532878876,
0.1747279167175293,
0.24488438665866852,
-0.19334571063518524,
-0.306379497051239,
0.9789032340049744,
-0.2593836784362793,
-0.5164896845817566,
0.2434348315000534,
-0.2072928249835968,
0.2358124852180481,
-0.3681226074695587,
-0.08414018154144287,
-0.14794307947158813,
-0.13977982103824615,
0.6670622229576111,
0.34798216819763184,
-0.6255728602409363,
-0.7545033097267151,
0.06666519492864609,
0.31318673491477966,
0.03612722083926201,
0.6969479918479919,
-1.0734076499938965,
0.6412858963012695,
0.23775222897529602,
0.9044398069381714,
0.4690742492675781,
-0.06358002126216888,
0.5011670589447021,
-0.7770623564720154,
-0.15248268842697144,
0.6194629669189453,
0.34411749243736267,
0.09803473949432373,
-0.41093727946281433,
0.4190203845500946,
-0.1138431504368782,
-0.7348588705062866,
-0.8423387408256531,
-0.186430424451828,
-1.0420631170272827,
-0.19526433944702148,
0.6989486813545227,
-0.5578399300575256,
0.02724006585776806,
-0.08905793726444244,
-0.15954051911830902,
0.4807872176170349,
-0.5808902382850647,
0.9518769979476929,
0.710683286190033,
-0.5016865134239197,
-0.08204883337020874,
-0.707826554775238,
0.16228969395160675,
0.5681991577148438,
-0.41961145401000977,
0.15478616952896118,
0.42637982964515686,
0.31366094946861267,
0.030445069074630737,
-0.21154209971427917,
0.23980048298835754,
0.2060326337814331,
-0.6352405548095703,
0.021940559148788452,
-0.46158090233802795,
-0.21598277986049652,
-0.15851649641990662,
0.034577786922454834,
-0.37785661220550537,
-0.32947495579719543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16116v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16116v2
|
Classifying Human-Generated and AI-Generated Election Claims in Social Media
| 2024-04-24T18:13:29 | 2024-04-26T01:51:51 |
Alphaeus Dmonte, Marcos Zampieri, Kevin Lybarger, Massimiliano Albanese, Genya Coulter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Politics is one of the most prevalent topics discussed on social media
platforms, particularly during major election cycles, where users engage in
conversations about candidates and electoral processes. Malicious actors may
use this opportunity to disseminate misinformation to undermine trust in the
electoral process. The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) exacerbates
this issue by enabling malicious actors to generate misinformation at an
unprecedented scale. Artificial intelligence (AI)-generated content is often
indistinguishable from authentic user content, raising concerns about the
integrity of information on social networks. In this paper, we present a novel
taxonomy for characterizing election-related claims. This taxonomy provides an
instrument for analyzing election-related claims, with granular categories
related to jurisdiction, equipment, processes, and the nature of claims. We
introduce ElectAI, a novel benchmark dataset that consists of 9,900 tweets,
each labeled as human- or AI-generated. For AI-generated tweets, the specific
LLM variant that produced them is specified. We annotated a subset of 1,550
tweets using the proposed taxonomy to capture the characteristics of
election-related claims. We explored the capabilities of LLMs in extracting the
taxonomy attributes and trained various machine learning models using ElectAI
to distinguish between human- and AI-generated posts and identify the specific
LLM variant.
|
[
-0.19891120493412018,
-0.6641234755516052,
0.43623825907707214,
-0.017333984375,
-0.29121193289756775,
0.28980332612991333,
-0.2615988254547119,
-0.4647101163864136,
0.4211287200450897,
0.6751967668533325,
-0.07036744803190231,
-0.23897850513458252,
-0.7117919325828552,
0.05680392310023308,
-0.6116502285003662,
0.931616485118866,
0.2170071303844452,
-0.3293660283088684,
-0.18427923321723938,
-0.16127312183380127,
0.028220420703291893,
-0.4661795496940613,
-0.48013222217559814,
-0.4747961759567261,
0.657737135887146,
0.23385843634605408,
0.5078163743019104,
0.5412148237228394,
0.602118730545044,
0.28321391344070435,
0.2472536712884903,
0.2438829243183136,
-0.37694430351257324,
-0.32104507088661194,
-0.19201990962028503,
-0.48091182112693787,
-0.2039744257926941,
0.13114331662654877,
0.5075502991676331,
0.16322804987430573,
-0.329887717962265,
0.37584471702575684,
-0.23280060291290283,
0.38204196095466614,
-0.8207276463508606,
0.12899459898471832,
-1.3622545003890991,
-0.41111692786216736,
-0.5058040618896484,
-0.47002533078193665,
-0.38338717818260193,
-0.4630188047885895,
-0.06703449040651321,
-0.20658615231513977,
0.33486950397491455,
0.0421389639377594,
1.056077241897583,
-0.029516033828258514,
-0.5196465253829956,
-0.449180006980896,
-0.6257396340370178,
0.35798120498657227,
-0.8476638197898865,
-0.1777728796005249,
0.2669173777103424,
0.44583314657211304,
0.0479295440018177,
-0.6163944602012634,
-0.8140408992767334,
0.08103084564208984,
-0.0346166267991066,
-0.1113327369093895,
-0.2330014556646347,
0.013427027501165867,
-0.11073530465364456,
0.04399668797850609,
-0.3727598786354065,
0.36582839488983154,
-0.4682990312576294,
-0.39597460627555847,
1.0967501401901245,
0.010317636653780937,
0.41295498609542847,
-0.7530443072319031,
-0.3325342535972595,
-0.008830280974507332,
-0.9755131602287292,
-0.21966314315795898,
0.8398692607879639,
0.5780243277549744,
-0.12722501158714294,
0.5583235025405884,
-0.10851047933101654,
0.5272369980812073,
-0.07651887834072113,
-0.025761965662240982,
0.10061171650886536,
-0.16313834488391876,
-0.18793323636054993,
0.3232106566429138,
1.2364245653152466,
0.2415345013141632,
0.20105795562267303,
-0.12349564582109451,
-0.343330055475235,
0.5023789405822754,
0.2961636483669281,
-0.7106710076332092,
-0.07056007534265518,
0.13156385719776154,
-0.5817785263061523,
-0.7850295305252075,
0.5398321151733398,
-0.6041679382324219,
-0.8793795108795166,
-0.20144779980182648,
0.3071937561035156,
-0.01242641732096672,
-0.6243463754653931,
-0.3168928325176239,
0.02292509190738201,
0.10790206491947174,
0.24412167072296143,
-0.38321763277053833,
0.0778801366686821,
0.9316641688346863,
0.532746434211731,
-0.09521477669477463,
-0.037483684718608856,
-0.5034253597259521,
0.006295242812484503,
-0.5354424118995667,
0.8555529117584229,
-0.6177831292152405,
0.2464430034160614,
0.4533950388431549,
-0.0920635238289833,
-0.02723044529557228,
-0.7040784955024719,
0.4393286406993866,
-1.179943323135376,
0.04192072153091431,
0.027820294722914696,
-0.6044905185699463,
-0.015810716897249222,
0.3324012756347656,
-0.7100030183792114,
0.703315794467926,
-0.12622876465320587,
-0.6099112629890442,
0.6565058827400208,
-0.43815818428993225,
-0.295428067445755,
0.40067264437675476,
-0.43213897943496704,
-0.504819393157959,
0.16320408880710602,
-0.07308103144168854,
0.6625142693519592,
-0.33620890974998474,
0.8042914867401123,
-0.20947577059268951,
0.17030560970306396,
0.27271023392677307,
-0.1917058676481247,
0.7862917184829712,
0.13925732672214508,
-0.25692132115364075,
0.22824636101722717,
-0.9086967706680298,
-0.3061356842517853,
0.21098119020462036,
-0.10784018039703369,
-0.4879097044467926,
0.40570658445358276,
0.05049605295062065,
0.15554563701152802,
0.29631704092025757,
-0.9381652474403381,
-0.12032502144575119,
-0.2784178853034973,
0.7632284164428711,
0.9298532605171204,
-0.03671708330512047,
0.11315419524908066,
-0.384760320186615,
0.1533101201057434,
0.3413677513599396,
-0.2860671877861023,
-0.020248671993613243,
-0.4547288715839386,
-0.4975712299346924,
0.22770723700523376,
0.4232773780822754,
0.7046070098876953,
-0.8395333886146545,
0.2581014037132263,
-0.6192808747291565,
-0.6344700455665588,
-0.3656523525714874,
0.046799976378679276,
-0.19241788983345032,
0.25862184166908264,
-0.14007015526294708,
0.24203182756900787,
-0.49607935547828674,
-0.9450940489768982,
-0.49282026290893555,
-0.7647266983985901,
-0.05080834776163101,
0.5070465803146362,
0.7979776859283447,
-0.35052490234375,
0.8966705799102783,
-0.08802202343940735,
-0.2895730435848236,
0.036442965269088745,
0.49160900712013245,
0.037908170372247696,
0.09557018429040909,
0.4743350148200989,
-1.0132360458374023,
-0.15672211349010468,
0.1704683154821396,
-0.4325063228607178,
-0.1828070729970932,
-0.4696604013442993,
0.06246956065297127,
0.2364226132631302,
0.2774481475353241,
-0.5854259729385376,
0.3767601549625397,
0.38037773966789246,
-0.41396769881248474,
0.40127336978912354,
0.17543993890285492,
0.26287373900413513,
-1.2865053415298462,
-0.16206768155097961,
0.18020610511302948,
-0.41433849930763245,
-0.4709080159664154,
-0.10732652992010117,
0.014827941544353962,
0.16676448285579681,
-0.4153328537940979,
0.38458237051963806,
-0.06682202965021133,
0.11725399643182755,
-0.19317084550857544,
0.20514509081840515,
-0.4275321066379547,
0.06253421306610107,
-0.18367324769496918,
0.4484490156173706,
0.4647652506828308,
-0.44588929414749146,
0.6505444645881653,
0.03326866775751114,
-0.44227826595306396,
0.47238144278526306,
-0.7188348770141602,
0.25429806113243103,
-0.25002148747444153,
0.03462580218911171,
-1.2357327938079834,
-0.678977906703949,
0.12280002236366272,
-0.7979571223258972,
0.10253274440765381,
0.12388443946838379,
-0.8541806936264038,
-0.15824773907661438,
-0.16711951792240143,
0.25546348094940186,
0.2868054509162903,
-0.6136420369148254,
0.7733205556869507,
0.7176015973091125,
-0.16455206274986267,
-0.24570710957050323,
-0.5703238248825073,
0.41077181696891785,
-0.441699355840683,
-0.47086217999458313,
0.506579577922821,
0.7958961129188538,
-0.46910789608955383,
0.3734668791294098,
0.4070107936859131,
-0.05592191591858864,
-0.18958459794521332,
0.07962723076343536,
0.1326259970664978,
-0.18245333433151245,
0.2890051007270813,
-0.26706817746162415,
0.2947952151298523,
0.2333531677722931,
0.3205967843532562,
0.4004788100719452,
0.12686282396316528,
-0.20166318118572235,
-0.4835737347602844,
0.33257800340652466,
0.6564876437187195,
-0.2343088835477829,
0.8895113468170166,
0.4539664387702942,
-0.6249526143074036,
-0.20078416168689728,
-0.8154013156890869,
-0.1033298596739769,
-0.3970090448856354,
0.34786105155944824,
0.14555718004703522,
-0.8182538151741028,
0.7514157295227051,
-0.11676312983036041,
0.5054221749305725,
0.889672040939331,
0.5067694783210754,
0.009206943213939667,
1.1268407106399536,
0.5561221837997437,
-0.35953348875045776,
0.3211388885974884,
-0.019227927550673485,
0.1623942255973816,
-0.3659931421279907,
-0.08895591646432877,
-0.7211823463439941,
-0.21360401809215546,
-0.9301034212112427,
-0.26006874442100525,
-0.06944067776203156,
-0.38420283794403076,
-0.49810221791267395,
0.16808612644672394,
-0.5422574877738953,
0.2417854219675064,
0.49573153257369995,
0.09093720465898514,
0.0131233474239707,
0.2971686124801636,
0.7102800607681274,
0.05635290592908859,
-0.6621820330619812,
-0.6777192950248718,
1.2313367128372192,
0.22000569105148315,
0.5541729927062988,
0.1914764791727066,
0.7825492024421692,
0.8775640726089478,
0.8020226359367371,
-0.5108939409255981,
0.37743908166885376,
-0.2564287781715393,
-0.6302294731140137,
-0.07629917562007904,
-0.7954676747322083,
-1.019744873046875,
0.15640006959438324,
-0.2955058813095093,
-0.809098482131958,
0.09380368888378143,
0.03511158376932144,
-0.25073596835136414,
0.7825173139572144,
-0.2417636215686798,
0.46782225370407104,
-0.39131858944892883,
0.07492712140083313,
-0.3392738699913025,
-0.5233628749847412,
0.43455952405929565,
-0.13362617790699005,
0.29786401987075806,
-0.22465838491916656,
-0.2691406011581421,
1.0140668153762817,
-0.39412540197372437,
0.9253488779067993,
-0.13923266530036926,
0.09467677026987076,
0.5718467831611633,
-0.19655835628509521,
0.531493604183197,
-0.07411101460456848,
-0.02599756233394146,
0.30215150117874146,
0.004383706953376532,
-0.1265803724527359,
-0.25937679409980774,
0.4280683398246765,
-0.9036699533462524,
-0.3721497356891632,
-0.48632869124412537,
-0.15088413655757904,
0.15601865947246552,
0.08679039031267166,
0.4490739107131958,
0.36791500449180603,
-0.4371671974658966,
0.3285454511642456,
0.3167005181312561,
-0.20895805954933167,
0.22994764149188995,
0.23829476535320282,
0.09447532892227173,
-0.47916707396507263,
1.2656768560409546,
0.14459827542304993,
-0.08955755084753036,
0.0671575590968132,
0.2761557698249817,
-0.20325279235839844,
-0.5119782090187073,
-0.25902628898620605,
0.2674630880355835,
-0.3596995770931244,
-0.6689568758010864,
-0.5032535791397095,
-0.375154584646225,
-0.3058707118034363,
0.134565070271492,
-0.36256149411201477,
-0.25434648990631104,
-0.4277741014957428,
0.08329714834690094,
0.29009395837783813,
0.9546930193901062,
0.11145038902759552,
0.597990870475769,
-0.5379821062088013,
0.43819841742515564,
0.22218522429466248,
0.32682642340660095,
-0.2304926961660385,
-0.3823021650314331,
0.17634135484695435,
0.22047151625156403,
-0.4263054430484772,
-1.1821506023406982,
0.18036675453186035,
0.5175458788871765,
0.41780954599380493,
0.6263301372528076,
0.3466660976409912,
0.31935521960258484,
-0.5016109347343445,
1.0258232355117798,
0.32091525197029114,
-0.49557361006736755,
0.701184093952179,
-0.43399131298065186,
-0.46034640073776245,
0.3875863552093506,
0.17127950489521027,
-0.29856714606285095,
-0.44656988978385925,
-0.8896779417991638,
-0.8869583606719971,
0.4990330934524536,
0.23779016733169556,
0.5425476431846619,
-0.27890336513519287,
0.38927093148231506,
-0.032805271446704865,
0.3419225513935089,
-0.7435619831085205,
-0.07787222415208817,
0.14516514539718628,
-0.25408655405044556,
0.05444883182644844,
-0.31978002190589905,
-0.32228562235832214,
0.16344000399112701,
0.6949788331985474,
-0.17893293499946594,
0.04603956267237663,
0.12466560304164886,
-0.007889781147241592,
-0.2698015570640564,
0.2830578684806824,
0.35813775658607483,
0.7413648366928101,
0.18200185894966125,
0.07383421063423157,
-0.24819450080394745,
-0.10611080378293991,
0.019922615960240364,
0.06780046224594116,
-0.4456535875797272,
0.2341366857290268,
0.531363308429718,
0.6400375366210938,
-0.3545013964176178,
-0.6223358511924744,
0.5304498672485352,
-0.03913162648677826,
-0.2278568297624588,
-0.605786144733429,
-0.22870132327079773,
-0.02561538852751255,
0.08323162794113159,
0.648555338382721,
0.18692360818386078,
0.09707922488451004,
-0.7784994840621948,
0.15445484220981598,
0.5527332425117493,
-0.06061657518148422,
-0.5252795219421387,
0.8647739291191101,
0.3929697871208191,
-0.5792242288589478,
0.41439229249954224,
-0.19184117019176483,
-0.6306056976318359,
0.8143886923789978,
0.1359705924987793,
0.8473546504974365,
-0.15858814120292664,
0.4202491044998169,
0.4254738390445709,
0.5451358556747437,
0.11493843048810959,
0.04223423823714256,
0.15502618253231049,
-1.0697543621063232,
-0.17477533221244812,
-0.43436911702156067,
-0.10199359804391861,
0.5191496014595032,
-0.4713723659515381,
0.0808790847659111,
-0.4970688819885254,
-0.5583402514457703,
0.33191534876823425,
0.01694740541279316,
-0.6957728266716003,
-0.07039202749729156,
0.4819950461387634,
0.667340099811554,
-1.1884247064590454,
0.1753005087375641,
0.8398441076278687,
0.019167013466358185,
-0.607196033000946,
-0.1168966293334961,
0.3091093897819519,
-0.5442960858345032,
0.5381487011909485,
0.12077280133962631,
0.11776544898748398,
-0.358668714761734,
-0.9637834429740906,
-0.4248775839805603,
0.7697457075119019,
0.502419650554657,
-0.31774213910102844,
-0.02508155070245266,
0.5179232358932495,
0.3769398331642151,
-0.727739691734314,
-0.13232895731925964,
0.4151175618171692,
0.10395873337984085,
-0.04240216314792633,
-0.7964844703674316,
-0.07475672662258148,
-0.1742250919342041,
0.16805142164230347,
0.19775347411632538,
-0.6636623740196228,
0.7879024147987366,
-0.07380477339029312,
-0.4347970485687256,
0.023379890248179436,
0.7831148505210876,
0.15803691744804382,
0.5134608149528503,
0.7248898148536682,
0.41431865096092224,
0.7779369354248047,
-0.2630617320537567,
1.081847906112671,
-0.18062420189380646,
0.3512306213378906,
0.9039553999900818,
-0.20301765203475952,
0.8652300834655762,
0.324021577835083,
-0.09095030277967453,
0.4696516990661621,
0.9057746529579163,
0.009215913712978363,
0.13233652710914612,
0.34230875968933105,
-0.12121055275201797,
-0.4352353811264038,
-0.3447279930114746,
-0.13571445643901825,
0.6825539469718933,
0.6216518878936768,
-0.5309546589851379,
-0.2330443561077118,
-0.17405535280704498,
-0.030304061248898506,
0.3242034614086151,
-0.4979541003704071,
1.049709439277649,
-0.15830136835575104,
-0.8477473855018616,
0.20050381124019623,
-0.10088041424751282,
0.7593711614608765,
-0.3408326804637909,
-0.2696027159690857,
0.32539212703704834,
0.10756780952215195,
-0.4561649560928345,
-0.8091925978660583,
0.22561755776405334,
0.0934322327375412,
0.08584575355052948,
0.05128021165728569,
0.8373414874076843,
-0.5361194610595703,
-0.8276219964027405,
0.09479869157075882,
0.40498510003089905,
-0.0101206349208951,
-0.08775061368942261,
-0.7402060031890869,
-0.02970120683312416,
-0.1929784119129181,
-0.35740548372268677,
-0.03791458532214165,
0.44840362668037415,
-0.17402032017707825,
0.6752395629882812,
0.5176989436149597,
0.5755356550216675,
-0.07575608789920807,
0.17609059810638428,
0.7653547525405884,
-0.158733531832695,
-0.37960779666900635,
-0.9663535952568054,
0.2518846392631531,
-0.4670303165912628,
-0.2649756371974945,
0.4916378855705261,
0.4692765176296234,
0.6170760989189148,
0.3090612292289734,
0.9696899652481079,
-0.4264877438545227,
0.6904429197311401,
-0.17519444227218628,
0.91462641954422,
-0.7640914916992188,
0.18146692216396332,
-0.31782087683677673,
-0.5630796551704407,
-0.0970594733953476,
0.2594316899776459,
-0.23797781765460968,
0.03713032603263855,
-0.017070507630705833,
0.7967773675918579,
-0.09665501862764359,
-0.18089739978313446,
-0.006051957607269287,
0.17551779747009277,
0.4164870083332062,
0.3975774943828583,
0.9724414944648743,
-0.2838933765888214,
0.6036940813064575,
-0.09596897661685944,
-0.11317292600870132,
-0.3545510768890381,
-0.6981813907623291,
-0.8619449138641357,
-0.7450649738311768,
-0.6052960157394409,
-0.44541022181510925,
-0.20682808756828308,
0.7080588936805725,
0.8500493764877319,
-0.8762311935424805,
-0.14512279629707336,
0.06995085626840591,
0.13116683065891266,
0.28230199217796326,
-0.32366928458213806,
0.5000661611557007,
-0.0830821767449379,
-0.37307053804397583,
-0.4198469817638397,
-0.08857990056276321,
-0.37010785937309265,
-0.30572766065597534,
0.12235832959413528,
-0.2412792146205902,
0.31677037477493286,
0.5069671869277954,
0.20065051317214966,
-0.9757187962532043,
-0.5072164535522461,
-0.16099455952644348,
-0.11661453545093536,
-0.03793082758784294,
0.7340786457061768,
-0.6811150312423706,
0.3508950173854828,
0.5785439014434814,
0.7773705124855042,
0.037240736186504364,
0.3671339750289917,
0.45019614696502686,
-0.7462866306304932,
-0.06041720137000084,
0.4202965199947357,
0.31646913290023804,
0.5438941717147827,
-0.5950657725334167,
0.45933377742767334,
0.23762956261634827,
-0.5125678181648254,
-0.9603426456451416,
0.19487115740776062,
-0.744081437587738,
-0.10817787796258926,
1.188192367553711,
0.1405148059129715,
-0.2855243384838104,
0.21005403995513916,
0.0938810333609581,
0.20697370171546936,
-0.42402729392051697,
1.0694035291671753,
0.8346942663192749,
0.14328694343566895,
-0.2980482876300812,
-0.5492397546768188,
0.3713690936565399,
-0.2827094495296478,
-0.766303300857544,
0.026434162631630898,
0.5298714637756348,
0.16109631955623627,
0.4756707549095154,
0.6196858882904053,
-0.19799041748046875,
0.4153233766555786,
-0.20685404539108276,
-0.19553188979625702,
0.3073890805244446,
-0.06834512948989868,
0.09286296367645264,
0.2930130958557129,
-0.27437326312065125,
-0.2587447464466095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16115v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16115v1
|
Online Personalizing White-box LLMs Generation with Neural Bandits
| 2024-04-24T18:13:12 | 2024-04-24T18:13:12 |
Zekai Chen, Weeden Daniel, Po-yu Chen, Francois Buet-Golfouse
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The advent of personalized content generation by LLMs presents a novel
challenge: how to efficiently adapt text to meet individual preferences without
the unsustainable demand of creating a unique model for each user. This study
introduces an innovative online method that employs neural bandit algorithms to
dynamically optimize soft instruction embeddings based on user feedback,
enhancing the personalization of open-ended text generation by white-box LLMs.
Through rigorous experimentation on various tasks, we demonstrate significant
performance improvements over baseline strategies. NeuralTS, in particular,
leads to substantial enhancements in personalized news headline generation,
achieving up to a 62.9% improvement in terms of best ROUGE scores and up to
2.76% increase in LLM-agent evaluation against the baseline.
|
[
-0.2627924680709839,
-0.8975640535354614,
0.565902829170227,
0.09955371171236038,
-0.1520063579082489,
0.4516911208629608,
-0.5245332717895508,
-0.13461154699325562,
0.686451256275177,
0.5745712518692017,
-0.7373073101043701,
-0.9195811748504639,
-0.3590114414691925,
-0.024746054783463478,
-0.144425168633461,
1.4412962198257446,
0.2332664430141449,
-0.11516625434160233,
-0.2522510886192322,
0.17074689269065857,
-0.641404926776886,
-0.3415769040584564,
-0.7032841444015503,
0.0836852490901947,
0.7758539915084839,
0.20229943096637726,
0.5342843532562256,
0.5858445167541504,
0.2858186960220337,
0.4486382007598877,
-0.23138193786144257,
0.42937999963760376,
-0.7465831637382507,
0.45744508504867554,
-0.14964893460273743,
-0.5738712549209595,
-0.3252013921737671,
-0.38627904653549194,
0.20341648161411285,
0.16707317531108856,
-0.3909500241279602,
0.18498177826404572,
0.16129666566848755,
0.6418770551681519,
-0.7245885729789734,
-0.13087324798107147,
-0.7152278423309326,
0.24259766936302185,
-0.12769350409507751,
-0.5810524225234985,
-0.3263552486896515,
-0.8526365160942078,
0.24944078922271729,
-0.7561555504798889,
0.30153271555900574,
-0.2844467759132385,
0.6103969812393188,
0.18623016774654388,
-0.347760409116745,
-0.5009371638298035,
-0.7843338847160339,
0.6158674955368042,
-0.7226415276527405,
-0.0780760869383812,
0.07743629813194275,
0.43034034967422485,
-0.12903718650341034,
-0.9549732208251953,
-0.05230451375246048,
-0.34193435311317444,
0.15417882800102234,
0.3933277130126953,
-0.2432931512594223,
-0.03558318316936493,
-0.0041540577076375484,
-0.11011012643575668,
-0.2527359426021576,
0.12340486794710159,
-0.4625517427921295,
-0.1320931613445282,
0.8590458631515503,
0.3240298926830292,
0.019625697284936905,
-0.1006753221154213,
-0.4246327579021454,
0.13549943268299103,
-0.6373664736747742,
0.24387887120246887,
1.07552170753479,
0.18851754069328308,
-0.039595745503902435,
0.4312102496623993,
-0.48626509308815,
0.7832767963409424,
0.27474379539489746,
-0.3330295979976654,
0.27895158529281616,
-0.13416191935539246,
0.03822069987654686,
0.2151111662387848,
0.5492653846740723,
0.5718407034873962,
0.1833949089050293,
-0.3433060348033905,
-0.44868922233581543,
-0.5305784940719604,
0.5625410079956055,
-0.7010635137557983,
0.05096294730901718,
0.059573084115982056,
-0.500521183013916,
-0.7681623101234436,
0.1968679428100586,
-0.7988249659538269,
-0.5936742424964905,
-0.32666802406311035,
0.5213685631752014,
-0.22766776382923126,
0.2030927836894989,
-0.1663883477449417,
-0.3165581226348877,
-0.17788636684417725,
0.574954628944397,
-0.9942079186439514,
0.1581605225801468,
0.42612406611442566,
0.8164900541305542,
-0.3143308162689209,
0.05122106894850731,
-0.7242669463157654,
0.2906799912452698,
-0.21243025362491608,
1.0159534215927124,
-0.21335887908935547,
-0.012394217774271965,
0.30361393094062805,
-0.43669527769088745,
0.244950070977211,
-0.5525267124176025,
0.12396049499511719,
-0.8409236669540405,
0.12429052591323853,
-0.1336258202791214,
-0.44188064336776733,
-0.031394172459840775,
0.4972596764564514,
-0.431716650724411,
0.6698668599128723,
0.23797607421875,
-0.4363745152950287,
0.15887664258480072,
-0.619423508644104,
-0.41444888710975647,
0.22870047390460968,
-0.07704136520624161,
-0.4179220199584961,
0.4761105477809906,
0.3210245668888092,
0.4884440004825592,
0.0322970487177372,
0.3660753667354584,
-0.19687548279762268,
-0.4765513241291046,
0.7164503335952759,
-0.41311880946159363,
0.4425116181373596,
0.20781101286411285,
-0.40429168939590454,
0.3412396013736725,
-0.6562281847000122,
0.12157310545444489,
0.19052401185035706,
-0.5868242979049683,
-0.1367924064397812,
0.26091283559799194,
-0.042336124926805496,
-0.15143315494060516,
0.500857412815094,
-0.498807817697525,
0.21829178929328918,
-0.41373276710510254,
0.4054068922996521,
1.2628917694091797,
0.16443486511707306,
0.2653422951698303,
-0.6713421940803528,
0.5864266753196716,
-0.12562011182308197,
-0.06169899180531502,
-0.5102220177650452,
-0.4465290606021881,
-0.6813069581985474,
-0.014406692236661911,
0.6160603165626526,
0.6930403709411621,
-0.6323496699333191,
0.49466508626937866,
-0.032348643988370895,
-0.18696388602256775,
-0.23652419447898865,
0.477127343416214,
0.2313256561756134,
0.21507446467876434,
0.17057153582572937,
-0.3809022605419159,
-0.3736276924610138,
-0.9551531672477722,
-0.4545649588108063,
0.4553984999656677,
-0.2621487081050873,
0.43192124366760254,
-0.09332536160945892,
-0.24100464582443237,
1.0037883520126343,
-0.9939566254615784,
-0.38752323389053345,
-0.2772460877895355,
0.10260575264692307,
0.07777529954910278,
0.05975261330604553,
0.4462551772594452,
-0.6460959315299988,
-0.640078604221344,
-0.257217675447464,
-0.5924954414367676,
-0.12355271726846695,
-0.37508100271224976,
0.06355775147676468,
0.10064125061035156,
0.5133050084114075,
-0.24164283275604248,
0.4584009051322937,
0.44252675771713257,
-0.2116338461637497,
0.10400156676769257,
-0.44663429260253906,
-0.02913995087146759,
-1.2704999446868896,
-0.546488344669342,
0.1517651379108429,
-0.3400767743587494,
-0.5938399434089661,
0.017845824360847473,
-0.1908481866121292,
-0.050810813903808594,
-0.6495012640953064,
0.40708741545677185,
-0.4400137960910797,
-0.0038812081329524517,
-0.3309977054595947,
0.5259650945663452,
-0.33395111560821533,
0.6413248777389526,
-0.2911325991153717,
0.5349048972129822,
0.20962627232074738,
-0.49139437079429626,
0.5338250994682312,
0.19111143052577972,
-0.4960603713989258,
0.38182148337364197,
-0.4928587079048157,
0.38052496314048767,
-0.42138350009918213,
0.1863565593957901,
-0.9820204377174377,
-0.3160378336906433,
0.18029586970806122,
-0.4469197690486908,
0.2953249514102936,
0.10088181495666504,
-0.3022862672805786,
0.11624471098184586,
-0.772335946559906,
-0.07835596799850464,
0.8113174438476562,
-0.5706422328948975,
0.4019736647605896,
0.22275134921073914,
-0.3655439019203186,
-0.29235708713531494,
-0.6570618748664856,
0.26886793971061707,
-0.18522672355175018,
-0.7082850933074951,
0.6845285296440125,
-0.1665991097688675,
-0.1700676679611206,
0.12850229442119598,
0.15966039896011353,
0.22977590560913086,
0.21640484035015106,
-0.025853602215647697,
0.04351869225502014,
-0.3775586783885956,
-0.01111733540892601,
0.3356296122074127,
-0.14097873866558075,
-0.0858394056558609,
-0.4128354489803314,
0.39301735162734985,
0.15700291097164154,
-0.09526623785495758,
-0.28684669733047485,
0.20190966129302979,
-0.1147063672542572,
-0.21396814286708832,
0.7020394206047058,
0.7894427180290222,
-0.2932518422603607,
-0.6920357942581177,
-0.6370410919189453,
-0.19322386384010315,
-0.6249402165412903,
0.39368709921836853,
-0.05594584345817566,
-1.0351753234863281,
0.29419761896133423,
-0.14356979727745056,
0.04203103855252266,
0.2545545995235443,
0.8671540021896362,
-0.35845810174942017,
1.0044313669204712,
0.46636223793029785,
0.3797759413719177,
0.659861147403717,
-0.16509245336055756,
-0.043383993208408356,
-0.7258553504943848,
-0.5810505747795105,
-0.07769416272640228,
-0.8967305421829224,
-0.8499936461448669,
-0.15423259139060974,
0.4144873023033142,
-0.035303372889757156,
-0.008791206404566765,
0.056207168847322464,
-0.7504020929336548,
0.5572128295898438,
0.9522339701652527,
0.6371377110481262,
0.17601001262664795,
0.2836408019065857,
0.07601547241210938,
-0.10190790146589279,
-0.5984767079353333,
-0.46198296546936035,
1.3740575313568115,
0.1691066026687622,
0.980258047580719,
0.36772727966308594,
1.058605432510376,
0.7068739533424377,
0.6094971895217896,
-0.6945807337760925,
0.5223050713539124,
-0.28030362725257874,
-0.42860767245292664,
-0.1255643516778946,
-0.3611970841884613,
-1.1549311876296997,
-0.049775395542383194,
-0.42215633392333984,
-0.9654034972190857,
-0.2847929894924164,
0.1947753131389618,
-0.8439640998840332,
0.3192112445831299,
-0.7853163480758667,
0.47892650961875916,
-0.578630805015564,
-0.5081217885017395,
-0.08084994554519653,
-0.398469477891922,
0.36614567041397095,
-0.23571395874023438,
-0.01049073040485382,
-0.043732695281505585,
-0.651734471321106,
0.6244770884513855,
-0.2996009886264801,
1.0800684690475464,
-0.14278307557106018,
0.2078252136707306,
0.490156888961792,
-0.10540896654129028,
0.6696569323539734,
0.2856188416481018,
0.14700905978679657,
0.04689191281795502,
-0.6086124777793884,
-0.16990254819393158,
-0.7333796620368958,
0.9829720854759216,
-0.8664656281471252,
-0.944774329662323,
-0.3362596929073334,
-0.5920753479003906,
-0.15275199711322784,
0.09278898686170578,
0.3467597961425781,
0.5335111021995544,
-0.23632609844207764,
0.4805212616920471,
0.7880440950393677,
-0.5215047001838684,
0.643658459186554,
0.3744411766529083,
-0.03099779784679413,
-0.9342465996742249,
1.285298228263855,
0.25596165657043457,
-0.003309280378744006,
0.6785188913345337,
0.4874342978000641,
-0.2694106698036194,
-1.0173238515853882,
-0.5342195630073547,
-0.16090857982635498,
-0.6398798823356628,
-0.5218048691749573,
-0.5979833006858826,
-0.29421722888946533,
-0.32076412439346313,
-0.6318656206130981,
0.08261426538228989,
-0.23079906404018402,
-0.6177735328674316,
0.06972989439964294,
0.3507715165615082,
1.1624739170074463,
0.18090252578258514,
0.7052224278450012,
-1.017136812210083,
0.41505560278892517,
0.5283778309822083,
0.291126012802124,
-0.2870466113090515,
-0.5048683285713196,
-0.2503499388694763,
0.009210025891661644,
-1.0133826732635498,
-1.267523169517517,
0.42472824454307556,
-0.1539924293756485,
0.6775007843971252,
0.3800428509712219,
-0.0497434027493,
0.3014342784881592,
-0.33767059445381165,
0.7531344294548035,
0.21897856891155243,
-0.7873942255973816,
0.4361211359500885,
-0.5702627301216125,
0.30589738488197327,
0.40974801778793335,
0.21898625791072845,
-0.21006818115711212,
-0.3508508503437042,
-0.706286609172821,
-0.7828344702720642,
0.8990496397018433,
0.3244122862815857,
0.6049975156784058,
0.16611550748348236,
0.45310714840888977,
0.07976306974887848,
0.4911034107208252,
-0.5136257410049438,
-0.14845573902130127,
-0.10466688126325607,
-0.47493499517440796,
-0.13153156638145447,
-0.2584036886692047,
0.01824173517525196,
0.07377695292234421,
0.4137638211250305,
-0.27572888135910034,
0.2703317105770111,
-0.034436553716659546,
-0.06028513237833977,
-0.02662242017686367,
0.1333666443824768,
0.9922812581062317,
0.6636839509010315,
-0.2892380952835083,
-0.27779871225357056,
0.5660910606384277,
-0.32371553778648376,
0.12044571340084076,
0.13184866309165955,
-0.739280641078949,
0.01998918317258358,
0.31217506527900696,
0.9111006855964661,
0.3578794300556183,
-0.6101288199424744,
0.5875166058540344,
-0.15944457054138184,
-0.3614021837711334,
-0.4899906814098358,
0.4550130069255829,
0.32441654801368713,
0.4376835525035858,
0.4485680162906647,
0.2909875810146332,
0.07374054193496704,
-0.3745984435081482,
0.14710476994514465,
0.49331510066986084,
-0.2097211629152298,
-0.1642967015504837,
0.6831674575805664,
0.4710840880870819,
-0.9497118592262268,
0.43805059790611267,
-0.1941032111644745,
-0.32931971549987793,
0.8166123628616333,
0.67759770154953,
1.2573468685150146,
-0.21377715468406677,
0.39910799264907837,
0.218135803937912,
0.33449599146842957,
0.19331373274326324,
0.10729427635669708,
0.01601485349237919,
-0.5205443501472473,
-0.1867193728685379,
-0.5900904536247253,
-0.46881118416786194,
0.31566938757896423,
-0.5228476524353027,
0.7616590857505798,
-0.7366555333137512,
-0.15835846960544586,
-0.04930263012647629,
-0.08251328766345978,
-0.5214009284973145,
0.2455129623413086,
0.21087294816970825,
0.669878363609314,
-0.1698995977640152,
0.37914711236953735,
0.7351915836334229,
-0.1726296842098236,
-0.33636224269866943,
0.26109474897384644,
0.1255875676870346,
-0.7440016865730286,
0.32043692469596863,
0.1770106852054596,
0.20425193011760712,
0.09063532203435898,
-0.3290008008480072,
-0.853325605392456,
1.2645994424819946,
0.5666817426681519,
-0.637056827545166,
-0.22045037150382996,
0.023523256182670593,
0.449173241853714,
-0.4720417261123657,
0.5217369794845581,
0.14994651079177856,
0.34622758626937866,
0.08736780285835266,
-0.1238950788974762,
-0.08815385401248932,
0.06511696428060532,
0.14391350746154785,
0.2913072407245636,
-0.9200012683868408,
0.7419573664665222,
-0.3960305154323578,
0.07463051378726959,
0.014334922656416893,
0.7977093458175659,
0.1094980463385582,
0.3801526725292206,
0.4468315541744232,
0.4188428521156311,
0.5382694602012634,
-0.04900466650724411,
1.1018946170806885,
-0.2776315212249756,
0.07900744676589966,
1.0965791940689087,
0.11119052022695541,
0.6126484870910645,
0.06864076852798462,
0.06611432135105133,
0.56684809923172,
0.7093452215194702,
-0.21755225956439972,
0.7675984501838684,
0.6392447352409363,
-0.4841315746307373,
-0.09422415494918823,
0.04545871913433075,
-0.21609561145305634,
0.4075496792793274,
0.17476995289325714,
-0.5544089674949646,
-0.4111185669898987,
0.005914528854191303,
-0.037622351199388504,
0.38403692841529846,
-0.38263174891471863,
1.0625215768814087,
-0.25837182998657227,
-0.8831067085266113,
0.2694733738899231,
0.516314685344696,
0.9952993988990784,
-0.9419495463371277,
0.11037124693393707,
-0.4703473448753357,
0.4159334599971771,
-0.2820456027984619,
-0.5447587370872498,
0.11360996961593628,
0.22970159351825714,
0.0336594358086586,
-0.5501308441162109,
0.90949547290802,
-0.480072557926178,
-0.5040134787559509,
0.01688418909907341,
0.4943751394748688,
-0.2209937423467636,
-0.004675385542213917,
-0.649522066116333,
0.06565693020820618,
0.2399701178073883,
-0.7023892402648926,
0.6453315019607544,
0.1473488062620163,
0.12824435532093048,
0.39635995030403137,
0.8788154125213623,
0.15641598403453827,
0.24262982606887817,
-0.20202714204788208,
0.9499991536140442,
-0.9127936363220215,
-0.609957218170166,
-0.9792429804801941,
0.5671019554138184,
-0.15116938948631287,
-0.7327841520309448,
0.8513635993003845,
0.7287108898162842,
1.0029666423797607,
-0.30483460426330566,
0.9708589911460876,
0.12514229118824005,
0.23004232347011566,
-0.7239567637443542,
0.6695441603660583,
-0.6633983850479126,
0.29006657004356384,
-0.017467960715293884,
-1.0109198093414307,
0.04835845157504082,
0.16939504444599152,
-0.06529469788074493,
0.235757514834404,
0.6204370260238647,
0.7483447194099426,
-0.00981578417122364,
-0.07687853276729584,
0.3980714678764343,
-0.09786273539066315,
0.13565006852149963,
0.562852144241333,
1.0894368886947632,
-0.08630933612585068,
0.7325785756111145,
-0.42245203256607056,
-0.1656385213136673,
-0.3239336311817169,
-1.0038553476333618,
-1.2380363941192627,
-0.2437824010848999,
-0.33530518412590027,
-0.4048886001110077,
0.2693220376968384,
1.051820993423462,
0.5957589149475098,
-0.6678328514099121,
-0.21226973831653595,
0.07089336961507797,
0.23425452411174774,
-0.15634500980377197,
-0.22444073855876923,
0.23660795390605927,
-0.6456807255744934,
-0.8811970949172974,
0.4692087173461914,
0.2698482871055603,
0.022893806919455528,
-0.47648340463638306,
-0.15397807955741882,
0.11784674227237701,
0.3901289105415344,
0.6171162724494934,
-0.06669887155294418,
-0.6518665552139282,
-0.07594451308250427,
0.22490617632865906,
-0.23578445613384247,
0.043925292789936066,
1.0196486711502075,
-0.839389979839325,
0.3385084271430969,
0.5778990983963013,
1.003403902053833,
0.8230406641960144,
0.2153555154800415,
0.43934527039527893,
-0.9471093416213989,
0.02075578086078167,
0.308077335357666,
0.008175361901521683,
0.2803124189376831,
-0.6948040723800659,
0.17097222805023193,
0.4338594675064087,
-0.23567065596580505,
-0.6797077655792236,
-0.0847349539399147,
-0.7853202819824219,
-0.32135939598083496,
1.0962966680526733,
-0.04401132091879845,
-0.2455420196056366,
0.13093037903308868,
-0.2730189263820648,
0.10869776457548141,
-0.5696772336959839,
0.8735528588294983,
0.42627012729644775,
-0.10615548491477966,
0.03211934119462967,
-0.7082427740097046,
0.42244666814804077,
0.2275923490524292,
-1.1367676258087158,
-0.6167511940002441,
0.28158169984817505,
0.38106149435043335,
0.07927979528903961,
0.6003918051719666,
0.4445466995239258,
0.257779061794281,
-0.11995192617177963,
-0.061617713421583176,
-0.6622378826141357,
-0.35558149218559265,
-0.32338571548461914,
0.5820708274841309,
-0.2893444895744324,
-0.2462899088859558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16104v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16104v1
|
Evolution of Voices in French Audiovisual Media Across Genders and Age in a Diachronic Perspective
| 2024-04-24T18:00:06 | 2024-04-24T18:00:06 |
Albert Rilliard, David Doukhan, Rémi Uro, Simon Devauchelle
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
We present a diachronic acoustic analysis of the voice of 1023 speakers from
French media archives. The speakers are spread across 32 categories based on
four periods (years 1955/56, 1975/76, 1995/96, 2015/16), four age groups
(20-35; 36-50; 51-65, >65), and two genders. The fundamental frequency ($F_0$)
and the first four formants (F1-4) were estimated. Procedures used to ensure
the quality of these estimations on heterogeneous data are described. From each
speaker's $F_0$ distribution, the base-$F_0$ value was calculated to estimate
the register. Average vocal tract length was estimated from formant
frequencies. Base-$F_0$ and vocal tract length were fit by linear mixed models
to evaluate how they may have changed across time periods and genders,
corrected for age effects. Results show an effect of the period with a tendency
to lower voices, independently of gender. A lowering of pitch is observed with
age for female but not male speakers.
|
[
-0.5866542458534241,
-0.47926557064056396,
0.3609902262687683,
0.4193302094936371,
0.3618580996990204,
0.13935253024101257,
-0.08156008273363113,
-0.2396511435508728,
0.029333414509892464,
0.35891902446746826,
-0.8402478694915771,
-0.32940346002578735,
-0.5691187977790833,
0.35155901312828064,
-0.5083326101303101,
0.43813589215278625,
0.5996789336204529,
0.24769049882888794,
0.3240610659122467,
-0.11627340316772461,
-0.5709174275398254,
-0.3560570478439331,
-0.5847187638282776,
0.05116946995258331,
0.43216773867607117,
0.4015979468822479,
0.3964925706386566,
0.2865850329399109,
-0.053113486617803574,
0.4007198214530945,
-0.4504414200782776,
0.19882941246032715,
-0.47679007053375244,
0.08778966963291168,
0.0016945918323472142,
-0.3774849772453308,
-0.6889495253562927,
0.200444757938385,
0.7703739404678345,
0.9076586961746216,
-0.29836800694465637,
-0.15559826791286469,
-0.09710196405649185,
0.8363029360771179,
-0.18727518618106842,
-0.20857985317707062,
-0.29531922936439514,
0.015843598172068596,
-0.1555410772562027,
-0.8162196278572083,
-0.37505683302879333,
-0.2522142827510834,
0.26528453826904297,
-0.2995878756046295,
0.6392571926116943,
-0.24710699915885925,
0.6651312708854675,
-0.20395058393478394,
-0.14619021117687225,
-0.1872876137495041,
-1.2687690258026123,
0.6640888452529907,
-0.5542136430740356,
0.8101986646652222,
0.2660568058490753,
0.43705055117607117,
-0.15786533057689667,
-0.6638773679733276,
-0.39034998416900635,
-0.12648676335811615,
0.29914018511772156,
0.15799836814403534,
-0.7001405954360962,
-0.4082898795604706,
0.2391117364168167,
0.3668915927410126,
-0.5886149406433105,
0.0632978305220604,
-0.8409072160720825,
0.0538344606757164,
0.6874200105667114,
-0.17424441874027252,
0.632750391960144,
-0.19440332055091858,
-0.23142391443252563,
-0.08237064629793167,
-0.17772868275642395,
-0.13532885909080505,
0.9110667109489441,
0.4573569893836975,
-0.4596680700778961,
0.46917277574539185,
-0.2092231959104538,
0.38466623425483704,
0.2519567310810089,
-0.06855504959821701,
0.3991602063179016,
-0.23896856606006622,
-0.14882111549377441,
0.1541823446750641,
0.8006945252418518,
0.34891951084136963,
0.7045387029647827,
0.15600447356700897,
-0.008085465990006924,
-0.2919203042984009,
0.09496843814849854,
-0.6097931265830994,
-0.335074782371521,
-0.2758771777153015,
-0.4838508367538452,
-0.11434484273195267,
0.12154607474803925,
-1.0593605041503906,
-0.417447030544281,
-0.27441641688346863,
0.11483072489500046,
-0.48036134243011475,
-0.498747855424881,
0.07464490830898285,
-0.20086510479450226,
-0.07678988575935364,
0.4989519715309143,
-0.9387116432189941,
0.48445025086402893,
0.009376741014420986,
0.5796244740486145,
0.14002729952335358,
0.07046705484390259,
-0.2835593819618225,
-0.17154847085475922,
-0.4332382082939148,
0.5701242089271545,
-0.6121697425842285,
-1.0508509874343872,
-0.07927478849887848,
0.33235883712768555,
-0.17379215359687805,
-0.5955029726028442,
0.5358957648277283,
-0.21994417905807495,
0.8105623126029968,
-0.03580232337117195,
-0.18095947802066803,
-0.24125950038433075,
-0.6402660608291626,
-0.9236327409744263,
0.8027529120445251,
0.39990395307540894,
-0.3834173381328583,
0.4391796886920929,
-0.2238035649061203,
0.08600176870822906,
0.05977381393313408,
-0.6660226583480835,
-0.35094743967056274,
0.07206016033887863,
0.485434889793396,
0.23927496373653412,
-0.454058974981308,
0.012939305044710636,
-0.10978469252586365,
-0.1859833002090454,
0.12529252469539642,
-0.9006730914115906,
0.8267241716384888,
0.154191255569458,
-0.4784221351146698,
-0.42707309126853943,
-0.7577889561653137,
-0.46859583258628845,
0.08144593983888626,
0.1458304077386856,
-0.0023949146270751953,
0.17033208906650543,
0.2327461540699005,
0.21927577257156372,
-0.24970881640911102,
-0.4517783522605896,
0.07721525430679321,
-0.46641531586647034,
0.765265166759491,
0.39609432220458984,
0.5380937457084656,
0.44601795077323914,
-0.48395225405693054,
0.51975417137146,
-0.1262514293193817,
0.4372285008430481,
-0.13417799770832062,
-0.6281090378761292,
-0.3941573202610016,
-0.22291095554828644,
-0.06747501343488693,
0.5271463394165039,
-0.07803460210561752,
0.08784229308366776,
-0.46623408794403076,
-0.623932421207428,
0.036021776497364044,
0.12584859132766724,
-0.24248936772346497,
0.06702885031700134,
0.32201457023620605,
-0.33849018812179565,
-0.26671645045280457,
-1.2714697122573853,
0.2397354245185852,
-0.7401922345161438,
-0.26355066895484924,
0.6316320300102234,
0.11451315879821777,
-0.27841177582740784,
0.7212592959403992,
-0.20856253802776337,
-0.021699432283639908,
0.049663983285427094,
0.4941542446613312,
0.22679519653320312,
0.390636146068573,
0.9198760390281677,
-1.1039624214172363,
0.15134213864803314,
-0.12949448823928833,
-0.4079801142215729,
-0.5046676993370056,
-0.019904911518096924,
0.07990150153636932,
0.24100996553897858,
0.5731343030929565,
-0.3075791299343109,
0.2948797047138214,
0.5838710069656372,
-0.282995343208313,
0.2653481066226959,
0.10832325369119644,
0.4854413568973541,
-0.7838524580001831,
-0.008301439695060253,
0.2593746483325958,
-0.003193589625880122,
-0.685190737247467,
-0.9878293871879578,
-0.2254088968038559,
-0.26550957560539246,
-0.5123027563095093,
0.23333740234375,
-0.4678567051887512,
0.022878654301166534,
0.12156166881322861,
0.5488085746765137,
-0.10115627944469452,
0.33156517148017883,
0.18638034164905548,
0.7386186122894287,
0.09326966851949692,
-0.2910291254520416,
0.13659636676311493,
0.271867036819458,
-0.012478901073336601,
0.7176872491836548,
-0.49593645334243774,
0.2796556055545807,
-0.47680458426475525,
0.18476539850234985,
-1.3409940004348755,
0.1773756742477417,
-0.04275190457701683,
-0.69447922706604,
0.5706619620323181,
-0.22979193925857544,
0.1110047698020935,
-0.38057491183280945,
-0.093121238052845,
0.4641822278499603,
0.3206908106803894,
0.05616288632154465,
0.7343854308128357,
0.06452677398920059,
-0.8531370162963867,
-0.334316223859787,
-0.3626258075237274,
0.18923065066337585,
-0.4768810570240021,
-0.9558552503585815,
0.28494498133659363,
-0.2875899076461792,
-0.4037227928638458,
-0.1474558562040329,
-0.5341184139251709,
-0.38325467705726624,
-0.28049030900001526,
0.11308564245700836,
0.05768595635890961,
-0.37611594796180725,
0.1143699586391449,
0.01942174881696701,
0.2798435688018799,
-0.31324148178100586,
-0.001153340796008706,
0.5978370308876038,
-0.02222670055925846,
0.07729460299015045,
-0.40211281180381775,
0.38384512066841125,
0.8252829909324646,
-0.20847542583942413,
0.45798200368881226,
0.5445985794067383,
-0.38949161767959595,
-0.3004208505153656,
-0.7677253484725952,
-0.30871617794036865,
-0.37237873673439026,
0.04717487841844559,
-0.45091959834098816,
-0.7669973969459534,
0.6664425134658813,
0.1419380009174347,
-0.2778588831424713,
0.9384351372718811,
0.568087100982666,
-0.24963299930095673,
0.7831798195838928,
0.3281271755695343,
0.2479136735200882,
0.7148698568344116,
-0.5685441493988037,
-0.19665473699569702,
-0.5663825273513794,
-0.464799702167511,
-0.7079171538352966,
-0.10994018614292145,
-0.9632461071014404,
-0.40974023938179016,
0.15116992592811584,
0.18282939493656158,
-0.29662322998046875,
0.2215188443660736,
-0.25365743041038513,
-0.10168258845806122,
0.04142642021179199,
-0.007045916747301817,
0.002160199685022235,
-0.03173310309648514,
0.3180174231529236,
-0.2363557666540146,
-0.4719270169734955,
-0.5465829968452454,
0.6467562317848206,
0.6950334906578064,
0.707611620426178,
0.5972923636436462,
0.22023634612560272,
0.9317731261253357,
-0.1224282756447792,
-0.1872965693473816,
0.4025413691997528,
-0.7012799978256226,
-0.8029206991195679,
-0.5180591940879822,
-0.37469983100891113,
-0.7874763607978821,
-0.05619022250175476,
0.0036257547326385975,
-0.817267894744873,
1.2085115909576416,
-0.22545045614242554,
-0.3511010408401489,
0.01910261996090412,
-0.22648192942142487,
0.640557050704956,
-0.14670589566230774,
-0.1631503701210022,
0.03382300212979317,
-0.7374352812767029,
0.23138414323329926,
-0.27413398027420044,
0.4668053984642029,
-0.4320223033428192,
0.12045304477214813,
0.8127087354660034,
-0.07798605412244797,
0.7472310066223145,
-0.2802535891532898,
-0.2314172387123108,
0.3680793344974518,
0.3564727008342743,
-0.183103546500206,
0.12368304282426834,
0.37075430154800415,
0.20003701746463776,
0.1885616034269333,
-0.08478309959173203,
-0.48116475343704224,
0.6582573652267456,
-1.1951370239257812,
-0.48906487226486206,
-0.0921768993139267,
-0.2098199725151062,
-0.17043466866016388,
-0.15591686964035034,
0.4500022530555725,
1.323562741279602,
-0.32099926471710205,
0.5578609704971313,
0.4762628376483917,
-0.52736896276474,
0.6750385761260986,
0.5297511219978333,
-0.14472804963588715,
-0.5757405757904053,
0.32373109459877014,
0.26358306407928467,
0.5193151831626892,
0.5701737999916077,
0.261025995016098,
-0.5237313508987427,
-0.22980253398418427,
-0.3453085720539093,
0.4987088143825531,
-0.7430126667022705,
0.3046847879886627,
-0.6363080143928528,
-0.306568443775177,
-0.3254537880420685,
0.39201101660728455,
-0.3367448151111603,
-0.6314849257469177,
-0.2447688728570938,
0.18813082575798035,
0.10223577916622162,
0.25597327947616577,
-0.014022805728018284,
0.2690573036670685,
-0.7458609938621521,
0.434464693069458,
0.6117357015609741,
-0.053514514118433,
-0.44065210223197937,
-0.6966713070869446,
0.2400083690881729,
0.03224262222647667,
-0.06519688665866852,
-1.401045560836792,
0.41354402899742126,
0.721527099609375,
0.7319925427436829,
0.1292707622051239,
-0.3231982886791229,
0.15231962502002716,
-0.6938645839691162,
1.1872957944869995,
0.1106041967868805,
-0.8919510841369629,
0.4820641279220581,
-0.8857563138008118,
0.254933625459671,
0.32792213559150696,
0.2218550145626068,
-0.7538450956344604,
-0.14346642792224884,
-0.6815007328987122,
-0.686651885509491,
0.6329662203788757,
0.6806447505950928,
0.3356931507587433,
0.046123623847961426,
0.15868046879768372,
0.15529344975948334,
0.3433153033256531,
-0.26715606451034546,
-0.39601024985313416,
-0.4349680542945862,
0.07064374536275864,
-0.43530964851379395,
-0.10942728817462921,
-0.3107598125934601,
-0.41868728399276733,
0.5841449499130249,
0.11002662777900696,
0.747086763381958,
0.44399356842041016,
-0.10598466545343399,
-0.4741012156009674,
0.5800634026527405,
1.2385236024856567,
1.0593440532684326,
-0.6034668684005737,
0.1775224506855011,
-0.0649678036570549,
-0.6176095604896545,
0.3731691241264343,
0.16422493755817413,
0.15408369898796082,
0.31140077114105225,
0.6235224008560181,
1.116900086402893,
0.3046223521232605,
-0.35139232873916626,
0.45685720443725586,
-0.16617043316364288,
-0.3287438154220581,
-0.7373265027999878,
-0.18080686032772064,
0.011525004170835018,
0.3950985074043274,
0.6265092492103577,
-0.08878224343061447,
0.07690147310495377,
-0.62348872423172,
0.28555750846862793,
-0.20397497713565826,
-0.6488037705421448,
-0.3831104636192322,
0.988636314868927,
0.27655377984046936,
-0.4736485779285431,
0.3726520240306854,
0.21164219081401825,
-0.18134181201457977,
0.47416895627975464,
0.25860416889190674,
1.3593868017196655,
-0.8277322053909302,
0.4867638051509857,
0.06616224348545074,
0.4780949354171753,
0.30373287200927734,
0.07857812941074371,
0.2598247528076172,
-0.8089528679847717,
-0.22289717197418213,
-0.7250344157218933,
-0.09806030243635178,
0.31165120005607605,
-0.529155969619751,
0.19774772226810455,
0.08940672129392624,
-0.5553193092346191,
0.5367569923400879,
-0.2137964814901352,
-0.6725176572799683,
0.4216042459011078,
0.6445139646530151,
0.7675085663795471,
-1.2265427112579346,
0.4075509309768677,
0.49360328912734985,
-0.41549018025398254,
-0.5289949774742126,
-0.1496269851922989,
0.3758501708507538,
-0.23785218596458435,
1.1086574792861938,
-0.242229625582695,
-0.4759577810764313,
0.11591896414756775,
-0.26082268357276917,
-0.5620085000991821,
0.7901073098182678,
0.19432246685028076,
-1.006425380706787,
-0.10598424822092056,
0.13179761171340942,
0.6303812861442566,
-0.5227506160736084,
0.32452887296676636,
0.3468189835548401,
0.3902631998062134,
0.0680045485496521,
-1.2153702974319458,
-0.6329733729362488,
-0.5333238244056702,
0.10966689884662628,
0.2027878612279892,
-0.4997831881046295,
1.1917507648468018,
0.33211761713027954,
-0.5079705715179443,
0.024333171546459198,
0.40380752086639404,
-0.18467341363430023,
0.22095973789691925,
0.9965659379959106,
0.017070967704057693,
0.30379658937454224,
-0.05598596855998039,
0.814694344997406,
-0.24874114990234375,
0.11684942245483398,
0.47245946526527405,
-0.04766351357102394,
0.4812142848968506,
0.009192227385938168,
-0.514093816280365,
0.7614496350288391,
0.7533760666847229,
0.10006998479366302,
0.2687376141548157,
-0.005188027862459421,
-0.3863160312175751,
-0.23487749695777893,
0.021593481302261353,
-0.44622936844825745,
0.6841383576393127,
0.2557460367679596,
-0.7137040495872498,
0.07780782878398895,
0.20171694457530975,
0.12124940752983093,
0.3111429512500763,
0.059738606214523315,
0.4702964127063751,
0.27153676748275757,
0.008101402781903744,
0.8129053115844727,
-0.19804131984710693,
-0.0206450242549181,
-0.5289787650108337,
0.029189374297857285,
-0.2576081156730652,
-0.24324816465377808,
-0.06013113632798195,
-0.44561028480529785,
-0.24207209050655365,
-0.14551801979541779,
-0.51433265209198,
0.09582284092903137,
0.4408145546913147,
-0.6576648950576782,
-0.39790648221969604,
0.4340556859970093,
0.6910548210144043,
0.014645680785179138,
0.17552658915519714,
-0.3354078531265259,
0.20798690617084503,
-0.10233107954263687,
-0.20422977209091187,
-0.35167965292930603,
0.4211854338645935,
-0.34091952443122864,
0.38261842727661133,
0.21423977613449097,
0.2918178141117096,
0.27459028363227844,
0.6091223359107971,
0.45358651876449585,
-0.23393934965133667,
-0.44356998801231384,
-0.7030429244041443,
0.5957047343254089,
-0.016682421788573265,
-0.24370010197162628,
0.5160083770751953,
0.5223397016525269,
0.44257494807243347,
-0.05550747737288475,
0.5513159036636353,
0.048673760145902634,
0.48112568259239197,
-0.5297146439552307,
0.5614503622055054,
-0.5227768421173096,
0.28258299827575684,
-0.6862624287605286,
-1.7634391784667969,
0.14650031924247742,
0.2722671926021576,
-0.29590094089508057,
0.4252186119556427,
0.6037498116493225,
0.630638837814331,
-0.0736154168844223,
0.440259724855423,
0.22424079477787018,
0.16544169187545776,
0.44718798995018005,
0.02040940523147583,
0.9212658405303955,
-0.06851612776517868,
0.06246260553598404,
-0.3883863389492035,
-0.264418363571167,
-0.16618065536022186,
-0.5772399306297302,
-0.6446338891983032,
-0.778541624546051,
-0.4122530519962311,
0.04401414468884468,
0.2530330419540405,
0.5683589577674866,
0.6992911100387573,
-0.5770697593688965,
-0.3629235327243805,
0.48441165685653687,
-0.6320992112159729,
-0.23922401666641235,
-0.1793271005153656,
0.30814117193222046,
0.5146707892417908,
-0.9438419342041016,
0.8279032111167908,
0.25302717089653015,
0.23347117006778717,
-0.4456998407840729,
-0.00922786071896553,
-0.2151249647140503,
0.4798838794231415,
0.3971153795719147,
0.3135982155799866,
-0.72934889793396,
-0.6452959179878235,
0.23306360840797424,
0.07268774509429932,
0.05659608542919159,
0.7810999155044556,
-0.3098825514316559,
0.8603413105010986,
0.6058024764060974,
-0.15763705968856812,
0.6787992119789124,
0.36881616711616516,
0.8341553211212158,
-1.031728982925415,
0.36951565742492676,
0.41542482376098633,
0.215022012591362,
0.5440695881843567,
0.10377297550439835,
0.5370280742645264,
0.8899790048599243,
-0.585455596446991,
-0.8034758567810059,
0.012749649584293365,
-1.1699693202972412,
-0.1664777398109436,
1.0389682054519653,
0.4644957184791565,
0.2868230938911438,
-0.062268998473882675,
-0.22487010061740875,
0.2696538269519806,
-0.5118130445480347,
0.18411995470523834,
0.7406532764434814,
-0.09191304445266724,
-0.7412356734275818,
-1.2705507278442383,
0.5542153716087341,
-0.10836166143417358,
-0.45373988151550293,
-0.2551850378513336,
0.6584013104438782,
0.1588841825723648,
0.5128065943717957,
0.4897753596305847,
-0.3216162323951721,
0.190409854054451,
0.06767715513706207,
0.037912413477897644,
0.43826737999916077,
-0.6966339945793152,
-0.20066295564174652,
0.10193847864866257,
-0.021675297990441322,
-0.054075688123703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16033v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16033v1
|
Cantor: Inspiring Multimodal Chain-of-Thought of MLLM
| 2024-04-24T17:59:48 | 2024-04-24T17:59:48 |
Timin Gao, Peixian Chen, Mengdan Zhang, Chaoyou Fu, Yunhang Shen, Yan Zhang, Shengchuan Zhang, Xiawu Zheng, Xing Sun, Liujuan Cao, Rongrong Ji
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
With the advent of large language models(LLMs) enhanced by the
chain-of-thought(CoT) methodology, visual reasoning problem is usually
decomposed into manageable sub-tasks and tackled sequentially with various
external tools. However, such a paradigm faces the challenge of the potential
"determining hallucinations" in decision-making due to insufficient visual
information and the limitation of low-level perception tools that fail to
provide abstract summaries necessary for comprehensive reasoning. We argue that
converging visual context acquisition and logical reasoning is pivotal for
tackling visual reasoning tasks. This paper delves into the realm of multimodal
CoT to solve intricate visual reasoning tasks with multimodal large language
models(MLLMs) and their cognitive capability. To this end, we propose an
innovative multimodal CoT framework, termed Cantor, characterized by a
perception-decision architecture. Cantor first acts as a decision generator and
integrates visual inputs to analyze the image and problem, ensuring a closer
alignment with the actual context. Furthermore, Cantor leverages the advanced
cognitive functions of MLLMs to perform as multifaceted experts for deriving
higher-level information, enhancing the CoT generation process. Our extensive
experiments demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed framework, showing
significant improvements in multimodal CoT performance across two complex
visual reasoning datasets, without necessitating fine-tuning or ground-truth
rationales. Project Page: https://ggg0919.github.io/cantor/ .
|
[
-0.6995276212692261,
-0.8824729919433594,
0.7040863037109375,
0.2830461859703064,
-0.3794049620628357,
-0.10166420787572861,
-0.3234250545501709,
-0.3417304754257202,
-0.025964289903640747,
0.4761579930782318,
-0.54559326171875,
-0.5643177628517151,
-0.45869550108909607,
0.06767717003822327,
-0.3565215468406677,
0.7794030904769897,
0.1911958009004593,
-0.01284295879304409,
-0.24861140549182892,
-0.1561931073665619,
-0.5209952592849731,
-0.4284207820892334,
-0.3945201337337494,
0.008284824900329113,
0.7978479266166687,
0.1948021948337555,
0.7922736406326294,
0.225068598985672,
0.4481163024902344,
0.3144611716270447,
0.062064073979854584,
0.6328564882278442,
-0.3264198899269104,
0.28244900703430176,
-0.38607218861579895,
-0.3792194724082947,
-0.35332047939300537,
-0.45415574312210083,
0.44170743227005005,
0.48798292875289917,
-0.24402323365211487,
0.058056868612766266,
-0.2860022783279419,
0.8453521728515625,
-1.0480611324310303,
0.2798749804496765,
-0.8347423672676086,
0.2712172865867615,
-0.053877271711826324,
-0.4917377829551697,
-0.6889079213142395,
0.21220822632312775,
0.028336625546216965,
-0.6454550623893738,
-0.14526374638080597,
0.30312514305114746,
0.12764276564121246,
0.30844515562057495,
-0.7469262480735779,
-0.44835251569747925,
-0.6317375898361206,
0.7173609733581543,
-0.30248674750328064,
0.6427327990531921,
0.26276895403862,
0.4735541343688965,
-0.2422478199005127,
-0.7267983555793762,
-0.8491008877754211,
-0.1464720070362091,
0.060002170503139496,
0.18061652779579163,
-0.03974318876862526,
0.0020859360229223967,
0.4080997109413147,
0.09716589748859406,
-0.5718075037002563,
-0.5282219648361206,
-0.440224826335907,
0.08449973165988922,
0.3825218081474304,
0.25129613280296326,
0.26298272609710693,
-0.2408672273159027,
-0.6313909292221069,
-0.11578963696956635,
-0.36311525106430054,
0.06628910452127457,
-0.07561300694942474,
0.13646996021270752,
-0.1016496866941452,
0.5578451752662659,
-0.13725119829177856,
1.010709524154663,
-0.1460399180650711,
-0.13510127365589142,
0.22356915473937988,
-0.3015337586402893,
-0.5766836404800415,
0.3432634770870209,
0.38253864645957947,
0.2627944052219391,
0.36335262656211853,
0.11123259365558624,
-0.0694490447640419,
0.3033282458782196,
0.5112859010696411,
-0.4072650969028473,
-0.3295450806617737,
0.04808444529771805,
-0.6366602182388306,
-0.208783820271492,
0.34176746010780334,
-0.9402028322219849,
-0.5754709243774414,
-0.551613986492157,
0.0422392338514328,
-0.4784400463104248,
-0.4297694265842438,
0.14829504489898682,
-0.23931458592414856,
0.13782688975334167,
0.5616670846939087,
-0.9025948643684387,
-0.08555418252944946,
0.6528766751289368,
0.5892124176025391,
0.022345073521137238,
-0.2903114855289459,
-0.5553895235061646,
0.4879423975944519,
-0.6892790794372559,
0.8694252967834473,
-0.7657333612442017,
-0.2576119899749756,
0.0059509798884391785,
-0.1471651941537857,
-0.09587441384792328,
-0.18374525010585785,
0.496532678604126,
-0.4626637399196625,
0.0026867352426052094,
-0.45629072189331055,
-0.13520684838294983,
-0.2888004183769226,
0.7001931071281433,
-0.6044942140579224,
0.6107745170593262,
-0.12650196254253387,
-0.7919327616691589,
0.5811895132064819,
-0.43455249071121216,
-0.2560020089149475,
0.04836580902338028,
-0.7709372639656067,
0.01935007981956005,
0.3459283709526062,
0.519121527671814,
0.30879324674606323,
-0.25890570878982544,
0.3456657826900482,
-0.6281625032424927,
-0.3304521143436432,
0.4802696108818054,
-0.7799550294876099,
0.8332626223564148,
0.31362318992614746,
-0.48185062408447266,
0.5299388766288757,
-0.8474747538566589,
0.09278382360935211,
-0.09402928501367569,
-0.17510926723480225,
-0.14317984879016876,
0.10032029449939728,
0.09137437492609024,
0.5815649628639221,
-0.11017991602420807,
0.002313390374183655,
0.15347523987293243,
-0.08476744592189789,
0.34287381172180176,
0.970578670501709,
-0.11458607017993927,
0.3350391983985901,
-0.3912259042263031,
0.3296373188495636,
0.24126505851745605,
0.4236529469490051,
-0.26638466119766235,
-0.5563197135925293,
-0.8557119369506836,
-0.5723015666007996,
-0.23014597594738007,
0.34878432750701904,
-1.1821751594543457,
0.19409528374671936,
-0.09418820589780807,
-0.30869460105895996,
-0.2606320381164551,
0.17094580829143524,
0.3318174481391907,
0.4544726014137268,
0.4350915849208832,
-0.0700579360127449,
-0.494549423456192,
-0.8409463763237,
0.09154555201530457,
-0.1771818846464157,
0.3487999141216278,
0.23174229264259338,
0.43547362089157104,
-0.4941922724246979,
0.606774628162384,
-0.3376079499721527,
-0.4345054626464844,
-0.06810002028942108,
-0.05219056457281113,
0.14597877860069275,
0.44118958711624146,
0.32049959897994995,
-1.2145497798919678,
-0.06790179014205933,
0.15573984384536743,
-1.110154151916504,
0.32476383447647095,
-0.4169405996799469,
-0.38829267024993896,
0.4135099947452545,
0.546204149723053,
-0.8373022079467773,
0.576164722442627,
0.395594984292984,
-0.5158352851867676,
0.6650552153587341,
-0.3826615810394287,
0.32575011253356934,
-0.6559387445449829,
-0.0363352932035923,
-0.40601491928100586,
0.009242278523743153,
-0.41660672426223755,
0.23093406856060028,
-0.05727516487240791,
0.12305625528097153,
-0.6531387567520142,
0.5221750140190125,
-0.4392503798007965,
-0.3370206952095032,
0.007028757128864527,
0.1390378773212433,
0.12243081629276276,
0.8438965082168579,
-0.1660967916250229,
0.5873158574104309,
0.724956214427948,
-0.3884968161582947,
0.6036008596420288,
0.22481128573417664,
-0.6771669983863831,
0.6640949249267578,
-0.14918266236782074,
-0.1340177059173584,
-0.28299680352211,
0.45165595412254333,
-0.9912120699882507,
-0.1305004209280014,
0.47705286741256714,
-0.07552449405193329,
-0.02711985632777214,
0.30895066261291504,
-0.7172417640686035,
-0.29091358184814453,
-0.16878251731395721,
0.7768541574478149,
0.20010876655578613,
-0.731772780418396,
0.9934816360473633,
0.13536407053470612,
0.1510285884141922,
-0.5798436403274536,
-0.7935056686401367,
0.26206880807876587,
-0.19829696416854858,
-0.5049816966056824,
0.1613844782114029,
-0.18981070816516876,
-0.5542886853218079,
-0.06680048257112503,
-0.05553431063890457,
0.10741539299488068,
-0.30195456743240356,
0.25385016202926636,
0.42328786849975586,
-0.060534220188856125,
0.5550951957702637,
0.17227181792259216,
-0.12763206660747528,
0.06395810097455978,
-0.520463764667511,
0.4243527948856354,
-0.6132705807685852,
-0.7339063882827759,
-0.33400464057922363,
0.4245609641075134,
1.048763394355774,
-0.46239787340164185,
0.4935150742530823,
0.891645610332489,
-0.2505631744861603,
-0.3015333116054535,
-0.638279914855957,
0.09851344674825668,
-0.4111747741699219,
0.16169556975364685,
-0.7295490503311157,
-0.517073392868042,
0.2893342971801758,
0.034143704921007156,
-0.2653833031654358,
0.1893303245306015,
0.9187412261962891,
-0.14501503109931946,
1.27334725856781,
0.2303944081068039,
0.5323161482810974,
0.46994438767433167,
-0.25309765338897705,
0.2753039300441742,
-0.8649412989616394,
-0.6386629939079285,
0.12362830340862274,
-0.2551932632923126,
-0.43496203422546387,
-0.7197381258010864,
0.6254618763923645,
0.17247578501701355,
-0.3137274384498596,
-0.2914991080760956,
-0.6845820546150208,
0.2931308150291443,
0.553672730922699,
0.3376479148864746,
0.37772828340530396,
-0.021713968366384506,
-0.3390529453754425,
0.32330769300460815,
-0.8375309109687805,
-0.3484274744987488,
1.0073350667953491,
-0.12726011872291565,
0.5704984664916992,
0.2527807950973511,
0.2856292128562927,
0.4275388717651367,
0.21310491859912872,
-0.4545053541660309,
0.6518425345420837,
0.055721722543239594,
-0.585318386554718,
-0.14819075167179108,
-0.19992439448833466,
-0.5885605216026306,
0.8695573806762695,
-0.5486279726028442,
-0.5708063840866089,
0.40932655334472656,
0.16164016723632812,
-0.22956199944019318,
0.2430190145969391,
-0.4647781252861023,
0.8805009722709656,
-0.5264126062393188,
-0.5322508811950684,
-0.5243709683418274,
-0.6681557893753052,
0.7603799700737,
0.05397622659802437,
0.5661843419075012,
0.05598662048578262,
-0.014411911368370056,
0.3708726465702057,
-0.1643243283033371,
0.6700006723403931,
-0.04703154414892197,
-0.15479275584220886,
0.5050040483474731,
0.14974138140678406,
0.2549174726009369,
0.25165730714797974,
0.08359366655349731,
0.07024743407964706,
0.14256934821605682,
-0.33271217346191406,
-0.9991989135742188,
0.6782059073448181,
-0.44189006090164185,
-0.5871516466140747,
-0.37430137395858765,
-0.8223721385002136,
-0.18032541871070862,
0.2223854809999466,
0.07421861588954926,
0.7243529558181763,
0.11615487188100815,
0.32997018098831177,
0.4727485179901123,
-0.13470880687236786,
0.3754081428050995,
-0.33566251397132874,
-0.681522011756897,
-0.7579611539840698,
0.8923159837722778,
-0.10847906023263931,
0.13723939657211304,
0.2894578278064728,
-0.03792272508144379,
-0.3863376975059509,
-0.23677560687065125,
-0.5611105561256409,
-0.10034426301717758,
-1.134117841720581,
-0.04704258590936661,
-0.6399728059768677,
0.011656802147626877,
-0.15793141722679138,
-0.47032397985458374,
-0.056086666882038116,
-0.39161187410354614,
-0.048469848930835724,
-0.05078933387994766,
-0.11484451591968536,
0.4400075376033783,
0.10157959163188934,
-0.1321047842502594,
-0.5610666871070862,
0.5091437697410583,
0.6904708743095398,
0.06673613935709,
0.3658108711242676,
0.18102915585041046,
-0.05355034023523331,
0.13958701491355896,
-0.33553817868232727,
-0.5745779275894165,
0.18355205655097961,
-0.17379608750343323,
0.5859760046005249,
0.7188294529914856,
0.13477623462677002,
1.0011117458343506,
-0.3159361481666565,
0.5897862315177917,
0.5943435430526733,
-0.9848750233650208,
0.45623666048049927,
-0.36687809228897095,
0.3594728410243988,
0.35958337783813477,
-0.14585347473621368,
-0.1592147946357727,
-0.2994033694267273,
-0.49883681535720825,
-0.6077432632446289,
0.22310583293437958,
0.27979111671447754,
-0.13487651944160461,
-0.3225192129611969,
-0.21925732493400574,
0.07437418401241302,
0.49696144461631775,
-0.6460337042808533,
0.2581177055835724,
-0.42920392751693726,
-0.14796334505081177,
-0.06594763696193695,
-0.16455873847007751,
-0.3409249186515808,
-0.6342033743858337,
0.3217582702636719,
-0.2923988997936249,
0.2768310010433197,
0.418414443731308,
-0.2177015244960785,
-0.04705100879073143,
0.37146249413490295,
1.1194159984588623,
1.0701292753219604,
-0.012509433552622795,
0.556114912033081,
0.23456938564777374,
0.2296641618013382,
-0.05864681676030159,
-0.4444583058357239,
0.3779316842556,
-0.28876420855522156,
0.9128974080085754,
0.8819482922554016,
0.4695258140563965,
-1.1134169101715088,
0.556681215763092,
0.004781269934028387,
-0.26679590344429016,
-0.5205992460250854,
0.1826743334531784,
-0.05959941819310188,
0.7327658534049988,
0.2710154354572296,
0.4598102569580078,
0.1623198240995407,
-0.8150359988212585,
0.2643912136554718,
0.4986964166164398,
-0.32995396852493286,
0.0002459738461766392,
0.4848509728908539,
0.007479260675609112,
-0.1834128350019455,
0.8401473760604858,
0.005723501555621624,
-0.44085487723350525,
0.5856163501739502,
0.5495351552963257,
0.6527455449104309,
0.27443140745162964,
0.15018689632415771,
-0.05097407102584839,
0.17112290859222412,
0.038940638303756714,
0.2348131239414215,
-0.6802411079406738,
-0.6364470720291138,
-0.14657200872898102,
-0.4819910526275635,
-0.11602749675512314,
-0.4458397924900055,
-0.6510423421859741,
0.2582469880580902,
-0.6478002667427063,
-0.1651957929134369,
-0.3194018006324768,
-0.5022885799407959,
-0.6689137816429138,
0.20280086994171143,
0.4933261275291443,
0.873975396156311,
-0.3635249733924866,
0.7877190709114075,
0.30636006593704224,
-0.28391554951667786,
-0.3291798233985901,
-0.11713121086359024,
0.03226778283715248,
-0.7601463794708252,
0.9324675798416138,
0.30840879678726196,
-0.38146939873695374,
-0.12576059997081757,
-0.24465465545654297,
-0.5161709785461426,
1.1853888034820557,
0.3255980610847473,
-0.6169601678848267,
-0.21807511150836945,
-0.2998563349246979,
0.4960452616214752,
-0.707909345626831,
0.19880130887031555,
0.2725992798805237,
0.715274453163147,
0.4855472445487976,
-0.5480109453201294,
0.051251161843538284,
-0.32582148909568787,
0.1633758842945099,
0.1212272047996521,
-0.46018075942993164,
1.051243782043457,
-0.44201725721359253,
-0.05322880670428276,
-0.1595187932252884,
0.5953224897384644,
0.6170543432235718,
0.4027100205421448,
0.6956148743629456,
0.5862837433815002,
0.8058195114135742,
0.2603488266468048,
1.078179121017456,
-0.17895574867725372,
0.23083582520484924,
1.0403773784637451,
-0.20202067494392395,
0.9282922744750977,
0.8375586271286011,
0.1371927410364151,
0.8376924395561218,
0.2942480742931366,
-0.013984953984618187,
0.7175740599632263,
0.1342879682779312,
-0.2644118368625641,
-0.6647464036941528,
-0.03459901362657547,
-0.5466101765632629,
0.6959627270698547,
0.5447729825973511,
-0.481478750705719,
-0.14835497736930847,
0.41114044189453125,
-0.5254828333854675,
0.004235294181853533,
-0.3742706775665283,
0.6450433135032654,
0.07593532651662827,
-0.7463563084602356,
0.7094557285308838,
-0.449923038482666,
0.24725928902626038,
-0.3677307665348053,
-0.32625213265419006,
0.32636740803718567,
0.3918197751045227,
-0.1560731828212738,
-0.516676127910614,
0.32944443821907043,
-0.3279162347316742,
-0.2713185250759125,
-0.39708152413368225,
0.5055001974105835,
-0.38115185499191284,
-0.9551979899406433,
0.5182297825813293,
0.4613592028617859,
-0.12360109388828278,
-0.0703132301568985,
-0.6792379021644592,
0.6529929041862488,
-0.22356709837913513,
-0.12284862995147705,
0.03508559614419937,
0.5894119143486023,
-0.2106904685497284,
0.7962753772735596,
0.9135215878486633,
-0.02650166116654873,
0.18968713283538818,
0.10156111419200897,
0.9710787534713745,
-0.638536810874939,
-0.628567099571228,
-1.0238583087921143,
0.6642181873321533,
-0.11223332583904266,
-0.24162760376930237,
0.42691469192504883,
0.2970607876777649,
0.8940272331237793,
-0.18473288416862488,
0.6033639907836914,
0.004145430866628885,
-0.3486841022968292,
-0.8015076518058777,
0.6038483381271362,
-0.649556040763855,
0.20106688141822815,
-0.46983131766319275,
-0.9334264993667603,
-0.532244861125946,
0.8689878582954407,
-0.40340471267700195,
-0.0200534425675869,
0.9755535125732422,
0.6377612352371216,
0.029465198516845703,
0.23264822363853455,
0.5482773184776306,
0.09841082990169525,
0.5166457891464233,
0.8207054138183594,
1.0242228507995605,
-0.04096180945634842,
0.5063865780830383,
-0.043007444590330124,
-0.2921504080295563,
-0.13997839391231537,
-0.7328749895095825,
-1.1587755680084229,
-0.8427950739860535,
0.11754395067691803,
-0.021723950281739235,
0.08966969698667526,
1.1482192277908325,
0.7621564865112305,
-0.5271607041358948,
-0.11366629600524902,
-0.4861985743045807,
0.28645744919776917,
-0.4262918531894684,
-0.2160758525133133,
0.3519555926322937,
-0.5928620100021362,
-0.38788196444511414,
0.26953890919685364,
0.741315484046936,
-0.24868686497211456,
-0.4425295889377594,
-0.2587414085865021,
-0.48569774627685547,
0.05731397122144699,
1.0441806316375732,
-0.3164871633052826,
-1.3909603357315063,
-0.17376255989074707,
-0.3570278584957123,
-0.07605596631765366,
-0.09911032021045685,
1.0419166088104248,
-0.9373391270637512,
0.9412962198257446,
0.4040455222129822,
0.4924585819244385,
0.49595293402671814,
-0.06648337841033936,
0.3579351007938385,
-0.08365249633789062,
0.40153637528419495,
0.09936033189296722,
0.5655899047851562,
0.07641815394163132,
-0.2534337043762207,
0.3324553966522217,
0.2821860611438751,
-0.1310163289308548,
-0.8301359415054321,
0.3956562280654907,
-1.2342932224273682,
-0.6336958408355713,
0.8180636167526245,
0.10966527462005615,
-0.3435918688774109,
-0.0369175486266613,
-0.6205745935440063,
0.0712982788681984,
-0.13172075152397156,
0.928519606590271,
0.800251841545105,
-0.3713807761669159,
-0.5829402208328247,
-0.29673174023628235,
0.3328567147254944,
0.35115328431129456,
-0.8563799858093262,
0.08116371929645538,
0.6272851228713989,
-0.4390715956687927,
0.29961666464805603,
0.5883294343948364,
-0.002977867377921939,
0.412456750869751,
0.3250526785850525,
-0.2890184819698334,
-0.463064581155777,
-0.9545033574104309,
0.013151180930435658,
0.6941530108451843,
-0.24603378772735596,
-0.051400937139987946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16030v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16030v1
|
MoDE: CLIP Data Experts via Clustering
| 2024-04-24T17:59:24 | 2024-04-24T17:59:24 |
Jiawei Ma, Po-Yao Huang, Saining Xie, Shang-Wen Li, Luke Zettlemoyer, Shih-Fu Chang, Wen-Tau Yih, Hu Xu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The success of contrastive language-image pretraining (CLIP) relies on the
supervision from the pairing between images and captions, which tends to be
noisy in web-crawled data. We present Mixture of Data Experts (MoDE) and learn
a system of CLIP data experts via clustering. Each data expert is trained on
one data cluster, being less sensitive to false negative noises in other
clusters. At inference time, we ensemble their outputs by applying weights
determined through the correlation between task metadata and cluster
conditions. To estimate the correlation precisely, the samples in one cluster
should be semantically similar, but the number of data experts should still be
reasonable for training and inference. As such, we consider the ontology in
human language and propose to use fine-grained cluster centers to represent
each data expert at a coarse-grained level. Experimental studies show that four
CLIP data experts on ViT-B/16 outperform the ViT-L/14 by OpenAI CLIP and
OpenCLIP on zero-shot image classification but with less ($<$35\%) training
cost. Meanwhile, MoDE can train all data expert asynchronously and can flexibly
include new data experts. The code is available at
https://github.com/facebookresearch/MetaCLIP/tree/main/mode.
|
[
-0.6827879548072815,
-0.7003320455551147,
0.39777469635009766,
0.14840182662010193,
-0.4301651418209076,
0.39916685223579407,
-0.4184270203113556,
-0.2690417766571045,
0.6835339665412903,
0.4493478536605835,
-0.40901973843574524,
-0.8034836053848267,
-0.5964075922966003,
-0.07438527047634125,
-0.7004699110984802,
0.8563664555549622,
0.23182420432567596,
-0.005413135979324579,
-0.22153793275356293,
0.01817336305975914,
-0.3888864517211914,
-0.3628976345062256,
-0.42439186573028564,
0.16428720951080322,
0.17622989416122437,
0.6794768571853638,
0.7403364181518555,
0.8978584408760071,
0.358536958694458,
0.3058605194091797,
0.19444610178470612,
0.12250501662492752,
-0.6018804311752319,
-0.3176232874393463,
-0.44124433398246765,
-0.5844837427139282,
-0.34520626068115234,
0.02293839305639267,
0.21160580217838287,
0.5325173735618591,
-0.18101197481155396,
-0.24033358693122864,
-0.14202675223350525,
0.5013790130615234,
-0.6340171694755554,
0.15444718301296234,
-1.0672308206558228,
0.07261471450328827,
-0.28150326013565063,
-0.1576947569847107,
-0.18601693212985992,
-0.1601906716823578,
0.32709789276123047,
-0.8040121793746948,
0.5626724362373352,
0.12370340526103973,
0.8915482759475708,
0.4980154037475586,
0.007241875398904085,
0.04610064998269081,
-0.39777398109436035,
1.0471049547195435,
-0.433483362197876,
0.10303021967411041,
0.5464496612548828,
0.37725600600242615,
0.1480957269668579,
-0.4871741831302643,
-0.5874069333076477,
0.39595699310302734,
0.13481074571609497,
0.1329779326915741,
-0.09083502739667892,
-0.07033985108137131,
-0.23013053834438324,
0.3697800934314728,
-0.19864770770072937,
0.33467116951942444,
-0.46205347776412964,
-0.11023198068141937,
0.6048183441162109,
0.07459598034620285,
0.0694434642791748,
-0.0693327784538269,
-0.4238644540309906,
-0.37964028120040894,
-0.45162233710289,
-0.10851801186800003,
0.037126123905181885,
0.15658994019031525,
-0.03357214853167534,
-0.07203453034162521,
-0.07212519645690918,
0.5707477331161499,
0.3877795338630676,
-0.48712968826293945,
0.25717824697494507,
-0.15393686294555664,
0.2210937738418579,
0.07189887762069702,
0.909146785736084,
0.6732035875320435,
0.19459602236747742,
-0.45739537477493286,
0.04465523734688759,
0.07826025784015656,
0.36369892954826355,
-0.6062026023864746,
-0.6677435636520386,
-0.09122743457555771,
-0.2615794241428375,
-0.4432808458805084,
0.5108281373977661,
-1.0789448022842407,
-0.13704991340637207,
-0.33767980337142944,
0.6222921013832092,
-0.4627927839756012,
-0.08370386064052582,
0.008234185166656971,
-0.16497986018657684,
-0.11668699234724045,
0.3213159739971161,
-0.8747836947441101,
0.7644898891448975,
0.5876800417900085,
0.8556297421455383,
-0.7194608449935913,
-0.4276973307132721,
-0.3398425281047821,
0.27223682403564453,
-0.2627880573272705,
1.3844751119613647,
-0.6297689080238342,
-0.5090534687042236,
-0.13507448136806488,
0.07667915523052216,
-0.11246387660503387,
-0.6131169199943542,
0.4826090633869171,
-0.3002898693084717,
0.06383292376995087,
-0.3303166925907135,
-0.5111225843429565,
-0.4192159175872803,
0.14254705607891083,
-0.5637941956520081,
1.0273886919021606,
0.1226491928100586,
-0.8840914368629456,
0.6544697284698486,
-0.2903997600078583,
-0.3630685806274414,
0.09347648173570633,
-0.7043753862380981,
-0.32981690764427185,
-0.28357651829719543,
0.5816592574119568,
0.7165229916572571,
-0.007159379310905933,
0.18960914015769958,
-0.4475420415401459,
-0.32024943828582764,
0.3529299795627594,
0.17615307867527008,
0.09527237713336945,
-0.021515721455216408,
-0.2918252646923065,
0.1593422144651413,
-0.800887405872345,
-0.11429997533559799,
-0.0839497372508049,
-0.10827396810054779,
-0.41596513986587524,
0.21928520500659943,
-0.05800938978791237,
0.0928480252623558,
-0.07659792900085449,
-0.4896887242794037,
0.020354920998215675,
0.047052521258592606,
0.5815972089767456,
0.8223851919174194,
0.03567950055003166,
0.38265088200569153,
-0.2674270570278168,
0.4511173367500305,
0.17124591767787933,
0.00924287736415863,
-0.18942785263061523,
-0.3591201901435852,
-0.708387553691864,
-0.5012370944023132,
0.29248565435409546,
0.4501791000366211,
-0.8385028839111328,
0.7881061434745789,
-0.3473789095878601,
-0.46506816148757935,
-0.5775394439697266,
0.33157142996788025,
0.3750753700733185,
0.7754511833190918,
0.6544228792190552,
-0.7503650784492493,
-0.37128978967666626,
-0.8558784127235413,
0.13051937520503998,
0.21097826957702637,
-0.12489914894104004,
0.4724757671356201,
0.3379269540309906,
-0.23013141751289368,
1.4902968406677246,
-0.9627975821495056,
-0.4943232536315918,
-0.07020457834005356,
0.26901236176490784,
0.06931499391794205,
0.5068983435630798,
0.7438041567802429,
-0.749494731426239,
-0.7016680240631104,
-0.18190431594848633,
-0.3691343069076538,
-0.06784355640411377,
0.1739322990179062,
-0.1560300886631012,
-0.05839766934514046,
0.664125382900238,
-0.1852613091468811,
0.2730157971382141,
0.43220144510269165,
0.07569620758295059,
0.6135968565940857,
-0.061438001692295074,
0.04747506603598595,
-1.075386881828308,
0.030009131878614426,
0.06748192012310028,
-0.42378440499305725,
-0.3748054504394531,
-0.3421948254108429,
-0.35416966676712036,
-0.00551082706078887,
-0.3279552757740021,
0.12366176396608353,
-0.1934349685907364,
-0.16861630976200104,
-0.44996964931488037,
0.2564455270767212,
-0.06581241637468338,
0.6791117191314697,
0.3669309616088867,
0.8386425375938416,
0.9195884466171265,
-0.7335413694381714,
0.08434969186782837,
0.5403369069099426,
-0.4453220069408417,
0.6206587553024292,
-0.6173096895217896,
0.2430150806903839,
-0.0082551259547472,
0.26374515891075134,
-0.8185818791389465,
-0.5330998301506042,
-0.03868037089705467,
-0.3290928602218628,
0.1713879555463791,
-0.08077860623598099,
-0.4896637201309204,
-0.3208754360675812,
-0.5289871692657471,
0.2827812135219574,
0.6611387133598328,
-0.5089491009712219,
0.07900126278400421,
0.8868577480316162,
-0.14851756393909454,
-0.3732959032058716,
-0.73420250415802,
-0.010959194973111153,
-0.2221294492483139,
-0.44054263830184937,
0.6699590682983398,
0.19919851422309875,
0.17337238788604736,
0.27184808254241943,
-0.06753049045801163,
-0.7455450892448425,
-0.029636386781930923,
0.24312588572502136,
0.03991682827472687,
0.027000026777386665,
0.19808916747570038,
0.30126431584358215,
-0.2156205028295517,
-0.18231022357940674,
-0.17298246920108795,
0.4741165339946747,
-0.15791675448417664,
-0.2652401328086853,
-0.23171809315681458,
0.2992429733276367,
0.017449546605348587,
-0.07207956165075302,
0.4841395616531372,
0.8676012754440308,
0.0009195468737743795,
-0.07681669294834137,
-0.6892582774162292,
-0.20393268764019012,
-0.46816688776016235,
0.36785832047462463,
-0.0866817831993103,
-1.0571624040603638,
0.5148830413818359,
-0.08432959765195847,
-0.023417675867676735,
0.4929099678993225,
0.22396230697631836,
-0.1613309532403946,
0.7804730534553528,
0.8493943810462952,
-0.4488907754421234,
0.5712276697158813,
-0.427741140127182,
-0.060933347791433334,
-0.39814963936805725,
-0.1032603532075882,
-0.2883872389793396,
-0.34309816360473633,
-0.29008063673973083,
-0.6849281787872314,
0.6020027995109558,
0.313791960477829,
0.14128319919109344,
0.4135633111000061,
-0.6637113094329834,
0.7231464385986328,
0.5763609409332275,
0.5296725034713745,
0.22931011021137238,
0.23507951200008392,
0.2909540832042694,
-0.11084809899330139,
-0.7770451903343201,
-0.23896905779838562,
0.9199008941650391,
0.2338477075099945,
1.0802271366119385,
-0.3608771562576294,
0.6676523089408875,
0.3218722343444824,
-0.2741768956184387,
-0.8310026526451111,
0.6055330634117126,
-0.6019569635391235,
-0.33918482065200806,
-0.09255865216255188,
-0.13253934681415558,
-0.8605921864509583,
0.09126924723386765,
-0.42083072662353516,
-0.5511881113052368,
0.36946722865104675,
0.381722629070282,
-0.33642852306365967,
0.3044784367084503,
-0.43060290813446045,
0.6528579592704773,
0.030223429203033447,
-0.23037010431289673,
-0.6124445796012878,
-0.9801006317138672,
0.20682770013809204,
-0.211319237947464,
0.30806446075439453,
0.05501578003168106,
-0.0811489075422287,
1.1165307760238647,
-0.572939932346344,
1.1151025295257568,
-0.09939455986022949,
0.39295393228530884,
0.589974045753479,
-0.0880175307393074,
-0.04877464100718498,
-0.345925509929657,
0.3170488774776459,
0.08450281620025635,
0.11102233082056046,
-0.5609396696090698,
-0.47760245203971863,
0.30336982011795044,
-0.804149866104126,
-0.24720105528831482,
0.1699020266532898,
-0.2944040596485138,
-0.20524682104587555,
0.2591284513473511,
0.5439265966415405,
0.5314348340034485,
-0.1308194249868393,
0.2613517940044403,
0.8038354516029358,
0.10370367020368576,
0.3130142092704773,
0.4219745993614197,
-0.05097077041864395,
-0.6671646237373352,
1.3556239604949951,
0.06911859661340714,
0.03059227392077446,
0.32290518283843994,
0.2828688323497772,
-0.05598941072821617,
-0.41857433319091797,
-0.2317250519990921,
0.02945834770798683,
-0.676695704460144,
-0.2537301182746887,
-0.7988024353981018,
0.0812961608171463,
-0.29127469658851624,
-0.5173249840736389,
-0.5602104067802429,
-0.44795092940330505,
-0.44550999999046326,
-0.015257038176059723,
0.5852539539337158,
0.6503766179084778,
-0.03553610295057297,
0.8469921946525574,
-1.1095870733261108,
0.011591476388275623,
0.5076191425323486,
0.16281558573246002,
0.014923210255801678,
-0.3424825668334961,
-0.47809454798698425,
-0.3497674763202667,
-0.46842166781425476,
-0.6604909300804138,
0.21678942441940308,
0.6827707290649414,
0.7042004466056824,
1.123917579650879,
-0.06336576491594315,
0.7310828566551208,
-0.48797479271888733,
0.7697462439537048,
0.26632389426231384,
-1.0491589307785034,
0.3003917336463928,
-0.43722227215766907,
-0.13657404482364655,
1.1053872108459473,
0.6446190476417542,
-0.2730381488800049,
-0.37699177861213684,
-0.5633559823036194,
-0.6086465716362,
0.6547088623046875,
-0.27862343192100525,
-0.1077924445271492,
-0.06654186546802521,
0.25316306948661804,
0.6095719933509827,
0.47266101837158203,
-0.42468181252479553,
0.10672490298748016,
-0.5239530801773071,
-0.3215804696083069,
0.04714289680123329,
-0.09237729012966156,
-0.1946062445640564,
-0.47118517756462097,
0.22260096669197083,
-0.4462776184082031,
0.26088836789131165,
0.1960134655237198,
-0.22616791725158691,
0.13166294991970062,
0.1779489815235138,
0.22179515659809113,
0.7498484253883362,
-0.21318352222442627,
0.30847790837287903,
0.10313259810209274,
-0.5663477182388306,
-0.12687599658966064,
-0.154082253575325,
-0.14393310248851776,
-0.020633844658732414,
0.41557028889656067,
0.7973824143409729,
0.7492387890815735,
-0.7156853079795837,
0.7864731550216675,
0.3232176601886749,
-0.48529279232025146,
0.004539751447737217,
0.21369002759456635,
-0.30418238043785095,
-0.07998663932085037,
0.35372984409332275,
0.10379122942686081,
0.28200972080230713,
-0.5316855311393738,
0.40659067034721375,
0.18293043971061707,
-0.41342228651046753,
-0.7644979953765869,
0.3128257989883423,
0.36477699875831604,
0.16366368532180786,
0.22364307940006256,
-0.2747620642185211,
-1.0291277170181274,
0.29768431186676025,
0.3694060742855072,
0.6838662624359131,
-0.15894865989685059,
0.3158448040485382,
0.14401191473007202,
-0.1408146768808365,
-0.3575544059276581,
0.08940783143043518,
-0.2605043649673462,
-0.8048956394195557,
-0.5481945872306824,
-0.32298457622528076,
-0.6811608672142029,
-0.33865904808044434,
-0.7990013360977173,
0.30141645669937134,
-0.4543938934803009,
-0.11106447875499725,
-0.17383801937103271,
-0.26798033714294434,
-0.5188630223274231,
0.15330399572849274,
-0.10382983833551407,
0.7909440994262695,
-1.1328684091567993,
0.8297492265701294,
0.8762438893318176,
-0.24703700840473175,
-0.5352398753166199,
-0.08061949163675308,
-0.2809908092021942,
-0.814136803150177,
0.45241492986679077,
0.31872090697288513,
-0.05851446092128754,
0.02756364829838276,
-1.1095651388168335,
-0.6650390625,
0.9417775273323059,
0.04638344794511795,
-0.17755365371704102,
0.014561155810952187,
-0.31660646200180054,
0.5808861255645752,
-0.4955311715602875,
0.02960056997835636,
0.6804985404014587,
0.14655733108520508,
0.2638825476169586,
-0.796938955783844,
-0.1671612411737442,
0.09507550299167633,
-0.3704412877559662,
0.04848853871226311,
-0.810335099697113,
1.0898091793060303,
-0.06404166668653488,
-0.29675447940826416,
-0.29698219895362854,
0.7562940716743469,
-0.004620605614036322,
0.25183477997779846,
0.8819004893302917,
0.692517876625061,
0.5838519930839539,
0.25540146231651306,
0.5127153992652893,
-0.2890716791152954,
0.3068719804286957,
1.026692509651184,
0.03346223756670952,
0.9747157692909241,
0.2283441573381424,
-0.5014379024505615,
0.7965970039367676,
0.6308446526527405,
-0.4428775906562805,
0.7952379584312439,
-0.28774964809417725,
-0.03867068514227867,
-0.5392371416091919,
-0.29442641139030457,
-0.1985817700624466,
0.43720144033432007,
0.4647349417209625,
-0.0684821680188179,
-0.31664350628852844,
-0.04994461312890053,
0.07168282568454742,
0.26683884859085083,
-0.35384273529052734,
0.9069961905479431,
0.051347263157367706,
-0.4398697018623352,
0.22572799026966095,
-0.18506452441215515,
1.019484043121338,
-0.32934266328811646,
0.04169387370347977,
0.18917806446552277,
-0.017580671235919,
-0.5591874718666077,
-0.9670745134353638,
0.23970676958560944,
-0.11959569156169891,
-0.18526987731456757,
0.22006094455718994,
0.7127564549446106,
-0.6239606142044067,
-0.3630778193473816,
0.10132276266813278,
0.20910672843456268,
0.6817858219146729,
-0.2360837161540985,
-0.5306064486503601,
-0.15353423357009888,
-0.1523725539445877,
0.3144945502281189,
0.3635439872741699,
0.09913542866706848,
-0.0744331032037735,
0.5316972136497498,
0.3238988220691681,
-0.019928932189941406,
0.1634996235370636,
-0.1986154019832611,
1.379565954208374,
-0.49987471103668213,
-0.7812169790267944,
-0.5959077477455139,
0.08745291084051132,
-0.24370896816253662,
-0.1425614058971405,
0.58790123462677,
0.40523335337638855,
0.794746994972229,
-0.17657539248466492,
0.6731307506561279,
-0.09758022427558899,
0.9316834211349487,
-0.5657404661178589,
0.47230595350265503,
-0.22757549583911896,
-0.3849954307079315,
-0.6406520009040833,
-0.7885799407958984,
-0.07291651517152786,
0.5089675784111023,
-0.4077904522418976,
-0.18747787177562714,
0.6219683885574341,
0.5713034868240356,
-0.2737710177898407,
-0.1019698902964592,
0.06651659309864044,
0.045886557549238205,
0.2712007761001587,
0.4335850477218628,
0.4070877730846405,
-0.1221526488661766,
0.6583547592163086,
-0.5846572518348694,
-0.507969856262207,
-0.33883336186408997,
-0.7303992509841919,
-1.1910555362701416,
-0.5485061407089233,
-0.2799401581287384,
0.3313893675804138,
-0.22112295031547546,
0.9767822623252869,
1.0528512001037598,
-0.8782798647880554,
-0.1768564134836197,
-0.006595835089683533,
-0.06966812163591385,
-0.0742482990026474,
-0.24857182800769806,
0.7007922530174255,
-0.3680020272731781,
-0.5490309596061707,
0.47559475898742676,
0.1973755806684494,
-0.011168314144015312,
-0.24033766984939575,
0.2205483615398407,
0.10374128818511963,
-0.22645294666290283,
0.5272486805915833,
0.3301525413990021,
-0.4670366644859314,
-0.13787584006786346,
-0.10303343832492828,
0.1313304752111435,
0.33559465408325195,
0.7895289659500122,
-0.8427954912185669,
0.5193285346031189,
0.4150538444519043,
0.7575200796127319,
0.4909895658493042,
0.6735259890556335,
0.34645769000053406,
-0.7362515926361084,
0.34258994460105896,
-0.018437698483467102,
0.09898339956998825,
0.2714345455169678,
-0.07608817517757416,
0.45573338866233826,
0.6107839345932007,
-0.6079843044281006,
-0.5899315476417542,
-0.017596960067749023,
-1.2721326351165771,
-0.23752714693546295,
0.8118830323219299,
-0.36913567781448364,
-0.2813727557659149,
-0.19434314966201782,
-0.29400479793548584,
-0.07810575515031815,
-0.7353799343109131,
0.9377051591873169,
0.49446094036102295,
-0.156884104013443,
-0.20855331420898438,
-0.17946048080921173,
0.417727530002594,
0.3916378319263458,
-0.8568392395973206,
-0.47961029410362244,
0.24847733974456787,
0.3390466272830963,
0.3018040060997009,
0.6161105632781982,
0.01854720711708069,
0.0539894700050354,
0.07474876195192337,
0.29041004180908203,
-0.09746653586626053,
-0.3755805492401123,
-0.05598193407058716,
-0.03714566305279732,
-0.0486455075442791,
-0.4563910663127899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16020v1
|
Universal Adversarial Triggers Are Not Universal
| 2024-04-24T17:53:14 | 2024-04-24T17:53:14 |
Nicholas Meade, Arkil Patel, Siva Reddy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work has developed optimization procedures to find token sequences,
called adversarial triggers, which can elicit unsafe responses from aligned
language models. These triggers are believed to be universally transferable,
i.e., a trigger optimized on one model can jailbreak other models. In this
paper, we concretely show that such adversarial triggers are not universal. We
extensively investigate trigger transfer amongst 13 open models and observe
inconsistent transfer. Our experiments further reveal a significant difference
in robustness to adversarial triggers between models Aligned by Preference
Optimization (APO) and models Aligned by Fine-Tuning (AFT). We find that APO
models are extremely hard to jailbreak even when the trigger is optimized
directly on the model. On the other hand, while AFT models may appear safe on
the surface, exhibiting refusals to a range of unsafe instructions, we show
that they are highly susceptible to adversarial triggers. Lastly, we observe
that most triggers optimized on AFT models also generalize to new unsafe
instructions from five diverse domains, further emphasizing their
vulnerability. Overall, our work highlights the need for more comprehensive
safety evaluations for aligned language models.
|
[
-0.1844988465309143,
-0.7716821432113647,
0.2025873214006424,
-0.09269388020038605,
-0.06300897896289825,
-0.5090460181236267,
-0.18376481533050537,
-0.5904775261878967,
-0.5732646584510803,
0.3516169488430023,
-0.4023427665233612,
-0.34274497628211975,
-0.8607911467552185,
-0.14941513538360596,
-0.7414370179176331,
1.2250611782073975,
0.07613566517829895,
-0.3156069219112396,
0.4174942970275879,
-0.38191893696784973,
-0.30878323316574097,
-0.7172510623931885,
-0.5493922233581543,
-0.05052179843187332,
0.20370858907699585,
-0.16409163177013397,
1.1322541236877441,
0.8911410570144653,
0.49893060326576233,
0.24870352447032928,
-0.1333962082862854,
-0.08923589438199997,
-0.4617738127708435,
-0.01806681603193283,
-0.23507335782051086,
-0.5191226005554199,
-0.2819429337978363,
-0.16681747138500214,
0.17327958345413208,
0.31002548336982727,
0.06604109704494476,
-0.0497874952852726,
-0.03931925445795059,
0.7097156047821045,
-0.9922917485237122,
-0.4271569848060608,
-1.1654433012008667,
-0.013254810124635696,
-0.09080763161182404,
0.2737780809402466,
-0.6245067119598389,
-0.6925479173660278,
0.059027817100286484,
-0.724962055683136,
0.12300083041191101,
-0.16680975258350372,
0.7992791533470154,
0.37464264035224915,
-0.7211966514587402,
-0.36869844794273376,
-0.6321648955345154,
0.3365614712238312,
-0.5073270201683044,
-0.21334868669509888,
-0.10995680838823318,
0.020812062546610832,
-0.24297598004341125,
-0.4183720052242279,
-0.34046053886413574,
-0.2889275550842285,
0.0751660093665123,
-0.4295363426208496,
-0.6502926349639893,
0.09739778190851212,
0.190809428691864,
-0.1562557816505432,
-0.40010836720466614,
0.33200111985206604,
-0.19661110639572144,
-0.2594869136810303,
0.6887645125389099,
0.19184784591197968,
0.49788758158683777,
0.16634535789489746,
-0.8050483465194702,
-0.27325350046157837,
-1.0921382904052734,
0.2722349464893341,
0.718913733959198,
0.5938427448272705,
-0.20736375451087952,
0.1799764186143875,
0.4993138313293457,
0.9286261200904846,
0.22909405827522278,
0.40398791432380676,
-0.35073330998420715,
-0.10062244534492493,
-0.0522896908223629,
-0.033212509006261826,
1.2457195520401,
0.27558842301368713,
0.787222146987915,
-0.33633479475975037,
0.02922058291733265,
0.006085697095841169,
0.7832570672035217,
-0.3927866816520691,
-0.2897970676422119,
0.053389694541692734,
-0.09183432161808014,
-0.7403759956359863,
0.3022221028804779,
-0.5756762027740479,
-0.39692145586013794,
0.21007488667964935,
0.6754534244537354,
-0.40601688623428345,
0.024851452559232712,
0.0567447803914547,
0.10868854075670242,
0.10927821695804596,
-0.00250865682028234,
-1.0932515859603882,
0.03325708955526352,
0.8418082594871521,
0.6414608955383301,
-0.30990859866142273,
-0.42282363772392273,
-0.3012925684452057,
0.19318826496601105,
-0.43689051270484924,
0.5642129778862,
-0.2900959849357605,
-0.50715571641922,
0.3363528549671173,
0.013295135460793972,
-0.3786435127258301,
-0.30837759375572205,
0.6679086685180664,
-0.623345136642456,
-0.06292262673377991,
-0.3651970326900482,
-0.23550423979759216,
-0.0946308970451355,
-0.21234165132045746,
-0.6165089011192322,
0.35246068239212036,
-0.14227594435214996,
-0.6906501054763794,
0.31167739629745483,
-0.6741344332695007,
-0.7808520793914795,
-0.575222909450531,
0.1656169295310974,
-0.3363373279571533,
-0.09967310726642609,
0.32971736788749695,
0.07951832562685013,
0.1283373087644577,
0.5117985606193542,
-0.856998085975647,
-0.3352266550064087,
0.3600376546382904,
-0.6113024353981018,
1.090361475944519,
0.3242202401161194,
-0.6697067022323608,
0.471752405166626,
-0.6374093890190125,
-0.2457599639892578,
0.22309444844722748,
-0.2770331799983978,
-0.3190045952796936,
-0.37158215045928955,
-0.1028285101056099,
0.15688978135585785,
0.1052137091755867,
-0.260375052690506,
0.59229975938797,
-0.16640260815620422,
0.27322500944137573,
1.2988970279693604,
-0.020464928820729256,
0.695357084274292,
-0.082148477435112,
0.320176899433136,
-0.08412737399339676,
0.44182348251342773,
0.09852586686611176,
-0.3184303343296051,
-0.5672187805175781,
-0.15038985013961792,
0.2665102481842041,
0.7092193365097046,
-0.31511396169662476,
0.6255040764808655,
0.10310386121273041,
-0.3136630356311798,
-0.48510515689849854,
-0.07612743228673935,
0.7659205794334412,
0.49247997999191284,
0.07115354388952255,
0.06545152515172958,
-0.4498121738433838,
-0.8419313430786133,
-0.710837185382843,
-0.25884780287742615,
0.10016580671072006,
0.05861680954694748,
0.44963961839675903,
0.15817472338676453,
0.43898364901542664,
-0.4369645118713379,
0.10978695750236511,
0.08699607104063034,
0.003055714536458254,
-0.12857173383235931,
0.523247241973877,
0.9792726039886475,
-0.7642725706100464,
-0.2983723282814026,
-0.11678094416856766,
-0.9531787633895874,
0.03638347610831261,
-0.022381192073225975,
-0.29352059960365295,
0.25682857632637024,
0.45697885751724243,
-0.6889488697052002,
0.44891124963760376,
0.46992361545562744,
-0.3975740969181061,
0.5886437892913818,
-0.010128848254680634,
0.15625353157520294,
-1.048564076423645,
0.4296252131462097,
-0.25143346190452576,
0.029695408418774605,
-0.8207146525382996,
0.5771511793136597,
0.2746809720993042,
-0.1885206699371338,
-0.9398385286331177,
0.5272725224494934,
-0.08980363607406616,
-0.02276366390287876,
-0.2405165731906891,
-0.04717326909303665,
-0.2496657818555832,
0.5317617654800415,
-0.4905567467212677,
0.9242189526557922,
0.7339507341384888,
-0.8874632716178894,
0.46412011981010437,
0.521552562713623,
-0.10977867990732193,
0.28371351957321167,
-0.7837005257606506,
0.31875109672546387,
0.19493326544761658,
-0.005978459492325783,
-0.7284576892852783,
-0.3197517991065979,
0.24171824753284454,
-0.3979664444923401,
0.5133534669876099,
-0.32052871584892273,
-0.08827053010463715,
-0.03967586159706116,
-0.34749898314476013,
0.1673797219991684,
0.4790326952934265,
-0.7339852452278137,
-0.10657364875078201,
0.3461461067199707,
0.3161468207836151,
-0.9296084046363831,
-0.48341530561447144,
-0.14204326272010803,
-0.4809016287326813,
-0.7368987202644348,
-0.03907163441181183,
0.16825993359088898,
-0.2275792807340622,
0.12485016882419586,
-0.14185462892055511,
0.26293230056762695,
0.5928026437759399,
0.4629308879375458,
0.3833574056625366,
-0.04674328491091728,
0.0033477346878498793,
-0.15545837581157684,
-0.18932335078716278,
0.06116410717368126,
-0.3602665662765503,
0.1827937215566635,
-0.1783635914325714,
-0.5855104923248291,
-0.2356441766023636,
0.29848966002464294,
0.7004271149635315,
-0.04137476533651352,
1.0099656581878662,
0.4922179579734802,
-0.46863439679145813,
0.1043776348233223,
-0.032621148973703384,
-0.12935398519039154,
-0.4175746440887451,
0.18694622814655304,
-0.45751234889030457,
-1.1191487312316895,
0.752486526966095,
0.14206595718860626,
0.11581141501665115,
0.5657055377960205,
0.4606029987335205,
0.5193518996238708,
1.3593366146087646,
0.7127729058265686,
-0.5227575302124023,
0.485508531332016,
-0.047738514840602875,
0.16822926700115204,
-0.7989643216133118,
0.093956857919693,
-0.6501585245132446,
-0.225732684135437,
-0.5237987041473389,
0.38383254408836365,
0.5855742692947388,
0.34305068850517273,
-0.6491548418998718,
0.7612053751945496,
-0.4845353662967682,
0.5454517602920532,
0.5912601351737976,
-0.2948527932167053,
0.05823008343577385,
-0.12360222637653351,
-0.2786927819252014,
0.3419663906097412,
-0.7242336869239807,
-0.46782365441322327,
1.4315201044082642,
-0.011955094523727894,
0.999617338180542,
0.35284024477005005,
0.38013604283332825,
0.2610124945640564,
0.14989396929740906,
-0.12820781767368317,
0.33403339982032776,
-0.5166462659835815,
-1.0506062507629395,
-0.2424575537443161,
-0.3221825361251831,
-1.1466889381408691,
0.22008153796195984,
-0.3396047055721283,
-1.3333845138549805,
0.2760021686553955,
0.16630388796329498,
-0.5930714011192322,
0.6084799766540527,
-0.8505315780639648,
1.016387701034546,
-0.10388092696666718,
-0.15680159628391266,
0.3424570858478546,
-0.806274950504303,
0.7134577035903931,
-0.17154869437217712,
0.22010846436023712,
-0.15490558743476868,
0.31100767850875854,
0.1910572350025177,
-0.271989643573761,
0.7466475367546082,
0.0423811636865139,
-0.06638902425765991,
0.23043379187583923,
0.4248936176300049,
0.7180847525596619,
-0.23439109325408936,
-0.2677352726459503,
0.07574369013309479,
-0.2957080602645874,
-0.32882440090179443,
-0.5523478388786316,
0.9041035175323486,
-1.0568981170654297,
-0.7859811782836914,
-0.2468189150094986,
-0.4798751473426819,
-0.006700846832245588,
0.08922576159238815,
0.7986156940460205,
0.28020933270454407,
-0.2522740364074707,
-0.09407442063093185,
0.37888211011886597,
0.07918638736009598,
0.4870293438434601,
0.5499178171157837,
0.08579201251268387,
-0.21975505352020264,
0.518638014793396,
-0.17756783962249756,
0.680837869644165,
0.00035874522291123867,
-0.015472738072276115,
-0.28668108582496643,
-0.5746452808380127,
-0.7909241914749146,
-0.3567269742488861,
-0.7000728845596313,
-0.3781101405620575,
-0.4755343496799469,
-0.12240387499332428,
-0.700934648513794,
-0.5407546162605286,
-0.38909757137298584,
-0.5755686163902283,
-0.36787664890289307,
-0.23951858282089233,
0.4448851943016052,
0.5905992984771729,
-0.6091460585594177,
0.2302282750606537,
-1.0342642068862915,
0.3483244478702545,
0.45634812116622925,
0.13940131664276123,
-0.033812347799539566,
-0.6345459818840027,
0.032603051513433456,
0.02076258324086666,
-0.4638814330101013,
-1.035040259361267,
0.21262992918491364,
0.28149983286857605,
0.5288483500480652,
0.6509941816329956,
0.47852861881256104,
0.5145488977432251,
-0.4360552132129669,
0.7097590565681458,
0.1934223473072052,
-1.1041455268859863,
0.7859604358673096,
-0.63071608543396,
0.12660276889801025,
0.4985608160495758,
0.5413525104522705,
-0.22781559824943542,
-0.5132204294204712,
-0.7846484780311584,
-0.8928830623626709,
0.885260283946991,
-0.05135199800133705,
0.24041838943958282,
0.00373623869381845,
0.48741117119789124,
0.2578967213630676,
0.07290016114711761,
-0.6972709894180298,
-0.49258124828338623,
0.10572201758623123,
0.004171295557171106,
0.10463949292898178,
0.014755133539438248,
-0.6332467794418335,
0.30165138840675354,
0.5942350625991821,
-0.15847358107566833,
-0.009977960959076881,
-0.035031091421842575,
-0.029657280072569847,
-0.563519299030304,
0.38745877146720886,
0.5092859864234924,
0.43596985936164856,
-0.050454188138246536,
0.09050378203392029,
0.008281131274998188,
-0.24737586081027985,
0.4900246858596802,
0.2138361781835556,
-0.4999988079071045,
-0.49797025322914124,
0.5884087681770325,
1.0001360177993774,
0.16406945884227753,
-0.29249751567840576,
0.6509992480278015,
-0.04745357856154442,
0.006945753935724497,
0.019749971106648445,
0.5496838092803955,
-0.37883466482162476,
0.1127818152308464,
0.143891379237175,
0.5630063414573669,
0.11774416267871857,
-0.6155725717544556,
0.37310922145843506,
0.6535196304321289,
-0.4976223111152649,
-0.44322293996810913,
1.0335301160812378,
0.26331382989883423,
-0.22829343378543854,
0.44984984397888184,
-0.10878918319940567,
-0.7402917742729187,
0.6363597512245178,
0.6921824216842651,
1.0138882398605347,
-0.3841099441051483,
-0.018931740894913673,
0.2657678723335266,
0.5619812607765198,
-0.0006874629179947078,
-0.22835567593574524,
0.3963471055030823,
-0.7840902209281921,
0.02416263148188591,
-0.3114561140537262,
-0.24639426171779633,
0.1201506108045578,
-0.9568756818771362,
0.08989103883504868,
-0.5338658690452576,
-0.10600953549146652,
0.18916498124599457,
-0.6259223222732544,
-0.23779374361038208,
-0.010181132704019547,
0.0498492605984211,
0.656578540802002,
-1.1544891595840454,
0.6288370490074158,
0.7065374851226807,
-0.07920483499765396,
-0.7650957107543945,
0.03683203458786011,
0.628028154373169,
-1.0682337284088135,
0.33530381321907043,
-0.0036274960730224848,
0.2004527896642685,
-0.2804695665836334,
-0.5972064733505249,
-0.8110715746879578,
0.5564869046211243,
0.8048300743103027,
-0.18625986576080322,
-0.05924331769347191,
-0.07858631759881973,
0.46362122893333435,
-0.2967447340488434,
-0.23676125705242157,
0.5718643665313721,
0.1557227075099945,
0.059951722621917725,
-0.8981078863143921,
0.362222284078598,
-0.1470780074596405,
-0.14792543649673462,
0.6557448506355286,
-0.663283109664917,
0.8701660633087158,
-0.6291508674621582,
-0.2436036914587021,
0.19501200318336487,
0.1444513499736786,
0.11450038850307465,
0.08092859387397766,
0.3550048768520355,
0.8637678623199463,
0.20160552859306335,
-0.1566779464483261,
1.208929419517517,
-0.46111899614334106,
0.23046594858169556,
0.8939328789710999,
-0.24199938774108887,
0.829248309135437,
0.1408684104681015,
-0.24233531951904297,
0.18279212713241577,
0.36880141496658325,
0.03299667313694954,
0.662307620048523,
-0.026787258684635162,
-0.2823464870452881,
-0.3137015104293823,
0.027009477838873863,
-0.4269315004348755,
0.5149521827697754,
0.08792532235383987,
-0.29765117168426514,
-0.21364115178585052,
0.019455712288618088,
0.286129355430603,
0.11786805838346481,
-0.13108593225479126,
0.9863905310630798,
0.09268801659345627,
-0.9400468468666077,
0.8411742448806763,
-0.10847395658493042,
0.4792865216732025,
-0.7153767943382263,
0.3648088276386261,
0.017459897324442863,
0.4585358500480652,
-0.06773991137742996,
-0.6948449015617371,
0.5317252278327942,
0.3043381869792938,
-0.04217308387160301,
0.13827694952487946,
1.0035902261734009,
-0.08429966866970062,
-0.05515483021736145,
0.41274237632751465,
0.005488409660756588,
-0.19288122653961182,
-0.22178354859352112,
-0.7092705368995667,
0.10843338817358017,
0.3722091615200043,
-0.36081016063690186,
0.676093578338623,
0.2566816508769989,
-0.0922321304678917,
0.6694830656051636,
1.0721416473388672,
-0.024851279333233833,
0.3687098026275635,
-0.18499243259429932,
0.8343555331230164,
-0.48566707968711853,
-0.30790403485298157,
-1.0241787433624268,
0.6170714497566223,
0.2338130623102188,
-0.5641998052597046,
0.6102343201637268,
0.13365890085697174,
0.7220712900161743,
-0.1100790947675705,
0.8693503737449646,
-0.012848381884396076,
-0.018354050815105438,
-0.5491045117378235,
0.8447615504264832,
-0.3627835810184479,
0.18045330047607422,
-0.13888061046600342,
-0.657452404499054,
-0.23572063446044922,
0.1258823424577713,
-0.20296762883663177,
-0.203087717294693,
0.4153524935245514,
0.6887460947036743,
0.09250931441783905,
0.1515674591064453,
0.3924279510974884,
0.09870642423629761,
0.32653990387916565,
0.9380666613578796,
0.6034615635871887,
-0.5038497447967529,
0.8897655010223389,
-0.1705198884010315,
-0.14453952014446259,
-0.36616507172584534,
-0.9238007664680481,
-0.7019522190093994,
-0.4926871955394745,
-0.2787204384803772,
-0.5610908269882202,
0.6322295665740967,
0.7176526188850403,
0.6784297823905945,
-1.079875111579895,
0.22766642272472382,
-0.29796236753463745,
0.2975645959377289,
0.05586506426334381,
-0.17591281235218048,
0.5349670052528381,
-0.3145158886909485,
-0.4102875888347626,
0.3201664984226227,
0.1488216519355774,
0.30347299575805664,
0.16880106925964355,
0.1670045405626297,
-0.12529484927654266,
-0.03869989514350891,
0.055260688066482544,
0.7886905074119568,
-0.731231689453125,
-0.6831419467926025,
-0.1483427882194519,
-0.360117107629776,
-0.18539075553417206,
0.660906195640564,
-0.28547343611717224,
0.3397008180618286,
0.32652747631073,
0.5148940086364746,
-0.0663534477353096,
-0.07739938795566559,
0.8487545847892761,
-0.8174248933792114,
0.4348938763141632,
-0.09199663251638412,
0.3774828612804413,
0.18773509562015533,
-0.5111413598060608,
0.47769424319267273,
0.10113490372896194,
-0.6275449395179749,
-0.7808884978294373,
0.6061599254608154,
-0.6149888038635254,
-0.37739071249961853,
1.1726752519607544,
-0.7282557487487793,
-0.2857692241668701,
0.2459305077791214,
0.04660093039274216,
0.4675518870353699,
-0.22204619646072388,
1.0148720741271973,
0.6619221568107605,
-0.21089684963226318,
0.3320358097553253,
-0.21165654063224792,
0.7321763634681702,
0.24317532777786255,
-0.6307700872421265,
0.0038152195047587156,
0.15250104665756226,
0.17693687975406647,
0.22514782845973969,
-0.019008582457900047,
-0.29390817880630493,
0.5236452221870422,
0.2551077604293823,
-0.05486907437443733,
-0.266755074262619,
-0.2770967185497284,
-0.8464418053627014,
0.2799609303474426,
0.05272223427891731,
-0.3215760290622711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16019v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16019v1
|
The PRISM Alignment Project: What Participatory, Representative and Individualised Human Feedback Reveals About the Subjective and Multicultural Alignment of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-24T17:51:36 | 2024-04-24T17:51:36 |
Hannah Rose Kirk, Alexander Whitefield, Paul Röttger, Andrew Bean, Katerina Margatina, Juan Ciro, Rafael Mosquera, Max Bartolo, Adina Williams, He He, Bertie Vidgen, Scott A. Hale
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Human feedback plays a central role in the alignment of Large Language Models
(LLMs). However, open questions remain about the methods (how), domains
(where), people (who) and objectives (to what end) of human feedback
collection. To navigate these questions, we introduce PRISM, a new dataset
which maps the sociodemographics and stated preferences of 1,500 diverse
participants from 75 countries, to their contextual preferences and
fine-grained feedback in 8,011 live conversations with 21 LLMs. PRISM
contributes (i) wide geographic and demographic participation in human feedback
data; (ii) two census-representative samples for understanding collective
welfare (UK and US); and (iii) individualised feedback where every rating is
linked to a detailed participant profile, thus permitting exploration of
personalisation and attribution of sample artefacts. We focus on collecting
conversations that centre subjective and multicultural perspectives on
value-laden and controversial topics, where we expect the most interpersonal
and cross-cultural disagreement. We demonstrate the usefulness of PRISM via
three case studies of dialogue diversity, preference diversity, and welfare
outcomes, showing that it matters which humans set alignment norms. As well as
offering a rich community resource, we advocate for broader participation in AI
development and a more inclusive approach to technology design.
|
[
-0.6549822092056274,
0.011215275153517723,
0.08662496507167816,
0.2177562266588211,
0.1400604248046875,
0.39411458373069763,
-0.35481730103492737,
-0.553207516670227,
0.19818978011608124,
0.44749927520751953,
-0.5246278643608093,
-0.38548845052719116,
-0.3913552463054657,
0.11600019782781601,
-0.2648918926715851,
0.8308858275413513,
0.09321326017379761,
0.48337218165397644,
0.08462255448102951,
-0.189591184258461,
-0.30848929286003113,
-0.3041323721408844,
-0.12321443855762482,
-0.5896720886230469,
0.6337496042251587,
0.7607572674751282,
0.9998829364776611,
0.40864086151123047,
0.4875570833683014,
0.2898433208465576,
0.05000144615769386,
-0.030422626063227654,
-0.5930895805358887,
-0.17255306243896484,
-0.5186389684677124,
-0.49540331959724426,
-0.5148736238479614,
0.2824397683143616,
0.4231203496456146,
0.9452314376831055,
-0.1645788848400116,
0.41862908005714417,
0.5738458633422852,
0.60365891456604,
-0.556669294834137,
0.13494502007961273,
-0.1447676420211792,
0.21651969850063324,
-0.3611235022544861,
-0.03654078394174576,
-0.34255334734916687,
-0.30653616786003113,
0.22501207888126373,
-0.3837265074253082,
0.03561140224337578,
0.15726721286773682,
0.6517934203147888,
0.16352950036525726,
-0.6473049521446228,
-0.22250090539455414,
-0.8430972099304199,
1.0987476110458374,
-0.3949365019798279,
0.29872843623161316,
0.25026631355285645,
0.32972264289855957,
-0.24912101030349731,
-0.23732197284698486,
-0.594241738319397,
0.4019079804420471,
0.025735987350344658,
0.13837368786334991,
0.2628602981567383,
-0.07285086810588837,
-0.3281058371067047,
0.373628705739975,
-0.4339463412761688,
0.2354159951210022,
-0.6018289923667908,
-0.4708643853664398,
0.8138412237167358,
0.31577545404434204,
0.24672584235668182,
-0.18199434876441956,
-0.2996828854084015,
0.0891454666852951,
-0.9157807230949402,
0.2685340344905853,
0.5277243256568909,
0.4217400550842285,
-0.3419937193393707,
0.8084335923194885,
-0.20785725116729736,
0.7700292468070984,
0.21873575448989868,
-0.14455921947956085,
0.35973069071769714,
-0.4187711477279663,
0.23709355294704437,
0.14724373817443848,
0.7769742012023926,
0.7176101803779602,
0.42199769616127014,
-0.16585978865623474,
0.03990563750267029,
0.029791411012411118,
0.06914573907852173,
-0.5741236209869385,
-0.044680386781692505,
0.3071939945220947,
-0.5086270570755005,
0.01669616624712944,
0.2518928050994873,
-0.7238650918006897,
-0.865411639213562,
-0.8786764144897461,
-0.25628718733787537,
0.08493021130561829,
-0.3959216773509979,
0.18752290308475494,
0.04577661678195,
0.6784204244613647,
0.6109697818756104,
-1.0446181297302246,
0.00755335995927453,
1.2071937322616577,
0.495943546295166,
-0.22875189781188965,
-0.6509364247322083,
-0.3320341110229492,
-0.012047894299030304,
-0.35059499740600586,
0.7574462294578552,
-0.7203166484832764,
-0.07915357500314713,
-0.03225679323077202,
0.12697307765483856,
0.4028658866882324,
-0.5931434631347656,
0.017219098284840584,
-0.140752375125885,
0.736926257610321,
-0.6738668084144592,
-0.21281284093856812,
0.13403980433940887,
0.3067970275878906,
-0.39735642075538635,
0.7768791317939758,
0.1858435422182083,
-0.7114982008934021,
0.716713547706604,
-0.4915332496166229,
0.02610040083527565,
0.17069819569587708,
-0.4264174997806549,
0.1087987869977951,
0.07257375866174698,
-0.01652897149324417,
0.25404754281044006,
-0.6423513889312744,
0.4812750220298767,
-0.43179741501808167,
-0.26957738399505615,
0.3882456421852112,
-0.20416586101055145,
0.9428238868713379,
0.31284666061401367,
-0.5313016176223755,
0.3368515968322754,
-0.6395928263664246,
-0.21445594727993011,
-0.3249427080154419,
-0.2975988984107971,
0.03058112971484661,
0.09039217233657837,
0.15072037279605865,
0.4009946584701538,
0.27367591857910156,
-0.7508593797683716,
0.3030586838722229,
-0.3372696340084076,
0.46307143568992615,
0.9281614422798157,
-0.3735635578632355,
0.7585152387619019,
-0.43113839626312256,
0.570748507976532,
0.061019521206617355,
0.45292794704437256,
0.2466719001531601,
-0.5941553115844727,
-0.5530750751495361,
-0.06296761333942413,
0.41135358810424805,
0.4247570037841797,
-0.32415637373924255,
0.43620309233665466,
-0.4177573323249817,
-0.1745900809764862,
-0.7669880986213684,
0.36611488461494446,
0.18485067784786224,
0.44404149055480957,
-0.2097514569759369,
-0.7399669289588928,
-0.4059155583381653,
-1.1033315658569336,
0.053395744413137436,
-0.37508848309516907,
-0.3823758363723755,
0.2403610348701477,
0.24555209279060364,
-0.17861729860305786,
1.4533218145370483,
-0.09485379606485367,
-0.13703280687332153,
-0.16441382467746735,
0.09982459992170334,
0.04908934608101845,
0.2464822232723236,
0.24262943863868713,
-0.8663095831871033,
-0.5303252339363098,
-0.04895200580358505,
-0.6995633840560913,
-0.3064860701560974,
0.10491479188203812,
-0.39728492498397827,
-0.13530926406383514,
-0.056750088930130005,
-0.1214749738574028,
0.0654352530837059,
0.7813907861709595,
-0.5342482328414917,
0.14279553294181824,
0.31288203597068787,
0.2230686992406845,
-1.3436769247055054,
0.0935850664973259,
-0.09283734112977982,
-0.1857820600271225,
-0.39746856689453125,
-0.20126141607761383,
-0.11432082206010818,
-0.15574082732200623,
-0.6369213461875916,
0.6696098446846008,
-0.6450903415679932,
-0.09238152205944061,
-0.068326935172081,
0.3816741108894348,
-0.1160682737827301,
0.30630987882614136,
0.059075817465782166,
0.7785104513168335,
0.3990287482738495,
-0.0544017031788826,
0.530778706073761,
0.5715400576591492,
-0.3698059618473053,
0.9158624410629272,
-0.32294416427612305,
0.10569015145301819,
-0.2813883125782013,
0.2922930419445038,
-0.7865301370620728,
-0.43349477648735046,
0.33838963508605957,
-0.38598379492759705,
0.0051344153471291065,
0.15640437602996826,
-0.21883197128772736,
-0.13357067108154297,
-0.47121933102607727,
0.459186315536499,
0.23410677909851074,
-0.42116859555244446,
0.5454995036125183,
1.0978947877883911,
-0.37038537859916687,
-0.8359742164611816,
-0.5844572186470032,
0.41026684641838074,
-0.0942627489566803,
-0.917208731174469,
-0.04467124864459038,
-0.06669799238443375,
-0.5919809937477112,
-0.10522960126399994,
0.30270880460739136,
0.12142891436815262,
0.13527442514896393,
0.4029218852519989,
0.17175689339637756,
-0.2552197277545929,
-0.054137617349624634,
-0.5182095766067505,
-0.2757505178451538,
-0.20556886494159698,
-0.0685150995850563,
0.8378589153289795,
-0.2719730734825134,
-0.5224294662475586,
-0.33196088671684265,
0.4935486912727356,
0.4451315104961395,
-0.18362493813037872,
0.6480547189712524,
0.39651405811309814,
-0.31276559829711914,
0.04664449021220207,
-0.5392612814903259,
-0.06281303614377975,
-0.41983363032341003,
0.09086761623620987,
0.1318545937538147,
-1.094611406326294,
0.6860916018486023,
0.0694950670003891,
0.27794548869132996,
0.04001985862851143,
0.9014428853988647,
0.02011766843497753,
0.97537761926651,
0.7551407814025879,
-0.4939720928668976,
0.2544238567352295,
-0.02651667594909668,
0.3501644730567932,
-0.9121896028518677,
-0.3233771026134491,
-0.37307658791542053,
-0.876004159450531,
-0.4581475257873535,
-0.36417898535728455,
0.22215089201927185,
0.012299088761210442,
-0.3970267176628113,
0.008161269128322601,
-0.5265803337097168,
0.5336735248565674,
0.5525522828102112,
-0.12230983376502991,
0.25048476457595825,
-0.16357681155204773,
0.3031899631023407,
-0.41252949833869934,
-0.41798752546310425,
-0.6289747357368469,
1.0086252689361572,
0.3829614818096161,
0.9649955034255981,
0.2834653854370117,
0.6102681756019592,
0.2222638875246048,
0.7839088439941406,
-0.7411224246025085,
0.3721471130847931,
0.269814133644104,
-0.7691118717193604,
-0.3376442492008209,
-0.189054936170578,
-1.0095638036727905,
0.34777912497520447,
-0.20829647779464722,
-0.9398910403251648,
0.44854736328125,
0.18671493232250214,
-0.4076741933822632,
0.06658492982387543,
-0.47590258717536926,
0.753361701965332,
-0.29762211441993713,
-0.5297063589096069,
0.033583864569664,
-0.8608307838439941,
0.22556860744953156,
0.027827870100736618,
0.32545721530914307,
-0.22425465285778046,
0.06364153325557709,
0.499754935503006,
-0.2800518572330475,
1.1372957229614258,
-0.09361903369426727,
-0.4730502665042877,
0.17908944189548492,
-0.10240978747606277,
-0.002288123359903693,
-0.08986164629459381,
-0.07840065658092499,
0.23853452503681183,
-0.26651790738105774,
-0.38941490650177,
-0.345398485660553,
0.4437936246395111,
-0.9474123120307922,
-0.6650428771972656,
-0.40336278080940247,
-0.6859859824180603,
-0.35625147819519043,
0.19532707333564758,
0.1821441948413849,
0.4576075077056885,
-0.11182247847318649,
0.47182896733283997,
0.33646419644355774,
-0.23968572914600372,
-0.01862267777323723,
0.5363600254058838,
-0.5043060779571533,
-0.30039146542549133,
0.8671004176139832,
0.026835639029741287,
0.2513652443885803,
0.2369607388973236,
0.21131761372089386,
-0.2308245748281479,
-0.105843186378479,
-0.638359010219574,
0.2920445501804352,
-0.5631930828094482,
-0.15633267164230347,
-0.21899084746837616,
0.07673528790473938,
-0.577830970287323,
-0.3201223313808441,
-0.49790674448013306,
-0.3274737000465393,
-0.10610101372003555,
0.09575498104095459,
-0.2218143492937088,
0.8984202742576599,
-0.1782829910516739,
0.15344132483005524,
-0.7256473898887634,
-0.01049860194325447,
0.10604354739189148,
0.3751368820667267,
-0.12485509365797043,
-0.09536831825971603,
-0.11776871234178543,
0.278409868478775,
-0.42199113965034485,
-0.9733286499977112,
0.21472126245498657,
0.05466507375240326,
0.2902356684207916,
0.46794337034225464,
0.193094402551651,
0.5150240659713745,
-0.20639416575431824,
1.1048507690429688,
0.15838216245174408,
-0.8031150102615356,
0.1379532516002655,
-0.43398481607437134,
0.36078566312789917,
0.6631737351417542,
0.34254205226898193,
-1.034635305404663,
-0.4558505117893219,
-0.05580875650048256,
-0.7639986276626587,
0.6738181710243225,
-0.27618545293807983,
-0.010436651296913624,
0.33749499917030334,
0.137297123670578,
0.09256637841463089,
0.2992008924484253,
-0.7193775773048401,
-0.08581281453371048,
0.036306072026491165,
-0.46176519989967346,
-0.08095642924308777,
-0.15238279104232788,
-0.6952018141746521,
-0.1839793473482132,
0.41503092646598816,
-0.27037039399147034,
-0.11281348019838333,
-0.08125046640634537,
-0.05179950222373009,
-0.39790356159210205,
0.35811853408813477,
0.31756892800331116,
1.0921235084533691,
0.14645452797412872,
0.02079308219254017,
-0.11668114364147186,
-0.20674145221710205,
0.26682379841804504,
-0.22678253054618835,
-0.14745688438415527,
-0.4568188786506653,
0.2488725632429123,
0.42113572359085083,
0.11002349853515625,
-0.5152971148490906,
0.6882309317588806,
-0.35204923152923584,
-0.10576127469539642,
-0.3543635904788971,
-0.05852138623595238,
0.2254123091697693,
0.32021501660346985,
0.10412207990884781,
-0.17551159858703613,
0.10934033244848251,
-0.7267580628395081,
-0.030088048428297043,
0.5206729173660278,
-0.5058304071426392,
-0.4473714530467987,
0.5214570164680481,
0.5339957475662231,
-0.5841996669769287,
0.7752013206481934,
0.024020951241254807,
-0.6213775277137756,
0.16741050779819489,
0.17333628237247467,
0.6265374422073364,
-0.1769351065158844,
0.44478797912597656,
-0.04856787249445915,
0.2209024429321289,
0.03692474961280823,
0.2562430799007416,
-0.2472505122423172,
-0.9622212052345276,
-0.364079087972641,
-0.6901809573173523,
-0.6959477663040161,
-0.2993944585323334,
-0.7821354866027832,
0.3300854563713074,
-0.03132612630724907,
-0.05584507808089256,
-0.21928566694259644,
0.049907393753528595,
-0.5148529410362244,
-0.2660195827484131,
0.40146708488464355,
0.7447968125343323,
-0.9871513843536377,
0.5921592116355896,
0.49693453311920166,
-0.1252332180738449,
-0.8622184991836548,
-0.04446275532245636,
0.6197712421417236,
-0.7359509468078613,
0.6383160948753357,
0.2087540477514267,
-0.15042684972286224,
-0.4873490035533905,
-0.48977530002593994,
-0.9727521538734436,
0.8601329326629639,
0.6018730998039246,
-0.49545297026634216,
-0.0820888876914978,
0.6928965449333191,
0.6337913274765015,
-0.31096136569976807,
0.18483150005340576,
0.5329753756523132,
0.5158988237380981,
0.02665575221180916,
-1.2443974018096924,
-0.31228184700012207,
-0.475420743227005,
-0.07602094858884811,
0.35266393423080444,
-1.0236314535140991,
0.8068568706512451,
0.0780782625079155,
-0.33996251225471497,
-0.020026398822665215,
0.5705293416976929,
0.048776671290397644,
0.06688587367534637,
0.45605581998825073,
0.28247299790382385,
0.7523159384727478,
-0.22870706021785736,
0.9916012287139893,
-0.6131319403648376,
0.200034037232399,
1.0450068712234497,
-0.6462542414665222,
0.5880424976348877,
0.620087206363678,
-0.12936408817768097,
0.3136473298072815,
0.7157195210456848,
0.2149810492992401,
0.22586819529533386,
0.3436068892478943,
-0.13043014705181122,
-0.1592009961605072,
-0.25678232312202454,
-0.35551270842552185,
0.6789368987083435,
0.10331688076257706,
0.03493813797831535,
-0.1697182059288025,
-0.014631547033786774,
-0.18006883561611176,
-0.002180436858907342,
-0.11750400066375732,
0.8519291281700134,
-0.0633261650800705,
-1.0710387229919434,
0.2276770919561386,
-0.35672733187675476,
0.7475632429122925,
-0.35625550150871277,
0.009581540711224079,
-0.348239928483963,
0.4740389287471771,
-0.46695834398269653,
-0.9121078252792358,
0.22611621022224426,
-0.11995537579059601,
-0.33447617292404175,
-0.32779964804649353,
0.054025448858737946,
-0.581222653388977,
-0.3174682557582855,
0.24654020369052887,
0.254223108291626,
0.14650189876556396,
0.2574424743652344,
-0.579278826713562,
0.13302883505821228,
0.1157265454530716,
-0.23948627710342407,
0.564012348651886,
0.3172053396701813,
-0.13301970064640045,
0.6368235349655151,
0.3094244599342346,
0.2966042160987854,
0.0879373624920845,
-0.01389255654066801,
0.7792409658432007,
-0.48268386721611023,
-0.31920844316482544,
-0.5913257598876953,
0.606941819190979,
-0.19231368601322174,
-0.6918749809265137,
0.8815755844116211,
0.637556791305542,
1.072195053100586,
0.3650626838207245,
0.6702854633331299,
-0.057026881724596024,
0.5687366127967834,
-0.1208096444606781,
0.43393978476524353,
-0.4572594165802002,
0.24098065495491028,
-0.09378337860107422,
-1.119794249534607,
-0.3182368576526642,
0.6814465522766113,
-0.40054529905319214,
-0.24992622435092926,
0.15750530362129211,
1.0353353023529053,
-0.01733209937810898,
0.2934249937534332,
-0.1422765851020813,
0.025858042761683464,
0.6537977457046509,
0.28968048095703125,
1.1456432342529297,
0.07824423909187317,
0.21310050785541534,
-0.27248185873031616,
-0.43180909752845764,
0.10977571457624435,
-0.7648620009422302,
-0.3512389063835144,
-0.7069031596183777,
-0.12952086329460144,
-0.5583847165107727,
-0.3283816874027252,
1.3373146057128906,
0.702065110206604,
-0.9108092784881592,
-0.7435995936393738,
0.3413503170013428,
-0.024236511439085007,
0.28940168023109436,
-0.26866596937179565,
-0.0009163593640550971,
-0.0508427694439888,
-0.9020656943321228,
-0.0615183524787426,
0.5539956092834473,
-0.3456220030784607,
-0.8465771079063416,
-0.3308035433292389,
0.19861271977424622,
-0.2229289412498474,
0.3030458390712738,
0.41841623187065125,
-0.762332558631897,
-0.3427902162075043,
-0.009928190149366856,
-0.1630830317735672,
0.18302062153816223,
0.9526433348655701,
-0.3878710865974426,
0.46197620034217834,
0.5938583612442017,
0.4639837145805359,
0.027684418484568596,
0.17907169461250305,
0.9962638020515442,
-0.42283937335014343,
0.42843863368034363,
0.3581544756889343,
0.4510990083217621,
0.6651492714881897,
-0.20309822261333466,
0.4016730487346649,
0.00007851107511669397,
-0.874503493309021,
-0.8244213461875916,
0.37243807315826416,
-0.7952274084091187,
0.00004472213549888693,
1.1057718992233276,
0.04297180101275444,
-0.3374342620372772,
-0.3066848814487457,
-0.4415377676486969,
-0.20403657853603363,
-0.377301961183548,
0.9928572177886963,
0.7964596748352051,
-0.28405851125717163,
-0.0235060416162014,
0.02006162516772747,
0.18061380088329315,
0.30924394726753235,
-0.6675370931625366,
0.21184757351875305,
0.7788299322128296,
0.23295004665851593,
0.4678290784358978,
0.8330198526382446,
-0.28945451974868774,
0.0934595912694931,
-0.34349071979522705,
0.20656375586986542,
0.4885086715221405,
-0.3727979063987732,
-0.41307303309440613,
0.26583099365234375,
0.21382857859134674,
0.2995831072330475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15993v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15993v3
|
Uncertainty Estimation and Quantification for LLMs: A Simple Supervised Approach
| 2024-04-24T17:10:35 | 2024-06-29T02:58:21 |
Linyu Liu, Yu Pan, Xiaocheng Li, Guanting Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, 68T07, 68T50
|
In this paper, we study the problem of uncertainty estimation and calibration
for LLMs. We first formulate the uncertainty estimation problem for LLMs and
then propose a supervised approach that takes advantage of the labeled datasets
and estimates the uncertainty of the LLMs' responses. Based on the formulation,
we illustrate the difference between the uncertainty estimation for LLMs and
that for standard ML models and explain why the hidden neurons of the LLMs may
contain uncertainty information. Our designed approach demonstrates the
benefits of utilizing hidden activations to enhance uncertainty estimation
across various tasks and shows robust transferability in out-of-distribution
settings. We distinguish the uncertainty estimation task from the uncertainty
calibration task and show that a better uncertainty estimation mode leads to a
better calibration performance. Furthermore, our method is easy to implement
and adaptable to different levels of model accessibility including black box,
grey box, and white box.
|
[
0.016935674473643303,
-0.7085720300674438,
0.9885063767433167,
-0.15377840399742126,
0.04280528426170349,
-0.1043933853507042,
-0.2229313850402832,
-0.3982316553592682,
0.030848361551761627,
0.19274629652500153,
-0.7180624604225159,
-0.5916147828102112,
-0.7300084829330444,
-0.13707146048545837,
-0.057391319423913956,
0.5184988975524902,
-0.08013118803501129,
0.3720815181732178,
-0.5713440775871277,
0.22761590778827667,
-0.09079490602016449,
-0.33002349734306335,
-0.5482115149497986,
-0.5218518376350403,
0.6789183616638184,
0.04812966287136078,
0.6265993118286133,
0.2845383882522583,
0.5614593625068665,
0.2417062222957611,
-0.48593756556510925,
0.2064165621995926,
-0.17836815118789673,
0.01641922816634178,
-0.04640804976224899,
-0.9396182298660278,
-0.6062890291213989,
-0.15348674356937408,
0.3177219033241272,
0.9283326268196106,
-0.1123700812458992,
0.5151183009147644,
0.15069392323493958,
0.6387055516242981,
-1.1812758445739746,
0.16821344196796417,
-0.4108901023864746,
0.42394205927848816,
0.21905606985092163,
-0.22073453664779663,
-0.41314399242401123,
-0.2530147135257721,
0.06302536278963089,
-0.8385806679725647,
0.087092325091362,
-0.012611341662704945,
0.4029197096824646,
0.7417245507240295,
-0.6861191987991333,
-0.3560464084148407,
-0.9343289136886597,
1.0141609907150269,
-0.6393669247627258,
0.30837810039520264,
0.5763095617294312,
0.3654617965221405,
-0.23594479262828827,
-0.7864206433296204,
-0.003752707736566663,
-0.05506858229637146,
-0.05287274718284607,
0.35617896914482117,
-0.05743565782904625,
0.24422001838684082,
0.28645068407058716,
0.2994524836540222,
-0.23065342009067535,
0.45578086376190186,
-0.001434829318895936,
-0.448728084564209,
0.6810342073440552,
0.21976743638515472,
-0.40714144706726074,
0.008568956516683102,
-0.6261826157569885,
0.08836305141448975,
-0.7216812372207642,
0.22176901996135712,
0.6535231471061707,
0.1566578894853592,
-0.06191999837756157,
0.5221084356307983,
-0.19716976583003998,
0.7958805561065674,
0.05743401497602463,
-0.3131049871444702,
0.000902531435713172,
-0.12036514282226562,
-0.4710245132446289,
-0.31620490550994873,
0.6317496299743652,
0.10145272314548492,
-0.05778060108423233,
-0.04185156524181366,
-0.49032121896743774,
-0.33674198389053345,
0.2275387942790985,
-0.5196297764778137,
-0.07487636804580688,
0.3682872951030731,
-0.37253472208976746,
-0.5154888033866882,
-0.17252294719219208,
-0.7387062907218933,
-0.5580219030380249,
-0.46317800879478455,
0.8439473509788513,
0.056276388466358185,
-0.0779862031340599,
0.1200513243675232,
0.05542811378836632,
-0.09721726924180984,
0.48527204990386963,
-0.9258821606636047,
0.3626261055469513,
0.4190221130847931,
0.3335261642932892,
-0.3337511718273163,
0.27113860845565796,
-0.13241320848464966,
0.20224030315876007,
-0.46014729142189026,
0.28717389702796936,
-0.039029818028211594,
-0.312505841255188,
-0.04704275727272034,
-0.1225908100605011,
-0.06281555444002151,
-0.5314412117004395,
0.3996073603630066,
-0.8235644102096558,
-0.1472085863351822,
-0.07022096961736679,
-0.8750050663948059,
-0.3551650643348694,
0.28744587302207947,
-0.6456946134567261,
1.0541356801986694,
0.054358143359422684,
-0.7412392497062683,
0.3353513777256012,
-0.3968101143836975,
0.15030118823051453,
-0.024199353531003,
-0.16651548445224762,
-0.4039781391620636,
0.41621342301368713,
0.4716985523700714,
0.5449164509773254,
0.07047401368618011,
0.16099567711353302,
-0.48073768615722656,
-0.48931190371513367,
0.656374454498291,
-0.8459276556968689,
0.8057441115379333,
0.2321736067533493,
0.18651585280895233,
0.12103704363107681,
-0.6090864539146423,
0.25627318024635315,
-0.17360232770442963,
-0.33039212226867676,
-0.14874932169914246,
0.1306348592042923,
-0.2447202503681183,
-0.385484904050827,
0.6100789308547974,
-0.34307780861854553,
-0.002352192997932434,
-0.17186975479125977,
0.2723408639431,
0.6098306775093079,
0.40281006693840027,
0.7326338291168213,
-0.09807112067937851,
0.42793554067611694,
0.09107174724340439,
0.4817986488342285,
0.3704002797603607,
-0.3402462601661682,
-0.5531796813011169,
-0.24422818422317505,
0.6386865973472595,
0.7708237767219543,
-0.5777181386947632,
0.5359609723091125,
0.028967013582587242,
-0.35464584827423096,
-0.3962605893611908,
0.17666693031787872,
0.012191652320325375,
0.5214734077453613,
0.2464657574892044,
-0.006173982284963131,
-0.36396777629852295,
-0.7343685030937195,
0.06265811622142792,
-0.21561190485954285,
-0.5778278112411499,
0.17644773423671722,
0.510987401008606,
-0.19840708374977112,
1.0392223596572876,
-0.5992053151130676,
-0.14592912793159485,
0.23726481199264526,
0.18222548067569733,
0.24389663338661194,
0.46273669600486755,
0.03971582278609276,
-0.8258485794067383,
-0.008855573832988739,
-0.2639426290988922,
-1.0516459941864014,
0.24903997778892517,
-0.06838120520114899,
0.002827746793627739,
-0.18312528729438782,
0.512760579586029,
-0.5371129512786865,
0.8993176817893982,
0.4783342182636261,
0.4924179017543793,
0.5199859142303467,
-0.4063872992992401,
-0.08453265577554703,
-1.0116149187088013,
-0.35753700137138367,
0.11266153305768967,
-0.393879234790802,
-0.659221351146698,
-0.018513858318328857,
0.34487423300743103,
0.3650413751602173,
-0.682499885559082,
0.22892051935195923,
-0.6485981941223145,
-0.4382280111312866,
-0.13068515062332153,
0.13178667426109314,
0.0395374670624733,
0.4538739323616028,
0.12569893896579742,
0.7149204015731812,
0.7655284404754639,
-0.5480844974517822,
0.5578064918518066,
-0.1046779453754425,
-0.5256780385971069,
0.49992382526397705,
-0.5912922620773315,
-0.024502962827682495,
-0.12402462959289551,
0.10106445848941803,
-0.9745771884918213,
-0.22594283521175385,
0.507579505443573,
-0.4149240553379059,
0.6070106029510498,
-0.32026201486587524,
-0.4245102107524872,
-0.3094152808189392,
-0.12959519028663635,
0.30800071358680725,
0.4587383270263672,
-0.30412620306015015,
0.5057265162467957,
0.2437579482793808,
0.2189510613679886,
-0.6057742238044739,
-0.8844553828239441,
-0.12229953706264496,
-0.3882126212120056,
-0.22481568157672882,
0.3015553951263428,
-0.10480593144893646,
-0.26812344789505005,
-0.1125892922282219,
-0.4209648072719574,
-0.38538414239883423,
0.34048914909362793,
0.5495474934577942,
0.12287220358848572,
-0.1935742199420929,
0.4354989230632782,
0.2188146412372589,
-0.11824209243059158,
0.16879524290561676,
0.04853246733546257,
-0.0067321681417524815,
0.0638912171125412,
-0.8784154653549194,
-0.5973730087280273,
0.11777543276548386,
-0.21194885671138763,
0.14173302054405212,
0.43028536438941956,
0.7336388826370239,
-0.7481496334075928,
-0.1780683696269989,
-0.2921087443828583,
-0.4373137652873993,
-0.5079503059387207,
0.30124473571777344,
-0.35164859890937805,
-0.49536773562431335,
0.5587428212165833,
-0.32622089982032776,
-0.3613136410713196,
0.21977286040782928,
0.613182544708252,
-0.739597737789154,
0.9471436142921448,
0.8079946637153625,
0.16646263003349304,
0.31449636816978455,
-0.246053546667099,
0.016719050705432892,
-1.0272600650787354,
-0.22360418736934662,
-0.10495785623788834,
-0.44208836555480957,
-0.28941842913627625,
-0.5099779963493347,
0.502985417842865,
0.35920101404190063,
-0.16819535195827484,
0.03713143989443779,
-0.4658977687358856,
0.20912818610668182,
0.758298933506012,
0.8512697219848633,
0.2548973560333252,
-0.02177431620657444,
0.12369722127914429,
-0.2632059156894684,
-0.6614235043525696,
-0.6977468729019165,
1.2098133563995361,
0.6316642165184021,
1.1890628337860107,
-0.035043928772211075,
0.8431113362312317,
0.27408450841903687,
0.44353869557380676,
-1.022749662399292,
0.3823147118091583,
0.37698328495025635,
-0.7006511092185974,
-0.5018745064735413,
-0.44063806533813477,
-0.8032543063163757,
0.034925129264593124,
-0.1315869241952896,
-1.1585336923599243,
0.36097219586372375,
0.1398523598909378,
-0.7962297797203064,
0.2416282743215561,
-0.783258318901062,
0.5152114629745483,
-0.2271208018064499,
-0.2338704764842987,
0.3215779960155487,
-0.8202571868896484,
0.28179559111595154,
-0.2967499792575836,
0.12883958220481873,
-0.25147661566734314,
-0.49979332089424133,
0.6900779604911804,
-0.2817648947238922,
1.3842147588729858,
-0.1265249252319336,
-0.14148089289665222,
0.5621185898780823,
-0.06829779595136642,
0.5327409505844116,
0.283946692943573,
-0.2980574071407318,
0.21389329433441162,
0.2096720188856125,
-0.2576518952846527,
-0.8051969408988953,
0.31176459789276123,
-0.6731865406036377,
-0.584003210067749,
-0.11671246588230133,
-1.226613998413086,
-0.44078153371810913,
-0.12063655257225037,
0.37785404920578003,
-0.07560396194458008,
0.07678533345460892,
-0.010976990684866905,
0.8390803337097168,
-0.043868906795978546,
0.6307439208030701,
0.20318777859210968,
0.013120918534696102,
-0.24511167407035828,
0.4265788197517395,
0.13204382359981537,
0.39368027448654175,
0.6977517008781433,
-0.04010140523314476,
-0.39048099517822266,
-0.6434276103973389,
-0.24358519911766052,
-0.07473208755254745,
-0.8604423403739929,
-0.3652535080909729,
-0.14023788273334503,
-0.3907904624938965,
-0.2798302173614502,
0.011306586675345898,
-0.2647107243537903,
-0.3800019323825836,
-1.0028375387191772,
-0.3300204575061798,
0.4332341253757477,
0.7830191254615784,
-0.30294734239578247,
0.8503321409225464,
-0.49226611852645874,
0.14186549186706543,
0.5315455794334412,
0.09441392868757248,
-0.44493088126182556,
-0.7151142954826355,
-0.19992826879024506,
0.703278660774231,
-0.30262354016304016,
-1.2753831148147583,
0.35877853631973267,
0.1657382696866989,
0.7627140283584595,
0.39293602108955383,
0.34999382495880127,
0.6473884582519531,
-0.00894126482307911,
0.6600838899612427,
0.030949587002396584,
-0.8799372315406799,
0.5091381072998047,
0.09468823671340942,
-0.03436005488038063,
0.49844977259635925,
0.5154300332069397,
0.28719988465309143,
-0.008598866872489452,
-0.3458859622478485,
-0.6562477946281433,
0.386301726102829,
0.24145609140396118,
0.08028765022754669,
0.55318284034729,
0.6281235218048096,
-0.21738727390766144,
0.4119444787502289,
-0.6958237290382385,
-0.42919641733169556,
0.3376396596431732,
-0.4557555317878723,
-0.21368564665317535,
-0.4240935146808624,
-0.4965716004371643,
-0.15977232158184052,
0.39494970440864563,
-0.18825042247772217,
0.5054463744163513,
0.02931448258459568,
-0.2107677161693573,
-0.23265555500984192,
-0.062001559883356094,
0.3962271213531494,
0.5543832182884216,
-0.7167326807975769,
0.39205628633499146,
0.6368180513381958,
-0.42217838764190674,
0.3112087845802307,
-0.06644249707460403,
-0.36937984824180603,
-0.02684170939028263,
0.3715958595275879,
0.6919734477996826,
0.17809103429317474,
-0.1977151781320572,
0.7191023826599121,
0.09923046082258224,
-0.33636704087257385,
-0.4542054533958435,
0.05479078367352486,
0.2692362070083618,
0.5632320046424866,
0.4298066198825836,
0.20512713491916656,
0.20386551320552826,
0.09023211151361465,
0.2293776124715805,
0.5068211555480957,
-0.6425061225891113,
-0.015842609107494354,
0.8917874097824097,
-0.21330071985721588,
-0.21582674980163574,
0.2849650979042053,
-0.03359478712081909,
-0.1292111724615097,
0.9304872155189514,
0.3345177471637726,
0.6223556995391846,
-0.1528499871492386,
0.1458648443222046,
0.0744771808385849,
0.4482210874557495,
0.016934921965003014,
0.29652220010757446,
-0.12014972418546677,
-0.8816072940826416,
-0.5712924003601074,
-0.5625131726264954,
-0.6462544202804565,
-0.17162710428237915,
-1.211530327796936,
-0.045650165528059006,
-0.02745531126856804,
-0.6591272950172424,
-0.18484309315681458,
0.017415320500731468,
-0.7557419538497925,
0.42343202233314514,
0.11699043959379196,
0.908772349357605,
-0.9974137544631958,
0.7411949634552002,
0.46128299832344055,
-0.2129753977060318,
-0.6945165395736694,
-0.21627144515514374,
-0.03303740173578262,
-1.023214340209961,
0.6050679683685303,
-0.11788817495107651,
0.05232777073979378,
0.14651130139827728,
-0.7786251306533813,
-1.0872089862823486,
1.5322861671447754,
0.4272404909133911,
-0.3543667495250702,
0.08348902314901352,
0.3105788826942444,
0.48927077651023865,
-0.05317145958542824,
0.27066370844841003,
0.32230550050735474,
0.30108407139778137,
0.23010262846946716,
-0.37381863594055176,
-0.1935884803533554,
0.31705793738365173,
0.14133578538894653,
-0.12013435363769531,
-0.08415596187114716,
0.6558439135551453,
-0.3797970414161682,
-0.025610532611608505,
0.24932049214839935,
0.9102745056152344,
0.24427686631679535,
0.44889137148857117,
0.32225388288497925,
0.3406490981578827,
0.8739144802093506,
-0.27251332998275757,
0.8006724715232849,
-0.2884719669818878,
0.6693003177642822,
1.260909914970398,
-0.07134678214788437,
0.9489392638206482,
0.9296703338623047,
-0.5474147796630859,
-0.10156724601984024,
1.3078796863555908,
0.1260526329278946,
0.48488888144493103,
0.5560609698295593,
-0.5711671710014343,
-0.44772475957870483,
0.05833720788359642,
-0.22509539127349854,
0.007790726143866777,
0.7351168394088745,
-0.3671543300151825,
-0.08478900790214539,
0.1053578108549118,
-0.26412513852119446,
-0.3864269554615021,
-0.39095374941825867,
0.5713607668876648,
0.33467748761177063,
-0.18578360974788666,
0.21968847513198853,
-0.06629178673028946,
0.4921088218688965,
-0.40260323882102966,
0.3010249733924866,
-0.1364952176809311,
0.021693862974643707,
-0.3568440079689026,
-0.8566826581954956,
0.08812558650970459,
-0.3662463128566742,
-0.004529740195721388,
-0.27221179008483887,
0.8094812035560608,
-0.49009934067726135,
-0.8265801072120667,
0.04302709177136421,
0.7793902158737183,
0.40494176745414734,
-0.29757389426231384,
-0.4479774832725525,
-0.06592801958322525,
-0.1579362154006958,
-0.5930900573730469,
0.2918110191822052,
0.25599539279937744,
0.1412879228591919,
0.8886841535568237,
0.30436456203460693,
0.08241868764162064,
0.47509801387786865,
-0.2939133644104004,
0.455867737531662,
-0.13031280040740967,
0.2828938066959381,
-0.596981406211853,
0.48832249641418457,
0.15035617351531982,
-0.15341950953006744,
0.6458379030227661,
0.30344757437705994,
0.5063928365707397,
-0.25334519147872925,
0.5089893937110901,
0.305631160736084,
0.3337036073207855,
-0.6722173094749451,
0.5067832469940186,
-0.5762248635292053,
0.4730599522590637,
0.12128683179616928,
-0.8007031083106995,
-0.6106986999511719,
0.6340150237083435,
-0.43724894523620605,
0.14284484088420868,
0.40174400806427,
1.0498172044754028,
-0.07145021110773087,
-0.22817115485668182,
0.5843541622161865,
-0.137721449136734,
-0.175862655043602,
0.7266541123390198,
0.9065712690353394,
-0.6527005434036255,
0.31367167830467224,
-0.7744624614715576,
-0.19294464588165283,
-0.030312011018395424,
-1.1808058023452759,
-0.4323054254055023,
-0.18280328810214996,
-0.5832050442695618,
0.06188475713133812,
-0.17697091400623322,
0.5278139114379883,
0.95107102394104,
-0.8356429934501648,
-0.18912111222743988,
0.08777772635221481,
0.42012181878089905,
-0.363262802362442,
-0.14312805235385895,
0.42172345519065857,
-0.2019430249929428,
-0.8565839529037476,
0.5004568099975586,
0.02325570583343506,
0.5446449518203735,
-0.22264030575752258,
0.006027029361575842,
-0.01033717766404152,
0.1220579519867897,
0.34048667550086975,
-0.08326376229524612,
-0.6704816818237305,
-0.2891455888748169,
0.021223673596978188,
-0.39619308710098267,
-0.09636005014181137,
0.26783207058906555,
-0.5551556944847107,
0.41997650265693665,
0.1938474476337433,
0.4821888506412506,
0.8111758828163147,
0.020175080746412277,
0.3416087031364441,
-1.2373826503753662,
0.20190978050231934,
0.21404561400413513,
0.3641781210899353,
0.12140638381242752,
-0.5254701375961304,
0.617258608341217,
0.02326483651995659,
-0.6317958831787109,
-0.8620630502700806,
0.33749741315841675,
-1.0358279943466187,
-0.13966521620750427,
1.1603606939315796,
-0.45887380838394165,
-0.2610330879688263,
0.03402692824602127,
0.09038618206977844,
0.4030003249645233,
0.07955729216337204,
0.43029534816741943,
0.4750988483428955,
-0.2557917833328247,
-0.27462539076805115,
-0.8983166813850403,
0.36718419194221497,
0.3062039911746979,
-0.7146629691123962,
-0.4371893107891083,
0.32366836071014404,
0.30311939120292664,
0.08734191954135895,
0.24246986210346222,
0.24454540014266968,
-0.0839814692735672,
0.09034695476293564,
0.2650519609451294,
0.06060873344540596,
-0.09270722419023514,
-0.4229951798915863,
0.29105260968208313,
0.011322537437081337,
-0.6972452402114868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15949v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15949v2
|
CORM: Cache Optimization with Recent Message for Large Language Model Inference
| 2024-04-24T16:11:54 | 2024-06-21T11:44:17 |
Jincheng Dai, Zhuowei Huang, Haiyun Jiang, Chen Chen, Deng Cai, Wei Bi, Shuming Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), despite their remarkable performance across a
wide range of tasks, necessitate substantial GPU memory and consume significant
computational resources. Beyond the memory taken up by model weights, the
memory used by the KV cache rises linearly with sequence length, becoming a
primary bottleneck for inference. In this paper, we introduce an innovative
method for optimizing the KV cache, which considerably minimizes its memory
footprint. Upon thorough investigation, we discover that in most Transformer
models, (i) there is a striking similarity between adjacent tokens' query
vectors, and (ii) the attention calculation of the current query can rely
exclusively on the attention information of a small fraction of preceding
queries. Based on these observations, we present CORM, a KV cache eviction
policy that dynamically retains essential key-value pairs for inference without
the need for model fine-tuning. Our validation shows that CORM reduces the
inference memory usage of KV cache by up to 70\% with negligible performance
degradation across six tasks in LongBench. Furthermore, we demonstrate that
CORM is compatible with GQA for further compression rate.
|
[
-0.5717229247093201,
-0.7581613659858704,
0.4326551556587219,
0.03239113837480545,
-0.24362550675868988,
-0.0490155853331089,
-0.4242541193962097,
-0.1501486748456955,
0.05870996043086052,
0.5964202880859375,
-0.5390706658363342,
-0.47732460498809814,
-0.22498862445354462,
-0.452426940202713,
-0.2596616744995117,
0.4840746223926544,
0.02707311511039734,
-0.20675913989543915,
-0.528449296951294,
-0.021796802058815956,
-0.31482499837875366,
-0.46394678950309753,
-0.6534191966056824,
-0.32942450046539307,
0.46221041679382324,
0.3852614760398865,
0.46859267354011536,
0.6918759346008301,
0.5653698444366455,
0.22441373765468597,
-0.2593081593513489,
0.19842767715454102,
-0.811328649520874,
0.6163557171821594,
-0.010486569255590439,
-0.46375247836112976,
-0.34825390577316284,
-0.42680278420448303,
0.5343876481056213,
0.15662388503551483,
-0.2727411389350891,
0.16490496695041656,
-0.23845361173152924,
0.624505877494812,
-1.1074323654174805,
0.18395015597343445,
-0.7216298580169678,
0.14467982947826385,
-0.1478927880525589,
-0.07827365398406982,
-0.8263171911239624,
-0.16632476449012756,
0.1968836486339569,
-0.5592692494392395,
0.44817620515823364,
0.2838010787963867,
0.8124570250511169,
0.6018922924995422,
-0.14177954196929932,
-0.15087422728538513,
-0.9072140455245972,
1.0751075744628906,
-0.4566743075847626,
0.5884301066398621,
0.2117246389389038,
0.46433210372924805,
-0.2582639157772064,
-0.773361086845398,
-0.5701853632926941,
-0.2522772550582886,
0.06455165147781372,
0.24054482579231262,
-0.2595144510269165,
0.31700435280799866,
0.16767896711826324,
0.408471941947937,
-0.5284007787704468,
0.18804006278514862,
-0.08596785366535187,
-0.3487856090068817,
0.28483280539512634,
0.29303455352783203,
0.015732120722532272,
0.04113313555717468,
-0.4551549553871155,
-0.2620829939842224,
-0.9047137498855591,
-0.09564092010259628,
0.15291728079319,
0.1655549854040146,
-0.015216742642223835,
0.24681353569030762,
-0.03328757360577583,
0.3370421230792999,
0.005742398556321859,
0.13443803787231445,
-0.21622397005558014,
-0.030399318784475327,
-0.3558940589427948,
0.030283255502581596,
0.6474176645278931,
0.20293281972408295,
-0.053466759622097015,
-0.4563952088356018,
0.03797133266925812,
0.20261503756046295,
0.42144975066185,
-0.9768178462982178,
-0.40654441714286804,
0.14543555676937103,
-0.0827505961060524,
0.009756210260093212,
-0.1484002321958542,
-1.1242872476577759,
0.024557365104556084,
-0.0050483886152505875,
0.24466173350811005,
0.11565610766410828,
0.0681813582777977,
0.12151741981506348,
-0.07875148952007294,
0.3559049665927887,
0.31240135431289673,
-0.9330068826675415,
0.603851854801178,
0.645412802696228,
0.5982981324195862,
-0.32484835386276245,
0.3077601194381714,
-0.8696051836013794,
0.24987861514091492,
0.04550949111580849,
0.3838031589984894,
-0.6478924751281738,
-0.35751873254776,
-0.2638349235057831,
-0.16624923050403595,
-0.042407311499118805,
-0.6870216727256775,
0.46996599435806274,
-1.089633822441101,
0.06120200827717781,
-0.33274081349372864,
-0.5004152059555054,
-0.24564655125141144,
0.1512955278158188,
-1.0801327228546143,
1.3488290309906006,
0.10401614010334015,
-0.4485180974006653,
0.044844917953014374,
-0.4819323718547821,
-0.23011529445648193,
-0.14791633188724518,
-0.0323655791580677,
-0.6782280206680298,
0.18355663120746613,
0.3736577033996582,
0.313737690448761,
-0.7010563611984253,
0.4308414161205292,
-0.28058260679244995,
-0.3262346088886261,
-0.40074411034584045,
-0.2883901000022888,
0.19600720703601837,
0.2833535671234131,
-0.3923618495464325,
0.008129548281431198,
-0.571146547794342,
-0.0022605478297919035,
0.11277175694704056,
-0.31947237253189087,
-0.3325745165348053,
0.1855410486459732,
-0.1935712993144989,
0.12416635453701019,
0.1557087004184723,
-0.2618146538734436,
0.20567598938941956,
-0.21079052984714508,
0.41754594445228577,
0.5315971970558167,
-0.05051920935511589,
0.7521378397941589,
0.020161928609013557,
0.6970961689949036,
-0.07140223681926727,
0.14244934916496277,
-0.09404007345438004,
-0.13082309067249298,
-1.1577078104019165,
-0.43059465289115906,
0.11832357197999954,
0.38526588678359985,
-0.44573503732681274,
0.23539620637893677,
-0.4043445587158203,
-0.413979172706604,
-0.44519221782684326,
0.06923716515302658,
0.4975680410861969,
0.42557957768440247,
0.5809814929962158,
-0.315658301115036,
-0.5652044415473938,
-0.9122050404548645,
-0.30642780661582947,
-0.045903705060482025,
0.3336515724658966,
0.6145389080047607,
0.37381914258003235,
-0.020042775198817253,
0.8992300033569336,
-0.47466611862182617,
0.2636725604534149,
-0.13053758442401886,
0.05485847592353821,
0.13872916996479034,
0.36358508467674255,
0.21003654599189758,
-0.6960867643356323,
-0.47040367126464844,
-0.16096282005310059,
-0.374113529920578,
-0.1690821796655655,
-0.059938132762908936,
-0.33658745884895325,
0.23352272808551788,
0.6946004629135132,
-0.7553982734680176,
0.3847420811653137,
0.6595114469528198,
0.15537531673908234,
0.48837119340896606,
-0.15993088483810425,
-0.441764771938324,
-0.7256668210029602,
0.06663821637630463,
-0.17931640148162842,
-0.40290841460227966,
-0.39126789569854736,
0.3656448721885681,
0.09113327413797379,
0.18662028014659882,
-0.40365466475486755,
0.943261981010437,
-0.6712124943733215,
0.03681463003158569,
-0.08707699924707413,
-0.08514269441366196,
0.14226801693439484,
0.6411278247833252,
-0.04687536135315895,
0.7481378316879272,
0.23714770376682281,
-0.6637338995933533,
0.305622398853302,
0.1694481372833252,
-0.29565852880477905,
-0.08395304530858994,
-0.3581671714782715,
0.6461978554725647,
-0.061452943831682205,
0.3906369209289551,
-1.0140421390533447,
-0.00999022088944912,
0.18179598450660706,
0.05031878873705864,
0.5449697375297546,
-0.0639662817120552,
-0.46931496262550354,
-0.6545252203941345,
-0.14191149175167084,
0.4989369809627533,
0.687954306602478,
-0.686577558517456,
0.7345290780067444,
0.23091064393520355,
0.10600540786981583,
-0.6715409755706787,
-0.4714171588420868,
-0.06530711054801941,
-0.3112644851207733,
-0.4513818919658661,
0.4444991946220398,
0.0900563970208168,
-0.1903330683708191,
-0.049153562635183334,
-0.41904693841934204,
-0.0527627170085907,
-0.05617644637823105,
0.04322075471282005,
0.06614089757204056,
-0.5192667245864868,
0.18854443728923798,
0.2723122239112854,
-0.13825005292892456,
0.0014759456971660256,
-0.2823193371295929,
1.0205775499343872,
-0.09524945169687271,
-0.41292575001716614,
-0.4547162353992462,
0.18830201029777527,
0.7962589859962463,
-0.19903604686260223,
0.7503795623779297,
0.5851895213127136,
-0.10316373407840729,
-0.1279522180557251,
-0.8877435922622681,
-0.33714529871940613,
-0.5004003047943115,
0.4802829623222351,
-0.2912522256374359,
-1.1696133613586426,
0.6893627047538757,
-0.20949403941631317,
-0.22475410997867584,
0.5237083435058594,
0.780771791934967,
0.20590384304523468,
0.6986440420150757,
0.3325653672218323,
-0.39778631925582886,
0.4153710603713989,
-0.3320276737213135,
0.3160449266433716,
-0.9594702124595642,
-0.2925073802471161,
-0.5507734417915344,
-0.4166610836982727,
-0.5140337347984314,
-0.8227882981300354,
0.2535609304904938,
0.008776884526014328,
-0.5862432718276978,
0.23283353447914124,
-0.40835997462272644,
0.4095606505870819,
0.5583629012107849,
0.22216609120368958,
0.2018086314201355,
0.08216560631990433,
-0.44591885805130005,
-0.14358337223529816,
-0.8598219752311707,
-0.16982527077198029,
0.7493512034416199,
0.13651859760284424,
1.0600248575210571,
-0.11337265372276306,
0.5883790850639343,
0.02684127353131771,
0.22824133932590485,
-0.7075599431991577,
0.5575350522994995,
0.0733398050069809,
-0.670121967792511,
-0.24104341864585876,
-0.49399882555007935,
-0.6997545957565308,
0.3163546025753021,
0.27591627836227417,
-0.825603723526001,
0.04105612635612488,
0.3517620265483856,
-0.30539649724960327,
0.44874680042266846,
-0.4477052390575409,
0.7357131242752075,
-0.16802692413330078,
-0.7327437996864319,
-0.5220965147018433,
-0.7969916462898254,
0.18587234616279602,
-0.09537577629089355,
-0.11513648182153702,
0.05260438099503517,
-0.08729948848485947,
0.4475744366645813,
-0.6245256662368774,
0.7523646354675293,
-0.25102582573890686,
0.14279939234256744,
0.35295844078063965,
-0.015791786834597588,
1.2447189092636108,
-0.11311215162277222,
-0.25327032804489136,
-0.21671779453754425,
-0.3427616357803345,
-0.4006858468055725,
-0.5066014528274536,
0.5834121108055115,
-0.6023165583610535,
-0.7368961572647095,
-0.05213390663266182,
-0.7730523347854614,
-0.02754429541528225,
0.11602216213941574,
0.19170284271240234,
0.18135857582092285,
-0.36393657326698303,
0.4047045409679413,
0.8397893905639648,
-0.5994707345962524,
0.4825071394443512,
0.32952865958213806,
-0.10477455705404282,
-0.24337553977966309,
0.5841270685195923,
-0.2157723307609558,
0.5514209270477295,
0.8116421103477478,
0.37283381819725037,
-0.2792029082775116,
-0.49269214272499084,
-0.15593859553337097,
0.213846817612648,
-0.6026073098182678,
-0.16357514262199402,
-0.8905706405639648,
-0.19692453742027283,
-0.07553939521312714,
-0.15098674595355988,
-0.7311481833457947,
-0.355094313621521,
-0.2466573417186737,
0.20515398681163788,
0.4407670795917511,
0.20841583609580994,
0.30826815962791443,
0.7990335822105408,
-0.7477331757545471,
0.1835826188325882,
0.21018259227275848,
0.03906857594847679,
0.3406786322593689,
-0.4966818690299988,
-0.3553866744041443,
-0.17207884788513184,
-0.4721583425998688,
-0.2313506305217743,
0.6531694531440735,
0.3161010444164276,
0.5397916436195374,
0.5032151341438293,
0.25720182061195374,
0.9107949137687683,
-0.5078948140144348,
0.6113224029541016,
0.134528249502182,
-0.8760629892349243,
0.11660405248403549,
-0.27575239539146423,
0.5265386700630188,
0.42583993077278137,
0.23368673026561737,
-0.44249945878982544,
-0.46434158086776733,
-0.5586360692977905,
-1.1097626686096191,
0.29677218198776245,
0.06717143952846527,
0.4017595648765564,
-0.14223800599575043,
0.38218027353286743,
0.048313967883586884,
0.21632951498031616,
-0.28014039993286133,
-0.21436633169651031,
0.31593379378318787,
-0.04589555412530899,
0.21647711098194122,
-0.45224201679229736,
0.18740962445735931,
-0.6777412295341492,
0.6083957552909851,
0.04201843589544296,
0.5415726900100708,
-0.12891234457492828,
-0.27487772703170776,
-0.16666941344738007,
0.13538013398647308,
0.7239797115325928,
0.36574122309684753,
-0.27267178893089294,
0.17814886569976807,
0.4338315725326538,
-0.7295343279838562,
-0.023847850039601326,
-0.18894191086292267,
0.015405566431581974,
-0.01427481696009636,
-0.19629952311515808,
0.862206220626831,
0.4344521462917328,
-0.5363804697990417,
0.21948738396167755,
-0.1621961146593094,
0.04939698427915573,
-0.24709057807922363,
0.18703493475914001,
0.3920332193374634,
0.422348290681839,
0.22495265305042267,
-0.11828389018774033,
-0.19221848249435425,
-0.04684321582317352,
0.1766710728406906,
0.5731779932975769,
-0.46174052357673645,
-0.34941422939300537,
0.8444231748580933,
0.08493519574403763,
-0.07134126871824265,
0.8864335417747498,
-0.14840932190418243,
-0.7240518927574158,
0.6520950794219971,
0.6253284811973572,
0.953773558139801,
-0.3267989754676819,
-0.2689892053604126,
0.42247849702835083,
0.26514044404029846,
-0.31325799226760864,
0.22418221831321716,
-0.18425600230693817,
-0.6656137108802795,
-0.5064016580581665,
-0.7445235252380371,
-0.448171466588974,
0.38822540640830994,
-0.7829377055168152,
0.3654803931713104,
-0.31395891308784485,
-0.0569041483104229,
-0.3164726495742798,
0.023749224841594696,
-0.8600795865058899,
0.1534605622291565,
0.04651359096169472,
0.9378386735916138,
-0.4336620569229126,
1.019989013671875,
-0.0006921286694705486,
0.1132052019238472,
-0.6485254168510437,
-0.27184247970581055,
-0.02200840227305889,
-0.9332460761070251,
0.6414780616760254,
0.15467610955238342,
-0.15609145164489746,
0.2300330549478531,
-0.5459141731262207,
-0.8566944599151611,
1.0532466173171997,
0.6968430876731873,
-0.9370081424713135,
-0.34487462043762207,
-0.04170393571257591,
0.38525667786598206,
-0.18478509783744812,
0.12165718525648117,
0.4865186810493469,
0.6098235249519348,
0.44223281741142273,
-0.6826187968254089,
0.038660962134599686,
-0.05983304604887962,
-0.07830432802438736,
0.5771237015724182,
-0.8025246858596802,
0.7023693919181824,
-0.12541905045509338,
-0.04390329122543335,
0.32587704062461853,
0.7174888849258423,
0.0567176379263401,
0.14649802446365356,
0.26116400957107544,
1.0119564533233643,
0.9394491314888,
-0.0721815899014473,
1.171819806098938,
-0.2987923324108124,
0.6747495532035828,
1.3090438842773438,
-0.31699103116989136,
0.8365517854690552,
0.6709071397781372,
-0.034272365272045135,
0.3707742393016815,
0.5183442831039429,
-0.057734277099370956,
0.7650824785232544,
0.49874216318130493,
-0.6338557004928589,
-0.3941553235054016,
0.08437871932983398,
-0.32693371176719666,
0.4813131093978882,
0.44473251700401306,
-0.5839104056358337,
-0.3983197808265686,
-0.4271085560321808,
0.2759777009487152,
-0.4939012825489044,
-0.20005913078784943,
0.5767373442649841,
0.252847820520401,
-0.7369441986083984,
0.6224220395088196,
-0.21927128732204437,
0.37065446376800537,
-0.30254992842674255,
0.2421463280916214,
-0.10339436680078506,
0.40906766057014465,
0.15522006154060364,
0.10303520411252975,
0.3025800585746765,
-0.2641146779060364,
-0.3338996171951294,
-0.16542033851146698,
0.7323270440101624,
-0.49339810013771057,
-0.21079662442207336,
0.36639872193336487,
0.3843317925930023,
0.16464051604270935,
-0.2543579041957855,
-0.35233670473098755,
0.0616082102060318,
-0.29205983877182007,
-0.4916607439517975,
0.2760000228881836,
0.21151994168758392,
-0.2062862664461136,
0.6780916452407837,
0.6292755603790283,
-0.008625529706478119,
0.2812056541442871,
-0.03725919499993324,
1.0935758352279663,
-0.64564049243927,
-0.34969112277030945,
-1.2033181190490723,
0.21267591416835785,
0.11759983748197556,
0.16006512939929962,
0.6056000590324402,
0.8465439081192017,
0.5187282562255859,
0.0007103860261850059,
0.7689763307571411,
0.2653413414955139,
0.05993301793932915,
-0.5204857587814331,
0.7411953806877136,
-0.4197637438774109,
0.24228428304195404,
-0.0698770061135292,
-1.1424931287765503,
-0.3403910994529724,
0.32567355036735535,
-0.5092959403991699,
0.036661192774772644,
0.8708972930908203,
1.021888256072998,
-0.27702778577804565,
-0.0022214222699403763,
0.25759372115135193,
0.1116446703672409,
0.4033809006214142,
0.6932879090309143,
0.6692186594009399,
-0.3968845307826996,
0.46138983964920044,
0.022446664050221443,
0.2854611277580261,
-0.5941570997238159,
-1.0871880054473877,
-0.9414100646972656,
-0.23098710179328918,
-0.07246071100234985,
-0.3768354654312134,
0.15983884036540985,
0.7354271411895752,
0.7656461596488953,
-0.767061173915863,
-0.10693289339542389,
-0.29363682866096497,
0.06941439211368561,
-0.03892415761947632,
-0.17719419300556183,
0.4480392038822174,
-0.3634469509124756,
-0.6096311807632446,
0.19265589118003845,
0.5040724277496338,
-0.24855732917785645,
-0.2610751986503601,
-0.3242260217666626,
-0.16122782230377197,
0.08970791846513748,
0.5209321975708008,
0.305528461933136,
-0.8866413235664368,
-0.316423237323761,
0.3003286123275757,
-0.23212900757789612,
0.4348963797092438,
0.8630380034446716,
-0.760141909122467,
0.7977500557899475,
0.5779872536659241,
0.9287929534912109,
1.2746952772140503,
-0.22439175844192505,
0.7769854068756104,
-0.7285199165344238,
0.3286583721637726,
0.3532094657421112,
0.16832736134529114,
0.09137725830078125,
-0.3027932345867157,
0.24541625380516052,
0.2133072465658188,
-0.5773625373840332,
-0.77298504114151,
0.08153948932886124,
-1.1313364505767822,
0.09514041990041733,
1.0409233570098877,
-0.04142012819647789,
-0.49351802468299866,
-0.08258403837680817,
0.122273288667202,
0.5843533277511597,
-0.5533493161201477,
0.6736768484115601,
0.8228275179862976,
0.13295967876911163,
-0.4747059941291809,
-0.7739081978797913,
0.4127713739871979,
0.5515931248664856,
-0.5828310251235962,
0.028285130858421326,
0.18356890976428986,
0.004885578062385321,
0.003908728249371052,
0.24697701632976532,
0.015964588150382042,
0.19604487717151642,
-0.1981094628572464,
0.22445090115070343,
0.08769185841083527,
-0.247915580868721,
-0.11404307931661606,
0.060050398111343384,
-0.23653393983840942,
0.01131043303757906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15928v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15928v1
|
Generalization Measures for Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual Transfer
| 2024-04-24T15:38:22 | 2024-04-24T15:38:22 |
Saksham Bassi, Duygu Ataman, Kyunghyun Cho
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A model's capacity to generalize its knowledge to interpret unseen inputs
with different characteristics is crucial to build robust and reliable machine
learning systems. Language model evaluation tasks lack information metrics
about model generalization and their applicability in a new setting is measured
using task and language-specific downstream performance, which is often lacking
in many languages and tasks. In this paper, we explore a set of efficient and
reliable measures that could aid in computing more information related to the
generalization capability of language models in cross-lingual zero-shot
settings. In addition to traditional measures such as variance in parameters
after training and distance from initialization, we also measure the
effectiveness of sharpness in loss landscape in capturing the success in
cross-lingual transfer and propose a novel and stable algorithm to reliably
compute the sharpness of a model optimum that correlates to generalization.
|
[
-0.2932437062263489,
-0.6689165234565735,
0.33584702014923096,
0.18050092458724976,
-0.08934862166643143,
-0.2161070704460144,
-0.4105551242828369,
-0.3252127766609192,
-0.022461766377091408,
0.09329573810100555,
-0.19921347498893738,
-0.6008391976356506,
-0.6482149958610535,
-0.248528391122818,
-0.5711319446563721,
0.9890700578689575,
-0.36407825350761414,
0.038368258625268936,
0.12398063391447067,
-0.2761019766330719,
-0.5774312615394592,
-0.3720375597476959,
-0.45404794812202454,
-0.3825344443321228,
0.6153445243835449,
0.25833073258399963,
0.5778510570526123,
0.4647287428379059,
0.6376045346260071,
0.2207993119955063,
0.3401118516921997,
-0.32558220624923706,
-0.6531491279602051,
0.0037410021759569645,
-0.47239449620246887,
-0.591786801815033,
-0.5080868601799011,
-0.01993924006819725,
1.0080937147140503,
1.0092278718948364,
0.05549445003271103,
0.3358810245990753,
0.1495225578546524,
0.3051668703556061,
-0.6616330146789551,
0.03974920138716698,
-0.5541089773178101,
0.40829646587371826,
-0.08023958653211594,
-0.295071542263031,
-0.23955565690994263,
-0.14949460327625275,
0.3411511778831482,
-0.7882664203643799,
0.34347206354141235,
-0.27375298738479614,
1.0990278720855713,
-0.14735540747642517,
-0.2951262891292572,
-0.011703895404934883,
-1.0232621431350708,
1.2296202182769775,
-0.5491890907287598,
0.654762327671051,
0.3608209788799286,
0.5131469368934631,
0.30733510851860046,
-0.30908069014549255,
-0.20042818784713745,
-0.32512298226356506,
0.044888935983181,
-0.018709275871515274,
-0.4680708348751068,
0.07590623944997787,
-0.07924188673496246,
0.34970730543136597,
-0.501685380935669,
0.15526054799556732,
-0.11514510959386826,
-0.3082049787044525,
0.6739122271537781,
0.08007330447435379,
0.5554107427597046,
0.23612014949321747,
-0.21482668817043304,
-0.3251989483833313,
-0.35909372568130493,
0.2644094228744507,
0.3530479669570923,
0.30878767371177673,
-0.17531932890415192,
0.3484055995941162,
-0.4479653835296631,
0.7942352294921875,
0.043986424803733826,
0.007874400354921818,
0.11182313412427902,
-0.9346503019332886,
-0.18599055707454681,
-0.5406825542449951,
0.5015219449996948,
0.46170544624328613,
0.49227824807167053,
-0.6121459007263184,
-0.20133277773857117,
-0.13261160254478455,
0.05322980135679245,
-0.7383950352668762,
-0.12248902022838593,
-0.25467315316200256,
-0.43407878279685974,
-0.2210405319929123,
-0.23109807074069977,
-0.5037673115730286,
0.27289286255836487,
-0.20411249995231628,
0.49042290449142456,
-0.5562590956687927,
-0.41549867391586304,
0.09210856258869171,
-0.2079893797636032,
0.509792685508728,
0.18530285358428955,
-1.063942551612854,
0.34728601574897766,
0.4867200553417206,
1.025102972984314,
-0.4223233759403229,
-0.3990788757801056,
-0.5538943409919739,
0.07850826531648636,
-0.6766104102134705,
0.5238565802574158,
-0.559719979763031,
-0.11093691736459732,
0.05134270340204239,
0.0022843184415251017,
-0.5355117321014404,
-0.24677059054374695,
0.28419774770736694,
-0.3525181710720062,
0.06654584407806396,
0.08890219777822495,
-0.4966981112957001,
-0.5902283191680908,
0.42674651741981506,
-0.31505393981933594,
0.6013217568397522,
0.2597457468509674,
-0.4754297137260437,
0.6065369844436646,
-0.5771899223327637,
-0.49343323707580566,
0.014277296140789986,
0.16368333995342255,
-0.2862982153892517,
0.46389827132225037,
0.19200797379016876,
0.8023038506507874,
-0.09553579986095428,
0.23975977301597595,
-0.508909285068512,
-0.5777844190597534,
0.000749722181353718,
-0.424796462059021,
0.6393325328826904,
0.009059542790055275,
-0.3348894417285919,
-0.014894925057888031,
-0.5986835360527039,
0.2889116406440735,
0.0019802297465503216,
-0.49677711725234985,
-0.6958795785903931,
-0.44058528542518616,
0.14079464972019196,
-0.12614604830741882,
0.1420331597328186,
-0.35538750886917114,
0.09119357168674469,
-0.3637310564517975,
0.0021607589442282915,
0.31346842646598816,
-0.16633661091327667,
0.6655104160308838,
-0.33461540937423706,
0.6629921793937683,
-0.21980233490467072,
0.08669448643922806,
-0.05743603780865669,
-0.29622671008110046,
-0.8986043930053711,
-0.209712415933609,
0.7899934649467468,
0.8237811923027039,
-0.6602137088775635,
0.231861874461174,
-0.45174288749694824,
-0.6821396350860596,
-0.4345146715641022,
0.16667500138282776,
0.6171267628669739,
0.34450000524520874,
0.17976602911949158,
-0.7465987801551819,
-0.26398542523384094,
-0.8430868983268738,
-0.4624410569667816,
0.029456518590450287,
-0.2634041905403137,
0.21632741391658783,
0.19711273908615112,
-0.25140580534935,
0.5593412518501282,
-0.0385156013071537,
-0.138193279504776,
-0.3432783782482147,
0.4853370487689972,
0.17929328978061676,
0.47659769654273987,
0.9142246842384338,
-0.396401047706604,
-0.6862809062004089,
0.5316171050071716,
-0.7711477875709534,
-0.22557415068149567,
-0.22875359654426575,
-0.1425563097000122,
0.21924513578414917,
-0.01849604956805706,
-0.21078601479530334,
0.3828302323818207,
0.647857129573822,
-0.2658267319202423,
0.5516210198402405,
-0.14660237729549408,
0.560900092124939,
-0.6742297410964966,
0.4955466687679291,
0.12435503304004669,
-0.24889039993286133,
-1.0743509531021118,
0.09110136330127716,
-0.11746647953987122,
0.15288177132606506,
-0.5247507691383362,
0.6938636898994446,
-0.543533980846405,
-0.3506145775318146,
0.0685550644993782,
0.27664270997047424,
-0.1471680849790573,
0.6396297812461853,
0.042732447385787964,
0.5373045802116394,
0.9472940564155579,
-0.6446847915649414,
0.3118653893470764,
-0.11381377279758453,
-0.08614272624254227,
1.0546752214431763,
-0.5826036930084229,
0.11853031069040298,
0.10252217948436737,
-0.352718323469162,
-0.9880823493003845,
0.029619649052619934,
0.21679289638996124,
-0.6871582269668579,
0.48129022121429443,
-0.22535346448421478,
0.08727992326021194,
0.13954709470272064,
-0.30360856652259827,
0.5009105205535889,
0.3803718388080597,
0.026858123019337654,
0.525372326374054,
0.14654101431369781,
-0.20798204839229584,
-0.5669181942939758,
-0.7416080832481384,
0.13435804843902588,
-0.22202187776565552,
-0.6176187992095947,
0.25849243998527527,
-0.03148718178272247,
-0.03352737054228783,
0.018395161256194115,
0.14104188978672028,
-0.32884523272514343,
0.08796346187591553,
-0.09401644021272659,
0.24492640793323517,
-0.3605715036392212,
-0.013515115715563297,
0.18229012191295624,
0.056271743029356,
-0.10024361312389374,
-0.23563025891780853,
0.47357693314552307,
-0.16732525825500488,
-0.39778855443000793,
-0.3512457311153412,
0.2946535348892212,
0.43019917607307434,
0.07894407957792282,
0.3491438329219818,
0.7238138914108276,
-0.263846218585968,
-0.19911392033100128,
-0.3756308853626251,
0.03049742616713047,
-0.2946685552597046,
0.7596611380577087,
-0.6459166407585144,
-0.7305893898010254,
0.77197265625,
0.11257614195346832,
0.19063110649585724,
0.5387303829193115,
0.3533884882926941,
0.24329037964344025,
1.0438916683197021,
1.049543023109436,
-0.24536500871181488,
0.4960247278213501,
-0.25628861784935,
0.27238816022872925,
-0.5706565976142883,
-0.16330426931381226,
-0.3702470362186432,
-0.3774484694004059,
-0.2738870084285736,
-0.45908123254776,
0.04814024269580841,
0.17482909560203552,
-0.003665684722363949,
0.3546226918697357,
-0.13539768755435944,
0.2311306744813919,
0.6411582827568054,
-0.3110664486885071,
0.31287890672683716,
0.3866722583770752,
-0.38343989849090576,
-0.0015974906273186207,
-0.814079225063324,
-0.24469731748104095,
1.1385254859924316,
0.5941070318222046,
0.6702132821083069,
-0.0795680582523346,
0.6114596724510193,
0.25723984837532043,
0.24521401524543762,
-0.9431399703025818,
0.4494859278202057,
-0.35141319036483765,
-0.32397663593292236,
-0.8071147799491882,
-0.6864131093025208,
-0.8899588584899902,
0.33851340413093567,
-0.07602965086698532,
-0.5654757022857666,
0.15316416323184967,
0.13871848583221436,
-0.27520695328712463,
0.3625011742115021,
-0.4766993224620819,
0.8044426441192627,
-0.34474194049835205,
-0.2252771407365799,
-0.24784567952156067,
-0.2899515926837921,
0.3110285997390747,
-0.24075891077518463,
0.03709235042333603,
-0.028097938746213913,
-0.12887735664844513,
0.8733618259429932,
0.04123756289482117,
0.7132302522659302,
-0.21525637805461884,
-0.0478610135614872,
-0.005271055735647678,
0.33327779173851013,
0.01642000302672386,
-0.40211719274520874,
0.15087534487247467,
0.6438024044036865,
0.13131524622440338,
-0.4089018404483795,
-0.8108781576156616,
0.5421884059906006,
-0.687619686126709,
-0.3354906141757965,
0.004620484542101622,
-0.7756063938140869,
-0.3556601107120514,
0.3281501531600952,
0.20209534466266632,
0.1232742965221405,
-0.3764350414276123,
0.15017758309841156,
0.4027068316936493,
-0.1357358694076538,
0.3154117465019226,
0.6994034647941589,
-0.3943883180618286,
-0.23914676904678345,
1.0355054140090942,
0.40886324644088745,
0.4523189961910248,
0.4733756482601166,
0.13357014954090118,
-0.08492152392864227,
-0.8066140413284302,
-0.7080174684524536,
0.016240330412983894,
-0.5400477647781372,
-0.10442595928907394,
-0.2515672445297241,
-0.3290169835090637,
-0.4880051016807556,
-0.24821719527244568,
-0.2599579393863678,
-0.5743831992149353,
-0.16077007353305817,
-0.09701620042324066,
-0.06905774772167206,
0.49237263202667236,
-0.3536969721317291,
0.1312449723482132,
-0.7988051772117615,
0.03152479976415634,
0.3901386260986328,
0.5252619981765747,
0.07757596671581268,
-0.8655978441238403,
-0.39509573578834534,
0.09840122610330582,
-0.06232751905918121,
-0.6557117700576782,
0.36467504501342773,
0.548424243927002,
0.8426585793495178,
0.4209938645362854,
-0.2967422604560852,
0.616226077079773,
-0.22114670276641846,
0.5686789155006409,
0.4536688029766083,
-1.1810795068740845,
0.43020230531692505,
-0.298941433429718,
0.3068167269229889,
0.39404264092445374,
0.42683279514312744,
-0.7484893202781677,
-0.46940046548843384,
-0.13545015454292297,
-0.511090874671936,
0.5343044996261597,
0.10033760219812393,
0.3352075517177582,
0.4306321442127228,
0.16362762451171875,
0.10751704126596451,
-0.10637031495571136,
-0.6400748491287231,
0.013889933936297894,
-0.05637048929929733,
-0.04587167501449585,
-0.1284705400466919,
-0.07319944351911545,
-0.03408430144190788,
-0.2699104845523834,
0.5919232368469238,
-0.23430576920509338,
-0.05927645415067673,
-0.030985159799456596,
-0.22839003801345825,
-0.20377473533153534,
0.3059040606021881,
0.5034680366516113,
0.5985689163208008,
-0.07114660739898682,
0.19464299082756042,
0.4939172863960266,
-0.45591819286346436,
0.2917496860027313,
0.016871975734829903,
-0.49404922127723694,
0.15251164138317108,
0.6554990410804749,
0.8625569939613342,
0.4749244451522827,
-0.4754989743232727,
0.6334496140480042,
0.08812673389911652,
-0.30948641896247864,
0.23626708984375,
0.09683886915445328,
-0.30945083498954773,
0.09634445607662201,
0.11942519247531891,
-0.09646199643611908,
0.4456164240837097,
-0.482533723115921,
0.2655036747455597,
0.6017687320709229,
-0.7083993554115295,
-0.6527919173240662,
0.14053557813167572,
0.15418978035449982,
-0.05351197347044945,
0.5542468428611755,
-0.04134197160601616,
-0.3572835326194763,
0.3959260582923889,
0.4297597110271454,
1.0758334398269653,
-0.639267086982727,
0.47275838255882263,
0.2764343023300171,
0.3022051751613617,
0.13513007760047913,
0.0410953089594841,
-0.21572284400463104,
-0.7640749216079712,
-0.44707709550857544,
-0.6581602096557617,
-0.2546444535255432,
-0.06309721618890762,
-0.5617229342460632,
0.18942946195602417,
-0.15128754079341888,
-0.3537905216217041,
-0.22702914476394653,
-0.03730881214141846,
-0.8907539248466492,
0.12843601405620575,
0.2864111065864563,
0.7574458718299866,
-1.062905192375183,
0.6766544580459595,
0.6090743541717529,
-0.3641079068183899,
-0.6890257000923157,
-0.3905344605445862,
-0.3926803171634674,
-0.836279034614563,
0.774161159992218,
-0.024671494960784912,
-0.328901082277298,
-0.4740011394023895,
-0.08413795381784439,
-1.0328912734985352,
0.9425243139266968,
0.6347128748893738,
-0.8083425164222717,
-0.11845677345991135,
0.4540325403213501,
0.5890800356864929,
-0.3627135157585144,
0.34394779801368713,
0.6984022855758667,
0.4985292851924896,
0.2625061869621277,
-1.388043999671936,
-0.05128505825996399,
-0.28126758337020874,
0.3782399892807007,
0.05742897465825081,
-0.2746850550174713,
0.7807769179344177,
-0.13680292665958405,
-0.41920074820518494,
-0.15524907410144806,
0.3818220794200897,
-0.2072429209947586,
0.4306023418903351,
0.40909436345100403,
0.610228955745697,
0.5776224136352539,
0.1273571103811264,
0.9148983955383301,
-0.3841436207294464,
0.517041802406311,
0.7474726438522339,
-0.0717446506023407,
0.8126986026763916,
0.39310240745544434,
-0.1212683692574501,
0.172085702419281,
0.3071434795856476,
-0.18990448117256165,
0.5202489495277405,
0.37302854657173157,
-0.017564918845891953,
-0.18832293152809143,
-0.14495769143104553,
-0.03908069431781769,
0.5044195652008057,
-0.012407485395669937,
-0.47478488087654114,
-0.3810718059539795,
0.15358412265777588,
0.15846571326255798,
-0.1147429347038269,
-0.48531273007392883,
0.7118086218833923,
-0.11218197643756866,
-0.7308594584465027,
0.9408882260322571,
0.08001603931188583,
0.7998030781745911,
-0.6157200336456299,
-0.09158070385456085,
-0.42302054166793823,
0.21882076561450958,
-0.15038324892520905,
-0.7298702001571655,
0.6619412899017334,
-0.06322453171014786,
-0.2118079960346222,
-0.0993761271238327,
0.8054858446121216,
-0.6660218834877014,
-0.7795330882072449,
0.5633105635643005,
0.5302062034606934,
0.43109482526779175,
0.04549035429954529,
-0.5276385545730591,
-0.05192869156599045,
0.0051650963723659515,
-0.14647233486175537,
0.39761948585510254,
0.2776321470737457,
-0.19987843930721283,
0.5273534655570984,
0.3678482472896576,
0.46618980169296265,
0.41260331869125366,
0.1773226410150528,
0.3524910807609558,
-0.5381547808647156,
-0.14659243822097778,
-0.722583532333374,
0.29003599286079407,
-0.024080028757452965,
-0.4124426245689392,
0.9312177896499634,
0.4218657314777374,
1.084401249885559,
-0.11427178978919983,
0.9691603779792786,
0.14542487263679504,
0.2741113305091858,
-0.35637593269348145,
0.9130637049674988,
-0.5177316665649414,
-0.1517626792192459,
-0.22572198510169983,
-0.9758546948432922,
-0.5701993107795715,
0.5305588841438293,
-0.487823486328125,
0.1471654772758484,
0.29654011130332947,
0.658686637878418,
-0.2919779419898987,
-0.5310724973678589,
1.0047805309295654,
-0.16374333202838898,
0.17819763720035553,
0.8191545605659485,
0.45926040410995483,
-0.4968767762184143,
0.5789242386817932,
-0.2610134482383728,
-0.5868030190467834,
-0.2738977372646332,
-0.6760438680648804,
-0.8872645497322083,
-0.6096384525299072,
-0.4610588848590851,
0.34819135069847107,
0.2574462294578552,
0.1347428411245346,
1.108139157295227,
-0.9340822696685791,
-0.5807298421859741,
0.1499207466840744,
0.010049520060420036,
-0.4587046504020691,
-0.2319479137659073,
0.31590452790260315,
-0.6763027906417847,
-0.6912247538566589,
0.16108494997024536,
0.42377403378486633,
-0.019455397501587868,
-0.4970304071903229,
-0.17575272917747498,
0.00010505146929062903,
0.36495664715766907,
0.6266428828239441,
0.29157885909080505,
-0.6425122022628784,
-0.4581335186958313,
0.08300622552633286,
0.13473860919475555,
-0.12667138874530792,
0.6995264291763306,
-0.32440218329429626,
0.5911818146705627,
0.6098931431770325,
0.7206587791442871,
0.3845144510269165,
-0.32078129053115845,
0.8990718722343445,
-0.6287218928337097,
-0.16884219646453857,
0.08054480701684952,
0.29818788170814514,
0.5812285542488098,
-0.1284012794494629,
0.6866912245750427,
0.13508294522762299,
-0.3464609384536743,
-0.653299868106842,
0.1094735711812973,
-0.6698237657546997,
0.008891664445400238,
0.9279468655586243,
-0.6933507323265076,
-0.22321876883506775,
0.060814712196588516,
0.1165851503610611,
0.3641555905342102,
-0.0010142488172277808,
0.5391484498977661,
0.7868415713310242,
-0.14813333749771118,
-0.2292909473180771,
-0.3666438162326813,
0.2318967580795288,
0.42456889152526855,
-0.6637012958526611,
-0.10142865777015686,
0.3305736184120178,
0.6211535930633545,
0.35480913519859314,
0.42606526613235474,
-0.0777771845459938,
0.301913857460022,
0.014263560995459557,
0.12075010687112808,
0.09744652360677719,
-0.4147157371044159,
-0.6541125774383545,
0.24521344900131226,
-0.0638677254319191,
-0.4505528211593628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15925v1
|
Inside the echo chamber: Linguistic underpinnings of misinformation on Twitter
| 2024-04-24T15:37:12 | 2024-04-24T15:37:12 |
Xinyu Wang, Jiayi Li, Sarah Rajtmajer
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL
|
Social media users drive the spread of misinformation online by sharing posts
that include erroneous information or commenting on controversial topics with
unsubstantiated arguments often in earnest. Work on echo chambers has suggested
that users' perspectives are reinforced through repeated interactions with
like-minded peers, promoted by homophily and bias in information diffusion.
Building on long-standing interest in the social bases of language and
linguistic underpinnings of social behavior, this work explores how
conversations around misinformation are mediated through language use. We
compare a number of linguistic measures, e.g., in-/out-group cues, readability,
and discourse connectives, within and across topics of conversation and user
communities. Our findings reveal increased presence of group identity signals
and processing fluency within echo chambers during discussions of
misinformation. We discuss the specific character of these broader trends
across topics and examine contextual influences.
|
[
-0.6096154451370239,
-0.9208675622940063,
0.6173793077468872,
-0.022082626819610596,
-0.23519112169742584,
0.5462828874588013,
-0.17186342179775238,
-0.5543193221092224,
0.5020366311073303,
0.18970336019992828,
-0.40183302760124207,
-0.14363931119441986,
-0.9487904906272888,
0.021218206733465195,
-0.5073962211608887,
0.7589883804321289,
0.34108537435531616,
-0.02895371988415718,
0.38937708735466003,
-0.09706347435712814,
-0.10099281370639801,
-0.8181588649749756,
-0.47422757744789124,
-0.3415473401546478,
0.7967993021011353,
0.4134472608566284,
1.0070521831512451,
0.373677134513855,
0.14630967378616333,
0.11649452149868011,
-0.07607777416706085,
-0.032043829560279846,
-0.7765102982521057,
0.10437918454408646,
-0.1915086954832077,
-0.5480428338050842,
0.14284740388393402,
-0.035925738513469696,
0.5201588273048401,
0.8157164454460144,
-0.19261524081230164,
0.21903297305107117,
0.40538161993026733,
0.5334227085113525,
-0.4019613564014435,
0.05362335219979286,
-0.8875246047973633,
-0.3632951080799103,
-0.4576059579849243,
-0.4967394471168518,
-0.038610853254795074,
-0.42379358410835266,
0.07661193609237671,
-0.38457638025283813,
0.4470573663711548,
0.020266195759177208,
0.7214104533195496,
-0.06410263478755951,
-0.29538214206695557,
-0.5687524676322937,
-0.523298978805542,
0.4156636893749237,
-0.28883305191993713,
0.49849408864974976,
0.6871697306632996,
0.048000551760196686,
0.08235505223274231,
-0.48661211133003235,
-0.6843090653419495,
0.4956881105899811,
-0.3684806525707245,
-0.21886777877807617,
-0.6708414554595947,
-0.073165662586689,
0.1073676347732544,
0.03297415375709534,
-0.23006436228752136,
-0.23155342042446136,
-0.7151553630828857,
-0.015934186056256294,
0.5417534708976746,
-0.17041772603988647,
0.47383132576942444,
-0.1386769860982895,
0.06116824969649315,
0.05141253024339676,
-0.7457705140113831,
-0.08210401982069016,
0.5231465697288513,
0.441473126411438,
0.02732929214835167,
0.3570720851421356,
0.07786614447832108,
0.10625962913036346,
0.2757052481174469,
0.2694641649723053,
0.3307346999645233,
-0.23724009096622467,
-0.11121173948049545,
0.3328164219856262,
0.5047611594200134,
0.6815412044525146,
0.46796196699142456,
-0.12808948755264282,
-0.04800693690776825,
0.1450066864490509,
0.3849281966686249,
-0.4482189416885376,
0.06166771799325943,
0.036883048713207245,
-0.6200437545776367,
-0.16790089011192322,
0.28496411442756653,
-1.0109013319015503,
-0.9043909311294556,
-0.0024318902287632227,
0.30884072184562683,
-0.09445171803236008,
-0.46608784794807434,
0.029715070500969887,
-0.5845618844032288,
0.0019918864127248526,
0.38276922702789307,
-0.9148199558258057,
0.5346490144729614,
0.8203125596046448,
0.8530994057655334,
0.23261691629886627,
-0.19869264960289001,
-0.12377452105283737,
0.21829882264137268,
-0.4977169334888458,
0.9452825784683228,
-0.5367264151573181,
-0.4657234847545624,
0.5555699467658997,
0.15306159853935242,
-0.019346237182617188,
-0.6094576716423035,
0.3439505398273468,
-0.3661620318889618,
0.34003522992134094,
-0.5781047344207764,
-0.36790210008621216,
-0.3297410011291504,
-0.1420096904039383,
-0.33973681926727295,
0.7870593667030334,
-0.018971621990203857,
-0.8738806247711182,
0.47895747423171997,
-0.5156565308570862,
-0.45227381587028503,
0.24924007058143616,
-0.4279349446296692,
0.10167776793241501,
0.3971095085144043,
0.15364700555801392,
0.429974764585495,
-0.06386727839708328,
-0.1684090942144394,
-0.16978007555007935,
-0.6035286784172058,
0.5113295912742615,
-0.35819312930107117,
0.688198983669281,
0.19026242196559906,
-0.5490789413452148,
-0.07693615555763245,
0.05852960795164108,
-0.40705516934394836,
-0.081331767141819,
0.11645326018333435,
-0.667161226272583,
0.09596546739339828,
-0.1771542727947235,
-0.046279557049274445,
-0.2493082582950592,
-0.25961482524871826,
-0.0473519004881382,
-0.06517751514911652,
0.39641073346138,
0.6141586899757385,
0.5572983026504517,
0.1673460751771927,
-0.8961085677146912,
0.189087375998497,
-0.015587935224175453,
0.24940602481365204,
-0.03454245254397392,
-0.7729638814926147,
-0.42575013637542725,
0.1855737864971161,
-0.38418686389923096,
0.38017040491104126,
-0.5237691402435303,
0.1719169020652771,
-0.1044996976852417,
-0.5625024437904358,
-1.0190870761871338,
0.1245117336511612,
0.015387997031211853,
0.08694961667060852,
0.32532522082328796,
0.11203818768262863,
-0.4028550386428833,
-0.970543622970581,
-0.7586990594863892,
-0.4744953513145447,
-0.04958605021238327,
0.26059579849243164,
0.05746906250715256,
-0.5234568119049072,
0.5870791673660278,
-0.21524471044540405,
-0.3073716461658478,
-0.4914444386959076,
0.6196469664573669,
0.17465583980083466,
-0.1506044864654541,
0.39736035466194153,
-0.8123542070388794,
-0.7228971719741821,
-0.10131612420082092,
-0.3972622752189636,
-0.36776891350746155,
-0.15248897671699524,
-0.05107766017317772,
0.2838958501815796,
0.6460628509521484,
-0.3158861994743347,
0.6259745359420776,
0.5454491972923279,
-0.4212166965007782,
0.061517778784036636,
0.31908494234085083,
0.7520589828491211,
-1.264952301979065,
-0.46363288164138794,
0.046499911695718765,
-0.0874025970697403,
-0.7171388268470764,
-0.3003312051296234,
-0.2974138855934143,
0.48501327633857727,
-0.3426207900047302,
0.29509177803993225,
-0.5816755294799805,
0.2974867522716522,
-0.3165072798728943,
0.3850165605545044,
-0.37233880162239075,
0.07572191208600998,
-0.2037663459777832,
0.6845372319221497,
0.7305611371994019,
-0.3665674030780792,
0.14531651139259338,
-0.07512408494949341,
-0.43688100576400757,
0.4523407220840454,
-0.39260342717170715,
0.09729598462581635,
-0.25932079553604126,
0.18847349286079407,
-1.2175711393356323,
-0.48889824748039246,
0.4362950623035431,
-0.7088038921356201,
0.0013755708932876587,
-0.25331994891166687,
-0.8033887147903442,
-0.055965229868888855,
-0.34335100650787354,
0.32296574115753174,
0.5881220698356628,
-0.2685641646385193,
0.4507800340652466,
1.0201719999313354,
-0.27874353528022766,
-0.26078304648399353,
-1.1090432405471802,
0.07401369512081146,
-0.39864879846572876,
-0.4802664518356323,
0.021096188575029373,
0.1182115450501442,
-1.0651034116744995,
0.06884995847940445,
-0.013127308338880539,
-0.14560621976852417,
-0.15301260352134705,
0.3712318241596222,
-0.20362712442874908,
-0.1754523366689682,
0.7169027924537659,
-0.05346625670790672,
0.3389957845211029,
0.12451521307229996,
-0.010615715757012367,
0.8088112473487854,
-0.15675166249275208,
-0.07346538454294205,
-0.5516353249549866,
0.6601418852806091,
0.3668360412120819,
0.5532279014587402,
1.0940845012664795,
0.13650614023208618,
-0.5417726039886475,
-0.22048696875572205,
-0.8538128137588501,
-0.6512256860733032,
-0.37018904089927673,
0.21895310282707214,
0.0836961641907692,
-1.0485267639160156,
0.6571326851844788,
0.08721458166837692,
-0.05618142709136009,
0.5165895223617554,
0.5067882537841797,
-0.4569239914417267,
0.6742206811904907,
0.5437425374984741,
-0.07424280792474747,
0.4425145983695984,
0.12057078629732132,
0.4938908815383911,
-0.4709292948246002,
0.08169715106487274,
-0.678229033946991,
-0.25653716921806335,
-0.6150655150413513,
-0.5175629258155823,
0.18202927708625793,
0.0056768907234072685,
0.28253549337387085,
0.07876401394605637,
-0.32356947660446167,
0.44103431701660156,
0.16406233608722687,
-0.15362504124641418,
0.36772119998931885,
0.15911266207695007,
0.4434472322463989,
-0.19846636056900024,
-0.7922700047492981,
-0.5825541615486145,
0.8608254194259644,
0.5018986463546753,
0.8838751316070557,
0.29200997948646545,
0.47233179211616516,
0.7757729291915894,
0.7349873781204224,
-0.4980483055114746,
0.22146481275558472,
0.3296399414539337,
-0.798531174659729,
-0.26398107409477234,
-0.26334360241889954,
-1.007315754890442,
0.31601807475090027,
-0.320353627204895,
-1.168961763381958,
0.24365003407001495,
0.05753529816865921,
-0.1212182492017746,
0.6085479259490967,
-0.5915006399154663,
0.4124622046947479,
0.03816245123744011,
0.02510235458612442,
-0.38505929708480835,
-0.582436203956604,
0.19291716814041138,
-0.35969385504722595,
0.6948971152305603,
-0.057964324951171875,
0.07921697199344635,
0.5029642581939697,
0.051840025931596756,
0.9329726099967957,
0.13359332084655762,
0.06043979898095131,
0.4335971176624298,
-0.07578445225954056,
0.09684770554304123,
0.06639420241117477,
0.16323116421699524,
0.6872222423553467,
-0.1905507892370224,
-0.09859390556812286,
-0.4788961410522461,
0.43957412242889404,
-0.8576620817184448,
-0.6645697951316833,
-0.35189664363861084,
-0.12161927670240402,
-0.1445140242576599,
-0.02170804888010025,
0.5440906286239624,
0.39087703824043274,
-0.16828343272209167,
0.5250263810157776,
0.6392644643783569,
0.22602006793022156,
0.3264211118221283,
0.09751908481121063,
-0.3292884826660156,
-0.10466056317090988,
0.42617300152778625,
0.4228809177875519,
0.44500669836997986,
0.10402076691389084,
0.3234008252620697,
-0.2950170636177063,
-0.0717996135354042,
-0.12337695062160492,
0.519930362701416,
-0.8179563283920288,
0.08701615780591965,
-0.7748435735702515,
-0.3153527081012726,
-0.5582142472267151,
-0.2826423645019531,
-0.20949040353298187,
-0.2080821692943573,
0.034335434436798096,
-0.25736111402511597,
0.12275974452495575,
1.1069082021713257,
-0.13299988210201263,
0.6985721588134766,
-0.6276494264602661,
0.08055119961500168,
0.27665892243385315,
0.3038797080516815,
0.019265202805399895,
-0.4864761531352997,
-0.41957810521125793,
0.13528472185134888,
-0.07262264937162399,
-1.4760680198669434,
-0.1125880777835846,
-0.186028853058815,
0.8263178467750549,
0.4122817814350128,
-0.16060757637023926,
0.35137686133384705,
-0.10257434844970703,
0.9616108536720276,
-0.08119796216487885,
-0.8439372181892395,
0.30684301257133484,
-0.5725019574165344,
0.0806645080447197,
0.7004246115684509,
0.6783826351165771,
-1.1251453161239624,
-0.8491960167884827,
-1.0045106410980225,
-0.6833781003952026,
0.41426223516464233,
0.24679730832576752,
0.23373264074325562,
-0.2064320296049118,
-0.11539776623249054,
0.2378721982240677,
0.5177915096282959,
-0.7327053546905518,
-0.48581695556640625,
-0.07778123021125793,
0.2108970284461975,
-0.007774956990033388,
-0.5551053285598755,
-0.4661138355731964,
-0.1505180448293686,
0.6321788430213928,
-0.03775141015648842,
0.13804060220718384,
0.23934465646743774,
0.10755753517150879,
-0.5059128999710083,
0.24500417709350586,
0.5097696781158447,
0.9287379384040833,
-0.09261488914489746,
0.34567514061927795,
-0.08126305788755417,
-0.41013142466545105,
-0.3330647051334381,
-0.12404889613389969,
-0.10822534561157227,
0.30375316739082336,
0.42415449023246765,
0.48269954323768616,
0.06042373925447464,
-0.21828967332839966,
0.47452953457832336,
-0.25974342226982117,
-0.43745023012161255,
-0.16212067008018494,
-0.14695684611797333,
0.20722101628780365,
0.34618186950683594,
0.8101298213005066,
0.12855355441570282,
0.03924364596605301,
-1.1575767993927002,
0.14302729070186615,
0.16977368295192719,
-0.5178205966949463,
-0.46876561641693115,
0.2844129800796509,
0.1948830485343933,
-0.42277729511260986,
0.30184438824653625,
0.1321352869272232,
-0.494322270154953,
0.0033521114382892847,
0.25041472911834717,
1.2190533876419067,
-0.20680546760559082,
0.22549019753932953,
0.09725860506296158,
0.7515171766281128,
0.12776930630207062,
0.16307881474494934,
-0.31594040989875793,
-0.9966566562652588,
0.07479306310415268,
-0.17753267288208008,
-0.17501170933246613,
0.18560196459293365,
-0.22930240631103516,
0.06941009312868118,
-0.2649584114551544,
-0.4527507424354553,
-0.04066367819905281,
-0.33311113715171814,
-0.5085375905036926,
-0.20174692571163177,
0.31733858585357666,
0.630462646484375,
-0.9075700044631958,
0.490898460149765,
0.4842124581336975,
-0.3198423385620117,
-0.6516355276107788,
0.993179976940155,
0.47807425260543823,
-0.5999253988265991,
0.2527695596218109,
0.1655983030796051,
-0.3850158452987671,
-0.34180667996406555,
-0.6066786646842957,
-0.7140864729881287,
0.47192293405532837,
-0.04559402912855148,
-0.21227914094924927,
0.33147382736206055,
0.2970890700817108,
0.5428329110145569,
-0.6352409720420837,
0.1768936961889267,
0.4729097783565521,
0.4909888505935669,
-0.005660719703882933,
-0.9720877408981323,
-0.022907491773366928,
-0.15574699640274048,
-0.3103487193584442,
0.23381361365318298,
-0.7442511320114136,
0.6651270985603333,
0.042542263865470886,
-0.5542176365852356,
-0.5495800375938416,
0.3759257197380066,
-0.08613628894090652,
0.3757875859737396,
0.610174834728241,
-0.05355297029018402,
0.7954339385032654,
-0.25469478964805603,
0.9540770649909973,
-0.3438572883605957,
0.054924529045820236,
0.7861366271972656,
-0.02045096829533577,
0.7467426061630249,
0.6753936409950256,
0.16775134205818176,
0.582164466381073,
0.5292163491249084,
0.4326583445072174,
0.3395846486091614,
0.10536310076713562,
-0.24295471608638763,
0.1547909528017044,
-0.2795591950416565,
-0.5327590703964233,
0.15761345624923706,
0.7975826263427734,
-0.6120909452438354,
-0.032366957515478134,
-0.28338104486465454,
0.3390628695487976,
0.12467123568058014,
-0.25174495577812195,
0.8859347105026245,
-0.035486850887537,
-0.6087192296981812,
0.22617222368717194,
-0.4316979646682739,
0.5514021515846252,
-0.5068938732147217,
0.026316199451684952,
-0.17754095792770386,
-0.11550017446279526,
-0.42324063181877136,
-1.1524245738983154,
0.5220436453819275,
-0.10739551484584808,
-0.12840527296066284,
-0.4768628478050232,
0.7018481492996216,
-0.5314385890960693,
-0.12438749521970749,
0.5874179005622864,
0.7747470140457153,
0.35192200541496277,
-0.38456201553344727,
-0.311282217502594,
0.3973076045513153,
0.04728478565812111,
0.01342784520238638,
-0.08701401203870773,
0.6827771067619324,
-0.02933744341135025,
0.3338252305984497,
0.5051308274269104,
0.34566646814346313,
0.38215798139572144,
0.457467257976532,
0.9154783487319946,
-0.47147834300994873,
-0.360729843378067,
-0.7650754451751709,
0.41867300868034363,
-0.3665879964828491,
-0.478335976600647,
0.9422566294670105,
0.43019261956214905,
1.1329445838928223,
0.23755764961242676,
1.0888400077819824,
0.13472630083560944,
0.9333043694496155,
-0.16387200355529785,
1.0532586574554443,
-0.5982357263565063,
0.09386773407459259,
-0.4227035641670227,
-0.8442927002906799,
-0.13126136362552643,
0.544461727142334,
-0.057163603603839874,
0.1308572143316269,
0.6927655935287476,
0.807616651058197,
0.062194712460041046,
0.4598277807235718,
0.25773316621780396,
0.6173721551895142,
0.21311791241168976,
-0.04571937769651413,
1.0622559785842896,
-0.051277656108140945,
0.19043952226638794,
-0.052270274609327316,
-0.3781353831291199,
-0.4347185492515564,
-0.2676878273487091,
-0.9901849031448364,
-0.8239549398422241,
-0.2478206306695938,
-0.524318516254425,
0.20677638053894043,
0.9368070960044861,
0.5309110879898071,
-0.3566436469554901,
-0.5804514288902283,
0.13637471199035645,
0.24880807101726532,
-0.023036502301692963,
-0.3692539930343628,
-0.04844949021935463,
-0.31703895330429077,
-0.5435612201690674,
0.09781643003225327,
0.4443128705024719,
-0.15102587640285492,
-0.3430056869983673,
0.24028517305850983,
-0.2979170083999634,
0.688722550868988,
0.15608011186122894,
0.2478819191455841,
-0.8040692210197449,
-0.4065099358558655,
-0.14498473703861237,
-0.3852923512458801,
0.09593383222818375,
0.866572380065918,
-0.4865667521953583,
0.5373712182044983,
0.5132130980491638,
0.39891213178634644,
0.01354518998414278,
0.3329441249370575,
0.5669533014297485,
-0.5515414476394653,
0.035542283207178116,
0.26894411444664,
0.2513595521450043,
0.4772433936595917,
-0.4600863456726074,
0.32365909218788147,
0.6186743378639221,
-0.586631715297699,
-0.7321169376373291,
-0.018517542630434036,
-0.5460483431816101,
-0.32168272137641907,
1.2407530546188354,
0.7066255211830139,
-0.2527925372123718,
-0.4346067011356354,
-0.32748299837112427,
0.16329723596572876,
-0.8149157166481018,
1.2191011905670166,
1.1968003511428833,
-0.25418561697006226,
-0.28450796008110046,
-0.5978692770004272,
0.9369286298751831,
0.024915333837270737,
-0.7564257383346558,
0.12963338196277618,
0.20438234508037567,
0.027746371924877167,
0.40049079060554504,
0.872318685054779,
0.008608952164649963,
0.11417210102081299,
0.12290169298648834,
-0.22513580322265625,
0.5266188979148865,
-0.30889368057250977,
-0.08162861317396164,
0.18170449137687683,
-0.39173680543899536,
-0.09192658960819244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15923v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15923v1
|
KGValidator: A Framework for Automatic Validation of Knowledge Graph Construction
| 2024-04-24T15:27:25 | 2024-04-24T15:27:25 |
Jack Boylan, Shashank Mangla, Dominic Thorn, Demian Gholipour Ghalandari, Parsa Ghaffari, Chris Hokamp
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This study explores the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) for automatic
evaluation of knowledge graph (KG) completion models. Historically, validating
information in KGs has been a challenging task, requiring large-scale human
annotation at prohibitive cost. With the emergence of general-purpose
generative AI and LLMs, it is now plausible that human-in-the-loop validation
could be replaced by a generative agent. We introduce a framework for
consistency and validation when using generative models to validate knowledge
graphs. Our framework is based upon recent open-source developments for
structural and semantic validation of LLM outputs, and upon flexible approaches
to fact checking and verification, supported by the capacity to reference
external knowledge sources of any kind. The design is easy to adapt and extend,
and can be used to verify any kind of graph-structured data through a
combination of model-intrinsic knowledge, user-supplied context, and agents
capable of external knowledge retrieval.
|
[
-0.33559978008270264,
-0.575938880443573,
0.6213433146476746,
-0.0163267869502306,
-0.014656892977654934,
0.16879791021347046,
-0.020283522084355354,
-0.23892155289649963,
-0.2013542503118515,
0.5424340963363647,
-0.16834025084972382,
-0.6750291585922241,
-0.664506733417511,
0.4836161136627197,
-0.4942740499973297,
0.7595836520195007,
-0.5858684182167053,
-0.09189105778932571,
-0.9276425242424011,
-0.15970295667648315,
-0.3648602366447449,
-0.2803489565849304,
-0.569259524345398,
-1.087782859802246,
0.4825468957424164,
0.033216726034879684,
0.756257176399231,
0.7189386487007141,
0.2629700005054474,
0.46097519993782043,
-0.1492883265018463,
0.6150242686271667,
-0.392330139875412,
0.20426084101200104,
-0.1028672382235527,
-0.2956720292568207,
-0.5310273766517639,
0.008071844466030598,
0.5906369090080261,
0.6557525396347046,
-0.07968025654554367,
0.0835498794913292,
0.00039130632649175823,
0.6164343953132629,
-0.5292825698852539,
0.685879111289978,
-0.5788239240646362,
0.10216584801673889,
0.24707405269145966,
0.07069184631109238,
-0.6242383122444153,
-0.9163563847541809,
-0.1601673811674118,
-0.6889753341674805,
-0.046738363802433014,
0.08672874420881271,
1.0658243894577026,
0.4168105721473694,
-0.746662974357605,
-0.30068400502204895,
-0.6179327368736267,
0.0815521776676178,
-0.3738844096660614,
0.6781385540962219,
0.5784114003181458,
0.6877474188804626,
-0.41818010807037354,
-0.9252009391784668,
-0.8613561987876892,
-0.48392125964164734,
-0.2930002212524414,
0.11760123819112778,
-0.12216654419898987,
0.3790050745010376,
0.43058305978775024,
0.3432709872722626,
-0.42564189434051514,
-0.05914788320660591,
-0.40414053201675415,
-0.4642917811870575,
0.46447890996932983,
0.13471513986587524,
0.5256403088569641,
-0.296803742647171,
-0.03940228372812271,
-0.118222177028656,
-0.9839041233062744,
-0.11242193728685379,
0.49669548869132996,
0.125356987118721,
0.021943166851997375,
0.9773714542388916,
-0.7542015910148621,
0.9873132109642029,
-0.14275000989437103,
-0.24172671139240265,
0.23791730403900146,
-0.10156957060098648,
-0.43981215357780457,
-0.08375824242830276,
0.8685463070869446,
0.3957061469554901,
0.33192187547683716,
-0.5752537250518799,
-0.13190332055091858,
0.23063471913337708,
0.3327058255672455,
-0.7904039621353149,
-0.4139431118965149,
0.2281481772661209,
-0.19696776568889618,
-0.36047467589378357,
-0.11800393462181091,
-0.3885495960712433,
-0.598207414150238,
-0.34691140055656433,
0.4436890780925751,
-0.35996249318122864,
-0.11437816172838211,
-0.10053080320358276,
-0.3881972134113312,
0.05320429801940918,
0.5378656983375549,
-0.3706327974796295,
-0.21205884218215942,
0.6823916435241699,
0.4767712652683258,
0.1953539401292801,
-0.34441980719566345,
-0.4491526186466217,
0.29024752974510193,
-0.7708722352981567,
0.7998843193054199,
-0.44236329197883606,
-0.3003104329109192,
-0.00639278395101428,
-0.0220655370503664,
0.07939036190509796,
-0.5489134788513184,
0.7161040306091309,
-1.3212802410125732,
0.07262294739484787,
-0.38410305976867676,
-0.8263611793518066,
-0.47603631019592285,
0.8610029816627502,
-0.6399549841880798,
1.1206364631652832,
0.5112782120704651,
-0.6390866041183472,
0.6981295347213745,
-0.5293142199516296,
-0.43886566162109375,
0.37176021933555603,
-0.29096031188964844,
-0.38353613018989563,
-0.2532201409339905,
0.032393187284469604,
0.2960643470287323,
-0.5670685172080994,
0.4633631110191345,
-0.4646117687225342,
0.026740891858935356,
-0.009442005306482315,
-0.22034722566604614,
0.6030928492546082,
0.1889115869998932,
0.14530862867832184,
0.15052570402622223,
-1.1389535665512085,
0.24606800079345703,
0.05715443566441536,
-0.8683180809020996,
-0.06835532188415527,
0.060538481920957565,
-0.4846792221069336,
0.1996517926454544,
0.14421536028385162,
-0.654727041721344,
0.29832836985588074,
-0.09386532753705978,
0.2705579400062561,
0.5084035396575928,
-0.001395136583596468,
0.07537513971328735,
-0.2351643145084381,
0.644087016582489,
0.007659912109375,
-0.036756731569767,
-0.07349210232496262,
-0.5128130316734314,
-0.7462059855461121,
-0.2621057629585266,
0.7288152575492859,
0.4408181607723236,
-1.0894604921340942,
0.7381316423416138,
-0.6749189496040344,
-0.6591923236846924,
-0.2867182791233063,
0.35267025232315063,
0.30378156900405884,
0.7975844144821167,
0.14039233326911926,
-0.1091829240322113,
-0.6482826471328735,
-0.6247089505195618,
0.2594926059246063,
-0.5024205446243286,
-0.20772422850131989,
0.3656797707080841,
0.5416366457939148,
-0.6546532511711121,
1.6190435886383057,
-0.3905918300151825,
-0.08497168868780136,
-0.23575739562511444,
0.09636133909225464,
-0.039692968130111694,
0.2384980171918869,
0.3200826346874237,
-0.7932484745979309,
-0.5414629578590393,
0.4133914113044739,
-1.2062945365905762,
-0.2702789902687073,
0.44075506925582886,
0.03210187703371048,
-0.053348109126091,
0.5789318084716797,
-0.8786712884902954,
0.41385239362716675,
0.5452070832252502,
-0.3751271069049835,
0.5039346218109131,
-0.3015112578868866,
0.3384043574333191,
-0.9269908666610718,
0.19325202703475952,
-0.40960291028022766,
-0.569944441318512,
-0.4331044554710388,
0.09399483352899551,
0.1586810052394867,
-0.10972799360752106,
0.01491041574627161,
0.6288662552833557,
-0.22648140788078308,
0.034246113151311874,
-0.25863850116729736,
0.3854389190673828,
0.2606499195098877,
0.18063773214817047,
-0.26868322491645813,
0.6615638732910156,
0.33344101905822754,
-0.6859474182128906,
1.019677758216858,
0.3062957227230072,
-0.5377506613731384,
0.6761017441749573,
-0.7181286811828613,
0.13018673658370972,
-0.4649108350276947,
0.4848363697528839,
-1.2201377153396606,
-0.6391679048538208,
0.25731173157691956,
-0.39894720911979675,
0.13363106548786163,
-0.6103519201278687,
-0.9286624789237976,
-0.6809437870979309,
0.2015318125486374,
0.2810613214969635,
0.5559775233268738,
-0.7109053134918213,
1.3714884519577026,
0.19237735867500305,
0.17074653506278992,
-0.32966718077659607,
-0.3002859055995941,
0.18423505127429962,
0.05772316828370094,
-0.813819408416748,
0.0246734619140625,
-0.029941920191049576,
-0.2131526619195938,
0.18207983672618866,
0.12456486374139786,
0.09739118069410324,
0.2171003669500351,
0.33742934465408325,
0.10102703422307968,
-0.04871762543916702,
0.17946133017539978,
-0.07566126435995102,
-0.2135012447834015,
-0.08490945398807526,
-0.3707948923110962,
0.4583348333835602,
0.24060691893100739,
-0.7545222640037537,
-0.21464793384075165,
-0.16182732582092285,
0.7333023548126221,
-0.09976603835821152,
0.5245504379272461,
0.5154699683189392,
-0.5245986580848694,
-0.09697549790143967,
-0.8409302830696106,
0.2712804973125458,
-0.44812217354774475,
0.4001791477203369,
-0.532734215259552,
-0.9325808882713318,
0.7290109395980835,
-0.29617840051651,
-0.3331604599952698,
0.7350453734397888,
0.5592341423034668,
0.29947179555892944,
1.103334665298462,
0.39017197489738464,
-0.158651664853096,
-0.16195876896381378,
-0.09795832633972168,
0.23912286758422852,
-0.83599853515625,
-0.4413411021232605,
-0.6477589011192322,
0.23139724135398865,
-0.31556373834609985,
-0.30940717458724976,
0.4835798740386963,
0.3631936013698578,
-0.3683486878871918,
0.1829107254743576,
-0.31781384348869324,
0.700678825378418,
0.17554625868797302,
-0.14587315917015076,
0.3516574203968048,
-0.16943323612213135,
-0.5844414830207825,
0.5215151906013489,
-0.7573355436325073,
-0.6734253764152527,
0.9072566032409668,
0.29821068048477173,
0.532608151435852,
0.24236559867858887,
0.4130040109157562,
0.4594533443450928,
1.012310266494751,
-0.8077273964881897,
0.6787316799163818,
0.06025669723749161,
-0.5590969920158386,
-0.3262298107147217,
-0.7062342762947083,
-0.74593585729599,
0.2633078098297119,
0.05099837854504585,
-0.6484734416007996,
-0.23381613194942474,
0.27702704071998596,
-0.23283369839191437,
0.2638435363769531,
-0.48908933997154236,
0.8767517805099487,
0.1158669963479042,
-0.0291807372123003,
0.056045111268758774,
-0.3262174725532532,
0.3454614579677582,
-0.04764743894338608,
0.0497213751077652,
-0.22468726336956024,
0.3033429682254791,
0.48484593629837036,
-0.7726870179176331,
0.8900991082191467,
-0.23546144366264343,
-0.32763877511024475,
0.5364347100257874,
0.15684516727924347,
0.906531035900116,
-0.30954205989837646,
-0.16763107478618622,
-0.18048910796642303,
-0.261512815952301,
0.09953261911869049,
-0.7800619006156921,
0.25726747512817383,
-0.9665394425392151,
-0.5189302563667297,
-0.04896830767393112,
-0.426963746547699,
-0.3532528579235077,
0.49812355637550354,
0.08621962368488312,
0.26414066553115845,
-0.16105586290359497,
0.24611926078796387,
0.47811657190322876,
0.05890068784356117,
-0.14103731513023376,
0.3791782557964325,
-0.4542538523674011,
-0.815322995185852,
0.7341732978820801,
0.10927341133356094,
0.23527897894382477,
0.32567307353019714,
0.2835719883441925,
-0.40753528475761414,
-0.5668349862098694,
-0.7840247750282288,
0.010328791104257107,
-1.4274101257324219,
-0.4846861660480499,
-0.6739621162414551,
-0.45194053649902344,
-0.4541380703449249,
0.058275457471609116,
-0.2556908428668976,
-0.2105187177658081,
0.008192251436412334,
-0.2401707023382187,
0.4229673147201538,
1.1134872436523438,
0.2490118443965912,
0.07922385632991791,
-0.8658656477928162,
0.1944427788257599,
0.6904177069664001,
0.4856550395488739,
0.14178697764873505,
-0.37246617674827576,
-0.25431257486343384,
-0.09134243428707123,
-0.2876824140548706,
-0.6983534693717957,
0.004816411063075066,
-0.07900732755661011,
0.7287366390228271,
0.4386920630931854,
-0.042839501053094864,
0.5377882719039917,
-0.5137726664543152,
0.8525818586349487,
0.10611675679683685,
-0.9038783311843872,
0.3485453724861145,
-0.3038465678691864,
0.15436436235904694,
0.5648258924484253,
0.3462256193161011,
-0.6493573188781738,
-0.24433526396751404,
-0.4750147759914398,
-0.6342670321464539,
0.4472021162509918,
0.15867337584495544,
-0.15347442030906677,
-0.03762417286634445,
0.6217278242111206,
-0.2959982454776764,
0.3047294020652771,
-0.7940769791603088,
-0.02230646088719368,
-0.23816488683223724,
-0.5253086686134338,
0.13675887882709503,
-0.5206649303436279,
-0.4532046616077423,
-0.020787760615348816,
0.9028608798980713,
-0.45391467213630676,
-0.1702432483434677,
0.10933186858892441,
-0.18919992446899414,
-0.1705271303653717,
0.18319222331047058,
0.3167659640312195,
0.7380964159965515,
0.06537315249443054,
0.264736533164978,
0.3130000829696655,
-0.15116740763187408,
0.45990028977394104,
0.20699726045131683,
-0.5039802193641663,
-0.09906744211912155,
0.45146360993385315,
0.6776649951934814,
-0.04780462384223938,
-0.5434494614601135,
0.47306185960769653,
0.13601043820381165,
-0.29965054988861084,
-0.26099470257759094,
0.11955304443836212,
0.17506885528564453,
0.2872169613838196,
0.19312547147274017,
-0.11401332914829254,
-0.15220627188682556,
-0.14277614653110504,
-0.017144707962870598,
0.3800118565559387,
-0.30600643157958984,
-0.1521306037902832,
0.61323481798172,
0.09400644153356552,
-0.20812278985977173,
0.7958313822746277,
-0.7400681972503662,
-0.9260770678520203,
0.6525201797485352,
0.24114425480365753,
0.8565922379493713,
-0.032502952963113785,
0.006091335788369179,
0.26668694615364075,
0.2415863573551178,
-0.13783413171768188,
0.07311402261257172,
-0.31280311942100525,
-1.1096291542053223,
-0.4459337592124939,
-0.7693043947219849,
-0.410838782787323,
-0.22505596280097961,
-0.15186718106269836,
0.28476202487945557,
-0.24245837330818176,
-0.25952383875846863,
-0.06328792124986649,
-0.19701312482357025,
-0.6563819646835327,
0.4128009080886841,
0.016544312238693237,
1.069524884223938,
-0.8338707089424133,
0.8839958310127258,
0.777610719203949,
-0.5024359226226807,
-0.9505774974822998,
-0.27191561460494995,
-0.047263942658901215,
-0.8399054408073425,
1.149001121520996,
-0.04028033837676048,
-0.29595136642456055,
-0.17719435691833496,
-0.1679178923368454,
-0.8872412443161011,
1.3481773138046265,
0.35195615887641907,
-0.14162574708461761,
-0.06119389086961746,
0.4074769914150238,
0.5602380037307739,
-0.22840848565101624,
0.3052399754524231,
0.28234046697616577,
0.7049382925033569,
0.7020463943481445,
-1.0042155981063843,
0.05453988537192345,
-0.15402577817440033,
0.1817314326763153,
0.0737081989645958,
-0.5199097394943237,
0.5738736987113953,
0.018092233687639236,
-0.12321349233388901,
0.041459016501903534,
0.7002834677696228,
0.3778286576271057,
0.08688203245401382,
0.6933045387268066,
0.899072527885437,
0.9818423986434937,
-0.22408424317836761,
1.1646419763565063,
-0.5490269064903259,
0.4695982336997986,
0.8087850213050842,
-0.5604589581489563,
0.5377955436706543,
-0.044914182275533676,
-0.48835447430610657,
0.5960365533828735,
0.4981825649738312,
-0.14894792437553406,
0.12606295943260193,
0.2984900176525116,
-0.17264346778392792,
-0.43924275040626526,
-0.21474961936473846,
-0.2355162650346756,
0.5220853090286255,
0.12772248685359955,
-0.43378669023513794,
-0.40026241540908813,
-0.21345588564872742,
0.10585944354534149,
-0.1612761914730072,
-0.35422587394714355,
0.8344150185585022,
-0.306368887424469,
-0.9193654656410217,
0.5098248720169067,
0.1546156108379364,
0.10330501198768616,
-0.8420251607894897,
0.05375207960605621,
0.062112029641866684,
0.272898405790329,
-0.34803837537765503,
-0.5588414072990417,
0.19110345840454102,
-0.06356637179851532,
-0.22623102366924286,
-0.046766288578510284,
0.870418906211853,
-0.4477158188819885,
-0.530252993106842,
0.31970295310020447,
0.3366979658603668,
-0.21878206729888916,
0.11751353740692139,
-0.300987184047699,
0.13386008143424988,
-0.11214146018028259,
-0.17233318090438843,
-0.03892774134874344,
0.5314251184463501,
0.05799819156527519,
0.943662166595459,
0.5059766173362732,
0.0808202400803566,
-0.18473242223262787,
0.3584662973880768,
0.9321137070655823,
-0.20404520630836487,
-0.44686758518218994,
-0.8848447203636169,
0.4486304521560669,
-0.20943647623062134,
0.1285802721977234,
1.0142958164215088,
0.6794496774673462,
0.8455918431282043,
0.22538341581821442,
1.0260287523269653,
-0.15632495284080505,
0.2200143039226532,
-0.5756796002388,
0.9541568160057068,
-0.41696053743362427,
0.09319338202476501,
-0.15704011917114258,
-0.643872082233429,
-0.2622208297252655,
0.47921258211135864,
-0.3524663746356964,
0.4505769908428192,
0.387500524520874,
0.6994093656539917,
0.0443081296980381,
0.07318472862243652,
0.4103848338127136,
0.256987988948822,
0.6316058039665222,
0.17901799082756042,
1.0322239398956299,
-0.28867673873901367,
0.5961353778839111,
0.08398696780204773,
-0.19853585958480835,
-0.020778387784957886,
-1.1822260618209839,
-0.8669120669364929,
-0.5048466920852661,
-0.5154522061347961,
-0.8405680656433105,
-0.15135276317596436,
1.1078851222991943,
0.6834427714347839,
-0.5672833323478699,
-0.02713025175035,
-0.007781206164509058,
0.4446401298046112,
0.15059387683868408,
-0.20486608147621155,
0.4130421578884125,
-0.47067463397979736,
-0.3327119052410126,
0.3146516978740692,
0.36379575729370117,
0.18871480226516724,
-0.4954250156879425,
-0.20867982506752014,
0.25124219059944153,
-0.02228557877242565,
0.8360280990600586,
0.1709432303905487,
-0.7168740630149841,
-0.43797552585601807,
-0.5212127566337585,
-0.15193235874176025,
0.15818755328655243,
0.7263730764389038,
-0.9390366673469543,
0.650335431098938,
0.6786699295043945,
0.8136261701583862,
0.26611021161079407,
-0.037575673311948776,
0.623820960521698,
-0.7260131239891052,
-0.25474730134010315,
-0.0439554825425148,
0.638145923614502,
0.5261305570602417,
-0.2006155401468277,
0.5028872489929199,
0.5034478902816772,
-0.5320259928703308,
-0.8174574375152588,
0.3176524043083191,
-0.5414308309555054,
0.08108284324407578,
1.1904911994934082,
-0.4092293381690979,
-0.18860197067260742,
-0.3172913193702698,
0.046447135508060455,
0.33850738406181335,
0.10412373393774033,
0.867917001247406,
1.0813708305358887,
0.13007891178131104,
0.040010593831539154,
-0.19265739619731903,
0.6215546131134033,
-0.24207189679145813,
-1.0300140380859375,
0.35401079058647156,
0.5905327200889587,
0.4892052114009857,
0.5219669938087463,
0.6836106777191162,
-0.08714814484119415,
0.16971206665039062,
-0.05920282378792763,
0.1755364090204239,
-0.41034168004989624,
-0.25339192152023315,
-0.04101948440074921,
0.5612707734107971,
0.4078860878944397,
0.24846790730953217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15894v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15894v1
|
Assessing The Potential Of Mid-Sized Language Models For Clinical QA
| 2024-04-24T14:32:34 | 2024-04-24T14:32:34 |
Elliot Bolton, Betty Xiong, Vijaytha Muralidharan, Joel Schamroth, Vivek Muralidharan, Christopher D. Manning, Roxana Daneshjou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models, such as GPT-4 and Med-PaLM, have shown impressive
performance on clinical tasks; however, they require access to compute, are
closed-source, and cannot be deployed on device. Mid-size models such as
BioGPT-large, BioMedLM, LLaMA 2, and Mistral 7B avoid these drawbacks, but
their capacity for clinical tasks has been understudied. To help assess their
potential for clinical use and help researchers decide which model they should
use, we compare their performance on two clinical question-answering (QA)
tasks: MedQA and consumer query answering. We find that Mistral 7B is the best
performing model, winning on all benchmarks and outperforming models trained
specifically for the biomedical domain. While Mistral 7B's MedQA score of 63.0%
approaches the original Med-PaLM, and it often can produce plausible responses
to consumer health queries, room for improvement still exists. This study
provides the first head-to-head assessment of open source mid-sized models on
clinical tasks.
|
[
-0.193141371011734,
-0.7182849049568176,
0.9898252487182617,
0.2170800119638443,
-0.2653541564941406,
-0.061636149883270264,
-0.20339184999465942,
-0.6915042400360107,
0.05182031914591789,
0.43038636445999146,
-0.22236058115959167,
-0.2911742627620697,
-0.6420694589614868,
0.20960919559001923,
-0.21348395943641663,
0.7288591861724854,
0.16066409647464752,
0.310400128364563,
-0.1779831051826477,
-0.315699964761734,
-0.5666470527648926,
-0.7171903252601624,
-0.7600786685943604,
-0.06249726936221123,
0.6663148999214172,
0.3032269775867462,
1.1175897121429443,
0.3553718328475952,
0.7031099200248718,
0.23041746020317078,
-0.10309208929538727,
-0.2882835268974304,
-0.41312485933303833,
0.05140452831983566,
-0.24940338730812073,
-0.4463059604167938,
-0.8432419300079346,
0.005272183567285538,
0.2678850293159485,
0.6552953720092773,
-0.28984808921813965,
0.5791798233985901,
-0.32895568013191223,
0.5556601285934448,
-0.5334939956665039,
0.11310996860265732,
-0.45479318499565125,
-0.39619287848472595,
-0.3357754349708557,
0.1882886439561844,
-0.35794979333877563,
-0.48607122898101807,
0.28250110149383545,
-0.446022093296051,
0.205525740981102,
0.0031063647475093603,
0.6750761270523071,
0.2704540193080902,
-0.360767662525177,
-0.43855157494544983,
-0.7081249356269836,
0.5045878887176514,
-1.0151108503341675,
0.4636683166027069,
0.4924103021621704,
0.7229153513908386,
-0.006522789131850004,
-1.003157377243042,
-0.7925384640693665,
-0.4355122447013855,
0.14249783754348755,
0.08543869853019714,
-0.6668814420700073,
0.29890280961990356,
0.276216596364975,
0.37861505150794983,
-0.8920429348945618,
0.11128070950508118,
-0.6750949025154114,
-0.080795519053936,
0.3895726501941681,
0.23806412518024445,
0.5447450876235962,
0.05494338646531105,
-0.06023046746850014,
0.0028294320218265057,
-0.887633204460144,
0.0975886881351471,
-0.4763995110988617,
-0.03642098233103752,
-0.07039128988981247,
0.6393378973007202,
-0.11463465541601181,
0.6027010679244995,
0.05459091439843178,
-0.2906455099582672,
-0.07883485406637192,
-0.3205240070819855,
-0.570606529712677,
-0.04774700850248337,
0.7264835238456726,
0.3865732252597809,
0.03397535905241966,
-0.2745346128940582,
-0.1284276694059372,
0.2340211570262909,
0.34639281034469604,
-0.9136046171188354,
-0.3284643888473511,
0.6204169392585754,
-0.5536577105522156,
0.046849168837070465,
-0.4719082713127136,
-0.42767366766929626,
-0.5070610046386719,
-0.11216571927070618,
0.35939180850982666,
0.027933914214372635,
-0.25337347388267517,
0.23998495936393738,
0.0802333876490593,
0.16756628453731537,
0.44572094082832336,
-0.5466623306274414,
0.47443267703056335,
0.3999502658843994,
0.7930591702461243,
0.011149449273943901,
0.15250182151794434,
-0.26922178268432617,
-0.11555100977420807,
-0.46997153759002686,
0.7487401962280273,
-0.3840913474559784,
-0.3619883060455322,
-0.17437422275543213,
0.062263280153274536,
-0.1756795197725296,
-0.9073375463485718,
0.4975450336933136,
-0.6313564777374268,
0.11576908081769943,
-0.6526170372962952,
-0.26103314757347107,
-0.061956387013196945,
0.3578864634037018,
-0.7539007067680359,
0.6717917323112488,
0.5764813423156738,
-0.7627161145210266,
0.1867833286523819,
-0.3861701190471649,
-0.07374411076307297,
0.22630248963832855,
-0.3050207197666168,
-0.3430248200893402,
0.15254151821136475,
0.09947840124368668,
0.3395666778087616,
-0.9777873754501343,
0.39684605598449707,
-0.5383854508399963,
-0.21877111494541168,
0.5890500545501709,
-0.4021145701408386,
0.5698745846748352,
0.28194114565849304,
-0.2862498462200165,
0.06937985122203827,
-0.6351713538169861,
0.07278233766555786,
0.156508669257164,
-0.09446416050195694,
-0.15665100514888763,
-0.34003928303718567,
0.25190189480781555,
0.4998669922351837,
0.25832873582839966,
-0.7556508779525757,
0.02092071995139122,
-0.3036784529685974,
0.533061683177948,
0.28980547189712524,
-0.035253796726465225,
0.06798950582742691,
-0.4708102345466614,
1.0105931758880615,
-0.13121740520000458,
0.5923844575881958,
0.3317514657974243,
-0.5983589291572571,
-0.46828705072402954,
-0.34829768538475037,
0.5499746799468994,
0.3914630115032196,
-0.823667585849762,
-0.16406333446502686,
-0.12069009244441986,
-0.9042375683784485,
-0.7941592931747437,
-0.15924081206321716,
0.4553159177303314,
0.5004501342773438,
0.3453311622142792,
-0.3141743838787079,
0.0797642320394516,
-1.0684233903884888,
-0.10387144982814789,
-0.31415849924087524,
-0.09641406685113907,
0.5502713322639465,
0.13503549993038177,
-0.2819852828979492,
0.6587504744529724,
-0.35204291343688965,
-0.2593415677547455,
-0.38613614439964294,
-0.458439439535141,
0.31574222445487976,
0.1070646345615387,
0.896955132484436,
-0.774736762046814,
-0.5032699704170227,
0.13629548251628876,
-0.5606164932250977,
-0.400307834148407,
0.23387058079242706,
0.1449088603258133,
-0.3200017511844635,
0.17305882275104523,
-0.7576841115951538,
0.5435189008712769,
0.8462596535682678,
-0.3368101716041565,
0.647017776966095,
-0.40456104278564453,
0.2387523353099823,
-0.826165497303009,
0.48596087098121643,
-0.15674760937690735,
-0.3309487998485565,
-0.7848727703094482,
-0.06467384845018387,
0.3832293450832367,
-0.3378222584724426,
-0.47913312911987305,
0.8191718459129333,
-0.3848970830440521,
-0.16624636948108673,
-0.3969191908836365,
0.017814358696341515,
-0.1182049810886383,
0.162343367934227,
-0.05267691984772682,
1.0396883487701416,
0.2824021279811859,
-0.3968311548233032,
0.04838104173541069,
0.12089792639017105,
-0.3964022397994995,
0.07268986850976944,
-1.3633379936218262,
0.09347373992204666,
0.09956817328929901,
0.3113004267215729,
-0.8800143599510193,
-0.3028447926044464,
-0.02210473082959652,
-0.41842660307884216,
-0.07848472893238068,
0.024723414331674576,
-0.5294780135154724,
-0.557003378868103,
0.054633691906929016,
0.705915093421936,
0.6513910889625549,
-0.213204026222229,
0.3060669004917145,
0.5917618870735168,
-0.5611374974250793,
-0.33481156826019287,
-0.28733035922050476,
-0.17019027471542358,
-0.09387198090553284,
-0.5279357433319092,
0.17055167257785797,
0.0299211535602808,
-0.19635899364948273,
-0.31770116090774536,
-0.18740314245224,
-0.13437066972255707,
0.044256821274757385,
0.3028431534767151,
0.3315494954586029,
-0.4209257662296295,
0.07704717665910721,
0.27895259857177734,
0.022102076560258865,
0.09782309830188751,
0.1741740107536316,
0.44098415970802307,
-0.11255504190921783,
-0.4158514440059662,
-0.2728942930698395,
0.20613275468349457,
1.0120840072631836,
-0.48511332273483276,
0.5870072245597839,
0.27209511399269104,
-0.48393672704696655,
0.15320484340190887,
-0.7438912987709045,
-0.07793731242418289,
-0.41565486788749695,
0.24077562987804413,
-0.22702591121196747,
-0.9002074003219604,
0.49580949544906616,
-0.04929763078689575,
0.04295608773827553,
0.5016440153121948,
1.0724915266036987,
0.1857425421476364,
1.047621488571167,
0.5644205212593079,
0.16159972548484802,
0.04542848840355873,
-0.004067834001034498,
0.1845170557498932,
-0.7386777997016907,
-0.13374727964401245,
-0.6480858325958252,
-0.05527525767683983,
-0.3274287283420563,
-0.5601152777671814,
0.9908580183982849,
0.10616231709718704,
-0.3230566680431366,
0.12339291721582413,
-0.3799358606338501,
0.11309406906366348,
0.2678205668926239,
0.2811046242713928,
0.2802604138851166,
-0.33306553959846497,
-0.20258453488349915,
0.2367348074913025,
-0.8707715272903442,
-0.7260494232177734,
1.1810195446014404,
0.6076905727386475,
0.5540706515312195,
0.3968164622783661,
0.06922891736030579,
0.21566322445869446,
0.7725338935852051,
-0.5156717896461487,
0.280568391084671,
-0.2829383313655853,
-0.7792874574661255,
-0.25120067596435547,
-0.20354026556015015,
-1.142319679260254,
0.5308910608291626,
-0.1307487189769745,
-0.6808025240898132,
0.3023325204849243,
0.24489693343639374,
-0.6831297278404236,
-0.07304088026285172,
-0.8551748394966125,
1.1240636110305786,
-0.039023786783218384,
-0.12146513909101486,
0.04986400529742241,
-0.635123074054718,
0.29352501034736633,
-0.2200535386800766,
0.307265043258667,
-0.2209128737449646,
0.01147597935050726,
0.7292328476905823,
-0.46425098180770874,
0.7523683905601501,
-0.19946125149726868,
-0.00199904921464622,
0.2700461745262146,
0.2589236795902252,
-0.06408777087926865,
0.19064539670944214,
0.024286726489663124,
0.04330515116453171,
0.9136853218078613,
-0.6843470931053162,
-0.6545290946960449,
0.4919518232345581,
-0.7983437776565552,
-0.5650043487548828,
-0.5094110369682312,
-0.24760273098945618,
-0.6736406683921814,
0.3039807081222534,
0.1838424950838089,
0.5185142159461975,
-0.3702515959739685,
0.11276600509881973,
0.36953070759773254,
-0.4147506058216095,
0.037992775440216064,
0.696718156337738,
-0.30395108461380005,
-0.3217744827270508,
0.4312472939491272,
-0.1408558040857315,
0.48478132486343384,
0.15016457438468933,
0.42472365498542786,
-0.4898080825805664,
-0.6961717009544373,
-0.6850478649139404,
0.561854898929596,
-0.3438892066478729,
-0.18612836301326752,
-0.6716033816337585,
-0.12277355790138245,
-0.5122529864311218,
0.11615051329135895,
-0.4293532371520996,
-0.20268531143665314,
0.06385544687509537,
0.23913562297821045,
0.056725192815065384,
0.8019078969955444,
0.3295915126800537,
0.47704970836639404,
-1.0287904739379883,
0.1793775111436844,
0.10690280050039291,
0.057505518198013306,
0.24978473782539368,
-0.2522166669368744,
-0.0923973023891449,
0.06989087164402008,
-0.33918723464012146,
-1.0025386810302734,
0.4160880744457245,
-0.2634924352169037,
0.34956681728363037,
0.4625054895877838,
-0.04935313016176224,
0.3937445282936096,
-0.42963463068008423,
0.8449820876121521,
0.36767223477363586,
-0.689302384853363,
0.18305322527885437,
-0.38362789154052734,
0.504747748374939,
0.5185894966125488,
0.5360386967658997,
-0.5873335003852844,
-0.28025898337364197,
-0.672594428062439,
-0.26037850975990295,
0.12114962190389633,
0.2650301456451416,
-0.24224606156349182,
-0.04115837812423706,
0.2991798222064972,
0.23111341893672943,
0.3289949297904968,
-0.41095608472824097,
0.2593318223953247,
0.23168043792247772,
-0.3342077136039734,
-0.24813970923423767,
-0.18756981194019318,
0.11221611499786377,
-0.1504196673631668,
0.09615226089954376,
-0.13209883868694305,
0.23974624276161194,
0.3721945285797119,
0.09182482212781906,
-0.021879948675632477,
0.36931300163269043,
0.38530564308166504,
1.045849323272705,
-0.10945752263069153,
0.01757110096514225,
-0.01661384478211403,
-0.9637606143951416,
0.009290384128689766,
0.10660416632890701,
-0.0878036841750145,
-0.03194095939397812,
0.5069153904914856,
0.3862386643886566,
0.06328801065683365,
-1.1021177768707275,
0.7962745428085327,
-0.24543964862823486,
0.010649224743247032,
-0.0068909297697246075,
-0.10677266865968704,
0.11951352655887604,
0.3441571593284607,
-0.13051603734493256,
-0.2655659317970276,
0.3880605697631836,
-0.6397533416748047,
-0.09942805022001266,
0.18246982991695404,
-0.4734047055244446,
-0.45308470726013184,
0.8521259427070618,
-0.05308251827955246,
0.03841790556907654,
0.6207522749900818,
0.25420528650283813,
-0.5735979080200195,
0.7021923661231995,
0.5927907824516296,
0.4579705595970154,
-0.32363855838775635,
0.1238083466887474,
0.21196235716342926,
0.2732465863227844,
-0.10787715762853622,
0.589320182800293,
0.1521739661693573,
-0.4468148648738861,
-0.31006112694740295,
-0.5260412693023682,
-0.616389811038971,
0.25076383352279663,
-0.6908512711524963,
-0.12306959927082062,
-0.41922613978385925,
-0.5869837403297424,
0.2785235345363617,
-0.03047080896794796,
-0.9420496225357056,
0.4590190351009369,
-0.1656871885061264,
1.0414336919784546,
-0.6389020681381226,
0.9578213691711426,
0.7433239221572876,
-0.5546042323112488,
-0.9702767729759216,
-0.18803322315216064,
-0.2828112542629242,
-0.7664890289306641,
0.37527328729629517,
-0.19296683371067047,
0.28505247831344604,
-0.32216912508010864,
-0.4170832931995392,
-0.7733396291732788,
1.2024410963058472,
0.30689823627471924,
-0.566299319267273,
-0.42867350578308105,
0.18717439472675323,
0.882826030254364,
-0.17984910309314728,
0.5500690340995789,
0.6449640393257141,
0.10718201100826263,
0.0013430165126919746,
-1.6315622329711914,
0.1962902694940567,
-0.08103520423173904,
-0.035164184868335724,
-0.0006597454776056111,
-0.7173057794570923,
0.982498288154602,
-0.3691430687904358,
-0.14571942389011383,
0.39747217297554016,
0.33099040389060974,
0.5581100583076477,
0.6616694927215576,
0.40623578429222107,
0.16196714341640472,
0.7108778357505798,
0.11840765923261642,
1.3533107042312622,
-0.19189491868019104,
0.22691310942173004,
0.8121523261070251,
-0.4858225882053375,
1.0440309047698975,
0.20804734528064728,
-0.46499061584472656,
0.1742052435874939,
0.7635641098022461,
0.40465229749679565,
0.36212480068206787,
0.3085889220237732,
-0.1890145242214203,
-0.15985150635242462,
0.0009909048676490784,
-0.43302029371261597,
0.2764594852924347,
0.610406219959259,
-0.29694482684135437,
-0.09477344900369644,
0.14617010951042175,
0.022112322971224785,
-0.17632757127285004,
-0.34463733434677124,
0.6125879883766174,
0.4120303690433502,
-0.5905554890632629,
0.7658668756484985,
0.10655919462442398,
0.030864017084240913,
-0.45077162981033325,
-0.022626949474215508,
-0.34627851843833923,
0.22767411172389984,
0.10088673233985901,
-0.49373042583465576,
-0.05598384514451027,
0.057581864297389984,
0.043814897537231445,
0.3673052489757538,
0.8064936995506287,
-0.2902768850326538,
-0.29054033756256104,
0.13407109677791595,
0.7634176015853882,
0.3486204743385315,
-0.22537030279636383,
-0.7626813054084778,
0.0908099114894867,
-0.40269243717193604,
0.030335169285535812,
0.5422145128250122,
0.46441131830215454,
-0.30654338002204895,
0.794228196144104,
0.6674413681030273,
0.4016264081001282,
0.11051338911056519,
0.01252694334834814,
0.9207943081855774,
-0.5855202078819275,
-0.5426456332206726,
-0.4819066822528839,
-0.07208403199911118,
0.02415790781378746,
-0.4196294844150543,
0.612105667591095,
0.5113258361816406,
0.476261705160141,
-0.0896386057138443,
0.6082541942596436,
0.1030014157295227,
0.7562686204910278,
-0.3974873721599579,
0.8027591705322266,
-0.5780168771743774,
0.030026763677597046,
-0.0988628938794136,
-0.7588496208190918,
-0.19042207300662994,
0.1969224214553833,
-0.4648713171482086,
0.0994759052991867,
0.8518267273902893,
0.7463970184326172,
-0.22243905067443848,
0.19547635316848755,
0.6298580765724182,
0.4532946050167084,
0.43303412199020386,
0.8606016635894775,
0.687944233417511,
-0.20349529385566711,
0.09342348575592041,
-0.06875412911176682,
-0.6674362421035767,
-0.07936004549264908,
-0.3743385970592499,
-0.9990758895874023,
-0.44679349660873413,
0.01968458667397499,
-0.5788007378578186,
0.06441503763198853,
0.6860880255699158,
0.6498715281486511,
-0.68653804063797,
-0.1384223848581314,
0.5461564660072327,
-0.42124754190444946,
-0.27905911207199097,
-0.05752423033118248,
0.7235518097877502,
0.18378180265426636,
-0.3545997738838196,
0.2086300253868103,
0.3064371943473816,
0.013828501105308533,
-0.38839709758758545,
0.2750617563724518,
0.305193692445755,
0.32232555747032166,
0.7863076329231262,
0.3694349229335785,
-0.886102557182312,
0.047824084758758545,
0.27512961626052856,
-0.42150214314460754,
-0.26337096095085144,
0.9186306595802307,
-0.6525903344154358,
0.28340980410575867,
0.2746397852897644,
0.906205952167511,
0.3548808991909027,
-0.026154281571507454,
0.5771511793136597,
0.1969100832939148,
-0.1688189059495926,
0.4480735957622528,
0.3681808412075043,
0.038787972182035446,
-0.1525200605392456,
0.3948570489883423,
-0.06531920284032822,
-0.8036693334579468,
-0.7282175421714783,
-0.10400693118572235,
-1.4054421186447144,
-0.35069596767425537,
1.2330119609832764,
-0.09221352636814117,
-0.298001766204834,
-0.25074732303619385,
-0.5118127465248108,
-0.045953959226608276,
-0.10578564554452896,
0.7226207256317139,
0.5133139491081238,
-0.12773489952087402,
-0.013720715418457985,
-1.0110405683517456,
0.617705762386322,
0.36360129714012146,
-0.8587121367454529,
0.03271019831299782,
0.45918601751327515,
0.45474186539649963,
-0.13738998770713806,
1.3018910884857178,
-0.4751717150211334,
0.7359466552734375,
-0.10956297814846039,
-0.10502536594867706,
0.22222058475017548,
-0.15006963908672333,
-0.11218491196632385,
0.23673152923583984,
0.46300455927848816,
-0.006727062165737152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15877v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15877v1
|
Effective Unsupervised Constrained Text Generation based on Perturbed Masking
| 2024-04-24T13:42:26 | 2024-04-24T13:42:26 |
Yingwen Fu, Wenjie Ou, Zhou Yu, Yue Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Unsupervised constrained text generation aims to generate text under a given
set of constraints without any supervised data. Current state-of-the-art
methods stochastically sample edit positions and actions, which may cause
unnecessary search steps. In this paper, we propose PMCTG to improve
effectiveness by searching for the best edit position and action in each step.
Specifically, PMCTG extends perturbed masking technique to effectively search
for the most incongruent token to edit. Then it introduces four multi-aspect
scoring functions to select edit action to further reduce search difficulty.
Since PMCTG does not require supervised data, it could be applied to different
generation tasks. We show that under the unsupervised setting, PMCTG achieves
new state-of-the-art results in two representative tasks, namely
keywords-to-sentence generation and paraphrasing.
|
[
-0.1729077398777008,
-0.8318184018135071,
0.6301361322402954,
0.384677916765213,
-0.5655975341796875,
0.11048072576522827,
-0.16776642203330994,
0.19703347980976105,
0.10659602284431458,
0.6367315053939819,
-0.7562367916107178,
-0.8631873726844788,
-0.5348038077354431,
0.22708159685134888,
-0.1721765697002411,
0.7716776132583618,
-0.17270104587078094,
-0.34085071086883545,
-0.2853119373321533,
0.11285184323787689,
-0.2792893350124359,
-0.7034088969230652,
-0.3603457510471344,
-0.29817697405815125,
0.11605612933635712,
0.5598068833351135,
0.4788931906223297,
0.468076229095459,
0.3840585947036743,
0.2885572016239166,
-0.2803668677806854,
0.6278396248817444,
-0.26167944073677063,
0.3331737816333771,
-0.24332034587860107,
0.02068767137825489,
-0.261036217212677,
0.10691158473491669,
0.6479684114456177,
0.4510119557380676,
-0.33907783031463623,
-0.16591079533100128,
0.1708543300628662,
0.4541224539279938,
-0.7075163722038269,
-0.05531138554215431,
-0.6796326637268066,
0.1983969807624817,
-0.4498230516910553,
-0.2470388263463974,
-0.12993988394737244,
0.06223510950803757,
-0.07455459237098694,
-0.6622439026832581,
0.46169158816337585,
-0.06153441593050957,
0.5059319138526917,
0.250460684299469,
-0.4032331109046936,
-0.13334274291992188,
-0.2940817177295685,
0.6545243859291077,
-0.6139082908630371,
0.1372152417898178,
0.3258824050426483,
-0.2842768132686615,
-0.5734528303146362,
-0.912032425403595,
-0.6306623220443726,
0.03230905160307884,
-0.053667400032281876,
0.3521927297115326,
-0.1502285748720169,
0.5221705436706543,
0.3117610812187195,
0.4256976246833801,
-0.26000744104385376,
0.047745998948812485,
0.03223467618227005,
-0.5615442991256714,
0.5807892680168152,
0.10397341847419739,
-0.11388039588928223,
-0.8660817742347717,
-0.3902047872543335,
-0.1888570636510849,
-0.5635981559753418,
0.1292995810508728,
0.8092615008354187,
0.12661653757095337,
0.4358311593532562,
0.6597267389297485,
-0.46224910020828247,
0.5747639536857605,
0.40378716588020325,
-0.08157234638929367,
-0.08192546665668488,
-0.5316431522369385,
-0.25840502977371216,
-0.068741075694561,
1.0218510627746582,
0.24690717458724976,
-0.41213491559028625,
0.0733916237950325,
-0.3843047320842743,
-0.3218592703342438,
0.4113609790802002,
-0.7465091347694397,
-0.5031290650367737,
-0.06322028487920761,
-0.367058128118515,
-0.5595613718032837,
0.3285983204841614,
-0.75602787733078,
-0.36368584632873535,
-0.1027522161602974,
0.3945140540599823,
-0.40789318084716797,
0.05693264678120613,
0.09527015686035156,
-0.022577710449695587,
-0.2640010416507721,
0.27433428168296814,
-0.461121141910553,
-0.17626939713954926,
0.2818478047847748,
0.6909874677658081,
-0.30502599477767944,
-0.11295389384031296,
-0.6761265993118286,
0.044192880392074585,
-0.38825806975364685,
0.8076962828636169,
-0.7764056921005249,
-0.49080219864845276,
0.07433128356933594,
-0.20108836889266968,
0.05654893442988396,
-0.41505855321884155,
0.7978113889694214,
-0.10288061946630478,
0.39601629972457886,
-0.1377706378698349,
-0.3866673707962036,
-0.20187786221504211,
0.039688590914011,
-0.4361439347267151,
1.2195724248886108,
0.33815765380859375,
-0.7311065793037415,
0.3943997621536255,
-0.7628363966941833,
-0.6840687990188599,
0.15346142649650574,
-0.10204260051250458,
-0.8179736137390137,
0.5300165414810181,
0.6600929498672485,
0.5645625591278076,
-0.10935681313276291,
0.35770925879478455,
0.17730839550495148,
-0.11616912484169006,
0.24211984872817993,
-0.30489104986190796,
0.375631719827652,
0.19680637121200562,
-0.4558391273021698,
0.2812437117099762,
-0.8125991821289062,
0.06811486929655075,
-0.1777420938014984,
-0.5883378982543945,
-0.13655732572078705,
0.23416486382484436,
0.07798431813716888,
0.1987629532814026,
0.043218158185482025,
-0.6008428335189819,
0.19903787970542908,
-0.17448657751083374,
0.7229403257369995,
0.6998613476753235,
0.4495602250099182,
0.35512638092041016,
-0.1824091225862503,
0.6307390332221985,
0.07968087494373322,
0.2619168162345886,
-0.29714545607566833,
-0.2670328617095947,
-0.5927444696426392,
-0.37760844826698303,
0.40006428956985474,
0.3906269371509552,
-1.117242455482483,
0.5853034853935242,
0.4413289725780487,
-0.33963531255722046,
-0.3842029869556427,
0.28558647632598877,
0.5493243932723999,
0.3697417974472046,
0.27045968174934387,
-0.48915529251098633,
-0.4993644058704376,
-0.8754660487174988,
-0.10879139602184296,
0.03438878431916237,
-0.11453952640295029,
0.23363356292247772,
0.1286432296037674,
-0.11518916487693787,
0.528420627117157,
-0.5435048937797546,
-0.40516409277915955,
-0.21707527339458466,
0.4708770215511322,
-0.09828296303749084,
0.5650591254234314,
0.16799518465995789,
-0.8998991250991821,
-0.24783965945243835,
-0.4064295291900635,
-0.20459505915641785,
-0.4584653079509735,
-0.37982797622680664,
-0.2281254231929779,
0.11445523053407669,
0.7297529578208923,
-0.5801099538803101,
0.44285157322883606,
0.5256809592247009,
-0.152495339512825,
0.49902021884918213,
-0.3463049829006195,
0.35322093963623047,
-1.152420997619629,
-0.09311166405677795,
-0.10131962597370148,
-0.39927053451538086,
-0.52855384349823,
0.3575684428215027,
0.17719514667987823,
-0.22131168842315674,
-0.39765480160713196,
-0.11771281063556671,
-0.5443785786628723,
0.6138513684272766,
-0.45290809869766235,
0.22979404032230377,
-0.062272001057863235,
0.42256519198417664,
-0.12576435506343842,
0.6569265723228455,
0.5132417678833008,
-0.6585122346878052,
0.1470259428024292,
0.2968190312385559,
-0.48106083273887634,
0.4722469747066498,
-0.36540916562080383,
0.47710859775543213,
-0.18372724950313568,
0.11939769983291626,
-1.052683711051941,
-0.22878508269786835,
0.015092716552317142,
-0.32349058985710144,
0.41266530752182007,
0.16433919966220856,
-0.6701586246490479,
-0.24461781978607178,
-0.5032325387001038,
0.3170665204524994,
0.16594478487968445,
-0.5571081638336182,
0.41488295793533325,
0.29336026310920715,
0.04162070155143738,
-0.43253129720687866,
-0.33904746174812317,
0.24118655920028687,
-0.13162967562675476,
-0.35823148488998413,
0.899741530418396,
0.02602759376168251,
0.14505347609519958,
-0.3044815957546234,
-0.4438712000846863,
0.1627514660358429,
-0.03619720786809921,
0.15198832750320435,
-0.14532102644443512,
0.09675740450620651,
-0.009940721094608307,
0.4362584948539734,
-0.019371194764971733,
-0.28219103813171387,
-0.21595190465450287,
0.43543654680252075,
0.5392285585403442,
-0.06349756568670273,
-0.27893224358558655,
0.6305320262908936,
0.4054599404335022,
-0.3255901038646698,
0.23618732392787933,
0.41827139258384705,
-0.23935867846012115,
-0.4168983995914459,
-0.5088275671005249,
-0.06940808892250061,
-0.5208187699317932,
0.5629064440727234,
-0.416342169046402,
-1.1205030679702759,
0.2204115241765976,
-0.26971176266670227,
0.01769525744020939,
0.38227716088294983,
0.38600242137908936,
0.014442448504269123,
1.0209898948669434,
0.7875477075576782,
0.42241984605789185,
0.6549457311630249,
0.20838738977909088,
0.23759415745735168,
-0.9777572154998779,
-0.19890674948692322,
-0.3495289385318756,
-0.38851043581962585,
-0.7985763549804688,
-0.5808217525482178,
0.42946186661720276,
0.6786242127418518,
0.16503772139549255,
0.3386066257953644,
-1.0738930702209473,
0.3918621838092804,
0.9096882343292236,
0.4079263508319855,
0.20327933132648468,
-0.030864451080560684,
-0.397020161151886,
-0.21859672665596008,
-0.7406469583511353,
-0.4398437738418579,
1.083768606185913,
-0.32144635915756226,
0.5354586243629456,
-0.16500388085842133,
0.6524479389190674,
0.13199050724506378,
0.06947261095046997,
-0.4862254559993744,
0.5726880431175232,
-0.4932290017604828,
-0.32065415382385254,
-0.2657860815525055,
-0.32108405232429504,
-0.6953309178352356,
0.12283487617969513,
-0.5283116102218628,
-0.621749758720398,
-0.040341541171073914,
0.16555313766002655,
-0.34412798285484314,
0.3260893225669861,
-0.49195724725723267,
0.47357475757598877,
0.005437865853309631,
-0.2261396199464798,
-0.06891989707946777,
-0.3774057626724243,
0.19924978911876678,
-0.2609320282936096,
-0.1430160254240036,
0.1741415411233902,
0.007672711741179228,
0.8371707201004028,
-0.5727168321609497,
0.6266576051712036,
-0.18262197077274323,
0.20371577143669128,
0.5171303749084473,
0.1515241265296936,
0.695311427116394,
0.13261838257312775,
-0.006618773564696312,
-0.05321376025676727,
-0.37193554639816284,
-0.24606895446777344,
-0.48668530583381653,
0.6727468371391296,
-0.3730907738208771,
-0.8624443411827087,
-0.25371646881103516,
-0.5837417244911194,
-0.1457556039094925,
0.13094154000282288,
0.7871647477149963,
0.13306188583374023,
-0.032365813851356506,
0.27940499782562256,
0.6150615215301514,
-0.3675507605075836,
0.7631683349609375,
0.2928234934806824,
0.18163195252418518,
-0.7359083294868469,
0.5025914311408997,
0.03113572485744953,
-0.029371337965130806,
0.6781589984893799,
0.4804571270942688,
-0.2975054681301117,
-0.8717575073242188,
-0.15325433015823364,
0.039161693304777145,
-0.349418967962265,
-0.6064134836196899,
-0.6583919525146484,
-0.1726822555065155,
-0.550534725189209,
-0.27284687757492065,
-0.2004784643650055,
-0.5291646718978882,
-0.35886910557746887,
-0.2410856932401657,
0.16089537739753723,
0.5683601498603821,
-0.2150624841451645,
0.6459531188011169,
-0.47121942043304443,
0.18977688252925873,
0.4787234961986542,
0.11652159690856934,
-0.47577545046806335,
-0.26070964336395264,
0.14788159728050232,
-0.2874642014503479,
-0.9398874640464783,
-0.8951854109764099,
0.13378745317459106,
0.146793395280838,
0.4994656443595886,
0.46558281779289246,
0.3344106078147888,
0.7545477151870728,
-0.399547815322876,
0.9247349500656128,
0.4323700964450836,
-1.3473504781723022,
0.7130861878395081,
-0.34154048562049866,
0.41431382298469543,
0.41921332478523254,
-0.03828240931034088,
-0.4337925910949707,
-0.685624361038208,
-0.742522656917572,
-1.1002744436264038,
0.8068025708198547,
0.5695568323135376,
0.14116907119750977,
0.0710839033126831,
0.7816236615180969,
0.19620883464813232,
0.5523738861083984,
-0.5619734525680542,
0.01741213910281658,
-0.41816446185112,
-0.011810068972408772,
-0.05955832079052925,
-0.39525771141052246,
0.131214901804924,
-0.13543540239334106,
0.6316865086555481,
-0.11482261121273041,
0.26414576172828674,
0.6423039436340332,
0.09160807728767395,
-0.1704203188419342,
0.2957249581813812,
0.7817357182502747,
0.4410397708415985,
0.12596538662910461,
0.3602224290370941,
-0.021250810474157333,
-0.5343800783157349,
-0.044519297778606415,
0.15490905940532684,
-0.4266955256462097,
0.14124666154384613,
0.2605333924293518,
0.7490901947021484,
0.11069227010011673,
-0.5447863936424255,
0.5635974407196045,
0.26613786816596985,
-0.5947113633155823,
0.012895467691123486,
0.1351005882024765,
-0.3319208025932312,
0.2961880564689636,
0.35804978013038635,
-0.045642901211977005,
0.03754503279924393,
-0.18867763876914978,
0.36432719230651855,
0.4317498803138733,
-0.322357714176178,
-0.1458793729543686,
0.8366082906723022,
0.06363913416862488,
-0.609329342842102,
0.46888482570648193,
-0.43091174960136414,
-0.805621862411499,
0.24883180856704712,
0.5912832021713257,
0.8419702649116516,
-0.452000230550766,
0.5228638648986816,
0.37874528765678406,
0.5504911541938782,
-0.19190645217895508,
0.22647014260292053,
-0.34302517771720886,
-0.4906691312789917,
-0.6523094773292542,
-0.610460638999939,
-0.45095786452293396,
0.5691545009613037,
-0.3226996064186096,
0.2575622498989105,
-0.4469327926635742,
-0.1049293652176857,
-0.07739386707544327,
0.039204858243465424,
-0.38160136342048645,
0.28659626841545105,
-0.341309130191803,
0.3849095404148102,
-0.48540666699409485,
0.6087948083877563,
0.9634768962860107,
-0.11351285129785538,
-0.6867307424545288,
0.16585427522659302,
-0.0980047956109047,
-0.4982021152973175,
0.057985205203294754,
0.07322915643453598,
0.0636250302195549,
-0.12045276910066605,
-0.6358150839805603,
-0.5630800127983093,
0.868507444858551,
0.3137001395225525,
-0.5165286660194397,
-0.14305976033210754,
0.04236370325088501,
0.26658353209495544,
-0.27102524042129517,
-0.08133415877819061,
0.3645147979259491,
0.4454340934753418,
0.14247627556324005,
-0.6915704607963562,
0.31855055689811707,
0.015840832144021988,
0.19981354475021362,
0.5864548087120056,
-0.7277143001556396,
0.9045217633247375,
0.09982861578464508,
-0.22703596949577332,
0.15797767043113708,
0.440965861082077,
0.06417147070169449,
0.2433813512325287,
0.5318815112113953,
0.6985222697257996,
0.6900787949562073,
-0.16100214421749115,
0.6739600896835327,
0.005015803966671228,
0.2351721078157425,
0.8077570796012878,
0.1618342250585556,
0.5316593647003174,
0.4731970727443695,
0.026060575619339943,
0.2362549602985382,
0.5601191520690918,
0.09371761977672577,
0.712843656539917,
0.3701622188091278,
-0.37380632758140564,
-0.5738913416862488,
0.08740471303462982,
0.3032059669494629,
0.6599535942077637,
0.0655951276421547,
-0.45010754466056824,
-0.2659979462623596,
0.20556746423244476,
0.3016319274902344,
0.49842286109924316,
-0.22413884103298187,
0.7706909775733948,
-0.16935588419437408,
-0.7788625955581665,
0.15897278487682343,
0.46559327840805054,
0.8201749324798584,
-0.5161857604980469,
-0.025202607735991478,
-0.2124037742614746,
0.008261349983513355,
-0.26624569296836853,
-0.6020907759666443,
0.14371362328529358,
-0.02064458839595318,
-0.11590926349163055,
-0.5676320195198059,
0.7800119519233704,
-0.42975279688835144,
-0.4510836899280548,
-0.1813453584909439,
0.26313525438308716,
-0.08570501208305359,
-0.5651395320892334,
-0.3671896457672119,
-0.347555547952652,
0.3597950041294098,
-0.38311368227005005,
0.20005322992801666,
0.7511817216873169,
-0.019687946885824203,
0.03127066045999527,
0.7040824294090271,
0.06735409796237946,
-0.08226168155670166,
-0.3158904016017914,
0.713358461856842,
-0.7350139021873474,
-0.5217550992965698,
-0.728649377822876,
0.5034934282302856,
-0.271280974149704,
-0.5476212501525879,
0.6999813318252563,
0.474773108959198,
0.6971957683563232,
0.2790263295173645,
0.7307306528091431,
-0.13493402302265167,
0.31971117854118347,
-0.6849796772003174,
0.5950356125831604,
-0.5297742486000061,
0.014158510603010654,
-0.6433732509613037,
-1.0415290594100952,
-0.5334378480911255,
0.7756198048591614,
0.07979007065296173,
-0.22465194761753082,
1.024092674255371,
0.8785756230354309,
0.02099541202187538,
-0.05990124121308327,
0.4538609981536865,
-0.054268866777420044,
0.501185417175293,
0.5626637935638428,
0.6834059357643127,
-0.37058326601982117,
0.6221787333488464,
-0.5369661450386047,
-0.4202919900417328,
0.11709899455308914,
-1.1504065990447998,
-1.0072659254074097,
-0.8676825761795044,
-0.6216399669647217,
-0.24079670011997223,
-0.25880667567253113,
0.6420243978500366,
0.7981893420219421,
-0.5758424997329712,
0.241440549492836,
-0.4986865222454071,
0.19249263405799866,
-0.37637341022491455,
-0.20467336475849152,
0.5634796023368835,
-0.28449222445487976,
-0.7357125878334045,
0.558968722820282,
0.4877740740776062,
-0.1027848869562149,
-0.01347699761390686,
0.32967060804367065,
-0.12137774378061295,
0.2903415262699127,
0.7387112975120544,
-0.13027876615524292,
-0.49380970001220703,
-0.4582795202732086,
-0.06327900290489197,
0.14726655185222626,
0.08719111979007721,
1.3622714281082153,
-0.49839603900909424,
0.5634952783584595,
0.3819698393344879,
0.42234721779823303,
0.6581364274024963,
0.25782135128974915,
0.3436206877231598,
-1.248968243598938,
0.020260177552700043,
0.2627755403518677,
0.14367146790027618,
0.3460143506526947,
-0.5129817724227905,
0.18158091604709625,
0.3664703071117401,
-0.6398687362670898,
-0.6075006127357483,
0.29466864466667175,
-0.875347912311554,
-0.4935227632522583,
1.2179396152496338,
0.07682128250598907,
0.04885747283697128,
0.02155904285609722,
-0.49623745679855347,
0.46449366211891174,
-0.4915744960308075,
0.9761804342269897,
0.7694490551948547,
-0.349977970123291,
-0.27288708090782166,
-0.044313497841358185,
0.5490115880966187,
0.4720984697341919,
-0.6790121793746948,
-0.05620536580681801,
0.5842732191085815,
0.026993343606591225,
0.14053842425346375,
0.5182050466537476,
-0.22735640406608582,
0.1520891636610031,
-0.12006979435682297,
-0.06416556984186172,
-0.42645856738090515,
-0.16251373291015625,
-0.07125593721866608,
0.5676749348640442,
-0.20006483793258667,
-0.3663783669471741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15848v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15848v2
|
Detecting Conceptual Abstraction in LLMs
| 2024-04-24T12:52:45 | 2024-04-25T23:11:20 |
Michaela Regneri, Alhassan Abdelhalim, Sören Laue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present a novel approach to detecting noun abstraction within a large
language model (LLM). Starting from a psychologically motivated set of noun
pairs in taxonomic relationships, we instantiate surface patterns indicating
hypernymy and analyze the attention matrices produced by BERT. We compare the
results to two sets of counterfactuals and show that we can detect hypernymy in
the abstraction mechanism, which cannot solely be related to the distributional
similarity of noun pairs. Our findings are a first step towards the
explainability of conceptual abstraction in LLMs.
|
[
-0.6796590089797974,
-1.0965043306350708,
0.9817746877670288,
0.29118606448173523,
-0.1761196255683899,
0.022168373689055443,
-0.17163527011871338,
-0.525353729724884,
0.5232736468315125,
0.31714168190956116,
-0.7946648001670837,
-0.5874778628349304,
-0.6514203548431396,
0.037229884415864944,
-0.8706657886505127,
0.682478666305542,
-0.256778359413147,
-0.3910764157772064,
-0.6903433799743652,
0.12669581174850464,
-0.0370669811964035,
-0.47995525598526,
-0.6312270164489746,
-0.5605319142341614,
0.6908767819404602,
-0.011213553138077259,
0.33636021614074707,
0.9598417282104492,
0.5887845158576965,
0.41022932529449463,
-0.12437042593955994,
0.14770139753818512,
-0.5053439736366272,
0.14032410085201263,
-0.132342129945755,
-0.38047704100608826,
-0.4370962381362915,
0.14534133672714233,
0.4896373152732849,
0.6554499864578247,
0.10836050659418106,
0.18352238833904266,
-0.03753279894590378,
0.6292383074760437,
-0.7911271452903748,
0.3824036717414856,
-0.7073245644569397,
-0.18460625410079956,
-0.3793538510799408,
-0.24912403523921967,
-0.4325019419193268,
0.14165031909942627,
0.12350007891654968,
-0.5846430659294128,
0.07352474331855774,
-0.10575312376022339,
0.9339364171028137,
0.133669912815094,
-0.09002479910850525,
-0.359505295753479,
-0.5547837018966675,
0.7926462292671204,
-0.38203123211860657,
0.5249932408332825,
0.30976757407188416,
-0.11889561265707016,
-0.21553905308246613,
-0.7108850479125977,
-0.8503340482711792,
-0.37896454334259033,
-0.26823166012763977,
0.17216522991657257,
-0.46019044518470764,
-0.013559741899371147,
0.22625479102134705,
0.05058513209223747,
-0.5098450779914856,
0.011184802278876305,
0.022484516724944115,
-0.14153093099594116,
0.3897659182548523,
0.243932843208313,
0.38111966848373413,
-0.3346448540687561,
-0.795281708240509,
0.5371624231338501,
-0.6096007227897644,
-0.3210931420326233,
0.1282275766134262,
0.05733451619744301,
-0.42800337076187134,
0.48434698581695557,
-0.13496972620487213,
0.7380911111831665,
-0.029542716220021248,
0.0654408261179924,
0.06006745621562004,
-0.2424384355545044,
-0.10751903057098389,
0.18692933022975922,
0.4801379144191742,
0.3184727728366852,
0.6685177683830261,
-0.3959989845752716,
-0.3208024203777313,
0.35389453172683716,
0.15579308569431305,
-0.54643714427948,
-0.2944122552871704,
0.3340396285057068,
-0.3681170642375946,
-0.21780414879322052,
-0.2427450567483902,
-0.04645919427275658,
-0.134665384888649,
-0.7331483960151672,
0.4866063594818115,
-0.31765463948249817,
-0.5467230677604675,
-0.08329351991415024,
-0.1936611533164978,
0.3000366687774658,
0.042428113520145416,
-0.7908039689064026,
0.4042896032333374,
1.0668444633483887,
1.115132212638855,
-0.48483189940452576,
-0.330718994140625,
0.09014181047677994,
0.4621281623840332,
-0.6513791084289551,
1.034209966659546,
-0.46169203519821167,
0.003409797791391611,
-0.2566189169883728,
-0.22577065229415894,
0.041931863874197006,
-0.6853873133659363,
-0.17320506274700165,
-0.6172338724136353,
-0.12818023562431335,
-0.19490638375282288,
-0.733234703540802,
-0.07091313600540161,
0.6015253663063049,
-0.5972359776496887,
0.9372453093528748,
0.19062407314777374,
-0.8567415475845337,
0.1938401460647583,
-0.6177190542221069,
0.020041240379214287,
0.1318371295928955,
-0.23391741514205933,
0.03435550257563591,
0.13868269324302673,
-0.272022545337677,
0.5874974727630615,
-0.028192302212119102,
0.2798157334327698,
-0.5276654362678528,
-0.3941490054130554,
0.4526199996471405,
0.11926470696926117,
0.8482965230941772,
0.004880818072706461,
-0.03631550446152687,
0.12606431543827057,
-0.903516411781311,
-0.13603618741035461,
-0.019228879362344742,
-0.18143527209758759,
-0.8943510055541992,
-0.10096251219511032,
-0.0334785021841526,
0.330228716135025,
0.36509111523628235,
-0.5343782305717468,
-0.13208353519439697,
-0.3858836889266968,
0.16539356112480164,
0.8873823881149292,
0.24311725795269012,
0.17921555042266846,
-0.32217472791671753,
0.24353088438510895,
0.46410778164863586,
-0.3382038176059723,
0.03715095669031143,
-0.43088504672050476,
-0.913109302520752,
-0.82417893409729,
0.40468183159828186,
0.27386483550071716,
-0.4928891956806183,
0.6274713277816772,
-0.26346465945243835,
-0.30254894495010376,
-0.2621918022632599,
0.31191059947013855,
0.5728693008422852,
0.46938279271125793,
0.06382248550653458,
-0.5356910228729248,
-0.8010736107826233,
-1.1088560819625854,
-0.10815232992172241,
-0.3369215726852417,
0.0931149497628212,
0.09316682070493698,
0.5991277098655701,
-0.30029281973838806,
0.9702648520469666,
-0.3165386915206909,
-0.18804314732551575,
-0.0677773728966713,
0.35157936811447144,
0.25626033544540405,
0.3444610834121704,
0.7641664147377014,
-0.3995743691921234,
-0.1353251338005066,
-0.20579315721988678,
-0.9890108704566956,
-0.19490569829940796,
0.05111117288470268,
-0.437781423330307,
0.20220664143562317,
1.1746001243591309,
-0.8741787672042847,
0.29413747787475586,
0.25229230523109436,
-0.2448691576719284,
0.48549842834472656,
0.0807349905371666,
-0.5080717206001282,
-0.8829016089439392,
-0.08777865767478943,
0.15497753024101257,
-0.11508791148662567,
-0.6855654120445251,
0.35462698340415955,
-0.145137220621109,
0.562461256980896,
-0.4435403347015381,
0.5542498230934143,
-0.4876096546649933,
-0.27046018838882446,
-0.4034969210624695,
0.3189854323863983,
-0.35004308819770813,
0.6382143497467041,
0.33720114827156067,
0.2658053934574127,
0.5555148720741272,
-0.874797523021698,
0.5761051774024963,
0.024667639285326004,
-0.5783569812774658,
0.5951080918312073,
-0.6897721886634827,
0.056277673691511154,
-0.5425455570220947,
0.1393928974866867,
-1.6827585697174072,
-0.20443540811538696,
0.3430463969707489,
-0.42039093375205994,
-0.035474009811878204,
-0.05420425906777382,
-0.4341702163219452,
-0.1344393640756607,
-0.29790180921554565,
0.2908065915107727,
0.1306832730770111,
-0.43513837456703186,
0.48838210105895996,
0.2849399745464325,
-0.22724191844463348,
-0.3981907069683075,
-0.7156339883804321,
-0.0940733328461647,
-0.24373382329940796,
-0.33168652653694153,
0.2403016984462738,
-0.011510467156767845,
-0.7231931686401367,
0.17566242814064026,
-0.09050877392292023,
-0.011141892522573471,
0.4793037474155426,
0.35853278636932373,
0.35667216777801514,
-0.3471798002719879,
0.2715146839618683,
-0.22777028381824493,
-0.06761273741722107,
0.8184024095535278,
-0.22297385334968567,
0.715143084526062,
0.24998612701892853,
-0.07612041383981705,
-0.4725932776927948,
0.11347579956054688,
0.7490764260292053,
0.0035269148647785187,
0.5555494427680969,
0.6121007204055786,
-0.6793199777603149,
-0.110682412981987,
-0.20369309186935425,
-0.12321183830499649,
-0.4572184383869171,
0.45994871854782104,
-0.6820846199989319,
-0.31793245673179626,
0.7537693381309509,
-0.024594655260443687,
-0.026673797518014908,
0.1575920432806015,
1.0011142492294312,
-0.2681584060192108,
0.7595602869987488,
0.4986378848552704,
-0.02022393047809601,
0.5165358781814575,
-0.44358694553375244,
0.1029222160577774,
-0.905680239200592,
-0.37357470393180847,
-0.29100003838539124,
-0.7180200219154358,
-0.7468985915184021,
-0.08151904493570328,
0.2783287465572357,
-0.01500725094228983,
-0.375139445066452,
0.161921426653862,
-0.16794370114803314,
0.6805869936943054,
0.43613141775131226,
0.24134598672389984,
0.3672176003456116,
0.07610297948122025,
-0.3026930093765259,
0.06303522735834122,
-0.33508697152137756,
-0.44910961389541626,
1.1007243394851685,
0.20968641340732574,
0.5637654066085815,
0.43447962403297424,
1.067301630973816,
0.28391024470329285,
0.6132124662399292,
-1.1735235452651978,
0.8007919788360596,
-0.00772689376026392,
-0.6004453301429749,
-0.32970261573791504,
-0.23135769367218018,
-1.0544856786727905,
0.21472686529159546,
-0.13112163543701172,
-0.9828552007675171,
0.15722787380218506,
-0.013652635738253593,
-0.21471451222896576,
-0.06761384755373001,
-0.46902960538864136,
0.5791958570480347,
0.12179974466562271,
-0.24715447425842285,
-0.2711992859840393,
-0.37228885293006897,
0.851710855960846,
-0.19726711511611938,
0.2602015733718872,
-0.41892823576927185,
-0.3956484794616699,
0.9287009239196777,
-0.016771070659160614,
0.7864611148834229,
-0.10482857376337051,
-0.5933152437210083,
0.1261177510023117,
0.5039469003677368,
0.20938503742218018,
-0.07089877873659134,
0.15210622549057007,
-0.09888111799955368,
-0.325218141078949,
-0.3839268982410431,
-0.6237398386001587,
1.074868083000183,
-0.7478110790252686,
-0.6146884560585022,
-0.30855825543403625,
-1.0747888088226318,
-0.39978092908859253,
0.18340200185775757,
-0.0053140087984502316,
0.14368103444576263,
-0.20792634785175323,
-0.2234107255935669,
0.817747175693512,
0.355854868888855,
0.6352989077568054,
0.5223813056945801,
-0.49710896611213684,
0.29229578375816345,
0.8247827887535095,
0.07340450584888458,
0.2040795534849167,
0.2789400815963745,
0.009609060361981392,
-0.3042067885398865,
-0.6399165391921997,
-0.07900825887918472,
0.40220025181770325,
-0.605859637260437,
0.05641347914934158,
-0.6456542015075684,
-0.25155574083328247,
-0.14199621975421906,
0.365344762802124,
-0.14933820068836212,
-0.554948091506958,
-0.07325799763202667,
-0.08823534101247787,
0.44578230381011963,
0.9614781141281128,
-0.19424521923065186,
0.18680340051651,
-0.3937476873397827,
0.792540431022644,
0.4963233172893524,
0.23670732975006104,
0.2289055436849594,
-0.6540857553482056,
0.022579766809940338,
-0.18465282022953033,
-0.041843194514513016,
-0.7542259097099304,
0.11269863694906235,
0.07680625468492508,
0.5570919513702393,
0.9648910760879517,
-0.16202481091022491,
0.6205079555511475,
-0.30395427346229553,
0.4984261095523834,
0.18967793881893158,
-1.029546856880188,
0.29965946078300476,
-0.44515231251716614,
0.14027175307273865,
-0.10459928214550018,
0.8445685505867004,
-0.5349105000495911,
-0.6841071248054504,
-0.7420206665992737,
-0.890203058719635,
0.5614868998527527,
-0.04389308765530586,
0.2779223322868347,
-0.2465716004371643,
0.3420916795730591,
-0.16701743006706238,
0.07745721191167831,
-0.6609429717063904,
-0.3290567994117737,
0.2933657467365265,
-0.21788817644119263,
-0.0831221491098404,
-0.32430556416511536,
-0.24747778475284576,
-0.26571914553642273,
0.44667747616767883,
0.11258119344711304,
0.4345708191394806,
0.042486436665058136,
-0.32806411385536194,
-0.2592303156852722,
-0.04437725991010666,
0.5726389288902283,
1.0690462589263916,
-0.3234668970108032,
0.5634363889694214,
-0.20407690107822418,
-0.24000316858291626,
0.20842131972312927,
-0.2199789434671402,
-0.16391679644584656,
0.4774862825870514,
0.7959038615226746,
0.4068603813648224,
0.3079306185245514,
-0.4693065583705902,
0.35274702310562134,
0.3396817147731781,
-0.45991718769073486,
-0.2924659848213196,
0.05164264142513275,
0.6121163368225098,
0.19057679176330566,
0.12700553238391876,
-0.3150850832462311,
0.19402067363262177,
-0.878930926322937,
0.31627094745635986,
0.6493207216262817,
-0.2598975598812103,
-0.2979249656200409,
0.17889536917209625,
-0.09084098041057587,
-0.04732247442007065,
0.5790588855743408,
-0.26818782091140747,
-0.5040314793586731,
0.7931678891181946,
0.659902036190033,
0.661973237991333,
-0.14361651241779327,
0.08771266043186188,
0.1239137053489685,
0.18161076307296753,
0.18676379323005676,
0.5774228572845459,
-0.1013675332069397,
-1.1523606777191162,
-0.48756682872772217,
-0.4665648937225342,
-0.16162340342998505,
0.6646667122840881,
-0.9583014845848083,
0.013976780697703362,
-0.647200345993042,
0.0387393981218338,
0.8803190588951111,
-0.5147508382797241,
-0.3750007450580597,
-0.03231790289282799,
0.6400080323219299,
0.7663367986679077,
-1.0243157148361206,
0.7452223896980286,
0.878661572933197,
-0.020625529810786247,
-0.28986164927482605,
0.033622998744249344,
0.02947819232940674,
-1.1244081258773804,
1.2866156101226807,
0.05316147580742836,
-0.3959306478500366,
0.09674059599637985,
-0.764371931552887,
-0.941983699798584,
0.6305418014526367,
0.3480389416217804,
-0.49360087513923645,
-0.05757616460323334,
-0.14158567786216736,
0.49719589948654175,
-0.27705979347229004,
0.1375059187412262,
0.9322105646133423,
0.6853840947151184,
-0.2416336089372635,
-0.6312302947044373,
0.1610444337129593,
-0.02359546720981598,
0.25935855507850647,
0.43392130732536316,
-0.5075420141220093,
0.8784634470939636,
-0.28138503432273865,
-0.4312623143196106,
0.2603550851345062,
0.8053482174873352,
0.36295783519744873,
0.40978556871414185,
0.6092950701713562,
0.8401527404785156,
0.5419816374778748,
-0.1481218785047531,
0.7654449939727783,
-0.30905622243881226,
0.2716870903968811,
0.9895142912864685,
-0.19786149263381958,
0.7808178663253784,
0.9411557912826538,
-0.29410430788993835,
0.915238618850708,
0.6453105211257935,
0.18567830324172974,
0.5362736582756042,
0.7796863913536072,
-0.3688841462135315,
-0.5460335612297058,
-0.306212842464447,
-0.16823707520961761,
0.7576442360877991,
0.7717927694320679,
-0.2902636229991913,
-0.4307247996330261,
-0.14362749457359314,
-0.06526995450258255,
0.1746859848499298,
-0.6242074370384216,
0.9646162390708923,
0.16106951236724854,
-0.4397948384284973,
0.8910109996795654,
0.05293659493327141,
0.6634923815727234,
-0.36839646100997925,
-0.04567926749587059,
-0.1433977633714676,
0.23715390264987946,
-0.2718636393547058,
-0.6374644637107849,
0.15364228188991547,
-0.15148532390594482,
-0.3387364447116852,
-0.03758719190955162,
0.5820654630661011,
-0.5738537311553955,
-0.34880027174949646,
0.3827120363712311,
1.0141959190368652,
0.4405967593193054,
0.08656919747591019,
-0.5859720706939697,
-0.05076627805829048,
-0.5446353554725647,
-0.3509962856769562,
0.14344422519207,
0.7889022827148438,
-0.3304748237133026,
0.792871356010437,
0.612693727016449,
0.21135185658931732,
0.1120273768901825,
0.07942526787519455,
0.6219258904457092,
-0.6663778424263,
-0.4348461925983429,
-1.179688572883606,
-0.15039731562137604,
0.2086867243051529,
-0.060304220765829086,
0.685101330280304,
0.45630577206611633,
1.1608755588531494,
-0.21267488598823547,
0.6492081880569458,
0.09797912836074829,
0.2947160303592682,
-0.6290639638900757,
0.49829140305519104,
-0.376440167427063,
0.11261020600795746,
-0.24681514501571655,
-0.7854533791542053,
-0.21676504611968994,
0.5331689715385437,
-0.14525917172431946,
-0.16407036781311035,
0.6769984364509583,
0.9428452253341675,
-0.23668989539146423,
-0.21429023146629333,
0.23973765969276428,
0.6005187630653381,
-0.365865558385849,
0.6258659362792969,
1.4339245557785034,
0.12165717780590057,
0.24744431674480438,
-0.04408277943730354,
-0.11613494902849197,
-0.09311041235923767,
-0.7416344881057739,
-1.0361964702606201,
-0.50481116771698,
-0.48620665073394775,
-0.32900160551071167,
0.09780006110668182,
0.9532586336135864,
0.6088997721672058,
-0.8595877289772034,
-0.4309224784374237,
-0.23171937465667725,
0.42839547991752625,
-0.48494940996170044,
-0.2591158449649811,
0.32449600100517273,
-0.5226131081581116,
-0.8119674921035767,
0.035072021186351776,
0.14569517970085144,
0.13911829888820648,
-0.40359219908714294,
0.06513889878988266,
-0.567201554775238,
0.2166527658700943,
0.7397961020469666,
-0.15305648744106293,
-0.9904742240905762,
-0.1653432995080948,
-0.36662325263023376,
-0.24484016001224518,
-0.11980248242616653,
0.9915290474891663,
-0.7153404355049133,
0.14479854702949524,
0.6278891563415527,
0.528494119644165,
0.33225658535957336,
-0.1858496069908142,
0.21655049920082092,
-0.9330896139144897,
0.1500978171825409,
-0.11807413399219513,
0.40177425742149353,
-0.039662010967731476,
-0.1874479353427887,
0.2695061266422272,
0.5141597390174866,
0.19751256704330444,
-0.8667007088661194,
0.4421863257884979,
-1.0831360816955566,
-0.453956663608551,
1.0188820362091064,
-0.2741253077983856,
-0.4312519431114197,
-0.41574057936668396,
0.19065415859222412,
0.18239392340183258,
-0.09124081581830978,
0.9918931722640991,
1.1813372373580933,
-0.4475077986717224,
-0.1510147899389267,
-0.17011888325214386,
0.4246968924999237,
0.3406594395637512,
-0.7509527206420898,
0.1778479814529419,
0.2969648540019989,
0.3437972068786621,
0.6391350030899048,
0.43188121914863586,
-0.07929347455501556,
0.5102761387825012,
-0.33294954895973206,
-0.008522305637598038,
-0.10320015251636505,
-0.45890066027641296,
-0.09981749951839447,
0.024632329121232033,
0.0977552980184555,
-0.5189395546913147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15846v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15846v2
|
From Complex to Simple: Enhancing Multi-Constraint Complex Instruction Following Ability of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-24T12:51:14 | 2024-06-18T13:16:36 |
Qianyu He, Jie Zeng, Qianxi He, Jiaqing Liang, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
It is imperative for Large language models (LLMs) to follow instructions with
elaborate requirements (i.e. Complex Instructions Following). Yet, it remains
under-explored how to enhance the ability of LLMs to follow complex
instructions with multiple constraints. To bridge the gap, we initially study
what training data is effective in enhancing complex constraints following
abilities. We found that training LLMs with instructions containing multiple
constraints enhances their understanding of complex instructions, especially
those with lower complexity levels. The improvement can even generalize to
compositions of out-of-domain constraints. Additionally, we further propose
methods addressing how to obtain and utilize the effective training data.
Finally, we conduct extensive experiments to prove the effectiveness of our
methods in terms of overall performance and training efficiency. We also
demonstrate that our methods improve models' ability to follow instructions
generally and generalize effectively across out-of-domain, in-domain, and
adversarial settings, while maintaining general capabilities.
|
[
-0.23467691242694855,
-0.8245179057121277,
0.7048751711845398,
0.2825816571712494,
0.1687333881855011,
0.2255905121564865,
-0.4515547454357147,
-0.37304508686065674,
-0.24005350470542908,
0.6059677004814148,
-0.7857325673103333,
-0.4810766875743866,
-0.7552335262298584,
0.02661057934165001,
-0.048599597066640854,
0.9431520104408264,
-0.16362139582633972,
0.3489518165588379,
-0.1903388798236847,
0.0030358596704900265,
-0.5061173439025879,
-0.7599640488624573,
-0.2050473690032959,
-0.4725838303565979,
0.40838658809661865,
0.7129806876182556,
0.6117928624153137,
0.8702422380447388,
0.4992188513278961,
0.294063538312912,
-0.14642098546028137,
0.7996251583099365,
-0.5569477677345276,
-0.002998451003804803,
-0.04653172940015793,
-0.6120228171348572,
-0.4527319669723511,
-0.1452484279870987,
0.639295756816864,
1.1444706916809082,
-0.09091796725988388,
-0.21037355065345764,
0.3209414482116699,
0.7867494225502014,
-0.5687286257743835,
0.4496055543422699,
-0.4442683160305023,
-0.049869392067193985,
-0.045369554311037064,
-0.21318082511425018,
-0.47539255023002625,
-0.31735748052597046,
0.3808199465274811,
-0.7931084036827087,
0.1786852926015854,
0.07219061255455017,
0.6451445817947388,
0.21657916903495789,
-0.6770334839820862,
-0.7093527913093567,
-1.0834827423095703,
0.5741345882415771,
-0.543092668056488,
0.3606806695461273,
0.24121928215026855,
0.18992669880390167,
-0.4955040216445923,
-0.5658223032951355,
-0.26861572265625,
-0.46141210198402405,
-0.09516751021146774,
-0.03980904072523117,
0.0690399557352066,
0.43788906931877136,
0.7400357127189636,
0.11927046626806259,
-0.21056368947029114,
-0.011244808323681355,
-0.3437795042991638,
-0.02886594459414482,
0.42827853560447693,
0.18748734891414642,
0.3956822156906128,
0.22234779596328735,
-0.21779188513755798,
-0.006225697696208954,
-0.9830690622329712,
0.17617641389369965,
0.37950390577316284,
0.34695976972579956,
-0.18606321513652802,
0.6698893308639526,
-0.45580416917800903,
0.8779154419898987,
0.018115302547812462,
-0.15028512477874756,
0.11738920211791992,
-0.4188518822193146,
0.019624827429652214,
-0.19702063500881195,
0.0839223712682724,
-0.1483091562986374,
0.19360436499118805,
-0.33812078833580017,
-0.22508524358272552,
-0.3346559405326843,
0.17605191469192505,
-0.8458036780357361,
-0.27486902475357056,
-0.10122230648994446,
-0.2882271707057953,
0.07248561829328537,
0.1445644050836563,
-0.45247066020965576,
-0.3646405339241028,
-0.94818115234375,
0.5491553544998169,
-0.4905702769756317,
0.05746360495686531,
0.43303820490837097,
-0.0267528984695673,
0.37054020166397095,
0.5148510932922363,
-1.0687990188598633,
0.465899795293808,
0.7768943309783936,
0.6199270486831665,
0.08244001865386963,
-0.316317081451416,
-0.8196730017662048,
0.5328580141067505,
-0.10741174221038818,
0.6395804286003113,
-0.7689300179481506,
-0.030335186049342155,
0.05508854612708092,
-0.03239501267671585,
-0.24030578136444092,
-0.5120583176612854,
0.450713187456131,
-0.3279077708721161,
-0.0461423434317112,
-0.2837679982185364,
-0.8052294850349426,
-0.3681843876838684,
0.28428977727890015,
-0.7047396898269653,
0.5039494633674622,
-0.100338414311409,
-0.30500340461730957,
-0.1505986899137497,
-0.7017828822135925,
-0.6885626316070557,
-0.32764163613319397,
-0.2045152485370636,
-0.351203978061676,
0.2509413957595825,
0.3580353558063507,
0.5242828130722046,
-0.334850549697876,
-0.062030382454395294,
-0.5919931530952454,
-0.2915205955505371,
0.08921727538108826,
-0.4146893620491028,
0.654831051826477,
-0.162532776594162,
-0.36804717779159546,
0.07146473973989487,
-0.7708962559700012,
0.03829450160264969,
0.04144753888249397,
-0.6263070106506348,
-0.2909202575683594,
0.07708476483821869,
-0.34237274527549744,
-0.11747484654188156,
0.14117898046970367,
-0.15866106748580933,
0.7194467186927795,
-0.36126476526260376,
0.41618895530700684,
0.5130271315574646,
0.007755530532449484,
0.6971004605293274,
-0.19937965273857117,
0.4188034236431122,
-0.25606778264045715,
0.22210939228534698,
-0.1175146996974945,
-0.2945204973220825,
-0.8776699900627136,
-0.22141125798225403,
0.37174558639526367,
0.7835816144943237,
-0.6829077005386353,
0.2945592403411865,
-0.1132754385471344,
-0.3595616817474365,
-0.41121816635131836,
0.47669053077697754,
0.6944250464439392,
0.1772468388080597,
0.4598270356655121,
-0.1387639045715332,
-0.585343062877655,
-0.7464028000831604,
-0.14116112887859344,
0.2685653269290924,
0.0022989530116319656,
0.32676568627357483,
0.5551182627677917,
-0.2784334719181061,
0.42092639207839966,
-0.7406743764877319,
-0.10794950276613235,
-0.3469860553741455,
0.21276341378688812,
0.06070147082209587,
0.661419153213501,
0.3434414863586426,
-0.8327521085739136,
-0.5976065397262573,
0.0005210691597312689,
-0.6562506556510925,
-0.0048917196691036224,
-0.2925249934196472,
-0.20630894601345062,
-0.20965436100959778,
0.6864072680473328,
-0.7020413279533386,
0.3804977238178253,
0.4054386615753174,
-0.07659424841403961,
0.5533113479614258,
-0.41801515221595764,
0.08455688506364822,
-0.8039082884788513,
-0.23747137188911438,
-0.18558798730373383,
-0.21385248005390167,
-1.1764500141143799,
0.21773609519004822,
0.1318625807762146,
0.06612307578325272,
-0.29097434878349304,
0.13662481307983398,
-0.9359390139579773,
0.15574857592582703,
-0.1683996021747589,
-0.051807504147291183,
0.01678784005343914,
0.7763006687164307,
0.049494046717882156,
0.549225926399231,
0.8043537735939026,
-0.7002806067466736,
0.36396095156669617,
0.15989434719085693,
-0.3781283497810364,
0.39332062005996704,
-0.5800597667694092,
0.3341830372810364,
-0.31907397508621216,
0.09913599491119385,
-1.0139660835266113,
-0.4447890520095825,
0.37575843930244446,
-0.09072725474834442,
0.863362193107605,
-0.37765100598335266,
-0.5272713303565979,
-0.011659553274512291,
-0.17994646728038788,
0.12477994710206985,
0.1918632984161377,
-0.5385012626647949,
1.046970009803772,
0.0612039789557457,
0.06711352616548538,
-0.6598491072654724,
-0.555189311504364,
0.0057503958232700825,
-0.13249680399894714,
-0.3902299702167511,
0.5133644938468933,
-0.41618266701698303,
-0.09411457926034927,
-0.07059665024280548,
-0.12538670003414154,
-0.28774458169937134,
0.2163502275943756,
0.12471797317266464,
0.07691869884729385,
-0.10153817385435104,
-0.040394559502601624,
0.16581593453884125,
0.14581991732120514,
0.009923212230205536,
-0.21916282176971436,
0.5471979975700378,
-0.09564294666051865,
-0.45034825801849365,
-0.6394473910331726,
0.5153355002403259,
0.4266023337841034,
-0.2644783556461334,
0.7012417912483215,
0.4126312732696533,
-0.37645041942596436,
-0.41525816917419434,
-0.43079498410224915,
-0.20822539925575256,
-0.4586350917816162,
0.6738108396530151,
-0.721452534198761,
-0.7760117053985596,
0.33637234568595886,
-0.5623428225517273,
0.13047835230827332,
-0.03608681261539459,
0.39754796028137207,
-0.2716418206691742,
1.3741010427474976,
0.8581573963165283,
0.036385681480169296,
0.5173882842063904,
-0.37449952960014343,
0.05136564373970032,
-1.0309374332427979,
-0.38606157898902893,
-0.5092582702636719,
-0.18720141053199768,
-0.24792607128620148,
-0.43105262517929077,
0.3063693046569824,
0.5705472826957703,
-0.17082561552524567,
0.2582908272743225,
-0.3377261161804199,
0.6264941096305847,
0.6007979512214661,
0.5506711006164551,
0.08958395570516586,
0.16640441119670868,
0.04768268018960953,
0.15220856666564941,
-0.978999137878418,
-0.39760127663612366,
1.073163390159607,
0.3896930515766144,
1.013757348060608,
0.386006623506546,
0.5500466227531433,
-0.07003824412822723,
0.3910687565803528,
-0.7592201828956604,
0.31811633706092834,
-0.3584868907928467,
-0.4776516556739807,
-0.22362816333770752,
-0.5130270719528198,
-0.7747942805290222,
0.16419453918933868,
-0.3323799967765808,
-0.5010568499565125,
-0.038137588649988174,
0.35078683495521545,
-0.520027756690979,
0.12873196601867676,
-0.9359223246574402,
0.666041374206543,
-0.5428803563117981,
-0.07841934263706207,
-0.25701457262039185,
-0.8172544240951538,
0.3194845914840698,
0.10347626358270645,
0.09991996735334396,
0.13470521569252014,
-0.2686888575553894,
0.39877891540527344,
-0.3510500490665436,
1.2249186038970947,
-0.08535607159137726,
0.10684306919574738,
0.1393829584121704,
-0.11955487728118896,
0.7168108224868774,
-0.24663813412189484,
0.16401435434818268,
-0.2520972490310669,
-0.30911538004875183,
-0.4912688136100769,
-0.98100745677948,
0.49230799078941345,
-0.9822095632553101,
-0.9653234481811523,
0.010651404969394207,
-0.8496668934822083,
-0.4955449402332306,
0.19503769278526306,
0.04656563326716423,
0.5766603946685791,
-0.07747094333171844,
0.42459073662757874,
1.210881233215332,
-0.049808233976364136,
0.1550118625164032,
0.43926486372947693,
0.32220035791397095,
-0.4497354328632355,
0.5807182788848877,
0.2669049799442291,
0.661763608455658,
0.6537892818450928,
0.2507595419883728,
-0.32869213819503784,
-0.7841331362724304,
-0.5679610371589661,
0.2504267692565918,
-0.912537693977356,
-0.1756161004304886,
-0.5540768504142761,
-0.2816832661628723,
-0.33687886595726013,
0.10385896265506744,
-0.1625722497701645,
-0.3759506940841675,
-0.5064592361450195,
0.0654808059334755,
0.09834418445825577,
0.9105334281921387,
0.25069618225097656,
0.550990104675293,
-0.866786003112793,
0.29658064246177673,
0.47750401496887207,
0.21597105264663696,
0.09521709382534027,
-0.706853449344635,
-0.34488630294799805,
0.215878427028656,
-0.2803528606891632,
-0.9671939611434937,
-0.19510561227798462,
0.48269420862197876,
0.8295774459838867,
0.2635880410671234,
-0.19592076539993286,
0.9602002501487732,
-0.6480228304862976,
0.2403586357831955,
0.0609225295484066,
-1.1157537698745728,
0.4212711751461029,
-0.12996622920036316,
0.2852652966976166,
0.2634989023208618,
0.4957723915576935,
-0.17073336243629456,
-0.2396755963563919,
-0.2526471018791199,
-0.5656679272651672,
0.7706664204597473,
0.3335762321949005,
0.23446795344352722,
0.6351227164268494,
0.8849589228630066,
-0.11171188205480576,
0.2656375467777252,
-0.7210208773612976,
-0.31668442487716675,
0.13961775600910187,
-0.28421008586883545,
0.14271938800811768,
-0.30911964178085327,
-0.37476804852485657,
-0.18205417692661285,
0.5800625681877136,
-0.13929475843906403,
0.018046220764517784,
0.06594983488321304,
-0.17380140721797943,
0.059270113706588745,
0.21919217705726624,
0.9795221090316772,
0.6675844192504883,
0.04871578514575958,
0.2502957880496979,
0.4648410975933075,
-0.25897592306137085,
0.07102358341217041,
0.15443703532218933,
-0.21304571628570557,
-0.23196816444396973,
0.7042526602745056,
0.9689027070999146,
0.06973223388195038,
-0.56367427110672,
0.3956970274448395,
0.050466518849134445,
-0.2565690577030182,
-0.12568838894367218,
0.39110681414604187,
0.2463589608669281,
0.4877943992614746,
0.11199215054512024,
0.31909191608428955,
0.10501660406589508,
-0.7207807898521423,
0.1961371749639511,
0.3989216685295105,
-0.3357805609703064,
-0.24522870779037476,
0.4786677360534668,
0.07929491251707077,
-0.2719486653804779,
0.4423689544200897,
-0.09659330546855927,
-0.7142500877380371,
0.6270713210105896,
0.6966371536254883,
0.5158244967460632,
-0.3351616859436035,
-0.10963254421949387,
0.1852257400751114,
0.45610511302948,
-0.43198567628860474,
0.4592388868331909,
0.045087944716215134,
-0.6592311263084412,
-0.5803908109664917,
-0.07114387303590775,
-0.5007242560386658,
-0.06721454113721848,
-0.6296792030334473,
0.308172345161438,
-0.6771298050880432,
0.16865503787994385,
0.08199634402990341,
0.019988903775811195,
-0.8261180520057678,
0.06274149566888809,
0.10304966568946838,
0.7852842807769775,
-0.6862393617630005,
1.0546106100082397,
0.6515049934387207,
-0.44106540083885193,
-1.1327941417694092,
-0.15816639363765717,
0.20717324316501617,
-0.7336491942405701,
0.5728464722633362,
0.34309321641921997,
-0.4261234700679779,
-0.09343802183866501,
-0.7950244545936584,
-0.8537323474884033,
0.9249216318130493,
0.4037933945655823,
-0.8447285294532776,
-0.08790864795446396,
0.29671359062194824,
0.49879971146583557,
-0.7430527210235596,
-0.0773303285241127,
0.6371577382087708,
0.41958391666412354,
0.2535613179206848,
-0.47855374217033386,
-0.0319904163479805,
-0.0605635792016983,
-0.121548593044281,
0.15482951700687408,
-0.622371256351471,
0.6805621385574341,
-0.4584013521671295,
-0.044439833611249924,
0.22975307703018188,
0.7312341332435608,
0.15358726680278778,
0.15688210725784302,
0.6801605224609375,
0.4331006109714508,
0.8903413414955139,
-0.10517474263906479,
0.8715389370918274,
-0.22181901335716248,
0.184921532869339,
1.4140251874923706,
-0.15498153865337372,
0.648247480392456,
0.31300923228263855,
0.21341855823993683,
0.45615503191947937,
0.5532827377319336,
-0.0964665412902832,
0.6303403377532959,
0.4053228795528412,
-0.16216164827346802,
-0.4607352614402771,
-0.19146916270256042,
-0.09745632857084274,
0.23364460468292236,
0.5651788711547852,
-0.1871713250875473,
0.0490860641002655,
0.12120989710092545,
0.11645623296499252,
0.15737831592559814,
-0.4116310477256775,
0.8510745763778687,
0.034290771931409836,
-0.6118448376655579,
0.6160107254981995,
-0.013778569176793098,
0.3276798725128174,
-0.7130188941955566,
-0.41758790612220764,
-0.008659386076033115,
0.21426154673099518,
-0.255148708820343,
-0.6103286743164062,
0.049442749470472336,
-0.04193677380681038,
-0.28989821672439575,
-0.09784461557865143,
0.5680723190307617,
-0.8007469773292542,
-0.32742828130722046,
0.23436595499515533,
0.541772723197937,
-0.012331200763583183,
-0.030872097238898277,
-0.7596494555473328,
0.04590040445327759,
0.28139880299568176,
-0.17838381230831146,
0.08204620331525803,
0.6503417491912842,
0.0677521824836731,
0.8610574007034302,
0.48182424902915955,
0.2900617718696594,
0.18853744864463806,
0.24450762569904327,
0.9536490440368652,
-0.616858959197998,
-0.12040814757347107,
-0.9079110026359558,
0.44692108035087585,
-0.10385846346616745,
-0.1651899516582489,
0.6868928074836731,
0.4533439874649048,
0.9802427291870117,
-0.17025871574878693,
0.7770965695381165,
0.04646243527531624,
0.4126267433166504,
-0.8819014430046082,
0.19233234226703644,
-0.5313690900802612,
0.5458161234855652,
0.09102021157741547,
-0.9304046034812927,
-0.713780403137207,
0.39703458547592163,
-0.2590039372444153,
-0.03652728348970413,
0.599515438079834,
1.0063562393188477,
-0.2514370381832123,
-0.19520297646522522,
0.05327516794204712,
0.11547493189573288,
0.5734306573867798,
0.8301375508308411,
1.0651981830596924,
-0.1914486587047577,
0.8059719204902649,
-0.3510342836380005,
-0.3565658628940582,
-0.13107730448246002,
-0.6149247884750366,
-1.263566255569458,
-0.2132045328617096,
-0.2714049220085144,
-0.35732221603393555,
0.03658109903335571,
1.3161059617996216,
0.9259559512138367,
-0.8925384879112244,
-0.35840168595314026,
-0.05734839662909508,
0.21567673981189728,
-0.458831787109375,
-0.02016434073448181,
0.378231018781662,
-0.5251748561859131,
-0.8482897877693176,
0.468123197555542,
0.25437816977500916,
0.3893755078315735,
-0.19378305971622467,
-0.3382088541984558,
-0.2573978900909424,
0.188108429312706,
0.7391457557678223,
0.21858830749988556,
-0.6739445924758911,
-0.40686964988708496,
0.13613350689411163,
-0.272458553314209,
0.0323232002556324,
1.1107628345489502,
0.02744719199836254,
0.4684814512729645,
0.5073445439338684,
0.7486446499824524,
0.488243043422699,
0.10721788555383682,
0.7457938194274902,
-0.8265315890312195,
0.039687056094408035,
0.11047544330358505,
0.31628793478012085,
0.2974449396133423,
-0.3422813415527344,
0.5197856426239014,
0.1053951308131218,
-0.3892543613910675,
-0.6421328186988831,
0.4777722656726837,
-0.9206969141960144,
-0.4404012858867645,
1.168921947479248,
-0.36128807067871094,
-0.007297854404896498,
-0.22630374133586884,
-0.4270327091217041,
0.3697013854980469,
-0.11922982335090637,
0.8186131715774536,
0.743453860282898,
-0.4403736889362335,
-0.2392442524433136,
-0.6836174130439758,
0.6118455529212952,
0.4544501304626465,
-0.9527389407157898,
0.15740206837654114,
0.42663779854774475,
0.29989510774612427,
-0.00480993976816535,
0.1292770802974701,
0.21309880912303925,
0.14639408886432648,
-0.3252003490924835,
-0.19922348856925964,
-0.1483522653579712,
-0.7772150039672852,
-0.4301208555698395,
0.1703375279903412,
0.17817586660385132,
-0.09275583922863007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15845v1
|
Exploring LLM Prompting Strategies for Joint Essay Scoring and Feedback Generation
| 2024-04-24T12:48:06 | 2024-04-24T12:48:06 |
Maja Stahl, Leon Biermann, Andreas Nehring, Henning Wachsmuth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Individual feedback can help students improve their essay writing skills.
However, the manual effort required to provide such feedback limits
individualization in practice. Automatically-generated essay feedback may serve
as an alternative to guide students at their own pace, convenience, and desired
frequency. Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated strong performance in
generating coherent and contextually relevant text. Yet, their ability to
provide helpful essay feedback is unclear. This work explores several prompting
strategies for LLM-based zero-shot and few-shot generation of essay feedback.
Inspired by Chain-of-Thought prompting, we study how and to what extent
automated essay scoring (AES) can benefit the quality of generated feedback. We
evaluate both the AES performance that LLMs can achieve with prompting only and
the helpfulness of the generated essay feedback. Our results suggest that
tackling AES and feedback generation jointly improves AES performance. However,
while our manual evaluation emphasizes the quality of the generated essay
feedback, the impact of essay scoring on the generated feedback remains low
ultimately.
|
[
-0.3850588798522949,
-1.0001959800720215,
1.0163875818252563,
0.21890436112880707,
-0.14694024622440338,
0.05065929517149925,
-0.38417088985443115,
-0.3136066794395447,
0.19031648337841034,
0.5343233346939087,
-0.6149448156356812,
-0.548908531665802,
-0.15395279228687286,
0.7075160145759583,
-0.24483062326908112,
1.1563206911087036,
-0.3545844256877899,
0.12976732850074768,
-0.4330780506134033,
0.20319873094558716,
-0.6590827107429504,
-0.314663290977478,
-0.8573461771011353,
-0.3510662317276001,
1.0748156309127808,
0.6369252800941467,
-0.040420763194561005,
0.41111260652542114,
0.5120444297790527,
0.30491647124290466,
0.43716198205947876,
0.16398517787456512,
-0.3137146234512329,
0.5190388560295105,
0.14890770614147186,
-0.5392128825187683,
-0.34156057238578796,
0.1345147043466568,
0.8567204475402832,
0.66087806224823,
0.05738011375069618,
0.42003053426742554,
0.5493273735046387,
0.4922983944416046,
-0.8166296482086182,
-0.1653968244791031,
-0.5178584456443787,
0.09410758316516876,
-0.19950072467327118,
-0.32424700260162354,
-0.658777117729187,
-0.4713045656681061,
-0.2032351791858673,
-0.442171573638916,
0.007141155190765858,
-0.00442903907969594,
0.4130309820175171,
0.1496773213148117,
-0.22524961829185486,
-0.34929484128952026,
-0.8058869242668152,
0.7808071374893188,
-0.6045724749565125,
-0.20452646911144257,
0.1528349369764328,
0.04630281403660774,
-0.24536007642745972,
-0.3762366473674774,
-0.5518031120300293,
-0.2835848927497864,
0.08610117435455322,
0.4638183116912842,
-0.061871130019426346,
0.30890774726867676,
0.22832980751991272,
0.2264929711818695,
-0.26804837584495544,
0.2774313986301422,
-0.23259882628917694,
-0.02165956050157547,
0.7572808265686035,
0.3013560175895691,
0.0797523483633995,
-0.12639087438583374,
-0.3595319092273712,
-0.16823802888393402,
-0.9056163430213928,
0.593598484992981,
0.7062278985977173,
0.4605189561843872,
0.25298193097114563,
0.6644541025161743,
-0.037248577922582626,
0.6584192514419556,
0.3265964090824127,
-0.28982093930244446,
-0.4220099449157715,
-0.20463620126247406,
-0.05949924513697624,
0.007568760309368372,
0.8142157196998596,
0.468641459941864,
0.14583802223205566,
0.002339437138289213,
-0.5153990983963013,
0.22705626487731934,
0.3196409344673157,
-0.4990200698375702,
0.042256224900484085,
0.06777511537075043,
-0.4399740993976593,
-0.4377874732017517,
0.22365756332874298,
-0.9554941654205322,
-0.201274111866951,
-0.48403069376945496,
0.8552649021148682,
-0.2020079344511032,
0.1279911994934082,
-0.2229270040988922,
-0.19448034465312958,
0.275907039642334,
0.49058449268341064,
-0.8301827907562256,
0.44807136058807373,
0.5298420190811157,
0.5887791514396667,
-0.4055092930793762,
-0.4269859790802002,
-0.7094211578369141,
0.15758349001407623,
-0.588743269443512,
1.1866093873977661,
-0.4895576238632202,
-0.5482394099235535,
0.24011899530887604,
-0.3618673086166382,
-0.16938334703445435,
-0.5176352858543396,
0.3502429127693176,
-0.19012844562530518,
0.26067647337913513,
-0.6883928179740906,
-0.7874739170074463,
0.002183292293921113,
0.18143299221992493,
-0.4437963366508484,
1.015162467956543,
-0.17639179527759552,
-0.5108578205108643,
0.4128144383430481,
-0.5051796436309814,
-0.42664918303489685,
0.3346768617630005,
-0.45610809326171875,
-0.06224820390343666,
0.2568070590496063,
0.21058158576488495,
0.6665827631950378,
-0.033291615545749664,
-0.12803798913955688,
-0.27524372935295105,
-0.5586084723472595,
0.27493196725845337,
-0.5467261672019958,
0.01032585185021162,
-0.08281508088111877,
-0.41608813405036926,
-0.05360075831413269,
-0.6395914554595947,
0.23300249874591827,
-0.03022785671055317,
-0.6311454176902771,
-0.11229182779788971,
-0.31663230061531067,
-0.3155001401901245,
-0.11435116082429886,
0.03916952759027481,
-0.3996371030807495,
0.39572539925575256,
-0.2844540476799011,
-0.2065863162279129,
1.0888961553573608,
0.5078176856040955,
0.2374706268310547,
-0.7284726500511169,
0.8845127820968628,
-0.2893616855144501,
-0.2675962448120117,
-0.7132534384727478,
-0.4151027798652649,
-0.7850955724716187,
-0.05866675451397896,
0.04058099910616875,
0.3737731873989105,
-0.6979124546051025,
0.09864547848701477,
0.2696264088153839,
-0.12362872064113617,
-0.6846488118171692,
0.5542908310890198,
0.4491283595561981,
0.44236230850219727,
0.10167615860700607,
-0.20875918865203857,
-0.4121663570404053,
-0.3723873198032379,
-0.2714679539203644,
-0.32413095235824585,
0.06947967410087585,
0.03275293856859207,
0.34045180678367615,
0.4158826470375061,
0.7971519231796265,
-0.4901694655418396,
-0.22417353093624115,
-0.5543898940086365,
0.38528046011924744,
-0.048954788595438004,
0.09524177759885788,
0.4094981849193573,
0.274453729391098,
-0.7674688100814819,
-0.38965630531311035,
-0.5899821519851685,
-0.4441126883029938,
-0.48157212138175964,
-0.08007525652647018,
0.3775727450847626,
0.4099918603897095,
-0.3898977041244507,
0.46046769618988037,
0.29432010650634766,
0.02172872982919216,
0.7231713533401489,
-0.10547636449337006,
0.3559045195579529,
-0.9479881525039673,
-0.019291022792458534,
-0.012481617741286755,
-0.03826092556118965,
-0.2980262041091919,
-0.02439664863049984,
-0.3808790445327759,
0.11336217820644379,
-0.18672101199626923,
0.495765745639801,
-0.4376877248287201,
0.26654496788978577,
-0.5072572827339172,
0.12629647552967072,
0.11373517662286758,
0.46847042441368103,
-0.23505795001983643,
0.8568635582923889,
0.412478506565094,
-0.6311050057411194,
0.021551158279180527,
-0.04869918152689934,
-0.05042260140180588,
0.7090876698493958,
-0.5090838670730591,
0.32854461669921875,
-0.17208729684352875,
0.4645289480686188,
-1.3061140775680542,
-0.29343634843826294,
0.04146668314933777,
-0.32768917083740234,
0.38747265934944153,
0.08442375808954239,
-0.1228911280632019,
-0.5569162964820862,
-0.931212842464447,
0.049490079283714294,
0.43226295709609985,
-0.39810630679130554,
0.1652379035949707,
-0.06998129189014435,
-0.37513163685798645,
-0.4982575476169586,
-0.4337307810783386,
0.06345140933990479,
-0.07474168390035629,
-0.4821847677230835,
0.23152559995651245,
-0.2646479308605194,
-0.5642498731613159,
-0.061306532472372055,
0.04364064335823059,
0.3801485598087311,
-0.2468803972005844,
0.3755979835987091,
0.43661272525787354,
-0.3534839451313019,
0.3340177834033966,
0.2424686849117279,
-0.06450135260820389,
0.1725909411907196,
-0.49035537242889404,
0.29193803668022156,
0.2744846045970917,
-0.5046252608299255,
-0.6350339651107788,
0.8824959993362427,
0.304576575756073,
0.14152497053146362,
0.6221261024475098,
0.4216090142726898,
-0.10673461109399796,
-0.588818371295929,
-0.8525537848472595,
-0.6792718768119812,
-0.4672833979129791,
-0.31108617782592773,
-0.2665739059448242,
-0.993309736251831,
0.2568263113498688,
-0.12424241006374359,
0.2762675881385803,
0.36110860109329224,
0.6127673387527466,
-0.45596185326576233,
0.9916893243789673,
0.67569500207901,
-0.021967876702547073,
0.25999149680137634,
-0.2862982451915741,
0.30087757110595703,
-0.6446619033813477,
0.031014086678624153,
-0.6083701252937317,
-0.337070107460022,
-0.33856484293937683,
-0.06908255815505981,
0.44125133752822876,
0.1543331891298294,
0.17967583239078522,
-0.1211267039179802,
-0.5376574397087097,
0.7814668416976929,
0.5421687364578247,
-0.04226081073284149,
0.17793363332748413,
0.1700073927640915,
-0.7082591652870178,
-0.16256947815418243,
-0.6723533868789673,
-0.7691755294799805,
1.1074161529541016,
0.18161293864250183,
0.7680540084838867,
-0.2696814239025116,
1.2326146364212036,
0.16065415740013123,
0.29268744587898254,
-0.7072675824165344,
0.7624151706695557,
-0.0636514201760292,
-0.18994340300559998,
-0.24197567999362946,
-0.3328515589237213,
-0.849145233631134,
-0.16352465748786926,
-0.3189351558685303,
-0.8699706196784973,
-0.2850080728530884,
0.2315502017736435,
-0.8895050883293152,
0.2853929102420807,
-0.5577804446220398,
0.32108649611473083,
0.012367689982056618,
-0.7404584288597107,
-0.16225826740264893,
-0.2449129819869995,
0.1274338960647583,
-0.01960575394332409,
-0.11094960570335388,
0.08456293493509293,
0.05690525844693184,
0.7350517511367798,
-0.482248455286026,
0.9881672263145447,
-0.09275432676076889,
-0.26662012934684753,
0.819351315498352,
0.1420632302761078,
0.521528422832489,
-0.010721642524003983,
-0.137741357088089,
-0.22699382901191711,
-0.29466915130615234,
0.02600451558828354,
-0.6015124917030334,
0.8029860854148865,
-0.6605068445205688,
-0.9016386866569519,
-0.11437568068504333,
-0.262116014957428,
-0.2689116299152374,
0.0446963794529438,
0.6431306600570679,
0.28934499621391296,
-0.0022713816724717617,
-0.06923310458660126,
0.5079010128974915,
-0.0510190911591053,
0.8577216267585754,
0.4196736514568329,
-0.19815108180046082,
-0.5306751728057861,
0.7111716270446777,
0.3192155957221985,
0.16728444397449493,
0.12288150191307068,
0.17936746776103973,
-0.32676446437835693,
-0.3401601314544678,
-0.5471976399421692,
0.39599478244781494,
-0.8094597458839417,
-0.36135372519493103,
-0.5383924841880798,
-0.16085882484912872,
-0.637877881526947,
-0.6150683760643005,
-0.04723908752202988,
-0.4697391092777252,
-0.15790437161922455,
-0.3603885769844055,
0.21764445304870605,
1.2869834899902344,
-0.1027425080537796,
0.21123509109020233,
-0.7535045742988586,
-0.06117859482765198,
0.4336633086204529,
0.2855284810066223,
0.39727675914764404,
-0.31964245438575745,
-0.15782484412193298,
-0.377357542514801,
-0.6019473671913147,
-0.9124429225921631,
-0.09832630306482315,
-0.16954465210437775,
0.40882599353790283,
0.4846770167350769,
-0.018154030665755272,
0.6577964425086975,
-0.44999223947525024,
1.179720163345337,
0.15665937960147858,
-0.754273533821106,
0.634925365447998,
-0.3027547001838684,
0.5718390941619873,
0.8129238486289978,
0.30837512016296387,
-0.35326144099235535,
-0.7985924482345581,
-0.11520278453826904,
-0.7162236571311951,
0.6823576092720032,
0.07891324162483215,
0.3646807372570038,
-0.11319775879383087,
0.6971809267997742,
0.3443305790424347,
0.20932172238826752,
-0.7922249436378479,
-0.002301502972841263,
0.13336718082427979,
-0.3657611906528473,
0.3105078339576721,
-0.24913497269153595,
-0.0425882451236248,
-0.2171979397535324,
0.7111102342605591,
-0.2470969408750534,
0.2982024848461151,
0.36550065875053406,
0.37741491198539734,
-0.8599641919136047,
0.3269483149051666,
0.6410224437713623,
0.1587604433298111,
0.2686576843261719,
-0.030244728550314903,
0.41587185859680176,
-0.34395360946655273,
0.3785640299320221,
-0.3897433578968048,
-0.44191718101501465,
0.035162653774023056,
0.5482089519500732,
0.6259758472442627,
-0.024942325428128242,
-0.25281432271003723,
0.4831726551055908,
-0.20202770829200745,
-0.42625585198402405,
-0.20884697139263153,
0.4016917049884796,
-0.16862405836582184,
-0.00926295854151249,
0.4186830520629883,
-0.13618113100528717,
-0.12253924459218979,
-0.32436496019363403,
0.039201535284519196,
0.5586999654769897,
-0.10255999863147736,
-0.3251131772994995,
0.45985081791877747,
0.3961566686630249,
-0.4023807942867279,
0.29208943247795105,
-0.15503719449043274,
-0.22401510179042816,
0.38961997628211975,
0.7774560451507568,
1.06203293800354,
-0.19836029410362244,
0.4716211259365082,
0.628221869468689,
0.10540562123060226,
-0.014057416468858719,
0.3026405870914459,
-0.32420533895492554,
-0.3796846568584442,
-0.668084442615509,
-0.7979193925857544,
-0.5942596793174744,
0.37044185400009155,
-0.5107046365737915,
0.5369699597358704,
-0.6440899968147278,
-0.2865522801876068,
-0.14599013328552246,
0.12248324602842331,
-0.3814759850502014,
0.06818632781505585,
0.26827841997146606,
0.493610680103302,
-0.695054292678833,
0.36674928665161133,
0.959153950214386,
-0.5435789227485657,
-1.4977612495422363,
0.45358806848526,
0.2990960478782654,
-0.4584335386753082,
0.24111036956310272,
0.42251017689704895,
-0.48021841049194336,
-0.032137420028448105,
-0.48891890048980713,
-0.5682279467582703,
0.8357096910476685,
0.15239650011062622,
-0.5505973696708679,
0.03287889435887337,
0.4283706247806549,
0.739142119884491,
-0.42420732975006104,
0.3507297933101654,
0.0738079622387886,
0.6233869194984436,
0.08739787340164185,
-0.39621463418006897,
0.034889619797468185,
-0.12448211014270782,
0.023911811411380768,
0.1151653304696083,
-0.7486658692359924,
0.705534815788269,
-0.27665936946868896,
-0.18471114337444305,
0.10965286940336227,
0.49250200390815735,
0.14068061113357544,
0.5096941590309143,
0.47088682651519775,
0.536156952381134,
0.7038004398345947,
0.18745042383670807,
0.8969128131866455,
-0.4831622838973999,
-0.22982169687747955,
0.8732948899269104,
-0.5974894165992737,
0.9687272906303406,
0.6090357303619385,
0.009862437844276428,
0.7582770586013794,
0.3135910928249359,
0.06008296087384224,
0.03441501781344414,
0.1912861317396164,
-0.7478184103965759,
-0.12449602782726288,
-0.2057798206806183,
-0.146470844745636,
0.5871315598487854,
0.054608412086963654,
-0.29273247718811035,
-0.11341502517461777,
0.01702331379055977,
0.03620321676135063,
0.19242054224014282,
-0.27192965149879456,
1.1212011575698853,
0.23450663685798645,
-1.5564029216766357,
0.22662805020809174,
-0.11990626156330109,
0.531931459903717,
-0.6246582865715027,
-0.2723323106765747,
-0.4310646653175354,
0.019387347623705864,
-0.241382896900177,
-0.5714967250823975,
0.16710932552814484,
0.47441616654396057,
-0.30798134207725525,
-0.4660961627960205,
0.8823813199996948,
-0.4853816330432892,
-0.42131417989730835,
0.23398971557617188,
0.5216861963272095,
-0.12160738557577133,
0.38249313831329346,
-0.22951172292232513,
-0.08854006230831146,
-0.13880807161331177,
-0.2922562062740326,
0.41623052954673767,
0.3718779385089874,
0.0258757546544075,
0.20789332687854767,
0.763701856136322,
0.21573026478290558,
-0.1066766157746315,
0.23363731801509857,
0.5755093097686768,
-0.4983338713645935,
-0.2881130576133728,
-0.9739128351211548,
0.4749439060688019,
0.07960204035043716,
-0.2816659212112427,
1.0287672281265259,
0.1715894192457199,
0.7988075613975525,
-0.0324830524623394,
0.9692562222480774,
0.33115455508232117,
0.5622739195823669,
-0.5963760018348694,
0.5311464667320251,
-0.4862459599971771,
0.3420751094818115,
-0.5385349988937378,
-0.9914156794548035,
-0.2196788638830185,
0.43359512090682983,
-0.2287714034318924,
0.046284712851047516,
0.8826468586921692,
0.800866425037384,
0.5184233784675598,
0.03502107039093971,
0.35437631607055664,
-0.05048348754644394,
0.15874157845973969,
0.4753294587135315,
1.1066547632217407,
-0.13657118380069733,
0.5903939604759216,
-0.09606264531612396,
-0.23149161040782928,
-0.039084408432245255,
-0.7318679690361023,
-0.9201076626777649,
-0.3214327096939087,
-0.2876581847667694,
-0.19513961672782898,
0.013194175437092781,
1.072606086730957,
0.3326661288738251,
-0.5875283479690552,
-0.41201043128967285,
-0.23519843816757202,
0.042794253677129745,
-0.04110400378704071,
-0.2838902473449707,
-0.05895556882023811,
-0.7177801728248596,
-0.5285778641700745,
0.3741316795349121,
0.711434006690979,
0.14053672552108765,
-0.4850567579269409,
-0.0814075917005539,
0.1581546515226364,
0.754595935344696,
0.32873761653900146,
0.030761631205677986,
-0.6299730539321899,
-0.3376210629940033,
0.18371053040027618,
-0.23619091510772705,
-0.025998802855610847,
1.1286982297897339,
-0.7191371321678162,
0.3106108605861664,
0.5938901305198669,
0.45789942145347595,
-0.02427000179886818,
0.009702689945697784,
0.7149075269699097,
-0.8431909084320068,
-0.23174232244491577,
0.18744517862796783,
0.16398833692073822,
0.3225361108779907,
-0.6258487701416016,
0.18635962903499603,
0.08488404750823975,
-0.8120387196540833,
-0.5829548835754395,
-0.12945392727851868,
-0.5344572067260742,
-0.20482318103313446,
1.1004893779754639,
-0.3700074851512909,
-0.1354876458644867,
0.20688797533512115,
-0.4929405748844147,
0.16012386977672577,
-0.4593104422092438,
1.0002388954162598,
1.053975224494934,
-0.4835718274116516,
-0.16529443860054016,
-0.07526476681232452,
0.5672319531440735,
0.7596281170845032,
-0.8905129432678223,
-0.2534279227256775,
0.43464556336402893,
-0.1232246607542038,
0.09930551052093506,
0.9023239612579346,
0.24925807118415833,
0.37756937742233276,
0.06730887293815613,
-0.19133789837360382,
0.19978930056095123,
-0.6541341543197632,
-0.5539625287055969,
0.4264371693134308,
0.24550585448741913,
0.14646561443805695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.12990v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.12990v1
|
BERT vs GPT for financial engineering
| 2024-04-24T11:30:04 | 2024-04-24T11:30:04 |
Edward Sharkey, Philip Treleaven
|
q-fin.ST
|
q-fin.ST, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The paper benchmarks several Transformer models [4], to show how these models
can judge sentiment from a news event. This signal can then be used for
downstream modelling and signal identification for commodity trading. We find
that fine-tuned BERT models outperform fine-tuned or vanilla GPT models on this
task. Transformer models have revolutionized the field of natural language
processing (NLP) in recent years, achieving state-of-the-art results on various
tasks such as machine translation, text summarization, question answering, and
natural language generation. Among the most prominent transformer models are
Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT) and Generative
Pre-trained Transformer (GPT), which differ in their architectures and
objectives.
A CopBERT model training data and process overview is provided. The CopBERT
model outperforms similar domain specific BERT trained models such as FinBERT.
The below confusion matrices show the performance on CopBERT & CopGPT
respectively. We see a ~10 percent increase in f1_score when compare CopBERT vs
GPT4 and 16 percent increase vs CopGPT. Whilst GPT4 is dominant It highlights
the importance of considering alternatives to GPT models for financial
engineering tasks, given risks of hallucinations, and challenges with
interpretability. We unsurprisingly see the larger LLMs outperform the BERT
models, with predictive power. In summary BERT is partially the new XGboost,
what it lacks in predictive power it provides with higher levels of
interpretability. Concluding that BERT models might not be the next XGboost
[2], but represent an interesting alternative for financial engineering tasks,
that require a blend of interpretability and accuracy.
|
[
-0.4289914667606354,
-0.5935578942298889,
0.3593815267086029,
0.31639885902404785,
-0.0438685342669487,
0.3124518096446991,
-0.19533339142799377,
-0.6186542510986328,
-0.21726468205451965,
0.366985023021698,
-0.5075748562812805,
-0.241287961602211,
-0.750593900680542,
-0.2692393958568573,
-0.6559939980506897,
1.5313036441802979,
-0.06977419555187225,
0.1995580494403839,
0.12601827085018158,
0.4727737605571747,
-0.07966528087854385,
-0.7622353434562683,
-1.0080927610397339,
-0.5826950669288635,
0.16589276492595673,
-0.42495355010032654,
1.121970534324646,
-0.17842505872249603,
0.7383647561073303,
0.3275021016597748,
-0.0898180827498436,
-0.3522437810897827,
-0.2654096186161041,
-0.24488499760627747,
0.07275733351707458,
-0.2295464277267456,
-0.5562949776649475,
0.25356584787368774,
0.19138391315937042,
0.7454512715339661,
-0.09299791604280472,
-0.03536493331193924,
0.2594330608844757,
0.7010713219642639,
-0.08117569983005524,
0.72477787733078,
-0.71022629737854,
-0.06275089830160141,
0.12000607699155807,
0.023453300818800926,
-0.5782734155654907,
-0.377214252948761,
0.7153074741363525,
-0.4334169030189514,
0.6429070234298706,
0.05398491024971008,
1.2412781715393066,
0.3089889585971832,
-0.3597729504108429,
-0.4794922173023224,
-0.748793363571167,
0.8433886766433716,
-0.566998302936554,
0.49916139245033264,
0.003697887994349003,
0.4793025851249695,
0.09388838708400726,
-0.9785508513450623,
-0.3079339563846588,
-0.36352789402008057,
-0.23442521691322327,
0.35417547821998596,
-0.21856790781021118,
0.2896692752838135,
0.04918329045176506,
0.49903109669685364,
-0.4294368326663971,
-0.0034781000576913357,
-0.3949694037437439,
-0.27621760964393616,
0.6195822954177856,
-0.2247007191181183,
-0.27811500430107117,
-0.37952548265457153,
-0.676502525806427,
-0.3888933062553406,
-0.4209606349468231,
0.16453783214092255,
0.6755105257034302,
0.3621516823768616,
0.022197632119059563,
0.1699475646018982,
0.22488181293010712,
0.42831504344940186,
0.15225553512573242,
0.15197311341762543,
0.04012095183134079,
-0.11207742989063263,
-0.36656084656715393,
0.017921749502420425,
0.591292142868042,
-0.018078725785017014,
0.3724214434623718,
-0.2772879898548126,
-0.29763054847717285,
-0.24525204300880432,
0.5359674096107483,
-0.464168518781662,
-0.6856124401092529,
0.06883613765239716,
-0.6612128615379333,
-0.3453361690044403,
0.1983155608177185,
-0.7166088819503784,
0.12196055799722672,
-0.5634134411811829,
0.398110955953598,
-0.4507814645767212,
-0.039140477776527405,
0.21841812133789062,
-0.2367212027311325,
0.7348451018333435,
0.2824840843677521,
-1.0937135219573975,
0.38346049189567566,
0.9747314453125,
0.6192284822463989,
0.11781303584575653,
0.10057990998029709,
-0.014715021476149559,
-0.14467386901378632,
-0.1573168784379959,
0.8177360892295837,
-0.3199580907821655,
-0.4781675636768341,
-0.09102004021406174,
-0.16953380405902863,
-0.23593825101852417,
-0.2714317739009857,
0.8114813566207886,
-0.7101101875305176,
0.13390181958675385,
-0.3450453579425812,
-0.6075215339660645,
-0.4334806203842163,
-0.03326321765780449,
-0.6276311278343201,
0.9637405872344971,
0.5131338834762573,
-0.6765427589416504,
0.5770726203918457,
-1.1638871431350708,
-0.25441935658454895,
-0.043540410697460175,
0.01445524487644434,
-0.6419685482978821,
0.05036110058426857,
0.18561643362045288,
0.4109247624874115,
-0.36988988518714905,
0.41798892617225647,
-0.3000119924545288,
-0.1656743884086609,
0.3486424386501312,
-0.702344536781311,
0.5209565758705139,
0.17860795557498932,
-0.40446770191192627,
0.06338416039943695,
-0.6383994221687317,
-0.020102238282561302,
0.10102532058954239,
-0.10881420969963074,
-0.01666935905814171,
0.3800373673439026,
0.45880696177482605,
0.17299295961856842,
0.26093727350234985,
-0.578441321849823,
0.023735743016004562,
-0.5427432656288147,
0.7168376445770264,
1.0603413581848145,
-0.2561092674732208,
0.3307725191116333,
-0.3726685345172882,
0.2746068835258484,
-0.2941707670688629,
0.3169707953929901,
0.3351167142391205,
-0.6223292946815491,
-0.640282154083252,
-0.1956171989440918,
0.5930248498916626,
0.5556272864341736,
-0.5806864500045776,
0.320316344499588,
-0.13615764677524567,
-0.4850894808769226,
-0.6005265116691589,
-0.09657710790634155,
-0.11979388445615768,
0.41485217213630676,
0.4581264555454254,
-0.0243122186511755,
-0.6243495941162109,
-1.0957159996032715,
-0.23895597457885742,
-0.24194927513599396,
-0.2969856262207031,
0.10517574846744537,
0.38472479581832886,
-0.1198219358921051,
0.9974225163459778,
-0.5773040652275085,
-0.11961673945188522,
-0.4808402359485626,
0.6059616804122925,
0.5446422100067139,
0.47275450825691223,
0.935360848903656,
-1.0087285041809082,
-0.4656759798526764,
0.0922432541847229,
-0.44715172052383423,
0.0918082669377327,
-0.3841347396373749,
0.0516391284763813,
0.28790566325187683,
0.12423453480005264,
-0.538679301738739,
0.43448320031166077,
0.6344037055969238,
-0.19267839193344116,
0.705254077911377,
-0.17583337426185608,
-0.05685802176594734,
-0.6992537379264832,
0.01070049311965704,
0.057565897703170776,
-0.19341018795967102,
-0.6263620257377625,
-0.02925039455294609,
-0.0439312718808651,
-0.19366511702537537,
-0.12904085218906403,
0.34377577900886536,
-0.2757667601108551,
-0.15828174352645874,
-0.32071653008461,
-0.04345213249325752,
-0.15902821719646454,
0.6048904061317444,
0.06042297184467316,
1.0733038187026978,
0.59965580701828,
-0.2025371938943863,
0.32295969128608704,
0.36042341589927673,
-0.4324803650379181,
0.07403014600276947,
-0.8980208039283752,
-0.023242484778165817,
0.004872893448919058,
0.12053307145833969,
-1.2567873001098633,
0.15633700788021088,
0.04661508649587631,
-0.3845532238483429,
0.5521711707115173,
0.1357303112745285,
-0.4490434527397156,
-0.6183193922042847,
-0.22031867504119873,
-0.026041772216558456,
0.8012846112251282,
-0.6565598249435425,
0.733939528465271,
-0.1867889016866684,
-0.5356901288032532,
-0.5073306560516357,
-0.5154736042022705,
-0.0689612552523613,
0.008458255790174007,
-0.7725687623023987,
0.4731069803237915,
0.005338472314178944,
-0.10051853209733963,
-0.10866338759660721,
-0.28680625557899475,
-0.07696451246738434,
0.09452757239341736,
0.16133910417556763,
0.7113135457038879,
-0.21425606310367584,
0.1281099170446396,
-0.04044725000858307,
-0.4989391267299652,
0.34461891651153564,
-0.37350404262542725,
0.4078749716281891,
-0.43665897846221924,
-0.3651476502418518,
-0.10771236568689346,
0.2569126486778259,
0.32467448711395264,
0.05955721437931061,
0.8561339974403381,
0.6278137564659119,
0.10204759240150452,
0.16337937116622925,
-0.5038226842880249,
-0.08936459571123123,
-0.5591580867767334,
0.18878760933876038,
-0.32849201560020447,
-0.8077400922775269,
0.5298001766204834,
-0.0348721444606781,
0.1977337896823883,
0.7964019775390625,
0.6072150468826294,
-0.28627318143844604,
1.009652853012085,
0.8721352219581604,
-0.30619436502456665,
0.491671621799469,
-0.46060726046562195,
0.8006381988525391,
-0.4799549877643585,
0.11927741020917892,
-0.49043384194374084,
-0.395744651556015,
-0.7432245016098022,
0.05990539863705635,
0.3320600986480713,
-0.18485094606876373,
-0.12229711562395096,
0.4803520441055298,
-0.5080331563949585,
0.25880903005599976,
0.6378338932991028,
0.1254701167345047,
0.0870276391506195,
-0.07211776077747345,
-0.10117319226264954,
-0.06285304576158524,
-0.543838381767273,
-0.6820653676986694,
1.3346375226974487,
0.47630318999290466,
0.839535117149353,
-0.18679994344711304,
0.4540923535823822,
0.33372923731803894,
0.7824487090110779,
-0.7179934978485107,
0.23074094951152802,
-0.28440937399864197,
-0.7613459825515747,
-0.20385529100894928,
-0.3326338231563568,
-0.6518146991729736,
0.1190827339887619,
-0.06544259190559387,
-0.5789507627487183,
0.1811835914850235,
-0.05420456454157829,
-0.49518799781799316,
0.514678418636322,
-0.8216439485549927,
0.8720589280128479,
-0.18430323898792267,
-0.05627351626753807,
0.05385414510965347,
-0.5767665505409241,
0.2828638255596161,
-0.45843538641929626,
0.10963859409093857,
0.07230034470558167,
0.2139652818441391,
0.5166434049606323,
-0.44533705711364746,
0.8369926810264587,
-0.15227238833904266,
-0.4308505356311798,
0.3426778316497803,
-0.33721786737442017,
0.5423587560653687,
0.0898917093873024,
-0.2818027436733246,
0.36478063464164734,
0.09554813802242279,
-0.5100967288017273,
-0.4603910446166992,
0.4449292719364166,
-0.9580896496772766,
-0.6065160632133484,
-0.38603219389915466,
-0.6932150721549988,
-0.23679430782794952,
-0.3236178159713745,
0.37405985593795776,
0.07044218480587006,
-0.2268868088722229,
0.15039695799350739,
0.28499892354011536,
-0.11485424637794495,
0.742073118686676,
0.16356883943080902,
0.07678963243961334,
-0.18469420075416565,
0.6610745191574097,
-0.004928662441670895,
0.3401464819908142,
0.5236891508102417,
-0.12087084352970123,
-0.4998626708984375,
-0.4040648639202118,
0.059068772941827774,
0.1722078025341034,
-0.7788901925086975,
-0.13372473418712616,
-0.5245528817176819,
-0.6283746957778931,
-0.42012134194374084,
-0.46491920948028564,
-0.39961183071136475,
-0.4408549666404724,
-0.02385600283741951,
-0.34826716780662537,
0.28208234906196594,
0.5947918891906738,
-0.157312273979187,
0.4828697443008423,
-0.6993780732154846,
0.1876695603132248,
0.5584492683410645,
0.48093876242637634,
0.0453699566423893,
-0.3010536730289459,
-0.08557382225990295,
0.06377891451120377,
-0.6649021506309509,
-0.6973798871040344,
0.3652679920196533,
-0.010197126306593418,
0.5546252131462097,
0.5127992630004883,
-0.02755393087863922,
0.43203526735305786,
-0.23894700407981873,
0.6671743392944336,
0.137361541390419,
-1.1003546714782715,
0.2249084711074829,
-0.21230992674827576,
-0.11345171928405762,
0.23724210262298584,
0.5356638431549072,
-0.3462996482849121,
-0.4626730978488922,
-0.8329055309295654,
-0.8556323051452637,
0.4773685336112976,
0.45126259326934814,
0.10046221315860748,
0.0455244816839695,
0.319744348526001,
0.5211023092269897,
0.438545823097229,
-0.9059618711471558,
-0.1007215604186058,
-0.5106258392333984,
-0.13831035792827606,
-0.1466590166091919,
-0.32368379831314087,
0.21966037154197693,
-0.3694818615913391,
0.8224656581878662,
-0.12231886386871338,
0.6358491778373718,
0.05366925895214081,
0.16599664092063904,
0.10068785399198532,
0.2968376874923706,
0.35426950454711914,
0.6338748931884766,
-0.5464978814125061,
-0.2540987730026245,
0.11463670432567596,
-0.45068660378456116,
-0.08666245639324188,
0.6119670867919922,
0.045094653964042664,
0.2693222761154175,
0.41409552097320557,
0.6563923358917236,
0.4689064919948578,
-0.5080034732818604,
0.45596960186958313,
-0.0684887245297432,
-0.6420051455497742,
-0.47184476256370544,
-0.11085231602191925,
-0.121005579829216,
0.37368911504745483,
0.5145277380943298,
0.4424201250076294,
0.17924536764621735,
-0.45371297001838684,
0.15968362987041473,
0.42893072962760925,
-0.44474613666534424,
-0.4167379140853882,
0.8832987546920776,
0.15021413564682007,
0.12511999905109406,
0.7461866736412048,
0.0531366690993309,
-0.6424596309661865,
0.6729997396469116,
0.2188650667667389,
1.1751292943954468,
0.0892559289932251,
0.23283229768276215,
0.05407872051000595,
0.4244917035102844,
-0.004398460499942303,
0.298220157623291,
-0.11192440241575241,
-0.6692109107971191,
-0.6828474402427673,
-0.7457010746002197,
-0.6740295886993408,
0.12957248091697693,
-0.8124954700469971,
-0.004614155273884535,
-0.3442980647087097,
-0.3415358066558838,
0.3142239451408386,
-0.1326248049736023,
-0.7860243320465088,
0.030230117961764336,
0.02149714156985283,
0.9250677824020386,
-0.6537405848503113,
0.8234606981277466,
0.4688658118247986,
-0.3674811124801636,
-0.6355549097061157,
-0.07613249868154526,
-0.27136167883872986,
-0.7570889592170715,
0.9042762517929077,
-0.007097400259226561,
0.3693634569644928,
-0.08018583059310913,
-0.49666479229927063,
-0.7635336518287659,
0.8184438943862915,
0.25937798619270325,
-0.5978872776031494,
-0.2962970435619354,
0.20799677073955536,
0.626871645450592,
-0.04253404960036278,
0.20112662017345428,
0.722612738609314,
0.6221262216567993,
0.22250491380691528,
-0.8964730501174927,
-0.4314190745353699,
-0.05476406589150429,
0.014827539213001728,
0.6231229305267334,
-0.5799340009689331,
1.0786826610565186,
-0.1404106467962265,
-0.06153577193617821,
0.19516439735889435,
0.7234484553337097,
-0.16148091852664948,
0.19337381422519684,
0.2977439761161804,
0.2470335066318512,
0.4661291241645813,
-0.6601450443267822,
1.226757287979126,
-0.5917242765426636,
0.8669942617416382,
0.8718149662017822,
-0.2516225278377533,
0.7852107286453247,
0.41303750872612,
-0.6428745985031128,
0.42865586280822754,
0.6926382780075073,
-0.26403316855430603,
0.5383152365684509,
0.11896148324012756,
-0.13214151561260223,
-0.3873766362667084,
0.5386437773704529,
-0.4919487237930298,
0.43124327063560486,
0.07188902795314789,
-0.4665233790874481,
-0.4443344175815582,
0.05812681093811989,
-0.19804826378822327,
-0.10451121628284454,
-0.13011153042316437,
0.5729131102561951,
0.21825383603572845,
-0.3114895820617676,
0.20191708207130432,
0.0034031528048217297,
0.608780562877655,
-0.8950079679489136,
0.10746613144874573,
-0.06395236402750015,
0.313183456659317,
0.18024460971355438,
-0.6478619575500488,
0.5826237797737122,
-0.13704556226730347,
-0.24855788052082062,
-0.736342191696167,
0.7534931898117065,
-0.005677590146660805,
-0.6835967898368835,
0.36749544739723206,
0.3358965516090393,
-0.024304170161485672,
-0.3108351230621338,
-0.800262451171875,
-0.4053071439266205,
-0.03174979239702225,
-0.33561646938323975,
0.22440820932388306,
0.34744736552238464,
0.3248894512653351,
0.6970250010490417,
0.8415940403938293,
-0.20704273879528046,
-0.08136579394340515,
0.1628389209508896,
0.8519039154052734,
-0.7633646130561829,
-0.4352501630783081,
-0.7187082767486572,
0.20686709880828857,
0.04793701693415642,
0.012790113687515259,
0.46827346086502075,
0.5188279747962952,
0.8488168120384216,
-0.43812066316604614,
0.8082267642021179,
0.07069724053144455,
0.4535368084907532,
-0.4642041325569153,
0.6565473079681396,
-0.11887295544147491,
0.268130362033844,
-0.4505489468574524,
-0.8843432664871216,
0.029491126537322998,
0.6965314149856567,
-0.7451462149620056,
0.20429843664169312,
0.6107616424560547,
0.3560222089290619,
0.000431597902206704,
0.7018118500709534,
0.3148391544818878,
0.1972413957118988,
0.40403905510902405,
0.6380422115325928,
0.8908244371414185,
-0.7114346623420715,
0.6565724015235901,
-0.15184108912944794,
0.024570366367697716,
-0.2184101939201355,
-0.9074618220329285,
-0.8279977440834045,
-0.38756805658340454,
-0.23651781678199768,
0.1650031954050064,
-0.05336185172200203,
0.7117692828178406,
0.5347960591316223,
-0.992820680141449,
-0.2289241999387741,
-0.11880408972501755,
0.00742873502895236,
-0.6407249569892883,
-0.2896326780319214,
0.3264400064945221,
-0.7027357220649719,
-0.7851628065109253,
0.05997874587774277,
0.34655311703681946,
0.3787919878959656,
-0.176263228058815,
0.11332239210605621,
0.036013681441545486,
0.1855180412530899,
0.7459738850593567,
-0.18319356441497803,
-0.6693419814109802,
-0.49911096692085266,
-0.03409496322274208,
0.09791985899209976,
0.17023193836212158,
0.7826831340789795,
-0.6242536306381226,
0.03137900307774544,
0.24018901586532593,
0.6247031092643738,
0.6469314694404602,
0.04892488569021225,
0.6508368849754333,
-0.49826234579086304,
0.08370880782604218,
0.09470924735069275,
0.5508872270584106,
-0.020894741639494896,
-0.3490106761455536,
0.661130428314209,
0.13251398503780365,
-0.737097442150116,
-0.298196405172348,
-0.07304559648036957,
-1.0832908153533936,
-0.4020269215106964,
0.5916682481765747,
-0.03369181603193283,
-0.0536046177148819,
-0.13422800600528717,
-0.42255356907844543,
-0.02862805873155594,
-0.3885629177093506,
0.9186578989028931,
0.9255226254463196,
-0.22241051495075226,
-0.049476392567157745,
-0.8646149635314941,
0.48816993832588196,
0.43828749656677246,
-0.5597410798072815,
-0.04360451549291611,
-0.05048457905650139,
0.031008286401629448,
0.23569835722446442,
0.15253421664237976,
0.025269964709877968,
0.2556850016117096,
0.10775444656610489,
0.17171144485473633,
0.12969191372394562,
-0.03677903115749359,
0.0841316431760788,
0.40905123949050903,
-0.08613216131925583,
-0.09172942489385605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15807v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15807v1
|
One Subgraph for All: Efficient Reasoning on Opening Subgraphs for Inductive Knowledge Graph Completion
| 2024-04-24T11:12:08 | 2024-04-24T11:12:08 |
Zhiwen Xie, Yi Zhang, Guangyou Zhou, Jin Liu, Xinhui Tu, Jimmy Xiangji Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge Graph Completion (KGC) has garnered massive research interest
recently, and most existing methods are designed following a transductive
setting where all entities are observed during training. Despite the great
progress on the transductive KGC, these methods struggle to conduct reasoning
on emerging KGs involving unseen entities. Thus, inductive KGC, which aims to
deduce missing links among unseen entities, has become a new trend. Many
existing studies transform inductive KGC as a graph classification problem by
extracting enclosing subgraphs surrounding each candidate triple.
Unfortunately, they still face certain challenges, such as the expensive time
consumption caused by the repeat extraction of enclosing subgraphs, and the
deficiency of entity-independent feature learning. To address these issues, we
propose a global-local anchor representation (GLAR) learning method for
inductive KGC. Unlike previous methods that utilize enclosing subgraphs, we
extract a shared opening subgraph for all candidates and perform reasoning on
it, enabling the model to perform reasoning more efficiently. Moreover, we
design some transferable global and local anchors to learn rich
entity-independent features for emerging entities. Finally, a global-local
graph reasoning model is applied on the opening subgraph to rank all
candidates. Extensive experiments show that our GLAR outperforms most existing
state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.5526086091995239,
-0.502212643623352,
0.5872980356216431,
-0.32040122151374817,
-0.2840487062931061,
0.15333986282348633,
-0.07212481647729874,
-0.3877617418766022,
0.22407303750514984,
0.1650071144104004,
-0.5362573266029358,
-0.9636996984481812,
-0.44958314299583435,
0.08208350837230682,
-0.04307936877012253,
0.7987365126609802,
-0.3679281175136566,
-0.2849271297454834,
-0.8132621645927429,
-0.350557804107666,
-0.26625582575798035,
-0.17331576347351074,
-0.5141199827194214,
-0.6623724699020386,
0.5105093121528625,
0.5668725371360779,
0.6669204831123352,
0.5743904709815979,
0.08156862109899521,
0.20460599660873413,
-0.019566074013710022,
0.5247620940208435,
-0.48995134234428406,
-0.10255485773086548,
-0.42911502718925476,
-0.22544653713703156,
-0.2453172355890274,
-0.14114516973495483,
0.6096470952033997,
0.9752970933914185,
0.02306334860622883,
0.0011985076125711203,
0.10284930467605591,
0.6128697395324707,
-0.7113195657730103,
0.5367408394813538,
-0.7234972715377808,
0.18947772681713104,
-0.16889573633670807,
-0.0432073250412941,
-0.5775129795074463,
-0.6318351030349731,
0.11648102849721909,
-0.8308867812156677,
0.4045336842536926,
-0.05046236887574196,
0.6048150658607483,
0.20469699800014496,
-0.6446009874343872,
-0.32329535484313965,
-0.3534291982650757,
0.260030061006546,
-0.12794440984725952,
0.725323498249054,
0.29677489399909973,
0.3762429356575012,
-0.3181551992893219,
-0.788310170173645,
-0.2903144657611847,
-0.3090747594833374,
-0.42699724435806274,
0.17561554908752441,
-0.10101626068353653,
0.16252835094928741,
0.14607097208499908,
0.26419946551322937,
-0.5256126523017883,
-0.07863982021808624,
-0.37681788206100464,
-0.3286435008049011,
0.2974044978618622,
-0.039993178099393845,
0.16573458909988403,
0.03632083907723427,
-0.44120022654533386,
0.2532365024089813,
-0.9565569162368774,
0.17054371535778046,
0.4896584153175354,
0.3839859664440155,
0.0833519846200943,
0.3671962320804596,
-0.5909432172775269,
0.4487019181251526,
-0.1764816790819168,
-0.2003646343946457,
0.317187637090683,
-0.2012065351009369,
-0.005946903023868799,
0.43754997849464417,
0.5820131301879883,
0.022431286051869392,
0.5960140824317932,
-0.5911448001861572,
0.38103511929512024,
-0.0967922955751419,
0.17183339595794678,
-0.5694246888160706,
-0.3828946053981781,
0.1239716187119484,
-0.3484016954898834,
0.020663270726799965,
-0.08415023982524872,
-0.30311107635498047,
-0.3564247786998749,
-0.08319707214832306,
0.13573166728019714,
-0.469743937253952,
-0.35197970271110535,
-0.2174404114484787,
0.11234603822231293,
0.04271344467997551,
0.3533404469490051,
-0.7598773241043091,
0.1452113837003708,
0.36480259895324707,
0.6976231336593628,
0.06439446657896042,
-0.35125643014907837,
-0.26259055733680725,
0.44922009110450745,
-0.48393377661705017,
0.6595394611358643,
-0.6407910585403442,
-0.3874920606613159,
-0.024456731975078583,
0.19500194489955902,
-0.14130795001983643,
-0.4939230680465698,
0.4752875864505768,
-0.6380637288093567,
-0.10906920582056046,
-0.45742902159690857,
-0.5730358362197876,
-0.36569496989250183,
0.27729326486587524,
-0.5527881383895874,
0.7796525359153748,
0.29070916771888733,
-0.9781967997550964,
0.39227089285850525,
-0.5048450827598572,
-0.6775623559951782,
0.09173698723316193,
-0.2706131041049957,
-0.2943335473537445,
-0.2930937111377716,
0.7011768221855164,
0.3331267237663269,
-0.2922425866127014,
0.01029210351407528,
-0.47259190678596497,
-0.2807512581348419,
-0.24209696054458618,
0.10088280588388443,
0.7167586088180542,
0.12245401740074158,
-0.11764039844274521,
-0.07075546681880951,
-0.4473886787891388,
0.2649269998073578,
0.05574366822838783,
-0.3504249155521393,
-0.2604271471500397,
-0.2455580085515976,
-1.024886965751648,
-0.1295998990535736,
0.14154008030891418,
-0.5408666133880615,
0.6141400933265686,
-0.08799398690462112,
0.16548483073711395,
0.6806068420410156,
0.31479933857917786,
0.6851593255996704,
0.2881443202495575,
0.39691638946533203,
0.13417430222034454,
0.20933234691619873,
-0.004884608089923859,
-0.7065154314041138,
-0.5580887794494629,
-0.29810285568237305,
0.5405393838882446,
0.30656036734580994,
-0.9330777525901794,
0.08669499307870865,
-0.3969478905200958,
-0.7075536847114563,
-0.5204094052314758,
0.1209874153137207,
0.3996478021144867,
0.7878079414367676,
0.5860651135444641,
-0.19301779568195343,
-0.2414003312587738,
-0.9127513766288757,
-0.11536307632923126,
-0.15017229318618774,
0.10941088199615479,
0.5169879198074341,
0.5547431707382202,
-0.22106072306632996,
1.0939300060272217,
-0.5426958799362183,
-0.45296522974967957,
-0.43791037797927856,
0.1335335522890091,
0.15537011623382568,
0.3922167718410492,
0.3119426369667053,
-0.5965257883071899,
-0.6808480620384216,
0.4365803301334381,
-1.1313918828964233,
0.08206690102815628,
0.0055991304107010365,
-0.37227901816368103,
0.08210760354995728,
0.5259397029876709,
-0.8676937818527222,
0.5950466394424438,
-0.005761484149843454,
0.08410356193780899,
0.15087497234344482,
-0.1931169480085373,
-0.025020917877554893,
-0.5859227180480957,
-0.17842380702495575,
-0.15744049847126007,
-0.04768036678433418,
-0.256221741437912,
-0.049682457000017166,
0.19486841559410095,
-0.003031704807654023,
-0.13288450241088867,
0.4968162477016449,
-0.6291499137878418,
-0.17107953131198883,
0.1317216455936432,
0.2357107400894165,
0.004776941612362862,
0.6551724076271057,
-0.19582599401474,
0.49590981006622314,
0.73944091796875,
-0.6099923849105835,
0.5595389604568481,
0.20939628779888153,
-0.4222548007965088,
0.14753468334674835,
-0.379986971616745,
0.16708166897296906,
-0.5842456221580505,
0.5281142592430115,
-0.9124770164489746,
-0.31356674432754517,
0.5124849677085876,
-0.5855172276496887,
0.5248963236808777,
-0.5576176047325134,
-0.18605366349220276,
-0.41706955432891846,
0.1970895528793335,
0.46434950828552246,
0.353957861661911,
-0.8580862283706665,
0.8988199234008789,
0.22004811465740204,
0.17285773158073425,
-0.804058313369751,
-0.17871803045272827,
-0.3189425468444824,
0.17275294661521912,
-0.6292724609375,
0.29267165064811707,
0.47244951128959656,
0.22019922733306885,
0.6671933531761169,
-0.4451959729194641,
0.23783881962299347,
0.058721285313367844,
0.17088210582733154,
-0.03960873559117317,
0.0051423185504972935,
0.2697726786136627,
0.13366234302520752,
-0.5632840991020203,
-0.19206632673740387,
-0.7348434329032898,
0.23982812464237213,
-0.12305884808301926,
-0.7501792907714844,
-0.10973438620567322,
0.40502431988716125,
0.5260029435157776,
-0.3859672546386719,
0.6210774183273315,
0.5394190549850464,
-0.5377290844917297,
-0.2129889875650406,
-0.3188180923461914,
0.09313192963600159,
-0.3912350535392761,
0.4370885193347931,
-0.5349922776222229,
-0.7495473027229309,
0.621890127658844,
-0.35826197266578674,
-0.26495829224586487,
0.32981717586517334,
0.44654685258865356,
0.12140321731567383,
0.9869221448898315,
0.48277488350868225,
-0.08028185367584229,
0.0424407459795475,
-0.42724505066871643,
0.5708170533180237,
-0.7194498777389526,
-0.7375666499137878,
-0.39367425441741943,
-0.2028471827507019,
-0.3657497465610504,
-0.3334817588329315,
0.678615152835846,
0.6134563088417053,
-0.2916141152381897,
0.3739434778690338,
-0.581792414188385,
0.8125649094581604,
0.7912343740463257,
-0.017613375559449196,
0.3514224886894226,
0.1244390681385994,
-0.8634369373321533,
0.08078096807003021,
-0.7801191806793213,
0.026231687515974045,
0.8921446800231934,
0.1587376445531845,
0.942783772945404,
0.047614891082048416,
0.7427869439125061,
0.08044075220823288,
0.5784138441085815,
-0.5926762819290161,
0.5079676508903503,
0.16703204810619354,
-0.5776826739311218,
-0.26876744627952576,
-0.6234939098358154,
-0.6759409308433533,
0.2478397637605667,
0.006256171967834234,
-1.0475631952285767,
0.1529044359922409,
-0.04300477355718613,
-0.02480032853782177,
0.6872031092643738,
-0.8102543354034424,
1.046079397201538,
0.06360647827386856,
-0.08898839354515076,
0.009793235920369625,
-0.771068274974823,
0.32394644618034363,
0.3368557095527649,
-0.055664174258708954,
-0.20796237885951996,
0.43547508120536804,
0.25965312123298645,
-0.3231838047504425,
0.688111424446106,
-0.4948006868362427,
0.0440661795437336,
0.7439258694648743,
0.09318608790636063,
0.8524799942970276,
0.16922511160373688,
0.2654758393764496,
0.14044852554798126,
-0.7222217917442322,
-0.21580451726913452,
-0.8815061450004578,
0.4790039658546448,
-0.6895546317100525,
-0.4382968246936798,
-0.11853563785552979,
-0.5494070649147034,
-0.3549109101295471,
0.26048341393470764,
0.3719088137149811,
0.5602562427520752,
0.15399514138698578,
0.27854764461517334,
0.7262442111968994,
0.008682899177074432,
0.036553774029016495,
0.03209732472896576,
0.017247917130589485,
-0.6566277742385864,
0.9622606039047241,
0.4206898808479309,
0.18105123937129974,
0.5669172406196594,
0.09714158624410629,
-0.7147961854934692,
-0.4566127359867096,
-0.5505915284156799,
0.17684975266456604,
-1.284279465675354,
-0.2811383903026581,
-0.8664661049842834,
-0.3157525658607483,
-0.6825082898139954,
-0.2706854045391083,
-0.3637523353099823,
-0.3159894347190857,
0.12263045459985733,
-0.36328622698783875,
0.17857186496257782,
0.5149734020233154,
-0.25805768370628357,
-0.12063289433717728,
-0.7378482222557068,
0.45956161618232727,
0.6300113201141357,
0.30785128474235535,
0.3467334508895874,
0.0888957530260086,
-0.3573625981807709,
-0.26364946365356445,
-0.20372290909290314,
-0.7396778464317322,
-0.33205175399780273,
0.054542284458875656,
1.1117521524429321,
0.47615113854408264,
0.40196967124938965,
0.44618210196495056,
-0.38320621848106384,
0.3837919533252716,
0.18505051732063293,
-0.6718223690986633,
0.5543540120124817,
-0.1761564314365387,
0.05309480428695679,
0.466903418302536,
1.0326299667358398,
-0.4481245279312134,
-0.21682126820087433,
-0.5798764824867249,
-0.9415743350982666,
0.4354996979236603,
0.09264714270830154,
-0.4106028378009796,
-0.19153033196926117,
0.30166035890579224,
-0.054270122200250626,
0.03453106805682182,
-0.750105082988739,
-0.2567882835865021,
-0.3635444939136505,
-0.2710397243499756,
0.6241081357002258,
-0.11183493584394455,
-0.2830418348312378,
-0.3942214548587799,
1.0047556161880493,
-0.636074423789978,
0.25293564796447754,
0.394265741109848,
-0.05750969052314758,
0.021347379311919212,
0.2613283693790436,
-0.06576275080442429,
0.635675847530365,
-0.11101327836513519,
0.3246462345123291,
0.4072181284427643,
-0.24585874378681183,
0.1594676524400711,
0.08395059406757355,
-0.38736337423324585,
-0.030067438259720802,
0.6179988384246826,
0.5296850800514221,
0.011181343346834183,
-0.09488098323345184,
0.5282139778137207,
0.1557285040616989,
-0.1315632462501526,
0.049914564937353134,
-0.03257939964532852,
0.3752989172935486,
0.4381527006626129,
0.2624925374984741,
-0.019541624933481216,
-0.12189726531505585,
-0.4713570773601532,
-0.051244691014289856,
0.49917665123939514,
-0.44738271832466125,
0.19260431826114655,
0.6890748143196106,
0.07937280833721161,
0.24271824955940247,
0.9547215104103088,
-0.736676812171936,
-0.7135961651802063,
0.49219876527786255,
0.5750283002853394,
0.9954278469085693,
0.19763147830963135,
0.3833472430706024,
0.6237857937812805,
0.4914986193180084,
0.23956900835037231,
-0.10012263804674149,
-0.4398740231990814,
-0.8544629812240601,
-0.45802178978919983,
-0.38702812790870667,
-0.5485008955001831,
-0.3246464729309082,
-0.3973669707775116,
-0.08127855509519577,
-0.19466616213321686,
0.2234160602092743,
-0.27055367827415466,
-0.03864702209830284,
-0.501179039478302,
0.05589669942855835,
0.11749880760908127,
0.93131422996521,
-0.7725251317024231,
1.0266238451004028,
0.6915085911750793,
-0.45557674765586853,
-0.9014580249786377,
-0.1739816814661026,
-0.17480988800525665,
-0.8569589853286743,
0.5515462756156921,
0.2682711184024811,
-0.0896034985780716,
-0.09476707875728607,
-0.5214201211929321,
-0.8713169097900391,
1.245307445526123,
0.3528115749359131,
0.13080628216266632,
-0.1754889339208603,
0.3005489706993103,
0.024638105183839798,
-0.5720618367195129,
0.21100665628910065,
0.520307719707489,
0.37002789974212646,
0.477707177400589,
-0.613418459892273,
0.31107380986213684,
-0.09455876797437668,
-0.14770352840423584,
0.2976388931274414,
-0.6312097311019897,
0.8150505423545837,
-0.5311670899391174,
-0.32372742891311646,
-0.2920389771461487,
0.736015796661377,
0.2250179946422577,
0.21657417714595795,
0.5944544076919556,
1.0745868682861328,
1.1031430959701538,
-0.2883720397949219,
0.8721541166305542,
0.04481920972466469,
0.6057262420654297,
0.9744202494621277,
-0.28450271487236023,
0.05943622812628746,
0.02185196243226528,
-0.17481708526611328,
0.6136757135391235,
0.5522711277008057,
0.1936337798833847,
0.9100455641746521,
0.03467288613319397,
-0.39749443531036377,
-0.7212287783622742,
-0.43565788865089417,
-0.7296125888824463,
0.21560311317443848,
0.25846365094184875,
-0.04419593885540962,
-0.8366183042526245,
-0.1345478594303131,
0.003373091109097004,
-0.2725536525249481,
-0.4459956884384155,
0.5202497839927673,
-0.06919156014919281,
-0.6553675532341003,
0.40531694889068604,
-0.23695451021194458,
-0.008532614447176456,
-0.8184908628463745,
-0.1862732619047165,
-0.3250798285007477,
0.2801171839237213,
-0.40486282110214233,
-0.682462215423584,
0.051417939364910126,
-0.4523881673812866,
-0.18294735252857208,
0.03460262715816498,
1.140958309173584,
-0.4565334916114807,
-0.168145552277565,
0.4744034707546234,
0.43752047419548035,
0.1296612173318863,
-0.0019490577979013324,
-0.13363125920295715,
-0.39789989590644836,
0.14004971086978912,
-0.07195770740509033,
0.24373334646224976,
0.7928375005722046,
-0.21406938135623932,
0.8214048147201538,
0.6013040542602539,
-0.25496575236320496,
0.0410148948431015,
0.14357970654964447,
0.9937628507614136,
-0.38696274161338806,
-0.4203473925590515,
-0.5880963802337646,
0.43138349056243896,
-0.22005413472652435,
-0.17086461186408997,
0.6650405526161194,
0.45220449566841125,
1.2565032243728638,
0.1386885792016983,
0.8435254096984863,
-0.18841798603534698,
0.32358089089393616,
-0.6290919780731201,
0.5163732767105103,
-0.43413758277893066,
-0.1860581487417221,
-0.22213731706142426,
-0.7884340286254883,
-0.1136326789855957,
0.6417675614356995,
-0.20435068011283875,
-0.04320250451564789,
0.8788450956344604,
0.5845088958740234,
-0.16664621233940125,
0.2707147002220154,
0.010148080997169018,
0.09886865317821503,
0.3926222622394562,
0.757482647895813,
0.826030433177948,
-0.21060246229171753,
0.8580121994018555,
-0.4255782961845398,
-0.17136073112487793,
0.051843948662281036,
-0.980236828327179,
-0.8930897116661072,
-0.3120182752609253,
-0.3622351288795471,
-0.45633405447006226,
-0.21183979511260986,
0.9261674284934998,
0.5237569808959961,
-0.6743304133415222,
0.5201675891876221,
-0.15769653022289276,
0.8219140768051147,
-0.2861253619194031,
-0.2141954004764557,
0.6145237684249878,
-0.3783263862133026,
-0.40175148844718933,
0.4555628001689911,
0.27052757143974304,
-0.08050237596035004,
-0.14609915018081665,
-0.08319461345672607,
-0.2240253984928131,
-0.5635308027267456,
0.2155141532421112,
0.5006373524665833,
-0.49624261260032654,
-0.6173146963119507,
-0.20093634724617004,
0.1512918323278427,
0.056798215955495834,
0.8956590294837952,
-0.9912934899330139,
0.4783930480480194,
0.5584131479263306,
0.8995965719223022,
0.7161432504653931,
-0.0856010913848877,
0.11130394041538239,
-1.1909215450286865,
0.014134775847196579,
0.030717791989445686,
0.5941416025161743,
0.2008369266986847,
-0.3450187146663666,
1.0134491920471191,
0.6438174843788147,
-0.3725474178791046,
-0.5547006130218506,
0.468911737203598,
-0.6430647969245911,
-0.21509014070034027,
0.8472881317138672,
-0.3649526536464691,
-0.1075548380613327,
-0.25513821840286255,
0.12253636866807938,
0.45972904562950134,
-0.1026400551199913,
0.30120527744293213,
0.5821967124938965,
-0.43037286400794983,
0.15921775996685028,
-0.40790069103240967,
0.23275808990001678,
-0.1436726450920105,
-0.5911900401115417,
0.050890590995550156,
0.20371925830841064,
0.17561644315719604,
0.5427516102790833,
1.0771214962005615,
-0.13336125016212463,
0.07505671679973602,
0.27413398027420044,
0.06276758760213852,
-0.4585879445075989,
-0.9817259907722473,
0.4749949872493744,
0.5632107257843018,
-0.22659994661808014,
-0.2680177092552185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15778v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15778v2
|
BASS: Batched Attention-optimized Speculative Sampling
| 2024-04-24T09:57:11 | 2024-06-26T17:29:46 |
Haifeng Qian, Sujan Kumar Gonugondla, Sungsoo Ha, Mingyue Shang, Sanjay Krishna Gouda, Ramesh Nallapati, Sudipta Sengupta, Xiaofei Ma, Anoop Deoras
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Speculative decoding has emerged as a powerful method to improve latency and
throughput in hosting large language models. However, most existing
implementations focus on generating a single sequence. Real-world generative AI
applications often require multiple responses and how to perform speculative
decoding in a batched setting while preserving its latency benefits poses
non-trivial challenges. This paper describes a system of batched speculative
decoding that sets a new state of the art in multi-sequence generation latency
and that demonstrates superior GPU utilization as well as quality of
generations within a time budget. For example, for a 7.8B-size model on a
single A100 GPU and with a batch size of 8, each sequence is generated at an
average speed of 5.8ms per token, the overall throughput being 1.1K tokens per
second. These results represent state-of-the-art latency and a 2.15X speed-up
over optimized regular decoding. Within a time budget that regular decoding
does not finish, our system is able to generate sequences with HumanEval
Pass@First of 43% and Pass@All of 61%, far exceeding what's feasible with
single-sequence speculative decoding. Our peak GPU utilization during decoding
reaches as high as 15.8%, more than 3X the highest of that of regular decoding
and around 10X of single-sequence speculative decoding.
|
[
-0.5010874271392822,
-0.7727314829826355,
0.44012320041656494,
0.5288178324699402,
-0.38548457622528076,
0.42617979645729065,
-0.16246449947357178,
-0.3056974411010742,
0.46699318289756775,
0.2656458020210266,
-0.5464439988136292,
-0.08166857808828354,
-0.40076181292533875,
0.09945736080408096,
-0.4597506821155548,
0.838090181350708,
0.42529135942459106,
-0.1450391262769699,
0.13231885433197021,
0.21961289644241333,
-0.1812676042318344,
-0.5934249758720398,
-1.0723729133605957,
0.36386343836784363,
0.42710691690444946,
0.3821379542350769,
0.5517696738243103,
0.7580644488334656,
0.5560715198516846,
0.21252873539924622,
0.24779191613197327,
0.33475133776664734,
-0.6287291646003723,
0.287952184677124,
0.3836888074874878,
-0.37240493297576904,
-0.6896510720252991,
-0.0995669737458229,
0.850600004196167,
0.34590473771095276,
-0.32416000962257385,
0.20905838906764984,
-0.24471770226955414,
0.4136137068271637,
-0.9123222231864929,
0.018370067700743675,
-0.5321906208992004,
0.2605400085449219,
-0.5852684378623962,
-0.628807544708252,
-0.8408215045928955,
-0.213345006108284,
-0.5680549144744873,
-0.8804617524147034,
0.7532995343208313,
0.36007946729660034,
0.4666016101837158,
0.5419437289237976,
0.18383890390396118,
0.25265344977378845,
-0.8069280385971069,
0.5013344287872314,
-0.7706472277641296,
0.357239693403244,
0.051151979714632034,
0.33532431721687317,
-0.05661208927631378,
-1.007149338722229,
-0.8252431154251099,
0.15517880022525787,
0.19371217489242554,
0.378910094499588,
-0.12282318621873856,
0.12130891531705856,
0.5292729735374451,
0.8283397555351257,
-0.6887419819831848,
-0.04048958420753479,
-0.24122604727745056,
-0.21141047775745392,
0.45576947927474976,
0.4593510925769806,
-0.1286037564277649,
-0.02126486971974373,
-0.33972373604774475,
-0.3169498145580292,
-0.4826242923736572,
0.12409358471632004,
0.4542919397354126,
0.3177555501461029,
0.02847590483725071,
0.22151096165180206,
-0.118382528424263,
0.6986762285232544,
0.3281008303165436,
0.12008164077997208,
0.03308235481381416,
-0.5755457878112793,
-0.259882390499115,
-0.018039627000689507,
0.914218008518219,
0.22042937576770782,
-0.32256564497947693,
-0.3754919469356537,
-0.22586576640605927,
0.43405452370643616,
0.6746795773506165,
-0.9032427072525024,
-0.17482149600982666,
0.4242423176765442,
-0.49105167388916016,
-0.21125273406505585,
0.05564948916435242,
-0.9985019564628601,
-0.15069498121738434,
0.11137126386165619,
-0.26839157938957214,
-0.45085737109184265,
-0.1621963530778885,
0.3400418162345886,
-0.3055751323699951,
0.1275433897972107,
0.10206004232168198,
-1.3049535751342773,
0.41384586691856384,
0.40603166818618774,
0.826349139213562,
-0.2796410620212555,
-0.06924653053283691,
-0.8896778225898743,
0.05752063915133476,
-0.6929628252983093,
0.8588440418243408,
-0.6079089641571045,
-0.3415297567844391,
-0.40274110436439514,
-0.3194216787815094,
-0.032566219568252563,
-0.2680453658103943,
0.6648864150047302,
-0.8434224128723145,
-0.19394217431545258,
-0.19166965782642365,
-0.46150073409080505,
0.13347038626670837,
0.14911192655563354,
-0.7227658033370972,
0.7246802449226379,
-0.04906870052218437,
-0.7853326797485352,
0.7241749167442322,
-0.4242568910121918,
-0.5636826753616333,
0.4896743595600128,
-0.2927427887916565,
-0.06070481985807419,
0.2417745590209961,
0.43837156891822815,
0.5476700663566589,
-0.3812600076198578,
0.15427760779857635,
-0.2356681525707245,
-0.8139795064926147,
-0.13279809057712555,
-0.8669248819351196,
0.19409003853797913,
0.6616759300231934,
-0.28867003321647644,
0.2866659164428711,
-0.8310901522636414,
0.1757853478193283,
0.048552677035331726,
-0.5050467848777771,
0.22549892961978912,
-0.18495142459869385,
0.4507896900177002,
0.04021981731057167,
-0.20535516738891602,
-0.42815375328063965,
0.46728479862213135,
-0.3987012803554535,
0.445108026266098,
0.6663411855697632,
0.009933355264365673,
0.1588616818189621,
-0.20000414550304413,
0.7231593132019043,
-0.12452578544616699,
0.05111017823219299,
-0.7353367805480957,
-0.4414485991001129,
-0.6458003520965576,
-0.3880593180656433,
-0.008491096086800098,
0.3697468936443329,
-0.9830043911933899,
0.16742758452892303,
-0.18323424458503723,
-0.17854668200016022,
-0.7198423147201538,
-0.3540537655353546,
0.27453017234802246,
0.24155037105083466,
0.512896716594696,
-0.306675523519516,
-0.3785702586174011,
-0.6463811993598938,
-0.16596882045269012,
0.10342192649841309,
0.13772256672382355,
0.3993028402328491,
-0.23082444071769714,
-0.13203983008861542,
0.5548872947692871,
-0.5095147490501404,
0.3037143647670746,
-0.1076902374625206,
0.20667947828769684,
0.3193916380405426,
0.5670371055603027,
0.4079720675945282,
-0.4989558160305023,
-0.1541360318660736,
-0.10963406413793564,
-0.6251947283744812,
0.556360125541687,
-0.40802815556526184,
-0.20346064865589142,
0.4581993520259857,
0.5295125842094421,
-0.6629731059074402,
0.2861650884151459,
0.43908318877220154,
-0.12254034727811813,
0.3885420262813568,
-0.5037263631820679,
0.5985925197601318,
-1.3096036911010742,
0.23163428902626038,
-0.14318254590034485,
-0.10216090083122253,
-0.48628997802734375,
0.477619469165802,
0.08972275257110596,
-0.02992134913802147,
-0.2955845594406128,
0.1656002253293991,
-0.38271617889404297,
-0.022416118532419205,
-0.35552963614463806,
-0.4611760079860687,
-0.1919821798801422,
0.5290623903274536,
0.001414433354511857,
1.2283377647399902,
0.6649080514907837,
-0.7137495875358582,
0.5802726149559021,
-0.1589401215314865,
-0.07622643560171127,
0.12119009345769882,
-0.5300968289375305,
0.5898526906967163,
-0.2550385594367981,
0.5170772075653076,
-0.8796634674072266,
-0.5776482224464417,
0.2669656276702881,
-0.4320300221443176,
0.43548357486724854,
0.01353053841739893,
-0.46173468232154846,
-0.8146570324897766,
-0.11051199585199356,
0.8803385496139526,
0.516741931438446,
-0.5609298348426819,
0.3837903141975403,
0.14963564276695251,
-0.09293016046285629,
-1.0116426944732666,
-0.6653265953063965,
0.2799162268638611,
0.08308396488428116,
-0.44918692111968994,
0.21517834067344666,
-0.025015583261847496,
0.06944946199655533,
0.015576318837702274,
-0.05967042222619057,
0.16691292822360992,
-0.251945436000824,
0.1877460777759552,
0.3254478871822357,
-0.42745137214660645,
-0.22601574659347534,
0.12908174097537994,
-0.19998623430728912,
-0.08076038211584091,
-0.9801848530769348,
0.9088171720504761,
-0.09320636838674545,
-0.10304483771324158,
-0.4251122772693634,
0.5280894041061401,
0.7766785025596619,
-0.1613367646932602,
0.4407936930656433,
0.9032583832740784,
-0.5016577243804932,
-0.38127222657203674,
-0.5146088004112244,
-0.33532652258872986,
-0.48599469661712646,
0.3068775236606598,
-0.5753338932991028,
-0.7624242901802063,
0.38564661145210266,
0.2369215041399002,
0.13469676673412323,
0.612429678440094,
0.5250288844108582,
0.1128767803311348,
0.6461939811706543,
0.5314188599586487,
-0.24350298941135406,
0.17133349180221558,
-0.36481615900993347,
0.21987232565879822,
-0.4814506471157074,
-0.16663749516010284,
-0.17052900791168213,
-0.31614950299263,
-0.42857176065444946,
-0.8644552826881409,
0.1818719357252121,
-0.10303586721420288,
-0.03344263136386871,
0.1243780255317688,
-0.4339900314807892,
0.5079084038734436,
0.7991160154342651,
0.11538819223642349,
0.12293599545955658,
0.297710657119751,
0.023995229974389076,
0.12355591356754303,
-1.018921136856079,
-0.2508609890937805,
1.2622644901275635,
-0.01705542393028736,
1.015066385269165,
-0.2010703831911087,
0.6137619018554688,
0.6346743702888489,
-0.0525188148021698,
-0.560966432094574,
0.49863263964653015,
-0.19447116553783417,
-0.4584773778915405,
-0.3075338304042816,
-0.45665866136550903,
-0.6949235796928406,
0.11942356824874878,
-0.3464062809944153,
-0.44408899545669556,
0.0932948961853981,
0.5026758313179016,
-1.0721557140350342,
0.6627565622329712,
-0.4955831468105316,
0.6314921975135803,
0.24053855240345,
-0.7503904104232788,
-0.47931039333343506,
-0.6506072282791138,
0.6655208468437195,
-0.03701905906200409,
-0.21297268569469452,
0.2997085154056549,
0.31421470642089844,
0.45533064007759094,
-0.16814443469047546,
0.4608931839466095,
-0.06548752635717392,
-0.05445748195052147,
0.20187370479106903,
-0.19131171703338623,
0.6194760203361511,
0.469005286693573,
0.09044047445058823,
-0.25783324241638184,
-0.16364651918411255,
-0.6539124846458435,
-0.4124014973640442,
0.8097094297409058,
-0.5087436437606812,
-0.5081214904785156,
-0.4757843613624573,
-0.8371235132217407,
-0.28970491886138916,
0.13474678993225098,
0.607882559299469,
0.6237101554870605,
-0.3043244183063507,
-0.17621281743049622,
0.7387077808380127,
-0.23966023325920105,
0.7156409025192261,
-0.22795893251895905,
0.17373298108577728,
-0.19773440062999725,
1.178392767906189,
-0.47183719277381897,
0.2202223539352417,
0.40677353739738464,
-0.44039463996887207,
-0.22638659179210663,
-0.597542941570282,
-0.9679131507873535,
-0.1950024515390396,
-0.43912848830223083,
-0.06203344464302063,
-0.9441530108451843,
-0.10163623094558716,
-0.7171382308006287,
-0.13519679009914398,
-0.6514389514923096,
-0.27559560537338257,
-0.14692044258117676,
0.02028798684477806,
0.16384519636631012,
0.7249372005462646,
-0.015468668192625046,
0.1630738526582718,
-0.9686120748519897,
0.6588032245635986,
0.09458493441343307,
0.21611328423023224,
0.207330584526062,
-0.3561369776725769,
-0.16953471302986145,
-0.20997461676597595,
0.01998589001595974,
-0.44777145981788635,
0.5964723825454712,
-0.10921438038349152,
0.5048614740371704,
0.7046489715576172,
0.17632664740085602,
0.8132022619247437,
-0.6016492247581482,
0.6791164875030518,
0.024290405213832855,
-0.5798546075820923,
0.30177345871925354,
-0.38096311688423157,
0.3148294985294342,
0.4218066334724426,
0.2928212285041809,
-0.5798053741455078,
-0.43574172258377075,
-0.5585196614265442,
-0.9633985757827759,
1.1827459335327148,
0.07150393724441528,
0.09159693866968155,
-0.2233957052230835,
0.5015838742256165,
0.340776652097702,
0.15524309873580933,
-0.011068117804825306,
-0.5340290665626526,
-0.30863410234451294,
0.02467222325503826,
-0.3753635585308075,
-0.2147337794303894,
-0.11980509757995605,
-0.03343933820724487,
0.4594604969024658,
-0.1953137218952179,
0.6169658899307251,
-0.06818041205406189,
0.2599165439605713,
-0.11881932616233826,
0.3593980669975281,
0.6234161257743835,
0.16452747583389282,
-0.3535943329334259,
0.17606376111507416,
-0.181870698928833,
-0.8025152087211609,
0.1293344497680664,
0.41628581285476685,
-0.11574488133192062,
-0.2723943889141083,
0.04960329830646515,
1.1358076333999634,
-0.20991386473178864,
-0.36310911178588867,
0.09143545478582382,
-0.39063316583633423,
0.1717040091753006,
0.08878500014543533,
0.15057866275310516,
-0.24012936651706696,
0.24074456095695496,
0.5333149433135986,
1.0314435958862305,
0.4952111542224884,
-0.3236314654350281,
0.2764192223548889,
0.23351044952869415,
0.2943500578403473,
-0.24051013588905334,
1.0095720291137695,
0.1996944099664688,
0.0664871335029602,
1.034125566482544,
-0.6039554476737976,
0.020102864131331444,
0.6476297974586487,
0.7050344944000244,
0.792138934135437,
0.041133493185043335,
-0.06036269664764404,
0.6601829528808594,
0.14503732323646545,
-0.22538155317306519,
0.5124927163124084,
-0.2993776798248291,
-0.7245004773139954,
-0.5577877163887024,
-0.730877697467804,
-0.38755056262016296,
-0.026828164234757423,
-0.9239923357963562,
-0.2837264835834503,
-0.6908000111579895,
-0.3392713963985443,
-0.21202172338962555,
-0.4456880986690521,
-0.6898697018623352,
0.22440993785858154,
0.4421163499355316,
0.7616795897483826,
-0.4189520478248596,
0.7933529019355774,
0.5788846015930176,
-0.14850030839443207,
-0.8303570747375488,
0.38775190711021423,
-0.09196384251117706,
-0.6952706575393677,
0.26782211661338806,
0.12391123920679092,
-0.33092474937438965,
0.4264194965362549,
-0.27672675251960754,
-0.8003523945808411,
0.8329024910926819,
0.40765243768692017,
-0.8458981513977051,
-0.1489519327878952,
-0.20574963092803955,
0.1745530366897583,
-0.10558810085058212,
0.32784417271614075,
0.6521856188774109,
0.15547539293766022,
0.29257020354270935,
-0.41660574078559875,
0.2079685926437378,
-0.7199816703796387,
0.025956250727176666,
0.10705287754535675,
-0.8078811764717102,
0.9057787656784058,
-0.7440771460533142,
-0.5005898475646973,
0.11116348952054977,
0.9183942079544067,
0.4133989214897156,
0.16163764894008636,
0.1303538978099823,
0.7215380668640137,
1.026296854019165,
-0.33445921540260315,
1.548276424407959,
-0.7287322282791138,
-0.003654584987089038,
0.8110762238502502,
0.04968927428126335,
0.76532381772995,
0.4316190779209137,
-0.20340654253959656,
-0.06486302614212036,
0.7737033367156982,
0.00984757300466299,
0.6375086307525635,
0.17166902124881744,
-0.4777708649635315,
-0.47522103786468506,
0.050665371119976044,
-0.541682779788971,
0.004525419790297747,
0.5421830415725708,
-0.09402748942375183,
0.26614752411842346,
0.11871341615915298,
-0.40651583671569824,
-0.3384108543395996,
-0.3152272701263428,
0.3526325225830078,
-0.2588288486003876,
-0.8926193714141846,
0.6711341738700867,
0.10927501320838928,
1.0435463190078735,
-0.44958049058914185,
-0.01300908625125885,
-0.5041312575340271,
0.42609304189682007,
-0.11093582957983017,
-0.4428786635398865,
0.03838980942964554,
-0.05919937789440155,
-0.5324549674987793,
-0.19154919683933258,
0.26837801933288574,
-0.23551762104034424,
-0.6003704071044922,
-0.16086283326148987,
0.2922403812408447,
0.14922887086868286,
-0.07017461955547333,
0.0077314297668635845,
0.4087311029434204,
-0.25499430298805237,
-0.18906474113464355,
-0.04853537306189537,
0.20491915941238403,
0.08723614364862442,
0.4139941334724426,
0.8272952437400818,
0.1092587262392044,
0.5217739939689636,
0.36868593096733093,
1.0331602096557617,
-0.8115074634552002,
-0.8221429586410522,
-0.6046754121780396,
0.14255112409591675,
0.10254759341478348,
-0.4348510503768921,
0.6431152820587158,
0.677984356880188,
0.8812832236289978,
-0.30789440870285034,
0.889937162399292,
-0.11827187985181808,
-0.24870605766773224,
-0.637131929397583,
0.5497116446495056,
-0.37653639912605286,
0.0936114639043808,
-0.22738125920295715,
-0.6227148771286011,
-0.19854481518268585,
0.41858410835266113,
0.1977040320634842,
0.17236697673797607,
0.7231583595275879,
0.6623775362968445,
0.01961546018719673,
0.3443405032157898,
0.3478643596172333,
0.08295293897390366,
0.20458370447158813,
0.8675195574760437,
0.7586204409599304,
-0.4491666853427887,
0.3108461797237396,
-0.016141550615429878,
-0.239515483379364,
0.04984498396515846,
-0.40396368503570557,
-0.583187997341156,
-0.3196982741355896,
-0.0287005677819252,
-0.34124860167503357,
0.3720327317714691,
0.955136775970459,
0.9817543029785156,
-0.946810245513916,
-0.004128879401832819,
-0.3439156115055084,
-0.7665497064590454,
-0.5876833200454712,
-0.23641978204250336,
0.3252505362033844,
-0.8979951739311218,
-1.0214345455169678,
0.6997761726379395,
0.566172182559967,
-0.0760762020945549,
-0.1433231681585312,
-0.2626290023326874,
0.11879215389490128,
0.1396743804216385,
0.4974548816680908,
0.3971104323863983,
-0.8084803223609924,
0.24775636196136475,
0.3036644458770752,
-0.24655447900295258,
0.09404846280813217,
1.1919444799423218,
-0.9789105653762817,
0.554232656955719,
0.3555692732334137,
1.0601592063903809,
0.9000616669654846,
0.1587967574596405,
0.5500868558883667,
-0.7045788764953613,
0.3902215361595154,
0.5038654804229736,
0.35699111223220825,
0.07151124626398087,
-0.7217805981636047,
0.15356798470020294,
0.5372710824012756,
-0.27753520011901855,
-0.5104221105575562,
-0.060644738376140594,
-1.2305407524108887,
-0.07163602113723755,
0.9030907154083252,
-0.06463578343391418,
-0.015282060019671917,
0.21925494074821472,
-0.13212284445762634,
0.39012518525123596,
-0.8463533520698547,
0.6007824540138245,
0.4724889099597931,
-0.28267741203308105,
-0.19644208252429962,
-0.3797586262226105,
0.613760769367218,
0.41347604990005493,
-0.8043181896209717,
0.24614448845386505,
0.700861930847168,
-0.3862012028694153,
0.17170082032680511,
0.8883382081985474,
-0.008169958367943764,
0.5517009496688843,
0.7852880358695984,
0.08418937027454376,
-0.10895409435033798,
-0.7020949125289917,
-0.17407986521720886,
0.5451693534851074,
-0.19456221163272858,
-0.3475669324398041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15777v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15777v4
|
A Comprehensive Survey on Evaluating Large Language Model Applications in the Medical Industry
| 2024-04-24T09:55:24 | 2024-05-29T15:50:43 |
Yining Huang, Keke Tang, Meilian Chen, Boyuan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Since the inception of the Transformer architecture in 2017, Large Language
Models (LLMs) such as GPT and BERT have evolved significantly, impacting
various industries with their advanced capabilities in language understanding
and generation. These models have shown potential to transform the medical
field, highlighting the necessity for specialized evaluation frameworks to
ensure their effective and ethical deployment. This comprehensive survey
delineates the extensive application and requisite evaluation of LLMs within
healthcare, emphasizing the critical need for empirical validation to fully
exploit their capabilities in enhancing healthcare outcomes. Our survey is
structured to provide an in-depth analysis of LLM applications across clinical
settings, medical text data processing, research, education, and public health
awareness. We begin by exploring the roles of LLMs in various medical
applications, detailing their evaluation based on performance in tasks such as
clinical diagnosis, medical text data processing, information retrieval, data
analysis, and educational content generation. The subsequent sections offer a
comprehensive discussion on the evaluation methods and metrics employed,
including models, evaluators, and comparative experiments. We further examine
the benchmarks and datasets utilized in these evaluations, providing a
categorized description of benchmarks for tasks like question answering,
summarization, information extraction, bioinformatics, information retrieval
and general comprehensive benchmarks. This structure ensures a thorough
understanding of how LLMs are assessed for their effectiveness, accuracy,
usability, and ethical alignment in the medical domain. ...
|
[
-0.023353036493062973,
-0.7100695967674255,
0.9589738845825195,
0.09001550078392029,
-0.04963133484125137,
0.01956735923886299,
-0.35183224081993103,
-0.5269752740859985,
-0.11622041463851929,
0.48563432693481445,
-0.30653515458106995,
-0.5654330849647522,
-0.7430239915847778,
0.01921054720878601,
-0.47937536239624023,
0.8918653130531311,
-0.06013030931353569,
0.5668690204620361,
-0.48734861612319946,
-0.12052823603153229,
-0.21606570482254028,
-0.701694905757904,
-0.655829906463623,
-0.6079246401786804,
0.4311787486076355,
-0.02261621505022049,
0.5986842513084412,
0.28318092226982117,
0.9014806747436523,
0.3290776014328003,
-0.2121548056602478,
0.030422598123550415,
-0.4445227086544037,
0.12875835597515106,
-0.2647361755371094,
-0.18161243200302124,
-0.5040221214294434,
-0.14509406685829163,
0.6775476336479187,
0.976610541343689,
-0.28142011165618896,
0.35513225197792053,
-0.10336562246084213,
0.6198650002479553,
-0.4075723886489868,
0.05004526674747467,
-0.45076245069503784,
0.06444614380598068,
-0.1513359248638153,
-0.044038791209459305,
-0.38376447558403015,
-0.5552971959114075,
0.3167419731616974,
0.07072853296995163,
-0.1259349286556244,
-0.15275736153125763,
0.6483500599861145,
0.10286224633455276,
-0.5576069951057434,
-0.6342687606811523,
-0.7962725162506104,
0.959348201751709,
-0.8250108957290649,
0.6196966171264648,
-0.00732802739366889,
0.45696061849594116,
-0.24602486193180084,
-1.06482994556427,
-0.2566286325454712,
-0.37153464555740356,
0.10242464393377304,
0.23814857006072998,
-0.3677026629447937,
0.2819373607635498,
-0.020637331530451775,
0.6701927185058594,
-0.7128409147262573,
0.5085917711257935,
-0.3944806754589081,
-0.10042452067136765,
0.5964145064353943,
0.5126544833183289,
0.5904232859611511,
-0.11714676767587662,
-0.0912204161286354,
-0.03846696764230728,
-0.803224503993988,
-0.14271636307239532,
-0.11570979654788971,
-0.18832969665527344,
-0.14705981314182281,
0.634807825088501,
0.14967842400074005,
0.6967377662658691,
-0.48100745677948,
-0.3438299596309662,
0.3533458411693573,
-0.3982202112674713,
-0.6144594550132751,
-0.24561187624931335,
0.9671475887298584,
0.46192365884780884,
0.01276012696325779,
-0.2242221236228943,
-0.297838032245636,
-0.025354819372296333,
0.5670745968818665,
-0.8261151313781738,
0.20518290996551514,
0.4228730797767639,
-0.90224289894104,
-0.2875051498413086,
-0.2995493710041046,
-0.7983591556549072,
-0.7016593813896179,
-0.2676032483577728,
0.027101553976535797,
-0.24149855971336365,
-0.1179787814617157,
0.3958340585231781,
0.22199289500713348,
0.4494513273239136,
0.279654324054718,
-0.6955035328865051,
0.3315425217151642,
1.0050773620605469,
0.6384363174438477,
-0.35715392231941223,
0.10253580659627914,
0.027397368103265762,
-0.14305119216442108,
-0.32210734486579895,
0.5513671040534973,
-0.47247084975242615,
-0.6100456714630127,
0.31001710891723633,
0.0012435776880010962,
-0.16150988638401031,
-0.7691389322280884,
0.8892802000045776,
-0.5074580311775208,
0.030208803713321686,
-0.022632470354437828,
-0.6513885259628296,
-0.06538736820220947,
0.47129857540130615,
-0.6311984658241272,
0.569693386554718,
0.15387076139450073,
-0.5205426216125488,
0.36863380670547485,
-0.8444371819496155,
-0.4963415563106537,
0.17394809424877167,
-0.3980584144592285,
-0.6449233293533325,
0.3450429439544678,
0.312051922082901,
0.7258465886116028,
-0.7813928723335266,
0.5070983171463013,
0.014645428396761417,
-0.29587414860725403,
0.39556846022605896,
-0.550316333770752,
0.6923452019691467,
0.268534779548645,
-0.15375110507011414,
0.38940659165382385,
-0.6633575558662415,
-0.016616787761449814,
0.12566404044628143,
-0.37100711464881897,
-0.2250836193561554,
0.200863778591156,
0.276254266500473,
0.09606367349624634,
0.22165846824645996,
-0.5976448655128479,
0.16045142710208893,
-0.47780531644821167,
0.5104051828384399,
0.5111300945281982,
0.26486942172050476,
0.1788715273141861,
-0.2736673951148987,
0.8629915118217468,
-0.27146485447883606,
0.5637348294258118,
-0.05472256988286972,
-0.4941377341747284,
-0.3122018873691559,
-0.4127484858036041,
0.2430097758769989,
0.38149765133857727,
-0.5197880268096924,
0.43766874074935913,
-0.5319517254829407,
-0.8082442283630371,
-0.7930446267127991,
-0.09689031541347504,
0.20113125443458557,
0.468710720539093,
0.20878371596336365,
-0.019086929038167,
-0.4695637822151184,
-1.1539182662963867,
-0.09704136848449707,
-0.24782238900661469,
-0.2429783046245575,
0.4843837022781372,
0.4177793562412262,
-0.8116687536239624,
0.571960985660553,
-0.3457522988319397,
-0.006568513344973326,
-0.4789270758628845,
-0.13007259368896484,
0.554882287979126,
0.1428116112947464,
0.5071402192115784,
-0.6981366276741028,
-0.17840728163719177,
0.16259965300559998,
-0.7970854640007019,
-0.16600531339645386,
0.02262425795197487,
0.20279303193092346,
-0.05294211208820343,
0.2334359586238861,
-0.49492132663726807,
0.09940900653600693,
0.9901814460754395,
-0.14712053537368774,
0.4905042350292206,
-0.22865626215934753,
0.3263469338417053,
-0.8908334970474243,
0.36643722653388977,
-0.006422160193324089,
-0.2424330711364746,
-0.5412973761558533,
0.2703855037689209,
0.032493893057107925,
-0.0144923385232687,
-0.3194185197353363,
0.5384700298309326,
-0.37249264121055603,
-0.015217112377285957,
-0.18337292969226837,
-0.08445092290639877,
-0.10677821934223175,
-0.30695265531539917,
-0.12647761404514313,
0.6669185161590576,
0.5006765127182007,
-0.3270924985408783,
0.36051613092422485,
0.2522011697292328,
-0.8661094903945923,
0.29275086522102356,
-0.9760740399360657,
-0.014381182380020618,
-0.0037326726596802473,
0.19622571766376495,
-0.8954200744628906,
-0.09862514585256577,
-0.04697936773300171,
-0.19181734323501587,
0.10131891071796417,
0.18718793988227844,
-0.7230243682861328,
-0.7086103558540344,
-0.2324170023202896,
0.2839820981025696,
0.8662998080253601,
-0.2497713416814804,
0.42970526218414307,
0.6351110339164734,
-0.21021616458892822,
-0.4206644892692566,
-0.7584131956100464,
0.23288226127624512,
-0.08583834022283554,
-0.5450983643531799,
0.09009484201669693,
0.010578127577900887,
-0.3239954710006714,
-0.21904346346855164,
-0.1429317146539688,
-0.07125338912010193,
0.05957047641277313,
0.22703221440315247,
0.5641983151435852,
-0.2964474558830261,
0.17255312204360962,
0.07012474536895752,
0.1435241848230362,
0.2851176857948303,
0.10661306232213974,
0.5278095602989197,
-0.03770953416824341,
-0.668290913105011,
-0.20753228664398193,
0.24206788837909698,
0.8100106716156006,
-0.17690855264663696,
0.662458598613739,
0.5337393879890442,
-0.34658098220825195,
0.11063134670257568,
-0.831628143787384,
-0.07588851451873779,
-0.3899431824684143,
0.7840110659599304,
0.08677710592746735,
-1.0502108335494995,
0.38008078932762146,
-0.30139219760894775,
0.26582440733909607,
0.52201247215271,
1.1149245500564575,
0.10818202793598175,
0.812518298625946,
0.37670913338661194,
-0.22679053246974945,
0.04808174446225166,
-0.027657531201839447,
0.35226255655288696,
-0.8851494193077087,
-0.37297070026397705,
-0.49383094906806946,
-0.11128312349319458,
-0.5487749576568604,
-0.5107724666595459,
0.7833452820777893,
-0.38515204191207886,
-0.0036664900835603476,
-0.025609809905290604,
-0.6621648073196411,
0.12417268753051758,
-0.07799294590950012,
0.12701526284217834,
0.3634991943836212,
-0.16466432809829712,
-0.10622473806142807,
-0.06959393620491028,
-0.4291572868824005,
-0.8093406558036804,
1.2562686204910278,
0.884316086769104,
0.8553441762924194,
-0.009739678353071213,
0.4574492275714874,
0.2297118604183197,
0.7329593300819397,
-1.0400307178497314,
0.4953345060348511,
-0.4271288216114044,
-0.590128481388092,
-0.3303433060646057,
-0.4135615825653076,
-1.0839627981185913,
0.23195020854473114,
0.0218819472938776,
-0.7044235467910767,
-0.16701412200927734,
-0.23965679109096527,
-0.2447057068347931,
0.2603728771209717,
-0.5762081146240234,
0.7699598073959351,
-0.4565698206424713,
-0.1313813328742981,
-0.35364601016044617,
-0.4404674172401428,
0.36893656849861145,
-0.39197543263435364,
0.248016357421875,
-0.03446970507502556,
-0.1482429802417755,
0.7433777451515198,
-0.05985735356807709,
0.7052411437034607,
-0.06836539506912231,
-0.3414700925350189,
0.07207547128200531,
-0.31502148509025574,
0.11815178394317627,
0.0030849508475512266,
-0.4530077278614044,
0.4367310702800751,
0.21895775198936462,
0.041674524545669556,
-0.47948479652404785,
0.643218994140625,
-0.6000992655754089,
-0.47615286707878113,
-0.3564179539680481,
-0.39574339985847473,
-0.6204807758331299,
0.16162526607513428,
-0.032540906220674515,
0.27748697996139526,
-0.5152130722999573,
0.39686909317970276,
0.5757116675376892,
-0.6396326422691345,
0.1725068837404251,
0.6366838216781616,
-0.3113655149936676,
-0.3299427330493927,
0.4156402051448822,
-0.1297585368156433,
0.11615849286317825,
0.40833330154418945,
0.34071680903434753,
-0.4203053414821625,
-0.9847646951675415,
-0.4970628023147583,
0.4077706038951874,
-0.6192657351493835,
0.0047620804980397224,
-0.579189121723175,
-0.4247440993785858,
-0.3119364082813263,
-0.05403592437505722,
-0.327735960483551,
0.02581912651658058,
0.05660415440797806,
-0.014650015160441399,
-0.015913091599941254,
1.110750436782837,
0.5561557412147522,
0.30020788311958313,
-0.9350858330726624,
0.20574533939361572,
0.027511822059750557,
0.5422056913375854,
0.07334166020154953,
-0.21836590766906738,
-0.2535516321659088,
-0.17738668620586395,
-0.2940254211425781,
-0.6726555228233337,
0.1770273745059967,
-0.0890156701207161,
0.9499858021736145,
0.3998977839946747,
-0.38897496461868286,
0.5068575739860535,
-0.8578684329986572,
1.0672112703323364,
0.2906894087791443,
-0.7463537454605103,
0.25605323910713196,
-0.20221242308616638,
0.33420661091804504,
0.6210689544677734,
0.48199397325515747,
-0.6619702577590942,
-0.1440853476524353,
-0.24219143390655518,
-0.9966028332710266,
0.33017459511756897,
0.034740857779979706,
0.2872275710105896,
0.11566758900880814,
0.25354743003845215,
0.041377194225788116,
0.2042824625968933,
-0.5309678316116333,
-0.14028100669384003,
0.4735560119152069,
-0.4236694276332855,
0.0022263401187956333,
-0.4053010642528534,
-0.23810872435569763,
-0.12988831102848053,
0.47280168533325195,
0.12558841705322266,
0.3475967049598694,
0.10185591876506805,
-0.0005691247060894966,
0.14838218688964844,
0.6166532039642334,
0.5772114396095276,
1.0466959476470947,
-0.0032414733432233334,
-0.22297407686710358,
0.06122327223420143,
-0.7741697430610657,
0.05867448449134827,
0.06361839175224304,
0.08636506646871567,
0.16770054399967194,
0.5782100558280945,
0.5118469595909119,
0.28257879614830017,
-1.0770797729492188,
0.72554612159729,
-0.004785869736224413,
0.02902921475470066,
-0.18162980675697327,
-0.24352632462978363,
0.17172278463840485,
0.05473002418875694,
0.18483476340770721,
-0.3703286945819855,
0.4898366928100586,
-0.37735626101493835,
0.153936967253685,
0.49424493312835693,
-0.3727496564388275,
-0.17643015086650848,
0.5107659101486206,
0.08978769183158875,
0.07883046567440033,
0.6063195466995239,
0.47543174028396606,
-0.14308294653892517,
0.5503918528556824,
0.512729287147522,
0.8840554356575012,
-0.41445043683052063,
-0.05542019009590149,
0.178137868642807,
0.36353954672813416,
-0.06827469170093536,
0.2161085307598114,
0.2509324252605438,
-0.5951765179634094,
-0.6360549926757812,
-0.8095381855964661,
-0.5974186062812805,
0.49663975834846497,
-0.4752110242843628,
0.2503403425216675,
-0.25305455923080444,
-0.4051762819290161,
0.16348138451576233,
-0.3222702145576477,
-0.7130489945411682,
0.277527779340744,
0.2600788474082947,
0.9194570183753967,
-0.5848814249038696,
0.7278026342391968,
0.9910036325454712,
-0.18536554276943207,
-0.5315126776695251,
-0.08273246139287949,
-0.07519938051700592,
-1.0790560245513916,
0.48383453488349915,
-0.028831053525209427,
0.08979561179876328,
-0.4741690754890442,
-0.33791258931159973,
-0.39389434456825256,
0.9605160355567932,
0.20242291688919067,
-0.8197922110557556,
-0.2930624186992645,
0.4929322302341461,
0.9176892638206482,
-0.28534457087516785,
0.6064317226409912,
0.7517758011817932,
0.46701154112815857,
-0.044958971440792084,
-1.2572259902954102,
0.06820715218782425,
-0.15810786187648773,
0.2276953011751175,
0.0742032527923584,
-0.4430358409881592,
0.479510098695755,
0.08867469429969788,
0.04030382260680199,
0.20191478729248047,
0.061081044375896454,
0.23500096797943115,
0.32331186532974243,
0.25715476274490356,
0.2869718074798584,
0.5516209602355957,
-0.06388156116008759,
1.2922182083129883,
-0.43941730260849,
0.42171385884284973,
0.7299970388412476,
-0.5583563446998596,
0.666649580001831,
0.42566564679145813,
-0.5487370491027832,
0.287981778383255,
0.44106701016426086,
-0.23105193674564362,
0.15102382004261017,
0.5120172500610352,
-0.2887033522129059,
0.07786448299884796,
-0.13956525921821594,
-0.43435484170913696,
0.5047722458839417,
0.6239648461341858,
-0.9365368485450745,
-0.3008478581905365,
0.10525359958410263,
0.05695291608572006,
-0.014579877257347107,
-0.34992051124572754,
0.8319113850593567,
0.2672094702720642,
-0.425919771194458,
0.3646285831928253,
0.10200320184230804,
0.4776078462600708,
-0.9379918575286865,
-0.08195813745260239,
0.17323580384254456,
0.21158112585544586,
-0.3055207431316376,
-0.8907579779624939,
0.36483076214790344,
0.12121441960334778,
-0.009441854432225227,
-0.3281064033508301,
0.850290060043335,
0.010949819348752499,
-0.5536637306213379,
0.2532954514026642,
0.5196173787117004,
0.24341556429862976,
0.17513209581375122,
-0.7097147703170776,
0.38429003953933716,
-0.24188955128192902,
-0.3467673361301422,
0.1486244648694992,
0.18089210987091064,
-0.048824410885572433,
0.6412907242774963,
0.500132143497467,
0.4740912914276123,
-0.1377391815185547,
0.5234797596931458,
0.8405390381813049,
-0.5614075064659119,
-0.1619642823934555,
-1.08659029006958,
0.45624780654907227,
-0.04052811488509178,
-0.10605109483003616,
0.6930082440376282,
0.7849218249320984,
0.3597443699836731,
-0.24367588758468628,
0.8988286256790161,
0.09998025000095367,
0.5715274810791016,
-0.43976131081581116,
1.056301474571228,
-0.40629321336746216,
0.2960701584815979,
-0.27648648619651794,
-0.6936464905738831,
-0.41377323865890503,
0.24892760813236237,
-0.6492773294448853,
0.19110453128814697,
0.48565635085105896,
0.42520901560783386,
0.17833232879638672,
0.05860266834497452,
0.6210638284683228,
0.25647613406181335,
0.5935207009315491,
0.4470159709453583,
0.8786199688911438,
-0.3704477548599243,
0.10908383131027222,
0.17729827761650085,
-0.3323022425174713,
-0.24127668142318726,
-0.7971442341804504,
-0.7683131694793701,
-0.3400624990463257,
-0.10552563518285751,
-0.20683503150939941,
0.05362163484096527,
0.9464167356491089,
0.6298378109931946,
-0.8805190920829773,
-0.3492966592311859,
0.2760506272315979,
-0.192446768283844,
-0.03787746652960777,
-0.2178313136100769,
0.4292246699333191,
-0.20742832124233246,
-0.7584294676780701,
0.3975124657154083,
0.4638015925884247,
-0.24051779508590698,
-0.5615137219429016,
0.21062742173671722,
0.12362567335367203,
0.10501352697610855,
0.9408010244369507,
-0.002410400891676545,
-0.7669358849525452,
0.0030434748623520136,
0.122904933989048,
-0.33509084582328796,
0.052938856184482574,
1.069406509399414,
-0.5544917583465576,
0.44671961665153503,
0.4099811613559723,
1.1317652463912964,
0.15244440734386444,
-0.23017588257789612,
0.4789762794971466,
-0.09762414544820786,
-0.26163429021835327,
0.5568599104881287,
0.46998751163482666,
0.38414978981018066,
-0.36005768179893494,
0.5752696394920349,
-0.16154217720031738,
-0.9477382898330688,
-0.8585750460624695,
-0.029955416917800903,
-1.0597550868988037,
-0.168866828083992,
1.2314649820327759,
-0.01172349788248539,
-0.06781788915395737,
-0.1457221657037735,
-0.10439256578683853,
0.10127858817577362,
-0.07223289459943771,
0.6689407229423523,
0.6127960085868835,
-0.3939955234527588,
0.10674798488616943,
-0.8739566206932068,
0.2565242350101471,
0.2578291594982147,
-0.9975615739822388,
-0.19165021181106567,
0.4781987965106964,
0.41872599720954895,
-0.023055793717503548,
0.6778492331504822,
-0.8042815923690796,
0.07204489409923553,
-0.556923508644104,
0.17718097567558289,
0.18796685338020325,
0.10216663032770157,
-0.6433103680610657,
0.14179033041000366,
0.2591695189476013,
-0.005199110135436058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15770v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15770v1
|
ChEX: Interactive Localization and Region Description in Chest X-rays
| 2024-04-24T09:44:44 | 2024-04-24T09:44:44 |
Philip Müller, Georgios Kaissis, Daniel Rueckert
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Report generation models offer fine-grained textual interpretations of
medical images like chest X-rays, yet they often lack interactivity (i.e. the
ability to steer the generation process through user queries) and localized
interpretability (i.e. visually grounding their predictions), which we deem
essential for future adoption in clinical practice. While there have been
efforts to tackle these issues, they are either limited in their interactivity
by not supporting textual queries or fail to also offer localized
interpretability. Therefore, we propose a novel multitask architecture and
training paradigm integrating textual prompts and bounding boxes for diverse
aspects like anatomical regions and pathologies. We call this approach the
Chest X-Ray Explainer (ChEX). Evaluations across a heterogeneous set of 9 chest
X-ray tasks, including localized image interpretation and report generation,
showcase its competitiveness with SOTA models while additional analysis
demonstrates ChEX's interactive capabilities.
|
[
-0.24438245594501495,
-0.5725468397140503,
1.1262089014053345,
-0.04102000594139099,
-0.3086496889591217,
-0.04224179685115814,
0.14511442184448242,
-0.48298510909080505,
0.1505821943283081,
0.5899306535720825,
-0.9948112368583679,
-0.6205152273178101,
-0.363355815410614,
0.08929884433746338,
-0.1712181270122528,
1.0484415292739868,
-0.16333572566509247,
-0.07405465841293335,
-0.30540651082992554,
0.1254158616065979,
-0.5842595100402832,
-0.39144545793533325,
-0.8932000398635864,
-0.2555532455444336,
0.32963550090789795,
0.10127061605453491,
1.0446772575378418,
0.9021906852722168,
0.2945535480976105,
0.29246923327445984,
0.2822783291339874,
-0.009608042426407337,
-0.0800153911113739,
-0.04294200241565704,
-0.08446548134088516,
-0.6403767466545105,
-0.4579128921031952,
-0.6055818796157837,
0.40562704205513,
0.7019264698028564,
0.18501876294612885,
-0.5828410387039185,
-0.4768039584159851,
0.48667028546333313,
-0.48851320147514343,
0.1425260603427887,
-0.08396952599287033,
0.300841748714447,
-0.045297615230083466,
-0.5164327621459961,
-0.13322417438030243,
-0.0750359520316124,
0.6660125851631165,
-0.8220692276954651,
0.35772162675857544,
-0.15089771151542664,
0.6768433451652527,
0.2377421110868454,
-0.647840142250061,
-0.5861479043960571,
-0.5322332382202148,
0.6389980912208557,
-0.34043848514556885,
0.4874238967895508,
0.31430330872535706,
0.6228194832801819,
0.21279603242874146,
-0.9638302326202393,
-0.09923055022954941,
0.012886174023151398,
-0.5839654803276062,
0.3803116977214813,
-0.6018851399421692,
0.006171622779220343,
-0.08618658781051636,
0.25863781571388245,
-0.6520606279373169,
-0.1272769719362259,
-0.14881494641304016,
-0.23540635406970978,
0.5827223062515259,
0.3473312556743622,
0.5703074932098389,
-0.28568384051322937,
-0.7146210074424744,
0.09755045175552368,
-0.47253021597862244,
0.09362553060054779,
-0.39090555906295776,
0.16077792644500732,
-0.2652045786380768,
0.137220561504364,
-0.5001614689826965,
0.679953396320343,
0.1264849156141281,
-0.033908236771821976,
0.30707481503486633,
-0.37295907735824585,
-0.2089037448167801,
0.47981181740760803,
0.5463511943817139,
0.054575707763433456,
-0.7526906728744507,
-0.026008540764451027,
0.10664195567369461,
-0.1350196897983551,
0.26396140456199646,
-0.5946910381317139,
-0.0016965939430519938,
0.5926300287246704,
-0.6924951076507568,
-0.3755713403224945,
0.0024455972015857697,
-0.7099986672401428,
-0.6417626738548279,
-0.29912880063056946,
0.21312695741653442,
-0.43174466490745544,
-0.14509066939353943,
0.30935850739479065,
0.028280552476644516,
-0.13346709311008453,
0.34740766882896423,
-0.35232463479042053,
0.4374009668827057,
0.1905469447374344,
0.7295698523521423,
0.18409162759780884,
-0.25874364376068115,
-0.7429158091545105,
0.26086241006851196,
-0.018459828570485115,
1.1861333847045898,
-0.6758852601051331,
-0.4022848904132843,
-0.02762490138411522,
0.20299920439720154,
-0.032107915729284286,
-0.4080714285373688,
0.26368701457977295,
-0.2600681483745575,
0.035735297948122025,
-0.33067816495895386,
0.0011956883827224374,
-0.27244189381599426,
0.14528772234916687,
-0.7185285687446594,
0.8283369541168213,
0.3128746747970581,
-0.3289281725883484,
0.3167233169078827,
-0.6939282417297363,
-0.39415889978408813,
0.1317838430404663,
-0.48494818806648254,
-0.31231048703193665,
0.21528668701648712,
0.5644267201423645,
0.6115505695343018,
-0.28192853927612305,
0.18199320137500763,
0.24411825835704803,
-0.023513203486800194,
0.5394697785377502,
0.08785318583250046,
0.5915793776512146,
0.3710385859012604,
-0.7282410264015198,
0.4388985335826874,
-0.7911698818206787,
0.2118747979402542,
-0.1414141058921814,
0.10447977483272552,
-0.17341969907283783,
-0.0885738655924797,
-0.025472166016697884,
0.49274885654449463,
0.01212665718048811,
-0.3861675262451172,
0.06282179802656174,
-0.1208178699016571,
0.32219505310058594,
0.21204224228858948,
0.11085078120231628,
0.18695062398910522,
-0.4661007523536682,
0.9844649434089661,
0.0950227603316307,
0.32672351598739624,
-0.5843302011489868,
-0.29363125562667847,
-0.43024325370788574,
-0.6514679193496704,
-0.1423669010400772,
0.39331018924713135,
-0.8529404997825623,
-0.15474040806293488,
-0.15639470517635345,
-0.6738491654396057,
-0.20741349458694458,
-0.10341133922338486,
0.6433802843093872,
0.31806841492652893,
0.1776987612247467,
-0.4389526844024658,
-0.5137901306152344,
-0.9560642838478088,
0.15973776578903198,
0.4044947624206543,
-0.007554783020168543,
0.34049779176712036,
0.2670462131500244,
-0.3830437660217285,
0.655685305595398,
-0.6912688612937927,
-0.40603914856910706,
-0.3758690357208252,
0.4034302830696106,
-0.11700578033924103,
0.1297648847103119,
0.5010179877281189,
-0.7832554578781128,
-0.6128333806991577,
0.5702812075614929,
-0.9901411533355713,
-0.1384289413690567,
-0.5827826857566833,
-0.3255304992198944,
0.07102544605731964,
0.7904465794563293,
-0.18597489595413208,
0.849307119846344,
0.32356467843055725,
-0.1885884553194046,
0.5152828097343445,
-0.34109774231910706,
0.3223857283592224,
-0.826625645160675,
0.13099722564220428,
0.14846672117710114,
-0.41042011976242065,
-0.7248905897140503,
0.23302578926086426,
0.14680644869804382,
-0.6467674374580383,
-0.6348111629486084,
0.5037811994552612,
-0.7188445329666138,
0.16954940557479858,
-0.2494473159313202,
0.11760745197534561,
0.2543318569660187,
0.2731514573097229,
0.7643407583236694,
0.22442708909511566,
0.8784337043762207,
-0.4434465765953064,
0.20355692505836487,
0.3012324273586273,
-0.2792884111404419,
0.9082399606704712,
-0.595215916633606,
0.10360518097877502,
-0.10559006035327911,
0.632182776927948,
-0.6428457498550415,
-0.39169400930404663,
-0.14206527173519135,
-0.04459935054183006,
0.30440229177474976,
0.07808033376932144,
-0.21374057233333588,
-0.24560631811618805,
-0.38866257667541504,
0.6155281066894531,
0.2694077789783478,
-0.55687415599823,
0.575199544429779,
0.09398813545703888,
-0.2558468282222748,
-0.29900068044662476,
-0.5968254208564758,
-0.01426195353269577,
-0.11442306637763977,
-0.6025915145874023,
0.30683809518814087,
-0.09134270250797272,
-0.0950736477971077,
0.15927012264728546,
-0.1749291568994522,
-0.49365541338920593,
-0.16504573822021484,
0.4240567088127136,
0.1596175879240036,
-0.25482675433158875,
0.13835839927196503,
0.19205805659294128,
-0.34414762258529663,
0.018593979999423027,
-0.29179927706718445,
0.19493702054023743,
-0.21158675849437714,
-0.24949966371059418,
-0.6168644428253174,
0.714493453502655,
0.39911893010139465,
-0.31014522910118103,
0.3191900849342346,
0.5106126070022583,
-0.5968396663665771,
-0.04837288707494736,
-0.29583796858787537,
-0.04140998795628548,
-0.43949058651924133,
0.5087248086929321,
-0.5614703893661499,
-0.7045121192932129,
0.6052069067955017,
-0.28651463985443115,
-0.33866411447525024,
0.16177955269813538,
0.639062225818634,
-0.03137597441673279,
1.1810649633407593,
0.5328196287155151,
0.5893417596817017,
0.033144235610961914,
-0.13854950666427612,
0.35914528369903564,
-0.8407321572303772,
-0.45111745595932007,
-0.47398629784584045,
-0.12260407954454422,
-0.2161022573709488,
-0.271564781665802,
0.905126690864563,
-0.32567813992500305,
0.201223224401474,
0.008963323198258877,
-0.6216719150543213,
0.5758742094039917,
0.2832621932029724,
0.4852610230445862,
0.11250726133584976,
0.16027595102787018,
0.16226720809936523,
-0.3014775216579437,
-1.0284537076950073,
-0.227310448884964,
0.8838606476783752,
0.0561794750392437,
0.7221648097038269,
0.09033147245645523,
0.8066859841346741,
0.0870247334241867,
-0.0381857268512249,
-0.6386183500289917,
0.1853146106004715,
-0.26632970571517944,
-0.611366868019104,
-0.03333479166030884,
-0.036724165081977844,
-1.4306939840316772,
-0.03793609142303467,
-0.2377692013978958,
-0.8264715075492859,
0.3560519516468048,
0.17257392406463623,
-0.937768280506134,
0.14628413319587708,
-0.42170682549476624,
0.9717965722084045,
-0.36247944831848145,
-0.5785608291625977,
-0.022788764908909798,
-0.8302938938140869,
0.3392179012298584,
-0.22798629105091095,
0.6729215383529663,
0.38193610310554504,
-0.04766438901424408,
0.28739508986473083,
-0.6601940989494324,
1.1022295951843262,
0.016106052324175835,
-0.16294226050376892,
0.28415825963020325,
0.378488689661026,
0.04852617532014847,
0.07448266446590424,
-0.02303912863135338,
-0.006647203583270311,
0.35682183504104614,
-0.4315902888774872,
-0.8711379170417786,
0.925252377986908,
-0.5956310033798218,
-0.2627895176410675,
-0.4793313145637512,
-0.8199613094329834,
-0.1191885694861412,
0.2699059545993805,
0.48969051241874695,
1.094763994216919,
0.011622725985944271,
-0.04726142808794975,
0.5864432454109192,
-0.4715000092983246,
-0.11136821657419205,
0.19815365970134735,
0.08394467085599899,
-0.2486725151538849,
1.1233906745910645,
0.04676138237118721,
0.14542485773563385,
0.675374448299408,
0.2959319055080414,
-0.28863248229026794,
-0.27440619468688965,
-0.291044145822525,
0.2785130441188812,
-0.9247154593467712,
-0.14245060086250305,
-0.5251448154449463,
0.016341790556907654,
-0.09072872251272202,
-1.0537430047988892,
-0.2253628820180893,
-0.21594788134098053,
0.08138508349657059,
0.08375103026628494,
-0.01739993505179882,
0.9607647061347961,
-0.14591844379901886,
0.5925037860870361,
-0.9377316832542419,
0.08733095973730087,
0.22570829093456268,
0.20181326568126678,
0.03562163934111595,
0.025406677275896072,
-0.7114751935005188,
-0.40349313616752625,
-0.196549192070961,
-1.0216856002807617,
0.24318787455558777,
-0.1498083621263504,
0.4816478490829468,
0.4046219289302826,
0.04495324566960335,
0.6778272390365601,
-0.20765094459056854,
0.8149396777153015,
0.33240097761154175,
-1.108512282371521,
0.9868609309196472,
-0.35577481985092163,
0.7851560115814209,
0.30655282735824585,
0.4096594750881195,
-0.3160082697868347,
-0.3057030439376831,
-0.7883849740028381,
-0.7765238881111145,
0.8605228662490845,
0.1208389550447464,
-0.18191111087799072,
-0.04666048288345337,
0.3428765535354614,
0.5752711296081543,
0.031694915145635605,
-0.6527871489524841,
-0.1249179095029831,
-0.3768475651741028,
-0.18140281736850739,
0.09226153790950775,
-0.26174575090408325,
-0.32738107442855835,
0.038479384034872055,
0.6752949953079224,
-0.29263368248939514,
0.41542670130729675,
0.6277421116828918,
-0.22436818480491638,
-0.06412836909294128,
0.38816988468170166,
0.6954817175865173,
0.8286506533622742,
-0.10784807056188583,
0.4411378800868988,
-0.15762516856193542,
-0.1528632789850235,
-0.0152369923889637,
0.07815362513065338,
0.17146143317222595,
0.11244464665651321,
0.6079452037811279,
0.7875279188156128,
0.5537043809890747,
-0.6628900766372681,
0.2071429193019867,
-0.17479775846004486,
-0.2863810658454895,
0.0683448389172554,
-0.13400687277317047,
-0.16115552186965942,
0.31912752985954285,
-0.033494073897600174,
0.03316655382514,
0.4102076590061188,
-0.6717128157615662,
0.1860514134168625,
0.1610259860754013,
-0.9163035750389099,
-0.4050329923629761,
0.7905886173248291,
0.20488661527633667,
0.3025185465812683,
0.4511183500289917,
-0.1786552369594574,
-0.531481146812439,
0.8104208707809448,
0.5276080965995789,
0.7038640975952148,
-0.08867021650075912,
0.4821467101573944,
0.45986542105674744,
0.2749212384223938,
0.42120224237442017,
0.29078420996665955,
-0.2102993130683899,
-0.19037586450576782,
-0.2417834848165512,
0.027796661481261253,
-0.342038631439209,
0.103167824447155,
-1.0291345119476318,
0.23851680755615234,
-0.306154727935791,
-0.006337918806821108,
0.27586236596107483,
-0.0905144214630127,
-0.7674728035926819,
0.6249854564666748,
0.19308987259864807,
0.8102498650550842,
-0.7006997466087341,
0.5411984920501709,
1.0989952087402344,
-0.3443889617919922,
-0.6536592841148376,
-0.14681999385356903,
0.49213099479675293,
-0.8607124090194702,
0.5041287541389465,
0.16348665952682495,
0.028754448518157005,
-0.22245991230010986,
-0.18474186956882477,
-0.6431676745414734,
1.1000988483428955,
0.1378924399614334,
-0.18690888583660126,
0.2692079246044159,
0.07360847294330597,
0.34070682525634766,
-0.4520726799964905,
0.5007978081703186,
0.5429918169975281,
0.34356772899627686,
-0.05172797664999962,
-0.8759260773658752,
0.5655397772789001,
-0.3355552852153778,
-0.08209139853715897,
-0.013880330137908459,
-0.5774075984954834,
0.6250565648078918,
-0.4075096845626831,
-0.10608110576868057,
0.1574150174856186,
0.3232461214065552,
0.14544297754764557,
0.7034655213356018,
0.432375431060791,
0.2731911838054657,
0.6975468397140503,
-0.13507777452468872,
1.7377145290374756,
0.03811874985694885,
0.023670751601457596,
1.1783663034439087,
-0.21488289535045624,
0.47605985403060913,
0.2293415665626526,
-0.02787703461945057,
0.7861691117286682,
0.6483927965164185,
0.27755409479141235,
0.48402339220046997,
-0.024979230016469955,
-0.47597724199295044,
-0.40837424993515015,
-0.40618693828582764,
-0.5738545656204224,
0.39591214060783386,
0.3367396295070648,
-0.19671496748924255,
-0.49908000230789185,
0.31895849108695984,
0.0950898602604866,
-0.049978602677583694,
-0.32994046807289124,
0.6642717719078064,
-0.2455894649028778,
-0.4888661503791809,
0.5020771622657776,
-0.23932884633541107,
0.026374781504273415,
-1.1708317995071411,
-0.06678406149148941,
-0.1715932935476303,
-0.015012098476290703,
-0.6615316867828369,
-0.6123024225234985,
0.38220518827438354,
-0.18401236832141876,
-0.28659820556640625,
-0.12760214507579803,
0.6719855666160583,
-0.1767401099205017,
-0.3225249946117401,
-0.029872378334403038,
0.5622101426124573,
0.4434798061847687,
-0.12288304418325424,
-0.548382580280304,
0.40313583612442017,
0.22697849571704865,
-0.008457235991954803,
0.4302074909210205,
0.6614332795143127,
-0.37822702527046204,
0.5674353837966919,
0.43834665417671204,
-0.32067209482192993,
-0.03146563842892647,
-0.07934625446796417,
0.8001244068145752,
-0.48651447892189026,
-0.7121254205703735,
-0.38033849000930786,
0.7627184987068176,
0.1259201318025589,
-0.18091192841529846,
0.5831550359725952,
0.5660675168037415,
0.6859641671180725,
-0.22534313797950745,
1.1641862392425537,
-0.028425442054867744,
-0.12103615701198578,
-0.6768958568572998,
0.5094021558761597,
-0.8658578991889954,
0.08911756426095963,
-0.0664302259683609,
-0.5239223837852478,
-0.5332925319671631,
0.5772770643234253,
-0.2502427399158478,
-0.10091526061296463,
1.4042255878448486,
0.5464910268783569,
-0.28628140687942505,
0.033579885959625244,
0.2931152880191803,
0.38045722246170044,
0.1268841177225113,
0.5474781394004822,
0.637928307056427,
-0.30371126532554626,
0.6171636581420898,
-0.6867629289627075,
-0.6656322479248047,
-0.03921450302004814,
-0.8597011566162109,
-0.7332891821861267,
-0.6578812599182129,
-0.9330026507377625,
-0.32552894949913025,
-0.23676256835460663,
0.4623735249042511,
1.2046507596969604,
-0.5434420704841614,
-0.3862287402153015,
0.18153570592403412,
-0.043850794434547424,
-0.5470138192176819,
-0.20791497826576233,
0.7461179494857788,
-0.30827978253364563,
-0.6095870137214661,
0.6156684160232544,
0.46446874737739563,
-0.24010305106639862,
-0.046548031270504,
0.011768522672355175,
0.07449185103178024,
0.010449104011058807,
0.7691888809204102,
0.5179910063743591,
-0.6501067280769348,
0.03231976553797722,
0.07663692533969879,
0.07959417998790741,
0.16877689957618713,
1.0159188508987427,
-1.0256623029708862,
1.1857610940933228,
-0.08532170951366425,
0.5738207697868347,
0.5227805376052856,
-0.36827701330184937,
0.561115562915802,
-0.7671508193016052,
0.05504285916686058,
-0.23595455288887024,
0.23875978589057922,
0.08246058225631714,
-0.79152911901474,
0.4361095428466797,
-0.027455167844891548,
-0.37583884596824646,
-0.7530084252357483,
0.31696367263793945,
-1.277780294418335,
-0.3600524663925171,
0.6180101633071899,
-0.1880401372909546,
-0.3670942187309265,
-0.24990813434123993,
-0.6455413699150085,
-0.03209983929991722,
-0.1533513218164444,
0.4922051429748535,
0.4138738512992859,
-0.7192250490188599,
-0.23119306564331055,
-0.5730875134468079,
0.4414982795715332,
0.48199662566185,
-1.2315247058868408,
-0.30830422043800354,
0.5141144394874573,
0.15728282928466797,
0.3168521225452423,
0.8574078679084778,
-0.18234847486019135,
0.8290361762046814,
0.016522560268640518,
0.09097667783498764,
-0.1711682826280594,
-0.08544621616601944,
-0.36281514167785645,
0.10029516369104385,
-0.1448574662208557,
-0.14542090892791748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15758v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15758v1
|
Let's Think Dot by Dot: Hidden Computation in Transformer Language Models
| 2024-04-24T09:30:00 | 2024-04-24T09:30:00 |
Jacob Pfau, William Merrill, Samuel R. Bowman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.6
|
Chain-of-thought responses from language models improve performance across
most benchmarks. However, it remains unclear to what extent these performance
gains can be attributed to human-like task decomposition or simply the greater
computation that additional tokens allow. We show that transformers can use
meaningless filler tokens (e.g., '......') in place of a chain of thought to
solve two hard algorithmic tasks they could not solve when responding without
intermediate tokens. However, we find empirically that learning to use filler
tokens is difficult and requires specific, dense supervision to converge. We
also provide a theoretical characterization of the class of problems where
filler tokens are useful in terms of the quantifier depth of a first-order
formula. For problems satisfying this characterization, chain-of-thought tokens
need not provide information about the intermediate computational steps
involved in multi-token computations. In summary, our results show that
additional tokens can provide computational benefits independent of token
choice. The fact that intermediate tokens can act as filler tokens raises
concerns about large language models engaging in unauditable, hidden
computations that are increasingly detached from the observed chain-of-thought
tokens.
|
[
-0.524131715297699,
-0.7102286219596863,
0.6121871471405029,
-0.054656244814395905,
-0.05033085122704506,
0.4825039505958557,
-0.3148057758808136,
-0.5092019438743591,
0.2642155885696411,
0.4421749413013458,
-0.5876522064208984,
0.2745310962200165,
-0.758602499961853,
0.062170591205358505,
-0.6236863732337952,
0.8489000797271729,
0.1259821206331253,
-0.12705466151237488,
-0.3863879442214966,
0.13183611631393433,
-0.4031968414783478,
-0.708061158657074,
-0.693013608455658,
-0.2966235876083374,
0.6934372186660767,
0.45872166752815247,
0.8112748265266418,
0.45922642946243286,
0.667119562625885,
0.3720566928386688,
-0.19252407550811768,
-0.002101768273860216,
-0.5612719655036926,
0.11047393828630447,
-0.03568056970834732,
-0.7347277402877808,
-0.4617013931274414,
0.08624087274074554,
0.3670956492424011,
1.1492432355880737,
-0.03384655341506004,
0.22990433871746063,
-0.15849995613098145,
0.904313862323761,
-0.5908567309379578,
0.35679852962493896,
-0.6578055024147034,
0.06720127910375595,
-0.1315443366765976,
0.1093558520078659,
-0.520663321018219,
-0.17116984724998474,
0.24299998581409454,
-0.6233265995979309,
0.2608349621295929,
0.15798239409923553,
0.6888691186904907,
0.43236038088798523,
-0.16834357380867004,
-0.34158334136009216,
-1.02349853515625,
0.6034861207008362,
-0.2731900215148926,
0.3027609884738922,
0.35483530163764954,
0.28011298179626465,
-0.12738631665706635,
-0.9833370447158813,
-1.052138090133667,
0.09590400010347366,
-0.3295000493526459,
0.07432638108730316,
-0.5211648344993591,
-0.012408838607370853,
0.5523422956466675,
0.7087484002113342,
0.03278668597340584,
-0.06981528550386429,
-0.5994788408279419,
-0.08941085636615753,
0.11088395118713379,
0.15951909124851227,
0.1928442269563675,
0.1595868170261383,
-0.42463597655296326,
-0.3388303816318512,
-0.6479254961013794,
0.39737626910209656,
0.1473226100206375,
0.2934093773365021,
-0.08019942045211792,
0.5508688688278198,
0.02044970542192459,
0.3569929897785187,
0.20808365941047668,
0.26676130294799805,
0.24687889218330383,
-0.2683018743991852,
-0.14895066618919373,
-0.40403294563293457,
0.6520970463752747,
-0.10354845970869064,
0.5361146330833435,
-0.43497753143310547,
-0.22923322021961212,
0.29583534598350525,
0.32812052965164185,
-0.7548420429229736,
-0.3192172944545746,
0.20574063062667847,
-0.26235300302505493,
-0.034057293087244034,
0.04379166662693024,
-0.3475314974784851,
-0.24546530842781067,
-0.34675756096839905,
0.1567291021347046,
-0.20517592132091522,
-0.4292774796485901,
0.16043497622013092,
-0.49369698762893677,
0.026807384565472603,
-0.024237414821982384,
-0.8662324547767639,
0.8124685883522034,
0.8832260370254517,
0.41205644607543945,
-0.26145705580711365,
-0.10072777420282364,
-0.4751439392566681,
-0.1960969865322113,
-0.5280780792236328,
0.8423087000846863,
-0.7601009607315063,
-0.3289773464202881,
-0.14688779413700104,
-0.12018697708845139,
-0.1695072501897812,
-0.4620812237262726,
0.4939832389354706,
-0.5041501522064209,
0.4559696316719055,
-0.6435039043426514,
-0.6066235303878784,
-0.11564528197050095,
-0.20225778222084045,
-0.959273636341095,
1.17751944065094,
-0.009198484010994434,
-0.8724717497825623,
0.41123148798942566,
-0.8432282209396362,
-0.2749868929386139,
0.24709771573543549,
-0.19724039733409882,
-0.262847363948822,
0.42901384830474854,
0.12082783877849579,
0.3734111487865448,
-0.1553257256746292,
0.21317371726036072,
-0.08124145120382309,
-0.5932945013046265,
0.6950181722640991,
-0.49133723974227905,
0.5855408906936646,
-0.04726622626185417,
-0.4247281849384308,
0.2600322365760803,
-0.7279723882675171,
0.045117635279893875,
0.015957728028297424,
-0.04249049723148346,
-0.19963258504867554,
0.05305900052189827,
-0.04700019210577011,
0.25377583503723145,
-0.03271055966615677,
-0.5924128293991089,
0.036221206188201904,
-0.6226629018783569,
0.4181801676750183,
0.8336299061775208,
-0.25213518738746643,
0.5742226243019104,
-0.2747414708137512,
0.49742069840431213,
0.12176275253295898,
0.007467489689588547,
-0.38270553946495056,
-0.6647141575813293,
-1.3616993427276611,
-0.3508155941963196,
0.4165610074996948,
0.2793336808681488,
-0.9508559107780457,
0.18729084730148315,
-0.3583630919456482,
-0.3502650856971741,
-0.6406568884849548,
-0.3328225016593933,
0.5559742450714111,
0.5697765350341797,
0.3095129132270813,
-0.15980704128742218,
-0.5681658387184143,
-1.0105395317077637,
-0.20743559300899506,
-0.0742194801568985,
-0.12475346028804779,
0.22140593826770782,
0.4491502046585083,
0.20202520489692688,
1.0288032293319702,
-0.521755576133728,
0.1302204579114914,
-0.09931092709302902,
-0.10156401246786118,
0.3700338304042816,
0.3609837591648102,
0.0958532840013504,
-0.746087908744812,
-0.4157288372516632,
0.035880059003829956,
-0.5408759117126465,
0.4035121202468872,
-0.04945681244134903,
0.15385550260543823,
-0.05670410394668579,
0.5171890258789062,
-0.8920868039131165,
0.5558668971061707,
0.33536216616630554,
-0.413211852312088,
0.449991911649704,
-0.35365238785743713,
-0.26414018869400024,
-0.6570071578025818,
0.27771034836769104,
-0.5969986319541931,
-0.3490167558193207,
-0.7693397998809814,
0.1109466701745987,
0.0093441316857934,
-0.22631193697452545,
-0.45610716938972473,
0.5389257669448853,
-0.4747811257839203,
-0.08463272452354431,
-0.4315159022808075,
0.06918187439441681,
-0.09875355660915375,
0.7819961905479431,
-0.2506940960884094,
1.1671565771102905,
0.7751359343528748,
-0.7331976890563965,
0.021206920966506004,
0.15191756188869476,
-0.1420835256576538,
0.24373558163642883,
-0.6419863104820251,
0.5157049298286438,
-0.23859922587871552,
0.20723658800125122,
-0.9442734122276306,
0.06086662411689758,
0.1895090937614441,
-0.4409078061580658,
0.16698820888996124,
0.36904191970825195,
-0.6670818328857422,
-0.5935642719268799,
-0.13739748299121857,
0.6095895767211914,
0.617355465888977,
-0.40814247727394104,
0.5863742828369141,
0.49793899059295654,
0.1163833737373352,
-0.6100967526435852,
-0.6311056017875671,
0.1811150312423706,
-0.15844397246837616,
-0.31861355900764465,
0.36663714051246643,
-0.2188389003276825,
-0.24180097877979279,
0.15880876779556274,
-0.24761293828487396,
-0.07989892363548279,
0.15427517890930176,
0.3846757709980011,
0.13500486314296722,
-0.14528663456439972,
0.29348161816596985,
-0.20219458639621735,
-0.5391965508460999,
0.22475826740264893,
-0.38367000222206116,
0.5266784429550171,
-0.3251984417438507,
-0.47576969861984253,
-0.26228755712509155,
0.5634062886238098,
0.5602179765701294,
-0.18752716481685638,
0.6523790955543518,
0.4785144627094269,
-0.36662429571151733,
-0.15870699286460876,
-0.583110511302948,
-0.11176095902919769,
-0.53793865442276,
0.1282631754875183,
-0.6629852652549744,
-1.0451748371124268,
0.6877184510231018,
0.13817930221557617,
-0.13712754845619202,
0.4556063115596771,
0.6826032996177673,
-0.19256246089935303,
0.7398545145988464,
1.0709534883499146,
0.21584567427635193,
0.4790560007095337,
-0.3318581283092499,
0.5096182823181152,
-0.6845229268074036,
-0.3102723956108093,
-0.35888075828552246,
-0.37004849314689636,
-0.6396114230155945,
-0.578079104423523,
0.2440893054008484,
-0.007795144338160753,
-0.17596593499183655,
0.35787615180015564,
-0.42563343048095703,
0.8571867346763611,
0.6304200291633606,
0.06853737682104111,
0.23314034938812256,
-0.004254473373293877,
-0.32454386353492737,
0.07095777988433838,
-0.7939625382423401,
-0.17682841420173645,
0.9912352561950684,
0.22179719805717468,
0.3268328011035919,
-0.3615169823169708,
0.3191849887371063,
0.15941213071346283,
0.09932329505681992,
-0.8238678574562073,
0.5183941721916199,
-0.10142120718955994,
-0.4678848087787628,
-0.35284924507141113,
-0.24180322885513306,
-1.1719435453414917,
0.3275364935398102,
0.07760319113731384,
-0.7445646524429321,
0.24276533722877502,
0.005927726626396179,
-0.23025476932525635,
0.37320664525032043,
-0.8577000498771667,
0.5797491073608398,
0.2443062961101532,
-0.05621650069952011,
-0.3798690438270569,
-0.4758276045322418,
0.1421889215707779,
-0.03520975634455681,
0.31422731280326843,
0.07586834579706192,
-0.07821541279554367,
0.7204992771148682,
-0.7391731142997742,
0.9361675381660461,
0.08287238329648972,
-0.061107248067855835,
0.39294323325157166,
-0.030596841126680374,
0.5155968070030212,
-0.29657208919525146,
0.16616791486740112,
0.09590740501880646,
-0.34564751386642456,
-0.5740453600883484,
-0.7134186625480652,
0.309935986995697,
-0.45068153738975525,
-0.7694822549819946,
-0.1929551512002945,
-0.5536646246910095,
-0.19385476410388947,
0.4108061194419861,
0.08137339353561401,
0.38623350858688354,
0.15041010081768036,
0.15604519844055176,
0.5645653009414673,
0.26903480291366577,
0.9394687414169312,
0.14258554577827454,
-0.23339666426181793,
-0.2541417181491852,
0.944580614566803,
0.03463141620159149,
0.30245786905288696,
0.36308103799819946,
0.17691461741924286,
-0.11083091795444489,
-0.08934252709150314,
-0.2737223505973816,
0.17302273213863373,
-0.8439157605171204,
-0.08862265944480896,
-0.5901020765304565,
-0.1599988043308258,
0.21820683777332306,
0.18462595343589783,
-0.3960440754890442,
-0.9484891295433044,
0.017667395994067192,
-0.5218773484230042,
0.2707459032535553,
0.8268672823905945,
0.031562767922878265,
0.2777039408683777,
-0.4156211316585541,
0.36631444096565247,
0.48613399267196655,
0.6718198657035828,
0.4213747978210449,
-0.034169819205999374,
-0.49359530210494995,
0.03248414769768715,
-0.039124540984630585,
-0.4448753595352173,
-0.09764356166124344,
-0.016965968534350395,
0.40563008189201355,
0.23325903713703156,
-0.11968378722667694,
0.9362230896949768,
-0.8129238486289978,
0.5913848280906677,
0.3489818572998047,
-1.205191969871521,
0.0015347714070230722,
-0.050111785531044006,
0.18555620312690735,
0.25111475586891174,
0.04954849183559418,
-0.5609274506568909,
-0.4929102063179016,
-0.7064883708953857,
-0.7103105783462524,
0.714263379573822,
0.699749231338501,
0.41185519099235535,
-0.29073309898376465,
0.23006395995616913,
0.22907249629497528,
0.281000554561615,
-0.8351617455482483,
-0.7249494791030884,
0.005486622918397188,
0.2721398174762726,
0.1971917450428009,
-0.38365402817726135,
-0.010646660812199116,
-0.27560845017433167,
0.0962994173169136,
0.014424293301999569,
0.47174975275993347,
0.01611475646495819,
0.05317569524049759,
-0.32946231961250305,
0.21238915622234344,
0.4589407742023468,
0.7729411721229553,
0.3073161542415619,
0.3395966589450836,
0.15937182307243347,
-0.26967307925224304,
-0.13506042957305908,
-0.34653106331825256,
-0.013946229591965675,
-0.07540814578533173,
0.35332533717155457,
0.9356728196144104,
0.3988947868347168,
-0.7453869581222534,
0.6936654448509216,
-0.17745374143123627,
0.027189867570996284,
-0.4550907015800476,
0.06308900564908981,
0.14495426416397095,
0.13587968051433563,
0.48530274629592896,
0.5835037231445312,
0.0240560881793499,
-0.46695852279663086,
0.3251279592514038,
0.4231047034263611,
-0.7790160179138184,
-0.6879058480262756,
0.6223818063735962,
0.02817598171532154,
-0.6226322054862976,
0.517022430896759,
-0.14896777272224426,
-0.7222179770469666,
0.49396249651908875,
0.6134130358695984,
1.007195234298706,
0.08121965080499649,
-0.061246078461408615,
-0.044679898768663406,
0.2545207440853119,
0.22663351893424988,
0.2780895531177521,
-0.3410245180130005,
-0.6151182651519775,
-0.7956498265266418,
-0.26431187987327576,
-0.3771464228630066,
-0.1976485252380371,
-0.5559734106063843,
0.16149687767028809,
-0.27352070808410645,
-0.25438955426216125,
0.018464915454387665,
-0.3910589814186096,
-1.0427731275558472,
0.0698910802602768,
0.2544032037258148,
0.720809817314148,
-0.5302097797393799,
0.7378310561180115,
0.21400676667690277,
-0.49183231592178345,
-0.7476565837860107,
-0.023750171065330505,
-0.6572749018669128,
-0.8416375517845154,
0.708283007144928,
0.3542504608631134,
-0.2756187617778778,
-0.1362394094467163,
-0.322607159614563,
-1.1023086309432983,
0.6267693042755127,
0.4219920337200165,
-0.2221270501613617,
-0.2862626016139984,
0.33835580945014954,
0.7082265019416809,
-0.23259225487709045,
0.6071433424949646,
0.4027149975299835,
0.3473738431930542,
0.1534309834241867,
-1.186644434928894,
0.20765194296836853,
-0.3830951452255249,
-0.05276336520910263,
0.2638539671897888,
-0.6299140453338623,
1.2673784494400024,
-0.25311025977134705,
-0.6646971106529236,
-0.28713446855545044,
0.590261697769165,
-0.21491293609142303,
-0.055834587663412094,
0.5755952000617981,
0.4796852469444275,
0.915808379650116,
0.01711283251643181,
1.2612555027008057,
-0.34648433327674866,
0.24733634293079376,
0.8314307928085327,
0.1426514983177185,
0.8452209234237671,
0.6169360280036926,
-0.5059798359870911,
0.8237953186035156,
0.1372811198234558,
0.21743565797805786,
0.2547428011894226,
0.30829954147338867,
0.08263763785362244,
-0.3155900835990906,
-0.038212843239307404,
-0.2936856150627136,
0.36721304059028625,
0.4209090769290924,
0.12845063209533691,
-0.016388393938541412,
-0.12687788903713226,
0.060744281858205795,
0.07251293957233429,
-0.07344108074903488,
0.8424716591835022,
0.26238274574279785,
-0.6798598766326904,
0.6644323468208313,
-0.27963197231292725,
0.3715093731880188,
-0.17017291486263275,
-0.18917585909366608,
-0.256592333316803,
0.13157866895198822,
-0.16281816363334656,
-0.5828367471694946,
0.530935525894165,
-0.049231018871068954,
-0.48186177015304565,
-0.47730767726898193,
0.5360976457595825,
-0.14473167061805725,
-0.6433967351913452,
0.2129323035478592,
0.7672481536865234,
0.03334415331482887,
-0.23102562129497528,
-0.3038690686225891,
-0.2642834484577179,
-0.24952591955661774,
-0.2240738570690155,
0.08867181837558746,
0.7251236438751221,
-0.09302159398794174,
1.0335693359375,
0.9130367636680603,
-0.03372116759419441,
0.2687276601791382,
0.05573150888085365,
1.2229453325271606,
-0.7630433440208435,
-0.6513489484786987,
-0.9390527606010437,
0.7197498679161072,
-0.12346280366182327,
-0.1288357675075531,
0.6792832016944885,
0.6291652321815491,
0.8004869222640991,
-0.06568349152803421,
0.5097389817237854,
0.12726472318172455,
0.6334004998207092,
-0.3801947236061096,
0.5907148718833923,
-0.2754098176956177,
0.3751855194568634,
-0.15800324082374573,
-0.7895385026931763,
-0.18018975853919983,
0.1628151684999466,
-0.08320125192403793,
-0.21049508452415466,
1.1329072713851929,
0.27456241846084595,
-0.07359809428453445,
-0.04788035526871681,
0.4019164443016052,
0.035816118121147156,
0.30212706327438354,
0.4718215763568878,
0.9577013850212097,
-0.482183039188385,
0.6906404495239258,
-0.13409098982810974,
0.026823386549949646,
0.20405526459217072,
-0.5710897445678711,
-1.106972336769104,
-0.7692779302597046,
-0.04132610559463501,
-0.10989084094762802,
-0.41219562292099,
0.6587528586387634,
0.7052380442619324,
-0.9967586398124695,
-0.31648319959640503,
-0.3512766361236572,
0.46362945437431335,
-0.30324339866638184,
-0.23261642456054688,
0.5159739255905151,
-0.6454867720603943,
-0.8674652576446533,
0.37315136194229126,
0.40048614144325256,
-0.17399807274341583,
-0.2686936557292938,
0.2431764006614685,
0.25240558385849,
0.15419542789459229,
0.5640223622322083,
0.041468773037195206,
-1.0562207698822021,
-0.3668960928916931,
0.3957344889640808,
0.055651161819696426,
0.3984106183052063,
1.252907395362854,
-1.3815504312515259,
0.6306686997413635,
0.2900356650352478,
0.6852205395698547,
0.760846734046936,
-0.12711678445339203,
0.6395865678787231,
-0.890959620475769,
0.35696303844451904,
0.20441415905952454,
0.3729335367679596,
0.16476917266845703,
-0.22116774320602417,
0.3010854721069336,
0.2491232454776764,
-0.1190638467669487,
-0.930774986743927,
0.4997015595436096,
-0.7517688274383545,
-0.1722271740436554,
0.6354070901870728,
-0.08361244946718216,
-0.3363315463066101,
-0.15502597391605377,
-0.0261725801974535,
0.12783128023147583,
-0.3325650990009308,
0.6991946697235107,
0.7404099702835083,
-0.21653200685977936,
-0.11262556165456772,
-0.15923084318637848,
0.6383857131004333,
0.5771759152412415,
-0.5498957633972168,
0.1882629096508026,
0.027009595185518265,
0.00022214851924218237,
0.42668578028678894,
0.7829923629760742,
0.07711350172758102,
0.08637111634016037,
0.3003137707710266,
-0.11644004285335541,
-0.1554093062877655,
-0.34307315945625305,
-0.0043722111731767654,
0.33623775839805603,
-0.12017408013343811,
-0.2680065929889679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15737v1
|
No Train but Gain: Language Arithmetic for training-free Language Adapters enhancement
| 2024-04-24T08:52:40 | 2024-04-24T08:52:40 |
Mateusz Klimaszewski, Piotr Andruszkiewicz, Alexandra Birch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modular deep learning is the state-of-the-art solution for lifting the curse
of multilinguality, preventing the impact of negative interference and enabling
cross-lingual performance in Multilingual Pre-trained Language Models. However,
a trade-off of this approach is the reduction in positive transfer learning
from closely related languages. In response, we introduce a novel method called
language arithmetic, which enables training-free post-processing to address
this limitation. Inspired by the task arithmetic framework, we apply learning
via addition to the language adapters, transitioning the framework from a
multi-task to a multilingual setup. The effectiveness of the proposed solution
is demonstrated on three downstream tasks in a MAD-X-based set of cross-lingual
schemes, acting as a post-processing procedure. Language arithmetic
consistently improves the baselines with significant gains in the most
challenging cases of zero-shot and low-resource applications. Our code and
models are available at https://github.com/mklimasz/language-arithmetic .
|
[
-0.31949692964553833,
-0.2608921229839325,
0.23369450867176056,
0.33627596497535706,
-0.08374610543251038,
0.10367114841938019,
-0.40427568554878235,
-0.2970498204231262,
0.24559636414051056,
0.31487005949020386,
-0.5624579191207886,
-0.17521099746227264,
-0.9691762328147888,
0.020531658083200455,
0.11450845003128052,
0.8731071949005127,
0.06904955208301544,
0.4962897002696991,
-0.12572413682937622,
-0.4353628158569336,
-0.4127058982849121,
-0.5760709643363953,
-0.8503846526145935,
-0.17139652371406555,
0.41001081466674805,
0.6042993664741516,
0.3846386969089508,
0.34143996238708496,
0.35264143347740173,
0.3501405715942383,
0.38270506262779236,
0.1331537365913391,
-0.39142122864723206,
-0.3386039435863495,
0.022041790187358856,
-0.6711820960044861,
-0.5715681910514832,
-0.31915104389190674,
0.767993688583374,
0.8862626552581787,
-0.16917024552822113,
0.08541359007358551,
-0.37323182821273804,
1.0151656866073608,
-0.8210172653198242,
0.5562995076179504,
-0.7470969557762146,
0.11229144036769867,
-0.04773714393377304,
-0.08762173354625702,
-0.4215638339519501,
-0.2942027151584625,
-0.3636823296546936,
-0.7041078209877014,
-0.0553397536277771,
-0.399143785238266,
0.32913464307785034,
0.19905118644237518,
-0.3942943513393402,
-0.07447854429483414,
-0.28543007373809814,
0.7730864882469177,
-0.6506108045578003,
0.7081120610237122,
0.33918726444244385,
0.08138170093297958,
0.28505900502204895,
-0.227756068110466,
-0.604536235332489,
-0.00032297353027388453,
0.03665173426270485,
-0.034664932638406754,
-0.1596546322107315,
0.06424906849861145,
0.13676702976226807,
0.5386987924575806,
-0.5497303605079651,
-0.07902906835079193,
-0.3571864068508148,
-0.10007105022668839,
0.5069740414619446,
-0.08525606244802475,
0.48827192187309265,
0.20625507831573486,
-0.047065071761608124,
-0.1707194745540619,
-0.9340310096740723,
0.23749059438705444,
0.2965694069862366,
0.4464056193828583,
-0.18266771733760834,
0.5274516940116882,
-0.39103513956069946,
0.49891698360443115,
0.15213996171951294,
0.1513451337814331,
0.4006889760494232,
-0.17953172326087952,
-0.20488250255584717,
0.27549561858177185,
0.7263855934143066,
0.08562126010656357,
0.44028687477111816,
-0.2721744179725647,
-0.3007592558860779,
0.1819857507944107,
0.06201554462313652,
-1.0357987880706787,
-0.24549627304077148,
-0.24014484882354736,
0.08503730595111847,
-0.18957173824310303,
-0.35172879695892334,
-0.2936649024486542,
-0.2620384991168976,
-0.29981669783592224,
0.6689335107803345,
-0.534242570400238,
-0.6433424949645996,
0.48681095242500305,
-0.03067648783326149,
0.12142504006624222,
0.07205366343259811,
-1.1855943202972412,
0.32291725277900696,
0.6783197522163391,
0.7056643962860107,
0.12760238349437714,
-0.27226772904396057,
-0.7927398681640625,
-0.08968809247016907,
-0.7635267376899719,
0.6118949055671692,
-0.5506981015205383,
-0.4886402189731598,
-0.029484475031495094,
0.0041919066570699215,
-0.34553515911102295,
-0.5939292311668396,
0.3330317735671997,
-0.5725408792495728,
0.10712035745382309,
-0.1716051995754242,
-0.3596024215221405,
-0.2809443175792694,
0.1973400115966797,
-0.6984749436378479,
0.9152488112449646,
0.11709321290254593,
-0.2844682037830353,
0.38304823637008667,
-0.7053344249725342,
-0.7800009846687317,
0.03642736375331879,
-0.05936993658542633,
-0.10139498859643936,
0.5105450749397278,
0.3685441017150879,
0.1311521679162979,
-0.0048335837200284,
0.01929134503006935,
-0.33748069405555725,
-0.2068234533071518,
-0.13563531637191772,
-0.3281789720058441,
0.8946271538734436,
-0.034808628261089325,
-0.37313908338546753,
0.3100535571575165,
-0.7648595571517944,
0.19271081686019897,
-0.1273943930864334,
-0.4516080319881439,
-0.41203203797340393,
-0.13342539966106415,
-0.38601604104042053,
0.6060873866081238,
0.1681901514530182,
-0.6117826104164124,
0.3016589879989624,
-0.6073362231254578,
-0.051540225744247437,
0.6616403460502625,
-0.46222278475761414,
0.7903266549110413,
-0.043292757123708725,
0.634967029094696,
0.18728044629096985,
-0.14658674597740173,
-0.3880225419998169,
-0.33205148577690125,
-1.23418390750885,
-0.12114464491605759,
0.22832733392715454,
0.7307046055793762,
-1.3276309967041016,
0.16097918152809143,
-0.6399103403091431,
-0.3601832985877991,
-0.7023329138755798,
0.2907043695449829,
0.6263013482093811,
0.2908633053302765,
0.34134671092033386,
-0.42579907178878784,
-0.7221199870109558,
-0.6034666895866394,
-0.28502732515335083,
-0.04840833321213722,
0.22835278511047363,
0.01693735457956791,
0.04675060883164406,
0.09639568626880646,
0.23256254196166992,
-0.41691067814826965,
-0.21986232697963715,
-0.41763558983802795,
0.20761333405971527,
0.14184096455574036,
0.5726962089538574,
0.5810264348983765,
-0.42599308490753174,
-0.6221542954444885,
0.2662348747253418,
-0.7311404943466187,
0.07851965725421906,
-0.021729109808802605,
-0.15144261717796326,
0.3895905613899231,
0.38849836587905884,
-0.7595025300979614,
0.09419054538011551,
0.643461287021637,
-0.3362087607383728,
0.4235997200012207,
-0.2600017786026001,
0.3094335198402405,
-0.742685854434967,
0.013420101255178452,
-0.12040755897760391,
-0.415447473526001,
-0.8173102736473083,
0.28615501523017883,
0.28443625569343567,
-0.35957446694374084,
-0.5350361466407776,
0.5377212762832642,
-0.290104478597641,
0.10203763842582703,
-0.34802523255348206,
-0.2048095166683197,
-0.061872657388448715,
0.7194882035255432,
0.2227897047996521,
0.9661968946456909,
0.7880920171737671,
-0.4508689343929291,
-0.01358167827129364,
-0.0655764564871788,
-0.2845122516155243,
0.5065430402755737,
-0.31817349791526794,
0.08449430763721466,
-0.1984826773405075,
-0.10607825219631195,
-0.8225753903388977,
0.2839953899383545,
0.2967340648174286,
-0.7079873085021973,
0.5202320218086243,
-0.18233223259449005,
-0.18511860072612762,
-0.10963419079780579,
-0.3710872232913971,
0.6593130826950073,
0.31559470295906067,
-0.34557652473449707,
0.32564783096313477,
0.4593016803264618,
-0.2910337448120117,
-0.6428192257881165,
-0.788345992565155,
0.17880024015903473,
0.18798813223838806,
-0.3644302487373352,
-0.07819027453660965,
-0.20889072120189667,
-0.11967751383781433,
-0.022877763956785202,
-0.26500222086906433,
-0.4691260755062103,
0.010293200612068176,
-0.13562487065792084,
0.30534857511520386,
-0.5745804309844971,
0.01907237060368061,
0.1687207669019699,
-0.38512665033340454,
0.17486263811588287,
-0.7266395688056946,
0.3697005808353424,
-0.19589997828006744,
-0.27399393916130066,
-0.19588519632816315,
0.3906377851963043,
0.5298963785171509,
-0.4124712646007538,
0.6620531678199768,
0.6622945666313171,
-0.37350931763648987,
-0.0702783614397049,
-0.31712642312049866,
0.08786347508430481,
-0.524812638759613,
0.5733355283737183,
-0.5685788989067078,
-0.9520995616912842,
0.06769008934497833,
0.21529759466648102,
0.09316634386777878,
0.4461168050765991,
0.5257720947265625,
0.5134478807449341,
1.0646822452545166,
0.799850583076477,
-0.06119805946946144,
0.632010817527771,
-0.30302464962005615,
0.3971489369869232,
-0.40389284491539,
-0.12778711318969727,
-0.26439082622528076,
-0.15997523069381714,
-0.38342902064323425,
-0.6365389823913574,
0.06768469512462616,
0.20833724737167358,
-0.10698526352643967,
0.49899065494537354,
-0.006333997473120689,
0.6635293960571289,
0.39792415499687195,
0.0048070028424263,
0.32671496272087097,
0.11803064495325089,
-0.008880367502570152,
-0.157673642039299,
-0.7580515742301941,
0.2919768989086151,
1.0804187059402466,
-0.2599014639854431,
0.44945478439331055,
0.28632423281669617,
0.7723782658576965,
0.29248565435409546,
0.4660879671573639,
-1.0670688152313232,
0.5741995573043823,
-0.46765467524528503,
-0.4256769120693207,
-0.28734660148620605,
-0.8990878462791443,
-0.600179135799408,
0.45366644859313965,
-0.15319669246673584,
-0.2971322238445282,
0.43675076961517334,
-0.04248490929603577,
-0.1262078434228897,
0.5597306489944458,
-0.8028758764266968,
0.9403976202011108,
-0.3406929671764374,
-0.2541770040988922,
-0.6422222256660461,
-0.2841837406158447,
0.37216514348983765,
-0.21094416081905365,
0.45494550466537476,
-0.16521009802818298,
-0.16914328932762146,
0.3959665298461914,
-0.43242311477661133,
0.5880212783813477,
-0.3099544644355774,
-0.16898949444293976,
0.05421370640397072,
0.28556880354881287,
0.3245924115180969,
-0.2520253658294678,
-0.27290934324264526,
0.35385578870773315,
-0.3425404131412506,
-0.7656744122505188,
-0.6608544588088989,
0.6849929690361023,
-0.6948989033699036,
-0.46722590923309326,
-0.24841129779815674,
-0.6953249573707581,
-0.4164799749851227,
0.6184089183807373,
-0.20398256182670593,
0.6127975583076477,
0.0739576444029808,
0.11837807297706604,
0.5676458477973938,
-0.11456084251403809,
0.77260422706604,
0.6655204892158508,
-0.22341154515743256,
-0.7856754064559937,
1.4117110967636108,
0.0719689279794693,
0.49065446853637695,
0.8184787631034851,
0.06714058667421341,
-0.30362582206726074,
-0.5318300724029541,
-1.062686562538147,
0.04001730680465698,
-0.6817032694816589,
-0.12798850238323212,
-0.524491012096405,
-0.013254884630441666,
-0.6635358333587646,
-0.03318832069635391,
-0.4121971130371094,
-1.0154523849487305,
-0.02349318563938141,
-0.3482629656791687,
0.08793029934167862,
0.5737932324409485,
-0.2974766194820404,
0.23352202773094177,
-0.9084632396697998,
0.41478732228279114,
0.3213815987110138,
0.4323525130748749,
0.06624165177345276,
-0.4464564919471741,
-0.7486116886138916,
0.20749017596244812,
-0.21115243434906006,
-0.45576906204223633,
0.40088385343551636,
0.6963865756988525,
0.4460834264755249,
0.42076873779296875,
-0.04421405494213104,
0.920335590839386,
-0.7512868046760559,
0.5048840641975403,
0.6554485559463501,
-1.1147239208221436,
0.025809768587350845,
-0.22609364986419678,
0.32457977533340454,
0.6563282608985901,
0.45236340165138245,
-0.5009418725967407,
-0.05218631401658058,
-0.3606639504432678,
-0.8971062302589417,
0.93873530626297,
-0.05356951057910919,
0.4435219466686249,
-0.19885505735874176,
0.04658900201320648,
0.023657727986574173,
0.42427828907966614,
-0.8997489809989929,
-0.471339613199234,
-0.40447402000427246,
-0.08633380383253098,
-0.23970623314380646,
-0.021263811737298965,
0.1941162794828415,
-0.5343624949455261,
0.7340230941772461,
-0.2534273862838745,
0.16939109563827515,
-0.22076494991779327,
-0.6232516765594482,
-0.15787643194198608,
0.33993110060691833,
0.5908677577972412,
0.5323912501335144,
0.1242806687951088,
0.21971824765205383,
0.39843615889549255,
-0.3084844648838043,
0.24219466745853424,
0.1277477890253067,
0.10898047685623169,
-0.013621562160551548,
0.25128135085105896,
0.9942220449447632,
0.5762088298797607,
-0.6285263895988464,
0.5905680656433105,
-0.14007671177387238,
-0.36355146765708923,
0.06705040484666824,
0.12555041909217834,
-0.042149532586336136,
-0.07494348287582397,
0.2600785791873932,
0.4996420443058014,
0.14902697503566742,
-0.45125746726989746,
0.401546835899353,
0.4412536323070526,
-0.7234963178634644,
-0.47362640500068665,
0.4483383893966675,
0.2132873684167862,
-0.41514086723327637,
0.39856046438217163,
-0.5236766934394836,
-0.47284650802612305,
0.38315314054489136,
0.7249055504798889,
1.0389132499694824,
-0.457466185092926,
0.26686540246009827,
0.42408302426338196,
0.32541894912719727,
0.18417863547801971,
0.4127294421195984,
-0.3322073817253113,
-0.7398648262023926,
-0.9398938417434692,
-0.5421541333198547,
-0.16406084597110748,
-0.23345619440078735,
-0.48843708634376526,
0.17865213751792908,
-0.38847023248672485,
0.3035811185836792,
-0.18268707394599915,
-0.09344291687011719,
-0.4445941150188446,
0.13006530702114105,
0.4881003797054291,
0.9296870827674866,
-0.7594278454780579,
1.190636157989502,
0.7384430170059204,
-0.30397993326187134,
-0.6148001551628113,
-0.297141432762146,
-0.2724003791809082,
-1.1459803581237793,
0.5169960260391235,
0.3777707517147064,
-0.3101041316986084,
0.15510062873363495,
0.21877089142799377,
-0.5908467173576355,
0.47728630900382996,
0.8848691582679749,
-0.3696730434894562,
0.1005093976855278,
0.5732979774475098,
0.3516043424606323,
-0.11525250971317291,
0.2521977424621582,
0.32759714126586914,
0.32091251015663147,
0.11381733417510986,
-0.7158157229423523,
0.010089018382132053,
-0.6291907429695129,
-0.3450095057487488,
0.6463543176651001,
-0.29214322566986084,
0.7584192156791687,
-0.2816040813922882,
-0.08041996508836746,
-0.14677371084690094,
0.5372535586357117,
-0.2264031171798706,
0.06068909540772438,
0.48565298318862915,
0.9723237156867981,
0.5768300890922546,
0.00036414965870790184,
1.1056891679763794,
-0.5022825002670288,
0.29095742106437683,
0.8327781558036804,
0.09650315344333649,
0.8657416701316833,
0.242479607462883,
-0.35548755526542664,
0.4748480021953583,
0.3580945134162903,
0.6671431064605713,
0.5961973071098328,
-0.13676908612251282,
-0.791027307510376,
-0.5450616478919983,
0.0062058609910309315,
-0.49374619126319885,
0.09455811977386475,
0.3381791412830353,
0.20752397179603577,
-0.3626590371131897,
-0.1388290375471115,
0.2957077622413635,
-0.22267168760299683,
-0.6351234912872314,
0.8889302015304565,
0.17843900620937347,
-0.6441571712493896,
0.8524235486984253,
-0.09326649457216263,
0.8185123801231384,
-0.8188166618347168,
-0.0746946930885315,
-0.31236493587493896,
0.4682362675666809,
-0.35751575231552124,
-0.5328288078308105,
0.6897636651992798,
-0.27673014998435974,
-0.20825448632240295,
-0.3010587692260742,
0.41967323422431946,
-0.8228077292442322,
-1.0259464979171753,
0.26284337043762207,
0.6446122527122498,
-0.089605413377285,
-0.21648333966732025,
-0.6776168346405029,
-0.39034056663513184,
0.12800419330596924,
0.18625199794769287,
0.5016814470291138,
0.6891696453094482,
0.0789855569601059,
0.3739711344242096,
0.8250786066055298,
0.31878307461738586,
0.343443900346756,
0.04071551561355591,
0.7454304099082947,
-0.5024299025535583,
-0.36983823776245117,
-0.9220430254936218,
0.5175573825836182,
0.20628631114959717,
-0.1985441893339157,
0.750576913356781,
0.7402796745300293,
1.0970823764801025,
-0.2383865863084793,
0.7482692003250122,
-0.13472336530685425,
-0.2143719494342804,
-0.32784730195999146,
0.690589189529419,
-0.8142306804656982,
0.0318039171397686,
-0.10548226535320282,
-0.4232725501060486,
-0.6931048631668091,
0.41472572088241577,
-0.4365720748901367,
-0.26171281933784485,
0.6050804853439331,
0.8411054015159607,
-0.20799022912979126,
-0.1428089439868927,
0.5006676912307739,
-0.21330630779266357,
0.17958655953407288,
0.720361590385437,
0.438469260931015,
-0.4719989597797394,
0.7790337204933167,
-0.37437739968299866,
-0.2503775954246521,
0.13305121660232544,
-0.7088299989700317,
-0.6358947157859802,
-0.18274180591106415,
-0.19618147611618042,
-0.05120456591248512,
0.15245935320854187,
0.8197818994522095,
0.8562952876091003,
-1.0997273921966553,
-0.6605129837989807,
-0.3133227229118347,
0.47781452536582947,
-0.3549920320510864,
-0.14891472458839417,
0.11610563844442368,
-0.9110882878303528,
-0.6863635778427124,
0.5504388213157654,
0.36052989959716797,
-0.4422851800918579,
0.06072855368256569,
-0.3410003185272217,
-0.2135467678308487,
0.01582661271095276,
0.9896359443664551,
0.402893602848053,
-0.09339616447687149,
0.15696236491203308,
0.146791473031044,
0.20697622001171112,
0.4284537732601166,
1.1893887519836426,
-0.799246072769165,
0.6103606224060059,
0.5523635149002075,
1.0306206941604614,
0.4090084135532379,
-0.45128166675567627,
0.7237504124641418,
-0.8816580772399902,
0.4914223253726959,
-0.1378338634967804,
0.45582112669944763,
0.4041525721549988,
-0.16123028099536896,
0.3471071124076843,
0.45032835006713867,
-0.18077455461025238,
-0.5348036289215088,
0.17197196185588837,
-0.5851544141769409,
-0.10000482946634293,
0.758165717124939,
-0.3312031030654907,
0.04417974129319191,
0.04160308092832565,
-0.0069263349287211895,
0.24108892679214478,
-0.39396780729293823,
0.6162819266319275,
0.3955191373825073,
-0.07509691268205643,
-0.25841987133026123,
-0.33457711338996887,
0.32055702805519104,
0.5429447889328003,
-0.8158714771270752,
0.02351345866918564,
0.453459769487381,
0.2017282098531723,
0.07120658457279205,
0.7256048917770386,
-0.2092810720205307,
0.4684929847717285,
0.002485281554982066,
0.28927081823349,
-0.13605216145515442,
-0.31677383184432983,
-0.5536888837814331,
0.003679368644952774,
0.2347905933856964,
-0.4298752546310425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15720v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15720v3
|
Annotator-Centric Active Learning for Subjective NLP Tasks
| 2024-04-24T08:13:02 | 2024-06-21T18:25:47 |
Michiel van der Meer, Neele Falk, Pradeep K. Murukannaiah, Enrico Liscio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Active Learning (AL) addresses the high costs of collecting human annotations
by strategically annotating the most informative samples. However, for
subjective NLP tasks, incorporating a wide range of perspectives in the
annotation process is crucial to capture the variability in human judgments. We
introduce Annotator-Centric Active Learning (ACAL), which incorporates an
annotator selection strategy following data sampling. Our objective is
two-fold: (1) to efficiently approximate the full diversity of human judgments,
and (2) to assess model performance using annotator-centric metrics, which
emphasize minority perspectives over a majority. We experiment with multiple
annotator selection strategies across seven subjective NLP tasks, employing
both traditional and novel, human-centered evaluation metrics. Our findings
indicate that ACAL improves data efficiency and excels in annotator-centric
performance evaluations. However, its success depends on the availability of a
sufficiently large and diverse pool of annotators to sample from.
|
[
-0.41355618834495544,
-0.5598869919776917,
0.05137745290994644,
0.11630594730377197,
-0.311984658241272,
0.018288906663656235,
-0.5727231502532959,
-0.7979496121406555,
0.16770906746387482,
0.026134058833122253,
-0.0941525250673294,
-0.4643516540527344,
-0.5912415981292725,
0.17886903882026672,
-0.17069467902183533,
1.1154385805130005,
-0.08219081163406372,
-0.12502992153167725,
-0.14865243434906006,
-0.4184362590312958,
-0.4010738134384155,
-0.594170331954956,
-0.7829114198684692,
-0.3750074505805969,
0.6947610974311829,
0.3435462713241577,
0.7353475689888,
0.6015415787696838,
0.5229328274726868,
0.26790547370910645,
-0.12572041153907776,
0.2856284976005554,
0.1430003046989441,
0.5372976064682007,
-0.13623401522636414,
-0.6132146120071411,
-0.4070332944393158,
0.28444838523864746,
0.4022604525089264,
0.9173089265823364,
-0.15075600147247314,
0.3639709949493408,
-0.19850470125675201,
0.5958017706871033,
-0.9965985417366028,
0.1291574090719223,
-0.6186317205429077,
0.6720467209815979,
0.03513304889202118,
0.12455084174871445,
-0.3264505863189697,
-0.2693779468536377,
0.37394773960113525,
-0.7706875801086426,
0.4490602910518646,
-0.12466498464345932,
0.3799688518047333,
0.5425594449043274,
-0.20437411963939667,
-0.33509692549705505,
-0.7570952773094177,
0.8519887924194336,
-0.4347887337207794,
0.39960432052612305,
0.4951544404029846,
0.3208460509777069,
0.6944652199745178,
-0.5321366786956787,
-0.4970376193523407,
-0.10675950348377228,
0.05529727041721344,
0.18910902738571167,
-0.25667136907577515,
0.013808449730277061,
0.28904151916503906,
0.41031351685523987,
-0.09074855595827103,
0.11081670969724655,
-0.2540605962276459,
-0.010498241521418095,
0.8986015319824219,
-0.2952960729598999,
0.06174972280859947,
-0.11108054965734482,
-0.2583226263523102,
-0.09293615818023682,
0.10839217901229858,
0.13971611857414246,
0.36300793290138245,
0.535169243812561,
0.1541498601436615,
0.6272522211074829,
-0.24792787432670593,
0.8596733808517456,
0.23737162351608276,
-0.058123502880334854,
0.6997570991516113,
-0.09711812436580658,
-0.11657264083623886,
0.18541742861270905,
0.6022627949714661,
0.158326655626297,
0.0848761647939682,
-0.3887314796447754,
-0.5581323504447937,
0.04560374468564987,
0.7148095369338989,
-0.32598158717155457,
-0.5221105217933655,
0.2044856995344162,
-0.41970187425613403,
-0.2863823175430298,
0.01262542326003313,
-0.5715309381484985,
-0.36607658863067627,
-0.6033803224563599,
0.41298824548721313,
-0.1309221237897873,
-0.2833578288555145,
-0.05363792926073074,
0.009798434562981129,
-0.06050712987780571,
0.6858462691307068,
-0.7545296549797058,
0.43121591210365295,
0.46185216307640076,
0.9777888059616089,
-0.6286438703536987,
-0.13305504620075226,
-0.6518986225128174,
-0.4470590353012085,
-0.12184984982013702,
0.7823889255523682,
-0.508966326713562,
-0.24106501042842865,
0.012912624515593052,
-0.43207013607025146,
-0.002883677138015628,
-0.514133632183075,
0.7330618500709534,
-0.48643234372138977,
0.06234201416373253,
-0.3433689773082733,
-0.14569441974163055,
-0.4554827809333801,
0.4394457936286926,
-0.953805685043335,
1.077925205230713,
-0.04766032099723816,
-0.8288642168045044,
0.7322087287902832,
-0.8714039921760559,
-0.6623548269271851,
0.18828009068965912,
-0.10977400839328766,
-0.4308004081249237,
0.11526291817426682,
0.08399023860692978,
0.5290049314498901,
0.2890087962150574,
-0.12832115590572357,
-0.11016594618558884,
-0.22658993303775787,
0.48130348324775696,
-0.30724912881851196,
0.39893007278442383,
0.2888023555278778,
-0.5812275409698486,
0.24468886852264404,
-0.6440135836601257,
-0.18996836245059967,
-0.1905393749475479,
-0.46234413981437683,
-0.4682888686656952,
0.15004754066467285,
0.2969132959842682,
0.33425337076187134,
0.044214602559804916,
-0.6401976346969604,
0.18410398066043854,
-0.12989874184131622,
-0.12557801604270935,
0.6856032609939575,
-0.08794684708118439,
0.5907502174377441,
-0.198798269033432,
0.5804020166397095,
-0.10851314663887024,
0.2592109143733978,
0.24241115152835846,
-0.4377135932445526,
-0.9342567324638367,
-0.5444985032081604,
0.4631826877593994,
0.34291762113571167,
-0.6259075999259949,
0.6791282892227173,
0.10923305153846741,
-0.6421259045600891,
-0.6578640937805176,
0.2992730438709259,
0.23036791384220123,
0.24717646837234497,
0.5464685559272766,
-0.769101619720459,
-0.30423370003700256,
-0.6577596664428711,
-0.3003794848918915,
-0.44406598806381226,
0.17112867534160614,
0.45662710070610046,
0.2531350553035736,
0.10537131130695343,
0.9326745867729187,
-0.34122830629348755,
-0.4488617777824402,
-0.35482722520828247,
0.31643831729888916,
0.049638278782367706,
0.22530898451805115,
0.4025779366493225,
-0.963312029838562,
-0.39586153626441956,
-0.09387798607349396,
-0.6938519477844238,
-0.13118262588977814,
-0.2464486062526703,
-0.088313028216362,
0.08485989272594452,
0.026069624349474907,
-0.41492170095443726,
0.26659002900123596,
0.32880541682243347,
-0.3528519570827484,
0.10941983014345169,
0.19089843332767487,
-0.08058468997478485,
-0.4951171875,
0.3217063248157501,
0.3279932141304016,
-0.203617125749588,
-0.5303248763084412,
0.04643256589770317,
-0.027486925944685936,
0.19808697700500488,
-0.48212024569511414,
0.36969971656799316,
-0.4825797975063324,
0.016472140327095985,
-0.4268663227558136,
0.10041452944278717,
-0.20654794573783875,
0.4060641825199127,
0.3102503716945648,
0.4023682773113251,
0.4772300720214844,
-0.5217970013618469,
0.2042563110589981,
0.3324199914932251,
-0.010889657773077488,
0.17924456298351288,
-0.5118780136108398,
0.2908748686313629,
-0.25933778285980225,
0.288778156042099,
-0.6883605122566223,
0.02081657387316227,
0.24306921660900116,
-0.38717061281204224,
0.3175126910209656,
-0.1168539822101593,
-0.3868723511695862,
-0.06430716812610626,
-0.22339871525764465,
0.4118068814277649,
0.21577772498130798,
-0.5566819906234741,
0.8036074042320251,
0.5319076776504517,
0.0399545319378376,
-0.8882907629013062,
-0.6956844925880432,
-0.011090773157775402,
0.034112948924303055,
0.22610539197921753,
-0.12917670607566833,
0.2230120748281479,
-0.43751055002212524,
-0.05346491187810898,
-0.4081830382347107,
0.23327915370464325,
0.5285643935203552,
0.5026199221611023,
0.1301017850637436,
0.14919395744800568,
0.12345647811889648,
-0.17056390643119812,
-0.02826119400560856,
0.1302921175956726,
-0.22258643805980682,
0.33139193058013916,
-0.0953657329082489,
-0.6651201844215393,
-0.3338635265827179,
0.23892126977443695,
0.08036821335554123,
-0.7259113788604736,
0.49953964352607727,
0.7845110297203064,
-0.2586001455783844,
-0.45771607756614685,
-0.5692353844642639,
-0.10438545048236847,
-0.31233474612236023,
0.3857884109020233,
-0.07986295968294144,
-0.6715604066848755,
0.26374396681785583,
0.27910327911376953,
0.702614963054657,
0.40259963274002075,
0.4706859588623047,
0.20125727355480194,
0.8733731508255005,
0.39552924036979675,
0.13333368301391602,
0.7613385915756226,
-0.437068909406662,
0.28136947751045227,
-0.7431715130805969,
-0.443637490272522,
-0.3012125790119171,
-0.8006782531738281,
-0.21148493885993958,
-0.635068416595459,
0.18631617724895477,
-0.0875556543469429,
-0.011737177148461342,
-0.15119905769824982,
-0.7596603631973267,
0.2668289542198181,
0.841727077960968,
0.32887527346611023,
0.36986440420150757,
-0.1890609860420227,
0.3126600384712219,
0.03150089457631111,
-0.4567674398422241,
-0.5372083187103271,
1.2003690004348755,
0.3768021762371063,
0.3997116684913635,
0.26479291915893555,
0.6990945339202881,
0.32947537302970886,
0.6896294355392456,
-1.2323696613311768,
0.4645013213157654,
-0.10737548023462296,
-0.8708300590515137,
-0.037118732929229736,
-0.4207681119441986,
-0.5938764214515686,
0.37622177600860596,
-0.5038672089576721,
-0.3030247390270233,
0.43407267332077026,
0.1759030818939209,
-0.41073837876319885,
0.41958341002464294,
-0.5929679870605469,
0.6521029472351074,
-0.4180886745452881,
-0.3466281294822693,
0.04068731144070625,
-0.7350138425827026,
0.08039461821317673,
-0.21603477001190186,
-0.04909960553050041,
-0.2737775146961212,
-0.40537944436073303,
0.9836106300354004,
0.29443395137786865,
0.9793351888656616,
-0.7092878222465515,
0.4432116746902466,
0.3027650713920593,
0.008714082650840282,
0.058758947998285294,
0.13606609404087067,
-0.3640100657939911,
0.22204674780368805,
-0.6645304560661316,
-0.372425377368927,
-0.4437410831451416,
0.34010758996009827,
-1.1037158966064453,
-0.2971966862678528,
-0.8447003364562988,
-0.35383936762809753,
-0.2635163366794586,
0.0075350250117480755,
-0.2017541080713272,
0.03249666839838028,
-0.10451554507017136,
0.2485649436712265,
0.3941771984100342,
0.13686594367027283,
0.5872638821601868,
0.3700830340385437,
0.0929628387093544,
-0.32544052600860596,
0.47281649708747864,
0.0872003585100174,
0.1693529486656189,
0.22429049015045166,
-0.09993843734264374,
-0.06737931072711945,
-0.8795260787010193,
-0.2536018490791321,
0.012010176666080952,
-0.7950279712677002,
-0.40743231773376465,
-1.1263726949691772,
0.031854048371315,
0.12024277448654175,
-0.12551167607307434,
-0.49967390298843384,
-0.6582509875297546,
-0.33556586503982544,
-0.4524165093898773,
0.32606080174446106,
0.40436992049217224,
-0.1747252345085144,
0.14544755220413208,
-0.3031196594238281,
0.3946464955806732,
0.5711221098899841,
0.1766313910484314,
0.20995360612869263,
-0.33239564299583435,
-0.37150490283966064,
-0.03537232056260109,
-0.4335693120956421,
-0.5894467234611511,
0.22011832892894745,
0.4077955186367035,
0.7580516934394836,
0.38893091678619385,
0.2621820569038391,
0.27126020193099976,
-0.22275912761688232,
0.8468268513679504,
0.23323550820350647,
-0.7348382472991943,
0.6029857397079468,
0.0640932023525238,
0.263503760099411,
1.281090497970581,
0.6384381651878357,
-0.3821234703063965,
-0.3431927561759949,
-0.5084593892097473,
-1.3201258182525635,
0.7555142045021057,
0.3284533619880676,
0.07538673281669617,
-0.122268445789814,
0.5088311433792114,
0.3997496962547302,
0.17258907854557037,
-0.9058871269226074,
-0.4577988386154175,
-0.593390166759491,
-0.21707181632518768,
-0.14600013196468353,
0.3566488027572632,
-0.3131408989429474,
-0.192775160074234,
0.6246169209480286,
-0.435579389333725,
0.1775037944316864,
0.48268553614616394,
-0.16200603544712067,
-0.2729094922542572,
0.05521294102072716,
-0.2567255198955536,
0.6148706674575806,
-0.3196544647216797,
0.43118494749069214,
0.25155946612358093,
-0.6287417411804199,
-0.07692883908748627,
0.39675360918045044,
-0.3328293561935425,
0.26223888993263245,
0.537559986114502,
0.8639321327209473,
-0.028181184083223343,
-0.6701191067695618,
0.6882729530334473,
-0.36002838611602783,
0.035464268177747726,
-0.35087212920188904,
0.3137650489807129,
-0.4437289237976074,
0.194691002368927,
0.8357372879981995,
0.6895903944969177,
0.3447099030017853,
-0.5099068880081177,
0.1914401799440384,
0.3050144612789154,
-0.8431351184844971,
-0.4487382769584656,
0.667079508304596,
0.4805231988430023,
-0.32676294445991516,
0.38778015971183777,
-0.21679751574993134,
-0.615562915802002,
0.3497309386730194,
0.18826639652252197,
1.0035799741744995,
-0.18427278101444244,
0.08817966282367706,
0.44869038462638855,
0.15472377836704254,
-0.20492911338806152,
0.1598212569952011,
-0.5573955774307251,
-0.7412405014038086,
-0.5091211199760437,
-0.7172031998634338,
-0.6625667214393616,
-0.46070608496665955,
-1.032278299331665,
0.21302054822444916,
-0.4538584351539612,
-0.36946821212768555,
0.15922150015830994,
0.45569881796836853,
-0.7066147327423096,
0.5289118885993958,
0.5272654891014099,
0.7256004214286804,
-1.1161831617355347,
0.4771359860897064,
1.2377731800079346,
-0.46241921186447144,
-0.569221019744873,
0.09620794653892517,
-0.09778694808483124,
-0.4719248414039612,
0.5206435322761536,
0.2709239423274994,
0.15944568812847137,
-0.34019744396209717,
-0.2566158175468445,
-0.4627980887889862,
0.976222813129425,
0.0013682766584679484,
-0.4787568747997284,
-0.061652153730392456,
-0.28188374638557434,
0.6412791013717651,
-0.3439844250679016,
0.4846278727054596,
0.13968683779239655,
0.2527007460594177,
-0.010874058119952679,
-0.8767968416213989,
0.06915643066167831,
-0.48785901069641113,
-0.3920381963253021,
0.23771806061267853,
-0.6977422833442688,
0.4911729693412781,
-0.12002335488796234,
0.04563398286700249,
-0.46021121740341187,
0.9281333684921265,
0.39525604248046875,
0.46146294474601746,
1.1695021390914917,
0.3695642948150635,
0.7118223905563354,
0.189116433262825,
0.9102490544319153,
-0.15251415967941284,
0.21519161760807037,
0.818023681640625,
-0.18511457741260529,
1.0405000448226929,
0.43068093061447144,
-0.04391029104590416,
0.11535363644361496,
0.5882008671760559,
-0.0256927702575922,
0.5369383096694946,
-0.08731509745121002,
-0.5826482772827148,
-0.43519020080566406,
-0.22319211065769196,
-0.060073595494031906,
0.7938817143440247,
-0.005899946205317974,
-0.4949011504650116,
0.10040813684463501,
-0.08216480910778046,
0.12266883254051208,
0.03801937401294708,
-0.2837648093700409,
1.0806941986083984,
0.02027970738708973,
-0.7619494199752808,
0.14233121275901794,
-0.04793865978717804,
0.8490635752677917,
-0.44039246439933777,
0.014405032619833946,
0.013068695552647114,
0.06527531147003174,
-0.4151792824268341,
-0.6396693587303162,
0.2360425889492035,
0.25563809275627136,
-0.02804535999894142,
-0.38035324215888977,
0.4865630269050598,
-0.2811761796474457,
-0.5901086926460266,
0.23166166245937347,
0.5332323312759399,
-0.06929273903369904,
-0.16801276803016663,
-0.6761786937713623,
-0.12325483560562134,
0.04449420049786568,
-0.48212918639183044,
0.18851631879806519,
0.3667062819004059,
0.018057897686958313,
0.31012430787086487,
0.7947582602500916,
0.3680534064769745,
-0.13849039375782013,
0.07722633332014084,
0.9586274027824402,
-0.5457452535629272,
-0.31793278455734253,
-0.6169962882995605,
0.4635702073574066,
-0.1899985820055008,
-0.6195628046989441,
0.7876361012458801,
0.7872148156166077,
0.800076961517334,
0.3134615421295166,
0.9998406767845154,
-0.2266237735748291,
0.5011211633682251,
-0.12627018988132477,
0.6054255366325378,
-0.5366951823234558,
0.18547187745571136,
-0.1423012763261795,
-1.206357479095459,
-0.6067647933959961,
1.0018110275268555,
-0.33387887477874756,
0.08509072661399841,
0.49145379662513733,
0.03575237840414047,
-0.37229374051094055,
0.4121371805667877,
-0.05229007452726364,
0.040358442813158035,
0.2525462806224823,
0.24423743784427643,
0.8265265822410583,
-0.23314525187015533,
0.23380672931671143,
-0.6550019979476929,
-0.41650334000587463,
-0.12119778990745544,
-0.5592818260192871,
-0.8528358340263367,
-0.4749743938446045,
-0.5940563678741455,
-0.09286125004291534,
0.026555923745036125,
1.431311845779419,
0.8756962418556213,
-0.7620697021484375,
-0.0800759568810463,
0.2514185607433319,
-0.188934326171875,
-0.40363821387290955,
-0.12297636270523071,
0.290260910987854,
-0.4213730990886688,
-0.7801081538200378,
0.09374795109033585,
-0.1553722769021988,
-0.531170666217804,
-0.17559540271759033,
0.1723671853542328,
-0.40440139174461365,
-0.23606933653354645,
0.5449384450912476,
0.11283480376005173,
-0.5003768801689148,
-0.14661937952041626,
-0.08584126830101013,
0.19287747144699097,
0.08863691240549088,
0.7588132619857788,
-0.8436097502708435,
0.5726408362388611,
0.275863379240036,
0.7055813074111938,
0.6451559066772461,
0.2518260180950165,
0.3214386999607086,
-0.8065448999404907,
0.1431199312210083,
0.9214575290679932,
0.11165826767683029,
0.7232580184936523,
-0.16772927343845367,
0.6667680144309998,
0.12536777555942535,
-0.4855056703090668,
-0.8875239491462708,
-0.15423686802387238,
-1.3380297422409058,
-0.17123454809188843,
1.4733216762542725,
-0.329555481672287,
-0.17585159838199615,
-0.40265747904777527,
-0.14932318031787872,
0.41941189765930176,
-0.6404266357421875,
0.8622053265571594,
0.31345242261886597,
-0.39760687947273254,
-0.03714935481548309,
-0.6468386054039001,
0.38002753257751465,
0.43767502903938293,
-0.6558027267456055,
0.07824643701314926,
0.4121491312980652,
-0.040342558175325394,
0.5052216649055481,
0.3357158303260803,
0.078410305082798,
0.284990519285202,
-0.3029361069202423,
0.5365226864814758,
-0.05512098968029022,
-0.28382381796836853,
-0.3805074989795685,
0.4154159426689148,
0.3905412256717682,
-0.2780150771141052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15702v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15702v1
|
Nyonic Technical Report
| 2024-04-24T07:38:44 | 2024-04-24T07:38:44 |
Junfeng Tian, Rui Wang, Cong Li, Yudong Zhou, Jun Liu, Jun Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This report details the development and key achievements of our latest
language model designed for custom large language models. The advancements
introduced include a novel Online Data Scheduler that supports flexible
training data adjustments and curriculum learning. The model's architecture is
fortified with state-of-the-art techniques such as Rotary Positional
Embeddings, QK-LayerNorm, and a specially crafted multilingual tokenizer to
enhance stability and performance. Moreover, our robust training framework
incorporates advanced monitoring and rapid recovery features to ensure optimal
efficiency. Our Wonton 7B model has demonstrated competitive performance on a
range of multilingual and English benchmarks. Future developments will
prioritize narrowing the performance gap with more extensively trained models,
thereby enhancing the model's real-world efficacy and adaptability.GitHub:
\url{https://github.com/nyonicai/nyonic-public}
|
[
-0.1055683046579361,
-0.3787800669670105,
0.00644957460463047,
0.15673783421516418,
-0.039033547043800354,
0.21254053711891174,
-0.1935001164674759,
-0.86085045337677,
0.37142473459243774,
0.5972552299499512,
-0.07845241576433182,
-0.4571959376335144,
-0.46918532252311707,
0.08615468442440033,
-0.44379767775535583,
0.7706751823425293,
-0.029601173475384712,
0.21574635803699493,
0.554892897605896,
-0.16081702709197998,
-0.5570487380027771,
-0.3664376437664032,
-0.8468959927558899,
-0.2409994751214981,
0.6709258556365967,
0.3213917315006256,
0.6148661375045776,
0.9050283432006836,
0.5178534388542175,
0.3964335024356842,
-0.11503490060567856,
-0.037627361714839935,
-0.3243234157562256,
0.10402213782072067,
0.2795209586620331,
-0.5513074994087219,
-1.2038236856460571,
-0.029113035649061203,
0.7505096793174744,
0.889099657535553,
-0.5725749731063843,
0.09824424982070923,
-0.2842366397380829,
0.4907510280609131,
-0.5392928719520569,
0.40817296504974365,
-0.45665645599365234,
0.2004649043083191,
-0.39743658900260925,
0.01588362455368042,
-0.43803393840789795,
-0.5876020789146423,
0.3901897966861725,
-1.1049482822418213,
-0.09524629265069962,
-0.21228601038455963,
0.7355770468711853,
0.014602520503103733,
-0.47628092765808105,
-0.28498926758766174,
-0.46911513805389404,
0.6958557367324829,
-0.8810092210769653,
0.9365266561508179,
0.20390848815441132,
0.753670334815979,
0.2094012200832367,
-1.0165928602218628,
-0.29338565468788147,
-0.5766730904579163,
0.21425069868564606,
0.22272787988185883,
0.16068635880947113,
-0.0070987907238304615,
-0.019290169700980186,
0.37606820464134216,
-0.41899701952934265,
0.22338366508483887,
-0.6444149017333984,
-0.19003453850746155,
0.40256330370903015,
0.23731085658073425,
0.16497232019901276,
0.006599397398531437,
0.10752880573272705,
0.13162292540073395,
-0.460880845785141,
-0.0957702174782753,
0.6476558446884155,
0.31803199648857117,
-0.40355414152145386,
0.26844483613967896,
-0.40734776854515076,
0.6617733836174011,
-0.003865648992359638,
-0.2297649085521698,
0.3100697696208954,
-0.23087352514266968,
0.033813491463661194,
0.22589203715324402,
0.29576265811920166,
0.3496057391166687,
0.16730426251888275,
-0.3434978425502777,
-0.6732092499732971,
-0.019145261496305466,
0.10072335600852966,
-0.8696455359458923,
-0.2832331955432892,
-0.10837458819150925,
-0.5250422954559326,
-0.46173450350761414,
-0.09008622914552689,
-0.6005150079727173,
-0.4147440493106842,
-0.46561336517333984,
0.40168216824531555,
-0.2546093165874481,
-0.7732099890708923,
0.54129958152771,
-0.019697826355695724,
-0.24391481280326843,
0.5640357732772827,
-0.9459308981895447,
0.4078150987625122,
0.5901493430137634,
1.003118872642517,
-0.27287372946739197,
-0.34657537937164307,
-0.5077465176582336,
0.009493667632341385,
-0.5342597961425781,
0.5133388042449951,
-0.4083225727081299,
0.12818458676338196,
0.24155031144618988,
-0.11539863795042038,
-0.08694001287221909,
-0.6764630079269409,
0.12992320954799652,
-0.9910891056060791,
0.42859259247779846,
0.2599462568759918,
-0.4066496789455414,
-0.15100088715553284,
0.5650395750999451,
-0.9479026794433594,
0.5543235540390015,
0.2955271601676941,
-0.8550174832344055,
0.0622829869389534,
-0.8266034722328186,
-0.07889874279499054,
0.1956479698419571,
0.0261028204113245,
-0.03236055001616478,
0.07124526053667068,
-0.37702676653862,
0.05137952044606209,
-0.4597216248512268,
0.7766284346580505,
-0.17706133425235748,
-0.5746455788612366,
0.22397169470787048,
-0.304295152425766,
0.7716968655586243,
0.33788520097732544,
-0.13853317499160767,
0.3384426236152649,
-1.2524386644363403,
-0.0870986133813858,
0.1138443648815155,
-0.6996389627456665,
0.12204984575510025,
-0.26549938321113586,
0.5067230463027954,
0.07458736002445221,
0.641764223575592,
-0.7201427221298218,
0.33102312684059143,
-0.6590697765350342,
0.564313530921936,
0.6225298047065735,
-0.49557921290397644,
0.47220465540885925,
-0.27413931488990784,
0.9192035794258118,
-0.049628399312496185,
0.32615992426872253,
-0.05910008028149605,
-0.0415160208940506,
-0.8116077184677124,
-0.10568182915449142,
0.6688946485519409,
0.5734410881996155,
-0.7507358193397522,
0.09574179351329803,
-0.4556492567062378,
-0.38156548142433167,
-0.5219408869743347,
-0.1541687250137329,
0.2504422068595886,
0.44537827372550964,
0.20624549686908722,
-0.4119631052017212,
-0.6687372922897339,
-0.9142976999282837,
0.18117791414260864,
0.07328417152166367,
0.22440840303897858,
-0.3107994496822357,
0.13886770606040955,
-0.3273177742958069,
0.7107834815979004,
-0.4989827871322632,
0.08871646970510483,
-0.6954967379570007,
0.051362812519073486,
0.4305833876132965,
0.1480974555015564,
0.6728121042251587,
-0.7023190259933472,
-0.5876691937446594,
0.18955105543136597,
-0.6315804123878479,
-0.13096053898334503,
0.25989729166030884,
0.018937427550554276,
0.4479960799217224,
0.4030435085296631,
-0.31778866052627563,
0.17462225258350372,
0.8819912075996399,
-0.18611538410186768,
0.7448408603668213,
-0.11651650816202164,
0.0605241023004055,
-1.3672350645065308,
0.12056424468755722,
-0.20629768073558807,
-0.1694616824388504,
-0.5692304372787476,
-0.11435665190219879,
0.18364974856376648,
-0.2133173942565918,
-0.5246996879577637,
0.47676002979278564,
-0.1846863478422165,
0.006008519325405359,
-0.48617008328437805,
0.15515057742595673,
-0.11675407737493515,
0.15983963012695312,
-0.18838250637054443,
0.7300105690956116,
0.5264906287193298,
-0.7637816071510315,
0.4477129578590393,
0.012438326142728329,
-0.46474072337150574,
0.18833474814891815,
-0.8492840528488159,
0.07474648952484131,
0.16451886296272278,
0.08049031347036362,
-0.374804824590683,
-0.5365082621574402,
0.06542885303497314,
-0.35824114084243774,
0.4758431613445282,
-0.10840646922588348,
-0.539435625076294,
0.022951655089855194,
-0.3250485062599182,
0.32623422145843506,
0.11367632448673248,
-0.39193177223205566,
0.4486945867538452,
0.7096203565597534,
-0.08984741568565369,
-0.4513140618801117,
-0.69363933801651,
0.07585009187459946,
-0.24724118411540985,
-0.6823672652244568,
0.43604692816734314,
-0.2879534065723419,
-0.2296009212732315,
-0.15727393329143524,
0.1463111937046051,
-0.6555209755897522,
0.28015950322151184,
-0.07122988253831863,
0.46168431639671326,
-0.42303648591041565,
0.10919725894927979,
-0.37829816341400146,
-0.36216023564338684,
-0.05066818371415138,
-0.2777009606361389,
0.6438995599746704,
0.13221152126789093,
0.21513310074806213,
-0.7655714154243469,
0.2816354036331177,
0.7117109298706055,
-0.4251919686794281,
0.8577439188957214,
0.5042513012886047,
-0.55827796459198,
-0.0772392749786377,
-0.3397771120071411,
-0.09587711840867996,
-0.5617274641990662,
0.8270193338394165,
-0.27215346693992615,
-0.9047648310661316,
0.5992040634155273,
0.19775418937206268,
0.24107350409030914,
0.25622427463531494,
0.2660246193408966,
0.4129640758037567,
1.1053858995437622,
1.1153628826141357,
-0.1795429140329361,
0.7942131757736206,
-0.10802454501390457,
0.1979418694972992,
-0.5333887338638306,
-0.09243116527795792,
-0.33108481764793396,
-0.04947429150342941,
-0.7843894362449646,
0.08894503116607666,
0.33569568395614624,
0.03483220189809799,
-0.36995628476142883,
0.5436252355575562,
-0.21632656455039978,
0.29282811284065247,
0.26030731201171875,
-0.4497404992580414,
0.37025415897369385,
-0.23777805268764496,
-0.011095479130744934,
-0.16451908648014069,
-0.7017223238945007,
-0.46551352739334106,
1.1008769273757935,
0.5316396951675415,
0.7482231259346008,
0.3556915521621704,
0.5892510414123535,
-0.10841566324234009,
0.3532501757144928,
-0.5444437861442566,
0.3794959783554077,
-0.219190314412117,
-0.712724506855011,
-0.06750071048736572,
-0.6152381896972656,
-0.8354225158691406,
0.03799030929803848,
0.23805248737335205,
-0.7119768261909485,
-0.33512598276138306,
0.25293800234794617,
-0.2914262115955353,
0.2693411409854889,
-0.8542081713676453,
0.8866657018661499,
-0.3412884473800659,
-0.07530438154935837,
-0.41741880774497986,
-0.2832493484020233,
0.4489750564098358,
-0.24342945218086243,
0.09636902064085007,
-0.10672895610332489,
-0.00650159502401948,
1.09628427028656,
0.012851855717599392,
0.7801516056060791,
-0.3113175928592682,
-0.09827723354101181,
-0.11227460205554962,
0.07275151461362839,
0.2653779685497284,
0.07634297013282776,
-0.46384331583976746,
0.09765204787254333,
0.12238789349794388,
-0.0455954372882843,
-0.3283163011074066,
0.8074129223823547,
-0.7405843734741211,
-0.18341198563575745,
-0.42850860953330994,
-0.9614689350128174,
-0.1864585280418396,
0.36423105001449585,
0.11880707740783691,
0.8649832606315613,
-0.03861628845334053,
0.28841325640678406,
0.4259081482887268,
-0.5149964690208435,
0.5744060277938843,
0.9858580231666565,
-0.5880752801895142,
-0.6905847191810608,
1.0900065898895264,
0.7138173580169678,
0.35009363293647766,
0.5444852113723755,
0.3499838411808014,
-0.1422968953847885,
-0.9189494252204895,
-0.09958308935165405,
0.21112912893295288,
-0.6832221746444702,
-0.2864527404308319,
-0.5695951581001282,
-0.34543371200561523,
-0.5907642245292664,
0.21600474417209625,
-0.9388187527656555,
-0.7131175994873047,
0.1282673180103302,
0.022526156157255173,
0.05099434778094292,
1.2802716493606567,
0.26627397537231445,
0.5055522918701172,
-0.7624238729476929,
0.11247614771127701,
-0.03509785979986191,
0.7554784417152405,
0.07636493444442749,
-0.7991352677345276,
-0.9460411071777344,
-0.283258855342865,
-0.6022688746452332,
-0.4549523890018463,
0.47298464179039,
0.11595462262630463,
0.5819026231765747,
0.11905741691589355,
-0.046863727271556854,
0.4394937753677368,
-0.48126181960105896,
0.43786364793777466,
0.2544090747833252,
-0.9335011839866638,
0.4094679057598114,
-0.6236950755119324,
0.5212000608444214,
0.3321148157119751,
0.18233177065849304,
-0.8321678638458252,
-0.2748089134693146,
-0.367378830909729,
-0.7533888816833496,
0.7367608547210693,
-0.2976008653640747,
0.04079504311084747,
0.1407514214515686,
0.32082754373550415,
0.3130628168582916,
0.2893121540546417,
-0.8172813653945923,
-0.17235122621059418,
-0.16196659207344055,
-0.4174576699733734,
0.20344017446041107,
-0.12383657693862915,
0.22647084295749664,
-0.19323711097240448,
0.441956490278244,
-0.1585111767053604,
0.16950595378875732,
-0.21018913388252258,
-0.2715732753276825,
0.021955423057079315,
0.3019806146621704,
0.858223021030426,
1.2558305263519287,
-0.378674179315567,
-0.10641282051801682,
0.14679598808288574,
-0.676515519618988,
-0.2658146023750305,
0.39452382922172546,
-0.15508252382278442,
-0.036936722695827484,
0.544746458530426,
0.5690707564353943,
0.5300792455673218,
-0.6242918372154236,
0.2189420461654663,
-0.2160138189792633,
-0.10789167881011963,
-0.5648093223571777,
0.09058096259832382,
0.2078353464603424,
0.38450485467910767,
0.3341905176639557,
-0.13505607843399048,
0.1401859074831009,
-0.37624576687812805,
0.1782839298248291,
-0.21903112530708313,
-0.34487736225128174,
-0.9395124912261963,
0.6211978793144226,
0.2702944576740265,
-0.27100324630737305,
0.46328261494636536,
-0.3380136787891388,
-0.6561070680618286,
0.501028835773468,
0.7251001596450806,
0.61844801902771,
-0.3585316240787506,
0.17558108270168304,
0.4832695424556732,
0.18149419128894806,
-0.0874989852309227,
0.3620610237121582,
0.49092599749565125,
-0.6401156187057495,
-0.41496503353118896,
-0.5087376832962036,
-0.4169696867465973,
0.19910359382629395,
-0.6912972331047058,
0.4659286141395569,
-0.5996915102005005,
-0.17507143318653107,
-0.024903539568185806,
0.26971250772476196,
-0.5326458215713501,
0.08936161547899246,
0.14110775291919708,
1.2088862657546997,
-0.4345976412296295,
1.2940994501113892,
0.6067771911621094,
-0.24534714221954346,
-0.9983299374580383,
-0.17008356750011444,
0.01623723842203617,
-0.5158756971359253,
0.835163414478302,
0.4818112552165985,
-0.17627346515655518,
0.03477241471409798,
-0.22949182987213135,
-0.9400191903114319,
1.356491208076477,
0.8588746786117554,
-0.7331534028053284,
-0.03441664204001427,
-0.05052714794874191,
0.4009048342704773,
-0.5540284514427185,
0.3247295916080475,
0.3832637071609497,
0.30267858505249023,
-0.35642537474632263,
-1.406335711479187,
-0.3827819526195526,
-0.29039713740348816,
-0.15085409581661224,
0.4130406081676483,
-0.7553502917289734,
0.9721251130104065,
0.10618908703327179,
-0.022637570276856422,
0.023092810064554214,
0.6848571300506592,
0.12271004170179367,
0.2834072709083557,
0.5635667443275452,
0.4184977114200592,
0.7650877833366394,
0.0762837678194046,
1.002010703086853,
-0.5296448469161987,
0.15950340032577515,
1.1861696243286133,
-0.46323809027671814,
0.8584813475608826,
0.22419264912605286,
0.07794573903083801,
0.1944374293088913,
0.42114561796188354,
0.1705528050661087,
0.6057506799697876,
0.1659104973077774,
-0.056207235902547836,
0.10026080161333084,
-0.5819628834724426,
-0.47401776909828186,
0.6919799447059631,
0.0056627471931278706,
0.0430791899561882,
-0.20486712455749512,
0.0551983043551445,
-0.09591684490442276,
-0.04455200210213661,
-0.19197367131710052,
0.3417900502681732,
-0.04561780393123627,
-0.46411439776420593,
0.4288063943386078,
0.3637695610523224,
0.9594512581825256,
-0.8746318817138672,
0.036456815898418427,
-0.23964108526706696,
0.4961608350276947,
-0.07363858819007874,
-0.3195286989212036,
0.37287116050720215,
-0.0867292508482933,
-0.11789572238922119,
-0.1287572681903839,
0.17695370316505432,
-0.4697691798210144,
-0.35080981254577637,
0.5369406342506409,
0.09526839852333069,
-0.20579832792282104,
0.3412018120288849,
-0.5581915378570557,
0.48503461480140686,
-0.0787275955080986,
-0.17056606709957123,
0.28986936807632446,
0.36095914244651794,
-0.025311755016446114,
0.7233085632324219,
0.1744460016489029,
0.3329586088657379,
0.3373418152332306,
0.6545997858047485,
0.7569006085395813,
-0.7849951982498169,
-0.7178072929382324,
-0.1283840388059616,
0.5336843729019165,
-0.0007455237791873515,
-0.6708776950836182,
0.559779167175293,
0.8295513391494751,
1.0618332624435425,
-0.02322370372712612,
0.47498834133148193,
0.1010255292057991,
0.5846970081329346,
-0.4954017698764801,
0.834395706653595,
-0.4747975766658783,
0.35568466782569885,
0.31020641326904297,
-0.6944769024848938,
-0.29930347204208374,
0.45729607343673706,
-0.13911877572536469,
-0.037038952112197876,
0.8342008590698242,
0.8468546271324158,
-0.17093458771705627,
0.034822978079319,
0.4571804106235504,
0.2540138363838196,
0.6414225101470947,
0.41391998529434204,
0.88105708360672,
-0.6221012473106384,
0.5738874673843384,
-0.4881170094013214,
-0.07890906184911728,
-0.14409653842449188,
-0.6817889213562012,
-0.8272135853767395,
-0.4176502227783203,
-0.5900946259498596,
0.1214466467499733,
0.031021729111671448,
1.115412950515747,
0.8589428663253784,
-0.8733689785003662,
-0.6567056179046631,
-0.037933263927698135,
-0.20778468251228333,
0.1777900755405426,
-0.24297398328781128,
0.07226082682609558,
-0.3598046898841858,
-0.9152492880821228,
0.6486235857009888,
0.25927892327308655,
-0.015193063765764236,
-0.32363465428352356,
-0.3788742423057556,
-0.16570740938186646,
-0.24036866426467896,
0.25763145089149475,
-0.10000358521938324,
-0.4894613027572632,
-0.15982739627361298,
0.21084663271903992,
-0.30574169754981995,
0.07560231536626816,
0.755220890045166,
-0.28623542189598083,
0.4567531645298004,
0.5282202363014221,
0.6548991799354553,
0.20917794108390808,
-0.7458785176277161,
0.8981726169586182,
-0.4933059513568878,
0.4320324957370758,
0.28046122193336487,
0.33336764574050903,
0.5332722067832947,
-0.12060333043336868,
0.2684396803379059,
0.13161230087280273,
-0.4903551936149597,
-0.9740997552871704,
0.13087505102157593,
-0.897741973400116,
0.02250404842197895,
0.4589761197566986,
-0.1061343178153038,
-0.04537694901227951,
-0.06943892687559128,
0.10190688073635101,
0.5117120146751404,
-0.43375542759895325,
0.824094831943512,
0.7802645564079285,
0.26637324690818787,
-0.21043287217617035,
-1.3693968057632446,
0.11477331817150116,
0.18723228573799133,
-0.8212243914604187,
-0.18472804129123688,
0.24660727381706238,
0.4659186601638794,
0.2690284550189972,
0.40651100873947144,
-0.13293884694576263,
0.47644466161727905,
-0.09036076813936234,
0.10236261785030365,
-0.3677891492843628,
-0.6710311770439148,
-0.45208272337913513,
0.15454934537410736,
0.33663180470466614,
-0.33871641755104065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15690v1
|
Neural Proto-Language Reconstruction
| 2024-04-24T06:56:46 | 2024-04-24T06:56:46 |
Chenxuan Cui, Ying Chen, Qinxin Wang, David R. Mortensen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Proto-form reconstruction has been a painstaking process for linguists.
Recently, computational models such as RNN and Transformers have been proposed
to automate this process. We take three different approaches to improve upon
previous methods, including data augmentation to recover missing reflexes,
adding a VAE structure to the Transformer model for proto-to-language
prediction, and using a neural machine translation model for the reconstruction
task. We find that with the additional VAE structure, the Transformer model has
a better performance on the WikiHan dataset, and the data augmentation step
stabilizes the training.
|
[
-0.3549245595932007,
-0.415639728307724,
0.1972447633743286,
-0.0970015600323677,
0.15314939618110657,
0.10183607041835785,
-0.39939016103744507,
-0.3602493703365326,
0.6006137728691101,
0.4811669886112213,
-0.43291962146759033,
0.19028957188129425,
-0.46841663122177124,
0.2934093475341797,
-0.5270903706550598,
0.6889770030975342,
0.27864235639572144,
-0.013988718390464783,
0.2181176394224167,
0.23095276951789856,
-0.393531858921051,
-0.303926944732666,
-0.568977952003479,
-0.44765108823776245,
0.3908870220184326,
0.4600383937358856,
0.6268230676651001,
0.6028490662574768,
0.18646202981472015,
0.40276914834976196,
0.0686355009675026,
-0.08032906800508499,
-0.1922198385000229,
0.1046273484826088,
0.05304329842329025,
-0.6551998257637024,
-0.6258379817008972,
-0.25921928882598877,
0.5346666574478149,
1.0022683143615723,
-0.037470195442438126,
-0.2567831873893738,
-0.06833720952272415,
0.7090368270874023,
-0.47215741872787476,
0.004268113058060408,
-0.42774781584739685,
-0.02159234695136547,
-0.03472215309739113,
-0.1454286277294159,
-0.44720110297203064,
-0.25521573424339294,
0.40169399976730347,
-0.489809513092041,
0.6677003502845764,
-0.2582058608531952,
0.6929836273193359,
-0.11605045944452286,
-0.3274707794189453,
0.13601170480251312,
-1.303888201713562,
0.35060447454452515,
-0.8813017010688782,
0.6693541407585144,
0.3374359607696533,
0.39397600293159485,
-0.25183841586112976,
-0.9887962341308594,
-0.6643583178520203,
-0.3799704909324646,
-0.2427838295698166,
0.20111845433712006,
-0.10099335759878159,
0.10129755735397339,
0.2957312762737274,
0.6100439429283142,
-0.5331189036369324,
0.1412116140127182,
-0.6063999533653259,
-0.3238754868507385,
0.5050347447395325,
0.03155500441789627,
0.40118876099586487,
-0.4830610156059265,
-0.1477888971567154,
-0.3704022467136383,
-0.6221125721931458,
-0.14982907474040985,
0.5325775146484375,
0.4393056035041809,
0.16755308210849762,
0.6306036114692688,
-0.4128333330154419,
0.9057843685150146,
0.13839314877986908,
0.11424127966165543,
0.29546287655830383,
-0.3763774633407593,
-0.0735086128115654,
-0.14951252937316895,
0.6786127090454102,
0.1433677077293396,
0.44098442792892456,
-0.44931307435035706,
-0.2346392273902893,
-0.059751931577920914,
0.505578339099884,
-0.2967398762702942,
-0.4313065707683563,
0.11571703106164932,
-0.4153764545917511,
-0.16794909536838531,
-0.04811739921569824,
-0.533586323261261,
-0.1028786301612854,
-0.6254810690879822,
0.2922399342060089,
-0.7657315731048584,
-0.5670840740203857,
0.09001575410366058,
-0.2116784155368805,
0.3985530734062195,
0.12994027137756348,
-1.141058087348938,
0.5605043768882751,
0.5338156223297119,
0.5567307472229004,
0.15365208685398102,
-0.4339010715484619,
-0.08805322647094727,
-0.1847221553325653,
-0.5427148938179016,
0.9282246828079224,
-0.19297564029693604,
-0.20806154608726501,
-0.08597065508365631,
0.10446836799383163,
-0.0658615380525589,
-0.5008735656738281,
0.23954537510871887,
-0.4546087980270386,
0.4188574552536011,
-0.05107850208878517,
-0.6356261968612671,
-0.48543083667755127,
0.22044837474822998,
-1.0358372926712036,
0.7738756537437439,
0.4667157530784607,
-0.47754397988319397,
0.09725756198167801,
-0.39442020654678345,
-0.38148200511932373,
0.16840994358062744,
0.059679772704839706,
-0.2697012722492218,
0.5141345858573914,
0.22516629099845886,
0.27082234621047974,
-0.2237798422574997,
0.20224502682685852,
-0.0595836415886879,
-0.2730740010738373,
-0.02452365681529045,
-0.393049955368042,
0.8011855483055115,
-0.2555195987224579,
-0.4468892514705658,
0.08738335222005844,
-1.0708545446395874,
-0.11272803694009781,
-0.07370436191558838,
-0.14365670084953308,
-0.13200350105762482,
0.13026681542396545,
0.16871170699596405,
0.29029712080955505,
-0.13375870883464813,
-0.575572669506073,
0.3537651300430298,
-1.168725848197937,
0.4132319986820221,
0.5208984017372131,
-0.1632537543773651,
0.7312655448913574,
-0.23987849056720734,
0.5098527669906616,
-0.10583683103322983,
0.0007779834559187293,
-0.10601441562175751,
-0.2784340977668762,
-1.143272042274475,
0.2964431643486023,
0.5599143505096436,
0.6141520142555237,
-0.976779580116272,
0.36575406789779663,
-0.6391264796257019,
-0.5096082091331482,
-0.6526170969009399,
-0.13445043563842773,
0.1333632916212082,
0.5130758881568909,
0.3530525863170624,
-0.340533047914505,
-1.0906389951705933,
-1.160415768623352,
-0.014500790275633335,
-0.44802242517471313,
-0.31358447670936584,
-0.018427399918437004,
0.2038431018590927,
0.0021021647844463587,
0.7019383907318115,
-0.14206042885780334,
-0.030436696484684944,
-0.15652760863304138,
0.10009343177080154,
0.2862505316734314,
0.3721274733543396,
0.38349395990371704,
-0.7777529358863831,
-0.42922908067703247,
0.12707343697547913,
-0.4136958718299866,
0.1211710125207901,
0.029705289751291275,
0.2825832664966583,
0.03933744505047798,
0.5290439128875732,
-0.6931079626083374,
0.5563474893569946,
0.27142032980918884,
-0.19610127806663513,
0.7007014155387878,
-0.029862383380532265,
0.26411959528923035,
-1.2635642290115356,
0.22211527824401855,
-0.34927859902381897,
-0.2920856475830078,
-1.0701000690460205,
-0.19604898989200592,
0.222868412733078,
-0.019321735948324203,
-0.4272734522819519,
0.340872198343277,
-0.6020333170890808,
-0.13949421048164368,
-0.629923403263092,
-0.08847623318433762,
-0.26581254601478577,
0.332965224981308,
0.34101828932762146,
0.7035611867904663,
0.6697445511817932,
-0.5280281901359558,
0.3895924389362335,
0.21351183950901031,
-0.21451587975025177,
-0.01816326007246971,
-0.701486349105835,
0.29997050762176514,
-0.5181757211685181,
0.09787820279598236,
-1.0217067003250122,
-0.31423309445381165,
0.15654608607292175,
-0.7628353834152222,
0.5013965368270874,
-0.1440950334072113,
-0.19528357684612274,
-0.5115854740142822,
-0.2399596869945526,
0.3779935836791992,
0.5424085855484009,
-0.3529628813266754,
0.9498875141143799,
0.10353511571884155,
-0.284152090549469,
-0.5262177586555481,
-0.2939954400062561,
0.41564813256263733,
-0.04977620393037796,
-0.3276292681694031,
0.6780346035957336,
0.1390424519777298,
-0.05302468314766884,
-0.05308804661035538,
0.38988688588142395,
0.008548194542527199,
-0.027079569175839424,
0.10030030459165573,
0.37360048294067383,
-0.4332767724990845,
-0.1339321732521057,
-0.4625803530216217,
-0.2782037556171417,
-0.04665747657418251,
-0.27254924178123474,
0.7028619647026062,
0.15865527093410492,
0.12475498765707016,
-0.17422454059123993,
0.25037842988967896,
0.6475933194160461,
-0.041642896831035614,
0.3262387812137604,
0.5435053706169128,
-0.6601428389549255,
0.07139135152101517,
-0.7070519924163818,
-0.46357864141464233,
-0.4213795065879822,
0.4284965395927429,
-0.44351208209991455,
-0.4402214586734772,
0.3376770317554474,
0.06911605596542358,
0.011169091798365116,
0.49964892864227295,
0.7256011366844177,
-0.20405495166778564,
0.9647643566131592,
0.9685380458831787,
-0.20639412105083466,
0.5810772180557251,
-0.3783159852027893,
0.26784607768058777,
-0.9205958843231201,
-0.33446499705314636,
-0.42329785227775574,
-0.3068402111530304,
-0.5738765001296997,
-0.2211855947971344,
0.17739500105381012,
0.11760233342647552,
0.3105093538761139,
1.041725754737854,
-0.2032843977212906,
0.18738692998886108,
0.6606158018112183,
0.14611367881298065,
0.16402527689933777,
0.17226886749267578,
0.09091793745756149,
0.005976667162030935,
-0.9440499544143677,
-0.39062657952308655,
1.0551236867904663,
0.0967002809047699,
0.29724863171577454,
-0.13306455314159393,
0.5621635317802429,
-0.2546773850917816,
0.5191081166267395,
-1.0785635709762573,
0.4118083119392395,
-0.08603601902723312,
-0.5925921201705933,
-0.25210490822792053,
-0.19550466537475586,
-1.074605107307434,
0.2041776478290558,
-0.2850508391857147,
-0.7088237404823303,
0.3833659291267395,
0.1879918873310089,
-0.4438701272010803,
0.24546892940998077,
-0.5843055844306946,
0.30221307277679443,
0.0932236835360527,
0.026707112789154053,
-0.1779625415802002,
-0.7126553654670715,
0.436580628156662,
0.040989916771650314,
-0.13421298563480377,
0.2553761899471283,
0.21134182810783386,
0.6628127694129944,
-0.5450807213783264,
0.7606729865074158,
-0.07071109861135483,
0.02344975806772709,
0.23332856595516205,
0.067714162170887,
0.2835227847099304,
-0.2169867604970932,
-0.08492274582386017,
-0.14778901636600494,
-0.4673030972480774,
-0.2552104890346527,
-0.8964589834213257,
0.3197196424007416,
-0.4515247642993927,
-0.5239913463592529,
-0.05388236045837402,
-0.6127731204032898,
-0.4132586121559143,
0.20233173668384552,
0.5004019141197205,
0.4237888753414154,
-0.4045725166797638,
0.051736507564783096,
0.32359254360198975,
0.01255787257105112,
0.8855146765708923,
0.5333139896392822,
0.004426371306180954,
-0.6598814129829407,
0.5122407078742981,
0.21048502624034882,
0.12856769561767578,
0.386216402053833,
-0.002142322948202491,
-0.2737370431423187,
-0.5552371144294739,
-0.3365575671195984,
0.20971859991550446,
-0.3301747441291809,
-0.2781919240951538,
-0.6521914601325989,
-0.4514380991458893,
-0.7381120324134827,
0.1795181781053543,
-0.6012611389160156,
-0.7963075637817383,
0.00783335417509079,
-0.11154305934906006,
0.26239559054374695,
0.6089010238647461,
-0.22796864807605743,
0.37704864144325256,
-0.8465316295623779,
0.5102729797363281,
0.05978216975927353,
0.2178931087255478,
0.14703422784805298,
-0.5227251052856445,
-0.19676090776920319,
0.16558198630809784,
-0.00836731307208538,
-0.7716044783592224,
0.43531450629234314,
0.2962546646595001,
0.3504141867160797,
0.005576243158429861,
-0.517341136932373,
0.6743158102035522,
-0.9770490527153015,
0.6332823038101196,
0.35302552580833435,
-0.5134170055389404,
0.6965848207473755,
-0.018203558400273323,
0.2859525680541992,
0.2773391902446747,
0.40646910667419434,
-0.4712468683719635,
-0.20120267570018768,
-0.8181595206260681,
-0.8287615776062012,
0.38474592566490173,
0.21857623755931854,
0.19514504075050354,
-0.17000435292720795,
0.5470156669616699,
0.28016921877861023,
-0.23551641404628754,
-0.5607019066810608,
-0.12720683217048645,
-0.17478366196155548,
-0.11387518793344498,
-0.3312121331691742,
-0.016554463654756546,
0.23720188438892365,
-0.4214650094509125,
0.6869295239448547,
-0.06411775946617126,
0.36658576130867004,
0.2248571664094925,
-0.25253695249557495,
-0.017597995698451996,
0.044487327337265015,
0.28481733798980713,
0.3990215063095093,
-0.07709022611379623,
-0.007188078481703997,
0.07427635043859482,
-0.52647864818573,
0.36835548281669617,
0.1584935486316681,
-0.3550947904586792,
0.2931438386440277,
0.6632868051528931,
1.0520206689834595,
0.15680046379566193,
-0.26697996258735657,
0.45091596245765686,
-0.013230687938630581,
-0.3033771216869354,
-0.4108647108078003,
-0.011381964199244976,
0.036572832614183426,
0.14735285937786102,
0.23008286952972412,
0.3836142122745514,
0.2803119122982025,
-0.5314304232597351,
0.41654491424560547,
0.03243613988161087,
-0.21547336876392365,
-0.9087080359458923,
0.5002537369728088,
-0.16329209506511688,
-0.781100332736969,
0.8847718834877014,
0.38787516951560974,
-0.5630884766578674,
0.5553288459777832,
0.8084108233451843,
0.9604740142822266,
-0.6208062171936035,
0.19104008376598358,
0.6046255230903625,
0.2454545646905899,
-0.3573096990585327,
0.5683175921440125,
0.21388565003871918,
-0.6869184374809265,
-0.9052412509918213,
-0.38184094429016113,
0.03388972580432892,
0.2726878225803375,
-0.6191128492355347,
0.4113868772983551,
-0.17972640693187714,
-0.3268953859806061,
0.1875055432319641,
-0.30516600608825684,
-0.8953146934509277,
0.4077550172805786,
0.1289045363664627,
1.0283738374710083,
-0.7999628782272339,
0.8834856152534485,
0.6169776320457458,
-0.4414128065109253,
-0.8482980728149414,
-0.19513161480426788,
-0.2462739199399948,
-0.5416703820228577,
0.5911187529563904,
-0.14803795516490936,
-0.03906429931521416,
0.3035573363304138,
-0.049627140164375305,
-1.0101337432861328,
0.7186868786811829,
0.34998655319213867,
-0.65145343542099,
-0.41537541151046753,
0.06500105559825897,
0.621174693107605,
-0.024174798280000687,
0.40124282240867615,
0.5458528995513916,
0.3134160041809082,
-0.3788638412952423,
-1.0379034280776978,
-0.08971785008907318,
-0.23954534530639648,
0.27744603157043457,
0.327465295791626,
-0.21413567662239075,
0.5736221075057983,
-0.019590657204389572,
-0.19769255816936493,
0.09100721776485443,
0.8401473760604858,
-0.2672911584377289,
-0.40714552998542786,
0.6152417659759521,
0.47882363200187683,
0.2991727292537689,
0.03660321980714798,
1.0744867324829102,
-0.2727053761482239,
0.1056673675775528,
0.8522757291793823,
0.11053518205881119,
0.9751729965209961,
0.4538637101650238,
-0.31993329524993896,
0.554182767868042,
0.38352644443511963,
0.07282575964927673,
0.40578120946884155,
-0.05063981935381889,
-0.11729097366333008,
0.12012398988008499,
0.010516627691686153,
-0.09963363409042358,
0.9034779071807861,
0.3647666573524475,
-0.3490453362464905,
-0.20477977395057678,
0.2636454701423645,
-0.47559458017349243,
-0.0752222016453743,
-0.07369209825992584,
0.9337010383605957,
0.04473770037293434,
-0.9538077116012573,
0.7555415034294128,
-0.05512917414307594,
0.44900205731391907,
-0.38631874322891235,
-0.1670108437538147,
-0.37669801712036133,
-0.0630469024181366,
-0.11429398506879807,
-0.38661831617355347,
0.5651940107345581,
-0.4936397671699524,
-0.3575702905654907,
-0.11150459945201874,
1.2451884746551514,
-0.6744493842124939,
-0.4687745273113251,
0.3650396764278412,
0.6654719114303589,
0.05558188259601593,
0.08767873793840408,
-0.37414470314979553,
-0.20021624863147736,
-0.1972665786743164,
-0.383861243724823,
-0.04257158935070038,
-0.04060262441635132,
-0.08257193863391876,
0.5035607814788818,
0.5318987965583801,
0.40067797899246216,
0.18666303157806396,
0.40231263637542725,
0.738525927066803,
-0.7457672357559204,
-0.2517610192298889,
-0.8495238423347473,
0.655739963054657,
-0.05727965012192726,
-0.07182839512825012,
0.5713950395584106,
0.6232115030288696,
0.903751790523529,
-0.38837677240371704,
0.685228705406189,
-0.26791152358055115,
0.4869127571582794,
-0.3845050632953644,
0.3813302218914032,
-0.16794604063034058,
-0.17078441381454468,
-0.17857372760772705,
-1.2456955909729004,
-0.3161693811416626,
0.507472813129425,
0.04702703282237053,
-0.10346522927284241,
0.582021951675415,
1.058159351348877,
-0.3486062288284302,
-0.046873096376657486,
0.2996845543384552,
0.1481277048587799,
0.049101900309324265,
0.7022666931152344,
0.7789495587348938,
-1.0086003541946411,
0.25659799575805664,
-0.5606486797332764,
-0.2722935974597931,
-0.0036401143297553062,
-0.5442013740539551,
-0.4728238880634308,
-0.9485439658164978,
-0.1962144523859024,
-0.4770725667476654,
-0.12568506598472595,
0.7434188723564148,
0.8912100195884705,
-0.8940165042877197,
-0.4588638246059418,
-0.3619193732738495,
-0.375595360994339,
-0.36536139249801636,
-0.21899019181728363,
0.3232916593551636,
-0.3755148649215698,
-0.8913282155990601,
0.9622986912727356,
0.3134382963180542,
0.2975904047489166,
-0.11125774681568146,
0.0857071653008461,
-0.21630455553531647,
-0.2581644654273987,
0.6394568085670471,
0.49996528029441833,
-0.7448247671127319,
-0.33905869722366333,
0.3156791031360626,
0.11447378247976303,
0.2283296138048172,
1.2617042064666748,
-1.0392563343048096,
0.5099373459815979,
0.7498208284378052,
0.8283027410507202,
0.6603867411613464,
-0.13838280737400055,
1.2094850540161133,
-0.6171443462371826,
0.12345076352357864,
0.4449743330478668,
0.4820909798145294,
0.4352806806564331,
-0.195115327835083,
0.44254791736602783,
0.2223912626504898,
-0.07649240642786026,
-0.5953874588012695,
0.31916284561157227,
-0.6676410436630249,
-0.267677903175354,
0.8022655248641968,
0.10808300226926804,
-0.42342886328697205,
-0.15476173162460327,
-0.04773204028606415,
0.6904127597808838,
0.48645326495170593,
0.8757693767547607,
0.8111523389816284,
-0.02615153044462204,
-0.30623549222946167,
-0.57599937915802,
0.511722981929779,
0.6318657994270325,
-0.582815408706665,
0.031837042421102524,
0.4000333547592163,
0.46574315428733826,
0.25847139954566956,
0.7709001302719116,
-0.2639147639274597,
0.357729434967041,
0.15768466889858246,
0.24279887974262238,
0.11004134267568588,
-0.6115673184394836,
-0.4311181604862213,
0.033363401889801025,
0.02119116485118866,
-0.03993891179561615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15676v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15676v1
|
Beyond Chain-of-Thought: A Survey of Chain-of-X Paradigms for LLMs
| 2024-04-24T06:12:00 | 2024-04-24T06:12:00 |
Yu Xia, Rui Wang, Xu Liu, Mingyan Li, Tong Yu, Xiang Chen, Julian McAuley, Shuai Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) has been a widely adopted prompting method, eliciting
impressive reasoning abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). Inspired by the
sequential thought structure of CoT, a number of Chain-of-X (CoX) methods have
been developed to address various challenges across diverse domains and tasks
involving LLMs. In this paper, we provide a comprehensive survey of Chain-of-X
methods for LLMs in different contexts. Specifically, we categorize them by
taxonomies of nodes, i.e., the X in CoX, and application tasks. We also discuss
the findings and implications of existing CoX methods, as well as potential
future directions. Our survey aims to serve as a detailed and up-to-date
resource for researchers seeking to apply the idea of CoT to broader scenarios.
|
[
-0.6142008900642395,
-0.6842439770698547,
0.9780264496803284,
0.11684449762105942,
-0.2185477763414383,
0.8670319318771362,
-0.06352096796035767,
-0.47034952044487,
0.3331366181373596,
0.4577639102935791,
-0.5398798584938049,
-0.5669476985931396,
-0.37256094813346863,
0.18072304129600525,
-0.6990211009979248,
0.6578109860420227,
-0.34742647409439087,
-0.06302493810653687,
-0.08780062943696976,
0.02311740443110466,
-0.38561108708381653,
-0.8786805868148804,
-0.7027378082275391,
-0.27582308650016785,
0.820767343044281,
0.17134389281272888,
0.5971626043319702,
0.3515974283218384,
0.22150160372257233,
0.15640169382095337,
-0.33621394634246826,
0.2747419476509094,
-0.32591667771339417,
0.19180355966091156,
-0.6791775226593018,
-0.801726758480072,
-0.5997931957244873,
0.04122238978743553,
0.7494482398033142,
0.8464874029159546,
-0.07891087979078293,
0.27695733308792114,
-0.12418410927057266,
0.8158275485038757,
-1.0212141275405884,
-0.20471419394016266,
-0.679252028465271,
0.22555269300937653,
0.05177311599254608,
-0.2394988089799881,
-0.4695553183555603,
-0.2741274833679199,
0.28714221715927124,
-0.2394692301750183,
-0.27333733439445496,
0.7161744832992554,
-0.039188869297504425,
-0.30058062076568604,
-0.6917209625244141,
-0.622448205947876,
-0.7023576498031616,
0.9371171593666077,
-0.32808786630630493,
0.413174033164978,
0.22776520252227783,
0.13508383929729462,
-0.2834973633289337,
-0.6837348937988281,
-0.7855773568153381,
-0.2618231475353241,
0.13244026899337769,
0.08590778708457947,
-0.20807886123657227,
0.17531590163707733,
0.02812398225069046,
0.6330963373184204,
-0.32125723361968994,
0.03151640668511391,
-0.007632169872522354,
0.3462236225605011,
0.5170780420303345,
0.29328641295433044,
0.16447517275810242,
0.08080659806728363,
-0.8594369292259216,
-0.06404834985733032,
-1.0632017850875854,
-0.10725624859333038,
0.030861184000968933,
-0.07181418687105179,
-0.021983182057738304,
0.28025540709495544,
-0.23123463988304138,
0.8602761626243591,
-0.05747688189148903,
-0.1471763253211975,
-0.05123729631304741,
-0.455612450838089,
-0.3237420916557312,
0.19701150059700012,
0.6433836221694946,
0.17822660505771637,
-0.09144919365644455,
-0.1737663447856903,
-0.35240408778190613,
-0.051637038588523865,
0.29546985030174255,
0.17634424567222595,
0.029212525114417076,
0.3592647612094879,
-0.36914655566215515,
-0.5299931168556213,
-0.07361911237239838,
-0.5934152007102966,
-0.4129045605659485,
-0.31755945086479187,
0.1040923222899437,
0.015998413786292076,
-0.4880264401435852,
0.1995723694562912,
-0.2150728702545166,
0.3197757303714752,
0.16809120774269104,
-0.3995576798915863,
0.7908208966255188,
0.6636815667152405,
0.8246804475784302,
-0.3887956738471985,
-0.11011366546154022,
-0.3963295817375183,
-0.05546499043703079,
-0.6973419785499573,
0.9460080862045288,
-0.7136012315750122,
-0.3683306872844696,
0.25431764125823975,
-0.15722261369228363,
0.07786024361848831,
-0.3902602791786194,
0.2483023852109909,
-0.6769717931747437,
-0.18716204166412354,
-0.6633605360984802,
-0.4395703971385956,
-0.07697262614965439,
0.806403398513794,
-0.5877904891967773,
1.1559619903564453,
0.02245754934847355,
-0.7432756423950195,
0.3554939925670624,
-0.3271721601486206,
-0.11355883628129959,
-0.19161120057106018,
-0.6563687324523926,
0.192717045545578,
0.14373505115509033,
-0.04728217422962189,
0.3974843919277191,
-1.0920772552490234,
0.24171720445156097,
-0.20929685235023499,
-0.1687806099653244,
0.5071293711662292,
-0.13324671983718872,
0.6212419867515564,
0.37323135137557983,
-0.5422293543815613,
0.23320844769477844,
-0.7733272910118103,
0.3855140805244446,
-0.056331027299165726,
0.17076538503170013,
-0.5144274830818176,
0.23294715583324432,
-0.28557226061820984,
0.7544354796409607,
-0.16343875229358673,
-0.4270308017730713,
0.46662667393684387,
-0.0508442223072052,
0.562461793422699,
0.6764982342720032,
0.12068261951208115,
0.2342236191034317,
-0.6009693741798401,
0.915477454662323,
0.004487108439207077,
0.15324944257736206,
-0.026180479675531387,
-0.37964344024658203,
-0.5879363417625427,
-0.02544255740940571,
-0.015457932837307453,
0.3839239776134491,
-1.1503125429153442,
0.40993624925613403,
-0.03627089411020279,
-0.5623482465744019,
0.004166404251009226,
-0.064865343272686,
0.7860463261604309,
0.12636855244636536,
0.3042452037334442,
-0.19316142797470093,
-0.5715741515159607,
-0.4085932672023773,
-0.0627267137169838,
-0.5766763687133789,
0.33337604999542236,
0.18643228709697723,
0.5242019295692444,
-0.19207507371902466,
0.9941375851631165,
-0.6268365979194641,
0.15716885030269623,
-0.4605056941509247,
-0.0060353330336511135,
0.11078771203756332,
0.1839103102684021,
0.26511624455451965,
-0.5405362248420715,
-0.24692951142787933,
0.21276013553142548,
-0.6798257231712341,
0.14579610526561737,
-0.15619441866874695,
-0.23840150237083435,
0.12252441048622131,
0.6739064455032349,
-0.17847779393196106,
0.30127668380737305,
0.5091614127159119,
-0.04822473227977753,
0.8981993198394775,
0.04247061908245087,
0.2373393476009369,
-1.0802314281463623,
-0.03646313399076462,
-0.24090531468391418,
-0.2744813561439514,
-0.551048219203949,
0.3288045823574066,
-0.17643801867961884,
0.310895174741745,
-0.7114385366439819,
0.617385983467102,
-0.810008704662323,
-0.18020978569984436,
-0.32776597142219543,
0.5797820091247559,
-0.11816694587469101,
0.23568816483020782,
0.3430815637111664,
0.7101162672042847,
0.8303170204162598,
-0.8149516582489014,
0.4486989676952362,
0.2528872489929199,
-0.21840104460716248,
0.3742331862449646,
-0.30711793899536133,
0.4732009768486023,
-0.0015478241257369518,
0.6130427718162537,
-1.0824716091156006,
0.40098413825035095,
0.38572123646736145,
0.02351859025657177,
-0.24558621644973755,
0.025199683383107185,
-0.7631858587265015,
-0.6133058071136475,
-0.6737056970596313,
0.7578718662261963,
0.4899028539657593,
-0.6795114278793335,
0.07754073292016983,
0.3299940526485443,
-0.026793332770466805,
-0.7158907651901245,
-0.521132230758667,
0.22625477612018585,
-0.15690961480140686,
-0.22703906893730164,
0.49389514327049255,
0.06326663494110107,
-0.6212435960769653,
-0.31397825479507446,
-0.3439314365386963,
-0.08712301403284073,
-0.3942616879940033,
-0.18677087128162384,
0.2549498379230499,
-0.036652274429798126,
0.29071784019470215,
0.17957112193107605,
0.12594762444496155,
0.23998130857944489,
-0.6499765515327454,
0.7706011533737183,
-0.16007781028747559,
-0.1367691159248352,
0.01582394912838936,
0.5378913879394531,
0.49913546442985535,
0.005131479352712631,
0.5044885277748108,
-0.028458522632718086,
-0.1671110838651657,
-0.3426138758659363,
-0.6168258786201477,
0.1279807686805725,
-0.4055774509906769,
-0.1814996600151062,
-0.41851264238357544,
-0.93961501121521,
0.5237796306610107,
-0.5467876195907593,
-0.13722927868366241,
0.01905747875571251,
0.5123727917671204,
-0.05537751689553261,
0.7985835671424866,
0.7639732360839844,
-0.1109025627374649,
0.2824374735355377,
-0.46746373176574707,
0.5459384918212891,
-1.278418779373169,
-0.11651799827814102,
-0.3900223672389984,
-0.018510350957512856,
-0.615770697593689,
-0.6535871624946594,
0.3585817813873291,
0.10268254578113556,
-0.03646200895309448,
0.463329941034317,
-0.40839532017707825,
0.2636050581932068,
0.15780076384544373,
-0.024643540382385254,
0.5416763424873352,
-0.22216735780239105,
-0.4336516857147217,
0.7501248121261597,
-1.0509462356567383,
-0.7117956876754761,
0.9157673716545105,
0.12013215571641922,
0.9227029085159302,
-0.1402113288640976,
0.7139161229133606,
0.4832490086555481,
0.11164157837629318,
-0.8120030760765076,
0.7298877239227295,
0.26898908615112305,
-0.7322255373001099,
-0.18653728067874908,
-0.1512024849653244,
-1.1363120079040527,
0.13653548061847687,
-0.12293954938650131,
-1.132200002670288,
0.37445521354675293,
0.2942489683628082,
-0.40052101016044617,
0.7428208589553833,
-0.08590256422758102,
0.21973927319049835,
-0.24227041006088257,
-0.33331212401390076,
-0.3296739161014557,
-0.8177501559257507,
0.5301306247711182,
-0.2087027132511139,
0.2559748888015747,
0.1691456139087677,
-0.24790646135807037,
0.6597753167152405,
-0.500751256942749,
0.7897990345954895,
0.4074352979660034,
-0.6830211281776428,
1.0257360935211182,
-0.11247242242097855,
0.567826509475708,
-0.09171982109546661,
-0.030288832262158394,
0.09471868723630905,
0.3775068521499634,
-0.10302847623825073,
-0.5775139331817627,
0.6341848969459534,
-0.4721965789794922,
-0.5949521064758301,
-0.7043787837028503,
-0.3880978226661682,
-0.5226939916610718,
-0.04385646432638168,
0.1814175695180893,
0.46648818254470825,
-0.05536128953099251,
-0.3516354560852051,
0.6046462059020996,
-0.23003694415092468,
0.34899312257766724,
0.009724101983010769,
-0.6305627822875977,
-0.4809197187423706,
0.7519884705543518,
0.13828125596046448,
0.7601236701011658,
0.5977895259857178,
0.09006230533123016,
-0.42636480927467346,
-0.4467780590057373,
-0.017546791583299637,
0.11530528962612152,
-0.8877898454666138,
-0.1980912983417511,
-0.6327285170555115,
-0.14948277175426483,
-0.18620038032531738,
-0.5016461610794067,
-0.2135917842388153,
-0.405447393655777,
0.33738547563552856,
-0.20785458385944366,
0.23365916311740875,
1.1336181163787842,
0.4005964994430542,
0.2737666070461273,
-0.6386719942092896,
0.1336936205625534,
0.13166676461696625,
0.4262893497943878,
0.38409149646759033,
0.2626703083515167,
-0.03390386700630188,
-0.05438634008169174,
-0.31764617562294006,
-0.8306714296340942,
-0.023016607388854027,
-0.40968218445777893,
0.6361783146858215,
0.3135308623313904,
0.38531041145324707,
0.6194559335708618,
-0.34259548783302307,
1.0261104106903076,
0.6250531673431396,
-1.0962982177734375,
0.5214040279388428,
-0.17450743913650513,
0.13592441380023956,
0.37130656838417053,
0.8604711294174194,
-0.6853910684585571,
-0.43574535846710205,
-0.602608859539032,
-0.9998286962509155,
0.26178357005119324,
0.35678672790527344,
-0.22102029621601105,
-0.6759543418884277,
0.4640772044658661,
0.328950434923172,
0.4373213052749634,
-0.4659508168697357,
-0.3518354296684265,
0.49370241165161133,
0.27390256524086,
0.20138981938362122,
-0.08743372559547424,
0.05631563812494278,
-0.13970404863357544,
0.5987712144851685,
-0.14311516284942627,
0.4520258903503418,
0.5010496377944946,
-0.17871589958667755,
-0.016016105189919472,
0.5085946321487427,
0.4535227417945862,
1.1443212032318115,
0.083742655813694,
0.5372023582458496,
0.4127090275287628,
-0.23738625645637512,
0.7552522420883179,
-0.8769961595535278,
0.18020260334014893,
-0.30853480100631714,
0.401154100894928,
0.37536394596099854,
0.06911886483430862,
-0.812471330165863,
0.0928042083978653,
0.11469946801662445,
-0.19009597599506378,
-0.47344478964805603,
0.17990535497665405,
-0.28266289830207825,
0.21730051934719086,
0.21608540415763855,
-0.18318147957324982,
0.35061463713645935,
-1.172995924949646,
0.005845934152603149,
0.278617262840271,
-0.6279061436653137,
-0.24129360914230347,
0.27472028136253357,
0.18225228786468506,
-0.15737958252429962,
0.3726429343223572,
-0.21079151332378387,
-0.354616641998291,
0.44320520758628845,
0.6885938048362732,
0.9449790120124817,
0.15570026636123657,
0.14063860476016998,
0.0038410539273172617,
0.13952475786209106,
-0.21944573521614075,
0.6407803297042847,
-0.432248055934906,
-0.6793636679649353,
-0.538654625415802,
-0.18894889950752258,
-0.5602189898490906,
-0.009265076369047165,
-0.8369156122207642,
0.26841339468955994,
-0.6322156190872192,
-0.49797946214675903,
-0.2462528795003891,
-0.12541943788528442,
-0.4417739808559418,
0.22191818058490753,
0.4467747211456299,
1.352592945098877,
-0.5093768239021301,
0.8303067088127136,
0.986395537853241,
-0.22093133628368378,
-0.5140966773033142,
0.2924771308898926,
0.1581924706697464,
-0.6365983486175537,
0.5670971870422363,
-0.18441258370876312,
-0.988519012928009,
0.07856885343790054,
-0.49958041310310364,
-0.9701836109161377,
1.1948069334030151,
-0.13925234973430634,
-0.8235471248626709,
-0.13420166075229645,
0.084853895008564,
0.325705349445343,
-0.6555458903312683,
0.17038248479366302,
0.9108215570449829,
0.1848987638950348,
0.12731225788593292,
-0.9214963316917419,
0.268318772315979,
-0.1585826724767685,
0.3206503987312317,
0.30306804180145264,
-0.7942940592765808,
0.6194497346878052,
-0.21336062252521515,
-0.030464205890893936,
0.30152377486228943,
0.3730982542037964,
0.6593230962753296,
0.3710513710975647,
0.8015264868736267,
0.02488592267036438,
0.788813054561615,
0.26404085755348206,
1.1787879467010498,
-0.3667829930782318,
0.2807038724422455,
0.9300617575645447,
-0.7470352649688721,
0.7399975061416626,
0.5969758033752441,
-0.45932382345199585,
0.7944976687431335,
0.5953439474105835,
0.5000037550926208,
0.21400544047355652,
0.8512268662452698,
-0.40678220987319946,
-0.22771374881267548,
-0.06422567367553711,
-0.4214123785495758,
0.09516280144453049,
0.5298694372177124,
-0.3031802773475647,
-0.05059357360005379,
0.08298639953136444,
0.1972299963235855,
-0.03300370275974274,
-0.719947874546051,
0.71109938621521,
0.32168295979499817,
-0.915148138999939,
0.7496024370193481,
-0.3352476954460144,
0.438236266374588,
-0.5398325324058533,
-0.17148840427398682,
0.2204313725233078,
0.021970493718981743,
-0.03034394048154354,
-1.1056551933288574,
0.06583213806152344,
-0.10831152647733688,
-0.1997133046388626,
-0.30112025141716003,
0.6236701011657715,
-0.14658266305923462,
-0.39704999327659607,
0.5809922814369202,
0.7745060920715332,
0.17131246626377106,
0.033451732248067856,
-0.42392584681510925,
0.37924614548683167,
-0.39133167266845703,
0.08105757087469101,
0.19082173705101013,
0.4284333288669586,
-0.6234829425811768,
0.9100756645202637,
0.3633955717086792,
-0.06022452190518379,
0.04492111876606941,
-0.043386247009038925,
1.2097256183624268,
-1.1051764488220215,
-0.5225641131401062,
-0.7921884655952454,
0.3529258966445923,
-0.11499439924955368,
-0.41477781534194946,
0.5563639998435974,
0.3111800253391266,
0.9225361347198486,
0.009971468709409237,
1.0015357732772827,
-0.19352999329566956,
0.067138671875,
-0.7573788166046143,
0.31995871663093567,
-0.32262924313545227,
0.279609739780426,
-0.8865973949432373,
-0.8320018649101257,
-0.2565639913082123,
0.3550734221935272,
-0.43850696086883545,
0.035724494606256485,
1.4539684057235718,
0.40511152148246765,
0.39371922612190247,
0.2229580134153366,
0.4302702844142914,
0.08601456135511398,
0.2622637450695038,
0.35419532656669617,
1.3864527940750122,
-0.16803742945194244,
0.27584487199783325,
-0.03280866518616676,
-0.3892150819301605,
-0.0017353050643578172,
-0.9499217867851257,
-1.0536116361618042,
-0.7494397163391113,
-0.5521344542503357,
-0.07894562184810638,
0.3230978846549988,
1.3152865171432495,
0.752360999584198,
-0.49806442856788635,
-0.5535319447517395,
-0.427303671836853,
0.31985601782798767,
-0.6439608931541443,
-0.07718368619680405,
0.23031611740589142,
-0.6201921105384827,
-0.19351036846637726,
0.29281842708587646,
0.4351121187210083,
-0.3128278851509094,
-0.4216773509979248,
0.159147709608078,
-0.5224767327308655,
0.40989819169044495,
1.2875889539718628,
0.09153147786855698,
-0.8994875550270081,
-0.29169103503227234,
0.23890100419521332,
0.2734187841415405,
0.09592074155807495,
1.3558002710342407,
-1.0744309425354004,
0.38135236501693726,
0.476934552192688,
0.29779842495918274,
0.21530234813690186,
-0.24016143381595612,
0.6917181015014648,
-0.5476746559143066,
-0.15695279836654663,
0.1793883740901947,
0.4569033682346344,
-0.2485230416059494,
-0.4323488771915436,
0.6180212497711182,
-0.04756531864404678,
-0.2956617772579193,
-0.8370632529258728,
0.5787946581840515,
-1.2052415609359741,
-0.31444552540779114,
1.1882175207138062,
-0.16982507705688477,
-0.3625539541244507,
-0.37093713879585266,
-0.43957510590553284,
-0.11480216681957245,
-0.0032159676775336266,
0.761789858341217,
0.686071515083313,
-0.5136328339576721,
-0.27013611793518066,
-0.13141436874866486,
0.21749593317508698,
0.1429288685321808,
-0.9332833886146545,
0.2490040361881256,
0.06257031857967377,
0.005743106361478567,
0.2946525514125824,
0.9347834587097168,
-0.2868718206882477,
0.11965008080005646,
-0.04803787171840668,
0.03397395461797714,
0.6089586019515991,
-0.5767625570297241,
-0.008868844248354435,
0.01091909408569336,
0.35900768637657166,
0.15961651504039764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15667v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15667v4
|
The Promise and Challenges of Using LLMs to Accelerate the Screening Process of Systematic Reviews
| 2024-04-24T05:53:20 | 2024-05-08T11:28:50 |
Aleksi Huotala, Miikka Kuutila, Paul Ralph, Mika Mäntylä
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Systematic review (SR) is a popular research method in software engineering
(SE). However, conducting an SR takes an average of 67 weeks. Thus, automating
any step of the SR process could reduce the effort associated with SRs. Our
objective is to investigate if Large Language Models (LLMs) can accelerate
title-abstract screening by simplifying abstracts for human screeners, and
automating title-abstract screening. We performed an experiment where humans
screened titles and abstracts for 20 papers with both original and simplified
abstracts from a prior SR. The experiment with human screeners was reproduced
with GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 LLMs to perform the same screening tasks. We also
studied if different prompting techniques (Zero-shot (ZS), One-shot (OS),
Few-shot (FS), and Few-shot with Chain-of-Thought (FS-CoT)) improve the
screening performance of LLMs. Lastly, we studied if redesigning the prompt
used in the LLM reproduction of screening leads to improved performance. Text
simplification did not increase the screeners' screening performance, but
reduced the time used in screening. Screeners' scientific literacy skills and
researcher status predict screening performance. Some LLM and prompt
combinations perform as well as human screeners in the screening tasks. Our
results indicate that the GPT-4 LLM is better than its predecessor, GPT-3.5.
Additionally, Few-shot and One-shot prompting outperforms Zero-shot prompting.
Using LLMs for text simplification in the screening process does not
significantly improve human performance. Using LLMs to automate title-abstract
screening seems promising, but current LLMs are not significantly more accurate
than human screeners. To recommend the use of LLMs in the screening process of
SRs, more research is needed. We recommend future SR studies publish
replication packages with screening data to enable more conclusive
experimenting with LLM screening.
|
[
-0.27385208010673523,
-0.1939607858657837,
0.9401191473007202,
0.12619541585445404,
-0.4675743579864502,
0.3209593594074249,
-0.09104478359222412,
-0.4412479102611542,
0.14398297667503357,
0.4674762785434723,
-0.39933162927627563,
-0.5003542304039001,
-0.6303017735481262,
0.5724754333496094,
-0.5048561692237854,
0.9380669593811035,
-0.4657629430294037,
0.31829503178596497,
0.20762677490711212,
0.25755566358566284,
-0.11972486972808838,
-0.2184421718120575,
-0.5743414163589478,
-0.5578897595405579,
0.6669915318489075,
0.4016808569431305,
0.5148302912712097,
0.46920281648635864,
0.8632265329360962,
0.29219570755958557,
-0.17996513843536377,
-0.07546516507863998,
-0.24805991351604462,
0.38372787833213806,
-0.1785101741552353,
-0.5417109727859497,
-0.4746570289134979,
0.049574900418519974,
0.5803784132003784,
0.7025197148323059,
-0.08729185163974762,
0.19862964749336243,
0.08530118316411972,
0.9019058346748352,
-0.4498041868209839,
-0.007794165518134832,
-0.3349815011024475,
0.2035037875175476,
0.09334390610456467,
-0.5081533789634705,
-0.22461716830730438,
-0.3657536208629608,
0.058742351830005646,
-0.3940482437610626,
0.12184774875640869,
0.2531822621822357,
0.8196239471435547,
-0.0013875552685931325,
-0.12591300904750824,
-0.1074044480919838,
-0.7735304832458496,
0.7819664478302002,
-0.7971967458724976,
0.006053941790014505,
0.1423657238483429,
0.24275818467140198,
-0.1749216765165329,
-0.3544636368751526,
-0.3212601840496063,
-0.6511765122413635,
-0.0849367082118988,
-0.039300501346588135,
0.10551352053880692,
0.5746546983718872,
0.555388867855072,
0.3213312029838562,
-0.7294438481330872,
0.26638415455818176,
-0.7686509490013123,
-0.33511489629745483,
0.6506265997886658,
0.3306121826171875,
0.3857443332672119,
-0.18831667304039001,
-0.24007423222064972,
0.023205449804663658,
-0.7708120346069336,
0.07770383358001709,
0.07569902390241623,
0.13038673996925354,
0.044212646782398224,
0.7262285351753235,
-0.7179588079452515,
0.5091838836669922,
-0.19076751172542572,
-0.2200893759727478,
0.009037446230649948,
-0.5062687397003174,
-0.0936407521367073,
0.030460689216852188,
0.6980384588241577,
0.4894501864910126,
0.3309553861618042,
0.18720659613609314,
-0.3642936050891876,
0.17474764585494995,
-0.022210177034139633,
-0.9998504519462585,
-0.056585464626550674,
0.33335644006729126,
-0.4707608222961426,
-0.23304419219493866,
0.0820251852273941,
-0.31327950954437256,
-0.32645463943481445,
-0.35600391030311584,
0.4091123342514038,
-0.23529760539531708,
0.13225911557674408,
0.26953184604644775,
-0.30683064460754395,
0.38821855187416077,
0.5258973240852356,
-0.4372579753398895,
0.32855600118637085,
0.587846577167511,
0.9716087579727173,
-0.5803215503692627,
-0.1902254968881607,
-0.07819806039333344,
-0.01311481837183237,
-0.6065328121185303,
0.9193739891052246,
-0.27649417519569397,
-0.5101807117462158,
-0.2676258981227875,
-0.24364438652992249,
0.03518206626176834,
-0.36222487688064575,
0.425234317779541,
-0.5297423005104065,
0.07857542484998703,
-0.06749457865953445,
-0.37959012389183044,
0.1595335155725479,
0.4068319499492645,
-0.433072566986084,
0.6356048583984375,
-0.20670093595981598,
-0.6861204504966736,
0.2498859167098999,
-0.6705194115638733,
-0.2691407799720764,
-0.03417259082198143,
-0.4432205855846405,
-0.299903005361557,
-0.10805076360702515,
0.4529467523097992,
0.21186979115009308,
-0.4171431362628937,
0.24796153604984283,
-0.19105668365955353,
-0.8615252375602722,
0.19979558885097504,
-0.06987206637859344,
0.301984041929245,
0.3343505859375,
-0.4585874676704407,
0.2257961481809616,
-0.17375968396663666,
0.05441000312566757,
-0.10417996346950531,
-0.34417638182640076,
-0.06041043624281883,
0.0005307696992531419,
-0.3676511347293854,
0.35787147283554077,
-0.14308525621891022,
-0.5721957087516785,
0.25736698508262634,
-0.4170896112918854,
0.08858074992895126,
0.7941192388534546,
0.18388065695762634,
0.5359868407249451,
-0.5516455769538879,
0.7794780731201172,
-0.073851078748703,
0.21565577387809753,
-0.545409083366394,
-0.366428405046463,
-0.8020254969596863,
-0.3094349503517151,
0.5208349823951721,
0.5434106588363647,
-0.7356610894203186,
0.14123283326625824,
-0.2732943296432495,
-0.41714730858802795,
-0.39288485050201416,
0.15411697328090668,
0.5314164757728577,
0.04922321066260338,
-0.059009842574596405,
-0.696682870388031,
-0.5276839733123779,
-1.0242767333984375,
-0.4899674952030182,
-0.387586385011673,
-0.2904298007488251,
0.17980444431304932,
0.5148823857307434,
-0.18663299083709717,
0.9387733340263367,
-0.6564984917640686,
-0.42175376415252686,
-0.6115596294403076,
0.3940381109714508,
0.3998834490776062,
0.08921577036380768,
-0.05045778676867485,
-0.5864796042442322,
-0.42998698353767395,
-0.36133524775505066,
-0.8029427528381348,
-0.5103623270988464,
0.016112137585878372,
0.19663693010807037,
0.3366461992263794,
0.6170946359634399,
-0.5166916251182556,
0.30744966864585876,
0.2965838611125946,
-0.04039289802312851,
0.6998857855796814,
-0.2066725343465805,
0.505829393863678,
-0.5578365325927734,
-0.06422369927167892,
0.2008855938911438,
-0.04851273074746132,
-0.34125009179115295,
0.10041426122188568,
-0.12110172212123871,
-0.28096267580986023,
-0.33999794721603394,
0.519213855266571,
-0.8509621024131775,
-0.22963149845600128,
-0.5609573721885681,
0.3106725811958313,
-0.044036656618118286,
0.144939586520195,
0.07570284605026245,
0.7673924565315247,
0.5074748992919922,
-0.8031262159347534,
-0.22249843180179596,
-0.20923902094364166,
-0.42713993787765503,
0.1484469324350357,
-0.6890069842338562,
-0.22258689999580383,
-0.35698235034942627,
0.7799082398414612,
-1.18930983543396,
-0.23013049364089966,
0.043107714504003525,
-0.3497702479362488,
0.13633233308792114,
-0.040266890078783035,
-0.3627125918865204,
-0.6499812006950378,
-0.9212367534637451,
0.18424493074417114,
0.6122374534606934,
-0.12998691201210022,
0.6037073731422424,
0.2128436118364334,
-0.7896762490272522,
-0.45193353295326233,
-0.5254376530647278,
0.20833079516887665,
0.05280519649386406,
-0.5215133428573608,
0.23178032040596008,
0.11986992508172989,
-0.42036837339401245,
-0.2792697846889496,
-0.2243649661540985,
0.14919458329677582,
-0.10229592025279999,
0.25356391072273254,
0.6041116118431091,
0.08210886269807816,
0.06808993220329285,
0.08820801973342896,
-0.2180958390235901,
0.14123262465000153,
0.07714931666851044,
0.24382157623767853,
0.26089727878570557,
-0.424560546875,
-0.7436403036117554,
0.17003963887691498,
0.5876656770706177,
-0.019709227606654167,
0.004114076029509306,
0.298507422208786,
0.05685099959373474,
-0.1304125040769577,
-0.7138836979866028,
-0.7464331388473511,
-0.4472543001174927,
0.2938825190067291,
-0.25024399161338806,
-1.0131611824035645,
0.23225757479667664,
-0.13652335107326508,
0.23502543568611145,
0.2146805226802826,
0.5135805606842041,
-0.37319403886795044,
1.0770275592803955,
0.539691150188446,
-0.19281445443630219,
0.5833316445350647,
-0.08351586014032364,
0.46304571628570557,
-0.9492319822311401,
0.06742729246616364,
-0.4458675682544708,
-0.39840930700302124,
-0.45680251717567444,
-0.7500845193862915,
0.7147465348243713,
-0.1623670905828476,
0.11123812198638916,
-0.04437684267759323,
-0.45870205760002136,
0.4846843183040619,
0.18612299859523773,
0.07461027801036835,
0.7248929142951965,
0.12410789728164673,
-0.3269563317298889,
-0.12023913115262985,
-0.5473601818084717,
-0.7510119676589966,
1.4703176021575928,
0.4264407157897949,
1.2132740020751953,
-0.37081629037857056,
0.8842867612838745,
0.39414113759994507,
0.667159378528595,
-0.5167639851570129,
0.960841953754425,
0.1441335827112198,
-0.6942086219787598,
-0.31575316190719604,
-0.26624032855033875,
-0.6911566853523254,
0.5833489298820496,
-0.07142297923564911,
-0.5798364281654358,
-0.08670204877853394,
0.1120801642537117,
-0.5521806478500366,
0.2517584264278412,
-0.555184006690979,
0.05254651978611946,
-0.2708767354488373,
-0.2756178081035614,
-0.32615190744400024,
-0.5814961791038513,
0.7019042372703552,
-0.15515650808811188,
0.4193646311759949,
-0.29276594519615173,
-0.1264391541481018,
0.8313144445419312,
-0.3977678716182709,
0.8260535597801208,
-0.057126082479953766,
-0.05751410126686096,
0.2708396315574646,
0.1623346358537674,
0.5261748433113098,
0.02248062938451767,
0.032508883625268936,
-0.05741507560014725,
-0.2565692365169525,
-0.08920137584209442,
-0.3009241819381714,
0.601151704788208,
-0.338559627532959,
-0.9088062644004822,
-0.8561222553253174,
-0.3719561696052551,
-0.002861361252143979,
-0.038370829075574875,
0.03545293211936951,
-0.07415390014648438,
0.03429587557911873,
-0.12789031863212585,
0.6109775304794312,
-0.13139022886753082,
0.16759124398231506,
0.8591528534889221,
-0.5288617610931396,
-0.08954266458749771,
0.4233088493347168,
0.13293783366680145,
0.3460806608200073,
0.22236193716526031,
0.1327209174633026,
-0.16528011858463287,
-0.8316009044647217,
-0.3139849603176117,
0.35756319761276245,
-0.37632647156715393,
-0.048769086599349976,
-1.0945361852645874,
-0.08065828680992126,
-0.3686276078224182,
0.07409314811229706,
0.04162479192018509,
-0.44844818115234375,
0.3482942581176758,
-0.18089576065540314,
0.29874658584594727,
0.6074507236480713,
-0.15186792612075806,
0.158848837018013,
-0.5375053882598877,
0.6968270540237427,
0.20309920608997345,
0.3400379717350006,
-0.132597416639328,
-0.747132420539856,
0.01663876883685589,
-0.26079490780830383,
-0.38418644666671753,
-0.5606415271759033,
0.13633498549461365,
-0.014588807709515095,
0.36779725551605225,
0.1256888210773468,
-0.03991222754120827,
0.49701768159866333,
-0.5073840022087097,
0.855046272277832,
0.045185718685388565,
-0.5394672155380249,
0.5220644474029541,
-0.44478827714920044,
0.4933129847049713,
0.7603321075439453,
0.5170912742614746,
-0.4542786478996277,
-0.7190622091293335,
-0.09930647164583206,
-1.203400731086731,
0.9914768934249878,
0.34166738390922546,
-0.16367606818675995,
0.22542056441307068,
0.2290506213903427,
-0.17201678454875946,
0.10923183709383011,
-0.5663263201713562,
-0.1516740620136261,
0.6128093004226685,
0.1959415227174759,
-0.028152652084827423,
-0.47421082854270935,
-0.11273805797100067,
-0.17719416320323944,
0.7842065095901489,
-0.030374709516763687,
0.1760776937007904,
0.6619168519973755,
-0.1656532883644104,
-0.2086273729801178,
0.6697819828987122,
0.49124574661254883,
0.4679354727268219,
-0.40221676230430603,
-0.15947182476520538,
0.12543076276779175,
-0.4901764690876007,
0.33074334263801575,
0.0579744428396225,
-0.403391569852829,
0.1504814773797989,
0.0710158571600914,
0.30072471499443054,
0.29635700583457947,
-0.8553208112716675,
0.3499625325202942,
-0.17420123517513275,
-0.368416428565979,
-0.1849220246076584,
0.057029202580451965,
0.044470660388469696,
-0.0037855852860957384,
0.663664698600769,
-0.23932984471321106,
0.5910308957099915,
-0.5406768918037415,
0.17212651669979095,
0.24271716177463531,
-0.21323049068450928,
0.14624178409576416,
0.37883231043815613,
0.22125959396362305,
-0.09649482369422913,
0.36940133571624756,
-0.2369636595249176,
-0.4132295846939087,
0.5819109678268433,
0.24640735983848572,
0.7558861374855042,
-0.3380095064640045,
0.15288950502872467,
0.46662378311157227,
0.5914088487625122,
-0.5446621775627136,
0.33390703797340393,
0.12158975005149841,
-0.3404829204082489,
-0.6846400499343872,
-0.6449066996574402,
-0.9020663499832153,
-0.09036537259817123,
-0.2915544807910919,
0.22573918104171753,
-0.43569016456604004,
-0.329250305891037,
0.005916409194469452,
-0.13287700712680817,
-0.18502607941627502,
0.20248286426067352,
0.24091225862503052,
1.0244438648223877,
-0.7997991442680359,
0.43461892008781433,
0.6004803776741028,
-0.27940815687179565,
-0.8910597562789917,
-0.17399612069129944,
0.27794134616851807,
-0.35248497128486633,
0.666768491268158,
0.38487428426742554,
-0.3767109215259552,
-0.1989344209432602,
-0.3684810698032379,
-0.833730161190033,
1.2607944011688232,
-0.0009401139686815441,
-0.8281591534614563,
-0.32375869154930115,
0.026818756014108658,
0.6565990447998047,
-0.37799549102783203,
0.5749583840370178,
0.6340339779853821,
0.4688751995563507,
0.012145178392529488,
-1.0198456048965454,
0.1435568481683731,
-0.1849447637796402,
0.2468719780445099,
0.09153777360916138,
-0.10444134473800659,
0.7627487778663635,
-0.6114366054534912,
-0.3023476302623749,
0.3136918544769287,
0.3894541561603546,
0.9303737878799438,
0.25099170207977295,
0.4761994183063507,
0.2498539537191391,
0.3363594114780426,
-0.1270224004983902,
1.2908935546875,
-0.4685598611831665,
0.10868827998638153,
0.7926238775253296,
-0.8165905475616455,
0.7191861867904663,
0.64155113697052,
-0.30473554134368896,
0.7205194234848022,
0.579757571220398,
0.12289200723171234,
0.12980416417121887,
0.6090885996818542,
-0.13790178298950195,
-0.2229619026184082,
-0.02455202490091324,
-0.2089233100414276,
0.04923371970653534,
0.2822487950325012,
-0.6375666260719299,
-0.4963774085044861,
0.08459977805614471,
-0.13748964667320251,
0.0885624960064888,
-0.39393001794815063,
0.658509373664856,
0.40388837456703186,
-0.9212296009063721,
0.38006162643432617,
0.25207507610321045,
1.0446728467941284,
-0.8497940897941589,
0.05889707803726196,
-0.23682056367397308,
0.15138712525367737,
-0.2681266963481903,
-0.7385299205780029,
-0.09775573015213013,
0.22203335165977478,
-0.10237899422645569,
-0.25946393609046936,
0.8977242708206177,
-0.2690734267234802,
-0.41886240243911743,
0.3427424132823944,
0.5062060952186584,
0.5330497622489929,
-0.1627146601676941,
-0.7598190307617188,
0.194660484790802,
-0.10168470442295074,
-0.44987568259239197,
0.34595227241516113,
-0.07317109405994415,
-0.4934258460998535,
0.9472723603248596,
0.7598870992660522,
0.26748812198638916,
0.00840270146727562,
0.22513271868228912,
0.9127649068832397,
-0.8509261608123779,
-0.3502759337425232,
-0.9024346470832825,
0.24768902361392975,
-0.15989060699939728,
0.20518718659877777,
0.7285043597221375,
0.6761587858200073,
0.47611331939697266,
-0.12884987890720367,
0.9029974341392517,
0.12101674824953079,
0.6220352649688721,
-0.4452431797981262,
0.5471493601799011,
-0.27285632491111755,
0.5131552815437317,
-0.34196391701698303,
-0.8561373949050903,
-0.389199823141098,
0.3574526906013489,
-0.5823939442634583,
0.23128460347652435,
0.8941508531570435,
1.0495765209197998,
0.2965642809867859,
-0.22873790562152863,
0.17333121597766876,
0.047772880643606186,
0.18199346959590912,
0.4963751435279846,
0.7662777900695801,
-0.39963436126708984,
0.5248820781707764,
0.06210080161690712,
-0.4128949046134949,
-0.5149518251419067,
-0.693916380405426,
-0.7714217305183411,
0.07584666460752487,
-0.37415698170661926,
-0.29977717995643616,
0.4640180766582489,
1.001524806022644,
0.5107572674751282,
-0.5525606274604797,
-0.4457438886165619,
0.1243627741932869,
0.21368621289730072,
-0.06389351189136505,
-0.21268266439437866,
0.04494492709636688,
-0.3822430968284607,
-0.5875274538993835,
0.30605411529541016,
0.6287679672241211,
0.0022347948979586363,
-0.3892084062099457,
-0.08865730464458466,
-0.11536403745412827,
0.13969765603542328,
0.4915480613708496,
0.3231116533279419,
-0.6698275804519653,
0.2603590786457062,
0.026456981897354126,
-0.5460600852966309,
0.022024603560566902,
1.1514970064163208,
-0.7906774878501892,
0.3003546893596649,
0.6490865349769592,
0.13403910398483276,
0.4249943196773529,
0.09549213945865631,
0.787196159362793,
-0.25672632455825806,
-0.1790514588356018,
0.35090920329093933,
0.4274691045284271,
0.2593584954738617,
-0.23468606173992157,
0.5276705622673035,
-0.05895937606692314,
-0.5547993779182434,
-0.8591428995132446,
0.23966515064239502,
-0.9009003639221191,
-0.2767845094203949,
1.4495724439620972,
0.18143706023693085,
-0.352824330329895,
-0.39573830366134644,
-0.4218398928642273,
-0.1619950830936432,
-0.5579413175582886,
0.897540807723999,
0.6448748707771301,
-0.32893818616867065,
-0.061094850301742554,
-0.4999306797981262,
0.53850919008255,
0.5970667004585266,
-0.7360491156578064,
-0.10252608358860016,
0.24148501455783844,
0.5665362477302551,
0.2541477680206299,
1.2020741701126099,
-0.7334279417991638,
0.48169440031051636,
-0.4582994878292084,
0.34444406628608704,
0.06950150430202484,
-0.10344991087913513,
-0.6584837436676025,
-0.12499184161424637,
0.45152100920677185,
0.27738791704177856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15660v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15660v1
|
KS-LLM: Knowledge Selection of Large Language Models with Evidence Document for Question Answering
| 2024-04-24T05:32:41 | 2024-04-24T05:32:41 |
Xinxin Zheng, Feihu Che, Jinyang Wu, Shuai Zhang, Shuai Nie, Kang Liu, Jianhua Tao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) suffer from the hallucination problem and face
significant challenges when applied to knowledge-intensive tasks. A promising
approach is to leverage evidence documents as extra supporting knowledge, which
can be obtained through retrieval or generation. However, existing methods
directly leverage the entire contents of the evidence document, which may
introduce noise information and impair the performance of large language
models. To tackle this problem, we propose a novel Knowledge Selection of Large
Language Models (KS-LLM) method, aiming to identify valuable information from
evidence documents. The KS-LLM approach utilizes triples to effectively select
knowledge snippets from evidence documents that are beneficial to answering
questions. Specifically, we first generate triples based on the input question,
then select the evidence sentences most similar to triples from the evidence
document, and finally combine the evidence sentences and triples to assist
large language models in generating answers. Experimental comparisons on
several question answering datasets, such as TriviaQA, WebQ, and NQ,
demonstrate that the proposed method surpasses the baselines and achieves the
best results.
|
[
-0.24645589292049408,
-0.7548477053642273,
1.1932026147842407,
-0.14357733726501465,
-0.4307107627391815,
0.03255615383386612,
-0.06573015451431274,
-0.37493062019348145,
0.16145266592502594,
0.8658355474472046,
-0.43724438548088074,
-0.6053641438484192,
-0.6072490811347961,
0.13740062713623047,
-0.3837338089942932,
0.7563191652297974,
-0.14999784529209137,
0.45357149839401245,
-0.6385467052459717,
0.10133355855941772,
-0.22515906393527985,
-0.40874603390693665,
-0.43191269040107727,
-0.35779088735580444,
0.4656471014022827,
0.5679283738136292,
0.2936534583568573,
0.5084325075149536,
0.4263104498386383,
0.1688874065876007,
-0.13919807970523834,
0.39672768115997314,
-0.44320130348205566,
0.517116367816925,
0.04253804311156273,
-0.6021050214767456,
-0.11625093221664429,
-0.23004186153411865,
0.6518792510032654,
0.7191548347473145,
0.12480863928794861,
0.14571520686149597,
-0.24591302871704102,
0.5076074004173279,
-0.6165422201156616,
0.2318301647901535,
-0.9241385459899902,
-0.02547493577003479,
-0.015225183218717575,
-0.18022477626800537,
-0.46631598472595215,
-0.5901799201965332,
0.23021942377090454,
-0.6215236783027649,
0.0881759375333786,
0.06634946912527084,
0.5301122665405273,
0.12062101811170578,
-0.5512847304344177,
-0.5750953555107117,
-0.5105010867118835,
0.6599546670913696,
-0.7857851982116699,
0.482393741607666,
0.6751377582550049,
0.36690568923950195,
-0.011163703165948391,
-0.48224154114723206,
-0.5904924273490906,
-0.493545800447464,
-0.15311208367347717,
-0.030695298686623573,
0.2578052580356598,
0.02874787710607052,
0.25229698419570923,
0.37063685059547424,
-0.4024500846862793,
0.06374042481184006,
-0.3050827980041504,
-0.5737999677658081,
0.4237777888774872,
0.06588761508464813,
0.31251728534698486,
-0.30873459577560425,
-0.147899329662323,
-0.07010450959205627,
-0.8656182289123535,
-0.2541617155075073,
0.2970062792301178,
0.19815225899219513,
0.3944365978240967,
0.8970450162887573,
-0.4846952557563782,
0.6555883884429932,
-0.09368155151605606,
-0.5533756613731384,
0.09293825179338455,
-0.3029610216617584,
-0.013934225775301456,
0.08716769516468048,
0.5489585399627686,
0.3682659864425659,
-0.009845188818871975,
-0.3936847150325775,
-0.10234248638153076,
-0.2203986644744873,
0.09854597598314285,
-0.9143136143684387,
-0.0303488839417696,
0.31105974316596985,
-0.40416333079338074,
-0.4871312975883484,
-0.37934374809265137,
-1.0567646026611328,
-0.5437544584274292,
-0.17159609496593475,
0.5135976076126099,
-0.47070732712745667,
-0.3219875991344452,
0.12363515049219131,
-0.3260420560836792,
0.3586142361164093,
0.2523565888404846,
-0.7906179428100586,
0.3803347647190094,
0.5771982669830322,
0.5071398615837097,
-0.2510307729244232,
-0.2203778624534607,
-0.8705511689186096,
0.3281500041484833,
-0.29726067185401917,
0.8539974093437195,
-0.6782991886138916,
-0.3372511863708496,
0.11297650635242462,
-0.16405723989009857,
0.21379198133945465,
-0.5116072297096252,
0.6689707636833191,
-0.8751592636108398,
0.41362136602401733,
-0.5281303524971008,
-0.7989931702613831,
-0.32545581459999084,
0.3275684714317322,
-0.7250680923461914,
1.0364723205566406,
-0.06017725542187691,
-0.7476166486740112,
0.4072955846786499,
-0.34229329228401184,
-0.44642889499664307,
0.07861901074647903,
-0.3653261363506317,
-0.2060474157333374,
0.058900557458400726,
0.43329188227653503,
0.6284787654876709,
-0.4498264789581299,
0.25175413489341736,
-0.38004812598228455,
-0.09321928769350052,
0.10958554595708847,
-0.03934188559651375,
0.41118812561035156,
0.11782217025756836,
-0.08113130927085876,
-0.07486625760793686,
-0.8746485710144043,
-0.0242520309984684,
0.3216327428817749,
-0.45095378160476685,
-0.5192356109619141,
0.0033657310996204615,
-0.3548090159893036,
0.1764298528432846,
0.2705269753932953,
-0.6236456632614136,
0.1582360714673996,
-0.279175728559494,
0.0017100900877267122,
0.6034252047538757,
0.23028597235679626,
0.252206414937973,
-0.5196776390075684,
0.6138609647750854,
-0.12052907794713974,
-0.2676289677619934,
-0.0311813335865736,
-0.39482924342155457,
-0.777330756187439,
-0.14801934361457825,
0.26927152276039124,
0.2661380469799042,
-1.0142303705215454,
0.2705509662628174,
-0.4616721570491791,
-0.29756632447242737,
-0.5761741995811462,
0.1499163657426834,
0.42826583981513977,
0.5617649555206299,
0.40710365772247314,
0.21106162667274475,
-0.5432343482971191,
-1.0521334409713745,
-0.31655675172805786,
-0.3387855887413025,
-0.1230580136179924,
0.5287560820579529,
0.4710754156112671,
0.18584083020687103,
0.6780602335929871,
-0.7741398215293884,
-0.011622927151620388,
-0.26646170020103455,
-0.03417127579450607,
-0.029984183609485626,
-0.15379299223423004,
0.23595362901687622,
-0.69081711769104,
-0.33377906680107117,
-0.11447501927614212,
-0.7199491858482361,
-0.15526257455348969,
0.07801269739866257,
-0.13234606385231018,
0.31620141863822937,
0.6024294495582581,
-0.7312936186790466,
0.14352287352085114,
0.053813014179468155,
-0.38539278507232666,
0.6077998280525208,
0.0812230184674263,
0.2357679307460785,
-1.2438019514083862,
0.16404680907726288,
-0.33568063378334045,
-0.2350669652223587,
-0.6648207902908325,
0.14870651066303253,
0.28595972061157227,
0.3244289755821228,
-0.2932271659374237,
0.5256772637367249,
-0.5174048542976379,
-0.11123295873403549,
-0.24761199951171875,
0.3468824028968811,
0.030207429081201553,
0.47708967328071594,
0.330444872379303,
0.6090747117996216,
0.41746261715888977,
-0.547687292098999,
0.29228928685188293,
0.40073326230049133,
-0.6999860405921936,
0.20196859538555145,
-0.25498679280281067,
0.33262449502944946,
-0.18027663230895996,
0.015467445366084576,
-0.8918998837471008,
-0.4088311195373535,
0.043656691908836365,
-0.4583226144313812,
0.2510240077972412,
-0.1938827931880951,
-0.5942785739898682,
-0.3171751797199249,
-0.25840696692466736,
0.23595954477787018,
0.4176999032497406,
-0.5357921123504639,
0.8297646045684814,
0.6457928419113159,
-0.4731259047985077,
-0.5738046765327454,
-0.37720537185668945,
0.010884015820920467,
-0.30347636342048645,
-0.5387877225875854,
0.14128094911575317,
-0.2253279834985733,
-0.2745668888092041,
-0.15014950931072235,
-0.3869110941886902,
0.09890751540660858,
0.07682069391012192,
-0.033884197473526,
0.3863779306411743,
-0.28060752153396606,
0.28514593839645386,
0.12370554357767105,
0.09988897293806076,
0.3095652163028717,
-0.09133446216583252,
0.6525214314460754,
0.15798969566822052,
-0.38288864493370056,
-0.04801732674241066,
0.5420466661453247,
0.7585139274597168,
0.03569697216153145,
0.6240144371986389,
0.27106261253356934,
-0.3096824884414673,
-0.12368788570165634,
-1.1744966506958008,
-0.40501275658607483,
-0.3435361087322235,
0.6017249226570129,
-0.47826042771339417,
-1.1207234859466553,
0.382183313369751,
-0.025279244408011436,
0.009921613149344921,
0.3270496428012848,
0.6622933149337769,
0.18057535588741302,
0.9556440711021423,
0.1810334175825119,
-0.24797052145004272,
0.025612587109208107,
0.11673340201377869,
0.1913023740053177,
-0.839827835559845,
-0.39782068133354187,
-0.6793689727783203,
0.21960660815238953,
-0.03432873636484146,
-0.39851438999176025,
0.3991997241973877,
0.007107999175786972,
0.046451933681964874,
-0.0025917200837284327,
-0.06881769001483917,
0.5719011425971985,
0.4813217520713806,
0.2517765462398529,
0.5524482727050781,
0.04040318727493286,
-0.42198848724365234,
0.21516834199428558,
-0.4939776062965393,
-0.5080862045288086,
1.4709380865097046,
0.11549703031778336,
0.42434582114219666,
0.29340270161628723,
0.5617801547050476,
-0.015025307424366474,
-0.025124667212367058,
-0.7863921523094177,
0.8576218485832214,
0.2075081616640091,
-0.5821586847305298,
-0.4549766480922699,
-0.5286681652069092,
-0.7026157975196838,
0.3759367763996124,
-0.3901689946651459,
-0.7580809593200684,
-0.3289875388145447,
-0.2851298749446869,
-0.5101597309112549,
0.31807777285575867,
-0.5118026733398438,
0.37102922797203064,
-0.20393706858158112,
-0.12363020330667496,
-0.27266985177993774,
-0.587515652179718,
0.538931667804718,
-0.29430556297302246,
0.12881438434123993,
-0.02141348086297512,
0.006982277613133192,
0.9311104416847229,
-0.18546870350837708,
0.5612991452217102,
-0.20629863440990448,
-0.3683731257915497,
0.09725603461265564,
0.24563832581043243,
0.7856716513633728,
0.06911122798919678,
-0.2814500629901886,
-0.09034107625484467,
0.2215479612350464,
-0.16210319101810455,
-0.6305698752403259,
0.6796486377716064,
-0.685555636882782,
-0.9448010325431824,
-0.21798834204673767,
-0.7490071058273315,
-0.5359438061714172,
0.47349271178245544,
0.026533568277955055,
0.38772839307785034,
-0.1356218159198761,
0.46223917603492737,
0.8603725433349609,
-0.13429467380046844,
0.2550705075263977,
0.7873431444168091,
-0.5301581621170044,
-0.6173791289329529,
0.646711528301239,
0.06411213427782059,
0.48445945978164673,
0.5739727020263672,
0.3513853847980499,
-0.5195155739784241,
-1.00113844871521,
-0.22508321702480316,
0.23979075253009796,
-0.872620165348053,
-0.3081475794315338,
-1.0848289728164673,
-0.40445300936698914,
-0.667768657207489,
0.23490270972251892,
0.028235282748937607,
-0.617556095123291,
-0.07349091023206711,
-0.35158631205558777,
0.3112286627292633,
0.6637102961540222,
0.1965654492378235,
-0.08026672154664993,
-0.75316321849823,
0.8417779803276062,
0.7304482460021973,
0.2840859591960907,
-0.06885162740945816,
-0.523588240146637,
-0.07719522714614868,
0.035558391362428665,
-0.04410508647561073,
-0.9662491679191589,
0.15812459588050842,
-0.04885891079902649,
0.8609099984169006,
0.2885536551475525,
0.19937756657600403,
0.40892040729522705,
-0.3148106038570404,
0.7522466778755188,
0.03259242698550224,
-0.5655456185340881,
0.6024739742279053,
-0.385746568441391,
0.16220560669898987,
0.6865907311439514,
0.5397440791130066,
-0.4740864038467407,
-0.4285524785518646,
-0.4890344440937042,
-0.7435863614082336,
0.7674230933189392,
0.31788119673728943,
-0.31875234842300415,
-0.057115472853183746,
0.3122572600841522,
0.41306042671203613,
0.2087172120809555,
-0.7206226587295532,
-0.006185194011777639,
0.247236430644989,
-0.32353028655052185,
0.2348540872335434,
-0.6435307264328003,
-0.3296228349208832,
-0.1714446097612381,
0.9891336560249329,
-0.2905965745449066,
0.07827161252498627,
0.1622961014509201,
-0.3299342393875122,
-0.23762986063957214,
0.23218369483947754,
0.42481404542922974,
0.7220361828804016,
-0.33419570326805115,
0.19007079303264618,
0.4342825412750244,
-0.6730489134788513,
-0.03186486288905144,
0.060810841619968414,
-0.3860122561454773,
-0.17620635032653809,
0.3711022138595581,
0.6471841335296631,
0.036435261368751526,
-0.8257720470428467,
0.6173173785209656,
-0.1457422524690628,
-0.5397006273269653,
-0.5068298578262329,
0.1441795825958252,
0.15637795627117157,
0.3009897768497467,
0.4412281811237335,
-0.4128183126449585,
0.11463015526533127,
-0.4697763919830322,
0.059432435780763626,
0.5991249084472656,
-0.07438773661851883,
0.12101881206035614,
0.28406062722206116,
0.012389766052365303,
-0.24838142096996307,
0.6412738561630249,
-0.04323267564177513,
-0.5649527907371521,
0.5226449370384216,
0.5546185970306396,
0.6626614928245544,
-0.03287910670042038,
0.15923462808132172,
0.34718257188796997,
0.09600762277841568,
-0.2137899547815323,
0.5298753380775452,
-0.03391940891742706,
-0.9476006627082825,
-0.49150124192237854,
-0.767707884311676,
-0.2579464614391327,
0.612608015537262,
-0.7471519708633423,
0.28243547677993774,
-0.08499568700790405,
0.3776957392692566,
0.05925710126757622,
0.15565413236618042,
-0.4906536042690277,
-0.010106099769473076,
0.2903483510017395,
0.8459137082099915,
-0.8180816173553467,
0.9192690253257751,
0.4074384868144989,
-0.352853000164032,
-0.7276586890220642,
0.17147859930992126,
0.017891043797135353,
-1.0153635740280151,
0.553712010383606,
0.006947867106646299,
-0.03314656391739845,
0.07603876292705536,
-0.6167076826095581,
-0.9531008005142212,
1.2342300415039062,
0.26384150981903076,
-0.26873108744621277,
-0.1584712117910385,
0.270613431930542,
0.19783076643943787,
-0.4504314661026001,
0.30892619490623474,
0.7492532134056091,
0.46936100721359253,
0.6603628396987915,
-0.5805466771125793,
0.30576667189598083,
-0.2673637866973877,
-0.20261788368225098,
0.20615516602993011,
-0.5028871297836304,
0.25284919142723083,
-0.19417349994182587,
-0.05550813302397728,
0.2602158784866333,
0.6198025345802307,
0.7751270532608032,
0.21047484874725342,
0.8254333138465881,
0.5883378982543945,
1.0723897218704224,
0.19763588905334473,
0.6586100459098816,
-0.3455718457698822,
-0.024500155821442604,
1.2556567192077637,
-0.45816418528556824,
0.8663185834884644,
0.7098163962364197,
-0.19861657917499542,
0.36059293150901794,
0.544202446937561,
0.025477299466729164,
0.6572819352149963,
0.32082700729370117,
-0.45078331232070923,
-0.5990138649940491,
-0.072020024061203,
-0.39296674728393555,
0.45754313468933105,
0.36659687757492065,
-0.2723705768585205,
-0.1473037600517273,
-0.14309567213058472,
0.18196044862270355,
-0.1731472611427307,
-0.1433718502521515,
1.1843639612197876,
-0.051405616104602814,
-1.0883100032806396,
0.43053555488586426,
-0.372494101524353,
0.2687225937843323,
-0.674125611782074,
-0.2673647403717041,
-0.27285417914390564,
-0.2598446011543274,
0.027522210031747818,
-0.8227931261062622,
0.02870096266269684,
0.030663928017020226,
-0.23657862842082977,
-0.10151571035385132,
0.9247502088546753,
-0.4931275248527527,
-0.6442064046859741,
0.20082303881645203,
0.5616915822029114,
0.3008466362953186,
-0.24747179448604584,
-0.06192338466644287,
-0.24934282898902893,
0.10075526684522629,
-0.16436783969402313,
0.4344481825828552,
0.5312815308570862,
0.14663557708263397,
0.7443686723709106,
0.8276663422584534,
0.2731155455112457,
-0.039753351360559464,
0.08205653727054596,
1.1111078262329102,
-0.71124666929245,
-0.4481295347213745,
-0.7473366260528564,
0.29448917508125305,
-0.4386131167411804,
0.09881386160850525,
0.8029652237892151,
0.7236610054969788,
0.5256360173225403,
0.05373144522309303,
1.0380430221557617,
-0.006026789080351591,
0.9092782735824585,
-0.9467080235481262,
0.7422640323638916,
-0.42346274852752686,
0.4742916524410248,
-0.2605763375759125,
-0.7550777792930603,
-0.1971098780632019,
0.297252357006073,
-0.403755784034729,
-0.10391616821289062,
1.004724144935608,
1.031948208808899,
0.0918087288737297,
0.41499513387680054,
0.31651201844215393,
0.5023082494735718,
0.1328606754541397,
0.6351017951965332,
1.0111258029937744,
-0.18446676433086395,
0.8000100255012512,
-0.15499170124530792,
-0.029450541362166405,
-0.2897162139415741,
-0.8980739712715149,
-1.1234042644500732,
-0.7758211493492126,
-0.13490299880504608,
-0.4757530987262726,
-0.08227769285440445,
0.8859105706214905,
0.5523743033409119,
-0.7571768760681152,
0.07752154022455215,
0.03244363144040108,
0.32534801959991455,
0.12998580932617188,
-0.11590152978897095,
0.522738516330719,
-0.3415740132331848,
-0.22743093967437744,
0.7096307873725891,
0.005304981488734484,
-0.15165507793426514,
-0.12799467146396637,
-0.02499593049287796,
-0.4743426740169525,
-0.021222800016403198,
0.6081168055534363,
-0.043733421713113785,
-0.814893901348114,
-0.4248430132865906,
0.14569783210754395,
0.12166930735111237,
-0.10978218913078308,
0.8265748620033264,
-0.7690240740776062,
0.4063590168952942,
0.6150680184364319,
0.8503971695899963,
0.8015803694725037,
-0.28959837555885315,
0.579528272151947,
-0.5027870535850525,
-0.18335843086242676,
0.37223294377326965,
0.408663272857666,
0.183567613363266,
-0.5118538737297058,
0.48426446318626404,
0.1112980768084526,
-0.5468226671218872,
-0.8852674961090088,
0.16330748796463013,
-0.8647391200065613,
-0.5507973432540894,
1.6506534814834595,
0.09118372201919556,
-0.17232520878314972,
-0.37509119510650635,
-0.24033550918102264,
0.147433802485466,
-0.1282871514558792,
1.0442944765090942,
1.0931684970855713,
0.1725391149520874,
-0.2870064675807953,
-0.6857197880744934,
0.5308159589767456,
0.39419835805892944,
-0.7925364971160889,
0.2205585092306137,
0.6853160262107849,
0.41580304503440857,
0.1055898442864418,
0.5796251893043518,
-0.22849972546100616,
0.12916059792041779,
-0.2276858538389206,
0.12160501629114151,
0.0004282479640096426,
-0.29864394664764404,
-0.19159691035747528,
0.48396939039230347,
0.2165631353855133,
0.1380613148212433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15653v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15653v1
|
CatLIP: CLIP-level Visual Recognition Accuracy with 2.7x Faster Pre-training on Web-scale Image-Text Data
| 2024-04-24T05:13:28 | 2024-04-24T05:13:28 |
Sachin Mehta, Maxwell Horton, Fartash Faghri, Mohammad Hossein Sekhavat, Mahyar Najibi, Mehrdad Farajtabar, Oncel Tuzel, Mohammad Rastegari
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Contrastive learning has emerged as a transformative method for learning
effective visual representations through the alignment of image and text
embeddings. However, pairwise similarity computation in contrastive loss
between image and text pairs poses computational challenges. This paper
presents a novel weakly supervised pre-training of vision models on web-scale
image-text data. The proposed method reframes pre-training on image-text data
as a classification task. Consequently, it eliminates the need for pairwise
similarity computations in contrastive loss, achieving a remarkable $2.7\times$
acceleration in training speed compared to contrastive learning on web-scale
data. Through extensive experiments spanning diverse vision tasks, including
detection and segmentation, we demonstrate that the proposed method maintains
high representation quality. Our source code along with pre-trained model
weights and training recipes is available at
\url{https://github.com/apple/corenet}.
|
[
-0.4320293664932251,
-0.1566888988018036,
0.22952279448509216,
0.09928853809833527,
-0.6410077810287476,
-0.07796930521726608,
-0.15687346458435059,
-0.6443196535110474,
0.31066253781318665,
0.4886760711669922,
-0.2413829118013382,
-0.41466987133026123,
-0.5519346594810486,
-0.007097308058291674,
-0.5241294503211975,
0.7198753356933594,
-0.08544515818357468,
0.12137971073389053,
-0.4005303382873535,
-0.23776556551456451,
0.031862106174230576,
-0.4165172874927521,
-0.43866467475891113,
0.07974059134721756,
0.31751132011413574,
0.508179247379303,
0.5974324941635132,
0.5762574076652527,
1.0812779664993286,
0.26499828696250916,
-0.01970900408923626,
0.03066016361117363,
-0.6820871233940125,
-0.3116610646247864,
-0.2525515854358673,
-0.5352875590324402,
-0.16982777416706085,
0.1066078394651413,
0.273967981338501,
0.7444080710411072,
0.08724955469369888,
0.13818223774433136,
0.427642822265625,
0.7359533309936523,
-0.7563126087188721,
-0.04488011449575424,
-0.8530594706535339,
0.2748295068740845,
-0.30476340651512146,
0.029208485037088394,
-0.25679582357406616,
-0.094940684735775,
0.3025696873664856,
-0.9906049370765686,
0.7695295810699463,
0.17696255445480347,
1.2891337871551514,
0.34026703238487244,
-0.0924404039978981,
-0.06665170937776566,
0.055804844945669174,
0.7711039185523987,
-0.24816343188285828,
0.5119063854217529,
0.3641604483127594,
0.2426386922597885,
0.21117424964904785,
-1.003108263015747,
-0.5609433650970459,
0.18139468133449554,
0.019170017912983894,
0.2367977499961853,
-0.002220726106315851,
-0.05575906112790108,
0.023929068818688393,
0.6106972694396973,
-0.38292014598846436,
0.0905851423740387,
-0.37851113080978394,
-0.14784103631973267,
0.23379674553871155,
0.053105149418115616,
0.07463405281305313,
-0.06213712692260742,
-0.5812422037124634,
-0.3195752203464508,
-0.3659135401248932,
0.3172915279865265,
-0.07924924045801163,
0.25005602836608887,
-0.45476672053337097,
0.16348129510879517,
-0.00032647198531776667,
0.26332932710647583,
0.4404674470424652,
-0.19238030910491943,
0.48075512051582336,
-0.34627676010131836,
0.010583599098026752,
-0.12364383041858673,
0.8025346398353577,
0.8240318298339844,
0.2001187652349472,
-0.032305583357810974,
0.0029400414787232876,
0.147980734705925,
0.26152318716049194,
-1.0971792936325073,
-0.8096177577972412,
-0.4452812969684601,
-0.6038220524787903,
-0.4060898423194885,
0.18166881799697876,
-0.5957766175270081,
-0.2780328094959259,
-0.17695607244968414,
0.506392240524292,
-0.27709147334098816,
0.07775904983282089,
0.046739205718040466,
-0.19006823003292084,
0.15700198709964752,
0.4851223826408386,
-0.7088567614555359,
0.640986442565918,
0.27868956327438354,
0.932194173336029,
-0.36781221628189087,
-0.17711453139781952,
-0.45478105545043945,
0.029130268841981888,
-0.5228561162948608,
0.7109404802322388,
-0.34643569588661194,
-0.3930503726005554,
-0.12666697800159454,
0.14327284693717957,
0.4553999602794647,
-0.707931637763977,
0.5400028228759766,
-0.20658110082149506,
-0.22898004949092865,
-0.12292841076850891,
-0.2676965296268463,
-0.02508590742945671,
0.40154749155044556,
-0.6594451665878296,
0.8100302815437317,
-0.36919745802879333,
-1.3091318607330322,
0.48694512248039246,
-0.09500288218259811,
-0.5684952735900879,
-0.019976720213890076,
-0.13331711292266846,
-0.9155174493789673,
0.03972262516617775,
0.5904393792152405,
0.7146666049957275,
-0.1371268630027771,
-0.2677912414073944,
-0.6837047934532166,
-0.6099492311477661,
0.05873105302453041,
-0.026274889707565308,
0.5711721777915955,
-0.34524092078208923,
-0.24774561822414398,
-0.05866657942533493,
-0.7974488139152527,
-0.022007714956998825,
0.19843091070652008,
-0.008440913632512093,
-0.6238672137260437,
-0.1414564698934555,
0.09025710821151733,
0.028583139181137085,
0.5342210531234741,
-0.4933061897754669,
0.10183145850896835,
-0.3986378610134125,
0.26392754912376404,
0.5902888178825378,
-0.2634660005569458,
0.5818520188331604,
-0.10696756094694138,
0.18590836226940155,
0.2303030639886856,
0.2744750380516052,
-0.3752247989177704,
-0.25477883219718933,
-0.9749641418457031,
-0.39109551906585693,
0.1740730106830597,
0.4962994456291199,
-0.979608416557312,
0.11180459707975388,
-0.3582654893398285,
-0.4869483709335327,
-0.07431819289922714,
0.2929304540157318,
0.6943985223770142,
0.8115873336791992,
0.7237454056739807,
-0.6111332774162292,
-0.6666055917739868,
-1.0933319330215454,
0.21610429883003235,
0.1125686839222908,
-0.2738117277622223,
0.354134202003479,
0.43297165632247925,
-0.22632956504821777,
0.6474282741546631,
-0.6242370009422302,
-0.5946008563041687,
-0.04171440005302429,
0.3737710416316986,
0.2734852135181427,
0.7855312824249268,
0.4695805609226227,
-1.0207751989364624,
-0.4942120611667633,
-0.08006789535284042,
-0.5558381080627441,
-0.05179043859243393,
0.23088179528713226,
-0.0006406158208847046,
-0.4168393313884735,
0.6846592426300049,
0.10359363257884979,
0.592691957950592,
0.48837900161743164,
0.2161671370267868,
0.4638187289237976,
-0.21146267652511597,
0.27982890605926514,
-1.072042465209961,
0.029175713658332825,
0.2652713656425476,
-0.428195059299469,
-0.31104031205177307,
-0.07902324199676514,
0.3465126156806946,
-0.34374284744262695,
-0.5975947976112366,
0.21040311455726624,
-0.5731549263000488,
-0.28247642517089844,
-0.15384873747825623,
0.08444394171237946,
0.2450537234544754,
0.5481008887290955,
0.39927202463150024,
0.9805009365081787,
0.7016825675964355,
-0.7689594030380249,
-0.12657217681407928,
0.3697628080844879,
-0.22321906685829163,
0.6999677419662476,
-0.7596532702445984,
0.11534065753221512,
0.19768637418746948,
0.2294604629278183,
-0.8344216346740723,
-0.1682475060224533,
-0.002103675389662385,
-0.28932255506515503,
0.08793921768665314,
0.06758490949869156,
-0.17004822194576263,
-0.34341299533843994,
-0.8982371091842651,
0.8436551690101624,
0.5312197804450989,
-0.9173574447631836,
0.1863921880722046,
0.35979846119880676,
0.06696590781211853,
-0.5137650966644287,
-0.9830853343009949,
-0.15661394596099854,
0.11015938222408295,
-0.11990753561258316,
0.8928959369659424,
0.29175159335136414,
0.21385319530963898,
0.030765369534492493,
-0.028152842074632645,
-0.5237311124801636,
-0.08732257038354874,
0.5863707661628723,
0.26858949661254883,
-0.06224982813000679,
0.08710411190986633,
-0.06393055617809296,
-0.022031506523489952,
-0.22481852769851685,
0.021713361144065857,
0.17497685551643372,
-0.20518186688423157,
-0.006281459238380194,
-0.7251038551330566,
0.10040682554244995,
0.11751366406679153,
-0.2693568766117096,
0.2772679626941681,
0.753075897693634,
-0.29440009593963623,
-0.15943700075149536,
-0.28241032361984253,
-0.16387248039245605,
-0.48897281289100647,
0.272830992937088,
-0.45447149872779846,
-0.7256297469139099,
0.41912680864334106,
-0.19318942725658417,
-0.3281494081020355,
0.296958327293396,
-0.017793908715248108,
-0.44496986269950867,
0.5979885458946228,
0.9026960730552673,
0.16142752766609192,
0.6992250084877014,
-0.32286956906318665,
-0.13391950726509094,
-0.8248053789138794,
-0.3340901732444763,
-0.30168992280960083,
-0.4239690601825714,
-0.42219847440719604,
-0.7180953025817871,
0.38705354928970337,
0.42365118861198425,
-0.13976477086544037,
0.25742989778518677,
-0.6176453232765198,
0.6892991065979004,
0.5477887988090515,
0.7428638339042664,
0.1085638776421547,
-0.12901386618614197,
-0.2584401071071625,
-0.3799584209918976,
-0.5826205015182495,
-0.13685694336891174,
1.135063886642456,
0.024929607287049294,
1.0430238246917725,
-0.2605518102645874,
0.7288902997970581,
0.25817060470581055,
0.19879287481307983,
-0.720172107219696,
0.5981304049491882,
-0.6287727952003479,
-0.02387283928692341,
-0.02604944072663784,
-0.3727498948574066,
-0.6931282877922058,
0.037068117409944534,
-0.7267861366271973,
-0.4110865890979767,
0.30923476815223694,
0.6245399713516235,
0.03381713479757309,
0.42237478494644165,
-0.5901890993118286,
0.8826615214347839,
-0.17644841969013214,
-0.6515966653823853,
-0.11783263832330704,
-0.8809184432029724,
0.35191380977630615,
0.10009115189313889,
-0.09864331781864166,
0.11149553954601288,
-0.3487919569015503,
0.8128054738044739,
-0.7100619673728943,
0.885905385017395,
0.04613525792956352,
0.415908545255661,
0.11676280200481415,
-0.0343342125415802,
0.2457437515258789,
-0.06895705312490463,
0.423854798078537,
0.39531275629997253,
-0.21194671094417572,
-0.6416395306587219,
-0.5466545224189758,
0.40031489729881287,
-0.5222499370574951,
-0.3957549035549164,
-0.2681976556777954,
0.1372121423482895,
-0.13287417590618134,
0.08978941291570663,
0.46213391423225403,
0.6501415371894836,
-0.20389501750469208,
0.28831642866134644,
0.6429246664047241,
0.015201869420707226,
0.40375038981437683,
0.04849271848797798,
-0.34675830602645874,
-0.716495931148529,
0.9941251873970032,
-0.2065715491771698,
0.0014977395767346025,
0.7007821798324585,
0.05426418036222458,
-0.23874932527542114,
-0.7065563797950745,
-0.22134363651275635,
0.1341181844472885,
-0.6230628490447998,
-0.41482654213905334,
-0.18984049558639526,
0.10572299361228943,
-0.12704971432685852,
-0.7412557601928711,
-0.563697338104248,
-0.28641289472579956,
-0.6611945629119873,
0.1579636186361313,
0.020905086770653725,
0.5070192217826843,
-0.027976656332612038,
0.3764069676399231,
-0.6116434931755066,
0.39213132858276367,
0.6083495616912842,
0.3303055763244629,
-0.09232605248689651,
-0.40111154317855835,
-0.3369646370410919,
-0.42523545026779175,
-0.24981212615966797,
-0.6156572699546814,
0.12384797632694244,
0.5294212102890015,
0.10023658722639084,
0.8037320971488953,
0.11959481984376907,
0.9507074952125549,
-0.5760694742202759,
0.7341851592063904,
0.957212507724762,
-1.245917558670044,
0.5215063691139221,
0.05803358927369118,
0.46784159541130066,
0.9752951860427856,
0.6741337180137634,
0.02680584229528904,
0.07464354485273361,
-0.30007943511009216,
-0.7819162011146545,
0.4384496212005615,
0.005200068932026625,
-0.11095646023750305,
0.25647836923599243,
0.26963621377944946,
0.23960043489933014,
0.053261809051036835,
-0.7299292087554932,
0.1410161554813385,
-0.7670289278030396,
-0.33796945214271545,
-0.15713444352149963,
-0.17599523067474365,
0.3853977620601654,
-0.43432536721229553,
0.37157368659973145,
-0.33427366614341736,
-0.056171316653490067,
0.48269569873809814,
-0.390968382358551,
0.46373939514160156,
-0.1070750504732132,
0.22454304993152618,
0.3388000428676605,
-0.1224711611866951,
0.628619372844696,
0.290027379989624,
-0.800186276435852,
0.09568888694047928,
0.021700285375118256,
0.04702581465244293,
-0.1548258364200592,
0.5515714883804321,
0.5364702343940735,
0.7193042635917664,
-0.7875794172286987,
1.1279518604278564,
-0.20999568700790405,
-0.2643715739250183,
-0.06152528524398804,
-0.2867027819156647,
-0.3907049000263214,
-0.048806872218847275,
0.39686673879623413,
0.18232405185699463,
0.45073840022087097,
-0.3326951861381531,
0.3411885201931,
0.25490763783454895,
-0.6187954545021057,
-0.37426698207855225,
0.6259816884994507,
0.5911279320716858,
0.04663804545998573,
0.3653630018234253,
-0.28478121757507324,
-0.9055821299552917,
0.4499271512031555,
0.4710150957107544,
0.5065987706184387,
-0.10545369982719421,
0.13363294303417206,
0.5665022730827332,
-0.0757315456867218,
-0.05729270353913307,
0.05717545375227928,
-0.4634632468223572,
-0.7641116976737976,
0.002693524584174156,
-0.4262164831161499,
-0.7487411499023438,
-0.06906742602586746,
-0.647807776927948,
0.31097498536109924,
-0.8926575183868408,
-0.15332230925559998,
0.0394565612077713,
-0.22658467292785645,
-0.6227255463600159,
0.4312448799610138,
0.0593210868537426,
0.5682483911514282,
-0.6471088528633118,
0.5537611246109009,
0.675508975982666,
-0.3944706618785858,
-0.7281270623207092,
0.09733901172876358,
-0.27409207820892334,
-0.47320112586021423,
0.8664785027503967,
0.682041585445404,
-0.5652568340301514,
-0.3461405038833618,
-0.7047624588012695,
-0.4087965190410614,
0.8503816723823547,
0.22349263727664948,
-0.7702122926712036,
0.18749648332595825,
-0.12582214176654816,
0.37941601872444153,
-0.30369332432746887,
0.32306841015815735,
-0.14533376693725586,
-0.19306182861328125,
0.053409334272146225,
-0.9583731889724731,
-0.05539137125015259,
-0.29662415385246277,
0.21726682782173157,
0.18908870220184326,
-0.527594268321991,
1.0167018175125122,
-0.15543656051158905,
-0.20331819355487823,
0.07505790889263153,
0.7349717617034912,
-0.17940478026866913,
0.37709054350852966,
0.6619271039962769,
0.799315869808197,
0.6097394824028015,
0.06242016702890396,
0.6871164441108704,
-0.16442492604255676,
0.33953243494033813,
1.191219687461853,
-0.10526587814092636,
1.1424006223678589,
0.392136812210083,
-0.24162384867668152,
0.4988332986831665,
0.5174641013145447,
-0.08242256939411163,
0.6601312756538391,
-0.039766471832990646,
0.03398401290178299,
-0.5352498292922974,
-0.24390213191509247,
-0.2925167977809906,
0.28806713223457336,
0.04495973885059357,
-0.4014011025428772,
0.06051572784781456,
0.24843406677246094,
-0.25745904445648193,
0.5054841041564941,
-0.7970834374427795,
0.4916563332080841,
0.0560283437371254,
-0.04437628760933876,
0.6976860761642456,
-0.3288949131965637,
1.2423168420791626,
-0.27978795766830444,
-0.21561028063297272,
0.028603658080101013,
0.2931601107120514,
-0.31220999360084534,
-0.8060811758041382,
0.02700778841972351,
0.0028398341964930296,
-0.2694500982761383,
0.09103474020957947,
0.7509223222732544,
-0.14801643788814545,
-0.526143491268158,
0.16835534572601318,
-0.046357203274965286,
0.1471349000930786,
0.0563725046813488,
-0.7147720456123352,
0.10006709396839142,
-0.09550034999847412,
0.3104977309703827,
-0.013367154635488987,
0.1928039789199829,
-0.03398173302412033,
0.593542754650116,
0.5660184621810913,
-0.2771689295768738,
0.045304249972105026,
-0.030377628281712532,
1.0605448484420776,
-0.5884193181991577,
-0.7341613173484802,
-0.5125999450683594,
0.04136980324983597,
-0.4535083770751953,
-0.3213055431842804,
0.6371219754219055,
0.8290864825248718,
0.9746072292327881,
-0.2697008550167084,
0.2256782352924347,
0.2931680977344513,
0.6188554763793945,
-0.6718971729278564,
0.3623490631580353,
-0.7314879894256592,
-0.2344183772802353,
-0.5046571493148804,
-0.6789170503616333,
-0.5473875999450684,
0.5063962936401367,
-0.40905046463012695,
-0.24950213730335236,
0.8105968236923218,
0.6695539951324463,
-0.46868622303009033,
-0.2243107259273529,
0.2501044273376465,
0.010314264334738255,
-0.07809966057538986,
0.6478896141052246,
0.5275086760520935,
-0.521255612373352,
0.8418667316436768,
-0.5672011375427246,
-0.21589846909046173,
-0.3277967870235443,
-0.7244290709495544,
-1.26389741897583,
-0.5707247853279114,
-0.23388798534870148,
0.12791478633880615,
0.07907487452030182,
0.6446943879127502,
1.1756449937820435,
-0.58614182472229,
0.14875712990760803,
-0.31448063254356384,
-0.13414102792739868,
-0.0755888819694519,
-0.14600040018558502,
0.5065059661865234,
-0.13714857399463654,
-0.5249946117401123,
-0.08606041222810745,
0.3072277903556824,
0.32892686128616333,
0.04200877249240875,
-0.05534440279006958,
-0.04095981642603874,
-0.21416252851486206,
0.3545873463153839,
0.42704588174819946,
-0.5073093175888062,
-0.11063545942306519,
-0.37895503640174866,
-0.10503054410219193,
0.5849076509475708,
0.8490403890609741,
-0.8628100156784058,
0.4728109538555145,
0.44586145877838135,
0.8314138650894165,
0.9799313545227051,
0.2998127341270447,
-0.040384482592344284,
-0.652482807636261,
0.6718646883964539,
0.1739356517791748,
0.37973642349243164,
0.7262538075447083,
-0.004041983745992184,
0.35650554299354553,
0.26476147770881653,
-0.2844753861427307,
-0.521287202835083,
0.3035047948360443,
-1.422439694404602,
-0.22392338514328003,
0.29463526606559753,
-0.5239075422286987,
-0.5878958702087402,
0.21758486330509186,
-0.39251330494880676,
-0.03188734129071236,
-0.4250102639198303,
0.48186132311820984,
0.017613481730222702,
-0.11591778695583344,
-0.503050684928894,
0.462973415851593,
0.5769108533859253,
0.3470816910266876,
-0.8567565679550171,
-0.4793521761894226,
0.2452312409877777,
0.13806785643100739,
0.2854025065898895,
0.4109015464782715,
0.06940405815839767,
0.36084359884262085,
0.40281257033348083,
0.30760446190834045,
-0.11222536116838455,
-0.37505340576171875,
-0.20762676000595093,
0.4193485379219055,
-0.08006288856267929,
-0.5883954167366028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15650v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15650v2
|
Return of EM: Entity-driven Answer Set Expansion for QA Evaluation
| 2024-04-24T05:08:55 | 2024-06-11T09:14:02 |
Dongryeol Lee, Minwoo Lee, Kyungmin Min, Joonsuk Park, Kyomin Jung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, directly using large language models (LLMs) has been shown to be
the most reliable method to evaluate QA models. However, it suffers from
limited interpretability, high cost, and environmental harm. To address these,
we propose to use soft EM with entity-driven answer set expansion. Our approach
expands the gold answer set to include diverse surface forms, based on the
observation that the surface forms often follow particular patterns depending
on the entity type. The experimental results show that our method outperforms
traditional evaluation methods by a large margin. Moreover, the reliability of
our evaluation method is comparable to that of LLM-based ones, while offering
the benefits of high interpretability and reduced environmental harm.
|
[
-0.2493884116411209,
-1.015353798866272,
0.9569743871688843,
0.24896369874477386,
0.008600439876317978,
0.08923663944005966,
-0.3714721202850342,
-0.2594749331474304,
0.03681900352239609,
0.7805563807487488,
-0.7081180810928345,
-0.5661038160324097,
-0.4887543320655823,
0.27780047059059143,
-0.33213964104652405,
1.0359950065612793,
-0.22825618088245392,
-0.29727280139923096,
-0.35691964626312256,
-0.23741823434829712,
-0.2941214144229889,
-0.3821868300437927,
-0.515804648399353,
-0.04331919923424721,
0.6971614360809326,
0.37873247265815735,
0.8009653687477112,
0.4377959966659546,
0.7736622095108032,
0.3705696165561676,
-0.03651119023561478,
0.31528741121292114,
-0.48471590876579285,
0.060449570417404175,
-0.14727367460727692,
-0.39745667576789856,
-0.6023150086402893,
-0.05971283093094826,
0.5226415991783142,
0.8013908267021179,
-0.31032097339630127,
0.4510883390903473,
-0.01664864644408226,
0.7377025485038757,
-0.7210005521774292,
0.24151292443275452,
-0.3748677968978882,
-0.12168853729963303,
0.2671271562576294,
-0.31369659304618835,
-0.6429474949836731,
-0.3817203640937805,
0.22976213693618774,
-0.6602344512939453,
-0.18449071049690247,
-0.21720030903816223,
0.7086098790168762,
0.24490784108638763,
-0.6592614054679871,
-0.36200758814811707,
-1.1737059354782104,
1.069216251373291,
-0.7080029845237732,
0.5898863673210144,
-0.09038228541612625,
0.258006751537323,
-0.3132370710372925,
-0.915786862373352,
-0.48670312762260437,
-0.4342930018901825,
0.2297171801328659,
0.35230669379234314,
0.03773471713066101,
0.13838611543178558,
0.2876877188682556,
0.45754319429397583,
-0.3491375148296356,
-0.09799661487340927,
-0.216598242521286,
0.26909083127975464,
0.9771550893783569,
0.19957737624645233,
0.7381370663642883,
0.09751303493976593,
-0.3599676787853241,
0.02046089805662632,
-0.8044665455818176,
-0.07607490569353104,
0.14740103483200073,
0.4194525182247162,
0.2987964153289795,
0.7896609902381897,
-0.13652798533439636,
0.6333962082862854,
0.02081838808953762,
-0.20512078702449799,
0.2361924648284912,
-0.22915470600128174,
-0.16243663430213928,
-0.15564404428005219,
0.3120463192462921,
0.47166118025779724,
0.012912482023239136,
-0.4586947560310364,
-0.3990383744239807,
-0.3017592132091522,
0.14199911057949066,
-0.8892968893051147,
0.2059554159641266,
0.4872765839099884,
-0.7284979820251465,
-0.04690465331077576,
0.2411593198776245,
-0.8867959976196289,
-0.1491059511899948,
-0.4077896773815155,
0.41753992438316345,
-0.12270957976579666,
-0.7045658230781555,
0.2633734345436096,
0.01023900043219328,
0.25322166085243225,
0.4004051685333252,
-0.3848054111003876,
0.8316909074783325,
0.7680039405822754,
0.5337111949920654,
-0.10499560832977295,
0.14323069155216217,
-0.9240482449531555,
0.030294101685285568,
-0.3871482312679291,
0.8793059587478638,
-0.7610492706298828,
-0.5558573603630066,
0.06617061048746109,
0.1645764261484146,
0.1048499122262001,
-0.7659765481948853,
0.42912542819976807,
-0.8016473054885864,
0.3231603503227234,
-0.3160165548324585,
-0.3932187855243683,
-0.33214902877807617,
0.09408824890851974,
-0.914296567440033,
0.9194322228431702,
0.5416286587715149,
-0.3600136935710907,
0.29274827241897583,
-0.8232227563858032,
-0.12543216347694397,
0.057825684547424316,
-0.02477218583226204,
-0.5671839714050293,
0.24358263611793518,
0.16301707923412323,
-0.00781259499490261,
-0.19476287066936493,
0.044796790927648544,
-0.7179205417633057,
-0.5690025091171265,
0.31759417057037354,
-0.45955565571784973,
0.778115451335907,
0.24750079214572906,
-0.5080919861793518,
-0.03182985261082649,
-0.8609551787376404,
0.4554320275783539,
0.010109960101544857,
-0.5788986682891846,
-0.4894348382949829,
-0.06620408594608307,
0.06863974034786224,
0.3567810654640198,
0.18424628674983978,
-0.7103006839752197,
0.03953840583562851,
-0.48614704608917236,
0.053196340799331665,
0.7519928812980652,
0.4575914740562439,
0.3699057996273041,
-0.2558707594871521,
0.8778036832809448,
0.053381435573101044,
-0.07289204746484756,
0.013131508603692055,
-0.48313000798225403,
-0.5605950951576233,
-0.41673076152801514,
0.4368440508842468,
0.6038343906402588,
-0.5983465909957886,
0.5109074115753174,
-0.43907493352890015,
-0.5882063508033752,
-0.4702388346195221,
0.2798299789428711,
0.44523537158966064,
0.25005626678466797,
0.27196836471557617,
-0.1122649684548378,
-0.3988960087299347,
-0.8767120838165283,
-0.39212435483932495,
-0.17403967678546906,
-0.24246686697006226,
0.6411299705505371,
0.34319183230400085,
-0.2582395076751709,
1.0116159915924072,
-0.4317529499530792,
0.12816044688224792,
-0.17509111762046814,
-0.3472677171230316,
0.3294326663017273,
0.38546550273895264,
0.34669843316078186,
-0.87269127368927,
-0.3364366888999939,
-0.13833612203598022,
-0.5993475317955017,
-0.09837780147790909,
-0.14983510971069336,
-0.22509309649467468,
0.029429391026496887,
0.07589956372976303,
-0.6712256073951721,
0.3328665792942047,
0.4784649610519409,
-0.5161909461021423,
0.19282850623130798,
0.028643451631069183,
0.5188080072402954,
-0.8767377734184265,
0.01744832471013069,
0.2080531120300293,
-0.08108973503112793,
-0.28711503744125366,
0.289829820394516,
-0.04326557368040085,
-0.29926955699920654,
-0.45891112089157104,
0.7752622961997986,
-0.6141765713691711,
-0.47512468695640564,
-0.2909470498561859,
0.3044567406177521,
0.275337278842926,
0.16398081183433533,
-0.1298876702785492,
0.7957882881164551,
0.21421778202056885,
-0.8131041526794434,
0.4247875511646271,
0.4109097123146057,
-0.07227809727191925,
0.4731961488723755,
-0.7530742287635803,
0.4173309803009033,
-0.3134413957595825,
0.2085898220539093,
-0.9702479839324951,
0.19221508502960205,
-0.1412217766046524,
-0.20986159145832062,
0.1580425351858139,
-0.12992145121097565,
-0.5680858492851257,
-0.4883926510810852,
-0.3815009295940399,
0.11059912294149399,
0.6692137122154236,
-0.8142299652099609,
0.9257706999778748,
0.13677839934825897,
-0.47711315751075745,
-0.39947324991226196,
-0.5544344782829285,
-0.1486937254667282,
-0.411731481552124,
-0.8228904604911804,
0.22276461124420166,
-0.3265039622783661,
-0.7855307459831238,
0.18214723467826843,
-0.2403397113084793,
-0.15445300936698914,
0.33107656240463257,
0.3516148626804352,
0.2381363809108734,
-0.6447449922561646,
0.22680948674678802,
0.10862834751605988,
0.1541055589914322,
0.12806212902069092,
0.014242754317820072,
0.3767740726470947,
-0.4644581377506256,
-0.46852633357048035,
-0.07180459797382355,
0.5134561061859131,
0.4554147720336914,
-0.5240734815597534,
0.5942625403404236,
0.22603937983512878,
-0.7193754315376282,
-0.13606123626232147,
-0.39437445998191833,
-0.25743088126182556,
-0.5132686495780945,
0.7605009078979492,
-0.5354430079460144,
-0.5432398915290833,
0.6016923785209656,
-0.11824342608451843,
0.3902641832828522,
0.743923544883728,
0.5611425042152405,
0.058571990579366684,
1.2363046407699585,
0.7713239789009094,
0.47347548604011536,
0.225168839097023,
-0.16216738522052765,
0.311237633228302,
-0.96241295337677,
-0.26006007194519043,
-0.3515133857727051,
-0.060156676918268204,
-0.737119734287262,
-0.01453387551009655,
0.27159547805786133,
0.0893927738070488,
0.09593468904495239,
0.1108318418264389,
-0.31003424525260925,
0.18193145096302032,
0.22270603477954865,
0.5112431645393372,
0.5672118067741394,
-0.001434020814485848,
0.5316786170005798,
-0.01458961796015501,
-0.5200740694999695,
-0.9830814003944397,
1.4211597442626953,
0.6495010852813721,
0.6635333895683289,
0.42916154861450195,
0.8882671594619751,
0.2222062051296234,
1.063075304031372,
-0.6218630075454712,
0.5988107919692993,
-0.07148118317127228,
-0.5498173236846924,
-0.503858745098114,
-0.41057491302490234,
-1.1638898849487305,
0.3065301775932312,
-0.020703041926026344,
-0.530900239944458,
-0.0063583520241081715,
-0.22980277240276337,
-0.6667588353157043,
0.20354394614696503,
-0.7712627649307251,
0.5486211180686951,
-0.29738232493400574,
-0.3887687921524048,
-0.1365906447172165,
-0.07439820468425751,
0.4314100444316864,
-0.09854556620121002,
0.1582929939031601,
-0.046227578073740005,
-0.4919644594192505,
1.0235146284103394,
-0.346824586391449,
0.43528786301612854,
-0.20532673597335815,
-0.5956398248672485,
0.7455136775970459,
-0.18799473345279694,
0.4290263056755066,
0.46834418177604675,
-0.29716530442237854,
-0.23232074081897736,
0.08528755605220795,
-0.47640499472618103,
-1.1138025522232056,
1.11188542842865,
-0.6133885979652405,
-0.785658597946167,
-0.13122934103012085,
-0.4430050849914551,
-0.510079026222229,
0.20048917829990387,
-0.220306858420372,
0.6158769726753235,
-0.09642642736434937,
0.016856271773576736,
0.9513387680053711,
-0.39356744289398193,
0.40261250734329224,
0.916836678981781,
-0.4093891978263855,
-0.4404446482658386,
0.6988039016723633,
0.3034760057926178,
0.038606274873018265,
-0.015032575465738773,
-0.05352677032351494,
-0.4989463686943054,
-0.3394627273082733,
-0.598656415939331,
0.31386202573776245,
-0.6101374626159668,
-0.15876995027065277,
-0.8535161018371582,
-0.07061763107776642,
-0.43254929780960083,
0.0650247111916542,
-0.32666075229644775,
-0.38700440526008606,
-0.1512930542230606,
-0.3624633550643921,
0.3434002697467804,
0.6321789026260376,
0.24406671524047852,
0.1269298791885376,
-1.1205496788024902,
0.35630539059638977,
0.26419368386268616,
0.8492318391799927,
-0.3152930736541748,
-0.3937724232673645,
-0.003508510533720255,
0.07645814120769501,
-0.24839475750923157,
-1.2158530950546265,
0.21283113956451416,
0.10414101928472519,
0.7342914342880249,
0.17570586502552032,
-0.014799828641116619,
0.44363823533058167,
-0.5690269470214844,
0.6524109840393066,
-0.03086099773645401,
-0.5595262050628662,
0.5257267355918884,
-0.2498788684606552,
0.09486792981624603,
0.5149768590927124,
0.23372501134872437,
-0.17144279181957245,
-0.2969247102737427,
-1.3075411319732666,
-0.9478194713592529,
0.04529108479619026,
0.001290980726480484,
0.3640765845775604,
-0.33335182070732117,
0.6344215869903564,
0.14135751128196716,
0.34082773327827454,
-0.4823750853538513,
-0.30118080973625183,
0.3613762855529785,
-0.2892754375934601,
0.08732984960079193,
-0.3957747519016266,
-0.25154632329940796,
0.3128089904785156,
0.6236664056777954,
-0.03996208682656288,
0.4205864667892456,
0.2655957043170929,
-0.2549281716346741,
-0.42848581075668335,
0.4662303626537323,
0.34575337171554565,
1.0315576791763306,
-0.2735729217529297,
-0.05928550660610199,
0.2879064083099365,
-0.1368020623922348,
0.2652028501033783,
0.10612740367650986,
-0.09855563938617706,
0.2278728485107422,
0.26510316133499146,
0.3324449360370636,
-0.0834413543343544,
-0.9510149359703064,
0.508392870426178,
0.18441295623779297,
-0.08604475110769272,
-0.3887467086315155,
0.013385733589529991,
-0.21524280309677124,
0.15802274644374847,
0.3115164637565613,
-0.2039678543806076,
0.6981728076934814,
-0.7415638566017151,
0.6492056250572205,
0.34568607807159424,
-0.548529326915741,
-0.2033785879611969,
0.44309279322624207,
0.4969789385795593,
-0.38076794147491455,
0.7703278064727783,
0.10721942782402039,
-0.4184167683124542,
1.0486464500427246,
0.6442808508872986,
0.890450656414032,
-0.23606881499290466,
0.08569001406431198,
0.2807863652706146,
0.3911125659942627,
0.194313645362854,
0.8209566473960876,
0.5445021390914917,
-0.4132581353187561,
-0.7127861976623535,
-0.2416047900915146,
-0.3109423816204071,
0.35379502177238464,
-0.7978542447090149,
0.15903064608573914,
-0.6553393006324768,
-0.18090596795082092,
-0.5865983366966248,
0.33456459641456604,
-0.7596441507339478,
0.6953417062759399,
0.13014836609363556,
1.1859750747680664,
-0.9336293935775757,
0.02994423359632492,
0.9255386590957642,
-0.6686586141586304,
-0.6803057789802551,
-0.017386868596076965,
-0.35737144947052,
-0.5040200352668762,
0.7047708630561829,
0.254057377576828,
-0.16105441749095917,
0.014197678305208683,
-0.39692631363868713,
-1.2906748056411743,
1.1418129205703735,
0.2710576057434082,
-0.6082711815834045,
0.21539412438869476,
-0.25932610034942627,
0.6476525068283081,
-0.35494327545166016,
0.6093055605888367,
0.5046482086181641,
0.6010425686836243,
-0.5302084684371948,
-0.8965169191360474,
0.4362170398235321,
-0.32302531599998474,
0.2943253219127655,
0.06213441863656044,
-0.7597169876098633,
0.25910893082618713,
-0.4602018892765045,
-0.3447388708591461,
-0.0021450293716043234,
1.1896811723709106,
0.6036102771759033,
0.40664488077163696,
0.7150751948356628,
0.370947927236557,
0.7617018222808838,
0.00717933801934123,
1.1865283250808716,
-0.18194347620010376,
0.49024146795272827,
0.945261538028717,
-0.5370610356330872,
0.9313907027244568,
0.584756076335907,
-0.3302905261516571,
0.9472930431365967,
0.7672032117843628,
-0.016005288809537888,
0.5194243788719177,
0.5517807006835938,
-0.24107512831687927,
-0.1576082706451416,
-0.1180773600935936,
-0.3762630522251129,
0.03077041357755661,
0.208443745970726,
-0.30339425802230835,
-0.15960536897182465,
0.08057689666748047,
-0.11883681267499924,
0.2908155620098114,
-0.588283121585846,
0.6767790913581848,
0.00643560104072094,
-0.522549569606781,
0.06338527053594589,
0.14163516461849213,
0.45019397139549255,
-0.08420618623495102,
-0.5647571682929993,
-0.24266356229782104,
0.04731738939881325,
-0.3878127336502075,
-0.8982608914375305,
0.22459541261196136,
-0.16925643384456635,
-0.0707053691148758,
-0.05646641179919243,
0.7740468978881836,
-0.4532759487628937,
-0.47045090794563293,
0.18251852691173553,
0.7624256014823914,
0.05317165330052376,
-0.018052436411380768,
-0.6397655010223389,
-0.23506012558937073,
-0.16766270995140076,
-0.7928048968315125,
0.09180206060409546,
0.42265793681144714,
-0.17967577278614044,
0.8609976172447205,
0.5025655627250671,
-0.11483169347047806,
0.22292642295360565,
0.0406244657933712,
0.8840078115463257,
-0.46421682834625244,
-0.3197155296802521,
-0.629579484462738,
0.6935836672782898,
-0.11106952279806137,
-0.06772926449775696,
0.6595042943954468,
0.8442798852920532,
0.5077175498008728,
-0.07246221601963043,
1.037785291671753,
0.17771171033382416,
0.7712295055389404,
-0.6805846691131592,
0.307771235704422,
-0.5170894265174866,
0.4934583306312561,
-0.32410889863967896,
-1.2745006084442139,
-0.08535081893205643,
0.28049641847610474,
-0.49506494402885437,
0.5957810878753662,
0.7422174215316772,
0.43715161085128784,
-0.09860484302043915,
-0.22088950872421265,
0.21315956115722656,
0.06915898621082306,
0.3752015233039856,
0.5070965886116028,
0.962899386882782,
-0.5509279370307922,
0.6353668570518494,
-0.16939802467823029,
-0.5787584781646729,
-0.19137731194496155,
-0.7564945816993713,
-0.43172961473464966,
-0.1381957083940506,
-0.8155702948570251,
-0.938167929649353,
0.03500412032008171,
0.8534827828407288,
0.38809147477149963,
-0.749319851398468,
0.17150738835334778,
0.23974990844726562,
0.05695212632417679,
-0.3506268262863159,
-0.3303288221359253,
0.3404484987258911,
-0.2255406379699707,
-0.9064614176750183,
0.2978946566581726,
0.33889240026474,
-0.020349618047475815,
-0.3864396810531616,
-0.09610037505626678,
0.19372963905334473,
0.43056023120880127,
0.5197013020515442,
0.28305187821388245,
-0.578601598739624,
-0.2907755374908447,
0.27400174736976624,
-0.25041452050209045,
-0.021010229364037514,
0.6872029900550842,
-0.7521919012069702,
-0.0063111442141234875,
0.22868528962135315,
0.9769198298454285,
0.05817380174994469,
0.060105614364147186,
0.92409348487854,
-0.2551654279232025,
-0.23326663672924042,
0.3018566071987152,
0.4242861270904541,
0.16176874935626984,
-0.7221908569335938,
0.6597253084182739,
-0.1271895468235016,
-0.3498595952987671,
-0.8978527188301086,
0.23994168639183044,
-1.0632153749465942,
-0.03794447332620621,
1.6066813468933105,
-0.49642011523246765,
-0.5490784049034119,
0.06303057074546814,
-0.21799777448177338,
0.037542711943387985,
-0.21676111221313477,
0.9354844093322754,
0.6564793586730957,
-0.24440473318099976,
-0.4371218681335449,
-0.2817148268222809,
0.13486839830875397,
0.5676324367523193,
-1.3118677139282227,
-0.1082288920879364,
0.4053271412849426,
0.6205053925514221,
0.24898555874824524,
0.709222137928009,
-0.4482109546661377,
0.5019761323928833,
-0.24012339115142822,
-0.027526728808879852,
0.03186112269759178,
-0.276681125164032,
-0.39912381768226624,
0.1414410024881363,
0.40570059418678284,
-0.2356133759021759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16076v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16076v1
|
Semantic Evolvement Enhanced Graph Autoencoder for Rumor Detection
| 2024-04-24T05:05:58 | 2024-04-24T05:05:58 |
Xiang Tao, Liang Wang, Qiang Liu, Shu Wu, Liang Wang
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Due to the rapid spread of rumors on social media, rumor detection has become
an extremely important challenge. Recently, numerous rumor detection models
which utilize textual information and the propagation structure of events have
been proposed. However, these methods overlook the importance of semantic
evolvement information of event in propagation process, which is often
challenging to be truly learned in supervised training paradigms and
traditional rumor detection methods. To address this issue, we propose a novel
semantic evolvement enhanced Graph Autoencoder for Rumor Detection (GARD) model
in this paper. The model learns semantic evolvement information of events by
capturing local semantic changes and global semantic evolvement information
through specific graph autoencoder and reconstruction strategies. By combining
semantic evolvement information and propagation structure information, the
model achieves a comprehensive understanding of event propagation and perform
accurate and robust detection, while also detecting rumors earlier by capturing
semantic evolvement information in the early stages. Moreover, in order to
enhance the model's ability to learn the distinct patterns of rumors and
non-rumors, we introduce a uniformity regularizer to further improve the
model's performance. Experimental results on three public benchmark datasets
confirm the superiority of our GARD method over the state-of-the-art approaches
in both overall performance and early rumor detection.
|
[
-0.38163211941719055,
-1.1121244430541992,
0.16850897669792175,
-0.0057139405980706215,
-0.48057326674461365,
0.0865432396531105,
-0.017671355977654457,
-0.7648272514343262,
0.6301140189170837,
0.1814710944890976,
-0.4684658348560333,
-0.4327690899372101,
-0.9575812220573425,
-0.184445321559906,
-0.6609534025192261,
1.0710517168045044,
0.09404707700014114,
-0.1685856431722641,
0.24287079274654388,
0.20850417017936707,
-0.12106409668922424,
-0.33475083112716675,
-0.6622501611709595,
-0.018551765009760857,
0.31090614199638367,
0.26678332686424255,
0.7570595145225525,
0.6906615495681763,
0.11913269013166428,
0.27961495518684387,
-0.1740960329771042,
0.5078912973403931,
-0.596727728843689,
0.283237487077713,
0.38531041145324707,
0.0782826617360115,
-0.5460880398750305,
-0.228183776140213,
0.8125524520874023,
0.37448936700820923,
-0.35210612416267395,
0.03831876069307327,
-0.19085389375686646,
0.23488543927669525,
-0.2818908393383026,
0.32656776905059814,
-0.9108990430831909,
0.08797486126422882,
-0.15946075320243835,
-0.11994185298681259,
-0.1878698617219925,
-0.3097752332687378,
0.012098089791834354,
-0.6804064512252808,
0.49985188245773315,
0.12974800169467926,
1.324137806892395,
-0.039212264120578766,
-0.16321700811386108,
-0.344833642244339,
-0.736253559589386,
0.05129407346248627,
-0.3638733923435211,
0.6597321629524231,
-0.23178991675376892,
0.4470081031322479,
-0.2865056097507477,
-1.1523020267486572,
-0.7708901166915894,
-0.1716538667678833,
0.13108237087726593,
0.04097461327910423,
-0.5726965069770813,
-0.048614807426929474,
-0.06179092079401016,
0.2612687051296234,
-0.5149967074394226,
-0.0029781057965010405,
-0.2960015833377838,
-0.5523257851600647,
0.29125237464904785,
-0.2067154347896576,
0.3364727795124054,
-0.3546535074710846,
-0.4834628403186798,
-0.17409226298332214,
-0.023676835000514984,
-0.3597322106361389,
0.7009873390197754,
-0.09834229946136475,
0.07857009768486023,
0.07746409624814987,
-0.6222026944160461,
0.5437914729118347,
0.35053932666778564,
0.19916775822639465,
0.6775427460670471,
-0.18961745500564575,
0.005394642241299152,
0.17600810527801514,
0.6859354972839355,
0.2778600752353668,
0.11617336422204971,
-0.5383017659187317,
-0.06435663998126984,
0.21303890645503998,
0.15793311595916748,
-0.7690398693084717,
-0.5099221467971802,
-0.09369541704654694,
-0.645296573638916,
-0.5128619074821472,
0.28362277150154114,
-1.0341567993164062,
-0.33041244745254517,
0.15837712585926056,
0.14743825793266296,
-0.5017441511154175,
-0.6042566895484924,
0.33038589358329773,
-0.617933452129364,
0.21844007074832916,
0.6110619902610779,
-0.435516357421875,
-0.037404537200927734,
0.48877155780792236,
0.6625633239746094,
0.09282158315181732,
-0.2236502468585968,
-0.43596091866493225,
0.4109645187854767,
-0.3842008113861084,
1.1955111026763916,
-0.48468777537345886,
-0.31482136249542236,
-0.22420495748519897,
-0.0538785383105278,
-0.0017359615303575993,
-0.09039468318223953,
0.9205793142318726,
-0.7535285353660583,
0.06817860156297684,
0.08910424262285233,
-0.6686134934425354,
-0.16960421204566956,
0.27960801124572754,
-0.4464840888977051,
0.8780332803726196,
0.06294671446084976,
-0.795931339263916,
0.7712492942810059,
-0.39541199803352356,
-0.3388853371143341,
0.27157649397850037,
0.013346354477107525,
-0.5537019968032837,
0.1598454713821411,
0.6260629296302795,
0.1858714520931244,
0.16972047090530396,
0.05931093543767929,
-0.47332099080085754,
-0.04304331913590431,
-0.05405965819954872,
-0.7593910098075867,
0.31504473090171814,
0.42576858401298523,
-0.1516125649213791,
0.14383113384246826,
-0.687390923500061,
0.12510858476161957,
0.11382240056991577,
0.02799731120467186,
-0.20384721457958221,
-0.1452779471874237,
-0.23375222086906433,
0.3910062611103058,
0.05181362107396126,
-0.7926743030548096,
0.09259102493524551,
-0.1826818883419037,
0.2022215873003006,
0.6326959729194641,
0.5906099081039429,
0.4232926070690155,
-0.34073877334594727,
0.16790558397769928,
0.21164754033088684,
0.5837518572807312,
0.0582207590341568,
-0.7231244444847107,
-0.9158258438110352,
-0.17661434412002563,
0.2038988173007965,
0.09029971063137054,
-0.6250234246253967,
0.37541458010673523,
-0.5711068511009216,
-0.4561835527420044,
-0.5900923609733582,
0.1328350454568863,
-0.06351020932197571,
0.6740663647651672,
0.29603785276412964,
-0.027713200077414513,
-0.6815994381904602,
-0.5908151865005493,
-0.41989144682884216,
-0.11690876632928848,
0.1775619089603424,
0.3385544419288635,
0.14994731545448303,
-0.3567623794078827,
0.9901688694953918,
-0.3529853820800781,
-0.25534865260124207,
-0.22199776768684387,
0.5328680276870728,
-0.017524471506476402,
0.2281249612569809,
0.6798203587532043,
-0.9690613150596619,
-0.35893410444259644,
-0.06844305992126465,
-0.7632009387016296,
-0.10526969283819199,
0.22404876351356506,
-0.19546952843666077,
0.30616986751556396,
0.5437809824943542,
-0.4394533932209015,
0.4128042161464691,
0.4279613196849823,
-0.48715394735336304,
0.4514290392398834,
-0.3140697479248047,
0.1714274287223816,
-0.7949163317680359,
-0.5690715312957764,
-0.24544024467468262,
-0.45909953117370605,
-0.5911732912063599,
-0.12569734454154968,
-0.01689588651061058,
0.10256635397672653,
-0.044498275965452194,
0.4704965353012085,
-0.7575989961624146,
0.13095346093177795,
-0.42111819982528687,
0.31849050521850586,
0.0833749771118164,
-0.053346943110227585,
0.16050109267234802,
0.2758904695510864,
0.5266059041023254,
-0.7361017465591431,
0.33290013670921326,
0.10462994873523712,
-0.25100934505462646,
0.16835276782512665,
-0.3981438875198364,
0.38757166266441345,
-0.554265558719635,
0.6428537964820862,
-0.8777791857719421,
-0.2799318730831146,
0.49265074729919434,
-0.8792951107025146,
0.09440196305513382,
-0.43384307622909546,
-0.6605559587478638,
-0.7168101668357849,
0.05068877711892128,
-0.2587684690952301,
0.837263286113739,
-0.6186997294425964,
0.6872276067733765,
0.5471760034561157,
0.028260763734579086,
-0.2697957754135132,
-0.5511961579322815,
0.2705724239349365,
-0.014984759502112865,
-1.0651893615722656,
0.1629038155078888,
0.24364033341407776,
0.10324601083993912,
0.24237127602100372,
-0.23019449412822723,
-0.12437863647937775,
-0.30342453718185425,
0.04187880828976631,
0.2917044162750244,
-0.10750681906938553,
0.1530480980873108,
0.08761128038167953,
-0.3537954092025757,
0.009088123217225075,
-0.8204638361930847,
0.5496379733085632,
-0.022332819178700447,
-0.0503857247531414,
-0.28853482007980347,
0.0454808734357357,
0.36076074838638306,
-0.047386534512043,
0.7730385065078735,
1.0364195108413696,
-0.1998574137687683,
-0.4654558300971985,
-0.9833882451057434,
-0.18649718165397644,
-0.4702180325984955,
0.6205812096595764,
-0.2271401584148407,
-0.6199827790260315,
0.5007361173629761,
-0.22986000776290894,
-0.5757245421409607,
0.6121988892555237,
0.2586011588573456,
0.1959572434425354,
1.0603127479553223,
0.4723174273967743,
-0.33405759930610657,
0.4327811598777771,
-0.3522394299507141,
-0.09999816864728928,
-0.6560210585594177,
-0.29761871695518494,
-0.2383972853422165,
-0.1434478908777237,
-0.16782328486442566,
-0.8014811873435974,
0.15312646329402924,
0.12803864479064941,
0.052839092910289764,
0.1287056803703308,
-0.6053473949432373,
0.27787649631500244,
-0.012426715344190598,
0.12361901253461838,
0.6445870995521545,
0.37262827157974243,
-0.054151587188243866,
0.23309196531772614,
-0.9539533257484436,
-0.09833269566297531,
0.7885523438453674,
0.5344368815422058,
0.80089271068573,
-0.06675777584314346,
0.6224880218505859,
0.5226033329963684,
0.21349211037158966,
-0.3114483654499054,
0.29131701588630676,
0.04684853181242943,
-0.19929982721805573,
-0.3982944190502167,
-0.5796292424201965,
-0.6471344232559204,
0.2809602618217468,
-0.07701388746500015,
-0.6611617207527161,
0.7127171158790588,
-0.05116964504122734,
0.1492878645658493,
0.48376765847206116,
-0.48667556047439575,
0.4462692141532898,
0.056966572999954224,
0.3097102642059326,
-0.360138475894928,
-0.45692917704582214,
0.13912200927734375,
0.13534259796142578,
0.5733537673950195,
-0.09154657274484634,
0.011806998401880264,
0.64271080493927,
-0.5664481520652771,
0.7332353591918945,
-0.46101075410842896,
0.07618933171033859,
0.5854017734527588,
-0.13421575725078583,
1.152566909790039,
0.35126155614852905,
-0.10436975210905075,
0.3307577669620514,
-0.5834782719612122,
-0.1496793031692505,
-0.4214722812175751,
0.6287086009979248,
-0.8204641342163086,
-0.3274169862270355,
-0.41150903701782227,
-0.6951146125793457,
-0.041741400957107544,
0.0984700545668602,
0.6179026961326599,
0.18320930004119873,
-0.3225843608379364,
-0.15684978663921356,
0.5527459383010864,
0.33331573009490967,
0.3558799624443054,
0.5982822775840759,
-0.2574448585510254,
-0.5039322376251221,
0.9029349684715271,
0.2130570262670517,
0.23299480974674225,
-0.2754134237766266,
0.11577139794826508,
-0.10575075447559357,
-0.7851983904838562,
-0.450271874666214,
0.1175195500254631,
-0.8612155318260193,
-0.13910596072673798,
-1.1236515045166016,
-0.6081352233886719,
-0.6167744398117065,
-0.0270419679582119,
-0.31623101234436035,
-0.2767748534679413,
-0.050433091819286346,
-0.18351440131664276,
0.569394588470459,
0.7050273418426514,
-0.1445697396993637,
0.19364236295223236,
-0.7219018340110779,
0.3664889335632324,
0.1839548498392105,
0.1440456360578537,
0.058731790632009506,
-0.8272019624710083,
0.10524362325668335,
0.21712487936019897,
0.09826592355966568,
-0.6756685972213745,
0.5380493402481079,
0.3917604386806488,
0.722637951374054,
0.5422797203063965,
0.21404030919075012,
0.8383144736289978,
-0.3687994182109833,
0.3563143014907837,
-0.08321499824523926,
-0.6143300533294678,
0.4590517580509186,
-0.5087571144104004,
0.060353707522153854,
0.26686525344848633,
0.14954634010791779,
-0.4752073287963867,
-0.6423123478889465,
-0.9576109647750854,
-0.6964775919914246,
0.4412451386451721,
0.25735560059547424,
0.4235142767429352,
-0.4016555845737457,
0.4929841458797455,
0.03673841804265976,
0.14431458711624146,
-0.581098198890686,
-0.26503923535346985,
-0.4117737114429474,
0.17848995327949524,
0.3575342297554016,
-0.5499193072319031,
0.06392025947570801,
-0.4574745297431946,
0.6533180475234985,
-0.09566814452409744,
0.532787561416626,
0.4780770242214203,
-0.4164220988750458,
-0.1589338481426239,
0.13103622198104858,
0.14308926463127136,
0.3212008774280548,
-0.20449601113796234,
-0.3130643367767334,
0.21429918706417084,
-0.7280107140541077,
-0.07456201314926147,
0.3892304003238678,
-0.44228798151016235,
0.47258397936820984,
0.15935459733009338,
1.0762711763381958,
0.05072202906012535,
0.06452759355306625,
0.6958525776863098,
-0.13640093803405762,
-0.3644360601902008,
-0.45330408215522766,
0.12118005007505417,
-0.2626439034938812,
0.22239834070205688,
0.6467589139938354,
0.17226822674274445,
0.3559291660785675,
-0.42550551891326904,
0.4537128210067749,
0.2728457748889923,
-0.7554747462272644,
-0.15101154148578644,
0.6266304850578308,
0.059409335255622864,
0.17669793963432312,
0.6286147832870483,
-0.6856275796890259,
-0.5471130013465881,
0.6991236805915833,
0.8413501977920532,
0.8502388000488281,
-0.16423338651657104,
0.5473283529281616,
0.10028423368930817,
0.24690479040145874,
-0.016926167532801628,
0.16718122363090515,
0.10517238080501556,
-0.9998682141304016,
-0.20418782532215118,
-0.7913346886634827,
0.03705964982509613,
-0.11145707219839096,
-0.366716593503952,
0.47883549332618713,
-0.15321461856365204,
0.04029475152492523,
-0.09811484813690186,
-0.426811546087265,
-0.30161866545677185,
0.022140702232718468,
0.350366473197937,
1.016979455947876,
-0.46185746788978577,
1.1183757781982422,
0.4981388747692108,
-0.22259406745433807,
-0.8772968649864197,
0.26561784744262695,
0.061542876064777374,
-0.7287090420722961,
0.7962163686752319,
-0.015865227207541466,
-0.04090286046266556,
0.48147398233413696,
-0.1586287021636963,
-1.1075268983840942,
1.2095320224761963,
0.24235834181308746,
-0.5296231508255005,
-0.3096122741699219,
-0.35143914818763733,
0.33531516790390015,
-0.6345881223678589,
0.4621492028236389,
-0.023838432505726814,
0.6260590553283691,
0.7479759454727173,
-0.5609292387962341,
-0.04940096661448479,
-0.0757952556014061,
0.020388543605804443,
0.35314029455184937,
-0.6880072951316833,
0.9097110629081726,
-0.20041503012180328,
-0.1531989425420761,
-0.059787750244140625,
0.9887149930000305,
-0.19494007527828217,
0.0922006294131279,
0.6244093179702759,
0.5022161602973938,
1.0214345455169678,
-0.14600655436515808,
1.1893450021743774,
-0.5583534240722656,
0.5162314176559448,
0.8610239624977112,
-0.06644479930400848,
0.2916800081729889,
-0.2512800097465515,
0.2624374032020569,
1.1409035921096802,
0.5047222971916199,
-0.285626083612442,
0.46066102385520935,
0.029203014448285103,
-0.2217033952474594,
-0.35586944222450256,
0.03528192639350891,
-0.5687537789344788,
0.3747231066226959,
0.5436840057373047,
-0.5049118399620056,
-0.7016233205795288,
0.30939793586730957,
0.295926034450531,
-0.3017299175262451,
-0.5715590715408325,
0.700215220451355,
-0.26084309816360474,
-0.2221045047044754,
0.22905594110488892,
-0.05439822003245354,
0.6529917120933533,
-0.8747405409812927,
-0.014556541107594967,
0.11752313375473022,
0.29432278871536255,
-0.10346291959285736,
-0.3427552580833435,
0.264035165309906,
-0.3499196469783783,
-0.21749630570411682,
0.09294874221086502,
1.4191474914550781,
-0.35701999068260193,
-0.5263620615005493,
0.5713071823120117,
0.41715148091316223,
0.04345440864562988,
-0.11997601389884949,
-0.4982691705226898,
0.054836954921483994,
-0.3179050385951996,
-0.27391475439071655,
0.2599906623363495,
0.6732944250106812,
-0.1606275737285614,
0.5483947992324829,
0.8896677494049072,
0.42736944556236267,
0.3397849500179291,
0.29798126220703125,
1.0814666748046875,
-0.20123445987701416,
-0.8628958463668823,
-0.714093804359436,
0.14780767261981964,
-0.7420355081558228,
-0.25230690836906433,
1.1168067455291748,
0.43332600593566895,
0.5378705859184265,
0.03854934498667717,
0.8113088607788086,
-0.11421769112348557,
0.3238822817802429,
-0.3574804365634918,
0.8803920149803162,
0.14449523389339447,
0.3010202646255493,
-0.46638771891593933,
-0.697543740272522,
-0.016646811738610268,
0.5885756015777588,
-0.30390745401382446,
0.24544477462768555,
0.7269802689552307,
0.6460743546485901,
-0.033751361072063446,
0.3844267725944519,
0.11764150857925415,
0.5634851455688477,
0.17704081535339355,
-0.0014976983657106757,
0.6533735990524292,
-0.39736250042915344,
0.8134859800338745,
-0.14245733618736267,
-0.25078368186950684,
-0.3094780147075653,
-0.9018329381942749,
-0.6094804406166077,
-0.37417280673980713,
-0.46101081371307373,
-0.6203126907348633,
0.6477850675582886,
0.554697573184967,
0.8621417284011841,
-0.40304574370384216,
0.18224740028381348,
-0.5163262486457825,
0.015505188144743443,
-0.16603687405586243,
-0.3385799527168274,
0.259958952665329,
-0.6962743997573853,
-0.4648984968662262,
0.41763389110565186,
0.2090340107679367,
0.10889522731304169,
-0.061956413090229034,
-0.14999938011169434,
-0.27934199571609497,
0.19253236055374146,
0.19898098707199097,
0.26388466358184814,
-0.41769030690193176,
-0.8114113211631775,
-0.1276189237833023,
-0.02819289080798626,
-0.044107213616371155,
0.48630276322364807,
-1.0447739362716675,
0.5611053705215454,
0.3668544590473175,
0.315434992313385,
0.8107715249061584,
0.056938402354717255,
0.6716465950012207,
-0.7376559376716614,
0.4408204257488251,
0.009476274251937866,
0.35241076350212097,
0.09756876528263092,
-0.8317933678627014,
0.32518118619918823,
0.6475515961647034,
-0.5947889685630798,
-0.6704899072647095,
0.009269066154956818,
-0.6022390127182007,
-0.28833523392677307,
1.2514475584030151,
0.1809692680835724,
-0.36577245593070984,
-0.5705437064170837,
0.024254074320197105,
0.27973780035972595,
-0.7308757901191711,
0.7086638808250427,
0.6987119317054749,
-0.2020956426858902,
-0.06332317739725113,
-0.5433207154273987,
0.4994257986545563,
-0.3216627538204193,
-0.480790913105011,
-0.1388767808675766,
0.4736575782299042,
0.5231537222862244,
0.1389838308095932,
0.7634073495864868,
-0.20462237298488617,
0.4926547110080719,
0.40961337089538574,
0.10269250720739365,
-0.6409028172492981,
-0.4376521408557892,
-0.16539369523525238,
0.29447656869888306,
-0.1299847811460495,
-0.20086562633514404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15639v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15639v1
|
CodeIP: A Grammar-Guided Multi-Bit Watermark for Large Language Models of Code
| 2024-04-24T04:25:04 | 2024-04-24T04:25:04 |
Batu Guan, Yao Wan, Zhangqian Bi, Zheng Wang, Hongyu Zhang, Yulei Sui, Pan Zhou, Lichao Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used to automate code
generation, it is often desired to know if the code is AI-generated and by
which model, especially for purposes like protecting intellectual property (IP)
in industry and preventing academic misconduct in education. Incorporating
watermarks into machine-generated content is one way to provide code
provenance, but existing solutions are restricted to a single bit or lack
flexibility. We present CodeIP, a new watermarking technique for LLM-based code
generation. CodeIP enables the insertion of multi-bit information while
preserving the semantics of the generated code, improving the strength and
diversity of the inerseted watermark. This is achieved by training a type
predictor to predict the subsequent grammar type of the next token to enhance
the syntactical and semantic correctness of the generated code. Experiments on
a real-world dataset across five programming languages showcase the
effectiveness of CodeIP.
|
[
-0.2970225214958191,
-0.4159616529941559,
0.2768423855304718,
0.3713885545730591,
-0.3533833622932434,
0.3354931175708771,
0.054235655814409256,
-0.2766328752040863,
0.3295467495918274,
0.8336411714553833,
-0.18767112493515015,
-0.6189664602279663,
-0.6492859125137329,
-0.12707051634788513,
-0.42204323410987854,
0.7656546235084534,
0.12371265143156052,
0.031495023518800735,
-0.2622348368167877,
0.06335830688476562,
-0.5247243642807007,
-0.8266584277153015,
-0.22154226899147034,
-0.0876665785908699,
-0.06334219127893448,
0.5761584043502808,
0.6149124503135681,
0.897561252117157,
0.6409515142440796,
0.2524574100971222,
-0.04875529929995537,
0.14596211910247803,
-0.10677488893270493,
0.020623931661248207,
0.31748753786087036,
-0.7093149423599243,
-0.34174367785453796,
-0.2830621004104614,
0.6523659229278564,
0.4753376245498657,
0.25345849990844727,
0.23538236320018768,
-0.08617700636386871,
0.5960900783538818,
-0.790992259979248,
0.3291013538837433,
-0.8710449934005737,
0.1962992399930954,
-0.2233460545539856,
-0.25050199031829834,
-0.6170802116394043,
-0.3638171851634979,
-0.5536522269248962,
-0.23877911269664764,
-0.049461010843515396,
0.15335887670516968,
0.8251384496688843,
0.24608661234378815,
-0.26007676124572754,
-0.07438104599714279,
-0.5019097924232483,
0.7087575197219849,
-0.9140413999557495,
0.11784908175468445,
0.4076603949069977,
0.21440742909908295,
-0.25501304864883423,
-0.7769307494163513,
-0.5173611640930176,
-0.01675358973443508,
0.3433834910392761,
-0.09810439497232437,
-0.033996470272541046,
0.04936129227280617,
0.28460878133773804,
0.2580552399158478,
-0.3175676763057709,
-0.059195052832365036,
-0.14464698731899261,
-0.30290910601615906,
0.4974174201488495,
-0.05121055245399475,
0.4729219377040863,
0.03578659147024155,
-0.29853636026382446,
0.04886199161410332,
-1.1638679504394531,
0.0408506877720356,
0.5286922454833984,
0.22981314361095428,
-0.0128755709156394,
0.6254023909568787,
0.15191687643527985,
0.7053187489509583,
-0.08767203241586685,
-0.39159584045410156,
0.1269300878047943,
-0.04128706827759743,
0.14835096895694733,
0.18487964570522308,
0.7879173755645752,
0.28458908200263977,
0.4690348207950592,
0.09029766917228699,
-0.17524397373199463,
0.2949691116809845,
-0.07399892807006836,
-0.9974300265312195,
-0.2403920590877533,
0.12367620319128036,
-0.4490680396556854,
-0.4961600601673126,
0.5156528949737549,
-0.8445583581924438,
-0.40267810225486755,
0.011149984784424305,
0.16591812670230865,
-0.44655266404151917,
-0.2802758514881134,
0.3509981632232666,
-0.3528781831264496,
0.23131895065307617,
-0.08954154700040817,
-0.7865864038467407,
0.09738937765359879,
0.8334755301475525,
0.7537598609924316,
0.05900038033723831,
-0.4180387258529663,
-0.8255163431167603,
0.5473809838294983,
-0.4344313442707062,
0.8519518375396729,
-0.9798821210861206,
-0.3441835045814514,
0.17073379456996918,
-0.2904958724975586,
0.270821213722229,
-0.6513431668281555,
-0.04610021412372589,
-0.6873602867126465,
-0.13417628407478333,
0.33479806780815125,
-0.8579887747764587,
0.18368083238601685,
0.10402759164571762,
-0.8673409819602966,
0.8561257719993591,
-0.05125948414206505,
-0.6993060111999512,
0.4975409507751465,
-0.610572338104248,
-0.4524917006492615,
0.26413723826408386,
-0.4541817009449005,
-0.8067314028739929,
0.0395323671400547,
0.1535007357597351,
0.29306039214134216,
-0.0151249123737216,
0.7052916884422302,
-0.5564274191856384,
-0.42286255955696106,
0.49614566564559937,
-0.47938498854637146,
0.5907361507415771,
0.019134506583213806,
-0.44289329648017883,
0.11286791414022446,
-0.8654388785362244,
0.34903666377067566,
0.1029837429523468,
-0.44848382472991943,
-0.16232307255268097,
-0.006283837370574474,
-0.22264839708805084,
0.27350303530693054,
0.2738940417766571,
-0.5470637679100037,
0.5115018486976624,
0.017957627773284912,
0.6256378293037415,
0.6435828804969788,
0.10413552075624466,
-0.025280792266130447,
-0.30862054228782654,
0.8578905463218689,
-0.06542269140481949,
0.1966724693775177,
-0.5312045812606812,
-0.6695841550827026,
-0.6748374700546265,
-0.6018785834312439,
0.5101337432861328,
0.3218127489089966,
-0.6218125820159912,
0.5501850247383118,
-0.43972331285476685,
-0.31122860312461853,
-0.4600948095321655,
0.3455350697040558,
0.5955666303634644,
-0.12113741785287857,
0.17921246588230133,
-0.3290100395679474,
-0.61467444896698,
-0.7991026639938354,
-0.26818594336509705,
-0.20635557174682617,
0.14445121586322784,
0.3645039200782776,
0.5288540720939636,
-0.19857986271381378,
0.9886600375175476,
-0.6146319508552551,
-0.07355207204818726,
-0.5916865468025208,
0.2993839383125305,
0.04521498829126358,
0.542052149772644,
0.3911179006099701,
-0.8126413226127625,
-0.5588381290435791,
-0.28698045015335083,
-0.3704325556755066,
-0.40939047932624817,
-0.1658412665128708,
-0.13150984048843384,
0.0558064728975296,
0.6224603652954102,
-0.4502854645252228,
0.4004327952861786,
0.958441972732544,
-0.5312623381614685,
0.6028212308883667,
-0.019227640703320503,
0.0010718796402215958,
-1.0277810096740723,
0.16839827597141266,
-0.51382976770401,
-0.26469239592552185,
-0.30241912603378296,
0.13334019482135773,
0.21438224613666534,
-0.482990026473999,
-0.40664955973625183,
0.40762007236480713,
-0.5516676902770996,
-0.21016021072864532,
-0.4920750558376312,
-0.4127849340438843,
0.3414783477783203,
0.27240273356437683,
0.04234936460852623,
1.1203583478927612,
0.6145927309989929,
-0.3184186816215515,
0.14548121392726898,
0.09020408242940903,
-0.2399924397468567,
0.22376132011413574,
-0.4978574812412262,
0.47291311621665955,
0.04672761261463165,
0.0956316590309143,
-0.9008405208587646,
-0.047321878373622894,
-0.24179303646087646,
-0.3879215121269226,
0.23503348231315613,
-0.7026984095573425,
-0.678108274936676,
-0.08295755833387375,
-0.4761013984680176,
0.4487798511981964,
0.3688701391220093,
-0.5709848403930664,
0.5457119345664978,
0.4553740918636322,
-0.1919942945241928,
-0.4997953176498413,
-0.7106286287307739,
0.4304931163787842,
-0.13618870079517365,
-0.5246738195419312,
0.48709774017333984,
-0.2722967565059662,
-0.1550808697938919,
-0.06509245187044144,
-0.09305185824632645,
-0.5486057996749878,
0.03193967416882515,
0.6979973912239075,
0.451687216758728,
-0.22395393252372742,
-0.11272361129522324,
0.10767106711864471,
-0.27943137288093567,
0.04182717576622963,
-0.278994619846344,
0.9588301777839661,
-0.12739621102809906,
-0.5349792242050171,
-0.2431533932685852,
0.6023451685905457,
0.7114781141281128,
-0.5427114367485046,
0.40435051918029785,
0.0816858783364296,
-0.25789979100227356,
-0.392025887966156,
-0.38633468747138977,
0.136226087808609,
-0.4900014400482178,
0.1701994240283966,
-0.30706262588500977,
-0.7678737044334412,
0.2410619705915451,
-0.3682234585285187,
-0.09070824831724167,
0.16672967374324799,
0.12032770365476608,
0.304338276386261,
0.8113939166069031,
0.8585307002067566,
-0.5540057420730591,
0.7654381394386292,
-0.3882232904434204,
0.08421825617551804,
-0.3611140549182892,
0.019781777635216713,
-0.5266997218132019,
0.04468850791454315,
-0.25063425302505493,
-0.4097656309604645,
-0.026682130992412567,
0.38306736946105957,
-0.29033029079437256,
0.4902460277080536,
-0.3202027976512909,
0.7550165057182312,
0.8726094961166382,
0.0018767485162243247,
0.3566811978816986,
-0.01671646721661091,
-0.017626319080591202,
-0.029148822650313377,
-0.6009875535964966,
-0.5936325788497925,
1.101951003074646,
0.09062878042459488,
0.7576541900634766,
-0.05916928872466087,
0.9956875443458557,
0.5485564470291138,
0.2532787322998047,
-0.5643406510353088,
0.6452271342277527,
-0.1362314671278,
-0.5680322647094727,
-0.04223257675766945,
-0.2218749225139618,
-0.7004663348197937,
-0.07488489151000977,
-0.16574232280254364,
-0.3274538516998291,
-0.02472561039030552,
0.2588021159172058,
-0.22337448596954346,
0.343080073595047,
-0.5790901780128479,
0.817295253276825,
-0.47942960262298584,
-0.2941858768463135,
-0.14494815468788147,
-0.46090126037597656,
-0.09235574305057526,
-0.20842288434505463,
0.3107735514640808,
-0.0862356498837471,
-0.04631263390183449,
0.47488969564437866,
-0.5402862429618835,
0.9464911818504333,
-0.3677256107330322,
-0.0848669782280922,
0.5027894377708435,
0.35833489894866943,
0.5086694955825806,
-0.04739201068878174,
0.025036459788680077,
0.3674428164958954,
-0.17146965861320496,
-0.10654717683792114,
-0.3121694326400757,
0.2576821446418762,
-0.4255928695201874,
-0.38957157731056213,
-0.1630961149930954,
-0.45839381217956543,
-0.07586287707090378,
0.6106429696083069,
0.08711685985326767,
0.5596465468406677,
0.2617186903953552,
0.21340365707874298,
0.4059818983078003,
-0.5217947959899902,
0.6819121241569519,
0.40966272354125977,
-0.39540529251098633,
-0.7798364758491516,
0.9777244329452515,
-0.23188111186027527,
0.3438068628311157,
0.4867039918899536,
0.17657174170017242,
0.1301916390657425,
-0.6931100487709045,
-0.3856019973754883,
0.054063647985458374,
-0.7190765738487244,
-0.6579107046127319,
-0.2778529226779938,
-0.35481536388397217,
-0.23491086065769196,
-0.29713961482048035,
-0.4934767186641693,
-0.3383074700832367,
0.09315557777881622,
0.04492919147014618,
0.2712908983230591,
0.5539665818214417,
0.1642599105834961,
0.4524439573287964,
-0.821208119392395,
0.43131768703460693,
0.19893765449523926,
0.7592388987541199,
-0.6579235196113586,
-0.40026307106018066,
-0.024292560294270515,
-0.11135545372962952,
-0.2016364485025406,
-0.614079475402832,
0.4629240930080414,
0.5416178703308105,
0.18886704742908478,
0.5440134406089783,
0.09503333270549774,
0.6727855205535889,
-0.7201481461524963,
0.7325344085693359,
0.25246769189834595,
-1.3022629022598267,
0.6801208257675171,
-0.044281382113695145,
0.14629489183425903,
0.4228670299053192,
-0.05192430689930916,
-0.33434170484542847,
-0.5763993263244629,
-0.5424937009811401,
-0.9977579116821289,
0.2061259150505066,
-0.12399593740701675,
0.29211434721946716,
-0.08728653192520142,
0.3006584346294403,
0.31082677841186523,
0.5395922064781189,
-1.1108171939849854,
-0.11861856281757355,
-0.3166002035140991,
-0.2960355877876282,
0.49955281615257263,
-0.615170955657959,
0.029066765680909157,
0.10928855091333389,
0.46897926926612854,
-0.3293265700340271,
0.5705048441886902,
-0.24466516077518463,
-0.17469564080238342,
0.014459801837801933,
0.28585633635520935,
0.47781479358673096,
0.5674927830696106,
-0.030992580577731133,
0.38481101393699646,
-0.4319058060646057,
-0.5107203722000122,
0.09901657700538635,
-0.04557295888662338,
-0.21238082647323608,
0.08018381893634796,
0.7001608610153198,
0.6760014295578003,
-0.14035609364509583,
-0.8973619341850281,
0.9816995859146118,
0.12075679749250412,
-0.20403656363487244,
-0.5191177129745483,
0.1977018564939499,
-0.08380462229251862,
0.17354395985603333,
0.19111305475234985,
-0.13059940934181213,
0.03253496438264847,
-0.30324867367744446,
0.39547961950302124,
0.4958021640777588,
-0.060118209570646286,
-0.11515723168849945,
0.6776795387268066,
0.20292411744594574,
-0.4415171444416046,
0.48494264483451843,
0.09424017369747162,
-0.6860101222991943,
0.8241921663284302,
0.9476778507232666,
0.7903257012367249,
0.06292720884084702,
-0.0005733119323849678,
0.07049543410539627,
0.17000621557235718,
0.06691170483827591,
0.6277368068695068,
0.09874347597360611,
-0.8513563871383667,
-0.5573270320892334,
-0.40545687079429626,
-0.5120795965194702,
0.1574842631816864,
-0.5151417255401611,
0.3593466281890869,
-0.7679153084754944,
-0.20670147240161896,
-0.026325810700654984,
-0.5054117441177368,
-0.36634451150894165,
0.0658138319849968,
0.4811779856681824,
0.8506924510002136,
-0.8490216135978699,
1.0594751834869385,
0.5700138807296753,
-0.38145092129707336,
-0.681969940662384,
0.2390432506799698,
-0.21847571432590485,
-0.9946139454841614,
0.772389829158783,
0.6099575161933899,
-0.1963776797056198,
0.012182115577161312,
-0.9530456066131592,
-0.9643902778625488,
0.7633926868438721,
0.7251429557800293,
-0.5756853818893433,
0.3613913655281067,
0.7040090560913086,
0.26435136795043945,
-0.4139954149723053,
-0.07684791833162308,
0.14736081659793854,
0.37747061252593994,
-0.32459142804145813,
-0.6057122945785522,
-0.05738036707043648,
-0.5700438618659973,
0.18811661005020142,
0.3407555818557739,
-0.6096315979957581,
0.5388184785842896,
-0.17735955119132996,
0.06582523137331009,
-0.05696453899145126,
0.427357017993927,
0.40542054176330566,
-0.013713784515857697,
0.515225350856781,
0.2771511673927307,
0.4416333734989166,
-0.03281654417514801,
0.8979231119155884,
-1.0376548767089844,
0.12148502469062805,
1.0710264444351196,
-0.30366307497024536,
0.9468387961387634,
0.679019570350647,
-0.1351349949836731,
0.579475998878479,
0.07396771013736725,
-0.4304955303668976,
0.5452792644500732,
0.4144132733345032,
-0.3116801977157593,
-0.2721046805381775,
-0.24217179417610168,
-0.3145749866962433,
0.5410998463630676,
0.15812209248542786,
-0.46464577317237854,
0.3067089021205902,
-0.14239487051963806,
0.13775832951068878,
0.043357718735933304,
-0.15850642323493958,
0.7563768029212952,
-0.10334770381450653,
-0.6503974795341492,
0.3941245377063751,
0.07429812103509903,
0.7523419260978699,
-0.6708893179893494,
-0.5109120011329651,
-0.4118824601173401,
0.2712428867816925,
-0.18236081302165985,
-0.7273327708244324,
0.13411766290664673,
0.11773015558719635,
-0.11100538820028305,
-0.25880953669548035,
0.7053878307342529,
-0.5497799515724182,
-0.4867660403251648,
0.3291438817977905,
0.16699707508087158,
0.0817769467830658,
-0.17588679492473602,
-0.5314533114433289,
0.2791570723056793,
-0.08045633137226105,
0.12738247215747833,
0.13957537710666656,
0.5120313167572021,
0.155905082821846,
0.9376690983772278,
0.5613175630569458,
0.32102733850479126,
0.3345910310745239,
0.21849587559700012,
0.832880437374115,
-0.7141199111938477,
-0.5657877922058105,
-1.0182714462280273,
0.34021690487861633,
-0.0032790745608508587,
-0.25967833399772644,
0.5431903004646301,
0.8222138285636902,
0.6843156814575195,
-0.2951917350292206,
1.0818473100662231,
-0.21288852393627167,
-0.07888725399971008,
-0.6053206920623779,
0.29049769043922424,
-0.110260508954525,
0.3103586733341217,
-0.625167965888977,
-0.7463751435279846,
-0.7433380484580994,
0.41767409443855286,
0.0927782952785492,
-0.13912838697433472,
0.6123602390289307,
0.8026139140129089,
0.09134747833013535,
-0.27574747800827026,
0.29332610964775085,
-0.4866831302642822,
0.6350976824760437,
0.4862675666809082,
0.847928524017334,
-0.22966834902763367,
0.8509406447410583,
-0.39338356256484985,
-0.21480970084667206,
-0.08681601285934448,
-1.2731457948684692,
-0.795600414276123,
-0.173263281583786,
-0.4990743398666382,
-0.2783493995666504,
0.08842790871858597,
0.9626359343528748,
0.6453893780708313,
-0.8487575650215149,
-0.3336743414402008,
-0.3039429783821106,
-0.1150597557425499,
-0.3010024130344391,
-0.1745317280292511,
0.3547559678554535,
-0.24303674697875977,
-0.39329108595848083,
0.16929297149181366,
0.49786943197250366,
0.22438174486160278,
-0.08944068104028702,
-0.05461245775222778,
0.08639213442802429,
-0.0160968117415905,
0.4200252592563629,
0.14157308638095856,
-0.386570543050766,
-0.30801376700401306,
-0.15590566396713257,
-0.0193419698625803,
0.34397393465042114,
1.0378398895263672,
-0.3446037769317627,
0.33254513144493103,
0.22952042520046234,
0.9170610904693604,
0.17884734272956848,
-0.15097473561763763,
0.6542325615882874,
-0.8981876373291016,
0.30186450481414795,
0.0940961167216301,
0.7313656210899353,
0.2651841342449188,
-0.1936037838459015,
0.3604776859283447,
0.41059213876724243,
-0.3037564754486084,
-0.7448069453239441,
0.23878662288188934,
-0.49862462282180786,
-0.2654406428337097,
1.3424803018569946,
-0.43207883834838867,
0.016326775774359703,
-0.09047414362430573,
-0.33218955993652344,
-0.035132769495248795,
-0.4411194920539856,
0.7217942476272583,
0.6115136742591858,
0.21474015712738037,
-0.18156003952026367,
-0.35388249158859253,
0.26240068674087524,
0.2731805443763733,
-0.999358057975769,
0.32885316014289856,
0.6982128024101257,
0.34639424085617065,
0.16465888917446136,
0.5294520854949951,
-0.33797580003738403,
0.20580054819583893,
0.2255481630563736,
0.7356327176094055,
-0.39536744356155396,
-0.7059968113899231,
-0.19931355118751526,
0.30209222435951233,
0.5786482691764832,
-0.4621066749095917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15604v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15604v1
|
Hybrid LLM/Rule-based Approaches to Business Insights Generation from Structured Data
| 2024-04-24T02:42:24 | 2024-04-24T02:42:24 |
Aliaksei Vertsel, Mikhail Rumiantsau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the field of business data analysis, the ability to extract actionable
insights from vast and varied datasets is essential for informed
decision-making and maintaining a competitive edge. Traditional rule-based
systems, while reliable, often fall short when faced with the complexity and
dynamism of modern business data. Conversely, Artificial Intelligence (AI)
models, particularly Large Language Models (LLMs), offer significant potential
in pattern recognition and predictive analytics but can lack the precision
necessary for specific business applications. This paper explores the efficacy
of hybrid approaches that integrate the robustness of rule-based systems with
the adaptive power of LLMs in generating actionable business insights.
|
[
0.10080257803201675,
-1.0799752473831177,
0.5556116104125977,
0.10316095501184464,
-0.23881879448890686,
0.36487123370170593,
-0.28498485684394836,
-0.6762368679046631,
0.22538329660892487,
0.6103560328483582,
-0.7277592420578003,
-0.6520609855651855,
-0.12258782982826233,
0.1835024356842041,
-0.28543010354042053,
1.1111466884613037,
0.15179120004177094,
0.14889797568321228,
-0.2722269594669342,
-0.07935546338558197,
-0.7814724445343018,
-0.6443420648574829,
-0.478539377450943,
-0.4938523471355438,
0.047951340675354004,
0.24997103214263916,
0.7628909349441528,
0.7225642800331116,
0.4460966885089874,
0.2958468198776245,
0.19102343916893005,
0.6561692357063293,
-0.34377244114875793,
0.1201619952917099,
-0.2741081714630127,
-0.5973248481750488,
-0.6324506402015686,
-0.034347545355558395,
0.5950286388397217,
0.9697471857070923,
-0.5187912583351135,
0.07083019614219666,
-0.1452159583568573,
0.6090516448020935,
-0.323317289352417,
0.6423774361610413,
-0.7334884405136108,
-0.0033428589813411236,
-0.1533084511756897,
-0.3467034697532654,
-0.3898586928844452,
-0.3159674406051636,
0.18083611130714417,
-0.5122867226600647,
0.002412814414128661,
0.23661494255065918,
0.68561190366745,
0.21475517749786377,
-0.3220171630382538,
-0.5505198240280151,
-1.3118220567703247,
0.7272079586982727,
-0.7520380616188049,
0.13997851312160492,
0.03385785594582558,
0.39346736669540405,
-0.2712077796459198,
-0.7984744310379028,
-0.3170407712459564,
0.19539982080459595,
-0.34162166714668274,
0.2945614159107208,
-0.10771148651838303,
-0.01737232692539692,
0.22798912227153778,
0.4212563931941986,
-0.15986189246177673,
0.465300053358078,
-0.2479209154844284,
0.13754485547542572,
1.0763570070266724,
0.7046347856521606,
0.011836669407784939,
-0.06109653413295746,
-0.1318177729845047,
0.10043966770172119,
-0.49671193957328796,
0.26973769068717957,
0.20589132606983185,
0.6318792700767517,
-0.05777939409017563,
0.5250562429428101,
-0.23721987009048462,
0.8586035370826721,
0.1526746153831482,
-0.5132598280906677,
0.08944626897573471,
-0.6205893158912659,
-0.37493351101875305,
0.12858939170837402,
0.7120004892349243,
0.11313154548406601,
0.18963609635829926,
-0.42774322628974915,
-0.23181775212287903,
0.38323283195495605,
0.1564844846725464,
-0.49252593517303467,
-0.30472731590270996,
0.40388309955596924,
-0.72259122133255,
-0.4036141335964203,
0.3442339599132538,
-1.0092841386795044,
-0.35723260045051575,
-0.5417659878730774,
0.1761561781167984,
-0.38950401544570923,
-0.21868441998958588,
0.1289624720811844,
-0.23257975280284882,
0.7485522627830505,
0.373013973236084,
-0.8362101912498474,
0.5366635918617249,
0.8890955448150635,
0.7582269906997681,
-0.218036949634552,
0.15649038553237915,
-0.46211493015289307,
0.4699336290359497,
-0.5622148513793945,
0.6103662252426147,
-0.7358819246292114,
-0.5030645132064819,
-0.0057982574217021465,
-0.2860715687274933,
-0.35938432812690735,
-0.8053082227706909,
0.3917945325374603,
-0.6110029220581055,
0.011557264253497124,
0.02203264832496643,
-0.6369583010673523,
-0.3669818043708801,
0.22510434687137604,
-0.6664327383041382,
0.9844191670417786,
-0.021969502791762352,
-0.5654485821723938,
0.7635414004325867,
-0.9043691754341125,
-0.7760875821113586,
0.4335253834724426,
-0.46157220005989075,
-0.6926340460777283,
0.10373277962207794,
0.014074179343879223,
0.5670966506004333,
-0.1581331342458725,
0.34747666120529175,
-0.22706599533557892,
0.11439599096775055,
0.3065148591995239,
-0.04757257178425789,
0.5832012891769409,
-0.024549009278416634,
-0.5595513582229614,
0.18499112129211426,
-1.166430950164795,
-0.05158061534166336,
0.39624324440956116,
-0.5698701739311218,
-0.46378570795059204,
0.5885215401649475,
-0.22428026795387268,
0.0331595279276371,
0.18770349025726318,
-0.5067780017852783,
0.08260609954595566,
-0.2700715959072113,
0.3208223283290863,
0.9112625122070312,
0.04251993075013161,
0.11396447569131851,
-0.5405281782150269,
0.5356875061988831,
0.001412629266269505,
-0.10871268063783646,
-0.05571366101503372,
-0.4009929895401001,
-0.6168221235275269,
-0.5764123797416687,
0.3139907717704773,
0.904205858707428,
-0.43834787607192993,
0.7273539900779724,
-0.46424829959869385,
-0.6761796474456787,
-0.4597104787826538,
0.433241069316864,
-0.032525435090065,
0.5967076420783997,
0.13275249302387238,
-0.22757944464683533,
-0.7637332677841187,
-0.9049630761146545,
-0.39430472254753113,
0.08221329748630524,
0.2387373149394989,
0.6398035883903503,
0.39976850152015686,
-0.28571727871894836,
1.0617918968200684,
-0.5024611353874207,
-0.1021718755364418,
-0.7308431267738342,
-0.11179760098457336,
0.5969152450561523,
0.11117216944694519,
0.3927361071109772,
-1.1218522787094116,
-0.2946412265300751,
0.2625320553779602,
-0.9206106662750244,
0.07805567234754562,
-0.32146528363227844,
-0.06560875475406647,
0.14533226191997528,
0.28795692324638367,
-0.45867061614990234,
0.5535862445831299,
0.2020406574010849,
-0.30454713106155396,
0.6294468641281128,
-0.1400379240512848,
-0.22195518016815186,
-1.16050124168396,
0.11563117802143097,
0.2232256531715393,
-0.5046163201332092,
-0.845891535282135,
-0.4460827112197876,
-0.042430486530065536,
-0.0913083404302597,
0.1981654316186905,
0.039587754756212234,
-0.44245901703834534,
-0.3074510395526886,
-0.063198521733284,
-0.2785381078720093,
0.05101083591580391,
0.33527979254722595,
0.3021697402000427,
0.6111965775489807,
0.32888224720954895,
-0.8318839073181152,
0.7422426342964172,
0.4621393382549286,
-0.5817704796791077,
0.4802812337875366,
-0.6119549870491028,
0.08093202859163284,
0.022759297862648964,
0.28377869725227356,
-0.8401296734809875,
-0.4621577560901642,
-0.021758023649454117,
-0.19663025438785553,
0.4467777907848358,
0.13443751633167267,
-0.7165603637695312,
-0.28067147731781006,
-0.21446919441223145,
0.21005423367023468,
0.6259483098983765,
-0.609067976474762,
1.1364340782165527,
0.4065176248550415,
-0.3176015019416809,
-0.09716156125068665,
-0.7248386740684509,
0.14131388068199158,
-0.3878486752510071,
-0.8871857523918152,
0.2978108823299408,
0.10985979437828064,
-0.8002106547355652,
0.011149534955620766,
0.028995288535952568,
0.23152290284633636,
0.3150460720062256,
0.20202802121639252,
0.5266380906105042,
-0.318876713514328,
-0.52251136302948,
-0.14664936065673828,
0.13270260393619537,
0.3833857476711273,
-0.31999823451042175,
0.4307619333267212,
-0.026066424325108528,
-0.09130208939313889,
-0.6524484753608704,
0.5587281584739685,
0.957741916179657,
-0.318611741065979,
1.0218583345413208,
-0.08262939751148224,
-0.4268180727958679,
-0.6629235148429871,
-0.3526853322982788,
-0.031882863491773605,
-0.4813835620880127,
0.19603915512561798,
-0.12390787899494171,
-0.2369924932718277,
0.5878787040710449,
-0.4024125039577484,
0.2568034827709198,
0.34366095066070557,
0.9047780632972717,
-0.03557422757148743,
1.1077920198440552,
0.8813071846961975,
-0.13567103445529938,
0.5437880158424377,
-0.2624123990535736,
0.7074136734008789,
-0.36769962310791016,
-0.7923057675361633,
-0.49112385511398315,
-0.2712308466434479,
-0.7324212789535522,
0.061766788363456726,
0.5581117868423462,
-0.253213107585907,
0.410945862531662,
-0.1110253781080246,
0.016801981255412102,
0.20992469787597656,
0.8095433712005615,
0.27152225375175476,
0.3596456050872803,
-0.1933659166097641,
0.14199134707450867,
0.23438453674316406,
-0.8183545470237732,
-0.38825294375419617,
0.9478391408920288,
0.21998243033885956,
0.8657090067863464,
0.2215106189250946,
0.3466629981994629,
0.49032872915267944,
-0.16587406396865845,
-0.9936646819114685,
0.3852563202381134,
-0.07060668617486954,
-0.5139320492744446,
-0.16130848228931427,
-0.558573842048645,
-0.6969718933105469,
-0.00676922220736742,
-0.507662296295166,
-0.37499669194221497,
0.19533413648605347,
0.054169267416000366,
-0.46796029806137085,
0.43393874168395996,
-0.8065409064292908,
0.47309622168540955,
-0.4378007650375366,
-0.5134618282318115,
-0.06467660516500473,
-0.5250686407089233,
0.3383080065250397,
-0.28845879435539246,
0.4881640076637268,
0.20441816747188568,
0.05761627107858658,
0.813726544380188,
-0.6120479106903076,
0.9358447194099426,
0.06193738803267479,
-0.09446648508310318,
0.06724928319454193,
0.04686521738767624,
0.784494936466217,
-0.17870303988456726,
-0.11819582432508469,
0.17229297757148743,
-0.17882274091243744,
-0.38444051146507263,
-0.7996333837509155,
0.13424013555049896,
-0.524646520614624,
-0.5450518131256104,
-0.22780372202396393,
-0.7324745655059814,
-0.48638463020324707,
0.034406550228595734,
0.09513798356056213,
0.37868964672088623,
-0.10654910653829575,
0.23107370734214783,
0.5491911768913269,
0.1006816178560257,
0.5396761298179626,
0.5287654399871826,
0.24407228827476501,
-0.32909443974494934,
0.717581033706665,
0.1942499727010727,
0.10216743499040604,
0.2500576972961426,
0.2390211671590805,
-0.3329721689224243,
-0.8876820802688599,
-0.24885612726211548,
0.308504581451416,
-0.3570680320262909,
-0.3622855842113495,
-0.25347304344177246,
-0.15725989639759064,
-0.4724693298339844,
-0.21831101179122925,
-0.058590374886989594,
-0.12064658850431442,
-0.2778891921043396,
-0.23014795780181885,
0.40397363901138306,
1.0873826742172241,
-0.07390344142913818,
-0.1351727992296219,
-0.7372512817382812,
0.2251238226890564,
0.21465106308460236,
0.2392835021018982,
-0.1699136346578598,
0.04976211115717888,
-0.4761359691619873,
0.08185315132141113,
-0.0035522643011063337,
-0.7197980284690857,
0.5199082493782043,
0.24527214467525482,
0.7464562058448792,
0.48482808470726013,
-0.07878083735704422,
0.45086589455604553,
-0.3238268196582794,
0.6358873248100281,
-0.0418240912258625,
-0.770054817199707,
0.8208667039871216,
-0.6991057395935059,
-0.3310675621032715,
0.3297116756439209,
0.3911738097667694,
-0.13509300351142883,
0.0765283852815628,
-0.5528357028961182,
-0.8012926578521729,
0.800370454788208,
0.044216617941856384,
-0.009321809746325016,
0.38134992122650146,
0.5473623871803284,
0.4066050946712494,
0.4405974745750427,
-0.4717862010002136,
-0.12206395715475082,
0.10173829644918442,
-0.5589655637741089,
-0.04728413745760918,
0.02599041536450386,
-0.12556418776512146,
-0.20126476883888245,
0.6838251352310181,
-0.20861738920211792,
-0.15187780559062958,
0.020969083532691002,
0.0562283881008625,
0.04352623596787453,
0.05846394971013069,
0.2928873896598816,
1.026416540145874,
-0.20246511697769165,
-0.3263808786869049,
-0.060138020664453506,
-0.36756017804145813,
-0.226751908659935,
0.01985323615372181,
-0.29789024591445923,
-0.16251300275325775,
0.39505788683891296,
0.7308060526847839,
-0.20207791030406952,
-0.8951014280319214,
0.2836705148220062,
0.16713665425777435,
-0.4026739001274109,
-0.27219316363334656,
0.25892505049705505,
-0.3035447895526886,
0.48522400856018066,
0.28245416283607483,
-0.25882643461227417,
0.08407521992921829,
-0.9465280175209045,
-0.07745380699634552,
0.6020911931991577,
0.13365191221237183,
-0.3343588411808014,
0.350197434425354,
0.275484174489975,
-0.40497684478759766,
0.5579213500022888,
0.46801629662513733,
-0.5521498322486877,
0.58055579662323,
0.6761708855628967,
0.5784069895744324,
0.04161320626735687,
-0.027249710634350777,
-0.21850034594535828,
0.044830478727817535,
0.19376321136951447,
0.27053189277648926,
-0.11429945379495621,
-0.9465163350105286,
-0.32530510425567627,
-0.6275283694267273,
-0.6792520880699158,
0.279732346534729,
-0.862992525100708,
0.20581616461277008,
-0.9290264844894409,
0.17183394730091095,
0.2572358250617981,
0.26660826802253723,
-0.5053771734237671,
0.2578856647014618,
0.029100652784109116,
0.9511960744857788,
-0.8388410806655884,
0.41624221205711365,
0.6701836585998535,
-0.15554213523864746,
-0.8461617231369019,
-0.23118706047534943,
0.06084197387099266,
-0.8743959665298462,
0.31330588459968567,
-0.04043487831950188,
-0.25295233726501465,
-0.14107510447502136,
-0.6471350193023682,
-0.4458017349243164,
1.2075762748718262,
0.04647716134786606,
-0.42790287733078003,
-0.09031202644109726,
0.15291529893875122,
0.4501557946205139,
-0.5772028565406799,
-0.44601985812187195,
1.196528673171997,
0.3968048691749573,
0.05225775018334389,
-0.7407441735267639,
-0.15745578706264496,
-0.3289710283279419,
-0.06949727982282639,
0.3998027741909027,
-0.8544039130210876,
0.5250318646430969,
-0.0994001105427742,
-0.09456457942724228,
-0.15491263568401337,
0.6533024311065674,
0.1123279333114624,
0.5659661293029785,
0.3323698937892914,
0.5526916980743408,
1.082555890083313,
0.15591537952423096,
0.9761586785316467,
-0.09413721412420273,
0.06775583326816559,
0.8623180985450745,
-0.46506765484809875,
0.8850565552711487,
0.038671959191560745,
-0.13694611191749573,
1.1237763166427612,
0.6707468628883362,
-0.4388815760612488,
0.4500969350337982,
-0.05859823152422905,
-0.16321824491024017,
-0.29791784286499023,
-0.0713106170296669,
0.047075942158699036,
0.8775719404220581,
0.7776035666465759,
-0.2966618835926056,
0.12987349927425385,
-0.4215790331363678,
0.04174237325787544,
0.263784795999527,
-0.6399818062782288,
1.3017268180847168,
-0.1441202014684677,
-0.4763472080230713,
0.08821634203195572,
0.10908448696136475,
0.6054401993751526,
-0.8127564787864685,
-0.10407774895429611,
-0.09818119555711746,
0.3053176999092102,
-0.3863517940044403,
-0.5994833111763,
0.34935262799263,
0.18108391761779785,
-0.4325367212295532,
-0.2450413703918457,
0.7097543478012085,
0.037916481494903564,
-0.6556143164634705,
0.2887658178806305,
0.4837614893913269,
-0.23399530351161957,
0.3233696222305298,
-0.5130258202552795,
-0.2914433777332306,
-0.01959013007581234,
0.14482364058494568,
0.013414942659437656,
0.507057249546051,
-0.0225526150316,
0.5032927989959717,
0.8594934940338135,
0.3048844635486603,
0.24447369575500488,
-0.2715582847595215,
0.8610047698020935,
-0.8746848702430725,
-0.7328600883483887,
-0.9689420461654663,
0.40312957763671875,
-0.2023693025112152,
0.11770989745855331,
0.8169748783111572,
0.6859301328659058,
0.5747345089912415,
0.2967747747898102,
1.2122997045516968,
0.1356063038110733,
0.5863282084465027,
-0.9412136673927307,
0.4174775779247284,
-0.315807968378067,
0.23621058464050293,
-0.23860985040664673,
-0.589337944984436,
-0.27562272548675537,
0.22521235048770905,
-0.4938376247882843,
0.13816235959529877,
0.25369763374328613,
0.6051380634307861,
-0.1841059923171997,
0.36399081349372864,
0.195602685213089,
0.41191962361335754,
0.41948968172073364,
0.35455676913261414,
0.7255911827087402,
0.0025971063878387213,
0.4073089361190796,
0.004567756317555904,
-0.4663359522819519,
-0.4493958055973053,
-0.7161272168159485,
-0.8088269233703613,
-0.3069414794445038,
-0.25534170866012573,
-0.600896418094635,
-0.2984068691730499,
0.7733321189880371,
0.8093425631523132,
-0.8060824871063232,
-0.3298467695713043,
-0.26090821623802185,
0.046541985124349594,
-0.18009555339813232,
-0.33562755584716797,
0.30670809745788574,
-0.23978093266487122,
-0.439614474773407,
0.6009392738342285,
0.5228918194770813,
0.24139350652694702,
-0.058131083846092224,
0.06175774708390236,
-0.11369512975215912,
0.6215594410896301,
0.5635518431663513,
0.3219839036464691,
-0.1919037252664566,
0.12456026673316956,
-0.09018649160861969,
0.2854979634284973,
0.16525132954120636,
1.014811635017395,
-0.7259549498558044,
0.016008732840418816,
0.3961872160434723,
0.8934956789016724,
0.3323172926902771,
0.3468557894229889,
0.7784932255744934,
-0.4326660633087158,
0.1012437716126442,
0.29512515664100647,
0.4400465786457062,
0.32357507944107056,
-0.7238922715187073,
0.3499545156955719,
0.5766450762748718,
-0.29005134105682373,
-0.7081023454666138,
0.32440385222435,
-0.9776269793510437,
-0.3696686327457428,
1.2136075496673584,
0.07877958565950394,
-0.6431647539138794,
-0.2614569664001465,
0.05327407643198967,
-0.1779758781194687,
-0.3118518590927124,
0.5616627931594849,
0.47457650303840637,
-0.7164183259010315,
0.3058536946773529,
-0.1756453812122345,
0.3455052077770233,
0.1403142809867859,
-1.1026787757873535,
0.2016526609659195,
0.7109130024909973,
0.2514069974422455,
0.08143848180770874,
0.20834888517856598,
0.04044588282704353,
0.027795590460300446,
0.04779129847884178,
-0.6946824193000793,
-0.07375410199165344,
-0.4471839964389801,
-0.2519190013408661,
0.25964727997779846,
-0.10770223289728165,
-0.21364443004131317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15592v1
|
ImplicitAVE: An Open-Source Dataset and Multimodal LLMs Benchmark for Implicit Attribute Value Extraction
| 2024-04-24T01:54:40 | 2024-04-24T01:54:40 |
Henry Peng Zou, Vinay Samuel, Yue Zhou, Weizhi Zhang, Liancheng Fang, Zihe Song, Philip S. Yu, Cornelia Caragea
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Existing datasets for attribute value extraction (AVE) predominantly focus on
explicit attribute values while neglecting the implicit ones, lack product
images, are often not publicly available, and lack an in-depth human inspection
across diverse domains. To address these limitations, we present ImplicitAVE,
the first, publicly available multimodal dataset for implicit attribute value
extraction. ImplicitAVE, sourced from the MAVE dataset, is carefully curated
and expanded to include implicit AVE and multimodality, resulting in a refined
dataset of 68k training and 1.6k testing data across five domains. We also
explore the application of multimodal large language models (MLLMs) to implicit
AVE, establishing a comprehensive benchmark for MLLMs on the ImplicitAVE
dataset. Six recent MLLMs with eleven variants are evaluated across diverse
settings, revealing that implicit value extraction remains a challenging task
for MLLMs. The contributions of this work include the development and release
of ImplicitAVE, and the exploration and benchmarking of various MLLMs for
implicit AVE, providing valuable insights and potential future research
directions. Dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/HenryPengZou/ImplicitAVE
|
[
-0.2148890644311905,
-0.5310901999473572,
0.44503188133239746,
0.3264937698841095,
0.3306480944156647,
-0.08319052308797836,
-0.1575620472431183,
-0.6882530450820923,
-0.2875271737575531,
0.17465394735336304,
-0.9196559190750122,
-0.5881069302558899,
-0.6014156341552734,
0.017094368115067482,
-0.22177930176258087,
0.7562092542648315,
-0.016684677451848984,
0.0020299830939620733,
-0.4211463928222656,
-0.4883403182029724,
-0.20174919068813324,
-0.2822383940219879,
-0.48366889357566833,
0.45724594593048096,
0.820636510848999,
0.3993101119995117,
0.36084479093551636,
0.2514917552471161,
0.5620875358581543,
0.30812448263168335,
0.33819708228111267,
0.4537127614021301,
-0.3366239070892334,
0.5164547562599182,
-0.021536555141210556,
0.18223313987255096,
-0.7065063118934631,
0.4642706513404846,
0.7244294285774231,
0.24518658220767975,
0.2998746633529663,
0.46689003705978394,
-0.1920367330312729,
0.45851945877075195,
-1.1438614130020142,
0.39578911662101746,
-0.738722562789917,
-0.15438410639762878,
-0.1798209249973297,
0.29159194231033325,
-0.14661720395088196,
-0.698265790939331,
0.16585791110992432,
-0.665623128414154,
0.023035598918795586,
0.19321009516716003,
0.8678995370864868,
0.2659529745578766,
-0.5532880425453186,
-0.24093440175056458,
-0.5936478972434998,
0.9570595026016235,
-0.2688063681125641,
0.9669373631477356,
0.38799914717674255,
0.44076618552207947,
0.15180142223834991,
-0.8304072022438049,
-0.6768917441368103,
-0.4003843069076538,
0.06530334055423737,
-0.04660520330071449,
-0.22254949808120728,
-0.1951369047164917,
0.17007175087928772,
0.3063378632068634,
-0.3407164216041565,
0.032718025147914886,
-0.4161822199821472,
-0.15578266978263855,
0.6217663288116455,
-0.054733045399188995,
0.2779862880706787,
-0.03637422248721123,
-0.6501585841178894,
-0.28961068391799927,
-0.7396692037582397,
0.27600154280662537,
0.04323025420308113,
0.3360554277896881,
0.008336798287928104,
0.7878056168556213,
-0.26083844900131226,
0.039298564195632935,
-0.45839428901672363,
-0.2819121181964874,
0.6026886701583862,
-0.3389489948749542,
-0.16692276298999786,
-0.23736999928951263,
0.7514598965644836,
0.2726442515850067,
0.39523717761039734,
-0.19398275017738342,
-0.2656158208847046,
-0.1320345252752304,
0.057562511414289474,
-0.6814236044883728,
0.10891139507293701,
0.28187036514282227,
-0.16621790826320648,
-0.16441710293293,
-0.1822626143693924,
-1.050646424293518,
-0.5188850164413452,
-0.48186981678009033,
0.10724397748708725,
-0.22508475184440613,
-0.3932175934314728,
-0.28580525517463684,
-0.14979910850524902,
0.47911104559898376,
0.4857605993747711,
-0.732917070388794,
0.25916075706481934,
0.52679443359375,
0.8747978806495667,
-0.525252640247345,
-0.26792556047439575,
-0.5422491431236267,
0.17990879714488983,
0.029091505333781242,
0.906501293182373,
-0.7002082467079163,
-0.28433749079704285,
-0.0688687413930893,
0.07430682331323624,
0.21021701395511627,
-0.2513563334941864,
0.8167336583137512,
-0.4410964250564575,
-0.11396653205156326,
-0.2664565443992615,
-0.06436195224523544,
-0.07137662172317505,
0.2715968191623688,
-1.0257617235183716,
1.5096770524978638,
0.07379422336816788,
-0.09982354938983917,
0.6178942322731018,
-0.7168827056884766,
-0.15460260212421417,
-0.015116761438548565,
-0.3045777678489685,
-0.4635547399520874,
0.2151564359664917,
0.5484935641288757,
0.40322864055633545,
-0.6738080978393555,
-0.12559226155281067,
-0.6654769778251648,
0.1449417918920517,
0.3789431154727936,
-0.7854142785072327,
0.5674611330032349,
0.13329830765724182,
-0.04953949525952339,
0.11842761188745499,
-0.8983424305915833,
0.26508820056915283,
0.23826716840267181,
-0.0683402270078659,
-0.48990270495414734,
-0.12023542821407318,
0.2809939682483673,
0.591886043548584,
0.3218858242034912,
-0.720557689666748,
0.46601906418800354,
0.23283374309539795,
-0.018995992839336395,
1.384324550628662,
-0.3622627258300781,
0.3746276795864105,
0.09594990313053131,
0.35286208987236023,
-0.2430407851934433,
0.35233885049819946,
0.06034357100725174,
-0.1625315397977829,
-0.5340879559516907,
-1.099472165107727,
0.12618954479694366,
0.32882019877433777,
-0.28615865111351013,
-0.25757795572280884,
-0.5052649974822998,
-0.2962936460971832,
-0.9614802002906799,
0.3063414990901947,
0.41995346546173096,
0.45796576142311096,
0.517138659954071,
0.250821053981781,
-0.32551848888397217,
-1.0952813625335693,
-0.1235051155090332,
0.0656886175274849,
-0.01723029650747776,
0.6526377201080322,
0.7231666445732117,
-0.12022838741540909,
1.1198437213897705,
-0.8190704584121704,
-0.5852851271629333,
0.14575371146202087,
0.42957374453544617,
-0.277788370847702,
0.5569725036621094,
0.5051783919334412,
-0.8445355296134949,
-0.22114330530166626,
-0.05429106950759888,
-0.7612980008125305,
-0.2597208023071289,
0.29995134472846985,
-0.35659968852996826,
0.12918484210968018,
0.3607301115989685,
-0.5724170804023743,
0.28243139386177063,
0.6584154367446899,
-0.06973637640476227,
0.5221786499023438,
0.012873530387878418,
0.3025721311569214,
-0.6514824032783508,
0.3529471457004547,
0.1510254144668579,
-0.12356878817081451,
-0.22074761986732483,
-0.05344798043370247,
0.23606687784194946,
0.06478378921747208,
-0.8659712672233582,
0.9522574543952942,
-0.7511898279190063,
-0.31321072578430176,
0.07735574245452881,
-0.042060837149620056,
0.021661220118403435,
0.7351149916648865,
0.14904773235321045,
1.0569730997085571,
0.30831047892570496,
-0.5482147336006165,
0.6309001445770264,
0.2877342402935028,
-0.4208161234855652,
0.7672411799430847,
-0.6620826721191406,
0.4965479373931885,
-0.2832542955875397,
-0.0613643117249012,
-1.007673740386963,
-0.10020523518323898,
0.13257689774036407,
-0.29291510581970215,
0.0030670813284814358,
-0.2838229238986969,
-0.42526480555534363,
0.15070782601833344,
-0.5096248984336853,
0.4773266017436981,
0.4571688175201416,
-0.4914247989654541,
0.9044387340545654,
0.5877977013587952,
-0.4281317889690399,
-0.8503870964050293,
-0.2806948125362396,
-0.2568904459476471,
-0.11594142764806747,
-0.4887729287147522,
0.05030622333288193,
-0.33413514494895935,
-0.2859955132007599,
0.08542649447917938,
-0.27460727095603943,
-0.27848124504089355,
0.06261749565601349,
0.5088210105895996,
0.33960893750190735,
-0.10061006247997284,
0.20049478113651276,
0.0791172981262207,
-0.15974414348602295,
0.03964720293879509,
-0.01089935190975666,
0.1419939249753952,
-0.31486383080482483,
-0.47012418508529663,
0.14362069964408875,
0.507736086845398,
0.6654117107391357,
-0.5821457505226135,
0.5462159514427185,
0.6868489980697632,
-0.4207080602645874,
-0.35168877243995667,
-0.6912122964859009,
0.13978564739227295,
-0.4478309452533722,
0.2003721296787262,
-0.6499781608581543,
-0.6978827118873596,
0.2777765095233917,
-0.3333103060722351,
0.22624313831329346,
0.44694626331329346,
0.29400700330734253,
-0.21533505618572235,
1.2049874067306519,
0.6623521447181702,
0.023538561537861824,
0.23495614528656006,
-0.1406250298023224,
-0.5470181107521057,
-0.9030371308326721,
-0.5768648386001587,
-0.7401995062828064,
-0.16830141842365265,
-0.2658706307411194,
-0.3935798704624176,
0.54116290807724,
-0.30427372455596924,
-0.034047625958919525,
-0.22029198706150055,
-0.09913783520460129,
0.41762253642082214,
0.5279400944709778,
0.2145019769668579,
0.3768913745880127,
0.03392857313156128,
0.075246162712574,
-0.32979992032051086,
0.07613984495401382,
-0.2876557409763336,
1.197088599205017,
0.2219812422990799,
0.814876139163971,
0.45301148295402527,
-0.2512384355068207,
0.5851671099662781,
0.5311152935028076,
-0.6843929886817932,
0.4417383074760437,
0.13548962771892548,
-0.6712729930877686,
-0.2273670732975006,
-0.3257010579109192,
-0.7768328189849854,
0.35363513231277466,
-0.4399142861366272,
-0.5507336258888245,
0.35999104380607605,
0.03399881720542908,
-0.006553524639457464,
-0.06921974569559097,
-0.4948136806488037,
0.8509999513626099,
-0.5813919901847839,
-0.7718007564544678,
0.1625138819217682,
-0.5497308373451233,
0.37936148047447205,
-0.10617086291313171,
0.12262441962957382,
-0.7494345307350159,
-0.24717678129673004,
0.3024451732635498,
-0.12107755243778229,
0.49021482467651367,
-0.04245317354798317,
-0.3504975736141205,
-0.21949635446071625,
-0.00015528603398706764,
0.610784649848938,
-0.02300167642533779,
-0.02169518917798996,
0.4071747958660126,
-0.4411543011665344,
-0.22119034826755524,
-0.7023774981498718,
0.8900482654571533,
-0.7202805280685425,
-0.18975353240966797,
-0.6449951529502869,
-0.4985955059528351,
-0.4526069760322571,
0.2327011674642563,
-0.2715054750442505,
0.34570467472076416,
-0.4477349519729614,
0.16183091700077057,
0.8257849216461182,
-0.12186942249536514,
0.39918240904808044,
0.6636311411857605,
-0.013781344518065453,
-0.49046364426612854,
0.9917851686477661,
-0.069570392370224,
0.21040093898773193,
0.2740791141986847,
0.005782944615930319,
-0.6917493343353271,
-0.29310646653175354,
-0.3563863933086395,
-0.007185806520283222,
-0.8613074421882629,
-0.10327418893575668,
-0.8059077262878418,
-0.02526143193244934,
-0.7423919439315796,
0.015910645946860313,
-0.5822960138320923,
-0.3469184935092926,
0.16299988329410553,
-0.20778164267539978,
0.6651688814163208,
0.5996775031089783,
-0.13353371620178223,
-0.16127634048461914,
-0.6247686743736267,
0.607877254486084,
0.5622745752334595,
0.4729729890823364,
-0.3238176703453064,
0.05159655213356018,
0.03650978207588196,
-0.001410829252563417,
0.16543500125408173,
-0.694136917591095,
0.4840167760848999,
0.36293768882751465,
0.8231397271156311,
0.23907101154327393,
-0.025869593024253845,
0.7014118432998657,
-0.41665172576904297,
0.5976501703262329,
-0.14780350029468536,
-0.8106345534324646,
0.5522014498710632,
-0.025102974846959114,
0.12978921830654144,
0.8584203720092773,
0.6218884587287903,
-0.4836137294769287,
-0.03663628175854683,
-0.17700697481632233,
-1.0323423147201538,
0.7435716390609741,
0.38199546933174133,
-0.08184492588043213,
0.22875897586345673,
-0.14739413559436798,
0.4243090748786926,
0.4827587306499481,
-0.8855902552604675,
-0.3373258113861084,
-0.11232946068048477,
-0.3424479365348816,
-0.06176342815160751,
-0.23559832572937012,
-0.10375920683145523,
-0.3452072739601135,
0.5731948018074036,
-0.19754566252231598,
0.2168939709663391,
0.09941323101520538,
-0.6477549076080322,
0.2602333724498749,
0.29810240864753723,
0.6268589496612549,
0.25456902384757996,
-0.5404676795005798,
0.2400205284357071,
0.1575138121843338,
-0.6214144825935364,
0.09014303982257843,
0.21531514823436737,
0.03159794956445694,
-0.24626070261001587,
0.09377316385507584,
0.7014463543891907,
0.11743476986885071,
-0.8881917595863342,
0.6993967890739441,
-0.19859613478183746,
0.11709882318973541,
-0.5356937050819397,
-0.2687700390815735,
-0.4003344476222992,
0.19165410101413727,
0.37600547075271606,
-0.001018822891637683,
0.29066202044487,
-0.2623929977416992,
0.11205566674470901,
0.6520320177078247,
-0.45712724328041077,
-0.2924093008041382,
0.7749163508415222,
0.4595213532447815,
0.3756919205188751,
0.9020458459854126,
0.20167556405067444,
-0.03664536029100418,
0.3969225287437439,
0.2554183006286621,
1.0592068433761597,
-0.12568335235118866,
0.073947973549366,
0.23521241545677185,
0.5121169686317444,
0.1664719581604004,
0.19696319103240967,
-0.28315722942352295,
-0.6596910357475281,
-0.31366467475891113,
-0.6256496906280518,
-0.333266019821167,
0.37199991941452026,
-0.4107414186000824,
0.34019291400909424,
-0.39908093214035034,
0.07162515074014664,
-0.08768538385629654,
-0.35925957560539246,
-0.8042196035385132,
0.27523937821388245,
0.30581942200660706,
0.7857296466827393,
-0.8013339042663574,
0.6741001605987549,
0.45095011591911316,
-0.8303102850914001,
-0.30851849913597107,
-0.2686464786529541,
0.29350292682647705,
-0.9448258876800537,
1.1876323223114014,
0.09595561772584915,
-0.6901477575302124,
-0.14786598086357117,
-0.8160691857337952,
-1.0720722675323486,
1.1279410123825073,
0.4102398157119751,
0.1115778386592865,
-0.10423952341079712,
0.26808735728263855,
0.047318749129772186,
-0.2783951759338379,
0.6296616792678833,
0.4247552454471588,
0.7909401059150696,
0.2621757686138153,
-0.5868849754333496,
0.029089532792568207,
-0.6073083281517029,
-0.051125284284353256,
0.0726047083735466,
-0.5051267147064209,
0.9315010905265808,
0.0632854476571083,
-0.24955378472805023,
-0.16365399956703186,
0.8026519417762756,
0.27296003699302673,
0.17349807918071747,
0.461764931678772,
0.261094868183136,
0.6209861040115356,
-0.2595950663089752,
0.9941813349723816,
0.10360687971115112,
0.13850750029087067,
1.0760409832000732,
-0.5947350263595581,
0.723344624042511,
0.18265420198440552,
0.0567106157541275,
0.22155290842056274,
0.2005307376384735,
0.14684288203716278,
0.6343258619308472,
-0.18804654479026794,
-0.4610501825809479,
-0.1817564219236374,
-0.308725506067276,
-0.4058036804199219,
0.4686068594455719,
0.6020345091819763,
-0.16111603379249573,
-0.1517811268568039,
0.11691271513700485,
0.25998353958129883,
-0.3699549436569214,
-0.3806951642036438,
0.7889279723167419,
-0.16954930126667023,
-0.3206736743450165,
0.3061509132385254,
-0.27598199248313904,
0.5553439855575562,
-1.0015984773635864,
-0.40614739060401917,
-0.3183555006980896,
0.20265674591064453,
-0.048726197332143784,
-0.6470661163330078,
-0.19268140196800232,
0.10561906546354294,
-0.10328030586242676,
-0.6463441252708435,
0.7468958497047424,
-0.5302016139030457,
-0.6387455463409424,
0.18663981556892395,
0.5713945627212524,
-0.05947934836149216,
-0.307343065738678,
-0.690104067325592,
0.11437634378671646,
-0.44429701566696167,
-0.5291875600814819,
0.17149223387241364,
0.32801783084869385,
-0.2390861064195633,
0.8420441150665283,
0.9189092516899109,
0.06696845591068268,
0.2745320498943329,
-0.12697090208530426,
0.8675899505615234,
-0.6480869054794312,
0.02390451543033123,
-0.7596458196640015,
0.8873510956764221,
-0.39985817670822144,
-0.7044268250465393,
0.9789651036262512,
0.6783431172370911,
0.6555485725402832,
-0.0986938327550888,
0.962687075138092,
0.0008714477880857885,
0.38047653436660767,
-0.7460522651672363,
0.5788108706474304,
-0.8769811391830444,
-0.03869667276740074,
-0.5332909822463989,
-0.7080374360084534,
-0.026357822120189667,
0.372734397649765,
0.03145523741841316,
0.11245210468769073,
0.6662495136260986,
0.7731617093086243,
-0.24388368427753448,
-0.2577889561653137,
0.08901569247245789,
0.1492650955915451,
0.36841756105422974,
0.2873438000679016,
1.0245208740234375,
-0.23157846927642822,
0.5451750159263611,
-0.008862628601491451,
-0.2963007688522339,
-0.04163471609354019,
-1.142518162727356,
-0.444697767496109,
-0.8071446418762207,
-0.20169363915920258,
-0.20600125193595886,
0.135858416557312,
1.0344442129135132,
0.7988463044166565,
-0.6645296216011047,
0.030131252482533455,
0.4110693037509918,
0.15739302337169647,
-0.4799128472805023,
-0.1721542626619339,
0.3543582260608673,
-0.039316754788160324,
-1.1347633600234985,
0.6576538681983948,
0.1576870083808899,
0.15075315535068512,
-0.3266158998012543,
0.07401075959205627,
-0.420753538608551,
0.1312025636434555,
0.7883903980255127,
0.44872498512268066,
-0.40205585956573486,
-0.2049887776374817,
0.14961498975753784,
-0.33748555183410645,
0.05127483233809471,
0.8337211608886719,
-0.7175176739692688,
0.23748162388801575,
0.43950724601745605,
0.5380052924156189,
0.4908428192138672,
-0.09636491537094116,
0.5744518041610718,
-1.1635698080062866,
0.1633240282535553,
0.11874399334192276,
0.2874445617198944,
0.029994482174515724,
-0.25586432218551636,
0.6284639835357666,
0.2460169494152069,
-0.24932651221752167,
-0.8322874903678894,
0.3042484223842621,
-1.2103952169418335,
-0.3085225522518158,
1.3079768419265747,
-0.06598395109176636,
-0.26549163460731506,
-0.2080129086971283,
-0.3557220995426178,
-0.18399599194526672,
-0.8509496450424194,
0.27697744965553284,
0.4202304184436798,
0.06855127215385437,
-0.3631161153316498,
-0.6616404056549072,
0.7103689908981323,
-0.029607541859149933,
-1.2051632404327393,
0.22385403513908386,
0.9882739782333374,
0.19359982013702393,
-0.18955592811107635,
0.7285757660865784,
-0.217295840382576,
0.11349653452634811,
-0.16751782596111298,
0.5556101202964783,
-0.4705110192298889,
-0.5477439165115356,
-0.3021925091743469,
0.44992202520370483,
-0.11779603362083435,
-0.17177462577819824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15588v1
|
Minimal Evidence Group Identification for Claim Verification
| 2024-04-24T01:44:09 | 2024-04-24T01:44:09 |
Xiangci Li, Sihao Chen, Rajvi Kapadia, Jessica Ouyang, Fan Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Claim verification in real-world settings (e.g. against a large collection of
candidate evidences retrieved from the web) typically requires identifying and
aggregating a complete set of evidence pieces that collectively provide full
support to the claim. The problem becomes particularly challenging when there
exists distinct sets of evidence that could be used to verify the claim from
different perspectives. In this paper, we formally define and study the problem
of identifying such minimal evidence groups (MEGs) for claim verification. We
show that MEG identification can be reduced from Set Cover problem, based on
entailment inference of whether a given evidence group provides full/partial
support to a claim. Our proposed approach achieves 18.4% and 34.8% absolute
improvements on the WiCE and SciFact datasets over LLM prompting. Finally, we
demonstrate the benefits of MEGs in downstream applications such as claim
generation.
|
[
-0.49966052174568176,
-0.4423299729824066,
0.6509237885475159,
-0.002329899463802576,
0.0033941823057830334,
0.03709324449300766,
0.13722804188728333,
-0.5591673851013184,
0.3094625473022461,
0.2362934947013855,
-0.7389454245567322,
-0.33898016810417175,
-0.6549012660980225,
0.35731184482574463,
-0.17114399373531342,
0.7097040414810181,
-0.02666986547410488,
-0.2360364943742752,
-0.3848992884159088,
-0.2523457109928131,
-0.32286742329597473,
-0.06281580775976181,
-0.4668937623500824,
-0.45274773240089417,
0.696486234664917,
0.6130402684211731,
0.24060110747814178,
0.665608823299408,
0.4066691994667053,
0.2685999274253845,
-0.19260606169700623,
0.6438796520233154,
-0.12119301408529282,
-0.4397510290145874,
0.02039784938097,
-0.42100080847740173,
-0.4191177189350128,
0.09008629620075226,
0.4856480062007904,
0.9015313386917114,
-0.02470751851797104,
0.5045538544654846,
-0.014531904831528664,
0.399177223443985,
-1.1849013566970825,
-0.2379501312971115,
-0.7885956168174744,
0.284639447927475,
-0.1460588574409485,
-0.20540201663970947,
-0.8370306491851807,
-0.2576720416545868,
0.11162687093019485,
-0.7164208292961121,
0.6625078916549683,
0.21641939878463745,
1.29094660282135,
-0.08420401811599731,
-0.7591871023178101,
-0.023810837417840958,
-0.4597882032394409,
0.47779160737991333,
-0.6901474595069885,
-0.005988160148262978,
0.6020667552947998,
0.15431030094623566,
-0.27785730361938477,
-0.22164590656757355,
-0.42705538868904114,
-0.14065396785736084,
-0.5120602250099182,
0.1605071872472763,
-0.2528713345527649,
0.21408191323280334,
0.8649006485939026,
0.46128585934638977,
-0.3684183657169342,
0.41559702157974243,
-0.29625168442726135,
-0.8665726184844971,
0.5754199624061584,
0.08559944480657578,
0.42530208826065063,
-0.0315573550760746,
-0.4592573344707489,
0.20142024755477905,
-1.3765509128570557,
-0.10022404789924622,
0.20283600687980652,
0.15823040902614594,
-0.2669094204902649,
0.8091257810592651,
-0.5519141554832458,
0.6142639517784119,
0.10655291378498077,
-0.06758414953947067,
0.09290789067745209,
-0.13516296446323395,
-0.46015414595603943,
0.3532656729221344,
0.39263924956321716,
0.15852323174476624,
-0.3890390694141388,
0.05287763476371765,
-0.10121231526136398,
-0.06026607006788254,
-0.23458319902420044,
-0.9528269171714783,
-0.04525521770119667,
0.12942777574062347,
-0.7280205488204956,
-0.10473708808422089,
0.11169948428869247,
-0.5878204703330994,
-1.0197914838790894,
-0.3251267373561859,
0.7711931467056274,
-0.19382859766483307,
-0.43149325251579285,
0.0737210214138031,
-0.44901639223098755,
0.4383366107940674,
0.5374755859375,
-0.48879677057266235,
0.31130102276802063,
0.5706706047058105,
0.6742199659347534,
0.006583882495760918,
0.1252918243408203,
-0.44361022114753723,
0.45253586769104004,
-0.4333043694496155,
1.0897265672683716,
-0.2765699326992035,
-0.24293027818202972,
0.13436131179332733,
0.10243533551692963,
0.08148793876171112,
-0.6505803465843201,
0.6473607420921326,
-0.43059971928596497,
0.40982046723365784,
-0.6028794050216675,
-0.8548483848571777,
-0.05170544236898422,
0.43834376335144043,
-0.884789228439331,
0.5534136891365051,
-0.24052493274211884,
-1.0698214769363403,
0.8635450601577759,
-0.7548530101776123,
-0.3639768958091736,
0.017225246876478195,
-0.059961747378110886,
-0.40798428654670715,
0.5518056750297546,
0.24574074149131775,
0.26401254534721375,
-0.10656744241714478,
-0.38508379459381104,
-0.39934611320495605,
-0.3110954463481903,
0.2936108410358429,
-0.25990644097328186,
0.8146140575408936,
0.17295792698860168,
0.004172982182353735,
-0.05843320116400719,
-0.9930789470672607,
0.007684730924665928,
0.40962842106819153,
-0.28264495730400085,
-0.7008742690086365,
0.19044767320156097,
-0.5197630524635315,
-0.22414091229438782,
0.24836432933807373,
-0.9629178047180176,
0.35020336508750916,
-0.07676710188388824,
0.0765109658241272,
0.9408802390098572,
0.3114970624446869,
0.20561492443084717,
-0.3575274348258972,
0.21041148900985718,
0.017724204808473587,
-0.07100949436426163,
-0.2232271432876587,
-0.4832538962364197,
-0.9729268550872803,
-0.7452590465545654,
0.878035843372345,
0.3997664153575897,
-0.6757568717002869,
0.311966210603714,
-0.45297425985336304,
-0.18560631573200226,
-0.35214823484420776,
-0.1402750462293625,
0.2171022742986679,
0.6270495057106018,
0.32132697105407715,
0.14665229618549347,
-0.6505144834518433,
-1.4743183851242065,
-0.4351166784763336,
-0.37445172667503357,
-0.7867723703384399,
0.03310226649045944,
0.3777236044406891,
0.1289953589439392,
1.0271450281143188,
-0.6315563321113586,
-0.15052808821201324,
-0.1244194358587265,
-0.03690918907523155,
0.4351111948490143,
0.1590844988822937,
0.07466956228017807,
-0.7254684567451477,
-0.380804181098938,
-0.05841176584362984,
-0.6728655695915222,
-0.4872790277004242,
-0.17997929453849792,
-0.22695882618427277,
-0.08001317828893661,
0.06941477209329605,
-0.7735289931297302,
0.5453130602836609,
0.1733601838350296,
-0.5043445229530334,
0.26077061891555786,
-0.11326770484447479,
0.12107165902853012,
-0.5760959386825562,
-0.12869837880134583,
0.06764142960309982,
-0.33388814330101013,
-0.4913245439529419,
-0.11927824467420578,
0.10643814504146576,
0.12480451166629791,
-0.3003986179828644,
0.2918914258480072,
-0.7256574630737305,
0.21659110486507416,
-0.32033857703208923,
0.02442662976682186,
0.1026456281542778,
0.2571365237236023,
-0.07195420563220978,
0.6147535443305969,
0.3570650815963745,
-0.949076235294342,
-0.06350446492433548,
0.2614840269088745,
-0.4689441919326782,
0.7210693955421448,
-0.40519949793815613,
0.06447717547416687,
-0.12447276711463928,
0.2873804271221161,
-0.8547530174255371,
-0.5729737877845764,
0.28195881843566895,
-0.22274820506572723,
0.27926355600357056,
-0.3258023262023926,
-0.5271636843681335,
-0.35891109704971313,
-0.19450123608112335,
0.0035749466624110937,
0.5561216473579407,
-0.9217235445976257,
0.8966904878616333,
0.35733240842819214,
0.12243441492319107,
-0.5367689728736877,
-0.4860786199569702,
0.0685780718922615,
-0.6666333675384521,
-0.39902955293655396,
0.6291516423225403,
0.42921629548072815,
-0.5170550346374512,
-0.09361480921506882,
-0.5272175073623657,
-0.10507606714963913,
-0.005077310837805271,
0.3201354146003723,
0.23007972538471222,
-0.2195643037557602,
0.3344493508338928,
0.025990284979343414,
-0.2059096097946167,
0.08757324516773224,
0.15233436226844788,
-0.05036202073097229,
0.25216153264045715,
-0.8108432292938232,
-0.22164376080036163,
0.7697660326957703,
-0.035161033272743225,
0.12241209298372269,
0.38058826327323914,
0.18150676786899567,
-0.9229459166526794,
-0.25429126620292664,
-0.9328713417053223,
-0.10467728972434998,
-0.5222135782241821,
0.03988119587302208,
-0.5620903372764587,
-0.7751336693763733,
0.7295408844947815,
-0.45223432779312134,
0.13915689289569855,
0.7626798152923584,
0.3633580803871155,
-0.1594560593366623,
0.8894866704940796,
0.6300849914550781,
-0.012106931768357754,
0.21263226866722107,
0.07635974138975143,
0.0957874283194542,
-0.6529603004455566,
-0.38140052556991577,
-0.5077804923057556,
-0.2704787254333496,
-0.3135939836502075,
-0.10799791663885117,
0.43930497765541077,
-0.0002605076297186315,
-0.15532387793064117,
0.39828619360923767,
-0.5595318078994751,
0.7908654808998108,
0.3667641580104828,
0.751726508140564,
0.6603088974952698,
0.2659079134464264,
0.02813519351184368,
-0.0013006074586883187,
-0.676795244216919,
-0.43809008598327637,
0.9538909792900085,
0.18566016852855682,
0.39015069603919983,
0.4826567769050598,
0.6508761644363403,
0.8927184343338013,
0.6149947047233582,
-0.6677721738815308,
0.9552285075187683,
0.3879159092903137,
-0.7650874853134155,
0.04084491357207298,
-0.6316881775856018,
-0.9952784776687622,
0.5492889285087585,
-0.47054585814476013,
-0.8021215200424194,
0.20357748866081238,
0.24908801913261414,
-0.33961209654808044,
0.22000174224376678,
-0.8059107065200806,
0.40989184379577637,
0.14643710851669312,
-0.3589077591896057,
-0.46387970447540283,
-0.36699414253234863,
0.5316877961158752,
0.10616819560527802,
-0.04468321427702904,
-0.3833380937576294,
-0.09676647931337357,
0.7585734128952026,
-0.9205455183982849,
0.8520973920822144,
-0.6155772805213928,
-0.11999057233333588,
0.6672164797782898,
0.05346236750483513,
0.7633365988731384,
-0.02222682721912861,
0.2033022940158844,
0.026803534477949142,
-0.09011761099100113,
-0.4755137264728546,
-0.47857576608657837,
0.25811854004859924,
-0.14938418567180634,
-0.6631444692611694,
-0.25220999121665955,
0.01142345741391182,
-0.39706504344940186,
0.30001816153526306,
0.43683508038520813,
0.13991263508796692,
-0.25238853693008423,
-0.11009757965803146,
1.12492036819458,
-0.027530726045370102,
0.5965782999992371,
0.7084580659866333,
0.20169387757778168,
-0.3872342109680176,
0.7647172808647156,
0.07461089640855789,
0.07567379623651505,
0.19315321743488312,
0.1977255493402481,
-0.28179001808166504,
-0.6333355903625488,
-0.5130271911621094,
0.1747337430715561,
-0.6775158047676086,
-0.5110958814620972,
-0.37739822268486023,
0.12467879801988602,
0.20163589715957642,
0.22408708930015564,
-0.04448475316166878,
-0.5203266739845276,
0.2649770975112915,
-0.3203734755516052,
0.4015519917011261,
0.4329705238342285,
-0.030785132199525833,
0.46574491262435913,
-0.6008666753768921,
0.44898390769958496,
0.2988269031047821,
0.26932787895202637,
-0.45020875334739685,
-0.22857457399368286,
-0.21151597797870636,
0.021521518006920815,
-0.1289552003145218,
-1.068265438079834,
-0.28437340259552,
0.24273881316184998,
0.6760413646697998,
0.7113533020019531,
0.24613769352436066,
0.8794751763343811,
-0.6640952229499817,
0.6720021367073059,
0.24147391319274902,
-1.035601019859314,
0.7096690535545349,
-0.2057056725025177,
-0.43046873807907104,
0.5142542123794556,
0.36966758966445923,
-0.21021966636180878,
0.10038965195417404,
-0.9313046932220459,
-0.5720583200454712,
0.1342289000749588,
0.16737477481365204,
-0.23238249123096466,
0.3064800500869751,
0.23904173076152802,
0.03300970420241356,
-0.11497814208269119,
-0.5386873483657837,
0.14741098880767822,
0.44391271471977234,
-0.2233145833015442,
0.8612859845161438,
-0.23582841455936432,
-0.8397751450538635,
-0.01080140471458435,
0.6173581480979919,
-0.4341598451137543,
0.6663036942481995,
0.4483162760734558,
-0.23773989081382751,
0.12956172227859497,
0.317181795835495,
0.49807319045066833,
0.8101441860198975,
0.004448472987860441,
0.35610130429267883,
0.6354208588600159,
-0.1877899318933487,
0.43882715702056885,
-0.2349865883588791,
-0.23223909735679626,
0.22688058018684387,
0.6573413014411926,
0.4063805341720581,
-0.40924161672592163,
-0.4984181821346283,
0.8341246843338013,
0.19775594770908356,
-0.23356470465660095,
-0.4524804651737213,
0.12314136326313019,
-0.44076377153396606,
0.02313406579196453,
0.5545156002044678,
-0.06927677989006042,
0.40937939286231995,
0.04898450896143913,
0.060048915445804596,
0.5666711926460266,
-0.15369895100593567,
-0.19532188773155212,
0.2602311372756958,
-0.0015492461388930678,
0.0244473684579134,
0.3715845048427582,
-0.03813265264034271,
-0.24324931204319,
0.966122031211853,
0.6277379393577576,
0.7265964150428772,
0.030619021505117416,
0.060445740818977356,
0.27591750025749207,
0.5259567499160767,
-0.15142667293548584,
-0.06938190758228302,
-0.14658093452453613,
-0.8346678018569946,
-0.7138260006904602,
-0.0009310245513916016,
-0.7304445505142212,
0.21471616625785828,
-0.7051519751548767,
0.4415314197540283,
-0.44254612922668457,
-0.14792019128799438,
0.08741500228643417,
-0.26131337881088257,
-0.4219370186328888,
0.06256140023469925,
0.3860962390899658,
1.0748194456100464,
-1.1991801261901855,
0.3607173264026642,
0.4372287690639496,
-0.23121842741966248,
-0.5551098585128784,
-0.15309005975723267,
0.4541688859462738,
-0.6061570644378662,
0.3428099751472473,
0.2758004367351532,
-0.05884527415037155,
-0.45141226053237915,
-0.9616097211837769,
-0.5250685214996338,
0.9874445199966431,
0.36769768595695496,
-0.048240162432193756,
0.2341720163822174,
-0.03286641836166382,
0.13971330225467682,
-0.4261731803417206,
0.218001127243042,
-0.006991460919380188,
0.5823358297348022,
0.2920559346675873,
-0.5650494694709778,
0.550144612789154,
-0.1683938354253769,
-0.10369952023029327,
0.1016836017370224,
-0.5789774060249329,
0.34969446063041687,
-0.21407122910022736,
-0.49935469031333923,
-0.18353423476219177,
1.0085978507995605,
0.6228873133659363,
0.5516568422317505,
0.9371567368507385,
0.5295224785804749,
1.1577386856079102,
-0.3133998513221741,
0.7722603678703308,
0.22921128571033478,
0.19690454006195068,
0.8701282739639282,
-0.293687641620636,
0.643399178981781,
0.41291001439094543,
-0.5033722519874573,
0.43958747386932373,
1.181780457496643,
-0.30761948227882385,
0.4535827338695526,
0.48063579201698303,
-0.5991004109382629,
-0.5692960023880005,
-0.2478843331336975,
-0.4555346369743347,
0.06094470992684364,
0.49835205078125,
-0.2791685163974762,
-0.21013645827770233,
-0.13925433158874512,
0.27090898156166077,
-0.4570765495300293,
-0.5077705979347229,
0.8279904723167419,
-0.19506095349788666,
-0.5363927483558655,
0.2916337251663208,
-0.0341801792383194,
0.4911927580833435,
-0.7316672801971436,
-0.3884737193584442,
-0.20211319625377655,
0.18468302488327026,
-0.7666506767272949,
-0.22625304758548737,
0.2016557902097702,
0.05517878010869026,
-0.3635326027870178,
-0.009653658606112003,
1.2119439840316772,
-0.07304142415523529,
-0.3291306495666504,
-0.21589571237564087,
0.34301918745040894,
0.04847965016961098,
-0.12163659930229187,
0.00737888365983963,
-0.5828571915626526,
-0.0819673165678978,
-0.1266939342021942,
0.2692970037460327,
0.5693263411521912,
-0.2661789357662201,
0.6833232045173645,
0.7072576284408569,
0.1516401320695877,
0.15905535221099854,
-0.2721526026725769,
0.7837388515472412,
-0.39013078808784485,
-0.15839442610740662,
-1.0441561937332153,
0.5750440359115601,
-0.771298348903656,
0.06151202321052551,
1.0391565561294556,
0.8291665315628052,
0.39668112993240356,
-0.19298474490642548,
0.7232738733291626,
-0.38477209210395813,
0.5699701309204102,
-0.8114492297172546,
0.6921818852424622,
-0.3423701822757721,
0.20392177999019623,
0.023194121196866035,
-0.5671724081039429,
-0.41617754101753235,
0.5377491116523743,
0.15074750781059265,
-0.3463113009929657,
0.6381402611732483,
0.6867414712905884,
-0.3700554668903351,
0.2810772657394409,
-0.08980245143175125,
0.023954112082719803,
0.29971736669540405,
0.6544155478477478,
1.086444616317749,
-0.3452911078929901,
0.23307715356349945,
0.12318770587444305,
-0.37441810965538025,
0.06901735067367554,
-1.1725493669509888,
-0.676775336265564,
0.058488957583904266,
-0.8909142017364502,
-0.8494476675987244,
-0.38471388816833496,
0.8500608205795288,
0.5943385362625122,
-0.8730854392051697,
0.3692314922809601,
0.06518439203500748,
0.33097410202026367,
-0.38819897174835205,
-0.10634119808673859,
0.5283600687980652,
0.14573058485984802,
-0.31643229722976685,
0.7228149771690369,
0.007822238840162754,
-0.023034635931253433,
0.11961917579174042,
0.2399299591779709,
-0.03471491485834122,
0.38921093940734863,
0.43523818254470825,
0.6124480366706848,
-0.5908632874488831,
-0.6048001646995544,
-0.3201863765716553,
0.008766579441726208,
0.24307434260845184,
0.9868643879890442,
-0.7853546142578125,
0.004644349683076143,
0.5815438032150269,
0.7980865836143494,
0.5863707065582275,
-0.01906517893075943,
0.11739232391119003,
-1.0222543478012085,
0.13097266852855682,
-0.10521230101585388,
0.6754739880561829,
-0.05398926883935928,
-0.31740516424179077,
1.0317665338516235,
0.5401606559753418,
-0.3344237208366394,
-0.9786604046821594,
0.405852347612381,
-1.1432949304580688,
0.20190633833408356,
1.0480687618255615,
-0.36734911799430847,
-0.26648908853530884,
-0.0260968916118145,
-0.02256409078836441,
-0.05885639414191246,
0.04422939568758011,
0.6602671146392822,
0.9361039400100708,
-0.3652472496032715,
-0.11194558441638947,
-0.25318336486816406,
0.21641050279140472,
0.36567413806915283,
-0.9603949785232544,
0.021503621712327003,
0.8926079273223877,
0.5277289152145386,
0.41941961646080017,
0.7162004113197327,
-0.1546853482723236,
-0.2245369404554367,
0.14440907537937164,
0.1754974126815796,
-0.19347114861011505,
-0.0035612343344837427,
-0.2053723782300949,
0.5007514357566833,
-0.27467888593673706,
-0.6541409492492676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02562v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02562v1
|
Gated Low-rank Adaptation for personalized Code-Switching Automatic Speech Recognition on the low-spec devices
| 2024-04-24T01:31:39 | 2024-04-24T01:31:39 |
Gwantae Kim, Bokyeung Lee, Donghyeon Kim, Hanseok Ko
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In recent times, there has been a growing interest in utilizing personalized
large models on low-spec devices, such as mobile and CPU-only devices. However,
utilizing a personalized large model in the on-device is inefficient, and
sometimes limited due to computational cost. To tackle the problem, this paper
presents the weights separation method to minimize on-device model weights
using parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods. Moreover, some people speak
multiple languages in an utterance, as known as code-switching, the
personalized ASR model is necessary to address such cases. However, current
multilingual speech recognition models are limited to recognizing a single
language within each utterance. To tackle this problem, we propose
code-switching speech recognition models that incorporate fine-tuned
monolingual and multilingual speech recognition models. Additionally, we
introduce a gated low-rank adaptation(GLoRA) for parameter-efficient
fine-tuning with minimal performance degradation. Our experiments, conducted on
Korean-English code-switching datasets, demonstrate that fine-tuning speech
recognition models for code-switching surpasses the performance of traditional
code-switching speech recognition models trained from scratch. Furthermore,
GLoRA enhances parameter-efficient fine-tuning performance compared to
conventional LoRA.
|
[
-0.5612456798553467,
-0.4281410872936249,
0.14331389963626862,
-0.010275479406118393,
-0.3053450584411621,
0.22679145634174347,
-0.30511757731437683,
-0.4969838559627533,
-0.051333021372556686,
0.32640543580055237,
-0.15093475580215454,
-0.38597583770751953,
-0.6699147820472717,
-0.024064552038908005,
-0.14741313457489014,
0.9410204291343689,
0.04673689976334572,
0.1443169116973877,
0.3528784215450287,
-0.19277651607990265,
-0.6304532885551453,
-0.3594436049461365,
-0.876325249671936,
-0.4054841697216034,
0.42877668142318726,
0.6297299861907959,
0.577578604221344,
0.6220041513442993,
0.12089277803897858,
0.23828263580799103,
-0.2022944688796997,
0.16972984373569489,
-0.22317034006118774,
-0.1997935026884079,
-0.13498318195343018,
-0.42272892594337463,
-0.5072644948959351,
-0.2248515635728836,
0.529658317565918,
0.6208741068840027,
-0.025500191375613213,
0.3377000093460083,
0.03412460535764694,
0.38155096769332886,
-0.5743890404701233,
0.06041806563735008,
-1.0299252271652222,
0.14712052047252655,
-0.266443133354187,
-0.32480284571647644,
-0.4023132622241974,
-0.30736130475997925,
-0.1729615032672882,
-0.25195103883743286,
0.17222283780574799,
-0.2232544720172882,
0.7723098397254944,
0.34845975041389465,
-0.31633448600769043,
-0.07438326627016068,
-1.0888501405715942,
0.7435686588287354,
-0.7382153272628784,
0.7620805501937866,
0.5202265381813049,
0.3485674262046814,
0.4442805349826813,
-0.3211296498775482,
-0.2989310026168823,
-0.23574630916118622,
0.262389600276947,
-0.23362937569618225,
-0.23111139237880707,
0.010215156711637974,
0.20514626801013947,
0.010432413779199123,
-0.4786023199558258,
0.30259719491004944,
-0.4970865845680237,
-0.3438756763935089,
0.6213849782943726,
-0.2767993211746216,
0.4301193356513977,
0.050483353435993195,
-0.26993662118911743,
0.07004459202289581,
-0.7497479319572449,
0.4073182940483093,
0.3058620095252991,
0.7446991205215454,
-0.2920609712600708,
0.0893513560295105,
-0.34229689836502075,
0.7105589509010315,
0.48280033469200134,
-0.358288049697876,
0.43505099415779114,
-0.2633821666240692,
-0.2704845368862152,
0.559965968132019,
0.41882678866386414,
-0.027388080954551697,
0.2980232238769531,
-0.4473552107810974,
-0.07064376771450043,
0.1440509706735611,
-0.05834519863128662,
-0.889535129070282,
-0.346069872379303,
0.09757790714502335,
-0.5515960454940796,
-0.13772034645080566,
-0.14147265255451202,
-0.6778491735458374,
-0.17557136714458466,
-0.2164304256439209,
0.4272386431694031,
-0.015843462198972702,
0.03573901578783989,
0.127126082777977,
0.2685164213180542,
0.0478496290743351,
0.3534223735332489,
-1.0124616622924805,
0.6379275321960449,
0.15787185728549957,
1.0082756280899048,
-0.42862215638160706,
-0.16623984277248383,
-1.3142064809799194,
0.15862351655960083,
-0.09278895705938339,
0.4039030969142914,
-0.4777916669845581,
-0.4970580041408539,
-0.29715415835380554,
0.18042612075805664,
-0.4299571216106415,
-0.7433919906616211,
0.5609928965568542,
-0.6387052536010742,
-0.06927622854709625,
0.04440909996628761,
-0.13260556757450104,
-0.09952512383460999,
-0.23948334157466888,
-0.5340982675552368,
0.5517522692680359,
-0.3179801404476166,
-0.3656516373157501,
0.32759761810302734,
-0.44435325264930725,
-0.5944799780845642,
-0.05102849751710892,
-0.11916680634021759,
-0.5333690047264099,
0.11389493197202682,
0.4485694169998169,
0.2605813443660736,
-0.32201912999153137,
-0.1102244034409523,
-0.16577763855457306,
-0.4760749638080597,
-0.00122440280392766,
-0.4021327495574951,
0.7153474688529968,
0.5872142910957336,
-0.3386073410511017,
0.047540996223688126,
-0.8772355318069458,
0.33378690481185913,
-0.26078689098358154,
-0.6345046758651733,
-0.49654000997543335,
0.17409446835517883,
0.3216686248779297,
0.5012194514274597,
0.29947757720947266,
-0.4787490963935852,
0.23181869089603424,
-0.32456812262535095,
0.5220670104026794,
0.4472131133079529,
-0.05852798372507095,
0.6339966058731079,
-0.3005293905735016,
0.6548395752906799,
0.32032760977745056,
0.02205941081047058,
0.308880090713501,
-0.5474629402160645,
-0.5619460940361023,
-0.37191733717918396,
0.5279344916343689,
0.7256276607513428,
-0.7358551025390625,
0.28773608803749084,
-0.3029329776763916,
-0.3732914924621582,
-0.7109235525131226,
0.6413173675537109,
0.6765355467796326,
0.3306805193424225,
0.4981936812400818,
-0.4712463915348053,
-0.3750108480453491,
-0.5244242548942566,
-0.5568481683731079,
-0.06423957645893097,
-0.11510832607746124,
0.49896952509880066,
0.23066197335720062,
-0.2650986313819885,
1.0200151205062866,
-0.48952603340148926,
-0.40094298124313354,
-0.30786529183387756,
-0.17054103314876556,
0.27730032801628113,
0.6747516989707947,
0.361553430557251,
-0.8133358955383301,
-0.5603718757629395,
0.5323658585548401,
-0.041192036122083664,
-0.38509953022003174,
-0.3043981194496155,
0.24301870167255402,
-0.06703568994998932,
0.6659412384033203,
-0.1510384976863861,
0.1036546528339386,
0.8223846554756165,
-0.3318445682525635,
0.40955811738967896,
-0.35698992013931274,
0.18293353915214539,
-0.9174800515174866,
-0.10160508006811142,
0.10003465414047241,
-0.3732491135597229,
-0.963623583316803,
-0.22248399257659912,
0.16906258463859558,
-0.18548063933849335,
-0.6758177876472473,
0.7945553064346313,
-0.42858991026878357,
-0.24890634417533875,
-0.1583649069070816,
0.004387619439512491,
-0.10323863476514816,
0.5541196465492249,
-0.06010304391384125,
0.8640868663787842,
0.34720543026924133,
-0.7714241147041321,
-0.13761524856090546,
0.2885872721672058,
-0.16664020717144012,
0.3078170418739319,
-0.4725061357021332,
0.34200990200042725,
0.23430663347244263,
-0.21449817717075348,
-0.8623626232147217,
0.10776889324188232,
0.1545821726322174,
-0.285970002412796,
0.24530096352100372,
-0.783854067325592,
-0.10868845880031586,
0.09545909613370895,
-0.14532575011253357,
0.7585540413856506,
0.5173558592796326,
-0.8489879965782166,
0.3013209104537964,
0.467560738325119,
-0.4306556284427643,
0.09803181886672974,
-0.6480529308319092,
-0.015042087063193321,
-0.355512797832489,
-0.353779673576355,
0.6696621179580688,
-0.2174505889415741,
-0.008435911498963833,
-0.4549597501754761,
-0.21660856902599335,
-0.2825748920440674,
-0.12986093759536743,
0.1796869933605194,
0.07582587748765945,
-0.26705998182296753,
0.010140299797058105,
0.42998170852661133,
-0.09604150056838989,
-0.34809646010398865,
-0.2935263514518738,
0.6398745775222778,
-0.16792915761470795,
-0.316166490316391,
-0.5192782282829285,
0.07369835674762726,
0.5249210000038147,
-0.5373455286026001,
0.25138726830482483,
0.6671159863471985,
-0.5113368034362793,
-0.26976609230041504,
-0.24928461015224457,
0.012982981279492378,
-0.5238934755325317,
0.5660487413406372,
-0.5894767045974731,
-0.773173451423645,
0.6709961295127869,
-0.24360236525535583,
-0.344417005777359,
0.01770341396331787,
0.6704652905464172,
0.2540145218372345,
1.059444546699524,
0.514778196811676,
-0.5626960396766663,
0.8242027759552002,
0.04546273499727249,
0.21900157630443573,
-0.9083908200263977,
0.2656787931919098,
-0.7379168272018433,
-0.43698781728744507,
-0.7746788859367371,
-0.5990378260612488,
0.5819821357727051,
0.1925334930419922,
-0.33194151520729065,
0.30652183294296265,
-0.5617681741714478,
0.4543342888355255,
0.3519141972064972,
0.2385702282190323,
0.7083926796913147,
0.16052700579166412,
0.170876607298851,
-0.0059473104774951935,
-0.5189256072044373,
-0.17965243756771088,
0.8756253123283386,
0.3241453766822815,
1.180238962173462,
0.07980605959892273,
0.702329158782959,
0.5175946950912476,
-0.29946842789649963,
-0.6756097674369812,
0.3870873749256134,
-0.679628849029541,
-0.20799674093723297,
-0.2862921953201294,
-0.6744399666786194,
-0.8084912300109863,
0.473403662443161,
0.14371825754642487,
-1.0122627019882202,
0.7408918738365173,
0.21214134991168976,
-0.5191437602043152,
0.39287900924682617,
-0.9233953952789307,
0.6513031721115112,
-0.1168108880519867,
-0.18365727365016937,
-0.177998885512352,
-0.3365616798400879,
0.3723316490650177,
-0.12748347222805023,
0.18636196851730347,
-0.04432208463549614,
0.08902551978826523,
0.6408658027648926,
-0.2271563559770584,
0.7979981303215027,
-0.5547327399253845,
-0.1497577577829361,
-0.10015738010406494,
-0.025559699162840843,
0.6075287461280823,
0.04757623374462128,
-0.17315755784511566,
0.21744543313980103,
0.19207283854484558,
-0.15185198187828064,
-0.24304626882076263,
0.7619533538818359,
-0.9819852113723755,
-0.066500224173069,
-0.05486529693007469,
-0.32396212220191956,
-0.5650400519371033,
0.08048319071531296,
0.3863687813282013,
0.5882941484451294,
-0.10866386443376541,
-0.05729608237743378,
0.6511343717575073,
-0.4319553077220917,
0.37367963790893555,
0.3863324522972107,
-0.21636465191841125,
-0.39493080973625183,
1.2258069515228271,
0.3213595747947693,
0.5144329071044922,
0.33071383833885193,
0.23611150681972504,
-0.2325207144021988,
-0.5018717050552368,
-0.7010475993156433,
-0.08074866980314255,
-0.47123733162879944,
-0.10468221455812454,
-0.36441779136657715,
-0.3867616057395935,
-0.22946633398532867,
-0.26722654700279236,
-0.44844332337379456,
-0.292977899312973,
-0.3920641839504242,
0.37647366523742676,
0.2239450365304947,
0.10943718999624252,
0.3127462565898895,
0.4662826657295227,
-0.6785187721252441,
0.8605454564094543,
0.4910453259944916,
0.39730265736579895,
-0.15710604190826416,
-0.9040531516075134,
-0.4873619079589844,
0.013708597980439663,
-0.16348126530647278,
-0.9135705828666687,
0.33702582120895386,
0.6979475617408752,
0.2993777394294739,
0.5163288712501526,
0.1158384382724762,
0.7219422459602356,
-0.5138894319534302,
0.25880736112594604,
0.14857909083366394,
-1.1821095943450928,
0.30793020129203796,
-0.3947921395301819,
0.6801561713218689,
0.6460781693458557,
-0.1800798624753952,
-0.7921103835105896,
-0.04882267862558365,
0.0354471430182457,
-0.7859999537467957,
0.8005095720291138,
-0.10868719965219498,
0.030998725444078445,
0.46774211525917053,
0.20354868471622467,
-0.1148812398314476,
0.19034266471862793,
-0.5909538865089417,
-0.10560920089483261,
-0.04609670117497444,
-0.2650262713432312,
-0.20322364568710327,
0.14171172678470612,
-0.0003177897888235748,
-0.6198779940605164,
0.5258204936981201,
-0.4841872453689575,
0.1502505987882614,
-0.037784676998853683,
-0.5432791709899902,
-0.13214640319347382,
0.6264702677726746,
0.6960886120796204,
0.2962004542350769,
-0.15510569512844086,
0.03653518110513687,
0.5205050110816956,
-0.6100115180015564,
0.4869810938835144,
0.265331506729126,
-0.4459165930747986,
0.0406152680516243,
-0.19359064102172852,
0.9291666746139526,
0.632875919342041,
-0.4290262460708618,
0.2521224617958069,
0.025210987776517868,
0.03447240591049194,
-0.003743543056771159,
0.2719184458255768,
0.010617824271321297,
0.197035014629364,
0.2713916301727295,
0.48012685775756836,
0.1441553682088852,
-0.31968212127685547,
0.12723523378372192,
0.3187074661254883,
-0.3764224350452423,
-0.28979048132896423,
0.8123965859413147,
0.3854747712612152,
-0.3787778913974762,
0.06660177558660507,
-0.38982367515563965,
-0.1876283884048462,
0.5737851858139038,
0.5865525603294373,
1.1780129671096802,
-0.5409377217292786,
0.36936819553375244,
0.07937618345022202,
0.22153352200984955,
0.01590009406208992,
0.17471730709075928,
-0.1737065315246582,
-0.8239452838897705,
-0.07842323184013367,
-0.6559808850288391,
-0.4372645318508148,
0.03424903377890587,
-0.6404914259910583,
0.42039063572883606,
-0.6550966501235962,
-0.20235896110534668,
-0.1469358205795288,
0.09409110993146896,
-0.6784995794296265,
0.2726970613002777,
0.2964705228805542,
0.6992846131324768,
-0.6120500564575195,
1.4257909059524536,
0.5718782544136047,
-0.09014835208654404,
-0.5915607810020447,
0.21722139418125153,
-0.0554613433778286,
-0.5897590517997742,
0.4341523349285126,
-0.13886673748493195,
-0.5636332631111145,
0.23855933547019958,
-0.1785850077867508,
-0.7945629954338074,
0.8509525656700134,
0.4463615119457245,
-0.6028661727905273,
-0.07562820613384247,
0.04882616549730301,
0.3150551915168762,
-0.40924376249313354,
-0.04590354859828949,
0.631136417388916,
0.2733945846557617,
-0.18914484977722168,
-1.233323097229004,
-0.0914304107427597,
-0.3007434010505676,
0.26386114954948425,
-0.09684329479932785,
-0.6472424864768982,
1.099123239517212,
-0.30496537685394287,
-0.07440599799156189,
0.015181989409029484,
0.3290339708328247,
0.25923678278923035,
0.29360735416412354,
0.8536191582679749,
-0.07742592692375183,
0.7620788812637329,
0.20182277262210846,
0.40120211243629456,
-0.48577025532722473,
0.3225780725479126,
1.2496840953826904,
-0.38239890336990356,
1.0934550762176514,
0.3227548599243164,
-0.1522218883037567,
0.22517737746238708,
0.32442140579223633,
-0.059581201523542404,
0.7858821153640747,
0.18278512358665466,
-0.19658194482326508,
-0.2137793004512787,
0.27878692746162415,
-0.5470609068870544,
0.7762454152107239,
0.08517047762870789,
-0.19953419268131256,
-0.2483184039592743,
0.26955047249794006,
-0.00428100535646081,
-0.23589515686035156,
-0.6354681253433228,
0.7604665160179138,
-0.002215587068349123,
-0.2682233154773712,
0.9061823487281799,
0.4213770031929016,
1.020088791847229,
-0.6644757986068726,
0.21892142295837402,
-0.09573759138584137,
0.3378196358680725,
-0.39876100420951843,
0.13449682295322418,
0.010931950062513351,
0.2378355860710144,
-0.4575738310813904,
-0.2866373062133789,
0.7746869325637817,
-0.6471431851387024,
-0.5618160963058472,
0.36004263162612915,
0.4974740147590637,
-0.046885933727025986,
-0.15423151850700378,
-0.5860815644264221,
0.3096325397491455,
0.00422803545370698,
0.03500128537416458,
0.6911072134971619,
-0.08211476355791092,
-0.14683426916599274,
0.5897912979125977,
0.8153473138809204,
0.38001981377601624,
0.34300509095191956,
0.2875060439109802,
0.779784619808197,
-0.5876188278198242,
-0.9491916298866272,
-0.48598551750183105,
0.20564670860767365,
0.2877885103225708,
-0.3389178216457367,
0.484096497297287,
0.6254016757011414,
0.8622643351554871,
-0.24564538896083832,
0.9558781981468201,
0.08959849178791046,
0.4545610249042511,
-0.6923348903656006,
1.0720365047454834,
-0.6268526315689087,
0.42987456917762756,
-0.6615561842918396,
-0.5435983538627625,
-0.07558266073465347,
0.587960958480835,
-0.407505065202713,
0.4122340679168701,
0.15065345168113708,
0.7759439945220947,
-0.3273335099220276,
-0.24707025289535522,
0.6279571652412415,
0.2245861440896988,
0.4337558448314667,
0.6624090671539307,
0.2271232008934021,
-0.5911522507667542,
0.453242689371109,
0.08288195729255676,
-0.2501278519630432,
-0.5318648219108582,
-0.4882715046405792,
-0.5670776963233948,
-0.49686408042907715,
-0.4700119197368622,
-0.15490363538265228,
0.1705426275730133,
0.9735126495361328,
0.9859147071838379,
-1.0404961109161377,
-0.5246599912643433,
0.2031809240579605,
0.2993934750556946,
-0.477050244808197,
-0.19416490197181702,
0.16413018107414246,
-0.32095780968666077,
-0.8425098061561584,
0.5996737480163574,
0.2276647984981537,
-0.1713719218969345,
-0.012807131744921207,
-0.4305223822593689,
0.042575810104608536,
0.06629582494497299,
0.5424360036849976,
0.7055097818374634,
-0.5127665400505066,
-0.290589302778244,
-0.3275052309036255,
-0.1361234188079834,
0.19817721843719482,
0.7682076692581177,
-0.8065019249916077,
0.538692831993103,
0.45778775215148926,
0.7194283604621887,
0.5305413603782654,
0.1574794054031372,
0.29955118894577026,
-0.7535611391067505,
0.14966237545013428,
-0.005996661260724068,
0.22383815050125122,
0.11475376039743423,
-0.21985189616680145,
0.05248117446899414,
0.14327506721019745,
-0.5159227252006531,
-0.9103711843490601,
0.2873433530330658,
-1.16434907913208,
0.009242015890777111,
1.1231186389923096,
0.09776788204908371,
0.15114475786685944,
-0.41867944598197937,
-0.4185660779476166,
0.07398805767297745,
-0.5154861211776733,
0.8086525797843933,
0.38407400250434875,
-0.29095807671546936,
-0.29293766617774963,
-0.6576842069625854,
0.770478367805481,
0.2883750796318054,
-1.0519473552703857,
-0.0021038397680968046,
0.03542022034525871,
0.3684736490249634,
-0.06081636622548103,
0.8605718016624451,
0.01853518933057785,
0.40996044874191284,
-0.3327869474887848,
0.14076992869377136,
0.013813938945531845,
-0.34126847982406616,
-0.7690392136573792,
0.114456407725811,
0.26816457509994507,
-0.6635177731513977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15578v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15578v1
|
Can Foundational Large Language Models Assist with Conducting Pharmaceuticals Manufacturing Investigations?
| 2024-04-24T00:56:22 | 2024-04-24T00:56:22 |
Hossein Salami, Brandye Smith-Goettler, Vijay Yadav
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
General purpose Large Language Models (LLM) such as the Generative Pretrained
Transformer (GPT) and Large Language Model Meta AI (LLaMA) have attracted much
attention in recent years. There is strong evidence that these models can
perform remarkably well in various natural language processing tasks. However,
how to leverage them to approach domain-specific use cases and drive value
remains an open question. In this work, we focus on a specific use case,
pharmaceutical manufacturing investigations, and propose that leveraging
historical records of manufacturing incidents and deviations in an organization
can be beneficial for addressing and closing new cases, or de-risking new
manufacturing campaigns. Using a small but diverse dataset of real
manufacturing deviations selected from different product lines, we evaluate and
quantify the power of three general purpose LLMs (GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Claude-2)
in performing tasks related to the above goal. In particular, (1) the ability
of LLMs in automating the process of extracting specific information such as
root cause of a case from unstructured data, as well as (2) the possibility of
identifying similar or related deviations by performing semantic search on the
database of historical records are examined. While our results point to the
high accuracy of GPT-4 and Claude-2 in the information extraction task, we
discuss cases of complex interplay between the apparent reasoning and
hallucination behavior of LLMs as a risk factor. Furthermore, we show that
semantic search on vector embedding of deviation descriptions can be used to
identify similar records, such as those with a similar type of defect, with a
high level of accuracy. We discuss further improvements to enhance the accuracy
of similar record identification.
|
[
-0.0680297389626503,
-0.767518937587738,
1.0638067722320557,
-0.2881109118461609,
-0.08463867008686066,
-0.3277292549610138,
0.01100595761090517,
-0.494922935962677,
0.04643537849187851,
0.730534017086029,
-0.6028196811676025,
-0.5982809662818909,
-0.5934534072875977,
0.03867509961128235,
-0.5445215702056885,
0.8955884575843811,
-0.16952455043792725,
-0.04809388890862465,
0.27506107091903687,
-0.02905675768852234,
-0.5811722874641418,
-1.063232421875,
-0.3906112015247345,
-0.34301233291625977,
0.4796712100505829,
0.021330680698156357,
0.49680057168006897,
0.5345252156257629,
0.7109825611114502,
0.288002610206604,
0.015608290210366249,
0.23096010088920593,
-0.37598517537117004,
0.11042220890522003,
-0.31327155232429504,
-0.5170916318893433,
-0.5976204872131348,
0.04389132931828499,
0.39396288990974426,
0.6626279354095459,
-0.15640628337860107,
0.015009014867246151,
-0.05367637798190117,
0.525916337966919,
-0.46799808740615845,
0.13931359350681305,
-0.7374901175498962,
0.13964422047138214,
-0.18113373219966888,
-0.3957448899745941,
-0.3953123688697815,
-0.21381857991218567,
0.21890223026275635,
-0.5832109451293945,
0.3579025864601135,
-0.0708196684718132,
1.0495221614837646,
0.09270621091127396,
-0.19792449474334717,
-0.6761444211006165,
-0.8837370276451111,
0.861285388469696,
-0.8278821706771851,
0.2880397140979767,
0.34417852759361267,
0.35925474762916565,
-0.506159782409668,
-0.843152642250061,
-0.35711973905563354,
-0.18955877423286438,
-0.21686752140522003,
-0.2838582396507263,
-0.1690225601196289,
-0.0046673184260725975,
0.29585036635398865,
0.6041314005851746,
-0.3773939311504364,
0.2718285024166107,
-0.5216557383537292,
-0.3568286597728729,
0.26993048191070557,
0.4055587351322174,
0.5131356120109558,
0.17692455649375916,
-0.10789971798658371,
0.018606694415211678,
-0.9083907008171082,
-0.3332146108150482,
-0.0653269812464714,
0.39217978715896606,
0.225640669465065,
0.7162380814552307,
-0.18063679337501526,
0.6328725814819336,
-0.26364627480506897,
-0.17729607224464417,
0.29490458965301514,
-0.3743916451931,
-0.5318760871887207,
0.09824870526790619,
0.6492829322814941,
0.23619720339775085,
0.1927320808172226,
-0.3132361173629761,
-0.23802193999290466,
0.0986122339963913,
0.29293209314346313,
-0.7869359850883484,
-0.08165785670280457,
0.1942785233259201,
-0.42010632157325745,
-0.08650649338960648,
0.0038268689531832933,
-0.7892979979515076,
-0.46199026703834534,
-0.47712594270706177,
0.5905035138130188,
-0.3394239544868469,
-0.20999740064144135,
0.2116466760635376,
-0.20737242698669434,
0.49643754959106445,
0.20538713037967682,
-0.9397661089897156,
0.13616041839122772,
0.916990339756012,
0.9363850951194763,
-0.3697814643383026,
-0.17411628365516663,
-0.793005645275116,
0.3001165986061096,
-0.4523298740386963,
0.6288133859634399,
-0.28532207012176514,
-0.5658908486366272,
0.09788696467876434,
0.16441835463047028,
0.07472684234380722,
-1.0237857103347778,
0.5878434181213379,
-0.4232741892337799,
0.04379342123866081,
-0.10650797188282013,
-0.38224223256111145,
-0.024719830602407455,
0.3474196791648865,
-0.6875942945480347,
0.5148178339004517,
0.04173290729522705,
-0.37339237332344055,
0.45999258756637573,
-0.4152531325817108,
-0.4698731601238251,
-0.1320454180240631,
-0.5575248599052429,
-0.5970798134803772,
0.13698747754096985,
0.15977871417999268,
0.6504861116409302,
-0.40934741497039795,
0.23371857404708862,
-0.1049652174115181,
-0.2362803965806961,
0.17610126733779907,
-0.3869512379169464,
0.5731208920478821,
-0.03187666833400726,
-0.5536350011825562,
-0.14565086364746094,
-0.6521494388580322,
-0.23256035149097443,
0.04445086047053337,
-0.2935020923614502,
-0.4943948984146118,
-0.11918958276510239,
-0.33717039227485657,
0.03743317723274231,
-0.12173088639974594,
-0.2031114399433136,
0.08539501577615738,
-0.4812994599342346,
0.06467196345329285,
0.5646646022796631,
0.3224385976791382,
0.1281507909297943,
-0.2764790654182434,
0.2596743404865265,
0.05292600765824318,
0.0844535380601883,
-0.27314257621765137,
-0.486664742231369,
-0.653134286403656,
-0.3883047103881836,
0.1002744808793068,
0.5540370941162109,
-0.3381214737892151,
0.19245357811450958,
-0.24571244418621063,
-0.11010365933179855,
-0.23960909247398376,
0.2187003344297409,
0.19843164086341858,
0.6934460401535034,
0.4142511785030365,
-0.28291448950767517,
-0.5356283783912659,
-0.9235309362411499,
-0.3031237721443176,
-0.09259746223688126,
-0.5132905840873718,
0.3153437077999115,
0.20888812839984894,
-0.545434832572937,
0.8036289215087891,
-0.5776777267456055,
-0.6594494581222534,
-0.0062378146685659885,
0.29477599263191223,
0.6552430391311646,
0.1989569365978241,
0.420818567276001,
-0.8019135594367981,
-0.09247644990682602,
0.2347005307674408,
-1.029397964477539,
-0.07338491827249527,
-0.015401870012283325,
-0.1945580244064331,
0.333493173122406,
0.5651100277900696,
-0.743769645690918,
0.42621883749961853,
0.30768418312072754,
-0.07689984887838364,
0.5036829113960266,
-0.19357247650623322,
0.35887259244918823,
-0.9809616804122925,
-0.021036043763160706,
0.1321403682231903,
0.13780193030834198,
-0.9285846948623657,
-0.17566554248332977,
-0.039201896637678146,
0.027015967294573784,
-0.6215673685073853,
0.1645459532737732,
-0.5741637945175171,
-0.07776769995689392,
-0.15457917749881744,
0.06590476632118225,
-0.09198692440986633,
0.21253927052021027,
0.07542905956506729,
0.5617530941963196,
0.3645285964012146,
-0.8857322335243225,
0.37157753109931946,
0.04811829328536987,
-0.4768248200416565,
0.4054187536239624,
-0.4429628252983093,
-0.02718263864517212,
0.027832312509417534,
-0.19951678812503815,
-0.6633830666542053,
-0.1884862333536148,
0.13628162443637848,
-0.3500261902809143,
0.520984947681427,
-0.2116788774728775,
-0.5229369401931763,
-0.0801854133605957,
-0.04106001555919647,
-0.03222259506583214,
0.5844107866287231,
-0.4608232378959656,
0.6948764324188232,
0.3761105239391327,
-0.2843804955482483,
-0.4355478286743164,
-0.9007006287574768,
0.0696520134806633,
-0.48853471875190735,
-0.3768923878669739,
0.14534705877304077,
0.07432525604963303,
-0.49653348326683044,
-0.10685112327337265,
-0.33542218804359436,
-0.25835877656936646,
0.10784976184368134,
0.13833202421665192,
0.653373122215271,
-0.5624675750732422,
0.30346933007240295,
-0.24722617864608765,
-0.17761802673339844,
0.31451866030693054,
-0.18923123180866241,
0.3847956955432892,
-0.018439745530486107,
-0.45002663135528564,
-0.3273698091506958,
0.40156227350234985,
0.7569144368171692,
0.04621637612581253,
0.6331115365028381,
0.20418812334537506,
-0.568548858165741,
-0.2063865214586258,
-0.6861882209777832,
-0.3422431945800781,
-0.4916115701198578,
0.4084281325340271,
-0.2636283338069916,
-0.752413809299469,
0.3770139217376709,
-0.3103773295879364,
0.016963375732302666,
0.5398810505867004,
0.8674114942550659,
0.15244877338409424,
0.4948968291282654,
0.454018235206604,
-0.23817697167396545,
0.13041603565216064,
-0.15135560929775238,
0.5933480262756348,
-0.7103358507156372,
-0.2809852659702301,
-0.4617801010608673,
0.07776554673910141,
-0.36665382981300354,
-0.4423041343688965,
0.5383191108703613,
-0.1723136603832245,
-0.11938156187534332,
-0.08038760721683502,
-0.3684171140193939,
0.42301979660987854,
0.21493583917617798,
-0.020996572449803352,
0.5708115696907043,
0.1215086504817009,
0.07383321970701218,
0.06895698606967926,
-0.2556490898132324,
-0.6628569960594177,
1.1706122159957886,
0.35588377714157104,
0.8499229550361633,
0.06933040171861649,
0.3854941725730896,
0.2830125391483307,
0.49618762731552124,
-0.9031615853309631,
0.3304344415664673,
-0.19703233242034912,
-0.6041510701179504,
-0.4350801706314087,
-0.35112297534942627,
-0.9957845211029053,
0.26317766308784485,
-0.04697156324982643,
-0.8357733488082886,
0.2742905914783478,
0.04654097929596901,
-0.3128209114074707,
0.32097578048706055,
-0.7325068712234497,
0.7500187754631042,
-0.4204613268375397,
-0.047904256731271744,
0.04781149700284004,
-0.34861037135124207,
0.47757869958877563,
-0.39511531591415405,
0.2801471948623657,
-0.11790919303894043,
0.048935044556856155,
0.43126359581947327,
-0.3458828926086426,
0.9498415589332581,
0.1829470545053482,
-0.26005709171295166,
0.15368860960006714,
0.10642768442630768,
0.46725696325302124,
-0.1911076456308365,
-0.10207943618297577,
0.25380533933639526,
-0.0012715102639049292,
0.05735637620091438,
-0.654278576374054,
0.6444490551948547,
-0.4842345118522644,
-0.9408160448074341,
-0.37564295530319214,
-0.434419721364975,
-0.36964794993400574,
0.3021467626094818,
0.26574403047561646,
0.5127611756324768,
-0.176629438996315,
0.3951350450515747,
0.8085078597068787,
-0.11128224432468414,
0.2350187450647354,
0.6992567777633667,
0.10647757351398468,
0.057336725294589996,
0.6447511911392212,
0.13554075360298157,
0.2503259778022766,
0.6340225338935852,
0.333322137594223,
-0.12990348041057587,
-0.7389918565750122,
-0.2968527674674988,
0.2766847014427185,
-0.7886931896209717,
-0.27390432357788086,
-0.6971506476402283,
-0.17210382223129272,
-0.4070797860622406,
0.09248928725719452,
-0.3253532946109772,
-0.13564598560333252,
-0.43178340792655945,
-0.22799193859100342,
0.24707309901714325,
0.632134735584259,
0.1317698359489441,
-0.07550497353076935,
-0.8912151455879211,
0.5256118774414062,
0.46401533484458923,
0.33423736691474915,
-0.12213826924562454,
-0.3405456840991974,
-0.21409134566783905,
0.13584212958812714,
-0.21435679495334625,
-0.9218867421150208,
0.5160915851593018,
-0.00858808122575283,
0.9839856624603271,
0.18103580176830292,
0.04521337151527405,
0.46318772435188293,
-0.6112047433853149,
0.7227798104286194,
-0.012228150852024555,
-0.7307204604148865,
0.6883417963981628,
-0.47732505202293396,
-0.17316634953022003,
0.27780959010124207,
0.6621237397193909,
-0.29468196630477905,
-0.27587732672691345,
-0.2000795155763626,
-0.9724543690681458,
0.5726730823516846,
0.20594781637191772,
-0.09378211945295334,
0.18539181351661682,
0.5749954581260681,
-0.11040962487459183,
0.007520883344113827,
-0.4711896479129791,
-0.20949992537498474,
0.24974243342876434,
-0.1556180715560913,
-0.16679450869560242,
-0.20893801748752594,
-0.38297519087791443,
0.07961729913949966,
0.6419662237167358,
0.03229667618870735,
0.039684541523456573,
0.41660523414611816,
-0.19956816732883453,
0.15909959375858307,
0.4727347791194916,
0.5090176463127136,
0.8081427812576294,
-0.2059970200061798,
0.096104197204113,
0.28256934881210327,
-0.6327141523361206,
0.11828286945819855,
0.053264543414115906,
0.12157628685235977,
-0.01844930090010166,
0.22062550485134125,
0.45335906744003296,
-0.04976231977343559,
-0.9565159678459167,
0.39289066195487976,
0.051633283495903015,
-0.2099502980709076,
-0.2346111536026001,
-0.03361475467681885,
-0.11406510323286057,
0.38295993208885193,
0.5165641903877258,
-0.6126987934112549,
0.4704797863960266,
-0.997346043586731,
0.4684830605983734,
0.2945355474948883,
-0.2794027030467987,
0.03422071784734726,
0.3218006193637848,
-0.22954054176807404,
-0.3121711313724518,
0.7762562036514282,
0.22820977866649628,
-0.31709638237953186,
0.6432886123657227,
0.6047409772872925,
0.8293433785438538,
-0.40793341398239136,
-0.05167429894208908,
0.004990478977560997,
0.41427257657051086,
-0.3182985782623291,
-0.35069897770881653,
0.26595085859298706,
-0.7411056756973267,
-0.34516650438308716,
-0.43447884917259216,
-0.4923376739025116,
0.5494733452796936,
-0.5543627738952637,
0.3634866774082184,
-0.2928706705570221,
-0.11628878861665726,
0.14779074490070343,
-0.3095604479312897,
-0.35327979922294617,
0.15411436557769775,
0.011341429315507412,
0.42740005254745483,
-0.7624151706695557,
0.6175054311752319,
0.3006657361984253,
-0.28275710344314575,
-0.7472046613693237,
-0.037606339901685715,
0.3276821970939636,
-0.5781285166740417,
0.9219260811805725,
0.022490104660391808,
-0.15783828496932983,
-0.5952260494232178,
-0.08921876549720764,
-0.6724554896354675,
1.2073765993118286,
0.14937424659729004,
-0.5557314157485962,
-0.01791256293654442,
0.40509968996047974,
0.6658840179443359,
-0.43013593554496765,
-0.16741032898426056,
1.0952352285385132,
0.09626825898885727,
0.18138164281845093,
-0.865242600440979,
0.1644521951675415,
-0.24565209448337555,
-0.1867445707321167,
0.4046778380870819,
-0.1150110736489296,
0.8748032450675964,
0.0024670567363500595,
-0.18951337039470673,
0.011034796945750713,
0.26156267523765564,
0.4875674545764923,
0.521801769733429,
0.18383006751537323,
0.3271885812282562,
0.8057064414024353,
-0.11537241190671921,
1.1361933946609497,
0.025723200291395187,
0.13356585800647736,
1.0350595712661743,
-0.3614024221897125,
0.7846424579620361,
0.44359102845191956,
-0.09029585868120193,
0.3474723994731903,
0.3513786494731903,
-0.20375239849090576,
0.4273994266986847,
0.3183414340019226,
-0.290038138628006,
-0.07270355522632599,
0.21280579268932343,
-0.3574528396129608,
-0.031166255474090576,
0.8381821513175964,
-0.7239357233047485,
-0.03942727670073509,
-0.11616326868534088,
0.1542123556137085,
-0.2380305379629135,
-0.23683728277683258,
0.7529202103614807,
0.1865384727716446,
-0.4774523675441742,
0.460127592086792,
-0.11815296113491058,
0.43527713418006897,
-0.68597012758255,
-0.20742633938789368,
-0.16339291632175446,
0.47831717133522034,
-0.09030674397945404,
-0.5568078756332397,
0.5584796667098999,
0.04367915540933609,
-0.1852356493473053,
-0.020436273887753487,
0.8032171130180359,
-0.0669092908501625,
-0.3997158408164978,
0.17337551712989807,
0.3414803147315979,
0.1423652470111847,
-0.2008548527956009,
-0.15565553307533264,
0.17345833778381348,
-0.13111545145511627,
-0.16003738343715668,
0.4173498749732971,
0.6765225529670715,
-0.1291680783033371,
0.5392771363258362,
0.565198540687561,
0.24093502759933472,
0.09469891339540482,
0.09769169241189957,
0.8313893675804138,
-0.6961459517478943,
-0.2292052060365677,
-0.986920952796936,
0.2716270983219147,
-0.056982383131980896,
0.02390952967107296,
0.637925386428833,
0.6152853965759277,
0.5709717273712158,
-0.03961898759007454,
0.886329174041748,
0.4243218004703522,
0.6738871932029724,
-0.8337317705154419,
0.5119873285293579,
-0.39201250672340393,
0.6731002926826477,
-0.1993410289287567,
-0.7120571732521057,
-0.5534482598304749,
0.47509366273880005,
-0.30544885993003845,
-0.10806110501289368,
0.6472773551940918,
0.8604536056518555,
-0.06380327045917511,
0.034596238285303116,
0.40198346972465515,
0.47095558047294617,
0.5968186259269714,
0.6027485728263855,
0.8321120142936707,
-0.3328859508037567,
0.6738134026527405,
0.01642998866736889,
-0.2908259928226471,
-0.1616712510585785,
-0.8212656378746033,
-0.9584192633628845,
-0.33216845989227295,
-0.1659073531627655,
-0.35699620842933655,
0.24285098910331726,
0.612067699432373,
0.49067339301109314,
-0.7899025082588196,
-0.2053183615207672,
-0.01182143110781908,
0.05522497370839119,
0.03544209897518158,
-0.18277110159397125,
0.48248904943466187,
-0.44102537631988525,
-0.6000153422355652,
0.34642162919044495,
0.5081126689910889,
0.29567253589630127,
-0.08947806805372238,
0.1370270848274231,
0.10443688929080963,
0.01538198720663786,
0.7217772006988525,
0.3105453848838806,
-0.5650343894958496,
-0.17622090876102448,
0.1265508532524109,
0.05180807784199715,
0.041906531900167465,
1.2102303504943848,
-0.49746400117874146,
0.2329600304365158,
0.38434186577796936,
0.8486688137054443,
0.6518158316612244,
-0.24096326529979706,
0.8408769965171814,
-0.3893252909183502,
-0.014878792688250542,
0.3245564103126526,
0.40347981452941895,
0.2552008032798767,
-0.7077179551124573,
0.6499252319335938,
0.26854339241981506,
-0.5232158899307251,
-0.7511855959892273,
0.10450347512960434,
-0.7791495323181152,
-0.33228814601898193,
1.2829843759536743,
-0.04416079446673393,
-0.17691250145435333,
-0.31961753964424133,
-0.06525616347789764,
0.16191227734088898,
-0.007345119025558233,
0.8262891173362732,
0.7449275851249695,
-0.4304446876049042,
-0.09229373186826706,
-0.8865842819213867,
0.37192127108573914,
0.07119549065828323,
-0.991848886013031,
0.08620259910821915,
0.589800238609314,
0.31973305344581604,
0.34503477811813354,
0.5622259378433228,
-0.639509379863739,
0.09746328741312027,
-0.1034153550863266,
-0.35427436232566833,
0.1774968057870865,
-0.14085392653942108,
-0.3360206186771393,
0.1722411960363388,
-0.05821366235613823,
-0.1999082714319229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15574v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15574v1
|
Retrieval Head Mechanistically Explains Long-Context Factuality
| 2024-04-24T00:24:03 | 2024-04-24T00:24:03 |
Wenhao Wu, Yizhong Wang, Guangxuan Xiao, Hao Peng, Yao Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the recent progress in long-context language models, it remains
elusive how transformer-based models exhibit the capability to retrieve
relevant information from arbitrary locations within the long context. This
paper aims to address this question. Our systematic investigation across a wide
spectrum of models reveals that a special type of attention heads are largely
responsible for retrieving information, which we dub retrieval heads. We
identify intriguing properties of retrieval heads:(1) universal: all the
explored models with long-context capability have a set of retrieval heads; (2)
sparse: only a small portion (less than 5\%) of the attention heads are
retrieval. (3) intrinsic: retrieval heads already exist in models pretrained
with short context. When extending the context length by continual pretraining,
it is still the same set of heads that perform information retrieval. (4)
dynamically activated: take Llama-2 7B for example, 12 retrieval heads always
attend to the required information no matter how the context is changed. The
rest of the retrieval heads are activated in different contexts. (5) causal:
completely pruning retrieval heads leads to failure in retrieving relevant
information and results in hallucination, while pruning random non-retrieval
heads does not affect the model's retrieval ability. We further show that
retrieval heads strongly influence chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning, where the
model needs to frequently refer back the question and previously-generated
context. Conversely, tasks where the model directly generates the answer using
its intrinsic knowledge are less impacted by masking out retrieval heads. These
observations collectively explain which internal part of the model seeks
information from the input tokens. We believe our insights will foster future
research on reducing hallucination, improving reasoning, and compressing the KV
cache.
|
[
-0.37726226449012756,
-0.7610161304473877,
0.967268168926239,
0.015525193884968758,
-0.2947169244289398,
-0.17493432760238647,
-0.3937203884124756,
-0.7049246430397034,
0.299709677696228,
0.5943615436553955,
-0.6161983609199524,
0.06634510308504105,
-0.6731129884719849,
0.20493030548095703,
-0.6501538753509521,
0.9467341899871826,
0.2076038271188736,
-0.5251203775405884,
-0.0195352490991354,
-0.13350681960582733,
-0.7048689126968384,
-0.7533556222915649,
-0.41909781098365784,
-0.46802666783332825,
0.9771292805671692,
0.14827187359333038,
0.7479331493377686,
0.6763133406639099,
0.6443615555763245,
0.16961008310317993,
-0.19310013949871063,
-0.24862246215343475,
-0.7895467877388,
0.3133840262889862,
-0.5063997507095337,
-0.7661287188529968,
-0.04388943687081337,
-0.23567795753479004,
0.48794183135032654,
0.741786777973175,
0.03940192610025406,
0.09667183458805084,
0.1309443563222885,
0.8517389297485352,
-0.8782433271408081,
-0.02255554310977459,
-0.8102666139602661,
0.05734365060925484,
-0.30197903513908386,
-0.5410811305046082,
-0.6162793636322021,
0.0016119886422529817,
0.5886978507041931,
-0.40524131059646606,
0.2400997281074524,
0.023520560935139656,
0.7757565379142761,
0.40599119663238525,
-0.665816605091095,
-0.38223591446876526,
-0.9674199819564819,
0.9552199840545654,
-0.21662192046642303,
0.5807350873947144,
0.4840434491634369,
0.3634704351425171,
0.054242704063653946,
-0.9222655892372131,
-0.524955153465271,
-0.14130868017673492,
-0.2768663167953491,
-0.12001386284828186,
-0.09059742838144302,
0.03667111694812775,
0.3334885835647583,
0.41192781925201416,
-0.21651548147201538,
-0.2533489167690277,
-0.48419496417045593,
-0.014892781153321266,
0.20140491425991058,
-0.08605751395225525,
0.13049842417240143,
-0.2581394612789154,
-0.38397321105003357,
-0.06403899937868118,
-0.880801260471344,
0.1855980008840561,
-0.07435030490159988,
0.39797043800354004,
0.21296654641628265,
0.4977780878543854,
-0.2066895067691803,
0.8366806507110596,
0.3454408347606659,
-0.1485937386751175,
0.012723063118755817,
-0.3203848898410797,
-0.13428451120853424,
0.02071986347436905,
0.2978145182132721,
0.03837105259299278,
0.26534369587898254,
-0.507959246635437,
-0.31716349720954895,
-0.19124111533164978,
0.8240851759910583,
-0.7135894298553467,
0.0850575864315033,
0.17974896728992462,
-0.45664823055267334,
-0.18444758653640747,
0.18516573309898376,
-0.4165068566799164,
0.0036230189725756645,
-0.6260995268821716,
0.573814332485199,
-0.2780686616897583,
-0.218901127576828,
-0.002171170199289918,
-0.16223536431789398,
0.44913727045059204,
0.18188424408435822,
-0.820918619632721,
0.08197025209665298,
0.7536872625350952,
0.7351850271224976,
-0.627648115158081,
-0.22475171089172363,
-0.33604326844215393,
0.08910263329744339,
-0.20037801563739777,
0.8112146854400635,
-0.8011846542358398,
-0.1562560498714447,
-0.07983031123876572,
0.4491942524909973,
-0.09809739887714386,
-0.7526741623878479,
0.3829250633716583,
-0.8851574063301086,
-0.11730461567640305,
-0.8628063797950745,
-0.14400792121887207,
-0.36187759041786194,
0.07943882048130035,
-0.6999515891075134,
0.6934517621994019,
0.15246793627738953,
-0.80486661195755,
0.3454402685165405,
-0.16991665959358215,
-0.45575523376464844,
-0.0356331542134285,
-0.38027647137641907,
-0.0300555732101202,
0.2887125611305237,
-0.21269968152046204,
0.3928227126598358,
-0.3555448055267334,
0.3988233208656311,
-0.087569460272789,
-0.7025302052497864,
0.2379806935787201,
-0.16705289483070374,
0.6256016492843628,
0.16446679830551147,
-0.5175132155418396,
-0.07577071338891983,
-0.4183669090270996,
-0.277103990316391,
0.15749935805797577,
-0.14401689171791077,
-0.4192015826702118,
-0.05003567785024643,
-0.23331230878829956,
0.3389532268047333,
0.06851999461650848,
-0.35155048966407776,
-0.01502165850251913,
0.027103323489427567,
0.49957704544067383,
0.6530426740646362,
0.21701045334339142,
0.37367329001426697,
-0.4127042293548584,
0.43294501304626465,
0.27848511934280396,
-0.06475339084863663,
-0.09989333897829056,
-0.21686609089374542,
-0.661933183670044,
-0.17515535652637482,
0.1180805116891861,
0.2119188904762268,
-0.6916154026985168,
0.33807802200317383,
-0.31299883127212524,
-0.1565837413072586,
-0.4032500982284546,
-0.1924443393945694,
0.40989887714385986,
0.8200691938400269,
0.3347240686416626,
-0.43396762013435364,
-0.42766863107681274,
-1.1965489387512207,
-0.2207072377204895,
0.053845491260290146,
0.015861807391047478,
0.5245899558067322,
0.5696890354156494,
-0.4189754128456116,
1.2381932735443115,
-0.42643940448760986,
-0.2041230946779251,
-0.23582370579242706,
-0.12781094014644623,
0.2705201506614685,
0.25424471497535706,
0.4845142662525177,
-1.0787475109100342,
-0.03324529901146889,
-0.2191828191280365,
-0.9185245633125305,
0.12578727304935455,
-0.23700515925884247,
-0.3083078861236572,
-0.21817432343959808,
0.2912611961364746,
-0.9876515865325928,
0.4897264540195465,
-0.02259983867406845,
-0.14168232679367065,
0.7754266858100891,
0.09992325305938721,
0.02437187172472477,
-0.5908635854721069,
0.48308229446411133,
-0.24588052928447723,
-0.3358546495437622,
-0.5751684308052063,
0.4987964928150177,
0.17031006515026093,
0.05408177524805069,
-0.5140261650085449,
0.5584039092063904,
-0.4591411352157593,
-0.23990249633789062,
-0.4977629780769348,
0.39633429050445557,
0.10716962069272995,
0.693926215171814,
0.18392860889434814,
0.9550042748451233,
0.3009639382362366,
-1.1621142625808716,
0.13354788720607758,
0.23248305916786194,
-0.15898850560188293,
0.6101497411727905,
-0.7957795858383179,
0.24605779349803925,
-0.5500327348709106,
0.37343505024909973,
-0.7071574330329895,
-0.294191837310791,
-0.07299628108739853,
-0.23949666321277618,
0.4047245979309082,
0.09180444478988647,
-0.25852784514427185,
-0.47298261523246765,
-0.194414421916008,
0.7755539417266846,
0.39725980162620544,
-0.583087682723999,
0.3580683767795563,
0.5642296075820923,
-0.07366374880075455,
-0.8086025714874268,
-0.6613194346427917,
-0.11512027680873871,
-0.2146497517824173,
-0.25866520404815674,
0.5867835283279419,
-0.03834635019302368,
-0.3084219992160797,
-0.15231066942214966,
-0.5832181572914124,
-0.09932049363851547,
0.005175570026040077,
0.015954699367284775,
0.09953784197568893,
-0.13621176779270172,
0.3888450860977173,
-0.18099935352802277,
0.04917071759700775,
0.2313915342092514,
-0.22870761156082153,
0.5361610054969788,
-0.06157059222459793,
-0.08307298272848129,
-0.3140682280063629,
0.20340415835380554,
0.6581939458847046,
-0.1698487102985382,
0.6816720962524414,
0.24239367246627808,
-0.4926738739013672,
0.16723991930484772,
-0.6924236416816711,
-0.6720200181007385,
-0.43339142203330994,
0.4703000783920288,
-0.6375383138656616,
-0.8820794224739075,
0.5121216177940369,
0.22329840064048767,
-0.15106146037578583,
0.4533449113368988,
0.4856184422969818,
0.019624462351202965,
0.5712884068489075,
0.7047579288482666,
0.0517188236117363,
0.42920631170272827,
-0.28316888213157654,
0.2965995669364929,
-1.3432908058166504,
-0.30616509914398193,
-0.32171350717544556,
-0.33678022027015686,
-0.44937247037887573,
-0.18436360359191895,
0.2603541314601898,
0.04533585160970688,
-0.048295143991708755,
0.4968065619468689,
-0.8061869144439697,
0.45501115918159485,
0.42430999875068665,
0.3939773738384247,
0.20438605546951294,
-0.1995946615934372,
-0.0011339136399328709,
-0.09941917657852173,
-0.40041959285736084,
-0.3724081218242645,
0.9790828227996826,
0.3304999768733978,
0.6137515306472778,
-0.08971162885427475,
0.3945431113243103,
0.2922223210334778,
-0.11716873198747635,
-0.8807541131973267,
0.41770249605178833,
0.3136017620563507,
-0.8324894905090332,
-0.2643887400627136,
-0.26794564723968506,
-1.1678496599197388,
0.40360966324806213,
0.2254454493522644,
-0.9004274606704712,
0.51473468542099,
0.015208704397082329,
-0.5361406803131104,
0.048674676567316055,
-0.24138744175434113,
0.6762046217918396,
-0.017914796248078346,
-0.4386058449745178,
-0.36260366439819336,
-0.8865869641304016,
0.3945666253566742,
-0.30150240659713745,
-0.05790482833981514,
0.14255157113075256,
0.14295120537281036,
0.8760384321212769,
-0.06763489544391632,
0.5895185470581055,
-0.0112041300162673,
-0.15213240683078766,
0.5157849192619324,
0.18659894168376923,
0.6641147136688232,
-0.03890441358089447,
0.07430744916200638,
-0.008971170522272587,
-0.023715784773230553,
-0.2856919765472412,
-0.6570191979408264,
0.5625801086425781,
-0.6247134804725647,
-0.9851139783859253,
-0.36226776242256165,
-0.5040016174316406,
-0.08044836670160294,
0.41915759444236755,
0.3328796923160553,
0.36735138297080994,
0.21259616315364838,
0.7195804715156555,
0.9799104332923889,
-0.05286913737654686,
0.24582020938396454,
0.17590714991092682,
-0.2472355216741562,
0.1640138477087021,
0.751270055770874,
0.2809390127658844,
0.2985938489437103,
0.5804218649864197,
-0.0325825959444046,
-0.08549252897500992,
-0.056163642555475235,
0.07102132588624954,
0.5760292410850525,
-0.9246990084648132,
-0.1236904188990593,
-0.9498088359832764,
-0.3672843277454376,
-0.1164546087384224,
-0.0038700103759765625,
-0.4184005558490753,
-0.4782869815826416,
-0.25473397970199585,
-0.18397347629070282,
-0.0018329594749957323,
0.6906634569168091,
0.18144331872463226,
0.3817617893218994,
-0.46034371852874756,
0.5143896341323853,
0.6643566489219666,
0.11680983752012253,
0.421032190322876,
-0.7347861528396606,
-0.18226775527000427,
0.10120834410190582,
-0.4711553752422333,
-0.9036222696304321,
0.20997554063796997,
-0.11857208609580994,
0.48263850808143616,
0.41003167629241943,
0.06306564062833786,
0.7277572154998779,
-0.4296839237213135,
0.6796653866767883,
-0.1579941213130951,
-0.6957877278327942,
0.4030133783817291,
-0.23634310066699982,
0.48437196016311646,
0.5819957256317139,
0.37292319536209106,
-0.5709983706474304,
-0.3674732744693756,
-0.49272415041923523,
-0.8708769679069519,
0.6815387010574341,
0.2727341651916504,
0.014317614026367664,
-0.3228139579296112,
0.7017431855201721,
0.43484658002853394,
0.4768747389316559,
-0.8028027415275574,
-0.037136614322662354,
-0.04242466762661934,
0.1278511881828308,
0.21930651366710663,
-0.5689648389816284,
0.0032721643801778555,
-0.16143904626369476,
0.4074100852012634,
-0.028488019481301308,
0.8149026036262512,
0.4249400794506073,
-0.4463992416858673,
-0.03293965384364128,
0.18016470968723297,
0.7588056325912476,
1.116106629371643,
-0.38799870014190674,
0.32598114013671875,
-0.0411066934466362,
-0.5277088284492493,
0.0005959526170045137,
-0.499440461397171,
-0.28510066866874695,
0.07445314526557922,
0.2619662880897522,
0.772351861000061,
0.3743606209754944,
-0.45161187648773193,
0.5190480351448059,
0.04422159865498543,
0.2897302806377411,
-0.6513367295265198,
-0.06222338229417801,
-0.11970000714063644,
0.19396749138832092,
0.8686102032661438,
0.04145742207765579,
0.41413283348083496,
-0.7594149708747864,
0.4397847652435303,
0.5591381788253784,
-0.5381475687026978,
-0.6142510175704956,
0.6538520455360413,
0.03883587196469307,
-0.3108113408088684,
0.7536764144897461,
0.17851531505584717,
-0.4922625422477722,
0.5524467825889587,
0.6304230093955994,
0.8276315927505493,
0.02816060744225979,
-0.11409324407577515,
0.35202157497406006,
0.16369596123695374,
-0.1762864589691162,
0.011829784139990807,
-0.5354288220405579,
-0.4293319284915924,
-0.3236853778362274,
-0.5531275868415833,
-0.20769451558589935,
0.22727438807487488,
-0.9633169174194336,
0.11606437712907791,
-0.08681083470582962,
-0.45148593187332153,
-0.3323005139827728,
-0.27337223291397095,
-0.8812809586524963,
0.36922675371170044,
0.1067185178399086,
0.6741535067558289,
-0.28215503692626953,
0.7360320687294006,
0.024248553439974785,
-0.43058454990386963,
-0.3491666316986084,
0.2591792047023773,
-0.24980126321315765,
-0.8343445658683777,
0.9337872266769409,
0.6435422897338867,
-0.29065558314323425,
-0.03541784733533859,
-0.44268617033958435,
-1.2832796573638916,
1.1219980716705322,
0.3397645354270935,
-0.6040029525756836,
-0.7675480246543884,
0.003940678667277098,
0.3369220495223999,
-0.3203158974647522,
0.33951929211616516,
0.6488921642303467,
0.37708234786987305,
0.07353772222995758,
-1.0476622581481934,
0.29212579131126404,
0.13895434141159058,
0.12022425979375839,
0.19680562615394592,
-0.7529557943344116,
0.8841893076896667,
-0.3377346992492676,
-0.3606337606906891,
-0.2247072011232376,
0.6636467576026917,
0.356131374835968,
-0.0576358363032341,
0.3652346730232239,
0.3067282736301422,
0.6949665546417236,
0.0032040667720139027,
1.1699855327606201,
-0.4211605191230774,
0.3466770052909851,
0.8588140606880188,
-0.036482978612184525,
0.8348076939582825,
0.9290783405303955,
0.05385252833366394,
0.6503565907478333,
0.5160600543022156,
0.40215781331062317,
0.9406179785728455,
-0.023768343031406403,
0.07457837462425232,
-0.09611538797616959,
-0.12742683291435242,
-0.48685982823371887,
0.45660167932510376,
0.25895896553993225,
-0.40596166253089905,
0.035418860614299774,
0.1357276737689972,
-0.05546282231807709,
-0.4156514108181,
-0.18510368466377258,
0.49358928203582764,
0.3686918020248413,
-1.0177130699157715,
0.7936994433403015,
-0.34115904569625854,
0.6105706095695496,
-0.4221201241016388,
0.12668371200561523,
-0.026647349819540977,
0.204701766371727,
-0.07315278053283691,
-0.5856556296348572,
0.48138463497161865,
-0.4269530177116394,
-0.444989949464798,
-0.058456677943468094,
0.7227046489715576,
-0.2551613450050354,
0.054459892213344574,
0.4522768259048462,
0.3762960135936737,
0.21061231195926666,
-0.4535961449146271,
-0.3429243266582489,
0.17456676065921783,
-0.09310392290353775,
-0.6053746342658997,
0.39289799332618713,
0.43631523847579956,
-0.10686313360929489,
0.7822785973548889,
0.3239285349845886,
-0.01353672705590725,
-0.05751447007060051,
-0.30115699768066406,
0.7431440353393555,
-1.0509426593780518,
-0.43307942152023315,
-0.8685749769210815,
0.2767321765422821,
0.09105130285024643,
-0.05801740661263466,
0.47542694211006165,
0.27608388662338257,
0.8261556625366211,
-0.20823878049850464,
0.4991847574710846,
0.028172025457024574,
0.4201880991458893,
-0.3585425019264221,
0.7177631855010986,
-0.6192630529403687,
0.061421602964401245,
-0.06540334224700928,
-1.1959397792816162,
-0.026903150603175163,
0.6870394945144653,
-0.30047547817230225,
0.15477092564105988,
1.025962233543396,
0.35164377093315125,
-0.22796593606472015,
-0.10611345618963242,
0.3802044987678528,
0.09466207027435303,
0.1597524881362915,
0.7478274703025818,
0.6218295097351074,
-0.3729623854160309,
0.4668674170970917,
-0.2544325292110443,
-0.09936127811670303,
-0.5160345435142517,
-0.49723735451698303,
-0.7794867753982544,
-0.7486820816993713,
-0.08832310885190964,
-0.23229782283306122,
0.14895741641521454,
0.7694749236106873,
0.7610111832618713,
-0.5718048214912415,
-0.19288226962089539,
-0.018743138760328293,
0.1186116635799408,
-0.1313905566930771,
-0.3016740381717682,
0.3150624632835388,
-0.5208309888839722,
-0.4113418757915497,
0.22796125710010529,
0.37836191058158875,
-0.16034509241580963,
-0.18323346972465515,
0.184950053691864,
-0.19535593688488007,
0.12195821851491928,
0.8128135204315186,
0.4199083745479584,
-1.0843026638031006,
-0.5724729895591736,
0.3233967125415802,
-0.40099087357521057,
0.30916428565979004,
0.9318044781684875,
-1.2234455347061157,
0.3499341607093811,
0.26503631472587585,
0.7575064897537231,
0.5628595948219299,
-0.04945288226008415,
0.6229938864707947,
-0.6208947896957397,
0.3152179419994354,
0.36312687397003174,
0.3663420081138611,
0.22171829640865326,
-0.6208770275115967,
0.521475076675415,
0.311641126871109,
-0.7208897471427917,
-1.0482362508773804,
0.4433225989341736,
-0.8074188828468323,
-0.315325528383255,
1.141587734222412,
0.0902462750673294,
-0.6066882610321045,
0.08374227583408356,
-0.07902202010154724,
0.35429975390434265,
-0.10024581849575043,
1.0975817441940308,
0.8417596817016602,
-0.13709263503551483,
-0.19422423839569092,
-0.5233855843544006,
0.43150758743286133,
0.5050601363182068,
-0.32003501057624817,
0.13016799092292786,
0.12112803012132645,
0.13762971758842468,
0.4224913716316223,
0.5791492462158203,
-0.12877370417118073,
0.41897276043891907,
-0.362954318523407,
-0.16188308596611023,
0.33668798208236694,
-0.6823202967643738,
-0.08863533288240433,
0.19042834639549255,
-0.04344730079174042,
0.0013311543734744191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15565v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15565v2
|
CASPR: Automated Evaluation Metric for Contrastive Summarization
| 2024-04-23T23:27:29 | 2024-05-13T21:39:10 |
Nirupan Ananthamurugan, Dat Duong, Philip George, Ankita Gupta, Sandeep Tata, Beliz Gunel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Summarizing comparative opinions about entities (e.g., hotels, phones) from a
set of source reviews, often referred to as contrastive summarization, can
considerably aid users in decision making. However, reliably measuring the
contrastiveness of the output summaries without relying on human evaluations
remains an open problem. Prior work has proposed token-overlap based metrics,
Distinctiveness Score, to measure contrast which does not take into account the
sensitivity to meaning-preserving lexical variations. In this work, we propose
an automated evaluation metric CASPR to better measure contrast between a pair
of summaries. Our metric is based on a simple and light-weight method that
leverages natural language inference (NLI) task to measure contrast by
segmenting reviews into single-claim sentences and carefully aggregating NLI
scores between them to come up with a summary-level score. We compare CASPR
with Distinctiveness Score and a simple yet powerful baseline based on
BERTScore. Our results on a prior dataset CoCoTRIP demonstrate that CASPR can
more reliably capture the contrastiveness of the summary pairs compared to the
baselines.
|
[
-0.7221642732620239,
0.027300463989377022,
0.018842525780200958,
0.5496973991394043,
-0.6489254236221313,
0.35424116253852844,
-0.09703413397073746,
-0.589461624622345,
0.826758623123169,
0.15987414121627808,
-0.1685285121202469,
-0.6304068565368652,
-0.5420884490013123,
0.4155218005180359,
-0.25901833176612854,
1.4029912948608398,
-0.11281387507915497,
-0.13523036241531372,
-0.19807928800582886,
-0.41001278162002563,
-0.05832711607217789,
-0.17416629195213318,
-0.44870585203170776,
-0.23219236731529236,
0.34976837038993835,
0.10997983813285828,
0.581628680229187,
0.1414155811071396,
0.8719890713691711,
0.27835923433303833,
-0.29253914952278137,
0.41669711470603943,
-0.03444461524486542,
-0.10060843080282211,
-0.3265402317047119,
-0.25578969717025757,
-0.38692736625671387,
-0.2156214863061905,
0.3882710933685303,
0.8005431294441223,
0.2662956118583679,
0.1791972666978836,
0.48558059334754944,
0.880113422870636,
-0.8477795124053955,
0.10328740626573563,
-0.4895560145378113,
0.2913122773170471,
0.2100127637386322,
-0.1681545376777649,
-0.07347455620765686,
-0.3926866948604584,
0.3923455774784088,
-0.3046007752418518,
0.499469518661499,
-0.010041685774922371,
1.0613679885864258,
0.17605726420879364,
-0.22150757908821106,
-0.4890860319137573,
-0.2819461226463318,
1.0051567554473877,
-0.9357839226722717,
-0.11896277219057083,
0.12502211332321167,
0.31761500239372253,
0.42120984196662903,
-0.6199701428413391,
-0.5038584470748901,
-0.3782513737678528,
-0.5821353197097778,
0.5587369203567505,
-0.3851501941680908,
-0.09420216828584671,
-0.29370248317718506,
0.590167224407196,
-0.5230196714401245,
-0.14896756410598755,
-0.3340502977371216,
-0.4211723804473877,
0.7066136002540588,
0.28210803866386414,
0.29073190689086914,
-0.36928460001945496,
-0.3701557517051697,
0.1525615155696869,
-0.23410212993621826,
0.04032977297902107,
0.19462837278842926,
0.23973830044269562,
-0.4057336151599884,
0.34373584389686584,
-0.3235302269458771,
0.22810791432857513,
-0.14144176244735718,
-0.06989842653274536,
0.4227249324321747,
-0.7405794858932495,
-0.3200019598007202,
0.14446820318698883,
0.7392851114273071,
0.9693644642829895,
0.04470622166991234,
-0.16147617995738983,
-0.30209824442863464,
0.30475911498069763,
0.04067311808466911,
-0.6613900065422058,
-0.4682092070579529,
0.05336128547787666,
-0.7399924993515015,
-0.316324383020401,
0.5977437496185303,
-0.7602192163467407,
-0.1103840097784996,
-0.243581622838974,
0.1979374885559082,
0.0004092097224202007,
-0.10521083325147629,
0.010021080262959003,
-0.5307899117469788,
0.2012627124786377,
0.33878472447395325,
-0.6625290513038635,
0.9085870385169983,
0.562497615814209,
1.1947075128555298,
-0.8030028343200684,
-0.16403032839298248,
-0.22763746976852417,
-0.14141729474067688,
-0.20624548196792603,
0.9633018970489502,
-0.1998661607503891,
-0.7256903052330017,
-0.19278472661972046,
-0.3328208923339844,
0.03980579972267151,
-0.7440291047096252,
0.6880347728729248,
-0.34518781304359436,
0.22282709181308746,
-0.4076032340526581,
-0.22493471205234528,
-0.06326887011528015,
0.3688940703868866,
-0.6932569742202759,
0.8020921945571899,
-0.02851944975554943,
-1.1552433967590332,
0.5887109041213989,
-0.4921165704727173,
-0.5232580900192261,
-0.21556133031845093,
0.05388975515961647,
-0.6819954514503479,
0.17887042462825775,
0.7047690153121948,
-0.017204010859131813,
0.04435687139630318,
-0.17093145847320557,
-0.1819152981042862,
-0.40304216742515564,
0.18769873678684235,
-0.18663190305233002,
0.7428896427154541,
0.3255936801433563,
-0.28779181838035583,
0.21025624871253967,
-0.44866853952407837,
-0.21309036016464233,
-0.17287404835224152,
-0.08936148881912231,
-0.6105688810348511,
-0.22391264140605927,
-0.017971722409129143,
0.03823550418019295,
0.23938538134098053,
-0.33872920274734497,
-0.16903087496757507,
-0.5094240307807922,
0.015719519928097725,
0.4465077519416809,
0.2888807952404022,
0.3769000768661499,
-0.6304387450218201,
0.5032127499580383,
0.14583715796470642,
-0.00331860245205462,
-0.26245221495628357,
-0.24768108129501343,
-0.8989893794059753,
-0.5557037591934204,
0.4488734304904938,
0.3539697229862213,
-0.26600316166877747,
0.7690510749816895,
-0.37851232290267944,
-0.47112199664115906,
-0.5715880393981934,
0.12054707109928131,
0.7826931476593018,
0.5496777892112732,
0.4739452600479126,
-0.8684032559394836,
-0.5876573324203491,
-0.9969279170036316,
-0.4515855014324188,
-0.10269604623317719,
-0.25180676579475403,
0.3744657337665558,
0.4294143617153168,
0.11070980131626129,
1.0552884340286255,
-0.5927347540855408,
-0.5621386170387268,
-0.6128316521644592,
0.4258297085762024,
0.1397424340248108,
0.3558729588985443,
0.5952600240707397,
-0.6147807836532593,
-0.5328580737113953,
-0.17622286081314087,
-0.40537306666374207,
-0.5993605852127075,
-0.2806905210018158,
0.0008325661765411496,
-0.08762019127607346,
0.2816445827484131,
-0.12703296542167664,
0.3970612585544586,
0.16094030439853668,
-0.04878709092736244,
0.6931586861610413,
-0.2241000533103943,
0.4577510952949524,
-0.9067812561988831,
0.2521902024745941,
0.1943763792514801,
-0.0870741531252861,
-0.07909289747476578,
-0.11235323548316956,
-0.3014052212238312,
0.19049404561519623,
-0.33140820264816284,
0.5705567598342896,
-0.3301514685153961,
-0.5892619490623474,
-0.23397207260131836,
0.5937016606330872,
0.48187392950057983,
0.2851353883743286,
0.1528802514076233,
0.9427759647369385,
0.12902221083641052,
-0.7290143370628357,
-0.10322579741477966,
0.4086535573005676,
-0.6077935695648193,
0.5270298719406128,
-0.8197047114372253,
-0.19805596768856049,
0.09707426279783249,
0.5381901860237122,
-1.2822635173797607,
-0.025579169392585754,
-0.1315821409225464,
-0.5329977869987488,
-0.34638991951942444,
0.2925112843513489,
-0.20175722241401672,
-0.1601877510547638,
-0.9218205809593201,
0.4113577902317047,
0.22123070061206818,
-0.6484273672103882,
0.4260639250278473,
0.28194206953048706,
-0.6327911615371704,
-0.7965568900108337,
-1.0556973218917847,
0.2523856461048126,
-0.12181847542524338,
-0.08237764239311218,
0.7134904861450195,
0.10939716547727585,
-0.7075727581977844,
0.14604057371616364,
-0.42453181743621826,
-0.12390407919883728,
-0.13207918405532837,
0.10982660204172134,
0.2759858965873718,
-0.09817150235176086,
-0.17572982609272003,
0.5101642608642578,
-0.14744406938552856,
0.14165136218070984,
0.3372660279273987,
0.31345367431640625,
-0.3830429017543793,
-0.35695889592170715,
-0.6301901340484619,
0.19879382848739624,
0.3530782461166382,
-0.30854567885398865,
0.16210399568080902,
0.29996514320373535,
-0.01591317728161812,
-0.21039220690727234,
-0.46321824193000793,
0.11892420053482056,
-0.30899032950401306,
0.2422737032175064,
-0.28366705775260925,
-0.4291168451309204,
0.8074957132339478,
0.11755981296300888,
0.3054235875606537,
0.7143137454986572,
0.34484705328941345,
0.013029578141868114,
0.7621203064918518,
0.3850921392440796,
-0.39036834239959717,
0.2526145279407501,
-0.07965762168169022,
0.14380288124084473,
-0.7920705676078796,
-0.2063748836517334,
-0.6425027847290039,
-0.41470786929130554,
-0.14402517676353455,
0.03866475075483322,
0.2657679617404938,
-0.0006545638898387551,
0.11411309987306595,
0.32506588101387024,
-0.5114914178848267,
0.8088327050209045,
0.3919413685798645,
0.07991061359643936,
0.5580155849456787,
-0.1675465852022171,
-0.26665472984313965,
-0.16582414507865906,
-0.24312840402126312,
-0.6816989779472351,
0.6640051603317261,
-0.03286384046077728,
0.37543919682502747,
0.187156081199646,
0.7759296298027039,
0.8596760034561157,
0.29609736800193787,
-0.5448716282844543,
0.6036454439163208,
-0.28817951679229736,
0.028814487159252167,
0.07190947234630585,
-0.2593589127063751,
-0.6180685758590698,
0.5379068851470947,
-0.21386422216892242,
-0.4502209722995758,
0.10582979023456573,
0.16006244719028473,
-0.5527686476707458,
0.1471691131591797,
-0.6391849517822266,
0.44190648198127747,
-0.11804123222827911,
-0.09757442772388458,
-0.33528855443000793,
-0.8318085670471191,
0.6139511466026306,
0.13748851418495178,
-0.08548939228057861,
-0.09105949103832245,
-0.13932017982006073,
0.7630687952041626,
-0.445100337266922,
0.7107303738594055,
0.044088058173656464,
0.33467692136764526,
0.2286061942577362,
0.10098423063755035,
-0.1255214959383011,
0.022396793588995934,
-0.1711949110031128,
0.15896041691303253,
-0.13198651373386383,
-0.27708810567855835,
-0.6491841077804565,
0.7826605439186096,
-0.5344765186309814,
-0.08575575053691864,
-0.3601182699203491,
-0.26225149631500244,
0.07452744245529175,
0.11491724103689194,
0.34211453795433044,
0.4573366940021515,
-0.47619572281837463,
-0.281660795211792,
0.04730750620365143,
-0.2769180238246918,
0.6048687100410461,
0.32031118869781494,
-0.04440292716026306,
-0.7323498725891113,
0.692229688167572,
-0.4060420095920563,
0.16986840963363647,
0.6920697689056396,
0.31256189942359924,
-0.507097601890564,
-0.45266082882881165,
-0.20849503576755524,
0.05615367740392685,
-0.6356678009033203,
-0.4020754098892212,
-0.700517475605011,
-0.11324789375066757,
-0.21965128183364868,
-0.702832043170929,
-0.04445995017886162,
-0.7195776104927063,
0.0464034378528595,
-0.08210090547800064,
-0.2055702954530716,
0.6307098269462585,
-0.066118024289608,
0.3401208817958832,
-0.6406391263008118,
0.39166224002838135,
0.13717927038669586,
0.13434527814388275,
0.027630284428596497,
-0.6012892127037048,
0.016001077368855476,
-0.5596358180046082,
-0.22194215655326843,
-0.44288143515586853,
0.5523607730865479,
0.2462436407804489,
0.4060865044593811,
0.7446199059486389,
0.4731476604938507,
0.7076155543327332,
0.055380094796419144,
1.1013883352279663,
0.4042806327342987,
-1.3657042980194092,
0.5419977903366089,
0.2789352238178253,
0.5150188207626343,
1.1119009256362915,
0.11784352362155914,
-0.15910135209560394,
-0.6643819808959961,
-0.5010716319084167,
-0.9640372395515442,
0.15892571210861206,
0.21494290232658386,
-0.04315423592925072,
-0.0716095045208931,
-0.09875801205635071,
0.30943021178245544,
0.2951112389564514,
-0.7820786833763123,
-0.04377937316894531,
-0.15489257872104645,
-0.24404901266098022,
0.11364639550447464,
-0.14401330053806305,
-0.01712169498205185,
-0.03318231552839279,
0.4851126968860626,
0.1703217774629593,
0.1665291041135788,
0.44064071774482727,
-0.3620973527431488,
0.3862040936946869,
0.3670976161956787,
0.6760363578796387,
0.7995675802230835,
-0.30955779552459717,
0.46361425518989563,
0.5098288059234619,
-0.4837646484375,
-0.373624324798584,
-0.08360131084918976,
0.010331487283110619,
0.47684165835380554,
0.8195918798446655,
0.30836427211761475,
0.2784045338630676,
-0.7388303279876709,
0.8107965588569641,
-0.046941421926021576,
-0.08672124147415161,
-0.17378592491149902,
-0.06887780129909515,
-0.4966726005077362,
-0.14547981321811676,
0.13285046815872192,
0.2880900204181671,
0.5119838118553162,
-0.25865018367767334,
0.5036273002624512,
0.3453727662563324,
-0.4443832337856293,
-0.09822280704975128,
0.3680900037288666,
0.5269676446914673,
-0.10866134613752365,
0.2792094647884369,
-0.35542282462120056,
-0.518731951713562,
0.832508385181427,
0.28985267877578735,
1.059943437576294,
-0.049473609775304794,
0.1279921531677246,
0.5633296966552734,
0.2780264914035797,
0.30094659328460693,
-0.18263855576515198,
-0.6327972412109375,
-0.5103881359100342,
-0.33906397223472595,
-0.44952210783958435,
-0.8072586059570312,
-0.23847654461860657,
-0.9724421501159668,
0.27529072761535645,
-0.4616719186306,
0.11009865254163742,
0.2192346751689911,
0.01167863979935646,
-0.23009440302848816,
0.3329487144947052,
-0.2910349667072296,
1.0235449075698853,
-1.0752589702606201,
0.22793664038181305,
0.21597574651241302,
-0.7258622050285339,
-0.17711828649044037,
0.3844524025917053,
0.06726729869842529,
-0.41689249873161316,
0.6207090020179749,
0.45322558283805847,
-0.7071903347969055,
-0.6893070936203003,
-0.1706514209508896,
-0.13306598365306854,
0.8797165155410767,
-0.08151097595691681,
-0.42849376797676086,
0.2473827749490738,
-0.08931078761816025,
0.7137972116470337,
-0.5365359783172607,
0.6428736448287964,
0.6702980399131775,
0.20348969101905823,
-0.09631074219942093,
-0.8474710583686829,
-0.09412360191345215,
-0.5092934966087341,
-0.23220683634281158,
0.11316899210214615,
-0.46533748507499695,
0.24350948631763458,
-0.378905326128006,
-0.2916939854621887,
0.23350487649440765,
0.7437001466751099,
0.2582087218761444,
0.7494664788246155,
0.7304924130439758,
0.38709864020347595,
0.40279489755630493,
-0.050400007516145706,
0.743533194065094,
-0.33758291602134705,
0.2703244090080261,
1.444820523262024,
-0.37029707431793213,
0.8452067375183105,
0.42547255754470825,
-0.25431394577026367,
0.6069750189781189,
0.33783575892448425,
-0.28355690836906433,
0.7018406987190247,
0.40199995040893555,
-0.48870089650154114,
0.22612924873828888,
-0.14566344022750854,
-0.1634937822818756,
0.37840259075164795,
0.23591655492782593,
-0.5550986528396606,
-0.4904603660106659,
-0.28641873598098755,
-0.04427306354045868,
0.45771482586860657,
-0.30323299765586853,
0.9743568897247314,
0.15937204658985138,
-0.804261326789856,
0.042496226727962494,
-0.08589550107717514,
0.760486900806427,
-0.5921970009803772,
-0.11459490656852722,
-0.571582019329071,
0.06723441183567047,
-0.48635298013687134,
-0.6961563229560852,
0.74287348985672,
0.3531164228916168,
-0.10822044312953949,
0.1810259371995926,
0.3883386552333832,
-0.15046575665473938,
-0.31732383370399475,
0.23619869351387024,
0.22381293773651123,
0.21239663660526276,
0.36393606662750244,
-0.7100841999053955,
0.04935665428638458,
-0.15382517874240875,
0.18584859371185303,
0.026038099080324173,
0.059600263833999634,
0.009262440726161003,
0.3643124997615814,
0.4174879789352417,
0.3313586413860321,
-0.4481673836708069,
0.55451899766922,
0.6768051981925964,
-0.5001518726348877,
-0.993044376373291,
-0.8198281526565552,
0.36688339710235596,
-0.659824788570404,
-0.7907689809799194,
0.6488434672355652,
1.0828157663345337,
0.6356080770492554,
0.10310792177915573,
0.7571884989738464,
0.2576805055141449,
0.7034856677055359,
-0.3980037271976471,
0.6179258227348328,
-0.254057914018631,
0.6528425812721252,
-0.6260519027709961,
-0.988905668258667,
-0.7653951644897461,
0.6434724926948547,
-0.3008394241333008,
-0.0185169018805027,
0.781416118144989,
0.6911391019821167,
-0.23299914598464966,
-0.07571961730718613,
-0.07404091209173203,
-0.2324146181344986,
0.17464476823806763,
0.2865750789642334,
0.5366542339324951,
-0.2363467514514923,
0.593451738357544,
-0.11861998587846756,
-0.19579152762889862,
-0.21084171533584595,
-0.9192326068878174,
-0.829515814781189,
-0.3478665351867676,
-0.5269646644592285,
-0.323550283908844,
0.10313911736011505,
0.9022440314292908,
0.4524019658565521,
-1.188790202140808,
-0.20882481336593628,
-0.2164793163537979,
0.10758132487535477,
-0.6223205924034119,
-0.2910202443599701,
0.8579548597335815,
-0.47368690371513367,
-0.7185127139091492,
0.029886139556765556,
0.5875070691108704,
0.040104418992996216,
-0.20885352790355682,
0.05441046506166458,
0.41917842626571655,
0.3722684681415558,
0.429390013217926,
0.25224652886390686,
-0.7885647416114807,
0.05731349065899849,
-0.4847075343132019,
-0.22039073705673218,
0.0018088500946760178,
1.0016162395477295,
-0.5888180732727051,
0.5421283841133118,
0.48630422353744507,
0.7579459547996521,
0.3848484754562378,
0.29108381271362305,
0.4611554741859436,
-0.8509243726730347,
0.0498996339738369,
0.21086594462394714,
0.5851123929023743,
0.38821378350257874,
0.05149150267243385,
0.4632030129432678,
-0.07427190989255905,
-0.28010293841362,
-0.6896914839744568,
0.21793833374977112,
-1.436394214630127,
-0.08200583606958389,
0.879252552986145,
-0.23009100556373596,
0.22092311084270477,
-0.25557941198349,
-0.3751637935638428,
-0.03610178455710411,
-0.3802715241909027,
1.257949948310852,
0.39170271158218384,
-0.2605232298374176,
-0.02335638366639614,
0.12049537897109985,
0.5630660653114319,
0.6315011978149414,
-1.0784013271331787,
-0.18803004920482635,
0.19813548028469086,
0.059645261615514755,
0.36617258191108704,
0.512363851070404,
-0.3108747601509094,
0.29740557074546814,
0.14703534543514252,
0.0048426431603729725,
-0.009680116549134254,
-0.1191268339753151,
-0.4947042763233185,
0.2761249840259552,
-0.18786568939685822,
-0.5383669137954712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15549v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15549v2
|
PRISM: Patient Records Interpretation for Semantic Clinical Trial Matching using Large Language Models
| 2024-04-23T22:33:19 | 2024-04-27T03:10:21 |
Shashi Kant Gupta, Aditya Basu, Mauro Nievas, Jerrin Thomas, Nathan Wolfrath, Adhitya Ramamurthi, Bradley Taylor, Anai N. Kothari, Regina Schwind, Therica M. Miller, Sorena Nadaf-Rahrov, Yanshan Wang, Hrituraj Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Clinical trial matching is the task of identifying trials for which patients
may be potentially eligible. Typically, this task is labor-intensive and
requires detailed verification of patient electronic health records (EHRs)
against the stringent inclusion and exclusion criteria of clinical trials. This
process is manual, time-intensive, and challenging to scale up, resulting in
many patients missing out on potential therapeutic options. Recent advancements
in Large Language Models (LLMs) have made automating patient-trial matching
possible, as shown in multiple concurrent research studies. However, the
current approaches are confined to constrained, often synthetic datasets that
do not adequately mirror the complexities encountered in real-world medical
data. In this study, we present the first, end-to-end large-scale empirical
evaluation of clinical trial matching using real-world EHRs. Our study
showcases the capability of LLMs to accurately match patients with appropriate
clinical trials. We perform experiments with proprietary LLMs, including GPT-4
and GPT-3.5, as well as our custom fine-tuned model called OncoLLM and show
that OncoLLM, despite its significantly smaller size, not only outperforms
GPT-3.5 but also matches the performance of qualified medical doctors. All
experiments were carried out on real-world EHRs that include clinical notes and
available clinical trials from a single cancer center in the United States.
|
[
0.13061341643333435,
-0.6805468797683716,
0.9524598717689514,
0.036829616874456406,
-0.23629803955554962,
-0.15456822514533997,
-0.03565604239702225,
-0.6331065893173218,
0.09912528097629547,
0.9342448711395264,
-0.5821802616119385,
-0.6371572017669678,
-0.5142577886581421,
0.18084730207920074,
-0.33612117171287537,
0.8246082067489624,
-0.3409360349178314,
0.5176913142204285,
-0.10349492728710175,
-0.0630364939570427,
-0.49446770548820496,
-0.29565951228141785,
-0.3098491132259369,
-0.5115200281143188,
0.4304239749908447,
0.40224599838256836,
0.6503332257270813,
0.8317416310310364,
0.9608112573623657,
0.2808586061000824,
0.07986883074045181,
-0.10206329077482224,
-0.6279411315917969,
0.22507978975772858,
-0.0626000240445137,
-0.6476873755455017,
-0.5490239262580872,
-0.08518336713314056,
0.43788832426071167,
0.7799966335296631,
-0.31840944290161133,
-0.06263866275548935,
-0.14633849263191223,
0.3630765676498413,
-0.3389829397201538,
0.06814101338386536,
-0.7061870098114014,
0.5517628788948059,
-0.2745175063610077,
-0.5801261067390442,
-0.4844329059123993,
-0.48633021116256714,
0.44283175468444824,
-0.9688990116119385,
0.4011329114437103,
0.3784528970718384,
1.0138370990753174,
0.20193952322006226,
-0.5601144433021545,
-0.4518228769302368,
-0.6391417384147644,
0.4988324046134949,
-0.7536993026733398,
0.27299782633781433,
0.3683219254016876,
0.7661269307136536,
-0.5095561742782593,
-0.9549707770347595,
-0.5202130079269409,
-0.14969803392887115,
-0.27755749225616455,
0.2598007023334503,
0.11308691650629044,
0.4222850501537323,
0.34395503997802734,
0.6195160150527954,
-0.9009563326835632,
0.23150038719177246,
-0.2660086154937744,
-0.35986608266830444,
0.36893343925476074,
0.6401798129081726,
0.5665842294692993,
-0.0047220694832503796,
-0.5040531158447266,
-0.10371392220258713,
-0.8356140851974487,
-0.35888299345970154,
-0.3327428698539734,
0.3390839695930481,
-0.04257369786500931,
0.9514266848564148,
-0.42509350180625916,
0.7638289332389832,
-0.026569833979010582,
-0.1365470439195633,
0.2261814922094345,
-0.40909627079963684,
-0.5029563307762146,
0.33290421962738037,
0.8012862801551819,
0.7633649706840515,
0.1616547852754593,
-0.16263915598392487,
0.1565941423177719,
0.16026407480239868,
0.1335945576429367,
-0.9443416595458984,
-0.045996665954589844,
0.4169960916042328,
-0.736565113067627,
-0.06454221904277802,
-0.17130210995674133,
-0.6546329855918884,
-0.6489036679267883,
-0.420603483915329,
0.5858892202377319,
-0.24340154230594635,
0.09689940512180328,
0.651930570602417,
-0.05458276346325874,
0.4519413709640503,
0.43888071179389954,
-0.505454957485199,
0.38924461603164673,
1.056700348854065,
0.7870249152183533,
-0.04881846532225609,
-0.175664022564888,
-0.7590179443359375,
0.10095833986997604,
-0.2558141052722931,
0.6422248482704163,
-0.39540380239486694,
-0.12990662455558777,
0.13739141821861267,
0.21589882671833038,
-0.2908068299293518,
-0.5564242005348206,
0.696312427520752,
-0.6158614754676819,
0.592914879322052,
-0.3135605752468109,
-1.0102038383483887,
0.1050376147031784,
0.4127748906612396,
-0.46111875772476196,
0.3780018985271454,
0.23670250177383423,
-0.48156672716140747,
0.7939045429229736,
-0.3067012131214142,
-0.14671294391155243,
0.49227824807167053,
-0.2956428825855255,
-0.6025874018669128,
0.003048847895115614,
-0.09551570564508438,
0.5480737090110779,
-0.7457767128944397,
0.16155806183815002,
-0.4040539264678955,
-0.18679691851139069,
0.311816543340683,
0.1847672164440155,
0.5796657204627991,
0.308859646320343,
-0.29107528924942017,
-0.047481901943683624,
-0.6751567721366882,
0.04567369073629379,
0.039879605174064636,
-0.058380126953125,
-0.22508175671100616,
-0.046775203198194504,
0.3130122125148773,
0.5228583812713623,
-0.011533647775650024,
-0.8330881595611572,
0.11809366941452026,
-0.41465622186660767,
0.3878857493400574,
0.34819215536117554,
0.018264317885041237,
-0.047667182981967926,
-0.5449159741401672,
0.7010789513587952,
-0.12491855025291443,
0.31219324469566345,
-0.1026700884103775,
-0.5838819146156311,
-0.382648766040802,
-0.3599892258644104,
0.4459112882614136,
0.6437392234802246,
-0.4271725118160248,
0.34767088294029236,
-0.745151162147522,
-0.28617411851882935,
-0.5944828391075134,
-0.19095003604888916,
0.4530661106109619,
0.6694684624671936,
0.35465654730796814,
-0.5019931793212891,
-0.3630182445049286,
-1.0743191242218018,
-0.1942913830280304,
0.03691379353404045,
-0.45564955472946167,
0.5981349945068359,
0.4409370720386505,
-0.19576594233512878,
0.9606924653053284,
-0.5549416542053223,
-0.931195855140686,
-0.07941345870494843,
-0.1503458172082901,
0.29686877131462097,
0.13612070679664612,
0.032198868691921234,
-0.8152415752410889,
-0.8166581988334656,
0.31408262252807617,
-0.9391981363296509,
-0.3786938488483429,
-0.29950758814811707,
-0.09545469284057617,
-0.49289411306381226,
0.39322584867477417,
-0.3779284358024597,
0.2962225675582886,
0.4792075455188751,
-0.881637454032898,
0.014068360440433025,
-0.5811260938644409,
0.5005673170089722,
-0.7971038818359375,
0.013287704437971115,
-0.0021707331761717796,
-0.49797600507736206,
-0.6719620227813721,
-0.03317175433039665,
0.14452466368675232,
-0.034437116235494614,
-0.42825525999069214,
0.3994200527667999,
-0.42838478088378906,
-0.1716664582490921,
-0.05644672363996506,
0.2845645248889923,
0.21715320646762848,
-0.06155705451965332,
0.13759173452854156,
0.329519122838974,
0.4124131202697754,
-0.10761214792728424,
0.35375815629959106,
0.6449565291404724,
-0.6182670593261719,
0.889787495136261,
-0.7718992233276367,
-0.2907811403274536,
-0.055161815136671066,
0.37399300932884216,
-0.6693458557128906,
-0.5007798671722412,
0.09303770214319229,
-0.2391722947359085,
0.06005769222974777,
-0.17485587298870087,
-0.4509991705417633,
-0.060433585196733475,
-0.07234220951795578,
0.38803061842918396,
0.49533864855766296,
-0.21974492073059082,
0.7901431918144226,
0.3449079990386963,
-0.25511547923088074,
-0.061929818242788315,
-0.8626048564910889,
0.3412158787250519,
-0.2502168118953705,
-0.6959269046783447,
0.3456818163394928,
0.05591123178601265,
-0.2562219798564911,
0.028021179139614105,
0.35628047585487366,
-0.20626018941402435,
-0.15094009041786194,
0.2598930597305298,
0.31100258231163025,
-0.33423301577568054,
-0.15413273870944977,
-0.08656342327594757,
-0.046541836112737656,
-0.011999703012406826,
-0.062441371381282806,
0.25688523054122925,
0.19531774520874023,
-0.7333597540855408,
-0.6219701766967773,
0.44581010937690735,
0.835168719291687,
0.02875782735645771,
0.6651792526245117,
0.11486648768186569,
-0.5310693979263306,
0.039719048887491226,
-0.7950805425643921,
-0.0183775182813406,
-0.40008553862571716,
0.29498010873794556,
-0.35767611861228943,
-0.7459442615509033,
0.5958758592605591,
0.05775733292102814,
-0.05546516180038452,
0.23058918118476868,
0.929406464099884,
0.2351435273885727,
0.9861075282096863,
0.06981442868709564,
0.28755196928977966,
0.04181630536913872,
0.21623001992702484,
0.0706520602107048,
-1.0001040697097778,
-0.550392210483551,
-0.44630053639411926,
-0.1694316565990448,
-0.5522031784057617,
-0.4354161024093628,
0.6456130146980286,
-0.45977139472961426,
-0.0723576545715332,
0.26433831453323364,
-0.5261729955673218,
0.3783240020275116,
0.056917138397693634,
0.26478198170661926,
0.6206673383712769,
-0.2934293746948242,
0.09595330059528351,
-0.3157406449317932,
-0.5698006749153137,
-0.3285168707370758,
1.3780955076217651,
0.3567460775375366,
0.4725187122821808,
0.26602569222450256,
0.3513413369655609,
0.30785542726516724,
0.42936328053474426,
-0.6175071001052856,
0.29861944913864136,
-0.12166249752044678,
-0.696426272392273,
-0.13141900300979614,
-0.5440592765808105,
-1.358806848526001,
0.5872992873191833,
-0.5764843821525574,
-0.46445420384407043,
0.12297430634498596,
0.09476850181818008,
-0.580937922000885,
-0.019485922530293465,
-0.48763489723205566,
1.0820902585983276,
-0.3227541148662567,
-0.3046661615371704,
-0.02306080237030983,
-0.6890586614608765,
0.2683631479740143,
-0.24585311114788055,
0.2767783999443054,
-0.22004254162311554,
-0.10049454122781754,
0.42624330520629883,
-0.5162719488143921,
0.35065776109695435,
-0.026585008949041367,
0.06947585195302963,
-0.23863865435123444,
0.1396578699350357,
0.5395272970199585,
-0.24808962643146515,
0.0219943355768919,
0.02957640029489994,
0.29079470038414,
-0.3385365605354309,
-0.5056085586547852,
0.7635772824287415,
-0.3663024604320526,
-0.19596585631370544,
-0.6143754124641418,
-0.5751749277114868,
-0.22444012761116028,
0.4366719722747803,
0.293321430683136,
0.48563194274902344,
-0.3446705937385559,
0.30090245604515076,
0.5701256990432739,
-0.3896377980709076,
-0.5590433478355408,
0.9217463731765747,
-0.26602932810783386,
-0.133323073387146,
0.5675629377365112,
-0.11018364131450653,
0.3869030177593231,
0.545431911945343,
0.40885597467422485,
-0.3402000665664673,
-0.8894852995872498,
-0.465527206659317,
0.25809308886528015,
-0.5637386441230774,
0.047623369842767715,
-0.6650466918945312,
0.3082471489906311,
-0.33540481328964233,
-0.11899003386497498,
-0.19105647504329681,
-0.001156867714598775,
-0.0357527881860733,
0.2728245258331299,
0.07739003002643585,
0.6863796710968018,
0.4822072386741638,
0.32929036021232605,
-0.9170287251472473,
0.5113961696624756,
0.08219435065984726,
0.4621167778968811,
-0.4732096493244171,
-0.6514695286750793,
-0.05678820237517357,
-0.05155423656105995,
0.04086533561348915,
-0.7865518927574158,
0.45420482754707336,
0.38683390617370605,
0.4681626260280609,
0.39475157856941223,
-0.0016794276889413595,
0.63190758228302,
-0.7974684238433838,
0.5594199299812317,
0.15421953797340393,
-0.706423282623291,
0.3879646956920624,
-0.5770303606987,
-0.08523260802030563,
0.8171904683113098,
0.12519864737987518,
-0.7121602296829224,
-0.07855686545372009,
-0.5089247822761536,
-0.7520706057548523,
0.6843861937522888,
0.2815573811531067,
-0.4581168293952942,
0.23879045248031616,
0.511100172996521,
-0.07364680618047714,
0.05866912379860878,
-0.47384151816368103,
-0.09090377390384674,
0.22025038301944733,
-0.695253849029541,
-0.045465968549251556,
-0.0027255883906036615,
-0.4180019199848175,
0.15918990969657898,
0.4411410689353943,
0.009478558786213398,
0.06629360467195511,
0.48948949575424194,
-0.1773831844329834,
-0.25576844811439514,
0.20188772678375244,
0.5053803324699402,
0.6759888529777527,
-0.26003411412239075,
-0.09909893572330475,
0.14166590571403503,
-0.4289058744907379,
-0.13379493355751038,
0.0637400820851326,
-0.1381949931383133,
-0.07649993151426315,
0.5452322959899902,
0.7304373383522034,
0.3999100625514984,
-1.0313581228256226,
0.8733929395675659,
-0.5130136013031006,
-0.19965125620365143,
-0.38168954849243164,
-0.04786034673452377,
-0.12418775260448456,
0.1521744728088379,
0.05927873030304909,
-0.5140380263328552,
0.5530336499214172,
-0.5359967350959778,
0.22148019075393677,
0.6138466596603394,
-0.6613729596138,
-0.09743683785200119,
0.7947222590446472,
0.023870792239904404,
-0.3139082193374634,
0.5575571060180664,
0.2971166670322418,
-0.41265714168548584,
0.5583639740943909,
0.41403132677078247,
0.5065145492553711,
0.004189366474747658,
-0.15982618927955627,
0.06267853081226349,
0.14696763455867767,
-0.3283848464488983,
-0.06740113347768784,
0.3514915704727173,
-0.5190308094024658,
-0.5289748311042786,
-0.4613097608089447,
-0.8089073300361633,
0.034349869936704636,
-0.7940734028816223,
0.406429260969162,
-0.0970904603600502,
0.02388862334191799,
0.14907759428024292,
-0.09380587935447693,
-0.7124199867248535,
0.18351054191589355,
0.12638096511363983,
0.8254539966583252,
-0.9908501505851746,
0.642099142074585,
0.3896901309490204,
0.14821945130825043,
-0.7514985799789429,
-0.3658580183982849,
0.4011608064174652,
-0.7833306193351746,
0.33240559697151184,
0.056537896394729614,
0.3303094208240509,
-0.27190813422203064,
0.09353379160165787,
-0.5843812823295593,
1.309075117111206,
0.2712566554546356,
-0.6495600938796997,
0.025906318798661232,
0.6352828145027161,
0.8608849048614502,
-0.38637855648994446,
0.35099130868911743,
0.7075008153915405,
0.4036521017551422,
0.25679129362106323,
-1.1943120956420898,
0.15051496028900146,
-0.02816840633749962,
-0.23848161101341248,
0.23208186030387878,
-0.25565046072006226,
0.8175881505012512,
0.22616536915302277,
-0.15113066136837006,
0.14680303633213043,
0.22858449816703796,
0.2209925502538681,
0.5597016215324402,
0.45095789432525635,
0.5721356868743896,
0.7115912437438965,
-0.20921888947486877,
1.2832881212234497,
-0.3708692491054535,
0.5811971426010132,
0.9239516258239746,
-0.9106144309043884,
0.44533610343933105,
0.3133299946784973,
-0.40944045782089233,
0.34247851371765137,
0.47376951575279236,
-0.0022738019470125437,
0.3220992684364319,
0.24649950861930847,
-0.14866934716701508,
-0.4539245367050171,
-0.12220940738916397,
-0.37887445092201233,
0.2150004804134369,
0.3921135365962982,
-0.4216251075267792,
-0.20441938936710358,
0.08864482492208481,
-0.12771181762218475,
0.12246967852115631,
-0.018746893852949142,
0.8043226003646851,
0.03339080512523651,
-0.7495028972625732,
0.22076211869716644,
-0.25257596373558044,
0.40103867650032043,
-0.7940066456794739,
-0.19413171708583832,
0.1891425997018814,
0.5497589707374573,
-0.29728877544403076,
-0.6421852707862854,
0.11091836541891098,
-0.14372648298740387,
0.11451686918735504,
0.011907827109098434,
0.46453508734703064,
-0.462726354598999,
-0.4932762086391449,
0.37434035539627075,
0.2364729344844818,
0.3194943964481354,
0.03617807477712631,
-0.7368747591972351,
0.23421381413936615,
-0.11559903621673584,
-0.3026154637336731,
0.6296989917755127,
0.4442741274833679,
0.1160520538687706,
0.7683182954788208,
0.668272852897644,
0.6547086834907532,
-0.16756178438663483,
-0.004477409645915031,
0.5725162625312805,
-0.36159181594848633,
-0.425277441740036,
-0.7114185690879822,
0.1767139881849289,
-0.05610894784331322,
-0.45398247241973877,
0.7322252988815308,
0.7573512196540833,
0.38274815678596497,
0.17394578456878662,
0.5680336952209473,
0.09729515761137009,
0.8274843096733093,
-0.6123754382133484,
0.4953972101211548,
-0.5257889628410339,
0.3788363039493561,
-0.1328863799571991,
-0.637166440486908,
-0.6393846273422241,
0.5080346465110779,
-0.36018896102905273,
-0.34373196959495544,
0.582033097743988,
0.7710616588592529,
-0.1513776034116745,
0.029195312410593033,
0.4678616523742676,
0.4109669327735901,
0.5942414402961731,
0.8997594118118286,
0.4390181601047516,
-0.5929640531539917,
0.2651568353176117,
-0.04989079385995865,
-0.5613343119621277,
-0.40915194153785706,
-0.8160193562507629,
-0.5641964077949524,
-0.32405492663383484,
-0.21280120313167572,
-0.629997730255127,
-0.05161796137690544,
1.1200941801071167,
0.6078153848648071,
-0.71358722448349,
-0.05484134703874588,
0.07224396616220474,
-0.40319541096687317,
-0.05182471498847008,
-0.1489463597536087,
0.5409518480300903,
0.17144596576690674,
-0.6803504228591919,
0.2999013662338257,
0.16852708160877228,
-0.2681677043437958,
-0.04572374373674393,
-0.19880984723567963,
0.10565246641635895,
-0.029354380443692207,
0.4300709068775177,
0.278506875038147,
-0.5920428037643433,
-0.1669400930404663,
0.13769012689590454,
-0.2954588532447815,
0.1259581595659256,
0.9960315823554993,
-0.7063983082771301,
0.7041159272193909,
0.47579658031463623,
0.5312756299972534,
0.6410636305809021,
0.05650864169001579,
0.4888855218887329,
0.08661343902349472,
-0.10989314317703247,
0.5233538150787354,
0.6338586807250977,
0.19840417802333832,
-0.3924112915992737,
0.3317722976207733,
-0.012216396629810333,
-0.8715831637382507,
-0.940316915512085,
0.05888817831873894,
-1.2752962112426758,
-0.02755984291434288,
1.1139979362487793,
-0.3305373191833496,
-0.045969247817993164,
-0.6777729988098145,
-0.14287929236888885,
0.04825296252965927,
0.01790890283882618,
0.7141872644424438,
0.5371620655059814,
-0.32401084899902344,
0.27540120482444763,
-0.7299495935440063,
0.40611743927001953,
0.4551539719104767,
-0.850649893283844,
0.14392057061195374,
0.6676560044288635,
0.40085792541503906,
-0.03406722471117973,
0.8476383686065674,
-0.3129815459251404,
0.3842948079109192,
-0.3072124421596527,
0.03740933537483215,
0.019294070079922676,
0.157241553068161,
-0.5076107382774353,
0.06445518136024475,
-0.019196191802620888,
0.09727244079113007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15538v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15538v1
|
DreamCraft: Text-Guided Generation of Functional 3D Environments in Minecraft
| 2024-04-23T21:57:14 | 2024-04-23T21:57:14 |
Sam Earle, Filippos Kokkinos, Yuhe Nie, Julian Togelius, Roberta Raileanu
|
cs.GR
|
cs.GR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Procedural Content Generation (PCG) algorithms enable the automatic
generation of complex and diverse artifacts. However, they don't provide
high-level control over the generated content and typically require domain
expertise. In contrast, text-to-3D methods allow users to specify desired
characteristics in natural language, offering a high amount of flexibility and
expressivity. But unlike PCG, such approaches cannot guarantee functionality,
which is crucial for certain applications like game design. In this paper, we
present a method for generating functional 3D artifacts from free-form text
prompts in the open-world game Minecraft. Our method, DreamCraft, trains
quantized Neural Radiance Fields (NeRFs) to represent artifacts that, when
viewed in-game, match given text descriptions. We find that DreamCraft produces
more aligned in-game artifacts than a baseline that post-processes the output
of an unconstrained NeRF. Thanks to the quantized representation of the
environment, functional constraints can be integrated using specialized loss
terms. We show how this can be leveraged to generate 3D structures that match a
target distribution or obey certain adjacency rules over the block types.
DreamCraft inherits a high degree of expressivity and controllability from the
NeRF, while still being able to incorporate functional constraints through
domain-specific objectives.
|
[
-0.25550514459609985,
-1.055548906326294,
0.5186149477958679,
0.2513926327228546,
-0.18955376744270325,
-0.1332693099975586,
-0.23597903549671173,
-0.3178287446498871,
0.041571181267499924,
0.8279146552085876,
-0.7812333703041077,
-0.7077537775039673,
0.0063614691607654095,
0.1320432722568512,
0.0798807442188263,
0.8495774865150452,
-0.10405194014310837,
-0.5400647521018982,
-0.6933478713035583,
0.12423408031463623,
-0.534721851348877,
-0.32782629132270813,
-0.48740896582603455,
-0.10302853584289551,
0.2803511619567871,
0.30082958936691284,
0.8905255794525146,
0.6864698529243469,
0.5947434902191162,
0.31577035784721375,
0.10848566889762878,
0.4713384807109833,
-0.3349606394767761,
0.3590584397315979,
0.08498181402683258,
-0.40482428669929504,
-0.4843194782733917,
-0.19271813333034515,
0.21060192584991455,
0.2593227028846741,
0.028215082362294197,
0.2593676745891571,
0.3562607169151306,
0.5052340626716614,
-0.5980669260025024,
0.26487067341804504,
-0.1734621822834015,
0.6430668234825134,
-0.2098284810781479,
-0.42411676049232483,
-0.22693005204200745,
-0.32231271266937256,
0.16327431797981262,
-1.13011634349823,
0.5181854963302612,
0.1447332799434662,
0.6465702056884766,
0.33647873997688293,
-0.23341256380081177,
-0.18023331463336945,
-0.6370152831077576,
0.6868719458580017,
-0.7700616121292114,
-0.03671218827366829,
0.30504292249679565,
0.28420108556747437,
-0.1944309026002884,
-0.6557133197784424,
-0.5809978246688843,
-0.15915852785110474,
-0.05137829855084419,
0.4179890751838684,
0.045434996485710144,
0.5107505321502686,
0.4574858248233795,
0.4966493248939514,
-0.6967301368713379,
-0.3612154424190521,
-0.21961134672164917,
-0.20012082159519196,
0.560768187046051,
0.48414623737335205,
0.22538910806179047,
-0.4928383529186249,
-0.4201551377773285,
-0.4106293022632599,
-0.836405336856842,
-0.056510552763938904,
0.452740341424942,
0.3354177474975586,
-0.2087792605161667,
0.8169759511947632,
0.07104896754026413,
1.0276144742965698,
-0.10298873484134674,
-0.05180962756276131,
-0.010287744924426079,
-0.051551587879657745,
-0.29102593660354614,
-0.08883938938379288,
0.7732600569725037,
0.566419780254364,
0.008742621168494225,
-0.0960778146982193,
-0.2268604040145874,
0.01332978904247284,
0.4706418812274933,
-0.8139662742614746,
-0.19560670852661133,
0.14220793545246124,
-0.7838499546051025,
-0.6460559964179993,
-0.10557421296834946,
-0.727483868598938,
-0.6223840117454529,
-0.1415456235408783,
0.4277557134628296,
-0.566942572593689,
-0.22162944078445435,
0.2496461421251297,
-0.28597909212112427,
-0.23459495604038239,
0.2686429023742676,
-0.8460682034492493,
0.13711483776569366,
0.4048446714878082,
1.0390993356704712,
-0.05616724491119385,
0.31667035818099976,
-0.2674259841442108,
0.31366780400276184,
-0.28665825724601746,
0.6172881126403809,
-0.583961546421051,
-0.7299572825431824,
0.05799032747745514,
-0.5456773638725281,
0.4645960032939911,
-0.6578410267829895,
0.11188953369855881,
-0.22744977474212646,
0.4770670533180237,
-0.01985049806535244,
-0.3906068801879883,
-0.2161857634782791,
0.5125519633293152,
-0.6767475605010986,
0.794302761554718,
0.2915395498275757,
-0.6780136227607727,
0.3160841763019562,
-0.7999281883239746,
-0.3664935529232025,
0.3425229787826538,
-0.3835439383983612,
-0.21257033944129944,
0.6857613325119019,
0.10652857273817062,
0.16701100766658783,
-0.29222849011421204,
-0.2244945466518402,
-0.2723013758659363,
-0.33062097430229187,
0.12536472082138062,
-0.29281556606292725,
0.4146345555782318,
0.3153102993965149,
-0.4099506437778473,
0.10389387607574463,
-0.8851034641265869,
0.30785712599754333,
-0.12338230013847351,
-0.26805272698402405,
-0.4021608829498291,
0.5331709980964661,
0.1959829479455948,
0.25796443223953247,
-0.09790189564228058,
-0.6583198308944702,
0.09897725284099579,
-0.6599310636520386,
0.20138265192508698,
0.5038819313049316,
0.23709826171398163,
0.4092227816581726,
-0.5723603963851929,
0.8315327167510986,
-0.14530254900455475,
0.09258296340703964,
-0.013822855427861214,
-0.4941469430923462,
-0.3142915368080139,
-0.14320607483386993,
-0.067238949239254,
0.35596564412117004,
-1.0628594160079956,
0.16408449411392212,
-0.04616189002990723,
-0.3782857656478882,
-0.18648357689380646,
-0.30074265599250793,
0.39648184180259705,
0.6408351063728333,
0.289848268032074,
-0.2469642013311386,
-0.6703519225120544,
-0.7533290982246399,
-0.1298961490392685,
-0.10746123641729355,
-0.3811968266963959,
0.5936364531517029,
0.08045411109924316,
0.21539530158042908,
0.9739421010017395,
-0.6242721676826477,
-0.6535755395889282,
0.09493227303028107,
0.12039854377508163,
0.1802317500114441,
0.6943142414093018,
0.47314587235450745,
-0.7011563181877136,
-0.33509498834609985,
0.12997423112392426,
-0.7953447699546814,
-0.07130799442529678,
-0.3025904595851898,
-0.23487114906311035,
0.04549838602542877,
0.520497739315033,
-0.5211383104324341,
0.4533814787864685,
0.6715235710144043,
-0.6854943633079529,
0.2943863570690155,
-0.10981474816799164,
0.23957490921020508,
-1.0015674829483032,
0.10289932042360306,
-0.170000359416008,
-0.09124213457107544,
-0.40284135937690735,
0.2642619013786316,
-0.1908109486103058,
-0.2770073413848877,
-0.4008801281452179,
0.5715827941894531,
-0.399833619594574,
0.3009832203388214,
-0.37851157784461975,
0.251383900642395,
0.13453157246112823,
0.5012328624725342,
0.29902520775794983,
0.3596043884754181,
0.48774558305740356,
-0.7142711877822876,
0.28946614265441895,
0.34031763672828674,
-0.25137051939964294,
0.892155110836029,
-0.6139994263648987,
-0.05273419991135597,
-0.09558958560228348,
-0.10956138372421265,
-0.5329475402832031,
-0.09089384227991104,
0.11884836107492447,
-0.5058996677398682,
-0.10295805335044861,
-0.17813937366008759,
-0.525353193283081,
-0.3753877580165863,
-0.08407279849052429,
0.4192330837249756,
0.8218833208084106,
-0.24741487205028534,
0.5615848898887634,
0.022569824010133743,
0.23832783102989197,
-0.2354249209165573,
-0.9861270189285278,
-0.14463874697685242,
-0.26390376687049866,
-0.8071220517158508,
0.7679692506790161,
-0.37630021572113037,
-0.15574078261852264,
0.21883557736873627,
-0.19069042801856995,
0.01824926771223545,
0.03383776172995567,
0.7329371571540833,
0.12917417287826538,
-0.5945826172828674,
-0.01641489751636982,
0.08950285613536835,
0.10944128036499023,
0.22256532311439514,
-0.637941300868988,
0.24685142934322357,
0.06168657913804054,
-0.3344983756542206,
0.12319539487361908,
0.3088400959968567,
0.19570639729499817,
-0.2438288927078247,
0.2357945591211319,
0.33096277713775635,
-0.6834419369697571,
-0.530519425868988,
-0.1525847613811493,
-0.10262959450483322,
-0.6107405424118042,
0.34349074959754944,
-0.49486976861953735,
-0.9525793790817261,
0.45350587368011475,
0.04260409250855446,
0.4477848708629608,
0.297868013381958,
0.2651192843914032,
-0.1568615734577179,
1.0649011135101318,
0.662788987159729,
0.9820968508720398,
0.379718154668808,
-0.1639130711555481,
-0.06010182201862335,
-0.8150826692581177,
-0.34429243206977844,
-0.16598226130008698,
-0.7366635799407959,
-0.3222433924674988,
-0.7326733469963074,
0.4177512526512146,
0.05156346410512924,
-0.08931457996368408,
0.09058406949043274,
-0.7185916304588318,
0.5978742837905884,
0.5780087113380432,
0.32365885376930237,
0.07583996653556824,
0.3409689962863922,
-0.11553648859262466,
-0.48355168104171753,
-0.541893720626831,
-0.5060040354728699,
0.7402225136756897,
-0.23638463020324707,
0.6804947257041931,
0.16175340116024017,
0.9400561451911926,
0.23635181784629822,
0.360077440738678,
-0.4417082369327545,
0.5014692544937134,
-0.14788147807121277,
-0.5010982155799866,
-0.22686578333377838,
-0.42810702323913574,
-0.7971961498260498,
0.14078910648822784,
-0.589203953742981,
-0.33380573987960815,
0.11767067015171051,
0.6437138915061951,
-0.776414155960083,
0.5766854286193848,
-0.3946206867694855,
0.8214430212974548,
0.02507161907851696,
-0.6186836361885071,
-0.11046691983938217,
-0.06637919694185257,
0.3519934117794037,
0.1664579212665558,
0.04700218513607979,
0.09470407664775848,
-0.1103287860751152,
0.11981368064880371,
-0.40932905673980713,
0.6801924705505371,
-0.48063674569129944,
-0.06954523175954819,
0.7024447917938232,
0.8039565086364746,
0.22925297915935516,
0.3495566248893738,
-0.035692088305950165,
-0.23652955889701843,
-0.1858898401260376,
-0.3106626868247986,
-0.6193776726722717,
0.7153424620628357,
-0.48716574907302856,
-0.6502662897109985,
-0.2587534487247467,
-0.7941804528236389,
-0.3086426258087158,
0.3787574768066406,
0.40124785900115967,
0.6317938566207886,
-0.5220828056335449,
0.27061858773231506,
0.8404476046562195,
-0.5708737969398499,
0.531406581401825,
0.138113334774971,
-0.17813758552074432,
-0.5346377491950989,
0.9183064699172974,
-0.19806219637393951,
0.19676390290260315,
0.5643360614776611,
0.17486736178398132,
-0.09196004271507263,
-0.675213098526001,
-0.4244116544723511,
-0.319475382566452,
-0.29190608859062195,
-0.6449450254440308,
-0.32462963461875916,
-0.24581275880336761,
-0.10260193794965744,
-0.5096974968910217,
-0.02963699959218502,
-0.4925954341888428,
-0.30949699878692627,
-0.13230575621128082,
0.3252072334289551,
0.8566006422042847,
-0.2093624770641327,
0.2421698421239853,
-0.893485426902771,
0.289747416973114,
0.19357627630233765,
0.6455925703048706,
-0.16340786218643188,
0.044474996626377106,
-0.2517487406730652,
0.2418154627084732,
-0.3089578449726105,
-0.7633135318756104,
0.3827178180217743,
0.21167084574699402,
0.16170112788677216,
0.20381887257099152,
0.07757321745157242,
0.7663407325744629,
-0.4334975779056549,
0.9893805384635925,
0.265206515789032,
-0.8024628162384033,
0.6041467189788818,
-0.6115212440490723,
0.5146310925483704,
0.24007229506969452,
-0.30113646388053894,
-0.7404043078422546,
-0.3876580595970154,
-0.6275953054428101,
-0.8003605604171753,
0.8391616940498352,
0.35294005274772644,
0.2748730778694153,
-0.442573606967926,
0.3751354515552521,
0.11605968326330185,
0.17952115833759308,
-0.7646626830101013,
0.011242805048823357,
-0.5253852009773254,
-0.4456809163093567,
0.3265475630760193,
-0.07756420969963074,
-0.2754606604576111,
0.42707058787345886,
0.3945198059082031,
-0.22548948228359222,
0.36910077929496765,
0.5485802888870239,
-0.2193189114332199,
-0.15091978013515472,
-0.22393254935741425,
0.6899710297584534,
0.19012580811977386,
-0.09218072146177292,
0.23709915578365326,
-0.08019806444644928,
-0.47167304158210754,
-0.04590951278805733,
-0.11562696844339371,
-0.3739830553531647,
-0.00036806604475714266,
0.19576287269592285,
0.6274979114532471,
-0.12304850667715073,
-0.6092295050621033,
0.4753929078578949,
-0.09609455615282059,
-0.7071501016616821,
-0.12374994158744812,
0.3517272472381592,
-0.1399693638086319,
0.27204394340515137,
0.01631123200058937,
0.44536837935447693,
0.0620209239423275,
0.08879156410694122,
0.09355728328227997,
0.40308043360710144,
-0.6097542643547058,
-0.24517129361629486,
1.0841748714447021,
0.3896559476852417,
-0.3425789773464203,
0.7826851606369019,
-0.15442998707294464,
0.20585116744041443,
0.7548123598098755,
0.8748968839645386,
1.0775843858718872,
0.19806115329265594,
0.4841671884059906,
0.6108978986740112,
0.26026445627212524,
0.24009621143341064,
0.6689580082893372,
-0.15684564411640167,
-0.3226427733898163,
-0.39596420526504517,
-0.6879016757011414,
-0.07462576031684875,
-0.11795423924922943,
-0.3849138021469116,
0.12413939088582993,
-0.797675609588623,
-0.1783265322446823,
-0.5344710350036621,
-0.32450631260871887,
-0.7311399579048157,
0.2478802353143692,
0.39151856303215027,
0.8938416242599487,
-0.4075066149234772,
0.290805459022522,
0.7612199783325195,
-0.5179876089096069,
-0.2853437662124634,
-0.14251232147216797,
0.2116875946521759,
-0.3502187132835388,
0.32406389713287354,
-0.07604635506868362,
0.17158840596675873,
0.010757296346127987,
-0.3993526101112366,
-0.909792959690094,
1.0617223978042603,
0.20715147256851196,
-0.3071736693382263,
-0.20216615498065948,
0.36701852083206177,
0.6574435234069824,
-0.25138235092163086,
0.01556708849966526,
-0.311588853597641,
0.4331253468990326,
-0.14362658560276031,
-0.24766144156455994,
0.3197154104709625,
-0.4603908360004425,
0.3485965132713318,
0.3374759554862976,
-0.40380942821502686,
0.7188071012496948,
-0.19664983451366425,
-0.4013436436653137,
0.1313943713903427,
0.9981525540351868,
0.361327201128006,
0.030142726376652718,
0.61087965965271,
0.4957655072212219,
0.42152026295661926,
-0.41598808765411377,
0.927733302116394,
-0.3789244592189789,
-0.10678955912590027,
0.8401480913162231,
0.03129132464528084,
0.4512714743614197,
0.37686723470687866,
0.22279079258441925,
0.5807257890701294,
0.5721839070320129,
-0.21021424233913422,
0.6317147016525269,
0.616504967212677,
-0.35577717423439026,
-0.04548176750540733,
0.1032847985625267,
-0.2986835837364197,
0.15189112722873688,
0.39270493388175964,
-0.2517390549182892,
-0.1205366849899292,
0.28096404671669006,
0.0034980622585862875,
0.4173773527145386,
-0.17648421227931976,
0.5887016654014587,
-0.11775048822164536,
-0.8551433682441711,
0.20179176330566406,
0.016364220529794693,
0.8242822885513306,
-0.7697769999504089,
-0.3715033233165741,
-0.46463486552238464,
0.192994624376297,
-0.4611753225326538,
-0.6075736880302429,
0.536954939365387,
-0.11987186223268509,
-0.22873032093048096,
-0.7182189226150513,
0.34323379397392273,
-0.5028480887413025,
-0.3175821304321289,
-0.44208937883377075,
0.28628507256507874,
-0.2157917618751526,
-0.21713504195213318,
-0.42518842220306396,
-0.2134471982717514,
0.06716108322143555,
-0.3285588324069977,
0.06797391921281815,
0.7305294275283813,
-0.10789736360311508,
0.12708725035190582,
0.5497351288795471,
0.10174290835857391,
0.11774606257677078,
-0.24805057048797607,
0.46086838841438293,
-0.689547598361969,
-0.5642615556716919,
-0.5992177128791809,
0.6793197989463806,
-0.15671665966510773,
-0.4630814492702484,
0.6825565099716187,
0.7217932939529419,
0.8114047646522522,
-0.38177239894866943,
0.9091931581497192,
-0.6229760050773621,
-0.1302337497472763,
-0.46809279918670654,
0.6445762515068054,
-0.5067322850227356,
0.10247991979122162,
-0.3232159912586212,
-0.9671286940574646,
-0.6786127090454102,
0.7126796245574951,
0.46177712082862854,
-0.005212877411395311,
0.6559550762176514,
0.8890227675437927,
-0.1495666652917862,
-0.016163351014256477,
0.3717688024044037,
-0.05696101114153862,
0.5066039562225342,
0.7373106479644775,
0.7492609620094299,
-0.20637038350105286,
0.7557872533798218,
-0.35933491587638855,
-0.20777086913585663,
0.26516079902648926,
-0.9697001576423645,
-0.9577799439430237,
-0.5520921349525452,
-0.5471142530441284,
-0.6918193697929382,
0.07349283248186111,
0.6722428798675537,
0.7471843361854553,
-0.5197115540504456,
-0.20476311445236206,
-0.48752376437187195,
-0.07445384562015533,
-0.5462777018547058,
-0.2787242531776428,
0.3934769928455353,
-0.29674232006073,
-0.6888769268989563,
0.4220053553581238,
0.3889945447444916,
0.3602920174598694,
-0.19331909716129303,
-0.04551692679524422,
0.47574618458747864,
0.09260959178209305,
0.725548267364502,
0.2448892444372177,
-0.44341668486595154,
-0.4041668772697449,
0.35107097029685974,
-0.0751652717590332,
-0.10623873025178909,
0.94509357213974,
-1.0915228128433228,
0.6829636693000793,
0.7988531589508057,
0.2621001601219177,
0.31816425919532776,
-0.3453279137611389,
0.9955378770828247,
-1.2013514041900635,
0.08993431180715561,
0.5219342708587646,
-0.041969332844018936,
0.1353331208229065,
-0.30066171288490295,
0.5055121183395386,
0.1304699033498764,
-0.19556258618831635,
-0.6564114689826965,
0.3790816068649292,
-0.7231643199920654,
-0.17930176854133606,
0.9451680779457092,
0.09141652286052704,
-0.23758260905742645,
0.17301100492477417,
-0.5033970475196838,
-0.06708437949419022,
0.15531179308891296,
0.8803979754447937,
0.4625052213668823,
-0.24964378774166107,
-0.029666893184185028,
-0.4141559302806854,
1.0437458753585815,
0.19789130985736847,
-0.8217228055000305,
0.17337903380393982,
1.0187345743179321,
-0.18126563727855682,
0.12516288459300995,
0.5277391672134399,
-0.45637646317481995,
0.3558956980705261,
0.22401641309261322,
0.4496525228023529,
-0.49125251173973083,
0.08218041062355042,
0.03942401334643364,
0.4450699985027313,
-0.21930630505084991,
-0.24501048028469086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15532v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15532v1
|
BattleAgent: Multi-modal Dynamic Emulation on Historical Battles to Complement Historical Analysis
| 2024-04-23T21:37:22 | 2024-04-23T21:37:22 |
Shuhang Lin, Wenyue Hua, Lingyao Li, Che-Jui Chang, Lizhou Fan, Jianchao Ji, Hang Hua, Mingyu Jin, Jiebo Luo, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MA
|
This paper presents BattleAgent, an emulation system that combines the Large
Vision-Language Model and Multi-agent System. This novel system aims to
simulate complex dynamic interactions among multiple agents, as well as between
agents and their environments, over a period of time. It emulates both the
decision-making processes of leaders and the viewpoints of ordinary
participants, such as soldiers. The emulation showcases the current
capabilities of agents, featuring fine-grained multi-modal interactions between
agents and landscapes. It develops customizable agent structures to meet
specific situational requirements, for example, a variety of battle-related
activities like scouting and trench digging. These components collaborate to
recreate historical events in a lively and comprehensive manner while offering
insights into the thoughts and feelings of individuals from diverse viewpoints.
The technological foundations of BattleAgent establish detailed and immersive
settings for historical battles, enabling individual agents to partake in,
observe, and dynamically respond to evolving battle scenarios. This methodology
holds the potential to substantially deepen our understanding of historical
events, particularly through individual accounts. Such initiatives can also aid
historical research, as conventional historical narratives often lack
documentation and prioritize the perspectives of decision-makers, thereby
overlooking the experiences of ordinary individuals. BattelAgent illustrates
AI's potential to revitalize the human aspect in crucial social events, thereby
fostering a more nuanced collective understanding and driving the progressive
development of human society.
|
[
-0.5676659941673279,
-1.2224892377853394,
0.7010213732719421,
0.11224041134119034,
0.07379306107759476,
0.5893195271492004,
0.11759971082210541,
-0.2693564295768738,
0.7936680912971497,
0.5476560592651367,
-0.6398152709007263,
-0.10285916924476624,
-0.15641489624977112,
-0.43663352727890015,
0.041077278554439545,
0.709116518497467,
-0.23939861357212067,
-0.25366121530532837,
-0.06811854988336563,
-0.06684179604053497,
-0.45403778553009033,
-1.0871416330337524,
-0.593827486038208,
-0.7954323887825012,
0.1876479834318161,
0.14273743331432343,
0.7754098176956177,
0.7288740873336792,
0.4655526578426361,
0.555719792842865,
0.18556568026542664,
0.059548359364271164,
-0.4367135763168335,
0.6749097108840942,
-0.3967631161212921,
-0.37102586030960083,
-0.6189658045768738,
0.042979445308446884,
0.5819324851036072,
0.19865836203098297,
-0.11220746487379074,
0.02607891522347927,
-0.2265898585319519,
0.08502398431301117,
-0.26440760493278503,
0.30155882239341736,
-0.10681474953889847,
0.2746787667274475,
-0.05247073248028755,
-0.5189239978790283,
-0.13036711513996124,
0.06115012243390083,
0.28691673278808594,
-0.8279464840888977,
0.37198102474212646,
-0.018081294372677803,
0.6506730914115906,
0.09780962020158768,
-0.515589714050293,
0.26421093940734863,
-1.010007619857788,
0.6033090949058533,
-0.15198972821235657,
0.11124782264232635,
0.21584166586399078,
0.7214484810829163,
-0.0995541587471962,
-1.0056887865066528,
-0.32602715492248535,
-0.3492409586906433,
0.2957330644130707,
0.6534870266914368,
-0.5042524337768555,
-0.0029252844396978617,
0.2532823383808136,
0.049585551023483276,
-0.2201918512582779,
-0.1145252212882042,
-0.19887034595012665,
-0.14614613354206085,
0.5493569374084473,
0.682820737361908,
0.470844030380249,
-0.13333657383918762,
-0.9529902338981628,
-0.3654164671897888,
-0.16240450739860535,
0.15798798203468323,
0.325313538312912,
-0.06943535804748535,
-0.3725908100605011,
0.5932875871658325,
-0.2400074005126953,
0.3010810911655426,
0.1957012265920639,
0.01273238006979227,
-0.006038514431566,
-0.2600271701812744,
-0.22532595694065094,
0.12323570251464844,
0.616813063621521,
0.5853024125099182,
-0.10627473890781403,
-0.25419577956199646,
-0.06791716814041138,
0.3359124958515167,
0.556768000125885,
-0.9871675372123718,
-0.2994561791419983,
0.07815692573785782,
-0.4063339829444885,
-0.4939078390598297,
-0.0845535397529602,
-1.3925838470458984,
-0.6083261370658875,
-0.33250728249549866,
0.5447798371315002,
-0.5785814523696899,
-0.2950204610824585,
-0.28645551204681396,
-0.7192678451538086,
0.2873256504535675,
0.8321018815040588,
-0.47386863827705383,
0.22385665774345398,
0.49682295322418213,
1.0484522581100464,
-0.14133170247077942,
-0.6755330562591553,
-0.4512966275215149,
0.4463207423686981,
-0.12337183207273483,
0.6696972250938416,
-0.6528749465942383,
-0.567723274230957,
-0.1576336771249771,
0.06725464016199112,
0.2367212325334549,
-0.20979560911655426,
0.30041074752807617,
-0.7686702013015747,
-0.2510756552219391,
-0.07498978078365326,
-0.5480161905288696,
-0.2569151520729065,
0.6929805278778076,
-1.1374715566635132,
0.4461418688297272,
-0.09598509967327118,
-0.334886759519577,
0.25752440094947815,
-0.6509601473808289,
-0.24650119245052338,
0.49656814336776733,
-0.42619016766548157,
-0.27623099088668823,
-0.12339500337839127,
0.03645522519946098,
0.19534634053707123,
-0.1696104258298874,
0.07777845859527588,
-0.30177757143974304,
-0.1433250904083252,
0.09785272926092148,
-0.4250900447368622,
0.42906785011291504,
0.061574239283800125,
-0.7818441987037659,
0.17314118146896362,
-0.43603456020355225,
-0.1743764728307724,
0.3327938914299011,
-0.17362816631793976,
-0.20706269145011902,
0.23870804905891418,
0.18190577626228333,
0.024775449186563492,
0.23665347695350647,
-0.24223944544792175,
0.6374860405921936,
-0.13673198223114014,
0.15831473469734192,
0.5304029583930969,
0.3368384540081024,
0.23657236993312836,
-0.7562131881713867,
0.7601712346076965,
-0.0990913137793541,
0.0036738133057951927,
-0.4683854877948761,
-0.36167430877685547,
-0.497557669878006,
-0.16840045154094696,
-0.012764707207679749,
0.5981425046920776,
-1.1044968366622925,
-0.12496145069599152,
-0.23468570411205292,
-0.501823365688324,
0.1759505718946457,
-0.34669816493988037,
-0.08008406311273575,
-0.12639714777469635,
0.28131723403930664,
-0.3290706276893616,
-0.9085726737976074,
-0.5636371970176697,
0.048708584159612656,
-0.6132339239120483,
0.33364224433898926,
0.28026634454727173,
0.40288496017456055,
-0.3271307051181793,
0.9771509170532227,
-0.13610495626926422,
-0.23624038696289062,
-0.319601446390152,
0.3825213313102722,
-0.448525607585907,
0.49694952368736267,
0.8182216286659241,
-0.9466572999954224,
0.16030573844909668,
0.35142454504966736,
-0.6916463971138,
0.22625526785850525,
-0.4035758674144745,
-0.04317834973335266,
-0.17724011838436127,
0.4475398361682892,
-0.24632827937602997,
0.4409253001213074,
0.4181760549545288,
-0.5795373916625977,
0.45055100321769714,
-0.3355991542339325,
0.9930000305175781,
-1.1944775581359863,
0.16078127920627594,
-0.3258638083934784,
-0.10416296124458313,
-0.7704437375068665,
0.25065264105796814,
-0.3438432216644287,
-0.3265041410923004,
-0.38270777463912964,
0.6764993071556091,
-0.19105425477027893,
0.26081418991088867,
-0.2749043405056,
0.265982985496521,
0.1418265849351883,
0.27466025948524475,
-0.028348397463560104,
0.44495078921318054,
0.14157874882221222,
-0.07903683185577393,
1.1756030321121216,
0.1923571079969406,
0.11520276963710785,
0.8817319869995117,
-0.49287140369415283,
0.021777639165520668,
0.080710768699646,
0.08902212232351303,
-0.8108417987823486,
-0.3833872973918915,
0.11695913225412369,
-0.5500598549842834,
0.057126447558403015,
-0.33115509152412415,
-0.2946923077106476,
-0.041700754314661026,
-0.28968545794487,
0.5529118180274963,
0.45242783427238464,
-0.36065924167633057,
1.2013168334960938,
0.5408906936645508,
-0.04839877039194107,
-0.24312865734100342,
-0.609126627445221,
0.43472328782081604,
-0.3239216208457947,
-0.4534352719783783,
0.2935483157634735,
0.0077093616127967834,
-0.5632259845733643,
-0.11840973049402237,
0.20804302394390106,
-0.4297274053096771,
-0.14869260787963867,
0.655475914478302,
0.44074875116348267,
-0.34211984276771545,
0.05596829578280449,
-0.37889766693115234,
0.09881103783845901,
-0.08611346036195755,
0.03314831480383873,
0.5319925546646118,
-0.3146820068359375,
-0.5246915817260742,
-0.35078269243240356,
0.5822673439979553,
1.0312612056732178,
-0.24107268452644348,
0.32272768020629883,
0.40066230297088623,
-0.34679853916168213,
0.08825568109750748,
-0.7949690222740173,
-0.09892464429140091,
-0.3983161449432373,
0.507335364818573,
-0.44242751598358154,
-0.5628535151481628,
0.6015745997428894,
-0.6760834455490112,
0.016606297343969345,
0.537390410900116,
0.88663649559021,
0.030338158831000328,
0.942406952381134,
0.32782822847366333,
-0.1840498000383377,
0.6290130615234375,
-0.34570345282554626,
-0.44905945658683777,
-0.4410790205001831,
-0.49175307154655457,
-0.1381869912147522,
-0.6112678050994873,
-0.34541764855384827,
-0.49918848276138306,
0.41905465722084045,
-0.2913419306278229,
-0.3493557572364807,
-0.26348206400871277,
0.038244981318712234,
0.23621048033237457,
0.39077261090278625,
0.2747049033641815,
0.2290823757648468,
0.0722612515091896,
0.05705590918660164,
-0.1745600700378418,
-0.5234927535057068,
-0.537476658821106,
0.6796258091926575,
0.061761047691106796,
0.9502743482589722,
0.33030733466148376,
0.7854461669921875,
0.9530154466629028,
-0.054030969738960266,
-0.8732824325561523,
0.4117838442325592,
0.27940553426742554,
-0.651818573474884,
-0.18463201820850372,
-0.2758541703224182,
-1.3000134229660034,
0.22182708978652954,
-0.38690492510795593,
-0.6379461884498596,
0.2620668113231659,
0.14549656212329865,
-0.6393769979476929,
0.6591601967811584,
-0.6908156275749207,
0.9976811408996582,
-0.28867870569229126,
-0.5443037152290344,
-0.3782583773136139,
-0.6885903477668762,
-0.08297927677631378,
0.2515939176082611,
0.05369730666279793,
0.28274106979370117,
-0.23355112969875336,
0.41560670733451843,
-0.07015657424926758,
0.9398823976516724,
0.01529148779809475,
0.6206158399581909,
0.29101213812828064,
0.540775716304779,
0.49064767360687256,
-0.2844983637332916,
0.1495743989944458,
-0.10185849666595459,
0.2557598352432251,
-0.37406742572784424,
-0.6030951142311096,
0.759912371635437,
-1.1453574895858765,
-0.5937516689300537,
-0.4827820658683777,
-0.32364723086357117,
0.19891119003295898,
0.00918468926101923,
-0.21966855227947235,
0.6912534832954407,
-1.1494319438934326,
0.08426475524902344,
0.16505691409111023,
0.1491634100675583,
0.49105751514434814,
0.3167743980884552,
-0.28441306948661804,
-0.5482907295227051,
0.8399257063865662,
0.17256183922290802,
0.1574435830116272,
0.2933291792869568,
0.08826249092817307,
0.27109745144844055,
-0.1954416036605835,
-1.0419563055038452,
-0.26164260506629944,
-0.5826417207717896,
-0.12898683547973633,
-0.4387741684913635,
0.05199500918388367,
0.2339649498462677,
-0.4579530954360962,
-0.2613523006439209,
-0.1676088571548462,
-0.040278222411870956,
-0.0018268304411321878,
0.38772958517074585,
0.9528871178627014,
-0.002813358325511217,
0.43053627014160156,
-0.4937674105167389,
0.3554436266422272,
0.40241122245788574,
0.08286399394273758,
-0.11790058016777039,
-0.04884141683578491,
-0.09241098910570145,
-0.07438869774341583,
-0.5296702980995178,
-1.3248064517974854,
0.42432525753974915,
-0.21745307743549347,
0.7517008781433105,
0.36226901412010193,
-0.10660815984010696,
0.5954501032829285,
-0.6587104201316833,
0.8614532351493835,
0.0971427783370018,
-0.8190180659294128,
0.5544787049293518,
-0.20987434685230255,
0.1640101671218872,
0.26035767793655396,
-0.026547374203801155,
-0.4446330964565277,
-0.17617957293987274,
-0.966082751750946,
-0.9144290089607239,
0.7737531065940857,
0.024965623393654823,
-0.1559237837791443,
0.2710370421409607,
0.08126292377710342,
-0.08960763365030289,
-0.013446317054331303,
-0.03166741877794266,
-0.20828814804553986,
-0.5130046606063843,
0.06913360208272934,
-0.2197365164756775,
0.10816723108291626,
-0.350202351808548,
0.018203921616077423,
0.4109334647655487,
0.02828977070748806,
0.1283872127532959,
0.21164657175540924,
-0.14633458852767944,
-0.1810319423675537,
0.22975921630859375,
0.4636625647544861,
0.6504175662994385,
-0.009442399255931377,
0.4329891800880432,
0.5231232047080994,
-0.7472184896469116,
0.39574679732322693,
0.44950875639915466,
-0.09074430167675018,
-0.05122935399413109,
0.3820441663265228,
0.9434412717819214,
0.2656618058681488,
-0.7077365517616272,
0.6349442601203918,
-0.14951331913471222,
0.0873248428106308,
-0.405169814825058,
-0.09502808004617691,
-0.17466598749160767,
1.3742711544036865,
0.5302358865737915,
0.20105931162834167,
0.03894957900047302,
-0.8337016105651855,
0.38661688566207886,
0.3814597725868225,
-0.5175585746765137,
-0.31864166259765625,
0.7133880257606506,
0.3753817677497864,
-0.7777608036994934,
-0.05053098499774933,
0.15259000658988953,
-0.5578445196151733,
0.9526965022087097,
0.4170076549053192,
0.5964523553848267,
-0.5364252924919128,
0.2000180184841156,
0.03384719043970108,
0.34457769989967346,
0.1456657201051712,
-0.05051921680569649,
0.03497001901268959,
-0.3877889811992645,
-0.17697837948799133,
-0.4008379578590393,
-0.7587249279022217,
0.2036067694425583,
-0.5113441348075867,
-0.027029508724808693,
-0.27616849541664124,
-0.5576816201210022,
0.05261242762207985,
0.2753794491291046,
-0.881729006767273,
0.044367048889398575,
0.1720251739025116,
0.5006811618804932,
-0.623001217842102,
0.40293869376182556,
1.1109596490859985,
-0.5954684019088745,
-0.35913026332855225,
0.011765844188630581,
0.3204812705516815,
-0.5437813997268677,
0.4930773079395294,
-0.35359835624694824,
-0.2882417142391205,
0.06942497193813324,
-0.1532009094953537,
-0.34843599796295166,
1.199415922164917,
0.42633306980133057,
-0.3693782091140747,
0.04163220897316933,
-0.21811676025390625,
0.44641515612602234,
-0.28974947333335876,
0.3993062376976013,
0.5985725522041321,
0.6694214344024658,
0.20810547471046448,
-0.690241813659668,
-0.10181926935911179,
-0.1332215815782547,
-0.1838206797838211,
0.20376089215278625,
-0.9624180197715759,
0.7643357515335083,
-0.19380798935890198,
-0.20905601978302002,
0.23039035499095917,
0.5017061829566956,
0.04583505913615227,
0.39343467354774475,
0.32509344816207886,
0.46259328722953796,
0.3627490997314453,
-0.40601417422294617,
0.9932148456573486,
-0.04496290162205696,
0.318956196308136,
0.7007368803024292,
-0.16794750094413757,
0.502692699432373,
0.47739455103874207,
-0.2161278873682022,
0.35349687933921814,
0.23995570838451385,
-0.15389297902584076,
0.23613570630550385,
-0.2469535917043686,
-0.604948878288269,
-0.35113275051116943,
0.014614465646445751,
-0.5333403944969177,
0.7822427749633789,
-0.05721331760287285,
-0.2383398413658142,
-0.5084025859832764,
-0.017186278477311134,
0.044137388467788696,
-0.10490255802869797,
-0.4479154050350189,
1.0016673803329468,
-0.5570959448814392,
-0.23297248780727386,
0.012224753387272358,
-0.2156422734260559,
0.2563095688819885,
-0.8924676775932312,
-0.4200536906719208,
-0.03534248098731041,
0.23434431850910187,
0.23400527238845825,
-0.6223880052566528,
-0.2649465799331665,
-0.3700728416442871,
-0.28910019993782043,
-0.035355500876903534,
0.5121030807495117,
-0.4815809726715088,
-0.22260737419128418,
0.1620405912399292,
1.1306928396224976,
0.1041698232293129,
0.08888320624828339,
-0.3808007538318634,
0.6400912404060364,
-0.20510981976985931,
-0.43821340799331665,
0.12224716693162918,
0.8197553157806396,
-0.006244281772524118,
0.2091948688030243,
0.25480708479881287,
0.12585878372192383,
-0.10257028788328171,
0.12425733357667923,
0.7664605379104614,
-0.9478529095649719,
-0.5960298180580139,
-1.2684558629989624,
0.17871147394180298,
-0.35510918498039246,
-0.21415355801582336,
0.5689913630485535,
0.7286878824234009,
0.5089540481567383,
0.00638126116245985,
1.0174225568771362,
0.05603082850575447,
-0.07980579137802124,
-0.06627709418535233,
0.8870097398757935,
-0.4549201428890228,
-0.4502754807472229,
-0.2077418863773346,
-0.31251898407936096,
-0.0030999903101474047,
0.3408331274986267,
0.15120230615139008,
0.07476875931024551,
0.29951170086860657,
0.2207302451133728,
-0.21733303368091583,
0.15025904774665833,
0.545038104057312,
0.19671475887298584,
0.3977460265159607,
0.37882983684539795,
1.2958296537399292,
-0.09393288940191269,
0.4734136164188385,
0.13706925511360168,
-0.5858672261238098,
-0.6459630131721497,
-0.48821771144866943,
-0.8575893044471741,
-0.7793275713920593,
0.1971282660961151,
-0.07122254371643066,
0.401877224445343,
1.190230369567871,
0.623957633972168,
-0.46254241466522217,
-0.5471771359443665,
0.6787123084068298,
-0.12781371176242828,
-0.26143941283226013,
-0.18154948949813843,
0.254609078168869,
-0.12377621233463287,
-0.810777485370636,
0.6373341679573059,
0.4401147663593292,
0.298202782869339,
-0.31739193201065063,
-0.0403531938791275,
-0.0595773309469223,
0.18077567219734192,
0.9028345942497253,
0.40069112181663513,
-0.7111596465110779,
-0.44581785798072815,
-0.3144977390766144,
0.04195863753557205,
0.2155841439962387,
1.2364466190338135,
-1.0789830684661865,
1.015955924987793,
0.2659897208213806,
0.9320394992828369,
0.8877533078193665,
0.17205330729484558,
0.5500549674034119,
-0.5027603507041931,
0.2780120074748993,
0.34795790910720825,
0.4636661410331726,
0.0922246128320694,
-0.17594873905181885,
0.25185003876686096,
0.482453852891922,
-0.5553962588310242,
-0.5609670877456665,
0.18385277688503265,
-1.0921754837036133,
-0.1785268634557724,
0.9029368758201599,
0.056134406477212906,
-0.021339453756809235,
-0.27568063139915466,
-0.7260832190513611,
0.55637127161026,
-0.4873463213443756,
0.7288023829460144,
0.8692482113838196,
-0.29823511838912964,
0.05377247929573059,
-0.8967947363853455,
0.14835765957832336,
0.015126793645322323,
-0.9256882071495056,
-0.12419498711824417,
1.0044339895248413,
-0.12220901995897293,
0.27616631984710693,
0.1716611534357071,
0.27960675954818726,
0.454129159450531,
0.42896509170532227,
0.40552976727485657,
-0.3735995888710022,
-0.26444292068481445,
-0.09513366967439651,
0.6275166273117065,
-0.46155068278312683,
-0.2113674134016037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15522v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15522v2
|
LogicBench: Towards Systematic Evaluation of Logical Reasoning Ability of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-23T21:08:49 | 2024-06-06T08:15:54 |
Mihir Parmar, Nisarg Patel, Neeraj Varshney, Mutsumi Nakamura, Man Luo, Santosh Mashetty, Arindam Mitra, Chitta Baral
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently developed large language models (LLMs) have been shown to perform
remarkably well on a wide range of language understanding tasks. But, can they
really "reason" over the natural language? This question has been receiving
significant research attention and many reasoning skills such as commonsense,
numerical, and qualitative have been studied. However, the crucial skill
pertaining to 'logical reasoning' has remained underexplored. Existing work
investigating this reasoning ability of LLMs has focused only on a couple of
inference rules (such as modus ponens and modus tollens) of propositional and
first-order logic. Addressing the above limitation, we comprehensively evaluate
the logical reasoning ability of LLMs on 25 different reasoning patterns
spanning over propositional, first-order, and non-monotonic logics. To enable
systematic evaluation, we introduce LogicBench, a natural language
question-answering dataset focusing on the use of a single inference rule. We
conduct detailed analysis with a range of LLMs such as GPT-4, ChatGPT, Gemini,
Llama-2, and Mistral using chain-of-thought prompting. Experimental results
show that existing LLMs do not fare well on LogicBench; especially, they
struggle with instances involving complex reasoning and negations. Furthermore,
they sometimes overlook contextual information necessary for reasoning to
arrive at the correct conclusion. We believe that our work and findings
facilitate future research for evaluating and enhancing the logical reasoning
ability of LLMs. Data and code are available at
https://github.com/Mihir3009/LogicBench.
|
[
-0.39360347390174866,
-1.0964750051498413,
0.8758368492126465,
0.2145427167415619,
-0.4422248899936676,
-0.2286922037601471,
-0.2133198231458664,
-0.2941274642944336,
-0.17061646282672882,
0.5812559127807617,
-0.7011342644691467,
-0.5620310306549072,
-0.41919106245040894,
0.28473755717277527,
-0.5353384017944336,
0.576501190662384,
0.161173477768898,
0.22453951835632324,
-0.3152247667312622,
-0.20374365150928497,
-0.576649010181427,
-0.43298614025115967,
-0.4934924840927124,
-0.345868855714798,
0.3224593698978424,
0.28761062026023865,
0.40420666337013245,
0.34947827458381653,
0.4382973909378052,
0.34461405873298645,
-0.23099327087402344,
0.1786896288394928,
-0.4267203211784363,
0.13779668509960175,
-0.6749812960624695,
-0.6408805847167969,
-0.3871166706085205,
0.009999241679906845,
0.5282245874404907,
0.7594144940376282,
-0.19899164140224457,
0.13684320449829102,
-0.34680840373039246,
0.6997143030166626,
-0.43706515431404114,
0.12719005346298218,
-0.772766649723053,
0.037969399243593216,
-0.2153765708208084,
-0.02613835036754608,
-0.6269079446792603,
-0.4756454527378082,
0.03210243955254555,
-0.5515303015708923,
-0.044193118810653687,
0.34303098917007446,
0.5144185423851013,
0.3182000517845154,
-0.3785306215286255,
-0.1915150284767151,
-0.45200586318969727,
0.8175737857818604,
-0.9881419539451599,
0.3098723292350769,
0.15856915712356567,
0.5099543333053589,
-0.4445299506187439,
-0.5784755349159241,
-0.6971839070320129,
-0.277951180934906,
-0.13255028426647186,
0.10016221553087234,
-0.22833673655986786,
0.10883107036352158,
0.6787327527999878,
0.31395673751831055,
-0.597873330116272,
-0.10300815850496292,
-0.2216690182685852,
-0.08076930046081543,
0.5188184380531311,
0.18071603775024414,
0.2014317661523819,
-0.17649447917938232,
-0.43886086344718933,
0.06736795604228973,
-0.5395005941390991,
0.10499489307403564,
0.09849834442138672,
0.022745540365576744,
0.10635355859994888,
0.5910109281539917,
-0.3497028648853302,
0.9475679397583008,
-0.16487960517406464,
-0.3194821774959564,
0.030069584026932716,
-0.378055602312088,
-0.2999034523963928,
0.021388180553913116,
0.5862516164779663,
0.16416287422180176,
0.4369768500328064,
-0.09355095773935318,
-0.17840518057346344,
0.3064139485359192,
-0.041622087359428406,
-0.6004886031150818,
-0.002770153572782874,
0.17554718255996704,
-0.3826088011264801,
-0.018682006746530533,
0.12482849508523941,
-0.47219038009643555,
-0.6537064909934998,
-0.5252911448478699,
0.29314202070236206,
-0.4640887975692749,
-0.34936726093292236,
0.5998643040657043,
-0.3053390085697174,
0.5395097732543945,
0.5359898209571838,
-0.3111487627029419,
0.5774698257446289,
0.8294537663459778,
0.4556269645690918,
-0.11256872117519379,
-0.23212388157844543,
-0.6312615871429443,
-0.24983052909374237,
-0.3745099902153015,
0.8320246934890747,
-0.6814041137695312,
-0.13190428912639618,
-0.2191922813653946,
-0.07932385802268982,
-0.174203023314476,
-0.6090772747993469,
1.0309168100357056,
-0.6672211289405823,
0.2504603862762451,
-0.45091158151626587,
-0.7911767363548279,
-0.34584328532218933,
0.46064987778663635,
-0.6441917419433594,
0.6776524186134338,
-0.11354939639568329,
-0.709036648273468,
0.2428155541419983,
-0.450498104095459,
-0.5995230674743652,
-0.17601275444030762,
-0.3167572021484375,
0.06345853954553604,
0.2168271541595459,
0.11616091430187225,
0.21128499507904053,
-0.7792558670043945,
0.44752758741378784,
-0.4343918561935425,
-0.17786158621311188,
0.5045442581176758,
-0.34868162870407104,
0.8608263731002808,
0.06948727369308472,
-0.30339542031288147,
0.3645608425140381,
-0.7115240097045898,
0.2105368971824646,
0.1706184595823288,
-0.11801453679800034,
-0.14898712933063507,
0.2303045690059662,
-0.363066166639328,
0.5881917476654053,
-0.09017427265644073,
-0.5080038905143738,
0.15810373425483704,
-0.44150808453559875,
0.49911391735076904,
0.7942606806755066,
-0.016820181161165237,
0.17058849334716797,
-0.3035550117492676,
0.5425670742988586,
-0.10599983483552933,
0.09953158348798752,
-0.01343317050486803,
-0.45968347787857056,
-0.8266456127166748,
-0.30594682693481445,
0.18723678588867188,
0.6040895581245422,
-0.6117383241653442,
0.44710052013397217,
-0.22958888113498688,
-0.3891347050666809,
-0.1902754157781601,
0.2898394465446472,
0.40610361099243164,
0.704582929611206,
0.40191930532455444,
-0.1874479055404663,
-0.4208905100822449,
-0.9199820160865784,
-0.4654945135116577,
-0.030876563861966133,
-0.017266079783439636,
0.03523246571421623,
0.5634340643882751,
0.023991776630282402,
1.0502198934555054,
-0.29645994305610657,
0.10563600808382034,
-0.6536821722984314,
-0.1250176578760147,
0.5673813819885254,
0.07709061354398727,
0.30035749077796936,
-0.5613567233085632,
0.07481035590171814,
-0.20959439873695374,
-0.6948391199111938,
-0.39847537875175476,
-0.1687806248664856,
-0.4292803406715393,
0.11327741295099258,
0.5294516682624817,
-0.7818011045455933,
0.37275588512420654,
0.28402119874954224,
-0.5281481146812439,
0.6440499424934387,
0.040885671973228455,
-0.08219821751117706,
-0.5813751816749573,
0.15718288719654083,
-0.038562286645174026,
-0.23229989409446716,
-0.5318164229393005,
-0.034987833350896835,
-0.1417497992515564,
0.121402308344841,
-0.2503294050693512,
0.789385974407196,
-0.16744612157344818,
-0.09043314307928085,
-0.24829229712486267,
0.4827123284339905,
0.19348694384098053,
0.3263043761253357,
0.11936457455158234,
0.31192073225975037,
0.46756619215011597,
-0.42285212874412537,
0.4880290925502777,
0.06081855669617653,
-0.6760151982307434,
0.4790274500846863,
-0.7255210280418396,
0.09875020384788513,
-0.11282889544963837,
0.3869823217391968,
-0.9116438031196594,
-0.14621347188949585,
0.31671807169914246,
-0.17388834059238434,
-0.05133480951189995,
-0.08993334323167801,
-0.686490535736084,
-0.2668536305427551,
-0.032919272780418396,
0.22038422524929047,
0.40442922711372375,
-0.30463239550590515,
0.65462726354599,
0.11123918741941452,
-0.12467062473297119,
-0.32748061418533325,
-0.5485057234764099,
-0.006795395165681839,
-0.18961773812770844,
-0.8491380214691162,
-0.07407282292842865,
-0.047501154243946075,
-0.7482566833496094,
-0.0687360167503357,
-0.5281261801719666,
0.05325714498758316,
0.238043874502182,
-0.004399657249450684,
0.2561134696006775,
-0.25428348779678345,
0.26473328471183777,
-0.0809369832277298,
-0.2499411404132843,
0.4087277352809906,
-0.37114495038986206,
0.4720986485481262,
-0.4150312542915344,
-0.6924962997436523,
-0.1799575686454773,
-0.016286728903651237,
0.566580057144165,
-0.5201864242553711,
0.6402824521064758,
0.05719233676791191,
-0.35397300124168396,
-0.5061041116714478,
-0.7856693863868713,
-0.2301158756017685,
-0.37700116634368896,
0.031993113458156586,
-0.42060890793800354,
-0.7716463804244995,
0.44232138991355896,
-0.14253397285938263,
-0.0093975979834795,
0.4161129295825958,
0.4225956201553345,
0.09198181331157684,
0.8102894425392151,
0.11362368613481522,
0.02387840859591961,
0.12561634182929993,
0.08734450489282608,
0.3805525004863739,
-0.43826472759246826,
-0.07326528429985046,
-0.36205586791038513,
-0.21298962831497192,
-0.3337846100330353,
-0.6197255253791809,
0.10544987767934799,
0.240721195936203,
-0.2240460366010666,
-0.0774189904332161,
-0.13044725358486176,
0.732369601726532,
0.3658299446105957,
0.06690020859241486,
0.5812685489654541,
-0.2205519825220108,
-0.26029083132743835,
0.24531865119934082,
-0.5707942843437195,
-0.6593061089515686,
0.7084399461746216,
0.18157249689102173,
0.6546515822410583,
0.16060775518417358,
0.3158937990665436,
0.15254317224025726,
0.2983170747756958,
-0.7895538806915283,
0.9871081113815308,
0.09083060920238495,
-0.8372266888618469,
-0.24755559861660004,
-0.5738435983657837,
-0.6430721879005432,
0.5879954695701599,
-0.03843146562576294,
-0.5472952127456665,
-0.1109672486782074,
0.046064525842666626,
-0.1261267513036728,
0.2771887183189392,
-0.6538385152816772,
1.0925629138946533,
-0.5867052674293518,
-0.3892042338848114,
-0.35446155071258545,
-0.6910413503646851,
0.6275418996810913,
0.032734040170907974,
0.3657534718513489,
-0.4088887870311737,
0.08497080206871033,
0.5107816457748413,
-0.4545181691646576,
0.6489261984825134,
-0.11548614501953125,
-0.12947116792201996,
0.4450565576553345,
0.32778292894363403,
0.282577782869339,
0.0439089871942997,
-0.37883713841438293,
0.0018108979566022754,
0.153925359249115,
-0.40909749269485474,
-0.8122519850730896,
0.47049543261528015,
-0.27719032764434814,
-0.8089423775672913,
-0.438272088766098,
-0.34266966581344604,
-0.35814523696899414,
0.3316099941730499,
-0.1549624651670456,
0.4027365446090698,
-0.15394212305545807,
0.11183488368988037,
0.6181585788726807,
-0.16372250020503998,
0.032752376049757004,
0.5278558731079102,
-0.47309020161628723,
-0.2113325148820877,
0.7379328012466431,
-0.07706515491008759,
0.4319220781326294,
0.364992618560791,
0.5039269328117371,
-0.2749972939491272,
-0.6375257968902588,
-0.3293360471725464,
0.2712118327617645,
-1.0055103302001953,
0.062342043966054916,
-0.11587464809417725,
0.00228484277613461,
-0.0478508435189724,
0.022757364436984062,
-0.023250557482242584,
-0.5471716523170471,
0.25010862946510315,
-0.12218701839447021,
0.24070411920547485,
0.5948237180709839,
0.31747081875801086,
-0.2464565932750702,
-0.5540906190872192,
0.4997728168964386,
0.2974774241447449,
0.2459832727909088,
-0.09984802454710007,
-0.5090393424034119,
0.3465237319469452,
-0.14780190587043762,
0.08747225999832153,
-0.861303985118866,
0.09806129336357117,
-0.15085230767726898,
0.7064232230186462,
0.4454762637615204,
0.12642022967338562,
0.5522528886795044,
-0.3883552849292755,
0.32333824038505554,
0.057799942791461945,
-1.0778025388717651,
0.7061465978622437,
-0.445295512676239,
0.3915691673755646,
0.6886996626853943,
0.06357859820127487,
-0.5677269101142883,
-0.22448116540908813,
-0.5127021670341492,
-0.596890389919281,
0.6678677797317505,
0.288739949464798,
-0.30215370655059814,
0.008221648633480072,
0.20833463966846466,
0.05776789039373398,
0.28158777952194214,
-0.5780391097068787,
0.036503300070762634,
-0.08601833134889603,
-0.1665719449520111,
0.096779003739357,
0.031759150326251984,
-0.20619627833366394,
-0.4526265263557434,
0.5013408064842224,
-0.17357942461967468,
-0.22107328474521637,
0.19807012379169464,
-0.2641684114933014,
0.23368926346302032,
0.6386001110076904,
0.4721813499927521,
0.9947136044502258,
-0.05964994803071022,
0.194802924990654,
0.33634355664253235,
0.017069540917873383,
0.018184838816523552,
0.24403713643550873,
-0.021922122687101364,
-0.2337932586669922,
0.5843062996864319,
0.5171158313751221,
0.14256197214126587,
-1.1416305303573608,
0.43223193287849426,
-0.1766921728849411,
-0.24303704500198364,
-0.28163889050483704,
0.3176865577697754,
0.21558481454849243,
0.24884110689163208,
0.10368728637695312,
0.013116908259689808,
0.04649026691913605,
-0.6634414196014404,
-0.06543778628110886,
0.34042710065841675,
-0.09359733760356903,
-0.09822073578834534,
0.21469183266162872,
0.18363095819950104,
-0.047025781124830246,
0.7393375039100647,
-0.43420055508613586,
-0.5151389837265015,
0.6498450040817261,
0.34125614166259766,
0.6292982697486877,
0.16170543432235718,
-0.12013721466064453,
0.18464095890522003,
0.5078980326652527,
-0.1338941603899002,
0.4770978093147278,
0.003345441771671176,
-0.8759896755218506,
-0.6292225122451782,
-0.580299437046051,
-0.5565990805625916,
0.0766495019197464,
-0.32213592529296875,
0.09416259825229645,
-0.7010131478309631,
0.07237797230482101,
-0.05980106443166733,
-0.1475072056055069,
-0.5759822130203247,
-0.017404748126864433,
0.2322261482477188,
1.2140706777572632,
-0.587457001209259,
0.7000954151153564,
0.7807168364524841,
-0.2874932289123535,
-0.6325848698616028,
-0.1972181648015976,
0.2722342014312744,
-0.4802974760532379,
0.5816310048103333,
0.3845142126083374,
-0.4205854535102844,
-0.1289878636598587,
-0.6061868071556091,
-0.5090256333351135,
0.8950911164283752,
0.5812488198280334,
-0.5530259609222412,
0.1841963678598404,
0.167819544672966,
0.47484591603279114,
-0.23277156054973602,
0.36768388748168945,
0.883536696434021,
0.7186822295188904,
0.14146928489208221,
-0.7537892460823059,
0.19149930775165558,
-0.4078209102153778,
-0.30021247267723083,
0.10436344146728516,
-0.4664858877658844,
0.5453070998191833,
-0.16634273529052734,
-0.21617311239242554,
-0.015188275836408138,
0.40508943796157837,
0.4872685372829437,
0.23015911877155304,
0.665829062461853,
0.7803295850753784,
0.9409019351005554,
-0.25820598006248474,
1.0606306791305542,
-0.17928776144981384,
0.07007157802581787,
1.181539535522461,
-0.6445167064666748,
0.7659747004508972,
0.38635075092315674,
-0.13298478722572327,
0.7205844521522522,
0.33454543352127075,
0.2004745602607727,
0.05638919398188591,
0.6130710244178772,
-0.24305810034275055,
-0.8636316061019897,
-0.08109795302152634,
-0.08352237194776535,
0.36529573798179626,
0.36978140473365784,
-0.11948063969612122,
-0.2825757563114166,
-0.3273218274116516,
-0.04959375783801079,
0.09131758660078049,
-0.19021369516849518,
0.5281246304512024,
0.2251693159341812,
-0.7228701710700989,
0.5109058022499084,
0.130086749792099,
0.17982099950313568,
-0.742007851600647,
-0.0960320457816124,
-0.1706867814064026,
0.3212756812572479,
-0.25215375423431396,
-0.8199071884155273,
0.07582204788923264,
0.1326693892478943,
-0.06201272830367088,
-0.19671282172203064,
0.8884417414665222,
0.08632154017686844,
-0.5430057048797607,
0.3332226276397705,
0.743015706539154,
-0.003334213048219681,
-0.06271332502365112,
-0.6953004598617554,
0.07006572932004929,
-0.1506248116493225,
-0.44039738178253174,
0.07995383441448212,
0.5623252391815186,
-0.12108646333217621,
0.8473641276359558,
0.6971819996833801,
-0.06177494302392006,
0.021040836349129677,
0.38954073190689087,
0.8559697866439819,
-0.7490289211273193,
-0.12954123318195343,
-0.8852604031562805,
0.5043842196464539,
-0.25919008255004883,
-0.344727486371994,
0.7855198979377747,
0.44291552901268005,
0.8212820291519165,
0.09954611957073212,
0.701575517654419,
-0.12477004528045654,
0.49269038438796997,
-0.6856819987297058,
0.16932620108127594,
-0.31618720293045044,
0.3858508765697479,
-0.17446358501911163,
-0.7161321640014648,
-0.31261223554611206,
0.8549605011940002,
-0.8376448750495911,
-0.024249333888292313,
0.8712879419326782,
0.693489134311676,
-0.09739866852760315,
0.40432602167129517,
0.19272100925445557,
0.4461123049259186,
0.24220193922519684,
0.5510017275810242,
1.1542086601257324,
0.044790830463171005,
0.4346756935119629,
-0.12188854813575745,
-0.18148085474967957,
0.024657174944877625,
-0.9292613863945007,
-1.0585461854934692,
-0.06512212753295898,
-0.0697643905878067,
-0.15445294976234436,
-0.055660635232925415,
0.9112949967384338,
0.3639652132987976,
-0.7040144205093384,
-0.251647025346756,
-0.4140004515647888,
0.4288997948169708,
-0.13785786926746368,
-0.19550172984600067,
0.1034952774643898,
-0.41495949029922485,
-0.19401155412197113,
0.6712489724159241,
0.3296850919723511,
-0.4218784272670746,
-0.1811663806438446,
-0.026937665417790413,
-0.382231742143631,
0.20923705399036407,
0.7299648523330688,
0.21781881153583527,
-0.8821374773979187,
-0.06861806660890579,
0.11442477256059647,
0.050046127289533615,
-0.060132551938295364,
0.7812961935997009,
-0.8415229916572571,
0.3974868059158325,
0.8347101211547852,
0.6415632367134094,
0.25140929222106934,
0.13736334443092346,
0.3585696518421173,
-0.15155871212482452,
-0.01053103432059288,
0.3900344669818878,
0.6342931985855103,
0.09406819194555283,
0.3691025674343109,
0.6156592965126038,
0.3096444308757782,
-0.3404141664505005,
-0.5564324855804443,
0.40951108932495117,
-0.9653111100196838,
-0.3974325954914093,
1.1963791847229004,
0.020779423415660858,
-0.11020153760910034,
-0.13044996559619904,
-0.40640148520469666,
-0.06726839393377304,
-0.17400451004505157,
0.40608006715774536,
0.8623051047325134,
-0.3194391131401062,
-0.08088941127061844,
-0.8418007493019104,
0.11091414093971252,
0.6980133652687073,
-1.132845163345337,
0.10031808912754059,
0.782740592956543,
0.31701233983039856,
-0.008097362704575062,
0.48309919238090515,
-0.08982056379318237,
0.38619694113731384,
-0.28797510266304016,
-0.17322899401187897,
0.12510526180267334,
-0.22855722904205322,
-0.37471771240234375,
0.06465040147304535,
0.294712096452713,
0.4253825843334198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15515v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15515v3
|
ToM-LM: Delegating Theory of Mind Reasoning to External Symbolic Executors in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-23T20:59:03 | 2024-06-26T15:57:22 |
Weizhi Tang, Vaishak Belle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Theory of Mind (ToM) refers to the ability of individuals to attribute mental
states to others. While Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown some promise
with ToM ability, they still struggle with complex ToM reasoning. Our approach
leverages an external symbolic executor, specifically the SMCDEL model checker,
and fine-tuning to improve the ToM reasoning ability of LLMs. In our approach,
an LLM is first fine-tuned through pairs of natural language and symbolic
formulation representation of ToM problems and is then instructed to generate
the symbolic formulation with a one-shot in-context example. The generated
symbolic formulation is then executed by the SMCDEL model checker to perform
transparent and verifiable ToM reasoning and give the final result. We
demonstrate that our approach, ToM-LM, shows a significant improvement over all
the constructed baselines. Our study proposes a novel view about externalizing
a particular component of ToM reasoning, mainly reasoning about beliefs, and
suggests generalizing it to other aspects of ToM reasoning.
|
[
-0.6316162347793579,
-0.832231342792511,
0.9376749992370605,
-0.32316726446151733,
-0.39779940247535706,
-0.17695565521717072,
-0.6340517997741699,
-0.6103113293647766,
0.1965966522693634,
0.5274878144264221,
-0.6096956729888916,
0.08458881080150604,
-0.6841144561767578,
-0.061279959976673126,
0.025381164625287056,
0.8402979373931885,
-0.10305874794721603,
0.19186441600322723,
-0.05512628331780434,
-0.06242819130420685,
-0.2840120494365692,
-0.4888989329338074,
-1.0661007165908813,
-0.6369178295135498,
0.5212904810905457,
-0.15078648924827576,
0.8166841864585876,
0.6792154312133789,
0.7056564092636108,
0.29121631383895874,
-0.21004724502563477,
0.5661923289299011,
-0.3937467634677887,
0.2841722071170807,
-0.6271637082099915,
-0.8858715295791626,
-0.4100607931613922,
-0.09870199114084244,
0.5577298402786255,
0.3639298677444458,
-0.1068807914853096,
-0.03307146951556206,
0.18387344479560852,
0.4508427381515503,
-0.6240373849868774,
0.38053107261657715,
-0.8263664245605469,
0.029652856290340424,
-0.016921300441026688,
-0.498810738325119,
-0.6076227426528931,
-0.6237231492996216,
0.14998221397399902,
-0.41110849380493164,
0.14381106197834015,
-0.018102306872606277,
0.6071327924728394,
0.46898314356803894,
-0.6744073629379272,
-0.22460505366325378,
-0.8678392171859741,
0.8506420850753784,
-0.6001688241958618,
0.2683731019496918,
0.382437527179718,
0.6627750396728516,
-0.24630039930343628,
-0.28662630915641785,
-0.7219371795654297,
-0.14762088656425476,
-0.18628457188606262,
-0.04583406075835228,
-0.0025652609765529633,
0.5206577777862549,
0.38901957869529724,
0.7237332463264465,
-0.3074720799922943,
-0.24802935123443604,
-0.03347788378596306,
0.06854010373353958,
0.702887237071991,
0.15822605788707733,
-0.006719257682561874,
0.2994496524333954,
-0.18017926812171936,
-0.23669584095478058,
-0.7340180277824402,
-0.3761526644229889,
-0.057542793452739716,
0.4211868345737457,
0.11537427455186844,
0.5190350413322449,
-0.035285137593746185,
0.3114825189113617,
0.29357418417930603,
-0.026620933786034584,
-0.30058473348617554,
-0.126224547624588,
-0.7724642157554626,
-0.13310536742210388,
0.2291450947523117,
0.16125620901584625,
0.5446362495422363,
0.2047683298587799,
-0.26046401262283325,
0.3043060004711151,
0.4046597182750702,
-0.4825930595397949,
-0.28128957748413086,
0.3180633783340454,
-0.4349782168865204,
0.08240295201539993,
-0.07231120020151138,
-0.36016201972961426,
-0.8214699029922485,
-0.6776382923126221,
0.6024985909461975,
-0.5956255197525024,
-0.3816479444503784,
0.1434100717306137,
-0.14062097668647766,
0.1719556301832199,
0.6057125926017761,
-0.5056313872337341,
0.16233417391777039,
0.7077979445457458,
0.5968323349952698,
0.10656379908323288,
-0.011463615112006664,
-0.259578675031662,
0.8083959221839905,
-0.45301809906959534,
0.7343456745147705,
-0.5131457448005676,
-0.3424597680568695,
0.1555890291929245,
0.006076860707253218,
0.08748138695955276,
-0.40371230244636536,
0.3951663672924042,
-0.2893133759498596,
0.5180843472480774,
-0.6426851749420166,
-0.9467002153396606,
-0.568115770816803,
0.3906630575656891,
-0.35790494084358215,
0.5861286520957947,
-0.18583795428276062,
-0.33986786007881165,
0.3913593590259552,
-0.8450086116790771,
-0.43703559041023254,
0.19860221445560455,
-0.5479515194892883,
-0.04564482718706131,
0.453567773103714,
0.13801690936088562,
0.6708981990814209,
-0.6296007633209229,
0.6435011029243469,
-0.4568573832511902,
-0.19955241680145264,
0.15526103973388672,
-0.2861649692058563,
1.038184642791748,
0.3923540711402893,
-0.36649274826049805,
0.3951681852340698,
-0.42481690645217896,
0.29348593950271606,
0.20650586485862732,
-0.011807288974523544,
-0.6836904287338257,
0.03729777783155441,
-0.38670510053634644,
0.13436686992645264,
0.1062009260058403,
-0.19390365481376648,
0.40893855690956116,
-0.5457032322883606,
0.17459842562675476,
1.1267008781433105,
0.033033352345228195,
0.44545143842697144,
-0.7471943497657776,
0.38925451040267944,
-0.05166330561041832,
0.06770812720060349,
-0.3685128390789032,
-0.39371582865715027,
-1.02232825756073,
-0.5133270025253296,
-0.3787728250026703,
0.19630375504493713,
-0.8158191442489624,
0.5127644538879395,
-0.276644766330719,
-0.3476981520652771,
-0.2617395222187042,
-0.09219425916671753,
0.6591048240661621,
-0.03973909839987755,
0.35418760776519775,
-0.1125304251909256,
-0.4189939498901367,
-1.118061900138855,
-0.37341272830963135,
-0.26315969228744507,
0.029121987521648407,
0.2582554221153259,
0.4578417241573334,
-0.07840299606323242,
0.6328664422035217,
-0.6769037246704102,
-0.4797343313694,
-0.3795875608921051,
-0.008105031214654446,
0.10374639183282852,
0.6758695840835571,
0.38849568367004395,
-0.4442985951900482,
-0.11075708270072937,
0.2205534130334854,
-0.8664313554763794,
0.22951480746269226,
-0.3334728479385376,
-0.37564265727996826,
0.31427159905433655,
0.15767902135849,
-0.9574263691902161,
0.19641919434070587,
0.14978663623332977,
-0.3302100896835327,
0.28674018383026123,
-0.37456339597702026,
0.12055598944425583,
-1.237134337425232,
-0.27850982546806335,
0.1070307195186615,
-0.22452212870121002,
-0.3745625615119934,
1.013946771621704,
-0.08996669948101044,
0.2900587320327759,
-0.1246037483215332,
0.5307096838951111,
-0.5352836847305298,
0.3175114393234253,
-0.26851707696914673,
0.03810274600982666,
-0.2677752375602722,
0.7259685397148132,
-0.08024757355451584,
0.4509977102279663,
0.3447803854942322,
-0.9719718098640442,
0.380329430103302,
-0.034715283662080765,
-0.15879322588443756,
0.9727318286895752,
-0.38939061760902405,
0.24328334629535675,
-0.16247959434986115,
0.5298046469688416,
-0.9050993919372559,
-0.1432957649230957,
0.23883457481861115,
0.05621036887168884,
0.42241135239601135,
0.07242574542760849,
-0.5012291669845581,
-0.3705800175666809,
-0.17307114601135254,
0.20588421821594238,
0.495398610830307,
-0.5546685457229614,
0.9063736796379089,
0.45202094316482544,
0.07654793560504913,
0.07464101165533066,
-0.8524162173271179,
0.007470655720680952,
-0.2578656077384949,
-0.49134454131126404,
0.20166051387786865,
-0.3031684458255768,
-0.6889172792434692,
-0.21319343149662018,
-0.11809585988521576,
-0.36819735169410706,
-0.0948081687092781,
0.18937282264232635,
-0.1043408066034317,
-0.327789306640625,
0.358039528131485,
0.39812275767326355,
-0.07353845983743668,
0.29938504099845886,
-0.4313757121562958,
0.30862316489219666,
0.05175129324197769,
-0.615402102470398,
-0.586582601070404,
0.2598305344581604,
0.4375149607658386,
-0.08939244598150253,
0.7162781953811646,
0.10312271863222122,
-0.7067868113517761,
-0.7141844630241394,
-0.6099806427955627,
-0.6250572800636292,
-0.45585358142852783,
0.10394380241632462,
-0.7091759443283081,
-0.862364649772644,
0.24445967376232147,
-0.09786011278629303,
0.13386206328868866,
0.2607848644256592,
0.8255825638771057,
0.043576620519161224,
1.1143020391464233,
0.739243745803833,
0.1076870933175087,
0.28583982586860657,
-0.3299872875213623,
0.27521851658821106,
-0.48701009154319763,
-0.010689429007470608,
-0.30074068903923035,
-0.3440123200416565,
-0.3639289438724518,
-0.5891110301017761,
0.19186455011367798,
-0.30601978302001953,
-0.35438072681427,
0.34008875489234924,
-0.5314649939537048,
0.5972573161125183,
0.5058174729347229,
0.25906217098236084,
0.4495563209056854,
-0.2148732841014862,
-0.3087107241153717,
-0.07092402130365372,
-0.37495091557502747,
-0.5652559399604797,
0.7948185205459595,
0.3321448266506195,
0.5738593935966492,
0.43440890312194824,
0.44720494747161865,
0.259822815656662,
0.38763728737831116,
-0.7173647880554199,
0.8523971438407898,
-0.012303482741117477,
-1.038688063621521,
-0.19301454722881317,
-0.24702255427837372,
-0.38244131207466125,
0.5297046303749084,
0.027036521583795547,
-0.7481868267059326,
0.049196984618902206,
0.38234683871269226,
-0.24394164979457855,
0.4720548093318939,
-0.6249046921730042,
0.35023558139801025,
-0.019675463438034058,
-0.22126872837543488,
-0.8731737732887268,
-0.4397061765193939,
0.703848659992218,
-0.03107830137014389,
-0.13911336660385132,
-0.02988664247095585,
0.21943716704845428,
0.2920220196247101,
-0.4437766671180725,
0.798393189907074,
-0.22780762612819672,
-0.9174975752830505,
0.21771349012851715,
0.5215620994567871,
0.8633818030357361,
-0.0770091637969017,
-0.08447910845279694,
-0.055876150727272034,
0.1315644383430481,
-0.11261121183633804,
-0.9519329071044922,
0.5961503386497498,
-0.4260382354259491,
-0.9987797737121582,
-0.3785790503025055,
-0.6898573040962219,
-0.35849815607070923,
0.15219834446907043,
-0.0012366718146950006,
0.1815064698457718,
0.03940783068537712,
0.24430768191814423,
0.6782016754150391,
-0.024635074660182,
0.19774064421653748,
0.43050283193588257,
-0.417592316865921,
-0.23275132477283478,
0.6529397964477539,
0.056275662034749985,
0.36491692066192627,
0.6973068714141846,
0.2303907722234726,
-0.15881097316741943,
-0.25794050097465515,
-0.03251175954937935,
0.22851043939590454,
-0.8730073571205139,
-0.031125755980610847,
-0.35483279824256897,
-0.14897863566875458,
-0.15583938360214233,
-0.2471359372138977,
-0.47998231649398804,
-0.42188796401023865,
0.23858216404914856,
-0.10392207652330399,
0.22040198743343353,
0.5943096876144409,
0.20317088067531586,
0.3425394594669342,
-0.3497043550014496,
0.34158164262771606,
0.3256044089794159,
0.32445359230041504,
0.046310365200042725,
-0.5025410652160645,
-0.24270780384540558,
0.46497273445129395,
-0.40681424736976624,
-0.525743305683136,
0.12708620727062225,
0.04593672603368759,
0.46931931376457214,
0.8278110027313232,
0.21099813282489777,
1.1637223958969116,
-0.22764739394187927,
0.6088985800743103,
-0.0585123747587204,
-1.0924923419952393,
0.7405360341072083,
-0.5152868628501892,
0.2054976373910904,
0.17127853631973267,
0.13399586081504822,
-0.2368791252374649,
-0.9722513556480408,
-0.5324993133544922,
-0.29872626066207886,
0.4491059482097626,
0.21869665384292603,
0.05697500705718994,
-0.13009558618068695,
0.3094787001609802,
0.15142077207565308,
0.18919137120246887,
-0.6322763562202454,
-0.3012208938598633,
0.32388225197792053,
-0.27209168672561646,
-0.20187069475650787,
-0.2364692986011505,
-0.5046782493591309,
-0.33736681938171387,
0.8931688070297241,
-0.38087788224220276,
0.44410526752471924,
0.1722916066646576,
-0.06454452872276306,
-0.37060093879699707,
0.2534504532814026,
0.7497777342796326,
0.8367054462432861,
-0.0918629989027977,
0.5461212396621704,
0.23634013533592224,
-0.020879505202174187,
0.04116280376911163,
-0.23771978914737701,
-0.08210578560829163,
-0.2563343942165375,
0.30866870284080505,
0.438699334859848,
0.0426674410700798,
-0.47117143869400024,
0.2120397835969925,
0.12617042660713196,
-0.09398002922534943,
-0.40289056301116943,
0.32076922059059143,
-0.07565511763095856,
0.5732203722000122,
0.3023112118244171,
-0.0025738892145454884,
-0.14860843122005463,
-0.4831955134868622,
0.04482252895832062,
0.6817861199378967,
-0.2696858048439026,
-0.3798110783100128,
0.7428697347640991,
0.13731181621551514,
-0.05624168738722801,
0.18025918304920197,
-0.22150708734989166,
-0.3002881109714508,
0.6137653589248657,
0.6986530423164368,
1.2241175174713135,
-0.2150973081588745,
-0.07401183992624283,
0.1239590123295784,
0.5788671374320984,
-0.17616163194179535,
0.456870436668396,
-0.11967383325099945,
-1.0466697216033936,
-0.5645809173583984,
-0.16928604245185852,
-0.446786105632782,
0.24679748713970184,
-0.6605343818664551,
0.1648654192686081,
-0.7417371869087219,
-0.17228847742080688,
-0.1963243931531906,
-0.015997547656297684,
-0.5551425814628601,
0.3645569682121277,
0.14727912843227386,
0.6956719756126404,
-0.3567412495613098,
1.1348330974578857,
0.8283159732818604,
-0.34417369961738586,
-0.7029286623001099,
0.1032792329788208,
0.287352055311203,
-0.7522295713424683,
0.6184517741203308,
0.05354420468211174,
-0.496155709028244,
-0.09475451707839966,
-0.474289208650589,
-0.6861775517463684,
0.9561812281608582,
0.7557268142700195,
-0.6347497701644897,
0.05837973579764366,
-0.26512712240219116,
0.6421998143196106,
-0.3186565935611725,
0.21140556037425995,
0.16044747829437256,
0.5438003540039062,
-0.07163184136152267,
-0.9495298266410828,
0.43529078364372253,
-0.018016481772065163,
0.14193040132522583,
0.4718484580516815,
-0.6098537445068359,
0.7397757768630981,
-0.2676085829734802,
-0.3869447708129883,
0.15542112290859222,
0.7345244884490967,
0.24555759131908417,
0.1784062385559082,
0.39667171239852905,
0.5421950221061707,
1.0190675258636475,
0.06721021980047226,
1.1761448383331299,
-0.510195791721344,
0.38685736060142517,
1.3412340879440308,
-0.49902766942977905,
0.6085774898529053,
0.6079021692276001,
-0.3673816919326782,
0.23561544716358185,
0.24578364193439484,
0.2512464225292206,
0.3595665991306305,
0.17963159084320068,
-0.2815079689025879,
-0.4690089821815491,
-0.1126738116145134,
-0.4524928629398346,
0.3609785735607147,
0.35188406705856323,
-0.6605594754219055,
0.053174324333667755,
-0.1092853918671608,
0.09007328748703003,
0.2167183756828308,
-0.32273826003074646,
0.6074313521385193,
0.25360357761383057,
-0.607966959476471,
0.4292800724506378,
0.03970320150256157,
0.5112923979759216,
-0.5575280785560608,
0.007172290701419115,
-0.12286949902772903,
0.7233793139457703,
0.1340639889240265,
-0.6080770492553711,
0.5864151120185852,
-0.34308061003685,
-0.16395530104637146,
-0.5585945844650269,
0.6494298577308655,
-0.4017733931541443,
-0.3247673809528351,
0.34140464663505554,
0.6848675608634949,
0.08928750455379486,
-0.2364923059940338,
-0.3882853388786316,
-0.25320178270339966,
-0.027380051091313362,
-0.2074107527732849,
0.16183136403560638,
0.6252202391624451,
-0.222891166806221,
1.1144065856933594,
0.5627244710922241,
0.220285102725029,
-0.29030343890190125,
0.12217772752046585,
0.6304922103881836,
-0.9579187035560608,
-0.6359317302703857,
-1.2563711404800415,
0.04148482531309128,
0.04851463809609413,
-0.251161128282547,
0.8855634927749634,
0.33345961570739746,
0.9530300498008728,
-0.24829064309597015,
0.7290843725204468,
0.03011140041053295,
0.31832942366600037,
-0.548993706703186,
0.7138477563858032,
-0.5317170023918152,
0.25091052055358887,
-0.3473680019378662,
-0.9458574652671814,
-0.4133010804653168,
0.9267991185188293,
-0.19240371882915497,
0.19436217844486237,
0.9543344378471375,
0.7590975761413574,
0.07578524202108383,
0.36821314692497253,
0.4308030307292938,
0.5510208010673523,
0.45948487520217896,
0.8913421630859375,
0.8974431157112122,
0.003873881185427308,
0.0967564582824707,
-0.25405848026275635,
0.01251468900591135,
0.009904453530907631,
-0.9943301677703857,
-1.0359704494476318,
-0.6703638434410095,
-0.4801965355873108,
-0.0784105733036995,
0.2238215059041977,
1.3044712543487549,
0.7366042137145996,
-0.8035573959350586,
-0.26004257798194885,
-0.2926581799983978,
0.3364400565624237,
-0.5212881565093994,
-0.2722611725330353,
0.08731342107057571,
-0.18864978849887848,
-0.7042347192764282,
0.28365084528923035,
0.48532482981681824,
-0.11121150851249695,
-0.4890064001083374,
0.028765037655830383,
-0.07852263748645782,
0.5171955823898315,
0.8574216365814209,
-0.1610250473022461,
-1.1680841445922852,
-0.7504199147224426,
-0.5648019909858704,
-0.14893852174282074,
-0.06894807517528534,
1.0817205905914307,
-0.6850953698158264,
0.4356124997138977,
0.36609259247779846,
0.7229511737823486,
0.08127064257860184,
-0.23516009747982025,
0.9868482351303101,
-0.5149424076080322,
0.06821288913488388,
0.08986753225326538,
0.5916294455528259,
-0.096633180975914,
-0.43394359946250916,
0.5288967490196228,
0.13172605633735657,
-0.3554730713367462,
-0.8679690361022949,
0.5131398439407349,
-0.9099807143211365,
-0.45777952671051025,
1.036777377128601,
-0.0731661394238472,
-0.005879072472453117,
0.08880332112312317,
-0.46180102229118347,
0.30087974667549133,
-0.23197044432163239,
0.9173132181167603,
0.7246239185333252,
-0.22489681839942932,
-0.2633689045906067,
-0.2530716061592102,
0.43433400988578796,
0.5195993185043335,
-0.9119996428489685,
0.15001480281352997,
0.4618723690509796,
-0.106098473072052,
0.2204386442899704,
0.6187751889228821,
0.1727844476699829,
-0.051719579845666885,
-0.1926073133945465,
0.05018836259841919,
-0.09579693526029587,
-0.22667008638381958,
-0.3716631531715393,
0.2859249711036682,
-0.012233152985572815,
-0.08052355796098709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00709v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00709v1
|
Evaluating Tool-Augmented Agents in Remote Sensing Platforms
| 2024-04-23T20:37:24 | 2024-04-23T20:37:24 |
Simranjit Singh, Michael Fore, Dimitrios Stamoulis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Tool-augmented Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive
capabilities in remote sensing (RS) applications. However, existing benchmarks
assume question-answering input templates over predefined image-text data
pairs. These standalone instructions neglect the intricacies of realistic
user-grounded tasks. Consider a geospatial analyst: they zoom in a map area,
they draw a region over which to collect satellite imagery, and they succinctly
ask "Detect all objects here". Where is `here`, if it is not explicitly
hardcoded in the image-text template, but instead is implied by the system
state, e.g., the live map positioning? To bridge this gap, we present
GeoLLM-QA, a benchmark designed to capture long sequences of verbal, visual,
and click-based actions on a real UI platform. Through in-depth evaluation of
state-of-the-art LLMs over a diverse set of 1,000 tasks, we offer insights
towards stronger agents for RS applications.
|
[
-0.5521343350410461,
-0.6219596862792969,
0.8769820928573608,
-0.058270953595638275,
-0.11103828251361847,
0.25168198347091675,
-0.30772432684898376,
-0.6173203587532043,
0.22902362048625946,
0.3507291078567505,
-0.48765406012535095,
-0.7918486595153809,
-0.50435870885849,
0.14879892766475677,
-0.29557740688323975,
0.4792851507663727,
-0.14547443389892578,
-0.4088655710220337,
-0.28783249855041504,
-0.30865025520324707,
-0.23255644738674164,
-0.3976612091064453,
-0.23689602315425873,
-0.12215196341276169,
0.48503029346466064,
0.2995748817920685,
1.2221907377243042,
0.1560678482055664,
0.5010925531387329,
0.3679848611354828,
0.046329036355018616,
0.4887458384037018,
-0.3873404264450073,
0.15273335576057434,
-0.2708073556423187,
-0.41342592239379883,
-0.306665301322937,
0.30546271800994873,
0.5315862894058228,
0.4352085590362549,
0.15995639562606812,
0.5431423783302307,
-0.20939385890960693,
0.22777198255062103,
-0.7796704173088074,
0.19377249479293823,
-0.3651878237724304,
-0.0771338939666748,
0.0515156127512455,
-0.19480423629283905,
-0.16763760149478912,
-0.2018951028585434,
0.13670888543128967,
-0.7183153033256531,
0.13751432299613953,
0.14418697357177734,
1.001565933227539,
0.2737140953540802,
-0.26862823963165283,
-0.06533955782651901,
-0.7049413919448853,
0.8351655006408691,
-0.5127246975898743,
0.3807278871536255,
0.5863765478134155,
0.49562540650367737,
-0.3205556273460388,
-0.5343506336212158,
-0.43172580003738403,
-0.44062209129333496,
0.09508926421403885,
0.1025732159614563,
0.03467049449682236,
-0.08914650231599808,
0.419445663690567,
0.02401409111917019,
-0.5472902655601501,
0.17856180667877197,
-0.2540181279182434,
-0.2602539360523224,
0.6129962205886841,
0.1306147575378418,
0.23105072975158691,
-0.3040624260902405,
-0.3412719964981079,
-0.27283161878585815,
-0.756116509437561,
0.1962733119726181,
0.0408942811191082,
0.5336962342262268,
-0.2557627856731415,
0.6755915880203247,
-0.20138335227966309,
0.7779012322425842,
-0.20479722321033478,
0.034932658076286316,
0.0014690508833155036,
-0.1339508444070816,
-0.22273235023021698,
-0.30680325627326965,
0.7951518893241882,
0.3830569386482239,
0.05753586068749428,
-0.40154629945755005,
-0.4551239311695099,
-0.018976563587784767,
0.21079860627651215,
-0.5984454154968262,
-0.06297168135643005,
0.5734722018241882,
-0.16551010310649872,
-0.05997615307569504,
0.18047118186950684,
-0.5844941735267639,
-0.684374988079071,
-0.3194551169872284,
0.3862166404724121,
-0.026038968935608864,
-0.41318607330322266,
0.018565194681286812,
0.003255866002291441,
0.6945329308509827,
0.4023186266422272,
-0.1487322449684143,
0.33530744910240173,
0.9199697971343994,
0.8372725248336792,
-0.07400566339492798,
-0.6309680342674255,
-0.9053144454956055,
-0.32959723472595215,
-0.46243351697921753,
1.0556756258010864,
-0.5288047790527344,
-0.40987223386764526,
-0.08830797672271729,
0.1731492429971695,
0.15611378848552704,
-0.5800875425338745,
0.2834623456001282,
-0.8385300040245056,
0.13747736811637878,
-0.699952244758606,
-0.21961002051830292,
-0.2411441206932068,
0.5453696250915527,
-0.6697462797164917,
1.4405043125152588,
0.4102602005004883,
-0.261751651763916,
0.6193372011184692,
-0.6312081813812256,
-0.06723186373710632,
0.17246390879154205,
-0.27603793144226074,
-0.19484195113182068,
-0.02649879828095436,
0.48413312435150146,
0.5471956133842468,
-0.5720049142837524,
0.07450289279222488,
-0.4008694887161255,
-0.5987061858177185,
0.4613089859485626,
-0.17433929443359375,
0.3980216383934021,
0.2701203525066376,
-0.447493314743042,
0.19625012576580048,
-0.401384562253952,
0.2312246710062027,
-0.01811377890408039,
-0.31972721219062805,
-0.07138419896364212,
0.0819690003991127,
0.3696778416633606,
0.11300785839557648,
0.17625156044960022,
-0.6825551986694336,
0.09337075054645538,
-0.2980671525001526,
0.09298945963382721,
0.47168171405792236,
-0.2649907171726227,
0.4599830210208893,
-0.04492141678929329,
0.8646465539932251,
-0.34611091017723083,
0.096040740609169,
-0.1342352032661438,
-0.18112869560718536,
-0.31117376685142517,
-0.49298784136772156,
0.15966986119747162,
0.5649704337120056,
-0.7649042010307312,
0.20540224015712738,
-0.614595353603363,
-0.6807746291160583,
-0.35747119784355164,
0.2405916154384613,
0.3008383512496948,
0.1134771779179573,
0.27212733030319214,
-0.30813294649124146,
-0.1214914545416832,
-0.33933204412460327,
-0.1767442375421524,
-0.04629550501704216,
-0.22989703714847565,
0.33240219950675964,
0.4536227285861969,
-0.022401684895157814,
1.1811692714691162,
-0.394319087266922,
0.011325626634061337,
-0.3928861618041992,
0.09099794924259186,
0.10204824805259705,
-0.05792839825153351,
0.8674699664115906,
-0.7807798385620117,
-0.26854074001312256,
0.14012590050697327,
-1.0792356729507446,
-0.09761900454759598,
-0.03553066775202751,
0.14226604998111725,
0.043379899114370346,
0.5684031248092651,
-0.9008705615997314,
0.6642662286758423,
0.46524983644485474,
-0.4339556097984314,
0.43564873933792114,
-0.20553112030029297,
0.32309460639953613,
-0.7745960354804993,
0.20782853662967682,
0.20083634555339813,
-0.4711139500141144,
-0.46099552512168884,
0.6506313681602478,
-0.01660006120800972,
-0.640753448009491,
-0.6642935276031494,
0.6611831188201904,
-0.9054889678955078,
-0.7344712615013123,
-0.46312636137008667,
0.23662996292114258,
-0.08072265982627869,
0.28839585185050964,
0.12574000656604767,
1.0475083589553833,
0.6141754388809204,
-0.4274156987667084,
0.6103753447532654,
-0.09217717498540878,
-0.3947848975658417,
0.5991792678833008,
-0.6183423399925232,
0.3053218722343445,
-0.09481579065322876,
0.17868757247924805,
-0.9773882627487183,
-0.18233154714107513,
0.11543731391429901,
-0.38600966334342957,
-0.03411673754453659,
-0.15755021572113037,
-0.774673342704773,
-0.3959815204143524,
-0.47907140851020813,
0.3931500315666199,
0.42463013529777527,
-0.56069016456604,
1.0925085544586182,
0.20936302840709686,
0.06971295922994614,
-0.46222612261772156,
-0.3546741008758545,
0.5533238649368286,
-0.20743435621261597,
-0.19696229696273804,
-0.360851913690567,
0.398654043674469,
-0.24255767464637756,
0.04513128846883774,
-0.08244555443525314,
0.041778575628995895,
0.34141069650650024,
0.6182503700256348,
0.05042015761137009,
-0.1877431422472,
-0.21683314442634583,
-0.5369769334793091,
-0.17490845918655396,
0.19422391057014465,
0.022368835285305977,
0.4718354344367981,
-0.3551889657974243,
-0.770470380783081,
-0.6220147013664246,
0.15227429568767548,
0.9322313666343689,
-0.5684509873390198,
0.2934216558933258,
0.5233079791069031,
-0.288533091545105,
-0.11810813099145889,
-0.571566104888916,
-0.04812287539243698,
-0.5296015739440918,
0.28751319646835327,
-0.5349317789077759,
-0.515446126461029,
0.6992783546447754,
-0.5164440870285034,
0.13485676050186157,
0.11458413302898407,
0.09332441538572311,
-0.16580244898796082,
0.5660949945449829,
0.3675268292427063,
-0.5045346021652222,
0.1972654163837433,
-0.3626593351364136,
0.16161109507083893,
-0.5740443468093872,
0.013125444762408733,
-0.4108645021915436,
-0.4776182174682617,
-0.37018340826034546,
-0.7926654815673828,
0.6422338485717773,
-0.20328593254089355,
-0.29401159286499023,
0.3891869783401489,
-0.4460131824016571,
0.5192293524742126,
0.5784874558448792,
0.19306276738643646,
-0.15983110666275024,
0.08735952526330948,
0.25952136516571045,
0.2121090292930603,
-0.6233161687850952,
-0.6934978365898132,
1.0691399574279785,
0.307539701461792,
0.9794238209724426,
-0.11532621830701828,
0.45507320761680603,
0.41540956497192383,
0.4459865689277649,
-0.7987260818481445,
1.0094820261001587,
0.2233242690563202,
-0.3548249304294586,
-0.4457772970199585,
0.019585687667131424,
-1.067980170249939,
0.3187428116798401,
-0.18652930855751038,
-0.6316607594490051,
0.08062054961919785,
0.031163262203335762,
-0.3401356637477875,
0.39393389225006104,
-0.5418633222579956,
0.7403580546379089,
-0.43396061658859253,
-0.43120166659355164,
-0.028734397143125534,
-0.5460467338562012,
-0.13468073308467865,
0.32404839992523193,
0.22581122815608978,
-0.30610617995262146,
-0.17179511487483978,
0.22991274297237396,
-0.3692845404148102,
0.9990419745445251,
-0.5882342457771301,
-0.1284155249595642,
0.6008070707321167,
0.4664306342601776,
0.5619791746139526,
-0.07594645023345947,
-0.10780590772628784,
0.018054435029625893,
0.15620817244052887,
-0.5744682550430298,
-0.66341632604599,
0.6033734083175659,
-0.7549040913581848,
-0.33542776107788086,
-0.5374334454536438,
-0.3820684850215912,
-0.1735469102859497,
-0.03924890235066414,
-0.24786387383937836,
0.5975079536437988,
-0.3610132038593292,
-0.11166787147521973,
0.3353867530822754,
-0.35602614283561707,
0.0758976861834526,
0.6463425159454346,
-0.3663616180419922,
-0.1941041350364685,
0.8792927265167236,
-0.03226763755083084,
0.19388996064662933,
0.36578673124313354,
-0.04131076857447624,
-0.4026799499988556,
-0.38675764203071594,
-0.5055181384086609,
0.2336055487394333,
-0.6993333697319031,
-0.2125442624092102,
-0.35612013936042786,
0.17683209478855133,
-0.13280430436134338,
-0.43013569712638855,
-0.30171892046928406,
-0.02635003998875618,
-0.376006543636322,
-0.20057149231433868,
0.5088223218917847,
0.6959717273712158,
0.07668907195329666,
0.24255669116973877,
-0.7056520581245422,
0.5186803936958313,
0.20424409210681915,
0.19693121314048767,
-0.15759064257144928,
-0.13076619803905487,
-0.11234372109174728,
0.025472331792116165,
-0.008698323741555214,
-0.65895015001297,
0.2551153004169464,
0.11864582449197769,
0.43577903509140015,
0.09198931604623795,
0.02156824618577957,
0.6541629433631897,
-0.14595003426074982,
1.0742472410202026,
-0.11621080338954926,
-0.6419241428375244,
0.579583466053009,
-0.3055178225040436,
0.712639570236206,
0.382670521736145,
0.1939002424478531,
-0.5186253786087036,
-0.503800630569458,
-0.21871837973594666,
-0.6715644001960754,
0.4562215209007263,
-0.2592983543872833,
0.10259060561656952,
0.0833931416273117,
0.45246705412864685,
-0.0402311235666275,
0.040047626942396164,
-0.430215984582901,
0.21176713705062866,
-0.18468360602855682,
-0.10628004372119904,
-0.2736019492149353,
-0.1720348745584488,
-0.2888849079608917,
0.07330240309238434,
0.11948879808187485,
-0.37002864480018616,
0.21773943305015564,
0.29452696442604065,
-0.4509868323802948,
0.013909178785979748,
0.2715541422367096,
0.3266289532184601,
0.8082060813903809,
-0.282804399728775,
0.3628793954849243,
0.20429016649723053,
-0.4230438470840454,
0.09594705700874329,
0.3318236172199249,
-0.10323210805654526,
-0.11099150776863098,
0.5273181200027466,
0.49227777123451233,
0.29924291372299194,
-0.9452086687088013,
0.6184678673744202,
0.11624033749103546,
-0.04604865610599518,
-0.1449776142835617,
-0.09786566346883774,
0.004836974665522575,
0.3379475772380829,
0.5887659192085266,
-0.32842251658439636,
0.13418126106262207,
-0.4732247292995453,
-0.016477156430482864,
0.6397139430046082,
-0.26782217621803284,
-0.5591553449630737,
0.5470797419548035,
0.26400431990623474,
-0.28314563632011414,
0.5527285933494568,
-0.3220181167125702,
-0.6208071708679199,
0.8396071195602417,
-0.008689879439771175,
0.9325940608978271,
0.08230966329574585,
0.32078954577445984,
0.18172281980514526,
0.6422293186187744,
0.08256169408559799,
0.7745270729064941,
-0.2982386648654938,
-0.5311693549156189,
-0.44949471950531006,
-0.280623197555542,
-0.7332231402397156,
-0.09227954596281052,
-0.48854392766952515,
0.07739143073558807,
-0.48870977759361267,
-0.24447664618492126,
-0.16348782181739807,
0.014747374691069126,
-1.1962074041366577,
0.19944562017917633,
0.08342675864696503,
1.0077118873596191,
-0.8872563242912292,
0.19698889553546906,
1.064205288887024,
-0.12435749173164368,
-0.7610971927642822,
-0.2727295160293579,
-0.009291299618780613,
-0.8158307075500488,
0.5494531393051147,
0.18709702789783478,
-0.45320144295692444,
-0.3040594756603241,
-0.8606544733047485,
-0.8355035781860352,
1.2449305057525635,
0.27504122257232666,
-0.18081267178058624,
0.3156519830226898,
0.3707587420940399,
0.6904304623603821,
0.09845864772796631,
0.5476004481315613,
0.24224701523780823,
0.42081522941589355,
-0.23594924807548523,
-1.1747052669525146,
0.23528681695461273,
0.009874074719846249,
-0.021535521373152733,
0.11415344476699829,
-0.5169115662574768,
0.3989373445510864,
-0.1812209039926529,
-0.4298209846019745,
0.12292474508285522,
0.7012662291526794,
0.19626905024051666,
0.5455971956253052,
0.6343713402748108,
0.5037381052970886,
0.48908722400665283,
-0.1934189349412918,
1.2204104661941528,
-0.3375021815299988,
0.25451990962028503,
0.9986634254455566,
-0.6517338752746582,
1.0281105041503906,
0.2888326346874237,
-0.4553806185722351,
0.33807647228240967,
0.7677883505821228,
0.1172860860824585,
0.3571482300758362,
0.1093270480632782,
-0.3116343915462494,
-0.4620053768157959,
-0.17334115505218506,
-0.22611933946609497,
0.6324708461761475,
0.3114960789680481,
0.0992102324962616,
-0.5545405149459839,
0.1311192810535431,
-0.23176586627960205,
0.38526883721351624,
-0.2717617452144623,
0.5230321884155273,
-0.0634787455201149,
-0.6151042580604553,
0.5833336710929871,
-0.10644499212503433,
0.5360409021377563,
-0.6395927667617798,
-0.04608721658587456,
-0.1631510704755783,
-0.20970498025417328,
-0.24474067986011505,
-1.0297273397445679,
-0.1022820696234703,
0.21168063580989838,
0.15971635282039642,
-0.14346395432949066,
0.7473113536834717,
0.08654434978961945,
-0.4750635325908661,
0.0630241110920906,
0.7158938050270081,
0.501751184463501,
-0.2575870454311371,
-0.527412474155426,
0.31898096203804016,
-0.5667942762374878,
-0.30815231800079346,
0.15460339188575745,
0.2931492328643799,
-0.15792909264564514,
0.9854121208190918,
0.6897892355918884,
0.18206779658794403,
-0.002867857925593853,
-0.11588285118341446,
1.1106919050216675,
-0.7741423845291138,
-0.3979972004890442,
-0.3271256387233734,
0.32069969177246094,
0.08323877304792404,
-0.053021401166915894,
0.7524253726005554,
0.6115999817848206,
0.5380428433418274,
0.00620129331946373,
0.7028809785842896,
-0.09240636974573135,
0.5266339778900146,
-0.33835986256599426,
0.4093247354030609,
-0.4981198310852051,
0.15699177980422974,
-0.11533895134925842,
-0.9882508516311646,
-0.21229898929595947,
0.22515970468521118,
-0.602451503276825,
-0.045883793383836746,
0.23886552453041077,
1.136143445968628,
-0.31847769021987915,
-0.30349037051200867,
0.27611613273620605,
-0.18796022236347198,
0.40971100330352783,
0.3599020838737488,
1.160282850265503,
-0.3395122289657593,
0.3233313262462616,
0.10636315494775772,
-0.1965649425983429,
0.07112760841846466,
-1.0615030527114868,
-0.7691497206687927,
-0.31443706154823303,
-0.18067891895771027,
-0.2686874568462372,
0.023869793862104416,
1.0765554904937744,
0.7201695442199707,
-0.6601000428199768,
-0.3210541307926178,
0.19775253534317017,
0.0843702033162117,
-0.39742109179496765,
-0.18975313007831573,
0.3583226203918457,
0.12304293364286423,
-0.6334308385848999,
0.5588801503181458,
0.3444971740245819,
-0.13013438880443573,
-0.5860238075256348,
-0.04421013593673706,
-0.018830517306923866,
-0.2272813469171524,
0.5926262736320496,
0.778842568397522,
-0.9797145128250122,
-0.4978063702583313,
0.17292621731758118,
-0.0313279926776886,
-0.10012113302946091,
0.7409778237342834,
-1.0913572311401367,
0.6837538480758667,
0.300235390663147,
0.8603676557540894,
0.30198824405670166,
0.33556067943573,
0.3990108370780945,
-0.6261273622512817,
0.20496506989002228,
0.13808511197566986,
-0.02965952642261982,
0.5048725605010986,
-0.3171832263469696,
0.509313702583313,
-0.0993073359131813,
-0.6327969431877136,
-0.8751261830329895,
-0.07312951236963272,
-1.1593620777130127,
-0.08022351562976837,
1.322297215461731,
-0.3362578749656677,
-0.259268194437027,
0.01836630143225193,
-0.3367839753627777,
-0.2760988175868988,
-0.21449829638004303,
0.5466711521148682,
0.5504500865936279,
0.04690992459654808,
-0.26743438839912415,
-0.45183953642845154,
0.20132668316364288,
0.28115910291671753,
-0.843422532081604,
-0.0347907654941082,
0.876964807510376,
0.4138047397136688,
0.14412209391593933,
0.6137979030609131,
0.09147291630506516,
0.4550490975379944,
-0.171077698469162,
0.13782814145088196,
-0.16328631341457367,
-0.22074556350708008,
-0.23364979028701782,
0.233435720205307,
0.5576574206352234,
-0.4018074870109558
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.